id	sid	tid	token	lemma	pos
18637	1	1	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	1	2	's	's	POS
18637	1	3	notes	note	NNS
18637	1	4	:	:	:
18637	1	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1	6	=	=	SYM
18637	1	7	o	o	NN
18637	1	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1	9	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	1	10	the	the	DT
18637	1	11	vowel	vowel	NN
18637	1	12	"	"	``
18637	1	13	o	o	NN
18637	1	14	"	"	''
18637	1	15	with	with	IN
18637	1	16	a	a	DT
18637	1	17	macron	macron	NN
18637	1	18	in	in	IN
18637	1	19	this	this	DT
18637	1	20	text	text	NN
18637	1	21	.	.	.
18637	2	1	The	the	DT
18637	2	2	original	original	JJ
18637	2	3	editor	editor	NN
18637	2	4	's	's	POS
18637	2	5	comments	comment	NNS
18637	2	6	are	be	VBP
18637	2	7	enclosed	enclose	VBN
18637	2	8	in	in	IN
18637	2	9	square	square	JJ
18637	2	10	brackets	bracket	NNS
18637	2	11	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2	13	.	.	.
18637	3	1	Notes	note	NNS
18637	3	2	unique	unique	JJ
18637	3	3	to	to	IN
18637	3	4	this	this	DT
18637	3	5	edition	edition	NN
18637	3	6	are	be	VBP
18637	3	7	also	also	RB
18637	3	8	enclosed	enclose	VBN
18637	3	9	in	in	IN
18637	3	10	square	square	JJ
18637	3	11	brackets	bracket	NNS
18637	3	12	,	,	,
18637	3	13	but	but	CC
18637	3	14	are	be	VBP
18637	3	15	preceded	precede	VBN
18637	3	16	by	by	IN
18637	3	17	the	the	DT
18637	3	18	words	word	NNS
18637	3	19	"	"	``
18637	3	20	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	3	21	's	's	POS
18637	3	22	Note	Note	NNP
18637	3	23	"	"	''
18637	3	24	.	.	.
18637	4	1	A	a	DT
18637	4	2	complete	complete	JJ
18637	4	3	list	list	NN
18637	4	4	of	of	IN
18637	4	5	all	all	DT
18637	4	6	changes	change	NNS
18637	4	7	made	make	VBN
18637	4	8	to	to	IN
18637	4	9	the	the	DT
18637	4	10	text	text	NN
18637	4	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	4	12	included	include	VBN
18637	4	13	at	at	IN
18637	4	14	the	the	DT
18637	4	15	end	end	NN
18637	4	16	of	of	IN
18637	4	17	the	the	DT
18637	4	18	file	file	NN
18637	4	19	.	.	.
18637	5	1	Variations	variation	NNS
18637	5	2	in	in	IN
18637	5	3	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	5	4	were	be	VBD
18637	5	5	left	leave	VBN
18637	5	6	as	as	IN
18637	5	7	in	in	IN
18637	5	8	the	the	DT
18637	5	9	original	original	NN
18637	5	10	.	.	.
18637	6	1	82d	82d	NNS
18637	6	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	6	3	}	}	-RRB-
18637	6	4	SENATE	SENATE	NNP
18637	6	5	{	{	-LRB-
18637	6	6	Document	Document	NNP
18637	6	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6	8	2d	2d	NNP
18637	6	9	Session	Session	NNP
18637	6	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6	11	}	}	-RRB-
18637	6	12	{	{	-LRB-
18637	6	13	No	no	UH
18637	6	14	.	.	.
18637	7	1	170	170	CD
18637	7	2	THE	the	DT
18637	7	3	CONSTITUTION	CONSTITUTION	NNP
18637	7	4	OF	of	IN
18637	7	5	THE	the	DT
18637	7	6	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	7	7	STATES	state	NNS
18637	7	8	OF	of	IN
18637	7	9	AMERICA	america	JJ
18637	7	10	ANALYSIS	analysi	NNS
18637	7	11	AND	and	CC
18637	7	12	INTERPRETATION	INTERPRETATION	NNP
18637	7	13	Annotations	Annotations	NNPS
18637	7	14	of	of	IN
18637	7	15	Cases	case	NNS
18637	7	16	Decided	decide	VBN
18637	7	17	by	by	IN
18637	7	18	the	the	DT
18637	7	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	7	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7	21	of	of	IN
18637	7	22	the	the	DT
18637	7	23	United	United	NNP
18637	7	24	States	States	NNP
18637	7	25	to	to	IN
18637	7	26	June	June	NNP
18637	7	27	30	30	CD
18637	7	28	,	,	,
18637	7	29	1952	1952	CD
18637	7	30	Prepared	prepare	VBN
18637	7	31	by	by	IN
18637	7	32	the	the	DT
18637	7	33	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	7	34	Reference	Reference	NNP
18637	7	35	Service	Service	NNP
18637	7	36	,	,	,
18637	7	37	Library	Library	NNP
18637	7	38	of	of	IN
18637	7	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7	40	EDWARD	EDWARD	NNP
18637	7	41	S.	S.	NNP
18637	7	42	CORWIN	CORWIN	NNP
18637	7	43	,	,	,
18637	7	44	Editor	Editor	NNP
18637	7	45	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7	46	Illustration	illustration	NN
18637	7	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7	48	United	United	NNP
18637	7	49	States	States	NNP
18637	7	50	Government	Government	NNP
18637	7	51	Printing	Printing	NNP
18637	7	52	Office	Office	NNP
18637	7	53	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	7	54	:	:	:
18637	7	55	1953	1953	CD
18637	7	56	For	for	IN
18637	7	57	sale	sale	NN
18637	7	58	by	by	IN
18637	7	59	the	the	DT
18637	7	60	Superintendent	Superintendent	NNP
18637	7	61	of	of	IN
18637	7	62	Documents	Documents	NNPS
18637	7	63	,	,	,
18637	7	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7	65	Government	Government	NNP
18637	7	66	Printing	Printing	NNP
18637	7	67	Office	Office	NNP
18637	7	68	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	7	69	25	25	CD
18637	7	70	D.C.--Price	d.c.--price	CD
18637	7	71	$	$	$
18637	7	72	6.25	6.25	CD
18637	7	73	SENATE	SENATE	NNP
18637	7	74	JOINT	JOINT	NNP
18637	7	75	RESOLUTION	resolution	NN
18637	7	76	69	69	CD
18637	7	77	JOINT	joint	JJ
18637	7	78	RESOLUTION	resolution	NN
18637	7	79	To	to	TO
18637	7	80	prepare	prepare	VB
18637	7	81	a	a	DT
18637	7	82	revised	revise	VBN
18637	7	83	edition	edition	NN
18637	7	84	of	of	IN
18637	7	85	the	the	DT
18637	7	86	Annotated	Annotated	NNP
18637	7	87	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7	88	of	of	IN
18637	7	89	the	the	DT
18637	7	90	United	United	NNP
18637	7	91	States	States	NNP
18637	7	92	of	of	IN
18637	7	93	America	America	NNP
18637	7	94	as	as	IN
18637	7	95	published	publish	VBN
18637	7	96	in	in	IN
18637	7	97	1938	1938	CD
18637	7	98	as	as	IN
18637	7	99	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	7	100	Document	Document	NNP
18637	7	101	232	232	CD
18637	7	102	of	of	IN
18637	7	103	the	the	DT
18637	7	104	Seventy	seventy	CD
18637	7	105	-	-	HYPH
18637	7	106	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	7	107	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7	108	.	.	.
18637	8	1	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	8	2	the	the	DT
18637	8	3	Annotated	Annotated	NNP
18637	8	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8	5	of	of	IN
18637	8	6	the	the	DT
18637	8	7	United	United	NNP
18637	8	8	States	States	NNP
18637	8	9	of	of	IN
18637	8	10	America	America	NNP
18637	8	11	published	publish	VBN
18637	8	12	in	in	IN
18637	8	13	1938	1938	CD
18637	8	14	as	as	IN
18637	8	15	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8	16	Document	Document	NNP
18637	8	17	232	232	CD
18637	8	18	,	,	,
18637	8	19	Seventy	seventy	CD
18637	8	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	8	21	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	8	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8	23	,	,	,
18637	8	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	8	25	served	serve	VBN
18637	8	26	a	a	DT
18637	8	27	very	very	RB
18637	8	28	useful	useful	JJ
18637	8	29	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8	30	by	by	IN
18637	8	31	supplying	supply	VBG
18637	8	32	essential	essential	JJ
18637	8	33	information	information	NN
18637	8	34	in	in	IN
18637	8	35	one	one	CD
18637	8	36	volume	volume	NN
18637	8	37	and	and	CC
18637	8	38	at	at	IN
18637	8	39	a	a	DT
18637	8	40	very	very	RB
18637	8	41	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	8	42	price	price	NN
18637	8	43	;	;	:
18637	8	44	and	and	CC
18637	8	45	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	8	46	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8	47	Document	Document	NNP
18637	8	48	232	232	CD
18637	8	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	8	50	no	no	RB
18637	8	51	longer	long	RBR
18637	8	52	available	available	JJ
18637	8	53	at	at	IN
18637	8	54	the	the	DT
18637	8	55	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8	56	Printing	Printing	NNP
18637	8	57	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8	58	;	;	:
18637	8	59	and	and	CC
18637	8	60	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	8	61	the	the	DT
18637	8	62	reprinting	reprinting	NN
18637	8	63	of	of	IN
18637	8	64	this	this	DT
18637	8	65	document	document	NN
18637	8	66	without	without	IN
18637	8	67	annotations	annotation	NNS
18637	8	68	for	for	IN
18637	8	69	the	the	DT
18637	8	70	last	last	JJ
18637	8	71	ten	ten	CD
18637	8	72	years	year	NNS
18637	8	73	is	be	VBZ
18637	8	74	now	now	RB
18637	8	75	considered	consider	VBN
18637	8	76	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	8	77	:	:	:
18637	8	78	Now	now	RB
18637	8	79	,	,	,
18637	8	80	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8	81	,	,	,
18637	8	82	be	be	VB
18637	8	83	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8	84	_	_	NNP
18637	8	85	Resolved	resolve	VBN
18637	8	86	by	by	IN
18637	8	87	the	the	DT
18637	8	88	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8	89	and	and	CC
18637	8	90	House	House	NNP
18637	8	91	of	of	IN
18637	8	92	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	8	93	of	of	IN
18637	8	94	the	the	DT
18637	8	95	United	United	NNP
18637	8	96	States	States	NNP
18637	8	97	of	of	IN
18637	8	98	America	America	NNP
18637	8	99	in	in	IN
18637	8	100	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8	101	assembled	assemble	VBD
18637	8	102	_	_	NNP
18637	8	103	,	,	,
18637	8	104	That	that	IN
18637	8	105	the	the	DT
18637	8	106	Librarian	Librarian	NNP
18637	8	107	of	of	IN
18637	8	108	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8	109	is	be	VBZ
18637	8	110	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	8	111	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8	112	and	and	CC
18637	8	113	directed	direct	VBN
18637	8	114	to	to	TO
18637	8	115	have	have	VB
18637	8	116	the	the	DT
18637	8	117	Annotated	Annotated	NNP
18637	8	118	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8	119	of	of	IN
18637	8	120	the	the	DT
18637	8	121	United	United	NNP
18637	8	122	States	States	NNP
18637	8	123	of	of	IN
18637	8	124	America	America	NNP
18637	8	125	,	,	,
18637	8	126	published	publish	VBN
18637	8	127	in	in	IN
18637	8	128	1938	1938	CD
18637	8	129	,	,	,
18637	8	130	revised	revise	VBN
18637	8	131	and	and	CC
18637	8	132	extended	extend	VBN
18637	8	133	to	to	TO
18637	8	134	include	include	VB
18637	8	135	annotations	annotation	NNS
18637	8	136	of	of	IN
18637	8	137	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	8	138	of	of	IN
18637	8	139	the	the	DT
18637	8	140	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8	141	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8	142	prior	prior	RB
18637	8	143	to	to	IN
18637	8	144	January	January	NNP
18637	8	145	1	1	CD
18637	8	146	,	,	,
18637	8	147	1948	1948	CD
18637	8	148	,	,	,
18637	8	149	construing	construe	VBG
18637	8	150	the	the	DT
18637	8	151	several	several	JJ
18637	8	152	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8	153	of	of	IN
18637	8	154	the	the	DT
18637	8	155	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8	156	correlated	correlate	VBD
18637	8	157	under	under	IN
18637	8	158	each	each	DT
18637	8	159	separate	separate	JJ
18637	8	160	provision	provision	NN
18637	8	161	,	,	,
18637	8	162	and	and	CC
18637	8	163	to	to	TO
18637	8	164	have	have	VB
18637	8	165	the	the	DT
18637	8	166	said	say	VBN
18637	8	167	revised	revised	JJ
18637	8	168	document	document	NN
18637	8	169	printed	print	VBN
18637	8	170	at	at	IN
18637	8	171	the	the	DT
18637	8	172	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8	173	Printing	Printing	NNP
18637	8	174	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8	175	.	.	.
18637	9	1	Three	three	CD
18637	9	2	thousand	thousand	CD
18637	9	3	copies	copy	NNS
18637	9	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	9	5	be	be	VB
18637	9	6	printed	print	VBN
18637	9	7	,	,	,
18637	9	8	of	of	IN
18637	9	9	which	which	WDT
18637	9	10	two	two	CD
18637	9	11	thousand	thousand	CD
18637	9	12	two	two	CD
18637	9	13	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	9	14	copies	copy	NNS
18637	9	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	9	16	be	be	VB
18637	9	17	for	for	IN
18637	9	18	the	the	DT
18637	9	19	use	use	NN
18637	9	20	of	of	IN
18637	9	21	the	the	DT
18637	9	22	House	House	NNP
18637	9	23	of	of	IN
18637	9	24	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	9	25	and	and	CC
18637	9	26	eight	eight	CD
18637	9	27	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	9	28	copies	copy	NNS
18637	9	29	for	for	IN
18637	9	30	the	the	DT
18637	9	31	use	use	NN
18637	9	32	of	of	IN
18637	9	33	the	the	DT
18637	9	34	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9	35	.	.	.
18637	10	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
18637	10	2	.	.	.
18637	11	1	2	2	LS
18637	11	2	.	.	.
18637	12	1	There	there	EX
18637	12	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	12	3	hereby	hereby	NNP
18637	12	4	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	12	5	to	to	TO
18637	12	6	be	be	VB
18637	12	7	appropriated	appropriate	VBN
18637	12	8	for	for	IN
18637	12	9	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	12	10	out	out	RP
18637	12	11	the	the	DT
18637	12	12	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	12	13	of	of	IN
18637	12	14	this	this	DT
18637	12	15	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12	16	,	,	,
18637	12	17	with	with	IN
18637	12	18	respect	respect	NN
18637	12	19	to	to	IN
18637	12	20	the	the	DT
18637	12	21	preparation	preparation	NN
18637	12	22	but	but	CC
18637	12	23	not	not	RB
18637	12	24	including	include	VBG
18637	12	25	printing	printing	NN
18637	12	26	,	,	,
18637	12	27	the	the	DT
18637	12	28	sum	sum	NN
18637	12	29	of	of	IN
18637	12	30	$	$	$
18637	12	31	35,000	35,000	CD
18637	12	32	to	to	TO
18637	12	33	remain	remain	VB
18637	12	34	available	available	JJ
18637	12	35	until	until	IN
18637	12	36	expended	expend	VBN
18637	12	37	.	.	.
18637	13	1	Approved	Approved	NNP
18637	13	2	June	June	NNP
18637	13	3	17	17	CD
18637	13	4	,	,	,
18637	13	5	1947	1947	CD
18637	13	6	.	.	.
18637	14	1	PREFACE	PREFACE	NNP
18637	14	2	By	by	IN
18637	14	3	Honorable	Honorable	NNP
18637	14	4	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	14	5	Wiley	Wiley	NNP
18637	14	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14	7	Chairman	Chairman	NNP
18637	14	8	,	,	,
18637	14	9	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	14	10	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	14	11	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	14	12	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	14	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14	14	To	to	IN
18637	14	15	the	the	DT
18637	14	16	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	14	17	and	and	CC
18637	14	18	Committees	Committees	NNPS
18637	14	19	of	of	IN
18637	14	20	the	the	DT
18637	14	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14	22	,	,	,
18637	14	23	the	the	DT
18637	14	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	14	26	more	more	JJR
18637	14	27	than	than	IN
18637	14	28	a	a	DT
18637	14	29	revered	revered	JJ
18637	14	30	abstraction	abstraction	NN
18637	14	31	;	;	:
18637	14	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	14	34	an	an	DT
18637	14	35	everyday	everyday	JJ
18637	14	36	companion	companion	NN
18637	14	37	and	and	CC
18637	14	38	counsellor	counsellor	NN
18637	14	39	.	.	.
18637	15	1	Into	into	IN
18637	15	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15	3	,	,	,
18637	15	4	the	the	DT
18637	15	5	Founding	Founding	NNP
18637	15	6	Fathers	Fathers	NNPS
18637	15	7	breathed	breathe	VBD
18637	15	8	the	the	DT
18637	15	9	spirit	spirit	NN
18637	15	10	of	of	IN
18637	15	11	life	life	NN
18637	15	12	;	;	:
18637	15	13	through	through	IN
18637	15	14	every	every	DT
18637	15	15	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	15	16	generation	generation	NN
18637	15	17	,	,	,
18637	15	18	that	that	DT
18637	15	19	spirit	spirit	NNP
18637	15	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	15	21	remained	remain	VBN
18637	15	22	vital	vital	JJ
18637	15	23	.	.	.
18637	16	1	In	in	IN
18637	16	2	more	more	JJR
18637	16	3	than	than	IN
18637	16	4	a	a	DT
18637	16	5	century	century	NN
18637	16	6	and	and	CC
18637	16	7	a	a	DT
18637	16	8	half	half	NN
18637	16	9	of	of	IN
18637	16	10	cataclysmic	cataclysmic	JJ
18637	16	11	events	event	NNS
18637	16	12	,	,	,
18637	16	13	the	the	DT
18637	16	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	16	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	16	16	successfully	successfully	RB
18637	16	17	withstood	withstand	VBN
18637	16	18	test	test	NN
18637	16	19	after	after	IN
18637	16	20	test	test	NN
18637	16	21	.	.	.
18637	17	1	No	no	DT
18637	17	2	crisis	crisis	NN
18637	17	3	--	--	:
18637	17	4	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	17	5	or	or	CC
18637	17	6	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	17	7	--	--	:
18637	17	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	17	9	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	17	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17	11	vitality	vitality	NN
18637	17	12	.	.	.
18637	18	1	The	the	DT
18637	18	2	system	system	NN
18637	18	3	of	of	IN
18637	18	4	checks	check	NNS
18637	18	5	and	and	CC
18637	18	6	balances	balance	NNS
18637	18	7	which	which	WDT
18637	18	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18	9	sets	set	VBZ
18637	18	10	up	up	RP
18637	18	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	18	12	enabled	enable	VBN
18637	18	13	the	the	DT
18637	18	14	growing	grow	VBG
18637	18	15	nation	nation	NN
18637	18	16	to	to	TO
18637	18	17	adapt	adapt	VB
18637	18	18	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18	19	to	to	IN
18637	18	20	every	every	DT
18637	18	21	need	need	NN
18637	18	22	and	and	CC
18637	18	23	at	at	IN
18637	18	24	the	the	DT
18637	18	25	same	same	JJ
18637	18	26	time	time	NN
18637	18	27	to	to	TO
18637	18	28	checkrein	checkrein	VB
18637	18	29	every	every	DT
18637	18	30	bid	bid	NN
18637	18	31	for	for	IN
18637	18	32	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18	33	power	power	NN
18637	18	34	.	.	.
18637	19	1	And	and	CC
18637	19	2	meantime	meantime	RB
18637	19	3	America	America	NNP
18637	19	4	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	19	6	evolved	evolve	VBN
18637	19	7	dynamically	dynamically	RB
18637	19	8	and	and	CC
18637	19	9	dramatically	dramatically	RB
18637	19	10	.	.	.
18637	20	1	The	the	DT
18637	20	2	humble	humble	JJ
18637	20	3	13	13	CD
18637	20	4	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	20	5	,	,	,
18637	20	6	carved	carve	VBN
18637	20	7	out	out	IN
18637	20	8	of	of	IN
18637	20	9	the	the	DT
18637	20	10	wilderness	wilderness	NN
18637	20	11	in	in	IN
18637	20	12	the	the	DT
18637	20	13	18th	18th	JJ
18637	20	14	Century	Century	NNP
18637	20	15	,	,	,
18637	20	16	emerged	emerge	VBD
18637	20	17	in	in	IN
18637	20	18	the	the	DT
18637	20	19	20th	20th	JJ
18637	20	20	Century	Century	NNP
18637	20	21	as	as	IN
18637	20	22	leader	leader	NN
18637	20	23	of	of	IN
18637	20	24	earth	earth	NN
18637	20	25	--	--	:
18637	20	26	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	20	27	--	--	:
18637	20	28	military	military	NN
18637	20	29	--	--	:
18637	20	30	political	political	JJ
18637	20	31	--	--	:
18637	20	32	economic	economic	JJ
18637	20	33	--	--	:
18637	20	34	psychological	psychological	JJ
18637	20	35	.	.	.
18637	21	1	Yet	yet	CC
18637	21	2	the	the	DT
18637	21	3	broad	broad	JJ
18637	21	4	outline	outline	NN
18637	21	5	of	of	IN
18637	21	6	the	the	DT
18637	21	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21	8	Law	Law	NNP
18637	21	9	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	21	10	today	today	NN
18637	21	11	fundamentally	fundamentally	RB
18637	21	12	intact	intact	JJ
18637	21	13	.	.	.
18637	22	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	22	3	small	small	JJ
18637	22	4	wonder	wonder	NN
18637	22	5	that	that	WDT
18637	22	6	W.E.	W.E.	NNP
18637	23	1	Gladstone	Gladstone	NNP
18637	23	2	described	describe	VBD
18637	23	3	the	the	DT
18637	23	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	23	5	as	as	IN
18637	23	6	"	"	``
18637	23	7	the	the	DT
18637	23	8	most	most	RBS
18637	23	9	wonderful	wonderful	JJ
18637	23	10	work	work	NN
18637	23	11	ever	ever	RB
18637	23	12	struck	strike	VBD
18637	23	13	off	off	RP
18637	23	14	at	at	IN
18637	23	15	a	a	DT
18637	23	16	given	give	VBN
18637	23	17	time	time	NN
18637	23	18	by	by	IN
18637	23	19	the	the	DT
18637	23	20	brain	brain	NN
18637	23	21	and	and	CC
18637	23	22	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	23	23	of	of	IN
18637	23	24	man	man	NN
18637	23	25	.	.	.
18637	23	26	"	"	''
18637	24	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	24	2	knew	know	VBD
18637	24	3	,	,	,
18637	24	4	as	as	IN
18637	24	5	should	should	MD
18637	24	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	24	7	,	,	,
18637	24	8	that	that	IN
18637	24	9	the	the	DT
18637	24	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	24	11	's	's	POS
18637	24	12	words	word	NNS
18637	24	13	,	,	,
18637	24	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	24	15	phrases	phrase	NNS
18637	24	16	,	,	,
18637	24	17	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	24	18	,	,	,
18637	24	19	sentences	sentence	NNS
18637	24	20	,	,	,
18637	24	21	paragraphs	paragraph	NNS
18637	24	22	,	,	,
18637	24	23	and	and	CC
18637	24	24	sections	section	NNS
18637	24	25	still	still	RB
18637	24	26	possess	possess	VBP
18637	24	27	a	a	DT
18637	24	28	miraculous	miraculous	JJ
18637	24	29	quality	quality	NN
18637	24	30	--	--	:
18637	24	31	a	a	DT
18637	24	32	mingled	mingled	JJ
18637	24	33	flexibility	flexibility	NN
18637	24	34	and	and	CC
18637	24	35	strength	strength	NN
18637	24	36	which	which	WDT
18637	24	37	permits	permit	VBZ
18637	24	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	24	39	adaptation	adaptation	NN
18637	24	40	to	to	IN
18637	24	41	the	the	DT
18637	24	42	needs	need	NNS
18637	24	43	of	of	IN
18637	24	44	the	the	DT
18637	24	45	hour	hour	NN
18637	24	46	without	without	IN
18637	24	47	sacrifice	sacrifice	NN
18637	24	48	of	of	IN
18637	24	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	24	50	essential	essential	JJ
18637	24	51	character	character	NN
18637	24	52	as	as	IN
18637	24	53	the	the	DT
18637	24	54	basic	basic	JJ
18637	24	55	framework	framework	NN
18637	24	56	of	of	IN
18637	24	57	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	24	58	.	.	.
18637	25	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	25	3	long	long	RB
18637	25	4	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	25	5	how	how	WRB
18637	25	6	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	25	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	25	9	to	to	TO
18637	25	10	have	have	VB
18637	25	11	a	a	DT
18637	25	12	handy	handy	JJ
18637	25	13	working	working	NN
18637	25	14	guide	guide	NN
18637	25	15	to	to	IN
18637	25	16	this	this	DT
18637	25	17	superb	superb	JJ
18637	25	18	charter	charter	NN
18637	25	19	.	.	.
18637	26	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	26	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	26	3	sought	seek	VBN
18637	26	4	a	a	DT
18637	26	5	map	map	NN
18637	26	6	,	,	,
18637	26	7	so	so	RB
18637	26	8	to	to	TO
18637	26	9	speak	speak	VB
18637	26	10	,	,	,
18637	26	11	of	of	IN
18637	26	12	the	the	DT
18637	26	13	great	great	JJ
18637	26	14	historical	historical	JJ
18637	26	15	landmarks	landmark	NNS
18637	26	16	of	of	IN
18637	26	17	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	26	18	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
18637	26	19	--	--	:
18637	26	20	landmarks	landmark	NNS
18637	26	21	which	which	WDT
18637	26	22	mark	mark	VBP
18637	26	23	the	the	DT
18637	26	24	oft	oft	NNP
18637	26	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	26	26	times	time	NNS
18637	26	27	epic	epic	JJ
18637	26	28	battles	battle	NNS
18637	26	29	of	of	IN
18637	26	30	clashing	clash	VBG
18637	26	31	legal	legal	JJ
18637	26	32	interpretations	interpretation	NNS
18637	26	33	.	.	.
18637	27	1	A	a	DT
18637	27	2	first	first	JJ
18637	27	3	step	step	NN
18637	27	4	was	be	VBD
18637	27	5	taken	take	VBN
18637	27	6	toward	toward	IN
18637	27	7	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	27	8	this	this	DT
18637	27	9	need	need	NN
18637	27	10	by	by	IN
18637	27	11	publication	publication	NN
18637	27	12	of	of	IN
18637	27	13	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	27	14	Document	Document	NNP
18637	27	15	12	12	CD
18637	27	16	,	,	,
18637	27	17	63d	63d	CD
18637	27	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	27	19	in	in	IN
18637	27	20	1913	1913	CD
18637	27	21	.	.	.
18637	28	1	Ten	ten	CD
18637	28	2	years	year	NNS
18637	28	3	later	later	RB
18637	28	4	,	,	,
18637	28	5	in	in	IN
18637	28	6	1923	1923	CD
18637	28	7	another	another	DT
18637	28	8	volume	volume	NN
18637	28	9	was	be	VBD
18637	28	10	issued	issue	VBN
18637	28	11	,	,	,
18637	28	12	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	28	13	Document	Document	NNP
18637	28	14	96	96	CD
18637	28	15	,	,	,
18637	28	16	67th	67th	JJ
18637	28	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	28	18	,	,	,
18637	28	19	and	and	CC
18637	28	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	28	21	was	be	VBD
18637	28	22	followed	follow	VBN
18637	28	23	in	in	IN
18637	28	24	turn	turn	NN
18637	28	25	by	by	IN
18637	28	26	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	28	27	Document	Document	NNP
18637	28	28	154	154	CD
18637	28	29	of	of	IN
18637	28	30	the	the	DT
18637	28	31	68th	68th	JJ
18637	28	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	28	33	.	.	.
18637	29	1	In	in	IN
18637	29	2	1936	1936	CD
18637	29	3	,	,	,
18637	29	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	29	5	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	29	6	a	a	DT
18637	29	7	further	further	JJ
18637	29	8	revision	revision	NN
18637	29	9	,	,	,
18637	29	10	this	this	DT
18637	29	11	time	time	NN
18637	29	12	by	by	IN
18637	29	13	the	the	DT
18637	29	14	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	29	15	Reference	Reference	NNP
18637	29	16	Service	Service	NNP
18637	29	17	.	.	.
18637	30	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	30	2	Wilfred	Wilfred	NNP
18637	30	3	C.	C.	NNP
18637	30	4	Gilbert	Gilbert	NNP
18637	30	5	,	,	,
18637	30	6	now	now	RB
18637	30	7	the	the	DT
18637	30	8	Assistant	Assistant	NNP
18637	30	9	Director	Director	NNP
18637	30	10	of	of	IN
18637	30	11	the	the	DT
18637	30	12	Service	Service	NNP
18637	30	13	,	,	,
18637	30	14	was	be	VBD
18637	30	15	the	the	DT
18637	30	16	editor	editor	NN
18637	30	17	of	of	IN
18637	30	18	this	this	DT
18637	30	19	volume	volume	NN
18637	30	20	which	which	WDT
18637	30	21	became	become	VBD
18637	30	22	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	30	23	Document	Document	NNP
18637	30	24	232	232	CD
18637	30	25	,	,	,
18637	30	26	74th	74th	JJ
18637	30	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	30	28	,	,	,
18637	30	29	and	and	CC
18637	30	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	30	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	30	32	given	give	VBN
18637	30	33	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	30	34	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	30	35	the	the	DT
18637	30	36	development	development	NN
18637	30	37	of	of	IN
18637	30	38	the	the	DT
18637	30	39	present	present	JJ
18637	30	40	edition	edition	NN
18637	30	41	of	of	IN
18637	30	42	this	this	DT
18637	30	43	volume	volume	NN
18637	30	44	.	.	.
18637	31	1	After	after	IN
18637	31	2	another	another	DT
18637	31	3	decade	decade	NN
18637	31	4	of	of	IN
18637	31	5	significant	significant	JJ
18637	31	6	and	and	CC
18637	31	7	far	far	RB
18637	31	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	31	9	reaching	reach	VBG
18637	31	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	31	11	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	31	12	,	,	,
18637	31	13	the	the	DT
18637	31	14	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	31	15	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	31	16	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	31	17	reported	report	VBD
18637	31	18	out	out	RP
18637	31	19	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	31	20	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	31	21	Resolution	Resolution	NNP
18637	31	22	69	69	CD
18637	31	23	of	of	IN
18637	31	24	the	the	DT
18637	31	25	80th	80th	JJ
18637	31	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	31	27	calling	call	VBG
18637	31	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	31	29	the	the	DT
18637	31	30	Librarian	Librarian	NNP
18637	31	31	of	of	IN
18637	31	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	31	33	for	for	IN
18637	31	34	the	the	DT
18637	31	35	preparation	preparation	NN
18637	31	36	of	of	IN
18637	31	37	the	the	DT
18637	31	38	new	new	JJ
18637	31	39	work	work	NN
18637	31	40	.	.	.
18637	32	1	However	however	RB
18637	32	2	,	,	,
18637	32	3	because	because	IN
18637	32	4	of	of	IN
18637	32	5	the	the	DT
18637	32	6	increase	increase	NN
18637	32	7	in	in	IN
18637	32	8	responsibilities	responsibility	NNS
18637	32	9	of	of	IN
18637	32	10	the	the	DT
18637	32	11	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	32	12	Reference	Reference	NNP
18637	32	13	Service	Service	NNP
18637	32	14	,	,	,
18637	32	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	32	16	was	be	VBD
18637	32	17	no	no	RB
18637	32	18	longer	long	RBR
18637	32	19	feasible	feasible	JJ
18637	32	20	for	for	IN
18637	32	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	32	22	to	to	TO
18637	32	23	undertake	undertake	VB
18637	32	24	this	this	DT
18637	32	25	additional	additional	JJ
18637	32	26	burden	burden	NN
18637	32	27	with	with	IN
18637	32	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	32	29	regular	regular	JJ
18637	32	30	staff	staff	NN
18637	32	31	.	.	.
18637	33	1	The	the	DT
18637	33	2	Director	Director	NNP
18637	33	3	of	of	IN
18637	33	4	the	the	DT
18637	33	5	Service	Service	NNP
18637	33	6	,	,	,
18637	33	7	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
18637	33	8	Ernest	Ernest	NNP
18637	33	9	S.	S.	NNP
18637	33	10	Griffith	Griffith	NNP
18637	33	11	,	,	,
18637	33	12	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	33	13	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	33	14	that	that	IN
18637	33	15	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
18637	33	16	Edward	Edward	NNP
18637	33	17	S.	S.	NNP
18637	33	18	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	33	19	be	be	VB
18637	33	20	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	33	21	to	to	TO
18637	33	22	head	head	VB
18637	33	23	the	the	DT
18637	33	24	project	project	NN
18637	33	25	with	with	IN
18637	33	26	a	a	DT
18637	33	27	collaborating	collaborate	VBG
18637	33	28	staff	staff	NN
18637	33	29	to	to	TO
18637	33	30	be	be	VB
18637	33	31	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	33	32	by	by	IN
18637	33	33	the	the	DT
18637	33	34	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	33	35	Reference	Reference	NNP
18637	33	36	Service	Service	NNP
18637	33	37	.	.	.
18637	34	1	In	in	IN
18637	34	2	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	34	3	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	34	4	at	at	IN
18637	34	5	the	the	DT
18637	34	6	time	time	NN
18637	34	7	,	,	,
18637	34	8	as	as	IN
18637	34	9	Chairman	Chairman	NNP
18637	34	10	of	of	IN
18637	34	11	the	the	DT
18637	34	12	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	34	13	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	34	14	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	34	15	,	,	,
18637	34	16	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	34	17	was	be	VBD
18637	34	18	delighted	delighted	JJ
18637	34	19	to	to	TO
18637	34	20	give	give	VB
18637	34	21	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	34	22	approval	approval	NN
18637	34	23	to	to	IN
18637	34	24	this	this	DT
18637	34	25	arrangement	arrangement	NN
18637	34	26	,	,	,
18637	34	27	for	for	IN
18637	34	28	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	34	29	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	34	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	34	31	particular	particular	JJ
18637	34	32	good	good	JJ
18637	34	33	fortune	fortune	NN
18637	34	34	in	in	IN
18637	34	35	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	34	36	the	the	DT
18637	34	37	services	service	NNS
18637	34	38	of	of	IN
18637	34	39	an	an	DT
18637	34	40	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	34	41	authority	authority	NN
18637	34	42	for	for	IN
18637	34	43	this	this	DT
18637	34	44	highly	highly	RB
18637	34	45	significant	significant	JJ
18637	34	46	and	and	CC
18637	34	47	delicate	delicate	JJ
18637	34	48	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	34	49	.	.	.
18637	35	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	35	2	should	should	MD
18637	35	3	like	like	VB
18637	35	4	now	now	RB
18637	35	5	to	to	TO
18637	35	6	express	express	VB
18637	35	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	35	8	thanks	thank	NNS
18637	35	9	and	and	CC
18637	35	10	appreciation	appreciation	NN
18637	35	11	to	to	IN
18637	35	12	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
18637	35	13	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	35	14	and	and	CC
18637	35	15	to	to	IN
18637	35	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	35	17	collaborators	collaborator	NNS
18637	35	18	from	from	IN
18637	35	19	the	the	DT
18637	35	20	Service	Service	NNP
18637	35	21	,	,	,
18637	35	22	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
18637	35	23	Norman	Norman	NNP
18637	35	24	J.	J.	NNP
18637	36	1	Small	small	JJ
18637	36	2	,	,	,
18637	36	3	Assistant	Assistant	NNP
18637	36	4	Editor	Editor	NNP
18637	36	5	,	,	,
18637	36	6	Miss	Miss	NNP
18637	36	7	Mary	Mary	NNP
18637	36	8	Louise	Louise	NNP
18637	36	9	Ramsey	Ramsey	NNP
18637	36	10	,	,	,
18637	36	11	and	and	CC
18637	36	12	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
18637	36	13	Robert	Robert	NNP
18637	36	14	J.	J.	NNP
18637	36	15	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	36	16	,	,	,
18637	36	17	for	for	IN
18637	36	18	all	all	DT
18637	36	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	36	20	prodigious	prodigious	JJ
18637	36	21	and	and	CC
18637	36	22	skilled	skilled	JJ
18637	36	23	labors	labor	NNS
18637	36	24	.	.	.
18637	37	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	37	2	,	,	,
18637	37	3	for	for	IN
18637	37	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	37	5	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	37	6	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	37	7	in	in	IN
18637	37	8	connection	connection	NN
18637	37	9	with	with	IN
18637	37	10	the	the	DT
18637	37	11	detailed	detailed	JJ
18637	37	12	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	37	13	and	and	CC
18637	37	14	printing	printing	NN
18637	37	15	arrangements	arrangement	NNS
18637	37	16	for	for	IN
18637	37	17	the	the	DT
18637	37	18	publication	publication	NN
18637	37	19	of	of	IN
18637	37	20	this	this	DT
18637	37	21	volume	volume	NN
18637	37	22	,	,	,
18637	37	23	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	37	24	should	should	MD
18637	37	25	like	like	VB
18637	37	26	to	to	TO
18637	37	27	express	express	VB
18637	37	28	appreciation	appreciation	NN
18637	37	29	to	to	IN
18637	37	30	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	37	31	Darrell	Darrell	NNP
18637	37	32	St.	St.	NNP
18637	37	33	Claire	Claire	NNP
18637	37	34	,	,	,
18637	37	35	Staff	Staff	NNP
18637	37	36	Member	Member	NNP
18637	37	37	for	for	IN
18637	37	38	the	the	DT
18637	37	39	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	37	40	Rules	Rules	NNPS
18637	37	41	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	37	42	,	,	,
18637	37	43	as	as	RB
18637	37	44	well	well	RB
18637	37	45	as	as	IN
18637	37	46	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	37	47	Clerk	Clerk	NNP
18637	37	48	for	for	IN
18637	37	49	the	the	DT
18637	37	50	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	37	51	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	37	52	on	on	IN
18637	37	53	the	the	DT
18637	37	54	Library	Library	NNP
18637	37	55	of	of	IN
18637	37	56	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	37	57	;	;	:
18637	37	58	and	and	CC
18637	37	59	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	37	60	Julius	Julius	NNP
18637	37	61	N.	N.	NNP
18637	37	62	Cahn	Cahn	NNP
18637	37	63	,	,	,
18637	37	64	previously	previously	RB
18637	37	65	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	37	66	Assistant	Assistant	NNP
18637	37	67	to	to	IN
18637	37	68	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	37	69	when	when	WRB
18637	37	70	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	37	71	was	be	VBD
18637	37	72	Chairman	Chairman	NNP
18637	37	73	of	of	IN
18637	37	74	the	the	DT
18637	37	75	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	37	76	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	37	77	and	and	CC
18637	37	78	now	now	RB
18637	37	79	Counsel	Counsel	NNP
18637	37	80	to	to	IN
18637	37	81	the	the	DT
18637	37	82	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	37	83	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	37	84	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	37	85	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	37	86	.	.	.
18637	38	1	Initiated	initiate	VBN
18637	38	2	in	in	IN
18637	38	3	the	the	DT
18637	38	4	Republican	republican	JJ
18637	38	5	80th	80th	NN
18637	38	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	38	7	,	,	,
18637	38	8	the	the	DT
18637	38	9	project	project	NN
18637	38	10	was	be	VBD
18637	38	11	undertaken	undertake	VBN
18637	38	12	With	with	IN
18637	38	13	funds	fund	NNS
18637	38	14	supplied	supply	VBN
18637	38	15	by	by	IN
18637	38	16	the	the	DT
18637	38	17	succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	38	18	Democratic	democratic	JJ
18637	38	19	81st	81st	NN
18637	38	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	38	21	,	,	,
18637	38	22	while	while	IN
18637	38	23	the	the	DT
18637	38	24	Democratic	democratic	JJ
18637	38	25	82d	82d	NNS
18637	38	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	38	27	extended	extend	VBD
18637	38	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	38	29	coverage	coverage	NN
18637	38	30	to	to	TO
18637	38	31	include	include	VB
18637	38	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	38	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	38	34	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	38	35	through	through	IN
18637	38	36	June	June	NNP
18637	38	37	30	30	CD
18637	38	38	,	,	,
18637	38	39	1952	1952	CD
18637	38	40	.	.	.
18637	39	1	The	the	DT
18637	39	2	document	document	NN
18637	39	3	thus	thus	RB
18637	39	4	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	39	5	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	39	6	nonpartisan	nonpartisan	JJ
18637	39	7	activity	activity	NN
18637	39	8	at	at	IN
18637	39	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	39	10	best	good	JJS
18637	39	11	,	,	,
18637	39	12	as	as	IN
18637	39	13	should	should	MD
18637	39	14	ever	ever	RB
18637	39	15	be	be	VB
18637	39	16	the	the	DT
18637	39	17	case	case	NN
18637	39	18	in	in	IN
18637	39	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	39	20	fidelity	fidelity	NN
18637	39	21	to	to	IN
18637	39	22	this	this	DT
18637	39	23	great	great	JJ
18637	39	24	charter	charter	NN
18637	39	25	.	.	.
18637	40	1	In	in	IN
18637	40	2	the	the	DT
18637	40	3	present	present	JJ
18637	40	4	volume	volume	NN
18637	40	5	,	,	,
18637	40	6	in	in	IN
18637	40	7	addition	addition	NN
18637	40	8	to	to	IN
18637	40	9	the	the	DT
18637	40	10	annotations	annotation	NNS
18637	40	11	indicating	indicate	VBG
18637	40	12	the	the	DT
18637	40	13	current	current	JJ
18637	40	14	state	state	NN
18637	40	15	of	of	IN
18637	40	16	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	40	17	,	,	,
18637	40	18	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
18637	40	19	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	40	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	40	21	undertaken	undertake	VBN
18637	40	22	to	to	TO
18637	40	23	supply	supply	VB
18637	40	24	an	an	DT
18637	40	25	historical	historical	JJ
18637	40	26	background	background	NN
18637	40	27	to	to	IN
18637	40	28	the	the	DT
18637	40	29	several	several	JJ
18637	40	30	lines	line	NNS
18637	40	31	of	of	IN
18637	40	32	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	40	33	.	.	.
18637	41	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	41	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	41	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	41	4	hope	hope	NN
18637	41	5	and	and	CC
18637	41	6	expectation	expectation	NN
18637	41	7	that	that	IN
18637	41	8	this	this	DT
18637	41	9	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	41	10	will	will	MD
18637	41	11	prove	prove	VB
18637	41	12	of	of	IN
18637	41	13	immense	immense	JJ
18637	41	14	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	41	15	to	to	IN
18637	41	16	users	user	NNS
18637	41	17	in	in	IN
18637	41	18	understanding	understand	VBG
18637	41	19	the	the	DT
18637	41	20	trends	trend	NNS
18637	41	21	of	of	IN
18637	41	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	41	23	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	41	24	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	41	25	.	.	.
18637	42	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	42	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	42	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	42	4	further	further	JJ
18637	42	5	hope	hope	NN
18637	42	6	that	that	IN
18637	42	7	this	this	DT
18637	42	8	edition	edition	NN
18637	42	9	as	as	IN
18637	42	10	a	a	DT
18637	42	11	whole	whole	NN
18637	42	12	may	may	MD
18637	42	13	serve	serve	VB
18637	42	14	a	a	DT
18637	42	15	still	still	RB
18637	42	16	larger	large	JJR
18637	42	17	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	42	18	--	--	:
18637	42	19	strengthening	strengthen	VBG
18637	42	20	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	42	21	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	42	22	of	of	IN
18637	42	23	and	and	CC
18637	42	24	loyalty	loyalty	NN
18637	42	25	to	to	IN
18637	42	26	the	the	DT
18637	42	27	principles	principle	NNS
18637	42	28	of	of	IN
18637	42	29	this	this	DT
18637	42	30	republic	republic	NN
18637	42	31	.	.	.
18637	43	1	In	in	IN
18637	43	2	that	that	DT
18637	43	3	way	way	NN
18637	43	4	,	,	,
18637	43	5	the	the	DT
18637	43	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	43	7	will	will	MD
18637	43	8	remain	remain	VB
18637	43	9	the	the	DT
18637	43	10	blueprint	blueprint	NN
18637	43	11	for	for	IN
18637	43	12	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	43	13	.	.	.
18637	44	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	44	2	will	will	MD
18637	44	3	continue	continue	VB
18637	44	4	as	as	IN
18637	44	5	an	an	DT
18637	44	6	inspiration	inspiration	NN
18637	44	7	for	for	IN
18637	44	8	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	44	9	of	of	IN
18637	44	10	this	this	DT
18637	44	11	blessed	bless	VBN
18637	44	12	land	land	NN
18637	44	13	,	,	,
18637	44	14	and	and	CC
18637	44	15	for	for	IN
18637	44	16	men	man	NNS
18637	44	17	and	and	CC
18637	44	18	women	woman	NNS
18637	44	19	everywhere	everywhere	RB
18637	44	20	;	;	:
18637	44	21	for	for	IN
18637	44	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	44	23	look	look	VBP
18637	44	24	to	to	IN
18637	44	25	these	these	DT
18637	44	26	shores	shore	NNS
18637	44	27	as	as	IN
18637	44	28	the	the	DT
18637	44	29	lighthouse	lighthouse	NN
18637	44	30	of	of	IN
18637	44	31	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	44	32	,	,	,
18637	44	33	in	in	IN
18637	44	34	a	a	DT
18637	44	35	world	world	NN
18637	44	36	where	where	WRB
18637	44	37	the	the	DT
18637	44	38	darkness	darkness	NN
18637	44	39	of	of	IN
18637	44	40	despotism	despotism	NN
18637	44	41	hangs	hang	VBZ
18637	44	42	so	so	RB
18637	44	43	heavily	heavily	RB
18637	44	44	.	.	.
18637	45	1	_	_	NNP
18637	45	2	May	May	NNP
18637	45	3	30	30	CD
18637	45	4	,	,	,
18637	45	5	1953	1953	CD
18637	45	6	.	.	.
18637	45	7	_	_	NNP
18637	45	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	45	9	Illustration	illustration	NN
18637	45	10	:	:	:
18637	45	11	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	45	12	Wiley	Wiley	NNP
18637	45	13	signature	signature	NN
18637	45	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	45	15	PREFACE	preface	NN
18637	45	16	For	for	IN
18637	45	17	many	many	JJ
18637	45	18	years	year	NNS
18637	45	19	the	the	DT
18637	45	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	45	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	45	22	felt	feel	VBN
18637	45	23	the	the	DT
18637	45	24	need	need	NN
18637	45	25	for	for	IN
18637	45	26	a	a	DT
18637	45	27	handy	handy	JJ
18637	45	28	,	,	,
18637	45	29	concise	concise	JJ
18637	45	30	guide	guide	NN
18637	45	31	to	to	IN
18637	45	32	the	the	DT
18637	45	33	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	45	34	of	of	IN
18637	45	35	the	the	DT
18637	45	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	45	37	.	.	.
18637	46	1	An	an	DT
18637	46	2	edition	edition	NN
18637	46	3	of	of	IN
18637	46	4	the	the	DT
18637	46	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	46	6	issued	issue	VBN
18637	46	7	in	in	IN
18637	46	8	1913	1913	CD
18637	46	9	as	as	IN
18637	46	10	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	46	11	Document	Document	NNP
18637	46	12	12	12	CD
18637	46	13	,	,	,
18637	46	14	63d	63d	NNPS
18637	46	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	46	16	,	,	,
18637	46	17	took	take	VBD
18637	46	18	a	a	DT
18637	46	19	step	step	NN
18637	46	20	in	in	IN
18637	46	21	this	this	DT
18637	46	22	direction	direction	NN
18637	46	23	by	by	IN
18637	46	24	supplying	supply	VBG
18637	46	25	under	under	IN
18637	46	26	each	each	DT
18637	46	27	clause	clause	NN
18637	46	28	,	,	,
18637	46	29	a	a	DT
18637	46	30	citation	citation	NN
18637	46	31	of	of	IN
18637	46	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	46	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	46	34	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	46	35	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	46	36	.	.	.
18637	47	1	This	this	DT
18637	47	2	was	be	VBD
18637	47	3	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	47	4	of	of	IN
18637	47	5	limited	limited	JJ
18637	47	6	usefulness	usefulness	NN
18637	47	7	,	,	,
18637	47	8	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	47	9	the	the	DT
18637	47	10	reader	reader	NN
18637	47	11	,	,	,
18637	47	12	as	as	IN
18637	47	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	47	14	did	do	VBD
18637	47	15	,	,	,
18637	47	16	to	to	IN
18637	47	17	an	an	DT
18637	47	18	examination	examination	NN
18637	47	19	of	of	IN
18637	47	20	cases	case	NNS
18637	47	21	for	for	IN
18637	47	22	any	any	DT
18637	47	23	specific	specific	JJ
18637	47	24	information	information	NN
18637	47	25	.	.	.
18637	48	1	In	in	IN
18637	48	2	1921	1921	CD
18637	48	3	the	the	DT
18637	48	4	matter	matter	NN
18637	48	5	received	receive	VBD
18637	48	6	further	further	JJ
18637	48	7	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	48	8	.	.	.
18637	49	1	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	49	2	Resolution	Resolution	NNP
18637	49	3	151	151	CD
18637	49	4	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	49	5	preparation	preparation	NN
18637	49	6	of	of	IN
18637	49	7	a	a	DT
18637	49	8	volume	volume	NN
18637	49	9	to	to	TO
18637	49	10	contain	contain	VB
18637	49	11	the	the	DT
18637	49	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	49	13	and	and	CC
18637	49	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	49	15	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	49	16	,	,	,
18637	49	17	to	to	IN
18637	49	18	January	January	NNP
18637	49	19	1	1	CD
18637	49	20	,	,	,
18637	49	21	1923	1923	CD
18637	49	22	"	"	``
18637	49	23	with	with	IN
18637	49	24	citations	citation	NNS
18637	49	25	to	to	IN
18637	49	26	the	the	DT
18637	49	27	cases	case	NNS
18637	49	28	of	of	IN
18637	49	29	the	the	DT
18637	49	30	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	49	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	49	32	of	of	IN
18637	49	33	the	the	DT
18637	49	34	United	United	NNP
18637	49	35	States	States	NNP
18637	49	36	construing	construe	VBG
18637	49	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	49	38	several	several	JJ
18637	49	39	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	49	40	.	.	.
18637	49	41	"	"	''
18637	50	1	This	this	DT
18637	50	2	was	be	VBD
18637	50	3	issued	issue	VBN
18637	50	4	as	as	IN
18637	50	5	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	50	6	Document	Document	NNP
18637	50	7	96	96	CD
18637	50	8	of	of	IN
18637	50	9	the	the	DT
18637	50	10	67th	67th	JJ
18637	50	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	50	12	,	,	,
18637	50	13	and	and	CC
18637	50	14	was	be	VBD
18637	50	15	followed	follow	VBN
18637	50	16	the	the	DT
18637	50	17	next	next	JJ
18637	50	18	year	year	NN
18637	50	19	by	by	IN
18637	50	20	a	a	DT
18637	50	21	similar	similar	JJ
18637	50	22	volume	volume	NN
18637	50	23	annotating	annotate	VBG
18637	50	24	the	the	DT
18637	50	25	cases	case	NNS
18637	50	26	through	through	IN
18637	50	27	the	the	DT
18637	50	28	October	October	NNP
18637	50	29	1923	1923	CD
18637	50	30	Term	Term	NNP
18637	50	31	of	of	IN
18637	50	32	the	the	DT
18637	50	33	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	50	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	50	35	.	.	.
18637	51	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	51	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	51	3	Document	Document	NNP
18637	51	4	154	154	CD
18637	51	5	,	,	,
18637	51	6	68th	68th	JJ
18637	51	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	51	8	.	.	.
18637	51	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	52	1	Both	both	DT
18637	52	2	of	of	IN
18637	52	3	these	these	DT
18637	52	4	volumes	volume	NNS
18637	52	5	went	go	VBD
18637	52	6	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	52	7	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	52	8	the	the	DT
18637	52	9	mere	mere	JJ
18637	52	10	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	52	11	of	of	IN
18637	52	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	52	13	,	,	,
18637	52	14	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	52	15	under	under	IN
18637	52	16	the	the	DT
18637	52	17	particular	particular	JJ
18637	52	18	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	52	19	of	of	IN
18637	52	20	the	the	DT
18637	52	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	52	22	a	a	DT
18637	52	23	brief	brief	JJ
18637	52	24	statement	statement	NN
18637	52	25	of	of	IN
18637	52	26	the	the	DT
18637	52	27	point	point	NN
18637	52	28	involved	involve	VBN
18637	52	29	in	in	IN
18637	52	30	the	the	DT
18637	52	31	principal	principal	JJ
18637	52	32	cases	case	NNS
18637	52	33	cited	cite	VBD
18637	52	34	.	.	.
18637	53	1	Thirteen	thirteen	CD
18637	53	2	years	year	NNS
18637	53	3	of	of	IN
18637	53	4	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	53	5	developments	development	NNS
18637	53	6	led	lead	VBD
18637	53	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	53	8	in	in	IN
18637	53	9	1936	1936	CD
18637	53	10	to	to	TO
18637	53	11	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	53	12	a	a	DT
18637	53	13	revision	revision	NN
18637	53	14	of	of	IN
18637	53	15	the	the	DT
18637	53	16	1924	1924	CD
18637	53	17	volume	volume	NN
18637	53	18	,	,	,
18637	53	19	and	and	CC
18637	53	20	under	under	IN
18637	53	21	authority	authority	NN
18637	53	22	of	of	IN
18637	53	23	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	53	24	Concurrent	Concurrent	NNP
18637	53	25	Resolution	Resolution	NNP
18637	53	26	35	35	CD
18637	53	27	introduced	introduce	VBN
18637	53	28	by	by	IN
18637	53	29	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	53	30	Ashurst	Ashurst	NNP
18637	53	31	,	,	,
18637	53	32	Chairman	Chairman	NNP
18637	53	33	of	of	IN
18637	53	34	the	the	DT
18637	53	35	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	53	36	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	53	37	,	,	,
18637	53	38	such	such	PDT
18637	53	39	a	a	DT
18637	53	40	revision	revision	NN
18637	53	41	was	be	VBD
18637	53	42	prepared	prepare	VBN
18637	53	43	in	in	IN
18637	53	44	the	the	DT
18637	53	45	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	53	46	Reference	Reference	NNP
18637	53	47	Service	Service	NNP
18637	53	48	and	and	CC
18637	53	49	issued	issue	VBD
18637	53	50	as	as	IN
18637	53	51	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	53	52	Document	Document	NNP
18637	53	53	232	232	CD
18637	53	54	,	,	,
18637	53	55	74th	74th	JJ
18637	53	56	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	53	57	.	.	.
18637	54	1	This	this	DT
18637	54	2	volume	volume	NN
18637	54	3	was	be	VBD
18637	54	4	,	,	,
18637	54	5	like	like	IN
18637	54	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	54	7	predecessors	predecessor	NNS
18637	54	8	,	,	,
18637	54	9	dedicated	dedicate	VBN
18637	54	10	to	to	IN
18637	54	11	the	the	DT
18637	54	12	need	need	NN
18637	54	13	felt	feel	VBN
18637	54	14	by	by	IN
18637	54	15	Members	member	NNS
18637	54	16	for	for	IN
18637	54	17	a	a	DT
18637	54	18	convenient	convenient	JJ
18637	54	19	ready	ready	JJ
18637	54	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	54	21	reference	reference	NN
18637	54	22	manual	manual	NN
18637	54	23	.	.	.
18637	55	1	However	however	RB
18637	55	2	,	,	,
18637	55	3	so	so	RB
18637	55	4	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	55	5	and	and	CC
18637	55	6	important	important	JJ
18637	55	7	had	have	VBD
18637	55	8	been	be	VBN
18637	55	9	the	the	DT
18637	55	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	55	11	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	55	12	of	of	IN
18637	55	13	the	the	DT
18637	55	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	55	15	in	in	IN
18637	55	16	the	the	DT
18637	55	17	interim	interim	NN
18637	55	18	that	that	IN
18637	55	19	a	a	DT
18637	55	20	very	very	RB
18637	55	21	much	much	RB
18637	55	22	larger	large	JJR
18637	55	23	volume	volume	NN
18637	55	24	was	be	VBD
18637	55	25	the	the	DT
18637	55	26	result	result	NN
18637	55	27	.	.	.
18637	56	1	After	after	IN
18637	56	2	another	another	DT
18637	56	3	decade	decade	NN
18637	56	4	,	,	,
18637	56	5	in	in	IN
18637	56	6	the	the	DT
18637	56	7	course	course	NN
18637	56	8	of	of	IN
18637	56	9	which	which	WDT
18637	56	10	many	many	JJ
18637	56	11	of	of	IN
18637	56	12	the	the	DT
18637	56	13	earlier	early	JJR
18637	56	14	interpretations	interpretation	NNS
18637	56	15	were	be	VBD
18637	56	16	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	56	17	and	and	CC
18637	56	18	modified	modify	VBN
18637	56	19	,	,	,
18637	56	20	the	the	DT
18637	56	21	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	56	22	again	again	RB
18637	56	23	moved	move	VBD
18637	56	24	for	for	IN
18637	56	25	a	a	DT
18637	56	26	revision	revision	NN
18637	56	27	of	of	IN
18637	56	28	the	the	DT
18637	56	29	Annotations	Annotations	NNPS
18637	56	30	.	.	.
18637	57	1	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	57	2	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	57	3	Resolution	Resolution	NNP
18637	57	4	69	69	CD
18637	57	5	introduced	introduce	VBN
18637	57	6	by	by	IN
18637	57	7	the	the	DT
18637	57	8	then	then	RB
18637	57	9	Chairman	Chairman	NNP
18637	57	10	of	of	IN
18637	57	11	the	the	DT
18637	57	12	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	57	13	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	57	14	,	,	,
18637	57	15	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	57	16	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	57	17	Wiley	Wiley	NNP
18637	57	18	,	,	,
18637	57	19	again	again	RB
18637	57	20	called	call	VBD
18637	57	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	57	22	the	the	DT
18637	57	23	Library	Library	NNP
18637	57	24	of	of	IN
18637	57	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	57	26	to	to	TO
18637	57	27	undertake	undertake	VB
18637	57	28	the	the	DT
18637	57	29	work	work	NN
18637	57	30	.	.	.
18637	58	1	The	the	DT
18637	58	2	confidence	confidence	NN
18637	58	3	thus	thus	RB
18637	58	4	implied	imply	VBN
18637	58	5	was	be	VBD
18637	58	6	most	most	RBS
18637	58	7	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
18637	58	8	appreciated	appreciate	VBN
18637	58	9	.	.	.
18637	59	1	To	to	TO
18637	59	2	meet	meet	VB
18637	59	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	59	4	responsibilities	responsibility	NNS
18637	59	5	,	,	,
18637	59	6	the	the	DT
18637	59	7	Librarian	Librarian	NNP
18637	59	8	called	call	VBD
18637	59	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	59	10	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
18637	59	11	Edward	Edward	NNP
18637	59	12	S.	S.	NNP
18637	59	13	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	59	14	to	to	TO
18637	59	15	head	head	VB
18637	59	16	the	the	DT
18637	59	17	project	project	NN
18637	59	18	.	.	.
18637	60	1	The	the	DT
18637	60	2	collaborating	collaborate	VBG
18637	60	3	staff	staff	NN
18637	60	4	,	,	,
18637	60	5	supplied	supply	VBN
18637	60	6	by	by	IN
18637	60	7	the	the	DT
18637	60	8	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	60	9	Reference	Reference	NNP
18637	60	10	Service	Service	NNP
18637	60	11	,	,	,
18637	60	12	included	include	VBD
18637	60	13	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
18637	60	14	Norman	Norman	NNP
18637	60	15	J.	J.	NNP
18637	61	1	Small	small	JJ
18637	61	2	as	as	IN
18637	61	3	assistant	assistant	NN
18637	61	4	editor	editor	NN
18637	61	5	,	,	,
18637	61	6	Miss	Miss	NNP
18637	61	7	Mary	Mary	NNP
18637	61	8	Louise	Louise	NNP
18637	61	9	Ramsey	Ramsey	NNP
18637	61	10	,	,	,
18637	61	11	and	and	CC
18637	61	12	Robert	Robert	NNP
18637	61	13	J.	J.	NNP
18637	61	14	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	61	15	.	.	.
18637	62	1	This	this	DT
18637	62	2	time	time	NN
18637	62	3	,	,	,
18637	62	4	more	more	RBR
18637	62	5	than	than	IN
18637	62	6	ever	ever	RB
18637	62	7	,	,	,
18637	62	8	the	the	DT
18637	62	9	compilers	compiler	NNS
18637	62	10	faced	face	VBD
18637	62	11	a	a	DT
18637	62	12	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	62	13	task	task	NN
18637	62	14	in	in	IN
18637	62	15	balancing	balance	VBG
18637	62	16	the	the	DT
18637	62	17	prime	prime	JJ
18637	62	18	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	62	19	of	of	IN
18637	62	20	a	a	DT
18637	62	21	thorough	thorough	JJ
18637	62	22	and	and	CC
18637	62	23	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	62	24	annotation	annotation	NN
18637	62	25	against	against	IN
18637	62	26	the	the	DT
18637	62	27	very	very	RB
18637	62	28	practical	practical	JJ
18637	62	29	desire	desire	NN
18637	62	30	to	to	TO
18637	62	31	keep	keep	VB
18637	62	32	the	the	DT
18637	62	33	results	result	NNS
18637	62	34	within	within	IN
18637	62	35	convenient	convenient	JJ
18637	62	36	compass	compass	NN
18637	62	37	.	.	.
18637	63	1	Work	work	VB
18637	63	2	on	on	IN
18637	63	3	the	the	DT
18637	63	4	project	project	NN
18637	63	5	was	be	VBD
18637	63	6	delayed	delay	VBN
18637	63	7	until	until	IN
18637	63	8	funds	fund	NNS
18637	63	9	were	be	VBD
18637	63	10	made	make	VBN
18637	63	11	available	available	JJ
18637	63	12	.	.	.
18637	64	1	In	in	IN
18637	64	2	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	64	3	the	the	DT
18637	64	4	annotations	annotation	NNS
18637	64	5	have	have	VBP
18637	64	6	been	be	VBN
18637	64	7	extended	extend	VBN
18637	64	8	to	to	IN
18637	64	9	a	a	DT
18637	64	10	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	64	11	later	later	JJ
18637	64	12	date	date	NN
18637	64	13	,	,	,
18637	64	14	covering	cover	VBG
18637	64	15	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	64	16	of	of	IN
18637	64	17	the	the	DT
18637	64	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	64	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	64	20	through	through	IN
18637	64	21	June	June	NNP
18637	64	22	30	30	CD
18637	64	23	,	,	,
18637	64	24	1952	1952	CD
18637	64	25	.	.	.
18637	65	1	Ernest	Ernest	NNP
18637	65	2	S.	S.	NNP
18637	65	3	Griffith	Griffith	NNP
18637	65	4	,	,	,
18637	65	5	_	_	NNP
18637	65	6	Director	Director	NNP
18637	65	7	,	,	,
18637	65	8	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	65	9	Reference	Reference	NNP
18637	65	10	Service	Service	NNP
18637	65	11	.	.	.
18637	65	12	_	_	NNP
18637	65	13	EDITOR	EDITOR	NNP
18637	65	14	'S	's	POS
18637	65	15	FOREWORD	FOREWORD	NNP
18637	65	16	The	the	DT
18637	65	17	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	65	18	of	of	IN
18637	65	19	this	this	DT
18637	65	20	volume	volume	NN
18637	65	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	65	22	twofold	twofold	JJ
18637	65	23	;	;	:
18637	65	24	first	first	RB
18637	65	25	,	,	,
18637	65	26	to	to	TO
18637	65	27	set	set	VB
18637	65	28	forth	forth	RP
18637	65	29	so	so	RB
18637	65	30	far	far	RB
18637	65	31	as	as	IN
18637	65	32	feasible	feasible	JJ
18637	65	33	the	the	DT
18637	65	34	currently	currently	RB
18637	65	35	operative	operative	JJ
18637	65	36	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	65	37	of	of	IN
18637	65	38	all	all	DT
18637	65	39	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	65	40	of	of	IN
18637	65	41	the	the	DT
18637	65	42	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	65	43	of	of	IN
18637	65	44	the	the	DT
18637	65	45	United	United	NNP
18637	65	46	States	States	NNP
18637	65	47	;	;	:
18637	65	48	second	second	LS
18637	65	49	,	,	,
18637	65	50	to	to	TO
18637	65	51	trace	trace	VB
18637	65	52	in	in	IN
18637	65	53	the	the	DT
18637	65	54	case	case	NN
18637	65	55	of	of	IN
18637	65	56	the	the	DT
18637	65	57	most	most	RBS
18637	65	58	important	important	JJ
18637	65	59	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	65	60	the	the	DT
18637	65	61	course	course	NN
18637	65	62	of	of	IN
18637	65	63	decision	decision	NN
18637	65	64	and	and	CC
18637	65	65	practice	practice	NN
18637	65	66	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	65	67	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	65	68	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	65	69	was	be	VBD
18637	65	70	arrived	arrive	VBN
18637	65	71	at	at	IN
18637	65	72	by	by	IN
18637	65	73	the	the	DT
18637	65	74	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	65	75	's	's	POS
18637	65	76	official	official	JJ
18637	65	77	interpreters	interpreter	NNS
18637	65	78	.	.	.
18637	66	1	Naturally	naturally	RB
18637	66	2	,	,	,
18637	66	3	the	the	DT
18637	66	4	most	most	RBS
18637	66	5	important	important	JJ
18637	66	6	source	source	NN
18637	66	7	of	of	IN
18637	66	8	material	material	NN
18637	66	9	relied	rely	VBN
18637	66	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	66	11	comprises	comprise	NNS
18637	66	12	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	66	13	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	66	14	of	of	IN
18637	66	15	the	the	DT
18637	66	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	66	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	66	18	;	;	:
18637	66	19	but	but	CC
18637	66	20	acts	act	NNS
18637	66	21	of	of	IN
18637	66	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	66	23	and	and	CC
18637	66	24	Executive	executive	JJ
18637	66	25	orders	order	NNS
18637	66	26	and	and	CC
18637	66	27	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	66	28	have	have	VBP
18637	66	29	also	also	RB
18637	66	30	been	be	VBN
18637	66	31	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	66	32	put	put	VBN
18637	66	33	under	under	IN
18637	66	34	requisition	requisition	NN
18637	66	35	.	.	.
18637	67	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	67	2	,	,	,
18637	67	3	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	67	4	of	of	IN
18637	67	5	the	the	DT
18637	67	6	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	67	7	which	which	WDT
18637	67	8	framed	frame	VBD
18637	67	9	the	the	DT
18637	67	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	67	11	have	have	VBP
18637	67	12	been	be	VBN
18637	67	13	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	67	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	67	15	at	at	IN
18637	67	16	times	time	NNS
18637	67	17	,	,	,
18637	67	18	as	as	IN
18637	67	19	have	have	VBP
18637	67	20	the	the	DT
18637	67	21	views	view	NNS
18637	67	22	of	of	IN
18637	67	23	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	67	24	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	67	25	and	and	CC
18637	67	26	occasionally	occasionally	RB
18637	67	27	of	of	IN
18637	67	28	writers	writer	NNS
18637	67	29	,	,	,
18637	67	30	when	when	WRB
18637	67	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	67	32	was	be	VBD
18637	67	33	thought	think	VBN
18637	67	34	that	that	IN
18637	67	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	67	36	would	would	MD
18637	67	37	aid	aid	VB
18637	67	38	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	67	39	.	.	.
18637	68	1	That	that	IN
18637	68	2	the	the	DT
18637	68	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	68	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	68	5	possessed	possess	VBN
18637	68	6	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	68	7	for	for	IN
18637	68	8	growth	growth	NN
18637	68	9	in	in	IN
18637	68	10	notable	notable	JJ
18637	68	11	measure	measure	NN
18637	68	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	68	13	evidenced	evidence	VBN
18637	68	14	by	by	IN
18637	68	15	the	the	DT
18637	68	16	simple	simple	JJ
18637	68	17	fact	fact	NN
18637	68	18	of	of	IN
18637	68	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	68	20	survival	survival	NN
18637	68	21	and	and	CC
18637	68	22	daily	daily	RB
18637	68	23	functioning	function	VBG
18637	68	24	in	in	IN
18637	68	25	an	an	DT
18637	68	26	environment	environment	NN
18637	68	27	so	so	RB
18637	68	28	vastly	vastly	RB
18637	68	29	different	different	JJ
18637	68	30	from	from	IN
18637	68	31	that	that	DT
18637	68	32	in	in	IN
18637	68	33	which	which	WDT
18637	68	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	68	35	was	be	VBD
18637	68	36	ordained	ordain	VBN
18637	68	37	and	and	CC
18637	68	38	established	establish	VBN
18637	68	39	by	by	IN
18637	68	40	the	the	DT
18637	68	41	American	american	JJ
18637	68	42	people	people	NNS
18637	68	43	.	.	.
18637	69	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	69	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	69	3	this	this	DT
18637	69	4	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	69	5	resided	reside	VBD
18637	69	6	to	to	IN
18637	69	7	any	any	DT
18637	69	8	great	great	JJ
18637	69	9	extent	extent	NN
18637	69	10	in	in	IN
18637	69	11	the	the	DT
18637	69	12	provision	provision	NN
18637	69	13	which	which	WDT
18637	69	14	the	the	DT
18637	69	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	69	16	makes	make	VBZ
18637	69	17	for	for	IN
18637	69	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	69	19	own	own	JJ
18637	69	20	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	69	21	.	.	.
18637	70	1	Far	far	RB
18637	70	2	more	more	JJR
18637	70	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	70	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	70	5	resided	reside	VBN
18637	70	6	in	in	IN
18637	70	7	the	the	DT
18637	70	8	power	power	NN
18637	70	9	of	of	IN
18637	70	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	70	11	review	review	NN
18637	70	12	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	70	13	by	by	IN
18637	70	14	the	the	DT
18637	70	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	70	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	70	17	,	,	,
18637	70	18	the	the	DT
18637	70	19	product	product	NN
18637	70	20	of	of	IN
18637	70	21	which	which	WDT
18637	70	22	,	,	,
18637	70	23	and	and	CC
18637	70	24	hence	hence	RB
18637	70	25	the	the	DT
18637	70	26	record	record	NN
18637	70	27	of	of	IN
18637	70	28	the	the	DT
18637	70	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	70	30	's	's	POS
18637	70	31	achievement	achievement	NN
18637	70	32	in	in	IN
18637	70	33	adapting	adapt	VBG
18637	70	34	the	the	DT
18637	70	35	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	70	36	to	to	IN
18637	70	37	changing	change	VBG
18637	70	38	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	70	39	,	,	,
18637	70	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	70	41	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	70	42	national	national	JJ
18637	70	43	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	70	44	Law	Law	NNP
18637	70	45	.	.	.
18637	71	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	71	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	71	3	explained	explain	VBN
18637	71	4	the	the	DT
18637	71	5	attention	attention	NN
18637	71	6	that	that	WDT
18637	71	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	71	8	been	be	VBN
18637	71	9	given	give	VBN
18637	71	10	in	in	IN
18637	71	11	some	some	DT
18637	71	12	of	of	IN
18637	71	13	these	these	DT
18637	71	14	pages	page	NNS
18637	71	15	to	to	IN
18637	71	16	the	the	DT
18637	71	17	development	development	NN
18637	71	18	of	of	IN
18637	71	19	certain	certain	JJ
18637	71	20	of	of	IN
18637	71	21	the	the	DT
18637	71	22	broader	broad	JJR
18637	71	23	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	71	24	which	which	WDT
18637	71	25	have	have	VBP
18637	71	26	influenced	influence	VBN
18637	71	27	the	the	DT
18637	71	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	71	29	in	in	IN
18637	71	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	71	31	determination	determination	NN
18637	71	32	of	of	IN
18637	71	33	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	71	34	issues	issue	NNS
18637	71	35	,	,	,
18637	71	36	especially	especially	RB
18637	71	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	71	38	conception	conception	NN
18637	71	39	of	of	IN
18637	71	40	the	the	DT
18637	71	41	nature	nature	NN
18637	71	42	of	of	IN
18637	71	43	the	the	DT
18637	71	44	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	71	45	System	System	NNP
18637	71	46	and	and	CC
18637	71	47	of	of	IN
18637	71	48	the	the	DT
18637	71	49	proper	proper	JJ
18637	71	50	role	role	NN
18637	71	51	of	of	IN
18637	71	52	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	71	53	power	power	NN
18637	71	54	in	in	IN
18637	71	55	relation	relation	NN
18637	71	56	to	to	IN
18637	71	57	private	private	JJ
18637	71	58	rights	right	NNS
18637	71	59	.	.	.
18637	72	1	On	on	IN
18637	72	2	both	both	CC
18637	72	3	these	these	DT
18637	72	4	great	great	JJ
18637	72	5	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	72	6	the	the	DT
18637	72	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	72	8	's	's	POS
18637	72	9	thinking	thinking	NN
18637	72	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	72	11	altered	alter	VBN
18637	72	12	at	at	IN
18637	72	13	times	time	NNS
18637	72	14	--	--	:
18637	72	15	on	on	IN
18637	72	16	a	a	DT
18637	72	17	few	few	JJ
18637	72	18	occasions	occasion	NNS
18637	72	19	to	to	IN
18637	72	20	such	such	PDT
18637	72	21	an	an	DT
18637	72	22	extent	extent	NN
18637	72	23	as	as	IN
18637	72	24	to	to	TO
18637	72	25	transcend	transcend	VB
18637	72	26	Tennyson	Tennyson	NNP
18637	72	27	's	's	POS
18637	72	28	idea	idea	NN
18637	72	29	of	of	IN
18637	72	30	the	the	DT
18637	72	31	law	law	NN
18637	72	32	"	"	``
18637	72	33	broadening	broaden	VBG
18637	72	34	from	from	IN
18637	72	35	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	72	36	to	to	IN
18637	72	37	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	72	38	"	"	''
18637	72	39	and	and	CC
18637	72	40	to	to	TO
18637	72	41	amount	amount	VB
18637	72	42	to	to	IN
18637	72	43	something	something	NN
18637	72	44	strongly	strongly	RB
18637	72	45	resembling	resemble	VBG
18637	72	46	a	a	DT
18637	72	47	juridical	juridical	JJ
18637	72	48	revolution	revolution	NN
18637	72	49	,	,	,
18637	72	50	bloodless	bloodless	NN
18637	72	51	but	but	CC
18637	72	52	not	not	RB
18637	72	53	wordless	wordless	JJ
18637	72	54	.	.	.
18637	73	1	The	the	DT
18637	73	2	first	first	JJ
18637	73	3	volume	volume	NN
18637	73	4	of	of	IN
18637	73	5	Reports	report	NNS
18637	73	6	which	which	WDT
18637	73	7	issued	issue	VBD
18637	73	8	from	from	IN
18637	73	9	the	the	DT
18637	73	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	73	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	73	12	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	73	13	's	's	POS
18637	73	14	death--11	death--11	NNP
18637	73	15	Peters	Peters	NNP
18637	73	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	73	17	1837)--signalizes	1837)--signalizes	CD
18637	73	18	such	such	PDT
18637	73	19	a	a	DT
18637	73	20	revolution	revolution	NN
18637	73	21	,	,	,
18637	73	22	that	that	DT
18637	73	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	73	24	to	to	TO
18637	73	25	say	say	VB
18637	73	26	,	,	,
18637	73	27	a	a	DT
18637	73	28	recasting	recasting	NN
18637	73	29	of	of	IN
18637	73	30	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	73	31	concepts	concept	NNS
18637	73	32	;	;	:
18637	73	33	so	so	RB
18637	73	34	does	do	VBZ
18637	73	35	100	100	CD
18637	73	36	years	year	NNS
18637	73	37	later	later	RBR
18637	73	38	,	,	,
18637	73	39	Volume	volume	NN
18637	73	40	301	301	CD
18637	73	41	of	of	IN
18637	73	42	the	the	DT
18637	73	43	United	United	NNP
18637	73	44	States	States	NNP
18637	73	45	Reports	Reports	NNPS
18637	73	46	,	,	,
18637	73	47	in	in	IN
18637	73	48	which	which	WDT
18637	73	49	the	the	DT
18637	73	50	National	National	NNP
18637	73	51	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	73	52	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	73	53	Act	Act	NNP
18637	73	54	[	[	-LRB-
18637	73	55	The	the	DT
18637	73	56	"	"	``
18637	73	57	Wagner	Wagner	NNP
18637	73	58	Act	Act	NNP
18637	73	59	"	"	''
18637	73	60	]	]	-RRB-
18637	73	61	and	and	CC
18637	73	62	the	the	DT
18637	73	63	Social	Social	NNP
18637	73	64	Security	Security	NNP
18637	73	65	Act	Act	NNP
18637	73	66	of	of	IN
18637	73	67	1935	1935	CD
18637	73	68	were	be	VBD
18637	73	69	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	73	70	.	.	.
18637	74	1	Another	another	DT
18637	74	2	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	74	3	revolution	revolution	NN
18637	74	4	was	be	VBD
18637	74	5	marked	mark	VBN
18637	74	6	by	by	IN
18637	74	7	the	the	DT
18637	74	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	74	9	's	's	POS
18637	74	10	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	74	11	in	in	IN
18637	74	12	1925	1925	CD
18637	74	13	of	of	IN
18637	74	14	the	the	DT
18637	74	15	theory	theory	NN
18637	74	16	that	that	IN
18637	74	17	the	the	DT
18637	74	18	word	word	NN
18637	74	19	"	"	``
18637	74	20	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	74	21	"	"	''
18637	74	22	in	in	IN
18637	74	23	the	the	DT
18637	74	24	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	74	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	74	26	rendered	render	VBD
18637	74	27	the	the	DT
18637	74	28	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	74	29	of	of	IN
18637	74	30	the	the	DT
18637	74	31	First	First	NNP
18637	74	32	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	74	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	74	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	74	35	available	available	JJ
18637	74	36	also	also	RB
18637	74	37	against	against	IN
18637	74	38	the	the	DT
18637	74	39	States	States	NNP
18637	74	40	.	.	.
18637	75	1	In	in	IN
18637	75	2	the	the	DT
18637	75	3	preparation	preparation	NN
18637	75	4	of	of	IN
18637	75	5	this	this	DT
18637	75	6	volume	volume	NN
18637	75	7	constant	constant	JJ
18637	75	8	use	use	NN
18637	75	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	75	10	been	be	VBN
18637	75	11	made	make	VBN
18637	75	12	of	of	IN
18637	75	13	"	"	``
18637	75	14	The	the	DT
18637	75	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	75	16	of	of	IN
18637	75	17	the	the	DT
18637	75	18	United	United	NNP
18637	75	19	States	States	NNP
18637	75	20	of	of	IN
18637	75	21	America	America	NNP
18637	75	22	Annotated	annotate	VBD
18637	75	23	,	,	,
18637	75	24	"	"	''
18637	75	25	which	which	WDT
18637	75	26	was	be	VBD
18637	75	27	brought	bring	VBN
18637	75	28	out	out	RP
18637	75	29	under	under	IN
18637	75	30	the	the	DT
18637	75	31	editorship	editorship	NN
18637	75	32	of	of	IN
18637	75	33	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	75	34	W.C.	W.C.	NNP
18637	75	35	Gilbert	Gilbert	NNP
18637	75	36	in	in	IN
18637	75	37	1938	1938	CD
18637	75	38	.	.	.
18637	76	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	76	2	copious	copious	JJ
18637	76	3	listing	listing	NN
18637	76	4	of	of	IN
18637	76	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	76	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	76	7	been	be	VBN
18637	76	8	especially	especially	RB
18637	76	9	valuable	valuable	JJ
18637	76	10	.	.	.
18637	77	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	77	2	admirable	admirable	JJ
18637	77	3	Tables	table	NNS
18637	77	4	of	of	IN
18637	77	5	Contents	Contents	NNPS
18637	77	6	and	and	CC
18637	77	7	Index	Index	NNP
18637	77	8	have	have	VBP
18637	77	9	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	77	10	a	a	DT
18637	77	11	model	model	NN
18637	77	12	for	for	IN
18637	77	13	those	those	DT
18637	77	14	of	of	IN
18637	77	15	the	the	DT
18637	77	16	present	present	JJ
18637	77	17	volume	volume	NN
18637	77	18	.	.	.
18637	78	1	If	if	IN
18637	78	2	this	this	DT
18637	78	3	model	model	NN
18637	78	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	78	5	been	be	VBN
18637	78	6	approximated	approximate	VBN
18637	78	7	the	the	DT
18637	78	8	contents	content	NNS
18637	78	9	of	of	IN
18637	78	10	this	this	DT
18637	78	11	volume	volume	NN
18637	78	12	ought	ought	MD
18637	78	13	to	to	TO
18637	78	14	be	be	VB
18637	78	15	readily	readily	RB
18637	78	16	accessible	accessible	JJ
18637	78	17	despite	despite	IN
18637	78	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	78	19	size	size	NN
18637	78	20	.	.	.
18637	79	1	The	the	DT
18637	79	2	coverage	coverage	NN
18637	79	3	of	of	IN
18637	79	4	the	the	DT
18637	79	5	volume	volume	NN
18637	79	6	ends	end	VBZ
18637	79	7	with	with	IN
18637	79	8	the	the	DT
18637	79	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	79	10	decided	decide	VBD
18637	79	11	June	June	NNP
18637	79	12	,	,	,
18637	79	13	1952	1952	CD
18637	79	14	.	.	.
18637	80	1	A	a	DT
18637	80	2	personal	personal	JJ
18637	80	3	word	word	NN
18637	80	4	or	or	CC
18637	80	5	two	two	CD
18637	80	6	must	must	MD
18637	80	7	be	be	VB
18637	80	8	added	add	VBN
18637	80	9	.	.	.
18637	81	1	The	the	DT
18637	81	2	Editor	Editor	NNP
18637	81	3	was	be	VBD
18637	81	4	invited	invite	VBN
18637	81	5	to	to	TO
18637	81	6	undertake	undertake	VB
18637	81	7	this	this	DT
18637	81	8	project	project	NN
18637	81	9	by	by	IN
18637	81	10	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
18637	81	11	Ernest	Ernest	NNP
18637	81	12	S.	S.	NNP
18637	81	13	Griffith	Griffith	NNP
18637	81	14	,	,	,
18637	81	15	Director	Director	NNP
18637	81	16	of	of	IN
18637	81	17	the	the	DT
18637	81	18	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	81	19	Reference	Reference	NNP
18637	81	20	Service	Service	NNP
18637	81	21	of	of	IN
18637	81	22	the	the	DT
18637	81	23	Library	Library	NNP
18637	81	24	of	of	IN
18637	81	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	81	26	,	,	,
18637	81	27	and	and	CC
18637	81	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	81	29	constant	constant	JJ
18637	81	30	interest	interest	NN
18637	81	31	in	in	IN
18637	81	32	the	the	DT
18637	81	33	progress	progress	NN
18637	81	34	of	of	IN
18637	81	35	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	81	36	labors	labor	NNS
18637	81	37	has	have	VBZ
18637	81	38	been	be	VBN
18637	81	39	a	a	DT
18637	81	40	tremendous	tremendous	JJ
18637	81	41	source	source	NN
18637	81	42	of	of	IN
18637	81	43	encouragement	encouragement	NN
18637	81	44	.	.	.
18637	82	1	To	to	IN
18637	82	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	82	3	able	able	JJ
18637	82	4	collaborators	collaborator	NNS
18637	82	5	the	the	DT
18637	82	6	Editor	Editor	NNP
18637	82	7	will	will	MD
18637	82	8	not	not	RB
18637	82	9	attempt	attempt	VB
18637	82	10	to	to	TO
18637	82	11	express	express	VB
18637	82	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	82	13	appreciation	appreciation	NN
18637	82	14	--	--	:
18637	82	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	82	16	share	share	VBP
18637	82	17	with	with	IN
18637	82	18	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	82	19	the	the	DT
18637	82	20	credit	credit	NN
18637	82	21	for	for	IN
18637	82	22	such	such	JJ
18637	82	23	merits	merit	NNS
18637	82	24	as	as	IN
18637	82	25	the	the	DT
18637	82	26	work	work	NN
18637	82	27	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	82	28	and	and	CC
18637	82	29	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	82	30	for	for	IN
18637	82	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	82	32	short	short	JJ
18637	82	33	comings	coming	NNS
18637	82	34	.	.	.
18637	83	1	And	and	CC
18637	83	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	83	3	am	be	VBP
18637	83	4	sure	sure	JJ
18637	83	5	that	that	IN
18637	83	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	83	7	join	join	VBP
18637	83	8	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	83	9	in	in	IN
18637	83	10	thanking	thank	VBG
18637	83	11	Miss	Miss	NNP
18637	83	12	Evelyn	Evelyn	NNP
18637	83	13	K.	K.	NNP
18637	83	14	Mayhugh	Mayhugh	NNP
18637	83	15	for	for	IN
18637	83	16	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	83	17	skill	skill	NN
18637	83	18	and	and	CC
18637	83	19	devotion	devotion	NN
18637	83	20	in	in	IN
18637	83	21	aiding	aid	VBG
18637	83	22	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	83	23	at	at	IN
18637	83	24	every	every	DT
18637	83	25	step	step	NN
18637	83	26	in	in	IN
18637	83	27	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	83	28	common	common	JJ
18637	83	29	task	task	NN
18637	83	30	.	.	.
18637	84	1	Edward	Edward	NNP
18637	84	2	S.	S.	NNP
18637	84	3	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	84	4	.	.	.
18637	85	1	INTRODUCTION	INTRODUCTION	NNP
18637	85	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	85	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	85	4	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	85	5	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	85	6	in	in	IN
18637	85	7	this	this	DT
18637	85	8	Introduction	introduction	NN
18637	85	9	to	to	IN
18637	85	10	the	the	DT
18637	85	11	_	_	NNP
18637	85	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	85	13	of	of	IN
18637	85	14	the	the	DT
18637	85	15	United	United	NNP
18637	85	16	States	States	NNP
18637	85	17	,	,	,
18637	85	18	Annotated	Annotated	NNP
18637	85	19	_	_	NNP
18637	85	20	to	to	TO
18637	85	21	sketch	sketch	VB
18637	85	22	rapidly	rapidly	RB
18637	85	23	certain	certain	JJ
18637	85	24	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	85	25	phases	phase	NNS
18637	85	26	of	of	IN
18637	85	27	the	the	DT
18637	85	28	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	85	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	85	30	's	's	POS
18637	85	31	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	85	32	of	of	IN
18637	85	33	the	the	DT
18637	85	34	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	85	35	for	for	IN
18637	85	36	the	the	DT
18637	85	37	illustration	illustration	NN
18637	85	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	85	39	may	may	MD
18637	85	40	afford	afford	VB
18637	85	41	of	of	IN
18637	85	42	the	the	DT
18637	85	43	interests	interest	NNS
18637	85	44	,	,	,
18637	85	45	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	85	46	,	,	,
18637	85	47	and	and	CC
18637	85	48	contingencies	contingency	NNS
18637	85	49	which	which	WDT
18637	85	50	have	have	VBP
18637	85	51	from	from	IN
18637	85	52	time	time	NN
18637	85	53	to	to	IN
18637	85	54	time	time	NN
18637	85	55	influenced	influence	VBD
18637	85	56	the	the	DT
18637	85	57	Court	Court	NNP
18637	85	58	in	in	IN
18637	85	59	this	this	DT
18637	85	60	still	still	RB
18637	85	61	supremely	supremely	RB
18637	85	62	important	important	JJ
18637	85	63	area	area	NN
18637	85	64	of	of	IN
18637	85	65	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	85	66	powers	power	NNS
18637	85	67	and	and	CC
18637	85	68	of	of	IN
18637	85	69	the	the	DT
18637	85	70	comparable	comparable	JJ
18637	85	71	factors	factor	NNS
18637	85	72	which	which	WDT
18637	85	73	give	give	VBP
18637	85	74	direction	direction	NN
18637	85	75	to	to	IN
18637	85	76	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	85	77	work	work	NN
18637	85	78	in	in	IN
18637	85	79	the	the	DT
18637	85	80	same	same	JJ
18637	85	81	field	field	NN
18637	85	82	at	at	IN
18637	85	83	the	the	DT
18637	85	84	present	present	JJ
18637	85	85	time	time	NN
18637	85	86	.	.	.
18637	86	1	As	as	IN
18637	86	2	employed	employ	VBN
18637	86	3	in	in	IN
18637	86	4	this	this	DT
18637	86	5	country	country	NN
18637	86	6	,	,	,
18637	86	7	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	86	8	Law	Law	NNP
18637	86	9	signifies	signify	VBZ
18637	86	10	a	a	DT
18637	86	11	body	body	NN
18637	86	12	of	of	IN
18637	86	13	rules	rule	NNS
18637	86	14	resulting	result	VBG
18637	86	15	from	from	IN
18637	86	16	the	the	DT
18637	86	17	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	86	18	by	by	IN
18637	86	19	a	a	DT
18637	86	20	high	high	JJ
18637	86	21	court	court	NN
18637	86	22	of	of	IN
18637	86	23	a	a	DT
18637	86	24	written	write	VBN
18637	86	25	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	86	26	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	86	27	in	in	IN
18637	86	28	the	the	DT
18637	86	29	course	course	NN
18637	86	30	of	of	IN
18637	86	31	disposing	dispose	VBG
18637	86	32	of	of	IN
18637	86	33	cases	case	NNS
18637	86	34	in	in	IN
18637	86	35	which	which	WDT
18637	86	36	the	the	DT
18637	86	37	validity	validity	NN
18637	86	38	,	,	,
18637	86	39	in	in	IN
18637	86	40	relation	relation	NN
18637	86	41	to	to	IN
18637	86	42	the	the	DT
18637	86	43	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	86	44	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	86	45	,	,	,
18637	86	46	of	of	IN
18637	86	47	some	some	DT
18637	86	48	act	act	NN
18637	86	49	of	of	IN
18637	86	50	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	86	51	power	power	NN
18637	86	52	,	,	,
18637	86	53	State	State	NNP
18637	86	54	or	or	CC
18637	86	55	national	national	JJ
18637	86	56	,	,	,
18637	86	57	has	have	VBZ
18637	86	58	been	be	VBN
18637	86	59	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	86	60	.	.	.
18637	87	1	This	this	DT
18637	87	2	function	function	NN
18637	87	3	,	,	,
18637	87	4	conveniently	conveniently	RB
18637	87	5	labelled	label	VBN
18637	87	6	"	"	``
18637	87	7	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	87	8	Review	Review	NNP
18637	87	9	,	,	,
18637	87	10	"	"	''
18637	87	11	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	87	12	the	the	DT
18637	87	13	power	power	NN
18637	87	14	and	and	CC
18637	87	15	duty	duty	NN
18637	87	16	on	on	IN
18637	87	17	the	the	DT
18637	87	18	part	part	NN
18637	87	19	of	of	IN
18637	87	20	the	the	DT
18637	87	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	87	22	of	of	IN
18637	87	23	pronouncing	pronounce	VBG
18637	87	24	void	void	VBP
18637	87	25	any	any	DT
18637	87	26	such	such	JJ
18637	87	27	act	act	NN
18637	87	28	which	which	WDT
18637	87	29	does	do	VBZ
18637	87	30	not	not	RB
18637	87	31	square	square	VB
18637	87	32	with	with	IN
18637	87	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	87	34	own	own	JJ
18637	87	35	reading	reading	NN
18637	87	36	of	of	IN
18637	87	37	the	the	DT
18637	87	38	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	87	39	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	87	40	.	.	.
18637	88	1	Theoretically	theoretically	RB
18637	88	2	,	,	,
18637	88	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	88	4	,	,	,
18637	88	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	88	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	88	7	a	a	DT
18637	88	8	purely	purely	RB
18637	88	9	juristic	juristic	JJ
18637	88	10	product	product	NN
18637	88	11	,	,	,
18637	88	12	and	and	CC
18637	88	13	as	as	IN
18637	88	14	such	such	JJ
18637	88	15	does	do	VBZ
18637	88	16	not	not	RB
18637	88	17	alter	alter	VB
18637	88	18	the	the	DT
18637	88	19	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	88	20	.	.	.
18637	89	1	To	to	IN
18637	89	2	those	those	DT
18637	89	3	who	who	WP
18637	89	4	hold	hold	VBP
18637	89	5	this	this	DT
18637	89	6	theory	theory	NN
18637	89	7	,	,	,
18637	89	8	the	the	DT
18637	89	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	89	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	89	11	not	not	RB
18637	89	12	elaborate	elaborate	VB
18637	89	13	the	the	DT
18637	89	14	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	89	15	,	,	,
18637	89	16	as	as	IN
18637	89	17	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	89	18	power	power	NN
18637	89	19	might	may	MD
18637	89	20	;	;	:
18637	89	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	89	22	elucidates	elucidate	VBZ
18637	89	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	89	24	,	,	,
18637	89	25	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	89	26	forth	forth	RP
18637	89	27	into	into	IN
18637	89	28	the	the	DT
18637	89	29	light	light	NN
18637	89	30	of	of	IN
18637	89	31	day	day	NN
18637	89	32	,	,	,
18637	89	33	as	as	IN
18637	89	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	89	35	were	be	VBD
18637	89	36	,	,	,
18637	89	37	what	what	WP
18637	89	38	was	be	VBD
18637	89	39	in	in	IN
18637	89	40	the	the	DT
18637	89	41	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	89	42	from	from	IN
18637	89	43	the	the	DT
18637	89	44	first	first	JJ
18637	89	45	.	.	.
18637	90	1	In	in	IN
18637	90	2	the	the	DT
18637	90	3	case	case	NN
18637	90	4	of	of	IN
18637	90	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	90	6	review	review	NN
18637	90	7	as	as	IN
18637	90	8	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	90	9	by	by	IN
18637	90	10	the	the	DT
18637	90	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	90	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	90	13	of	of	IN
18637	90	14	the	the	DT
18637	90	15	United	United	NNP
18637	90	16	States	States	NNP
18637	90	17	in	in	IN
18637	90	18	relation	relation	NN
18637	90	19	to	to	IN
18637	90	20	the	the	DT
18637	90	21	national	national	JJ
18637	90	22	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	90	23	,	,	,
18637	90	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	90	25	preservative	preservative	JJ
18637	90	26	character	character	NN
18637	90	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	90	28	been	be	VBN
18637	90	29	at	at	IN
18637	90	30	times	time	NNS
18637	90	31	a	a	DT
18637	90	32	theme	theme	NN
18637	90	33	of	of	IN
18637	90	34	enthusiastic	enthusiastic	JJ
18637	90	35	encomium	encomium	NN
18637	90	36	,	,	,
18637	90	37	as	as	IN
18637	90	38	in	in	IN
18637	90	39	the	the	DT
18637	90	40	following	follow	VBG
18637	90	41	passage	passage	NN
18637	90	42	from	from	IN
18637	90	43	a	a	DT
18637	90	44	speech	speech	NN
18637	90	45	by	by	IN
18637	90	46	the	the	DT
18637	90	47	late	late	JJ
18637	90	48	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	90	49	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	90	50	White	White	NNP
18637	90	51	,	,	,
18637	90	52	made	make	VBN
18637	90	53	shortly	shortly	RB
18637	90	54	before	before	IN
18637	90	55	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	90	56	ascended	ascend	VBD
18637	90	57	the	the	DT
18637	90	58	Bench	Bench	NNP
18637	90	59	:	:	:
18637	90	60	...	...	.
18637	91	1	The	the	DT
18637	91	2	glory	glory	NN
18637	91	3	and	and	CC
18637	91	4	ornament	ornament	NN
18637	91	5	of	of	IN
18637	91	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	91	7	system	system	NN
18637	91	8	which	which	WDT
18637	91	9	distinguishes	distinguish	VBZ
18637	91	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	91	11	from	from	IN
18637	91	12	every	every	DT
18637	91	13	other	other	JJ
18637	91	14	government	government	NN
18637	91	15	on	on	IN
18637	91	16	the	the	DT
18637	91	17	face	face	NN
18637	91	18	of	of	IN
18637	91	19	the	the	DT
18637	91	20	earth	earth	NN
18637	91	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	91	22	that	that	IN
18637	91	23	there	there	EX
18637	91	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	91	25	a	a	DT
18637	91	26	great	great	JJ
18637	91	27	and	and	CC
18637	91	28	mighty	mighty	JJ
18637	91	29	power	power	NN
18637	91	30	hovering	hovering	NN
18637	91	31	over	over	IN
18637	91	32	the	the	DT
18637	91	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	91	34	of	of	IN
18637	91	35	the	the	DT
18637	91	36	land	land	NN
18637	91	37	to	to	TO
18637	91	38	which	which	WDT
18637	91	39	has	have	VBZ
18637	91	40	been	be	VBN
18637	91	41	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	91	42	the	the	DT
18637	91	43	awful	awful	JJ
18637	91	44	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	91	45	of	of	IN
18637	91	46	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	91	47	all	all	PDT
18637	91	48	the	the	DT
18637	91	49	coordinate	coordinate	JJ
18637	91	50	departments	department	NNS
18637	91	51	of	of	IN
18637	91	52	government	government	NN
18637	91	53	within	within	IN
18637	91	54	the	the	DT
18637	91	55	walls	wall	NNS
18637	91	56	of	of	IN
18637	91	57	the	the	DT
18637	91	58	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	91	59	fabric	fabric	NN
18637	91	60	which	which	WDT
18637	91	61	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	91	62	fathers	father	NNS
18637	91	63	built	build	VBN
18637	91	64	for	for	IN
18637	91	65	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	91	66	protection	protection	NN
18637	91	67	and	and	CC
18637	91	68	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	91	69	.	.	.
18637	92	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	92	2	1	1	CD
18637	92	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	92	4	At	at	IN
18637	92	5	other	other	JJ
18637	92	6	times	time	NNS
18637	92	7	the	the	DT
18637	92	8	subject	subject	NN
18637	92	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	92	10	been	be	VBN
18637	92	11	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	92	12	with	with	IN
18637	92	13	less	less	RBR
18637	92	14	enthusiastically	enthusiastically	RB
18637	92	15	,	,	,
18637	92	16	even	even	RB
18637	92	17	skeptically	skeptically	RB
18637	92	18	.	.	.
18637	93	1	One	one	CD
18637	93	2	obstacle	obstacle	NN
18637	93	3	that	that	WDT
18637	93	4	the	the	DT
18637	93	5	theory	theory	NN
18637	93	6	encountered	encounter	VBD
18637	93	7	very	very	RB
18637	93	8	early	early	RB
18637	93	9	was	be	VBD
18637	93	10	the	the	DT
18637	93	11	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	93	12	of	of	IN
18637	93	13	certain	certain	JJ
18637	93	14	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	93	15	to	to	TO
18637	93	16	regard	regard	VB
18637	93	17	the	the	DT
18637	93	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	93	19	as	as	IN
18637	93	20	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	93	21	a	a	DT
18637	93	22	source	source	NN
18637	93	23	of	of	IN
18637	93	24	rules	rule	NNS
18637	93	25	for	for	IN
18637	93	26	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	93	27	decision	decision	NN
18637	93	28	.	.	.
18637	94	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	94	2	was	be	VBD
18637	94	3	rather	rather	RB
18637	94	4	,	,	,
18637	94	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	94	6	urged	urge	VBD
18637	94	7	,	,	,
18637	94	8	a	a	DT
18637	94	9	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	94	10	discretionary	discretionary	JJ
18637	94	11	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	94	12	to	to	IN
18637	94	13	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	94	14	and	and	CC
18637	94	15	to	to	IN
18637	94	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	94	17	.	.	.
18637	95	1	And	and	CC
18637	95	2	pursuing	pursue	VBG
18637	95	3	the	the	DT
18637	95	4	logic	logic	NN
18637	95	5	of	of	IN
18637	95	6	this	this	DT
18637	95	7	position	position	NN
18637	95	8	,	,	,
18637	95	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	95	10	contended	contend	VBD
18637	95	11	that	that	IN
18637	95	12	while	while	IN
18637	95	13	the	the	DT
18637	95	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	95	15	was	be	VBD
18637	95	16	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	95	17	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	95	18	to	to	TO
18637	95	19	read	read	VB
18637	95	20	the	the	DT
18637	95	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	95	22	independently	independently	RB
18637	95	23	for	for	IN
18637	95	24	the	the	DT
18637	95	25	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	95	26	of	of	IN
18637	95	27	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	95	28	cases	case	NNS
18637	95	29	,	,	,
18637	95	30	this	this	DT
18637	95	31	very	very	JJ
18637	95	32	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	95	33	automatically	automatically	RB
18637	95	34	limited	limit	VBD
18637	95	35	the	the	DT
18637	95	36	authoritativeness	authoritativeness	NN
18637	95	37	of	of	IN
18637	95	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	95	39	readings	reading	NNS
18637	95	40	;	;	:
18637	95	41	and	and	CC
18637	95	42	that	that	IN
18637	95	43	within	within	IN
18637	95	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	95	45	respective	respective	JJ
18637	95	46	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NNS
18637	95	47	President	President	NNP
18637	95	48	and	and	CC
18637	95	49	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	95	50	enjoyed	enjoy	VBD
18637	95	51	the	the	DT
18637	95	52	same	same	JJ
18637	95	53	correlative	correlative	JJ
18637	95	54	independence	independence	NN
18637	95	55	as	as	IN
18637	95	56	the	the	DT
18637	95	57	Court	Court	NNP
18637	95	58	did	do	VBD
18637	95	59	within	within	IN
18637	95	60	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	95	61	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	95	62	.	.	.
18637	96	1	This	this	DT
18637	96	2	was	be	VBD
18637	96	3	,	,	,
18637	96	4	in	in	IN
18637	96	5	effect	effect	NN
18637	96	6	,	,	,
18637	96	7	the	the	DT
18637	96	8	position	position	NN
18637	96	9	earlier	early	RBR
18637	96	10	of	of	IN
18637	96	11	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	96	12	and	and	CC
18637	96	13	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	96	14	,	,	,
18637	96	15	later	later	RB
18637	96	16	of	of	IN
18637	96	17	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	96	18	,	,	,
18637	96	19	and	and	CC
18637	96	20	in	in	IN
18637	96	21	recent	recent	JJ
18637	96	22	times	time	NNS
18637	96	23	that	that	DT
18637	96	24	of	of	IN
18637	96	25	the	the	DT
18637	96	26	two	two	CD
18637	96	27	Roosevelts	Roosevelts	NNPS
18637	96	28	.	.	.
18637	97	1	Another	another	DT
18637	97	2	obstacle	obstacle	NN
18637	97	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	97	4	been	be	VBN
18637	97	5	of	of	IN
18637	97	6	the	the	DT
18637	97	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	97	8	's	's	POS
18637	97	9	own	own	JJ
18637	97	10	making	making	NN
18637	97	11	.	.	.
18637	98	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	98	2	because	because	IN
18637	98	3	of	of	IN
18637	98	4	the	the	DT
18637	98	5	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	98	6	of	of	IN
18637	98	7	amending	amend	VBG
18637	98	8	the	the	DT
18637	98	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	98	10	or	or	CC
18637	98	11	for	for	IN
18637	98	12	cautionary	cautionary	JJ
18637	98	13	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	98	14	,	,	,
18637	98	15	the	the	DT
18637	98	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	98	17	took	take	VBD
18637	98	18	the	the	DT
18637	98	19	position	position	NN
18637	98	20	,	,	,
18637	98	21	as	as	RB
18637	98	22	early	early	RB
18637	98	23	as	as	IN
18637	98	24	1851	1851	CD
18637	98	25	,	,	,
18637	98	26	that	that	IN
18637	98	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	98	28	would	would	MD
18637	98	29	reverse	reverse	VB
18637	98	30	previous	previous	JJ
18637	98	31	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	98	32	on	on	IN
18637	98	33	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	98	34	issues	issue	NNS
18637	98	35	when	when	WRB
18637	98	36	convinced	convinced	JJ
18637	98	37	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	98	38	were	be	VBD
18637	98	39	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
18637	98	40	.	.	.
18637	99	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	99	2	2	2	LS
18637	99	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	99	4	An	an	DT
18637	99	5	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	99	6	instance	instance	NN
18637	99	7	of	of	IN
18637	99	8	this	this	DT
18637	99	9	nature	nature	NN
18637	99	10	was	be	VBD
18637	99	11	the	the	DT
18637	99	12	decision	decision	NN
18637	99	13	in	in	IN
18637	99	14	the	the	DT
18637	99	15	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	99	16	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	99	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	99	18	,	,	,
18637	99	19	in	in	IN
18637	99	20	1871	1871	CD
18637	99	21	,	,	,
18637	99	22	reversing	reverse	VBG
18637	99	23	the	the	DT
18637	99	24	decision	decision	NN
18637	99	25	which	which	WDT
18637	99	26	had	have	VBD
18637	99	27	been	be	VBN
18637	99	28	rendered	render	VBN
18637	99	29	in	in	IN
18637	99	30	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	99	31	_	_	NNP
18637	99	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	99	33	_	_	NNP
18637	99	34	Griswold	Griswold	NNP
18637	99	35	fifteen	fifteen	CD
18637	99	36	months	month	NNS
18637	99	37	earlier;[3	earlier;[3	JJ
18637	99	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	99	39	and	and	CC
18637	99	40	no	no	RB
18637	99	41	less	less	RBR
18637	99	42	shattering	shatter	VBG
18637	99	43	to	to	IN
18637	99	44	the	the	DT
18637	99	45	prestige	prestige	NN
18637	99	46	of	of	IN
18637	99	47	_	_	NNP
18637	99	48	stare	stare	NN
18637	99	49	decisis	decisis	NN
18637	99	50	_	_	NNP
18637	99	51	in	in	IN
18637	99	52	the	the	DT
18637	99	53	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	99	54	field	field	NN
18637	99	55	was	be	VBD
18637	99	56	the	the	DT
18637	99	57	Income	Income	NNP
18637	99	58	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	99	59	decision	decision	NN
18637	99	60	of	of	IN
18637	99	61	1895,[4	1895,[4	CD
18637	99	62	]	]	-RRB-
18637	99	63	in	in	IN
18637	99	64	which	which	WDT
18637	99	65	the	the	DT
18637	99	66	Court	Court	NNP
18637	99	67	accepted	accept	VBD
18637	99	68	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	99	69	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
18637	99	70	Choate	Choate	NNP
18637	99	71	's	's	POS
18637	99	72	invitation	invitation	NN
18637	99	73	to	to	TO
18637	99	74	"	"	``
18637	99	75	correct	correct	VB
18637	99	76	a	a	DT
18637	99	77	century	century	NN
18637	99	78	of	of	IN
18637	99	79	error	error	NN
18637	99	80	"	"	''
18637	99	81	.	.	.
18637	100	1	The	the	DT
18637	100	2	"	"	``
18637	100	3	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	100	4	revolution	revolution	NN
18637	100	5	"	"	''
18637	100	6	of	of	IN
18637	100	7	1937	1937	CD
18637	100	8	produced	produce	VBD
18637	100	9	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	100	10	reversals	reversal	NNS
18637	100	11	of	of	IN
18637	100	12	earlier	early	JJR
18637	100	13	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	100	14	on	on	IN
18637	100	15	the	the	DT
18637	100	16	ground	ground	NN
18637	100	17	of	of	IN
18637	100	18	"	"	``
18637	100	19	error	error	NN
18637	100	20	"	"	''
18637	100	21	,	,	,
18637	100	22	some	some	DT
18637	100	23	of	of	IN
18637	100	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	100	25	,	,	,
18637	100	26	the	the	DT
18637	100	27	late	late	JJ
18637	100	28	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	100	29	James	James	NNP
18637	100	30	M.	M.	NNP
18637	100	31	Beck	Beck	NNP
18637	100	32	complained	complain	VBD
18637	100	33	,	,	,
18637	100	34	without	without	IN
18637	100	35	"	"	``
18637	100	36	the	the	DT
18637	100	37	obsequious	obsequious	JJ
18637	100	38	respect	respect	NN
18637	100	39	of	of	IN
18637	100	40	a	a	DT
18637	100	41	funeral	funeral	JJ
18637	100	42	oration	oration	NN
18637	100	43	"	"	''
18637	100	44	.	.	.
18637	101	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	101	2	5	5	CD
18637	101	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	101	4	In	in	IN
18637	101	5	1944	1944	CD
18637	101	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	101	7	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	101	8	cited	cite	VBD
18637	101	9	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	101	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	101	11	decided	decide	VBN
18637	101	12	between	between	IN
18637	101	13	March	March	NNP
18637	101	14	27	27	CD
18637	101	15	,	,	,
18637	101	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	101	17	and	and	CC
18637	101	18	June	June	NNP
18637	101	19	14	14	CD
18637	101	20	,	,	,
18637	101	21	1943	1943	CD
18637	101	22	in	in	IN
18637	101	23	which	which	WDT
18637	101	24	one	one	CD
18637	101	25	or	or	CC
18637	101	26	more	more	JJR
18637	101	27	prior	prior	JJ
18637	101	28	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	101	29	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	101	30	were	be	VBD
18637	101	31	overturned	overturn	VBN
18637	101	32	.	.	.
18637	102	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	102	2	6	6	CD
18637	102	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	102	4	On	on	IN
18637	102	5	the	the	DT
18637	102	6	same	same	JJ
18637	102	7	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	102	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	102	9	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	102	10	expressed	express	VBD
18637	102	11	the	the	DT
18637	102	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	102	13	that	that	IN
18637	102	14	adjudications	adjudication	NNS
18637	102	15	of	of	IN
18637	102	16	the	the	DT
18637	102	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	102	18	were	be	VBD
18637	102	19	rapidly	rapidly	RB
18637	102	20	gravitating	gravitate	VBG
18637	102	21	"	"	''
18637	102	22	into	into	IN
18637	102	23	the	the	DT
18637	102	24	same	same	JJ
18637	102	25	class	class	NN
18637	102	26	as	as	IN
18637	102	27	a	a	DT
18637	102	28	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	102	29	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	102	30	ticket	ticket	NN
18637	102	31	,	,	,
18637	102	32	good	good	JJ
18637	102	33	for	for	IN
18637	102	34	this	this	DT
18637	102	35	day	day	NN
18637	102	36	and	and	CC
18637	102	37	train	train	VB
18637	102	38	only	only	RB
18637	102	39	"	"	''
18637	102	40	.	.	.
18637	103	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	103	2	7	7	CD
18637	103	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	103	4	Years	year	NNS
18637	103	5	ago	ago	RB
18637	103	6	the	the	DT
18637	103	7	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	103	8	historian	historian	NN
18637	103	9	of	of	IN
18637	103	10	the	the	DT
18637	103	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	103	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	103	13	,	,	,
18637	103	14	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	103	15	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	103	16	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	103	17	,	,	,
18637	103	18	had	have	VBD
18637	103	19	written	write	VBN
18637	103	20	:	:	:
18637	103	21	However	however	RB
18637	103	22	the	the	DT
18637	103	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	103	24	may	may	MD
18637	103	25	interpret	interpret	VB
18637	103	26	the	the	DT
18637	103	27	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	103	28	of	of	IN
18637	103	29	the	the	DT
18637	103	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	103	31	,	,	,
18637	103	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	103	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	103	34	still	still	RB
18637	103	35	the	the	DT
18637	103	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	103	37	which	which	WDT
18637	103	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	103	39	the	the	DT
18637	103	40	law	law	NN
18637	103	41	and	and	CC
18637	103	42	not	not	RB
18637	103	43	the	the	DT
18637	103	44	decision	decision	NN
18637	103	45	of	of	IN
18637	103	46	the	the	DT
18637	103	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	103	48	.	.	.
18637	104	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	104	2	8	8	CD
18637	104	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	104	4	In	in	IN
18637	104	5	short	short	JJ
18637	104	6	,	,	,
18637	104	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	104	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	104	9	"	"	``
18637	104	10	not	not	RB
18637	104	11	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	104	12	so	so	RB
18637	104	13	"	"	''
18637	104	14	that	that	IN
18637	104	15	the	the	DT
18637	104	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	104	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	104	18	preserved	preserve	VBN
18637	104	19	in	in	IN
18637	104	20	the	the	DT
18637	104	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	104	22	's	's	POS
18637	104	23	reading	reading	NN
18637	104	24	of	of	IN
18637	104	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	104	26	.	.	.
18637	105	1	A	a	DT
18637	105	2	third	third	JJ
18637	105	3	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	105	4	in	in	IN
18637	105	5	the	the	DT
18637	105	6	way	way	NN
18637	105	7	of	of	IN
18637	105	8	the	the	DT
18637	105	9	theory	theory	NN
18637	105	10	that	that	IN
18637	105	11	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	105	12	Review	Review	NNP
18637	105	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	105	14	preservative	preservative	JJ
18637	105	15	of	of	IN
18637	105	16	the	the	DT
18637	105	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	105	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	105	19	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	105	20	when	when	WRB
18637	105	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	105	22	turn	turn	VBP
18637	105	23	to	to	TO
18637	105	24	consider	consider	VB
18637	105	25	the	the	DT
18637	105	26	statistical	statistical	JJ
18637	105	27	aspects	aspect	NNS
18637	105	28	of	of	IN
18637	105	29	the	the	DT
18637	105	30	matter	matter	NN
18637	105	31	.	.	.
18637	106	1	The	the	DT
18637	106	2	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	106	3	that	that	IN
18637	106	4	the	the	DT
18637	106	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	106	6	of	of	IN
18637	106	7	the	the	DT
18637	106	8	United	United	NNP
18637	106	9	States	States	NNP
18637	106	10	contained	contain	VBD
18637	106	11	in	in	IN
18637	106	12	embryo	embryo	NN
18637	106	13	from	from	IN
18637	106	14	the	the	DT
18637	106	15	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	106	16	the	the	DT
18637	106	17	entirety	entirety	NN
18637	106	18	of	of	IN
18637	106	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	106	20	national	national	JJ
18637	106	21	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	106	22	Law	Law	NNP
18637	106	23	confronts	confront	NNS
18637	106	24	the	the	DT
18637	106	25	will	will	NN
18637	106	26	to	to	TO
18637	106	27	believe	believe	VB
18637	106	28	with	with	IN
18637	106	29	an	an	DT
18637	106	30	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	106	31	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	106	32	test	test	NN
18637	106	33	.	.	.
18637	107	1	Compared	compare	VBN
18637	107	2	with	with	IN
18637	107	3	the	the	DT
18637	107	4	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	107	5	Document	Document	NNP
18637	107	6	,	,	,
18637	107	7	with	with	IN
18637	107	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	107	9	7,000	7,000	CD
18637	107	10	words	word	NNS
18637	107	11	more	more	RBR
18637	107	12	or	or	CC
18637	107	13	less	less	RBR
18637	107	14	,	,	,
18637	107	15	the	the	DT
18637	107	16	bulk	bulk	NN
18637	107	17	of	of	IN
18637	107	18	material	material	NN
18637	107	19	requiring	require	VBG
18637	107	20	to	to	TO
18637	107	21	be	be	VB
18637	107	22	noticed	notice	VBN
18637	107	23	in	in	IN
18637	107	24	the	the	DT
18637	107	25	preparation	preparation	NN
18637	107	26	of	of	IN
18637	107	27	an	an	DT
18637	107	28	annotation	annotation	NN
18637	107	29	of	of	IN
18637	107	30	this	this	DT
18637	107	31	kind	kind	NN
18637	107	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	107	33	simply	simply	RB
18637	107	34	immense	immense	JJ
18637	107	35	.	.	.
18637	108	1	First	first	RB
18637	108	2	and	and	CC
18637	108	3	last	last	JJ
18637	108	4	,	,	,
18637	108	5	the	the	DT
18637	108	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	108	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	108	8	probably	probably	RB
18637	108	9	decided	decide	VBN
18637	108	10	well	well	RB
18637	108	11	over	over	IN
18637	108	12	4,000	4,000	CD
18637	108	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	108	14	involving	involve	VBG
18637	108	15	questions	question	NNS
18637	108	16	of	of	IN
18637	108	17	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	108	18	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	108	19	.	.	.
18637	109	1	In	in	IN
18637	109	2	many	many	JJ
18637	109	3	instances	instance	NNS
18637	109	4	,	,	,
18637	109	5	to	to	TO
18637	109	6	be	be	VB
18637	109	7	sure	sure	JJ
18637	109	8	,	,	,
18637	109	9	the	the	DT
18637	109	10	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	109	11	issue	issue	NN
18637	109	12	was	be	VBD
18637	109	13	disposed	dispose	VBN
18637	109	14	of	of	IN
18637	109	15	quite	quite	RB
18637	109	16	briefly	briefly	NN
18637	109	17	.	.	.
18637	110	1	In	in	IN
18637	110	2	some	some	DT
18637	110	3	instances	instance	NNS
18637	110	4	,	,	,
18637	110	5	on	on	IN
18637	110	6	the	the	DT
18637	110	7	other	other	JJ
18637	110	8	hand	hand	NN
18637	110	9	,	,	,
18637	110	10	the	the	DT
18637	110	11	published	publish	VBN
18637	110	12	report	report	NN
18637	110	13	of	of	IN
18637	110	14	the	the	DT
18637	110	15	case	case	NN
18637	110	16	runs	run	VBZ
18637	110	17	to	to	IN
18637	110	18	more	more	JJR
18637	110	19	than	than	IN
18637	110	20	200	200	CD
18637	110	21	pages	page	NNS
18637	110	22	.	.	.
18637	111	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	111	2	9	9	CD
18637	111	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	111	4	In	in	IN
18637	111	5	the	the	DT
18637	111	6	total	total	NN
18637	111	7	,	,	,
18637	111	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	111	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	111	10	probable	probable	JJ
18637	111	11	that	that	IN
18637	111	12	at	at	RB
18637	111	13	least	least	RBS
18637	111	14	50,000	50,000	CD
18637	111	15	pages	page	NNS
18637	111	16	of	of	IN
18637	111	17	the	the	DT
18637	111	18	United	United	NNP
18637	111	19	States	States	NNP
18637	111	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	111	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	111	22	Reports	report	NNS
18637	111	23	are	be	VBP
18637	111	24	devoted	devoted	JJ
18637	111	25	to	to	IN
18637	111	26	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	111	27	Law	Law	NNP
18637	111	28	topics	topic	NNS
18637	111	29	.	.	.
18637	112	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	112	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	112	3	this	this	DT
18637	112	4	the	the	DT
18637	112	5	whole	whole	JJ
18637	112	6	story	story	NN
18637	112	7	,	,	,
18637	112	8	or	or	CC
18637	112	9	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	112	10	the	the	DT
18637	112	11	most	most	RBS
18637	112	12	important	important	JJ
18637	112	13	part	part	NN
18637	112	14	of	of	IN
18637	112	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	112	16	.	.	.
18637	113	1	Even	even	RB
18637	113	2	more	more	RBR
18637	113	3	striking	striking	JJ
18637	113	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	113	5	the	the	DT
18637	113	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	113	7	that	that	IN
18637	113	8	the	the	DT
18637	113	9	vast	vast	JJ
18637	113	10	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	113	11	of	of	IN
18637	113	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	113	13	forming	form	VBG
18637	113	14	the	the	DT
18637	113	15	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	113	16	of	of	IN
18637	113	17	national	national	JJ
18637	113	18	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	113	19	Law	Law	NNP
18637	113	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	113	21	stemmed	stem	VBN
18637	113	22	,	,	,
18637	113	23	or	or	CC
18637	113	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	113	25	purported	purport	VBN
18637	113	26	to	to	TO
18637	113	27	stem	stem	VB
18637	113	28	,	,	,
18637	113	29	from	from	IN
18637	113	30	four	four	CD
18637	113	31	or	or	CC
18637	113	32	five	five	CD
18637	113	33	brief	brief	JJ
18637	113	34	phrases	phrase	NNS
18637	113	35	of	of	IN
18637	113	36	the	the	DT
18637	113	37	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	113	38	Document	Document	NNP
18637	113	39	,	,	,
18637	113	40	the	the	DT
18637	113	41	power	power	NN
18637	113	42	"	"	''
18637	113	43	to	to	TO
18637	113	44	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	113	45	...	...	:
18637	113	46	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	113	47	among	among	IN
18637	113	48	the	the	DT
18637	113	49	States	States	NNP
18637	113	50	,	,	,
18637	113	51	"	"	''
18637	113	52	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	113	53	of	of	IN
18637	113	54	"	"	``
18637	113	55	the	the	DT
18637	113	56	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	113	57	of	of	IN
18637	113	58	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	113	59	"	"	''
18637	113	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	113	61	now	now	RB
18637	113	62	practically	practically	RB
18637	113	63	dried	dry	VBN
18637	113	64	up	up	RP
18637	113	65	as	as	IN
18637	113	66	a	a	DT
18637	113	67	formal	formal	JJ
18637	113	68	source	source	NN
18637	113	69	of	of	IN
18637	113	70	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	113	71	law	law	NN
18637	113	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	113	73	,	,	,
18637	113	74	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	113	75	of	of	IN
18637	113	76	"	"	``
18637	113	77	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	113	78	or	or	CC
18637	113	79	property	property	NN
18637	113	80	without	without	IN
18637	113	81	due	due	JJ
18637	113	82	process	process	NN
18637	113	83	of	of	IN
18637	113	84	law	law	NN
18637	113	85	"	"	''
18637	113	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	113	87	which	which	WDT
18637	113	88	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	113	89	occurs	occur	VBZ
18637	113	90	both	both	DT
18637	113	91	as	as	IN
18637	113	92	a	a	DT
18637	113	93	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	113	94	on	on	IN
18637	113	95	the	the	DT
18637	113	96	National	National	NNP
18637	113	97	Government	Government	NNP
18637	113	98	and	and	CC
18637	113	99	,	,	,
18637	113	100	since	since	IN
18637	113	101	1868	1868	CD
18637	113	102	,	,	,
18637	113	103	on	on	IN
18637	113	104	the	the	DT
18637	113	105	States	States	NNP
18637	113	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	113	107	,	,	,
18637	113	108	and	and	CC
18637	113	109	out	out	IN
18637	113	110	of	of	IN
18637	113	111	four	four	CD
18637	113	112	or	or	CC
18637	113	113	five	five	CD
18637	113	114	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	113	115	which	which	WDT
18637	113	116	the	the	DT
18637	113	117	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	113	118	is	be	VBZ
18637	113	119	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	113	120	to	to	TO
18637	113	121	embody	embody	VB
18637	113	122	.	.	.
18637	114	1	The	the	DT
18637	114	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	114	3	are	be	VBP
18637	114	4	,	,	,
18637	114	5	in	in	IN
18637	114	6	truth	truth	NN
18637	114	7	,	,	,
18637	114	8	the	the	DT
18637	114	9	essence	essence	NN
18637	114	10	of	of	IN
18637	114	11	the	the	DT
18637	114	12	matter	matter	NN
18637	114	13	,	,	,
18637	114	14	for	for	IN
18637	114	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	114	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	114	17	through	through	IN
18637	114	18	these	these	DT
18637	114	19	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	114	20	,	,	,
18637	114	21	and	and	CC
18637	114	22	under	under	IN
18637	114	23	the	the	DT
18637	114	24	cover	cover	NN
18637	114	25	which	which	WDT
18637	114	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	114	27	afford	afford	VBP
18637	114	28	,	,	,
18637	114	29	that	that	IN
18637	114	30	outside	outside	JJ
18637	114	31	interests	interest	NNS
18637	114	32	,	,	,
18637	114	33	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	114	34	,	,	,
18637	114	35	preconceptions	preconception	NNS
18637	114	36	,	,	,
18637	114	37	have	have	VBP
18637	114	38	found	find	VBN
18637	114	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	114	40	way	way	NN
18637	114	41	into	into	IN
18637	114	42	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	114	43	Law	Law	NNP
18637	114	44	,	,	,
18637	114	45	have	have	VBP
18637	114	46	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	114	47	become	become	VBN
18637	114	48	for	for	IN
18637	114	49	better	well	JJR
18637	114	50	,	,	,
18637	114	51	for	for	IN
18637	114	52	worse	bad	JJR
18637	114	53	,	,	,
18637	114	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	114	55	leavening	leavening	NN
18637	114	56	element	element	NN
18637	114	57	.	.	.
18637	115	1	That	that	DT
18637	115	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	115	3	to	to	TO
18637	115	4	say	say	VB
18637	115	5	,	,	,
18637	115	6	the	the	DT
18637	115	7	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
18637	115	8	of	of	IN
18637	115	9	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	115	10	Law	Law	NNP
18637	115	11	as	as	IN
18637	115	12	a	a	DT
18637	115	13	system	system	NN
18637	115	14	of	of	IN
18637	115	15	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	115	16	on	on	IN
18637	115	17	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	115	18	action	action	NN
18637	115	19	in	in	IN
18637	115	20	the	the	DT
18637	115	21	United	United	NNP
18637	115	22	States	States	NNP
18637	115	23	,	,	,
18637	115	24	which	which	WDT
18637	115	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	115	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	115	27	primary	primary	JJ
18637	115	28	_	_	NNP
18637	115	29	raison	raison	NNP
18637	115	30	d'etre	d'etre	NNP
18637	115	31	_	_	NNP
18637	115	32	,	,	,
18637	115	33	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	115	34	for	for	IN
18637	115	35	the	the	DT
18637	115	36	most	most	JJS
18637	115	37	part	part	NN
18637	115	38	on	on	IN
18637	115	39	the	the	DT
18637	115	40	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
18637	115	41	of	of	IN
18637	115	42	these	these	DT
18637	115	43	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	115	44	as	as	IN
18637	115	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	115	46	are	be	VBP
18637	115	47	applied	apply	VBN
18637	115	48	by	by	IN
18637	115	49	the	the	DT
18637	115	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	115	51	to	to	IN
18637	115	52	that	that	DT
18637	115	53	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	115	54	.	.	.
18637	116	1	The	the	DT
18637	116	2	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	116	3	to	to	TO
18637	116	4	which	which	WDT
18637	116	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	116	6	refer	refer	VBP
18637	116	7	are	be	VBP
18637	116	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	116	9	1	1	LS
18637	116	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	116	11	the	the	DT
18637	116	12	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	116	13	or	or	CC
18637	116	14	concept	concept	NN
18637	116	15	of	of	IN
18637	116	16	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	116	17	;	;	:
18637	116	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	116	19	2	2	LS
18637	116	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	116	21	the	the	DT
18637	116	22	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	116	23	of	of	IN
18637	116	24	the	the	DT
18637	116	25	Separation	Separation	NNP
18637	116	26	of	of	IN
18637	116	27	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	116	28	;	;	:
18637	116	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	116	30	3	3	LS
18637	116	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	116	32	the	the	DT
18637	116	33	concept	concept	NN
18637	116	34	of	of	IN
18637	116	35	a	a	DT
18637	116	36	Government	Government	NNP
18637	116	37	of	of	IN
18637	116	38	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	116	39	and	and	CC
18637	116	40	not	not	RB
18637	116	41	of	of	IN
18637	116	42	Men	Men	NNPS
18637	116	43	,	,	,
18637	116	44	as	as	IN
18637	116	45	opposed	oppose	VBN
18637	116	46	especially	especially	RB
18637	116	47	to	to	IN
18637	116	48	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	116	49	conceptions	conception	NNS
18637	116	50	of	of	IN
18637	116	51	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	116	52	power	power	NN
18637	116	53	;	;	:
18637	116	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	116	55	4	4	LS
18637	116	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	116	57	and	and	CC
18637	116	58	the	the	DT
18637	116	59	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	116	60	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	116	61	of	of	IN
18637	116	62	Due	Due	NNP
18637	116	63	Process	Process	NNP
18637	116	64	of	of	IN
18637	116	65	Law	Law	NNP
18637	116	66	and	and	CC
18637	116	67	attendant	attendant	JJ
18637	116	68	conceptions	conception	NNS
18637	116	69	of	of	IN
18637	116	70	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	116	71	.	.	.
18637	117	1	What	what	WP
18637	117	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	117	3	proposed	propose	VBD
18637	117	4	to	to	TO
18637	117	5	do	do	VB
18637	117	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	117	7	to	to	TO
18637	117	8	take	take	VB
18637	117	9	up	up	RP
18637	117	10	each	each	DT
18637	117	11	of	of	IN
18637	117	12	these	these	DT
18637	117	13	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	117	14	or	or	CC
18637	117	15	concepts	concept	NNS
18637	117	16	in	in	IN
18637	117	17	turn	turn	NN
18637	117	18	,	,	,
18637	117	19	tell	tell	VB
18637	117	20	something	something	NN
18637	117	21	of	of	IN
18637	117	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	117	23	earlier	early	JJR
18637	117	24	history	history	NN
18637	117	25	,	,	,
18637	117	26	and	and	CC
18637	117	27	then	then	RB
18637	117	28	project	project	NN
18637	117	29	against	against	IN
18637	117	30	this	this	DT
18637	117	31	background	background	NN
18637	117	32	a	a	DT
18637	117	33	summary	summary	NN
18637	117	34	account	account	NN
18637	117	35	of	of	IN
18637	117	36	what	what	WP
18637	117	37	has	have	VBZ
18637	117	38	happened	happen	VBN
18637	117	39	to	to	IN
18637	117	40	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	117	41	in	in	IN
18637	117	42	recent	recent	JJ
18637	117	43	years	year	NNS
18637	117	44	in	in	IN
18637	117	45	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	117	46	of	of	IN
18637	117	47	the	the	DT
18637	117	48	impact	impact	NN
18637	117	49	of	of	IN
18637	117	50	war	war	NN
18637	117	51	,	,	,
18637	117	52	of	of	IN
18637	117	53	economic	economic	JJ
18637	117	54	crisis	crisis	NN
18637	117	55	,	,	,
18637	117	56	and	and	CC
18637	117	57	of	of	IN
18637	117	58	the	the	DT
18637	117	59	political	political	JJ
18637	117	60	and	and	CC
18637	117	61	ideological	ideological	JJ
18637	117	62	reaction	reaction	NN
18637	117	63	to	to	IN
18637	117	64	the	the	DT
18637	117	65	latter	latter	JJ
18637	117	66	during	during	IN
18637	117	67	the	the	DT
18637	117	68	Administrations	Administrations	NNP
18637	117	69	of	of	IN
18637	117	70	Franklin	Franklin	NNP
18637	117	71	D.	D.	NNP
18637	117	72	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	117	73	.	.	.
18637	118	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	118	2	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	118	3	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	118	4	in	in	IN
18637	118	5	the	the	DT
18637	118	6	United	United	NNP
18637	118	7	States	States	NNP
18637	118	8	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	118	9	the	the	DT
18637	118	10	following	follow	VBG
18637	118	11	elements	element	NNS
18637	118	12	:	:	:
18637	118	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	118	14	1	1	LS
18637	118	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	118	16	as	as	IN
18637	118	17	in	in	IN
18637	118	18	all	all	DT
18637	118	19	federations	federation	NNS
18637	118	20	,	,	,
18637	118	21	the	the	DT
18637	118	22	union	union	NN
18637	118	23	of	of	IN
18637	118	24	several	several	JJ
18637	118	25	autonomous	autonomous	JJ
18637	118	26	political	political	JJ
18637	118	27	entities	entity	NNS
18637	118	28	,	,	,
18637	118	29	or	or	CC
18637	118	30	"	"	``
18637	118	31	States	state	NNS
18637	118	32	,	,	,
18637	118	33	"	"	''
18637	118	34	for	for	IN
18637	118	35	common	common	JJ
18637	118	36	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	118	37	;	;	:
18637	118	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	118	39	2	2	LS
18637	118	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	118	41	the	the	DT
18637	118	42	division	division	NN
18637	118	43	of	of	IN
18637	118	44	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	118	45	powers	power	NNS
18637	118	46	between	between	IN
18637	118	47	a	a	DT
18637	118	48	"	"	``
18637	118	49	National	National	NNP
18637	118	50	Government	Government	NNP
18637	118	51	,	,	,
18637	118	52	"	"	''
18637	118	53	on	on	IN
18637	118	54	the	the	DT
18637	118	55	one	one	CD
18637	118	56	hand	hand	NN
18637	118	57	,	,	,
18637	118	58	and	and	CC
18637	118	59	constituent	constituent	NN
18637	118	60	"	"	``
18637	118	61	States	States	NNP
18637	118	62	,	,	,
18637	118	63	"	"	''
18637	118	64	on	on	IN
18637	118	65	the	the	DT
18637	118	66	other	other	JJ
18637	118	67	,	,	,
18637	118	68	which	which	WDT
18637	118	69	division	division	NN
18637	118	70	is	be	VBZ
18637	118	71	governed	govern	VBN
18637	118	72	by	by	IN
18637	118	73	the	the	DT
18637	118	74	rule	rule	NN
18637	118	75	that	that	IN
18637	118	76	the	the	DT
18637	118	77	former	former	JJ
18637	118	78	is	be	VBZ
18637	118	79	"	"	``
18637	118	80	a	a	DT
18637	118	81	government	government	NN
18637	118	82	of	of	IN
18637	118	83	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	118	84	powers	power	NNS
18637	118	85	"	"	''
18637	118	86	while	while	IN
18637	118	87	the	the	DT
18637	118	88	latter	latter	JJ
18637	118	89	are	be	VBP
18637	118	90	governments	government	NNS
18637	118	91	of	of	IN
18637	118	92	"	"	``
18637	118	93	residual	residual	JJ
18637	118	94	powers	power	NNS
18637	118	95	"	"	''
18637	118	96	;	;	,
18637	118	97	(	(	-LRB-
18637	118	98	3	3	LS
18637	118	99	)	)	-RRB-
18637	118	100	the	the	DT
18637	118	101	direct	direct	JJ
18637	118	102	operation	operation	NN
18637	118	103	,	,	,
18637	118	104	for	for	IN
18637	118	105	the	the	DT
18637	118	106	most	most	JJS
18637	118	107	part	part	NN
18637	118	108	,	,	,
18637	118	109	of	of	IN
18637	118	110	each	each	DT
18637	118	111	of	of	IN
18637	118	112	these	these	DT
18637	118	113	centers	center	NNS
18637	118	114	of	of	IN
18637	118	115	government	government	NN
18637	118	116	,	,	,
18637	118	117	within	within	IN
18637	118	118	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	118	119	assigned	assigned	JJ
18637	118	120	sphere	sphere	NN
18637	118	121	,	,	,
18637	118	122	upon	upon	IN
18637	118	123	all	all	DT
18637	118	124	persons	person	NNS
18637	118	125	and	and	CC
18637	118	126	property	property	NN
18637	118	127	within	within	IN
18637	118	128	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	118	129	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	118	130	limits	limit	NNS
18637	118	131	;	;	,
18637	118	132	(	(	-LRB-
18637	118	133	4	4	LS
18637	118	134	)	)	-RRB-
18637	118	135	the	the	DT
18637	118	136	provision	provision	NN
18637	118	137	of	of	IN
18637	118	138	each	each	DT
18637	118	139	center	center	NN
18637	118	140	with	with	IN
18637	118	141	the	the	DT
18637	118	142	complete	complete	JJ
18637	118	143	apparatus	apparatus	NN
18637	118	144	of	of	IN
18637	118	145	law	law	NN
18637	118	146	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	118	147	,	,	,
18637	118	148	both	both	CC
18637	118	149	executive	executive	JJ
18637	118	150	and	and	CC
18637	118	151	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	118	152	;	;	:
18637	118	153	(	(	-LRB-
18637	118	154	5	5	LS
18637	118	155	)	)	-RRB-
18637	118	156	the	the	DT
18637	118	157	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	118	158	of	of	IN
18637	118	159	the	the	DT
18637	118	160	"	"	``
18637	118	161	National	National	NNP
18637	118	162	Government	Government	NNP
18637	118	163	"	"	''
18637	118	164	within	within	IN
18637	118	165	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	118	166	assigned	assigned	JJ
18637	118	167	sphere	sphere	NN
18637	118	168	over	over	IN
18637	118	169	any	any	DT
18637	118	170	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	118	171	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	118	172	of	of	IN
18637	118	173	"	"	``
18637	118	174	state	state	NN
18637	118	175	"	"	''
18637	118	176	power	power	NN
18637	118	177	;	;	:
18637	118	178	(	(	-LRB-
18637	118	179	6	6	LS
18637	118	180	)	)	-RRB-
18637	118	181	dual	dual	JJ
18637	118	182	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	118	183	.	.	.
18637	119	1	The	the	DT
18637	119	2	third	third	JJ
18637	119	3	and	and	CC
18637	119	4	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	119	5	of	of	IN
18637	119	6	the	the	DT
18637	119	7	above	above	RB
18637	119	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	119	9	listed	list	VBN
18637	119	10	salient	salient	NN
18637	119	11	features	feature	NNS
18637	119	12	of	of	IN
18637	119	13	the	the	DT
18637	119	14	American	American	NNP
18637	119	15	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	119	16	System	System	NNP
18637	119	17	are	be	VBP
18637	119	18	the	the	DT
18637	119	19	ones	one	NNS
18637	119	20	which	which	WDT
18637	119	21	at	at	IN
18637	119	22	the	the	DT
18637	119	23	outset	outset	NN
18637	119	24	marked	mark	VBD
18637	119	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	119	26	off	off	RP
18637	119	27	most	most	RBS
18637	119	28	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	119	29	from	from	IN
18637	119	30	all	all	DT
18637	119	31	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	119	32	systems	system	NNS
18637	119	33	,	,	,
18637	119	34	in	in	IN
18637	119	35	which	which	WDT
18637	119	36	the	the	DT
18637	119	37	member	member	NN
18637	119	38	states	state	NNS
18637	119	39	generally	generally	RB
18637	119	40	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	119	41	to	to	TO
18637	119	42	obey	obey	VB
18637	119	43	the	the	DT
18637	119	44	mandates	mandate	NNS
18637	119	45	of	of	IN
18637	119	46	a	a	DT
18637	119	47	common	common	JJ
18637	119	48	government	government	NN
18637	119	49	for	for	IN
18637	119	50	certain	certain	JJ
18637	119	51	stipulated	stipulated	JJ
18637	119	52	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	119	53	,	,	,
18637	119	54	but	but	CC
18637	119	55	retained	retain	VBD
18637	119	56	to	to	IN
18637	119	57	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	119	58	the	the	DT
18637	119	59	right	right	NN
18637	119	60	of	of	IN
18637	119	61	ordaining	ordain	VBG
18637	119	62	and	and	CC
18637	119	63	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	119	64	the	the	DT
18637	119	65	laws	law	NNS
18637	119	66	of	of	IN
18637	119	67	the	the	DT
18637	119	68	union	union	NN
18637	119	69	.	.	.
18637	120	1	This	this	DT
18637	120	2	,	,	,
18637	120	3	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	120	4	,	,	,
18637	120	5	was	be	VBD
18637	120	6	the	the	DT
18637	120	7	system	system	NN
18637	120	8	provided	provide	VBN
18637	120	9	in	in	IN
18637	120	10	the	the	DT
18637	120	11	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	120	12	of	of	IN
18637	120	13	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	120	14	.	.	.
18637	121	1	The	the	DT
18637	121	2	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	121	3	of	of	IN
18637	121	4	1787	1787	CD
18637	121	5	was	be	VBD
18637	121	6	well	well	RB
18637	121	7	aware	aware	JJ
18637	121	8	,	,	,
18637	121	9	of	of	IN
18637	121	10	course	course	NN
18637	121	11	,	,	,
18637	121	12	that	that	IN
18637	121	13	if	if	IN
18637	121	14	the	the	DT
18637	121	15	inanities	inanity	NNS
18637	121	16	and	and	CC
18637	121	17	futilities	futility	NNS
18637	121	18	of	of	IN
18637	121	19	the	the	DT
18637	121	20	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	121	21	were	be	VBD
18637	121	22	to	to	TO
18637	121	23	be	be	VB
18637	121	24	avoided	avoid	VBN
18637	121	25	in	in	IN
18637	121	26	the	the	DT
18637	121	27	new	new	JJ
18637	121	28	system	system	NN
18637	121	29	,	,	,
18637	121	30	the	the	DT
18637	121	31	latter	latter	JJ
18637	121	32	must	must	MD
18637	121	33	incorporate	incorporate	VB
18637	121	34	"	"	``
18637	121	35	a	a	DT
18637	121	36	coercive	coercive	JJ
18637	121	37	principle	principle	NN
18637	121	38	"	"	''
18637	121	39	;	;	:
18637	121	40	and	and	CC
18637	121	41	as	as	IN
18637	121	42	Ellsworth	Ellsworth	NNP
18637	121	43	of	of	IN
18637	121	44	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	121	45	expressed	express	VBD
18637	121	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	121	47	,	,	,
18637	121	48	the	the	DT
18637	121	49	only	only	JJ
18637	121	50	question	question	NN
18637	121	51	was	be	VBD
18637	121	52	whether	whether	IN
18637	121	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	121	54	should	should	MD
18637	121	55	be	be	VB
18637	121	56	"	"	``
18637	121	57	a	a	DT
18637	121	58	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	121	59	of	of	IN
18637	121	60	law	law	NN
18637	121	61	,	,	,
18637	121	62	or	or	CC
18637	121	63	a	a	DT
18637	121	64	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	121	65	of	of	IN
18637	121	66	arms	arm	NNS
18637	121	67	,	,	,
18637	121	68	"	"	''
18637	121	69	that	that	IN
18637	121	70	"	"	``
18637	121	71	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	121	72	which	which	WDT
18637	121	73	acts	act	VBZ
18637	121	74	only	only	RB
18637	121	75	upon	upon	IN
18637	121	76	delinquent	delinquent	JJ
18637	121	77	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	121	78	"	"	''
18637	121	79	or	or	CC
18637	121	80	that	that	IN
18637	121	81	which	which	WDT
18637	121	82	is	be	VBZ
18637	121	83	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	121	84	to	to	IN
18637	121	85	"	"	``
18637	121	86	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	121	87	bodies	body	NNS
18637	121	88	,	,	,
18637	121	89	states	state	NNS
18637	121	90	,	,	,
18637	121	91	in	in	IN
18637	121	92	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	121	93	political	political	JJ
18637	121	94	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	121	95	.	.	.
18637	122	1	"	"	``
18637	122	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	122	3	10	10	CD
18637	122	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	122	5	In	in	IN
18637	122	6	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	122	7	Review	Review	NNP
18637	122	8	the	the	DT
18637	122	9	former	former	JJ
18637	122	10	principle	principle	NN
18637	122	11	was	be	VBD
18637	122	12	established	establish	VBN
18637	122	13	,	,	,
18637	122	14	albeit	albeit	IN
18637	122	15	without	without	IN
18637	122	16	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	122	17	discarding	discard	VBG
18637	122	18	the	the	DT
18637	122	19	latter	latter	JJ
18637	122	20	,	,	,
18637	122	21	as	as	IN
18637	122	22	the	the	DT
18637	122	23	War	War	NNP
18637	122	24	between	between	IN
18637	122	25	the	the	DT
18637	122	26	States	States	NNPS
18637	122	27	was	be	VBD
18637	122	28	to	to	TO
18637	122	29	demonstrate	demonstrate	VB
18637	122	30	.	.	.
18637	123	1	The	the	DT
18637	123	2	sheer	sheer	JJ
18637	123	3	fact	fact	NN
18637	123	4	of	of	IN
18637	123	5	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	123	6	enters	enter	VBZ
18637	123	7	the	the	DT
18637	123	8	purview	purview	NN
18637	123	9	of	of	IN
18637	123	10	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	123	11	Law	Law	NNP
18637	123	12	,	,	,
18637	123	13	that	that	RB
18637	123	14	is	is	RB
18637	123	15	,	,	,
18637	123	16	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	123	17	a	a	DT
18637	123	18	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	123	19	concept	concept	NN
18637	123	20	,	,	,
18637	123	21	in	in	IN
18637	123	22	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	123	23	of	of	IN
18637	123	24	the	the	DT
18637	123	25	conflicts	conflict	NNS
18637	123	26	which	which	WDT
18637	123	27	have	have	VBP
18637	123	28	at	at	IN
18637	123	29	times	time	NNS
18637	123	30	arisen	arise	VBN
18637	123	31	between	between	IN
18637	123	32	the	the	DT
18637	123	33	idea	idea	NN
18637	123	34	of	of	IN
18637	123	35	State	State	NNP
18637	123	36	Autonomy	Autonomy	NNP
18637	123	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	123	38	"	"	``
18637	123	39	State	State	NNP
18637	123	40	Sovereignty	Sovereignty	NNP
18637	123	41	"	"	''
18637	123	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	123	43	and	and	CC
18637	123	44	the	the	DT
18637	123	45	principle	principle	NN
18637	123	46	of	of	IN
18637	123	47	National	National	NNP
18637	123	48	Supremacy	Supremacy	NNP
18637	123	49	.	.	.
18637	124	1	Exaltation	exaltation	NN
18637	124	2	of	of	IN
18637	124	3	the	the	DT
18637	124	4	latter	latter	JJ
18637	124	5	principle	principle	NN
18637	124	6	,	,	,
18637	124	7	as	as	IN
18637	124	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	124	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	124	10	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	124	11	in	in	IN
18637	124	12	the	the	DT
18637	124	13	Supremacy	Supremacy	NNP
18637	124	14	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	124	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	124	16	Article	Article	NNP
18637	124	17	VI	VI	NNP
18637	124	18	,	,	,
18637	124	19	paragraph	paragraph	NN
18637	124	20	2	2	CD
18637	124	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	124	22	of	of	IN
18637	124	23	the	the	DT
18637	124	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	124	25	,	,	,
18637	124	26	was	be	VBD
18637	124	27	the	the	DT
18637	124	28	very	very	JJ
18637	124	29	keystone	keystone	NN
18637	124	30	of	of	IN
18637	124	31	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	124	32	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	124	33	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	124	34	's	's	POS
18637	124	35	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	124	36	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
18637	124	37	.	.	.
18637	125	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	125	2	was	be	VBD
18637	125	3	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	125	4	's	's	POS
18637	125	5	position	position	NN
18637	125	6	that	that	IN
18637	125	7	the	the	DT
18637	125	8	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	125	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	125	10	was	be	VBD
18637	125	11	intended	intend	VBN
18637	125	12	to	to	TO
18637	125	13	be	be	VB
18637	125	14	applied	apply	VBN
18637	125	15	literally	literally	RB
18637	125	16	,	,	,
18637	125	17	so	so	IN
18637	125	18	that	that	IN
18637	125	19	if	if	IN
18637	125	20	an	an	DT
18637	125	21	unforced	unforced	JJ
18637	125	22	reading	reading	NN
18637	125	23	of	of	IN
18637	125	24	the	the	DT
18637	125	25	terms	term	NNS
18637	125	26	in	in	IN
18637	125	27	which	which	WDT
18637	125	28	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	125	29	power	power	NN
18637	125	30	was	be	VBD
18637	125	31	granted	grant	VBN
18637	125	32	to	to	IN
18637	125	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	125	34	confirmed	confirm	VBD
18637	125	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	125	36	right	right	NN
18637	125	37	to	to	TO
18637	125	38	enact	enact	VB
18637	125	39	a	a	DT
18637	125	40	particular	particular	JJ
18637	125	41	statute	statute	NN
18637	125	42	,	,	,
18637	125	43	the	the	DT
18637	125	44	circumstance	circumstance	NN
18637	125	45	that	that	WDT
18637	125	46	the	the	DT
18637	125	47	statute	statute	NN
18637	125	48	projected	project	VBD
18637	125	49	national	national	JJ
18637	125	50	power	power	NN
18637	125	51	into	into	IN
18637	125	52	a	a	DT
18637	125	53	hitherto	hitherto	JJ
18637	125	54	accustomed	accustomed	JJ
18637	125	55	field	field	NN
18637	125	56	of	of	IN
18637	125	57	state	state	NN
18637	125	58	power	power	NN
18637	125	59	with	with	IN
18637	125	60	unavoidable	unavoidable	JJ
18637	125	61	curtailment	curtailment	NN
18637	125	62	of	of	IN
18637	125	63	the	the	DT
18637	125	64	latter	latter	NN
18637	125	65	was	be	VBD
18637	125	66	a	a	DT
18637	125	67	matter	matter	NN
18637	125	68	of	of	IN
18637	125	69	indifference	indifference	NN
18637	125	70	.	.	.
18637	126	1	State	state	NN
18637	126	2	power	power	NN
18637	126	3	,	,	,
18637	126	4	as	as	IN
18637	126	5	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	126	6	in	in	IN
18637	126	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	126	8	early	early	JJ
18637	126	9	nationalistic	nationalistic	JJ
18637	126	10	days	day	NNS
18637	126	11	phrased	phrase	VBN
18637	126	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	126	13	,	,	,
18637	126	14	was	be	VBD
18637	126	15	"	"	``
18637	126	16	no	no	DT
18637	126	17	criterion	criterion	NN
18637	126	18	of	of	IN
18637	126	19	national	national	JJ
18637	126	20	power	power	NN
18637	126	21	,	,	,
18637	126	22	"	"	''
18637	126	23	and	and	CC
18637	126	24	hence	hence	RB
18637	126	25	no	no	DT
18637	126	26	independent	independent	JJ
18637	126	27	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	126	28	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	126	29	.	.	.
18637	127	1	Quite	quite	JJ
18637	127	2	different	different	JJ
18637	127	3	was	be	VBD
18637	127	4	the	the	DT
18637	127	5	outlook	outlook	NN
18637	127	6	of	of	IN
18637	127	7	the	the	DT
18637	127	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	127	9	over	over	IN
18637	127	10	which	which	WDT
18637	127	11	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	127	12	's	's	POS
18637	127	13	successor	successor	NN
18637	127	14	,	,	,
18637	127	15	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	127	16	,	,	,
18637	127	17	presided	preside	VBD
18637	127	18	.	.	.
18637	128	1	That	that	DT
18637	128	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	128	3	took	take	VBD
18637	128	4	as	as	IN
18637	128	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	128	6	point	point	NN
18637	128	7	of	of	IN
18637	128	8	departure	departure	NN
18637	128	9	the	the	DT
18637	128	10	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	128	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	128	12	,	,	,
18637	128	13	which	which	WDT
18637	128	14	reads	read	VBZ
18637	128	15	,	,	,
18637	128	16	"	"	``
18637	128	17	The	the	DT
18637	128	18	powers	power	NNS
18637	128	19	not	not	RB
18637	128	20	delegated	delegate	VBD
18637	128	21	to	to	IN
18637	128	22	the	the	DT
18637	128	23	United	United	NNP
18637	128	24	States	States	NNP
18637	128	25	by	by	IN
18637	128	26	this	this	DT
18637	128	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	128	28	,	,	,
18637	128	29	nor	nor	CC
18637	128	30	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	128	31	by	by	IN
18637	128	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	128	33	to	to	IN
18637	128	34	the	the	DT
18637	128	35	States	States	NNP
18637	128	36	,	,	,
18637	128	37	are	be	VBP
18637	128	38	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	128	39	to	to	IN
18637	128	40	the	the	DT
18637	128	41	States	States	NNP
18637	128	42	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	128	43	,	,	,
18637	128	44	or	or	CC
18637	128	45	to	to	IN
18637	128	46	the	the	DT
18637	128	47	people	people	NNS
18637	128	48	.	.	.
18637	128	49	"	"	''
18637	129	1	In	in	IN
18637	129	2	construing	construe	VBG
18637	129	3	this	this	DT
18637	129	4	provision	provision	NN
18637	129	5	the	the	DT
18637	129	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	129	7	under	under	IN
18637	129	8	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	129	9	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	129	10	talked	talk	VBD
18637	129	11	as	as	IN
18637	129	12	if	if	IN
18637	129	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	129	14	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	129	15	all	all	PDT
18637	129	16	the	the	DT
18637	129	17	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	129	18	powers	power	NNS
18637	129	19	of	of	IN
18637	129	20	the	the	DT
18637	129	21	States	States	NNP
18637	129	22	as	as	IN
18637	129	23	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	129	24	national	national	JJ
18637	129	25	power	power	NN
18637	129	26	;	;	:
18637	129	27	at	at	IN
18637	129	28	other	other	JJ
18637	129	29	times	time	NNS
18637	129	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	129	31	talked	talk	VBD
18637	129	32	as	as	IN
18637	129	33	if	if	IN
18637	129	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	129	35	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	129	36	certain	certain	JJ
18637	129	37	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	129	38	as	as	IN
18637	129	39	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	129	40	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	129	41	to	to	IN
18637	129	42	the	the	DT
18637	129	43	States	States	NNPS
18637	129	44	,	,	,
18637	129	45	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	129	46	being	being	NN
18637	129	47	,	,	,
18637	129	48	of	of	IN
18637	129	49	course	course	NN
18637	129	50	,	,	,
18637	129	51	the	the	DT
18637	129	52	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	129	53	instance	instance	NN
18637	129	54	.	.	.
18637	130	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	130	2	11	11	CD
18637	130	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	130	4	But	but	CC
18637	130	5	whether	whether	IN
18637	130	6	following	follow	VBG
18637	130	7	the	the	DT
18637	130	8	one	one	CD
18637	130	9	line	line	NN
18637	130	10	of	of	IN
18637	130	11	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	130	12	or	or	CC
18637	130	13	the	the	DT
18637	130	14	other	other	JJ
18637	130	15	,	,	,
18637	130	16	the	the	DT
18637	130	17	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	130	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	130	19	subtly	subtly	RB
18637	130	20	transformed	transform	VBD
18637	130	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	130	22	function	function	NN
18637	130	23	,	,	,
18637	130	24	and	and	CC
18637	130	25	so	so	IN
18637	130	26	that	that	DT
18637	130	27	of	of	IN
18637	130	28	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	130	29	Review	Review	NNP
18637	130	30	,	,	,
18637	130	31	in	in	IN
18637	130	32	relation	relation	NN
18637	130	33	to	to	IN
18637	130	34	the	the	DT
18637	130	35	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	130	36	System	System	NNP
18637	130	37	.	.	.
18637	131	1	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	131	2	viewed	view	VBD
18637	131	3	the	the	DT
18637	131	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	131	5	as	as	RB
18637	131	6	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	131	7	an	an	DT
18637	131	8	organ	organ	NN
18637	131	9	of	of	IN
18637	131	10	the	the	DT
18637	131	11	National	National	NNP
18637	131	12	Government	Government	NNP
18637	131	13	and	and	CC
18637	131	14	of	of	IN
18637	131	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	131	16	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	131	17	.	.	.
18637	132	1	The	the	DT
18637	132	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	132	3	under	under	IN
18637	132	4	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	132	5	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	132	6	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	132	7	as	as	IN
18637	132	8	standing	stand	VBG
18637	132	9	outside	outside	RB
18637	132	10	of	of	IN
18637	132	11	and	and	CC
18637	132	12	above	above	IN
18637	132	13	both	both	DT
18637	132	14	the	the	DT
18637	132	15	National	National	NNP
18637	132	16	Government	Government	NNP
18637	132	17	and	and	CC
18637	132	18	the	the	DT
18637	132	19	States	States	NNPS
18637	132	20	,	,	,
18637	132	21	and	and	CC
18637	132	22	as	as	IN
18637	132	23	vested	vest	VBN
18637	132	24	with	with	IN
18637	132	25	a	a	DT
18637	132	26	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	132	27	-	-	JJ
18637	132	28	arbitral	arbitral	JJ
18637	132	29	function	function	NN
18637	132	30	between	between	IN
18637	132	31	two	two	CD
18637	132	32	centers	center	NNS
18637	132	33	of	of	IN
18637	132	34	diverse	diverse	NN
18637	132	35	,	,	,
18637	132	36	but	but	CC
18637	132	37	essentially	essentially	RB
18637	132	38	equal	equal	JJ
18637	132	39	,	,	,
18637	132	40	because	because	IN
18637	132	41	"	"	``
18637	132	42	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	132	43	"	"	''
18637	132	44	,	,	,
18637	132	45	powers	power	NNS
18637	132	46	.	.	.
18637	133	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	133	2	in	in	IN
18637	133	3	Ableman	Ableman	NNP
18637	133	4	_	_	NNP
18637	133	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	133	6	_	_	NNP
18637	133	7	Booth	Booth	NNP
18637	133	8	,	,	,
18637	133	9	which	which	WDT
18637	133	10	was	be	VBD
18637	133	11	decided	decide	VBN
18637	133	12	on	on	IN
18637	133	13	the	the	DT
18637	133	14	eve	eve	NN
18637	133	15	of	of	IN
18637	133	16	the	the	DT
18637	133	17	War	War	NNP
18637	133	18	between	between	IN
18637	133	19	the	the	DT
18637	133	20	States	States	NNPS
18637	133	21	,	,	,
18637	133	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	133	23	find	find	VBP
18637	133	24	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	133	25	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	133	26	using	use	VBG
18637	133	27	this	this	DT
18637	133	28	arresting	arrest	VBG
18637	133	29	language	language	NN
18637	133	30	:	:	:
18637	133	31	This	this	DT
18637	133	32	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	133	33	power	power	NN
18637	133	34	was	be	VBD
18637	133	35	justly	justly	RB
18637	133	36	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	133	37	as	as	IN
18637	133	38	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
18637	133	39	,	,	,
18637	133	40	not	not	RB
18637	133	41	merely	merely	RB
18637	133	42	to	to	TO
18637	133	43	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	133	44	the	the	DT
18637	133	45	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	133	46	of	of	IN
18637	133	47	the	the	DT
18637	133	48	laws	law	NNS
18637	133	49	of	of	IN
18637	133	50	the	the	DT
18637	133	51	United	United	NNP
18637	133	52	States	States	NNP
18637	133	53	,	,	,
18637	133	54	but	but	CC
18637	133	55	also	also	RB
18637	133	56	to	to	TO
18637	133	57	guard	guard	VB
18637	133	58	the	the	DT
18637	133	59	States	States	NNPS
18637	133	60	from	from	IN
18637	133	61	any	any	DT
18637	133	62	encroachment	encroachment	NN
18637	133	63	upon	upon	IN
18637	133	64	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	133	65	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	133	66	rights	right	NNS
18637	133	67	by	by	IN
18637	133	68	the	the	DT
18637	133	69	general	general	JJ
18637	133	70	government	government	NN
18637	133	71	....	....	.
18637	134	1	So	so	RB
18637	134	2	long	long	RB
18637	134	3	...	...	NFP
18637	134	4	as	as	IN
18637	134	5	this	this	DT
18637	134	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	134	7	shall	shall	MD
18637	134	8	endure	endure	VB
18637	134	9	,	,	,
18637	134	10	this	this	DT
18637	134	11	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	134	12	must	must	MD
18637	134	13	exist	exist	VB
18637	134	14	with	with	IN
18637	134	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	134	16	,	,	,
18637	134	17	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	134	18	in	in	IN
18637	134	19	the	the	DT
18637	134	20	peaceful	peaceful	JJ
18637	134	21	forms	form	NNS
18637	134	22	of	of	IN
18637	134	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	134	24	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	134	25	,	,	,
18637	134	26	the	the	DT
18637	134	27	angry	angry	JJ
18637	134	28	and	and	CC
18637	134	29	irritating	irritating	JJ
18637	134	30	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	134	31	between	between	IN
18637	134	32	sovereignties	sovereignty	NNS
18637	134	33	,	,	,
18637	134	34	which	which	WDT
18637	134	35	in	in	IN
18637	134	36	other	other	JJ
18637	134	37	countries	country	NNS
18637	134	38	have	have	VBP
18637	134	39	been	be	VBN
18637	134	40	determined	determine	VBN
18637	134	41	by	by	IN
18637	134	42	the	the	DT
18637	134	43	arbitrament	arbitrament	NN
18637	134	44	of	of	IN
18637	134	45	force	force	NN
18637	134	46	.	.	.
18637	135	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	135	2	12	12	CD
18637	135	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	135	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	135	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	135	6	,	,	,
18637	135	7	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	135	8	,	,	,
18637	135	9	the	the	DT
18637	135	10	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	135	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	135	12	,	,	,
18637	135	13	rather	rather	RB
18637	135	14	than	than	IN
18637	135	15	the	the	DT
18637	135	16	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	135	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	135	18	,	,	,
18637	135	19	which	which	WDT
18637	135	20	elaborated	elaborate	VBD
18637	135	21	the	the	DT
18637	135	22	concept	concept	NN
18637	135	23	of	of	IN
18637	135	24	Dual	Dual	NNP
18637	135	25	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	135	26	.	.	.
18637	136	1	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	136	2	's	's	POS
18637	136	3	federalism	federalism	NN
18637	136	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	136	5	more	more	RBR
18637	136	6	aptly	aptly	RB
18637	136	7	termed	term	VBN
18637	136	8	national	national	JJ
18637	136	9	federalism	federalism	NN
18637	136	10	;	;	:
18637	136	11	and	and	CC
18637	136	12	turning	turn	VBG
18637	136	13	to	to	IN
18637	136	14	modern	modern	JJ
18637	136	15	issues	issue	NNS
18637	136	16	,	,	,
18637	136	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	136	18	may	may	MD
18637	136	19	say	say	VB
18637	136	20	without	without	IN
18637	136	21	exaggeration	exaggeration	NN
18637	136	22	that	that	IN
18637	136	23	the	the	DT
18637	136	24	broad	broad	JJ
18637	136	25	general	general	JJ
18637	136	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	136	27	issue	issue	NN
18637	136	28	between	between	IN
18637	136	29	the	the	DT
18637	136	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	136	31	and	and	CC
18637	136	32	the	the	DT
18637	136	33	Franklin	Franklin	NNP
18637	136	34	D.	D.	NNP
18637	136	35	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	136	36	program	program	NN
18637	136	37	in	in	IN
18637	136	38	such	such	JJ
18637	136	39	cases	case	NNS
18637	136	40	as	as	IN
18637	136	41	Schechter	Schechter	NNP
18637	136	42	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	136	43	_	_	NNP
18637	136	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	136	45	_	_	NNP
18637	136	46	United	United	NNP
18637	136	47	States	States	NNP
18637	136	48	and	and	CC
18637	136	49	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	136	50	_	_	NNP
18637	136	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	136	52	_	_	NNP
18637	136	53	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	136	54	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	136	55	Co.[13	Co.[13	NNP
18637	136	56	]	]	-RRB-
18637	136	57	was	be	VBD
18637	136	58	,	,	,
18637	136	59	whether	whether	IN
18637	136	60	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	136	61	's	's	POS
18637	136	62	or	or	CC
18637	136	63	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	136	64	's	's	POS
18637	136	65	brand	brand	NN
18637	136	66	of	of	IN
18637	136	67	federalism	federalism	NN
18637	136	68	should	should	MD
18637	136	69	prevail	prevail	VB
18637	136	70	.	.	.
18637	137	1	More	more	RBR
18637	137	2	precisely	precisely	RB
18637	137	3	,	,	,
18637	137	4	the	the	DT
18637	137	5	issue	issue	NN
18637	137	6	in	in	IN
18637	137	7	these	these	DT
18637	137	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	137	9	was	be	VBD
18637	137	10	whether	whether	IN
18637	137	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	137	12	'	'	POS
18637	137	13	power	power	NN
18637	137	14	to	to	TO
18637	137	15	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	137	16	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	137	17	must	must	MD
18637	137	18	stop	stop	VB
18637	137	19	short	short	RB
18637	137	20	of	of	IN
18637	137	21	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	137	22	the	the	DT
18637	137	23	employer	employer	NN
18637	137	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	137	25	employee	employee	NN
18637	137	26	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	137	27	in	in	IN
18637	137	28	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	137	29	production	production	NN
18637	137	30	,	,	,
18637	137	31	that	that	IN
18637	137	32	having	have	VBG
18637	137	33	been	be	VBN
18637	137	34	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
18637	137	35	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	137	36	by	by	IN
18637	137	37	the	the	DT
18637	137	38	States	States	NNP
18637	137	39	.	.	.
18637	138	1	In	in	IN
18637	138	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	138	3	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	138	4	's	's	POS
18637	138	5	words	word	NNS
18637	138	6	in	in	IN
18637	138	7	the	the	DT
18637	138	8	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	138	9	case	case	NN
18637	138	10	:	:	:
18637	138	11	Much	much	JJ
18637	138	12	stress	stress	NN
18637	138	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	138	14	put	put	VBN
18637	138	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	138	16	the	the	DT
18637	138	17	evils	evil	NNS
18637	138	18	which	which	WDT
18637	138	19	come	come	VBP
18637	138	20	from	from	IN
18637	138	21	the	the	DT
18637	138	22	struggle	struggle	NN
18637	138	23	between	between	IN
18637	138	24	employers	employer	NNS
18637	138	25	and	and	CC
18637	138	26	employees	employee	NNS
18637	138	27	over	over	IN
18637	138	28	the	the	DT
18637	138	29	matter	matter	NN
18637	138	30	of	of	IN
18637	138	31	wages	wage	NNS
18637	138	32	,	,	,
18637	138	33	working	working	NN
18637	138	34	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	138	35	,	,	,
18637	138	36	the	the	DT
18637	138	37	right	right	NN
18637	138	38	of	of	IN
18637	138	39	collective	collective	JJ
18637	138	40	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	138	41	,	,	,
18637	138	42	etc	etc	FW
18637	138	43	.	.	FW
18637	138	44	,	,	,
18637	138	45	and	and	CC
18637	138	46	the	the	DT
18637	138	47	resulting	result	VBG
18637	138	48	strikes	strike	NNS
18637	138	49	,	,	,
18637	138	50	curtailment	curtailment	NN
18637	138	51	and	and	CC
18637	138	52	irregularity	irregularity	NN
18637	138	53	of	of	IN
18637	138	54	production	production	NN
18637	138	55	and	and	CC
18637	138	56	effect	effect	NN
18637	138	57	on	on	IN
18637	138	58	prices	price	NNS
18637	138	59	;	;	:
18637	138	60	and	and	CC
18637	138	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	138	62	is	be	VBZ
18637	138	63	insisted	insist	VBN
18637	138	64	that	that	IN
18637	138	65	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	138	66	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	138	67	is	be	VBZ
18637	138	68	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	138	69	affected	affect	VBN
18637	138	70	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	138	71	....	....	.
18637	139	1	The	the	DT
18637	139	2	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	139	3	answer	answer	NN
18637	139	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	139	5	that	that	IN
18637	139	6	the	the	DT
18637	139	7	evils	evil	NNS
18637	139	8	are	be	VBP
18637	139	9	all	all	DT
18637	139	10	local	local	JJ
18637	139	11	evils	evil	NNS
18637	139	12	over	over	IN
18637	139	13	which	which	WDT
18637	139	14	the	the	DT
18637	139	15	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	139	16	Government	Government	NNP
18637	139	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	139	18	no	no	DT
18637	139	19	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	139	20	control	control	NN
18637	139	21	.	.	.
18637	140	1	The	the	DT
18637	140	2	relation	relation	NN
18637	140	3	of	of	IN
18637	140	4	employer	employer	NN
18637	140	5	and	and	CC
18637	140	6	employee	employee	NN
18637	140	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	140	8	a	a	DT
18637	140	9	local	local	JJ
18637	140	10	relation	relation	NN
18637	140	11	.	.	.
18637	141	1	At	at	IN
18637	141	2	common	common	JJ
18637	141	3	law	law	NN
18637	141	4	,	,	,
18637	141	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	141	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	141	7	one	one	CD
18637	141	8	of	of	IN
18637	141	9	the	the	DT
18637	141	10	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	141	11	relations	relation	NNS
18637	141	12	.	.	.
18637	142	1	The	the	DT
18637	142	2	wages	wage	NNS
18637	142	3	are	be	VBP
18637	142	4	paid	pay	VBN
18637	142	5	for	for	IN
18637	142	6	the	the	DT
18637	142	7	doing	doing	NN
18637	142	8	of	of	IN
18637	142	9	local	local	JJ
18637	142	10	work	work	NN
18637	142	11	.	.	.
18637	143	1	Working	working	NN
18637	143	2	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	143	3	are	be	VBP
18637	143	4	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	143	5	local	local	JJ
18637	143	6	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	143	7	.	.	.
18637	144	1	The	the	DT
18637	144	2	employees	employee	NNS
18637	144	3	are	be	VBP
18637	144	4	not	not	RB
18637	144	5	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	144	6	in	in	IN
18637	144	7	or	or	CC
18637	144	8	about	about	IN
18637	144	9	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	144	10	,	,	,
18637	144	11	but	but	CC
18637	144	12	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	144	13	in	in	IN
18637	144	14	producing	produce	VBG
18637	144	15	a	a	DT
18637	144	16	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	144	17	.	.	.
18637	145	1	And	and	CC
18637	145	2	the	the	DT
18637	145	3	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	145	4	and	and	CC
18637	145	5	evils	evil	NNS
18637	145	6	,	,	,
18637	145	7	which	which	WDT
18637	145	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	145	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	145	10	the	the	DT
18637	145	11	object	object	NN
18637	145	12	of	of	IN
18637	145	13	the	the	DT
18637	145	14	act	act	NN
18637	145	15	to	to	TO
18637	145	16	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	145	17	and	and	CC
18637	145	18	minimize	minimize	VB
18637	145	19	,	,	,
18637	145	20	are	be	VBP
18637	145	21	local	local	JJ
18637	145	22	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	145	23	and	and	CC
18637	145	24	evils	evil	NNS
18637	145	25	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	145	26	local	local	JJ
18637	145	27	work	work	NN
18637	145	28	undertaken	undertake	VBN
18637	145	29	to	to	TO
18637	145	30	accomplish	accomplish	VB
18637	145	31	that	that	IN
18637	145	32	local	local	JJ
18637	145	33	result	result	NN
18637	145	34	.	.	.
18637	146	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	146	2	effect	effect	NN
18637	146	3	as	as	IN
18637	146	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	146	5	may	may	MD
18637	146	6	have	have	VB
18637	146	7	upon	upon	IN
18637	146	8	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	146	9	,	,	,
18637	146	10	however	however	RB
18637	146	11	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	146	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	146	13	may	may	MD
18637	146	14	be	be	VB
18637	146	15	,	,	,
18637	146	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	146	17	secondary	secondary	JJ
18637	146	18	and	and	CC
18637	146	19	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	146	20	.	.	.
18637	147	1	An	an	DT
18637	147	2	increase	increase	NN
18637	147	3	in	in	IN
18637	147	4	the	the	DT
18637	147	5	greatness	greatness	NN
18637	147	6	of	of	IN
18637	147	7	the	the	DT
18637	147	8	effect	effect	NN
18637	147	9	adds	add	VBZ
18637	147	10	to	to	IN
18637	147	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	147	12	importance	importance	NN
18637	147	13	.	.	.
18637	148	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	148	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	148	3	not	not	RB
18637	148	4	alter	alter	VB
18637	148	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	148	6	character	character	NN
18637	148	7	.	.	.
18637	149	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	149	2	14	14	CD
18637	149	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	149	4	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	149	5	all	all	DT
18637	149	6	know	know	VBP
18637	149	7	how	how	WRB
18637	149	8	this	this	DT
18637	149	9	issue	issue	NN
18637	149	10	was	be	VBD
18637	149	11	finally	finally	RB
18637	149	12	resolved	resolve	VBN
18637	149	13	.	.	.
18637	150	1	In	in	IN
18637	150	2	the	the	DT
18637	150	3	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	150	4	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	150	5	Standards	Standards	NNP
18637	150	6	Act	Act	NNP
18637	150	7	of	of	IN
18637	150	8	1938	1938	CD
18637	150	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	150	10	not	not	RB
18637	150	11	only	only	RB
18637	150	12	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	150	13	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	150	14	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	150	15	in	in	IN
18637	150	16	goods	good	NNS
18637	150	17	produced	produce	VBN
18637	150	18	by	by	IN
18637	150	19	substandard	substandard	JJ
18637	150	20	labor	labor	NN
18637	150	21	,	,	,
18637	150	22	but	but	CC
18637	150	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	150	24	directly	directly	RB
18637	150	25	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	150	26	,	,	,
18637	150	27	with	with	IN
18637	150	28	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	150	29	,	,	,
18637	150	30	the	the	DT
18637	150	31	employment	employment	NN
18637	150	32	of	of	IN
18637	150	33	labor	labor	NN
18637	150	34	in	in	IN
18637	150	35	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	150	36	production	production	NN
18637	150	37	for	for	IN
18637	150	38	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	150	39	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	150	40	on	on	IN
18637	150	41	other	other	JJ
18637	150	42	than	than	IN
18637	150	43	certain	certain	JJ
18637	150	44	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	150	45	terms	term	NNS
18637	150	46	.	.	.
18637	151	1	And	and	CC
18637	151	2	in	in	IN
18637	151	3	United	United	NNP
18637	151	4	States	States	NNP
18637	151	5	_	_	NNP
18637	151	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	151	7	_	_	NNP
18637	151	8	Darby[15	Darby[15	NNP
18637	151	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	151	10	this	this	DT
18637	151	11	Act	Act	NNP
18637	151	12	was	be	VBD
18637	151	13	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	151	14	by	by	IN
18637	151	15	the	the	DT
18637	151	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	151	17	,	,	,
18637	151	18	in	in	IN
18637	151	19	all	all	DT
18637	151	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	151	21	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	151	22	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	151	23	,	,	,
18637	151	24	on	on	IN
18637	151	25	the	the	DT
18637	151	26	basis	basis	NN
18637	151	27	of	of	IN
18637	151	28	an	an	DT
18637	151	29	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	151	30	by	by	IN
18637	151	31	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	151	32	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	151	33	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	151	34	which	which	WDT
18637	151	35	in	in	IN
18637	151	36	turn	turn	NN
18637	151	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	151	38	based	base	VBN
18637	151	39	on	on	IN
18637	151	40	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	151	41	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	151	42	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	151	43	's	's	POS
18637	151	44	famous	famous	JJ
18637	151	45	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	151	46	in	in	IN
18637	151	47	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	151	48	_	_	NNP
18637	151	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	151	50	_	_	NNP
18637	151	51	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	151	52	and	and	CC
18637	151	53	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	151	54	_	_	NNP
18637	151	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	151	56	_	_	NNP
18637	151	57	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	151	58	rendered	render	VBD
18637	151	59	more	more	JJR
18637	151	60	than	than	IN
18637	151	61	a	a	DT
18637	151	62	century	century	NN
18637	151	63	and	and	CC
18637	151	64	a	a	DT
18637	151	65	quarter	quarter	NN
18637	151	66	ago	ago	RB
18637	151	67	.	.	.
18637	152	1	In	in	IN
18637	152	2	short	short	JJ
18637	152	3	,	,	,
18637	152	4	as	as	IN
18637	152	5	a	a	DT
18637	152	6	principle	principle	NN
18637	152	7	capable	capable	JJ
18637	152	8	of	of	IN
18637	152	9	delimiting	delimit	VBG
18637	152	10	the	the	DT
18637	152	11	national	national	JJ
18637	152	12	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	152	13	power	power	NN
18637	152	14	,	,	,
18637	152	15	the	the	DT
18637	152	16	concept	concept	NN
18637	152	17	of	of	IN
18637	152	18	Dual	Dual	NNP
18637	152	19	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	152	20	as	as	IN
18637	152	21	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	152	22	the	the	DT
18637	152	23	present	present	JJ
18637	152	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	152	25	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	152	26	today	today	NN
18637	152	27	to	to	TO
18637	152	28	be	be	VB
18637	152	29	at	at	IN
18637	152	30	an	an	DT
18637	152	31	end	end	NN
18637	152	32	,	,	,
18637	152	33	with	with	IN
18637	152	34	consequent	consequent	JJ
18637	152	35	aggrandizement	aggrandizement	NN
18637	152	36	of	of	IN
18637	152	37	national	national	JJ
18637	152	38	power	power	NN
18637	152	39	.	.	.
18637	153	1	There	there	EX
18637	153	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	153	3	,	,	,
18637	153	4	however	however	RB
18637	153	5	,	,	,
18637	153	6	another	another	DT
18637	153	7	side	side	NN
18637	153	8	to	to	IN
18637	153	9	the	the	DT
18637	153	10	story	story	NN
18637	153	11	.	.	.
18637	154	1	For	for	IN
18637	154	2	in	in	IN
18637	154	3	one	one	CD
18637	154	4	respect	respect	NN
18637	154	5	even	even	RB
18637	154	6	the	the	DT
18637	154	7	great	great	JJ
18637	154	8	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	154	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	154	10	been	be	VBN
18637	154	11	in	in	IN
18637	154	12	effect	effect	NN
18637	154	13	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	154	14	in	in	IN
18637	154	15	support	support	NN
18637	154	16	of	of	IN
18637	154	17	enlarged	enlarged	JJ
18637	154	18	views	view	NNS
18637	154	19	of	of	IN
18637	154	20	national	national	JJ
18637	154	21	authority	authority	NN
18637	154	22	.	.	.
18637	155	1	Without	without	IN
18637	155	2	essaying	essay	VBG
18637	155	3	a	a	DT
18637	155	4	vain	vain	JJ
18637	155	5	task	task	NN
18637	155	6	of	of	IN
18637	155	7	"	"	``
18637	155	8	tithing	tithe	VBG
18637	155	9	mint	mint	NN
18637	155	10	,	,	,
18637	155	11	anise	anise	NN
18637	155	12	and	and	CC
18637	155	13	cummin	cummin	NNP
18637	155	14	,	,	,
18637	155	15	"	"	''
18637	155	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	155	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	155	18	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	155	19	accurate	accurate	JJ
18637	155	20	to	to	TO
18637	155	21	say	say	VB
18637	155	22	that	that	IN
18637	155	23	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	155	24	the	the	DT
18637	155	25	100	100	CD
18637	155	26	years	year	NNS
18637	155	27	which	which	WDT
18637	155	28	lie	lie	VBP
18637	155	29	between	between	IN
18637	155	30	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	155	31	's	's	POS
18637	155	32	death	death	NN
18637	155	33	and	and	CC
18637	155	34	the	the	DT
18637	155	35	cases	case	NNS
18637	155	36	of	of	IN
18637	155	37	the	the	DT
18637	155	38	1930	1930	CD
18637	155	39	's	's	POS
18637	155	40	,	,	,
18637	155	41	the	the	DT
18637	155	42	conception	conception	NN
18637	155	43	of	of	IN
18637	155	44	the	the	DT
18637	155	45	federal	federal	JJ
18637	155	46	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	155	47	which	which	WDT
18637	155	48	on	on	IN
18637	155	49	the	the	DT
18637	155	50	whole	whole	NN
18637	155	51	prevailed	prevail	VBD
18637	155	52	with	with	IN
18637	155	53	the	the	DT
18637	155	54	Court	Court	NNP
18637	155	55	was	be	VBD
18637	155	56	a	a	DT
18637	155	57	competitive	competitive	JJ
18637	155	58	conception	conception	NN
18637	155	59	,	,	,
18637	155	60	one	one	CD
18637	155	61	which	which	WDT
18637	155	62	envisaged	envisage	VBD
18637	155	63	the	the	DT
18637	155	64	National	National	NNP
18637	155	65	Government	Government	NNP
18637	155	66	and	and	CC
18637	155	67	the	the	DT
18637	155	68	States	States	NNPS
18637	155	69	as	as	IN
18637	155	70	jealous	jealous	JJ
18637	155	71	rivals	rival	NNS
18637	155	72	.	.	.
18637	156	1	To	to	TO
18637	156	2	be	be	VB
18637	156	3	sure	sure	JJ
18637	156	4	,	,	,
18637	156	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	156	6	occasionally	occasionally	RB
18637	156	7	get	get	VBP
18637	156	8	some	some	DT
18637	156	9	striking	striking	JJ
18637	156	10	statements	statement	NNS
18637	156	11	of	of	IN
18637	156	12	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	156	13	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	156	14	,	,	,
18637	156	15	as	as	IN
18637	156	16	in	in	IN
18637	156	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	156	18	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	156	19	's	's	POS
18637	156	20	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	156	21	in	in	IN
18637	156	22	1880	1880	CD
18637	156	23	for	for	IN
18637	156	24	a	a	DT
18637	156	25	divided	divide	VBN
18637	156	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	156	27	in	in	IN
18637	156	28	the	the	DT
18637	156	29	Siebold	Siebold	NNP
18637	156	30	Case,[16	Case,[16	NNP
18637	156	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	156	32	where	where	WRB
18637	156	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	156	34	reflected	reflect	VBN
18637	156	35	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	156	36	of	of	IN
18637	156	37	certain	certain	JJ
18637	156	38	results	result	NNS
18637	156	39	of	of	IN
18637	156	40	the	the	DT
18637	156	41	War	War	NNP
18637	156	42	between	between	IN
18637	156	43	the	the	DT
18637	156	44	States	States	NNPS
18637	156	45	;	;	:
18637	156	46	or	or	CC
18637	156	47	later	later	RB
18637	156	48	in	in	IN
18637	156	49	a	a	DT
18637	156	50	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	156	51	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	156	52	dictum	dictum	JJ
18637	156	53	by	by	IN
18637	156	54	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	156	55	McKenna	McKenna	NNP
18637	156	56	,	,	,
18637	156	57	in	in	IN
18637	156	58	Hoke	Hoke	NNP
18637	156	59	_	_	NNP
18637	156	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	156	61	_	_	NNP
18637	156	62	United	United	NNP
18637	156	63	States	States	NNP
18637	156	64	,	,	,
18637	156	65	in	in	IN
18637	156	66	which	which	WDT
18637	156	67	the	the	DT
18637	156	68	Mann	Mann	NNP
18637	156	69	White	White	NNP
18637	156	70	Slave	Slave	NNP
18637	156	71	Act	Act	NNP
18637	156	72	was	be	VBD
18637	156	73	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	156	74	in	in	IN
18637	156	75	1913	1913	CD
18637	156	76	:	:	:
18637	156	77	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	156	78	dual	dual	JJ
18637	156	79	form	form	NN
18637	156	80	of	of	IN
18637	156	81	government	government	NN
18637	156	82	has	have	VBZ
18637	156	83	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	156	84	perplexities	perplexity	NNS
18637	156	85	,	,	,
18637	156	86	State	State	NNP
18637	156	87	and	and	CC
18637	156	88	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	156	89	having	have	VBG
18637	156	90	different	different	JJ
18637	156	91	spheres	sphere	NNS
18637	156	92	of	of	IN
18637	156	93	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	156	94	...	...	:
18637	156	95	but	but	CC
18637	156	96	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	156	97	must	must	MD
18637	156	98	be	be	VB
18637	156	99	kept	keep	VBN
18637	156	100	in	in	IN
18637	156	101	mind	mind	NN
18637	156	102	that	that	IN
18637	156	103	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	156	104	are	be	VBP
18637	156	105	one	one	CD
18637	156	106	people	people	NNS
18637	156	107	;	;	:
18637	156	108	and	and	CC
18637	156	109	the	the	DT
18637	156	110	powers	power	NNS
18637	156	111	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	156	112	to	to	IN
18637	156	113	the	the	DT
18637	156	114	states	state	NNS
18637	156	115	and	and	CC
18637	156	116	those	those	DT
18637	156	117	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	156	118	on	on	IN
18637	156	119	the	the	DT
18637	156	120	nation	nation	NN
18637	156	121	are	be	VBP
18637	156	122	adapted	adapt	VBN
18637	156	123	to	to	TO
18637	156	124	be	be	VB
18637	156	125	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	156	126	,	,	,
18637	156	127	whether	whether	CC
18637	156	128	independently	independently	RB
18637	156	129	or	or	CC
18637	156	130	concurrently	concurrently	RB
18637	156	131	,	,	,
18637	156	132	to	to	TO
18637	156	133	promote	promote	VB
18637	156	134	the	the	DT
18637	156	135	general	general	JJ
18637	156	136	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	156	137	,	,	,
18637	156	138	material	material	NN
18637	156	139	and	and	CC
18637	156	140	moral	moral	JJ
18637	156	141	.	.	.
18637	157	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	157	2	17	17	CD
18637	157	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	157	4	The	the	DT
18637	157	5	competitive	competitive	JJ
18637	157	6	concept	concept	NN
18637	157	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	157	8	,	,	,
18637	157	9	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	157	10	,	,	,
18637	157	11	the	the	DT
18637	157	12	one	one	NN
18637	157	13	much	much	RB
18637	157	14	more	more	RBR
18637	157	15	generally	generally	RB
18637	157	16	evident	evident	JJ
18637	157	17	in	in	IN
18637	157	18	the	the	DT
18637	157	19	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	157	20	results	result	NNS
18637	157	21	for	for	IN
18637	157	22	American	American	NNP
18637	157	23	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	157	24	Law	Law	NNP
18637	157	25	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	157	26	three	three	CD
18637	157	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	157	28	quarters	quarter	NNS
18637	157	29	of	of	IN
18637	157	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	157	31	history	history	NN
18637	157	32	.	.	.
18637	158	1	Of	of	IN
18637	158	2	direct	direct	JJ
18637	158	3	pertinence	pertinence	NN
18637	158	4	in	in	IN
18637	158	5	this	this	DT
18637	158	6	connection	connection	NN
18637	158	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	158	8	the	the	DT
18637	158	9	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	158	10	of	of	IN
18637	158	11	tax	tax	NN
18637	158	12	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	158	13	which	which	WDT
18637	158	14	converted	convert	VBD
18637	158	15	federalism	federalism	NN
18637	158	16	into	into	IN
18637	158	17	a	a	DT
18637	158	18	principle	principle	NN
18637	158	19	of	of	IN
18637	158	20	private	private	JJ
18637	158	21	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	158	22	from	from	IN
18637	158	23	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	158	24	,	,	,
18637	158	25	so	so	IN
18637	158	26	that	that	IN
18637	158	27	,	,	,
18637	158	28	for	for	IN
18637	158	29	example	example	NN
18637	158	30	,	,	,
18637	158	31	neither	neither	CC
18637	158	32	government	government	NN
18637	158	33	could	could	MD
18637	158	34	tax	tax	VB
18637	158	35	as	as	IN
18637	158	36	income	income	NN
18637	158	37	the	the	DT
18637	158	38	official	official	JJ
18637	158	39	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	158	40	paid	pay	VBN
18637	158	41	by	by	IN
18637	158	42	the	the	DT
18637	158	43	other	other	JJ
18637	158	44	government	government	NN
18637	158	45	.	.	.
18637	159	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	159	2	18	18	CD
18637	159	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	159	4	This	this	DT
18637	159	5	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	159	6	traces	trace	VBZ
18637	159	7	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	159	8	to	to	IN
18637	159	9	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	159	10	's	's	POS
18637	159	11	famous	famous	JJ
18637	159	12	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	159	13	in	in	IN
18637	159	14	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	159	15	_	_	NNP
18637	159	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	159	17	_	_	NNP
18637	159	18	Maryland,[19	Maryland,[19	NNP
18637	159	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	159	20	and	and	CC
18637	159	21	bespeaks	bespeak	VBZ
18637	159	22	a	a	DT
18637	159	23	conception	conception	NN
18637	159	24	of	of	IN
18637	159	25	the	the	DT
18637	159	26	federal	federal	JJ
18637	159	27	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	159	28	which	which	WDT
18637	159	29	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	159	30	the	the	DT
18637	159	31	National	National	NNP
18637	159	32	Government	Government	NNP
18637	159	33	and	and	CC
18637	159	34	the	the	DT
18637	159	35	States	States	NNP
18637	159	36	as	as	IN
18637	159	37	bent	bent	JJ
18637	159	38	on	on	IN
18637	159	39	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	159	40	frustration	frustration	NN
18637	159	41	.	.	.
18637	160	1	Today	today	NN
18637	160	2	the	the	DT
18637	160	3	principle	principle	NN
18637	160	4	of	of	IN
18637	160	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	160	6	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	160	7	,	,	,
18637	160	8	except	except	IN
18637	160	9	so	so	RB
18637	160	10	far	far	RB
18637	160	11	as	as	IN
18637	160	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	160	13	may	may	MD
18637	160	14	choose	choose	VB
18637	160	15	to	to	TO
18637	160	16	apply	apply	VB
18637	160	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	160	18	to	to	IN
18637	160	19	federal	federal	JJ
18637	160	20	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	160	21	by	by	IN
18637	160	22	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	160	23	of	of	IN
18637	160	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	160	25	protective	protective	JJ
18637	160	26	powers	power	NNS
18637	160	27	under	under	IN
18637	160	28	the	the	DT
18637	160	29	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	160	30	and	and	CC
18637	160	31	proper	proper	JJ
18637	160	32	clause	clause	NN
18637	160	33	,	,	,
18637	160	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	160	35	at	at	IN
18637	160	36	an	an	DT
18637	160	37	end	end	NN
18637	160	38	.	.	.
18637	161	1	By	by	IN
18637	161	2	the	the	DT
18637	161	3	cooperative	cooperative	JJ
18637	161	4	conception	conception	NN
18637	161	5	of	of	IN
18637	161	6	the	the	DT
18637	161	7	federal	federal	JJ
18637	161	8	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	161	9	the	the	DT
18637	161	10	States	States	NNPS
18637	161	11	and	and	CC
18637	161	12	the	the	DT
18637	161	13	National	National	NNP
18637	161	14	Government	Government	NNP
18637	161	15	are	be	VBP
18637	161	16	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	161	17	as	as	IN
18637	161	18	mutually	mutually	RB
18637	161	19	complementary	complementary	JJ
18637	161	20	parts	part	NNS
18637	161	21	of	of	IN
18637	161	22	a	a	DT
18637	161	23	single	single	JJ
18637	161	24	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	161	25	mechanism	mechanism	NN
18637	161	26	all	all	DT
18637	161	27	of	of	IN
18637	161	28	whose	whose	WP$
18637	161	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	161	30	are	be	VBP
18637	161	31	intended	intend	VBN
18637	161	32	to	to	TO
18637	161	33	realize	realize	VB
18637	161	34	the	the	DT
18637	161	35	current	current	JJ
18637	161	36	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	161	37	of	of	IN
18637	161	38	government	government	NN
18637	161	39	according	accord	VBG
18637	161	40	to	to	IN
18637	161	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	161	42	applicability	applicability	NN
18637	161	43	to	to	IN
18637	161	44	the	the	DT
18637	161	45	problem	problem	NN
18637	161	46	in	in	IN
18637	161	47	hand	hand	NN
18637	161	48	.	.	.
18637	162	1	This	this	DT
18637	162	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	162	3	the	the	DT
18637	162	4	conception	conception	NN
18637	162	5	on	on	IN
18637	162	6	which	which	WDT
18637	162	7	the	the	DT
18637	162	8	recent	recent	JJ
18637	162	9	social	social	JJ
18637	162	10	and	and	CC
18637	162	11	economic	economic	JJ
18637	162	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	162	13	professes	profess	VBZ
18637	162	14	to	to	TO
18637	162	15	rest	rest	VB
18637	162	16	.	.	.
18637	163	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	163	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	163	3	the	the	DT
18637	163	4	conception	conception	NN
18637	163	5	which	which	WDT
18637	163	6	the	the	DT
18637	163	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	163	8	invokes	invoke	VBZ
18637	163	9	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	163	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	163	11	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	163	12	in	in	IN
18637	163	13	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	163	14	the	the	DT
18637	163	15	Social	Social	NNP
18637	163	16	Security	Security	NNP
18637	163	17	Act	Act	NNP
18637	163	18	of	of	IN
18637	163	19	1935	1935	CD
18637	163	20	and	and	CC
18637	163	21	supplementary	supplementary	JJ
18637	163	22	state	state	NN
18637	163	23	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	163	24	.	.	.
18637	164	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	164	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	164	3	the	the	DT
18637	164	4	conception	conception	NN
18637	164	5	which	which	WDT
18637	164	6	underlies	underlie	VBZ
18637	164	7	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	164	8	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	164	9	of	of	IN
18637	164	10	recent	recent	JJ
18637	164	11	years	year	NNS
18637	164	12	making	make	VBG
18637	164	13	certain	certain	JJ
18637	164	14	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	164	15	against	against	IN
18637	164	16	the	the	DT
18637	164	17	States	States	NNP
18637	164	18	,	,	,
18637	164	19	like	like	IN
18637	164	20	theft	theft	NN
18637	164	21	,	,	,
18637	164	22	racketeering	racketeering	NN
18637	164	23	,	,	,
18637	164	24	kidnapping	kidnapping	NN
18637	164	25	,	,	,
18637	164	26	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	164	27	also	also	RB
18637	164	28	against	against	IN
18637	164	29	the	the	DT
18637	164	30	National	National	NNP
18637	164	31	Government	Government	NNP
18637	164	32	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	164	33	the	the	DT
18637	164	34	offender	offender	NN
18637	164	35	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	164	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	164	37	activities	activity	NNS
18637	164	38	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	164	39	state	state	NN
18637	164	40	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	164	41	lines	line	NNS
18637	164	42	.	.	.
18637	165	1	The	the	DT
18637	165	2	usually	usually	RB
18637	165	3	cited	cite	VBN
18637	165	4	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	165	5	justification	justification	NN
18637	165	6	for	for	IN
18637	165	7	such	such	JJ
18637	165	8	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	165	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	165	10	that	that	DT
18637	165	11	which	which	WDT
18637	165	12	was	be	VBD
18637	165	13	advanced	advanced	JJ
18637	165	14	forty	forty	CD
18637	165	15	years	year	NNS
18637	165	16	ago	ago	RB
18637	165	17	in	in	IN
18637	165	18	the	the	DT
18637	165	19	above	above	RB
18637	165	20	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	165	21	Hoke	Hoke	NNP
18637	165	22	Case	Case	NNP
18637	165	23	.	.	.
18637	166	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	166	2	20	20	CD
18637	166	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	166	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	166	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	166	6	been	be	VBN
18637	166	7	argued	argue	VBN
18637	166	8	that	that	IN
18637	166	9	the	the	DT
18637	166	10	cooperative	cooperative	JJ
18637	166	11	conception	conception	NN
18637	166	12	of	of	IN
18637	166	13	the	the	DT
18637	166	14	federal	federal	JJ
18637	166	15	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	166	16	,	,	,
18637	166	17	especially	especially	RB
18637	166	18	as	as	IN
18637	166	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	166	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	166	21	realized	realize	VBN
18637	166	22	in	in	IN
18637	166	23	the	the	DT
18637	166	24	policy	policy	NN
18637	166	25	of	of	IN
18637	166	26	federal	federal	JJ
18637	166	27	subventions	subvention	NNS
18637	166	28	to	to	IN
18637	166	29	the	the	DT
18637	166	30	States	States	NNP
18637	166	31	,	,	,
18637	166	32	tends	tend	VBZ
18637	166	33	to	to	TO
18637	166	34	break	break	VB
18637	166	35	down	down	RP
18637	166	36	state	state	NN
18637	166	37	initiative	initiative	NN
18637	166	38	and	and	CC
18637	166	39	to	to	TO
18637	166	40	devitalize	devitalize	VB
18637	166	41	state	state	NN
18637	166	42	policies	policy	NNS
18637	166	43	.	.	.
18637	167	1	Actually	actually	RB
18637	167	2	,	,	,
18637	167	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	167	4	effect	effect	NN
18637	167	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	167	6	often	often	RB
18637	167	7	been	be	VBN
18637	167	8	just	just	RB
18637	167	9	the	the	DT
18637	167	10	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	167	11	,	,	,
18637	167	12	and	and	CC
18637	167	13	for	for	IN
18637	167	14	the	the	DT
18637	167	15	reason	reason	NN
18637	167	16	pointed	point	VBD
18637	167	17	out	out	RP
18637	167	18	by	by	IN
18637	167	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	167	20	Cardozo	Cardozo	NNP
18637	167	21	in	in	IN
18637	167	22	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	167	23	_	_	NNP
18637	167	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	167	25	_	_	NNP
18637	167	26	Davis,[21	Davis,[21	NNP
18637	167	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	167	28	decided	decide	VBD
18637	167	29	in	in	IN
18637	167	30	1937	1937	CD
18637	167	31	,	,	,
18637	167	32	namely	namely	RB
18637	167	33	,	,	,
18637	167	34	that	that	IN
18637	167	35	the	the	DT
18637	167	36	States	States	NNPS
18637	167	37	,	,	,
18637	167	38	competing	compete	VBG
18637	167	39	as	as	IN
18637	167	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	167	41	do	do	VBP
18637	167	42	with	with	IN
18637	167	43	one	one	NN
18637	167	44	another	another	DT
18637	167	45	to	to	TO
18637	167	46	attract	attract	VB
18637	167	47	investors	investor	NNS
18637	167	48	,	,	,
18637	167	49	have	have	VBP
18637	167	50	not	not	RB
18637	167	51	been	be	VBN
18637	167	52	able	able	JJ
18637	167	53	to	to	TO
18637	167	54	embark	embark	VB
18637	167	55	separately	separately	RB
18637	167	56	upon	upon	IN
18637	167	57	expensive	expensive	JJ
18637	167	58	programs	program	NNS
18637	167	59	of	of	IN
18637	167	60	relief	relief	NN
18637	167	61	and	and	CC
18637	167	62	social	social	JJ
18637	167	63	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	167	64	.	.	.
18637	168	1	Another	another	DT
18637	168	2	great	great	JJ
18637	168	3	objection	objection	NN
18637	168	4	to	to	IN
18637	168	5	Cooperative	Cooperative	NNP
18637	168	6	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	168	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	168	8	more	more	RBR
18637	168	9	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	168	10	to	to	TO
18637	168	11	meet	meet	VB
18637	168	12	.	.	.
18637	169	1	This	this	DT
18637	169	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	169	3	,	,	,
18637	169	4	that	that	IN
18637	169	5	Cooperative	Cooperative	NNP
18637	169	6	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	169	7	invites	invite	VBZ
18637	169	8	further	further	JJ
18637	169	9	aggrandizement	aggrandizement	NN
18637	169	10	of	of	IN
18637	169	11	national	national	JJ
18637	169	12	power	power	NN
18637	169	13	.	.	.
18637	170	1	Unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
18637	170	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	170	3	does	do	VBZ
18637	170	4	,	,	,
18637	170	5	for	for	IN
18637	170	6	when	when	WRB
18637	170	7	two	two	CD
18637	170	8	cooperate	cooperate	NN
18637	170	9	,	,	,
18637	170	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	170	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	170	12	the	the	DT
18637	170	13	stronger	strong	JJR
18637	170	14	member	member	NN
18637	170	15	of	of	IN
18637	170	16	the	the	DT
18637	170	17	combination	combination	NN
18637	170	18	who	who	WP
18637	170	19	usually	usually	RB
18637	170	20	calls	call	VBZ
18637	170	21	the	the	DT
18637	170	22	tunes	tune	NNS
18637	170	23	.	.	.
18637	171	1	Resting	rest	VBG
18637	171	2	as	as	IN
18637	171	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	171	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	171	5	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	171	6	on	on	IN
18637	171	7	the	the	DT
18637	171	8	superior	superior	JJ
18637	171	9	fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	171	10	resources	resource	NNS
18637	171	11	of	of	IN
18637	171	12	the	the	DT
18637	171	13	National	National	NNP
18637	171	14	Government	Government	NNP
18637	171	15	,	,	,
18637	171	16	Cooperative	Cooperative	NNP
18637	171	17	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	171	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	171	19	been	be	VBN
18637	171	20	,	,	,
18637	171	21	at	at	IN
18637	171	22	least	least	JJS
18637	171	23	to	to	IN
18637	171	24	date	date	NN
18637	171	25	,	,	,
18637	171	26	a	a	DT
18637	171	27	short	short	JJ
18637	171	28	expression	expression	NN
18637	171	29	for	for	IN
18637	171	30	a	a	DT
18637	171	31	constantly	constantly	RB
18637	171	32	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	171	33	concentration	concentration	NN
18637	171	34	of	of	IN
18637	171	35	power	power	NN
18637	171	36	at	at	IN
18637	171	37	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	171	38	in	in	IN
18637	171	39	the	the	DT
18637	171	40	stimulation	stimulation	NN
18637	171	41	and	and	CC
18637	171	42	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	171	43	of	of	IN
18637	171	44	local	local	JJ
18637	171	45	policies	policy	NNS
18637	171	46	.	.	.
18637	172	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	172	2	22	22	CD
18637	172	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	172	4	The	the	DT
18637	172	5	last	last	JJ
18637	172	6	element	element	NN
18637	172	7	of	of	IN
18637	172	8	the	the	DT
18637	172	9	concept	concept	NN
18637	172	10	of	of	IN
18637	172	11	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	172	12	to	to	TO
18637	172	13	demand	demand	VB
18637	172	14	attention	attention	NN
18637	172	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	172	16	the	the	DT
18637	172	17	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	172	18	that	that	IN
18637	172	19	the	the	DT
18637	172	20	National	National	NNP
18637	172	21	Government	Government	NNP
18637	172	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	172	23	a	a	DT
18637	172	24	government	government	NN
18637	172	25	of	of	IN
18637	172	26	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	172	27	powers	power	NNS
18637	172	28	only	only	RB
18637	172	29	,	,	,
18637	172	30	and	and	CC
18637	172	31	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	172	32	under	under	IN
18637	172	33	the	the	DT
18637	172	34	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	172	35	at	at	IN
18637	172	36	all	all	DT
18637	172	37	times	time	NNS
18637	172	38	of	of	IN
18637	172	39	justifying	justify	VBG
18637	172	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	172	41	measures	measure	NNS
18637	172	42	juridically	juridically	RB
18637	172	43	by	by	IN
18637	172	44	pointing	point	VBG
18637	172	45	to	to	IN
18637	172	46	some	some	DT
18637	172	47	particular	particular	JJ
18637	172	48	clause	clause	NN
18637	172	49	or	or	CC
18637	172	50	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	172	51	of	of	IN
18637	172	52	the	the	DT
18637	172	53	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	172	54	which	which	WDT
18637	172	55	,	,	,
18637	172	56	when	when	WRB
18637	172	57	read	read	VB
18637	172	58	separately	separately	RB
18637	172	59	or	or	CC
18637	172	60	in	in	IN
18637	172	61	combination	combination	NN
18637	172	62	,	,	,
18637	172	63	may	may	MD
18637	172	64	be	be	VB
18637	172	65	thought	think	VBN
18637	172	66	to	to	TO
18637	172	67	grant	grant	VB
18637	172	68	power	power	NN
18637	172	69	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	172	70	to	to	IN
18637	172	71	such	such	JJ
18637	172	72	measures	measure	NNS
18637	172	73	.	.	.
18637	173	1	In	in	IN
18637	173	2	spite	spite	NN
18637	173	3	of	of	IN
18637	173	4	such	such	JJ
18637	173	5	recent	recent	JJ
18637	173	6	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	173	7	as	as	IN
18637	173	8	that	that	DT
18637	173	9	in	in	IN
18637	173	10	United	United	NNP
18637	173	11	States	States	NNP
18637	173	12	_	_	NNP
18637	173	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	173	14	_	_	NNP
18637	173	15	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	173	16	,	,	,
18637	173	17	this	this	DT
18637	173	18	time	time	NN
18637	173	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	173	20	honored	honor	VBN
18637	173	21	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	173	22	still	still	RB
18637	173	23	guides	guide	VBZ
18637	173	24	the	the	DT
18637	173	25	authoritative	authoritative	JJ
18637	173	26	interpreters	interpreter	NNS
18637	173	27	of	of	IN
18637	173	28	the	the	DT
18637	173	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	173	30	in	in	IN
18637	173	31	determining	determine	VBG
18637	173	32	the	the	DT
18637	173	33	validity	validity	NN
18637	173	34	of	of	IN
18637	173	35	acts	act	NNS
18637	173	36	which	which	WDT
18637	173	37	are	be	VBP
18637	173	38	passed	pass	VBN
18637	173	39	by	by	IN
18637	173	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	173	41	in	in	IN
18637	173	42	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	173	43	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	173	44	of	of	IN
18637	173	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	173	46	powers	power	NNS
18637	173	47	of	of	IN
18637	173	48	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	173	49	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	173	50	--	--	:
18637	173	51	the	the	DT
18637	173	52	course	course	NN
18637	173	53	of	of	IN
18637	173	54	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	173	55	pursued	pursue	VBN
18637	173	56	by	by	IN
18637	173	57	the	the	DT
18637	173	58	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	173	59	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	173	60	in	in	IN
18637	173	61	the	the	DT
18637	173	62	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	173	63	Case	Case	NNP
18637	173	64	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	173	65	is	be	VBZ
18637	173	66	proof	proof	NN
18637	173	67	that	that	IN
18637	173	68	such	such	JJ
18637	173	69	is	be	VBZ
18637	173	70	the	the	DT
18637	173	71	fact	fact	NN
18637	173	72	.	.	.
18637	174	1	In	in	IN
18637	174	2	the	the	DT
18637	174	3	field	field	NN
18637	174	4	of	of	IN
18637	174	5	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	174	6	relations	relation	NNS
18637	174	7	,	,	,
18637	174	8	on	on	IN
18637	174	9	the	the	DT
18637	174	10	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	174	11	,	,	,
18637	174	12	the	the	DT
18637	174	13	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	174	14	of	of	IN
18637	174	15	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	174	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	174	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	174	18	always	always	RB
18637	174	19	had	have	VBN
18637	174	20	a	a	DT
18637	174	21	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	174	22	row	row	NN
18637	174	23	to	to	TO
18637	174	24	hoe	hoe	VB
18637	174	25	,	,	,
18637	174	26	and	and	CC
18637	174	27	today	today	NN
18637	174	28	may	may	MD
18637	174	29	be	be	VB
18637	174	30	unqualifiedly	unqualifiedly	RB
18637	174	31	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	174	32	to	to	TO
18637	174	33	be	be	VB
18637	174	34	defunct	defunct	JJ
18637	174	35	.	.	.
18637	175	1	As	as	RB
18637	175	2	early	early	RB
18637	175	3	as	as	IN
18637	175	4	the	the	DT
18637	175	5	old	old	JJ
18637	175	6	case	case	NN
18637	175	7	of	of	IN
18637	175	8	Penhallow	Penhallow	NNP
18637	175	9	_	_	NNP
18637	175	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	175	11	_	_	NNP
18637	175	12	Doane	Doane	NNP
18637	175	13	,	,	,
18637	175	14	which	which	WDT
18637	175	15	was	be	VBD
18637	175	16	decided	decide	VBN
18637	175	17	by	by	IN
18637	175	18	the	the	DT
18637	175	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	175	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	175	21	in	in	IN
18637	175	22	1795	1795	CD
18637	175	23	,	,	,
18637	175	24	certain	certain	JJ
18637	175	25	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	175	26	thought	think	VBD
18637	175	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	175	28	pertinent	pertinent	VBD
18637	175	29	to	to	TO
18637	175	30	urge	urge	VB
18637	175	31	the	the	DT
18637	175	32	following	follow	VBG
18637	175	33	conception	conception	NN
18637	175	34	of	of	IN
18637	175	35	the	the	DT
18637	175	36	War	War	NNP
18637	175	37	Power	Power	NNP
18637	175	38	:	:	:
18637	175	39	A	a	DT
18637	175	40	formal	formal	JJ
18637	175	41	compact	compact	NN
18637	175	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	175	43	not	not	RB
18637	175	44	essential	essential	JJ
18637	175	45	to	to	IN
18637	175	46	the	the	DT
18637	175	47	institution	institution	NN
18637	175	48	of	of	IN
18637	175	49	a	a	DT
18637	175	50	government	government	NN
18637	175	51	.	.	.
18637	176	1	Every	every	DT
18637	176	2	nation	nation	NN
18637	176	3	that	that	WDT
18637	176	4	governs	govern	VBZ
18637	176	5	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	176	6	,	,	,
18637	176	7	under	under	IN
18637	176	8	what	what	WDT
18637	176	9	form	form	NN
18637	176	10	soever	soever	NN
18637	176	11	,	,	,
18637	176	12	without	without	IN
18637	176	13	any	any	DT
18637	176	14	dependence	dependence	NN
18637	176	15	on	on	IN
18637	176	16	a	a	DT
18637	176	17	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	176	18	power	power	NN
18637	176	19	,	,	,
18637	176	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	176	21	a	a	DT
18637	176	22	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	176	23	state	state	NN
18637	176	24	.	.	.
18637	177	1	In	in	IN
18637	177	2	every	every	DT
18637	177	3	society	society	NN
18637	177	4	there	there	EX
18637	177	5	must	must	MD
18637	177	6	be	be	VB
18637	177	7	a	a	DT
18637	177	8	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	177	9	.	.	.
18637	178	1	1	1	CD
18637	178	2	Dall	dall	NN
18637	178	3	.	.	.
18637	179	1	Rep.	Rep.	NNP
18637	179	2	46	46	CD
18637	179	3	,	,	,
18637	179	4	57	57	CD
18637	179	5	.	.	.
18637	180	1	Vatt	Vatt	NNP
18637	180	2	.	.	.
18637	181	1	B.	B.	NNP
18637	182	1	1	1	LS
18637	182	2	.	.	.
18637	182	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	182	4	.	.	.
18637	183	1	1	1	LS
18637	183	2	.	.	.
18637	183	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	183	4	.	.	.
18637	184	1	4	4	LS
18637	184	2	.	.	.
18637	185	1	The	the	DT
18637	185	2	powers	power	NNS
18637	185	3	of	of	IN
18637	185	4	war	war	NN
18637	185	5	form	form	VBP
18637	185	6	an	an	DT
18637	185	7	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	185	8	characteristic	characteristic	NN
18637	185	9	of	of	IN
18637	185	10	national	national	JJ
18637	185	11	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	185	12	;	;	:
18637	185	13	and	and	CC
18637	185	14	,	,	,
18637	185	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	185	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	185	17	not	not	RB
18637	185	18	denied	deny	VBN
18637	185	19	,	,	,
18637	185	20	that	that	IN
18637	185	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	185	22	possessed	possess	VBD
18637	185	23	those	those	DT
18637	185	24	powers	power	NNS
18637	185	25	....	....	NFP
18637	185	26	[23	[23	XX
18637	185	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	185	28	To	to	TO
18637	185	29	be	be	VB
18637	185	30	sure	sure	JJ
18637	185	31	,	,	,
18637	185	32	only	only	RB
18637	185	33	two	two	CD
18637	185	34	of	of	IN
18637	185	35	the	the	DT
18637	185	36	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	185	37	felt	feel	VBD
18637	185	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	185	39	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	185	40	to	to	TO
18637	185	41	comment	comment	VB
18637	185	42	on	on	IN
18637	185	43	this	this	DT
18637	185	44	argument	argument	NN
18637	185	45	,	,	,
18637	185	46	which	which	WDT
18637	185	47	one	one	NN
18637	185	48	of	of	IN
18637	185	49	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	185	50	endorsed	endorse	VBD
18637	185	51	,	,	,
18637	185	52	while	while	IN
18637	185	53	the	the	DT
18637	185	54	other	other	JJ
18637	185	55	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	185	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	185	57	.	.	.
18637	186	1	Yet	yet	RB
18637	186	2	seventy	seventy	CD
18637	186	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	186	4	five	five	CD
18637	186	5	years	year	NNS
18637	186	6	later	later	RBR
18637	186	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	186	8	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	186	9	incorporated	incorporate	VBD
18637	186	10	closely	closely	RB
18637	186	11	kindred	kindred	JJ
18637	186	12	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	186	13	into	into	IN
18637	186	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	186	15	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	186	16	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	186	17	in	in	IN
18637	186	18	the	the	DT
18637	186	19	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	186	20	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	186	21	Cases;[24	Cases;[24	NNP
18637	186	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	186	23	and	and	CC
18637	186	24	in	in	IN
18637	186	25	the	the	DT
18637	186	26	years	year	NNS
18637	186	27	following	follow	VBG
18637	186	28	the	the	DT
18637	186	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	186	30	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	186	31	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	186	32	brought	bring	VBD
18637	186	33	the	the	DT
18637	186	34	same	same	JJ
18637	186	35	general	general	JJ
18637	186	36	outlook	outlook	NN
18637	186	37	to	to	IN
18637	186	38	questions	question	NNS
18637	186	39	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	186	40	the	the	DT
18637	186	41	National	National	NNP
18637	186	42	Government	Government	NNP
18637	186	43	's	's	POS
18637	186	44	powers	power	NNS
18637	186	45	in	in	IN
18637	186	46	the	the	DT
18637	186	47	field	field	NN
18637	186	48	of	of	IN
18637	186	49	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	186	50	relations	relation	NNS
18637	186	51	.	.	.
18637	187	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	187	2	in	in	IN
18637	187	3	the	the	DT
18637	187	4	Chinese	Chinese	NNP
18637	187	5	Exclusion	Exclusion	NNP
18637	187	6	Case	Case	NNP
18637	187	7	,	,	,
18637	187	8	decided	decide	VBD
18637	187	9	in	in	IN
18637	187	10	1889	1889	CD
18637	187	11	,	,	,
18637	187	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	187	13	Field	Field	NNP
18637	187	14	,	,	,
18637	187	15	in	in	IN
18637	187	16	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	187	17	the	the	DT
18637	187	18	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	187	19	power	power	NN
18637	187	20	of	of	IN
18637	187	21	the	the	DT
18637	187	22	National	National	NNP
18637	187	23	Government	Government	NNP
18637	187	24	,	,	,
18637	187	25	and	and	CC
18637	187	26	hence	hence	RB
18637	187	27	of	of	IN
18637	187	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	187	29	,	,	,
18637	187	30	to	to	TO
18637	187	31	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	187	32	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	187	33	from	from	IN
18637	187	34	American	american	JJ
18637	187	35	shores	shore	NNS
18637	187	36	,	,	,
18637	187	37	remarked	remark	VBD
18637	187	38	:	:	:
18637	187	39	While	while	IN
18637	187	40	under	under	IN
18637	187	41	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	187	42	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	187	43	and	and	CC
18637	187	44	form	form	NN
18637	187	45	of	of	IN
18637	187	46	government	government	NN
18637	187	47	the	the	DT
18637	187	48	great	great	JJ
18637	187	49	mass	mass	NN
18637	187	50	of	of	IN
18637	187	51	local	local	JJ
18637	187	52	matters	matter	NNS
18637	187	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	187	54	controlled	control	VBN
18637	187	55	by	by	IN
18637	187	56	local	local	JJ
18637	187	57	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	187	58	,	,	,
18637	187	59	the	the	DT
18637	187	60	United	United	NNP
18637	187	61	States	States	NNP
18637	187	62	,	,	,
18637	187	63	in	in	IN
18637	187	64	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	187	65	relation	relation	NN
18637	187	66	to	to	IN
18637	187	67	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	187	68	countries	country	NNS
18637	187	69	and	and	CC
18637	187	70	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	187	71	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	187	72	or	or	CC
18637	187	73	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	187	74	,	,	,
18637	187	75	are	be	VBP
18637	187	76	one	one	CD
18637	187	77	nation	nation	NN
18637	187	78	,	,	,
18637	187	79	invested	invest	VBN
18637	187	80	with	with	IN
18637	187	81	the	the	DT
18637	187	82	powers	power	NNS
18637	187	83	which	which	WDT
18637	187	84	belong	belong	VBP
18637	187	85	to	to	IN
18637	187	86	independent	independent	JJ
18637	187	87	nations	nation	NNS
18637	187	88	,	,	,
18637	187	89	the	the	DT
18637	187	90	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	187	91	of	of	IN
18637	187	92	which	which	WDT
18637	187	93	can	can	MD
18637	187	94	be	be	VB
18637	187	95	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	187	96	for	for	IN
18637	187	97	the	the	DT
18637	187	98	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	187	99	of	of	IN
18637	187	100	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	187	101	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	187	102	independence	independence	NN
18637	187	103	and	and	CC
18637	187	104	security	security	NN
18637	187	105	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	187	106	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	187	107	entire	entire	JJ
18637	187	108	territory	territory	NN
18637	187	109	.	.	.
18637	188	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	188	2	25	25	CD
18637	188	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	188	4	And	and	CC
18637	188	5	four	four	CD
18637	188	6	years	year	NNS
18637	188	7	later	later	RB
18637	188	8	the	the	DT
18637	188	9	power	power	NN
18637	188	10	of	of	IN
18637	188	11	the	the	DT
18637	188	12	National	National	NNP
18637	188	13	Government	Government	NNP
18637	188	14	to	to	TO
18637	188	15	deport	deport	VB
18637	188	16	alien	alien	JJ
18637	188	17	residents	resident	NNS
18637	188	18	at	at	IN
18637	188	19	the	the	DT
18637	188	20	option	option	NN
18637	188	21	of	of	IN
18637	188	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	188	23	was	be	VBD
18637	188	24	based	base	VBN
18637	188	25	by	by	IN
18637	188	26	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	188	27	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	188	28	on	on	IN
18637	188	29	the	the	DT
18637	188	30	same	same	JJ
18637	188	31	general	general	JJ
18637	188	32	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	188	33	.	.	.
18637	189	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	189	2	26	26	CD
18637	189	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	189	4	Finally	finally	RB
18637	189	5	,	,	,
18637	189	6	in	in	IN
18637	189	7	1936	1936	CD
18637	189	8	,	,	,
18637	189	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	189	10	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	189	11	,	,	,
18637	189	12	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	189	13	for	for	IN
18637	189	14	the	the	DT
18637	189	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	189	16	in	in	IN
18637	189	17	United	United	NNP
18637	189	18	States	States	NNP
18637	189	19	_	_	NNP
18637	189	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	189	21	_	_	NNP
18637	189	22	Curtiss	Curtiss	NNP
18637	189	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	189	24	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	189	25	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	189	26	,	,	,
18637	189	27	with	with	IN
18637	189	28	World	World	NNP
18637	189	29	War	War	NNP
18637	189	30	I	I	NNP
18637	189	31	a	a	DT
18637	189	32	still	still	RB
18637	189	33	recent	recent	JJ
18637	189	34	memory	memory	NN
18637	189	35	,	,	,
18637	189	36	took	take	VBD
18637	189	37	over	over	RP
18637	189	38	bodily	bodily	JJ
18637	189	39	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	189	40	's	's	POS
18637	189	41	argument	argument	NN
18637	189	42	of	of	IN
18637	189	43	140	140	CD
18637	189	44	years	year	NNS
18637	189	45	earlier	early	RBR
18637	189	46	,	,	,
18637	189	47	and	and	CC
18637	189	48	elevated	elevate	VBD
18637	189	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	189	50	to	to	IN
18637	189	51	the	the	DT
18637	189	52	head	head	NN
18637	189	53	of	of	IN
18637	189	54	the	the	DT
18637	189	55	column	column	NN
18637	189	56	of	of	IN
18637	189	57	authoritative	authoritative	JJ
18637	189	58	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	189	59	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	189	60	.	.	.
18637	190	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	190	2	said	say	VBD
18637	190	3	:	:	:
18637	190	4	A	a	DT
18637	190	5	political	political	JJ
18637	190	6	society	society	NN
18637	190	7	can	can	MD
18637	190	8	not	not	RB
18637	190	9	endure	endure	VB
18637	190	10	without	without	IN
18637	190	11	a	a	DT
18637	190	12	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	190	13	will	will	MD
18637	190	14	somewhere	somewhere	RB
18637	190	15	.	.	.
18637	191	1	Sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	191	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	191	3	never	never	RB
18637	191	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	191	5	in	in	IN
18637	191	6	suspense	suspense	NN
18637	191	7	.	.	.
18637	192	1	When	when	WRB
18637	192	2	,	,	,
18637	192	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	192	4	,	,	,
18637	192	5	the	the	DT
18637	192	6	external	external	JJ
18637	192	7	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	192	8	of	of	IN
18637	192	9	Great	Great	NNP
18637	192	10	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	192	11	in	in	IN
18637	192	12	respect	respect	NN
18637	192	13	of	of	IN
18637	192	14	the	the	DT
18637	192	15	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	192	16	ceased	cease	VBD
18637	192	17	,	,	,
18637	192	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	192	19	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	192	20	passed	pass	VBD
18637	192	21	to	to	IN
18637	192	22	the	the	DT
18637	192	23	Union	Union	NNP
18637	192	24	....	....	.
18637	193	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	193	2	results	result	VBZ
18637	193	3	that	that	IN
18637	193	4	the	the	DT
18637	193	5	investment	investment	NN
18637	193	6	of	of	IN
18637	193	7	the	the	DT
18637	193	8	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	193	9	government	government	NN
18637	193	10	with	with	IN
18637	193	11	the	the	DT
18637	193	12	powers	power	NNS
18637	193	13	of	of	IN
18637	193	14	external	external	JJ
18637	193	15	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	193	16	did	do	VBD
18637	193	17	not	not	RB
18637	193	18	depend	depend	VB
18637	193	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	193	20	the	the	DT
18637	193	21	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	193	22	grants	grant	NNS
18637	193	23	of	of	IN
18637	193	24	the	the	DT
18637	193	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	193	26	.	.	.
18637	194	1	The	the	DT
18637	194	2	powers	power	NNS
18637	194	3	to	to	TO
18637	194	4	declare	declare	VB
18637	194	5	and	and	CC
18637	194	6	wage	wage	VB
18637	194	7	war	war	NN
18637	194	8	,	,	,
18637	194	9	to	to	TO
18637	194	10	conclude	conclude	VB
18637	194	11	peace	peace	NN
18637	194	12	,	,	,
18637	194	13	to	to	TO
18637	194	14	make	make	VB
18637	194	15	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	194	16	,	,	,
18637	194	17	to	to	TO
18637	194	18	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	194	19	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	194	20	relations	relation	NNS
18637	194	21	with	with	IN
18637	194	22	other	other	JJ
18637	194	23	sovereignties	sovereignty	NNS
18637	194	24	,	,	,
18637	194	25	if	if	IN
18637	194	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	194	27	had	have	VBD
18637	194	28	never	never	RB
18637	194	29	been	be	VBN
18637	194	30	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	194	31	in	in	IN
18637	194	32	the	the	DT
18637	194	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	194	34	,	,	,
18637	194	35	would	would	MD
18637	194	36	have	have	VB
18637	194	37	vested	vest	VBN
18637	194	38	in	in	IN
18637	194	39	the	the	DT
18637	194	40	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	194	41	government	government	NN
18637	194	42	as	as	IN
18637	194	43	a	a	DT
18637	194	44	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	194	45	concomitant	concomitant	NN
18637	194	46	of	of	IN
18637	194	47	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	194	48	.	.	.
18637	195	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	195	2	27	27	CD
18637	195	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	195	4	In	in	IN
18637	195	5	short	short	JJ
18637	195	6	,	,	,
18637	195	7	the	the	DT
18637	195	8	power	power	NN
18637	195	9	of	of	IN
18637	195	10	the	the	DT
18637	195	11	National	National	NNP
18637	195	12	Government	Government	NNP
18637	195	13	in	in	IN
18637	195	14	the	the	DT
18637	195	15	field	field	NN
18637	195	16	of	of	IN
18637	195	17	international	international	JJ
18637	195	18	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	195	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	195	20	not	not	RB
18637	195	21	simply	simply	RB
18637	195	22	a	a	DT
18637	195	23	complexus	complexus	NN
18637	195	24	of	of	IN
18637	195	25	particular	particular	JJ
18637	195	26	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	195	27	powers	power	NNS
18637	195	28	;	;	:
18637	195	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	195	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	195	31	an	an	DT
18637	195	32	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	195	33	power	power	NN
18637	195	34	,	,	,
18637	195	35	one	one	CD
18637	195	36	which	which	WDT
18637	195	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	195	38	attributable	attributable	JJ
18637	195	39	to	to	IN
18637	195	40	the	the	DT
18637	195	41	National	National	NNP
18637	195	42	Government	Government	NNP
18637	195	43	on	on	IN
18637	195	44	the	the	DT
18637	195	45	ground	ground	NN
18637	195	46	solely	solely	RB
18637	195	47	of	of	IN
18637	195	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	195	49	belonging	belonging	NN
18637	195	50	to	to	IN
18637	195	51	the	the	DT
18637	195	52	American	American	NNP
18637	195	53	People	People	NNP
18637	195	54	as	as	IN
18637	195	55	a	a	DT
18637	195	56	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	195	57	political	political	JJ
18637	195	58	entity	entity	NN
18637	195	59	at	at	IN
18637	195	60	International	International	NNP
18637	195	61	Law	Law	NNP
18637	195	62	.	.	.
18637	196	1	In	in	IN
18637	196	2	that	that	DT
18637	196	3	field	field	NN
18637	196	4	the	the	DT
18637	196	5	principle	principle	NN
18637	196	6	of	of	IN
18637	196	7	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	196	8	no	no	RB
18637	196	9	longer	long	RBR
18637	196	10	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	196	11	,	,	,
18637	196	12	if	if	IN
18637	196	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	196	14	ever	ever	RB
18637	196	15	did	do	VBD
18637	196	16	.	.	.
18637	197	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	197	2	28	28	CD
18637	197	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	197	4	II	II	NNP
18637	197	5	The	the	DT
18637	197	6	Separation	separation	NN
18637	197	7	of	of	IN
18637	197	8	Powers	power	NNS
18637	197	9	The	the	DT
18637	197	10	second	second	JJ
18637	197	11	great	great	JJ
18637	197	12	structural	structural	JJ
18637	197	13	principle	principle	NN
18637	197	14	of	of	IN
18637	197	15	American	American	NNP
18637	197	16	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	197	17	Law	Law	NNP
18637	197	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	197	19	supplied	supply	VBN
18637	197	20	by	by	IN
18637	197	21	the	the	DT
18637	197	22	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	197	23	of	of	IN
18637	197	24	the	the	DT
18637	197	25	Separation	Separation	NNP
18637	197	26	of	of	IN
18637	197	27	Powers	power	NNS
18637	197	28	.	.	.
18637	198	1	The	the	DT
18637	198	2	notion	notion	NN
18637	198	3	of	of	IN
18637	198	4	three	three	CD
18637	198	5	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	198	6	functions	function	NNS
18637	198	7	of	of	IN
18637	198	8	government	government	NN
18637	198	9	approximating	approximate	VBG
18637	198	10	what	what	WP
18637	198	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	198	12	today	today	NN
18637	198	13	term	term	NN
18637	198	14	the	the	DT
18637	198	15	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	198	16	,	,	,
18637	198	17	the	the	DT
18637	198	18	executive	executive	NN
18637	198	19	,	,	,
18637	198	20	and	and	CC
18637	198	21	the	the	DT
18637	198	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	198	23	,	,	,
18637	198	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	198	25	set	set	VBN
18637	198	26	forth	forth	RP
18637	198	27	in	in	IN
18637	198	28	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
18637	198	29	's	's	POS
18637	198	30	Politics,[29	politics,[29	NN
18637	198	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	198	32	but	but	CC
18637	198	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	198	34	was	be	VBD
18637	198	35	the	the	DT
18637	198	36	celebrated	celebrated	JJ
18637	198	37	Montesquieu	Montesquieu	NNP
18637	198	38	who	who	WP
18637	198	39	,	,	,
18637	198	40	by	by	IN
18637	198	41	joining	join	VBG
18637	198	42	the	the	DT
18637	198	43	idea	idea	NN
18637	198	44	to	to	IN
18637	198	45	the	the	DT
18637	198	46	notion	notion	NN
18637	198	47	of	of	IN
18637	198	48	a	a	DT
18637	198	49	"	"	``
18637	198	50	mixed	mixed	JJ
18637	198	51	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	198	52	"	"	''
18637	198	53	of	of	IN
18637	198	54	"	"	``
18637	198	55	checks	check	NNS
18637	198	56	and	and	CC
18637	198	57	balances	balance	NNS
18637	198	58	"	"	''
18637	198	59	,	,	,
18637	198	60	in	in	IN
18637	198	61	Book	Book	NNP
18637	198	62	XI	XI	NNP
18637	198	63	of	of	IN
18637	198	64	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	198	65	Spirit	Spirit	NNP
18637	198	66	of	of	IN
18637	198	67	the	the	DT
18637	198	68	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	198	69	,	,	,
18637	198	70	brought	bring	VBD
18637	198	71	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
18637	198	72	's	's	POS
18637	198	73	discovery	discovery	NN
18637	198	74	to	to	IN
18637	198	75	the	the	DT
18637	198	76	service	service	NN
18637	198	77	of	of	IN
18637	198	78	the	the	DT
18637	198	79	rising	rise	VBG
18637	198	80	libertarianism	libertarianism	NN
18637	198	81	of	of	IN
18637	198	82	the	the	DT
18637	198	83	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
18637	198	84	century	century	NN
18637	198	85	.	.	.
18637	199	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	199	2	was	be	VBD
18637	199	3	Montesquieu	Montesquieu	NNP
18637	199	4	's	's	POS
18637	199	5	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	199	6	contention	contention	NN
18637	199	7	that	that	IN
18637	199	8	"	"	``
18637	199	9	men	man	NNS
18637	199	10	entrusted	entrust	VBD
18637	199	11	with	with	IN
18637	199	12	power	power	NN
18637	199	13	tend	tend	VBP
18637	199	14	to	to	TO
18637	199	15	abuse	abuse	VB
18637	199	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	199	17	"	"	''
18637	199	18	.	.	.
18637	200	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	200	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	200	3	was	be	VBD
18637	200	4	desirable	desirable	JJ
18637	200	5	to	to	TO
18637	200	6	divide	divide	VB
18637	200	7	the	the	DT
18637	200	8	powers	power	NNS
18637	200	9	of	of	IN
18637	200	10	government	government	NN
18637	200	11	,	,	,
18637	200	12	first	first	RB
18637	200	13	,	,	,
18637	200	14	in	in	IN
18637	200	15	order	order	NN
18637	200	16	to	to	TO
18637	200	17	keep	keep	VB
18637	200	18	to	to	IN
18637	200	19	a	a	DT
18637	200	20	minimum	minimum	NN
18637	200	21	the	the	DT
18637	200	22	powers	power	NNS
18637	200	23	lodged	lodge	VBN
18637	200	24	in	in	IN
18637	200	25	any	any	DT
18637	200	26	single	single	JJ
18637	200	27	organ	organ	NN
18637	200	28	of	of	IN
18637	200	29	government	government	NN
18637	200	30	;	;	:
18637	200	31	secondly	secondly	RB
18637	200	32	,	,	,
18637	200	33	in	in	IN
18637	200	34	order	order	NN
18637	200	35	to	to	TO
18637	200	36	be	be	VB
18637	200	37	able	able	JJ
18637	200	38	to	to	TO
18637	200	39	oppose	oppose	VB
18637	200	40	organ	organ	NN
18637	200	41	to	to	TO
18637	200	42	organ	organ	VB
18637	200	43	.	.	.
18637	201	1	In	in	IN
18637	201	2	the	the	DT
18637	201	3	United	United	NNP
18637	201	4	States	States	NNP
18637	201	5	libertarian	libertarian	JJ
18637	201	6	application	application	NN
18637	201	7	of	of	IN
18637	201	8	the	the	DT
18637	201	9	principle	principle	NN
18637	201	10	was	be	VBD
18637	201	11	originally	originally	RB
18637	201	12	not	not	RB
18637	201	13	too	too	RB
18637	201	14	much	much	RB
18637	201	15	embarrassed	embarrass	VBN
18637	201	16	by	by	IN
18637	201	17	inherited	inherited	JJ
18637	201	18	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	201	19	.	.	.
18637	202	1	In	in	IN
18637	202	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	202	3	most	most	RBS
18637	202	4	dogmatic	dogmatic	JJ
18637	202	5	form	form	NN
18637	202	6	the	the	DT
18637	202	7	American	american	JJ
18637	202	8	conception	conception	NN
18637	202	9	of	of	IN
18637	202	10	the	the	DT
18637	202	11	Separation	Separation	NNP
18637	202	12	of	of	IN
18637	202	13	Powers	power	NNS
18637	202	14	may	may	MD
18637	202	15	be	be	VB
18637	202	16	summed	sum	VBN
18637	202	17	up	up	RP
18637	202	18	in	in	IN
18637	202	19	the	the	DT
18637	202	20	following	following	JJ
18637	202	21	propositions	proposition	NNS
18637	202	22	:	:	:
18637	202	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	202	24	1	1	LS
18637	202	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	202	26	There	there	EX
18637	202	27	are	be	VBP
18637	202	28	three	three	CD
18637	202	29	intrinsically	intrinsically	RB
18637	202	30	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	202	31	functions	function	NNS
18637	202	32	of	of	IN
18637	202	33	government	government	NN
18637	202	34	,	,	,
18637	202	35	the	the	DT
18637	202	36	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	202	37	,	,	,
18637	202	38	the	the	DT
18637	202	39	executive	executive	NN
18637	202	40	,	,	,
18637	202	41	and	and	CC
18637	202	42	the	the	DT
18637	202	43	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	202	44	;	;	:
18637	202	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	202	46	2	2	LS
18637	202	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	202	48	these	these	DT
18637	202	49	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	202	50	functions	function	NNS
18637	202	51	ought	ought	MD
18637	202	52	to	to	TO
18637	202	53	be	be	VB
18637	202	54	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	202	55	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	202	56	by	by	IN
18637	202	57	three	three	CD
18637	202	58	separately	separately	RB
18637	202	59	manned	manned	JJ
18637	202	60	departments	department	NNS
18637	202	61	of	of	IN
18637	202	62	government	government	NN
18637	202	63	;	;	:
18637	202	64	which	which	WDT
18637	202	65	,	,	,
18637	202	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	202	67	3	3	LS
18637	202	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	202	69	should	should	MD
18637	202	70	be	be	VB
18637	202	71	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	202	72	equal	equal	JJ
18637	202	73	and	and	CC
18637	202	74	mutually	mutually	RB
18637	202	75	independent	independent	JJ
18637	202	76	;	;	:
18637	202	77	and	and	CC
18637	202	78	finally	finally	RB
18637	202	79	,	,	,
18637	202	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	202	81	4	4	LS
18637	202	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	202	83	a	a	DT
18637	202	84	corollary	corollary	JJ
18637	202	85	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	202	86	stated	state	VBN
18637	202	87	by	by	IN
18637	202	88	Locke	Locke	NNP
18637	202	89	--	--	:
18637	202	90	the	the	DT
18637	202	91	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	202	92	may	may	MD
18637	202	93	not	not	RB
18637	202	94	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	202	95	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	202	96	powers	power	NNS
18637	202	97	.	.	.
18637	203	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	203	2	30	30	CD
18637	203	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	203	4	Prior	prior	RB
18637	203	5	even	even	RB
18637	203	6	to	to	IN
18637	203	7	Franklin	Franklin	NNP
18637	203	8	D.	D.	NNP
18637	203	9	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	203	10	this	this	DT
18637	203	11	entire	entire	JJ
18637	203	12	colligation	colligation	NN
18637	203	13	of	of	IN
18637	203	14	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	203	15	had	have	VBD
18637	203	16	been	be	VBN
18637	203	17	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	203	18	by	by	IN
18637	203	19	three	three	CD
18637	203	20	developments	development	NNS
18637	203	21	in	in	IN
18637	203	22	national	national	JJ
18637	203	23	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	203	24	practice	practice	NN
18637	203	25	:	:	:
18637	203	26	first	first	RB
18637	203	27	,	,	,
18637	203	28	the	the	DT
18637	203	29	growth	growth	NN
18637	203	30	of	of	IN
18637	203	31	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	203	32	initiative	initiative	NN
18637	203	33	in	in	IN
18637	203	34	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	203	35	;	;	:
18637	203	36	secondly	secondly	RB
18637	203	37	,	,	,
18637	203	38	the	the	DT
18637	203	39	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	203	40	by	by	IN
18637	203	41	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	203	42	of	of	IN
18637	203	43	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	203	44	powers	power	NNS
18637	203	45	to	to	IN
18637	203	46	the	the	DT
18637	203	47	President	President	NNP
18637	203	48	;	;	:
18637	203	49	thirdly	thirdly	RB
18637	203	50	,	,	,
18637	203	51	the	the	DT
18637	203	52	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	203	53	in	in	IN
18637	203	54	many	many	JJ
18637	203	55	instances	instance	NNS
18637	203	56	of	of	IN
18637	203	57	like	like	IN
18637	203	58	powers	power	NNS
18637	203	59	to	to	IN
18637	203	60	so	so	RB
18637	203	61	-	-	HYPH
18637	203	62	called	call	VBN
18637	203	63	independent	independent	JJ
18637	203	64	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	203	65	or	or	CC
18637	203	66	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	203	67	,	,	,
18637	203	68	in	in	IN
18637	203	69	which	which	WDT
18637	203	70	are	be	VBP
18637	203	71	merged	merge	VBN
18637	203	72	in	in	IN
18637	203	73	greater	great	JJR
18637	203	74	or	or	CC
18637	203	75	less	less	JJR
18637	203	76	measure	measure	VB
18637	203	77	the	the	DT
18637	203	78	three	three	CD
18637	203	79	powers	power	NNS
18637	203	80	of	of	IN
18637	203	81	government	government	NN
18637	203	82	of	of	IN
18637	203	83	Montesquieu	Montesquieu	NNP
18637	203	84	's	's	POS
18637	203	85	postulate	postulate	NN
18637	203	86	.	.	.
18637	204	1	Under	under	IN
18637	204	2	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	204	3	the	the	DT
18637	204	4	first	first	JJ
18637	204	5	two	two	CD
18637	204	6	of	of	IN
18637	204	7	these	these	DT
18637	204	8	developments	development	NNS
18637	204	9	were	be	VBD
18637	204	10	brought	bring	VBN
18637	204	11	to	to	IN
18637	204	12	a	a	DT
18637	204	13	pitch	pitch	NN
18637	204	14	not	not	RB
18637	204	15	formerly	formerly	RB
18637	204	16	approximated	approximate	VBN
18637	204	17	,	,	,
18637	204	18	except	except	IN
18637	204	19	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	204	20	during	during	IN
18637	204	21	World	World	NNP
18637	204	22	War	War	NNP
18637	204	23	I.	I.	NNP
18637	205	1	The	the	DT
18637	205	2	truth	truth	NN
18637	205	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	205	4	that	that	IN
18637	205	5	the	the	DT
18637	205	6	practice	practice	NN
18637	205	7	of	of	IN
18637	205	8	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	205	9	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	205	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	205	11	inevitably	inevitably	RB
18637	205	12	and	and	CC
18637	205	13	inextricably	inextricably	RB
18637	205	14	involved	involve	VBN
18637	205	15	with	with	IN
18637	205	16	the	the	DT
18637	205	17	whole	whole	JJ
18637	205	18	idea	idea	NN
18637	205	19	of	of	IN
18637	205	20	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	205	21	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	205	22	in	in	IN
18637	205	23	the	the	DT
18637	205	24	economic	economic	JJ
18637	205	25	field	field	NN
18637	205	26	,	,	,
18637	205	27	where	where	WRB
18637	205	28	the	the	DT
18637	205	29	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	205	30	to	to	TO
18637	205	31	be	be	VB
18637	205	32	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	205	33	are	be	VBP
18637	205	34	of	of	IN
18637	205	35	infinite	infinite	JJ
18637	205	36	complexity	complexity	NN
18637	205	37	and	and	CC
18637	205	38	are	be	VBP
18637	205	39	constantly	constantly	RB
18637	205	40	undergoing	undergo	VBG
18637	205	41	change	change	NN
18637	205	42	.	.	.
18637	206	1	Granted	grant	VBN
18637	206	2	such	such	JJ
18637	206	3	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	206	4	,	,	,
18637	206	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	206	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	206	7	simply	simply	RB
18637	206	8	out	out	IN
18637	206	9	of	of	IN
18637	206	10	the	the	DT
18637	206	11	question	question	NN
18637	206	12	to	to	TO
18637	206	13	demand	demand	VB
18637	206	14	that	that	IN
18637	206	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	206	16	should	should	MD
18637	206	17	attempt	attempt	VB
18637	206	18	to	to	TO
18637	206	19	impose	impose	VB
18637	206	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	206	21	the	the	DT
18637	206	22	shifting	shifting	NN
18637	206	23	and	and	CC
18637	206	24	complex	complex	JJ
18637	206	25	scene	scene	NN
18637	206	26	the	the	DT
18637	206	27	relatively	relatively	RB
18637	206	28	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	206	29	molds	mold	NNS
18637	206	30	of	of	IN
18637	206	31	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	206	32	provision	provision	NN
18637	206	33	,	,	,
18637	206	34	unqualified	unqualifie	VBN
18637	206	35	by	by	IN
18637	206	36	a	a	DT
18637	206	37	large	large	JJ
18637	206	38	degree	degree	NN
18637	206	39	of	of	IN
18637	206	40	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	206	41	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	206	42	.	.	.
18637	207	1	One	one	CD
18637	207	2	of	of	IN
18637	207	3	the	the	DT
18637	207	4	major	major	JJ
18637	207	5	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	207	6	urged	urge	VBD
18637	207	7	for	for	IN
18637	207	8	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	207	9	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	207	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	207	11	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	207	12	by	by	IN
18637	207	13	the	the	DT
18637	207	14	need	need	NN
18637	207	15	for	for	IN
18637	207	16	gearing	gear	VBG
18637	207	17	the	the	DT
18637	207	18	different	different	JJ
18637	207	19	parts	part	NNS
18637	207	20	of	of	IN
18637	207	21	the	the	DT
18637	207	22	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	207	23	process	process	NN
18637	207	24	with	with	IN
18637	207	25	one	one	CD
18637	207	26	another	another	DT
18637	207	27	for	for	IN
18637	207	28	a	a	DT
18637	207	29	planned	plan	VBN
18637	207	30	result	result	NN
18637	207	31	.	.	.
18637	208	1	In	in	IN
18637	208	2	wartime	wartime	NN
18637	208	3	this	this	DT
18637	208	4	need	need	NN
18637	208	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	208	6	freely	freely	RB
18637	208	7	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	208	8	by	by	IN
18637	208	9	all	all	DT
18637	208	10	;	;	:
18637	208	11	but	but	CC
18637	208	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	208	13	need	need	NN
18637	208	14	in	in	IN
18637	208	15	economic	economic	JJ
18637	208	16	crisis	crisis	NN
18637	208	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	208	18	conceivably	conceivably	RB
18637	208	19	even	even	RB
18637	208	20	greater	great	JJR
18637	208	21	,	,	,
18637	208	22	the	the	DT
18637	208	23	results	result	NNS
18637	208	24	sought	seek	VBD
18637	208	25	being	be	VBG
18637	208	26	more	more	RBR
18637	208	27	complex	complex	JJ
18637	208	28	.	.	.
18637	209	1	So	so	RB
18637	209	2	in	in	IN
18637	209	3	the	the	DT
18637	209	4	interest	interest	NN
18637	209	5	both	both	DT
18637	209	6	of	of	IN
18637	209	7	unity	unity	NN
18637	209	8	of	of	IN
18637	209	9	design	design	NN
18637	209	10	and	and	CC
18637	209	11	of	of	IN
18637	209	12	flexibility	flexibility	NN
18637	209	13	of	of	IN
18637	209	14	detail	detail	NN
18637	209	15	,	,	,
18637	209	16	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	209	17	power	power	NN
18637	209	18	today	today	NN
18637	209	19	takes	take	VBZ
18637	209	20	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	209	21	toll	toll	NN
18637	209	22	from	from	IN
18637	209	23	both	both	DT
18637	209	24	ends	end	NNS
18637	209	25	of	of	IN
18637	209	26	the	the	DT
18637	209	27	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	209	28	process	process	NN
18637	209	29	--	--	:
18637	209	30	both	both	DT
18637	209	31	from	from	IN
18637	209	32	the	the	DT
18637	209	33	formulation	formulation	NN
18637	209	34	of	of	IN
18637	209	35	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	209	36	and	and	CC
18637	209	37	from	from	IN
18637	209	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	209	39	administration	administration	NN
18637	209	40	.	.	.
18637	210	1	In	in	IN
18637	210	2	other	other	JJ
18637	210	3	words	word	NNS
18637	210	4	,	,	,
18637	210	5	as	as	IN
18637	210	6	a	a	DT
18637	210	7	barrier	barrier	NN
18637	210	8	capable	capable	JJ
18637	210	9	of	of	IN
18637	210	10	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	210	11	such	such	JJ
18637	210	12	fusion	fusion	NN
18637	210	13	of	of	IN
18637	210	14	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	210	15	and	and	CC
18637	210	16	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	210	17	power	power	NN
18637	210	18	,	,	,
18637	210	19	the	the	DT
18637	210	20	principle	principle	NN
18637	210	21	of	of	IN
18637	210	22	the	the	DT
18637	210	23	Separation	Separation	NNP
18637	210	24	of	of	IN
18637	210	25	Powers	power	NNS
18637	210	26	does	do	VBZ
18637	210	27	not	not	RB
18637	210	28	appear	appear	VB
18637	210	29	to	to	TO
18637	210	30	have	have	VB
18637	210	31	retained	retain	VBN
18637	210	32	much	much	JJ
18637	210	33	of	of	IN
18637	210	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	210	35	original	original	JJ
18637	210	36	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
18637	210	37	;	;	:
18637	210	38	for	for	IN
18637	210	39	on	on	IN
18637	210	40	only	only	RB
18637	210	41	one	one	CD
18637	210	42	occasion[31	occasion[31	NN
18637	210	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	210	44	prior	prior	RB
18637	210	45	to	to	IN
18637	210	46	the	the	DT
18637	210	47	disallowance	disallowance	NN
18637	210	48	,	,	,
18637	210	49	in	in	IN
18637	210	50	Youngstown	Youngstown	NNP
18637	210	51	_	_	NNP
18637	210	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	210	53	_	_	NNP
18637	210	54	Sawyer,[32	Sawyer,[32	NNP
18637	210	55	]	]	-RRB-
18637	210	56	President	President	NNP
18637	210	57	Truman	Truman	NNP
18637	210	58	's	's	POS
18637	210	59	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	210	60	in	in	IN
18637	210	61	April	April	NNP
18637	210	62	1952	1952	CD
18637	210	63	of	of	IN
18637	210	64	the	the	DT
18637	210	65	steel	steel	NN
18637	210	66	industry	industry	NN
18637	210	67	has	have	VBZ
18637	210	68	the	the	DT
18637	210	69	Court	Court	NNP
18637	210	70	been	be	VBN
18637	210	71	constrained	constrain	VBN
18637	210	72	to	to	TO
18637	210	73	condemn	condemn	VB
18637	210	74	,	,	,
18637	210	75	as	as	IN
18637	210	76	in	in	IN
18637	210	77	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	210	78	with	with	IN
18637	210	79	that	that	DT
18637	210	80	principle	principle	NN
18637	210	81	,	,	,
18637	210	82	a	a	DT
18637	210	83	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	210	84	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	210	85	of	of	IN
18637	210	86	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	210	87	power	power	NN
18637	210	88	.	.	.
18637	211	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	211	2	,	,	,
18637	211	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	211	4	application	application	NN
18637	211	5	in	in	IN
18637	211	6	the	the	DT
18637	211	7	field	field	NN
18637	211	8	of	of	IN
18637	211	9	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	211	10	relations	relation	NNS
18637	211	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	211	12	been	be	VBN
18637	211	13	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	211	14	terminated	terminate	VBN
18637	211	15	by	by	IN
18637	211	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	211	17	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	211	18	's	's	POS
18637	211	19	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	211	20	in	in	IN
18637	211	21	the	the	DT
18637	211	22	Curtiss	Curtiss	NNP
18637	211	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	211	24	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	211	25	Case	Case	NNP
18637	211	26	.	.	.
18637	212	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	212	2	33	33	CD
18637	212	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	212	4	The	the	DT
18637	212	5	Youngstown	Youngstown	NNP
18637	212	6	Opinion	Opinion	NNP
18637	212	7	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	212	8	to	to	TO
18637	212	9	rest	rest	VB
18637	212	10	on	on	IN
18637	212	11	the	the	DT
18637	212	12	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	212	13	that	that	IN
18637	212	14	since	since	IN
18637	212	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	212	16	could	could	MD
18637	212	17	have	have	VB
18637	212	18	ordered	order	VBN
18637	212	19	the	the	DT
18637	212	20	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	212	21	,	,	,
18637	212	22	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	212	23	,	,	,
18637	212	24	under	under	IN
18637	212	25	the	the	DT
18637	212	26	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	212	27	and	and	CC
18637	212	28	proper	proper	JJ
18637	212	29	clause	clause	NN
18637	212	30	,	,	,
18637	212	31	the	the	DT
18637	212	32	President	President	NNP
18637	212	33	,	,	,
18637	212	34	in	in	IN
18637	212	35	making	make	VBG
18637	212	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	212	37	on	on	IN
18637	212	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	212	39	own	own	JJ
18637	212	40	,	,	,
18637	212	41	usurped	usurped	JJ
18637	212	42	"	"	``
18637	212	43	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	212	44	power	power	NN
18637	212	45	"	"	''
18637	212	46	and	and	CC
18637	212	47	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	212	48	violated	violate	VBD
18637	212	49	the	the	DT
18637	212	50	principle	principle	NN
18637	212	51	of	of	IN
18637	212	52	the	the	DT
18637	212	53	Separation	Separation	NNP
18637	212	54	of	of	IN
18637	212	55	Powers	power	NNS
18637	212	56	.	.	.
18637	213	1	In	in	IN
18637	213	2	referring	refer	VBG
18637	213	3	to	to	IN
18637	213	4	this	this	DT
18637	213	5	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	213	6	,	,	,
18637	213	7	the	the	DT
18637	213	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	213	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	213	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	213	11	in	in	IN
18637	213	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	213	13	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	213	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	213	15	,	,	,
18637	213	16	for	for	IN
18637	213	17	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	213	18	and	and	CC
18637	213	19	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	213	20	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	213	21	and	and	CC
18637	213	22	Minton	Minton	NNP
18637	213	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	213	24	quoted	quote	VBD
18637	213	25	as	as	IN
18637	213	26	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	213	27	from	from	IN
18637	213	28	a	a	DT
18637	213	29	1915	1915	CD
18637	213	30	brief	brief	NN
18637	213	31	of	of	IN
18637	213	32	the	the	DT
18637	213	33	then	then	RB
18637	213	34	Solicitor	Solicitor	NNP
18637	213	35	General	General	NNP
18637	213	36	of	of	IN
18637	213	37	the	the	DT
18637	213	38	United	United	NNP
18637	213	39	States	States	NNP
18637	213	40	on	on	IN
18637	213	41	this	this	DT
18637	213	42	same	same	JJ
18637	213	43	question	question	NN
18637	213	44	:	:	:
18637	213	45	The	the	DT
18637	213	46	function	function	NN
18637	213	47	of	of	IN
18637	213	48	making	make	VBG
18637	213	49	laws	law	NNS
18637	213	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	213	51	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	213	52	to	to	IN
18637	213	53	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	213	54	,	,	,
18637	213	55	and	and	CC
18637	213	56	the	the	DT
18637	213	57	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	213	58	can	can	MD
18637	213	59	not	not	RB
18637	213	60	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	213	61	that	that	DT
18637	213	62	function	function	NN
18637	213	63	to	to	IN
18637	213	64	any	any	DT
18637	213	65	degree	degree	NN
18637	213	66	.	.	.
18637	214	1	But	but	CC
18637	214	2	this	this	DT
18637	214	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	214	4	not	not	RB
18637	214	5	to	to	TO
18637	214	6	say	say	VB
18637	214	7	that	that	IN
18637	214	8	all	all	DT
18637	214	9	of	of	IN
18637	214	10	the	the	DT
18637	214	11	_	_	NNP
18637	214	12	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	214	13	_	_	NNP
18637	214	14	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	214	15	which	which	WDT
18637	214	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	214	17	might	may	MD
18637	214	18	be	be	VB
18637	214	19	made	make	VBN
18637	214	20	are	be	VBP
18637	214	21	perforce	perforce	NN
18637	214	22	removed	remove	VBN
18637	214	23	from	from	IN
18637	214	24	the	the	DT
18637	214	25	possibility	possibility	NN
18637	214	26	of	of	IN
18637	214	27	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	214	28	influence	influence	NN
18637	214	29	.	.	.
18637	215	1	The	the	DT
18637	215	2	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	215	3	may	may	MD
18637	215	4	act	act	VB
18637	215	5	upon	upon	IN
18637	215	6	things	thing	NNS
18637	215	7	and	and	CC
18637	215	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	215	9	men	man	NNS
18637	215	10	in	in	IN
18637	215	11	many	many	JJ
18637	215	12	relations	relation	NNS
18637	215	13	which	which	WDT
18637	215	14	have	have	VBP
18637	215	15	not	not	RB
18637	215	16	,	,	,
18637	215	17	though	though	IN
18637	215	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	215	19	might	may	MD
18637	215	20	have	have	VB
18637	215	21	,	,	,
18637	215	22	been	be	VBN
18637	215	23	actually	actually	RB
18637	215	24	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	215	25	by	by	IN
18637	215	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	215	27	.	.	.
18637	216	1	In	in	IN
18637	216	2	other	other	JJ
18637	216	3	words	word	NNS
18637	216	4	,	,	,
18637	216	5	just	just	RB
18637	216	6	as	as	IN
18637	216	7	there	there	EX
18637	216	8	are	be	VBP
18637	216	9	fields	field	NNS
18637	216	10	which	which	WDT
18637	216	11	are	be	VBP
18637	216	12	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	216	13	to	to	IN
18637	216	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	216	15	and	and	CC
18637	216	16	fields	field	NNS
18637	216	17	which	which	WDT
18637	216	18	are	be	VBP
18637	216	19	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	216	20	to	to	IN
18637	216	21	the	the	DT
18637	216	22	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	216	23	,	,	,
18637	216	24	so	so	CC
18637	216	25	there	there	EX
18637	216	26	are	be	VBP
18637	216	27	fields	field	NNS
18637	216	28	which	which	WDT
18637	216	29	are	be	VBP
18637	216	30	common	common	JJ
18637	216	31	to	to	IN
18637	216	32	both	both	DT
18637	216	33	,	,	,
18637	216	34	in	in	IN
18637	216	35	the	the	DT
18637	216	36	sense	sense	NN
18637	216	37	that	that	IN
18637	216	38	the	the	DT
18637	216	39	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	216	40	may	may	MD
18637	216	41	move	move	VB
18637	216	42	within	within	IN
18637	216	43	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	216	44	until	until	IN
18637	216	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	216	46	shall	shall	MD
18637	216	47	have	have	VB
18637	216	48	been	be	VBN
18637	216	49	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	216	50	by	by	IN
18637	216	51	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	216	52	action	action	NN
18637	216	53	.	.	.
18637	217	1	These	these	DT
18637	217	2	are	be	VBP
18637	217	3	not	not	RB
18637	217	4	the	the	DT
18637	217	5	fields	field	NNS
18637	217	6	of	of	IN
18637	217	7	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	217	8	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	217	9	,	,	,
18637	217	10	but	but	CC
18637	217	11	fields	field	NNS
18637	217	12	within	within	IN
18637	217	13	which	which	WDT
18637	217	14	the	the	DT
18637	217	15	lawmaking	lawmaking	NN
18637	217	16	power	power	NN
18637	217	17	may	may	MD
18637	217	18	enter	enter	VB
18637	217	19	and	and	CC
18637	217	20	dominate	dominate	VB
18637	217	21	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	217	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	217	23	chooses	choose	VBZ
18637	217	24	.	.	.
18637	218	1	This	this	DT
18637	218	2	situation	situation	NN
18637	218	3	results	result	VBZ
18637	218	4	from	from	IN
18637	218	5	the	the	DT
18637	218	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	218	7	that	that	IN
18637	218	8	the	the	DT
18637	218	9	President	President	NNP
18637	218	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	218	11	the	the	DT
18637	218	12	active	active	JJ
18637	218	13	agent	agent	NN
18637	218	14	,	,	,
18637	218	15	not	not	RB
18637	218	16	of	of	IN
18637	218	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	218	18	,	,	,
18637	218	19	but	but	CC
18637	218	20	of	of	IN
18637	218	21	the	the	DT
18637	218	22	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	218	23	.	.	.
18637	219	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	219	2	34	34	CD
18637	219	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	219	4	Or	or	CC
18637	219	5	,	,	,
18637	219	6	in	in	IN
18637	219	7	more	more	JJR
18637	219	8	general	general	JJ
18637	219	9	terms	term	NNS
18637	219	10	,	,	,
18637	219	11	the	the	DT
18637	219	12	fact	fact	NN
18637	219	13	that	that	IN
18637	219	14	one	one	CD
18637	219	15	of	of	IN
18637	219	16	the	the	DT
18637	219	17	three	three	CD
18637	219	18	departments	department	NNS
18637	219	19	may	may	MD
18637	219	20	apply	apply	VB
18637	219	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	219	22	distinctive	distinctive	JJ
18637	219	23	techniques	technique	NNS
18637	219	24	to	to	IN
18637	219	25	a	a	DT
18637	219	26	certain	certain	JJ
18637	219	27	subject	subject	JJ
18637	219	28	matter	matter	NN
18637	219	29	sheds	shed	VBZ
18637	219	30	little	little	JJ
18637	219	31	or	or	CC
18637	219	32	no	no	DT
18637	219	33	light	light	NN
18637	219	34	on	on	IN
18637	219	35	the	the	DT
18637	219	36	question	question	NN
18637	219	37	whether	whether	IN
18637	219	38	one	one	CD
18637	219	39	of	of	IN
18637	219	40	the	the	DT
18637	219	41	other	other	JJ
18637	219	42	departments	department	NNS
18637	219	43	may	may	MD
18637	219	44	deal	deal	VB
18637	219	45	with	with	IN
18637	219	46	the	the	DT
18637	219	47	same	same	JJ
18637	219	48	subject	subject	JJ
18637	219	49	matter	matter	NN
18637	219	50	according	accord	VBG
18637	219	51	to	to	IN
18637	219	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	219	53	distinctive	distinctive	JJ
18637	219	54	techniques	technique	NNS
18637	219	55	.	.	.
18637	220	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	220	2	,	,	,
18637	220	3	were	be	VBD
18637	220	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	220	5	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	220	6	,	,	,
18637	220	7	the	the	DT
18637	220	8	action	action	NN
18637	220	9	of	of	IN
18637	220	10	the	the	DT
18637	220	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	220	12	in	in	IN
18637	220	13	disallowing	disallow	VBG
18637	220	14	President	President	NNP
18637	220	15	Truman	Truman	NNP
18637	220	16	's	's	POS
18637	220	17	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	220	18	order	order	NN
18637	220	19	would	would	MD
18637	220	20	have	have	VB
18637	220	21	been	be	VBN
18637	220	22	of	of	IN
18637	220	23	very	very	RB
18637	220	24	questionable	questionable	JJ
18637	220	25	validity	validity	NN
18637	220	26	,	,	,
18637	220	27	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	220	28	as	as	IN
18637	220	29	the	the	DT
18637	220	30	President	President	NNP
18637	220	31	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	220	32	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	220	33	that	that	IN
18637	220	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	220	35	could	could	MD
18637	220	36	do	do	VB
18637	220	37	so	so	RB
18637	220	38	.	.	.
18637	221	1	The	the	DT
18637	221	2	conception	conception	NN
18637	221	3	of	of	IN
18637	221	4	the	the	DT
18637	221	5	Separation	Separation	NNP
18637	221	6	of	of	IN
18637	221	7	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	221	8	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	221	9	advanced	advance	VBN
18637	221	10	in	in	IN
18637	221	11	Youngstown	Youngstown	NNP
18637	221	12	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	221	13	to	to	TO
18637	221	14	have	have	VB
18637	221	15	been	be	VBN
18637	221	16	an	an	DT
18637	221	17	ad	ad	FW
18637	221	18	hoc	hoc	FW
18637	221	19	discovery	discovery	NN
18637	221	20	for	for	IN
18637	221	21	the	the	DT
18637	221	22	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	221	23	of	of	IN
18637	221	24	disposing	dispose	VBG
18637	221	25	of	of	IN
18637	221	26	that	that	DT
18637	221	27	particular	particular	JJ
18637	221	28	case	case	NN
18637	221	29	.	.	.
18637	222	1	To	to	TO
18637	222	2	sum	sum	VB
18637	222	3	up	up	RP
18637	222	4	the	the	DT
18637	222	5	argument	argument	NN
18637	222	6	to	to	IN
18637	222	7	this	this	DT
18637	222	8	point	point	NN
18637	222	9	:	:	:
18637	222	10	War	war	NN
18637	222	11	,	,	,
18637	222	12	the	the	DT
18637	222	13	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	222	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	222	15	Truman	Truman	NNP
18637	222	16	programs	program	NNS
18637	222	17	,	,	,
18637	222	18	and	and	CC
18637	222	19	the	the	DT
18637	222	20	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	222	21	of	of	IN
18637	222	22	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	222	23	Law	Law	NNP
18637	222	24	on	on	IN
18637	222	25	which	which	WDT
18637	222	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	222	27	rest	rest	VBP
18637	222	28	,	,	,
18637	222	29	and	and	CC
18637	222	30	the	the	DT
18637	222	31	conception	conception	NN
18637	222	32	of	of	IN
18637	222	33	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	222	34	function	function	NN
18637	222	35	which	which	WDT
18637	222	36	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	222	37	incorporate	incorporate	VBP
18637	222	38	,	,	,
18637	222	39	have	have	VBP
18637	222	40	all	all	DT
18637	222	41	tremendously	tremendously	RB
18637	222	42	strengthened	strengthen	VBN
18637	222	43	forces	force	NNS
18637	222	44	which	which	WDT
18637	222	45	even	even	RB
18637	222	46	earlier	early	RBR
18637	222	47	were	be	VBD
18637	222	48	making	make	VBG
18637	222	49	,	,	,
18637	222	50	slowly	slowly	RB
18637	222	51	,	,	,
18637	222	52	to	to	TO
18637	222	53	be	be	VB
18637	222	54	sure	sure	JJ
18637	222	55	,	,	,
18637	222	56	but	but	CC
18637	222	57	with	with	IN
18637	222	58	"	"	``
18637	222	59	the	the	DT
18637	222	60	inevitability	inevitability	NN
18637	222	61	of	of	IN
18637	222	62	gradualness	gradualness	NN
18637	222	63	,	,	,
18637	222	64	"	"	``
18637	222	65	for	for	IN
18637	222	66	the	the	DT
18637	222	67	concentration	concentration	NN
18637	222	68	of	of	IN
18637	222	69	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	222	70	power	power	NN
18637	222	71	in	in	IN
18637	222	72	the	the	DT
18637	222	73	United	United	NNP
18637	222	74	States	States	NNP
18637	222	75	,	,	,
18637	222	76	first	first	RB
18637	222	77	in	in	IN
18637	222	78	the	the	DT
18637	222	79	hands	hand	NNS
18637	222	80	of	of	IN
18637	222	81	the	the	DT
18637	222	82	National	National	NNP
18637	222	83	Government	Government	NNP
18637	222	84	;	;	:
18637	222	85	and	and	CC
18637	222	86	,	,	,
18637	222	87	secondly	secondly	RB
18637	222	88	,	,	,
18637	222	89	in	in	IN
18637	222	90	the	the	DT
18637	222	91	hands	hand	NNS
18637	222	92	of	of	IN
18637	222	93	the	the	DT
18637	222	94	national	national	NNP
18637	222	95	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	222	96	.	.	.
18637	223	1	In	in	IN
18637	223	2	the	the	DT
18637	223	3	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	223	4	Law	Law	NNP
18637	223	5	which	which	WDT
18637	223	6	the	the	DT
18637	223	7	validation	validation	NN
18637	223	8	of	of	IN
18637	223	9	the	the	DT
18637	223	10	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	223	11	program	program	NN
18637	223	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	223	13	brought	bring	VBN
18637	223	14	into	into	IN
18637	223	15	full	full	JJ
18637	223	16	being	being	NN
18637	223	17	,	,	,
18637	223	18	the	the	DT
18637	223	19	two	two	CD
18637	223	20	main	main	JJ
18637	223	21	structural	structural	JJ
18637	223	22	elements	element	NNS
18637	223	23	of	of	IN
18637	223	24	government	government	NN
18637	223	25	in	in	IN
18637	223	26	the	the	DT
18637	223	27	United	United	NNP
18637	223	28	States	States	NNP
18637	223	29	in	in	IN
18637	223	30	the	the	DT
18637	223	31	past	past	NN
18637	223	32	,	,	,
18637	223	33	the	the	DT
18637	223	34	principle	principle	NN
18637	223	35	of	of	IN
18637	223	36	Dual	Dual	NNP
18637	223	37	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	223	38	and	and	CC
18637	223	39	the	the	DT
18637	223	40	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	223	41	of	of	IN
18637	223	42	the	the	DT
18637	223	43	Separation	Separation	NNP
18637	223	44	of	of	IN
18637	223	45	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	223	46	,	,	,
18637	223	47	have	have	VBP
18637	223	48	undergone	undergo	VBN
18637	223	49	a	a	DT
18637	223	50	radical	radical	JJ
18637	223	51	and	and	CC
18637	223	52	enfeebling	enfeeble	VBG
18637	223	53	transformation	transformation	NN
18637	223	54	which	which	WDT
18637	223	55	war	war	NN
18637	223	56	has	have	VBZ
18637	223	57	,	,	,
18637	223	58	naturally	naturally	RB
18637	223	59	,	,	,
18637	223	60	carried	carry	VBN
18637	223	61	still	still	RB
18637	223	62	further	further	RB
18637	223	63	.	.	.
18637	224	1	III	III	NNP
18637	224	2	A	a	DT
18637	224	3	Government	Government	NNP
18637	224	4	of	of	IN
18637	224	5	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	224	6	and	and	CC
18637	224	7	Not	not	RB
18637	224	8	of	of	IN
18637	224	9	Men	men	NN
18637	224	10	The	the	DT
18637	224	11	earliest	early	JJS
18637	224	12	repositories	repository	NNS
18637	224	13	of	of	IN
18637	224	14	executive	executive	JJ
18637	224	15	power	power	NN
18637	224	16	in	in	IN
18637	224	17	this	this	DT
18637	224	18	country	country	NN
18637	224	19	were	be	VBD
18637	224	20	the	the	DT
18637	224	21	provincial	provincial	JJ
18637	224	22	governors	governor	NNS
18637	224	23	.	.	.
18637	225	1	Being	be	VBG
18637	225	2	the	the	DT
18637	225	3	point	point	NN
18637	225	4	of	of	IN
18637	225	5	tangency	tangency	NN
18637	225	6	and	and	CC
18637	225	7	hence	hence	RB
18637	225	8	of	of	IN
18637	225	9	irritation	irritation	NN
18637	225	10	between	between	IN
18637	225	11	imperial	imperial	JJ
18637	225	12	policy	policy	NN
18637	225	13	and	and	CC
18637	225	14	colonial	colonial	JJ
18637	225	15	particularism	particularism	NN
18637	225	16	,	,	,
18637	225	17	these	these	DT
18637	225	18	officers	officer	NNS
18637	225	19	incurred	incur	VBD
18637	225	20	a	a	DT
18637	225	21	widespread	widespread	JJ
18637	225	22	unpopularity	unpopularity	NN
18637	225	23	that	that	WDT
18637	225	24	was	be	VBD
18637	225	25	easily	easily	RB
18637	225	26	generalized	generalize	VBN
18637	225	27	into	into	IN
18637	225	28	distrust	distrust	NN
18637	225	29	of	of	IN
18637	225	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	225	31	office	office	NN
18637	225	32	.	.	.
18637	226	1	So	so	RB
18637	226	2	when	when	WRB
18637	226	3	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	226	4	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	226	5	in	in	IN
18637	226	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	226	7	_	_	NNP
18637	226	8	Summary	Summary	NNP
18637	226	9	View	View	NNP
18637	226	10	_	_	NNP
18637	226	11	,	,	,
18637	226	12	in	in	IN
18637	226	13	1774	1774	CD
18637	226	14	,	,	,
18637	226	15	that	that	IN
18637	226	16	the	the	DT
18637	226	17	King	King	NNP
18637	226	18	"	"	``
18637	226	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	226	20	no	no	DT
18637	226	21	more	more	JJR
18637	226	22	than	than	IN
18637	226	23	the	the	DT
18637	226	24	chief	chief	JJ
18637	226	25	officer	officer	NN
18637	226	26	of	of	IN
18637	226	27	the	the	DT
18637	226	28	people	people	NNS
18637	226	29	,	,	,
18637	226	30	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	226	31	by	by	IN
18637	226	32	the	the	DT
18637	226	33	laws	law	NNS
18637	226	34	and	and	CC
18637	226	35	circumscribed	circumscribe	VBN
18637	226	36	with	with	IN
18637	226	37	definite	definite	JJ
18637	226	38	powers	power	NNS
18637	226	39	,	,	,
18637	226	40	to	to	TO
18637	226	41	assist	assist	VB
18637	226	42	in	in	IN
18637	226	43	working	work	VBG
18637	226	44	the	the	DT
18637	226	45	great	great	JJ
18637	226	46	machine	machine	NN
18637	226	47	of	of	IN
18637	226	48	government,"[35	government,"[35	CD
18637	226	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	226	50	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	226	51	voiced	voice	VBD
18637	226	52	a	a	DT
18637	226	53	theory	theory	NN
18637	226	54	of	of	IN
18637	226	55	executive	executive	JJ
18637	226	56	power	power	NN
18637	226	57	which	which	WDT
18637	226	58	,	,	,
18637	226	59	impudently	impudently	RB
18637	226	60	as	as	IN
18637	226	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	226	62	flouted	flout	VBD
18637	226	63	historical	historical	JJ
18637	226	64	fact	fact	NN
18637	226	65	,	,	,
18637	226	66	had	have	VBD
18637	226	67	the	the	DT
18637	226	68	support	support	NN
18637	226	69	of	of	IN
18637	226	70	the	the	DT
18637	226	71	draftsmen	draftsman	NNS
18637	226	72	of	of	IN
18637	226	73	the	the	DT
18637	226	74	first	first	JJ
18637	226	75	American	american	JJ
18637	226	76	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	226	77	.	.	.
18637	227	1	In	in	IN
18637	227	2	most	most	JJS
18637	227	3	of	of	IN
18637	227	4	these	these	DT
18637	227	5	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	227	6	the	the	DT
18637	227	7	governors	governor	NNS
18637	227	8	were	be	VBD
18637	227	9	elected	elect	VBN
18637	227	10	annually	annually	RB
18637	227	11	by	by	IN
18637	227	12	the	the	DT
18637	227	13	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	227	14	assemblies	assembly	NNS
18637	227	15	,	,	,
18637	227	16	were	be	VBD
18637	227	17	stripped	strip	VBN
18637	227	18	of	of	IN
18637	227	19	every	every	DT
18637	227	20	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	227	21	of	of	IN
18637	227	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	227	23	predecessors	predecessor	NNS
18637	227	24	in	in	IN
18637	227	25	relation	relation	NN
18637	227	26	to	to	IN
18637	227	27	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	227	28	,	,	,
18637	227	29	and	and	CC
18637	227	30	were	be	VBD
18637	227	31	forced	force	VBN
18637	227	32	to	to	TO
18637	227	33	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	227	34	the	the	DT
18637	227	35	powers	power	NNS
18637	227	36	left	leave	VBD
18637	227	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	227	38	subject	subject	JJ
18637	227	39	to	to	IN
18637	227	40	the	the	DT
18637	227	41	advice	advice	NN
18637	227	42	of	of	IN
18637	227	43	a	a	DT
18637	227	44	council	council	NN
18637	227	45	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	227	46	also	also	RB
18637	227	47	by	by	IN
18637	227	48	the	the	DT
18637	227	49	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	227	50	,	,	,
18637	227	51	and	and	CC
18637	227	52	from	from	IN
18637	227	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	227	54	own	own	JJ
18637	227	55	members	member	NNS
18637	227	56	if	if	IN
18637	227	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	227	58	so	so	RB
18637	227	59	desired	desire	VBD
18637	227	60	.	.	.
18637	228	1	Finally	finally	RB
18637	228	2	,	,	,
18637	228	3	out	out	IN
18637	228	4	of	of	IN
18637	228	5	abundant	abundant	JJ
18637	228	6	caution	caution	NN
18637	228	7	the	the	DT
18637	228	8	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	228	9	of	of	IN
18637	228	10	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	228	11	decreed	decree	VBD
18637	228	12	that	that	IN
18637	228	13	executive	executive	JJ
18637	228	14	powers	power	NNS
18637	228	15	were	be	VBD
18637	228	16	to	to	TO
18637	228	17	be	be	VB
18637	228	18	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	228	19	"	"	''
18637	228	20	according	accord	VBG
18637	228	21	to	to	IN
18637	228	22	the	the	DT
18637	228	23	laws	law	NNS
18637	228	24	of	of	IN
18637	228	25	"	"	``
18637	228	26	the	the	DT
18637	228	27	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
18637	228	28	,	,	,
18637	228	29	and	and	CC
18637	228	30	that	that	IN
18637	228	31	no	no	DT
18637	228	32	power	power	NN
18637	228	33	or	or	CC
18637	228	34	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	228	35	was	be	VBD
18637	228	36	ever	ever	RB
18637	228	37	to	to	TO
18637	228	38	be	be	VB
18637	228	39	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	228	40	"	"	''
18637	228	41	by	by	IN
18637	228	42	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	228	43	of	of	IN
18637	228	44	any	any	DT
18637	228	45	law	law	NN
18637	228	46	,	,	,
18637	228	47	statute	statute	NN
18637	228	48	or	or	CC
18637	228	49	custom	custom	NN
18637	228	50	of	of	IN
18637	228	51	England	England	NNP
18637	228	52	.	.	.
18637	228	53	"	"	''
18637	229	1	"	"	``
18637	229	2	Executive	executive	JJ
18637	229	3	power	power	NN
18637	229	4	"	"	''
18637	229	5	,	,	,
18637	229	6	in	in	IN
18637	229	7	short	short	JJ
18637	229	8	,	,	,
18637	229	9	was	be	VBD
18637	229	10	left	leave	VBN
18637	229	11	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	229	12	to	to	IN
18637	229	13	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	229	14	definition	definition	NN
18637	229	15	and	and	CC
18637	229	16	was	be	VBD
18637	229	17	cut	cut	VBN
18637	229	18	off	off	RP
18637	229	19	from	from	IN
18637	229	20	all	all	DT
18637	229	21	resources	resource	NNS
18637	229	22	of	of	IN
18637	229	23	the	the	DT
18637	229	24	common	common	JJ
18637	229	25	law	law	NN
18637	229	26	and	and	CC
18637	229	27	the	the	DT
18637	229	28	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	229	29	of	of	IN
18637	229	30	English	english	JJ
18637	229	31	monarchy	monarchy	NN
18637	229	32	.	.	.
18637	230	1	Fortunately	fortunately	RB
18637	230	2	or	or	CC
18637	230	3	unfortunately	unfortunately	RB
18637	230	4	,	,	,
18637	230	5	the	the	DT
18637	230	6	earlier	early	JJR
18637	230	7	tradition	tradition	NN
18637	230	8	of	of	IN
18637	230	9	executive	executive	JJ
18637	230	10	power	power	NN
18637	230	11	was	be	VBD
18637	230	12	not	not	RB
18637	230	13	to	to	TO
18637	230	14	be	be	VB
18637	230	15	exorcised	exorcise	VBN
18637	230	16	so	so	RB
18637	230	17	readily	readily	RB
18637	230	18	.	.	.
18637	231	1	Historically	historically	RB
18637	231	2	,	,	,
18637	231	3	this	this	DT
18637	231	4	tradition	tradition	NN
18637	231	5	traces	trace	VBZ
18637	231	6	to	to	IN
18637	231	7	the	the	DT
18637	231	8	fact	fact	NN
18637	231	9	that	that	IN
18637	231	10	the	the	DT
18637	231	11	royal	royal	NN
18637	231	12	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	231	13	was	be	VBD
18637	231	14	residual	residual	JJ
18637	231	15	power	power	NN
18637	231	16	,	,	,
18637	231	17	that	that	IN
18637	231	18	the	the	DT
18637	231	19	monarch	monarch	NN
18637	231	20	was	be	VBD
18637	231	21	first	first	RB
18637	231	22	on	on	IN
18637	231	23	the	the	DT
18637	231	24	ground	ground	NN
18637	231	25	,	,	,
18637	231	26	that	that	IN
18637	231	27	the	the	DT
18637	231	28	other	other	JJ
18637	231	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	231	30	of	of	IN
18637	231	31	government	government	NN
18637	231	32	were	be	VBD
18637	231	33	off	off	IN
18637	231	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	231	35	shoots	shoot	NNS
18637	231	36	from	from	IN
18637	231	37	monarchical	monarchical	JJ
18637	231	38	power	power	NN
18637	231	39	.	.	.
18637	232	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	232	2	,	,	,
18637	232	3	when	when	WRB
18637	232	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	232	5	forefathers	forefather	NNS
18637	232	6	turned	turn	VBD
18637	232	7	to	to	IN
18637	232	8	Roman	roman	JJ
18637	232	9	history	history	NN
18637	232	10	,	,	,
18637	232	11	as	as	IN
18637	232	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	232	13	intermittently	intermittently	RB
18637	232	14	did	do	VBD
18637	232	15	,	,	,
18637	232	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	232	17	was	be	VBD
18637	232	18	borne	bear	VBN
18637	232	19	in	in	IN
18637	232	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	232	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	232	22	that	that	DT
18637	232	23	dictatorship	dictatorship	NN
18637	232	24	had	have	VBD
18637	232	25	at	at	IN
18637	232	26	one	one	CD
18637	232	27	time	time	NN
18637	232	28	been	be	VBN
18637	232	29	a	a	DT
18637	232	30	normal	normal	JJ
18637	232	31	feature	feature	NN
18637	232	32	of	of	IN
18637	232	33	republican	republican	JJ
18637	232	34	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	232	35	.	.	.
18637	233	1	And	and	CC
18637	233	2	what	what	WDT
18637	233	3	history	history	NN
18637	233	4	consecrated	consecrate	VBD
18637	233	5	,	,	,
18637	233	6	doctrine	doctrine	VB
18637	233	7	illumined	illumined	JJ
18637	233	8	.	.	.
18637	234	1	In	in	IN
18637	234	2	Chapter	chapter	NN
18637	234	3	XI	XI	NNP
18637	234	4	of	of	IN
18637	234	5	John	John	NNP
18637	234	6	Locke	Locke	NNP
18637	234	7	's	's	POS
18637	234	8	Second	Second	NNP
18637	234	9	Treatise	Treatise	NNP
18637	234	10	on	on	IN
18637	234	11	Civil	civil	JJ
18637	234	12	Government	Government	NNP
18637	234	13	,	,	,
18637	234	14	from	from	IN
18637	234	15	the	the	DT
18637	234	16	pages	page	NNS
18637	234	17	of	of	IN
18637	234	18	which	which	WDT
18637	234	19	much	much	JJ
18637	234	20	of	of	IN
18637	234	21	the	the	DT
18637	234	22	opening	open	VBG
18637	234	23	paragraphs	paragraph	NNS
18637	234	24	of	of	IN
18637	234	25	the	the	DT
18637	234	26	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
18637	234	27	of	of	IN
18637	234	28	Independence	Independence	NNP
18637	234	29	comes	come	VBZ
18637	234	30	,	,	,
18637	234	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	234	32	read	read	VBP
18637	234	33	:	:	:
18637	234	34	"	"	``
18637	234	35	Absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	234	36	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	234	37	power	power	NN
18637	234	38	,	,	,
18637	234	39	or	or	CC
18637	234	40	governing	govern	VBG
18637	234	41	without	without	IN
18637	234	42	settled	settle	VBN
18637	234	43	standing	stand	VBG
18637	234	44	laws	law	NNS
18637	234	45	,	,	,
18637	234	46	can	can	MD
18637	234	47	neither	neither	DT
18637	234	48	of	of	IN
18637	234	49	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	234	50	consist	consist	VBP
18637	234	51	with	with	IN
18637	234	52	the	the	DT
18637	234	53	ends	end	NNS
18637	234	54	of	of	IN
18637	234	55	society	society	NN
18637	234	56	and	and	CC
18637	234	57	government	government	NN
18637	234	58	"	"	''
18637	234	59	.	.	.
18637	235	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	235	2	36	36	CD
18637	235	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	235	4	In	in	IN
18637	235	5	Chapter	Chapter	NNP
18637	235	6	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	235	7	of	of	IN
18637	235	8	the	the	DT
18637	235	9	same	same	JJ
18637	235	10	work	work	NN
18637	235	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	235	12	are	be	VBP
18637	235	13	told	tell	VBN
18637	235	14	,	,	,
18637	235	15	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	235	16	,	,	,
18637	235	17	that	that	IN
18637	235	18	"	"	``
18637	235	19	prerogative	prerogative	JJ
18637	235	20	"	"	''
18637	235	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	235	22	the	the	DT
18637	235	23	power	power	NN
18637	235	24	"	"	''
18637	235	25	to	to	TO
18637	235	26	act	act	VB
18637	235	27	according	accord	VBG
18637	235	28	to	to	IN
18637	235	29	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	235	30	without	without	IN
18637	235	31	the	the	DT
18637	235	32	prescription	prescription	NN
18637	235	33	of	of	IN
18637	235	34	the	the	DT
18637	235	35	law	law	NN
18637	235	36	and	and	CC
18637	235	37	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	235	38	against	against	IN
18637	235	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	235	40	"	"	''
18637	235	41	;	;	:
18637	235	42	and	and	CC
18637	235	43	that	that	IN
18637	235	44	this	this	DT
18637	235	45	power	power	NN
18637	235	46	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	235	47	to	to	IN
18637	235	48	the	the	DT
18637	235	49	executive	executive	NN
18637	235	50	,	,	,
18637	235	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	235	52	being	be	VBG
18637	235	53	"	"	``
18637	235	54	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	235	55	to	to	TO
18637	235	56	foresee	foresee	VB
18637	235	57	and	and	CC
18637	235	58	so	so	RB
18637	235	59	by	by	IN
18637	235	60	laws	law	NNS
18637	235	61	to	to	TO
18637	235	62	provide	provide	VB
18637	235	63	for	for	IN
18637	235	64	all	all	DT
18637	235	65	accidents	accident	NNS
18637	235	66	and	and	CC
18637	235	67	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	235	68	that	that	WDT
18637	235	69	may	may	MD
18637	235	70	concern	concern	VB
18637	235	71	the	the	DT
18637	235	72	public	public	NN
18637	235	73	,	,	,
18637	235	74	or	or	CC
18637	235	75	make	make	VB
18637	235	76	such	such	JJ
18637	235	77	laws	law	NNS
18637	235	78	as	as	IN
18637	235	79	will	will	MD
18637	235	80	do	do	VB
18637	235	81	no	no	DT
18637	235	82	harm	harm	NN
18637	235	83	if	if	IN
18637	235	84	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	235	85	are	be	VBP
18637	235	86	executed	execute	VBN
18637	235	87	with	with	IN
18637	235	88	inflexible	inflexible	JJ
18637	235	89	rigor	rigor	NN
18637	235	90	.	.	.
18637	235	91	"	"	''
18637	236	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	236	2	,	,	,
18637	236	3	continues	continue	VBZ
18637	236	4	Locke	Locke	NNP
18637	236	5	,	,	,
18637	236	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	236	7	this	this	DT
18637	236	8	"	"	``
18637	236	9	undoubted	undoubted	JJ
18637	236	10	prerogative	prerogative	JJ
18637	236	11	"	"	''
18637	236	12	ever	ever	RB
18637	236	13	questioned	question	VBN
18637	236	14	,	,	,
18637	236	15	"	"	''
18637	236	16	for	for	IN
18637	236	17	the	the	DT
18637	236	18	people	people	NNS
18637	236	19	are	be	VBP
18637	236	20	very	very	RB
18637	236	21	seldom	seldom	JJ
18637	236	22	or	or	CC
18637	236	23	never	never	RB
18637	236	24	scrupulous	scrupulous	JJ
18637	236	25	or	or	CC
18637	236	26	nice	nice	JJ
18637	236	27	in	in	IN
18637	236	28	the	the	DT
18637	236	29	point	point	NN
18637	236	30	"	"	''
18637	236	31	whilst	whilst	IN
18637	236	32	the	the	DT
18637	236	33	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	236	34	"	"	``
18637	236	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	236	36	in	in	IN
18637	236	37	any	any	DT
18637	236	38	tolerable	tolerable	JJ
18637	236	39	degree	degree	NN
18637	236	40	employed	employ	VBN
18637	236	41	for	for	IN
18637	236	42	the	the	DT
18637	236	43	use	use	NN
18637	236	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	236	45	was	be	VBD
18637	236	46	meant	mean	VBN
18637	236	47	,	,	,
18637	236	48	that	that	RB
18637	236	49	is	is	RB
18637	236	50	,	,	,
18637	236	51	for	for	IN
18637	236	52	the	the	DT
18637	236	53	good	good	NN
18637	236	54	of	of	IN
18637	236	55	the	the	DT
18637	236	56	people	people	NNS
18637	236	57	.	.	.
18637	237	1	"	"	``
18637	237	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	237	3	37	37	CD
18637	237	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	237	5	A	a	DT
18637	237	6	parallel	parallel	JJ
18637	237	7	ambivalence	ambivalence	NN
18637	237	8	pervades	pervade	NNS
18637	237	9	both	both	DT
18637	237	10	practice	practice	NN
18637	237	11	and	and	CC
18637	237	12	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	237	13	under	under	IN
18637	237	14	the	the	DT
18637	237	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	237	16	from	from	IN
18637	237	17	the	the	DT
18637	237	18	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	237	19	.	.	.
18637	238	1	The	the	DT
18637	238	2	opening	opening	NN
18637	238	3	clause	clause	NN
18637	238	4	of	of	IN
18637	238	5	Article	Article	NNP
18637	238	6	II	ii	CD
18637	238	7	of	of	IN
18637	238	8	the	the	DT
18637	238	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	238	10	reads	read	VBZ
18637	238	11	:	:	:
18637	238	12	"	"	``
18637	238	13	The	the	DT
18637	238	14	executive	executive	JJ
18637	238	15	power	power	NN
18637	238	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	238	17	be	be	VB
18637	238	18	vested	vest	VBN
18637	238	19	in	in	IN
18637	238	20	a	a	DT
18637	238	21	President	President	NNP
18637	238	22	of	of	IN
18637	238	23	the	the	DT
18637	238	24	United	United	NNP
18637	238	25	States	States	NNP
18637	238	26	of	of	IN
18637	238	27	America	America	NNP
18637	238	28	"	"	''
18637	238	29	.	.	.
18637	239	1	The	the	DT
18637	239	2	primary	primary	JJ
18637	239	3	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	239	4	of	of	IN
18637	239	5	this	this	DT
18637	239	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	239	7	,	,	,
18637	239	8	which	which	WDT
18637	239	9	made	make	VBD
18637	239	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	239	11	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	239	12	late	late	RB
18637	239	13	in	in	IN
18637	239	14	the	the	DT
18637	239	15	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	239	16	and	and	CC
18637	239	17	was	be	VBD
18637	239	18	never	never	RB
18637	239	19	separately	separately	RB
18637	239	20	passed	pass	VBN
18637	239	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	239	22	by	by	IN
18637	239	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	239	24	,	,	,
18637	239	25	was	be	VBD
18637	239	26	to	to	TO
18637	239	27	settle	settle	VB
18637	239	28	the	the	DT
18637	239	29	question	question	NN
18637	239	30	whether	whether	IN
18637	239	31	the	the	DT
18637	239	32	executive	executive	JJ
18637	239	33	branch	branch	NN
18637	239	34	should	should	MD
18637	239	35	be	be	VB
18637	239	36	plural	plural	JJ
18637	239	37	or	or	CC
18637	239	38	single	single	JJ
18637	239	39	;	;	:
18637	239	40	a	a	DT
18637	239	41	secondary	secondary	JJ
18637	239	42	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	239	43	was	be	VBD
18637	239	44	to	to	TO
18637	239	45	give	give	VB
18637	239	46	the	the	DT
18637	239	47	President	President	NNP
18637	239	48	a	a	DT
18637	239	49	title	title	NN
18637	239	50	.	.	.
18637	240	1	There	there	EX
18637	240	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	240	3	no	no	DT
18637	240	4	hint	hint	NN
18637	240	5	in	in	IN
18637	240	6	the	the	DT
18637	240	7	published	publish	VBN
18637	240	8	records	record	NNS
18637	240	9	that	that	IN
18637	240	10	the	the	DT
18637	240	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	240	12	was	be	VBD
18637	240	13	supposed	suppose	VBN
18637	240	14	to	to	TO
18637	240	15	add	add	VB
18637	240	16	cubits	cubit	NNS
18637	240	17	to	to	IN
18637	240	18	the	the	DT
18637	240	19	succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	240	20	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	240	21	which	which	WDT
18637	240	22	recite	recite	VBP
18637	240	23	the	the	DT
18637	240	24	President	President	NNP
18637	240	25	's	's	POS
18637	240	26	powers	power	NNS
18637	240	27	and	and	CC
18637	240	28	duties	duty	NNS
18637	240	29	in	in	IN
18637	240	30	detail	detail	NN
18637	240	31	.	.	.
18637	241	1	For	for	IN
18637	241	2	all	all	PDT
18637	241	3	that	that	DT
18637	241	4	,	,	,
18637	241	5	the	the	DT
18637	241	6	"	"	``
18637	241	7	executive	executive	JJ
18637	241	8	power	power	NN
18637	241	9	"	"	''
18637	241	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	241	11	was	be	VBD
18637	241	12	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	241	13	as	as	IN
18637	241	14	a	a	DT
18637	241	15	grant	grant	NN
18637	241	16	of	of	IN
18637	241	17	power	power	NN
18637	241	18	in	in	IN
18637	241	19	the	the	DT
18637	241	20	first	first	JJ
18637	241	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	241	22	to	to	TO
18637	241	23	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	241	24	under	under	IN
18637	241	25	the	the	DT
18637	241	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	241	27	,	,	,
18637	241	28	and	and	CC
18637	241	29	outside	outside	IN
18637	241	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	241	31	in	in	IN
18637	241	32	1793	1793	CD
18637	241	33	.	.	.
18637	242	1	On	on	IN
18637	242	2	the	the	DT
18637	242	3	former	former	JJ
18637	242	4	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	242	5	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	242	6	and	and	CC
18637	242	7	others	other	NNS
18637	242	8	advanced	advance	VBD
18637	242	9	the	the	DT
18637	242	10	contention	contention	NN
18637	242	11	that	that	IN
18637	242	12	the	the	DT
18637	242	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	242	14	empowered	empower	VBD
18637	242	15	the	the	DT
18637	242	16	President	President	NNP
18637	242	17	to	to	TO
18637	242	18	remove	remove	VB
18637	242	19	without	without	IN
18637	242	20	the	the	DT
18637	242	21	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	242	22	's	's	POS
18637	242	23	consent	consent	NN
18637	242	24	all	all	DT
18637	242	25	executive	executive	JJ
18637	242	26	officers	officer	NNS
18637	242	27	,	,	,
18637	242	28	even	even	RB
18637	242	29	those	those	DT
18637	242	30	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	242	31	with	with	IN
18637	242	32	that	that	DT
18637	242	33	consent	consent	NN
18637	242	34	,	,	,
18637	242	35	and	and	CC
18637	242	36	in	in	IN
18637	242	37	effect	effect	NN
18637	242	38	this	this	DT
18637	242	39	view	view	NN
18637	242	40	prevailed	prevail	VBD
18637	242	41	,	,	,
18637	242	42	to	to	TO
18637	242	43	be	be	VB
18637	242	44	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	242	45	by	by	IN
18637	242	46	the	the	DT
18637	242	47	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	242	48	Court	Court	NNP
18637	242	49	137	137	CD
18637	242	50	years	year	NNS
18637	242	51	later	later	RB
18637	242	52	in	in	IN
18637	242	53	the	the	DT
18637	242	54	famous	famous	JJ
18637	242	55	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	242	56	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
18637	242	57	Case	Case	NNP
18637	242	58	.	.	.
18637	243	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	243	2	38	38	CD
18637	243	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	243	4	In	in	IN
18637	243	5	1793	1793	CD
18637	243	6	the	the	DT
18637	243	7	protagonist	protagonist	NN
18637	243	8	of	of	IN
18637	243	9	"	"	``
18637	243	10	executive	executive	JJ
18637	243	11	power	power	NN
18637	243	12	"	"	''
18637	243	13	was	be	VBD
18637	243	14	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	243	15	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	243	16	,	,	,
18637	243	17	who	who	WP
18637	243	18	appealed	appeal	VBD
18637	243	19	to	to	IN
18637	243	20	the	the	DT
18637	243	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	243	22	in	in	IN
18637	243	23	defense	defense	NN
18637	243	24	of	of	IN
18637	243	25	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	243	26	's	's	POS
18637	243	27	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	243	28	of	of	IN
18637	243	29	neutrality	neutrality	NN
18637	243	30	,	,	,
18637	243	31	issued	issue	VBN
18637	243	32	on	on	IN
18637	243	33	the	the	DT
18637	243	34	outbreak	outbreak	NN
18637	243	35	of	of	IN
18637	243	36	war	war	NN
18637	243	37	between	between	IN
18637	243	38	France	France	NNP
18637	243	39	and	and	CC
18637	243	40	Great	Great	NNP
18637	243	41	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	243	42	.	.	.
18637	244	1	Prompted	prompt	VBN
18637	244	2	by	by	IN
18637	244	3	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	244	4	to	to	TO
18637	244	5	take	take	VB
18637	244	6	up	up	RP
18637	244	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	244	8	pen	pen	NN
18637	244	9	and	and	CC
18637	244	10	"	"	``
18637	244	11	cut	cut	VBD
18637	244	12	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	244	13	to	to	IN
18637	244	14	pieces	piece	NNS
18637	244	15	in	in	IN
18637	244	16	face	face	NN
18637	244	17	of	of	IN
18637	244	18	public	public	NN
18637	244	19	,	,	,
18637	244	20	"	"	''
18637	244	21	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	244	22	shifted	shift	VBD
18637	244	23	position	position	NN
18637	244	24	,	,	,
18637	244	25	and	and	CC
18637	244	26	charged	charge	VBD
18637	244	27	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	244	28	with	with	IN
18637	244	29	endeavoring	endeavor	VBG
18637	244	30	to	to	TO
18637	244	31	smuggle	smuggle	VB
18637	244	32	the	the	DT
18637	244	33	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	244	34	of	of	IN
18637	244	35	the	the	DT
18637	244	36	King	King	NNP
18637	244	37	of	of	IN
18637	244	38	Great	Great	NNP
18637	244	39	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	244	40	into	into	IN
18637	244	41	the	the	DT
18637	244	42	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	244	43	via	via	IN
18637	244	44	the	the	DT
18637	244	45	"	"	``
18637	244	46	executive	executive	JJ
18637	244	47	power	power	NN
18637	244	48	"	"	''
18637	244	49	clause	clause	NN
18637	244	50	.	.	.
18637	245	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	245	2	39	39	CD
18637	245	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	245	4	Three	three	CD
18637	245	5	years	year	NNS
18637	245	6	earlier	early	RBR
18637	245	7	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	245	8	had	have	VBD
18637	245	9	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	245	10	written	write	VBN
18637	245	11	in	in	IN
18637	245	12	an	an	DT
18637	245	13	official	official	JJ
18637	245	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	245	15	as	as	IN
18637	245	16	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	245	17	of	of	IN
18637	245	18	State	State	NNP
18637	245	19	:	:	:
18637	245	20	[	[	-LRB-
18637	245	21	The	the	DT
18637	245	22	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	245	23	branch	branch	NN
18637	245	24	of	of	IN
18637	245	25	the	the	DT
18637	245	26	government	government	NN
18637	245	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	245	28	,	,	,
18637	245	29	"	"	``
18637	245	30	possessing	possess	VBG
18637	245	31	the	the	DT
18637	245	32	rights	right	NNS
18637	245	33	of	of	IN
18637	245	34	self	self	NN
18637	245	35	-	-	HYPH
18637	245	36	government	government	NN
18637	245	37	from	from	IN
18637	245	38	nature	nature	NN
18637	245	39	,	,	,
18637	245	40	can	can	MD
18637	245	41	not	not	RB
18637	245	42	be	be	VB
18637	245	43	controlled	control	VBN
18637	245	44	in	in	IN
18637	245	45	the	the	DT
18637	245	46	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	245	47	of	of	IN
18637	245	48	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	245	49	but	but	CC
18637	245	50	by	by	IN
18637	245	51	a	a	DT
18637	245	52	law	law	NN
18637	245	53	,	,	,
18637	245	54	passed	pass	VBN
18637	245	55	in	in	IN
18637	245	56	the	the	DT
18637	245	57	forms	form	NNS
18637	245	58	of	of	IN
18637	245	59	the	the	DT
18637	245	60	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	245	61	"	"	''
18637	245	62	.	.	.
18637	246	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	246	2	40	40	CD
18637	246	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	246	4	This	this	DT
18637	246	5	time	time	NN
18637	246	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	246	7	endorsement	endorsement	NN
18637	246	8	of	of	IN
18637	246	9	the	the	DT
18637	246	10	broad	broad	JJ
18637	246	11	conception	conception	NN
18637	246	12	of	of	IN
18637	246	13	the	the	DT
18637	246	14	executive	executive	JJ
18637	246	15	power	power	NN
18637	246	16	came	come	VBD
18637	246	17	early	early	RB
18637	246	18	.	.	.
18637	247	1	In	in	IN
18637	247	2	laying	lay	VBG
18637	247	3	the	the	DT
18637	247	4	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	247	5	in	in	IN
18637	247	6	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	247	7	_	_	NNP
18637	247	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	247	9	_	_	NNP
18637	247	10	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	247	11	for	for	IN
18637	247	12	the	the	DT
18637	247	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	247	14	's	's	POS
18637	247	15	claim	claim	NN
18637	247	16	of	of	IN
18637	247	17	power	power	NN
18637	247	18	to	to	TO
18637	247	19	pass	pass	VB
18637	247	20	on	on	RP
18637	247	21	the	the	DT
18637	247	22	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	247	23	of	of	IN
18637	247	24	acts	act	NNS
18637	247	25	of	of	IN
18637	247	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	247	27	,	,	,
18637	247	28	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	247	29	said	say	VBD
18637	247	30	:	:	:
18637	247	31	"	"	``
18637	247	32	The	the	DT
18637	247	33	government	government	NN
18637	247	34	of	of	IN
18637	247	35	the	the	DT
18637	247	36	United	United	NNP
18637	247	37	States	States	NNP
18637	247	38	has	have	VBZ
18637	247	39	been	be	VBN
18637	247	40	emphatically	emphatically	RB
18637	247	41	termed	term	VBN
18637	247	42	a	a	DT
18637	247	43	government	government	NN
18637	247	44	of	of	IN
18637	247	45	laws	law	NNS
18637	247	46	and	and	CC
18637	247	47	not	not	RB
18637	247	48	of	of	IN
18637	247	49	men	man	NNS
18637	247	50	"	"	''
18637	247	51	.	.	.
18637	248	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	248	2	41	41	CD
18637	248	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	248	4	Two	two	CD
18637	248	5	pages	page	NNS
18637	248	6	along	along	IN
18637	248	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	248	8	added	add	VBD
18637	248	9	these	these	DT
18637	248	10	words	word	NNS
18637	248	11	:	:	:
18637	248	12	By	by	IN
18637	248	13	the	the	DT
18637	248	14	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	248	15	of	of	IN
18637	248	16	the	the	DT
18637	248	17	United	United	NNP
18637	248	18	States	States	NNP
18637	248	19	,	,	,
18637	248	20	the	the	DT
18637	248	21	President	President	NNP
18637	248	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	248	23	invested	invest	VBN
18637	248	24	with	with	IN
18637	248	25	certain	certain	JJ
18637	248	26	important	important	JJ
18637	248	27	political	political	JJ
18637	248	28	powers	power	NNS
18637	248	29	,	,	,
18637	248	30	in	in	IN
18637	248	31	the	the	DT
18637	248	32	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	248	33	of	of	IN
18637	248	34	which	which	WDT
18637	248	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	248	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	248	37	to	to	TO
18637	248	38	use	use	VB
18637	248	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	248	40	own	own	JJ
18637	248	41	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	248	42	,	,	,
18637	248	43	and	and	CC
18637	248	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	248	45	accountable	accountable	JJ
18637	248	46	only	only	RB
18637	248	47	to	to	IN
18637	248	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	248	49	country	country	NN
18637	248	50	in	in	IN
18637	248	51	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	248	52	political	political	JJ
18637	248	53	character	character	NN
18637	248	54	,	,	,
18637	248	55	and	and	CC
18637	248	56	to	to	IN
18637	248	57	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	248	58	own	own	JJ
18637	248	59	conscience	conscience	NN
18637	248	60	.	.	.
18637	249	1	To	to	TO
18637	249	2	aid	aid	VB
18637	249	3	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	249	4	in	in	IN
18637	249	5	the	the	DT
18637	249	6	performance	performance	NN
18637	249	7	of	of	IN
18637	249	8	these	these	DT
18637	249	9	duties	duty	NNS
18637	249	10	,	,	,
18637	249	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	249	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	249	13	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	249	14	to	to	TO
18637	249	15	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	249	16	certain	certain	JJ
18637	249	17	officers	officer	NNS
18637	249	18	,	,	,
18637	249	19	who	who	WP
18637	249	20	act	act	VBP
18637	249	21	by	by	IN
18637	249	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	249	23	authority	authority	NN
18637	249	24	and	and	CC
18637	249	25	in	in	IN
18637	249	26	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	249	27	with	with	IN
18637	249	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	249	29	orders	order	NNS
18637	249	30	.	.	.
18637	250	1	In	in	IN
18637	250	2	such	such	JJ
18637	250	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	250	4	,	,	,
18637	250	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	250	6	acts	act	NNS
18637	250	7	are	be	VBP
18637	250	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	250	9	acts	act	NNS
18637	250	10	;	;	:
18637	250	11	and	and	CC
18637	250	12	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	250	13	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	250	14	may	may	MD
18637	250	15	be	be	VB
18637	250	16	entertained	entertain	VBN
18637	250	17	of	of	IN
18637	250	18	the	the	DT
18637	250	19	manner	manner	NN
18637	250	20	in	in	IN
18637	250	21	which	which	WDT
18637	250	22	executive	executive	JJ
18637	250	23	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	250	24	may	may	MD
18637	250	25	be	be	VB
18637	250	26	used	use	VBN
18637	250	27	,	,	,
18637	250	28	still	still	RB
18637	250	29	there	there	EX
18637	250	30	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	250	31	,	,	,
18637	250	32	and	and	CC
18637	250	33	can	can	MD
18637	250	34	exist	exist	VB
18637	250	35	,	,	,
18637	250	36	no	no	DT
18637	250	37	power	power	NN
18637	250	38	to	to	TO
18637	250	39	control	control	VB
18637	250	40	that	that	DT
18637	250	41	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	250	42	.	.	.
18637	251	1	The	the	DT
18637	251	2	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	251	3	are	be	VBP
18637	251	4	political	political	JJ
18637	251	5	.	.	.
18637	252	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	252	2	respect	respect	VBP
18637	252	3	the	the	DT
18637	252	4	nation	nation	NN
18637	252	5	,	,	,
18637	252	6	not	not	RB
18637	252	7	individual	individual	JJ
18637	252	8	rights	right	NNS
18637	252	9	,	,	,
18637	252	10	and	and	CC
18637	252	11	being	be	VBG
18637	252	12	entrusted	entrust	VBN
18637	252	13	to	to	IN
18637	252	14	the	the	DT
18637	252	15	executive	executive	NN
18637	252	16	,	,	,
18637	252	17	the	the	DT
18637	252	18	decision	decision	NN
18637	252	19	of	of	IN
18637	252	20	the	the	DT
18637	252	21	executive	executive	NN
18637	252	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	252	23	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	252	24	.	.	.
18637	253	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	253	2	42	42	CD
18637	253	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	253	4	From	from	IN
18637	253	5	these	these	DT
18637	253	6	words	word	NNS
18637	253	7	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	253	8	the	the	DT
18637	253	9	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	253	10	of	of	IN
18637	253	11	Political	Political	NNP
18637	253	12	Questions	Questions	NNPS
18637	253	13	,	,	,
18637	253	14	an	an	DT
18637	253	15	escape	escape	NN
18637	253	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	253	17	from	from	IN
18637	253	18	the	the	DT
18637	253	19	trammels	trammel	NNS
18637	253	20	of	of	IN
18637	253	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	253	22	review	review	NN
18637	253	23	for	for	IN
18637	253	24	high	high	JJ
18637	253	25	executive	executive	JJ
18637	253	26	officers	officer	NNS
18637	253	27	in	in	IN
18637	253	28	the	the	DT
18637	253	29	performance	performance	NN
18637	253	30	of	of	IN
18637	253	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	253	32	discretionary	discretionary	JJ
18637	253	33	duties	duty	NNS
18637	253	34	.	.	.
18637	254	1	The	the	DT
18637	254	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	254	3	was	be	VBD
18637	254	4	continued	continue	VBN
18637	254	5	,	,	,
18637	254	6	even	even	RB
18637	254	7	expanded	expand	VBN
18637	254	8	,	,	,
18637	254	9	by	by	IN
18637	254	10	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	254	11	's	's	POS
18637	254	12	successor	successor	NN
18637	254	13	.	.	.
18637	255	1	In	in	IN
18637	255	2	Luther	Luther	NNP
18637	255	3	_	_	NNP
18637	255	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	255	5	_	_	NNP
18637	255	6	Borden,[43	Borden,[43	NNP
18637	255	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	255	8	decided	decide	VBN
18637	255	9	in	in	IN
18637	255	10	1849	1849	CD
18637	255	11	,	,	,
18637	255	12	the	the	DT
18637	255	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	255	14	was	be	VBD
18637	255	15	invited	invite	VBN
18637	255	16	to	to	TO
18637	255	17	review	review	VB
18637	255	18	the	the	DT
18637	255	19	determination	determination	NN
18637	255	20	by	by	IN
18637	255	21	the	the	DT
18637	255	22	President	President	NNP
18637	255	23	that	that	IN
18637	255	24	the	the	DT
18637	255	25	existing	exist	VBG
18637	255	26	government	government	NN
18637	255	27	of	of	IN
18637	255	28	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	255	29	Island	Island	NNP
18637	255	30	was	be	VBD
18637	255	31	"	"	``
18637	255	32	republican	republican	JJ
18637	255	33	"	"	''
18637	255	34	in	in	IN
18637	255	35	form	form	NN
18637	255	36	.	.	.
18637	256	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	256	2	declined	decline	VBD
18637	256	3	the	the	DT
18637	256	4	invitation	invitation	NN
18637	256	5	,	,	,
18637	256	6	holding	hold	VBG
18637	256	7	that	that	IN
18637	256	8	the	the	DT
18637	256	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	256	10	of	of	IN
18637	256	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	256	12	and	and	CC
18637	256	13	of	of	IN
18637	256	14	the	the	DT
18637	256	15	President	President	NNP
18637	256	16	as	as	IN
18637	256	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	256	18	's	's	POS
18637	256	19	delegate	delegate	NN
18637	256	20	was	be	VBD
18637	256	21	final	final	JJ
18637	256	22	in	in	IN
18637	256	23	the	the	DT
18637	256	24	matter	matter	NN
18637	256	25	,	,	,
18637	256	26	and	and	CC
18637	256	27	bound	bind	VBD
18637	256	28	the	the	DT
18637	256	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	256	30	.	.	.
18637	257	1	Otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	257	2	said	say	VBD
18637	257	3	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	257	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	257	5	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	257	6	,	,	,
18637	257	7	the	the	DT
18637	257	8	guarantee	guarantee	NN
18637	257	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	257	10	of	of	IN
18637	257	11	the	the	DT
18637	257	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	257	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	257	14	Article	Article	NNP
18637	257	15	IV	IV	NNP
18637	257	16	,	,	,
18637	257	17	section	section	NN
18637	257	18	4	4	CD
18637	257	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	257	20	"	"	''
18637	257	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	257	22	a	a	DT
18637	257	23	guarantee	guarantee	NN
18637	257	24	of	of	IN
18637	257	25	anarchy	anarchy	NN
18637	257	26	and	and	CC
18637	257	27	not	not	RB
18637	257	28	of	of	IN
18637	257	29	order	order	NN
18637	257	30	"	"	''
18637	257	31	.	.	.
18637	258	1	But	but	CC
18637	258	2	a	a	DT
18637	258	3	year	year	NN
18637	258	4	later	later	RB
18637	258	5	the	the	DT
18637	258	6	same	same	JJ
18637	258	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	258	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	258	9	,	,	,
18637	258	10	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	258	11	again	again	RB
18637	258	12	for	for	IN
18637	258	13	the	the	DT
18637	258	14	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	258	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	258	16	,	,	,
18637	258	17	did	do	VBD
18637	258	18	not	not	RB
18637	258	19	hesitate	hesitate	VB
18637	258	20	to	to	TO
18637	258	21	rule	rule	VB
18637	258	22	that	that	IN
18637	258	23	the	the	DT
18637	258	24	President	President	NNP
18637	258	25	's	's	POS
18637	258	26	powers	power	NNS
18637	258	27	as	as	IN
18637	258	28	commander	commander	NN
18637	258	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	258	30	in	in	IN
18637	258	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	258	32	chief	chief	NN
18637	258	33	were	be	VBD
18637	258	34	purely	purely	RB
18637	258	35	military	military	JJ
18637	258	36	in	in	IN
18637	258	37	character	character	NN
18637	258	38	,	,	,
18637	258	39	those	those	DT
18637	258	40	of	of	IN
18637	258	41	any	any	DT
18637	258	42	top	top	JJ
18637	258	43	general	general	JJ
18637	258	44	or	or	CC
18637	258	45	top	top	JJ
18637	258	46	admiral	admiral	NN
18637	258	47	.	.	.
18637	259	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	259	2	44	44	CD
18637	259	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	259	4	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	259	5	had	have	VBD
18637	259	6	said	say	VBN
18637	259	7	the	the	DT
18637	259	8	same	same	JJ
18637	259	9	thing	thing	NN
18637	259	10	in	in	IN
18637	259	11	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	259	12	No	No	NNP
18637	259	13	.	.	.
18637	260	1	69	69	CD
18637	260	2	.	.	.
18637	261	1	Alongside	alongside	IN
18637	261	2	the	the	DT
18637	261	3	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	261	4	of	of	IN
18637	261	5	the	the	DT
18637	261	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	261	7	of	of	IN
18637	261	8	this	this	DT
18637	261	9	period	period	NN
18637	261	10	,	,	,
18637	261	11	however	however	RB
18637	261	12	,	,	,
18637	261	13	stand	stand	VBP
18637	261	14	certain	certain	JJ
18637	261	15	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	261	16	of	of	IN
18637	261	17	Attorneys	Attorneys	NNP
18637	261	18	General	General	NNP
18637	261	19	that	that	WDT
18637	261	20	yield	yield	VBP
18637	261	21	a	a	DT
18637	261	22	less	less	RBR
18637	261	23	balanced	balanced	JJ
18637	261	24	bill	bill	NN
18637	261	25	of	of	IN
18637	261	26	fare	fare	NN
18637	261	27	.	.	.
18637	262	1	For	for	IN
18637	262	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	262	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	262	4	the	the	DT
18637	262	5	case	case	NN
18637	262	6	that	that	WDT
18637	262	7	,	,	,
18637	262	8	from	from	IN
18637	262	9	the	the	DT
18637	262	10	first	first	JJ
18637	262	11	down	down	RB
18637	262	12	to	to	IN
18637	262	13	the	the	DT
18637	262	14	present	present	JJ
18637	262	15	year	year	NN
18637	262	16	of	of	IN
18637	262	17	grace	grace	NN
18637	262	18	,	,	,
18637	262	19	these	these	DT
18637	262	20	family	family	NN
18637	262	21	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
18637	262	22	of	of	IN
18637	262	23	the	the	DT
18637	262	24	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	262	25	in	in	IN
18637	262	26	power	power	NN
18637	262	27	have	have	VBP
18637	262	28	tended	tend	VBN
18637	262	29	to	to	TO
18637	262	30	favor	favor	VB
18637	262	31	expansive	expansive	JJ
18637	262	32	conceptions	conception	NNS
18637	262	33	of	of	IN
18637	262	34	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	262	35	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	262	36	.	.	.
18637	263	1	As	as	RB
18637	263	2	early	early	RB
18637	263	3	as	as	IN
18637	263	4	1831	1831	CD
18637	263	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	263	6	find	find	VBP
18637	263	7	an	an	DT
18637	263	8	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	263	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	263	10	General	General	NNP
18637	263	11	arguing	argue	VBG
18637	263	12	before	before	IN
18637	263	13	the	the	DT
18637	263	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	263	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	263	16	that	that	IN
18637	263	17	,	,	,
18637	263	18	in	in	IN
18637	263	19	performance	performance	NN
18637	263	20	of	of	IN
18637	263	21	the	the	DT
18637	263	22	trust	trust	NN
18637	263	23	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	263	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	263	25	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	263	26	by	by	IN
18637	263	27	the	the	DT
18637	263	28	"	"	``
18637	263	29	faithful	faithful	JJ
18637	263	30	execution	execution	NN
18637	263	31	"	"	''
18637	263	32	clause	clause	NN
18637	263	33	,	,	,
18637	263	34	the	the	DT
18637	263	35	President	President	NNP
18637	263	36	"	"	``
18637	263	37	not	not	RB
18637	263	38	only	only	RB
18637	263	39	may	may	MD
18637	263	40	,	,	,
18637	263	41	but	but	CC
18637	263	42	...	...	NFP
18637	263	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	263	44	bound	bind	VBN
18637	263	45	to	to	TO
18637	263	46	avail	avail	VB
18637	263	47	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	263	48	of	of	IN
18637	263	49	every	every	DT
18637	263	50	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	263	51	means	mean	VBZ
18637	263	52	not	not	RB
18637	263	53	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	263	54	by	by	IN
18637	263	55	law	law	NN
18637	263	56	.	.	.
18637	264	1	"	"	``
18637	264	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	264	3	45	45	CD
18637	264	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	264	5	Especially	especially	RB
18637	264	6	noteworthy	noteworthy	JJ
18637	264	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	264	8	a	a	DT
18637	264	9	series	series	NN
18637	264	10	of	of	IN
18637	264	11	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	264	12	handed	hand	VBN
18637	264	13	down	down	RP
18637	264	14	by	by	IN
18637	264	15	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	264	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	264	17	General	General	NNP
18637	264	18	Cushing	Cushing	NNP
18637	264	19	in	in	IN
18637	264	20	the	the	DT
18637	264	21	course	course	NN
18637	264	22	of	of	IN
18637	264	23	the	the	DT
18637	264	24	years	year	NNS
18637	264	25	1853	1853	CD
18637	264	26	to	to	IN
18637	264	27	1855	1855	CD
18637	264	28	.	.	.
18637	265	1	In	in	IN
18637	265	2	one	one	CD
18637	265	3	of	of	IN
18637	265	4	these	these	DT
18637	265	5	the	the	DT
18637	265	6	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	265	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	265	8	General	General	NNP
18637	265	9	laid	lay	VBD
18637	265	10	down	down	RP
18637	265	11	the	the	DT
18637	265	12	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	265	13	that	that	IN
18637	265	14	a	a	DT
18637	265	15	marshal	marshal	NN
18637	265	16	of	of	IN
18637	265	17	the	the	DT
18637	265	18	United	United	NNP
18637	265	19	States	States	NNP
18637	265	20	,	,	,
18637	265	21	when	when	WRB
18637	265	22	opposed	oppose	VBN
18637	265	23	in	in	IN
18637	265	24	the	the	DT
18637	265	25	execution	execution	NN
18637	265	26	of	of	IN
18637	265	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	265	28	duty	duty	NN
18637	265	29	by	by	IN
18637	265	30	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	265	31	combinations	combination	NNS
18637	265	32	too	too	RB
18637	265	33	powerful	powerful	JJ
18637	265	34	to	to	TO
18637	265	35	be	be	VB
18637	265	36	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	265	37	with	with	IN
18637	265	38	by	by	IN
18637	265	39	the	the	DT
18637	265	40	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	265	41	processes	process	NNS
18637	265	42	of	of	IN
18637	265	43	a	a	DT
18637	265	44	federal	federal	JJ
18637	265	45	court	court	NN
18637	265	46	,	,	,
18637	265	47	had	have	VBD
18637	265	48	authority	authority	NN
18637	265	49	to	to	TO
18637	265	50	summon	summon	VB
18637	265	51	the	the	DT
18637	265	52	entire	entire	JJ
18637	265	53	able	able	JJ
18637	265	54	-	-	HYPH
18637	265	55	bodied	bodied	JJ
18637	265	56	force	force	NN
18637	265	57	of	of	IN
18637	265	58	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	265	59	precinct	precinct	NN
18637	265	60	as	as	IN
18637	265	61	a	a	DT
18637	265	62	_	_	NNP
18637	265	63	posse	posse	NN
18637	265	64	comitatus	comitatus	NN
18637	265	65	_	_	NNP
18637	265	66	,	,	,
18637	265	67	comprising	comprise	VBG
18637	265	68	not	not	RB
18637	265	69	only	only	RB
18637	265	70	bystanders	bystander	NNS
18637	265	71	and	and	CC
18637	265	72	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	265	73	generally	generally	RB
18637	265	74	but	but	CC
18637	265	75	any	any	DT
18637	265	76	and	and	CC
18637	265	77	all	all	DT
18637	265	78	armed	armed	JJ
18637	265	79	forces,[46	forces,[46	NNP
18637	265	80	]	]	-RRB-
18637	265	81	which	which	WDT
18637	265	82	is	be	VBZ
18637	265	83	precisely	precisely	RB
18637	265	84	the	the	DT
18637	265	85	theory	theory	NN
18637	265	86	upon	upon	IN
18637	265	87	which	which	WDT
18637	265	88	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	265	89	based	base	VBD
18637	265	90	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	265	91	call	call	NN
18637	265	92	for	for	IN
18637	265	93	volunteers	volunteer	NNS
18637	265	94	in	in	IN
18637	265	95	April	April	NNP
18637	265	96	,	,	,
18637	265	97	1861	1861	CD
18637	265	98	.	.	.
18637	266	1	Also	also	RB
18637	266	2	manifest	manifest	NN
18637	266	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	266	4	the	the	DT
18637	266	5	debt	debt	NN
18637	266	6	of	of	IN
18637	266	7	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	266	8	's	's	POS
18637	266	9	message	message	NN
18637	266	10	of	of	IN
18637	266	11	July	July	NNP
18637	266	12	4	4	CD
18637	266	13	,	,	,
18637	266	14	1861	1861	CD
18637	266	15	,	,	,
18637	266	16	to	to	IN
18637	266	17	these	these	DT
18637	266	18	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	266	19	.	.	.
18637	267	1	Here	here	RB
18637	267	2	in	in	IN
18637	267	3	so	so	RB
18637	267	4	many	many	JJ
18637	267	5	words	word	NNS
18637	267	6	the	the	DT
18637	267	7	President	President	NNP
18637	267	8	lays	lay	VBZ
18637	267	9	claim	claim	NN
18637	267	10	to	to	IN
18637	267	11	"	"	``
18637	267	12	the	the	DT
18637	267	13	war	war	NN
18637	267	14	power	power	NN
18637	267	15	"	"	''
18637	267	16	,	,	,
18637	267	17	partly	partly	RB
18637	267	18	on	on	IN
18637	267	19	the	the	DT
18637	267	20	ground	ground	NN
18637	267	21	of	of	IN
18637	267	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	267	23	duty	duty	NN
18637	267	24	to	to	TO
18637	267	25	"	"	``
18637	267	26	take	take	VB
18637	267	27	care	care	NN
18637	267	28	that	that	IN
18637	267	29	the	the	DT
18637	267	30	laws	law	NNS
18637	267	31	be	be	VB
18637	267	32	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	267	33	executed	execute	VBN
18637	267	34	"	"	''
18637	267	35	,	,	,
18637	267	36	partly	partly	RB
18637	267	37	in	in	IN
18637	267	38	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	267	39	on	on	IN
18637	267	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	267	41	powers	power	NNS
18637	267	42	as	as	IN
18637	267	43	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	267	44	-	-	HYPH
18637	267	45	in	in	IN
18637	267	46	-	-	HYPH
18637	267	47	Chief	chief	NN
18637	267	48	,	,	,
18637	267	49	incidentally	incidentally	RB
18637	267	50	furnishing	furnish	VBG
18637	267	51	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	267	52	a	a	DT
18637	267	53	formula	formula	NN
18637	267	54	which	which	WDT
18637	267	55	has	have	VBZ
18637	267	56	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	267	57	reappeared	reappear	VBN
18637	267	58	in	in	IN
18637	267	59	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	267	60	of	of	IN
18637	267	61	Attorneys	Attorneys	NNP
18637	267	62	-	-	HYPH
18637	267	63	General	General	NNP
18637	267	64	in	in	IN
18637	267	65	recent	recent	JJ
18637	267	66	years	year	NNS
18637	267	67	.	.	.
18637	268	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	268	2	did	do	VBD
18637	268	3	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	268	4	ever	ever	RB
18637	268	5	relinquish	relinquish	VB
18637	268	6	the	the	DT
18637	268	7	belief	belief	NN
18637	268	8	that	that	IN
18637	268	9	on	on	IN
18637	268	10	the	the	DT
18637	268	11	one	one	CD
18637	268	12	ground	ground	NN
18637	268	13	or	or	CC
18637	268	14	the	the	DT
18637	268	15	other	other	JJ
18637	268	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	268	17	possessed	possess	VBD
18637	268	18	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	268	19	resources	resource	NNS
18637	268	20	of	of	IN
18637	268	21	power	power	NN
18637	268	22	which	which	WDT
18637	268	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	268	24	lacked	lack	VBD
18637	268	25	and	and	CC
18637	268	26	the	the	DT
18637	268	27	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	268	28	of	of	IN
18637	268	29	which	which	WDT
18637	268	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	268	31	could	could	MD
18637	268	32	not	not	RB
18637	268	33	control	control	VB
18637	268	34	--	--	:
18637	268	35	an	an	DT
18637	268	36	idea	idea	NN
18637	268	37	in	in	IN
18637	268	38	the	the	DT
18637	268	39	conscientious	conscientious	JJ
18637	268	40	pursuit	pursuit	NN
18637	268	41	of	of	IN
18637	268	42	which	which	WDT
18637	268	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	268	44	successor	successor	NN
18637	268	45	came	come	VBD
18637	268	46	to	to	IN
18637	268	47	the	the	DT
18637	268	48	verge	verge	NN
18637	268	49	of	of	IN
18637	268	50	utter	utter	JJ
18637	268	51	disaster	disaster	NN
18637	268	52	.	.	.
18637	269	1	When	when	WRB
18637	269	2	first	first	RB
18637	269	3	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	269	4	with	with	IN
18637	269	5	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	269	6	's	's	POS
18637	269	7	theory	theory	NN
18637	269	8	in	in	IN
18637	269	9	the	the	DT
18637	269	10	Prize	Prize	NNP
18637	269	11	Cases,[47	cases,[47	NN
18637	269	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	269	13	in	in	IN
18637	269	14	the	the	DT
18637	269	15	midst	midst	NN
18637	269	16	of	of	IN
18637	269	17	war	war	NNP
18637	269	18	,	,	,
18637	269	19	a	a	DT
18637	269	20	closely	closely	RB
18637	269	21	divided	divide	VBN
18637	269	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	269	23	treated	treat	VBD
18637	269	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	269	25	with	with	IN
18637	269	26	abundant	abundant	JJ
18637	269	27	indulgence	indulgence	NN
18637	269	28	;	;	:
18637	269	29	but	but	CC
18637	269	30	in	in	IN
18637	269	31	_	_	NNP
18637	269	32	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	269	33	parte	parte	NN
18637	269	34	_	_	NNP
18637	269	35	Milligan[48	Milligan[48	NNP
18637	269	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	269	37	another	another	DT
18637	269	38	closely	closely	RB
18637	269	39	divided	divide	VBN
18637	269	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	269	41	swung	swing	VBD
18637	269	42	violently	violently	RB
18637	269	43	to	to	IN
18637	269	44	the	the	DT
18637	269	45	other	other	JJ
18637	269	46	direction	direction	NN
18637	269	47	,	,	,
18637	269	48	adopting	adopt	VBG
18637	269	49	the	the	DT
18637	269	50	comfortable	comfortable	JJ
18637	269	51	position	position	NN
18637	269	52	that	that	IN
18637	269	53	the	the	DT
18637	269	54	normal	normal	JJ
18637	269	55	powers	power	NNS
18637	269	56	of	of	IN
18637	269	57	the	the	DT
18637	269	58	government	government	NN
18637	269	59	were	be	VBD
18637	269	60	perfectly	perfectly	RB
18637	269	61	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	269	62	to	to	IN
18637	269	63	any	any	DT
18637	269	64	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	269	65	that	that	WDT
18637	269	66	could	could	MD
18637	269	67	possibly	possibly	RB
18637	269	68	arise	arise	VB
18637	269	69	,	,	,
18637	269	70	and	and	CC
18637	269	71	citing	cite	VBG
18637	269	72	the	the	DT
18637	269	73	war	war	NN
18637	269	74	just	just	RB
18637	269	75	"	"	``
18637	269	76	happily	happily	RB
18637	269	77	terminated	terminate	VBN
18637	269	78	"	"	''
18637	269	79	in	in	IN
18637	269	80	proof	proof	NN
18637	269	81	.	.	.
18637	270	1	But	but	CC
18637	270	2	once	once	RB
18637	270	3	again	again	RB
18637	270	4	the	the	DT
18637	270	5	principle	principle	NN
18637	270	6	of	of	IN
18637	270	7	equilibrium	equilibrium	NN
18637	270	8	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	270	9	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	270	10	.	.	.
18637	271	1	Five	five	CD
18637	271	2	months	month	NNS
18637	271	3	after	after	IN
18637	271	4	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
18637	271	5	,	,	,
18637	271	6	the	the	DT
18637	271	7	same	same	JJ
18637	271	8	Bench	Bench	NNP
18637	271	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	271	10	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	271	11	in	in	IN
18637	271	12	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	271	13	_	_	NNP
18637	271	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	271	15	_	_	NNP
18637	271	16	Johnson[49	Johnson[49	NNP
18637	271	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	271	18	that	that	IN
18637	271	19	the	the	DT
18637	271	20	President	President	NNP
18637	271	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	271	22	not	not	RB
18637	271	23	accountable	accountable	JJ
18637	271	24	to	to	IN
18637	271	25	any	any	DT
18637	271	26	court	court	NN
18637	271	27	save	save	VB
18637	271	28	that	that	DT
18637	271	29	of	of	IN
18637	271	30	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	271	31	either	either	CC
18637	271	32	for	for	IN
18637	271	33	the	the	DT
18637	271	34	nonperformance	nonperformance	NN
18637	271	35	of	of	IN
18637	271	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	271	37	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	271	38	duties	duty	NNS
18637	271	39	or	or	CC
18637	271	40	for	for	IN
18637	271	41	the	the	DT
18637	271	42	exceeding	exceeding	NN
18637	271	43	of	of	IN
18637	271	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	271	45	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	271	46	powers	power	NNS
18637	271	47	.	.	.
18637	272	1	This	this	DT
18637	272	2	was	be	VBD
18637	272	3	in	in	IN
18637	272	4	the	the	DT
18637	272	5	1866	1866	CD
18637	272	6	-	-	SYM
18637	272	7	1867	1867	CD
18637	272	8	term	term	NN
18637	272	9	of	of	IN
18637	272	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	272	11	.	.	.
18637	273	1	Sixteen	sixteen	CD
18637	273	2	years	year	NNS
18637	273	3	later	later	RB
18637	273	4	,	,	,
18637	273	5	in	in	IN
18637	273	6	1882	1882	CD
18637	273	7	,	,	,
18637	273	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	273	9	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
18637	273	10	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	273	11	gave	give	VBD
18637	273	12	classic	classic	JJ
18637	273	13	expression	expression	NN
18637	273	14	to	to	IN
18637	273	15	the	the	DT
18637	273	16	principle	principle	NN
18637	273	17	of	of	IN
18637	273	18	"	"	``
18637	273	19	a	a	DT
18637	273	20	government	government	NN
18637	273	21	of	of	IN
18637	273	22	laws	law	NNS
18637	273	23	and	and	CC
18637	273	24	not	not	RB
18637	273	25	of	of	IN
18637	273	26	men	man	NNS
18637	273	27	"	"	''
18637	273	28	in	in	IN
18637	273	29	these	these	DT
18637	273	30	words	word	NNS
18637	273	31	:	:	:
18637	273	32	"	"	``
18637	273	33	No	no	DT
18637	273	34	man	man	NN
18637	273	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	273	36	so	so	RB
18637	273	37	high	high	JJ
18637	273	38	that	that	IN
18637	273	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	273	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	273	41	above	above	IN
18637	273	42	the	the	DT
18637	273	43	law	law	NN
18637	273	44	....	....	.
18637	273	45	All	all	DT
18637	273	46	officers	officer	NNS
18637	273	47	are	be	VBP
18637	273	48	creatures	creature	NNS
18637	273	49	of	of	IN
18637	273	50	the	the	DT
18637	273	51	law	law	NN
18637	273	52	and	and	CC
18637	273	53	are	be	VBP
18637	273	54	bound	bind	VBN
18637	273	55	to	to	TO
18637	273	56	obey	obey	VB
18637	273	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	273	58	.	.	.
18637	274	1	"	"	``
18637	274	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	274	3	50	50	CD
18637	274	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	274	5	Eight	eight	CD
18637	274	6	years	year	NNS
18637	274	7	later	later	RB
18637	274	8	this	this	DT
18637	274	9	same	same	JJ
18637	274	10	great	great	JJ
18637	274	11	Judge	judge	NN
18637	274	12	queried	query	VBD
18637	274	13	whether	whether	IN
18637	274	14	the	the	DT
18637	274	15	President	President	NNP
18637	274	16	's	's	POS
18637	274	17	duty	duty	NN
18637	274	18	to	to	TO
18637	274	19	take	take	VB
18637	274	20	care	care	NN
18637	274	21	that	that	IN
18637	274	22	the	the	DT
18637	274	23	laws	law	NNS
18637	274	24	be	be	VB
18637	274	25	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	274	26	executed	execute	VBN
18637	274	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	274	28	"	"	``
18637	274	29	limited	limited	JJ
18637	274	30	to	to	IN
18637	274	31	the	the	DT
18637	274	32	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	274	33	of	of	IN
18637	274	34	acts	act	NNS
18637	274	35	of	of	IN
18637	274	36	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	274	37	or	or	CC
18637	274	38	of	of	IN
18637	274	39	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	274	40	according	accord	VBG
18637	274	41	to	to	IN
18637	274	42	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	274	43	express	express	JJ
18637	274	44	terms	term	NNS
18637	274	45	,	,	,
18637	274	46	"	"	``
18637	274	47	whether	whether	IN
18637	274	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	274	49	did	do	VBD
18637	274	50	not	not	RB
18637	274	51	also	also	RB
18637	274	52	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	274	53	"	"	``
18637	274	54	the	the	DT
18637	274	55	rights	right	NNS
18637	274	56	,	,	,
18637	274	57	duties	duty	NNS
18637	274	58	,	,	,
18637	274	59	and	and	CC
18637	274	60	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	274	61	growing	grow	VBG
18637	274	62	out	out	IN
18637	274	63	of	of	IN
18637	274	64	the	the	DT
18637	274	65	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	274	66	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	274	67	...	...	NFP
18637	274	68	and	and	CC
18637	274	69	all	all	PDT
18637	274	70	the	the	DT
18637	274	71	protection	protection	NN
18637	274	72	implied	imply	VBN
18637	274	73	by	by	IN
18637	274	74	the	the	DT
18637	274	75	nature	nature	NN
18637	274	76	of	of	IN
18637	274	77	the	the	DT
18637	274	78	government	government	NN
18637	274	79	under	under	IN
18637	274	80	the	the	DT
18637	274	81	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	274	82	.	.	.
18637	275	1	"	"	``
18637	275	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	275	3	51	51	CD
18637	275	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	275	5	Then	then	RB
18637	275	6	in	in	IN
18637	275	7	1895	1895	CD
18637	275	8	,	,	,
18637	275	9	in	in	IN
18637	275	10	the	the	DT
18637	275	11	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	275	12	Case,[52	Case,[52	NNP
18637	275	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	275	14	the	the	DT
18637	275	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	275	16	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	275	17	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	275	18	the	the	DT
18637	275	19	right	right	NN
18637	275	20	of	of	IN
18637	275	21	the	the	DT
18637	275	22	National	National	NNP
18637	275	23	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	275	24	to	to	TO
18637	275	25	go	go	VB
18637	275	26	into	into	IN
18637	275	27	the	the	DT
18637	275	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	275	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	275	30	and	and	CC
18637	275	31	secure	secure	VB
18637	275	32	an	an	DT
18637	275	33	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	275	34	against	against	IN
18637	275	35	striking	strike	VBG
18637	275	36	railway	railway	NN
18637	275	37	employees	employee	NNS
18637	275	38	who	who	WP
18637	275	39	were	be	VBD
18637	275	40	interfering	interfere	VBG
18637	275	41	with	with	IN
18637	275	42	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	275	43	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	275	44	,	,	,
18637	275	45	although	although	IN
18637	275	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	275	47	was	be	VBD
18637	275	48	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	275	49	that	that	IN
18637	275	50	there	there	EX
18637	275	51	was	be	VBD
18637	275	52	no	no	DT
18637	275	53	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	275	54	basis	basis	NN
18637	275	55	for	for	IN
18637	275	56	such	such	JJ
18637	275	57	action	action	NN
18637	275	58	.	.	.
18637	276	1	The	the	DT
18637	276	2	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	276	3	of	of	IN
18637	276	4	the	the	DT
18637	276	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	276	6	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	276	7	the	the	DT
18637	276	8	logic	logic	NN
18637	276	9	of	of	IN
18637	276	10	the	the	DT
18637	276	11	holding	holding	NN
18637	276	12	to	to	IN
18637	276	13	any	any	DT
18637	276	14	widespread	widespread	JJ
18637	276	15	public	public	JJ
18637	276	16	interest	interest	NN
18637	276	17	.	.	.
18637	277	1	The	the	DT
18637	277	2	great	great	JJ
18637	277	3	accession	accession	NN
18637	277	4	to	to	IN
18637	277	5	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	277	6	power	power	NN
18637	277	7	in	in	IN
18637	277	8	recent	recent	JJ
18637	277	9	decades	decade	NNS
18637	277	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	277	11	been	be	VBN
18637	277	12	accompanied	accompany	VBN
18637	277	13	by	by	IN
18637	277	14	the	the	DT
18637	277	15	breakdown	breakdown	NN
18637	277	16	dealt	deal	VBD
18637	277	17	with	with	IN
18637	277	18	earlier	early	JJR
18637	277	19	of	of	IN
18637	277	20	the	the	DT
18637	277	21	two	two	CD
18637	277	22	great	great	JJ
18637	277	23	structural	structural	JJ
18637	277	24	principles	principle	NNS
18637	277	25	of	of	IN
18637	277	26	the	the	DT
18637	277	27	American	American	NNP
18637	277	28	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	277	29	System	System	NNP
18637	277	30	,	,	,
18637	277	31	the	the	DT
18637	277	32	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	277	33	of	of	IN
18637	277	34	Dual	Dual	NNP
18637	277	35	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	277	36	and	and	CC
18637	277	37	the	the	DT
18637	277	38	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	277	39	of	of	IN
18637	277	40	the	the	DT
18637	277	41	Separation	Separation	NNP
18637	277	42	of	of	IN
18637	277	43	Powers	power	NNS
18637	277	44	.	.	.
18637	278	1	The	the	DT
18637	278	2	first	first	JJ
18637	278	3	exponent	exponent	NN
18637	278	4	of	of	IN
18637	278	5	"	"	``
18637	278	6	the	the	DT
18637	278	7	New	New	NNP
18637	278	8	Presidency	Presidency	NNP
18637	278	9	"	"	''
18637	278	10	,	,	,
18637	278	11	as	as	IN
18637	278	12	some	some	DT
18637	278	13	termed	term	VBD
18637	278	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	278	15	,	,	,
18637	278	16	was	be	VBD
18637	278	17	Theodore	Theodore	NNP
18637	278	18	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	278	19	,	,	,
18637	278	20	who	who	WP
18637	278	21	tells	tell	VBZ
18637	278	22	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	278	23	in	in	IN
18637	278	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	278	25	_	_	NNP
18637	278	26	Autobiography	Autobiography	NNP
18637	278	27	_	_	NNP
18637	278	28	that	that	IN
18637	278	29	the	the	DT
18637	278	30	principle	principle	NN
18637	278	31	which	which	WDT
18637	278	32	governed	govern	VBD
18637	278	33	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	278	34	in	in	IN
18637	278	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	278	36	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	278	37	of	of	IN
18637	278	38	the	the	DT
18637	278	39	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	278	40	office	office	NN
18637	278	41	was	be	VBD
18637	278	42	that	that	IN
18637	278	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	278	44	had	have	VBD
18637	278	45	not	not	RB
18637	278	46	only	only	RB
18637	278	47	a	a	DT
18637	278	48	right	right	NN
18637	278	49	but	but	CC
18637	278	50	a	a	DT
18637	278	51	duty	duty	NN
18637	278	52	"	"	``
18637	278	53	to	to	TO
18637	278	54	do	do	VB
18637	278	55	anything	anything	NN
18637	278	56	that	that	WDT
18637	278	57	the	the	DT
18637	278	58	needs	need	NNS
18637	278	59	of	of	IN
18637	278	60	the	the	DT
18637	278	61	Nation	nation	NN
18637	278	62	demanded	demand	VBD
18637	278	63	unless	unless	IN
18637	278	64	such	such	JJ
18637	278	65	action	action	NN
18637	278	66	was	be	VBD
18637	278	67	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	278	68	by	by	IN
18637	278	69	the	the	DT
18637	278	70	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	278	71	or	or	CC
18637	278	72	by	by	IN
18637	278	73	the	the	DT
18637	278	74	laws	law	NNS
18637	278	75	.	.	.
18637	279	1	"	"	``
18637	279	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	279	3	53	53	CD
18637	279	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	279	5	In	in	IN
18637	279	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	279	7	book	book	NN
18637	279	8	,	,	,
18637	279	9	_	_	NNP
18637	279	10	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	279	11	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	279	12	Magistrate	Magistrate	NNP
18637	279	13	and	and	CC
18637	279	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	279	15	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	279	16	_	_	NNP
18637	279	17	,	,	,
18637	279	18	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	279	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	279	20	President	President	NNP
18637	279	21	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	279	22	warmly	warmly	RB
18637	279	23	protested	protest	VBD
18637	279	24	against	against	IN
18637	279	25	the	the	DT
18637	279	26	notion	notion	NN
18637	279	27	that	that	IN
18637	279	28	the	the	DT
18637	279	29	President	President	NNP
18637	279	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	279	31	any	any	DT
18637	279	32	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	279	33	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	279	34	to	to	TO
18637	279	35	attempt	attempt	VB
18637	279	36	the	the	DT
18637	279	37	role	role	NN
18637	279	38	of	of	IN
18637	279	39	a	a	DT
18637	279	40	"	"	``
18637	279	41	Universal	Universal	NNP
18637	279	42	Providence	Providence	NNP
18637	279	43	.	.	.
18637	280	1	"	"	``
18637	280	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	280	3	54	54	CD
18637	280	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	280	5	A	a	DT
18637	280	6	decade	decade	NN
18637	280	7	earlier	early	RBR
18637	280	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	280	9	destined	destine	VBN
18637	280	10	successor	successor	NN
18637	280	11	,	,	,
18637	280	12	Woodrow	Woodrow	NNP
18637	280	13	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	280	14	,	,	,
18637	280	15	had	have	VBD
18637	280	16	avowed	avow	VBN
18637	280	17	the	the	DT
18637	280	18	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	280	19	that	that	IN
18637	280	20	"	"	``
18637	280	21	the	the	DT
18637	280	22	President	President	NNP
18637	280	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	280	24	at	at	IN
18637	280	25	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	280	26	,	,	,
18637	280	27	both	both	CC
18637	280	28	in	in	IN
18637	280	29	law	law	NN
18637	280	30	and	and	CC
18637	280	31	conscience	conscience	NN
18637	280	32	,	,	,
18637	280	33	to	to	TO
18637	280	34	be	be	VB
18637	280	35	as	as	RB
18637	280	36	big	big	JJ
18637	280	37	a	a	DT
18637	280	38	man	man	NN
18637	280	39	as	as	IN
18637	280	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	280	41	can	can	MD
18637	280	42	"	"	``
18637	280	43	.	.	.
18637	281	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	281	2	55	55	CD
18637	281	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	281	4	But	but	CC
18637	281	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	281	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	281	7	the	the	DT
18637	281	8	second	second	JJ
18637	281	9	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	281	10	who	who	WP
18637	281	11	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	281	12	all	all	DT
18637	281	13	twentieth	twentieth	JJ
18637	281	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	281	15	century	century	NN
18637	281	16	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	281	17	succeeded	succeed	VBD
18637	281	18	in	in	IN
18637	281	19	affixing	affix	VBG
18637	281	20	the	the	DT
18637	281	21	stamp	stamp	NN
18637	281	22	both	both	DT
18637	281	23	of	of	IN
18637	281	24	personality	personality	NN
18637	281	25	and	and	CC
18637	281	26	of	of	IN
18637	281	27	crisis	crisis	NN
18637	281	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	281	29	the	the	DT
18637	281	30	Presidency	Presidency	NNP
18637	281	31	as	as	IN
18637	281	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	281	33	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	281	34	at	at	IN
18637	281	35	this	this	DT
18637	281	36	moment	moment	NN
18637	281	37	.	.	.
18637	282	1	In	in	IN
18637	282	2	the	the	DT
18637	282	3	solution	solution	NN
18637	282	4	of	of	IN
18637	282	5	the	the	DT
18637	282	6	problems	problem	NNS
18637	282	7	of	of	IN
18637	282	8	an	an	DT
18637	282	9	economic	economic	JJ
18637	282	10	crisis	crisis	NN
18637	282	11	,	,	,
18637	282	12	"	"	''
18637	282	13	a	a	DT
18637	282	14	crisis	crisis	NN
18637	282	15	greater	great	JJR
18637	282	16	than	than	IN
18637	282	17	war	war	NN
18637	282	18	"	"	''
18637	282	19	,	,	,
18637	282	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	282	21	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	282	22	for	for	IN
18637	282	23	the	the	DT
18637	282	24	National	National	NNP
18637	282	25	Government	Government	NNP
18637	282	26	in	in	IN
18637	282	27	general	general	JJ
18637	282	28	,	,	,
18637	282	29	and	and	CC
18637	282	30	for	for	IN
18637	282	31	the	the	DT
18637	282	32	President	President	NNP
18637	282	33	in	in	IN
18637	282	34	particular	particular	JJ
18637	282	35	,	,	,
18637	282	36	powers	power	NNS
18637	282	37	which	which	WDT
18637	282	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	282	39	had	have	VBD
18637	282	40	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
18637	282	41	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	282	42	only	only	RB
18637	282	43	on	on	IN
18637	282	44	the	the	DT
18637	282	45	justification	justification	NN
18637	282	46	of	of	IN
18637	282	47	war	war	NN
18637	282	48	.	.	.
18637	283	1	Then	then	RB
18637	283	2	when	when	WRB
18637	283	3	the	the	DT
18637	283	4	greatest	great	JJS
18637	283	5	crisis	crisis	NN
18637	283	6	in	in	IN
18637	283	7	the	the	DT
18637	283	8	history	history	NN
18637	283	9	of	of	IN
18637	283	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	283	11	international	international	JJ
18637	283	12	relations	relation	NNS
18637	283	13	arose	arise	VBD
18637	283	14	,	,	,
18637	283	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	283	16	imparted	impart	VBD
18637	283	17	to	to	IN
18637	283	18	the	the	DT
18637	283	19	President	President	NNP
18637	283	20	's	's	POS
18637	283	21	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	283	22	powers	power	NNS
18637	283	23	new	new	JJ
18637	283	24	extension	extension	NN
18637	283	25	,	,	,
18637	283	26	now	now	RB
18637	283	27	without	without	IN
18637	283	28	consulting	consult	VBG
18637	283	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	283	30	,	,	,
18637	283	31	now	now	RB
18637	283	32	with	with	IN
18637	283	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	283	34	's	's	POS
18637	283	35	approval	approval	NN
18637	283	36	;	;	:
18637	283	37	and	and	CC
18637	283	38	when	when	WRB
18637	283	39	at	at	IN
18637	283	40	last	last	RB
18637	283	41	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	283	42	entered	enter	VBD
18637	283	43	World	World	NNP
18637	283	44	War	War	NNP
18637	283	45	II	II	NNP
18637	283	46	,	,	,
18637	283	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	283	48	endowed	endow	VBD
18637	283	49	the	the	DT
18637	283	50	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	283	51	of	of	IN
18637	283	52	both	both	CC
18637	283	53	the	the	DT
18637	283	54	War	War	NNP
18637	283	55	between	between	IN
18637	283	56	the	the	DT
18637	283	57	States	States	NNPS
18637	283	58	and	and	CC
18637	283	59	of	of	IN
18637	283	60	World	World	NNP
18637	283	61	War	War	NNP
18637	283	62	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	283	63	with	with	IN
18637	283	64	unprecedented	unprecedented	JJ
18637	283	65	scope	scope	NN
18637	283	66	.	.	.
18637	284	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	284	2	56	56	CD
18637	284	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	284	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	284	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	284	6	timely	timely	RB
18637	284	7	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	284	8	to	to	TO
18637	284	9	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	284	10	whether	whether	IN
18637	284	11	American	American	NNP
18637	284	12	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	284	13	Law	Law	NNP
18637	284	14	today	today	NN
18637	284	15	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	284	16	the	the	DT
18637	284	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	284	18	a	a	DT
18637	284	19	dependable	dependable	JJ
18637	284	20	weapon	weapon	NN
18637	284	21	with	with	IN
18637	284	22	which	which	WDT
18637	284	23	to	to	TO
18637	284	24	combat	combat	VB
18637	284	25	effectively	effectively	RB
18637	284	26	contemporary	contemporary	JJ
18637	284	27	enlarged	enlarged	JJ
18637	284	28	conceptions	conception	NNS
18637	284	29	of	of	IN
18637	284	30	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	284	31	power	power	NN
18637	284	32	.	.	.
18637	285	1	Pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	285	2	in	in	IN
18637	285	3	this	this	DT
18637	285	4	connection	connection	NN
18637	285	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	285	6	the	the	DT
18637	285	7	aforementioned	aforementioned	JJ
18637	285	8	recent	recent	JJ
18637	285	9	action	action	NN
18637	285	10	of	of	IN
18637	285	11	the	the	DT
18637	285	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	285	13	in	in	IN
18637	285	14	Youngstown	Youngstown	NNP
18637	285	15	_	_	NNP
18637	285	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	285	17	_	_	NNP
18637	285	18	Sawyer	Sawyer	NNP
18637	285	19	disallowing	disallow	VBG
18637	285	20	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	285	21	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	285	22	of	of	IN
18637	285	23	the	the	DT
18637	285	24	steel	steel	NN
18637	285	25	industry	industry	NN
18637	285	26	.	.	.
18637	286	1	The	the	DT
18637	286	2	net	net	JJ
18637	286	3	result	result	NN
18637	286	4	of	of	IN
18637	286	5	that	that	DT
18637	286	6	Case	Case	NNP
18637	286	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	286	8	distinctly	distinctly	RB
18637	286	9	favorable	favorable	JJ
18637	286	10	to	to	IN
18637	286	11	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	286	12	pretensions	pretension	NNS
18637	286	13	,	,	,
18637	286	14	in	in	IN
18637	286	15	two	two	CD
18637	286	16	respects	respect	NNS
18637	286	17	:	:	:
18637	286	18	First	first	RB
18637	286	19	,	,	,
18637	286	20	because	because	IN
18637	286	21	of	of	IN
18637	286	22	the	the	DT
18637	286	23	failure	failure	NN
18637	286	24	of	of	IN
18637	286	25	the	the	DT
18637	286	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	286	27	to	to	TO
18637	286	28	traverse	traverse	VB
18637	286	29	the	the	DT
18637	286	30	President	President	NNP
18637	286	31	's	's	POS
18637	286	32	finding	finding	NN
18637	286	33	of	of	IN
18637	286	34	facts	fact	NNS
18637	286	35	allegedly	allegedly	RB
18637	286	36	justifying	justify	VBG
18637	286	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	286	38	action	action	NN
18637	286	39	,	,	,
18637	286	40	an	an	DT
18637	286	41	omission	omission	NN
18637	286	42	in	in	IN
18637	286	43	accord	accord	NN
18637	286	44	with	with	IN
18637	286	45	the	the	DT
18637	286	46	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	286	47	of	of	IN
18637	286	48	Political	Political	NNP
18637	286	49	Questions	Questions	NNPS
18637	286	50	;	;	:
18637	286	51	secondly	secondly	RB
18637	286	52	,	,	,
18637	286	53	the	the	DT
18637	286	54	evident	evident	JJ
18637	286	55	endorsement	endorsement	NN
18637	286	56	by	by	IN
18637	286	57	a	a	DT
18637	286	58	majority	majority	NN
18637	286	59	of	of	IN
18637	286	60	the	the	DT
18637	286	61	Court	Court	NNP
18637	286	62	of	of	IN
18637	286	63	the	the	DT
18637	286	64	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	286	65	that	that	WDT
18637	286	66	,	,	,
18637	286	67	as	as	IN
18637	286	68	stated	state	VBN
18637	286	69	in	in	IN
18637	286	70	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	286	71	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	286	72	's	's	POS
18637	286	73	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	286	74	:	:	:
18637	286	75	"	"	``
18637	286	76	The	the	DT
18637	286	77	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	286	78	does	do	VBZ
18637	286	79	grant	grant	VB
18637	286	80	to	to	IN
18637	286	81	the	the	DT
18637	286	82	President	President	NNP
18637	286	83	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	286	84	authority	authority	NN
18637	286	85	in	in	IN
18637	286	86	times	time	NNS
18637	286	87	of	of	IN
18637	286	88	grave	grave	NN
18637	286	89	and	and	CC
18637	286	90	imperative	imperative	JJ
18637	286	91	national	national	JJ
18637	286	92	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	286	93	"	"	''
18637	286	94	.	.	.
18637	287	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	287	2	57	57	CD
18637	287	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	287	4	That	that	IN
18637	287	5	the	the	DT
18637	287	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	287	7	would	would	MD
18637	287	8	have	have	VB
18637	287	9	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	287	10	,	,	,
18637	287	11	as	as	IN
18637	287	12	against	against	IN
18637	287	13	the	the	DT
18637	287	14	President	President	NNP
18637	287	15	's	's	POS
18637	287	16	action	action	NN
18637	287	17	,	,	,
18637	287	18	a	a	DT
18637	287	19	clear	clear	RB
18637	287	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	287	21	cut	cut	VBN
18637	287	22	manifestation	manifestation	NN
18637	287	23	of	of	IN
18637	287	24	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	287	25	action	action	NN
18637	287	26	to	to	IN
18637	287	27	the	the	DT
18637	287	28	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	287	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	287	30	,	,	,
18637	287	31	on	on	IN
18637	287	32	the	the	DT
18637	287	33	other	other	JJ
18637	287	34	hand	hand	NN
18637	287	35	,	,	,
18637	287	36	unquestionable	unquestionable	JJ
18637	287	37	.	.	.
18637	288	1	In	in	IN
18637	288	2	short	short	JJ
18637	288	3	,	,	,
18637	288	4	if	if	IN
18637	288	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	288	6	are	be	VBP
18637	288	7	today	today	NN
18637	288	8	looking	look	VBG
18637	288	9	for	for	IN
18637	288	10	a	a	DT
18637	288	11	check	check	NN
18637	288	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	288	13	the	the	DT
18637	288	14	development	development	NN
18637	288	15	of	of	IN
18637	288	16	executive	executive	JJ
18637	288	17	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	288	18	government	government	NN
18637	288	19	,	,	,
18637	288	20	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	288	21	best	good	JJS
18637	288	22	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	288	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	288	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	288	25	the	the	DT
18637	288	26	powers	power	NNS
18637	288	27	of	of	IN
18637	288	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	288	29	,	,	,
18637	288	30	which	which	WDT
18637	288	31	can	can	MD
18637	288	32	always	always	RB
18637	288	33	supply	supply	VB
18637	288	34	needed	need	VBN
18637	288	35	gaps	gap	NNS
18637	288	36	in	in	IN
18637	288	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	288	38	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	288	39	.	.	.
18637	289	1	The	the	DT
18637	289	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	289	3	can	can	MD
18637	289	4	only	only	RB
18637	289	5	say	say	VB
18637	289	6	"	"	``
18637	289	7	no	no	UH
18637	289	8	"	"	''
18637	289	9	,	,	,
18637	289	10	and	and	CC
18637	289	11	there	there	EX
18637	289	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	289	13	no	no	DT
18637	289	14	guarantee	guarantee	NN
18637	289	15	that	that	IN
18637	289	16	in	in	IN
18637	289	17	the	the	DT
18637	289	18	public	public	JJ
18637	289	19	interest	interest	NN
18637	289	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	289	21	would	would	MD
18637	289	22	wish	wish	VB
18637	289	23	to	to	TO
18637	289	24	assume	assume	VB
18637	289	25	this	this	DT
18637	289	26	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	289	27	.	.	.
18637	290	1	IV	IV	NNP
18637	290	2	The	the	DT
18637	290	3	Concept	Concept	NNP
18637	290	4	of	of	IN
18637	290	5	Substantive	Substantive	NNP
18637	290	6	Due	Due	NNP
18637	290	7	Process	Process	NNP
18637	290	8	of	of	IN
18637	290	9	Law	Law	NNP
18637	290	10	A	a	DT
18637	290	11	cursory	cursory	JJ
18637	290	12	examination	examination	NN
18637	290	13	of	of	IN
18637	290	14	the	the	DT
18637	290	15	pages	page	NNS
18637	290	16	of	of	IN
18637	290	17	this	this	DT
18637	290	18	volume	volume	NN
18637	290	19	reveals	reveal	VBZ
18637	290	20	that	that	IN
18637	290	21	fully	fully	RB
18637	290	22	a	a	DT
18637	290	23	quarter	quarter	NN
18637	290	24	of	of	IN
18637	290	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	290	26	deal	deal	VBP
18637	290	27	with	with	IN
18637	290	28	cases	case	NNS
18637	290	29	in	in	IN
18637	290	30	which	which	WDT
18637	290	31	the	the	DT
18637	290	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	290	33	has	have	VBZ
18637	290	34	been	be	VBN
18637	290	35	asked	ask	VBN
18637	290	36	to	to	TO
18637	290	37	protect	protect	VB
18637	290	38	private	private	JJ
18637	290	39	interests	interest	NNS
18637	290	40	of	of	IN
18637	290	41	one	one	CD
18637	290	42	kind	kind	NN
18637	290	43	or	or	CC
18637	290	44	another	another	DT
18637	290	45	against	against	IN
18637	290	46	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	290	47	,	,	,
18637	290	48	most	most	JJS
18637	290	49	generally	generally	RB
18637	290	50	state	state	VBP
18637	290	51	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	290	52	,	,	,
18637	290	53	which	which	WDT
18637	290	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	290	55	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	290	56	to	to	TO
18637	290	57	invade	invade	VB
18637	290	58	"	"	``
18637	290	59	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	290	60	"	"	''
18637	290	61	or	or	CC
18637	290	62	"	"	``
18637	290	63	property	property	NN
18637	290	64	"	"	''
18637	290	65	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	290	66	to	to	IN
18637	290	67	"	"	``
18637	290	68	due	due	JJ
18637	290	69	process	process	NN
18637	290	70	of	of	IN
18637	290	71	law	law	NN
18637	290	72	"	"	''
18637	290	73	.	.	.
18637	291	1	How	how	WRB
18637	291	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	291	3	this	this	DT
18637	291	4	vast	vast	JJ
18637	291	5	proliferation	proliferation	NN
18637	291	6	of	of	IN
18637	291	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	291	8	,	,	,
18637	291	9	and	and	CC
18637	291	10	attendant	attendant	JJ
18637	291	11	expansion	expansion	NN
18637	291	12	of	of	IN
18637	291	13	the	the	DT
18637	291	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	291	15	's	's	POS
18637	291	16	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	291	17	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	291	18	,	,	,
18637	291	19	to	to	TO
18637	291	20	be	be	VB
18637	291	21	explained	explain	VBN
18637	291	22	?	?	.
18637	292	1	The	the	DT
18637	292	2	explanation	explanation	NN
18637	292	3	,	,	,
18637	292	4	in	in	IN
18637	292	5	brief	brief	NN
18637	292	6	,	,	,
18637	292	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	292	8	to	to	TO
18637	292	9	be	be	VB
18637	292	10	found	find	VBN
18637	292	11	in	in	IN
18637	292	12	the	the	DT
18637	292	13	replacement	replacement	NN
18637	292	14	of	of	IN
18637	292	15	the	the	DT
18637	292	16	original	original	JJ
18637	292	17	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	292	18	of	of	IN
18637	292	19	the	the	DT
18637	292	20	due	due	JJ
18637	292	21	process	process	NN
18637	292	22	clause	clause	NN
18637	292	23	with	with	IN
18637	292	24	a	a	DT
18637	292	25	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	292	26	of	of	IN
18637	292	27	vastly	vastly	RB
18637	292	28	greater	great	JJR
18637	292	29	scope	scope	NN
18637	292	30	.	.	.
18637	293	1	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	293	2	review	review	NN
18637	293	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	293	4	always	always	RB
18637	293	5	a	a	DT
18637	293	6	function	function	NN
18637	293	7	,	,	,
18637	293	8	so	so	RB
18637	293	9	to	to	TO
18637	293	10	speak	speak	VB
18637	293	11	,	,	,
18637	293	12	of	of	IN
18637	293	13	the	the	DT
18637	293	14	viable	viable	JJ
18637	293	15	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	293	16	Law	Law	NNP
18637	293	17	of	of	IN
18637	293	18	a	a	DT
18637	293	19	particular	particular	JJ
18637	293	20	period	period	NN
18637	293	21	.	.	.
18637	294	1	From	from	IN
18637	294	2	what	what	WP
18637	294	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	294	4	been	be	VBN
18637	294	5	previously	previously	RB
18637	294	6	said	say	VBN
18637	294	7	in	in	IN
18637	294	8	this	this	DT
18637	294	9	Introduction	introduction	NN
18637	294	10	,	,	,
18637	294	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	294	12	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	294	13	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	294	14	that	that	IN
18637	294	15	the	the	DT
18637	294	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	294	17	's	's	POS
18637	294	18	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	294	19	of	of	IN
18637	294	20	the	the	DT
18637	294	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	294	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	294	23	involved	involve	VBN
18637	294	24	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	294	25	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	294	26	lawmaking	lawmaking	NN
18637	294	27	,	,	,
18637	294	28	but	but	CC
18637	294	29	in	in	IN
18637	294	30	no	no	DT
18637	294	31	other	other	JJ
18637	294	32	instance	instance	NN
18637	294	33	has	have	VBZ
18637	294	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	294	35	lawmaking	lawmaking	NN
18637	294	36	been	be	VBN
18637	294	37	more	more	RBR
18637	294	38	evident	evident	JJ
18637	294	39	than	than	IN
18637	294	40	in	in	IN
18637	294	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	294	42	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	294	43	of	of	IN
18637	294	44	the	the	DT
18637	294	45	due	due	JJ
18637	294	46	process	process	NN
18637	294	47	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	294	48	,	,	,
18637	294	49	and	and	CC
18637	294	50	in	in	IN
18637	294	51	no	no	DT
18637	294	52	other	other	JJ
18637	294	53	instance	instance	NN
18637	294	54	have	have	VB
18637	294	55	the	the	DT
18637	294	56	state	state	NN
18637	294	57	judiciaries	judiciary	NNS
18637	294	58	contributed	contribute	VBD
18637	294	59	so	so	RB
18637	294	60	much	much	RB
18637	294	61	to	to	IN
18637	294	62	the	the	DT
18637	294	63	final	final	JJ
18637	294	64	result	result	NN
18637	294	65	.	.	.
18637	295	1	The	the	DT
18637	295	2	modern	modern	JJ
18637	295	3	concept	concept	NN
18637	295	4	of	of	IN
18637	295	5	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	295	6	due	due	JJ
18637	295	7	process	process	NN
18637	295	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	295	9	not	not	RB
18637	295	10	the	the	DT
18637	295	11	achievement	achievement	NN
18637	295	12	of	of	IN
18637	295	13	any	any	DT
18637	295	14	one	one	CD
18637	295	15	American	american	JJ
18637	295	16	high	high	JJ
18637	295	17	court	court	NN
18637	295	18	;	;	:
18637	295	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	295	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	295	21	the	the	DT
18637	295	22	joint	joint	JJ
18637	295	23	achievement	achievement	NN
18637	295	24	of	of	IN
18637	295	25	several	several	JJ
18637	295	26	--	--	:
18637	295	27	in	in	IN
18637	295	28	the	the	DT
18637	295	29	end	end	NN
18637	295	30	,	,	,
18637	295	31	of	of	IN
18637	295	32	all	all	DT
18637	295	33	.	.	.
18637	296	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	296	2	58	58	CD
18637	296	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	296	4	The	the	DT
18637	296	5	thing	thing	NN
18637	296	6	which	which	WDT
18637	296	7	renders	render	VBZ
18637	296	8	the	the	DT
18637	296	9	due	due	JJ
18637	296	10	process	process	NN
18637	296	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	296	12	an	an	DT
18637	296	13	important	important	JJ
18637	296	14	datum	datum	NN
18637	296	15	of	of	IN
18637	296	16	American	American	NNP
18637	296	17	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	296	18	Law	Law	NNP
18637	296	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	296	20	the	the	DT
18637	296	21	role	role	NN
18637	296	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	296	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	296	24	played	play	VBN
18637	296	25	first	first	RB
18637	296	26	and	and	CC
18637	296	27	last	last	RB
18637	296	28	in	in	IN
18637	296	29	articulating	articulate	VBG
18637	296	30	certain	certain	JJ
18637	296	31	theories	theory	NNS
18637	296	32	of	of	IN
18637	296	33	private	private	JJ
18637	296	34	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	296	35	with	with	IN
18637	296	36	the	the	DT
18637	296	37	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	296	38	Document	Document	NNP
18637	296	39	.	.	.
18637	297	1	The	the	DT
18637	297	2	first	first	JJ
18637	297	3	such	such	JJ
18637	297	4	theory	theory	NN
18637	297	5	was	be	VBD
18637	297	6	Locke	Locke	NNP
18637	297	7	's	's	POS
18637	297	8	conception	conception	NN
18637	297	9	of	of	IN
18637	297	10	the	the	DT
18637	297	11	property	property	NN
18637	297	12	right	right	NN
18637	297	13	as	as	IN
18637	297	14	anterior	anterior	NN
18637	297	15	to	to	IN
18637	297	16	government	government	NN
18637	297	17	and	and	CC
18637	297	18	hence	hence	RB
18637	297	19	as	as	IN
18637	297	20	setting	set	VBG
18637	297	21	a	a	DT
18637	297	22	moral	moral	JJ
18637	297	23	limit	limit	NN
18637	297	24	to	to	IN
18637	297	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	297	26	powers	power	NNS
18637	297	27	.	.	.
18637	298	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	298	2	59	59	CD
18637	298	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	298	4	But	but	CC
18637	298	5	while	while	IN
18637	298	6	Locke	Locke	NNP
18637	298	7	's	's	POS
18637	298	8	influence	influence	NN
18637	298	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	298	10	seen	see	VBN
18637	298	11	to	to	TO
18637	298	12	pervade	pervade	VB
18637	298	13	the	the	DT
18637	298	14	Declarations	Declarations	NNPS
18637	298	15	and	and	CC
18637	298	16	Bills	Bills	NNPS
18637	298	17	of	of	IN
18637	298	18	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	298	19	which	which	WDT
18637	298	20	often	often	RB
18637	298	21	accompanied	accompany	VBD
18637	298	22	the	the	DT
18637	298	23	revolutionary	revolutionary	JJ
18637	298	24	State	State	NNP
18637	298	25	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
18637	298	26	,	,	,
18637	298	27	yet	yet	CC
18637	298	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	298	29	promise	promise	NN
18637	298	30	was	be	VBD
18637	298	31	early	early	RB
18637	298	32	defeated	defeat	VBN
18637	298	33	by	by	IN
18637	298	34	the	the	DT
18637	298	35	overwhelming	overwhelming	JJ
18637	298	36	power	power	NN
18637	298	37	of	of	IN
18637	298	38	the	the	DT
18637	298	39	first	first	JJ
18637	298	40	state	state	NN
18637	298	41	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	298	42	,	,	,
18637	298	43	especially	especially	RB
18637	298	44	_	_	NNP
18637	298	45	vis	vis	FW
18637	298	46	-	-	HYPH
18637	298	47	a	a	FW
18637	298	48	-	-	HYPH
18637	298	49	vis	vis	FW
18637	298	50	_	_	NNP
18637	298	51	the	the	DT
18637	298	52	property	property	NN
18637	298	53	right	right	RB
18637	298	54	.	.	.
18637	299	1	One	one	CD
18637	299	2	highly	highly	RB
18637	299	3	impressive	impressive	JJ
18637	299	4	exhibit	exhibit	NN
18637	299	5	of	of	IN
18637	299	6	early	early	JJ
18637	299	7	state	state	NN
18637	299	8	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	299	9	power	power	NN
18637	299	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	299	11	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	299	12	by	by	IN
18637	299	13	the	the	DT
18637	299	14	ferocious	ferocious	JJ
18637	299	15	catalogue	catalogue	NN
18637	299	16	of	of	IN
18637	299	17	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	299	18	directed	direct	VBN
18637	299	19	against	against	IN
18637	299	20	the	the	DT
18637	299	21	Tories	Tories	NNPS
18637	299	22	,	,	,
18637	299	23	embracing	embrace	VBG
18637	299	24	acts	act	NNS
18637	299	25	of	of	IN
18637	299	26	confiscation	confiscation	NN
18637	299	27	,	,	,
18637	299	28	bills	bill	NNS
18637	299	29	of	of	IN
18637	299	30	pains	pain	NNS
18637	299	31	and	and	CC
18637	299	32	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	299	33	,	,	,
18637	299	34	even	even	RB
18637	299	35	acts	act	NNS
18637	299	36	of	of	IN
18637	299	37	attainder	attainder	NN
18637	299	38	.	.	.
18637	300	1	A	a	DT
18637	300	2	second	second	JJ
18637	300	3	exhibit	exhibit	NN
18637	300	4	of	of	IN
18637	300	5	the	the	DT
18637	300	6	same	same	JJ
18637	300	7	kind	kind	NN
18637	300	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	300	9	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	300	10	by	by	IN
18637	300	11	the	the	DT
18637	300	12	flood	flood	NN
18637	300	13	of	of	IN
18637	300	14	paper	paper	NN
18637	300	15	money	money	NN
18637	300	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	300	17	and	and	CC
18637	300	18	other	other	JJ
18637	300	19	measures	measure	NNS
18637	300	20	of	of	IN
18637	300	21	like	like	JJ
18637	300	22	intent	intent	NN
18637	300	23	which	which	WDT
18637	300	24	the	the	DT
18637	300	25	widespread	widespread	JJ
18637	300	26	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	300	27	class	class	NN
18637	300	28	forced	force	VBN
18637	300	29	through	through	IN
18637	300	30	the	the	DT
18637	300	31	great	great	JJ
18637	300	32	majority	majority	NN
18637	300	33	of	of	IN
18637	300	34	the	the	DT
18637	300	35	state	state	NN
18637	300	36	assemblies	assembly	NNS
18637	300	37	in	in	IN
18637	300	38	the	the	DT
18637	300	39	years	year	NNS
18637	300	40	following	follow	VBG
18637	300	41	the	the	DT
18637	300	42	general	general	JJ
18637	300	43	collapse	collapse	NN
18637	300	44	of	of	IN
18637	300	45	values	value	NNS
18637	300	46	in	in	IN
18637	300	47	1780	1780	CD
18637	300	48	.	.	.
18637	301	1	The	the	DT
18637	301	2	most	most	RBS
18637	301	3	important	important	JJ
18637	301	4	reaction	reaction	NN
18637	301	5	of	of	IN
18637	301	6	the	the	DT
18637	301	7	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	301	8	interest	interest	NN
18637	301	9	to	to	IN
18637	301	10	this	this	DT
18637	301	11	course	course	NN
18637	301	12	of	of	IN
18637	301	13	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	301	14	was	be	VBD
18637	301	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	301	16	energetic	energetic	JJ
18637	301	17	part	part	NN
18637	301	18	in	in	IN
18637	301	19	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	301	20	about	about	RP
18637	301	21	the	the	DT
18637	301	22	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	301	23	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	301	24	.	.	.
18637	302	1	Closer	close	RBR
18637	302	2	,	,	,
18637	302	3	however	however	RB
18637	302	4	,	,	,
18637	302	5	to	to	IN
18637	302	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	302	7	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	302	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	302	9	the	the	DT
18637	302	10	leadership	leadership	NN
18637	302	11	taken	take	VBN
18637	302	12	by	by	IN
18637	302	13	the	the	DT
18637	302	14	new	new	JJ
18637	302	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	302	16	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	302	17	in	in	IN
18637	302	18	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	302	19	the	the	DT
18637	302	20	availability	availability	NN
18637	302	21	against	against	IN
18637	302	22	predatory	predatory	NN
18637	302	23	state	state	NN
18637	302	24	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	302	25	of	of	IN
18637	302	26	extra	extra	JJ
18637	302	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	302	28	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	302	29	principles	principle	NNS
18637	302	30	sounding	sound	VBG
18637	302	31	in	in	IN
18637	302	32	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	302	33	Law	Law	NNP
18637	302	34	.	.	.
18637	303	1	In	in	IN
18637	303	2	1795	1795	CD
18637	303	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	303	4	Paterson	Paterson	NNP
18637	303	5	of	of	IN
18637	303	6	the	the	DT
18637	303	7	new	new	JJ
18637	303	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	303	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	303	10	admonished	admonish	VBD
18637	303	11	a	a	DT
18637	303	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	303	13	jury	jury	NN
18637	303	14	that	that	DT
18637	303	15	to	to	TO
18637	303	16	construe	construe	VB
18637	303	17	a	a	DT
18637	303	18	certain	certain	JJ
18637	303	19	state	state	NN
18637	303	20	statute	statute	NN
18637	303	21	in	in	IN
18637	303	22	a	a	DT
18637	303	23	way	way	NN
18637	303	24	to	to	TO
18637	303	25	bring	bring	VB
18637	303	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	303	27	into	into	IN
18637	303	28	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	303	29	with	with	IN
18637	303	30	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	303	31	's	's	POS
18637	303	32	property	property	NN
18637	303	33	rights	right	NNS
18637	303	34	would	would	MD
18637	303	35	render	render	VB
18637	303	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	303	37	void	void	JJ
18637	303	38	.	.	.
18637	304	1	"	"	``
18637	304	2	Men	man	NNS
18637	304	3	,	,	,
18637	304	4	"	"	''
18637	304	5	said	say	VBD
18637	304	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	304	7	,	,	,
18637	304	8	"	"	``
18637	304	9	have	have	VB
18637	304	10	a	a	DT
18637	304	11	sense	sense	NN
18637	304	12	of	of	IN
18637	304	13	property	property	NN
18637	304	14	....	....	.
18637	305	1	The	the	DT
18637	305	2	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	305	3	of	of	IN
18637	305	4	property	property	NN
18637	305	5	...	...	:
18637	305	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	305	7	a	a	DT
18637	305	8	primary	primary	JJ
18637	305	9	object	object	NN
18637	305	10	of	of	IN
18637	305	11	the	the	DT
18637	305	12	social	social	JJ
18637	305	13	compact	compact	NNP
18637	305	14	"	"	''
18637	305	15	.	.	.
18637	306	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	306	2	60	60	CD
18637	306	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	306	4	Three	three	CD
18637	306	5	years	year	NNS
18637	306	6	later	later	RBR
18637	306	7	,	,	,
18637	306	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	306	9	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	306	10	proclaimed	proclaim	VBD
18637	306	11	from	from	IN
18637	306	12	the	the	DT
18637	306	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	306	14	Bench	Bench	NNP
18637	306	15	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	306	16	,	,	,
18637	306	17	with	with	IN
18637	306	18	characteristic	characteristic	JJ
18637	306	19	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	306	20	,	,	,
18637	306	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	306	22	rejection	rejection	NN
18637	306	23	of	of	IN
18637	306	24	the	the	DT
18637	306	25	idea	idea	NN
18637	306	26	that	that	IN
18637	306	27	state	state	VBP
18637	306	28	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	306	29	power	power	NN
18637	306	30	was	be	VBD
18637	306	31	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	306	32	unless	unless	IN
18637	306	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	306	34	authority	authority	NN
18637	306	35	was	be	VBD
18637	306	36	"	"	``
18637	306	37	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	306	38	restrained	restrain	VBN
18637	306	39	"	"	''
18637	306	40	by	by	IN
18637	306	41	the	the	DT
18637	306	42	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	306	43	of	of	IN
18637	306	44	the	the	DT
18637	306	45	State	State	NNP
18637	306	46	.	.	.
18637	307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	307	2	61	61	CD
18637	307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	307	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	307	5	too	too	RB
18637	307	6	was	be	VBD
18637	307	7	thinking	think	VBG
18637	307	8	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	307	9	of	of	IN
18637	307	10	the	the	DT
18637	307	11	rights	right	NNS
18637	307	12	of	of	IN
18637	307	13	property	property	NN
18637	307	14	.	.	.
18637	308	1	To	to	TO
18637	308	2	dicta	dicta	NN
18637	308	3	such	such	JJ
18637	308	4	as	as	IN
18637	308	5	these	these	DT
18637	308	6	constantly	constantly	RB
18637	308	7	accrued	accrue	VBD
18637	308	8	others	other	NNS
18637	308	9	of	of	IN
18637	308	10	like	like	IN
18637	308	11	tenor	tenor	NN
18637	308	12	from	from	IN
18637	308	13	various	various	JJ
18637	308	14	high	high	JJ
18637	308	15	state	state	NN
18637	308	16	courts	court	NNS
18637	308	17	,	,	,
18637	308	18	the	the	DT
18637	308	19	total	total	NN
18637	308	20	of	of	IN
18637	308	21	which	which	WDT
18637	308	22	had	have	VBD
18637	308	23	come	come	VBN
18637	308	24	to	to	TO
18637	308	25	comprise	comprise	VB
18637	308	26	prior	prior	RB
18637	308	27	to	to	IN
18637	308	28	the	the	DT
18637	308	29	War	War	NNP
18637	308	30	between	between	IN
18637	308	31	the	the	DT
18637	308	32	States	States	NNPS
18637	308	33	an	an	DT
18637	308	34	impressive	impressive	JJ
18637	308	35	body	body	NN
18637	308	36	of	of	IN
18637	308	37	coherent	coherent	JJ
18637	308	38	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	308	39	protective	protective	NN
18637	308	40	of	of	IN
18637	308	41	vested	vested	JJ
18637	308	42	rights	right	NNS
18637	308	43	but	but	CC
18637	308	44	claiming	claim	VBG
18637	308	45	little	little	JJ
18637	308	46	direct	direct	JJ
18637	308	47	support	support	NN
18637	308	48	from	from	IN
18637	308	49	written	write	VBN
18637	308	50	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	308	51	texts	text	NNS
18637	308	52	.	.	.
18637	309	1	This	this	DT
18637	309	2	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	309	3	was	be	VBD
18637	309	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	309	5	weakness	weakness	NN
18637	309	6	.	.	.
18637	310	1	For	for	IN
18637	310	2	the	the	DT
18637	310	3	question	question	NN
18637	310	4	early	early	RB
18637	310	5	obtruded	obtrude	VBD
18637	310	6	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	310	7	,	,	,
18637	310	8	whether	whether	IN
18637	310	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	310	10	review	review	NN
18637	310	11	could	could	MD
18637	310	12	pretend	pretend	VB
18637	310	13	to	to	TO
18637	310	14	operate	operate	VB
18637	310	15	on	on	IN
18637	310	16	a	a	DT
18637	310	17	merely	merely	RB
18637	310	18	moral	moral	JJ
18637	310	19	basis	basis	NN
18637	310	20	.	.	.
18637	311	1	Both	both	DT
18637	311	2	the	the	DT
18637	311	3	notion	notion	NN
18637	311	4	that	that	IN
18637	311	5	the	the	DT
18637	311	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	311	7	was	be	VBD
18637	311	8	an	an	DT
18637	311	9	emanation	emanation	NN
18637	311	10	from	from	IN
18637	311	11	the	the	DT
18637	311	12	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	311	13	of	of	IN
18637	311	14	the	the	DT
18637	311	15	people	people	NNS
18637	311	16	,	,	,
18637	311	17	and	and	CC
18637	311	18	the	the	DT
18637	311	19	idea	idea	NN
18637	311	20	that	that	IN
18637	311	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	311	22	review	review	NN
18637	311	23	was	be	VBD
18637	311	24	but	but	CC
18637	311	25	a	a	DT
18637	311	26	special	special	JJ
18637	311	27	aspect	aspect	NN
18637	311	28	of	of	IN
18637	311	29	normal	normal	JJ
18637	311	30	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	311	31	function	function	NN
18637	311	32	,	,	,
18637	311	33	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	311	34	the	the	DT
18637	311	35	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	311	36	.	.	.
18637	312	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	312	2	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	312	3	followed	follow	VBD
18637	312	4	that	that	IN
18637	312	5	unless	unless	IN
18637	312	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	312	7	protection	protection	NN
18637	312	8	of	of	IN
18637	312	9	the	the	DT
18637	312	10	property	property	NN
18637	312	11	right	right	NN
18637	312	12	against	against	IN
18637	312	13	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	312	14	power	power	NN
18637	312	15	was	be	VBD
18637	312	16	to	to	TO
18637	312	17	be	be	VB
18637	312	18	waived	waive	VBN
18637	312	19	,	,	,
18637	312	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	312	21	must	must	MD
18637	312	22	be	be	VB
18637	312	23	rested	rest	VBN
18637	312	24	on	on	IN
18637	312	25	some	some	DT
18637	312	26	clause	clause	NN
18637	312	27	of	of	IN
18637	312	28	the	the	DT
18637	312	29	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	312	30	document	document	NN
18637	312	31	;	;	:
18637	312	32	and	and	CC
18637	312	33	,	,	,
18637	312	34	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	312	35	as	as	IN
18637	312	36	the	the	DT
18637	312	37	due	due	JJ
18637	312	38	process	process	NN
18637	312	39	clause	clause	NN
18637	312	40	and	and	CC
18637	312	41	the	the	DT
18637	312	42	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
18637	312	43	law	law	NN
18637	312	44	of	of	IN
18637	312	45	the	the	DT
18637	312	46	land	land	NN
18637	312	47	clause	clause	NN
18637	312	48	of	of	IN
18637	312	49	certain	certain	JJ
18637	312	50	of	of	IN
18637	312	51	the	the	DT
18637	312	52	early	early	JJ
18637	312	53	state	state	NN
18637	312	54	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	312	55	were	be	VBD
18637	312	56	the	the	DT
18637	312	57	only	only	JJ
18637	312	58	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	312	59	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	312	60	which	which	WDT
18637	312	61	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	312	62	mentioned	mention	VBD
18637	312	63	property	property	NN
18637	312	64	,	,	,
18637	312	65	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	312	66	were	be	VBD
18637	312	67	the	the	DT
18637	312	68	ones	one	NNS
18637	312	69	selected	select	VBN
18637	312	70	for	for	IN
18637	312	71	the	the	DT
18637	312	72	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	312	73	.	.	.
18637	313	1	The	the	DT
18637	313	2	absorptive	absorptive	JJ
18637	313	3	powers	power	NNS
18637	313	4	of	of	IN
18637	313	5	the	the	DT
18637	313	6	law	law	NN
18637	313	7	of	of	IN
18637	313	8	the	the	DT
18637	313	9	land	land	NN
18637	313	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	313	11	,	,	,
18637	313	12	the	the	DT
18637	313	13	precursor	precursor	NN
18637	313	14	in	in	IN
18637	313	15	the	the	DT
18637	313	16	original	original	JJ
18637	313	17	state	state	NN
18637	313	18	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	313	19	of	of	IN
18637	313	20	the	the	DT
18637	313	21	historically	historically	RB
18637	313	22	synonymous	synonymous	JJ
18637	313	23	due	due	JJ
18637	313	24	process	process	NN
18637	313	25	clause	clause	NN
18637	313	26	,	,	,
18637	313	27	was	be	VBD
18637	313	28	foreshadowed	foreshadow	VBN
18637	313	29	as	as	RB
18637	313	30	early	early	RB
18637	313	31	as	as	IN
18637	313	32	1819	1819	CD
18637	313	33	in	in	IN
18637	313	34	a	a	DT
18637	313	35	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	313	36	by	by	IN
18637	313	37	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	313	38	William	William	NNP
18637	313	39	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	313	40	of	of	IN
18637	313	41	the	the	DT
18637	313	42	United	United	NNP
18637	313	43	States	States	NNP
18637	313	44	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	313	45	Court	Court	NNP
18637	313	46	:	:	:
18637	313	47	As	as	IN
18637	313	48	to	to	IN
18637	313	49	the	the	DT
18637	313	50	words	word	NNS
18637	313	51	from	from	IN
18637	313	52	Magna	Magna	NNP
18637	313	53	Charta	Charta	NNP
18637	313	54	...	...	:
18637	313	55	after	after	IN
18637	313	56	volumes	volume	NNS
18637	313	57	spoken	speak	VBN
18637	313	58	and	and	CC
18637	313	59	written	write	VBN
18637	313	60	with	with	IN
18637	313	61	a	a	DT
18637	313	62	view	view	NN
18637	313	63	to	to	IN
18637	313	64	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	313	65	exposition	exposition	NN
18637	313	66	,	,	,
18637	313	67	the	the	DT
18637	313	68	good	good	JJ
18637	313	69	sense	sense	NN
18637	313	70	of	of	IN
18637	313	71	mankind	mankind	NN
18637	313	72	has	have	VBZ
18637	313	73	at	at	IN
18637	313	74	length	length	NN
18637	313	75	settled	settle	VBN
18637	313	76	down	down	RP
18637	313	77	to	to	IN
18637	313	78	this	this	DT
18637	313	79	:	:	:
18637	313	80	that	that	IN
18637	313	81	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	313	82	were	be	VBD
18637	313	83	intended	intend	VBN
18637	313	84	to	to	TO
18637	313	85	secure	secure	VB
18637	313	86	the	the	DT
18637	313	87	individual	individual	NN
18637	313	88	from	from	IN
18637	313	89	the	the	DT
18637	313	90	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	313	91	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	313	92	of	of	IN
18637	313	93	the	the	DT
18637	313	94	powers	power	NNS
18637	313	95	of	of	IN
18637	313	96	government	government	NN
18637	313	97	,	,	,
18637	313	98	unrestrained	unrestraine	VBN
18637	313	99	by	by	IN
18637	313	100	the	the	DT
18637	313	101	established	establish	VBN
18637	313	102	principles	principle	NNS
18637	313	103	of	of	IN
18637	313	104	private	private	JJ
18637	313	105	rights	right	NNS
18637	313	106	and	and	CC
18637	313	107	distributive	distributive	JJ
18637	313	108	justice	justice	NN
18637	313	109	.	.	.
18637	314	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	314	2	62	62	CD
18637	314	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	314	4	Thirty	thirty	CD
18637	314	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	314	6	eight	eight	CD
18637	314	7	years	year	NNS
18637	314	8	later	later	RB
18637	314	9	,	,	,
18637	314	10	in	in	IN
18637	314	11	1857	1857	CD
18637	314	12	,	,	,
18637	314	13	the	the	DT
18637	314	14	prophecy	prophecy	NN
18637	314	15	of	of	IN
18637	314	16	these	these	DT
18637	314	17	words	word	NNS
18637	314	18	was	be	VBD
18637	314	19	realized	realize	VBN
18637	314	20	in	in	IN
18637	314	21	the	the	DT
18637	314	22	famous	famous	JJ
18637	314	23	Dred	Dred	NNP
18637	314	24	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	314	25	Case,[63	Case,[63	NNP
18637	314	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	314	27	in	in	IN
18637	314	28	which	which	WDT
18637	314	29	Section	section	NN
18637	314	30	8	8	CD
18637	314	31	of	of	IN
18637	314	32	the	the	DT
18637	314	33	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	314	34	Compromise	Compromise	NNP
18637	314	35	,	,	,
18637	314	36	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	314	37	slavery	slavery	NNP
18637	314	38	was	be	VBD
18637	314	39	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	314	40	from	from	IN
18637	314	41	the	the	DT
18637	314	42	territories	territory	NNS
18637	314	43	,	,	,
18637	314	44	was	be	VBD
18637	314	45	held	hold	VBN
18637	314	46	void	void	JJ
18637	314	47	under	under	IN
18637	314	48	the	the	DT
18637	314	49	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	314	50	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	314	51	,	,	,
18637	314	52	not	not	RB
18637	314	53	on	on	IN
18637	314	54	the	the	DT
18637	314	55	ground	ground	NN
18637	314	56	that	that	IN
18637	314	57	the	the	DT
18637	314	58	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	314	59	for	for	IN
18637	314	60	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	314	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	314	62	was	be	VBD
18637	314	63	not	not	RB
18637	314	64	due	due	JJ
18637	314	65	process	process	NN
18637	314	66	of	of	IN
18637	314	67	law	law	NN
18637	314	68	,	,	,
18637	314	69	but	but	CC
18637	314	70	because	because	IN
18637	314	71	the	the	DT
18637	314	72	Court	Court	NNP
18637	314	73	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	314	74	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	314	75	as	as	RB
18637	314	76	unjust	unjust	JJ
18637	314	77	to	to	TO
18637	314	78	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	314	79	people	people	NNS
18637	314	80	to	to	TO
18637	314	81	take	take	VB
18637	314	82	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	314	83	slaves	slave	NNS
18637	314	84	,	,	,
18637	314	85	or	or	CC
18637	314	86	other	other	JJ
18637	314	87	property	property	NN
18637	314	88	,	,	,
18637	314	89	into	into	IN
18637	314	90	the	the	DT
18637	314	91	territories	territory	NNS
18637	314	92	,	,	,
18637	314	93	the	the	DT
18637	314	94	common	common	JJ
18637	314	95	property	property	NN
18637	314	96	of	of	IN
18637	314	97	all	all	PDT
18637	314	98	the	the	DT
18637	314	99	States	States	NNPS
18637	314	100	.	.	.
18637	315	1	Meanwhile	meanwhile	RB
18637	315	2	,	,	,
18637	315	3	in	in	IN
18637	315	4	the	the	DT
18637	315	5	previous	previous	JJ
18637	315	6	year	year	NN
18637	315	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	315	8	1856	1856	CD
18637	315	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	315	10	the	the	DT
18637	315	11	recently	recently	RB
18637	315	12	established	establish	VBN
18637	315	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	315	14	of	of	IN
18637	315	15	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	315	16	of	of	IN
18637	315	17	New	New	NNP
18637	315	18	York	York	NNP
18637	315	19	had	have	VBD
18637	315	20	,	,	,
18637	315	21	in	in	IN
18637	315	22	the	the	DT
18637	315	23	landmark	landmark	NN
18637	315	24	case	case	NN
18637	315	25	of	of	IN
18637	315	26	Wynehamer	Wynehamer	NNP
18637	315	27	_	_	NNP
18637	315	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	315	29	_	_	NNP
18637	315	30	People,[64	People,[64	NNP
18637	315	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	315	32	set	set	VBN
18637	315	33	aside	aside	RP
18637	315	34	a	a	DT
18637	315	35	state	state	NN
18637	315	36	-	-	HYPH
18637	315	37	wide	wide	JJ
18637	315	38	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	315	39	law	law	NN
18637	315	40	as	as	IN
18637	315	41	comprising	comprise	VBG
18637	315	42	,	,	,
18637	315	43	with	with	IN
18637	315	44	regard	regard	NN
18637	315	45	to	to	IN
18637	315	46	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	315	47	in	in	IN
18637	315	48	existence	existence	NN
18637	315	49	at	at	IN
18637	315	50	the	the	DT
18637	315	51	time	time	NN
18637	315	52	of	of	IN
18637	315	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	315	54	going	go	VBG
18637	315	55	into	into	IN
18637	315	56	effect	effect	NN
18637	315	57	,	,	,
18637	315	58	an	an	DT
18637	315	59	act	act	NN
18637	315	60	of	of	IN
18637	315	61	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	315	62	of	of	IN
18637	315	63	property	property	NN
18637	315	64	not	not	RB
18637	315	65	within	within	IN
18637	315	66	the	the	DT
18637	315	67	power	power	NN
18637	315	68	of	of	IN
18637	315	69	government	government	NN
18637	315	70	to	to	TO
18637	315	71	perform	perform	VB
18637	315	72	"	"	``
18637	315	73	even	even	RB
18637	315	74	by	by	IN
18637	315	75	the	the	DT
18637	315	76	forms	form	NNS
18637	315	77	of	of	IN
18637	315	78	due	due	JJ
18637	315	79	process	process	NN
18637	315	80	of	of	IN
18637	315	81	law	law	NN
18637	315	82	"	"	''
18637	315	83	.	.	.
18637	316	1	The	the	DT
18637	316	2	term	term	NN
18637	316	3	due	due	JJ
18637	316	4	process	process	NN
18637	316	5	of	of	IN
18637	316	6	law	law	NN
18637	316	7	,	,	,
18637	316	8	in	in	IN
18637	316	9	short	short	JJ
18637	316	10	,	,	,
18637	316	11	simply	simply	RB
18637	316	12	drops	drop	VBZ
18637	316	13	out	out	IN
18637	316	14	of	of	IN
18637	316	15	the	the	DT
18637	316	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	316	17	,	,	,
18637	316	18	which	which	WDT
18637	316	19	comes	come	VBZ
18637	316	20	to	to	TO
18637	316	21	read	read	VB
18637	316	22	"	"	``
18637	316	23	no	no	DT
18637	316	24	person	person	NN
18637	316	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	316	26	be	be	VB
18637	316	27	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	316	28	of	of	IN
18637	316	29	property	property	NN
18637	316	30	"	"	''
18637	316	31	,	,	,
18637	316	32	period	period	NN
18637	316	33	.	.	.
18637	317	1	At	at	IN
18637	317	2	the	the	DT
18637	317	3	same	same	JJ
18637	317	4	time	time	NN
18637	317	5	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	317	6	Comstock	Comstock	NNP
18637	317	7	's	's	POS
18637	317	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	317	9	in	in	IN
18637	317	10	the	the	DT
18637	317	11	case	case	NN
18637	317	12	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	317	13	repudiates	repudiate	VBZ
18637	317	14	all	all	DT
18637	317	15	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	317	16	against	against	IN
18637	317	17	the	the	DT
18637	317	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	317	19	sounding	sound	VBG
18637	317	20	in	in	IN
18637	317	21	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	317	22	Law	Law	NNP
18637	317	23	concepts	concept	NNS
18637	317	24	,	,	,
18637	317	25	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	317	26	principles	principle	NNS
18637	317	27	of	of	IN
18637	317	28	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	317	29	,	,	,
18637	317	30	common	common	JJ
18637	317	31	reason	reason	NN
18637	317	32	and	and	CC
18637	317	33	natural	natural	JJ
18637	317	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	317	35	,	,	,
18637	317	36	and	and	CC
18637	317	37	so	so	RB
18637	317	38	forth	forth	RB
18637	317	39	.	.	.
18637	318	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	318	2	theories	theory	NNS
18637	318	3	were	be	VBD
18637	318	4	subversive	subversive	JJ
18637	318	5	of	of	IN
18637	318	6	the	the	DT
18637	318	7	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	318	8	powers	power	NNS
18637	318	9	of	of	IN
18637	318	10	government	government	NN
18637	318	11	.	.	.
18637	319	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	319	2	,	,	,
18637	319	3	there	there	EX
18637	319	4	was	be	VBD
18637	319	5	"	"	``
18637	319	6	no	no	DT
18637	319	7	process	process	NN
18637	319	8	of	of	IN
18637	319	9	reasoning	reason	VBG
18637	319	10	by	by	IN
18637	319	11	which	which	WDT
18637	319	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	319	13	can	can	MD
18637	319	14	be	be	VB
18637	319	15	demonstrated	demonstrate	VBN
18637	319	16	that	that	IN
18637	319	17	the	the	DT
18637	319	18	'	'	``
18637	319	19	Act	Act	NNP
18637	319	20	for	for	IN
18637	319	21	the	the	DT
18637	319	22	Prevention	Prevention	NNP
18637	319	23	of	of	IN
18637	319	24	Intemperance	Intemperance	NNP
18637	319	25	,	,	,
18637	319	26	Pauperism	Pauperism	NNP
18637	319	27	and	and	CC
18637	319	28	Crime	Crime	NNP
18637	319	29	'	'	''
18637	319	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	319	31	void	void	JJ
18637	319	32	,	,	,
18637	319	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	319	34	principles	principle	NNS
18637	319	35	and	and	CC
18637	319	36	theories	theory	NNS
18637	319	37	outside	outside	IN
18637	319	38	of	of	IN
18637	319	39	the	the	DT
18637	319	40	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	319	41	,	,	,
18637	319	42	which	which	WDT
18637	319	43	will	will	MD
18637	319	44	not	not	RB
18637	319	45	also	also	RB
18637	319	46	,	,	,
18637	319	47	and	and	CC
18637	319	48	by	by	IN
18637	319	49	an	an	DT
18637	319	50	easier	easy	JJR
18637	319	51	induction	induction	NN
18637	319	52	,	,	,
18637	319	53	bring	bring	VB
18637	319	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	319	55	in	in	IN
18637	319	56	direct	direct	JJ
18637	319	57	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	319	58	with	with	IN
18637	319	59	the	the	DT
18637	319	60	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	319	61	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	319	62	.	.	.
18637	320	1	"	"	``
18637	320	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	320	3	65	65	CD
18637	320	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	320	5	Thus	thus	RB
18637	320	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	320	7	was	be	VBD
18637	320	8	foreshadowed	foreshadow	VBN
18637	320	9	that	that	IN
18637	320	10	the	the	DT
18637	320	11	law	law	NN
18637	320	12	of	of	IN
18637	320	13	the	the	DT
18637	320	14	land	land	NN
18637	320	15	and	and	CC
18637	320	16	the	the	DT
18637	320	17	due	due	JJ
18637	320	18	process	process	NN
18637	320	19	of	of	IN
18637	320	20	law	law	NN
18637	320	21	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	320	22	,	,	,
18637	320	23	which	which	WDT
18637	320	24	were	be	VBD
18637	320	25	originally	originally	RB
18637	320	26	inserted	insert	VBN
18637	320	27	in	in	IN
18637	320	28	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	320	29	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	320	30	to	to	TO
18637	320	31	consecrate	consecrate	VB
18637	320	32	a	a	DT
18637	320	33	specific	specific	JJ
18637	320	34	mode	mode	NN
18637	320	35	of	of	IN
18637	320	36	trial	trial	NN
18637	320	37	in	in	IN
18637	320	38	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	320	39	cases	case	NNS
18637	320	40	,	,	,
18637	320	41	to	to	IN
18637	320	42	wit	wit	NN
18637	320	43	,	,	,
18637	320	44	the	the	DT
18637	320	45	grand	grand	JJ
18637	320	46	jury	jury	NN
18637	320	47	,	,	,
18637	320	48	petit	petit	NN
18637	320	49	jury	jury	NN
18637	320	50	process	process	NN
18637	320	51	of	of	IN
18637	320	52	the	the	DT
18637	320	53	common	common	JJ
18637	320	54	law	law	NN
18637	320	55	,	,	,
18637	320	56	would	would	MD
18637	320	57	be	be	VB
18637	320	58	transformed	transform	VBN
18637	320	59	into	into	IN
18637	320	60	a	a	DT
18637	320	61	general	general	JJ
18637	320	62	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	320	63	upon	upon	IN
18637	320	64	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	320	65	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	320	66	capable	capable	JJ
18637	320	67	of	of	IN
18637	320	68	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	320	69	property	property	NN
18637	320	70	rights	right	NNS
18637	320	71	detrimentally	detrimentally	RB
18637	320	72	.	.	.
18637	321	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	321	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	321	3	against	against	IN
18637	321	4	this	this	DT
18637	321	5	background	background	NN
18637	321	6	that	that	IN
18637	321	7	the	the	DT
18637	321	8	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	321	9	of	of	IN
18637	321	10	the	the	DT
18637	321	11	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	321	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	321	13	in	in	IN
18637	321	14	1868	1868	CD
18637	321	15	must	must	MD
18637	321	16	be	be	VB
18637	321	17	projected	project	VBN
18637	321	18	.	.	.
18637	322	1	Applied	apply	VBN
18637	322	2	,	,	,
18637	322	3	as	as	IN
18637	322	4	in	in	IN
18637	322	5	the	the	DT
18637	322	6	Dred	Dred	NNP
18637	322	7	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	322	8	and	and	CC
18637	322	9	Wynehamer	Wynehamer	NNP
18637	322	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	322	11	,	,	,
18637	322	12	the	the	DT
18637	322	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	322	14	which	which	WDT
18637	322	15	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	322	16	any	any	DT
18637	322	17	State	State	NNP
18637	322	18	"	"	``
18637	322	19	to	to	TO
18637	322	20	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	322	21	any	any	DT
18637	322	22	person	person	NN
18637	322	23	of	of	IN
18637	322	24	life	life	NN
18637	322	25	,	,	,
18637	322	26	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	322	27	or	or	CC
18637	322	28	property	property	NN
18637	322	29	without	without	IN
18637	322	30	due	due	JJ
18637	322	31	process	process	NN
18637	322	32	of	of	IN
18637	322	33	law	law	NN
18637	322	34	"	"	''
18637	322	35	proffered	proffer	VBD
18637	322	36	the	the	DT
18637	322	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	322	38	,	,	,
18637	322	39	in	in	IN
18637	322	40	implication	implication	NN
18637	322	41	,	,	,
18637	322	42	a	a	DT
18637	322	43	vast	vast	JJ
18637	322	44	new	new	JJ
18637	322	45	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	322	46	,	,	,
18637	322	47	but	but	CC
18637	322	48	this	this	DT
18637	322	49	the	the	DT
18637	322	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	322	51	at	at	IN
18637	322	52	first	first	RB
18637	322	53	manifested	manifest	VBD
18637	322	54	the	the	DT
18637	322	55	greatest	great	JJS
18637	322	56	reluctance	reluctance	NN
18637	322	57	to	to	TO
18637	322	58	enter	enter	VB
18637	322	59	upon	upon	IN
18637	322	60	.	.	.
18637	323	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	323	2	did	do	VBD
18637	323	3	not	not	RB
18637	323	4	wish	wish	VB
18637	323	5	,	,	,
18637	323	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	323	7	protested	protest	VBD
18637	323	8	,	,	,
18637	323	9	to	to	TO
18637	323	10	become	become	VB
18637	323	11	"	"	``
18637	323	12	a	a	DT
18637	323	13	perpetual	perpetual	JJ
18637	323	14	censor	censor	NN
18637	323	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	323	16	all	all	DT
18637	323	17	State	State	NNP
18637	323	18	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	323	19	"	"	''
18637	323	20	;	;	,
18637	323	21	nor	nor	CC
18637	323	22	did	do	VBD
18637	323	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	323	24	wish	wish	VB
18637	323	25	,	,	,
18637	323	26	by	by	IN
18637	323	27	enlarged	enlarged	JJ
18637	323	28	conceptions	conception	NNS
18637	323	29	of	of	IN
18637	323	30	the	the	DT
18637	323	31	rights	right	NNS
18637	323	32	protected	protect	VBN
18637	323	33	by	by	IN
18637	323	34	the	the	DT
18637	323	35	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	323	36	,	,	,
18637	323	37	to	to	TO
18637	323	38	encourage	encourage	VB
18637	323	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	323	40	to	to	TO
18637	323	41	take	take	VB
18637	323	42	over	over	RP
18637	323	43	,	,	,
18637	323	44	under	under	IN
18637	323	45	the	the	DT
18637	323	46	fifth	fifth	JJ
18637	323	47	section	section	NN
18637	323	48	of	of	IN
18637	323	49	the	the	DT
18637	323	50	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	323	51	,	,	,
18637	323	52	the	the	DT
18637	323	53	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	323	54	of	of	IN
18637	323	55	all	all	DT
18637	323	56	civil	civil	JJ
18637	323	57	rights	right	NNS
18637	323	58	.	.	.
18637	324	1	"	"	``
18637	324	2	The	the	DT
18637	324	3	federal	federal	JJ
18637	324	4	equilibrium	equilibrium	NN
18637	324	5	"	"	''
18637	324	6	had	have	VBD
18637	324	7	already	already	RB
18637	324	8	been	be	VBN
18637	324	9	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	324	10	disturbed	disturb	VBN
18637	324	11	by	by	IN
18637	324	12	the	the	DT
18637	324	13	results	result	NNS
18637	324	14	of	of	IN
18637	324	15	the	the	DT
18637	324	16	War	War	NNP
18637	324	17	between	between	IN
18637	324	18	the	the	DT
18637	324	19	States	States	NNP
18637	324	20	and	and	CC
18637	324	21	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
18637	324	22	.	.	.
18637	325	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	325	2	66	66	CD
18637	325	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	325	4	But	but	CC
18637	325	5	this	this	DT
18637	325	6	self	self	NN
18637	325	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	325	8	denying	deny	VBG
18637	325	9	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	325	10	,	,	,
18637	325	11	which	which	WDT
18637	325	12	never	never	RB
18637	325	13	had	have	VBD
18637	325	14	the	the	DT
18637	325	15	support	support	NN
18637	325	16	of	of	IN
18637	325	17	more	more	JJR
18637	325	18	than	than	IN
18637	325	19	a	a	DT
18637	325	20	very	very	RB
18637	325	21	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	325	22	majority	majority	NN
18637	325	23	of	of	IN
18637	325	24	the	the	DT
18637	325	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	325	26	,	,	,
18637	325	27	soon	soon	RB
18637	325	28	began	begin	VBD
18637	325	29	to	to	TO
18637	325	30	crumble	crumble	VB
18637	325	31	at	at	IN
18637	325	32	the	the	DT
18637	325	33	edges	edge	NNS
18637	325	34	.	.	.
18637	326	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	326	2	was	be	VBD
18637	326	3	a	a	DT
18637	326	4	period	period	NN
18637	326	5	of	of	IN
18637	326	6	immense	immense	JJ
18637	326	7	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	326	8	expansion	expansion	NN
18637	326	9	,	,	,
18637	326	10	and	and	CC
18637	326	11	the	the	DT
18637	326	12	men	man	NNS
18637	326	13	who	who	WP
18637	326	14	directed	direct	VBD
18637	326	15	this	this	DT
18637	326	16	wanted	want	VBD
18637	326	17	a	a	DT
18637	326	18	free	free	JJ
18637	326	19	hand	hand	NN
18637	326	20	.	.	.
18637	327	1	In	in	IN
18637	327	2	1878	1878	CD
18637	327	3	the	the	DT
18637	327	4	American	American	NNP
18637	327	5	Bar	Bar	NNP
18637	327	6	Association	Association	NNP
18637	327	7	was	be	VBD
18637	327	8	formed	form	VBN
18637	327	9	from	from	IN
18637	327	10	the	the	DT
18637	327	11	elite	elite	NN
18637	327	12	of	of	IN
18637	327	13	the	the	DT
18637	327	14	American	American	NNP
18637	327	15	Bar	Bar	NNP
18637	327	16	.	.	.
18637	328	1	Organized	organize	VBN
18637	328	2	as	as	IN
18637	328	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	328	4	was	be	VBD
18637	328	5	in	in	IN
18637	328	6	the	the	DT
18637	328	7	wake	wake	NN
18637	328	8	of	of	IN
18637	328	9	the	the	DT
18637	328	10	"	"	``
18637	328	11	barbarous	barbarous	JJ
18637	328	12	"	"	''
18637	328	13	decision	decision	NN
18637	328	14	--	--	:
18637	328	15	as	as	IN
18637	328	16	one	one	CD
18637	328	17	member	member	NN
18637	328	18	termed	term	VBD
18637	328	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	328	20	--	--	:
18637	328	21	in	in	IN
18637	328	22	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	328	23	_	_	NNP
18637	328	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	328	25	_	_	NNP
18637	328	26	Illinois,[67	Illinois,[67	NNP
18637	328	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	328	28	in	in	IN
18637	328	29	which	which	WDT
18637	328	30	the	the	DT
18637	328	31	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	328	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	328	33	had	have	VBD
18637	328	34	held	hold	VBN
18637	328	35	that	that	IN
18637	328	36	states	state	NNS
18637	328	37	were	be	VBD
18637	328	38	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	328	39	by	by	IN
18637	328	40	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	328	41	of	of	IN
18637	328	42	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	328	43	police	police	NN
18637	328	44	power	power	NN
18637	328	45	to	to	TO
18637	328	46	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	328	47	the	the	DT
18637	328	48	charges	charge	NNS
18637	328	49	of	of	IN
18637	328	50	"	"	``
18637	328	51	businesses	business	NNS
18637	328	52	affected	affect	VBN
18637	328	53	with	with	IN
18637	328	54	a	a	DT
18637	328	55	public	public	JJ
18637	328	56	interest	interest	NN
18637	328	57	,	,	,
18637	328	58	"	"	''
18637	328	59	the	the	DT
18637	328	60	Association	Association	NNP
18637	328	61	,	,	,
18637	328	62	through	through	IN
18637	328	63	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	328	64	more	more	JJR
18637	328	65	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	328	66	members	member	NNS
18637	328	67	,	,	,
18637	328	68	became	become	VBD
18637	328	69	the	the	DT
18637	328	70	mouthpiece	mouthpiece	NN
18637	328	71	of	of	IN
18637	328	72	a	a	DT
18637	328	73	new	new	JJ
18637	328	74	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	328	75	philosophy	philosophy	NN
18637	328	76	which	which	WDT
18637	328	77	was	be	VBD
18637	328	78	compounded	compound	VBN
18637	328	79	in	in	IN
18637	328	80	about	about	RB
18637	328	81	equal	equal	JJ
18637	328	82	parts	part	NNS
18637	328	83	from	from	IN
18637	328	84	the	the	DT
18637	328	85	teachings	teaching	NNS
18637	328	86	of	of	IN
18637	328	87	the	the	DT
18637	328	88	British	British	NNP
18637	328	89	Manchester	Manchester	NNP
18637	328	90	School	School	NNP
18637	328	91	of	of	IN
18637	328	92	Political	Political	NNP
18637	328	93	Economy	Economy	NNP
18637	328	94	and	and	CC
18637	328	95	Herbert	Herbert	NNP
18637	328	96	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
18637	328	97	's	's	POS
18637	328	98	highly	highly	RB
18637	328	99	sentimentalized	sentimentalized	JJ
18637	328	100	version	version	NN
18637	328	101	of	of	IN
18637	328	102	the	the	DT
18637	328	103	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	328	104	of	of	IN
18637	328	105	evolution	evolution	NN
18637	328	106	,	,	,
18637	328	107	just	just	RB
18637	328	108	then	then	RB
18637	328	109	becoming	become	VBG
18637	328	110	the	the	DT
18637	328	111	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
18637	328	112	vogue	vogue	NN
18637	328	113	;	;	:
18637	328	114	plus	plus	CC
18637	328	115	a	a	DT
18637	328	116	"	"	``
18637	328	117	booster"--in	booster"--in	VBD
18637	328	118	the	the	DT
18637	328	119	chemical	chemical	NN
18637	328	120	sense	sense	NN
18637	328	121	--	--	:
18637	328	122	from	from	IN
18637	328	123	Sir	Sir	NNP
18637	328	124	Henry	Henry	NNP
18637	328	125	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	328	126	's	's	POS
18637	328	127	_	_	NNP
18637	328	128	Ancient	Ancient	NNP
18637	328	129	Law	Law	NNP
18637	328	130	_	_	NNP
18637	328	131	,	,	,
18637	328	132	first	first	RB
18637	328	133	published	publish	VBN
18637	328	134	in	in	IN
18637	328	135	1861	1861	CD
18637	328	136	.	.	.
18637	329	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	329	2	refer	refer	VBP
18637	329	3	to	to	IN
18637	329	4	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	329	5	's	's	POS
18637	329	6	famous	famous	JJ
18637	329	7	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	329	8	that	that	IN
18637	329	9	"	"	``
18637	329	10	the	the	DT
18637	329	11	movement	movement	NN
18637	329	12	of	of	IN
18637	329	13	the	the	DT
18637	329	14	progressive	progressive	JJ
18637	329	15	societies	society	NNS
18637	329	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	329	17	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
18637	329	18	been	be	VBN
18637	329	19	a	a	DT
18637	329	20	movement	movement	NN
18637	329	21	from	from	IN
18637	329	22	_	_	NNP
18637	329	23	Status	Status	NNP
18637	329	24	to	to	IN
18637	329	25	Contract	Contract	NNP
18637	329	26	_	_	NNP
18637	329	27	"	"	''
18637	329	28	.	.	.
18637	330	1	If	if	IN
18637	330	2	hitherto	hitherto	NNP
18637	330	3	,	,	,
18637	330	4	why	why	WRB
18637	330	5	not	not	RB
18637	330	6	henceforth	henceforth	RB
18637	330	7	?	?	.
18637	331	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	331	2	68	68	CD
18637	331	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	331	4	In	in	IN
18637	331	5	short	short	JJ
18637	331	6	,	,	,
18637	331	7	the	the	DT
18637	331	8	American	american	JJ
18637	331	9	people	people	NNS
18637	331	10	were	be	VBD
18637	331	11	presented	present	VBN
18637	331	12	,	,	,
18637	331	13	overnight	overnight	RB
18637	331	14	as	as	IN
18637	331	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	331	16	were	be	VBD
18637	331	17	,	,	,
18637	331	18	with	with	IN
18637	331	19	a	a	DT
18637	331	20	new	new	JJ
18637	331	21	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	331	22	of	of	IN
18637	331	23	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	331	24	Law	Law	NNP
18637	331	25	.	.	.
18637	332	1	Encouraged	encourage	VBN
18637	332	2	by	by	IN
18637	332	3	certain	certain	JJ
18637	332	4	dicta	dicta	NN
18637	332	5	of	of	IN
18637	332	6	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	332	7	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	332	8	of	of	IN
18637	332	9	the	the	DT
18637	332	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	332	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	332	12	,	,	,
18637	332	13	a	a	DT
18637	332	14	growing	grow	VBG
18637	332	15	procession	procession	NN
18637	332	16	of	of	IN
18637	332	17	high	high	JJ
18637	332	18	State	State	NNP
18637	332	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	332	20	--	--	:
18637	332	21	those	those	DT
18637	332	22	of	of	IN
18637	332	23	New	New	NNP
18637	332	24	York	York	NNP
18637	332	25	,	,	,
18637	332	26	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	332	27	,	,	,
18637	332	28	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	332	29	,	,	,
18637	332	30	and	and	CC
18637	332	31	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	332	32	,	,	,
18637	332	33	leading	lead	VBG
18637	332	34	the	the	DT
18637	332	35	way	way	NN
18637	332	36	--	--	:
18637	332	37	now	now	RB
18637	332	38	began	begin	VBD
18637	332	39	infiltrating	infiltrate	VBG
18637	332	40	the	the	DT
18637	332	41	due	due	JJ
18637	332	42	process	process	NN
18637	332	43	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	332	44	and	and	CC
18637	332	45	especially	especially	RB
18637	332	46	the	the	DT
18637	332	47	word	word	NN
18637	332	48	"	"	``
18637	332	49	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	332	50	"	"	''
18637	332	51	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	332	52	,	,	,
18637	332	53	of	of	IN
18637	332	54	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	332	55	several	several	JJ
18637	332	56	State	State	NNP
18637	332	57	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	332	58	with	with	IN
18637	332	59	the	the	DT
18637	332	60	new	new	JJ
18637	332	61	revelation	revelation	NN
18637	332	62	.	.	.
18637	333	1	The	the	DT
18637	333	2	product	product	NN
18637	333	3	of	of	IN
18637	333	4	these	these	DT
18637	333	5	activities	activity	NNS
18637	333	6	was	be	VBD
18637	333	7	the	the	DT
18637	333	8	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	333	9	of	of	IN
18637	333	10	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	333	11	of	of	IN
18637	333	12	contract	contract	NN
18637	333	13	,	,	,
18637	333	14	the	the	DT
18637	333	15	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	333	16	purport	purport	NN
18637	333	17	of	of	IN
18637	333	18	which	which	WDT
18637	333	19	was	be	VBD
18637	333	20	that	that	DT
18637	333	21	any	any	DT
18637	333	22	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	333	23	which	which	WDT
18637	333	24	restricted	restrict	VBD
18637	333	25	the	the	DT
18637	333	26	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	333	27	of	of	IN
18637	333	28	male	male	JJ
18637	333	29	persons	person	NNS
18637	333	30	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	333	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	333	32	one	one	CD
18637	333	33	years	year	NNS
18637	333	34	of	of	IN
18637	333	35	age	age	NN
18637	333	36	,	,	,
18637	333	37	whether	whether	IN
18637	333	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	333	39	were	be	VBD
18637	333	40	employers	employer	NNS
18637	333	41	or	or	CC
18637	333	42	employees	employee	NNS
18637	333	43	,	,	,
18637	333	44	in	in	IN
18637	333	45	the	the	DT
18637	333	46	making	making	NN
18637	333	47	of	of	IN
18637	333	48	business	business	NN
18637	333	49	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	333	50	,	,	,
18637	333	51	far	far	RB
18637	333	52	from	from	IN
18637	333	53	being	be	VBG
18637	333	54	presumptively	presumptively	RB
18637	333	55	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	333	56	,	,	,
18637	333	57	must	must	MD
18637	333	58	be	be	VB
18637	333	59	justified	justify	VBN
18637	333	60	by	by	IN
18637	333	61	well	well	RB
18637	333	62	known	know	VBN
18637	333	63	facts	fact	NNS
18637	333	64	of	of	IN
18637	333	65	which	which	WDT
18637	333	66	the	the	DT
18637	333	67	court	court	NN
18637	333	68	was	be	VBD
18637	333	69	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	333	70	to	to	TO
18637	333	71	take	take	VB
18637	333	72	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	333	73	notice	notice	NN
18637	333	74	;	;	:
18637	333	75	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	333	76	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	333	77	fell	fall	VBD
18637	333	78	under	under	IN
18637	333	79	the	the	DT
18637	333	80	ban	ban	NN
18637	333	81	of	of	IN
18637	333	82	the	the	DT
18637	333	83	due	due	JJ
18637	333	84	process	process	NN
18637	333	85	clause	clause	NN
18637	333	86	.	.	.
18637	334	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	334	2	69	69	CD
18637	334	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	334	4	At	at	IN
18637	334	5	last	last	JJ
18637	334	6	,	,	,
18637	334	7	in	in	IN
18637	334	8	1898	1898	CD
18637	334	9	,	,	,
18637	334	10	the	the	DT
18637	334	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	334	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	334	13	at	at	IN
18637	334	14	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	334	15	,	,	,
18637	334	16	following	follow	VBG
18637	334	17	some	some	DT
18637	334	18	tentative	tentative	JJ
18637	334	19	gestures	gesture	NNS
18637	334	20	in	in	IN
18637	334	21	that	that	DT
18637	334	22	direction	direction	NN
18637	334	23	,	,	,
18637	334	24	accepted	accept	VBD
18637	334	25	the	the	DT
18637	334	26	new	new	JJ
18637	334	27	dispensation	dispensation	NN
18637	334	28	outright	outright	RB
18637	334	29	.	.	.
18637	335	1	In	in	IN
18637	335	2	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
18637	335	3	_	_	NNP
18637	335	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	335	5	_	_	NNP
18637	335	6	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	335	7	decided	decide	VBD
18637	335	8	that	that	DT
18637	335	9	year	year	NN
18637	335	10	,	,	,
18637	335	11	partially	partially	RB
18637	335	12	overturning	overturn	VBG
18637	335	13	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	335	14	_	_	NNP
18637	335	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	335	16	_	_	NNP
18637	335	17	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	335	18	,	,	,
18637	335	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	335	20	gave	give	VBD
18637	335	21	notice	notice	NN
18637	335	22	of	of	IN
18637	335	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	335	24	intention	intention	NN
18637	335	25	to	to	TO
18637	335	26	review	review	VB
18637	335	27	in	in	IN
18637	335	28	detail	detail	NN
18637	335	29	the	the	DT
18637	335	30	"	"	``
18637	335	31	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	335	32	"	"	''
18637	335	33	of	of	IN
18637	335	34	railway	railway	NN
18637	335	35	rates	rate	NNS
18637	335	36	set	set	VBN
18637	335	37	by	by	IN
18637	335	38	State	State	NNP
18637	335	39	authority	authority	NN
18637	335	40	and	and	CC
18637	335	41	in	in	IN
18637	335	42	Holden	Holden	NNP
18637	335	43	_	_	NNP
18637	335	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	335	45	_	_	NNP
18637	335	46	Hardy	Hardy	NNP
18637	335	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	335	48	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	335	49	,	,	,
18637	335	50	at	at	IN
18637	335	51	the	the	DT
18637	335	52	same	same	JJ
18637	335	53	term	term	NN
18637	335	54	,	,	,
18637	335	55	the	the	DT
18637	335	56	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	335	57	of	of	IN
18637	335	58	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	335	59	of	of	IN
18637	335	60	contract	contract	NN
18637	335	61	.	.	.
18637	336	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	336	2	70	70	CD
18637	336	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	336	4	The	the	DT
18637	336	5	result	result	NN
18637	336	6	of	of	IN
18637	336	7	the	the	DT
18637	336	8	two	two	CD
18637	336	9	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	336	10	for	for	IN
18637	336	11	the	the	DT
18637	336	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	336	13	's	's	POS
18637	336	14	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	336	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	336	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	336	17	roughly	roughly	RB
18637	336	18	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	336	19	by	by	IN
18637	336	20	the	the	DT
18637	336	21	fact	fact	NN
18637	336	22	that	that	IN
18637	336	23	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	336	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	336	25	had	have	VBD
18637	336	26	decided	decide	VBN
18637	336	27	134	134	CD
18637	336	28	cases	case	NNS
18637	336	29	under	under	IN
18637	336	30	the	the	DT
18637	336	31	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	336	32	during	during	IN
18637	336	33	the	the	DT
18637	336	34	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	336	35	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	336	36	years	year	NNS
18637	336	37	,	,	,
18637	336	38	in	in	IN
18637	336	39	the	the	DT
18637	336	40	ensuing	ensue	VBG
18637	336	41	thirteen	thirteen	CD
18637	336	42	years	year	NNS
18637	336	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	336	44	decided	decide	VBD
18637	336	45	430	430	CD
18637	336	46	such	such	JJ
18637	336	47	cases	case	NNS
18637	336	48	.	.	.
18637	337	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	337	2	71	71	CD
18637	337	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	337	4	For	for	IN
18637	337	5	more	more	JJR
18637	337	6	than	than	IN
18637	337	7	a	a	DT
18637	337	8	generation	generation	NN
18637	337	9	now	now	RB
18637	337	10	the	the	DT
18637	337	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	337	12	became	become	VBD
18637	337	13	the	the	DT
18637	337	14	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	337	15	guardian	guardian	NN
18637	337	16	,	,	,
18637	337	17	in	in	IN
18637	337	18	the	the	DT
18637	337	19	name	name	NN
18637	337	20	of	of	IN
18637	337	21	the	the	DT
18637	337	22	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	337	23	Document	Document	NNP
18637	337	24	,	,	,
18637	337	25	of	of	IN
18637	337	26	the	the	DT
18637	337	27	_	_	NNP
18637	337	28	laissez	laissez	NN
18637	337	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	337	30	faire	faire	FW
18637	337	31	_	_	NNP
18637	337	32	conception	conception	NN
18637	337	33	of	of	IN
18637	337	34	the	the	DT
18637	337	35	proper	proper	JJ
18637	337	36	relation	relation	NN
18637	337	37	of	of	IN
18637	337	38	Government	government	NN
18637	337	39	to	to	IN
18637	337	40	Private	Private	NNP
18637	337	41	Enterprise	Enterprise	NNP
18637	337	42	,	,	,
18637	337	43	a	a	DT
18637	337	44	rather	rather	RB
18637	337	45	inconstant	inconstant	JJ
18637	337	46	guardian	guardian	NN
18637	337	47	,	,	,
18637	337	48	however	however	RB
18637	337	49	,	,	,
18637	337	50	for	for	IN
18637	337	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	337	52	fluctuating	fluctuate	VBG
18637	337	53	membership	membership	NN
18637	337	54	tipped	tip	VBD
18637	337	55	the	the	DT
18637	337	56	scales	scale	NNS
18637	337	57	now	now	RB
18637	337	58	in	in	IN
18637	337	59	favor	favor	NN
18637	337	60	of	of	IN
18637	337	61	Business	Business	NNP
18637	337	62	,	,	,
18637	337	63	now	now	RB
18637	337	64	in	in	IN
18637	337	65	favor	favor	NN
18637	337	66	of	of	IN
18637	337	67	Government	Government	NNP
18637	337	68	.	.	.
18637	338	1	And	and	CC
18637	338	2	today	today	NN
18637	338	3	the	the	DT
18637	338	4	latter	latter	JJ
18637	338	5	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	338	6	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	338	7	to	to	TO
18637	338	8	have	have	VB
18637	338	9	prevailed	prevail	VBN
18637	338	10	.	.	.
18637	339	1	In	in	IN
18637	339	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	339	3	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	339	4	early	early	RB
18637	339	5	in	in	IN
18637	339	6	1937	1937	CD
18637	339	7	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	339	8	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	339	9	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	339	10	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	339	11	measures	measure	NNS
18637	339	12	,	,	,
18637	339	13	the	the	DT
18637	339	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	339	15	not	not	RB
18637	339	16	only	only	RB
18637	339	17	subordinated	subordinate	VBD
18637	339	18	the	the	DT
18637	339	19	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	339	20	of	of	IN
18637	339	21	employers	employer	NNS
18637	339	22	to	to	TO
18637	339	23	contract	contract	VB
18637	339	24	to	to	IN
18637	339	25	the	the	DT
18637	339	26	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	339	27	of	of	IN
18637	339	28	employees	employee	NNS
18637	339	29	to	to	TO
18637	339	30	organize	organize	VB
18637	339	31	,	,	,
18637	339	32	but	but	CC
18637	339	33	intimated	intimate	VBD
18637	339	34	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	339	35	that	that	IN
18637	339	36	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	339	37	in	in	IN
18637	339	38	some	some	DT
18637	339	39	of	of	IN
18637	339	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	339	41	phases	phase	NNS
18637	339	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	339	43	much	much	RB
18637	339	44	more	more	RBR
18637	339	45	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	339	46	upon	upon	IN
18637	339	47	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	339	48	implementation	implementation	NN
18637	339	49	that	that	IN
18637	339	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	339	51	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	339	52	protection	protection	NN
18637	339	53	.	.	.
18637	340	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	340	2	72	72	CD
18637	340	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	340	4	In	in	IN
18637	340	5	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	340	6	to	to	IN
18637	340	7	this	this	DT
18637	340	8	withdrawal	withdrawal	NN
18637	340	9	,	,	,
18637	340	10	however	however	RB
18637	340	11	,	,	,
18637	340	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	340	13	been	be	VBN
18637	340	14	the	the	DT
18637	340	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	340	16	's	's	POS
18637	340	17	projection	projection	NN
18637	340	18	of	of	IN
18637	340	19	another	another	DT
18637	340	20	segment	segment	NN
18637	340	21	of	of	IN
18637	340	22	"	"	``
18637	340	23	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	340	24	"	"	''
18637	340	25	into	into	IN
18637	340	26	new	new	JJ
18637	340	27	territory	territory	NN
18637	340	28	.	.	.
18637	341	1	In	in	IN
18637	341	2	Gitlow	Gitlow	NNP
18637	341	3	_	_	NNP
18637	341	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	341	5	_	_	NNP
18637	341	6	New	New	NNP
18637	341	7	York,[73	York,[73	NNP
18637	341	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	341	9	decided	decide	VBD
18637	341	10	in	in	IN
18637	341	11	1925	1925	CD
18637	341	12	,	,	,
18637	341	13	even	even	RB
18637	341	14	in	in	IN
18637	341	15	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	341	16	an	an	DT
18637	341	17	antisyndicalist	antisyndicalist	NN
18637	341	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	341	19	,	,	,
18637	341	20	the	the	DT
18637	341	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	341	22	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	341	23	_	_	NNP
18637	341	24	arguendo	arguendo	JJ
18637	341	25	_	_	NNP
18637	341	26	the	the	DT
18637	341	27	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	341	28	which	which	WDT
18637	341	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	341	30	had	have	VBD
18637	341	31	previously	previously	RB
18637	341	32	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	341	33	,	,	,
18637	341	34	that	that	IN
18637	341	35	"	"	``
18637	341	36	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	341	37	"	"	''
18637	341	38	in	in	IN
18637	341	39	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	341	40	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	341	41	renders	render	NNS
18637	341	42	available	available	JJ
18637	341	43	against	against	IN
18637	341	44	the	the	DT
18637	341	45	States	States	NNPS
18637	341	46	the	the	DT
18637	341	47	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	341	48	which	which	WDT
18637	341	49	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	341	50	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	341	51	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	341	52	on	on	IN
18637	341	53	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	341	54	.	.	.
18637	342	1	For	for	IN
18637	342	2	fifteen	fifteen	CD
18637	342	3	years	year	NNS
18637	342	4	little	little	JJ
18637	342	5	happened	happen	VBD
18637	342	6	.	.	.
18637	343	1	Then	then	RB
18637	343	2	in	in	IN
18637	343	3	1940	1940	CD
18637	343	4	,	,	,
18637	343	5	the	the	DT
18637	343	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	343	7	supplemented	supplement	VBD
18637	343	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	343	9	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	343	10	in	in	IN
18637	343	11	the	the	DT
18637	343	12	Gitlow	Gitlow	NNP
18637	343	13	Case	Case	NNP
18637	343	14	with	with	IN
18637	343	15	the	the	DT
18637	343	16	so	so	RB
18637	343	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	343	18	called	call	VBN
18637	343	19	"	"	``
18637	343	20	Clear	Clear	NNP
18637	343	21	and	and	CC
18637	343	22	Present	Present	NNP
18637	343	23	Danger	Danger	NNP
18637	343	24	"	"	''
18637	343	25	rule	rule	NN
18637	343	26	,	,	,
18637	343	27	an	an	DT
18637	343	28	expedient	expedient	NN
18637	343	29	which	which	WDT
18637	343	30	was	be	VBD
18637	343	31	designed	design	VBN
18637	343	32	to	to	IN
18637	343	33	divest	divest	NN
18637	343	34	state	state	NN
18637	343	35	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	343	36	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	343	37	of	of	IN
18637	343	38	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	343	39	of	of	IN
18637	343	40	speech	speech	NN
18637	343	41	,	,	,
18637	343	42	of	of	IN
18637	343	43	press	press	NN
18637	343	44	,	,	,
18637	343	45	of	of	IN
18637	343	46	religion	religion	NN
18637	343	47	,	,	,
18637	343	48	and	and	CC
18637	343	49	so	so	RB
18637	343	50	forth	forth	RB
18637	343	51	,	,	,
18637	343	52	of	of	IN
18637	343	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	343	54	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	343	55	validity	validity	NN
18637	343	56	,	,	,
18637	343	57	just	just	RB
18637	343	58	as	as	IN
18637	343	59	,	,	,
18637	343	60	earlier	early	RBR
18637	343	61	,	,	,
18637	343	62	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	343	63	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	343	64	of	of	IN
18637	343	65	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	343	66	of	of	IN
18637	343	67	contract	contract	NN
18637	343	68	had	have	VBD
18637	343	69	been	be	VBN
18637	343	70	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	343	71	disabled	disabled	JJ
18637	343	72	.	.	.
18637	344	1	By	by	IN
18637	344	2	certain	certain	JJ
18637	344	3	of	of	IN
18637	344	4	the	the	DT
18637	344	5	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	344	6	,	,	,
18637	344	7	this	this	DT
18637	344	8	result	result	NN
18637	344	9	was	be	VBD
18637	344	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	344	11	to	to	TO
18637	344	12	be	be	VB
18637	344	13	required	require	VBN
18637	344	14	by	by	IN
18637	344	15	"	"	``
18637	344	16	the	the	DT
18637	344	17	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	344	18	position	position	NN
18637	344	19	"	"	''
18637	344	20	of	of	IN
18637	344	21	some	some	DT
18637	344	22	of	of	IN
18637	344	23	these	these	DT
18637	344	24	freedoms	freedom	NNS
18637	344	25	in	in	IN
18637	344	26	the	the	DT
18637	344	27	hierarchy	hierarchy	NN
18637	344	28	of	of	IN
18637	344	29	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	344	30	values	value	NNS
18637	344	31	;	;	,
18637	344	32	an	an	DT
18637	344	33	idea	idea	NN
18637	344	34	to	to	TO
18637	344	35	which	which	WDT
18637	344	36	certain	certain	JJ
18637	344	37	other	other	JJ
18637	344	38	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	344	39	demurred	demur	VBD
18637	344	40	.	.	.
18637	345	1	The	the	DT
18637	345	2	result	result	NN
18637	345	3	to	to	IN
18637	345	4	date	date	NN
18637	345	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	345	6	been	be	VBN
18637	345	7	a	a	DT
18637	345	8	series	series	NN
18637	345	9	of	of	IN
18637	345	10	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	345	11	the	the	DT
18637	345	12	net	net	JJ
18637	345	13	product	product	NN
18637	345	14	of	of	IN
18637	345	15	which	which	WDT
18637	345	16	for	for	IN
18637	345	17	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	345	18	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	345	19	Law	Law	NNP
18637	345	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	345	21	at	at	IN
18637	345	22	this	this	DT
18637	345	23	juncture	juncture	NN
18637	345	24	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	345	25	to	to	TO
18637	345	26	estimate	estimate	VB
18637	345	27	;	;	:
18637	345	28	and	and	CC
18637	345	29	the	the	DT
18637	345	30	recent	recent	JJ
18637	345	31	decision	decision	NN
18637	345	32	in	in	IN
18637	345	33	Dennis	Dennis	NNP
18637	345	34	_	_	NNP
18637	345	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	345	36	_	_	NNP
18637	345	37	United	United	NNP
18637	345	38	States	States	NNP
18637	345	39	under	under	IN
18637	345	40	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	345	41	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	345	42	augments	augment	VBZ
18637	345	43	the	the	DT
18637	345	44	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	345	45	.	.	.
18637	346	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	346	2	74	74	CD
18637	346	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	346	4	A	a	DT
18637	346	5	passing	pass	VBG
18637	346	6	glance	glance	NN
18637	346	7	will	will	MD
18637	346	8	suffice	suffice	VB
18637	346	9	for	for	IN
18637	346	10	the	the	DT
18637	346	11	operation	operation	NN
18637	346	12	of	of	IN
18637	346	13	the	the	DT
18637	346	14	due	due	JJ
18637	346	15	process	process	NN
18637	346	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	346	17	of	of	IN
18637	346	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	346	19	V	V	NNP
18637	346	20	in	in	IN
18637	346	21	the	the	DT
18637	346	22	domain	domain	NN
18637	346	23	of	of	IN
18637	346	24	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	346	25	relations	relation	NNS
18637	346	26	and	and	CC
18637	346	27	the	the	DT
18637	346	28	War	War	NNP
18637	346	29	Power	Power	NNP
18637	346	30	.	.	.
18637	347	1	The	the	DT
18637	347	2	reader	reader	NN
18637	347	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	347	4	only	only	RB
18637	347	5	to	to	TO
18637	347	6	consult	consult	VB
18637	347	7	in	in	IN
18637	347	8	these	these	DT
18637	347	9	pages	page	NNS
18637	347	10	such	such	JJ
18637	347	11	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	347	12	as	as	IN
18637	347	13	those	those	DT
18637	347	14	in	in	IN
18637	347	15	Belmont	Belmont	NNP
18637	347	16	_	_	NNP
18637	347	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	347	18	_	_	NNP
18637	347	19	United	United	NNP
18637	347	20	States	States	NNP
18637	347	21	,	,	,
18637	347	22	Yakus	Yakus	NNP
18637	347	23	_	_	NNP
18637	347	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	347	25	_	_	NNP
18637	347	26	United	United	NNP
18637	347	27	States	States	NNP
18637	347	28	,	,	,
18637	347	29	Korematsu	Korematsu	NNP
18637	347	30	_	_	NNP
18637	347	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	347	32	_	_	NNP
18637	347	33	United	United	NNP
18637	347	34	States	States	NNP
18637	347	35	,	,	,
18637	347	36	to	to	TO
18637	347	37	be	be	VB
18637	347	38	persuaded	persuade	VBN
18637	347	39	that	that	IN
18637	347	40	even	even	RB
18637	347	41	the	the	DT
18637	347	42	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	347	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	347	44	no	no	DT
18637	347	45	exception	exception	NN
18637	347	46	to	to	IN
18637	347	47	the	the	DT
18637	347	48	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	347	49	,	,	,
18637	347	50	_	_	NNP
18637	347	51	inter	inter	NN
18637	347	52	arma	arma	NNP
18637	347	53	silent	silent	JJ
18637	347	54	leges	lex	NNS
18637	347	55	_	_	NNP
18637	347	56	.	.	.
18637	348	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	348	2	75	75	CD
18637	348	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	348	4	In	in	IN
18637	348	5	short	short	JJ
18637	348	6	,	,	,
18637	348	7	the	the	DT
18637	348	8	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	348	9	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	348	10	of	of	IN
18637	348	11	due	due	JJ
18637	348	12	process	process	NN
18637	348	13	of	of	IN
18637	348	14	law	law	NN
18637	348	15	does	do	VBZ
18637	348	16	not	not	RB
18637	348	17	today	today	NN
18637	348	18	support	support	VB
18637	348	19	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	348	20	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	348	21	in	in	IN
18637	348	22	the	the	DT
18637	348	23	field	field	NN
18637	348	24	of	of	IN
18637	348	25	social	social	JJ
18637	348	26	and	and	CC
18637	348	27	economic	economic	JJ
18637	348	28	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	348	29	in	in	IN
18637	348	30	anything	anything	NN
18637	348	31	like	like	IN
18637	348	32	the	the	DT
18637	348	33	same	same	JJ
18637	348	34	measure	measure	NN
18637	348	35	that	that	IN
18637	348	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	348	37	did	do	VBD
18637	348	38	,	,	,
18637	348	39	first	first	RB
18637	348	40	in	in	IN
18637	348	41	the	the	DT
18637	348	42	States	States	NNPS
18637	348	43	,	,	,
18637	348	44	then	then	RB
18637	348	45	through	through	IN
18637	348	46	the	the	DT
18637	348	47	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	348	48	Court	Court	NNP
18637	348	49	on	on	IN
18637	348	50	the	the	DT
18637	348	51	basis	basis	NN
18637	348	52	of	of	IN
18637	348	53	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	348	54	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	348	55	,	,	,
18637	348	56	in	in	IN
18637	348	57	the	the	DT
18637	348	58	half	half	JJ
18637	348	59	century	century	NN
18637	348	60	between	between	IN
18637	348	61	1885	1885	CD
18637	348	62	and	and	CC
18637	348	63	1935	1935	CD
18637	348	64	.	.	.
18637	349	1	But	but	CC
18637	349	2	this	this	DT
18637	349	3	fact	fact	NN
18637	349	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	349	5	not	not	RB
18637	349	6	signify	signify	VB
18637	349	7	that	that	IN
18637	349	8	the	the	DT
18637	349	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	349	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	349	11	not	not	RB
18637	349	12	,	,	,
18637	349	13	in	in	IN
18637	349	14	both	both	CC
18637	349	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	349	16	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	349	17	sense	sense	NN
18637	349	18	and	and	CC
18637	349	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	349	20	broader	broad	JJR
18637	349	21	sense	sense	NN
18637	349	22	,	,	,
18637	349	23	especially	especially	RB
18637	349	24	when	when	WRB
18637	349	25	supplemented	supplement	VBN
18637	349	26	by	by	IN
18637	349	27	the	the	DT
18637	349	28	equal	equal	JJ
18637	349	29	protection	protection	NN
18637	349	30	clause	clause	NN
18637	349	31	of	of	IN
18637	349	32	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	349	33	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	349	34	,	,	,
18637	349	35	a	a	DT
18637	349	36	still	still	RB
18637	349	37	valuable	valuable	JJ
18637	349	38	and	and	CC
18637	349	39	viable	viable	JJ
18637	349	40	source	source	NN
18637	349	41	of	of	IN
18637	349	42	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	349	43	protection	protection	NN
18637	349	44	against	against	IN
18637	349	45	parochial	parochial	JJ
18637	349	46	despotisms	despotism	NNS
18637	349	47	and	and	CC
18637	349	48	petty	petty	JJ
18637	349	49	tyrannies	tyranny	NNS
18637	349	50	.	.	.
18637	350	1	Yet	yet	RB
18637	350	2	even	even	RB
18637	350	3	in	in	IN
18637	350	4	this	this	DT
18637	350	5	respect	respect	NN
18637	350	6	,	,	,
18637	350	7	as	as	IN
18637	350	8	certain	certain	JJ
18637	350	9	recent	recent	JJ
18637	350	10	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	350	11	have	have	VBP
18637	350	12	shown	show	VBN
18637	350	13	,	,	,
18637	350	14	the	the	DT
18637	350	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	350	16	can	can	MD
18637	350	17	often	often	RB
18637	350	18	act	act	VB
18637	350	19	more	more	RBR
18637	350	20	effectively	effectively	RB
18637	350	21	on	on	IN
18637	350	22	the	the	DT
18637	350	23	basis	basis	NN
18637	350	24	of	of	IN
18637	350	25	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	350	26	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	350	27	implementing	implement	VBG
18637	350	28	the	the	DT
18637	350	29	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	350	30	than	than	IN
18637	350	31	when	when	WRB
18637	350	32	operating	operate	VBG
18637	350	33	directly	directly	RB
18637	350	34	on	on	IN
18637	350	35	the	the	DT
18637	350	36	basis	basis	NN
18637	350	37	of	of	IN
18637	350	38	the	the	DT
18637	350	39	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	350	40	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	350	41	.	.	.
18637	351	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	351	2	76	76	CD
18637	351	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	351	4	RÃ	RÃ	NNP
18637	351	5	©	©	NNP
18637	351	6	sumÃ	sumã	CD
18637	351	7	©	©	NNP
18637	351	8	Considered	consider	VBN
18637	351	9	for	for	IN
18637	351	10	the	the	DT
18637	351	11	two	two	CD
18637	351	12	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	351	13	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	351	14	of	of	IN
18637	351	15	the	the	DT
18637	351	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	351	17	of	of	IN
18637	351	18	government	government	NN
18637	351	19	and	and	CC
18637	351	20	the	the	DT
18637	351	21	liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	351	22	of	of	IN
18637	351	23	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	351	24	,	,	,
18637	351	25	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	351	26	of	of	IN
18637	351	27	the	the	DT
18637	351	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	351	29	by	by	IN
18637	351	30	the	the	DT
18637	351	31	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	351	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	351	33	falls	fall	VBZ
18637	351	34	into	into	IN
18637	351	35	four	four	CD
18637	351	36	tolerably	tolerably	RB
18637	351	37	distinguishable	distinguishable	JJ
18637	351	38	periods	period	NNS
18637	351	39	.	.	.
18637	352	1	The	the	DT
18637	352	2	first	first	JJ
18637	352	3	,	,	,
18637	352	4	which	which	WDT
18637	352	5	reaches	reach	VBZ
18637	352	6	to	to	IN
18637	352	7	the	the	DT
18637	352	8	death	death	NN
18637	352	9	of	of	IN
18637	352	10	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	352	11	,	,	,
18637	352	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	352	13	the	the	DT
18637	352	14	period	period	NN
18637	352	15	of	of	IN
18637	352	16	the	the	DT
18637	352	17	dominance	dominance	NN
18637	352	18	of	of	IN
18637	352	19	the	the	DT
18637	352	20	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	352	21	Document	Document	NNP
18637	352	22	.	.	.
18637	353	1	The	the	DT
18637	353	2	tradition	tradition	NN
18637	353	3	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	353	4	the	the	DT
18637	353	5	original	original	JJ
18637	353	6	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	353	7	of	of	IN
18637	353	8	the	the	DT
18637	353	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	353	10	was	be	VBD
18637	353	11	still	still	RB
18637	353	12	fresh	fresh	JJ
18637	353	13	,	,	,
18637	353	14	and	and	CC
18637	353	15	in	in	IN
18637	353	16	the	the	DT
18637	353	17	person	person	NN
18637	353	18	and	and	CC
18637	353	19	office	office	NN
18637	353	20	of	of	IN
18637	353	21	the	the	DT
18637	353	22	great	great	JJ
18637	353	23	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	353	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	353	25	the	the	DT
18637	353	26	intentions	intention	NNS
18637	353	27	of	of	IN
18637	353	28	the	the	DT
18637	353	29	framers	framer	NNS
18637	353	30	enjoyed	enjoy	VBD
18637	353	31	a	a	DT
18637	353	32	renewed	renew	VBN
18637	353	33	vitality	vitality	NN
18637	353	34	.	.	.
18637	354	1	This	this	DT
18637	354	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	354	3	not	not	RB
18637	354	4	to	to	TO
18637	354	5	say	say	VB
18637	354	6	that	that	IN
18637	354	7	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	354	8	did	do	VBD
18637	354	9	not	not	RB
18637	354	10	have	have	VB
18637	354	11	views	view	NNS
18637	354	12	of	of	IN
18637	354	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	354	14	own	own	JJ
18637	354	15	to	to	TO
18637	354	16	advance	advance	NN
18637	354	17	;	;	:
18637	354	18	nor	nor	CC
18637	354	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	354	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	354	21	to	to	TO
18637	354	22	say	say	VB
18637	354	23	that	that	IN
18637	354	24	the	the	DT
18637	354	25	historicity	historicity	NN
18637	354	26	of	of	IN
18637	354	27	a	a	DT
18637	354	28	particular	particular	JJ
18637	354	29	theory	theory	NN
18637	354	30	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	354	31	the	the	DT
18637	354	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	354	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	354	34	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	354	35	a	a	DT
18637	354	36	matter	matter	NN
18637	354	37	of	of	IN
18637	354	38	critical	critical	JJ
18637	354	39	concern	concern	NN
18637	354	40	save	save	IN
18637	354	41	to	to	IN
18637	354	42	students	student	NNS
18637	354	43	of	of	IN
18637	354	44	history	history	NN
18637	354	45	.	.	.
18637	355	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	355	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	355	3	only	only	RB
18637	355	4	to	to	TO
18637	355	5	say	say	VB
18637	355	6	that	that	IN
18637	355	7	the	the	DT
18637	355	8	theories	theory	NNS
18637	355	9	which	which	WDT
18637	355	10	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	355	11	urged	urge	VBD
18637	355	12	in	in	IN
18637	355	13	support	support	NN
18637	355	14	of	of	IN
18637	355	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	355	16	preferences	preference	NNS
18637	355	17	were	be	VBD
18637	355	18	,	,	,
18637	355	19	in	in	IN
18637	355	20	fact	fact	NN
18637	355	21	,	,	,
18637	355	22	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	355	23	verifiable	verifiable	JJ
18637	355	24	as	as	IN
18637	355	25	theories	theory	NNS
18637	355	26	of	of	IN
18637	355	27	the	the	DT
18637	355	28	framers	framer	NNS
18637	355	29	of	of	IN
18637	355	30	the	the	DT
18637	355	31	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	355	32	.	.	.
18637	356	1	The	the	DT
18637	356	2	second	second	JJ
18637	356	3	period	period	NN
18637	356	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	356	5	a	a	DT
18637	356	6	lengthy	lengthy	JJ
18637	356	7	one	one	NN
18637	356	8	,	,	,
18637	356	9	stretching	stretch	VBG
18637	356	10	from	from	IN
18637	356	11	the	the	DT
18637	356	12	accession	accession	NN
18637	356	13	of	of	IN
18637	356	14	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	356	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	356	16	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	356	17	in	in	IN
18637	356	18	1835	1835	CD
18637	356	19	to	to	IN
18637	356	20	,	,	,
18637	356	21	say	say	VB
18637	356	22	,	,	,
18637	356	23	1895	1895	CD
18637	356	24	.	.	.
18637	357	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	357	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	357	3	the	the	DT
18637	357	4	period	period	NN
18637	357	5	_	_	NNP
18637	357	6	par	par	NN
18637	357	7	excellence	excellence	NN
18637	357	8	_	_	NNP
18637	357	9	of	of	IN
18637	357	10	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	357	11	Theory	Theory	NNP
18637	357	12	.	.	.
18637	358	1	More	More	JJR
18637	358	2	and	and	CC
18637	358	3	more	more	RBR
18637	358	4	the	the	DT
18637	358	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	358	6	text	text	NN
18637	358	7	fades	fade	NNS
18637	358	8	into	into	IN
18637	358	9	the	the	DT
18637	358	10	background	background	NN
18637	358	11	,	,	,
18637	358	12	and	and	CC
18637	358	13	the	the	DT
18637	358	14	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	358	15	of	of	IN
18637	358	16	the	the	DT
18637	358	17	_	_	NNP
18637	358	18	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	358	19	_	_	NNP
18637	358	20	,	,	,
18637	358	21	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	358	22	's	's	POS
18637	358	23	sole	sole	JJ
18637	358	24	book	book	NN
18637	358	25	of	of	IN
18637	358	26	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	358	27	,	,	,
18637	358	28	ceases	cease	VBZ
18637	358	29	to	to	TO
18637	358	30	be	be	VB
18637	358	31	cited	cite	VBN
18637	358	32	.	.	.
18637	359	1	Among	among	IN
18637	359	2	the	the	DT
18637	359	3	theories	theory	NNS
18637	359	4	which	which	WDT
18637	359	5	in	in	IN
18637	359	6	one	one	CD
18637	359	7	way	way	NN
18637	359	8	or	or	CC
18637	359	9	other	other	JJ
18637	359	10	received	receive	VBD
18637	359	11	the	the	DT
18637	359	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	359	13	's	's	POS
18637	359	14	approval	approval	NN
18637	359	15	during	during	IN
18637	359	16	this	this	DT
18637	359	17	period	period	NN
18637	359	18	were	be	VBD
18637	359	19	the	the	DT
18637	359	20	notion	notion	NN
18637	359	21	of	of	IN
18637	359	22	Dual	Dual	NNP
18637	359	23	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	359	24	,	,	,
18637	359	25	the	the	DT
18637	359	26	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	359	27	of	of	IN
18637	359	28	the	the	DT
18637	359	29	Police	Police	NNP
18637	359	30	Power	Power	NNP
18637	359	31	,	,	,
18637	359	32	the	the	DT
18637	359	33	taboo	taboo	NN
18637	359	34	on	on	IN
18637	359	35	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	359	36	of	of	IN
18637	359	37	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	359	38	power	power	NN
18637	359	39	,	,	,
18637	359	40	the	the	DT
18637	359	41	derived	derive	VBN
18637	359	42	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	359	43	of	of	IN
18637	359	44	Due	Due	NNP
18637	359	45	Process	Process	NNP
18637	359	46	of	of	IN
18637	359	47	Law	Law	NNP
18637	359	48	,	,	,
18637	359	49	the	the	DT
18637	359	50	conception	conception	NN
18637	359	51	of	of	IN
18637	359	52	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	359	53	as	as	IN
18637	359	54	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	359	55	of	of	IN
18637	359	56	Contract	Contract	NNP
18637	359	57	,	,	,
18637	359	58	and	and	CC
18637	359	59	still	still	RB
18637	359	60	others	other	NNS
18637	359	61	.	.	.
18637	360	1	The	the	DT
18637	360	2	sources	source	NNS
18637	360	3	of	of	IN
18637	360	4	some	some	DT
18637	360	5	of	of	IN
18637	360	6	these	these	DT
18637	360	7	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	360	8	and	and	CC
18637	360	9	the	the	DT
18637	360	10	nature	nature	NN
18637	360	11	of	of	IN
18637	360	12	the	the	DT
18637	360	13	interests	interest	NNS
18637	360	14	benefited	benefit	VBN
18637	360	15	by	by	IN
18637	360	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	360	17	have	have	VBP
18637	360	18	been	be	VBN
18637	360	19	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	360	20	earlier	early	RBR
18637	360	21	in	in	IN
18637	360	22	these	these	DT
18637	360	23	pages	page	NNS
18637	360	24	.	.	.
18637	361	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	361	2	net	net	JJ
18637	361	3	result	result	NN
18637	361	4	was	be	VBD
18637	361	5	to	to	TO
18637	361	6	put	put	VB
18637	361	7	the	the	DT
18637	361	8	national	national	JJ
18637	361	9	law	law	NN
18637	361	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	361	11	making	make	VBG
18637	361	12	power	power	NN
18637	361	13	into	into	IN
18637	361	14	a	a	DT
18637	361	15	strait	strait	NN
18637	361	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	361	17	jacket	jacket	NN
18637	361	18	so	so	RB
18637	361	19	far	far	RB
18637	361	20	as	as	IN
18637	361	21	the	the	DT
18637	361	22	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	361	23	of	of	IN
18637	361	24	business	business	NN
18637	361	25	was	be	VBD
18637	361	26	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	361	27	.	.	.
18637	362	1	The	the	DT
18637	362	2	third	third	JJ
18637	362	3	period	period	NN
18637	362	4	was	be	VBD
18637	362	5	that	that	DT
18637	362	6	of	of	IN
18637	362	7	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	362	8	Review	Review	NNP
18637	362	9	pure	pure	JJ
18637	362	10	and	and	CC
18637	362	11	simple	simple	JJ
18637	362	12	.	.	.
18637	363	1	The	the	DT
18637	363	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	363	3	,	,	,
18637	363	4	as	as	IN
18637	363	5	heir	heir	NN
18637	363	6	to	to	IN
18637	363	7	the	the	DT
18637	363	8	accumulated	accumulate	VBN
18637	363	9	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	363	10	of	of	IN
18637	363	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	363	12	predecessors	predecessor	NNS
18637	363	13	,	,	,
18637	363	14	found	find	VBD
18637	363	15	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	363	16	for	for	IN
18637	363	17	the	the	DT
18637	363	18	time	time	NN
18637	363	19	being	be	VBG
18637	363	20	in	in	IN
18637	363	21	possession	possession	NN
18637	363	22	of	of	IN
18637	363	23	such	such	PDT
18637	363	24	a	a	DT
18637	363	25	variety	variety	NN
18637	363	26	of	of	IN
18637	363	27	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	363	28	of	of	IN
18637	363	29	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	363	30	exegesis	exegesis	NN
18637	363	31	that	that	IN
18637	363	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	363	33	was	be	VBD
18637	363	34	often	often	RB
18637	363	35	able	able	JJ
18637	363	36	to	to	TO
18637	363	37	achieve	achieve	VB
18637	363	38	almost	almost	RB
18637	363	39	any	any	DT
18637	363	40	result	result	NN
18637	363	41	in	in	IN
18637	363	42	the	the	DT
18637	363	43	field	field	NN
18637	363	44	of	of	IN
18637	363	45	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	363	46	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	363	47	which	which	WDT
18637	363	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	363	49	considered	consider	VBD
18637	363	50	desirable	desirable	JJ
18637	363	51	,	,	,
18637	363	52	and	and	CC
18637	363	53	that	that	IN
18637	363	54	without	without	IN
18637	363	55	flagrant	flagrant	JJ
18637	363	56	departure	departure	NN
18637	363	57	from	from	IN
18637	363	58	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	363	59	good	good	JJ
18637	363	60	form	form	NN
18637	363	61	.	.	.
18637	364	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	364	2	,	,	,
18637	364	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	364	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	364	5	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	364	6	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	364	7	that	that	IN
18637	364	8	the	the	DT
18637	364	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	364	10	was	be	VBD
18637	364	11	in	in	IN
18637	364	12	actual	actual	JJ
18637	364	13	possession	possession	NN
18637	364	14	and	and	CC
18637	364	15	in	in	IN
18637	364	16	active	active	JJ
18637	364	17	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	364	18	of	of	IN
18637	364	19	what	what	WP
18637	364	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	364	21	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	364	22	once	once	RB
18637	364	23	termed	term	VBD
18637	364	24	"	"	``
18637	364	25	the	the	DT
18637	364	26	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	364	27	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	364	28	of	of	IN
18637	364	29	choice	choice	NN
18637	364	30	.	.	.
18637	364	31	"	"	''
18637	365	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	365	2	was	be	VBD
18637	365	3	early	early	JJ
18637	365	4	in	in	IN
18637	365	5	this	this	DT
18637	365	6	period	period	NN
18637	365	7	that	that	IN
18637	365	8	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	365	9	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	365	10	,	,	,
18637	365	11	soon	soon	RB
18637	365	12	to	to	TO
18637	365	13	ascend	ascend	VB
18637	365	14	the	the	DT
18637	365	15	Bench	Bench	NNP
18637	365	16	,	,	,
18637	365	17	said	say	VBD
18637	365	18	,	,	,
18637	365	19	without	without	IN
18637	365	20	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	365	21	intending	intend	VBG
18637	365	22	all	all	DT
18637	365	23	that	that	WDT
18637	365	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	365	25	words	word	NNS
18637	365	26	literally	literally	RB
18637	365	27	conveyed	convey	VBN
18637	365	28	,	,	,
18637	365	29	"	"	``
18637	365	30	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	365	31	are	be	VBP
18637	365	32	under	under	IN
18637	365	33	a	a	DT
18637	365	34	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	365	35	,	,	,
18637	365	36	but	but	CC
18637	365	37	the	the	DT
18637	365	38	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	365	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	365	40	what	what	WP
18637	365	41	the	the	DT
18637	365	42	judges	judge	NNS
18637	365	43	say	say	VBP
18637	365	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	365	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	365	46	.	.	.
18637	365	47	"	"	''
18637	366	1	A	a	DT
18637	366	2	decade	decade	NN
18637	366	3	later	later	RBR
18637	366	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	366	5	was	be	VBD
18637	366	6	suggested	suggest	VBN
18637	366	7	by	by	IN
18637	366	8	an	an	DT
18637	366	9	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	366	10	law	law	NN
18637	366	11	teacher	teacher	NN
18637	366	12	that	that	WDT
18637	366	13	attorneys	attorney	NNS
18637	366	14	arguing	argue	VBG
18637	366	15	"	"	``
18637	366	16	due	due	JJ
18637	366	17	process	process	NN
18637	366	18	cases	case	NNS
18637	366	19	"	"	''
18637	366	20	before	before	IN
18637	366	21	the	the	DT
18637	366	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	366	23	ought	ought	MD
18637	366	24	to	to	TO
18637	366	25	address	address	VB
18637	366	26	the	the	DT
18637	366	27	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	366	28	not	not	RB
18637	366	29	as	as	IN
18637	366	30	"	"	``
18637	366	31	Your	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	366	32	Honors	honor	NNS
18637	366	33	"	"	''
18637	366	34	but	but	CC
18637	366	35	as	as	IN
18637	366	36	"	"	``
18637	366	37	Your	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	366	38	Lordships	lordship	NNS
18637	366	39	"	"	''
18637	366	40	;	;	:
18637	366	41	and	and	CC
18637	366	42	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	366	43	Borah	Borah	NNP
18637	366	44	,	,	,
18637	366	45	in	in	IN
18637	366	46	the	the	DT
18637	366	47	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	366	48	debate	debate	NN
18637	366	49	on	on	IN
18637	366	50	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	366	51	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	366	52	'	'	POS
18637	366	53	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	366	54	for	for	IN
18637	366	55	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	366	56	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	366	57	,	,	,
18637	366	58	in	in	IN
18637	366	59	1930	1930	CD
18637	366	60	,	,	,
18637	366	61	declared	declare	VBD
18637	366	62	that	that	IN
18637	366	63	the	the	DT
18637	366	64	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	366	65	Court	Court	NNP
18637	366	66	had	have	VBD
18637	366	67	become	become	VBN
18637	366	68	"	"	``
18637	366	69	economic	economic	JJ
18637	366	70	dictator	dictator	NN
18637	366	71	in	in	IN
18637	366	72	the	the	DT
18637	366	73	United	United	NNP
18637	366	74	States	States	NNP
18637	366	75	"	"	''
18637	366	76	.	.	.
18637	367	1	Some	some	DT
18637	367	2	of	of	IN
18637	367	3	the	the	DT
18637	367	4	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	367	5	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	367	6	in	in	IN
18637	367	7	these	these	DT
18637	367	8	observations	observation	NNS
18637	367	9	,	,	,
18637	367	10	especially	especially	RB
18637	367	11	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	367	12	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	367	13	and	and	CC
18637	367	14	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	367	15	.	.	.
18637	368	1	Asserted	asserted	VB
18637	368	2	the	the	DT
18637	368	3	latter	latter	JJ
18637	368	4	,	,	,
18637	368	5	the	the	DT
18637	368	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	368	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	368	8	made	make	VBN
18637	368	9	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	368	10	"	"	``
18637	368	11	a	a	DT
18637	368	12	super	super	JJ
18637	368	13	-	-	JJ
18637	368	14	legislature	legislature	JJ
18637	368	15	"	"	''
18637	368	16	and	and	CC
18637	368	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	368	18	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	368	19	could	could	MD
18637	368	20	discover	discover	VB
18637	368	21	"	"	``
18637	368	22	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	368	23	any	any	DT
18637	368	24	limit	limit	NN
18637	368	25	but	but	CC
18637	368	26	the	the	DT
18637	368	27	sky	sky	NN
18637	368	28	"	"	''
18637	368	29	to	to	IN
18637	368	30	the	the	DT
18637	368	31	power	power	NN
18637	368	32	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	368	33	by	by	IN
18637	368	34	the	the	DT
18637	368	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	368	36	to	to	TO
18637	368	37	disallow	disallow	VB
18637	368	38	State	state	NN
18637	368	39	acts	act	NNS
18637	368	40	"	"	``
18637	368	41	which	which	WDT
18637	368	42	may	may	MD
18637	368	43	happen	happen	VB
18637	368	44	to	to	TO
18637	368	45	strike	strike	VB
18637	368	46	a	a	DT
18637	368	47	majority	majority	NN
18637	368	48	[	[	-LRB-
18637	368	49	of	of	IN
18637	368	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	368	51	members	member	NNS
18637	368	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	368	53	as	as	IN
18637	368	54	for	for	IN
18637	368	55	any	any	DT
18637	368	56	reason	reason	NN
18637	368	57	undesirable	undesirable	JJ
18637	368	58	"	"	''
18637	368	59	.	.	.
18637	369	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	369	2	77	77	CD
18637	369	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	369	4	The	the	DT
18637	369	5	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	369	6	period	period	NN
18637	369	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	369	8	still	still	RB
18637	369	9	with	with	IN
18637	369	10	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	369	11	.	.	.
18637	370	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	370	2	was	be	VBD
18637	370	3	ushered	usher	VBN
18637	370	4	in	in	RP
18637	370	5	by	by	IN
18637	370	6	World	World	NNP
18637	370	7	War	War	NNP
18637	370	8	I	I	NNP
18637	370	9	,	,	,
18637	370	10	but	but	CC
18637	370	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	370	12	results	result	NNS
18637	370	13	were	be	VBD
18637	370	14	consolidated	consolidate	VBN
18637	370	15	and	and	CC
18637	370	16	extended	extend	VBN
18637	370	17	during	during	IN
18637	370	18	the	the	DT
18637	370	19	1930	1930	CD
18637	370	20	's	's	POS
18637	370	21	,	,	,
18637	370	22	and	and	CC
18637	370	23	have	have	VBP
18637	370	24	been	be	VBN
18637	370	25	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	370	26	still	still	RB
18637	370	27	further	further	RB
18637	370	28	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
18637	370	29	and	and	CC
18637	370	30	confirmed	confirm	VBN
18637	370	31	by	by	IN
18637	370	32	World	World	NNP
18637	370	33	War	War	NNP
18637	370	34	II	II	NNP
18637	370	35	and	and	CC
18637	370	36	the	the	DT
18637	370	37	"	"	``
18637	370	38	cold	cold	JJ
18637	370	39	war	war	NN
18637	370	40	"	"	''
18637	370	41	.	.	.
18637	371	1	Many	many	JJ
18637	371	2	of	of	IN
18637	371	3	these	these	DT
18637	371	4	results	result	NNS
18637	371	5	have	have	VBP
18637	371	6	been	be	VBN
18637	371	7	treated	treat	VBN
18637	371	8	above	above	RB
18637	371	9	.	.	.
18637	372	1	Others	other	NNS
18637	372	2	can	can	MD
18637	372	3	be	be	VB
18637	372	4	searched	search	VBN
18637	372	5	out	out	RP
18637	372	6	in	in	IN
18637	372	7	the	the	DT
18637	372	8	pages	page	NNS
18637	372	9	of	of	IN
18637	372	10	this	this	DT
18637	372	11	volume	volume	NN
18637	372	12	.	.	.
18637	373	1	What	what	WP
18637	373	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	373	3	sum	sum	VBP
18637	373	4	up	up	RP
18637	373	5	to	to	IN
18637	373	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	373	7	this	this	DT
18637	373	8	:	:	:
18637	373	9	that	that	IN
18637	373	10	what	what	WP
18637	373	11	was	be	VBD
18637	373	12	once	once	RB
18637	373	13	vaunted	vaunt	VBN
18637	373	14	as	as	IN
18637	373	15	a	a	DT
18637	373	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	373	17	of	of	IN
18637	373	18	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	373	19	,	,	,
18637	373	20	both	both	DT
18637	373	21	State	State	NNP
18637	373	22	rights	right	NNS
18637	373	23	and	and	CC
18637	373	24	private	private	JJ
18637	373	25	rights	right	NNS
18637	373	26	,	,	,
18637	373	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	373	28	been	be	VBN
18637	373	29	replaced	replace	VBN
18637	373	30	to	to	IN
18637	373	31	a	a	DT
18637	373	32	great	great	JJ
18637	373	33	extent	extent	NN
18637	373	34	by	by	IN
18637	373	35	a	a	DT
18637	373	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	373	37	of	of	IN
18637	373	38	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	373	39	.	.	.
18637	374	1	The	the	DT
18637	374	2	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	374	3	System	System	NNP
18637	374	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	374	5	shifted	shift	VBN
18637	374	6	base	base	NN
18637	374	7	in	in	IN
18637	374	8	the	the	DT
18637	374	9	direction	direction	NN
18637	374	10	of	of	IN
18637	374	11	a	a	DT
18637	374	12	consolidated	consolidated	JJ
18637	374	13	national	national	JJ
18637	374	14	power	power	NN
18637	374	15	;	;	:
18637	374	16	within	within	IN
18637	374	17	the	the	DT
18637	374	18	National	National	NNP
18637	374	19	Government	Government	NNP
18637	374	20	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	374	21	there	there	EX
18637	374	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	374	23	been	be	VBN
18637	374	24	an	an	DT
18637	374	25	increased	increase	VBN
18637	374	26	flow	flow	NN
18637	374	27	of	of	IN
18637	374	28	power	power	NN
18637	374	29	in	in	IN
18637	374	30	the	the	DT
18637	374	31	direction	direction	NN
18637	374	32	of	of	IN
18637	374	33	the	the	DT
18637	374	34	President	President	NNP
18637	374	35	;	;	:
18637	374	36	even	even	RB
18637	374	37	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	374	38	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	374	39	of	of	IN
18637	374	40	the	the	DT
18637	374	41	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	374	42	of	of	IN
18637	374	43	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	374	44	has	have	VBZ
18637	374	45	faltered	falter	VBN
18637	374	46	at	at	IN
18637	374	47	times	time	NNS
18637	374	48	,	,	,
18637	374	49	in	in	IN
18637	374	50	the	the	DT
18637	374	51	presence	presence	NN
18637	374	52	of	of	IN
18637	374	53	national	national	JJ
18637	374	54	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	374	55	.	.	.
18637	375	1	In	in	IN
18637	375	2	this	this	DT
18637	375	3	situation	situation	NN
18637	375	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	375	5	review	review	NN
18637	375	6	as	as	IN
18637	375	7	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	375	8	by	by	IN
18637	375	9	the	the	DT
18637	375	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	375	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	375	12	does	do	VBZ
18637	375	13	not	not	RB
18637	375	14	cease	cease	VB
18637	375	15	being	be	VBG
18637	375	16	an	an	DT
18637	375	17	important	important	JJ
18637	375	18	technique	technique	NN
18637	375	19	of	of	IN
18637	375	20	government	government	NN
18637	375	21	under	under	IN
18637	375	22	the	the	DT
18637	375	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	375	24	,	,	,
18637	375	25	but	but	CC
18637	375	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	375	27	field	field	NN
18637	375	28	of	of	IN
18637	375	29	operation	operation	NN
18637	375	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	375	31	contracted	contract	VBN
18637	375	32	.	.	.
18637	376	1	The	the	DT
18637	376	2	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	376	3	which	which	WDT
18637	376	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	376	5	serves	serve	VBZ
18637	376	6	more	more	RBR
18637	376	7	and	and	CC
18637	376	8	more	more	RBR
18637	376	9	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	376	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	376	11	the	the	DT
18637	376	12	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	376	13	for	for	IN
18637	376	14	which	which	WDT
18637	376	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	376	16	was	be	VBD
18637	376	17	originally	originally	RB
18637	376	18	created	create	VBN
18637	376	19	to	to	TO
18637	376	20	serve	serve	VB
18637	376	21	,	,	,
18637	376	22	the	the	DT
18637	376	23	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	376	24	of	of	IN
18637	376	25	the	the	DT
18637	376	26	principle	principle	NN
18637	376	27	of	of	IN
18637	376	28	National	National	NNP
18637	376	29	Supremacy	Supremacy	NNP
18637	376	30	.	.	.
18637	377	1	But	but	CC
18637	377	2	in	in	IN
18637	377	3	fact	fact	NN
18637	377	4	,	,	,
18637	377	5	this	this	DT
18637	377	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	377	7	the	the	DT
18637	377	8	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	377	9	which	which	WDT
18637	377	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	377	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	377	12	always	always	RB
18637	377	13	served	serve	VBN
18637	377	14	predominantly	predominantly	RB
18637	377	15	,	,	,
18637	377	16	even	even	RB
18637	377	17	in	in	IN
18637	377	18	the	the	DT
18637	377	19	era	era	NN
18637	377	20	when	when	WRB
18637	377	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	377	22	was	be	VBD
18637	377	23	cutting	cut	VBG
18637	377	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	377	25	widest	wide	JJS
18637	377	26	swathe	swathe	NN
18637	377	27	in	in	IN
18637	377	28	the	the	DT
18637	377	29	field	field	NN
18637	377	30	of	of	IN
18637	377	31	national	national	JJ
18637	377	32	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	377	33	policy	policy	NN
18637	377	34	,	,	,
18637	377	35	the	the	DT
18637	377	36	period	period	NN
18637	377	37	from	from	IN
18637	377	38	1895	1895	CD
18637	377	39	to	to	IN
18637	377	40	1935	1935	CD
18637	377	41	.	.	.
18637	378	1	Even	even	RB
18637	378	2	then	then	RB
18637	378	3	there	there	EX
18637	378	4	was	be	VBD
18637	378	5	a	a	DT
18637	378	6	multiplicity	multiplicity	NN
18637	378	7	of	of	IN
18637	378	8	state	state	NN
18637	378	9	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	378	10	and	and	CC
18637	378	11	only	only	RB
18637	378	12	one	one	CD
18637	378	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	378	14	,	,	,
18637	378	15	so	so	IN
18637	378	16	that	that	IN
18637	378	17	the	the	DT
18637	378	18	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	378	19	grist	grist	NN
18637	378	20	that	that	WDT
18637	378	21	found	find	VBD
18637	378	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	378	23	way	way	NN
18637	378	24	to	to	IN
18637	378	25	the	the	DT
18637	378	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	378	27	's	's	POS
18637	378	28	mill	mill	NN
18637	378	29	was	be	VBD
18637	378	30	overwhelmingly	overwhelmingly	RB
18637	378	31	of	of	IN
18637	378	32	local	local	JJ
18637	378	33	provenience	provenience	NN
18637	378	34	.	.	.
18637	379	1	And	and	CC
18637	379	2	since	since	IN
18637	379	3	then	then	RB
18637	379	4	several	several	JJ
18637	379	5	things	thing	NNS
18637	379	6	have	have	VBP
18637	379	7	happened	happen	VBN
18637	379	8	to	to	TO
18637	379	9	confirm	confirm	VB
18637	379	10	this	this	DT
18637	379	11	predominance	predominance	NN
18637	379	12	:	:	:
18637	379	13	first	first	RB
18637	379	14	,	,	,
18637	379	15	the	the	DT
18637	379	16	annexation	annexation	NN
18637	379	17	to	to	IN
18637	379	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	379	19	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	379	20	of	of	IN
18637	379	21	much	much	JJ
18637	379	22	of	of	IN
18637	379	23	the	the	DT
18637	379	24	content	content	NN
18637	379	25	of	of	IN
18637	379	26	the	the	DT
18637	379	27	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	379	28	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	379	29	of	of	IN
18637	379	30	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	379	31	;	;	:
18637	379	32	secondly	secondly	RB
18637	379	33	,	,	,
18637	379	34	the	the	DT
18637	379	35	extension	extension	NN
18637	379	36	of	of	IN
18637	379	37	national	national	JJ
18637	379	38	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	379	39	power	power	NN
18637	379	40	,	,	,
18637	379	41	especially	especially	RB
18637	379	42	along	along	IN
18637	379	43	the	the	DT
18637	379	44	route	route	NN
18637	379	45	of	of	IN
18637	379	46	the	the	DT
18637	379	47	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	379	48	clause	clause	NNP
18637	379	49	,	,	,
18637	379	50	into	into	IN
18637	379	51	the	the	DT
18637	379	52	field	field	NN
18637	379	53	of	of	IN
18637	379	54	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	379	55	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	379	56	,	,	,
18637	379	57	with	with	IN
18637	379	58	the	the	DT
18637	379	59	result	result	NN
18637	379	60	of	of	IN
18637	379	61	touching	touching	JJ
18637	379	62	state	state	NN
18637	379	63	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	379	64	power	power	NN
18637	379	65	on	on	IN
18637	379	66	many	many	JJ
18637	379	67	more	more	JJR
18637	379	68	fronts	front	NNS
18637	379	69	than	than	IN
18637	379	70	ever	ever	RB
18637	379	71	before	before	RB
18637	379	72	;	;	:
18637	379	73	thirdly	thirdly	RB
18637	379	74	,	,	,
18637	379	75	the	the	DT
18637	379	76	integration	integration	NN
18637	379	77	of	of	IN
18637	379	78	the	the	DT
18637	379	79	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	379	80	's	's	POS
18637	379	81	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	379	82	life	life	NN
18637	379	83	,	,	,
18637	379	84	which	which	WDT
18637	379	85	has	have	VBZ
18637	379	86	brought	bring	VBN
18637	379	87	to	to	IN
18637	379	88	the	the	DT
18637	379	89	National	National	NNP
18637	379	90	Government	Government	NNP
18637	379	91	a	a	DT
18637	379	92	major	major	JJ
18637	379	93	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	379	94	for	for	IN
18637	379	95	the	the	DT
18637	379	96	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	379	97	of	of	IN
18637	379	98	a	a	DT
18637	379	99	functioning	function	VBG
18637	379	100	social	social	JJ
18637	379	101	order	order	NN
18637	379	102	.	.	.
18637	380	1	Forty	forty	CD
18637	380	2	years	year	NNS
18637	380	3	ago	ago	RB
18637	380	4	the	the	DT
18637	380	5	late	late	JJ
18637	380	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	380	7	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	380	8	said	say	VBD
18637	380	9	:	:	:
18637	380	10	"	"	``
18637	380	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	380	12	do	do	VBP
18637	380	13	not	not	RB
18637	380	14	think	think	VB
18637	380	15	the	the	DT
18637	380	16	United	United	NNP
18637	380	17	States	States	NNP
18637	380	18	would	would	MD
18637	380	19	come	come	VB
18637	380	20	to	to	IN
18637	380	21	an	an	DT
18637	380	22	end	end	NN
18637	380	23	if	if	IN
18637	380	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	380	25	[	[	-LRB-
18637	380	26	the	the	DT
18637	380	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	380	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	380	29	lost	lose	VBD
18637	380	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	380	31	power	power	NN
18637	380	32	to	to	TO
18637	380	33	declare	declare	VB
18637	380	34	an	an	DT
18637	380	35	Act	Act	NNP
18637	380	36	of	of	IN
18637	380	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	380	38	void	void	NN
18637	380	39	.	.	.
18637	381	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	381	2	do	do	VBP
18637	381	3	think	think	VB
18637	381	4	the	the	DT
18637	381	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	381	6	would	would	MD
18637	381	7	be	be	VB
18637	381	8	imperiled	imperil	VBN
18637	381	9	if	if	IN
18637	381	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	381	11	could	could	MD
18637	381	12	not	not	RB
18637	381	13	make	make	VB
18637	381	14	that	that	DT
18637	381	15	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	381	16	as	as	IN
18637	381	17	to	to	IN
18637	381	18	the	the	DT
18637	381	19	laws	law	NNS
18637	381	20	of	of	IN
18637	381	21	the	the	DT
18637	381	22	several	several	JJ
18637	381	23	States	States	NNPS
18637	381	24	"	"	''
18637	381	25	.	.	.
18637	382	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	382	2	78	78	CD
18637	382	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	382	4	By	by	IN
18637	382	5	and	and	CC
18637	382	6	large	large	JJ
18637	382	7	,	,	,
18637	382	8	this	this	DT
18637	382	9	still	still	RB
18637	382	10	sizes	size	VBZ
18637	382	11	up	up	RP
18637	382	12	the	the	DT
18637	382	13	situation	situation	NN
18637	382	14	.	.	.
18637	383	1	Edward	Edward	NNP
18637	383	2	S.	S.	NNP
18637	383	3	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	383	4	.	.	.
18637	384	1	_	_	NNP
18637	384	2	January	January	NNP
18637	384	3	,	,	,
18637	384	4	1953	1953	CD
18637	384	5	.	.	.
18637	384	6	_	_	NNP
18637	384	7	Notes	Notes	NNP
18637	384	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	384	9	1	1	CD
18637	384	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	384	11	_	_	NNP
18637	384	12	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	384	13	.	.	.
18637	385	1	Record	Record	NNP
18637	385	2	_	_	NNP
18637	385	3	,	,	,
18637	385	4	vol	vol	NNP
18637	385	5	.	.	.
18637	386	1	23	23	CD
18637	386	2	,	,	,
18637	386	3	p.	p.	NN
18637	386	4	6516	6516	CD
18637	386	5	.	.	.
18637	387	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	387	2	2	2	CD
18637	387	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	387	4	_	_	NNP
18637	387	5	The	the	DT
18637	387	6	Genessee	Genessee	NNP
18637	387	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	387	8	_	_	NNP
18637	387	9	,	,	,
18637	387	10	12	12	CD
18637	387	11	How	how	WRB
18637	387	12	.	.	.
18637	388	1	443	443	CD
18637	388	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	388	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	388	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	388	5	,	,	,
18637	388	6	overturning	overturn	VBG
18637	388	7	_	_	NNP
18637	388	8	The	the	DT
18637	388	9	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	388	10	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	388	11	_	_	NNP
18637	388	12	,	,	,
18637	388	13	10	10	CD
18637	388	14	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	388	15	.	.	.
18637	389	1	428	428	CD
18637	389	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	389	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	389	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	389	5	.	.	.
18637	390	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	390	2	3	3	LS
18637	390	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	390	4	Knox	Knox	NNP
18637	390	5	_	_	NNP
18637	390	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	390	7	_	_	NNP
18637	390	8	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	390	9	,	,	,
18637	390	10	12	12	CD
18637	390	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	390	12	.	.	.
18637	391	1	457	457	CD
18637	391	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	391	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	391	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	391	5	;	;	:
18637	391	6	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	391	7	_	_	NNP
18637	391	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	391	9	_	_	NNP
18637	391	10	Griswold	Griswold	NNP
18637	391	11	,	,	,
18637	391	12	8	8	CD
18637	391	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	391	14	.	.	.
18637	392	1	603	603	CD
18637	392	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	392	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	392	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	392	5	.	.	.
18637	393	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	393	2	4	4	CD
18637	393	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	393	4	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	393	5	_	_	NNP
18637	393	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	393	7	_	_	NNP
18637	393	8	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	393	9	'	'	POS
18637	393	10	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	393	11	&	&	CC
18637	393	12	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	393	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	393	14	,	,	,
18637	393	15	157	157	CD
18637	393	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	393	17	429	429	CD
18637	393	18	;	;	:
18637	393	19	Same	same	JJ
18637	393	20	,	,	,
18637	393	21	158	158	CD
18637	393	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	393	23	601	601	CD
18637	393	24	.	.	.
18637	394	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	394	2	5	5	CD
18637	394	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	394	4	_	_	NNP
18637	394	5	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	394	6	.	.	.
18637	395	1	Record	Record	NNP
18637	395	2	_	_	NNP
18637	395	3	,	,	,
18637	395	4	vol	vol	NNP
18637	395	5	.	.	.
18637	396	1	78	78	CD
18637	396	2	,	,	,
18637	396	3	p.	p.	NN
18637	396	4	5358	5358	CD
18637	396	5	.	.	.
18637	397	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	397	2	6	6	CD
18637	397	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	397	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	397	5	_	_	NNP
18637	397	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	397	7	_	_	NNP
18637	397	8	Allwright	Allwright	NNP
18637	397	9	,	,	,
18637	397	10	321	321	CD
18637	397	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	397	12	649	649	CD
18637	397	13	,	,	,
18637	397	14	665	665	CD
18637	397	15	.	.	.
18637	398	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	398	2	7	7	CD
18637	398	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	398	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	398	5	.	.	.
18637	399	1	669	669	CD
18637	399	2	.	.	.
18637	400	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	400	2	8	8	CD
18637	400	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	400	4	_	_	NNP
18637	400	5	The	the	DT
18637	400	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	400	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	400	8	in	in	IN
18637	400	9	United	United	NNP
18637	400	10	States	States	NNP
18637	400	11	History	History	NNP
18637	400	12	_	_	NNP
18637	400	13	,	,	,
18637	400	14	III	III	NNP
18637	400	15	,	,	,
18637	400	16	470	470	CD
18637	400	17	-	-	CD
18637	400	18	471	471	CD
18637	400	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	400	20	1922	1922	CD
18637	400	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	400	22	.	.	.
18637	401	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	401	2	9	9	CD
18637	401	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	401	4	The	the	DT
18637	401	5	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	401	6	College	College	NNP
18637	401	7	Case	Case	NNP
18637	401	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	401	9	1819	1819	CD
18637	401	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	401	11	occupies	occupy	VBZ
18637	401	12	197	197	CD
18637	401	13	pages	page	NNS
18637	401	14	of	of	IN
18637	401	15	4	4	CD
18637	401	16	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
18637	401	17	;	;	:
18637	401	18	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	401	19	_	_	NNP
18637	401	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	401	21	_	_	NNP
18637	401	22	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	401	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	401	24	1824	1824	CD
18637	401	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	401	26	,	,	,
18637	401	27	240	240	CD
18637	401	28	pages	page	NNS
18637	401	29	of	of	IN
18637	401	30	9	9	CD
18637	401	31	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
18637	401	32	;	;	:
18637	401	33	The	the	DT
18637	401	34	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	401	35	River	River	NNP
18637	401	36	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	401	37	case	case	NN
18637	401	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	401	39	1837	1837	CD
18637	401	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	401	41	,	,	,
18637	401	42	230	230	CD
18637	401	43	pages	page	NNS
18637	401	44	of	of	IN
18637	401	45	11	11	CD
18637	401	46	Peters	Peters	NNP
18637	401	47	;	;	:
18637	401	48	the	the	DT
18637	401	49	Passenger	Passenger	NNP
18637	401	50	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	401	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	401	52	1849	1849	CD
18637	401	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	401	54	,	,	,
18637	401	55	290	290	CD
18637	401	56	pages	page	NNS
18637	401	57	of	of	IN
18637	401	58	7	7	CD
18637	401	59	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	401	60	;	;	:
18637	401	61	the	the	DT
18637	401	62	Dred	Dred	NNP
18637	401	63	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	401	64	Case	Case	NNP
18637	401	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	401	66	1857	1857	CD
18637	401	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	401	68	,	,	,
18637	401	69	240	240	CD
18637	401	70	pages	page	NNS
18637	401	71	of	of	IN
18637	401	72	19	19	CD
18637	401	73	Howard	howard	NN
18637	401	74	;	;	:
18637	401	75	_	_	NNP
18637	401	76	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	401	77	parte	parte	NN
18637	401	78	_	_	NNP
18637	401	79	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
18637	401	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	401	81	1866	1866	CD
18637	401	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	401	83	,	,	,
18637	401	84	140	140	CD
18637	401	85	pages	page	NNS
18637	401	86	of	of	IN
18637	401	87	4	4	CD
18637	401	88	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	401	89	;	;	:
18637	401	90	the	the	DT
18637	401	91	first	first	JJ
18637	401	92	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	401	93	Case	Case	NNP
18637	401	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	401	95	1895	1895	CD
18637	401	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	401	97	,	,	,
18637	401	98	325	325	CD
18637	401	99	pages	page	NNS
18637	401	100	of	of	IN
18637	401	101	157	157	CD
18637	401	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	401	103	;	;	:
18637	401	104	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	401	105	_	_	NNP
18637	401	106	v.	v.	IN
18637	401	107	_	_	NNP
18637	401	108	United	United	NNP
18637	401	109	States	States	NNP
18637	401	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	401	111	1926	1926	CD
18637	401	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	401	113	,	,	,
18637	401	114	243	243	CD
18637	401	115	pages	page	NNS
18637	401	116	of	of	IN
18637	401	117	272	272	CD
18637	401	118	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	401	119	[	[	-LRB-
18637	401	120	10	10	CD
18637	401	121	]	]	-RRB-
18637	401	122	Max	Max	NNP
18637	401	123	Farrand	Farrand	NNP
18637	401	124	,	,	,
18637	401	125	_	_	NNP
18637	401	126	The	the	DT
18637	401	127	Records	Records	NNPS
18637	401	128	of	of	IN
18637	401	129	the	the	DT
18637	401	130	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	401	131	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	401	132	of	of	IN
18637	401	133	1787	1787	CD
18637	401	134	_	_	NNP
18637	401	135	,	,	,
18637	401	136	III	III	NNP
18637	401	137	,	,	,
18637	401	138	240	240	CD
18637	401	139	-	-	HYPH
18637	401	140	241	241	CD
18637	401	141	(	(	-LRB-
18637	401	142	1911	1911	CD
18637	401	143	)	)	-RRB-
18637	401	144	.	.	.
18637	402	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	402	2	11	11	CD
18637	402	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	402	4	See	See	NNP
18637	402	5	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	402	6	's	's	POS
18637	402	7	words	word	NNS
18637	402	8	in	in	IN
18637	402	9	5	5	CD
18637	402	10	How	how	WRB
18637	402	11	.	.	.
18637	403	1	504	504	CD
18637	403	2	,	,	,
18637	403	3	573	573	CD
18637	403	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	403	5	574	574	CD
18637	403	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	403	7	1847	1847	CD
18637	403	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	403	9	,	,	,
18637	403	10	and	and	CC
18637	403	11	7	7	CD
18637	403	12	How	how	WRB
18637	403	13	.	.	.
18637	404	1	283	283	CD
18637	404	2	,	,	,
18637	404	3	465	465	CD
18637	404	4	-	-	SYM
18637	404	5	70	70	CD
18637	404	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	404	7	1849	1849	CD
18637	404	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	404	9	.	.	.
18637	405	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	405	2	12	12	CD
18637	405	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	405	4	21	21	CD
18637	405	5	How	how	WRB
18637	405	6	.	.	.
18637	406	1	506	506	CD
18637	406	2	,	,	,
18637	406	3	520	520	CD
18637	406	4	-	-	SYM
18637	406	5	521	521	CD
18637	406	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	406	7	1859	1859	CD
18637	406	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	406	9	.	.	.
18637	407	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	407	2	13	13	CD
18637	407	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	407	4	295	295	CD
18637	407	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	407	6	495	495	CD
18637	407	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	407	8	1935	1935	CD
18637	407	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	407	10	;	;	:
18637	407	11	298	298	CD
18637	407	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	407	13	238	238	CD
18637	407	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	407	15	1936	1936	CD
18637	407	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	407	17	.	.	.
18637	408	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	408	2	14	14	CD
18637	408	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	408	4	298	298	CD
18637	408	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	408	6	238	238	CD
18637	408	7	,	,	,
18637	408	8	308	308	CD
18637	408	9	-	-	SYM
18637	408	10	309	309	CD
18637	408	11	.	.	.
18637	409	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	409	2	15	15	CD
18637	409	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	409	4	312	312	CD
18637	409	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	409	6	100	100	CD
18637	409	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	409	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	409	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	409	10	.	.	.
18637	410	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	410	2	16	16	CD
18637	410	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	410	4	100	100	CD
18637	410	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	410	6	371	371	CD
18637	410	7	.	.	.
18637	411	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	411	2	17	17	CD
18637	411	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	411	4	227	227	CD
18637	411	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	411	6	308	308	CD
18637	411	7	,	,	,
18637	411	8	322	322	CD
18637	411	9	.	.	.
18637	412	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	412	2	18	18	CD
18637	412	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	412	4	Dobbins	Dobbins	NNP
18637	412	5	_	_	NNP
18637	412	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	412	7	_	_	NNP
18637	412	8	Commsrs	Commsrs	NNP
18637	412	9	.	.	NNP
18637	412	10	,	,	,
18637	412	11	16	16	CD
18637	412	12	Pet	pet	NN
18637	412	13	.	.	.
18637	413	1	435	435	CD
18637	413	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	413	3	1842	1842	CD
18637	413	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	413	5	;	;	:
18637	413	6	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	413	7	_	_	NNP
18637	413	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	413	9	_	_	NNP
18637	413	10	Day	Day	NNP
18637	413	11	,	,	,
18637	413	12	11	11	CD
18637	413	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	413	14	.	.	.
18637	414	1	113	113	CD
18637	414	2	.	.	.
18637	415	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	415	2	1870	1870	CD
18637	415	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	415	4	.	.	.
18637	416	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	416	2	19	19	CD
18637	416	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	416	4	4	4	CD
18637	416	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	416	6	.	.	.
18637	417	1	316	316	CD
18637	417	2	,	,	,
18637	417	3	431	431	CD
18637	417	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	417	5	1819	1819	CD
18637	417	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	417	7	.	.	.
18637	418	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	418	2	20	20	CD
18637	418	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	418	4	For	for	IN
18637	418	5	references	reference	NNS
18637	418	6	and	and	CC
18637	418	7	further	further	JJ
18637	418	8	details	detail	NNS
18637	418	9	,	,	,
18637	418	10	see	see	VB
18637	418	11	E.S.	E.S.	NNP
18637	419	1	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	419	2	,	,	,
18637	419	3	_	_	NNP
18637	419	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	419	5	over	over	IN
18637	419	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	419	7	_	_	NNP
18637	419	8	,	,	,
18637	419	9	129	129	CD
18637	419	10	-	-	SYM
18637	419	11	176	176	CD
18637	419	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	419	13	1938	1938	CD
18637	419	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	419	15	.	.	.
18637	420	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	420	2	21	21	CD
18637	420	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	420	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	420	5	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	420	6	's	's	POS
18637	420	7	Note	note	NN
18637	420	8	:	:	:
18637	420	9	Footnote	footnote	NN
18637	420	10	21	21	CD
18637	420	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	420	12	missing	miss	VBG
18637	420	13	from	from	IN
18637	420	14	original	original	JJ
18637	420	15	text	text	NN
18637	420	16	.	.	.
18637	420	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	421	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	421	2	22	22	CD
18637	421	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	421	4	In	in	IN
18637	421	5	this	this	DT
18637	421	6	connection	connection	NN
18637	421	7	,	,	,
18637	421	8	_	_	NNP
18637	421	9	see	see	VBP
18637	421	10	_	_	NNP
18637	421	11	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	421	12	_	_	NNP
18637	421	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	421	14	_	_	NNP
18637	421	15	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	421	16	Service	Service	NNP
18637	421	17	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	421	18	.	.	.
18637	421	19	,	,	,
18637	421	20	330	330	CD
18637	421	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	421	22	127	127	CD
18637	421	23	,	,	,
18637	421	24	142	142	CD
18637	421	25	-	-	SYM
18637	421	26	145	145	CD
18637	421	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	421	28	1947	1947	CD
18637	421	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	421	30	.	.	.
18637	422	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	422	2	23	23	CD
18637	422	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	422	4	3	3	CD
18637	422	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	422	6	.	.	.
18637	423	1	54	54	CD
18637	423	2	,	,	,
18637	423	3	74	74	CD
18637	423	4	.	.	.
18637	424	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	424	2	24	24	CD
18637	424	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	424	4	12	12	CD
18637	424	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	424	6	.	.	.
18637	425	1	457	457	CD
18637	425	2	,	,	,
18637	425	3	555	555	CD
18637	425	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	425	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	425	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	425	7	.	.	.
18637	426	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	426	2	25	25	CD
18637	426	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	426	4	130	130	CD
18637	426	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	426	6	581	581	CD
18637	426	7	,	,	,
18637	426	8	604	604	CD
18637	426	9	.	.	.
18637	427	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	427	2	26	26	CD
18637	427	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	427	4	Fong	Fong	NNP
18637	427	5	Yue	Yue	NNP
18637	427	6	Ting	Ting	NNP
18637	427	7	,	,	,
18637	427	8	149	149	CD
18637	427	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	427	10	698	698	CD
18637	427	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	427	12	1893	1893	CD
18637	427	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	427	14	.	.	.
18637	428	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	428	2	27	27	CD
18637	428	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	428	4	299	299	CD
18637	428	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	428	6	304	304	CD
18637	428	7	,	,	,
18637	428	8	316	316	CD
18637	428	9	-	-	SYM
18637	428	10	318	318	CD
18637	428	11	.	.	.
18637	429	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	429	2	28	28	CD
18637	429	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	429	4	_	_	NNP
18637	429	5	See	See	NNP
18637	429	6	also	also	RB
18637	429	7	_	_	NNP
18637	429	8	University	University	NNP
18637	429	9	of	of	IN
18637	429	10	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	429	11	_	_	NNP
18637	429	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	429	13	_	_	NNP
18637	429	14	United	United	NNP
18637	429	15	States	States	NNP
18637	429	16	,	,	,
18637	429	17	289	289	CD
18637	429	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	429	19	48	48	CD
18637	429	20	,	,	,
18637	429	21	59	59	CD
18637	429	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	429	23	1933	1933	CD
18637	429	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	429	25	.	.	.
18637	430	1	In	in	IN
18637	430	2	Lichter	Lichter	NNP
18637	430	3	_	_	NNP
18637	430	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	430	5	_	_	NNP
18637	430	6	United	United	NNP
18637	430	7	States	States	NNP
18637	430	8	,	,	,
18637	430	9	334	334	CD
18637	430	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	430	11	742	742	CD
18637	430	12	,	,	,
18637	430	13	782	782	CD
18637	430	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	430	15	1948	1948	CD
18637	430	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	430	17	,	,	,
18637	430	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	430	19	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	430	20	,	,	,
18637	430	21	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	430	22	for	for	IN
18637	430	23	the	the	DT
18637	430	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	430	25	,	,	,
18637	430	26	says	say	VBZ
18637	430	27	:	:	:
18637	430	28	"	"	``
18637	430	29	The	the	DT
18637	430	30	war	war	NN
18637	430	31	powers	power	NNS
18637	430	32	of	of	IN
18637	430	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	430	34	and	and	CC
18637	430	35	the	the	DT
18637	430	36	President	President	NNP
18637	430	37	are	be	VBP
18637	430	38	only	only	RB
18637	430	39	those	those	DT
18637	430	40	which	which	WDT
18637	430	41	are	be	VBP
18637	430	42	derived	derive	VBN
18637	430	43	from	from	IN
18637	430	44	the	the	DT
18637	430	45	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	430	46	"	"	''
18637	430	47	,	,	,
18637	430	48	but	but	CC
18637	430	49	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	430	50	adds	add	VBZ
18637	430	51	:	:	:
18637	430	52	"	"	``
18637	430	53	the	the	DT
18637	430	54	primary	primary	JJ
18637	430	55	implication	implication	NN
18637	430	56	of	of	IN
18637	430	57	a	a	DT
18637	430	58	war	war	NN
18637	430	59	power	power	NN
18637	430	60	is	be	VBZ
18637	430	61	that	that	IN
18637	430	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	430	63	shall	shall	MD
18637	430	64	be	be	VB
18637	430	65	an	an	DT
18637	430	66	effective	effective	JJ
18637	430	67	power	power	NN
18637	430	68	to	to	TO
18637	430	69	wage	wage	VB
18637	430	70	war	war	NN
18637	430	71	successfully	successfully	RB
18637	430	72	"	"	''
18637	430	73	,	,	,
18637	430	74	which	which	WDT
18637	430	75	looks	look	VBZ
18637	430	76	very	very	RB
18637	430	77	like	like	IN
18637	430	78	an	an	DT
18637	430	79	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	430	80	to	to	TO
18637	430	81	duck	duck	VB
18637	430	82	the	the	DT
18637	430	83	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	430	84	of	of	IN
18637	430	85	an	an	DT
18637	430	86	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	430	87	war	war	NN
18637	430	88	power	power	NN
18637	430	89	while	while	IN
18637	430	90	appropriating	appropriate	VBG
18637	430	91	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	430	92	results	result	NNS
18637	430	93	.	.	.
18637	431	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	431	2	29	29	CD
18637	431	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	431	4	Welldon	Welldon	NNP
18637	431	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	431	6	tr	tr	UH
18637	431	7	.	.	.
18637	432	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	432	2	,	,	,
18637	432	3	Book	Book	NNP
18637	432	4	VI	VI	NNP
18637	432	5	,	,	,
18637	432	6	chap	chap	NNP
18637	432	7	.	.	.
18637	433	1	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	433	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	433	3	1888	1888	CD
18637	433	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	433	5	.	.	.
18637	434	1	Jowett	Jowett	NNP
18637	434	2	and	and	CC
18637	434	3	some	some	DT
18637	434	4	others	other	NNS
18637	434	5	propose	propose	VBP
18637	434	6	a	a	DT
18637	434	7	different	different	JJ
18637	434	8	arrangement	arrangement	NN
18637	434	9	.	.	.
18637	435	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	435	2	30	30	CD
18637	435	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	435	4	John	John	NNP
18637	435	5	Locke	Locke	NNP
18637	435	6	.	.	.
18637	436	1	The	the	DT
18637	436	2	Second	Second	NNP
18637	436	3	Treatise	Treatise	NNP
18637	436	4	on	on	IN
18637	436	5	Civil	civil	JJ
18637	436	6	Government	Government	NNP
18637	436	7	,	,	,
18637	436	8	§	§	NNP
18637	436	9	141	141	CD
18637	436	10	.	.	.
18637	437	1	For	for	IN
18637	437	2	the	the	DT
18637	437	3	historical	historical	JJ
18637	437	4	background	background	NN
18637	437	5	of	of	IN
18637	437	6	this	this	DT
18637	437	7	principle	principle	NN
18637	437	8	,	,	,
18637	437	9	see	see	VB
18637	437	10	P.W.	P.W.	NNP
18637	438	1	Duff	Duff	NNP
18637	438	2	and	and	CC
18637	438	3	H.E.	H.E.	NNP
18637	439	1	Whiteside	whiteside	JJ
18637	439	2	,	,	,
18637	439	3	"	"	''
18637	439	4	_	_	NNP
18637	439	5	Delegata	Delegata	NNP
18637	439	6	Potestas	Potestas	NNP
18637	439	7	Non	Non	NNP
18637	439	8	P[=o]test	P[=o]test	NNP
18637	439	9	Delegari	Delegari	NNP
18637	439	10	_	_	NNP
18637	439	11	"	"	''
18637	439	12	,	,	,
18637	439	13	_	_	NNP
18637	439	14	Selected	Selected	NNP
18637	439	15	Essays	Essays	NNPS
18637	439	16	on	on	IN
18637	439	17	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	439	18	Law	Law	NNP
18637	439	19	_	_	NNP
18637	439	20	,	,	,
18637	439	21	IV	IV	NNP
18637	439	22	,	,	,
18637	439	23	291	291	CD
18637	439	24	-	-	SYM
18637	439	25	316	316	CD
18637	439	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	439	27	1938	1938	CD
18637	439	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	439	29	.	.	.
18637	440	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	440	2	31	31	CD
18637	440	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	440	4	Panama	Panama	NNP
18637	440	5	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	440	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	440	7	_	_	NNP
18637	440	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	440	9	_	_	NNP
18637	440	10	Ryan	Ryan	NNP
18637	440	11	,	,	,
18637	440	12	293	293	CD
18637	440	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	440	14	388	388	CD
18637	440	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	440	16	1935	1935	CD
18637	440	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	440	18	;	;	:
18637	440	19	Schechter	Schechter	NNP
18637	440	20	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	440	21	_	_	NNP
18637	440	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	440	23	_	_	NNP
18637	440	24	United	United	NNP
18637	440	25	States	States	NNP
18637	440	26	,	,	,
18637	440	27	295	295	CD
18637	440	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	440	29	495	495	CD
18637	440	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	440	31	1935	1935	CD
18637	440	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	440	33	.	.	.
18637	441	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	441	2	32	32	CD
18637	441	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	441	4	343	343	CD
18637	441	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	441	6	579	579	CD
18637	441	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	441	8	1952	1952	CD
18637	441	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	441	10	.	.	.
18637	442	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	442	2	33	33	CD
18637	442	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	442	4	299	299	CD
18637	442	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	442	6	304	304	CD
18637	442	7	,	,	,
18637	442	8	327	327	CD
18637	442	9	-	-	SYM
18637	442	10	329	329	CD
18637	442	11	.	.	.
18637	443	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	443	2	34	34	CD
18637	443	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	443	4	343	343	CD
18637	443	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	443	6	579	579	CD
18637	443	7	,	,	,
18637	443	8	690	690	CD
18637	443	9	.	.	.
18637	444	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	444	2	35	35	CD
18637	444	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	444	4	Andrew	Andrew	NNP
18637	444	5	C.	C.	NNP
18637	444	6	McLaughlin	McLaughlin	NNP
18637	444	7	,	,	,
18637	444	8	_	_	NNP
18637	444	9	A	a	DT
18637	444	10	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	444	11	History	history	NN
18637	444	12	of	of	IN
18637	444	13	the	the	DT
18637	444	14	United	United	NNP
18637	444	15	States	States	NNP
18637	444	16	_	_	NNP
18637	444	17	,	,	,
18637	444	18	81	81	CD
18637	444	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	444	20	1935	1935	CD
18637	444	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	444	22	.	.	.
18637	445	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	445	2	36	36	CD
18637	445	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	445	4	Locke	Locke	NNP
18637	445	5	,	,	,
18637	445	6	op	op	NN
18637	445	7	.	.	.
18637	446	1	cit	cit	NNP
18637	446	2	.	.	.
18637	446	3	,	,	,
18637	446	4	§	§	NNP
18637	446	5	137	137	CD
18637	446	6	.	.	.
18637	447	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	447	2	37	37	CD
18637	447	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	447	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	447	5	.	.	.
18637	447	6	,	,	,
18637	447	7	§	§	NNP
18637	447	8	159	159	CD
18637	447	9	-	-	SYM
18637	447	10	161	161	CD
18637	447	11	.	.	.
18637	448	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	448	2	38	38	CD
18637	448	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	448	4	Meyers	Meyers	NNP
18637	448	5	_	_	NNP
18637	448	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	448	7	_	_	NNP
18637	448	8	United	United	NNP
18637	448	9	States	States	NNP
18637	448	10	,	,	,
18637	448	11	272	272	CD
18637	448	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	448	13	52	52	CD
18637	448	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	448	15	1926	1926	CD
18637	448	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	448	17	.	.	.
18637	449	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	449	2	39	39	CD
18637	449	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	449	4	For	for	IN
18637	449	5	the	the	DT
18637	449	6	famous	famous	JJ
18637	449	7	debate	debate	NN
18637	449	8	between	between	IN
18637	449	9	"	"	``
18637	449	10	Pacificus	Pacificus	NNP
18637	449	11	"	"	''
18637	449	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	449	13	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	449	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	449	15	and	and	CC
18637	449	16	"	"	``
18637	449	17	Helvidius	Helvidius	NNP
18637	449	18	"	"	''
18637	449	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	449	20	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	449	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	449	22	,	,	,
18637	449	23	see	see	VB
18637	449	24	E.S.	E.S.	NNP
18637	450	1	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	450	2	,	,	,
18637	450	3	_	_	NNP
18637	450	4	The	the	DT
18637	450	5	President	President	NNP
18637	450	6	's	's	POS
18637	450	7	Control	Control	NNP
18637	450	8	of	of	IN
18637	450	9	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	450	10	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	450	11	_	_	NNP
18637	450	12	,	,	,
18637	450	13	chap	chap	NNP
18637	450	14	.	.	.
18637	451	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	451	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	451	3	1917	1917	CD
18637	451	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	451	5	.	.	.
18637	452	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	452	2	40	40	CD
18637	452	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	452	4	Writings	Writings	NNP
18637	452	5	of	of	IN
18637	452	6	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	452	7	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	452	8	,	,	,
18637	452	9	V	V	NNP
18637	452	10	,	,	,
18637	452	11	209	209	CD
18637	452	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	452	13	P.L.	P.L.	NNP
18637	453	1	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	453	2	,	,	,
18637	453	3	ed	ed	NNP
18637	453	4	.	.	.
18637	454	1	;	;	:
18637	454	2	1895	1895	CD
18637	454	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	454	4	.	.	.
18637	455	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	455	2	41	41	CD
18637	455	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	455	4	1	1	CD
18637	455	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	455	6	.	.	.
18637	456	1	137	137	CD
18637	456	2	,	,	,
18637	456	3	163	163	CD
18637	456	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	456	5	1803	1803	CD
18637	456	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	456	7	.	.	.
18637	457	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	457	2	42	42	CD
18637	457	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	457	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	457	5	.	.	.
18637	457	6	,	,	,
18637	457	7	165	165	CD
18637	457	8	-	-	SYM
18637	457	9	166	166	CD
18637	457	10	.	.	.
18637	458	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	458	2	43	43	CD
18637	458	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	458	4	7	7	CD
18637	458	5	How	how	WRB
18637	458	6	.	.	.
18637	459	1	1	1	LS
18637	459	2	.	.	.
18637	460	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	460	2	44	44	CD
18637	460	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	460	4	Fleming	Fleming	NNP
18637	460	5	_	_	NNP
18637	460	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	460	7	_	_	NNP
18637	460	8	Page	Page	NNP
18637	460	9	,	,	,
18637	460	10	9	9	CD
18637	460	11	How	how	WRB
18637	460	12	.	.	.
18637	461	1	602	602	CD
18637	461	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	461	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	461	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	461	5	.	.	.
18637	462	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	462	2	45	45	CD
18637	462	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	462	4	United	United	NNP
18637	462	5	States	States	NNP
18637	462	6	_	_	NNP
18637	462	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	462	8	_	_	NNP
18637	462	9	Tingy	Tingy	NNP
18637	462	10	,	,	,
18637	462	11	5	5	CD
18637	462	12	Pet	pet	NN
18637	462	13	.	.	.
18637	463	1	115	115	CD
18637	463	2	,	,	,
18637	463	3	122	122	CD
18637	463	4	.	.	.
18637	464	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	464	2	46	46	CD
18637	464	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	464	4	6	6	CD
18637	464	5	_	_	NNP
18637	464	6	Op	Op	NNP
18637	464	7	.	.	.
18637	465	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	465	2	.	.	.
18637	466	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	466	2	_	_	NNP
18637	466	3	466	466	CD
18637	466	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	466	5	1854	1854	CD
18637	466	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	466	7	.	.	.
18637	467	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	467	2	47	47	CD
18637	467	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	467	4	2	2	CD
18637	467	5	Black	Black	NNP
18637	467	6	635	635	CD
18637	467	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	467	8	1863	1863	CD
18637	467	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	467	10	.	.	.
18637	468	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	468	2	48	48	CD
18637	468	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	468	4	4	4	CD
18637	468	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	468	6	.	.	.
18637	469	1	2	2	CD
18637	469	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	469	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	469	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	469	5	.	.	.
18637	470	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	470	2	49	49	CD
18637	470	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	470	4	4	4	CD
18637	470	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	470	6	.	.	.
18637	471	1	475	475	CD
18637	471	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	471	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	471	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	471	5	.	.	.
18637	472	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	472	2	50	50	CD
18637	472	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	472	4	United	United	NNP
18637	472	5	States	States	NNP
18637	472	6	_	_	NNP
18637	472	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	472	8	_	_	NNP
18637	472	9	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	472	10	,	,	,
18637	472	11	106	106	CD
18637	472	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	472	13	196	196	CD
18637	472	14	,	,	,
18637	472	15	220	220	CD
18637	472	16	.	.	.
18637	473	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	473	2	51	51	CD
18637	473	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	473	4	In	in	IN
18637	473	5	Re	Re	NNP
18637	473	6	Neagle	Neagle	NNP
18637	473	7	,	,	,
18637	473	8	135	135	CD
18637	473	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	473	10	1	1	CD
18637	473	11	,	,	,
18637	473	12	64	64	CD
18637	473	13	.	.	.
18637	474	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	474	2	52	52	CD
18637	474	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	474	4	158	158	CD
18637	474	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	474	6	564	564	CD
18637	474	7	.	.	.
18637	475	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	475	2	53	53	CD
18637	475	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	475	4	_	_	NNP
18637	475	5	Autobiography	Autobiography	NNP
18637	475	6	_	_	NNP
18637	475	7	,	,	,
18637	475	8	388	388	CD
18637	475	9	-	-	SYM
18637	475	10	389	389	CD
18637	475	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	475	12	1913	1913	CD
18637	475	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	475	14	.	.	.
18637	476	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	476	2	54	54	CD
18637	476	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	476	4	_	_	NNP
18637	476	5	Op	Op	NNP
18637	476	6	.	.	.
18637	477	1	cit	cit	NNP
18637	477	2	.	.	.
18637	477	3	_	_	NNP
18637	477	4	,	,	,
18637	477	5	144	144	CD
18637	477	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	477	7	1916	1916	CD
18637	477	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	477	9	.	.	.
18637	478	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	478	2	55	55	CD
18637	478	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	478	4	_	_	NNP
18637	478	5	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	478	6	Government	Government	NNP
18637	478	7	in	in	IN
18637	478	8	the	the	DT
18637	478	9	United	United	NNP
18637	478	10	States	States	NNP
18637	478	11	_	_	NNP
18637	478	12	,	,	,
18637	478	13	70	70	CD
18637	478	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	478	15	1908	1908	CD
18637	478	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	478	17	.	.	.
18637	479	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	479	2	56	56	CD
18637	479	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	479	4	_	_	NNP
18637	479	5	See	See	NNP
18637	479	6	_	_	NNP
18637	479	7	E.S.	E.S.	NNP
18637	480	1	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	480	2	.	.	.
18637	481	1	_	_	NNP
18637	481	2	Total	Total	NNP
18637	481	3	War	War	NNP
18637	481	4	and	and	CC
18637	481	5	the	the	DT
18637	481	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	481	7	_	_	NNP
18637	481	8	,	,	,
18637	481	9	35	35	CD
18637	481	10	-	-	SYM
18637	481	11	77	77	CD
18637	481	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	481	13	1947	1947	CD
18637	481	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	481	15	.	.	.
18637	482	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	482	2	57	57	CD
18637	482	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	482	4	343	343	CD
18637	482	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	482	6	579	579	CD
18637	482	7	,	,	,
18637	482	8	662	662	CD
18637	482	9	.	.	.
18637	483	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	483	2	58	58	CD
18637	483	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	483	4	_	_	NNP
18637	483	5	See	See	NNP
18637	483	6	_	_	NNP
18637	483	7	E.S.	E.S.	NNP
18637	484	1	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	484	2	.	.	.
18637	485	1	_	_	NNP
18637	485	2	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	485	3	Against	against	IN
18637	485	4	Government	Government	NNP
18637	485	5	_	_	NNP
18637	485	6	,	,	,
18637	485	7	Chaps	Chaps	NNP
18637	485	8	.	.	.
18637	486	1	III	III	NNP
18637	486	2	,	,	,
18637	486	3	IV	IV	NNP
18637	486	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	486	5	1948	1948	CD
18637	486	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	486	7	.	.	.
18637	487	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	487	2	59	59	CD
18637	487	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	487	4	"	"	``
18637	487	5	...	...	NFP
18637	487	6	the	the	DT
18637	487	7	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	487	8	power	power	NNP
18637	487	9	can	can	MD
18637	487	10	not	not	RB
18637	487	11	take	take	VB
18637	487	12	from	from	IN
18637	487	13	any	any	DT
18637	487	14	man	man	NN
18637	487	15	any	any	DT
18637	487	16	part	part	NN
18637	487	17	of	of	IN
18637	487	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	487	19	property	property	NN
18637	487	20	without	without	IN
18637	487	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	487	22	consent	consent	NN
18637	487	23	"	"	''
18637	487	24	.	.	.
18637	488	1	_	_	NNP
18637	488	2	Second	Second	NNP
18637	488	3	Treatise	Treatise	NNP
18637	488	4	_	_	NNP
18637	488	5	,	,	,
18637	488	6	§	§	NNP
18637	488	7	138	138	CD
18637	488	8	.	.	.
18637	489	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	489	2	60	60	CD
18637	489	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	489	4	Van	Van	NNP
18637	489	5	Home	Home	NNP
18637	489	6	's	's	POS
18637	489	7	Lessee	Lessee	NNP
18637	489	8	_	_	NNP
18637	489	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	489	10	_	_	NNP
18637	489	11	Dorrance	Dorrance	NNP
18637	489	12	,	,	,
18637	489	13	2	2	CD
18637	489	14	Dall	dall	NN
18637	489	15	.	.	.
18637	490	1	304	304	CD
18637	490	2	,	,	,
18637	490	3	310	310	CD
18637	490	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	490	5	1795	1795	CD
18637	490	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	490	7	.	.	.
18637	491	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	491	2	61	61	CD
18637	491	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	491	4	Calder	Calder	NNP
18637	491	5	_	_	NNP
18637	491	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	491	7	_	_	NNP
18637	491	8	Bull	Bull	NNP
18637	491	9	,	,	,
18637	491	10	3	3	CD
18637	491	11	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	491	12	.	.	.
18637	492	1	386	386	CD
18637	492	2	,	,	,
18637	492	3	388	388	CD
18637	492	4	-	-	SYM
18637	492	5	389	389	CD
18637	492	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	492	7	1798	1798	CD
18637	492	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	492	9	.	.	.
18637	493	1	_	_	NNP
18637	493	2	See	See	NNP
18637	493	3	also	also	RB
18637	493	4	_	_	NNP
18637	493	5	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	493	6	Association	Association	NNP
18637	493	7	_	_	NNP
18637	493	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	493	9	_	_	NNP
18637	493	10	Topeka	Topeka	NNP
18637	493	11	,	,	,
18637	493	12	20	20	CD
18637	493	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	493	14	.	.	.
18637	494	1	655	655	CD
18637	494	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	494	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	494	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	494	5	.	.	.
18637	495	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	495	2	62	62	CD
18637	495	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	495	4	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	495	5	of	of	IN
18637	495	6	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	495	7	_	_	NNP
18637	495	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	495	9	_	_	NNP
18637	495	10	Okely	okely	RB
18637	495	11	,	,	,
18637	495	12	4	4	CD
18637	495	13	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	495	14	.	.	.
18637	496	1	235	235	CD
18637	496	2	,	,	,
18637	496	3	244	244	CD
18637	496	4	.	.	.
18637	497	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	497	2	63	63	CD
18637	497	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	497	4	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	497	5	_	_	NNP
18637	497	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	497	7	_	_	NNP
18637	497	8	Sandford	Sandford	NNP
18637	497	9	,	,	,
18637	497	10	19	19	CD
18637	497	11	How	how	WRB
18637	497	12	.	.	.
18637	498	1	393	393	CD
18637	498	2	,	,	,
18637	498	3	450	450	CD
18637	498	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	498	5	1857	1857	CD
18637	498	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	498	7	.	.	.
18637	499	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	499	2	64	64	CD
18637	499	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	499	4	13	13	CD
18637	499	5	N.Y.	New York	NNP
18637	499	6	378	378	CD
18637	499	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	499	8	1856	1856	CD
18637	499	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	499	10	.	.	.
18637	500	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	500	2	65	65	CD
18637	500	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	500	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	500	5	.	.	.
18637	501	1	390	390	CD
18637	501	2	-	-	SYM
18637	501	3	392	392	CD
18637	501	4	.	.	.
18637	502	1	The	the	DT
18637	502	2	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	502	3	veto	veto	NN
18637	502	4	of	of	IN
18637	502	5	the	the	DT
18637	502	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	502	7	of	of	IN
18637	502	8	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	502	9	in	in	IN
18637	502	10	the	the	DT
18637	502	11	Wynehamer	Wynehamer	NNP
18637	502	12	case	case	NN
18637	502	13	was	be	VBD
18637	502	14	replaced	replace	VBN
18637	502	15	by	by	IN
18637	502	16	the	the	DT
18637	502	17	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	502	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	502	19	,	,	,
18637	502	20	under	under	IN
18637	502	21	the	the	DT
18637	502	22	due	due	JJ
18637	502	23	process	process	NN
18637	502	24	clause	clause	NN
18637	502	25	of	of	IN
18637	502	26	the	the	DT
18637	502	27	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	502	28	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	502	29	,	,	,
18637	502	30	by	by	IN
18637	502	31	a	a	DT
18637	502	32	more	more	RBR
18637	502	33	flexible	flexible	JJ
18637	502	34	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	502	35	,	,	,
18637	502	36	which	which	WDT
18637	502	37	left	leave	VBD
18637	502	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	502	39	open	open	JJ
18637	502	40	to	to	IN
18637	502	41	the	the	DT
18637	502	42	State	State	NNP
18637	502	43	to	to	TO
18637	502	44	show	show	VB
18637	502	45	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	502	46	justification	justification	NN
18637	502	47	for	for	IN
18637	502	48	that	that	DT
18637	502	49	type	type	NN
18637	502	50	of	of	IN
18637	502	51	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	502	52	in	in	IN
18637	502	53	terms	term	NNS
18637	502	54	of	of	IN
18637	502	55	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	502	56	ends	end	NNS
18637	502	57	of	of	IN
18637	502	58	the	the	DT
18637	502	59	Police	Police	NNP
18637	502	60	Power	Power	NNP
18637	502	61	,	,	,
18637	502	62	namely	namely	RB
18637	502	63	,	,	,
18637	502	64	the	the	DT
18637	502	65	promotion	promotion	NN
18637	502	66	of	of	IN
18637	502	67	the	the	DT
18637	502	68	public	public	JJ
18637	502	69	health	health	NN
18637	502	70	,	,	,
18637	502	71	safety	safety	NN
18637	502	72	and	and	CC
18637	502	73	morals	moral	NNS
18637	502	74	.	.	.
18637	503	1	_	_	NNP
18637	503	2	See	See	NNP
18637	503	3	_	_	NNP
18637	503	4	Mugler	Mugler	NNP
18637	503	5	_	_	NNP
18637	503	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	503	7	_	_	NNP
18637	503	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	503	9	,	,	,
18637	503	10	123	123	CD
18637	503	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	503	12	623	623	CD
18637	503	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	503	14	1887	1887	CD
18637	503	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	503	16	;	;	:
18637	503	17	and	and	CC
18637	503	18	for	for	IN
18637	503	19	a	a	DT
18637	503	20	transitional	transitional	JJ
18637	503	21	case	case	NN
18637	503	22	,	,	,
18637	503	23	Bartemeyer	Bartemeyer	NNP
18637	503	24	_	_	NNP
18637	503	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	503	26	_	_	NNP
18637	503	27	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	503	28	,	,	,
18637	503	29	18	18	CD
18637	503	30	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	503	31	.	.	.
18637	504	1	129	129	CD
18637	504	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	504	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	504	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	504	5	.	.	.
18637	505	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	505	2	66	66	CD
18637	505	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	505	4	The	the	DT
18637	505	5	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	505	6	House	House	NNP
18637	505	7	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	505	8	,	,	,
18637	505	9	16	16	CD
18637	505	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	505	11	.	.	.
18637	506	1	36	36	CD
18637	506	2	,	,	,
18637	506	3	78	78	CD
18637	506	4	-	-	SYM
18637	506	5	82	82	CD
18637	506	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	506	7	1873	1873	CD
18637	506	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	506	9	.	.	.
18637	507	1	The	the	DT
18637	507	2	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	507	3	of	of	IN
18637	507	4	the	the	DT
18637	507	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	507	6	was	be	VBD
18637	507	7	focused	focus	VBN
18637	507	8	principally	principally	RB
18637	507	9	on	on	IN
18637	507	10	the	the	DT
18637	507	11	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	507	12	and	and	CC
18637	507	13	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	507	14	clause	clause	NN
18637	507	15	,	,	,
18637	507	16	and	and	CC
18637	507	17	the	the	DT
18637	507	18	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	507	19	construction	construction	NN
18637	507	20	given	give	VBN
18637	507	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	507	22	at	at	IN
18637	507	23	this	this	DT
18637	507	24	time	time	NN
18637	507	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	507	26	still	still	RB
18637	507	27	the	the	DT
18637	507	28	law	law	NN
18637	507	29	of	of	IN
18637	507	30	the	the	DT
18637	507	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	507	32	.	.	.
18637	508	1	But	but	CC
18637	508	2	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	508	3	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	508	4	and	and	CC
18637	508	5	Swayne	Swayne	NNP
18637	508	6	pointed	point	VBD
18637	508	7	out	out	RP
18637	508	8	the	the	DT
18637	508	9	potentialities	potentiality	NNS
18637	508	10	of	of	IN
18637	508	11	the	the	DT
18637	508	12	due	due	JJ
18637	508	13	process	process	NN
18637	508	14	of	of	IN
18637	508	15	law	law	NN
18637	508	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	508	17	,	,	,
18637	508	18	and	and	CC
18637	508	19	the	the	DT
18637	508	20	former	former	JJ
18637	508	21	's	's	POS
18637	508	22	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	508	23	of	of	IN
18637	508	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	508	25	may	may	MD
18637	508	26	be	be	VB
18637	508	27	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	508	28	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	508	29	as	as	IN
18637	508	30	the	the	DT
18637	508	31	first	first	JJ
18637	508	32	step	step	NN
18637	508	33	toward	toward	IN
18637	508	34	the	the	DT
18637	508	35	translation	translation	NN
18637	508	36	by	by	IN
18637	508	37	the	the	DT
18637	508	38	Court	Court	NNP
18637	508	39	of	of	IN
18637	508	40	"	"	``
18637	508	41	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	508	42	"	"	''
18637	508	43	as	as	IN
18637	508	44	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	508	45	on	on	IN
18637	508	46	Contract	Contract	NNP
18637	508	47	.	.	.
18637	509	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	509	2	67	67	CD
18637	509	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	509	4	94	94	CD
18637	509	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	509	6	113	113	CD
18637	509	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	509	8	1876	1876	CD
18637	509	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	509	10	.	.	.
18637	510	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	510	2	68	68	CD
18637	510	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	510	4	Benjamin	Benjamin	NNP
18637	510	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	510	6	Twiss	Twiss	NNP
18637	510	7	,	,	,
18637	510	8	_	_	NNP
18637	510	9	Lawyers	Lawyers	NNPS
18637	510	10	and	and	CC
18637	510	11	the	the	DT
18637	510	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	510	13	,	,	,
18637	510	14	How	how	WRB
18637	510	15	Laissez	Laissez	NNP
18637	510	16	Faire	Faire	NNP
18637	510	17	Came	come	VBD
18637	510	18	to	to	IN
18637	510	19	the	the	DT
18637	510	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	510	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	510	22	_	_	NNP
18637	510	23	,	,	,
18637	510	24	141	141	CD
18637	510	25	-	-	SYM
18637	510	26	173	173	CD
18637	510	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	510	28	1942	1942	CD
18637	510	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	510	30	.	.	.
18637	511	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	511	2	69	69	CD
18637	511	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	511	4	_	_	NNP
18637	511	5	See	See	NNP
18637	511	6	_	_	NNP
18637	511	7	especially	especially	RB
18637	511	8	Lochner	Lochner	NNP
18637	511	9	_	_	NNP
18637	511	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	511	11	_	_	NNP
18637	511	12	New	New	NNP
18637	511	13	York	York	NNP
18637	511	14	,	,	,
18637	511	15	198	198	CD
18637	511	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	511	17	45	45	CD
18637	511	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	511	19	1905	1905	CD
18637	511	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	511	21	;	;	:
18637	511	22	and	and	CC
18637	511	23	Adkins	Adkins	NNPS
18637	511	24	_	_	NNP
18637	511	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	511	26	_	_	NNP
18637	511	27	Children	Children	NNP
18637	511	28	's	's	POS
18637	511	29	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	511	30	,	,	,
18637	511	31	261	261	CD
18637	511	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	511	33	525	525	CD
18637	511	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	511	35	1923	1923	CD
18637	511	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	511	37	.	.	.
18637	512	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	512	2	70	70	CD
18637	512	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	512	4	169	169	CD
18637	512	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	512	6	466	466	CD
18637	512	7	;	;	:
18637	512	8	ibid	ibid	RB
18637	512	9	.	.	.
18637	513	1	366	366	CD
18637	513	2	.	.	.
18637	514	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	514	2	71	71	CD
18637	514	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	514	4	_	_	NNP
18637	514	5	See	See	NNP
18637	514	6	_	_	NNP
18637	514	7	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	514	8	W.	W.	NNP
18637	514	9	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	514	10	,	,	,
18637	514	11	_	_	NNP
18637	514	12	The	the	DT
18637	514	13	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	514	14	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	514	15	and	and	CC
18637	514	16	the	the	DT
18637	514	17	States	States	NNP
18637	514	18	_	_	NNP
18637	514	19	,	,	,
18637	514	20	188	188	CD
18637	514	21	-	-	SYM
18637	514	22	206	206	CD
18637	514	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	514	24	1912	1912	CD
18637	514	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	514	26	.	.	.
18637	515	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	515	2	72	72	CD
18637	515	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	515	4	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	515	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	515	6	_	_	NNP
18637	515	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	515	8	_	_	NNP
18637	515	9	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	515	10	&	&	CC
18637	515	11	Laughlin	Laughlin	NNP
18637	515	12	,	,	,
18637	515	13	301	301	CD
18637	515	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	515	15	1	1	CD
18637	515	16	,	,	,
18637	515	17	33	33	CD
18637	515	18	-	-	SYM
18637	515	19	34	34	CD
18637	515	20	;	;	:
18637	515	21	West	West	NNP
18637	515	22	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	515	23	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	515	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	515	25	_	_	NNP
18637	515	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	515	27	_	_	NNP
18637	515	28	Parrish	Parrish	NNP
18637	515	29	,	,	,
18637	515	30	300	300	CD
18637	515	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	515	32	379	379	CD
18637	515	33	,	,	,
18637	515	34	391	391	CD
18637	515	35	-	-	SYM
18637	515	36	392	392	CD
18637	515	37	.	.	.
18637	516	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	516	2	73	73	CD
18637	516	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	516	4	268	268	CD
18637	516	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	516	6	652	652	CD
18637	516	7	,	,	,
18637	516	8	666	666	CD
18637	516	9	;	;	:
18637	516	10	_	_	NNP
18637	516	11	cf	cf	NNP
18637	516	12	.	.	.
18637	516	13	_	_	NNP
18637	516	14	Prudential	Prudential	NNP
18637	516	15	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	516	16	.	.	.
18637	517	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	517	2	_	_	NNP
18637	517	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	517	4	_	_	NNP
18637	517	5	Cheek	Cheek	NNP
18637	517	6	,	,	,
18637	517	7	259	259	CD
18637	517	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	517	9	530	530	CD
18637	517	10	,	,	,
18637	517	11	543	543	CD
18637	517	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	517	13	1922	1922	CD
18637	517	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	517	15	.	.	.
18637	518	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	518	2	74	74	CD
18637	518	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	518	4	The	the	DT
18637	518	5	subject	subject	NN
18637	518	6	can	can	MD
18637	518	7	be	be	VB
18637	518	8	pursued	pursue	VBN
18637	518	9	in	in	IN
18637	518	10	detail	detail	NN
18637	518	11	in	in	IN
18637	518	12	connection	connection	NN
18637	518	13	with	with	IN
18637	518	14	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	518	15	I	I	NNP
18637	518	16	,	,	,
18637	518	17	pp	pp	NNP
18637	518	18	.	.	.
18637	519	1	769	769	CD
18637	519	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	519	3	810	810	CD
18637	519	4	.	.	.
18637	520	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	520	2	75	75	CD
18637	520	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	520	4	These	these	DT
18637	520	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	520	6	are	be	VBP
18637	520	7	treated	treat	VBN
18637	520	8	in	in	IN
18637	520	9	the	the	DT
18637	520	10	text	text	NN
18637	520	11	,	,	,
18637	520	12	_	_	NNP
18637	520	13	see	see	VBP
18637	520	14	_	_	NNP
18637	520	15	Table	Table	NNP
18637	520	16	of	of	IN
18637	520	17	Cases	case	NNS
18637	520	18	.	.	.
18637	521	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	521	2	76	76	CD
18637	521	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	521	4	_	_	NNP
18637	521	5	See	See	NNP
18637	521	6	_	_	NNP
18637	521	7	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	521	8	_	_	NNP
18637	521	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	521	10	_	_	NNP
18637	521	11	United	United	NNP
18637	521	12	States	States	NNP
18637	521	13	,	,	,
18637	521	14	341	341	CD
18637	521	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	521	16	97	97	CD
18637	521	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	521	18	1951	1951	CD
18637	521	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	521	20	.	.	.
18637	522	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	522	2	77	77	CD
18637	522	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	522	4	_	_	NNP
18637	522	5	See	See	NNP
18637	522	6	:	:	:
18637	522	7	_	_	NNP
18637	522	8	Oliver	Oliver	NNP
18637	522	9	Wendell	Wendell	NNP
18637	522	10	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	522	11	,	,	,
18637	522	12	_	_	NNP
18637	522	13	Collected	Collected	NNP
18637	522	14	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	522	15	Papers	Papers	NNP
18637	522	16	_	_	NNP
18637	522	17	,	,	,
18637	522	18	239	239	CD
18637	522	19	,	,	,
18637	522	20	295	295	CD
18637	522	21	-	-	SYM
18637	522	22	296	296	CD
18637	522	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	522	24	1920	1920	CD
18637	522	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	522	26	;	;	:
18637	522	27	Merlo	Merlo	NNP
18637	522	28	J.	J.	NNP
18637	522	29	Pusey	Pusey	NNP
18637	522	30	,	,	,
18637	522	31	_	_	NNP
18637	522	32	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	522	33	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	522	34	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	522	35	_	_	NNP
18637	522	36	,	,	,
18637	522	37	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	522	38	,	,	,
18637	522	39	203	203	CD
18637	522	40	-	-	SYM
18637	522	41	206	206	CD
18637	522	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	522	43	1951	1951	CD
18637	522	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	522	45	.	.	.
18637	523	1	Burns	Burns	NNP
18637	523	2	Baking	Baking	NNP
18637	523	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	523	4	_	_	NNP
18637	523	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	523	6	_	_	NNP
18637	523	7	Bryan	Bryan	NNP
18637	523	8	,	,	,
18637	523	9	204	204	CD
18637	523	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	523	11	504	504	CD
18637	523	12	,	,	,
18637	523	13	534	534	CD
18637	523	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	523	15	1924	1924	CD
18637	523	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	523	17	;	;	:
18637	523	18	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	523	19	_	_	NNP
18637	523	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	523	21	_	_	NNP
18637	523	22	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	523	23	,	,	,
18637	523	24	281	281	CD
18637	523	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	523	26	586	586	CD
18637	523	27	,	,	,
18637	523	28	595	595	CD
18637	523	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	523	30	1930	1930	CD
18637	523	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	523	32	;	;	:
18637	523	33	_	_	NNP
18637	523	34	American	American	NNP
18637	523	35	Political	Political	NNP
18637	523	36	Science	Science	NNP
18637	523	37	Review	Review	NNP
18637	523	38	_	_	NNP
18637	523	39	,	,	,
18637	523	40	xii	xii	NNP
18637	523	41	,	,	,
18637	523	42	241	241	CD
18637	523	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	523	44	1918	1918	CD
18637	523	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	523	46	;	;	:
18637	523	47	_	_	NNP
18637	523	48	New	New	NNP
18637	523	49	York	York	NNP
18637	523	50	Times	Times	NNP
18637	523	51	_	_	NNP
18637	523	52	,	,	,
18637	523	53	February	February	NNP
18637	523	54	12	12	CD
18637	523	55	,	,	,
18637	523	56	1930	1930	CD
18637	523	57	.	.	.
18637	524	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	524	2	was	be	VBD
18637	524	3	also	also	RB
18637	524	4	during	during	IN
18637	524	5	the	the	DT
18637	524	6	same	same	JJ
18637	524	7	period	period	NN
18637	524	8	that	that	WDT
18637	524	9	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	524	10	Andrew	Andrew	NNP
18637	524	11	A.	A.	NNP
18637	524	12	Bruce	Bruce	NNP
18637	524	13	of	of	IN
18637	524	14	North	North	NNP
18637	524	15	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	524	16	wrote	write	VBD
18637	524	17	:	:	:
18637	524	18	"	"	``
18637	524	19	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	524	20	are	be	VBP
18637	524	21	governed	govern	VBN
18637	524	22	by	by	IN
18637	524	23	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	524	24	judges	judge	NNS
18637	524	25	and	and	CC
18637	524	26	not	not	RB
18637	524	27	by	by	IN
18637	524	28	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	524	29	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	524	30	....	....	.
18637	525	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	525	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	525	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	525	4	judges	judge	NNS
18637	525	5	who	who	WP
18637	525	6	formulate	formulate	VBP
18637	525	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	525	8	public	public	JJ
18637	525	9	policies	policy	NNS
18637	525	10	and	and	CC
18637	525	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	525	12	basic	basic	JJ
18637	525	13	law	law	NN
18637	525	14	"	"	''
18637	525	15	.	.	.
18637	526	1	_	_	NNP
18637	526	2	The	the	DT
18637	526	3	American	American	NNP
18637	526	4	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	526	5	_	_	NNP
18637	526	6	,	,	,
18637	526	7	6	6	CD
18637	526	8	,	,	,
18637	526	9	8	8	CD
18637	526	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	526	11	1924	1924	CD
18637	526	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	526	13	.	.	.
18637	527	1	Substantially	substantially	RB
18637	527	2	contemporaneously	contemporaneously	RB
18637	527	3	a	a	DT
18637	527	4	well	well	RB
18637	527	5	read	read	VBN
18637	527	6	French	french	JJ
18637	527	7	critic	critic	NN
18637	527	8	described	describe	VBD
18637	527	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	527	10	system	system	NN
18637	527	11	as	as	IN
18637	527	12	_	_	NNP
18637	527	13	Le	Le	NNP
18637	527	14	Gouvernment	Gouvernment	NNP
18637	527	15	des	des	NNP
18637	527	16	Juges	Juges	NNPS
18637	527	17	_	_	NNP
18637	527	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	527	19	1921	1921	CD
18637	527	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	527	21	;	;	:
18637	527	22	while	while	IN
18637	527	23	toward	toward	IN
18637	527	24	the	the	DT
18637	527	25	end	end	NN
18637	527	26	of	of	IN
18637	527	27	the	the	DT
18637	527	28	period	period	NN
18637	527	29	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	527	30	B.	B.	NNP
18637	527	31	Boudin	Boudin	NNP
18637	527	32	published	publish	VBD
18637	527	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	527	34	well	well	RB
18637	527	35	known	know	VBN
18637	527	36	_	_	NNP
18637	527	37	Government	Government	NNP
18637	527	38	by	by	IN
18637	527	39	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	527	40	_	_	NNP
18637	527	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	527	42	2	2	CD
18637	527	43	vols	vol	NNS
18637	527	44	.	.	.
18637	527	45	,	,	,
18637	527	46	1932	1932	CD
18637	527	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	527	48	.	.	.
18637	528	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	528	2	78	78	CD
18637	528	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	528	4	_	_	NNP
18637	528	5	Collected	Collected	NNP
18637	528	6	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	528	7	Papers	Papers	NNP
18637	528	8	_	_	NNP
18637	528	9	,	,	,
18637	528	10	295	295	CD
18637	528	11	-	-	SYM
18637	528	12	296	296	CD
18637	528	13	.	.	.
18637	529	1	CONTENTS	content	NNS
18637	529	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	529	3	For	for	IN
18637	529	4	contents	content	NNS
18637	529	5	in	in	IN
18637	529	6	detail	detail	NN
18637	529	7	,	,	,
18637	529	8	see	see	VB
18637	529	9	tables	table	NNS
18637	529	10	at	at	IN
18637	529	11	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	529	12	of	of	IN
18637	529	13	each	each	DT
18637	529	14	article	article	NN
18637	529	15	and	and	CC
18637	529	16	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	529	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	529	18	Page	Page	NNP
18637	529	19	Prefaces	Prefaces	NNP
18637	529	20	III	III	NNP
18637	529	21	,	,	,
18637	529	22	V	V	NNP
18637	529	23	Editor	Editor	NNP
18637	529	24	's	be	VBZ
18637	529	25	forward	forward	RB
18637	529	26	VII	VII	NNP
18637	529	27	Editor	Editor	NNP
18637	529	28	's	's	POS
18637	529	29	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	529	30	IX	IX	NNP
18637	529	31	Historical	Historical	NNP
18637	529	32	note	note	NN
18637	529	33	on	on	IN
18637	529	34	formation	formation	NN
18637	529	35	of	of	IN
18637	529	36	the	the	DT
18637	529	37	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	529	38	9	9	CD
18637	529	39	Text	Text	NNP
18637	529	40	of	of	IN
18637	529	41	the	the	DT
18637	529	42	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	529	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	529	44	literal	literal	JJ
18637	529	45	print	print	NN
18637	529	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	529	47	17	17	CD
18637	529	48	Text	text	NN
18637	529	49	of	of	IN
18637	529	50	the	the	DT
18637	529	51	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	529	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	529	53	literal	literal	JJ
18637	529	54	print	print	NN
18637	529	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	529	56	37	37	CD
18637	529	57	The	the	DT
18637	529	58	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	529	59	,	,	,
18637	529	60	with	with	IN
18637	529	61	annotations	annotation	NNS
18637	529	62	55	55	CD
18637	529	63	The	the	DT
18637	529	64	preamble	preamble	JJ
18637	529	65	59	59	CD
18637	529	66	Article	article	NN
18637	529	67	I.	i.	NN
18637	530	1	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	530	2	Department	Department	NNP
18637	530	3	:	:	:
18637	530	4	Section	section	NN
18637	530	5	1	1	CD
18637	530	6	.	.	.
18637	531	1	The	the	DT
18637	531	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	531	3	71	71	CD
18637	531	4	2	2	CD
18637	531	5	.	.	.
18637	532	1	House	House	NNP
18637	532	2	of	of	IN
18637	532	3	Representatives	Representatives	NNP
18637	532	4	87	87	CD
18637	532	5	3	3	CD
18637	532	6	.	.	.
18637	533	1	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	533	2	91	91	CD
18637	533	3	4	4	CD
18637	533	4	.	.	.
18637	534	1	Elections	election	NNS
18637	534	2	and	and	CC
18637	534	3	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	534	4	92	92	CD
18637	534	5	5	5	CD
18637	534	6	.	.	.
18637	535	1	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	535	2	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	535	3	95	95	CD
18637	535	4	6	6	CD
18637	535	5	.	.	.
18637	536	1	Rights	right	NNS
18637	536	2	of	of	IN
18637	536	3	Members	Members	NNP
18637	536	4	99	99	CD
18637	536	5	7	7	CD
18637	536	6	.	.	.
18637	537	1	Bills	bill	NNS
18637	537	2	and	and	CC
18637	537	3	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	537	4	101	101	CD
18637	537	5	8	8	CD
18637	537	6	.	.	.
18637	538	1	Powers	power	NNS
18637	538	2	of	of	IN
18637	538	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	538	4	105	105	CD
18637	538	5	9	9	CD
18637	538	6	.	.	.
18637	539	1	Powers	power	NNS
18637	539	2	denied	deny	VBD
18637	539	3	to	to	IN
18637	539	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	539	5	312	312	CD
18637	539	6	10	10	CD
18637	539	7	.	.	.
18637	540	1	Powers	power	NNS
18637	540	2	denied	deny	VBD
18637	540	3	to	to	IN
18637	540	4	the	the	DT
18637	540	5	States	States	NNP
18637	540	6	325	325	CD
18637	540	7	Article	Article	NNP
18637	540	8	II	ii	CD
18637	540	9	.	.	.
18637	541	1	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	541	2	Department	Department	NNP
18637	541	3	:	:	:
18637	541	4	Section	section	NN
18637	541	5	1	1	CD
18637	541	6	.	.	.
18637	542	1	The	the	DT
18637	542	2	President	President	NNP
18637	542	3	377	377	CD
18637	542	4	2	2	CD
18637	542	5	.	.	.
18637	543	1	Powers	power	NNS
18637	543	2	and	and	CC
18637	543	3	duties	duty	NNS
18637	543	4	of	of	IN
18637	543	5	the	the	DT
18637	543	6	President	President	NNP
18637	543	7	389	389	CD
18637	543	8	3	3	CD
18637	543	9	.	.	.
18637	544	1	Miscellaneous	miscellaneous	JJ
18637	544	2	powers	power	NNS
18637	544	3	and	and	CC
18637	544	4	duties	duty	NNS
18637	544	5	of	of	IN
18637	544	6	the	the	DT
18637	544	7	President	President	NNP
18637	544	8	462	462	CD
18637	544	9	4	4	CD
18637	544	10	.	.	.
18637	545	1	Impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	545	2	501	501	CD
18637	545	3	Article	article	NN
18637	545	4	III	iii	CD
18637	545	5	.	.	.
18637	546	1	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	546	2	Department	Department	NNP
18637	546	3	:	:	:
18637	546	4	Section	section	NN
18637	546	5	1	1	CD
18637	546	6	.	.	.
18637	547	1	The	the	DT
18637	547	2	judges	judge	NNS
18637	547	3	,	,	,
18637	547	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	547	5	terms	term	NNS
18637	547	6	,	,	,
18637	547	7	and	and	CC
18637	547	8	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	547	9	511	511	CD
18637	547	10	2	2	CD
18637	547	11	.	.	.
18637	548	1	Jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	548	2	538	538	CD
18637	548	3	3	3	CD
18637	548	4	.	.	.
18637	549	1	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	549	2	638	638	CD
18637	549	3	Article	article	NN
18637	549	4	IV	IV	NNP
18637	549	5	.	.	.
18637	550	1	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	550	2	relations	relation	NNS
18637	550	3	:	:	:
18637	550	4	Section	section	NN
18637	550	5	1	1	CD
18637	550	6	.	.	.
18637	551	1	Full	full	JJ
18637	551	2	faith	faith	NN
18637	551	3	and	and	CC
18637	551	4	credit	credit	NN
18637	551	5	given	give	VBN
18637	551	6	in	in	IN
18637	551	7	each	each	DT
18637	551	8	State	State	NNP
18637	551	9	647	647	CD
18637	551	10	2	2	CD
18637	551	11	.	.	.
18637	552	1	Citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	552	2	686	686	CD
18637	552	3	3	3	CD
18637	552	4	.	.	.
18637	553	1	New	New	NNP
18637	553	2	States	States	NNP
18637	553	3	and	and	CC
18637	553	4	government	government	NN
18637	553	5	of	of	IN
18637	553	6	Territory	territory	NN
18637	553	7	,	,	,
18637	553	8	etc	etc	FW
18637	553	9	.	.	.
18637	554	1	697	697	CD
18637	554	2	4	4	CD
18637	554	3	.	.	.
18637	555	1	Form	form	NN
18637	555	2	of	of	IN
18637	555	3	State	State	NNP
18637	555	4	government	government	NN
18637	555	5	704	704	CD
18637	555	6	Article	Article	NNP
18637	555	7	V.	V.	NNP
18637	555	8	Mode	Mode	NNP
18637	555	9	of	of	IN
18637	555	10	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	555	11	707	707	CD
18637	555	12	Article	Article	NNP
18637	555	13	VI	VI	NNP
18637	555	14	.	.	.
18637	556	1	Miscellaneous	miscellaneous	JJ
18637	556	2	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	556	3	717	717	CD
18637	556	4	Article	article	NN
18637	556	5	VII	vii	NN
18637	556	6	.	.	.
18637	557	1	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	557	2	741	741	CD
18637	557	3	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	557	4	to	to	IN
18637	557	5	the	the	DT
18637	557	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	557	7	:	:	:
18637	557	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	557	9	1	1	CD
18637	557	10	.	.	.
18637	558	1	Religion	religion	NN
18637	558	2	,	,	,
18637	558	3	free	free	JJ
18637	558	4	speech	speech	NN
18637	558	5	,	,	,
18637	558	6	etc	etc	FW
18637	558	7	.	.	.
18637	559	1	753	753	CD
18637	559	2	2	2	CD
18637	559	3	.	.	.
18637	560	1	Bearing	bear	VBG
18637	560	2	arms	arm	NNS
18637	560	3	811	811	CD
18637	560	4	3	3	CD
18637	560	5	.	.	.
18637	561	1	Quartering	quarter	VBG
18637	561	2	soldiers	soldier	NNS
18637	561	3	815	815	CD
18637	561	4	4	4	CD
18637	561	5	.	.	.
18637	562	1	Searches	search	NNS
18637	562	2	and	and	CC
18637	562	3	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	562	4	819	819	CD
18637	562	5	5	5	CD
18637	562	6	.	.	.
18637	563	1	Rights	right	NNS
18637	563	2	of	of	IN
18637	563	3	persons	person	NNS
18637	563	4	833	833	CD
18637	563	5	6	6	CD
18637	563	6	.	.	.
18637	564	1	Rights	right	NNS
18637	564	2	of	of	IN
18637	564	3	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	564	4	in	in	IN
18637	564	5	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	564	6	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	564	7	873	873	CD
18637	564	8	7	7	CD
18637	564	9	.	.	.
18637	565	1	Civil	civil	JJ
18637	565	2	trials	trial	NNS
18637	565	3	887	887	CD
18637	565	4	8	8	CD
18637	565	5	.	.	.
18637	566	1	Punishment	punishment	NN
18637	566	2	for	for	IN
18637	566	3	crime	crime	NN
18637	566	4	899	899	CD
18637	566	5	9	9	CD
18637	566	6	.	.	.
18637	567	1	Rights	right	NNS
18637	567	2	retained	retain	VBN
18637	567	3	by	by	IN
18637	567	4	the	the	DT
18637	567	5	people	people	NNS
18637	567	6	907	907	CD
18637	567	7	10	10	CD
18637	567	8	.	.	.
18637	568	1	Reserved	Reserved	NNP
18637	568	2	State	State	NNP
18637	568	3	powers	power	NNS
18637	568	4	911	911	CD
18637	568	5	11	11	CD
18637	568	6	.	.	.
18637	569	1	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	569	2	against	against	IN
18637	569	3	States	States	NNP
18637	569	4	923	923	CD
18637	569	5	12	12	CD
18637	569	6	.	.	.
18637	570	1	Election	election	NN
18637	570	2	of	of	IN
18637	570	3	President	President	NNP
18637	570	4	,	,	,
18637	570	5	etc	etc	FW
18637	570	6	.	.	.
18637	571	1	937	937	CD
18637	571	2	13	13	CD
18637	571	3	.	.	.
18637	572	1	Slavery	slavery	NN
18637	572	2	and	and	CC
18637	572	3	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	572	4	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	572	5	945	945	NNP
18637	572	6	Section	Section	NNP
18637	572	7	1	1	CD
18637	572	8	.	.	.
18637	573	1	Prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	573	2	of	of	IN
18637	573	3	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	573	4	and	and	CC
18637	573	5	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	573	6	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	573	7	949	949	CD
18637	573	8	2	2	CD
18637	573	9	.	.	.
18637	574	1	Power	power	NN
18637	574	2	of	of	IN
18637	574	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	574	4	949	949	CD
18637	574	5	14	14	CD
18637	574	6	.	.	.
18637	575	1	Rights	right	NNS
18637	575	2	of	of	IN
18637	575	3	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	575	4	955	955	CD
18637	575	5	Section	section	NN
18637	575	6	1	1	CD
18637	575	7	.	.	.
18637	576	1	Citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	576	2	;	;	:
18637	576	3	due	due	JJ
18637	576	4	process	process	NN
18637	576	5	;	;	:
18637	576	6	equal	equal	JJ
18637	576	7	protection	protection	NN
18637	576	8	963	963	CD
18637	576	9	2	2	CD
18637	576	10	.	.	.
18637	577	1	Apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	577	2	of	of	IN
18637	577	3	representation	representation	NN
18637	577	4	1170	1170	CD
18637	577	5	3	3	CD
18637	577	6	.	.	.
18637	578	1	Disqualification	disqualification	NN
18637	578	2	of	of	IN
18637	578	3	officers	officer	NNS
18637	578	4	1173	1173	CD
18637	578	5	4	4	CD
18637	578	6	.	.	.
18637	579	1	Public	public	JJ
18637	579	2	debt	debt	NN
18637	579	3	;	;	:
18637	579	4	claims	claim	NNS
18637	579	5	for	for	IN
18637	579	6	loss	loss	NN
18637	579	7	of	of	IN
18637	579	8	slaves	slave	NNS
18637	579	9	1174	1174	CD
18637	579	10	5	5	CD
18637	579	11	.	.	.
18637	580	1	Enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	580	2	1175	1175	CD
18637	580	3	15	15	CD
18637	580	4	.	.	.
18637	581	1	Right	right	RB
18637	581	2	of	of	IN
18637	581	3	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	581	4	to	to	TO
18637	581	5	vote	vote	VB
18637	581	6	1179	1179	CD
18637	581	7	Section	section	NN
18637	581	8	1	1	CD
18637	581	9	.	.	.
18637	582	1	Suffrage	suffrage	VB
18637	582	2	not	not	RB
18637	582	3	to	to	TO
18637	582	4	be	be	VB
18637	582	5	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	582	6	for	for	IN
18637	582	7	race	race	NN
18637	582	8	,	,	,
18637	582	9	color	color	NN
18637	582	10	,	,	,
18637	582	11	etc	etc	FW
18637	582	12	.	.	.
18637	583	1	1183	1183	CD
18637	583	2	2	2	CD
18637	583	3	.	.	.
18637	584	1	Power	power	NN
18637	584	2	of	of	IN
18637	584	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	584	4	1183	1183	CD
18637	584	5	16	16	CD
18637	584	6	.	.	.
18637	585	1	Income	income	NN
18637	585	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	585	3	1187	1187	CD
18637	585	4	17	17	CD
18637	585	5	.	.	.
18637	586	1	Popular	popular	JJ
18637	586	2	election	election	NN
18637	586	3	of	of	IN
18637	586	4	Senators	senator	NNS
18637	586	5	1203	1203	CD
18637	586	6	18	18	CD
18637	586	7	.	.	.
18637	587	1	Prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	587	2	of	of	IN
18637	587	3	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	587	4	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	587	5	1209	1209	CD
18637	587	6	Section	section	NN
18637	587	7	1	1	CD
18637	587	8	.	.	.
18637	588	1	Prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	588	2	of	of	IN
18637	588	3	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	588	4	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	588	5	1213	1213	CD
18637	588	6	2	2	CD
18637	588	7	.	.	.
18637	589	1	Concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	589	2	power	power	NN
18637	589	3	to	to	TO
18637	589	4	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	589	5	1213	1213	CD
18637	589	6	3	3	CD
18637	589	7	.	.	.
18637	590	1	Time	time	NN
18637	590	2	limit	limit	NN
18637	590	3	on	on	IN
18637	590	4	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	590	5	1213	1213	CD
18637	590	6	19	19	CD
18637	590	7	.	.	.
18637	591	1	Equal	equal	JJ
18637	591	2	suffrage	suffrage	JJ
18637	591	3	1215	1215	CD
18637	591	4	20	20	CD
18637	591	5	.	.	.
18637	592	1	Commencement	commencement	NN
18637	592	2	of	of	IN
18637	592	3	the	the	DT
18637	592	4	terms	term	NNS
18637	592	5	of	of	IN
18637	592	6	the	the	DT
18637	592	7	President	President	NNP
18637	592	8	,	,	,
18637	592	9	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	592	10	President	President	NNP
18637	592	11	,	,	,
18637	592	12	and	and	CC
18637	592	13	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	592	14	of	of	IN
18637	592	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	592	16	,	,	,
18637	592	17	etc	etc	FW
18637	592	18	.	.	.
18637	593	1	1221	1221	CD
18637	593	2	Section	section	NN
18637	593	3	1	1	CD
18637	593	4	.	.	.
18637	594	1	Commencement	commencement	NN
18637	594	2	of	of	IN
18637	594	3	terms	term	NNS
18637	594	4	of	of	IN
18637	594	5	President	President	NNP
18637	594	6	,	,	,
18637	594	7	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	594	8	President	President	NNP
18637	594	9	,	,	,
18637	594	10	Senators	Senators	NNP
18637	594	11	,	,	,
18637	594	12	and	and	CC
18637	594	13	Representatives	representative	NNS
18637	594	14	1225	1225	CD
18637	594	15	2	2	CD
18637	594	16	.	.	.
18637	595	1	Meeting	meet	VBG
18637	595	2	of	of	IN
18637	595	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	595	4	1225	1225	CD
18637	595	5	3	3	CD
18637	595	6	.	.	.
18637	596	1	Death	death	NN
18637	596	2	or	or	CC
18637	596	3	disqualification	disqualification	NN
18637	596	4	of	of	IN
18637	596	5	President	President	NNP
18637	596	6	elect	elect	NNP
18637	596	7	1225	1225	CD
18637	596	8	4	4	CD
18637	596	9	.	.	.
18637	597	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	597	2	to	to	TO
18637	597	3	provide	provide	VB
18637	597	4	for	for	IN
18637	597	5	case	case	NN
18637	597	6	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	597	7	death	death	NN
18637	597	8	occurs	occur	VBZ
18637	597	9	among	among	IN
18637	597	10	those	those	DT
18637	597	11	from	from	IN
18637	597	12	whom	whom	WP
18637	597	13	House	House	NNP
18637	597	14	chooses	choose	VBZ
18637	597	15	a	a	DT
18637	597	16	President	President	NNP
18637	597	17	1225	1225	CD
18637	597	18	5	5	CD
18637	597	19	.	.	.
18637	598	1	Date	date	NN
18637	598	2	of	of	IN
18637	598	3	effect	effect	NN
18637	598	4	1226	1226	CD
18637	598	5	6	6	CD
18637	598	6	.	.	.
18637	599	1	Time	time	NN
18637	599	2	limit	limit	NN
18637	599	3	on	on	IN
18637	599	4	ratificn	ratificn	NNP
18637	599	5	1226	1226	CD
18637	599	6	21	21	CD
18637	599	7	.	.	.
18637	600	1	Repeal	repeal	NN
18637	600	2	of	of	IN
18637	600	3	Eighteenth	Eighteenth	NNP
18637	600	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	600	5	1227	1227	CD
18637	600	6	Section	Section	NNP
18637	600	7	1	1	CD
18637	600	8	.	.	.
18637	601	1	Repeal	repeal	NN
18637	601	2	of	of	IN
18637	601	3	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	601	4	1231	1231	CD
18637	601	5	2	2	CD
18637	601	6	.	.	.
18637	602	1	Transportation	transportation	NN
18637	602	2	into	into	IN
18637	602	3	States	States	NNPS
18637	602	4	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	602	5	1231	1231	CD
18637	602	6	3	3	CD
18637	602	7	.	.	.
18637	603	1	Time	time	NN
18637	603	2	limit	limit	NN
18637	603	3	on	on	IN
18637	603	4	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	603	5	1231	1231	CD
18637	603	6	22	22	CD
18637	603	7	.	.	.
18637	604	1	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	604	2	Tenure	Tenure	NNP
18637	604	3	1235	1235	CD
18637	604	4	Section	Section	NNP
18637	604	5	1	1	CD
18637	604	6	.	.	.
18637	605	1	Restriction	restriction	NN
18637	605	2	on	on	IN
18637	605	3	Number	Number	NNP
18637	605	4	of	of	IN
18637	605	5	terms	term	NNS
18637	605	6	1237	1237	CD
18637	605	7	2	2	CD
18637	605	8	.	.	.
18637	606	1	Time	time	NN
18637	606	2	limit	limit	NN
18637	606	3	on	on	IN
18637	606	4	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	606	5	1237	1237	CD
18637	606	6	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	606	7	of	of	IN
18637	606	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	606	9	held	hold	VBD
18637	606	10	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	606	11	in	in	IN
18637	606	12	whole	whole	NN
18637	606	13	or	or	CC
18637	606	14	in	in	IN
18637	606	15	part	part	NN
18637	606	16	by	by	IN
18637	606	17	the	the	DT
18637	606	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	606	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	606	20	of	of	IN
18637	606	21	the	the	DT
18637	606	22	United	United	NNP
18637	606	23	States	States	NNP
18637	606	24	1239	1239	CD
18637	606	25	Table	table	NN
18637	606	26	of	of	IN
18637	606	27	Cases	case	NNS
18637	606	28	1257	1257	CD
18637	606	29	Index	Index	NNP
18637	606	30	1337	1337	CD
18637	606	31	THE	the	DT
18637	606	32	CONSTITUTION	CONSTITUTION	NNP
18637	606	33	OF	of	IN
18637	606	34	THE	the	DT
18637	606	35	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	606	36	STATES	state	NNS
18637	606	37	OF	of	IN
18637	606	38	AMERICA	AMERICA	NNP
18637	606	39	HISTORICAL	HISTORICAL	NNP
18637	606	40	NOTE	NOTE	NNP
18637	606	41	ON	on	IN
18637	606	42	FORMATION	formation	NN
18637	606	43	OF	of	IN
18637	606	44	THE	the	DT
18637	606	45	CONSTITUTION	CONSTITUTION	NNP
18637	606	46	In	in	IN
18637	606	47	June	June	NNP
18637	606	48	1774	1774	CD
18637	606	49	,	,	,
18637	606	50	the	the	DT
18637	606	51	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	606	52	and	and	CC
18637	606	53	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	606	54	assemblies	assembly	NNS
18637	606	55	independently	independently	RB
18637	606	56	proposed	propose	VBD
18637	606	57	an	an	DT
18637	606	58	intercolonial	intercolonial	JJ
18637	606	59	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	606	60	of	of	IN
18637	606	61	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	606	62	from	from	IN
18637	606	63	the	the	DT
18637	606	64	several	several	JJ
18637	606	65	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	606	66	to	to	TO
18637	606	67	restore	restore	VB
18637	606	68	union	union	NN
18637	606	69	and	and	CC
18637	606	70	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	606	71	between	between	IN
18637	606	72	Great	Great	NNP
18637	606	73	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	606	74	and	and	CC
18637	606	75	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	606	76	American	American	NNP
18637	606	77	Colonies	Colonies	NNPS
18637	606	78	.	.	.
18637	607	1	Pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	607	2	to	to	IN
18637	607	3	these	these	DT
18637	607	4	calls	call	NNS
18637	607	5	there	there	RB
18637	607	6	met	meet	VBD
18637	607	7	in	in	IN
18637	607	8	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	607	9	in	in	IN
18637	607	10	September	September	NNP
18637	607	11	of	of	IN
18637	607	12	that	that	DT
18637	607	13	year	year	NN
18637	607	14	the	the	DT
18637	607	15	first	first	JJ
18637	607	16	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	607	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	607	18	,	,	,
18637	607	19	composed	compose	VBN
18637	607	20	of	of	IN
18637	607	21	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	607	22	from	from	IN
18637	607	23	12	12	CD
18637	607	24	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	607	25	.	.	.
18637	608	1	On	on	IN
18637	608	2	October	October	NNP
18637	608	3	14	14	CD
18637	608	4	,	,	,
18637	608	5	1774	1774	CD
18637	608	6	,	,	,
18637	608	7	the	the	DT
18637	608	8	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	608	9	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	608	10	what	what	WP
18637	608	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	608	12	come	come	VBN
18637	608	13	to	to	TO
18637	608	14	be	be	VB
18637	608	15	known	know	VBN
18637	608	16	as	as	IN
18637	608	17	the	the	DT
18637	608	18	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
18637	608	19	and	and	CC
18637	608	20	Resolves	Resolves	NNPS
18637	608	21	of	of	IN
18637	608	22	the	the	DT
18637	608	23	First	First	NNP
18637	608	24	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	608	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	608	26	.	.	.
18637	609	1	In	in	IN
18637	609	2	that	that	DT
18637	609	3	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	609	4	,	,	,
18637	609	5	addressed	address	VBD
18637	609	6	to	to	IN
18637	609	7	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	609	8	Majesty	Majesty	NNP
18637	609	9	and	and	CC
18637	609	10	to	to	IN
18637	609	11	the	the	DT
18637	609	12	people	people	NNS
18637	609	13	of	of	IN
18637	609	14	Great	Great	NNP
18637	609	15	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	609	16	,	,	,
18637	609	17	there	there	EX
18637	609	18	was	be	VBD
18637	609	19	embodied	embody	VBN
18637	609	20	a	a	DT
18637	609	21	statement	statement	NN
18637	609	22	of	of	IN
18637	609	23	rights	right	NNS
18637	609	24	and	and	CC
18637	609	25	principles	principle	NNS
18637	609	26	,	,	,
18637	609	27	many	many	DT
18637	609	28	of	of	IN
18637	609	29	which	which	WDT
18637	609	30	were	be	VBD
18637	609	31	later	later	RB
18637	609	32	to	to	TO
18637	609	33	be	be	VB
18637	609	34	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	609	35	in	in	IN
18637	609	36	the	the	DT
18637	609	37	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
18637	609	38	of	of	IN
18637	609	39	Independence	Independence	NNP
18637	609	40	and	and	CC
18637	609	41	the	the	DT
18637	609	42	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	609	43	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	609	44	.	.	.
18637	610	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	610	2	a	a	LS
18637	610	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	610	4	This	this	DT
18637	610	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	610	6	adjourned	adjourn	VBD
18637	610	7	in	in	IN
18637	610	8	October	October	NNP
18637	610	9	with	with	IN
18637	610	10	a	a	DT
18637	610	11	recommendation	recommendation	NN
18637	610	12	that	that	IN
18637	610	13	another	another	DT
18637	610	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	610	15	be	be	VB
18637	610	16	held	hold	VBN
18637	610	17	in	in	IN
18637	610	18	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	610	19	the	the	DT
18637	610	20	following	follow	VBG
18637	610	21	May.	May	NNP
18637	611	1	Before	before	IN
18637	611	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	611	3	successor	successor	NN
18637	611	4	met	meet	VBD
18637	611	5	,	,	,
18637	611	6	the	the	DT
18637	611	7	battle	battle	NN
18637	611	8	of	of	IN
18637	611	9	Lexington	Lexington	NNP
18637	611	10	had	have	VBD
18637	611	11	been	be	VBN
18637	611	12	fought	fight	VBN
18637	611	13	.	.	.
18637	612	1	In	in	IN
18637	612	2	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	612	3	the	the	DT
18637	612	4	colonists	colonist	NNS
18637	612	5	had	have	VBD
18637	612	6	organized	organize	VBN
18637	612	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	612	8	own	own	JJ
18637	612	9	government	government	NN
18637	612	10	in	in	IN
18637	612	11	defiance	defiance	NN
18637	612	12	of	of	IN
18637	612	13	the	the	DT
18637	612	14	royal	royal	JJ
18637	612	15	governor	governor	NN
18637	612	16	and	and	CC
18637	612	17	the	the	DT
18637	612	18	Crown	Crown	NNP
18637	612	19	.	.	.
18637	613	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	613	2	,	,	,
18637	613	3	by	by	IN
18637	613	4	general	general	JJ
18637	613	5	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	613	6	and	and	CC
18637	613	7	by	by	IN
18637	613	8	common	common	JJ
18637	613	9	consent	consent	NN
18637	613	10	,	,	,
18637	613	11	the	the	DT
18637	613	12	second	second	JJ
18637	613	13	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	613	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	613	15	assumed	assume	VBD
18637	613	16	control	control	NN
18637	613	17	of	of	IN
18637	613	18	the	the	DT
18637	613	19	"	"	``
18637	613	20	Twelve	Twelve	NNP
18637	613	21	United	United	NNP
18637	613	22	Colonies	Colonies	NNPS
18637	613	23	"	"	''
18637	613	24	,	,	,
18637	613	25	soon	soon	RB
18637	613	26	to	to	TO
18637	613	27	become	become	VB
18637	613	28	the	the	DT
18637	613	29	"	"	``
18637	613	30	Thirteen	Thirteen	NNP
18637	613	31	United	United	NNP
18637	613	32	Colonies	Colonies	NNPS
18637	613	33	"	"	''
18637	613	34	by	by	IN
18637	613	35	the	the	DT
18637	613	36	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	613	37	of	of	IN
18637	613	38	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	613	39	.	.	.
18637	614	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	614	2	became	become	VBD
18637	614	3	a	a	DT
18637	614	4	_	_	NNP
18637	614	5	de	de	FW
18637	614	6	facto	facto	FW
18637	614	7	_	_	NNP
18637	614	8	government	government	NN
18637	614	9	:	:	:
18637	614	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	614	11	called	call	VBD
18637	614	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	614	13	the	the	DT
18637	614	14	other	other	JJ
18637	614	15	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	614	16	to	to	TO
18637	614	17	assist	assist	VB
18637	614	18	in	in	IN
18637	614	19	the	the	DT
18637	614	20	defense	defense	NN
18637	614	21	of	of	IN
18637	614	22	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	614	23	;	;	:
18637	614	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	614	25	issued	issue	VBD
18637	614	26	bills	bill	NNS
18637	614	27	of	of	IN
18637	614	28	credit	credit	NN
18637	614	29	;	;	:
18637	614	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	614	31	took	take	VBD
18637	614	32	steps	step	NNS
18637	614	33	to	to	TO
18637	614	34	organize	organize	VB
18637	614	35	a	a	DT
18637	614	36	military	military	JJ
18637	614	37	force	force	NN
18637	614	38	,	,	,
18637	614	39	and	and	CC
18637	614	40	appointed	appoint	VBD
18637	614	41	George	George	NNP
18637	614	42	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	614	43	commander	commander	NN
18637	614	44	in	in	IN
18637	614	45	chief	chief	NN
18637	614	46	of	of	IN
18637	614	47	the	the	DT
18637	614	48	Army	Army	NNP
18637	614	49	.	.	.
18637	615	1	While	while	IN
18637	615	2	the	the	DT
18637	615	3	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	615	4	of	of	IN
18637	615	5	the	the	DT
18637	615	6	causes	cause	NNS
18637	615	7	and	and	CC
18637	615	8	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	615	9	of	of	IN
18637	615	10	taking	take	VBG
18637	615	11	up	up	RP
18637	615	12	arms	arm	NNS
18637	615	13	of	of	IN
18637	615	14	July	July	NNP
18637	615	15	6	6	CD
18637	615	16	,	,	,
18637	615	17	1775,[b	1775,[b	CD
18637	615	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	615	19	expressed	express	VBD
18637	615	20	a	a	DT
18637	615	21	"	"	``
18637	615	22	wish	wish	NN
18637	615	23	"	"	''
18637	615	24	to	to	TO
18637	615	25	see	see	VB
18637	615	26	the	the	DT
18637	615	27	union	union	NN
18637	615	28	between	between	IN
18637	615	29	Great	Great	NNP
18637	615	30	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	615	31	and	and	CC
18637	615	32	the	the	DT
18637	615	33	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	615	34	"	"	``
18637	615	35	restored	restore	VBD
18637	615	36	"	"	''
18637	615	37	,	,	,
18637	615	38	sentiment	sentiment	NN
18637	615	39	for	for	IN
18637	615	40	independence	independence	NN
18637	615	41	was	be	VBD
18637	615	42	growing	grow	VBG
18637	615	43	.	.	.
18637	616	1	Finally	finally	RB
18637	616	2	,	,	,
18637	616	3	on	on	IN
18637	616	4	May	May	NNP
18637	616	5	15	15	CD
18637	616	6	,	,	,
18637	616	7	1776	1776	CD
18637	616	8	,	,	,
18637	616	9	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	616	10	instructed	instruct	VBD
18637	616	11	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	616	12	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	616	13	to	to	IN
18637	616	14	the	the	DT
18637	616	15	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	616	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	616	17	to	to	TO
18637	616	18	have	have	VB
18637	616	19	that	that	DT
18637	616	20	body	body	NN
18637	616	21	"	"	''
18637	616	22	declare	declare	VB
18637	616	23	the	the	DT
18637	616	24	united	united	NNP
18637	616	25	colonies	colonies	NNPS
18637	616	26	free	free	JJ
18637	616	27	and	and	CC
18637	616	28	independent	independent	JJ
18637	616	29	States	state	NNS
18637	616	30	.	.	.
18637	617	1	"	"	``
18637	617	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	617	3	c	c	NN
18637	617	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	617	5	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	617	6	on	on	IN
18637	617	7	June	June	NNP
18637	617	8	7	7	CD
18637	617	9	a	a	DT
18637	617	10	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	617	11	was	be	VBD
18637	617	12	introduced	introduce	VBN
18637	617	13	in	in	IN
18637	617	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	617	15	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	617	16	the	the	DT
18637	617	17	union	union	NN
18637	617	18	with	with	IN
18637	617	19	Great	Great	NNP
18637	617	20	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	617	21	dissolved	dissolve	VBN
18637	617	22	,	,	,
18637	617	23	proposing	propose	VBG
18637	617	24	the	the	DT
18637	617	25	formation	formation	NN
18637	617	26	of	of	IN
18637	617	27	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	617	28	alliances	alliance	NNS
18637	617	29	,	,	,
18637	617	30	and	and	CC
18637	617	31	suggesting	suggest	VBG
18637	617	32	the	the	DT
18637	617	33	drafting	drafting	NN
18637	617	34	of	of	IN
18637	617	35	a	a	DT
18637	617	36	plan	plan	NN
18637	617	37	of	of	IN
18637	617	38	confederation	confederation	NN
18637	617	39	to	to	TO
18637	617	40	be	be	VB
18637	617	41	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	617	42	to	to	IN
18637	617	43	the	the	DT
18637	617	44	respective	respective	JJ
18637	617	45	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	617	46	.	.	.
18637	618	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	618	2	d	d	LS
18637	618	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	618	4	Some	some	DT
18637	618	5	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	618	6	argued	argue	VBD
18637	618	7	for	for	IN
18637	618	8	confederation	confederation	NN
18637	618	9	first	first	RB
18637	618	10	and	and	CC
18637	618	11	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	618	12	afterwards	afterwards	RB
18637	618	13	.	.	.
18637	619	1	This	this	DT
18637	619	2	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	619	3	did	do	VBD
18637	619	4	not	not	RB
18637	619	5	prevail	prevail	VB
18637	619	6	.	.	.
18637	620	1	Independence	independence	NN
18637	620	2	was	be	VBD
18637	620	3	declared	declare	VBN
18637	620	4	on	on	IN
18637	620	5	July	July	NNP
18637	620	6	4	4	CD
18637	620	7	,	,	,
18637	620	8	1776	1776	CD
18637	620	9	;	;	:
18637	620	10	the	the	DT
18637	620	11	preparation	preparation	NN
18637	620	12	of	of	IN
18637	620	13	a	a	DT
18637	620	14	plan	plan	NN
18637	620	15	of	of	IN
18637	620	16	confederation	confederation	NN
18637	620	17	was	be	VBD
18637	620	18	postponed	postpone	VBN
18637	620	19	.	.	.
18637	621	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	621	2	was	be	VBD
18637	621	3	not	not	RB
18637	621	4	until	until	IN
18637	621	5	November	November	NNP
18637	621	6	17	17	CD
18637	621	7	,	,	,
18637	621	8	1777	1777	CD
18637	621	9	,	,	,
18637	621	10	that	that	IN
18637	621	11	the	the	DT
18637	621	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	621	13	was	be	VBD
18637	621	14	able	able	JJ
18637	621	15	to	to	TO
18637	621	16	agree	agree	VB
18637	621	17	on	on	IN
18637	621	18	a	a	DT
18637	621	19	form	form	NN
18637	621	20	of	of	IN
18637	621	21	government	government	NN
18637	621	22	which	which	WDT
18637	621	23	stood	stand	VBD
18637	621	24	some	some	DT
18637	621	25	chance	chance	NN
18637	621	26	of	of	IN
18637	621	27	being	be	VBG
18637	621	28	approved	approve	VBN
18637	621	29	by	by	IN
18637	621	30	the	the	DT
18637	621	31	separate	separate	JJ
18637	621	32	States	state	NNS
18637	621	33	.	.	.
18637	622	1	The	the	DT
18637	622	2	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	622	3	of	of	IN
18637	622	4	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	622	5	were	be	VBD
18637	622	6	then	then	RB
18637	622	7	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	622	8	to	to	IN
18637	622	9	the	the	DT
18637	622	10	several	several	JJ
18637	622	11	States	States	NNPS
18637	622	12	,	,	,
18637	622	13	and	and	CC
18637	622	14	on	on	IN
18637	622	15	July	July	NNP
18637	622	16	9	9	CD
18637	622	17	,	,	,
18637	622	18	1778	1778	CD
18637	622	19	,	,	,
18637	622	20	were	be	VBD
18637	622	21	finally	finally	RB
18637	622	22	approved	approve	VBN
18637	622	23	by	by	IN
18637	622	24	a	a	DT
18637	622	25	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	622	26	number	number	NN
18637	622	27	to	to	TO
18637	622	28	become	become	VB
18637	622	29	operative	operative	JJ
18637	622	30	.	.	.
18637	623	1	Weaknesses	weakness	NNS
18637	623	2	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	623	3	in	in	IN
18637	623	4	the	the	DT
18637	623	5	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	623	6	of	of	IN
18637	623	7	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	623	8	became	become	VBD
18637	623	9	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	623	10	before	before	IN
18637	623	11	the	the	DT
18637	623	12	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
18637	623	13	out	out	IN
18637	623	14	of	of	IN
18637	623	15	which	which	WDT
18637	623	16	that	that	DT
18637	623	17	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	623	18	was	be	VBD
18637	623	19	born	bear	VBN
18637	623	20	had	have	VBD
18637	623	21	been	be	VBN
18637	623	22	concluded	conclude	VBN
18637	623	23	.	.	.
18637	624	1	Even	even	RB
18637	624	2	before	before	IN
18637	624	3	the	the	DT
18637	624	4	thirteenth	thirteenth	JJ
18637	624	5	State	State	NNP
18637	624	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	624	7	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	624	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	624	9	conditionally	conditionally	RB
18637	624	10	joined	join	VBD
18637	624	11	the	the	DT
18637	624	12	"	"	``
18637	624	13	firm	firm	JJ
18637	624	14	league	league	NN
18637	624	15	of	of	IN
18637	624	16	friendship	friendship	NN
18637	624	17	"	"	''
18637	624	18	on	on	IN
18637	624	19	March	March	NNP
18637	624	20	1	1	CD
18637	624	21	,	,	,
18637	624	22	1781	1781	CD
18637	624	23	,	,	,
18637	624	24	the	the	DT
18637	624	25	need	need	NN
18637	624	26	for	for	IN
18637	624	27	a	a	DT
18637	624	28	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	624	29	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	624	30	was	be	VBD
18637	624	31	widely	widely	RB
18637	624	32	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	624	33	.	.	.
18637	625	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	625	2	under	under	IN
18637	625	3	the	the	DT
18637	625	4	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	625	5	lacked	lack	VBD
18637	625	6	authority	authority	NN
18637	625	7	to	to	TO
18637	625	8	levy	levy	VB
18637	625	9	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	625	10	.	.	.
18637	626	1	She	-PRON-	PRP
18637	626	2	could	could	MD
18637	626	3	only	only	RB
18637	626	4	request	request	VB
18637	626	5	the	the	DT
18637	626	6	States	States	NNPS
18637	626	7	to	to	TO
18637	626	8	contribute	contribute	VB
18637	626	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	626	10	fair	fair	JJ
18637	626	11	share	share	NN
18637	626	12	to	to	IN
18637	626	13	the	the	DT
18637	626	14	common	common	JJ
18637	626	15	treasury	treasury	NN
18637	626	16	,	,	,
18637	626	17	but	but	CC
18637	626	18	the	the	DT
18637	626	19	requested	requested	JJ
18637	626	20	amounts	amount	NNS
18637	626	21	were	be	VBD
18637	626	22	not	not	RB
18637	626	23	forthcoming	forthcoming	JJ
18637	626	24	.	.	.
18637	627	1	To	to	TO
18637	627	2	remedy	remedy	VB
18637	627	3	this	this	DT
18637	627	4	defect	defect	NN
18637	627	5	,	,	,
18637	627	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	627	7	applied	apply	VBD
18637	627	8	to	to	IN
18637	627	9	the	the	DT
18637	627	10	States	States	NNP
18637	627	11	for	for	IN
18637	627	12	power	power	NN
18637	627	13	to	to	TO
18637	627	14	lay	lay	VB
18637	627	15	duties	duty	NNS
18637	627	16	and	and	CC
18637	627	17	secure	secure	VB
18637	627	18	the	the	DT
18637	627	19	public	public	JJ
18637	627	20	debts	debt	NNS
18637	627	21	.	.	.
18637	628	1	Twelve	twelve	CD
18637	628	2	States	States	NNPS
18637	628	3	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	628	4	to	to	IN
18637	628	5	such	such	PDT
18637	628	6	an	an	DT
18637	628	7	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	628	8	,	,	,
18637	628	9	but	but	CC
18637	628	10	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	628	11	Island	Island	NNP
18637	628	12	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	628	13	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	628	14	consent	consent	NN
18637	628	15	,	,	,
18637	628	16	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	628	17	defeating	defeat	VBG
18637	628	18	the	the	DT
18637	628	19	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	628	20	.	.	.
18637	629	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	629	2	was	be	VBD
18637	629	3	emphasized	emphasize	VBN
18637	629	4	a	a	DT
18637	629	5	second	second	JJ
18637	629	6	weakness	weakness	NN
18637	629	7	in	in	IN
18637	629	8	the	the	DT
18637	629	9	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	629	10	of	of	IN
18637	629	11	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	629	12	,	,	,
18637	629	13	namely	namely	RB
18637	629	14	,	,	,
18637	629	15	the	the	DT
18637	629	16	_	_	NNP
18637	629	17	liberum	liberum	NNP
18637	629	18	veto	veto	NN
18637	629	19	_	_	NNP
18637	629	20	which	which	WDT
18637	629	21	each	each	DT
18637	629	22	State	state	NN
18637	629	23	possessed	possess	VBD
18637	629	24	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	629	25	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	629	26	to	to	IN
18637	629	27	that	that	DT
18637	629	28	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	629	29	were	be	VBD
18637	629	30	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	629	31	.	.	.
18637	630	1	Not	not	RB
18637	630	2	only	only	RB
18637	630	3	did	do	VBD
18637	630	4	all	all	DT
18637	630	5	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	630	6	have	have	VB
18637	630	7	to	to	TO
18637	630	8	be	be	VB
18637	630	9	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	630	10	by	by	IN
18637	630	11	each	each	DT
18637	630	12	of	of	IN
18637	630	13	the	the	DT
18637	630	14	13	13	CD
18637	630	15	States	States	NNPS
18637	630	16	,	,	,
18637	630	17	but	but	CC
18637	630	18	all	all	DT
18637	630	19	important	important	JJ
18637	630	20	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	630	21	needed	need	VBD
18637	630	22	the	the	DT
18637	630	23	approval	approval	NN
18637	630	24	of	of	IN
18637	630	25	9	9	CD
18637	630	26	States	state	NNS
18637	630	27	.	.	.
18637	631	1	With	with	IN
18637	631	2	several	several	JJ
18637	631	3	delegations	delegation	NNS
18637	631	4	often	often	RB
18637	631	5	absent	absent	JJ
18637	631	6	,	,	,
18637	631	7	one	one	CD
18637	631	8	or	or	CC
18637	631	9	two	two	CD
18637	631	10	States	state	NNS
18637	631	11	were	be	VBD
18637	631	12	able	able	JJ
18637	631	13	to	to	TO
18637	631	14	defeat	defeat	VB
18637	631	15	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	631	16	proposals	proposal	NNS
18637	631	17	of	of	IN
18637	631	18	major	major	JJ
18637	631	19	importance	importance	NN
18637	631	20	.	.	.
18637	632	1	Other	other	JJ
18637	632	2	imperfections	imperfection	NNS
18637	632	3	in	in	IN
18637	632	4	the	the	DT
18637	632	5	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	632	6	of	of	IN
18637	632	7	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	632	8	also	also	RB
18637	632	9	proved	prove	VBD
18637	632	10	embarrassing	embarrassing	JJ
18637	632	11	.	.	.
18637	633	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	633	2	could	could	MD
18637	633	3	,	,	,
18637	633	4	for	for	IN
18637	633	5	example	example	NN
18637	633	6	,	,	,
18637	633	7	negotiate	negotiate	VB
18637	633	8	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	633	9	with	with	IN
18637	633	10	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	633	11	powers	power	NNS
18637	633	12	,	,	,
18637	633	13	but	but	CC
18637	633	14	all	all	DT
18637	633	15	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	633	16	had	have	VBD
18637	633	17	to	to	TO
18637	633	18	be	be	VB
18637	633	19	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	633	20	by	by	IN
18637	633	21	the	the	DT
18637	633	22	several	several	JJ
18637	633	23	States	state	NNS
18637	633	24	.	.	.
18637	634	1	Even	even	RB
18637	634	2	when	when	WRB
18637	634	3	a	a	DT
18637	634	4	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	634	5	was	be	VBD
18637	634	6	approved	approve	VBN
18637	634	7	,	,	,
18637	634	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	634	9	lacked	lack	VBD
18637	634	10	authority	authority	NN
18637	634	11	to	to	TO
18637	634	12	secure	secure	VB
18637	634	13	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	634	14	to	to	IN
18637	634	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	634	16	stipulations	stipulation	NNS
18637	634	17	.	.	.
18637	635	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	635	2	could	could	MD
18637	635	3	not	not	RB
18637	635	4	act	act	VB
18637	635	5	directly	directly	RB
18637	635	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	635	7	the	the	DT
18637	635	8	States	States	NNPS
18637	635	9	or	or	CC
18637	635	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	635	11	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	635	12	.	.	.
18637	636	1	Under	under	IN
18637	636	2	such	such	JJ
18637	636	3	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	636	4	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	636	5	nations	nation	NNS
18637	636	6	doubted	doubt	VBD
18637	636	7	the	the	DT
18637	636	8	value	value	NN
18637	636	9	of	of	IN
18637	636	10	a	a	DT
18637	636	11	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	636	12	with	with	IN
18637	636	13	the	the	DT
18637	636	14	new	new	NNP
18637	636	15	republic	republic	NN
18637	636	16	.	.	.
18637	637	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	637	2	,	,	,
18637	637	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	637	4	had	have	VBD
18637	637	5	no	no	DT
18637	637	6	authority	authority	NN
18637	637	7	to	to	TO
18637	637	8	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	637	9	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	637	10	or	or	CC
18637	637	11	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	637	12	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	637	13	.	.	.
18637	638	1	Legislation	legislation	NN
18637	638	2	in	in	IN
18637	638	3	this	this	DT
18637	638	4	field	field	NN
18637	638	5	,	,	,
18637	638	6	subject	subject	JJ
18637	638	7	to	to	IN
18637	638	8	unimportant	unimportant	JJ
18637	638	9	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	638	10	,	,	,
18637	638	11	was	be	VBD
18637	638	12	left	leave	VBN
18637	638	13	to	to	IN
18637	638	14	the	the	DT
18637	638	15	individual	individual	JJ
18637	638	16	States	States	NNP
18637	638	17	.	.	.
18637	639	1	Disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	639	2	between	between	IN
18637	639	3	States	state	NNS
18637	639	4	with	with	IN
18637	639	5	common	common	JJ
18637	639	6	interests	interest	NNS
18637	639	7	in	in	IN
18637	639	8	the	the	DT
18637	639	9	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	639	10	of	of	IN
18637	639	11	certain	certain	JJ
18637	639	12	rivers	river	NNS
18637	639	13	and	and	CC
18637	639	14	bays	bay	NNS
18637	639	15	were	be	VBD
18637	639	16	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
18637	639	17	.	.	.
18637	640	1	Discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	640	2	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	640	3	were	be	VBD
18637	640	4	followed	follow	VBN
18637	640	5	by	by	IN
18637	640	6	reprisals	reprisal	NNS
18637	640	7	.	.	.
18637	641	1	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	641	2	,	,	,
18637	641	3	recognizing	recognize	VBG
18637	641	4	the	the	DT
18637	641	5	need	need	NN
18637	641	6	for	for	IN
18637	641	7	an	an	DT
18637	641	8	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	641	9	with	with	IN
18637	641	10	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	641	11	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	641	12	the	the	DT
18637	641	13	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	641	14	and	and	CC
18637	641	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	641	16	of	of	IN
18637	641	17	the	the	DT
18637	641	18	Potomac	Potomac	NNP
18637	641	19	River	River	NNP
18637	641	20	,	,	,
18637	641	21	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	641	22	in	in	IN
18637	641	23	June	June	NNP
18637	641	24	1784	1784	CD
18637	641	25	,	,	,
18637	641	26	four	four	CD
18637	641	27	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	641	28	to	to	TO
18637	641	29	"	"	''
18637	641	30	frame	frame	VB
18637	641	31	such	such	JJ
18637	641	32	liberal	liberal	JJ
18637	641	33	and	and	CC
18637	641	34	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	641	35	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	641	36	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	641	37	the	the	DT
18637	641	38	said	say	VBN
18637	641	39	river	river	NN
18637	641	40	as	as	IN
18637	641	41	may	may	MD
18637	641	42	be	be	VB
18637	641	43	mutually	mutually	RB
18637	641	44	advantageous	advantageous	JJ
18637	641	45	to	to	IN
18637	641	46	the	the	DT
18637	641	47	two	two	CD
18637	641	48	States	States	NNPS
18637	641	49	.	.	.
18637	641	50	"	"	''
18637	642	1	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	642	2	in	in	IN
18637	642	3	January	January	NNP
18637	642	4	1785	1785	CD
18637	642	5	responded	respond	VBD
18637	642	6	to	to	IN
18637	642	7	the	the	DT
18637	642	8	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	642	9	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	642	10	by	by	IN
18637	642	11	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	642	12	a	a	DT
18637	642	13	like	like	JJ
18637	642	14	number	number	NN
18637	642	15	of	of	IN
18637	642	16	commissioners[e	commissioners[e	NNP
18637	642	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	642	18	"	"	``
18637	642	19	for	for	IN
18637	642	20	the	the	DT
18637	642	21	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	642	22	of	of	IN
18637	642	23	settling	settle	VBG
18637	642	24	the	the	DT
18637	642	25	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	642	26	and	and	CC
18637	642	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	642	28	over	over	IN
18637	642	29	that	that	DT
18637	642	30	part	part	NN
18637	642	31	of	of	IN
18637	642	32	the	the	DT
18637	642	33	bay	bay	NN
18637	642	34	of	of	IN
18637	642	35	Chesapeake	Chesapeake	NNP
18637	642	36	which	which	WDT
18637	642	37	lies	lie	VBZ
18637	642	38	within	within	IN
18637	642	39	the	the	DT
18637	642	40	limits	limit	NNS
18637	642	41	of	of	IN
18637	642	42	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	642	43	,	,	,
18637	642	44	and	and	CC
18637	642	45	over	over	IN
18637	642	46	the	the	DT
18637	642	47	rivers	river	NNS
18637	642	48	Potomac	Potomac	NNP
18637	642	49	and	and	CC
18637	642	50	Pocomoke	Pocomoke	NNP
18637	642	51	"	"	''
18637	642	52	with	with	IN
18637	642	53	full	full	JJ
18637	642	54	power	power	NN
18637	642	55	on	on	IN
18637	642	56	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	642	57	of	of	IN
18637	642	58	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	642	59	"	"	''
18637	642	60	to	to	TO
18637	642	61	adjudge	adjudge	VB
18637	642	62	and	and	CC
18637	642	63	settle	settle	VB
18637	642	64	the	the	DT
18637	642	65	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	642	66	to	to	TO
18637	642	67	be	be	VB
18637	642	68	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	642	69	by	by	IN
18637	642	70	the	the	DT
18637	642	71	said	say	VBN
18637	642	72	States	States	NNP
18637	642	73	,	,	,
18637	642	74	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	642	75	,	,	,
18637	642	76	over	over	IN
18637	642	77	the	the	DT
18637	642	78	waters	water	NNS
18637	642	79	and	and	CC
18637	642	80	navigations	navigation	NNS
18637	642	81	of	of	IN
18637	642	82	the	the	DT
18637	642	83	same	same	JJ
18637	642	84	.	.	.
18637	643	1	"	"	``
18637	643	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	643	3	f	f	NNP
18637	643	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	643	5	At	at	IN
18637	643	6	the	the	DT
18637	643	7	invitation	invitation	NN
18637	643	8	of	of	IN
18637	643	9	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	643	10	the	the	DT
18637	643	11	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	643	12	met	meet	VBD
18637	643	13	at	at	IN
18637	643	14	Mount	Mount	NNP
18637	643	15	Vernon	Vernon	NNP
18637	643	16	,	,	,
18637	643	17	in	in	IN
18637	643	18	March	March	NNP
18637	643	19	1785	1785	CD
18637	643	20	,	,	,
18637	643	21	and	and	CC
18637	643	22	drafted	draft	VBD
18637	643	23	a	a	DT
18637	643	24	compact	compact	JJ
18637	643	25	which	which	WDT
18637	643	26	,	,	,
18637	643	27	in	in	IN
18637	643	28	many	many	JJ
18637	643	29	of	of	IN
18637	643	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	643	31	details	detail	NNS
18637	643	32	relative	relative	JJ
18637	643	33	to	to	IN
18637	643	34	the	the	DT
18637	643	35	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	643	36	and	and	CC
18637	643	37	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	643	38	of	of	IN
18637	643	39	the	the	DT
18637	643	40	Potomac	Potomac	NNP
18637	643	41	,	,	,
18637	643	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	643	43	still	still	RB
18637	643	44	in	in	IN
18637	643	45	force	force	NN
18637	643	46	.	.	.
18637	644	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	644	2	g	g	NN
18637	644	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	644	4	What	what	WP
18637	644	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	644	6	more	more	RBR
18637	644	7	important	important	JJ
18637	644	8	,	,	,
18637	644	9	the	the	DT
18637	644	10	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	644	11	submitted	submit	VBD
18637	644	12	to	to	IN
18637	644	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	644	14	respective	respective	JJ
18637	644	15	States	state	NNS
18637	644	16	a	a	DT
18637	644	17	report	report	NN
18637	644	18	in	in	IN
18637	644	19	favor	favor	NN
18637	644	20	of	of	IN
18637	644	21	a	a	DT
18637	644	22	convention	convention	NN
18637	644	23	of	of	IN
18637	644	24	all	all	PDT
18637	644	25	the	the	DT
18637	644	26	States	States	NNPS
18637	644	27	"	"	''
18637	644	28	to	to	TO
18637	644	29	take	take	VB
18637	644	30	into	into	IN
18637	644	31	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	644	32	the	the	DT
18637	644	33	trade	trade	NN
18637	644	34	and	and	CC
18637	644	35	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	644	36	"	"	''
18637	644	37	of	of	IN
18637	644	38	the	the	DT
18637	644	39	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	644	40	.	.	.
18637	645	1	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	645	2	,	,	,
18637	645	3	in	in	IN
18637	645	4	January	January	NNP
18637	645	5	1786	1786	CD
18637	645	6	,	,	,
18637	645	7	advocated	advocate	VBD
18637	645	8	such	such	PDT
18637	645	9	a	a	DT
18637	645	10	convention	convention	NN
18637	645	11	,	,	,
18637	645	12	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	645	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	645	14	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	645	15	to	to	TO
18637	645	16	meet	meet	VB
18637	645	17	with	with	IN
18637	645	18	those	those	DT
18637	645	19	of	of	IN
18637	645	20	other	other	JJ
18637	645	21	States	States	NNPS
18637	645	22	,	,	,
18637	645	23	at	at	IN
18637	645	24	a	a	DT
18637	645	25	time	time	NN
18637	645	26	and	and	CC
18637	645	27	place	place	NN
18637	645	28	to	to	TO
18637	645	29	be	be	VB
18637	645	30	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	645	31	on	on	RP
18637	645	32	,	,	,
18637	645	33	"	"	``
18637	645	34	to	to	TO
18637	645	35	take	take	VB
18637	645	36	into	into	IN
18637	645	37	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	645	38	the	the	DT
18637	645	39	trade	trade	NN
18637	645	40	of	of	IN
18637	645	41	the	the	DT
18637	645	42	United	United	NNP
18637	645	43	States	States	NNP
18637	645	44	;	;	:
18637	645	45	to	to	TO
18637	645	46	examine	examine	VB
18637	645	47	the	the	DT
18637	645	48	relative	relative	JJ
18637	645	49	situations	situation	NNS
18637	645	50	and	and	CC
18637	645	51	trade	trade	NN
18637	645	52	of	of	IN
18637	645	53	the	the	DT
18637	645	54	said	say	VBN
18637	645	55	States	state	NNS
18637	645	56	;	;	:
18637	645	57	to	to	TO
18637	645	58	consider	consider	VB
18637	645	59	how	how	WRB
18637	645	60	far	far	RB
18637	645	61	a	a	DT
18637	645	62	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	645	63	system	system	NN
18637	645	64	in	in	IN
18637	645	65	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	645	66	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	645	67	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	645	68	may	may	MD
18637	645	69	be	be	VB
18637	645	70	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	645	71	to	to	IN
18637	645	72	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	645	73	common	common	JJ
18637	645	74	interest	interest	NN
18637	645	75	and	and	CC
18637	645	76	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	645	77	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	645	78	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	645	79	;	;	:
18637	645	80	and	and	CC
18637	645	81	to	to	TO
18637	645	82	report	report	VB
18637	645	83	to	to	IN
18637	645	84	the	the	DT
18637	645	85	several	several	JJ
18637	645	86	States	States	NNP
18637	645	87	,	,	,
18637	645	88	such	such	PDT
18637	645	89	an	an	DT
18637	645	90	act	act	NN
18637	645	91	relative	relative	JJ
18637	645	92	to	to	IN
18637	645	93	this	this	DT
18637	645	94	great	great	JJ
18637	645	95	object	object	NN
18637	645	96	,	,	,
18637	645	97	as	as	IN
18637	645	98	when	when	WRB
18637	645	99	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	645	100	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	645	101	by	by	IN
18637	645	102	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	645	103	,	,	,
18637	645	104	will	will	MD
18637	645	105	enable	enable	VB
18637	645	106	the	the	DT
18637	645	107	United	United	NNP
18637	645	108	States	States	NNP
18637	645	109	in	in	IN
18637	645	110	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	645	111	,	,	,
18637	645	112	effectually	effectually	RB
18637	645	113	to	to	TO
18637	645	114	provide	provide	VB
18637	645	115	for	for	IN
18637	645	116	the	the	DT
18637	645	117	same	same	JJ
18637	645	118	.	.	.
18637	646	1	"	"	``
18637	646	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	646	3	h	h	NN
18637	646	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	646	5	This	this	DT
18637	646	6	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	646	7	for	for	IN
18637	646	8	a	a	DT
18637	646	9	general	general	JJ
18637	646	10	trade	trade	NN
18637	646	11	convention	convention	NN
18637	646	12	seemingly	seemingly	RB
18637	646	13	met	meet	VBD
18637	646	14	with	with	IN
18637	646	15	general	general	JJ
18637	646	16	approval	approval	NN
18637	646	17	;	;	:
18637	646	18	nine	nine	CD
18637	646	19	States	States	NNP
18637	646	20	appointed	appoint	VBD
18637	646	21	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	646	22	.	.	.
18637	647	1	Under	under	IN
18637	647	2	the	the	DT
18637	647	3	leadership	leadership	NN
18637	647	4	of	of	IN
18637	647	5	the	the	DT
18637	647	6	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	647	7	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	647	8	,	,	,
18637	647	9	which	which	WDT
18637	647	10	included	include	VBD
18637	647	11	Randolph	Randolph	NNP
18637	647	12	and	and	CC
18637	647	13	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	647	14	,	,	,
18637	647	15	Annapolis	Annapolis	NNP
18637	647	16	was	be	VBD
18637	647	17	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	647	18	as	as	IN
18637	647	19	the	the	DT
18637	647	20	place	place	NN
18637	647	21	and	and	CC
18637	647	22	the	the	DT
18637	647	23	first	first	JJ
18637	647	24	Monday	Monday	NNP
18637	647	25	in	in	IN
18637	647	26	September	September	NNP
18637	647	27	1786	1786	CD
18637	647	28	as	as	IN
18637	647	29	the	the	DT
18637	647	30	time	time	NN
18637	647	31	for	for	IN
18637	647	32	the	the	DT
18637	647	33	convention	convention	NN
18637	647	34	.	.	.
18637	648	1	The	the	DT
18637	648	2	attendance	attendance	NN
18637	648	3	at	at	IN
18637	648	4	Annapolis	Annapolis	NNP
18637	648	5	proved	prove	VBD
18637	648	6	disappointing	disappointing	JJ
18637	648	7	.	.	.
18637	649	1	Only	only	RB
18637	649	2	five	five	CD
18637	649	3	States	state	NNS
18637	649	4	--	--	:
18637	649	5	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	649	6	,	,	,
18637	649	7	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	649	8	,	,	,
18637	649	9	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	649	10	,	,	,
18637	649	11	New	New	NNP
18637	649	12	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	649	13	,	,	,
18637	649	14	and	and	CC
18637	649	15	New	New	NNP
18637	649	16	York	York	NNP
18637	649	17	--	--	:
18637	649	18	were	be	VBD
18637	649	19	represented	represent	VBN
18637	649	20	;	;	:
18637	649	21	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	649	22	from	from	IN
18637	649	23	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	649	24	,	,	,
18637	649	25	New	New	NNP
18637	649	26	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	649	27	,	,	,
18637	649	28	North	North	NNP
18637	649	29	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	649	30	,	,	,
18637	649	31	and	and	CC
18637	649	32	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	649	33	Island	Island	NNP
18637	649	34	failed	fail	VBD
18637	649	35	to	to	TO
18637	649	36	attend	attend	VB
18637	649	37	.	.	.
18637	650	1	Because	because	IN
18637	650	2	of	of	IN
18637	650	3	the	the	DT
18637	650	4	small	small	JJ
18637	650	5	representation	representation	NN
18637	650	6	,	,	,
18637	650	7	the	the	DT
18637	650	8	Annapolis	Annapolis	NNP
18637	650	9	convention	convention	NN
18637	650	10	did	do	VBD
18637	650	11	not	not	RB
18637	650	12	deem	deem	VB
18637	650	13	"	"	``
18637	650	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	650	15	advisable	advisable	JJ
18637	650	16	to	to	TO
18637	650	17	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	650	18	on	on	IN
18637	650	19	the	the	DT
18637	650	20	business	business	NN
18637	650	21	of	of	IN
18637	650	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	650	23	mission	mission	NN
18637	650	24	.	.	.
18637	650	25	"	"	''
18637	651	1	After	after	IN
18637	651	2	an	an	DT
18637	651	3	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	651	4	of	of	IN
18637	651	5	views	view	NNS
18637	651	6	,	,	,
18637	651	7	the	the	DT
18637	651	8	Annapolis	Annapolis	NNP
18637	651	9	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	651	10	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	651	11	submitted	submit	VBD
18637	651	12	to	to	IN
18637	651	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	651	14	respective	respective	JJ
18637	651	15	States	state	NNS
18637	651	16	a	a	DT
18637	651	17	report	report	NN
18637	651	18	in	in	IN
18637	651	19	which	which	WDT
18637	651	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	651	21	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	651	22	that	that	IN
18637	651	23	a	a	DT
18637	651	24	convention	convention	NN
18637	651	25	of	of	IN
18637	651	26	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	651	27	from	from	IN
18637	651	28	all	all	PDT
18637	651	29	the	the	DT
18637	651	30	States	States	NNPS
18637	651	31	meet	meet	VBP
18637	651	32	at	at	IN
18637	651	33	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	651	34	on	on	IN
18637	651	35	the	the	DT
18637	651	36	second	second	JJ
18637	651	37	Monday	Monday	NNP
18637	651	38	in	in	IN
18637	651	39	May	May	NNP
18637	651	40	1787	1787	CD
18637	651	41	to	to	TO
18637	651	42	examine	examine	VB
18637	651	43	the	the	DT
18637	651	44	defects	defect	NNS
18637	651	45	in	in	IN
18637	651	46	the	the	DT
18637	651	47	existing	exist	VBG
18637	651	48	system	system	NN
18637	651	49	of	of	IN
18637	651	50	government	government	NN
18637	651	51	and	and	CC
18637	651	52	formulate	formulate	VB
18637	651	53	"	"	``
18637	651	54	a	a	DT
18637	651	55	plan	plan	NN
18637	651	56	for	for	IN
18637	651	57	supplying	supply	VBG
18637	651	58	such	such	JJ
18637	651	59	defects	defect	NNS
18637	651	60	as	as	IN
18637	651	61	may	may	MD
18637	651	62	be	be	VB
18637	651	63	discovered	discover	VBN
18637	651	64	.	.	.
18637	652	1	"	"	``
18637	652	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	652	3	i	i	NN
18637	652	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	652	5	The	the	DT
18637	652	6	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	652	7	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	652	8	acted	act	VBD
18637	652	9	promptly	promptly	RB
18637	652	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	652	11	this	this	DT
18637	652	12	recommendation	recommendation	NN
18637	652	13	and	and	CC
18637	652	14	appointed	appoint	VBD
18637	652	15	a	a	DT
18637	652	16	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	652	17	to	to	TO
18637	652	18	go	go	VB
18637	652	19	to	to	IN
18637	652	20	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	652	21	.	.	.
18637	653	1	Within	within	IN
18637	653	2	a	a	DT
18637	653	3	few	few	JJ
18637	653	4	weeks	week	NNS
18637	653	5	New	New	NNP
18637	653	6	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	653	7	,	,	,
18637	653	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	653	9	,	,	,
18637	653	10	North	North	NNP
18637	653	11	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	653	12	,	,	,
18637	653	13	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	653	14	,	,	,
18637	653	15	and	and	CC
18637	653	16	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	653	17	also	also	RB
18637	653	18	made	make	VBD
18637	653	19	appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	653	20	.	.	.
18637	654	1	New	New	NNP
18637	654	2	York	York	NNP
18637	654	3	and	and	CC
18637	654	4	several	several	JJ
18637	654	5	other	other	JJ
18637	654	6	States	States	NNPS
18637	654	7	hesitated	hesitate	VBD
18637	654	8	on	on	IN
18637	654	9	the	the	DT
18637	654	10	ground	ground	NN
18637	654	11	that	that	IN
18637	654	12	,	,	,
18637	654	13	without	without	IN
18637	654	14	the	the	DT
18637	654	15	consent	consent	NN
18637	654	16	of	of	IN
18637	654	17	the	the	DT
18637	654	18	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	654	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	654	20	,	,	,
18637	654	21	the	the	DT
18637	654	22	work	work	NN
18637	654	23	of	of	IN
18637	654	24	the	the	DT
18637	654	25	convention	convention	NN
18637	654	26	would	would	MD
18637	654	27	be	be	VB
18637	654	28	extra	extra	RB
18637	654	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	654	30	legal	legal	JJ
18637	654	31	;	;	:
18637	654	32	that	that	IN
18637	654	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	654	34	alone	alone	RB
18637	654	35	could	could	MD
18637	654	36	propose	propose	VB
18637	654	37	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	654	38	to	to	IN
18637	654	39	the	the	DT
18637	654	40	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	654	41	of	of	IN
18637	654	42	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	654	43	.	.	.
18637	655	1	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	655	2	was	be	VBD
18637	655	3	quite	quite	RB
18637	655	4	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
18637	655	5	to	to	TO
18637	655	6	attend	attend	VB
18637	655	7	an	an	DT
18637	655	8	irregular	irregular	JJ
18637	655	9	convention	convention	NN
18637	655	10	.	.	.
18637	656	1	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	656	2	approval	approval	NN
18637	656	3	of	of	IN
18637	656	4	the	the	DT
18637	656	5	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	656	6	convention	convention	NN
18637	656	7	became	become	VBD
18637	656	8	,	,	,
18637	656	9	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	656	10	,	,	,
18637	656	11	highly	highly	RB
18637	656	12	important	important	JJ
18637	656	13	.	.	.
18637	657	1	After	after	IN
18637	657	2	some	some	DT
18637	657	3	hesitancy	hesitancy	NN
18637	657	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	657	5	approved	approve	VBD
18637	657	6	the	the	DT
18637	657	7	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	657	8	for	for	IN
18637	657	9	a	a	DT
18637	657	10	convention	convention	NN
18637	657	11	at	at	IN
18637	657	12	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	657	13	"	"	''
18637	657	14	for	for	IN
18637	657	15	the	the	DT
18637	657	16	sole	sole	JJ
18637	657	17	and	and	CC
18637	657	18	express	express	VB
18637	657	19	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	657	20	of	of	IN
18637	657	21	revising	revise	VBG
18637	657	22	the	the	DT
18637	657	23	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	657	24	of	of	IN
18637	657	25	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	657	26	and	and	CC
18637	657	27	reporting	report	VBG
18637	657	28	to	to	IN
18637	657	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	657	30	and	and	CC
18637	657	31	the	the	DT
18637	657	32	several	several	JJ
18637	657	33	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	657	34	such	such	JJ
18637	657	35	alterations	alteration	NNS
18637	657	36	and	and	CC
18637	657	37	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	657	38	therein	therein	RB
18637	657	39	as	as	IN
18637	657	40	shall	shall	MD
18637	657	41	when	when	WRB
18637	657	42	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	657	43	to	to	IN
18637	657	44	in	in	IN
18637	657	45	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	657	46	and	and	CC
18637	657	47	confirmed	confirm	VBN
18637	657	48	by	by	IN
18637	657	49	the	the	DT
18637	657	50	States	States	NNP
18637	657	51	render	render	VBP
18637	657	52	the	the	DT
18637	657	53	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	657	54	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	657	55	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	657	56	to	to	IN
18637	657	57	the	the	DT
18637	657	58	exigencies	exigency	NNS
18637	657	59	of	of	IN
18637	657	60	Government	Government	NNP
18637	657	61	and	and	CC
18637	657	62	the	the	DT
18637	657	63	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	657	64	of	of	IN
18637	657	65	the	the	DT
18637	657	66	Union	Union	NNP
18637	657	67	.	.	.
18637	657	68	"	"	''
18637	658	1	Thereupon	thereupon	RB
18637	658	2	,	,	,
18637	658	3	the	the	DT
18637	658	4	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	658	5	States	States	NNP
18637	658	6	,	,	,
18637	658	7	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	658	8	Island	Island	NNP
18637	658	9	alone	alone	RB
18637	658	10	excepted	except	VBD
18637	658	11	,	,	,
18637	658	12	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	658	13	in	in	IN
18637	658	14	due	due	JJ
18637	658	15	course	course	NN
18637	658	16	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	658	17	to	to	IN
18637	658	18	the	the	DT
18637	658	19	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	658	20	,	,	,
18637	658	21	and	and	CC
18637	658	22	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	658	23	accepted	accept	VBD
18637	658	24	membership	membership	NN
18637	658	25	on	on	IN
18637	658	26	the	the	DT
18637	658	27	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	658	28	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	658	29	.	.	.
18637	659	1	Although	although	IN
18637	659	2	scheduled	schedule	VBN
18637	659	3	to	to	TO
18637	659	4	convene	convene	VB
18637	659	5	on	on	IN
18637	659	6	May	May	NNP
18637	659	7	14	14	CD
18637	659	8	,	,	,
18637	659	9	1787	1787	CD
18637	659	10	,	,	,
18637	659	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	659	12	was	be	VBD
18637	659	13	not	not	RB
18637	659	14	until	until	IN
18637	659	15	May	May	NNP
18637	659	16	25	25	CD
18637	659	17	that	that	DT
18637	659	18	enough	enough	JJ
18637	659	19	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	659	20	were	be	VBD
18637	659	21	present	present	JJ
18637	659	22	to	to	TO
18637	659	23	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	659	24	with	with	IN
18637	659	25	the	the	DT
18637	659	26	organization	organization	NN
18637	659	27	of	of	IN
18637	659	28	the	the	DT
18637	659	29	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	659	30	.	.	.
18637	660	1	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	660	2	was	be	VBD
18637	660	3	elected	elect	VBN
18637	660	4	as	as	IN
18637	660	5	presiding	preside	VBG
18637	660	6	officer	officer	NN
18637	660	7	.	.	.
18637	661	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	661	2	was	be	VBD
18637	661	3	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	661	4	that	that	IN
18637	661	5	the	the	DT
18637	661	6	sessions	session	NNS
18637	661	7	were	be	VBD
18637	661	8	to	to	TO
18637	661	9	be	be	VB
18637	661	10	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	661	11	secret	secret	JJ
18637	661	12	.	.	.
18637	662	1	On	on	IN
18637	662	2	May	May	NNP
18637	662	3	29	29	CD
18637	662	4	Randolph	Randolph	NNP
18637	662	5	,	,	,
18637	662	6	on	on	IN
18637	662	7	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	662	8	of	of	IN
18637	662	9	the	the	DT
18637	662	10	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	662	11	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	662	12	,	,	,
18637	662	13	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	662	14	to	to	IN
18637	662	15	the	the	DT
18637	662	16	convention	convention	NN
18637	662	17	15	15	CD
18637	662	18	propositions	proposition	NNS
18637	662	19	as	as	IN
18637	662	20	a	a	DT
18637	662	21	plan	plan	NN
18637	662	22	of	of	IN
18637	662	23	government	government	NN
18637	662	24	.	.	.
18637	663	1	Despite	despite	IN
18637	663	2	the	the	DT
18637	663	3	fact	fact	NN
18637	663	4	that	that	IN
18637	663	5	the	the	DT
18637	663	6	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	663	7	were	be	VBD
18637	663	8	limited	limit	VBN
18637	663	9	by	by	IN
18637	663	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	663	11	instructions	instruction	NNS
18637	663	12	to	to	IN
18637	663	13	a	a	DT
18637	663	14	revision	revision	NN
18637	663	15	of	of	IN
18637	663	16	the	the	DT
18637	663	17	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	663	18	,	,	,
18637	663	19	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	663	20	had	have	VBD
18637	663	21	really	really	RB
18637	663	22	recommended	recommend	VBN
18637	663	23	a	a	DT
18637	663	24	new	new	JJ
18637	663	25	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	663	26	of	of	IN
18637	663	27	government	government	NN
18637	663	28	.	.	.
18637	664	1	For	for	IN
18637	664	2	example	example	NN
18637	664	3	,	,	,
18637	664	4	provision	provision	NN
18637	664	5	was	be	VBD
18637	664	6	made	make	VBN
18637	664	7	in	in	IN
18637	664	8	the	the	DT
18637	664	9	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	664	10	plan	plan	NN
18637	664	11	for	for	IN
18637	664	12	the	the	DT
18637	664	13	separation	separation	NN
18637	664	14	of	of	IN
18637	664	15	the	the	DT
18637	664	16	three	three	CD
18637	664	17	branches	branch	NNS
18637	664	18	of	of	IN
18637	664	19	government	government	NN
18637	664	20	;	;	:
18637	664	21	under	under	IN
18637	664	22	the	the	DT
18637	664	23	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	664	24	executive	executive	JJ
18637	664	25	,	,	,
18637	664	26	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	664	27	,	,	,
18637	664	28	and	and	CC
18637	664	29	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	664	30	powers	power	NNS
18637	664	31	were	be	VBD
18637	664	32	vested	vest	VBN
18637	664	33	in	in	IN
18637	664	34	the	the	DT
18637	664	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	664	36	.	.	.
18637	665	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	665	2	the	the	DT
18637	665	3	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	665	4	was	be	VBD
18637	665	5	to	to	TO
18637	665	6	consist	consist	VB
18637	665	7	of	of	IN
18637	665	8	two	two	CD
18637	665	9	houses	house	NNS
18637	665	10	rather	rather	RB
18637	665	11	than	than	IN
18637	665	12	one	one	CD
18637	665	13	.	.	.
18637	666	1	On	on	IN
18637	666	2	May	May	NNP
18637	666	3	30	30	CD
18637	666	4	the	the	DT
18637	666	5	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	666	6	went	go	VBD
18637	666	7	into	into	IN
18637	666	8	a	a	DT
18637	666	9	committee	committee	NN
18637	666	10	of	of	IN
18637	666	11	the	the	DT
18637	666	12	whole	whole	NN
18637	666	13	to	to	TO
18637	666	14	consider	consider	VB
18637	666	15	the	the	DT
18637	666	16	15	15	CD
18637	666	17	propositions	proposition	NNS
18637	666	18	of	of	IN
18637	666	19	the	the	DT
18637	666	20	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	666	21	plan	plan	NN
18637	666	22	_	_	NNP
18637	666	23	seriatim	seriatim	NN
18637	666	24	_	_	NNP
18637	666	25	.	.	.
18637	667	1	These	these	DT
18637	667	2	discussions	discussion	NNS
18637	667	3	continued	continue	VBD
18637	667	4	until	until	IN
18637	667	5	June	June	NNP
18637	667	6	13	13	CD
18637	667	7	,	,	,
18637	667	8	when	when	WRB
18637	667	9	the	the	DT
18637	667	10	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	667	11	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	667	12	in	in	IN
18637	667	13	amended	amend	VBN
18637	667	14	form	form	NN
18637	667	15	were	be	VBD
18637	667	16	reported	report	VBN
18637	667	17	out	out	IN
18637	667	18	of	of	IN
18637	667	19	committee	committee	NN
18637	667	20	.	.	.
18637	668	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	668	2	provided	provide	VBD
18637	668	3	for	for	IN
18637	668	4	proportional	proportional	JJ
18637	668	5	representation	representation	NN
18637	668	6	in	in	IN
18637	668	7	both	both	DT
18637	668	8	houses	house	NNS
18637	668	9	.	.	.
18637	669	1	The	the	DT
18637	669	2	small	small	JJ
18637	669	3	States	States	NNPS
18637	669	4	were	be	VBD
18637	669	5	dissatisfied	dissatisfied	JJ
18637	669	6	.	.	.
18637	670	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
18637	670	2	,	,	,
18637	670	3	on	on	IN
18637	670	4	June	June	NNP
18637	670	5	14	14	CD
18637	670	6	when	when	WRB
18637	670	7	the	the	DT
18637	670	8	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	670	9	was	be	VBD
18637	670	10	ready	ready	JJ
18637	670	11	to	to	TO
18637	670	12	consider	consider	VB
18637	670	13	the	the	DT
18637	670	14	report	report	NN
18637	670	15	on	on	IN
18637	670	16	the	the	DT
18637	670	17	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	670	18	plan	plan	NN
18637	670	19	,	,	,
18637	670	20	Paterson	Paterson	NNP
18637	670	21	of	of	IN
18637	670	22	New	New	NNP
18637	670	23	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	670	24	requested	request	VBD
18637	670	25	an	an	DT
18637	670	26	adjournment	adjournment	NN
18637	670	27	to	to	TO
18637	670	28	allow	allow	VB
18637	670	29	certain	certain	JJ
18637	670	30	delegations	delegation	NNS
18637	670	31	more	more	JJR
18637	670	32	time	time	NN
18637	670	33	to	to	TO
18637	670	34	prepare	prepare	VB
18637	670	35	a	a	DT
18637	670	36	substitute	substitute	NN
18637	670	37	plan	plan	NN
18637	670	38	.	.	.
18637	671	1	The	the	DT
18637	671	2	request	request	NN
18637	671	3	was	be	VBD
18637	671	4	granted	grant	VBN
18637	671	5	,	,	,
18637	671	6	and	and	CC
18637	671	7	on	on	IN
18637	671	8	the	the	DT
18637	671	9	next	next	JJ
18637	671	10	day	day	NN
18637	671	11	Paterson	Paterson	NNP
18637	671	12	submitted	submit	VBD
18637	671	13	nine	nine	CD
18637	671	14	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	671	15	embodying	embody	VBG
18637	671	16	important	important	JJ
18637	671	17	changes	change	NNS
18637	671	18	in	in	IN
18637	671	19	the	the	DT
18637	671	20	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	671	21	of	of	IN
18637	671	22	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	671	23	,	,	,
18637	671	24	but	but	CC
18637	671	25	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	671	26	amendatory	amendatory	JJ
18637	671	27	in	in	IN
18637	671	28	nature	nature	NN
18637	671	29	.	.	.
18637	672	1	Vigorous	vigorous	JJ
18637	672	2	debate	debate	NN
18637	672	3	followed	follow	VBD
18637	672	4	.	.	.
18637	673	1	On	on	IN
18637	673	2	June	June	NNP
18637	673	3	19	19	CD
18637	673	4	the	the	DT
18637	673	5	States	States	NNPS
18637	673	6	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	673	7	the	the	DT
18637	673	8	New	New	NNP
18637	673	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	673	10	plan	plan	NN
18637	673	11	and	and	CC
18637	673	12	voted	vote	VBD
18637	673	13	to	to	TO
18637	673	14	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	673	15	with	with	IN
18637	673	16	a	a	DT
18637	673	17	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	673	18	of	of	IN
18637	673	19	the	the	DT
18637	673	20	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	673	21	plan	plan	NN
18637	673	22	.	.	.
18637	674	1	The	the	DT
18637	674	2	small	small	JJ
18637	674	3	States	States	NNPS
18637	674	4	became	become	VBD
18637	674	5	more	more	RBR
18637	674	6	and	and	CC
18637	674	7	more	more	RBR
18637	674	8	discontented	discontent	VBN
18637	674	9	;	;	:
18637	674	10	there	there	EX
18637	674	11	were	be	VBD
18637	674	12	threats	threat	NNS
18637	674	13	of	of	IN
18637	674	14	withdrawal	withdrawal	NN
18637	674	15	.	.	.
18637	675	1	On	on	IN
18637	675	2	July	July	NNP
18637	675	3	2	2	CD
18637	675	4	the	the	DT
18637	675	5	convention	convention	NN
18637	675	6	was	be	VBD
18637	675	7	deadlocked	deadlocke	VBN
18637	675	8	over	over	RP
18637	675	9	giving	give	VBG
18637	675	10	each	each	DT
18637	675	11	State	state	NN
18637	675	12	an	an	DT
18637	675	13	equal	equal	JJ
18637	675	14	vote	vote	NN
18637	675	15	in	in	IN
18637	675	16	the	the	DT
18637	675	17	upper	upper	JJ
18637	675	18	house	house	NN
18637	675	19	--	--	:
18637	675	20	five	five	CD
18637	675	21	States	state	NNS
18637	675	22	in	in	IN
18637	675	23	the	the	DT
18637	675	24	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	675	25	,	,	,
18637	675	26	five	five	CD
18637	675	27	in	in	IN
18637	675	28	the	the	DT
18637	675	29	negative	negative	JJ
18637	675	30	,	,	,
18637	675	31	one	one	CD
18637	675	32	divided	divide	VBD
18637	675	33	.	.	.
18637	676	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	676	2	j	j	NNP
18637	676	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	676	4	The	the	DT
18637	676	5	problem	problem	NN
18637	676	6	was	be	VBD
18637	676	7	referred	refer	VBN
18637	676	8	to	to	IN
18637	676	9	a	a	DT
18637	676	10	committee	committee	NN
18637	676	11	of	of	IN
18637	676	12	11	11	CD
18637	676	13	,	,	,
18637	676	14	there	there	EX
18637	676	15	being	be	VBG
18637	676	16	1	1	CD
18637	676	17	delegate	delegate	NN
18637	676	18	from	from	IN
18637	676	19	each	each	DT
18637	676	20	State	state	NN
18637	676	21	,	,	,
18637	676	22	to	to	TO
18637	676	23	effect	effect	VB
18637	676	24	a	a	DT
18637	676	25	compromise	compromise	NN
18637	676	26	.	.	.
18637	677	1	On	on	IN
18637	677	2	July	July	NNP
18637	677	3	5	5	CD
18637	677	4	the	the	DT
18637	677	5	committee	committee	NN
18637	677	6	submitted	submit	VBD
18637	677	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	677	8	report	report	NN
18637	677	9	,	,	,
18637	677	10	which	which	WDT
18637	677	11	became	become	VBD
18637	677	12	the	the	DT
18637	677	13	basis	basis	NN
18637	677	14	for	for	IN
18637	677	15	the	the	DT
18637	677	16	"	"	``
18637	677	17	great	great	JJ
18637	677	18	compromise	compromise	NN
18637	677	19	"	"	''
18637	677	20	of	of	IN
18637	677	21	the	the	DT
18637	677	22	convention	convention	NN
18637	677	23	.	.	.
18637	678	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	678	2	was	be	VBD
18637	678	3	recommended	recommend	VBN
18637	678	4	that	that	IN
18637	678	5	in	in	IN
18637	678	6	the	the	DT
18637	678	7	upper	upper	JJ
18637	678	8	house	house	NN
18637	678	9	each	each	DT
18637	678	10	State	State	NNP
18637	678	11	should	should	MD
18637	678	12	have	have	VB
18637	678	13	an	an	DT
18637	678	14	equal	equal	JJ
18637	678	15	vote	vote	NN
18637	678	16	,	,	,
18637	678	17	that	that	IN
18637	678	18	in	in	IN
18637	678	19	the	the	DT
18637	678	20	lower	low	JJR
18637	678	21	branch	branch	NN
18637	678	22	each	each	DT
18637	678	23	State	state	NN
18637	678	24	should	should	MD
18637	678	25	have	have	VB
18637	678	26	one	one	CD
18637	678	27	representative	representative	NN
18637	678	28	for	for	IN
18637	678	29	every	every	DT
18637	678	30	40,000	40,000	CD
18637	678	31	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	678	32	,	,	,
18637	678	33	counting	count	VBG
18637	678	34	three	three	CD
18637	678	35	-	-	HYPH
18637	678	36	fifths	fifth	NNS
18637	678	37	of	of	IN
18637	678	38	the	the	DT
18637	678	39	slaves	slave	NNS
18637	678	40	,	,	,
18637	678	41	that	that	DT
18637	678	42	money	money	NN
18637	678	43	bills	bill	NNS
18637	678	44	should	should	MD
18637	678	45	originate	originate	VB
18637	678	46	in	in	IN
18637	678	47	the	the	DT
18637	678	48	lower	low	JJR
18637	678	49	house	house	NN
18637	678	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	678	51	not	not	RB
18637	678	52	subject	subject	JJ
18637	678	53	to	to	IN
18637	678	54	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	678	55	by	by	IN
18637	678	56	the	the	DT
18637	678	57	upper	upper	JJ
18637	678	58	chamber	chamber	NN
18637	678	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	678	60	.	.	.
18637	679	1	When	when	WRB
18637	679	2	on	on	IN
18637	679	3	July	July	NNP
18637	679	4	12	12	CD
18637	679	5	the	the	DT
18637	679	6	motion	motion	NN
18637	679	7	of	of	IN
18637	679	8	Gouverneur	Gouverneur	NNP
18637	679	9	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	679	10	of	of	IN
18637	679	11	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	679	12	that	that	IN
18637	679	13	direct	direct	JJ
18637	679	14	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	679	15	should	should	MD
18637	679	16	also	also	RB
18637	679	17	be	be	VB
18637	679	18	in	in	IN
18637	679	19	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	679	20	to	to	IN
18637	679	21	representation	representation	NN
18637	679	22	,	,	,
18637	679	23	was	be	VBD
18637	679	24	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	679	25	,	,	,
18637	679	26	a	a	DT
18637	679	27	crisis	crisis	NN
18637	679	28	had	have	VBD
18637	679	29	been	be	VBN
18637	679	30	successfully	successfully	RB
18637	679	31	surmounted	surmount	VBN
18637	679	32	.	.	.
18637	680	1	A	a	DT
18637	680	2	compromise	compromise	NN
18637	680	3	spirit	spirit	NN
18637	680	4	began	begin	VBD
18637	680	5	to	to	TO
18637	680	6	prevail	prevail	VB
18637	680	7	.	.	.
18637	681	1	The	the	DT
18637	681	2	small	small	JJ
18637	681	3	States	States	NNPS
18637	681	4	were	be	VBD
18637	681	5	now	now	RB
18637	681	6	willing	willing	JJ
18637	681	7	to	to	TO
18637	681	8	support	support	VB
18637	681	9	a	a	DT
18637	681	10	strong	strong	JJ
18637	681	11	national	national	JJ
18637	681	12	government	government	NN
18637	681	13	.	.	.
18637	682	1	Debates	debate	NNS
18637	682	2	on	on	IN
18637	682	3	the	the	DT
18637	682	4	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	682	5	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	682	6	continued	continue	VBD
18637	682	7	.	.	.
18637	683	1	The	the	DT
18637	683	2	15	15	CD
18637	683	3	original	original	JJ
18637	683	4	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	683	5	had	have	VBD
18637	683	6	been	be	VBN
18637	683	7	expanded	expand	VBN
18637	683	8	into	into	IN
18637	683	9	23	23	CD
18637	683	10	.	.	.
18637	684	1	Since	since	IN
18637	684	2	these	these	DT
18637	684	3	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	684	4	were	be	VBD
18637	684	5	largely	largely	RB
18637	684	6	declarations	declaration	NNS
18637	684	7	of	of	IN
18637	684	8	principles	principle	NNS
18637	684	9	,	,	,
18637	684	10	on	on	IN
18637	684	11	July	July	NNP
18637	684	12	24	24	CD
18637	684	13	a	a	DT
18637	684	14	committee	committee	NN
18637	684	15	of	of	IN
18637	684	16	five[k	five[k	NNP
18637	684	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	684	18	was	be	VBD
18637	684	19	selected	select	VBN
18637	684	20	to	to	TO
18637	684	21	draft	draft	VB
18637	684	22	a	a	DT
18637	684	23	detailed	detailed	JJ
18637	684	24	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	684	25	embodying	embody	VBG
18637	684	26	the	the	DT
18637	684	27	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	684	28	principles	principle	NNS
18637	684	29	which	which	WDT
18637	684	30	had	have	VBD
18637	684	31	thus	thus	RB
18637	684	32	far	far	RB
18637	684	33	been	be	VBN
18637	684	34	approved	approve	VBN
18637	684	35	.	.	.
18637	685	1	The	the	DT
18637	685	2	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	685	3	adjourned	adjourn	VBD
18637	685	4	from	from	IN
18637	685	5	July	July	NNP
18637	685	6	26	26	CD
18637	685	7	to	to	IN
18637	685	8	August	August	NNP
18637	685	9	6	6	CD
18637	685	10	to	to	TO
18637	685	11	await	await	VB
18637	685	12	the	the	DT
18637	685	13	report	report	NN
18637	685	14	of	of	IN
18637	685	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	685	16	committee	committee	NN
18637	685	17	of	of	IN
18637	685	18	detail	detail	NN
18637	685	19	.	.	.
18637	686	1	This	this	DT
18637	686	2	committee	committee	NN
18637	686	3	,	,	,
18637	686	4	in	in	IN
18637	686	5	preparing	prepare	VBG
18637	686	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	686	7	draft	draft	NN
18637	686	8	of	of	IN
18637	686	9	a	a	DT
18637	686	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	686	11	,	,	,
18637	686	12	turned	turn	VBD
18637	686	13	for	for	IN
18637	686	14	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	686	15	to	to	IN
18637	686	16	the	the	DT
18637	686	17	State	State	NNP
18637	686	18	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	686	19	,	,	,
18637	686	20	to	to	IN
18637	686	21	the	the	DT
18637	686	22	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	686	23	of	of	IN
18637	686	24	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	686	25	,	,	,
18637	686	26	to	to	IN
18637	686	27	the	the	DT
18637	686	28	various	various	JJ
18637	686	29	plans	plan	NNS
18637	686	30	which	which	WDT
18637	686	31	had	have	VBD
18637	686	32	been	be	VBN
18637	686	33	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	686	34	to	to	IN
18637	686	35	the	the	DT
18637	686	36	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	686	37	and	and	CC
18637	686	38	other	other	JJ
18637	686	39	available	available	JJ
18637	686	40	material	material	NN
18637	686	41	.	.	.
18637	687	1	On	on	IN
18637	687	2	the	the	DT
18637	687	3	whole	whole	NN
18637	687	4	the	the	DT
18637	687	5	report	report	NN
18637	687	6	of	of	IN
18637	687	7	the	the	DT
18637	687	8	committee	committee	NN
18637	687	9	conformed	conform	VBD
18637	687	10	to	to	IN
18637	687	11	the	the	DT
18637	687	12	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	687	13	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	687	14	by	by	IN
18637	687	15	the	the	DT
18637	687	16	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	687	17	,	,	,
18637	687	18	though	though	IN
18637	687	19	on	on	IN
18637	687	20	many	many	JJ
18637	687	21	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	687	22	the	the	DT
18637	687	23	members	member	NNS
18637	687	24	of	of	IN
18637	687	25	the	the	DT
18637	687	26	committee	committee	NN
18637	687	27	left	leave	VBD
18637	687	28	the	the	DT
18637	687	29	imprint	imprint	NN
18637	687	30	of	of	IN
18637	687	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	687	32	individual	individual	JJ
18637	687	33	and	and	CC
18637	687	34	collective	collective	JJ
18637	687	35	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	687	36	.	.	.
18637	688	1	In	in	IN
18637	688	2	a	a	DT
18637	688	3	few	few	JJ
18637	688	4	instances	instance	NNS
18637	688	5	the	the	DT
18637	688	6	committee	committee	NN
18637	688	7	avowedly	avowedly	RB
18637	688	8	exercised	exercise	VBD
18637	688	9	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	688	10	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	688	11	.	.	.
18637	689	1	From	from	IN
18637	689	2	August	August	NNP
18637	689	3	6	6	CD
18637	689	4	to	to	IN
18637	689	5	September	September	NNP
18637	689	6	10	10	CD
18637	689	7	the	the	DT
18637	689	8	report	report	NN
18637	689	9	of	of	IN
18637	689	10	the	the	DT
18637	689	11	committee	committee	NNP
18637	689	12	of	of	IN
18637	689	13	detail	detail	NNP
18637	689	14	was	be	VBD
18637	689	15	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	689	16	,	,	,
18637	689	17	section	section	NN
18637	689	18	by	by	IN
18637	689	19	section	section	NN
18637	689	20	,	,	,
18637	689	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	689	22	by	by	IN
18637	689	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	689	24	.	.	.
18637	690	1	Details	detail	NNS
18637	690	2	were	be	VBD
18637	690	3	attended	attend	VBN
18637	690	4	to	to	TO
18637	690	5	,	,	,
18637	690	6	further	further	JJ
18637	690	7	compromises	compromise	NNS
18637	690	8	were	be	VBD
18637	690	9	effected	effect	VBN
18637	690	10	.	.	.
18637	691	1	Toward	toward	IN
18637	691	2	the	the	DT
18637	691	3	close	close	NN
18637	691	4	of	of	IN
18637	691	5	these	these	DT
18637	691	6	discussions	discussion	NNS
18637	691	7	,	,	,
18637	691	8	on	on	IN
18637	691	9	September	September	NNP
18637	691	10	8	8	CD
18637	691	11	,	,	,
18637	691	12	another	another	DT
18637	691	13	committee	committee	NN
18637	691	14	of	of	IN
18637	691	15	five[l	five[l	NNP
18637	691	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	691	17	was	be	VBD
18637	691	18	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	691	19	"	"	``
18637	691	20	to	to	TO
18637	691	21	revise	revise	VB
18637	691	22	the	the	DT
18637	691	23	style	style	NN
18637	691	24	of	of	IN
18637	691	25	and	and	CC
18637	691	26	arrange	arrange	VB
18637	691	27	the	the	DT
18637	691	28	articles	article	NNS
18637	691	29	which	which	WDT
18637	691	30	had	have	VBD
18637	691	31	been	be	VBN
18637	691	32	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	691	33	to	to	IN
18637	691	34	by	by	IN
18637	691	35	the	the	DT
18637	691	36	house	house	NN
18637	691	37	.	.	.
18637	691	38	"	"	''
18637	692	1	On	on	IN
18637	692	2	Wednesday	Wednesday	NNP
18637	692	3	,	,	,
18637	692	4	September	September	NNP
18637	692	5	12	12	CD
18637	692	6	the	the	DT
18637	692	7	report	report	NN
18637	692	8	of	of	IN
18637	692	9	the	the	DT
18637	692	10	committee	committee	NNP
18637	692	11	of	of	IN
18637	692	12	style	style	NN
18637	692	13	was	be	VBD
18637	692	14	ordered	order	VBN
18637	692	15	printed	print	VBN
18637	692	16	for	for	IN
18637	692	17	the	the	DT
18637	692	18	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	692	19	of	of	IN
18637	692	20	the	the	DT
18637	692	21	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	692	22	.	.	.
18637	693	1	The	the	DT
18637	693	2	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	693	3	for	for	IN
18637	693	4	3	3	CD
18637	693	5	days	day	NNS
18637	693	6	compared	compare	VBN
18637	693	7	this	this	DT
18637	693	8	report	report	NN
18637	693	9	with	with	IN
18637	693	10	the	the	DT
18637	693	11	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	693	12	of	of	IN
18637	693	13	the	the	DT
18637	693	14	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	693	15	.	.	.
18637	694	1	The	the	DT
18637	694	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	694	3	was	be	VBD
18637	694	4	ordered	order	VBN
18637	694	5	engrossed	engross	VBN
18637	694	6	on	on	IN
18637	694	7	Saturday	Saturday	NNP
18637	694	8	,	,	,
18637	694	9	September	September	NNP
18637	694	10	15	15	CD
18637	694	11	.	.	.
18637	695	1	The	the	DT
18637	695	2	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	695	3	met	meet	VBD
18637	695	4	on	on	IN
18637	695	5	Monday	Monday	NNP
18637	695	6	,	,	,
18637	695	7	September	September	NNP
18637	695	8	17	17	CD
18637	695	9	,	,	,
18637	695	10	for	for	IN
18637	695	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	695	12	final	final	JJ
18637	695	13	session	session	NN
18637	695	14	.	.	.
18637	696	1	Several	several	JJ
18637	696	2	of	of	IN
18637	696	3	the	the	DT
18637	696	4	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	696	5	were	be	VBD
18637	696	6	disappointed	disappoint	VBN
18637	696	7	in	in	IN
18637	696	8	the	the	DT
18637	696	9	result	result	NN
18637	696	10	.	.	.
18637	697	1	A	a	DT
18637	697	2	few	few	JJ
18637	697	3	deemed	deem	VBD
18637	697	4	the	the	DT
18637	697	5	new	new	JJ
18637	697	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	697	7	a	a	DT
18637	697	8	mere	mere	JJ
18637	697	9	makeshift	makeshift	NN
18637	697	10	,	,	,
18637	697	11	a	a	DT
18637	697	12	series	series	NN
18637	697	13	of	of	IN
18637	697	14	unfortunate	unfortunate	JJ
18637	697	15	compromises	compromise	NNS
18637	697	16	.	.	.
18637	698	1	The	the	DT
18637	698	2	advocates	advocate	NNS
18637	698	3	of	of	IN
18637	698	4	the	the	DT
18637	698	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	698	6	,	,	,
18637	698	7	realizing	realize	VBG
18637	698	8	the	the	DT
18637	698	9	impending	impend	VBG
18637	698	10	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	698	11	of	of	IN
18637	698	12	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	698	13	the	the	DT
18637	698	14	consent	consent	NN
18637	698	15	of	of	IN
18637	698	16	the	the	DT
18637	698	17	States	States	NNPS
18637	698	18	to	to	IN
18637	698	19	the	the	DT
18637	698	20	new	new	JJ
18637	698	21	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	698	22	of	of	IN
18637	698	23	Government	Government	NNP
18637	698	24	,	,	,
18637	698	25	were	be	VBD
18637	698	26	anxious	anxious	JJ
18637	698	27	to	to	TO
18637	698	28	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	698	29	the	the	DT
18637	698	30	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	698	31	support	support	NN
18637	698	32	of	of	IN
18637	698	33	the	the	DT
18637	698	34	delegations	delegation	NNS
18637	698	35	from	from	IN
18637	698	36	each	each	DT
18637	698	37	State	state	NN
18637	698	38	.	.	.
18637	699	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	699	2	was	be	VBD
18637	699	3	feared	fear	VBN
18637	699	4	that	that	IN
18637	699	5	many	many	JJ
18637	699	6	of	of	IN
18637	699	7	the	the	DT
18637	699	8	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	699	9	would	would	MD
18637	699	10	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	699	11	to	to	TO
18637	699	12	give	give	VB
18637	699	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	699	14	individual	individual	JJ
18637	699	15	assent	assent	NN
18637	699	16	to	to	IN
18637	699	17	the	the	DT
18637	699	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	699	19	.	.	.
18637	700	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
18637	700	2	,	,	,
18637	700	3	in	in	IN
18637	700	4	order	order	NN
18637	700	5	that	that	IN
18637	700	6	the	the	DT
18637	700	7	action	action	NN
18637	700	8	of	of	IN
18637	700	9	the	the	DT
18637	700	10	convention	convention	NN
18637	700	11	would	would	MD
18637	700	12	appear	appear	VB
18637	700	13	to	to	TO
18637	700	14	be	be	VB
18637	700	15	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	700	16	,	,	,
18637	700	17	Gouverneur	Gouverneur	NNP
18637	700	18	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	700	19	devised	devise	VBD
18637	700	20	the	the	DT
18637	700	21	formula	formula	NN
18637	700	22	"	"	``
18637	700	23	Done	do	VBN
18637	700	24	in	in	IN
18637	700	25	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	700	26	,	,	,
18637	700	27	by	by	IN
18637	700	28	the	the	DT
18637	700	29	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	700	30	consent	consent	NN
18637	700	31	of	of	IN
18637	700	32	the	the	DT
18637	700	33	States	States	NNPS
18637	700	34	present	present	VBP
18637	700	35	the	the	DT
18637	700	36	17th	17th	NN
18637	700	37	of	of	IN
18637	700	38	September	September	NNP
18637	700	39	*	*	NFP
18637	700	40	*	*	NFP
18637	700	41	*	*	NFP
18637	700	42	In	in	IN
18637	700	43	witness	witness	NN
18637	700	44	whereof	whereof	IN
18637	700	45	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	700	46	have	have	VBP
18637	700	47	hereunto	hereunto	NNS
18637	700	48	subscribed	subscribe	VBN
18637	700	49	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	700	50	names	name	NNS
18637	700	51	.	.	.
18637	700	52	"	"	''
18637	701	1	Thirty	thirty	CD
18637	701	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	701	3	nine	nine	CD
18637	701	4	of	of	IN
18637	701	5	the	the	DT
18637	701	6	forty	forty	CD
18637	701	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	701	8	two	two	CD
18637	701	9	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	701	10	present	present	JJ
18637	701	11	thereupon	thereupon	RB
18637	701	12	"	"	``
18637	701	13	subscribed	subscribe	VBN
18637	701	14	"	"	''
18637	701	15	to	to	IN
18637	701	16	the	the	DT
18637	701	17	document	document	NN
18637	701	18	.	.	.
18637	702	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	702	2	m	m	NN
18637	702	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	702	4	The	the	DT
18637	702	5	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	702	6	had	have	VBD
18637	702	7	been	be	VBN
18637	702	8	called	call	VBN
18637	702	9	to	to	TO
18637	702	10	revise	revise	VB
18637	702	11	the	the	DT
18637	702	12	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	702	13	of	of	IN
18637	702	14	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	702	15	.	.	.
18637	703	1	Instead	instead	RB
18637	703	2	,	,	,
18637	703	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	703	4	reported	report	VBD
18637	703	5	to	to	IN
18637	703	6	the	the	DT
18637	703	7	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	703	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	703	9	a	a	DT
18637	703	10	new	new	JJ
18637	703	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	703	12	.	.	.
18637	704	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	704	2	,	,	,
18637	704	3	while	while	IN
18637	704	4	the	the	DT
18637	704	5	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	704	6	specified	specify	VBD
18637	704	7	that	that	IN
18637	704	8	no	no	DT
18637	704	9	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	704	10	should	should	MD
18637	704	11	be	be	VB
18637	704	12	effective	effective	JJ
18637	704	13	until	until	IN
18637	704	14	approved	approve	VBN
18637	704	15	by	by	IN
18637	704	16	the	the	DT
18637	704	17	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	704	18	of	of	IN
18637	704	19	all	all	PDT
18637	704	20	the	the	DT
18637	704	21	States	States	NNPS
18637	704	22	,	,	,
18637	704	23	the	the	DT
18637	704	24	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	704	25	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	704	26	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	704	27	that	that	IN
18637	704	28	the	the	DT
18637	704	29	new	new	JJ
18637	704	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	704	31	should	should	MD
18637	704	32	supplant	supplant	VB
18637	704	33	the	the	DT
18637	704	34	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	704	35	of	of	IN
18637	704	36	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	704	37	when	when	WRB
18637	704	38	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	704	39	by	by	IN
18637	704	40	conventions	convention	NNS
18637	704	41	in	in	IN
18637	704	42	nine	nine	CD
18637	704	43	States	States	NNPS
18637	704	44	.	.	.
18637	705	1	For	for	IN
18637	705	2	these	these	DT
18637	705	3	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	705	4	,	,	,
18637	705	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	705	6	was	be	VBD
18637	705	7	feared	fear	VBN
18637	705	8	that	that	IN
18637	705	9	the	the	DT
18637	705	10	new	new	JJ
18637	705	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	705	12	might	may	MD
18637	705	13	arouse	arouse	VB
18637	705	14	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	705	15	in	in	IN
18637	705	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	705	17	.	.	.
18637	706	1	Three	three	CD
18637	706	2	members	member	NNS
18637	706	3	of	of	IN
18637	706	4	the	the	DT
18637	706	5	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	706	6	--	--	:
18637	706	7	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	706	8	,	,	,
18637	706	9	Gorham	Gorham	NNP
18637	706	10	,	,	,
18637	706	11	and	and	CC
18637	706	12	King	King	NNP
18637	706	13	--	--	:
18637	706	14	were	be	VBD
18637	706	15	also	also	RB
18637	706	16	Members	Members	NNP
18637	706	17	of	of	IN
18637	706	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	706	19	.	.	.
18637	707	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	707	2	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	707	3	at	at	IN
18637	707	4	once	once	RB
18637	707	5	to	to	IN
18637	707	6	New	New	NNP
18637	707	7	York	York	NNP
18637	707	8	,	,	,
18637	707	9	where	where	WRB
18637	707	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	707	11	was	be	VBD
18637	707	12	in	in	IN
18637	707	13	session	session	NN
18637	707	14	,	,	,
18637	707	15	to	to	TO
18637	707	16	placate	placate	VB
18637	707	17	the	the	DT
18637	707	18	expected	expect	VBN
18637	707	19	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	707	20	.	.	.
18637	708	1	Aware	aware	JJ
18637	708	2	of	of	IN
18637	708	3	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	708	4	vanishing	vanish	VBG
18637	708	5	authority	authority	NN
18637	708	6	,	,	,
18637	708	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	708	8	on	on	IN
18637	708	9	September	September	NNP
18637	708	10	28	28	CD
18637	708	11	,	,	,
18637	708	12	after	after	IN
18637	708	13	some	some	DT
18637	708	14	debate	debate	NN
18637	708	15	,	,	,
18637	708	16	decided	decide	VBD
18637	708	17	to	to	TO
18637	708	18	submit	submit	VB
18637	708	19	the	the	DT
18637	708	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	708	21	to	to	IN
18637	708	22	the	the	DT
18637	708	23	States	States	NNP
18637	708	24	for	for	IN
18637	708	25	action	action	NN
18637	708	26	.	.	.
18637	709	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	709	2	made	make	VBD
18637	709	3	no	no	DT
18637	709	4	recommendation	recommendation	NN
18637	709	5	for	for	IN
18637	709	6	or	or	CC
18637	709	7	against	against	IN
18637	709	8	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	709	9	.	.	.
18637	710	1	Two	two	CD
18637	710	2	parties	party	NNS
18637	710	3	soon	soon	RB
18637	710	4	developed	develop	VBD
18637	710	5	,	,	,
18637	710	6	one	one	CD
18637	710	7	in	in	IN
18637	710	8	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	710	9	and	and	CC
18637	710	10	one	one	CD
18637	710	11	in	in	IN
18637	710	12	support	support	NN
18637	710	13	of	of	IN
18637	710	14	the	the	DT
18637	710	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	710	16	,	,	,
18637	710	17	and	and	CC
18637	710	18	the	the	DT
18637	710	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	710	20	was	be	VBD
18637	710	21	debated	debate	VBN
18637	710	22	,	,	,
18637	710	23	criticized	criticize	VBN
18637	710	24	,	,	,
18637	710	25	and	and	CC
18637	710	26	expounded	expound	VBD
18637	710	27	clause	clause	NN
18637	710	28	by	by	IN
18637	710	29	clause	clause	NN
18637	710	30	.	.	.
18637	711	1	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	711	2	,	,	,
18637	711	3	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	711	4	,	,	,
18637	711	5	and	and	CC
18637	711	6	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	711	7	wrote	write	VBD
18637	711	8	a	a	DT
18637	711	9	series	series	NN
18637	711	10	of	of	IN
18637	711	11	commentaries	commentary	NNS
18637	711	12	,	,	,
18637	711	13	now	now	RB
18637	711	14	known	know	VBN
18637	711	15	as	as	IN
18637	711	16	the	the	DT
18637	711	17	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	711	18	Papers	Papers	NNP
18637	711	19	,	,	,
18637	711	20	in	in	IN
18637	711	21	support	support	NN
18637	711	22	of	of	IN
18637	711	23	the	the	DT
18637	711	24	new	new	JJ
18637	711	25	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	711	26	of	of	IN
18637	711	27	government	government	NN
18637	711	28	.	.	.
18637	712	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	712	2	n	n	LS
18637	712	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	712	4	The	the	DT
18637	712	5	closeness	closeness	NN
18637	712	6	and	and	CC
18637	712	7	bitterness	bitterness	NN
18637	712	8	of	of	IN
18637	712	9	the	the	DT
18637	712	10	struggle	struggle	NN
18637	712	11	over	over	IN
18637	712	12	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	712	13	and	and	CC
18637	712	14	the	the	DT
18637	712	15	conferring	conferring	NN
18637	712	16	of	of	IN
18637	712	17	additional	additional	JJ
18637	712	18	powers	power	NNS
18637	712	19	on	on	IN
18637	712	20	the	the	DT
18637	712	21	central	central	JJ
18637	712	22	government	government	NN
18637	712	23	can	can	MD
18637	712	24	scarcely	scarcely	RB
18637	712	25	be	be	VB
18637	712	26	exaggerated	exaggerate	VBN
18637	712	27	.	.	.
18637	713	1	In	in	IN
18637	713	2	some	some	DT
18637	713	3	States	States	NNP
18637	713	4	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	713	5	was	be	VBD
18637	713	6	effected	effect	VBN
18637	713	7	only	only	RB
18637	713	8	after	after	IN
18637	713	9	a	a	DT
18637	713	10	bitter	bitter	JJ
18637	713	11	struggle	struggle	NN
18637	713	12	in	in	IN
18637	713	13	the	the	DT
18637	713	14	State	State	NNP
18637	713	15	convention	convention	NN
18637	713	16	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	713	17	.	.	.
18637	714	1	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	714	2	,	,	,
18637	714	3	on	on	IN
18637	714	4	December	December	NNP
18637	714	5	7	7	CD
18637	714	6	,	,	,
18637	714	7	1787	1787	CD
18637	714	8	,	,	,
18637	714	9	became	become	VBD
18637	714	10	the	the	DT
18637	714	11	first	first	JJ
18637	714	12	State	State	NNP
18637	714	13	to	to	TO
18637	714	14	ratify	ratify	VB
18637	714	15	the	the	DT
18637	714	16	new	new	JJ
18637	714	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	714	18	,	,	,
18637	714	19	the	the	DT
18637	714	20	vote	vote	NN
18637	714	21	being	be	VBG
18637	714	22	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	714	23	.	.	.
18637	715	1	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	715	2	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	715	3	on	on	IN
18637	715	4	December	December	NNP
18637	715	5	12	12	CD
18637	715	6	,	,	,
18637	715	7	1787	1787	CD
18637	715	8	,	,	,
18637	715	9	by	by	IN
18637	715	10	a	a	DT
18637	715	11	vote	vote	NN
18637	715	12	of	of	IN
18637	715	13	46	46	CD
18637	715	14	to	to	TO
18637	715	15	23	23	CD
18637	715	16	,	,	,
18637	715	17	a	a	DT
18637	715	18	vote	vote	NN
18637	715	19	scarcely	scarcely	RB
18637	715	20	indicative	indicative	JJ
18637	715	21	of	of	IN
18637	715	22	the	the	DT
18637	715	23	struggle	struggle	NN
18637	715	24	which	which	WDT
18637	715	25	had	have	VBD
18637	715	26	taken	take	VBN
18637	715	27	place	place	NN
18637	715	28	in	in	IN
18637	715	29	that	that	DT
18637	715	30	State	State	NNP
18637	715	31	.	.	.
18637	716	1	New	New	NNP
18637	716	2	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	716	3	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	716	4	on	on	IN
18637	716	5	December	December	NNP
18637	716	6	19	19	CD
18637	716	7	,	,	,
18637	716	8	1787	1787	CD
18637	716	9	,	,	,
18637	716	10	and	and	CC
18637	716	11	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	716	12	on	on	IN
18637	716	13	January	January	NNP
18637	716	14	2	2	CD
18637	716	15	,	,	,
18637	716	16	1788	1788	CD
18637	716	17	,	,	,
18637	716	18	the	the	DT
18637	716	19	vote	vote	NN
18637	716	20	in	in	IN
18637	716	21	both	both	DT
18637	716	22	States	state	NNS
18637	716	23	being	be	VBG
18637	716	24	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	716	25	.	.	.
18637	717	1	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	717	2	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	717	3	on	on	IN
18637	717	4	January	January	NNP
18637	717	5	9	9	CD
18637	717	6	,	,	,
18637	717	7	1788	1788	CD
18637	717	8	;	;	:
18637	717	9	yeas	yeas	RB
18637	717	10	128	128	CD
18637	717	11	,	,	,
18637	717	12	nays	nay	VBZ
18637	717	13	40	40	CD
18637	717	14	.	.	.
18637	718	1	On	on	IN
18637	718	2	February	February	NNP
18637	718	3	6	6	CD
18637	718	4	,	,	,
18637	718	5	1788	1788	CD
18637	718	6	,	,	,
18637	718	7	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	718	8	,	,	,
18637	718	9	by	by	IN
18637	718	10	a	a	DT
18637	718	11	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	718	12	margin	margin	NN
18637	718	13	of	of	IN
18637	718	14	19	19	CD
18637	718	15	votes	vote	NNS
18637	718	16	in	in	IN
18637	718	17	a	a	DT
18637	718	18	convention	convention	NN
18637	718	19	with	with	IN
18637	718	20	a	a	DT
18637	718	21	membership	membership	NN
18637	718	22	of	of	IN
18637	718	23	355	355	CD
18637	718	24	,	,	,
18637	718	25	endorsed	endorse	VBD
18637	718	26	the	the	DT
18637	718	27	new	new	JJ
18637	718	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	718	29	,	,	,
18637	718	30	but	but	CC
18637	718	31	recommended	recommend	VBD
18637	718	32	that	that	IN
18637	718	33	a	a	DT
18637	718	34	bill	bill	NN
18637	718	35	of	of	IN
18637	718	36	rights	right	NNS
18637	718	37	be	be	VB
18637	718	38	added	add	VBN
18637	718	39	to	to	TO
18637	718	40	protect	protect	VB
18637	718	41	the	the	DT
18637	718	42	States	States	NNPS
18637	718	43	from	from	IN
18637	718	44	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	718	45	encroachment	encroachment	NN
18637	718	46	on	on	IN
18637	718	47	individual	individual	JJ
18637	718	48	liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	718	49	.	.	.
18637	719	1	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	719	2	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	719	3	on	on	IN
18637	719	4	April	April	NNP
18637	719	5	28	28	CD
18637	719	6	,	,	,
18637	719	7	1788	1788	CD
18637	719	8	;	;	:
18637	719	9	yeas	yeas	RB
18637	719	10	63	63	CD
18637	719	11	,	,	,
18637	719	12	nays	nay	VBZ
18637	719	13	11	11	CD
18637	719	14	.	.	.
18637	720	1	South	South	NNP
18637	720	2	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	720	3	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	720	4	on	on	IN
18637	720	5	May	May	NNP
18637	720	6	23	23	CD
18637	720	7	,	,	,
18637	720	8	1788	1788	CD
18637	720	9	;	;	:
18637	720	10	yeas	yeas	RB
18637	720	11	149	149	CD
18637	720	12	,	,	,
18637	720	13	nays	nay	VBZ
18637	720	14	73	73	CD
18637	720	15	.	.	.
18637	721	1	On	on	IN
18637	721	2	June	June	NNP
18637	721	3	21	21	CD
18637	721	4	,	,	,
18637	721	5	1788	1788	CD
18637	721	6	,	,	,
18637	721	7	by	by	IN
18637	721	8	a	a	DT
18637	721	9	vote	vote	NN
18637	721	10	of	of	IN
18637	721	11	57	57	CD
18637	721	12	to	to	IN
18637	721	13	46	46	CD
18637	721	14	,	,	,
18637	721	15	New	New	NNP
18637	721	16	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	721	17	became	become	VBD
18637	721	18	the	the	DT
18637	721	19	ninth	ninth	JJ
18637	721	20	State	State	NNP
18637	721	21	to	to	TO
18637	721	22	ratify	ratify	VB
18637	721	23	,	,	,
18637	721	24	but	but	CC
18637	721	25	like	like	IN
18637	721	26	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	721	27	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	721	28	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	721	29	a	a	DT
18637	721	30	bill	bill	NN
18637	721	31	of	of	IN
18637	721	32	rights	right	NNS
18637	721	33	.	.	.
18637	722	1	By	by	IN
18637	722	2	the	the	DT
18637	722	3	terms	term	NNS
18637	722	4	of	of	IN
18637	722	5	the	the	DT
18637	722	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	722	7	nine	nine	CD
18637	722	8	States	States	NNPS
18637	722	9	were	be	VBD
18637	722	10	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	722	11	for	for	IN
18637	722	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	722	13	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	722	14	among	among	IN
18637	722	15	the	the	DT
18637	722	16	States	States	NNP
18637	722	17	so	so	RB
18637	722	18	ratifying	ratify	VBG
18637	722	19	.	.	.
18637	723	1	The	the	DT
18637	723	2	advocates	advocate	NNS
18637	723	3	of	of	IN
18637	723	4	the	the	DT
18637	723	5	new	new	JJ
18637	723	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	723	7	realized	realize	VBD
18637	723	8	,	,	,
18637	723	9	however	however	RB
18637	723	10	,	,	,
18637	723	11	that	that	IN
18637	723	12	the	the	DT
18637	723	13	new	new	JJ
18637	723	14	government	government	NN
18637	723	15	could	could	MD
18637	723	16	not	not	RB
18637	723	17	succeed	succeed	VB
18637	723	18	without	without	IN
18637	723	19	the	the	DT
18637	723	20	addition	addition	NN
18637	723	21	of	of	IN
18637	723	22	New	New	NNP
18637	723	23	York	York	NNP
18637	723	24	and	and	CC
18637	723	25	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	723	26	,	,	,
18637	723	27	neither	neither	DT
18637	723	28	of	of	IN
18637	723	29	which	which	WDT
18637	723	30	had	have	VBD
18637	723	31	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	723	32	.	.	.
18637	724	1	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	724	2	,	,	,
18637	724	3	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	724	4	,	,	,
18637	724	5	and	and	CC
18637	724	6	Randolph	Randolph	NNP
18637	724	7	led	lead	VBD
18637	724	8	the	the	DT
18637	724	9	struggle	struggle	NN
18637	724	10	for	for	IN
18637	724	11	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	724	12	in	in	IN
18637	724	13	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	724	14	.	.	.
18637	725	1	On	on	IN
18637	725	2	June	June	NNP
18637	725	3	25	25	CD
18637	725	4	,	,	,
18637	725	5	1788	1788	CD
18637	725	6	,	,	,
18637	725	7	by	by	IN
18637	725	8	a	a	DT
18637	725	9	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	725	10	margin	margin	NN
18637	725	11	of	of	IN
18637	725	12	10	10	CD
18637	725	13	votes	vote	NNS
18637	725	14	in	in	IN
18637	725	15	a	a	DT
18637	725	16	convention	convention	NN
18637	725	17	of	of	IN
18637	725	18	168	168	CD
18637	725	19	members	member	NNS
18637	725	20	,	,	,
18637	725	21	that	that	IN
18637	725	22	State	state	NN
18637	725	23	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	725	24	over	over	IN
18637	725	25	the	the	DT
18637	725	26	objection	objection	NN
18637	725	27	of	of	IN
18637	725	28	such	such	JJ
18637	725	29	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	725	30	as	as	IN
18637	725	31	George	George	NNP
18637	725	32	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	725	33	and	and	CC
18637	725	34	Patrick	Patrick	NNP
18637	725	35	Henry	Henry	NNP
18637	725	36	.	.	.
18637	726	1	In	in	IN
18637	726	2	New	New	NNP
18637	726	3	York	York	NNP
18637	726	4	an	an	DT
18637	726	5	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	726	6	to	to	TO
18637	726	7	attach	attach	VB
18637	726	8	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	726	9	to	to	TO
18637	726	10	ratification	ratification	VB
18637	726	11	almost	almost	RB
18637	726	12	succeeded	succeeded	JJ
18637	726	13	.	.	.
18637	727	1	But	but	CC
18637	727	2	on	on	IN
18637	727	3	July	July	NNP
18637	727	4	26	26	CD
18637	727	5	,	,	,
18637	727	6	1788	1788	CD
18637	727	7	,	,	,
18637	727	8	New	New	NNP
18637	727	9	York	York	NNP
18637	727	10	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	727	11	,	,	,
18637	727	12	with	with	IN
18637	727	13	a	a	DT
18637	727	14	recommendation	recommendation	NN
18637	727	15	that	that	IN
18637	727	16	a	a	DT
18637	727	17	bill	bill	NN
18637	727	18	of	of	IN
18637	727	19	rights	right	NNS
18637	727	20	be	be	VB
18637	727	21	appended	append	VBN
18637	727	22	.	.	.
18637	728	1	The	the	DT
18637	728	2	vote	vote	NN
18637	728	3	was	be	VBD
18637	728	4	close	close	JJ
18637	728	5	--	--	:
18637	728	6	yeas	yeas	RB
18637	728	7	30	30	CD
18637	728	8	,	,	,
18637	728	9	nays	nay	VBZ
18637	728	10	27	27	CD
18637	728	11	.	.	.
18637	729	1	Eleven	Eleven	NNP
18637	729	2	States	state	NNS
18637	729	3	having	have	VBG
18637	729	4	thus	thus	RB
18637	729	5	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	729	6	the	the	DT
18637	729	7	Constitution,[o	Constitution,[o	NNP
18637	729	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	729	9	the	the	DT
18637	729	10	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	729	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	729	12	--	--	:
18637	729	13	which	which	WDT
18637	729	14	still	still	RB
18637	729	15	functioned	function	VBD
18637	729	16	at	at	IN
18637	729	17	irregular	irregular	JJ
18637	729	18	intervals	interval	NNS
18637	729	19	--	--	:
18637	729	20	passed	pass	VBD
18637	729	21	a	a	DT
18637	729	22	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	729	23	on	on	IN
18637	729	24	September	September	NNP
18637	729	25	13	13	CD
18637	729	26	,	,	,
18637	729	27	1788	1788	CD
18637	729	28	,	,	,
18637	729	29	to	to	TO
18637	729	30	put	put	VB
18637	729	31	the	the	DT
18637	729	32	new	new	JJ
18637	729	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	729	34	into	into	IN
18637	729	35	operation	operation	NN
18637	729	36	.	.	.
18637	730	1	The	the	DT
18637	730	2	first	first	JJ
18637	730	3	Wednesday	Wednesday	NNP
18637	730	4	of	of	IN
18637	730	5	January	January	NNP
18637	730	6	1789	1789	CD
18637	730	7	was	be	VBD
18637	730	8	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	730	9	as	as	IN
18637	730	10	the	the	DT
18637	730	11	day	day	NN
18637	730	12	for	for	IN
18637	730	13	choosing	choose	VBG
18637	730	14	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	730	15	electors	elector	NNS
18637	730	16	,	,	,
18637	730	17	the	the	DT
18637	730	18	first	first	JJ
18637	730	19	Wednesday	Wednesday	NNP
18637	730	20	of	of	IN
18637	730	21	February	February	NNP
18637	730	22	for	for	IN
18637	730	23	the	the	DT
18637	730	24	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	730	25	of	of	IN
18637	730	26	electors	elector	NNS
18637	730	27	,	,	,
18637	730	28	and	and	CC
18637	730	29	the	the	DT
18637	730	30	first	first	JJ
18637	730	31	Wednesday	Wednesday	NNP
18637	730	32	of	of	IN
18637	730	33	March	March	NNP
18637	730	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	730	35	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	731	1	March	March	NNP
18637	731	2	4	4	CD
18637	731	3	,	,	,
18637	731	4	1789	1789	CD
18637	731	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	731	6	for	for	IN
18637	731	7	the	the	DT
18637	731	8	opening	opening	NN
18637	731	9	session	session	NN
18637	731	10	of	of	IN
18637	731	11	the	the	DT
18637	731	12	new	new	JJ
18637	731	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	731	14	.	.	.
18637	732	1	Owing	owe	VBG
18637	732	2	to	to	IN
18637	732	3	various	various	JJ
18637	732	4	delays	delay	NNS
18637	732	5	,	,	,
18637	732	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	732	7	was	be	VBD
18637	732	8	late	late	RB
18637	732	9	in	in	IN
18637	732	10	assembling	assemble	VBG
18637	732	11	,	,	,
18637	732	12	and	and	CC
18637	732	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	732	14	was	be	VBD
18637	732	15	not	not	RB
18637	732	16	until	until	IN
18637	732	17	April	April	NNP
18637	732	18	30	30	CD
18637	732	19	,	,	,
18637	732	20	1789	1789	CD
18637	732	21	,	,	,
18637	732	22	that	that	IN
18637	732	23	George	George	NNP
18637	732	24	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	732	25	was	be	VBD
18637	732	26	inaugurated	inaugurate	VBN
18637	732	27	as	as	IN
18637	732	28	the	the	DT
18637	732	29	first	first	JJ
18637	732	30	President	President	NNP
18637	732	31	of	of	IN
18637	732	32	the	the	DT
18637	732	33	United	United	NNP
18637	732	34	States	States	NNP
18637	732	35	.	.	.
18637	733	1	Notes	note	NNS
18637	733	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	733	3	a	a	DT
18637	733	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	733	5	The	the	DT
18637	733	6	colonists	colonist	NNS
18637	733	7	,	,	,
18637	733	8	for	for	IN
18637	733	9	example	example	NN
18637	733	10	,	,	,
18637	733	11	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	733	12	the	the	DT
18637	733	13	right	right	NN
18637	733	14	"	"	''
18637	733	15	to	to	IN
18637	733	16	life	life	NN
18637	733	17	,	,	,
18637	733	18	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	733	19	,	,	,
18637	733	20	and	and	CC
18637	733	21	property	property	NN
18637	733	22	"	"	''
18637	733	23	,	,	,
18637	733	24	"	"	''
18637	733	25	the	the	DT
18637	733	26	rights	right	NNS
18637	733	27	,	,	,
18637	733	28	liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	733	29	,	,	,
18637	733	30	and	and	CC
18637	733	31	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	733	32	of	of	IN
18637	733	33	free	free	JJ
18637	733	34	and	and	CC
18637	733	35	natural	natural	RB
18637	733	36	-	-	HYPH
18637	733	37	born	bear	VBN
18637	733	38	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	733	39	within	within	IN
18637	733	40	the	the	DT
18637	733	41	realm	realm	NN
18637	733	42	of	of	IN
18637	733	43	England	England	NNP
18637	733	44	"	"	''
18637	733	45	;	;	:
18637	733	46	the	the	DT
18637	733	47	right	right	NN
18637	733	48	to	to	TO
18637	733	49	participate	participate	VB
18637	733	50	in	in	IN
18637	733	51	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	733	52	councils	council	NNS
18637	733	53	;	;	:
18637	733	54	"	"	``
18637	733	55	the	the	DT
18637	733	56	great	great	JJ
18637	733	57	and	and	CC
18637	733	58	inestimable	inestimable	JJ
18637	733	59	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	733	60	of	of	IN
18637	733	61	being	be	VBG
18637	733	62	tried	try	VBN
18637	733	63	by	by	IN
18637	733	64	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	733	65	peers	peer	NNS
18637	733	66	of	of	IN
18637	733	67	the	the	DT
18637	733	68	vicinage	vicinage	NN
18637	733	69	,	,	,
18637	733	70	according	accord	VBG
18637	733	71	to	to	IN
18637	733	72	the	the	DT
18637	733	73	course	course	NN
18637	733	74	of	of	IN
18637	733	75	[	[	-LRB-
18637	733	76	the	the	DT
18637	733	77	common	common	JJ
18637	733	78	law	law	NN
18637	733	79	of	of	IN
18637	733	80	England	England	NNP
18637	733	81	]	]	-RRB-
18637	733	82	"	"	''
18637	733	83	;	;	:
18637	733	84	"	"	``
18637	733	85	the	the	DT
18637	733	86	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	733	87	and	and	CC
18637	733	88	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	733	89	granted	grant	VBD
18637	733	90	and	and	CC
18637	733	91	confirmed	confirm	VBD
18637	733	92	to	to	IN
18637	733	93	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	733	94	by	by	IN
18637	733	95	royal	royal	JJ
18637	733	96	charters	charter	NNS
18637	733	97	,	,	,
18637	733	98	or	or	CC
18637	733	99	secured	secure	VBN
18637	733	100	by	by	IN
18637	733	101	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	733	102	several	several	JJ
18637	733	103	codes	code	NNS
18637	733	104	of	of	IN
18637	733	105	provincial	provincial	JJ
18637	733	106	laws	law	NNS
18637	733	107	"	"	''
18637	733	108	;	;	:
18637	733	109	"	"	``
18637	733	110	a	a	DT
18637	733	111	right	right	NN
18637	733	112	peaceably	peaceably	RB
18637	733	113	to	to	TO
18637	733	114	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	733	115	,	,	,
18637	733	116	consider	consider	VB
18637	733	117	of	of	IN
18637	733	118	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	733	119	grievances	grievance	NNS
18637	733	120	,	,	,
18637	733	121	and	and	CC
18637	733	122	petition	petition	VB
18637	733	123	the	the	DT
18637	733	124	king	king	NN
18637	733	125	.	.	.
18637	733	126	"	"	''
18637	734	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	734	2	further	further	RB
18637	734	3	declared	declare	VBD
18637	734	4	that	that	IN
18637	734	5	the	the	DT
18637	734	6	keeping	keeping	NN
18637	734	7	of	of	IN
18637	734	8	a	a	DT
18637	734	9	standing	stand	VBG
18637	734	10	army	army	NN
18637	734	11	in	in	IN
18637	734	12	the	the	DT
18637	734	13	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	734	14	in	in	IN
18637	734	15	time	time	NN
18637	734	16	of	of	IN
18637	734	17	peace	peace	NN
18637	734	18	without	without	IN
18637	734	19	the	the	DT
18637	734	20	consent	consent	NN
18637	734	21	of	of	IN
18637	734	22	the	the	DT
18637	734	23	colony	colony	NN
18637	734	24	in	in	IN
18637	734	25	which	which	WDT
18637	734	26	the	the	DT
18637	734	27	army	army	NN
18637	734	28	was	be	VBD
18637	734	29	kept	keep	VBN
18637	734	30	was	be	VBD
18637	734	31	"	"	``
18637	734	32	against	against	IN
18637	734	33	law	law	NN
18637	734	34	"	"	''
18637	734	35	;	;	:
18637	734	36	that	that	IN
18637	734	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	734	38	was	be	VBD
18637	734	39	"	"	``
18637	734	40	indispensably	indispensably	RB
18637	734	41	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	734	42	to	to	IN
18637	734	43	good	good	JJ
18637	734	44	government	government	NN
18637	734	45	,	,	,
18637	734	46	and	and	CC
18637	734	47	rendered	render	VBN
18637	734	48	essential	essential	JJ
18637	734	49	by	by	IN
18637	734	50	the	the	DT
18637	734	51	English	English	NNP
18637	734	52	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	734	53	,	,	,
18637	734	54	that	that	IN
18637	734	55	the	the	DT
18637	734	56	constituent	constituent	NN
18637	734	57	branches	branch	NNS
18637	734	58	of	of	IN
18637	734	59	the	the	DT
18637	734	60	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	734	61	be	be	VB
18637	734	62	independent	independent	JJ
18637	734	63	of	of	IN
18637	734	64	each	each	DT
18637	734	65	other	other	JJ
18637	734	66	"	"	''
18637	734	67	;	;	:
18637	734	68	that	that	IN
18637	734	69	certain	certain	JJ
18637	734	70	acts	act	NNS
18637	734	71	of	of	IN
18637	734	72	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
18637	734	73	in	in	IN
18637	734	74	contravention	contravention	NN
18637	734	75	of	of	IN
18637	734	76	the	the	DT
18637	734	77	foregoing	foregoing	JJ
18637	734	78	principles	principle	NNS
18637	734	79	were	be	VBD
18637	734	80	"	"	``
18637	734	81	infringements	infringement	NNS
18637	734	82	and	and	CC
18637	734	83	violations	violation	NNS
18637	734	84	of	of	IN
18637	734	85	the	the	DT
18637	734	86	rights	right	NNS
18637	734	87	of	of	IN
18637	734	88	the	the	DT
18637	734	89	colonists	colonist	NNS
18637	734	90	.	.	.
18637	734	91	"	"	''
18637	735	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	735	2	Text	text	NN
18637	735	3	in	in	IN
18637	735	4	Documents	Documents	NNP
18637	735	5	Illustrative	Illustrative	NNP
18637	735	6	of	of	IN
18637	735	7	the	the	DT
18637	735	8	Formation	Formation	NNP
18637	735	9	of	of	IN
18637	735	10	the	the	DT
18637	735	11	Union	Union	NNP
18637	735	12	,	,	,
18637	735	13	pp	pp	NNP
18637	735	14	.	.	.
18637	736	1	1	1	CD
18637	736	2	-	-	SYM
18637	736	3	5	5	CD
18637	736	4	.	.	.
18637	736	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	737	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	737	2	b	b	LS
18637	737	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	737	4	Text	Text	NNP
18637	737	5	in	in	IN
18637	737	6	Documents	Documents	NNP
18637	737	7	Illustrative	Illustrative	NNP
18637	737	8	of	of	IN
18637	737	9	the	the	DT
18637	737	10	Formation	Formation	NNP
18637	737	11	of	of	IN
18637	737	12	the	the	DT
18637	737	13	Union	Union	NNP
18637	737	14	,	,	,
18637	737	15	pp	pp	NNP
18637	737	16	.	.	.
18637	738	1	10	10	CD
18637	738	2	-	-	SYM
18637	738	3	17	17	CD
18637	738	4	.	.	.
18637	739	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	739	2	c	c	NN
18637	739	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	739	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	739	5	.	.	.
18637	739	6	,	,	,
18637	739	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	739	8	.	.	.
18637	740	1	19	19	CD
18637	740	2	-	-	SYM
18637	740	3	20	20	CD
18637	740	4	.	.	.
18637	741	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	741	2	d	d	NN
18637	741	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	741	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	741	5	.	.	.
18637	741	6	,	,	,
18637	741	7	p.	p.	NN
18637	741	8	21	21	CD
18637	741	9	.	.	.
18637	742	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	742	2	e	e	NNP
18637	742	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	742	4	George	George	NNP
18637	742	5	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	742	6	,	,	,
18637	742	7	Edmund	Edmund	NNP
18637	742	8	Randolph	Randolph	NNP
18637	742	9	,	,	,
18637	742	10	James	James	NNP
18637	742	11	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	742	12	,	,	,
18637	742	13	and	and	CC
18637	742	14	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	742	15	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	742	16	were	be	VBD
18637	742	17	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	742	18	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	742	19	for	for	IN
18637	742	20	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	742	21	;	;	:
18637	742	22	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	742	23	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	742	24	,	,	,
18637	742	25	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	742	26	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	742	27	,	,	,
18637	742	28	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
18637	742	29	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	742	30	,	,	,
18637	742	31	and	and	CC
18637	742	32	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	742	33	of	of	IN
18637	742	34	St.	St.	NNP
18637	742	35	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	742	36	Jenifer	Jenifer	NNP
18637	742	37	for	for	IN
18637	742	38	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	742	39	.	.	.
18637	743	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	743	2	f	f	LS
18637	743	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	743	4	The	the	DT
18637	743	5	text	text	NN
18637	743	6	of	of	IN
18637	743	7	the	the	DT
18637	743	8	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	743	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	743	10	to	to	TO
18637	743	11	be	be	VB
18637	743	12	found	find	VBN
18637	743	13	in	in	IN
18637	743	14	153	153	CD
18637	743	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	743	16	162	162	CD
18637	743	17	-	-	SYM
18637	743	18	163	163	CD
18637	743	19	.	.	.
18637	744	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	744	2	g	g	NN
18637	744	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	744	4	See	see	VB
18637	744	5	Wharton	Wharton	NNP
18637	744	6	_	_	NNP
18637	744	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	744	8	_	_	NNP
18637	744	9	Wise	Wise	NNP
18637	744	10	,	,	,
18637	744	11	153	153	CD
18637	744	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	744	13	155	155	CD
18637	744	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	744	15	1894	1894	CD
18637	744	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	744	17	.	.	.
18637	745	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	745	2	h	h	NN
18637	745	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	745	4	Text	Text	NNP
18637	745	5	in	in	IN
18637	745	6	Documents	Documents	NNP
18637	745	7	Illustrative	Illustrative	NNP
18637	745	8	of	of	IN
18637	745	9	the	the	DT
18637	745	10	Formation	Formation	NNP
18637	745	11	of	of	IN
18637	745	12	the	the	DT
18637	745	13	Union	Union	NNP
18637	745	14	,	,	,
18637	745	15	p.	p.	NN
18637	745	16	38	38	CD
18637	745	17	.	.	.
18637	746	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	746	2	i	i	NN
18637	746	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	746	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	746	5	.	.	.
18637	746	6	,	,	,
18637	746	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	746	8	.	.	.
18637	747	1	39	39	CD
18637	747	2	-	-	SYM
18637	747	3	43	43	CD
18637	747	4	.	.	.
18637	748	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	748	2	j	j	NNP
18637	748	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	748	4	The	the	DT
18637	748	5	New	New	NNP
18637	748	6	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	748	7	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	748	8	did	do	VBD
18637	748	9	not	not	RB
18637	748	10	arrive	arrive	VB
18637	748	11	until	until	IN
18637	748	12	July	July	NNP
18637	748	13	23	23	CD
18637	748	14	,	,	,
18637	748	15	1787	1787	CD
18637	748	16	.	.	.
18637	749	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	749	2	k	k	NNP
18637	749	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	749	4	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	749	5	of	of	IN
18637	749	6	South	South	NNP
18637	749	7	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	749	8	,	,	,
18637	749	9	Randolph	Randolph	NNP
18637	749	10	of	of	IN
18637	749	11	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	749	12	,	,	,
18637	749	13	Gorham	Gorham	NNP
18637	749	14	of	of	IN
18637	749	15	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	749	16	,	,	,
18637	749	17	Ellsworth	Ellsworth	NNP
18637	749	18	of	of	IN
18637	749	19	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	749	20	,	,	,
18637	749	21	and	and	CC
18637	749	22	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	749	23	of	of	IN
18637	749	24	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	749	25	.	.	.
18637	750	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	750	2	l	l	NN
18637	750	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	750	4	William	William	NNP
18637	750	5	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
18637	750	6	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	750	7	of	of	IN
18637	750	8	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	750	9	,	,	,
18637	750	10	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	750	11	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	750	12	of	of	IN
18637	750	13	New	New	NNP
18637	750	14	York	York	NNP
18637	750	15	,	,	,
18637	750	16	Gouverneur	Gouverneur	NNP
18637	750	17	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	750	18	of	of	IN
18637	750	19	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	750	20	,	,	,
18637	750	21	James	James	NNP
18637	750	22	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	750	23	of	of	IN
18637	750	24	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	750	25	,	,	,
18637	750	26	and	and	CC
18637	750	27	Rufus	Rufus	NNP
18637	750	28	King	King	NNP
18637	750	29	,	,	,
18637	750	30	of	of	IN
18637	750	31	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	750	32	.	.	.
18637	751	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	751	2	m	m	NN
18637	751	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	751	4	At	at	IN
18637	751	5	least	least	RBS
18637	751	6	65	65	CD
18637	751	7	persons	person	NNS
18637	751	8	had	have	VBD
18637	751	9	received	receive	VBN
18637	751	10	appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	751	11	as	as	IN
18637	751	12	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	751	13	to	to	IN
18637	751	14	the	the	DT
18637	751	15	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	751	16	;	;	:
18637	751	17	55	55	CD
18637	751	18	actually	actually	RB
18637	751	19	attended	attend	VBN
18637	751	20	at	at	IN
18637	751	21	different	different	JJ
18637	751	22	times	time	NNS
18637	751	23	during	during	IN
18637	751	24	the	the	DT
18637	751	25	course	course	NN
18637	751	26	of	of	IN
18637	751	27	the	the	DT
18637	751	28	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	751	29	;	;	:
18637	751	30	39	39	CD
18637	751	31	signed	sign	VBD
18637	751	32	the	the	DT
18637	751	33	document	document	NN
18637	751	34	.	.	.
18637	752	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	752	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	752	3	been	be	VBN
18637	752	4	estimated	estimate	VBN
18637	752	5	that	that	IN
18637	752	6	generally	generally	RB
18637	752	7	fewer	few	JJR
18637	752	8	than	than	IN
18637	752	9	30	30	CD
18637	752	10	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	752	11	attended	attend	VBD
18637	752	12	the	the	DT
18637	752	13	daily	daily	JJ
18637	752	14	sessions	session	NNS
18637	752	15	.	.	.
18637	753	1	For	for	IN
18637	753	2	further	further	JJ
18637	753	3	details	detail	NNS
18637	753	4	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	753	5	the	the	DT
18637	753	6	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	753	7	of	of	IN
18637	753	8	1787	1787	CD
18637	753	9	_	_	NNP
18637	753	10	see	see	NNP
18637	753	11	_	_	NNP
18637	753	12	:	:	:
18637	753	13	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	753	14	,	,	,
18637	753	15	Debates	Debates	NNP
18637	753	16	;	;	:
18637	753	17	Farrand	Farrand	NNP
18637	753	18	,	,	,
18637	753	19	Records	Records	NNPS
18637	753	20	of	of	IN
18637	753	21	the	the	DT
18637	753	22	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	753	23	Conventions	Conventions	NNPS
18637	753	24	;	;	:
18637	753	25	Farrand	Farrand	NNP
18637	753	26	,	,	,
18637	753	27	The	the	DT
18637	753	28	Framing	framing	NN
18637	753	29	of	of	IN
18637	753	30	the	the	DT
18637	753	31	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	753	32	;	;	:
18637	753	33	Meigs	Meigs	NNP
18637	753	34	,	,	,
18637	753	35	Growth	Growth	NNP
18637	753	36	of	of	IN
18637	753	37	the	the	DT
18637	753	38	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	753	39	.	.	.
18637	754	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	754	2	n	n	LS
18637	754	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	754	4	These	these	DT
18637	754	5	commentaries	commentary	NNS
18637	754	6	on	on	IN
18637	754	7	the	the	DT
18637	754	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	754	9	,	,	,
18637	754	10	written	write	VBN
18637	754	11	during	during	IN
18637	754	12	the	the	DT
18637	754	13	struggle	struggle	NN
18637	754	14	for	for	IN
18637	754	15	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	754	16	,	,	,
18637	754	17	have	have	VBP
18637	754	18	been	be	VBN
18637	754	19	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	754	20	cited	cite	VBN
18637	754	21	by	by	IN
18637	754	22	the	the	DT
18637	754	23	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	754	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	754	25	as	as	IN
18637	754	26	an	an	DT
18637	754	27	authoritative	authoritative	JJ
18637	754	28	contemporary	contemporary	JJ
18637	754	29	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	754	30	of	of	IN
18637	754	31	the	the	DT
18637	754	32	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	754	33	of	of	IN
18637	754	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	754	35	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	754	36	.	.	.
18637	755	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	755	2	o	o	NN
18637	755	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	755	4	North	North	NNP
18637	755	5	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	755	6	added	add	VBD
18637	755	7	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	755	8	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	755	9	on	on	IN
18637	755	10	November	November	NNP
18637	755	11	21	21	CD
18637	755	12	,	,	,
18637	755	13	1789	1789	CD
18637	755	14	;	;	:
18637	755	15	yeas	yeas	RB
18637	755	16	184	184	CD
18637	755	17	,	,	,
18637	755	18	nays	nay	VBZ
18637	755	19	77	77	CD
18637	755	20	.	.	.
18637	756	1	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	756	2	Island	Island	NNP
18637	756	3	did	do	VBD
18637	756	4	not	not	RB
18637	756	5	ratify	ratify	VB
18637	756	6	until	until	IN
18637	756	7	May	May	NNP
18637	756	8	29	29	CD
18637	756	9	,	,	,
18637	756	10	1790	1790	CD
18637	756	11	;	;	:
18637	756	12	yeas	yeas	RB
18637	756	13	34	34	CD
18637	756	14	,	,	,
18637	756	15	nays	nay	VBZ
18637	756	16	32	32	CD
18637	756	17	.	.	.
18637	757	1	THE	the	DT
18637	757	2	CONSTITUTION	CONSTITUTION	NNP
18637	757	3	OF	of	IN
18637	757	4	THE	the	DT
18637	757	5	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	757	6	STATES	state	NNS
18637	757	7	OF	of	IN
18637	757	8	AMERICA	AMERICA	NNP
18637	757	9	LITERAL	LITERAL	NNP
18637	757	10	PRINT	PRINT	NNP
18637	757	11	CONSTITUTION	constitution	NN
18637	757	12	OF	of	IN
18637	757	13	THE	the	DT
18637	757	14	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	757	15	STATES	STATES	NNP
18637	757	16	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	757	17	the	the	DT
18637	757	18	People	People	NNS
18637	757	19	of	of	IN
18637	757	20	the	the	DT
18637	757	21	United	United	NNP
18637	757	22	States	States	NNP
18637	757	23	,	,	,
18637	757	24	in	in	IN
18637	757	25	Order	order	NN
18637	757	26	to	to	TO
18637	757	27	form	form	VB
18637	757	28	a	a	DT
18637	757	29	more	more	RBR
18637	757	30	perfect	perfect	JJ
18637	757	31	Union	Union	NNP
18637	757	32	,	,	,
18637	757	33	establish	establish	VB
18637	757	34	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	757	35	,	,	,
18637	757	36	insure	insure	VB
18637	757	37	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	757	38	Tranquility	tranquility	NN
18637	757	39	,	,	,
18637	757	40	provide	provide	VB
18637	757	41	for	for	IN
18637	757	42	the	the	DT
18637	757	43	common	common	JJ
18637	757	44	defence	defence	NN
18637	757	45	,	,	,
18637	757	46	promote	promote	VB
18637	757	47	the	the	DT
18637	757	48	general	general	JJ
18637	757	49	Welfare	welfare	NN
18637	757	50	,	,	,
18637	757	51	and	and	CC
18637	757	52	secure	secure	VB
18637	757	53	the	the	DT
18637	757	54	Blessings	Blessings	NNP
18637	757	55	of	of	IN
18637	757	56	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	757	57	to	to	IN
18637	757	58	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	757	59	and	and	CC
18637	757	60	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	757	61	Posterity	Posterity	NNP
18637	757	62	,	,	,
18637	757	63	do	do	VB
18637	757	64	ordain	ordain	VB
18637	757	65	and	and	CC
18637	757	66	establish	establish	VB
18637	757	67	this	this	DT
18637	757	68	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	757	69	for	for	IN
18637	757	70	the	the	DT
18637	757	71	United	United	NNP
18637	757	72	States	States	NNP
18637	757	73	of	of	IN
18637	757	74	America	America	NNP
18637	757	75	.	.	.
18637	758	1	Article	article	NN
18637	758	2	.	.	.
18637	759	1	I.	I.	NNP
18637	760	1	Section	section	NN
18637	760	2	.	.	.
18637	761	1	1	1	LS
18637	761	2	.	.	.
18637	762	1	All	all	DT
18637	762	2	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	762	3	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	762	4	herein	herein	NN
18637	762	5	granted	grant	VBN
18637	762	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	762	7	be	be	VB
18637	762	8	vested	vest	VBN
18637	762	9	in	in	IN
18637	762	10	a	a	DT
18637	762	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	762	12	of	of	IN
18637	762	13	the	the	DT
18637	762	14	United	United	NNP
18637	762	15	States	States	NNP
18637	762	16	,	,	,
18637	762	17	which	which	WDT
18637	762	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	762	19	consist	consist	VB
18637	762	20	of	of	IN
18637	762	21	a	a	DT
18637	762	22	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	762	23	and	and	CC
18637	762	24	House	House	NNP
18637	762	25	of	of	IN
18637	762	26	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	762	27	.	.	.
18637	763	1	Section	section	NN
18637	763	2	.	.	.
18637	764	1	2	2	LS
18637	764	2	.	.	.
18637	765	1	The	the	DT
18637	765	2	House	House	NNP
18637	765	3	of	of	IN
18637	765	4	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	765	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	765	6	be	be	VB
18637	765	7	composed	compose	VBN
18637	765	8	of	of	IN
18637	765	9	Members	member	NNS
18637	765	10	chosen	choose	VBD
18637	765	11	every	every	DT
18637	765	12	second	second	JJ
18637	765	13	Year	Year	NNP
18637	765	14	by	by	IN
18637	765	15	the	the	DT
18637	765	16	People	People	NNS
18637	765	17	of	of	IN
18637	765	18	the	the	DT
18637	765	19	several	several	JJ
18637	765	20	States	States	NNPS
18637	765	21	,	,	,
18637	765	22	and	and	CC
18637	765	23	the	the	DT
18637	765	24	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	765	25	in	in	IN
18637	765	26	each	each	DT
18637	765	27	State	state	NN
18637	765	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	765	29	have	have	VB
18637	765	30	the	the	DT
18637	765	31	Qualifications	Qualifications	NNPS
18637	765	32	requisite	requisite	NN
18637	765	33	for	for	IN
18637	765	34	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	765	35	of	of	IN
18637	765	36	the	the	DT
18637	765	37	most	most	RBS
18637	765	38	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	765	39	Branch	Branch	NNP
18637	765	40	of	of	IN
18637	765	41	the	the	DT
18637	765	42	State	State	NNP
18637	765	43	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	765	44	.	.	.
18637	766	1	No	no	DT
18637	766	2	Person	person	NN
18637	766	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	766	4	be	be	VB
18637	766	5	a	a	DT
18637	766	6	Representative	Representative	NNP
18637	766	7	who	who	WP
18637	766	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	766	9	not	not	RB
18637	766	10	have	have	VB
18637	766	11	attained	attain	VBN
18637	766	12	to	to	IN
18637	766	13	the	the	DT
18637	766	14	age	age	NN
18637	766	15	of	of	IN
18637	766	16	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	766	17	five	five	CD
18637	766	18	Years	year	NNS
18637	766	19	,	,	,
18637	766	20	and	and	CC
18637	766	21	been	be	VBN
18637	766	22	seven	seven	CD
18637	766	23	Years	year	NNS
18637	766	24	a	a	DT
18637	766	25	Citizen	Citizen	NNP
18637	766	26	of	of	IN
18637	766	27	the	the	DT
18637	766	28	United	United	NNP
18637	766	29	States	States	NNP
18637	766	30	,	,	,
18637	766	31	and	and	CC
18637	766	32	who	who	WP
18637	766	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	766	34	not	not	RB
18637	766	35	,	,	,
18637	766	36	when	when	WRB
18637	766	37	elected	elect	VBN
18637	766	38	,	,	,
18637	766	39	be	be	VB
18637	766	40	an	an	DT
18637	766	41	Inhabitant	Inhabitant	NNP
18637	766	42	of	of	IN
18637	766	43	that	that	DT
18637	766	44	State	State	NNP
18637	766	45	in	in	IN
18637	766	46	which	which	WDT
18637	766	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	766	48	shall	shall	MD
18637	766	49	be	be	VB
18637	766	50	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	766	51	.	.	.
18637	767	1	Representatives	representative	NNS
18637	767	2	and	and	CC
18637	767	3	direct	direct	JJ
18637	767	4	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	767	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	767	6	be	be	VB
18637	767	7	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	767	8	among	among	IN
18637	767	9	the	the	DT
18637	767	10	several	several	JJ
18637	767	11	States	state	NNS
18637	767	12	which	which	WDT
18637	767	13	may	may	MD
18637	767	14	be	be	VB
18637	767	15	included	include	VBN
18637	767	16	within	within	IN
18637	767	17	this	this	DT
18637	767	18	Union	Union	NNP
18637	767	19	,	,	,
18637	767	20	according	accord	VBG
18637	767	21	to	to	IN
18637	767	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	767	23	respective	respective	JJ
18637	767	24	Numbers	number	NNS
18637	767	25	,	,	,
18637	767	26	which	which	WDT
18637	767	27	shall	shall	MD
18637	767	28	be	be	VB
18637	767	29	determined	determine	VBN
18637	767	30	by	by	IN
18637	767	31	adding	add	VBG
18637	767	32	to	to	IN
18637	767	33	the	the	DT
18637	767	34	whole	whole	JJ
18637	767	35	Number	number	NN
18637	767	36	of	of	IN
18637	767	37	free	free	JJ
18637	767	38	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	767	39	,	,	,
18637	767	40	including	include	VBG
18637	767	41	those	those	DT
18637	767	42	bound	bind	VBN
18637	767	43	to	to	IN
18637	767	44	Service	Service	NNP
18637	767	45	for	for	IN
18637	767	46	a	a	DT
18637	767	47	Term	Term	NNP
18637	767	48	of	of	IN
18637	767	49	Years	Years	NNPS
18637	767	50	,	,	,
18637	767	51	and	and	CC
18637	767	52	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	767	53	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	767	54	not	not	RB
18637	767	55	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	767	56	,	,	,
18637	767	57	three	three	CD
18637	767	58	fifths	fifth	NNS
18637	767	59	of	of	IN
18637	767	60	all	all	DT
18637	767	61	other	other	JJ
18637	767	62	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	767	63	.	.	.
18637	768	1	The	the	DT
18637	768	2	actual	actual	JJ
18637	768	3	Enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	768	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	768	5	be	be	VB
18637	768	6	made	make	VBN
18637	768	7	within	within	IN
18637	768	8	three	three	CD
18637	768	9	Years	year	NNS
18637	768	10	after	after	IN
18637	768	11	the	the	DT
18637	768	12	first	first	JJ
18637	768	13	Meeting	Meeting	NNP
18637	768	14	of	of	IN
18637	768	15	the	the	DT
18637	768	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	768	17	of	of	IN
18637	768	18	the	the	DT
18637	768	19	United	United	NNP
18637	768	20	States	States	NNP
18637	768	21	,	,	,
18637	768	22	and	and	CC
18637	768	23	within	within	IN
18637	768	24	every	every	DT
18637	768	25	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	768	26	Term	Term	NNP
18637	768	27	of	of	IN
18637	768	28	ten	ten	CD
18637	768	29	Years	year	NNS
18637	768	30	,	,	,
18637	768	31	in	in	IN
18637	768	32	such	such	JJ
18637	768	33	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	768	34	as	as	IN
18637	768	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	768	36	shall	shall	MD
18637	768	37	by	by	IN
18637	768	38	Law	Law	NNP
18637	768	39	direct	direct	RB
18637	768	40	.	.	.
18637	769	1	The	the	DT
18637	769	2	Number	Number	NNP
18637	769	3	of	of	IN
18637	769	4	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	769	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	769	6	not	not	RB
18637	769	7	exceed	exceed	VB
18637	769	8	one	one	CD
18637	769	9	for	for	IN
18637	769	10	every	every	DT
18637	769	11	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	769	12	Thousand	thousand	CD
18637	769	13	,	,	,
18637	769	14	but	but	CC
18637	769	15	each	each	DT
18637	769	16	State	state	NN
18637	769	17	shall	shall	MD
18637	769	18	have	have	VB
18637	769	19	at	at	RB
18637	769	20	Least	least	RBS
18637	769	21	one	one	CD
18637	769	22	Representative	representative	NN
18637	769	23	;	;	:
18637	769	24	and	and	CC
18637	769	25	until	until	IN
18637	769	26	such	such	JJ
18637	769	27	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	769	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	769	29	be	be	VB
18637	769	30	made	make	VBN
18637	769	31	,	,	,
18637	769	32	the	the	DT
18637	769	33	State	State	NNP
18637	769	34	of	of	IN
18637	769	35	New	New	NNP
18637	769	36	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	769	37	shall	shall	MD
18637	769	38	be	be	VB
18637	769	39	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	769	40	to	to	TO
18637	769	41	chuse	chuse	VB
18637	769	42	three	three	CD
18637	769	43	,	,	,
18637	769	44	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	769	45	eight	eight	CD
18637	769	46	,	,	,
18637	769	47	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	769	48	-	-	HYPH
18637	769	49	Island	Island	NNP
18637	769	50	and	and	CC
18637	769	51	Providence	Providence	NNP
18637	769	52	Plantations	Plantations	NNP
18637	769	53	one	one	CD
18637	769	54	,	,	,
18637	769	55	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	769	56	five	five	CD
18637	769	57	,	,	,
18637	769	58	New	New	NNP
18637	769	59	-	-	HYPH
18637	769	60	York	York	NNP
18637	769	61	six	six	CD
18637	769	62	,	,	,
18637	769	63	New	New	NNP
18637	769	64	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	769	65	four	four	CD
18637	769	66	,	,	,
18637	769	67	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	769	68	eight	eight	CD
18637	769	69	,	,	,
18637	769	70	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	769	71	one	one	CD
18637	769	72	,	,	,
18637	769	73	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	769	74	six	six	CD
18637	769	75	,	,	,
18637	769	76	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	769	77	ten	ten	CD
18637	769	78	,	,	,
18637	769	79	North	North	NNP
18637	769	80	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	769	81	five	five	CD
18637	769	82	,	,	,
18637	769	83	South	South	NNP
18637	769	84	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	769	85	five	five	CD
18637	769	86	,	,	,
18637	769	87	and	and	CC
18637	769	88	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	769	89	three	three	CD
18637	769	90	.	.	.
18637	770	1	When	when	WRB
18637	770	2	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	770	3	happen	happen	VBP
18637	770	4	in	in	IN
18637	770	5	the	the	DT
18637	770	6	Representation	Representation	NNP
18637	770	7	from	from	IN
18637	770	8	any	any	DT
18637	770	9	State	State	NNP
18637	770	10	,	,	,
18637	770	11	the	the	DT
18637	770	12	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	770	13	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	770	14	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	770	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	770	16	issue	issue	VB
18637	770	17	Writs	Writs	NNP
18637	770	18	of	of	IN
18637	770	19	Election	Election	NNP
18637	770	20	to	to	TO
18637	770	21	fill	fill	VB
18637	770	22	such	such	JJ
18637	770	23	Vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	770	24	.	.	.
18637	771	1	The	the	DT
18637	771	2	House	House	NNP
18637	771	3	of	of	IN
18637	771	4	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	771	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	771	6	chuse	chuse	VB
18637	771	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	771	8	Speaker	Speaker	NNP
18637	771	9	and	and	CC
18637	771	10	other	other	JJ
18637	771	11	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	771	12	;	;	:
18637	771	13	and	and	CC
18637	771	14	shall	shall	MD
18637	771	15	have	have	VB
18637	771	16	the	the	DT
18637	771	17	sole	sole	JJ
18637	771	18	Power	Power	NNP
18637	771	19	of	of	IN
18637	771	20	Impeachment	Impeachment	NNP
18637	771	21	.	.	.
18637	772	1	Section	section	NN
18637	772	2	.	.	.
18637	773	1	3	3	LS
18637	773	2	.	.	.
18637	774	1	The	the	DT
18637	774	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	774	3	of	of	IN
18637	774	4	the	the	DT
18637	774	5	United	United	NNP
18637	774	6	States	States	NNP
18637	774	7	shall	shall	MD
18637	774	8	be	be	VB
18637	774	9	composed	compose	VBN
18637	774	10	of	of	IN
18637	774	11	two	two	CD
18637	774	12	Senators	senator	NNS
18637	774	13	from	from	IN
18637	774	14	each	each	DT
18637	774	15	State	state	NN
18637	774	16	,	,	,
18637	774	17	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	774	18	by	by	IN
18637	774	19	the	the	DT
18637	774	20	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	774	21	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	774	22	,	,	,
18637	774	23	for	for	IN
18637	774	24	six	six	CD
18637	774	25	Years	year	NNS
18637	774	26	;	;	:
18637	774	27	and	and	CC
18637	774	28	each	each	DT
18637	774	29	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	774	30	shall	shall	MD
18637	774	31	have	have	VB
18637	774	32	one	one	CD
18637	774	33	Vote	vote	NN
18637	774	34	.	.	.
18637	775	1	Immediately	immediately	RB
18637	775	2	after	after	IN
18637	775	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	775	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	775	5	be	be	VB
18637	775	6	assembled	assemble	VBN
18637	775	7	in	in	IN
18637	775	8	Consequence	Consequence	NNP
18637	775	9	of	of	IN
18637	775	10	the	the	DT
18637	775	11	first	first	JJ
18637	775	12	Election	Election	NNP
18637	775	13	,	,	,
18637	775	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	775	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	775	16	be	be	VB
18637	775	17	divided	divide	VBN
18637	775	18	as	as	RB
18637	775	19	equally	equally	RB
18637	775	20	as	as	IN
18637	775	21	may	may	MD
18637	775	22	be	be	VB
18637	775	23	into	into	IN
18637	775	24	three	three	CD
18637	775	25	Classes	class	NNS
18637	775	26	.	.	.
18637	776	1	The	the	DT
18637	776	2	Seats	seat	NNS
18637	776	3	of	of	IN
18637	776	4	the	the	DT
18637	776	5	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	776	6	of	of	IN
18637	776	7	the	the	DT
18637	776	8	first	first	JJ
18637	776	9	Class	Class	NNP
18637	776	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	776	11	be	be	VB
18637	776	12	vacated	vacate	VBN
18637	776	13	at	at	IN
18637	776	14	the	the	DT
18637	776	15	Expiration	Expiration	NNP
18637	776	16	of	of	IN
18637	776	17	the	the	DT
18637	776	18	second	second	JJ
18637	776	19	Year	Year	NNP
18637	776	20	,	,	,
18637	776	21	of	of	IN
18637	776	22	the	the	DT
18637	776	23	second	second	JJ
18637	776	24	Class	Class	NNP
18637	776	25	at	at	IN
18637	776	26	the	the	DT
18637	776	27	Expiration	Expiration	NNP
18637	776	28	of	of	IN
18637	776	29	the	the	DT
18637	776	30	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	776	31	Year	Year	NNP
18637	776	32	,	,	,
18637	776	33	and	and	CC
18637	776	34	of	of	IN
18637	776	35	the	the	DT
18637	776	36	third	third	JJ
18637	776	37	Class	Class	NNP
18637	776	38	at	at	IN
18637	776	39	the	the	DT
18637	776	40	Expiration	Expiration	NNP
18637	776	41	of	of	IN
18637	776	42	the	the	DT
18637	776	43	sixth	sixth	JJ
18637	776	44	Year	Year	NNP
18637	776	45	,	,	,
18637	776	46	so	so	IN
18637	776	47	that	that	IN
18637	776	48	one	one	CD
18637	776	49	third	third	NN
18637	776	50	may	may	MD
18637	776	51	be	be	VB
18637	776	52	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	776	53	every	every	DT
18637	776	54	second	second	JJ
18637	776	55	Year	year	NN
18637	776	56	;	;	,
18637	776	57	and	and	CC
18637	776	58	if	if	IN
18637	776	59	Vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	776	60	happen	happen	VBP
18637	776	61	by	by	IN
18637	776	62	Resignation	resignation	NN
18637	776	63	,	,	,
18637	776	64	or	or	CC
18637	776	65	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	776	66	,	,	,
18637	776	67	during	during	IN
18637	776	68	the	the	DT
18637	776	69	Recess	Recess	NNP
18637	776	70	of	of	IN
18637	776	71	the	the	DT
18637	776	72	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	776	73	of	of	IN
18637	776	74	any	any	DT
18637	776	75	State	State	NNP
18637	776	76	,	,	,
18637	776	77	the	the	DT
18637	776	78	Executive	executive	NN
18637	776	79	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	776	80	may	may	MD
18637	776	81	make	make	VB
18637	776	82	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	776	83	Appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	776	84	until	until	IN
18637	776	85	the	the	DT
18637	776	86	next	next	JJ
18637	776	87	Meeting	Meeting	NNP
18637	776	88	of	of	IN
18637	776	89	the	the	DT
18637	776	90	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	776	91	,	,	,
18637	776	92	which	which	WDT
18637	776	93	shall	shall	MD
18637	776	94	then	then	RB
18637	776	95	fill	fill	VB
18637	776	96	such	such	JJ
18637	776	97	Vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	776	98	.	.	.
18637	777	1	No	no	DT
18637	777	2	Person	person	NN
18637	777	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	777	4	be	be	VB
18637	777	5	a	a	DT
18637	777	6	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	777	7	who	who	WP
18637	777	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	777	9	not	not	RB
18637	777	10	have	have	VB
18637	777	11	attained	attain	VBN
18637	777	12	to	to	IN
18637	777	13	the	the	DT
18637	777	14	Age	Age	NNP
18637	777	15	of	of	IN
18637	777	16	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	777	17	Years	year	NNS
18637	777	18	,	,	,
18637	777	19	and	and	CC
18637	777	20	been	be	VBN
18637	777	21	nine	nine	CD
18637	777	22	Years	year	NNS
18637	777	23	a	a	DT
18637	777	24	Citizen	Citizen	NNP
18637	777	25	of	of	IN
18637	777	26	the	the	DT
18637	777	27	United	United	NNP
18637	777	28	States	States	NNP
18637	777	29	,	,	,
18637	777	30	and	and	CC
18637	777	31	who	who	WP
18637	777	32	shall	shall	MD
18637	777	33	not	not	RB
18637	777	34	,	,	,
18637	777	35	when	when	WRB
18637	777	36	elected	elect	VBN
18637	777	37	,	,	,
18637	777	38	be	be	VB
18637	777	39	an	an	DT
18637	777	40	Inhabitant	Inhabitant	NNP
18637	777	41	of	of	IN
18637	777	42	that	that	DT
18637	777	43	State	State	NNP
18637	777	44	for	for	IN
18637	777	45	which	which	WDT
18637	777	46	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	777	47	shall	shall	MD
18637	777	48	be	be	VB
18637	777	49	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	777	50	.	.	.
18637	778	1	The	the	DT
18637	778	2	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	778	3	President	President	NNP
18637	778	4	of	of	IN
18637	778	5	the	the	DT
18637	778	6	United	United	NNP
18637	778	7	States	States	NNP
18637	778	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	778	9	be	be	VB
18637	778	10	President	President	NNP
18637	778	11	of	of	IN
18637	778	12	the	the	DT
18637	778	13	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	778	14	,	,	,
18637	778	15	but	but	CC
18637	778	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	778	17	have	have	VB
18637	778	18	no	no	DT
18637	778	19	Vote	vote	NN
18637	778	20	,	,	,
18637	778	21	unless	unless	IN
18637	778	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	778	23	be	be	VBP
18637	778	24	equally	equally	RB
18637	778	25	divided	divided	JJ
18637	778	26	.	.	.
18637	779	1	The	the	DT
18637	779	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	779	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	779	4	chuse	chuse	VB
18637	779	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	779	6	other	other	JJ
18637	779	7	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	779	8	,	,	,
18637	779	9	and	and	CC
18637	779	10	also	also	RB
18637	779	11	a	a	DT
18637	779	12	President	President	NNP
18637	779	13	pro	pro	NN
18637	779	14	tempore	tempore	JJ
18637	779	15	,	,	,
18637	779	16	in	in	IN
18637	779	17	the	the	DT
18637	779	18	Absence	absence	NN
18637	779	19	of	of	IN
18637	779	20	the	the	DT
18637	779	21	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	779	22	President	President	NNP
18637	779	23	,	,	,
18637	779	24	or	or	CC
18637	779	25	when	when	WRB
18637	779	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	779	27	shall	shall	MD
18637	779	28	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	779	29	the	the	DT
18637	779	30	Office	Office	NNP
18637	779	31	of	of	IN
18637	779	32	President	President	NNP
18637	779	33	of	of	IN
18637	779	34	the	the	DT
18637	779	35	United	United	NNP
18637	779	36	States	States	NNP
18637	779	37	.	.	.
18637	780	1	The	the	DT
18637	780	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	780	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	780	4	have	have	VB
18637	780	5	the	the	DT
18637	780	6	sole	sole	JJ
18637	780	7	Power	Power	NNP
18637	780	8	to	to	TO
18637	780	9	try	try	VB
18637	780	10	all	all	DT
18637	780	11	Impeachments	Impeachments	NNPS
18637	780	12	.	.	.
18637	781	1	When	when	WRB
18637	781	2	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	781	3	for	for	IN
18637	781	4	that	that	DT
18637	781	5	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	781	6	,	,	,
18637	781	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	781	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	781	9	be	be	VB
18637	781	10	on	on	IN
18637	781	11	Oath	Oath	NNP
18637	781	12	or	or	CC
18637	781	13	Affirmation	Affirmation	NNP
18637	781	14	.	.	.
18637	782	1	When	when	WRB
18637	782	2	the	the	DT
18637	782	3	President	President	NNP
18637	782	4	of	of	IN
18637	782	5	the	the	DT
18637	782	6	United	United	NNP
18637	782	7	States	States	NNP
18637	782	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	782	9	tried	try	VBN
18637	782	10	the	the	DT
18637	782	11	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	782	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	782	13	shall	shall	MD
18637	782	14	preside	preside	VB
18637	782	15	:	:	:
18637	782	16	And	and	CC
18637	782	17	no	no	DT
18637	782	18	Person	person	NN
18637	782	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	782	20	be	be	VB
18637	782	21	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	782	22	without	without	IN
18637	782	23	the	the	DT
18637	782	24	Concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	782	25	of	of	IN
18637	782	26	two	two	CD
18637	782	27	thirds	third	NNS
18637	782	28	of	of	IN
18637	782	29	the	the	DT
18637	782	30	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	782	31	present	present	JJ
18637	782	32	.	.	.
18637	783	1	Judgment	judgment	NN
18637	783	2	in	in	IN
18637	783	3	Cases	case	NNS
18637	783	4	of	of	IN
18637	783	5	Impeachment	Impeachment	NNP
18637	783	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	783	7	not	not	RB
18637	783	8	extend	extend	VB
18637	783	9	further	further	RB
18637	783	10	than	than	IN
18637	783	11	to	to	IN
18637	783	12	removal	removal	NN
18637	783	13	from	from	IN
18637	783	14	Office	Office	NNP
18637	783	15	,	,	,
18637	783	16	and	and	CC
18637	783	17	disqualification	disqualification	NN
18637	783	18	to	to	TO
18637	783	19	hold	hold	VB
18637	783	20	and	and	CC
18637	783	21	enjoy	enjoy	VB
18637	783	22	any	any	DT
18637	783	23	Office	Office	NNP
18637	783	24	of	of	IN
18637	783	25	honor	honor	NN
18637	783	26	,	,	,
18637	783	27	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	783	28	or	or	CC
18637	783	29	Profit	Profit	NNP
18637	783	30	under	under	IN
18637	783	31	the	the	DT
18637	783	32	United	United	NNP
18637	783	33	States	States	NNP
18637	783	34	:	:	:
18637	783	35	but	but	CC
18637	783	36	the	the	DT
18637	783	37	Party	Party	NNP
18637	783	38	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	783	39	shall	shall	MD
18637	783	40	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	783	41	be	be	VB
18637	783	42	liable	liable	JJ
18637	783	43	and	and	CC
18637	783	44	subject	subject	JJ
18637	783	45	to	to	IN
18637	783	46	Indictment	Indictment	NNP
18637	783	47	,	,	,
18637	783	48	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	783	49	,	,	,
18637	783	50	Judgment	Judgment	NNP
18637	783	51	and	and	CC
18637	783	52	Punishment	Punishment	NNP
18637	783	53	,	,	,
18637	783	54	according	accord	VBG
18637	783	55	to	to	IN
18637	783	56	Law	Law	NNP
18637	783	57	.	.	.
18637	784	1	Section	section	NN
18637	784	2	.	.	.
18637	785	1	4	4	LS
18637	785	2	.	.	.
18637	786	1	The	the	DT
18637	786	2	Times	Times	NNP
18637	786	3	,	,	,
18637	786	4	Places	Places	NNPS
18637	786	5	and	and	CC
18637	786	6	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	786	7	of	of	IN
18637	786	8	holding	hold	VBG
18637	786	9	Elections	Elections	NNPS
18637	786	10	for	for	IN
18637	786	11	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	786	12	and	and	CC
18637	786	13	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	786	14	,	,	,
18637	786	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	786	16	be	be	VB
18637	786	17	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	786	18	in	in	IN
18637	786	19	each	each	DT
18637	786	20	State	state	NN
18637	786	21	by	by	IN
18637	786	22	the	the	DT
18637	786	23	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	786	24	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	786	25	;	;	:
18637	786	26	but	but	CC
18637	786	27	the	the	DT
18637	786	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	786	29	may	may	MD
18637	786	30	at	at	IN
18637	786	31	any	any	DT
18637	786	32	time	time	NN
18637	786	33	by	by	IN
18637	786	34	Law	Law	NNP
18637	786	35	make	make	VBP
18637	786	36	or	or	CC
18637	786	37	alter	alter	VB
18637	786	38	such	such	JJ
18637	786	39	Regulations	Regulations	NNPS
18637	786	40	,	,	,
18637	786	41	except	except	IN
18637	786	42	as	as	IN
18637	786	43	to	to	IN
18637	786	44	the	the	DT
18637	786	45	Places	Places	NNPS
18637	786	46	of	of	IN
18637	786	47	chusing	chuse	VBG
18637	786	48	Senators	senator	NNS
18637	786	49	.	.	.
18637	787	1	The	the	DT
18637	787	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	787	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	787	4	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	787	5	at	at	IN
18637	787	6	least	least	JJS
18637	787	7	once	once	RB
18637	787	8	in	in	IN
18637	787	9	every	every	DT
18637	787	10	Year	Year	NNP
18637	787	11	,	,	,
18637	787	12	and	and	CC
18637	787	13	such	such	JJ
18637	787	14	Meeting	meeting	NN
18637	787	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	787	16	be	be	VB
18637	787	17	on	on	IN
18637	787	18	the	the	DT
18637	787	19	first	first	JJ
18637	787	20	Monday	Monday	NNP
18637	787	21	in	in	IN
18637	787	22	December	December	NNP
18637	787	23	,	,	,
18637	787	24	unless	unless	IN
18637	787	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	787	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	787	27	by	by	IN
18637	787	28	Law	Law	NNP
18637	787	29	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	787	30	a	a	DT
18637	787	31	different	different	JJ
18637	787	32	Day	day	NN
18637	787	33	.	.	.
18637	788	1	Section	section	NN
18637	788	2	.	.	.
18637	789	1	5	5	CD
18637	789	2	.	.	.
18637	790	1	Each	each	DT
18637	790	2	House	House	NNP
18637	790	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	790	4	be	be	VB
18637	790	5	the	the	DT
18637	790	6	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	790	7	of	of	IN
18637	790	8	the	the	DT
18637	790	9	Elections	Elections	NNPS
18637	790	10	,	,	,
18637	790	11	Returns	Returns	NNPS
18637	790	12	and	and	CC
18637	790	13	Qualifications	Qualifications	NNPS
18637	790	14	of	of	IN
18637	790	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	790	16	own	own	JJ
18637	790	17	Members	member	NNS
18637	790	18	,	,	,
18637	790	19	and	and	CC
18637	790	20	a	a	DT
18637	790	21	Majority	majority	NN
18637	790	22	of	of	IN
18637	790	23	each	each	DT
18637	790	24	shall	shall	MD
18637	790	25	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	790	26	a	a	DT
18637	790	27	Quorum	Quorum	NNP
18637	790	28	to	to	TO
18637	790	29	do	do	VB
18637	790	30	Business	business	NN
18637	790	31	;	;	:
18637	790	32	but	but	CC
18637	790	33	a	a	DT
18637	790	34	smaller	small	JJR
18637	790	35	Number	Number	NNP
18637	790	36	may	may	MD
18637	790	37	adjourn	adjourn	VB
18637	790	38	from	from	IN
18637	790	39	day	day	NN
18637	790	40	to	to	IN
18637	790	41	day	day	NN
18637	790	42	,	,	,
18637	790	43	and	and	CC
18637	790	44	may	may	MD
18637	790	45	be	be	VB
18637	790	46	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	790	47	to	to	TO
18637	790	48	compel	compel	VB
18637	790	49	the	the	DT
18637	790	50	Attendance	attendance	NN
18637	790	51	of	of	IN
18637	790	52	absent	absent	JJ
18637	790	53	Members	member	NNS
18637	790	54	,	,	,
18637	790	55	in	in	IN
18637	790	56	such	such	JJ
18637	790	57	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	790	58	,	,	,
18637	790	59	and	and	CC
18637	790	60	under	under	IN
18637	790	61	such	such	JJ
18637	790	62	Penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	790	63	as	as	IN
18637	790	64	each	each	DT
18637	790	65	House	House	NNP
18637	790	66	may	may	MD
18637	790	67	provide	provide	VB
18637	790	68	.	.	.
18637	791	1	Each	each	DT
18637	791	2	House	House	NNP
18637	791	3	may	may	MD
18637	791	4	determine	determine	VB
18637	791	5	the	the	DT
18637	791	6	Rules	Rules	NNPS
18637	791	7	of	of	IN
18637	791	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	791	9	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNP
18637	791	10	,	,	,
18637	791	11	punish	punish	VB
18637	791	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	791	13	Members	member	NNS
18637	791	14	for	for	IN
18637	791	15	disorderly	disorderly	JJ
18637	791	16	Behaviour	Behaviour	NNP
18637	791	17	,	,	,
18637	791	18	and	and	CC
18637	791	19	,	,	,
18637	791	20	with	with	IN
18637	791	21	the	the	DT
18637	791	22	Concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	791	23	of	of	IN
18637	791	24	two	two	CD
18637	791	25	thirds	third	NNS
18637	791	26	,	,	,
18637	791	27	expel	expel	VB
18637	791	28	a	a	DT
18637	791	29	Member	Member	NNP
18637	791	30	.	.	.
18637	792	1	Each	each	DT
18637	792	2	House	House	NNP
18637	792	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	792	4	keep	keep	VB
18637	792	5	a	a	DT
18637	792	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	792	7	of	of	IN
18637	792	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	792	9	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNP
18637	792	10	,	,	,
18637	792	11	and	and	CC
18637	792	12	from	from	IN
18637	792	13	time	time	NN
18637	792	14	to	to	IN
18637	792	15	time	time	NN
18637	792	16	publish	publish	VB
18637	792	17	the	the	DT
18637	792	18	same	same	JJ
18637	792	19	,	,	,
18637	792	20	excepting	except	VBG
18637	792	21	such	such	JJ
18637	792	22	Parts	part	NNS
18637	792	23	as	as	IN
18637	792	24	may	may	MD
18637	792	25	in	in	IN
18637	792	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	792	27	Judgment	Judgment	NNP
18637	792	28	require	require	NN
18637	792	29	Secrecy	secrecy	NN
18637	792	30	;	;	:
18637	792	31	and	and	CC
18637	792	32	the	the	DT
18637	792	33	Yeas	Yeas	NNPS
18637	792	34	and	and	CC
18637	792	35	Nays	Nays	NNPS
18637	792	36	of	of	IN
18637	792	37	the	the	DT
18637	792	38	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	792	39	of	of	IN
18637	792	40	either	either	DT
18637	792	41	House	House	NNP
18637	792	42	on	on	IN
18637	792	43	any	any	DT
18637	792	44	question	question	NN
18637	792	45	shall	shall	MD
18637	792	46	,	,	,
18637	792	47	at	at	IN
18637	792	48	the	the	DT
18637	792	49	Desire	Desire	NNP
18637	792	50	of	of	IN
18637	792	51	one	one	CD
18637	792	52	fifth	fifth	NN
18637	792	53	of	of	IN
18637	792	54	those	those	DT
18637	792	55	Present	present	JJ
18637	792	56	,	,	,
18637	792	57	be	be	VB
18637	792	58	entered	enter	VBN
18637	792	59	on	on	IN
18637	792	60	the	the	DT
18637	792	61	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	792	62	.	.	.
18637	793	1	Neither	neither	DT
18637	793	2	House	House	NNP
18637	793	3	,	,	,
18637	793	4	during	during	IN
18637	793	5	the	the	DT
18637	793	6	Session	Session	NNP
18637	793	7	of	of	IN
18637	793	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	793	9	,	,	,
18637	793	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	793	11	,	,	,
18637	793	12	without	without	IN
18637	793	13	the	the	DT
18637	793	14	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	793	15	of	of	IN
18637	793	16	the	the	DT
18637	793	17	other	other	JJ
18637	793	18	,	,	,
18637	793	19	adjourn	adjourn	JJ
18637	793	20	for	for	IN
18637	793	21	more	more	JJR
18637	793	22	than	than	IN
18637	793	23	three	three	CD
18637	793	24	days	day	NNS
18637	793	25	,	,	,
18637	793	26	nor	nor	CC
18637	793	27	to	to	IN
18637	793	28	any	any	DT
18637	793	29	other	other	JJ
18637	793	30	Place	Place	NNP
18637	793	31	than	than	IN
18637	793	32	that	that	DT
18637	793	33	in	in	IN
18637	793	34	which	which	WDT
18637	793	35	the	the	DT
18637	793	36	two	two	CD
18637	793	37	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	793	38	shall	shall	MD
18637	793	39	be	be	VB
18637	793	40	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	793	41	.	.	.
18637	794	1	Section	section	NN
18637	794	2	.	.	.
18637	795	1	6	6	CD
18637	795	2	.	.	.
18637	796	1	The	the	DT
18637	796	2	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	796	3	and	and	CC
18637	796	4	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	796	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	796	6	receive	receive	VB
18637	796	7	a	a	DT
18637	796	8	Compensation	compensation	NN
18637	796	9	for	for	IN
18637	796	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	796	11	Services	service	NNS
18637	796	12	,	,	,
18637	796	13	to	to	TO
18637	796	14	be	be	VB
18637	796	15	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	796	16	by	by	IN
18637	796	17	Law	Law	NNP
18637	796	18	,	,	,
18637	796	19	and	and	CC
18637	796	20	paid	pay	VBD
18637	796	21	out	out	IN
18637	796	22	of	of	IN
18637	796	23	the	the	DT
18637	796	24	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	796	25	of	of	IN
18637	796	26	the	the	DT
18637	796	27	United	United	NNP
18637	796	28	States	States	NNP
18637	796	29	.	.	.
18637	797	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	797	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	797	3	in	in	IN
18637	797	4	all	all	DT
18637	797	5	Cases	case	NNS
18637	797	6	,	,	,
18637	797	7	except	except	IN
18637	797	8	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	797	9	,	,	,
18637	797	10	Felony	Felony	NNP
18637	797	11	and	and	CC
18637	797	12	Breach	Breach	NNP
18637	797	13	of	of	IN
18637	797	14	the	the	DT
18637	797	15	Peace	Peace	NNP
18637	797	16	,	,	,
18637	797	17	be	be	VB
18637	797	18	privileged	privileged	JJ
18637	797	19	from	from	IN
18637	797	20	Arrest	arrest	NN
18637	797	21	during	during	IN
18637	797	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	797	23	Attendance	attendance	NN
18637	797	24	at	at	IN
18637	797	25	the	the	DT
18637	797	26	Session	session	NN
18637	797	27	of	of	IN
18637	797	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	797	29	respective	respective	JJ
18637	797	30	Houses	house	NNS
18637	797	31	,	,	,
18637	797	32	and	and	CC
18637	797	33	in	in	IN
18637	797	34	going	go	VBG
18637	797	35	to	to	IN
18637	797	36	and	and	CC
18637	797	37	returning	return	VBG
18637	797	38	from	from	IN
18637	797	39	the	the	DT
18637	797	40	same	same	JJ
18637	797	41	;	;	:
18637	797	42	and	and	CC
18637	797	43	for	for	IN
18637	797	44	any	any	DT
18637	797	45	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	797	46	or	or	CC
18637	797	47	Debate	Debate	NNP
18637	797	48	in	in	IN
18637	797	49	either	either	CC
18637	797	50	House	House	NNP
18637	797	51	,	,	,
18637	797	52	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	797	53	shall	shall	MD
18637	797	54	not	not	RB
18637	797	55	be	be	VB
18637	797	56	questioned	question	VBN
18637	797	57	in	in	IN
18637	797	58	any	any	DT
18637	797	59	other	other	JJ
18637	797	60	Place	Place	NNP
18637	797	61	.	.	.
18637	798	1	No	no	DT
18637	798	2	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	798	3	or	or	CC
18637	798	4	Representative	Representative	NNP
18637	798	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	798	6	,	,	,
18637	798	7	during	during	IN
18637	798	8	the	the	DT
18637	798	9	Time	Time	NNP
18637	798	10	for	for	IN
18637	798	11	which	which	WDT
18637	798	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	798	13	was	be	VBD
18637	798	14	elected	elect	VBN
18637	798	15	,	,	,
18637	798	16	be	be	VB
18637	798	17	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	798	18	to	to	IN
18637	798	19	any	any	DT
18637	798	20	civil	civil	JJ
18637	798	21	Office	Office	NNP
18637	798	22	under	under	IN
18637	798	23	the	the	DT
18637	798	24	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	798	25	of	of	IN
18637	798	26	the	the	DT
18637	798	27	United	United	NNP
18637	798	28	States	States	NNP
18637	798	29	,	,	,
18637	798	30	which	which	WDT
18637	798	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	798	32	have	have	VB
18637	798	33	been	be	VBN
18637	798	34	created	create	VBN
18637	798	35	,	,	,
18637	798	36	or	or	CC
18637	798	37	the	the	DT
18637	798	38	Emoluments	Emoluments	NNPS
18637	798	39	whereof	whereof	NN
18637	798	40	shall	shall	MD
18637	798	41	have	have	VB
18637	798	42	been	be	VBN
18637	798	43	encreased	encrease	VBN
18637	798	44	during	during	IN
18637	798	45	such	such	JJ
18637	798	46	time	time	NN
18637	798	47	;	;	:
18637	798	48	and	and	CC
18637	798	49	no	no	DT
18637	798	50	Person	person	NN
18637	798	51	holding	hold	VBG
18637	798	52	any	any	DT
18637	798	53	Office	Office	NNP
18637	798	54	under	under	IN
18637	798	55	the	the	DT
18637	798	56	United	United	NNP
18637	798	57	States	States	NNP
18637	798	58	,	,	,
18637	798	59	shall	shall	MD
18637	798	60	be	be	VB
18637	798	61	a	a	DT
18637	798	62	Member	Member	NNP
18637	798	63	of	of	IN
18637	798	64	either	either	DT
18637	798	65	House	House	NNP
18637	798	66	during	during	IN
18637	798	67	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	798	68	Continuance	Continuance	NNP
18637	798	69	in	in	IN
18637	798	70	Office	Office	NNP
18637	798	71	.	.	.
18637	799	1	Section	section	NN
18637	799	2	.	.	.
18637	800	1	7	7	LS
18637	800	2	.	.	.
18637	801	1	All	all	DT
18637	801	2	Bills	bill	NNS
18637	801	3	for	for	IN
18637	801	4	raising	raise	VBG
18637	801	5	Revenue	revenue	NN
18637	801	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	801	7	originate	originate	VB
18637	801	8	in	in	IN
18637	801	9	the	the	DT
18637	801	10	House	House	NNP
18637	801	11	of	of	IN
18637	801	12	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	801	13	;	;	:
18637	801	14	but	but	CC
18637	801	15	the	the	DT
18637	801	16	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	801	17	may	may	MD
18637	801	18	propose	propose	VB
18637	801	19	or	or	CC
18637	801	20	concur	concur	VB
18637	801	21	with	with	IN
18637	801	22	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	801	23	as	as	IN
18637	801	24	on	on	IN
18637	801	25	other	other	JJ
18637	801	26	Bills	bill	NNS
18637	801	27	.	.	.
18637	802	1	Every	every	DT
18637	802	2	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	802	3	which	which	WDT
18637	802	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	802	5	have	have	VB
18637	802	6	passed	pass	VBN
18637	802	7	the	the	DT
18637	802	8	House	House	NNP
18637	802	9	of	of	IN
18637	802	10	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	802	11	and	and	CC
18637	802	12	the	the	DT
18637	802	13	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	802	14	,	,	,
18637	802	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	802	16	,	,	,
18637	802	17	before	before	IN
18637	802	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	802	19	become	become	VBP
18637	802	20	a	a	DT
18637	802	21	Law	Law	NNP
18637	802	22	,	,	,
18637	802	23	be	be	VB
18637	802	24	presented	present	VBN
18637	802	25	to	to	IN
18637	802	26	the	the	DT
18637	802	27	President	President	NNP
18637	802	28	of	of	IN
18637	802	29	the	the	DT
18637	802	30	United	United	NNP
18637	802	31	States	States	NNP
18637	802	32	;	;	:
18637	802	33	If	if	IN
18637	802	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	802	35	approve	approve	VBP
18637	802	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	802	37	shall	shall	MD
18637	802	38	sign	sign	VB
18637	802	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	802	40	,	,	,
18637	802	41	but	but	CC
18637	802	42	if	if	IN
18637	802	43	not	not	RB
18637	802	44	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	802	45	shall	shall	MD
18637	802	46	return	return	VB
18637	802	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	802	48	,	,	,
18637	802	49	with	with	IN
18637	802	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	802	51	Objections	objection	NNS
18637	802	52	to	to	IN
18637	802	53	that	that	DT
18637	802	54	House	House	NNP
18637	802	55	in	in	IN
18637	802	56	which	which	WDT
18637	802	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	802	58	shall	shall	MD
18637	802	59	have	have	VB
18637	802	60	originated	originate	VBN
18637	802	61	,	,	,
18637	802	62	who	who	WP
18637	802	63	shall	shall	MD
18637	802	64	enter	enter	VB
18637	802	65	the	the	DT
18637	802	66	Objections	objection	NNS
18637	802	67	at	at	IN
18637	802	68	large	large	JJ
18637	802	69	on	on	IN
18637	802	70	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	802	71	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	802	72	,	,	,
18637	802	73	and	and	CC
18637	802	74	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	802	75	to	to	TO
18637	802	76	reconsider	reconsider	VB
18637	802	77	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	802	78	.	.	.
18637	803	1	If	if	IN
18637	803	2	after	after	IN
18637	803	3	such	such	JJ
18637	803	4	Reconsideration	reconsideration	NN
18637	803	5	two	two	CD
18637	803	6	thirds	third	NNS
18637	803	7	of	of	IN
18637	803	8	that	that	IN
18637	803	9	House	House	NNP
18637	803	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	803	11	agree	agree	VB
18637	803	12	to	to	TO
18637	803	13	pass	pass	VB
18637	803	14	the	the	DT
18637	803	15	Bill	bill	NN
18637	803	16	,	,	,
18637	803	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	803	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	803	19	be	be	VB
18637	803	20	sent	send	VBN
18637	803	21	,	,	,
18637	803	22	together	together	RB
18637	803	23	with	with	IN
18637	803	24	the	the	DT
18637	803	25	Objections	objection	NNS
18637	803	26	,	,	,
18637	803	27	to	to	IN
18637	803	28	the	the	DT
18637	803	29	other	other	JJ
18637	803	30	House	House	NNP
18637	803	31	,	,	,
18637	803	32	by	by	IN
18637	803	33	which	which	WDT
18637	803	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	803	35	shall	shall	MD
18637	803	36	likewise	likewise	RB
18637	803	37	be	be	VB
18637	803	38	reconsidered	reconsider	VBN
18637	803	39	,	,	,
18637	803	40	and	and	CC
18637	803	41	if	if	IN
18637	803	42	approved	approve	VBN
18637	803	43	by	by	IN
18637	803	44	two	two	CD
18637	803	45	thirds	third	NNS
18637	803	46	of	of	IN
18637	803	47	that	that	DT
18637	803	48	House	House	NNP
18637	803	49	,	,	,
18637	803	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	803	51	shall	shall	MD
18637	803	52	become	become	VB
18637	803	53	a	a	DT
18637	803	54	Law	law	NN
18637	803	55	.	.	.
18637	804	1	But	but	CC
18637	804	2	in	in	IN
18637	804	3	all	all	DT
18637	804	4	such	such	JJ
18637	804	5	Cases	case	NNS
18637	804	6	the	the	DT
18637	804	7	Votes	vote	NNS
18637	804	8	of	of	IN
18637	804	9	both	both	DT
18637	804	10	Houses	house	NNS
18637	804	11	shall	shall	MD
18637	804	12	be	be	VB
18637	804	13	determined	determine	VBN
18637	804	14	by	by	IN
18637	804	15	yeas	yea	NNS
18637	804	16	and	and	CC
18637	804	17	Nays	Nays	NNP
18637	804	18	,	,	,
18637	804	19	and	and	CC
18637	804	20	the	the	DT
18637	804	21	Names	Names	NNPS
18637	804	22	of	of	IN
18637	804	23	the	the	DT
18637	804	24	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	804	25	voting	vote	VBG
18637	804	26	for	for	IN
18637	804	27	and	and	CC
18637	804	28	against	against	IN
18637	804	29	the	the	DT
18637	804	30	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	804	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	804	32	be	be	VB
18637	804	33	entered	enter	VBN
18637	804	34	on	on	IN
18637	804	35	the	the	DT
18637	804	36	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	804	37	of	of	IN
18637	804	38	each	each	DT
18637	804	39	House	House	NNP
18637	804	40	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	804	41	.	.	.
18637	805	1	If	if	IN
18637	805	2	any	any	DT
18637	805	3	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	805	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	805	5	not	not	RB
18637	805	6	be	be	VB
18637	805	7	returned	return	VBN
18637	805	8	by	by	IN
18637	805	9	the	the	DT
18637	805	10	President	President	NNP
18637	805	11	within	within	IN
18637	805	12	ten	ten	CD
18637	805	13	Days	day	NNS
18637	805	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	805	15	Sundays	sunday	NNS
18637	805	16	excepted	except	VBN
18637	805	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	805	18	after	after	IN
18637	805	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	805	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	805	21	have	have	VB
18637	805	22	been	be	VBN
18637	805	23	presented	present	VBN
18637	805	24	to	to	IN
18637	805	25	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	805	26	,	,	,
18637	805	27	the	the	DT
18637	805	28	Same	same	JJ
18637	805	29	shall	shall	MD
18637	805	30	be	be	VB
18637	805	31	a	a	DT
18637	805	32	Law	Law	NNP
18637	805	33	,	,	,
18637	805	34	in	in	IN
18637	805	35	like	like	IN
18637	805	36	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	805	37	as	as	IN
18637	805	38	if	if	IN
18637	805	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	805	40	had	have	VBD
18637	805	41	signed	sign	VBN
18637	805	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	805	43	,	,	,
18637	805	44	unless	unless	IN
18637	805	45	the	the	DT
18637	805	46	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	805	47	by	by	IN
18637	805	48	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	805	49	Adjournment	adjournment	NN
18637	805	50	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	805	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	805	52	Return	return	NN
18637	805	53	,	,	,
18637	805	54	in	in	IN
18637	805	55	which	which	WDT
18637	805	56	Case	Case	NNP
18637	805	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	805	58	shall	shall	MD
18637	805	59	not	not	RB
18637	805	60	be	be	VB
18637	805	61	a	a	DT
18637	805	62	Law	law	NN
18637	805	63	.	.	.
18637	806	1	Every	every	DT
18637	806	2	Order	order	NN
18637	806	3	,	,	,
18637	806	4	Resolution	resolution	NN
18637	806	5	,	,	,
18637	806	6	or	or	CC
18637	806	7	Vote	vote	NN
18637	806	8	to	to	TO
18637	806	9	which	which	WDT
18637	806	10	the	the	DT
18637	806	11	Concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	806	12	of	of	IN
18637	806	13	the	the	DT
18637	806	14	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	806	15	and	and	CC
18637	806	16	House	House	NNP
18637	806	17	of	of	IN
18637	806	18	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	806	19	may	may	MD
18637	806	20	be	be	VB
18637	806	21	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	806	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	806	23	except	except	IN
18637	806	24	on	on	IN
18637	806	25	a	a	DT
18637	806	26	question	question	NN
18637	806	27	of	of	IN
18637	806	28	Adjournment	adjournment	NN
18637	806	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	806	30	shall	shall	MD
18637	806	31	be	be	VB
18637	806	32	presented	present	VBN
18637	806	33	to	to	IN
18637	806	34	the	the	DT
18637	806	35	President	President	NNP
18637	806	36	of	of	IN
18637	806	37	the	the	DT
18637	806	38	United	United	NNP
18637	806	39	States	States	NNP
18637	806	40	;	;	:
18637	806	41	and	and	CC
18637	806	42	before	before	IN
18637	806	43	the	the	DT
18637	806	44	Same	same	JJ
18637	806	45	shall	shall	MD
18637	806	46	take	take	VB
18637	806	47	Effect	effect	NN
18637	806	48	,	,	,
18637	806	49	shall	shall	MD
18637	806	50	be	be	VB
18637	806	51	approved	approve	VBN
18637	806	52	by	by	IN
18637	806	53	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	806	54	,	,	,
18637	806	55	or	or	CC
18637	806	56	being	be	VBG
18637	806	57	disapproved	disapprove	VBN
18637	806	58	by	by	IN
18637	806	59	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	806	60	,	,	,
18637	806	61	shall	shall	MD
18637	806	62	be	be	VB
18637	806	63	repassed	repasse	VBN
18637	806	64	by	by	IN
18637	806	65	two	two	CD
18637	806	66	thirds	third	NNS
18637	806	67	of	of	IN
18637	806	68	the	the	DT
18637	806	69	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	806	70	and	and	CC
18637	806	71	House	House	NNP
18637	806	72	of	of	IN
18637	806	73	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	806	74	,	,	,
18637	806	75	according	accord	VBG
18637	806	76	to	to	IN
18637	806	77	the	the	DT
18637	806	78	Rules	Rules	NNPS
18637	806	79	and	and	CC
18637	806	80	Limitations	Limitations	NNPS
18637	806	81	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	806	82	in	in	IN
18637	806	83	the	the	DT
18637	806	84	Case	Case	NNP
18637	806	85	of	of	IN
18637	806	86	a	a	DT
18637	806	87	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	806	88	.	.	.
18637	807	1	Section	section	NN
18637	807	2	.	.	.
18637	808	1	8	8	LS
18637	808	2	.	.	.
18637	809	1	The	the	DT
18637	809	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	809	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	809	4	have	have	VB
18637	809	5	Power	power	NN
18637	809	6	To	to	TO
18637	809	7	lay	lay	VB
18637	809	8	and	and	CC
18637	809	9	collect	collect	VB
18637	809	10	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	809	11	,	,	,
18637	809	12	Duties	Duties	NNPS
18637	809	13	,	,	,
18637	809	14	Imposts	Imposts	NNPS
18637	809	15	and	and	CC
18637	809	16	Excises	Excises	NNPS
18637	809	17	,	,	,
18637	809	18	to	to	TO
18637	809	19	pay	pay	VB
18637	809	20	the	the	DT
18637	809	21	Debts	debt	NNS
18637	809	22	and	and	CC
18637	809	23	provide	provide	VB
18637	809	24	for	for	IN
18637	809	25	the	the	DT
18637	809	26	common	common	JJ
18637	809	27	Defence	Defence	NNP
18637	809	28	and	and	CC
18637	809	29	general	general	JJ
18637	809	30	Welfare	Welfare	NNP
18637	809	31	of	of	IN
18637	809	32	the	the	DT
18637	809	33	United	United	NNP
18637	809	34	States	States	NNP
18637	809	35	;	;	:
18637	809	36	but	but	CC
18637	809	37	all	all	DT
18637	809	38	Duties	Duties	NNPS
18637	809	39	,	,	,
18637	809	40	Imposts	Imposts	NNPS
18637	809	41	and	and	CC
18637	809	42	Excises	excise	NNS
18637	809	43	shall	shall	MD
18637	809	44	be	be	VB
18637	809	45	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	809	46	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	809	47	the	the	DT
18637	809	48	United	United	NNP
18637	809	49	States	States	NNP
18637	809	50	;	;	:
18637	809	51	To	to	TO
18637	809	52	borrow	borrow	VB
18637	809	53	Money	money	NN
18637	809	54	on	on	IN
18637	809	55	the	the	DT
18637	809	56	credit	credit	NN
18637	809	57	of	of	IN
18637	809	58	the	the	DT
18637	809	59	United	United	NNP
18637	809	60	States	States	NNP
18637	809	61	;	;	:
18637	809	62	To	to	TO
18637	809	63	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	809	64	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	809	65	with	with	IN
18637	809	66	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	809	67	Nations	Nations	NNPS
18637	809	68	,	,	,
18637	809	69	and	and	CC
18637	809	70	among	among	IN
18637	809	71	the	the	DT
18637	809	72	several	several	JJ
18637	809	73	States	States	NNPS
18637	809	74	,	,	,
18637	809	75	and	and	CC
18637	809	76	with	with	IN
18637	809	77	the	the	DT
18637	809	78	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	809	79	Tribes	Tribes	NNPS
18637	809	80	;	;	:
18637	809	81	To	to	TO
18637	809	82	establish	establish	VB
18637	809	83	an	an	DT
18637	809	84	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	809	85	Rule	rule	NN
18637	809	86	of	of	IN
18637	809	87	Naturalization	Naturalization	NNP
18637	809	88	,	,	,
18637	809	89	and	and	CC
18637	809	90	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	809	91	Laws	law	NNS
18637	809	92	on	on	IN
18637	809	93	the	the	DT
18637	809	94	subject	subject	NN
18637	809	95	of	of	IN
18637	809	96	Bankruptcies	Bankruptcies	NNPS
18637	809	97	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	809	98	the	the	DT
18637	809	99	United	United	NNP
18637	809	100	States	States	NNP
18637	809	101	;	;	:
18637	809	102	To	to	TO
18637	809	103	coin	coin	VB
18637	809	104	Money	money	NN
18637	809	105	,	,	,
18637	809	106	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	809	107	the	the	DT
18637	809	108	Value	Value	NNP
18637	809	109	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	809	110	,	,	,
18637	809	111	and	and	CC
18637	809	112	of	of	IN
18637	809	113	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	809	114	Coin	Coin	NNP
18637	809	115	,	,	,
18637	809	116	and	and	CC
18637	809	117	fix	fix	VB
18637	809	118	the	the	DT
18637	809	119	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	809	120	of	of	IN
18637	809	121	Weights	Weights	NNPS
18637	809	122	and	and	CC
18637	809	123	Measures	Measures	NNPS
18637	809	124	;	;	:
18637	809	125	To	to	TO
18637	809	126	provide	provide	VB
18637	809	127	for	for	IN
18637	809	128	the	the	DT
18637	809	129	Punishment	punishment	NN
18637	809	130	of	of	IN
18637	809	131	counterfeiting	counterfeit	VBG
18637	809	132	the	the	DT
18637	809	133	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	809	134	and	and	CC
18637	809	135	current	current	JJ
18637	809	136	Coin	coin	NN
18637	809	137	of	of	IN
18637	809	138	the	the	DT
18637	809	139	United	United	NNP
18637	809	140	States	States	NNP
18637	809	141	;	;	:
18637	809	142	To	to	TO
18637	809	143	establish	establish	VB
18637	809	144	Post	Post	NNP
18637	809	145	Offices	office	NNS
18637	809	146	and	and	CC
18637	809	147	post	post	VB
18637	809	148	Roads	road	NNS
18637	809	149	;	;	:
18637	809	150	To	to	TO
18637	809	151	promote	promote	VB
18637	809	152	the	the	DT
18637	809	153	Progress	Progress	NNP
18637	809	154	of	of	IN
18637	809	155	Science	Science	NNP
18637	809	156	and	and	CC
18637	809	157	useful	useful	JJ
18637	809	158	Arts	art	NNS
18637	809	159	,	,	,
18637	809	160	by	by	IN
18637	809	161	securing	secure	VBG
18637	809	162	for	for	IN
18637	809	163	limited	limited	JJ
18637	809	164	Times	Times	NNP
18637	809	165	to	to	IN
18637	809	166	Authors	Authors	NNPS
18637	809	167	and	and	CC
18637	809	168	Inventors	inventor	NNS
18637	809	169	the	the	DT
18637	809	170	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	809	171	Right	right	NN
18637	809	172	to	to	IN
18637	809	173	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	809	174	respective	respective	JJ
18637	809	175	Writings	Writings	NNPS
18637	809	176	and	and	CC
18637	809	177	Discoveries	Discoveries	NNPS
18637	809	178	;	;	:
18637	809	179	To	to	TO
18637	809	180	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	809	181	Tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	809	182	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	809	183	to	to	IN
18637	809	184	the	the	DT
18637	809	185	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	809	186	Court	Court	NNP
18637	809	187	;	;	:
18637	809	188	To	to	TO
18637	809	189	define	define	VB
18637	809	190	and	and	CC
18637	809	191	punish	punish	VB
18637	809	192	Piracies	Piracies	NNPS
18637	809	193	and	and	CC
18637	809	194	Felonies	Felonies	NNPS
18637	809	195	committed	commit	VBD
18637	809	196	on	on	IN
18637	809	197	the	the	DT
18637	809	198	high	high	JJ
18637	809	199	Seas	Seas	NNPS
18637	809	200	,	,	,
18637	809	201	and	and	CC
18637	809	202	Offences	offence	NNS
18637	809	203	against	against	IN
18637	809	204	the	the	DT
18637	809	205	Law	Law	NNP
18637	809	206	of	of	IN
18637	809	207	Nations	Nations	NNPS
18637	809	208	;	;	:
18637	809	209	To	to	TO
18637	809	210	declare	declare	VB
18637	809	211	War	war	NN
18637	809	212	,	,	,
18637	809	213	grant	grant	VB
18637	809	214	Letters	letter	NNS
18637	809	215	of	of	IN
18637	809	216	Marque	Marque	NNP
18637	809	217	and	and	CC
18637	809	218	Reprisal	Reprisal	NNP
18637	809	219	,	,	,
18637	809	220	and	and	CC
18637	809	221	make	make	VB
18637	809	222	Rules	rule	NNS
18637	809	223	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	809	224	Captures	capture	NNS
18637	809	225	on	on	IN
18637	809	226	Land	Land	NNP
18637	809	227	and	and	CC
18637	809	228	Water	Water	NNP
18637	809	229	;	;	:
18637	809	230	To	to	TO
18637	809	231	raise	raise	VB
18637	809	232	and	and	CC
18637	809	233	support	support	VB
18637	809	234	Armies	army	NNS
18637	809	235	,	,	,
18637	809	236	but	but	CC
18637	809	237	no	no	DT
18637	809	238	Appropriation	Appropriation	NNP
18637	809	239	of	of	IN
18637	809	240	Money	Money	NNP
18637	809	241	to	to	IN
18637	809	242	that	that	DT
18637	809	243	Use	Use	NNP
18637	809	244	shall	shall	MD
18637	809	245	be	be	VB
18637	809	246	for	for	IN
18637	809	247	a	a	DT
18637	809	248	longer	long	JJR
18637	809	249	Term	term	NN
18637	809	250	than	than	IN
18637	809	251	two	two	CD
18637	809	252	Years	year	NNS
18637	809	253	;	;	:
18637	809	254	To	to	TO
18637	809	255	provide	provide	VB
18637	809	256	and	and	CC
18637	809	257	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	809	258	a	a	DT
18637	809	259	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	809	260	;	;	:
18637	809	261	To	to	TO
18637	809	262	make	make	VB
18637	809	263	Rules	rule	NNS
18637	809	264	for	for	IN
18637	809	265	the	the	DT
18637	809	266	Government	Government	NNP
18637	809	267	and	and	CC
18637	809	268	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	809	269	of	of	IN
18637	809	270	the	the	DT
18637	809	271	land	land	NN
18637	809	272	and	and	CC
18637	809	273	naval	naval	JJ
18637	809	274	Forces	force	NNS
18637	809	275	;	;	:
18637	809	276	To	to	TO
18637	809	277	provide	provide	VB
18637	809	278	for	for	IN
18637	809	279	calling	call	VBG
18637	809	280	forth	forth	RP
18637	809	281	the	the	DT
18637	809	282	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	809	283	to	to	TO
18637	809	284	execute	execute	VB
18637	809	285	the	the	DT
18637	809	286	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	809	287	of	of	IN
18637	809	288	the	the	DT
18637	809	289	Union	Union	NNP
18637	809	290	,	,	,
18637	809	291	suppress	suppress	NN
18637	809	292	Insurrections	insurrection	NNS
18637	809	293	and	and	CC
18637	809	294	repel	repel	JJ
18637	809	295	Invasions	invasion	NNS
18637	809	296	;	;	:
18637	809	297	To	to	TO
18637	809	298	provide	provide	VB
18637	809	299	for	for	IN
18637	809	300	organizing	organizing	NN
18637	809	301	,	,	,
18637	809	302	arming	arm	VBG
18637	809	303	,	,	,
18637	809	304	and	and	CC
18637	809	305	disciplining	discipline	VBG
18637	809	306	,	,	,
18637	809	307	the	the	DT
18637	809	308	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	809	309	,	,	,
18637	809	310	and	and	CC
18637	809	311	for	for	IN
18637	809	312	governing	govern	VBG
18637	809	313	such	such	JJ
18637	809	314	Part	part	NN
18637	809	315	of	of	IN
18637	809	316	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	809	317	as	as	IN
18637	809	318	may	may	MD
18637	809	319	be	be	VB
18637	809	320	employed	employ	VBN
18637	809	321	in	in	IN
18637	809	322	the	the	DT
18637	809	323	Service	Service	NNP
18637	809	324	of	of	IN
18637	809	325	the	the	DT
18637	809	326	United	United	NNP
18637	809	327	States	States	NNP
18637	809	328	,	,	,
18637	809	329	reserving	reserve	VBG
18637	809	330	to	to	IN
18637	809	331	the	the	DT
18637	809	332	States	States	NNP
18637	809	333	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	809	334	,	,	,
18637	809	335	the	the	DT
18637	809	336	Appointment	Appointment	NNP
18637	809	337	of	of	IN
18637	809	338	the	the	DT
18637	809	339	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	809	340	,	,	,
18637	809	341	and	and	CC
18637	809	342	the	the	DT
18637	809	343	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	809	344	of	of	IN
18637	809	345	training	train	VBG
18637	809	346	the	the	DT
18637	809	347	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	809	348	according	accord	VBG
18637	809	349	to	to	IN
18637	809	350	the	the	DT
18637	809	351	discipline	discipline	NN
18637	809	352	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	809	353	by	by	IN
18637	809	354	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	809	355	;	;	:
18637	809	356	To	to	TO
18637	809	357	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	809	358	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	809	359	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
18637	809	360	in	in	IN
18637	809	361	all	all	DT
18637	809	362	Cases	case	NNS
18637	809	363	whatsoever	whatsoever	RB
18637	809	364	,	,	,
18637	809	365	over	over	IN
18637	809	366	such	such	JJ
18637	809	367	District	District	NNP
18637	809	368	(	(	-LRB-
18637	809	369	not	not	RB
18637	809	370	exceeding	exceed	VBG
18637	809	371	ten	ten	CD
18637	809	372	Miles	Miles	NNP
18637	809	373	square	square	JJ
18637	809	374	)	)	-RRB-
18637	809	375	as	as	IN
18637	809	376	may	may	NNP
18637	809	377	,	,	,
18637	809	378	by	by	IN
18637	809	379	Cession	Cession	NNP
18637	809	380	of	of	IN
18637	809	381	Particular	Particular	NNP
18637	809	382	States	States	NNP
18637	809	383	,	,	,
18637	809	384	and	and	CC
18637	809	385	the	the	DT
18637	809	386	Acceptance	Acceptance	NNP
18637	809	387	of	of	IN
18637	809	388	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	809	389	,	,	,
18637	809	390	become	become	VB
18637	809	391	the	the	DT
18637	809	392	Seat	Seat	NNP
18637	809	393	of	of	IN
18637	809	394	the	the	DT
18637	809	395	Government	Government	NNP
18637	809	396	of	of	IN
18637	809	397	the	the	DT
18637	809	398	United	United	NNP
18637	809	399	States	States	NNP
18637	809	400	,	,	,
18637	809	401	and	and	CC
18637	809	402	to	to	TO
18637	809	403	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	809	404	like	like	IN
18637	809	405	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	809	406	over	over	IN
18637	809	407	all	all	DT
18637	809	408	Places	Places	NNPS
18637	809	409	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	809	410	by	by	IN
18637	809	411	the	the	DT
18637	809	412	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	809	413	of	of	IN
18637	809	414	the	the	DT
18637	809	415	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	809	416	of	of	IN
18637	809	417	the	the	DT
18637	809	418	State	State	NNP
18637	809	419	in	in	IN
18637	809	420	which	which	WDT
18637	809	421	the	the	DT
18637	809	422	Same	same	JJ
18637	809	423	shall	shall	MD
18637	809	424	be	be	VB
18637	809	425	,	,	,
18637	809	426	for	for	IN
18637	809	427	the	the	DT
18637	809	428	Erection	Erection	NNP
18637	809	429	of	of	IN
18637	809	430	Forts	Forts	NNPS
18637	809	431	,	,	,
18637	809	432	Magazines	Magazines	NNPS
18637	809	433	,	,	,
18637	809	434	Arsenals	Arsenals	NNPS
18637	809	435	,	,	,
18637	809	436	dock	dock	NN
18637	809	437	-	-	HYPH
18637	809	438	Yards	Yards	NNPS
18637	809	439	,	,	,
18637	809	440	and	and	CC
18637	809	441	other	other	JJ
18637	809	442	needful	needful	JJ
18637	809	443	Buildings;--And	Buildings;--And	NNS
18637	809	444	To	to	TO
18637	809	445	make	make	VB
18637	809	446	all	all	DT
18637	809	447	Laws	law	NNS
18637	809	448	which	which	WDT
18637	809	449	shall	shall	MD
18637	809	450	be	be	VB
18637	809	451	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	809	452	and	and	CC
18637	809	453	proper	proper	JJ
18637	809	454	for	for	IN
18637	809	455	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	809	456	into	into	IN
18637	809	457	Execution	execution	NN
18637	809	458	the	the	DT
18637	809	459	foregoing	forego	VBG
18637	809	460	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	809	461	,	,	,
18637	809	462	and	and	CC
18637	809	463	all	all	DT
18637	809	464	other	other	JJ
18637	809	465	Powers	power	NNS
18637	809	466	vested	vest	VBN
18637	809	467	by	by	IN
18637	809	468	this	this	DT
18637	809	469	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	809	470	in	in	IN
18637	809	471	the	the	DT
18637	809	472	Government	Government	NNP
18637	809	473	of	of	IN
18637	809	474	the	the	DT
18637	809	475	United	United	NNP
18637	809	476	States	States	NNP
18637	809	477	,	,	,
18637	809	478	or	or	CC
18637	809	479	in	in	IN
18637	809	480	any	any	DT
18637	809	481	Department	Department	NNP
18637	809	482	or	or	CC
18637	809	483	Officer	Officer	NNP
18637	809	484	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	809	485	.	.	.
18637	810	1	Section	section	NN
18637	810	2	.	.	.
18637	811	1	9	9	CD
18637	811	2	.	.	.
18637	812	1	The	the	DT
18637	812	2	Migration	Migration	NNP
18637	812	3	or	or	CC
18637	812	4	Importation	Importation	NNP
18637	812	5	of	of	IN
18637	812	6	such	such	JJ
18637	812	7	Persons	Persons	NNP
18637	812	8	as	as	IN
18637	812	9	any	any	DT
18637	812	10	of	of	IN
18637	812	11	the	the	DT
18637	812	12	States	States	NNP
18637	812	13	now	now	RB
18637	812	14	existing	exist	VBG
18637	812	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	812	16	think	think	VB
18637	812	17	proper	proper	JJ
18637	812	18	to	to	TO
18637	812	19	admit	admit	VB
18637	812	20	,	,	,
18637	812	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	812	22	not	not	RB
18637	812	23	be	be	VB
18637	812	24	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	812	25	by	by	IN
18637	812	26	the	the	DT
18637	812	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	812	28	prior	prior	RB
18637	812	29	to	to	IN
18637	812	30	the	the	DT
18637	812	31	Year	Year	NNP
18637	812	32	one	one	CD
18637	812	33	thousand	thousand	CD
18637	812	34	eight	eight	CD
18637	812	35	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	812	36	and	and	CC
18637	812	37	eight	eight	CD
18637	812	38	,	,	,
18637	812	39	but	but	CC
18637	812	40	a	a	DT
18637	812	41	Tax	tax	NN
18637	812	42	or	or	CC
18637	812	43	duty	duty	NN
18637	812	44	may	may	MD
18637	812	45	be	be	VB
18637	812	46	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	812	47	on	on	IN
18637	812	48	such	such	JJ
18637	812	49	Importation	Importation	NNP
18637	812	50	,	,	,
18637	812	51	not	not	RB
18637	812	52	exceeding	exceed	VBG
18637	812	53	ten	ten	CD
18637	812	54	dollars	dollar	NNS
18637	812	55	for	for	IN
18637	812	56	each	each	DT
18637	812	57	Person	person	NN
18637	812	58	.	.	.
18637	813	1	The	the	DT
18637	813	2	Privilege	Privilege	NNP
18637	813	3	of	of	IN
18637	813	4	the	the	DT
18637	813	5	Writ	Writ	NNP
18637	813	6	of	of	IN
18637	813	7	Habeas	Habeas	NNP
18637	813	8	Corpus	Corpus	NNP
18637	813	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	813	10	not	not	RB
18637	813	11	be	be	VB
18637	813	12	suspended	suspend	VBN
18637	813	13	,	,	,
18637	813	14	unless	unless	IN
18637	813	15	when	when	WRB
18637	813	16	in	in	IN
18637	813	17	Cases	case	NNS
18637	813	18	of	of	IN
18637	813	19	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
18637	813	20	or	or	CC
18637	813	21	Invasion	Invasion	NNP
18637	813	22	the	the	DT
18637	813	23	public	public	JJ
18637	813	24	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	813	25	may	may	MD
18637	813	26	require	require	VB
18637	813	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	813	28	.	.	.
18637	814	1	No	no	DT
18637	814	2	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	814	3	of	of	IN
18637	814	4	Attainder	Attainder	NNP
18637	814	5	or	or	CC
18637	814	6	ex	ex	FW
18637	814	7	post	post	FW
18637	814	8	facto	facto	FW
18637	814	9	Law	Law	NNP
18637	814	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	814	11	be	be	VB
18637	814	12	passed	pass	VBN
18637	814	13	.	.	.
18637	815	1	No	no	DT
18637	815	2	Capitation	Capitation	NNP
18637	815	3	,	,	,
18637	815	4	or	or	CC
18637	815	5	other	other	JJ
18637	815	6	direct	direct	JJ
18637	815	7	,	,	,
18637	815	8	Tax	tax	NN
18637	815	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	815	10	be	be	VB
18637	815	11	laid	lay	VBN
18637	815	12	,	,	,
18637	815	13	unless	unless	IN
18637	815	14	in	in	IN
18637	815	15	Proportion	proportion	NN
18637	815	16	to	to	IN
18637	815	17	the	the	DT
18637	815	18	Census	Census	NNP
18637	815	19	or	or	CC
18637	815	20	Enumeration	Enumeration	NNP
18637	815	21	herein	herein	NNP
18637	815	22	before	before	IN
18637	815	23	directed	direct	VBN
18637	815	24	to	to	TO
18637	815	25	be	be	VB
18637	815	26	taken	take	VBN
18637	815	27	.	.	.
18637	816	1	No	no	DT
18637	816	2	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	816	3	or	or	CC
18637	816	4	Duty	Duty	NNP
18637	816	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	816	6	be	be	VB
18637	816	7	laid	lay	VBN
18637	816	8	on	on	IN
18637	816	9	Articles	article	NNS
18637	816	10	exported	export	VBN
18637	816	11	from	from	IN
18637	816	12	any	any	DT
18637	816	13	State	State	NNP
18637	816	14	.	.	.
18637	817	1	No	no	DT
18637	817	2	Preference	Preference	NNP
18637	817	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	817	4	be	be	VB
18637	817	5	given	give	VBN
18637	817	6	by	by	IN
18637	817	7	any	any	DT
18637	817	8	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	817	9	of	of	IN
18637	817	10	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	817	11	or	or	CC
18637	817	12	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	817	13	to	to	IN
18637	817	14	the	the	DT
18637	817	15	Ports	Ports	NNPS
18637	817	16	of	of	IN
18637	817	17	one	one	CD
18637	817	18	State	state	NN
18637	817	19	over	over	IN
18637	817	20	those	those	DT
18637	817	21	of	of	IN
18637	817	22	another	another	DT
18637	817	23	;	;	:
18637	817	24	nor	nor	CC
18637	817	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	817	26	Vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	817	27	bound	bind	VBN
18637	817	28	to	to	IN
18637	817	29	,	,	,
18637	817	30	or	or	CC
18637	817	31	from	from	IN
18637	817	32	,	,	,
18637	817	33	one	one	CD
18637	817	34	State	state	NN
18637	817	35	,	,	,
18637	817	36	be	be	VB
18637	817	37	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	817	38	to	to	TO
18637	817	39	enter	enter	VB
18637	817	40	,	,	,
18637	817	41	clear	clear	JJ
18637	817	42	or	or	CC
18637	817	43	pay	pay	VB
18637	817	44	Duties	duty	NNS
18637	817	45	in	in	IN
18637	817	46	another	another	DT
18637	817	47	.	.	.
18637	818	1	No	no	DT
18637	818	2	Money	money	NN
18637	818	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	818	4	be	be	VB
18637	818	5	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	818	6	from	from	IN
18637	818	7	the	the	DT
18637	818	8	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	818	9	,	,	,
18637	818	10	but	but	CC
18637	818	11	in	in	IN
18637	818	12	Consequence	Consequence	NNP
18637	818	13	of	of	IN
18637	818	14	Appropriations	Appropriations	NNPS
18637	818	15	made	make	VBN
18637	818	16	by	by	IN
18637	818	17	Law	Law	NNP
18637	818	18	;	;	:
18637	818	19	and	and	CC
18637	818	20	a	a	DT
18637	818	21	regular	regular	JJ
18637	818	22	Statement	Statement	NNP
18637	818	23	and	and	CC
18637	818	24	Account	Account	NNP
18637	818	25	of	of	IN
18637	818	26	the	the	DT
18637	818	27	Receipts	Receipts	NNPS
18637	818	28	and	and	CC
18637	818	29	Expenditures	Expenditures	NNPS
18637	818	30	of	of	IN
18637	818	31	all	all	DT
18637	818	32	public	public	JJ
18637	818	33	Money	money	NN
18637	818	34	shall	shall	MD
18637	818	35	be	be	VB
18637	818	36	published	publish	VBN
18637	818	37	from	from	IN
18637	818	38	time	time	NN
18637	818	39	to	to	IN
18637	818	40	time	time	NN
18637	818	41	.	.	.
18637	819	1	No	no	DT
18637	819	2	Title	title	NN
18637	819	3	of	of	IN
18637	819	4	Nobility	Nobility	NNP
18637	819	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	819	6	be	be	VB
18637	819	7	granted	grant	VBN
18637	819	8	by	by	IN
18637	819	9	the	the	DT
18637	819	10	United	United	NNP
18637	819	11	States	States	NNP
18637	819	12	:	:	:
18637	819	13	And	and	CC
18637	819	14	no	no	DT
18637	819	15	Person	person	NN
18637	819	16	holding	hold	VBG
18637	819	17	any	any	DT
18637	819	18	Office	Office	NNP
18637	819	19	of	of	IN
18637	819	20	Profit	Profit	NNP
18637	819	21	or	or	CC
18637	819	22	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	819	23	under	under	IN
18637	819	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	819	25	,	,	,
18637	819	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	819	27	,	,	,
18637	819	28	without	without	IN
18637	819	29	the	the	DT
18637	819	30	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	819	31	of	of	IN
18637	819	32	the	the	DT
18637	819	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	819	34	,	,	,
18637	819	35	accept	accept	VB
18637	819	36	of	of	IN
18637	819	37	any	any	DT
18637	819	38	present	present	NN
18637	819	39	,	,	,
18637	819	40	Emolument	Emolument	NNP
18637	819	41	,	,	,
18637	819	42	Office	Office	NNP
18637	819	43	,	,	,
18637	819	44	or	or	CC
18637	819	45	Title	Title	NNP
18637	819	46	,	,	,
18637	819	47	of	of	IN
18637	819	48	any	any	DT
18637	819	49	kind	kind	NN
18637	819	50	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	819	51	,	,	,
18637	819	52	from	from	IN
18637	819	53	any	any	DT
18637	819	54	King	King	NNP
18637	819	55	,	,	,
18637	819	56	Prince	Prince	NNP
18637	819	57	,	,	,
18637	819	58	or	or	CC
18637	819	59	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	819	60	State	state	NN
18637	819	61	.	.	.
18637	820	1	Section	section	NN
18637	820	2	.	.	.
18637	821	1	10	10	CD
18637	821	2	.	.	.
18637	822	1	No	no	DT
18637	822	2	State	state	NN
18637	822	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	822	4	enter	enter	VB
18637	822	5	into	into	IN
18637	822	6	any	any	DT
18637	822	7	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	822	8	,	,	,
18637	822	9	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	822	10	,	,	,
18637	822	11	or	or	CC
18637	822	12	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	822	13	;	;	:
18637	822	14	grant	grant	VBP
18637	822	15	Letters	letter	NNS
18637	822	16	of	of	IN
18637	822	17	Marque	Marque	NNP
18637	822	18	and	and	CC
18637	822	19	Reprisal	Reprisal	NNP
18637	822	20	;	;	,
18637	822	21	coin	coin	NN
18637	822	22	Money	money	NN
18637	822	23	;	;	:
18637	822	24	emit	emit	NN
18637	822	25	Bills	Bills	NNPS
18637	822	26	of	of	IN
18637	822	27	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	822	28	;	;	:
18637	822	29	make	make	VB
18637	822	30	any	any	DT
18637	822	31	Thing	thing	NN
18637	822	32	but	but	CC
18637	822	33	gold	gold	NN
18637	822	34	and	and	CC
18637	822	35	silver	silver	NN
18637	822	36	Coin	Coin	NNP
18637	822	37	a	a	DT
18637	822	38	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	822	39	in	in	IN
18637	822	40	Payment	Payment	NNP
18637	822	41	of	of	IN
18637	822	42	Debts	Debts	NNP
18637	822	43	;	;	:
18637	822	44	pass	pass	VB
18637	822	45	any	any	DT
18637	822	46	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	822	47	of	of	IN
18637	822	48	Attainder	Attainder	NNP
18637	822	49	,	,	,
18637	822	50	ex	ex	FW
18637	822	51	post	post	FW
18637	822	52	facto	facto	FW
18637	822	53	Law	Law	NNP
18637	822	54	,	,	,
18637	822	55	or	or	CC
18637	822	56	Law	Law	NNP
18637	822	57	impairing	impair	VBG
18637	822	58	the	the	DT
18637	822	59	Obligation	Obligation	NNP
18637	822	60	of	of	IN
18637	822	61	Contracts	Contracts	NNPS
18637	822	62	,	,	,
18637	822	63	or	or	CC
18637	822	64	grant	grant	VB
18637	822	65	any	any	DT
18637	822	66	Title	title	NN
18637	822	67	of	of	IN
18637	822	68	Nobility	Nobility	NNP
18637	822	69	.	.	.
18637	823	1	No	no	DT
18637	823	2	State	state	NN
18637	823	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	823	4	,	,	,
18637	823	5	without	without	IN
18637	823	6	the	the	DT
18637	823	7	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	823	8	of	of	IN
18637	823	9	the	the	DT
18637	823	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	823	11	,	,	,
18637	823	12	lay	lie	VBD
18637	823	13	any	any	DT
18637	823	14	Imposts	Imposts	NNPS
18637	823	15	or	or	CC
18637	823	16	Duties	duty	NNS
18637	823	17	on	on	IN
18637	823	18	Imports	Imports	NNPS
18637	823	19	or	or	CC
18637	823	20	Exports	Exports	NNPS
18637	823	21	,	,	,
18637	823	22	except	except	IN
18637	823	23	what	what	WP
18637	823	24	may	may	MD
18637	823	25	be	be	VB
18637	823	26	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	823	27	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	823	28	for	for	IN
18637	823	29	executing	execute	VBG
18637	823	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	823	31	's	be	VBZ
18637	823	32	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	823	33	Laws	law	NNS
18637	823	34	:	:	:
18637	823	35	and	and	CC
18637	823	36	the	the	DT
18637	823	37	net	net	JJ
18637	823	38	Produce	Produce	NNP
18637	823	39	of	of	IN
18637	823	40	all	all	DT
18637	823	41	Duties	Duties	NNPS
18637	823	42	and	and	CC
18637	823	43	Imposts	Imposts	NNPS
18637	823	44	,	,	,
18637	823	45	laid	lay	VBN
18637	823	46	by	by	IN
18637	823	47	any	any	DT
18637	823	48	State	State	NNP
18637	823	49	on	on	IN
18637	823	50	Imports	Imports	NNPS
18637	823	51	or	or	CC
18637	823	52	Exports	Exports	NNPS
18637	823	53	,	,	,
18637	823	54	shall	shall	MD
18637	823	55	be	be	VB
18637	823	56	for	for	IN
18637	823	57	the	the	DT
18637	823	58	Use	Use	NNP
18637	823	59	of	of	IN
18637	823	60	the	the	DT
18637	823	61	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	823	62	of	of	IN
18637	823	63	the	the	DT
18637	823	64	United	United	NNP
18637	823	65	States	States	NNP
18637	823	66	;	;	:
18637	823	67	and	and	CC
18637	823	68	all	all	DT
18637	823	69	such	such	JJ
18637	823	70	Laws	law	NNS
18637	823	71	shall	shall	MD
18637	823	72	be	be	VB
18637	823	73	subject	subject	JJ
18637	823	74	to	to	IN
18637	823	75	the	the	DT
18637	823	76	Revision	Revision	NNP
18637	823	77	and	and	CC
18637	823	78	Controul	Controul	NNP
18637	823	79	of	of	IN
18637	823	80	the	the	DT
18637	823	81	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	823	82	.	.	.
18637	824	1	No	no	DT
18637	824	2	State	state	NN
18637	824	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	824	4	,	,	,
18637	824	5	without	without	IN
18637	824	6	the	the	DT
18637	824	7	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	824	8	of	of	IN
18637	824	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	824	10	,	,	,
18637	824	11	lay	lie	VBD
18637	824	12	any	any	DT
18637	824	13	Duty	Duty	NNP
18637	824	14	of	of	IN
18637	824	15	Tonnage	Tonnage	NNP
18637	824	16	,	,	,
18637	824	17	keep	keep	VB
18637	824	18	Troops	troop	NNS
18637	824	19	,	,	,
18637	824	20	or	or	CC
18637	824	21	Ships	Ships	NNPS
18637	824	22	of	of	IN
18637	824	23	War	War	NNP
18637	824	24	in	in	IN
18637	824	25	time	time	NN
18637	824	26	of	of	IN
18637	824	27	Peace	Peace	NNP
18637	824	28	,	,	,
18637	824	29	enter	enter	VB
18637	824	30	into	into	IN
18637	824	31	any	any	DT
18637	824	32	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	824	33	or	or	CC
18637	824	34	Compact	Compact	NNP
18637	824	35	with	with	IN
18637	824	36	another	another	DT
18637	824	37	State	state	NN
18637	824	38	,	,	,
18637	824	39	or	or	CC
18637	824	40	with	with	IN
18637	824	41	a	a	DT
18637	824	42	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	824	43	Power	power	NN
18637	824	44	,	,	,
18637	824	45	or	or	CC
18637	824	46	engage	engage	VB
18637	824	47	in	in	IN
18637	824	48	War	War	NNP
18637	824	49	,	,	,
18637	824	50	unless	unless	IN
18637	824	51	actually	actually	RB
18637	824	52	invaded	invade	VBN
18637	824	53	,	,	,
18637	824	54	or	or	CC
18637	824	55	in	in	IN
18637	824	56	such	such	JJ
18637	824	57	imminent	imminent	JJ
18637	824	58	Danger	Danger	NNP
18637	824	59	as	as	IN
18637	824	60	will	will	MD
18637	824	61	not	not	RB
18637	824	62	admit	admit	VB
18637	824	63	of	of	IN
18637	824	64	delay	delay	NN
18637	824	65	.	.	.
18637	825	1	Article	article	NN
18637	825	2	.	.	.
18637	826	1	II	ii	CD
18637	826	2	.	.	.
18637	827	1	Section	section	NN
18637	827	2	.	.	.
18637	828	1	1	1	LS
18637	828	2	.	.	.
18637	829	1	The	the	DT
18637	829	2	executive	executive	JJ
18637	829	3	Power	power	NN
18637	829	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	829	5	be	be	VB
18637	829	6	vested	vest	VBN
18637	829	7	in	in	IN
18637	829	8	a	a	DT
18637	829	9	President	President	NNP
18637	829	10	of	of	IN
18637	829	11	the	the	DT
18637	829	12	United	United	NNP
18637	829	13	States	States	NNP
18637	829	14	of	of	IN
18637	829	15	America	America	NNP
18637	829	16	.	.	.
18637	830	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	830	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	830	3	hold	hold	VB
18637	830	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	830	5	Office	Office	NNP
18637	830	6	during	during	IN
18637	830	7	the	the	DT
18637	830	8	Term	Term	NNP
18637	830	9	of	of	IN
18637	830	10	four	four	CD
18637	830	11	Years	Years	NNPS
18637	830	12	,	,	,
18637	830	13	and	and	CC
18637	830	14	,	,	,
18637	830	15	together	together	RB
18637	830	16	with	with	IN
18637	830	17	the	the	DT
18637	830	18	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	830	19	President	President	NNP
18637	830	20	,	,	,
18637	830	21	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	830	22	for	for	IN
18637	830	23	the	the	DT
18637	830	24	same	same	JJ
18637	830	25	Term	Term	NNP
18637	830	26	,	,	,
18637	830	27	be	be	VB
18637	830	28	elected	elect	VBN
18637	830	29	,	,	,
18637	830	30	as	as	IN
18637	830	31	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	830	32	Each	each	DT
18637	830	33	State	state	NN
18637	830	34	shall	shall	MD
18637	830	35	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	830	36	,	,	,
18637	830	37	in	in	IN
18637	830	38	such	such	JJ
18637	830	39	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	830	40	as	as	IN
18637	830	41	the	the	DT
18637	830	42	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	830	43	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	830	44	may	may	MD
18637	830	45	direct	direct	VB
18637	830	46	,	,	,
18637	830	47	a	a	DT
18637	830	48	Number	Number	NNP
18637	830	49	of	of	IN
18637	830	50	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	830	51	,	,	,
18637	830	52	equal	equal	JJ
18637	830	53	to	to	IN
18637	830	54	the	the	DT
18637	830	55	whole	whole	JJ
18637	830	56	Number	Number	NNP
18637	830	57	of	of	IN
18637	830	58	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	830	59	and	and	CC
18637	830	60	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	830	61	to	to	TO
18637	830	62	which	which	WDT
18637	830	63	the	the	DT
18637	830	64	State	state	NN
18637	830	65	may	may	MD
18637	830	66	be	be	VB
18637	830	67	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	830	68	in	in	IN
18637	830	69	the	the	DT
18637	830	70	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	830	71	:	:	:
18637	830	72	but	but	CC
18637	830	73	no	no	DT
18637	830	74	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	830	75	or	or	CC
18637	830	76	Representative	Representative	NNP
18637	830	77	,	,	,
18637	830	78	or	or	CC
18637	830	79	Person	person	NN
18637	830	80	holding	hold	VBG
18637	830	81	an	an	DT
18637	830	82	Office	Office	NNP
18637	830	83	of	of	IN
18637	830	84	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	830	85	or	or	CC
18637	830	86	Profit	Profit	NNP
18637	830	87	under	under	IN
18637	830	88	the	the	DT
18637	830	89	United	United	NNP
18637	830	90	States	States	NNP
18637	830	91	,	,	,
18637	830	92	shall	shall	MD
18637	830	93	be	be	VB
18637	830	94	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	830	95	an	an	DT
18637	830	96	Elector	Elector	NNP
18637	830	97	.	.	.
18637	831	1	The	the	DT
18637	831	2	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	831	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	831	4	meet	meet	VB
18637	831	5	in	in	IN
18637	831	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	831	7	respective	respective	JJ
18637	831	8	States	state	NNS
18637	831	9	,	,	,
18637	831	10	and	and	CC
18637	831	11	vote	vote	NN
18637	831	12	by	by	IN
18637	831	13	Ballot	Ballot	NNP
18637	831	14	for	for	IN
18637	831	15	two	two	CD
18637	831	16	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	831	17	,	,	,
18637	831	18	of	of	IN
18637	831	19	whom	whom	WP
18637	831	20	one	one	CD
18637	831	21	at	at	RB
18637	831	22	least	least	JJS
18637	831	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	831	24	not	not	RB
18637	831	25	be	be	VB
18637	831	26	an	an	DT
18637	831	27	Inhabitant	Inhabitant	NNP
18637	831	28	of	of	IN
18637	831	29	the	the	DT
18637	831	30	same	same	JJ
18637	831	31	State	state	NN
18637	831	32	with	with	IN
18637	831	33	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	831	34	.	.	.
18637	832	1	And	and	CC
18637	832	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	832	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	832	4	make	make	VB
18637	832	5	a	a	DT
18637	832	6	List	list	NN
18637	832	7	of	of	IN
18637	832	8	all	all	PDT
18637	832	9	the	the	DT
18637	832	10	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	832	11	voted	vote	VBD
18637	832	12	for	for	IN
18637	832	13	,	,	,
18637	832	14	and	and	CC
18637	832	15	of	of	IN
18637	832	16	the	the	DT
18637	832	17	Number	Number	NNP
18637	832	18	of	of	IN
18637	832	19	Votes	vote	NNS
18637	832	20	for	for	IN
18637	832	21	each	each	DT
18637	832	22	;	;	:
18637	832	23	which	which	WDT
18637	832	24	List	list	VBP
18637	832	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	832	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	832	27	sign	sign	VB
18637	832	28	and	and	CC
18637	832	29	certify	certify	VB
18637	832	30	,	,	,
18637	832	31	and	and	CC
18637	832	32	transmit	transmit	VB
18637	832	33	sealed	seal	VBN
18637	832	34	to	to	IN
18637	832	35	the	the	DT
18637	832	36	Seat	Seat	NNP
18637	832	37	of	of	IN
18637	832	38	the	the	DT
18637	832	39	Government	Government	NNP
18637	832	40	of	of	IN
18637	832	41	the	the	DT
18637	832	42	United	United	NNP
18637	832	43	States	States	NNP
18637	832	44	,	,	,
18637	832	45	directed	direct	VBN
18637	832	46	to	to	IN
18637	832	47	the	the	DT
18637	832	48	President	President	NNP
18637	832	49	of	of	IN
18637	832	50	the	the	DT
18637	832	51	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	832	52	.	.	.
18637	833	1	The	the	DT
18637	833	2	President	President	NNP
18637	833	3	of	of	IN
18637	833	4	the	the	DT
18637	833	5	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	833	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	833	7	,	,	,
18637	833	8	in	in	IN
18637	833	9	the	the	DT
18637	833	10	Presence	Presence	NNP
18637	833	11	of	of	IN
18637	833	12	the	the	DT
18637	833	13	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	833	14	and	and	CC
18637	833	15	House	House	NNP
18637	833	16	of	of	IN
18637	833	17	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	833	18	,	,	,
18637	833	19	open	open	VB
18637	833	20	all	all	PDT
18637	833	21	the	the	DT
18637	833	22	Certificates	Certificates	NNPS
18637	833	23	,	,	,
18637	833	24	and	and	CC
18637	833	25	the	the	DT
18637	833	26	Votes	Votes	NNPS
18637	833	27	shall	shall	MD
18637	833	28	then	then	RB
18637	833	29	be	be	VB
18637	833	30	counted	count	VBN
18637	833	31	.	.	.
18637	834	1	The	the	DT
18637	834	2	Person	person	NN
18637	834	3	having	have	VBG
18637	834	4	the	the	DT
18637	834	5	greatest	great	JJS
18637	834	6	Number	Number	NNP
18637	834	7	of	of	IN
18637	834	8	Votes	vote	NNS
18637	834	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	834	10	be	be	VB
18637	834	11	the	the	DT
18637	834	12	President	President	NNP
18637	834	13	,	,	,
18637	834	14	if	if	IN
18637	834	15	such	such	JJ
18637	834	16	Number	Number	NNP
18637	834	17	be	be	VBP
18637	834	18	a	a	DT
18637	834	19	Majority	majority	NN
18637	834	20	of	of	IN
18637	834	21	the	the	DT
18637	834	22	whole	whole	JJ
18637	834	23	Number	Number	NNP
18637	834	24	of	of	IN
18637	834	25	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	834	26	appointed	appoint	VBD
18637	834	27	;	;	:
18637	834	28	and	and	CC
18637	834	29	if	if	IN
18637	834	30	there	there	EX
18637	834	31	be	be	VB
18637	834	32	more	more	JJR
18637	834	33	than	than	IN
18637	834	34	one	one	CD
18637	834	35	who	who	WP
18637	834	36	have	have	VBP
18637	834	37	such	such	JJ
18637	834	38	Majority	Majority	NNP
18637	834	39	,	,	,
18637	834	40	and	and	CC
18637	834	41	have	have	VBP
18637	834	42	an	an	DT
18637	834	43	equal	equal	JJ
18637	834	44	Number	number	NN
18637	834	45	of	of	IN
18637	834	46	Votes	vote	NNS
18637	834	47	,	,	,
18637	834	48	then	then	RB
18637	834	49	the	the	DT
18637	834	50	House	House	NNP
18637	834	51	of	of	IN
18637	834	52	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	834	53	shall	shall	MD
18637	834	54	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	834	55	chuse	chuse	VB
18637	834	56	by	by	IN
18637	834	57	Ballot	Ballot	NNP
18637	834	58	one	one	CD
18637	834	59	of	of	IN
18637	834	60	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	834	61	for	for	IN
18637	834	62	President	President	NNP
18637	834	63	;	;	:
18637	834	64	and	and	CC
18637	834	65	if	if	IN
18637	834	66	no	no	DT
18637	834	67	Person	person	NN
18637	834	68	have	have	VBP
18637	834	69	a	a	DT
18637	834	70	Majority	majority	NN
18637	834	71	,	,	,
18637	834	72	then	then	RB
18637	834	73	from	from	IN
18637	834	74	the	the	DT
18637	834	75	five	five	CD
18637	834	76	highest	high	JJS
18637	834	77	on	on	IN
18637	834	78	the	the	DT
18637	834	79	List	list	NN
18637	834	80	the	the	DT
18637	834	81	said	say	VBD
18637	834	82	House	House	NNP
18637	834	83	shall	shall	MD
18637	834	84	in	in	IN
18637	834	85	like	like	IN
18637	834	86	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	834	87	chuse	chuse	NN
18637	834	88	the	the	DT
18637	834	89	President	President	NNP
18637	834	90	.	.	.
18637	835	1	But	but	CC
18637	835	2	in	in	IN
18637	835	3	chusing	chuse	VBG
18637	835	4	the	the	DT
18637	835	5	President	President	NNP
18637	835	6	,	,	,
18637	835	7	the	the	DT
18637	835	8	Votes	Votes	NNPS
18637	835	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	835	10	be	be	VB
18637	835	11	taken	take	VBN
18637	835	12	by	by	IN
18637	835	13	States	States	NNP
18637	835	14	,	,	,
18637	835	15	the	the	DT
18637	835	16	Representation	representation	NN
18637	835	17	from	from	IN
18637	835	18	each	each	DT
18637	835	19	State	state	NN
18637	835	20	having	have	VBG
18637	835	21	one	one	CD
18637	835	22	Vote	vote	NN
18637	835	23	;	;	:
18637	835	24	a	a	DT
18637	835	25	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	835	26	for	for	IN
18637	835	27	this	this	DT
18637	835	28	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	835	29	shall	shall	MD
18637	835	30	consist	consist	VB
18637	835	31	of	of	IN
18637	835	32	a	a	DT
18637	835	33	Member	Member	NNP
18637	835	34	or	or	CC
18637	835	35	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	835	36	from	from	IN
18637	835	37	two	two	CD
18637	835	38	thirds	third	NNS
18637	835	39	of	of	IN
18637	835	40	the	the	DT
18637	835	41	States	States	NNPS
18637	835	42	,	,	,
18637	835	43	and	and	CC
18637	835	44	a	a	DT
18637	835	45	Majority	majority	NN
18637	835	46	of	of	IN
18637	835	47	all	all	PDT
18637	835	48	the	the	DT
18637	835	49	States	state	NNS
18637	835	50	shall	shall	MD
18637	835	51	be	be	VB
18637	835	52	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	835	53	to	to	IN
18637	835	54	a	a	DT
18637	835	55	Choice	Choice	NNP
18637	835	56	.	.	.
18637	836	1	In	in	IN
18637	836	2	every	every	DT
18637	836	3	Case	Case	NNP
18637	836	4	,	,	,
18637	836	5	after	after	IN
18637	836	6	the	the	DT
18637	836	7	Choice	Choice	NNP
18637	836	8	of	of	IN
18637	836	9	the	the	DT
18637	836	10	President	President	NNP
18637	836	11	,	,	,
18637	836	12	the	the	DT
18637	836	13	Person	person	NN
18637	836	14	having	have	VBG
18637	836	15	the	the	DT
18637	836	16	greatest	great	JJS
18637	836	17	Number	Number	NNP
18637	836	18	of	of	IN
18637	836	19	Votes	vote	NNS
18637	836	20	of	of	IN
18637	836	21	the	the	DT
18637	836	22	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	836	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	836	24	be	be	VB
18637	836	25	the	the	DT
18637	836	26	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	836	27	President	President	NNP
18637	836	28	.	.	.
18637	837	1	But	but	CC
18637	837	2	if	if	IN
18637	837	3	there	there	EX
18637	837	4	should	should	MD
18637	837	5	remain	remain	VB
18637	837	6	two	two	CD
18637	837	7	or	or	CC
18637	837	8	more	more	JJR
18637	837	9	who	who	WP
18637	837	10	have	have	VBP
18637	837	11	equal	equal	JJ
18637	837	12	Votes	vote	NNS
18637	837	13	,	,	,
18637	837	14	the	the	DT
18637	837	15	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	837	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	837	17	chuse	chuse	VB
18637	837	18	from	from	IN
18637	837	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	837	20	by	by	IN
18637	837	21	Ballot	Ballot	NNP
18637	837	22	the	the	DT
18637	837	23	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	837	24	President	President	NNP
18637	837	25	.	.	.
18637	838	1	The	the	DT
18637	838	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	838	3	may	may	MD
18637	838	4	determine	determine	VB
18637	838	5	the	the	DT
18637	838	6	Time	time	NN
18637	838	7	of	of	IN
18637	838	8	chusing	chuse	VBG
18637	838	9	the	the	DT
18637	838	10	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	838	11	,	,	,
18637	838	12	and	and	CC
18637	838	13	the	the	DT
18637	838	14	Day	day	NN
18637	838	15	on	on	IN
18637	838	16	which	which	WDT
18637	838	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	838	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	838	19	give	give	VB
18637	838	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	838	21	Votes	vote	NNS
18637	838	22	;	;	:
18637	838	23	which	which	WDT
18637	838	24	Day	day	NN
18637	838	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	838	26	be	be	VB
18637	838	27	the	the	DT
18637	838	28	same	same	JJ
18637	838	29	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	838	30	the	the	DT
18637	838	31	United	United	NNP
18637	838	32	States	States	NNP
18637	838	33	.	.	.
18637	839	1	No	no	DT
18637	839	2	Person	person	NN
18637	839	3	except	except	IN
18637	839	4	a	a	DT
18637	839	5	natural	natural	JJ
18637	839	6	born	bear	VBN
18637	839	7	Citizen	Citizen	NNP
18637	839	8	,	,	,
18637	839	9	or	or	CC
18637	839	10	a	a	DT
18637	839	11	Citizen	Citizen	NNP
18637	839	12	of	of	IN
18637	839	13	the	the	DT
18637	839	14	United	United	NNP
18637	839	15	States	States	NNP
18637	839	16	,	,	,
18637	839	17	at	at	IN
18637	839	18	the	the	DT
18637	839	19	time	time	NN
18637	839	20	of	of	IN
18637	839	21	the	the	DT
18637	839	22	Adoption	Adoption	NNP
18637	839	23	of	of	IN
18637	839	24	this	this	DT
18637	839	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	839	26	,	,	,
18637	839	27	shall	shall	MD
18637	839	28	be	be	VB
18637	839	29	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	839	30	to	to	IN
18637	839	31	the	the	DT
18637	839	32	Office	Office	NNP
18637	839	33	of	of	IN
18637	839	34	President	President	NNP
18637	839	35	;	;	:
18637	839	36	neither	neither	DT
18637	839	37	shall	shall	MD
18637	839	38	any	any	DT
18637	839	39	person	person	NN
18637	839	40	be	be	VB
18637	839	41	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	839	42	to	to	IN
18637	839	43	that	that	DT
18637	839	44	Office	office	NN
18637	839	45	who	who	WP
18637	839	46	shall	shall	MD
18637	839	47	not	not	RB
18637	839	48	have	have	VB
18637	839	49	attained	attain	VBN
18637	839	50	to	to	IN
18637	839	51	the	the	DT
18637	839	52	Age	Age	NNP
18637	839	53	of	of	IN
18637	839	54	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	839	55	five	five	CD
18637	839	56	Years	year	NNS
18637	839	57	,	,	,
18637	839	58	and	and	CC
18637	839	59	been	be	VBN
18637	839	60	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	839	61	Years	year	NNS
18637	839	62	a	a	DT
18637	839	63	Resident	resident	NN
18637	839	64	within	within	IN
18637	839	65	the	the	DT
18637	839	66	United	United	NNP
18637	839	67	States	States	NNP
18637	839	68	.	.	.
18637	840	1	In	in	IN
18637	840	2	Case	case	NN
18637	840	3	of	of	IN
18637	840	4	the	the	DT
18637	840	5	Removal	Removal	NNP
18637	840	6	of	of	IN
18637	840	7	the	the	DT
18637	840	8	President	President	NNP
18637	840	9	from	from	IN
18637	840	10	Office	Office	NNP
18637	840	11	,	,	,
18637	840	12	or	or	CC
18637	840	13	of	of	IN
18637	840	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	840	15	Death	Death	NNP
18637	840	16	,	,	,
18637	840	17	Resignation	resignation	NN
18637	840	18	,	,	,
18637	840	19	or	or	CC
18637	840	20	Inability	inability	NN
18637	840	21	to	to	TO
18637	840	22	discharge	discharge	VB
18637	840	23	the	the	DT
18637	840	24	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	840	25	and	and	CC
18637	840	26	Duties	Duties	NNPS
18637	840	27	of	of	IN
18637	840	28	the	the	DT
18637	840	29	said	say	VBD
18637	840	30	Office	Office	NNP
18637	840	31	,	,	,
18637	840	32	the	the	DT
18637	840	33	Same	same	JJ
18637	840	34	shall	shall	MD
18637	840	35	devolve	devolve	VB
18637	840	36	on	on	IN
18637	840	37	the	the	DT
18637	840	38	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	840	39	President	President	NNP
18637	840	40	,	,	,
18637	840	41	and	and	CC
18637	840	42	the	the	DT
18637	840	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	840	44	may	may	MD
18637	840	45	by	by	IN
18637	840	46	Law	Law	NNP
18637	840	47	provide	provide	VB
18637	840	48	for	for	IN
18637	840	49	the	the	DT
18637	840	50	Case	Case	NNP
18637	840	51	of	of	IN
18637	840	52	Removal	Removal	NNP
18637	840	53	,	,	,
18637	840	54	Death	Death	NNP
18637	840	55	,	,	,
18637	840	56	Resignation	Resignation	NNP
18637	840	57	or	or	CC
18637	840	58	Inability	Inability	NNP
18637	840	59	,	,	,
18637	840	60	both	both	DT
18637	840	61	of	of	IN
18637	840	62	the	the	DT
18637	840	63	President	President	NNP
18637	840	64	and	and	CC
18637	840	65	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	840	66	President	President	NNP
18637	840	67	,	,	,
18637	840	68	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	840	69	what	what	WP
18637	840	70	Officer	Officer	NNP
18637	840	71	shall	shall	MD
18637	840	72	then	then	RB
18637	840	73	act	act	VB
18637	840	74	as	as	IN
18637	840	75	President	President	NNP
18637	840	76	,	,	,
18637	840	77	and	and	CC
18637	840	78	such	such	JJ
18637	840	79	Officer	Officer	NNP
18637	840	80	shall	shall	MD
18637	840	81	act	act	VB
18637	840	82	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	840	83	,	,	,
18637	840	84	until	until	IN
18637	840	85	the	the	DT
18637	840	86	Disability	Disability	NNP
18637	840	87	be	be	VB
18637	840	88	removed	remove	VBN
18637	840	89	,	,	,
18637	840	90	or	or	CC
18637	840	91	a	a	DT
18637	840	92	President	President	NNP
18637	840	93	shall	shall	MD
18637	840	94	be	be	VB
18637	840	95	elected	elect	VBN
18637	840	96	.	.	.
18637	841	1	The	the	DT
18637	841	2	President	President	NNP
18637	841	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	841	4	,	,	,
18637	841	5	at	at	IN
18637	841	6	stated	state	VBN
18637	841	7	Times	Times	NNP
18637	841	8	,	,	,
18637	841	9	receive	receive	VB
18637	841	10	for	for	IN
18637	841	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	841	12	Services	Services	NNPS
18637	841	13	,	,	,
18637	841	14	a	a	DT
18637	841	15	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	841	16	,	,	,
18637	841	17	which	which	WDT
18637	841	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	841	19	neither	neither	CC
18637	841	20	be	be	VB
18637	841	21	encreased	encrease	VBN
18637	841	22	nor	nor	CC
18637	841	23	diminished	diminish	VBN
18637	841	24	during	during	IN
18637	841	25	the	the	DT
18637	841	26	Period	Period	NNP
18637	841	27	for	for	IN
18637	841	28	which	which	WDT
18637	841	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	841	30	shall	shall	MD
18637	841	31	have	have	VB
18637	841	32	been	be	VBN
18637	841	33	elected	elect	VBN
18637	841	34	,	,	,
18637	841	35	and	and	CC
18637	841	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	841	37	shall	shall	MD
18637	841	38	not	not	RB
18637	841	39	receive	receive	VB
18637	841	40	within	within	IN
18637	841	41	that	that	DT
18637	841	42	Period	period	NN
18637	841	43	any	any	DT
18637	841	44	other	other	JJ
18637	841	45	Emolument	Emolument	NNP
18637	841	46	from	from	IN
18637	841	47	the	the	DT
18637	841	48	United	United	NNP
18637	841	49	States	States	NNP
18637	841	50	,	,	,
18637	841	51	or	or	CC
18637	841	52	any	any	DT
18637	841	53	of	of	IN
18637	841	54	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	841	55	.	.	.
18637	842	1	Before	before	IN
18637	842	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	842	3	enter	enter	VBP
18637	842	4	on	on	IN
18637	842	5	the	the	DT
18637	842	6	Execution	Execution	NNP
18637	842	7	of	of	IN
18637	842	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	842	9	Office	Office	NNP
18637	842	10	,	,	,
18637	842	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	842	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	842	13	take	take	VB
18637	842	14	the	the	DT
18637	842	15	following	follow	VBG
18637	842	16	Oath	Oath	NNP
18637	842	17	or	or	CC
18637	842	18	Affirmation:--"I	affirmation:--"i	CD
18637	842	19	do	do	VBP
18637	842	20	solemnly	solemnly	RB
18637	842	21	swear	swear	VB
18637	842	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	842	23	or	or	CC
18637	842	24	affirm	affirm	NN
18637	842	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	842	26	that	that	IN
18637	842	27	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	842	28	will	will	MD
18637	842	29	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	842	30	execute	execute	VB
18637	842	31	the	the	DT
18637	842	32	Office	Office	NNP
18637	842	33	of	of	IN
18637	842	34	President	President	NNP
18637	842	35	of	of	IN
18637	842	36	the	the	DT
18637	842	37	United	United	NNP
18637	842	38	States	States	NNP
18637	842	39	,	,	,
18637	842	40	and	and	CC
18637	842	41	will	will	MD
18637	842	42	to	to	IN
18637	842	43	the	the	DT
18637	842	44	best	good	JJS
18637	842	45	of	of	IN
18637	842	46	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	842	47	Ability	ability	NN
18637	842	48	,	,	,
18637	842	49	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	842	50	,	,	,
18637	842	51	protect	protect	VB
18637	842	52	and	and	CC
18637	842	53	defend	defend	VB
18637	842	54	the	the	DT
18637	842	55	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	842	56	of	of	IN
18637	842	57	the	the	DT
18637	842	58	United	United	NNP
18637	842	59	States	States	NNP
18637	842	60	.	.	.
18637	842	61	"	"	''
18637	843	1	Section	section	NN
18637	843	2	.	.	.
18637	844	1	2	2	LS
18637	844	2	.	.	.
18637	845	1	The	the	DT
18637	845	2	President	President	NNP
18637	845	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	845	4	be	be	VB
18637	845	5	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	845	6	in	in	IN
18637	845	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	845	8	of	of	IN
18637	845	9	the	the	DT
18637	845	10	Army	Army	NNP
18637	845	11	and	and	CC
18637	845	12	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	845	13	of	of	IN
18637	845	14	the	the	DT
18637	845	15	United	United	NNP
18637	845	16	States	States	NNP
18637	845	17	,	,	,
18637	845	18	and	and	CC
18637	845	19	of	of	IN
18637	845	20	the	the	DT
18637	845	21	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	845	22	of	of	IN
18637	845	23	the	the	DT
18637	845	24	several	several	JJ
18637	845	25	States	States	NNPS
18637	845	26	,	,	,
18637	845	27	when	when	WRB
18637	845	28	called	call	VBN
18637	845	29	into	into	IN
18637	845	30	the	the	DT
18637	845	31	actual	actual	JJ
18637	845	32	Service	Service	NNP
18637	845	33	of	of	IN
18637	845	34	the	the	DT
18637	845	35	United	United	NNP
18637	845	36	States	States	NNP
18637	845	37	;	;	:
18637	845	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	845	39	may	may	MD
18637	845	40	require	require	VB
18637	845	41	the	the	DT
18637	845	42	Opinion	Opinion	NNP
18637	845	43	,	,	,
18637	845	44	in	in	IN
18637	845	45	writing	writing	NN
18637	845	46	,	,	,
18637	845	47	of	of	IN
18637	845	48	the	the	DT
18637	845	49	principal	principal	JJ
18637	845	50	Officer	Officer	NNP
18637	845	51	in	in	IN
18637	845	52	each	each	DT
18637	845	53	of	of	IN
18637	845	54	the	the	DT
18637	845	55	executive	executive	JJ
18637	845	56	Departments	department	NNS
18637	845	57	,	,	,
18637	845	58	upon	upon	IN
18637	845	59	any	any	DT
18637	845	60	Subject	Subject	NNP
18637	845	61	relating	relate	VBG
18637	845	62	to	to	IN
18637	845	63	the	the	DT
18637	845	64	Duties	Duties	NNPS
18637	845	65	of	of	IN
18637	845	66	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	845	67	respective	respective	JJ
18637	845	68	Offices	office	NNS
18637	845	69	,	,	,
18637	845	70	and	and	CC
18637	845	71	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	845	72	shall	shall	MD
18637	845	73	have	have	VB
18637	845	74	Power	Power	NNP
18637	845	75	to	to	TO
18637	845	76	grant	grant	VB
18637	845	77	Reprieves	Reprieves	NNP
18637	845	78	and	and	CC
18637	845	79	Pardons	Pardons	NNPS
18637	845	80	for	for	IN
18637	845	81	Offences	offence	NNS
18637	845	82	against	against	IN
18637	845	83	the	the	DT
18637	845	84	United	United	NNP
18637	845	85	States	States	NNP
18637	845	86	,	,	,
18637	845	87	except	except	IN
18637	845	88	in	in	IN
18637	845	89	Cases	case	NNS
18637	845	90	of	of	IN
18637	845	91	Impeachment	Impeachment	NNP
18637	845	92	.	.	.
18637	846	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	846	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	846	3	have	have	VB
18637	846	4	Power	power	NN
18637	846	5	,	,	,
18637	846	6	by	by	RB
18637	846	7	and	and	CC
18637	846	8	with	with	IN
18637	846	9	the	the	DT
18637	846	10	Advice	Advice	NNP
18637	846	11	and	and	CC
18637	846	12	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	846	13	of	of	IN
18637	846	14	the	the	DT
18637	846	15	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	846	16	,	,	,
18637	846	17	to	to	TO
18637	846	18	make	make	VB
18637	846	19	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	846	20	,	,	,
18637	846	21	provided	provide	VBN
18637	846	22	two	two	CD
18637	846	23	thirds	third	NNS
18637	846	24	of	of	IN
18637	846	25	the	the	DT
18637	846	26	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	846	27	present	present	JJ
18637	846	28	concur	concur	NN
18637	846	29	;	;	:
18637	846	30	and	and	CC
18637	846	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	846	32	shall	shall	MD
18637	846	33	nominate	nominate	VB
18637	846	34	,	,	,
18637	846	35	and	and	CC
18637	846	36	by	by	RB
18637	846	37	and	and	CC
18637	846	38	with	with	IN
18637	846	39	the	the	DT
18637	846	40	Advice	Advice	NNP
18637	846	41	and	and	CC
18637	846	42	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	846	43	of	of	IN
18637	846	44	the	the	DT
18637	846	45	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	846	46	,	,	,
18637	846	47	shall	shall	MD
18637	846	48	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	846	49	Ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	846	50	,	,	,
18637	846	51	other	other	JJ
18637	846	52	public	public	JJ
18637	846	53	Ministers	Ministers	NNPS
18637	846	54	and	and	CC
18637	846	55	Consuls	Consuls	NNPS
18637	846	56	,	,	,
18637	846	57	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	846	58	of	of	IN
18637	846	59	the	the	DT
18637	846	60	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	846	61	Court	Court	NNP
18637	846	62	,	,	,
18637	846	63	and	and	CC
18637	846	64	all	all	DT
18637	846	65	other	other	JJ
18637	846	66	Officers	officer	NNS
18637	846	67	of	of	IN
18637	846	68	the	the	DT
18637	846	69	United	United	NNP
18637	846	70	States	States	NNP
18637	846	71	,	,	,
18637	846	72	whose	whose	WP$
18637	846	73	Appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	846	74	are	be	VBP
18637	846	75	not	not	RB
18637	846	76	herein	herein	RB
18637	846	77	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	846	78	provided	provide	VBN
18637	846	79	for	for	IN
18637	846	80	,	,	,
18637	846	81	and	and	CC
18637	846	82	which	which	WDT
18637	846	83	shall	shall	MD
18637	846	84	be	be	VB
18637	846	85	established	establish	VBN
18637	846	86	by	by	IN
18637	846	87	Law	Law	NNP
18637	846	88	:	:	:
18637	846	89	but	but	CC
18637	846	90	the	the	DT
18637	846	91	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	846	92	may	may	MD
18637	846	93	by	by	IN
18637	846	94	Law	Law	NNP
18637	846	95	vest	vest	VBD
18637	846	96	the	the	DT
18637	846	97	Appointment	Appointment	NNP
18637	846	98	of	of	IN
18637	846	99	such	such	JJ
18637	846	100	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	846	101	Officers	officer	NNS
18637	846	102	,	,	,
18637	846	103	as	as	IN
18637	846	104	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	846	105	think	think	VBP
18637	846	106	proper	proper	JJ
18637	846	107	,	,	,
18637	846	108	in	in	IN
18637	846	109	the	the	DT
18637	846	110	President	President	NNP
18637	846	111	alone	alone	RB
18637	846	112	,	,	,
18637	846	113	in	in	IN
18637	846	114	the	the	DT
18637	846	115	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	846	116	of	of	IN
18637	846	117	Law	Law	NNP
18637	846	118	,	,	,
18637	846	119	or	or	CC
18637	846	120	in	in	IN
18637	846	121	the	the	DT
18637	846	122	Heads	head	NNS
18637	846	123	of	of	IN
18637	846	124	Departments	Departments	NNP
18637	846	125	.	.	.
18637	847	1	The	the	DT
18637	847	2	President	President	NNP
18637	847	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	847	4	have	have	VB
18637	847	5	Power	power	NN
18637	847	6	to	to	TO
18637	847	7	fill	fill	VB
18637	847	8	up	up	RP
18637	847	9	all	all	DT
18637	847	10	Vacancies	Vacancies	NNPS
18637	847	11	that	that	WDT
18637	847	12	may	may	MD
18637	847	13	happen	happen	VB
18637	847	14	during	during	IN
18637	847	15	the	the	DT
18637	847	16	Recess	Recess	NNP
18637	847	17	of	of	IN
18637	847	18	the	the	DT
18637	847	19	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	847	20	,	,	,
18637	847	21	by	by	IN
18637	847	22	granting	grant	VBG
18637	847	23	Commissions	Commissions	NNPS
18637	847	24	which	which	WDT
18637	847	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	847	26	expire	expire	VB
18637	847	27	at	at	IN
18637	847	28	the	the	DT
18637	847	29	End	end	NN
18637	847	30	of	of	IN
18637	847	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	847	32	next	next	JJ
18637	847	33	Session	session	NN
18637	847	34	.	.	.
18637	848	1	Section	section	NN
18637	848	2	.	.	.
18637	849	1	3	3	LS
18637	849	2	.	.	.
18637	850	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	850	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	850	3	from	from	IN
18637	850	4	time	time	NN
18637	850	5	to	to	IN
18637	850	6	time	time	NN
18637	850	7	give	give	VB
18637	850	8	to	to	IN
18637	850	9	the	the	DT
18637	850	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	850	11	Information	Information	NNP
18637	850	12	of	of	IN
18637	850	13	the	the	DT
18637	850	14	State	State	NNP
18637	850	15	of	of	IN
18637	850	16	the	the	DT
18637	850	17	Union	Union	NNP
18637	850	18	,	,	,
18637	850	19	and	and	CC
18637	850	20	recommend	recommend	VB
18637	850	21	to	to	IN
18637	850	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	850	23	Consideration	consideration	NN
18637	850	24	such	such	JJ
18637	850	25	Measures	measure	NNS
18637	850	26	as	as	IN
18637	850	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	850	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	850	29	judge	judge	VB
18637	850	30	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	850	31	and	and	CC
18637	850	32	expedient	expedient	JJ
18637	850	33	;	;	:
18637	850	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	850	35	may	may	MD
18637	850	36	,	,	,
18637	850	37	on	on	IN
18637	850	38	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	850	39	Occasions	Occasions	NNP
18637	850	40	,	,	,
18637	850	41	convene	convene	VB
18637	850	42	both	both	DT
18637	850	43	Houses	house	NNS
18637	850	44	,	,	,
18637	850	45	or	or	CC
18637	850	46	either	either	DT
18637	850	47	of	of	IN
18637	850	48	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	850	49	,	,	,
18637	850	50	and	and	CC
18637	850	51	in	in	IN
18637	850	52	Case	case	NN
18637	850	53	of	of	IN
18637	850	54	Disagreement	Disagreement	NNP
18637	850	55	between	between	IN
18637	850	56	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	850	57	,	,	,
18637	850	58	with	with	IN
18637	850	59	Respect	respect	NN
18637	850	60	to	to	IN
18637	850	61	the	the	DT
18637	850	62	Time	Time	NNP
18637	850	63	of	of	IN
18637	850	64	Adjournment	Adjournment	NNP
18637	850	65	,	,	,
18637	850	66	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	850	67	may	may	MD
18637	850	68	adjourn	adjourn	VB
18637	850	69	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	850	70	to	to	IN
18637	850	71	such	such	JJ
18637	850	72	Time	time	NN
18637	850	73	as	as	IN
18637	850	74	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	850	75	shall	shall	MD
18637	850	76	think	think	VB
18637	850	77	proper	proper	JJ
18637	850	78	;	;	:
18637	850	79	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	850	80	shall	shall	MD
18637	850	81	receive	receive	VB
18637	850	82	Ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	850	83	and	and	CC
18637	850	84	other	other	JJ
18637	850	85	public	public	JJ
18637	850	86	Ministers	minister	NNS
18637	850	87	;	;	:
18637	850	88	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	850	89	shall	shall	MD
18637	850	90	take	take	VB
18637	850	91	Care	care	NN
18637	850	92	that	that	IN
18637	850	93	the	the	DT
18637	850	94	Laws	law	NNS
18637	850	95	be	be	VB
18637	850	96	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	850	97	executed	execute	VBN
18637	850	98	,	,	,
18637	850	99	and	and	CC
18637	850	100	shall	shall	MD
18637	850	101	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	850	102	all	all	PDT
18637	850	103	the	the	DT
18637	850	104	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	850	105	of	of	IN
18637	850	106	the	the	DT
18637	850	107	United	United	NNP
18637	850	108	States	States	NNP
18637	850	109	.	.	.
18637	851	1	Section	section	NN
18637	851	2	.	.	.
18637	852	1	4	4	LS
18637	852	2	.	.	.
18637	853	1	The	the	DT
18637	853	2	President	President	NNP
18637	853	3	,	,	,
18637	853	4	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	853	5	President	President	NNP
18637	853	6	and	and	CC
18637	853	7	all	all	DT
18637	853	8	civil	civil	JJ
18637	853	9	Officers	officer	NNS
18637	853	10	of	of	IN
18637	853	11	the	the	DT
18637	853	12	United	United	NNP
18637	853	13	States	States	NNP
18637	853	14	,	,	,
18637	853	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	853	16	be	be	VB
18637	853	17	removed	remove	VBN
18637	853	18	from	from	IN
18637	853	19	Office	Office	NNP
18637	853	20	on	on	IN
18637	853	21	Impeachment	Impeachment	NNP
18637	853	22	for	for	IN
18637	853	23	,	,	,
18637	853	24	and	and	CC
18637	853	25	Conviction	Conviction	NNP
18637	853	26	of	of	IN
18637	853	27	,	,	,
18637	853	28	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	853	29	,	,	,
18637	853	30	Bribery	Bribery	NNP
18637	853	31	,	,	,
18637	853	32	or	or	CC
18637	853	33	other	other	JJ
18637	853	34	high	high	JJ
18637	853	35	Crimes	Crimes	NNPS
18637	853	36	and	and	CC
18637	853	37	Misdemeanors	Misdemeanors	NNPS
18637	853	38	.	.	.
18637	854	1	Article	article	NN
18637	854	2	.	.	.
18637	855	1	III	iii	CD
18637	855	2	.	.	.
18637	856	1	Section	section	NN
18637	856	2	.	.	.
18637	857	1	1	1	LS
18637	857	2	.	.	.
18637	858	1	The	the	DT
18637	858	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	858	3	Power	Power	NNP
18637	858	4	of	of	IN
18637	858	5	the	the	DT
18637	858	6	United	United	NNP
18637	858	7	States	States	NNP
18637	858	8	,	,	,
18637	858	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	858	10	be	be	VB
18637	858	11	vested	vest	VBN
18637	858	12	in	in	IN
18637	858	13	one	one	CD
18637	858	14	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	858	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	858	16	,	,	,
18637	858	17	and	and	CC
18637	858	18	in	in	IN
18637	858	19	such	such	JJ
18637	858	20	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	858	21	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	858	22	as	as	IN
18637	858	23	the	the	DT
18637	858	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	858	25	may	may	MD
18637	858	26	from	from	IN
18637	858	27	time	time	NN
18637	858	28	to	to	IN
18637	858	29	time	time	NN
18637	858	30	ordain	ordain	NN
18637	858	31	and	and	CC
18637	858	32	establish	establish	VB
18637	858	33	.	.	.
18637	859	1	The	the	DT
18637	859	2	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	859	3	,	,	,
18637	859	4	both	both	DT
18637	859	5	of	of	IN
18637	859	6	the	the	DT
18637	859	7	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	859	8	and	and	CC
18637	859	9	inferior	inferior	NNP
18637	859	10	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	859	11	,	,	,
18637	859	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	859	13	hold	hold	VB
18637	859	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	859	15	Offices	office	NNS
18637	859	16	during	during	IN
18637	859	17	good	good	JJ
18637	859	18	Behaviour	Behaviour	NNP
18637	859	19	,	,	,
18637	859	20	and	and	CC
18637	859	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	859	22	,	,	,
18637	859	23	at	at	IN
18637	859	24	stated	state	VBN
18637	859	25	Times	Times	NNP
18637	859	26	,	,	,
18637	859	27	receive	receive	VB
18637	859	28	for	for	IN
18637	859	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	859	30	Services	Services	NNPS
18637	859	31	,	,	,
18637	859	32	a	a	DT
18637	859	33	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	859	34	,	,	,
18637	859	35	which	which	WDT
18637	859	36	shall	shall	MD
18637	859	37	not	not	RB
18637	859	38	be	be	VB
18637	859	39	diminished	diminish	VBN
18637	859	40	during	during	IN
18637	859	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	859	42	Continuance	Continuance	NNP
18637	859	43	in	in	IN
18637	859	44	Office	Office	NNP
18637	859	45	.	.	.
18637	860	1	Section	section	NN
18637	860	2	.	.	.
18637	861	1	2	2	LS
18637	861	2	.	.	.
18637	862	1	The	the	DT
18637	862	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	862	3	Power	Power	NNP
18637	862	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	862	5	extend	extend	VB
18637	862	6	to	to	IN
18637	862	7	all	all	DT
18637	862	8	Cases	case	NNS
18637	862	9	,	,	,
18637	862	10	in	in	IN
18637	862	11	Law	Law	NNP
18637	862	12	and	and	CC
18637	862	13	Equity	Equity	NNP
18637	862	14	,	,	,
18637	862	15	arising	arise	VBG
18637	862	16	under	under	IN
18637	862	17	this	this	DT
18637	862	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	862	19	,	,	,
18637	862	20	the	the	DT
18637	862	21	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	862	22	of	of	IN
18637	862	23	the	the	DT
18637	862	24	United	United	NNP
18637	862	25	States	States	NNP
18637	862	26	,	,	,
18637	862	27	and	and	CC
18637	862	28	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	862	29	made	make	VBD
18637	862	30	,	,	,
18637	862	31	or	or	CC
18637	862	32	which	which	WDT
18637	862	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	862	34	be	be	VB
18637	862	35	made	make	VBN
18637	862	36	,	,	,
18637	862	37	under	under	IN
18637	862	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	862	39	Authority;--to	Authority;--to	NNP
18637	862	40	all	all	DT
18637	862	41	Cases	case	NNS
18637	862	42	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	862	43	Ambassadors	Ambassadors	NNPS
18637	862	44	,	,	,
18637	862	45	other	other	JJ
18637	862	46	public	public	JJ
18637	862	47	Ministers	Ministers	NNP
18637	862	48	and	and	CC
18637	862	49	Consuls;--to	Consuls;--to	NNP
18637	862	50	all	all	DT
18637	862	51	Cases	case	NNS
18637	862	52	of	of	IN
18637	862	53	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	862	54	and	and	CC
18637	862	55	maritime	maritime	NN
18637	862	56	Jurisdiction;--to	Jurisdiction;--to	NNP
18637	862	57	Controversies	Controversies	NNPS
18637	862	58	to	to	TO
18637	862	59	which	which	WDT
18637	862	60	the	the	DT
18637	862	61	United	United	NNP
18637	862	62	States	States	NNP
18637	862	63	shall	shall	MD
18637	862	64	be	be	VB
18637	862	65	a	a	DT
18637	862	66	Party;--to	Party;--to	NNP
18637	862	67	Controversies	Controversies	NNPS
18637	862	68	between	between	IN
18637	862	69	two	two	CD
18637	862	70	or	or	CC
18637	862	71	more	more	JJR
18637	862	72	States;--between	states;--between	IN
18637	862	73	a	a	DT
18637	862	74	State	State	NNP
18637	862	75	and	and	CC
18637	862	76	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	862	77	of	of	IN
18637	862	78	another	another	DT
18637	862	79	State;--between	State;--between	NNP
18637	862	80	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	862	81	of	of	IN
18637	862	82	different	different	JJ
18637	862	83	States;--between	states;--between	JJ
18637	862	84	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	862	85	of	of	IN
18637	862	86	the	the	DT
18637	862	87	same	same	JJ
18637	862	88	State	State	NNP
18637	862	89	claiming	claim	VBG
18637	862	90	Lands	Lands	NNPS
18637	862	91	under	under	IN
18637	862	92	Grants	Grants	NNPS
18637	862	93	of	of	IN
18637	862	94	different	different	JJ
18637	862	95	States	state	NNS
18637	862	96	,	,	,
18637	862	97	and	and	CC
18637	862	98	between	between	IN
18637	862	99	a	a	DT
18637	862	100	State	state	NN
18637	862	101	,	,	,
18637	862	102	or	or	CC
18637	862	103	the	the	DT
18637	862	104	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	862	105	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	862	106	,	,	,
18637	862	107	and	and	CC
18637	862	108	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	862	109	States	state	NNS
18637	862	110	,	,	,
18637	862	111	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	862	112	or	or	CC
18637	862	113	Subjects	subject	NNS
18637	862	114	.	.	.
18637	863	1	In	in	IN
18637	863	2	all	all	DT
18637	863	3	Cases	case	NNS
18637	863	4	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	863	5	Ambassadors	Ambassadors	NNPS
18637	863	6	,	,	,
18637	863	7	other	other	JJ
18637	863	8	public	public	JJ
18637	863	9	Ministers	Ministers	NNPS
18637	863	10	and	and	CC
18637	863	11	Consuls	Consuls	NNP
18637	863	12	,	,	,
18637	863	13	and	and	CC
18637	863	14	those	those	DT
18637	863	15	in	in	IN
18637	863	16	which	which	WDT
18637	863	17	a	a	DT
18637	863	18	State	state	NN
18637	863	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	863	20	be	be	VB
18637	863	21	Party	Party	NNP
18637	863	22	,	,	,
18637	863	23	the	the	DT
18637	863	24	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	863	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	863	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	863	27	have	have	VB
18637	863	28	original	original	JJ
18637	863	29	Jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	863	30	.	.	.
18637	864	1	In	in	IN
18637	864	2	all	all	PDT
18637	864	3	the	the	DT
18637	864	4	other	other	JJ
18637	864	5	Cases	case	NNS
18637	864	6	before	before	IN
18637	864	7	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	864	8	,	,	,
18637	864	9	the	the	DT
18637	864	10	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	864	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	864	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	864	13	have	have	VB
18637	864	14	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	864	15	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	864	16	,	,	,
18637	864	17	both	both	CC
18637	864	18	as	as	IN
18637	864	19	to	to	IN
18637	864	20	Law	Law	NNP
18637	864	21	and	and	CC
18637	864	22	Fact	Fact	NNP
18637	864	23	,	,	,
18637	864	24	with	with	IN
18637	864	25	such	such	JJ
18637	864	26	Exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	864	27	,	,	,
18637	864	28	and	and	CC
18637	864	29	under	under	IN
18637	864	30	such	such	JJ
18637	864	31	Regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	864	32	as	as	IN
18637	864	33	the	the	DT
18637	864	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	864	35	shall	shall	MD
18637	864	36	make	make	VB
18637	864	37	.	.	.
18637	865	1	The	the	DT
18637	865	2	Trial	trial	NN
18637	865	3	of	of	IN
18637	865	4	all	all	DT
18637	865	5	Crimes	Crimes	NNPS
18637	865	6	,	,	,
18637	865	7	except	except	IN
18637	865	8	in	in	IN
18637	865	9	Cases	case	NNS
18637	865	10	of	of	IN
18637	865	11	Impeachment	Impeachment	NNP
18637	865	12	,	,	,
18637	865	13	shall	shall	MD
18637	865	14	be	be	VB
18637	865	15	by	by	IN
18637	865	16	Jury	jury	NN
18637	865	17	;	;	:
18637	865	18	and	and	CC
18637	865	19	such	such	JJ
18637	865	20	Trial	trial	NN
18637	865	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	865	22	be	be	VB
18637	865	23	held	hold	VBN
18637	865	24	in	in	IN
18637	865	25	the	the	DT
18637	865	26	State	State	NNP
18637	865	27	where	where	WRB
18637	865	28	the	the	DT
18637	865	29	said	say	VBN
18637	865	30	Crimes	crime	NNS
18637	865	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	865	32	have	have	VB
18637	865	33	been	be	VBN
18637	865	34	committed	commit	VBN
18637	865	35	;	;	:
18637	865	36	but	but	CC
18637	865	37	when	when	WRB
18637	865	38	not	not	RB
18637	865	39	committed	commit	VBN
18637	865	40	within	within	IN
18637	865	41	any	any	DT
18637	865	42	State	State	NNP
18637	865	43	,	,	,
18637	865	44	the	the	DT
18637	865	45	Trial	trial	NN
18637	865	46	shall	shall	MD
18637	865	47	be	be	VB
18637	865	48	at	at	IN
18637	865	49	such	such	JJ
18637	865	50	Place	Place	NNP
18637	865	51	or	or	CC
18637	865	52	Places	Places	NNPS
18637	865	53	as	as	IN
18637	865	54	the	the	DT
18637	865	55	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	865	56	may	may	MD
18637	865	57	by	by	IN
18637	865	58	Law	Law	NNP
18637	865	59	have	have	VBP
18637	865	60	directed	direct	VBN
18637	865	61	.	.	.
18637	866	1	Section	section	NN
18637	866	2	.	.	.
18637	867	1	3	3	LS
18637	867	2	.	.	.
18637	868	1	Treason	treason	NN
18637	868	2	against	against	IN
18637	868	3	the	the	DT
18637	868	4	United	United	NNP
18637	868	5	States	States	NNP
18637	868	6	,	,	,
18637	868	7	shall	shall	MD
18637	868	8	consist	consist	VB
18637	868	9	only	only	RB
18637	868	10	in	in	IN
18637	868	11	levying	levy	VBG
18637	868	12	War	war	NN
18637	868	13	against	against	IN
18637	868	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	868	15	,	,	,
18637	868	16	or	or	CC
18637	868	17	in	in	IN
18637	868	18	adhering	adhere	VBG
18637	868	19	to	to	IN
18637	868	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	868	21	Enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	868	22	,	,	,
18637	868	23	giving	give	VBG
18637	868	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	868	25	Aid	Aid	NNP
18637	868	26	and	and	CC
18637	868	27	Comfort	Comfort	NNP
18637	868	28	.	.	.
18637	869	1	No	no	DT
18637	869	2	Person	person	NN
18637	869	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	869	4	be	be	VB
18637	869	5	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	869	6	of	of	IN
18637	869	7	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	869	8	unless	unless	IN
18637	869	9	on	on	IN
18637	869	10	the	the	DT
18637	869	11	Testimony	Testimony	NNP
18637	869	12	of	of	IN
18637	869	13	two	two	CD
18637	869	14	Witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	869	15	to	to	IN
18637	869	16	the	the	DT
18637	869	17	same	same	JJ
18637	869	18	overt	overt	JJ
18637	869	19	Act	Act	NNP
18637	869	20	,	,	,
18637	869	21	or	or	CC
18637	869	22	on	on	IN
18637	869	23	Confession	Confession	NNP
18637	869	24	in	in	IN
18637	869	25	open	open	JJ
18637	869	26	Court	court	NN
18637	869	27	.	.	.
18637	870	1	The	the	DT
18637	870	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	870	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	870	4	have	have	VB
18637	870	5	Power	power	NN
18637	870	6	to	to	TO
18637	870	7	declare	declare	VB
18637	870	8	the	the	DT
18637	870	9	Punishment	Punishment	NNP
18637	870	10	of	of	IN
18637	870	11	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	870	12	,	,	,
18637	870	13	but	but	CC
18637	870	14	no	no	DT
18637	870	15	Attainder	Attainder	NNP
18637	870	16	of	of	IN
18637	870	17	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	870	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	870	19	work	work	VB
18637	870	20	Corruption	Corruption	NNP
18637	870	21	of	of	IN
18637	870	22	Blood	Blood	NNP
18637	870	23	,	,	,
18637	870	24	or	or	CC
18637	870	25	Forfeiture	Forfeiture	NNP
18637	870	26	except	except	IN
18637	870	27	during	during	IN
18637	870	28	the	the	DT
18637	870	29	Life	Life	NNP
18637	870	30	of	of	IN
18637	870	31	the	the	DT
18637	870	32	Person	person	NN
18637	870	33	attainted	attaint	VBN
18637	870	34	.	.	.
18637	871	1	Article	article	NN
18637	871	2	.	.	.
18637	872	1	IV	IV	NNP
18637	872	2	.	.	.
18637	873	1	Section	section	NN
18637	873	2	1	1	CD
18637	873	3	.	.	.
18637	874	1	Full	full	JJ
18637	874	2	Faith	Faith	NNP
18637	874	3	and	and	CC
18637	874	4	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	874	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	874	6	be	be	VB
18637	874	7	given	give	VBN
18637	874	8	in	in	IN
18637	874	9	each	each	DT
18637	874	10	State	state	NN
18637	874	11	to	to	IN
18637	874	12	the	the	DT
18637	874	13	public	public	JJ
18637	874	14	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	874	15	,	,	,
18637	874	16	Records	Records	NNPS
18637	874	17	,	,	,
18637	874	18	and	and	CC
18637	874	19	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	874	20	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNPS
18637	874	21	of	of	IN
18637	874	22	every	every	DT
18637	874	23	other	other	JJ
18637	874	24	State	State	NNP
18637	874	25	.	.	.
18637	875	1	And	and	CC
18637	875	2	the	the	DT
18637	875	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	875	4	may	may	MD
18637	875	5	by	by	IN
18637	875	6	general	general	JJ
18637	875	7	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	875	8	prescribe	prescribe	VBP
18637	875	9	the	the	DT
18637	875	10	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	875	11	in	in	IN
18637	875	12	which	which	WDT
18637	875	13	such	such	JJ
18637	875	14	Acts	act	NNS
18637	875	15	,	,	,
18637	875	16	Records	Records	NNPS
18637	875	17	and	and	CC
18637	875	18	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNPS
18637	875	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	875	20	be	be	VB
18637	875	21	proved	prove	VBN
18637	875	22	,	,	,
18637	875	23	and	and	CC
18637	875	24	the	the	DT
18637	875	25	Effect	Effect	NNP
18637	875	26	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	875	27	.	.	.
18637	876	1	Section	section	NN
18637	876	2	2	2	CD
18637	876	3	.	.	.
18637	877	1	The	the	DT
18637	877	2	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	877	3	of	of	IN
18637	877	4	each	each	DT
18637	877	5	State	state	NN
18637	877	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	877	7	be	be	VB
18637	877	8	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	877	9	to	to	IN
18637	877	10	all	all	DT
18637	877	11	Privileges	Privileges	NNPS
18637	877	12	and	and	CC
18637	877	13	Immunities	Immunities	NNPS
18637	877	14	of	of	IN
18637	877	15	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	877	16	in	in	IN
18637	877	17	the	the	DT
18637	877	18	several	several	JJ
18637	877	19	States	state	NNS
18637	877	20	.	.	.
18637	878	1	A	a	DT
18637	878	2	Person	person	NN
18637	878	3	charged	charge	VBN
18637	878	4	in	in	IN
18637	878	5	any	any	DT
18637	878	6	State	State	NNP
18637	878	7	with	with	IN
18637	878	8	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	878	9	,	,	,
18637	878	10	Felony	Felony	NNP
18637	878	11	,	,	,
18637	878	12	or	or	CC
18637	878	13	other	other	JJ
18637	878	14	Crime	Crime	NNP
18637	878	15	,	,	,
18637	878	16	who	who	WP
18637	878	17	shall	shall	MD
18637	878	18	flee	flee	VB
18637	878	19	from	from	IN
18637	878	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	878	21	,	,	,
18637	878	22	and	and	CC
18637	878	23	be	be	VB
18637	878	24	found	find	VBN
18637	878	25	in	in	IN
18637	878	26	another	another	DT
18637	878	27	State	State	NNP
18637	878	28	,	,	,
18637	878	29	shall	shall	MD
18637	878	30	on	on	IN
18637	878	31	Demand	demand	NN
18637	878	32	of	of	IN
18637	878	33	the	the	DT
18637	878	34	executive	executive	NN
18637	878	35	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	878	36	of	of	IN
18637	878	37	the	the	DT
18637	878	38	State	State	NNP
18637	878	39	from	from	IN
18637	878	40	which	which	WDT
18637	878	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	878	42	fled	flee	VBD
18637	878	43	,	,	,
18637	878	44	be	be	VB
18637	878	45	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	878	46	up	up	RP
18637	878	47	,	,	,
18637	878	48	to	to	TO
18637	878	49	be	be	VB
18637	878	50	removed	remove	VBN
18637	878	51	to	to	IN
18637	878	52	the	the	DT
18637	878	53	State	state	NN
18637	878	54	having	have	VBG
18637	878	55	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	878	56	of	of	IN
18637	878	57	the	the	DT
18637	878	58	Crime	Crime	NNP
18637	878	59	.	.	.
18637	879	1	No	no	DT
18637	879	2	Person	person	NN
18637	879	3	held	hold	VBN
18637	879	4	to	to	IN
18637	879	5	Service	Service	NNP
18637	879	6	or	or	CC
18637	879	7	Labour	Labour	NNP
18637	879	8	in	in	IN
18637	879	9	one	one	CD
18637	879	10	State	state	NN
18637	879	11	,	,	,
18637	879	12	under	under	IN
18637	879	13	the	the	DT
18637	879	14	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	879	15	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	879	16	,	,	,
18637	879	17	escaping	escape	VBG
18637	879	18	into	into	IN
18637	879	19	another	another	DT
18637	879	20	,	,	,
18637	879	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	879	22	,	,	,
18637	879	23	in	in	IN
18637	879	24	Consequence	Consequence	NNP
18637	879	25	of	of	IN
18637	879	26	any	any	DT
18637	879	27	Law	Law	NNP
18637	879	28	or	or	CC
18637	879	29	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	879	30	therein	therein	RB
18637	879	31	,	,	,
18637	879	32	be	be	VB
18637	879	33	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	879	34	from	from	IN
18637	879	35	such	such	JJ
18637	879	36	Service	Service	NNP
18637	879	37	or	or	CC
18637	879	38	Labour	Labour	NNP
18637	879	39	,	,	,
18637	879	40	but	but	CC
18637	879	41	shall	shall	MD
18637	879	42	be	be	VB
18637	879	43	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	879	44	up	up	RP
18637	879	45	on	on	IN
18637	879	46	Claim	Claim	NNP
18637	879	47	of	of	IN
18637	879	48	the	the	DT
18637	879	49	Party	Party	NNP
18637	879	50	to	to	TO
18637	879	51	whom	whom	WP
18637	879	52	such	such	JJ
18637	879	53	Service	Service	NNP
18637	879	54	or	or	CC
18637	879	55	Labour	Labour	NNP
18637	879	56	may	may	MD
18637	879	57	be	be	VB
18637	879	58	due	due	JJ
18637	879	59	.	.	.
18637	880	1	Section	section	NN
18637	880	2	.	.	.
18637	881	1	3	3	LS
18637	881	2	.	.	.
18637	882	1	New	New	NNP
18637	882	2	States	States	NNP
18637	882	3	may	may	MD
18637	882	4	be	be	VB
18637	882	5	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	882	6	by	by	IN
18637	882	7	the	the	DT
18637	882	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	882	9	into	into	IN
18637	882	10	this	this	DT
18637	882	11	Union	Union	NNP
18637	882	12	;	;	:
18637	882	13	but	but	CC
18637	882	14	no	no	DT
18637	882	15	new	new	JJ
18637	882	16	State	State	NNP
18637	882	17	shall	shall	MD
18637	882	18	be	be	VB
18637	882	19	formed	form	VBN
18637	882	20	or	or	CC
18637	882	21	erected	erect	VBN
18637	882	22	within	within	IN
18637	882	23	the	the	DT
18637	882	24	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	882	25	of	of	IN
18637	882	26	any	any	DT
18637	882	27	other	other	JJ
18637	882	28	State	state	NN
18637	882	29	;	;	:
18637	882	30	nor	nor	CC
18637	882	31	any	any	DT
18637	882	32	State	state	NN
18637	882	33	be	be	VB
18637	882	34	formed	form	VBN
18637	882	35	by	by	IN
18637	882	36	the	the	DT
18637	882	37	Junction	Junction	NNP
18637	882	38	of	of	IN
18637	882	39	two	two	CD
18637	882	40	or	or	CC
18637	882	41	more	more	JJR
18637	882	42	States	States	NNPS
18637	882	43	,	,	,
18637	882	44	or	or	CC
18637	882	45	Parts	Parts	NNPS
18637	882	46	of	of	IN
18637	882	47	States	States	NNP
18637	882	48	,	,	,
18637	882	49	without	without	IN
18637	882	50	the	the	DT
18637	882	51	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	882	52	of	of	IN
18637	882	53	the	the	DT
18637	882	54	Legislatures	Legislatures	NNPS
18637	882	55	of	of	IN
18637	882	56	the	the	DT
18637	882	57	States	States	NNP
18637	882	58	concerned	concern	VBD
18637	882	59	as	as	RB
18637	882	60	well	well	RB
18637	882	61	as	as	IN
18637	882	62	of	of	IN
18637	882	63	the	the	DT
18637	882	64	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	882	65	.	.	.
18637	883	1	The	the	DT
18637	883	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	883	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	883	4	have	have	VB
18637	883	5	Power	power	NN
18637	883	6	to	to	TO
18637	883	7	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	883	8	of	of	IN
18637	883	9	and	and	CC
18637	883	10	make	make	VB
18637	883	11	all	all	DT
18637	883	12	needful	needful	JJ
18637	883	13	Rules	Rules	NNPS
18637	883	14	and	and	CC
18637	883	15	Regulations	Regulations	NNPS
18637	883	16	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	883	17	the	the	DT
18637	883	18	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	883	19	or	or	CC
18637	883	20	other	other	JJ
18637	883	21	Property	Property	NNP
18637	883	22	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	883	23	to	to	IN
18637	883	24	the	the	DT
18637	883	25	United	United	NNP
18637	883	26	States	States	NNP
18637	883	27	;	;	:
18637	883	28	and	and	CC
18637	883	29	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	883	30	in	in	IN
18637	883	31	this	this	DT
18637	883	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	883	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	883	34	be	be	VB
18637	883	35	so	so	RB
18637	883	36	construed	construe	VBN
18637	883	37	as	as	IN
18637	883	38	to	to	IN
18637	883	39	Prejudice	Prejudice	NNP
18637	883	40	any	any	DT
18637	883	41	Claims	claim	NNS
18637	883	42	of	of	IN
18637	883	43	the	the	DT
18637	883	44	United	United	NNP
18637	883	45	States	States	NNP
18637	883	46	,	,	,
18637	883	47	or	or	CC
18637	883	48	of	of	IN
18637	883	49	any	any	DT
18637	883	50	particular	particular	JJ
18637	883	51	State	state	NN
18637	883	52	.	.	.
18637	884	1	Section	section	NN
18637	884	2	.	.	.
18637	885	1	4	4	LS
18637	885	2	.	.	.
18637	886	1	The	the	DT
18637	886	2	United	United	NNP
18637	886	3	States	States	NNP
18637	886	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	886	5	guarantee	guarantee	VB
18637	886	6	to	to	IN
18637	886	7	every	every	DT
18637	886	8	State	State	NNP
18637	886	9	in	in	IN
18637	886	10	this	this	DT
18637	886	11	Union	Union	NNP
18637	886	12	a	a	DT
18637	886	13	Republican	Republican	NNP
18637	886	14	Form	Form	NNP
18637	886	15	of	of	IN
18637	886	16	Government	Government	NNP
18637	886	17	,	,	,
18637	886	18	and	and	CC
18637	886	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	886	20	protect	protect	VB
18637	886	21	each	each	DT
18637	886	22	of	of	IN
18637	886	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	886	24	against	against	IN
18637	886	25	Invasion	Invasion	NNP
18637	886	26	;	;	:
18637	886	27	and	and	CC
18637	886	28	on	on	IN
18637	886	29	Application	application	NN
18637	886	30	of	of	IN
18637	886	31	the	the	DT
18637	886	32	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	886	33	,	,	,
18637	886	34	or	or	CC
18637	886	35	of	of	IN
18637	886	36	the	the	DT
18637	886	37	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	886	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	886	39	when	when	WRB
18637	886	40	the	the	DT
18637	886	41	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	886	42	can	can	MD
18637	886	43	not	not	RB
18637	886	44	be	be	VB
18637	886	45	convened	convene	VBN
18637	886	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	886	47	against	against	IN
18637	886	48	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	886	49	Violence	violence	NN
18637	886	50	.	.	.
18637	887	1	Article	article	NN
18637	887	2	.	.	.
18637	888	1	V.	V.	NNP
18637	888	2	The	the	DT
18637	888	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	888	4	,	,	,
18637	888	5	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	888	6	two	two	CD
18637	888	7	thirds	third	NNS
18637	888	8	of	of	IN
18637	888	9	both	both	DT
18637	888	10	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	888	11	shall	shall	MD
18637	888	12	deem	deem	VB
18637	888	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	888	14	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	888	15	,	,	,
18637	888	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	888	17	propose	propose	VB
18637	888	18	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	888	19	to	to	IN
18637	888	20	this	this	DT
18637	888	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	888	22	,	,	,
18637	888	23	or	or	CC
18637	888	24	,	,	,
18637	888	25	on	on	IN
18637	888	26	the	the	DT
18637	888	27	Application	Application	NNP
18637	888	28	of	of	IN
18637	888	29	the	the	DT
18637	888	30	Legislatures	Legislatures	NNPS
18637	888	31	of	of	IN
18637	888	32	two	two	CD
18637	888	33	thirds	third	NNS
18637	888	34	of	of	IN
18637	888	35	the	the	DT
18637	888	36	several	several	JJ
18637	888	37	States	States	NNPS
18637	888	38	,	,	,
18637	888	39	shall	shall	MD
18637	888	40	call	call	VB
18637	888	41	a	a	DT
18637	888	42	Convention	convention	NN
18637	888	43	for	for	IN
18637	888	44	proposing	propose	VBG
18637	888	45	Amendments	Amendments	NNP
18637	888	46	,	,	,
18637	888	47	which	which	WDT
18637	888	48	,	,	,
18637	888	49	in	in	IN
18637	888	50	either	either	DT
18637	888	51	Case	Case	NNP
18637	888	52	,	,	,
18637	888	53	shall	shall	MD
18637	888	54	be	be	VB
18637	888	55	valid	valid	JJ
18637	888	56	to	to	IN
18637	888	57	all	all	DT
18637	888	58	Intents	Intents	NNPS
18637	888	59	and	and	CC
18637	888	60	Purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	888	61	,	,	,
18637	888	62	as	as	IN
18637	888	63	Part	part	NN
18637	888	64	of	of	IN
18637	888	65	this	this	DT
18637	888	66	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	888	67	,	,	,
18637	888	68	when	when	WRB
18637	888	69	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	888	70	by	by	IN
18637	888	71	the	the	DT
18637	888	72	Legislatures	Legislatures	NNPS
18637	888	73	of	of	IN
18637	888	74	three	three	CD
18637	888	75	fourths	fourth	NNS
18637	888	76	of	of	IN
18637	888	77	the	the	DT
18637	888	78	several	several	JJ
18637	888	79	States	States	NNPS
18637	888	80	,	,	,
18637	888	81	or	or	CC
18637	888	82	by	by	IN
18637	888	83	Conventions	convention	NNS
18637	888	84	in	in	IN
18637	888	85	three	three	CD
18637	888	86	fourths	fourth	NNS
18637	888	87	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	888	88	,	,	,
18637	888	89	as	as	IN
18637	888	90	the	the	DT
18637	888	91	one	one	CD
18637	888	92	or	or	CC
18637	888	93	the	the	DT
18637	888	94	other	other	JJ
18637	888	95	Mode	Mode	NNP
18637	888	96	of	of	IN
18637	888	97	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	888	98	may	may	MD
18637	888	99	be	be	VB
18637	888	100	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	888	101	by	by	IN
18637	888	102	the	the	DT
18637	888	103	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	888	104	;	;	:
18637	888	105	Provided	provide	VBN
18637	888	106	that	that	IN
18637	888	107	no	no	DT
18637	888	108	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	888	109	which	which	WDT
18637	888	110	may	may	MD
18637	888	111	be	be	VB
18637	888	112	made	make	VBN
18637	888	113	prior	prior	RB
18637	888	114	to	to	IN
18637	888	115	the	the	DT
18637	888	116	Year	Year	NNP
18637	888	117	One	one	CD
18637	888	118	thousand	thousand	CD
18637	888	119	eight	eight	CD
18637	888	120	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	888	121	and	and	CC
18637	888	122	eight	eight	CD
18637	888	123	shall	shall	NN
18637	888	124	in	in	IN
18637	888	125	any	any	DT
18637	888	126	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	888	127	affect	affect	VB
18637	888	128	the	the	DT
18637	888	129	first	first	JJ
18637	888	130	and	and	CC
18637	888	131	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	888	132	Clauses	clause	NNS
18637	888	133	in	in	IN
18637	888	134	the	the	DT
18637	888	135	Ninth	Ninth	NNP
18637	888	136	Section	Section	NNP
18637	888	137	of	of	IN
18637	888	138	the	the	DT
18637	888	139	first	first	JJ
18637	888	140	Article	article	NN
18637	888	141	;	;	:
18637	888	142	and	and	CC
18637	888	143	that	that	IN
18637	888	144	no	no	DT
18637	888	145	State	State	NNP
18637	888	146	,	,	,
18637	888	147	without	without	IN
18637	888	148	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	888	149	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	888	150	,	,	,
18637	888	151	shall	shall	MD
18637	888	152	be	be	VB
18637	888	153	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	888	154	of	of	IN
18637	888	155	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	888	156	's	be	VBZ
18637	888	157	equal	equal	JJ
18637	888	158	Suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	888	159	in	in	IN
18637	888	160	the	the	DT
18637	888	161	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	888	162	.	.	.
18637	889	1	Article	article	NN
18637	889	2	.	.	.
18637	890	1	VI	VI	NNP
18637	890	2	.	.	.
18637	891	1	All	all	DT
18637	891	2	Debts	debt	NNS
18637	891	3	contracted	contract	VBD
18637	891	4	and	and	CC
18637	891	5	Engagements	Engagements	NNPS
18637	891	6	entered	enter	VBD
18637	891	7	into	into	IN
18637	891	8	,	,	,
18637	891	9	before	before	IN
18637	891	10	the	the	DT
18637	891	11	Adoption	Adoption	NNP
18637	891	12	of	of	IN
18637	891	13	this	this	DT
18637	891	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	891	15	,	,	,
18637	891	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	891	17	be	be	VB
18637	891	18	as	as	RB
18637	891	19	valid	valid	JJ
18637	891	20	against	against	IN
18637	891	21	the	the	DT
18637	891	22	United	United	NNP
18637	891	23	States	States	NNP
18637	891	24	under	under	IN
18637	891	25	this	this	DT
18637	891	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	891	27	,	,	,
18637	891	28	as	as	IN
18637	891	29	under	under	IN
18637	891	30	the	the	DT
18637	891	31	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	891	32	.	.	.
18637	892	1	This	this	DT
18637	892	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	892	3	,	,	,
18637	892	4	and	and	CC
18637	892	5	the	the	DT
18637	892	6	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	892	7	of	of	IN
18637	892	8	the	the	DT
18637	892	9	United	United	NNP
18637	892	10	States	States	NNP
18637	892	11	which	which	WDT
18637	892	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	892	13	be	be	VB
18637	892	14	made	make	VBN
18637	892	15	in	in	IN
18637	892	16	Pursuance	Pursuance	NNP
18637	892	17	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	892	18	;	;	:
18637	892	19	and	and	CC
18637	892	20	all	all	DT
18637	892	21	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	892	22	made	make	VBD
18637	892	23	,	,	,
18637	892	24	or	or	CC
18637	892	25	which	which	WDT
18637	892	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	892	27	be	be	VB
18637	892	28	made	make	VBN
18637	892	29	,	,	,
18637	892	30	under	under	IN
18637	892	31	the	the	DT
18637	892	32	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	892	33	of	of	IN
18637	892	34	the	the	DT
18637	892	35	United	United	NNP
18637	892	36	States	States	NNP
18637	892	37	,	,	,
18637	892	38	shall	shall	MD
18637	892	39	be	be	VB
18637	892	40	the	the	DT
18637	892	41	supreme	supreme	JJ
18637	892	42	Law	Law	NNP
18637	892	43	of	of	IN
18637	892	44	the	the	DT
18637	892	45	Land	Land	NNP
18637	892	46	;	;	:
18637	892	47	and	and	CC
18637	892	48	the	the	DT
18637	892	49	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	892	50	in	in	IN
18637	892	51	every	every	DT
18637	892	52	State	state	NN
18637	892	53	shall	shall	MD
18637	892	54	be	be	VB
18637	892	55	bound	bind	VBN
18637	892	56	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	892	57	,	,	,
18637	892	58	any	any	DT
18637	892	59	Thing	thing	NN
18637	892	60	in	in	IN
18637	892	61	the	the	DT
18637	892	62	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	892	63	or	or	CC
18637	892	64	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	892	65	of	of	IN
18637	892	66	any	any	DT
18637	892	67	State	State	NNP
18637	892	68	to	to	IN
18637	892	69	the	the	DT
18637	892	70	Contrary	Contrary	NNP
18637	892	71	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	892	72	.	.	.
18637	893	1	The	the	DT
18637	893	2	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	893	3	and	and	CC
18637	893	4	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	893	5	before	before	IN
18637	893	6	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	893	7	,	,	,
18637	893	8	and	and	CC
18637	893	9	the	the	DT
18637	893	10	Members	member	NNS
18637	893	11	of	of	IN
18637	893	12	the	the	DT
18637	893	13	several	several	JJ
18637	893	14	State	State	NNP
18637	893	15	Legislatures	Legislatures	NNPS
18637	893	16	,	,	,
18637	893	17	and	and	CC
18637	893	18	all	all	DT
18637	893	19	executive	executive	JJ
18637	893	20	and	and	CC
18637	893	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	893	22	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	893	23	,	,	,
18637	893	24	both	both	DT
18637	893	25	of	of	IN
18637	893	26	the	the	DT
18637	893	27	United	United	NNP
18637	893	28	States	States	NNP
18637	893	29	and	and	CC
18637	893	30	of	of	IN
18637	893	31	the	the	DT
18637	893	32	several	several	JJ
18637	893	33	States	state	NNS
18637	893	34	,	,	,
18637	893	35	shall	shall	MD
18637	893	36	be	be	VB
18637	893	37	bound	bind	VBN
18637	893	38	by	by	IN
18637	893	39	Oath	Oath	NNP
18637	893	40	or	or	CC
18637	893	41	Affirmation	Affirmation	NNP
18637	893	42	,	,	,
18637	893	43	to	to	TO
18637	893	44	support	support	VB
18637	893	45	this	this	DT
18637	893	46	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	893	47	;	;	:
18637	893	48	but	but	CC
18637	893	49	no	no	DT
18637	893	50	religious	religious	JJ
18637	893	51	Test	test	NN
18637	893	52	shall	shall	MD
18637	893	53	ever	ever	RB
18637	893	54	be	be	VB
18637	893	55	required	require	VBN
18637	893	56	as	as	IN
18637	893	57	a	a	DT
18637	893	58	Qualification	qualification	NN
18637	893	59	to	to	IN
18637	893	60	any	any	DT
18637	893	61	Office	Office	NNP
18637	893	62	or	or	CC
18637	893	63	public	public	NNP
18637	893	64	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	893	65	under	under	IN
18637	893	66	the	the	DT
18637	893	67	United	United	NNP
18637	893	68	States	States	NNP
18637	893	69	.	.	.
18637	894	1	Article	article	NN
18637	894	2	.	.	.
18637	895	1	VII	VII	NNP
18637	895	2	.	.	.
18637	896	1	The	the	DT
18637	896	2	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	896	3	of	of	IN
18637	896	4	the	the	DT
18637	896	5	Conventions	Conventions	NNPS
18637	896	6	of	of	IN
18637	896	7	nine	nine	CD
18637	896	8	States	States	NNPS
18637	896	9	,	,	,
18637	896	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	896	11	be	be	VB
18637	896	12	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	896	13	for	for	IN
18637	896	14	the	the	DT
18637	896	15	Establishment	Establishment	NNP
18637	896	16	of	of	IN
18637	896	17	this	this	DT
18637	896	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	896	19	between	between	IN
18637	896	20	the	the	DT
18637	896	21	States	States	NNP
18637	896	22	so	so	RB
18637	896	23	ratifying	ratify	VBG
18637	896	24	the	the	DT
18637	896	25	Same	same	JJ
18637	896	26	.	.	.
18637	897	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	897	2	Sidenote	sidenote	NN
18637	897	3	:	:	:
18637	897	4	The	the	DT
18637	897	5	Word	Word	NNP
18637	897	6	,	,	,
18637	897	7	"	"	''
18637	897	8	the	the	DT
18637	897	9	,	,	,
18637	897	10	"	"	''
18637	897	11	being	be	VBG
18637	897	12	interlined	interline	VBN
18637	897	13	between	between	IN
18637	897	14	the	the	DT
18637	897	15	seventh	seventh	JJ
18637	897	16	and	and	CC
18637	897	17	eighth	eighth	JJ
18637	897	18	Lines	line	NNS
18637	897	19	of	of	IN
18637	897	20	the	the	DT
18637	897	21	first	first	JJ
18637	897	22	Page	Page	NNP
18637	897	23	,	,	,
18637	897	24	The	the	DT
18637	897	25	Word	Word	NNP
18637	897	26	"	"	``
18637	897	27	Thirty	Thirty	NNP
18637	897	28	"	"	''
18637	897	29	being	be	VBG
18637	897	30	partly	partly	RB
18637	897	31	written	write	VBN
18637	897	32	on	on	IN
18637	897	33	an	an	DT
18637	897	34	Erazure	Erazure	NNP
18637	897	35	in	in	IN
18637	897	36	the	the	DT
18637	897	37	fifteenth	fifteenth	JJ
18637	897	38	Line	Line	NNP
18637	897	39	of	of	IN
18637	897	40	the	the	DT
18637	897	41	first	first	JJ
18637	897	42	Page	Page	NNP
18637	897	43	,	,	,
18637	897	44	The	the	DT
18637	897	45	Words	word	NNS
18637	897	46	"	"	''
18637	897	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	897	48	tried	try	VBN
18637	897	49	"	"	''
18637	897	50	being	be	VBG
18637	897	51	interlined	interline	VBN
18637	897	52	between	between	IN
18637	897	53	the	the	DT
18637	897	54	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	897	55	second	second	JJ
18637	897	56	and	and	CC
18637	897	57	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	897	58	third	third	JJ
18637	897	59	Lines	line	NNS
18637	897	60	of	of	IN
18637	897	61	the	the	DT
18637	897	62	first	first	JJ
18637	897	63	Page	Page	NNP
18637	897	64	and	and	CC
18637	897	65	the	the	DT
18637	897	66	Word	Word	NNP
18637	897	67	"	"	``
18637	897	68	the	the	DT
18637	897	69	"	"	''
18637	897	70	being	be	VBG
18637	897	71	interlined	interline	VBN
18637	897	72	between	between	IN
18637	897	73	the	the	DT
18637	897	74	forty	forty	CD
18637	897	75	third	third	JJ
18637	897	76	and	and	CC
18637	897	77	forty	forty	CD
18637	897	78	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	897	79	Lines	line	NNS
18637	897	80	of	of	IN
18637	897	81	the	the	DT
18637	897	82	second	second	JJ
18637	897	83	Page	Page	NNP
18637	897	84	.	.	.
18637	898	1	Attest	Attest	NNP
18637	898	2	William	William	NNP
18637	898	3	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	898	4	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	898	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	898	6	done	do	VBN
18637	898	7	in	in	IN
18637	898	8	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	898	9	by	by	IN
18637	898	10	the	the	DT
18637	898	11	Unanimous	Unanimous	NNP
18637	898	12	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	898	13	of	of	IN
18637	898	14	the	the	DT
18637	898	15	States	States	NNPS
18637	898	16	present	present	VBP
18637	898	17	the	the	DT
18637	898	18	Seventeenth	seventeenth	JJ
18637	898	19	Day	Day	NNP
18637	898	20	of	of	IN
18637	898	21	September	September	NNP
18637	898	22	in	in	IN
18637	898	23	the	the	DT
18637	898	24	Year	Year	NNP
18637	898	25	of	of	IN
18637	898	26	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	898	27	Lord	Lord	NNP
18637	898	28	one	one	CD
18637	898	29	thousand	thousand	CD
18637	898	30	seven	seven	CD
18637	898	31	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	898	32	and	and	CC
18637	898	33	Eighty	eighty	CD
18637	898	34	seven	seven	CD
18637	898	35	and	and	CC
18637	898	36	of	of	IN
18637	898	37	the	the	DT
18637	898	38	Independence	Independence	NNP
18637	898	39	of	of	IN
18637	898	40	the	the	DT
18637	898	41	United	United	NNP
18637	898	42	States	States	NNP
18637	898	43	of	of	IN
18637	898	44	America	America	NNP
18637	898	45	the	the	DT
18637	898	46	Twelfth	Twelfth	NNP
18637	898	47	In	in	IN
18637	898	48	witness	witness	NN
18637	898	49	whereof	whereof	IN
18637	898	50	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	898	51	have	have	VBP
18637	898	52	hereunto	hereunto	NNS
18637	898	53	subscribed	subscribe	VBN
18637	898	54	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	898	55	Names	name	NNS
18637	898	56	,	,	,
18637	898	57	Go	go	VB
18637	898	58	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	898	59	--	--	:
18637	898	60	Presidt	Presidt	NNP
18637	898	61	and	and	CC
18637	898	62	deputy	deputy	NN
18637	898	63	from	from	IN
18637	898	64	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	898	65	New	New	NNP
18637	898	66	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	898	67	{	{	-LRB-
18637	898	68	John	John	NNP
18637	898	69	Langdon	Langdon	NNP
18637	898	70	{	{	-LRB-
18637	898	71	Nicholas	Nicholas	NNP
18637	898	72	Gilman	Gilman	NNP
18637	898	73	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	898	74	{	{	-LRB-
18637	898	75	Nathaniel	Nathaniel	NNP
18637	898	76	Gorham	Gorham	NNP
18637	898	77	{	{	-LRB-
18637	898	78	Rufus	Rufus	NNP
18637	898	79	King	King	NNP
18637	898	80	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	898	81	{	{	-LRB-
18637	898	82	Wm	Wm	NNP
18637	898	83	:	:	:
18637	898	84	Saml	Saml	NNP
18637	898	85	.	.	.
18637	899	1	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	899	2	{	{	-LRB-
18637	899	3	Roger	Roger	NNP
18637	899	4	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	899	5	New	New	NNP
18637	899	6	York	York	NNP
18637	899	7	:	:	:
18637	899	8	:	:	:
18637	899	9	:	:	:
18637	899	10	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	899	11	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	899	12	{	{	-LRB-
18637	899	13	Wil	Wil	NNP
18637	899	14	:	:	:
18637	899	15	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
18637	899	16	New	New	NNP
18637	899	17	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	899	18	{	{	-LRB-
18637	899	19	David	David	NNP
18637	899	20	Brearley	Brearley	NNP
18637	899	21	.	.	.
18637	900	1	{	{	-LRB-
18637	900	2	Wm	Wm	NNP
18637	900	3	.	.	.
18637	901	1	Paterson	Paterson	NNP
18637	901	2	.	.	.
18637	902	1	{	{	-LRB-
18637	902	2	Jona	Jona	NNP
18637	902	3	:	:	:
18637	902	4	Dayton	Dayton	NNP
18637	902	5	{	{	-LRB-
18637	902	6	B	B	NNP
18637	902	7	Franklin	Franklin	NNP
18637	902	8	{	{	-LRB-
18637	902	9	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	902	10	Mifflin	Mifflin	NNP
18637	902	11	{	{	-LRB-
18637	902	12	Robt	Robt	NNP
18637	902	13	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	902	14	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	902	15	{	{	-LRB-
18637	902	16	Geo	Geo	NNP
18637	902	17	.	.	.
18637	903	1	Clymer	Clymer	NNP
18637	903	2	{	{	-LRB-
18637	903	3	Thos	Thos	NNP
18637	903	4	.	.	.
18637	904	1	FitzSimons	FitzSimons	NNP
18637	904	2	{	{	-LRB-
18637	904	3	Jared	Jared	NNP
18637	904	4	Ingersoll	Ingersoll	NNP
18637	904	5	{	{	-LRB-
18637	904	6	James	James	NNP
18637	904	7	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	904	8	{	{	-LRB-
18637	904	9	Gouv	Gouv	NNP
18637	904	10	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	904	11	{	{	-LRB-
18637	904	12	Geo	Geo	NNP
18637	904	13	:	:	:
18637	904	14	Read	read	VB
18637	904	15	{	{	-LRB-
18637	904	16	Gunning	Gunning	NNP
18637	904	17	Bedford	Bedford	NNP
18637	904	18	jun	jun	NNP
18637	904	19	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	904	20	{	{	-LRB-
18637	904	21	John	John	NNP
18637	904	22	Dickinson	Dickinson	NNP
18637	904	23	{	{	-LRB-
18637	904	24	Richard	Richard	NNP
18637	904	25	Bassett	Bassett	NNP
18637	904	26	{	{	-LRB-
18637	904	27	Jaco	Jaco	NNP
18637	904	28	:	:	:
18637	904	29	Broom	Broom	NNP
18637	904	30	{	{	-LRB-
18637	904	31	James	James	NNP
18637	904	32	McHenry	McHenry	NNP
18637	904	33	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	904	34	{	{	-LRB-
18637	904	35	Dan	Dan	NNP
18637	904	36	of	of	IN
18637	904	37	St	St	NNP
18637	904	38	Thos	Thos	NNP
18637	904	39	.	.	.
18637	905	1	Jenifer	Jenifer	NNP
18637	905	2	{	{	-LRB-
18637	905	3	Danl	Danl	NNP
18637	905	4	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	905	5	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	905	6	{	{	-LRB-
18637	905	7	John	John	NNP
18637	905	8	Blair--	Blair--	NNP
18637	905	9	{	{	-LRB-
18637	905	10	James	James	NNP
18637	905	11	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	905	12	Jr.	Jr.	NNP
18637	905	13	{	{	-LRB-
18637	905	14	Wm	Wm	NNP
18637	905	15	.	.	.
18637	906	1	Blount	Blount	NNP
18637	906	2	North	North	NNP
18637	906	3	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	906	4	{	{	-LRB-
18637	906	5	Richd	Richd	NNP
18637	906	6	.	.	.
18637	907	1	Dobbs	dobb	NNS
18637	907	2	Spaight	Spaight	NNP
18637	907	3	.	.	.
18637	908	1	{	{	-LRB-
18637	908	2	Hu	Hu	NNP
18637	908	3	Williamson	Williamson	NNP
18637	908	4	{	{	-LRB-
18637	908	5	J.	J.	NNP
18637	908	6	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	908	7	South	South	NNP
18637	908	8	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	908	9	{	{	-LRB-
18637	908	10	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	908	11	Cotesworth	Cotesworth	NNP
18637	908	12	Pinckney	Pinckney	NNP
18637	908	13	{	{	-LRB-
18637	908	14	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	908	15	Pinckney	Pinckney	NNP
18637	908	16	{	{	-LRB-
18637	908	17	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	908	18	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	908	19	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	908	20	{	{	-LRB-
18637	908	21	William	William	NNP
18637	908	22	Few	Few	NNP
18637	908	23	{	{	-LRB-
18637	908	24	Abr	Abr	NNP
18637	908	25	Baldwin	baldwin	JJ
18637	908	26	*	*	NFP
18637	908	27	*	*	NFP
18637	908	28	*	*	NFP
18637	908	29	*	*	NFP
18637	908	30	*	*	NFP
18637	908	31	In	in	IN
18637	908	32	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	908	33	Monday	Monday	NNP
18637	908	34	,	,	,
18637	908	35	September	September	NNP
18637	908	36	17th	17th	NN
18637	908	37	1787	1787	CD
18637	908	38	.	.	.
18637	909	1	Present	present	JJ
18637	909	2	The	the	DT
18637	909	3	States	States	NNP
18637	909	4	of	of	IN
18637	909	5	New	New	NNP
18637	909	6	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	909	7	,	,	,
18637	909	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	909	9	,	,	,
18637	909	10	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	909	11	,	,	,
18637	909	12	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	909	13	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	909	14	from	from	IN
18637	909	15	New	New	NNP
18637	909	16	York	York	NNP
18637	909	17	,	,	,
18637	909	18	New	New	NNP
18637	909	19	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	909	20	,	,	,
18637	909	21	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	909	22	,	,	,
18637	909	23	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	909	24	,	,	,
18637	909	25	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	909	26	,	,	,
18637	909	27	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	909	28	,	,	,
18637	909	29	North	North	NNP
18637	909	30	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	909	31	,	,	,
18637	909	32	South	South	NNP
18637	909	33	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	909	34	and	and	CC
18637	909	35	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	909	36	.	.	.
18637	910	1	Resolved	resolve	VBN
18637	910	2	,	,	,
18637	910	3	That	that	IN
18637	910	4	the	the	DT
18637	910	5	preceeding	preceede	VBG
18637	910	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	910	7	be	be	VB
18637	910	8	laid	lay	VBN
18637	910	9	before	before	IN
18637	910	10	the	the	DT
18637	910	11	United	United	NNP
18637	910	12	States	States	NNP
18637	910	13	in	in	IN
18637	910	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	910	15	assembled	assemble	VBD
18637	910	16	,	,	,
18637	910	17	and	and	CC
18637	910	18	that	that	IN
18637	910	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	910	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	910	21	the	the	DT
18637	910	22	Opinion	Opinion	NNP
18637	910	23	of	of	IN
18637	910	24	this	this	DT
18637	910	25	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	910	26	,	,	,
18637	910	27	that	that	IN
18637	910	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	910	29	should	should	MD
18637	910	30	afterwards	afterwards	RB
18637	910	31	be	be	VB
18637	910	32	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	910	33	to	to	IN
18637	910	34	a	a	DT
18637	910	35	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	910	36	of	of	IN
18637	910	37	Delegates	Delegates	NNPS
18637	910	38	,	,	,
18637	910	39	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	910	40	in	in	IN
18637	910	41	each	each	DT
18637	910	42	State	State	NNP
18637	910	43	by	by	IN
18637	910	44	the	the	DT
18637	910	45	People	People	NNS
18637	910	46	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	910	47	,	,	,
18637	910	48	under	under	IN
18637	910	49	the	the	DT
18637	910	50	Recommendation	Recommendation	NNP
18637	910	51	of	of	IN
18637	910	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	910	53	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	910	54	,	,	,
18637	910	55	for	for	IN
18637	910	56	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	910	57	Assent	Assent	NNP
18637	910	58	and	and	CC
18637	910	59	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	910	60	;	;	:
18637	910	61	and	and	CC
18637	910	62	that	that	IN
18637	910	63	each	each	DT
18637	910	64	Convention	convention	NN
18637	910	65	assenting	assent	VBG
18637	910	66	to	to	IN
18637	910	67	,	,	,
18637	910	68	and	and	CC
18637	910	69	ratifying	ratify	VBG
18637	910	70	the	the	DT
18637	910	71	Same	same	JJ
18637	910	72	,	,	,
18637	910	73	should	should	MD
18637	910	74	give	give	VB
18637	910	75	Notice	Notice	NNP
18637	910	76	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	910	77	to	to	IN
18637	910	78	the	the	DT
18637	910	79	United	United	NNP
18637	910	80	States	States	NNP
18637	910	81	in	in	IN
18637	910	82	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	910	83	assembled	assemble	VBD
18637	910	84	.	.	.
18637	911	1	Resolved	resolve	VBN
18637	911	2	,	,	,
18637	911	3	That	that	IN
18637	911	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	911	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	911	6	the	the	DT
18637	911	7	Opinion	Opinion	NNP
18637	911	8	of	of	IN
18637	911	9	this	this	DT
18637	911	10	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	911	11	,	,	,
18637	911	12	that	that	IN
18637	911	13	as	as	RB
18637	911	14	soon	soon	RB
18637	911	15	as	as	IN
18637	911	16	the	the	DT
18637	911	17	Conventions	Conventions	NNPS
18637	911	18	of	of	IN
18637	911	19	nine	nine	CD
18637	911	20	States	States	NNPS
18637	911	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	911	22	have	have	VB
18637	911	23	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	911	24	this	this	DT
18637	911	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	911	26	,	,	,
18637	911	27	the	the	DT
18637	911	28	United	United	NNP
18637	911	29	States	States	NNP
18637	911	30	in	in	IN
18637	911	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	911	32	assembled	assemble	VBD
18637	911	33	should	should	MD
18637	911	34	fix	fix	VB
18637	911	35	a	a	DT
18637	911	36	Day	day	NN
18637	911	37	on	on	IN
18637	911	38	which	which	WDT
18637	911	39	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	911	40	should	should	MD
18637	911	41	be	be	VB
18637	911	42	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	911	43	by	by	IN
18637	911	44	the	the	DT
18637	911	45	States	state	NNS
18637	911	46	which	which	WDT
18637	911	47	shall	shall	MD
18637	911	48	have	have	VB
18637	911	49	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	911	50	the	the	DT
18637	911	51	same	same	JJ
18637	911	52	,	,	,
18637	911	53	and	and	CC
18637	911	54	a	a	DT
18637	911	55	Day	day	NN
18637	911	56	on	on	IN
18637	911	57	which	which	WDT
18637	911	58	the	the	DT
18637	911	59	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	911	60	should	should	MD
18637	911	61	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	911	62	to	to	TO
18637	911	63	vote	vote	VB
18637	911	64	for	for	IN
18637	911	65	the	the	DT
18637	911	66	President	President	NNP
18637	911	67	,	,	,
18637	911	68	and	and	CC
18637	911	69	the	the	DT
18637	911	70	Time	Time	NNP
18637	911	71	and	and	CC
18637	911	72	Place	Place	NNP
18637	911	73	for	for	IN
18637	911	74	commencing	commence	VBG
18637	911	75	Proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	911	76	under	under	IN
18637	911	77	this	this	DT
18637	911	78	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	911	79	.	.	.
18637	912	1	That	that	IN
18637	912	2	after	after	IN
18637	912	3	such	such	JJ
18637	912	4	Publication	publication	NN
18637	912	5	the	the	DT
18637	912	6	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	912	7	should	should	MD
18637	912	8	be	be	VB
18637	912	9	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	912	10	,	,	,
18637	912	11	and	and	CC
18637	912	12	the	the	DT
18637	912	13	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	912	14	and	and	CC
18637	912	15	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	912	16	elected	elect	VBD
18637	912	17	:	:	:
18637	912	18	That	that	IN
18637	912	19	the	the	DT
18637	912	20	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	912	21	should	should	MD
18637	912	22	meet	meet	VB
18637	912	23	on	on	IN
18637	912	24	the	the	DT
18637	912	25	Day	day	NN
18637	912	26	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	912	27	for	for	IN
18637	912	28	the	the	DT
18637	912	29	Election	Election	NNP
18637	912	30	of	of	IN
18637	912	31	the	the	DT
18637	912	32	President	President	NNP
18637	912	33	,	,	,
18637	912	34	and	and	CC
18637	912	35	should	should	MD
18637	912	36	transmit	transmit	VB
18637	912	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	912	38	Votes	vote	NNS
18637	912	39	certified	certify	VBN
18637	912	40	,	,	,
18637	912	41	signed	sign	VBN
18637	912	42	,	,	,
18637	912	43	sealed	seal	VBN
18637	912	44	and	and	CC
18637	912	45	directed	direct	VBN
18637	912	46	,	,	,
18637	912	47	as	as	IN
18637	912	48	the	the	DT
18637	912	49	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	912	50	requires	require	VBZ
18637	912	51	,	,	,
18637	912	52	to	to	IN
18637	912	53	the	the	DT
18637	912	54	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	912	55	of	of	IN
18637	912	56	the	the	DT
18637	912	57	United	United	NNP
18637	912	58	States	States	NNP
18637	912	59	in	in	IN
18637	912	60	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	912	61	assembled	assemble	VBD
18637	912	62	,	,	,
18637	912	63	that	that	IN
18637	912	64	the	the	DT
18637	912	65	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	912	66	and	and	CC
18637	912	67	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	912	68	should	should	MD
18637	912	69	convene	convene	VB
18637	912	70	at	at	IN
18637	912	71	the	the	DT
18637	912	72	Time	Time	NNP
18637	912	73	and	and	CC
18637	912	74	Place	Place	NNP
18637	912	75	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	912	76	;	;	:
18637	912	77	that	that	IN
18637	912	78	the	the	DT
18637	912	79	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	912	80	should	should	MD
18637	912	81	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	912	82	a	a	DT
18637	912	83	President	President	NNP
18637	912	84	of	of	IN
18637	912	85	the	the	DT
18637	912	86	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	912	87	,	,	,
18637	912	88	for	for	IN
18637	912	89	the	the	DT
18637	912	90	sole	sole	JJ
18637	912	91	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	912	92	of	of	IN
18637	912	93	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	912	94	,	,	,
18637	912	95	opening	opening	NN
18637	912	96	and	and	CC
18637	912	97	counting	count	VBG
18637	912	98	the	the	DT
18637	912	99	Votes	Votes	NNPS
18637	912	100	for	for	IN
18637	912	101	President	President	NNP
18637	912	102	;	;	:
18637	912	103	and	and	CC
18637	912	104	,	,	,
18637	912	105	that	that	IN
18637	912	106	after	after	IN
18637	912	107	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	912	108	shall	shall	MD
18637	912	109	be	be	VB
18637	912	110	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	912	111	,	,	,
18637	912	112	the	the	DT
18637	912	113	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	912	114	,	,	,
18637	912	115	together	together	RB
18637	912	116	with	with	IN
18637	912	117	the	the	DT
18637	912	118	President	President	NNP
18637	912	119	,	,	,
18637	912	120	should	should	MD
18637	912	121	,	,	,
18637	912	122	without	without	IN
18637	912	123	Delay	Delay	NNP
18637	912	124	,	,	,
18637	912	125	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	912	126	to	to	TO
18637	912	127	execute	execute	VB
18637	912	128	this	this	DT
18637	912	129	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	912	130	.	.	.
18637	913	1	By	by	IN
18637	913	2	the	the	DT
18637	913	3	Unanimous	Unanimous	NNP
18637	913	4	Order	Order	NNP
18637	913	5	of	of	IN
18637	913	6	the	the	DT
18637	913	7	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	913	8	Go	Go	NNP
18637	913	9	.	.	.
18637	914	1	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	914	2	Presidt	Presidt	NNP
18637	914	3	W.	W.	NNP
18637	914	4	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	914	5	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	914	6	.	.	.
18637	915	1	AMENDMENTS	amendment	NNS
18637	915	2	TO	to	IN
18637	915	3	THE	the	DT
18637	915	4	CONSTITUTION	CONSTITUTION	NNP
18637	915	5	OF	of	IN
18637	915	6	THE	the	DT
18637	915	7	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	915	8	STATES	state	NNS
18637	915	9	OF	of	IN
18637	915	10	AMERICA	america	JJ
18637	915	11	ARTICLES	articles	NN
18637	915	12	IN	in	IN
18637	915	13	ADDITION	addition	NN
18637	915	14	TO	to	IN
18637	915	15	,	,	,
18637	915	16	AND	and	CC
18637	915	17	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	915	18	OF	of	IN
18637	915	19	,	,	,
18637	915	20	THE	the	DT
18637	915	21	CONSTITUTION	CONSTITUTION	NNP
18637	915	22	OF	of	IN
18637	915	23	THE	the	DT
18637	915	24	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	915	25	STATES	state	NNS
18637	915	26	OF	of	IN
18637	915	27	AMERICA	AMERICA	NNP
18637	915	28	,	,	,
18637	915	29	PROPOSED	propose	VBN
18637	915	30	BY	by	IN
18637	915	31	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	915	32	,	,	,
18637	915	33	AND	and	CC
18637	915	34	RATIFIED	ratified	NN
18637	915	35	BY	by	IN
18637	915	36	THE	the	DT
18637	915	37	SEVERAL	several	JJ
18637	915	38	STATES	state	NNS
18637	915	39	,	,	,
18637	915	40	PURSUANT	PURSUANT	NNP
18637	915	41	TO	to	IN
18637	915	42	THE	the	DT
18637	915	43	FIFTH	FIFTH	NNP
18637	915	44	ARTICLE	article	NN
18637	915	45	OF	of	IN
18637	915	46	THE	the	DT
18637	915	47	ORIGINAL	original	JJ
18637	915	48	CONSTITUTION	CONSTITUTION	NNP
18637	915	49	.	.	.
18637	916	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	916	2	a	a	DT
18637	916	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	916	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	916	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	916	6	I.	i.	NN
18637	917	1	]	]	-RRB-
18637	917	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	917	3	b	b	NN
18637	917	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	917	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	917	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	917	7	make	make	VB
18637	917	8	no	no	DT
18637	917	9	law	law	NN
18637	917	10	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	917	11	an	an	DT
18637	917	12	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	917	13	of	of	IN
18637	917	14	religion	religion	NN
18637	917	15	,	,	,
18637	917	16	or	or	CC
18637	917	17	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	917	18	the	the	DT
18637	917	19	free	free	JJ
18637	917	20	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	917	21	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	917	22	;	;	:
18637	917	23	or	or	CC
18637	917	24	abridging	abridge	VBG
18637	917	25	the	the	DT
18637	917	26	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	917	27	of	of	IN
18637	917	28	speech	speech	NN
18637	917	29	,	,	,
18637	917	30	or	or	CC
18637	917	31	of	of	IN
18637	917	32	the	the	DT
18637	917	33	press	press	NN
18637	917	34	;	;	:
18637	917	35	or	or	CC
18637	917	36	the	the	DT
18637	917	37	right	right	NN
18637	917	38	of	of	IN
18637	917	39	the	the	DT
18637	917	40	people	people	NNS
18637	917	41	peaceably	peaceably	RB
18637	917	42	to	to	TO
18637	917	43	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	917	44	,	,	,
18637	917	45	and	and	CC
18637	917	46	to	to	TO
18637	917	47	petition	petition	VB
18637	917	48	the	the	DT
18637	917	49	Government	Government	NNP
18637	917	50	for	for	IN
18637	917	51	a	a	DT
18637	917	52	redress	redress	NN
18637	917	53	of	of	IN
18637	917	54	grievances	grievance	NNS
18637	917	55	.	.	.
18637	918	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	918	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	918	3	II	II	NNP
18637	918	4	.	.	.
18637	918	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	919	1	A	a	DT
18637	919	2	well	well	RB
18637	919	3	regulated	regulated	JJ
18637	919	4	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	919	5	,	,	,
18637	919	6	being	be	VBG
18637	919	7	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	919	8	to	to	IN
18637	919	9	the	the	DT
18637	919	10	security	security	NN
18637	919	11	of	of	IN
18637	919	12	a	a	DT
18637	919	13	free	free	JJ
18637	919	14	State	State	NNP
18637	919	15	,	,	,
18637	919	16	the	the	DT
18637	919	17	right	right	NN
18637	919	18	of	of	IN
18637	919	19	the	the	DT
18637	919	20	people	people	NNS
18637	919	21	to	to	TO
18637	919	22	keep	keep	VB
18637	919	23	and	and	CC
18637	919	24	bear	bear	VB
18637	919	25	Arms	arm	NNS
18637	919	26	,	,	,
18637	919	27	shall	shall	MD
18637	919	28	not	not	RB
18637	919	29	be	be	VB
18637	919	30	infringed	infringe	VBN
18637	919	31	.	.	.
18637	920	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	920	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	920	3	III	iii	CD
18637	920	4	.	.	.
18637	920	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	921	1	No	no	DT
18637	921	2	Soldier	soldier	NN
18637	921	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	921	4	,	,	,
18637	921	5	in	in	IN
18637	921	6	time	time	NN
18637	921	7	of	of	IN
18637	921	8	peace	peace	NN
18637	921	9	be	be	VB
18637	921	10	quartered	quarter	VBN
18637	921	11	in	in	IN
18637	921	12	any	any	DT
18637	921	13	house	house	NN
18637	921	14	,	,	,
18637	921	15	without	without	IN
18637	921	16	the	the	DT
18637	921	17	consent	consent	NN
18637	921	18	of	of	IN
18637	921	19	the	the	DT
18637	921	20	Owner	Owner	NNP
18637	921	21	,	,	,
18637	921	22	nor	nor	CC
18637	921	23	in	in	IN
18637	921	24	time	time	NN
18637	921	25	of	of	IN
18637	921	26	war	war	NN
18637	921	27	,	,	,
18637	921	28	but	but	CC
18637	921	29	in	in	IN
18637	921	30	a	a	DT
18637	921	31	manner	manner	NN
18637	921	32	to	to	TO
18637	921	33	be	be	VB
18637	921	34	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	921	35	by	by	IN
18637	921	36	law	law	NN
18637	921	37	.	.	.
18637	922	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	922	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	922	3	IV	IV	NNP
18637	922	4	.	.	.
18637	922	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	923	1	The	the	DT
18637	923	2	right	right	NN
18637	923	3	of	of	IN
18637	923	4	the	the	DT
18637	923	5	people	people	NNS
18637	923	6	to	to	TO
18637	923	7	be	be	VB
18637	923	8	secure	secure	JJ
18637	923	9	in	in	IN
18637	923	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	923	11	persons	person	NNS
18637	923	12	,	,	,
18637	923	13	houses	house	NNS
18637	923	14	,	,	,
18637	923	15	papers	paper	NNS
18637	923	16	,	,	,
18637	923	17	and	and	CC
18637	923	18	effects	effect	NNS
18637	923	19	,	,	,
18637	923	20	against	against	IN
18637	923	21	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	923	22	searches	search	NNS
18637	923	23	and	and	CC
18637	923	24	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	923	25	,	,	,
18637	923	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	923	27	not	not	RB
18637	923	28	be	be	VB
18637	923	29	violated	violate	VBN
18637	923	30	,	,	,
18637	923	31	and	and	CC
18637	923	32	no	no	DT
18637	923	33	Warrants	Warrants	NNP
18637	923	34	shall	shall	MD
18637	923	35	issue	issue	VB
18637	923	36	,	,	,
18637	923	37	but	but	CC
18637	923	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	923	39	probable	probable	JJ
18637	923	40	cause	cause	NN
18637	923	41	,	,	,
18637	923	42	supported	support	VBN
18637	923	43	by	by	IN
18637	923	44	Oath	Oath	NNP
18637	923	45	or	or	CC
18637	923	46	affirmation	affirmation	NN
18637	923	47	,	,	,
18637	923	48	and	and	CC
18637	923	49	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	923	50	describing	describe	VBG
18637	923	51	the	the	DT
18637	923	52	place	place	NN
18637	923	53	to	to	TO
18637	923	54	be	be	VB
18637	923	55	searched	search	VBN
18637	923	56	,	,	,
18637	923	57	and	and	CC
18637	923	58	the	the	DT
18637	923	59	persons	person	NNS
18637	923	60	or	or	CC
18637	923	61	things	thing	NNS
18637	923	62	to	to	TO
18637	923	63	be	be	VB
18637	923	64	seized	seize	VBN
18637	923	65	.	.	.
18637	924	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	924	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	924	3	V.	V.	NNP
18637	924	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	924	5	No	no	DT
18637	924	6	person	person	NN
18637	924	7	shall	shall	MD
18637	924	8	be	be	VB
18637	924	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	924	10	to	to	TO
18637	924	11	answer	answer	VB
18637	924	12	for	for	IN
18637	924	13	a	a	DT
18637	924	14	capital	capital	NN
18637	924	15	,	,	,
18637	924	16	or	or	CC
18637	924	17	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	924	18	infamous	infamous	JJ
18637	924	19	crime	crime	NN
18637	924	20	,	,	,
18637	924	21	unless	unless	IN
18637	924	22	on	on	IN
18637	924	23	a	a	DT
18637	924	24	presentment	presentment	NN
18637	924	25	or	or	CC
18637	924	26	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	924	27	of	of	IN
18637	924	28	a	a	DT
18637	924	29	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	924	30	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	924	31	,	,	,
18637	924	32	except	except	IN
18637	924	33	in	in	IN
18637	924	34	cases	case	NNS
18637	924	35	arising	arise	VBG
18637	924	36	in	in	IN
18637	924	37	the	the	DT
18637	924	38	land	land	NN
18637	924	39	or	or	CC
18637	924	40	naval	naval	JJ
18637	924	41	forces	force	NNS
18637	924	42	,	,	,
18637	924	43	or	or	CC
18637	924	44	in	in	IN
18637	924	45	the	the	DT
18637	924	46	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	924	47	,	,	,
18637	924	48	when	when	WRB
18637	924	49	in	in	IN
18637	924	50	actual	actual	JJ
18637	924	51	service	service	NN
18637	924	52	in	in	IN
18637	924	53	time	time	NN
18637	924	54	of	of	IN
18637	924	55	War	War	NNP
18637	924	56	or	or	CC
18637	924	57	public	public	JJ
18637	924	58	danger	danger	NN
18637	924	59	;	;	:
18637	924	60	nor	nor	CC
18637	924	61	shall	shall	MD
18637	924	62	any	any	DT
18637	924	63	person	person	NN
18637	924	64	be	be	VB
18637	924	65	subject	subject	JJ
18637	924	66	for	for	IN
18637	924	67	the	the	DT
18637	924	68	same	same	JJ
18637	924	69	offence	offence	NN
18637	924	70	to	to	TO
18637	924	71	be	be	VB
18637	924	72	twice	twice	RB
18637	924	73	put	put	VBN
18637	924	74	in	in	IN
18637	924	75	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	924	76	of	of	IN
18637	924	77	life	life	NN
18637	924	78	or	or	CC
18637	924	79	limb	limb	NN
18637	924	80	;	;	,
18637	924	81	nor	nor	CC
18637	924	82	shall	shall	MD
18637	924	83	be	be	VB
18637	924	84	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	924	85	in	in	IN
18637	924	86	any	any	DT
18637	924	87	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	924	88	case	case	NN
18637	924	89	to	to	TO
18637	924	90	be	be	VB
18637	924	91	a	a	DT
18637	924	92	witness	witness	NN
18637	924	93	against	against	IN
18637	924	94	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	924	95	,	,	,
18637	924	96	nor	nor	CC
18637	924	97	be	be	VB
18637	924	98	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	924	99	of	of	IN
18637	924	100	life	life	NN
18637	924	101	,	,	,
18637	924	102	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	924	103	,	,	,
18637	924	104	or	or	CC
18637	924	105	property	property	NN
18637	924	106	,	,	,
18637	924	107	without	without	IN
18637	924	108	due	due	JJ
18637	924	109	process	process	NN
18637	924	110	of	of	IN
18637	924	111	law	law	NN
18637	924	112	;	;	:
18637	924	113	nor	nor	CC
18637	924	114	shall	shall	MD
18637	924	115	private	private	JJ
18637	924	116	property	property	NN
18637	924	117	be	be	VB
18637	924	118	taken	take	VBN
18637	924	119	for	for	IN
18637	924	120	public	public	JJ
18637	924	121	use	use	NN
18637	924	122	,	,	,
18637	924	123	without	without	IN
18637	924	124	just	just	RB
18637	924	125	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	924	126	.	.	.
18637	925	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	925	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	925	3	VI	VI	NNP
18637	925	4	.	.	.
18637	925	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	926	1	In	in	IN
18637	926	2	all	all	DT
18637	926	3	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	926	4	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	926	5	,	,	,
18637	926	6	the	the	DT
18637	926	7	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	926	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	926	9	enjoy	enjoy	VB
18637	926	10	the	the	DT
18637	926	11	right	right	NN
18637	926	12	to	to	IN
18637	926	13	a	a	DT
18637	926	14	speedy	speedy	JJ
18637	926	15	and	and	CC
18637	926	16	public	public	JJ
18637	926	17	trial	trial	NN
18637	926	18	,	,	,
18637	926	19	by	by	IN
18637	926	20	an	an	DT
18637	926	21	impartial	impartial	JJ
18637	926	22	jury	jury	NN
18637	926	23	of	of	IN
18637	926	24	the	the	DT
18637	926	25	State	State	NNP
18637	926	26	and	and	CC
18637	926	27	district	district	NN
18637	926	28	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	926	29	the	the	DT
18637	926	30	crime	crime	NN
18637	926	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	926	32	have	have	VB
18637	926	33	been	be	VBN
18637	926	34	committed	commit	VBN
18637	926	35	,	,	,
18637	926	36	which	which	WDT
18637	926	37	district	district	NN
18637	926	38	shall	shall	MD
18637	926	39	have	have	VB
18637	926	40	been	be	VBN
18637	926	41	previously	previously	RB
18637	926	42	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	926	43	by	by	IN
18637	926	44	law	law	NN
18637	926	45	,	,	,
18637	926	46	and	and	CC
18637	926	47	to	to	TO
18637	926	48	be	be	VB
18637	926	49	informed	inform	VBN
18637	926	50	of	of	IN
18637	926	51	the	the	DT
18637	926	52	nature	nature	NN
18637	926	53	and	and	CC
18637	926	54	cause	cause	NN
18637	926	55	of	of	IN
18637	926	56	the	the	DT
18637	926	57	accusation	accusation	NN
18637	926	58	;	;	:
18637	926	59	to	to	TO
18637	926	60	be	be	VB
18637	926	61	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	926	62	with	with	IN
18637	926	63	the	the	DT
18637	926	64	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	926	65	against	against	IN
18637	926	66	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	926	67	;	;	:
18637	926	68	to	to	TO
18637	926	69	have	have	VB
18637	926	70	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	926	71	process	process	NN
18637	926	72	for	for	IN
18637	926	73	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	926	74	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	926	75	in	in	IN
18637	926	76	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	926	77	favor	favor	NN
18637	926	78	,	,	,
18637	926	79	and	and	CC
18637	926	80	to	to	TO
18637	926	81	have	have	VB
18637	926	82	the	the	DT
18637	926	83	Assistance	assistance	NN
18637	926	84	of	of	IN
18637	926	85	Counsel	Counsel	NNP
18637	926	86	for	for	IN
18637	926	87	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	926	88	defence	defence	NN
18637	926	89	.	.	.
18637	927	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	927	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	927	3	VII	VII	NNP
18637	927	4	.	.	.
18637	927	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	928	1	In	in	IN
18637	928	2	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	928	3	at	at	IN
18637	928	4	common	common	JJ
18637	928	5	law	law	NN
18637	928	6	,	,	,
18637	928	7	where	where	WRB
18637	928	8	the	the	DT
18637	928	9	value	value	NN
18637	928	10	in	in	IN
18637	928	11	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	928	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	928	13	exceed	exceed	VB
18637	928	14	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	928	15	dollars	dollar	NNS
18637	928	16	,	,	,
18637	928	17	the	the	DT
18637	928	18	right	right	NN
18637	928	19	of	of	IN
18637	928	20	trial	trial	NN
18637	928	21	by	by	IN
18637	928	22	jury	jury	NN
18637	928	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	928	24	be	be	VB
18637	928	25	preserved	preserve	VBN
18637	928	26	,	,	,
18637	928	27	and	and	CC
18637	928	28	no	no	DT
18637	928	29	fact	fact	NN
18637	928	30	tried	try	VBN
18637	928	31	by	by	IN
18637	928	32	a	a	DT
18637	928	33	jury	jury	NN
18637	928	34	,	,	,
18637	928	35	shall	shall	MD
18637	928	36	be	be	VB
18637	928	37	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	928	38	re	re	JJ
18637	928	39	-	-	VBN
18637	928	40	examined	examine	VBN
18637	928	41	in	in	IN
18637	928	42	any	any	DT
18637	928	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	928	44	of	of	IN
18637	928	45	the	the	DT
18637	928	46	United	United	NNP
18637	928	47	States	States	NNP
18637	928	48	,	,	,
18637	928	49	than	than	IN
18637	928	50	according	accord	VBG
18637	928	51	to	to	IN
18637	928	52	the	the	DT
18637	928	53	rules	rule	NNS
18637	928	54	of	of	IN
18637	928	55	the	the	DT
18637	928	56	common	common	JJ
18637	928	57	law	law	NN
18637	928	58	.	.	.
18637	929	1	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	929	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	929	3	VIII	VIII	NNP
18637	929	4	.	.	.
18637	929	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	930	1	Excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	930	2	bail	bail	NN
18637	930	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	930	4	not	not	RB
18637	930	5	be	be	VB
18637	930	6	required	require	VBN
18637	930	7	,	,	,
18637	930	8	nor	nor	CC
18637	930	9	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	930	10	fines	fine	NNS
18637	930	11	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	930	12	,	,	,
18637	930	13	nor	nor	CC
18637	930	14	cruel	cruel	JJ
18637	930	15	and	and	CC
18637	930	16	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	930	17	punishments	punishment	NNS
18637	930	18	inflicted	inflict	VBN
18637	930	19	.	.	.
18637	931	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	931	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	931	3	IX	IX	NNP
18637	931	4	.	.	.
18637	931	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	932	1	The	the	DT
18637	932	2	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	932	3	in	in	IN
18637	932	4	the	the	DT
18637	932	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	932	6	,	,	,
18637	932	7	of	of	IN
18637	932	8	certain	certain	JJ
18637	932	9	rights	right	NNS
18637	932	10	,	,	,
18637	932	11	shall	shall	MD
18637	932	12	not	not	RB
18637	932	13	be	be	VB
18637	932	14	construed	construe	VBN
18637	932	15	to	to	TO
18637	932	16	deny	deny	VB
18637	932	17	or	or	CC
18637	932	18	disparage	disparage	VB
18637	932	19	others	other	NNS
18637	932	20	retained	retain	VBN
18637	932	21	by	by	IN
18637	932	22	the	the	DT
18637	932	23	people	people	NNS
18637	932	24	.	.	.
18637	933	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	933	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	933	3	X.	X.	NNP
18637	933	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	934	1	The	the	DT
18637	934	2	powers	power	NNS
18637	934	3	not	not	RB
18637	934	4	delegated	delegate	VBD
18637	934	5	to	to	IN
18637	934	6	the	the	DT
18637	934	7	United	United	NNP
18637	934	8	States	States	NNP
18637	934	9	by	by	IN
18637	934	10	the	the	DT
18637	934	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	934	12	,	,	,
18637	934	13	nor	nor	CC
18637	934	14	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	934	15	by	by	IN
18637	934	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	934	17	to	to	IN
18637	934	18	the	the	DT
18637	934	19	States	States	NNP
18637	934	20	,	,	,
18637	934	21	are	be	VBP
18637	934	22	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	934	23	to	to	IN
18637	934	24	the	the	DT
18637	934	25	States	States	NNP
18637	934	26	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	934	27	,	,	,
18637	934	28	or	or	CC
18637	934	29	to	to	IN
18637	934	30	the	the	DT
18637	934	31	people	people	NNS
18637	934	32	.	.	.
18637	935	1	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	935	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	935	3	XI	XI	NNP
18637	935	4	.	.	.
18637	936	1	]	]	-RRB-
18637	936	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	936	3	c	c	NN
18637	936	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	936	5	The	the	DT
18637	936	6	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	936	7	power	power	NN
18637	936	8	of	of	IN
18637	936	9	the	the	DT
18637	936	10	United	United	NNP
18637	936	11	States	States	NNP
18637	936	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	936	13	not	not	RB
18637	936	14	be	be	VB
18637	936	15	construed	construe	VBN
18637	936	16	to	to	TO
18637	936	17	extend	extend	VB
18637	936	18	to	to	IN
18637	936	19	any	any	DT
18637	936	20	suit	suit	NN
18637	936	21	in	in	IN
18637	936	22	law	law	NN
18637	936	23	or	or	CC
18637	936	24	equity	equity	NN
18637	936	25	,	,	,
18637	936	26	commenced	commence	VBD
18637	936	27	or	or	CC
18637	936	28	prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
18637	936	29	against	against	IN
18637	936	30	one	one	CD
18637	936	31	of	of	IN
18637	936	32	the	the	DT
18637	936	33	United	United	NNP
18637	936	34	States	States	NNP
18637	936	35	by	by	IN
18637	936	36	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	936	37	of	of	IN
18637	936	38	another	another	DT
18637	936	39	State	state	NN
18637	936	40	,	,	,
18637	936	41	or	or	CC
18637	936	42	by	by	IN
18637	936	43	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	936	44	or	or	CC
18637	936	45	Subjects	Subjects	NNPS
18637	936	46	of	of	IN
18637	936	47	any	any	DT
18637	936	48	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	936	49	State	State	NNP
18637	936	50	.	.	.
18637	937	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	937	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	937	3	XII	XII	NNP
18637	937	4	.	.	.
18637	938	1	]	]	-RRB-
18637	938	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	938	3	d	d	NN
18637	938	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	938	5	The	the	DT
18637	938	6	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	938	7	shall	shall	MD
18637	938	8	meet	meet	VB
18637	938	9	in	in	IN
18637	938	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	938	11	respective	respective	JJ
18637	938	12	states	state	NNS
18637	938	13	and	and	CC
18637	938	14	vote	vote	NN
18637	938	15	by	by	IN
18637	938	16	ballot	ballot	NN
18637	938	17	for	for	IN
18637	938	18	President	President	NNP
18637	938	19	and	and	CC
18637	938	20	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	938	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	938	22	President	President	NNP
18637	938	23	,	,	,
18637	938	24	one	one	CD
18637	938	25	of	of	IN
18637	938	26	whom	whom	WP
18637	938	27	,	,	,
18637	938	28	at	at	IN
18637	938	29	least	least	JJS
18637	938	30	,	,	,
18637	938	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	938	32	not	not	RB
18637	938	33	be	be	VB
18637	938	34	an	an	DT
18637	938	35	inhabitant	inhabitant	NN
18637	938	36	of	of	IN
18637	938	37	the	the	DT
18637	938	38	same	same	JJ
18637	938	39	state	state	NN
18637	938	40	with	with	IN
18637	938	41	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	938	42	;	;	:
18637	938	43	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	938	44	shall	shall	MD
18637	938	45	name	name	VB
18637	938	46	in	in	IN
18637	938	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	938	48	ballots	ballot	NNS
18637	938	49	the	the	DT
18637	938	50	person	person	NN
18637	938	51	voted	vote	VBD
18637	938	52	for	for	IN
18637	938	53	as	as	IN
18637	938	54	President	President	NNP
18637	938	55	,	,	,
18637	938	56	and	and	CC
18637	938	57	in	in	IN
18637	938	58	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	938	59	ballots	ballot	NNS
18637	938	60	the	the	DT
18637	938	61	person	person	NN
18637	938	62	voted	vote	VBD
18637	938	63	for	for	IN
18637	938	64	as	as	IN
18637	938	65	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	938	66	-	-	HYPH
18637	938	67	President	President	NNP
18637	938	68	,	,	,
18637	938	69	and	and	CC
18637	938	70	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	938	71	shall	shall	MD
18637	938	72	make	make	VB
18637	938	73	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	938	74	lists	list	NNS
18637	938	75	of	of	IN
18637	938	76	all	all	DT
18637	938	77	persons	person	NNS
18637	938	78	voted	vote	VBD
18637	938	79	for	for	IN
18637	938	80	as	as	IN
18637	938	81	President	President	NNP
18637	938	82	,	,	,
18637	938	83	and	and	CC
18637	938	84	of	of	IN
18637	938	85	all	all	DT
18637	938	86	persons	person	NNS
18637	938	87	voted	vote	VBD
18637	938	88	for	for	IN
18637	938	89	as	as	IN
18637	938	90	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	938	91	-	-	HYPH
18637	938	92	President	President	NNP
18637	938	93	,	,	,
18637	938	94	and	and	CC
18637	938	95	of	of	IN
18637	938	96	the	the	DT
18637	938	97	number	number	NN
18637	938	98	of	of	IN
18637	938	99	votes	vote	NNS
18637	938	100	for	for	IN
18637	938	101	each	each	DT
18637	938	102	,	,	,
18637	938	103	which	which	WDT
18637	938	104	lists	list	VBZ
18637	938	105	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	938	106	shall	shall	MD
18637	938	107	sign	sign	VB
18637	938	108	and	and	CC
18637	938	109	certify	certify	VB
18637	938	110	,	,	,
18637	938	111	and	and	CC
18637	938	112	transmit	transmit	VB
18637	938	113	sealed	seal	VBN
18637	938	114	to	to	IN
18637	938	115	the	the	DT
18637	938	116	seat	seat	NN
18637	938	117	of	of	IN
18637	938	118	the	the	DT
18637	938	119	government	government	NN
18637	938	120	of	of	IN
18637	938	121	the	the	DT
18637	938	122	United	United	NNP
18637	938	123	States	States	NNP
18637	938	124	,	,	,
18637	938	125	directed	direct	VBN
18637	938	126	to	to	IN
18637	938	127	the	the	DT
18637	938	128	President	President	NNP
18637	938	129	of	of	IN
18637	938	130	the	the	DT
18637	938	131	Senate;--The	senate;--the	JJ
18637	938	132	President	President	NNP
18637	938	133	of	of	IN
18637	938	134	the	the	DT
18637	938	135	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	938	136	shall	shall	MD
18637	938	137	,	,	,
18637	938	138	in	in	IN
18637	938	139	the	the	DT
18637	938	140	presence	presence	NN
18637	938	141	of	of	IN
18637	938	142	the	the	DT
18637	938	143	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	938	144	and	and	CC
18637	938	145	House	House	NNP
18637	938	146	of	of	IN
18637	938	147	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	938	148	,	,	,
18637	938	149	open	open	VB
18637	938	150	all	all	PDT
18637	938	151	the	the	DT
18637	938	152	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	938	153	and	and	CC
18637	938	154	the	the	DT
18637	938	155	votes	vote	NNS
18637	938	156	shall	shall	MD
18637	938	157	then	then	RB
18637	938	158	be	be	VB
18637	938	159	counted;--The	counted;--The	.
18637	938	160	person	person	NN
18637	938	161	having	have	VBG
18637	938	162	the	the	DT
18637	938	163	greatest	great	JJS
18637	938	164	number	number	NN
18637	938	165	of	of	IN
18637	938	166	votes	vote	NNS
18637	938	167	for	for	IN
18637	938	168	President	President	NNP
18637	938	169	,	,	,
18637	938	170	shall	shall	MD
18637	938	171	be	be	VB
18637	938	172	the	the	DT
18637	938	173	President	President	NNP
18637	938	174	,	,	,
18637	938	175	if	if	IN
18637	938	176	such	such	JJ
18637	938	177	number	number	NN
18637	938	178	be	be	VB
18637	938	179	a	a	DT
18637	938	180	majority	majority	NN
18637	938	181	of	of	IN
18637	938	182	the	the	DT
18637	938	183	whole	whole	JJ
18637	938	184	number	number	NN
18637	938	185	of	of	IN
18637	938	186	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	938	187	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	938	188	;	;	:
18637	938	189	and	and	CC
18637	938	190	if	if	IN
18637	938	191	no	no	DT
18637	938	192	person	person	NN
18637	938	193	have	have	VBP
18637	938	194	such	such	JJ
18637	938	195	majority	majority	NN
18637	938	196	,	,	,
18637	938	197	then	then	RB
18637	938	198	from	from	IN
18637	938	199	the	the	DT
18637	938	200	persons	person	NNS
18637	938	201	having	have	VBG
18637	938	202	the	the	DT
18637	938	203	highest	high	JJS
18637	938	204	numbers	number	NNS
18637	938	205	not	not	RB
18637	938	206	exceeding	exceed	VBG
18637	938	207	three	three	CD
18637	938	208	on	on	IN
18637	938	209	the	the	DT
18637	938	210	list	list	NN
18637	938	211	of	of	IN
18637	938	212	those	those	DT
18637	938	213	voted	vote	VBN
18637	938	214	for	for	IN
18637	938	215	as	as	IN
18637	938	216	President	President	NNP
18637	938	217	,	,	,
18637	938	218	the	the	DT
18637	938	219	House	House	NNP
18637	938	220	of	of	IN
18637	938	221	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	938	222	shall	shall	MD
18637	938	223	choose	choose	VB
18637	938	224	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	938	225	,	,	,
18637	938	226	by	by	IN
18637	938	227	ballot	ballot	NN
18637	938	228	,	,	,
18637	938	229	the	the	DT
18637	938	230	President	President	NNP
18637	938	231	.	.	.
18637	939	1	But	but	CC
18637	939	2	in	in	IN
18637	939	3	choosing	choose	VBG
18637	939	4	the	the	DT
18637	939	5	President	President	NNP
18637	939	6	,	,	,
18637	939	7	the	the	DT
18637	939	8	votes	vote	NNS
18637	939	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	939	10	be	be	VB
18637	939	11	taken	take	VBN
18637	939	12	by	by	IN
18637	939	13	states	state	NNS
18637	939	14	,	,	,
18637	939	15	the	the	DT
18637	939	16	representation	representation	NN
18637	939	17	from	from	IN
18637	939	18	each	each	DT
18637	939	19	state	state	NN
18637	939	20	having	have	VBG
18637	939	21	one	one	CD
18637	939	22	vote	vote	NN
18637	939	23	;	;	:
18637	939	24	a	a	DT
18637	939	25	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	939	26	for	for	IN
18637	939	27	this	this	DT
18637	939	28	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	939	29	shall	shall	MD
18637	939	30	consist	consist	VB
18637	939	31	of	of	IN
18637	939	32	a	a	DT
18637	939	33	member	member	NN
18637	939	34	or	or	CC
18637	939	35	members	member	NNS
18637	939	36	from	from	IN
18637	939	37	two	two	CD
18637	939	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	939	39	thirds	third	NNS
18637	939	40	of	of	IN
18637	939	41	the	the	DT
18637	939	42	states	state	NNS
18637	939	43	,	,	,
18637	939	44	and	and	CC
18637	939	45	a	a	DT
18637	939	46	majority	majority	NN
18637	939	47	of	of	IN
18637	939	48	all	all	PDT
18637	939	49	the	the	DT
18637	939	50	states	state	NNS
18637	939	51	shall	shall	MD
18637	939	52	be	be	VB
18637	939	53	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	939	54	to	to	IN
18637	939	55	a	a	DT
18637	939	56	choice	choice	NN
18637	939	57	.	.	.
18637	940	1	And	and	CC
18637	940	2	if	if	IN
18637	940	3	the	the	DT
18637	940	4	House	House	NNP
18637	940	5	of	of	IN
18637	940	6	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	940	7	shall	shall	MD
18637	940	8	not	not	RB
18637	940	9	choose	choose	VB
18637	940	10	a	a	DT
18637	940	11	President	President	NNP
18637	940	12	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	940	13	the	the	DT
18637	940	14	right	right	NN
18637	940	15	of	of	IN
18637	940	16	choice	choice	NN
18637	940	17	shall	shall	MD
18637	940	18	devolve	devolve	VB
18637	940	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	940	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	940	21	,	,	,
18637	940	22	before	before	IN
18637	940	23	the	the	DT
18637	940	24	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	940	25	day	day	NN
18637	940	26	of	of	IN
18637	940	27	March	March	NNP
18637	940	28	next	next	RB
18637	940	29	following	follow	VBG
18637	940	30	,	,	,
18637	940	31	then	then	RB
18637	940	32	the	the	DT
18637	940	33	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	940	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	940	35	President	President	NNP
18637	940	36	shall	shall	MD
18637	940	37	act	act	VB
18637	940	38	as	as	IN
18637	940	39	President	President	NNP
18637	940	40	,	,	,
18637	940	41	as	as	IN
18637	940	42	in	in	IN
18637	940	43	the	the	DT
18637	940	44	case	case	NN
18637	940	45	of	of	IN
18637	940	46	the	the	DT
18637	940	47	death	death	NN
18637	940	48	or	or	CC
18637	940	49	other	other	JJ
18637	940	50	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	940	51	disability	disability	NN
18637	940	52	of	of	IN
18637	940	53	the	the	DT
18637	940	54	President	President	NNP
18637	940	55	--	--	:
18637	940	56	The	the	DT
18637	940	57	person	person	NN
18637	940	58	having	have	VBG
18637	940	59	the	the	DT
18637	940	60	greatest	great	JJS
18637	940	61	number	number	NN
18637	940	62	of	of	IN
18637	940	63	votes	vote	NNS
18637	940	64	as	as	IN
18637	940	65	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	940	66	-	-	HYPH
18637	940	67	President	President	NNP
18637	940	68	,	,	,
18637	940	69	shall	shall	MD
18637	940	70	be	be	VB
18637	940	71	the	the	DT
18637	940	72	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	940	73	-	-	HYPH
18637	940	74	President	President	NNP
18637	940	75	,	,	,
18637	940	76	if	if	IN
18637	940	77	such	such	JJ
18637	940	78	number	number	NN
18637	940	79	be	be	VB
18637	940	80	a	a	DT
18637	940	81	majority	majority	NN
18637	940	82	of	of	IN
18637	940	83	the	the	DT
18637	940	84	whole	whole	JJ
18637	940	85	number	number	NN
18637	940	86	of	of	IN
18637	940	87	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	940	88	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	940	89	,	,	,
18637	940	90	and	and	CC
18637	940	91	if	if	IN
18637	940	92	no	no	DT
18637	940	93	person	person	NN
18637	940	94	have	have	VBP
18637	940	95	a	a	DT
18637	940	96	majority	majority	NN
18637	940	97	,	,	,
18637	940	98	then	then	RB
18637	940	99	from	from	IN
18637	940	100	the	the	DT
18637	940	101	two	two	CD
18637	940	102	highest	high	JJS
18637	940	103	numbers	number	NNS
18637	940	104	on	on	IN
18637	940	105	the	the	DT
18637	940	106	list	list	NN
18637	940	107	,	,	,
18637	940	108	the	the	DT
18637	940	109	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	940	110	shall	shall	MD
18637	940	111	choose	choose	VB
18637	940	112	the	the	DT
18637	940	113	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	940	114	-	-	HYPH
18637	940	115	President	President	NNP
18637	940	116	;	;	:
18637	940	117	a	a	DT
18637	940	118	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	940	119	for	for	IN
18637	940	120	the	the	DT
18637	940	121	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	940	122	shall	shall	MD
18637	940	123	consist	consist	VB
18637	940	124	of	of	IN
18637	940	125	two	two	CD
18637	940	126	-	-	HYPH
18637	940	127	thirds	third	NNS
18637	940	128	of	of	IN
18637	940	129	the	the	DT
18637	940	130	whole	whole	JJ
18637	940	131	number	number	NN
18637	940	132	of	of	IN
18637	940	133	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	940	134	,	,	,
18637	940	135	and	and	CC
18637	940	136	a	a	DT
18637	940	137	majority	majority	NN
18637	940	138	of	of	IN
18637	940	139	the	the	DT
18637	940	140	whole	whole	JJ
18637	940	141	number	number	NN
18637	940	142	shall	shall	MD
18637	940	143	be	be	VB
18637	940	144	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	940	145	to	to	IN
18637	940	146	a	a	DT
18637	940	147	choice	choice	NN
18637	940	148	.	.	.
18637	941	1	But	but	CC
18637	941	2	no	no	DT
18637	941	3	person	person	NN
18637	941	4	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	941	5	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	941	6	to	to	IN
18637	941	7	the	the	DT
18637	941	8	office	office	NN
18637	941	9	of	of	IN
18637	941	10	President	President	NNP
18637	941	11	shall	shall	MD
18637	941	12	be	be	VB
18637	941	13	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	941	14	to	to	IN
18637	941	15	that	that	DT
18637	941	16	of	of	IN
18637	941	17	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	941	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	941	19	President	President	NNP
18637	941	20	of	of	IN
18637	941	21	the	the	DT
18637	941	22	United	United	NNP
18637	941	23	States	States	NNP
18637	941	24	.	.	.
18637	942	1	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	942	2	XIII	XIII	NNP
18637	942	3	.	.	.
18637	943	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	943	2	e	e	LS
18637	943	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	943	4	Section	section	NN
18637	943	5	1	1	CD
18637	943	6	.	.	.
18637	944	1	Neither	neither	DT
18637	944	2	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	944	3	nor	nor	CC
18637	944	4	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	944	5	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	944	6	,	,	,
18637	944	7	except	except	IN
18637	944	8	as	as	IN
18637	944	9	a	a	DT
18637	944	10	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	944	11	for	for	IN
18637	944	12	crime	crime	NN
18637	944	13	whereof	whereof	IN
18637	944	14	the	the	DT
18637	944	15	party	party	NN
18637	944	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	944	17	have	have	VB
18637	944	18	been	be	VBN
18637	944	19	duly	duly	RB
18637	944	20	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	944	21	,	,	,
18637	944	22	shall	shall	MD
18637	944	23	exist	exist	VB
18637	944	24	within	within	IN
18637	944	25	the	the	DT
18637	944	26	United	United	NNP
18637	944	27	States	States	NNP
18637	944	28	,	,	,
18637	944	29	or	or	CC
18637	944	30	any	any	DT
18637	944	31	place	place	NN
18637	944	32	subject	subject	JJ
18637	944	33	to	to	IN
18637	944	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	944	35	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	944	36	.	.	.
18637	945	1	Section	section	NN
18637	945	2	2	2	CD
18637	945	3	.	.	.
18637	946	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	946	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	946	3	have	have	VB
18637	946	4	power	power	NN
18637	946	5	to	to	TO
18637	946	6	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	946	7	this	this	DT
18637	946	8	article	article	NN
18637	946	9	by	by	IN
18637	946	10	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	946	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	946	12	.	.	.
18637	947	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	947	2	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	947	3	.	.	.
18637	948	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	948	2	f	f	NNP
18637	948	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	948	4	Section	section	NN
18637	948	5	1	1	CD
18637	948	6	.	.	.
18637	949	1	All	all	DT
18637	949	2	persons	person	NNS
18637	949	3	born	bear	VBN
18637	949	4	or	or	CC
18637	949	5	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	949	6	in	in	IN
18637	949	7	the	the	DT
18637	949	8	United	United	NNP
18637	949	9	States	States	NNP
18637	949	10	and	and	CC
18637	949	11	subject	subject	JJ
18637	949	12	to	to	IN
18637	949	13	the	the	DT
18637	949	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	949	15	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	949	16	,	,	,
18637	949	17	are	be	VBP
18637	949	18	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	949	19	of	of	IN
18637	949	20	the	the	DT
18637	949	21	United	United	NNP
18637	949	22	States	States	NNP
18637	949	23	and	and	CC
18637	949	24	of	of	IN
18637	949	25	the	the	DT
18637	949	26	State	State	NNP
18637	949	27	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	949	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	949	29	reside	reside	VBP
18637	949	30	.	.	.
18637	950	1	No	no	DT
18637	950	2	State	state	NN
18637	950	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	950	4	make	make	VB
18637	950	5	or	or	CC
18637	950	6	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	950	7	any	any	DT
18637	950	8	law	law	NN
18637	950	9	which	which	WDT
18637	950	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	950	11	abridge	abridge	VB
18637	950	12	the	the	DT
18637	950	13	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	950	14	or	or	CC
18637	950	15	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	950	16	of	of	IN
18637	950	17	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	950	18	of	of	IN
18637	950	19	the	the	DT
18637	950	20	United	United	NNP
18637	950	21	States	States	NNP
18637	950	22	;	;	:
18637	950	23	nor	nor	CC
18637	950	24	shall	shall	MD
18637	950	25	any	any	DT
18637	950	26	State	state	NN
18637	950	27	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	950	28	any	any	DT
18637	950	29	person	person	NN
18637	950	30	of	of	IN
18637	950	31	life	life	NN
18637	950	32	,	,	,
18637	950	33	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	950	34	,	,	,
18637	950	35	or	or	CC
18637	950	36	property	property	NN
18637	950	37	,	,	,
18637	950	38	without	without	IN
18637	950	39	due	due	JJ
18637	950	40	process	process	NN
18637	950	41	of	of	IN
18637	950	42	law	law	NN
18637	950	43	;	;	:
18637	950	44	nor	nor	CC
18637	950	45	deny	deny	VB
18637	950	46	to	to	IN
18637	950	47	any	any	DT
18637	950	48	person	person	NN
18637	950	49	within	within	IN
18637	950	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	950	51	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	950	52	the	the	DT
18637	950	53	equal	equal	JJ
18637	950	54	protection	protection	NN
18637	950	55	of	of	IN
18637	950	56	the	the	DT
18637	950	57	laws	law	NNS
18637	950	58	.	.	.
18637	951	1	Section	section	NN
18637	951	2	2	2	CD
18637	951	3	.	.	.
18637	952	1	Representatives	representative	NNS
18637	952	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	952	3	be	be	VB
18637	952	4	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	952	5	among	among	IN
18637	952	6	the	the	DT
18637	952	7	several	several	JJ
18637	952	8	States	state	NNS
18637	952	9	according	accord	VBG
18637	952	10	to	to	IN
18637	952	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	952	12	respective	respective	JJ
18637	952	13	numbers	number	NNS
18637	952	14	,	,	,
18637	952	15	counting	count	VBG
18637	952	16	the	the	DT
18637	952	17	whole	whole	JJ
18637	952	18	number	number	NN
18637	952	19	of	of	IN
18637	952	20	persons	person	NNS
18637	952	21	in	in	IN
18637	952	22	each	each	DT
18637	952	23	State	state	NN
18637	952	24	,	,	,
18637	952	25	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	952	26	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	952	27	not	not	RB
18637	952	28	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	952	29	.	.	.
18637	953	1	But	but	CC
18637	953	2	when	when	WRB
18637	953	3	the	the	DT
18637	953	4	right	right	NN
18637	953	5	to	to	TO
18637	953	6	vote	vote	VB
18637	953	7	at	at	IN
18637	953	8	any	any	DT
18637	953	9	election	election	NN
18637	953	10	for	for	IN
18637	953	11	the	the	DT
18637	953	12	choice	choice	NN
18637	953	13	of	of	IN
18637	953	14	electors	elector	NNS
18637	953	15	for	for	IN
18637	953	16	President	President	NNP
18637	953	17	and	and	CC
18637	953	18	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	953	19	President	President	NNP
18637	953	20	of	of	IN
18637	953	21	the	the	DT
18637	953	22	United	United	NNP
18637	953	23	States	States	NNP
18637	953	24	,	,	,
18637	953	25	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	953	26	in	in	IN
18637	953	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	953	28	,	,	,
18637	953	29	the	the	DT
18637	953	30	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	953	31	and	and	CC
18637	953	32	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	953	33	officers	officer	NNS
18637	953	34	of	of	IN
18637	953	35	a	a	DT
18637	953	36	State	state	NN
18637	953	37	,	,	,
18637	953	38	or	or	CC
18637	953	39	the	the	DT
18637	953	40	members	member	NNS
18637	953	41	of	of	IN
18637	953	42	the	the	DT
18637	953	43	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	953	44	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	953	45	,	,	,
18637	953	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	953	47	denied	deny	VBN
18637	953	48	to	to	IN
18637	953	49	any	any	DT
18637	953	50	of	of	IN
18637	953	51	the	the	DT
18637	953	52	male	male	JJ
18637	953	53	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	953	54	of	of	IN
18637	953	55	such	such	JJ
18637	953	56	State	State	NNP
18637	953	57	,	,	,
18637	953	58	being	be	VBG
18637	953	59	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	953	60	-	-	HYPH
18637	953	61	one	one	CD
18637	953	62	years	year	NNS
18637	953	63	of	of	IN
18637	953	64	age	age	NN
18637	953	65	,	,	,
18637	953	66	and	and	CC
18637	953	67	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	953	68	of	of	IN
18637	953	69	the	the	DT
18637	953	70	United	United	NNP
18637	953	71	States	States	NNP
18637	953	72	,	,	,
18637	953	73	or	or	CC
18637	953	74	in	in	IN
18637	953	75	any	any	DT
18637	953	76	way	way	NN
18637	953	77	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	953	78	,	,	,
18637	953	79	except	except	IN
18637	953	80	for	for	IN
18637	953	81	participation	participation	NN
18637	953	82	in	in	IN
18637	953	83	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	953	84	,	,	,
18637	953	85	or	or	CC
18637	953	86	other	other	JJ
18637	953	87	crime	crime	NN
18637	953	88	,	,	,
18637	953	89	the	the	DT
18637	953	90	basis	basis	NN
18637	953	91	of	of	IN
18637	953	92	representation	representation	NN
18637	953	93	therein	therein	RB
18637	953	94	shall	shall	MD
18637	953	95	be	be	VB
18637	953	96	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	953	97	in	in	IN
18637	953	98	the	the	DT
18637	953	99	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	953	100	which	which	WDT
18637	953	101	the	the	DT
18637	953	102	number	number	NN
18637	953	103	of	of	IN
18637	953	104	such	such	JJ
18637	953	105	male	male	JJ
18637	953	106	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	953	107	shall	shall	MD
18637	953	108	bear	bear	VB
18637	953	109	to	to	IN
18637	953	110	the	the	DT
18637	953	111	whole	whole	JJ
18637	953	112	number	number	NN
18637	953	113	of	of	IN
18637	953	114	male	male	JJ
18637	953	115	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	953	116	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	953	117	-	-	HYPH
18637	953	118	one	one	CD
18637	953	119	years	year	NNS
18637	953	120	of	of	IN
18637	953	121	age	age	NN
18637	953	122	in	in	IN
18637	953	123	such	such	JJ
18637	953	124	State	state	NN
18637	953	125	.	.	.
18637	954	1	Section	section	NN
18637	954	2	3	3	CD
18637	954	3	.	.	.
18637	955	1	No	no	DT
18637	955	2	person	person	NN
18637	955	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	955	4	be	be	VB
18637	955	5	a	a	DT
18637	955	6	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	955	7	or	or	CC
18637	955	8	Representative	Representative	NNP
18637	955	9	in	in	IN
18637	955	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	955	11	,	,	,
18637	955	12	or	or	CC
18637	955	13	elector	elector	NN
18637	955	14	of	of	IN
18637	955	15	President	President	NNP
18637	955	16	and	and	CC
18637	955	17	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	955	18	President	President	NNP
18637	955	19	,	,	,
18637	955	20	or	or	CC
18637	955	21	hold	hold	VB
18637	955	22	any	any	DT
18637	955	23	office	office	NN
18637	955	24	,	,	,
18637	955	25	civil	civil	JJ
18637	955	26	or	or	CC
18637	955	27	military	military	JJ
18637	955	28	,	,	,
18637	955	29	under	under	IN
18637	955	30	the	the	DT
18637	955	31	United	United	NNP
18637	955	32	States	States	NNP
18637	955	33	,	,	,
18637	955	34	or	or	CC
18637	955	35	under	under	IN
18637	955	36	any	any	DT
18637	955	37	State	State	NNP
18637	955	38	,	,	,
18637	955	39	who	who	WP
18637	955	40	,	,	,
18637	955	41	having	have	VBG
18637	955	42	previously	previously	RB
18637	955	43	taken	take	VBN
18637	955	44	an	an	DT
18637	955	45	oath	oath	NN
18637	955	46	,	,	,
18637	955	47	as	as	IN
18637	955	48	a	a	DT
18637	955	49	member	member	NN
18637	955	50	of	of	IN
18637	955	51	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	955	52	,	,	,
18637	955	53	or	or	CC
18637	955	54	as	as	IN
18637	955	55	an	an	DT
18637	955	56	officer	officer	NN
18637	955	57	of	of	IN
18637	955	58	the	the	DT
18637	955	59	United	United	NNP
18637	955	60	States	States	NNP
18637	955	61	,	,	,
18637	955	62	or	or	CC
18637	955	63	as	as	IN
18637	955	64	a	a	DT
18637	955	65	member	member	NN
18637	955	66	of	of	IN
18637	955	67	any	any	DT
18637	955	68	State	State	NNP
18637	955	69	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	955	70	,	,	,
18637	955	71	or	or	CC
18637	955	72	as	as	IN
18637	955	73	an	an	DT
18637	955	74	executive	executive	JJ
18637	955	75	or	or	CC
18637	955	76	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	955	77	officer	officer	NN
18637	955	78	of	of	IN
18637	955	79	any	any	DT
18637	955	80	State	State	NNP
18637	955	81	,	,	,
18637	955	82	to	to	TO
18637	955	83	support	support	VB
18637	955	84	the	the	DT
18637	955	85	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	955	86	of	of	IN
18637	955	87	the	the	DT
18637	955	88	United	United	NNP
18637	955	89	States	States	NNP
18637	955	90	,	,	,
18637	955	91	shall	shall	MD
18637	955	92	have	have	VB
18637	955	93	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	955	94	in	in	IN
18637	955	95	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	955	96	or	or	CC
18637	955	97	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	955	98	against	against	IN
18637	955	99	the	the	DT
18637	955	100	same	same	JJ
18637	955	101	,	,	,
18637	955	102	or	or	CC
18637	955	103	given	give	VBN
18637	955	104	aid	aid	NN
18637	955	105	or	or	CC
18637	955	106	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	955	107	to	to	IN
18637	955	108	the	the	DT
18637	955	109	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	955	110	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	955	111	.	.	.
18637	956	1	But	but	CC
18637	956	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	956	3	may	may	MD
18637	956	4	by	by	IN
18637	956	5	a	a	DT
18637	956	6	vote	vote	NN
18637	956	7	of	of	IN
18637	956	8	two	two	CD
18637	956	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	956	10	thirds	third	NNS
18637	956	11	of	of	IN
18637	956	12	each	each	DT
18637	956	13	House	House	NNP
18637	956	14	,	,	,
18637	956	15	remove	remove	VB
18637	956	16	such	such	JJ
18637	956	17	disability	disability	NN
18637	956	18	.	.	.
18637	957	1	Section	section	NN
18637	957	2	4	4	CD
18637	957	3	.	.	.
18637	958	1	The	the	DT
18637	958	2	validity	validity	NN
18637	958	3	of	of	IN
18637	958	4	the	the	DT
18637	958	5	public	public	JJ
18637	958	6	debt	debt	NN
18637	958	7	of	of	IN
18637	958	8	the	the	DT
18637	958	9	United	United	NNP
18637	958	10	States	States	NNP
18637	958	11	,	,	,
18637	958	12	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	958	13	by	by	IN
18637	958	14	law	law	NN
18637	958	15	,	,	,
18637	958	16	including	include	VBG
18637	958	17	debts	debt	NNS
18637	958	18	incurred	incur	VBN
18637	958	19	for	for	IN
18637	958	20	payment	payment	NN
18637	958	21	of	of	IN
18637	958	22	pensions	pension	NNS
18637	958	23	and	and	CC
18637	958	24	bounties	bounty	NNS
18637	958	25	for	for	IN
18637	958	26	services	service	NNS
18637	958	27	in	in	IN
18637	958	28	suppressing	suppress	VBG
18637	958	29	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	958	30	or	or	CC
18637	958	31	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	958	32	,	,	,
18637	958	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	958	34	not	not	RB
18637	958	35	be	be	VB
18637	958	36	questioned	question	VBN
18637	958	37	.	.	.
18637	959	1	But	but	CC
18637	959	2	neither	neither	CC
18637	959	3	the	the	DT
18637	959	4	United	United	NNP
18637	959	5	States	States	NNP
18637	959	6	nor	nor	CC
18637	959	7	any	any	DT
18637	959	8	State	State	NNP
18637	959	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	959	10	assume	assume	VB
18637	959	11	or	or	CC
18637	959	12	pay	pay	VB
18637	959	13	any	any	DT
18637	959	14	debt	debt	NN
18637	959	15	or	or	CC
18637	959	16	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	959	17	incurred	incur	VBN
18637	959	18	in	in	IN
18637	959	19	aid	aid	NN
18637	959	20	of	of	IN
18637	959	21	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	959	22	or	or	CC
18637	959	23	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	959	24	against	against	IN
18637	959	25	the	the	DT
18637	959	26	United	United	NNP
18637	959	27	States	States	NNP
18637	959	28	,	,	,
18637	959	29	or	or	CC
18637	959	30	any	any	DT
18637	959	31	claim	claim	NN
18637	959	32	for	for	IN
18637	959	33	the	the	DT
18637	959	34	loss	loss	NN
18637	959	35	or	or	CC
18637	959	36	emancipation	emancipation	NN
18637	959	37	of	of	IN
18637	959	38	any	any	DT
18637	959	39	slave	slave	NN
18637	959	40	;	;	:
18637	959	41	but	but	CC
18637	959	42	all	all	DT
18637	959	43	such	such	JJ
18637	959	44	debts	debt	NNS
18637	959	45	,	,	,
18637	959	46	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	959	47	and	and	CC
18637	959	48	claims	claim	NNS
18637	959	49	shall	shall	MD
18637	959	50	be	be	VB
18637	959	51	held	hold	VBN
18637	959	52	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	959	53	and	and	CC
18637	959	54	void	void	JJ
18637	959	55	.	.	.
18637	960	1	Section	section	NN
18637	960	2	5	5	CD
18637	960	3	.	.	.
18637	961	1	The	the	DT
18637	961	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	961	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	961	4	have	have	VB
18637	961	5	power	power	NN
18637	961	6	to	to	TO
18637	961	7	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	961	8	,	,	,
18637	961	9	by	by	IN
18637	961	10	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	961	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	961	12	,	,	,
18637	961	13	the	the	DT
18637	961	14	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	961	15	of	of	IN
18637	961	16	this	this	DT
18637	961	17	article	article	NN
18637	961	18	.	.	.
18637	962	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	962	2	XV	XV	NNP
18637	962	3	.	.	.
18637	963	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	963	2	g	g	NNP
18637	963	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	963	4	Section	section	NN
18637	963	5	1	1	CD
18637	963	6	.	.	.
18637	964	1	The	the	DT
18637	964	2	right	right	NN
18637	964	3	of	of	IN
18637	964	4	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	964	5	of	of	IN
18637	964	6	the	the	DT
18637	964	7	United	United	NNP
18637	964	8	States	States	NNP
18637	964	9	to	to	TO
18637	964	10	vote	vote	VB
18637	964	11	shall	shall	MD
18637	964	12	not	not	RB
18637	964	13	be	be	VB
18637	964	14	denied	deny	VBN
18637	964	15	or	or	CC
18637	964	16	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	964	17	by	by	IN
18637	964	18	the	the	DT
18637	964	19	United	United	NNP
18637	964	20	States	States	NNP
18637	964	21	or	or	CC
18637	964	22	by	by	IN
18637	964	23	any	any	DT
18637	964	24	State	State	NNP
18637	964	25	on	on	IN
18637	964	26	account	account	NN
18637	964	27	of	of	IN
18637	964	28	race	race	NN
18637	964	29	,	,	,
18637	964	30	color	color	NN
18637	964	31	,	,	,
18637	964	32	or	or	CC
18637	964	33	previous	previous	JJ
18637	964	34	condition	condition	NN
18637	964	35	of	of	IN
18637	964	36	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	964	37	.	.	.
18637	965	1	Section	section	NN
18637	965	2	2	2	CD
18637	965	3	.	.	.
18637	966	1	The	the	DT
18637	966	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	966	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	966	4	have	have	VB
18637	966	5	power	power	NN
18637	966	6	to	to	TO
18637	966	7	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	966	8	this	this	DT
18637	966	9	article	article	NN
18637	966	10	by	by	IN
18637	966	11	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	966	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	966	13	.	.	.
18637	967	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	967	2	XVI	XVI	NNP
18637	967	3	.	.	.
18637	968	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	968	2	h	h	LS
18637	968	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	968	4	The	the	DT
18637	968	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	968	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	968	7	have	have	VB
18637	968	8	power	power	NN
18637	968	9	to	to	TO
18637	968	10	lay	lay	VB
18637	968	11	and	and	CC
18637	968	12	collect	collect	VB
18637	968	13	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	968	14	on	on	IN
18637	968	15	incomes	income	NNS
18637	968	16	,	,	,
18637	968	17	from	from	IN
18637	968	18	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	968	19	source	source	NN
18637	968	20	derived	derive	VBN
18637	968	21	,	,	,
18637	968	22	without	without	IN
18637	968	23	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	968	24	among	among	IN
18637	968	25	the	the	DT
18637	968	26	several	several	JJ
18637	968	27	States	States	NNPS
18637	968	28	,	,	,
18637	968	29	and	and	CC
18637	968	30	without	without	IN
18637	968	31	regard	regard	NN
18637	968	32	to	to	IN
18637	968	33	any	any	DT
18637	968	34	census	census	NN
18637	968	35	or	or	CC
18637	968	36	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	968	37	.	.	.
18637	969	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	969	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	969	3	XVII	XVII	NNP
18637	969	4	.	.	.
18637	970	1	]	]	-RRB-
18637	970	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	970	3	i	i	NN
18637	970	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	970	5	The	the	DT
18637	970	6	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	970	7	of	of	IN
18637	970	8	the	the	DT
18637	970	9	United	United	NNP
18637	970	10	States	States	NNP
18637	970	11	shall	shall	MD
18637	970	12	be	be	VB
18637	970	13	composed	compose	VBN
18637	970	14	of	of	IN
18637	970	15	two	two	CD
18637	970	16	Senators	senator	NNS
18637	970	17	from	from	IN
18637	970	18	each	each	DT
18637	970	19	State	state	NN
18637	970	20	,	,	,
18637	970	21	elected	elect	VBN
18637	970	22	by	by	IN
18637	970	23	the	the	DT
18637	970	24	people	people	NNS
18637	970	25	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	970	26	,	,	,
18637	970	27	for	for	IN
18637	970	28	six	six	CD
18637	970	29	years	year	NNS
18637	970	30	;	;	:
18637	970	31	and	and	CC
18637	970	32	each	each	DT
18637	970	33	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	970	34	shall	shall	MD
18637	970	35	have	have	VB
18637	970	36	one	one	CD
18637	970	37	vote	vote	NN
18637	970	38	.	.	.
18637	971	1	The	the	DT
18637	971	2	electors	elector	NNS
18637	971	3	in	in	IN
18637	971	4	each	each	DT
18637	971	5	State	state	NN
18637	971	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	971	7	have	have	VB
18637	971	8	the	the	DT
18637	971	9	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	971	10	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	971	11	for	for	IN
18637	971	12	electors	elector	NNS
18637	971	13	of	of	IN
18637	971	14	the	the	DT
18637	971	15	most	most	RBS
18637	971	16	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	971	17	branch	branch	NN
18637	971	18	of	of	IN
18637	971	19	the	the	DT
18637	971	20	State	State	NNP
18637	971	21	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	971	22	.	.	.
18637	972	1	When	when	WRB
18637	972	2	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	972	3	happen	happen	VBP
18637	972	4	in	in	IN
18637	972	5	the	the	DT
18637	972	6	representation	representation	NN
18637	972	7	of	of	IN
18637	972	8	any	any	DT
18637	972	9	State	State	NNP
18637	972	10	in	in	IN
18637	972	11	the	the	DT
18637	972	12	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	972	13	,	,	,
18637	972	14	the	the	DT
18637	972	15	executive	executive	JJ
18637	972	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	972	17	of	of	IN
18637	972	18	such	such	JJ
18637	972	19	State	State	NNP
18637	972	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	972	21	issue	issue	VB
18637	972	22	writs	writ	NNS
18637	972	23	of	of	IN
18637	972	24	election	election	NN
18637	972	25	to	to	TO
18637	972	26	fill	fill	VB
18637	972	27	such	such	JJ
18637	972	28	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	972	29	:	:	:
18637	972	30	_	_	NNP
18637	972	31	Provided	Provided	NNP
18637	972	32	_	_	NNP
18637	972	33	,	,	,
18637	972	34	That	that	IN
18637	972	35	the	the	DT
18637	972	36	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	972	37	of	of	IN
18637	972	38	any	any	DT
18637	972	39	State	State	NNP
18637	972	40	may	may	MD
18637	972	41	empower	empower	VB
18637	972	42	the	the	DT
18637	972	43	executive	executive	NN
18637	972	44	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	972	45	to	to	TO
18637	972	46	make	make	VB
18637	972	47	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	972	48	appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	972	49	until	until	IN
18637	972	50	the	the	DT
18637	972	51	people	people	NNS
18637	972	52	fill	fill	VBP
18637	972	53	the	the	DT
18637	972	54	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	972	55	by	by	IN
18637	972	56	election	election	NN
18637	972	57	as	as	IN
18637	972	58	the	the	DT
18637	972	59	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	972	60	may	may	MD
18637	972	61	direct	direct	VB
18637	972	62	.	.	.
18637	973	1	This	this	DT
18637	973	2	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	973	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	973	4	not	not	RB
18637	973	5	be	be	VB
18637	973	6	so	so	RB
18637	973	7	construed	construe	VBN
18637	973	8	as	as	IN
18637	973	9	to	to	TO
18637	973	10	affect	affect	VB
18637	973	11	the	the	DT
18637	973	12	election	election	NN
18637	973	13	or	or	CC
18637	973	14	term	term	NN
18637	973	15	of	of	IN
18637	973	16	any	any	DT
18637	973	17	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	973	18	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	973	19	before	before	IN
18637	973	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	973	21	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	973	22	valid	valid	JJ
18637	973	23	as	as	IN
18637	973	24	part	part	NN
18637	973	25	of	of	IN
18637	973	26	the	the	DT
18637	973	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	973	28	.	.	.
18637	974	1	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	974	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	974	3	XVIII	xviii	NN
18637	974	4	.	.	.
18637	975	1	]	]	-RRB-
18637	975	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	975	3	j	j	NNP
18637	975	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	975	5	Section	section	NN
18637	975	6	1	1	CD
18637	975	7	.	.	.
18637	976	1	After	after	IN
18637	976	2	one	one	CD
18637	976	3	year	year	NN
18637	976	4	from	from	IN
18637	976	5	the	the	DT
18637	976	6	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	976	7	of	of	IN
18637	976	8	this	this	DT
18637	976	9	article	article	NN
18637	976	10	the	the	DT
18637	976	11	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	976	12	,	,	,
18637	976	13	sale	sale	NN
18637	976	14	,	,	,
18637	976	15	or	or	CC
18637	976	16	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	976	17	of	of	IN
18637	976	18	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	976	19	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	976	20	within	within	IN
18637	976	21	,	,	,
18637	976	22	the	the	DT
18637	976	23	importation	importation	NN
18637	976	24	thereof	thereof	VBD
18637	976	25	into	into	IN
18637	976	26	,	,	,
18637	976	27	or	or	CC
18637	976	28	the	the	DT
18637	976	29	exportation	exportation	NN
18637	976	30	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	976	31	from	from	IN
18637	976	32	the	the	DT
18637	976	33	United	United	NNP
18637	976	34	States	States	NNP
18637	976	35	and	and	CC
18637	976	36	all	all	DT
18637	976	37	territory	territory	NN
18637	976	38	subject	subject	JJ
18637	976	39	to	to	IN
18637	976	40	the	the	DT
18637	976	41	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	976	42	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	976	43	for	for	IN
18637	976	44	beverage	beverage	NN
18637	976	45	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	976	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	976	47	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	976	48	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	976	49	.	.	.
18637	977	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
18637	977	2	.	.	.
18637	978	1	2	2	LS
18637	978	2	.	.	.
18637	979	1	The	the	DT
18637	979	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	979	3	and	and	CC
18637	979	4	the	the	DT
18637	979	5	several	several	JJ
18637	979	6	States	state	NNS
18637	979	7	shall	shall	MD
18637	979	8	have	have	VB
18637	979	9	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	979	10	power	power	NN
18637	979	11	to	to	TO
18637	979	12	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	979	13	this	this	DT
18637	979	14	article	article	NN
18637	979	15	by	by	IN
18637	979	16	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	979	17	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	979	18	.	.	.
18637	980	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
18637	980	2	.	.	.
18637	981	1	3	3	LS
18637	981	2	.	.	.
18637	982	1	This	this	DT
18637	982	2	article	article	NN
18637	982	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	982	4	be	be	VB
18637	982	5	inoperative	inoperative	JJ
18637	982	6	unless	unless	IN
18637	982	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	982	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	982	9	have	have	VB
18637	982	10	been	be	VBN
18637	982	11	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	982	12	as	as	IN
18637	982	13	an	an	DT
18637	982	14	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	982	15	to	to	IN
18637	982	16	the	the	DT
18637	982	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	982	18	by	by	IN
18637	982	19	the	the	DT
18637	982	20	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	982	21	of	of	IN
18637	982	22	the	the	DT
18637	982	23	several	several	JJ
18637	982	24	States	States	NNPS
18637	982	25	,	,	,
18637	982	26	as	as	IN
18637	982	27	provided	provide	VBN
18637	982	28	in	in	IN
18637	982	29	the	the	DT
18637	982	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	982	31	,	,	,
18637	982	32	within	within	IN
18637	982	33	seven	seven	CD
18637	982	34	years	year	NNS
18637	982	35	from	from	IN
18637	982	36	the	the	DT
18637	982	37	date	date	NN
18637	982	38	of	of	IN
18637	982	39	the	the	DT
18637	982	40	submission	submission	NN
18637	982	41	hereof	hereof	NNP
18637	982	42	to	to	IN
18637	982	43	the	the	DT
18637	982	44	States	States	NNP
18637	982	45	by	by	IN
18637	982	46	the	the	DT
18637	982	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	982	48	.	.	.
18637	983	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	983	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	983	3	XIX	XIX	NNP
18637	983	4	.	.	.
18637	984	1	]	]	-RRB-
18637	984	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	984	3	k	k	NN
18637	984	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	984	5	The	the	DT
18637	984	6	right	right	NN
18637	984	7	of	of	IN
18637	984	8	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	984	9	of	of	IN
18637	984	10	the	the	DT
18637	984	11	United	United	NNP
18637	984	12	States	States	NNP
18637	984	13	to	to	TO
18637	984	14	vote	vote	VB
18637	984	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	984	16	not	not	RB
18637	984	17	be	be	VB
18637	984	18	denied	deny	VBN
18637	984	19	or	or	CC
18637	984	20	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	984	21	by	by	IN
18637	984	22	the	the	DT
18637	984	23	United	United	NNP
18637	984	24	States	States	NNP
18637	984	25	or	or	CC
18637	984	26	by	by	IN
18637	984	27	any	any	DT
18637	984	28	State	State	NNP
18637	984	29	on	on	IN
18637	984	30	account	account	NN
18637	984	31	of	of	IN
18637	984	32	sex	sex	NN
18637	984	33	.	.	.
18637	985	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	985	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	985	3	have	have	VB
18637	985	4	power	power	NN
18637	985	5	to	to	TO
18637	985	6	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	985	7	this	this	DT
18637	985	8	article	article	NN
18637	985	9	by	by	IN
18637	985	10	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	985	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	985	12	.	.	.
18637	986	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	986	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	986	3	XX	XX	NNP
18637	986	4	.	.	.
18637	987	1	]	]	-RRB-
18637	987	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	987	3	l	l	NN
18637	987	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	987	5	Section	section	NN
18637	987	6	1	1	CD
18637	987	7	.	.	.
18637	988	1	The	the	DT
18637	988	2	terms	term	NNS
18637	988	3	of	of	IN
18637	988	4	the	the	DT
18637	988	5	President	President	NNP
18637	988	6	and	and	CC
18637	988	7	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	988	8	President	President	NNP
18637	988	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	988	10	end	end	VB
18637	988	11	at	at	IN
18637	988	12	noon	noon	NN
18637	988	13	on	on	IN
18637	988	14	the	the	DT
18637	988	15	20th	20th	JJ
18637	988	16	day	day	NN
18637	988	17	of	of	IN
18637	988	18	January	January	NNP
18637	988	19	,	,	,
18637	988	20	and	and	CC
18637	988	21	the	the	DT
18637	988	22	terms	term	NNS
18637	988	23	of	of	IN
18637	988	24	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	988	25	and	and	CC
18637	988	26	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	988	27	at	at	IN
18637	988	28	noon	noon	NN
18637	988	29	on	on	IN
18637	988	30	the	the	DT
18637	988	31	3d	3d	JJ
18637	988	32	day	day	NN
18637	988	33	of	of	IN
18637	988	34	January	January	NNP
18637	988	35	,	,	,
18637	988	36	of	of	IN
18637	988	37	the	the	DT
18637	988	38	years	year	NNS
18637	988	39	in	in	IN
18637	988	40	which	which	WDT
18637	988	41	such	such	JJ
18637	988	42	terms	term	NNS
18637	988	43	would	would	MD
18637	988	44	have	have	VB
18637	988	45	ended	end	VBN
18637	988	46	if	if	IN
18637	988	47	this	this	DT
18637	988	48	article	article	NN
18637	988	49	had	have	VBD
18637	988	50	not	not	RB
18637	988	51	been	be	VBN
18637	988	52	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	988	53	;	;	:
18637	988	54	and	and	CC
18637	988	55	the	the	DT
18637	988	56	terms	term	NNS
18637	988	57	of	of	IN
18637	988	58	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	988	59	successors	successor	NNS
18637	988	60	shall	shall	MD
18637	988	61	then	then	RB
18637	988	62	begin	begin	VB
18637	988	63	.	.	.
18637	989	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
18637	989	2	.	.	.
18637	990	1	2	2	LS
18637	990	2	.	.	.
18637	991	1	The	the	DT
18637	991	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	991	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	991	4	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	991	5	at	at	IN
18637	991	6	least	least	JJS
18637	991	7	once	once	RB
18637	991	8	in	in	IN
18637	991	9	every	every	DT
18637	991	10	year	year	NN
18637	991	11	,	,	,
18637	991	12	and	and	CC
18637	991	13	such	such	JJ
18637	991	14	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	991	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	991	16	begin	begin	VB
18637	991	17	at	at	IN
18637	991	18	noon	noon	NN
18637	991	19	on	on	IN
18637	991	20	the	the	DT
18637	991	21	3d	3d	JJ
18637	991	22	day	day	NN
18637	991	23	of	of	IN
18637	991	24	January	January	NNP
18637	991	25	,	,	,
18637	991	26	unless	unless	IN
18637	991	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	991	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	991	29	by	by	IN
18637	991	30	law	law	NN
18637	991	31	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	991	32	a	a	DT
18637	991	33	different	different	JJ
18637	991	34	day	day	NN
18637	991	35	.	.	.
18637	992	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
18637	992	2	.	.	.
18637	993	1	3	3	LS
18637	993	2	.	.	.
18637	994	1	If	if	IN
18637	994	2	,	,	,
18637	994	3	at	at	IN
18637	994	4	the	the	DT
18637	994	5	time	time	NN
18637	994	6	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	994	7	for	for	IN
18637	994	8	the	the	DT
18637	994	9	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	994	10	of	of	IN
18637	994	11	the	the	DT
18637	994	12	term	term	NN
18637	994	13	of	of	IN
18637	994	14	the	the	DT
18637	994	15	President	President	NNP
18637	994	16	,	,	,
18637	994	17	the	the	DT
18637	994	18	President	President	NNP
18637	994	19	elect	elect	NN
18637	994	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	994	21	have	have	VB
18637	994	22	died	die	VBN
18637	994	23	,	,	,
18637	994	24	the	the	DT
18637	994	25	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	994	26	President	President	NNP
18637	994	27	elect	elect	NNP
18637	994	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	994	29	become	become	VB
18637	994	30	President	President	NNP
18637	994	31	.	.	.
18637	995	1	If	if	IN
18637	995	2	a	a	DT
18637	995	3	President	President	NNP
18637	995	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	995	5	not	not	RB
18637	995	6	have	have	VB
18637	995	7	been	be	VBN
18637	995	8	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	995	9	before	before	IN
18637	995	10	the	the	DT
18637	995	11	time	time	NN
18637	995	12	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	995	13	for	for	IN
18637	995	14	the	the	DT
18637	995	15	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	995	16	of	of	IN
18637	995	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	995	18	term	term	NN
18637	995	19	,	,	,
18637	995	20	or	or	CC
18637	995	21	if	if	IN
18637	995	22	the	the	DT
18637	995	23	President	President	NNP
18637	995	24	elect	elect	NN
18637	995	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	995	26	have	have	VB
18637	995	27	failed	fail	VBN
18637	995	28	to	to	TO
18637	995	29	qualify	qualify	VB
18637	995	30	,	,	,
18637	995	31	then	then	RB
18637	995	32	the	the	DT
18637	995	33	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	995	34	President	President	NNP
18637	995	35	elect	elect	NNP
18637	995	36	shall	shall	MD
18637	995	37	act	act	VB
18637	995	38	as	as	IN
18637	995	39	President	President	NNP
18637	995	40	until	until	IN
18637	995	41	a	a	DT
18637	995	42	President	President	NNP
18637	995	43	shall	shall	MD
18637	995	44	have	have	VB
18637	995	45	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	995	46	;	;	:
18637	995	47	and	and	CC
18637	995	48	the	the	DT
18637	995	49	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	995	50	may	may	MD
18637	995	51	by	by	IN
18637	995	52	law	law	NN
18637	995	53	provide	provide	VB
18637	995	54	for	for	IN
18637	995	55	the	the	DT
18637	995	56	case	case	NN
18637	995	57	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	995	58	neither	neither	CC
18637	995	59	a	a	DT
18637	995	60	President	President	NNP
18637	995	61	elect	elect	NN
18637	995	62	nor	nor	CC
18637	995	63	a	a	DT
18637	995	64	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	995	65	President	President	NNP
18637	995	66	elect	elect	NN
18637	995	67	shall	shall	MD
18637	995	68	have	have	VB
18637	995	69	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	995	70	,	,	,
18637	995	71	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	995	72	who	who	WP
18637	995	73	shall	shall	MD
18637	995	74	then	then	RB
18637	995	75	act	act	VB
18637	995	76	as	as	IN
18637	995	77	President	President	NNP
18637	995	78	,	,	,
18637	995	79	or	or	CC
18637	995	80	the	the	DT
18637	995	81	manner	manner	NN
18637	995	82	in	in	IN
18637	995	83	which	which	WDT
18637	995	84	one	one	NN
18637	995	85	who	who	WP
18637	995	86	is	be	VBZ
18637	995	87	to	to	TO
18637	995	88	act	act	VB
18637	995	89	shall	shall	MD
18637	995	90	be	be	VB
18637	995	91	selected	select	VBN
18637	995	92	,	,	,
18637	995	93	and	and	CC
18637	995	94	such	such	JJ
18637	995	95	person	person	NN
18637	995	96	shall	shall	MD
18637	995	97	act	act	VB
18637	995	98	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	995	99	until	until	IN
18637	995	100	a	a	DT
18637	995	101	President	President	NNP
18637	995	102	or	or	CC
18637	995	103	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	995	104	President	President	NNP
18637	995	105	shall	shall	MD
18637	995	106	have	have	VB
18637	995	107	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	995	108	.	.	.
18637	996	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
18637	996	2	.	.	.
18637	997	1	4	4	LS
18637	997	2	.	.	.
18637	998	1	The	the	DT
18637	998	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	998	3	may	may	MD
18637	998	4	by	by	IN
18637	998	5	law	law	NN
18637	998	6	provide	provide	VB
18637	998	7	for	for	IN
18637	998	8	the	the	DT
18637	998	9	case	case	NN
18637	998	10	of	of	IN
18637	998	11	the	the	DT
18637	998	12	death	death	NN
18637	998	13	of	of	IN
18637	998	14	any	any	DT
18637	998	15	of	of	IN
18637	998	16	the	the	DT
18637	998	17	persons	person	NNS
18637	998	18	from	from	IN
18637	998	19	whom	whom	WP
18637	998	20	the	the	DT
18637	998	21	House	House	NNP
18637	998	22	of	of	IN
18637	998	23	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	998	24	may	may	MD
18637	998	25	choose	choose	VB
18637	998	26	a	a	DT
18637	998	27	President	President	NNP
18637	998	28	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	998	29	the	the	DT
18637	998	30	right	right	NN
18637	998	31	of	of	IN
18637	998	32	choice	choice	NN
18637	998	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	998	34	have	have	VB
18637	998	35	devolved	devolve	VBN
18637	998	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	998	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	998	38	,	,	,
18637	998	39	and	and	CC
18637	998	40	for	for	IN
18637	998	41	the	the	DT
18637	998	42	case	case	NN
18637	998	43	of	of	IN
18637	998	44	the	the	DT
18637	998	45	death	death	NN
18637	998	46	of	of	IN
18637	998	47	any	any	DT
18637	998	48	of	of	IN
18637	998	49	the	the	DT
18637	998	50	persons	person	NNS
18637	998	51	from	from	IN
18637	998	52	whom	whom	WP
18637	998	53	the	the	DT
18637	998	54	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	998	55	may	may	MD
18637	998	56	choose	choose	VB
18637	998	57	a	a	DT
18637	998	58	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	998	59	President	President	NNP
18637	998	60	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	998	61	the	the	DT
18637	998	62	right	right	NN
18637	998	63	of	of	IN
18637	998	64	choice	choice	NN
18637	998	65	shall	shall	MD
18637	998	66	have	have	VB
18637	998	67	devolved	devolve	VBN
18637	998	68	upon	upon	IN
18637	998	69	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	998	70	.	.	.
18637	999	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
18637	999	2	.	.	.
18637	1000	1	5	5	CD
18637	1000	2	.	.	.
18637	1001	1	Sections	section	NNS
18637	1001	2	1	1	CD
18637	1001	3	and	and	CC
18637	1001	4	2	2	CD
18637	1001	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	1001	6	take	take	VB
18637	1001	7	effect	effect	NN
18637	1001	8	on	on	IN
18637	1001	9	the	the	DT
18637	1001	10	15th	15th	JJ
18637	1001	11	day	day	NN
18637	1001	12	of	of	IN
18637	1001	13	October	October	NNP
18637	1001	14	following	follow	VBG
18637	1001	15	the	the	DT
18637	1001	16	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1001	17	of	of	IN
18637	1001	18	this	this	DT
18637	1001	19	article	article	NN
18637	1001	20	.	.	.
18637	1002	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
18637	1002	2	.	.	.
18637	1003	1	6	6	CD
18637	1003	2	.	.	.
18637	1004	1	This	this	DT
18637	1004	2	article	article	NN
18637	1004	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	1004	4	be	be	VB
18637	1004	5	inoperative	inoperative	JJ
18637	1004	6	unless	unless	IN
18637	1004	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1004	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	1004	9	have	have	VB
18637	1004	10	been	be	VBN
18637	1004	11	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1004	12	as	as	IN
18637	1004	13	an	an	DT
18637	1004	14	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1004	15	to	to	IN
18637	1004	16	the	the	DT
18637	1004	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1004	18	by	by	IN
18637	1004	19	the	the	DT
18637	1004	20	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1004	21	of	of	IN
18637	1004	22	three	three	CD
18637	1004	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	1004	24	fourths	fourth	NNS
18637	1004	25	of	of	IN
18637	1004	26	the	the	DT
18637	1004	27	several	several	JJ
18637	1004	28	States	state	NNS
18637	1004	29	within	within	IN
18637	1004	30	seven	seven	CD
18637	1004	31	years	year	NNS
18637	1004	32	from	from	IN
18637	1004	33	the	the	DT
18637	1004	34	date	date	NN
18637	1004	35	of	of	IN
18637	1004	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1004	37	submission	submission	NN
18637	1004	38	.	.	.
18637	1005	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1005	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1005	3	XXI	XXI	NNP
18637	1005	4	.	.	.
18637	1006	1	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1006	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1006	3	m	m	NN
18637	1006	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1006	5	Section	section	NN
18637	1006	6	1	1	CD
18637	1006	7	.	.	.
18637	1007	1	The	the	DT
18637	1007	2	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
18637	1007	3	article	article	NN
18637	1007	4	of	of	IN
18637	1007	5	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1007	6	to	to	IN
18637	1007	7	the	the	DT
18637	1007	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1007	9	of	of	IN
18637	1007	10	the	the	DT
18637	1007	11	United	United	NNP
18637	1007	12	States	States	NNP
18637	1007	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	1007	14	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	1007	15	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	1007	16	.	.	.
18637	1008	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
18637	1008	2	.	.	.
18637	1009	1	2	2	LS
18637	1009	2	.	.	.
18637	1010	1	The	the	DT
18637	1010	2	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1010	3	or	or	CC
18637	1010	4	importation	importation	NN
18637	1010	5	into	into	IN
18637	1010	6	any	any	DT
18637	1010	7	State	State	NNP
18637	1010	8	,	,	,
18637	1010	9	Territory	territory	NN
18637	1010	10	,	,	,
18637	1010	11	or	or	CC
18637	1010	12	possession	possession	NN
18637	1010	13	of	of	IN
18637	1010	14	the	the	DT
18637	1010	15	United	United	NNP
18637	1010	16	States	States	NNP
18637	1010	17	for	for	IN
18637	1010	18	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	1010	19	or	or	CC
18637	1010	20	use	use	VBP
18637	1010	21	therein	therein	RB
18637	1010	22	of	of	IN
18637	1010	23	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	1010	24	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	1010	25	,	,	,
18637	1010	26	in	in	IN
18637	1010	27	violation	violation	NN
18637	1010	28	of	of	IN
18637	1010	29	the	the	DT
18637	1010	30	laws	law	NNS
18637	1010	31	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	1010	32	,	,	,
18637	1010	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	1010	34	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	1010	35	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	1010	36	.	.	.
18637	1011	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
18637	1011	2	.	.	.
18637	1012	1	3	3	LS
18637	1012	2	.	.	.
18637	1013	1	This	this	DT
18637	1013	2	article	article	NN
18637	1013	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	1013	4	be	be	VB
18637	1013	5	inoperative	inoperative	JJ
18637	1013	6	unless	unless	IN
18637	1013	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1013	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	1013	9	have	have	VB
18637	1013	10	been	be	VBN
18637	1013	11	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1013	12	as	as	IN
18637	1013	13	an	an	DT
18637	1013	14	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1013	15	to	to	IN
18637	1013	16	the	the	DT
18637	1013	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1013	18	by	by	IN
18637	1013	19	conventions	convention	NNS
18637	1013	20	in	in	IN
18637	1013	21	the	the	DT
18637	1013	22	several	several	JJ
18637	1013	23	States	States	NNPS
18637	1013	24	,	,	,
18637	1013	25	as	as	IN
18637	1013	26	provided	provide	VBN
18637	1013	27	in	in	IN
18637	1013	28	the	the	DT
18637	1013	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1013	30	,	,	,
18637	1013	31	within	within	IN
18637	1013	32	seven	seven	CD
18637	1013	33	years	year	NNS
18637	1013	34	from	from	IN
18637	1013	35	the	the	DT
18637	1013	36	date	date	NN
18637	1013	37	of	of	IN
18637	1013	38	the	the	DT
18637	1013	39	submission	submission	NN
18637	1013	40	hereof	hereof	NNP
18637	1013	41	to	to	IN
18637	1013	42	the	the	DT
18637	1013	43	States	States	NNP
18637	1013	44	by	by	IN
18637	1013	45	the	the	DT
18637	1013	46	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1013	47	.	.	.
18637	1014	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1014	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1014	3	XXII	XXII	NNP
18637	1014	4	.	.	.
18637	1015	1	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1015	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1015	3	n	n	NN
18637	1015	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1015	5	Section	section	NN
18637	1015	6	1	1	CD
18637	1015	7	.	.	.
18637	1016	1	No	no	DT
18637	1016	2	person	person	NN
18637	1016	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	1016	4	be	be	VB
18637	1016	5	elected	elect	VBN
18637	1016	6	to	to	IN
18637	1016	7	the	the	DT
18637	1016	8	office	office	NN
18637	1016	9	of	of	IN
18637	1016	10	the	the	DT
18637	1016	11	President	President	NNP
18637	1016	12	more	more	RBR
18637	1016	13	than	than	IN
18637	1016	14	twice	twice	RB
18637	1016	15	,	,	,
18637	1016	16	and	and	CC
18637	1016	17	no	no	DT
18637	1016	18	person	person	NN
18637	1016	19	who	who	WP
18637	1016	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	1016	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	1016	22	the	the	DT
18637	1016	23	office	office	NN
18637	1016	24	of	of	IN
18637	1016	25	President	President	NNP
18637	1016	26	,	,	,
18637	1016	27	or	or	CC
18637	1016	28	acted	act	VBD
18637	1016	29	as	as	IN
18637	1016	30	President	President	NNP
18637	1016	31	,	,	,
18637	1016	32	for	for	IN
18637	1016	33	more	more	JJR
18637	1016	34	than	than	IN
18637	1016	35	two	two	CD
18637	1016	36	years	year	NNS
18637	1016	37	of	of	IN
18637	1016	38	a	a	DT
18637	1016	39	term	term	NN
18637	1016	40	to	to	TO
18637	1016	41	which	which	WDT
18637	1016	42	some	some	DT
18637	1016	43	other	other	JJ
18637	1016	44	person	person	NN
18637	1016	45	was	be	VBD
18637	1016	46	elected	elect	VBN
18637	1016	47	President	President	NNP
18637	1016	48	shall	shall	MD
18637	1016	49	be	be	VB
18637	1016	50	elected	elect	VBN
18637	1016	51	to	to	IN
18637	1016	52	the	the	DT
18637	1016	53	office	office	NN
18637	1016	54	of	of	IN
18637	1016	55	the	the	DT
18637	1016	56	President	President	NNP
18637	1016	57	more	more	RBR
18637	1016	58	than	than	IN
18637	1016	59	once	once	RB
18637	1016	60	.	.	.
18637	1017	1	But	but	CC
18637	1017	2	this	this	DT
18637	1017	3	Article	article	NN
18637	1017	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	1017	5	not	not	RB
18637	1017	6	apply	apply	VB
18637	1017	7	to	to	IN
18637	1017	8	any	any	DT
18637	1017	9	person	person	NN
18637	1017	10	holding	hold	VBG
18637	1017	11	the	the	DT
18637	1017	12	office	office	NN
18637	1017	13	of	of	IN
18637	1017	14	President	President	NNP
18637	1017	15	when	when	WRB
18637	1017	16	this	this	DT
18637	1017	17	Article	article	NN
18637	1017	18	was	be	VBD
18637	1017	19	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1017	20	by	by	IN
18637	1017	21	the	the	DT
18637	1017	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1017	23	,	,	,
18637	1017	24	and	and	CC
18637	1017	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	1017	26	not	not	RB
18637	1017	27	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	1017	28	any	any	DT
18637	1017	29	person	person	NN
18637	1017	30	who	who	WP
18637	1017	31	may	may	MD
18637	1017	32	be	be	VB
18637	1017	33	holding	hold	VBG
18637	1017	34	the	the	DT
18637	1017	35	office	office	NN
18637	1017	36	of	of	IN
18637	1017	37	President	President	NNP
18637	1017	38	,	,	,
18637	1017	39	or	or	CC
18637	1017	40	acting	act	VBG
18637	1017	41	as	as	IN
18637	1017	42	President	President	NNP
18637	1017	43	,	,	,
18637	1017	44	during	during	IN
18637	1017	45	the	the	DT
18637	1017	46	term	term	NN
18637	1017	47	within	within	IN
18637	1017	48	which	which	WDT
18637	1017	49	this	this	DT
18637	1017	50	Article	article	NN
18637	1017	51	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	1017	52	operative	operative	JJ
18637	1017	53	from	from	IN
18637	1017	54	holding	hold	VBG
18637	1017	55	the	the	DT
18637	1017	56	office	office	NN
18637	1017	57	of	of	IN
18637	1017	58	President	President	NNP
18637	1017	59	or	or	CC
18637	1017	60	acting	act	VBG
18637	1017	61	as	as	IN
18637	1017	62	President	President	NNP
18637	1017	63	during	during	IN
18637	1017	64	the	the	DT
18637	1017	65	remainder	remainder	NN
18637	1017	66	of	of	IN
18637	1017	67	such	such	JJ
18637	1017	68	term	term	NN
18637	1017	69	.	.	.
18637	1018	1	Section	section	NN
18637	1018	2	2	2	CD
18637	1018	3	.	.	.
18637	1019	1	This	this	DT
18637	1019	2	Article	article	NN
18637	1019	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	1019	4	be	be	VB
18637	1019	5	inoperative	inoperative	JJ
18637	1019	6	unless	unless	IN
18637	1019	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1019	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	1019	9	have	have	VB
18637	1019	10	been	be	VBN
18637	1019	11	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1019	12	as	as	IN
18637	1019	13	an	an	DT
18637	1019	14	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1019	15	to	to	IN
18637	1019	16	the	the	DT
18637	1019	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1019	18	by	by	IN
18637	1019	19	the	the	DT
18637	1019	20	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1019	21	of	of	IN
18637	1019	22	three	three	CD
18637	1019	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	1019	24	fourths	fourth	NNS
18637	1019	25	of	of	IN
18637	1019	26	the	the	DT
18637	1019	27	several	several	JJ
18637	1019	28	States	state	NNS
18637	1019	29	within	within	IN
18637	1019	30	seven	seven	CD
18637	1019	31	years	year	NNS
18637	1019	32	from	from	IN
18637	1019	33	the	the	DT
18637	1019	34	date	date	NN
18637	1019	35	of	of	IN
18637	1019	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1019	37	submission	submission	NN
18637	1019	38	to	to	IN
18637	1019	39	the	the	DT
18637	1019	40	States	States	NNP
18637	1019	41	by	by	IN
18637	1019	42	the	the	DT
18637	1019	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1019	44	.	.	.
18637	1020	1	Notes	note	NNS
18637	1020	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1020	3	a	a	DT
18637	1020	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1020	5	In	In	NNP
18637	1020	6	Dillon	Dillon	NNP
18637	1020	7	_	_	NNP
18637	1020	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	1020	9	_	_	NNP
18637	1020	10	Gloss	Gloss	NNP
18637	1020	11	,	,	,
18637	1020	12	256	256	CD
18637	1020	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	1020	14	368	368	CD
18637	1020	15	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1020	16	1921	1921	CD
18637	1020	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1020	18	,	,	,
18637	1020	19	the	the	DT
18637	1020	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1020	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1020	22	stated	state	VBD
18637	1020	23	that	that	IN
18637	1020	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1020	25	would	would	MD
18637	1020	26	take	take	VB
18637	1020	27	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1020	28	notice	notice	NN
18637	1020	29	of	of	IN
18637	1020	30	the	the	DT
18637	1020	31	date	date	NN
18637	1020	32	on	on	IN
18637	1020	33	which	which	WDT
18637	1020	34	a	a	DT
18637	1020	35	State	state	NN
18637	1020	36	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1020	37	a	a	DT
18637	1020	38	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1020	39	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1020	40	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1020	41	.	.	.
18637	1021	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	1021	2	the	the	DT
18637	1021	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1021	4	consulted	consult	VBD
18637	1021	5	the	the	DT
18637	1021	6	State	State	NNP
18637	1021	7	Journals	Journals	NNPS
18637	1021	8	to	to	TO
18637	1021	9	determine	determine	VB
18637	1021	10	the	the	DT
18637	1021	11	dates	date	NNS
18637	1021	12	on	on	IN
18637	1021	13	which	which	WDT
18637	1021	14	each	each	DT
18637	1021	15	house	house	NN
18637	1021	16	of	of	IN
18637	1021	17	the	the	DT
18637	1021	18	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1021	19	of	of	IN
18637	1021	20	certain	certain	JJ
18637	1021	21	States	States	NNP
18637	1021	22	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1021	23	the	the	DT
18637	1021	24	18th	18th	JJ
18637	1021	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1021	26	.	.	.
18637	1022	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1022	2	,	,	,
18637	1022	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	1022	4	,	,	,
18637	1022	5	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	1022	6	that	that	IN
18637	1022	7	the	the	DT
18637	1022	8	date	date	NN
18637	1022	9	on	on	IN
18637	1022	10	which	which	WDT
18637	1022	11	the	the	DT
18637	1022	12	governor	governor	NN
18637	1022	13	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1022	14	the	the	DT
18637	1022	15	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1022	16	,	,	,
18637	1022	17	or	or	CC
18637	1022	18	the	the	DT
18637	1022	19	date	date	NN
18637	1022	20	on	on	IN
18637	1022	21	which	which	WDT
18637	1022	22	the	the	DT
18637	1022	23	secretary	secretary	NNP
18637	1022	24	of	of	IN
18637	1022	25	state	state	NN
18637	1022	26	of	of	IN
18637	1022	27	a	a	DT
18637	1022	28	given	give	VBN
18637	1022	29	State	State	NNP
18637	1022	30	certified	certify	VBD
18637	1022	31	the	the	DT
18637	1022	32	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1022	33	,	,	,
18637	1022	34	or	or	CC
18637	1022	35	the	the	DT
18637	1022	36	date	date	NN
18637	1022	37	on	on	IN
18637	1022	38	which	which	WDT
18637	1022	39	the	the	DT
18637	1022	40	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1022	41	of	of	IN
18637	1022	42	State	State	NNP
18637	1022	43	of	of	IN
18637	1022	44	the	the	DT
18637	1022	45	United	United	NNP
18637	1022	46	States	States	NNP
18637	1022	47	received	receive	VBD
18637	1022	48	a	a	DT
18637	1022	49	copy	copy	NN
18637	1022	50	of	of	IN
18637	1022	51	said	say	VBN
18637	1022	52	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	1022	53	,	,	,
18637	1022	54	or	or	CC
18637	1022	55	the	the	DT
18637	1022	56	date	date	NN
18637	1022	57	on	on	IN
18637	1022	58	which	which	WDT
18637	1022	59	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1022	60	proclaimed	proclaim	VBD
18637	1022	61	that	that	IN
18637	1022	62	the	the	DT
18637	1022	63	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1022	64	had	have	VBD
18637	1022	65	been	be	VBN
18637	1022	66	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1022	67	are	be	VBP
18637	1022	68	not	not	RB
18637	1022	69	controlling	control	VBG
18637	1022	70	.	.	.
18637	1023	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	1023	2	,	,	,
18637	1023	3	the	the	DT
18637	1023	4	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1023	5	date	date	NN
18637	1023	6	given	give	VBN
18637	1023	7	in	in	IN
18637	1023	8	the	the	DT
18637	1023	9	following	follow	VBG
18637	1023	10	notes	note	NNS
18637	1023	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	1023	12	the	the	DT
18637	1023	13	date	date	NN
18637	1023	14	on	on	IN
18637	1023	15	which	which	WDT
18637	1023	16	the	the	DT
18637	1023	17	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1023	18	of	of	IN
18637	1023	19	a	a	DT
18637	1023	20	given	give	VBN
18637	1023	21	State	state	NN
18637	1023	22	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1023	23	the	the	DT
18637	1023	24	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1023	25	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1023	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1023	27	signature	signature	NN
18637	1023	28	by	by	IN
18637	1023	29	the	the	DT
18637	1023	30	speaker	speaker	NN
18637	1023	31	or	or	CC
18637	1023	32	presiding	preside	VBG
18637	1023	33	officers	officer	NNS
18637	1023	34	of	of	IN
18637	1023	35	both	both	DT
18637	1023	36	houses	house	NNS
18637	1023	37	being	be	VBG
18637	1023	38	considered	consider	VBN
18637	1023	39	a	a	DT
18637	1023	40	part	part	NN
18637	1023	41	of	of	IN
18637	1023	42	the	the	DT
18637	1023	43	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1023	44	of	of	IN
18637	1023	45	the	the	DT
18637	1023	46	"	"	``
18637	1023	47	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1023	48	"	"	''
18637	1023	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1023	50	.	.	.
18637	1024	1	When	when	WRB
18637	1024	2	that	that	DT
18637	1024	3	date	date	NN
18637	1024	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	1024	5	not	not	RB
18637	1024	6	available	available	JJ
18637	1024	7	,	,	,
18637	1024	8	the	the	DT
18637	1024	9	date	date	NN
18637	1024	10	given	give	VBN
18637	1024	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	1024	12	that	that	DT
18637	1024	13	on	on	IN
18637	1024	14	which	which	WDT
18637	1024	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1024	16	was	be	VBD
18637	1024	17	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1024	18	by	by	IN
18637	1024	19	the	the	DT
18637	1024	20	governor	governor	NN
18637	1024	21	or	or	CC
18637	1024	22	certified	certify	VBN
18637	1024	23	by	by	IN
18637	1024	24	the	the	DT
18637	1024	25	secretary	secretary	NNP
18637	1024	26	of	of	IN
18637	1024	27	state	state	NN
18637	1024	28	of	of	IN
18637	1024	29	the	the	DT
18637	1024	30	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1024	31	State	State	NNP
18637	1024	32	.	.	.
18637	1025	1	In	in	IN
18637	1025	2	each	each	DT
18637	1025	3	case	case	NN
18637	1025	4	such	such	JJ
18637	1025	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	1025	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	1025	7	been	be	VBN
18637	1025	8	noted	note	VBN
18637	1025	9	.	.	.
18637	1026	1	Except	except	IN
18637	1026	2	as	as	IN
18637	1026	3	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	1026	4	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	1026	5	information	information	NN
18637	1026	6	as	as	IN
18637	1026	7	to	to	IN
18637	1026	8	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1026	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	1026	10	based	base	VBN
18637	1026	11	on	on	IN
18637	1026	12	data	datum	NNS
18637	1026	13	supplied	supply	VBN
18637	1026	14	by	by	IN
18637	1026	15	the	the	DT
18637	1026	16	Department	Department	NNP
18637	1026	17	of	of	IN
18637	1026	18	State	State	NNP
18637	1026	19	.	.	.
18637	1027	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1027	2	b	b	NN
18637	1027	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1027	4	Brackets	bracket	NNS
18637	1027	5	enclosing	enclose	VBG
18637	1027	6	an	an	DT
18637	1027	7	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1027	8	number	number	NN
18637	1027	9	indicate	indicate	VBP
18637	1027	10	that	that	IN
18637	1027	11	the	the	DT
18637	1027	12	number	number	NN
18637	1027	13	was	be	VBD
18637	1027	14	not	not	RB
18637	1027	15	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	1027	16	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	1027	17	in	in	IN
18637	1027	18	the	the	DT
18637	1027	19	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	1027	20	proposing	propose	VBG
18637	1027	21	the	the	DT
18637	1027	22	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1027	23	.	.	.
18637	1028	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1028	2	will	will	MD
18637	1028	3	be	be	VB
18637	1028	4	seen	see	VBN
18637	1028	5	,	,	,
18637	1028	6	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	1028	7	,	,	,
18637	1028	8	that	that	IN
18637	1028	9	only	only	JJ
18637	1028	10	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	1028	11	XIII	XIII	NNP
18637	1028	12	,	,	,
18637	1028	13	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	1028	14	,	,	,
18637	1028	15	XV	XV	NNP
18637	1028	16	and	and	CC
18637	1028	17	XVI	XVI	NNP
18637	1028	18	were	be	VBD
18637	1028	19	thus	thus	RB
18637	1028	20	technically	technically	RB
18637	1028	21	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1028	22	by	by	IN
18637	1028	23	number	number	NN
18637	1028	24	.	.	.
18637	1029	1	The	the	DT
18637	1029	2	first	first	JJ
18637	1029	3	10	10	CD
18637	1029	4	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	1029	5	along	along	IN
18637	1029	6	with	with	IN
18637	1029	7	2	2	CD
18637	1029	8	others	other	NNS
18637	1029	9	which	which	WDT
18637	1029	10	failed	fail	VBD
18637	1029	11	of	of	IN
18637	1029	12	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1029	13	were	be	VBD
18637	1029	14	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1029	15	by	by	IN
18637	1029	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1029	17	on	on	IN
18637	1029	18	September	September	NNP
18637	1029	19	25	25	CD
18637	1029	20	,	,	,
18637	1029	21	1789	1789	CD
18637	1029	22	,	,	,
18637	1029	23	when	when	WRB
18637	1029	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1029	25	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1029	26	the	the	DT
18637	1029	27	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1029	28	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1029	29	1	1	CD
18637	1029	30	Ann	Ann	NNP
18637	1029	31	.	.	.
18637	1030	1	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1030	2	.	.	.
18637	1031	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1031	2	1st	1st	NNP
18637	1031	3	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1031	4	.	.	NNP
18637	1031	5	,	,	,
18637	1031	6	1st	1st	JJ
18637	1031	7	sess	sess	NN
18637	1031	8	.	.	.
18637	1031	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1032	1	90	90	CD
18637	1032	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1032	3	,	,	,
18637	1032	4	having	have	VBG
18637	1032	5	previously	previously	RB
18637	1032	6	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1032	7	the	the	DT
18637	1032	8	House	House	NNP
18637	1032	9	on	on	IN
18637	1032	10	September	September	NNP
18637	1032	11	24	24	CD
18637	1032	12	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1032	13	_	_	NNP
18637	1032	14	Id.	Idaho	NNP
18637	1032	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1032	16	,	,	,
18637	1032	17	948	948	CD
18637	1032	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1032	19	.	.	.
18637	1033	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1033	2	appear	appear	VBP
18637	1033	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1033	4	in	in	IN
18637	1033	5	1	1	CD
18637	1033	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1033	7	.	.	.
18637	1034	1	97	97	CD
18637	1034	2	.	.	.
18637	1035	1	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1035	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1035	3	completed	complete	VBN
18637	1035	4	on	on	IN
18637	1035	5	December	December	NNP
18637	1035	6	15	15	CD
18637	1035	7	,	,	,
18637	1035	8	1791	1791	CD
18637	1035	9	,	,	,
18637	1035	10	when	when	WRB
18637	1035	11	the	the	DT
18637	1035	12	eleventh	eleventh	JJ
18637	1035	13	State	State	NNP
18637	1035	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1035	15	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1035	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1035	17	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1035	18	these	these	DT
18637	1035	19	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	1035	20	,	,	,
18637	1035	21	there	there	EX
18637	1035	22	being	be	VBG
18637	1035	23	then	then	RB
18637	1035	24	14	14	CD
18637	1035	25	States	state	NNS
18637	1035	26	in	in	IN
18637	1035	27	the	the	DT
18637	1035	28	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1035	29	.	.	.
18637	1036	1	The	the	DT
18637	1036	2	several	several	JJ
18637	1036	3	State	State	NNP
18637	1036	4	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1036	5	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1036	6	the	the	DT
18637	1036	7	first	first	JJ
18637	1036	8	10	10	CD
18637	1036	9	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	1036	10	to	to	IN
18637	1036	11	the	the	DT
18637	1036	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1036	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1036	14	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	1037	1	nos	nos	NNP
18637	1037	2	.	.	.
18637	1038	1	3	3	CD
18637	1038	2	to	to	IN
18637	1038	3	12	12	CD
18637	1038	4	of	of	IN
18637	1038	5	those	those	DT
18637	1038	6	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1038	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1038	8	on	on	IN
18637	1038	9	the	the	DT
18637	1038	10	following	follow	VBG
18637	1038	11	dates	date	NNS
18637	1038	12	:	:	:
18637	1038	13	New	New	NNP
18637	1038	14	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1038	15	,	,	,
18637	1038	16	November	November	NNP
18637	1038	17	20	20	CD
18637	1038	18	,	,	,
18637	1038	19	1789	1789	CD
18637	1038	20	;	;	:
18637	1038	21	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1038	22	,	,	,
18637	1038	23	December	December	NNP
18637	1038	24	19	19	CD
18637	1038	25	,	,	,
18637	1038	26	1789	1789	CD
18637	1038	27	;	;	:
18637	1038	28	North	North	NNP
18637	1038	29	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1038	30	,	,	,
18637	1038	31	December	December	NNP
18637	1038	32	22	22	CD
18637	1038	33	,	,	,
18637	1038	34	1789	1789	CD
18637	1038	35	;	;	:
18637	1038	36	South	South	NNP
18637	1038	37	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1038	38	,	,	,
18637	1038	39	January	January	NNP
18637	1038	40	19	19	CD
18637	1038	41	,	,	,
18637	1038	42	1790	1790	CD
18637	1038	43	;	;	:
18637	1038	44	New	New	NNP
18637	1038	45	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1038	46	,	,	,
18637	1038	47	January	January	NNP
18637	1038	48	25	25	CD
18637	1038	49	,	,	,
18637	1038	50	1790	1790	CD
18637	1038	51	;	;	:
18637	1038	52	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	1038	53	,	,	,
18637	1038	54	January	January	NNP
18637	1038	55	28	28	CD
18637	1038	56	,	,	,
18637	1038	57	1790	1790	CD
18637	1038	58	;	;	:
18637	1038	59	New	New	NNP
18637	1038	60	York	York	NNP
18637	1038	61	,	,	,
18637	1038	62	February	February	NNP
18637	1038	63	27	27	CD
18637	1038	64	,	,	,
18637	1038	65	1790	1790	CD
18637	1038	66	;	;	:
18637	1038	67	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	1038	68	,	,	,
18637	1038	69	March	March	NNP
18637	1038	70	10	10	CD
18637	1038	71	,	,	,
18637	1038	72	1790	1790	CD
18637	1038	73	;	;	:
18637	1038	74	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	1038	75	Island	Island	NNP
18637	1038	76	,	,	,
18637	1038	77	June	June	NNP
18637	1038	78	7	7	CD
18637	1038	79	,	,	,
18637	1038	80	1790	1790	CD
18637	1038	81	;	;	:
18637	1038	82	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	1038	83	,	,	,
18637	1038	84	November	November	NNP
18637	1038	85	3	3	CD
18637	1038	86	,	,	,
18637	1038	87	1791	1791	CD
18637	1038	88	;	;	:
18637	1038	89	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1038	90	,	,	,
18637	1038	91	December	December	NNP
18637	1038	92	15	15	CD
18637	1038	93	,	,	,
18637	1038	94	1791	1791	CD
18637	1038	95	.	.	.
18637	1039	1	The	the	DT
18637	1039	2	two	two	CD
18637	1039	3	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	1039	4	which	which	WDT
18637	1039	5	failed	fail	VBD
18637	1039	6	of	of	IN
18637	1039	7	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1039	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1039	9	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	1040	1	nos	nos	NNP
18637	1040	2	.	.	.
18637	1041	1	1	1	CD
18637	1041	2	and	and	CC
18637	1041	3	2	2	CD
18637	1041	4	of	of	IN
18637	1041	5	those	those	DT
18637	1041	6	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1041	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1041	8	prescribed	prescribe	VBD
18637	1041	9	the	the	DT
18637	1041	10	ratio	ratio	NN
18637	1041	11	of	of	IN
18637	1041	12	representation	representation	NN
18637	1041	13	to	to	IN
18637	1041	14	population	population	NN
18637	1041	15	in	in	IN
18637	1041	16	the	the	DT
18637	1041	17	House	House	NNP
18637	1041	18	,	,	,
18637	1041	19	and	and	CC
18637	1041	20	specified	specify	VBD
18637	1041	21	that	that	IN
18637	1041	22	no	no	DT
18637	1041	23	law	law	NN
18637	1041	24	varying	vary	VBG
18637	1041	25	the	the	DT
18637	1041	26	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	1041	27	of	of	IN
18637	1041	28	members	member	NNS
18637	1041	29	of	of	IN
18637	1041	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1041	31	should	should	MD
18637	1041	32	be	be	VB
18637	1041	33	effective	effective	JJ
18637	1041	34	until	until	IN
18637	1041	35	after	after	IN
18637	1041	36	an	an	DT
18637	1041	37	intervening	intervene	VBG
18637	1041	38	election	election	NN
18637	1041	39	of	of	IN
18637	1041	40	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1041	41	.	.	.
18637	1042	1	The	the	DT
18637	1042	2	first	first	JJ
18637	1042	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1042	4	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1042	5	by	by	IN
18637	1042	6	10	10	CD
18637	1042	7	States	state	NNS
18637	1042	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1042	9	1	1	CD
18637	1042	10	short	short	RB
18637	1042	11	of	of	IN
18637	1042	12	the	the	DT
18637	1042	13	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	1042	14	number	number	NN
18637	1042	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1042	16	and	and	CC
18637	1042	17	the	the	DT
18637	1042	18	second	second	JJ
18637	1042	19	by	by	IN
18637	1042	20	6	6	CD
18637	1042	21	States	state	NNS
18637	1042	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1042	23	2	2	CD
18637	1042	24	Doc	doc	NN
18637	1042	25	.	.	.
18637	1043	1	Hist	hist	NN
18637	1043	2	.	.	.
18637	1044	1	Const	Const	NNP
18637	1044	2	.	.	NNP
18637	1044	3	,	,	,
18637	1044	4	325	325	CD
18637	1044	5	-	-	SYM
18637	1044	6	390	390	CD
18637	1044	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1044	8	.	.	.
18637	1045	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1045	2	c	c	NN
18637	1045	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1045	4	The	the	DT
18637	1045	5	11th	11th	JJ
18637	1045	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1045	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1045	8	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1045	9	by	by	IN
18637	1045	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1045	11	on	on	IN
18637	1045	12	March	March	NNP
18637	1045	13	4	4	CD
18637	1045	14	,	,	,
18637	1045	15	1794	1794	CD
18637	1045	16	,	,	,
18637	1045	17	when	when	WRB
18637	1045	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1045	19	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1045	20	the	the	DT
18637	1045	21	House	House	NNP
18637	1045	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1045	23	4	4	CD
18637	1045	24	Ann	Ann	NNP
18637	1045	25	.	.	.
18637	1046	1	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1046	2	.	.	.
18637	1047	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1047	2	3d	3d	NNP
18637	1047	3	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1047	4	.	.	NNP
18637	1047	5	,	,	,
18637	1047	6	1st	1st	JJ
18637	1047	7	sess	sess	NN
18637	1047	8	.	.	.
18637	1047	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1048	1	477	477	CD
18637	1048	2	,	,	,
18637	1048	3	478	478	CD
18637	1048	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1048	5	,	,	,
18637	1048	6	having	have	VBG
18637	1048	7	previously	previously	RB
18637	1048	8	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1048	9	the	the	DT
18637	1048	10	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1048	11	on	on	IN
18637	1048	12	January	January	NNP
18637	1048	13	14	14	CD
18637	1048	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1048	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1048	16	Id.	Idaho	NNP
18637	1048	17	_	_	NNP
18637	1048	18	,	,	,
18637	1048	19	30	30	CD
18637	1048	20	,	,	,
18637	1048	21	31	31	CD
18637	1048	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1048	23	.	.	.
18637	1049	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1049	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1049	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1049	4	in	in	IN
18637	1049	5	1	1	CD
18637	1049	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1049	7	.	.	.
18637	1050	1	402	402	CD
18637	1050	2	.	.	.
18637	1051	1	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1051	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1051	3	completed	complete	VBN
18637	1051	4	on	on	IN
18637	1051	5	February	February	NNP
18637	1051	6	7	7	CD
18637	1051	7	,	,	,
18637	1051	8	1795	1795	CD
18637	1051	9	,	,	,
18637	1051	10	when	when	WRB
18637	1051	11	the	the	DT
18637	1051	12	twelfth	twelfth	JJ
18637	1051	13	State	State	NNP
18637	1051	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1051	15	North	North	NNP
18637	1051	16	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1051	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1051	18	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1051	19	the	the	DT
18637	1051	20	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1051	21	,	,	,
18637	1051	22	there	there	EX
18637	1051	23	being	be	VBG
18637	1051	24	then	then	RB
18637	1051	25	15	15	CD
18637	1051	26	States	state	NNS
18637	1051	27	in	in	IN
18637	1051	28	the	the	DT
18637	1051	29	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1051	30	.	.	.
18637	1052	1	Official	official	JJ
18637	1052	2	announcement	announcement	NN
18637	1052	3	of	of	IN
18637	1052	4	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1052	5	was	be	VBD
18637	1052	6	not	not	RB
18637	1052	7	made	make	VBN
18637	1052	8	until	until	IN
18637	1052	9	January	January	NNP
18637	1052	10	8	8	CD
18637	1052	11	,	,	,
18637	1052	12	1798	1798	CD
18637	1052	13	,	,	,
18637	1052	14	when	when	WRB
18637	1052	15	President	President	NNP
18637	1052	16	John	John	NNP
18637	1052	17	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	1052	18	in	in	IN
18637	1052	19	a	a	DT
18637	1052	20	message	message	NN
18637	1052	21	to	to	IN
18637	1052	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1052	23	stated	state	VBD
18637	1052	24	that	that	IN
18637	1052	25	the	the	DT
18637	1052	26	11th	11th	NNP
18637	1052	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1052	28	had	have	VBD
18637	1052	29	been	be	VBN
18637	1052	30	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	1052	31	by	by	IN
18637	1052	32	three	three	CD
18637	1052	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	1052	34	fourths	fourth	NNS
18637	1052	35	of	of	IN
18637	1052	36	the	the	DT
18637	1052	37	States	States	NNPS
18637	1052	38	and	and	CC
18637	1052	39	that	that	IN
18637	1052	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1052	41	"	"	``
18637	1052	42	may	may	MD
18637	1052	43	now	now	RB
18637	1052	44	be	be	VB
18637	1052	45	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	1052	46	to	to	TO
18637	1052	47	be	be	VB
18637	1052	48	a	a	DT
18637	1052	49	part	part	NN
18637	1052	50	of	of	IN
18637	1052	51	the	the	DT
18637	1052	52	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1052	53	"	"	''
18637	1052	54	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1052	55	1	1	CD
18637	1052	56	Mess	mess	NN
18637	1052	57	.	.	.
18637	1053	1	and	and	CC
18637	1053	2	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	1053	3	of	of	IN
18637	1053	4	Pres	Pres	NNPS
18637	1053	5	.	.	.
18637	1054	1	250	250	LS
18637	1054	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1054	3	.	.	.
18637	1055	1	In	in	IN
18637	1055	2	the	the	DT
18637	1055	3	interim	interim	JJ
18637	1055	4	South	South	NNP
18637	1055	5	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1055	6	had	have	VBD
18637	1055	7	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1055	8	,	,	,
18637	1055	9	and	and	CC
18637	1055	10	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	1055	11	had	have	VBD
18637	1055	12	been	be	VBN
18637	1055	13	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	1055	14	into	into	IN
18637	1055	15	the	the	DT
18637	1055	16	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1055	17	as	as	IN
18637	1055	18	the	the	DT
18637	1055	19	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	1055	20	State	State	NNP
18637	1055	21	.	.	.
18637	1056	1	The	the	DT
18637	1056	2	several	several	JJ
18637	1056	3	State	State	NNP
18637	1056	4	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1056	5	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1056	6	the	the	DT
18637	1056	7	11th	11th	JJ
18637	1056	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1056	9	on	on	IN
18637	1056	10	the	the	DT
18637	1056	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	1056	12	dates	date	NNS
18637	1056	13	:	:	:
18637	1056	14	New	New	NNP
18637	1056	15	York	York	NNP
18637	1056	16	,	,	,
18637	1056	17	March	March	NNP
18637	1056	18	27	27	CD
18637	1056	19	,	,	,
18637	1056	20	1794	1794	CD
18637	1056	21	;	;	:
18637	1056	22	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	1056	23	Island	Island	NNP
18637	1056	24	,	,	,
18637	1056	25	March	March	NNP
18637	1056	26	31	31	CD
18637	1056	27	,	,	,
18637	1056	28	1794	1794	CD
18637	1056	29	;	;	:
18637	1056	30	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	1056	31	,	,	,
18637	1056	32	May	May	NNP
18637	1056	33	8	8	CD
18637	1056	34	,	,	,
18637	1056	35	1794	1794	CD
18637	1056	36	;	;	:
18637	1056	37	New	New	NNP
18637	1056	38	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1056	39	,	,	,
18637	1056	40	June	June	NNP
18637	1056	41	16	16	CD
18637	1056	42	,	,	,
18637	1056	43	1794	1794	CD
18637	1056	44	;	;	:
18637	1056	45	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	1056	46	,	,	,
18637	1056	47	June	June	NNP
18637	1056	48	26	26	CD
18637	1056	49	,	,	,
18637	1056	50	1794	1794	CD
18637	1056	51	;	;	:
18637	1056	52	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	1056	53	,	,	,
18637	1056	54	between	between	IN
18637	1056	55	October	October	NNP
18637	1056	56	9	9	CD
18637	1056	57	and	and	CC
18637	1056	58	November	November	NNP
18637	1056	59	9	9	CD
18637	1056	60	,	,	,
18637	1056	61	1794	1794	CD
18637	1056	62	;	;	:
18637	1056	63	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1056	64	,	,	,
18637	1056	65	November	November	NNP
18637	1056	66	18	18	CD
18637	1056	67	,	,	,
18637	1056	68	1794	1794	CD
18637	1056	69	;	;	:
18637	1056	70	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	1056	71	,	,	,
18637	1056	72	November	November	NNP
18637	1056	73	29	29	CD
18637	1056	74	,	,	,
18637	1056	75	1794	1794	CD
18637	1056	76	;	;	:
18637	1056	77	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	1056	78	,	,	,
18637	1056	79	December	December	NNP
18637	1056	80	7	7	CD
18637	1056	81	,	,	,
18637	1056	82	1794	1794	CD
18637	1056	83	;	;	:
18637	1056	84	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1056	85	,	,	,
18637	1056	86	December	December	NNP
18637	1056	87	26	26	CD
18637	1056	88	,	,	,
18637	1056	89	1794	1794	CD
18637	1056	90	;	;	:
18637	1056	91	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	1056	92	,	,	,
18637	1056	93	January	January	NNP
18637	1056	94	23	23	CD
18637	1056	95	,	,	,
18637	1056	96	1795	1795	CD
18637	1056	97	;	;	:
18637	1056	98	North	North	NNP
18637	1056	99	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1056	100	,	,	,
18637	1056	101	February	February	NNP
18637	1056	102	7	7	CD
18637	1056	103	,	,	,
18637	1056	104	1795	1795	CD
18637	1056	105	;	;	:
18637	1056	106	South	South	NNP
18637	1056	107	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1056	108	,	,	,
18637	1056	109	December	December	NNP
18637	1056	110	4	4	CD
18637	1056	111	,	,	,
18637	1056	112	1797	1797	CD
18637	1056	113	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1056	114	State	State	NNP
18637	1056	115	Department	Department	NNP
18637	1056	116	,	,	,
18637	1056	117	Press	Press	NNP
18637	1056	118	Releases	Releases	NNP
18637	1056	119	,	,	,
18637	1056	120	vol	vol	NNP
18637	1056	121	.	.	.
18637	1057	1	XII	XII	NNP
18637	1057	2	,	,	,
18637	1057	3	p.	p.	NN
18637	1057	4	247	247	CD
18637	1057	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1057	6	1935	1935	CD
18637	1057	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1057	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1057	9	.	.	.
18637	1058	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1058	2	d	d	LS
18637	1058	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1058	4	The	the	DT
18637	1058	5	12th	12th	NN
18637	1058	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1058	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1058	8	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1058	9	by	by	IN
18637	1058	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1058	11	on	on	IN
18637	1058	12	December	December	NNP
18637	1058	13	9	9	CD
18637	1058	14	,	,	,
18637	1058	15	1803	1803	CD
18637	1058	16	,	,	,
18637	1058	17	when	when	WRB
18637	1058	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1058	19	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1058	20	the	the	DT
18637	1058	21	House	House	NNP
18637	1058	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1058	23	13	13	CD
18637	1058	24	Ann	Ann	NNP
18637	1058	25	.	.	.
18637	1059	1	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1059	2	.	.	.
18637	1060	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1060	2	8th	8th	JJ
18637	1060	3	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1060	4	.	.	NNP
18637	1060	5	,	,	,
18637	1060	6	1st	1st	JJ
18637	1060	7	sess	sess	NN
18637	1060	8	.	.	.
18637	1060	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1061	1	775	775	CD
18637	1061	2	,	,	,
18637	1061	3	776	776	CD
18637	1061	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1061	5	,	,	,
18637	1061	6	having	have	VBG
18637	1061	7	previously	previously	RB
18637	1061	8	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1061	9	the	the	DT
18637	1061	10	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1061	11	on	on	IN
18637	1061	12	December	December	NNP
18637	1061	13	2	2	CD
18637	1061	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1061	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1061	16	Id.	Idaho	NNP
18637	1061	17	_	_	NNP
18637	1061	18	,	,	,
18637	1061	19	209	209	CD
18637	1061	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1061	21	.	.	.
18637	1062	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1062	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1062	3	not	not	RB
18637	1062	4	signed	sign	VBN
18637	1062	5	by	by	IN
18637	1062	6	the	the	DT
18637	1062	7	presiding	preside	VBG
18637	1062	8	officers	officer	NNS
18637	1062	9	of	of	IN
18637	1062	10	the	the	DT
18637	1062	11	House	House	NNP
18637	1062	12	and	and	CC
18637	1062	13	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1062	14	until	until	IN
18637	1062	15	December	December	NNP
18637	1062	16	12	12	CD
18637	1062	17	.	.	.
18637	1063	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1063	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1063	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1063	4	in	in	IN
18637	1063	5	2	2	CD
18637	1063	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1063	7	.	.	.
18637	1064	1	306	306	CD
18637	1064	2	.	.	.
18637	1065	1	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1065	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1065	3	probably	probably	RB
18637	1065	4	completed	complete	VBN
18637	1065	5	on	on	IN
18637	1065	6	June	June	NNP
18637	1065	7	15	15	CD
18637	1065	8	,	,	,
18637	1065	9	1804	1804	CD
18637	1065	10	,	,	,
18637	1065	11	when	when	WRB
18637	1065	12	the	the	DT
18637	1065	13	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1065	14	of	of	IN
18637	1065	15	the	the	DT
18637	1065	16	thirteenth	thirteenth	JJ
18637	1065	17	State	State	NNP
18637	1065	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1065	19	New	New	NNP
18637	1065	20	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1065	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1065	22	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1065	23	the	the	DT
18637	1065	24	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1065	25	,	,	,
18637	1065	26	there	there	EX
18637	1065	27	being	be	VBG
18637	1065	28	then	then	RB
18637	1065	29	17	17	CD
18637	1065	30	States	state	NNS
18637	1065	31	in	in	IN
18637	1065	32	the	the	DT
18637	1065	33	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1065	34	.	.	.
18637	1066	1	The	the	DT
18637	1066	2	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1066	3	of	of	IN
18637	1066	4	New	New	NNP
18637	1066	5	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1066	6	,	,	,
18637	1066	7	however	however	RB
18637	1066	8	,	,	,
18637	1066	9	vetoed	veto	VBD
18637	1066	10	this	this	DT
18637	1066	11	act	act	NN
18637	1066	12	of	of	IN
18637	1066	13	the	the	DT
18637	1066	14	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1066	15	on	on	IN
18637	1066	16	June	June	NNP
18637	1066	17	20	20	CD
18637	1066	18	,	,	,
18637	1066	19	and	and	CC
18637	1066	20	the	the	DT
18637	1066	21	act	act	NN
18637	1066	22	failed	fail	VBD
18637	1066	23	to	to	TO
18637	1066	24	pass	pass	VB
18637	1066	25	again	again	RB
18637	1066	26	by	by	IN
18637	1066	27	two	two	CD
18637	1066	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	1066	29	thirds	third	NNS
18637	1066	30	vote	vote	NN
18637	1066	31	then	then	RB
18637	1066	32	required	require	VBN
18637	1066	33	by	by	IN
18637	1066	34	the	the	DT
18637	1066	35	State	State	NNP
18637	1066	36	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	1066	37	.	.	.
18637	1067	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	1067	2	as	as	IN
18637	1067	3	art	art	NN
18637	1067	4	.	.	.
18637	1068	1	V	v	NN
18637	1068	2	of	of	IN
18637	1068	3	the	the	DT
18637	1068	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1068	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1068	6	specifies	specify	VBZ
18637	1068	7	that	that	IN
18637	1068	8	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	1068	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	1068	10	become	become	VB
18637	1068	11	effective	effective	JJ
18637	1068	12	"	"	''
18637	1068	13	when	when	WRB
18637	1068	14	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1068	15	by	by	IN
18637	1068	16	the	the	DT
18637	1068	17	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1068	18	of	of	IN
18637	1068	19	three	three	CD
18637	1068	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	1068	21	fourths	fourth	NNS
18637	1068	22	of	of	IN
18637	1068	23	the	the	DT
18637	1068	24	several	several	JJ
18637	1068	25	States	state	NNS
18637	1068	26	or	or	CC
18637	1068	27	by	by	IN
18637	1068	28	conventions	convention	NNS
18637	1068	29	in	in	IN
18637	1068	30	three	three	CD
18637	1068	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	1068	32	fourths	fourth	NNS
18637	1068	33	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	1068	34	,	,	,
18637	1068	35	"	"	``
18637	1068	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1068	37	has	have	VBZ
18637	1068	38	been	be	VBN
18637	1068	39	generally	generally	RB
18637	1068	40	believed	believe	VBN
18637	1068	41	that	that	IN
18637	1068	42	an	an	DT
18637	1068	43	approval	approval	NN
18637	1068	44	or	or	CC
18637	1068	45	veto	veto	NN
18637	1068	46	by	by	IN
18637	1068	47	a	a	DT
18637	1068	48	governor	governor	NN
18637	1068	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	1068	50	without	without	IN
18637	1068	51	significance	significance	NN
18637	1068	52	.	.	.
18637	1069	1	If	if	IN
18637	1069	2	the	the	DT
18637	1069	3	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1069	4	by	by	IN
18637	1069	5	New	New	NNP
18637	1069	6	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1069	7	be	be	VB
18637	1069	8	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	1069	9	ineffective	ineffective	JJ
18637	1069	10	,	,	,
18637	1069	11	then	then	RB
18637	1069	12	the	the	DT
18637	1069	13	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1069	14	became	become	VBD
18637	1069	15	operative	operative	JJ
18637	1069	16	by	by	IN
18637	1069	17	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	1069	18	's	's	POS
18637	1069	19	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1069	20	on	on	IN
18637	1069	21	July	July	NNP
18637	1069	22	27	27	CD
18637	1069	23	,	,	,
18637	1069	24	1804	1804	CD
18637	1069	25	.	.	.
18637	1070	1	On	on	IN
18637	1070	2	September	September	NNP
18637	1070	3	25	25	CD
18637	1070	4	,	,	,
18637	1070	5	1804	1804	CD
18637	1070	6	,	,	,
18637	1070	7	in	in	IN
18637	1070	8	a	a	DT
18637	1070	9	circular	circular	JJ
18637	1070	10	letter	letter	NN
18637	1070	11	to	to	IN
18637	1070	12	the	the	DT
18637	1070	13	Governors	Governors	NNPS
18637	1070	14	of	of	IN
18637	1070	15	the	the	DT
18637	1070	16	several	several	JJ
18637	1070	17	States	States	NNPS
18637	1070	18	,	,	,
18637	1070	19	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1070	20	of	of	IN
18637	1070	21	State	State	NNP
18637	1070	22	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	1070	23	declared	declare	VBD
18637	1070	24	the	the	DT
18637	1070	25	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1070	26	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1070	27	by	by	IN
18637	1070	28	three	three	CD
18637	1070	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	1070	30	fourths	fourth	NNS
18637	1070	31	of	of	IN
18637	1070	32	the	the	DT
18637	1070	33	States	States	NNPS
18637	1070	34	.	.	.
18637	1071	1	The	the	DT
18637	1071	2	several	several	JJ
18637	1071	3	State	State	NNP
18637	1071	4	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1071	5	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1071	6	the	the	DT
18637	1071	7	12th	12th	JJ
18637	1071	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1071	9	on	on	IN
18637	1071	10	the	the	DT
18637	1071	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	1071	12	dates	date	NNS
18637	1071	13	:	:	:
18637	1071	14	North	North	NNP
18637	1071	15	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1071	16	,	,	,
18637	1071	17	December	December	NNP
18637	1071	18	22	22	CD
18637	1071	19	,	,	,
18637	1071	20	1803	1803	CD
18637	1071	21	;	;	:
18637	1071	22	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1071	23	,	,	,
18637	1071	24	December	December	NNP
18637	1071	25	24	24	CD
18637	1071	26	,	,	,
18637	1071	27	1803	1803	CD
18637	1071	28	;	;	:
18637	1071	29	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	1071	30	,	,	,
18637	1071	31	December	December	NNP
18637	1071	32	27	27	CD
18637	1071	33	,	,	,
18637	1071	34	1803	1803	CD
18637	1071	35	;	;	:
18637	1071	36	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1071	37	,	,	,
18637	1071	38	between	between	IN
18637	1071	39	December	December	NNP
18637	1071	40	5	5	CD
18637	1071	41	and	and	CC
18637	1071	42	December	December	NNP
18637	1071	43	30	30	CD
18637	1071	44	,	,	,
18637	1071	45	1803	1803	CD
18637	1071	46	;	;	:
18637	1071	47	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1071	48	,	,	,
18637	1071	49	between	between	IN
18637	1071	50	December	December	NNP
18637	1071	51	20	20	CD
18637	1071	52	,	,	,
18637	1071	53	1803	1803	CD
18637	1071	54	and	and	CC
18637	1071	55	February	February	NNP
18637	1071	56	3	3	CD
18637	1071	57	,	,	,
18637	1071	58	1804	1804	CD
18637	1071	59	;	;	:
18637	1071	60	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	1071	61	,	,	,
18637	1071	62	January	January	NNP
18637	1071	63	5	5	CD
18637	1071	64	,	,	,
18637	1071	65	1804	1804	CD
18637	1071	66	;	;	:
18637	1071	67	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	1071	68	,	,	,
18637	1071	69	January	January	NNP
18637	1071	70	30	30	CD
18637	1071	71	,	,	,
18637	1071	72	1804	1804	CD
18637	1071	73	;	;	:
18637	1071	74	New	New	NNP
18637	1071	75	York	York	NNP
18637	1071	76	,	,	,
18637	1071	77	February	February	NNP
18637	1071	78	10	10	CD
18637	1071	79	,	,	,
18637	1071	80	1804	1804	CD
18637	1071	81	;	;	:
18637	1071	82	New	New	NNP
18637	1071	83	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1071	84	,	,	,
18637	1071	85	February	February	NNP
18637	1071	86	22	22	CD
18637	1071	87	,	,	,
18637	1071	88	1804	1804	CD
18637	1071	89	;	;	:
18637	1071	90	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	1071	91	Island	Island	NNP
18637	1071	92	,	,	,
18637	1071	93	between	between	IN
18637	1071	94	February	February	NNP
18637	1071	95	27	27	CD
18637	1071	96	and	and	CC
18637	1071	97	March	March	NNP
18637	1071	98	12	12	CD
18637	1071	99	,	,	,
18637	1071	100	1804	1804	CD
18637	1071	101	;	;	:
18637	1071	102	South	South	NNP
18637	1071	103	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1071	104	,	,	,
18637	1071	105	May	May	NNP
18637	1071	106	15	15	CD
18637	1071	107	,	,	,
18637	1071	108	1804	1804	CD
18637	1071	109	;	;	:
18637	1071	110	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	1071	111	,	,	,
18637	1071	112	May	May	NNP
18637	1071	113	19	19	CD
18637	1071	114	,	,	,
18637	1071	115	1804	1804	CD
18637	1071	116	;	;	:
18637	1071	117	New	New	NNP
18637	1071	118	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1071	119	,	,	,
18637	1071	120	June	June	NNP
18637	1071	121	15	15	CD
18637	1071	122	,	,	,
18637	1071	123	1804	1804	CD
18637	1071	124	;	;	:
18637	1071	125	and	and	CC
18637	1071	126	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	1071	127	,	,	,
18637	1071	128	July	July	NNP
18637	1071	129	27	27	CD
18637	1071	130	,	,	,
18637	1071	131	1804	1804	CD
18637	1071	132	.	.	.
18637	1072	1	The	the	DT
18637	1072	2	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1072	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1072	4	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1072	5	by	by	IN
18637	1072	6	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	1072	7	on	on	IN
18637	1072	8	January	January	NNP
18637	1072	9	18	18	CD
18637	1072	10	,	,	,
18637	1072	11	1804	1804	CD
18637	1072	12	,	,	,
18637	1072	13	and	and	CC
18637	1072	14	by	by	IN
18637	1072	15	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	1072	16	at	at	IN
18637	1072	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1072	18	session	session	NN
18637	1072	19	begun	begin	VBN
18637	1072	20	May	May	NNP
18637	1072	21	10	10	CD
18637	1072	22	,	,	,
18637	1072	23	1804	1804	CD
18637	1072	24	.	.	.
18637	1073	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1073	2	e	e	LS
18637	1073	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1073	4	The	the	DT
18637	1073	5	13th	13th	NN
18637	1073	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1073	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1073	8	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1073	9	by	by	IN
18637	1073	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1073	11	on	on	IN
18637	1073	12	January	January	NNP
18637	1073	13	31	31	CD
18637	1073	14	,	,	,
18637	1073	15	1865	1865	CD
18637	1073	16	,	,	,
18637	1073	17	when	when	WRB
18637	1073	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1073	19	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1073	20	the	the	DT
18637	1073	21	House	House	NNP
18637	1073	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1073	23	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1073	24	.	.	.
18637	1074	1	Globe	Globe	NNP
18637	1074	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1074	3	38th	38th	NNP
18637	1074	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1074	5	.	.	NNP
18637	1074	6	,	,	,
18637	1074	7	2d	2d	CD
18637	1074	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	1074	9	.	.	.
18637	1074	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1075	1	531	531	CD
18637	1075	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1075	3	,	,	,
18637	1075	4	having	have	VBG
18637	1075	5	previously	previously	RB
18637	1075	6	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1075	7	the	the	DT
18637	1075	8	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1075	9	on	on	IN
18637	1075	10	April	April	NNP
18637	1075	11	8	8	CD
18637	1075	12	,	,	,
18637	1075	13	1864	1864	CD
18637	1075	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1075	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1075	16	Id.	Idaho	NNP
18637	1075	17	_	_	NNP
18637	1075	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1075	19	38th	38th	NNP
18637	1075	20	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1075	21	.	.	NNP
18637	1075	22	,	,	,
18637	1075	23	1st	1st	JJ
18637	1075	24	sess	sess	NN
18637	1075	25	.	.	.
18637	1075	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1076	1	1490	1490	CD
18637	1076	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1076	3	.	.	.
18637	1077	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1077	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1077	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1077	4	in	in	IN
18637	1077	5	13	13	CD
18637	1077	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1077	7	.	.	.
18637	1078	1	567	567	CD
18637	1078	2	under	under	IN
18637	1078	3	the	the	DT
18637	1078	4	date	date	NN
18637	1078	5	of	of	IN
18637	1078	6	February	February	NNP
18637	1078	7	1	1	CD
18637	1078	8	,	,	,
18637	1078	9	1865	1865	CD
18637	1078	10	.	.	.
18637	1079	1	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1079	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1079	3	completed	complete	VBN
18637	1079	4	on	on	IN
18637	1079	5	December	December	NNP
18637	1079	6	6	6	CD
18637	1079	7	,	,	,
18637	1079	8	1865	1865	CD
18637	1079	9	,	,	,
18637	1079	10	when	when	WRB
18637	1079	11	the	the	DT
18637	1079	12	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1079	13	of	of	IN
18637	1079	14	the	the	DT
18637	1079	15	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	1079	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	1079	17	seventh	seventh	JJ
18637	1079	18	State	State	NNP
18637	1079	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1079	20	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	1079	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1079	22	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1079	23	the	the	DT
18637	1079	24	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1079	25	,	,	,
18637	1079	26	there	there	EX
18637	1079	27	being	be	VBG
18637	1079	28	then	then	RB
18637	1079	29	36	36	CD
18637	1079	30	States	state	NNS
18637	1079	31	in	in	IN
18637	1079	32	the	the	DT
18637	1079	33	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1079	34	.	.	.
18637	1080	1	On	on	IN
18637	1080	2	December	December	NNP
18637	1080	3	18	18	CD
18637	1080	4	,	,	,
18637	1080	5	1865	1865	CD
18637	1080	6	,	,	,
18637	1080	7	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1080	8	of	of	IN
18637	1080	9	State	State	NNP
18637	1080	10	Seward	Seward	NNP
18637	1080	11	certified	certify	VBD
18637	1080	12	that	that	IN
18637	1080	13	the	the	DT
18637	1080	14	13th	13th	NN
18637	1080	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1080	16	had	have	VBD
18637	1080	17	become	become	VBN
18637	1080	18	a	a	DT
18637	1080	19	part	part	NN
18637	1080	20	of	of	IN
18637	1080	21	the	the	DT
18637	1080	22	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1080	23	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1080	24	13	13	CD
18637	1080	25	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	1080	26	.	.	.
18637	1081	1	774	774	LS
18637	1081	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1081	3	.	.	.
18637	1082	1	The	the	DT
18637	1082	2	several	several	JJ
18637	1082	3	State	State	NNP
18637	1082	4	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1082	5	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1082	6	the	the	DT
18637	1082	7	13th	13th	JJ
18637	1082	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1082	9	on	on	IN
18637	1082	10	the	the	DT
18637	1082	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	1082	12	dates	date	NNS
18637	1082	13	:	:	:
18637	1082	14	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	1082	15	,	,	,
18637	1082	16	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	17	1	1	CD
18637	1082	18	,	,	,
18637	1082	19	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	20	;	;	:
18637	1082	21	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	1082	22	Island	Island	NNP
18637	1082	23	,	,	,
18637	1082	24	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	25	,	,	,
18637	1082	26	2	2	CD
18637	1082	27	,	,	,
18637	1082	28	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	29	;	;	:
18637	1082	30	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	1082	31	,	,	,
18637	1082	32	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	33	2	2	CD
18637	1082	34	,	,	,
18637	1082	35	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	36	;	;	:
18637	1082	37	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1082	38	,	,	,
18637	1082	39	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	40	3	3	CD
18637	1082	41	,	,	,
18637	1082	42	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	43	;	;	:
18637	1082	44	New	New	NNP
18637	1082	45	York	York	NNP
18637	1082	46	,	,	,
18637	1082	47	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	48	3	3	CD
18637	1082	49	,	,	,
18637	1082	50	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	51	;	;	:
18637	1082	52	West	West	NNP
18637	1082	53	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1082	54	,	,	,
18637	1082	55	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	56	3	3	CD
18637	1082	57	,	,	,
18637	1082	58	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	59	;	;	:
18637	1082	60	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	1082	61	,	,	,
18637	1082	62	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	63	6	6	CD
18637	1082	64	,	,	,
18637	1082	65	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	66	;	;	:
18637	1082	67	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	1082	68	,	,	,
18637	1082	69	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	70	7	7	CD
18637	1082	71	,	,	,
18637	1082	72	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	73	;	;	:
18637	1082	74	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	1082	75	,	,	,
18637	1082	76	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	77	7	7	CD
18637	1082	78	,	,	,
18637	1082	79	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	80	;	;	:
18637	1082	81	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	1082	82	,	,	,
18637	1082	83	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	84	7	7	CD
18637	1082	85	,	,	,
18637	1082	86	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	87	;	;	:
18637	1082	88	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	1082	89	,	,	,
18637	1082	90	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	91	8	8	CD
18637	1082	92	,	,	,
18637	1082	93	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	94	;	;	:
18637	1082	95	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1082	96	,	,	,
18637	1082	97	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	98	9	9	CD
18637	1082	99	,	,	,
18637	1082	100	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	101	;	;	:
18637	1082	102	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1082	103	,	,	,
18637	1082	104	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	105	10	10	CD
18637	1082	106	,	,	,
18637	1082	107	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	108	;	;	:
18637	1082	109	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	1082	110	,	,	,
18637	1082	111	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	112	15	15	CD
18637	1082	113	or	or	CC
18637	1082	114	16	16	CD
18637	1082	115	,	,	,
18637	1082	116	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	117	;	;	:
18637	1082	118	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	1082	119	,	,	,
18637	1082	120	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	121	16	16	CD
18637	1082	122	,	,	,
18637	1082	123	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	124	;	;	:
18637	1082	125	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	1082	126	,	,	,
18637	1082	127	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	128	16	16	CD
18637	1082	129	,	,	,
18637	1082	130	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	131	;	;	:
18637	1082	132	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	1082	133	,	,	,
18637	1082	134	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	135	23	23	CD
18637	1082	136	,	,	,
18637	1082	137	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	138	;	;	:
18637	1082	139	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	1082	140	,	,	,
18637	1082	141	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	142	24	24	CD
18637	1082	143	,	,	,
18637	1082	144	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	145	;	;	:
18637	1082	146	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	1082	147	,	,	,
18637	1082	148	March	March	NNP
18637	1082	149	9	9	CD
18637	1082	150	,	,	,
18637	1082	151	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	152	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1082	153	date	date	NN
18637	1082	154	on	on	IN
18637	1082	155	which	which	WDT
18637	1082	156	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1082	157	was	be	VBD
18637	1082	158	"	"	``
18637	1082	159	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1082	160	"	"	''
18637	1082	161	by	by	IN
18637	1082	162	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1082	163	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1082	164	;	;	:
18637	1082	165	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	1082	166	,	,	,
18637	1082	167	April	April	NNP
18637	1082	168	7	7	CD
18637	1082	169	,	,	,
18637	1082	170	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	171	;	;	:
18637	1082	172	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	1082	173	,	,	,
18637	1082	174	April	April	NNP
18637	1082	175	14	14	CD
18637	1082	176	,	,	,
18637	1082	177	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	178	;	;	:
18637	1082	179	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	1082	180	,	,	,
18637	1082	181	May	May	NNP
18637	1082	182	4	4	CD
18637	1082	183	,	,	,
18637	1082	184	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	185	;	;	:
18637	1082	186	New	New	NNP
18637	1082	187	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1082	188	,	,	,
18637	1082	189	June	June	NNP
18637	1082	190	30	30	CD
18637	1082	191	,	,	,
18637	1082	192	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	193	;	;	:
18637	1082	194	South	South	NNP
18637	1082	195	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1082	196	,	,	,
18637	1082	197	November	November	NNP
18637	1082	198	13	13	CD
18637	1082	199	,	,	,
18637	1082	200	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	201	;	;	:
18637	1082	202	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	1082	203	,	,	,
18637	1082	204	December	December	NNP
18637	1082	205	2	2	CD
18637	1082	206	,	,	,
18637	1082	207	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	208	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1082	209	date	date	NN
18637	1082	210	on	on	IN
18637	1082	211	which	which	WDT
18637	1082	212	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1082	213	was	be	VBD
18637	1082	214	"	"	``
18637	1082	215	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1082	216	"	"	''
18637	1082	217	by	by	IN
18637	1082	218	Provisional	Provisional	NNP
18637	1082	219	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1082	220	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1082	221	;	;	:
18637	1082	222	North	North	NNP
18637	1082	223	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1082	224	,	,	,
18637	1082	225	December	December	NNP
18637	1082	226	4	4	CD
18637	1082	227	,	,	,
18637	1082	228	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	229	;	;	:
18637	1082	230	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	1082	231	,	,	,
18637	1082	232	December	December	NNP
18637	1082	233	6	6	CD
18637	1082	234	,	,	,
18637	1082	235	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	236	;	;	:
18637	1082	237	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	1082	238	,	,	,
18637	1082	239	December	December	NNP
18637	1082	240	11	11	CD
18637	1082	241	,	,	,
18637	1082	242	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	243	;	;	:
18637	1082	244	California	California	NNP
18637	1082	245	,	,	,
18637	1082	246	December	December	NNP
18637	1082	247	15	15	CD
18637	1082	248	,	,	,
18637	1082	249	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	250	;	;	:
18637	1082	251	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	1082	252	,	,	,
18637	1082	253	December	December	NNP
18637	1082	254	28	28	CD
18637	1082	255	,	,	,
18637	1082	256	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	257	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1082	258	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	1082	259	again	again	RB
18637	1082	260	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1082	261	this	this	DT
18637	1082	262	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1082	263	on	on	IN
18637	1082	264	June	June	NNP
18637	1082	265	9	9	CD
18637	1082	266	,	,	,
18637	1082	267	1868	1868	CD
18637	1082	268	,	,	,
18637	1082	269	upon	upon	IN
18637	1082	270	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1082	271	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	1082	272	of	of	IN
18637	1082	273	a	a	DT
18637	1082	274	new	new	JJ
18637	1082	275	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	1082	276	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1082	277	;	;	:
18637	1082	278	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	1082	279	,	,	,
18637	1082	280	January	January	NNP
18637	1082	281	17	17	CD
18637	1082	282	,	,	,
18637	1082	283	1866	1866	CD
18637	1082	284	;	;	:
18637	1082	285	New	New	NNP
18637	1082	286	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1082	287	,	,	,
18637	1082	288	January	January	NNP
18637	1082	289	23	23	CD
18637	1082	290	,	,	,
18637	1082	291	1866	1866	CD
18637	1082	292	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1082	293	after	after	IN
18637	1082	294	having	have	VBG
18637	1082	295	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1082	296	the	the	DT
18637	1082	297	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1082	298	on	on	IN
18637	1082	299	March	March	NNP
18637	1082	300	16	16	CD
18637	1082	301	,	,	,
18637	1082	302	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	303	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1082	304	;	;	:
18637	1082	305	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	1082	306	,	,	,
18637	1082	307	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	308	18	18	CD
18637	1082	309	,	,	,
18637	1082	310	1870	1870	CD
18637	1082	311	;	;	:
18637	1082	312	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	1082	313	,	,	,
18637	1082	314	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	315	12	12	CD
18637	1082	316	,	,	,
18637	1082	317	1901	1901	CD
18637	1082	318	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1082	319	after	after	IN
18637	1082	320	having	have	VBG
18637	1082	321	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1082	322	the	the	DT
18637	1082	323	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1082	324	on	on	IN
18637	1082	325	February	February	NNP
18637	1082	326	8	8	CD
18637	1082	327	,	,	,
18637	1082	328	1865	1865	CD
18637	1082	329	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1082	330	.	.	.
18637	1083	1	The	the	DT
18637	1083	2	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1083	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1083	4	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1083	5	by	by	IN
18637	1083	6	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	1083	7	on	on	IN
18637	1083	8	February	February	NNP
18637	1083	9	24	24	CD
18637	1083	10	,	,	,
18637	1083	11	1865	1865	CD
18637	1083	12	,	,	,
18637	1083	13	and	and	CC
18637	1083	14	by	by	IN
18637	1083	15	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	1083	16	on	on	IN
18637	1083	17	December	December	NNP
18637	1083	18	2	2	CD
18637	1083	19	,	,	,
18637	1083	20	1865	1865	CD
18637	1083	21	.	.	.
18637	1084	1	"	"	``
18637	1084	2	A	a	DT
18637	1084	3	thirteenth	thirteenth	JJ
18637	1084	4	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1084	5	depriving	depriving	NN
18637	1084	6	of	of	IN
18637	1084	7	United	United	NNP
18637	1084	8	States	States	NNP
18637	1084	9	citizenship	citizenship	VBP
18637	1084	10	any	any	DT
18637	1084	11	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	1084	12	who	who	WP
18637	1084	13	should	should	MD
18637	1084	14	accept	accept	VB
18637	1084	15	any	any	DT
18637	1084	16	title	title	NN
18637	1084	17	,	,	,
18637	1084	18	office	office	NN
18637	1084	19	,	,	,
18637	1084	20	or	or	CC
18637	1084	21	emolument	emolument	NN
18637	1084	22	from	from	IN
18637	1084	23	a	a	DT
18637	1084	24	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1084	25	power	power	NN
18637	1084	26	,	,	,
18637	1084	27	was	be	VBD
18637	1084	28	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1084	29	by	by	IN
18637	1084	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1084	31	on	on	IN
18637	1084	32	May	May	NNP
18637	1084	33	1	1	CD
18637	1084	34	,	,	,
18637	1084	35	1810	1810	CD
18637	1084	36	,	,	,
18637	1084	37	when	when	WRB
18637	1084	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1084	39	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1084	40	the	the	DT
18637	1084	41	House	House	NNP
18637	1084	42	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1084	43	21	21	CD
18637	1084	44	Ann	Ann	NNP
18637	1084	45	.	.	.
18637	1085	1	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1085	2	.	.	.
18637	1086	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1086	2	11th	11th	NNP
18637	1086	3	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1086	4	.	.	NNP
18637	1086	5	,	,	,
18637	1086	6	2d	2d	CD
18637	1086	7	sess	sess	NN
18637	1086	8	.	.	.
18637	1086	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1087	1	2050	2050	CD
18637	1087	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1087	3	,	,	,
18637	1087	4	having	have	VBG
18637	1087	5	previously	previously	RB
18637	1087	6	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1087	7	the	the	DT
18637	1087	8	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1087	9	on	on	IN
18637	1087	10	April	April	NNP
18637	1087	11	27	27	CD
18637	1087	12	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1087	13	20	20	CD
18637	1087	14	Ann	Ann	NNP
18637	1087	15	.	.	.
18637	1088	1	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1088	2	.	.	.
18637	1089	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1089	2	11th	11th	NNP
18637	1089	3	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1089	4	.	.	NNP
18637	1089	5	,	,	,
18637	1089	6	2d	2d	CD
18637	1089	7	sess	sess	NN
18637	1089	8	.	.	.
18637	1089	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1090	1	672	672	CD
18637	1090	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1090	3	.	.	.
18637	1091	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1091	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1091	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1091	4	in	in	IN
18637	1091	5	2	2	CD
18637	1091	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1091	7	.	.	.
18637	1092	1	613	613	CD
18637	1092	2	.	.	.
18637	1093	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1093	2	failed	fail	VBD
18637	1093	3	of	of	IN
18637	1093	4	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	1093	5	,	,	,
18637	1093	6	being	be	VBG
18637	1093	7	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1093	8	by	by	IN
18637	1093	9	but	but	CC
18637	1093	10	12	12	CD
18637	1093	11	States	state	NNS
18637	1093	12	up	up	RB
18637	1093	13	to	to	IN
18637	1093	14	December	December	NNP
18637	1093	15	10	10	CD
18637	1093	16	,	,	,
18637	1093	17	1812	1812	CD
18637	1093	18	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1093	19	2	2	CD
18637	1093	20	Miscell	Miscell	NNP
18637	1093	21	.	.	.
18637	1094	1	Amer	amer	NN
18637	1094	2	.	.	.
18637	1095	1	State	State	NNP
18637	1095	2	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	1095	3	,	,	,
18637	1095	4	477	477	CD
18637	1095	5	-	-	SYM
18637	1095	6	479	479	CD
18637	1095	7	;	;	:
18637	1095	8	2	2	CD
18637	1095	9	Doc	doc	NN
18637	1095	10	.	.	.
18637	1096	1	Hist	hist	NN
18637	1096	2	.	.	.
18637	1097	1	Const	Const	NNP
18637	1097	2	.	.	.
18637	1098	1	454	454	CD
18637	1098	2	-	-	SYM
18637	1098	3	499	499	CD
18637	1098	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1098	5	,	,	,
18637	1098	6	there	there	EX
18637	1098	7	then	then	RB
18637	1098	8	being	be	VBG
18637	1098	9	18	18	CD
18637	1098	10	in	in	IN
18637	1098	11	all	all	DT
18637	1098	12	.	.	.
18637	1099	1	"	"	``
18637	1099	2	Another	another	DT
18637	1099	3	thirteenth	thirteenth	JJ
18637	1099	4	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1099	5	,	,	,
18637	1099	6	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	1099	7	any	any	DT
18637	1099	8	future	future	JJ
18637	1099	9	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1099	10	that	that	WDT
18637	1099	11	should	should	MD
18637	1099	12	empower	empower	VB
18637	1099	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1099	14	to	to	TO
18637	1099	15	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	1099	16	with	with	IN
18637	1099	17	the	the	DT
18637	1099	18	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	1099	19	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	1099	20	of	of	IN
18637	1099	21	any	any	DT
18637	1099	22	State	State	NNP
18637	1099	23	,	,	,
18637	1099	24	was	be	VBD
18637	1099	25	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1099	26	by	by	IN
18637	1099	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1099	28	on	on	IN
18637	1099	29	March	March	NNP
18637	1099	30	2	2	CD
18637	1099	31	,	,	,
18637	1099	32	1861	1861	CD
18637	1099	33	,	,	,
18637	1099	34	when	when	WRB
18637	1099	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1099	36	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1099	37	the	the	DT
18637	1099	38	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1099	39	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1099	40	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1099	41	.	.	.
18637	1100	1	Globe	Globe	NNP
18637	1100	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1100	3	36th	36th	NNP
18637	1100	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1100	5	.	.	NNP
18637	1100	6	,	,	,
18637	1100	7	2d	2d	CD
18637	1100	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	1100	9	.	.	.
18637	1100	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1101	1	1403	1403	CD
18637	1101	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1101	3	,	,	,
18637	1101	4	having	have	VBG
18637	1101	5	previously	previously	RB
18637	1101	6	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1101	7	the	the	DT
18637	1101	8	House	House	NNP
18637	1101	9	on	on	IN
18637	1101	10	February	February	NNP
18637	1101	11	28	28	CD
18637	1101	12	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1101	13	_	_	NNP
18637	1101	14	Id.	Idaho	NNP
18637	1101	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1101	16	,	,	,
18637	1101	17	1285	1285	CD
18637	1101	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1101	19	.	.	.
18637	1102	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1102	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1102	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1102	4	in	in	IN
18637	1102	5	12	12	CD
18637	1102	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1102	7	.	.	.
18637	1103	1	251	251	CD
18637	1103	2	.	.	.
18637	1104	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1104	2	failed	fail	VBD
18637	1104	3	of	of	IN
18637	1104	4	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	1104	5	,	,	,
18637	1104	6	being	be	VBG
18637	1104	7	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1104	8	by	by	IN
18637	1104	9	but	but	CC
18637	1104	10	three	three	CD
18637	1104	11	States	state	NNS
18637	1104	12	:	:	:
18637	1104	13	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1104	14	,	,	,
18637	1104	15	May	May	NNP
18637	1104	16	13	13	CD
18637	1104	17	,	,	,
18637	1104	18	1861	1861	CD
18637	1104	19	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1104	20	58	58	CD
18637	1104	21	Laws	law	NNS
18637	1104	22	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1104	23	,	,	,
18637	1104	24	190	190	CD
18637	1104	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1104	26	;	;	:
18637	1104	27	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1104	28	,	,	,
18637	1104	29	January	January	NNP
18637	1104	30	10	10	CD
18637	1104	31	,	,	,
18637	1104	32	1862	1862	CD
18637	1104	33	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1104	34	Laws	Laws	NNP
18637	1104	35	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1104	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1104	37	1861	1861	CD
18637	1104	38	-	-	SYM
18637	1104	39	62	62	CD
18637	1104	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1104	41	21	21	CD
18637	1104	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1104	43	;	;	:
18637	1104	44	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	1104	45	,	,	,
18637	1104	46	February	February	NNP
18637	1104	47	14	14	CD
18637	1104	48	,	,	,
18637	1104	49	1862	1862	CD
18637	1104	50	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1104	51	2	2	CD
18637	1104	52	Doc	Doc	NNP
18637	1104	53	.	.	.
18637	1105	1	Hist	hist	NN
18637	1105	2	.	.	.
18637	1106	1	Const	Const	NNP
18637	1106	2	.	.	NNP
18637	1106	3	,	,	,
18637	1106	4	518	518	CD
18637	1106	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1106	6	irregular	irregular	JJ
18637	1106	7	,	,	,
18637	1106	8	because	because	IN
18637	1106	9	by	by	IN
18637	1106	10	convention	convention	NN
18637	1106	11	instead	instead	RB
18637	1106	12	of	of	IN
18637	1106	13	by	by	IN
18637	1106	14	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1106	15	as	as	IN
18637	1106	16	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	1106	17	by	by	IN
18637	1106	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1106	19	.	.	.
18637	1106	20	"	"	''
18637	1107	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1107	2	Burdick	Burdick	NNP
18637	1107	3	,	,	,
18637	1107	4	The	the	DT
18637	1107	5	Law	Law	NNP
18637	1107	6	of	of	IN
18637	1107	7	the	the	DT
18637	1107	8	American	American	NNP
18637	1107	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1107	10	,	,	,
18637	1107	11	637	637	CD
18637	1107	12	.	.	.
18637	1107	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1108	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1108	2	f	f	LS
18637	1108	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1108	4	The	the	DT
18637	1108	5	14th	14th	JJ
18637	1108	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1108	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1108	8	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1108	9	by	by	IN
18637	1108	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1108	11	on	on	IN
18637	1108	12	June	June	NNP
18637	1108	13	13	13	CD
18637	1108	14	,	,	,
18637	1108	15	1866	1866	CD
18637	1108	16	,	,	,
18637	1108	17	when	when	WRB
18637	1108	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1108	19	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1108	20	the	the	DT
18637	1108	21	House	House	NNP
18637	1108	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1108	23	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1108	24	.	.	.
18637	1109	1	Globe	Globe	NNP
18637	1109	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1109	3	39th	39th	NNP
18637	1109	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1109	5	.	.	NNP
18637	1109	6	,	,	,
18637	1109	7	1st	1st	JJ
18637	1109	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	1109	9	.	.	.
18637	1109	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1110	1	3148	3148	CD
18637	1110	2	,	,	,
18637	1110	3	3149	3149	CD
18637	1110	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1110	5	,	,	,
18637	1110	6	having	have	VBG
18637	1110	7	previously	previously	RB
18637	1110	8	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1110	9	the	the	DT
18637	1110	10	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1110	11	on	on	IN
18637	1110	12	June	June	NNP
18637	1110	13	8	8	CD
18637	1110	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1110	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1110	16	Id.	Idaho	NNP
18637	1110	17	_	_	NNP
18637	1110	18	,	,	,
18637	1110	19	3042	3042	CD
18637	1110	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1110	21	.	.	.
18637	1111	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1111	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1111	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1111	4	in	in	IN
18637	1111	5	14	14	CD
18637	1111	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1111	7	.	.	.
18637	1112	1	358	358	CD
18637	1112	2	under	under	IN
18637	1112	3	date	date	NN
18637	1112	4	of	of	IN
18637	1112	5	June	June	NNP
18637	1112	6	16	16	CD
18637	1112	7	,	,	,
18637	1112	8	1866	1866	CD
18637	1112	9	.	.	.
18637	1113	1	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1113	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1113	3	probably	probably	RB
18637	1113	4	completed	complete	VBN
18637	1113	5	on	on	IN
18637	1113	6	July	July	NNP
18637	1113	7	9	9	CD
18637	1113	8	,	,	,
18637	1113	9	1868	1868	CD
18637	1113	10	,	,	,
18637	1113	11	when	when	WRB
18637	1113	12	the	the	DT
18637	1113	13	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1113	14	of	of	IN
18637	1113	15	the	the	DT
18637	1113	16	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	1113	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	1113	18	eighth	eighth	JJ
18637	1113	19	State	State	NNP
18637	1113	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1113	21	South	South	NNP
18637	1113	22	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1113	23	or	or	CC
18637	1113	24	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	1113	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1113	26	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1113	27	the	the	DT
18637	1113	28	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1113	29	,	,	,
18637	1113	30	there	there	EX
18637	1113	31	being	be	VBG
18637	1113	32	then	then	RB
18637	1113	33	37	37	CD
18637	1113	34	States	States	NNPS
18637	1113	35	in	in	IN
18637	1113	36	the	the	DT
18637	1113	37	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1113	38	.	.	.
18637	1114	1	However	however	RB
18637	1114	2	,	,	,
18637	1114	3	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1114	4	and	and	CC
18637	1114	5	New	New	NNP
18637	1114	6	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1114	7	had	have	VBD
18637	1114	8	prior	prior	RB
18637	1114	9	to	to	IN
18637	1114	10	that	that	DT
18637	1114	11	date	date	NN
18637	1114	12	"	"	``
18637	1114	13	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	1114	14	"	"	''
18637	1114	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1114	16	earlier	early	JJR
18637	1114	17	assent	assent	NN
18637	1114	18	to	to	IN
18637	1114	19	this	this	DT
18637	1114	20	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1114	21	.	.	.
18637	1115	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	1115	2	,	,	,
18637	1115	3	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1115	4	of	of	IN
18637	1115	5	State	State	NNP
18637	1115	6	Seward	Seward	NNP
18637	1115	7	on	on	IN
18637	1115	8	July	July	NNP
18637	1115	9	20	20	CD
18637	1115	10	,	,	,
18637	1115	11	1868	1868	CD
18637	1115	12	,	,	,
18637	1115	13	certified	certify	VBD
18637	1115	14	that	that	IN
18637	1115	15	the	the	DT
18637	1115	16	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1115	17	had	have	VBD
18637	1115	18	become	become	VBN
18637	1115	19	a	a	DT
18637	1115	20	part	part	NN
18637	1115	21	of	of	IN
18637	1115	22	the	the	DT
18637	1115	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1115	24	if	if	IN
18637	1115	25	the	the	DT
18637	1115	26	said	say	VBN
18637	1115	27	withdrawals	withdrawal	NNS
18637	1115	28	were	be	VBD
18637	1115	29	ineffective	ineffective	JJ
18637	1115	30	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1115	31	15	15	CD
18637	1115	32	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1115	33	.	.	.
18637	1116	1	706	706	CD
18637	1116	2	-	-	SYM
18637	1116	3	707	707	CD
18637	1116	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1116	5	.	.	.
18637	1117	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1117	2	at	at	IN
18637	1117	3	once	once	RB
18637	1117	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1117	5	July	July	NNP
18637	1117	6	21	21	CD
18637	1117	7	,	,	,
18637	1117	8	1868	1868	CD
18637	1117	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1117	10	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1117	11	a	a	DT
18637	1117	12	joint	joint	JJ
18637	1117	13	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	1117	14	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	1117	15	the	the	DT
18637	1117	16	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1117	17	a	a	DT
18637	1117	18	part	part	NN
18637	1117	19	of	of	IN
18637	1117	20	the	the	DT
18637	1117	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1117	22	and	and	CC
18637	1117	23	directing	direct	VBG
18637	1117	24	the	the	DT
18637	1117	25	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1117	26	to	to	TO
18637	1117	27	promulgate	promulgate	VB
18637	1117	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1117	29	as	as	IN
18637	1117	30	such	such	JJ
18637	1117	31	.	.	.
18637	1118	1	On	on	IN
18637	1118	2	July	July	NNP
18637	1118	3	28	28	CD
18637	1118	4	,	,	,
18637	1118	5	1868	1868	CD
18637	1118	6	,	,	,
18637	1118	7	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1118	8	Seward	Seward	NNP
18637	1118	9	certified	certify	VBD
18637	1118	10	without	without	IN
18637	1118	11	reservation	reservation	NN
18637	1118	12	that	that	IN
18637	1118	13	the	the	DT
18637	1118	14	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1118	15	was	be	VBD
18637	1118	16	a	a	DT
18637	1118	17	part	part	NN
18637	1118	18	of	of	IN
18637	1118	19	the	the	DT
18637	1118	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1118	21	.	.	.
18637	1119	1	In	in	IN
18637	1119	2	the	the	DT
18637	1119	3	interim	interim	NN
18637	1119	4	,	,	,
18637	1119	5	two	two	CD
18637	1119	6	other	other	JJ
18637	1119	7	States	States	NNPS
18637	1119	8	,	,	,
18637	1119	9	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	1119	10	on	on	IN
18637	1119	11	July	July	NNP
18637	1119	12	13	13	CD
18637	1119	13	and	and	CC
18637	1119	14	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	1119	15	on	on	IN
18637	1119	16	July	July	NNP
18637	1119	17	21	21	CD
18637	1119	18	,	,	,
18637	1119	19	1868	1868	CD
18637	1119	20	,	,	,
18637	1119	21	had	have	VBD
18637	1119	22	added	add	VBN
18637	1119	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1119	24	ratifications	ratification	NNS
18637	1119	25	.	.	.
18637	1120	1	The	the	DT
18637	1120	2	several	several	JJ
18637	1120	3	State	State	NNP
18637	1120	4	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1120	5	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1120	6	the	the	DT
18637	1120	7	14th	14th	JJ
18637	1120	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1120	9	on	on	IN
18637	1120	10	the	the	DT
18637	1120	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	1120	12	dates	date	NNS
18637	1120	13	:	:	:
18637	1120	14	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	1120	15	,	,	,
18637	1120	16	June	June	NNP
18637	1120	17	30	30	CD
18637	1120	18	,	,	,
18637	1120	19	1866	1866	CD
18637	1120	20	;	;	:
18637	1120	21	New	New	NNP
18637	1120	22	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1120	23	,	,	,
18637	1120	24	July	July	NNP
18637	1120	25	7	7	CD
18637	1120	26	,	,	,
18637	1120	27	1866	1866	CD
18637	1120	28	;	;	:
18637	1120	29	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	1120	30	,	,	,
18637	1120	31	July	July	NNP
18637	1120	32	19	19	CD
18637	1120	33	,	,	,
18637	1120	34	1866	1866	CD
18637	1120	35	;	;	:
18637	1120	36	New	New	NNP
18637	1120	37	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1120	38	,	,	,
18637	1120	39	September	September	NNP
18637	1120	40	11	11	CD
18637	1120	41	,	,	,
18637	1120	42	1866	1866	CD
18637	1120	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1120	44	the	the	DT
18637	1120	45	New	New	NNP
18637	1120	46	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1120	47	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	1120	48	on	on	IN
18637	1120	49	February	February	NNP
18637	1120	50	20	20	CD
18637	1120	51	,	,	,
18637	1120	52	1868	1868	CD
18637	1120	53	"	"	``
18637	1120	54	withdrew	withdraw	VBD
18637	1120	55	"	"	''
18637	1120	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1120	57	consent	consent	NN
18637	1120	58	to	to	IN
18637	1120	59	the	the	DT
18637	1120	60	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1120	61	;	;	:
18637	1120	62	the	the	DT
18637	1120	63	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1120	64	vetoed	veto	VBD
18637	1120	65	that	that	DT
18637	1120	66	bill	bill	NN
18637	1120	67	on	on	IN
18637	1120	68	March	March	NNP
18637	1120	69	5	5	CD
18637	1120	70	,	,	,
18637	1120	71	1868	1868	CD
18637	1120	72	;	;	:
18637	1120	73	and	and	CC
18637	1120	74	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1120	75	was	be	VBD
18637	1120	76	repassed	repasse	VBN
18637	1120	77	over	over	IN
18637	1120	78	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1120	79	veto	veto	NN
18637	1120	80	on	on	IN
18637	1120	81	March	March	NNP
18637	1120	82	24	24	CD
18637	1120	83	,	,	,
18637	1120	84	1868	1868	CD
18637	1120	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1120	86	;	;	:
18637	1120	87	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	1120	88	,	,	,
18637	1120	89	September	September	NNP
18637	1120	90	19	19	CD
18637	1120	91	,	,	,
18637	1120	92	1866	1866	CD
18637	1120	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1120	94	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	1120	95	"	"	``
18637	1120	96	withdrew	withdraw	VBD
18637	1120	97	"	"	''
18637	1120	98	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1120	99	consent	consent	NN
18637	1120	100	on	on	IN
18637	1120	101	October	October	NNP
18637	1120	102	15	15	CD
18637	1120	103	,	,	,
18637	1120	104	1868	1868	CD
18637	1120	105	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1120	106	;	;	:
18637	1120	107	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	1120	108	,	,	,
18637	1120	109	October	October	NNP
18637	1120	110	30	30	CD
18637	1120	111	,	,	,
18637	1120	112	1866	1866	CD
18637	1120	113	;	;	:
18637	1120	114	New	New	NNP
18637	1120	115	York	York	NNP
18637	1120	116	,	,	,
18637	1120	117	January	January	NNP
18637	1120	118	10	10	CD
18637	1120	119	,	,	,
18637	1120	120	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	121	;	;	:
18637	1120	122	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1120	123	,	,	,
18637	1120	124	January	January	NNP
18637	1120	125	11	11	CD
18637	1120	126	,	,	,
18637	1120	127	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	128	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1120	129	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1120	130	"	"	``
18637	1120	131	withdrew	withdraw	VBD
18637	1120	132	"	"	``
18637	1120	133	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1120	134	consent	consent	NN
18637	1120	135	on	on	IN
18637	1120	136	January	January	NNP
18637	1120	137	15	15	CD
18637	1120	138	,	,	,
18637	1120	139	1868	1868	CD
18637	1120	140	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1120	141	;	;	:
18637	1120	142	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	1120	143	,	,	,
18637	1120	144	January	January	NNP
18637	1120	145	15	15	CD
18637	1120	146	,	,	,
18637	1120	147	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	148	;	;	:
18637	1120	149	West	West	NNP
18637	1120	150	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1120	151	,	,	,
18637	1120	152	January	January	NNP
18637	1120	153	16	16	CD
18637	1120	154	,	,	,
18637	1120	155	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	156	;	;	:
18637	1120	157	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	1120	158	,	,	,
18637	1120	159	January	January	NNP
18637	1120	160	16	16	CD
18637	1120	161	,	,	,
18637	1120	162	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	163	;	;	:
18637	1120	164	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	1120	165	,	,	,
18637	1120	166	January	January	NNP
18637	1120	167	17	17	CD
18637	1120	168	,	,	,
18637	1120	169	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	170	;	;	:
18637	1120	171	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	1120	172	,	,	,
18637	1120	173	January	January	NNP
18637	1120	174	17	17	CD
18637	1120	175	,	,	,
18637	1120	176	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	177	;	;	:
18637	1120	178	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	1120	179	,	,	,
18637	1120	180	January	January	NNP
18637	1120	181	19	19	CD
18637	1120	182	,	,	,
18637	1120	183	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	184	;	;	:
18637	1120	185	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	1120	186	,	,	,
18637	1120	187	January	January	NNP
18637	1120	188	22	22	CD
18637	1120	189	,	,	,
18637	1120	190	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	191	;	;	:
18637	1120	192	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	1120	193	,	,	,
18637	1120	194	January	January	NNP
18637	1120	195	23	23	CD
18637	1120	196	,	,	,
18637	1120	197	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	198	;	;	:
18637	1120	199	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	1120	200	,	,	,
18637	1120	201	January	January	NNP
18637	1120	202	26	26	CD
18637	1120	203	,	,	,
18637	1120	204	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	205	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1120	206	date	date	NN
18637	1120	207	on	on	IN
18637	1120	208	which	which	WDT
18637	1120	209	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1120	210	was	be	VBD
18637	1120	211	certified	certify	VBN
18637	1120	212	by	by	IN
18637	1120	213	the	the	DT
18637	1120	214	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	1120	215	secretary	secretary	NN
18637	1120	216	of	of	IN
18637	1120	217	state	state	NN
18637	1120	218	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1120	219	;	;	:
18637	1120	220	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	1120	221	Island	Island	NNP
18637	1120	222	,	,	,
18637	1120	223	February	February	NNP
18637	1120	224	7	7	CD
18637	1120	225	,	,	,
18637	1120	226	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	227	;	;	:
18637	1120	228	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	1120	229	,	,	,
18637	1120	230	February	February	NNP
18637	1120	231	12	12	CD
18637	1120	232	,	,	,
18637	1120	233	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	234	;	;	:
18637	1120	235	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	1120	236	,	,	,
18637	1120	237	February	February	NNP
18637	1120	238	13	13	CD
18637	1120	239	,	,	,
18637	1120	240	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	241	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1120	242	actually	actually	RB
18637	1120	243	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1120	244	February	February	NNP
18637	1120	245	7	7	CD
18637	1120	246	,	,	,
18637	1120	247	but	but	CC
18637	1120	248	not	not	RB
18637	1120	249	signed	sign	VBN
18637	1120	250	by	by	IN
18637	1120	251	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1120	252	officers	officer	NNS
18637	1120	253	until	until	IN
18637	1120	254	February	February	NNP
18637	1120	255	13	13	CD
18637	1120	256	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1120	257	;	;	:
18637	1120	258	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	1120	259	,	,	,
18637	1120	260	March	March	NNP
18637	1120	261	20	20	CD
18637	1120	262	,	,	,
18637	1120	263	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	264	;	;	:
18637	1120	265	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	1120	266	,	,	,
18637	1120	267	June	June	NNP
18637	1120	268	15	15	CD
18637	1120	269	,	,	,
18637	1120	270	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	271	;	;	:
18637	1120	272	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	1120	273	,	,	,
18637	1120	274	March	March	NNP
18637	1120	275	9	9	CD
18637	1120	276	,	,	,
18637	1120	277	1868	1868	CD
18637	1120	278	;	;	:
18637	1120	279	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	1120	280	,	,	,
18637	1120	281	April	April	NNP
18637	1120	282	6	6	CD
18637	1120	283	,	,	,
18637	1120	284	1868	1868	CD
18637	1120	285	;	;	:
18637	1120	286	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	1120	287	,	,	,
18637	1120	288	June	June	NNP
18637	1120	289	9	9	CD
18637	1120	290	,	,	,
18637	1120	291	1868	1868	CD
18637	1120	292	;	;	:
18637	1120	293	North	North	NNP
18637	1120	294	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1120	295	,	,	,
18637	1120	296	July	July	NNP
18637	1120	297	2	2	CD
18637	1120	298	,	,	,
18637	1120	299	1868	1868	CD
18637	1120	300	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1120	301	after	after	IN
18637	1120	302	having	have	VBG
18637	1120	303	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1120	304	the	the	DT
18637	1120	305	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1120	306	on	on	IN
18637	1120	307	December	December	NNP
18637	1120	308	13	13	CD
18637	1120	309	,	,	,
18637	1120	310	1866	1866	CD
18637	1120	311	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1120	312	;	;	:
18637	1120	313	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	1120	314	,	,	,
18637	1120	315	July	July	NNP
18637	1120	316	9	9	CD
18637	1120	317	,	,	,
18637	1120	318	1868	1868	CD
18637	1120	319	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1120	320	after	after	IN
18637	1120	321	having	have	VBG
18637	1120	322	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1120	323	the	the	DT
18637	1120	324	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1120	325	on	on	IN
18637	1120	326	February	February	NNP
18637	1120	327	6	6	CD
18637	1120	328	,	,	,
18637	1120	329	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	330	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1120	331	;	;	:
18637	1120	332	South	South	NNP
18637	1120	333	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1120	334	,	,	,
18637	1120	335	July	July	NNP
18637	1120	336	8	8	CD
18637	1120	337	,	,	,
18637	1120	338	1868	1868	CD
18637	1120	339	;	;	:
18637	1120	340	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1120	341	after	after	IN
18637	1120	342	having	have	VBG
18637	1120	343	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1120	344	the	the	DT
18637	1120	345	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1120	346	on	on	IN
18637	1120	347	December	December	NNP
18637	1120	348	20	20	CD
18637	1120	349	,	,	,
18637	1120	350	1866	1866	CD
18637	1120	351	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1120	352	;	;	:
18637	1120	353	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	1120	354	,	,	,
18637	1120	355	July	July	NNP
18637	1120	356	13	13	CD
18637	1120	357	,	,	,
18637	1120	358	1868	1868	CD
18637	1120	359	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1120	360	date	date	NN
18637	1120	361	on	on	IN
18637	1120	362	which	which	WDT
18637	1120	363	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1120	364	was	be	VBD
18637	1120	365	"	"	``
18637	1120	366	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1120	367	"	"	''
18637	1120	368	by	by	IN
18637	1120	369	the	the	DT
18637	1120	370	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1120	371	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1120	372	;	;	:
18637	1120	373	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	1120	374	,	,	,
18637	1120	375	July	July	NNP
18637	1120	376	21	21	CD
18637	1120	377	,	,	,
18637	1120	378	1868	1868	CD
18637	1120	379	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1120	380	after	after	IN
18637	1120	381	having	have	VBG
18637	1120	382	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1120	383	the	the	DT
18637	1120	384	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1120	385	on	on	IN
18637	1120	386	November	November	NNP
18637	1120	387	9	9	CD
18637	1120	388	,	,	,
18637	1120	389	1866	1866	CD
18637	1120	390	-	-	HYPH
18637	1120	391	-Georgia	-georgia	NN
18637	1120	392	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1120	393	again	again	RB
18637	1120	394	on	on	IN
18637	1120	395	February	February	NNP
18637	1120	396	2	2	CD
18637	1120	397	,	,	,
18637	1120	398	1870	1870	CD
18637	1120	399	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1120	400	;	;	:
18637	1120	401	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1120	402	,	,	,
18637	1120	403	October	October	NNP
18637	1120	404	8	8	CD
18637	1120	405	,	,	,
18637	1120	406	1869	1869	CD
18637	1120	407	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1120	408	after	after	IN
18637	1120	409	having	have	VBG
18637	1120	410	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1120	411	the	the	DT
18637	1120	412	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1120	413	on	on	IN
18637	1120	414	January	January	NNP
18637	1120	415	9	9	CD
18637	1120	416	,	,	,
18637	1120	417	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	418	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1120	419	;	;	:
18637	1120	420	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	1120	421	,	,	,
18637	1120	422	January	January	NNP
18637	1120	423	17	17	CD
18637	1120	424	,	,	,
18637	1120	425	1870	1870	CD
18637	1120	426	;	;	:
18637	1120	427	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	1120	428	,	,	,
18637	1120	429	February	February	NNP
18637	1120	430	18	18	CD
18637	1120	431	,	,	,
18637	1120	432	1870	1870	CD
18637	1120	433	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1120	434	after	after	IN
18637	1120	435	having	have	VBG
18637	1120	436	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1120	437	the	the	DT
18637	1120	438	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1120	439	on	on	IN
18637	1120	440	October	October	NNP
18637	1120	441	27	27	CD
18637	1120	442	,	,	,
18637	1120	443	1866	1866	CD
18637	1120	444	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1120	445	;	;	:
18637	1120	446	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	1120	447	,	,	,
18637	1120	448	February	February	NNP
18637	1120	449	12	12	CD
18637	1120	450	,	,	,
18637	1120	451	1901	1901	CD
18637	1120	452	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1120	453	after	after	IN
18637	1120	454	having	have	VBG
18637	1120	455	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1120	456	the	the	DT
18637	1120	457	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1120	458	on	on	IN
18637	1120	459	February	February	NNP
18637	1120	460	7	7	CD
18637	1120	461	,	,	,
18637	1120	462	1867	1867	CD
18637	1120	463	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1120	464	.	.	.
18637	1121	1	The	the	DT
18637	1121	2	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1121	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1121	4	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1121	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1121	6	and	and	CC
18637	1121	7	not	not	RB
18637	1121	8	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	1121	9	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1121	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1121	11	by	by	IN
18637	1121	12	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	1121	13	on	on	IN
18637	1121	14	January	January	NNP
18637	1121	15	8	8	CD
18637	1121	16	,	,	,
18637	1121	17	1807	1807	CD
18637	1121	18	,	,	,
18637	1121	19	and	and	CC
18637	1121	20	by	by	IN
18637	1121	21	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1121	22	on	on	IN
18637	1121	23	March	March	NNP
18637	1121	24	23	23	CD
18637	1121	25	,	,	,
18637	1121	26	1867	1867	CD
18637	1121	27	.	.	.
18637	1122	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1122	2	g	g	NNP
18637	1122	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1122	4	The	the	DT
18637	1122	5	15th	15th	JJ
18637	1122	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1122	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1122	8	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1122	9	by	by	IN
18637	1122	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1122	11	on	on	IN
18637	1122	12	February	February	NNP
18637	1122	13	26	26	CD
18637	1122	14	,	,	,
18637	1122	15	1869	1869	CD
18637	1122	16	,	,	,
18637	1122	17	when	when	WRB
18637	1122	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1122	19	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1122	20	the	the	DT
18637	1122	21	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1122	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1122	23	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1122	24	.	.	.
18637	1123	1	Globe	Globe	NNP
18637	1123	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1123	3	40th	40th	NNP
18637	1123	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1123	5	.	.	NNP
18637	1123	6	,	,	,
18637	1123	7	3rd	3rd	JJ
18637	1123	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	1123	9	.	.	.
18637	1123	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1124	1	1641	1641	CD
18637	1124	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1124	3	,	,	,
18637	1124	4	having	have	VBG
18637	1124	5	previously	previously	RB
18637	1124	6	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1124	7	the	the	DT
18637	1124	8	House	House	NNP
18637	1124	9	on	on	IN
18637	1124	10	February	February	NNP
18637	1124	11	25	25	CD
18637	1124	12	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1124	13	_	_	NNP
18637	1124	14	Id.	Idaho	NNP
18637	1124	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1124	16	1563	1563	CD
18637	1124	17	,	,	,
18637	1124	18	1564	1564	CD
18637	1124	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1124	20	.	.	.
18637	1125	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1125	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1125	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1125	4	in	in	IN
18637	1125	5	15	15	CD
18637	1125	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1125	7	.	.	.
18637	1126	1	346	346	CD
18637	1126	2	under	under	IN
18637	1126	3	date	date	NN
18637	1126	4	of	of	IN
18637	1126	5	February	February	NNP
18637	1126	6	27	27	CD
18637	1126	7	,	,	,
18637	1126	8	1869	1869	CD
18637	1126	9	.	.	.
18637	1127	1	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1127	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1127	3	probably	probably	RB
18637	1127	4	completed	complete	VBN
18637	1127	5	on	on	IN
18637	1127	6	February	February	NNP
18637	1127	7	3	3	CD
18637	1127	8	,	,	,
18637	1127	9	1870	1870	CD
18637	1127	10	,	,	,
18637	1127	11	when	when	WRB
18637	1127	12	the	the	DT
18637	1127	13	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1127	14	of	of	IN
18637	1127	15	the	the	DT
18637	1127	16	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	1127	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	1127	18	eighth	eighth	JJ
18637	1127	19	State	State	NNP
18637	1127	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1127	21	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	1127	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1127	23	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1127	24	the	the	DT
18637	1127	25	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1127	26	,	,	,
18637	1127	27	there	there	EX
18637	1127	28	being	be	VBG
18637	1127	29	then	then	RB
18637	1127	30	37	37	CD
18637	1127	31	States	States	NNPS
18637	1127	32	in	in	IN
18637	1127	33	the	the	DT
18637	1127	34	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1127	35	.	.	.
18637	1128	1	However	however	RB
18637	1128	2	,	,	,
18637	1128	3	New	New	NNP
18637	1128	4	York	York	NNP
18637	1128	5	had	have	VBD
18637	1128	6	prior	prior	RB
18637	1128	7	to	to	IN
18637	1128	8	that	that	DT
18637	1128	9	date	date	NN
18637	1128	10	"	"	``
18637	1128	11	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	1128	12	"	"	''
18637	1128	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1128	14	earlier	early	JJR
18637	1128	15	assent	assent	NN
18637	1128	16	to	to	IN
18637	1128	17	this	this	DT
18637	1128	18	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1128	19	.	.	.
18637	1129	1	Even	even	RB
18637	1129	2	if	if	IN
18637	1129	3	this	this	DT
18637	1129	4	withdrawal	withdrawal	NN
18637	1129	5	were	be	VBD
18637	1129	6	effective	effective	JJ
18637	1129	7	,	,	,
18637	1129	8	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	1129	9	's	's	POS
18637	1129	10	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1129	11	on	on	IN
18637	1129	12	February	February	NNP
18637	1129	13	17	17	CD
18637	1129	14	,	,	,
18637	1129	15	1870	1870	CD
18637	1129	16	,	,	,
18637	1129	17	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	1129	18	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1129	19	of	of	IN
18637	1129	20	State	State	NNP
18637	1129	21	Fish	Fish	NNP
18637	1129	22	's	's	POS
18637	1129	23	certification	certification	NN
18637	1129	24	of	of	IN
18637	1129	25	March	March	NNP
18637	1129	26	30	30	CD
18637	1129	27	,	,	,
18637	1129	28	1870	1870	CD
18637	1129	29	,	,	,
18637	1129	30	that	that	IN
18637	1129	31	the	the	DT
18637	1129	32	15th	15th	NNP
18637	1129	33	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1129	34	had	have	VBD
18637	1129	35	become	become	VBN
18637	1129	36	a	a	DT
18637	1129	37	part	part	NN
18637	1129	38	of	of	IN
18637	1129	39	the	the	DT
18637	1129	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1129	41	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1129	42	16	16	CD
18637	1129	43	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	1129	44	1131	1131	CD
18637	1129	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1129	46	.	.	.
18637	1130	1	The	the	DT
18637	1130	2	several	several	JJ
18637	1130	3	State	State	NNP
18637	1130	4	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1130	5	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1130	6	the	the	DT
18637	1130	7	15th	15th	JJ
18637	1130	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1130	9	on	on	IN
18637	1130	10	the	the	DT
18637	1130	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	1130	12	dates	date	NNS
18637	1130	13	:	:	:
18637	1130	14	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	1130	15	,	,	,
18637	1130	16	March	March	NNP
18637	1130	17	1	1	CD
18637	1130	18	,	,	,
18637	1130	19	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	20	;	;	:
18637	1130	21	West	West	NNP
18637	1130	22	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1130	23	,	,	,
18637	1130	24	March	March	NNP
18637	1130	25	3	3	CD
18637	1130	26	,	,	,
18637	1130	27	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	28	;	;	:
18637	1130	29	North	North	NNP
18637	1130	30	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1130	31	,	,	,
18637	1130	32	March	March	NNP
18637	1130	33	5	5	CD
18637	1130	34	,	,	,
18637	1130	35	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	36	;	;	:
18637	1130	37	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	1130	38	,	,	,
18637	1130	39	March	March	NNP
18637	1130	40	5	5	CD
18637	1130	41	,	,	,
18637	1130	42	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1130	44	date	date	NN
18637	1130	45	on	on	IN
18637	1130	46	which	which	WDT
18637	1130	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1130	48	was	be	VBD
18637	1130	49	"	"	``
18637	1130	50	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1130	51	"	"	''
18637	1130	52	by	by	IN
18637	1130	53	the	the	DT
18637	1130	54	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1130	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1130	56	;	;	:
18637	1130	57	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	1130	58	March	March	NNP
18637	1130	59	5	5	CD
18637	1130	60	,	,	,
18637	1130	61	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	62	;	;	:
18637	1130	63	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	1130	64	,	,	,
18637	1130	65	March	March	NNP
18637	1130	66	5	5	CD
18637	1130	67	,	,	,
18637	1130	68	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	69	;	;	:
18637	1130	70	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	1130	71	,	,	,
18637	1130	72	March	March	NNP
18637	1130	73	5	5	CD
18637	1130	74	,	,	,
18637	1130	75	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	76	;	;	:
18637	1130	77	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	1130	78	,	,	,
18637	1130	79	March	March	NNP
18637	1130	80	11	11	CD
18637	1130	81	,	,	,
18637	1130	82	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	83	;	;	:
18637	1130	84	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	1130	85	,	,	,
18637	1130	86	March	March	NNP
18637	1130	87	12	12	CD
18637	1130	88	,	,	,
18637	1130	89	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	90	;	;	:
18637	1130	91	South	South	NNP
18637	1130	92	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1130	93	,	,	,
18637	1130	94	March	March	NNP
18637	1130	95	15	15	CD
18637	1130	96	,	,	,
18637	1130	97	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	98	;	;	:
18637	1130	99	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	1130	100	,	,	,
18637	1130	101	March	March	NNP
18637	1130	102	15	15	CD
18637	1130	103	,	,	,
18637	1130	104	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	105	;	;	:
18637	1130	106	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	1130	107	,	,	,
18637	1130	108	March	March	NNP
18637	1130	109	25	25	CD
18637	1130	110	,	,	,
18637	1130	111	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	112	;	;	:
18637	1130	113	New	New	NNP
18637	1130	114	York	York	NNP
18637	1130	115	,	,	,
18637	1130	116	April	April	NNP
18637	1130	117	14	14	CD
18637	1130	118	,	,	,
18637	1130	119	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	120	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1130	121	New	New	NNP
18637	1130	122	York	York	NNP
18637	1130	123	"	"	''
18637	1130	124	withdrew	withdraw	VBD
18637	1130	125	"	"	``
18637	1130	126	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1130	127	consent	consent	NN
18637	1130	128	to	to	IN
18637	1130	129	the	the	DT
18637	1130	130	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1130	131	on	on	IN
18637	1130	132	January	January	NNP
18637	1130	133	5	5	CD
18637	1130	134	,	,	,
18637	1130	135	1870	1870	CD
18637	1130	136	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1130	137	;	;	:
18637	1130	138	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	1130	139	,	,	,
18637	1130	140	May	May	NNP
18637	1130	141	14	14	CD
18637	1130	142	,	,	,
18637	1130	143	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	144	;	;	:
18637	1130	145	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	1130	146	,	,	,
18637	1130	147	May	May	NNP
18637	1130	148	19	19	CD
18637	1130	149	,	,	,
18637	1130	150	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	151	;	;	:
18637	1130	152	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	1130	153	,	,	,
18637	1130	154	June	June	NNP
18637	1130	155	14	14	CD
18637	1130	156	,	,	,
18637	1130	157	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	158	;	;	:
18637	1130	159	New	New	NNP
18637	1130	160	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1130	161	,	,	,
18637	1130	162	July	July	NNP
18637	1130	163	1	1	CD
18637	1130	164	,	,	,
18637	1130	165	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	166	;	;	:
18637	1130	167	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1130	168	,	,	,
18637	1130	169	October	October	NNP
18637	1130	170	8	8	CD
18637	1130	171	,	,	,
18637	1130	172	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	173	;	;	:
18637	1130	174	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	1130	175	,	,	,
18637	1130	176	October	October	NNP
18637	1130	177	20	20	CD
18637	1130	178	,	,	,
18637	1130	179	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	180	;	;	:
18637	1130	181	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	1130	182	,	,	,
18637	1130	183	November	November	NNP
18637	1130	184	16	16	CD
18637	1130	185	,	,	,
18637	1130	186	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	187	;	;	:
18637	1130	188	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	1130	189	,	,	,
18637	1130	190	January	January	NNP
18637	1130	191	7	7	CD
18637	1130	192	,	,	,
18637	1130	193	1870	1870	CD
18637	1130	194	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1130	195	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	1130	196	had	have	VBD
18637	1130	197	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1130	198	the	the	DT
18637	1130	199	first	first	JJ
18637	1130	200	section	section	NN
18637	1130	201	of	of	IN
18637	1130	202	the	the	DT
18637	1130	203	15th	15th	JJ
18637	1130	204	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1130	205	on	on	IN
18637	1130	206	March	March	NNP
18637	1130	207	1	1	CD
18637	1130	208	,	,	,
18637	1130	209	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	210	;	;	:
18637	1130	211	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1130	212	failed	fail	VBD
18637	1130	213	to	to	TO
18637	1130	214	include	include	VB
18637	1130	215	in	in	IN
18637	1130	216	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1130	217	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1130	218	the	the	DT
18637	1130	219	second	second	JJ
18637	1130	220	section	section	NN
18637	1130	221	of	of	IN
18637	1130	222	the	the	DT
18637	1130	223	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1130	224	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1130	225	;	;	:
18637	1130	226	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	1130	227	,	,	,
18637	1130	228	January	January	NNP
18637	1130	229	13	13	CD
18637	1130	230	,	,	,
18637	1130	231	1870	1870	CD
18637	1130	232	;	;	:
18637	1130	233	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	1130	234	,	,	,
18637	1130	235	January	January	NNP
18637	1130	236	17	17	CD
18637	1130	237	,	,	,
18637	1130	238	1870	1870	CD
18637	1130	239	;	;	:
18637	1130	240	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	1130	241	Island	Island	NNP
18637	1130	242	,	,	,
18637	1130	243	January	January	NNP
18637	1130	244	18	18	CD
18637	1130	245	,	,	,
18637	1130	246	1870	1870	CD
18637	1130	247	;	;	:
18637	1130	248	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	1130	249	,	,	,
18637	1130	250	January	January	NNP
18637	1130	251	19	19	CD
18637	1130	252	,	,	,
18637	1130	253	1870	1870	CD
18637	1130	254	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1130	255	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	1130	256	had	have	VBD
18637	1130	257	by	by	IN
18637	1130	258	a	a	DT
18637	1130	259	defectively	defectively	RB
18637	1130	260	worded	word	VBN
18637	1130	261	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	1130	262	previously	previously	RB
18637	1130	263	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1130	264	this	this	DT
18637	1130	265	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1130	266	on	on	IN
18637	1130	267	February	February	NNP
18637	1130	268	27	27	CD
18637	1130	269	,	,	,
18637	1130	270	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	271	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1130	272	;	;	:
18637	1130	273	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1130	274	,	,	,
18637	1130	275	January	January	NNP
18637	1130	276	27	27	CD
18637	1130	277	,	,	,
18637	1130	278	1870	1870	CD
18637	1130	279	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1130	280	after	after	IN
18637	1130	281	having	have	VBG
18637	1130	282	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1130	283	the	the	DT
18637	1130	284	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1130	285	on	on	IN
18637	1130	286	May	May	NNP
18637	1130	287	4	4	CD
18637	1130	288	,	,	,
18637	1130	289	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	290	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1130	291	;	;	:
18637	1130	292	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	1130	293	,	,	,
18637	1130	294	February	February	NNP
18637	1130	295	2	2	CD
18637	1130	296	,	,	,
18637	1130	297	1870	1870	CD
18637	1130	298	;	;	:
18637	1130	299	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	1130	300	,	,	,
18637	1130	301	February	February	NNP
18637	1130	302	3	3	CD
18637	1130	303	,	,	,
18637	1130	304	1870	1870	CD
18637	1130	305	;	;	:
18637	1130	306	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	1130	307	,	,	,
18637	1130	308	February	February	NNP
18637	1130	309	17	17	CD
18637	1130	310	,	,	,
18637	1130	311	1870	1870	CD
18637	1130	312	;	;	:
18637	1130	313	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	1130	314	,	,	,
18637	1130	315	February	February	NNP
18637	1130	316	18	18	CD
18637	1130	317	,	,	,
18637	1130	318	1870	1870	CD
18637	1130	319	;	;	:
18637	1130	320	New	New	NNP
18637	1130	321	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1130	322	,	,	,
18637	1130	323	February	February	NNP
18637	1130	324	15	15	CD
18637	1130	325	,	,	,
18637	1130	326	1871	1871	CD
18637	1130	327	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1130	328	after	after	IN
18637	1130	329	having	have	VBG
18637	1130	330	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1130	331	the	the	DT
18637	1130	332	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1130	333	on	on	IN
18637	1130	334	February	February	NNP
18637	1130	335	7	7	CD
18637	1130	336	,	,	,
18637	1130	337	1870	1870	CD
18637	1130	338	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1130	339	;	;	:
18637	1130	340	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	1130	341	,	,	,
18637	1130	342	February	February	NNP
18637	1130	343	12	12	CD
18637	1130	344	,	,	,
18637	1130	345	1901	1901	CD
18637	1130	346	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1130	347	date	date	NN
18637	1130	348	on	on	IN
18637	1130	349	which	which	WDT
18637	1130	350	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1130	351	by	by	IN
18637	1130	352	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1130	353	;	;	:
18637	1130	354	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	1130	355	had	have	VBD
18637	1130	356	previously	previously	RB
18637	1130	357	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1130	358	the	the	DT
18637	1130	359	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1130	360	on	on	IN
18637	1130	361	March	March	NNP
18637	1130	362	18	18	CD
18637	1130	363	,	,	,
18637	1130	364	1869	1869	CD
18637	1130	365	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1130	366	.	.	.
18637	1131	1	The	the	DT
18637	1131	2	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1131	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1131	4	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1131	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1131	6	and	and	CC
18637	1131	7	not	not	RB
18637	1131	8	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	1131	9	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1131	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1131	11	by	by	IN
18637	1131	12	California	California	NNP
18637	1131	13	,	,	,
18637	1131	14	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	1131	15	,	,	,
18637	1131	16	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1131	17	,	,	,
18637	1131	18	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	1131	19	,	,	,
18637	1131	20	and	and	CC
18637	1131	21	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	1131	22	.	.	.
18637	1132	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1132	2	h	h	LS
18637	1132	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1132	4	The	the	DT
18637	1132	5	16th	16th	JJ
18637	1132	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1132	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1132	8	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1132	9	by	by	IN
18637	1132	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1132	11	on	on	IN
18637	1132	12	July	July	NNP
18637	1132	13	12	12	CD
18637	1132	14	,	,	,
18637	1132	15	1909	1909	CD
18637	1132	16	,	,	,
18637	1132	17	when	when	WRB
18637	1132	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1132	19	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1132	20	the	the	DT
18637	1132	21	House	House	NNP
18637	1132	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1132	23	44	44	CD
18637	1132	24	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1132	25	.	.	.
18637	1133	1	Rec	Rec	NNP
18637	1133	2	.	.	.
18637	1134	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1134	2	61st	61st	JJ
18637	1134	3	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1134	4	.	.	NNP
18637	1134	5	,	,	,
18637	1134	6	1st	1st	JJ
18637	1134	7	sess	sess	NN
18637	1134	8	.	.	.
18637	1134	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1135	1	4390	4390	CD
18637	1135	2	,	,	,
18637	1135	3	4440	4440	CD
18637	1135	4	,	,	,
18637	1135	5	4441	4441	CD
18637	1135	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1135	7	,	,	,
18637	1135	8	having	have	VBG
18637	1135	9	previously	previously	RB
18637	1135	10	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1135	11	the	the	DT
18637	1135	12	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1135	13	on	on	IN
18637	1135	14	July	July	NNP
18637	1135	15	5	5	CD
18637	1135	16	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1135	17	_	_	NNP
18637	1135	18	Id.	Idaho	NNP
18637	1135	19	_	_	NNP
18637	1135	20	,	,	,
18637	1135	21	4121	4121	CD
18637	1135	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1135	23	.	.	.
18637	1136	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1136	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1136	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1136	4	in	in	IN
18637	1136	5	36	36	CD
18637	1136	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1136	7	184	184	CD
18637	1136	8	.	.	.
18637	1137	1	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1137	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1137	3	completed	complete	VBN
18637	1137	4	on	on	IN
18637	1137	5	February	February	NNP
18637	1137	6	3	3	CD
18637	1137	7	,	,	,
18637	1137	8	1913	1913	CD
18637	1137	9	,	,	,
18637	1137	10	when	when	WRB
18637	1137	11	the	the	DT
18637	1137	12	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1137	13	of	of	IN
18637	1137	14	the	the	DT
18637	1137	15	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	1137	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	1137	17	sixth	sixth	JJ
18637	1137	18	State	State	NNP
18637	1137	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1137	20	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	1137	21	,	,	,
18637	1137	22	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	1137	23	,	,	,
18637	1137	24	or	or	CC
18637	1137	25	New	New	NNP
18637	1137	26	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	1137	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1137	28	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1137	29	the	the	DT
18637	1137	30	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1137	31	,	,	,
18637	1137	32	there	there	EX
18637	1137	33	being	be	VBG
18637	1137	34	then	then	RB
18637	1137	35	48	48	CD
18637	1137	36	States	state	NNS
18637	1137	37	in	in	IN
18637	1137	38	the	the	DT
18637	1137	39	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1137	40	.	.	.
18637	1138	1	On	on	IN
18637	1138	2	February	February	NNP
18637	1138	3	25	25	CD
18637	1138	4	,	,	,
18637	1138	5	1913	1913	CD
18637	1138	6	,	,	,
18637	1138	7	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1138	8	of	of	IN
18637	1138	9	State	State	NNP
18637	1138	10	Knox	Knox	NNP
18637	1138	11	certified	certify	VBD
18637	1138	12	that	that	IN
18637	1138	13	this	this	DT
18637	1138	14	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1138	15	had	have	VBD
18637	1138	16	become	become	VBN
18637	1138	17	a	a	DT
18637	1138	18	part	part	NN
18637	1138	19	of	of	IN
18637	1138	20	the	the	DT
18637	1138	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1138	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1138	23	37	37	CD
18637	1138	24	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1138	25	.	.	.
18637	1139	1	1785	1785	LS
18637	1139	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1139	3	.	.	.
18637	1140	1	The	the	DT
18637	1140	2	several	several	JJ
18637	1140	3	State	State	NNP
18637	1140	4	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1140	5	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1140	6	the	the	DT
18637	1140	7	16th	16th	JJ
18637	1140	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1140	9	on	on	IN
18637	1140	10	the	the	DT
18637	1140	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	1140	12	dates	date	NNS
18637	1140	13	:	:	:
18637	1140	14	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	1140	15	,	,	,
18637	1140	16	August	August	NNP
18637	1140	17	10	10	CD
18637	1140	18	,	,	,
18637	1140	19	1909	1909	CD
18637	1140	20	;	;	:
18637	1140	21	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	1140	22	,	,	,
18637	1140	23	February	February	NNP
18637	1140	24	8	8	CD
18637	1140	25	,	,	,
18637	1140	26	1910	1910	CD
18637	1140	27	;	;	:
18637	1140	28	South	South	NNP
18637	1140	29	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1140	30	,	,	,
18637	1140	31	February	February	NNP
18637	1140	32	19	19	CD
18637	1140	33	,	,	,
18637	1140	34	1910	1910	CD
18637	1140	35	;	;	:
18637	1140	36	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	1140	37	,	,	,
18637	1140	38	March	March	NNP
18637	1140	39	1	1	CD
18637	1140	40	,	,	,
18637	1140	41	1910	1910	CD
18637	1140	42	;	;	:
18637	1140	43	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	1140	44	,	,	,
18637	1140	45	March	March	NNP
18637	1140	46	7	7	CD
18637	1140	47	,	,	,
18637	1140	48	1910	1910	CD
18637	1140	49	;	;	:
18637	1140	50	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	1140	51	,	,	,
18637	1140	52	March	March	NNP
18637	1140	53	10	10	CD
18637	1140	54	,	,	,
18637	1140	55	1910	1910	CD
18637	1140	56	;	;	:
18637	1140	57	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1140	58	,	,	,
18637	1140	59	April	April	NNP
18637	1140	60	8	8	CD
18637	1140	61	,	,	,
18637	1140	62	1910	1910	CD
18637	1140	63	;	;	:
18637	1140	64	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	1140	65	,	,	,
18637	1140	66	August	August	NNP
18637	1140	67	3	3	CD
18637	1140	68	,	,	,
18637	1140	69	1910	1910	CD
18637	1140	70	;	;	:
18637	1140	71	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	1140	72	,	,	,
18637	1140	73	August	August	NNP
18637	1140	74	16	16	CD
18637	1140	75	,	,	,
18637	1140	76	1910	1910	CD
18637	1140	77	;	;	:
18637	1140	78	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1140	79	,	,	,
18637	1140	80	January	January	NNP
18637	1140	81	19	19	CD
18637	1140	82	,	,	,
18637	1140	83	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	84	;	;	:
18637	1140	85	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
18637	1140	86	,	,	,
18637	1140	87	January	January	NNP
18637	1140	88	20	20	CD
18637	1140	89	,	,	,
18637	1140	90	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	91	;	;	:
18637	1140	92	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	1140	93	,	,	,
18637	1140	94	January	January	NNP
18637	1140	95	23	23	CD
18637	1140	96	,	,	,
18637	1140	97	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	98	;	;	:
18637	1140	99	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	1140	100	,	,	,
18637	1140	101	January	January	NNP
18637	1140	102	26	26	CD
18637	1140	103	,	,	,
18637	1140	104	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	105	;	;	:
18637	1140	106	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	1140	107	,	,	,
18637	1140	108	January	January	NNP
18637	1140	109	27	27	CD
18637	1140	110	,	,	,
18637	1140	111	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	112	;	;	:
18637	1140	113	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	1140	114	,	,	,
18637	1140	115	January	January	NNP
18637	1140	116	30	30	CD
18637	1140	117	,	,	,
18637	1140	118	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	119	;	;	:
18637	1140	120	California	California	NNP
18637	1140	121	,	,	,
18637	1140	122	January	January	NNP
18637	1140	123	31	31	CD
18637	1140	124	,	,	,
18637	1140	125	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	126	;	;	:
18637	1140	127	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	1140	128	,	,	,
18637	1140	129	January	January	NNP
18637	1140	130	31	31	CD
18637	1140	131	,	,	,
18637	1140	132	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	133	;	;	:
18637	1140	134	South	South	NNP
18637	1140	135	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	1140	136	,	,	,
18637	1140	137	February	February	NNP
18637	1140	138	1	1	CD
18637	1140	139	,	,	,
18637	1140	140	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	141	;	;	:
18637	1140	142	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	1140	143	,	,	,
18637	1140	144	February	February	NNP
18637	1140	145	9	9	CD
18637	1140	146	,	,	,
18637	1140	147	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	148	;	;	:
18637	1140	149	North	North	NNP
18637	1140	150	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1140	151	,	,	,
18637	1140	152	February	February	NNP
18637	1140	153	11	11	CD
18637	1140	154	,	,	,
18637	1140	155	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	156	;	;	:
18637	1140	157	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	1140	158	,	,	,
18637	1140	159	February	February	NNP
18637	1140	160	15	15	CD
18637	1140	161	,	,	,
18637	1140	162	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	163	;	;	:
18637	1140	164	North	North	NNP
18637	1140	165	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	1140	166	,	,	,
18637	1140	167	February	February	NNP
18637	1140	168	17	17	CD
18637	1140	169	,	,	,
18637	1140	170	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	171	;	;	:
18637	1140	172	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	1140	173	,	,	,
18637	1140	174	February	February	NNP
18637	1140	175	23	23	CD
18637	1140	176	,	,	,
18637	1140	177	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	178	;	;	:
18637	1140	179	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	1140	180	,	,	,
18637	1140	181	February	February	NNP
18637	1140	182	24	24	CD
18637	1140	183	,	,	,
18637	1140	184	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	185	;	;	:
18637	1140	186	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	1140	187	,	,	,
18637	1140	188	March	March	NNP
18637	1140	189	2	2	CD
18637	1140	190	,	,	,
18637	1140	191	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	192	;	;	:
18637	1140	193	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	1140	194	,	,	,
18637	1140	195	March	March	NNP
18637	1140	196	16	16	CD
18637	1140	197	,	,	,
18637	1140	198	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	199	;	;	:
18637	1140	200	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	1140	201	,	,	,
18637	1140	202	March	March	NNP
18637	1140	203	31	31	CD
18637	1140	204	,	,	,
18637	1140	205	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	206	;	;	:
18637	1140	207	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	1140	208	,	,	,
18637	1140	209	April	April	NNP
18637	1140	210	7	7	CD
18637	1140	211	,	,	,
18637	1140	212	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	213	;	;	:
18637	1140	214	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	1140	215	,	,	,
18637	1140	216	April	April	NNP
18637	1140	217	22	22	CD
18637	1140	218	,	,	,
18637	1140	219	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	220	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1140	221	after	after	IN
18637	1140	222	having	have	VBG
18637	1140	223	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1140	224	the	the	DT
18637	1140	225	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1140	226	at	at	IN
18637	1140	227	the	the	DT
18637	1140	228	session	session	NN
18637	1140	229	begun	begin	VBN
18637	1140	230	January	January	NNP
18637	1140	231	9	9	CD
18637	1140	232	,	,	,
18637	1140	233	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	234	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1140	235	;	;	:
18637	1140	236	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	1140	237	,	,	,
18637	1140	238	May	May	NNP
18637	1140	239	16	16	CD
18637	1140	240	,	,	,
18637	1140	241	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	242	;	;	:
18637	1140	243	New	New	NNP
18637	1140	244	York	York	NNP
18637	1140	245	,	,	,
18637	1140	246	July	July	NNP
18637	1140	247	12	12	CD
18637	1140	248	,	,	,
18637	1140	249	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	250	;	;	:
18637	1140	251	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	1140	252	,	,	,
18637	1140	253	April	April	NNP
18637	1140	254	3	3	CD
18637	1140	255	,	,	,
18637	1140	256	1912	1912	CD
18637	1140	257	;	;	:
18637	1140	258	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	1140	259	,	,	,
18637	1140	260	June	June	NNP
18637	1140	261	11	11	CD
18637	1140	262	,	,	,
18637	1140	263	1912	1912	CD
18637	1140	264	;	;	:
18637	1140	265	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	1140	266	,	,	,
18637	1140	267	June	June	NNP
18637	1140	268	28	28	CD
18637	1140	269	,	,	,
18637	1140	270	1912	1912	CD
18637	1140	271	;	;	:
18637	1140	272	West	West	NNP
18637	1140	273	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1140	274	,	,	,
18637	1140	275	January	January	NNP
18637	1140	276	31	31	CD
18637	1140	277	,	,	,
18637	1140	278	1913	1913	CD
18637	1140	279	;	;	:
18637	1140	280	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	1140	281	,	,	,
18637	1140	282	February	February	NNP
18637	1140	283	3	3	CD
18637	1140	284	,	,	,
18637	1140	285	1913	1913	CD
18637	1140	286	;	;	:
18637	1140	287	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	1140	288	,	,	,
18637	1140	289	February	February	NNP
18637	1140	290	3	3	CD
18637	1140	291	,	,	,
18637	1140	292	1913	1913	CD
18637	1140	293	;	;	:
18637	1140	294	New	New	NNP
18637	1140	295	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	1140	296	,	,	,
18637	1140	297	February	February	NNP
18637	1140	298	3	3	CD
18637	1140	299	,	,	,
18637	1140	300	1913	1913	CD
18637	1140	301	;	;	:
18637	1140	302	New	New	NNP
18637	1140	303	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1140	304	,	,	,
18637	1140	305	February	February	NNP
18637	1140	306	4	4	CD
18637	1140	307	,	,	,
18637	1140	308	1913	1913	CD
18637	1140	309	;	;	:
18637	1140	310	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	1140	311	,	,	,
18637	1140	312	February	February	NNP
18637	1140	313	19	19	CD
18637	1140	314	,	,	,
18637	1140	315	1913	1913	CD
18637	1140	316	;	;	:
18637	1140	317	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	1140	318	,	,	,
18637	1140	319	March	March	NNP
18637	1140	320	4	4	CD
18637	1140	321	,	,	,
18637	1140	322	1913	1913	CD
18637	1140	323	;	;	:
18637	1140	324	New	New	NNP
18637	1140	325	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1140	326	,	,	,
18637	1140	327	March	March	NNP
18637	1140	328	7	7	CD
18637	1140	329	,	,	,
18637	1140	330	1913	1913	CD
18637	1140	331	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1140	332	after	after	IN
18637	1140	333	having	have	VBG
18637	1140	334	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1140	335	the	the	DT
18637	1140	336	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1140	337	on	on	IN
18637	1140	338	March	March	NNP
18637	1140	339	2	2	CD
18637	1140	340	,	,	,
18637	1140	341	1911	1911	CD
18637	1140	342	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1140	343	.	.	.
18637	1141	1	The	the	DT
18637	1141	2	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1141	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1141	4	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1141	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1141	6	and	and	CC
18637	1141	7	not	not	RB
18637	1141	8	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	1141	9	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1141	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1141	11	by	by	IN
18637	1141	12	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	1141	13	,	,	,
18637	1141	14	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	1141	15	Island	Island	NNP
18637	1141	16	,	,	,
18637	1141	17	and	and	CC
18637	1141	18	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	1141	19	.	.	.
18637	1142	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1142	2	i	i	NN
18637	1142	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1142	4	The	the	DT
18637	1142	5	17th	17th	JJ
18637	1142	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1142	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1142	8	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1142	9	by	by	IN
18637	1142	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1142	11	on	on	IN
18637	1142	12	May	May	NNP
18637	1142	13	13	13	CD
18637	1142	14	,	,	,
18637	1142	15	1912	1912	CD
18637	1142	16	,	,	,
18637	1142	17	when	when	WRB
18637	1142	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1142	19	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1142	20	the	the	DT
18637	1142	21	House	House	NNP
18637	1142	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1142	23	48	48	CD
18637	1142	24	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1142	25	.	.	.
18637	1143	1	Rec	Rec	NNP
18637	1143	2	.	.	.
18637	1144	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1144	2	62d	62d	NNS
18637	1144	3	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1144	4	.	.	NNP
18637	1144	5	,	,	,
18637	1144	6	2d	2d	CD
18637	1144	7	sess	sess	NN
18637	1144	8	.	.	.
18637	1144	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1145	1	6367	6367	CD
18637	1145	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1145	3	,	,	,
18637	1145	4	having	have	VBG
18637	1145	5	previously	previously	RB
18637	1145	6	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1145	7	the	the	DT
18637	1145	8	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1145	9	on	on	IN
18637	1145	10	June	June	NNP
18637	1145	11	12	12	CD
18637	1145	12	,	,	,
18637	1145	13	1911	1911	CD
18637	1145	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1145	15	47	47	CD
18637	1145	16	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1145	17	.	.	.
18637	1146	1	Rec	Rec	NNP
18637	1146	2	.	.	.
18637	1147	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1147	2	62d	62d	NNS
18637	1147	3	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1147	4	.	.	.
18637	1148	1	1st	1st	NNP
18637	1148	2	sess	sess	NN
18637	1148	3	.	.	.
18637	1148	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1149	1	1925	1925	CD
18637	1149	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1149	3	.	.	.
18637	1150	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1150	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1150	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1150	4	in	in	IN
18637	1150	5	37	37	CD
18637	1150	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1150	7	.	.	.
18637	1151	1	646	646	CD
18637	1151	2	.	.	.
18637	1152	1	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1152	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1152	3	completed	complete	VBN
18637	1152	4	on	on	IN
18637	1152	5	April	April	NNP
18637	1152	6	8	8	CD
18637	1152	7	,	,	,
18637	1152	8	1913	1913	CD
18637	1152	9	,	,	,
18637	1152	10	when	when	WRB
18637	1152	11	the	the	DT
18637	1152	12	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	1152	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	1152	14	sixth	sixth	JJ
18637	1152	15	State	State	NNP
18637	1152	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1152	17	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	1152	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1152	19	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1152	20	the	the	DT
18637	1152	21	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1152	22	,	,	,
18637	1152	23	there	there	EX
18637	1152	24	being	be	VBG
18637	1152	25	then	then	RB
18637	1152	26	48	48	CD
18637	1152	27	States	state	NNS
18637	1152	28	in	in	IN
18637	1152	29	the	the	DT
18637	1152	30	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1152	31	.	.	.
18637	1153	1	On	on	IN
18637	1153	2	May	May	NNP
18637	1153	3	31	31	CD
18637	1153	4	,	,	,
18637	1153	5	1913	1913	CD
18637	1153	6	,	,	,
18637	1153	7	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1153	8	of	of	IN
18637	1153	9	State	State	NNP
18637	1153	10	Bryan	Bryan	NNP
18637	1153	11	certified	certify	VBD
18637	1153	12	that	that	IN
18637	1153	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1153	14	had	have	VBD
18637	1153	15	become	become	VBN
18637	1153	16	a	a	DT
18637	1153	17	part	part	NN
18637	1153	18	of	of	IN
18637	1153	19	the	the	DT
18637	1153	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1153	21	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1153	22	38	38	CD
18637	1153	23	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1153	24	.	.	.
18637	1154	1	2049	2049	CD
18637	1154	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1154	3	.	.	.
18637	1155	1	The	the	DT
18637	1155	2	several	several	JJ
18637	1155	3	State	State	NNP
18637	1155	4	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1155	5	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1155	6	the	the	DT
18637	1155	7	17th	17th	JJ
18637	1155	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1155	9	on	on	IN
18637	1155	10	the	the	DT
18637	1155	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	1155	12	dates	date	NNS
18637	1155	13	:	:	:
18637	1155	14	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	1155	15	,	,	,
18637	1155	16	May	May	NNP
18637	1155	17	22	22	CD
18637	1155	18	,	,	,
18637	1155	19	1912	1912	CD
18637	1155	20	;	;	:
18637	1155	21	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	1155	22	,	,	,
18637	1155	23	June	June	NNP
18637	1155	24	3	3	CD
18637	1155	25	,	,	,
18637	1155	26	1912	1912	CD
18637	1155	27	;	;	:
18637	1155	28	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	1155	29	,	,	,
18637	1155	30	June	June	NNP
18637	1155	31	10	10	CD
18637	1155	32	,	,	,
18637	1155	33	1912	1912	CD
18637	1155	34	;	;	:
18637	1155	35	New	New	NNP
18637	1155	36	York	York	NNP
18637	1155	37	,	,	,
18637	1155	38	January	January	NNP
18637	1155	39	15	15	CD
18637	1155	40	,	,	,
18637	1155	41	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	42	;	;	:
18637	1155	43	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	1155	44	,	,	,
18637	1155	45	January	January	NNP
18637	1155	46	17	17	CD
18637	1155	47	,	,	,
18637	1155	48	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	49	;	;	:
18637	1155	50	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	1155	51	,	,	,
18637	1155	52	January	January	NNP
18637	1155	53	23	23	CD
18637	1155	54	,	,	,
18637	1155	55	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	56	;	;	:
18637	1155	57	North	North	NNP
18637	1155	58	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1155	59	,	,	,
18637	1155	60	January	January	NNP
18637	1155	61	25	25	CD
18637	1155	62	,	,	,
18637	1155	63	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	64	;	;	:
18637	1155	65	California	California	NNP
18637	1155	66	,	,	,
18637	1155	67	January	January	NNP
18637	1155	68	28	28	CD
18637	1155	69	,	,	,
18637	1155	70	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	71	;	;	:
18637	1155	72	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	1155	73	,	,	,
18637	1155	74	January	January	NNP
18637	1155	75	28	28	CD
18637	1155	76	,	,	,
18637	1155	77	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	78	;	;	:
18637	1155	79	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	1155	80	,	,	,
18637	1155	81	January	January	NNP
18637	1155	82	30	30	CD
18637	1155	83	,	,	,
18637	1155	84	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	85	;	;	:
18637	1155	86	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	1155	87	,	,	,
18637	1155	88	January	January	NNP
18637	1155	89	30	30	CD
18637	1155	90	,	,	,
18637	1155	91	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	92	;	;	:
18637	1155	93	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
18637	1155	94	,	,	,
18637	1155	95	January	January	NNP
18637	1155	96	31	31	CD
18637	1155	97	,	,	,
18637	1155	98	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	99	;	;	:
18637	1155	100	West	West	NNP
18637	1155	101	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1155	102	,	,	,
18637	1155	103	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	104	4	4	CD
18637	1155	105	,	,	,
18637	1155	106	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	107	;	;	:
18637	1155	108	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	1155	109	,	,	,
18637	1155	110	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	111	5	5	CD
18637	1155	112	,	,	,
18637	1155	113	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	114	;	;	:
18637	1155	115	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	1155	116	,	,	,
18637	1155	117	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	118	6	6	CD
18637	1155	119	,	,	,
18637	1155	120	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	121	;	;	:
18637	1155	122	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	1155	123	,	,	,
18637	1155	124	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	125	7	7	CD
18637	1155	126	,	,	,
18637	1155	127	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	128	;	;	:
18637	1155	129	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	1155	130	,	,	,
18637	1155	131	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	132	7	7	CD
18637	1155	133	,	,	,
18637	1155	134	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	135	;	;	:
18637	1155	136	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	1155	137	,	,	,
18637	1155	138	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	139	8	8	CD
18637	1155	140	,	,	,
18637	1155	141	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	142	;	;	:
18637	1155	143	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	1155	144	,	,	,
18637	1155	145	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	146	11	11	CD
18637	1155	147	,	,	,
18637	1155	148	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	149	;	;	:
18637	1155	150	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	1155	151	,	,	,
18637	1155	152	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	153	13	13	CD
18637	1155	154	,	,	,
18637	1155	155	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	156	;	;	:
18637	1155	157	North	North	NNP
18637	1155	158	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	1155	159	,	,	,
18637	1155	160	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	161	14	14	CD
18637	1155	162	,	,	,
18637	1155	163	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	164	;	;	:
18637	1155	165	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	1155	166	,	,	,
18637	1155	167	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	168	18	18	CD
18637	1155	169	,	,	,
18637	1155	170	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	171	;	;	:
18637	1155	172	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	1155	173	,	,	,
18637	1155	174	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	175	19	19	CD
18637	1155	176	,	,	,
18637	1155	177	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	178	;	;	:
18637	1155	179	New	New	NNP
18637	1155	180	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1155	181	,	,	,
18637	1155	182	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	183	19	19	CD
18637	1155	184	,	,	,
18637	1155	185	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	186	;	;	:
18637	1155	187	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	1155	188	,	,	,
18637	1155	189	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	190	19	19	CD
18637	1155	191	,	,	,
18637	1155	192	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	193	;	;	:
18637	1155	194	South	South	NNP
18637	1155	195	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	1155	196	,	,	,
18637	1155	197	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	198	19	19	CD
18637	1155	199	,	,	,
18637	1155	200	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	201	;	;	:
18637	1155	202	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	1155	203	,	,	,
18637	1155	204	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	205	20	20	CD
18637	1155	206	,	,	,
18637	1155	207	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	208	;	;	:
18637	1155	209	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	1155	210	,	,	,
18637	1155	211	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	212	24	24	CD
18637	1155	213	,	,	,
18637	1155	214	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	215	;	;	:
18637	1155	216	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1155	217	,	,	,
18637	1155	218	February	February	NNP
18637	1155	219	25	25	CD
18637	1155	220	,	,	,
18637	1155	221	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	222	;	;	:
18637	1155	223	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	1155	224	,	,	,
18637	1155	225	March	March	NNP
18637	1155	226	7	7	CD
18637	1155	227	,	,	,
18637	1155	228	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	229	;	;	:
18637	1155	230	New	New	NNP
18637	1155	231	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	1155	232	,	,	,
18637	1155	233	March	March	NNP
18637	1155	234	13	13	CD
18637	1155	235	,	,	,
18637	1155	236	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	237	;	;	:
18637	1155	238	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	1155	239	,	,	,
18637	1155	240	March	March	NNP
18637	1155	241	14	14	CD
18637	1155	242	,	,	,
18637	1155	243	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	244	;	;	:
18637	1155	245	New	New	NNP
18637	1155	246	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1155	247	,	,	,
18637	1155	248	March	March	NNP
18637	1155	249	17	17	CD
18637	1155	250	,	,	,
18637	1155	251	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	252	;	;	:
18637	1155	253	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	1155	254	,	,	,
18637	1155	255	April	April	NNP
18637	1155	256	1	1	CD
18637	1155	257	,	,	,
18637	1155	258	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	259	;	;	:
18637	1155	260	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	1155	261	,	,	,
18637	1155	262	April	April	NNP
18637	1155	263	2	2	CD
18637	1155	264	,	,	,
18637	1155	265	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	266	;	;	:
18637	1155	267	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	1155	268	,	,	,
18637	1155	269	April	April	NNP
18637	1155	270	8	8	CD
18637	1155	271	,	,	,
18637	1155	272	1913	1913	CD
18637	1155	273	;	;	:
18637	1155	274	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	1155	275	,	,	,
18637	1155	276	June	June	NNP
18637	1155	277	5	5	CD
18637	1155	278	,	,	,
18637	1155	279	1914	1914	CD
18637	1155	280	.	.	.
18637	1156	1	The	the	DT
18637	1156	2	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1156	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1156	4	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1156	5	by	by	IN
18637	1156	6	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	1156	7	on	on	IN
18637	1156	8	February	February	NNP
18637	1156	9	26	26	CD
18637	1156	10	,	,	,
18637	1156	11	1913	1913	CD
18637	1156	12	.	.	.
18637	1157	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1157	2	j	j	NNP
18637	1157	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1157	4	The	the	DT
18637	1157	5	18th	18th	JJ
18637	1157	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1157	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1157	8	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1157	9	by	by	IN
18637	1157	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1157	11	on	on	IN
18637	1157	12	December	December	NNP
18637	1157	13	18	18	CD
18637	1157	14	,	,	,
18637	1157	15	1917	1917	CD
18637	1157	16	,	,	,
18637	1157	17	when	when	WRB
18637	1157	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1157	19	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1157	20	the	the	DT
18637	1157	21	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1157	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1157	23	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1157	24	.	.	.
18637	1158	1	Rec	Rec	NNP
18637	1158	2	.	.	.
18637	1159	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1159	2	65th	65th	NNP
18637	1159	3	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1159	4	.	.	NNP
18637	1159	5	,	,	,
18637	1159	6	2d	2d	CD
18637	1159	7	sess	sess	NN
18637	1159	8	.	.	.
18637	1159	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1160	1	478	478	LS
18637	1160	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1160	3	,	,	,
18637	1160	4	having	have	VBG
18637	1160	5	previously	previously	RB
18637	1160	6	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1160	7	the	the	DT
18637	1160	8	House	House	NNP
18637	1160	9	on	on	IN
18637	1160	10	December	December	NNP
18637	1160	11	17	17	CD
18637	1160	12	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1160	13	_	_	NNP
18637	1160	14	Id.	Idaho	NNP
18637	1160	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1160	16	,	,	,
18637	1160	17	470	470	CD
18637	1160	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1160	19	.	.	.
18637	1161	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1161	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1161	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1161	4	in	in	IN
18637	1161	5	40	40	CD
18637	1161	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1161	7	1050	1050	CD
18637	1161	8	.	.	.
18637	1162	1	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1162	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1162	3	completed	complete	VBN
18637	1162	4	on	on	IN
18637	1162	5	January	January	NNP
18637	1162	6	16	16	CD
18637	1162	7	,	,	,
18637	1162	8	1919	1919	CD
18637	1162	9	,	,	,
18637	1162	10	when	when	WRB
18637	1162	11	the	the	DT
18637	1162	12	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	1162	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	1162	14	sixth	sixth	JJ
18637	1162	15	State	state	NN
18637	1162	16	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1162	17	the	the	DT
18637	1162	18	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1162	19	,	,	,
18637	1162	20	there	there	EX
18637	1162	21	being	be	VBG
18637	1162	22	then	then	RB
18637	1162	23	48	48	CD
18637	1162	24	States	state	NNS
18637	1162	25	in	in	IN
18637	1162	26	the	the	DT
18637	1162	27	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1162	28	.	.	.
18637	1163	1	On	on	IN
18637	1163	2	January	January	NNP
18637	1163	3	29	29	CD
18637	1163	4	,	,	,
18637	1163	5	1919	1919	CD
18637	1163	6	,	,	,
18637	1163	7	Acting	Acting	NNP
18637	1163	8	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1163	9	of	of	IN
18637	1163	10	State	State	NNP
18637	1163	11	Polk	Polk	NNP
18637	1163	12	certified	certify	VBD
18637	1163	13	that	that	IN
18637	1163	14	this	this	DT
18637	1163	15	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1163	16	had	have	VBD
18637	1163	17	been	be	VBN
18637	1163	18	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	1163	19	by	by	IN
18637	1163	20	the	the	DT
18637	1163	21	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	1163	22	number	number	NN
18637	1163	23	of	of	IN
18637	1163	24	States	States	NNP
18637	1163	25	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1163	26	40	40	CD
18637	1163	27	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1163	28	.	.	.
18637	1164	1	1941	1941	CD
18637	1164	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1164	3	.	.	.
18637	1165	1	By	by	IN
18637	1165	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1165	3	terms	term	NNS
18637	1165	4	this	this	DT
18637	1165	5	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1165	6	did	do	VBD
18637	1165	7	not	not	RB
18637	1165	8	became	become	VBD
18637	1165	9	effective	effective	JJ
18637	1165	10	until	until	IN
18637	1165	11	1	1	CD
18637	1165	12	year	year	NN
18637	1165	13	after	after	IN
18637	1165	14	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1165	15	.	.	.
18637	1166	1	The	the	DT
18637	1166	2	several	several	JJ
18637	1166	3	State	State	NNP
18637	1166	4	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1166	5	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1166	6	the	the	DT
18637	1166	7	18th	18th	JJ
18637	1166	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1166	9	on	on	IN
18637	1166	10	the	the	DT
18637	1166	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	1166	12	dates	date	NNS
18637	1166	13	:	:	:
18637	1166	14	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	1166	15	,	,	,
18637	1166	16	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	17	8	8	CD
18637	1166	18	,	,	,
18637	1166	19	1918	1918	CD
18637	1166	20	;	;	:
18637	1166	21	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1166	22	,	,	,
18637	1166	23	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	24	11	11	CD
18637	1166	25	,	,	,
18637	1166	26	1918	1918	CD
18637	1166	27	;	;	:
18637	1166	28	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	1166	29	,	,	,
18637	1166	30	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	31	14	14	CD
18637	1166	32	,	,	,
18637	1166	33	1918	1918	CD
18637	1166	34	;	;	:
18637	1166	35	North	North	NNP
18637	1166	36	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	1166	37	,	,	,
18637	1166	38	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	39	28	28	CD
18637	1166	40	,	,	,
18637	1166	41	1918	1918	CD
18637	1166	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1166	43	date	date	NN
18637	1166	44	on	on	IN
18637	1166	45	which	which	WDT
18637	1166	46	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1166	47	by	by	IN
18637	1166	48	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1166	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1166	50	;	;	:
18637	1166	51	South	South	NNP
18637	1166	52	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1166	53	,	,	,
18637	1166	54	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	55	29	29	CD
18637	1166	56	,	,	,
18637	1166	57	1918	1918	CD
18637	1166	58	;	;	:
18637	1166	59	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1166	60	,	,	,
18637	1166	61	February	February	NNP
18637	1166	62	13	13	CD
18637	1166	63	,	,	,
18637	1166	64	1918	1918	CD
18637	1166	65	;	;	:
18637	1166	66	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	1166	67	,	,	,
18637	1166	68	February	February	NNP
18637	1166	69	19	19	CD
18637	1166	70	,	,	,
18637	1166	71	1918	1918	CD
18637	1166	72	;	;	:
18637	1166	73	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	1166	74	,	,	,
18637	1166	75	March	March	NNP
18637	1166	76	4	4	CD
18637	1166	77	,	,	,
18637	1166	78	1918	1918	CD
18637	1166	79	;	;	:
18637	1166	80	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	1166	81	,	,	,
18637	1166	82	March	March	NNP
18637	1166	83	18	18	CD
18637	1166	84	,	,	,
18637	1166	85	1918	1918	CD
18637	1166	86	;	;	:
18637	1166	87	South	South	NNP
18637	1166	88	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	1166	89	,	,	,
18637	1166	90	March	March	NNP
18637	1166	91	20	20	CD
18637	1166	92	,	,	,
18637	1166	93	1918	1918	CD
18637	1166	94	;	;	:
18637	1166	95	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	1166	96	,	,	,
18637	1166	97	April	April	NNP
18637	1166	98	2	2	CD
18637	1166	99	,	,	,
18637	1166	100	1918	1918	CD
18637	1166	101	;	;	:
18637	1166	102	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	1166	103	,	,	,
18637	1166	104	May	May	NNP
18637	1166	105	24	24	CD
18637	1166	106	,	,	,
18637	1166	107	1918	1918	CD
18637	1166	108	;	;	:
18637	1166	109	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	1166	110	,	,	,
18637	1166	111	June	June	NNP
18637	1166	112	26	26	CD
18637	1166	113	,	,	,
18637	1166	114	1918	1918	CD
18637	1166	115	;	;	:
18637	1166	116	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	1166	117	,	,	,
18637	1166	118	August	August	NNP
18637	1166	119	9	9	CD
18637	1166	120	,	,	,
18637	1166	121	1918	1918	CD
18637	1166	122	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1166	123	date	date	NN
18637	1166	124	on	on	IN
18637	1166	125	which	which	WDT
18637	1166	126	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1166	127	by	by	IN
18637	1166	128	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1166	129	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1166	130	;	;	:
18637	1166	131	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	1166	132	,	,	,
18637	1166	133	November	November	NNP
18637	1166	134	27	27	CD
18637	1166	135	,	,	,
18637	1166	136	1918	1918	CD
18637	1166	137	;	;	:
18637	1166	138	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	1166	139	,	,	,
18637	1166	140	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	141	2	2	CD
18637	1166	142	,	,	,
18637	1166	143	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	144	;	;	:
18637	1166	145	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1166	146	,	,	,
18637	1166	147	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	148	7	7	CD
18637	1166	149	,	,	,
18637	1166	150	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	151	;	;	:
18637	1166	152	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	1166	153	,	,	,
18637	1166	154	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	155	7	7	CD
18637	1166	156	,	,	,
18637	1166	157	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	158	;	;	:
18637	1166	159	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
18637	1166	160	,	,	,
18637	1166	161	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	162	8	8	CD
18637	1166	163	,	,	,
18637	1166	164	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	165	;	;	:
18637	1166	166	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	1166	167	,	,	,
18637	1166	168	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	169	8	8	CD
18637	1166	170	,	,	,
18637	1166	171	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	172	;	;	:
18637	1166	173	West	West	NNP
18637	1166	174	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1166	175	,	,	,
18637	1166	176	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	177	13	13	CD
18637	1166	178	,	,	,
18637	1166	179	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	180	;	;	:
18637	1166	181	California	California	NNP
18637	1166	182	,	,	,
18637	1166	183	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	184	13	13	CD
18637	1166	185	,	,	,
18637	1166	186	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	187	;	;	:
18637	1166	188	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	1166	189	,	,	,
18637	1166	190	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	191	13	13	CD
18637	1166	192	,	,	,
18637	1166	193	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	194	;	;	:
18637	1166	195	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	1166	196	,	,	,
18637	1166	197	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	198	13	13	CD
18637	1166	199	,	,	,
18637	1166	200	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	201	;	;	:
18637	1166	202	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	1166	203	,	,	,
18637	1166	204	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	205	14	14	CD
18637	1166	206	,	,	,
18637	1166	207	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	208	;	;	:
18637	1166	209	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	1166	210	,	,	,
18637	1166	211	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	212	14	14	CD
18637	1166	213	,	,	,
18637	1166	214	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	215	;	;	:
18637	1166	216	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	1166	217	,	,	,
18637	1166	218	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	219	14	14	CD
18637	1166	220	,	,	,
18637	1166	221	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	222	;	;	:
18637	1166	223	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	1166	224	,	,	,
18637	1166	225	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	226	14	14	CD
18637	1166	227	,	,	,
18637	1166	228	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	229	;	;	:
18637	1166	230	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	1166	231	,	,	,
18637	1166	232	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	233	15	15	CD
18637	1166	234	,	,	,
18637	1166	235	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	236	;	;	:
18637	1166	237	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	1166	238	,	,	,
18637	1166	239	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	240	15	15	CD
18637	1166	241	,	,	,
18637	1166	242	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	243	;	;	:
18637	1166	244	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	1166	245	,	,	,
18637	1166	246	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	247	15	15	CD
18637	1166	248	,	,	,
18637	1166	249	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	250	;	;	:
18637	1166	251	New	New	NNP
18637	1166	252	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1166	253	,	,	,
18637	1166	254	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	255	15	15	CD
18637	1166	256	,	,	,
18637	1166	257	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	258	;	;	:
18637	1166	259	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	1166	260	,	,	,
18637	1166	261	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	262	15	15	CD
18637	1166	263	,	,	,
18637	1166	264	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	265	;	;	:
18637	1166	266	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	1166	267	,	,	,
18637	1166	268	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	269	16	16	CD
18637	1166	270	,	,	,
18637	1166	271	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	272	;	;	:
18637	1166	273	North	North	NNP
18637	1166	274	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1166	275	,	,	,
18637	1166	276	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	277	16	16	CD
18637	1166	278	,	,	,
18637	1166	279	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	280	;	;	:
18637	1166	281	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	1166	282	,	,	,
18637	1166	283	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	284	16	16	CD
18637	1166	285	,	,	,
18637	1166	286	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	287	;	;	:
18637	1166	288	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	1166	289	,	,	,
18637	1166	290	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	291	16	16	CD
18637	1166	292	,	,	,
18637	1166	293	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	294	;	;	:
18637	1166	295	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	1166	296	,	,	,
18637	1166	297	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	298	16	16	CD
18637	1166	299	,	,	,
18637	1166	300	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	301	;	;	:
18637	1166	302	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	1166	303	,	,	,
18637	1166	304	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	305	17	17	CD
18637	1166	306	,	,	,
18637	1166	307	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	308	;	;	:
18637	1166	309	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	1166	310	,	,	,
18637	1166	311	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	312	17	17	CD
18637	1166	313	,	,	,
18637	1166	314	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	315	;	;	:
18637	1166	316	New	New	NNP
18637	1166	317	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	1166	318	,	,	,
18637	1166	319	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	320	20	20	CD
18637	1166	321	,	,	,
18637	1166	322	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	323	;	;	:
18637	1166	324	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	1166	325	,	,	,
18637	1166	326	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	327	21	21	CD
18637	1166	328	,	,	,
18637	1166	329	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	330	;	;	:
18637	1166	331	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	1166	332	,	,	,
18637	1166	333	February	February	NNP
18637	1166	334	25	25	CD
18637	1166	335	,	,	,
18637	1166	336	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	337	;	;	:
18637	1166	338	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	1166	339	,	,	,
18637	1166	340	May	May	NNP
18637	1166	341	6	6	CD
18637	1166	342	,	,	,
18637	1166	343	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	344	;	;	:
18637	1166	345	New	New	NNP
18637	1166	346	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1166	347	,	,	,
18637	1166	348	March	March	NNP
18637	1166	349	9	9	CD
18637	1166	350	,	,	,
18637	1166	351	1922	1922	CD
18637	1166	352	;	;	:
18637	1166	353	New	New	NNP
18637	1166	354	York	York	NNP
18637	1166	355	,	,	,
18637	1166	356	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	357	29	29	CD
18637	1166	358	,	,	,
18637	1166	359	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	360	;	;	:
18637	1166	361	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	1166	362	,	,	,
18637	1166	363	January	January	NNP
18637	1166	364	29	29	CD
18637	1166	365	,	,	,
18637	1166	366	1919	1919	CD
18637	1166	367	.	.	.
18637	1167	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1167	2	k	k	NN
18637	1167	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1167	4	The	the	DT
18637	1167	5	19th	19th	JJ
18637	1167	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1167	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1167	8	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1167	9	by	by	IN
18637	1167	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1167	11	on	on	IN
18637	1167	12	June	June	NNP
18637	1167	13	4	4	CD
18637	1167	14	,	,	,
18637	1167	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	1167	16	,	,	,
18637	1167	17	when	when	WRB
18637	1167	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1167	19	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1167	20	the	the	DT
18637	1167	21	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1167	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1167	23	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1167	24	.	.	.
18637	1168	1	Rec	Rec	NNP
18637	1168	2	.	.	.
18637	1169	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1169	2	66th	66th	JJ
18637	1169	3	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1169	4	.	.	NNP
18637	1169	5	,	,	,
18637	1169	6	1st	1st	JJ
18637	1169	7	sess	sess	NN
18637	1169	8	.	.	.
18637	1169	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1170	1	635	635	CD
18637	1170	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1170	3	,	,	,
18637	1170	4	having	have	VBG
18637	1170	5	previously	previously	RB
18637	1170	6	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1170	7	the	the	DT
18637	1170	8	House	House	NNP
18637	1170	9	on	on	IN
18637	1170	10	May	May	NNP
18637	1170	11	21	21	CD
18637	1170	12	,	,	,
18637	1170	13	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1170	14	_	_	NNP
18637	1170	15	Id.	Idaho	NNP
18637	1170	16	_	_	NNP
18637	1170	17	,	,	,
18637	1170	18	94	94	CD
18637	1170	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1170	20	.	.	.
18637	1171	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1171	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1171	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1171	4	in	in	IN
18637	1171	5	41	41	CD
18637	1171	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1171	7	.	.	.
18637	1172	1	362	362	CD
18637	1172	2	.	.	.
18637	1173	1	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1173	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1173	3	completed	complete	VBN
18637	1173	4	on	on	IN
18637	1173	5	August	August	NNP
18637	1173	6	18	18	CD
18637	1173	7	,	,	,
18637	1173	8	1920	1920	CD
18637	1173	9	,	,	,
18637	1173	10	when	when	WRB
18637	1173	11	the	the	DT
18637	1173	12	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	1173	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	1173	14	sixth	sixth	JJ
18637	1173	15	State	State	NNP
18637	1173	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1173	17	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	1173	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1173	19	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1173	20	the	the	DT
18637	1173	21	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1173	22	,	,	,
18637	1173	23	there	there	EX
18637	1173	24	being	be	VBG
18637	1173	25	then	then	RB
18637	1173	26	48	48	CD
18637	1173	27	States	state	NNS
18637	1173	28	in	in	IN
18637	1173	29	the	the	DT
18637	1173	30	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1173	31	.	.	.
18637	1174	1	On	on	IN
18637	1174	2	August	August	NNP
18637	1174	3	26	26	CD
18637	1174	4	,	,	,
18637	1174	5	1920	1920	CD
18637	1174	6	,	,	,
18637	1174	7	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1174	8	of	of	IN
18637	1174	9	State	State	NNP
18637	1174	10	Colby	Colby	NNP
18637	1174	11	certified	certify	VBD
18637	1174	12	that	that	IN
18637	1174	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1174	14	had	have	VBD
18637	1174	15	become	become	VBN
18637	1174	16	a	a	DT
18637	1174	17	part	part	NN
18637	1174	18	of	of	IN
18637	1174	19	the	the	DT
18637	1174	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1174	21	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1174	22	41	41	CD
18637	1174	23	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	1174	24	.	.	.
18637	1175	1	1823	1823	CD
18637	1175	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1175	3	.	.	.
18637	1176	1	The	the	DT
18637	1176	2	several	several	JJ
18637	1176	3	State	State	NNP
18637	1176	4	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1176	5	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1176	6	the	the	DT
18637	1176	7	19th	19th	JJ
18637	1176	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1176	9	on	on	IN
18637	1176	10	the	the	DT
18637	1176	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	1176	12	dates	date	NNS
18637	1176	13	:	:	:
18637	1176	14	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	1176	15	,	,	,
18637	1176	16	June	June	NNP
18637	1176	17	10	10	CD
18637	1176	18	,	,	,
18637	1176	19	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1176	21	readopted	readopte	VBN
18637	1176	22	June	June	NNP
18637	1176	23	17	17	CD
18637	1176	24	,	,	,
18637	1176	25	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1176	27	;	;	:
18637	1176	28	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	1176	29	,	,	,
18637	1176	30	June	June	NNP
18637	1176	31	10	10	CD
18637	1176	32	,	,	,
18637	1176	33	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	34	;	;	:
18637	1176	35	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	1176	36	,	,	,
18637	1176	37	June	June	NNP
18637	1176	38	10	10	CD
18637	1176	39	,	,	,
18637	1176	40	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	41	;	;	:
18637	1176	42	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	1176	43	,	,	,
18637	1176	44	June	June	NNP
18637	1176	45	16	16	CD
18637	1176	46	,	,	,
18637	1176	47	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	48	;	;	:
18637	1176	49	New	New	NNP
18637	1176	50	York	York	NNP
18637	1176	51	,	,	,
18637	1176	52	June	June	NNP
18637	1176	53	16	16	CD
18637	1176	54	,	,	,
18637	1176	55	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	56	;	;	:
18637	1176	57	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1176	58	,	,	,
18637	1176	59	June	June	NNP
18637	1176	60	16	16	CD
18637	1176	61	,	,	,
18637	1176	62	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	63	;	;	:
18637	1176	64	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	1176	65	,	,	,
18637	1176	66	June	June	NNP
18637	1176	67	24	24	CD
18637	1176	68	,	,	,
18637	1176	69	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	70	;	;	:
18637	1176	71	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	1176	72	,	,	,
18637	1176	73	June	June	NNP
18637	1176	74	25	25	CD
18637	1176	75	,	,	,
18637	1176	76	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	77	;	;	:
18637	1176	78	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	1176	79	,	,	,
18637	1176	80	June	June	NNP
18637	1176	81	28	28	CD
18637	1176	82	,	,	,
18637	1176	83	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	84	;	;	:
18637	1176	85	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	1176	86	,	,	,
18637	1176	87	July	July	NNP
18637	1176	88	2	2	CD
18637	1176	89	,	,	,
18637	1176	90	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1176	92	date	date	NN
18637	1176	93	on	on	IN
18637	1176	94	which	which	WDT
18637	1176	95	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1176	96	by	by	IN
18637	1176	97	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1176	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1176	99	;	;	:
18637	1176	100	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	1176	101	,	,	,
18637	1176	102	July	July	NNP
18637	1176	103	3	3	CD
18637	1176	104	,	,	,
18637	1176	105	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	106	;	;	:
18637	1176	107	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	1176	108	,	,	,
18637	1176	109	July	July	NNP
18637	1176	110	28	28	CD
18637	1176	111	,	,	,
18637	1176	112	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	113	;	;	:
18637	1176	114	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	1176	115	,	,	,
18637	1176	116	August	August	NNP
18637	1176	117	2	2	CD
18637	1176	118	,	,	,
18637	1176	119	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	120	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1176	121	date	date	NN
18637	1176	122	on	on	IN
18637	1176	123	which	which	WDT
18637	1176	124	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1176	125	by	by	IN
18637	1176	126	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1176	127	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1176	128	;	;	:
18637	1176	129	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	1176	130	,	,	,
18637	1176	131	August	August	NNP
18637	1176	132	2	2	CD
18637	1176	133	,	,	,
18637	1176	134	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	135	;	;	:
18637	1176	136	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	1176	137	,	,	,
18637	1176	138	September	September	NNP
18637	1176	139	8	8	CD
18637	1176	140	,	,	,
18637	1176	141	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	142	;	;	:
18637	1176	143	New	New	NNP
18637	1176	144	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1176	145	,	,	,
18637	1176	146	September	September	NNP
18637	1176	147	10	10	CD
18637	1176	148	,	,	,
18637	1176	149	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	150	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1176	151	date	date	NN
18637	1176	152	on	on	IN
18637	1176	153	which	which	WDT
18637	1176	154	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1176	155	by	by	IN
18637	1176	156	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1176	157	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1176	158	;	;	:
18637	1176	159	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	1176	160	,	,	,
18637	1176	161	October	October	NNP
18637	1176	162	2	2	CD
18637	1176	163	,	,	,
18637	1176	164	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	165	;	;	:
18637	1176	166	California	California	NNP
18637	1176	167	,	,	,
18637	1176	168	November	November	NNP
18637	1176	169	1	1	CD
18637	1176	170	,	,	,
18637	1176	171	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	172	;	;	:
18637	1176	173	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	1176	174	,	,	,
18637	1176	175	November	November	NNP
18637	1176	176	5	5	CD
18637	1176	177	,	,	,
18637	1176	178	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	179	;	;	:
18637	1176	180	North	North	NNP
18637	1176	181	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	1176	182	,	,	,
18637	1176	183	December	December	NNP
18637	1176	184	1	1	CD
18637	1176	185	,	,	,
18637	1176	186	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	187	;	;	:
18637	1176	188	South	South	NNP
18637	1176	189	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	1176	190	,	,	,
18637	1176	191	December	December	NNP
18637	1176	192	4	4	CD
18637	1176	193	,	,	,
18637	1176	194	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	195	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1176	196	date	date	NN
18637	1176	197	on	on	IN
18637	1176	198	which	which	WDT
18637	1176	199	certified	certify	VBN
18637	1176	200	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1176	201	;	;	:
18637	1176	202	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	1176	203	,	,	,
18637	1176	204	December	December	NNP
18637	1176	205	15	15	CD
18637	1176	206	,	,	,
18637	1176	207	1919	1919	CD
18637	1176	208	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1176	209	date	date	NN
18637	1176	210	on	on	IN
18637	1176	211	which	which	WDT
18637	1176	212	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1176	213	by	by	IN
18637	1176	214	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1176	215	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1176	216	;	;	:
18637	1176	217	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	1176	218	,	,	,
18637	1176	219	January	January	NNP
18637	1176	220	6	6	CD
18637	1176	221	,	,	,
18637	1176	222	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	223	;	;	:
18637	1176	224	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	1176	225	Island	Island	NNP
18637	1176	226	,	,	,
18637	1176	227	January	January	NNP
18637	1176	228	6	6	CD
18637	1176	229	,	,	,
18637	1176	230	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	231	;	;	:
18637	1176	232	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	1176	233	,	,	,
18637	1176	234	January	January	NNP
18637	1176	235	13	13	CD
18637	1176	236	,	,	,
18637	1176	237	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	238	;	;	:
18637	1176	239	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	1176	240	,	,	,
18637	1176	241	January	January	NNP
18637	1176	242	16	16	CD
18637	1176	243	,	,	,
18637	1176	244	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	245	;	;	:
18637	1176	246	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	1176	247	,	,	,
18637	1176	248	January	January	NNP
18637	1176	249	27	27	CD
18637	1176	250	,	,	,
18637	1176	251	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	252	;	;	:
18637	1176	253	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	1176	254	,	,	,
18637	1176	255	February	February	NNP
18637	1176	256	7	7	CD
18637	1176	257	,	,	,
18637	1176	258	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	259	;	;	:
18637	1176	260	New	New	NNP
18637	1176	261	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1176	262	,	,	,
18637	1176	263	February	February	NNP
18637	1176	264	9	9	CD
18637	1176	265	,	,	,
18637	1176	266	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	267	;	;	:
18637	1176	268	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
18637	1176	269	,	,	,
18637	1176	270	February	February	NNP
18637	1176	271	11	11	CD
18637	1176	272	,	,	,
18637	1176	273	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	274	;	;	:
18637	1176	275	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	1176	276	,	,	,
18637	1176	277	February	February	NNP
18637	1176	278	12	12	CD
18637	1176	279	,	,	,
18637	1176	280	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	281	;	;	:
18637	1176	282	New	New	NNP
18637	1176	283	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	1176	284	,	,	,
18637	1176	285	February	February	NNP
18637	1176	286	21	21	CD
18637	1176	287	,	,	,
18637	1176	288	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	289	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1176	290	date	date	NN
18637	1176	291	on	on	IN
18637	1176	292	which	which	WDT
18637	1176	293	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1176	294	by	by	IN
18637	1176	295	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1176	296	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1176	297	;	;	:
18637	1176	298	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	1176	299	,	,	,
18637	1176	300	February	February	NNP
18637	1176	301	28	28	CD
18637	1176	302	,	,	,
18637	1176	303	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	304	;	;	:
18637	1176	305	West	West	NNP
18637	1176	306	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1176	307	,	,	,
18637	1176	308	March	March	NNP
18637	1176	309	10	10	CD
18637	1176	310	,	,	,
18637	1176	311	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	312	;	;	:
18637	1176	313	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	1176	314	,	,	,
18637	1176	315	March	March	NNP
18637	1176	316	22	22	CD
18637	1176	317	,	,	,
18637	1176	318	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	319	;	;	:
18637	1176	320	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	1176	321	,	,	,
18637	1176	322	August	August	NNP
18637	1176	323	18	18	CD
18637	1176	324	,	,	,
18637	1176	325	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	326	;	;	:
18637	1176	327	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	1176	328	,	,	,
18637	1176	329	September	September	NNP
18637	1176	330	14	14	CD
18637	1176	331	,	,	,
18637	1176	332	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	333	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1176	334	confirmed	confirm	VBN
18637	1176	335	September	September	NNP
18637	1176	336	21	21	CD
18637	1176	337	,	,	,
18637	1176	338	1920	1920	CD
18637	1176	339	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1176	340	;	;	:
18637	1176	341	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	1176	342	,	,	,
18637	1176	343	February	February	NNP
18637	1176	344	8	8	CD
18637	1176	345	,	,	,
18637	1176	346	1921	1921	CD
18637	1176	347	.	.	.
18637	1177	1	The	the	DT
18637	1177	2	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1177	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1177	4	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1177	5	by	by	IN
18637	1177	6	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	1177	7	on	on	IN
18637	1177	8	July	July	NNP
18637	1177	9	24	24	CD
18637	1177	10	,	,	,
18637	1177	11	1919	1919	CD
18637	1177	12	;	;	:
18637	1177	13	by	by	IN
18637	1177	14	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	1177	15	on	on	IN
18637	1177	16	September	September	NNP
18637	1177	17	22	22	CD
18637	1177	18	,	,	,
18637	1177	19	1919	1919	CD
18637	1177	20	;	;	:
18637	1177	21	by	by	IN
18637	1177	22	South	South	NNP
18637	1177	23	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1177	24	on	on	IN
18637	1177	25	January	January	NNP
18637	1177	26	29	29	CD
18637	1177	27	,	,	,
18637	1177	28	1920	1920	CD
18637	1177	29	;	;	:
18637	1177	30	by	by	IN
18637	1177	31	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1177	32	on	on	IN
18637	1177	33	February	February	NNP
18637	1177	34	12	12	CD
18637	1177	35	,	,	,
18637	1177	36	1920	1920	CD
18637	1177	37	;	;	:
18637	1177	38	by	by	IN
18637	1177	39	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1177	40	on	on	IN
18637	1177	41	February	February	NNP
18637	1177	42	24	24	CD
18637	1177	43	,	,	,
18637	1177	44	1920	1920	CD
18637	1177	45	;	;	:
18637	1177	46	by	by	IN
18637	1177	47	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	1177	48	on	on	IN
18637	1177	49	March	March	NNP
18637	1177	50	29	29	CD
18637	1177	51	,	,	,
18637	1177	52	1920	1920	CD
18637	1177	53	;	;	:
18637	1177	54	by	by	IN
18637	1177	55	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	1177	56	on	on	IN
18637	1177	57	July	July	NNP
18637	1177	58	1	1	CD
18637	1177	59	,	,	,
18637	1177	60	1920	1920	CD
18637	1177	61	.	.	.
18637	1178	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1178	2	l	l	NN
18637	1178	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1178	4	The	the	DT
18637	1178	5	20th	20th	JJ
18637	1178	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1178	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1178	8	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1178	9	by	by	IN
18637	1178	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1178	11	on	on	IN
18637	1178	12	March	March	NNP
18637	1178	13	2	2	CD
18637	1178	14	,	,	,
18637	1178	15	1932	1932	CD
18637	1178	16	,	,	,
18637	1178	17	when	when	WRB
18637	1178	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1178	19	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1178	20	the	the	DT
18637	1178	21	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1178	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1178	23	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1178	24	.	.	.
18637	1179	1	Rec	Rec	NNP
18637	1179	2	.	.	.
18637	1180	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1180	2	72d	72d	CD
18637	1180	3	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1180	4	.	.	NNP
18637	1180	5	,	,	,
18637	1180	6	1st	1st	JJ
18637	1180	7	sess	sess	NN
18637	1180	8	.	.	.
18637	1180	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1181	1	5086	5086	CD
18637	1181	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1181	3	,	,	,
18637	1181	4	having	have	VBG
18637	1181	5	previously	previously	RB
18637	1181	6	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1181	7	the	the	DT
18637	1181	8	House	House	NNP
18637	1181	9	on	on	IN
18637	1181	10	March	March	NNP
18637	1181	11	1	1	CD
18637	1181	12	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1181	13	_	_	NNP
18637	1181	14	Id.	Idaho	NNP
18637	1181	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1181	16	,	,	,
18637	1181	17	5027	5027	CD
18637	1181	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1181	19	.	.	.
18637	1182	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1182	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1182	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1182	4	in	in	IN
18637	1182	5	47	47	CD
18637	1182	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1182	7	.	.	.
18637	1183	1	745	745	CD
18637	1183	2	.	.	.
18637	1184	1	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1184	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1184	3	completed	complete	VBN
18637	1184	4	on	on	IN
18637	1184	5	January	January	NNP
18637	1184	6	23	23	CD
18637	1184	7	,	,	,
18637	1184	8	1933	1933	CD
18637	1184	9	,	,	,
18637	1184	10	when	when	WRB
18637	1184	11	the	the	DT
18637	1184	12	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	1184	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	1184	14	sixth	sixth	JJ
18637	1184	15	State	state	NN
18637	1184	16	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1184	17	the	the	DT
18637	1184	18	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1184	19	,	,	,
18637	1184	20	there	there	EX
18637	1184	21	being	be	VBG
18637	1184	22	then	then	RB
18637	1184	23	48	48	CD
18637	1184	24	States	state	NNS
18637	1184	25	in	in	IN
18637	1184	26	the	the	DT
18637	1184	27	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1184	28	.	.	.
18637	1185	1	On	on	IN
18637	1185	2	February	February	NNP
18637	1185	3	6	6	CD
18637	1185	4	,	,	,
18637	1185	5	1933	1933	CD
18637	1185	6	,	,	,
18637	1185	7	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1185	8	of	of	IN
18637	1185	9	State	State	NNP
18637	1185	10	Stimson	Stimson	NNP
18637	1185	11	certified	certify	VBD
18637	1185	12	that	that	IN
18637	1185	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1185	14	had	have	VBD
18637	1185	15	become	become	VBN
18637	1185	16	a	a	DT
18637	1185	17	part	part	NN
18637	1185	18	of	of	IN
18637	1185	19	the	the	DT
18637	1185	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1185	21	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1185	22	47	47	CD
18637	1185	23	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1185	24	.	.	.
18637	1186	1	2569	2569	CD
18637	1186	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1186	3	.	.	.
18637	1187	1	The	the	DT
18637	1187	2	several	several	JJ
18637	1187	3	State	State	NNP
18637	1187	4	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1187	5	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1187	6	the	the	DT
18637	1187	7	20th	20th	JJ
18637	1187	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1187	9	on	on	IN
18637	1187	10	the	the	DT
18637	1187	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	1187	12	dates	date	NNS
18637	1187	13	:	:	:
18637	1187	14	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1187	15	,	,	,
18637	1187	16	March	March	NNP
18637	1187	17	4	4	CD
18637	1187	18	,	,	,
18637	1187	19	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	20	;	;	:
18637	1187	21	New	New	NNP
18637	1187	22	York	York	NNP
18637	1187	23	,	,	,
18637	1187	24	March	March	NNP
18637	1187	25	11	11	CD
18637	1187	26	,	,	,
18637	1187	27	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	28	;	;	:
18637	1187	29	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	1187	30	,	,	,
18637	1187	31	March	March	NNP
18637	1187	32	16	16	CD
18637	1187	33	,	,	,
18637	1187	34	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	35	;	;	:
18637	1187	36	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	1187	37	,	,	,
18637	1187	38	March	March	NNP
18637	1187	39	17	17	CD
18637	1187	40	,	,	,
18637	1187	41	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	42	;	;	:
18637	1187	43	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	1187	44	,	,	,
18637	1187	45	March	March	NNP
18637	1187	46	17	17	CD
18637	1187	47	,	,	,
18637	1187	48	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	49	;	;	:
18637	1187	50	New	New	NNP
18637	1187	51	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1187	52	,	,	,
18637	1187	53	March	March	NNP
18637	1187	54	21	21	CD
18637	1187	55	,	,	,
18637	1187	56	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	57	;	;	:
18637	1187	58	South	South	NNP
18637	1187	59	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1187	60	,	,	,
18637	1187	61	March	March	NNP
18637	1187	62	25	25	CD
18637	1187	63	,	,	,
18637	1187	64	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	65	;	;	:
18637	1187	66	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	1187	67	,	,	,
18637	1187	68	March	March	NNP
18637	1187	69	31	31	CD
18637	1187	70	,	,	,
18637	1187	71	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	72	;	;	:
18637	1187	73	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	1187	74	,	,	,
18637	1187	75	April	April	NNP
18637	1187	76	1	1	CD
18637	1187	77	,	,	,
18637	1187	78	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	79	;	;	:
18637	1187	80	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	1187	81	Island	Island	NNP
18637	1187	82	,	,	,
18637	1187	83	April	April	NNP
18637	1187	84	14	14	CD
18637	1187	85	,	,	,
18637	1187	86	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	87	;	;	:
18637	1187	88	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	1187	89	,	,	,
18637	1187	90	April	April	NNP
18637	1187	91	21	21	CD
18637	1187	92	,	,	,
18637	1187	93	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	94	;	;	:
18637	1187	95	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	1187	96	,	,	,
18637	1187	97	June	June	NNP
18637	1187	98	22	22	CD
18637	1187	99	,	,	,
18637	1187	100	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	101	;	;	:
18637	1187	102	West	West	NNP
18637	1187	103	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1187	104	,	,	,
18637	1187	105	July	July	NNP
18637	1187	106	30	30	CD
18637	1187	107	,	,	,
18637	1187	108	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	109	;	;	:
18637	1187	110	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	1187	111	,	,	,
18637	1187	112	August	August	NNP
18637	1187	113	11	11	CD
18637	1187	114	,	,	,
18637	1187	115	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	116	;	;	:
18637	1187	117	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	1187	118	,	,	,
18637	1187	119	August	August	NNP
18637	1187	120	15	15	CD
18637	1187	121	,	,	,
18637	1187	122	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	123	;	;	:
18637	1187	124	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	1187	125	,	,	,
18637	1187	126	September	September	NNP
18637	1187	127	7	7	CD
18637	1187	128	,	,	,
18637	1187	129	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	130	;	;	:
18637	1187	131	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	1187	132	,	,	,
18637	1187	133	September	September	NNP
18637	1187	134	13	13	CD
18637	1187	135	,	,	,
18637	1187	136	1932	1932	CD
18637	1187	137	;	;	:
18637	1187	138	California	California	NNP
18637	1187	139	,	,	,
18637	1187	140	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	141	4	4	CD
18637	1187	142	,	,	,
18637	1187	143	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	144	;	;	:
18637	1187	145	North	North	NNP
18637	1187	146	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1187	147	,	,	,
18637	1187	148	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	149	5	5	CD
18637	1187	150	,	,	,
18637	1187	151	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	152	;	;	:
18637	1187	153	North	North	NNP
18637	1187	154	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	1187	155	,	,	,
18637	1187	156	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	157	9	9	CD
18637	1187	158	,	,	,
18637	1187	159	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	160	;	;	:
18637	1187	161	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	1187	162	,	,	,
18637	1187	163	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	164	12	12	CD
18637	1187	165	,	,	,
18637	1187	166	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	167	;	;	:
18637	1187	168	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	1187	169	,	,	,
18637	1187	170	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	171	13	13	CD
18637	1187	172	,	,	,
18637	1187	173	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	174	;	;	:
18637	1187	175	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	1187	176	,	,	,
18637	1187	177	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	178	13	13	CD
18637	1187	179	,	,	,
18637	1187	180	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	181	;	;	:
18637	1187	182	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	1187	183	,	,	,
18637	1187	184	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	185	13	13	CD
18637	1187	186	,	,	,
18637	1187	187	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	188	;	;	:
18637	1187	189	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	1187	190	,	,	,
18637	1187	191	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	192	13	13	CD
18637	1187	193	,	,	,
18637	1187	194	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	195	;	;	:
18637	1187	196	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	1187	197	,	,	,
18637	1187	198	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	199	16	16	CD
18637	1187	200	,	,	,
18637	1187	201	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	202	;	;	:
18637	1187	203	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	1187	204	,	,	,
18637	1187	205	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	206	16	16	CD
18637	1187	207	,	,	,
18637	1187	208	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	209	;	;	:
18637	1187	210	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	1187	211	,	,	,
18637	1187	212	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	213	19	19	CD
18637	1187	214	,	,	,
18637	1187	215	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	216	;	;	:
18637	1187	217	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	1187	218	,	,	,
18637	1187	219	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	220	19	19	CD
18637	1187	221	,	,	,
18637	1187	222	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	223	;	;	:
18637	1187	224	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	1187	225	,	,	,
18637	1187	226	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	227	19	19	CD
18637	1187	228	,	,	,
18637	1187	229	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	230	;	;	:
18637	1187	231	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	1187	232	,	,	,
18637	1187	233	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	234	20	20	CD
18637	1187	235	,	,	,
18637	1187	236	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	237	;	;	:
18637	1187	238	South	South	NNP
18637	1187	239	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	1187	240	,	,	,
18637	1187	241	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	242	20	20	CD
18637	1187	243	,	,	,
18637	1187	244	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	245	;	;	:
18637	1187	246	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	1187	247	,	,	,
18637	1187	248	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	249	20	20	CD
18637	1187	250	,	,	,
18637	1187	251	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	252	;	;	:
18637	1187	253	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
18637	1187	254	,	,	,
18637	1187	255	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	256	21	21	CD
18637	1187	257	,	,	,
18637	1187	258	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	259	;	;	:
18637	1187	260	New	New	NNP
18637	1187	261	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	1187	262	,	,	,
18637	1187	263	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	264	21	21	CD
18637	1187	265	,	,	,
18637	1187	266	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	267	;	;	:
18637	1187	268	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	1187	269	,	,	,
18637	1187	270	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	271	23	23	CD
18637	1187	272	,	,	,
18637	1187	273	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	274	;	;	:
18637	1187	275	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	1187	276	,	,	,
18637	1187	277	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	278	23	23	CD
18637	1187	279	,	,	,
18637	1187	280	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	281	;	;	:
18637	1187	282	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1187	283	,	,	,
18637	1187	284	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	285	23	23	CD
18637	1187	286	,	,	,
18637	1187	287	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	288	;	;	:
18637	1187	289	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	1187	290	,	,	,
18637	1187	291	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	292	23	23	CD
18637	1187	293	,	,	,
18637	1187	294	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	295	;	;	:
18637	1187	296	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	1187	297	,	,	,
18637	1187	298	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	299	24	24	CD
18637	1187	300	,	,	,
18637	1187	301	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	302	;	;	:
18637	1187	303	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	1187	304	,	,	,
18637	1187	305	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	306	24	24	CD
18637	1187	307	,	,	,
18637	1187	308	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	309	;	;	:
18637	1187	310	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	1187	311	,	,	,
18637	1187	312	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	313	24	24	CD
18637	1187	314	,	,	,
18637	1187	315	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	316	;	;	:
18637	1187	317	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	1187	318	,	,	,
18637	1187	319	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	320	26	26	CD
18637	1187	321	,	,	,
18637	1187	322	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	323	;	;	:
18637	1187	324	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	1187	325	,	,	,
18637	1187	326	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	327	27	27	CD
18637	1187	328	,	,	,
18637	1187	329	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	330	;	;	:
18637	1187	331	New	New	NNP
18637	1187	332	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1187	333	,	,	,
18637	1187	334	January	January	NNP
18637	1187	335	31	31	CD
18637	1187	336	,	,	,
18637	1187	337	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	338	;	;	:
18637	1187	339	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	1187	340	,	,	,
18637	1187	341	February	February	NNP
18637	1187	342	2	2	CD
18637	1187	343	,	,	,
18637	1187	344	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	345	;	;	:
18637	1187	346	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1187	347	,	,	,
18637	1187	348	March	March	NNP
18637	1187	349	24	24	CD
18637	1187	350	,	,	,
18637	1187	351	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	352	;	;	:
18637	1187	353	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	1187	354	,	,	,
18637	1187	355	April	April	NNP
18637	1187	356	26	26	CD
18637	1187	357	,	,	,
18637	1187	358	1933	1933	CD
18637	1187	359	.	.	.
18637	1188	1	A	a	DT
18637	1188	2	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1188	3	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1188	4	which	which	WDT
18637	1188	5	would	would	MD
18637	1188	6	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	1188	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1188	8	to	to	TO
18637	1188	9	limit	limit	VB
18637	1188	10	,	,	,
18637	1188	11	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1188	12	,	,	,
18637	1188	13	and	and	CC
18637	1188	14	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	1188	15	the	the	DT
18637	1188	16	labor	labor	NN
18637	1188	17	of	of	IN
18637	1188	18	persons	person	NNS
18637	1188	19	under	under	IN
18637	1188	20	18	18	CD
18637	1188	21	years	year	NNS
18637	1188	22	of	of	IN
18637	1188	23	age	age	NN
18637	1188	24	was	be	VBD
18637	1188	25	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1188	26	by	by	IN
18637	1188	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1188	28	on	on	IN
18637	1188	29	June	June	NNP
18637	1188	30	2	2	CD
18637	1188	31	,	,	,
18637	1188	32	1924	1924	CD
18637	1188	33	.	.	.
18637	1189	1	This	this	DT
18637	1189	2	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	1189	3	at	at	IN
18637	1189	4	the	the	DT
18637	1189	5	time	time	NN
18637	1189	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1189	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1189	8	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	1189	9	to	to	IN
18637	1189	10	the	the	DT
18637	1189	11	States	States	NNPS
18637	1189	12	was	be	VBD
18637	1189	13	referred	refer	VBN
18637	1189	14	to	to	IN
18637	1189	15	as	as	IN
18637	1189	16	"	"	``
18637	1189	17	the	the	DT
18637	1189	18	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1189	19	20th	20th	NNP
18637	1189	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1189	21	.	.	.
18637	1189	22	"	"	''
18637	1190	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1190	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1190	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1190	4	in	in	IN
18637	1190	5	43	43	CD
18637	1190	6	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	1190	7	.	.	.
18637	1191	1	670	670	CD
18637	1191	2	.	.	.
18637	1192	1	The	the	DT
18637	1192	2	status	status	NN
18637	1192	3	of	of	IN
18637	1192	4	this	this	DT
18637	1192	5	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1192	6	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1192	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	1192	8	a	a	DT
18637	1192	9	matter	matter	NN
18637	1192	10	of	of	IN
18637	1192	11	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	1192	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1192	13	.	.	.
18637	1193	1	The	the	DT
18637	1193	2	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	1193	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1193	4	of	of	IN
18637	1193	5	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	1193	6	in	in	IN
18637	1193	7	Wise	Wise	NNP
18637	1193	8	_	_	NNP
18637	1193	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	1193	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1193	11	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	1193	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1193	13	270	270	CD
18637	1193	14	Ky.	Kentucky	NNP
18637	1193	15	1	1	CD
18637	1193	16	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1193	17	1937	1937	CD
18637	1193	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1193	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1193	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	1193	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	1193	22	that	that	IN
18637	1193	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1193	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	1193	25	no	no	RB
18637	1193	26	longer	longer	RB
18637	1193	27	open	open	JJ
18637	1193	28	to	to	IN
18637	1193	29	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1193	30	because	because	IN
18637	1193	31	:	:	:
18637	1193	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1193	33	1	1	LS
18637	1193	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1193	35	Rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1193	36	by	by	IN
18637	1193	37	more	more	JJR
18637	1193	38	than	than	IN
18637	1193	39	one	one	CD
18637	1193	40	-	-	HYPH
18637	1193	41	fourth	fourth	NN
18637	1193	42	of	of	IN
18637	1193	43	the	the	DT
18637	1193	44	States	States	NNPS
18637	1193	45	;	;	:
18637	1193	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1193	47	2	2	LS
18637	1193	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1193	49	a	a	DT
18637	1193	50	State	state	NN
18637	1193	51	may	may	MD
18637	1193	52	not	not	RB
18637	1193	53	reject	reject	VB
18637	1193	54	and	and	CC
18637	1193	55	then	then	RB
18637	1193	56	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	1193	57	ratify	ratify	VB
18637	1193	58	,	,	,
18637	1193	59	at	at	IN
18637	1193	60	least	least	JJS
18637	1193	61	when	when	WRB
18637	1193	62	more	more	JJR
18637	1193	63	than	than	IN
18637	1193	64	one	one	CD
18637	1193	65	-	-	HYPH
18637	1193	66	fourth	fourth	NN
18637	1193	67	of	of	IN
18637	1193	68	the	the	DT
18637	1193	69	States	States	NNPS
18637	1193	70	are	be	VBP
18637	1193	71	on	on	IN
18637	1193	72	record	record	NN
18637	1193	73	as	as	IN
18637	1193	74	rejecting	reject	VBG
18637	1193	75	;	;	:
18637	1193	76	and	and	CC
18637	1193	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1193	78	3	3	LS
18637	1193	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1193	80	more	more	JJR
18637	1193	81	than	than	IN
18637	1193	82	a	a	DT
18637	1193	83	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	1193	84	time	time	NN
18637	1193	85	has	have	VBZ
18637	1193	86	elapsed	elapse	VBN
18637	1193	87	since	since	IN
18637	1193	88	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1193	89	was	be	VBD
18637	1193	90	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	1193	91	to	to	IN
18637	1193	92	the	the	DT
18637	1193	93	States	States	NNP
18637	1193	94	in	in	IN
18637	1193	95	1924	1924	CD
18637	1193	96	.	.	.
18637	1194	1	The	the	DT
18637	1194	2	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	1194	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1194	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1194	5	in	in	IN
18637	1194	6	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	1194	7	_	_	NNP
18637	1194	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	1194	9	_	_	NNP
18637	1194	10	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	1194	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1194	12	146	146	CD
18637	1194	13	Kan.	Kansas	NNP
18637	1194	14	390	390	CD
18637	1194	15	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1194	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	1194	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1194	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1194	19	came	come	VBD
18637	1194	20	to	to	IN
18637	1194	21	the	the	DT
18637	1194	22	opposite	opposite	JJ
18637	1194	23	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	1194	24	.	.	.
18637	1195	1	On	on	IN
18637	1195	2	October	October	NNP
18637	1195	3	1	1	CD
18637	1195	4	,	,	,
18637	1195	5	1937	1937	CD
18637	1195	6	,	,	,
18637	1195	7	27	27	CD
18637	1195	8	States	state	NNS
18637	1195	9	had	have	VBD
18637	1195	10	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	1195	11	the	the	DT
18637	1195	12	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1195	13	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1195	14	.	.	.
18637	1196	1	Of	of	IN
18637	1196	2	these	these	DT
18637	1196	3	States	States	NNP
18637	1196	4	10	10	CD
18637	1196	5	had	have	VBD
18637	1196	6	previously	previously	RB
18637	1196	7	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1196	8	the	the	DT
18637	1196	9	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1196	10	on	on	IN
18637	1196	11	one	one	CD
18637	1196	12	or	or	CC
18637	1196	13	more	more	JJR
18637	1196	14	occasions	occasion	NNS
18637	1196	15	.	.	.
18637	1197	1	At	at	RB
18637	1197	2	least	least	RBS
18637	1197	3	26	26	CD
18637	1197	4	different	different	JJ
18637	1197	5	States	state	NNS
18637	1197	6	have	have	VBP
18637	1197	7	at	at	IN
18637	1197	8	one	one	CD
18637	1197	9	time	time	NN
18637	1197	10	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	1197	11	the	the	DT
18637	1197	12	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1197	13	.	.	.
18637	1198	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1198	2	m	m	NN
18637	1198	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1198	4	The	the	DT
18637	1198	5	21st	21st	JJ
18637	1198	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1198	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1198	8	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1198	9	by	by	IN
18637	1198	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1198	11	on	on	IN
18637	1198	12	February	February	NNP
18637	1198	13	20	20	CD
18637	1198	14	,	,	,
18637	1198	15	1933	1933	CD
18637	1198	16	,	,	,
18637	1198	17	when	when	WRB
18637	1198	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1198	19	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1198	20	the	the	DT
18637	1198	21	House	House	NNP
18637	1198	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1198	23	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1198	24	.	.	.
18637	1199	1	Rec	Rec	NNP
18637	1199	2	.	.	.
18637	1200	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1200	2	72d	72d	CD
18637	1200	3	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1200	4	.	.	NNP
18637	1200	5	,	,	,
18637	1200	6	2d	2d	CD
18637	1200	7	sess	sess	NN
18637	1200	8	.	.	.
18637	1200	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1201	1	4516	4516	CD
18637	1201	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1201	3	,	,	,
18637	1201	4	having	have	VBG
18637	1201	5	previously	previously	RB
18637	1201	6	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1201	7	the	the	DT
18637	1201	8	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1201	9	on	on	IN
18637	1201	10	February	February	NNP
18637	1201	11	16	16	CD
18637	1201	12	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1201	13	_	_	NNP
18637	1201	14	Id.	Idaho	NNP
18637	1201	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1201	16	,	,	,
18637	1201	17	4231	4231	CD
18637	1201	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1201	19	.	.	.
18637	1202	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1202	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1202	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1202	4	in	in	IN
18637	1202	5	47	47	CD
18637	1202	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1202	7	.	.	.
18637	1203	1	1625	1625	CD
18637	1203	2	.	.	.
18637	1204	1	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1204	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1204	3	completed	complete	VBN
18637	1204	4	on	on	IN
18637	1204	5	December	December	NNP
18637	1204	6	5	5	CD
18637	1204	7	,	,	,
18637	1204	8	1933	1933	CD
18637	1204	9	,	,	,
18637	1204	10	when	when	WRB
18637	1204	11	the	the	DT
18637	1204	12	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	1204	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	1204	14	sixth	sixth	JJ
18637	1204	15	State	State	NNP
18637	1204	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1204	17	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	1204	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1204	19	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1204	20	the	the	DT
18637	1204	21	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1204	22	,	,	,
18637	1204	23	there	there	EX
18637	1204	24	being	be	VBG
18637	1204	25	then	then	RB
18637	1204	26	48	48	CD
18637	1204	27	States	state	NNS
18637	1204	28	in	in	IN
18637	1204	29	the	the	DT
18637	1204	30	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1204	31	.	.	.
18637	1205	1	On	on	IN
18637	1205	2	December	December	NNP
18637	1205	3	5	5	CD
18637	1205	4	,	,	,
18637	1205	5	1933	1933	CD
18637	1205	6	,	,	,
18637	1205	7	Acting	Acting	NNP
18637	1205	8	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1205	9	of	of	IN
18637	1205	10	State	State	NNP
18637	1205	11	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	1205	12	certified	certify	VBD
18637	1205	13	that	that	IN
18637	1205	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1205	15	had	have	VBD
18637	1205	16	been	be	VBN
18637	1205	17	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	1205	18	by	by	IN
18637	1205	19	the	the	DT
18637	1205	20	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	1205	21	number	number	NN
18637	1205	22	of	of	IN
18637	1205	23	States	state	NNS
18637	1205	24	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1205	25	48	48	CD
18637	1205	26	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1205	27	.	.	.
18637	1206	1	1749	1749	CD
18637	1206	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1206	3	.	.	.
18637	1207	1	The	the	DT
18637	1207	2	several	several	JJ
18637	1207	3	State	State	NNP
18637	1207	4	conventions	convention	NNS
18637	1207	5	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1207	6	the	the	DT
18637	1207	7	21st	21st	JJ
18637	1207	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1207	9	on	on	IN
18637	1207	10	the	the	DT
18637	1207	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	1207	12	dates	date	NNS
18637	1207	13	:	:	:
18637	1207	14	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	1207	15	,	,	,
18637	1207	16	April	April	NNP
18637	1207	17	10	10	CD
18637	1207	18	,	,	,
18637	1207	19	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	20	;	;	:
18637	1207	21	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	1207	22	,	,	,
18637	1207	23	April	April	NNP
18637	1207	24	25	25	CD
18637	1207	25	,	,	,
18637	1207	26	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	27	;	;	:
18637	1207	28	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	1207	29	Island	Island	NNP
18637	1207	30	,	,	,
18637	1207	31	May	May	NNP
18637	1207	32	8	8	CD
18637	1207	33	,	,	,
18637	1207	34	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	35	;	;	:
18637	1207	36	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	1207	37	,	,	,
18637	1207	38	May	May	NNP
18637	1207	39	25	25	CD
18637	1207	40	,	,	,
18637	1207	41	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	42	;	;	:
18637	1207	43	New	New	NNP
18637	1207	44	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1207	45	,	,	,
18637	1207	46	June	June	NNP
18637	1207	47	1	1	CD
18637	1207	48	,	,	,
18637	1207	49	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	50	;	;	:
18637	1207	51	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	1207	52	,	,	,
18637	1207	53	June	June	NNP
18637	1207	54	24	24	CD
18637	1207	55	,	,	,
18637	1207	56	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	57	;	;	:
18637	1207	58	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	1207	59	,	,	,
18637	1207	60	June	June	NNP
18637	1207	61	26	26	CD
18637	1207	62	,	,	,
18637	1207	63	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	64	;	;	:
18637	1207	65	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	1207	66	,	,	,
18637	1207	67	June	June	NNP
18637	1207	68	26	26	CD
18637	1207	69	,	,	,
18637	1207	70	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	71	;	;	:
18637	1207	72	New	New	NNP
18637	1207	73	York	York	NNP
18637	1207	74	,	,	,
18637	1207	75	June	June	NNP
18637	1207	76	27	27	CD
18637	1207	77	,	,	,
18637	1207	78	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	79	;	;	:
18637	1207	80	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	1207	81	,	,	,
18637	1207	82	July	July	NNP
18637	1207	83	10	10	CD
18637	1207	84	,	,	,
18637	1207	85	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	86	;	;	:
18637	1207	87	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	1207	88	,	,	,
18637	1207	89	July	July	NNP
18637	1207	90	10	10	CD
18637	1207	91	,	,	,
18637	1207	92	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	93	;	;	:
18637	1207	94	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	1207	95	,	,	,
18637	1207	96	July	July	NNP
18637	1207	97	11	11	CD
18637	1207	98	,	,	,
18637	1207	99	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	100	;	;	:
18637	1207	101	New	New	NNP
18637	1207	102	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1207	103	,	,	,
18637	1207	104	July	July	NNP
18637	1207	105	11	11	CD
18637	1207	106	,	,	,
18637	1207	107	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	108	;	;	:
18637	1207	109	California	California	NNP
18637	1207	110	,	,	,
18637	1207	111	July	July	NNP
18637	1207	112	24	24	CD
18637	1207	113	,	,	,
18637	1207	114	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	115	;	;	:
18637	1207	116	West	West	NNP
18637	1207	117	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1207	118	,	,	,
18637	1207	119	July	July	NNP
18637	1207	120	25	25	CD
18637	1207	121	,	,	,
18637	1207	122	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	123	;	;	:
18637	1207	124	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	1207	125	,	,	,
18637	1207	126	August	August	NNP
18637	1207	127	1	1	CD
18637	1207	128	,	,	,
18637	1207	129	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	130	;	;	:
18637	1207	131	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	1207	132	,	,	,
18637	1207	133	August	August	NNP
18637	1207	134	7	7	CD
18637	1207	135	,	,	,
18637	1207	136	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	137	;	;	:
18637	1207	138	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	1207	139	,	,	,
18637	1207	140	August	August	NNP
18637	1207	141	8	8	CD
18637	1207	142	,	,	,
18637	1207	143	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	144	;	;	:
18637	1207	145	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	1207	146	,	,	,
18637	1207	147	August	August	NNP
18637	1207	148	11	11	CD
18637	1207	149	,	,	,
18637	1207	150	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	151	;	;	:
18637	1207	152	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	1207	153	,	,	,
18637	1207	154	August	August	NNP
18637	1207	155	29	29	CD
18637	1207	156	,	,	,
18637	1207	157	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	158	;	;	:
18637	1207	159	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	1207	160	,	,	,
18637	1207	161	September	September	NNP
18637	1207	162	5	5	CD
18637	1207	163	,	,	,
18637	1207	164	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	165	;	;	:
18637	1207	166	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	1207	167	,	,	,
18637	1207	168	September	September	NNP
18637	1207	169	5	5	CD
18637	1207	170	,	,	,
18637	1207	171	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	172	;	;	:
18637	1207	173	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	1207	174	,	,	,
18637	1207	175	September	September	NNP
18637	1207	176	23	23	CD
18637	1207	177	,	,	,
18637	1207	178	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	179	;	;	:
18637	1207	180	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	1207	181	,	,	,
18637	1207	182	September	September	NNP
18637	1207	183	26	26	CD
18637	1207	184	,	,	,
18637	1207	185	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	186	;	;	:
18637	1207	187	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	1207	188	,	,	,
18637	1207	189	October	October	NNP
18637	1207	190	3	3	CD
18637	1207	191	,	,	,
18637	1207	192	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	193	;	;	:
18637	1207	194	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	1207	195	,	,	,
18637	1207	196	October	October	NNP
18637	1207	197	10	10	CD
18637	1207	198	,	,	,
18637	1207	199	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	200	;	;	:
18637	1207	201	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
18637	1207	202	,	,	,
18637	1207	203	October	October	NNP
18637	1207	204	17	17	CD
18637	1207	205	,	,	,
18637	1207	206	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	207	;	;	:
18637	1207	208	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1207	209	,	,	,
18637	1207	210	October	October	NNP
18637	1207	211	18	18	CD
18637	1207	212	,	,	,
18637	1207	213	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	214	;	;	:
18637	1207	215	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1207	216	,	,	,
18637	1207	217	October	October	NNP
18637	1207	218	25	25	CD
18637	1207	219	,	,	,
18637	1207	220	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	221	;	;	:
18637	1207	222	New	New	NNP
18637	1207	223	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	1207	224	,	,	,
18637	1207	225	November	November	NNP
18637	1207	226	2	2	CD
18637	1207	227	,	,	,
18637	1207	228	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	229	;	;	:
18637	1207	230	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	1207	231	,	,	,
18637	1207	232	November	November	NNP
18637	1207	233	14	14	CD
18637	1207	234	,	,	,
18637	1207	235	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	236	;	;	:
18637	1207	237	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	1207	238	,	,	,
18637	1207	239	November	November	NNP
18637	1207	240	24	24	CD
18637	1207	241	,	,	,
18637	1207	242	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	243	;	;	:
18637	1207	244	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	1207	245	,	,	,
18637	1207	246	November	November	NNP
18637	1207	247	27	27	CD
18637	1207	248	,	,	,
18637	1207	249	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	250	;	;	:
18637	1207	251	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1207	252	,	,	,
18637	1207	253	December	December	NNP
18637	1207	254	5	5	CD
18637	1207	255	,	,	,
18637	1207	256	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	257	;	;	:
18637	1207	258	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	1207	259	,	,	,
18637	1207	260	December	December	NNP
18637	1207	261	5	5	CD
18637	1207	262	,	,	,
18637	1207	263	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	264	;	;	:
18637	1207	265	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	1207	266	,	,	,
18637	1207	267	December	December	NNP
18637	1207	268	5	5	CD
18637	1207	269	,	,	,
18637	1207	270	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	271	;	;	:
18637	1207	272	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	1207	273	,	,	,
18637	1207	274	December	December	NNP
18637	1207	275	6	6	CD
18637	1207	276	,	,	,
18637	1207	277	1933	1933	CD
18637	1207	278	;	;	:
18637	1207	279	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	1207	280	,	,	,
18637	1207	281	August	August	NNP
18637	1207	282	6	6	CD
18637	1207	283	,	,	,
18637	1207	284	1934	1934	CD
18637	1207	285	.	.	.
18637	1208	1	The	the	DT
18637	1208	2	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1208	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1208	4	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1208	5	by	by	IN
18637	1208	6	a	a	DT
18637	1208	7	convention	convention	NN
18637	1208	8	in	in	IN
18637	1208	9	the	the	DT
18637	1208	10	State	State	NNP
18637	1208	11	of	of	IN
18637	1208	12	South	South	NNP
18637	1208	13	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1208	14	,	,	,
18637	1208	15	on	on	IN
18637	1208	16	December	December	NNP
18637	1208	17	4	4	CD
18637	1208	18	,	,	,
18637	1208	19	1933	1933	CD
18637	1208	20	.	.	.
18637	1209	1	The	the	DT
18637	1209	2	electorate	electorate	NN
18637	1209	3	of	of	IN
18637	1209	4	the	the	DT
18637	1209	5	State	State	NNP
18637	1209	6	of	of	IN
18637	1209	7	North	North	NNP
18637	1209	8	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1209	9	voted	vote	VBD
18637	1209	10	against	against	IN
18637	1209	11	holding	hold	VBG
18637	1209	12	a	a	DT
18637	1209	13	convention	convention	NN
18637	1209	14	at	at	IN
18637	1209	15	a	a	DT
18637	1209	16	general	general	JJ
18637	1209	17	election	election	NN
18637	1209	18	held	hold	VBN
18637	1209	19	on	on	IN
18637	1209	20	November	November	NNP
18637	1209	21	7	7	CD
18637	1209	22	,	,	,
18637	1209	23	1933	1933	CD
18637	1209	24	.	.	.
18637	1210	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1210	2	n	n	NN
18637	1210	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1210	4	The	the	DT
18637	1210	5	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	1210	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	1210	7	second	second	NN
18637	1210	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1210	9	was	be	VBD
18637	1210	10	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1210	11	by	by	IN
18637	1210	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1210	13	on	on	IN
18637	1210	14	March	March	NNP
18637	1210	15	24	24	CD
18637	1210	16	,	,	,
18637	1210	17	1947	1947	CD
18637	1210	18	,	,	,
18637	1210	19	having	have	VBG
18637	1210	20	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1210	21	the	the	DT
18637	1210	22	House	House	NNP
18637	1210	23	on	on	IN
18637	1210	24	March	March	NNP
18637	1210	25	21	21	CD
18637	1210	26	,	,	,
18637	1210	27	1947	1947	CD
18637	1210	28	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1210	29	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1210	30	.	.	.
18637	1211	1	Rec	Rec	NNP
18637	1211	2	.	.	.
18637	1212	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1212	2	80th	80th	JJ
18637	1212	3	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	1212	4	.	.	NNP
18637	1212	5	,	,	,
18637	1212	6	1st	1st	JJ
18637	1212	7	sess	sess	NN
18637	1212	8	.	.	.
18637	1212	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1213	1	2392	2392	CD
18637	1213	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1213	3	and	and	CC
18637	1213	4	having	have	VBG
18637	1213	5	previously	previously	RB
18637	1213	6	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1213	7	the	the	DT
18637	1213	8	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1213	9	on	on	IN
18637	1213	10	March	March	NNP
18637	1213	11	12	12	CD
18637	1213	12	,	,	,
18637	1213	13	1947	1947	CD
18637	1213	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1213	15	Id.	Idaho	NNP
18637	1214	1	1978	1978	CD
18637	1214	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1214	3	.	.	.
18637	1215	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1215	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1215	3	officially	officially	RB
18637	1215	4	in	in	IN
18637	1215	5	61	61	CD
18637	1215	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	1215	7	.	.	.
18637	1216	1	959	959	CD
18637	1216	2	.	.	.
18637	1217	1	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	1217	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1217	3	completed	complete	VBN
18637	1217	4	on	on	IN
18637	1217	5	February	February	NNP
18637	1217	6	27	27	CD
18637	1217	7	,	,	,
18637	1217	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	1217	9	,	,	,
18637	1217	10	when	when	WRB
18637	1217	11	the	the	DT
18637	1217	12	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	1217	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	1217	14	sixth	sixth	JJ
18637	1217	15	State	State	NNP
18637	1217	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1217	17	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	1217	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1217	19	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1217	20	the	the	DT
18637	1217	21	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	1217	22	;	;	:
18637	1217	23	there	there	EX
18637	1217	24	being	be	VBG
18637	1217	25	then	then	RB
18637	1217	26	48	48	CD
18637	1217	27	States	state	NNS
18637	1217	28	in	in	IN
18637	1217	29	the	the	DT
18637	1217	30	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1217	31	.	.	.
18637	1218	1	On	on	IN
18637	1218	2	March	March	NNP
18637	1218	3	1	1	CD
18637	1218	4	,	,	,
18637	1218	5	1951	1951	CD
18637	1218	6	,	,	,
18637	1218	7	Jess	Jess	NNP
18637	1218	8	Larson	Larson	NNP
18637	1218	9	,	,	,
18637	1218	10	Administrator	Administrator	NNP
18637	1218	11	of	of	IN
18637	1218	12	General	General	NNP
18637	1218	13	Services	Services	NNP
18637	1218	14	,	,	,
18637	1218	15	certified	certify	VBD
18637	1218	16	that	that	IN
18637	1218	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1218	18	had	have	VBD
18637	1218	19	been	be	VBN
18637	1218	20	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	1218	21	by	by	IN
18637	1218	22	the	the	DT
18637	1218	23	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	1218	24	number	number	NN
18637	1218	25	of	of	IN
18637	1218	26	States	States	NNP
18637	1218	27	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1218	28	16	16	CD
18637	1218	29	F.R.	F.R.	NNP
18637	1219	1	2019	2019	CD
18637	1219	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1219	3	.	.	.
18637	1220	1	A	a	DT
18637	1220	2	total	total	NN
18637	1220	3	of	of	IN
18637	1220	4	41	41	CD
18637	1220	5	State	state	NN
18637	1220	6	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1220	7	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1220	8	the	the	DT
18637	1220	9	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	1220	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	1220	11	second	second	NN
18637	1220	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1220	13	on	on	IN
18637	1220	14	the	the	DT
18637	1220	15	following	follow	VBG
18637	1220	16	dates	date	NNS
18637	1220	17	:	:	:
18637	1220	18	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	1220	19	,	,	,
18637	1220	20	March	March	NNP
18637	1220	21	31	31	CD
18637	1220	22	,	,	,
18637	1220	23	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	24	;	;	:
18637	1220	25	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	1220	26	,	,	,
18637	1220	27	March	March	NNP
18637	1220	28	31	31	CD
18637	1220	29	,	,	,
18637	1220	30	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	31	;	;	:
18637	1220	32	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	1220	33	,	,	,
18637	1220	34	April	April	NNP
18637	1220	35	1	1	CD
18637	1220	36	,	,	,
18637	1220	37	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	38	;	;	:
18637	1220	39	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	1220	40	,	,	,
18637	1220	41	April	April	NNP
18637	1220	42	1	1	CD
18637	1220	43	,	,	,
18637	1220	44	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	45	;	;	:
18637	1220	46	New	New	NNP
18637	1220	47	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1220	48	,	,	,
18637	1220	49	April	April	NNP
18637	1220	50	1	1	CD
18637	1220	51	,	,	,
18637	1220	52	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	53	;	;	:
18637	1220	54	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	1220	55	,	,	,
18637	1220	56	April	April	NNP
18637	1220	57	2	2	CD
18637	1220	58	,	,	,
18637	1220	59	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	60	;	;	:
18637	1220	61	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	1220	62	,	,	,
18637	1220	63	April	April	NNP
18637	1220	64	3	3	CD
18637	1220	65	,	,	,
18637	1220	66	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	67	;	;	:
18637	1220	68	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	1220	69	,	,	,
18637	1220	70	April	April	NNP
18637	1220	71	3	3	CD
18637	1220	72	,	,	,
18637	1220	73	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	74	;	;	:
18637	1220	75	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	1220	76	,	,	,
18637	1220	77	April	April	NNP
18637	1220	78	12	12	CD
18637	1220	79	,	,	,
18637	1220	80	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	81	;	;	:
18637	1220	82	California	California	NNP
18637	1220	83	,	,	,
18637	1220	84	April	April	NNP
18637	1220	85	15	15	CD
18637	1220	86	,	,	,
18637	1220	87	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	88	;	;	:
18637	1220	89	New	New	NNP
18637	1220	90	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1220	91	,	,	,
18637	1220	92	April	April	NNP
18637	1220	93	15	15	CD
18637	1220	94	,	,	,
18637	1220	95	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	96	;	;	:
18637	1220	97	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	1220	98	,	,	,
18637	1220	99	April	April	NNP
18637	1220	100	15	15	CD
18637	1220	101	,	,	,
18637	1220	102	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	103	;	;	:
18637	1220	104	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1220	105	,	,	,
18637	1220	106	April	April	NNP
18637	1220	107	16	16	CD
18637	1220	108	,	,	,
18637	1220	109	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	110	;	;	:
18637	1220	111	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	1220	112	;	;	:
18637	1220	113	April	April	NNP
18637	1220	114	16	16	CD
18637	1220	115	,	,	,
18637	1220	116	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	117	;	;	:
18637	1220	118	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	1220	119	,	,	,
18637	1220	120	April	April	NNP
18637	1220	121	29	29	CD
18637	1220	122	,	,	,
18637	1220	123	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	124	;	;	:
18637	1220	125	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	1220	126	,	,	,
18637	1220	127	May	May	NNP
18637	1220	128	21	21	CD
18637	1220	129	,	,	,
18637	1220	130	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	131	;	;	:
18637	1220	132	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	1220	133	,	,	,
18637	1220	134	May	May	NNP
18637	1220	135	22	22	CD
18637	1220	136	,	,	,
18637	1220	137	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	138	;	;	:
18637	1220	139	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	1220	140	,	,	,
18637	1220	141	May	May	NNP
18637	1220	142	23	23	CD
18637	1220	143	,	,	,
18637	1220	144	1947	1947	CD
18637	1220	145	;	;	:
18637	1220	146	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1220	147	,	,	,
18637	1220	148	January	January	NNP
18637	1220	149	28	28	CD
18637	1220	150	,	,	,
18637	1220	151	1948	1948	CD
18637	1220	152	;	;	:
18637	1220	153	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	1220	154	,	,	,
18637	1220	155	February	February	NNP
18637	1220	156	12	12	CD
18637	1220	157	,	,	,
18637	1220	158	1948	1948	CD
18637	1220	159	;	;	:
18637	1220	160	New	New	NNP
18637	1220	161	York	York	NNP
18637	1220	162	,	,	,
18637	1220	163	March	March	NNP
18637	1220	164	9	9	CD
18637	1220	165	,	,	,
18637	1220	166	1948	1948	CD
18637	1220	167	;	;	:
18637	1220	168	South	South	NNP
18637	1220	169	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	1220	170	,	,	,
18637	1220	171	January	January	NNP
18637	1220	172	21	21	CD
18637	1220	173	,	,	,
18637	1220	174	1949	1949	CD
18637	1220	175	;	;	:
18637	1220	176	North	North	NNP
18637	1220	177	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	1220	178	,	,	,
18637	1220	179	February	February	NNP
18637	1220	180	25	25	CD
18637	1220	181	,	,	,
18637	1220	182	1949	1949	CD
18637	1220	183	;	;	:
18637	1220	184	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	1220	185	,	,	,
18637	1220	186	May	May	NNP
18637	1220	187	17	17	CD
18637	1220	188	,	,	,
18637	1220	189	1950	1950	CD
18637	1220	190	;	;	:
18637	1220	191	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	1220	192	,	,	,
18637	1220	193	January	January	NNP
18637	1220	194	25	25	CD
18637	1220	195	,	,	,
18637	1220	196	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	197	;	;	:
18637	1220	198	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	1220	199	,	,	,
18637	1220	200	January	January	NNP
18637	1220	201	29	29	CD
18637	1220	202	,	,	,
18637	1220	203	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	204	;	;	:
18637	1220	205	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
18637	1220	206	,	,	,
18637	1220	207	January	January	NNP
18637	1220	208	30	30	CD
18637	1220	209	,	,	,
18637	1220	210	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	211	;	;	:
18637	1220	212	New	New	NNP
18637	1220	213	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	1220	214	,	,	,
18637	1220	215	February	February	NNP
18637	1220	216	12	12	CD
18637	1220	217	,	,	,
18637	1220	218	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	219	;	;	:
18637	1220	220	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	1220	221	,	,	,
18637	1220	222	February	February	NNP
18637	1220	223	12	12	CD
18637	1220	224	,	,	,
18637	1220	225	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	226	;	;	:
18637	1220	227	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	1220	228	,	,	,
18637	1220	229	February	February	NNP
18637	1220	230	15	15	CD
18637	1220	231	,	,	,
18637	1220	232	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	233	;	;	:
18637	1220	234	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	1220	235	,	,	,
18637	1220	236	February	February	NNP
18637	1220	237	17	17	CD
18637	1220	238	,	,	,
18637	1220	239	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	240	;	;	:
18637	1220	241	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	1220	242	,	,	,
18637	1220	243	February	February	NNP
18637	1220	244	20	20	CD
18637	1220	245	,	,	,
18637	1220	246	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	247	;	;	:
18637	1220	248	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	1220	249	,	,	,
18637	1220	250	February	February	NNP
18637	1220	251	22	22	CD
18637	1220	252	,	,	,
18637	1220	253	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	254	;	;	:
18637	1220	255	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	1220	256	,	,	,
18637	1220	257	February	February	NNP
18637	1220	258	26	26	CD
18637	1220	259	,	,	,
18637	1220	260	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	261	;	;	:
18637	1220	262	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	1220	263	,	,	,
18637	1220	264	February	February	NNP
18637	1220	265	26	26	CD
18637	1220	266	,	,	,
18637	1220	267	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	268	;	;	:
18637	1220	269	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	1220	270	,	,	,
18637	1220	271	February	February	NNP
18637	1220	272	27	27	CD
18637	1220	273	,	,	,
18637	1220	274	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	275	;	;	:
18637	1220	276	North	North	NNP
18637	1220	277	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1220	278	,	,	,
18637	1220	279	February	February	NNP
18637	1220	280	28	28	CD
18637	1220	281	,	,	,
18637	1220	282	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	283	;	;	:
18637	1220	284	South	South	NNP
18637	1220	285	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1220	286	,	,	,
18637	1220	287	March	March	NNP
18637	1220	288	13	13	CD
18637	1220	289	,	,	,
18637	1220	290	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	291	;	;	:
18637	1220	292	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1220	293	,	,	,
18637	1220	294	March	March	NNP
18637	1220	295	14	14	CD
18637	1220	296	,	,	,
18637	1220	297	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	298	;	;	:
18637	1220	299	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	1220	300	,	,	,
18637	1220	301	April	April	NNP
18637	1220	302	16	16	CD
18637	1220	303	,	,	,
18637	1220	304	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	305	;	;	:
18637	1220	306	and	and	CC
18637	1220	307	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	1220	308	,	,	,
18637	1220	309	May	May	NNP
18637	1220	310	4	4	CD
18637	1220	311	,	,	,
18637	1220	312	1951	1951	CD
18637	1220	313	.	.	.
18637	1221	1	THE	the	DT
18637	1221	2	CONSTITUTION	CONSTITUTION	NNP
18637	1221	3	OF	of	IN
18637	1221	4	THE	the	DT
18637	1221	5	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	1221	6	STATES	state	NNS
18637	1221	7	OF	of	IN
18637	1221	8	AMERICA	AMERICA	NNP
18637	1221	9	WITH	with	IN
18637	1221	10	ANNOTATIONS	annotation	NNS
18637	1221	11	PREAMBLE	PREAMBLE	NNP
18637	1221	12	The	the	DT
18637	1221	13	Preamble	Preamble	NNP
18637	1221	14	:	:	:
18637	1221	15	Page	Page	NNP
18637	1221	16	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	1221	17	and	and	CC
18637	1221	18	effect	effect	NN
18637	1221	19	59	59	CD
18637	1221	20	"	"	``
18637	1221	21	The	the	DT
18637	1221	22	people	people	NNS
18637	1221	23	of	of	IN
18637	1221	24	the	the	DT
18637	1221	25	United	United	NNP
18637	1221	26	States	States	NNP
18637	1221	27	"	"	''
18637	1221	28	59	59	CD
18637	1221	29	THE	the	DT
18637	1221	30	CONSTITUTION	CONSTITUTION	NNP
18637	1221	31	OF	of	IN
18637	1221	32	THE	the	DT
18637	1221	33	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	1221	34	STATES	state	NNS
18637	1221	35	OF	of	IN
18637	1221	36	AMERICA	AMERICA	NNP
18637	1221	37	WITH	with	IN
18637	1221	38	ANNOTATIONS	annotation	NNS
18637	1221	39	The	the	DT
18637	1221	40	Preamble	Preamble	NNP
18637	1221	41	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1221	42	the	the	DT
18637	1221	43	People	People	NNS
18637	1221	44	of	of	IN
18637	1221	45	the	the	DT
18637	1221	46	United	United	NNP
18637	1221	47	States	States	NNP
18637	1221	48	,	,	,
18637	1221	49	in	in	IN
18637	1221	50	Order	order	NN
18637	1221	51	to	to	TO
18637	1221	52	form	form	VB
18637	1221	53	a	a	DT
18637	1221	54	more	more	RBR
18637	1221	55	perfect	perfect	JJ
18637	1221	56	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1221	57	,	,	,
18637	1221	58	establish	establish	VB
18637	1221	59	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1221	60	,	,	,
18637	1221	61	insure	insure	VB
18637	1221	62	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	1221	63	Tranquility	tranquility	NN
18637	1221	64	,	,	,
18637	1221	65	provide	provide	VB
18637	1221	66	for	for	IN
18637	1221	67	the	the	DT
18637	1221	68	common	common	JJ
18637	1221	69	defence	defence	NN
18637	1221	70	,	,	,
18637	1221	71	promote	promote	VB
18637	1221	72	the	the	DT
18637	1221	73	general	general	JJ
18637	1221	74	Welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1221	75	,	,	,
18637	1221	76	and	and	CC
18637	1221	77	secure	secure	VB
18637	1221	78	the	the	DT
18637	1221	79	Blessings	Blessings	NNP
18637	1221	80	of	of	IN
18637	1221	81	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	1221	82	to	to	IN
18637	1221	83	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1221	84	and	and	CC
18637	1221	85	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1221	86	Posterity	Posterity	NNP
18637	1221	87	,	,	,
18637	1221	88	do	do	VB
18637	1221	89	ordain	ordain	VB
18637	1221	90	and	and	CC
18637	1221	91	establish	establish	VB
18637	1221	92	this	this	DT
18637	1221	93	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1221	94	for	for	IN
18637	1221	95	the	the	DT
18637	1221	96	United	United	NNP
18637	1221	97	States	States	NNP
18637	1221	98	of	of	IN
18637	1221	99	America	America	NNP
18637	1221	100	.	.	.
18637	1222	1	Purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1222	2	and	and	CC
18637	1222	3	Effect	effect	NN
18637	1222	4	of	of	IN
18637	1222	5	the	the	DT
18637	1222	6	Preamble	Preamble	NNP
18637	1222	7	Although	although	IN
18637	1222	8	the	the	DT
18637	1222	9	preamble	preamble	NN
18637	1222	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	1222	11	not	not	RB
18637	1222	12	a	a	DT
18637	1222	13	source	source	NN
18637	1222	14	of	of	IN
18637	1222	15	power	power	NN
18637	1222	16	for	for	IN
18637	1222	17	any	any	DT
18637	1222	18	department	department	NN
18637	1222	19	of	of	IN
18637	1222	20	the	the	DT
18637	1222	21	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1222	22	Government,[1	Government,[1	NNP
18637	1222	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1222	24	the	the	DT
18637	1222	25	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1222	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1222	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	1222	28	often	often	RB
18637	1222	29	referred	refer	VBN
18637	1222	30	to	to	IN
18637	1222	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1222	32	as	as	IN
18637	1222	33	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	1222	34	of	of	IN
18637	1222	35	the	the	DT
18637	1222	36	origin	origin	NN
18637	1222	37	,	,	,
18637	1222	38	scope	scope	NN
18637	1222	39	,	,	,
18637	1222	40	and	and	CC
18637	1222	41	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1222	42	of	of	IN
18637	1222	43	the	the	DT
18637	1222	44	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1222	45	.	.	.
18637	1223	1	"	"	``
18637	1223	2	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1223	3	true	true	JJ
18637	1223	4	office	office	NN
18637	1223	5	"	"	''
18637	1223	6	wrote	write	VBD
18637	1223	7	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
18637	1223	8	Story	Story	NNP
18637	1223	9	in	in	IN
18637	1223	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1223	11	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	1223	12	,	,	,
18637	1223	13	"	"	''
18637	1223	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	1223	15	to	to	TO
18637	1223	16	expound	expound	VB
18637	1223	17	the	the	DT
18637	1223	18	nature	nature	NN
18637	1223	19	and	and	CC
18637	1223	20	extent	extent	NN
18637	1223	21	and	and	CC
18637	1223	22	application	application	NN
18637	1223	23	of	of	IN
18637	1223	24	the	the	DT
18637	1223	25	powers	power	NNS
18637	1223	26	actually	actually	RB
18637	1223	27	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	1223	28	by	by	IN
18637	1223	29	the	the	DT
18637	1223	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1223	31	,	,	,
18637	1223	32	and	and	CC
18637	1223	33	not	not	RB
18637	1223	34	substantively	substantively	RB
18637	1223	35	to	to	TO
18637	1223	36	create	create	VB
18637	1223	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1223	38	.	.	.
18637	1224	1	For	for	IN
18637	1224	2	example	example	NN
18637	1224	3	,	,	,
18637	1224	4	the	the	DT
18637	1224	5	preamble	preamble	NN
18637	1224	6	declares	declare	VBZ
18637	1224	7	one	one	CD
18637	1224	8	object	object	NN
18637	1224	9	to	to	TO
18637	1224	10	be	be	VB
18637	1224	11	,	,	,
18637	1224	12	'	'	''
18637	1224	13	to	to	TO
18637	1224	14	provide	provide	VB
18637	1224	15	for	for	IN
18637	1224	16	the	the	DT
18637	1224	17	common	common	JJ
18637	1224	18	defense	defense	NN
18637	1224	19	.	.	.
18637	1224	20	'	'	''
18637	1225	1	No	no	DT
18637	1225	2	one	one	NN
18637	1225	3	can	can	MD
18637	1225	4	doubt	doubt	VB
18637	1225	5	that	that	IN
18637	1225	6	this	this	DT
18637	1225	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	1225	8	not	not	RB
18637	1225	9	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	1225	10	the	the	DT
18637	1225	11	powers	power	NNS
18637	1225	12	of	of	IN
18637	1225	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1225	14	to	to	TO
18637	1225	15	pass	pass	VB
18637	1225	16	any	any	DT
18637	1225	17	measures	measure	NNS
18637	1225	18	which	which	WDT
18637	1225	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1225	20	deem	deem	VBP
18637	1225	21	useful	useful	JJ
18637	1225	22	for	for	IN
18637	1225	23	the	the	DT
18637	1225	24	common	common	JJ
18637	1225	25	defence	defence	NN
18637	1225	26	.	.	.
18637	1226	1	But	but	CC
18637	1226	2	suppose	suppose	VB
18637	1226	3	the	the	DT
18637	1226	4	terms	term	NNS
18637	1226	5	of	of	IN
18637	1226	6	a	a	DT
18637	1226	7	given	give	VBN
18637	1226	8	power	power	NN
18637	1226	9	admit	admit	NN
18637	1226	10	of	of	IN
18637	1226	11	two	two	CD
18637	1226	12	constructions	construction	NNS
18637	1226	13	,	,	,
18637	1226	14	the	the	DT
18637	1226	15	one	one	CD
18637	1226	16	more	more	RBR
18637	1226	17	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	1226	18	,	,	,
18637	1226	19	the	the	DT
18637	1226	20	other	other	JJ
18637	1226	21	more	more	RBR
18637	1226	22	liberal	liberal	JJ
18637	1226	23	,	,	,
18637	1226	24	and	and	CC
18637	1226	25	each	each	DT
18637	1226	26	of	of	IN
18637	1226	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1226	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	1226	29	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	1226	30	with	with	IN
18637	1226	31	the	the	DT
18637	1226	32	words	word	NNS
18637	1226	33	,	,	,
18637	1226	34	but	but	CC
18637	1226	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	1226	36	,	,	,
18637	1226	37	and	and	CC
18637	1226	38	ought	ought	MD
18637	1226	39	to	to	TO
18637	1226	40	be	be	VB
18637	1226	41	,	,	,
18637	1226	42	governed	govern	VBN
18637	1226	43	by	by	IN
18637	1226	44	the	the	DT
18637	1226	45	intent	intent	NN
18637	1226	46	of	of	IN
18637	1226	47	the	the	DT
18637	1226	48	power	power	NN
18637	1226	49	;	;	:
18637	1226	50	if	if	IN
18637	1226	51	one	one	PRP
18637	1226	52	could	could	MD
18637	1226	53	promote	promote	VB
18637	1226	54	and	and	CC
18637	1226	55	the	the	DT
18637	1226	56	other	other	JJ
18637	1226	57	defeat	defeat	NN
18637	1226	58	the	the	DT
18637	1226	59	common	common	JJ
18637	1226	60	defence	defence	NN
18637	1226	61	,	,	,
18637	1226	62	ought	ought	MD
18637	1226	63	not	not	RB
18637	1226	64	the	the	DT
18637	1226	65	former	former	JJ
18637	1226	66	,	,	,
18637	1226	67	upon	upon	IN
18637	1226	68	the	the	DT
18637	1226	69	soundest	soundest	JJ
18637	1226	70	principles	principle	NNS
18637	1226	71	of	of	IN
18637	1226	72	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	1226	73	,	,	,
18637	1226	74	to	to	TO
18637	1226	75	be	be	VB
18637	1226	76	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	1226	77	?	?	.
18637	1227	1	"	"	``
18637	1227	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1227	3	2	2	CD
18637	1227	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1227	5	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	1227	6	,	,	,
18637	1227	7	the	the	DT
18637	1227	8	preamble	preamble	NN
18637	1227	9	bears	bear	VBZ
18637	1227	10	witness	witness	NN
18637	1227	11	to	to	IN
18637	1227	12	the	the	DT
18637	1227	13	fact	fact	NN
18637	1227	14	that	that	IN
18637	1227	15	the	the	DT
18637	1227	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1227	17	emanated	emanate	VBD
18637	1227	18	from	from	IN
18637	1227	19	the	the	DT
18637	1227	20	people	people	NNS
18637	1227	21	,	,	,
18637	1227	22	and	and	CC
18637	1227	23	was	be	VBD
18637	1227	24	not	not	RB
18637	1227	25	the	the	DT
18637	1227	26	act	act	NN
18637	1227	27	of	of	IN
18637	1227	28	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	1227	29	and	and	CC
18637	1227	30	independent	independent	JJ
18637	1227	31	States,[3	States,[3	NNP
18637	1227	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1227	33	and	and	CC
18637	1227	34	that	that	IN
18637	1227	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1227	36	was	be	VBD
18637	1227	37	made	make	VBN
18637	1227	38	for	for	IN
18637	1227	39	,	,	,
18637	1227	40	and	and	CC
18637	1227	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	1227	42	binding	bind	VBG
18637	1227	43	only	only	RB
18637	1227	44	in	in	RB
18637	1227	45	,	,	,
18637	1227	46	the	the	DT
18637	1227	47	United	United	NNP
18637	1227	48	States	States	NNP
18637	1227	49	of	of	IN
18637	1227	50	America	America	NNP
18637	1227	51	.	.	.
18637	1228	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1228	2	4	4	CD
18637	1228	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1228	4	In	in	IN
18637	1228	5	the	the	DT
18637	1228	6	Dred	Dred	NNP
18637	1228	7	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	1228	8	case,[5	case,[5	DT
18637	1228	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1228	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1228	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1228	12	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	1228	13	declared	declare	VBD
18637	1228	14	that	that	DT
18637	1228	15	:	:	:
18637	1228	16	"	"	``
18637	1228	17	The	the	DT
18637	1228	18	words	word	NNS
18637	1228	19	'	'	POS
18637	1228	20	people	people	NNS
18637	1228	21	of	of	IN
18637	1228	22	the	the	DT
18637	1228	23	United	United	NNP
18637	1228	24	States	States	NNP
18637	1228	25	'	'	POS
18637	1228	26	and	and	CC
18637	1228	27	'	'	``
18637	1228	28	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	1228	29	'	'	''
18637	1228	30	are	be	VBP
18637	1228	31	synonymous	synonymous	JJ
18637	1228	32	terms	term	NNS
18637	1228	33	,	,	,
18637	1228	34	and	and	CC
18637	1228	35	mean	mean	VB
18637	1228	36	the	the	DT
18637	1228	37	same	same	JJ
18637	1228	38	thing	thing	NN
18637	1228	39	.	.	.
18637	1229	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1229	2	both	both	DT
18637	1229	3	describe	describe	VBP
18637	1229	4	the	the	DT
18637	1229	5	political	political	JJ
18637	1229	6	body	body	NN
18637	1229	7	who	who	WP
18637	1229	8	,	,	,
18637	1229	9	according	accord	VBG
18637	1229	10	to	to	IN
18637	1229	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1229	12	republican	republican	JJ
18637	1229	13	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	1229	14	,	,	,
18637	1229	15	form	form	VB
18637	1229	16	the	the	DT
18637	1229	17	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	1229	18	,	,	,
18637	1229	19	and	and	CC
18637	1229	20	who	who	WP
18637	1229	21	hold	hold	VBP
18637	1229	22	the	the	DT
18637	1229	23	power	power	NN
18637	1229	24	and	and	CC
18637	1229	25	conduct	conduct	VB
18637	1229	26	the	the	DT
18637	1229	27	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1229	28	through	through	IN
18637	1229	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1229	30	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	1229	31	.	.	.
18637	1230	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1230	2	are	be	VBP
18637	1230	3	what	what	WP
18637	1230	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1230	5	familiarly	familiarly	RB
18637	1230	6	call	call	VBP
18637	1230	7	the	the	DT
18637	1230	8	'	'	``
18637	1230	9	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	1230	10	people	people	NNS
18637	1230	11	,	,	,
18637	1230	12	'	'	''
18637	1230	13	and	and	CC
18637	1230	14	every	every	DT
18637	1230	15	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	1230	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	1230	17	one	one	CD
18637	1230	18	of	of	IN
18637	1230	19	this	this	DT
18637	1230	20	people	people	NNS
18637	1230	21	,	,	,
18637	1230	22	and	and	CC
18637	1230	23	a	a	DT
18637	1230	24	constituent	constituent	NN
18637	1230	25	member	member	NN
18637	1230	26	of	of	IN
18637	1230	27	this	this	DT
18637	1230	28	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	1230	29	.	.	.
18637	1231	1	"	"	``
18637	1231	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1231	3	6	6	CD
18637	1231	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1231	5	Notes	note	NNS
18637	1231	6	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1231	7	1	1	CD
18637	1231	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1231	9	Jacobson	Jacobson	NNP
18637	1231	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1231	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	1231	12	_	_	NNP
18637	1231	13	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	1231	14	,	,	,
18637	1231	15	197	197	CD
18637	1231	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	1231	17	11	11	CD
18637	1231	18	,	,	,
18637	1231	19	22	22	CD
18637	1231	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1231	21	1905	1905	CD
18637	1231	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1231	23	.	.	.
18637	1232	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1232	2	2	2	CD
18637	1232	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1232	4	1	1	CD
18637	1232	5	Story	story	NN
18637	1232	6	,	,	,
18637	1232	7	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	1232	8	on	on	IN
18637	1232	9	the	the	DT
18637	1232	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1232	11	,	,	,
18637	1232	12	§	â§	NN
18637	1232	13	462	462	CD
18637	1232	14	.	.	.
18637	1233	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1233	2	3	3	LS
18637	1233	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1233	4	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	1233	5	_	_	NNP
18637	1233	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	1233	7	_	_	NNP
18637	1233	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1233	9	,	,	,
18637	1233	10	4	4	CD
18637	1233	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	1233	12	.	.	.
18637	1234	1	316	316	CD
18637	1234	2	,	,	,
18637	1234	3	403	403	CD
18637	1234	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1234	5	1819	1819	CD
18637	1234	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1234	7	;	;	:
18637	1234	8	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
18637	1234	9	_	_	NNP
18637	1234	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	1234	11	_	_	NNP
18637	1234	12	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	1234	13	,	,	,
18637	1234	14	2	2	CD
18637	1234	15	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	1234	16	.	.	.
18637	1235	1	419	419	CD
18637	1235	2	,	,	,
18637	1235	3	470	470	CD
18637	1235	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1235	5	1793	1793	CD
18637	1235	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1235	7	;	;	:
18637	1235	8	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	1235	9	_	_	NNP
18637	1235	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	1235	11	_	_	NNP
18637	1235	12	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	1235	13	,	,	,
18637	1235	14	Wheat	Wheat	NNP
18637	1235	15	.	.	.
18637	1236	1	304	304	CD
18637	1236	2	,	,	,
18637	1236	3	324	324	CD
18637	1236	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1236	5	1816	1816	CD
18637	1236	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1236	7	.	.	.
18637	1237	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1237	2	4	4	CD
18637	1237	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1237	4	Downes	Downes	NNPS
18637	1237	5	_	_	NNP
18637	1237	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	1237	7	_	_	NNP
18637	1237	8	Bidwell	Bidwell	NNP
18637	1237	9	,	,	,
18637	1237	10	182	182	CD
18637	1237	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	1237	12	244	244	CD
18637	1237	13	,	,	,
18637	1237	14	251	251	CD
18637	1237	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1237	16	1901	1901	CD
18637	1237	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1237	18	;	;	:
18637	1237	19	In	in	IN
18637	1237	20	re	re	NNP
18637	1237	21	Ross	Ross	NNP
18637	1237	22	,	,	,
18637	1237	23	140	140	CD
18637	1237	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	1237	25	453	453	CD
18637	1237	26	,	,	,
18637	1237	27	464	464	CD
18637	1237	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1237	29	1891	1891	CD
18637	1237	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1237	31	.	.	.
18637	1238	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1238	2	5	5	CD
18637	1238	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1238	4	19	19	CD
18637	1238	5	How	how	WRB
18637	1238	6	.	.	.
18637	1239	1	393	393	CD
18637	1239	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1239	3	1857	1857	CD
18637	1239	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1239	5	.	.	.
18637	1240	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1240	2	6	6	CD
18637	1240	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1240	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	1240	5	.	.	.
18637	1241	1	404	404	CD
18637	1241	2	.	.	.
18637	1242	1	ARTICLE	article	NN
18637	1242	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1242	3	LEGISLATIVE	LEGISLATIVE	NNP
18637	1242	4	DEPARTMENT	DEPARTMENT	NNP
18637	1242	5	Section	section	NN
18637	1242	6	1	1	CD
18637	1242	7	.	.	.
18637	1243	1	Nature	nature	NN
18637	1243	2	of	of	IN
18637	1243	3	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1243	4	power	power	NN
18637	1243	5	:	:	:
18637	1243	6	Page	Page	NNP
18637	1243	7	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	1243	8	of	of	IN
18637	1243	9	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	1243	10	powers	power	NNS
18637	1243	11	71	71	CD
18637	1243	12	Nondelegability	Nondelegability	NNP
18637	1243	13	of	of	IN
18637	1243	14	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1243	15	power	power	NN
18637	1243	16	73	73	CD
18637	1243	17	Origin	Origin	NNP
18637	1243	18	of	of	IN
18637	1243	19	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1243	20	73	73	CD
18637	1243	21	Functions	function	NNS
18637	1243	22	which	which	WDT
18637	1243	23	may	may	MD
18637	1243	24	be	be	VB
18637	1243	25	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	1243	26	74	74	CD
18637	1243	27	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1243	28	to	to	TO
18637	1243	29	supplement	supplement	VB
18637	1243	30	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	1243	31	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	1243	32	74	74	CD
18637	1243	33	Standards	Standards	NNPS
18637	1243	34	for	for	IN
18637	1243	35	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	1243	36	action	action	NN
18637	1243	37	75	75	CD
18637	1243	38	Rule	rule	NN
18637	1243	39	-	-	HYPH
18637	1243	40	making	make	VBG
18637	1243	41	power	power	NN
18637	1243	42	76	76	CD
18637	1243	43	Orders	order	NNS
18637	1243	44	directed	direct	VBN
18637	1243	45	to	to	IN
18637	1243	46	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1243	47	persons	person	NNS
18637	1243	48	77	77	CD
18637	1243	49	Delegation	delegation	NN
18637	1243	50	to	to	IN
18637	1243	51	private	private	JJ
18637	1243	52	persons	person	NNS
18637	1243	53	78	78	CD
18637	1243	54	Power	power	NN
18637	1243	55	to	to	TO
18637	1243	56	give	give	VB
18637	1243	57	effect	effect	NN
18637	1243	58	to	to	IN
18637	1243	59	contingent	contingent	JJ
18637	1243	60	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1243	61	79	79	CD
18637	1243	62	Modification	modification	NN
18637	1243	63	of	of	IN
18637	1243	64	tariff	tariff	NN
18637	1243	65	laws	law	NNS
18637	1243	66	79	79	CD
18637	1243	67	Arms	arm	NNS
18637	1243	68	embargo	embargo	NN
18637	1243	69	80	80	CD
18637	1243	70	Internal	internal	JJ
18637	1243	71	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	1243	72	80	80	CD
18637	1243	73	Emergency	emergency	NN
18637	1243	74	statutes	statute	VBZ
18637	1243	75	81	81	CD
18637	1243	76	Punishment	punishment	NN
18637	1243	77	of	of	IN
18637	1243	78	violations	violation	NNS
18637	1243	79	82	82	CD
18637	1243	80	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1243	81	investigations	investigation	NNS
18637	1243	82	82	82	CD
18637	1243	83	Investigations	investigation	NNS
18637	1243	84	in	in	IN
18637	1243	85	aid	aid	NN
18637	1243	86	of	of	IN
18637	1243	87	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1243	88	82	82	CD
18637	1243	89	Conduct	conduct	NN
18637	1243	90	of	of	IN
18637	1243	91	executive	executive	JJ
18637	1243	92	department	department	NN
18637	1243	93	82	82	CD
18637	1243	94	Private	private	JJ
18637	1243	95	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	1243	96	83	83	CD
18637	1243	97	Purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1243	98	of	of	IN
18637	1243	99	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	1243	100	84	84	CD
18637	1243	101	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1243	102	functions	function	NNS
18637	1243	103	85	85	CD
18637	1243	104	Sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	1243	105	of	of	IN
18637	1243	106	the	the	DT
18637	1243	107	investigatory	investigatory	JJ
18637	1243	108	power	power	NN
18637	1243	109	85	85	CD
18637	1243	110	Contempt	contempt	NN
18637	1243	111	85	85	CD
18637	1243	112	Criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	1243	113	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	1243	114	85	85	CD
18637	1243	115	Sections	section	NNS
18637	1243	116	2	2	CD
18637	1243	117	and	and	CC
18637	1243	118	3	3	CD
18637	1243	119	.	.	.
18637	1244	1	House	House	NNP
18637	1244	2	of	of	IN
18637	1244	3	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1244	4	and	and	CC
18637	1244	5	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1244	6	:	:	:
18637	1244	7	Qualifications	Qualifications	NNP
18637	1244	8	of	of	IN
18637	1244	9	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	1244	10	of	of	IN
18637	1244	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1244	12	87	87	CD
18637	1244	13	Right	right	JJ
18637	1244	14	to	to	TO
18637	1244	15	vote	vote	VB
18637	1244	16	for	for	IN
18637	1244	17	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1244	18	and	and	CC
18637	1244	19	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1244	20	protection	protection	NN
18637	1244	21	thereof	thereof	IN
18637	1244	22	87	87	CD
18637	1244	23	When	when	WRB
18637	1244	24	the	the	DT
18637	1244	25	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	1244	26	must	must	MD
18637	1244	27	be	be	VB
18637	1244	28	possessed	possess	VBN
18637	1244	29	88	88	CD
18637	1244	30	Enlargement	Enlargement	NNP
18637	1244	31	of	of	IN
18637	1244	32	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	1244	33	88	88	CD
18637	1244	34	Inability	Inability	NNP
18637	1244	35	of	of	IN
18637	1244	36	States	States	NNPS
18637	1244	37	to	to	TO
18637	1244	38	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	1244	39	89	89	CD
18637	1244	40	Census	Census	NNP
18637	1244	41	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	1244	42	90	90	CD
18637	1244	43	Section	section	NN
18637	1244	44	4	4	CD
18637	1244	45	.	.	.
18637	1245	1	Elections	election	NNS
18637	1245	2	and	and	CC
18637	1245	3	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	1245	4	:	:	:
18637	1245	5	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	1245	6	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1245	7	under	under	IN
18637	1245	8	this	this	DT
18637	1245	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	1245	10	92	92	CD
18637	1245	11	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	1245	12	defined	define	VBD
18637	1245	13	93	93	CD
18637	1245	14	Inequality	inequality	NN
18637	1245	15	of	of	IN
18637	1245	16	election	election	NN
18637	1245	17	districts	district	NNS
18637	1245	18	93	93	CD
18637	1245	19	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1245	20	protection	protection	NN
18637	1245	21	of	of	IN
18637	1245	22	the	the	DT
18637	1245	23	electoral	electoral	JJ
18637	1245	24	process	process	NN
18637	1245	25	94	94	CD
18637	1245	26	Section	section	NN
18637	1245	27	5	5	CD
18637	1245	28	.	.	.
18637	1246	1	Powers	power	NNS
18637	1246	2	and	and	CC
18637	1246	3	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1246	4	of	of	IN
18637	1246	5	the	the	DT
18637	1246	6	houses	house	NNS
18637	1246	7	:	:	:
18637	1246	8	Power	power	NN
18637	1246	9	to	to	TO
18637	1246	10	judge	judge	VB
18637	1246	11	elections	election	NNS
18637	1246	12	95	95	CD
18637	1246	13	Quorum	Quorum	NNP
18637	1246	14	to	to	TO
18637	1246	15	do	do	VB
18637	1246	16	business	business	NN
18637	1246	17	96	96	CD
18637	1246	18	Rules	rule	NNS
18637	1246	19	of	of	IN
18637	1246	20	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	1246	21	96	96	CD
18637	1246	22	Powers	power	NNS
18637	1246	23	of	of	IN
18637	1246	24	the	the	DT
18637	1246	25	houses	house	NNS
18637	1246	26	over	over	IN
18637	1246	27	members	member	NNS
18637	1246	28	97	97	CD
18637	1246	29	Duty	duty	NN
18637	1246	30	to	to	TO
18637	1246	31	keep	keep	VB
18637	1246	32	a	a	DT
18637	1246	33	journal	journal	NN
18637	1246	34	98	98	CD
18637	1246	35	Section	Section	NNP
18637	1246	36	6	6	CD
18637	1246	37	.	.	.
18637	1247	1	Compensation	compensation	NN
18637	1247	2	,	,	,
18637	1247	3	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	1247	4	,	,	,
18637	1247	5	and	and	CC
18637	1247	6	disabilities	disability	NNS
18637	1247	7	of	of	IN
18637	1247	8	Members	member	NNS
18637	1247	9	:	:	:
18637	1247	10	When	when	WRB
18637	1247	11	the	the	DT
18637	1247	12	pay	pay	NN
18637	1247	13	starts	start	VBZ
18637	1247	14	99	99	CD
18637	1247	15	Privilege	privilege	NN
18637	1247	16	from	from	IN
18637	1247	17	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	1247	18	99	99	CD
18637	1247	19	Privilege	privilege	NN
18637	1247	20	of	of	IN
18637	1247	21	speech	speech	NN
18637	1247	22	or	or	CC
18637	1247	23	debate	debate	NN
18637	1247	24	99	99	CD
18637	1247	25	Incompatible	incompatible	JJ
18637	1247	26	offices	office	NNS
18637	1247	27	101	101	CD
18637	1247	28	Section	Section	NNP
18637	1247	29	7	7	CD
18637	1247	30	.	.	.
18637	1248	1	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1248	2	process	process	NN
18637	1248	3	:	:	:
18637	1248	4	Revenue	revenue	NN
18637	1248	5	bills	bill	NNS
18637	1248	6	102	102	CD
18637	1248	7	Approval	approval	NN
18637	1248	8	by	by	IN
18637	1248	9	the	the	DT
18637	1248	10	President	President	NNP
18637	1248	11	103	103	CD
18637	1248	12	Veto	Veto	NNP
18637	1248	13	power	power	NN
18637	1248	14	103	103	CD
18637	1248	15	Presentation	presentation	NN
18637	1248	16	of	of	IN
18637	1248	17	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	1248	18	104	104	CD
18637	1248	19	Section	section	NN
18637	1248	20	8	8	CD
18637	1248	21	.	.	.
18637	1249	1	Powers	power	NNS
18637	1249	2	of	of	IN
18637	1249	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1249	4	:	:	:
18637	1249	5	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1249	6	1	1	CD
18637	1249	7	.	.	.
18637	1250	1	Taxing	tax	VBG
18637	1250	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	1250	3	spending	spend	VBG
18637	1250	4	power	power	NN
18637	1250	5	105	105	CD
18637	1250	6	Kinds	kind	NNS
18637	1250	7	of	of	IN
18637	1250	8	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1250	9	permitted	permit	VBD
18637	1250	10	105	105	CD
18637	1250	11	Decline	Decline	NNP
18637	1250	12	of	of	IN
18637	1250	13	forbidden	forbidden	JJ
18637	1250	14	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1250	15	matter	matter	NN
18637	1250	16	test	test	NN
18637	1250	17	105	105	CD
18637	1250	18	Rise	rise	NN
18637	1250	19	and	and	CC
18637	1250	20	fall	fall	NN
18637	1250	21	of	of	IN
18637	1250	22	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	1250	23	_	_	NNP
18637	1250	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	1250	25	_	_	NNP
18637	1250	26	Day	Day	NNP
18637	1250	27	106	106	CD
18637	1250	28	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	1250	29	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1250	30	of	of	IN
18637	1250	31	State	state	NN
18637	1250	32	interests	interest	NNS
18637	1250	33	106	106	CD
18637	1250	34	Immunity	immunity	NN
18637	1250	35	left	leave	VBN
18637	1250	36	to	to	IN
18637	1250	37	the	the	DT
18637	1250	38	States	States	NNP
18637	1250	39	108	108	CD
18637	1250	40	Conflicting	Conflicting	NNP
18637	1250	41	views	view	NNS
18637	1250	42	on	on	IN
18637	1250	43	the	the	DT
18637	1250	44	court	court	NN
18637	1250	45	108	108	CD
18637	1250	46	Rule	rule	NN
18637	1250	47	of	of	IN
18637	1250	48	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	1250	49	109	109	CD
18637	1250	50	Purposes	Purposes	NNPS
18637	1250	51	of	of	IN
18637	1250	52	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1250	53	110	110	CD
18637	1250	54	Regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1250	55	by	by	IN
18637	1250	56	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1250	57	110	110	CD
18637	1250	58	Extermination	extermination	NN
18637	1250	59	by	by	IN
18637	1250	60	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1250	61	110	110	CD
18637	1250	62	Protective	protective	JJ
18637	1250	63	tariff	tariff	NN
18637	1250	64	112	112	CD
18637	1250	65	Spending	spending	NN
18637	1250	66	for	for	IN
18637	1250	67	the	the	DT
18637	1250	68	general	general	JJ
18637	1250	69	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1250	70	112	112	CD
18637	1250	71	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	1250	72	_	_	NNP
18637	1250	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	1250	74	_	_	NNP
18637	1250	75	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	1250	76	113	113	CD
18637	1250	77	Triumph	Triumph	NNP
18637	1250	78	of	of	IN
18637	1250	79	Hamiltonian	hamiltonian	JJ
18637	1250	80	theory	theory	NN
18637	1250	81	113	113	CD
18637	1250	82	Security	Security	NNP
18637	1250	83	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1250	84	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	1250	85	,	,	,
18637	1250	86	The	the	DT
18637	1250	87	115	115	CD
18637	1250	88	Earmarked	Earmarked	NNP
18637	1250	89	funds	fund	NNS
18637	1250	90	116	116	CD
18637	1250	91	Conditional	conditional	JJ
18637	1250	92	grants	grant	NNS
18637	1250	93	-	-	HYPH
18637	1250	94	in	in	IN
18637	1250	95	-	-	HYPH
18637	1250	96	aid	aid	NN
18637	1250	97	116	116	CD
18637	1250	98	"	"	``
18637	1250	99	Debts	Debts	NNP
18637	1250	100	of	of	IN
18637	1250	101	the	the	DT
18637	1250	102	United	United	NNP
18637	1250	103	States	States	NNP
18637	1250	104	"	"	''
18637	1250	105	116	116	CD
18637	1250	106	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	1250	107	2	2	CD
18637	1250	108	.	.	.
18637	1251	1	Borrowing	borrowing	NN
18637	1251	2	power	power	NN
18637	1251	3	117	117	CD
18637	1251	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1251	5	3	3	CD
18637	1251	6	.	.	.
18637	1252	1	Power	power	NN
18637	1252	2	to	to	TO
18637	1252	3	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1252	4	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1252	5	and	and	CC
18637	1252	6	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1252	7	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	8	118	118	CD
18637	1252	9	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	1252	10	of	of	IN
18637	1252	11	the	the	DT
18637	1252	12	clause	clause	NN
18637	1252	13	118	118	CD
18637	1252	14	Definition	definition	NN
18637	1252	15	of	of	IN
18637	1252	16	terms	term	NNS
18637	1252	17	:	:	:
18637	1252	18	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNPS
18637	1252	19	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	1252	21	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	22	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	1252	23	118	118	CD
18637	1252	24	"	"	``
18637	1252	25	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1252	26	"	"	''
18637	1252	27	118	118	CD
18637	1252	28	"	"	``
18637	1252	29	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1252	30	"	"	''
18637	1252	31	today	today	NN
18637	1252	32	119	119	CD
18637	1252	33	"	"	``
18637	1252	34	Necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1252	35	and	and	CC
18637	1252	36	proper	proper	JJ
18637	1252	37	"	"	''
18637	1252	38	clause	clause	NN
18637	1252	39	121	121	CD
18637	1252	40	"	"	''
18637	1252	41	Among	among	IN
18637	1252	42	the	the	DT
18637	1252	43	several	several	JJ
18637	1252	44	States	state	NNS
18637	1252	45	"	"	``
18637	1252	46	121	121	CD
18637	1252	47	"	"	``
18637	1252	48	Regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1252	49	"	"	''
18637	1252	50	123	123	CD
18637	1252	51	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	1252	52	versus	versus	IN
18637	1252	53	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1252	54	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	55	123	123	CD
18637	1252	56	Instruments	Instruments	NNPS
18637	1252	57	of	of	IN
18637	1252	58	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	59	125	125	CD
18637	1252	60	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1252	61	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1252	62	of	of	IN
18637	1252	63	waterways	waterway	NNS
18637	1252	64	126	126	CD
18637	1252	65	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	1252	66	126	126	CD
18637	1252	67	Hydroelectric	Hydroelectric	NNP
18637	1252	68	power	power	NN
18637	1252	69	130	130	CD
18637	1252	70	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1252	71	'	'	POS
18637	1252	72	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	1252	73	over	over	IN
18637	1252	74	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1252	75	streams	stream	NNS
18637	1252	76	today	today	NN
18637	1252	77	131	131	CD
18637	1252	78	Purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	1252	79	for	for	IN
18637	1252	80	which	which	WDT
18637	1252	81	power	power	NN
18637	1252	82	may	may	MD
18637	1252	83	be	be	VB
18637	1252	84	generated	generate	VBN
18637	1252	85	131	131	CD
18637	1252	86	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1252	87	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1252	88	of	of	IN
18637	1252	89	land	land	NN
18637	1252	90	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1252	91	132	132	CD
18637	1252	92	Early	early	JJ
18637	1252	93	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	1252	94	:	:	:
18637	1252	95	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	1252	96	provision	provision	NN
18637	1252	97	for	for	IN
18637	1252	98	highways	highway	NNS
18637	1252	99	132	132	CD
18637	1252	100	Beginnings	Beginnings	NNPS
18637	1252	101	of	of	IN
18637	1252	102	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1252	103	railway	railway	NN
18637	1252	104	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1252	105	132	132	CD
18637	1252	106	Regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1252	107	of	of	IN
18637	1252	108	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1252	109	:	:	:
18637	1252	110	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	1252	111	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1252	112	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1252	113	133	133	CD
18637	1252	114	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	1252	115	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1252	116	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1252	117	today	today	NN
18637	1252	118	135	135	CD
18637	1252	119	Shreveport	Shreveport	NNP
18637	1252	120	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1252	121	135	135	CD
18637	1252	122	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1252	123	of	of	IN
18637	1252	124	1920	1920	CD
18637	1252	125	and	and	CC
18637	1252	126	State	State	NNP
18637	1252	127	railway	railway	NN
18637	1252	128	rate	rate	NN
18637	1252	129	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1252	130	136	136	CD
18637	1252	131	Regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1252	132	of	of	IN
18637	1252	133	other	other	JJ
18637	1252	134	agents	agent	NNS
18637	1252	135	of	of	IN
18637	1252	136	carriage	carriage	NN
18637	1252	137	and	and	CC
18637	1252	138	communication	communication	NN
18637	1252	139	137	137	CD
18637	1252	140	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	1252	141	of	of	IN
18637	1252	142	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1252	143	protective	protective	NN
18637	1252	144	of	of	IN
18637	1252	145	labor	labor	NN
18637	1252	146	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1252	147	in	in	IN
18637	1252	148	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1252	149	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1252	150	139	139	CD
18637	1252	151	Adair	Adair	NNP
18637	1252	152	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1252	153	141	141	CD
18637	1252	154	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	1252	155	Retirement	Retirement	NNP
18637	1252	156	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1252	157	142	142	CD
18637	1252	158	Bills	Bills	NNPS
18637	1252	159	of	of	IN
18637	1252	160	Lading	lade	VBG
18637	1252	161	:	:	:
18637	1252	162	Ferger	Ferger	NNP
18637	1252	163	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1252	164	143	143	CD
18637	1252	165	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1252	166	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1252	167	of	of	IN
18637	1252	168	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	169	as	as	IN
18637	1252	170	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	1252	171	144	144	CD
18637	1252	172	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	1252	173	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1252	174	:	:	:
18637	1252	175	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	1252	176	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	1252	177	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1252	178	144	144	CD
18637	1252	179	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	1252	180	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1252	181	revised	revise	VBD
18637	1252	182	146	146	CD
18637	1252	183	"	"	``
18637	1252	184	Current	Current	NNP
18637	1252	185	of	of	IN
18637	1252	186	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	187	"	"	''
18637	1252	188	concept	concept	NN
18637	1252	189	:	:	:
18637	1252	190	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	1252	191	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1252	192	147	147	CD
18637	1252	193	Danbury	Danbury	NNP
18637	1252	194	Hatters	Hatters	NNPS
18637	1252	195	Case	case	NN
18637	1252	196	149	149	CD
18637	1252	197	Stockyards	Stockyards	NNPS
18637	1252	198	and	and	CC
18637	1252	199	Grain	Grain	NNP
18637	1252	200	Futures	Futures	NNPS
18637	1252	201	Acts	act	VBZ
18637	1252	202	149	149	CD
18637	1252	203	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	1252	204	and	and	CC
18637	1252	205	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	1252	206	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1252	207	150	150	CD
18637	1252	208	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1252	209	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1252	210	of	of	IN
18637	1252	211	production	production	NN
18637	1252	212	and	and	CC
18637	1252	213	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	1252	214	relations	relation	NNS
18637	1252	215	152	152	CD
18637	1252	216	Antidepression	Antidepression	NNP
18637	1252	217	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1252	218	152	152	CD
18637	1252	219	National	National	NNP
18637	1252	220	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	1252	221	Recovery	Recovery	NNP
18637	1252	222	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1252	223	152	152	CD
18637	1252	224	Schechter	Schechter	NNP
18637	1252	225	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1252	226	152	152	CD
18637	1252	227	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	1252	228	Adjustment	Adjustment	NNP
18637	1252	229	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1252	230	153	153	CD
18637	1252	231	Bituminous	Bituminous	NNP
18637	1252	232	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	1252	233	Conservation	Conservation	NNP
18637	1252	234	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1252	235	153	153	CD
18637	1252	236	National	National	NNP
18637	1252	237	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	1252	238	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	1252	239	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1252	240	154	154	CD
18637	1252	241	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	1252	242	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	1252	243	Standards	Standards	NNP
18637	1252	244	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1252	245	:	:	:
18637	1252	246	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	1252	247	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1252	248	155	155	CD
18637	1252	249	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	1252	250	Marketing	Marketing	NNP
18637	1252	251	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	1252	252	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1252	253	159	159	CD
18637	1252	254	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	1252	255	of	of	IN
18637	1252	256	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1252	257	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	1252	258	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	259	160	160	CD
18637	1252	260	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	1252	261	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	262	;	;	:
18637	1252	263	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	1252	264	's	's	POS
18637	1252	265	embargo	embargo	NN
18637	1252	266	160	160	CD
18637	1252	267	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	1252	268	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	269	;	;	:
18637	1252	270	protective	protective	JJ
18637	1252	271	tariffs	tariff	NNS
18637	1252	272	162	162	CD
18637	1252	273	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	1252	274	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	275	;	;	,
18637	1252	276	banned	ban	VBN
18637	1252	277	articles	article	NNS
18637	1252	278	162	162	CD
18637	1252	279	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	1252	280	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	281	;	;	:
18637	1252	282	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	1252	283	of	of	IN
18637	1252	284	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1252	285	and	and	CC
18637	1252	286	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1252	287	163	163	CD
18637	1252	288	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	1252	289	of	of	IN
18637	1252	290	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1252	291	prohibitive	prohibitive	NN
18637	1252	292	of	of	IN
18637	1252	293	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	294	168	168	CD
18637	1252	295	Lottery	Lottery	NNP
18637	1252	296	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1252	297	169	169	CD
18637	1252	298	National	national	JJ
18637	1252	299	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
18637	1252	300	and	and	CC
18637	1252	301	State	State	NNP
18637	1252	302	police	police	NN
18637	1252	303	power	power	NN
18637	1252	304	169	169	CD
18637	1252	305	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	1252	306	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	307	v.	v.	IN
18637	1252	308	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	309	Dagenhart	Dagenhart	NNP
18637	1252	310	170	170	CD
18637	1252	311	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	1252	312	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	313	in	in	IN
18637	1252	314	stolen	steal	VBN
18637	1252	315	goods	good	NNS
18637	1252	316	banned	ban	VBD
18637	1252	317	171	171	CD
18637	1252	318	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	1252	319	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1252	320	172	172	CD
18637	1252	321	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1252	322	and	and	CC
18637	1252	323	the	the	DT
18637	1252	324	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1252	325	system	system	NN
18637	1252	326	173	173	CD
18637	1252	327	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1252	328	clause	clause	NN
18637	1252	329	as	as	IN
18637	1252	330	a	a	DT
18637	1252	331	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	1252	332	on	on	IN
18637	1252	333	State	State	NNP
18637	1252	334	power	power	NN
18637	1252	335	173	173	CD
18637	1252	336	Doctrinal	doctrinal	JJ
18637	1252	337	background	background	NN
18637	1252	338	173	173	CD
18637	1252	339	Doctrinal	doctrinal	JJ
18637	1252	340	background	background	NN
18637	1252	341	:	:	:
18637	1252	342	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	1252	343	's	's	POS
18637	1252	344	contribution	contribution	NN
18637	1252	345	175	175	CD
18637	1252	346	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	1252	347	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	348	v.	v.	IN
18637	1252	349	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	350	Board	Board	NNP
18637	1252	351	of	of	IN
18637	1252	352	Port	Port	NNP
18637	1252	353	Wardens	Wardens	NNP
18637	1252	354	175	175	CD
18637	1252	355	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1252	356	formulas	formula	NNS
18637	1252	357	176	176	CD
18637	1252	358	Taxing	tax	VBG
18637	1252	359	power	power	NN
18637	1252	360	of	of	IN
18637	1252	361	the	the	DT
18637	1252	362	State	State	NNP
18637	1252	363	and	and	CC
18637	1252	364	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1252	365	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	366	177	177	CD
18637	1252	367	Browne	Browne	NNP
18637	1252	368	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	369	v.	v.	IN
18637	1252	370	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	371	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1252	372	:	:	:
18637	1252	373	Original	original	JJ
18637	1252	374	package	package	NN
18637	1252	375	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1252	376	177	177	CD
18637	1252	377	State	state	NN
18637	1252	378	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1252	379	of	of	IN
18637	1252	380	the	the	DT
18637	1252	381	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1252	382	matter	matter	NN
18637	1252	383	of	of	IN
18637	1252	384	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1252	385	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1252	386	178	178	CD
18637	1252	387	General	General	NNP
18637	1252	388	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	1252	389	178	178	CD
18637	1252	390	State	State	NNP
18637	1252	391	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	1252	392	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	1252	393	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1252	394	179	179	CD
18637	1252	395	Goods	good	NNS
18637	1252	396	in	in	IN
18637	1252	397	transit	transit	NN
18637	1252	398	180	180	CD
18637	1252	399	State	state	NN
18637	1252	400	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1252	401	of	of	IN
18637	1252	402	manufacturing	manufacturing	NN
18637	1252	403	and	and	CC
18637	1252	404	mining	mining	NN
18637	1252	405	181	181	CD
18637	1252	406	Production	production	NN
18637	1252	407	for	for	IN
18637	1252	408	an	an	DT
18637	1252	409	established	established	JJ
18637	1252	410	market	market	NN
18637	1252	411	182	182	CD
18637	1252	412	Rejection	rejection	NN
18637	1252	413	of	of	IN
18637	1252	414	original	original	JJ
18637	1252	415	package	package	NN
18637	1252	416	concept	concept	NN
18637	1252	417	in	in	IN
18637	1252	418	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1252	419	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1252	420	182	182	CD
18637	1252	421	Inspection	Inspection	NNP
18637	1252	422	charges	charge	VBZ
18637	1252	423	183	183	CD
18637	1252	424	Local	local	JJ
18637	1252	425	sales	sale	NNS
18637	1252	426	:	:	:
18637	1252	427	Peddlers	peddler	NNS
18637	1252	428	184	184	CD
18637	1252	429	Stoppage	stoppage	NN
18637	1252	430	in	in	IN
18637	1252	431	transit	transit	NN
18637	1252	432	185	185	CD
18637	1252	433	Drummer	Drummer	NNP
18637	1252	434	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	1252	435	;	;	:
18637	1252	436	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	1252	437	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	438	v.	v.	IN
18637	1252	439	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	440	Shelby	Shelby	NNP
18637	1252	441	County	County	NNP
18637	1252	442	Taxing	Taxing	NNP
18637	1252	443	District	District	NNP
18637	1252	444	186	186	CD
18637	1252	445	Limitation	Limitation	NNP
18637	1252	446	of	of	IN
18637	1252	447	the	the	DT
18637	1252	448	Robbins	Robbins	NNPS
18637	1252	449	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1252	450	187	187	CD
18637	1252	451	Robbins	robbin	NNS
18637	1252	452	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1252	453	today	today	NN
18637	1252	454	189	189	CD
18637	1252	455	Depression	Depression	NNP
18637	1252	456	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	1252	457	:	:	:
18637	1252	458	Use	use	VB
18637	1252	459	taxes	tax	VBZ
18637	1252	460	189	189	CD
18637	1252	461	Depression	depression	NN
18637	1252	462	Cases	case	NNS
18637	1252	463	:	:	:
18637	1252	464	Sales	sale	NNS
18637	1252	465	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1252	466	190	190	CD
18637	1252	467	End	end	NN
18637	1252	468	of	of	IN
18637	1252	469	the	the	DT
18637	1252	470	Depression	Depression	NNP
18637	1252	471	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	1252	472	191	191	CD
18637	1252	473	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1252	474	of	of	IN
18637	1252	475	carriage	carriage	NN
18637	1252	476	of	of	IN
18637	1252	477	persons	person	NNS
18637	1252	478	192	192	CD
18637	1252	479	State	state	NN
18637	1252	480	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1252	481	of	of	IN
18637	1252	482	the	the	DT
18637	1252	483	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1252	484	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	485	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	1252	486	:	:	:
18637	1252	487	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	1252	488	Corporations	Corporations	NNP
18637	1252	489	193	193	CD
18637	1252	490	Doctrinal	doctrinal	JJ
18637	1252	491	history	history	NN
18637	1252	492	193	193	CD
18637	1252	493	License	license	NN
18637	1252	494	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1252	495	194	194	CD
18637	1252	496	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	1252	497	of	of	IN
18637	1252	498	Western	Western	NNP
18637	1252	499	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1252	500	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	1252	501	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	502	v.	v.	IN
18637	1252	503	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	504	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	1252	505	196	196	CD
18637	1252	506	Spread	Spread	NNP
18637	1252	507	of	of	IN
18637	1252	508	the	the	DT
18637	1252	509	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1252	510	196	196	CD
18637	1252	511	Status	Status	NNP
18637	1252	512	of	of	IN
18637	1252	513	the	the	DT
18637	1252	514	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1252	515	today	today	NN
18637	1252	516	197	197	CD
18637	1252	517	State	state	NN
18637	1252	518	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1252	519	of	of	IN
18637	1252	520	property	property	NN
18637	1252	521	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1252	522	in	in	IN
18637	1252	523	,	,	,
18637	1252	524	and	and	CC
18637	1252	525	of	of	IN
18637	1252	526	the	the	DT
18637	1252	527	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	1252	528	from	from	IN
18637	1252	529	,	,	,
18637	1252	530	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1252	531	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1252	532	198	198	CD
18637	1252	533	General	General	NNP
18637	1252	534	issue	issue	NN
18637	1252	535	198	198	CD
18637	1252	536	Development	Development	NNP
18637	1252	537	of	of	IN
18637	1252	538	the	the	DT
18637	1252	539	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	1252	540	rule	rule	NN
18637	1252	541	199	199	CD
18637	1252	542	Unit	Unit	NNP
18637	1252	543	rule	rule	VB
18637	1252	544	200	200	CD
18637	1252	545	Apportioned	apportioned	JJ
18637	1252	546	property	property	NN
18637	1252	547	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1252	548	201	201	CD
18637	1252	549	Apportioned	apportioned	JJ
18637	1252	550	gross	gross	JJ
18637	1252	551	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	1252	552	taxes	tax	VBZ
18637	1252	553	202	202	CD
18637	1252	554	Franchise	franchise	NN
18637	1252	555	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1252	556	202	202	CD
18637	1252	557	Gross	gross	JJ
18637	1252	558	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	1252	559	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1252	560	,	,	,
18637	1252	561	classes	class	NNS
18637	1252	562	of	of	IN
18637	1252	563	203	203	CD
18637	1252	564	Multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	1252	565	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1252	566	test	test	NN
18637	1252	567	204	204	CD
18637	1252	568	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	1252	569	cases	case	NNS
18637	1252	570	206	206	CD
18637	1252	571	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1252	572	on	on	IN
18637	1252	573	net	net	JJ
18637	1252	574	income	income	NN
18637	1252	575	208	208	CD
18637	1252	576	Miscellaneous	miscellaneous	JJ
18637	1252	577	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1252	578	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	1252	579	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1252	580	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	581	209	209	CD
18637	1252	582	Vessels	Vessels	NNP
18637	1252	583	209	209	CD
18637	1252	584	Airplanes	Airplanes	NNP
18637	1252	585	210	210	CD
18637	1252	586	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	1252	587	vehicles	vehicle	VBZ
18637	1252	588	211	211	CD
18637	1252	589	Public	public	JJ
18637	1252	590	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	1252	591	:	:	:
18637	1252	592	Regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	1252	593	charges	charge	NNS
18637	1252	594	213	213	CD
18637	1252	595	Dominance	dominance	NN
18637	1252	596	of	of	IN
18637	1252	597	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1252	598	214	214	CD
18637	1252	599	McCarran	McCarran	NNP
18637	1252	600	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1252	601	:	:	:
18637	1252	602	Regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1252	603	of	of	IN
18637	1252	604	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	1252	605	214	214	CD
18637	1252	606	Police	police	NN
18637	1252	607	power	power	NN
18637	1252	608	and	and	CC
18637	1252	609	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1252	610	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	611	215	215	CD
18637	1252	612	Origin	origin	NN
18637	1252	613	of	of	IN
18637	1252	614	police	police	NN
18637	1252	615	power	power	NN
18637	1252	616	215	215	CD
18637	1252	617	State	state	NN
18637	1252	618	curbs	curb	NNS
18637	1252	619	on	on	IN
18637	1252	620	entry	entry	NN
18637	1252	621	of	of	IN
18637	1252	622	foreigners	foreigner	NNS
18637	1252	623	216	216	CD
18637	1252	624	State	State	NNP
18637	1252	625	quarantine	quarantine	NN
18637	1252	626	laws	law	NNS
18637	1252	627	217	217	CD
18637	1252	628	State	state	NN
18637	1252	629	game	game	NN
18637	1252	630	protection	protection	NN
18637	1252	631	and	and	CC
18637	1252	632	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1252	633	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	634	217	217	CD
18637	1252	635	Police	Police	NNP
18637	1252	636	power	power	NN
18637	1252	637	and	and	CC
18637	1252	638	interstate	interstate	NN
18637	1252	639	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1252	640	217	217	CD
18637	1252	641	General	general	JJ
18637	1252	642	principles	principle	NNS
18637	1252	643	217	217	CD
18637	1252	644	State	state	NN
18637	1252	645	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1252	646	of	of	IN
18637	1252	647	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	1252	648	of	of	IN
18637	1252	649	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1252	650	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1252	651	220	220	CD
18637	1252	652	Railway	railway	NN
18637	1252	653	rate	rate	NN
18637	1252	654	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1252	655	220	220	CD
18637	1252	656	Adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	1252	657	service	service	NN
18637	1252	658	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1252	659	221	221	CD
18637	1252	660	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	1252	661	and	and	CC
18637	1252	662	other	other	JJ
18637	1252	663	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1252	664	221	221	CD
18637	1252	665	Invalid	Invalid	NNP
18637	1252	666	State	State	NNP
18637	1252	667	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1252	668	222	222	CD
18637	1252	669	State	state	NN
18637	1252	670	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1252	671	of	of	IN
18637	1252	672	length	length	NN
18637	1252	673	of	of	IN
18637	1252	674	trains	train	NNS
18637	1252	675	223	223	CD
18637	1252	676	Lesson	Lesson	NNP
18637	1252	677	of	of	IN
18637	1252	678	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	1252	679	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	1252	680	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	1252	681	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	682	v.	v.	IN
18637	1252	683	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	684	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	1252	685	225	225	CD
18637	1252	686	State	State	NNP
18637	1252	687	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1252	688	of	of	IN
18637	1252	689	motor	motor	NN
18637	1252	690	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	1252	691	:	:	:
18637	1252	692	Valid	Valid	NNP
18637	1252	693	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1252	694	226	226	CD
18637	1252	695	Invalid	Invalid	NNP
18637	1252	696	State	State	NNP
18637	1252	697	acts	act	VBZ
18637	1252	698	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	1252	699	motor	motor	NN
18637	1252	700	carriers	carrier	VBZ
18637	1252	701	227	227	CD
18637	1252	702	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	1252	703	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	1252	704	228	228	CD
18637	1252	705	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	1252	706	;	;	,
18637	1252	707	general	general	JJ
18637	1252	708	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1252	709	228	228	CD
18637	1252	710	Bridges	Bridges	NNPS
18637	1252	711	,	,	,
18637	1252	712	dams	dam	NNS
18637	1252	713	,	,	,
18637	1252	714	ferries	ferry	NNS
18637	1252	715	,	,	,
18637	1252	716	wharves	wharve	VBZ
18637	1252	717	230	230	CD
18637	1252	718	Ferries	ferry	NNS
18637	1252	719	231	231	CD
18637	1252	720	Telegraphs	Telegraphs	NNPS
18637	1252	721	and	and	CC
18637	1252	722	telephones	telephone	VBZ
18637	1252	723	231	231	CD
18637	1252	724	Gas	gas	NN
18637	1252	725	and	and	CC
18637	1252	726	electricity	electricity	NN
18637	1252	727	233	233	CD
18637	1252	728	Foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1252	729	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	1252	730	234	234	CD
18637	1252	731	Miscellaneous	miscellaneous	JJ
18637	1252	732	234	234	CD
18637	1252	733	Banks	Banks	NNPS
18637	1252	734	and	and	CC
18637	1252	735	banking	bank	VBG
18637	1252	736	234	234	CD
18637	1252	737	Brokers	Brokers	NNPS
18637	1252	738	235	235	CD
18637	1252	739	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1252	740	men	man	NNS
18637	1252	741	235	235	CD
18637	1252	742	Attachment	attachment	NN
18637	1252	743	and	and	CC
18637	1252	744	garnishment	garnishment	JJ
18637	1252	745	235	235	CD
18637	1252	746	Statutory	Statutory	NNP
18637	1252	747	liens	lien	VBZ
18637	1252	748	235	235	CD
18637	1252	749	Police	police	NN
18637	1252	750	power	power	NN
18637	1252	751	and	and	CC
18637	1252	752	the	the	DT
18637	1252	753	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1252	754	matter	matter	NN
18637	1252	755	of	of	IN
18637	1252	756	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	757	235	235	CD
18637	1252	758	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	1252	759	of	of	IN
18637	1252	760	the	the	DT
18637	1252	761	police	police	NN
18637	1252	762	power	power	NN
18637	1252	763	235	235	CD
18637	1252	764	Quarantine	Quarantine	NNP
18637	1252	765	laws	law	NNS
18637	1252	766	236	236	CD
18637	1252	767	State	state	NN
18637	1252	768	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	1252	769	laws	law	VBZ
18637	1252	770	237	237	CD
18637	1252	771	State	state	NN
18637	1252	772	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	1252	773	laws	law	NNS
18637	1252	774	:	:	:
18637	1252	775	The	the	DT
18637	1252	776	original	original	JJ
18637	1252	777	package	package	NN
18637	1252	778	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1252	779	238	238	CD
18637	1252	780	Oleomargarine	Oleomargarine	NNP
18637	1252	781	and	and	CC
18637	1252	782	cigarettes	cigarette	VBZ
18637	1252	783	239	239	CD
18637	1252	784	Demise	Demise	NNP
18637	1252	785	of	of	IN
18637	1252	786	the	the	DT
18637	1252	787	original	original	JJ
18637	1252	788	package	package	NN
18637	1252	789	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1252	790	240	240	CD
18637	1252	791	Curbs	curb	NNS
18637	1252	792	on	on	IN
18637	1252	793	the	the	DT
18637	1252	794	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1252	795	movement	movement	NN
18637	1252	796	of	of	IN
18637	1252	797	persons	person	NNS
18637	1252	798	241	241	CD
18637	1252	799	State	state	NN
18637	1252	800	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	1252	801	and	and	CC
18637	1252	802	embargo	embargo	NN
18637	1252	803	measures	measure	NNS
18637	1252	804	242	242	CD
18637	1252	805	State	state	NN
18637	1252	806	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	1252	807	and	and	CC
18637	1252	808	embargo	embargo	NN
18637	1252	809	measures	measure	NNS
18637	1252	810	:	:	:
18637	1252	811	The	the	DT
18637	1252	812	Milk	milk	NN
18637	1252	813	Cases	case	NNS
18637	1252	814	244	244	CD
18637	1252	815	State	state	NN
18637	1252	816	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	1252	817	and	and	CC
18637	1252	818	embargo	embargo	NN
18637	1252	819	measures	measure	NNS
18637	1252	820	:	:	:
18637	1252	821	The	the	DT
18637	1252	822	Shrimp	Shrimp	NNP
18637	1252	823	Cases	case	NNS
18637	1252	824	245	245	CD
18637	1252	825	Concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	1252	826	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1252	827	and	and	CC
18637	1252	828	State	state	NN
18637	1252	829	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1252	830	246	246	CD
18637	1252	831	General	General	NNP
18637	1252	832	issue	issue	NN
18637	1252	833	246	246	CD
18637	1252	834	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	1252	835	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1252	836	246	246	CD
18637	1252	837	Quarantine	quarantine	NN
18637	1252	838	Cases	case	NNS
18637	1252	839	248	248	CD
18637	1252	840	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	1252	841	cases	case	NNS
18637	1252	842	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	1252	843	State	State	NNP
18637	1252	844	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1252	845	249	249	CD
18637	1252	846	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	1252	847	cases	case	NNS
18637	1252	848	nullifying	nullify	VBG
18637	1252	849	State	state	NN
18637	1252	850	action	action	NN
18637	1252	851	250	250	CD
18637	1252	852	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1252	853	versus	versus	IN
18637	1252	854	State	state	NN
18637	1252	855	labor	labor	NN
18637	1252	856	laws	law	NNS
18637	1252	857	251	251	CD
18637	1252	858	Commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1252	859	with	with	IN
18637	1252	860	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	1252	861	Tribes	Tribes	NNP
18637	1252	862	252	252	CD
18637	1252	863	United	United	NNP
18637	1252	864	States	States	NNP
18637	1252	865	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	866	v.	v.	IN
18637	1252	867	_	_	NNP
18637	1252	868	Kagama	Kagama	NNP
18637	1252	869	252	252	CD
18637	1252	870	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1252	871	4	4	CD
18637	1252	872	.	.	.
18637	1253	1	Naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	1253	2	and	and	CC
18637	1253	3	bankruptcies	bankruptcie	VBZ
18637	1253	4	254	254	CD
18637	1253	5	Naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	1253	6	and	and	CC
18637	1253	7	citizenship	citizenship	VBP
18637	1253	8	254	254	CD
18637	1253	9	Categories	category	NNS
18637	1253	10	of	of	IN
18637	1253	11	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	1253	12	persons	person	NNS
18637	1253	13	254	254	CD
18637	1253	14	Who	who	WP
18637	1253	15	are	be	VBP
18637	1253	16	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	1253	17	for	for	IN
18637	1253	18	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	1253	19	255	255	CD
18637	1253	20	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	1253	21	of	of	IN
18637	1253	22	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	1253	23	256	256	CD
18637	1253	24	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	1253	25	of	of	IN
18637	1253	26	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	1253	27	persons	person	NNS
18637	1253	28	257	257	CD
18637	1253	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1253	30	'	'	POS
18637	1253	31	power	power	NN
18637	1253	32	exclusive	exclusive	NN
18637	1253	33	258	258	CD
18637	1253	34	Right	right	JJ
18637	1253	35	of	of	IN
18637	1253	36	expatriation	expatriation	NN
18637	1253	37	:	:	:
18637	1253	38	Loss	loss	NN
18637	1253	39	of	of	IN
18637	1253	40	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	1253	41	258	258	CD
18637	1253	42	Exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	1253	43	of	of	IN
18637	1253	44	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	1253	45	259	259	CD
18637	1253	46	Bankruptcy	Bankruptcy	NNP
18637	1253	47	262	262	CD
18637	1253	48	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	1253	49	who	who	WP
18637	1253	50	may	may	MD
18637	1253	51	be	be	VB
18637	1253	52	released	release	VBN
18637	1253	53	from	from	IN
18637	1253	54	debt	debt	NN
18637	1253	55	262	262	CD
18637	1253	56	Liberalization	liberalization	NN
18637	1253	57	of	of	IN
18637	1253	58	relief	relief	NN
18637	1253	59	granted	grant	VBD
18637	1253	60	262	262	CD
18637	1253	61	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1253	62	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	1253	63	on	on	IN
18637	1253	64	the	the	DT
18637	1253	65	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	1253	66	power	power	NN
18637	1253	67	263	263	CD
18637	1253	68	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1253	69	not	not	RB
18637	1253	70	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	1253	71	264	264	CD
18637	1253	72	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1253	73	status	status	NN
18637	1253	74	of	of	IN
18637	1253	75	State	state	NN
18637	1253	76	insolvency	insolvency	NN
18637	1253	77	laws	law	NNS
18637	1253	78	264	264	CD
18637	1253	79	Clauses	clause	NNS
18637	1253	80	5	5	CD
18637	1253	81	and	and	CC
18637	1253	82	6	6	CD
18637	1253	83	.	.	.
18637	1254	1	Fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	1254	2	and	and	CC
18637	1254	3	monetary	monetary	JJ
18637	1254	4	powers	power	NNS
18637	1254	5	of	of	IN
18637	1254	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1254	7	265	265	CD
18637	1254	8	Coinage	Coinage	NNP
18637	1254	9	,	,	,
18637	1254	10	weights	weight	NNS
18637	1254	11	,	,	,
18637	1254	12	and	and	CC
18637	1254	13	measures	measure	VBZ
18637	1254	14	265	265	CD
18637	1254	15	Punishment	punishment	NN
18637	1254	16	of	of	IN
18637	1254	17	counterfeiting	counterfeit	VBG
18637	1254	18	266	266	CD
18637	1254	19	Borrowing	Borrowing	NNP
18637	1254	20	power	power	NN
18637	1254	21	versus	versus	IN
18637	1254	22	the	the	DT
18637	1254	23	fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	1254	24	power	power	NN
18637	1254	25	266	266	CD
18637	1254	26	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	1254	27	7	7	CD
18637	1254	28	.	.	.
18637	1255	1	Postal	postal	JJ
18637	1255	2	power	power	NN
18637	1255	3	267	267	CD
18637	1255	4	"	"	``
18637	1255	5	Establish	establish	VB
18637	1255	6	"	"	''
18637	1255	7	267	267	CD
18637	1255	8	Powers	power	NNS
18637	1255	9	to	to	TO
18637	1255	10	protect	protect	VB
18637	1255	11	the	the	DT
18637	1255	12	mails	mail	NNS
18637	1255	13	268	268	CD
18637	1255	14	Antislavery	Antislavery	NNP
18637	1255	15	and	and	CC
18637	1255	16	the	the	DT
18637	1255	17	mails	mail	NNS
18637	1255	18	268	268	CD
18637	1255	19	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1255	20	to	to	TO
18637	1255	21	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	1255	22	harmful	harmful	JJ
18637	1255	23	use	use	NN
18637	1255	24	of	of	IN
18637	1255	25	the	the	DT
18637	1255	26	postal	postal	JJ
18637	1255	27	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	1255	28	268	268	CD
18637	1255	29	Exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	1255	30	power	power	NN
18637	1255	31	as	as	IN
18637	1255	32	an	an	DT
18637	1255	33	adjunct	adjunct	NN
18637	1255	34	to	to	IN
18637	1255	35	other	other	JJ
18637	1255	36	powers	power	NNS
18637	1255	37	269	269	CD
18637	1255	38	State	state	NN
18637	1255	39	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1255	40	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	1255	41	the	the	DT
18637	1255	42	mails	mail	NNS
18637	1255	43	270	270	CD
18637	1255	44	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	1255	45	8	8	CD
18637	1255	46	.	.	.
18637	1256	1	Copyrights	Copyrights	NNPS
18637	1256	2	and	and	CC
18637	1256	3	Patents	Patents	NNPS
18637	1256	4	271	271	CD
18637	1256	5	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	1256	6	of	of	IN
18637	1256	7	the	the	DT
18637	1256	8	power	power	NN
18637	1256	9	271	271	CD
18637	1256	10	Patentable	patentable	JJ
18637	1256	11	discoveries	discovery	NNS
18637	1256	12	271	271	CD
18637	1256	13	Procedure	procedure	NN
18637	1256	14	in	in	IN
18637	1256	15	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	1256	16	patents	patent	NNS
18637	1256	17	274	274	CD
18637	1256	18	Nature	nature	NN
18637	1256	19	and	and	CC
18637	1256	20	scope	scope	NN
18637	1256	21	of	of	IN
18637	1256	22	the	the	DT
18637	1256	23	right	right	JJ
18637	1256	24	secured	secure	VBN
18637	1256	25	274	274	CD
18637	1256	26	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1256	27	of	of	IN
18637	1256	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1256	29	over	over	IN
18637	1256	30	patent	patent	NN
18637	1256	31	rights	right	NNS
18637	1256	32	275	275	CD
18637	1256	33	State	State	NNP
18637	1256	34	power	power	NN
18637	1256	35	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	1256	36	patents	patent	NNS
18637	1256	37	and	and	CC
18637	1256	38	copyrights	copyright	VBZ
18637	1256	39	276	276	CD
18637	1256	40	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	1256	41	-	-	HYPH
18637	1256	42	marks	mark	NNS
18637	1256	43	and	and	CC
18637	1256	44	advertisements	advertisement	VBZ
18637	1256	45	276	276	CD
18637	1256	46	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	1256	47	9	9	CD
18637	1256	48	.	.	.
18637	1257	1	_	_	NNP
18637	1257	2	See	See	NNP
18637	1257	3	_	_	NNP
18637	1257	4	article	article	NN
18637	1257	5	III	III	NNP
18637	1257	6	277	277	CD
18637	1257	7	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	1257	8	10	10	CD
18637	1257	9	.	.	.
18637	1258	1	Piracies	piracy	NNS
18637	1258	2	and	and	CC
18637	1258	3	felonies	felonie	VBZ
18637	1258	4	277	277	CD
18637	1258	5	Origin	Origin	NNP
18637	1258	6	of	of	IN
18637	1258	7	the	the	DT
18637	1258	8	clause	clause	NN
18637	1258	9	277	277	CD
18637	1258	10	Definition	Definition	NNP
18637	1258	11	of	of	IN
18637	1258	12	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	1258	13	277	277	CD
18637	1258	14	Extraterritorial	extraterritorial	JJ
18637	1258	15	reach	reach	NN
18637	1258	16	of	of	IN
18637	1258	17	the	the	DT
18637	1258	18	power	power	NN
18637	1258	19	278	278	CD
18637	1258	20	Clauses	clause	NNS
18637	1258	21	11	11	CD
18637	1258	22	,	,	,
18637	1258	23	12	12	CD
18637	1258	24	,	,	,
18637	1258	25	13	13	CD
18637	1258	26	,	,	,
18637	1258	27	and	and	CC
18637	1258	28	14	14	CD
18637	1258	29	.	.	.
18637	1259	1	War	war	NN
18637	1259	2	:	:	:
18637	1259	3	Military	military	JJ
18637	1259	4	establishments	establishment	NNS
18637	1259	5	279	279	CD
18637	1259	6	War	war	NN
18637	1259	7	power	power	NN
18637	1259	8	279	279	CD
18637	1259	9	Source	source	NN
18637	1259	10	and	and	CC
18637	1259	11	scope	scope	VB
18637	1259	12	279	279	CD
18637	1259	13	An	an	DT
18637	1259	14	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	1259	15	power	power	NN
18637	1259	16	280	280	CD
18637	1259	17	A	a	DT
18637	1259	18	complexus	complexus	NN
18637	1259	19	of	of	IN
18637	1259	20	granted	grant	VBN
18637	1259	21	powers	power	NNS
18637	1259	22	281	281	CD
18637	1259	23	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
18637	1259	24	of	of	IN
18637	1259	25	war	war	NN
18637	1259	26	:	:	:
18637	1259	27	When	when	WRB
18637	1259	28	required	require	VBN
18637	1259	29	281	281	CD
18637	1259	30	Prize	Prize	NNP
18637	1259	31	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	1259	32	,	,	,
18637	1259	33	The	the	DT
18637	1259	34	,	,	,
18637	1259	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1259	36	1863	1863	CD
18637	1259	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1259	38	282	282	CD
18637	1259	39	Power	power	NN
18637	1259	40	to	to	TO
18637	1259	41	raise	raise	VB
18637	1259	42	and	and	CC
18637	1259	43	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	1259	44	armed	armed	JJ
18637	1259	45	forces	force	NNS
18637	1259	46	283	283	CD
18637	1259	47	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	1259	48	of	of	IN
18637	1259	49	specific	specific	JJ
18637	1259	50	grants	grant	NNS
18637	1259	51	283	283	CD
18637	1259	52	Time	time	NN
18637	1259	53	limit	limit	NN
18637	1259	54	on	on	IN
18637	1259	55	appropriations	appropriation	NNS
18637	1259	56	for	for	IN
18637	1259	57	the	the	DT
18637	1259	58	army	army	NN
18637	1259	59	283	283	CD
18637	1259	60	Establishment	Establishment	NNP
18637	1259	61	of	of	IN
18637	1259	62	the	the	DT
18637	1259	63	air	air	NN
18637	1259	64	force	force	NN
18637	1259	65	284	284	CD
18637	1259	66	Conscription	Conscription	NNP
18637	1259	67	284	284	CD
18637	1259	68	Care	Care	NNP
18637	1259	69	of	of	IN
18637	1259	70	the	the	DT
18637	1259	71	armed	armed	JJ
18637	1259	72	forces	force	NNS
18637	1259	73	285	285	CD
18637	1259	74	Trial	trial	NN
18637	1259	75	and	and	CC
18637	1259	76	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	1259	77	of	of	IN
18637	1259	78	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	1259	79	285	285	CD
18637	1259	80	War	war	NN
18637	1259	81	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1259	82	286	286	CD
18637	1259	83	Revolutionary	Revolutionary	NNP
18637	1259	84	war	war	NN
18637	1259	85	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1259	86	286	286	CD
18637	1259	87	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	1259	88	War	War	NNP
18637	1259	89	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1259	90	287	287	CD
18637	1259	91	World	World	NNP
18637	1259	92	War	War	NNP
18637	1259	93	I	I	NNP
18637	1259	94	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1259	95	287	287	CD
18637	1259	96	World	World	NNP
18637	1259	97	War	War	NNP
18637	1259	98	II	II	NNP
18637	1259	99	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1259	100	288	288	CD
18637	1259	101	Mobilization	mobilization	NN
18637	1259	102	of	of	IN
18637	1259	103	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	1259	104	resources	resource	NNS
18637	1259	105	288	288	CD
18637	1259	106	Delegation	delegation	NN
18637	1259	107	of	of	IN
18637	1259	108	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1259	109	power	power	NN
18637	1259	110	in	in	IN
18637	1259	111	wartime	wartime	JJ
18637	1259	112	289	289	CD
18637	1259	113	Mergence	mergence	RB
18637	1259	114	of	of	IN
18637	1259	115	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1259	116	and	and	CC
18637	1259	117	executive	executive	JJ
18637	1259	118	in	in	IN
18637	1259	119	wartime	wartime	JJ
18637	1259	120	290	290	CD
18637	1259	121	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	1259	122	of	of	IN
18637	1259	123	Lichter	Lichter	NNP
18637	1259	124	_	_	NNP
18637	1259	125	v.	v.	IN
18637	1259	126	_	_	NNP
18637	1259	127	United	United	NNP
18637	1259	128	States	States	NNP
18637	1259	129	290	290	CD
18637	1259	130	War	War	NNP
18637	1259	131	powers	power	NNS
18637	1259	132	in	in	IN
18637	1259	133	time	time	NN
18637	1259	134	of	of	IN
18637	1259	135	peace	peace	NN
18637	1259	136	291	291	CD
18637	1259	137	Atomic	Atomic	NNP
18637	1259	138	Energy	Energy	NNP
18637	1259	139	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1259	140	292	292	CD
18637	1259	141	Postwar	postwar	JJ
18637	1259	142	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1259	143	292	292	CD
18637	1259	144	Private	private	JJ
18637	1259	145	rights	right	NNS
18637	1259	146	in	in	IN
18637	1259	147	wartime	wartime	JJ
18637	1259	148	293	293	CD
18637	1259	149	Enemy	Enemy	NNP
18637	1259	150	country	country	NN
18637	1259	151	293	293	CD
18637	1259	152	Theatre	Theatre	NNP
18637	1259	153	of	of	IN
18637	1259	154	military	military	JJ
18637	1259	155	operations	operation	NNS
18637	1259	156	294	294	CD
18637	1259	157	Enemy	Enemy	NNP
18637	1259	158	property	property	NN
18637	1259	159	294	294	CD
18637	1259	160	Prizes	Prizes	NNPS
18637	1259	161	of	of	IN
18637	1259	162	war	war	NN
18637	1259	163	295	295	CD
18637	1259	164	Police	Police	NNS
18637	1259	165	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1259	166	:	:	:
18637	1259	167	Rent	rent	VB
18637	1259	168	control	control	NN
18637	1259	169	296	296	CD
18637	1259	170	Personal	personal	JJ
18637	1259	171	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	1259	172	in	in	IN
18637	1259	173	wartime	wartime	JJ
18637	1259	174	297	297	CD
18637	1259	175	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	1259	176	enemies	enemie	VBZ
18637	1259	177	297	297	CD
18637	1259	178	Eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	1259	179	domain	domain	NN
18637	1259	180	298	298	CD
18637	1259	181	Clauses	clause	NNS
18637	1259	182	15	15	CD
18637	1259	183	and	and	CC
18637	1259	184	16	16	CD
18637	1259	185	.	.	.
18637	1260	1	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	1260	2	299	299	CD
18637	1260	3	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	1260	4	clauses	clause	VBZ
18637	1260	5	299	299	CD
18637	1260	6	Calling	call	VBG
18637	1260	7	out	out	RP
18637	1260	8	the	the	DT
18637	1260	9	militia	militia	NN
18637	1260	10	299	299	CD
18637	1260	11	Regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1260	12	of	of	IN
18637	1260	13	the	the	DT
18637	1260	14	militia	militia	NN
18637	1260	15	299	299	CD
18637	1260	16	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	1260	17	17	17	CD
18637	1260	18	.	.	.
18637	1261	1	Seat	seat	NN
18637	1261	2	of	of	IN
18637	1261	3	government	government	NN
18637	1261	4	,	,	,
18637	1261	5	etc	etc	FW
18637	1261	6	.	.	.
18637	1262	1	300	300	CD
18637	1262	2	Seat	seat	NN
18637	1262	3	of	of	IN
18637	1262	4	government	government	NN
18637	1262	5	300	300	CD
18637	1262	6	Nature	nature	NN
18637	1262	7	and	and	CC
18637	1262	8	extent	extent	NN
18637	1262	9	of	of	IN
18637	1262	10	rights	right	NNS
18637	1262	11	ceded	cede	VBN
18637	1262	12	to	to	IN
18637	1262	13	United	United	NNP
18637	1262	14	States	States	NNP
18637	1262	15	301	301	CD
18637	1262	16	Retrocession	Retrocession	NNP
18637	1262	17	of	of	IN
18637	1262	18	Alexandria	Alexandria	NNP
18637	1262	19	county	county	NN
18637	1262	20	301	301	CD
18637	1262	21	Continuance	continuance	NN
18637	1262	22	of	of	IN
18637	1262	23	State	state	NN
18637	1262	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	1262	25	302	302	CD
18637	1262	26	Status	status	NN
18637	1262	27	of	of	IN
18637	1262	28	the	the	DT
18637	1262	29	district	district	NN
18637	1262	30	today	today	NN
18637	1262	31	302	302	CD
18637	1262	32	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1262	33	power	power	NN
18637	1262	34	over	over	IN
18637	1262	35	the	the	DT
18637	1262	36	district	district	NN
18637	1262	37	303	303	CD
18637	1262	38	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	1262	39	in	in	IN
18637	1262	40	the	the	DT
18637	1262	41	district	district	NN
18637	1262	42	303	303	CD
18637	1262	43	Delegation	Delegation	NNP
18637	1262	44	of	of	IN
18637	1262	45	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1262	46	power	power	NN
18637	1262	47	to	to	IN
18637	1262	48	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	1262	49	officers	officer	NNS
18637	1262	50	304	304	CD
18637	1262	51	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	1262	52	of	of	IN
18637	1262	53	the	the	DT
18637	1262	54	district	district	NN
18637	1262	55	304	304	CD
18637	1262	56	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	1262	57	over	over	IN
18637	1262	58	places	place	NNS
18637	1262	59	purchased	purchase	VBD
18637	1262	60	305	305	CD
18637	1262	61	"	"	``
18637	1262	62	Places	Places	NNPS
18637	1262	63	"	"	''
18637	1262	64	305	305	CD
18637	1262	65	Duration	duration	NN
18637	1262	66	of	of	IN
18637	1262	67	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1262	68	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	1262	69	305	305	CD
18637	1262	70	Reservation	Reservation	NNP
18637	1262	71	of	of	IN
18637	1262	72	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	1262	73	by	by	IN
18637	1262	74	States	States	NNP
18637	1262	75	306	306	CD
18637	1262	76	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	1262	77	18	18	CD
18637	1262	78	.	.	.
18637	1263	1	"	"	``
18637	1263	2	Necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1263	3	and	and	CC
18637	1263	4	proper	proper	JJ
18637	1263	5	"	"	''
18637	1263	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	1263	7	307	307	CD
18637	1263	8	Coefficient	Coefficient	NNP
18637	1263	9	or	or	CC
18637	1263	10	elastic	elastic	JJ
18637	1263	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	1263	12	307	307	CD
18637	1263	13	Scope	scope	NN
18637	1263	14	of	of	IN
18637	1263	15	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	1263	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	1263	17	307	307	CD
18637	1263	18	Operation	Operation	NNP
18637	1263	19	of	of	IN
18637	1263	20	coefficient	coefficient	NNP
18637	1263	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	1263	22	308	308	CD
18637	1263	23	Definition	definition	NN
18637	1263	24	and	and	CC
18637	1263	25	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	1263	26	of	of	IN
18637	1263	27	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	1263	28	308	308	CD
18637	1263	29	Chartering	charter	VBG
18637	1263	30	of	of	IN
18637	1263	31	banks	bank	NNS
18637	1263	32	309	309	CD
18637	1263	33	Currency	Currency	NNP
18637	1263	34	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1263	35	309	309	CD
18637	1263	36	Power	power	NN
18637	1263	37	to	to	TO
18637	1263	38	charter	charter	VB
18637	1263	39	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	1263	40	310	310	CD
18637	1263	41	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	1263	42	and	and	CC
18637	1263	43	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1263	44	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	1263	45	310	310	CD
18637	1263	46	Special	special	JJ
18637	1263	47	acts	act	NNS
18637	1263	48	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	1263	49	claims	claim	NNS
18637	1263	50	311	311	CD
18637	1263	51	Maritime	Maritime	NNP
18637	1263	52	law	law	NN
18637	1263	53	311	311	CD
18637	1263	54	Section	section	NN
18637	1263	55	9	9	CD
18637	1263	56	.	.	.
18637	1264	1	Powers	power	NNS
18637	1264	2	denied	deny	VBD
18637	1264	3	to	to	IN
18637	1264	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1264	5	312	312	CD
18637	1264	6	General	general	JJ
18637	1264	7	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1264	8	of	of	IN
18637	1264	9	the	the	DT
18637	1264	10	section	section	NN
18637	1264	11	312	312	CD
18637	1264	12	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1264	13	1	1	CD
18637	1264	14	.	.	.
18637	1265	1	Importation	importation	NN
18637	1265	2	of	of	IN
18637	1265	3	slaves	slave	NNS
18637	1265	4	312	312	CD
18637	1265	5	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1265	6	2	2	CD
18637	1265	7	.	.	.
18637	1266	1	Suspension	suspension	NN
18637	1266	2	of	of	IN
18637	1266	3	the	the	DT
18637	1266	4	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	1266	5	of	of	IN
18637	1266	6	the	the	DT
18637	1266	7	writ	writ	NNP
18637	1266	8	of	of	IN
18637	1266	9	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	1266	10	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	1266	11	312	312	CD
18637	1266	12	Habeas	Habeas	NNP
18637	1266	13	corpus	corpus	NN
18637	1266	14	312	312	CD
18637	1266	15	Purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1266	16	of	of	IN
18637	1266	17	the	the	DT
18637	1266	18	writ	writ	VBN
18637	1266	19	312	312	CD
18637	1266	20	Errors	Errors	NNPS
18637	1266	21	which	which	WDT
18637	1266	22	may	may	MD
18637	1266	23	be	be	VB
18637	1266	24	corrected	correct	VBN
18637	1266	25	on	on	IN
18637	1266	26	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	1266	27	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	1266	28	313	313	CD
18637	1266	29	Habeas	Habeas	NNP
18637	1266	30	corpus	corpus	NN
18637	1266	31	not	not	RB
18637	1266	32	a	a	DT
18637	1266	33	substitute	substitute	NN
18637	1266	34	for	for	IN
18637	1266	35	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	1266	36	314	314	CD
18637	1266	37	Issuance	Issuance	NNP
18637	1266	38	of	of	IN
18637	1266	39	the	the	DT
18637	1266	40	writ	writ	VBN
18637	1266	41	314	314	CD
18637	1266	42	Suspension	suspension	NN
18637	1266	43	of	of	IN
18637	1266	44	the	the	DT
18637	1266	45	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	1266	46	315	315	CD
18637	1266	47	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	1266	48	3	3	CD
18637	1266	49	.	.	.
18637	1267	1	Attainder	Attainder	NNP
18637	1267	2	and	and	CC
18637	1267	3	ex	ex	FW
18637	1267	4	post	post	FW
18637	1267	5	facto	facto	FW
18637	1267	6	laws	law	NNS
18637	1267	7	315	315	CD
18637	1267	8	Bills	bill	NNS
18637	1267	9	of	of	IN
18637	1267	10	attainder	attainder	NN
18637	1267	11	315	315	CD
18637	1267	12	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	1267	13	post	post	NN
18637	1267	14	facto	facto	FW
18637	1267	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	1267	16	316	316	CD
18637	1267	17	Definition	definition	NN
18637	1267	18	316	316	CD
18637	1267	19	What	what	WP
18637	1267	20	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	1267	21	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	1267	22	317	317	CD
18637	1267	23	Changes	change	NNS
18637	1267	24	in	in	IN
18637	1267	25	place	place	NN
18637	1267	26	or	or	CC
18637	1267	27	mode	mode	NN
18637	1267	28	of	of	IN
18637	1267	29	trial	trial	NN
18637	1267	30	317	317	CD
18637	1267	31	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	1267	32	4	4	CD
18637	1267	33	.	.	.
18637	1268	1	Capitation	capitation	NN
18637	1268	2	and	and	CC
18637	1268	3	direct	direct	JJ
18637	1268	4	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1268	5	317	317	CD
18637	1268	6	Direct	direct	JJ
18637	1268	7	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1268	8	317	317	CD
18637	1268	9	The	the	DT
18637	1268	10	Hylton	Hylton	NNP
18637	1268	11	case	case	NN
18637	1268	12	317	317	CD
18637	1268	13	From	from	IN
18637	1268	14	the	the	DT
18637	1268	15	Hylton	Hylton	NNP
18637	1268	16	to	to	IN
18637	1268	17	the	the	DT
18637	1268	18	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	1268	19	case	case	NN
18637	1268	20	318	318	CD
18637	1268	21	Restriction	restriction	NN
18637	1268	22	of	of	IN
18637	1268	23	the	the	DT
18637	1268	24	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	1268	25	decision	decision	NN
18637	1268	26	319	319	CD
18637	1268	27	Miscellaneous	Miscellaneous	NNP
18637	1268	28	321	321	CD
18637	1268	29	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	1268	30	5	5	CD
18637	1268	31	.	.	.
18637	1269	1	Export	export	NN
18637	1269	2	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1269	3	321	321	CD
18637	1269	4	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1269	5	on	on	IN
18637	1269	6	exports	export	NNS
18637	1269	7	321	321	CD
18637	1269	8	Stamp	stamp	NN
18637	1269	9	taxes	tax	VBZ
18637	1269	10	322	322	CD
18637	1269	11	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1269	12	6	6	CD
18637	1269	13	.	.	.
18637	1270	1	"	"	``
18637	1270	2	No	no	DT
18637	1270	3	preference	preference	NN
18637	1270	4	"	"	''
18637	1270	5	clause	clause	NN
18637	1270	6	322	322	CD
18637	1270	7	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1270	8	7	7	CD
18637	1270	9	.	.	.
18637	1271	1	Appropriations	appropriation	NNS
18637	1271	2	and	and	CC
18637	1271	3	accounting	accounting	NN
18637	1271	4	of	of	IN
18637	1271	5	public	public	JJ
18637	1271	6	mon	mon	NNP
18637	1271	7	323	323	NNP
18637	1271	8	Appropriations	Appropriations	NNP
18637	1271	9	323	323	NNP
18637	1271	10	Payment	Payment	NNP
18637	1271	11	of	of	IN
18637	1271	12	claims	claim	VBZ
18637	1271	13	324	324	CD
18637	1271	14	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	1271	15	8	8	CD
18637	1271	16	.	.	.
18637	1272	1	Titles	title	NNS
18637	1272	2	of	of	IN
18637	1272	3	nobility	nobility	NN
18637	1272	4	and	and	CC
18637	1272	5	gifts	gift	NNS
18637	1272	6	from	from	IN
18637	1272	7	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1272	8	States	States	NNP
18637	1272	9	324	324	NNP
18637	1272	10	Section	Section	NNP
18637	1272	11	10	10	CD
18637	1272	12	.	.	.
18637	1273	1	Powers	power	NNS
18637	1273	2	denied	deny	VBD
18637	1273	3	to	to	IN
18637	1273	4	the	the	DT
18637	1273	5	States	States	NNP
18637	1273	6	325	325	CD
18637	1273	7	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	1273	8	1	1	CD
18637	1273	9	.	.	.
18637	1274	1	Not	not	RB
18637	1274	2	to	to	TO
18637	1274	3	make	make	VB
18637	1274	4	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	1274	5	,	,	,
18637	1274	6	coin	coin	VB
18637	1274	7	money	money	NN
18637	1274	8	,	,	,
18637	1274	9	pass	pass	VB
18637	1274	10	ex	ex	FW
18637	1274	11	post	post	FW
18637	1274	12	facto	facto	JJ
18637	1274	13	laws	law	NNS
18637	1274	14	,	,	,
18637	1274	15	impair	impair	JJ
18637	1274	16	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	1274	17	,	,	,
18637	1274	18	etc	etc	FW
18637	1274	19	.	.	.
18637	1275	1	325	325	CD
18637	1275	2	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	1275	3	,	,	,
18637	1275	4	alliances	alliance	NNS
18637	1275	5	,	,	,
18637	1275	6	or	or	CC
18637	1275	7	confederations	confederation	NNS
18637	1275	8	325	325	CD
18637	1275	9	Bills	bill	NNS
18637	1275	10	of	of	IN
18637	1275	11	credit	credit	NN
18637	1275	12	326	326	CD
18637	1275	13	Legal	legal	JJ
18637	1275	14	tender	tender	NN
18637	1275	15	326	326	CD
18637	1275	16	Bills	bill	NNS
18637	1275	17	of	of	IN
18637	1275	18	attainder	attainder	NN
18637	1275	19	326	326	CD
18637	1275	20	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	1275	21	post	post	FW
18637	1275	22	facto	facto	FW
18637	1275	23	laws	law	NNS
18637	1275	24	327	327	CD
18637	1275	25	Scope	scope	NN
18637	1275	26	of	of	IN
18637	1275	27	provision	provision	NN
18637	1275	28	327	327	CD
18637	1275	29	Denial	denial	NN
18637	1275	30	of	of	IN
18637	1275	31	future	future	JJ
18637	1275	32	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	1275	33	to	to	IN
18637	1275	34	past	past	JJ
18637	1275	35	offenders	offender	NNS
18637	1275	36	327	327	CD
18637	1275	37	Changes	change	NNS
18637	1275	38	in	in	IN
18637	1275	39	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	1275	40	328	328	CD
18637	1275	41	Changes	Changes	NNPS
18637	1275	42	in	in	IN
18637	1275	43	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	1275	44	328	328	CD
18637	1275	45	Obligation	Obligation	NNP
18637	1275	46	of	of	IN
18637	1275	47	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	1275	48	329	329	CD
18637	1275	49	Definition	definition	NN
18637	1275	50	of	of	IN
18637	1275	51	terms	term	NNS
18637	1275	52	329	329	CD
18637	1275	53	"	"	``
18637	1275	54	Law	Law	NNP
18637	1275	55	"	"	''
18637	1275	56	329	329	CD
18637	1275	57	Status	status	NN
18637	1275	58	of	of	IN
18637	1275	59	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1275	60	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	1275	61	329	329	CD
18637	1275	62	"	"	``
18637	1275	63	Obligation	Obligation	NNP
18637	1275	64	"	"	''
18637	1275	65	332	332	CD
18637	1275	66	"	"	``
18637	1275	67	Impair	Impair	NNP
18637	1275	68	"	"	''
18637	1275	69	332	332	CD
18637	1275	70	"	"	''
18637	1275	71	Contracts	contract	NNS
18637	1275	72	,	,	,
18637	1275	73	"	"	''
18637	1275	74	extended	extended	JJ
18637	1275	75	to	to	TO
18637	1275	76	cover	cover	VB
18637	1275	77	public	public	JJ
18637	1275	78	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	1275	79	332	332	CD
18637	1275	80	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	1275	81	_	_	NNP
18637	1275	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	1275	83	_	_	NNP
18637	1275	84	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	1275	85	335	335	NNP
18637	1275	86	New	New	NNP
18637	1275	87	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1275	88	_	_	NNP
18637	1275	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	1275	90	_	_	NNP
18637	1275	91	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	1275	92	336	336	CD
18637	1275	93	Corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	1275	94	charters	charter	NNS
18637	1275	95	;	;	:
18637	1275	96	Different	different	JJ
18637	1275	97	ways	way	NNS
18637	1275	98	of	of	IN
18637	1275	99	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	1275	100	336	336	CD
18637	1275	101	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	1275	102	College	College	NNP
18637	1275	103	case	case	NN
18637	1275	104	338	338	CD
18637	1275	105	Classes	class	NNS
18637	1275	106	of	of	IN
18637	1275	107	cases	case	NNS
18637	1275	108	under	under	IN
18637	1275	109	the	the	DT
18637	1275	110	clause	clause	NN
18637	1275	111	339	339	CD
18637	1275	112	Public	public	JJ
18637	1275	113	grants	grant	NNS
18637	1275	114	339	339	CD
18637	1275	115	Municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	1275	116	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	1275	117	339	339	CD
18637	1275	118	Public	public	JJ
18637	1275	119	offices	office	NNS
18637	1275	120	340	340	CD
18637	1275	121	Revocable	revocable	JJ
18637	1275	122	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	1275	123	versus	versus	IN
18637	1275	124	"	"	``
18637	1275	125	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	1275	126	"	"	''
18637	1275	127	:	:	:
18637	1275	128	Tax	tax	NN
18637	1275	129	exemptions	exemption	NNS
18637	1275	130	341	341	CD
18637	1275	131	Vested	vested	JJ
18637	1275	132	rights	right	NNS
18637	1275	133	343	343	CD
18637	1275	134	Reservation	reservation	NN
18637	1275	135	of	of	IN
18637	1275	136	the	the	DT
18637	1275	137	right	right	NN
18637	1275	138	to	to	TO
18637	1275	139	alter	alter	VB
18637	1275	140	and	and	CC
18637	1275	141	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	1275	142	343	343	CD
18637	1275	143	Right	right	NN
18637	1275	144	to	to	TO
18637	1275	145	reserve	reserve	VB
18637	1275	146	:	:	:
18637	1275	147	When	when	WRB
18637	1275	148	limited	limited	JJ
18637	1275	149	343	343	CD
18637	1275	150	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	1275	151	as	as	IN
18637	1275	152	persons	person	NNS
18637	1275	153	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1275	154	to	to	IN
18637	1275	155	the	the	DT
18637	1275	156	law	law	NN
18637	1275	157	345	345	CD
18637	1275	158	Corporations	Corporations	NNPS
18637	1275	159	and	and	CC
18637	1275	160	the	the	DT
18637	1275	161	police	police	NN
18637	1275	162	power	power	NN
18637	1275	163	345	345	CD
18637	1275	164	Strict	strict	JJ
18637	1275	165	construction	construction	NN
18637	1275	166	of	of	IN
18637	1275	167	public	public	JJ
18637	1275	168	grants	grant	NNS
18637	1275	169	346	346	CD
18637	1275	170	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	1275	171	River	River	NNP
18637	1275	172	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	1275	173	case	case	NN
18637	1275	174	346	346	CD
18637	1275	175	Application	application	NN
18637	1275	176	of	of	IN
18637	1275	177	the	the	DT
18637	1275	178	strict	strict	JJ
18637	1275	179	construction	construction	NN
18637	1275	180	rule	rule	NN
18637	1275	181	346	346	CD
18637	1275	182	Strict	strict	JJ
18637	1275	183	construction	construction	NN
18637	1275	184	of	of	IN
18637	1275	185	tax	tax	NN
18637	1275	186	exemptions	exemption	NNS
18637	1275	187	347	347	CD
18637	1275	188	Strict	strict	JJ
18637	1275	189	construction	construction	NN
18637	1275	190	and	and	CC
18637	1275	191	the	the	DT
18637	1275	192	police	police	NN
18637	1275	193	power	power	NN
18637	1275	194	348	348	CD
18637	1275	195	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	1275	196	of	of	IN
18637	1275	197	inalienable	inalienable	JJ
18637	1275	198	State	State	NNP
18637	1275	199	powers	power	NNS
18637	1275	200	349	349	CD
18637	1275	201	Eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	1275	202	domain	domain	NN
18637	1275	203	power	power	NN
18637	1275	204	inalienable	inalienable	JJ
18637	1275	205	349	349	CD
18637	1275	206	Taxing	tax	VBG
18637	1275	207	power	power	NN
18637	1275	208	not	not	RB
18637	1275	209	inalienable	inalienable	JJ
18637	1275	210	350	350	CD
18637	1275	211	Police	police	NN
18637	1275	212	power	power	NN
18637	1275	213	:	:	:
18637	1275	214	When	when	WRB
18637	1275	215	inalienable	inalienable	JJ
18637	1275	216	351	351	CD
18637	1275	217	Private	private	JJ
18637	1275	218	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	1275	219	352	352	CD
18637	1275	220	Scope	scope	NN
18637	1275	221	of	of	IN
18637	1275	222	the	the	DT
18637	1275	223	term	term	NN
18637	1275	224	352	352	CD
18637	1275	225	Source	Source	NNP
18637	1275	226	of	of	IN
18637	1275	227	the	the	DT
18637	1275	228	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	1275	229	352	352	CD
18637	1275	230	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	1275	231	_	_	NNP
18637	1275	232	v.	v.	IN
18637	1275	233	_	_	NNP
18637	1275	234	Saunders	Saunders	NNP
18637	1275	235	353	353	CD
18637	1275	236	Remedy	Remedy	NNP
18637	1275	237	a	a	DT
18637	1275	238	part	part	NN
18637	1275	239	of	of	IN
18637	1275	240	the	the	DT
18637	1275	241	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	1275	242	354	354	CD
18637	1275	243	Establishment	Establishment	NNP
18637	1275	244	of	of	IN
18637	1275	245	the	the	DT
18637	1275	246	rule	rule	NN
18637	1275	247	354	354	CD
18637	1275	248	Qualifications	Qualifications	NNPS
18637	1275	249	of	of	IN
18637	1275	250	the	the	DT
18637	1275	251	rule	rule	NN
18637	1275	252	355	355	CD
18637	1275	253	Municipal	Municipal	NNP
18637	1275	254	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	1275	255	cases	case	NNS
18637	1275	256	356	356	CD
18637	1275	257	Private	private	JJ
18637	1275	258	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	1275	259	and	and	CC
18637	1275	260	the	the	DT
18637	1275	261	police	police	NN
18637	1275	262	power	power	NN
18637	1275	263	357	357	CD
18637	1275	264	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	1275	265	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1275	266	358	358	CD
18637	1275	267	Individual	individual	JJ
18637	1275	268	rights	right	NNS
18637	1275	269	versus	versus	IN
18637	1275	270	public	public	JJ
18637	1275	271	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1275	272	359	359	CD
18637	1275	273	Evaluation	Evaluation	NNP
18637	1275	274	of	of	IN
18637	1275	275	the	the	DT
18637	1275	276	clause	clause	NN
18637	1275	277	today	today	NN
18637	1275	278	359	359	CD
18637	1275	279	Statistical	statistical	JJ
18637	1275	280	data	datum	NNS
18637	1275	281	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	1275	282	to	to	IN
18637	1275	283	the	the	DT
18637	1275	284	clause	clause	NN
18637	1275	285	361	361	CD
18637	1275	286	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	1275	287	2	2	CD
18637	1275	288	.	.	.
18637	1276	1	Not	not	RB
18637	1276	2	to	to	TO
18637	1276	3	levy	levy	VB
18637	1276	4	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1276	5	on	on	IN
18637	1276	6	exports	export	NNS
18637	1276	7	and	and	CC
18637	1276	8	imports	import	NNS
18637	1276	9	362	362	CD
18637	1276	10	Duties	duty	NNS
18637	1276	11	on	on	IN
18637	1276	12	exports	export	NNS
18637	1276	13	and	and	CC
18637	1276	14	imports	import	NNS
18637	1276	15	362	362	CD
18637	1276	16	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	1276	17	362	362	CD
18637	1276	18	Privilege	Privilege	NNP
18637	1276	19	taxes	tax	VBZ
18637	1276	20	363	363	CD
18637	1276	21	Property	property	NN
18637	1276	22	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1276	23	364	364	CD
18637	1276	24	Inspection	inspection	NN
18637	1276	25	laws	law	NNS
18637	1276	26	364	364	CD
18637	1276	27	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1276	28	3	3	CD
18637	1276	29	.	.	.
18637	1277	1	Not	not	RB
18637	1277	2	to	to	TO
18637	1277	3	lay	lay	VB
18637	1277	4	tonnage	tonnage	NN
18637	1277	5	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1277	6	,	,	,
18637	1277	7	keep	keep	VB
18637	1277	8	troops	troop	NNS
18637	1277	9	,	,	,
18637	1277	10	make	make	VB
18637	1277	11	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	1277	12	,	,	,
18637	1277	13	or	or	CC
18637	1277	14	engage	engage	VB
18637	1277	15	in	in	IN
18637	1277	16	war	war	NN
18637	1277	17	365	365	CD
18637	1277	18	Tonnage	tonnage	NN
18637	1277	19	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1277	20	365	365	CD
18637	1277	21	Keeping	keep	VBG
18637	1277	22	troops	troop	NNS
18637	1277	23	366	366	CD
18637	1277	24	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	1277	25	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	1277	26	366	366	CD
18637	1277	27	Background	background	NN
18637	1277	28	of	of	IN
18637	1277	29	clause	clause	NN
18637	1277	30	366	366	CD
18637	1277	31	Subject	subject	JJ
18637	1277	32	matter	matter	NN
18637	1277	33	of	of	IN
18637	1277	34	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1277	35	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	1277	36	368	368	CD
18637	1277	37	Consent	consent	NN
18637	1277	38	of	of	IN
18637	1277	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1277	40	368	368	CD
18637	1277	41	Grants	Grants	NNPS
18637	1277	42	of	of	IN
18637	1277	43	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	1277	44	to	to	IN
18637	1277	45	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	1277	46	by	by	IN
18637	1277	47	two	two	CD
18637	1277	48	States	state	NNS
18637	1277	49	369	369	CD
18637	1277	50	Legal	legal	JJ
18637	1277	51	effect	effect	NN
18637	1277	52	of	of	IN
18637	1277	53	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1277	54	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	1277	55	369	369	CD
18637	1277	56	LEGISLATIVE	LEGISLATIVE	NNP
18637	1277	57	DEPARTMENT	DEPARTMENT	NNP
18637	1277	58	Article	Article	NNP
18637	1277	59	I	I	NNP
18637	1277	60	Section	Section	NNP
18637	1277	61	1	1	CD
18637	1277	62	.	.	.
18637	1278	1	All	all	DT
18637	1278	2	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1278	3	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	1278	4	herein	herein	NN
18637	1278	5	granted	grant	VBN
18637	1278	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	1278	7	be	be	VB
18637	1278	8	vested	vest	VBN
18637	1278	9	in	in	IN
18637	1278	10	a	a	DT
18637	1278	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1278	12	of	of	IN
18637	1278	13	the	the	DT
18637	1278	14	United	United	NNP
18637	1278	15	States	States	NNP
18637	1278	16	,	,	,
18637	1278	17	which	which	WDT
18637	1278	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	1278	19	consist	consist	VB
18637	1278	20	of	of	IN
18637	1278	21	a	a	DT
18637	1278	22	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1278	23	and	and	CC
18637	1278	24	House	House	NNP
18637	1278	25	of	of	IN
18637	1278	26	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1278	27	.	.	.
18637	1279	1	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	1279	2	of	of	IN
18637	1279	3	Enumerated	Enumerated	NNP
18637	1279	4	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	1279	5	Two	two	CD
18637	1279	6	important	important	JJ
18637	1279	7	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	1279	8	of	of	IN
18637	1279	9	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	1279	10	Law	Law	NNP
18637	1279	11	--	--	:
18637	1279	12	that	that	IN
18637	1279	13	the	the	DT
18637	1279	14	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1279	15	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1279	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	1279	17	one	one	CD
18637	1279	18	of	of	IN
18637	1279	19	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	1279	20	powers	power	NNS
18637	1279	21	and	and	CC
18637	1279	22	that	that	IN
18637	1279	23	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1279	24	power	power	NN
18637	1279	25	may	may	MD
18637	1279	26	not	not	RB
18637	1279	27	be	be	VB
18637	1279	28	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	1279	29	--	--	:
18637	1279	30	are	be	VBP
18637	1279	31	derived	derive	VBN
18637	1279	32	in	in	IN
18637	1279	33	part	part	NN
18637	1279	34	from	from	IN
18637	1279	35	this	this	DT
18637	1279	36	section	section	NN
18637	1279	37	.	.	.
18637	1280	1	The	the	DT
18637	1280	2	classical	classical	JJ
18637	1280	3	statement	statement	NN
18637	1280	4	of	of	IN
18637	1280	5	the	the	DT
18637	1280	6	former	former	JJ
18637	1280	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	1280	8	that	that	IN
18637	1280	9	by	by	IN
18637	1280	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1280	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1280	12	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1280	13	in	in	IN
18637	1280	14	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	1280	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1280	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	1280	17	_	_	NNP
18637	1280	18	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1280	19	:	:	:
18637	1280	20	"	"	``
18637	1280	21	This	this	DT
18637	1280	22	government	government	NN
18637	1280	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	1280	24	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	1280	25	by	by	IN
18637	1280	26	all	all	DT
18637	1280	27	,	,	,
18637	1280	28	to	to	TO
18637	1280	29	be	be	VB
18637	1280	30	one	one	CD
18637	1280	31	of	of	IN
18637	1280	32	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	1280	33	powers	power	NNS
18637	1280	34	.	.	.
18637	1281	1	The	the	DT
18637	1281	2	principle	principle	NN
18637	1281	3	,	,	,
18637	1281	4	that	that	IN
18637	1281	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1281	6	can	can	MD
18637	1281	7	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	1281	8	only	only	RB
18637	1281	9	the	the	DT
18637	1281	10	powers	power	NNS
18637	1281	11	granted	grant	VBD
18637	1281	12	to	to	IN
18637	1281	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1281	14	,	,	,
18637	1281	15	would	would	MD
18637	1281	16	seem	seem	VB
18637	1281	17	too	too	RB
18637	1281	18	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	1281	19	,	,	,
18637	1281	20	to	to	TO
18637	1281	21	have	have	VB
18637	1281	22	required	require	VBN
18637	1281	23	to	to	TO
18637	1281	24	be	be	VB
18637	1281	25	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	1281	26	by	by	IN
18637	1281	27	all	all	PDT
18637	1281	28	those	those	DT
18637	1281	29	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	1281	30	,	,	,
18637	1281	31	which	which	WDT
18637	1281	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1281	33	enlightened	enlightened	JJ
18637	1281	34	friends	friend	NNS
18637	1281	35	,	,	,
18637	1281	36	while	while	IN
18637	1281	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1281	38	was	be	VBD
18637	1281	39	depending	depend	VBG
18637	1281	40	before	before	IN
18637	1281	41	the	the	DT
18637	1281	42	people	people	NNS
18637	1281	43	,	,	,
18637	1281	44	found	find	VBD
18637	1281	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1281	46	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1281	47	to	to	TO
18637	1281	48	urge	urge	VB
18637	1281	49	;	;	:
18637	1281	50	that	that	IN
18637	1281	51	principle	principle	NN
18637	1281	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	1281	53	now	now	RB
18637	1281	54	universally	universally	RB
18637	1281	55	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	1281	56	.	.	.
18637	1282	1	"	"	``
18637	1282	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1282	3	1	1	CD
18637	1282	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1282	5	That	that	DT
18637	1282	6	,	,	,
18637	1282	7	however	however	RB
18637	1282	8	,	,	,
18637	1282	9	"	"	``
18637	1282	10	the	the	DT
18637	1282	11	executive	executive	JJ
18637	1282	12	power	power	NN
18637	1282	13	"	"	''
18637	1282	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	1282	15	not	not	RB
18637	1282	16	confined	confine	VBN
18637	1282	17	to	to	IN
18637	1282	18	the	the	DT
18637	1282	19	items	item	NNS
18637	1282	20	of	of	IN
18637	1282	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1282	22	which	which	WDT
18637	1282	23	are	be	VBP
18637	1282	24	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	1282	25	in	in	IN
18637	1282	26	article	article	NN
18637	1282	27	II	II	NNP
18637	1282	28	was	be	VBD
18637	1282	29	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	1282	30	early	early	RB
18637	1282	31	in	in	IN
18637	1282	32	the	the	DT
18637	1282	33	history	history	NN
18637	1282	34	of	of	IN
18637	1282	35	the	the	DT
18637	1282	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1282	37	by	by	IN
18637	1282	38	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	1282	39	and	and	CC
18637	1282	40	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	1282	41	alike	alike	RB
18637	1282	42	and	and	CC
18637	1282	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	1282	44	today	today	NN
18637	1282	45	the	the	DT
18637	1282	46	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1282	47	of	of	IN
18637	1282	48	the	the	DT
18637	1282	49	Court;[2	Court;[2	NNP
18637	1282	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1282	51	and	and	CC
18637	1282	52	a	a	DT
18637	1282	53	similar	similar	JJ
18637	1282	54	latitudinarian	latitudinarian	JJ
18637	1282	55	conception	conception	NN
18637	1282	56	of	of	IN
18637	1282	57	"	"	``
18637	1282	58	the	the	DT
18637	1282	59	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1282	60	power	power	NN
18637	1282	61	of	of	IN
18637	1282	62	the	the	DT
18637	1282	63	United	United	NNP
18637	1282	64	States	States	NNP
18637	1282	65	"	"	''
18637	1282	66	was	be	VBD
18637	1282	67	voiced	voice	VBN
18637	1282	68	in	in	IN
18637	1282	69	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1282	70	Brewer	Brewer	NNP
18637	1282	71	's	's	POS
18637	1282	72	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1282	73	for	for	IN
18637	1282	74	the	the	DT
18637	1282	75	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1282	76	in	in	IN
18637	1282	77	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	1282	78	_	_	NNP
18637	1282	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	1282	80	_	_	NNP
18637	1282	81	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	1282	82	.	.	.
18637	1283	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1283	2	3	3	CD
18637	1283	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1283	4	But	but	CC
18637	1283	5	even	even	RB
18637	1283	6	when	when	WRB
18637	1283	7	confined	confine	VBN
18637	1283	8	to	to	IN
18637	1283	9	"	"	``
18637	1283	10	the	the	DT
18637	1283	11	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1283	12	powers	power	NNS
18637	1283	13	herein	herein	NNP
18637	1283	14	granted	grant	VBD
18637	1283	15	,	,	,
18637	1283	16	"	"	''
18637	1283	17	the	the	DT
18637	1283	18	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1283	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	1283	20	severely	severely	RB
18637	1283	21	strained	strain	VBN
18637	1283	22	by	by	IN
18637	1283	23	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1283	24	's	's	POS
18637	1283	25	conception	conception	NN
18637	1283	26	of	of	IN
18637	1283	27	some	some	DT
18637	1283	28	of	of	IN
18637	1283	29	these	these	DT
18637	1283	30	as	as	IN
18637	1283	31	set	set	VBN
18637	1283	32	forth	forth	RP
18637	1283	33	in	in	IN
18637	1283	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1283	35	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	1283	36	_	_	NNP
18637	1283	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	1283	38	_	_	NNP
18637	1283	39	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1283	40	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1283	41	:	:	:
18637	1283	42	This	this	DT
18637	1283	43	asserts	assert	VBZ
18637	1283	44	that	that	IN
18637	1283	45	"	"	``
18637	1283	46	the	the	DT
18637	1283	47	sword	sword	NN
18637	1283	48	and	and	CC
18637	1283	49	the	the	DT
18637	1283	50	purse	purse	NN
18637	1283	51	,	,	,
18637	1283	52	all	all	PDT
18637	1283	53	the	the	DT
18637	1283	54	external	external	JJ
18637	1283	55	relations	relation	NNS
18637	1283	56	,	,	,
18637	1283	57	and	and	CC
18637	1283	58	no	no	DT
18637	1283	59	inconsiderable	inconsiderable	JJ
18637	1283	60	portion	portion	NN
18637	1283	61	of	of	IN
18637	1283	62	the	the	DT
18637	1283	63	industry	industry	NN
18637	1283	64	of	of	IN
18637	1283	65	the	the	DT
18637	1283	66	nation	nation	NN
18637	1283	67	,	,	,
18637	1283	68	are	be	VBP
18637	1283	69	intrusted	intrust	VBN
18637	1283	70	to	to	IN
18637	1283	71	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1283	72	government";[4	government";[4	NN
18637	1283	73	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1283	74	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1283	75	characterizes	characterize	VBZ
18637	1283	76	"	"	``
18637	1283	77	the	the	DT
18637	1283	78	power	power	NN
18637	1283	79	of	of	IN
18637	1283	80	making	make	VBG
18637	1283	81	war	war	NN
18637	1283	82	,	,	,
18637	1283	83	"	"	''
18637	1283	84	of	of	IN
18637	1283	85	"	"	``
18637	1283	86	levying	levy	VBG
18637	1283	87	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1283	88	,	,	,
18637	1283	89	"	"	''
18637	1283	90	and	and	CC
18637	1283	91	of	of	IN
18637	1283	92	"	"	``
18637	1283	93	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	1283	94	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1283	95	"	"	''
18637	1283	96	as	as	IN
18637	1283	97	"	"	``
18637	1283	98	great	great	JJ
18637	1283	99	,	,	,
18637	1283	100	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	1283	101	and	and	CC
18637	1283	102	independent	independent	JJ
18637	1283	103	powers";[5	powers";[5	NN
18637	1283	104	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1283	105	and	and	CC
18637	1283	106	the	the	DT
18637	1283	107	power	power	NN
18637	1283	108	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	1283	109	by	by	IN
18637	1283	110	the	the	DT
18637	1283	111	"	"	``
18637	1283	112	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1283	113	and	and	CC
18637	1283	114	proper	proper	JJ
18637	1283	115	"	"	''
18637	1283	116	clause	clause	NN
18637	1283	117	embraces	embrace	NNS
18637	1283	118	,	,	,
18637	1283	119	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1283	120	declares	declare	VBZ
18637	1283	121	,	,	,
18637	1283	122	"	"	``
18637	1283	123	all	all	DT
18637	1283	124	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1283	125	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1283	126	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1283	127	means	mean	NNS
18637	1283	128	which	which	WDT
18637	1283	129	are	be	VBP
18637	1283	130	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	1283	131	"	"	''
18637	1283	132	to	to	TO
18637	1283	133	carry	carry	VB
18637	1283	134	out	out	RP
18637	1283	135	"	"	``
18637	1283	136	the	the	DT
18637	1283	137	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	1283	138	ends	end	NNS
18637	1283	139	"	"	''
18637	1283	140	of	of	IN
18637	1283	141	the	the	DT
18637	1283	142	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1283	143	,	,	,
18637	1283	144	unless	unless	IN
18637	1283	145	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	1283	146	by	by	IN
18637	1283	147	"	"	``
18637	1283	148	the	the	DT
18637	1283	149	letter	letter	NN
18637	1283	150	and	and	CC
18637	1283	151	spirit	spirit	NN
18637	1283	152	of	of	IN
18637	1283	153	the	the	DT
18637	1283	154	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1283	155	.	.	.
18637	1284	1	"	"	``
18637	1284	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1284	3	6	6	CD
18637	1284	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1284	5	Nine	nine	CD
18637	1284	6	years	year	NNS
18637	1284	7	later	later	RB
18637	1284	8	,	,	,
18637	1284	9	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1284	10	introduced	introduce	VBD
18637	1284	11	what	what	WP
18637	1284	12	Story	story	NN
18637	1284	13	in	in	IN
18637	1284	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1284	15	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	1284	16	labels	label	VBZ
18637	1284	17	the	the	DT
18637	1284	18	concept	concept	NN
18637	1284	19	of	of	IN
18637	1284	20	"	"	``
18637	1284	21	resulting	result	VBG
18637	1284	22	powers	power	NNS
18637	1284	23	,	,	,
18637	1284	24	"	"	''
18637	1284	25	those	those	DT
18637	1284	26	which	which	WDT
18637	1284	27	"	"	''
18637	1284	28	rather	rather	RB
18637	1284	29	be	be	VB
18637	1284	30	a	a	DT
18637	1284	31	result	result	NN
18637	1284	32	from	from	IN
18637	1284	33	the	the	DT
18637	1284	34	whole	whole	JJ
18637	1284	35	mass	mass	NN
18637	1284	36	of	of	IN
18637	1284	37	the	the	DT
18637	1284	38	powers	power	NNS
18637	1284	39	of	of	IN
18637	1284	40	the	the	DT
18637	1284	41	National	National	NNP
18637	1284	42	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1284	43	,	,	,
18637	1284	44	and	and	CC
18637	1284	45	from	from	IN
18637	1284	46	the	the	DT
18637	1284	47	nature	nature	NN
18637	1284	48	of	of	IN
18637	1284	49	political	political	JJ
18637	1284	50	society	society	NN
18637	1284	51	,	,	,
18637	1284	52	than	than	IN
18637	1284	53	a	a	DT
18637	1284	54	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	1284	55	or	or	CC
18637	1284	56	incident	incident	NN
18637	1284	57	of	of	IN
18637	1284	58	the	the	DT
18637	1284	59	powers	power	NNS
18637	1284	60	specially	specially	RB
18637	1284	61	enumerated	enumerate	VBD
18637	1284	62	.	.	.
18637	1285	1	"	"	``
18637	1285	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1285	3	7	7	CD
18637	1285	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1285	5	Story	story	NN
18637	1285	6	's	's	POS
18637	1285	7	reference	reference	NN
18637	1285	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	1285	9	to	to	IN
18637	1285	10	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1285	11	's	's	POS
18637	1285	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1285	13	in	in	IN
18637	1285	14	American	American	NNP
18637	1285	15	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	1285	16	Company	Company	NNP
18637	1285	17	_	_	NNP
18637	1285	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	1285	19	_	_	NNP
18637	1285	20	Canter,[8	Canter,[8	NNP
18637	1285	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1285	22	where	where	WRB
18637	1285	23	the	the	DT
18637	1285	24	latter	latter	JJ
18637	1285	25	says	say	VBZ
18637	1285	26	,	,	,
18637	1285	27	that	that	IN
18637	1285	28	"	"	``
18637	1285	29	the	the	DT
18637	1285	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1285	31	confers	confer	NNS
18637	1285	32	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	1285	33	on	on	IN
18637	1285	34	the	the	DT
18637	1285	35	government	government	NN
18637	1285	36	of	of	IN
18637	1285	37	the	the	DT
18637	1285	38	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1285	39	,	,	,
18637	1285	40	the	the	DT
18637	1285	41	powers	power	NNS
18637	1285	42	of	of	IN
18637	1285	43	making	make	VBG
18637	1285	44	war	war	NN
18637	1285	45	,	,	,
18637	1285	46	and	and	CC
18637	1285	47	of	of	IN
18637	1285	48	making	make	VBG
18637	1285	49	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	1285	50	;	;	:
18637	1285	51	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	1285	52	,	,	,
18637	1285	53	that	that	IN
18637	1285	54	government	government	NN
18637	1285	55	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	1285	56	the	the	DT
18637	1285	57	power	power	NN
18637	1285	58	of	of	IN
18637	1285	59	acquiring	acquire	VBG
18637	1285	60	territory	territory	NN
18637	1285	61	,	,	,
18637	1285	62	either	either	CC
18637	1285	63	by	by	IN
18637	1285	64	conquest	conquest	NN
18637	1285	65	or	or	CC
18637	1285	66	by	by	IN
18637	1285	67	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	1285	68	.	.	.
18637	1286	1	"	"	``
18637	1286	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1286	3	9	9	CD
18637	1286	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1286	5	And	and	CC
18637	1286	6	from	from	IN
18637	1286	7	the	the	DT
18637	1286	8	power	power	NN
18637	1286	9	to	to	TO
18637	1286	10	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	1286	11	territory	territory	NN
18637	1286	12	,	,	,
18637	1286	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1286	14	continues	continue	VBZ
18637	1286	15	,	,	,
18637	1286	16	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	1286	17	as	as	IN
18637	1286	18	"	"	``
18637	1286	19	the	the	DT
18637	1286	20	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
18637	1286	21	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	1286	22	"	"	''
18637	1286	23	the	the	DT
18637	1286	24	right	right	NN
18637	1286	25	to	to	TO
18637	1286	26	govern	govern	VB
18637	1286	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1286	28	.	.	.
18637	1287	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1287	2	10	10	CD
18637	1287	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1287	4	Subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	1287	5	,	,	,
18637	1287	6	powers	power	NNS
18637	1287	7	have	have	VBP
18637	1287	8	been	be	VBN
18637	1287	9	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	1287	10	ascribed	ascribe	VBN
18637	1287	11	to	to	IN
18637	1287	12	the	the	DT
18637	1287	13	National	National	NNP
18637	1287	14	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1287	15	by	by	IN
18637	1287	16	the	the	DT
18637	1287	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1287	18	on	on	IN
18637	1287	19	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	1287	20	which	which	WDT
18637	1287	21	ill	ill	JJ
18637	1287	22	accord	accord	NN
18637	1287	23	with	with	IN
18637	1287	24	the	the	DT
18637	1287	25	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1287	26	of	of	IN
18637	1287	27	enumerated	enumerated	JJ
18637	1287	28	powers	power	NNS
18637	1287	29	:	:	:
18637	1287	30	the	the	DT
18637	1287	31	power	power	NN
18637	1287	32	to	to	TO
18637	1287	33	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	1287	34	in	in	IN
18637	1287	35	effectuation	effectuation	NN
18637	1287	36	of	of	IN
18637	1287	37	the	the	DT
18637	1287	38	"	"	``
18637	1287	39	rights	right	NNS
18637	1287	40	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	1287	41	given	give	VBN
18637	1287	42	,	,	,
18637	1287	43	and	and	CC
18637	1287	44	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1287	45	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	1287	46	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	1287	47	"	"	''
18637	1287	48	by	by	IN
18637	1287	49	the	the	DT
18637	1287	50	Constitution;[11	Constitution;[11	NNP
18637	1287	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1287	52	the	the	DT
18637	1287	53	power	power	NN
18637	1287	54	to	to	TO
18637	1287	55	impart	impart	VB
18637	1287	56	to	to	IN
18637	1287	57	the	the	DT
18637	1287	58	paper	paper	NN
18637	1287	59	currency	currency	NN
18637	1287	60	of	of	IN
18637	1287	61	the	the	DT
18637	1287	62	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1287	63	the	the	DT
18637	1287	64	quality	quality	NN
18637	1287	65	of	of	IN
18637	1287	66	legal	legal	JJ
18637	1287	67	tender	tender	NN
18637	1287	68	in	in	IN
18637	1287	69	the	the	DT
18637	1287	70	payment	payment	NN
18637	1287	71	of	of	IN
18637	1287	72	debts;[12	debts;[12	NNPS
18637	1287	73	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1287	74	the	the	DT
18637	1287	75	power	power	NN
18637	1287	76	to	to	TO
18637	1287	77	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	1287	78	territory	territory	NN
18637	1287	79	by	by	IN
18637	1287	80	discovery;[13	discovery;[13	NNP
18637	1287	81	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1287	82	the	the	DT
18637	1287	83	power	power	NN
18637	1287	84	to	to	TO
18637	1287	85	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	1287	86	for	for	IN
18637	1287	87	the	the	DT
18637	1287	88	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	1287	89	tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	1287	90	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	1287	91	situated	situate	VBN
18637	1287	92	in	in	IN
18637	1287	93	the	the	DT
18637	1287	94	United	United	NNP
18637	1287	95	States;[14	States;[14	NNP
18637	1287	96	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1287	97	the	the	DT
18637	1287	98	power	power	NN
18637	1287	99	to	to	TO
18637	1287	100	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	1287	101	and	and	CC
18637	1287	102	deport	deport	VB
18637	1287	103	aliens;[15	aliens;[15	NNP
18637	1287	104	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1287	105	and	and	CC
18637	1287	106	to	to	TO
18637	1287	107	require	require	VB
18637	1287	108	that	that	IN
18637	1287	109	those	those	DT
18637	1287	110	who	who	WP
18637	1287	111	are	be	VBP
18637	1287	112	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	1287	113	be	be	VB
18637	1287	114	registered	register	VBN
18637	1287	115	and	and	CC
18637	1287	116	fingerprinted;[16	fingerprinted;[16	NN
18637	1287	117	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1287	118	and	and	CC
18637	1287	119	finally	finally	RB
18637	1287	120	the	the	DT
18637	1287	121	complete	complete	JJ
18637	1287	122	powers	power	NNS
18637	1287	123	of	of	IN
18637	1287	124	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	1287	125	,	,	,
18637	1287	126	both	both	CC
18637	1287	127	those	those	DT
18637	1287	128	of	of	IN
18637	1287	129	war	war	NN
18637	1287	130	and	and	CC
18637	1287	131	peace	peace	NN
18637	1287	132	,	,	,
18637	1287	133	in	in	IN
18637	1287	134	the	the	DT
18637	1287	135	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	1287	136	of	of	IN
18637	1287	137	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1287	138	relations	relation	NNS
18637	1287	139	.	.	.
18637	1288	1	In	in	IN
18637	1288	2	the	the	DT
18637	1288	3	words	word	NNS
18637	1288	4	of	of	IN
18637	1288	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1288	6	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	1288	7	in	in	IN
18637	1288	8	United	United	NNP
18637	1288	9	States	States	NNP
18637	1288	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1288	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	1288	12	_	_	NNP
18637	1288	13	Curtiss	Curtiss	NNP
18637	1288	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	1288	15	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	1288	16	Export	Export	NNP
18637	1288	17	Corporation,[17	Corporation,[17	NNP
18637	1288	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1288	19	decided	decide	VBN
18637	1288	20	in	in	IN
18637	1288	21	1936	1936	CD
18637	1288	22	:	:	:
18637	1288	23	"	"	``
18637	1288	24	The	the	DT
18637	1288	25	broad	broad	JJ
18637	1288	26	statement	statement	NN
18637	1288	27	that	that	IN
18637	1288	28	the	the	DT
18637	1288	29	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1288	30	government	government	NN
18637	1288	31	can	can	MD
18637	1288	32	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	1288	33	no	no	DT
18637	1288	34	powers	power	NNS
18637	1288	35	except	except	IN
18637	1288	36	those	those	DT
18637	1288	37	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	1288	38	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	1288	39	in	in	IN
18637	1288	40	the	the	DT
18637	1288	41	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1288	42	,	,	,
18637	1288	43	and	and	CC
18637	1288	44	such	such	JJ
18637	1288	45	implied	imply	VBN
18637	1288	46	powers	power	NNS
18637	1288	47	as	as	IN
18637	1288	48	are	be	VBP
18637	1288	49	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1288	50	and	and	CC
18637	1288	51	proper	proper	JJ
18637	1288	52	to	to	TO
18637	1288	53	carry	carry	VB
18637	1288	54	into	into	IN
18637	1288	55	effect	effect	NN
18637	1288	56	the	the	DT
18637	1288	57	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	1288	58	powers	power	NNS
18637	1288	59	,	,	,
18637	1288	60	is	be	VBZ
18637	1288	61	categorically	categorically	RB
18637	1288	62	true	true	JJ
18637	1288	63	only	only	RB
18637	1288	64	in	in	IN
18637	1288	65	respect	respect	NN
18637	1288	66	of	of	IN
18637	1288	67	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1288	68	internal	internal	JJ
18637	1288	69	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	1288	70	.	.	.
18637	1289	1	In	in	IN
18637	1289	2	that	that	DT
18637	1289	3	field	field	NN
18637	1289	4	,	,	,
18637	1289	5	the	the	DT
18637	1289	6	primary	primary	JJ
18637	1289	7	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1289	8	of	of	IN
18637	1289	9	the	the	DT
18637	1289	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1289	11	was	be	VBD
18637	1289	12	to	to	TO
18637	1289	13	carve	carve	VB
18637	1289	14	from	from	IN
18637	1289	15	the	the	DT
18637	1289	16	general	general	JJ
18637	1289	17	mass	mass	NN
18637	1289	18	of	of	IN
18637	1289	19	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1289	20	powers	power	NNS
18637	1289	21	_	_	NNP
18637	1289	22	then	then	RB
18637	1289	23	possessed	possess	VBN
18637	1289	24	by	by	IN
18637	1289	25	the	the	DT
18637	1289	26	states	state	NNS
18637	1289	27	_	_	NNP
18637	1289	28	such	such	JJ
18637	1289	29	portions	portion	NNS
18637	1289	30	as	as	IN
18637	1289	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1289	32	was	be	VBD
18637	1289	33	thought	think	VBN
18637	1289	34	desirable	desirable	JJ
18637	1289	35	to	to	IN
18637	1289	36	vest	vest	VB
18637	1289	37	in	in	IN
18637	1289	38	the	the	DT
18637	1289	39	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1289	40	government	government	NN
18637	1289	41	,	,	,
18637	1289	42	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	1289	43	those	those	DT
18637	1289	44	not	not	RB
18637	1289	45	included	include	VBN
18637	1289	46	in	in	IN
18637	1289	47	the	the	DT
18637	1289	48	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	1289	49	still	still	RB
18637	1289	50	in	in	IN
18637	1289	51	the	the	DT
18637	1289	52	states	state	NNS
18637	1289	53	....	....	.
18637	1289	54	That	that	IN
18637	1289	55	this	this	DT
18637	1289	56	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1289	57	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	1289	58	only	only	RB
18637	1289	59	to	to	IN
18637	1289	60	powers	power	NNS
18637	1289	61	which	which	WDT
18637	1289	62	the	the	DT
18637	1289	63	states	state	NNS
18637	1289	64	had	have	VBD
18637	1289	65	,	,	,
18637	1289	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	1289	67	self	self	NN
18637	1289	68	evident	evident	JJ
18637	1289	69	.	.	.
18637	1290	1	And	and	CC
18637	1290	2	since	since	IN
18637	1290	3	the	the	DT
18637	1290	4	states	state	NNS
18637	1290	5	severally	severally	RB
18637	1290	6	never	never	RB
18637	1290	7	possessed	possess	VBD
18637	1290	8	international	international	JJ
18637	1290	9	powers	power	NNS
18637	1290	10	,	,	,
18637	1290	11	such	such	JJ
18637	1290	12	powers	power	NNS
18637	1290	13	could	could	MD
18637	1290	14	not	not	RB
18637	1290	15	have	have	VB
18637	1290	16	been	be	VBN
18637	1290	17	carved	carve	VBN
18637	1290	18	from	from	IN
18637	1290	19	the	the	DT
18637	1290	20	mass	mass	NN
18637	1290	21	of	of	IN
18637	1290	22	state	state	NN
18637	1290	23	powers	power	NNS
18637	1290	24	but	but	CC
18637	1290	25	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	1290	26	were	be	VBD
18637	1290	27	transmitted	transmit	VBN
18637	1290	28	to	to	IN
18637	1290	29	the	the	DT
18637	1290	30	United	United	NNP
18637	1290	31	States	States	NNP
18637	1290	32	from	from	IN
18637	1290	33	some	some	DT
18637	1290	34	other	other	JJ
18637	1290	35	source	source	NN
18637	1290	36	....	....	.
18637	1290	37	A	a	DT
18637	1290	38	political	political	JJ
18637	1290	39	society	society	NN
18637	1290	40	can	can	MD
18637	1290	41	not	not	RB
18637	1290	42	endure	endure	VB
18637	1290	43	without	without	IN
18637	1290	44	a	a	DT
18637	1290	45	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	1290	46	will	will	MD
18637	1290	47	somewhere	somewhere	RB
18637	1290	48	.	.	.
18637	1291	1	Sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	1291	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1291	3	never	never	RB
18637	1291	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	1291	5	in	in	IN
18637	1291	6	suspense	suspense	NN
18637	1291	7	.	.	.
18637	1292	1	When	when	WRB
18637	1292	2	,	,	,
18637	1292	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	1292	4	,	,	,
18637	1292	5	the	the	DT
18637	1292	6	external	external	JJ
18637	1292	7	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	1292	8	of	of	IN
18637	1292	9	Great	Great	NNP
18637	1292	10	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	1292	11	in	in	IN
18637	1292	12	respect	respect	NN
18637	1292	13	of	of	IN
18637	1292	14	the	the	DT
18637	1292	15	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	1292	16	ceased	cease	VBD
18637	1292	17	,	,	,
18637	1292	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1292	19	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	1292	20	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1292	21	to	to	IN
18637	1292	22	the	the	DT
18637	1292	23	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1292	24	....	....	.
18637	1293	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1293	2	results	result	VBZ
18637	1293	3	that	that	IN
18637	1293	4	the	the	DT
18637	1293	5	investment	investment	NN
18637	1293	6	of	of	IN
18637	1293	7	the	the	DT
18637	1293	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1293	9	government	government	NN
18637	1293	10	with	with	IN
18637	1293	11	the	the	DT
18637	1293	12	powers	power	NNS
18637	1293	13	of	of	IN
18637	1293	14	external	external	JJ
18637	1293	15	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	1293	16	did	do	VBD
18637	1293	17	not	not	RB
18637	1293	18	depend	depend	VB
18637	1293	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	1293	20	the	the	DT
18637	1293	21	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	1293	22	grants	grant	NNS
18637	1293	23	of	of	IN
18637	1293	24	the	the	DT
18637	1293	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1293	26	.	.	.
18637	1294	1	The	the	DT
18637	1294	2	powers	power	NNS
18637	1294	3	to	to	TO
18637	1294	4	declare	declare	VB
18637	1294	5	and	and	CC
18637	1294	6	wage	wage	VB
18637	1294	7	war	war	NN
18637	1294	8	,	,	,
18637	1294	9	to	to	TO
18637	1294	10	conclude	conclude	VB
18637	1294	11	peace	peace	NN
18637	1294	12	,	,	,
18637	1294	13	to	to	TO
18637	1294	14	make	make	VB
18637	1294	15	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	1294	16	,	,	,
18637	1294	17	to	to	TO
18637	1294	18	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	1294	19	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	1294	20	relations	relation	NNS
18637	1294	21	with	with	IN
18637	1294	22	other	other	JJ
18637	1294	23	sovereignties	sovereignty	NNS
18637	1294	24	,	,	,
18637	1294	25	if	if	IN
18637	1294	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1294	27	had	have	VBD
18637	1294	28	never	never	RB
18637	1294	29	been	be	VBN
18637	1294	30	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	1294	31	in	in	IN
18637	1294	32	the	the	DT
18637	1294	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1294	34	,	,	,
18637	1294	35	would	would	MD
18637	1294	36	have	have	VB
18637	1294	37	vested	vest	VBN
18637	1294	38	in	in	IN
18637	1294	39	the	the	DT
18637	1294	40	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1294	41	government	government	NN
18637	1294	42	as	as	IN
18637	1294	43	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1294	44	concomitants	concomitant	NNS
18637	1294	45	of	of	IN
18637	1294	46	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	1294	47	.	.	.
18637	1295	1	"	"	``
18637	1295	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1295	3	18	18	CD
18637	1295	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1295	5	Yet	yet	CC
18637	1295	6	for	for	IN
18637	1295	7	the	the	DT
18637	1295	8	most	most	JJS
18637	1295	9	part	part	NN
18637	1295	10	,	,	,
18637	1295	11	these	these	DT
18637	1295	12	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	1295	13	do	do	VBP
18637	1295	14	not	not	RB
18637	1295	15	,	,	,
18637	1295	16	as	as	IN
18637	1295	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1295	18	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	1295	19	suggests	suggest	VBZ
18637	1295	20	,	,	,
18637	1295	21	directly	directly	RB
18637	1295	22	affect	affect	VB
18637	1295	23	"	"	``
18637	1295	24	the	the	DT
18637	1295	25	internal	internal	JJ
18637	1295	26	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	1295	27	"	"	''
18637	1295	28	of	of	IN
18637	1295	29	the	the	DT
18637	1295	30	nation	nation	NN
18637	1295	31	;	;	:
18637	1295	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1295	33	touch	touch	VBP
18637	1295	34	principally	principally	RB
18637	1295	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1295	36	peripheral	peripheral	JJ
18637	1295	37	relations	relation	NNS
18637	1295	38	,	,	,
18637	1295	39	as	as	IN
18637	1295	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1295	41	were	be	VBD
18637	1295	42	.	.	.
18637	1296	1	The	the	DT
18637	1296	2	most	most	RBS
18637	1296	3	serious	serious	JJ
18637	1296	4	inroads	inroad	NNS
18637	1296	5	on	on	IN
18637	1296	6	the	the	DT
18637	1296	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1296	8	of	of	IN
18637	1296	9	enumerated	enumerated	JJ
18637	1296	10	powers	power	NNS
18637	1296	11	are	be	VBP
18637	1296	12	,	,	,
18637	1296	13	in	in	IN
18637	1296	14	fact	fact	NN
18637	1296	15	,	,	,
18637	1296	16	those	those	DT
18637	1296	17	which	which	WDT
18637	1296	18	have	have	VBP
18637	1296	19	taken	take	VBN
18637	1296	20	place	place	NN
18637	1296	21	under	under	IN
18637	1296	22	cover	cover	NN
18637	1296	23	of	of	IN
18637	1296	24	the	the	DT
18637	1296	25	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1296	26	--	--	:
18637	1296	27	the	the	DT
18637	1296	28	vast	vast	JJ
18637	1296	29	expansion	expansion	NN
18637	1296	30	in	in	IN
18637	1296	31	recent	recent	JJ
18637	1296	32	years	year	NNS
18637	1296	33	of	of	IN
18637	1296	34	national	national	JJ
18637	1296	35	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1296	36	power	power	NN
18637	1296	37	in	in	IN
18637	1296	38	the	the	DT
18637	1296	39	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1296	40	of	of	IN
18637	1296	41	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1296	42	among	among	IN
18637	1296	43	the	the	DT
18637	1296	44	States	States	NNP
18637	1296	45	and	and	CC
18637	1296	46	in	in	IN
18637	1296	47	the	the	DT
18637	1296	48	expenditure	expenditure	NN
18637	1296	49	of	of	IN
18637	1296	50	the	the	DT
18637	1296	51	national	national	JJ
18637	1296	52	revenues	revenue	NNS
18637	1296	53	;	;	:
18637	1296	54	and	and	CC
18637	1296	55	verbally	verbally	RB
18637	1296	56	at	at	IN
18637	1296	57	least	least	JJS
18637	1296	58	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1296	59	laid	lay	VBD
18637	1296	60	the	the	DT
18637	1296	61	ground	ground	NN
18637	1296	62	for	for	IN
18637	1296	63	these	these	DT
18637	1296	64	developments	development	NNS
18637	1296	65	in	in	IN
18637	1296	66	some	some	DT
18637	1296	67	of	of	IN
18637	1296	68	the	the	DT
18637	1296	69	phraseology	phraseology	NN
18637	1296	70	above	above	RB
18637	1296	71	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	1296	72	from	from	IN
18637	1296	73	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1296	74	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1296	75	in	in	IN
18637	1296	76	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	1296	77	_	_	NNP
18637	1296	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	1296	79	_	_	NNP
18637	1296	80	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1296	81	.	.	.
18637	1297	1	Nondelegability	Nondelegability	NNP
18637	1297	2	of	of	IN
18637	1297	3	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	1297	4	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1297	5	ORIGIN	ORIGIN	NNP
18637	1297	6	OF	of	IN
18637	1297	7	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNP
18637	1297	8	At	at	IN
18637	1297	9	least	least	RBS
18637	1297	10	three	three	CD
18637	1297	11	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	1297	12	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	1297	13	have	have	VBP
18637	1297	14	contributed	contribute	VBN
18637	1297	15	to	to	IN
18637	1297	16	the	the	DT
18637	1297	17	development	development	NN
18637	1297	18	of	of	IN
18637	1297	19	the	the	DT
18637	1297	20	principle	principle	NN
18637	1297	21	that	that	IN
18637	1297	22	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1297	23	power	power	NN
18637	1297	24	can	can	MD
18637	1297	25	not	not	RB
18637	1297	26	be	be	VB
18637	1297	27	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	1297	28	.	.	.
18637	1298	1	One	one	CD
18637	1298	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1298	3	the	the	DT
18637	1298	4	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1298	5	of	of	IN
18637	1298	6	separation	separation	NN
18637	1298	7	of	of	IN
18637	1298	8	powers	power	NNS
18637	1298	9	:	:	:
18637	1298	10	Why	why	WRB
18637	1298	11	go	go	VB
18637	1298	12	to	to	IN
18637	1298	13	the	the	DT
18637	1298	14	trouble	trouble	NN
18637	1298	15	of	of	IN
18637	1298	16	separating	separate	VBG
18637	1298	17	the	the	DT
18637	1298	18	three	three	CD
18637	1298	19	powers	power	NNS
18637	1298	20	of	of	IN
18637	1298	21	government	government	NN
18637	1298	22	if	if	IN
18637	1298	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1298	24	can	can	MD
18637	1298	25	straightway	straightway	RB
18637	1298	26	remerge	remerge	VB
18637	1298	27	on	on	IN
18637	1298	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1298	29	own	own	JJ
18637	1298	30	motion	motion	NN
18637	1298	31	?	?	.
18637	1299	1	The	the	DT
18637	1299	2	second	second	JJ
18637	1299	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	1299	4	the	the	DT
18637	1299	5	concept	concept	NN
18637	1299	6	of	of	IN
18637	1299	7	due	due	JJ
18637	1299	8	process	process	NN
18637	1299	9	of	of	IN
18637	1299	10	law	law	NN
18637	1299	11	,	,	,
18637	1299	12	which	which	WDT
18637	1299	13	precludes	preclude	VBZ
18637	1299	14	the	the	DT
18637	1299	15	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	1299	16	of	of	IN
18637	1299	17	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	1299	18	functions	function	NNS
18637	1299	19	to	to	IN
18637	1299	20	private	private	JJ
18637	1299	21	persons	person	NNS
18637	1299	22	.	.	.
18637	1300	1	Lastly	lastly	RB
18637	1300	2	,	,	,
18637	1300	3	there	there	EX
18637	1300	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	1300	5	the	the	DT
18637	1300	6	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	1300	7	of	of	IN
18637	1300	8	agency	agency	NN
18637	1300	9	"	"	``
18637	1300	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1300	11	Delegata	Delegata	NNP
18637	1300	12	potestas	potesta	VBD
18637	1300	13	non	non	AFX
18637	1300	14	potest	potest	NNP
18637	1300	15	delegari	delegari	NNP
18637	1300	16	_	_	NNP
18637	1300	17	,	,	,
18637	1300	18	"	"	''
18637	1300	19	which	which	WDT
18637	1300	20	John	John	NNP
18637	1300	21	Locke	Locke	NNP
18637	1300	22	borrowed	borrow	VBD
18637	1300	23	and	and	CC
18637	1300	24	formulated	formulate	VBD
18637	1300	25	as	as	IN
18637	1300	26	a	a	DT
18637	1300	27	dogma	dogma	NN
18637	1300	28	of	of	IN
18637	1300	29	political	political	JJ
18637	1300	30	science	science	NN
18637	1300	31	.	.	.
18637	1301	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1301	2	19	19	CD
18637	1301	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1301	4	In	in	IN
18637	1301	5	Hampton	Hampton	NNP
18637	1301	6	Jr.	Jr.	NNP
18637	1301	7	&	&	CC
18637	1301	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	1301	9	_	_	NNP
18637	1301	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	1301	11	_	_	NNP
18637	1301	12	United	United	NNP
18637	1301	13	States,[20	States,[20	NNP
18637	1301	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1301	15	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1301	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1301	17	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	1301	18	offered	offer	VBD
18637	1301	19	the	the	DT
18637	1301	20	following	follow	VBG
18637	1301	21	explanation	explanation	NN
18637	1301	22	of	of	IN
18637	1301	23	the	the	DT
18637	1301	24	origin	origin	NN
18637	1301	25	and	and	CC
18637	1301	26	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	1301	27	of	of	IN
18637	1301	28	this	this	DT
18637	1301	29	idea	idea	NN
18637	1301	30	as	as	IN
18637	1301	31	a	a	DT
18637	1301	32	postulate	postulate	NN
18637	1301	33	of	of	IN
18637	1301	34	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1301	35	law	law	NN
18637	1301	36	:	:	:
18637	1301	37	"	"	``
18637	1301	38	The	the	DT
18637	1301	39	well	well	RB
18637	1301	40	-	-	HYPH
18637	1301	41	known	know	VBN
18637	1301	42	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	1301	43	'	'	''
18637	1301	44	_	_	NNP
18637	1301	45	Delegata	Delegata	NNP
18637	1301	46	potestas	potesta	VBD
18637	1301	47	non	non	AFX
18637	1301	48	potest	potest	NNP
18637	1301	49	delegari	delegari	NNP
18637	1301	50	_	_	NNP
18637	1301	51	,	,	,
18637	1301	52	'	'	''
18637	1301	53	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	1301	54	to	to	IN
18637	1301	55	the	the	DT
18637	1301	56	law	law	NN
18637	1301	57	of	of	IN
18637	1301	58	agency	agency	NN
18637	1301	59	in	in	IN
18637	1301	60	the	the	DT
18637	1301	61	general	general	JJ
18637	1301	62	and	and	CC
18637	1301	63	common	common	JJ
18637	1301	64	law	law	NN
18637	1301	65	,	,	,
18637	1301	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	1301	67	well	well	RB
18637	1301	68	understood	understand	VBN
18637	1301	69	and	and	CC
18637	1301	70	has	have	VBZ
18637	1301	71	had	have	VBN
18637	1301	72	wider	wide	JJR
18637	1301	73	application	application	NN
18637	1301	74	in	in	IN
18637	1301	75	the	the	DT
18637	1301	76	construction	construction	NN
18637	1301	77	of	of	IN
18637	1301	78	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1301	79	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1301	80	and	and	CC
18637	1301	81	State	State	NNP
18637	1301	82	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
18637	1301	83	than	than	IN
18637	1301	84	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1301	85	has	have	VBZ
18637	1301	86	in	in	IN
18637	1301	87	private	private	JJ
18637	1301	88	law	law	NN
18637	1301	89	.	.	.
18637	1302	1	The	the	DT
18637	1302	2	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1302	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1302	4	and	and	CC
18637	1302	5	State	State	NNP
18637	1302	6	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
18637	1302	7	of	of	IN
18637	1302	8	this	this	DT
18637	1302	9	country	country	NN
18637	1302	10	divide	divide	VBP
18637	1302	11	the	the	DT
18637	1302	12	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	1302	13	power	power	NN
18637	1302	14	into	into	IN
18637	1302	15	three	three	CD
18637	1302	16	branches	branch	NNS
18637	1302	17	.	.	.
18637	1303	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1303	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1303	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1303	4	in	in	IN
18637	1303	5	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	1303	6	out	out	RP
18637	1303	7	that	that	IN
18637	1303	8	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1303	9	division	division	NN
18637	1303	10	*	*	NFP
18637	1303	11	*	*	NFP
18637	1303	12	*	*	NFP
18637	1303	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1303	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	1303	15	a	a	DT
18637	1303	16	breach	breach	NN
18637	1303	17	of	of	IN
18637	1303	18	the	the	DT
18637	1303	19	National	national	JJ
18637	1303	20	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	1303	21	law	law	NN
18637	1303	22	if	if	IN
18637	1303	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1303	24	gives	give	VBZ
18637	1303	25	up	up	RP
18637	1303	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1303	27	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1303	28	power	power	NN
18637	1303	29	and	and	CC
18637	1303	30	transfers	transfer	VBZ
18637	1303	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1303	32	to	to	IN
18637	1303	33	the	the	DT
18637	1303	34	President	President	NNP
18637	1303	35	,	,	,
18637	1303	36	or	or	CC
18637	1303	37	to	to	IN
18637	1303	38	the	the	DT
18637	1303	39	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1303	40	branch	branch	NN
18637	1303	41	,	,	,
18637	1303	42	or	or	CC
18637	1303	43	if	if	IN
18637	1303	44	by	by	IN
18637	1303	45	law	law	NN
18637	1303	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1303	47	attempts	attempt	VBZ
18637	1303	48	to	to	TO
18637	1303	49	invest	invest	VB
18637	1303	50	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1303	51	or	or	CC
18637	1303	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1303	53	members	member	NNS
18637	1303	54	with	with	IN
18637	1303	55	either	either	DT
18637	1303	56	executive	executive	JJ
18637	1303	57	power	power	NN
18637	1303	58	or	or	CC
18637	1303	59	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1303	60	power	power	NN
18637	1303	61	.	.	.
18637	1304	1	This	this	DT
18637	1304	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1304	3	not	not	RB
18637	1304	4	to	to	TO
18637	1304	5	say	say	VB
18637	1304	6	that	that	IN
18637	1304	7	the	the	DT
18637	1304	8	three	three	CD
18637	1304	9	branches	branch	NNS
18637	1304	10	are	be	VBP
18637	1304	11	not	not	RB
18637	1304	12	co	co	JJ
18637	1304	13	-	-	JJ
18637	1304	14	ordinate	ordinate	JJ
18637	1304	15	parts	part	NNS
18637	1304	16	of	of	IN
18637	1304	17	one	one	CD
18637	1304	18	government	government	NN
18637	1304	19	and	and	CC
18637	1304	20	that	that	IN
18637	1304	21	each	each	DT
18637	1304	22	in	in	IN
18637	1304	23	the	the	DT
18637	1304	24	field	field	NN
18637	1304	25	of	of	IN
18637	1304	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1304	27	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1304	28	may	may	MD
18637	1304	29	not	not	RB
18637	1304	30	invoke	invoke	VB
18637	1304	31	the	the	DT
18637	1304	32	action	action	NN
18637	1304	33	of	of	IN
18637	1304	34	the	the	DT
18637	1304	35	two	two	CD
18637	1304	36	other	other	JJ
18637	1304	37	branches	branch	NNS
18637	1304	38	in	in	IN
18637	1304	39	so	so	RB
18637	1304	40	far	far	RB
18637	1304	41	as	as	IN
18637	1304	42	the	the	DT
18637	1304	43	action	action	NN
18637	1304	44	invoked	invoke	VBD
18637	1304	45	shall	shall	MD
18637	1304	46	not	not	RB
18637	1304	47	be	be	VB
18637	1304	48	an	an	DT
18637	1304	49	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	1304	50	of	of	IN
18637	1304	51	the	the	DT
18637	1304	52	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1304	53	field	field	NN
18637	1304	54	of	of	IN
18637	1304	55	action	action	NN
18637	1304	56	of	of	IN
18637	1304	57	another	another	DT
18637	1304	58	branch	branch	NN
18637	1304	59	.	.	.
18637	1305	1	In	in	IN
18637	1305	2	determining	determine	VBG
18637	1305	3	what	what	WP
18637	1305	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1305	5	may	may	MD
18637	1305	6	do	do	VB
18637	1305	7	in	in	IN
18637	1305	8	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	1305	9	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	1305	10	from	from	IN
18637	1305	11	another	another	DT
18637	1305	12	branch	branch	NN
18637	1305	13	,	,	,
18637	1305	14	the	the	DT
18637	1305	15	extent	extent	NN
18637	1305	16	and	and	CC
18637	1305	17	character	character	NN
18637	1305	18	of	of	IN
18637	1305	19	that	that	DT
18637	1305	20	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	1305	21	must	must	MD
18637	1305	22	be	be	VB
18637	1305	23	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	1305	24	according	accord	VBG
18637	1305	25	to	to	IN
18637	1305	26	common	common	JJ
18637	1305	27	sense	sense	NN
18637	1305	28	and	and	CC
18637	1305	29	the	the	DT
18637	1305	30	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	1305	31	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	1305	32	of	of	IN
18637	1305	33	the	the	DT
18637	1305	34	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	1305	35	co	co	NN
18637	1305	36	-	-	NN
18637	1305	37	ordination	ordination	NN
18637	1305	38	.	.	.
18637	1306	1	"	"	``
18637	1306	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1306	3	21	21	CD
18637	1306	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1306	5	FUNCTIONS	functions	NN
18637	1306	6	WHICH	which	WDT
18637	1306	7	MAY	MAY	MD
18637	1306	8	BE	be	VB
18637	1306	9	DELEGATED	delegate	VBD
18637	1306	10	Yielding	yield	VBG
18637	1306	11	to	to	TO
18637	1306	12	"	"	``
18637	1306	13	common	common	JJ
18637	1306	14	sense	sense	NN
18637	1306	15	and	and	CC
18637	1306	16	the	the	DT
18637	1306	17	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	1306	18	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	1306	19	of	of	IN
18637	1306	20	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	1306	21	co	co	JJ
18637	1306	22	-	-	NN
18637	1306	23	ordination	ordination	JJ
18637	1306	24	"	"	''
18637	1306	25	the	the	DT
18637	1306	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1306	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	1306	28	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	1306	29	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	1306	30	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	1306	31	granting	grant	VBG
18637	1306	32	in	in	IN
18637	1306	33	the	the	DT
18637	1306	34	total	total	JJ
18637	1306	35	vast	vast	JJ
18637	1306	36	powers	power	NNS
18637	1306	37	to	to	TO
18637	1306	38	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	1306	39	or	or	CC
18637	1306	40	executive	executive	JJ
18637	1306	41	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	1306	42	.	.	.
18637	1307	1	Two	two	CD
18637	1307	2	different	different	JJ
18637	1307	3	theories	theory	NNS
18637	1307	4	,	,	,
18637	1307	5	both	both	DT
18637	1307	6	enunciated	enunciate	VBD
18637	1307	7	during	during	IN
18637	1307	8	the	the	DT
18637	1307	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1307	10	Justiceship	Justiceship	NNP
18637	1307	11	of	of	IN
18637	1307	12	John	John	NNP
18637	1307	13	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1307	14	,	,	,
18637	1307	15	have	have	VBP
18637	1307	16	been	be	VBN
18637	1307	17	utilized	utilize	VBN
18637	1307	18	to	to	TO
18637	1307	19	justify	justify	VB
18637	1307	20	these	these	DT
18637	1307	21	results	result	NNS
18637	1307	22	.	.	.
18637	1308	1	First	first	RB
18637	1308	2	in	in	IN
18637	1308	3	importance	importance	NN
18637	1308	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	1308	5	the	the	DT
18637	1308	6	theory	theory	NN
18637	1308	7	that	that	IN
18637	1308	8	another	another	DT
18637	1308	9	department	department	NN
18637	1308	10	may	may	MD
18637	1308	11	be	be	VB
18637	1308	12	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	1308	13	to	to	TO
18637	1308	14	"	"	``
18637	1308	15	fill	fill	VB
18637	1308	16	up	up	RP
18637	1308	17	the	the	DT
18637	1308	18	details	detail	NNS
18637	1308	19	"	"	''
18637	1308	20	of	of	IN
18637	1308	21	a	a	DT
18637	1308	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	1308	23	.	.	.
18637	1309	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1309	2	22	22	CD
18637	1309	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1309	4	The	the	DT
18637	1309	5	second	second	JJ
18637	1309	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	1309	7	that	that	IN
18637	1309	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1309	9	may	may	MD
18637	1309	10	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	1309	11	contingently	contingently	RB
18637	1309	12	,	,	,
18637	1309	13	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	1309	14	to	to	IN
18637	1309	15	others	other	NNS
18637	1309	16	the	the	DT
18637	1309	17	task	task	NN
18637	1309	18	of	of	IN
18637	1309	19	ascertaining	ascertain	VBG
18637	1309	20	the	the	DT
18637	1309	21	facts	fact	NNS
18637	1309	22	which	which	WDT
18637	1309	23	bring	bring	VBP
18637	1309	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1309	25	declared	declared	JJ
18637	1309	26	policy	policy	NN
18637	1309	27	into	into	IN
18637	1309	28	operation	operation	NN
18637	1309	29	.	.	.
18637	1310	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1310	2	23	23	CD
18637	1310	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1310	4	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	1310	5	TO	to	TO
18637	1310	6	SUPPLEMENT	SUPPLEMENT	NNP
18637	1310	7	STATUTORY	STATUTORY	NNP
18637	1310	8	PROVISIONS	PROVISIONS	NNP
18637	1310	9	The	the	DT
18637	1310	10	pioneer	pioneer	NN
18637	1310	11	case	case	NN
18637	1310	12	which	which	WDT
18637	1310	13	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	1310	14	the	the	DT
18637	1310	15	right	right	NN
18637	1310	16	of	of	IN
18637	1310	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1310	18	to	to	TO
18637	1310	19	lodge	lodge	VB
18637	1310	20	in	in	IN
18637	1310	21	another	another	DT
18637	1310	22	department	department	NN
18637	1310	23	the	the	DT
18637	1310	24	power	power	NN
18637	1310	25	to	to	TO
18637	1310	26	"	"	``
18637	1310	27	fill	fill	VB
18637	1310	28	up	up	RP
18637	1310	29	the	the	DT
18637	1310	30	details	detail	NNS
18637	1310	31	"	"	''
18637	1310	32	of	of	IN
18637	1310	33	a	a	DT
18637	1310	34	statute	statute	NN
18637	1310	35	arose	arise	VBD
18637	1310	36	out	out	IN
18637	1310	37	of	of	IN
18637	1310	38	the	the	DT
18637	1310	39	authority	authority	NN
18637	1310	40	given	give	VBN
18637	1310	41	to	to	IN
18637	1310	42	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1310	43	courts	court	NNS
18637	1310	44	to	to	TO
18637	1310	45	establish	establish	VB
18637	1310	46	rules	rule	NNS
18637	1310	47	of	of	IN
18637	1310	48	practice	practice	NN
18637	1310	49	,	,	,
18637	1310	50	provided	provide	VBN
18637	1310	51	such	such	JJ
18637	1310	52	rules	rule	NNS
18637	1310	53	were	be	VBD
18637	1310	54	not	not	RB
18637	1310	55	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	1310	56	to	to	IN
18637	1310	57	the	the	DT
18637	1310	58	laws	law	NNS
18637	1310	59	of	of	IN
18637	1310	60	the	the	DT
18637	1310	61	United	United	NNP
18637	1310	62	States	States	NNP
18637	1310	63	.	.	.
18637	1311	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1311	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1311	3	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1311	4	overruled	overrule	VBD
18637	1311	5	the	the	DT
18637	1311	6	objection	objection	NN
18637	1311	7	that	that	IN
18637	1311	8	this	this	DT
18637	1311	9	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	1311	10	an	an	DT
18637	1311	11	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	1311	12	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	1311	13	of	of	IN
18637	1311	14	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1311	15	power	power	NN
18637	1311	16	,	,	,
18637	1311	17	saying	say	VBG
18637	1311	18	:	:	:
18637	1311	19	"	"	``
18637	1311	20	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1311	21	will	will	MD
18637	1311	22	not	not	RB
18637	1311	23	be	be	VB
18637	1311	24	contended	contend	VBN
18637	1311	25	,	,	,
18637	1311	26	that	that	IN
18637	1311	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1311	28	can	can	MD
18637	1311	29	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	1311	30	to	to	IN
18637	1311	31	the	the	DT
18637	1311	32	courts	court	NNS
18637	1311	33	,	,	,
18637	1311	34	or	or	CC
18637	1311	35	to	to	IN
18637	1311	36	any	any	DT
18637	1311	37	other	other	JJ
18637	1311	38	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	1311	39	,	,	,
18637	1311	40	powers	power	NNS
18637	1311	41	which	which	WDT
18637	1311	42	are	be	VBP
18637	1311	43	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	1311	44	and	and	CC
18637	1311	45	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	1311	46	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1311	47	.	.	.
18637	1312	1	But	but	CC
18637	1312	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1312	3	may	may	MD
18637	1312	4	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	1312	5	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	1312	6	to	to	IN
18637	1312	7	others	other	NNS
18637	1312	8	,	,	,
18637	1312	9	powers	power	NNS
18637	1312	10	which	which	WDT
18637	1312	11	the	the	DT
18637	1312	12	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1312	13	may	may	MD
18637	1312	14	rightfully	rightfully	RB
18637	1312	15	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	1312	16	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1312	17	.	.	.
18637	1313	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1313	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1313	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1313	4	The	the	DT
18637	1313	5	line	line	NN
18637	1313	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	1313	7	not	not	RB
18637	1313	8	been	be	VBN
18637	1313	9	exactly	exactly	RB
18637	1313	10	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	1313	11	which	which	WDT
18637	1313	12	separates	separate	VBZ
18637	1313	13	those	those	DT
18637	1313	14	important	important	JJ
18637	1313	15	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	1313	16	,	,	,
18637	1313	17	which	which	WDT
18637	1313	18	must	must	MD
18637	1313	19	be	be	VB
18637	1313	20	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	1313	21	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	1313	22	by	by	IN
18637	1313	23	the	the	DT
18637	1313	24	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1313	25	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1313	26	,	,	,
18637	1313	27	from	from	IN
18637	1313	28	those	those	DT
18637	1313	29	of	of	IN
18637	1313	30	less	less	JJR
18637	1313	31	interest	interest	NN
18637	1313	32	,	,	,
18637	1313	33	in	in	IN
18637	1313	34	which	which	WDT
18637	1313	35	a	a	DT
18637	1313	36	general	general	JJ
18637	1313	37	provision	provision	NN
18637	1313	38	may	may	MD
18637	1313	39	be	be	VB
18637	1313	40	made	make	VBN
18637	1313	41	,	,	,
18637	1313	42	and	and	CC
18637	1313	43	power	power	NN
18637	1313	44	given	give	VBN
18637	1313	45	to	to	IN
18637	1313	46	those	those	DT
18637	1313	47	who	who	WP
18637	1313	48	are	be	VBP
18637	1313	49	to	to	TO
18637	1313	50	act	act	VB
18637	1313	51	under	under	IN
18637	1313	52	such	such	JJ
18637	1313	53	general	general	JJ
18637	1313	54	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	1313	55	,	,	,
18637	1313	56	to	to	TO
18637	1313	57	fill	fill	VB
18637	1313	58	up	up	RP
18637	1313	59	the	the	DT
18637	1313	60	details	detail	NNS
18637	1313	61	.	.	.
18637	1314	1	"	"	``
18637	1314	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1314	3	24	24	CD
18637	1314	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1314	5	STANDARDS	standard	NNS
18637	1314	6	FOR	for	IN
18637	1314	7	ADMINISTRATIVE	ADMINISTRATIVE	NNP
18637	1314	8	ACTION	action	NN
18637	1314	9	Before	before	IN
18637	1314	10	another	another	DT
18637	1314	11	agency	agency	NN
18637	1314	12	can	can	MD
18637	1314	13	"	"	``
18637	1314	14	fill	fill	VB
18637	1314	15	up	up	RP
18637	1314	16	the	the	DT
18637	1314	17	details	detail	NNS
18637	1314	18	,	,	,
18637	1314	19	"	"	``
18637	1314	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1314	21	must	must	MD
18637	1314	22	enact	enact	VB
18637	1314	23	something	something	NN
18637	1314	24	to	to	TO
18637	1314	25	be	be	VB
18637	1314	26	thus	thus	RB
18637	1314	27	supplemented	supplement	VBN
18637	1314	28	.	.	.
18637	1315	1	In	in	IN
18637	1315	2	the	the	DT
18637	1315	3	current	current	JJ
18637	1315	4	idiom	idiom	NN
18637	1315	5	,	,	,
18637	1315	6	the	the	DT
18637	1315	7	lawmakers	lawmaker	NNS
18637	1315	8	must	must	MD
18637	1315	9	first	first	RB
18637	1315	10	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	1315	11	a	a	DT
18637	1315	12	policy	policy	NN
18637	1315	13	or	or	CC
18637	1315	14	set	set	VBN
18637	1315	15	up	up	RP
18637	1315	16	an	an	DT
18637	1315	17	"	"	``
18637	1315	18	intelligible	intelligible	JJ
18637	1315	19	standard	standard	NN
18637	1315	20	"	"	''
18637	1315	21	to	to	TO
18637	1315	22	which	which	WDT
18637	1315	23	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	1315	24	action	action	NN
18637	1315	25	must	must	MD
18637	1315	26	conform	conform	VB
18637	1315	27	.	.	.
18637	1316	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1316	2	25	25	CD
18637	1316	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1316	4	But	but	CC
18637	1316	5	the	the	DT
18637	1316	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1316	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	1316	8	taken	take	VBN
18637	1316	9	a	a	DT
18637	1316	10	generous	generous	JJ
18637	1316	11	view	view	NN
18637	1316	12	of	of	IN
18637	1316	13	what	what	WP
18637	1316	14	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	1316	15	a	a	DT
18637	1316	16	policy	policy	NN
18637	1316	17	or	or	CC
18637	1316	18	standard	standard	NN
18637	1316	19	.	.	.
18637	1317	1	Although	although	IN
18637	1317	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1317	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	1317	4	said	say	VBN
18637	1317	5	that	that	IN
18637	1317	6	"	"	``
18637	1317	7	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	1317	8	safeguards	safeguard	NNS
18637	1317	9	can	can	MD
18637	1317	10	not	not	RB
18637	1317	11	validate	validate	VB
18637	1317	12	an	an	DT
18637	1317	13	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	1317	14	delegation,"[26	delegation,"[26	NN
18637	1317	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1317	16	the	the	DT
18637	1317	17	nature	nature	NN
18637	1317	18	of	of	IN
18637	1317	19	the	the	DT
18637	1317	20	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	1317	21	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1317	22	to	to	TO
18637	1317	23	be	be	VB
18637	1317	24	one	one	CD
18637	1317	25	of	of	IN
18637	1317	26	the	the	DT
18637	1317	27	elements	element	NNS
18637	1317	28	weighed	weigh	VBD
18637	1317	29	in	in	IN
18637	1317	30	determining	determine	VBG
18637	1317	31	whether	whether	IN
18637	1317	32	a	a	DT
18637	1317	33	specific	specific	JJ
18637	1317	34	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	1317	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	1317	36	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1317	37	.	.	.
18637	1318	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1318	2	27	27	CD
18637	1318	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1318	4	In	in	IN
18637	1318	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	1318	6	where	where	WRB
18637	1318	7	the	the	DT
18637	1318	8	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	1318	9	power	power	NN
18637	1318	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	1318	11	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	1318	12	by	by	IN
18637	1318	13	orders	order	NNS
18637	1318	14	directed	direct	VBN
18637	1318	15	to	to	IN
18637	1318	16	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1318	17	persons	person	NNS
18637	1318	18	after	after	IN
18637	1318	19	notice	notice	NN
18637	1318	20	and	and	CC
18637	1318	21	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	1318	22	,	,	,
18637	1318	23	with	with	IN
18637	1318	24	findings	finding	NNS
18637	1318	25	of	of	IN
18637	1318	26	fact	fact	NN
18637	1318	27	and	and	CC
18637	1318	28	of	of	IN
18637	1318	29	law	law	NN
18637	1318	30	based	base	VBN
18637	1318	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	1318	32	the	the	DT
18637	1318	33	record	record	NN
18637	1318	34	made	make	VBN
18637	1318	35	in	in	IN
18637	1318	36	the	the	DT
18637	1318	37	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	1318	38	,	,	,
18637	1318	39	the	the	DT
18637	1318	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1318	41	has	have	VBZ
18637	1318	42	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	1318	43	that	that	IN
18637	1318	44	such	such	JJ
18637	1318	45	general	general	JJ
18637	1318	46	terms	term	NNS
18637	1318	47	as	as	IN
18637	1318	48	"	"	``
18637	1318	49	public	public	JJ
18637	1318	50	interest,"[28	interest,"[28	NNP
18637	1318	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1318	52	"	"	``
18637	1318	53	public	public	JJ
18637	1318	54	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	1318	55	,	,	,
18637	1318	56	interest	interest	NN
18637	1318	57	,	,	,
18637	1318	58	or	or	CC
18637	1318	59	necessity,"[29	necessity,"[29	NNP
18637	1318	60	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1318	61	or	or	CC
18637	1318	62	"	"	``
18637	1318	63	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	1318	64	profits,"[30	profits,"[30	NN
18637	1318	65	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1318	66	were	be	VBD
18637	1318	67	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	1318	68	to	to	TO
18637	1318	69	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	1318	70	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1318	71	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	1318	72	.	.	.
18637	1319	1	But	but	CC
18637	1319	2	in	in	IN
18637	1319	3	two	two	CD
18637	1319	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	1319	5	arising	arise	VBG
18637	1319	6	under	under	IN
18637	1319	7	the	the	DT
18637	1319	8	National	National	NNP
18637	1319	9	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	1319	10	Recovery	Recovery	NNP
18637	1319	11	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1319	12	,	,	,
18637	1319	13	a	a	DT
18637	1319	14	policy	policy	NN
18637	1319	15	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	1319	16	of	of	IN
18637	1319	17	comparable	comparable	JJ
18637	1319	18	generality	generality	NN
18637	1319	19	was	be	VBD
18637	1319	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	1319	21	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	1319	22	for	for	IN
18637	1319	23	the	the	DT
18637	1319	24	promulgation	promulgation	NN
18637	1319	25	of	of	IN
18637	1319	26	rules	rule	NNS
18637	1319	27	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	1319	28	to	to	IN
18637	1319	29	all	all	DT
18637	1319	30	persons	person	NNS
18637	1319	31	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1319	32	in	in	IN
18637	1319	33	a	a	DT
18637	1319	34	designated	designate	VBN
18637	1319	35	activity	activity	NN
18637	1319	36	,	,	,
18637	1319	37	without	without	IN
18637	1319	38	the	the	DT
18637	1319	39	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	1319	40	safeguards	safeguard	NNS
18637	1319	41	which	which	WDT
18637	1319	42	surround	surround	VBP
18637	1319	43	the	the	DT
18637	1319	44	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	1319	45	of	of	IN
18637	1319	46	individual	individual	JJ
18637	1319	47	orders	order	NNS
18637	1319	48	.	.	.
18637	1320	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1320	2	31	31	CD
18637	1320	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1320	4	By	by	IN
18637	1320	5	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	1320	6	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	1320	7	,	,	,
18637	1320	8	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	1320	9	more	more	RBR
18637	1320	10	elaborate	elaborate	JJ
18637	1320	11	,	,	,
18637	1320	12	but	but	CC
18637	1320	13	still	still	RB
18637	1320	14	very	very	RB
18637	1320	15	broad	broad	JJ
18637	1320	16	,	,	,
18637	1320	17	standards	standard	NNS
18637	1320	18	have	have	VBP
18637	1320	19	been	be	VBN
18637	1320	20	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	1320	21	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	1320	22	for	for	IN
18637	1320	23	various	various	JJ
18637	1320	24	price	price	NN
18637	1320	25	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	1320	26	measures	measure	NNS
18637	1320	27	.	.	.
18637	1321	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1321	2	32	32	CD
18637	1321	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1321	4	In	in	IN
18637	1321	5	a	a	DT
18637	1321	6	recent	recent	JJ
18637	1321	7	case,[33	case,[33	CD
18637	1321	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1321	9	the	the	DT
18637	1321	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1321	11	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1321	12	a	a	DT
18637	1321	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	1321	14	which	which	WDT
18637	1321	15	,	,	,
18637	1321	16	without	without	IN
18637	1321	17	any	any	DT
18637	1321	18	explicit	explicit	JJ
18637	1321	19	standards	standard	NNS
18637	1321	20	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	1321	21	,	,	,
18637	1321	22	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	1321	23	the	the	DT
18637	1321	24	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1321	25	Home	Home	NNP
18637	1321	26	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	1321	27	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	1321	28	Board	Board	NNP
18637	1321	29	to	to	TO
18637	1321	30	make	make	VB
18637	1321	31	rules	rule	NNS
18637	1321	32	and	and	CC
18637	1321	33	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1321	34	for	for	IN
18637	1321	35	the	the	DT
18637	1321	36	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	1321	37	of	of	IN
18637	1321	38	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1321	39	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	1321	40	and	and	CC
18637	1321	41	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	1321	42	Associations	Associations	NNPS
18637	1321	43	.	.	.
18637	1322	1	That	that	DT
18637	1322	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	1322	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1322	4	influenced	influence	VBN
18637	1322	5	by	by	IN
18637	1322	6	the	the	DT
18637	1322	7	fact	fact	NN
18637	1322	8	that	that	IN
18637	1322	9	the	the	DT
18637	1322	10	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	1322	11	was	be	VBD
18637	1322	12	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	1322	13	by	by	IN
18637	1322	14	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1322	15	law	law	NN
18637	1322	16	as	as	RB
18637	1322	17	well	well	RB
18637	1322	18	as	as	IN
18637	1322	19	by	by	IN
18637	1322	20	the	the	DT
18637	1322	21	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	1322	22	problems	problem	NNS
18637	1322	23	involved	involve	VBN
18637	1322	24	in	in	IN
18637	1322	25	the	the	DT
18637	1322	26	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	1322	27	of	of	IN
18637	1322	28	financial	financial	JJ
18637	1322	29	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	1322	30	.	.	.
18637	1323	1	The	the	DT
18637	1323	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1323	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1323	4	at	at	IN
18637	1323	5	pains	pain	NNS
18637	1323	6	to	to	TO
18637	1323	7	make	make	VB
18637	1323	8	clear	clear	JJ
18637	1323	9	that	that	IN
18637	1323	10	this	this	DT
18637	1323	11	decision	decision	NN
18637	1323	12	would	would	MD
18637	1323	13	not	not	RB
18637	1323	14	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	1323	15	govern	govern	VB
18637	1323	16	the	the	DT
18637	1323	17	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	1323	18	of	of	IN
18637	1323	19	dissimilar	dissimilar	JJ
18637	1323	20	cases	case	NNS
18637	1323	21	.	.	.
18637	1324	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1324	2	34	34	CD
18637	1324	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1324	4	RULE	rule	NN
18637	1324	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	1324	6	MAKING	making	NN
18637	1324	7	POWER	POWER	NNP
18637	1324	8	After	after	IN
18637	1324	9	Wayman	Wayman	NNP
18637	1324	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1324	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	1324	12	_	_	NNP
18637	1324	13	Southard	Southard	NNP
18637	1324	14	,	,	,
18637	1324	15	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	1324	16	three	three	CD
18637	1324	17	quarters	quarter	NNS
18637	1324	18	of	of	IN
18637	1324	19	a	a	DT
18637	1324	20	century	century	NN
18637	1324	21	elapsed	elapse	VBN
18637	1324	22	before	before	IN
18637	1324	23	the	the	DT
18637	1324	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1324	25	had	have	VBD
18637	1324	26	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	1324	27	to	to	TO
18637	1324	28	approve	approve	VB
18637	1324	29	the	the	DT
18637	1324	30	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	1324	31	to	to	IN
18637	1324	32	an	an	DT
18637	1324	33	executive	executive	JJ
18637	1324	34	officer	officer	NN
18637	1324	35	of	of	IN
18637	1324	36	power	power	NN
18637	1324	37	to	to	TO
18637	1324	38	issue	issue	VB
18637	1324	39	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1324	40	for	for	IN
18637	1324	41	the	the	DT
18637	1324	42	administration	administration	NN
18637	1324	43	of	of	IN
18637	1324	44	a	a	DT
18637	1324	45	statute	statute	NN
18637	1324	46	.	.	.
18637	1325	1	In	in	IN
18637	1325	2	1897	1897	CD
18637	1325	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1325	4	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1325	5	the	the	DT
18637	1325	6	authority	authority	NN
18637	1325	7	granted	grant	VBN
18637	1325	8	to	to	IN
18637	1325	9	the	the	DT
18637	1325	10	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	1325	11	of	of	IN
18637	1325	12	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	1325	13	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	1325	14	to	to	TO
18637	1325	15	designate	designate	VB
18637	1325	16	the	the	DT
18637	1325	17	"	"	``
18637	1325	18	marks	mark	NNS
18637	1325	19	,	,	,
18637	1325	20	brands	brand	NNS
18637	1325	21	and	and	CC
18637	1325	22	stamps	stamp	NNS
18637	1325	23	"	"	''
18637	1325	24	to	to	TO
18637	1325	25	be	be	VB
18637	1325	26	affixed	affix	VBN
18637	1325	27	to	to	IN
18637	1325	28	packages	package	NNS
18637	1325	29	of	of	IN
18637	1325	30	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
18637	1325	31	.	.	.
18637	1326	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1326	2	35	35	CD
18637	1326	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1326	4	Soon	soon	RB
18637	1326	5	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	1326	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1326	7	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	1326	8	an	an	DT
18637	1326	9	act	act	NN
18637	1326	10	which	which	WDT
18637	1326	11	directed	direct	VBD
18637	1326	12	the	the	DT
18637	1326	13	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1326	14	of	of	IN
18637	1326	15	the	the	DT
18637	1326	16	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	1326	17	to	to	TO
18637	1326	18	promulgate	promulgate	VB
18637	1326	19	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	1326	20	standards	standard	NNS
18637	1326	21	of	of	IN
18637	1326	22	quality	quality	NN
18637	1326	23	and	and	CC
18637	1326	24	purity	purity	NN
18637	1326	25	for	for	IN
18637	1326	26	tea	tea	NN
18637	1326	27	imported	import	VBN
18637	1326	28	into	into	IN
18637	1326	29	the	the	DT
18637	1326	30	United	United	NNP
18637	1326	31	States	States	NNP
18637	1326	32	.	.	.
18637	1327	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1327	2	36	36	CD
18637	1327	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1327	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1327	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	1327	6	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1327	7	the	the	DT
18637	1327	8	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	1327	9	to	to	IN
18637	1327	10	executive	executive	JJ
18637	1327	11	or	or	CC
18637	1327	12	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	1327	13	officials	official	NNS
18637	1327	14	of	of	IN
18637	1327	15	authority	authority	NN
18637	1327	16	to	to	TO
18637	1327	17	make	make	VB
18637	1327	18	rules	rule	NNS
18637	1327	19	governing	govern	VBG
18637	1327	20	the	the	DT
18637	1327	21	use	use	NN
18637	1327	22	of	of	IN
18637	1327	23	forest	forest	NN
18637	1327	24	reservations;[37	reservations;[37	NNP
18637	1327	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1327	26	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	1327	27	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	1327	28	variations	variation	NNS
18637	1327	29	and	and	CC
18637	1327	30	tolerances	tolerance	NNS
18637	1327	31	in	in	IN
18637	1327	32	the	the	DT
18637	1327	33	marking	marking	NN
18637	1327	34	of	of	IN
18637	1327	35	food	food	NN
18637	1327	36	packages	package	NNS
18637	1327	37	to	to	TO
18637	1327	38	disclose	disclose	VB
18637	1327	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1327	40	contents;[38	contents;[38	NNP
18637	1327	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1327	42	designating	designate	VBG
18637	1327	43	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	1327	44	markets	market	NNS
18637	1327	45	at	at	IN
18637	1327	46	which	which	WDT
18637	1327	47	grading	grading	NN
18637	1327	48	of	of	IN
18637	1327	49	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	1327	50	would	would	MD
18637	1327	51	be	be	VB
18637	1327	52	compulsory;[39	compulsory;[39	NNP
18637	1327	53	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1327	54	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	1327	55	priorities	priority	NNS
18637	1327	56	for	for	IN
18637	1327	57	the	the	DT
18637	1327	58	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1327	59	of	of	IN
18637	1327	60	freight	freight	NN
18637	1327	61	during	during	IN
18637	1327	62	a	a	DT
18637	1327	63	period	period	NN
18637	1327	64	of	of	IN
18637	1327	65	emergency;[40	emergency;[40	NNP
18637	1327	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1327	67	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	1327	68	price	price	NN
18637	1327	69	schedules	schedule	NNS
18637	1327	70	for	for	IN
18637	1327	71	the	the	DT
18637	1327	72	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	1327	73	of	of	IN
18637	1327	74	milk;[41	milk;[41	NNP
18637	1327	75	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1327	76	or	or	CC
18637	1327	77	for	for	IN
18637	1327	78	all	all	DT
18637	1327	79	commodities[42	commodities[42	NN
18637	1327	80	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1327	81	and	and	CC
18637	1327	82	for	for	IN
18637	1327	83	rental	rental	JJ
18637	1327	84	housing[43	housing[43	NNP
18637	1327	85	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1327	86	in	in	IN
18637	1327	87	time	time	NN
18637	1327	88	of	of	IN
18637	1327	89	war	war	NN
18637	1327	90	;	;	,
18637	1327	91	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	1327	92	wages	wage	NNS
18637	1327	93	and	and	CC
18637	1327	94	prices	price	NNS
18637	1327	95	in	in	IN
18637	1327	96	the	the	DT
18637	1327	97	production	production	NN
18637	1327	98	and	and	CC
18637	1327	99	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	1327	100	of	of	IN
18637	1327	101	coal;[44	coal;[44	NNP
18637	1327	102	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1327	103	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	1327	104	a	a	DT
18637	1327	105	curfew	curfew	NN
18637	1327	106	to	to	TO
18637	1327	107	protect	protect	VB
18637	1327	108	military	military	JJ
18637	1327	109	resources	resource	NNS
18637	1327	110	in	in	IN
18637	1327	111	designated	designate	VBN
18637	1327	112	areas	area	NNS
18637	1327	113	from	from	IN
18637	1327	114	espionage	espionage	NN
18637	1327	115	and	and	CC
18637	1327	116	sabotage;[45	sabotage;[45	NNP
18637	1327	117	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1327	118	providing	provide	VBG
18637	1327	119	for	for	IN
18637	1327	120	the	the	DT
18637	1327	121	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	1327	122	of	of	IN
18637	1327	123	receivers	receiver	NNS
18637	1327	124	or	or	CC
18637	1327	125	conservators	conservator	NNS
18637	1327	126	for	for	IN
18637	1327	127	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1327	128	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	1327	129	and	and	CC
18637	1327	130	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	1327	131	Associations;[46	Associations;[46	NNP
18637	1327	132	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1327	133	allotting	allot	VBG
18637	1327	134	marketing	marketing	NN
18637	1327	135	quotas	quota	NNS
18637	1327	136	for	for	IN
18637	1327	137	tobacco;[47	tobacco;[47	NNP
18637	1327	138	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1327	139	and	and	CC
18637	1327	140	prescribing	prescribing	NN
18637	1327	141	methods	method	NNS
18637	1327	142	of	of	IN
18637	1327	143	accounting	account	VBG
18637	1327	144	for	for	IN
18637	1327	145	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	1327	146	in	in	IN
18637	1327	147	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1327	148	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1327	149	.	.	.
18637	1328	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1328	2	48	48	CD
18637	1328	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1328	4	ORDERS	order	NNS
18637	1328	5	DIRECTED	direct	VBN
18637	1328	6	TO	to	IN
18637	1328	7	PARTICULAR	PARTICULAR	NNP
18637	1328	8	PERSONS	persons	VB
18637	1328	9	The	the	DT
18637	1328	10	now	now	RB
18637	1328	11	familiar	familiar	JJ
18637	1328	12	pattern	pattern	NN
18637	1328	13	of	of	IN
18637	1328	14	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1328	15	of	of	IN
18637	1328	16	important	important	JJ
18637	1328	17	segments	segment	NNS
18637	1328	18	of	of	IN
18637	1328	19	the	the	DT
18637	1328	20	economy	economy	NN
18637	1328	21	by	by	IN
18637	1328	22	boards	board	NNS
18637	1328	23	or	or	CC
18637	1328	24	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	1328	25	which	which	WDT
18637	1328	26	combine	combine	VBP
18637	1328	27	in	in	IN
18637	1328	28	varying	vary	VBG
18637	1328	29	proportions	proportion	NNS
18637	1328	30	the	the	DT
18637	1328	31	functions	function	NNS
18637	1328	32	of	of	IN
18637	1328	33	all	all	DT
18637	1328	34	three	three	CD
18637	1328	35	departments	department	NNS
18637	1328	36	of	of	IN
18637	1328	37	government	government	NN
18637	1328	38	was	be	VBD
18637	1328	39	first	first	RB
18637	1328	40	established	establish	VBN
18637	1328	41	by	by	IN
18637	1328	42	the	the	DT
18637	1328	43	States	States	NNPS
18637	1328	44	in	in	IN
18637	1328	45	the	the	DT
18637	1328	46	field	field	NN
18637	1328	47	of	of	IN
18637	1328	48	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	1328	49	rate	rate	NN
18637	1328	50	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1328	51	.	.	.
18637	1329	1	Discovering	discover	VBG
18637	1329	2	that	that	DT
18637	1329	3	direct	direct	JJ
18637	1329	4	action	action	NN
18637	1329	5	was	be	VBD
18637	1329	6	impracticable	impracticable	JJ
18637	1329	7	,	,	,
18637	1329	8	the	the	DT
18637	1329	9	State	State	NNP
18637	1329	10	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1329	11	created	create	VBD
18637	1329	12	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	1329	13	to	to	TO
18637	1329	14	deal	deal	VB
18637	1329	15	with	with	IN
18637	1329	16	the	the	DT
18637	1329	17	problem	problem	NN
18637	1329	18	.	.	.
18637	1330	1	One	one	CD
18637	1330	2	of	of	IN
18637	1330	3	the	the	DT
18637	1330	4	pioneers	pioneer	NNS
18637	1330	5	in	in	IN
18637	1330	6	this	this	DT
18637	1330	7	development	development	NN
18637	1330	8	was	be	VBD
18637	1330	9	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	1330	10	,	,	,
18637	1330	11	whose	whose	WP$
18637	1330	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1330	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1330	14	justified	justify	VBD
18637	1330	15	the	the	DT
18637	1330	16	practice	practice	NN
18637	1330	17	in	in	IN
18637	1330	18	an	an	DT
18637	1330	19	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1330	20	which	which	WDT
18637	1330	21	,	,	,
18637	1330	22	with	with	IN
18637	1330	23	the	the	DT
18637	1330	24	implied[49	implied[49	NN
18637	1330	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1330	26	and	and	CC
18637	1330	27	later	later	RBR
18637	1330	28	the	the	DT
18637	1330	29	explicit,[50	explicit,[50	NN
18637	1330	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1330	31	endorsement	endorsement	NN
18637	1330	32	of	of	IN
18637	1330	33	the	the	DT
18637	1330	34	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1330	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1330	36	,	,	,
18637	1330	37	practically	practically	RB
18637	1330	38	settled	settle	VBD
18637	1330	39	the	the	DT
18637	1330	40	law	law	NN
18637	1330	41	on	on	IN
18637	1330	42	this	this	DT
18637	1330	43	point	point	NN
18637	1330	44	:	:	:
18637	1330	45	"	"	``
18637	1330	46	If	if	IN
18637	1330	47	such	such	PDT
18637	1330	48	a	a	DT
18637	1330	49	power	power	NN
18637	1330	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	1330	51	to	to	TO
18637	1330	52	be	be	VB
18637	1330	53	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	1330	54	at	at	RB
18637	1330	55	all	all	RB
18637	1330	56	,	,	,
18637	1330	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1330	58	can	can	MD
18637	1330	59	only	only	RB
18637	1330	60	be	be	VB
18637	1330	61	satisfactorily	satisfactorily	RB
18637	1330	62	done	do	VBN
18637	1330	63	by	by	IN
18637	1330	64	a	a	DT
18637	1330	65	board	board	NN
18637	1330	66	or	or	CC
18637	1330	67	commission	commission	NN
18637	1330	68	,	,	,
18637	1330	69	constantly	constantly	RB
18637	1330	70	in	in	IN
18637	1330	71	session	session	NN
18637	1330	72	,	,	,
18637	1330	73	whose	whose	WP$
18637	1330	74	time	time	NN
18637	1330	75	is	be	VBZ
18637	1330	76	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	1330	77	given	give	VBN
18637	1330	78	to	to	IN
18637	1330	79	the	the	DT
18637	1330	80	subject	subject	NN
18637	1330	81	,	,	,
18637	1330	82	and	and	CC
18637	1330	83	who	who	WP
18637	1330	84	,	,	,
18637	1330	85	after	after	IN
18637	1330	86	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	1330	87	of	of	IN
18637	1330	88	the	the	DT
18637	1330	89	facts	fact	NNS
18637	1330	90	,	,	,
18637	1330	91	can	can	MD
18637	1330	92	fix	fix	VB
18637	1330	93	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1330	94	with	with	IN
18637	1330	95	reference	reference	NN
18637	1330	96	to	to	IN
18637	1330	97	the	the	DT
18637	1330	98	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	1330	99	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	1330	100	of	of	IN
18637	1330	101	each	each	DT
18637	1330	102	road	road	NN
18637	1330	103	,	,	,
18637	1330	104	and	and	CC
18637	1330	105	each	each	DT
18637	1330	106	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1330	107	kind	kind	NN
18637	1330	108	of	of	IN
18637	1330	109	business	business	NN
18637	1330	110	,	,	,
18637	1330	111	and	and	CC
18637	1330	112	who	who	WP
18637	1330	113	can	can	MD
18637	1330	114	change	change	VB
18637	1330	115	or	or	CC
18637	1330	116	modify	modify	VB
18637	1330	117	these	these	DT
18637	1330	118	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1330	119	to	to	TO
18637	1330	120	suit	suit	VB
18637	1330	121	the	the	DT
18637	1330	122	ever	ever	RB
18637	1330	123	-	-	HYPH
18637	1330	124	varying	vary	VBG
18637	1330	125	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	1330	126	of	of	IN
18637	1330	127	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	1330	128	.	.	.
18637	1331	1	"	"	``
18637	1331	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1331	3	51	51	CD
18637	1331	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1331	5	Contemporaneously	contemporaneously	RB
18637	1331	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1331	7	created	create	VBD
18637	1331	8	the	the	DT
18637	1331	9	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	1331	10	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1331	11	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1331	12	to	to	TO
18637	1331	13	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1331	14	the	the	DT
18637	1331	15	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1331	16	and	and	CC
18637	1331	17	practices	practice	NNS
18637	1331	18	of	of	IN
18637	1331	19	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	1331	20	with	with	IN
18637	1331	21	respect	respect	NN
18637	1331	22	to	to	IN
18637	1331	23	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1331	24	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1331	25	.	.	.
18637	1332	1	Although	although	IN
18637	1332	2	the	the	DT
18637	1332	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1332	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1332	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	1332	6	never	never	RB
18637	1332	7	had	have	VBN
18637	1332	8	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	1332	9	to	to	TO
18637	1332	10	render	render	VB
18637	1332	11	a	a	DT
18637	1332	12	direct	direct	JJ
18637	1332	13	decision	decision	NN
18637	1332	14	on	on	IN
18637	1332	15	the	the	DT
18637	1332	16	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	1332	17	of	of	IN
18637	1332	18	rate	rate	NN
18637	1332	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	1332	20	making	make	VBG
18637	1332	21	power	power	NN
18637	1332	22	to	to	IN
18637	1332	23	the	the	DT
18637	1332	24	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1332	25	,	,	,
18637	1332	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1332	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	1332	28	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	1332	29	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	1332	30	rate	rate	NN
18637	1332	31	orders	order	NNS
18637	1332	32	issued	issue	VBN
18637	1332	33	by	by	IN
18637	1332	34	that	that	DT
18637	1332	35	agency	agency	NN
18637	1332	36	.	.	.
18637	1333	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1333	2	52	52	CD
18637	1333	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1333	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	1333	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1333	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	1333	7	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	1333	8	the	the	DT
18637	1333	9	power	power	NN
18637	1333	10	of	of	IN
18637	1333	11	the	the	DT
18637	1333	12	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1333	13	of	of	IN
18637	1333	14	War	War	NNP
18637	1333	15	to	to	TO
18637	1333	16	order	order	VB
18637	1333	17	the	the	DT
18637	1333	18	removal	removal	NN
18637	1333	19	or	or	CC
18637	1333	20	alteration	alteration	NN
18637	1333	21	of	of	IN
18637	1333	22	bridges	bridge	NNS
18637	1333	23	which	which	WDT
18637	1333	24	unreasonably	unreasonably	RB
18637	1333	25	obstructed	obstruct	VBD
18637	1333	26	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1333	27	over	over	IN
18637	1333	28	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1333	29	waters;[53	waters;[53	NNP
18637	1333	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1333	31	the	the	DT
18637	1333	32	power	power	NN
18637	1333	33	of	of	IN
18637	1333	34	the	the	DT
18637	1333	35	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1333	36	Reserve	Reserve	NNP
18637	1333	37	Board	Board	NNP
18637	1333	38	to	to	TO
18637	1333	39	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	1333	40	national	national	JJ
18637	1333	41	banks	bank	NNS
18637	1333	42	to	to	TO
18637	1333	43	act	act	VB
18637	1333	44	as	as	IN
18637	1333	45	fiduciaries;[54	fiduciaries;[54	NNP
18637	1333	46	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1333	47	the	the	DT
18637	1333	48	authority	authority	NN
18637	1333	49	of	of	IN
18637	1333	50	the	the	DT
18637	1333	51	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1333	52	of	of	IN
18637	1333	53	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	1333	54	to	to	TO
18637	1333	55	deport	deport	VB
18637	1333	56	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	1333	57	of	of	IN
18637	1333	58	certain	certain	JJ
18637	1333	59	enumerated	enumerated	JJ
18637	1333	60	classes	class	NNS
18637	1333	61	,	,	,
18637	1333	62	if	if	IN
18637	1333	63	after	after	IN
18637	1333	64	hearing	hear	VBG
18637	1333	65	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1333	66	found	find	VBD
18637	1333	67	such	such	JJ
18637	1333	68	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	1333	69	to	to	TO
18637	1333	70	be	be	VB
18637	1333	71	"	"	``
18637	1333	72	undesirable	undesirable	JJ
18637	1333	73	residents";[55	residents";[55	NN
18637	1333	74	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1333	75	the	the	DT
18637	1333	76	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	1333	77	of	of	IN
18637	1333	78	the	the	DT
18637	1333	79	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	1333	80	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1333	81	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1333	82	to	to	TO
18637	1333	83	approve	approve	VB
18637	1333	84	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	1333	85	consolidations	consolidation	NNS
18637	1333	86	found	find	VBN
18637	1333	87	to	to	TO
18637	1333	88	be	be	VB
18637	1333	89	in	in	IN
18637	1333	90	the	the	DT
18637	1333	91	"	"	``
18637	1333	92	public	public	JJ
18637	1333	93	interest";[56	interest";[56	NN
18637	1333	94	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1333	95	and	and	CC
18637	1333	96	the	the	DT
18637	1333	97	powers	power	NNS
18637	1333	98	of	of	IN
18637	1333	99	the	the	DT
18637	1333	100	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1333	101	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	1333	102	Commission[57	Commission[57	NNP
18637	1333	103	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1333	104	and	and	CC
18637	1333	105	the	the	DT
18637	1333	106	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1333	107	Communications	Communications	NNPS
18637	1333	108	Commission[58	Commission[58	NNP
18637	1333	109	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1333	110	to	to	TO
18637	1333	111	license	license	VB
18637	1333	112	broadcasting	broadcasting	NN
18637	1333	113	stations	station	NNS
18637	1333	114	as	as	IN
18637	1333	115	"	"	``
18637	1333	116	public	public	JJ
18637	1333	117	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	1333	118	,	,	,
18637	1333	119	interest	interest	NN
18637	1333	120	and	and	CC
18637	1333	121	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	1333	122	"	"	''
18637	1333	123	may	may	MD
18637	1333	124	require	require	VB
18637	1333	125	.	.	.
18637	1334	1	The	the	DT
18637	1334	2	terms	term	NNS
18637	1334	3	,	,	,
18637	1334	4	however	however	RB
18637	1334	5	,	,	,
18637	1334	6	in	in	IN
18637	1334	7	which	which	WDT
18637	1334	8	a	a	DT
18637	1334	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	1334	10	delegates	delegate	VBZ
18637	1334	11	authority	authority	NN
18637	1334	12	to	to	IN
18637	1334	13	an	an	DT
18637	1334	14	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	1334	15	agent	agent	NN
18637	1334	16	are	be	VBP
18637	1334	17	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1334	18	to	to	IN
18637	1334	19	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1334	20	review	review	NN
18637	1334	21	;	;	:
18637	1334	22	and	and	CC
18637	1334	23	in	in	IN
18637	1334	24	a	a	DT
18637	1334	25	recent	recent	JJ
18637	1334	26	case	case	NN
18637	1334	27	the	the	DT
18637	1334	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1334	29	disallowed	disallow	VBD
18637	1334	30	an	an	DT
18637	1334	31	order	order	NN
18637	1334	32	of	of	IN
18637	1334	33	the	the	DT
18637	1334	34	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1334	35	of	of	IN
18637	1334	36	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	1334	37	proporting	proporte	VBG
18637	1334	38	resting	rest	VBG
18637	1334	39	on	on	IN
18637	1334	40	§	§	NNP
18637	1334	41	8	8	CD
18637	1334	42	of	of	IN
18637	1334	43	the	the	DT
18637	1334	44	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	1334	45	Marketing	Marketing	NNP
18637	1334	46	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	1334	47	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1334	48	of	of	IN
18637	1334	49	1937[59	1937[59	CD
18637	1334	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1334	51	as	as	IN
18637	1334	52	_	_	NNP
18637	1334	53	ultra	ultra	JJ
18637	1334	54	vires	vis	NNS
18637	1334	55	_	_	NNP
18637	1334	56	.	.	.
18637	1335	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1335	2	60	60	CD
18637	1335	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1335	4	DELEGATION	delegation	NN
18637	1335	5	TO	to	IN
18637	1335	6	PRIVATE	private	JJ
18637	1335	7	PERSONS	PERSONS	NNP
18637	1335	8	Although	although	IN
18637	1335	9	in	in	IN
18637	1335	10	a	a	DT
18637	1335	11	few	few	JJ
18637	1335	12	early	early	JJ
18637	1335	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	1335	14	the	the	DT
18637	1335	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1335	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1335	17	enforced	enforce	VBD
18637	1335	18	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	1335	19	which	which	WDT
18637	1335	20	gave	give	VBD
18637	1335	21	legal	legal	JJ
18637	1335	22	effect	effect	NN
18637	1335	23	to	to	IN
18637	1335	24	local	local	JJ
18637	1335	25	customs	custom	NNS
18637	1335	26	of	of	IN
18637	1335	27	miners	miner	NNS
18637	1335	28	with	with	IN
18637	1335	29	respect	respect	NN
18637	1335	30	to	to	IN
18637	1335	31	mining	mining	NN
18637	1335	32	claims	claim	NNS
18637	1335	33	on	on	IN
18637	1335	34	public	public	JJ
18637	1335	35	lands,[61	lands,[61	NN
18637	1335	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1335	37	and	and	CC
18637	1335	38	to	to	IN
18637	1335	39	standards	standard	NNS
18637	1335	40	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	1335	41	by	by	IN
18637	1335	42	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	1335	43	for	for	IN
18637	1335	44	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	1335	45	on	on	IN
18637	1335	46	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	1335	47	cars,[62	cars,[62	CD
18637	1335	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1335	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1335	50	held	hold	VBD
18637	1335	51	,	,	,
18637	1335	52	in	in	IN
18637	1335	53	Schechter	Schechter	NNP
18637	1335	54	Poultry	Poultry	NNP
18637	1335	55	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	1335	56	_	_	NNP
18637	1335	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	1335	58	_	_	NNP
18637	1335	59	United	United	NNP
18637	1335	60	States,[63	States,[63	NNP
18637	1335	61	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1335	62	and	and	CC
18637	1335	63	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	1335	64	_	_	NNP
18637	1335	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	1335	66	_	_	NNP
18637	1335	67	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	1335	68	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	1335	69	Company[64	Company[64	NNP
18637	1335	70	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1335	71	that	that	IN
18637	1335	72	private	private	JJ
18637	1335	73	trade	trade	NN
18637	1335	74	groups	group	NNS
18637	1335	75	could	could	MD
18637	1335	76	not	not	RB
18637	1335	77	be	be	VB
18637	1335	78	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	1335	79	to	to	TO
18637	1335	80	issue	issue	VB
18637	1335	81	binding	bind	VBG
18637	1335	82	rules	rule	NNS
18637	1335	83	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	1335	84	methods	method	NNS
18637	1335	85	of	of	IN
18637	1335	86	competition	competition	NN
18637	1335	87	or	or	CC
18637	1335	88	wages	wage	NNS
18637	1335	89	and	and	CC
18637	1335	90	hours	hour	NNS
18637	1335	91	of	of	IN
18637	1335	92	labor	labor	NN
18637	1335	93	.	.	.
18637	1336	1	On	on	IN
18637	1336	2	the	the	DT
18637	1336	3	other	other	JJ
18637	1336	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	1336	5	,	,	,
18637	1336	6	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	1336	7	providing	provide	VBG
18637	1336	8	that	that	IN
18637	1336	9	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	1336	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	1336	11	the	the	DT
18637	1336	12	production	production	NN
18637	1336	13	or	or	CC
18637	1336	14	marketing	marketing	NN
18637	1336	15	of	of	IN
18637	1336	16	agricultural	agricultural	JJ
18637	1336	17	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	1336	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	1336	19	become	become	VB
18637	1336	20	operative	operative	JJ
18637	1336	21	only	only	RB
18637	1336	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	1336	23	a	a	DT
18637	1336	24	favorable	favorable	JJ
18637	1336	25	vote	vote	NN
18637	1336	26	by	by	IN
18637	1336	27	a	a	DT
18637	1336	28	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	1336	29	majority	majority	NN
18637	1336	30	of	of	IN
18637	1336	31	the	the	DT
18637	1336	32	persons	person	NNS
18637	1336	33	affected	affect	VBN
18637	1336	34	have	have	VBP
18637	1336	35	been	be	VBN
18637	1336	36	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	1336	37	.	.	.
18637	1337	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1337	2	65	65	CD
18637	1337	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1337	4	The	the	DT
18637	1337	5	position	position	NN
18637	1337	6	of	of	IN
18637	1337	7	the	the	DT
18637	1337	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1337	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	1337	10	that	that	IN
18637	1337	11	such	such	PDT
18637	1337	12	a	a	DT
18637	1337	13	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	1337	14	does	do	VBZ
18637	1337	15	not	not	RB
18637	1337	16	involve	involve	VB
18637	1337	17	any	any	DT
18637	1337	18	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	1337	19	of	of	IN
18637	1337	20	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1337	21	authority	authority	NN
18637	1337	22	,	,	,
18637	1337	23	since	since	IN
18637	1337	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1337	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	1337	26	merely	merely	RB
18637	1337	27	placed	place	VBN
18637	1337	28	a	a	DT
18637	1337	29	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	1337	30	upon	upon	IN
18637	1337	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1337	32	own	own	JJ
18637	1337	33	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1337	34	by	by	IN
18637	1337	35	withholding	withhold	VBG
18637	1337	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1337	37	operation	operation	NN
18637	1337	38	in	in	IN
18637	1337	39	a	a	DT
18637	1337	40	given	give	VBN
18637	1337	41	case	case	NN
18637	1337	42	unless	unless	IN
18637	1337	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1337	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	1337	45	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1337	46	upon	upon	IN
18637	1337	47	a	a	DT
18637	1337	48	referendum	referendum	NN
18637	1337	49	.	.	.
18637	1338	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1338	2	66	66	CD
18637	1338	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1338	4	POWER	power	NN
18637	1338	5	TO	to	TO
18637	1338	6	GIVE	give	VB
18637	1338	7	EFFECT	effect	NN
18637	1338	8	TO	to	IN
18637	1338	9	CONTINGENT	CONTINGENT	NNP
18637	1338	10	LEGISLATION	LEGISLATION	NNP
18637	1338	11	An	an	DT
18637	1338	12	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	1338	13	different	different	JJ
18637	1338	14	problem	problem	NN
18637	1338	15	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	1338	16	when	when	WRB
18637	1338	17	,	,	,
18637	1338	18	instead	instead	RB
18637	1338	19	of	of	IN
18637	1338	20	directing	direct	VBG
18637	1338	21	another	another	DT
18637	1338	22	department	department	NN
18637	1338	23	of	of	IN
18637	1338	24	government	government	NN
18637	1338	25	to	to	TO
18637	1338	26	apply	apply	VB
18637	1338	27	a	a	DT
18637	1338	28	general	general	JJ
18637	1338	29	statute	statute	NN
18637	1338	30	to	to	IN
18637	1338	31	individual	individual	JJ
18637	1338	32	cases	case	NNS
18637	1338	33	,	,	,
18637	1338	34	or	or	CC
18637	1338	35	to	to	TO
18637	1338	36	supplement	supplement	VB
18637	1338	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1338	38	by	by	IN
18637	1338	39	detailed	detailed	JJ
18637	1338	40	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1338	41	,	,	,
18637	1338	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1338	43	commands	command	VBZ
18637	1338	44	that	that	IN
18637	1338	45	a	a	DT
18637	1338	46	previously	previously	RB
18637	1338	47	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	1338	48	statute	statute	NN
18637	1338	49	be	be	VB
18637	1338	50	revived	revive	VBN
18637	1338	51	,	,	,
18637	1338	52	suspended	suspend	VBN
18637	1338	53	or	or	CC
18637	1338	54	modified	modify	VBN
18637	1338	55	,	,	,
18637	1338	56	or	or	CC
18637	1338	57	that	that	IN
18637	1338	58	a	a	DT
18637	1338	59	new	new	JJ
18637	1338	60	rule	rule	NN
18637	1338	61	be	be	VB
18637	1338	62	put	put	VBN
18637	1338	63	into	into	IN
18637	1338	64	operation	operation	NN
18637	1338	65	,	,	,
18637	1338	66	upon	upon	IN
18637	1338	67	the	the	DT
18637	1338	68	finding	finding	NN
18637	1338	69	of	of	IN
18637	1338	70	certain	certain	JJ
18637	1338	71	facts	fact	NNS
18637	1338	72	by	by	IN
18637	1338	73	an	an	DT
18637	1338	74	executive	executive	JJ
18637	1338	75	or	or	CC
18637	1338	76	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	1338	77	officer	officer	NN
18637	1338	78	.	.	.
18637	1339	1	Since	since	IN
18637	1339	2	the	the	DT
18637	1339	3	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	1339	4	function	function	NN
18637	1339	5	in	in	IN
18637	1339	6	such	such	JJ
18637	1339	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	1339	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	1339	9	not	not	RB
18637	1339	10	that	that	DT
18637	1339	11	of	of	IN
18637	1339	12	"	"	``
18637	1339	13	filling	fill	VBG
18637	1339	14	up	up	RP
18637	1339	15	the	the	DT
18637	1339	16	details	detail	NNS
18637	1339	17	"	"	''
18637	1339	18	of	of	IN
18637	1339	19	a	a	DT
18637	1339	20	statute	statute	NN
18637	1339	21	,	,	,
18637	1339	22	authority	authority	NN
18637	1339	23	for	for	IN
18637	1339	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1339	25	must	must	MD
18637	1339	26	be	be	VB
18637	1339	27	sought	seek	VBN
18637	1339	28	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	1339	29	than	than	IN
18637	1339	30	in	in	IN
18637	1339	31	Wayman	Wayman	NNP
18637	1339	32	_	_	NNP
18637	1339	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	1339	34	_	_	NNP
18637	1339	35	Southard	Southard	NNP
18637	1339	36	and	and	CC
18637	1339	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1339	38	progeny	progeny	NN
18637	1339	39	.	.	.
18637	1340	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1340	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1340	3	to	to	TO
18637	1340	4	be	be	VB
18637	1340	5	found	find	VBN
18637	1340	6	in	in	IN
18637	1340	7	an	an	DT
18637	1340	8	even	even	RB
18637	1340	9	earlier	early	JJR
18637	1340	10	case	case	NN
18637	1340	11	--	--	:
18637	1340	12	The	the	DT
18637	1340	13	Brig	Brig	NNP
18637	1340	14	Aurora[67]--where	Aurora[67]--where	NNP
18637	1340	15	the	the	DT
18637	1340	16	revival	revival	NN
18637	1340	17	of	of	IN
18637	1340	18	a	a	DT
18637	1340	19	law	law	NN
18637	1340	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	1340	21	the	the	DT
18637	1340	22	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	1340	23	of	of	IN
18637	1340	24	a	a	DT
18637	1340	25	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	1340	26	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	1340	27	was	be	VBD
18637	1340	28	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	1340	29	in	in	IN
18637	1340	30	1813	1813	CD
18637	1340	31	.	.	.
18637	1341	1	After	after	IN
18637	1341	2	previous	previous	JJ
18637	1341	3	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	1341	4	on	on	IN
18637	1341	5	British	british	JJ
18637	1341	6	shipping	shipping	NN
18637	1341	7	had	have	VBD
18637	1341	8	lapsed	lapse	VBN
18637	1341	9	,	,	,
18637	1341	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1341	11	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1341	12	a	a	DT
18637	1341	13	new	new	JJ
18637	1341	14	law	law	NN
18637	1341	15	stating	state	VBG
18637	1341	16	that	that	IN
18637	1341	17	those	those	DT
18637	1341	18	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	1341	19	should	should	MD
18637	1341	20	be	be	VB
18637	1341	21	renewed	renew	VBN
18637	1341	22	in	in	IN
18637	1341	23	the	the	DT
18637	1341	24	event	event	NN
18637	1341	25	the	the	DT
18637	1341	26	President	President	NNP
18637	1341	27	found	find	VBD
18637	1341	28	and	and	CC
18637	1341	29	proclaimed	proclaim	VBD
18637	1341	30	that	that	IN
18637	1341	31	France	France	NNP
18637	1341	32	had	have	VBD
18637	1341	33	abandoned	abandon	VBN
18637	1341	34	certain	certain	JJ
18637	1341	35	practices	practice	NNS
18637	1341	36	which	which	WDT
18637	1341	37	violated	violate	VBD
18637	1341	38	the	the	DT
18637	1341	39	neutral	neutral	JJ
18637	1341	40	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1341	41	of	of	IN
18637	1341	42	the	the	DT
18637	1341	43	United	United	NNP
18637	1341	44	States	States	NNP
18637	1341	45	.	.	.
18637	1342	1	To	to	IN
18637	1342	2	the	the	DT
18637	1342	3	objection	objection	NN
18637	1342	4	that	that	IN
18637	1342	5	this	this	DT
18637	1342	6	was	be	VBD
18637	1342	7	an	an	DT
18637	1342	8	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	1342	9	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	1342	10	of	of	IN
18637	1342	11	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1342	12	power	power	NN
18637	1342	13	,	,	,
18637	1342	14	the	the	DT
18637	1342	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1342	16	answered	answer	VBD
18637	1342	17	briefly	briefly	RB
18637	1342	18	that	that	IN
18637	1342	19	"	"	``
18637	1342	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1342	21	can	can	MD
18637	1342	22	see	see	VB
18637	1342	23	no	no	DT
18637	1342	24	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	1342	25	reason	reason	NN
18637	1342	26	,	,	,
18637	1342	27	why	why	WRB
18637	1342	28	the	the	DT
18637	1342	29	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1342	30	should	should	MD
18637	1342	31	not	not	RB
18637	1342	32	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	1342	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1342	34	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	1342	35	in	in	IN
18637	1342	36	reviving	revive	VBG
18637	1342	37	the	the	DT
18637	1342	38	act	act	NN
18637	1342	39	of	of	IN
18637	1342	40	March	March	NNP
18637	1342	41	1st	1st	NN
18637	1342	42	,	,	,
18637	1342	43	1809	1809	CD
18637	1342	44	,	,	,
18637	1342	45	either	either	CC
18637	1342	46	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	1342	47	or	or	CC
18637	1342	48	conditionally	conditionally	RB
18637	1342	49	,	,	,
18637	1342	50	as	as	IN
18637	1342	51	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1342	52	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	1342	53	should	should	MD
18637	1342	54	direct	direct	VB
18637	1342	55	.	.	.
18637	1343	1	"	"	``
18637	1343	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1343	3	68	68	CD
18637	1343	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1343	5	MODIFICATION	modification	NN
18637	1343	6	OF	of	IN
18637	1343	7	TARIFF	TARIFF	NNP
18637	1343	8	LAWS	laws	IN
18637	1343	9	This	this	DT
18637	1343	10	point	point	NN
18637	1343	11	was	be	VBD
18637	1343	12	raised	raise	VBN
18637	1343	13	again	again	RB
18637	1343	14	in	in	IN
18637	1343	15	Field	Field	NNP
18637	1343	16	_	_	NNP
18637	1343	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	1343	18	_	_	NNP
18637	1343	19	Clark,[69	Clark,[69	NNP
18637	1343	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1343	21	where	where	WRB
18637	1343	22	the	the	DT
18637	1343	23	Tariff	Tariff	NNP
18637	1343	24	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1343	25	of	of	IN
18637	1343	26	1890	1890	CD
18637	1343	27	was	be	VBD
18637	1343	28	assailed	assail	VBN
18637	1343	29	as	as	IN
18637	1343	30	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	1343	31	because	because	IN
18637	1343	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1343	33	directed	direct	VBD
18637	1343	34	the	the	DT
18637	1343	35	President	President	NNP
18637	1343	36	to	to	TO
18637	1343	37	suspend	suspend	VB
18637	1343	38	the	the	DT
18637	1343	39	free	free	JJ
18637	1343	40	importation	importation	NN
18637	1343	41	of	of	IN
18637	1343	42	enumerated	enumerated	JJ
18637	1343	43	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	1343	44	"	"	''
18637	1343	45	for	for	IN
18637	1343	46	such	such	JJ
18637	1343	47	time	time	NN
18637	1343	48	as	as	IN
18637	1343	49	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1343	50	shall	shall	MD
18637	1343	51	deem	deem	VB
18637	1343	52	just	just	RB
18637	1343	53	"	"	``
18637	1343	54	if	if	IN
18637	1343	55	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1343	56	found	find	VBD
18637	1343	57	that	that	IN
18637	1343	58	other	other	JJ
18637	1343	59	countries	country	NNS
18637	1343	60	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	1343	61	upon	upon	IN
18637	1343	62	agricultural	agricultural	JJ
18637	1343	63	or	or	CC
18637	1343	64	other	other	JJ
18637	1343	65	products	product	NNS
18637	1343	66	of	of	IN
18637	1343	67	the	the	DT
18637	1343	68	United	United	NNP
18637	1343	69	States	States	NNP
18637	1343	70	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1343	71	or	or	CC
18637	1343	72	other	other	JJ
18637	1343	73	exactions	exaction	NNS
18637	1343	74	which	which	WDT
18637	1343	75	"	"	``
18637	1343	76	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1343	77	may	may	MD
18637	1343	78	deem	deem	VB
18637	1343	79	to	to	TO
18637	1343	80	be	be	VB
18637	1343	81	reciprocally	reciprocally	RB
18637	1343	82	unequal	unequal	JJ
18637	1343	83	and	and	CC
18637	1343	84	unjust	unjust	JJ
18637	1343	85	.	.	.
18637	1343	86	"	"	''
18637	1344	1	In	in	IN
18637	1344	2	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	1344	3	this	this	DT
18637	1344	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	1344	5	the	the	DT
18637	1344	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1344	7	relied	rely	VBD
18637	1344	8	heavily	heavily	RB
18637	1344	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	1344	10	two	two	CD
18637	1344	11	factors	factor	NNS
18637	1344	12	:	:	:
18637	1344	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1344	14	1	1	LS
18637	1344	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1344	16	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1344	17	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	1344	18	which	which	WDT
18637	1344	19	demonstrated	demonstrate	VBD
18637	1344	20	that	that	IN
18637	1344	21	"	"	``
18637	1344	22	in	in	IN
18637	1344	23	the	the	DT
18637	1344	24	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	1344	25	of	of	IN
18637	1344	26	the	the	DT
18637	1344	27	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1344	28	branch	branch	NN
18637	1344	29	of	of	IN
18637	1344	30	the	the	DT
18637	1344	31	government	government	NN
18637	1344	32	,	,	,
18637	1344	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1344	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	1344	35	often	often	RB
18637	1344	36	desirable	desirable	JJ
18637	1344	37	,	,	,
18637	1344	38	if	if	IN
18637	1344	39	not	not	RB
18637	1344	40	essential	essential	JJ
18637	1344	41	,	,	,
18637	1344	42	*	*	NFP
18637	1344	43	*	*	NFP
18637	1344	44	*	*	NFP
18637	1344	45	,	,	,
18637	1344	46	to	to	TO
18637	1344	47	invest	invest	VB
18637	1344	48	the	the	DT
18637	1344	49	President	President	NNP
18637	1344	50	with	with	IN
18637	1344	51	large	large	JJ
18637	1344	52	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	1344	53	in	in	IN
18637	1344	54	matters	matter	NNS
18637	1344	55	arising	arise	VBG
18637	1344	56	out	out	IN
18637	1344	57	of	of	IN
18637	1344	58	the	the	DT
18637	1344	59	execution	execution	NN
18637	1344	60	of	of	IN
18637	1344	61	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	1344	62	relating	relate	VBG
18637	1344	63	to	to	IN
18637	1344	64	trade	trade	NN
18637	1344	65	and	and	CC
18637	1344	66	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1344	67	with	with	IN
18637	1344	68	other	other	JJ
18637	1344	69	nations";[70	nations";[70	NNS
18637	1344	70	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1344	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1344	72	2	2	LS
18637	1344	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1344	74	that	that	WDT
18637	1344	75	the	the	DT
18637	1344	76	act	act	NN
18637	1344	77	"	"	``
18637	1344	78	did	do	VBD
18637	1344	79	not	not	RB
18637	1344	80	,	,	,
18637	1344	81	in	in	IN
18637	1344	82	any	any	DT
18637	1344	83	real	real	JJ
18637	1344	84	sense	sense	NN
18637	1344	85	,	,	,
18637	1344	86	invest	invest	VB
18637	1344	87	the	the	DT
18637	1344	88	President	President	NNP
18637	1344	89	with	with	IN
18637	1344	90	the	the	DT
18637	1344	91	power	power	NN
18637	1344	92	of	of	IN
18637	1344	93	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1344	94	.	.	.
18637	1345	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1345	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1345	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1345	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1345	5	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1345	6	prescribed	prescribe	VBD
18637	1345	7	,	,	,
18637	1345	8	in	in	IN
18637	1345	9	advance	advance	NN
18637	1345	10	,	,	,
18637	1345	11	the	the	DT
18637	1345	12	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1345	13	to	to	TO
18637	1345	14	be	be	VB
18637	1345	15	levied	levy	VBN
18637	1345	16	,	,	,
18637	1345	17	*	*	NFP
18637	1345	18	*	*	NFP
18637	1345	19	*	*	NFP
18637	1345	20	,	,	,
18637	1345	21	while	while	IN
18637	1345	22	the	the	DT
18637	1345	23	suspension	suspension	NN
18637	1345	24	lasted	last	VBD
18637	1345	25	.	.	.
18637	1346	1	Nothing	nothing	NN
18637	1346	2	involving	involve	VBG
18637	1346	3	the	the	DT
18637	1346	4	expediency	expediency	NN
18637	1346	5	or	or	CC
18637	1346	6	the	the	DT
18637	1346	7	just	just	JJ
18637	1346	8	operation	operation	NN
18637	1346	9	of	of	IN
18637	1346	10	such	such	JJ
18637	1346	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1346	12	was	be	VBD
18637	1346	13	left	leave	VBN
18637	1346	14	to	to	IN
18637	1346	15	the	the	DT
18637	1346	16	determination	determination	NN
18637	1346	17	of	of	IN
18637	1346	18	the	the	DT
18637	1346	19	President	President	NNP
18637	1346	20	.	.	.
18637	1347	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1347	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1347	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1347	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1347	5	had	have	VBD
18637	1347	6	no	no	DT
18637	1347	7	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	1347	8	in	in	IN
18637	1347	9	the	the	DT
18637	1347	10	premises	premise	NNS
18637	1347	11	except	except	IN
18637	1347	12	in	in	IN
18637	1347	13	respect	respect	NN
18637	1347	14	to	to	IN
18637	1347	15	the	the	DT
18637	1347	16	duration	duration	NN
18637	1347	17	of	of	IN
18637	1347	18	the	the	DT
18637	1347	19	suspension	suspension	NN
18637	1347	20	so	so	RB
18637	1347	21	ordered	order	VBD
18637	1347	22	.	.	.
18637	1348	1	"	"	``
18637	1348	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1348	3	71	71	CD
18637	1348	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1348	5	By	by	IN
18637	1348	6	similar	similar	JJ
18637	1348	7	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	1348	8	,	,	,
18637	1348	9	the	the	DT
18637	1348	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1348	11	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1348	12	the	the	DT
18637	1348	13	flexible	flexible	JJ
18637	1348	14	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	1348	15	of	of	IN
18637	1348	16	the	the	DT
18637	1348	17	Tariff	Tariff	NNP
18637	1348	18	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1348	19	of	of	IN
18637	1348	20	1922	1922	CD
18637	1348	21	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	1348	22	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1348	23	were	be	VBD
18637	1348	24	increased	increase	VBN
18637	1348	25	or	or	CC
18637	1348	26	decreased	decrease	VBD
18637	1348	27	to	to	TO
18637	1348	28	reflect	reflect	VB
18637	1348	29	differences	difference	NNS
18637	1348	30	in	in	IN
18637	1348	31	cost	cost	NN
18637	1348	32	of	of	IN
18637	1348	33	production	production	NN
18637	1348	34	at	at	IN
18637	1348	35	home	home	NN
18637	1348	36	and	and	CC
18637	1348	37	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	1348	38	,	,	,
18637	1348	39	as	as	IN
18637	1348	40	such	such	JJ
18637	1348	41	differences	difference	NNS
18637	1348	42	were	be	VBD
18637	1348	43	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	1348	44	and	and	CC
18637	1348	45	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
18637	1348	46	by	by	IN
18637	1348	47	the	the	DT
18637	1348	48	President	President	NNP
18637	1348	49	.	.	.
18637	1349	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1349	2	72	72	CD
18637	1349	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1349	4	ARMS	arms	NN
18637	1349	5	EMBARGO	embargo	NN
18637	1349	6	That	that	IN
18637	1349	7	the	the	DT
18637	1349	8	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	1349	9	of	of	IN
18637	1349	10	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	1349	11	in	in	IN
18637	1349	12	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	1349	13	with	with	IN
18637	1349	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1349	15	relations	relation	NNS
18637	1349	16	stands	stand	VBZ
18637	1349	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	1349	18	a	a	DT
18637	1349	19	different	different	JJ
18637	1349	20	footing	footing	NN
18637	1349	21	than	than	IN
18637	1349	22	the	the	DT
18637	1349	23	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	1349	24	of	of	IN
18637	1349	25	authority	authority	NN
18637	1349	26	to	to	TO
18637	1349	27	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1349	28	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	1349	29	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	1349	30	was	be	VBD
18637	1349	31	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	1349	32	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	1349	33	in	in	IN
18637	1349	34	United	United	NNP
18637	1349	35	States	States	NNP
18637	1349	36	_	_	NNP
18637	1349	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	1349	38	_	_	NNP
18637	1349	39	Curtiss	Curtiss	NNP
18637	1349	40	-	-	HYPH
18637	1349	41	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	1349	42	Export	Export	NNP
18637	1349	43	Corp.[73	corp.[73	NN
18637	1349	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1349	45	There	there	RB
18637	1349	46	the	the	DT
18637	1349	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1349	48	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	1349	49	the	the	DT
18637	1349	50	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	1349	51	Resolution	Resolution	NNP
18637	1349	52	of	of	IN
18637	1349	53	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1349	54	which	which	WDT
18637	1349	55	made	make	VBD
18637	1349	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1349	57	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	1349	58	to	to	TO
18637	1349	59	sell	sell	VB
18637	1349	60	arms	arm	NNS
18637	1349	61	to	to	IN
18637	1349	62	certain	certain	JJ
18637	1349	63	warring	warring	NN
18637	1349	64	countries	country	NNS
18637	1349	65	"	"	''
18637	1349	66	if	if	IN
18637	1349	67	the	the	DT
18637	1349	68	President	President	NNP
18637	1349	69	finds	find	VBZ
18637	1349	70	that	that	IN
18637	1349	71	the	the	DT
18637	1349	72	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	1349	73	of	of	IN
18637	1349	74	the	the	DT
18637	1349	75	sale	sale	NN
18637	1349	76	of	of	IN
18637	1349	77	arms	arm	NNS
18637	1349	78	and	and	CC
18637	1349	79	munitions	munition	NNS
18637	1349	80	of	of	IN
18637	1349	81	war	war	NN
18637	1349	82	in	in	IN
18637	1349	83	the	the	DT
18637	1349	84	United	United	NNP
18637	1349	85	States	States	NNP
18637	1349	86	to	to	IN
18637	1349	87	those	those	DT
18637	1349	88	countries	country	NNS
18637	1349	89	now	now	RB
18637	1349	90	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1349	91	in	in	IN
18637	1349	92	armed	armed	JJ
18637	1349	93	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	1349	94	in	in	IN
18637	1349	95	the	the	DT
18637	1349	96	Chaco	Chaco	NNP
18637	1349	97	may	may	MD
18637	1349	98	contribute	contribute	VB
18637	1349	99	to	to	IN
18637	1349	100	the	the	DT
18637	1349	101	reestablishment	reestablishment	NN
18637	1349	102	of	of	IN
18637	1349	103	peace	peace	NN
18637	1349	104	*	*	NFP
18637	1349	105	*	*	NFP
18637	1349	106	*	*	NFP
18637	1349	107	,	,	,
18637	1349	108	and	and	CC
18637	1349	109	if	if	IN
18637	1349	110	*	*	NFP
18637	1349	111	*	*	NFP
18637	1349	112	*	*	NFP
18637	1349	113	,	,	,
18637	1349	114	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1349	115	makes	make	VBZ
18637	1349	116	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	1349	117	to	to	IN
18637	1349	118	that	that	DT
18637	1349	119	effect	effect	NN
18637	1349	120	,	,	,
18637	1349	121	*	*	NFP
18637	1349	122	*	*	NFP
18637	1349	123	*	*	NFP
18637	1349	124	"	"	''
18637	1349	125	Said	say	VBD
18637	1349	126	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1349	127	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	1349	128	for	for	IN
18637	1349	129	the	the	DT
18637	1349	130	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1349	131	:	:	:
18637	1349	132	"	"	``
18637	1349	133	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1349	134	is	be	VBZ
18637	1349	135	important	important	JJ
18637	1349	136	to	to	TO
18637	1349	137	bear	bear	VB
18637	1349	138	in	in	IN
18637	1349	139	mind	mind	NN
18637	1349	140	that	that	IN
18637	1349	141	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1349	142	are	be	VBP
18637	1349	143	here	here	RB
18637	1349	144	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	1349	145	not	not	RB
18637	1349	146	alone	alone	JJ
18637	1349	147	with	with	IN
18637	1349	148	an	an	DT
18637	1349	149	authority	authority	NN
18637	1349	150	vested	vest	VBN
18637	1349	151	in	in	IN
18637	1349	152	the	the	DT
18637	1349	153	President	President	NNP
18637	1349	154	by	by	IN
18637	1349	155	an	an	DT
18637	1349	156	exertion	exertion	NN
18637	1349	157	of	of	IN
18637	1349	158	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1349	159	power	power	NN
18637	1349	160	,	,	,
18637	1349	161	but	but	CC
18637	1349	162	with	with	IN
18637	1349	163	such	such	PDT
18637	1349	164	an	an	DT
18637	1349	165	authority	authority	NN
18637	1349	166	plus	plus	CC
18637	1349	167	the	the	DT
18637	1349	168	very	very	RB
18637	1349	169	delicate	delicate	JJ
18637	1349	170	,	,	,
18637	1349	171	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	1349	172	and	and	CC
18637	1349	173	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	1349	174	power	power	NN
18637	1349	175	of	of	IN
18637	1349	176	the	the	DT
18637	1349	177	President	President	NNP
18637	1349	178	as	as	IN
18637	1349	179	the	the	DT
18637	1349	180	sole	sole	JJ
18637	1349	181	organ	organ	NN
18637	1349	182	of	of	IN
18637	1349	183	the	the	DT
18637	1349	184	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1349	185	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1349	186	in	in	IN
18637	1349	187	the	the	DT
18637	1349	188	field	field	NN
18637	1349	189	of	of	IN
18637	1349	190	international	international	NNP
18637	1349	191	relations--	relations--	NNP
18637	1349	192	*	*	NFP
18637	1349	193	*	*	NFP
18637	1349	194	*	*	NFP
18637	1349	195	,	,	,
18637	1349	196	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1349	197	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1349	198	which	which	WDT
18637	1349	199	is	be	VBZ
18637	1349	200	to	to	TO
18637	1349	201	be	be	VB
18637	1349	202	made	make	VBN
18637	1349	203	effective	effective	JJ
18637	1349	204	through	through	IN
18637	1349	205	negotiation	negotiation	NN
18637	1349	206	and	and	CC
18637	1349	207	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	1349	208	within	within	IN
18637	1349	209	the	the	DT
18637	1349	210	international	international	JJ
18637	1349	211	field	field	NN
18637	1349	212	must	must	MD
18637	1349	213	often	often	RB
18637	1349	214	accord	accord	VB
18637	1349	215	to	to	IN
18637	1349	216	the	the	DT
18637	1349	217	President	President	NNP
18637	1349	218	a	a	DT
18637	1349	219	degree	degree	NN
18637	1349	220	of	of	IN
18637	1349	221	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	1349	222	and	and	CC
18637	1349	223	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	1349	224	from	from	IN
18637	1349	225	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	1349	226	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	1349	227	which	which	WDT
18637	1349	228	would	would	MD
18637	1349	229	not	not	RB
18637	1349	230	be	be	VB
18637	1349	231	admissible	admissible	JJ
18637	1349	232	were	be	VBD
18637	1349	233	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	1349	234	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	1349	235	alone	alone	RB
18637	1349	236	involved	involved	JJ
18637	1349	237	.	.	.
18637	1350	1	"	"	``
18637	1350	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1350	3	74	74	CD
18637	1350	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1350	5	INTERNAL	INTERNAL	NNS
18637	1350	6	AFFAIRS	affair	NNS
18637	1350	7	Panama	Panama	NNP
18637	1350	8	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	1350	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	1350	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1350	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	1350	12	_	_	NNP
18637	1350	13	Ryan[75	Ryan[75	NNP
18637	1350	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1350	15	was	be	VBD
18637	1350	16	the	the	DT
18637	1350	17	first	first	JJ
18637	1350	18	case	case	NN
18637	1350	19	in	in	IN
18637	1350	20	which	which	WDT
18637	1350	21	the	the	DT
18637	1350	22	President	President	NNP
18637	1350	23	had	have	VBD
18637	1350	24	been	be	VBN
18637	1350	25	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	1350	26	to	to	TO
18637	1350	27	put	put	VB
18637	1350	28	into	into	IN
18637	1350	29	effect	effect	NN
18637	1350	30	by	by	IN
18637	1350	31	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	1350	32	,	,	,
18637	1350	33	a	a	DT
18637	1350	34	new	new	JJ
18637	1350	35	and	and	CC
18637	1350	36	independent	independent	JJ
18637	1350	37	rule	rule	NN
18637	1350	38	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	1350	39	to	to	IN
18637	1350	40	internal	internal	JJ
18637	1350	41	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	1350	42	.	.	.
18637	1351	1	One	one	CD
18637	1351	2	section	section	NN
18637	1351	3	of	of	IN
18637	1351	4	the	the	DT
18637	1351	5	National	National	NNP
18637	1351	6	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	1351	7	Recovery	Recovery	NNP
18637	1351	8	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1351	9	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	1351	10	the	the	DT
18637	1351	11	President	President	NNP
18637	1351	12	to	to	TO
18637	1351	13	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	1351	14	the	the	DT
18637	1351	15	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	1351	16	in	in	IN
18637	1351	17	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1351	18	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1351	19	of	of	IN
18637	1351	20	oil	oil	NN
18637	1351	21	produced	produce	VBN
18637	1351	22	or	or	CC
18637	1351	23	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	1351	24	from	from	IN
18637	1351	25	storage	storage	NN
18637	1351	26	in	in	IN
18637	1351	27	violation	violation	NN
18637	1351	28	of	of	IN
18637	1351	29	State	State	NNP
18637	1351	30	law	law	NN
18637	1351	31	.	.	.
18637	1352	1	Apart	apart	RB
18637	1352	2	from	from	IN
18637	1352	3	the	the	DT
18637	1352	4	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	1352	5	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	1352	6	stated	state	VBD
18637	1352	7	in	in	IN
18637	1352	8	the	the	DT
18637	1352	9	first	first	JJ
18637	1352	10	section	section	NN
18637	1352	11	--	--	:
18637	1352	12	economic	economic	JJ
18637	1352	13	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	1352	14	and	and	CC
18637	1352	15	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	1352	16	of	of	IN
18637	1352	17	natural	natural	JJ
18637	1352	18	resources	resource	NNS
18637	1352	19	--	--	:
18637	1352	20	the	the	DT
18637	1352	21	measure	measure	NN
18637	1352	22	contained	contain	VBD
18637	1352	23	no	no	DT
18637	1352	24	standard	standard	NN
18637	1352	25	or	or	CC
18637	1352	26	statement	statement	NN
18637	1352	27	of	of	IN
18637	1352	28	policy	policy	NN
18637	1352	29	by	by	IN
18637	1352	30	which	which	WDT
18637	1352	31	the	the	DT
18637	1352	32	President	President	NNP
18637	1352	33	should	should	MD
18637	1352	34	be	be	VB
18637	1352	35	guided	guide	VBN
18637	1352	36	in	in	IN
18637	1352	37	determining	determine	VBG
18637	1352	38	whether	whether	IN
18637	1352	39	or	or	CC
18637	1352	40	when	when	WRB
18637	1352	41	to	to	TO
18637	1352	42	issue	issue	VB
18637	1352	43	the	the	DT
18637	1352	44	order	order	NN
18637	1352	45	.	.	.
18637	1353	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	1353	2	did	do	VBD
18637	1353	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1353	4	require	require	VB
18637	1353	5	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1353	6	to	to	TO
18637	1353	7	make	make	VB
18637	1353	8	any	any	DT
18637	1353	9	findings	finding	NNS
18637	1353	10	of	of	IN
18637	1353	11	fact	fact	NN
18637	1353	12	to	to	TO
18637	1353	13	disclose	disclose	VB
18637	1353	14	the	the	DT
18637	1353	15	basis	basis	NN
18637	1353	16	of	of	IN
18637	1353	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1353	18	action	action	NN
18637	1353	19	.	.	.
18637	1354	1	By	by	IN
18637	1354	2	a	a	DT
18637	1354	3	vote	vote	NN
18637	1354	4	of	of	IN
18637	1354	5	eight	eight	CD
18637	1354	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	1354	7	to	to	IN
18637	1354	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	1354	9	one	one	NN
18637	1354	10	the	the	DT
18637	1354	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1354	12	held	hold	VBD
18637	1354	13	the	the	DT
18637	1354	14	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	1354	15	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	1354	16	.	.	.
18637	1355	1	The	the	DT
18637	1355	2	only	only	JJ
18637	1355	3	case	case	NN
18637	1355	4	in	in	IN
18637	1355	5	which	which	WDT
18637	1355	6	the	the	DT
18637	1355	7	power	power	NN
18637	1355	8	of	of	IN
18637	1355	9	an	an	DT
18637	1355	10	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	1355	11	official	official	NN
18637	1355	12	to	to	TO
18637	1355	13	modify	modify	VB
18637	1355	14	a	a	DT
18637	1355	15	rule	rule	NN
18637	1355	16	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	1355	17	by	by	IN
18637	1355	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1355	19	relating	relate	VBG
18637	1355	20	to	to	IN
18637	1355	21	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	1355	22	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	1355	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	1355	24	been	be	VBN
18637	1355	25	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	1355	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	1355	27	Opp	Opp	NNP
18637	1355	28	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	1355	29	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	1355	30	_	_	NNP
18637	1355	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	1355	32	_	_	NNP
18637	1355	33	Administrator	Administrator	NNP
18637	1355	34	.	.	.
18637	1356	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1356	2	76	76	CD
18637	1356	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1356	4	That	that	DT
18637	1356	5	case	case	NN
18637	1356	6	involved	involve	VBD
18637	1356	7	the	the	DT
18637	1356	8	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	1356	9	of	of	IN
18637	1356	10	the	the	DT
18637	1356	11	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	1356	12	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	1356	13	Standards	Standards	NNP
18637	1356	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1356	15	which	which	WDT
18637	1356	16	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	1356	17	the	the	DT
18637	1356	18	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	1356	19	of	of	IN
18637	1356	20	Industry	Industry	NNP
18637	1356	21	Advisory	Advisory	NNP
18637	1356	22	Committees	Committees	NNPS
18637	1356	23	to	to	TO
18637	1356	24	investigate	investigate	VB
18637	1356	25	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	1356	26	in	in	IN
18637	1356	27	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1356	28	industries	industry	NNS
18637	1356	29	,	,	,
18637	1356	30	with	with	IN
18637	1356	31	notice	notice	NN
18637	1356	32	and	and	CC
18637	1356	33	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	1356	34	to	to	TO
18637	1356	35	be	be	VB
18637	1356	36	heard	hear	VBN
18637	1356	37	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	1356	38	to	to	IN
18637	1356	39	interested	interested	JJ
18637	1356	40	parties	party	NNS
18637	1356	41	.	.	.
18637	1357	1	Upon	upon	IN
18637	1357	2	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	1357	3	of	of	IN
18637	1357	4	factors	factor	NNS
18637	1357	5	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	1357	6	in	in	IN
18637	1357	7	the	the	DT
18637	1357	8	law	law	NN
18637	1357	9	and	and	CC
18637	1357	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	1357	11	finding	find	VBG
18637	1357	12	that	that	IN
18637	1357	13	the	the	DT
18637	1357	14	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	1357	15	specified	specify	VBN
18637	1357	16	in	in	IN
18637	1357	17	the	the	DT
18637	1357	18	law	law	NN
18637	1357	19	were	be	VBD
18637	1357	20	fulfilled	fulfil	VBN
18637	1357	21	,	,	,
18637	1357	22	such	such	JJ
18637	1357	23	Committees	Committees	NNPS
18637	1357	24	were	be	VBD
18637	1357	25	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	1357	26	to	to	TO
18637	1357	27	recommend	recommend	VB
18637	1357	28	and	and	CC
18637	1357	29	the	the	DT
18637	1357	30	Administrator	Administrator	NNP
18637	1357	31	to	to	TO
18637	1357	32	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	1357	33	,	,	,
18637	1357	34	higher	high	JJR
18637	1357	35	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	1357	36	wage	wage	NN
18637	1357	37	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1357	38	for	for	IN
18637	1357	39	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1357	40	industries	industry	NNS
18637	1357	41	.	.	.
18637	1358	1	Emphasizing	emphasize	VBG
18637	1358	2	the	the	DT
18637	1358	3	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	1358	4	which	which	WDT
18637	1358	5	the	the	DT
18637	1358	6	agency	agency	NN
18637	1358	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1358	8	directed	direct	VBN
18637	1358	9	to	to	TO
18637	1358	10	follow	follow	VB
18637	1358	11	and	and	CC
18637	1358	12	the	the	DT
18637	1358	13	fact	fact	NN
18637	1358	14	that	that	IN
18637	1358	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1358	16	would	would	MD
18637	1358	17	be	be	VB
18637	1358	18	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	1358	19	for	for	IN
18637	1358	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1358	21	to	to	TO
18637	1358	22	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	1358	23	specific	specific	JJ
18637	1358	24	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	1358	25	wages	wage	NNS
18637	1358	26	for	for	IN
18637	1358	27	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1358	28	industries,[77	industries,[77	NN
18637	1358	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1358	30	a	a	DT
18637	1358	31	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	1358	32	court	court	NN
18637	1358	33	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1358	34	the	the	DT
18637	1358	35	law	law	NN
18637	1358	36	on	on	IN
18637	1358	37	the	the	DT
18637	1358	38	ground	ground	NN
18637	1358	39	that	that	IN
18637	1358	40	the	the	DT
18637	1358	41	sole	sole	JJ
18637	1358	42	function	function	NN
18637	1358	43	of	of	IN
18637	1358	44	the	the	DT
18637	1358	45	Administrator	administrator	NN
18637	1358	46	was	be	VBD
18637	1358	47	to	to	TO
18637	1358	48	put	put	VB
18637	1358	49	into	into	IN
18637	1358	50	effect	effect	NN
18637	1358	51	the	the	DT
18637	1358	52	definite	definite	JJ
18637	1358	53	policy	policy	NN
18637	1358	54	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	1358	55	by	by	IN
18637	1358	56	the	the	DT
18637	1358	57	legislators	legislator	NNS
18637	1358	58	.	.	.
18637	1359	1	EMERGENCY	emergency	NN
18637	1359	2	STATUTES	statute	NNS
18637	1359	3	Occupying	occupy	VBG
18637	1359	4	a	a	DT
18637	1359	5	midway	midway	NN
18637	1359	6	station	station	NN
18637	1359	7	between	between	IN
18637	1359	8	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1359	9	which	which	WDT
18637	1359	10	deals	deal	VBZ
18637	1359	11	with	with	IN
18637	1359	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1359	13	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	1359	14	and	and	CC
18637	1359	15	purely	purely	RB
18637	1359	16	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	1359	17	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1359	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	1359	19	what	what	WP
18637	1359	20	may	may	MD
18637	1359	21	be	be	VB
18637	1359	22	termed	term	VBN
18637	1359	23	"	"	``
18637	1359	24	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	1359	25	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	1359	26	.	.	.
18637	1359	27	"	"	''
18637	1360	1	These	these	DT
18637	1360	2	are	be	VBP
18637	1360	3	largely	largely	RB
18637	1360	4	the	the	DT
18637	1360	5	outgrowth	outgrowth	NN
18637	1360	6	of	of	IN
18637	1360	7	the	the	DT
18637	1360	8	two	two	CD
18637	1360	9	World	World	NNP
18637	1360	10	Wars	Wars	NNPS
18637	1360	11	.	.	.
18637	1361	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	1361	2	on	on	IN
18637	1361	3	December	December	NNP
18637	1361	4	16	16	CD
18637	1361	5	,	,	,
18637	1361	6	1950	1950	CD
18637	1361	7	,	,	,
18637	1361	8	President	President	NNP
18637	1361	9	Truman	Truman	NNP
18637	1361	10	issued	issue	VBD
18637	1361	11	a	a	DT
18637	1361	12	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	1361	13	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	1361	14	"	"	``
18637	1361	15	the	the	DT
18637	1361	16	existence	existence	NN
18637	1361	17	of	of	IN
18637	1361	18	a	a	DT
18637	1361	19	national	national	JJ
18637	1361	20	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	1361	21	,	,	,
18637	1361	22	"	"	''
18637	1361	23	and	and	CC
18637	1361	24	by	by	IN
18637	1361	25	so	so	RB
18637	1361	26	doing	do	VBG
18637	1361	27	"	"	``
18637	1361	28	activated	activate	VBN
18637	1361	29	"	"	''
18637	1361	30	more	more	JJR
18637	1361	31	than	than	IN
18637	1361	32	sixty	sixty	CD
18637	1361	33	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	1361	34	or	or	CC
18637	1361	35	parts	part	NNS
18637	1361	36	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	1361	37	which	which	WDT
18637	1361	38	by	by	IN
18637	1361	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1361	40	terms	term	NNS
18637	1361	41	apply	apply	VBP
18637	1361	42	to	to	IN
18637	1361	43	or	or	CC
18637	1361	44	during	during	IN
18637	1361	45	"	"	``
18637	1361	46	a	a	DT
18637	1361	47	condition	condition	NN
18637	1361	48	of	of	IN
18637	1361	49	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	1361	50	"	"	''
18637	1361	51	or	or	CC
18637	1361	52	"	"	``
18637	1361	53	in	in	IN
18637	1361	54	time	time	NN
18637	1361	55	of	of	IN
18637	1361	56	war	war	NN
18637	1361	57	or	or	CC
18637	1361	58	national	national	JJ
18637	1361	59	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	1361	60	,	,	,
18637	1361	61	"	"	''
18637	1361	62	etc	etc	FW
18637	1361	63	.	.	.
18637	1362	1	Most	Most	JJS
18637	1362	2	of	of	IN
18637	1362	3	these	these	DT
18637	1362	4	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	1362	5	leave	leave	VBP
18637	1362	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1362	7	to	to	IN
18637	1362	8	the	the	DT
18637	1362	9	President	President	NNP
18637	1362	10	to	to	TO
18637	1362	11	determine	determine	VB
18637	1362	12	the	the	DT
18637	1362	13	question	question	NN
18637	1362	14	of	of	IN
18637	1362	15	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	1362	16	,	,	,
18637	1362	17	and	and	CC
18637	1362	18	the	the	DT
18637	1362	19	White	White	NNP
18637	1362	20	House	House	NNP
18637	1362	21	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	1362	22	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	1362	23	to	to	TO
18637	1362	24	be	be	VB
18637	1362	25	that	that	IN
18637	1362	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1362	27	all	all	DT
18637	1362	28	do	do	VBP
18637	1362	29	so	so	RB
18637	1362	30	.	.	.
18637	1363	1	Many	many	JJ
18637	1363	2	of	of	IN
18637	1363	3	the	the	DT
18637	1363	4	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	1363	5	thus	thus	RB
18637	1363	6	activated	activate	VBD
18637	1363	7	delegate	delegate	NN
18637	1363	8	powers	power	NNS
18637	1363	9	of	of	IN
18637	1363	10	greater	great	JJR
18637	1363	11	or	or	CC
18637	1363	12	less	less	JJR
18637	1363	13	importance	importance	NN
18637	1363	14	to	to	IN
18637	1363	15	the	the	DT
18637	1363	16	President	President	NNP
18637	1363	17	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1363	18	or	or	CC
18637	1363	19	remove	remove	VB
18637	1363	20	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	1363	21	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	1363	22	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	1363	23	.	.	.
18637	1364	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1364	2	78	78	CD
18637	1364	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1364	4	PUNISHMENT	punishment	NN
18637	1364	5	OF	of	IN
18637	1364	6	VIOLATIONS	violations	NN
18637	1364	7	If	if	IN
18637	1364	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1364	9	so	so	RB
18637	1364	10	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	1364	11	,	,	,
18637	1364	12	violations	violation	NNS
18637	1364	13	of	of	IN
18637	1364	14	valid	valid	JJ
18637	1364	15	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	1364	16	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1364	17	may	may	MD
18637	1364	18	be	be	VB
18637	1364	19	punished	punish	VBN
18637	1364	20	as	as	IN
18637	1364	21	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	1364	22	.	.	.
18637	1365	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1365	2	79	79	CD
18637	1365	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1365	4	But	but	CC
18637	1365	5	the	the	DT
18637	1365	6	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	1365	7	must	must	MD
18637	1365	8	be	be	VB
18637	1365	9	provided	provide	VBN
18637	1365	10	in	in	IN
18637	1365	11	the	the	DT
18637	1365	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	1365	13	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1365	14	;	;	:
18637	1365	15	additional	additional	JJ
18637	1365	16	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	1365	17	can	can	MD
18637	1365	18	not	not	RB
18637	1365	19	be	be	VB
18637	1365	20	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	1365	21	by	by	IN
18637	1365	22	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	1365	23	action	action	NN
18637	1365	24	.	.	.
18637	1366	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1366	2	80	80	CD
18637	1366	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1366	4	In	in	IN
18637	1366	5	an	an	DT
18637	1366	6	early	early	JJ
18637	1366	7	case	case	NN
18637	1366	8	,	,	,
18637	1366	9	the	the	DT
18637	1366	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1366	11	held	hold	VBD
18637	1366	12	that	that	IN
18637	1366	13	a	a	DT
18637	1366	14	section	section	NN
18637	1366	15	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	1366	16	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	1366	17	for	for	IN
18637	1366	18	any	any	DT
18637	1366	19	violation	violation	NN
18637	1366	20	of	of	IN
18637	1366	21	a	a	DT
18637	1366	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	1366	23	did	do	VBD
18637	1366	24	not	not	RB
18637	1366	25	warrant	warrant	VB
18637	1366	26	a	a	DT
18637	1366	27	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	1366	28	for	for	IN
18637	1366	29	wilful	wilful	JJ
18637	1366	30	disobedience	disobedience	NN
18637	1366	31	of	of	IN
18637	1366	32	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1366	33	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	1366	34	by	by	RB
18637	1366	35	,	,	,
18637	1366	36	and	and	CC
18637	1366	37	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	1366	38	issued	issue	VBN
18637	1366	39	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	1366	40	to	to	IN
18637	1366	41	,	,	,
18637	1366	42	the	the	DT
18637	1366	43	act	act	NN
18637	1366	44	.	.	.
18637	1367	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1367	2	81	81	CD
18637	1367	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1367	4	Without	without	IN
18637	1367	5	disavowing	disavow	VBG
18637	1367	6	this	this	DT
18637	1367	7	general	general	JJ
18637	1367	8	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	1367	9	,	,	,
18637	1367	10	the	the	DT
18637	1367	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1367	12	,	,	,
18637	1367	13	in	in	IN
18637	1367	14	1944	1944	CD
18637	1367	15	,	,	,
18637	1367	16	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	1367	17	a	a	DT
18637	1367	18	suspension	suspension	NN
18637	1367	19	order	order	NN
18637	1367	20	issued	issue	VBN
18637	1367	21	by	by	IN
18637	1367	22	the	the	DT
18637	1367	23	OPA	OPA	NNP
18637	1367	24	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	1367	25	a	a	DT
18637	1367	26	dealer	dealer	NN
18637	1367	27	in	in	IN
18637	1367	28	fuel	fuel	NN
18637	1367	29	oil	oil	NN
18637	1367	30	who	who	WP
18637	1367	31	had	have	VBD
18637	1367	32	violated	violate	VBN
18637	1367	33	rationing	ration	VBG
18637	1367	34	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1367	35	was	be	VBD
18637	1367	36	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	1367	37	to	to	TO
18637	1367	38	receive	receive	VB
18637	1367	39	or	or	CC
18637	1367	40	deal	deal	VB
18637	1367	41	on	on	IN
18637	1367	42	that	that	DT
18637	1367	43	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	1367	44	.	.	.
18637	1368	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1368	2	82	82	CD
18637	1368	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1368	4	Although	although	IN
18637	1368	5	such	such	JJ
18637	1368	6	an	an	DT
18637	1368	7	order	order	NN
18637	1368	8	was	be	VBD
18637	1368	9	not	not	RB
18637	1368	10	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	1368	11	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	1368	12	by	by	IN
18637	1368	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	1368	14	,	,	,
18637	1368	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1368	16	was	be	VBD
18637	1368	17	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	1368	18	as	as	IN
18637	1368	19	being	be	VBG
18637	1368	20	a	a	DT
18637	1368	21	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	1368	22	measure	measure	NN
18637	1368	23	for	for	IN
18637	1368	24	effecting	effect	VBG
18637	1368	25	a	a	DT
18637	1368	26	fair	fair	JJ
18637	1368	27	allocation	allocation	NN
18637	1368	28	of	of	IN
18637	1368	29	fuel	fuel	NN
18637	1368	30	oil	oil	NN
18637	1368	31	,	,	,
18637	1368	32	rather	rather	RB
18637	1368	33	than	than	IN
18637	1368	34	as	as	IN
18637	1368	35	a	a	DT
18637	1368	36	means	means	NN
18637	1368	37	of	of	IN
18637	1368	38	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	1368	39	for	for	IN
18637	1368	40	an	an	DT
18637	1368	41	offender	offender	NN
18637	1368	42	.	.	.
18637	1369	1	In	in	IN
18637	1369	2	another	another	DT
18637	1369	3	OPA	opa	NN
18637	1369	4	case	case	NN
18637	1369	5	,	,	,
18637	1369	6	the	the	DT
18637	1369	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1369	8	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	1369	9	that	that	IN
18637	1369	10	in	in	IN
18637	1369	11	a	a	DT
18637	1369	12	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	1369	13	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	1369	14	,	,	,
18637	1369	15	a	a	DT
18637	1369	16	price	price	NN
18637	1369	17	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1369	18	was	be	VBD
18637	1369	19	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1369	20	to	to	IN
18637	1369	21	the	the	DT
18637	1369	22	same	same	JJ
18637	1369	23	rule	rule	NN
18637	1369	24	of	of	IN
18637	1369	25	strict	strict	JJ
18637	1369	26	construction	construction	NN
18637	1369	27	as	as	IN
18637	1369	28	a	a	DT
18637	1369	29	statute	statute	NN
18637	1369	30	,	,	,
18637	1369	31	and	and	CC
18637	1369	32	that	that	IN
18637	1369	33	omissions	omission	NNS
18637	1369	34	from	from	IN
18637	1369	35	,	,	,
18637	1369	36	or	or	CC
18637	1369	37	indefiniteness	indefiniteness	RB
18637	1369	38	in	in	IN
18637	1369	39	,	,	,
18637	1369	40	such	such	PDT
18637	1369	41	a	a	DT
18637	1369	42	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1369	43	,	,	,
18637	1369	44	could	could	MD
18637	1369	45	not	not	RB
18637	1369	46	be	be	VB
18637	1369	47	cured	cure	VBN
18637	1369	48	by	by	IN
18637	1369	49	the	the	DT
18637	1369	50	Administrator	administrator	NN
18637	1369	51	's	's	POS
18637	1369	52	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	1369	53	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	1369	54	.	.	.
18637	1370	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1370	2	83	83	CD
18637	1370	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1370	4	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1370	5	Investigations	investigation	NNS
18637	1370	6	INVESTIGATIONS	investigations	RB
18637	1370	7	IN	in	IN
18637	1370	8	AID	aid	NN
18637	1370	9	OF	of	IN
18637	1370	10	LEGISLATION	LEGISLATION	NNP
18637	1370	11	No	no	DT
18637	1370	12	provision	provision	NN
18637	1370	13	of	of	IN
18637	1370	14	the	the	DT
18637	1370	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1370	16	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	1370	17	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	1370	18	either	either	DT
18637	1370	19	house	house	NN
18637	1370	20	of	of	IN
18637	1370	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1370	22	to	to	TO
18637	1370	23	make	make	VB
18637	1370	24	investigations	investigation	NNS
18637	1370	25	and	and	CC
18637	1370	26	exact	exact	JJ
18637	1370	27	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	1370	28	to	to	IN
18637	1370	29	the	the	DT
18637	1370	30	end	end	NN
18637	1370	31	that	that	IN
18637	1370	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1370	33	may	may	MD
18637	1370	34	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	1370	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1370	36	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1370	37	function	function	NN
18637	1370	38	effectively	effectively	RB
18637	1370	39	and	and	CC
18637	1370	40	advisedly	advisedly	RB
18637	1370	41	.	.	.
18637	1371	1	But	but	CC
18637	1371	2	such	such	PDT
18637	1371	3	a	a	DT
18637	1371	4	power	power	NN
18637	1371	5	had	have	VBD
18637	1371	6	been	be	VBN
18637	1371	7	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	1371	8	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	1371	9	by	by	IN
18637	1371	10	the	the	DT
18637	1371	11	British	British	NNP
18637	1371	12	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
18637	1371	13	and	and	CC
18637	1371	14	by	by	IN
18637	1371	15	the	the	DT
18637	1371	16	Assemblies	assembly	NNS
18637	1371	17	of	of	IN
18637	1371	18	the	the	DT
18637	1371	19	American	American	NNP
18637	1371	20	Colonies	Colonies	NNPS
18637	1371	21	prior	prior	RB
18637	1371	22	to	to	IN
18637	1371	23	the	the	DT
18637	1371	24	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	1371	25	of	of	IN
18637	1371	26	the	the	DT
18637	1371	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1371	28	.	.	.
18637	1372	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1372	2	84	84	CD
18637	1372	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1372	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1372	5	was	be	VBD
18637	1372	6	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	1372	7	by	by	IN
18637	1372	8	the	the	DT
18637	1372	9	House	House	NNP
18637	1372	10	of	of	IN
18637	1372	11	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1372	12	as	as	RB
18637	1372	13	early	early	RB
18637	1372	14	as	as	IN
18637	1372	15	1792	1792	CD
18637	1372	16	when	when	WRB
18637	1372	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1372	18	appointed	appoint	VBD
18637	1372	19	a	a	DT
18637	1372	20	committee	committee	NN
18637	1372	21	to	to	TO
18637	1372	22	investigate	investigate	VB
18637	1372	23	the	the	DT
18637	1372	24	disaster	disaster	NN
18637	1372	25	to	to	IN
18637	1372	26	General	General	NNP
18637	1372	27	St.	St.	NNP
18637	1372	28	Clair	Clair	NNP
18637	1372	29	and	and	CC
18637	1372	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1372	31	army	army	NN
18637	1372	32	in	in	IN
18637	1372	33	the	the	DT
18637	1372	34	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	1372	35	and	and	CC
18637	1372	36	empowered	empower	VBD
18637	1372	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1372	38	to	to	TO
18637	1372	39	"	"	``
18637	1372	40	call	call	VB
18637	1372	41	for	for	IN
18637	1372	42	such	such	JJ
18637	1372	43	persons	person	NNS
18637	1372	44	,	,	,
18637	1372	45	papers	paper	NNS
18637	1372	46	,	,	,
18637	1372	47	and	and	CC
18637	1372	48	records	record	NNS
18637	1372	49	,	,	,
18637	1372	50	as	as	IN
18637	1372	51	may	may	MD
18637	1372	52	be	be	VB
18637	1372	53	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1372	54	to	to	TO
18637	1372	55	assist	assist	VB
18637	1372	56	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1372	57	inquiries	inquiry	NNS
18637	1372	58	.	.	.
18637	1373	1	"	"	``
18637	1373	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1373	3	85	85	CD
18637	1373	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1373	5	CONDUCT	conduct	NN
18637	1373	6	OF	of	IN
18637	1373	7	EXECUTIVE	executive	NN
18637	1373	8	DEPARTMENT	DEPARTMENT	NNP
18637	1373	9	For	for	IN
18637	1373	10	many	many	JJ
18637	1373	11	years	year	NNS
18637	1373	12	the	the	DT
18637	1373	13	investigating	investigate	VBG
18637	1373	14	function	function	NN
18637	1373	15	of	of	IN
18637	1373	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1373	17	was	be	VBD
18637	1373	18	limited	limit	VBN
18637	1373	19	to	to	IN
18637	1373	20	inquiries	inquiry	NNS
18637	1373	21	into	into	IN
18637	1373	22	the	the	DT
18637	1373	23	administration	administration	NN
18637	1373	24	of	of	IN
18637	1373	25	the	the	DT
18637	1373	26	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	1373	27	Department	Department	NNP
18637	1373	28	or	or	CC
18637	1373	29	of	of	IN
18637	1373	30	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	1373	31	of	of	IN
18637	1373	32	the	the	DT
18637	1373	33	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1373	34	.	.	.
18637	1374	1	Until	until	IN
18637	1374	2	the	the	DT
18637	1374	3	administration	administration	NN
18637	1374	4	of	of	IN
18637	1374	5	Andrew	Andrew	NNP
18637	1374	6	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	1374	7	this	this	DT
18637	1374	8	power	power	NN
18637	1374	9	was	be	VBD
18637	1374	10	not	not	RB
18637	1374	11	seriously	seriously	RB
18637	1374	12	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	1374	13	.	.	.
18637	1375	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1375	2	86	86	CD
18637	1375	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1375	4	During	during	IN
18637	1375	5	the	the	DT
18637	1375	6	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	1375	7	over	over	IN
18637	1375	8	renewal	renewal	NN
18637	1375	9	of	of	IN
18637	1375	10	the	the	DT
18637	1375	11	charter	charter	NN
18637	1375	12	of	of	IN
18637	1375	13	the	the	DT
18637	1375	14	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	1375	15	of	of	IN
18637	1375	16	the	the	DT
18637	1375	17	United	United	NNP
18637	1375	18	States	States	NNP
18637	1375	19	,	,	,
18637	1375	20	John	John	NNP
18637	1375	21	Quincy	Quincy	NNP
18637	1375	22	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	1375	23	contended	contend	VBD
18637	1375	24	that	that	IN
18637	1375	25	an	an	DT
18637	1375	26	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	1375	27	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	1375	28	into	into	IN
18637	1375	29	the	the	DT
18637	1375	30	operations	operation	NNS
18637	1375	31	of	of	IN
18637	1375	32	the	the	DT
18637	1375	33	bank	bank	NN
18637	1375	34	would	would	MD
18637	1375	35	be	be	VB
18637	1375	36	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	1375	37	the	the	DT
18637	1375	38	power	power	NN
18637	1375	39	of	of	IN
18637	1375	40	the	the	DT
18637	1375	41	House	House	NNP
18637	1375	42	.	.	.
18637	1376	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1376	2	87	87	CD
18637	1376	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1376	4	Four	four	CD
18637	1376	5	years	year	NNS
18637	1376	6	later	later	RBR
18637	1376	7	the	the	DT
18637	1376	8	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1376	9	power	power	NN
18637	1376	10	of	of	IN
18637	1376	11	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	1376	12	was	be	VBD
18637	1376	13	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	1376	14	by	by	IN
18637	1376	15	the	the	DT
18637	1376	16	President	President	NNP
18637	1376	17	.	.	.
18637	1377	1	A	a	DT
18637	1377	2	committee	committee	NN
18637	1377	3	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	1377	4	by	by	IN
18637	1377	5	the	the	DT
18637	1377	6	House	House	NNP
18637	1377	7	of	of	IN
18637	1377	8	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1377	9	"	"	''
18637	1377	10	with	with	IN
18637	1377	11	power	power	NN
18637	1377	12	to	to	TO
18637	1377	13	send	send	VB
18637	1377	14	for	for	IN
18637	1377	15	persons	person	NNS
18637	1377	16	and	and	CC
18637	1377	17	papers	paper	NNS
18637	1377	18	,	,	,
18637	1377	19	and	and	CC
18637	1377	20	with	with	IN
18637	1377	21	instructions	instruction	NNS
18637	1377	22	to	to	TO
18637	1377	23	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	1377	24	into	into	IN
18637	1377	25	the	the	DT
18637	1377	26	condition	condition	NN
18637	1377	27	of	of	IN
18637	1377	28	the	the	DT
18637	1377	29	various	various	JJ
18637	1377	30	executive	executive	NN
18637	1377	31	departments	department	NNS
18637	1377	32	,	,	,
18637	1377	33	the	the	DT
18637	1377	34	ability	ability	NN
18637	1377	35	and	and	CC
18637	1377	36	integrity	integrity	NN
18637	1377	37	with	with	IN
18637	1377	38	which	which	WDT
18637	1377	39	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1377	40	have	have	VBP
18637	1377	41	been	be	VBN
18637	1377	42	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	1377	43	,	,	,
18637	1377	44	*	*	NFP
18637	1377	45	*	*	NFP
18637	1377	46	*	*	NFP
18637	1377	47	"	"	''
18637	1377	48	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1377	49	88	88	CD
18637	1377	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1377	51	called	call	VBN
18637	1377	52	upon	upon	IN
18637	1377	53	the	the	DT
18637	1377	54	President	President	NNP
18637	1377	55	and	and	CC
18637	1377	56	the	the	DT
18637	1377	57	heads	head	NNS
18637	1377	58	of	of	IN
18637	1377	59	departments	department	NNS
18637	1377	60	for	for	IN
18637	1377	61	lists	list	NNS
18637	1377	62	of	of	IN
18637	1377	63	persons	person	NNS
18637	1377	64	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	1377	65	without	without	IN
18637	1377	66	the	the	DT
18637	1377	67	consent	consent	NN
18637	1377	68	of	of	IN
18637	1377	69	the	the	DT
18637	1377	70	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1377	71	and	and	CC
18637	1377	72	the	the	DT
18637	1377	73	amounts	amount	NNS
18637	1377	74	paid	pay	VBN
18637	1377	75	to	to	IN
18637	1377	76	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1377	77	.	.	.
18637	1378	1	Resentful	resentful	JJ
18637	1378	2	of	of	IN
18637	1378	3	this	this	DT
18637	1378	4	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	1378	5	"	"	''
18637	1378	6	to	to	TO
18637	1378	7	invade	invade	VB
18637	1378	8	the	the	DT
18637	1378	9	just	just	JJ
18637	1378	10	rights	right	NNS
18637	1378	11	of	of	IN
18637	1378	12	the	the	DT
18637	1378	13	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	1378	14	Departments	Departments	NNPS
18637	1378	15	"	"	''
18637	1378	16	the	the	DT
18637	1378	17	President	President	NNP
18637	1378	18	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	1378	19	to	to	TO
18637	1378	20	comply	comply	VB
18637	1378	21	and	and	CC
18637	1378	22	the	the	DT
18637	1378	23	majority	majority	NN
18637	1378	24	of	of	IN
18637	1378	25	the	the	DT
18637	1378	26	committee	committee	NN
18637	1378	27	acquiesced	acquiesce	VBD
18637	1378	28	.	.	.
18637	1379	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1379	2	89	89	CD
18637	1379	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1379	4	Nevertheless	nevertheless	JJ
18637	1379	5	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1379	6	investigations	investigation	NNS
18637	1379	7	of	of	IN
18637	1379	8	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	1379	9	Departments	Departments	NNPS
18637	1379	10	have	have	VBP
18637	1379	11	continued	continue	VBN
18637	1379	12	to	to	IN
18637	1379	13	the	the	DT
18637	1379	14	present	present	JJ
18637	1379	15	day	day	NN
18637	1379	16	.	.	.
18637	1380	1	Shortly	shortly	RB
18637	1380	2	before	before	IN
18637	1380	3	the	the	DT
18637	1380	4	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	1380	5	War	War	NNP
18637	1380	6	,	,	,
18637	1380	7	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	1380	8	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	1380	9	against	against	IN
18637	1380	10	a	a	DT
18637	1380	11	witness	witness	NN
18637	1380	12	who	who	WP
18637	1380	13	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	1380	14	to	to	TO
18637	1380	15	testify	testify	VB
18637	1380	16	in	in	IN
18637	1380	17	an	an	DT
18637	1380	18	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	1380	19	of	of	IN
18637	1380	20	John	John	NNP
18637	1380	21	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	1380	22	's	's	POS
18637	1380	23	raid	raid	NN
18637	1380	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	1380	25	the	the	DT
18637	1380	26	arsenal	arsenal	NN
18637	1380	27	at	at	IN
18637	1380	28	Harper	Harper	NNP
18637	1380	29	's	's	POS
18637	1380	30	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	1380	31	occasioned	occasion	VBD
18637	1380	32	a	a	DT
18637	1380	33	thorough	thorough	JJ
18637	1380	34	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	1380	35	by	by	IN
18637	1380	36	the	the	DT
18637	1380	37	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1380	38	of	of	IN
18637	1380	39	the	the	DT
18637	1380	40	basis	basis	NN
18637	1380	41	of	of	IN
18637	1380	42	this	this	DT
18637	1380	43	power	power	NN
18637	1380	44	.	.	.
18637	1381	1	After	after	IN
18637	1381	2	a	a	DT
18637	1381	3	protracted	protract	VBN
18637	1381	4	debate	debate	NN
18637	1381	5	,	,	,
18637	1381	6	which	which	WDT
18637	1381	7	cut	cut	VBD
18637	1381	8	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	1381	9	across	across	IN
18637	1381	10	sectional	sectional	JJ
18637	1381	11	and	and	CC
18637	1381	12	party	party	NN
18637	1381	13	lines	line	NNS
18637	1381	14	,	,	,
18637	1381	15	the	the	DT
18637	1381	16	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1381	17	voted	vote	VBD
18637	1381	18	overwhelmingly	overwhelmingly	RB
18637	1381	19	to	to	TO
18637	1381	20	imprison	imprison	VB
18637	1381	21	the	the	DT
18637	1381	22	contumacious	contumacious	JJ
18637	1381	23	witness	witness	NN
18637	1381	24	.	.	.
18637	1382	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1382	2	90	90	CD
18637	1382	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1382	4	Notwithstanding	Notwithstanding	NNP
18637	1382	5	this	this	DT
18637	1382	6	firmly	firmly	RB
18637	1382	7	established	establish	VBD
18637	1382	8	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1382	9	practice	practice	NN
18637	1382	10	the	the	DT
18637	1382	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1382	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1382	13	took	take	VBD
18637	1382	14	a	a	DT
18637	1382	15	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	1382	16	view	view	NN
18637	1382	17	of	of	IN
18637	1382	18	the	the	DT
18637	1382	19	power	power	NN
18637	1382	20	in	in	IN
18637	1382	21	the	the	DT
18637	1382	22	case	case	NN
18637	1382	23	of	of	IN
18637	1382	24	Kilbourn	Kilbourn	NNP
18637	1382	25	_	_	NNP
18637	1382	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	1382	27	_	_	NNP
18637	1382	28	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	1382	29	.	.	.
18637	1383	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1383	2	91	91	CD
18637	1383	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1383	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1383	5	held	hold	VBD
18637	1383	6	that	that	IN
18637	1383	7	the	the	DT
18637	1383	8	House	House	NNP
18637	1383	9	of	of	IN
18637	1383	10	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1383	11	had	have	VBD
18637	1383	12	overstepped	overstep	VBN
18637	1383	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1383	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	1383	15	when	when	WRB
18637	1383	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1383	17	instituted	institute	VBD
18637	1383	18	an	an	DT
18637	1383	19	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	1383	20	of	of	IN
18637	1383	21	losses	loss	NNS
18637	1383	22	suffered	suffer	VBN
18637	1383	23	by	by	IN
18637	1383	24	the	the	DT
18637	1383	25	United	United	NNP
18637	1383	26	States	States	NNP
18637	1383	27	as	as	IN
18637	1383	28	a	a	DT
18637	1383	29	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	1383	30	of	of	IN
18637	1383	31	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	1383	32	Cooke	Cooke	NNP
18637	1383	33	and	and	CC
18637	1383	34	Company	Company	NNP
18637	1383	35	,	,	,
18637	1383	36	whose	whose	WP$
18637	1383	37	estate	estate	NN
18637	1383	38	was	be	VBD
18637	1383	39	being	be	VBG
18637	1383	40	administered	administer	VBN
18637	1383	41	in	in	IN
18637	1383	42	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	1383	43	by	by	IN
18637	1383	44	a	a	DT
18637	1383	45	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1383	46	court	court	NN
18637	1383	47	.	.	.
18637	1384	1	But	but	CC
18637	1384	2	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	1384	3	half	half	PDT
18637	1384	4	a	a	DT
18637	1384	5	century	century	NN
18637	1384	6	later	later	RB
18637	1384	7	,	,	,
18637	1384	8	in	in	IN
18637	1384	9	McGrain	McGrain	NNP
18637	1384	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1384	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	1384	12	_	_	NNP
18637	1384	13	Daugherty,[92	Daugherty,[92	NNP
18637	1384	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1384	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1384	16	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1384	17	in	in	IN
18637	1384	18	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	1384	19	terms	term	NNS
18637	1384	20	,	,	,
18637	1384	21	the	the	DT
18637	1384	22	power	power	NN
18637	1384	23	of	of	IN
18637	1384	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1384	25	to	to	TO
18637	1384	26	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	1384	27	into	into	IN
18637	1384	28	the	the	DT
18637	1384	29	administration	administration	NN
18637	1384	30	of	of	IN
18637	1384	31	an	an	DT
18637	1384	32	executive	executive	JJ
18637	1384	33	department	department	NN
18637	1384	34	and	and	CC
18637	1384	35	to	to	TO
18637	1384	36	sift	sift	VB
18637	1384	37	charges	charge	NNS
18637	1384	38	of	of	IN
18637	1384	39	malfeasance	malfeasance	NN
18637	1384	40	in	in	IN
18637	1384	41	such	such	JJ
18637	1384	42	administration	administration	NN
18637	1384	43	.	.	.
18637	1385	1	PRIVATE	private	JJ
18637	1385	2	AFFAIRS	affair	NNS
18637	1385	3	Beginning	begin	VBG
18637	1385	4	with	with	IN
18637	1385	5	the	the	DT
18637	1385	6	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	1385	7	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	1385	8	by	by	IN
18637	1385	9	the	the	DT
18637	1385	10	House	House	NNP
18637	1385	11	of	of	IN
18637	1385	12	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1385	13	in	in	IN
18637	1385	14	1827	1827	CD
18637	1385	15	which	which	WDT
18637	1385	16	vested	vest	VBD
18637	1385	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1385	18	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	1385	19	on	on	IN
18637	1385	20	Manufactures	Manufactures	NNP
18637	1385	21	"	"	''
18637	1385	22	with	with	IN
18637	1385	23	the	the	DT
18637	1385	24	power	power	NN
18637	1385	25	to	to	TO
18637	1385	26	send	send	VB
18637	1385	27	for	for	IN
18637	1385	28	persons	person	NNS
18637	1385	29	and	and	CC
18637	1385	30	papers	paper	NNS
18637	1385	31	with	with	IN
18637	1385	32	a	a	DT
18637	1385	33	view	view	NN
18637	1385	34	to	to	TO
18637	1385	35	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	1385	36	and	and	CC
18637	1385	37	report	report	VB
18637	1385	38	to	to	IN
18637	1385	39	this	this	DT
18637	1385	40	House	House	NNP
18637	1385	41	such	such	JJ
18637	1385	42	facts	fact	NNS
18637	1385	43	as	as	IN
18637	1385	44	may	may	MD
18637	1385	45	be	be	VB
18637	1385	46	useful	useful	JJ
18637	1385	47	to	to	TO
18637	1385	48	guide	guide	VB
18637	1385	49	the	the	DT
18637	1385	50	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	1385	51	of	of	IN
18637	1385	52	this	this	DT
18637	1385	53	House	House	NNP
18637	1385	54	in	in	IN
18637	1385	55	relation	relation	NN
18637	1385	56	to	to	IN
18637	1385	57	a	a	DT
18637	1385	58	revision	revision	NN
18637	1385	59	of	of	IN
18637	1385	60	the	the	DT
18637	1385	61	tariff	tariff	NN
18637	1385	62	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1385	63	on	on	IN
18637	1385	64	imported	import	VBN
18637	1385	65	goods,"[93	goods,"[93	NNP
18637	1385	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1385	67	the	the	DT
18637	1385	68	two	two	CD
18637	1385	69	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	1385	70	have	have	VBP
18637	1385	71	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	1385	72	the	the	DT
18637	1385	73	right	right	NN
18637	1385	74	to	to	TO
18637	1385	75	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	1385	76	into	into	IN
18637	1385	77	private	private	JJ
18637	1385	78	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	1385	79	when	when	WRB
18637	1385	80	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1385	81	to	to	TO
18637	1385	82	enlighten	enlighten	VB
18637	1385	83	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1385	84	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	1385	85	on	on	IN
18637	1385	86	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1385	87	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1385	88	.	.	.
18637	1386	1	In	in	IN
18637	1386	2	Kilbourn	Kilbourn	NNP
18637	1386	3	_	_	NNP
18637	1386	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	1386	5	_	_	NNP
18637	1386	6	Thompson,[94	Thompson,[94	NNP
18637	1386	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1386	8	the	the	DT
18637	1386	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1386	10	denied	deny	VBD
18637	1386	11	the	the	DT
18637	1386	12	right	right	NN
18637	1386	13	of	of	IN
18637	1386	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1386	15	to	to	TO
18637	1386	16	pry	pry	VB
18637	1386	17	into	into	IN
18637	1386	18	private	private	JJ
18637	1386	19	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	1386	20	.	.	.
18637	1387	1	Again	again	RB
18637	1387	2	,	,	,
18637	1387	3	in	in	IN
18637	1387	4	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	1387	5	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1387	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1387	7	_	_	NNP
18637	1387	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	1387	9	_	_	NNP
18637	1387	10	Brimson,[95	Brimson,[95	NNP
18637	1387	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1387	12	in	in	IN
18637	1387	13	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	1387	14	a	a	DT
18637	1387	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	1387	16	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	1387	17	the	the	DT
18637	1387	18	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	1387	19	to	to	TO
18637	1387	20	use	use	VB
18637	1387	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1387	22	process	process	NN
18637	1387	23	to	to	TO
18637	1387	24	compel	compel	VB
18637	1387	25	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	1387	26	to	to	TO
18637	1387	27	give	give	VB
18637	1387	28	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	1387	29	sought	seek	VBN
18637	1387	30	by	by	IN
18637	1387	31	the	the	DT
18637	1387	32	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1387	33	for	for	IN
18637	1387	34	the	the	DT
18637	1387	35	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	1387	36	of	of	IN
18637	1387	37	the	the	DT
18637	1387	38	act	act	NN
18637	1387	39	,	,	,
18637	1387	40	the	the	DT
18637	1387	41	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1387	42	warned	warn	VBD
18637	1387	43	that	that	IN
18637	1387	44	,	,	,
18637	1387	45	"	"	``
18637	1387	46	neither	neither	DT
18637	1387	47	branch	branch	NN
18637	1387	48	of	of	IN
18637	1387	49	the	the	DT
18637	1387	50	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1387	51	department	department	NN
18637	1387	52	,	,	,
18637	1387	53	still	still	RB
18637	1387	54	less	less	CC
18637	1387	55	any	any	DT
18637	1387	56	merely	merely	RB
18637	1387	57	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	1387	58	body	body	NN
18637	1387	59	,	,	,
18637	1387	60	established	establish	VBN
18637	1387	61	by	by	IN
18637	1387	62	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1387	63	,	,	,
18637	1387	64	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	1387	65	,	,	,
18637	1387	66	or	or	CC
18637	1387	67	can	can	MD
18637	1387	68	be	be	VB
18637	1387	69	invested	invest	VBN
18637	1387	70	with	with	IN
18637	1387	71	,	,	,
18637	1387	72	a	a	DT
18637	1387	73	general	general	JJ
18637	1387	74	power	power	NN
18637	1387	75	of	of	IN
18637	1387	76	making	make	VBG
18637	1387	77	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	1387	78	into	into	IN
18637	1387	79	the	the	DT
18637	1387	80	private	private	JJ
18637	1387	81	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	1387	82	of	of	IN
18637	1387	83	the	the	DT
18637	1387	84	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	1387	85	.	.	.
18637	1388	1	"	"	``
18637	1388	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1388	3	96	96	CD
18637	1388	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1388	5	Finally	finally	RB
18637	1388	6	,	,	,
18637	1388	7	however	however	RB
18637	1388	8	,	,	,
18637	1388	9	in	in	IN
18637	1388	10	McGrain	McGrain	NNP
18637	1388	11	_	_	NNP
18637	1388	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	1388	13	_	_	NNP
18637	1388	14	Daugherty,[97	Daugherty,[97	NNP
18637	1388	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1388	16	the	the	DT
18637	1388	17	power	power	NN
18637	1388	18	of	of	IN
18637	1388	19	either	either	CC
18637	1388	20	House	House	NNP
18637	1388	21	"	"	''
18637	1388	22	to	to	TO
18637	1388	23	compel	compel	VB
18637	1388	24	a	a	DT
18637	1388	25	private	private	JJ
18637	1388	26	individual	individual	NN
18637	1388	27	to	to	TO
18637	1388	28	appear	appear	VB
18637	1388	29	before	before	IN
18637	1388	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1388	31	or	or	CC
18637	1388	32	one	one	CD
18637	1388	33	of	of	IN
18637	1388	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1388	35	committees	committee	NNS
18637	1388	36	and	and	CC
18637	1388	37	give	give	VB
18637	1388	38	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	1388	39	needed	need	VBN
18637	1388	40	to	to	TO
18637	1388	41	enable	enable	VB
18637	1388	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1388	43	efficiently	efficiently	RB
18637	1388	44	to	to	TO
18637	1388	45	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	1388	46	a	a	DT
18637	1388	47	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1388	48	function	function	NN
18637	1388	49	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	1388	50	to	to	IN
18637	1388	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1388	52	under	under	IN
18637	1388	53	the	the	DT
18637	1388	54	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1388	55	,	,	,
18637	1388	56	*	*	NFP
18637	1388	57	*	*	NFP
18637	1388	58	*	*	NFP
18637	1388	59	"	"	''
18637	1388	60	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1388	61	98	98	CD
18637	1388	62	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1388	63	was	be	VBD
18637	1388	64	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	1388	65	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	1388	66	and	and	CC
18637	1388	67	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1388	68	.	.	.
18637	1389	1	PURPOSE	purpose	NN
18637	1389	2	OF	of	IN
18637	1389	3	INQUIRY	INQUIRY	NNP
18637	1389	4	In	in	IN
18637	1389	5	the	the	DT
18637	1389	6	absence	absence	NN
18637	1389	7	of	of	IN
18637	1389	8	any	any	DT
18637	1389	9	showing	showing	NN
18637	1389	10	that	that	DT
18637	1389	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1389	12	was	be	VBD
18637	1389	13	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
18637	1389	14	as	as	IN
18637	1389	15	a	a	DT
18637	1389	16	result	result	NN
18637	1389	17	of	of	IN
18637	1389	18	the	the	DT
18637	1389	19	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	1389	20	undertaken	undertake	VBN
18637	1389	21	in	in	IN
18637	1389	22	Kilbourn	Kilbourn	NNP
18637	1389	23	_	_	NNP
18637	1389	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	1389	25	_	_	NNP
18637	1389	26	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	1389	27	,	,	,
18637	1389	28	the	the	DT
18637	1389	29	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1389	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1389	31	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	1389	32	that	that	IN
18637	1389	33	the	the	DT
18637	1389	34	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1389	35	was	be	VBD
18637	1389	36	an	an	DT
18637	1389	37	improper	improper	JJ
18637	1389	38	one	one	NN
18637	1389	39	--	--	:
18637	1389	40	to	to	TO
18637	1389	41	pry	pry	NNP
18637	1389	42	into	into	IN
18637	1389	43	matters	matter	NNS
18637	1389	44	with	with	IN
18637	1389	45	which	which	WDT
18637	1389	46	the	the	DT
18637	1389	47	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	1389	48	alone	alone	RB
18637	1389	49	was	be	VBD
18637	1389	50	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	1389	51	to	to	TO
18637	1389	52	deal	deal	VB
18637	1389	53	.	.	.
18637	1390	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1390	2	99	99	CD
18637	1390	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1390	4	Subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	1390	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	1390	6	have	have	VBP
18637	1390	7	given	give	VBN
18637	1390	8	the	the	DT
18637	1390	9	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1390	10	the	the	DT
18637	1390	11	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	1390	12	of	of	IN
18637	1390	13	a	a	DT
18637	1390	14	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	1390	15	that	that	IN
18637	1390	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1390	17	object	object	NN
18637	1390	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	1390	19	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	1390	20	.	.	.
18637	1391	1	In	in	IN
18637	1391	2	re	re	RB
18637	1391	3	Chapman[100	Chapman[100	NNP
18637	1391	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1391	5	established	establish	VBD
18637	1391	6	the	the	DT
18637	1391	7	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	1391	8	that	that	WDT
18637	1391	9	to	to	TO
18637	1391	10	make	make	VB
18637	1391	11	an	an	DT
18637	1391	12	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	1391	13	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	1391	14	"	"	''
18637	1391	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1391	16	was	be	VBD
18637	1391	17	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	1391	18	not	not	RB
18637	1391	19	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1391	20	that	that	IN
18637	1391	21	the	the	DT
18637	1391	22	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	1391	23	should	should	MD
18637	1391	24	declare	declare	VB
18637	1391	25	in	in	IN
18637	1391	26	advance	advance	NN
18637	1391	27	what	what	WP
18637	1391	28	the	the	DT
18637	1391	29	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1391	30	meditated	meditate	VBD
18637	1391	31	doing	do	VBG
18637	1391	32	when	when	WRB
18637	1391	33	the	the	DT
18637	1391	34	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	1391	35	was	be	VBD
18637	1391	36	concluded	conclude	VBN
18637	1391	37	.	.	.
18637	1392	1	"	"	``
18637	1392	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1392	3	101	101	CD
18637	1392	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1392	5	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	1392	6	,	,	,
18637	1392	7	in	in	IN
18637	1392	8	McGrain	McGrain	NNP
18637	1392	9	_	_	NNP
18637	1392	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	1392	11	_	_	NNP
18637	1392	12	Daugherty	Daugherty	NNP
18637	1392	13	,	,	,
18637	1392	14	the	the	DT
18637	1392	15	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	1392	16	was	be	VBD
18637	1392	17	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	1392	18	to	to	TO
18637	1392	19	have	have	VB
18637	1392	20	been	be	VBN
18637	1392	21	undertaken	undertake	VBN
18637	1392	22	in	in	IN
18637	1392	23	good	good	JJ
18637	1392	24	faith	faith	NN
18637	1392	25	to	to	TO
18637	1392	26	aid	aid	VB
18637	1392	27	the	the	DT
18637	1392	28	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1392	29	in	in	IN
18637	1392	30	legislating	legislating	NN
18637	1392	31	.	.	.
18637	1393	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1393	2	102	102	CD
18637	1393	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1393	4	Going	go	VBG
18637	1393	5	one	one	CD
18637	1393	6	step	step	NN
18637	1393	7	further	far	RBR
18637	1393	8	in	in	IN
18637	1393	9	Sinclair	Sinclair	NNP
18637	1393	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1393	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	1393	12	_	_	NNP
18637	1393	13	United	United	NNP
18637	1393	14	States,[103	States,[103	NNP
18637	1393	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1393	16	which	which	WDT
18637	1393	17	on	on	IN
18637	1393	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1393	19	facts	fact	NNS
18637	1393	20	presented	present	VBD
18637	1393	21	a	a	DT
18637	1393	22	close	close	JJ
18637	1393	23	parallel	parallel	NN
18637	1393	24	to	to	IN
18637	1393	25	the	the	DT
18637	1393	26	Kilbourn	Kilbourn	NNP
18637	1393	27	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1393	28	,	,	,
18637	1393	29	the	the	DT
18637	1393	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1393	31	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	1393	32	the	the	DT
18637	1393	33	right	right	NN
18637	1393	34	of	of	IN
18637	1393	35	the	the	DT
18637	1393	36	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1393	37	to	to	TO
18637	1393	38	carry	carry	VB
18637	1393	39	on	on	RP
18637	1393	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1393	41	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	1393	42	of	of	IN
18637	1393	43	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	1393	44	leases	lease	NNS
18637	1393	45	of	of	IN
18637	1393	46	government	government	NN
18637	1393	47	property	property	NN
18637	1393	48	after	after	IN
18637	1393	49	suit	suit	NN
18637	1393	50	for	for	IN
18637	1393	51	the	the	DT
18637	1393	52	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	1393	53	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	1393	54	had	have	VBD
18637	1393	55	been	be	VBN
18637	1393	56	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	1393	57	.	.	.
18637	1394	1	The	the	DT
18637	1394	2	president	president	NN
18637	1394	3	of	of	IN
18637	1394	4	the	the	DT
18637	1394	5	lessee	lessee	NNP
18637	1394	6	corporation	corporation	NNP
18637	1394	7	had	have	VBD
18637	1394	8	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	1394	9	to	to	TO
18637	1394	10	testify	testify	VB
18637	1394	11	on	on	IN
18637	1394	12	the	the	DT
18637	1394	13	ground	ground	NN
18637	1394	14	that	that	IN
18637	1394	15	the	the	DT
18637	1394	16	questions	question	NNS
18637	1394	17	related	relate	VBN
18637	1394	18	to	to	IN
18637	1394	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1394	20	private	private	JJ
18637	1394	21	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	1394	22	and	and	CC
18637	1394	23	to	to	IN
18637	1394	24	matters	matter	NNS
18637	1394	25	cognizable	cognizable	JJ
18637	1394	26	only	only	RB
18637	1394	27	in	in	IN
18637	1394	28	the	the	DT
18637	1394	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	1394	30	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	1394	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1394	32	were	be	VBD
18637	1394	33	pending	pende	VBG
18637	1394	34	and	and	CC
18637	1394	35	that	that	IN
18637	1394	36	the	the	DT
18637	1394	37	committee	committee	NN
18637	1394	38	avowedly	avowedly	RB
18637	1394	39	had	have	VBD
18637	1394	40	departed	depart	VBN
18637	1394	41	from	from	IN
18637	1394	42	any	any	DT
18637	1394	43	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	1394	44	in	in	IN
18637	1394	45	aid	aid	NN
18637	1394	46	of	of	IN
18637	1394	47	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1394	48	.	.	.
18637	1395	1	The	the	DT
18637	1395	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1395	3	prudently	prudently	RB
18637	1395	4	had	have	VBD
18637	1395	5	directed	direct	VBN
18637	1395	6	the	the	DT
18637	1395	7	investigating	investigate	VBG
18637	1395	8	committee	committee	NN
18637	1395	9	to	to	TO
18637	1395	10	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	1395	11	what	what	WP
18637	1395	12	,	,	,
18637	1395	13	if	if	IN
18637	1395	14	any	any	DT
18637	1395	15	,	,	,
18637	1395	16	other	other	JJ
18637	1395	17	or	or	CC
18637	1395	18	additional	additional	JJ
18637	1395	19	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1395	20	may	may	MD
18637	1395	21	be	be	VB
18637	1395	22	advisable	advisable	JJ
18637	1395	23	.	.	.
18637	1396	1	Conceding	concede	VBG
18637	1396	2	"	"	''
18637	1396	3	that	that	IN
18637	1396	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1396	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	1396	6	without	without	IN
18637	1396	7	authority	authority	NN
18637	1396	8	to	to	TO
18637	1396	9	compel	compel	VB
18637	1396	10	disclosures	disclosure	NNS
18637	1396	11	for	for	IN
18637	1396	12	the	the	DT
18637	1396	13	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1396	14	of	of	IN
18637	1396	15	aiding	aid	VBG
18637	1396	16	the	the	DT
18637	1396	17	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	1396	18	of	of	IN
18637	1396	19	pending	pende	VBG
18637	1396	20	suits	suit	NNS
18637	1396	21	,	,	,
18637	1396	22	"	"	''
18637	1396	23	the	the	DT
18637	1396	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1396	25	declared	declare	VBD
18637	1396	26	that	that	IN
18637	1396	27	the	the	DT
18637	1396	28	authority	authority	NN
18637	1396	29	"	"	``
18637	1396	30	to	to	TO
18637	1396	31	require	require	VB
18637	1396	32	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	1396	33	disclosures	disclosure	NNS
18637	1396	34	in	in	IN
18637	1396	35	aid	aid	NN
18637	1396	36	of	of	IN
18637	1396	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1396	38	own	own	JJ
18637	1396	39	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1396	40	power	power	NN
18637	1396	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	1396	42	not	not	RB
18637	1396	43	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	1396	44	because	because	IN
18637	1396	45	the	the	DT
18637	1396	46	information	information	NN
18637	1396	47	sought	seek	VBD
18637	1396	48	to	to	TO
18637	1396	49	be	be	VB
18637	1396	50	elicited	elicit	VBN
18637	1396	51	may	may	MD
18637	1396	52	also	also	RB
18637	1396	53	be	be	VB
18637	1396	54	of	of	IN
18637	1396	55	use	use	NN
18637	1396	56	in	in	IN
18637	1396	57	such	such	JJ
18637	1396	58	suits	suit	NNS
18637	1396	59	.	.	.
18637	1397	1	"	"	``
18637	1397	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1397	3	104	104	NNP
18637	1397	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1397	5	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	1397	6	FUNCTIONS	FUNCTIONS	NNP
18637	1397	7	When	when	WRB
18637	1397	8	either	either	CC
18637	1397	9	House	House	NNP
18637	1397	10	exercises	exercise	VBZ
18637	1397	11	a	a	DT
18637	1397	12	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1397	13	function	function	NN
18637	1397	14	,	,	,
18637	1397	15	as	as	IN
18637	1397	16	in	in	IN
18637	1397	17	judging	judging	NN
18637	1397	18	of	of	IN
18637	1397	19	elections	election	NNS
18637	1397	20	or	or	CC
18637	1397	21	determining	determine	VBG
18637	1397	22	whether	whether	IN
18637	1397	23	a	a	DT
18637	1397	24	member	member	NN
18637	1397	25	should	should	MD
18637	1397	26	be	be	VB
18637	1397	27	expelled	expel	VBN
18637	1397	28	,	,	,
18637	1397	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1397	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	1397	31	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	1397	32	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	1397	33	to	to	TO
18637	1397	34	compel	compel	VB
18637	1397	35	the	the	DT
18637	1397	36	attendance	attendance	NN
18637	1397	37	of	of	IN
18637	1397	38	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	1397	39	to	to	TO
18637	1397	40	disclose	disclose	VB
18637	1397	41	the	the	DT
18637	1397	42	facts	fact	NNS
18637	1397	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	1397	44	which	which	WDT
18637	1397	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1397	46	action	action	NN
18637	1397	47	must	must	MD
18637	1397	48	be	be	VB
18637	1397	49	based	base	VBN
18637	1397	50	.	.	.
18637	1398	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	1398	2	the	the	DT
18637	1398	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1398	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	1398	5	that	that	IN
18637	1398	6	since	since	IN
18637	1398	7	a	a	DT
18637	1398	8	House	House	NNP
18637	1398	9	had	have	VBD
18637	1398	10	a	a	DT
18637	1398	11	right	right	NN
18637	1398	12	to	to	TO
18637	1398	13	expel	expel	VB
18637	1398	14	a	a	DT
18637	1398	15	member	member	NN
18637	1398	16	for	for	IN
18637	1398	17	any	any	DT
18637	1398	18	offense	offense	NN
18637	1398	19	which	which	WDT
18637	1398	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1398	21	deemed	deem	VBD
18637	1398	22	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
18637	1398	23	with	with	IN
18637	1398	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1398	25	trust	trust	NN
18637	1398	26	and	and	CC
18637	1398	27	duty	duty	NN
18637	1398	28	as	as	IN
18637	1398	29	a	a	DT
18637	1398	30	member	member	NN
18637	1398	31	,	,	,
18637	1398	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1398	33	was	be	VBD
18637	1398	34	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	1398	35	to	to	TO
18637	1398	36	investigate	investigate	VB
18637	1398	37	such	such	JJ
18637	1398	38	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	1398	39	and	and	CC
18637	1398	40	to	to	IN
18637	1398	41	summon	summon	VB
18637	1398	42	private	private	JJ
18637	1398	43	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	1398	44	to	to	TO
18637	1398	45	give	give	VB
18637	1398	46	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	1398	47	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	1398	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1398	49	.	.	.
18637	1399	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1399	2	105	105	CD
18637	1399	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1399	4	The	the	DT
18637	1399	5	decision	decision	NN
18637	1399	6	in	in	IN
18637	1399	7	Barry	Barry	NNP
18637	1399	8	_	_	NNP
18637	1399	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	1399	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1399	11	United	United	NNP
18637	1399	12	States	States	NNP
18637	1399	13	ex	ex	NNP
18637	1399	14	rel	rel	NN
18637	1399	15	.	.	.
18637	1400	1	Cunningham[106	Cunningham[106	NNP
18637	1400	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1400	3	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
18637	1400	4	the	the	DT
18637	1400	5	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1400	6	of	of	IN
18637	1400	7	a	a	DT
18637	1400	8	similar	similar	JJ
18637	1400	9	power	power	NN
18637	1400	10	in	in	IN
18637	1400	11	investigating	investigate	VBG
18637	1400	12	a	a	DT
18637	1400	13	Senatorial	senatorial	JJ
18637	1400	14	election	election	NN
18637	1400	15	.	.	.
18637	1401	1	SANCTIONS	sanction	NNS
18637	1401	2	OF	of	IN
18637	1401	3	THE	the	DT
18637	1401	4	INVESTIGATORY	INVESTIGATORY	NNP
18637	1401	5	POWER	power	NN
18637	1401	6	Contempt	Contempt	NNP
18637	1401	7	Explicit	explicit	JJ
18637	1401	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1401	9	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	1401	10	of	of	IN
18637	1401	11	the	the	DT
18637	1401	12	right	right	NN
18637	1401	13	of	of	IN
18637	1401	14	either	either	CC
18637	1401	15	House	House	NNP
18637	1401	16	of	of	IN
18637	1401	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1401	18	to	to	TO
18637	1401	19	commit	commit	VB
18637	1401	20	for	for	IN
18637	1401	21	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	1401	22	a	a	DT
18637	1401	23	witness	witness	NN
18637	1401	24	who	who	WP
18637	1401	25	ignores	ignore	VBZ
18637	1401	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1401	27	summons	summon	NNS
18637	1401	28	or	or	CC
18637	1401	29	refuses	refuse	VBZ
18637	1401	30	to	to	TO
18637	1401	31	answer	answer	VB
18637	1401	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1401	33	inquiries	inquiry	NNS
18637	1401	34	dates	date	NNS
18637	1401	35	from	from	IN
18637	1401	36	McGrain	McGrain	NNP
18637	1401	37	_	_	NNP
18637	1401	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	1401	39	_	_	NNP
18637	1401	40	Daugherty	Daugherty	NNP
18637	1401	41	.	.	.
18637	1402	1	But	but	CC
18637	1402	2	the	the	DT
18637	1402	3	principle	principle	NN
18637	1402	4	there	there	RB
18637	1402	5	applied	apply	VBD
18637	1402	6	had	have	VBD
18637	1402	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1402	8	roots	root	NNS
18637	1402	9	in	in	IN
18637	1402	10	an	an	DT
18637	1402	11	early	early	JJ
18637	1402	12	case	case	NN
18637	1402	13	,	,	,
18637	1402	14	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	1402	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1402	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	1402	17	_	_	NNP
18637	1402	18	Dunn,[107	Dunn,[107	NNP
18637	1402	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1402	20	which	which	WDT
18637	1402	21	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	1402	22	in	in	IN
18637	1402	23	broad	broad	JJ
18637	1402	24	terms	term	NNS
18637	1402	25	the	the	DT
18637	1402	26	right	right	NN
18637	1402	27	of	of	IN
18637	1402	28	either	either	DT
18637	1402	29	branch	branch	NN
18637	1402	30	of	of	IN
18637	1402	31	the	the	DT
18637	1402	32	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1402	33	to	to	TO
18637	1402	34	attach	attach	VB
18637	1402	35	and	and	CC
18637	1402	36	punish	punish	VB
18637	1402	37	a	a	DT
18637	1402	38	person	person	NN
18637	1402	39	other	other	JJ
18637	1402	40	than	than	IN
18637	1402	41	a	a	DT
18637	1402	42	member	member	NN
18637	1402	43	for	for	IN
18637	1402	44	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	1402	45	of	of	IN
18637	1402	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1402	47	authority	authority	NN
18637	1402	48	--	--	:
18637	1402	49	in	in	IN
18637	1402	50	that	that	DT
18637	1402	51	case	case	NN
18637	1402	52	an	an	DT
18637	1402	53	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	1402	54	to	to	TO
18637	1402	55	bribe	bribe	VB
18637	1402	56	one	one	CD
18637	1402	57	of	of	IN
18637	1402	58	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1402	59	members	member	NNS
18637	1402	60	.	.	.
18637	1403	1	The	the	DT
18637	1403	2	right	right	NN
18637	1403	3	to	to	TO
18637	1403	4	punish	punish	VB
18637	1403	5	a	a	DT
18637	1403	6	contumacious	contumacious	JJ
18637	1403	7	witness	witness	NN
18637	1403	8	was	be	VBD
18637	1403	9	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	1403	10	in	in	IN
18637	1403	11	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1403	12	_	_	NNP
18637	1403	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	1403	14	_	_	NNP
18637	1403	15	Gordon,[108	Gordon,[108	NNP
18637	1403	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1403	17	although	although	IN
18637	1403	18	the	the	DT
18637	1403	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1403	20	there	there	RB
18637	1403	21	held	hold	VBD
18637	1403	22	that	that	IN
18637	1403	23	the	the	DT
18637	1403	24	implied	implied	JJ
18637	1403	25	power	power	NN
18637	1403	26	to	to	TO
18637	1403	27	deal	deal	VB
18637	1403	28	with	with	IN
18637	1403	29	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	1403	30	did	do	VBD
18637	1403	31	not	not	RB
18637	1403	32	extend	extend	VB
18637	1403	33	to	to	IN
18637	1403	34	the	the	DT
18637	1403	35	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	1403	36	of	of	IN
18637	1403	37	a	a	DT
18637	1403	38	person	person	NN
18637	1403	39	who	who	WP
18637	1403	40	published	publish	VBD
18637	1403	41	matter	matter	NN
18637	1403	42	defamatory	defamatory	JJ
18637	1403	43	of	of	IN
18637	1403	44	the	the	DT
18637	1403	45	House	House	NNP
18637	1403	46	.	.	.
18637	1404	1	Both	both	DT
18637	1404	2	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	1404	3	_	_	NNP
18637	1404	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	1404	5	_	_	NNP
18637	1404	6	Dunn	Dunn	NNP
18637	1404	7	and	and	CC
18637	1404	8	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1404	9	_	_	NNP
18637	1404	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	1404	11	_	_	NNP
18637	1404	12	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	1404	13	emphasized	emphasize	VBD
18637	1404	14	that	that	IN
18637	1404	15	the	the	DT
18637	1404	16	power	power	NN
18637	1404	17	to	to	TO
18637	1404	18	punish	punish	VB
18637	1404	19	for	for	IN
18637	1404	20	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	1404	21	rests	rest	NNS
18637	1404	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	1404	23	the	the	DT
18637	1404	24	right	right	NN
18637	1404	25	of	of	IN
18637	1404	26	self	self	NN
18637	1404	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	1404	28	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	1404	29	;	;	:
18637	1404	30	that	that	RB
18637	1404	31	is	is	RB
18637	1404	32	,	,	,
18637	1404	33	in	in	IN
18637	1404	34	the	the	DT
18637	1404	35	words	word	NNS
18637	1404	36	of	of	IN
18637	1404	37	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1404	38	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1404	39	White	White	NNP
18637	1404	40	,	,	,
18637	1404	41	"	"	''
18637	1404	42	the	the	DT
18637	1404	43	right	right	NN
18637	1404	44	to	to	TO
18637	1404	45	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	1404	46	acts	act	NNS
18637	1404	47	which	which	WDT
18637	1404	48	in	in	RB
18637	1404	49	and	and	CC
18637	1404	50	of	of	IN
18637	1404	51	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1404	52	inherently	inherently	RB
18637	1404	53	obstruct	obstruct	VBP
18637	1404	54	or	or	CC
18637	1404	55	prevent	prevent	VBP
18637	1404	56	the	the	DT
18637	1404	57	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	1404	58	of	of	IN
18637	1404	59	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1404	60	duty	duty	NN
18637	1404	61	or	or	CC
18637	1404	62	the	the	DT
18637	1404	63	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	1404	64	to	to	TO
18637	1404	65	do	do	VB
18637	1404	66	that	that	DT
18637	1404	67	which	which	WDT
18637	1404	68	there	there	EX
18637	1404	69	is	be	VBZ
18637	1404	70	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	1404	71	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1404	72	power	power	NN
18637	1404	73	to	to	TO
18637	1404	74	compel	compel	VB
18637	1404	75	in	in	IN
18637	1404	76	order	order	NN
18637	1404	77	that	that	IN
18637	1404	78	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1404	79	functions	function	NNS
18637	1404	80	may	may	MD
18637	1404	81	be	be	VB
18637	1404	82	performed	perform	VBN
18637	1404	83	.	.	.
18637	1405	1	"	"	``
18637	1405	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1405	3	109	109	CD
18637	1405	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1405	5	Whence	whence	NN
18637	1405	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1405	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1405	8	argued	argue	VBN
18637	1405	9	,	,	,
18637	1405	10	in	in	IN
18637	1405	11	Jurney	Jurney	NNP
18637	1405	12	_	_	NNP
18637	1405	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	1405	14	_	_	NNP
18637	1405	15	MacCracken[110	MacCracken[110	NNP
18637	1405	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1405	17	that	that	IN
18637	1405	18	the	the	DT
18637	1405	19	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1405	20	had	have	VBD
18637	1405	21	no	no	DT
18637	1405	22	power	power	NN
18637	1405	23	to	to	TO
18637	1405	24	punish	punish	VB
18637	1405	25	a	a	DT
18637	1405	26	witness	witness	NN
18637	1405	27	who	who	WP
18637	1405	28	,	,	,
18637	1405	29	having	have	VBG
18637	1405	30	been	be	VBN
18637	1405	31	commanded	command	VBN
18637	1405	32	to	to	TO
18637	1405	33	produce	produce	VB
18637	1405	34	papers	paper	NNS
18637	1405	35	,	,	,
18637	1405	36	destroyed	destroy	VBD
18637	1405	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1405	38	after	after	IN
18637	1405	39	service	service	NN
18637	1405	40	of	of	IN
18637	1405	41	the	the	DT
18637	1405	42	subpoena	subpoena	NN
18637	1405	43	,	,	,
18637	1405	44	because	because	IN
18637	1405	45	the	the	DT
18637	1405	46	"	"	``
18637	1405	47	power	power	NN
18637	1405	48	to	to	TO
18637	1405	49	punish	punish	VB
18637	1405	50	for	for	IN
18637	1405	51	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	1405	52	may	may	MD
18637	1405	53	never	never	RB
18637	1405	54	be	be	VB
18637	1405	55	exerted	exert	VBN
18637	1405	56	,	,	,
18637	1405	57	in	in	IN
18637	1405	58	the	the	DT
18637	1405	59	case	case	NN
18637	1405	60	of	of	IN
18637	1405	61	a	a	DT
18637	1405	62	private	private	JJ
18637	1405	63	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	1405	64	,	,	,
18637	1405	65	solely	solely	RB
18637	1405	66	_	_	NNP
18637	1405	67	qua	qua	NNP
18637	1405	68	_	_	NNP
18637	1405	69	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	1405	70	.	.	.
18637	1406	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1406	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1406	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1406	4	the	the	DT
18637	1406	5	power	power	NN
18637	1406	6	to	to	TO
18637	1406	7	punish	punish	VB
18637	1406	8	ceases	cease	NNS
18637	1406	9	as	as	RB
18637	1406	10	soon	soon	RB
18637	1406	11	as	as	IN
18637	1406	12	the	the	DT
18637	1406	13	obstruction	obstruction	NN
18637	1406	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	1406	15	been	be	VBN
18637	1406	16	removed	remove	VBN
18637	1406	17	,	,	,
18637	1406	18	or	or	CC
18637	1406	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1406	20	removal	removal	NN
18637	1406	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	1406	22	become	become	VBN
18637	1406	23	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	1406	24	;	;	:
18637	1406	25	*	*	NFP
18637	1406	26	*	*	NFP
18637	1406	27	*	*	NFP
18637	1406	28	"	"	``
18637	1406	29	The	the	DT
18637	1406	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1406	31	confirmed	confirm	VBD
18637	1406	32	the	the	DT
18637	1406	33	power	power	NN
18637	1406	34	to	to	TO
18637	1406	35	punish	punish	VB
18637	1406	36	for	for	IN
18637	1406	37	a	a	DT
18637	1406	38	past	past	JJ
18637	1406	39	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	1406	40	as	as	IN
18637	1406	41	an	an	DT
18637	1406	42	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	1406	43	means	mean	VBZ
18637	1406	44	for	for	IN
18637	1406	45	vindicating	vindicate	VBG
18637	1406	46	"	"	``
18637	1406	47	the	the	DT
18637	1406	48	established	established	JJ
18637	1406	49	and	and	CC
18637	1406	50	essential	essential	JJ
18637	1406	51	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	1406	52	of	of	IN
18637	1406	53	requiring	require	VBG
18637	1406	54	the	the	DT
18637	1406	55	production	production	NN
18637	1406	56	of	of	IN
18637	1406	57	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	1406	58	.	.	.
18637	1407	1	"	"	``
18637	1407	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1407	3	111	111	CD
18637	1407	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1407	5	Criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	1407	6	Prosecutions	Prosecutions	NNPS
18637	1407	7	Under	under	IN
18637	1407	8	the	the	DT
18637	1407	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	1407	10	laid	lay	VBN
18637	1407	11	down	down	RP
18637	1407	12	by	by	IN
18637	1407	13	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	1407	14	_	_	NNP
18637	1407	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	1407	16	_	_	NNP
18637	1407	17	Dunn	Dunn	NNP
18637	1407	18	,	,	,
18637	1407	19	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	1407	20	for	for	IN
18637	1407	21	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	1407	22	of	of	IN
18637	1407	23	one	one	CD
18637	1407	24	of	of	IN
18637	1407	25	the	the	DT
18637	1407	26	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	1407	27	of	of	IN
18637	1407	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1407	29	could	could	MD
18637	1407	30	not	not	RB
18637	1407	31	extend	extend	VB
18637	1407	32	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	1407	33	the	the	DT
18637	1407	34	adjournment	adjournment	NN
18637	1407	35	of	of	IN
18637	1407	36	the	the	DT
18637	1407	37	body	body	NN
18637	1407	38	which	which	WDT
18637	1407	39	ordered	order	VBD
18637	1407	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1407	41	.	.	.
18637	1408	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1408	2	112	112	CD
18637	1408	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1408	4	This	this	DT
18637	1408	5	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	1408	6	seriously	seriously	RB
18637	1408	7	impaired	impair	VBD
18637	1408	8	the	the	DT
18637	1408	9	efficacy	efficacy	NN
18637	1408	10	of	of	IN
18637	1408	11	such	such	JJ
18637	1408	12	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	1408	13	.	.	.
18637	1409	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	1409	2	,	,	,
18637	1409	3	in	in	IN
18637	1409	4	1857	1857	CD
18637	1409	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1409	6	found	find	VBD
18637	1409	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1409	8	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1409	9	to	to	TO
18637	1409	10	provide	provide	VB
18637	1409	11	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	1409	12	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	1409	13	for	for	IN
18637	1409	14	recalcitrant	recalcitrant	JJ
18637	1409	15	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	1409	16	,	,	,
18637	1409	17	in	in	IN
18637	1409	18	order	order	NN
18637	1409	19	to	to	TO
18637	1409	20	make	make	VB
18637	1409	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1409	22	power	power	NN
18637	1409	23	to	to	TO
18637	1409	24	compel	compel	VB
18637	1409	25	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	1409	26	more	more	RBR
18637	1409	27	effective	effective	JJ
18637	1409	28	.	.	.
18637	1410	1	The	the	DT
18637	1410	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1410	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1410	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	1410	5	that	that	IN
18637	1410	6	the	the	DT
18637	1410	7	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1410	8	of	of	IN
18637	1410	9	this	this	DT
18637	1410	10	statute	statute	NN
18637	1410	11	was	be	VBD
18637	1410	12	merely	merely	RB
18637	1410	13	to	to	TO
18637	1410	14	supplement	supplement	VB
18637	1410	15	the	the	DT
18637	1410	16	power	power	NN
18637	1410	17	of	of	IN
18637	1410	18	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	1410	19	by	by	IN
18637	1410	20	providing	provide	VBG
18637	1410	21	additional	additional	JJ
18637	1410	22	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	1410	23	,	,	,
18637	1410	24	and	and	CC
18637	1410	25	overruled	overrule	VBD
18637	1410	26	all	all	DT
18637	1410	27	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1410	28	objections	objection	NNS
18637	1410	29	to	to	IN
18637	1410	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1410	31	saying	say	VBG
18637	1410	32	:	:	:
18637	1410	33	"	"	``
18637	1410	34	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1410	35	grant	grant	VBP
18637	1410	36	that	that	IN
18637	1410	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1410	38	could	could	MD
18637	1410	39	not	not	RB
18637	1410	40	divest	divest	VB
18637	1410	41	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1410	42	,	,	,
18637	1410	43	or	or	CC
18637	1410	44	either	either	DT
18637	1410	45	of	of	IN
18637	1410	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1410	47	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	1410	48	,	,	,
18637	1410	49	of	of	IN
18637	1410	50	the	the	DT
18637	1410	51	essential	essential	JJ
18637	1410	52	and	and	CC
18637	1410	53	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	1410	54	power	power	NN
18637	1410	55	to	to	TO
18637	1410	56	punish	punish	VB
18637	1410	57	for	for	IN
18637	1410	58	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	1410	59	,	,	,
18637	1410	60	in	in	IN
18637	1410	61	cases	case	NNS
18637	1410	62	to	to	TO
18637	1410	63	which	which	WDT
18637	1410	64	the	the	DT
18637	1410	65	power	power	NN
18637	1410	66	of	of	IN
18637	1410	67	either	either	CC
18637	1410	68	House	House	NNP
18637	1410	69	properly	properly	RB
18637	1410	70	extended	extend	VBD
18637	1410	71	;	;	:
18637	1410	72	but	but	CC
18637	1410	73	,	,	,
18637	1410	74	because	because	IN
18637	1410	75	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1410	76	,	,	,
18637	1410	77	by	by	IN
18637	1410	78	the	the	DT
18637	1410	79	act	act	NN
18637	1410	80	of	of	IN
18637	1410	81	1857	1857	CD
18637	1410	82	,	,	,
18637	1410	83	sought	seek	VBD
18637	1410	84	to	to	TO
18637	1410	85	aid	aid	VB
18637	1410	86	each	each	DT
18637	1410	87	of	of	IN
18637	1410	88	the	the	DT
18637	1410	89	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	1410	90	in	in	IN
18637	1410	91	the	the	DT
18637	1410	92	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	1410	93	of	of	IN
18637	1410	94	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1410	95	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1410	96	functions	function	NNS
18637	1410	97	,	,	,
18637	1410	98	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1410	99	does	do	VBZ
18637	1410	100	not	not	RB
18637	1410	101	follow	follow	VB
18637	1410	102	that	that	IN
18637	1410	103	any	any	DT
18637	1410	104	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	1410	105	of	of	IN
18637	1410	106	the	the	DT
18637	1410	107	power	power	NN
18637	1410	108	in	in	IN
18637	1410	109	each	each	DT
18637	1410	110	to	to	TO
18637	1410	111	punish	punish	VB
18637	1410	112	for	for	IN
18637	1410	113	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	1410	114	was	be	VBD
18637	1410	115	involved	involve	VBN
18637	1410	116	;	;	:
18637	1410	117	*	*	NFP
18637	1410	118	*	*	NFP
18637	1410	119	*	*	NFP
18637	1410	120	.	.	.
18637	1411	1	"	"	``
18637	1411	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1411	3	113	113	CD
18637	1411	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1411	5	In	in	IN
18637	1411	6	a	a	DT
18637	1411	7	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	1411	8	for	for	IN
18637	1411	9	wilful	wilful	JJ
18637	1411	10	failure	failure	NN
18637	1411	11	of	of	IN
18637	1411	12	a	a	DT
18637	1411	13	person	person	NN
18637	1411	14	to	to	TO
18637	1411	15	produce	produce	VB
18637	1411	16	records	record	NNS
18637	1411	17	within	within	IN
18637	1411	18	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1411	19	custody	custody	NN
18637	1411	20	and	and	CC
18637	1411	21	control	control	NN
18637	1411	22	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	1411	23	to	to	IN
18637	1411	24	a	a	DT
18637	1411	25	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	1411	26	subpoena	subpoena	NN
18637	1411	27	issued	issue	VBN
18637	1411	28	by	by	IN
18637	1411	29	a	a	DT
18637	1411	30	committee	committee	NN
18637	1411	31	of	of	IN
18637	1411	32	the	the	DT
18637	1411	33	House	House	NNP
18637	1411	34	of	of	IN
18637	1411	35	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1411	36	,	,	,
18637	1411	37	the	the	DT
18637	1411	38	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1411	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1411	40	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	1411	41	that	that	IN
18637	1411	42	the	the	DT
18637	1411	43	presence	presence	NN
18637	1411	44	of	of	IN
18637	1411	45	a	a	DT
18637	1411	46	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	1411	47	of	of	IN
18637	1411	48	the	the	DT
18637	1411	49	committee	committee	NN
18637	1411	50	at	at	IN
18637	1411	51	the	the	DT
18637	1411	52	time	time	NN
18637	1411	53	of	of	IN
18637	1411	54	the	the	DT
18637	1411	55	return	return	NN
18637	1411	56	of	of	IN
18637	1411	57	the	the	DT
18637	1411	58	subpoena	subpoena	NN
18637	1411	59	was	be	VBD
18637	1411	60	not	not	RB
18637	1411	61	an	an	DT
18637	1411	62	essential	essential	JJ
18637	1411	63	element	element	NN
18637	1411	64	of	of	IN
18637	1411	65	the	the	DT
18637	1411	66	offense	offense	NN
18637	1411	67	.	.	.
18637	1412	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1412	2	114	114	CD
18637	1412	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1412	4	Previously	previously	RB
18637	1412	5	the	the	DT
18637	1412	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1412	7	had	have	VBD
18637	1412	8	held	hold	VBN
18637	1412	9	that	that	IN
18637	1412	10	a	a	DT
18637	1412	11	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	1412	12	could	could	MD
18637	1412	13	not	not	RB
18637	1412	14	be	be	VB
18637	1412	15	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	1412	16	under	under	IN
18637	1412	17	a	a	DT
18637	1412	18	general	general	JJ
18637	1412	19	perjury	perjury	NN
18637	1412	20	statute	statute	NN
18637	1412	21	for	for	IN
18637	1412	22	false	false	JJ
18637	1412	23	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	1412	24	given	give	VBN
18637	1412	25	before	before	IN
18637	1412	26	a	a	DT
18637	1412	27	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1412	28	committee	committee	NN
18637	1412	29	unless	unless	IN
18637	1412	30	a	a	DT
18637	1412	31	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	1412	32	of	of	IN
18637	1412	33	the	the	DT
18637	1412	34	committee	committee	NN
18637	1412	35	was	be	VBD
18637	1412	36	present	present	JJ
18637	1412	37	when	when	WRB
18637	1412	38	the	the	DT
18637	1412	39	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	1412	40	was	be	VBD
18637	1412	41	given	give	VBN
18637	1412	42	.	.	.
18637	1413	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1413	2	115	115	CD
18637	1413	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1413	4	Section	section	NN
18637	1413	5	2	2	CD
18637	1413	6	.	.	.
18637	1414	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1414	2	1	1	CD
18637	1414	3	.	.	.
18637	1415	1	The	the	DT
18637	1415	2	House	House	NNP
18637	1415	3	of	of	IN
18637	1415	4	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1415	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	1415	6	be	be	VB
18637	1415	7	composed	compose	VBN
18637	1415	8	of	of	IN
18637	1415	9	Members	member	NNS
18637	1415	10	chosen	choose	VBD
18637	1415	11	every	every	DT
18637	1415	12	second	second	JJ
18637	1415	13	Year	Year	NNP
18637	1415	14	by	by	IN
18637	1415	15	the	the	DT
18637	1415	16	People	People	NNS
18637	1415	17	of	of	IN
18637	1415	18	the	the	DT
18637	1415	19	several	several	JJ
18637	1415	20	States	States	NNPS
18637	1415	21	,	,	,
18637	1415	22	and	and	CC
18637	1415	23	the	the	DT
18637	1415	24	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	1415	25	in	in	IN
18637	1415	26	each	each	DT
18637	1415	27	State	state	NN
18637	1415	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	1415	29	have	have	VB
18637	1415	30	the	the	DT
18637	1415	31	Qualifications	Qualifications	NNPS
18637	1415	32	requisite	requisite	NN
18637	1415	33	for	for	IN
18637	1415	34	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	1415	35	of	of	IN
18637	1415	36	the	the	DT
18637	1415	37	most	most	RBS
18637	1415	38	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	1415	39	Branch	Branch	NNP
18637	1415	40	of	of	IN
18637	1415	41	the	the	DT
18637	1415	42	State	State	NNP
18637	1415	43	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	1415	44	.	.	.
18637	1416	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1416	2	2	2	CD
18637	1416	3	.	.	.
18637	1417	1	No	no	DT
18637	1417	2	Person	person	NN
18637	1417	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	1417	4	be	be	VB
18637	1417	5	a	a	DT
18637	1417	6	Representative	Representative	NNP
18637	1417	7	who	who	WP
18637	1417	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	1417	9	not	not	RB
18637	1417	10	have	have	VB
18637	1417	11	attained	attain	VBN
18637	1417	12	to	to	IN
18637	1417	13	the	the	DT
18637	1417	14	Age	Age	NNP
18637	1417	15	of	of	IN
18637	1417	16	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	1417	17	five	five	CD
18637	1417	18	Years	year	NNS
18637	1417	19	,	,	,
18637	1417	20	and	and	CC
18637	1417	21	been	be	VBN
18637	1417	22	seven	seven	CD
18637	1417	23	Years	year	NNS
18637	1417	24	a	a	DT
18637	1417	25	Citizen	Citizen	NNP
18637	1417	26	of	of	IN
18637	1417	27	the	the	DT
18637	1417	28	United	United	NNP
18637	1417	29	States	States	NNP
18637	1417	30	,	,	,
18637	1417	31	and	and	CC
18637	1417	32	who	who	WP
18637	1417	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	1417	34	not	not	RB
18637	1417	35	,	,	,
18637	1417	36	when	when	WRB
18637	1417	37	elected	elect	VBN
18637	1417	38	,	,	,
18637	1417	39	be	be	VB
18637	1417	40	an	an	DT
18637	1417	41	Inhabitant	Inhabitant	NNP
18637	1417	42	of	of	IN
18637	1417	43	the	the	DT
18637	1417	44	State	State	NNP
18637	1417	45	in	in	IN
18637	1417	46	which	which	WDT
18637	1417	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1417	48	shall	shall	MD
18637	1417	49	be	be	VB
18637	1417	50	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	1417	51	.	.	.
18637	1418	1	Qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	1418	2	of	of	IN
18637	1418	3	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	1418	4	of	of	IN
18637	1418	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1418	6	CONGRESSIONAL	CONGRESSIONAL	NNP
18637	1418	7	PROTECTION	PROTECTION	NNP
18637	1418	8	OF	of	IN
18637	1418	9	RIGHT	right	NN
18637	1418	10	TO	to	IN
18637	1418	11	VOTE	VOTE	NNP
18637	1418	12	FOR	for	IN
18637	1418	13	REPRESENTATIVES	representatives	NN
18637	1418	14	Although	although	IN
18637	1418	15	the	the	DT
18637	1418	16	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	1418	17	of	of	IN
18637	1418	18	electors	elector	NNS
18637	1418	19	of	of	IN
18637	1418	20	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	1418	21	of	of	IN
18637	1418	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1418	23	are	be	VBP
18637	1418	24	defined	define	VBN
18637	1418	25	by	by	IN
18637	1418	26	State	State	NNP
18637	1418	27	law,[116	law,[116	NNP
18637	1418	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1418	29	the	the	DT
18637	1418	30	right	right	NN
18637	1418	31	to	to	TO
18637	1418	32	vote	vote	VB
18637	1418	33	for	for	IN
18637	1418	34	such	such	JJ
18637	1418	35	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1418	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	1418	37	derived	derive	VBN
18637	1418	38	from	from	IN
18637	1418	39	the	the	DT
18637	1418	40	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1418	41	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1418	42	.	.	.
18637	1419	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1419	2	117	117	CD
18637	1419	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1419	4	Unlike	unlike	IN
18637	1419	5	the	the	DT
18637	1419	6	rights	right	NNS
18637	1419	7	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	1419	8	by	by	IN
18637	1419	9	the	the	DT
18637	1419	10	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	1419	11	and	and	CC
18637	1419	12	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	1419	13	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	1419	14	,	,	,
18637	1419	15	this	this	DT
18637	1419	16	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	1419	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	1419	18	secured	secure	VBN
18637	1419	19	against	against	IN
18637	1419	20	the	the	DT
18637	1419	21	actions	action	NNS
18637	1419	22	of	of	IN
18637	1419	23	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	1419	24	as	as	RB
18637	1419	25	well	well	RB
18637	1419	26	as	as	IN
18637	1419	27	of	of	IN
18637	1419	28	the	the	DT
18637	1419	29	States	States	NNP
18637	1419	30	.	.	.
18637	1420	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1420	2	118	118	CD
18637	1420	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1420	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1420	5	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	1420	6	the	the	DT
18637	1420	7	right	right	NN
18637	1420	8	to	to	TO
18637	1420	9	cast	cast	VB
18637	1420	10	a	a	DT
18637	1420	11	ballot	ballot	NN
18637	1420	12	and	and	CC
18637	1420	13	to	to	TO
18637	1420	14	have	have	VB
18637	1420	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1420	16	counted	count	VBN
18637	1420	17	honestly	honestly	RB
18637	1420	18	.	.	.
18637	1421	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1421	2	119	119	CD
18637	1421	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1421	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	1421	5	a	a	DT
18637	1421	6	primary	primary	JJ
18637	1421	7	election	election	NN
18637	1421	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	1421	9	made	make	VBN
18637	1421	10	by	by	IN
18637	1421	11	law	law	NN
18637	1421	12	an	an	DT
18637	1421	13	integral	integral	JJ
18637	1421	14	part	part	NN
18637	1421	15	of	of	IN
18637	1421	16	the	the	DT
18637	1421	17	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	1421	18	of	of	IN
18637	1421	19	choice	choice	NN
18637	1421	20	or	or	CC
18637	1421	21	where	where	WRB
18637	1421	22	the	the	DT
18637	1421	23	choice	choice	NN
18637	1421	24	of	of	IN
18637	1421	25	a	a	DT
18637	1421	26	representative	representative	NN
18637	1421	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	1421	28	in	in	IN
18637	1421	29	fact	fact	NN
18637	1421	30	controlled	control	VBN
18637	1421	31	by	by	IN
18637	1421	32	the	the	DT
18637	1421	33	primary	primary	NN
18637	1421	34	,	,	,
18637	1421	35	the	the	DT
18637	1421	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1421	37	safeguards	safeguard	VBZ
18637	1421	38	the	the	DT
18637	1421	39	rights	right	NNS
18637	1421	40	of	of	IN
18637	1421	41	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	1421	42	electors	elector	NNS
18637	1421	43	to	to	TO
18637	1421	44	participate	participate	VB
18637	1421	45	therein	therein	RB
18637	1421	46	.	.	.
18637	1422	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1422	2	120	120	CD
18637	1422	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1422	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1422	5	may	may	MD
18637	1422	6	protect	protect	VB
18637	1422	7	this	this	DT
18637	1422	8	right	right	NN
18637	1422	9	by	by	IN
18637	1422	10	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	1422	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1422	12	.	.	.
18637	1423	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1423	2	121	121	CD
18637	1423	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1423	4	In	in	IN
18637	1423	5	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	1423	6	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	1423	7	under	under	IN
18637	1423	8	section	section	NN
18637	1423	9	19	19	CD
18637	1423	10	of	of	IN
18637	1423	11	the	the	DT
18637	1423	12	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
18637	1423	13	Code,[122	Code,[122	NNP
18637	1423	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1423	15	the	the	DT
18637	1423	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1423	17	had	have	VBD
18637	1423	18	held	hold	VBN
18637	1423	19	that	that	IN
18637	1423	20	failure	failure	NN
18637	1423	21	to	to	IN
18637	1423	22	count	count	VB
18637	1423	23	ballots	ballot	NNS
18637	1423	24	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	1423	25	cast,[123	cast,[123	VBN
18637	1423	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1423	27	or	or	CC
18637	1423	28	dilution	dilution	NN
18637	1423	29	of	of	IN
18637	1423	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1423	31	value	value	NN
18637	1423	32	by	by	IN
18637	1423	33	stuffing	stuff	VBG
18637	1423	34	the	the	DT
18637	1423	35	ballot	ballot	NN
18637	1423	36	box	box	NN
18637	1423	37	with	with	IN
18637	1423	38	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	1423	39	ballots[124	ballots[124	NNP
18637	1423	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1423	41	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	1423	42	a	a	DT
18637	1423	43	denial	denial	NN
18637	1423	44	of	of	IN
18637	1423	45	the	the	DT
18637	1423	46	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1423	47	right	right	NN
18637	1423	48	to	to	TO
18637	1423	49	elect	elect	VB
18637	1423	50	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1423	51	in	in	IN
18637	1423	52	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1423	53	.	.	.
18637	1424	1	But	but	CC
18637	1424	2	the	the	DT
18637	1424	3	bribery	bribery	NN
18637	1424	4	of	of	IN
18637	1424	5	voters	voter	NNS
18637	1424	6	,	,	,
18637	1424	7	although	although	IN
18637	1424	8	within	within	IN
18637	1424	9	reach	reach	NN
18637	1424	10	of	of	IN
18637	1424	11	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1424	12	power	power	NN
18637	1424	13	under	under	IN
18637	1424	14	other	other	JJ
18637	1424	15	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	1424	16	of	of	IN
18637	1424	17	the	the	DT
18637	1424	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1424	19	,	,	,
18637	1424	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	1424	21	not	not	RB
18637	1424	22	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	1424	23	to	to	TO
18637	1424	24	be	be	VB
18637	1424	25	an	an	DT
18637	1424	26	interference	interference	NN
18637	1424	27	with	with	IN
18637	1424	28	the	the	DT
18637	1424	29	rights	right	NNS
18637	1424	30	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	1424	31	by	by	IN
18637	1424	32	this	this	DT
18637	1424	33	section	section	NN
18637	1424	34	to	to	IN
18637	1424	35	other	other	JJ
18637	1424	36	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	1424	37	voters	voter	NNS
18637	1424	38	.	.	.
18637	1425	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1425	2	125	125	CD
18637	1425	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1425	4	WHEN	when	WRB
18637	1425	5	THE	the	DT
18637	1425	6	ABOVE	above	JJ
18637	1425	7	QUALIFICATIONS	qualification	NNS
18637	1425	8	MUST	MUST	MD
18637	1425	9	BE	be	VB
18637	1425	10	POSSESSED	possess	VBN
18637	1425	11	The	the	DT
18637	1425	12	principal	principal	JJ
18637	1425	13	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	1425	14	which	which	WDT
18637	1425	15	have	have	VBP
18637	1425	16	arisen	arise	VBN
18637	1425	17	under	under	IN
18637	1425	18	these	these	DT
18637	1425	19	sections	section	NNS
18637	1425	20	have	have	VBP
18637	1425	21	related	relate	VBN
18637	1425	22	to	to	IN
18637	1425	23	the	the	DT
18637	1425	24	time	time	NN
18637	1425	25	as	as	IN
18637	1425	26	of	of	IN
18637	1425	27	which	which	WDT
18637	1425	28	members	member	NNS
18637	1425	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	1425	30	elect	elect	NNP
18637	1425	31	must	must	MD
18637	1425	32	fulfill	fulfill	VB
18637	1425	33	the	the	DT
18637	1425	34	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	1425	35	of	of	IN
18637	1425	36	eligibility	eligibility	NN
18637	1425	37	,	,	,
18637	1425	38	and	and	CC
18637	1425	39	whether	whether	IN
18637	1425	40	additional	additional	JJ
18637	1425	41	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	1425	42	may	may	MD
18637	1425	43	be	be	VB
18637	1425	44	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	1425	45	by	by	IN
18637	1425	46	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1425	47	or	or	CC
18637	1425	48	State	State	NNP
18637	1425	49	law	law	NN
18637	1425	50	.	.	.
18637	1426	1	Although	although	IN
18637	1426	2	on	on	IN
18637	1426	3	two	two	CD
18637	1426	4	occasions	occasion	NNS
18637	1426	5	when	when	WRB
18637	1426	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1426	7	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	1426	8	to	to	TO
18637	1426	9	seat	seat	VB
18637	1426	10	persons	person	NNS
18637	1426	11	who	who	WP
18637	1426	12	were	be	VBD
18637	1426	13	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	1426	14	when	when	WRB
18637	1426	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1426	16	sought	seek	VBD
18637	1426	17	to	to	TO
18637	1426	18	take	take	VB
18637	1426	19	the	the	DT
18637	1426	20	oath	oath	NN
18637	1426	21	of	of	IN
18637	1426	22	office	office	NN
18637	1426	23	,	,	,
18637	1426	24	the	the	DT
18637	1426	25	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1426	26	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	1426	27	that	that	IN
18637	1426	28	eligibility	eligibility	NN
18637	1426	29	must	must	MD
18637	1426	30	exist	exist	VB
18637	1426	31	at	at	IN
18637	1426	32	the	the	DT
18637	1426	33	time	time	NN
18637	1426	34	of	of	IN
18637	1426	35	election	election	NN
18637	1426	36	,	,	,
18637	1426	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1426	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	1426	39	now	now	RB
18637	1426	40	established	establish	VBN
18637	1426	41	in	in	IN
18637	1426	42	both	both	DT
18637	1426	43	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	1426	44	that	that	IN
18637	1426	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1426	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	1426	47	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	1426	48	if	if	IN
18637	1426	49	the	the	DT
18637	1426	50	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	1426	51	are	be	VBP
18637	1426	52	met	meet	VBN
18637	1426	53	when	when	WRB
18637	1426	54	the	the	DT
18637	1426	55	oath	oath	NN
18637	1426	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	1426	57	administered	administer	VBN
18637	1426	58	.	.	.
18637	1427	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	1427	2	persons	person	NNS
18637	1427	3	elected	elect	VBN
18637	1427	4	to	to	IN
18637	1427	5	either	either	CC
18637	1427	6	House	House	NNP
18637	1427	7	before	before	IN
18637	1427	8	attaining	attain	VBG
18637	1427	9	the	the	DT
18637	1427	10	required	require	VBN
18637	1427	11	age	age	NN
18637	1427	12	or	or	CC
18637	1427	13	term	term	NN
18637	1427	14	of	of	IN
18637	1427	15	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	1427	16	have	have	VBP
18637	1427	17	been	be	VBN
18637	1427	18	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	1427	19	as	as	RB
18637	1427	20	soon	soon	RB
18637	1427	21	as	as	IN
18637	1427	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1427	23	became	become	VBD
18637	1427	24	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	1427	25	.	.	.
18637	1428	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1428	2	126	126	CD
18637	1428	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1428	4	ENLARGEMENT	enlargement	NN
18637	1428	5	OF	of	IN
18637	1428	6	QUALIFICATIONS	qualifications	NN
18637	1428	7	Writing	write	VBG
18637	1428	8	in	in	IN
18637	1428	9	The	the	DT
18637	1428	10	Federalist[127	Federalist[127	NNP
18637	1428	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1428	12	with	with	IN
18637	1428	13	reference	reference	NN
18637	1428	14	to	to	IN
18637	1428	15	the	the	DT
18637	1428	16	election	election	NN
18637	1428	17	of	of	IN
18637	1428	18	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	1428	19	of	of	IN
18637	1428	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1428	21	,	,	,
18637	1428	22	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	1428	23	expressed	express	VBD
18637	1428	24	the	the	DT
18637	1428	25	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1428	26	that	that	IN
18637	1428	27	"	"	``
18637	1428	28	the	the	DT
18637	1428	29	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	1428	30	of	of	IN
18637	1428	31	persons	person	NNS
18637	1428	32	who	who	WP
18637	1428	33	may	may	MD
18637	1428	34	*	*	NFP
18637	1428	35	*	*	NFP
18637	1428	36	*	*	NFP
18637	1428	37	be	be	VB
18637	1428	38	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	1428	39	*	*	NFP
18637	1428	40	*	*	NFP
18637	1428	41	*	*	NFP
18637	1428	42	are	be	VBP
18637	1428	43	defined	define	VBN
18637	1428	44	and	and	CC
18637	1428	45	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	1428	46	in	in	IN
18637	1428	47	the	the	DT
18637	1428	48	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1428	49	and	and	CC
18637	1428	50	are	be	VBP
18637	1428	51	unalterable	unalterable	JJ
18637	1428	52	by	by	IN
18637	1428	53	the	the	DT
18637	1428	54	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1428	55	.	.	.
18637	1428	56	"	"	''
18637	1429	1	The	the	DT
18637	1429	2	question	question	NN
18637	1429	3	remained	remain	VBD
18637	1429	4	academic	academic	JJ
18637	1429	5	until	until	IN
18637	1429	6	the	the	DT
18637	1429	7	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	1429	8	War	War	NNP
18637	1429	9	,	,	,
18637	1429	10	when	when	WRB
18637	1429	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1429	12	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1429	13	a	a	DT
18637	1429	14	law	law	NN
18637	1429	15	requiring	require	VBG
18637	1429	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1429	17	members	member	NNS
18637	1429	18	to	to	TO
18637	1429	19	take	take	VB
18637	1429	20	an	an	DT
18637	1429	21	oath	oath	NN
18637	1429	22	that	that	IN
18637	1429	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1429	24	had	have	VBD
18637	1429	25	never	never	RB
18637	1429	26	been	be	VBN
18637	1429	27	disloyal	disloyal	JJ
18637	1429	28	to	to	IN
18637	1429	29	the	the	DT
18637	1429	30	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1429	31	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1429	32	.	.	.
18637	1430	1	In	in	IN
18637	1430	2	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	1430	3	contests	contest	NNS
18637	1430	4	over	over	IN
18637	1430	5	the	the	DT
18637	1430	6	seating	seating	NN
18637	1430	7	of	of	IN
18637	1430	8	men	man	NNS
18637	1430	9	charged	charge	VBN
18637	1430	10	with	with	IN
18637	1430	11	disloyalty	disloyalty	NN
18637	1430	12	,	,	,
18637	1430	13	the	the	DT
18637	1430	14	right	right	NN
18637	1430	15	of	of	IN
18637	1430	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1430	17	to	to	TO
18637	1430	18	establish	establish	VB
18637	1430	19	by	by	IN
18637	1430	20	law	law	NN
18637	1430	21	other	other	JJ
18637	1430	22	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	1430	23	for	for	IN
18637	1430	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1430	25	members	member	NNS
18637	1430	26	than	than	IN
18637	1430	27	those	those	DT
18637	1430	28	contained	contain	VBN
18637	1430	29	in	in	IN
18637	1430	30	the	the	DT
18637	1430	31	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1430	32	was	be	VBD
18637	1430	33	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	1430	34	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	1430	35	.	.	.
18637	1431	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	1431	2	,	,	,
18637	1431	3	both	both	CC
18637	1431	4	the	the	DT
18637	1431	5	House	House	NNP
18637	1431	6	and	and	CC
18637	1431	7	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1431	8	,	,	,
18637	1431	9	relying	rely	VBG
18637	1431	10	on	on	IN
18637	1431	11	this	this	DT
18637	1431	12	act	act	NN
18637	1431	13	,	,	,
18637	1431	14	did	do	VBD
18637	1431	15	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	1431	16	to	to	TO
18637	1431	17	seat	seat	VB
18637	1431	18	several	several	JJ
18637	1431	19	persons	person	NNS
18637	1431	20	.	.	.
18637	1432	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1432	2	128	128	CD
18637	1432	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1432	4	At	at	IN
18637	1432	5	this	this	DT
18637	1432	6	time	time	NN
18637	1432	7	the	the	DT
18637	1432	8	principal	principal	JJ
18637	1432	9	argument	argument	NN
18637	1432	10	against	against	IN
18637	1432	11	the	the	DT
18637	1432	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	1432	13	was	be	VBD
18637	1432	14	that	that	IN
18637	1432	15	all	all	DT
18637	1432	16	persons	person	NNS
18637	1432	17	were	be	VBD
18637	1432	18	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	1432	19	for	for	IN
18637	1432	20	the	the	DT
18637	1432	21	office	office	NN
18637	1432	22	of	of	IN
18637	1432	23	Representative	Representative	NNP
18637	1432	24	unless	unless	IN
18637	1432	25	the	the	DT
18637	1432	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1432	27	made	make	VBD
18637	1432	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1432	29	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	1432	30	.	.	.
18637	1433	1	In	in	IN
18637	1433	2	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	1433	3	_	_	NNP
18637	1433	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	1433	5	_	_	NNP
18637	1433	6	United	United	NNP
18637	1433	7	States,[129	States,[129	NNP
18637	1433	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1433	9	the	the	DT
18637	1433	10	argument	argument	NN
18637	1433	11	was	be	VBD
18637	1433	12	given	give	VBN
18637	1433	13	a	a	DT
18637	1433	14	new	new	JJ
18637	1433	15	twist	twist	NN
18637	1433	16	.	.	.
18637	1434	1	A	a	DT
18637	1434	2	law	law	NN
18637	1434	3	providing	provide	VBG
18637	1434	4	that	that	IN
18637	1434	5	a	a	DT
18637	1434	6	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	1434	7	or	or	CC
18637	1434	8	Representative	Representative	NNP
18637	1434	9	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	1434	10	of	of	IN
18637	1434	11	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	1434	12	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	1434	13	money	money	NN
18637	1434	14	for	for	IN
18637	1434	15	services	service	NNS
18637	1434	16	rendered	render	VBN
18637	1434	17	before	before	IN
18637	1434	18	a	a	DT
18637	1434	19	government	government	NN
18637	1434	20	department	department	NN
18637	1434	21	should	should	MD
18637	1434	22	be	be	VB
18637	1434	23	"	"	``
18637	1434	24	rendered	render	VBN
18637	1434	25	forever	forever	RB
18637	1434	26	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	1434	27	incapable	incapable	JJ
18637	1434	28	of	of	IN
18637	1434	29	holding	hold	VBG
18637	1434	30	any	any	DT
18637	1434	31	office	office	NN
18637	1434	32	of	of	IN
18637	1434	33	honor	honor	NN
18637	1434	34	,	,	,
18637	1434	35	trust	trust	NN
18637	1434	36	or	or	CC
18637	1434	37	profit	profit	NN
18637	1434	38	under	under	IN
18637	1434	39	the	the	DT
18637	1434	40	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1434	41	of	of	IN
18637	1434	42	the	the	DT
18637	1434	43	United	United	NNP
18637	1434	44	States	States	NNP
18637	1434	45	,	,	,
18637	1434	46	"	"	''
18637	1434	47	was	be	VBD
18637	1434	48	assailed	assail	VBN
18637	1434	49	as	as	IN
18637	1434	50	an	an	DT
18637	1434	51	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	1434	52	interference	interference	NN
18637	1434	53	with	with	IN
18637	1434	54	the	the	DT
18637	1434	55	authority	authority	NN
18637	1434	56	of	of	IN
18637	1434	57	each	each	DT
18637	1434	58	House	House	NNP
18637	1434	59	to	to	TO
18637	1434	60	judge	judge	VB
18637	1434	61	the	the	DT
18637	1434	62	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	1434	63	of	of	IN
18637	1434	64	,	,	,
18637	1434	65	or	or	CC
18637	1434	66	to	to	TO
18637	1434	67	expel	expel	VB
18637	1434	68	,	,	,
18637	1434	69	one	one	CD
18637	1434	70	of	of	IN
18637	1434	71	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1434	72	own	own	JJ
18637	1434	73	members	member	NNS
18637	1434	74	.	.	.
18637	1435	1	The	the	DT
18637	1435	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1435	3	construed	construe	VBD
18637	1435	4	the	the	DT
18637	1435	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	1435	6	not	not	RB
18637	1435	7	to	to	TO
18637	1435	8	affect	affect	VB
18637	1435	9	the	the	DT
18637	1435	10	offender	offender	NN
18637	1435	11	's	's	POS
18637	1435	12	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	1435	13	as	as	IN
18637	1435	14	a	a	DT
18637	1435	15	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	1435	16	,	,	,
18637	1435	17	and	and	CC
18637	1435	18	left	leave	VBD
18637	1435	19	undecided	undecided	JJ
18637	1435	20	the	the	DT
18637	1435	21	power	power	NN
18637	1435	22	of	of	IN
18637	1435	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1435	24	to	to	TO
18637	1435	25	impose	impose	VB
18637	1435	26	additional	additional	JJ
18637	1435	27	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	1435	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1435	29	or	or	CC
18637	1435	30	disqualifications	disqualification	NNS
18637	1435	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1435	32	.	.	.
18637	1436	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1436	2	130	130	CD
18637	1436	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1436	4	In	in	IN
18637	1436	5	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	1436	6	the	the	DT
18637	1436	7	power	power	NN
18637	1436	8	granted	grant	VBN
18637	1436	9	by	by	IN
18637	1436	10	section	section	NN
18637	1436	11	5	5	CD
18637	1436	12	to	to	TO
18637	1436	13	judge	judge	VB
18637	1436	14	the	the	DT
18637	1436	15	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	1436	16	of	of	IN
18637	1436	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1436	18	own	own	JJ
18637	1436	19	members	member	NNS
18637	1436	20	,	,	,
18637	1436	21	each	each	DT
18637	1436	22	House	House	NNP
18637	1436	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	1436	24	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	1436	25	the	the	DT
18637	1436	26	power	power	NN
18637	1436	27	to	to	TO
18637	1436	28	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	1436	29	into	into	IN
18637	1436	30	the	the	DT
18637	1436	31	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	1436	32	of	of	IN
18637	1436	33	a	a	DT
18637	1436	34	member	member	NN
18637	1436	35	-	-	HYPH
18637	1436	36	elect	elect	NN
18637	1436	37	prior	prior	RB
18637	1436	38	to	to	IN
18637	1436	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1436	40	election	election	NN
18637	1436	41	.	.	.
18637	1437	1	In	in	IN
18637	1437	2	1900	1900	CD
18637	1437	3	the	the	DT
18637	1437	4	House	House	NNP
18637	1437	5	of	of	IN
18637	1437	6	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1437	7	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	1437	8	to	to	TO
18637	1437	9	seat	seat	VB
18637	1437	10	a	a	DT
18637	1437	11	person	person	NN
18637	1437	12	who	who	WP
18637	1437	13	practiced	practice	VBD
18637	1437	14	polygamy,[131	polygamy,[131	NNP
18637	1437	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1437	16	and	and	CC
18637	1437	17	in	in	IN
18637	1437	18	1928	1928	CD
18637	1437	19	the	the	DT
18637	1437	20	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1437	21	voted	vote	VBD
18637	1437	22	to	to	TO
18637	1437	23	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	1437	24	a	a	DT
18637	1437	25	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	1437	26	-	-	HYPH
18637	1437	27	elect	elect	NNP
18637	1437	28	on	on	IN
18637	1437	29	the	the	DT
18637	1437	30	ground	ground	NN
18637	1437	31	that	that	IN
18637	1437	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1437	33	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	1437	34	of	of	IN
18637	1437	35	large	large	JJ
18637	1437	36	campaign	campaign	NN
18637	1437	37	contributions	contribution	NNS
18637	1437	38	from	from	IN
18637	1437	39	persons	person	NNS
18637	1437	40	who	who	WP
18637	1437	41	were	be	VBD
18637	1437	42	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1437	43	to	to	IN
18637	1437	44	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1437	45	by	by	IN
18637	1437	46	a	a	DT
18637	1437	47	State	State	NNP
18637	1437	48	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	1437	49	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1437	50	of	of	IN
18637	1437	51	which	which	WDT
18637	1437	52	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1437	53	had	have	VBD
18637	1437	54	been	be	VBN
18637	1437	55	Chairman	Chairman	NNP
18637	1437	56	were	be	VBD
18637	1437	57	"	"	``
18637	1437	58	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	1437	59	to	to	TO
18637	1437	60	sound	sound	VB
18637	1437	61	public	public	JJ
18637	1437	62	policy	policy	NN
18637	1437	63	"	"	''
18637	1437	64	and	and	CC
18637	1437	65	tainted	taint	VBD
18637	1437	66	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1437	67	credentials	credential	NNS
18637	1437	68	with	with	IN
18637	1437	69	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	1437	70	and	and	CC
18637	1437	71	corruption	corruption	NN
18637	1437	72	.	.	.
18637	1438	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1438	2	132	132	CD
18637	1438	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1438	4	INABILITY	inability	NN
18637	1438	5	OF	of	IN
18637	1438	6	THE	the	DT
18637	1438	7	STATES	state	NNS
18637	1438	8	TO	to	TO
18637	1438	9	ENLARGE	ENLARGE	NNP
18637	1438	10	A	a	DT
18637	1438	11	State	state	NN
18637	1438	12	may	may	MD
18637	1438	13	not	not	RB
18637	1438	14	add	add	VB
18637	1438	15	to	to	IN
18637	1438	16	the	the	DT
18637	1438	17	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	1438	18	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	1438	19	by	by	IN
18637	1438	20	the	the	DT
18637	1438	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1438	22	for	for	IN
18637	1438	23	members	member	NNS
18637	1438	24	of	of	IN
18637	1438	25	the	the	DT
18637	1438	26	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1438	27	and	and	CC
18637	1438	28	House	House	NNP
18637	1438	29	of	of	IN
18637	1438	30	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1438	31	.	.	.
18637	1439	1	Asserting	assert	VBG
18637	1439	2	this	this	DT
18637	1439	3	principle	principle	NN
18637	1439	4	,	,	,
18637	1439	5	the	the	DT
18637	1439	6	House	House	NNP
18637	1439	7	in	in	IN
18637	1439	8	1807	1807	CD
18637	1439	9	seated	seat	VBD
18637	1439	10	a	a	DT
18637	1439	11	member	member	NN
18637	1439	12	whose	whose	WP$
18637	1439	13	election	election	NN
18637	1439	14	was	be	VBD
18637	1439	15	contested	contest	VBN
18637	1439	16	on	on	IN
18637	1439	17	the	the	DT
18637	1439	18	ground	ground	NN
18637	1439	19	that	that	IN
18637	1439	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1439	21	had	have	VBD
18637	1439	22	not	not	RB
18637	1439	23	been	be	VBN
18637	1439	24	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	1439	25	months	month	NNS
18637	1439	26	a	a	DT
18637	1439	27	resident	resident	NN
18637	1439	28	of	of	IN
18637	1439	29	the	the	DT
18637	1439	30	district	district	NN
18637	1439	31	from	from	IN
18637	1439	32	which	which	WDT
18637	1439	33	elected	elect	VBN
18637	1439	34	as	as	IN
18637	1439	35	required	require	VBN
18637	1439	36	by	by	IN
18637	1439	37	State	State	NNP
18637	1439	38	law	law	NN
18637	1439	39	.	.	.
18637	1440	1	No	no	DT
18637	1440	2	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	1440	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1440	4	made	make	VBN
18637	1440	5	to	to	TO
18637	1440	6	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	1440	7	whether	whether	IN
18637	1440	8	these	these	DT
18637	1440	9	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	1440	10	were	be	VBD
18637	1440	11	met	meet	VBN
18637	1440	12	because	because	IN
18637	1440	13	the	the	DT
18637	1440	14	State	State	NNP
18637	1440	15	law	law	NN
18637	1440	16	was	be	VBD
18637	1440	17	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	1440	18	to	to	TO
18637	1440	19	be	be	VB
18637	1440	20	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	1440	21	.	.	.
18637	1441	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1441	2	133	133	CD
18637	1441	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1441	4	Both	both	CC
18637	1441	5	the	the	DT
18637	1441	6	House	House	NNP
18637	1441	7	and	and	CC
18637	1441	8	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1441	9	have	have	VBP
18637	1441	10	seated	seat	VBN
18637	1441	11	members	member	NNS
18637	1441	12	elected	elect	VBN
18637	1441	13	during	during	IN
18637	1441	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1441	15	term	term	NN
18637	1441	16	of	of	IN
18637	1441	17	office	office	NN
18637	1441	18	as	as	IN
18637	1441	19	State	State	NNP
18637	1441	20	judges	judge	NNS
18637	1441	21	,	,	,
18637	1441	22	despite	despite	IN
18637	1441	23	the	the	DT
18637	1441	24	provision	provision	NN
18637	1441	25	of	of	IN
18637	1441	26	State	State	NNP
18637	1441	27	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	1441	28	purporting	purport	VBG
18637	1441	29	to	to	TO
18637	1441	30	bar	bar	VB
18637	1441	31	the	the	DT
18637	1441	32	election	election	NN
18637	1441	33	of	of	IN
18637	1441	34	judges	judge	NNS
18637	1441	35	to	to	IN
18637	1441	36	any	any	DT
18637	1441	37	other	other	JJ
18637	1441	38	office	office	NN
18637	1441	39	under	under	IN
18637	1441	40	the	the	DT
18637	1441	41	State	State	NNP
18637	1441	42	or	or	CC
18637	1441	43	the	the	DT
18637	1441	44	United	United	NNP
18637	1441	45	States	States	NNP
18637	1441	46	during	during	IN
18637	1441	47	such	such	JJ
18637	1441	48	term	term	NN
18637	1441	49	.	.	.
18637	1442	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1442	2	134	134	CD
18637	1442	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1442	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1442	5	3	3	CD
18637	1442	6	.	.	.
18637	1443	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1443	2	Representatives	representative	NNS
18637	1443	3	and	and	CC
18637	1443	4	direct	direct	JJ
18637	1443	5	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1443	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	1443	7	be	be	VB
18637	1443	8	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	1443	9	among	among	IN
18637	1443	10	the	the	DT
18637	1443	11	several	several	JJ
18637	1443	12	States	state	NNS
18637	1443	13	which	which	WDT
18637	1443	14	may	may	MD
18637	1443	15	be	be	VB
18637	1443	16	included	include	VBN
18637	1443	17	within	within	IN
18637	1443	18	this	this	DT
18637	1443	19	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1443	20	,	,	,
18637	1443	21	according	accord	VBG
18637	1443	22	to	to	IN
18637	1443	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1443	24	respective	respective	JJ
18637	1443	25	Numbers	number	NNS
18637	1443	26	,	,	,
18637	1443	27	which	which	WDT
18637	1443	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	1443	29	be	be	VB
18637	1443	30	determined	determine	VBN
18637	1443	31	by	by	IN
18637	1443	32	adding	add	VBG
18637	1443	33	to	to	IN
18637	1443	34	the	the	DT
18637	1443	35	whole	whole	JJ
18637	1443	36	Number	number	NN
18637	1443	37	of	of	IN
18637	1443	38	free	free	JJ
18637	1443	39	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	1443	40	,	,	,
18637	1443	41	including	include	VBG
18637	1443	42	those	those	DT
18637	1443	43	bound	bind	VBN
18637	1443	44	to	to	IN
18637	1443	45	Service	Service	NNP
18637	1443	46	for	for	IN
18637	1443	47	a	a	DT
18637	1443	48	Term	Term	NNP
18637	1443	49	of	of	IN
18637	1443	50	Years	Years	NNPS
18637	1443	51	,	,	,
18637	1443	52	and	and	CC
18637	1443	53	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	1443	54	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	1443	55	not	not	RB
18637	1443	56	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	1443	57	,	,	,
18637	1443	58	three	three	CD
18637	1443	59	fifths	fifth	NNS
18637	1443	60	of	of	IN
18637	1443	61	all	all	DT
18637	1443	62	other	other	JJ
18637	1443	63	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	1443	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1443	65	.	.	.
18637	1444	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1444	2	135	135	CD
18637	1444	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1444	4	The	the	DT
18637	1444	5	actual	actual	JJ
18637	1444	6	Enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	1444	7	shall	shall	MD
18637	1444	8	be	be	VB
18637	1444	9	made	make	VBN
18637	1444	10	within	within	IN
18637	1444	11	three	three	CD
18637	1444	12	Years	year	NNS
18637	1444	13	after	after	IN
18637	1444	14	the	the	DT
18637	1444	15	first	first	JJ
18637	1444	16	Meeting	Meeting	NNP
18637	1444	17	of	of	IN
18637	1444	18	the	the	DT
18637	1444	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1444	20	of	of	IN
18637	1444	21	the	the	DT
18637	1444	22	United	United	NNP
18637	1444	23	States	States	NNP
18637	1444	24	,	,	,
18637	1444	25	and	and	CC
18637	1444	26	within	within	IN
18637	1444	27	every	every	DT
18637	1444	28	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	1444	29	Term	Term	NNP
18637	1444	30	of	of	IN
18637	1444	31	ten	ten	CD
18637	1444	32	Years	year	NNS
18637	1444	33	,	,	,
18637	1444	34	in	in	IN
18637	1444	35	such	such	JJ
18637	1444	36	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	1444	37	as	as	IN
18637	1444	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1444	39	shall	shall	MD
18637	1444	40	by	by	IN
18637	1444	41	Law	Law	NNP
18637	1444	42	direct	direct	RB
18637	1444	43	.	.	.
18637	1445	1	The	the	DT
18637	1445	2	Number	Number	NNP
18637	1445	3	of	of	IN
18637	1445	4	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1445	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	1445	6	not	not	RB
18637	1445	7	exceed	exceed	VB
18637	1445	8	one	one	CD
18637	1445	9	for	for	IN
18637	1445	10	every	every	DT
18637	1445	11	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	1445	12	Thousand	thousand	CD
18637	1445	13	,	,	,
18637	1445	14	but	but	CC
18637	1445	15	each	each	DT
18637	1445	16	State	state	NN
18637	1445	17	shall	shall	MD
18637	1445	18	have	have	VB
18637	1445	19	at	at	RB
18637	1445	20	Least	least	RBS
18637	1445	21	one	one	CD
18637	1445	22	Representative	representative	NN
18637	1445	23	;	;	:
18637	1445	24	and	and	CC
18637	1445	25	until	until	IN
18637	1445	26	such	such	JJ
18637	1445	27	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	1445	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	1445	29	be	be	VB
18637	1445	30	made	make	VBN
18637	1445	31	,	,	,
18637	1445	32	the	the	DT
18637	1445	33	State	State	NNP
18637	1445	34	of	of	IN
18637	1445	35	New	New	NNP
18637	1445	36	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	1445	37	shall	shall	MD
18637	1445	38	be	be	VB
18637	1445	39	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	1445	40	to	to	TO
18637	1445	41	chuse	chuse	VB
18637	1445	42	three	three	CD
18637	1445	43	,	,	,
18637	1445	44	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	1445	45	eight	eight	CD
18637	1445	46	,	,	,
18637	1445	47	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	1445	48	-	-	HYPH
18637	1445	49	Island	Island	NNP
18637	1445	50	and	and	CC
18637	1445	51	Providence	Providence	NNP
18637	1445	52	Plantations	Plantations	NNP
18637	1445	53	one	one	CD
18637	1445	54	,	,	,
18637	1445	55	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	1445	56	five	five	CD
18637	1445	57	,	,	,
18637	1445	58	New	New	NNP
18637	1445	59	-	-	HYPH
18637	1445	60	York	York	NNP
18637	1445	61	six	six	CD
18637	1445	62	,	,	,
18637	1445	63	New	New	NNP
18637	1445	64	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1445	65	four	four	CD
18637	1445	66	,	,	,
18637	1445	67	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	1445	68	eight	eight	CD
18637	1445	69	,	,	,
18637	1445	70	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	1445	71	one	one	CD
18637	1445	72	,	,	,
18637	1445	73	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	1445	74	six	six	CD
18637	1445	75	,	,	,
18637	1445	76	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1445	77	ten	ten	CD
18637	1445	78	,	,	,
18637	1445	79	North	North	NNP
18637	1445	80	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1445	81	five	five	CD
18637	1445	82	,	,	,
18637	1445	83	South	South	NNP
18637	1445	84	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1445	85	five	five	CD
18637	1445	86	,	,	,
18637	1445	87	and	and	CC
18637	1445	88	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	1445	89	three	three	CD
18637	1445	90	.	.	.
18637	1446	1	THE	the	DT
18637	1446	2	CENSUS	census	NN
18637	1446	3	REQUIREMENT	REQUIREMENT	VBD
18637	1446	4	While	while	IN
18637	1446	5	section	section	NN
18637	1446	6	2	2	CD
18637	1446	7	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	1446	8	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	1446	9	for	for	IN
18637	1446	10	an	an	DT
18637	1446	11	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	1446	12	of	of	IN
18637	1446	13	persons	person	NNS
18637	1446	14	,	,	,
18637	1446	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1446	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	1446	17	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	1446	18	directed	direct	VBN
18637	1446	19	an	an	DT
18637	1446	20	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	1446	21	not	not	RB
18637	1446	22	only	only	RB
18637	1446	23	of	of	IN
18637	1446	24	the	the	DT
18637	1446	25	free	free	JJ
18637	1446	26	persons	person	NNS
18637	1446	27	in	in	IN
18637	1446	28	the	the	DT
18637	1446	29	States	States	NNP
18637	1446	30	,	,	,
18637	1446	31	but	but	CC
18637	1446	32	also	also	RB
18637	1446	33	of	of	IN
18637	1446	34	those	those	DT
18637	1446	35	in	in	IN
18637	1446	36	the	the	DT
18637	1446	37	territories	territory	NNS
18637	1446	38	,	,	,
18637	1446	39	and	and	CC
18637	1446	40	has	have	VBZ
18637	1446	41	required	require	VBN
18637	1446	42	all	all	DT
18637	1446	43	persons	person	NNS
18637	1446	44	over	over	IN
18637	1446	45	eighteen	eighteen	CD
18637	1446	46	years	year	NNS
18637	1446	47	of	of	IN
18637	1446	48	age	age	NN
18637	1446	49	to	to	TO
18637	1446	50	answer	answer	VB
18637	1446	51	an	an	DT
18637	1446	52	ever	ever	RB
18637	1446	53	-	-	HYPH
18637	1446	54	lengthening	lengthen	VBG
18637	1446	55	list	list	NN
18637	1446	56	of	of	IN
18637	1446	57	inquiries	inquiry	NNS
18637	1446	58	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	1446	59	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1446	60	personal	personal	JJ
18637	1446	61	and	and	CC
18637	1446	62	economic	economic	JJ
18637	1446	63	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	1446	64	.	.	.
18637	1447	1	This	this	DT
18637	1447	2	extended	extended	JJ
18637	1447	3	scope	scope	NN
18637	1447	4	of	of	IN
18637	1447	5	the	the	DT
18637	1447	6	census	census	NN
18637	1447	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	1447	8	received	receive	VBN
18637	1447	9	the	the	DT
18637	1447	10	implied	imply	VBN
18637	1447	11	approval	approval	NN
18637	1447	12	of	of	IN
18637	1447	13	the	the	DT
18637	1447	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1447	15	Court;[136	Court;[136	NNP
18637	1447	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1447	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1447	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	1447	19	one	one	CD
18637	1447	20	of	of	IN
18637	1447	21	the	the	DT
18637	1447	22	methods	method	NNS
18637	1447	23	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	1447	24	the	the	DT
18637	1447	25	national	national	JJ
18637	1447	26	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1447	27	exercises	exercise	VBZ
18637	1447	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1447	29	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	1447	30	power	power	NN
18637	1447	31	to	to	TO
18637	1447	32	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	1447	33	the	the	DT
18637	1447	34	information	information	NN
18637	1447	35	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1447	36	for	for	IN
18637	1447	37	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
18637	1447	38	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1447	39	action	action	NN
18637	1447	40	.	.	.
18637	1448	1	Although	although	IN
18637	1448	2	taking	take	VBG
18637	1448	3	an	an	DT
18637	1448	4	enlarged	enlarged	JJ
18637	1448	5	view	view	NN
18637	1448	6	of	of	IN
18637	1448	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1448	8	power	power	NN
18637	1448	9	in	in	IN
18637	1448	10	making	make	VBG
18637	1448	11	the	the	DT
18637	1448	12	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	1448	13	of	of	IN
18637	1448	14	persons	person	NNS
18637	1448	15	called	call	VBN
18637	1448	16	for	for	IN
18637	1448	17	by	by	IN
18637	1448	18	this	this	DT
18637	1448	19	section	section	NN
18637	1448	20	,	,	,
18637	1448	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1448	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	1448	23	not	not	RB
18637	1448	24	always	always	RB
18637	1448	25	complied	comply	VBN
18637	1448	26	with	with	IN
18637	1448	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1448	28	positive	positive	JJ
18637	1448	29	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	1448	30	to	to	IN
18637	1448	31	reapportion	reapportion	NN
18637	1448	32	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	1448	33	among	among	IN
18637	1448	34	the	the	DT
18637	1448	35	States	States	NNP
18637	1448	36	after	after	IN
18637	1448	37	the	the	DT
18637	1448	38	census	census	NN
18637	1448	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	1448	40	taken	take	VBN
18637	1448	41	.	.	.
18637	1449	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1449	2	failed	fail	VBD
18637	1449	3	to	to	TO
18637	1449	4	make	make	VB
18637	1449	5	such	such	PDT
18637	1449	6	a	a	DT
18637	1449	7	reapportionment	reapportionment	NN
18637	1449	8	after	after	IN
18637	1449	9	the	the	DT
18637	1449	10	census	census	NN
18637	1449	11	of	of	IN
18637	1449	12	1920	1920	CD
18637	1449	13	,	,	,
18637	1449	14	being	be	VBG
18637	1449	15	unable	unable	JJ
18637	1449	16	to	to	TO
18637	1449	17	reach	reach	VB
18637	1449	18	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	1449	19	for	for	IN
18637	1449	20	allotting	allot	VBG
18637	1449	21	representation	representation	NN
18637	1449	22	without	without	IN
18637	1449	23	further	further	RB
18637	1449	24	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	1449	25	the	the	DT
18637	1449	26	size	size	NN
18637	1449	27	of	of	IN
18637	1449	28	the	the	DT
18637	1449	29	House	House	NNP
18637	1449	30	.	.	.
18637	1450	1	Ultimately	ultimately	RB
18637	1450	2	,	,	,
18637	1450	3	by	by	IN
18637	1450	4	the	the	DT
18637	1450	5	act	act	NN
18637	1450	6	of	of	IN
18637	1450	7	June	June	NNP
18637	1450	8	18	18	CD
18637	1450	9	,	,	,
18637	1450	10	1929,[137	1929,[137	LS
18637	1450	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1450	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1450	13	provided	provide	VBD
18637	1450	14	that	that	IN
18637	1450	15	the	the	DT
18637	1450	16	membership	membership	NN
18637	1450	17	of	of	IN
18637	1450	18	the	the	DT
18637	1450	19	House	House	NNP
18637	1450	20	of	of	IN
18637	1450	21	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1450	22	should	should	MD
18637	1450	23	henceforth	henceforth	RB
18637	1450	24	be	be	VB
18637	1450	25	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	1450	26	to	to	IN
18637	1450	27	435	435	CD
18637	1450	28	members	member	NNS
18637	1450	29	,	,	,
18637	1450	30	to	to	TO
18637	1450	31	be	be	VB
18637	1450	32	distributed	distribute	VBN
18637	1450	33	among	among	IN
18637	1450	34	the	the	DT
18637	1450	35	States	States	NNP
18637	1450	36	by	by	IN
18637	1450	37	the	the	DT
18637	1450	38	so	so	RB
18637	1450	39	-	-	HYPH
18637	1450	40	called	call	VBN
18637	1450	41	"	"	``
18637	1450	42	method	method	NN
18637	1450	43	of	of	IN
18637	1450	44	major	major	JJ
18637	1450	45	fractions	fraction	NNS
18637	1450	46	"	"	''
18637	1450	47	which	which	WDT
18637	1450	48	had	have	VBD
18637	1450	49	been	be	VBN
18637	1450	50	earlier	early	RBR
18637	1450	51	employed	employ	VBN
18637	1450	52	in	in	IN
18637	1450	53	the	the	DT
18637	1450	54	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	1450	55	of	of	IN
18637	1450	56	1911	1911	CD
18637	1450	57	.	.	.
18637	1451	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1451	2	4	4	CD
18637	1451	3	.	.	.
18637	1452	1	When	when	WRB
18637	1452	2	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	1452	3	happen	happen	VBP
18637	1452	4	in	in	IN
18637	1452	5	the	the	DT
18637	1452	6	Representation	Representation	NNP
18637	1452	7	from	from	IN
18637	1452	8	any	any	DT
18637	1452	9	State	State	NNP
18637	1452	10	,	,	,
18637	1452	11	the	the	DT
18637	1452	12	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	1452	13	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	1452	14	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	1452	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	1452	16	issue	issue	VB
18637	1452	17	Writs	Writs	NNP
18637	1452	18	of	of	IN
18637	1452	19	Election	Election	NNP
18637	1452	20	to	to	TO
18637	1452	21	fill	fill	VB
18637	1452	22	such	such	JJ
18637	1452	23	Vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	1452	24	.	.	.
18637	1453	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1453	2	5	5	CD
18637	1453	3	.	.	.
18637	1454	1	The	the	DT
18637	1454	2	House	House	NNP
18637	1454	3	of	of	IN
18637	1454	4	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1454	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	1454	6	chuse	chuse	VB
18637	1454	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1454	8	Speaker	Speaker	NNP
18637	1454	9	and	and	CC
18637	1454	10	other	other	JJ
18637	1454	11	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	1454	12	;	;	:
18637	1454	13	and	and	CC
18637	1454	14	shall	shall	MD
18637	1454	15	have	have	VB
18637	1454	16	the	the	DT
18637	1454	17	sole	sole	JJ
18637	1454	18	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1454	19	of	of	IN
18637	1454	20	Impeachment	Impeachment	NNP
18637	1454	21	.	.	.
18637	1455	1	Section	section	NN
18637	1455	2	3	3	CD
18637	1455	3	.	.	.
18637	1456	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1456	2	1	1	CD
18637	1456	3	.	.	.
18637	1457	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1457	2	The	the	DT
18637	1457	3	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1457	4	of	of	IN
18637	1457	5	the	the	DT
18637	1457	6	United	United	NNP
18637	1457	7	States	States	NNP
18637	1457	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	1457	9	be	be	VB
18637	1457	10	composed	compose	VBN
18637	1457	11	of	of	IN
18637	1457	12	two	two	CD
18637	1457	13	Senators	senator	NNS
18637	1457	14	from	from	IN
18637	1457	15	each	each	DT
18637	1457	16	State	state	NN
18637	1457	17	,	,	,
18637	1457	18	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	1457	19	by	by	IN
18637	1457	20	the	the	DT
18637	1457	21	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	1457	22	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	1457	23	,	,	,
18637	1457	24	for	for	IN
18637	1457	25	six	six	CD
18637	1457	26	Years	year	NNS
18637	1457	27	;	;	:
18637	1457	28	and	and	CC
18637	1457	29	each	each	DT
18637	1457	30	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	1457	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	1457	32	have	have	VB
18637	1457	33	one	one	CD
18637	1457	34	vote	vote	NN
18637	1457	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1457	36	.	.	.
18637	1458	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1458	2	2	2	CD
18637	1458	3	.	.	.
18637	1459	1	Immediately	immediately	RB
18637	1459	2	after	after	IN
18637	1459	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1459	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	1459	5	be	be	VB
18637	1459	6	assembled	assemble	VBN
18637	1459	7	in	in	IN
18637	1459	8	Consequence	Consequence	NNP
18637	1459	9	of	of	IN
18637	1459	10	the	the	DT
18637	1459	11	first	first	JJ
18637	1459	12	Election	Election	NNP
18637	1459	13	,	,	,
18637	1459	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1459	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	1459	16	be	be	VB
18637	1459	17	divided	divide	VBN
18637	1459	18	as	as	RB
18637	1459	19	equally	equally	RB
18637	1459	20	as	as	IN
18637	1459	21	may	may	MD
18637	1459	22	be	be	VB
18637	1459	23	into	into	IN
18637	1459	24	three	three	CD
18637	1459	25	classes	class	NNS
18637	1459	26	.	.	.
18637	1460	1	The	the	DT
18637	1460	2	Seats	seat	NNS
18637	1460	3	of	of	IN
18637	1460	4	the	the	DT
18637	1460	5	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	1460	6	of	of	IN
18637	1460	7	the	the	DT
18637	1460	8	first	first	JJ
18637	1460	9	Class	Class	NNP
18637	1460	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	1460	11	be	be	VB
18637	1460	12	vacated	vacate	VBN
18637	1460	13	at	at	IN
18637	1460	14	the	the	DT
18637	1460	15	Expiration	Expiration	NNP
18637	1460	16	of	of	IN
18637	1460	17	the	the	DT
18637	1460	18	second	second	JJ
18637	1460	19	Year	Year	NNP
18637	1460	20	,	,	,
18637	1460	21	of	of	IN
18637	1460	22	the	the	DT
18637	1460	23	second	second	JJ
18637	1460	24	Class	Class	NNP
18637	1460	25	at	at	IN
18637	1460	26	the	the	DT
18637	1460	27	Expiration	Expiration	NNP
18637	1460	28	of	of	IN
18637	1460	29	the	the	DT
18637	1460	30	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	1460	31	Year	Year	NNP
18637	1460	32	,	,	,
18637	1460	33	and	and	CC
18637	1460	34	of	of	IN
18637	1460	35	the	the	DT
18637	1460	36	third	third	JJ
18637	1460	37	Class	Class	NNP
18637	1460	38	at	at	IN
18637	1460	39	the	the	DT
18637	1460	40	Expiration	Expiration	NNP
18637	1460	41	of	of	IN
18637	1460	42	the	the	DT
18637	1460	43	sixth	sixth	JJ
18637	1460	44	Year	Year	NNP
18637	1460	45	,	,	,
18637	1460	46	so	so	IN
18637	1460	47	that	that	IN
18637	1460	48	one	one	CD
18637	1460	49	third	third	NN
18637	1460	50	may	may	MD
18637	1460	51	be	be	VB
18637	1460	52	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	1460	53	every	every	DT
18637	1460	54	second	second	JJ
18637	1460	55	Year	year	NN
18637	1460	56	;	;	,
18637	1460	57	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1460	58	and	and	CC
18637	1460	59	if	if	IN
18637	1460	60	Vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	1460	61	happen	happen	VB
18637	1460	62	by	by	IN
18637	1460	63	Resignation	resignation	NN
18637	1460	64	,	,	,
18637	1460	65	or	or	CC
18637	1460	66	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	1460	67	,	,	,
18637	1460	68	during	during	IN
18637	1460	69	the	the	DT
18637	1460	70	Recess	Recess	NNP
18637	1460	71	of	of	IN
18637	1460	72	the	the	DT
18637	1460	73	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	1460	74	of	of	IN
18637	1460	75	any	any	DT
18637	1460	76	State	State	NNP
18637	1460	77	,	,	,
18637	1460	78	the	the	DT
18637	1460	79	Executive	executive	NN
18637	1460	80	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	1460	81	may	may	MD
18637	1460	82	make	make	VB
18637	1460	83	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	1460	84	Appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	1460	85	until	until	IN
18637	1460	86	the	the	DT
18637	1460	87	next	next	JJ
18637	1460	88	Meeting	Meeting	NNP
18637	1460	89	of	of	IN
18637	1460	90	the	the	DT
18637	1460	91	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	1460	92	,	,	,
18637	1460	93	which	which	WDT
18637	1460	94	shall	shall	MD
18637	1460	95	then	then	RB
18637	1460	96	fill	fill	VB
18637	1460	97	such	such	JJ
18637	1460	98	Vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	1460	99	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1460	100	.	.	.
18637	1461	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1461	2	138	138	CD
18637	1461	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1461	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1461	5	3	3	CD
18637	1461	6	.	.	.
18637	1462	1	No	no	DT
18637	1462	2	Person	person	NN
18637	1462	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	1462	4	be	be	VB
18637	1462	5	a	a	DT
18637	1462	6	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	1462	7	who	who	WP
18637	1462	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	1462	9	not	not	RB
18637	1462	10	have	have	VB
18637	1462	11	attained	attain	VBN
18637	1462	12	to	to	IN
18637	1462	13	the	the	DT
18637	1462	14	Age	Age	NNP
18637	1462	15	of	of	IN
18637	1462	16	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	1462	17	Years	year	NNS
18637	1462	18	,	,	,
18637	1462	19	and	and	CC
18637	1462	20	been	be	VBN
18637	1462	21	nine	nine	CD
18637	1462	22	Years	year	NNS
18637	1462	23	a	a	DT
18637	1462	24	Citizen	Citizen	NNP
18637	1462	25	of	of	IN
18637	1462	26	the	the	DT
18637	1462	27	United	United	NNP
18637	1462	28	States	States	NNP
18637	1462	29	,	,	,
18637	1462	30	and	and	CC
18637	1462	31	who	who	WP
18637	1462	32	shall	shall	MD
18637	1462	33	not	not	RB
18637	1462	34	,	,	,
18637	1462	35	when	when	WRB
18637	1462	36	elected	elect	VBN
18637	1462	37	,	,	,
18637	1462	38	be	be	VB
18637	1462	39	an	an	DT
18637	1462	40	Inhabitant	Inhabitant	NNP
18637	1462	41	of	of	IN
18637	1462	42	that	that	DT
18637	1462	43	State	State	NNP
18637	1462	44	for	for	IN
18637	1462	45	which	which	WDT
18637	1462	46	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1462	47	shall	shall	MD
18637	1462	48	be	be	VB
18637	1462	49	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	1462	50	.	.	.
18637	1463	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1463	2	4	4	CD
18637	1463	3	.	.	.
18637	1464	1	The	the	DT
18637	1464	2	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	1464	3	President	President	NNP
18637	1464	4	of	of	IN
18637	1464	5	the	the	DT
18637	1464	6	United	United	NNP
18637	1464	7	States	States	NNP
18637	1464	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	1464	9	be	be	VB
18637	1464	10	President	President	NNP
18637	1464	11	of	of	IN
18637	1464	12	the	the	DT
18637	1464	13	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1464	14	,	,	,
18637	1464	15	but	but	CC
18637	1464	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	1464	17	have	have	VB
18637	1464	18	no	no	DT
18637	1464	19	Vote	vote	NN
18637	1464	20	,	,	,
18637	1464	21	unless	unless	IN
18637	1464	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1464	23	be	be	VBP
18637	1464	24	equally	equally	RB
18637	1464	25	divided	divided	JJ
18637	1464	26	.	.	.
18637	1465	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1465	2	5	5	CD
18637	1465	3	.	.	.
18637	1466	1	The	the	DT
18637	1466	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1466	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	1466	4	chuse	chuse	VB
18637	1466	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1466	6	other	other	JJ
18637	1466	7	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	1466	8	,	,	,
18637	1466	9	and	and	CC
18637	1466	10	also	also	RB
18637	1466	11	a	a	DT
18637	1466	12	President	President	NNP
18637	1466	13	pro	pro	NN
18637	1466	14	tempore	tempore	JJ
18637	1466	15	,	,	,
18637	1466	16	in	in	IN
18637	1466	17	the	the	DT
18637	1466	18	Absence	absence	NN
18637	1466	19	of	of	IN
18637	1466	20	the	the	DT
18637	1466	21	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	1466	22	President	President	NNP
18637	1466	23	,	,	,
18637	1466	24	or	or	CC
18637	1466	25	when	when	WRB
18637	1466	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1466	27	shall	shall	MD
18637	1466	28	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	1466	29	the	the	DT
18637	1466	30	Office	Office	NNP
18637	1466	31	of	of	IN
18637	1466	32	President	President	NNP
18637	1466	33	of	of	IN
18637	1466	34	the	the	DT
18637	1466	35	United	United	NNP
18637	1466	36	States	States	NNP
18637	1466	37	.	.	.
18637	1467	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1467	2	6	6	CD
18637	1467	3	.	.	.
18637	1468	1	The	the	DT
18637	1468	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1468	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	1468	4	have	have	VB
18637	1468	5	the	the	DT
18637	1468	6	sole	sole	JJ
18637	1468	7	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1468	8	to	to	TO
18637	1468	9	try	try	VB
18637	1468	10	all	all	DT
18637	1468	11	Impeachments	Impeachments	NNPS
18637	1468	12	.	.	.
18637	1469	1	When	when	WRB
18637	1469	2	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	1469	3	for	for	IN
18637	1469	4	that	that	DT
18637	1469	5	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	1469	6	,	,	,
18637	1469	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1469	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	1469	9	be	be	VB
18637	1469	10	on	on	IN
18637	1469	11	Oath	Oath	NNP
18637	1469	12	or	or	CC
18637	1469	13	Affirmation	Affirmation	NNP
18637	1469	14	.	.	.
18637	1470	1	When	when	WRB
18637	1470	2	the	the	DT
18637	1470	3	President	President	NNP
18637	1470	4	of	of	IN
18637	1470	5	the	the	DT
18637	1470	6	United	United	NNP
18637	1470	7	States	States	NNP
18637	1470	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	1470	9	tried	try	VBN
18637	1470	10	,	,	,
18637	1470	11	the	the	DT
18637	1470	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1470	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1470	14	shall	shall	MD
18637	1470	15	preside	preside	VB
18637	1470	16	:	:	:
18637	1470	17	And	and	CC
18637	1470	18	no	no	DT
18637	1470	19	Person	person	NN
18637	1470	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	1470	21	be	be	VB
18637	1470	22	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	1470	23	without	without	IN
18637	1470	24	the	the	DT
18637	1470	25	Concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	1470	26	of	of	IN
18637	1470	27	two	two	CD
18637	1470	28	thirds	third	NNS
18637	1470	29	of	of	IN
18637	1470	30	the	the	DT
18637	1470	31	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	1470	32	present	present	JJ
18637	1470	33	.	.	.
18637	1471	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1471	2	7	7	CD
18637	1471	3	.	.	.
18637	1472	1	Judgment	judgment	NN
18637	1472	2	in	in	IN
18637	1472	3	Cases	case	NNS
18637	1472	4	of	of	IN
18637	1472	5	Impeachment	Impeachment	NNP
18637	1472	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	1472	7	not	not	RB
18637	1472	8	extend	extend	VB
18637	1472	9	further	further	RB
18637	1472	10	than	than	IN
18637	1472	11	to	to	IN
18637	1472	12	removal	removal	NN
18637	1472	13	from	from	IN
18637	1472	14	Office	Office	NNP
18637	1472	15	,	,	,
18637	1472	16	and	and	CC
18637	1472	17	disqualification	disqualification	NN
18637	1472	18	to	to	TO
18637	1472	19	hold	hold	VB
18637	1472	20	and	and	CC
18637	1472	21	enjoy	enjoy	VB
18637	1472	22	any	any	DT
18637	1472	23	Office	Office	NNP
18637	1472	24	of	of	IN
18637	1472	25	honor	honor	NN
18637	1472	26	,	,	,
18637	1472	27	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	1472	28	or	or	CC
18637	1472	29	Profit	Profit	NNP
18637	1472	30	under	under	IN
18637	1472	31	the	the	DT
18637	1472	32	United	United	NNP
18637	1472	33	States	States	NNP
18637	1472	34	;	;	:
18637	1472	35	but	but	CC
18637	1472	36	the	the	DT
18637	1472	37	Party	Party	NNP
18637	1472	38	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	1472	39	shall	shall	MD
18637	1472	40	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	1472	41	be	be	VB
18637	1472	42	liable	liable	JJ
18637	1472	43	and	and	CC
18637	1472	44	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1472	45	to	to	IN
18637	1472	46	Indictment	Indictment	NNP
18637	1472	47	,	,	,
18637	1472	48	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	1472	49	,	,	,
18637	1472	50	Judgment	Judgment	NNP
18637	1472	51	and	and	CC
18637	1472	52	Punishment	Punishment	NNP
18637	1472	53	,	,	,
18637	1472	54	according	accord	VBG
18637	1472	55	to	to	IN
18637	1472	56	Law	Law	NNP
18637	1472	57	.	.	.
18637	1473	1	Section	section	NN
18637	1473	2	4	4	CD
18637	1473	3	.	.	.
18637	1474	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1474	2	1	1	CD
18637	1474	3	.	.	.
18637	1475	1	The	the	DT
18637	1475	2	Times	Times	NNP
18637	1475	3	,	,	,
18637	1475	4	Places	Places	NNPS
18637	1475	5	and	and	CC
18637	1475	6	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	1475	7	of	of	IN
18637	1475	8	holding	hold	VBG
18637	1475	9	Elections	Elections	NNPS
18637	1475	10	for	for	IN
18637	1475	11	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	1475	12	and	and	CC
18637	1475	13	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1475	14	,	,	,
18637	1475	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	1475	16	be	be	VB
18637	1475	17	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	1475	18	in	in	IN
18637	1475	19	each	each	DT
18637	1475	20	State	state	NN
18637	1475	21	by	by	IN
18637	1475	22	the	the	DT
18637	1475	23	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	1475	24	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	1475	25	;	;	:
18637	1475	26	but	but	CC
18637	1475	27	the	the	DT
18637	1475	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1475	29	may	may	MD
18637	1475	30	at	at	IN
18637	1475	31	any	any	DT
18637	1475	32	time	time	NN
18637	1475	33	by	by	IN
18637	1475	34	Law	Law	NNP
18637	1475	35	make	make	VBP
18637	1475	36	or	or	CC
18637	1475	37	alter	alter	VB
18637	1475	38	such	such	JJ
18637	1475	39	Regulations	Regulations	NNPS
18637	1475	40	,	,	,
18637	1475	41	except	except	IN
18637	1475	42	as	as	IN
18637	1475	43	to	to	IN
18637	1475	44	the	the	DT
18637	1475	45	Places	Places	NNPS
18637	1475	46	of	of	IN
18637	1475	47	chusing	chuse	VBG
18637	1475	48	Senators	senator	NNS
18637	1475	49	.	.	.
18637	1476	1	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1476	2	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
18637	1476	3	Under	under	IN
18637	1476	4	This	this	DT
18637	1476	5	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	1476	6	Not	not	RB
18637	1476	7	until	until	IN
18637	1476	8	1842	1842	CD
18637	1476	9	did	do	VBD
18637	1476	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1476	11	undertake	undertake	VB
18637	1476	12	to	to	TO
18637	1476	13	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	1476	14	the	the	DT
18637	1476	15	power	power	NN
18637	1476	16	to	to	TO
18637	1476	17	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1476	18	the	the	DT
18637	1476	19	"	"	``
18637	1476	20	times	time	NNS
18637	1476	21	,	,	,
18637	1476	22	places	place	NNS
18637	1476	23	and	and	CC
18637	1476	24	manner	manner	NN
18637	1476	25	of	of	IN
18637	1476	26	holding	hold	VBG
18637	1476	27	elections	election	NNS
18637	1476	28	for	for	IN
18637	1476	29	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	1476	30	and	and	CC
18637	1476	31	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1476	32	.	.	.
18637	1476	33	"	"	''
18637	1477	1	In	in	IN
18637	1477	2	that	that	DT
18637	1477	3	year	year	NN
18637	1477	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1477	5	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1477	6	a	a	DT
18637	1477	7	law	law	NN
18637	1477	8	requiring	require	VBG
18637	1477	9	the	the	DT
18637	1477	10	election	election	NN
18637	1477	11	of	of	IN
18637	1477	12	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1477	13	by	by	IN
18637	1477	14	districts	district	NNS
18637	1477	15	.	.	.
18637	1478	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1478	2	139	139	CD
18637	1478	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1478	4	Prior	prior	RB
18637	1478	5	to	to	IN
18637	1478	6	that	that	DT
18637	1478	7	time	time	NN
18637	1478	8	some	some	DT
18637	1478	9	of	of	IN
18637	1478	10	the	the	DT
18637	1478	11	States	States	NNPS
18637	1478	12	had	have	VBD
18637	1478	13	sought	seek	VBN
18637	1478	14	to	to	TO
18637	1478	15	increase	increase	VB
18637	1478	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1478	17	influence	influence	NN
18637	1478	18	by	by	IN
18637	1478	19	electing	elect	VBG
18637	1478	20	all	all	DT
18637	1478	21	of	of	IN
18637	1478	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1478	23	Representatives	representative	NNS
18637	1478	24	on	on	IN
18637	1478	25	a	a	DT
18637	1478	26	general	general	JJ
18637	1478	27	ticket	ticket	NN
18637	1478	28	.	.	.
18637	1479	1	The	the	DT
18637	1479	2	frequent	frequent	JJ
18637	1479	3	deadlocks	deadlock	NNS
18637	1479	4	between	between	IN
18637	1479	5	the	the	DT
18637	1479	6	two	two	CD
18637	1479	7	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	1479	8	of	of	IN
18637	1479	9	State	State	NNP
18637	1479	10	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1479	11	with	with	IN
18637	1479	12	respect	respect	NN
18637	1479	13	to	to	IN
18637	1479	14	the	the	DT
18637	1479	15	election	election	NN
18637	1479	16	of	of	IN
18637	1479	17	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	1479	18	prompted	prompt	VBD
18637	1479	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1479	20	to	to	TO
18637	1479	21	pass	pass	VB
18637	1479	22	a	a	DT
18637	1479	23	further	further	JJ
18637	1479	24	act	act	NN
18637	1479	25	in	in	IN
18637	1479	26	1866	1866	CD
18637	1479	27	,	,	,
18637	1479	28	which	which	WDT
18637	1479	29	compelled	compel	VBD
18637	1479	30	the	the	DT
18637	1479	31	two	two	CD
18637	1479	32	bodies	body	NNS
18637	1479	33	to	to	TO
18637	1479	34	meet	meet	VB
18637	1479	35	in	in	IN
18637	1479	36	joint	joint	JJ
18637	1479	37	session	session	NN
18637	1479	38	on	on	IN
18637	1479	39	a	a	DT
18637	1479	40	specified	specify	VBN
18637	1479	41	day	day	NN
18637	1479	42	,	,	,
18637	1479	43	and	and	CC
18637	1479	44	to	to	TO
18637	1479	45	meet	meet	VB
18637	1479	46	everyday	everyday	NN
18637	1479	47	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	1479	48	and	and	CC
18637	1479	49	vote	vote	VB
18637	1479	50	for	for	IN
18637	1479	51	a	a	DT
18637	1479	52	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	1479	53	until	until	IN
18637	1479	54	one	one	CD
18637	1479	55	was	be	VBD
18637	1479	56	elected	elect	VBN
18637	1479	57	.	.	.
18637	1480	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1480	2	140	140	CD
18637	1480	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1480	4	The	the	DT
18637	1480	5	first	first	JJ
18637	1480	6	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	1480	7	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1480	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	1480	9	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	1480	10	with	with	IN
18637	1480	11	elections	election	NNS
18637	1480	12	was	be	VBD
18637	1480	13	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	1480	14	in	in	IN
18637	1480	15	1870	1870	CD
18637	1480	16	.	.	.
18637	1481	1	Under	under	IN
18637	1481	2	the	the	DT
18637	1481	3	Enforcement	Enforcement	NNP
18637	1481	4	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1481	5	of	of	IN
18637	1481	6	1870	1870	CD
18637	1481	7	and	and	CC
18637	1481	8	kindred	kindred	JJ
18637	1481	9	measures,[141	measures,[141	NNP
18637	1481	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1481	11	false	false	JJ
18637	1481	12	registration	registration	NN
18637	1481	13	,	,	,
18637	1481	14	bribery	bribery	NN
18637	1481	15	,	,	,
18637	1481	16	voting	vote	VBG
18637	1481	17	without	without	IN
18637	1481	18	legal	legal	JJ
18637	1481	19	right	right	NN
18637	1481	20	,	,	,
18637	1481	21	making	make	VBG
18637	1481	22	false	false	JJ
18637	1481	23	returns	return	NNS
18637	1481	24	of	of	IN
18637	1481	25	votes	vote	NNS
18637	1481	26	cast	cast	VBN
18637	1481	27	,	,	,
18637	1481	28	interference	interference	NN
18637	1481	29	in	in	IN
18637	1481	30	any	any	DT
18637	1481	31	manner	manner	NN
18637	1481	32	with	with	IN
18637	1481	33	officers	officer	NNS
18637	1481	34	of	of	IN
18637	1481	35	election	election	NN
18637	1481	36	,	,	,
18637	1481	37	and	and	CC
18637	1481	38	the	the	DT
18637	1481	39	neglect	neglect	NN
18637	1481	40	by	by	IN
18637	1481	41	any	any	DT
18637	1481	42	such	such	JJ
18637	1481	43	officer	officer	NN
18637	1481	44	of	of	IN
18637	1481	45	any	any	DT
18637	1481	46	duty	duty	NN
18637	1481	47	required	require	VBN
18637	1481	48	of	of	IN
18637	1481	49	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1481	50	by	by	IN
18637	1481	51	State	State	NNP
18637	1481	52	of	of	IN
18637	1481	53	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1481	54	law	law	NN
18637	1481	55	,	,	,
18637	1481	56	were	be	VBD
18637	1481	57	made	make	VBN
18637	1481	58	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1481	59	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	1481	60	.	.	.
18637	1482	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	1482	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1482	3	made	make	VBN
18637	1482	4	for	for	IN
18637	1482	5	the	the	DT
18637	1482	6	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	1482	7	by	by	IN
18637	1482	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1482	9	judges	judge	NNS
18637	1482	10	of	of	IN
18637	1482	11	persons	person	NNS
18637	1482	12	to	to	TO
18637	1482	13	attend	attend	VB
18637	1482	14	at	at	IN
18637	1482	15	places	place	NNS
18637	1482	16	of	of	IN
18637	1482	17	registration	registration	NN
18637	1482	18	and	and	CC
18637	1482	19	at	at	IN
18637	1482	20	elections	election	NNS
18637	1482	21	with	with	IN
18637	1482	22	authority	authority	NN
18637	1482	23	to	to	TO
18637	1482	24	challenge	challenge	VB
18637	1482	25	any	any	DT
18637	1482	26	person	person	NN
18637	1482	27	proposing	propose	VBG
18637	1482	28	to	to	TO
18637	1482	29	register	register	VB
18637	1482	30	or	or	CC
18637	1482	31	vote	vote	VB
18637	1482	32	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	1482	33	,	,	,
18637	1482	34	to	to	TO
18637	1482	35	witness	witness	VB
18637	1482	36	the	the	DT
18637	1482	37	counting	counting	NN
18637	1482	38	of	of	IN
18637	1482	39	votes	vote	NNS
18637	1482	40	,	,	,
18637	1482	41	and	and	CC
18637	1482	42	to	to	TO
18637	1482	43	identify	identify	VB
18637	1482	44	by	by	IN
18637	1482	45	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1482	46	signatures	signature	NNS
18637	1482	47	the	the	DT
18637	1482	48	registration	registration	NN
18637	1482	49	of	of	IN
18637	1482	50	voters	voter	NNS
18637	1482	51	and	and	CC
18637	1482	52	election	election	NN
18637	1482	53	tally	tally	NN
18637	1482	54	sheets	sheet	NNS
18637	1482	55	.	.	.
18637	1483	1	After	after	IN
18637	1483	2	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	1483	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	1483	4	four	four	CD
18637	1483	5	years	year	NNS
18637	1483	6	experience	experience	VBP
18637	1483	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1483	8	repealed	repeal	VBD
18637	1483	9	those	those	DT
18637	1483	10	portions	portion	NNS
18637	1483	11	of	of	IN
18637	1483	12	the	the	DT
18637	1483	13	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
18637	1483	14	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1483	15	which	which	WDT
18637	1483	16	dealt	deal	VBD
18637	1483	17	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	1483	18	with	with	IN
18637	1483	19	elections	election	NNS
18637	1483	20	,	,	,
18637	1483	21	but	but	CC
18637	1483	22	left	leave	VBD
18637	1483	23	in	in	IN
18637	1483	24	effect	effect	NN
18637	1483	25	those	those	DT
18637	1483	26	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	1483	27	generally	generally	RB
18637	1483	28	with	with	IN
18637	1483	29	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	1483	30	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	1483	31	.	.	.
18637	1484	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1484	2	142	142	CD
18637	1484	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1484	4	As	as	IN
18637	1484	5	seen	see	VBN
18637	1484	6	earlier	early	RBR
18637	1484	7	,	,	,
18637	1484	8	those	those	DT
18637	1484	9	sections	section	NNS
18637	1484	10	have	have	VBP
18637	1484	11	been	be	VBN
18637	1484	12	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	1484	13	for	for	IN
18637	1484	14	the	the	DT
18637	1484	15	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	1484	16	of	of	IN
18637	1484	17	election	election	NN
18637	1484	18	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	1484	19	which	which	WDT
18637	1484	20	interfere	interfere	VBP
18637	1484	21	with	with	IN
18637	1484	22	the	the	DT
18637	1484	23	rights	right	NNS
18637	1484	24	of	of	IN
18637	1484	25	voters	voter	NNS
18637	1484	26	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	1484	27	by	by	IN
18637	1484	28	the	the	DT
18637	1484	29	second	second	JJ
18637	1484	30	section	section	NN
18637	1484	31	of	of	IN
18637	1484	32	this	this	DT
18637	1484	33	article	article	NN
18637	1484	34	.	.	.
18637	1485	1	The	the	DT
18637	1485	2	election	election	NN
18637	1485	3	laws	law	NNS
18637	1485	4	,	,	,
18637	1485	5	of	of	IN
18637	1485	6	the	the	DT
18637	1485	7	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
18637	1485	8	period	period	NN
18637	1485	9	were	be	VBD
18637	1485	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	1485	11	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	1485	12	in	in	IN
18637	1485	13	part	part	NN
18637	1485	14	as	as	IN
18637	1485	15	applied	apply	VBN
18637	1485	16	to	to	IN
18637	1485	17	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	1485	18	elections,[143	elections,[143	NNP
18637	1485	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1485	20	but	but	CC
18637	1485	21	were	be	VBD
18637	1485	22	found	find	VBN
18637	1485	23	to	to	TO
18637	1485	24	be	be	VB
18637	1485	25	a	a	DT
18637	1485	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1485	27	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1485	28	of	of	IN
18637	1485	29	the	the	DT
18637	1485	30	authority	authority	NN
18637	1485	31	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	1485	32	by	by	IN
18637	1485	33	this	this	DT
18637	1485	34	section	section	NN
18637	1485	35	with	with	IN
18637	1485	36	respect	respect	NN
18637	1485	37	to	to	IN
18637	1485	38	the	the	DT
18637	1485	39	election	election	NN
18637	1485	40	of	of	IN
18637	1485	41	members	member	NNS
18637	1485	42	of	of	IN
18637	1485	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1485	44	.	.	.
18637	1486	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1486	2	144	144	CD
18637	1486	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1486	4	LEGISLATURE	LEGISLATURE	NNP
18637	1486	5	DEFINED	DEFINED	NNP
18637	1486	6	While	while	IN
18637	1486	7	requiring	require	VBG
18637	1486	8	the	the	DT
18637	1486	9	election	election	NN
18637	1486	10	of	of	IN
18637	1486	11	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1486	12	by	by	IN
18637	1486	13	districts	district	NNS
18637	1486	14	,	,	,
18637	1486	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1486	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	1486	17	left	leave	VBN
18637	1486	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1486	19	to	to	IN
18637	1486	20	the	the	DT
18637	1486	21	States	States	NNPS
18637	1486	22	to	to	TO
18637	1486	23	define	define	VB
18637	1486	24	the	the	DT
18637	1486	25	areas	area	NNS
18637	1486	26	from	from	IN
18637	1486	27	which	which	WDT
18637	1486	28	members	member	NNS
18637	1486	29	should	should	MD
18637	1486	30	be	be	VB
18637	1486	31	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	1486	32	.	.	.
18637	1487	1	This	this	DT
18637	1487	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	1487	3	occasioned	occasion	VBN
18637	1487	4	a	a	DT
18637	1487	5	number	number	NN
18637	1487	6	of	of	IN
18637	1487	7	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	1487	8	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	1487	9	the	the	DT
18637	1487	10	validity	validity	NN
18637	1487	11	of	of	IN
18637	1487	12	action	action	NN
18637	1487	13	taken	take	VBN
18637	1487	14	by	by	IN
18637	1487	15	the	the	DT
18637	1487	16	States	States	NNP
18637	1487	17	.	.	.
18637	1488	1	In	in	IN
18637	1488	2	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1488	3	ex	ex	JJ
18637	1488	4	rel	rel	NN
18637	1488	5	.	.	.
18637	1489	1	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	1489	2	_	_	NNP
18637	1489	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	1489	4	_	_	NNP
18637	1489	5	Hildebrant,[145	Hildebrant,[145	NNP
18637	1489	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1489	7	a	a	DT
18637	1489	8	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	1489	9	that	that	IN
18637	1489	10	a	a	DT
18637	1489	11	redistricting	redistricte	VBG
18637	1489	12	law	law	NN
18637	1489	13	be	be	VB
18637	1489	14	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	1489	15	to	to	IN
18637	1489	16	a	a	DT
18637	1489	17	popular	popular	JJ
18637	1489	18	referendum	referendum	NN
18637	1489	19	was	be	VBD
18637	1489	20	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	1489	21	and	and	CC
18637	1489	22	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	1489	23	.	.	.
18637	1490	1	After	after	IN
18637	1490	2	the	the	DT
18637	1490	3	reapportionment	reapportionment	NN
18637	1490	4	made	make	VBD
18637	1490	5	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	1490	6	to	to	IN
18637	1490	7	the	the	DT
18637	1490	8	1930	1930	CD
18637	1490	9	census	census	NN
18637	1490	10	,	,	,
18637	1490	11	deadlocks	deadlock	NNS
18637	1490	12	between	between	IN
18637	1490	13	the	the	DT
18637	1490	14	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1490	15	and	and	CC
18637	1490	16	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1490	17	in	in	IN
18637	1490	18	several	several	JJ
18637	1490	19	States	States	NNP
18637	1490	20	,	,	,
18637	1490	21	produced	produce	VBD
18637	1490	22	a	a	DT
18637	1490	23	series	series	NN
18637	1490	24	of	of	IN
18637	1490	25	cases	case	NNS
18637	1490	26	in	in	IN
18637	1490	27	which	which	WDT
18637	1490	28	the	the	DT
18637	1490	29	right	right	NN
18637	1490	30	of	of	IN
18637	1490	31	the	the	DT
18637	1490	32	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	1490	33	to	to	TO
18637	1490	34	veto	veto	VB
18637	1490	35	a	a	DT
18637	1490	36	reapportionment	reapportionment	JJ
18637	1490	37	bill	bill	NN
18637	1490	38	was	be	VBD
18637	1490	39	questioned	question	VBN
18637	1490	40	.	.	.
18637	1491	1	Contrasting	contrast	VBG
18637	1491	2	this	this	DT
18637	1491	3	function	function	NN
18637	1491	4	with	with	IN
18637	1491	5	other	other	JJ
18637	1491	6	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1491	7	committed	commit	VBN
18637	1491	8	to	to	IN
18637	1491	9	State	State	NNP
18637	1491	10	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1491	11	by	by	IN
18637	1491	12	the	the	DT
18637	1491	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1491	14	,	,	,
18637	1491	15	the	the	DT
18637	1491	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1491	17	decided	decide	VBD
18637	1491	18	that	that	IN
18637	1491	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1491	20	was	be	VBD
18637	1491	21	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1491	22	in	in	IN
18637	1491	23	character	character	NN
18637	1491	24	and	and	CC
18637	1491	25	hence	hence	RB
18637	1491	26	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1491	27	to	to	IN
18637	1491	28	gubernatorial	gubernatorial	JJ
18637	1491	29	veto	veto	NN
18637	1491	30	to	to	IN
18637	1491	31	the	the	DT
18637	1491	32	same	same	JJ
18637	1491	33	extent	extent	NN
18637	1491	34	as	as	IN
18637	1491	35	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	1491	36	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1491	37	under	under	IN
18637	1491	38	the	the	DT
18637	1491	39	terms	term	NNS
18637	1491	40	of	of	IN
18637	1491	41	the	the	DT
18637	1491	42	State	State	NNP
18637	1491	43	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	1491	44	.	.	.
18637	1492	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1492	2	146	146	CD
18637	1492	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1492	4	PRESENT	present	NN
18637	1492	5	INEQUALITY	inequality	NN
18637	1492	6	OF	of	IN
18637	1492	7	ELECTION	election	NN
18637	1492	8	DISTRICTS	DISTRICTS	NNP
18637	1492	9	The	the	DT
18637	1492	10	Reapportionment	Reapportionment	NNP
18637	1492	11	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1492	12	of	of	IN
18637	1492	13	1929[147	1929[147	CD
18637	1492	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1492	15	omitted	omit	VBD
18637	1492	16	a	a	DT
18637	1492	17	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	1492	18	contained	contain	VBN
18637	1492	19	in	in	IN
18637	1492	20	the	the	DT
18637	1492	21	1911	1911	CD
18637	1492	22	law[148	law[148	NNPS
18637	1492	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1492	24	that	that	IN
18637	1492	25	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1492	26	districts	district	NNS
18637	1492	27	be	be	VB
18637	1492	28	"	"	``
18637	1492	29	composed	compose	VBN
18637	1492	30	of	of	IN
18637	1492	31	a	a	DT
18637	1492	32	contiguous	contiguous	JJ
18637	1492	33	and	and	CC
18637	1492	34	compact	compact	JJ
18637	1492	35	territory	territory	NN
18637	1492	36	,	,	,
18637	1492	37	*	*	NFP
18637	1492	38	*	*	NFP
18637	1492	39	*	*	NFP
18637	1492	40	containing	contain	VBG
18637	1492	41	as	as	RB
18637	1492	42	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	1492	43	as	as	RB
18637	1492	44	practicable	practicable	JJ
18637	1492	45	an	an	DT
18637	1492	46	equal	equal	JJ
18637	1492	47	number	number	NN
18637	1492	48	of	of	IN
18637	1492	49	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	1492	50	.	.	.
18637	1492	51	"	"	''
18637	1493	1	Since	since	IN
18637	1493	2	the	the	DT
18637	1493	3	earlier	early	JJR
18637	1493	4	act	act	NN
18637	1493	5	was	be	VBD
18637	1493	6	not	not	RB
18637	1493	7	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	1493	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1493	9	was	be	VBD
18637	1493	10	argued	argue	VBN
18637	1493	11	that	that	IN
18637	1493	12	the	the	DT
18637	1493	13	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	1493	14	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	1493	15	compactness	compactness	NN
18637	1493	16	,	,	,
18637	1493	17	contiguity	contiguity	NN
18637	1493	18	and	and	CC
18637	1493	19	equality	equality	NN
18637	1493	20	of	of	IN
18637	1493	21	population	population	NN
18637	1493	22	of	of	IN
18637	1493	23	districts	district	NNS
18637	1493	24	was	be	VBD
18637	1493	25	still	still	RB
18637	1493	26	controlling	control	VBG
18637	1493	27	.	.	.
18637	1494	1	The	the	DT
18637	1494	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1494	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1494	4	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	1494	5	this	this	DT
18637	1494	6	view	view	NN
18637	1494	7	.	.	.
18637	1495	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1495	2	149	149	CD
18637	1495	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1495	4	In	in	IN
18637	1495	5	Colegrove	Colegrove	NNP
18637	1495	6	_	_	NNP
18637	1495	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	1495	8	_	_	NNP
18637	1495	9	Green,[150	Green,[150	NNP
18637	1495	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1495	11	the	the	DT
18637	1495	12	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	1495	13	Apportionment	Apportionment	NNP
18637	1495	14	law	law	NN
18637	1495	15	,	,	,
18637	1495	16	which	which	WDT
18637	1495	17	created	create	VBD
18637	1495	18	districts	district	NNS
18637	1495	19	now	now	RB
18637	1495	20	having	have	VBG
18637	1495	21	glaringly	glaringly	RB
18637	1495	22	unequal	unequal	JJ
18637	1495	23	populations	population	NNS
18637	1495	24	,	,	,
18637	1495	25	was	be	VBD
18637	1495	26	attacked	attack	VBN
18637	1495	27	as	as	IN
18637	1495	28	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	1495	29	on	on	IN
18637	1495	30	the	the	DT
18637	1495	31	ground	ground	NN
18637	1495	32	that	that	IN
18637	1495	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1495	34	denied	deny	VBD
18637	1495	35	to	to	IN
18637	1495	36	voters	voter	NNS
18637	1495	37	in	in	IN
18637	1495	38	the	the	DT
18637	1495	39	more	more	RBR
18637	1495	40	populous	populous	JJ
18637	1495	41	districts	district	NNS
18637	1495	42	the	the	DT
18637	1495	43	full	full	JJ
18637	1495	44	right	right	NN
18637	1495	45	to	to	TO
18637	1495	46	vote	vote	VB
18637	1495	47	and	and	CC
18637	1495	48	to	to	IN
18637	1495	49	the	the	DT
18637	1495	50	equal	equal	JJ
18637	1495	51	protection	protection	NN
18637	1495	52	of	of	IN
18637	1495	53	the	the	DT
18637	1495	54	laws	law	NNS
18637	1495	55	.	.	.
18637	1496	1	The	the	DT
18637	1496	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1496	3	dismissed	dismiss	VBD
18637	1496	4	the	the	DT
18637	1496	5	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	1496	6	,	,	,
18637	1496	7	three	three	CD
18637	1496	8	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	1496	9	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	1496	10	that	that	IN
18637	1496	11	the	the	DT
18637	1496	12	issue	issue	NN
18637	1496	13	was	be	VBD
18637	1496	14	not	not	RB
18637	1496	15	justiciable	justiciable	JJ
18637	1496	16	,	,	,
18637	1496	17	and	and	CC
18637	1496	18	a	a	DT
18637	1496	19	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	1496	20	that	that	IN
18637	1496	21	the	the	DT
18637	1496	22	case	case	NN
18637	1496	23	was	be	VBD
18637	1496	24	one	one	CD
18637	1496	25	in	in	IN
18637	1496	26	which	which	WDT
18637	1496	27	the	the	DT
18637	1496	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1496	29	should	should	MD
18637	1496	30	decline	decline	VB
18637	1496	31	to	to	TO
18637	1496	32	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	1496	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	1496	34	.	.	.
18637	1497	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1497	2	151	151	CD
18637	1497	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1497	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1497	5	Black	Black	NNP
18637	1497	6	,	,	,
18637	1497	7	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	1497	8	in	in	IN
18637	1497	9	an	an	DT
18637	1497	10	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1497	11	in	in	IN
18637	1497	12	which	which	WDT
18637	1497	13	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	1497	14	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	1497	15	and	and	CC
18637	1497	16	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	1497	17	joined	join	VBD
18637	1497	18	,	,	,
18637	1497	19	argued	argue	VBD
18637	1497	20	:	:	:
18637	1497	21	"	"	``
18637	1497	22	While	while	IN
18637	1497	23	the	the	DT
18637	1497	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1497	25	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	1497	26	no	no	DT
18637	1497	27	express	express	JJ
18637	1497	28	provision	provision	NN
18637	1497	29	requiring	require	VBG
18637	1497	30	that	that	IN
18637	1497	31	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1497	32	election	election	NN
18637	1497	33	districts	district	NNS
18637	1497	34	established	establish	VBN
18637	1497	35	by	by	IN
18637	1497	36	the	the	DT
18637	1497	37	States	States	NNPS
18637	1497	38	must	must	MD
18637	1497	39	contain	contain	VB
18637	1497	40	approximately	approximately	RB
18637	1497	41	equal	equal	JJ
18637	1497	42	populations	population	NNS
18637	1497	43	,	,	,
18637	1497	44	the	the	DT
18637	1497	45	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	1497	46	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	1497	47	right	right	RB
18637	1497	48	to	to	TO
18637	1497	49	vote	vote	VB
18637	1497	50	and	and	CC
18637	1497	51	the	the	DT
18637	1497	52	right	right	NN
18637	1497	53	to	to	TO
18637	1497	54	have	have	VB
18637	1497	55	one	one	NN
18637	1497	56	's	's	POS
18637	1497	57	vote	vote	NN
18637	1497	58	counted	count	VBN
18637	1497	59	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	1497	60	imply	imply	VB
18637	1497	61	the	the	DT
18637	1497	62	policy	policy	NN
18637	1497	63	that	that	WDT
18637	1497	64	State	State	NNP
18637	1497	65	election	election	NN
18637	1497	66	systems	system	NNS
18637	1497	67	,	,	,
18637	1497	68	no	no	RB
18637	1497	69	matter	matter	RB
18637	1497	70	what	what	WP
18637	1497	71	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1497	72	form	form	NN
18637	1497	73	,	,	,
18637	1497	74	should	should	MD
18637	1497	75	be	be	VB
18637	1497	76	designed	design	VBN
18637	1497	77	to	to	TO
18637	1497	78	give	give	VB
18637	1497	79	approximately	approximately	RB
18637	1497	80	equal	equal	JJ
18637	1497	81	weight	weight	NN
18637	1497	82	of	of	IN
18637	1497	83	each	each	DT
18637	1497	84	vote	vote	NN
18637	1497	85	case	case	NN
18637	1497	86	.	.	.
18637	1498	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1498	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1498	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1498	4	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1498	5	which	which	WDT
18637	1498	6	must	must	MD
18637	1498	7	inevitably	inevitably	RB
18637	1498	8	bring	bring	VB
18637	1498	9	about	about	RP
18637	1498	10	glaringly	glaringly	RB
18637	1498	11	unequal	unequal	JJ
18637	1498	12	representation	representation	NN
18637	1498	13	in	in	IN
18637	1498	14	the	the	DT
18637	1498	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1498	16	in	in	IN
18637	1498	17	favor	favor	NN
18637	1498	18	of	of	IN
18637	1498	19	special	special	JJ
18637	1498	20	classes	class	NNS
18637	1498	21	and	and	CC
18637	1498	22	groups	group	NNS
18637	1498	23	should	should	MD
18637	1498	24	be	be	VB
18637	1498	25	invalidated	invalidate	VBN
18637	1498	26	,	,	,
18637	1498	27	'	'	''
18637	1498	28	whether	whether	IN
18637	1498	29	accomplished	accomplish	VBN
18637	1498	30	ingeniously	ingeniously	RB
18637	1498	31	or	or	CC
18637	1498	32	ingenuously	ingenuously	RB
18637	1498	33	'	'	''
18637	1498	34	.	.	.
18637	1499	1	"	"	``
18637	1499	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1499	3	152	152	CD
18637	1499	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1499	5	CONGRESSIONAL	congressional	JJ
18637	1499	6	PROTECTION	protection	NN
18637	1499	7	OF	of	IN
18637	1499	8	THE	the	DT
18637	1499	9	ELECTORAL	electoral	NN
18637	1499	10	PROCESS	process	NN
18637	1499	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1499	12	can	can	MD
18637	1499	13	by	by	IN
18637	1499	14	law	law	NN
18637	1499	15	protect	protect	VB
18637	1499	16	the	the	DT
18637	1499	17	voter	voter	NN
18637	1499	18	from	from	IN
18637	1499	19	personal	personal	JJ
18637	1499	20	violence	violence	NN
18637	1499	21	or	or	CC
18637	1499	22	intimidation	intimidation	NN
18637	1499	23	and	and	CC
18637	1499	24	the	the	DT
18637	1499	25	election	election	NN
18637	1499	26	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1499	27	from	from	IN
18637	1499	28	corruption	corruption	NN
18637	1499	29	and	and	CC
18637	1499	30	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	1499	31	.	.	.
18637	1500	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1500	2	153	153	CD
18637	1500	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1500	4	To	to	TO
18637	1500	5	accomplish	accomplish	VB
18637	1500	6	these	these	DT
18637	1500	7	ends	end	NNS
18637	1500	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1500	9	may	may	MD
18637	1500	10	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	1500	11	the	the	DT
18637	1500	12	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	1500	13	of	of	IN
18637	1500	14	the	the	DT
18637	1500	15	States	States	NNPS
18637	1500	16	and	and	CC
18637	1500	17	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	1500	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1500	19	by	by	IN
18637	1500	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1500	21	own	own	JJ
18637	1500	22	sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	1500	23	.	.	.
18637	1501	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1501	2	154	154	CD
18637	1501	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1501	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1501	5	may	may	MD
18637	1501	6	punish	punish	VB
18637	1501	7	a	a	DT
18637	1501	8	State	State	NNP
18637	1501	9	election	election	NN
18637	1501	10	officer	officer	NN
18637	1501	11	for	for	IN
18637	1501	12	violating	violate	VBG
18637	1501	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1501	14	duty	duty	NN
18637	1501	15	under	under	IN
18637	1501	16	a	a	DT
18637	1501	17	State	State	NNP
18637	1501	18	law	law	NN
18637	1501	19	governing	govern	VBG
18637	1501	20	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1501	21	elections	election	NNS
18637	1501	22	.	.	.
18637	1502	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1502	2	155	155	CD
18637	1502	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1502	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1502	5	may	may	MD
18637	1502	6	also	also	RB
18637	1502	7	punish	punish	VB
18637	1502	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1502	9	officers	officer	NNS
18637	1502	10	and	and	CC
18637	1502	11	employees	employee	NNS
18637	1502	12	who	who	WP
18637	1502	13	solicit	solicit	VBP
18637	1502	14	or	or	CC
18637	1502	15	receive	receive	VBP
18637	1502	16	contributions	contribution	NNS
18637	1502	17	to	to	TO
18637	1502	18	procure	procure	VB
18637	1502	19	the	the	DT
18637	1502	20	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	1502	21	of	of	IN
18637	1502	22	a	a	DT
18637	1502	23	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1502	24	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	1502	25	in	in	IN
18637	1502	26	a	a	DT
18637	1502	27	State	State	NNP
18637	1502	28	primary	primary	JJ
18637	1502	29	election	election	NN
18637	1502	30	.	.	.
18637	1503	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1503	2	156	156	CD
18637	1503	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1503	4	At	at	IN
18637	1503	5	one	one	CD
18637	1503	6	time	time	NN
18637	1503	7	the	the	DT
18637	1503	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1503	9	held	hold	VBD
18637	1503	10	that	that	IN
18637	1503	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1503	12	had	have	VBD
18637	1503	13	no	no	DT
18637	1503	14	power	power	NN
18637	1503	15	,	,	,
18637	1503	16	at	at	IN
18637	1503	17	least	least	JJS
18637	1503	18	prior	prior	RB
18637	1503	19	to	to	IN
18637	1503	20	the	the	DT
18637	1503	21	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	1503	22	of	of	IN
18637	1503	23	the	the	DT
18637	1503	24	Seventeenth	Seventeenth	NNP
18637	1503	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1503	26	,	,	,
18637	1503	27	to	to	TO
18637	1503	28	limit	limit	VB
18637	1503	29	the	the	DT
18637	1503	30	expenditures	expenditure	NNS
18637	1503	31	made	make	VBN
18637	1503	32	to	to	TO
18637	1503	33	procure	procure	VB
18637	1503	34	a	a	DT
18637	1503	35	primary	primary	JJ
18637	1503	36	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	1503	37	to	to	IN
18637	1503	38	the	the	DT
18637	1503	39	United	United	NNP
18637	1503	40	States	States	NNP
18637	1503	41	Senate,[157	Senate,[157	NNP
18637	1503	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1503	43	but	but	CC
18637	1503	44	this	this	DT
18637	1503	45	decision	decision	NN
18637	1503	46	has	have	VBZ
18637	1503	47	been	be	VBN
18637	1503	48	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	1503	49	weakened	weaken	VBN
18637	1503	50	,	,	,
18637	1503	51	and	and	CC
18637	1503	52	the	the	DT
18637	1503	53	right	right	NN
18637	1503	54	of	of	IN
18637	1503	55	the	the	DT
18637	1503	56	National	National	NNP
18637	1503	57	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1503	58	to	to	TO
18637	1503	59	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1503	60	primary	primary	JJ
18637	1503	61	elections	election	NNS
18637	1503	62	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	1503	63	under	under	IN
18637	1503	64	State	State	NNP
18637	1503	65	law	law	NN
18637	1503	66	for	for	IN
18637	1503	67	the	the	DT
18637	1503	68	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	1503	69	of	of	IN
18637	1503	70	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	1503	71	of	of	IN
18637	1503	72	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1503	73	has	have	VBZ
18637	1503	74	been	be	VBN
18637	1503	75	squarely	squarely	RB
18637	1503	76	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	1503	77	where	where	WRB
18637	1503	78	such	such	JJ
18637	1503	79	primary	primary	NN
18637	1503	80	is	be	VBZ
18637	1503	81	made	make	VBN
18637	1503	82	by	by	IN
18637	1503	83	State	State	NNP
18637	1503	84	law	law	NN
18637	1503	85	"	"	''
18637	1503	86	an	an	DT
18637	1503	87	integral	integral	JJ
18637	1503	88	part	part	NN
18637	1503	89	of	of	IN
18637	1503	90	the	the	DT
18637	1503	91	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	1503	92	of	of	IN
18637	1503	93	choice	choice	NN
18637	1503	94	,	,	,
18637	1503	95	or	or	CC
18637	1503	96	where	where	WRB
18637	1503	97	in	in	IN
18637	1503	98	fact	fact	NN
18637	1503	99	the	the	DT
18637	1503	100	primary	primary	NN
18637	1503	101	effectively	effectively	RB
18637	1503	102	controls	control	VBZ
18637	1503	103	the	the	DT
18637	1503	104	choice,	choice,	NN
18637	1503	105	...	...	:
18637	1503	106	"[158	"[158	LS
18637	1503	107	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1503	108	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1503	109	2	2	CD
18637	1503	110	.	.	.
18637	1504	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1504	2	The	the	DT
18637	1504	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1504	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	1504	5	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	1504	6	at	at	IN
18637	1504	7	least	least	JJS
18637	1504	8	once	once	RB
18637	1504	9	in	in	IN
18637	1504	10	every	every	DT
18637	1504	11	Year	Year	NNP
18637	1504	12	,	,	,
18637	1504	13	and	and	CC
18637	1504	14	such	such	JJ
18637	1504	15	Meeting	meeting	NN
18637	1504	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	1504	17	be	be	VB
18637	1504	18	on	on	IN
18637	1504	19	the	the	DT
18637	1504	20	first	first	JJ
18637	1504	21	Monday	Monday	NNP
18637	1504	22	in	in	IN
18637	1504	23	December	December	NNP
18637	1504	24	,	,	,
18637	1504	25	unless	unless	IN
18637	1504	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1504	27	shall	shall	MD
18637	1504	28	by	by	IN
18637	1504	29	law	law	NN
18637	1504	30	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	1504	31	a	a	DT
18637	1504	32	different	different	JJ
18637	1504	33	Day	day	NN
18637	1504	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1504	35	.	.	.
18637	1505	1	Section	section	NN
18637	1505	2	5	5	CD
18637	1505	3	.	.	.
18637	1506	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1506	2	1	1	CD
18637	1506	3	.	.	.
18637	1507	1	Each	each	DT
18637	1507	2	House	House	NNP
18637	1507	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	1507	4	be	be	VB
18637	1507	5	the	the	DT
18637	1507	6	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	1507	7	of	of	IN
18637	1507	8	the	the	DT
18637	1507	9	Elections	Elections	NNPS
18637	1507	10	,	,	,
18637	1507	11	Returns	Returns	NNPS
18637	1507	12	and	and	CC
18637	1507	13	Qualifications	Qualifications	NNPS
18637	1507	14	of	of	IN
18637	1507	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1507	16	own	own	JJ
18637	1507	17	Members	member	NNS
18637	1507	18	,	,	,
18637	1507	19	and	and	CC
18637	1507	20	a	a	DT
18637	1507	21	Majority	majority	NN
18637	1507	22	of	of	IN
18637	1507	23	each	each	DT
18637	1507	24	shall	shall	MD
18637	1507	25	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	1507	26	a	a	DT
18637	1507	27	Quorum	Quorum	NNP
18637	1507	28	to	to	TO
18637	1507	29	do	do	VB
18637	1507	30	Business	business	NN
18637	1507	31	;	;	:
18637	1507	32	but	but	CC
18637	1507	33	a	a	DT
18637	1507	34	smaller	small	JJR
18637	1507	35	Number	Number	NNP
18637	1507	36	may	may	MD
18637	1507	37	adjourn	adjourn	VB
18637	1507	38	from	from	IN
18637	1507	39	day	day	NN
18637	1507	40	to	to	IN
18637	1507	41	day	day	NN
18637	1507	42	,	,	,
18637	1507	43	and	and	CC
18637	1507	44	may	may	MD
18637	1507	45	be	be	VB
18637	1507	46	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	1507	47	to	to	TO
18637	1507	48	compel	compel	VB
18637	1507	49	the	the	DT
18637	1507	50	Attendance	attendance	NN
18637	1507	51	of	of	IN
18637	1507	52	absent	absent	JJ
18637	1507	53	Members	member	NNS
18637	1507	54	,	,	,
18637	1507	55	in	in	IN
18637	1507	56	such	such	JJ
18637	1507	57	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	1507	58	,	,	,
18637	1507	59	and	and	CC
18637	1507	60	under	under	IN
18637	1507	61	such	such	JJ
18637	1507	62	Penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	1507	63	as	as	IN
18637	1507	64	each	each	DT
18637	1507	65	House	House	NNP
18637	1507	66	may	may	MD
18637	1507	67	provide	provide	VB
18637	1507	68	.	.	.
18637	1508	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1508	2	2	2	CD
18637	1508	3	.	.	.
18637	1509	1	Each	each	DT
18637	1509	2	House	House	NNP
18637	1509	3	may	may	MD
18637	1509	4	determine	determine	VB
18637	1509	5	the	the	DT
18637	1509	6	Rules	Rules	NNPS
18637	1509	7	of	of	IN
18637	1509	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1509	9	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNP
18637	1509	10	,	,	,
18637	1509	11	punish	punish	VB
18637	1509	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1509	13	Members	member	NNS
18637	1509	14	for	for	IN
18637	1509	15	disorderly	disorderly	JJ
18637	1509	16	Behaviour	Behaviour	NNP
18637	1509	17	,	,	,
18637	1509	18	and	and	CC
18637	1509	19	,	,	,
18637	1509	20	with	with	IN
18637	1509	21	the	the	DT
18637	1509	22	Concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	1509	23	of	of	IN
18637	1509	24	two	two	CD
18637	1509	25	thirds	third	NNS
18637	1509	26	,	,	,
18637	1509	27	expel	expel	VB
18637	1509	28	a	a	DT
18637	1509	29	Member	Member	NNP
18637	1509	30	.	.	.
18637	1510	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1510	2	3	3	CD
18637	1510	3	.	.	.
18637	1511	1	Each	each	DT
18637	1511	2	House	House	NNP
18637	1511	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	1511	4	keep	keep	VB
18637	1511	5	a	a	DT
18637	1511	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	1511	7	of	of	IN
18637	1511	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1511	9	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNP
18637	1511	10	,	,	,
18637	1511	11	and	and	CC
18637	1511	12	from	from	IN
18637	1511	13	time	time	NN
18637	1511	14	to	to	IN
18637	1511	15	time	time	NN
18637	1511	16	publish	publish	VB
18637	1511	17	the	the	DT
18637	1511	18	same	same	JJ
18637	1511	19	,	,	,
18637	1511	20	excepting	except	VBG
18637	1511	21	such	such	JJ
18637	1511	22	Parts	part	NNS
18637	1511	23	as	as	IN
18637	1511	24	may	may	MD
18637	1511	25	in	in	IN
18637	1511	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1511	27	Judgment	Judgment	NNP
18637	1511	28	require	require	NN
18637	1511	29	Secrecy	secrecy	NN
18637	1511	30	;	;	:
18637	1511	31	and	and	CC
18637	1511	32	the	the	DT
18637	1511	33	Yeas	Yeas	NNPS
18637	1511	34	and	and	CC
18637	1511	35	Nays	Nays	NNPS
18637	1511	36	of	of	IN
18637	1511	37	the	the	DT
18637	1511	38	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	1511	39	of	of	IN
18637	1511	40	either	either	DT
18637	1511	41	House	House	NNP
18637	1511	42	on	on	IN
18637	1511	43	any	any	DT
18637	1511	44	question	question	NN
18637	1511	45	shall	shall	MD
18637	1511	46	,	,	,
18637	1511	47	at	at	IN
18637	1511	48	the	the	DT
18637	1511	49	Desire	Desire	NNP
18637	1511	50	of	of	IN
18637	1511	51	one	one	CD
18637	1511	52	fifth	fifth	NN
18637	1511	53	of	of	IN
18637	1511	54	those	those	DT
18637	1511	55	Present	present	JJ
18637	1511	56	,	,	,
18637	1511	57	be	be	VB
18637	1511	58	entered	enter	VBN
18637	1511	59	on	on	IN
18637	1511	60	the	the	DT
18637	1511	61	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	1511	62	.	.	.
18637	1512	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1512	2	4	4	CD
18637	1512	3	.	.	.
18637	1513	1	Neither	neither	DT
18637	1513	2	House	House	NNP
18637	1513	3	,	,	,
18637	1513	4	during	during	IN
18637	1513	5	the	the	DT
18637	1513	6	Session	Session	NNP
18637	1513	7	of	of	IN
18637	1513	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1513	9	,	,	,
18637	1513	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	1513	11	,	,	,
18637	1513	12	without	without	IN
18637	1513	13	the	the	DT
18637	1513	14	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	1513	15	of	of	IN
18637	1513	16	the	the	DT
18637	1513	17	other	other	JJ
18637	1513	18	,	,	,
18637	1513	19	adjourn	adjourn	JJ
18637	1513	20	for	for	IN
18637	1513	21	more	more	JJR
18637	1513	22	than	than	IN
18637	1513	23	three	three	CD
18637	1513	24	days	day	NNS
18637	1513	25	,	,	,
18637	1513	26	nor	nor	CC
18637	1513	27	to	to	IN
18637	1513	28	any	any	DT
18637	1513	29	other	other	JJ
18637	1513	30	Place	Place	NNP
18637	1513	31	than	than	IN
18637	1513	32	that	that	DT
18637	1513	33	in	in	IN
18637	1513	34	which	which	WDT
18637	1513	35	the	the	DT
18637	1513	36	two	two	CD
18637	1513	37	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	1513	38	shall	shall	MD
18637	1513	39	be	be	VB
18637	1513	40	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	1513	41	.	.	.
18637	1514	1	Powers	power	NNS
18637	1514	2	and	and	CC
18637	1514	3	Duties	Duties	NNPS
18637	1514	4	of	of	IN
18637	1514	5	the	the	DT
18637	1514	6	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	1514	7	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	1514	8	TO	to	TO
18637	1514	9	JUDGE	judge	VB
18637	1514	10	ELECTIONS	ELECTIONS	NNP
18637	1514	11	Each	each	DT
18637	1514	12	House	House	NNP
18637	1514	13	,	,	,
18637	1514	14	in	in	IN
18637	1514	15	judging	judging	NN
18637	1514	16	of	of	IN
18637	1514	17	elections	election	NNS
18637	1514	18	under	under	IN
18637	1514	19	this	this	DT
18637	1514	20	clause	clause	NN
18637	1514	21	acts	act	VBZ
18637	1514	22	as	as	IN
18637	1514	23	a	a	DT
18637	1514	24	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1514	25	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	1514	26	,	,	,
18637	1514	27	with	with	IN
18637	1514	28	like	like	IN
18637	1514	29	power	power	NN
18637	1514	30	to	to	TO
18637	1514	31	compel	compel	VB
18637	1514	32	attendance	attendance	NN
18637	1514	33	of	of	IN
18637	1514	34	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	1514	35	.	.	.
18637	1515	1	In	in	IN
18637	1515	2	the	the	DT
18637	1515	3	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1515	4	of	of	IN
18637	1515	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1515	6	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	1515	7	,	,	,
18637	1515	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1515	9	may	may	MD
18637	1515	10	issue	issue	VB
18637	1515	11	a	a	DT
18637	1515	12	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	1515	13	for	for	IN
18637	1515	14	the	the	DT
18637	1515	15	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	1515	16	of	of	IN
18637	1515	17	a	a	DT
18637	1515	18	witness	witness	NN
18637	1515	19	to	to	TO
18637	1515	20	procure	procure	VB
18637	1515	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1515	22	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	1515	23	,	,	,
18637	1515	24	without	without	IN
18637	1515	25	previous	previous	JJ
18637	1515	26	subpoena	subpoena	NN
18637	1515	27	,	,	,
18637	1515	28	if	if	IN
18637	1515	29	there	there	EX
18637	1515	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	1515	31	good	good	JJ
18637	1515	32	reason	reason	NN
18637	1515	33	to	to	TO
18637	1515	34	believe	believe	VB
18637	1515	35	that	that	IN
18637	1515	36	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	1515	37	such	such	JJ
18637	1515	38	witness	witness	NN
18637	1515	39	would	would	MD
18637	1515	40	not	not	RB
18637	1515	41	be	be	VB
18637	1515	42	forthcoming	forthcoming	JJ
18637	1515	43	.	.	.
18637	1516	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1516	2	159	159	CD
18637	1516	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1516	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1516	5	may	may	MD
18637	1516	6	punish	punish	VB
18637	1516	7	perjury	perjury	NN
18637	1516	8	committed	commit	VBN
18637	1516	9	in	in	IN
18637	1516	10	testifying	testify	VBG
18637	1516	11	before	before	IN
18637	1516	12	a	a	DT
18637	1516	13	notary	notary	JJ
18637	1516	14	public	public	NN
18637	1516	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	1516	16	a	a	DT
18637	1516	17	contested	contested	JJ
18637	1516	18	election	election	NN
18637	1516	19	.	.	.
18637	1517	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1517	2	160	160	CD
18637	1517	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1517	4	The	the	DT
18637	1517	5	power	power	NN
18637	1517	6	to	to	TO
18637	1517	7	judge	judge	VB
18637	1517	8	elections	election	NNS
18637	1517	9	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	1517	10	to	to	IN
18637	1517	11	an	an	DT
18637	1517	12	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	1517	13	of	of	IN
18637	1517	14	expenditures	expenditure	NNS
18637	1517	15	made	make	VBN
18637	1517	16	to	to	TO
18637	1517	17	influence	influence	VB
18637	1517	18	nominations	nomination	NNS
18637	1517	19	at	at	IN
18637	1517	20	a	a	DT
18637	1517	21	primary	primary	JJ
18637	1517	22	election	election	NN
18637	1517	23	.	.	.
18637	1518	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1518	2	161	161	CD
18637	1518	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1518	4	Refusal	refusal	NN
18637	1518	5	to	to	TO
18637	1518	6	permit	permit	VB
18637	1518	7	a	a	DT
18637	1518	8	person	person	NN
18637	1518	9	presenting	present	VBG
18637	1518	10	credentials	credential	NNS
18637	1518	11	in	in	IN
18637	1518	12	due	due	JJ
18637	1518	13	form	form	NN
18637	1518	14	to	to	TO
18637	1518	15	take	take	VB
18637	1518	16	the	the	DT
18637	1518	17	oath	oath	NN
18637	1518	18	of	of	IN
18637	1518	19	office	office	NN
18637	1518	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	1518	21	not	not	RB
18637	1518	22	oust	oust	VB
18637	1518	23	the	the	DT
18637	1518	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	1518	25	of	of	IN
18637	1518	26	the	the	DT
18637	1518	27	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1518	28	to	to	TO
18637	1518	29	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	1518	30	into	into	IN
18637	1518	31	the	the	DT
18637	1518	32	legality	legality	NN
18637	1518	33	of	of	IN
18637	1518	34	the	the	DT
18637	1518	35	election	election	NN
18637	1518	36	.	.	.
18637	1519	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1519	2	162	162	CD
18637	1519	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1519	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	1519	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	1519	6	such	such	JJ
18637	1519	7	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	1519	8	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	1519	9	deprive	deprive	VBP
18637	1519	10	the	the	DT
18637	1519	11	State	State	NNP
18637	1519	12	which	which	WDT
18637	1519	13	elected	elect	VBD
18637	1519	14	such	such	JJ
18637	1519	15	person	person	NN
18637	1519	16	of	of	IN
18637	1519	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1519	18	equal	equal	JJ
18637	1519	19	suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	1519	20	in	in	IN
18637	1519	21	the	the	DT
18637	1519	22	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1519	23	.	.	.
18637	1520	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1520	2	163	163	CD
18637	1520	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1520	4	"	"	``
18637	1520	5	A	a	NN
18637	1520	6	QUORUM	quorum	NN
18637	1520	7	TO	to	TO
18637	1520	8	DO	do	VB
18637	1520	9	BUSINESS	business	PRP
18637	1520	10	"	"	``
18637	1520	11	For	for	IN
18637	1520	12	many	many	JJ
18637	1520	13	years	year	NNS
18637	1520	14	the	the	DT
18637	1520	15	view	view	NN
18637	1520	16	prevailed	prevail	VBD
18637	1520	17	in	in	IN
18637	1520	18	the	the	DT
18637	1520	19	House	House	NNP
18637	1520	20	of	of	IN
18637	1520	21	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1520	22	that	that	IN
18637	1520	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1520	24	was	be	VBD
18637	1520	25	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1520	26	for	for	IN
18637	1520	27	a	a	DT
18637	1520	28	majority	majority	NN
18637	1520	29	of	of	IN
18637	1520	30	the	the	DT
18637	1520	31	members	member	NNS
18637	1520	32	to	to	TO
18637	1520	33	vote	vote	VB
18637	1520	34	on	on	IN
18637	1520	35	any	any	DT
18637	1520	36	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	1520	37	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	1520	38	to	to	IN
18637	1520	39	the	the	DT
18637	1520	40	House	House	NNP
18637	1520	41	in	in	IN
18637	1520	42	order	order	NN
18637	1520	43	to	to	TO
18637	1520	44	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	1520	45	the	the	DT
18637	1520	46	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1520	47	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	1520	48	for	for	IN
18637	1520	49	a	a	DT
18637	1520	50	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	1520	51	.	.	.
18637	1521	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1521	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1521	3	a	a	DT
18637	1521	4	common	common	JJ
18637	1521	5	practice	practice	NN
18637	1521	6	for	for	IN
18637	1521	7	the	the	DT
18637	1521	8	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	1521	9	to	to	TO
18637	1521	10	break	break	VB
18637	1521	11	a	a	DT
18637	1521	12	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	1521	13	by	by	IN
18637	1521	14	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	1521	15	to	to	TO
18637	1521	16	vote	vote	VB
18637	1521	17	.	.	.
18637	1522	1	This	this	DT
18637	1522	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1522	3	changed	change	VBN
18637	1522	4	in	in	IN
18637	1522	5	1890	1890	CD
18637	1522	6	,	,	,
18637	1522	7	by	by	IN
18637	1522	8	a	a	DT
18637	1522	9	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	1522	10	made	make	VBN
18637	1522	11	by	by	IN
18637	1522	12	Speaker	Speaker	NNP
18637	1522	13	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	1522	14	,	,	,
18637	1522	15	and	and	CC
18637	1522	16	later	later	RB
18637	1522	17	embodied	embody	VBN
18637	1522	18	in	in	IN
18637	1522	19	Rule	Rule	NNP
18637	1522	20	XV	XV	NNP
18637	1522	21	of	of	IN
18637	1522	22	the	the	DT
18637	1522	23	House	House	NNP
18637	1522	24	,	,	,
18637	1522	25	that	that	IN
18637	1522	26	members	member	NNS
18637	1522	27	present	present	JJ
18637	1522	28	in	in	IN
18637	1522	29	the	the	DT
18637	1522	30	chamber	chamber	NN
18637	1522	31	but	but	CC
18637	1522	32	not	not	RB
18637	1522	33	voting	voting	NN
18637	1522	34	would	would	MD
18637	1522	35	be	be	VB
18637	1522	36	counted	count	VBN
18637	1522	37	in	in	IN
18637	1522	38	determining	determine	VBG
18637	1522	39	the	the	DT
18637	1522	40	presence	presence	NN
18637	1522	41	of	of	IN
18637	1522	42	a	a	DT
18637	1522	43	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	1522	44	.	.	.
18637	1523	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1523	2	164	164	CD
18637	1523	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1523	4	The	the	DT
18637	1523	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1523	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1523	7	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	1523	8	this	this	DT
18637	1523	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	1523	10	in	in	IN
18637	1523	11	United	United	NNP
18637	1523	12	States	States	NNP
18637	1523	13	_	_	NNP
18637	1523	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	1523	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1523	16	Ballin,[165	Ballin,[165	NNP
18637	1523	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1523	18	saying	say	VBG
18637	1523	19	that	that	IN
18637	1523	20	the	the	DT
18637	1523	21	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	1523	22	of	of	IN
18637	1523	23	the	the	DT
18637	1523	24	House	House	NNP
18637	1523	25	to	to	TO
18637	1523	26	transact	transact	VB
18637	1523	27	business	business	NN
18637	1523	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	1523	29	"	"	``
18637	1523	30	created	create	VBN
18637	1523	31	by	by	IN
18637	1523	32	the	the	DT
18637	1523	33	mere	mere	JJ
18637	1523	34	presence	presence	NN
18637	1523	35	of	of	IN
18637	1523	36	a	a	DT
18637	1523	37	majority	majority	NN
18637	1523	38	,	,	,
18637	1523	39	"	"	''
18637	1523	40	and	and	CC
18637	1523	41	that	that	IN
18637	1523	42	since	since	IN
18637	1523	43	the	the	DT
18637	1523	44	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1523	45	does	do	VBZ
18637	1523	46	not	not	RB
18637	1523	47	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	1523	48	any	any	DT
18637	1523	49	method	method	NN
18637	1523	50	for	for	IN
18637	1523	51	determining	determine	VBG
18637	1523	52	the	the	DT
18637	1523	53	presence	presence	NN
18637	1523	54	of	of	IN
18637	1523	55	such	such	JJ
18637	1523	56	majority	majority	NN
18637	1523	57	"	"	``
18637	1523	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1523	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	1523	60	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	1523	61	within	within	IN
18637	1523	62	the	the	DT
18637	1523	63	competency	competency	NN
18637	1523	64	of	of	IN
18637	1523	65	the	the	DT
18637	1523	66	House	House	NNP
18637	1523	67	to	to	TO
18637	1523	68	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	1523	69	any	any	DT
18637	1523	70	method	method	NN
18637	1523	71	which	which	WDT
18637	1523	72	shall	shall	MD
18637	1523	73	be	be	VB
18637	1523	74	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	1523	75	certain	certain	JJ
18637	1523	76	to	to	TO
18637	1523	77	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	1523	78	the	the	DT
18637	1523	79	fact	fact	NN
18637	1523	80	.	.	.
18637	1524	1	"	"	``
18637	1524	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1524	3	166	166	CD
18637	1524	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1524	5	The	the	DT
18637	1524	6	rules	rule	NNS
18637	1524	7	of	of	IN
18637	1524	8	the	the	DT
18637	1524	9	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1524	10	provide	provide	VBP
18637	1524	11	for	for	IN
18637	1524	12	the	the	DT
18637	1524	13	ascertainment	ascertainment	NN
18637	1524	14	of	of	IN
18637	1524	15	a	a	DT
18637	1524	16	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	1524	17	only	only	RB
18637	1524	18	by	by	IN
18637	1524	19	a	a	DT
18637	1524	20	roll	roll	NN
18637	1524	21	call,[167	call,[167	NN
18637	1524	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1524	23	but	but	CC
18637	1524	24	in	in	IN
18637	1524	25	a	a	DT
18637	1524	26	few	few	JJ
18637	1524	27	cases	case	NNS
18637	1524	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1524	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	1524	30	held	hold	VBN
18637	1524	31	that	that	IN
18637	1524	32	if	if	IN
18637	1524	33	a	a	DT
18637	1524	34	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	1524	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	1524	36	present	present	JJ
18637	1524	37	,	,	,
18637	1524	38	a	a	DT
18637	1524	39	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	1524	40	can	can	MD
18637	1524	41	be	be	VB
18637	1524	42	determined	determine	VBN
18637	1524	43	by	by	IN
18637	1524	44	the	the	DT
18637	1524	45	vote	vote	NN
18637	1524	46	of	of	IN
18637	1524	47	a	a	DT
18637	1524	48	lesser	less	JJR
18637	1524	49	number	number	NN
18637	1524	50	of	of	IN
18637	1524	51	members	member	NNS
18637	1524	52	.	.	.
18637	1525	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1525	2	168	168	CD
18637	1525	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1525	4	RULES	rule	NNS
18637	1525	5	OF	of	IN
18637	1525	6	PROCEDURE	PROCEDURE	NNP
18637	1525	7	In	in	IN
18637	1525	8	the	the	DT
18637	1525	9	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1525	10	of	of	IN
18637	1525	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1525	12	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1525	13	power	power	NN
18637	1525	14	to	to	TO
18637	1525	15	determine	determine	VB
18637	1525	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1525	17	rules	rule	NNS
18637	1525	18	of	of	IN
18637	1525	19	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	1525	20	the	the	DT
18637	1525	21	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	1525	22	of	of	IN
18637	1525	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1525	24	may	may	MD
18637	1525	25	not	not	RB
18637	1525	26	"	"	``
18637	1525	27	ignore	ignore	VB
18637	1525	28	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1525	29	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	1525	30	or	or	CC
18637	1525	31	violate	violate	VB
18637	1525	32	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	1525	33	rights	right	NNS
18637	1525	34	,	,	,
18637	1525	35	and	and	CC
18637	1525	36	there	there	EX
18637	1525	37	should	should	MD
18637	1525	38	be	be	VB
18637	1525	39	a	a	DT
18637	1525	40	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	1525	41	relation	relation	NN
18637	1525	42	between	between	IN
18637	1525	43	the	the	DT
18637	1525	44	mode	mode	NN
18637	1525	45	or	or	CC
18637	1525	46	method	method	NN
18637	1525	47	of	of	IN
18637	1525	48	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	1525	49	established	establish	VBN
18637	1525	50	by	by	IN
18637	1525	51	the	the	DT
18637	1525	52	rule	rule	NN
18637	1525	53	and	and	CC
18637	1525	54	the	the	DT
18637	1525	55	result	result	NN
18637	1525	56	which	which	WDT
18637	1525	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	1525	58	sought	seek	VBN
18637	1525	59	to	to	TO
18637	1525	60	be	be	VB
18637	1525	61	attained	attain	VBN
18637	1525	62	.	.	.
18637	1526	1	But	but	CC
18637	1526	2	within	within	IN
18637	1526	3	these	these	DT
18637	1526	4	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	1526	5	all	all	DT
18637	1526	6	matters	matter	NNS
18637	1526	7	of	of	IN
18637	1526	8	method	method	NN
18637	1526	9	are	be	VBP
18637	1526	10	open	open	JJ
18637	1526	11	to	to	IN
18637	1526	12	the	the	DT
18637	1526	13	determination	determination	NN
18637	1526	14	of	of	IN
18637	1526	15	the	the	DT
18637	1526	16	House	House	NNP
18637	1526	17	,	,	,
18637	1526	18	*	*	NFP
18637	1526	19	*	*	NFP
18637	1526	20	*	*	NFP
18637	1526	21	The	the	DT
18637	1526	22	power	power	NN
18637	1526	23	to	to	TO
18637	1526	24	make	make	VB
18637	1526	25	rules	rule	NNS
18637	1526	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	1526	27	not	not	RB
18637	1526	28	one	one	CD
18637	1526	29	which	which	WDT
18637	1526	30	once	once	RB
18637	1526	31	exercised	exercise	VBD
18637	1526	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	1526	33	exhausted	exhaust	VBN
18637	1526	34	.	.	.
18637	1527	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1527	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1527	3	a	a	DT
18637	1527	4	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	1527	5	power	power	NN
18637	1527	6	,	,	,
18637	1527	7	always	always	RB
18637	1527	8	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1527	9	to	to	TO
18637	1527	10	be	be	VB
18637	1527	11	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	1527	12	by	by	IN
18637	1527	13	the	the	DT
18637	1527	14	House	House	NNP
18637	1527	15	,	,	,
18637	1527	16	and	and	CC
18637	1527	17	within	within	IN
18637	1527	18	the	the	DT
18637	1527	19	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	1527	20	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	1527	21	,	,	,
18637	1527	22	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	1527	23	and	and	CC
18637	1527	24	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	1527	25	the	the	DT
18637	1527	26	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	1527	27	of	of	IN
18637	1527	28	any	any	DT
18637	1527	29	other	other	JJ
18637	1527	30	body	body	NN
18637	1527	31	or	or	CC
18637	1527	32	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	1527	33	.	.	.
18637	1528	1	"	"	``
18637	1528	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1528	3	169	169	CD
18637	1528	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1528	5	Where	where	WRB
18637	1528	6	a	a	DT
18637	1528	7	rule	rule	NN
18637	1528	8	affects	affect	VBZ
18637	1528	9	private	private	JJ
18637	1528	10	rights	right	NNS
18637	1528	11	,	,	,
18637	1528	12	the	the	DT
18637	1528	13	construction	construction	NN
18637	1528	14	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	1528	15	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	1528	16	a	a	DT
18637	1528	17	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1528	18	question	question	NN
18637	1528	19	.	.	.
18637	1529	1	In	in	IN
18637	1529	2	United	United	NNP
18637	1529	3	States	States	NNP
18637	1529	4	_	_	NNP
18637	1529	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	1529	6	_	_	NNP
18637	1529	7	Smith,[170	Smith,[170	NNP
18637	1529	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1529	9	the	the	DT
18637	1529	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1529	11	held	hold	VBD
18637	1529	12	that	that	IN
18637	1529	13	the	the	DT
18637	1529	14	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1529	15	's	's	POS
18637	1529	16	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	1529	17	to	to	TO
18637	1529	18	reconsider	reconsider	VB
18637	1529	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1529	20	confirmation	confirmation	NN
18637	1529	21	of	of	IN
18637	1529	22	a	a	DT
18637	1529	23	person	person	NN
18637	1529	24	nominated	nominate	VBN
18637	1529	25	by	by	IN
18637	1529	26	the	the	DT
18637	1529	27	President	President	NNP
18637	1529	28	as	as	IN
18637	1529	29	Chairman	Chairman	NNP
18637	1529	30	of	of	IN
18637	1529	31	the	the	DT
18637	1529	32	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1529	33	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1529	34	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1529	35	was	be	VBD
18637	1529	36	not	not	RB
18637	1529	37	warranted	warrant	VBN
18637	1529	38	by	by	IN
18637	1529	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1529	40	rules	rule	NNS
18637	1529	41	,	,	,
18637	1529	42	and	and	CC
18637	1529	43	did	do	VBD
18637	1529	44	not	not	RB
18637	1529	45	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	1529	46	the	the	DT
18637	1529	47	appointee	appointee	NN
18637	1529	48	of	of	IN
18637	1529	49	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1529	50	title	title	NN
18637	1529	51	to	to	IN
18637	1529	52	the	the	DT
18637	1529	53	office	office	NN
18637	1529	54	.	.	.
18637	1530	1	In	in	IN
18637	1530	2	Christoffel	Christoffel	NNP
18637	1530	3	_	_	NNP
18637	1530	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	1530	5	_	_	NNP
18637	1530	6	United	United	NNP
18637	1530	7	States[171	States[171	NNP
18637	1530	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1530	9	a	a	DT
18637	1530	10	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	1530	11	divided	divide	VBN
18637	1530	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1530	13	upset	upset	VBD
18637	1530	14	a	a	DT
18637	1530	15	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	1530	16	for	for	IN
18637	1530	17	perjury	perjury	NN
18637	1530	18	in	in	IN
18637	1530	19	the	the	DT
18637	1530	20	district	district	NN
18637	1530	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	1530	22	of	of	IN
18637	1530	23	one	one	CD
18637	1530	24	who	who	WP
18637	1530	25	had	have	VBD
18637	1530	26	denied	deny	VBN
18637	1530	27	under	under	IN
18637	1530	28	oath	oath	NN
18637	1530	29	before	before	IN
18637	1530	30	a	a	DT
18637	1530	31	House	House	NNP
18637	1530	32	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	1530	33	any	any	DT
18637	1530	34	affiliation	affiliation	NN
18637	1530	35	with	with	IN
18637	1530	36	Communism	Communism	NNP
18637	1530	37	.	.	.
18637	1531	1	The	the	DT
18637	1531	2	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	1531	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1531	4	based	base	VBN
18637	1531	5	on	on	IN
18637	1531	6	the	the	DT
18637	1531	7	ground	ground	NN
18637	1531	8	that	that	WDT
18637	1531	9	inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	1531	10	as	as	IN
18637	1531	11	a	a	DT
18637	1531	12	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	1531	13	of	of	IN
18637	1531	14	the	the	DT
18637	1531	15	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	1531	16	,	,	,
18637	1531	17	while	while	IN
18637	1531	18	present	present	JJ
18637	1531	19	at	at	IN
18637	1531	20	the	the	DT
18637	1531	21	outset	outset	NN
18637	1531	22	,	,	,
18637	1531	23	was	be	VBD
18637	1531	24	not	not	RB
18637	1531	25	present	present	JJ
18637	1531	26	at	at	IN
18637	1531	27	the	the	DT
18637	1531	28	time	time	NN
18637	1531	29	of	of	IN
18637	1531	30	the	the	DT
18637	1531	31	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	1531	32	perjury	perjury	NN
18637	1531	33	,	,	,
18637	1531	34	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	1531	35	before	before	IN
18637	1531	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1531	37	was	be	VBD
18637	1531	38	not	not	RB
18637	1531	39	before	before	IN
18637	1531	40	a	a	DT
18637	1531	41	"	"	``
18637	1531	42	competent	competent	JJ
18637	1531	43	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	1531	44	"	"	''
18637	1531	45	within	within	IN
18637	1531	46	the	the	DT
18637	1531	47	sense	sense	NN
18637	1531	48	of	of	IN
18637	1531	49	the	the	DT
18637	1531	50	District	District	NNP
18637	1531	51	of	of	IN
18637	1531	52	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	1531	53	Code	Code	NNP
18637	1531	54	.	.	.
18637	1532	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1532	2	172	172	CD
18637	1532	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1532	4	Four	four	CD
18637	1532	5	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	1532	6	,	,	,
18637	1532	7	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	1532	8	by	by	IN
18637	1532	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1532	10	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	1532	11	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	1532	12	,	,	,
18637	1532	13	arguing	argue	VBG
18637	1532	14	that	that	IN
18637	1532	15	under	under	IN
18637	1532	16	the	the	DT
18637	1532	17	rules	rule	NNS
18637	1532	18	and	and	CC
18637	1532	19	practices	practice	NNS
18637	1532	20	of	of	IN
18637	1532	21	the	the	DT
18637	1532	22	House	House	NNP
18637	1532	23	,	,	,
18637	1532	24	"	"	''
18637	1532	25	a	a	DT
18637	1532	26	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	1532	27	once	once	RB
18637	1532	28	established	establish	VBN
18637	1532	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	1532	30	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	1532	31	to	to	TO
18637	1532	32	continue	continue	VB
18637	1532	33	unless	unless	IN
18637	1532	34	and	and	CC
18637	1532	35	until	until	IN
18637	1532	36	a	a	DT
18637	1532	37	point	point	NN
18637	1532	38	of	of	IN
18637	1532	39	no	no	DT
18637	1532	40	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	1532	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	1532	42	raised	raise	VBN
18637	1532	43	"	"	''
18637	1532	44	and	and	CC
18637	1532	45	that	that	IN
18637	1532	46	the	the	DT
18637	1532	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1532	48	was	be	VBD
18637	1532	49	,	,	,
18637	1532	50	in	in	IN
18637	1532	51	effect	effect	NN
18637	1532	52	,	,	,
18637	1532	53	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
18637	1532	54	this	this	DT
18637	1532	55	rule	rule	NN
18637	1532	56	,	,	,
18637	1532	57	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	1532	58	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
18637	1532	59	at	at	IN
18637	1532	60	the	the	DT
18637	1532	61	same	same	JJ
18637	1532	62	time	time	NN
18637	1532	63	the	the	DT
18637	1532	64	rule	rule	NN
18637	1532	65	of	of	IN
18637	1532	66	self	self	NN
18637	1532	67	-	-	HYPH
18637	1532	68	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	1532	69	observed	observe	VBN
18637	1532	70	by	by	IN
18637	1532	71	courts	court	NNS
18637	1532	72	"	"	''
18637	1532	73	where	where	WRB
18637	1532	74	such	such	PDT
18637	1532	75	an	an	DT
18637	1532	76	issue	issue	NN
18637	1532	77	is	be	VBZ
18637	1532	78	tendered	tender	VBN
18637	1532	79	.	.	.
18637	1533	1	"	"	``
18637	1533	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1533	3	173	173	CD
18637	1533	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1533	5	POWERS	power	NNS
18637	1533	6	OF	of	IN
18637	1533	7	THE	the	DT
18637	1533	8	HOUSES	house	NNS
18637	1533	9	OVER	OVER	NNP
18637	1533	10	MEMBERS	member	NNS
18637	1533	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1533	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	1533	13	authority	authority	NN
18637	1533	14	to	to	TO
18637	1533	15	make	make	VB
18637	1533	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1533	17	an	an	DT
18637	1533	18	offense	offense	NN
18637	1533	19	against	against	IN
18637	1533	20	the	the	DT
18637	1533	21	United	United	NNP
18637	1533	22	States	States	NNP
18637	1533	23	for	for	IN
18637	1533	24	a	a	DT
18637	1533	25	Member	Member	NNP
18637	1533	26	,	,	,
18637	1533	27	during	during	IN
18637	1533	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1533	29	continuance	continuance	NN
18637	1533	30	in	in	IN
18637	1533	31	office	office	NN
18637	1533	32	,	,	,
18637	1533	33	to	to	TO
18637	1533	34	receive	receive	VB
18637	1533	35	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	1533	36	for	for	IN
18637	1533	37	services	service	NNS
18637	1533	38	before	before	IN
18637	1533	39	a	a	DT
18637	1533	40	government	government	NN
18637	1533	41	department	department	NN
18637	1533	42	in	in	IN
18637	1533	43	relation	relation	NN
18637	1533	44	to	to	IN
18637	1533	45	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	1533	46	in	in	IN
18637	1533	47	which	which	WDT
18637	1533	48	the	the	DT
18637	1533	49	United	United	NNP
18637	1533	50	States	States	NNP
18637	1533	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	1533	52	interested	interested	JJ
18637	1533	53	.	.	.
18637	1534	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	1534	2	a	a	DT
18637	1534	3	statute	statute	NN
18637	1534	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	1534	5	not	not	RB
18637	1534	6	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	1534	7	with	with	IN
18637	1534	8	the	the	DT
18637	1534	9	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	1534	10	authority	authority	NN
18637	1534	11	of	of	IN
18637	1534	12	the	the	DT
18637	1534	13	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1534	14	or	or	CC
18637	1534	15	House	House	NNP
18637	1534	16	over	over	IN
18637	1534	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1534	18	own	own	JJ
18637	1534	19	Members	member	NNS
18637	1534	20	.	.	.
18637	1535	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1535	2	174	174	CD
18637	1535	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1535	4	In	in	IN
18637	1535	5	upholding	uphold	VBG
18637	1535	6	the	the	DT
18637	1535	7	power	power	NN
18637	1535	8	of	of	IN
18637	1535	9	the	the	DT
18637	1535	10	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1535	11	to	to	TO
18637	1535	12	investigate	investigate	VB
18637	1535	13	charges	charge	NNS
18637	1535	14	that	that	IN
18637	1535	15	some	some	DT
18637	1535	16	Senators	senator	NNS
18637	1535	17	had	have	VBD
18637	1535	18	been	be	VBN
18637	1535	19	speculating	speculate	VBG
18637	1535	20	in	in	IN
18637	1535	21	sugar	sugar	NN
18637	1535	22	stocks	stock	NNS
18637	1535	23	during	during	IN
18637	1535	24	the	the	DT
18637	1535	25	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	1535	26	of	of	IN
18637	1535	27	a	a	DT
18637	1535	28	tariff	tariff	NN
18637	1535	29	bill	bill	NN
18637	1535	30	,	,	,
18637	1535	31	the	the	DT
18637	1535	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1535	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1535	34	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	1535	35	that	that	IN
18637	1535	36	"	"	``
18637	1535	37	the	the	DT
18637	1535	38	right	right	NN
18637	1535	39	to	to	TO
18637	1535	40	expel	expel	VB
18637	1535	41	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	1535	42	to	to	IN
18637	1535	43	all	all	DT
18637	1535	44	cases	case	NNS
18637	1535	45	where	where	WRB
18637	1535	46	the	the	DT
18637	1535	47	offence	offence	NN
18637	1535	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	1535	49	such	such	JJ
18637	1535	50	as	as	IN
18637	1535	51	in	in	IN
18637	1535	52	the	the	DT
18637	1535	53	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	1535	54	of	of	IN
18637	1535	55	the	the	DT
18637	1535	56	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1535	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	1535	58	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	1535	59	with	with	IN
18637	1535	60	the	the	DT
18637	1535	61	trust	trust	NN
18637	1535	62	and	and	CC
18637	1535	63	duty	duty	NN
18637	1535	64	of	of	IN
18637	1535	65	a	a	DT
18637	1535	66	Member	Member	NNP
18637	1535	67	.	.	.
18637	1536	1	"	"	``
18637	1536	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1536	3	175	175	CD
18637	1536	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1536	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1536	6	cited	cite	VBD
18637	1536	7	with	with	IN
18637	1536	8	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	1536	9	approval	approval	NN
18637	1536	10	the	the	DT
18637	1536	11	action	action	NN
18637	1536	12	of	of	IN
18637	1536	13	the	the	DT
18637	1536	14	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1536	15	in	in	IN
18637	1536	16	expelling	expel	VBG
18637	1536	17	William	William	NNP
18637	1536	18	Blount	Blount	NNP
18637	1536	19	in	in	IN
18637	1536	20	1797	1797	CD
18637	1536	21	for	for	IN
18637	1536	22	attempting	attempt	VBG
18637	1536	23	to	to	TO
18637	1536	24	seduce	seduce	VB
18637	1536	25	an	an	DT
18637	1536	26	American	american	JJ
18637	1536	27	agent	agent	NN
18637	1536	28	among	among	IN
18637	1536	29	the	the	DT
18637	1536	30	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	1536	31	from	from	IN
18637	1536	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1536	33	duty	duty	NN
18637	1536	34	and	and	CC
18637	1536	35	for	for	IN
18637	1536	36	negotiating	negotiate	VBG
18637	1536	37	for	for	IN
18637	1536	38	services	service	NNS
18637	1536	39	in	in	IN
18637	1536	40	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	1536	41	of	of	IN
18637	1536	42	the	the	DT
18637	1536	43	British	british	JJ
18637	1536	44	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1536	45	among	among	IN
18637	1536	46	the	the	DT
18637	1536	47	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	1536	48	--	--	:
18637	1536	49	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	1536	50	which	which	WDT
18637	1536	51	was	be	VBD
18637	1536	52	not	not	RB
18637	1536	53	a	a	DT
18637	1536	54	"	"	``
18637	1536	55	statutable	statutable	JJ
18637	1536	56	offense	offense	NN
18637	1536	57	"	"	''
18637	1536	58	and	and	CC
18637	1536	59	which	which	WDT
18637	1536	60	was	be	VBD
18637	1536	61	not	not	RB
18637	1536	62	committed	commit	VBN
18637	1536	63	in	in	IN
18637	1536	64	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1536	65	official	official	JJ
18637	1536	66	character	character	NN
18637	1536	67	,	,	,
18637	1536	68	nor	nor	CC
18637	1536	69	during	during	IN
18637	1536	70	the	the	DT
18637	1536	71	session	session	NN
18637	1536	72	of	of	IN
18637	1536	73	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1536	74	nor	nor	CC
18637	1536	75	at	at	IN
18637	1536	76	the	the	DT
18637	1536	77	seat	seat	NN
18637	1536	78	of	of	IN
18637	1536	79	government	government	NN
18637	1536	80	.	.	.
18637	1537	1	THE	the	DT
18637	1537	2	DUTY	DUTY	NNS
18637	1537	3	TO	to	TO
18637	1537	4	KEEP	keep	VB
18637	1537	5	A	a	DT
18637	1537	6	JOURNAL	journal	NN
18637	1537	7	The	the	DT
18637	1537	8	object	object	NN
18637	1537	9	of	of	IN
18637	1537	10	the	the	DT
18637	1537	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	1537	12	requiring	require	VBG
18637	1537	13	the	the	DT
18637	1537	14	keeping	keeping	NN
18637	1537	15	of	of	IN
18637	1537	16	a	a	DT
18637	1537	17	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	1537	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	1537	19	"	"	``
18637	1537	20	to	to	TO
18637	1537	21	insure	insure	VB
18637	1537	22	publicity	publicity	NN
18637	1537	23	to	to	IN
18637	1537	24	the	the	DT
18637	1537	25	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	1537	26	of	of	IN
18637	1537	27	the	the	DT
18637	1537	28	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1537	29	,	,	,
18637	1537	30	and	and	CC
18637	1537	31	a	a	DT
18637	1537	32	correspondent	correspondent	NN
18637	1537	33	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	1537	34	of	of	IN
18637	1537	35	the	the	DT
18637	1537	36	members	member	NNS
18637	1537	37	to	to	IN
18637	1537	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1537	39	respective	respective	JJ
18637	1537	40	constituents	constituent	NNS
18637	1537	41	.	.	.
18637	1538	1	"	"	``
18637	1538	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1538	3	176	176	CD
18637	1538	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1538	5	When	when	WRB
18637	1538	6	the	the	DT
18637	1538	7	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	1538	8	of	of	IN
18637	1538	9	either	either	CC
18637	1538	10	House	House	NNP
18637	1538	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	1538	12	put	put	VBN
18637	1538	13	in	in	IN
18637	1538	14	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	1538	15	for	for	IN
18637	1538	16	the	the	DT
18637	1538	17	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1538	18	of	of	IN
18637	1538	19	determining	determine	VBG
18637	1538	20	whether	whether	IN
18637	1538	21	the	the	DT
18637	1538	22	yeas	yea	NNS
18637	1538	23	and	and	CC
18637	1538	24	nays	nay	NNS
18637	1538	25	,	,	,
18637	1538	26	were	be	VBD
18637	1538	27	ordered	order	VBN
18637	1538	28	,	,	,
18637	1538	29	and	and	CC
18637	1538	30	what	what	WP
18637	1538	31	the	the	DT
18637	1538	32	vote	vote	NN
18637	1538	33	was	be	VBD
18637	1538	34	on	on	IN
18637	1538	35	any	any	DT
18637	1538	36	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1538	37	question	question	NN
18637	1538	38	,	,	,
18637	1538	39	the	the	DT
18637	1538	40	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	1538	41	must	must	MD
18637	1538	42	be	be	VB
18637	1538	43	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	1538	44	to	to	TO
18637	1538	45	show	show	VB
18637	1538	46	the	the	DT
18637	1538	47	truth	truth	NN
18637	1538	48	,	,	,
18637	1538	49	and	and	CC
18637	1538	50	a	a	DT
18637	1538	51	statement	statement	NN
18637	1538	52	therein	therein	RB
18637	1538	53	that	that	IN
18637	1538	54	a	a	DT
18637	1538	55	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	1538	56	was	be	VBD
18637	1538	57	present	present	JJ
18637	1538	58	,	,	,
18637	1538	59	though	though	IN
18637	1538	60	not	not	RB
18637	1538	61	disclosed	disclose	VBN
18637	1538	62	by	by	IN
18637	1538	63	the	the	DT
18637	1538	64	yeas	yea	NNS
18637	1538	65	and	and	CC
18637	1538	66	nays	nay	NNS
18637	1538	67	,	,	,
18637	1538	68	is	be	VBZ
18637	1538	69	final	final	JJ
18637	1538	70	.	.	.
18637	1539	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1539	2	177	177	CD
18637	1539	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1539	4	But	but	CC
18637	1539	5	when	when	WRB
18637	1539	6	an	an	DT
18637	1539	7	enrolled	enrol	VBN
18637	1539	8	bill	bill	NN
18637	1539	9	,	,	,
18637	1539	10	which	which	WDT
18637	1539	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	1539	12	been	be	VBN
18637	1539	13	signed	sign	VBN
18637	1539	14	by	by	IN
18637	1539	15	the	the	DT
18637	1539	16	Speaker	Speaker	NNP
18637	1539	17	of	of	IN
18637	1539	18	the	the	DT
18637	1539	19	House	House	NNP
18637	1539	20	and	and	CC
18637	1539	21	by	by	IN
18637	1539	22	the	the	DT
18637	1539	23	President	President	NNP
18637	1539	24	of	of	IN
18637	1539	25	the	the	DT
18637	1539	26	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1539	27	,	,	,
18637	1539	28	in	in	IN
18637	1539	29	open	open	JJ
18637	1539	30	session	session	NN
18637	1539	31	,	,	,
18637	1539	32	receives	receive	VBZ
18637	1539	33	the	the	DT
18637	1539	34	approval	approval	NN
18637	1539	35	of	of	IN
18637	1539	36	the	the	DT
18637	1539	37	President	President	NNP
18637	1539	38	and	and	CC
18637	1539	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	1539	40	deposited	deposit	VBN
18637	1539	41	in	in	IN
18637	1539	42	the	the	DT
18637	1539	43	Department	Department	NNP
18637	1539	44	of	of	IN
18637	1539	45	State	State	NNP
18637	1539	46	,	,	,
18637	1539	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1539	48	authentication	authentication	NN
18637	1539	49	as	as	IN
18637	1539	50	a	a	DT
18637	1539	51	bill	bill	NN
18637	1539	52	that	that	WDT
18637	1539	53	has	have	VBZ
18637	1539	54	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1539	55	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1539	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	1539	57	complete	complete	JJ
18637	1539	58	and	and	CC
18637	1539	59	unimpeachable	unimpeachable	JJ
18637	1539	60	,	,	,
18637	1539	61	and	and	CC
18637	1539	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1539	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	1539	64	not	not	RB
18637	1539	65	competent	competent	JJ
18637	1539	66	to	to	TO
18637	1539	67	show	show	VB
18637	1539	68	from	from	IN
18637	1539	69	the	the	DT
18637	1539	70	Journals	Journals	NNPS
18637	1539	71	of	of	IN
18637	1539	72	either	either	CC
18637	1539	73	House	House	NNP
18637	1539	74	that	that	WDT
18637	1539	75	an	an	DT
18637	1539	76	act	act	NN
18637	1539	77	so	so	RB
18637	1539	78	authenticated	authenticate	VBN
18637	1539	79	,	,	,
18637	1539	80	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1539	81	,	,	,
18637	1539	82	and	and	CC
18637	1539	83	deposited	deposit	VBN
18637	1539	84	,	,	,
18637	1539	85	in	in	IN
18637	1539	86	fact	fact	NN
18637	1539	87	omitted	omit	VBD
18637	1539	88	one	one	CD
18637	1539	89	section	section	NN
18637	1539	90	actually	actually	RB
18637	1539	91	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1539	92	by	by	IN
18637	1539	93	both	both	DT
18637	1539	94	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	1539	95	of	of	IN
18637	1539	96	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1539	97	.	.	.
18637	1540	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1540	2	178	178	CD
18637	1540	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1540	4	Section	section	NN
18637	1540	5	6	6	CD
18637	1540	6	.	.	.
18637	1541	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1541	2	1	1	CD
18637	1541	3	.	.	.
18637	1542	1	The	the	DT
18637	1542	2	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	1542	3	and	and	CC
18637	1542	4	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1542	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	1542	6	receive	receive	VB
18637	1542	7	a	a	DT
18637	1542	8	Compensation	compensation	NN
18637	1542	9	for	for	IN
18637	1542	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1542	11	Services	service	NNS
18637	1542	12	,	,	,
18637	1542	13	to	to	TO
18637	1542	14	be	be	VB
18637	1542	15	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	1542	16	by	by	IN
18637	1542	17	Law	Law	NNP
18637	1542	18	,	,	,
18637	1542	19	and	and	CC
18637	1542	20	paid	pay	VBD
18637	1542	21	out	out	IN
18637	1542	22	of	of	IN
18637	1542	23	the	the	DT
18637	1542	24	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	1542	25	of	of	IN
18637	1542	26	the	the	DT
18637	1542	27	United	United	NNP
18637	1542	28	States	States	NNP
18637	1542	29	.	.	.
18637	1543	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1543	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	1543	3	in	in	IN
18637	1543	4	all	all	DT
18637	1543	5	Cases	case	NNS
18637	1543	6	,	,	,
18637	1543	7	except	except	IN
18637	1543	8	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	1543	9	,	,	,
18637	1543	10	Felony	Felony	NNP
18637	1543	11	and	and	CC
18637	1543	12	Breach	Breach	NNP
18637	1543	13	of	of	IN
18637	1543	14	the	the	DT
18637	1543	15	Peace	Peace	NNP
18637	1543	16	,	,	,
18637	1543	17	be	be	VB
18637	1543	18	privileged	privileged	JJ
18637	1543	19	from	from	IN
18637	1543	20	Arrest	arrest	NN
18637	1543	21	during	during	IN
18637	1543	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1543	23	Attendance	attendance	NN
18637	1543	24	at	at	IN
18637	1543	25	the	the	DT
18637	1543	26	Session	session	NN
18637	1543	27	of	of	IN
18637	1543	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1543	29	respective	respective	JJ
18637	1543	30	Houses	house	NNS
18637	1543	31	,	,	,
18637	1543	32	and	and	CC
18637	1543	33	in	in	IN
18637	1543	34	going	go	VBG
18637	1543	35	to	to	IN
18637	1543	36	and	and	CC
18637	1543	37	returning	return	VBG
18637	1543	38	from	from	IN
18637	1543	39	the	the	DT
18637	1543	40	same	same	JJ
18637	1543	41	;	;	:
18637	1543	42	and	and	CC
18637	1543	43	for	for	IN
18637	1543	44	any	any	DT
18637	1543	45	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	1543	46	or	or	CC
18637	1543	47	Debate	Debate	NNP
18637	1543	48	in	in	IN
18637	1543	49	either	either	CC
18637	1543	50	House	House	NNP
18637	1543	51	,	,	,
18637	1543	52	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1543	53	shall	shall	MD
18637	1543	54	not	not	RB
18637	1543	55	be	be	VB
18637	1543	56	questioned	question	VBN
18637	1543	57	in	in	IN
18637	1543	58	any	any	DT
18637	1543	59	other	other	JJ
18637	1543	60	Place	Place	NNP
18637	1543	61	.	.	.
18637	1544	1	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	1544	2	,	,	,
18637	1544	3	Immunities	Immunities	NNPS
18637	1544	4	and	and	CC
18637	1544	5	Disabilities	Disabilities	NNPS
18637	1544	6	of	of	IN
18637	1544	7	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	1544	8	WHEN	when	WRB
18637	1544	9	THE	the	DT
18637	1544	10	PAY	pay	NN
18637	1544	11	STARTS	STARTS	NNP
18637	1544	12	A	a	DT
18637	1544	13	Member	Member	NNP
18637	1544	14	of	of	IN
18637	1544	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1544	16	who	who	WP
18637	1544	17	receives	receive	VBZ
18637	1544	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1544	19	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	1544	20	of	of	IN
18637	1544	21	admission	admission	NN
18637	1544	22	,	,	,
18637	1544	23	and	and	CC
18637	1544	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	1544	25	seated	seat	VBN
18637	1544	26	,	,	,
18637	1544	27	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	1544	28	to	to	TO
18637	1544	29	vote	vote	VB
18637	1544	30	,	,	,
18637	1544	31	and	and	CC
18637	1544	32	serve	serve	VB
18637	1544	33	on	on	IN
18637	1544	34	committees	committee	NNS
18637	1544	35	,	,	,
18637	1544	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	1544	37	_	_	NNP
18637	1544	38	prima	prima	NN
18637	1544	39	facie	facie	NNP
18637	1544	40	_	_	NNP
18637	1544	41	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	1544	42	to	to	IN
18637	1544	43	the	the	DT
18637	1544	44	seat	seat	NN
18637	1544	45	and	and	CC
18637	1544	46	salary	salary	NN
18637	1544	47	,	,	,
18637	1544	48	even	even	RB
18637	1544	49	though	though	IN
18637	1544	50	the	the	DT
18637	1544	51	House	House	NNP
18637	1544	52	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	1544	53	declares	declare	VBZ
18637	1544	54	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1544	55	seat	seat	NN
18637	1544	56	vacant	vacant	JJ
18637	1544	57	.	.	.
18637	1545	1	The	the	DT
18637	1545	2	one	one	NN
18637	1545	3	who	who	WP
18637	1545	4	contested	contest	VBD
18637	1545	5	the	the	DT
18637	1545	6	election	election	NN
18637	1545	7	and	and	CC
18637	1545	8	was	be	VBD
18637	1545	9	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	1545	10	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	1545	11	to	to	TO
18637	1545	12	fill	fill	VB
18637	1545	13	the	the	DT
18637	1545	14	vacancy	vacancy	NN
18637	1545	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	1545	16	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	1545	17	to	to	IN
18637	1545	18	salary	salary	VB
18637	1545	19	only	only	RB
18637	1545	20	from	from	IN
18637	1545	21	the	the	DT
18637	1545	22	time	time	NN
18637	1545	23	the	the	DT
18637	1545	24	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	1545	25	of	of	IN
18637	1545	26	such	such	JJ
18637	1545	27	"	"	``
18637	1545	28	predecessor	predecessor	NN
18637	1545	29	"	"	''
18637	1545	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	1545	31	ceased	cease	VBN
18637	1545	32	.	.	.
18637	1546	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1546	2	179	179	CD
18637	1546	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1546	4	PRIVILEGE	privilege	NN
18637	1546	5	FROM	from	IN
18637	1546	6	ARREST	ARREST	NNP
18637	1546	7	This	this	DT
18637	1546	8	clause	clause	NN
18637	1546	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	1546	10	practically	practically	RB
18637	1546	11	obsolete	obsolete	JJ
18637	1546	12	.	.	.
18637	1547	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1547	2	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	1547	3	only	only	RB
18637	1547	4	to	to	IN
18637	1547	5	arrests	arrest	NNS
18637	1547	6	in	in	IN
18637	1547	7	civil	civil	JJ
18637	1547	8	suits	suit	NNS
18637	1547	9	,	,	,
18637	1547	10	which	which	WDT
18637	1547	11	were	be	VBD
18637	1547	12	still	still	RB
18637	1547	13	common	common	JJ
18637	1547	14	in	in	IN
18637	1547	15	this	this	DT
18637	1547	16	country	country	NN
18637	1547	17	at	at	IN
18637	1547	18	the	the	DT
18637	1547	19	time	time	NN
18637	1547	20	the	the	DT
18637	1547	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1547	22	was	be	VBD
18637	1547	23	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	1547	24	.	.	.
18637	1548	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1548	2	180	180	CD
18637	1548	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1548	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1548	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	1548	6	not	not	RB
18637	1548	7	apply	apply	VB
18637	1548	8	to	to	IN
18637	1548	9	service	service	NN
18637	1548	10	of	of	IN
18637	1548	11	process	process	NN
18637	1548	12	in	in	IN
18637	1548	13	either	either	DT
18637	1548	14	civil[181	civil[181	NN
18637	1548	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1548	16	or	or	CC
18637	1548	17	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	1548	18	cases	case	NNS
18637	1548	19	.	.	.
18637	1549	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1549	2	182	182	CD
18637	1549	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1549	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	1549	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	1549	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1549	7	apply	apply	VB
18637	1549	8	to	to	TO
18637	1549	9	arrest	arrest	VB
18637	1549	10	in	in	IN
18637	1549	11	any	any	DT
18637	1549	12	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	1549	13	case	case	NN
18637	1549	14	.	.	.
18637	1550	1	The	the	DT
18637	1550	2	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	1550	3	"	"	``
18637	1550	4	treason	treason	NN
18637	1550	5	,	,	,
18637	1550	6	felony	felony	NN
18637	1550	7	or	or	CC
18637	1550	8	breach	breach	NN
18637	1550	9	of	of	IN
18637	1550	10	the	the	DT
18637	1550	11	peace	peace	NN
18637	1550	12	"	"	''
18637	1550	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	1550	14	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	1550	15	to	to	TO
18637	1550	16	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	1550	17	all	all	DT
18637	1550	18	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	1550	19	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	1550	20	from	from	IN
18637	1550	21	the	the	DT
18637	1550	22	operation	operation	NN
18637	1550	23	of	of	IN
18637	1550	24	the	the	DT
18637	1550	25	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	1550	26	.	.	.
18637	1551	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1551	2	183	183	CD
18637	1551	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1551	4	THE	the	DT
18637	1551	5	PRIVILEGE	PRIVILEGE	NNP
18637	1551	6	OF	of	IN
18637	1551	7	SPEECH	speech	NN
18637	1551	8	OR	or	CC
18637	1551	9	DEBATE	debate	NN
18637	1551	10	The	the	DT
18637	1551	11	protection	protection	NN
18637	1551	12	of	of	IN
18637	1551	13	this	this	DT
18637	1551	14	clause	clause	NN
18637	1551	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	1551	16	not	not	RB
18637	1551	17	limited	limit	VBN
18637	1551	18	to	to	IN
18637	1551	19	words	word	NNS
18637	1551	20	spoken	speak	VBN
18637	1551	21	in	in	IN
18637	1551	22	debate	debate	NN
18637	1551	23	,	,	,
18637	1551	24	but	but	CC
18637	1551	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	1551	26	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	1551	27	to	to	IN
18637	1551	28	written	write	VBN
18637	1551	29	reports	report	NNS
18637	1551	30	,	,	,
18637	1551	31	to	to	IN
18637	1551	32	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	1551	33	offered	offer	VBN
18637	1551	34	,	,	,
18637	1551	35	to	to	IN
18637	1551	36	the	the	DT
18637	1551	37	act	act	NN
18637	1551	38	of	of	IN
18637	1551	39	voting	voting	NN
18637	1551	40	and	and	CC
18637	1551	41	to	to	IN
18637	1551	42	all	all	DT
18637	1551	43	things	thing	NNS
18637	1551	44	generally	generally	RB
18637	1551	45	done	do	VBN
18637	1551	46	in	in	IN
18637	1551	47	a	a	DT
18637	1551	48	session	session	NN
18637	1551	49	of	of	IN
18637	1551	50	the	the	DT
18637	1551	51	House	House	NNP
18637	1551	52	by	by	IN
18637	1551	53	one	one	CD
18637	1551	54	of	of	IN
18637	1551	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1551	56	members	member	NNS
18637	1551	57	in	in	IN
18637	1551	58	relation	relation	NN
18637	1551	59	to	to	IN
18637	1551	60	the	the	DT
18637	1551	61	business	business	NN
18637	1551	62	before	before	IN
18637	1551	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1551	64	.	.	.
18637	1552	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1552	2	184	184	CD
18637	1552	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1552	4	In	in	IN
18637	1552	5	Kilbourn	Kilbourn	NNP
18637	1552	6	_	_	NNP
18637	1552	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	1552	8	_	_	NNP
18637	1552	9	Thompson[185	Thompson[185	NNP
18637	1552	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1552	11	the	the	DT
18637	1552	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1552	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1552	14	quoted	quote	VBD
18637	1552	15	with	with	IN
18637	1552	16	approval	approval	NN
18637	1552	17	the	the	DT
18637	1552	18	following	follow	VBG
18637	1552	19	excerpt	excerpt	NN
18637	1552	20	from	from	IN
18637	1552	21	the	the	DT
18637	1552	22	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1552	23	of	of	IN
18637	1552	24	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1552	25	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1552	26	Parsons	Parsons	NNP
18637	1552	27	in	in	IN
18637	1552	28	the	the	DT
18637	1552	29	early	early	JJ
18637	1552	30	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	1552	31	of	of	IN
18637	1552	32	Coffin	Coffin	NNP
18637	1552	33	_	_	NNP
18637	1552	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	1552	35	_	_	NNP
18637	1552	36	Coffin,[186	Coffin,[186	NNP
18637	1552	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1552	38	giving	give	VBG
18637	1552	39	a	a	DT
18637	1552	40	broad	broad	JJ
18637	1552	41	scope	scope	NN
18637	1552	42	to	to	IN
18637	1552	43	the	the	DT
18637	1552	44	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	1552	45	of	of	IN
18637	1552	46	legislators	legislator	NNS
18637	1552	47	:	:	:
18637	1552	48	"	"	``
18637	1552	49	'	'	``
18637	1552	50	These	these	DT
18637	1552	51	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	1552	52	are	be	VBP
18637	1552	53	thus	thus	RB
18637	1552	54	secured	secure	VBN
18637	1552	55	,	,	,
18637	1552	56	not	not	RB
18637	1552	57	with	with	IN
18637	1552	58	the	the	DT
18637	1552	59	intention	intention	NN
18637	1552	60	of	of	IN
18637	1552	61	protecting	protect	VBG
18637	1552	62	the	the	DT
18637	1552	63	members	member	NNS
18637	1552	64	against	against	IN
18637	1552	65	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	1552	66	for	for	IN
18637	1552	67	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1552	68	own	own	JJ
18637	1552	69	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	1552	70	,	,	,
18637	1552	71	but	but	CC
18637	1552	72	to	to	TO
18637	1552	73	support	support	VB
18637	1552	74	the	the	DT
18637	1552	75	rights	right	NNS
18637	1552	76	of	of	IN
18637	1552	77	the	the	DT
18637	1552	78	people	people	NNS
18637	1552	79	,	,	,
18637	1552	80	by	by	IN
18637	1552	81	enabling	enable	VBG
18637	1552	82	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1552	83	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	1552	84	to	to	TO
18637	1552	85	execute	execute	VB
18637	1552	86	the	the	DT
18637	1552	87	functions	function	NNS
18637	1552	88	of	of	IN
18637	1552	89	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1552	90	office	office	NN
18637	1552	91	without	without	IN
18637	1552	92	fear	fear	NN
18637	1552	93	of	of	IN
18637	1552	94	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	1552	95	,	,	,
18637	1552	96	civil	civil	JJ
18637	1552	97	or	or	CC
18637	1552	98	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	1552	99	.	.	.
18637	1553	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1553	2	,	,	,
18637	1553	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	1553	4	,	,	,
18637	1553	5	think	think	VBP
18637	1553	6	that	that	IN
18637	1553	7	the	the	DT
18637	1553	8	article	article	NN
18637	1553	9	ought	ought	MD
18637	1553	10	not	not	RB
18637	1553	11	to	to	TO
18637	1553	12	be	be	VB
18637	1553	13	construed	construe	VBN
18637	1553	14	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	1553	15	,	,	,
18637	1553	16	but	but	CC
18637	1553	17	liberally	liberally	RB
18637	1553	18	,	,	,
18637	1553	19	that	that	IN
18637	1553	20	the	the	DT
18637	1553	21	full	full	JJ
18637	1553	22	design	design	NN
18637	1553	23	of	of	IN
18637	1553	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1553	25	may	may	MD
18637	1553	26	be	be	VB
18637	1553	27	answered	answer	VBN
18637	1553	28	.	.	.
18637	1554	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1554	2	will	will	MD
18637	1554	3	not	not	RB
18637	1554	4	confine	confine	VB
18637	1554	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1554	6	to	to	IN
18637	1554	7	delivering	deliver	VBG
18637	1554	8	an	an	DT
18637	1554	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1554	10	,	,	,
18637	1554	11	uttering	utter	VBG
18637	1554	12	a	a	DT
18637	1554	13	speech	speech	NN
18637	1554	14	,	,	,
18637	1554	15	or	or	CC
18637	1554	16	haranguing	harangue	VBG
18637	1554	17	in	in	IN
18637	1554	18	debate	debate	NN
18637	1554	19	,	,	,
18637	1554	20	but	but	CC
18637	1554	21	will	will	MD
18637	1554	22	extend	extend	VB
18637	1554	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1554	24	to	to	IN
18637	1554	25	the	the	DT
18637	1554	26	giving	giving	NN
18637	1554	27	of	of	IN
18637	1554	28	a	a	DT
18637	1554	29	vote	vote	NN
18637	1554	30	,	,	,
18637	1554	31	to	to	IN
18637	1554	32	the	the	DT
18637	1554	33	making	making	NN
18637	1554	34	of	of	IN
18637	1554	35	a	a	DT
18637	1554	36	written	write	VBN
18637	1554	37	report	report	NN
18637	1554	38	,	,	,
18637	1554	39	and	and	CC
18637	1554	40	to	to	IN
18637	1554	41	every	every	DT
18637	1554	42	other	other	JJ
18637	1554	43	act	act	NN
18637	1554	44	resulting	result	VBG
18637	1554	45	from	from	IN
18637	1554	46	the	the	DT
18637	1554	47	nature	nature	NN
18637	1554	48	and	and	CC
18637	1554	49	in	in	IN
18637	1554	50	the	the	DT
18637	1554	51	execution	execution	NN
18637	1554	52	of	of	IN
18637	1554	53	the	the	DT
18637	1554	54	office	office	NN
18637	1554	55	.	.	.
18637	1555	1	And	and	CC
18637	1555	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1555	3	would	would	MD
18637	1555	4	define	define	VB
18637	1555	5	the	the	DT
18637	1555	6	article	article	NN
18637	1555	7	as	as	IN
18637	1555	8	securing	secure	VBG
18637	1555	9	to	to	IN
18637	1555	10	every	every	DT
18637	1555	11	member	member	NN
18637	1555	12	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	1555	13	from	from	IN
18637	1555	14	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	1555	15	for	for	IN
18637	1555	16	everything	everything	NN
18637	1555	17	said	say	VBD
18637	1555	18	or	or	CC
18637	1555	19	done	do	VBN
18637	1555	20	by	by	IN
18637	1555	21	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1555	22	as	as	IN
18637	1555	23	a	a	DT
18637	1555	24	representative	representative	NN
18637	1555	25	,	,	,
18637	1555	26	in	in	IN
18637	1555	27	the	the	DT
18637	1555	28	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1555	29	of	of	IN
18637	1555	30	the	the	DT
18637	1555	31	functions	function	NNS
18637	1555	32	of	of	IN
18637	1555	33	that	that	DT
18637	1555	34	office	office	NN
18637	1555	35	,	,	,
18637	1555	36	without	without	IN
18637	1555	37	inquiring	inquire	VBG
18637	1555	38	whether	whether	IN
18637	1555	39	the	the	DT
18637	1555	40	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1555	41	was	be	VBD
18637	1555	42	regular	regular	JJ
18637	1555	43	,	,	,
18637	1555	44	according	accord	VBG
18637	1555	45	to	to	IN
18637	1555	46	the	the	DT
18637	1555	47	rules	rule	NNS
18637	1555	48	of	of	IN
18637	1555	49	the	the	DT
18637	1555	50	House	House	NNP
18637	1555	51	,	,	,
18637	1555	52	or	or	CC
18637	1555	53	irregular	irregular	JJ
18637	1555	54	and	and	CC
18637	1555	55	against	against	IN
18637	1555	56	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1555	57	rules	rule	NNS
18637	1555	58	.	.	.
18637	1556	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1556	2	do	do	VBP
18637	1556	3	not	not	RB
18637	1556	4	confine	confine	VB
18637	1556	5	the	the	DT
18637	1556	6	member	member	NN
18637	1556	7	to	to	IN
18637	1556	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1556	9	place	place	NN
18637	1556	10	in	in	IN
18637	1556	11	the	the	DT
18637	1556	12	House	House	NNP
18637	1556	13	;	;	:
18637	1556	14	and	and	CC
18637	1556	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1556	16	am	be	VBP
18637	1556	17	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	1556	18	that	that	IN
18637	1556	19	there	there	EX
18637	1556	20	are	be	VBP
18637	1556	21	cases	case	NNS
18637	1556	22	in	in	IN
18637	1556	23	which	which	WDT
18637	1556	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1556	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	1556	26	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	1556	27	to	to	IN
18637	1556	28	this	this	DT
18637	1556	29	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	1556	30	when	when	WRB
18637	1556	31	not	not	RB
18637	1556	32	within	within	IN
18637	1556	33	the	the	DT
18637	1556	34	walls	wall	NNS
18637	1556	35	of	of	IN
18637	1556	36	the	the	DT
18637	1556	37	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	1556	38	'	'	POS
18637	1556	39	chamber	chamber	NN
18637	1556	40	.	.	.
18637	1557	1	'	'	``
18637	1557	2	"	"	``
18637	1557	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1557	4	187	187	CD
18637	1557	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1557	6	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	1557	7	the	the	DT
18637	1557	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1557	9	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	1557	10	that	that	IN
18637	1557	11	Members	member	NNS
18637	1557	12	of	of	IN
18637	1557	13	the	the	DT
18637	1557	14	House	House	NNP
18637	1557	15	of	of	IN
18637	1557	16	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1557	17	were	be	VBD
18637	1557	18	not	not	RB
18637	1557	19	liable	liable	JJ
18637	1557	20	to	to	IN
18637	1557	21	a	a	DT
18637	1557	22	suit	suit	NN
18637	1557	23	for	for	IN
18637	1557	24	false	false	JJ
18637	1557	25	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	1557	26	by	by	IN
18637	1557	27	reason	reason	NN
18637	1557	28	of	of	IN
18637	1557	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1557	30	initiation	initiation	NN
18637	1557	31	and	and	CC
18637	1557	32	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	1557	33	of	of	IN
18637	1557	34	the	the	DT
18637	1557	35	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1557	36	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	1557	37	under	under	IN
18637	1557	38	which	which	WDT
18637	1557	39	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	1557	40	was	be	VBD
18637	1557	41	arrested	arrest	VBN
18637	1557	42	.	.	.
18637	1558	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1558	2	188	188	CD
18637	1558	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1558	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	1558	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	1558	6	the	the	DT
18637	1558	7	claim	claim	NN
18637	1558	8	of	of	IN
18637	1558	9	an	an	DT
18637	1558	10	unworthy	unworthy	JJ
18637	1558	11	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1558	12	destroy	destroy	VBP
18637	1558	13	the	the	DT
18637	1558	14	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	1558	15	.	.	.
18637	1559	1	"	"	``
18637	1559	2	Legislators	legislator	NNS
18637	1559	3	are	be	VBP
18637	1559	4	immune	immune	JJ
18637	1559	5	from	from	IN
18637	1559	6	deterrents	deterrent	NNS
18637	1559	7	to	to	IN
18637	1559	8	the	the	DT
18637	1559	9	uninhibited	uninhibited	JJ
18637	1559	10	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	1559	11	of	of	IN
18637	1559	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1559	13	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1559	14	duty	duty	NN
18637	1559	15	,	,	,
18637	1559	16	not	not	RB
18637	1559	17	for	for	IN
18637	1559	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1559	19	private	private	JJ
18637	1559	20	indulgence	indulgence	NN
18637	1559	21	but	but	CC
18637	1559	22	for	for	IN
18637	1559	23	the	the	DT
18637	1559	24	public	public	JJ
18637	1559	25	good	good	NN
18637	1559	26	.	.	.
18637	1560	1	One	one	PRP
18637	1560	2	must	must	MD
18637	1560	3	not	not	RB
18637	1560	4	expect	expect	VB
18637	1560	5	uncommon	uncommon	JJ
18637	1560	6	courage	courage	NN
18637	1560	7	even	even	RB
18637	1560	8	in	in	IN
18637	1560	9	legislators	legislator	NNS
18637	1560	10	"	"	''
18637	1560	11	.	.	.
18637	1561	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1561	2	189	189	CD
18637	1561	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1561	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1561	5	2	2	CD
18637	1561	6	.	.	.
18637	1562	1	No	no	DT
18637	1562	2	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	1562	3	or	or	CC
18637	1562	4	Representative	Representative	NNP
18637	1562	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	1562	6	,	,	,
18637	1562	7	during	during	IN
18637	1562	8	the	the	DT
18637	1562	9	Time	Time	NNP
18637	1562	10	for	for	IN
18637	1562	11	which	which	WDT
18637	1562	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1562	13	was	be	VBD
18637	1562	14	elected	elect	VBN
18637	1562	15	,	,	,
18637	1562	16	be	be	VB
18637	1562	17	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	1562	18	to	to	IN
18637	1562	19	any	any	DT
18637	1562	20	civil	civil	JJ
18637	1562	21	Office	Office	NNP
18637	1562	22	under	under	IN
18637	1562	23	the	the	DT
18637	1562	24	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	1562	25	of	of	IN
18637	1562	26	the	the	DT
18637	1562	27	United	United	NNP
18637	1562	28	States	States	NNP
18637	1562	29	,	,	,
18637	1562	30	which	which	WDT
18637	1562	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	1562	32	have	have	VB
18637	1562	33	been	be	VBN
18637	1562	34	created	create	VBN
18637	1562	35	,	,	,
18637	1562	36	or	or	CC
18637	1562	37	the	the	DT
18637	1562	38	Emoluments	Emoluments	NNPS
18637	1562	39	whereof	whereof	NN
18637	1562	40	shall	shall	MD
18637	1562	41	have	have	VB
18637	1562	42	been	be	VBN
18637	1562	43	encreased	encrease	VBN
18637	1562	44	during	during	IN
18637	1562	45	such	such	JJ
18637	1562	46	time	time	NN
18637	1562	47	;	;	:
18637	1562	48	and	and	CC
18637	1562	49	no	no	DT
18637	1562	50	Person	person	NN
18637	1562	51	holding	hold	VBG
18637	1562	52	any	any	DT
18637	1562	53	Office	Office	NNP
18637	1562	54	under	under	IN
18637	1562	55	the	the	DT
18637	1562	56	United	United	NNP
18637	1562	57	States	States	NNP
18637	1562	58	,	,	,
18637	1562	59	shall	shall	MD
18637	1562	60	be	be	VB
18637	1562	61	a	a	DT
18637	1562	62	Member	Member	NNP
18637	1562	63	of	of	IN
18637	1562	64	either	either	DT
18637	1562	65	House	House	NNP
18637	1562	66	during	during	IN
18637	1562	67	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1562	68	Continuance	Continuance	NNP
18637	1562	69	in	in	IN
18637	1562	70	Office	Office	NNP
18637	1562	71	.	.	.
18637	1563	1	INCOMPATIBLE	INCOMPATIBLE	NNP
18637	1563	2	OFFICES	offices	NN
18637	1563	3	According	accord	VBG
18637	1563	4	to	to	IN
18637	1563	5	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1563	6	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	1563	7	,	,	,
18637	1563	8	visitors	visitor	NNS
18637	1563	9	to	to	IN
18637	1563	10	academies	academy	NNS
18637	1563	11	,	,	,
18637	1563	12	regents	regent	NNS
18637	1563	13	,	,	,
18637	1563	14	directors	director	NNS
18637	1563	15	and	and	CC
18637	1563	16	trustees	trustee	NNS
18637	1563	17	of	of	IN
18637	1563	18	public	public	JJ
18637	1563	19	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	1563	20	,	,	,
18637	1563	21	and	and	CC
18637	1563	22	members	member	NNS
18637	1563	23	of	of	IN
18637	1563	24	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	1563	25	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	1563	26	who	who	WP
18637	1563	27	receive	receive	VBP
18637	1563	28	no	no	DT
18637	1563	29	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	1563	30	as	as	IN
18637	1563	31	such	such	JJ
18637	1563	32	,	,	,
18637	1563	33	are	be	VBP
18637	1563	34	not	not	RB
18637	1563	35	officers	officer	NNS
18637	1563	36	within	within	IN
18637	1563	37	the	the	DT
18637	1563	38	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1563	39	inhibition	inhibition	NN
18637	1563	40	of	of	IN
18637	1563	41	section	section	NN
18637	1563	42	6	6	CD
18637	1563	43	.	.	.
18637	1564	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1564	2	190	190	CD
18637	1564	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1564	4	Government	government	NN
18637	1564	5	contractors	contractor	NNS
18637	1564	6	and	and	CC
18637	1564	7	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1564	8	officers	officer	NNS
18637	1564	9	who	who	WP
18637	1564	10	resign	resign	VBP
18637	1564	11	before	before	IN
18637	1564	12	presenting	present	VBG
18637	1564	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1564	14	credentials	credential	NNS
18637	1564	15	may	may	MD
18637	1564	16	be	be	VB
18637	1564	17	seated	seat	VBN
18637	1564	18	as	as	IN
18637	1564	19	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	1564	20	of	of	IN
18637	1564	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1564	22	.	.	.
18637	1565	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1565	2	191	191	CD
18637	1565	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1565	4	In	in	IN
18637	1565	5	1909	1909	CD
18637	1565	6	,	,	,
18637	1565	7	after	after	IN
18637	1565	8	having	have	VBG
18637	1565	9	increased	increase	VBN
18637	1565	10	the	the	DT
18637	1565	11	salary	salary	NN
18637	1565	12	of	of	IN
18637	1565	13	the	the	DT
18637	1565	14	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1565	15	of	of	IN
18637	1565	16	State,[192	State,[192	NNP
18637	1565	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1565	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1565	19	reduced	reduce	VBD
18637	1565	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1565	21	to	to	IN
18637	1565	22	the	the	DT
18637	1565	23	former	former	JJ
18637	1565	24	figure	figure	NN
18637	1565	25	so	so	IN
18637	1565	26	that	that	IN
18637	1565	27	a	a	DT
18637	1565	28	Member	Member	NNP
18637	1565	29	of	of	IN
18637	1565	30	the	the	DT
18637	1565	31	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1565	32	at	at	IN
18637	1565	33	the	the	DT
18637	1565	34	time	time	NN
18637	1565	35	the	the	DT
18637	1565	36	increase	increase	NN
18637	1565	37	was	be	VBD
18637	1565	38	voted	vote	VBN
18637	1565	39	would	would	MD
18637	1565	40	be	be	VB
18637	1565	41	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	1565	42	for	for	IN
18637	1565	43	that	that	DT
18637	1565	44	office	office	NN
18637	1565	45	.	.	.
18637	1566	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1566	2	193	193	CD
18637	1566	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1566	4	The	the	DT
18637	1566	5	first	first	JJ
18637	1566	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	1566	7	again	again	RB
18637	1566	8	became	become	VBD
18637	1566	9	a	a	DT
18637	1566	10	subject	subject	NN
18637	1566	11	of	of	IN
18637	1566	12	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	1566	13	in	in	IN
18637	1566	14	1937	1937	CD
18637	1566	15	,	,	,
18637	1566	16	when	when	WRB
18637	1566	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1566	18	Black	Black	NNP
18637	1566	19	was	be	VBD
18637	1566	20	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	1566	21	to	to	IN
18637	1566	22	the	the	DT
18637	1566	23	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1566	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1566	25	in	in	IN
18637	1566	26	face	face	NN
18637	1566	27	of	of	IN
18637	1566	28	the	the	DT
18637	1566	29	fact	fact	NN
18637	1566	30	that	that	IN
18637	1566	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1566	32	had	have	VBD
18637	1566	33	recently	recently	RB
18637	1566	34	improved	improve	VBN
18637	1566	35	the	the	DT
18637	1566	36	financial	financial	JJ
18637	1566	37	position	position	NN
18637	1566	38	of	of	IN
18637	1566	39	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	1566	40	retiring	retire	VBG
18637	1566	41	at	at	IN
18637	1566	42	seventy	seventy	CD
18637	1566	43	and	and	CC
18637	1566	44	the	the	DT
18637	1566	45	term	term	NN
18637	1566	46	for	for	IN
18637	1566	47	which	which	WDT
18637	1566	48	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	1566	49	Black	Black	NNP
18637	1566	50	had	have	VBD
18637	1566	51	been	be	VBN
18637	1566	52	elected	elect	VBN
18637	1566	53	to	to	IN
18637	1566	54	the	the	DT
18637	1566	55	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1566	56	from	from	IN
18637	1566	57	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	1566	58	in	in	IN
18637	1566	59	1932	1932	CD
18637	1566	60	had	have	VBD
18637	1566	61	still	still	RB
18637	1566	62	some	some	DT
18637	1566	63	time	time	NN
18637	1566	64	to	to	TO
18637	1566	65	run	run	VB
18637	1566	66	.	.	.
18637	1567	1	The	the	DT
18637	1567	2	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	1567	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1567	4	defended	defend	VBN
18637	1567	5	by	by	IN
18637	1567	6	the	the	DT
18637	1567	7	argument	argument	NN
18637	1567	8	that	that	WDT
18637	1567	9	inasmuch	inasmuch	VBP
18637	1567	10	as	as	IN
18637	1567	11	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	1567	12	Black	Black	NNP
18637	1567	13	was	be	VBD
18637	1567	14	only	only	RB
18637	1567	15	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	1567	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	1567	17	one	one	CD
18637	1567	18	years	year	NNS
18637	1567	19	old	old	JJ
18637	1567	20	at	at	IN
18637	1567	21	the	the	DT
18637	1567	22	time	time	NN
18637	1567	23	and	and	CC
18637	1567	24	so	so	RB
18637	1567	25	would	would	MD
18637	1567	26	be	be	VB
18637	1567	27	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	1567	28	for	for	IN
18637	1567	29	the	the	DT
18637	1567	30	"	"	``
18637	1567	31	increased	increase	VBN
18637	1567	32	emolument	emolument	NN
18637	1567	33	"	"	''
18637	1567	34	for	for	IN
18637	1567	35	nineteen	nineteen	CD
18637	1567	36	years	year	NNS
18637	1567	37	,	,	,
18637	1567	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1567	39	was	be	VBD
18637	1567	40	not	not	RB
18637	1567	41	_	_	NNP
18637	1567	42	as	as	IN
18637	1567	43	to	to	IN
18637	1567	44	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1567	45	_	_	NNP
18637	1567	46	an	an	DT
18637	1567	47	increased	increase	VBN
18637	1567	48	emolument	emolument	NN
18637	1567	49	.	.	.
18637	1568	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1568	2	194	194	CD
18637	1568	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1568	4	Section	section	NN
18637	1568	5	7	7	CD
18637	1568	6	.	.	.
18637	1569	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1569	2	1	1	CD
18637	1569	3	.	.	.
18637	1570	1	All	all	DT
18637	1570	2	Bills	bill	NNS
18637	1570	3	for	for	IN
18637	1570	4	raising	raise	VBG
18637	1570	5	Revenue	revenue	NN
18637	1570	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	1570	7	originate	originate	VB
18637	1570	8	in	in	IN
18637	1570	9	the	the	DT
18637	1570	10	House	House	NNP
18637	1570	11	of	of	IN
18637	1570	12	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1570	13	;	;	:
18637	1570	14	but	but	CC
18637	1570	15	the	the	DT
18637	1570	16	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1570	17	may	may	MD
18637	1570	18	propose	propose	VB
18637	1570	19	or	or	CC
18637	1570	20	concur	concur	VB
18637	1570	21	with	with	IN
18637	1570	22	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	1570	23	as	as	IN
18637	1570	24	on	on	IN
18637	1570	25	other	other	JJ
18637	1570	26	Bills	bill	NNS
18637	1570	27	.	.	.
18637	1571	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1571	2	2	2	CD
18637	1571	3	.	.	.
18637	1572	1	Every	every	DT
18637	1572	2	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	1572	3	which	which	WDT
18637	1572	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	1572	5	have	have	VB
18637	1572	6	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1572	7	the	the	DT
18637	1572	8	House	House	NNP
18637	1572	9	of	of	IN
18637	1572	10	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1572	11	and	and	CC
18637	1572	12	the	the	DT
18637	1572	13	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1572	14	,	,	,
18637	1572	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	1572	16	,	,	,
18637	1572	17	before	before	IN
18637	1572	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1572	19	become	become	VBP
18637	1572	20	a	a	DT
18637	1572	21	Law	Law	NNP
18637	1572	22	,	,	,
18637	1572	23	be	be	VB
18637	1572	24	presented	present	VBN
18637	1572	25	to	to	IN
18637	1572	26	the	the	DT
18637	1572	27	President	President	NNP
18637	1572	28	of	of	IN
18637	1572	29	the	the	DT
18637	1572	30	United	United	NNP
18637	1572	31	States	States	NNP
18637	1572	32	;	;	:
18637	1572	33	If	if	IN
18637	1572	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1572	35	approve	approve	VBP
18637	1572	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1572	37	shall	shall	MD
18637	1572	38	sign	sign	VB
18637	1572	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1572	40	,	,	,
18637	1572	41	but	but	CC
18637	1572	42	if	if	IN
18637	1572	43	not	not	RB
18637	1572	44	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1572	45	shall	shall	MD
18637	1572	46	return	return	VB
18637	1572	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1572	48	,	,	,
18637	1572	49	with	with	IN
18637	1572	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1572	51	Objections	objection	NNS
18637	1572	52	to	to	IN
18637	1572	53	that	that	DT
18637	1572	54	House	House	NNP
18637	1572	55	in	in	IN
18637	1572	56	which	which	WDT
18637	1572	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1572	58	shall	shall	MD
18637	1572	59	have	have	VB
18637	1572	60	originated	originate	VBN
18637	1572	61	,	,	,
18637	1572	62	who	who	WP
18637	1572	63	shall	shall	MD
18637	1572	64	enter	enter	VB
18637	1572	65	the	the	DT
18637	1572	66	Objections	objection	NNS
18637	1572	67	at	at	IN
18637	1572	68	large	large	JJ
18637	1572	69	on	on	IN
18637	1572	70	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1572	71	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	1572	72	,	,	,
18637	1572	73	and	and	CC
18637	1572	74	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	1572	75	to	to	TO
18637	1572	76	reconsider	reconsider	VB
18637	1572	77	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1572	78	.	.	.
18637	1573	1	If	if	IN
18637	1573	2	after	after	IN
18637	1573	3	such	such	JJ
18637	1573	4	Reconsideration	reconsideration	NN
18637	1573	5	two	two	CD
18637	1573	6	thirds	third	NNS
18637	1573	7	of	of	IN
18637	1573	8	that	that	IN
18637	1573	9	House	House	NNP
18637	1573	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	1573	11	agree	agree	VB
18637	1573	12	to	to	TO
18637	1573	13	pass	pass	VB
18637	1573	14	the	the	DT
18637	1573	15	Bill	bill	NN
18637	1573	16	,	,	,
18637	1573	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1573	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	1573	19	be	be	VB
18637	1573	20	sent	send	VBN
18637	1573	21	,	,	,
18637	1573	22	together	together	RB
18637	1573	23	with	with	IN
18637	1573	24	the	the	DT
18637	1573	25	Objections	objection	NNS
18637	1573	26	,	,	,
18637	1573	27	to	to	IN
18637	1573	28	the	the	DT
18637	1573	29	other	other	JJ
18637	1573	30	House	House	NNP
18637	1573	31	,	,	,
18637	1573	32	by	by	IN
18637	1573	33	which	which	WDT
18637	1573	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1573	35	shall	shall	MD
18637	1573	36	likewise	likewise	RB
18637	1573	37	be	be	VB
18637	1573	38	reconsidered	reconsider	VBN
18637	1573	39	,	,	,
18637	1573	40	and	and	CC
18637	1573	41	if	if	IN
18637	1573	42	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1573	43	by	by	IN
18637	1573	44	two	two	CD
18637	1573	45	thirds	third	NNS
18637	1573	46	of	of	IN
18637	1573	47	that	that	DT
18637	1573	48	House	House	NNP
18637	1573	49	,	,	,
18637	1573	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1573	51	shall	shall	MD
18637	1573	52	become	become	VB
18637	1573	53	a	a	DT
18637	1573	54	Law	law	NN
18637	1573	55	.	.	.
18637	1574	1	But	but	CC
18637	1574	2	in	in	IN
18637	1574	3	all	all	DT
18637	1574	4	such	such	JJ
18637	1574	5	Cases	case	NNS
18637	1574	6	the	the	DT
18637	1574	7	Votes	vote	NNS
18637	1574	8	of	of	IN
18637	1574	9	both	both	DT
18637	1574	10	Houses	house	NNS
18637	1574	11	shall	shall	MD
18637	1574	12	be	be	VB
18637	1574	13	determined	determine	VBN
18637	1574	14	by	by	IN
18637	1574	15	yeas	yea	NNS
18637	1574	16	and	and	CC
18637	1574	17	Nays	Nays	NNP
18637	1574	18	,	,	,
18637	1574	19	and	and	CC
18637	1574	20	the	the	DT
18637	1574	21	Names	Names	NNPS
18637	1574	22	of	of	IN
18637	1574	23	the	the	DT
18637	1574	24	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	1574	25	voting	vote	VBG
18637	1574	26	for	for	IN
18637	1574	27	and	and	CC
18637	1574	28	against	against	IN
18637	1574	29	the	the	DT
18637	1574	30	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	1574	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	1574	32	be	be	VB
18637	1574	33	entered	enter	VBN
18637	1574	34	on	on	IN
18637	1574	35	the	the	DT
18637	1574	36	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	1574	37	of	of	IN
18637	1574	38	each	each	DT
18637	1574	39	House	House	NNP
18637	1574	40	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	1574	41	.	.	.
18637	1575	1	If	if	IN
18637	1575	2	any	any	DT
18637	1575	3	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	1575	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	1575	5	not	not	RB
18637	1575	6	be	be	VB
18637	1575	7	returned	return	VBN
18637	1575	8	by	by	IN
18637	1575	9	the	the	DT
18637	1575	10	President	President	NNP
18637	1575	11	within	within	IN
18637	1575	12	ten	ten	CD
18637	1575	13	Days	day	NNS
18637	1575	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1575	15	Sundays	sunday	NNS
18637	1575	16	excepted	except	VBN
18637	1575	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1575	18	after	after	IN
18637	1575	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1575	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	1575	21	have	have	VB
18637	1575	22	been	be	VBN
18637	1575	23	presented	present	VBN
18637	1575	24	to	to	IN
18637	1575	25	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1575	26	,	,	,
18637	1575	27	the	the	DT
18637	1575	28	Same	same	JJ
18637	1575	29	shall	shall	MD
18637	1575	30	be	be	VB
18637	1575	31	a	a	DT
18637	1575	32	Law	Law	NNP
18637	1575	33	,	,	,
18637	1575	34	in	in	IN
18637	1575	35	like	like	IN
18637	1575	36	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	1575	37	as	as	IN
18637	1575	38	if	if	IN
18637	1575	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1575	40	had	have	VBD
18637	1575	41	signed	sign	VBN
18637	1575	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1575	43	,	,	,
18637	1575	44	unless	unless	IN
18637	1575	45	the	the	DT
18637	1575	46	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1575	47	by	by	IN
18637	1575	48	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1575	49	Adjournment	adjournment	NN
18637	1575	50	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	1575	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1575	52	Return	return	NN
18637	1575	53	,	,	,
18637	1575	54	in	in	IN
18637	1575	55	which	which	WDT
18637	1575	56	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1575	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1575	58	shall	shall	MD
18637	1575	59	not	not	RB
18637	1575	60	be	be	VB
18637	1575	61	a	a	DT
18637	1575	62	Law	law	NN
18637	1575	63	.	.	.
18637	1576	1	THE	the	DT
18637	1576	2	LEGISLATIVE	LEGISLATIVE	NNP
18637	1576	3	PROCESS	PROCESS	NNP
18637	1576	4	REVENUE	revenue	NN
18637	1576	5	BILLS	bill	NNS
18637	1576	6	Only	only	RB
18637	1576	7	bills	bill	NNS
18637	1576	8	to	to	TO
18637	1576	9	levy	levy	VB
18637	1576	10	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1576	11	in	in	IN
18637	1576	12	the	the	DT
18637	1576	13	strict	strict	JJ
18637	1576	14	sense	sense	NN
18637	1576	15	of	of	IN
18637	1576	16	the	the	DT
18637	1576	17	word	word	NN
18637	1576	18	are	be	VBP
18637	1576	19	comprehended	comprehend	VBN
18637	1576	20	by	by	IN
18637	1576	21	the	the	DT
18637	1576	22	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	1576	23	"	"	``
18637	1576	24	all	all	DT
18637	1576	25	bills	bill	NNS
18637	1576	26	for	for	IN
18637	1576	27	raising	raise	VBG
18637	1576	28	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	1576	29	"	"	''
18637	1576	30	;	;	,
18637	1576	31	bills	bill	NNS
18637	1576	32	for	for	IN
18637	1576	33	other	other	JJ
18637	1576	34	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	1576	35	,	,	,
18637	1576	36	which	which	WDT
18637	1576	37	incidentally	incidentally	RB
18637	1576	38	create	create	VBP
18637	1576	39	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	1576	40	,	,	,
18637	1576	41	are	be	VBP
18637	1576	42	not	not	RB
18637	1576	43	included	include	VBN
18637	1576	44	.	.	.
18637	1577	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1577	2	195	195	CD
18637	1577	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1577	4	An	an	DT
18637	1577	5	act	act	NN
18637	1577	6	providing	provide	VBG
18637	1577	7	a	a	DT
18637	1577	8	national	national	JJ
18637	1577	9	currency	currency	NN
18637	1577	10	secured	secure	VBN
18637	1577	11	by	by	IN
18637	1577	12	a	a	DT
18637	1577	13	pledge	pledge	NN
18637	1577	14	of	of	IN
18637	1577	15	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	1577	16	of	of	IN
18637	1577	17	the	the	DT
18637	1577	18	United	United	NNP
18637	1577	19	States	States	NNP
18637	1577	20	,	,	,
18637	1577	21	which	which	WDT
18637	1577	22	,	,	,
18637	1577	23	"	"	``
18637	1577	24	in	in	IN
18637	1577	25	the	the	DT
18637	1577	26	furtherance	furtherance	NN
18637	1577	27	of	of	IN
18637	1577	28	that	that	DT
18637	1577	29	object	object	NN
18637	1577	30	,	,	,
18637	1577	31	and	and	CC
18637	1577	32	also	also	RB
18637	1577	33	to	to	TO
18637	1577	34	meet	meet	VB
18637	1577	35	the	the	DT
18637	1577	36	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	1577	37	attending	attend	VBG
18637	1577	38	the	the	DT
18637	1577	39	execution	execution	NN
18637	1577	40	of	of	IN
18637	1577	41	the	the	DT
18637	1577	42	act	act	NN
18637	1577	43	,	,	,
18637	1577	44	"	"	``
18637	1577	45	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	1577	46	a	a	DT
18637	1577	47	tax	tax	NN
18637	1577	48	on	on	IN
18637	1577	49	the	the	DT
18637	1577	50	circulating	circulate	VBG
18637	1577	51	notes	note	NNS
18637	1577	52	of	of	IN
18637	1577	53	national	national	JJ
18637	1577	54	banks	bank	NNS
18637	1577	55	was	be	VBD
18637	1577	56	held	hold	VBN
18637	1577	57	not	not	RB
18637	1577	58	to	to	TO
18637	1577	59	be	be	VB
18637	1577	60	a	a	DT
18637	1577	61	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	1577	62	measure	measure	NN
18637	1577	63	which	which	WDT
18637	1577	64	must	must	MD
18637	1577	65	originate	originate	VB
18637	1577	66	in	in	IN
18637	1577	67	the	the	DT
18637	1577	68	House	House	NNP
18637	1577	69	of	of	IN
18637	1577	70	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1577	71	.	.	.
18637	1578	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1578	2	196	196	CD
18637	1578	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1578	4	Neither	neither	CC
18637	1578	5	was	be	VBD
18637	1578	6	a	a	DT
18637	1578	7	bill	bill	NN
18637	1578	8	which	which	WDT
18637	1578	9	provided	provide	VBD
18637	1578	10	that	that	IN
18637	1578	11	the	the	DT
18637	1578	12	District	District	NNP
18637	1578	13	of	of	IN
18637	1578	14	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	1578	15	should	should	MD
18637	1578	16	raise	raise	VB
18637	1578	17	by	by	IN
18637	1578	18	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1578	19	and	and	CC
18637	1578	20	pay	pay	NN
18637	1578	21	to	to	IN
18637	1578	22	designated	designate	VBN
18637	1578	23	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	1578	24	companies	company	NNS
18637	1578	25	a	a	DT
18637	1578	26	specified	specify	VBN
18637	1578	27	sum	sum	NN
18637	1578	28	for	for	IN
18637	1578	29	the	the	DT
18637	1578	30	elimination	elimination	NN
18637	1578	31	of	of	IN
18637	1578	32	grade	grade	NN
18637	1578	33	crossings	crossing	NNS
18637	1578	34	and	and	CC
18637	1578	35	the	the	DT
18637	1578	36	construction	construction	NN
18637	1578	37	of	of	IN
18637	1578	38	a	a	DT
18637	1578	39	union	union	NN
18637	1578	40	railway	railway	NN
18637	1578	41	station	station	NN
18637	1578	42	.	.	.
18637	1579	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1579	2	197	197	CD
18637	1579	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1579	4	The	the	DT
18637	1579	5	substitution	substitution	NN
18637	1579	6	of	of	IN
18637	1579	7	a	a	DT
18637	1579	8	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	1579	9	tax	tax	NN
18637	1579	10	for	for	IN
18637	1579	11	an	an	DT
18637	1579	12	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	1579	13	tax,[198	tax,[198	NN
18637	1579	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1579	15	and	and	CC
18637	1579	16	the	the	DT
18637	1579	17	addition	addition	NN
18637	1579	18	of	of	IN
18637	1579	19	a	a	DT
18637	1579	20	section	section	NN
18637	1579	21	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	1579	22	an	an	DT
18637	1579	23	excise	excise	JJ
18637	1579	24	tax	tax	NN
18637	1579	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	1579	26	the	the	DT
18637	1579	27	use	use	NN
18637	1579	28	of	of	IN
18637	1579	29	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1579	30	built	build	VBN
18637	1579	31	pleasure	pleasure	NN
18637	1579	32	yachts,[199	yachts,[199	NNP
18637	1579	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1579	34	have	have	VBP
18637	1579	35	been	be	VBN
18637	1579	36	held	hold	VBN
18637	1579	37	to	to	TO
18637	1579	38	be	be	VB
18637	1579	39	within	within	IN
18637	1579	40	the	the	DT
18637	1579	41	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1579	42	's	's	POS
18637	1579	43	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1579	44	power	power	NN
18637	1579	45	to	to	TO
18637	1579	46	propose	propose	VB
18637	1579	47	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	1579	48	.	.	.
18637	1580	1	APPROVAL	APPROVAL	NNP
18637	1580	2	BY	by	IN
18637	1580	3	THE	the	DT
18637	1580	4	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	1580	5	The	the	DT
18637	1580	6	President	President	NNP
18637	1580	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	1580	8	not	not	RB
18637	1580	9	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	1580	10	to	to	IN
18637	1580	11	signing	sign	VBG
18637	1580	12	a	a	DT
18637	1580	13	bill	bill	NN
18637	1580	14	on	on	IN
18637	1580	15	a	a	DT
18637	1580	16	day	day	NN
18637	1580	17	when	when	WRB
18637	1580	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1580	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	1580	20	in	in	IN
18637	1580	21	session	session	NN
18637	1580	22	.	.	.
18637	1581	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1581	2	200	200	CD
18637	1581	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1581	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1581	5	may	may	MD
18637	1581	6	sign	sign	VB
18637	1581	7	within	within	IN
18637	1581	8	ten	ten	CD
18637	1581	9	days	day	NNS
18637	1581	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1581	11	Sundays	sunday	NNS
18637	1581	12	excepted	except	VBN
18637	1581	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1581	14	after	after	IN
18637	1581	15	the	the	DT
18637	1581	16	bill	bill	NN
18637	1581	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	1581	18	presented	present	VBN
18637	1581	19	to	to	IN
18637	1581	20	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1581	21	,	,	,
18637	1581	22	even	even	RB
18637	1581	23	if	if	IN
18637	1581	24	that	that	DT
18637	1581	25	period	period	NN
18637	1581	26	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	1581	27	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	1581	28	the	the	DT
18637	1581	29	date	date	NN
18637	1581	30	of	of	IN
18637	1581	31	the	the	DT
18637	1581	32	final	final	JJ
18637	1581	33	adjournment	adjournment	NN
18637	1581	34	of	of	IN
18637	1581	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1581	36	.	.	.
18637	1582	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1582	2	201	201	CD
18637	1582	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1582	4	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1582	5	duty	duty	NN
18637	1582	6	in	in	IN
18637	1582	7	case	case	NN
18637	1582	8	of	of	IN
18637	1582	9	approval	approval	NN
18637	1582	10	of	of	IN
18637	1582	11	a	a	DT
18637	1582	12	measure	measure	NN
18637	1582	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	1582	14	merely	merely	RB
18637	1582	15	to	to	TO
18637	1582	16	sign	sign	VB
18637	1582	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1582	18	.	.	.
18637	1583	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1583	2	need	nee	MD
18637	1583	3	not	not	RB
18637	1583	4	write	write	VB
18637	1583	5	on	on	IN
18637	1583	6	the	the	DT
18637	1583	7	bill	bill	NN
18637	1583	8	the	the	DT
18637	1583	9	word	word	NN
18637	1583	10	"	"	``
18637	1583	11	approved	approve	VBD
18637	1583	12	"	"	''
18637	1583	13	nor	nor	CC
18637	1583	14	the	the	DT
18637	1583	15	date	date	NN
18637	1583	16	.	.	.
18637	1584	1	If	if	IN
18637	1584	2	no	no	DT
18637	1584	3	date	date	NN
18637	1584	4	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1584	5	on	on	IN
18637	1584	6	the	the	DT
18637	1584	7	face	face	NN
18637	1584	8	of	of	IN
18637	1584	9	the	the	DT
18637	1584	10	roll	roll	NN
18637	1584	11	,	,	,
18637	1584	12	the	the	DT
18637	1584	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1584	14	may	may	MD
18637	1584	15	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	1584	16	the	the	DT
18637	1584	17	fact	fact	NN
18637	1584	18	by	by	IN
18637	1584	19	resort	resort	NN
18637	1584	20	to	to	IN
18637	1584	21	any	any	DT
18637	1584	22	source	source	NN
18637	1584	23	of	of	IN
18637	1584	24	information	information	NN
18637	1584	25	capable	capable	JJ
18637	1584	26	of	of	IN
18637	1584	27	furnishing	furnish	VBG
18637	1584	28	a	a	DT
18637	1584	29	satisfactory	satisfactory	JJ
18637	1584	30	answer	answer	NN
18637	1584	31	.	.	.
18637	1585	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1585	2	202	202	CD
18637	1585	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1585	4	A	a	DT
18637	1585	5	bill	bill	NN
18637	1585	6	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	1585	7	law	law	NN
18637	1585	8	on	on	IN
18637	1585	9	the	the	DT
18637	1585	10	date	date	NN
18637	1585	11	of	of	IN
18637	1585	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1585	13	approval	approval	NN
18637	1585	14	by	by	IN
18637	1585	15	the	the	DT
18637	1585	16	President	President	NNP
18637	1585	17	.	.	.
18637	1586	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1586	2	203	203	CD
18637	1586	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1586	4	When	when	WRB
18637	1586	5	no	no	DT
18637	1586	6	time	time	NN
18637	1586	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	1586	8	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	1586	9	by	by	IN
18637	1586	10	the	the	DT
18637	1586	11	act	act	NN
18637	1586	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1586	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	1586	14	effective	effective	JJ
18637	1586	15	from	from	IN
18637	1586	16	the	the	DT
18637	1586	17	date	date	NN
18637	1586	18	of	of	IN
18637	1586	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1586	20	approval,[204	approval,[204	NN
18637	1586	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1586	22	which	which	WDT
18637	1586	23	usually	usually	RB
18637	1586	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	1586	25	taken	take	VBN
18637	1586	26	to	to	TO
18637	1586	27	be	be	VB
18637	1586	28	the	the	DT
18637	1586	29	first	first	JJ
18637	1586	30	moment	moment	NN
18637	1586	31	of	of	IN
18637	1586	32	the	the	DT
18637	1586	33	day	day	NN
18637	1586	34	,	,	,
18637	1586	35	fractions	fraction	NNS
18637	1586	36	of	of	IN
18637	1586	37	a	a	DT
18637	1586	38	day	day	NN
18637	1586	39	being	be	VBG
18637	1586	40	disregarded	disregard	VBN
18637	1586	41	.	.	.
18637	1587	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1587	2	205	205	CD
18637	1587	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1587	4	THE	the	DT
18637	1587	5	VETO	veto	NN
18637	1587	6	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	1587	7	If	if	IN
18637	1587	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1587	9	adjourns	adjourn	VBZ
18637	1587	10	within	within	IN
18637	1587	11	ten	ten	CD
18637	1587	12	days	day	NNS
18637	1587	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1587	14	Sundays	sunday	NNS
18637	1587	15	excepted	except	VBN
18637	1587	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1587	17	of	of	IN
18637	1587	18	the	the	DT
18637	1587	19	presentation	presentation	NN
18637	1587	20	of	of	IN
18637	1587	21	a	a	DT
18637	1587	22	bill	bill	NN
18637	1587	23	to	to	IN
18637	1587	24	the	the	DT
18637	1587	25	President	President	NNP
18637	1587	26	,	,	,
18637	1587	27	the	the	DT
18637	1587	28	return	return	NN
18637	1587	29	of	of	IN
18637	1587	30	the	the	DT
18637	1587	31	bill	bill	NN
18637	1587	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	1587	33	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	1587	34	within	within	IN
18637	1587	35	the	the	DT
18637	1587	36	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	1587	37	of	of	IN
18637	1587	38	this	this	DT
18637	1587	39	clause	clause	NN
18637	1587	40	.	.	.
18637	1588	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	1588	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1588	3	does	do	VBZ
18637	1588	4	not	not	RB
18637	1588	5	become	become	VB
18637	1588	6	law	law	NN
18637	1588	7	if	if	IN
18637	1588	8	the	the	DT
18637	1588	9	President	President	NNP
18637	1588	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	1588	11	not	not	RB
18637	1588	12	sign	sign	VB
18637	1588	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1588	14	,	,	,
18637	1588	15	but	but	CC
18637	1588	16	succumbs	succumb	NNS
18637	1588	17	to	to	IN
18637	1588	18	what	what	WP
18637	1588	19	in	in	IN
18637	1588	20	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1588	21	parlance	parlance	NN
18637	1588	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	1588	23	called	call	VBN
18637	1588	24	a	a	DT
18637	1588	25	"	"	``
18637	1588	26	pocket	pocket	NN
18637	1588	27	veto	veto	NN
18637	1588	28	.	.	.
18637	1589	1	"	"	``
18637	1589	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1589	3	206	206	CD
18637	1589	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1589	5	But	but	CC
18637	1589	6	a	a	DT
18637	1589	7	brief	brief	JJ
18637	1589	8	recess	recess	NN
18637	1589	9	by	by	IN
18637	1589	10	the	the	DT
18637	1589	11	House	House	NNP
18637	1589	12	in	in	IN
18637	1589	13	which	which	WDT
18637	1589	14	a	a	DT
18637	1589	15	bill	bill	NN
18637	1589	16	originated	originate	VBD
18637	1589	17	,	,	,
18637	1589	18	while	while	IN
18637	1589	19	the	the	DT
18637	1589	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1589	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	1589	22	still	still	RB
18637	1589	23	in	in	IN
18637	1589	24	session	session	NN
18637	1589	25	,	,	,
18637	1589	26	does	do	VBZ
18637	1589	27	not	not	RB
18637	1589	28	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	1589	29	the	the	DT
18637	1589	30	return	return	NN
18637	1589	31	of	of	IN
18637	1589	32	a	a	DT
18637	1589	33	bill	bill	NN
18637	1589	34	by	by	IN
18637	1589	35	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	1589	36	to	to	IN
18637	1589	37	one	one	CD
18637	1589	38	of	of	IN
18637	1589	39	the	the	DT
18637	1589	40	officers	officer	NNS
18637	1589	41	of	of	IN
18637	1589	42	the	the	DT
18637	1589	43	House	House	NNP
18637	1589	44	who	who	WP
18637	1589	45	has	have	VBZ
18637	1589	46	implied	imply	VBN
18637	1589	47	authority	authority	NN
18637	1589	48	to	to	TO
18637	1589	49	receive	receive	VB
18637	1589	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1589	51	.	.	.
18637	1590	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1590	2	207	207	CD
18637	1590	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1590	4	The	the	DT
18637	1590	5	two	two	CD
18637	1590	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	1590	7	thirds	third	NNS
18637	1590	8	vote	vote	NN
18637	1590	9	of	of	IN
18637	1590	10	each	each	DT
18637	1590	11	House	House	NNP
18637	1590	12	required	require	VBN
18637	1590	13	to	to	TO
18637	1590	14	pass	pass	VB
18637	1590	15	a	a	DT
18637	1590	16	bill	bill	NN
18637	1590	17	over	over	IN
18637	1590	18	a	a	DT
18637	1590	19	veto	veto	NN
18637	1590	20	means	mean	VBZ
18637	1590	21	two	two	CD
18637	1590	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	1590	23	thirds	third	NNS
18637	1590	24	of	of	IN
18637	1590	25	a	a	DT
18637	1590	26	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	1590	27	.	.	.
18637	1591	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1591	2	208	208	CD
18637	1591	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1591	4	After	after	IN
18637	1591	5	a	a	DT
18637	1591	6	bill	bill	NN
18637	1591	7	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	1591	8	law	law	NN
18637	1591	9	the	the	DT
18637	1591	10	President	President	NNP
18637	1591	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	1591	12	no	no	DT
18637	1591	13	authority	authority	NN
18637	1591	14	to	to	TO
18637	1591	15	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	1591	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1591	17	.	.	.
18637	1592	1	Asserting	assert	VBG
18637	1592	2	this	this	DT
18637	1592	3	truism	truism	NN
18637	1592	4	,	,	,
18637	1592	5	the	the	DT
18637	1592	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1592	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1592	8	held	hold	VBD
18637	1592	9	in	in	IN
18637	1592	10	The	the	DT
18637	1592	11	Confiscation	Confiscation	NNP
18637	1592	12	Cases,[209	Cases,[209	NNP
18637	1592	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1592	14	that	that	IN
18637	1592	15	the	the	DT
18637	1592	16	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	1592	17	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	1592	18	issued	issue	VBN
18637	1592	19	by	by	IN
18637	1592	20	the	the	DT
18637	1592	21	President	President	NNP
18637	1592	22	in	in	IN
18637	1592	23	1868	1868	CD
18637	1592	24	did	do	VBD
18637	1592	25	not	not	RB
18637	1592	26	require	require	VB
18637	1592	27	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	1592	28	of	of	IN
18637	1592	29	a	a	DT
18637	1592	30	decree	decree	NN
18637	1592	31	condemning	condemn	VBG
18637	1592	32	property	property	NN
18637	1592	33	which	which	WDT
18637	1592	34	had	have	VBD
18637	1592	35	been	be	VBN
18637	1592	36	seized	seize	VBN
18637	1592	37	under	under	IN
18637	1592	38	the	the	DT
18637	1592	39	Confiscation	Confiscation	NNP
18637	1592	40	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1592	41	of	of	IN
18637	1592	42	1862	1862	CD
18637	1592	43	.	.	.
18637	1593	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1593	2	210	210	CD
18637	1593	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1593	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1593	5	3	3	CD
18637	1593	6	.	.	.
18637	1594	1	Every	every	DT
18637	1594	2	Order	order	NN
18637	1594	3	,	,	,
18637	1594	4	Resolution	resolution	NN
18637	1594	5	,	,	,
18637	1594	6	or	or	CC
18637	1594	7	Vote	vote	NN
18637	1594	8	to	to	TO
18637	1594	9	which	which	WDT
18637	1594	10	the	the	DT
18637	1594	11	Concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	1594	12	of	of	IN
18637	1594	13	the	the	DT
18637	1594	14	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1594	15	and	and	CC
18637	1594	16	House	House	NNP
18637	1594	17	of	of	IN
18637	1594	18	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1594	19	may	may	MD
18637	1594	20	be	be	VB
18637	1594	21	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1594	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1594	23	except	except	IN
18637	1594	24	on	on	IN
18637	1594	25	a	a	DT
18637	1594	26	question	question	NN
18637	1594	27	of	of	IN
18637	1594	28	Adjournment	adjournment	NN
18637	1594	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1594	30	shall	shall	MD
18637	1594	31	be	be	VB
18637	1594	32	presented	present	VBN
18637	1594	33	to	to	IN
18637	1594	34	the	the	DT
18637	1594	35	President	President	NNP
18637	1594	36	of	of	IN
18637	1594	37	the	the	DT
18637	1594	38	United	United	NNP
18637	1594	39	States	States	NNP
18637	1594	40	;	;	:
18637	1594	41	and	and	CC
18637	1594	42	before	before	IN
18637	1594	43	the	the	DT
18637	1594	44	Same	same	JJ
18637	1594	45	shall	shall	MD
18637	1594	46	take	take	VB
18637	1594	47	Effect	effect	NN
18637	1594	48	,	,	,
18637	1594	49	shall	shall	MD
18637	1594	50	be	be	VB
18637	1594	51	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1594	52	by	by	IN
18637	1594	53	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1594	54	,	,	,
18637	1594	55	or	or	CC
18637	1594	56	being	be	VBG
18637	1594	57	disapproved	disapprove	VBN
18637	1594	58	by	by	IN
18637	1594	59	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1594	60	,	,	,
18637	1594	61	shall	shall	MD
18637	1594	62	be	be	VB
18637	1594	63	repassed	repasse	VBN
18637	1594	64	by	by	IN
18637	1594	65	two	two	CD
18637	1594	66	thirds	third	NNS
18637	1594	67	of	of	IN
18637	1594	68	the	the	DT
18637	1594	69	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1594	70	and	and	CC
18637	1594	71	House	House	NNP
18637	1594	72	of	of	IN
18637	1594	73	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	1594	74	,	,	,
18637	1594	75	according	accord	VBG
18637	1594	76	to	to	IN
18637	1594	77	the	the	DT
18637	1594	78	Rules	Rules	NNPS
18637	1594	79	and	and	CC
18637	1594	80	Limitations	Limitations	NNPS
18637	1594	81	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	1594	82	in	in	IN
18637	1594	83	the	the	DT
18637	1594	84	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1594	85	of	of	IN
18637	1594	86	a	a	DT
18637	1594	87	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	1594	88	.	.	.
18637	1595	1	PRESENTATION	presentation	NN
18637	1595	2	OF	of	IN
18637	1595	3	RESOLUTIONS	resolution	NNS
18637	1595	4	The	the	DT
18637	1595	5	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	1595	6	nature	nature	NN
18637	1595	7	of	of	IN
18637	1595	8	this	this	DT
18637	1595	9	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	1595	10	ill	ill	RB
18637	1595	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	1595	12	considered	consider	VBN
18637	1595	13	provision	provision	NN
18637	1595	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	1595	15	emphasized	emphasize	VBN
18637	1595	16	by	by	IN
18637	1595	17	the	the	DT
18637	1595	18	single	single	JJ
18637	1595	19	exception	exception	NN
18637	1595	20	specified	specify	VBN
18637	1595	21	to	to	IN
18637	1595	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1595	23	operation	operation	NN
18637	1595	24	.	.	.
18637	1596	1	Actually	actually	RB
18637	1596	2	,	,	,
18637	1596	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1596	4	was	be	VBD
18637	1596	5	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	1596	6	from	from	IN
18637	1596	7	the	the	DT
18637	1596	8	first	first	JJ
18637	1596	9	to	to	TO
18637	1596	10	give	give	VB
18637	1596	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1596	12	any	any	DT
18637	1596	13	such	such	JJ
18637	1596	14	scope	scope	NN
18637	1596	15	.	.	.
18637	1597	1	Otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	1597	2	the	the	DT
18637	1597	3	intermediate	intermediate	JJ
18637	1597	4	stages	stage	NNS
18637	1597	5	of	of	IN
18637	1597	6	the	the	DT
18637	1597	7	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1597	8	process	process	NN
18637	1597	9	would	would	MD
18637	1597	10	have	have	VB
18637	1597	11	been	be	VBN
18637	1597	12	bogged	bogge	VBN
18637	1597	13	down	down	RP
18637	1597	14	hopelessly	hopelessly	RB
18637	1597	15	,	,	,
18637	1597	16	not	not	RB
18637	1597	17	to	to	TO
18637	1597	18	mention	mention	VB
18637	1597	19	other	other	JJ
18637	1597	20	highly	highly	RB
18637	1597	21	undesirable	undesirable	JJ
18637	1597	22	results	result	NNS
18637	1597	23	.	.	.
18637	1598	1	In	in	IN
18637	1598	2	a	a	DT
18637	1598	3	report	report	NN
18637	1598	4	rendered	render	VBN
18637	1598	5	by	by	IN
18637	1598	6	the	the	DT
18637	1598	7	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1598	8	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	1598	9	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	1598	10	in	in	IN
18637	1598	11	1897	1897	CD
18637	1598	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1598	13	was	be	VBD
18637	1598	14	shown	show	VBN
18637	1598	15	that	that	IN
18637	1598	16	the	the	DT
18637	1598	17	word	word	NN
18637	1598	18	"	"	``
18637	1598	19	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1598	20	"	"	''
18637	1598	21	in	in	IN
18637	1598	22	the	the	DT
18637	1598	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	1598	24	had	have	VBD
18637	1598	25	come	come	VBN
18637	1598	26	in	in	IN
18637	1598	27	practice	practice	NN
18637	1598	28	to	to	TO
18637	1598	29	refer	refer	VB
18637	1598	30	"	"	''
18637	1598	31	to	to	IN
18637	1598	32	the	the	DT
18637	1598	33	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	1598	34	occasioned	occasion	VBN
18637	1598	35	by	by	IN
18637	1598	36	the	the	DT
18637	1598	37	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	1598	38	of	of	IN
18637	1598	39	other	other	JJ
18637	1598	40	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	1598	41	of	of	IN
18637	1598	42	the	the	DT
18637	1598	43	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1598	44	,	,	,
18637	1598	45	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	1598	46	every	every	DT
18637	1598	47	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1598	48	of	of	IN
18637	1598	49	'	'	``
18637	1598	50	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1598	51	powers	power	NNS
18637	1598	52	'	'	POS
18637	1598	53	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	1598	54	the	the	DT
18637	1598	55	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	1598	56	of	of	IN
18637	1598	57	the	the	DT
18637	1598	58	two	two	CD
18637	1598	59	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	1598	60	"	"	''
18637	1598	61	;	;	:
18637	1598	62	or	or	CC
18637	1598	63	more	more	JJR
18637	1598	64	briefly	briefly	RB
18637	1598	65	,	,	,
18637	1598	66	"	"	``
18637	1598	67	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1598	68	"	"	''
18637	1598	69	here	here	RB
18637	1598	70	means	mean	VBZ
18637	1598	71	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1598	72	if	if	IN
18637	1598	73	an	an	DT
18637	1598	74	"	"	``
18637	1598	75	order	order	NN
18637	1598	76	,	,	,
18637	1598	77	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	1598	78	,	,	,
18637	1598	79	or	or	CC
18637	1598	80	vote	vote	NN
18637	1598	81	"	"	''
18637	1598	82	is	be	VBZ
18637	1598	83	to	to	TO
18637	1598	84	have	have	VB
18637	1598	85	the	the	DT
18637	1598	86	force	force	NN
18637	1598	87	of	of	IN
18637	1598	88	law	law	NN
18637	1598	89	.	.	.
18637	1599	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	1599	2	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	1599	3	have	have	VBP
18637	1599	4	come	come	VBN
18637	1599	5	to	to	TO
18637	1599	6	be	be	VB
18637	1599	7	termed	term	VBN
18637	1599	8	"	"	``
18637	1599	9	joint	joint	JJ
18637	1599	10	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	1599	11	"	"	''
18637	1599	12	and	and	CC
18637	1599	13	stand	stand	VB
18637	1599	14	on	on	IN
18637	1599	15	a	a	DT
18637	1599	16	level	level	NN
18637	1599	17	with	with	IN
18637	1599	18	"	"	``
18637	1599	19	bills	bill	NNS
18637	1599	20	,	,	,
18637	1599	21	"	"	''
18637	1599	22	which	which	WDT
18637	1599	23	if	if	IN
18637	1599	24	"	"	``
18637	1599	25	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	1599	26	"	"	''
18637	1599	27	become	become	VBN
18637	1599	28	Statutes	statute	NNS
18637	1599	29	.	.	.
18637	1600	1	But	but	CC
18637	1600	2	"	"	``
18637	1600	3	votes	vote	NNS
18637	1600	4	"	"	''
18637	1600	5	taken	take	VBN
18637	1600	6	in	in	RP
18637	1600	7	either	either	CC
18637	1600	8	House	House	NNP
18637	1600	9	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	1600	10	to	to	IN
18637	1600	11	the	the	DT
18637	1600	12	final	final	JJ
18637	1600	13	passage	passage	NN
18637	1600	14	of	of	IN
18637	1600	15	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1600	16	need	nee	MD
18637	1600	17	not	not	RB
18637	1600	18	be	be	VB
18637	1600	19	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	1600	20	to	to	IN
18637	1600	21	the	the	DT
18637	1600	22	President	President	NNP
18637	1600	23	,	,	,
18637	1600	24	nor	nor	CC
18637	1600	25	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	1600	26	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1600	27	by	by	IN
18637	1600	28	the	the	DT
18637	1600	29	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	1600	30	concurrently	concurrently	RB
18637	1600	31	with	with	IN
18637	1600	32	a	a	DT
18637	1600	33	view	view	NN
18637	1600	34	to	to	IN
18637	1600	35	expressing	express	VBG
18637	1600	36	an	an	DT
18637	1600	37	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1600	38	or	or	CC
18637	1600	39	to	to	IN
18637	1600	40	devising	devise	VBG
18637	1600	41	a	a	DT
18637	1600	42	common	common	JJ
18637	1600	43	program	program	NN
18637	1600	44	of	of	IN
18637	1600	45	action	action	NN
18637	1600	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1600	47	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	1600	48	,	,	,
18637	1600	49	the	the	DT
18637	1600	50	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	1600	51	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	1600	52	by	by	IN
18637	1600	53	which	which	WDT
18637	1600	54	during	during	IN
18637	1600	55	the	the	DT
18637	1600	56	fight	fight	NN
18637	1600	57	over	over	IN
18637	1600	58	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
18637	1600	59	the	the	DT
18637	1600	60	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	1600	61	States	States	NNPS
18637	1600	62	were	be	VBD
18637	1600	63	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	1600	64	from	from	IN
18637	1600	65	representation	representation	NN
18637	1600	66	in	in	IN
18637	1600	67	the	the	DT
18637	1600	68	House	House	NNP
18637	1600	69	and	and	CC
18637	1600	70	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	1600	71	,	,	,
18637	1600	72	the	the	DT
18637	1600	73	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	1600	74	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	1600	75	on	on	IN
18637	1600	76	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
18637	1600	77	containing	contain	VBG
18637	1600	78	members	member	NNS
18637	1600	79	from	from	IN
18637	1600	80	both	both	DT
18637	1600	81	Houses	Houses	NNP
18637	1600	82	was	be	VBD
18637	1600	83	created	create	VBN
18637	1600	84	,	,	,
18637	1600	85	etc	etc	FW
18637	1600	86	.	.	.
18637	1601	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1601	2	,	,	,
18637	1601	3	or	or	CC
18637	1601	4	to	to	IN
18637	1601	5	directing	direct	VBG
18637	1601	6	the	the	DT
18637	1601	7	expenditure	expenditure	NN
18637	1601	8	of	of	IN
18637	1601	9	money	money	NN
18637	1601	10	appropriated	appropriate	VBN
18637	1601	11	to	to	IN
18637	1601	12	the	the	DT
18637	1601	13	use	use	NN
18637	1601	14	of	of	IN
18637	1601	15	the	the	DT
18637	1601	16	two	two	CD
18637	1601	17	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	1601	18	.	.	.
18637	1602	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1602	2	211	211	CD
18637	1602	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1602	4	Within	within	IN
18637	1602	5	recent	recent	JJ
18637	1602	6	years	year	NNS
18637	1602	7	the	the	DT
18637	1602	8	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	1602	9	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	1602	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	1602	11	been	be	VBN
18637	1602	12	put	put	VBN
18637	1602	13	to	to	IN
18637	1602	14	a	a	DT
18637	1602	15	new	new	JJ
18637	1602	16	use	use	NN
18637	1602	17	--	--	:
18637	1602	18	the	the	DT
18637	1602	19	termination	termination	NN
18637	1602	20	of	of	IN
18637	1602	21	powers	power	NNS
18637	1602	22	delegated	delegate	VBD
18637	1602	23	to	to	IN
18637	1602	24	the	the	DT
18637	1602	25	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1602	26	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	1602	27	,	,	,
18637	1602	28	or	or	CC
18637	1602	29	the	the	DT
18637	1602	30	disapproval	disapproval	NN
18637	1602	31	of	of	IN
18637	1602	32	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1602	33	exercises	exercise	NNS
18637	1602	34	of	of	IN
18637	1602	35	power	power	NN
18637	1602	36	by	by	IN
18637	1602	37	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1602	38	.	.	.
18637	1603	1	Most	Most	JJS
18637	1603	2	of	of	IN
18637	1603	3	the	the	DT
18637	1603	4	important	important	JJ
18637	1603	5	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1603	6	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	1603	7	for	for	IN
18637	1603	8	the	the	DT
18637	1603	9	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	1603	10	of	of	IN
18637	1603	11	World	World	NNP
18637	1603	12	War	War	NNP
18637	1603	13	II	II	NNP
18637	1603	14	provided	provide	VBD
18637	1603	15	that	that	IN
18637	1603	16	the	the	DT
18637	1603	17	powers	power	NNS
18637	1603	18	granted	grant	VBD
18637	1603	19	to	to	IN
18637	1603	20	the	the	DT
18637	1603	21	President	President	NNP
18637	1603	22	should	should	MD
18637	1603	23	come	come	VB
18637	1603	24	to	to	IN
18637	1603	25	an	an	DT
18637	1603	26	end	end	NN
18637	1603	27	upon	upon	IN
18637	1603	28	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	1603	29	of	of	IN
18637	1603	30	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	1603	31	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	1603	32	to	to	IN
18637	1603	33	that	that	DT
18637	1603	34	effect	effect	NN
18637	1603	35	.	.	.
18637	1604	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1604	2	212	212	CD
18637	1604	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1604	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	1604	5	,	,	,
18637	1604	6	measures	measure	NNS
18637	1604	7	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	1604	8	the	the	DT
18637	1604	9	President	President	NNP
18637	1604	10	to	to	TO
18637	1604	11	reorganize	reorganize	VB
18637	1604	12	executive	executive	JJ
18637	1604	13	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	1604	14	have	have	VBP
18637	1604	15	provided	provide	VBN
18637	1604	16	that	that	IN
18637	1604	17	a	a	DT
18637	1604	18	Reorganization	Reorganization	NNP
18637	1604	19	Plan	Plan	NNP
18637	1604	20	promulgated	promulgate	VBN
18637	1604	21	by	by	IN
18637	1604	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1604	23	should	should	MD
18637	1604	24	be	be	VB
18637	1604	25	reported	report	VBN
18637	1604	26	by	by	IN
18637	1604	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1604	28	and	and	CC
18637	1604	29	should	should	MD
18637	1604	30	not	not	RB
18637	1604	31	become	become	VB
18637	1604	32	effective	effective	JJ
18637	1604	33	if	if	IN
18637	1604	34	one[213	one[213	CD
18637	1604	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1604	36	or	or	CC
18637	1604	37	both[214	both[214	NNP
18637	1604	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1604	39	Houses	house	NNS
18637	1604	40	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	1604	41	a	a	DT
18637	1604	42	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	1604	43	disapproving	disapprove	VBG
18637	1604	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1604	45	.	.	.
18637	1605	1	Also	also	RB
18637	1605	2	,	,	,
18637	1605	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1605	4	was	be	VBD
18637	1605	5	settled	settle	VBN
18637	1605	6	as	as	RB
18637	1605	7	early	early	RB
18637	1605	8	as	as	IN
18637	1605	9	1789	1789	CD
18637	1605	10	that	that	IN
18637	1605	11	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	1605	12	of	of	IN
18637	1605	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1605	14	proposing	propose	VBG
18637	1605	15	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	1605	16	to	to	IN
18637	1605	17	the	the	DT
18637	1605	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1605	19	need	nee	MD
18637	1605	20	not	not	RB
18637	1605	21	be	be	VB
18637	1605	22	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	1605	23	to	to	IN
18637	1605	24	the	the	DT
18637	1605	25	President	President	NNP
18637	1605	26	,	,	,
18637	1605	27	the	the	DT
18637	1605	28	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	1605	29	of	of	IN
18637	1605	30	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	1605	31	having	have	VBG
18637	1605	32	been	be	VBN
18637	1605	33	referred	refer	VBN
18637	1605	34	to	to	IN
18637	1605	35	the	the	DT
18637	1605	36	States	state	NNS
18637	1605	37	without	without	IN
18637	1605	38	being	be	VBG
18637	1605	39	laid	lay	VBN
18637	1605	40	before	before	IN
18637	1605	41	President	President	NNP
18637	1605	42	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	1605	43	for	for	IN
18637	1605	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1605	45	approval	approval	NN
18637	1605	46	--	--	:
18637	1605	47	a	a	DT
18637	1605	48	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	1605	49	which	which	WDT
18637	1605	50	the	the	DT
18637	1605	51	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1605	52	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	1605	53	in	in	IN
18637	1605	54	due	due	JJ
18637	1605	55	course	course	NN
18637	1605	56	.	.	.
18637	1606	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1606	2	215	215	CD
18637	1606	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1606	4	Section	section	NN
18637	1606	5	8	8	CD
18637	1606	6	.	.	.
18637	1607	1	The	the	DT
18637	1607	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1607	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	1607	4	have	have	VB
18637	1607	5	Power	power	NN
18637	1607	6	to	to	TO
18637	1607	7	lay	lay	VB
18637	1607	8	and	and	CC
18637	1607	9	collect	collect	VB
18637	1607	10	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1607	11	,	,	,
18637	1607	12	Duties	Duties	NNPS
18637	1607	13	,	,	,
18637	1607	14	Imposts	Imposts	NNPS
18637	1607	15	and	and	CC
18637	1607	16	Excises	Excises	NNPS
18637	1607	17	,	,	,
18637	1607	18	to	to	TO
18637	1607	19	pay	pay	VB
18637	1607	20	the	the	DT
18637	1607	21	Debts	debt	NNS
18637	1607	22	and	and	CC
18637	1607	23	provide	provide	VB
18637	1607	24	for	for	IN
18637	1607	25	the	the	DT
18637	1607	26	common	common	JJ
18637	1607	27	Defence	Defence	NNP
18637	1607	28	and	and	CC
18637	1607	29	general	general	JJ
18637	1607	30	Welfare	Welfare	NNP
18637	1607	31	of	of	IN
18637	1607	32	the	the	DT
18637	1607	33	United	United	NNP
18637	1607	34	States	States	NNP
18637	1607	35	;	;	:
18637	1607	36	but	but	CC
18637	1607	37	all	all	DT
18637	1607	38	Duties	Duties	NNPS
18637	1607	39	,	,	,
18637	1607	40	Imposts	Imposts	NNPS
18637	1607	41	and	and	CC
18637	1607	42	Excises	excise	NNS
18637	1607	43	shall	shall	MD
18637	1607	44	be	be	VB
18637	1607	45	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	1607	46	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	1607	47	the	the	DT
18637	1607	48	United	United	NNP
18637	1607	49	States	States	NNP
18637	1607	50	.	.	.
18637	1608	1	The	the	DT
18637	1608	2	Taxing	tax	VBG
18637	1608	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	1608	4	Spending	spend	VBG
18637	1608	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1608	6	KINDS	kind	NNS
18637	1608	7	OF	of	IN
18637	1608	8	TAXES	taxis	NNS
18637	1608	9	PERMITTED	permit	VBN
18637	1608	10	By	by	IN
18637	1608	11	the	the	DT
18637	1608	12	terms	term	NNS
18637	1608	13	of	of	IN
18637	1608	14	the	the	DT
18637	1608	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1608	16	,	,	,
18637	1608	17	the	the	DT
18637	1608	18	power	power	NN
18637	1608	19	of	of	IN
18637	1608	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1608	21	to	to	TO
18637	1608	22	levy	levy	VB
18637	1608	23	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1608	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	1608	25	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1608	26	to	to	IN
18637	1608	27	but	but	CC
18637	1608	28	one	one	CD
18637	1608	29	exception	exception	NN
18637	1608	30	and	and	CC
18637	1608	31	two	two	CD
18637	1608	32	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	1608	33	.	.	.
18637	1609	1	Articles	article	NNS
18637	1609	2	exported	export	VBN
18637	1609	3	from	from	IN
18637	1609	4	any	any	DT
18637	1609	5	State	State	NNP
18637	1609	6	may	may	MD
18637	1609	7	not	not	RB
18637	1609	8	be	be	VB
18637	1609	9	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	1609	10	at	at	RB
18637	1609	11	all	all	RB
18637	1609	12	.	.	.
18637	1610	1	Direct	direct	JJ
18637	1610	2	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1610	3	must	must	MD
18637	1610	4	be	be	VB
18637	1610	5	levied	levy	VBN
18637	1610	6	by	by	IN
18637	1610	7	the	the	DT
18637	1610	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	1610	9	of	of	IN
18637	1610	10	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	1610	11	and	and	CC
18637	1610	12	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	1610	13	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1610	14	by	by	IN
18637	1610	15	the	the	DT
18637	1610	16	rule	rule	NN
18637	1610	17	of	of	IN
18637	1610	18	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	1610	19	.	.	.
18637	1611	1	The	the	DT
18637	1611	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1611	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	1611	4	emphasized	emphasize	VBN
18637	1611	5	the	the	DT
18637	1611	6	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	1611	7	character	character	NN
18637	1611	8	of	of	IN
18637	1611	9	this	this	DT
18637	1611	10	power	power	NN
18637	1611	11	by	by	IN
18637	1611	12	saying	say	VBG
18637	1611	13	from	from	IN
18637	1611	14	time	time	NN
18637	1611	15	to	to	IN
18637	1611	16	time	time	NN
18637	1611	17	that	that	IN
18637	1611	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1611	19	"	"	``
18637	1611	20	reaches	reach	VBZ
18637	1611	21	every	every	DT
18637	1611	22	subject,"[216	subject,"[216	NN
18637	1611	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1611	24	that	that	IN
18637	1611	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1611	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	1611	27	"	"	``
18637	1611	28	exhaustive"[217	exhaustive"[217	NN
18637	1611	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1611	30	or	or	CC
18637	1611	31	that	that	IN
18637	1611	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1611	33	"	"	``
18637	1611	34	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	1611	35	every	every	DT
18637	1611	36	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
18637	1611	37	power	power	NN
18637	1611	38	of	of	IN
18637	1611	39	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1611	40	.	.	.
18637	1612	1	"	"	``
18637	1612	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1612	3	218	218	CD
18637	1612	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1612	5	Despite	despite	IN
18637	1612	6	these	these	DT
18637	1612	7	generalizations	generalization	NNS
18637	1612	8	,	,	,
18637	1612	9	the	the	DT
18637	1612	10	power	power	NN
18637	1612	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	1612	12	been	be	VBN
18637	1612	13	at	at	IN
18637	1612	14	times	time	NNS
18637	1612	15	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	1612	16	curtailed	curtail	VBN
18637	1612	17	by	by	IN
18637	1612	18	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1612	19	decision	decision	NN
18637	1612	20	with	with	IN
18637	1612	21	respect	respect	NN
18637	1612	22	to	to	IN
18637	1612	23	the	the	DT
18637	1612	24	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1612	25	matter	matter	NN
18637	1612	26	of	of	IN
18637	1612	27	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1612	28	,	,	,
18637	1612	29	the	the	DT
18637	1612	30	manner	manner	NN
18637	1612	31	in	in	IN
18637	1612	32	which	which	WDT
18637	1612	33	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1612	34	are	be	VBP
18637	1612	35	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	1612	36	,	,	,
18637	1612	37	and	and	CC
18637	1612	38	the	the	DT
18637	1612	39	objects	object	NNS
18637	1612	40	for	for	IN
18637	1612	41	which	which	WDT
18637	1612	42	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1612	43	may	may	MD
18637	1612	44	be	be	VB
18637	1612	45	levied	levy	VBN
18637	1612	46	.	.	.
18637	1613	1	DECLINE	DECLINE	NNS
18637	1613	2	OF	of	IN
18637	1613	3	THE	the	DT
18637	1613	4	FORBIDDEN	FORBIDDEN	NNP
18637	1613	5	SUBJECT	SUBJECT	NNS
18637	1613	6	MATTER	matter	NN
18637	1613	7	TEST	test	NN
18637	1613	8	In	in	IN
18637	1613	9	recent	recent	JJ
18637	1613	10	years	year	NNS
18637	1613	11	the	the	DT
18637	1613	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1613	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1613	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	1613	15	restored	restore	VBN
18637	1613	16	to	to	IN
18637	1613	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1613	18	the	the	DT
18637	1613	19	power	power	NN
18637	1613	20	to	to	TO
18637	1613	21	tax	tax	VB
18637	1613	22	most	most	JJS
18637	1613	23	of	of	IN
18637	1613	24	the	the	DT
18637	1613	25	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1613	26	matter	matter	NN
18637	1613	27	which	which	WDT
18637	1613	28	had	have	VBD
18637	1613	29	previously	previously	RB
18637	1613	30	been	be	VBN
18637	1613	31	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	1613	32	from	from	IN
18637	1613	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1613	34	reach	reach	NN
18637	1613	35	by	by	IN
18637	1613	36	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1613	37	decision	decision	NN
18637	1613	38	.	.	.
18637	1614	1	The	the	DT
18637	1614	2	holding	holding	NN
18637	1614	3	of	of	IN
18637	1614	4	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	1614	5	_	_	NNP
18637	1614	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	1614	7	_	_	NNP
18637	1614	8	Gore[219	Gore[219	NNP
18637	1614	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1614	10	and	and	CC
18637	1614	11	Miles	Miles	NNP
18637	1614	12	_	_	NNP
18637	1614	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	1614	14	_	_	NNP
18637	1614	15	Graham[220	Graham[220	NNP
18637	1614	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1614	17	that	that	IN
18637	1614	18	the	the	DT
18637	1614	19	inclusion	inclusion	NN
18637	1614	20	of	of	IN
18637	1614	21	the	the	DT
18637	1614	22	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	1614	23	received	receive	VBN
18637	1614	24	by	by	IN
18637	1614	25	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1614	26	judges	judge	NNS
18637	1614	27	in	in	IN
18637	1614	28	measuring	measure	VBG
18637	1614	29	the	the	DT
18637	1614	30	liability	liability	NN
18637	1614	31	for	for	IN
18637	1614	32	a	a	DT
18637	1614	33	nondiscriminatory	nondiscriminatory	JJ
18637	1614	34	income	income	NN
18637	1614	35	tax	tax	NN
18637	1614	36	violated	violate	VBD
18637	1614	37	the	the	DT
18637	1614	38	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1614	39	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	1614	40	that	that	IN
18637	1614	41	the	the	DT
18637	1614	42	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	1614	43	of	of	IN
18637	1614	44	such	such	JJ
18637	1614	45	judges	judge	NNS
18637	1614	46	should	should	MD
18637	1614	47	not	not	RB
18637	1614	48	be	be	VB
18637	1614	49	diminished	diminish	VBN
18637	1614	50	during	during	IN
18637	1614	51	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1614	52	continuance	continuance	NN
18637	1614	53	in	in	IN
18637	1614	54	office	office	NN
18637	1614	55	was	be	VBD
18637	1614	56	repudiated	repudiate	VBN
18637	1614	57	in	in	IN
18637	1614	58	O'Malley	O'Malley	NNP
18637	1614	59	_	_	NNP
18637	1614	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	1614	61	_	_	NNP
18637	1614	62	Woodrough	Woodrough	NNP
18637	1614	63	.	.	.
18637	1615	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1615	2	221	221	CD
18637	1615	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1615	4	The	the	DT
18637	1615	5	specific	specific	JJ
18637	1615	6	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	1615	7	of	of	IN
18637	1615	8	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	1615	9	_	_	NNP
18637	1615	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	1615	11	_	_	NNP
18637	1615	12	Day[222	Day[222	NNP
18637	1615	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1615	14	that	that	IN
18637	1615	15	the	the	DT
18637	1615	16	salary	salary	NN
18637	1615	17	of	of	IN
18637	1615	18	a	a	DT
18637	1615	19	State	state	NN
18637	1615	20	officer	officer	NN
18637	1615	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	1615	22	immune	immune	JJ
18637	1615	23	to	to	IN
18637	1615	24	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1615	25	income	income	NN
18637	1615	26	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1615	27	also	also	RB
18637	1615	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	1615	29	been	be	VBN
18637	1615	30	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	1615	31	.	.	.
18637	1616	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1616	2	223	223	CD
18637	1616	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1616	4	But	but	CC
18637	1616	5	the	the	DT
18637	1616	6	principle	principle	NN
18637	1616	7	underlying	underlie	VBG
18637	1616	8	that	that	DT
18637	1616	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	1616	10	--	--	:
18637	1616	11	that	that	IN
18637	1616	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1616	13	may	may	MD
18637	1616	14	not	not	RB
18637	1616	15	lay	lay	VB
18637	1616	16	a	a	DT
18637	1616	17	tax	tax	NN
18637	1616	18	which	which	WDT
18637	1616	19	would	would	MD
18637	1616	20	impair	impair	VB
18637	1616	21	the	the	DT
18637	1616	22	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	1616	23	of	of	IN
18637	1616	24	the	the	DT
18637	1616	25	States	States	NNPS
18637	1616	26	--	--	:
18637	1616	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	1616	28	still	still	RB
18637	1616	29	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	1616	30	as	as	IN
18637	1616	31	retaining	retain	VBG
18637	1616	32	some	some	DT
18637	1616	33	vitality	vitality	NN
18637	1616	34	.	.	.
18637	1617	1	THE	the	DT
18637	1617	2	RISE	RISE	NNP
18637	1617	3	AND	and	CC
18637	1617	4	FALL	FALL	NNP
18637	1617	5	OF	of	IN
18637	1617	6	COLLECTOR	COLLECTOR	NNP
18637	1617	7	_	_	NNP
18637	1617	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	1617	9	_	_	NNP
18637	1617	10	DAY	DAY	NNP
18637	1617	11	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	1617	12	_	_	NNP
18637	1617	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	1617	14	_	_	NNP
18637	1617	15	Day	Day	NNP
18637	1617	16	was	be	VBD
18637	1617	17	decided	decide	VBN
18637	1617	18	in	in	IN
18637	1617	19	1871	1871	CD
18637	1617	20	while	while	IN
18637	1617	21	the	the	DT
18637	1617	22	country	country	NN
18637	1617	23	was	be	VBD
18637	1617	24	still	still	RB
18637	1617	25	in	in	IN
18637	1617	26	the	the	DT
18637	1617	27	throes	throe	NNS
18637	1617	28	of	of	IN
18637	1617	29	reconstruction	reconstruction	NN
18637	1617	30	.	.	.
18637	1618	1	As	as	IN
18637	1618	2	noted	note	VBN
18637	1618	3	by	by	IN
18637	1618	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1618	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1618	6	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	1618	7	in	in	IN
18637	1618	8	a	a	DT
18637	1618	9	footnote	footnote	NN
18637	1618	10	to	to	IN
18637	1618	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1618	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1618	13	in	in	IN
18637	1618	14	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	1618	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1618	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	1618	17	_	_	NNP
18637	1618	18	Gerhardt,[224	Gerhardt,[224	NNP
18637	1618	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1618	20	the	the	DT
18637	1618	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1618	22	had	have	VBD
18637	1618	23	not	not	RB
18637	1618	24	then	then	RB
18637	1618	25	determined	determine	VBN
18637	1618	26	how	how	WRB
18637	1618	27	far	far	RB
18637	1618	28	the	the	DT
18637	1618	29	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	1618	30	War	War	NNP
18637	1618	31	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	1618	32	had	have	VBD
18637	1618	33	broadened	broaden	VBN
18637	1618	34	the	the	DT
18637	1618	35	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1618	36	power	power	NN
18637	1618	37	at	at	IN
18637	1618	38	the	the	DT
18637	1618	39	expense	expense	NN
18637	1618	40	of	of	IN
18637	1618	41	the	the	DT
18637	1618	42	States	States	NNPS
18637	1618	43	;	;	:
18637	1618	44	the	the	DT
18637	1618	45	fact	fact	NN
18637	1618	46	that	that	IN
18637	1618	47	the	the	DT
18637	1618	48	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	1618	49	power	power	NN
18637	1618	50	had	have	VBD
18637	1618	51	recently	recently	RB
18637	1618	52	been	be	VBN
18637	1618	53	used	use	VBN
18637	1618	54	with	with	IN
18637	1618	55	destructive	destructive	JJ
18637	1618	56	effect	effect	NN
18637	1618	57	upon	upon	IN
18637	1618	58	notes	note	NNS
18637	1618	59	issued	issue	VBN
18637	1618	60	by	by	IN
18637	1618	61	State	State	NNP
18637	1618	62	banks[225	banks[225	NNP
18637	1618	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1618	64	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	1618	65	the	the	DT
18637	1618	66	possibility	possibility	NN
18637	1618	67	of	of	IN
18637	1618	68	similar	similar	JJ
18637	1618	69	attacks	attack	NNS
18637	1618	70	upon	upon	IN
18637	1618	71	the	the	DT
18637	1618	72	existence	existence	NN
18637	1618	73	of	of	IN
18637	1618	74	the	the	DT
18637	1618	75	States	States	NNP
18637	1618	76	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1618	77	.	.	.
18637	1619	1	Two	two	CD
18637	1619	2	years	year	NNS
18637	1619	3	later	later	RBR
18637	1619	4	the	the	DT
18637	1619	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1619	6	took	take	VBD
18637	1619	7	the	the	DT
18637	1619	8	logical	logical	JJ
18637	1619	9	further	further	JJ
18637	1619	10	step	step	NN
18637	1619	11	of	of	IN
18637	1619	12	holding	hold	VBG
18637	1619	13	that	that	IN
18637	1619	14	the	the	DT
18637	1619	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1619	16	income	income	NN
18637	1619	17	tax	tax	NN
18637	1619	18	could	could	MD
18637	1619	19	not	not	RB
18637	1619	20	be	be	VB
18637	1619	21	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	1619	22	on	on	IN
18637	1619	23	income	income	NN
18637	1619	24	received	receive	VBN
18637	1619	25	by	by	IN
18637	1619	26	a	a	DT
18637	1619	27	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	1619	28	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	1619	29	from	from	IN
18637	1619	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1619	31	investments	investment	NNS
18637	1619	32	.	.	.
18637	1620	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1620	2	226	226	CD
18637	1620	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1620	4	A	a	DT
18637	1620	5	far	far	RB
18637	1620	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	1620	7	reaching	reach	VBG
18637	1620	8	extension	extension	NN
18637	1620	9	of	of	IN
18637	1620	10	private	private	JJ
18637	1620	11	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	1620	12	was	be	VBD
18637	1620	13	granted	grant	VBN
18637	1620	14	in	in	IN
18637	1620	15	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	1620	16	_	_	NNP
18637	1620	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	1620	18	_	_	NNP
18637	1620	19	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	1620	20	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	1620	21	and	and	CC
18637	1620	22	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	1620	23	Co	Co	NNP
18637	1620	24	.	.	.
18637	1620	25	,[227	,[227	NFP
18637	1620	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1620	27	where	where	WRB
18637	1620	28	interest	interest	NN
18637	1620	29	received	receive	VBN
18637	1620	30	by	by	IN
18637	1620	31	a	a	DT
18637	1620	32	private	private	JJ
18637	1620	33	investor	investor	NN
18637	1620	34	on	on	IN
18637	1620	35	State	State	NNP
18637	1620	36	or	or	CC
18637	1620	37	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	1620	38	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	1620	39	was	be	VBD
18637	1620	40	held	hold	VBN
18637	1620	41	to	to	TO
18637	1620	42	be	be	VB
18637	1620	43	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	1620	44	from	from	IN
18637	1620	45	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1620	46	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1620	47	.	.	.
18637	1621	1	As	as	IN
18637	1621	2	the	the	DT
18637	1621	3	apprehensions	apprehension	NNS
18637	1621	4	of	of	IN
18637	1621	5	this	this	DT
18637	1621	6	era	era	NN
18637	1621	7	subsided	subside	VBD
18637	1621	8	,	,	,
18637	1621	9	the	the	DT
18637	1621	10	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1621	11	of	of	IN
18637	1621	12	these	these	DT
18637	1621	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	1621	14	was	be	VBD
18637	1621	15	pushed	push	VBN
18637	1621	16	into	into	IN
18637	1621	17	the	the	DT
18637	1621	18	background	background	NN
18637	1621	19	.	.	.
18637	1622	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1622	2	never	never	RB
18637	1622	3	received	receive	VBD
18637	1622	4	the	the	DT
18637	1622	5	same	same	JJ
18637	1622	6	wide	wide	JJ
18637	1622	7	application	application	NN
18637	1622	8	as	as	IN
18637	1622	9	did	do	VBD
18637	1622	10	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	1622	11	_	_	NNP
18637	1622	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	1622	13	_	_	NNP
18637	1622	14	Maryland[228	Maryland[228	NNP
18637	1622	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1622	16	in	in	IN
18637	1622	17	curbing	curb	VBG
18637	1622	18	the	the	DT
18637	1622	19	power	power	NN
18637	1622	20	of	of	IN
18637	1622	21	the	the	DT
18637	1622	22	States	States	NNPS
18637	1622	23	to	to	TO
18637	1622	24	tax	tax	VB
18637	1622	25	operations	operation	NNS
18637	1622	26	or	or	CC
18637	1622	27	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	1622	28	of	of	IN
18637	1622	29	the	the	DT
18637	1622	30	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1622	31	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1622	32	.	.	.
18637	1623	1	Only	only	RB
18637	1623	2	once	once	RB
18637	1623	3	since	since	IN
18637	1623	4	the	the	DT
18637	1623	5	turn	turn	NN
18637	1623	6	of	of	IN
18637	1623	7	the	the	DT
18637	1623	8	century	century	NN
18637	1623	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	1623	10	the	the	DT
18637	1623	11	national	national	JJ
18637	1623	12	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	1623	13	power	power	NN
18637	1623	14	been	be	VBN
18637	1623	15	further	further	RB
18637	1623	16	narrowed	narrow	VBN
18637	1623	17	in	in	IN
18637	1623	18	the	the	DT
18637	1623	19	name	name	NN
18637	1623	20	of	of	IN
18637	1623	21	Dual	Dual	NNP
18637	1623	22	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	1623	23	.	.	.
18637	1624	1	In	in	IN
18637	1624	2	1931	1931	CD
18637	1624	3	the	the	DT
18637	1624	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1624	5	held	hold	VBD
18637	1624	6	that	that	IN
18637	1624	7	a	a	DT
18637	1624	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1624	9	excise	excise	NN
18637	1624	10	tax	tax	NN
18637	1624	11	was	be	VBD
18637	1624	12	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	1624	13	to	to	IN
18637	1624	14	the	the	DT
18637	1624	15	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	1624	16	and	and	CC
18637	1624	17	sale	sale	NN
18637	1624	18	to	to	IN
18637	1624	19	a	a	DT
18637	1624	20	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	1624	21	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	1624	22	of	of	IN
18637	1624	23	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	1624	24	for	for	IN
18637	1624	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1624	26	police	police	NN
18637	1624	27	force	force	NN
18637	1624	28	.	.	.
18637	1625	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1625	2	229	229	CD
18637	1625	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1625	4	Justices	Justices	NNP
18637	1625	5	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	1625	6	and	and	CC
18637	1625	7	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	1625	8	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	1625	9	from	from	IN
18637	1625	10	this	this	DT
18637	1625	11	decision	decision	NN
18637	1625	12	and	and	CC
18637	1625	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1625	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	1625	15	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
18637	1625	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	1625	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1625	18	would	would	MD
18637	1625	19	be	be	VB
18637	1625	20	followed	follow	VBN
18637	1625	21	today	today	NN
18637	1625	22	.	.	.
18637	1626	1	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	1626	2	TAXATION	taxation	NN
18637	1626	3	OF	of	IN
18637	1626	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	1626	5	INTERESTS	INTERESTS	NNP
18637	1626	6	Within	within	IN
18637	1626	7	a	a	DT
18637	1626	8	decade	decade	NN
18637	1626	9	after	after	IN
18637	1626	10	the	the	DT
18637	1626	11	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	1626	12	decision	decision	NN
18637	1626	13	the	the	DT
18637	1626	14	retreat	retreat	NN
18637	1626	15	from	from	IN
18637	1626	16	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	1626	17	_	_	NNP
18637	1626	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	1626	19	_	_	NNP
18637	1626	20	Day	Day	NNP
18637	1626	21	began	begin	VBD
18637	1626	22	.	.	.
18637	1627	1	In	in	IN
18637	1627	2	1903	1903	CD
18637	1627	3	,	,	,
18637	1627	4	a	a	DT
18637	1627	5	succession	succession	NN
18637	1627	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	1627	7	upon	upon	IN
18637	1627	8	a	a	DT
18637	1627	9	bequest	bequest	NN
18637	1627	10	to	to	IN
18637	1627	11	a	a	DT
18637	1627	12	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	1627	13	for	for	IN
18637	1627	14	public	public	JJ
18637	1627	15	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	1627	16	was	be	VBD
18637	1627	17	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	1627	18	on	on	IN
18637	1627	19	the	the	DT
18637	1627	20	ground	ground	NN
18637	1627	21	that	that	IN
18637	1627	22	the	the	DT
18637	1627	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	1627	24	was	be	VBD
18637	1627	25	payable	payable	JJ
18637	1627	26	out	out	IN
18637	1627	27	of	of	IN
18637	1627	28	the	the	DT
18637	1627	29	estate	estate	NN
18637	1627	30	before	before	IN
18637	1627	31	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	1627	32	to	to	IN
18637	1627	33	the	the	DT
18637	1627	34	legatee	legatee	NN
18637	1627	35	.	.	.
18637	1628	1	Looking	look	VBG
18637	1628	2	to	to	TO
18637	1628	3	form	form	VB
18637	1628	4	and	and	CC
18637	1628	5	not	not	RB
18637	1628	6	to	to	TO
18637	1628	7	substance	substance	VB
18637	1628	8	,	,	,
18637	1628	9	in	in	IN
18637	1628	10	disregard	disregard	NN
18637	1628	11	of	of	IN
18637	1628	12	the	the	DT
18637	1628	13	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	1628	14	of	of	IN
18637	1628	15	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	1628	16	_	_	NNP
18637	1628	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	1628	18	_	_	NNP
18637	1628	19	Maryland,[230	Maryland,[230	NNP
18637	1628	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1628	21	a	a	DT
18637	1628	22	closely	closely	RB
18637	1628	23	divided	divide	VBN
18637	1628	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1628	25	declined	decline	VBD
18637	1628	26	to	to	TO
18637	1628	27	"	"	``
18637	1628	28	regard	regard	VB
18637	1628	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1628	30	as	as	IN
18637	1628	31	a	a	DT
18637	1628	32	tax	tax	NN
18637	1628	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	1628	34	the	the	DT
18637	1628	35	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	1628	36	,	,	,
18637	1628	37	though	though	IN
18637	1628	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1628	39	might	may	MD
18637	1628	40	operate	operate	VB
18637	1628	41	incidentally	incidentally	RB
18637	1628	42	to	to	TO
18637	1628	43	reduce	reduce	VB
18637	1628	44	the	the	DT
18637	1628	45	bequest	bequest	NN
18637	1628	46	by	by	IN
18637	1628	47	the	the	DT
18637	1628	48	amount	amount	NN
18637	1628	49	of	of	IN
18637	1628	50	the	the	DT
18637	1628	51	tax	tax	NN
18637	1628	52	.	.	.
18637	1629	1	"	"	``
18637	1629	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1629	3	231	231	CD
18637	1629	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1629	5	When	when	WRB
18637	1629	6	South	South	NNP
18637	1629	7	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	1629	8	embarked	embark	VBD
18637	1629	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	1629	10	the	the	DT
18637	1629	11	business	business	NN
18637	1629	12	of	of	IN
18637	1629	13	dispensing	dispense	VBG
18637	1629	14	alcoholic	alcoholic	JJ
18637	1629	15	beverages	beverage	NNS
18637	1629	16	,	,	,
18637	1629	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1629	18	agents	agent	NNS
18637	1629	19	were	be	VBD
18637	1629	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	1629	21	to	to	TO
18637	1629	22	be	be	VB
18637	1629	23	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1629	24	to	to	IN
18637	1629	25	the	the	DT
18637	1629	26	national	national	JJ
18637	1629	27	internal	internal	NNP
18637	1629	28	revenue	revenue	NNP
18637	1629	29	tax	tax	NNP
18637	1629	30	,	,	,
18637	1629	31	the	the	DT
18637	1629	32	ground	ground	NN
18637	1629	33	of	of	IN
18637	1629	34	the	the	DT
18637	1629	35	holding	holding	NN
18637	1629	36	being	be	VBG
18637	1629	37	that	that	IN
18637	1629	38	in	in	IN
18637	1629	39	1787	1787	CD
18637	1629	40	such	such	PDT
18637	1629	41	a	a	DT
18637	1629	42	business	business	NN
18637	1629	43	was	be	VBD
18637	1629	44	not	not	RB
18637	1629	45	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	1629	46	as	as	IN
18637	1629	47	one	one	CD
18637	1629	48	of	of	IN
18637	1629	49	the	the	DT
18637	1629	50	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	1629	51	functions	function	NNS
18637	1629	52	of	of	IN
18637	1629	53	government	government	NN
18637	1629	54	.	.	.
18637	1630	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1630	2	232	232	CD
18637	1630	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1630	4	Another	another	DT
18637	1630	5	decision	decision	NN
18637	1630	6	marking	mark	VBG
18637	1630	7	a	a	DT
18637	1630	8	clear	clear	JJ
18637	1630	9	departure	departure	NN
18637	1630	10	from	from	IN
18637	1630	11	the	the	DT
18637	1630	12	logic	logic	NN
18637	1630	13	of	of	IN
18637	1630	14	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	1630	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1630	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	1630	17	_	_	NNP
18637	1630	18	Day	Day	NNP
18637	1630	19	was	be	VBD
18637	1630	20	Flint	Flint	NNP
18637	1630	21	_	_	NNP
18637	1630	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	1630	23	_	_	NNP
18637	1630	24	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	1630	25	Tracy	Tracy	NNP
18637	1630	26	Company,[233	Company,[233	NNP
18637	1630	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1630	28	where	where	WRB
18637	1630	29	the	the	DT
18637	1630	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1630	31	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1630	32	an	an	DT
18637	1630	33	act	act	NN
18637	1630	34	of	of	IN
18637	1630	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1630	36	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	1630	37	the	the	DT
18637	1630	38	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	1630	39	of	of	IN
18637	1630	40	doing	do	VBG
18637	1630	41	business	business	NN
18637	1630	42	as	as	IN
18637	1630	43	a	a	DT
18637	1630	44	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	1630	45	,	,	,
18637	1630	46	the	the	DT
18637	1630	47	tax	tax	NN
18637	1630	48	being	be	VBG
18637	1630	49	measured	measure	VBN
18637	1630	50	by	by	IN
18637	1630	51	the	the	DT
18637	1630	52	income	income	NN
18637	1630	53	.	.	.
18637	1631	1	The	the	DT
18637	1631	2	argument	argument	NN
18637	1631	3	that	that	IN
18637	1631	4	the	the	DT
18637	1631	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	1631	6	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	1631	7	an	an	DT
18637	1631	8	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	1631	9	burden	burden	NN
18637	1631	10	on	on	IN
18637	1631	11	the	the	DT
18637	1631	12	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1631	13	by	by	IN
18637	1631	14	a	a	DT
18637	1631	15	State	state	NN
18637	1631	16	of	of	IN
18637	1631	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1631	18	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	1631	19	power	power	NN
18637	1631	20	to	to	TO
18637	1631	21	create	create	VB
18637	1631	22	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	1631	23	franchises	franchise	NNS
18637	1631	24	was	be	VBD
18637	1631	25	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	1631	26	,	,	,
18637	1631	27	partly	partly	RB
18637	1631	28	in	in	IN
18637	1631	29	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	1631	30	of	of	IN
18637	1631	31	the	the	DT
18637	1631	32	principle	principle	NN
18637	1631	33	of	of	IN
18637	1631	34	national	national	JJ
18637	1631	35	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	1631	36	,	,	,
18637	1631	37	and	and	CC
18637	1631	38	partly	partly	RB
18637	1631	39	on	on	IN
18637	1631	40	the	the	DT
18637	1631	41	ground	ground	NN
18637	1631	42	that	that	IN
18637	1631	43	the	the	DT
18637	1631	44	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	1631	45	franchises	franchise	NNS
18637	1631	46	were	be	VBD
18637	1631	47	private	private	JJ
18637	1631	48	property	property	NN
18637	1631	49	.	.	.
18637	1632	1	This	this	DT
18637	1632	2	case	case	NN
18637	1632	3	also	also	RB
18637	1632	4	qualified	qualify	VBD
18637	1632	5	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	1632	6	_	_	NNP
18637	1632	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	1632	8	_	_	NNP
18637	1632	9	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	1632	10	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	1632	11	and	and	CC
18637	1632	12	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	1632	13	Company	Company	NNP
18637	1632	14	to	to	IN
18637	1632	15	the	the	DT
18637	1632	16	extent	extent	NN
18637	1632	17	of	of	IN
18637	1632	18	allowing	allow	VBG
18637	1632	19	interest	interest	NN
18637	1632	20	on	on	IN
18637	1632	21	State	State	NNP
18637	1632	22	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	1632	23	to	to	TO
18637	1632	24	be	be	VB
18637	1632	25	included	include	VBN
18637	1632	26	in	in	IN
18637	1632	27	measuring	measure	VBG
18637	1632	28	the	the	DT
18637	1632	29	tax	tax	NN
18637	1632	30	on	on	IN
18637	1632	31	the	the	DT
18637	1632	32	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	1632	33	.	.	.
18637	1633	1	Subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	1633	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	1633	3	have	have	VBP
18637	1633	4	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	1633	5	an	an	DT
18637	1633	6	estate	estate	NN
18637	1633	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	1633	8	on	on	IN
18637	1633	9	the	the	DT
18637	1633	10	net	net	JJ
18637	1633	11	estate	estate	NN
18637	1633	12	of	of	IN
18637	1633	13	a	a	DT
18637	1633	14	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	1633	15	,	,	,
18637	1633	16	including	include	VBG
18637	1633	17	State	state	NN
18637	1633	18	bonds;[234	bonds;[234	NNS
18637	1633	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1633	20	excise	excise	VBP
18637	1633	21	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1633	22	on	on	IN
18637	1633	23	the	the	DT
18637	1633	24	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1633	25	of	of	IN
18637	1633	26	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	1633	27	in	in	IN
18637	1633	28	performance	performance	NN
18637	1633	29	of	of	IN
18637	1633	30	a	a	DT
18637	1633	31	contract	contract	NN
18637	1633	32	to	to	TO
18637	1633	33	sell	sell	VB
18637	1633	34	and	and	CC
18637	1633	35	deliver	deliver	VB
18637	1633	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1633	37	to	to	IN
18637	1633	38	a	a	DT
18637	1633	39	county;[235	county;[235	NN
18637	1633	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1633	41	on	on	IN
18637	1633	42	the	the	DT
18637	1633	43	importation	importation	NN
18637	1633	44	of	of	IN
18637	1633	45	scientific	scientific	JJ
18637	1633	46	apparatus	apparatus	NN
18637	1633	47	by	by	IN
18637	1633	48	a	a	DT
18637	1633	49	State	State	NNP
18637	1633	50	university;[236	university;[236	NNPS
18637	1633	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1633	52	on	on	IN
18637	1633	53	admissions	admission	NNS
18637	1633	54	to	to	IN
18637	1633	55	athletic	athletic	JJ
18637	1633	56	contests	contest	NNS
18637	1633	57	sponsored	sponsor	VBN
18637	1633	58	by	by	IN
18637	1633	59	a	a	DT
18637	1633	60	State	State	NNP
18637	1633	61	institution	institution	NN
18637	1633	62	,	,	,
18637	1633	63	the	the	DT
18637	1633	64	net	net	JJ
18637	1633	65	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	1633	66	of	of	IN
18637	1633	67	which	which	WDT
18637	1633	68	were	be	VBD
18637	1633	69	used	use	VBN
18637	1633	70	to	to	TO
18637	1633	71	further	further	VB
18637	1633	72	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1633	73	educational	educational	JJ
18637	1633	74	program;[237	program;[237	NNPS
18637	1633	75	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1633	76	and	and	CC
18637	1633	77	on	on	IN
18637	1633	78	admissions	admission	NNS
18637	1633	79	to	to	IN
18637	1633	80	recreational	recreational	JJ
18637	1633	81	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	1633	82	operated	operate	VBN
18637	1633	83	on	on	IN
18637	1633	84	a	a	DT
18637	1633	85	nonprofit	nonprofit	JJ
18637	1633	86	basis	basis	NN
18637	1633	87	by	by	IN
18637	1633	88	a	a	DT
18637	1633	89	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	1633	90	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	1633	91	.	.	.
18637	1634	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1634	2	238	238	CD
18637	1634	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1634	4	Income	income	NN
18637	1634	5	derived	derive	VBN
18637	1634	6	by	by	IN
18637	1634	7	independent	independent	JJ
18637	1634	8	engineering	engineering	NN
18637	1634	9	contractors	contractor	NNS
18637	1634	10	from	from	IN
18637	1634	11	the	the	DT
18637	1634	12	performance	performance	NN
18637	1634	13	of	of	IN
18637	1634	14	State	State	NNP
18637	1634	15	functions;[239	functions;[239	CD
18637	1634	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1634	17	the	the	DT
18637	1634	18	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	1634	19	of	of	IN
18637	1634	20	trustees	trustee	NNS
18637	1634	21	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	1634	22	to	to	TO
18637	1634	23	manage	manage	VB
18637	1634	24	a	a	DT
18637	1634	25	street	street	NN
18637	1634	26	railway	railway	NN
18637	1634	27	taken	take	VBN
18637	1634	28	over	over	RP
18637	1634	29	and	and	CC
18637	1634	30	operated	operate	VBN
18637	1634	31	by	by	IN
18637	1634	32	a	a	DT
18637	1634	33	State;[240	state;[240	NN
18637	1634	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1634	35	profits	profit	NNS
18637	1634	36	derived	derive	VBN
18637	1634	37	from	from	IN
18637	1634	38	the	the	DT
18637	1634	39	sale	sale	NN
18637	1634	40	of	of	IN
18637	1634	41	State	State	NNP
18637	1634	42	bonds;[241	bonds;[241	NNPS
18637	1634	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1634	44	or	or	CC
18637	1634	45	from	from	IN
18637	1634	46	oil	oil	NN
18637	1634	47	produced	produce	VBN
18637	1634	48	by	by	IN
18637	1634	49	lessees	lessee	NNS
18637	1634	50	of	of	IN
18637	1634	51	State	State	NNP
18637	1634	52	lands;[242	lands;[242	LS
18637	1634	53	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1634	54	have	have	VBP
18637	1634	55	all	all	DT
18637	1634	56	been	be	VBN
18637	1634	57	held	hold	VBN
18637	1634	58	to	to	TO
18637	1634	59	be	be	VB
18637	1634	60	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1634	61	to	to	IN
18637	1634	62	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1634	63	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1634	64	despite	despite	IN
18637	1634	65	a	a	DT
18637	1634	66	possible	possible	JJ
18637	1634	67	economic	economic	JJ
18637	1634	68	burden	burden	NN
18637	1634	69	on	on	IN
18637	1634	70	the	the	DT
18637	1634	71	State	State	NNP
18637	1634	72	.	.	.
18637	1635	1	IS	be	VBZ
18637	1635	2	ANY	any	DT
18637	1635	3	IMMUNITY	IMMUNITY	NNP
18637	1635	4	LEFT	leave	VBN
18637	1635	5	THE	the	DT
18637	1635	6	STATES	state	NNS
18637	1635	7	?	?	.
18637	1636	1	Although	although	IN
18637	1636	2	there	there	EX
18637	1636	3	have	have	VBP
18637	1636	4	been	be	VBN
18637	1636	5	sharp	sharp	JJ
18637	1636	6	differences	difference	NNS
18637	1636	7	of	of	IN
18637	1636	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1636	9	among	among	IN
18637	1636	10	members	member	NNS
18637	1636	11	of	of	IN
18637	1636	12	the	the	DT
18637	1636	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1636	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1636	15	in	in	IN
18637	1636	16	recent	recent	JJ
18637	1636	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	1636	18	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	1636	19	with	with	IN
18637	1636	20	the	the	DT
18637	1636	21	tax	tax	NN
18637	1636	22	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	1636	23	of	of	IN
18637	1636	24	State	state	NN
18637	1636	25	functions	function	NNS
18637	1636	26	and	and	CC
18637	1636	27	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	1636	28	,	,	,
18637	1636	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1636	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	1636	31	been	be	VBN
18637	1636	32	stated	state	VBN
18637	1636	33	that	that	IN
18637	1636	34	"	"	``
18637	1636	35	all	all	DT
18637	1636	36	agree	agree	VBP
18637	1636	37	that	that	IN
18637	1636	38	not	not	RB
18637	1636	39	all	all	DT
18637	1636	40	of	of	IN
18637	1636	41	the	the	DT
18637	1636	42	former	former	JJ
18637	1636	43	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	1636	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	1636	45	gone	go	VBN
18637	1636	46	.	.	.
18637	1637	1	"	"	``
18637	1637	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1637	3	243	243	CD
18637	1637	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1637	5	Twice	twice	RB
18637	1637	6	the	the	DT
18637	1637	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1637	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	1637	9	made	make	VBN
18637	1637	10	an	an	DT
18637	1637	11	effort	effort	NN
18637	1637	12	to	to	TO
18637	1637	13	express	express	VB
18637	1637	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1637	15	new	new	JJ
18637	1637	16	point	point	NN
18637	1637	17	of	of	IN
18637	1637	18	view	view	NN
18637	1637	19	in	in	IN
18637	1637	20	a	a	DT
18637	1637	21	statement	statement	NN
18637	1637	22	of	of	IN
18637	1637	23	general	general	JJ
18637	1637	24	principles	principle	NNS
18637	1637	25	by	by	IN
18637	1637	26	which	which	WDT
18637	1637	27	the	the	DT
18637	1637	28	right	right	NN
18637	1637	29	to	to	IN
18637	1637	30	such	such	JJ
18637	1637	31	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	1637	32	shall	shall	MD
18637	1637	33	be	be	VB
18637	1637	34	determined	determine	VBN
18637	1637	35	.	.	.
18637	1638	1	However	however	RB
18637	1638	2	,	,	,
18637	1638	3	the	the	DT
18637	1638	4	failure	failure	NN
18637	1638	5	to	to	TO
18637	1638	6	muster	muster	VB
18637	1638	7	a	a	DT
18637	1638	8	majority	majority	NN
18637	1638	9	in	in	IN
18637	1638	10	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	1638	11	with	with	IN
18637	1638	12	any	any	DT
18637	1638	13	single	single	JJ
18637	1638	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1638	15	in	in	IN
18637	1638	16	the	the	DT
18637	1638	17	more	more	RBR
18637	1638	18	recent	recent	JJ
18637	1638	19	of	of	IN
18637	1638	20	these	these	DT
18637	1638	21	cases	case	NNS
18637	1638	22	leaves	leave	VBZ
18637	1638	23	the	the	DT
18637	1638	24	question	question	NN
18637	1638	25	very	very	RB
18637	1638	26	much	much	RB
18637	1638	27	in	in	IN
18637	1638	28	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	1638	29	.	.	.
18637	1639	1	In	in	IN
18637	1639	2	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	1639	3	_	_	NNP
18637	1639	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	1639	5	_	_	NNP
18637	1639	6	Gerhardt,[244	Gerhardt,[244	NNP
18637	1639	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1639	8	where	where	WRB
18637	1639	9	,	,	,
18637	1639	10	without	without	IN
18637	1639	11	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	1639	12	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	1639	13	_	_	NNP
18637	1639	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	1639	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1639	16	Day	Day	NNP
18637	1639	17	,	,	,
18637	1639	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1639	19	narrowed	narrow	VBD
18637	1639	20	the	the	DT
18637	1639	21	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	1639	22	of	of	IN
18637	1639	23	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	1639	24	of	of	IN
18637	1639	25	State	State	NNP
18637	1639	26	officers	officer	NNS
18637	1639	27	and	and	CC
18637	1639	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1639	29	income	income	NN
18637	1639	30	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1639	31	,	,	,
18637	1639	32	the	the	DT
18637	1639	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1639	34	announced	announce	VBD
18637	1639	35	"	"	``
18637	1639	36	*	*	NFP
18637	1639	37	*	*	NFP
18637	1639	38	*	*	NFP
18637	1639	39	,	,	,
18637	1639	40	two	two	CD
18637	1639	41	guiding	guide	VBG
18637	1639	42	principles	principle	NNS
18637	1639	43	of	of	IN
18637	1639	44	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	1639	45	for	for	IN
18637	1639	46	holding	hold	VBG
18637	1639	47	the	the	DT
18637	1639	48	tax	tax	NN
18637	1639	49	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	1639	50	of	of	IN
18637	1639	51	State	state	NN
18637	1639	52	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	1639	53	to	to	IN
18637	1639	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1639	55	proper	proper	JJ
18637	1639	56	function	function	NN
18637	1639	57	.	.	.
18637	1640	1	The	the	DT
18637	1640	2	one	one	CD
18637	1640	3	,	,	,
18637	1640	4	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	1640	5	upon	upon	IN
18637	1640	6	the	the	DT
18637	1640	7	nature	nature	NN
18637	1640	8	of	of	IN
18637	1640	9	the	the	DT
18637	1640	10	function	function	NN
18637	1640	11	being	be	VBG
18637	1640	12	performed	perform	VBN
18637	1640	13	by	by	IN
18637	1640	14	the	the	DT
18637	1640	15	State	State	NNP
18637	1640	16	or	or	CC
18637	1640	17	in	in	IN
18637	1640	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1640	19	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	1640	20	,	,	,
18637	1640	21	excludes	exclude	NNS
18637	1640	22	from	from	IN
18637	1640	23	the	the	DT
18637	1640	24	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	1640	25	activities	activity	NNS
18637	1640	26	thought	think	VBD
18637	1640	27	not	not	RB
18637	1640	28	to	to	TO
18637	1640	29	be	be	VB
18637	1640	30	essential	essential	JJ
18637	1640	31	to	to	IN
18637	1640	32	the	the	DT
18637	1640	33	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	1640	34	of	of	IN
18637	1640	35	State	state	NN
18637	1640	36	governments	government	NNS
18637	1640	37	even	even	RB
18637	1640	38	though	though	IN
18637	1640	39	the	the	DT
18637	1640	40	tax	tax	NN
18637	1640	41	be	be	VB
18637	1640	42	collected	collect	VBN
18637	1640	43	from	from	IN
18637	1640	44	the	the	DT
18637	1640	45	State	State	NNP
18637	1640	46	treasury	treasury	NN
18637	1640	47	.	.	.
18637	1641	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1641	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1641	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1641	4	The	the	DT
18637	1641	5	other	other	JJ
18637	1641	6	principle	principle	NN
18637	1641	7	,	,	,
18637	1641	8	exemplified	exemplify	VBN
18637	1641	9	by	by	IN
18637	1641	10	those	those	DT
18637	1641	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	1641	12	where	where	WRB
18637	1641	13	the	the	DT
18637	1641	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	1641	15	laid	lay	VBN
18637	1641	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	1641	17	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	1641	18	affects	affect	VBZ
18637	1641	19	the	the	DT
18637	1641	20	State	state	NN
18637	1641	21	only	only	RB
18637	1641	22	as	as	IN
18637	1641	23	the	the	DT
18637	1641	24	burden	burden	NN
18637	1641	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	1641	26	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1641	27	on	on	RP
18637	1641	28	to	to	IN
18637	1641	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1641	30	by	by	IN
18637	1641	31	the	the	DT
18637	1641	32	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	1641	33	,	,	,
18637	1641	34	forbids	forbid	NNS
18637	1641	35	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	1641	36	of	of	IN
18637	1641	37	the	the	DT
18637	1641	38	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	1641	39	when	when	WRB
18637	1641	40	the	the	DT
18637	1641	41	burden	burden	NN
18637	1641	42	on	on	IN
18637	1641	43	the	the	DT
18637	1641	44	State	state	NN
18637	1641	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	1641	46	so	so	RB
18637	1641	47	speculative	speculative	JJ
18637	1641	48	and	and	CC
18637	1641	49	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
18637	1641	50	that	that	IN
18637	1641	51	if	if	IN
18637	1641	52	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	1641	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1641	54	would	would	MD
18637	1641	55	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	1641	56	the	the	DT
18637	1641	57	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1641	58	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	1641	59	power	power	NN
18637	1641	60	without	without	IN
18637	1641	61	affording	afford	VBG
18637	1641	62	any	any	DT
18637	1641	63	corresponding	corresponding	JJ
18637	1641	64	tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	1641	65	protection	protection	NN
18637	1641	66	to	to	IN
18637	1641	67	the	the	DT
18637	1641	68	State	State	NNP
18637	1641	69	government	government	NN
18637	1641	70	;	;	:
18637	1641	71	even	even	RB
18637	1641	72	though	though	IN
18637	1641	73	the	the	DT
18637	1641	74	function	function	NN
18637	1641	75	be	be	VB
18637	1641	76	thought	think	VBN
18637	1641	77	important	important	JJ
18637	1641	78	enough	enough	RB
18637	1641	79	to	to	TO
18637	1641	80	demand	demand	VB
18637	1641	81	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	1641	82	from	from	IN
18637	1641	83	a	a	DT
18637	1641	84	tax	tax	NN
18637	1641	85	upon	upon	IN
18637	1641	86	the	the	DT
18637	1641	87	State	State	NNP
18637	1641	88	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1641	89	,	,	,
18637	1641	90	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1641	91	is	be	VBZ
18637	1641	92	not	not	RB
18637	1641	93	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	1641	94	protected	protect	VBN
18637	1641	95	from	from	IN
18637	1641	96	a	a	DT
18637	1641	97	tax	tax	NN
18637	1641	98	which	which	WDT
18637	1641	99	well	well	RB
18637	1641	100	may	may	MD
18637	1641	101	be	be	VB
18637	1641	102	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	1641	103	or	or	CC
18637	1641	104	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	1641	105	absorbed	absorb	VBN
18637	1641	106	by	by	IN
18637	1641	107	private	private	JJ
18637	1641	108	persons	person	NNS
18637	1641	109	.	.	.
18637	1642	1	"	"	``
18637	1642	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1642	3	245	245	CD
18637	1642	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1642	5	CONFLICTING	conflict	VBG
18637	1642	6	VIEWS	view	NNS
18637	1642	7	ON	on	IN
18637	1642	8	THE	the	DT
18637	1642	9	COURT	court	NN
18637	1642	10	The	the	DT
18637	1642	11	second	second	JJ
18637	1642	12	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	1642	13	to	to	TO
18637	1642	14	formulate	formulate	VB
18637	1642	15	a	a	DT
18637	1642	16	general	general	JJ
18637	1642	17	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1642	18	was	be	VBD
18637	1642	19	made	make	VBN
18637	1642	20	in	in	IN
18637	1642	21	New	New	NNP
18637	1642	22	York	York	NNP
18637	1642	23	_	_	NNP
18637	1642	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	1642	25	_	_	NNP
18637	1642	26	United	United	NNP
18637	1642	27	States,[246	States,[246	NNP
18637	1642	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1642	29	where	where	WRB
18637	1642	30	,	,	,
18637	1642	31	on	on	IN
18637	1642	32	review	review	NN
18637	1642	33	of	of	IN
18637	1642	34	a	a	DT
18637	1642	35	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	1642	36	affirming	affirming	NN
18637	1642	37	the	the	DT
18637	1642	38	right	right	NN
18637	1642	39	of	of	IN
18637	1642	40	the	the	DT
18637	1642	41	United	United	NNP
18637	1642	42	States	States	NNP
18637	1642	43	to	to	TO
18637	1642	44	tax	tax	VB
18637	1642	45	the	the	DT
18637	1642	46	sale	sale	NN
18637	1642	47	of	of	IN
18637	1642	48	mineral	mineral	NN
18637	1642	49	waters	water	NNS
18637	1642	50	taken	take	VBN
18637	1642	51	from	from	IN
18637	1642	52	property	property	NN
18637	1642	53	owned	own	VBN
18637	1642	54	and	and	CC
18637	1642	55	operated	operate	VBN
18637	1642	56	by	by	IN
18637	1642	57	the	the	DT
18637	1642	58	State	State	NNP
18637	1642	59	of	of	IN
18637	1642	60	New	New	NNP
18637	1642	61	York	York	NNP
18637	1642	62	,	,	,
18637	1642	63	the	the	DT
18637	1642	64	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1642	65	was	be	VBD
18637	1642	66	asked	ask	VBN
18637	1642	67	to	to	TO
18637	1642	68	and	and	CC
18637	1642	69	did	do	VBD
18637	1642	70	reconsider	reconsider	VB
18637	1642	71	the	the	DT
18637	1642	72	right	right	NN
18637	1642	73	of	of	IN
18637	1642	74	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1642	75	to	to	TO
18637	1642	76	tax	tax	NN
18637	1642	77	business	business	NN
18637	1642	78	enterprises	enterprise	NNS
18637	1642	79	carried	carry	VBN
18637	1642	80	on	on	RP
18637	1642	81	by	by	IN
18637	1642	82	the	the	DT
18637	1642	83	States	States	NNP
18637	1642	84	.	.	.
18637	1643	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1643	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	1643	3	,	,	,
18637	1643	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	1643	5	for	for	IN
18637	1643	6	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1643	7	and	and	CC
18637	1643	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1643	9	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	1643	10	,	,	,
18637	1643	11	made	make	VBD
18637	1643	12	the	the	DT
18637	1643	13	question	question	NN
18637	1643	14	of	of	IN
18637	1643	15	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	1643	16	_	_	IN
18637	1643	17	vel	vel	NNP
18637	1643	18	non	non	AFX
18637	1643	19	_	_	NNP
18637	1643	20	against	against	IN
18637	1643	21	State	state	NN
18637	1643	22	activities	activity	NNS
18637	1643	23	the	the	DT
18637	1643	24	test	test	NN
18637	1643	25	of	of	IN
18637	1643	26	the	the	DT
18637	1643	27	validity	validity	NN
18637	1643	28	of	of	IN
18637	1643	29	such	such	PDT
18637	1643	30	a	a	DT
18637	1643	31	tax	tax	NN
18637	1643	32	.	.	.
18637	1644	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1644	2	found	find	VBD
18637	1644	3	"	"	``
18637	1644	4	no	no	DT
18637	1644	5	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	1644	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	1644	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1644	8	to	to	TO
18637	1644	9	include	include	VB
18637	1644	10	the	the	DT
18637	1644	11	States	States	NNP
18637	1644	12	in	in	IN
18637	1644	13	levying	levy	VBG
18637	1644	14	a	a	DT
18637	1644	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	1644	16	exacted	exact	VBN
18637	1644	17	equally	equally	RB
18637	1644	18	from	from	IN
18637	1644	19	private	private	JJ
18637	1644	20	persons	person	NNS
18637	1644	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	1644	22	the	the	DT
18637	1644	23	same	same	JJ
18637	1644	24	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1644	25	matter	matter	NN
18637	1644	26	.	.	.
18637	1645	1	"	"	``
18637	1645	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1645	3	247	247	CD
18637	1645	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1645	5	In	in	IN
18637	1645	6	a	a	DT
18637	1645	7	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	1645	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1645	9	in	in	IN
18637	1645	10	which	which	WDT
18637	1645	11	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	1645	12	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	1645	13	,	,	,
18637	1645	14	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	1645	15	,	,	,
18637	1645	16	and	and	CC
18637	1645	17	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	1645	18	joined	join	VBD
18637	1645	19	,	,	,
18637	1645	20	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1645	21	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1645	22	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	1645	23	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	1645	24	the	the	DT
18637	1645	25	criterion	criterion	NN
18637	1645	26	of	of	IN
18637	1645	27	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	1645	28	.	.	.
18637	1646	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1646	2	repeated	repeat	VBD
18637	1646	3	what	what	WP
18637	1646	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1646	5	had	have	VBD
18637	1646	6	said	say	VBN
18637	1646	7	in	in	IN
18637	1646	8	an	an	DT
18637	1646	9	earlier	early	JJR
18637	1646	10	case	case	NN
18637	1646	11	to	to	IN
18637	1646	12	the	the	DT
18637	1646	13	effect	effect	NN
18637	1646	14	that	that	IN
18637	1646	15	"	"	``
18637	1646	16	'	'	``
18637	1646	17	*	*	NFP
18637	1646	18	*	*	NFP
18637	1646	19	*	*	NFP
18637	1646	20	the	the	DT
18637	1646	21	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	1646	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	1646	23	the	the	DT
18637	1646	24	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	1646	25	power	power	NN
18637	1646	26	of	of	IN
18637	1646	27	each	each	DT
18637	1646	28	,	,	,
18637	1646	29	so	so	RB
18637	1646	30	far	far	RB
18637	1646	31	as	as	IN
18637	1646	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1646	33	affects	affect	VBZ
18637	1646	34	the	the	DT
18637	1646	35	other	other	JJ
18637	1646	36	,	,	,
18637	1646	37	must	must	MD
18637	1646	38	receive	receive	VB
18637	1646	39	a	a	DT
18637	1646	40	practical	practical	JJ
18637	1646	41	construction	construction	NN
18637	1646	42	which	which	WDT
18637	1646	43	permits	permit	VBZ
18637	1646	44	both	both	DT
18637	1646	45	to	to	TO
18637	1646	46	function	function	VB
18637	1646	47	with	with	IN
18637	1646	48	the	the	DT
18637	1646	49	minimum	minimum	NN
18637	1646	50	of	of	IN
18637	1646	51	interference	interference	NN
18637	1646	52	each	each	DT
18637	1646	53	with	with	IN
18637	1646	54	the	the	DT
18637	1646	55	other	other	JJ
18637	1646	56	;	;	:
18637	1646	57	and	and	CC
18637	1646	58	that	that	IN
18637	1646	59	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	1646	60	can	can	MD
18637	1646	61	not	not	RB
18637	1646	62	be	be	VB
18637	1646	63	so	so	RB
18637	1646	64	varied	varied	JJ
18637	1646	65	or	or	CC
18637	1646	66	extended	extended	JJ
18637	1646	67	as	as	IN
18637	1646	68	seriously	seriously	RB
18637	1646	69	to	to	TO
18637	1646	70	impair	impair	VB
18637	1646	71	either	either	CC
18637	1646	72	the	the	DT
18637	1646	73	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	1646	74	power	power	NN
18637	1646	75	of	of	IN
18637	1646	76	the	the	DT
18637	1646	77	government	government	NN
18637	1646	78	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	1646	79	the	the	DT
18637	1646	80	tax	tax	NN
18637	1646	81	*	*	NFP
18637	1646	82	*	*	NFP
18637	1646	83	*	*	NFP
18637	1646	84	or	or	CC
18637	1646	85	the	the	DT
18637	1646	86	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	1646	87	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1646	88	of	of	IN
18637	1646	89	the	the	DT
18637	1646	90	functions	function	NNS
18637	1646	91	of	of	IN
18637	1646	92	the	the	DT
18637	1646	93	government	government	NN
18637	1646	94	affected	affect	VBN
18637	1646	95	by	by	IN
18637	1646	96	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1646	97	.	.	.
18637	1647	1	'	'	``
18637	1647	2	"	"	``
18637	1647	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1647	4	248	248	CD
18637	1647	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1647	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	1647	7	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	1647	8	and	and	CC
18637	1647	9	Black	Black	NNP
18637	1647	10	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	1647	11	in	in	IN
18637	1647	12	an	an	DT
18637	1647	13	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1647	14	written	write	VBN
18637	1647	15	by	by	IN
18637	1647	16	the	the	DT
18637	1647	17	former	former	JJ
18637	1647	18	on	on	IN
18637	1647	19	the	the	DT
18637	1647	20	ground	ground	NN
18637	1647	21	that	that	IN
18637	1647	22	the	the	DT
18637	1647	23	decision	decision	NN
18637	1647	24	disregarded	disregard	VBD
18637	1647	25	the	the	DT
18637	1647	26	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	1647	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1647	28	,	,	,
18637	1647	29	placed	place	VBD
18637	1647	30	"	"	``
18637	1647	31	the	the	DT
18637	1647	32	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	1647	33	States	States	NNP
18637	1647	34	on	on	IN
18637	1647	35	the	the	DT
18637	1647	36	same	same	JJ
18637	1647	37	plane	plane	NN
18637	1647	38	as	as	IN
18637	1647	39	private	private	JJ
18637	1647	40	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	1647	41	,	,	,
18637	1647	42	"	"	''
18637	1647	43	and	and	CC
18637	1647	44	made	make	VBD
18637	1647	45	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1647	46	"	"	``
18637	1647	47	pay	pay	VB
18637	1647	48	the	the	DT
18637	1647	49	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1647	50	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1647	51	for	for	IN
18637	1647	52	the	the	DT
18637	1647	53	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	1647	54	of	of	IN
18637	1647	55	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	1647	56	powers	power	NNS
18637	1647	57	of	of	IN
18637	1647	58	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	1647	59	guaranteed	guarantee	VBD
18637	1647	60	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1647	61	by	by	IN
18637	1647	62	the	the	DT
18637	1647	63	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1647	64	.	.	.
18637	1648	1	"	"	``
18637	1648	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1648	3	249	249	CD
18637	1648	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1648	5	In	in	IN
18637	1648	6	the	the	DT
18637	1648	7	most	most	RBS
18637	1648	8	recent	recent	JJ
18637	1648	9	case	case	NN
18637	1648	10	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	1648	11	with	with	IN
18637	1648	12	State	State	NNP
18637	1648	13	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	1648	14	the	the	DT
18637	1648	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1648	16	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1648	17	the	the	DT
18637	1648	18	tax	tax	NN
18637	1648	19	on	on	IN
18637	1648	20	the	the	DT
18637	1648	21	second	second	JJ
18637	1648	22	ground	ground	NN
18637	1648	23	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	1648	24	in	in	IN
18637	1648	25	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	1648	26	_	_	NNP
18637	1648	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	1648	28	_	_	NNP
18637	1648	29	Gerhardt	Gerhardt	NNP
18637	1648	30	--	--	:
18637	1648	31	that	that	IN
18637	1648	32	the	the	DT
18637	1648	33	burden	burden	NN
18637	1648	34	of	of	IN
18637	1648	35	the	the	DT
18637	1648	36	tax	tax	NN
18637	1648	37	was	be	VBD
18637	1648	38	borne	bear	VBN
18637	1648	39	by	by	IN
18637	1648	40	private	private	JJ
18637	1648	41	persons	person	NNS
18637	1648	42	--	--	:
18637	1648	43	and	and	CC
18637	1648	44	did	do	VBD
18637	1648	45	not	not	RB
18637	1648	46	consider	consider	VB
18637	1648	47	whether	whether	IN
18637	1648	48	the	the	DT
18637	1648	49	function	function	NN
18637	1648	50	was	be	VBD
18637	1648	51	one	one	CD
18637	1648	52	which	which	WDT
18637	1648	53	the	the	DT
18637	1648	54	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1648	55	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1648	56	might	may	MD
18637	1648	57	have	have	VB
18637	1648	58	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	1648	59	if	if	IN
18637	1648	60	the	the	DT
18637	1648	61	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	1648	62	had	have	VBD
18637	1648	63	borne	bear	VBN
18637	1648	64	the	the	DT
18637	1648	65	burden	burden	NN
18637	1648	66	of	of	IN
18637	1648	67	the	the	DT
18637	1648	68	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	1648	69	.	.	.
18637	1649	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1649	2	250	250	CD
18637	1649	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1649	4	THE	the	DT
18637	1649	5	RULE	rule	NN
18637	1649	6	OF	of	IN
18637	1649	7	UNIFORMITY	UNIFORMITY	NNP
18637	1649	8	Whether	whether	IN
18637	1649	9	a	a	DT
18637	1649	10	tax	tax	NN
18637	1649	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	1649	12	to	to	TO
18637	1649	13	be	be	VB
18637	1649	14	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	1649	15	among	among	IN
18637	1649	16	the	the	DT
18637	1649	17	States	States	NNP
18637	1649	18	according	accord	VBG
18637	1649	19	to	to	IN
18637	1649	20	the	the	DT
18637	1649	21	census	census	NN
18637	1649	22	taken	take	VBN
18637	1649	23	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	1649	24	to	to	IN
18637	1649	25	article	article	NN
18637	1649	26	I	i	NN
18637	1649	27	,	,	,
18637	1649	28	section	section	NN
18637	1649	29	2	2	CD
18637	1649	30	,	,	,
18637	1649	31	or	or	CC
18637	1649	32	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	1649	33	uniformly	uniformly	RB
18637	1649	34	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	1649	35	the	the	DT
18637	1649	36	United	United	NNP
18637	1649	37	States	States	NNP
18637	1649	38	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	1649	39	upon	upon	IN
18637	1649	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1649	41	classification	classification	NN
18637	1649	42	as	as	IN
18637	1649	43	direct	direct	JJ
18637	1649	44	or	or	CC
18637	1649	45	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	1649	46	.	.	.
18637	1650	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1650	2	251	251	CD
18637	1650	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1650	4	The	the	DT
18637	1650	5	rule	rule	NN
18637	1650	6	of	of	IN
18637	1650	7	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	1650	8	for	for	IN
18637	1650	9	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	1650	10	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1650	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	1650	12	easy	easy	JJ
18637	1650	13	to	to	TO
18637	1650	14	obey	obey	VB
18637	1650	15	.	.	.
18637	1651	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1651	2	exacts	exact	VBZ
18637	1651	3	only	only	RB
18637	1651	4	that	that	IN
18637	1651	5	the	the	DT
18637	1651	6	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1651	7	matter	matter	NN
18637	1651	8	of	of	IN
18637	1651	9	a	a	DT
18637	1651	10	levy	levy	NN
18637	1651	11	be	be	VB
18637	1651	12	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	1651	13	at	at	IN
18637	1651	14	the	the	DT
18637	1651	15	same	same	JJ
18637	1651	16	rate	rate	NN
18637	1651	17	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	1651	18	found	find	VBN
18637	1651	19	in	in	IN
18637	1651	20	the	the	DT
18637	1651	21	United	United	NNP
18637	1651	22	States	States	NNP
18637	1651	23	;	;	:
18637	1651	24	or	or	CC
18637	1651	25	,	,	,
18637	1651	26	as	as	IN
18637	1651	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1651	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	1651	29	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	1651	30	phrased	phrase	VBN
18637	1651	31	,	,	,
18637	1651	32	the	the	DT
18637	1651	33	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	1651	34	required	require	VBN
18637	1651	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	1651	36	"	"	``
18637	1651	37	geographical	geographical	JJ
18637	1651	38	,	,	,
18637	1651	39	"	"	''
18637	1651	40	not	not	RB
18637	1651	41	"	"	``
18637	1651	42	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
18637	1651	43	.	.	.
18637	1652	1	"	"	``
18637	1652	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1652	3	252	252	CD
18637	1652	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1652	5	The	the	DT
18637	1652	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	1652	7	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	1652	8	places	place	VBZ
18637	1652	9	no	no	DT
18637	1652	10	obstacle	obstacle	NN
18637	1652	11	in	in	IN
18637	1652	12	the	the	DT
18637	1652	13	way	way	NN
18637	1652	14	of	of	IN
18637	1652	15	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1652	16	classification	classification	NN
18637	1652	17	for	for	IN
18637	1652	18	the	the	DT
18637	1652	19	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1652	20	of	of	IN
18637	1652	21	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1652	22	,	,	,
18637	1652	23	nor	nor	CC
18637	1652	24	in	in	IN
18637	1652	25	the	the	DT
18637	1652	26	way	way	NN
18637	1652	27	of	of	IN
18637	1652	28	what	what	WP
18637	1652	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	1652	30	called	call	VBN
18637	1652	31	progressive	progressive	JJ
18637	1652	32	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1652	33	.	.	.
18637	1653	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1653	2	253	253	CD
18637	1653	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1653	4	A	a	DT
18637	1653	5	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	1653	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	1653	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	1653	8	not	not	RB
18637	1653	9	fail	fail	VB
18637	1653	10	of	of	IN
18637	1653	11	the	the	DT
18637	1653	12	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	1653	13	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	1653	14	because	because	IN
18637	1653	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1653	16	operation	operation	NN
18637	1653	17	and	and	CC
18637	1653	18	incidence	incidence	NN
18637	1653	19	may	may	MD
18637	1653	20	be	be	VB
18637	1653	21	affected	affect	VBN
18637	1653	22	by	by	IN
18637	1653	23	differences	difference	NNS
18637	1653	24	in	in	IN
18637	1653	25	State	state	NN
18637	1653	26	laws	law	NNS
18637	1653	27	.	.	.
18637	1654	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1654	2	254	254	CD
18637	1654	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1654	4	A	a	DT
18637	1654	5	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1654	6	estate	estate	NN
18637	1654	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	1654	8	law	law	NN
18637	1654	9	which	which	WDT
18637	1654	10	permitted	permit	VBD
18637	1654	11	a	a	DT
18637	1654	12	deduction	deduction	NN
18637	1654	13	for	for	IN
18637	1654	14	a	a	DT
18637	1654	15	like	like	JJ
18637	1654	16	tax	tax	NN
18637	1654	17	paid	pay	VBN
18637	1654	18	to	to	IN
18637	1654	19	a	a	DT
18637	1654	20	State	state	NN
18637	1654	21	was	be	VBD
18637	1654	22	not	not	RB
18637	1654	23	rendered	render	VBN
18637	1654	24	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	1654	25	by	by	IN
18637	1654	26	the	the	DT
18637	1654	27	fact	fact	NN
18637	1654	28	that	that	IN
18637	1654	29	one	one	CD
18637	1654	30	State	state	NN
18637	1654	31	levied	levy	VBD
18637	1654	32	no	no	DT
18637	1654	33	such	such	JJ
18637	1654	34	tax	tax	NN
18637	1654	35	.	.	.
18637	1655	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1655	2	255	255	CD
18637	1655	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1655	4	The	the	DT
18637	1655	5	term	term	NN
18637	1655	6	"	"	``
18637	1655	7	United	United	NNP
18637	1655	8	States	States	NNP
18637	1655	9	"	"	''
18637	1655	10	in	in	IN
18637	1655	11	this	this	DT
18637	1655	12	clause	clause	NN
18637	1655	13	refers	refer	VBZ
18637	1655	14	only	only	RB
18637	1655	15	to	to	IN
18637	1655	16	the	the	DT
18637	1655	17	States	States	NNP
18637	1655	18	of	of	IN
18637	1655	19	the	the	DT
18637	1655	20	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1655	21	,	,	,
18637	1655	22	the	the	DT
18637	1655	23	District	District	NNP
18637	1655	24	of	of	IN
18637	1655	25	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	1655	26	,	,	,
18637	1655	27	and	and	CC
18637	1655	28	incorporated	incorporated	JJ
18637	1655	29	territories	territory	NNS
18637	1655	30	.	.	.
18637	1656	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1656	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1656	3	not	not	RB
18637	1656	4	bound	bind	VBN
18637	1656	5	by	by	IN
18637	1656	6	the	the	DT
18637	1656	7	rule	rule	NN
18637	1656	8	of	of	IN
18637	1656	9	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	1656	10	in	in	IN
18637	1656	11	framing	frame	VBG
18637	1656	12	tax	tax	NN
18637	1656	13	measures	measure	NNS
18637	1656	14	for	for	IN
18637	1656	15	unincorporated	unincorporated	JJ
18637	1656	16	territories	territory	NNS
18637	1656	17	.	.	.
18637	1657	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1657	2	256	256	CD
18637	1657	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1657	4	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	1657	5	,	,	,
18637	1657	6	in	in	IN
18637	1657	7	Binns	Binns	NNP
18637	1657	8	_	_	NNP
18637	1657	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	1657	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1657	11	United	United	NNP
18637	1657	12	States,[257	States,[257	NNP
18637	1657	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1657	14	the	the	DT
18637	1657	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1657	16	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1657	17	license	license	NN
18637	1657	18	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1657	19	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	1657	20	by	by	IN
18637	1657	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1657	22	but	but	CC
18637	1657	23	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	1657	24	only	only	RB
18637	1657	25	in	in	IN
18637	1657	26	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	1657	27	,	,	,
18637	1657	28	where	where	WRB
18637	1657	29	the	the	DT
18637	1657	30	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	1657	31	,	,	,
18637	1657	32	although	although	IN
18637	1657	33	paid	pay	VBN
18637	1657	34	into	into	IN
18637	1657	35	the	the	DT
18637	1657	36	general	general	JJ
18637	1657	37	fund	fund	NN
18637	1657	38	of	of	IN
18637	1657	39	the	the	DT
18637	1657	40	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	1657	41	,	,	,
18637	1657	42	did	do	VBD
18637	1657	43	not	not	RB
18637	1657	44	in	in	IN
18637	1657	45	fact	fact	NN
18637	1657	46	equal	equal	JJ
18637	1657	47	the	the	DT
18637	1657	48	total	total	JJ
18637	1657	49	cost	cost	NN
18637	1657	50	of	of	IN
18637	1657	51	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	1657	52	the	the	DT
18637	1657	53	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	1657	54	government	government	NN
18637	1657	55	.	.	.
18637	1658	1	PURPOSES	purposes	NN
18637	1658	2	OF	of	IN
18637	1658	3	TAXATION	taxation	NN
18637	1658	4	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	1658	5	by	by	IN
18637	1658	6	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	1658	7	The	the	DT
18637	1658	8	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	1658	9	of	of	IN
18637	1658	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1658	11	in	in	IN
18637	1658	12	selecting	select	VBG
18637	1658	13	the	the	DT
18637	1658	14	objectives	objective	NNS
18637	1658	15	of	of	IN
18637	1658	16	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1658	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	1658	18	also	also	RB
18637	1658	19	been	be	VBN
18637	1658	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	1658	21	at	at	IN
18637	1658	22	times	time	NNS
18637	1658	23	to	to	TO
18637	1658	24	be	be	VB
18637	1658	25	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1658	26	to	to	IN
18637	1658	27	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	1658	28	implied	imply	VBN
18637	1658	29	from	from	IN
18637	1658	30	the	the	DT
18637	1658	31	nature	nature	NN
18637	1658	32	of	of	IN
18637	1658	33	the	the	DT
18637	1658	34	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1658	35	System	System	NNP
18637	1658	36	.	.	.
18637	1659	1	Apart	apart	RB
18637	1659	2	from	from	IN
18637	1659	3	matters	matter	NNS
18637	1659	4	which	which	WDT
18637	1659	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1659	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	1659	7	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	1659	8	to	to	TO
18637	1659	9	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1659	10	,	,	,
18637	1659	11	the	the	DT
18637	1659	12	national	national	JJ
18637	1659	13	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	1659	14	power	power	NN
18637	1659	15	,	,	,
18637	1659	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1659	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	1659	18	been	be	VBN
18637	1659	19	said	say	VBN
18637	1659	20	,	,	,
18637	1659	21	"	"	``
18637	1659	22	reaches	reach	VBZ
18637	1659	23	only	only	RB
18637	1659	24	existing	exist	VBG
18637	1659	25	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	1659	26	.	.	.
18637	1660	1	"	"	``
18637	1660	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1660	3	258	258	CD
18637	1660	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1660	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1660	6	may	may	MD
18637	1660	7	tax	tax	VB
18637	1660	8	any	any	DT
18637	1660	9	activity	activity	NN
18637	1660	10	actually	actually	RB
18637	1660	11	carried	carry	VBN
18637	1660	12	on	on	RP
18637	1660	13	,	,	,
18637	1660	14	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	1660	15	of	of	IN
18637	1660	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	1660	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1660	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	1660	19	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	1660	20	or	or	CC
18637	1660	21	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	1660	22	by	by	IN
18637	1660	23	the	the	DT
18637	1660	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	1660	25	of	of	IN
18637	1660	26	the	the	DT
18637	1660	27	United	United	NNP
18637	1660	28	States[259	States[259	NNP
18637	1660	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1660	30	or	or	CC
18637	1660	31	by	by	IN
18637	1660	32	those	those	DT
18637	1660	33	of	of	IN
18637	1660	34	a	a	DT
18637	1660	35	State	state	NN
18637	1660	36	.	.	.
18637	1661	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1661	2	260	260	CD
18637	1661	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1661	4	But	but	CC
18637	1661	5	so	so	RB
18637	1661	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	1661	7	called	call	VBN
18637	1661	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1661	9	"	"	``
18637	1661	10	licenses	license	NNS
18637	1661	11	,	,	,
18637	1661	12	"	"	''
18637	1661	13	so	so	RB
18637	1661	14	far	far	RB
18637	1661	15	as	as	IN
18637	1661	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1661	17	relate	relate	VBP
18637	1661	18	to	to	IN
18637	1661	19	trade	trade	NN
18637	1661	20	within	within	IN
18637	1661	21	State	state	NN
18637	1661	22	limits	limit	NNS
18637	1661	23	,	,	,
18637	1661	24	merely	merely	RB
18637	1661	25	express	express	VB
18637	1661	26	"	"	''
18637	1661	27	the	the	DT
18637	1661	28	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1661	29	of	of	IN
18637	1661	30	the	the	DT
18637	1661	31	government	government	NN
18637	1661	32	not	not	RB
18637	1661	33	to	to	TO
18637	1661	34	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	1661	35	*	*	NFP
18637	1661	36	*	*	NFP
18637	1661	37	*	*	NFP
18637	1661	38	with	with	IN
18637	1661	39	the	the	DT
18637	1661	40	trade	trade	NN
18637	1661	41	nominally	nominally	RB
18637	1661	42	licensed	license	VBN
18637	1661	43	,	,	,
18637	1661	44	if	if	IN
18637	1661	45	the	the	DT
18637	1661	46	required	require	VBN
18637	1661	47	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1661	48	are	be	VBP
18637	1661	49	paid	pay	VBN
18637	1661	50	.	.	.
18637	1661	51	"	"	''
18637	1662	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	1662	2	the	the	DT
18637	1662	3	"	"	``
18637	1662	4	licensed	licensed	JJ
18637	1662	5	"	"	''
18637	1662	6	trade	trade	NN
18637	1662	7	shall	shall	MD
18637	1662	8	be	be	VB
18637	1662	9	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	1662	10	at	at	RB
18637	1662	11	all	all	DT
18637	1662	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	1662	13	a	a	DT
18637	1662	14	question	question	NN
18637	1662	15	for	for	IN
18637	1662	16	decision	decision	NN
18637	1662	17	by	by	IN
18637	1662	18	the	the	DT
18637	1662	19	State	State	NNP
18637	1662	20	.	.	.
18637	1663	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1663	2	261	261	CD
18637	1663	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1663	4	This	this	DT
18637	1663	5	,	,	,
18637	1663	6	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	1663	7	,	,	,
18637	1663	8	does	do	VBZ
18637	1663	9	not	not	RB
18637	1663	10	signify	signify	VB
18637	1663	11	that	that	IN
18637	1663	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1663	13	may	may	MD
18637	1663	14	not	not	RB
18637	1663	15	often	often	RB
18637	1663	16	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1663	17	to	to	IN
18637	1663	18	some	some	DT
18637	1663	19	extent	extent	NN
18637	1663	20	a	a	DT
18637	1663	21	business	business	NN
18637	1663	22	within	within	IN
18637	1663	23	a	a	DT
18637	1663	24	State	state	NN
18637	1663	25	in	in	IN
18637	1663	26	order	order	NN
18637	1663	27	the	the	DT
18637	1663	28	more	more	RBR
18637	1663	29	effectively	effectively	RB
18637	1663	30	to	to	TO
18637	1663	31	tax	tax	VB
18637	1663	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1663	33	.	.	.
18637	1664	1	Under	under	IN
18637	1664	2	the	the	DT
18637	1664	3	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1664	4	and	and	CC
18637	1664	5	proper	proper	JJ
18637	1664	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	1664	7	,	,	,
18637	1664	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1664	9	may	may	MD
18637	1664	10	do	do	VB
18637	1664	11	this	this	DT
18637	1664	12	very	very	JJ
18637	1664	13	thing	thing	NN
18637	1664	14	.	.	.
18637	1665	1	Not	not	RB
18637	1665	2	only	only	RB
18637	1665	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	1665	4	the	the	DT
18637	1665	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1665	6	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1665	7	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1665	8	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	1665	9	the	the	DT
18637	1665	10	packaging	packaging	NN
18637	1665	11	of	of	IN
18637	1665	12	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	1665	13	articles	article	NNS
18637	1665	14	such	such	JJ
18637	1665	15	as	as	IN
18637	1665	16	tobacco[262	tobacco[262	NNP
18637	1665	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1665	18	and	and	CC
18637	1665	19	oleomargarine,[263	oleomargarine,[263	NN
18637	1665	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1665	21	ostensibly	ostensibly	RB
18637	1665	22	designed	design	VBN
18637	1665	23	to	to	TO
18637	1665	24	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	1665	25	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	1665	26	in	in	IN
18637	1665	27	the	the	DT
18637	1665	28	collection	collection	NN
18637	1665	29	of	of	IN
18637	1665	30	the	the	DT
18637	1665	31	tax	tax	NN
18637	1665	32	;	;	:
18637	1665	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1665	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	1665	35	also	also	RB
18637	1665	36	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	1665	37	measures	measure	NNS
18637	1665	38	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	1665	39	drugs[264	drugs[264	NNP
18637	1665	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1665	41	and	and	CC
18637	1665	42	firearms[265	firearms[265	LS
18637	1665	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1665	44	which	which	WDT
18637	1665	45	prescribed	prescribe	VBD
18637	1665	46	rigorous	rigorous	JJ
18637	1665	47	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	1665	48	under	under	IN
18637	1665	49	which	which	WDT
18637	1665	50	such	such	JJ
18637	1665	51	articles	article	NNS
18637	1665	52	could	could	MD
18637	1665	53	be	be	VB
18637	1665	54	sold	sell	VBN
18637	1665	55	or	or	CC
18637	1665	56	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	1665	57	,	,	,
18637	1665	58	and	and	CC
18637	1665	59	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	1665	60	heavy	heavy	JJ
18637	1665	61	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	1665	62	upon	upon	IN
18637	1665	63	persons	person	NNS
18637	1665	64	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	1665	65	with	with	IN
18637	1665	66	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1665	67	in	in	IN
18637	1665	68	any	any	DT
18637	1665	69	other	other	JJ
18637	1665	70	way	way	NN
18637	1665	71	.	.	.
18637	1666	1	These	these	DT
18637	1666	2	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1666	3	were	be	VBD
18637	1666	4	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	1666	5	as	as	IN
18637	1666	6	conducive	conducive	JJ
18637	1666	7	to	to	IN
18637	1666	8	the	the	DT
18637	1666	9	efficient	efficient	JJ
18637	1666	10	collection	collection	NN
18637	1666	11	of	of	IN
18637	1666	12	the	the	DT
18637	1666	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	1666	14	though	though	IN
18637	1666	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1666	16	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	1666	17	transcended	transcend	VBD
18637	1666	18	in	in	IN
18637	1666	19	some	some	DT
18637	1666	20	respects	respect	NNS
18637	1666	21	this	this	DT
18637	1666	22	ground	ground	NN
18637	1666	23	of	of	IN
18637	1666	24	justification	justification	NN
18637	1666	25	.	.	.
18637	1667	1	Extermination	extermination	NN
18637	1667	2	by	by	IN
18637	1667	3	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	1667	4	A	a	DT
18637	1667	5	problem	problem	NN
18637	1667	6	of	of	IN
18637	1667	7	a	a	DT
18637	1667	8	different	different	JJ
18637	1667	9	order	order	NN
18637	1667	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	1667	11	presented	present	VBN
18637	1667	12	where	where	WRB
18637	1667	13	the	the	DT
18637	1667	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	1667	15	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1667	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	1667	17	the	the	DT
18637	1667	18	effect	effect	NN
18637	1667	19	of	of	IN
18637	1667	20	suppressing	suppress	VBG
18637	1667	21	an	an	DT
18637	1667	22	activity	activity	NN
18637	1667	23	or	or	CC
18637	1667	24	where	where	WRB
18637	1667	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1667	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	1667	27	coupled	couple	VBN
18637	1667	28	with	with	IN
18637	1667	29	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1667	30	which	which	WDT
18637	1667	31	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	1667	32	have	have	VBP
18637	1667	33	no	no	DT
18637	1667	34	possible	possible	JJ
18637	1667	35	relation	relation	NN
18637	1667	36	to	to	IN
18637	1667	37	the	the	DT
18637	1667	38	collection	collection	NN
18637	1667	39	of	of	IN
18637	1667	40	the	the	DT
18637	1667	41	tax	tax	NN
18637	1667	42	.	.	.
18637	1668	1	Where	where	WRB
18637	1668	2	a	a	DT
18637	1668	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	1668	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	1668	5	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	1668	6	unconditionally	unconditionally	RB
18637	1668	7	,	,	,
18637	1668	8	so	so	IN
18637	1668	9	that	that	IN
18637	1668	10	no	no	DT
18637	1668	11	other	other	JJ
18637	1668	12	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1668	13	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1668	14	on	on	IN
18637	1668	15	the	the	DT
18637	1668	16	face	face	NN
18637	1668	17	of	of	IN
18637	1668	18	the	the	DT
18637	1668	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	1668	20	,	,	,
18637	1668	21	the	the	DT
18637	1668	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1668	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	1668	24	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	1668	25	to	to	TO
18637	1668	26	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	1668	27	into	into	IN
18637	1668	28	the	the	DT
18637	1668	29	motives	motive	NNS
18637	1668	30	of	of	IN
18637	1668	31	the	the	DT
18637	1668	32	lawmakers	lawmaker	NNS
18637	1668	33	and	and	CC
18637	1668	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	1668	35	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	1668	36	the	the	DT
18637	1668	37	tax	tax	NN
18637	1668	38	despite	despite	IN
18637	1668	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1668	40	prohibitive	prohibitive	JJ
18637	1668	41	proportions	proportion	NNS
18637	1668	42	.	.	.
18637	1669	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1669	2	266	266	CD
18637	1669	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1669	4	In	in	IN
18637	1669	5	the	the	DT
18637	1669	6	language	language	NN
18637	1669	7	of	of	IN
18637	1669	8	a	a	DT
18637	1669	9	recent	recent	JJ
18637	1669	10	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1669	11	:	:	:
18637	1669	12	"	"	``
18637	1669	13	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1669	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	1669	15	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	1669	16	serious	serious	JJ
18637	1669	17	question	question	NN
18637	1669	18	that	that	IN
18637	1669	19	a	a	DT
18637	1669	20	tax	tax	NN
18637	1669	21	does	do	VBZ
18637	1669	22	not	not	RB
18637	1669	23	cease	cease	VB
18637	1669	24	to	to	TO
18637	1669	25	be	be	VB
18637	1669	26	valid	valid	JJ
18637	1669	27	merely	merely	RB
18637	1669	28	because	because	IN
18637	1669	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1669	30	regulates	regulate	VBZ
18637	1669	31	,	,	,
18637	1669	32	discourages	discourage	NNS
18637	1669	33	,	,	,
18637	1669	34	or	or	CC
18637	1669	35	even	even	RB
18637	1669	36	definitely	definitely	RB
18637	1669	37	deters	deter	VBZ
18637	1669	38	the	the	DT
18637	1669	39	activities	activity	NNS
18637	1669	40	taxed	tax	VBD
18637	1669	41	.	.	.
18637	1670	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1670	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1670	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1670	4	The	the	DT
18637	1670	5	principle	principle	NN
18637	1670	6	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	1670	7	even	even	RB
18637	1670	8	though	though	IN
18637	1670	9	the	the	DT
18637	1670	10	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	1670	11	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	1670	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	1670	13	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	1670	14	negligible	negligible	JJ
18637	1670	15	,	,	,
18637	1670	16	*	*	NFP
18637	1670	17	*	*	NFP
18637	1670	18	*	*	NFP
18637	1670	19	,	,	,
18637	1670	20	or	or	CC
18637	1670	21	the	the	DT
18637	1670	22	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	1670	23	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1670	24	of	of	IN
18637	1670	25	the	the	DT
18637	1670	26	tax	tax	NN
18637	1670	27	may	may	MD
18637	1670	28	be	be	VB
18637	1670	29	secondary	secondary	JJ
18637	1670	30	,	,	,
18637	1670	31	*	*	NFP
18637	1670	32	*	*	NFP
18637	1670	33	*	*	NFP
18637	1670	34	Nor	nor	CC
18637	1670	35	does	do	VBZ
18637	1670	36	a	a	DT
18637	1670	37	tax	tax	NN
18637	1670	38	statute	statute	NN
18637	1670	39	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	1670	40	fall	fall	VB
18637	1670	41	because	because	IN
18637	1670	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1670	43	touches	touch	VBZ
18637	1670	44	on	on	IN
18637	1670	45	activities	activity	NNS
18637	1670	46	which	which	WDT
18637	1670	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1670	48	might	may	MD
18637	1670	49	not	not	RB
18637	1670	50	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	1670	51	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1670	52	.	.	.
18637	1671	1	As	as	IN
18637	1671	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1671	3	pointed	point	VBN
18637	1671	4	out	out	RP
18637	1671	5	in	in	IN
18637	1671	6	Magnano	Magnano	NNP
18637	1671	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	1671	8	_	_	NNP
18637	1671	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	1671	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1671	11	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	1671	12	,	,	,
18637	1671	13	292	292	CD
18637	1671	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	1671	15	40	40	CD
18637	1671	16	,	,	,
18637	1671	17	47	47	CD
18637	1671	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1671	19	1934	1934	CD
18637	1671	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1671	21	:	:	:
18637	1671	22	'	'	``
18637	1671	23	From	from	IN
18637	1671	24	the	the	DT
18637	1671	25	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	1671	26	of	of	IN
18637	1671	27	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1671	28	government	government	NN
18637	1671	29	,	,	,
18637	1671	30	the	the	DT
18637	1671	31	courts	court	NNS
18637	1671	32	have	have	VBP
18637	1671	33	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	1671	34	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1671	35	although	although	IN
18637	1671	36	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	1671	37	with	with	IN
18637	1671	38	the	the	DT
18637	1671	39	collateral	collateral	JJ
18637	1671	40	intent	intent	NN
18637	1671	41	of	of	IN
18637	1671	42	effecting	effect	VBG
18637	1671	43	ulterior	ulterior	JJ
18637	1671	44	ends	end	NNS
18637	1671	45	which	which	WDT
18637	1671	46	,	,	,
18637	1671	47	considered	consider	VBN
18637	1671	48	apart	apart	RB
18637	1671	49	,	,	,
18637	1671	50	were	be	VBD
18637	1671	51	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	1671	52	the	the	DT
18637	1671	53	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1671	54	power	power	NN
18637	1671	55	of	of	IN
18637	1671	56	the	the	DT
18637	1671	57	lawmakers	lawmaker	NNS
18637	1671	58	to	to	TO
18637	1671	59	realize	realize	VB
18637	1671	60	by	by	IN
18637	1671	61	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1671	62	directly	directly	RB
18637	1671	63	addressed	address	VBD
18637	1671	64	to	to	IN
18637	1671	65	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1671	66	accomplishment	accomplishment	NN
18637	1671	67	.	.	.
18637	1672	1	'	'	``
18637	1672	2	"	"	``
18637	1672	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1672	4	267	267	CD
18637	1672	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1672	6	But	but	CC
18637	1672	7	where	where	WRB
18637	1672	8	the	the	DT
18637	1672	9	tax	tax	NN
18637	1672	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	1672	11	conditional	conditional	JJ
18637	1672	12	,	,	,
18637	1672	13	and	and	CC
18637	1672	14	may	may	MD
18637	1672	15	be	be	VB
18637	1672	16	avoided	avoid	VBN
18637	1672	17	by	by	IN
18637	1672	18	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	1672	19	with	with	IN
18637	1672	20	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1672	21	set	set	VBN
18637	1672	22	out	out	RP
18637	1672	23	in	in	IN
18637	1672	24	the	the	DT
18637	1672	25	statute	statute	NN
18637	1672	26	,	,	,
18637	1672	27	the	the	DT
18637	1672	28	validity	validity	NN
18637	1672	29	of	of	IN
18637	1672	30	the	the	DT
18637	1672	31	measure	measure	NN
18637	1672	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	1672	33	determined	determine	VBN
18637	1672	34	by	by	IN
18637	1672	35	the	the	DT
18637	1672	36	power	power	NN
18637	1672	37	of	of	IN
18637	1672	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1672	39	to	to	TO
18637	1672	40	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1672	41	the	the	DT
18637	1672	42	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1672	43	matter	matter	NN
18637	1672	44	.	.	.
18637	1673	1	If	if	IN
18637	1673	2	the	the	DT
18637	1673	3	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1673	4	are	be	VBP
18637	1673	5	within	within	IN
18637	1673	6	the	the	DT
18637	1673	7	competence	competence	NN
18637	1673	8	of	of	IN
18637	1673	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1673	10	,	,	,
18637	1673	11	apart	apart	RB
18637	1673	12	from	from	IN
18637	1673	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1673	14	power	power	NN
18637	1673	15	to	to	IN
18637	1673	16	tax	tax	NN
18637	1673	17	,	,	,
18637	1673	18	the	the	DT
18637	1673	19	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	1673	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	1673	21	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	1673	22	as	as	IN
18637	1673	23	an	an	DT
18637	1673	24	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	1673	25	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	1673	26	for	for	IN
18637	1673	27	making	make	VBG
18637	1673	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1673	29	effective;[268	effective;[268	LS
18637	1673	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1673	31	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	1673	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1673	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	1673	34	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	1673	35	.	.	.
18637	1674	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1674	2	269	269	CD
18637	1674	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1674	4	During	during	IN
18637	1674	5	the	the	DT
18637	1674	6	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	1674	7	Era	Era	NNP
18637	1674	8	,	,	,
18637	1674	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1674	10	levied	levy	VBD
18637	1674	11	a	a	DT
18637	1674	12	heavy	heavy	JJ
18637	1674	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	1674	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	1674	15	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	1674	16	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	1674	17	who	who	WP
18637	1674	18	operated	operate	VBD
18637	1674	19	in	in	IN
18637	1674	20	violation	violation	NN
18637	1674	21	of	of	IN
18637	1674	22	State	State	NNP
18637	1674	23	law	law	NN
18637	1674	24	.	.	.
18637	1675	1	In	in	IN
18637	1675	2	United	United	NNP
18637	1675	3	States	States	NNP
18637	1675	4	_	_	NNP
18637	1675	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	1675	6	_	_	NNP
18637	1675	7	Constantine[270	Constantine[270	NNP
18637	1675	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1675	9	the	the	DT
18637	1675	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1675	11	held	hold	VBD
18637	1675	12	that	that	IN
18637	1675	13	this	this	DT
18637	1675	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	1675	15	was	be	VBD
18637	1675	16	unenforceable	unenforceable	JJ
18637	1675	17	after	after	IN
18637	1675	18	the	the	DT
18637	1675	19	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	1675	20	of	of	IN
18637	1675	21	the	the	DT
18637	1675	22	Eighteenth	Eighteenth	NNP
18637	1675	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1675	24	,	,	,
18637	1675	25	since	since	IN
18637	1675	26	the	the	DT
18637	1675	27	National	National	NNP
18637	1675	28	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1675	29	had	have	VBD
18637	1675	30	no	no	DT
18637	1675	31	power	power	NN
18637	1675	32	to	to	TO
18637	1675	33	impose	impose	VB
18637	1675	34	an	an	DT
18637	1675	35	additional	additional	JJ
18637	1675	36	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	1675	37	for	for	IN
18637	1675	38	infractions	infraction	NNS
18637	1675	39	of	of	IN
18637	1675	40	State	State	NNP
18637	1675	41	law	law	NN
18637	1675	42	.	.	.
18637	1676	1	The	the	DT
18637	1676	2	Protective	Protective	NNP
18637	1676	3	Tariff	Tariff	NNP
18637	1676	4	The	the	DT
18637	1676	5	earliest	early	JJS
18637	1676	6	examples	example	NNS
18637	1676	7	of	of	IN
18637	1676	8	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1676	9	levied	levy	VBN
18637	1676	10	with	with	IN
18637	1676	11	a	a	DT
18637	1676	12	view	view	NN
18637	1676	13	to	to	IN
18637	1676	14	promoting	promote	VBG
18637	1676	15	desired	desire	VBN
18637	1676	16	economic	economic	JJ
18637	1676	17	objectives	objective	NNS
18637	1676	18	in	in	IN
18637	1676	19	addition	addition	NN
18637	1676	20	to	to	IN
18637	1676	21	raising	raise	VBG
18637	1676	22	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	1676	23	were	be	VBD
18637	1676	24	,	,	,
18637	1676	25	of	of	IN
18637	1676	26	course	course	NN
18637	1676	27	,	,	,
18637	1676	28	import	import	NN
18637	1676	29	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1676	30	.	.	.
18637	1677	1	The	the	DT
18637	1677	2	second	second	JJ
18637	1677	3	statute	statute	NN
18637	1677	4	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	1677	5	by	by	IN
18637	1677	6	the	the	DT
18637	1677	7	first	first	JJ
18637	1677	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1677	9	was	be	VBD
18637	1677	10	a	a	DT
18637	1677	11	tariff	tariff	NN
18637	1677	12	act	act	NN
18637	1677	13	which	which	WDT
18637	1677	14	recited	recite	VBD
18637	1677	15	that	that	IN
18637	1677	16	"	"	``
18637	1677	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1677	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	1677	19	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1677	20	for	for	IN
18637	1677	21	the	the	DT
18637	1677	22	support	support	NN
18637	1677	23	of	of	IN
18637	1677	24	government	government	NN
18637	1677	25	,	,	,
18637	1677	26	for	for	IN
18637	1677	27	the	the	DT
18637	1677	28	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	1677	29	of	of	IN
18637	1677	30	the	the	DT
18637	1677	31	debts	debt	NNS
18637	1677	32	of	of	IN
18637	1677	33	the	the	DT
18637	1677	34	United	United	NNP
18637	1677	35	States	States	NNP
18637	1677	36	,	,	,
18637	1677	37	and	and	CC
18637	1677	38	the	the	DT
18637	1677	39	encouragement	encouragement	NN
18637	1677	40	and	and	CC
18637	1677	41	protection	protection	NN
18637	1677	42	of	of	IN
18637	1677	43	manufactures	manufacture	NNS
18637	1677	44	,	,	,
18637	1677	45	that	that	WDT
18637	1677	46	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1677	47	be	be	VB
18637	1677	48	laid	lay	VBN
18637	1677	49	on	on	IN
18637	1677	50	goods	good	NNS
18637	1677	51	,	,	,
18637	1677	52	wares	ware	NNS
18637	1677	53	and	and	CC
18637	1677	54	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	1677	55	imported	import	VBN
18637	1677	56	.	.	.
18637	1678	1	"	"	``
18637	1678	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1678	3	271	271	CD
18637	1678	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1678	5	After	after	IN
18637	1678	6	being	be	VBG
18637	1678	7	debated	debate	VBN
18637	1678	8	for	for	IN
18637	1678	9	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	1678	10	a	a	DT
18637	1678	11	century	century	NN
18637	1678	12	and	and	CC
18637	1678	13	a	a	DT
18637	1678	14	half	half	NN
18637	1678	15	,	,	,
18637	1678	16	the	the	DT
18637	1678	17	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	1678	18	of	of	IN
18637	1678	19	protective	protective	JJ
18637	1678	20	tariffs	tariff	NNS
18637	1678	21	was	be	VBD
18637	1678	22	finally	finally	RB
18637	1678	23	settled	settle	VBN
18637	1678	24	by	by	IN
18637	1678	25	the	the	DT
18637	1678	26	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	1678	27	decision	decision	NN
18637	1678	28	of	of	IN
18637	1678	29	the	the	DT
18637	1678	30	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1678	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1678	32	in	in	IN
18637	1678	33	Hampton	Hampton	NNP
18637	1678	34	and	and	CC
18637	1678	35	Company	Company	NNP
18637	1678	36	_	_	NNP
18637	1678	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	1678	38	_	_	NNP
18637	1678	39	United	United	NNP
18637	1678	40	States,[272	States,[272	NNP
18637	1678	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1678	42	where	where	WRB
18637	1678	43	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1678	44	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1678	45	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	1678	46	wrote	write	VBD
18637	1678	47	:	:	:
18637	1678	48	"	"	``
18637	1678	49	The	the	DT
18637	1678	50	second	second	JJ
18637	1678	51	objection	objection	NN
18637	1678	52	to	to	IN
18637	1678	53	§	§	NNP
18637	1678	54	315	315	CD
18637	1678	55	is	be	VBZ
18637	1678	56	that	that	IN
18637	1678	57	the	the	DT
18637	1678	58	declared	declare	VBN
18637	1678	59	plan	plan	NN
18637	1678	60	of	of	IN
18637	1678	61	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1678	62	,	,	,
18637	1678	63	either	either	CC
18637	1678	64	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	1678	65	or	or	CC
18637	1678	66	by	by	IN
18637	1678	67	clear	clear	JJ
18637	1678	68	implication	implication	NN
18637	1678	69	,	,	,
18637	1678	70	formulates	formulate	VBZ
18637	1678	71	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1678	72	rule	rule	NN
18637	1678	73	to	to	TO
18637	1678	74	guide	guide	VB
18637	1678	75	the	the	DT
18637	1678	76	President	President	NNP
18637	1678	77	and	and	CC
18637	1678	78	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1678	79	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	1678	80	Tariff	Tariff	NNP
18637	1678	81	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1678	82	as	as	IN
18637	1678	83	one	one	CD
18637	1678	84	directed	direct	VBD
18637	1678	85	to	to	IN
18637	1678	86	a	a	DT
18637	1678	87	tariff	tariff	NN
18637	1678	88	system	system	NN
18637	1678	89	of	of	IN
18637	1678	90	protection	protection	NN
18637	1678	91	that	that	WDT
18637	1678	92	will	will	MD
18637	1678	93	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	1678	94	damaging	damage	VBG
18637	1678	95	competition	competition	NN
18637	1678	96	to	to	IN
18637	1678	97	the	the	DT
18637	1678	98	country	country	NN
18637	1678	99	's	's	POS
18637	1678	100	industries	industry	NNS
18637	1678	101	by	by	IN
18637	1678	102	the	the	DT
18637	1678	103	importation	importation	NN
18637	1678	104	of	of	IN
18637	1678	105	goods	good	NNS
18637	1678	106	from	from	IN
18637	1678	107	other	other	JJ
18637	1678	108	countries	country	NNS
18637	1678	109	at	at	IN
18637	1678	110	too	too	RB
18637	1678	111	low	low	JJ
18637	1678	112	a	a	DT
18637	1678	113	rate	rate	NN
18637	1678	114	to	to	TO
18637	1678	115	equalize	equalize	VB
18637	1678	116	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1678	117	and	and	CC
18637	1678	118	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	1678	119	competition	competition	NN
18637	1678	120	in	in	IN
18637	1678	121	the	the	DT
18637	1678	122	markets	market	NNS
18637	1678	123	of	of	IN
18637	1678	124	the	the	DT
18637	1678	125	United	United	NNP
18637	1678	126	States	States	NNP
18637	1678	127	.	.	.
18637	1679	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1679	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1679	3	contended	contend	VBN
18637	1679	4	that	that	IN
18637	1679	5	the	the	DT
18637	1679	6	only	only	JJ
18637	1679	7	power	power	NN
18637	1679	8	of	of	IN
18637	1679	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1679	10	in	in	IN
18637	1679	11	the	the	DT
18637	1679	12	levying	levying	NN
18637	1679	13	of	of	IN
18637	1679	14	customs	custom	NNS
18637	1679	15	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1679	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	1679	17	to	to	TO
18637	1679	18	create	create	VB
18637	1679	19	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	1679	20	,	,	,
18637	1679	21	and	and	CC
18637	1679	22	that	that	IN
18637	1679	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1679	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	1679	25	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	1679	26	to	to	TO
18637	1679	27	frame	frame	VB
18637	1679	28	the	the	DT
18637	1679	29	customs	custom	NNS
18637	1679	30	duties	duty	NNS
18637	1679	31	with	with	IN
18637	1679	32	any	any	DT
18637	1679	33	other	other	JJ
18637	1679	34	view	view	NN
18637	1679	35	than	than	IN
18637	1679	36	that	that	DT
18637	1679	37	of	of	IN
18637	1679	38	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	1679	39	raising	raising	NN
18637	1679	40	.	.	.
18637	1680	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1680	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1680	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1680	4	In	in	IN
18637	1680	5	this	this	DT
18637	1680	6	first	first	JJ
18637	1680	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1680	8	sat	sit	VBD
18637	1680	9	many	many	JJ
18637	1680	10	members	member	NNS
18637	1680	11	of	of	IN
18637	1680	12	the	the	DT
18637	1680	13	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	1680	14	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	1680	15	of	of	IN
18637	1680	16	1787	1787	CD
18637	1680	17	.	.	.
18637	1681	1	This	this	DT
18637	1681	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1681	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	1681	4	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	1681	5	laid	lay	VBN
18637	1681	6	down	down	RP
18637	1681	7	the	the	DT
18637	1681	8	principle	principle	NN
18637	1681	9	that	that	IN
18637	1681	10	a	a	DT
18637	1681	11	contemporaneous	contemporaneous	JJ
18637	1681	12	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1681	13	exposition	exposition	NN
18637	1681	14	of	of	IN
18637	1681	15	the	the	DT
18637	1681	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1681	17	when	when	WRB
18637	1681	18	the	the	DT
18637	1681	19	founders	founder	NNS
18637	1681	20	of	of	IN
18637	1681	21	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1681	22	Government	government	NN
18637	1681	23	and	and	CC
18637	1681	24	framers	framer	NNS
18637	1681	25	of	of	IN
18637	1681	26	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1681	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1681	28	were	be	VBD
18637	1681	29	actively	actively	RB
18637	1681	30	participating	participate	VBG
18637	1681	31	in	in	IN
18637	1681	32	public	public	JJ
18637	1681	33	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	1681	34	,	,	,
18637	1681	35	long	long	RB
18637	1681	36	acquiesced	acquiesce	VBN
18637	1681	37	in	in	IN
18637	1681	38	,	,	,
18637	1681	39	fixes	fix	VBZ
18637	1681	40	the	the	DT
18637	1681	41	construction	construction	NN
18637	1681	42	to	to	TO
18637	1681	43	be	be	VB
18637	1681	44	given	give	VBN
18637	1681	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1681	46	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	1681	47	.	.	.
18637	1682	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1682	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1682	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1682	4	The	the	DT
18637	1682	5	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	1682	6	and	and	CC
18637	1682	7	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	1682	8	of	of	IN
18637	1682	9	a	a	DT
18637	1682	10	number	number	NN
18637	1682	11	of	of	IN
18637	1682	12	customs	custom	NNS
18637	1682	13	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	1682	14	laws	law	NNS
18637	1682	15	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	1682	16	with	with	IN
18637	1682	17	a	a	DT
18637	1682	18	motive	motive	NN
18637	1682	19	of	of	IN
18637	1682	20	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	1682	21	a	a	DT
18637	1682	22	system	system	NN
18637	1682	23	of	of	IN
18637	1682	24	protection	protection	NN
18637	1682	25	,	,	,
18637	1682	26	since	since	IN
18637	1682	27	the	the	DT
18637	1682	28	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	1682	29	law	law	NN
18637	1682	30	of	of	IN
18637	1682	31	1789	1789	CD
18637	1682	32	,	,	,
18637	1682	33	are	be	VBP
18637	1682	34	matters	matter	NNS
18637	1682	35	of	of	IN
18637	1682	36	history	history	NN
18637	1682	37	.	.	.
18637	1683	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1683	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1683	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1683	4	Whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	1683	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1683	6	may	may	MD
18637	1683	7	think	think	VB
18637	1683	8	of	of	IN
18637	1683	9	the	the	DT
18637	1683	10	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	1683	11	of	of	IN
18637	1683	12	a	a	DT
18637	1683	13	protection	protection	NN
18637	1683	14	policy	policy	NN
18637	1683	15	,	,	,
18637	1683	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1683	17	can	can	MD
18637	1683	18	not	not	RB
18637	1683	19	hold	hold	VB
18637	1683	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1683	21	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	1683	22	.	.	.
18637	1684	1	So	so	RB
18637	1684	2	long	long	RB
18637	1684	3	as	as	IN
18637	1684	4	the	the	DT
18637	1684	5	motive	motive	NN
18637	1684	6	of	of	IN
18637	1684	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1684	8	and	and	CC
18637	1684	9	the	the	DT
18637	1684	10	effect	effect	NN
18637	1684	11	of	of	IN
18637	1684	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1684	13	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1684	14	action	action	NN
18637	1684	15	are	be	VBP
18637	1684	16	to	to	TO
18637	1684	17	secure	secure	VB
18637	1684	18	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	1684	19	for	for	IN
18637	1684	20	the	the	DT
18637	1684	21	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	1684	22	of	of	IN
18637	1684	23	the	the	DT
18637	1684	24	general	general	JJ
18637	1684	25	government	government	NN
18637	1684	26	,	,	,
18637	1684	27	the	the	DT
18637	1684	28	existence	existence	NN
18637	1684	29	of	of	IN
18637	1684	30	other	other	JJ
18637	1684	31	motives	motive	NNS
18637	1684	32	in	in	IN
18637	1684	33	the	the	DT
18637	1684	34	selection	selection	NN
18637	1684	35	of	of	IN
18637	1684	36	the	the	DT
18637	1684	37	subject	subject	NN
18637	1684	38	of	of	IN
18637	1684	39	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1684	40	can	can	MD
18637	1684	41	not	not	RB
18637	1684	42	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	1684	43	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1684	44	action	action	NN
18637	1684	45	.	.	.
18637	1685	1	"	"	``
18637	1685	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1685	3	273	273	CD
18637	1685	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1685	5	SPENDING	spending	NN
18637	1685	6	FOR	for	IN
18637	1685	7	THE	the	DT
18637	1685	8	GENERAL	GENERAL	NNP
18637	1685	9	WELFARE	WELFARE	NNP
18637	1685	10	The	the	DT
18637	1685	11	grant	grant	NN
18637	1685	12	of	of	IN
18637	1685	13	power	power	NN
18637	1685	14	to	to	TO
18637	1685	15	"	"	``
18637	1685	16	provide	provide	VB
18637	1685	17	*	*	NFP
18637	1685	18	*	*	NFP
18637	1685	19	*	*	NFP
18637	1685	20	for	for	IN
18637	1685	21	the	the	DT
18637	1685	22	general	general	JJ
18637	1685	23	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1685	24	"	"	``
18637	1685	25	raises	raise	VBZ
18637	1685	26	a	a	DT
18637	1685	27	two	two	CD
18637	1685	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	1685	29	fold	fold	JJ
18637	1685	30	question	question	NN
18637	1685	31	:	:	:
18637	1685	32	How	how	WRB
18637	1685	33	may	may	MD
18637	1685	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1685	35	provide	provide	VB
18637	1685	36	for	for	IN
18637	1685	37	"	"	``
18637	1685	38	the	the	DT
18637	1685	39	general	general	JJ
18637	1685	40	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1685	41	"	"	''
18637	1685	42	and	and	CC
18637	1685	43	what	what	WP
18637	1685	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	1685	45	"	"	``
18637	1685	46	the	the	DT
18637	1685	47	general	general	JJ
18637	1685	48	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1685	49	"	"	''
18637	1685	50	which	which	WDT
18637	1685	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1685	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	1685	53	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	1685	54	to	to	TO
18637	1685	55	promote	promote	VB
18637	1685	56	?	?	.
18637	1686	1	The	the	DT
18637	1686	2	first	first	JJ
18637	1686	3	half	half	NN
18637	1686	4	of	of	IN
18637	1686	5	this	this	DT
18637	1686	6	question	question	NN
18637	1686	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1686	8	answered	answer	VBN
18637	1686	9	by	by	IN
18637	1686	10	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	1686	11	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	1686	12	in	in	IN
18637	1686	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1686	14	Opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1686	15	on	on	IN
18637	1686	16	the	the	DT
18637	1686	17	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	1686	18	as	as	IN
18637	1686	19	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	1686	20	:	:	:
18637	1686	21	"	"	``
18637	1686	22	*	*	NFP
18637	1686	23	*	*	NFP
18637	1686	24	*	*	NFP
18637	1686	25	the	the	DT
18637	1686	26	laying	laying	NN
18637	1686	27	of	of	IN
18637	1686	28	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1686	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	1686	30	the	the	DT
18637	1686	31	_	_	NNP
18637	1686	32	power	power	NN
18637	1686	33	_	_	NNP
18637	1686	34	,	,	,
18637	1686	35	and	and	CC
18637	1686	36	the	the	DT
18637	1686	37	general	general	JJ
18637	1686	38	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1686	39	the	the	DT
18637	1686	40	_	_	NNP
18637	1686	41	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1686	42	_	_	NNP
18637	1686	43	for	for	IN
18637	1686	44	which	which	WDT
18637	1686	45	the	the	DT
18637	1686	46	power	power	NN
18637	1686	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	1686	48	to	to	TO
18637	1686	49	be	be	VB
18637	1686	50	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	1686	51	.	.	.
18637	1687	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1687	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1687	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1687	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1687	5	are	be	VBP
18637	1687	6	not	not	RB
18637	1687	7	to	to	TO
18637	1687	8	lay	lay	VB
18637	1687	9	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1687	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1687	11	ad	ad	NN
18637	1687	12	libitum	libitum	NN
18637	1687	13	for	for	IN
18637	1687	14	any	any	DT
18637	1687	15	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1687	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1687	17	please	please	VBP
18637	1687	18	_	_	NNP
18637	1687	19	;	;	:
18637	1687	20	but	but	CC
18637	1687	21	only	only	RB
18637	1687	22	_	_	NNP
18637	1687	23	to	to	TO
18637	1687	24	pay	pay	VB
18637	1687	25	the	the	DT
18637	1687	26	debts	debt	NNS
18637	1687	27	or	or	CC
18637	1687	28	provide	provide	VB
18637	1687	29	for	for	IN
18637	1687	30	the	the	DT
18637	1687	31	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1687	32	of	of	IN
18637	1687	33	the	the	DT
18637	1687	34	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1687	35	_	_	NNP
18637	1687	36	.	.	.
18637	1688	1	In	in	IN
18637	1688	2	like	like	JJ
18637	1688	3	manner	manner	NN
18637	1688	4	,	,	,
18637	1688	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1688	6	are	be	VBP
18637	1688	7	not	not	RB
18637	1688	8	_	_	NNP
18637	1688	9	to	to	TO
18637	1688	10	do	do	VB
18637	1688	11	anything	anything	NN
18637	1688	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1688	13	please	please	VBP
18637	1688	14	_	_	NNP
18637	1688	15	to	to	TO
18637	1688	16	provide	provide	VB
18637	1688	17	for	for	IN
18637	1688	18	the	the	DT
18637	1688	19	general	general	JJ
18637	1688	20	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1688	21	,	,	,
18637	1688	22	but	but	CC
18637	1688	23	only	only	RB
18637	1688	24	to	to	IN
18637	1688	25	_	_	NNP
18637	1688	26	lay	lie	VBD
18637	1688	27	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1688	28	_	_	NNP
18637	1688	29	for	for	IN
18637	1688	30	that	that	DT
18637	1688	31	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1688	32	.	.	.
18637	1689	1	"	"	``
18637	1689	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1689	3	274	274	CD
18637	1689	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1689	5	The	the	DT
18637	1689	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	1689	7	,	,	,
18637	1689	8	in	in	IN
18637	1689	9	short	short	JJ
18637	1689	10	,	,	,
18637	1689	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	1689	12	not	not	RB
18637	1689	13	an	an	DT
18637	1689	14	independent	independent	JJ
18637	1689	15	grant	grant	NN
18637	1689	16	of	of	IN
18637	1689	17	power	power	NN
18637	1689	18	,	,	,
18637	1689	19	but	but	CC
18637	1689	20	a	a	DT
18637	1689	21	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	1689	22	of	of	IN
18637	1689	23	the	the	DT
18637	1689	24	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	1689	25	power	power	NN
18637	1689	26	.	.	.
18637	1690	1	Although	although	IN
18637	1690	2	a	a	DT
18637	1690	3	broader	broad	JJR
18637	1690	4	view	view	NN
18637	1690	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	1690	6	been	be	VBN
18637	1690	7	occasionally	occasionally	RB
18637	1690	8	asserted,[275	asserted,[275	JJ
18637	1690	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1690	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1690	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	1690	12	not	not	RB
18637	1690	13	acted	act	VBN
18637	1690	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	1690	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1690	16	and	and	CC
18637	1690	17	the	the	DT
18637	1690	18	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	1690	19	have	have	VBP
18637	1690	20	had	have	VBN
18637	1690	21	no	no	DT
18637	1690	22	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	1690	23	to	to	TO
18637	1690	24	adjudicate	adjudicate	VB
18637	1690	25	the	the	DT
18637	1690	26	point	point	NN
18637	1690	27	.	.	.
18637	1691	1	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	1691	2	_	_	NNP
18637	1691	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	1691	4	_	_	NNP
18637	1691	5	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	1691	6	With	with	IN
18637	1691	7	respect	respect	NN
18637	1691	8	to	to	IN
18637	1691	9	the	the	DT
18637	1691	10	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	1691	11	of	of	IN
18637	1691	12	"	"	``
18637	1691	13	the	the	DT
18637	1691	14	general	general	JJ
18637	1691	15	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1691	16	"	"	``
18637	1691	17	the	the	DT
18637	1691	18	pages	page	NNS
18637	1691	19	of	of	IN
18637	1691	20	The	the	DT
18637	1691	21	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	1691	22	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1691	23	disclose	disclose	VBP
18637	1691	24	a	a	DT
18637	1691	25	sharp	sharp	JJ
18637	1691	26	divergence	divergence	NN
18637	1691	27	of	of	IN
18637	1691	28	views	view	NNS
18637	1691	29	between	between	IN
18637	1691	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1691	31	two	two	CD
18637	1691	32	principal	principal	JJ
18637	1691	33	authors	author	NNS
18637	1691	34	.	.	.
18637	1692	1	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	1692	2	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	1692	3	the	the	DT
18637	1692	4	literal	literal	JJ
18637	1692	5	,	,	,
18637	1692	6	broad	broad	JJ
18637	1692	7	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	1692	8	of	of	IN
18637	1692	9	the	the	DT
18637	1692	10	clause;[276	clause;[276	NNS
18637	1692	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1692	12	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	1692	13	contended	contend	VBD
18637	1692	14	that	that	IN
18637	1692	15	the	the	DT
18637	1692	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	1692	17	of	of	IN
18637	1692	18	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1692	19	and	and	CC
18637	1692	20	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	1692	21	of	of	IN
18637	1692	22	the	the	DT
18637	1692	23	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1692	24	government	government	NN
18637	1692	25	should	should	MD
18637	1692	26	be	be	VB
18637	1692	27	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	1692	28	as	as	RB
18637	1692	29	merely	merely	RB
18637	1692	30	instrumental	instrumental	JJ
18637	1692	31	to	to	IN
18637	1692	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1692	33	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	1692	34	powers	power	NNS
18637	1692	35	,	,	,
18637	1692	36	in	in	IN
18637	1692	37	other	other	JJ
18637	1692	38	words	word	NNS
18637	1692	39	,	,	,
18637	1692	40	as	as	IN
18637	1692	41	little	little	JJ
18637	1692	42	more	more	JJR
18637	1692	43	than	than	IN
18637	1692	44	a	a	DT
18637	1692	45	power	power	NN
18637	1692	46	of	of	IN
18637	1692	47	self	self	NN
18637	1692	48	-	-	HYPH
18637	1692	49	support	support	NN
18637	1692	50	.	.	.
18637	1693	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1693	2	277	277	CD
18637	1693	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1693	4	From	from	IN
18637	1693	5	an	an	DT
18637	1693	6	early	early	JJ
18637	1693	7	date	date	NN
18637	1693	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1693	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	1693	10	acted	act	VBN
18637	1693	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	1693	12	the	the	DT
18637	1693	13	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	1693	14	espoused	espouse	VBN
18637	1693	15	by	by	IN
18637	1693	16	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	1693	17	.	.	.
18637	1694	1	Appropriations	appropriation	NNS
18637	1694	2	for	for	IN
18637	1694	3	subsidies[278	subsidies[278	FW
18637	1694	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1694	5	and	and	CC
18637	1694	6	for	for	IN
18637	1694	7	an	an	DT
18637	1694	8	ever	ever	RB
18637	1694	9	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	1694	10	variety	variety	NN
18637	1694	11	of	of	IN
18637	1694	12	"	"	``
18637	1694	13	internal	internal	JJ
18637	1694	14	improvements"[279	improvements"[279	NN
18637	1694	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1694	16	constructed	construct	VBN
18637	1694	17	by	by	IN
18637	1694	18	the	the	DT
18637	1694	19	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1694	20	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1694	21	,	,	,
18637	1694	22	had	have	VBD
18637	1694	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1694	24	beginnings	beginning	NNS
18637	1694	25	in	in	IN
18637	1694	26	the	the	DT
18637	1694	27	administrations	administration	NNS
18637	1694	28	of	of	IN
18637	1694	29	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	1694	30	and	and	CC
18637	1694	31	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	1694	32	.	.	.
18637	1695	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1695	2	280	280	CD
18637	1695	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1695	4	Since	since	IN
18637	1695	5	1914	1914	CD
18637	1695	6	,	,	,
18637	1695	7	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1695	8	grants	grant	NNS
18637	1695	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	1695	10	in	in	NN
18637	1695	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	1695	12	aid,--sums	aid,--sum	NNS
18637	1695	13	of	of	IN
18637	1695	14	money	money	NN
18637	1695	15	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	1695	16	among	among	IN
18637	1695	17	the	the	DT
18637	1695	18	States	States	NNP
18637	1695	19	for	for	IN
18637	1695	20	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1695	21	uses	use	NNS
18637	1695	22	,	,	,
18637	1695	23	often	often	RB
18637	1695	24	conditioned	condition	VBN
18637	1695	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	1695	26	the	the	DT
18637	1695	27	duplication	duplication	NN
18637	1695	28	of	of	IN
18637	1695	29	the	the	DT
18637	1695	30	sums	sum	NNS
18637	1695	31	by	by	IN
18637	1695	32	the	the	DT
18637	1695	33	recipient	recipient	JJ
18637	1695	34	State	State	NNP
18637	1695	35	,	,	,
18637	1695	36	and	and	CC
18637	1695	37	upon	upon	IN
18637	1695	38	observance	observance	NN
18637	1695	39	of	of	IN
18637	1695	40	stipulated	stipulate	VBN
18637	1695	41	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	1695	42	as	as	IN
18637	1695	43	to	to	IN
18637	1695	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1695	45	use	use	NN
18637	1695	46	--	--	:
18637	1695	47	have	have	VBP
18637	1695	48	become	become	VBN
18637	1695	49	commonplace	commonplace	JJ
18637	1695	50	.	.	.
18637	1696	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1696	2	281	281	CD
18637	1696	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1696	4	Triumph	Triumph	NNP
18637	1696	5	of	of	IN
18637	1696	6	the	the	DT
18637	1696	7	Hamiltonian	Hamiltonian	NNP
18637	1696	8	Theory	Theory	NNP
18637	1696	9	The	the	DT
18637	1696	10	scope	scope	NN
18637	1696	11	of	of	IN
18637	1696	12	the	the	DT
18637	1696	13	national	national	JJ
18637	1696	14	spending	spending	NN
18637	1696	15	power	power	NN
18637	1696	16	was	be	VBD
18637	1696	17	brought	bring	VBN
18637	1696	18	before	before	IN
18637	1696	19	the	the	DT
18637	1696	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1696	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1696	22	at	at	IN
18637	1696	23	least	least	JJS
18637	1696	24	five	five	CD
18637	1696	25	times	time	NNS
18637	1696	26	prior	prior	RB
18637	1696	27	to	to	IN
18637	1696	28	1936	1936	CD
18637	1696	29	,	,	,
18637	1696	30	but	but	CC
18637	1696	31	the	the	DT
18637	1696	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1696	33	disposed	dispose	VBD
18637	1696	34	of	of	IN
18637	1696	35	four	four	CD
18637	1696	36	of	of	IN
18637	1696	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1696	38	without	without	IN
18637	1696	39	construing	construe	VBG
18637	1696	40	the	the	DT
18637	1696	41	"	"	``
18637	1696	42	general	general	JJ
18637	1696	43	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1696	44	"	"	''
18637	1696	45	clause	clause	NN
18637	1696	46	.	.	.
18637	1697	1	In	in	IN
18637	1697	2	the	the	DT
18637	1697	3	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	1697	4	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	1697	5	Cases[282	Cases[282	NNP
18637	1697	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1697	7	and	and	CC
18637	1697	8	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	1697	9	_	_	NNP
18637	1697	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	1697	11	_	_	NNP
18637	1697	12	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	1697	13	City	City	NNP
18637	1697	14	Title	Title	NNP
18637	1697	15	and	and	CC
18637	1697	16	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	1697	17	Company,[283	Company,[283	NNP
18637	1697	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1697	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1697	20	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	1697	21	the	the	DT
18637	1697	22	power	power	NN
18637	1697	23	of	of	IN
18637	1697	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1697	25	to	to	TO
18637	1697	26	construct	construct	VB
18637	1697	27	internal	internal	JJ
18637	1697	28	improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	1697	29	,	,	,
18637	1697	30	and	and	CC
18637	1697	31	to	to	TO
18637	1697	32	charter	charter	VB
18637	1697	33	and	and	CC
18637	1697	34	purchase	purchase	VB
18637	1697	35	the	the	DT
18637	1697	36	capital	capital	NN
18637	1697	37	stock	stock	NN
18637	1697	38	of	of	IN
18637	1697	39	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1697	40	land	land	NN
18637	1697	41	banks	bank	NNS
18637	1697	42	,	,	,
18637	1697	43	by	by	IN
18637	1697	44	reference	reference	NN
18637	1697	45	to	to	IN
18637	1697	46	the	the	DT
18637	1697	47	powers	power	NNS
18637	1697	48	of	of	IN
18637	1697	49	the	the	DT
18637	1697	50	National	National	NNP
18637	1697	51	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1697	52	over	over	IN
18637	1697	53	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1697	54	,	,	,
18637	1697	55	the	the	DT
18637	1697	56	post	post	JJ
18637	1697	57	roads	road	NNS
18637	1697	58	and	and	CC
18637	1697	59	fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	1697	60	operations	operation	NNS
18637	1697	61	,	,	,
18637	1697	62	and	and	CC
18637	1697	63	to	to	IN
18637	1697	64	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1697	65	war	war	NN
18637	1697	66	powers	power	NNS
18637	1697	67	.	.	.
18637	1698	1	Decisions	decision	NNS
18637	1698	2	on	on	IN
18637	1698	3	the	the	DT
18637	1698	4	merits	merit	NNS
18637	1698	5	were	be	VBD
18637	1698	6	withheld	withhold	VBN
18637	1698	7	in	in	IN
18637	1698	8	two	two	CD
18637	1698	9	other	other	JJ
18637	1698	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	1698	11	--	--	:
18637	1698	12	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	1698	13	_	_	NNP
18637	1698	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	1698	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1698	16	Mellon	Mellon	NNP
18637	1698	17	and	and	CC
18637	1698	18	Frothingham	Frothingham	NNP
18637	1698	19	_	_	NNP
18637	1698	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	1698	21	_	_	NNP
18637	1698	22	Mellon[284]--on	Mellon[284]--on	NNP
18637	1698	23	the	the	DT
18637	1698	24	ground	ground	NN
18637	1698	25	that	that	IN
18637	1698	26	neither	neither	CC
18637	1698	27	a	a	DT
18637	1698	28	State	state	NN
18637	1698	29	nor	nor	CC
18637	1698	30	an	an	DT
18637	1698	31	individual	individual	JJ
18637	1698	32	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	1698	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	1698	34	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	1698	35	to	to	IN
18637	1698	36	a	a	DT
18637	1698	37	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	1698	38	in	in	IN
18637	1698	39	the	the	DT
18637	1698	40	courts	court	NNS
18637	1698	41	against	against	IN
18637	1698	42	an	an	DT
18637	1698	43	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	1698	44	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	1698	45	of	of	IN
18637	1698	46	national	national	JJ
18637	1698	47	funds	fund	NNS
18637	1698	48	.	.	.
18637	1699	1	In	in	IN
18637	1699	2	United	United	NNP
18637	1699	3	States	States	NNP
18637	1699	4	_	_	NNP
18637	1699	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	1699	6	_	_	NNP
18637	1699	7	Gettysburg	Gettysburg	NNP
18637	1699	8	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	1699	9	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	1699	10	Co	Co	NNP
18637	1699	11	.	.	.
18637	1699	12	,[285	,[285	NFP
18637	1699	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1699	14	however	however	RB
18637	1699	15	,	,	,
18637	1699	16	the	the	DT
18637	1699	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1699	18	had	have	VBD
18637	1699	19	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	1699	20	"	"	``
18637	1699	21	the	the	DT
18637	1699	22	great	great	JJ
18637	1699	23	power	power	NN
18637	1699	24	of	of	IN
18637	1699	25	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1699	26	to	to	TO
18637	1699	27	be	be	VB
18637	1699	28	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	1699	29	for	for	IN
18637	1699	30	the	the	DT
18637	1699	31	common	common	JJ
18637	1699	32	defence	defence	NN
18637	1699	33	and	and	CC
18637	1699	34	the	the	DT
18637	1699	35	general	general	JJ
18637	1699	36	welfare,"[286	welfare,"[286	NN
18637	1699	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1699	38	to	to	TO
18637	1699	39	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	1699	40	the	the	DT
18637	1699	41	right	right	NN
18637	1699	42	of	of	IN
18637	1699	43	the	the	DT
18637	1699	44	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1699	45	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1699	46	to	to	TO
18637	1699	47	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	1699	48	land	land	NN
18637	1699	49	within	within	IN
18637	1699	50	a	a	DT
18637	1699	51	State	State	NNP
18637	1699	52	for	for	IN
18637	1699	53	use	use	NN
18637	1699	54	as	as	IN
18637	1699	55	a	a	DT
18637	1699	56	national	national	JJ
18637	1699	57	park	park	NN
18637	1699	58	.	.	.
18637	1700	1	Finally	finally	RB
18637	1700	2	,	,	,
18637	1700	3	in	in	IN
18637	1700	4	United	United	NNP
18637	1700	5	States	States	NNP
18637	1700	6	_	_	NNP
18637	1700	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	1700	8	_	_	NNP
18637	1700	9	Butler,[287	Butler,[287	NNP
18637	1700	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1700	11	the	the	DT
18637	1700	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1700	13	gave	give	VBD
18637	1700	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1700	15	unqualified	unqualified	JJ
18637	1700	16	endorsement	endorsement	NN
18637	1700	17	to	to	IN
18637	1700	18	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	1700	19	's	's	POS
18637	1700	20	views	view	NNS
18637	1700	21	on	on	IN
18637	1700	22	the	the	DT
18637	1700	23	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	1700	24	power	power	NN
18637	1700	25	.	.	.
18637	1701	1	Wrote	write	VBD
18637	1701	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1701	3	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	1701	4	for	for	IN
18637	1701	5	the	the	DT
18637	1701	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1701	7	:	:	:
18637	1701	8	"	"	``
18637	1701	9	Since	since	IN
18637	1701	10	the	the	DT
18637	1701	11	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	1701	12	of	of	IN
18637	1701	13	the	the	DT
18637	1701	14	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	1701	15	sharp	sharp	JJ
18637	1701	16	differences	difference	NNS
18637	1701	17	of	of	IN
18637	1701	18	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1701	19	have	have	VBP
18637	1701	20	persisted	persist	VBN
18637	1701	21	as	as	IN
18637	1701	22	to	to	IN
18637	1701	23	the	the	DT
18637	1701	24	true	true	JJ
18637	1701	25	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	1701	26	of	of	IN
18637	1701	27	the	the	DT
18637	1701	28	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	1701	29	.	.	.
18637	1702	1	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	1702	2	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	1702	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1702	4	amounted	amount	VBD
18637	1702	5	to	to	IN
18637	1702	6	no	no	DT
18637	1702	7	more	more	JJR
18637	1702	8	than	than	IN
18637	1702	9	a	a	DT
18637	1702	10	reference	reference	NN
18637	1702	11	to	to	IN
18637	1702	12	the	the	DT
18637	1702	13	other	other	JJ
18637	1702	14	powers	power	NNS
18637	1702	15	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	1702	16	in	in	IN
18637	1702	17	the	the	DT
18637	1702	18	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	1702	19	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	1702	20	of	of	IN
18637	1702	21	the	the	DT
18637	1702	22	same	same	JJ
18637	1702	23	section	section	NN
18637	1702	24	;	;	:
18637	1702	25	that	that	IN
18637	1702	26	,	,	,
18637	1702	27	as	as	IN
18637	1702	28	the	the	DT
18637	1702	29	United	United	NNP
18637	1702	30	States	States	NNP
18637	1702	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	1702	32	a	a	DT
18637	1702	33	government	government	NN
18637	1702	34	of	of	IN
18637	1702	35	limited	limited	JJ
18637	1702	36	and	and	CC
18637	1702	37	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	1702	38	powers	power	NNS
18637	1702	39	,	,	,
18637	1702	40	the	the	DT
18637	1702	41	grant	grant	NN
18637	1702	42	of	of	IN
18637	1702	43	power	power	NN
18637	1702	44	to	to	IN
18637	1702	45	tax	tax	VB
18637	1702	46	and	and	CC
18637	1702	47	spend	spend	VB
18637	1702	48	for	for	IN
18637	1702	49	the	the	DT
18637	1702	50	general	general	JJ
18637	1702	51	national	national	JJ
18637	1702	52	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1702	53	must	must	MD
18637	1702	54	be	be	VB
18637	1702	55	confined	confine	VBN
18637	1702	56	to	to	IN
18637	1702	57	the	the	DT
18637	1702	58	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	1702	59	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1702	60	fields	field	NNS
18637	1702	61	committed	commit	VBN
18637	1702	62	to	to	IN
18637	1702	63	the	the	DT
18637	1702	64	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1702	65	.	.	.
18637	1703	1	In	in	IN
18637	1703	2	this	this	DT
18637	1703	3	view	view	NN
18637	1703	4	the	the	DT
18637	1703	5	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	1703	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	1703	7	mere	mere	JJ
18637	1703	8	tautology	tautology	NN
18637	1703	9	,	,	,
18637	1703	10	for	for	IN
18637	1703	11	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1703	12	and	and	CC
18637	1703	13	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	1703	14	are	be	VBP
18637	1703	15	or	or	CC
18637	1703	16	may	may	MD
18637	1703	17	be	be	VB
18637	1703	18	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1703	19	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	1703	20	of	of	IN
18637	1703	21	the	the	DT
18637	1703	22	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1703	23	of	of	IN
18637	1703	24	any	any	DT
18637	1703	25	of	of	IN
18637	1703	26	the	the	DT
18637	1703	27	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	1703	28	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1703	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	1703	30	.	.	.
18637	1704	1	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	1704	2	,	,	,
18637	1704	3	on	on	IN
18637	1704	4	the	the	DT
18637	1704	5	other	other	JJ
18637	1704	6	hand	hand	NN
18637	1704	7	,	,	,
18637	1704	8	maintained	maintain	VBD
18637	1704	9	the	the	DT
18637	1704	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	1704	11	confers	confer	NNS
18637	1704	12	a	a	DT
18637	1704	13	power	power	NN
18637	1704	14	separate	separate	JJ
18637	1704	15	and	and	CC
18637	1704	16	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	1704	17	from	from	IN
18637	1704	18	those	those	DT
18637	1704	19	later	later	RB
18637	1704	20	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	1704	21	,	,	,
18637	1704	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	1704	23	not	not	RB
18637	1704	24	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	1704	25	in	in	IN
18637	1704	26	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	1704	27	by	by	IN
18637	1704	28	the	the	DT
18637	1704	29	grant	grant	NN
18637	1704	30	of	of	IN
18637	1704	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1704	32	,	,	,
18637	1704	33	and	and	CC
18637	1704	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1704	35	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	1704	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	1704	37	a	a	DT
18637	1704	38	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	1704	39	power	power	NN
18637	1704	40	to	to	IN
18637	1704	41	tax	tax	NN
18637	1704	42	and	and	CC
18637	1704	43	to	to	TO
18637	1704	44	appropriate	appropriate	VB
18637	1704	45	,	,	,
18637	1704	46	limited	limit	VBN
18637	1704	47	only	only	RB
18637	1704	48	by	by	IN
18637	1704	49	the	the	DT
18637	1704	50	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	1704	51	that	that	IN
18637	1704	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1704	53	shall	shall	MD
18637	1704	54	be	be	VB
18637	1704	55	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	1704	56	to	to	TO
18637	1704	57	provide	provide	VB
18637	1704	58	for	for	IN
18637	1704	59	the	the	DT
18637	1704	60	general	general	JJ
18637	1704	61	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1704	62	of	of	IN
18637	1704	63	the	the	DT
18637	1704	64	United	United	NNP
18637	1704	65	States	States	NNP
18637	1704	66	.	.	.
18637	1705	1	Each	each	DT
18637	1705	2	contention	contention	NN
18637	1705	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	1705	4	had	have	VBN
18637	1705	5	the	the	DT
18637	1705	6	support	support	NN
18637	1705	7	of	of	IN
18637	1705	8	those	those	DT
18637	1705	9	whose	whose	WP$
18637	1705	10	views	view	NNS
18637	1705	11	are	be	VBP
18637	1705	12	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	1705	13	to	to	IN
18637	1705	14	weight	weight	NN
18637	1705	15	.	.	.
18637	1706	1	This	this	DT
18637	1706	2	court	court	NN
18637	1706	3	had	have	VBD
18637	1706	4	noticed	notice	VBN
18637	1706	5	the	the	DT
18637	1706	6	question	question	NN
18637	1706	7	,	,	,
18637	1706	8	but	but	CC
18637	1706	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	1706	10	never	never	RB
18637	1706	11	found	find	VBN
18637	1706	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1706	13	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1706	14	to	to	TO
18637	1706	15	decide	decide	VB
18637	1706	16	which	which	WDT
18637	1706	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	1706	18	the	the	DT
18637	1706	19	true	true	JJ
18637	1706	20	construction	construction	NN
18637	1706	21	.	.	.
18637	1707	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1707	2	Story	Story	NNP
18637	1707	3	,	,	,
18637	1707	4	in	in	IN
18637	1707	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1707	6	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	1707	7	,	,	,
18637	1707	8	espouses	espouse	VBZ
18637	1707	9	the	the	DT
18637	1707	10	Hamiltonian	hamiltonian	JJ
18637	1707	11	position	position	NN
18637	1707	12	.	.	.
18637	1708	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1708	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	1708	3	not	not	RB
18637	1708	4	review	review	VB
18637	1708	5	the	the	DT
18637	1708	6	writings	writing	NNS
18637	1708	7	of	of	IN
18637	1708	8	public	public	JJ
18637	1708	9	men	man	NNS
18637	1708	10	and	and	CC
18637	1708	11	commentators	commentator	NNS
18637	1708	12	or	or	CC
18637	1708	13	discuss	discuss	VB
18637	1708	14	the	the	DT
18637	1708	15	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1708	16	practice	practice	NN
18637	1708	17	.	.	.
18637	1709	1	Study	study	NN
18637	1709	2	of	of	IN
18637	1709	3	all	all	PDT
18637	1709	4	these	these	DT
18637	1709	5	leads	lead	VBZ
18637	1709	6	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1709	7	to	to	TO
18637	1709	8	conclude	conclude	VB
18637	1709	9	that	that	IN
18637	1709	10	the	the	DT
18637	1709	11	reading	reading	NN
18637	1709	12	advocated	advocate	VBN
18637	1709	13	by	by	IN
18637	1709	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1709	15	Story	Story	NNP
18637	1709	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	1709	17	the	the	DT
18637	1709	18	correct	correct	JJ
18637	1709	19	one	one	NN
18637	1709	20	.	.	.
18637	1710	1	While	while	IN
18637	1710	2	,	,	,
18637	1710	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	1710	4	,	,	,
18637	1710	5	the	the	DT
18637	1710	6	power	power	NN
18637	1710	7	to	to	TO
18637	1710	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	1710	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	1710	10	not	not	RB
18637	1710	11	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	1710	12	,	,	,
18637	1710	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1710	14	confines	confine	NNS
18637	1710	15	are	be	VBP
18637	1710	16	set	set	VBN
18637	1710	17	in	in	IN
18637	1710	18	the	the	DT
18637	1710	19	clause	clause	NN
18637	1710	20	which	which	WDT
18637	1710	21	confers	confer	VBZ
18637	1710	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1710	23	,	,	,
18637	1710	24	and	and	CC
18637	1710	25	not	not	RB
18637	1710	26	in	in	IN
18637	1710	27	those	those	DT
18637	1710	28	of	of	IN
18637	1710	29	§	§	NNP
18637	1710	30	8	8	CD
18637	1710	31	which	which	WDT
18637	1710	32	bestow	bestow	VBP
18637	1710	33	and	and	CC
18637	1710	34	define	define	VB
18637	1710	35	the	the	DT
18637	1710	36	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1710	37	powers	power	NNS
18637	1710	38	of	of	IN
18637	1710	39	the	the	DT
18637	1710	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1710	41	.	.	.
18637	1711	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1711	2	results	result	VBZ
18637	1711	3	that	that	IN
18637	1711	4	the	the	DT
18637	1711	5	power	power	NN
18637	1711	6	of	of	IN
18637	1711	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1711	8	to	to	TO
18637	1711	9	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	1711	10	expenditure	expenditure	NN
18637	1711	11	of	of	IN
18637	1711	12	public	public	JJ
18637	1711	13	moneys	money	NNS
18637	1711	14	for	for	IN
18637	1711	15	public	public	JJ
18637	1711	16	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	1711	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	1711	18	not	not	RB
18637	1711	19	limited	limit	VBN
18637	1711	20	by	by	IN
18637	1711	21	the	the	DT
18637	1711	22	direct	direct	JJ
18637	1711	23	grants	grant	NNS
18637	1711	24	of	of	IN
18637	1711	25	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1711	26	power	power	NN
18637	1711	27	found	find	VBN
18637	1711	28	in	in	IN
18637	1711	29	the	the	DT
18637	1711	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1711	31	.	.	.
18637	1712	1	"	"	``
18637	1712	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1712	3	288	288	CD
18637	1712	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1712	5	The	the	DT
18637	1712	6	Security	Security	NNP
18637	1712	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1712	8	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	1712	9	Although	although	IN
18637	1712	10	holding	hold	VBG
18637	1712	11	that	that	IN
18637	1712	12	the	the	DT
18637	1712	13	spending	spending	NN
18637	1712	14	power	power	NN
18637	1712	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	1712	16	not	not	RB
18637	1712	17	limited	limit	VBN
18637	1712	18	by	by	IN
18637	1712	19	the	the	DT
18637	1712	20	specific	specific	JJ
18637	1712	21	grants	grant	NNS
18637	1712	22	of	of	IN
18637	1712	23	power	power	NN
18637	1712	24	contained	contain	VBN
18637	1712	25	in	in	IN
18637	1712	26	article	article	NN
18637	1712	27	I	i	NN
18637	1712	28	,	,	,
18637	1712	29	section	section	NN
18637	1712	30	8	8	CD
18637	1712	31	,	,	,
18637	1712	32	the	the	DT
18637	1712	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1712	34	found	find	VBD
18637	1712	35	,	,	,
18637	1712	36	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	1712	37	,	,	,
18637	1712	38	that	that	IN
18637	1712	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1712	40	was	be	VBD
18637	1712	41	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	1712	42	by	by	IN
18637	1712	43	the	the	DT
18637	1712	44	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	1712	45	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1712	46	,	,	,
18637	1712	47	and	and	CC
18637	1712	48	on	on	IN
18637	1712	49	this	this	DT
18637	1712	50	ground	ground	NN
18637	1712	51	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	1712	52	in	in	IN
18637	1712	53	the	the	DT
18637	1712	54	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	1712	55	case	case	NN
18637	1712	56	that	that	IN
18637	1712	57	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1712	58	could	could	MD
18637	1712	59	not	not	RB
18637	1712	60	use	use	VB
18637	1712	61	moneys	money	NNS
18637	1712	62	raised	raise	VBN
18637	1712	63	by	by	IN
18637	1712	64	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1712	65	to	to	TO
18637	1712	66	"	"	``
18637	1712	67	purchase	purchase	VB
18637	1712	68	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	1712	69	"	"	''
18637	1712	70	with	with	IN
18637	1712	71	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	1712	72	"	"	''
18637	1712	73	of	of	IN
18637	1712	74	matters	matter	NNS
18637	1712	75	of	of	IN
18637	1712	76	State	state	NN
18637	1712	77	concern	concern	NN
18637	1712	78	with	with	IN
18637	1712	79	respect	respect	NN
18637	1712	80	to	to	IN
18637	1712	81	which	which	WDT
18637	1712	82	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1712	83	has	have	VBZ
18637	1712	84	no	no	DT
18637	1712	85	authority	authority	NN
18637	1712	86	to	to	TO
18637	1712	87	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	1712	88	.	.	.
18637	1713	1	"	"	``
18637	1713	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1713	3	289	289	CD
18637	1713	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1713	5	Within	within	IN
18637	1713	6	little	little	JJ
18637	1713	7	more	more	JJR
18637	1713	8	than	than	IN
18637	1713	9	a	a	DT
18637	1713	10	year	year	NN
18637	1713	11	this	this	DT
18637	1713	12	decision	decision	NN
18637	1713	13	was	be	VBD
18637	1713	14	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	1713	15	to	to	IN
18637	1713	16	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	1713	17	proportions	proportion	NNS
18637	1713	18	by	by	IN
18637	1713	19	Steward	Steward	NNP
18637	1713	20	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	1713	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	1713	22	_	_	NNP
18637	1713	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	1713	24	_	_	NNP
18637	1713	25	Davis,[290	Davis,[290	NNP
18637	1713	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1713	27	which	which	WDT
18637	1713	28	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1713	29	the	the	DT
18637	1713	30	tax	tax	NN
18637	1713	31	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	1713	32	on	on	IN
18637	1713	33	employers	employer	NNS
18637	1713	34	to	to	TO
18637	1713	35	provide	provide	VB
18637	1713	36	unemployment	unemployment	NN
18637	1713	37	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	1713	38	,	,	,
18637	1713	39	and	and	CC
18637	1713	40	the	the	DT
18637	1713	41	credit	credit	NN
18637	1713	42	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	1713	43	for	for	IN
18637	1713	44	similar	similar	JJ
18637	1713	45	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1713	46	paid	pay	VBN
18637	1713	47	to	to	IN
18637	1713	48	a	a	DT
18637	1713	49	State	state	NN
18637	1713	50	.	.	.
18637	1714	1	To	to	IN
18637	1714	2	the	the	DT
18637	1714	3	argument	argument	NN
18637	1714	4	that	that	IN
18637	1714	5	the	the	DT
18637	1714	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	1714	7	and	and	CC
18637	1714	8	credit	credit	NN
18637	1714	9	in	in	IN
18637	1714	10	combination	combination	NN
18637	1714	11	were	be	VBD
18637	1714	12	"	"	``
18637	1714	13	weapons	weapon	NNS
18637	1714	14	of	of	IN
18637	1714	15	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	1714	16	,	,	,
18637	1714	17	destroying	destroy	VBG
18637	1714	18	or	or	CC
18637	1714	19	impairing	impair	VBG
18637	1714	20	the	the	DT
18637	1714	21	autonomy	autonomy	NN
18637	1714	22	of	of	IN
18637	1714	23	the	the	DT
18637	1714	24	States	States	NNPS
18637	1714	25	,	,	,
18637	1714	26	"	"	''
18637	1714	27	the	the	DT
18637	1714	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1714	29	replied	reply	VBD
18637	1714	30	that	that	IN
18637	1714	31	relief	relief	NN
18637	1714	32	of	of	IN
18637	1714	33	unemployment	unemployment	NN
18637	1714	34	was	be	VBD
18637	1714	35	a	a	DT
18637	1714	36	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	1714	37	object	object	NN
18637	1714	38	of	of	IN
18637	1714	39	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1714	40	expenditure	expenditure	NN
18637	1714	41	under	under	IN
18637	1714	42	the	the	DT
18637	1714	43	"	"	``
18637	1714	44	general	general	JJ
18637	1714	45	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1714	46	"	"	''
18637	1714	47	clause	clause	NN
18637	1714	48	;	;	:
18637	1714	49	that	that	IN
18637	1714	50	the	the	DT
18637	1714	51	Social	Social	NNP
18637	1714	52	Security	Security	NNP
18637	1714	53	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1714	54	represented	represent	VBD
18637	1714	55	a	a	DT
18637	1714	56	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	1714	57	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	1714	58	to	to	TO
18637	1714	59	solve	solve	VB
18637	1714	60	the	the	DT
18637	1714	61	problem	problem	NN
18637	1714	62	by	by	IN
18637	1714	63	the	the	DT
18637	1714	64	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	1714	65	of	of	IN
18637	1714	66	State	State	NNP
18637	1714	67	and	and	CC
18637	1714	68	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1714	69	Governments	Governments	NNPS
18637	1714	70	;	;	:
18637	1714	71	that	that	IN
18637	1714	72	the	the	DT
18637	1714	73	credit	credit	NN
18637	1714	74	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	1714	75	for	for	IN
18637	1714	76	State	state	NN
18637	1714	77	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	1714	78	bore	bear	VBD
18637	1714	79	a	a	DT
18637	1714	80	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	1714	81	relation	relation	NN
18637	1714	82	"	"	''
18637	1714	83	to	to	IN
18637	1714	84	the	the	DT
18637	1714	85	fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	1714	86	need	need	NN
18637	1714	87	subserved	subserve	VBN
18637	1714	88	by	by	IN
18637	1714	89	the	the	DT
18637	1714	90	tax	tax	NN
18637	1714	91	in	in	IN
18637	1714	92	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1714	93	normal	normal	JJ
18637	1714	94	operation,"[291	operation,"[291	NN
18637	1714	95	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1714	96	since	since	IN
18637	1714	97	State	state	NN
18637	1714	98	unemployment	unemployment	NN
18637	1714	99	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	1714	100	payments	payment	NNS
18637	1714	101	would	would	MD
18637	1714	102	relieve	relieve	VB
18637	1714	103	the	the	DT
18637	1714	104	burden	burden	NN
18637	1714	105	for	for	IN
18637	1714	106	direct	direct	JJ
18637	1714	107	relief	relief	NN
18637	1714	108	borne	bear	VBN
18637	1714	109	by	by	IN
18637	1714	110	the	the	DT
18637	1714	111	national	national	NNP
18637	1714	112	treasury	treasury	NNP
18637	1714	113	.	.	.
18637	1715	1	The	the	DT
18637	1715	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1715	3	reserved	reserve	VBD
18637	1715	4	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	1715	5	as	as	IN
18637	1715	6	to	to	IN
18637	1715	7	the	the	DT
18637	1715	8	validity	validity	NN
18637	1715	9	of	of	IN
18637	1715	10	a	a	DT
18637	1715	11	tax	tax	NN
18637	1715	12	"	"	''
18637	1715	13	if	if	IN
18637	1715	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1715	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	1715	16	laid	lay	VBN
18637	1715	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	1715	18	the	the	DT
18637	1715	19	condition	condition	NN
18637	1715	20	that	that	IN
18637	1715	21	a	a	DT
18637	1715	22	State	state	NN
18637	1715	23	may	may	MD
18637	1715	24	escape	escape	VB
18637	1715	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1715	26	operation	operation	NN
18637	1715	27	through	through	IN
18637	1715	28	the	the	DT
18637	1715	29	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	1715	30	of	of	IN
18637	1715	31	a	a	DT
18637	1715	32	statute	statute	NN
18637	1715	33	unrelated	unrelated	JJ
18637	1715	34	in	in	IN
18637	1715	35	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1715	36	matter	matter	NN
18637	1715	37	to	to	IN
18637	1715	38	activities	activity	NNS
18637	1715	39	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	1715	40	within	within	IN
18637	1715	41	the	the	DT
18637	1715	42	scope	scope	NN
18637	1715	43	of	of	IN
18637	1715	44	national	national	JJ
18637	1715	45	policy	policy	NN
18637	1715	46	and	and	CC
18637	1715	47	power	power	NN
18637	1715	48	.	.	.
18637	1716	1	"	"	``
18637	1716	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1716	3	292	292	CD
18637	1716	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1716	5	Earmarked	Earmarked	NNP
18637	1716	6	Funds	fund	NNS
18637	1716	7	The	the	DT
18637	1716	8	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	1716	9	of	of	IN
18637	1716	10	the	the	DT
18637	1716	11	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	1716	12	of	of	IN
18637	1716	13	a	a	DT
18637	1716	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	1716	15	to	to	IN
18637	1716	16	a	a	DT
18637	1716	17	specific	specific	JJ
18637	1716	18	use	use	NN
18637	1716	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	1716	20	not	not	RB
18637	1716	21	affect	affect	VB
18637	1716	22	the	the	DT
18637	1716	23	validity	validity	NN
18637	1716	24	of	of	IN
18637	1716	25	the	the	DT
18637	1716	26	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	1716	27	,	,	,
18637	1716	28	if	if	IN
18637	1716	29	the	the	DT
18637	1716	30	general	general	JJ
18637	1716	31	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1716	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	1716	33	advanced	advanced	JJ
18637	1716	34	and	and	CC
18637	1716	35	no	no	DT
18637	1716	36	other	other	JJ
18637	1716	37	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1716	38	provision	provision	NN
18637	1716	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	1716	40	violated	violate	VBN
18637	1716	41	.	.	.
18637	1717	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	1717	2	a	a	DT
18637	1717	3	processing	processing	NN
18637	1717	4	tax	tax	NN
18637	1717	5	on	on	IN
18637	1717	6	coconut	coconut	NN
18637	1717	7	oil	oil	NN
18637	1717	8	was	be	VBD
18637	1717	9	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	1717	10	despite	despite	IN
18637	1717	11	the	the	DT
18637	1717	12	fact	fact	NN
18637	1717	13	that	that	IN
18637	1717	14	the	the	DT
18637	1717	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	1717	16	collected	collect	VBN
18637	1717	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	1717	18	oil	oil	NN
18637	1717	19	of	of	IN
18637	1717	20	Philippine	philippine	JJ
18637	1717	21	production	production	NN
18637	1717	22	was	be	VBD
18637	1717	23	segregated	segregate	VBN
18637	1717	24	and	and	CC
18637	1717	25	paid	pay	VBN
18637	1717	26	into	into	IN
18637	1717	27	the	the	DT
18637	1717	28	Philippine	Philippine	NNP
18637	1717	29	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	1717	30	.	.	.
18637	1718	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1718	2	293	293	CD
18637	1718	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1718	4	In	in	IN
18637	1718	5	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	1718	6	_	_	NNP
18637	1718	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	1718	8	_	_	NNP
18637	1718	9	Davis,[294	Davis,[294	NNP
18637	1718	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1718	11	the	the	DT
18637	1718	12	excise	excise	NN
18637	1718	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	1718	14	on	on	IN
18637	1718	15	employers	employer	NNS
18637	1718	16	,	,	,
18637	1718	17	the	the	DT
18637	1718	18	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	1718	19	of	of	IN
18637	1718	20	which	which	WDT
18637	1718	21	were	be	VBD
18637	1718	22	not	not	RB
18637	1718	23	earmarked	earmark	VBN
18637	1718	24	in	in	IN
18637	1718	25	any	any	DT
18637	1718	26	way	way	NN
18637	1718	27	,	,	,
18637	1718	28	although	although	IN
18637	1718	29	intended	intend	VBN
18637	1718	30	to	to	TO
18637	1718	31	provide	provide	VB
18637	1718	32	funds	fund	NNS
18637	1718	33	for	for	IN
18637	1718	34	payments	payment	NNS
18637	1718	35	to	to	IN
18637	1718	36	retired	retire	VBN
18637	1718	37	workers	worker	NNS
18637	1718	38	,	,	,
18637	1718	39	was	be	VBD
18637	1718	40	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	1718	41	under	under	IN
18637	1718	42	the	the	DT
18637	1718	43	"	"	``
18637	1718	44	general	general	JJ
18637	1718	45	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1718	46	"	"	''
18637	1718	47	clause	clause	NN
18637	1718	48	,	,	,
18637	1718	49	the	the	DT
18637	1718	50	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	1718	51	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1718	52	being	be	VBG
18637	1718	53	found	find	VBN
18637	1718	54	to	to	TO
18637	1718	55	be	be	VB
18637	1718	56	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	1718	57	.	.	.
18637	1719	1	Conditional	Conditional	NNP
18637	1719	2	Grants	Grants	NNPS
18637	1719	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	1719	4	in	in	IN
18637	1719	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	1719	6	Aid	aid	NN
18637	1719	7	In	in	IN
18637	1719	8	the	the	DT
18637	1719	9	Steward	Steward	NNP
18637	1719	10	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	1719	11	Company	Company	NNP
18637	1719	12	case	case	NN
18637	1719	13	,	,	,
18637	1719	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1719	15	was	be	VBD
18637	1719	16	a	a	DT
18637	1719	17	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	1719	18	who	who	WP
18637	1719	19	complained	complain	VBD
18637	1719	20	of	of	IN
18637	1719	21	the	the	DT
18637	1719	22	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	1719	23	of	of	IN
18637	1719	24	the	the	DT
18637	1719	25	State	State	NNP
18637	1719	26	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	1719	27	and	and	CC
18637	1719	28	the	the	DT
18637	1719	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1719	30	put	put	VBD
18637	1719	31	great	great	JJ
18637	1719	32	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	1719	33	on	on	IN
18637	1719	34	the	the	DT
18637	1719	35	fact	fact	NN
18637	1719	36	that	that	IN
18637	1719	37	the	the	DT
18637	1719	38	State	State	NNP
18637	1719	39	was	be	VBD
18637	1719	40	a	a	DT
18637	1719	41	willing	willing	JJ
18637	1719	42	partner	partner	NN
18637	1719	43	in	in	IN
18637	1719	44	the	the	DT
18637	1719	45	plan	plan	NN
18637	1719	46	of	of	IN
18637	1719	47	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	1719	48	embodied	embody	VBN
18637	1719	49	in	in	IN
18637	1719	50	the	the	DT
18637	1719	51	Social	Social	NNP
18637	1719	52	Security	Security	NNP
18637	1719	53	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1719	54	.	.	.
18637	1720	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1720	2	295	295	CD
18637	1720	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1720	4	A	a	DT
18637	1720	5	decade	decade	NN
18637	1720	6	later	later	RBR
18637	1720	7	the	the	DT
18637	1720	8	right	right	NN
18637	1720	9	of	of	IN
18637	1720	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1720	11	to	to	TO
18637	1720	12	impose	impose	VB
18637	1720	13	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	1720	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	1720	15	grants	grant	NNS
18637	1720	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	1720	17	in	in	IN
18637	1720	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	1720	19	aid	aid	NN
18637	1720	20	over	over	IN
18637	1720	21	the	the	DT
18637	1720	22	objection	objection	NN
18637	1720	23	of	of	IN
18637	1720	24	a	a	DT
18637	1720	25	State	State	NNP
18637	1720	26	was	be	VBD
18637	1720	27	squarely	squarely	RB
18637	1720	28	presented	present	VBN
18637	1720	29	in	in	IN
18637	1720	30	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	1720	31	_	_	NNP
18637	1720	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	1720	33	_	_	NNP
18637	1720	34	United	United	NNP
18637	1720	35	States	States	NNP
18637	1720	36	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	1720	37	Service	Service	NNP
18637	1720	38	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1720	39	.	.	.
18637	1721	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1721	2	296	296	CD
18637	1721	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1721	4	The	the	DT
18637	1721	5	State	State	NNP
18637	1721	6	objected	object	VBD
18637	1721	7	to	to	IN
18637	1721	8	the	the	DT
18637	1721	9	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	1721	10	of	of	IN
18637	1721	11	a	a	DT
18637	1721	12	provision	provision	NN
18637	1721	13	of	of	IN
18637	1721	14	the	the	DT
18637	1721	15	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	1721	16	Act,[297	Act,[297	NNP
18637	1721	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1721	18	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	1721	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1721	20	right	right	NN
18637	1721	21	to	to	TO
18637	1721	22	receive	receive	VB
18637	1721	23	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1721	24	highway	highway	NN
18637	1721	25	funds	fund	NNS
18637	1721	26	would	would	MD
18637	1721	27	be	be	VB
18637	1721	28	diminished	diminish	VBN
18637	1721	29	in	in	IN
18637	1721	30	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	1721	31	of	of	IN
18637	1721	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1721	33	failure	failure	NN
18637	1721	34	to	to	TO
18637	1721	35	remove	remove	VB
18637	1721	36	from	from	IN
18637	1721	37	office	office	NN
18637	1721	38	a	a	DT
18637	1721	39	member	member	NN
18637	1721	40	of	of	IN
18637	1721	41	the	the	DT
18637	1721	42	State	State	NNP
18637	1721	43	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	1721	44	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1721	45	found	find	VBD
18637	1721	46	to	to	TO
18637	1721	47	have	have	VB
18637	1721	48	taken	take	VBN
18637	1721	49	an	an	DT
18637	1721	50	active	active	JJ
18637	1721	51	part	part	NN
18637	1721	52	in	in	IN
18637	1721	53	party	party	NN
18637	1721	54	politics	politic	NNS
18637	1721	55	while	while	IN
18637	1721	56	in	in	IN
18637	1721	57	office	office	NN
18637	1721	58	.	.	.
18637	1722	1	Although	although	IN
18637	1722	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1722	3	found	find	VBD
18637	1722	4	that	that	IN
18637	1722	5	the	the	DT
18637	1722	6	State	State	NNP
18637	1722	7	had	have	VBD
18637	1722	8	created	create	VBN
18637	1722	9	a	a	DT
18637	1722	10	legal	legal	JJ
18637	1722	11	right	right	NN
18637	1722	12	which	which	WDT
18637	1722	13	entitled	entitle	VBD
18637	1722	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1722	15	to	to	IN
18637	1722	16	an	an	DT
18637	1722	17	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	1722	18	of	of	IN
18637	1722	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1722	20	objection	objection	NN
18637	1722	21	,	,	,
18637	1722	22	the	the	DT
18637	1722	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1722	24	denied	deny	VBD
18637	1722	25	the	the	DT
18637	1722	26	relief	relief	NN
18637	1722	27	sought	seek	VBN
18637	1722	28	on	on	IN
18637	1722	29	the	the	DT
18637	1722	30	ground	ground	NN
18637	1722	31	that	that	IN
18637	1722	32	,	,	,
18637	1722	33	"	"	``
18637	1722	34	While	while	IN
18637	1722	35	the	the	DT
18637	1722	36	United	United	NNP
18637	1722	37	States	States	NNP
18637	1722	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	1722	39	not	not	RB
18637	1722	40	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	1722	41	with	with	IN
18637	1722	42	,	,	,
18637	1722	43	and	and	CC
18637	1722	44	has	have	VBZ
18637	1722	45	no	no	DT
18637	1722	46	power	power	NN
18637	1722	47	to	to	TO
18637	1722	48	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1722	49	local	local	JJ
18637	1722	50	political	political	JJ
18637	1722	51	activities	activity	NNS
18637	1722	52	as	as	IN
18637	1722	53	such	such	JJ
18637	1722	54	of	of	IN
18637	1722	55	State	State	NNP
18637	1722	56	officials	official	NNS
18637	1722	57	,	,	,
18637	1722	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1722	59	does	do	VBZ
18637	1722	60	have	have	VB
18637	1722	61	power	power	NN
18637	1722	62	to	to	TO
18637	1722	63	fix	fix	VB
18637	1722	64	the	the	DT
18637	1722	65	terms	term	NNS
18637	1722	66	upon	upon	IN
18637	1722	67	which	which	WDT
18637	1722	68	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1722	69	money	money	NN
18637	1722	70	allotments	allotment	NNS
18637	1722	71	to	to	IN
18637	1722	72	State	state	NN
18637	1722	73	shall	shall	MD
18637	1722	74	be	be	VB
18637	1722	75	disbursed	disburse	VBN
18637	1722	76	.	.	.
18637	1723	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1723	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1723	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1723	4	The	the	DT
18637	1723	5	end	end	NN
18637	1723	6	sought	seek	VBN
18637	1723	7	by	by	IN
18637	1723	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1723	9	through	through	IN
18637	1723	10	the	the	DT
18637	1723	11	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	1723	12	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1723	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	1723	14	better	well	JJR
18637	1723	15	public	public	JJ
18637	1723	16	service	service	NN
18637	1723	17	by	by	IN
18637	1723	18	requiring	require	VBG
18637	1723	19	those	those	DT
18637	1723	20	who	who	WP
18637	1723	21	administer	administer	VBP
18637	1723	22	funds	fund	NNS
18637	1723	23	for	for	IN
18637	1723	24	national	national	JJ
18637	1723	25	needs	need	NNS
18637	1723	26	to	to	TO
18637	1723	27	abstain	abstain	VB
18637	1723	28	from	from	IN
18637	1723	29	active	active	JJ
18637	1723	30	political	political	JJ
18637	1723	31	partisanship	partisanship	NN
18637	1723	32	.	.	.
18637	1724	1	So	so	RB
18637	1724	2	even	even	RB
18637	1724	3	though	though	IN
18637	1724	4	the	the	DT
18637	1724	5	action	action	NN
18637	1724	6	taken	take	VBN
18637	1724	7	by	by	IN
18637	1724	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1724	9	does	do	VBZ
18637	1724	10	have	have	VB
18637	1724	11	effect	effect	NN
18637	1724	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	1724	13	certain	certain	JJ
18637	1724	14	activities	activity	NNS
18637	1724	15	within	within	IN
18637	1724	16	the	the	DT
18637	1724	17	State	State	NNP
18637	1724	18	,	,	,
18637	1724	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1724	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	1724	21	never	never	RB
18637	1724	22	been	be	VBN
18637	1724	23	thought	think	VBN
18637	1724	24	that	that	IN
18637	1724	25	such	such	JJ
18637	1724	26	effect	effect	NN
18637	1724	27	made	make	VBD
18637	1724	28	the	the	DT
18637	1724	29	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1724	30	act	act	NNP
18637	1724	31	invalid	invalid	NNP
18637	1724	32	.	.	.
18637	1725	1	"	"	``
18637	1725	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1725	3	298	298	CD
18637	1725	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1725	5	"	"	``
18637	1725	6	Debts	debt	NNS
18637	1725	7	of	of	IN
18637	1725	8	the	the	DT
18637	1725	9	United	United	NNP
18637	1725	10	States	States	NNP
18637	1725	11	"	"	``
18637	1725	12	The	the	DT
18637	1725	13	power	power	NN
18637	1725	14	to	to	TO
18637	1725	15	pay	pay	VB
18637	1725	16	the	the	DT
18637	1725	17	debts	debt	NNS
18637	1725	18	of	of	IN
18637	1725	19	the	the	DT
18637	1725	20	United	United	NNP
18637	1725	21	States	States	NNP
18637	1725	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	1725	23	broad	broad	JJ
18637	1725	24	enough	enough	RB
18637	1725	25	to	to	TO
18637	1725	26	include	include	VB
18637	1725	27	claims	claim	NNS
18637	1725	28	of	of	IN
18637	1725	29	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	1725	30	arising	arise	VBG
18637	1725	31	on	on	IN
18637	1725	32	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	1725	33	of	of	IN
18637	1725	34	right	right	NN
18637	1725	35	and	and	CC
18637	1725	36	justice	justice	NN
18637	1725	37	.	.	.
18637	1726	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1726	2	299	299	CD
18637	1726	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1726	4	The	the	DT
18637	1726	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1726	6	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1726	7	an	an	DT
18637	1726	8	act	act	NN
18637	1726	9	of	of	IN
18637	1726	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1726	11	which	which	WDT
18637	1726	12	set	set	VBD
18637	1726	13	apart	apart	RB
18637	1726	14	for	for	IN
18637	1726	15	the	the	DT
18637	1726	16	use	use	NN
18637	1726	17	of	of	IN
18637	1726	18	the	the	DT
18637	1726	19	Philippine	Philippine	NNP
18637	1726	20	Islands	Islands	NNPS
18637	1726	21	,	,	,
18637	1726	22	the	the	DT
18637	1726	23	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	1726	24	from	from	IN
18637	1726	25	a	a	DT
18637	1726	26	processing	processing	NN
18637	1726	27	tax	tax	NN
18637	1726	28	on	on	IN
18637	1726	29	coconut	coconut	NN
18637	1726	30	oil	oil	NN
18637	1726	31	of	of	IN
18637	1726	32	Philippine	philippine	JJ
18637	1726	33	production	production	NN
18637	1726	34	,	,	,
18637	1726	35	as	as	IN
18637	1726	36	being	be	VBG
18637	1726	37	in	in	IN
18637	1726	38	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	1726	39	of	of	IN
18637	1726	40	a	a	DT
18637	1726	41	moral	moral	JJ
18637	1726	42	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	1726	43	to	to	TO
18637	1726	44	protect	protect	VB
18637	1726	45	and	and	CC
18637	1726	46	promote	promote	VB
18637	1726	47	the	the	DT
18637	1726	48	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1726	49	of	of	IN
18637	1726	50	the	the	DT
18637	1726	51	people	people	NNS
18637	1726	52	of	of	IN
18637	1726	53	the	the	DT
18637	1726	54	Islands	Islands	NNPS
18637	1726	55	.	.	.
18637	1727	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1727	2	300	300	CD
18637	1727	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1727	4	Curiously	curiously	RB
18637	1727	5	enough	enough	RB
18637	1727	6	,	,	,
18637	1727	7	this	this	DT
18637	1727	8	power	power	NN
18637	1727	9	was	be	VBD
18637	1727	10	first	first	RB
18637	1727	11	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	1727	12	to	to	TO
18637	1727	13	assist	assist	VB
18637	1727	14	the	the	DT
18637	1727	15	United	United	NNP
18637	1727	16	States	States	NNP
18637	1727	17	to	to	TO
18637	1727	18	collect	collect	VB
18637	1727	19	a	a	DT
18637	1727	20	debt	debt	NN
18637	1727	21	due	due	JJ
18637	1727	22	to	to	IN
18637	1727	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1727	24	.	.	.
18637	1728	1	In	in	IN
18637	1728	2	United	United	NNP
18637	1728	3	States	States	NNP
18637	1728	4	_	_	NNP
18637	1728	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	1728	6	_	_	NNP
18637	1728	7	Fisher[301	Fisher[301	NNP
18637	1728	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1728	9	the	the	DT
18637	1728	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1728	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1728	12	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1728	13	a	a	DT
18637	1728	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	1728	15	which	which	WDT
18637	1728	16	gave	give	VBD
18637	1728	17	the	the	DT
18637	1728	18	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1728	19	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1728	20	priority	priority	NN
18637	1728	21	in	in	IN
18637	1728	22	the	the	DT
18637	1728	23	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	1728	24	of	of	IN
18637	1728	25	the	the	DT
18637	1728	26	estates	estate	NNS
18637	1728	27	of	of	IN
18637	1728	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1728	29	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
18637	1728	30	debtors	debtor	NNS
18637	1728	31	.	.	.
18637	1729	1	The	the	DT
18637	1729	2	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	1729	3	in	in	IN
18637	1729	4	that	that	DT
18637	1729	5	case	case	NN
18637	1729	6	was	be	VBD
18637	1729	7	the	the	DT
18637	1729	8	endorser	endorser	NN
18637	1729	9	of	of	IN
18637	1729	10	a	a	DT
18637	1729	11	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1729	12	bill	bill	NN
18637	1729	13	of	of	IN
18637	1729	14	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	1729	15	which	which	WDT
18637	1729	16	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	1729	17	had	have	VBD
18637	1729	18	been	be	VBN
18637	1729	19	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	1729	20	by	by	IN
18637	1729	21	the	the	DT
18637	1729	22	United	United	NNP
18637	1729	23	States	States	NNP
18637	1729	24	.	.	.
18637	1730	1	Invoking	invoke	VBG
18637	1730	2	the	the	DT
18637	1730	3	"	"	``
18637	1730	4	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1730	5	and	and	CC
18637	1730	6	proper	proper	JJ
18637	1730	7	"	"	''
18637	1730	8	clause	clause	NN
18637	1730	9	,	,	,
18637	1730	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1730	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1730	12	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1730	13	deduced	deduce	VBD
18637	1730	14	the	the	DT
18637	1730	15	power	power	NN
18637	1730	16	to	to	TO
18637	1730	17	collect	collect	VB
18637	1730	18	a	a	DT
18637	1730	19	debt	debt	NN
18637	1730	20	from	from	IN
18637	1730	21	the	the	DT
18637	1730	22	power	power	NN
18637	1730	23	to	to	TO
18637	1730	24	pay	pay	VB
18637	1730	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1730	26	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	1730	27	by	by	IN
18637	1730	28	the	the	DT
18637	1730	29	following	following	JJ
18637	1730	30	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	1730	31	:	:	:
18637	1730	32	"	"	``
18637	1730	33	The	the	DT
18637	1730	34	government	government	NN
18637	1730	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	1730	36	to	to	TO
18637	1730	37	pay	pay	VB
18637	1730	38	the	the	DT
18637	1730	39	debt	debt	NN
18637	1730	40	of	of	IN
18637	1730	41	the	the	DT
18637	1730	42	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1730	43	,	,	,
18637	1730	44	and	and	CC
18637	1730	45	must	must	MD
18637	1730	46	be	be	VB
18637	1730	47	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	1730	48	to	to	TO
18637	1730	49	use	use	VB
18637	1730	50	the	the	DT
18637	1730	51	means	mean	NNS
18637	1730	52	which	which	WDT
18637	1730	53	appear	appear	VBP
18637	1730	54	to	to	IN
18637	1730	55	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1730	56	most	most	RBS
18637	1730	57	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	1730	58	to	to	TO
18637	1730	59	effect	effect	VB
18637	1730	60	that	that	DT
18637	1730	61	object	object	NN
18637	1730	62	.	.	.
18637	1731	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1731	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	1731	3	,	,	,
18637	1731	4	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	1731	5	,	,	,
18637	1731	6	a	a	DT
18637	1731	7	right	right	NN
18637	1731	8	to	to	TO
18637	1731	9	make	make	VB
18637	1731	10	remittances	remittance	NNS
18637	1731	11	by	by	IN
18637	1731	12	bills	bill	NNS
18637	1731	13	or	or	CC
18637	1731	14	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	1731	15	,	,	,
18637	1731	16	and	and	CC
18637	1731	17	to	to	TO
18637	1731	18	take	take	VB
18637	1731	19	those	those	DT
18637	1731	20	precautions	precaution	NNS
18637	1731	21	which	which	WDT
18637	1731	22	will	will	MD
18637	1731	23	render	render	VB
18637	1731	24	the	the	DT
18637	1731	25	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	1731	26	safe	safe	JJ
18637	1731	27	.	.	.
18637	1732	1	"	"	``
18637	1732	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1732	3	302	302	CD
18637	1732	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1732	5	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1732	6	2	2	CD
18637	1732	7	.	.	.
18637	1733	1	_	_	NNP
18637	1733	2	The	the	DT
18637	1733	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1733	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	1733	5	have	have	VB
18637	1733	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1733	7	_	_	NNP
18637	1733	8	*	*	NFP
18637	1733	9	*	*	NFP
18637	1733	10	*	*	NFP
18637	1733	11	To	to	TO
18637	1733	12	borrow	borrow	VB
18637	1733	13	Money	money	NN
18637	1733	14	on	on	IN
18637	1733	15	the	the	DT
18637	1733	16	credit	credit	NN
18637	1733	17	of	of	IN
18637	1733	18	the	the	DT
18637	1733	19	United	United	NNP
18637	1733	20	States	States	NNP
18637	1733	21	.	.	.
18637	1734	1	The	the	DT
18637	1734	2	Borrowing	Borrowing	NNP
18637	1734	3	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1734	4	The	the	DT
18637	1734	5	original	original	JJ
18637	1734	6	draft	draft	NN
18637	1734	7	of	of	IN
18637	1734	8	the	the	DT
18637	1734	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1734	10	reported	report	VBD
18637	1734	11	to	to	IN
18637	1734	12	the	the	DT
18637	1734	13	convention	convention	NN
18637	1734	14	by	by	IN
18637	1734	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1734	16	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	1734	17	of	of	IN
18637	1734	18	Detail	Detail	NNP
18637	1734	19	empowered	empower	VBD
18637	1734	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1734	21	"	"	``
18637	1734	22	To	to	TO
18637	1734	23	borrow	borrow	VB
18637	1734	24	money	money	NN
18637	1734	25	and	and	CC
18637	1734	26	emit	emit	VB
18637	1734	27	bills	bill	NNS
18637	1734	28	on	on	IN
18637	1734	29	the	the	DT
18637	1734	30	credit	credit	NN
18637	1734	31	of	of	IN
18637	1734	32	the	the	DT
18637	1734	33	United	United	NNP
18637	1734	34	States	States	NNP
18637	1734	35	.	.	.
18637	1735	1	"	"	``
18637	1735	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1735	3	303	303	CD
18637	1735	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1735	5	When	when	WRB
18637	1735	6	this	this	DT
18637	1735	7	section	section	NN
18637	1735	8	was	be	VBD
18637	1735	9	reached	reach	VBN
18637	1735	10	in	in	IN
18637	1735	11	the	the	DT
18637	1735	12	debates	debate	NNS
18637	1735	13	,	,	,
18637	1735	14	Gouverneur	Gouverneur	NNP
18637	1735	15	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	1735	16	moved	move	VBD
18637	1735	17	to	to	TO
18637	1735	18	strike	strike	VB
18637	1735	19	out	out	RP
18637	1735	20	the	the	DT
18637	1735	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	1735	22	"	"	''
18637	1735	23	and	and	CC
18637	1735	24	emit	emit	VB
18637	1735	25	bills	bill	NNS
18637	1735	26	on	on	IN
18637	1735	27	the	the	DT
18637	1735	28	credit	credit	NN
18637	1735	29	of	of	IN
18637	1735	30	the	the	DT
18637	1735	31	United	United	NNP
18637	1735	32	States	States	NNP
18637	1735	33	.	.	.
18637	1735	34	"	"	''
18637	1736	1	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	1736	2	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	1736	3	that	that	IN
18637	1736	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1736	5	might	may	MD
18637	1736	6	be	be	VB
18637	1736	7	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	1736	8	"	"	''
18637	1736	9	to	to	TO
18637	1736	10	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	1736	11	the	the	DT
18637	1736	12	making	make	VBG
18637	1736	13	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1736	14	a	a	DT
18637	1736	15	tender	tender	NN
18637	1736	16	.	.	.
18637	1736	17	"	"	''
18637	1737	1	After	after	IN
18637	1737	2	a	a	DT
18637	1737	3	spirited	spirited	JJ
18637	1737	4	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	1737	5	of	of	IN
18637	1737	6	views	view	NNS
18637	1737	7	on	on	IN
18637	1737	8	the	the	DT
18637	1737	9	subject	subject	NN
18637	1737	10	of	of	IN
18637	1737	11	paper	paper	NN
18637	1737	12	money	money	NN
18637	1737	13	the	the	DT
18637	1737	14	convention	convention	NN
18637	1737	15	voted	vote	VBD
18637	1737	16	,	,	,
18637	1737	17	nine	nine	CD
18637	1737	18	States	state	NNS
18637	1737	19	to	to	IN
18637	1737	20	two	two	CD
18637	1737	21	,	,	,
18637	1737	22	to	to	TO
18637	1737	23	delete	delete	VB
18637	1737	24	the	the	DT
18637	1737	25	words	word	NNS
18637	1737	26	"	"	''
18637	1737	27	and	and	CC
18637	1737	28	emit	emit	VB
18637	1737	29	bills	bill	NNS
18637	1737	30	.	.	.
18637	1738	1	"	"	``
18637	1738	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1738	3	304	304	CD
18637	1738	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1738	5	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	1738	6	,	,	,
18637	1738	7	in	in	IN
18637	1738	8	1870	1870	CD
18637	1738	9	,	,	,
18637	1738	10	the	the	DT
18637	1738	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1738	12	relied	rely	VBD
18637	1738	13	in	in	IN
18637	1738	14	part	part	NN
18637	1738	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	1738	16	this	this	DT
18637	1738	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	1738	18	in	in	IN
18637	1738	19	holding	hold	VBG
18637	1738	20	that	that	IN
18637	1738	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1738	22	had	have	VBD
18637	1738	23	authority	authority	NN
18637	1738	24	to	to	TO
18637	1738	25	issue	issue	VB
18637	1738	26	treasury	treasury	NNP
18637	1738	27	notes	note	NNS
18637	1738	28	and	and	CC
18637	1738	29	to	to	TO
18637	1738	30	make	make	VB
18637	1738	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1738	32	legal	legal	JJ
18637	1738	33	tender	tender	NN
18637	1738	34	in	in	IN
18637	1738	35	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
18637	1738	36	of	of	IN
18637	1738	37	antecedent	antecedent	NN
18637	1738	38	debts	debt	NNS
18637	1738	39	.	.	.
18637	1739	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1739	2	305	305	CD
18637	1739	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1739	4	When	when	WRB
18637	1739	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1739	6	borrows	borrow	VBZ
18637	1739	7	money	money	NN
18637	1739	8	"	"	''
18637	1739	9	on	on	IN
18637	1739	10	the	the	DT
18637	1739	11	credit	credit	NN
18637	1739	12	of	of	IN
18637	1739	13	the	the	DT
18637	1739	14	United	United	NNP
18637	1739	15	States	States	NNP
18637	1739	16	"	"	''
18637	1739	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1739	18	creates	create	VBZ
18637	1739	19	a	a	DT
18637	1739	20	binding	bind	VBG
18637	1739	21	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	1739	22	to	to	TO
18637	1739	23	pay	pay	VB
18637	1739	24	the	the	DT
18637	1739	25	debt	debt	NN
18637	1739	26	as	as	IN
18637	1739	27	stipulated	stipulate	VBN
18637	1739	28	and	and	CC
18637	1739	29	can	can	MD
18637	1739	30	not	not	RB
18637	1739	31	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	1739	32	vary	vary	VB
18637	1739	33	the	the	DT
18637	1739	34	terms	term	NNS
18637	1739	35	of	of	IN
18637	1739	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1739	37	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	1739	38	.	.	.
18637	1740	1	A	a	DT
18637	1740	2	law	law	NN
18637	1740	3	purporting	purporting	NN
18637	1740	4	to	to	TO
18637	1740	5	abrogate	abrogate	VB
18637	1740	6	a	a	DT
18637	1740	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	1740	8	in	in	IN
18637	1740	9	government	government	NN
18637	1740	10	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	1740	11	calling	call	VBG
18637	1740	12	for	for	IN
18637	1740	13	payment	payment	NN
18637	1740	14	in	in	IN
18637	1740	15	gold	gold	NN
18637	1740	16	coin	coin	NN
18637	1740	17	was	be	VBD
18637	1740	18	held	hold	VBN
18637	1740	19	to	to	TO
18637	1740	20	contravene	contravene	VB
18637	1740	21	this	this	DT
18637	1740	22	clause	clause	NN
18637	1740	23	,	,	,
18637	1740	24	although	although	IN
18637	1740	25	the	the	DT
18637	1740	26	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	1740	27	was	be	VBD
18637	1740	28	denied	deny	VBN
18637	1740	29	a	a	DT
18637	1740	30	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	1740	31	in	in	IN
18637	1740	32	the	the	DT
18637	1740	33	absence	absence	NN
18637	1740	34	of	of	IN
18637	1740	35	a	a	DT
18637	1740	36	showing	showing	NN
18637	1740	37	of	of	IN
18637	1740	38	actual	actual	JJ
18637	1740	39	damage	damage	NN
18637	1740	40	.	.	.
18637	1741	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1741	2	306	306	CD
18637	1741	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1741	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	1741	5	3	3	CD
18637	1741	6	.	.	.
18637	1742	1	_	_	NNP
18637	1742	2	The	the	DT
18637	1742	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1742	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	1742	5	have	have	VB
18637	1742	6	power	power	NN
18637	1742	7	_	_	NNP
18637	1742	8	*	*	NFP
18637	1742	9	*	*	NFP
18637	1742	10	*	*	NFP
18637	1742	11	To	to	TO
18637	1742	12	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1742	13	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1742	14	with	with	IN
18637	1742	15	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1742	16	Nations	Nations	NNPS
18637	1742	17	,	,	,
18637	1742	18	and	and	CC
18637	1742	19	among	among	IN
18637	1742	20	the	the	DT
18637	1742	21	several	several	JJ
18637	1742	22	States	States	NNPS
18637	1742	23	,	,	,
18637	1742	24	and	and	CC
18637	1742	25	with	with	IN
18637	1742	26	the	the	DT
18637	1742	27	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	1742	28	Tribes	Tribes	NNPS
18637	1742	29	.	.	.
18637	1743	1	Purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1743	2	of	of	IN
18637	1743	3	the	the	DT
18637	1743	4	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	1743	5	This	this	DT
18637	1743	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	1743	7	serves	serve	VBZ
18637	1743	8	a	a	DT
18637	1743	9	two	two	CD
18637	1743	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	1743	11	fold	fold	JJ
18637	1743	12	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1743	13	:	:	:
18637	1743	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1743	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	1743	16	the	the	DT
18637	1743	17	direct	direct	JJ
18637	1743	18	source	source	NN
18637	1743	19	of	of	IN
18637	1743	20	the	the	DT
18637	1743	21	most	most	RBS
18637	1743	22	important	important	JJ
18637	1743	23	powers	power	NNS
18637	1743	24	which	which	WDT
18637	1743	25	the	the	DT
18637	1743	26	National	National	NNP
18637	1743	27	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1743	28	exercises	exercise	VBZ
18637	1743	29	in	in	IN
18637	1743	30	time	time	NN
18637	1743	31	of	of	IN
18637	1743	32	peace	peace	NN
18637	1743	33	:	:	:
18637	1743	34	and	and	CC
18637	1743	35	,	,	,
18637	1743	36	except	except	IN
18637	1743	37	for	for	IN
18637	1743	38	the	the	DT
18637	1743	39	due	due	JJ
18637	1743	40	process	process	NN
18637	1743	41	of	of	IN
18637	1743	42	law	law	NN
18637	1743	43	clause	clause	NN
18637	1743	44	of	of	IN
18637	1743	45	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1743	46	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	1743	47	,	,	,
18637	1743	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1743	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	1743	50	the	the	DT
18637	1743	51	most	most	RBS
18637	1743	52	important	important	JJ
18637	1743	53	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	1743	54	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	1743	55	by	by	IN
18637	1743	56	the	the	DT
18637	1743	57	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1743	58	on	on	IN
18637	1743	59	the	the	DT
18637	1743	60	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1743	61	of	of	IN
18637	1743	62	State	State	NNP
18637	1743	63	power	power	NN
18637	1743	64	.	.	.
18637	1744	1	The	the	DT
18637	1744	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	1744	3	,	,	,
18637	1744	4	or	or	CC
18637	1744	5	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	1744	6	,	,	,
18637	1744	7	operation	operation	NN
18637	1744	8	of	of	IN
18637	1744	9	the	the	DT
18637	1744	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	1744	11	was	be	VBD
18637	1744	12	long	long	RB
18637	1744	13	the	the	DT
18637	1744	14	more	more	RBR
18637	1744	15	important	important	JJ
18637	1744	16	one	one	NN
18637	1744	17	from	from	IN
18637	1744	18	the	the	DT
18637	1744	19	point	point	NN
18637	1744	20	of	of	IN
18637	1744	21	view	view	NN
18637	1744	22	of	of	IN
18637	1744	23	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	1744	24	Law	Law	NNP
18637	1744	25	.	.	.
18637	1745	1	Of	of	IN
18637	1745	2	the	the	DT
18637	1745	3	approximately	approximately	RB
18637	1745	4	1400	1400	CD
18637	1745	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	1745	6	which	which	WDT
18637	1745	7	reached	reach	VBD
18637	1745	8	the	the	DT
18637	1745	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1745	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1745	11	under	under	IN
18637	1745	12	the	the	DT
18637	1745	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	1745	14	prior	prior	RB
18637	1745	15	to	to	IN
18637	1745	16	1900	1900	CD
18637	1745	17	,	,	,
18637	1745	18	the	the	DT
18637	1745	19	overwhelming	overwhelming	JJ
18637	1745	20	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	1745	21	stemmed	stem	VBD
18637	1745	22	from	from	IN
18637	1745	23	State	State	NNP
18637	1745	24	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1745	25	.	.	.
18637	1746	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1746	2	307	307	CD
18637	1746	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1746	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1746	5	resulted	result	VBD
18637	1746	6	that	that	IN
18637	1746	7	,	,	,
18637	1746	8	with	with	IN
18637	1746	9	an	an	DT
18637	1746	10	important	important	JJ
18637	1746	11	exception	exception	NN
18637	1746	12	to	to	TO
18637	1746	13	be	be	VB
18637	1746	14	noted	note	VBN
18637	1746	15	in	in	IN
18637	1746	16	a	a	DT
18637	1746	17	moment	moment	NN
18637	1746	18	,	,	,
18637	1746	19	the	the	DT
18637	1746	20	guiding	guide	VBG
18637	1746	21	lines	line	NNS
18637	1746	22	in	in	IN
18637	1746	23	construction	construction	NN
18637	1746	24	of	of	IN
18637	1746	25	the	the	DT
18637	1746	26	clause	clause	NN
18637	1746	27	were	be	VBD
18637	1746	28	initially	initially	RB
18637	1746	29	laid	lay	VBN
18637	1746	30	down	down	RP
18637	1746	31	from	from	IN
18637	1746	32	the	the	DT
18637	1746	33	point	point	NN
18637	1746	34	of	of	IN
18637	1746	35	view	view	NN
18637	1746	36	of	of	IN
18637	1746	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1746	38	operation	operation	NN
18637	1746	39	as	as	IN
18637	1746	40	a	a	DT
18637	1746	41	curb	curb	NN
18637	1746	42	on	on	IN
18637	1746	43	State	State	NNP
18637	1746	44	power	power	NN
18637	1746	45	,	,	,
18637	1746	46	rather	rather	RB
18637	1746	47	than	than	IN
18637	1746	48	of	of	IN
18637	1746	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1746	50	operation	operation	NN
18637	1746	51	as	as	IN
18637	1746	52	a	a	DT
18637	1746	53	source	source	NN
18637	1746	54	of	of	IN
18637	1746	55	national	national	JJ
18637	1746	56	power	power	NN
18637	1746	57	;	;	:
18637	1746	58	and	and	CC
18637	1746	59	the	the	DT
18637	1746	60	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	1746	61	of	of	IN
18637	1746	62	this	this	DT
18637	1746	63	was	be	VBD
18637	1746	64	that	that	IN
18637	1746	65	the	the	DT
18637	1746	66	word	word	NN
18637	1746	67	"	"	``
18637	1746	68	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1746	69	,	,	,
18637	1746	70	"	"	''
18637	1746	71	as	as	IN
18637	1746	72	designating	designate	VBG
18637	1746	73	the	the	DT
18637	1746	74	thing	thing	NN
18637	1746	75	to	to	TO
18637	1746	76	be	be	VB
18637	1746	77	protected	protect	VBN
18637	1746	78	against	against	IN
18637	1746	79	State	state	NN
18637	1746	80	interference	interference	NN
18637	1746	81	,	,	,
18637	1746	82	came	come	VBD
18637	1746	83	to	to	TO
18637	1746	84	dominate	dominate	VB
18637	1746	85	the	the	DT
18637	1746	86	clause	clause	NN
18637	1746	87	,	,	,
18637	1746	88	while	while	IN
18637	1746	89	the	the	DT
18637	1746	90	word	word	NN
18637	1746	91	"	"	``
18637	1746	92	regulate	regulate	NN
18637	1746	93	"	"	''
18637	1746	94	remained	remain	VBD
18637	1746	95	in	in	IN
18637	1746	96	the	the	DT
18637	1746	97	background	background	NN
18637	1746	98	.	.	.
18637	1747	1	Definition	definition	NN
18637	1747	2	of	of	IN
18637	1747	3	Terms	term	NNS
18637	1747	4	:	:	:
18637	1747	5	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	1747	6	_	_	NNP
18637	1747	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	1747	8	_	_	NNP
18637	1747	9	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	1747	10	"	"	``
18637	1747	11	COMMERCE	COMMERCE	NNP
18637	1747	12	"	"	''
18637	1747	13	The	the	DT
18637	1747	14	etymology	etymology	NN
18637	1747	15	of	of	IN
18637	1747	16	the	the	DT
18637	1747	17	word	word	NN
18637	1747	18	,	,	,
18637	1747	19	"	"	''
18637	1747	20	cum	cum	NNP
18637	1747	21	merce	merce	NNP
18637	1747	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1747	23	with	with	IN
18637	1747	24	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	1747	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1747	26	"	"	``
18637	1747	27	carries	carry	VBZ
18637	1747	28	the	the	DT
18637	1747	29	primary	primary	JJ
18637	1747	30	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	1747	31	of	of	IN
18637	1747	32	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	1747	33	--	--	:
18637	1747	34	i.e	i.e	NNP
18637	1747	35	.	.	NNP
18637	1747	36	,	,	,
18637	1747	37	"	"	``
18637	1747	38	to	to	TO
18637	1747	39	buy	buy	VB
18637	1747	40	and	and	CC
18637	1747	41	sell	sell	VB
18637	1747	42	goods	good	NNS
18637	1747	43	;	;	,
18637	1747	44	to	to	TO
18637	1747	45	trade	trade	VB
18637	1747	46	"	"	''
18637	1747	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1747	48	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	1747	49	's	's	POS
18637	1747	50	International	International	NNP
18637	1747	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1747	52	.	.	.
18637	1748	1	This	this	DT
18637	1748	2	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	1748	3	conception	conception	NN
18637	1748	4	was	be	VBD
18637	1748	5	replaced	replace	VBN
18637	1748	6	in	in	IN
18637	1748	7	the	the	DT
18637	1748	8	great	great	JJ
18637	1748	9	leading	leading	JJ
18637	1748	10	case	case	NN
18637	1748	11	of	of	IN
18637	1748	12	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	1748	13	_	_	NNP
18637	1748	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	1748	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1748	16	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	1748	17	,	,	,
18637	1748	18	9	9	CD
18637	1748	19	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	1748	20	.	.	.
18637	1749	1	1	1	CD
18637	1749	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1749	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	1749	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1749	5	,	,	,
18637	1749	6	by	by	IN
18637	1749	7	a	a	DT
18637	1749	8	much	much	RB
18637	1749	9	broader	broad	JJR
18637	1749	10	one	one	CD
18637	1749	11	,	,	,
18637	1749	12	on	on	IN
18637	1749	13	which	which	WDT
18637	1749	14	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	1749	15	of	of	IN
18637	1749	16	the	the	DT
18637	1749	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	1749	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	1749	19	been	be	VBN
18637	1749	20	patterned	pattern	VBN
18637	1749	21	ever	ever	RB
18637	1749	22	since	since	RB
18637	1749	23	.	.	.
18637	1750	1	The	the	DT
18637	1750	2	case	case	NN
18637	1750	3	arose	arise	VBD
18637	1750	4	out	out	IN
18637	1750	5	of	of	IN
18637	1750	6	a	a	DT
18637	1750	7	series	series	NN
18637	1750	8	of	of	IN
18637	1750	9	acts	act	NNS
18637	1750	10	of	of	IN
18637	1750	11	the	the	DT
18637	1750	12	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	1750	13	of	of	IN
18637	1750	14	New	New	NNP
18637	1750	15	York	York	NNP
18637	1750	16	,	,	,
18637	1750	17	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1750	18	between	between	IN
18637	1750	19	the	the	DT
18637	1750	20	years	year	NNS
18637	1750	21	1798	1798	CD
18637	1750	22	and	and	CC
18637	1750	23	1811	1811	CD
18637	1750	24	,	,	,
18637	1750	25	which	which	WDT
18637	1750	26	conferred	confer	VBD
18637	1750	27	upon	upon	IN
18637	1750	28	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
18637	1750	29	and	and	CC
18637	1750	30	Fulton	Fulton	NNP
18637	1750	31	the	the	DT
18637	1750	32	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	1750	33	right	right	NN
18637	1750	34	to	to	TO
18637	1750	35	navigate	navigate	VB
18637	1750	36	the	the	DT
18637	1750	37	waters	water	NNS
18637	1750	38	of	of	IN
18637	1750	39	that	that	DT
18637	1750	40	State	state	NN
18637	1750	41	with	with	IN
18637	1750	42	steam	steam	NN
18637	1750	43	-	-	HYPH
18637	1750	44	propelled	propel	VBN
18637	1750	45	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	1750	46	.	.	.
18637	1751	1	Gibbons	gibbon	NNS
18637	1751	2	challenged	challenge	VBD
18637	1751	3	the	the	DT
18637	1751	4	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	1751	5	by	by	IN
18637	1751	6	sending	send	VBG
18637	1751	7	from	from	IN
18637	1751	8	Elizabethtown	Elizabethtown	NNP
18637	1751	9	,	,	,
18637	1751	10	New	New	NNP
18637	1751	11	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1751	12	,	,	,
18637	1751	13	into	into	IN
18637	1751	14	the	the	DT
18637	1751	15	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	1751	16	in	in	IN
18637	1751	17	the	the	DT
18637	1751	18	State	State	NNP
18637	1751	19	of	of	IN
18637	1751	20	New	New	NNP
18637	1751	21	York	York	NNP
18637	1751	22	two	two	CD
18637	1751	23	steam	steam	NN
18637	1751	24	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	1751	25	which	which	WDT
18637	1751	26	had	have	VBD
18637	1751	27	been	be	VBN
18637	1751	28	licensed	license	VBN
18637	1751	29	and	and	CC
18637	1751	30	enrolled	enrol	VBN
18637	1751	31	to	to	TO
18637	1751	32	engage	engage	VB
18637	1751	33	in	in	IN
18637	1751	34	the	the	DT
18637	1751	35	coasting	coasting	JJ
18637	1751	36	trade	trade	NN
18637	1751	37	under	under	IN
18637	1751	38	an	an	DT
18637	1751	39	act	act	NN
18637	1751	40	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1751	41	by	by	IN
18637	1751	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1751	43	in	in	IN
18637	1751	44	1793	1793	CD
18637	1751	45	.	.	.
18637	1752	1	Counsel	Counsel	NNP
18637	1752	2	for	for	IN
18637	1752	3	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	1752	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1752	5	an	an	DT
18637	1752	6	assignee	assignee	NN
18637	1752	7	of	of	IN
18637	1752	8	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
18637	1752	9	and	and	CC
18637	1752	10	Fulton	Fulton	NNP
18637	1752	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1752	12	argued	argue	VBD
18637	1752	13	that	that	IN
18637	1752	14	since	since	IN
18637	1752	15	Gibbons	gibbon	NNS
18637	1752	16	'	'	POS
18637	1752	17	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	1752	18	carried	carry	VBD
18637	1752	19	only	only	RB
18637	1752	20	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	1752	21	between	between	IN
18637	1752	22	New	New	NNP
18637	1752	23	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	1752	24	and	and	CC
18637	1752	25	New	New	NNP
18637	1752	26	York	York	NNP
18637	1752	27	,	,	,
18637	1752	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1752	29	were	be	VBD
18637	1752	30	not	not	RB
18637	1752	31	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1752	32	in	in	IN
18637	1752	33	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	1752	34	and	and	CC
18637	1752	35	hence	hence	RB
18637	1752	36	not	not	RB
18637	1752	37	in	in	IN
18637	1752	38	"	"	``
18637	1752	39	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1752	40	"	"	''
18637	1752	41	in	in	IN
18637	1752	42	the	the	DT
18637	1752	43	sense	sense	NN
18637	1752	44	of	of	IN
18637	1752	45	the	the	DT
18637	1752	46	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1752	47	.	.	.
18637	1753	1	This	this	DT
18637	1753	2	argument	argument	NN
18637	1753	3	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1753	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1753	5	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1753	6	answered	answer	VBD
18637	1753	7	as	as	IN
18637	1753	8	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	1753	9	:	:	:
18637	1753	10	"	"	``
18637	1753	11	The	the	DT
18637	1753	12	subject	subject	NN
18637	1753	13	to	to	TO
18637	1753	14	be	be	VB
18637	1753	15	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	1753	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	1753	17	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1753	18	;	;	:
18637	1753	19	*	*	NFP
18637	1753	20	*	*	NFP
18637	1753	21	*	*	NFP
18637	1753	22	The	the	DT
18637	1753	23	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	1753	24	for	for	IN
18637	1753	25	the	the	DT
18637	1753	26	appellee	appellee	NN
18637	1753	27	would	would	MD
18637	1753	28	limit	limit	VB
18637	1753	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1753	30	to	to	IN
18637	1753	31	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	1753	32	,	,	,
18637	1753	33	to	to	IN
18637	1753	34	buying	buy	VBG
18637	1753	35	and	and	CC
18637	1753	36	selling	selling	NN
18637	1753	37	,	,	,
18637	1753	38	or	or	CC
18637	1753	39	the	the	DT
18637	1753	40	interchange	interchange	NN
18637	1753	41	of	of	IN
18637	1753	42	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	1753	43	,	,	,
18637	1753	44	and	and	CC
18637	1753	45	do	do	VBP
18637	1753	46	not	not	RB
18637	1753	47	admit	admit	VB
18637	1753	48	that	that	IN
18637	1753	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1753	50	comprehends	comprehend	VBZ
18637	1753	51	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1753	52	.	.	.
18637	1754	1	This	this	DT
18637	1754	2	would	would	MD
18637	1754	3	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	1754	4	a	a	DT
18637	1754	5	general	general	JJ
18637	1754	6	term	term	NN
18637	1754	7	,	,	,
18637	1754	8	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	1754	9	to	to	IN
18637	1754	10	many	many	JJ
18637	1754	11	objects	object	NNS
18637	1754	12	,	,	,
18637	1754	13	to	to	IN
18637	1754	14	one	one	CD
18637	1754	15	of	of	IN
18637	1754	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1754	17	significations	signification	NNS
18637	1754	18	.	.	.
18637	1755	1	Commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1755	2	,	,	,
18637	1755	3	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	1755	4	,	,	,
18637	1755	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	1755	6	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	1755	7	,	,	,
18637	1755	8	but	but	CC
18637	1755	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1755	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	1755	11	something	something	NN
18637	1755	12	more	more	JJR
18637	1755	13	--	--	:
18637	1755	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1755	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	1755	16	intercourse	intercourse	JJ
18637	1755	17	.	.	.
18637	1756	1	"	"	``
18637	1756	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1756	3	308	308	CD
18637	1756	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1756	5	The	the	DT
18637	1756	6	term	term	NN
18637	1756	7	,	,	,
18637	1756	8	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	1756	9	,	,	,
18637	1756	10	included	include	VBD
18637	1756	11	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1756	12	--	--	:
18637	1756	13	a	a	DT
18637	1756	14	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	1756	15	which	which	WDT
18637	1756	16	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1756	17	supported	support	VBD
18637	1756	18	by	by	IN
18637	1756	19	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	1756	20	to	to	IN
18637	1756	21	general	general	JJ
18637	1756	22	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	1756	23	,	,	,
18637	1756	24	to	to	IN
18637	1756	25	the	the	DT
18637	1756	26	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	1756	27	in	in	IN
18637	1756	28	article	article	NN
18637	1756	29	I	i	NN
18637	1756	30	,	,	,
18637	1756	31	§	§	NNP
18637	1756	32	9	9	CD
18637	1756	33	,	,	,
18637	1756	34	against	against	IN
18637	1756	35	any	any	DT
18637	1756	36	preference	preference	NN
18637	1756	37	being	be	VBG
18637	1756	38	given	give	VBN
18637	1756	39	"	"	``
18637	1756	40	'	'	``
18637	1756	41	*	*	NFP
18637	1756	42	*	*	NFP
18637	1756	43	*	*	NFP
18637	1756	44	by	by	IN
18637	1756	45	any	any	DT
18637	1756	46	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1756	47	of	of	IN
18637	1756	48	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1756	49	or	or	CC
18637	1756	50	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	1756	51	,	,	,
18637	1756	52	to	to	IN
18637	1756	53	the	the	DT
18637	1756	54	ports	port	NNS
18637	1756	55	of	of	IN
18637	1756	56	one	one	CD
18637	1756	57	State	state	NN
18637	1756	58	over	over	IN
18637	1756	59	those	those	DT
18637	1756	60	of	of	IN
18637	1756	61	another	another	DT
18637	1756	62	,	,	,
18637	1756	63	'	'	''
18637	1756	64	"	"	''
18637	1756	65	and	and	CC
18637	1756	66	to	to	IN
18637	1756	67	the	the	DT
18637	1756	68	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	1756	69	and	and	CC
18637	1756	70	demonstrated	demonstrate	VBN
18637	1756	71	power	power	NN
18637	1756	72	of	of	IN
18637	1756	73	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1756	74	to	to	TO
18637	1756	75	impose	impose	VB
18637	1756	76	embargoes	embargo	NNS
18637	1756	77	.	.	.
18637	1757	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1757	2	309	309	CD
18637	1757	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1757	4	"	"	``
18637	1757	5	COMMERCE	COMMERCE	NNP
18637	1757	6	"	"	''
18637	1757	7	TODAY	today	NN
18637	1757	8	Later	later	RB
18637	1757	9	in	in	IN
18637	1757	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1757	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1757	12	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1757	13	qualified	qualify	VBD
18637	1757	14	the	the	DT
18637	1757	15	word	word	NN
18637	1757	16	"	"	``
18637	1757	17	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	1757	18	"	"	''
18637	1757	19	with	with	IN
18637	1757	20	the	the	DT
18637	1757	21	word	word	NN
18637	1757	22	"	"	``
18637	1757	23	commercial	commercial	NN
18637	1757	24	.	.	.
18637	1758	1	"	"	``
18637	1758	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1758	3	310	310	CD
18637	1758	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1758	5	Today	today	NN
18637	1758	6	"	"	''
18637	1758	7	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1758	8	"	"	''
18637	1758	9	in	in	IN
18637	1758	10	the	the	DT
18637	1758	11	sense	sense	NN
18637	1758	12	of	of	IN
18637	1758	13	the	the	DT
18637	1758	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1758	15	,	,	,
18637	1758	16	and	and	CC
18637	1758	17	hence	hence	RB
18637	1758	18	"	"	``
18637	1758	19	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1758	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1758	21	"	"	''
18637	1758	22	when	when	WRB
18637	1758	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1758	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	1758	25	carried	carry	VBN
18637	1758	26	on	on	RP
18637	1758	27	across	across	IN
18637	1758	28	State	state	NN
18637	1758	29	lines	line	NNS
18637	1758	30	,	,	,
18637	1758	31	covers	cover	VBZ
18637	1758	32	every	every	DT
18637	1758	33	species	species	NN
18637	1758	34	of	of	IN
18637	1758	35	movement	movement	NN
18637	1758	36	of	of	IN
18637	1758	37	persons	person	NNS
18637	1758	38	and	and	CC
18637	1758	39	things	thing	NNS
18637	1758	40	,	,	,
18637	1758	41	whether	whether	IN
18637	1758	42	for	for	IN
18637	1758	43	profit	profit	NN
18637	1758	44	or	or	CC
18637	1758	45	not;[311	not;[311	NNP
18637	1758	46	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1758	47	every	every	DT
18637	1758	48	species	species	NN
18637	1758	49	of	of	IN
18637	1758	50	communication	communication	NN
18637	1758	51	,	,	,
18637	1758	52	every	every	DT
18637	1758	53	species	species	NN
18637	1758	54	of	of	IN
18637	1758	55	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	1758	56	of	of	IN
18637	1758	57	intelligence	intelligence	NN
18637	1758	58	,	,	,
18637	1758	59	whether	whether	IN
18637	1758	60	for	for	IN
18637	1758	61	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	1758	62	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	1758	63	or	or	CC
18637	1758	64	otherwise;[312	otherwise;[312	NNS
18637	1758	65	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1758	66	every	every	DT
18637	1758	67	species	species	NN
18637	1758	68	of	of	IN
18637	1758	69	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	1758	70	negotiation	negotiation	NN
18637	1758	71	which	which	WDT
18637	1758	72	,	,	,
18637	1758	73	as	as	IN
18637	1758	74	shown	show	VBN
18637	1758	75	"	"	''
18637	1758	76	by	by	IN
18637	1758	77	the	the	DT
18637	1758	78	established	establish	VBN
18637	1758	79	course	course	NN
18637	1758	80	of	of	IN
18637	1758	81	the	the	DT
18637	1758	82	business	business	NN
18637	1758	83	,	,	,
18637	1758	84	"	"	''
18637	1758	85	will	will	MD
18637	1758	86	involve	involve	VB
18637	1758	87	sooner	soon	RBR
18637	1758	88	or	or	CC
18637	1758	89	later	later	RB
18637	1758	90	an	an	DT
18637	1758	91	act	act	NN
18637	1758	92	of	of	IN
18637	1758	93	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1758	94	of	of	IN
18637	1758	95	persons	person	NNS
18637	1758	96	or	or	CC
18637	1758	97	things	thing	NNS
18637	1758	98	,	,	,
18637	1758	99	or	or	CC
18637	1758	100	the	the	DT
18637	1758	101	flow	flow	NN
18637	1758	102	of	of	IN
18637	1758	103	services	service	NNS
18637	1758	104	or	or	CC
18637	1758	105	power	power	NN
18637	1758	106	across	across	IN
18637	1758	107	State	State	NNP
18637	1758	108	lines	line	NNS
18637	1758	109	.	.	.
18637	1759	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1759	2	313	313	CD
18637	1759	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1759	4	From	from	IN
18637	1759	5	time	time	NN
18637	1759	6	to	to	IN
18637	1759	7	time	time	NN
18637	1759	8	the	the	DT
18637	1759	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1759	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	1759	11	said	say	VBN
18637	1759	12	that	that	IN
18637	1759	13	certain	certain	JJ
18637	1759	14	things	thing	NNS
18637	1759	15	were	be	VBD
18637	1759	16	not	not	RB
18637	1759	17	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1759	18	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1759	19	,	,	,
18637	1759	20	such	such	JJ
18637	1759	21	as	as	IN
18637	1759	22	mining	mining	NN
18637	1759	23	or	or	CC
18637	1759	24	manufacturing	manufacturing	NN
18637	1759	25	undertaken	undertake	VBN
18637	1759	26	"	"	''
18637	1759	27	with	with	IN
18637	1759	28	the	the	DT
18637	1759	29	intent	intent	NN
18637	1759	30	"	"	''
18637	1759	31	that	that	IN
18637	1759	32	the	the	DT
18637	1759	33	product	product	NN
18637	1759	34	shall	shall	MD
18637	1759	35	be	be	VB
18637	1759	36	transported	transport	VBN
18637	1759	37	to	to	IN
18637	1759	38	other	other	JJ
18637	1759	39	States;[314	States;[314	NFP
18637	1759	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1759	41	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	1759	42	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	1759	43	when	when	WRB
18637	1759	44	carried	carry	VBN
18637	1759	45	on	on	RP
18637	1759	46	across	across	IN
18637	1759	47	State	State	NNP
18637	1759	48	lines;[315	lines;[315	HYPH
18637	1759	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1759	50	exhibitions	exhibition	NNS
18637	1759	51	of	of	IN
18637	1759	52	baseball	baseball	NN
18637	1759	53	between	between	IN
18637	1759	54	professional	professional	JJ
18637	1759	55	teams	team	NNS
18637	1759	56	which	which	WDT
18637	1759	57	travel	travel	VBP
18637	1759	58	from	from	IN
18637	1759	59	State	state	NN
18637	1759	60	to	to	TO
18637	1759	61	State;[316	state;[316	LS
18637	1759	62	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1759	63	the	the	DT
18637	1759	64	making	making	NN
18637	1759	65	of	of	IN
18637	1759	66	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	1759	67	for	for	IN
18637	1759	68	the	the	DT
18637	1759	69	insertion	insertion	NN
18637	1759	70	of	of	IN
18637	1759	71	advertisements	advertisement	NNS
18637	1759	72	in	in	IN
18637	1759	73	periodicals	periodical	NNS
18637	1759	74	in	in	IN
18637	1759	75	another	another	DT
18637	1759	76	State;[317	state;[317	NN
18637	1759	77	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1759	78	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	1759	79	for	for	IN
18637	1759	80	personal	personal	JJ
18637	1759	81	services	service	NNS
18637	1759	82	to	to	TO
18637	1759	83	be	be	VB
18637	1759	84	rendered	render	VBN
18637	1759	85	in	in	IN
18637	1759	86	another	another	DT
18637	1759	87	State	state	NN
18637	1759	88	.	.	.
18637	1760	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1760	2	318	318	CD
18637	1760	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1760	4	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	1760	5	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	1760	6	either	either	CC
18637	1760	7	overturn	overturn	NN
18637	1760	8	or	or	CC
18637	1760	9	cast	cast	VBN
18637	1760	10	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	1760	11	on	on	IN
18637	1760	12	most	most	JJS
18637	1760	13	if	if	IN
18637	1760	14	not	not	RB
18637	1760	15	all	all	DT
18637	1760	16	of	of	IN
18637	1760	17	these	these	DT
18637	1760	18	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	1760	19	.	.	.
18637	1761	1	By	by	IN
18637	1761	2	one	one	CD
18637	1761	3	of	of	IN
18637	1761	4	these	these	DT
18637	1761	5	the	the	DT
18637	1761	6	gathering	gathering	NN
18637	1761	7	of	of	IN
18637	1761	8	news	news	NN
18637	1761	9	by	by	IN
18637	1761	10	a	a	DT
18637	1761	11	press	press	NN
18637	1761	12	association	association	NN
18637	1761	13	and	and	CC
18637	1761	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1761	15	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	1761	16	to	to	IN
18637	1761	17	client	client	NN
18637	1761	18	newspapers	newspaper	NNS
18637	1761	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	1761	20	termed	term	VBN
18637	1761	21	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1761	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1761	23	.	.	.
18637	1762	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1762	2	319	319	CD
18637	1762	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1762	4	By	by	IN
18637	1762	5	another	another	DT
18637	1762	6	the	the	DT
18637	1762	7	activities	activity	NNS
18637	1762	8	of	of	IN
18637	1762	9	a	a	DT
18637	1762	10	Group	Group	NNP
18637	1762	11	Health	Health	NNP
18637	1762	12	Association	Association	NNP
18637	1762	13	which	which	WDT
18637	1762	14	serves	serve	VBZ
18637	1762	15	only	only	RB
18637	1762	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1762	17	own	own	JJ
18637	1762	18	members	member	NNS
18637	1762	19	are	be	VBP
18637	1762	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	1762	21	to	to	TO
18637	1762	22	be	be	VB
18637	1762	23	"	"	``
18637	1762	24	trade	trade	NN
18637	1762	25	"	"	''
18637	1762	26	within	within	IN
18637	1762	27	the	the	DT
18637	1762	28	protection	protection	NN
18637	1762	29	of	of	IN
18637	1762	30	the	the	DT
18637	1762	31	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	1762	32	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1762	33	and	and	CC
18637	1762	34	hence	hence	RB
18637	1762	35	capable	capable	JJ
18637	1762	36	,	,	,
18637	1762	37	if	if	IN
18637	1762	38	extended	extend	VBN
18637	1762	39	,	,	,
18637	1762	40	of	of	IN
18637	1762	41	becoming	become	VBG
18637	1762	42	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1762	43	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1762	44	.	.	.
18637	1763	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1763	2	320	320	CD
18637	1763	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1763	4	By	by	IN
18637	1763	5	a	a	DT
18637	1763	6	third	third	NN
18637	1763	7	the	the	DT
18637	1763	8	business	business	NN
18637	1763	9	of	of	IN
18637	1763	10	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	1763	11	when	when	WRB
18637	1763	12	transacted	transact	VBN
18637	1763	13	between	between	IN
18637	1763	14	an	an	DT
18637	1763	15	insurer	insurer	NN
18637	1763	16	and	and	CC
18637	1763	17	an	an	DT
18637	1763	18	insured	insure	VBN
18637	1763	19	in	in	IN
18637	1763	20	different	different	JJ
18637	1763	21	States	States	NNP
18637	1763	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	1763	23	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1763	24	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1763	25	.	.	.
18637	1764	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1764	2	321	321	CD
18637	1764	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1764	4	THE	the	DT
18637	1764	5	"	"	``
18637	1764	6	NECESSARY	necessary	NN
18637	1764	7	AND	and	CC
18637	1764	8	PROPER	proper	NN
18637	1764	9	"	"	''
18637	1764	10	CLAUSE	clause	NN
18637	1764	11	In	in	IN
18637	1764	12	the	the	DT
18637	1764	13	majority	majority	NN
18637	1764	14	of	of	IN
18637	1764	15	the	the	DT
18637	1764	16	above	above	JJ
18637	1764	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	1764	18	the	the	DT
18637	1764	19	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1764	20	clause	clause	NN
18637	1764	21	was	be	VBD
18637	1764	22	involved	involve	VBN
18637	1764	23	solely	solely	RB
18637	1764	24	as	as	IN
18637	1764	25	a	a	DT
18637	1764	26	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	1764	27	on	on	IN
18637	1764	28	the	the	DT
18637	1764	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	1764	30	of	of	IN
18637	1764	31	the	the	DT
18637	1764	32	States	States	NNP
18637	1764	33	.	.	.
18637	1765	1	But	but	CC
18637	1765	2	when	when	WRB
18637	1765	3	the	the	DT
18637	1765	4	clause	clause	NN
18637	1765	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	1765	6	treated	treat	VBN
18637	1765	7	as	as	IN
18637	1765	8	a	a	DT
18637	1765	9	source	source	NN
18637	1765	10	of	of	IN
18637	1765	11	national	national	JJ
18637	1765	12	power	power	NN
18637	1765	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1765	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	1765	15	,	,	,
18637	1765	16	of	of	IN
18637	1765	17	course	course	NN
18637	1765	18	,	,	,
18637	1765	19	read	read	VBN
18637	1765	20	in	in	IN
18637	1765	21	association	association	NN
18637	1765	22	with	with	IN
18637	1765	23	the	the	DT
18637	1765	24	power	power	NN
18637	1765	25	of	of	IN
18637	1765	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1765	27	"	"	''
18637	1765	28	*	*	NFP
18637	1765	29	*	*	NFP
18637	1765	30	*	*	NFP
18637	1765	31	To	to	TO
18637	1765	32	make	make	VB
18637	1765	33	all	all	DT
18637	1765	34	Laws	law	NNS
18637	1765	35	which	which	WDT
18637	1765	36	shall	shall	MD
18637	1765	37	be	be	VB
18637	1765	38	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1765	39	and	and	CC
18637	1765	40	proper	proper	JJ
18637	1765	41	for	for	IN
18637	1765	42	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	1765	43	into	into	IN
18637	1765	44	Execution	execution	NN
18637	1765	45	the	the	DT
18637	1765	46	foregoing	forego	VBG
18637	1765	47	Powers	power	NNS
18637	1765	48	,	,	,
18637	1765	49	*	*	NFP
18637	1765	50	*	*	NFP
18637	1765	51	*	*	NFP
18637	1765	52	,	,	,
18637	1765	53	"	"	''
18637	1765	54	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1765	55	322	322	CD
18637	1765	56	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1765	57	with	with	IN
18637	1765	58	the	the	DT
18637	1765	59	result	result	NN
18637	1765	60	that	that	IN
18637	1765	61	,	,	,
18637	1765	62	as	as	IN
18637	1765	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	1765	64	pointed	point	VBN
18637	1765	65	out	out	RP
18637	1765	66	later	later	RB
18637	1765	67	,	,	,
18637	1765	68	"	"	``
18637	1765	69	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1765	70	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1765	71	"	"	''
18637	1765	72	has	have	VBZ
18637	1765	73	come	come	VBN
18637	1765	74	in	in	IN
18637	1765	75	recent	recent	JJ
18637	1765	76	years	year	NNS
18637	1765	77	practically	practically	RB
18637	1765	78	to	to	TO
18637	1765	79	connote	connote	VB
18637	1765	80	both	both	CC
18637	1765	81	those	those	DT
18637	1765	82	operations	operation	NNS
18637	1765	83	which	which	WDT
18637	1765	84	precede	precede	VBP
18637	1765	85	as	as	RB
18637	1765	86	well	well	RB
18637	1765	87	as	as	IN
18637	1765	88	those	those	DT
18637	1765	89	which	which	WDT
18637	1765	90	follow	follow	VBP
18637	1765	91	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	1765	92	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	1765	93	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1765	94	,	,	,
18637	1765	95	provided	provide	VBD
18637	1765	96	such	such	JJ
18637	1765	97	operations	operation	NNS
18637	1765	98	are	be	VBP
18637	1765	99	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	1765	100	by	by	IN
18637	1765	101	the	the	DT
18637	1765	102	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1765	103	to	to	TO
18637	1765	104	be	be	VB
18637	1765	105	capable	capable	JJ
18637	1765	106	of	of	IN
18637	1765	107	"	"	``
18637	1765	108	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	1765	109	"	"	''
18637	1765	110	such	such	JJ
18637	1765	111	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	1765	112	.	.	.
18637	1766	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1766	2	323	323	CD
18637	1766	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1766	4	"	"	``
18637	1766	5	AMONG	among	IN
18637	1766	6	THE	the	DT
18637	1766	7	SEVERAL	several	JJ
18637	1766	8	STATES	state	NNS
18637	1766	9	"	"	''
18637	1766	10	In	in	IN
18637	1766	11	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	1766	12	_	_	NNP
18637	1766	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	1766	14	_	_	NNP
18637	1766	15	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1766	16	,	,	,
18637	1766	17	decided	decide	VBD
18637	1766	18	in	in	IN
18637	1766	19	1821	1821	CD
18637	1766	20	,	,	,
18637	1766	21	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1766	22	had	have	VBD
18637	1766	23	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	1766	24	,	,	,
18637	1766	25	"	"	``
18637	1766	26	for	for	IN
18637	1766	27	all	all	DT
18637	1766	28	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	1766	29	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	1766	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1766	31	are	be	VBP
18637	1766	32	one	one	CD
18637	1766	33	nation	nation	NN
18637	1766	34	.	.	.
18637	1767	1	"	"	``
18637	1767	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1767	3	324	324	CD
18637	1767	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1767	5	In	In	NNP
18637	1767	6	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	1767	7	_	_	NNP
18637	1767	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	1767	9	_	_	NNP
18637	1767	10	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	1767	11	,	,	,
18637	1767	12	however	however	RB
18637	1767	13	,	,	,
18637	1767	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1767	15	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	1767	16	that	that	IN
18637	1767	17	the	the	DT
18637	1767	18	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	1767	19	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1767	20	"	"	``
18637	1767	21	among	among	IN
18637	1767	22	the	the	DT
18637	1767	23	several	several	JJ
18637	1767	24	States	States	NNPS
18637	1767	25	"	"	''
18637	1767	26	was	be	VBD
18637	1767	27	"	"	``
18637	1767	28	not	not	RB
18637	1767	29	one	one	CD
18637	1767	30	which	which	WDT
18637	1767	31	would	would	MD
18637	1767	32	probably	probably	RB
18637	1767	33	have	have	VB
18637	1767	34	been	be	VBN
18637	1767	35	selected	select	VBN
18637	1767	36	to	to	TO
18637	1767	37	indicate	indicate	VB
18637	1767	38	the	the	DT
18637	1767	39	completely	completely	RB
18637	1767	40	interior	interior	JJ
18637	1767	41	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	1767	42	of	of	IN
18637	1767	43	a	a	DT
18637	1767	44	State	State	NNP
18637	1767	45	"	"	''
18637	1767	46	;	;	:
18637	1767	47	and	and	CC
18637	1767	48	added	add	VBD
18637	1767	49	:	:	:
18637	1767	50	"	"	``
18637	1767	51	The	the	DT
18637	1767	52	genius	genius	NN
18637	1767	53	and	and	CC
18637	1767	54	character	character	NN
18637	1767	55	of	of	IN
18637	1767	56	the	the	DT
18637	1767	57	whole	whole	JJ
18637	1767	58	government	government	NN
18637	1767	59	seem	seem	VBP
18637	1767	60	to	to	TO
18637	1767	61	be	be	VB
18637	1767	62	,	,	,
18637	1767	63	that	that	IN
18637	1767	64	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1767	65	action	action	NN
18637	1767	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	1767	67	to	to	TO
18637	1767	68	be	be	VB
18637	1767	69	applied	apply	VBN
18637	1767	70	to	to	IN
18637	1767	71	all	all	DT
18637	1767	72	external	external	JJ
18637	1767	73	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	1767	74	of	of	IN
18637	1767	75	the	the	DT
18637	1767	76	nation	nation	NN
18637	1767	77	,	,	,
18637	1767	78	and	and	CC
18637	1767	79	to	to	IN
18637	1767	80	those	those	DT
18637	1767	81	internal	internal	JJ
18637	1767	82	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	1767	83	which	which	WDT
18637	1767	84	affect	affect	VBP
18637	1767	85	the	the	DT
18637	1767	86	States	States	NNP
18637	1767	87	generally	generally	RB
18637	1767	88	;	;	:
18637	1767	89	but	but	CC
18637	1767	90	not	not	RB
18637	1767	91	those	those	DT
18637	1767	92	which	which	WDT
18637	1767	93	are	be	VBP
18637	1767	94	completely	completely	RB
18637	1767	95	within	within	IN
18637	1767	96	a	a	DT
18637	1767	97	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1767	98	State	state	NN
18637	1767	99	,	,	,
18637	1767	100	which	which	WDT
18637	1767	101	do	do	VBP
18637	1767	102	not	not	RB
18637	1767	103	affect	affect	VB
18637	1767	104	other	other	JJ
18637	1767	105	States	States	NNPS
18637	1767	106	,	,	,
18637	1767	107	and	and	CC
18637	1767	108	with	with	IN
18637	1767	109	which	which	WDT
18637	1767	110	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1767	111	is	be	VBZ
18637	1767	112	not	not	RB
18637	1767	113	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1767	114	to	to	TO
18637	1767	115	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	1767	116	,	,	,
18637	1767	117	for	for	IN
18637	1767	118	the	the	DT
18637	1767	119	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1767	120	of	of	IN
18637	1767	121	executing	execute	VBG
18637	1767	122	some	some	DT
18637	1767	123	of	of	IN
18637	1767	124	the	the	DT
18637	1767	125	general	general	JJ
18637	1767	126	powers	power	NNS
18637	1767	127	of	of	IN
18637	1767	128	the	the	DT
18637	1767	129	government	government	NN
18637	1767	130	.	.	.
18637	1768	1	"	"	``
18637	1768	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1768	3	325	325	CD
18637	1768	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1768	5	This	this	DT
18637	1768	6	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	1768	7	of	of	IN
18637	1768	8	an	an	DT
18637	1768	9	"	"	``
18637	1768	10	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	1768	11	internal	internal	JJ
18637	1768	12	"	"	''
18637	1768	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1768	14	of	of	IN
18637	1768	15	a	a	DT
18637	1768	16	State	State	NNP
18637	1768	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1768	18	"	"	``
18637	1768	19	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	1768	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1768	21	"	"	''
18637	1768	22	today	today	NN
18637	1768	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1768	24	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1768	25	at	at	IN
18637	1768	26	times	time	NNS
18637	1768	27	to	to	TO
18637	1768	28	have	have	VB
18637	1768	29	been	be	VBN
18637	1768	30	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	1768	31	as	as	IN
18637	1768	32	implying	imply	VBG
18637	1768	33	the	the	DT
18637	1768	34	existence	existence	NN
18637	1768	35	of	of	IN
18637	1768	36	an	an	DT
18637	1768	37	area	area	NN
18637	1768	38	of	of	IN
18637	1768	39	State	State	NNP
18637	1768	40	power	power	NN
18637	1768	41	which	which	WDT
18637	1768	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1768	43	was	be	VBD
18637	1768	44	not	not	RB
18637	1768	45	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	1768	46	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	1768	47	to	to	TO
18637	1768	48	enter	enter	VB
18637	1768	49	.	.	.
18637	1769	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1769	2	326	326	CD
18637	1769	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1769	4	This	this	DT
18637	1769	5	inference	inference	NN
18637	1769	6	overlooked	overlook	VBD
18637	1769	7	the	the	DT
18637	1769	8	fact	fact	NN
18637	1769	9	that	that	IN
18637	1769	10	,	,	,
18637	1769	11	in	in	IN
18637	1769	12	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	1769	13	of	of	IN
18637	1769	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1769	15	powers	power	NNS
18637	1769	16	under	under	IN
18637	1769	17	the	the	DT
18637	1769	18	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1769	19	and	and	CC
18637	1769	20	proper	proper	JJ
18637	1769	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	1769	22	,	,	,
18637	1769	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1769	24	can	can	MD
18637	1769	25	,	,	,
18637	1769	26	as	as	IN
18637	1769	27	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1769	28	indicates	indicate	VBZ
18637	1769	29	in	in	IN
18637	1769	30	the	the	DT
18637	1769	31	words	word	NNS
18637	1769	32	above	above	IN
18637	1769	33	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	1769	34	,	,	,
18637	1769	35	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	1769	36	with	with	IN
18637	1769	37	the	the	DT
18637	1769	38	completely	completely	RB
18637	1769	39	internal	internal	JJ
18637	1769	40	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	1769	41	of	of	IN
18637	1769	42	a	a	DT
18637	1769	43	State	state	NN
18637	1769	44	"	"	''
18637	1769	45	for	for	IN
18637	1769	46	the	the	DT
18637	1769	47	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1769	48	of	of	IN
18637	1769	49	executing	execute	VBG
18637	1769	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1769	51	general	general	JJ
18637	1769	52	powers	power	NNS
18637	1769	53	,	,	,
18637	1769	54	"	"	''
18637	1769	55	one	one	CD
18637	1769	56	of	of	IN
18637	1769	57	which	which	WDT
18637	1769	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	1769	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1769	60	power	power	NN
18637	1769	61	over	over	IN
18637	1769	62	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1769	63	and	and	CC
18637	1769	64	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1769	65	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1769	66	.	.	.
18637	1770	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1770	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1770	3	today	today	NN
18637	1770	4	established	establish	VBN
18637	1770	5	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1770	6	that	that	IN
18637	1770	7	"	"	``
18637	1770	8	no	no	DT
18637	1770	9	form	form	NN
18637	1770	10	of	of	IN
18637	1770	11	State	state	NN
18637	1770	12	activity	activity	NN
18637	1770	13	can	can	MD
18637	1770	14	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	1770	15	thwart	thwart	VB
18637	1770	16	the	the	DT
18637	1770	17	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	1770	18	power	power	NN
18637	1770	19	granted	grant	VBN
18637	1770	20	by	by	IN
18637	1770	21	the	the	DT
18637	1770	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1770	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	1770	24	to	to	IN
18637	1770	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1770	26	.	.	.
18637	1771	1	"	"	``
18637	1771	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1771	3	327	327	CD
18637	1771	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1771	5	And	and	CC
18637	1771	6	while	while	IN
18637	1771	7	the	the	DT
18637	1771	8	word	word	NN
18637	1771	9	"	"	''
18637	1771	10	among	among	IN
18637	1771	11	"	"	``
18637	1771	12	serves	serve	VBZ
18637	1771	13	to	to	TO
18637	1771	14	demark	demark	VB
18637	1771	15	"	"	``
18637	1771	16	the	the	DT
18637	1771	17	completely	completely	RB
18637	1771	18	internal	internal	JJ
18637	1771	19	"	"	''
18637	1771	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1771	21	of	of	IN
18637	1771	22	a	a	DT
18637	1771	23	State	State	NNP
18637	1771	24	from	from	IN
18637	1771	25	that	that	DT
18637	1771	26	which	which	WDT
18637	1771	27	"	"	``
18637	1771	28	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	1771	29	to	to	IN
18637	1771	30	or	or	CC
18637	1771	31	affects	affect	VBZ
18637	1771	32	"	"	``
18637	1771	33	other	other	JJ
18637	1771	34	States	States	NNPS
18637	1771	35	,	,	,
18637	1771	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1771	37	also	also	RB
18637	1771	38	serves	serve	VBZ
18637	1771	39	,	,	,
18637	1771	40	as	as	IN
18637	1771	41	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1771	42	further	further	RB
18637	1771	43	pointed	point	VBD
18637	1771	44	out	out	RP
18637	1771	45	,	,	,
18637	1771	46	to	to	TO
18637	1771	47	emphasize	emphasize	VB
18637	1771	48	the	the	DT
18637	1771	49	fact	fact	NN
18637	1771	50	that	that	IN
18637	1771	51	"	"	``
18637	1771	52	the	the	DT
18637	1771	53	power	power	NN
18637	1771	54	of	of	IN
18637	1771	55	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1771	56	does	do	VBZ
18637	1771	57	not	not	RB
18637	1771	58	stop	stop	VB
18637	1771	59	at	at	IN
18637	1771	60	the	the	DT
18637	1771	61	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	1771	62	lines	line	NNS
18637	1771	63	of	of	IN
18637	1771	64	the	the	DT
18637	1771	65	several	several	JJ
18637	1771	66	States	state	NNS
18637	1771	67	,	,	,
18637	1771	68	"	"	''
18637	1771	69	but	but	CC
18637	1771	70	"	"	``
18637	1771	71	must	must	MD
18637	1771	72	be	be	VB
18637	1771	73	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	1771	74	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	1771	75	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1771	76	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	1771	77	?	?	.
18637	1771	78	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1772	1	the	the	DT
18637	1772	2	subject	subject	NN
18637	1772	3	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	1772	4	.	.	.
18637	1773	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1773	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1773	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1773	4	Commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1773	5	among	among	IN
18637	1773	6	the	the	DT
18637	1773	7	States	States	NNPS
18637	1773	8	must	must	MD
18637	1773	9	,	,	,
18637	1773	10	of	of	IN
18637	1773	11	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	1773	12	,	,	,
18637	1773	13	be	be	VB
18637	1773	14	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1773	15	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1773	16	within	within	IN
18637	1773	17	?	?	.
18637	1773	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1774	1	the	the	DT
18637	1774	2	States	States	NNP
18637	1774	3	.	.	.
18637	1775	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1775	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1775	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1775	4	The	the	DT
18637	1775	5	power	power	NN
18637	1775	6	of	of	IN
18637	1775	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1775	8	,	,	,
18637	1775	9	then	then	RB
18637	1775	10	,	,	,
18637	1775	11	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	1775	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1775	13	may	may	MD
18637	1775	14	be	be	VB
18637	1775	15	,	,	,
18637	1775	16	must	must	MD
18637	1775	17	be	be	VB
18637	1775	18	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	1775	19	within	within	IN
18637	1775	20	the	the	DT
18637	1775	21	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	1775	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	1775	23	of	of	IN
18637	1775	24	the	the	DT
18637	1775	25	several	several	JJ
18637	1775	26	States	state	NNS
18637	1775	27	.	.	.
18637	1776	1	"	"	``
18637	1776	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1776	3	328	328	CD
18637	1776	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1776	5	"	"	``
18637	1776	6	REGULATE	REGULATE	NNP
18637	1776	7	"	"	''
18637	1776	8	Elucidating	elucidate	VBG
18637	1776	9	this	this	DT
18637	1776	10	word	word	NN
18637	1776	11	in	in	IN
18637	1776	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1776	13	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1776	14	for	for	IN
18637	1776	15	the	the	DT
18637	1776	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1776	17	in	in	IN
18637	1776	18	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	1776	19	_	_	NNP
18637	1776	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	1776	21	_	_	NNP
18637	1776	22	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	1776	23	,	,	,
18637	1776	24	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1776	25	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1776	26	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1776	27	said	say	VBD
18637	1776	28	:	:	:
18637	1776	29	"	"	``
18637	1776	30	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1776	31	are	be	VBP
18637	1776	32	now	now	RB
18637	1776	33	arrived	arrive	VBN
18637	1776	34	at	at	IN
18637	1776	35	the	the	DT
18637	1776	36	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	1776	37	--	--	:
18637	1776	38	What	what	WP
18637	1776	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	1776	40	this	this	DT
18637	1776	41	power	power	NN
18637	1776	42	?	?	.
18637	1777	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1777	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1777	3	the	the	DT
18637	1777	4	power	power	NN
18637	1777	5	to	to	TO
18637	1777	6	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1777	7	;	;	:
18637	1777	8	that	that	RB
18637	1777	9	is	is	RB
18637	1777	10	,	,	,
18637	1777	11	to	to	TO
18637	1777	12	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	1777	13	the	the	DT
18637	1777	14	rule	rule	NN
18637	1777	15	by	by	IN
18637	1777	16	which	which	WDT
18637	1777	17	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1777	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	1777	19	to	to	TO
18637	1777	20	be	be	VB
18637	1777	21	governed	govern	VBN
18637	1777	22	.	.	.
18637	1778	1	This	this	DT
18637	1778	2	power	power	NN
18637	1778	3	,	,	,
18637	1778	4	like	like	IN
18637	1778	5	all	all	DT
18637	1778	6	others	other	NNS
18637	1778	7	vested	vest	VBN
18637	1778	8	in	in	IN
18637	1778	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1778	10	,	,	,
18637	1778	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	1778	12	complete	complete	JJ
18637	1778	13	in	in	IN
18637	1778	14	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1778	15	,	,	,
18637	1778	16	may	may	MD
18637	1778	17	be	be	VB
18637	1778	18	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	1778	19	to	to	IN
18637	1778	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1778	21	utmost	utmost	JJ
18637	1778	22	extent	extent	NN
18637	1778	23	,	,	,
18637	1778	24	and	and	CC
18637	1778	25	acknowledges	acknowledge	VBZ
18637	1778	26	no	no	DT
18637	1778	27	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	1778	28	,	,	,
18637	1778	29	other	other	JJ
18637	1778	30	than	than	IN
18637	1778	31	are	be	VBP
18637	1778	32	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	1778	33	in	in	IN
18637	1778	34	the	the	DT
18637	1778	35	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1778	36	.	.	.
18637	1779	1	These	these	DT
18637	1779	2	are	be	VBP
18637	1779	3	expressed	express	VBN
18637	1779	4	in	in	IN
18637	1779	5	plain	plain	JJ
18637	1779	6	terms	term	NNS
18637	1779	7	,	,	,
18637	1779	8	and	and	CC
18637	1779	9	do	do	VBP
18637	1779	10	not	not	RB
18637	1779	11	affect	affect	VB
18637	1779	12	the	the	DT
18637	1779	13	questions	question	NNS
18637	1779	14	which	which	WDT
18637	1779	15	arise	arise	VBP
18637	1779	16	in	in	IN
18637	1779	17	this	this	DT
18637	1779	18	case	case	NN
18637	1779	19	,	,	,
18637	1779	20	or	or	CC
18637	1779	21	which	which	WDT
18637	1779	22	have	have	VBP
18637	1779	23	been	be	VBN
18637	1779	24	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	1779	25	at	at	IN
18637	1779	26	the	the	DT
18637	1779	27	bar	bar	NN
18637	1779	28	.	.	.
18637	1780	1	If	if	IN
18637	1780	2	,	,	,
18637	1780	3	as	as	IN
18637	1780	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	1780	5	always	always	RB
18637	1780	6	been	be	VBN
18637	1780	7	understood	understand	VBN
18637	1780	8	,	,	,
18637	1780	9	the	the	DT
18637	1780	10	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	1780	11	of	of	IN
18637	1780	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1780	13	,	,	,
18637	1780	14	though	though	IN
18637	1780	15	limited	limit	VBN
18637	1780	16	to	to	IN
18637	1780	17	specified	specified	JJ
18637	1780	18	objects	object	NNS
18637	1780	19	,	,	,
18637	1780	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	1780	21	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	1780	22	as	as	IN
18637	1780	23	to	to	IN
18637	1780	24	those	those	DT
18637	1780	25	objects	object	NNS
18637	1780	26	,	,	,
18637	1780	27	the	the	DT
18637	1780	28	power	power	NN
18637	1780	29	over	over	IN
18637	1780	30	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1780	31	with	with	IN
18637	1780	32	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1780	33	nations	nation	NNS
18637	1780	34	,	,	,
18637	1780	35	and	and	CC
18637	1780	36	among	among	IN
18637	1780	37	the	the	DT
18637	1780	38	several	several	JJ
18637	1780	39	States	States	NNP
18637	1780	40	,	,	,
18637	1780	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	1780	42	vested	vest	VBN
18637	1780	43	in	in	IN
18637	1780	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1780	45	as	as	RB
18637	1780	46	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	1780	47	as	as	IN
18637	1780	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1780	49	would	would	MD
18637	1780	50	be	be	VB
18637	1780	51	in	in	IN
18637	1780	52	a	a	DT
18637	1780	53	single	single	JJ
18637	1780	54	government	government	NN
18637	1780	55	,	,	,
18637	1780	56	having	have	VBG
18637	1780	57	in	in	IN
18637	1780	58	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1780	59	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	1780	60	the	the	DT
18637	1780	61	same	same	JJ
18637	1780	62	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	1780	63	on	on	IN
18637	1780	64	the	the	DT
18637	1780	65	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1780	66	of	of	IN
18637	1780	67	the	the	DT
18637	1780	68	power	power	NN
18637	1780	69	as	as	IN
18637	1780	70	are	be	VBP
18637	1780	71	found	find	VBN
18637	1780	72	in	in	IN
18637	1780	73	the	the	DT
18637	1780	74	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1780	75	of	of	IN
18637	1780	76	the	the	DT
18637	1780	77	United	United	NNP
18637	1780	78	States	States	NNP
18637	1780	79	.	.	.
18637	1781	1	The	the	DT
18637	1781	2	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	1781	3	and	and	CC
18637	1781	4	the	the	DT
18637	1781	5	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	1781	6	of	of	IN
18637	1781	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1781	8	,	,	,
18637	1781	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1781	10	identity	identity	NN
18637	1781	11	with	with	IN
18637	1781	12	the	the	DT
18637	1781	13	people	people	NNS
18637	1781	14	,	,	,
18637	1781	15	and	and	CC
18637	1781	16	the	the	DT
18637	1781	17	influence	influence	NN
18637	1781	18	which	which	WDT
18637	1781	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1781	20	constituents	constituent	NNS
18637	1781	21	possess	possess	VBP
18637	1781	22	at	at	IN
18637	1781	23	elections	election	NNS
18637	1781	24	,	,	,
18637	1781	25	are	be	VBP
18637	1781	26	,	,	,
18637	1781	27	in	in	IN
18637	1781	28	this	this	DT
18637	1781	29	,	,	,
18637	1781	30	as	as	IN
18637	1781	31	in	in	IN
18637	1781	32	many	many	JJ
18637	1781	33	other	other	JJ
18637	1781	34	instances	instance	NNS
18637	1781	35	,	,	,
18637	1781	36	as	as	IN
18637	1781	37	that	that	DT
18637	1781	38	,	,	,
18637	1781	39	for	for	IN
18637	1781	40	example	example	NN
18637	1781	41	,	,	,
18637	1781	42	of	of	IN
18637	1781	43	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	1781	44	war	war	NN
18637	1781	45	,	,	,
18637	1781	46	the	the	DT
18637	1781	47	sole	sole	JJ
18637	1781	48	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	1781	49	on	on	IN
18637	1781	50	which	which	WDT
18637	1781	51	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1781	52	have	have	VBP
18637	1781	53	relied	rely	VBN
18637	1781	54	,	,	,
18637	1781	55	to	to	TO
18637	1781	56	secure	secure	VB
18637	1781	57	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1781	58	from	from	IN
18637	1781	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1781	60	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	1781	61	.	.	.
18637	1782	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1782	2	are	be	VBP
18637	1782	3	the	the	DT
18637	1782	4	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	1782	5	on	on	IN
18637	1782	6	which	which	WDT
18637	1782	7	the	the	DT
18637	1782	8	people	people	NNS
18637	1782	9	must	must	MD
18637	1782	10	often	often	RB
18637	1782	11	rely	rely	VB
18637	1782	12	solely	solely	RB
18637	1782	13	,	,	,
18637	1782	14	in	in	IN
18637	1782	15	all	all	DT
18637	1782	16	representative	representative	JJ
18637	1782	17	governments	government	NNS
18637	1782	18	.	.	.
18637	1783	1	"	"	``
18637	1783	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1783	3	329	329	CD
18637	1783	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1783	5	INTERSTATE	interstate	JJ
18637	1783	6	VERSUS	versu	NNS
18637	1783	7	FOREIGN	foreign	JJ
18637	1783	8	COMMERCE	COMMERCE	NNS
18637	1783	9	There	there	EX
18637	1783	10	are	be	VBP
18637	1783	11	certain	certain	JJ
18637	1783	12	later	later	RB
18637	1783	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1783	14	dicta	dicta	NN
18637	1783	15	which	which	WDT
18637	1783	16	urge	urge	VBP
18637	1783	17	or	or	CC
18637	1783	18	suggest	suggest	VBP
18637	1783	19	that	that	IN
18637	1783	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1783	21	's	's	POS
18637	1783	22	power	power	NN
18637	1783	23	to	to	TO
18637	1783	24	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1783	25	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1783	26	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1783	27	restrictively	restrictively	RB
18637	1783	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	1783	29	less	less	JJR
18637	1783	30	than	than	IN
18637	1783	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1783	32	analogous	analogous	JJ
18637	1783	33	power	power	NN
18637	1783	34	over	over	IN
18637	1783	35	foreign	foreign	NNP
18637	1783	36	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1783	37	,	,	,
18637	1783	38	the	the	DT
18637	1783	39	argument	argument	NN
18637	1783	40	being	be	VBG
18637	1783	41	that	that	IN
18637	1783	42	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	1783	43	the	the	DT
18637	1783	44	latter	latter	NN
18637	1783	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	1783	46	a	a	DT
18637	1783	47	branch	branch	NN
18637	1783	48	of	of	IN
18637	1783	49	the	the	DT
18637	1783	50	nation	nation	NN
18637	1783	51	's	's	POS
18637	1783	52	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	1783	53	power	power	NN
18637	1783	54	over	over	IN
18637	1783	55	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1783	56	relations	relation	NNS
18637	1783	57	,	,	,
18637	1783	58	the	the	DT
18637	1783	59	former	former	JJ
18637	1783	60	was	be	VBD
18637	1783	61	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	1783	62	upon	upon	IN
18637	1783	63	the	the	DT
18637	1783	64	National	National	NNP
18637	1783	65	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1783	66	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	1783	67	in	in	IN
18637	1783	68	order	order	NN
18637	1783	69	to	to	TO
18637	1783	70	protect	protect	VB
18637	1783	71	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	1783	72	of	of	IN
18637	1783	73	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1783	74	from	from	IN
18637	1783	75	State	State	NNP
18637	1783	76	interference	interference	NN
18637	1783	77	.	.	.
18637	1784	1	The	the	DT
18637	1784	2	four	four	CD
18637	1784	3	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	1784	4	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	1784	5	in	in	IN
18637	1784	6	the	the	DT
18637	1784	7	Lottery	Lottery	NNP
18637	1784	8	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1784	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1784	10	decided	decide	VBN
18637	1784	11	in	in	IN
18637	1784	12	1903	1903	CD
18637	1784	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1784	14	endorsed	endorse	VBD
18637	1784	15	this	this	DT
18637	1784	16	view	view	NN
18637	1784	17	in	in	IN
18637	1784	18	the	the	DT
18637	1784	19	following	follow	VBG
18637	1784	20	words	word	NNS
18637	1784	21	:	:	:
18637	1784	22	"	"	``
18637	1784	23	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1784	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	1784	25	argued	argue	VBN
18637	1784	26	that	that	IN
18637	1784	27	the	the	DT
18637	1784	28	power	power	NN
18637	1784	29	to	to	TO
18637	1784	30	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1784	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1784	32	among	among	IN
18637	1784	33	the	the	DT
18637	1784	34	several	several	JJ
18637	1784	35	States	States	NNP
18637	1784	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	1784	37	the	the	DT
18637	1784	38	same	same	JJ
18637	1784	39	as	as	IN
18637	1784	40	the	the	DT
18637	1784	41	power	power	NN
18637	1784	42	to	to	TO
18637	1784	43	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1784	44	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1784	45	with	with	IN
18637	1784	46	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1784	47	nations	nation	NNS
18637	1784	48	,	,	,
18637	1784	49	and	and	CC
18637	1784	50	among	among	IN
18637	1784	51	the	the	DT
18637	1784	52	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	1784	53	tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	1784	54	.	.	.
18637	1785	1	But	but	CC
18637	1785	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1785	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1785	4	scope	scope	NN
18637	1785	5	the	the	DT
18637	1785	6	same	same	JJ
18637	1785	7	?	?	.
18637	1786	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1786	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1786	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1786	4	,	,	,
18637	1786	5	the	the	DT
18637	1786	6	power	power	NN
18637	1786	7	to	to	TO
18637	1786	8	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1786	9	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1786	10	with	with	IN
18637	1786	11	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1786	12	nations	nation	NNS
18637	1786	13	and	and	CC
18637	1786	14	the	the	DT
18637	1786	15	power	power	NN
18637	1786	16	to	to	TO
18637	1786	17	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1786	18	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1786	19	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1786	20	,	,	,
18637	1786	21	are	be	VBP
18637	1786	22	to	to	TO
18637	1786	23	be	be	VB
18637	1786	24	taken	take	VBN
18637	1786	25	_	_	NNP
18637	1786	26	diverso	diverso	NN
18637	1786	27	intuitu	intuitu	NNP
18637	1786	28	_	_	NNP
18637	1786	29	,	,	,
18637	1786	30	for	for	IN
18637	1786	31	the	the	DT
18637	1786	32	latter	latter	NN
18637	1786	33	was	be	VBD
18637	1786	34	intended	intend	VBN
18637	1786	35	to	to	TO
18637	1786	36	secure	secure	VB
18637	1786	37	equality	equality	NN
18637	1786	38	and	and	CC
18637	1786	39	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	1786	40	in	in	IN
18637	1786	41	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	1786	42	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	1786	43	as	as	IN
18637	1786	44	between	between	IN
18637	1786	45	the	the	DT
18637	1786	46	States	States	NNPS
18637	1786	47	,	,	,
18637	1786	48	not	not	RB
18637	1786	49	to	to	TO
18637	1786	50	permit	permit	VB
18637	1786	51	the	the	DT
18637	1786	52	creation	creation	NN
18637	1786	53	of	of	IN
18637	1786	54	impediments	impediment	NNS
18637	1786	55	to	to	IN
18637	1786	56	such	such	JJ
18637	1786	57	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	1786	58	;	;	:
18637	1786	59	while	while	IN
18637	1786	60	the	the	DT
18637	1786	61	former	former	JJ
18637	1786	62	clothes	clothe	NNS
18637	1786	63	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1786	64	with	with	IN
18637	1786	65	that	that	DT
18637	1786	66	power	power	NN
18637	1786	67	over	over	IN
18637	1786	68	international	international	NNP
18637	1786	69	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1786	70	,	,	,
18637	1786	71	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	1786	72	to	to	IN
18637	1786	73	a	a	DT
18637	1786	74	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	1786	75	nation	nation	NN
18637	1786	76	in	in	IN
18637	1786	77	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1786	78	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	1786	79	with	with	IN
18637	1786	80	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1786	81	nations	nation	NNS
18637	1786	82	,	,	,
18637	1786	83	and	and	CC
18637	1786	84	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1786	85	,	,	,
18637	1786	86	generally	generally	RB
18637	1786	87	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	1786	88	,	,	,
18637	1786	89	to	to	IN
18637	1786	90	no	no	DT
18637	1786	91	implied	implied	JJ
18637	1786	92	or	or	CC
18637	1786	93	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	1786	94	power	power	NN
18637	1786	95	in	in	IN
18637	1786	96	the	the	DT
18637	1786	97	States	States	NNP
18637	1786	98	.	.	.
18637	1787	1	The	the	DT
18637	1787	2	laws	law	NNS
18637	1787	3	which	which	WDT
18637	1787	4	would	would	MD
18637	1787	5	be	be	VB
18637	1787	6	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1787	7	and	and	CC
18637	1787	8	proper	proper	JJ
18637	1787	9	in	in	IN
18637	1787	10	the	the	DT
18637	1787	11	one	one	CD
18637	1787	12	case	case	NN
18637	1787	13	,	,	,
18637	1787	14	would	would	MD
18637	1787	15	not	not	RB
18637	1787	16	be	be	VB
18637	1787	17	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1787	18	or	or	CC
18637	1787	19	proper	proper	JJ
18637	1787	20	in	in	IN
18637	1787	21	the	the	DT
18637	1787	22	other	other	JJ
18637	1787	23	.	.	.
18637	1788	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1788	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1788	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1788	4	But	but	CC
18637	1788	5	that	that	DT
18637	1788	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	1788	7	not	not	RB
18637	1788	8	challenge	challenge	VB
18637	1788	9	the	the	DT
18637	1788	10	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1788	11	power	power	NN
18637	1788	12	of	of	IN
18637	1788	13	a	a	DT
18637	1788	14	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	1788	15	nation	nation	NN
18637	1788	16	to	to	TO
18637	1788	17	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	1788	18	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1788	19	persons	person	NNS
18637	1788	20	or	or	CC
18637	1788	21	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	1788	22	,	,	,
18637	1788	23	or	or	CC
18637	1788	24	place	place	VB
18637	1788	25	an	an	DT
18637	1788	26	embargo	embargo	NN
18637	1788	27	,	,	,
18637	1788	28	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	1788	29	not	not	RB
18637	1788	30	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	1788	31	,	,	,
18637	1788	32	upon	upon	IN
18637	1788	33	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1788	34	ships	ship	NNS
18637	1788	35	or	or	CC
18637	1788	36	manufactures	manufacture	NNS
18637	1788	37	.	.	.
18637	1789	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1789	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1789	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1789	4	The	the	DT
18637	1789	5	same	same	JJ
18637	1789	6	view	view	NN
18637	1789	7	must	must	MD
18637	1789	8	be	be	VB
18637	1789	9	taken	take	VBN
18637	1789	10	as	as	IN
18637	1789	11	to	to	IN
18637	1789	12	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1789	13	with	with	IN
18637	1789	14	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	1789	15	tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	1789	16	.	.	.
18637	1790	1	There	there	EX
18637	1790	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1790	3	no	no	DT
18637	1790	4	reservation	reservation	NN
18637	1790	5	of	of	IN
18637	1790	6	police	police	NN
18637	1790	7	powers	power	NNS
18637	1790	8	or	or	CC
18637	1790	9	any	any	DT
18637	1790	10	other	other	JJ
18637	1790	11	to	to	IN
18637	1790	12	a	a	DT
18637	1790	13	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1790	14	nation	nation	NN
18637	1790	15	or	or	CC
18637	1790	16	to	to	IN
18637	1790	17	an	an	DT
18637	1790	18	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	1790	19	tribe	tribe	NN
18637	1790	20	,	,	,
18637	1790	21	and	and	CC
18637	1790	22	the	the	DT
18637	1790	23	scope	scope	NN
18637	1790	24	of	of	IN
18637	1790	25	the	the	DT
18637	1790	26	power	power	NN
18637	1790	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	1790	28	not	not	RB
18637	1790	29	the	the	DT
18637	1790	30	same	same	JJ
18637	1790	31	as	as	IN
18637	1790	32	that	that	DT
18637	1790	33	over	over	IN
18637	1790	34	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1790	35	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1790	36	.	.	.
18637	1791	1	"	"	``
18637	1791	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1791	3	330	330	CD
18637	1791	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1791	5	And	and	CC
18637	1791	6	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	1791	7	years	year	NNS
18637	1791	8	later	later	RB
18637	1791	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1791	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1791	11	White	White	NNP
18637	1791	12	,	,	,
18637	1791	13	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	1791	14	for	for	IN
18637	1791	15	the	the	DT
18637	1791	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1791	17	,	,	,
18637	1791	18	expressed	express	VBD
18637	1791	19	the	the	DT
18637	1791	20	same	same	JJ
18637	1791	21	view	view	NN
18637	1791	22	,	,	,
18637	1791	23	as	as	IN
18637	1791	24	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	1791	25	:	:	:
18637	1791	26	"	"	``
18637	1791	27	In	in	IN
18637	1791	28	the	the	DT
18637	1791	29	argument	argument	NN
18637	1791	30	reference	reference	NN
18637	1791	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	1791	32	made	make	VBN
18637	1791	33	to	to	IN
18637	1791	34	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	1791	35	of	of	IN
18637	1791	36	this	this	DT
18637	1791	37	court	court	NN
18637	1791	38	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	1791	39	with	with	IN
18637	1791	40	the	the	DT
18637	1791	41	subject	subject	NN
18637	1791	42	of	of	IN
18637	1791	43	the	the	DT
18637	1791	44	power	power	NN
18637	1791	45	of	of	IN
18637	1791	46	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1791	47	to	to	TO
18637	1791	48	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1791	49	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1791	50	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1791	51	,	,	,
18637	1791	52	but	but	CC
18637	1791	53	the	the	DT
18637	1791	54	very	very	JJ
18637	1791	55	postulate	postulate	NN
18637	1791	56	upon	upon	IN
18637	1791	57	which	which	WDT
18637	1791	58	the	the	DT
18637	1791	59	authority	authority	NN
18637	1791	60	of	of	IN
18637	1791	61	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1791	62	to	to	TO
18637	1791	63	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	1791	64	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	1791	65	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1791	66	importations	importation	NNS
18637	1791	67	as	as	IN
18637	1791	68	expounded	expound	VBN
18637	1791	69	by	by	IN
18637	1791	70	the	the	DT
18637	1791	71	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	1791	72	of	of	IN
18637	1791	73	this	this	DT
18637	1791	74	court	court	NN
18637	1791	75	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	1791	76	is	be	VBZ
18637	1791	77	the	the	DT
18637	1791	78	broad	broad	JJ
18637	1791	79	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	1791	80	which	which	WDT
18637	1791	81	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	1791	82	between	between	IN
18637	1791	83	the	the	DT
18637	1791	84	two	two	CD
18637	1791	85	powers	power	NNS
18637	1791	86	and	and	CC
18637	1791	87	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	1791	88	the	the	DT
18637	1791	89	cases	case	NNS
18637	1791	90	cited	cite	VBN
18637	1791	91	and	and	CC
18637	1791	92	many	many	JJ
18637	1791	93	more	more	JJR
18637	1791	94	which	which	WDT
18637	1791	95	might	may	MD
18637	1791	96	be	be	VB
18637	1791	97	cited	cite	VBN
18637	1791	98	announcing	announce	VBG
18637	1791	99	the	the	DT
18637	1791	100	principles	principle	NNS
18637	1791	101	which	which	WDT
18637	1791	102	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1791	103	uphold	uphold	VBP
18637	1791	104	have	have	VBP
18637	1791	105	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	1791	106	no	no	DT
18637	1791	107	relation	relation	NN
18637	1791	108	to	to	IN
18637	1791	109	the	the	DT
18637	1791	110	question	question	NN
18637	1791	111	in	in	IN
18637	1791	112	hand	hand	NN
18637	1791	113	.	.	.
18637	1792	1	"	"	``
18637	1792	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1792	3	331	331	CD
18637	1792	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1792	5	But	but	CC
18637	1792	6	dicta	dicta	NN
18637	1792	7	to	to	IN
18637	1792	8	the	the	DT
18637	1792	9	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	1792	10	are	be	VBP
18637	1792	11	much	much	RB
18637	1792	12	more	more	RBR
18637	1792	13	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	1792	14	and	and	CC
18637	1792	15	span	span	VBP
18637	1792	16	a	a	DT
18637	1792	17	far	far	RB
18637	1792	18	longer	long	JJR
18637	1792	19	period	period	NN
18637	1792	20	of	of	IN
18637	1792	21	time	time	NN
18637	1792	22	.	.	.
18637	1793	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	1793	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1793	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1793	4	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	1793	5	wrote	write	VBD
18637	1793	6	in	in	IN
18637	1793	7	1847	1847	CD
18637	1793	8	:	:	:
18637	1793	9	"	"	``
18637	1793	10	The	the	DT
18637	1793	11	power	power	NN
18637	1793	12	to	to	TO
18637	1793	13	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1793	14	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1793	15	among	among	IN
18637	1793	16	the	the	DT
18637	1793	17	several	several	JJ
18637	1793	18	States	States	NNP
18637	1793	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	1793	20	granted	grant	VBN
18637	1793	21	to	to	IN
18637	1793	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1793	23	in	in	IN
18637	1793	24	the	the	DT
18637	1793	25	same	same	JJ
18637	1793	26	clause	clause	NN
18637	1793	27	,	,	,
18637	1793	28	and	and	CC
18637	1793	29	by	by	IN
18637	1793	30	the	the	DT
18637	1793	31	same	same	JJ
18637	1793	32	words	word	NNS
18637	1793	33	,	,	,
18637	1793	34	as	as	IN
18637	1793	35	the	the	DT
18637	1793	36	power	power	NN
18637	1793	37	to	to	TO
18637	1793	38	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1793	39	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1793	40	with	with	IN
18637	1793	41	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1793	42	nations	nation	NNS
18637	1793	43	,	,	,
18637	1793	44	and	and	CC
18637	1793	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	1793	46	coextensive	coextensive	JJ
18637	1793	47	with	with	IN
18637	1793	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1793	49	.	.	.
18637	1794	1	"	"	``
18637	1794	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1794	3	332	332	CD
18637	1794	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1794	5	And	and	CC
18637	1794	6	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	1794	7	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	1794	8	years	year	NNS
18637	1794	9	later	later	RBR
18637	1794	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1794	11	Field	Field	NNP
18637	1794	12	,	,	,
18637	1794	13	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	1794	14	for	for	IN
18637	1794	15	the	the	DT
18637	1794	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1794	17	,	,	,
18637	1794	18	said	say	VBD
18637	1794	19	:	:	:
18637	1794	20	"	"	``
18637	1794	21	The	the	DT
18637	1794	22	power	power	NN
18637	1794	23	to	to	TO
18637	1794	24	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1794	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1794	26	among	among	IN
18637	1794	27	the	the	DT
18637	1794	28	several	several	JJ
18637	1794	29	States	States	NNP
18637	1794	30	was	be	VBD
18637	1794	31	granted	grant	VBN
18637	1794	32	to	to	IN
18637	1794	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1794	34	in	in	IN
18637	1794	35	terms	term	NNS
18637	1794	36	as	as	RB
18637	1794	37	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	1794	38	as	as	IN
18637	1794	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	1794	40	the	the	DT
18637	1794	41	power	power	NN
18637	1794	42	to	to	TO
18637	1794	43	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1794	44	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1794	45	with	with	IN
18637	1794	46	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1794	47	nations	nation	NNS
18637	1794	48	.	.	.
18637	1795	1	"	"	``
18637	1795	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1795	3	333	333	CD
18637	1795	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1795	5	Today	today	NN
18637	1795	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1795	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	1795	8	firmly	firmly	RB
18637	1795	9	established	establish	VBN
18637	1795	10	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1795	11	that	that	IN
18637	1795	12	the	the	DT
18637	1795	13	power	power	NN
18637	1795	14	to	to	TO
18637	1795	15	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1795	16	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1795	17	,	,	,
18637	1795	18	whether	whether	IN
18637	1795	19	with	with	IN
18637	1795	20	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1795	21	nations	nation	NNS
18637	1795	22	or	or	CC
18637	1795	23	among	among	IN
18637	1795	24	the	the	DT
18637	1795	25	several	several	JJ
18637	1795	26	States	States	NNP
18637	1795	27	comprises	comprise	VBZ
18637	1795	28	the	the	DT
18637	1795	29	power	power	NN
18637	1795	30	to	to	TO
18637	1795	31	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	1795	32	or	or	CC
18637	1795	33	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	1795	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1795	35	at	at	IN
18637	1795	36	all	all	DT
18637	1795	37	times	time	NNS
18637	1795	38	for	for	IN
18637	1795	39	the	the	DT
18637	1795	40	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1795	41	of	of	IN
18637	1795	42	the	the	DT
18637	1795	43	public	public	NN
18637	1795	44	,	,	,
18637	1795	45	provided	provide	VBN
18637	1795	46	only	only	RB
18637	1795	47	the	the	DT
18637	1795	48	specific	specific	JJ
18637	1795	49	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	1795	50	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	1795	51	upon	upon	IN
18637	1795	52	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1795	53	's	's	POS
18637	1795	54	powers	power	NNS
18637	1795	55	,	,	,
18637	1795	56	as	as	IN
18637	1795	57	by	by	IN
18637	1795	58	the	the	DT
18637	1795	59	due	due	JJ
18637	1795	60	process	process	NN
18637	1795	61	clause	clause	NN
18637	1795	62	of	of	IN
18637	1795	63	the	the	DT
18637	1795	64	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	1795	65	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1795	66	,	,	,
18637	1795	67	are	be	VBP
18637	1795	68	not	not	RB
18637	1795	69	transgressed	transgress	VBN
18637	1795	70	.	.	.
18637	1796	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1796	2	334	334	CD
18637	1796	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1796	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	1796	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	1796	6	the	the	DT
18637	1796	7	power	power	NN
18637	1796	8	to	to	TO
18637	1796	9	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1796	10	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1796	11	stop	stop	VB
18637	1796	12	with	with	IN
18637	1796	13	,	,	,
18637	1796	14	nor	nor	CC
18637	1796	15	in	in	IN
18637	1796	16	fact	fact	NN
18637	1796	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	1796	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1796	19	most	most	RBS
18637	1796	20	commonly	commonly	RB
18637	1796	21	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	1796	22	in	in	IN
18637	1796	23	,	,	,
18637	1796	24	measures	measure	NNS
18637	1796	25	designed	design	VBN
18637	1796	26	to	to	TO
18637	1796	27	outlaw	outlaw	VB
18637	1796	28	some	some	DT
18637	1796	29	branch	branch	NN
18637	1796	30	of	of	IN
18637	1796	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1796	32	.	.	.
18637	1797	1	In	in	IN
18637	1797	2	the	the	DT
18637	1797	3	words	word	NNS
18637	1797	4	of	of	IN
18637	1797	5	the	the	DT
18637	1797	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1797	7	:	:	:
18637	1797	8	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1797	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	1797	10	the	the	DT
18637	1797	11	power	power	NN
18637	1797	12	to	to	TO
18637	1797	13	provide	provide	VB
18637	1797	14	by	by	IN
18637	1797	15	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	1797	16	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1797	17	for	for	IN
18637	1797	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1797	19	"	"	``
18637	1797	20	protection	protection	NN
18637	1797	21	and	and	CC
18637	1797	22	advancement";[335	advancement";[335	NNP
18637	1797	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1797	24	to	to	TO
18637	1797	25	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	1797	26	measures	measure	NNS
18637	1797	27	"	"	''
18637	1797	28	to	to	TO
18637	1797	29	promote	promote	VB
18637	1797	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1797	31	growth	growth	NN
18637	1797	32	and	and	CC
18637	1797	33	insure	insure	VB
18637	1797	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1797	35	safety";[336	safety";[336	:
18637	1797	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1797	37	"	"	``
18637	1797	38	to	to	TO
18637	1797	39	foster	foster	VB
18637	1797	40	,	,	,
18637	1797	41	protect	protect	VB
18637	1797	42	,	,	,
18637	1797	43	control	control	NN
18637	1797	44	and	and	CC
18637	1797	45	restrain	restrain	NN
18637	1797	46	,	,	,
18637	1797	47	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1797	48	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1797	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1797	50	.	.	.
18637	1798	1	"	"	``
18637	1798	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1798	3	337	337	CD
18637	1798	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1798	5	This	this	DT
18637	1798	6	protective	protective	JJ
18637	1798	7	power	power	NN
18637	1798	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	1798	9	,	,	,
18637	1798	10	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	1798	11	,	,	,
18637	1798	12	two	two	CD
18637	1798	13	dimensions	dimension	NNS
18637	1798	14	.	.	.
18637	1799	1	In	in	IN
18637	1799	2	the	the	DT
18637	1799	3	first	first	JJ
18637	1799	4	place	place	NN
18637	1799	5	,	,	,
18637	1799	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1799	7	includes	include	VBZ
18637	1799	8	the	the	DT
18637	1799	9	power	power	NN
18637	1799	10	to	to	TO
18637	1799	11	reach	reach	VB
18637	1799	12	and	and	CC
18637	1799	13	remove	remove	VB
18637	1799	14	every	every	DT
18637	1799	15	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
18637	1799	16	obstacle	obstacle	NN
18637	1799	17	to	to	IN
18637	1799	18	or	or	CC
18637	1799	19	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	1799	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	1799	21	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1799	22	and	and	CC
18637	1799	23	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1799	24	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1799	25	from	from	IN
18637	1799	26	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	1799	27	source	source	NN
18637	1799	28	arising	arise	VBG
18637	1799	29	,	,	,
18637	1799	30	whether	whether	IN
18637	1799	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1799	32	results	result	VBZ
18637	1799	33	from	from	IN
18637	1799	34	unfavorable	unfavorable	JJ
18637	1799	35	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	1799	36	within	within	IN
18637	1799	37	the	the	DT
18637	1799	38	States	States	NNPS
18637	1799	39	or	or	CC
18637	1799	40	from	from	IN
18637	1799	41	State	state	NN
18637	1799	42	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1799	43	policy	policy	NN
18637	1799	44	,	,	,
18637	1799	45	like	like	IN
18637	1799	46	the	the	DT
18637	1799	47	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	1799	48	involved	involve	VBN
18637	1799	49	in	in	IN
18637	1799	50	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	1799	51	_	_	NNP
18637	1799	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	1799	53	_	_	NNP
18637	1799	54	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	1799	55	;	;	:
18637	1799	56	or	or	CC
18637	1799	57	from	from	IN
18637	1799	58	both	both	CC
18637	1799	59	combined	combine	VBN
18637	1799	60	.	.	.
18637	1800	1	In	in	IN
18637	1800	2	the	the	DT
18637	1800	3	second	second	JJ
18637	1800	4	place	place	NN
18637	1800	5	,	,	,
18637	1800	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1800	7	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	1800	8	--	--	:
18637	1800	9	as	as	IN
18637	1800	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	1800	11	also	also	RB
18637	1800	12	the	the	DT
18637	1800	13	power	power	NN
18637	1800	14	to	to	TO
18637	1800	15	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	1800	16	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1800	17	--	--	:
18637	1800	18	to	to	IN
18637	1800	19	the	the	DT
18637	1800	20	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	1800	21	and	and	CC
18637	1800	22	agents	agent	NNS
18637	1800	23	by	by	IN
18637	1800	24	which	which	WDT
18637	1800	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1800	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	1800	27	carried	carry	VBN
18637	1800	28	on	on	RB
18637	1800	29	;	;	,
18637	1800	30	nor	nor	CC
18637	1800	31	are	be	VBP
18637	1800	32	such	such	JJ
18637	1800	33	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	1800	34	and	and	CC
18637	1800	35	agents	agent	NNS
18637	1800	36	confined	confine	VBN
18637	1800	37	to	to	IN
18637	1800	38	those	those	DT
18637	1800	39	which	which	WDT
18637	1800	40	were	be	VBD
18637	1800	41	known	know	VBN
18637	1800	42	or	or	CC
18637	1800	43	in	in	IN
18637	1800	44	use	use	NN
18637	1800	45	when	when	WRB
18637	1800	46	the	the	DT
18637	1800	47	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1800	48	was	be	VBD
18637	1800	49	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	1800	50	.	.	.
18637	1801	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1801	2	338	338	CD
18637	1801	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1801	4	INSTRUMENTS	instrument	NNS
18637	1801	5	OF	of	IN
18637	1801	6	COMMERCE	commerce	NN
18637	1801	7	The	the	DT
18637	1801	8	applicability	applicability	NN
18637	1801	9	of	of	IN
18637	1801	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1801	11	's	's	POS
18637	1801	12	power	power	NN
18637	1801	13	to	to	IN
18637	1801	14	the	the	DT
18637	1801	15	agents	agent	NNS
18637	1801	16	and	and	CC
18637	1801	17	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	1801	18	of	of	IN
18637	1801	19	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1801	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	1801	21	implied	imply	VBN
18637	1801	22	in	in	IN
18637	1801	23	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1801	24	's	's	POS
18637	1801	25	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1801	26	in	in	IN
18637	1801	27	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	1801	28	_	_	NNP
18637	1801	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	1801	30	_	_	NNP
18637	1801	31	Ogden,[339	Ogden,[339	NNP
18637	1801	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1801	33	where	where	WRB
18637	1801	34	the	the	DT
18637	1801	35	waters	water	NNS
18637	1801	36	of	of	IN
18637	1801	37	the	the	DT
18637	1801	38	State	State	NNP
18637	1801	39	of	of	IN
18637	1801	40	New	New	NNP
18637	1801	41	York	York	NNP
18637	1801	42	in	in	IN
18637	1801	43	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1801	44	quality	quality	NN
18637	1801	45	as	as	IN
18637	1801	46	highways	highway	NNS
18637	1801	47	of	of	IN
18637	1801	48	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1801	49	and	and	CC
18637	1801	50	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1801	51	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1801	52	are	be	VBP
18637	1801	53	held	hold	VBN
18637	1801	54	to	to	TO
18637	1801	55	be	be	VB
18637	1801	56	governed	govern	VBN
18637	1801	57	by	by	IN
18637	1801	58	the	the	DT
18637	1801	59	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	1801	60	power	power	NN
18637	1801	61	of	of	IN
18637	1801	62	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1801	63	.	.	.
18637	1802	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	1802	2	,	,	,
18637	1802	3	the	the	DT
18637	1802	4	same	same	JJ
18637	1802	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1802	6	recognizes	recognize	VBZ
18637	1802	7	that	that	IN
18637	1802	8	in	in	IN
18637	1802	9	"	"	``
18637	1802	10	the	the	DT
18637	1802	11	progress	progress	NN
18637	1802	12	of	of	IN
18637	1802	13	things	thing	NNS
18637	1802	14	,	,	,
18637	1802	15	"	"	''
18637	1802	16	new	new	JJ
18637	1802	17	and	and	CC
18637	1802	18	other	other	JJ
18637	1802	19	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	1802	20	of	of	IN
18637	1802	21	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1802	22	will	will	MD
18637	1802	23	make	make	VB
18637	1802	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1802	25	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	1802	26	.	.	.
18637	1803	1	When	when	WRB
18637	1803	2	the	the	DT
18637	1803	3	Licensing	Licensing	NNP
18637	1803	4	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1803	5	of	of	IN
18637	1803	6	1793	1793	CD
18637	1803	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1803	8	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1803	9	,	,	,
18637	1803	10	the	the	DT
18637	1803	11	only	only	JJ
18637	1803	12	craft	craft	NN
18637	1803	13	to	to	TO
18637	1803	14	which	which	WDT
18637	1803	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1803	16	could	could	MD
18637	1803	17	apply	apply	VB
18637	1803	18	were	be	VBD
18637	1803	19	sailing	sailing	NN
18637	1803	20	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	1803	21	,	,	,
18637	1803	22	but	but	CC
18637	1803	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1803	24	and	and	CC
18637	1803	25	the	the	DT
18637	1803	26	power	power	NN
18637	1803	27	by	by	IN
18637	1803	28	which	which	WDT
18637	1803	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1803	30	was	be	VBD
18637	1803	31	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	1803	32	were	be	VBD
18637	1803	33	,	,	,
18637	1803	34	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	1803	35	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	1803	36	,	,	,
18637	1803	37	indifferent	indifferent	JJ
18637	1803	38	to	to	IN
18637	1803	39	the	the	DT
18637	1803	40	"	"	``
18637	1803	41	principle	principle	NN
18637	1803	42	"	"	''
18637	1803	43	by	by	IN
18637	1803	44	which	which	WDT
18637	1803	45	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	1803	46	were	be	VBD
18637	1803	47	moved	move	VBN
18637	1803	48	.	.	.
18637	1804	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1804	2	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	1804	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	1804	4	reached	reach	VBD
18637	1804	5	steam	steam	NN
18637	1804	6	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	1804	7	as	as	RB
18637	1804	8	well	well	RB
18637	1804	9	.	.	.
18637	1805	1	A	a	DT
18637	1805	2	little	little	JJ
18637	1805	3	over	over	IN
18637	1805	4	half	half	PDT
18637	1805	5	a	a	DT
18637	1805	6	century	century	NN
18637	1805	7	later	later	RBR
18637	1805	8	the	the	DT
18637	1805	9	principle	principle	NN
18637	1805	10	embodied	embody	VBD
18637	1805	11	in	in	IN
18637	1805	12	this	this	DT
18637	1805	13	holding	holding	NN
18637	1805	14	was	be	VBD
18637	1805	15	given	give	VBN
18637	1805	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1805	17	classic	classic	JJ
18637	1805	18	expression	expression	NN
18637	1805	19	in	in	IN
18637	1805	20	the	the	DT
18637	1805	21	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1805	22	of	of	IN
18637	1805	23	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1805	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1805	25	Waite	Waite	NNP
18637	1805	26	in	in	IN
18637	1805	27	the	the	DT
18637	1805	28	case	case	NN
18637	1805	29	of	of	IN
18637	1805	30	the	the	DT
18637	1805	31	Pensacola	Pensacola	NNP
18637	1805	32	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	1805	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	1805	34	_	_	NNP
18637	1805	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	1805	36	_	_	NNP
18637	1805	37	Western	Western	NNP
18637	1805	38	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1805	39	Co	Co	NNP
18637	1805	40	.	.	.
18637	1805	41	,[340	,[340	NFP
18637	1805	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1805	43	a	a	DT
18637	1805	44	case	case	NN
18637	1805	45	closely	closely	RB
18637	1805	46	paralleling	parallel	VBG
18637	1805	47	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	1805	48	_	_	NNP
18637	1805	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	1805	50	_	_	NNP
18637	1805	51	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	1805	52	in	in	IN
18637	1805	53	other	other	JJ
18637	1805	54	respects	respect	NNS
18637	1805	55	also	also	RB
18637	1805	56	.	.	.
18637	1806	1	The	the	DT
18637	1806	2	passage	passage	NN
18637	1806	3	alluded	allude	VBD
18637	1806	4	to	to	IN
18637	1806	5	reads	read	NNS
18637	1806	6	as	as	IN
18637	1806	7	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	1806	8	:	:	:
18637	1806	9	"	"	``
18637	1806	10	The	the	DT
18637	1806	11	powers	power	NNS
18637	1806	12	thus	thus	RB
18637	1806	13	granted	grant	VBN
18637	1806	14	are	be	VBP
18637	1806	15	not	not	RB
18637	1806	16	confined	confine	VBN
18637	1806	17	to	to	IN
18637	1806	18	the	the	DT
18637	1806	19	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	1806	20	of	of	IN
18637	1806	21	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1806	22	,	,	,
18637	1806	23	or	or	CC
18637	1806	24	the	the	DT
18637	1806	25	postal	postal	JJ
18637	1806	26	service	service	NN
18637	1806	27	known	know	VBN
18637	1806	28	or	or	CC
18637	1806	29	in	in	IN
18637	1806	30	use	use	NN
18637	1806	31	when	when	WRB
18637	1806	32	the	the	DT
18637	1806	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1806	34	was	be	VBD
18637	1806	35	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	1806	36	,	,	,
18637	1806	37	but	but	CC
18637	1806	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1806	39	keep	keep	VBP
18637	1806	40	pace	pace	NN
18637	1806	41	with	with	IN
18637	1806	42	the	the	DT
18637	1806	43	progress	progress	NN
18637	1806	44	of	of	IN
18637	1806	45	the	the	DT
18637	1806	46	country	country	NN
18637	1806	47	,	,	,
18637	1806	48	and	and	CC
18637	1806	49	adapt	adapt	VB
18637	1806	50	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1806	51	to	to	IN
18637	1806	52	the	the	DT
18637	1806	53	new	new	JJ
18637	1806	54	developments	development	NNS
18637	1806	55	of	of	IN
18637	1806	56	times	time	NNS
18637	1806	57	and	and	CC
18637	1806	58	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	1806	59	.	.	.
18637	1807	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1807	2	extend	extend	VBP
18637	1807	3	from	from	IN
18637	1807	4	the	the	DT
18637	1807	5	horse	horse	NN
18637	1807	6	with	with	IN
18637	1807	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1807	8	rider	rider	NN
18637	1807	9	to	to	IN
18637	1807	10	the	the	DT
18637	1807	11	stage	stage	NN
18637	1807	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	1807	13	coach	coach	NN
18637	1807	14	,	,	,
18637	1807	15	from	from	IN
18637	1807	16	the	the	DT
18637	1807	17	sailing	sailing	NN
18637	1807	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	1807	19	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	1807	20	to	to	IN
18637	1807	21	the	the	DT
18637	1807	22	steamboat	steamboat	NN
18637	1807	23	,	,	,
18637	1807	24	from	from	IN
18637	1807	25	the	the	DT
18637	1807	26	coach	coach	NN
18637	1807	27	and	and	CC
18637	1807	28	the	the	DT
18637	1807	29	steamboat	steamboat	NN
18637	1807	30	to	to	IN
18637	1807	31	the	the	DT
18637	1807	32	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	1807	33	,	,	,
18637	1807	34	and	and	CC
18637	1807	35	from	from	IN
18637	1807	36	the	the	DT
18637	1807	37	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	1807	38	to	to	IN
18637	1807	39	the	the	DT
18637	1807	40	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	1807	41	,	,	,
18637	1807	42	as	as	IN
18637	1807	43	these	these	DT
18637	1807	44	new	new	JJ
18637	1807	45	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	1807	46	are	be	VBP
18637	1807	47	successively	successively	RB
18637	1807	48	brought	bring	VBN
18637	1807	49	into	into	IN
18637	1807	50	use	use	NN
18637	1807	51	to	to	TO
18637	1807	52	meet	meet	VB
18637	1807	53	the	the	DT
18637	1807	54	demands	demand	NNS
18637	1807	55	of	of	IN
18637	1807	56	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	1807	57	population	population	NN
18637	1807	58	and	and	CC
18637	1807	59	wealth	wealth	NN
18637	1807	60	.	.	.
18637	1808	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1808	2	were	be	VBD
18637	1808	3	intended	intend	VBN
18637	1808	4	for	for	IN
18637	1808	5	the	the	DT
18637	1808	6	government	government	NN
18637	1808	7	of	of	IN
18637	1808	8	the	the	DT
18637	1808	9	business	business	NN
18637	1808	10	to	to	TO
18637	1808	11	which	which	WDT
18637	1808	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1808	13	relate	relate	VBP
18637	1808	14	,	,	,
18637	1808	15	at	at	IN
18637	1808	16	all	all	DT
18637	1808	17	times	time	NNS
18637	1808	18	and	and	CC
18637	1808	19	under	under	IN
18637	1808	20	all	all	DT
18637	1808	21	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	1808	22	.	.	.
18637	1809	1	As	as	IN
18637	1809	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1809	3	were	be	VBD
18637	1809	4	intrusted	intrust	VBN
18637	1809	5	to	to	IN
18637	1809	6	the	the	DT
18637	1809	7	general	general	JJ
18637	1809	8	government	government	NN
18637	1809	9	for	for	IN
18637	1809	10	the	the	DT
18637	1809	11	good	good	NN
18637	1809	12	of	of	IN
18637	1809	13	the	the	DT
18637	1809	14	nation	nation	NN
18637	1809	15	,	,	,
18637	1809	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1809	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	1809	18	not	not	RB
18637	1809	19	only	only	RB
18637	1809	20	the	the	DT
18637	1809	21	right	right	NN
18637	1809	22	,	,	,
18637	1809	23	but	but	CC
18637	1809	24	the	the	DT
18637	1809	25	duty	duty	NN
18637	1809	26	,	,	,
18637	1809	27	of	of	IN
18637	1809	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1809	29	to	to	TO
18637	1809	30	see	see	VB
18637	1809	31	to	to	IN
18637	1809	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1809	33	that	that	DT
18637	1809	34	intercourse	intercourse	VBP
18637	1809	35	among	among	IN
18637	1809	36	the	the	DT
18637	1809	37	States	States	NNP
18637	1809	38	and	and	CC
18637	1809	39	the	the	DT
18637	1809	40	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	1809	41	of	of	IN
18637	1809	42	intelligence	intelligence	NN
18637	1809	43	are	be	VBP
18637	1809	44	not	not	RB
18637	1809	45	obstructed	obstruct	VBN
18637	1809	46	or	or	CC
18637	1809	47	unnecessarily	unnecessarily	RB
18637	1809	48	encumbered	encumber	VBN
18637	1809	49	by	by	IN
18637	1809	50	State	State	NNP
18637	1809	51	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1809	52	.	.	.
18637	1810	1	"	"	``
18637	1810	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1810	3	341	341	CD
18637	1810	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1810	5	The	The	NNP
18637	1810	6	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	1810	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1810	8	of	of	IN
18637	1810	9	1927	1927	CD
18637	1810	10	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	1810	11	"	"	``
18637	1810	12	all	all	DT
18637	1810	13	forms	form	NNS
18637	1810	14	of	of	IN
18637	1810	15	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1810	16	and	and	CC
18637	1810	17	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1810	18	radio	radio	NN
18637	1810	19	transmissions	transmission	NNS
18637	1810	20	within	within	IN
18637	1810	21	the	the	DT
18637	1810	22	United	United	NNP
18637	1810	23	States	States	NNP
18637	1810	24	,	,	,
18637	1810	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1810	26	Territories	Territories	NNPS
18637	1810	27	and	and	CC
18637	1810	28	possessions	possession	NNS
18637	1810	29	"	"	''
18637	1810	30	were	be	VBD
18637	1810	31	brought	bring	VBN
18637	1810	32	under	under	IN
18637	1810	33	national	national	JJ
18637	1810	34	control	control	NN
18637	1810	35	,	,	,
18637	1810	36	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	1810	37	another	another	DT
18637	1810	38	illustration	illustration	NN
18637	1810	39	.	.	.
18637	1811	1	Thanks	thank	NNS
18637	1811	2	to	to	IN
18637	1811	3	the	the	DT
18637	1811	4	foregoing	foregoing	NN
18637	1811	5	doctrine	doctrine	VB
18637	1811	6	the	the	DT
18637	1811	7	measure	measure	NN
18637	1811	8	met	meet	VBD
18637	1811	9	no	no	DT
18637	1811	10	serious	serious	JJ
18637	1811	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1811	12	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	1811	13	either	either	CC
18637	1811	14	on	on	IN
18637	1811	15	the	the	DT
18637	1811	16	floors	floor	NNS
18637	1811	17	of	of	IN
18637	1811	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1811	19	or	or	CC
18637	1811	20	in	in	IN
18637	1811	21	the	the	DT
18637	1811	22	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	1811	23	.	.	.
18637	1812	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1812	2	342	342	CD
18637	1812	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1812	4	Congressional	Congressional	NNP
18637	1812	5	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	1812	6	of	of	IN
18637	1812	7	Waterways	Waterways	NNP
18637	1812	8	NAVIGATION	NAVIGATION	NNP
18637	1812	9	In	in	IN
18637	1812	10	the	the	DT
18637	1812	11	case	case	NN
18637	1812	12	of	of	IN
18637	1812	13	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	1812	14	_	_	NNP
18637	1812	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	1812	16	_	_	NNP
18637	1812	17	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	1812	18	&	&	CC
18637	1812	19	Belmont	Belmont	NNP
18637	1812	20	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	1812	21	Co	Co	NNP
18637	1812	22	.	.	.
18637	1812	23	,[343	,[343	NFP
18637	1812	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1812	25	decided	decide	VBN
18637	1812	26	in	in	IN
18637	1812	27	1852	1852	CD
18637	1812	28	,	,	,
18637	1812	29	the	the	DT
18637	1812	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1812	31	,	,	,
18637	1812	32	on	on	IN
18637	1812	33	the	the	DT
18637	1812	34	application	application	NN
18637	1812	35	of	of	IN
18637	1812	36	the	the	DT
18637	1812	37	complaining	complain	VBG
18637	1812	38	State	State	NNP
18637	1812	39	,	,	,
18637	1812	40	acting	act	VBG
18637	1812	41	as	as	IN
18637	1812	42	representative	representative	NN
18637	1812	43	of	of	IN
18637	1812	44	the	the	DT
18637	1812	45	interests	interest	NNS
18637	1812	46	of	of	IN
18637	1812	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1812	48	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	1812	49	,	,	,
18637	1812	50	granted	grant	VBD
18637	1812	51	an	an	DT
18637	1812	52	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	1812	53	requiring	require	VBG
18637	1812	54	that	that	IN
18637	1812	55	a	a	DT
18637	1812	56	bridge	bridge	NN
18637	1812	57	,	,	,
18637	1812	58	erected	erect	VBN
18637	1812	59	over	over	IN
18637	1812	60	the	the	DT
18637	1812	61	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1812	62	under	under	IN
18637	1812	63	a	a	DT
18637	1812	64	charter	charter	NN
18637	1812	65	from	from	IN
18637	1812	66	the	the	DT
18637	1812	67	State	State	NNP
18637	1812	68	of	of	IN
18637	1812	69	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1812	70	,	,	,
18637	1812	71	either	either	CC
18637	1812	72	be	be	VB
18637	1812	73	altered	alter	VBN
18637	1812	74	so	so	IN
18637	1812	75	as	as	IN
18637	1812	76	to	to	TO
18637	1812	77	admit	admit	VB
18637	1812	78	of	of	IN
18637	1812	79	free	free	JJ
18637	1812	80	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1812	81	of	of	IN
18637	1812	82	the	the	DT
18637	1812	83	river	river	NN
18637	1812	84	,	,	,
18637	1812	85	or	or	CC
18637	1812	86	else	else	RB
18637	1812	87	be	be	VB
18637	1812	88	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	1812	89	abated	abate	VBN
18637	1812	90	.	.	.
18637	1813	1	The	the	DT
18637	1813	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	1813	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1813	4	justified	justify	VBN
18637	1813	5	by	by	IN
18637	1813	6	the	the	DT
18637	1813	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1813	8	on	on	IN
18637	1813	9	the	the	DT
18637	1813	10	basis	basis	NN
18637	1813	11	both	both	DT
18637	1813	12	of	of	IN
18637	1813	13	the	the	DT
18637	1813	14	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1813	15	clause	clause	NNP
18637	1813	16	and	and	CC
18637	1813	17	of	of	IN
18637	1813	18	a	a	DT
18637	1813	19	compact	compact	NN
18637	1813	20	between	between	IN
18637	1813	21	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	1813	22	and	and	CC
18637	1813	23	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	1813	24	,	,	,
18637	1813	25	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	1813	26	both	both	PDT
18637	1813	27	these	these	DT
18637	1813	28	States	state	NNS
18637	1813	29	had	have	VBD
18637	1813	30	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	1813	31	to	to	TO
18637	1813	32	keep	keep	VB
18637	1813	33	the	the	DT
18637	1813	34	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1813	35	River	River	NNP
18637	1813	36	"	"	''
18637	1813	37	free	free	JJ
18637	1813	38	and	and	CC
18637	1813	39	common	common	JJ
18637	1813	40	to	to	IN
18637	1813	41	the	the	DT
18637	1813	42	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	1813	43	of	of	IN
18637	1813	44	the	the	DT
18637	1813	45	United	United	NNP
18637	1813	46	States	States	NNP
18637	1813	47	.	.	.
18637	1813	48	"	"	''
18637	1814	1	The	the	DT
18637	1814	2	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	1814	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1814	4	promptly	promptly	RB
18637	1814	5	rendered	render	VBN
18637	1814	6	inoperative	inoperative	JJ
18637	1814	7	by	by	IN
18637	1814	8	an	an	DT
18637	1814	9	act	act	NN
18637	1814	10	of	of	IN
18637	1814	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1814	12	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	1814	13	the	the	DT
18637	1814	14	bridge	bridge	NN
18637	1814	15	to	to	TO
18637	1814	16	be	be	VB
18637	1814	17	"	"	``
18637	1814	18	a	a	DT
18637	1814	19	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	1814	20	structure	structure	NN
18637	1814	21	"	"	''
18637	1814	22	and	and	CC
18637	1814	23	requiring	require	VBG
18637	1814	24	all	all	DT
18637	1814	25	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	1814	26	navigating	navigate	VBG
18637	1814	27	the	the	DT
18637	1814	28	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	1814	29	to	to	TO
18637	1814	30	be	be	VB
18637	1814	31	so	so	RB
18637	1814	32	regulated	regulated	JJ
18637	1814	33	as	as	IN
18637	1814	34	not	not	RB
18637	1814	35	to	to	TO
18637	1814	36	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	1814	37	with	with	IN
18637	1814	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1814	39	.	.	.
18637	1815	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1815	2	344	344	CD
18637	1815	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1815	4	This	this	DT
18637	1815	5	act	act	NN
18637	1815	6	the	the	DT
18637	1815	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1815	8	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1815	9	as	as	IN
18637	1815	10	within	within	IN
18637	1815	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1815	12	's	's	POS
18637	1815	13	power	power	NN
18637	1815	14	under	under	IN
18637	1815	15	the	the	DT
18637	1815	16	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1815	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	1815	18	,	,	,
18637	1815	19	saying	say	VBG
18637	1815	20	:	:	:
18637	1815	21	"	"	``
18637	1815	22	So	so	RB
18637	1815	23	far	far	RB
18637	1815	24	,	,	,
18637	1815	25	*	*	NFP
18637	1815	26	*	*	NFP
18637	1815	27	*	*	NFP
18637	1815	28	,	,	,
18637	1815	29	as	as	IN
18637	1815	30	this	this	DT
18637	1815	31	bridge	bridge	NN
18637	1815	32	created	create	VBD
18637	1815	33	an	an	DT
18637	1815	34	obstruction	obstruction	NN
18637	1815	35	to	to	IN
18637	1815	36	the	the	DT
18637	1815	37	free	free	JJ
18637	1815	38	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1815	39	of	of	IN
18637	1815	40	the	the	DT
18637	1815	41	river	river	NN
18637	1815	42	,	,	,
18637	1815	43	in	in	IN
18637	1815	44	view	view	NN
18637	1815	45	of	of	IN
18637	1815	46	the	the	DT
18637	1815	47	previous	previous	JJ
18637	1815	48	acts	act	NNS
18637	1815	49	of	of	IN
18637	1815	50	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1815	51	,	,	,
18637	1815	52	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1815	53	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1815	54	the	the	DT
18637	1815	55	said	say	VBN
18637	1815	56	acts	act	NNS
18637	1815	57	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1815	58	are	be	VBP
18637	1815	59	to	to	TO
18637	1815	60	be	be	VB
18637	1815	61	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	1815	62	as	as	IN
18637	1815	63	modified	modify	VBN
18637	1815	64	by	by	IN
18637	1815	65	this	this	DT
18637	1815	66	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	1815	67	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1815	68	;	;	:
18637	1815	69	and	and	CC
18637	1815	70	,	,	,
18637	1815	71	although	although	IN
18637	1815	72	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1815	73	still	still	RB
18637	1815	74	may	may	MD
18637	1815	75	be	be	VB
18637	1815	76	an	an	DT
18637	1815	77	obstruction	obstruction	NN
18637	1815	78	in	in	IN
18637	1815	79	fact	fact	NN
18637	1815	80	,	,	,
18637	1815	81	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1815	82	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1815	83	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1815	84	is	be	VBZ
18637	1815	85	not	not	RB
18637	1815	86	so	so	RB
18637	1815	87	in	in	IN
18637	1815	88	the	the	DT
18637	1815	89	contemplation	contemplation	NN
18637	1815	90	of	of	IN
18637	1815	91	law	law	NN
18637	1815	92	.	.	.
18637	1816	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1816	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1816	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1816	4	That	that	DT
18637	1816	5	body	body	NN
18637	1816	6	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1816	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1816	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1816	9	having	have	VBG
18637	1816	10	in	in	IN
18637	1816	11	the	the	DT
18637	1816	12	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1816	13	of	of	IN
18637	1816	14	this	this	DT
18637	1816	15	power	power	NN
18637	1816	16	,	,	,
18637	1816	17	regulated	regulate	VBD
18637	1816	18	the	the	DT
18637	1816	19	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1816	20	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	1816	21	with	with	IN
18637	1816	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1816	23	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	1816	24	and	and	CC
18637	1816	25	continuation	continuation	NN
18637	1816	26	,	,	,
18637	1816	27	the	the	DT
18637	1816	28	authority	authority	NN
18637	1816	29	to	to	TO
18637	1816	30	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	1816	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1816	32	would	would	MD
18637	1816	33	seem	seem	VB
18637	1816	34	to	to	TO
18637	1816	35	be	be	VB
18637	1816	36	complete	complete	JJ
18637	1816	37	.	.	.
18637	1817	1	That	that	DT
18637	1817	2	authority	authority	NN
18637	1817	3	combines	combine	VBZ
18637	1817	4	the	the	DT
18637	1817	5	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	1817	6	powers	power	NNS
18637	1817	7	of	of	IN
18637	1817	8	both	both	DT
18637	1817	9	governments	government	NNS
18637	1817	10	,	,	,
18637	1817	11	State	State	NNP
18637	1817	12	and	and	CC
18637	1817	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1817	14	,	,	,
18637	1817	15	which	which	WDT
18637	1817	16	,	,	,
18637	1817	17	if	if	IN
18637	1817	18	not	not	RB
18637	1817	19	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	1817	20	,	,	,
18637	1817	21	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	1817	22	none	none	NN
18637	1817	23	can	can	MD
18637	1817	24	be	be	VB
18637	1817	25	found	find	VBN
18637	1817	26	in	in	IN
18637	1817	27	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1817	28	system	system	NN
18637	1817	29	of	of	IN
18637	1817	30	government	government	NN
18637	1817	31	.	.	.
18637	1818	1	"	"	``
18637	1818	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1818	3	345	345	CD
18637	1818	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1818	5	In	in	IN
18637	1818	6	short	short	JJ
18637	1818	7	,	,	,
18637	1818	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1818	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	1818	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1818	11	and	and	CC
18637	1818	12	not	not	RB
18637	1818	13	the	the	DT
18637	1818	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1818	15	which	which	WDT
18637	1818	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	1818	17	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	1818	18	by	by	IN
18637	1818	19	the	the	DT
18637	1818	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1818	21	to	to	TO
18637	1818	22	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1818	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1818	24	.	.	.
18637	1819	1	The	the	DT
18637	1819	2	law	law	NN
18637	1819	3	and	and	CC
18637	1819	4	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1819	5	of	of	IN
18637	1819	6	the	the	DT
18637	1819	7	earlier	early	JJR
18637	1819	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	1819	9	with	with	IN
18637	1819	10	respect	respect	NN
18637	1819	11	to	to	IN
18637	1819	12	the	the	DT
18637	1819	13	fostering	fostering	NN
18637	1819	14	and	and	CC
18637	1819	15	protection	protection	NN
18637	1819	16	of	of	IN
18637	1819	17	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1819	18	are	be	VBP
18637	1819	19	well	well	RB
18637	1819	20	summed	sum	VBN
18637	1819	21	up	up	RP
18637	1819	22	in	in	IN
18637	1819	23	the	the	DT
18637	1819	24	following	follow	VBG
18637	1819	25	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	1819	26	cited	cite	VBN
18637	1819	27	passage	passage	NN
18637	1819	28	from	from	IN
18637	1819	29	the	the	DT
18637	1819	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1819	31	's	's	POS
18637	1819	32	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1819	33	in	in	IN
18637	1819	34	Gilman	Gilman	NNP
18637	1819	35	_	_	NNP
18637	1819	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	1819	37	_	_	NNP
18637	1819	38	Philadelphia,[346	Philadelphia,[346	NNP
18637	1819	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1819	40	decided	decide	VBD
18637	1819	41	in	in	IN
18637	1819	42	1866	1866	CD
18637	1819	43	.	.	.
18637	1820	1	"	"	``
18637	1820	2	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1820	3	includes	include	VBZ
18637	1820	4	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1820	5	.	.	.
18637	1821	1	The	the	DT
18637	1821	2	power	power	NN
18637	1821	3	to	to	TO
18637	1821	4	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1821	5	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1821	6	comprehends	comprehend	VBZ
18637	1821	7	the	the	DT
18637	1821	8	control	control	NN
18637	1821	9	for	for	IN
18637	1821	10	that	that	DT
18637	1821	11	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1821	12	,	,	,
18637	1821	13	and	and	CC
18637	1821	14	to	to	IN
18637	1821	15	the	the	DT
18637	1821	16	extent	extent	NN
18637	1821	17	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1821	18	,	,	,
18637	1821	19	of	of	IN
18637	1821	20	all	all	PDT
18637	1821	21	the	the	DT
18637	1821	22	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1821	23	waters	water	NNS
18637	1821	24	of	of	IN
18637	1821	25	the	the	DT
18637	1821	26	United	United	NNP
18637	1821	27	States	States	NNP
18637	1821	28	which	which	WDT
18637	1821	29	are	be	VBP
18637	1821	30	accessible	accessible	JJ
18637	1821	31	from	from	IN
18637	1821	32	a	a	DT
18637	1821	33	State	state	NN
18637	1821	34	other	other	JJ
18637	1821	35	than	than	IN
18637	1821	36	those	those	DT
18637	1821	37	in	in	IN
18637	1821	38	which	which	WDT
18637	1821	39	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1821	40	lie	lie	VBP
18637	1821	41	.	.	.
18637	1822	1	For	for	IN
18637	1822	2	this	this	DT
18637	1822	3	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1822	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1822	5	are	be	VBP
18637	1822	6	the	the	DT
18637	1822	7	public	public	JJ
18637	1822	8	property	property	NN
18637	1822	9	of	of	IN
18637	1822	10	the	the	DT
18637	1822	11	nation	nation	NN
18637	1822	12	,	,	,
18637	1822	13	and	and	CC
18637	1822	14	subject	subject	VB
18637	1822	15	to	to	IN
18637	1822	16	all	all	DT
18637	1822	17	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	1822	18	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1822	19	by	by	IN
18637	1822	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1822	21	.	.	.
18637	1823	1	This	this	DT
18637	1823	2	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	1823	3	includes	include	VBZ
18637	1823	4	the	the	DT
18637	1823	5	power	power	NN
18637	1823	6	to	to	TO
18637	1823	7	keep	keep	VB
18637	1823	8	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1823	9	open	open	JJ
18637	1823	10	and	and	CC
18637	1823	11	free	free	JJ
18637	1823	12	from	from	IN
18637	1823	13	any	any	DT
18637	1823	14	obstruction	obstruction	NN
18637	1823	15	to	to	IN
18637	1823	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1823	17	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1823	18	,	,	,
18637	1823	19	interposed	interpose	VBN
18637	1823	20	by	by	IN
18637	1823	21	the	the	DT
18637	1823	22	States	States	NNPS
18637	1823	23	or	or	CC
18637	1823	24	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	1823	25	;	;	:
18637	1823	26	to	to	TO
18637	1823	27	remove	remove	VB
18637	1823	28	such	such	JJ
18637	1823	29	obstructions	obstruction	NNS
18637	1823	30	when	when	WRB
18637	1823	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1823	32	exist	exist	VBP
18637	1823	33	;	;	:
18637	1823	34	and	and	CC
18637	1823	35	to	to	TO
18637	1823	36	provide	provide	VB
18637	1823	37	,	,	,
18637	1823	38	by	by	IN
18637	1823	39	such	such	JJ
18637	1823	40	sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	1823	41	as	as	IN
18637	1823	42	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1823	43	may	may	MD
18637	1823	44	deem	deem	VB
18637	1823	45	proper	proper	JJ
18637	1823	46	,	,	,
18637	1823	47	against	against	IN
18637	1823	48	the	the	DT
18637	1823	49	occurrence	occurrence	NN
18637	1823	50	of	of	IN
18637	1823	51	the	the	DT
18637	1823	52	evil	evil	NN
18637	1823	53	and	and	CC
18637	1823	54	for	for	IN
18637	1823	55	the	the	DT
18637	1823	56	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	1823	57	of	of	IN
18637	1823	58	offenders	offender	NNS
18637	1823	59	.	.	.
18637	1824	1	For	for	IN
18637	1824	2	these	these	DT
18637	1824	3	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	1824	4	,	,	,
18637	1824	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1824	6	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	1824	7	all	all	PDT
18637	1824	8	the	the	DT
18637	1824	9	powers	power	NNS
18637	1824	10	which	which	WDT
18637	1824	11	existed	exist	VBD
18637	1824	12	in	in	IN
18637	1824	13	the	the	DT
18637	1824	14	States	States	NNP
18637	1824	15	before	before	IN
18637	1824	16	the	the	DT
18637	1824	17	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	1824	18	of	of	IN
18637	1824	19	the	the	DT
18637	1824	20	national	national	JJ
18637	1824	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1824	22	,	,	,
18637	1824	23	and	and	CC
18637	1824	24	which	which	WDT
18637	1824	25	have	have	VBP
18637	1824	26	always	always	RB
18637	1824	27	existed	exist	VBN
18637	1824	28	in	in	IN
18637	1824	29	the	the	DT
18637	1824	30	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
18637	1824	31	in	in	IN
18637	1824	32	England	England	NNP
18637	1824	33	.	.	.
18637	1825	1	"	"	``
18637	1825	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1825	3	347	347	CD
18637	1825	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1825	5	Thus	thus	RB
18637	1825	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1825	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1825	8	within	within	IN
18637	1825	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1825	10	powers	power	NNS
18637	1825	11	in	in	IN
18637	1825	12	vesting	vest	VBG
18637	1825	13	the	the	DT
18637	1825	14	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	1825	15	of	of	IN
18637	1825	16	War	War	NNP
18637	1825	17	with	with	IN
18637	1825	18	power	power	NN
18637	1825	19	to	to	TO
18637	1825	20	determine	determine	VB
18637	1825	21	whether	whether	IN
18637	1825	22	a	a	DT
18637	1825	23	structure	structure	NN
18637	1825	24	of	of	IN
18637	1825	25	any	any	DT
18637	1825	26	nature	nature	NN
18637	1825	27	in	in	IN
18637	1825	28	or	or	CC
18637	1825	29	over	over	IN
18637	1825	30	a	a	DT
18637	1825	31	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1825	32	stream	stream	NN
18637	1825	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	1825	34	an	an	DT
18637	1825	35	obstruction	obstruction	NN
18637	1825	36	to	to	IN
18637	1825	37	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1825	38	and	and	CC
18637	1825	39	to	to	TO
18637	1825	40	order	order	VB
18637	1825	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1825	42	abatement	abatement	NN
18637	1825	43	if	if	IN
18637	1825	44	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1825	45	so	so	RB
18637	1825	46	finds	find	VBZ
18637	1825	47	.	.	.
18637	1826	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1826	2	348	348	CD
18637	1826	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1826	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	1826	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	1826	6	the	the	DT
18637	1826	7	United	United	NNP
18637	1826	8	States	States	NNP
18637	1826	9	required	require	VBD
18637	1826	10	to	to	TO
18637	1826	11	compensate	compensate	VB
18637	1826	12	the	the	DT
18637	1826	13	owners	owner	NNS
18637	1826	14	of	of	IN
18637	1826	15	such	such	JJ
18637	1826	16	structures	structure	NNS
18637	1826	17	for	for	IN
18637	1826	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1826	19	loss	loss	NN
18637	1826	20	,	,	,
18637	1826	21	since	since	IN
18637	1826	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1826	23	were	be	VBD
18637	1826	24	always	always	RB
18637	1826	25	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1826	26	to	to	IN
18637	1826	27	the	the	DT
18637	1826	28	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	1826	29	represented	represent	VBN
18637	1826	30	by	by	IN
18637	1826	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1826	32	's	's	POS
18637	1826	33	powers	power	NNS
18637	1826	34	over	over	IN
18637	1826	35	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1826	36	;	;	:
18637	1826	37	and	and	CC
18637	1826	38	the	the	DT
18637	1826	39	same	same	JJ
18637	1826	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	1826	41	true	true	JJ
18637	1826	42	of	of	IN
18637	1826	43	the	the	DT
18637	1826	44	property	property	NN
18637	1826	45	of	of	IN
18637	1826	46	riparian	riparian	JJ
18637	1826	47	owners	owner	NNS
18637	1826	48	which	which	WDT
18637	1826	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	1826	50	damaged	damage	VBN
18637	1826	51	.	.	.
18637	1827	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1827	2	349	349	CD
18637	1827	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1827	4	And	and	CC
18637	1827	5	while	while	IN
18637	1827	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1827	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1827	8	formerly	formerly	RB
18637	1827	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	1827	10	that	that	IN
18637	1827	11	lands	land	NNS
18637	1827	12	adjoining	adjoining	JJ
18637	1827	13	nonnavigable	nonnavigable	JJ
18637	1827	14	streams	stream	NNS
18637	1827	15	were	be	VBD
18637	1827	16	not	not	RB
18637	1827	17	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1827	18	to	to	IN
18637	1827	19	the	the	DT
18637	1827	20	above	above	RB
18637	1827	21	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	1827	22	servitude,[350	servitude,[350	NNP
18637	1827	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1827	24	this	this	DT
18637	1827	25	rule	rule	NN
18637	1827	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	1827	27	been	be	VBN
18637	1827	28	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	1827	29	by	by	IN
18637	1827	30	recent	recent	JJ
18637	1827	31	decisions;[351	decisions;[351	NNPS
18637	1827	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1827	33	and	and	CC
18637	1827	34	at	at	IN
18637	1827	35	any	any	DT
18637	1827	36	rate	rate	NN
18637	1827	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1827	38	would	would	MD
18637	1827	39	not	not	RB
18637	1827	40	apply	apply	VB
18637	1827	41	as	as	IN
18637	1827	42	to	to	IN
18637	1827	43	a	a	DT
18637	1827	44	stream	stream	NN
18637	1827	45	which	which	WDT
18637	1827	46	had	have	VBD
18637	1827	47	been	be	VBN
18637	1827	48	rendered	render	VBN
18637	1827	49	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1827	50	by	by	IN
18637	1827	51	improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	1827	52	.	.	.
18637	1828	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1828	2	352	352	CD
18637	1828	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1828	4	In	in	IN
18637	1828	5	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	1828	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1828	7	power	power	NN
18637	1828	8	to	to	TO
18637	1828	9	foster	foster	VB
18637	1828	10	and	and	CC
18637	1828	11	protect	protect	VB
18637	1828	12	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1828	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1828	14	legislates	legislate	VBZ
18637	1828	15	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	1828	16	on	on	IN
18637	1828	17	things	thing	NNS
18637	1828	18	external	external	JJ
18637	1828	19	to	to	IN
18637	1828	20	the	the	DT
18637	1828	21	act	act	NN
18637	1828	22	of	of	IN
18637	1828	23	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1828	24	.	.	.
18637	1829	1	But	but	CC
18637	1829	2	that	that	DT
18637	1829	3	act	act	NN
18637	1829	4	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1829	5	and	and	CC
18637	1829	6	the	the	DT
18637	1829	7	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	1829	8	by	by	IN
18637	1829	9	which	which	WDT
18637	1829	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1829	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	1829	12	accomplished	accomplish	VBN
18637	1829	13	are	be	VBP
18637	1829	14	also	also	RB
18637	1829	15	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1829	16	to	to	IN
18637	1829	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1829	18	's	's	POS
18637	1829	19	power	power	NN
18637	1829	20	if	if	IN
18637	1829	21	and	and	CC
18637	1829	22	when	when	WRB
18637	1829	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1829	24	enter	enter	VBP
18637	1829	25	into	into	IN
18637	1829	26	or	or	CC
18637	1829	27	form	form	VB
18637	1829	28	a	a	DT
18637	1829	29	part	part	NN
18637	1829	30	of	of	IN
18637	1829	31	"	"	``
18637	1829	32	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1829	33	among	among	IN
18637	1829	34	the	the	DT
18637	1829	35	several	several	JJ
18637	1829	36	States	state	NNS
18637	1829	37	.	.	.
18637	1829	38	"	"	''
18637	1830	1	When	when	WRB
18637	1830	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	1830	3	this	this	DT
18637	1830	4	happen	happen	VB
18637	1830	5	?	?	.
18637	1831	1	Words	word	NNS
18637	1831	2	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	1831	3	above	above	RB
18637	1831	4	from	from	IN
18637	1831	5	the	the	DT
18637	1831	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1831	7	's	's	POS
18637	1831	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1831	9	in	in	IN
18637	1831	10	the	the	DT
18637	1831	11	Gilman	Gilman	NNP
18637	1831	12	case	case	NN
18637	1831	13	answered	answer	VBD
18637	1831	14	this	this	DT
18637	1831	15	question	question	NN
18637	1831	16	to	to	IN
18637	1831	17	some	some	DT
18637	1831	18	extent	extent	NN
18637	1831	19	;	;	:
18637	1831	20	but	but	CC
18637	1831	21	the	the	DT
18637	1831	22	decisive	decisive	JJ
18637	1831	23	answer	answer	NN
18637	1831	24	to	to	IN
18637	1831	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1831	26	was	be	VBD
18637	1831	27	returned	return	VBN
18637	1831	28	five	five	CD
18637	1831	29	years	year	NNS
18637	1831	30	later	later	RB
18637	1831	31	in	in	IN
18637	1831	32	the	the	DT
18637	1831	33	case	case	NN
18637	1831	34	of	of	IN
18637	1831	35	The	the	DT
18637	1831	36	"	"	``
18637	1831	37	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	1831	38	Ball	Ball	NNP
18637	1831	39	.	.	.
18637	1832	1	"	"	``
18637	1832	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1832	3	353	353	CD
18637	1832	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1832	5	Here	here	RB
18637	1832	6	the	the	DT
18637	1832	7	question	question	NN
18637	1832	8	at	at	IN
18637	1832	9	issue	issue	NN
18637	1832	10	was	be	VBD
18637	1832	11	whether	whether	IN
18637	1832	12	an	an	DT
18637	1832	13	act	act	NN
18637	1832	14	of	of	IN
18637	1832	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1832	16	,	,	,
18637	1832	17	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1832	18	in	in	IN
18637	1832	19	1838	1838	CD
18637	1832	20	and	and	CC
18637	1832	21	amended	amend	VBN
18637	1832	22	in	in	IN
18637	1832	23	1852	1852	CD
18637	1832	24	,	,	,
18637	1832	25	which	which	WDT
18637	1832	26	required	require	VBD
18637	1832	27	that	that	IN
18637	1832	28	steam	steam	NN
18637	1832	29	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	1832	30	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1832	31	in	in	IN
18637	1832	32	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	1832	33	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	1832	34	or	or	CC
18637	1832	35	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	1832	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	1832	37	the	the	DT
18637	1832	38	"	"	``
18637	1832	39	bays	bay	NNS
18637	1832	40	,	,	,
18637	1832	41	lakes	lake	NNS
18637	1832	42	,	,	,
18637	1832	43	rivers	river	NNS
18637	1832	44	,	,	,
18637	1832	45	or	or	CC
18637	1832	46	other	other	JJ
18637	1832	47	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1832	48	waters	water	NNS
18637	1832	49	of	of	IN
18637	1832	50	the	the	DT
18637	1832	51	United	United	NNP
18637	1832	52	States	States	NNP
18637	1832	53	,	,	,
18637	1832	54	"	"	''
18637	1832	55	applied	apply	VBD
18637	1832	56	to	to	IN
18637	1832	57	the	the	DT
18637	1832	58	case	case	NN
18637	1832	59	of	of	IN
18637	1832	60	a	a	DT
18637	1832	61	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	1832	62	which	which	WDT
18637	1832	63	navigated	navigate	VBD
18637	1832	64	only	only	RB
18637	1832	65	the	the	DT
18637	1832	66	waters	water	NNS
18637	1832	67	of	of	IN
18637	1832	68	the	the	DT
18637	1832	69	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	1832	70	River	River	NNP
18637	1832	71	,	,	,
18637	1832	72	a	a	DT
18637	1832	73	stream	stream	NN
18637	1832	74	which	which	WDT
18637	1832	75	lies	lie	VBZ
18637	1832	76	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	1832	77	in	in	IN
18637	1832	78	the	the	DT
18637	1832	79	State	State	NNP
18637	1832	80	of	of	IN
18637	1832	81	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	1832	82	.	.	.
18637	1833	1	Argued	argue	VBN
18637	1833	2	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	1833	3	for	for	IN
18637	1833	4	the	the	DT
18637	1833	5	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	1833	6	:	:	:
18637	1833	7	"	"	``
18637	1833	8	The	the	DT
18637	1833	9	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1833	10	rivers	river	NNS
18637	1833	11	of	of	IN
18637	1833	12	the	the	DT
18637	1833	13	United	United	NNP
18637	1833	14	States	States	NNP
18637	1833	15	pass	pass	VBP
18637	1833	16	through	through	IN
18637	1833	17	States	state	NNS
18637	1833	18	,	,	,
18637	1833	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1833	20	form	form	VBP
18637	1833	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1833	22	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	1833	23	lines	line	NNS
18637	1833	24	,	,	,
18637	1833	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1833	26	are	be	VBP
18637	1833	27	not	not	RB
18637	1833	28	in	in	IN
18637	1833	29	any	any	DT
18637	1833	30	one	one	CD
18637	1833	31	State	state	NN
18637	1833	32	,	,	,
18637	1833	33	nor	nor	CC
18637	1833	34	the	the	DT
18637	1833	35	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	1833	36	property	property	NN
18637	1833	37	of	of	IN
18637	1833	38	any	any	DT
18637	1833	39	one	one	CD
18637	1833	40	,	,	,
18637	1833	41	but	but	CC
18637	1833	42	are	be	VBP
18637	1833	43	common	common	JJ
18637	1833	44	to	to	IN
18637	1833	45	all	all	DT
18637	1833	46	.	.	.
18637	1834	1	To	to	TO
18637	1834	2	make	make	VB
18637	1834	3	waters	water	NNS
18637	1834	4	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1834	5	waters	water	NNS
18637	1834	6	of	of	IN
18637	1834	7	the	the	DT
18637	1834	8	United	United	NNP
18637	1834	9	States	States	NNP
18637	1834	10	,	,	,
18637	1834	11	some	some	DT
18637	1834	12	other	other	JJ
18637	1834	13	incident	incident	NN
18637	1834	14	must	must	MD
18637	1834	15	attach	attach	VB
18637	1834	16	to	to	IN
18637	1834	17	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1834	18	besides	besides	IN
18637	1834	19	the	the	DT
18637	1834	20	territorial	territorial	NN
18637	1834	21	and	and	CC
18637	1834	22	the	the	DT
18637	1834	23	capability	capability	NN
18637	1834	24	for	for	IN
18637	1834	25	public	public	JJ
18637	1834	26	use	use	NN
18637	1834	27	.	.	.
18637	1835	1	This	this	DT
18637	1835	2	term	term	NN
18637	1835	3	contrasts	contrast	VBZ
18637	1835	4	with	with	IN
18637	1835	5	_	_	NNP
18637	1835	6	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	1835	7	_	_	NNP
18637	1835	8	waters	water	NNS
18637	1835	9	of	of	IN
18637	1835	10	the	the	DT
18637	1835	11	United	United	NNP
18637	1835	12	States	States	NNP
18637	1835	13	,	,	,
18637	1835	14	and	and	CC
18637	1835	15	implies	imply	VBZ
18637	1835	16	,	,	,
18637	1835	17	not	not	RB
18637	1835	18	simply	simply	RB
18637	1835	19	that	that	IN
18637	1835	20	the	the	DT
18637	1835	21	waters	water	NNS
18637	1835	22	are	be	VBP
18637	1835	23	public	public	JJ
18637	1835	24	and	and	CC
18637	1835	25	within	within	IN
18637	1835	26	the	the	DT
18637	1835	27	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1835	28	,	,	,
18637	1835	29	but	but	CC
18637	1835	30	that	that	IN
18637	1835	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1835	32	have	have	VBP
18637	1835	33	attached	attach	VBN
18637	1835	34	to	to	IN
18637	1835	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1835	36	some	some	DT
18637	1835	37	circumstance	circumstance	NN
18637	1835	38	that	that	WDT
18637	1835	39	brings	bring	VBZ
18637	1835	40	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1835	41	within	within	IN
18637	1835	42	the	the	DT
18637	1835	43	scope	scope	NN
18637	1835	44	of	of	IN
18637	1835	45	the	the	DT
18637	1835	46	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	1835	47	of	of	IN
18637	1835	48	the	the	DT
18637	1835	49	United	United	NNP
18637	1835	50	States	States	NNP
18637	1835	51	as	as	IN
18637	1835	52	defined	define	VBN
18637	1835	53	by	by	IN
18637	1835	54	the	the	DT
18637	1835	55	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	1835	56	.	.	.
18637	1835	57	"	"	''
18637	1836	1	Then	then	RB
18637	1836	2	as	as	IN
18637	1836	3	a	a	DT
18637	1836	4	sort	sort	NN
18637	1836	5	of	of	IN
18637	1836	6	_	_	NNP
18637	1836	7	reductio	reductio	NN
18637	1836	8	ad	ad	NN
18637	1836	9	absurdum	absurdum	NN
18637	1836	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1836	11	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	1836	12	added	add	VBD
18637	1836	13	:	:	:
18637	1836	14	"	"	``
18637	1836	15	*	*	NFP
18637	1836	16	*	*	NFP
18637	1836	17	*	*	NFP
18637	1836	18	if	if	IN
18637	1836	19	merely	merely	RB
18637	1836	20	because	because	IN
18637	1836	21	a	a	DT
18637	1836	22	stream	stream	NN
18637	1836	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	1836	24	a	a	DT
18637	1836	25	highway	highway	NN
18637	1836	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1836	27	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	1836	28	a	a	DT
18637	1836	29	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1836	30	water	water	NN
18637	1836	31	of	of	IN
18637	1836	32	the	the	DT
18637	1836	33	United	United	NNP
18637	1836	34	States	States	NNP
18637	1836	35	,	,	,
18637	1836	36	in	in	IN
18637	1836	37	a	a	DT
18637	1836	38	sense	sense	NN
18637	1836	39	that	that	WDT
18637	1836	40	attaches	attach	VBZ
18637	1836	41	to	to	IN
18637	1836	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1836	43	and	and	CC
18637	1836	44	to	to	IN
18637	1836	45	the	the	DT
18637	1836	46	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	1836	47	trading	trading	NN
18637	1836	48	upon	upon	IN
18637	1836	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1836	50	the	the	DT
18637	1836	51	regulating	regulating	NN
18637	1836	52	control	control	NN
18637	1836	53	of	of	IN
18637	1836	54	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1836	55	,	,	,
18637	1836	56	then	then	RB
18637	1836	57	every	every	DT
18637	1836	58	highway	highway	NN
18637	1836	59	must	must	MD
18637	1836	60	be	be	VB
18637	1836	61	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	1836	62	as	as	IN
18637	1836	63	a	a	DT
18637	1836	64	highway	highway	NN
18637	1836	65	of	of	IN
18637	1836	66	the	the	DT
18637	1836	67	United	United	NNP
18637	1836	68	States	States	NNP
18637	1836	69	,	,	,
18637	1836	70	and	and	CC
18637	1836	71	the	the	DT
18637	1836	72	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	1836	73	upon	upon	IN
18637	1836	74	_	_	NNP
18637	1836	75	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1836	76	_	_	NNP
18637	1836	77	must	must	MD
18637	1836	78	be	be	VB
18637	1836	79	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1836	80	to	to	IN
18637	1836	81	the	the	DT
18637	1836	82	same	same	JJ
18637	1836	83	control	control	NN
18637	1836	84	.	.	.
18637	1837	1	But	but	CC
18637	1837	2	this	this	DT
18637	1837	3	will	will	MD
18637	1837	4	not	not	RB
18637	1837	5	be	be	VB
18637	1837	6	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	1837	7	on	on	IN
18637	1837	8	the	the	DT
18637	1837	9	part	part	NN
18637	1837	10	of	of	IN
18637	1837	11	the	the	DT
18637	1837	12	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1837	13	.	.	.
18637	1838	1	"	"	``
18637	1838	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1838	3	354	354	CD
18637	1838	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1838	5	The	the	DT
18637	1838	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1838	7	answered	answer	VBD
18637	1838	8	:	:	:
18637	1838	9	"	"	``
18637	1838	10	In	in	IN
18637	1838	11	this	this	DT
18637	1838	12	case	case	NN
18637	1838	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1838	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	1838	15	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	1838	16	that	that	IN
18637	1838	17	the	the	DT
18637	1838	18	steamer	steamer	NN
18637	1838	19	was	be	VBD
18637	1838	20	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1838	21	in	in	IN
18637	1838	22	shipping	shipping	NN
18637	1838	23	and	and	CC
18637	1838	24	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	1838	25	down	down	RP
18637	1838	26	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	1838	27	River	River	NNP
18637	1838	28	,	,	,
18637	1838	29	goods	good	NNS
18637	1838	30	destined	destine	VBN
18637	1838	31	and	and	CC
18637	1838	32	marked	mark	VBN
18637	1838	33	for	for	IN
18637	1838	34	other	other	JJ
18637	1838	35	States	States	NNPS
18637	1838	36	than	than	IN
18637	1838	37	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	1838	38	,	,	,
18637	1838	39	and	and	CC
18637	1838	40	in	in	IN
18637	1838	41	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	1838	42	and	and	CC
18637	1838	43	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	1838	44	up	up	RP
18637	1838	45	the	the	DT
18637	1838	46	river	river	NN
18637	1838	47	goods	good	NNS
18637	1838	48	brought	bring	VBN
18637	1838	49	within	within	IN
18637	1838	50	the	the	DT
18637	1838	51	State	State	NNP
18637	1838	52	from	from	IN
18637	1838	53	without	without	IN
18637	1838	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1838	55	limits	limit	NNS
18637	1838	56	;	;	:
18637	1838	57	*	*	NFP
18637	1838	58	*	*	NFP
18637	1838	59	*	*	NFP
18637	1838	60	So	so	RB
18637	1838	61	far	far	RB
18637	1838	62	as	as	IN
18637	1838	63	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1838	64	was	be	VBD
18637	1838	65	employed	employ	VBN
18637	1838	66	in	in	IN
18637	1838	67	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	1838	68	goods	good	NNS
18637	1838	69	destined	destine	VBN
18637	1838	70	for	for	IN
18637	1838	71	other	other	JJ
18637	1838	72	States	States	NNPS
18637	1838	73	,	,	,
18637	1838	74	or	or	CC
18637	1838	75	goods	good	NNS
18637	1838	76	brought	bring	VBN
18637	1838	77	from	from	IN
18637	1838	78	without	without	IN
18637	1838	79	the	the	DT
18637	1838	80	limits	limit	NNS
18637	1838	81	of	of	IN
18637	1838	82	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	1838	83	and	and	CC
18637	1838	84	destined	destine	VBN
18637	1838	85	to	to	IN
18637	1838	86	places	place	NNS
18637	1838	87	within	within	IN
18637	1838	88	that	that	DT
18637	1838	89	State	State	NNP
18637	1838	90	,	,	,
18637	1838	91	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1838	92	was	be	VBD
18637	1838	93	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1838	94	in	in	IN
18637	1838	95	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1838	96	between	between	IN
18637	1838	97	the	the	DT
18637	1838	98	States	States	NNP
18637	1838	99	,	,	,
18637	1838	100	and	and	CC
18637	1838	101	however	however	RB
18637	1838	102	limited	limited	JJ
18637	1838	103	that	that	IN
18637	1838	104	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1838	105	may	may	MD
18637	1838	106	have	have	VB
18637	1838	107	been	be	VBN
18637	1838	108	,	,	,
18637	1838	109	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1838	110	was	be	VBD
18637	1838	111	,	,	,
18637	1838	112	so	so	RB
18637	1838	113	far	far	RB
18637	1838	114	as	as	IN
18637	1838	115	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1838	116	went	go	VBD
18637	1838	117	,	,	,
18637	1838	118	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1838	119	to	to	IN
18637	1838	120	the	the	DT
18637	1838	121	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1838	122	of	of	IN
18637	1838	123	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1838	124	.	.	.
18637	1839	1	She	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1839	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1839	3	employed	employ	VBN
18637	1839	4	as	as	IN
18637	1839	5	an	an	DT
18637	1839	6	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	1839	7	of	of	IN
18637	1839	8	that	that	DT
18637	1839	9	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1839	10	;	;	:
18637	1839	11	for	for	IN
18637	1839	12	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	1839	13	a	a	DT
18637	1839	14	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	1839	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	1839	16	begun	begin	VBN
18637	1839	17	to	to	TO
18637	1839	18	move	move	VB
18637	1839	19	as	as	IN
18637	1839	20	an	an	DT
18637	1839	21	article	article	NN
18637	1839	22	of	of	IN
18637	1839	23	trade	trade	NN
18637	1839	24	from	from	IN
18637	1839	25	one	one	CD
18637	1839	26	State	state	NN
18637	1839	27	to	to	IN
18637	1839	28	another	another	DT
18637	1839	29	,	,	,
18637	1839	30	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1839	31	in	in	IN
18637	1839	32	that	that	DT
18637	1839	33	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	1839	34	between	between	IN
18637	1839	35	the	the	DT
18637	1839	36	States	States	NNP
18637	1839	37	has	have	VBZ
18637	1839	38	commenced	commence	VBN
18637	1839	39	.	.	.
18637	1840	1	"	"	``
18637	1840	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1840	3	355	355	CD
18637	1840	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1840	5	Turning	turn	VBG
18637	1840	6	then	then	RB
18637	1840	7	to	to	IN
18637	1840	8	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	1840	9	's	's	POS
18637	1840	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1840	11	reductio	reductio	NN
18637	1840	12	ad	ad	NN
18637	1840	13	absurdum	absurdum	NN
18637	1840	14	_	_	NNP
18637	1840	15	,	,	,
18637	1840	16	the	the	DT
18637	1840	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1840	18	added	add	VBD
18637	1840	19	:	:	:
18637	1840	20	"	"	``
18637	1840	21	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1840	22	answer	answer	VBP
18637	1840	23	that	that	IN
18637	1840	24	the	the	DT
18637	1840	25	present	present	JJ
18637	1840	26	case	case	NN
18637	1840	27	relates	relate	VBZ
18637	1840	28	to	to	IN
18637	1840	29	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1840	30	on	on	IN
18637	1840	31	the	the	DT
18637	1840	32	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1840	33	waters	water	NNS
18637	1840	34	of	of	IN
18637	1840	35	the	the	DT
18637	1840	36	United	United	NNP
18637	1840	37	States	States	NNP
18637	1840	38	,	,	,
18637	1840	39	and	and	CC
18637	1840	40	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1840	41	are	be	VBP
18637	1840	42	not	not	RB
18637	1840	43	called	call	VBN
18637	1840	44	upon	upon	IN
18637	1840	45	to	to	TO
18637	1840	46	express	express	VB
18637	1840	47	an	an	DT
18637	1840	48	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1840	49	upon	upon	IN
18637	1840	50	the	the	DT
18637	1840	51	power	power	NN
18637	1840	52	of	of	IN
18637	1840	53	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1840	54	over	over	IN
18637	1840	55	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1840	56	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1840	57	when	when	WRB
18637	1840	58	carried	carry	VBN
18637	1840	59	on	on	RP
18637	1840	60	by	by	IN
18637	1840	61	land	land	NN
18637	1840	62	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1840	63	.	.	.
18637	1841	1	And	and	CC
18637	1841	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1841	3	answer	answer	VBP
18637	1841	4	further	further	RB
18637	1841	5	,	,	,
18637	1841	6	that	that	IN
18637	1841	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1841	8	are	be	VBP
18637	1841	9	unable	unable	JJ
18637	1841	10	to	to	TO
18637	1841	11	draw	draw	VB
18637	1841	12	any	any	DT
18637	1841	13	clear	clear	JJ
18637	1841	14	and	and	CC
18637	1841	15	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	1841	16	line	line	NN
18637	1841	17	between	between	IN
18637	1841	18	the	the	DT
18637	1841	19	authority	authority	NN
18637	1841	20	of	of	IN
18637	1841	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1841	22	to	to	TO
18637	1841	23	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1841	24	an	an	DT
18637	1841	25	agency	agency	NN
18637	1841	26	employed	employ	VBN
18637	1841	27	in	in	IN
18637	1841	28	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1841	29	between	between	IN
18637	1841	30	the	the	DT
18637	1841	31	States	States	NNPS
18637	1841	32	,	,	,
18637	1841	33	when	when	WRB
18637	1841	34	the	the	DT
18637	1841	35	agency	agency	NN
18637	1841	36	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	1841	37	through	through	IN
18637	1841	38	two	two	CD
18637	1841	39	or	or	CC
18637	1841	40	more	more	JJR
18637	1841	41	States	States	NNPS
18637	1841	42	,	,	,
18637	1841	43	and	and	CC
18637	1841	44	when	when	WRB
18637	1841	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1841	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	1841	47	confined	confine	VBN
18637	1841	48	in	in	IN
18637	1841	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1841	50	action	action	NN
18637	1841	51	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	1841	52	within	within	IN
18637	1841	53	the	the	DT
18637	1841	54	limits	limit	NNS
18637	1841	55	of	of	IN
18637	1841	56	a	a	DT
18637	1841	57	single	single	JJ
18637	1841	58	State	state	NN
18637	1841	59	.	.	.
18637	1842	1	If	if	IN
18637	1842	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1842	3	authority	authority	NN
18637	1842	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	1842	5	not	not	RB
18637	1842	6	extend	extend	VB
18637	1842	7	to	to	IN
18637	1842	8	an	an	DT
18637	1842	9	agency	agency	NN
18637	1842	10	in	in	IN
18637	1842	11	such	such	JJ
18637	1842	12	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1842	13	,	,	,
18637	1842	14	when	when	WRB
18637	1842	15	that	that	DT
18637	1842	16	agency	agency	NN
18637	1842	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	1842	18	confined	confine	VBN
18637	1842	19	within	within	IN
18637	1842	20	the	the	DT
18637	1842	21	limits	limit	NNS
18637	1842	22	of	of	IN
18637	1842	23	a	a	DT
18637	1842	24	State	State	NNP
18637	1842	25	,	,	,
18637	1842	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1842	27	entire	entire	JJ
18637	1842	28	authority	authority	NN
18637	1842	29	over	over	IN
18637	1842	30	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1842	31	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1842	32	may	may	MD
18637	1842	33	be	be	VB
18637	1842	34	defeated	defeat	VBN
18637	1842	35	.	.	.
18637	1843	1	Several	several	JJ
18637	1843	2	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	1843	3	combining	combine	VBG
18637	1843	4	,	,	,
18637	1843	5	each	each	DT
18637	1843	6	taking	take	VBG
18637	1843	7	up	up	RP
18637	1843	8	the	the	DT
18637	1843	9	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	1843	10	transported	transport	VBN
18637	1843	11	at	at	IN
18637	1843	12	the	the	DT
18637	1843	13	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	1843	14	line	line	NN
18637	1843	15	at	at	IN
18637	1843	16	one	one	CD
18637	1843	17	end	end	NN
18637	1843	18	of	of	IN
18637	1843	19	a	a	DT
18637	1843	20	State	state	NN
18637	1843	21	,	,	,
18637	1843	22	and	and	CC
18637	1843	23	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	1843	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1843	25	at	at	IN
18637	1843	26	the	the	DT
18637	1843	27	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	1843	28	line	line	NN
18637	1843	29	at	at	IN
18637	1843	30	the	the	DT
18637	1843	31	other	other	JJ
18637	1843	32	end	end	NN
18637	1843	33	,	,	,
18637	1843	34	the	the	DT
18637	1843	35	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1843	36	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	1843	37	would	would	MD
18637	1843	38	be	be	VB
18637	1843	39	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	1843	40	ousted	oust	VBN
18637	1843	41	,	,	,
18637	1843	42	and	and	CC
18637	1843	43	the	the	DT
18637	1843	44	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1843	45	provision	provision	NN
18637	1843	46	would	would	MD
18637	1843	47	become	become	VB
18637	1843	48	a	a	DT
18637	1843	49	dead	dead	JJ
18637	1843	50	letter	letter	NN
18637	1843	51	.	.	.
18637	1844	1	"	"	``
18637	1844	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1844	3	356	356	CD
18637	1844	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1844	5	In	in	IN
18637	1844	6	short	short	JJ
18637	1844	7	,	,	,
18637	1844	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1844	9	was	be	VBD
18637	1844	10	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	1844	11	inferentially	inferentially	RB
18637	1844	12	,	,	,
18637	1844	13	that	that	IN
18637	1844	14	the	the	DT
18637	1844	15	principle	principle	NN
18637	1844	16	of	of	IN
18637	1844	17	the	the	DT
18637	1844	18	decision	decision	NN
18637	1844	19	would	would	MD
18637	1844	20	apply	apply	VB
18637	1844	21	to	to	IN
18637	1844	22	land	land	NN
18637	1844	23	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1844	24	;	;	:
18637	1844	25	but	but	CC
18637	1844	26	the	the	DT
18637	1844	27	actual	actual	JJ
18637	1844	28	demonstration	demonstration	NN
18637	1844	29	of	of	IN
18637	1844	30	the	the	DT
18637	1844	31	fact	fact	NN
18637	1844	32	still	still	RB
18637	1844	33	awaited	await	VBD
18637	1844	34	some	some	DT
18637	1844	35	years	year	NNS
18637	1844	36	.	.	.
18637	1845	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1845	2	357	357	CD
18637	1845	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1845	4	See	see	VB
18637	1845	5	_	_	NNP
18637	1845	6	infra	infra	FW
18637	1845	7	_	_	NNP
18637	1845	8	.	.	.
18637	1846	1	HYDROELECTRIC	HYDROELECTRIC	NNP
18637	1846	2	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	1846	3	As	as	IN
18637	1846	4	a	a	DT
18637	1846	5	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	1846	6	,	,	,
18637	1846	7	in	in	IN
18637	1846	8	part	part	NN
18637	1846	9	,	,	,
18637	1846	10	of	of	IN
18637	1846	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1846	12	power	power	NN
18637	1846	13	to	to	TO
18637	1846	14	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	1846	15	or	or	CC
18637	1846	16	remove	remove	VB
18637	1846	17	obstructions	obstruction	NNS
18637	1846	18	to	to	IN
18637	1846	19	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1846	20	in	in	IN
18637	1846	21	the	the	DT
18637	1846	22	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1846	23	waters	water	NNS
18637	1846	24	of	of	IN
18637	1846	25	the	the	DT
18637	1846	26	United	United	NNP
18637	1846	27	States	States	NNP
18637	1846	28	,	,	,
18637	1846	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1846	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	1846	31	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	1846	32	the	the	DT
18637	1846	33	right	right	NN
18637	1846	34	to	to	TO
18637	1846	35	develop	develop	VB
18637	1846	36	hydroelectric	hydroelectric	JJ
18637	1846	37	power	power	NN
18637	1846	38	,	,	,
18637	1846	39	and	and	CC
18637	1846	40	the	the	DT
18637	1846	41	ancillary	ancillary	JJ
18637	1846	42	right	right	NN
18637	1846	43	to	to	TO
18637	1846	44	sell	sell	VB
18637	1846	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1846	46	to	to	IN
18637	1846	47	all	all	DT
18637	1846	48	takers	taker	NNS
18637	1846	49	.	.	.
18637	1847	1	By	by	IN
18637	1847	2	a	a	DT
18637	1847	3	long	long	RB
18637	1847	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	1847	5	standing	stand	VBG
18637	1847	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1847	7	of	of	IN
18637	1847	8	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	1847	9	Law	Law	NNP
18637	1847	10	the	the	DT
18637	1847	11	States	States	NNPS
18637	1847	12	possess	possess	VBP
18637	1847	13	dominion	dominion	NN
18637	1847	14	over	over	IN
18637	1847	15	the	the	DT
18637	1847	16	beds	bed	NNS
18637	1847	17	of	of	IN
18637	1847	18	all	all	DT
18637	1847	19	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1847	20	streams	stream	NNS
18637	1847	21	within	within	IN
18637	1847	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1847	23	borders,[358	borders,[358	NN
18637	1847	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1847	25	but	but	CC
18637	1847	26	on	on	IN
18637	1847	27	account	account	NN
18637	1847	28	of	of	IN
18637	1847	29	the	the	DT
18637	1847	30	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	1847	31	which	which	WDT
18637	1847	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1847	33	's	's	POS
18637	1847	34	power	power	NN
18637	1847	35	to	to	TO
18637	1847	36	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1847	37	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1847	38	imposes	impose	NNS
18637	1847	39	upon	upon	IN
18637	1847	40	such	such	JJ
18637	1847	41	streams	stream	NNS
18637	1847	42	,	,	,
18637	1847	43	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1847	44	are	be	VBP
18637	1847	45	practically	practically	RB
18637	1847	46	unable	unable	JJ
18637	1847	47	,	,	,
18637	1847	48	without	without	IN
18637	1847	49	the	the	DT
18637	1847	50	assent	assent	NN
18637	1847	51	of	of	IN
18637	1847	52	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1847	53	,	,	,
18637	1847	54	to	to	TO
18637	1847	55	utilize	utilize	VB
18637	1847	56	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1847	57	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	1847	58	for	for	IN
18637	1847	59	power	power	NN
18637	1847	60	development	development	NN
18637	1847	61	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	1847	62	.	.	.
18637	1848	1	Sensing	sense	VBG
18637	1848	2	,	,	,
18637	1848	3	no	no	RB
18637	1848	4	doubt	doubt	RB
18637	1848	5	,	,	,
18637	1848	6	that	that	IN
18637	1848	7	controlling	control	VBG
18637	1848	8	power	power	NN
18637	1848	9	to	to	IN
18637	1848	10	this	this	DT
18637	1848	11	end	end	NN
18637	1848	12	must	must	MD
18637	1848	13	be	be	VB
18637	1848	14	attributed	attribute	VBN
18637	1848	15	to	to	IN
18637	1848	16	some	some	DT
18637	1848	17	government	government	NN
18637	1848	18	in	in	IN
18637	1848	19	the	the	DT
18637	1848	20	United	United	NNP
18637	1848	21	States	States	NNP
18637	1848	22	and	and	CC
18637	1848	23	that	that	IN
18637	1848	24	"	"	``
18637	1848	25	in	in	IN
18637	1848	26	such	such	JJ
18637	1848	27	matters	matter	NNS
18637	1848	28	there	there	EX
18637	1848	29	can	can	MD
18637	1848	30	be	be	VB
18637	1848	31	no	no	DT
18637	1848	32	divided	divided	JJ
18637	1848	33	empire,"[359	empire,"[359	NN
18637	1848	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1848	35	the	the	DT
18637	1848	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1848	37	held	hold	VBD
18637	1848	38	,	,	,
18637	1848	39	in	in	IN
18637	1848	40	1913	1913	CD
18637	1848	41	,	,	,
18637	1848	42	in	in	IN
18637	1848	43	United	United	NNP
18637	1848	44	States	States	NNP
18637	1848	45	_	_	NNP
18637	1848	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	1848	47	_	_	NNP
18637	1848	48	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	1848	49	-	-	HYPH
18637	1848	50	Dunbar	Dunbar	NNP
18637	1848	51	Co	Co	NNP
18637	1848	52	.	.	.
18637	1848	53	,[360	,[360	NFP
18637	1848	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1848	55	that	that	IN
18637	1848	56	in	in	IN
18637	1848	57	constructing	construct	VBG
18637	1848	58	works	work	NNS
18637	1848	59	for	for	IN
18637	1848	60	the	the	DT
18637	1848	61	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	1848	62	of	of	IN
18637	1848	63	the	the	DT
18637	1848	64	navigability	navigability	NN
18637	1848	65	of	of	IN
18637	1848	66	a	a	DT
18637	1848	67	stream	stream	NN
18637	1848	68	,	,	,
18637	1848	69	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1848	70	was	be	VBD
18637	1848	71	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	1848	72	,	,	,
18637	1848	73	as	as	IN
18637	1848	74	a	a	DT
18637	1848	75	part	part	NN
18637	1848	76	of	of	IN
18637	1848	77	a	a	DT
18637	1848	78	general	general	JJ
18637	1848	79	plan	plan	NN
18637	1848	80	,	,	,
18637	1848	81	to	to	TO
18637	1848	82	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	1848	83	the	the	DT
18637	1848	84	lease	lease	NN
18637	1848	85	or	or	CC
18637	1848	86	sale	sale	NN
18637	1848	87	of	of	IN
18637	1848	88	such	such	JJ
18637	1848	89	excess	excess	JJ
18637	1848	90	water	water	NN
18637	1848	91	power	power	NN
18637	1848	92	as	as	IN
18637	1848	93	might	may	MD
18637	1848	94	result	result	VB
18637	1848	95	from	from	IN
18637	1848	96	the	the	DT
18637	1848	97	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	1848	98	of	of	IN
18637	1848	99	the	the	DT
18637	1848	100	flow	flow	NN
18637	1848	101	of	of	IN
18637	1848	102	the	the	DT
18637	1848	103	stream	stream	NN
18637	1848	104	.	.	.
18637	1849	1	"	"	``
18637	1849	2	If	if	IN
18637	1849	3	the	the	DT
18637	1849	4	primary	primary	JJ
18637	1849	5	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1849	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	1849	7	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	1849	8	,	,	,
18637	1849	9	"	"	''
18637	1849	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1849	11	said	say	VBD
18637	1849	12	,	,	,
18637	1849	13	"	"	``
18637	1849	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1849	15	can	can	MD
18637	1849	16	see	see	VB
18637	1849	17	no	no	DT
18637	1849	18	sound	sound	JJ
18637	1849	19	objection	objection	NN
18637	1849	20	to	to	IN
18637	1849	21	leasing	lease	VBG
18637	1849	22	any	any	DT
18637	1849	23	excess	excess	NN
18637	1849	24	of	of	IN
18637	1849	25	power	power	NN
18637	1849	26	over	over	IN
18637	1849	27	the	the	DT
18637	1849	28	needs	need	NNS
18637	1849	29	of	of	IN
18637	1849	30	the	the	DT
18637	1849	31	government	government	NN
18637	1849	32	.	.	.
18637	1850	1	The	the	DT
18637	1850	2	practice	practice	NN
18637	1850	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	1850	4	not	not	RB
18637	1850	5	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	1850	6	in	in	IN
18637	1850	7	respect	respect	NN
18637	1850	8	to	to	IN
18637	1850	9	similar	similar	JJ
18637	1850	10	public	public	JJ
18637	1850	11	works	work	NNS
18637	1850	12	constructed	construct	VBN
18637	1850	13	by	by	IN
18637	1850	14	State	state	NN
18637	1850	15	governments	government	NNS
18637	1850	16	.	.	.
18637	1851	1	"	"	``
18637	1851	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1851	3	361	361	CD
18637	1851	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1851	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1851	6	's	's	POS
18637	1851	7	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	1851	8	Over	over	IN
18637	1851	9	Navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1851	10	Streams	stream	NNS
18637	1851	11	Today	Today	NNP
18637	1851	12	Since	since	IN
18637	1851	13	the	the	DT
18637	1851	14	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	1851	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	1851	16	Dunbar	Dunbar	NNP
18637	1851	17	case	case	NN
18637	1851	18	the	the	DT
18637	1851	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1851	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	1851	21	come	come	VBN
18637	1851	22	,	,	,
18637	1851	23	in	in	IN
18637	1851	24	effect	effect	NN
18637	1851	25	,	,	,
18637	1851	26	to	to	TO
18637	1851	27	hold	hold	VB
18637	1851	28	that	that	IN
18637	1851	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1851	30	will	will	MD
18637	1851	31	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	1851	32	any	any	DT
18637	1851	33	act	act	NN
18637	1851	34	of	of	IN
18637	1851	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1851	36	which	which	WDT
18637	1851	37	purports	purport	VBZ
18637	1851	38	to	to	TO
18637	1851	39	be	be	VB
18637	1851	40	for	for	IN
18637	1851	41	the	the	DT
18637	1851	42	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	1851	43	of	of	IN
18637	1851	44	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1851	45	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	1851	46	other	other	JJ
18637	1851	47	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	1851	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1851	49	may	may	MD
18637	1851	50	also	also	RB
18637	1851	51	embody	embody	VB
18637	1851	52	;	;	:
18637	1851	53	nor	nor	CC
18637	1851	54	does	do	VBZ
18637	1851	55	the	the	DT
18637	1851	56	stream	stream	NN
18637	1851	57	involved	involve	VBN
18637	1851	58	have	have	VB
18637	1851	59	to	to	TO
18637	1851	60	be	be	VB
18637	1851	61	one	one	CD
18637	1851	62	which	which	WDT
18637	1851	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	1851	64	"	"	``
18637	1851	65	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1851	66	in	in	IN
18637	1851	67	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1851	68	natural	natural	JJ
18637	1851	69	state	state	NN
18637	1851	70	.	.	.
18637	1851	71	"	"	''
18637	1852	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	1852	2	,	,	,
18637	1852	3	at	at	IN
18637	1852	4	least	least	JJS
18637	1852	5	,	,	,
18637	1852	6	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	1852	7	to	to	TO
18637	1852	8	be	be	VB
18637	1852	9	the	the	DT
18637	1852	10	algebraic	algebraic	NN
18637	1852	11	sum	sum	NN
18637	1852	12	of	of	IN
18637	1852	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1852	14	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	1852	15	in	in	IN
18637	1852	16	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	1852	17	_	_	NNP
18637	1852	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	1852	19	_	_	NNP
18637	1852	20	California,[362	California,[362	NNP
18637	1852	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1852	22	decided	decide	VBD
18637	1852	23	in	in	IN
18637	1852	24	1931	1931	CD
18637	1852	25	,	,	,
18637	1852	26	and	and	CC
18637	1852	27	in	in	IN
18637	1852	28	the	the	DT
18637	1852	29	United	United	NNP
18637	1852	30	States	States	NNP
18637	1852	31	_	_	NNP
18637	1852	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	1852	33	_	_	NNP
18637	1852	34	Appalachian	Appalachian	NNP
18637	1852	35	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	1852	36	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1852	37	Co	Co	NNP
18637	1852	38	.	.	.
18637	1852	39	,[363	,[363	NFP
18637	1852	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1852	41	decided	decide	VBN
18637	1852	42	in	in	IN
18637	1852	43	1940	1940	CD
18637	1852	44	.	.	.
18637	1853	1	In	in	IN
18637	1853	2	the	the	DT
18637	1853	3	former	former	JJ
18637	1853	4	the	the	DT
18637	1853	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1853	6	,	,	,
18637	1853	7	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	1853	8	through	through	IN
18637	1853	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1853	10	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	1853	11	,	,	,
18637	1853	12	said	say	VBD
18637	1853	13	that	that	IN
18637	1853	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1853	15	was	be	VBD
18637	1853	16	not	not	RB
18637	1853	17	free	free	JJ
18637	1853	18	to	to	TO
18637	1853	19	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	1853	20	into	into	IN
18637	1853	21	the	the	DT
18637	1853	22	motives	motive	NNS
18637	1853	23	"	"	''
18637	1853	24	which	which	WDT
18637	1853	25	induced	induce	VBD
18637	1853	26	members	member	NNS
18637	1853	27	of	of	IN
18637	1853	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1853	29	to	to	TO
18637	1853	30	enact	enact	VB
18637	1853	31	the	the	DT
18637	1853	32	Boulder	Boulder	NNP
18637	1853	33	Canyon	Canyon	NNP
18637	1853	34	Project	Project	NNP
18637	1853	35	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1853	36	,	,	,
18637	1853	37	"	"	''
18637	1853	38	adding	add	VBG
18637	1853	39	:	:	:
18637	1853	40	"	"	``
18637	1853	41	As	as	IN
18637	1853	42	the	the	DT
18637	1853	43	river	river	NN
18637	1853	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	1853	45	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1853	46	and	and	CC
18637	1853	47	the	the	DT
18637	1853	48	means	mean	NNS
18637	1853	49	which	which	WDT
18637	1853	50	the	the	DT
18637	1853	51	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1853	52	provides	provide	NNS
18637	1853	53	are	be	VBP
18637	1853	54	not	not	RB
18637	1853	55	unrelated	unrelated	JJ
18637	1853	56	to	to	IN
18637	1853	57	the	the	DT
18637	1853	58	control	control	NN
18637	1853	59	of	of	IN
18637	1853	60	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1853	61	,	,	,
18637	1853	62	*	*	NFP
18637	1853	63	*	*	NFP
18637	1853	64	*	*	NFP
18637	1853	65	,	,	,
18637	1853	66	the	the	DT
18637	1853	67	erection	erection	NN
18637	1853	68	and	and	CC
18637	1853	69	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	1853	70	of	of	IN
18637	1853	71	such	such	JJ
18637	1853	72	dam	dam	NN
18637	1853	73	and	and	CC
18637	1853	74	reservoir	reservoir	NN
18637	1853	75	are	be	VBP
18637	1853	76	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	1853	77	within	within	IN
18637	1853	78	the	the	DT
18637	1853	79	powers	power	NNS
18637	1853	80	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	1853	81	upon	upon	IN
18637	1853	82	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1853	83	.	.	.
18637	1854	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	1854	2	the	the	DT
18637	1854	3	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1854	4	structures	structure	NNS
18637	1854	5	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1854	6	are	be	VBP
18637	1854	7	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	1854	8	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1854	9	,	,	,
18637	1854	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	1854	11	not	not	RB
18637	1854	12	for	for	IN
18637	1854	13	this	this	DT
18637	1854	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1854	15	to	to	TO
18637	1854	16	determine	determine	VB
18637	1854	17	.	.	.
18637	1855	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1855	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1855	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1855	4	And	and	CC
18637	1855	5	the	the	DT
18637	1855	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	1855	7	that	that	WDT
18637	1855	8	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	1855	9	other	other	JJ
18637	1855	10	than	than	IN
18637	1855	11	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1855	12	will	will	MD
18637	1855	13	also	also	RB
18637	1855	14	be	be	VB
18637	1855	15	served	serve	VBN
18637	1855	16	could	could	MD
18637	1855	17	not	not	RB
18637	1855	18	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	1855	19	the	the	DT
18637	1855	20	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1855	21	of	of	IN
18637	1855	22	the	the	DT
18637	1855	23	authority	authority	NN
18637	1855	24	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	1855	25	,	,	,
18637	1855	26	even	even	RB
18637	1855	27	if	if	IN
18637	1855	28	those	those	DT
18637	1855	29	other	other	JJ
18637	1855	30	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	1855	31	would	would	MD
18637	1855	32	not	not	RB
18637	1855	33	alone	alone	RB
18637	1855	34	have	have	VB
18637	1855	35	justified	justify	VBN
18637	1855	36	an	an	DT
18637	1855	37	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1855	38	of	of	IN
18637	1855	39	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	1855	40	power	power	NN
18637	1855	41	.	.	.
18637	1856	1	"	"	``
18637	1856	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1856	3	364	364	CD
18637	1856	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1856	5	And	and	CC
18637	1856	6	in	in	IN
18637	1856	7	the	the	DT
18637	1856	8	Appalachian	Appalachian	NNP
18637	1856	9	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	1856	10	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1856	11	case	case	NN
18637	1856	12	,	,	,
18637	1856	13	the	the	DT
18637	1856	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1856	15	,	,	,
18637	1856	16	abandoning	abandon	VBG
18637	1856	17	previous	previous	JJ
18637	1856	18	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	1856	19	which	which	WDT
18637	1856	20	had	have	VBD
18637	1856	21	laid	lay	VBN
18637	1856	22	down	down	RP
18637	1856	23	the	the	DT
18637	1856	24	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1856	25	that	that	DT
18637	1856	26	to	to	TO
18637	1856	27	be	be	VB
18637	1856	28	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1856	29	to	to	IN
18637	1856	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1856	31	's	's	POS
18637	1856	32	power	power	NN
18637	1856	33	to	to	TO
18637	1856	34	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1856	35	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1856	36	a	a	DT
18637	1856	37	stream	stream	NN
18637	1856	38	must	must	MD
18637	1856	39	be	be	VB
18637	1856	40	"	"	``
18637	1856	41	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	1856	42	in	in	IN
18637	1856	43	fact	fact	NN
18637	1856	44	,	,	,
18637	1856	45	"	"	''
18637	1856	46	said	say	VBD
18637	1856	47	:	:	:
18637	1856	48	"	"	``
18637	1856	49	A	a	DT
18637	1856	50	waterway	waterway	NN
18637	1856	51	,	,	,
18637	1856	52	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	1856	53	suitable	suitable	JJ
18637	1856	54	for	for	IN
18637	1856	55	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1856	56	,	,	,
18637	1856	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	1856	58	not	not	RB
18637	1856	59	barred	bar	VBN
18637	1856	60	from	from	IN
18637	1856	61	that	that	DT
18637	1856	62	classification	classification	NN
18637	1856	63	merely	merely	RB
18637	1856	64	because	because	IN
18637	1856	65	artificial	artificial	JJ
18637	1856	66	aids	aids	NNP
18637	1856	67	must	must	MD
18637	1856	68	make	make	VB
18637	1856	69	the	the	DT
18637	1856	70	highway	highway	NN
18637	1856	71	suitable	suitable	JJ
18637	1856	72	for	for	IN
18637	1856	73	use	use	NN
18637	1856	74	before	before	IN
18637	1856	75	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	1856	76	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1856	77	may	may	MD
18637	1856	78	be	be	VB
18637	1856	79	undertaken	undertake	VBN
18637	1856	80	,	,	,
18637	1856	81	"	"	''
18637	1856	82	provided	provide	VBN
18637	1856	83	there	there	EX
18637	1856	84	must	must	MD
18637	1856	85	be	be	VB
18637	1856	86	a	a	DT
18637	1856	87	"	"	``
18637	1856	88	balance	balance	NN
18637	1856	89	between	between	IN
18637	1856	90	cost	cost	NN
18637	1856	91	and	and	CC
18637	1856	92	need	need	VBP
18637	1856	93	at	at	IN
18637	1856	94	a	a	DT
18637	1856	95	time	time	NN
18637	1856	96	when	when	WRB
18637	1856	97	the	the	DT
18637	1856	98	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	1856	99	would	would	MD
18637	1856	100	be	be	VB
18637	1856	101	useful	useful	JJ
18637	1856	102	.	.	.
18637	1857	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1857	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1857	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1857	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	1857	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	1857	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1857	7	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1857	8	that	that	IN
18637	1857	9	the	the	DT
18637	1857	10	improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	1857	11	should	should	MD
18637	1857	12	be	be	VB
18637	1857	13	actually	actually	RB
18637	1857	14	completed	complete	VBN
18637	1857	15	or	or	CC
18637	1857	16	even	even	RB
18637	1857	17	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	1857	18	.	.	.
18637	1858	1	The	the	DT
18637	1858	2	power	power	NN
18637	1858	3	of	of	IN
18637	1858	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1858	5	over	over	IN
18637	1858	6	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1858	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	1858	8	not	not	RB
18637	1858	9	to	to	TO
18637	1858	10	be	be	VB
18637	1858	11	hampered	hamper	VBN
18637	1858	12	because	because	IN
18637	1858	13	of	of	IN
18637	1858	14	the	the	DT
18637	1858	15	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	1858	16	for	for	IN
18637	1858	17	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	1858	18	improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	1858	19	to	to	TO
18637	1858	20	make	make	VB
18637	1858	21	an	an	DT
18637	1858	22	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1858	23	waterway	waterway	NN
18637	1858	24	available	available	JJ
18637	1858	25	for	for	IN
18637	1858	26	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	1858	27	.	.	.
18637	1859	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1859	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1859	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1859	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	1859	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	1859	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1859	7	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1859	8	for	for	IN
18637	1859	9	navigability	navigability	NN
18637	1859	10	that	that	IN
18637	1859	11	the	the	DT
18637	1859	12	use	use	NN
18637	1859	13	should	should	MD
18637	1859	14	be	be	VB
18637	1859	15	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	1859	16	.	.	.
18637	1860	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1860	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1860	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1860	4	Even	even	RB
18637	1860	5	absence	absence	NN
18637	1860	6	of	of	IN
18637	1860	7	use	use	NN
18637	1860	8	over	over	IN
18637	1860	9	long	long	JJ
18637	1860	10	periods	period	NNS
18637	1860	11	of	of	IN
18637	1860	12	years	year	NNS
18637	1860	13	,	,	,
18637	1860	14	because	because	IN
18637	1860	15	of	of	IN
18637	1860	16	changed	change	VBN
18637	1860	17	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	1860	18	,	,	,
18637	1860	19	*	*	NFP
18637	1860	20	*	*	NFP
18637	1860	21	*	*	NFP
18637	1860	22	does	do	VBZ
18637	1860	23	not	not	RB
18637	1860	24	affect	affect	VB
18637	1860	25	the	the	DT
18637	1860	26	navigability	navigability	NN
18637	1860	27	of	of	IN
18637	1860	28	rivers	river	NNS
18637	1860	29	in	in	IN
18637	1860	30	the	the	DT
18637	1860	31	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1860	32	sense	sense	NN
18637	1860	33	.	.	.
18637	1861	1	"	"	``
18637	1861	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1861	3	365	365	CD
18637	1861	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1861	5	Purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	1861	6	for	for	IN
18637	1861	7	Which	which	WDT
18637	1861	8	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1861	9	May	May	MD
18637	1861	10	be	be	VB
18637	1861	11	Exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	1861	12	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	1861	13	,	,	,
18637	1861	14	the	the	DT
18637	1861	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1861	16	defined	define	VBD
18637	1861	17	the	the	DT
18637	1861	18	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	1861	19	for	for	IN
18637	1861	20	which	which	WDT
18637	1861	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1861	22	may	may	MD
18637	1861	23	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1861	24	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1861	25	in	in	IN
18637	1861	26	the	the	DT
18637	1861	27	broadest	broad	JJS
18637	1861	28	terms	term	NNS
18637	1861	29	,	,	,
18637	1861	30	as	as	IN
18637	1861	31	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	1861	32	:	:	:
18637	1861	33	"	"	``
18637	1861	34	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1861	35	can	can	MD
18637	1861	36	not	not	RB
18637	1861	37	properly	properly	RB
18637	1861	38	be	be	VB
18637	1861	39	said	say	VBN
18637	1861	40	that	that	IN
18637	1861	41	the	the	DT
18637	1861	42	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1861	43	power	power	NN
18637	1861	44	of	of	IN
18637	1861	45	the	the	DT
18637	1861	46	United	United	NNP
18637	1861	47	States	States	NNP
18637	1861	48	over	over	IN
18637	1861	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1861	50	waters	water	NNS
18637	1861	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	1861	52	limited	limit	VBN
18637	1861	53	to	to	TO
18637	1861	54	control	control	VB
18637	1861	55	for	for	IN
18637	1861	56	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1861	57	.	.	.
18637	1862	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1862	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1862	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1862	4	That	that	DT
18637	1862	5	authority	authority	NN
18637	1862	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	1862	7	as	as	RB
18637	1862	8	broad	broad	JJ
18637	1862	9	as	as	IN
18637	1862	10	the	the	DT
18637	1862	11	needs	need	NNS
18637	1862	12	of	of	IN
18637	1862	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1862	14	.	.	.
18637	1863	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1863	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1863	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1863	4	Flood	flood	NN
18637	1863	5	protection	protection	NN
18637	1863	6	,	,	,
18637	1863	7	watershed	watershed	JJ
18637	1863	8	development	development	NN
18637	1863	9	,	,	,
18637	1863	10	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	1863	11	of	of	IN
18637	1863	12	the	the	DT
18637	1863	13	cost	cost	NN
18637	1863	14	of	of	IN
18637	1863	15	improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	1863	16	through	through	IN
18637	1863	17	utilization	utilization	NN
18637	1863	18	of	of	IN
18637	1863	19	power	power	NN
18637	1863	20	are	be	VBP
18637	1863	21	likewise	likewise	RB
18637	1863	22	parts	part	NNS
18637	1863	23	of	of	IN
18637	1863	24	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1863	25	control	control	NN
18637	1863	26	.	.	.
18637	1864	1	"	"	``
18637	1864	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1864	3	366	366	CD
18637	1864	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1864	5	These	these	DT
18637	1864	6	views	view	NNS
18637	1864	7	the	the	DT
18637	1864	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1864	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	1864	10	since	since	RB
18637	1864	11	reiterated	reiterate	VBN
18637	1864	12	.	.	.
18637	1865	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1865	2	367	367	CD
18637	1865	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1865	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	1865	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	1865	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1865	7	by	by	IN
18637	1865	8	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	1865	9	of	of	IN
18637	1865	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1865	11	's	's	POS
18637	1865	12	power	power	NN
18637	1865	13	over	over	IN
18637	1865	14	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	1865	15	alone	alone	RB
18637	1865	16	that	that	IN
18637	1865	17	the	the	DT
18637	1865	18	National	National	NNP
18637	1865	19	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1865	20	may	may	MD
18637	1865	21	develop	develop	VB
18637	1865	22	super	super	JJ
18637	1865	23	-	-	NN
18637	1865	24	power	power	NN
18637	1865	25	.	.	.
18637	1866	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1866	2	war	war	NN
18637	1866	3	powers	power	NNS
18637	1866	4	and	and	CC
18637	1866	5	power	power	NN
18637	1866	6	of	of	IN
18637	1866	7	expenditure	expenditure	NN
18637	1866	8	in	in	IN
18637	1866	9	furtherance	furtherance	NN
18637	1866	10	of	of	IN
18637	1866	11	the	the	DT
18637	1866	12	common	common	JJ
18637	1866	13	defense	defense	NN
18637	1866	14	and	and	CC
18637	1866	15	the	the	DT
18637	1866	16	general	general	JJ
18637	1866	17	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	1866	18	supplement	supplement	VBD
18637	1866	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1866	20	powers	power	NNS
18637	1866	21	over	over	IN
18637	1866	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1866	23	in	in	IN
18637	1866	24	this	this	DT
18637	1866	25	respect	respect	NN
18637	1866	26	.	.	.
18637	1867	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1867	2	368	368	CD
18637	1867	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1867	4	Congressional	Congressional	NNP
18637	1867	5	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	1867	6	of	of	IN
18637	1867	7	Land	Land	NNP
18637	1867	8	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	1867	9	EARLY	early	NN
18637	1867	10	ACTS	act	NNS
18637	1867	11	;	;	:
18637	1867	12	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	1867	13	PROVISION	provision	NN
18637	1867	14	FOR	for	IN
18637	1867	15	HIGHWAYS	highway	NNS
18637	1867	16	The	the	DT
18637	1867	17	acquisition	acquisition	NN
18637	1867	18	and	and	CC
18637	1867	19	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	1867	20	of	of	IN
18637	1867	21	California	California	NNP
18637	1867	22	stimulated	stimulate	VBD
18637	1867	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1867	24	some	some	DT
18637	1867	25	years	year	NNS
18637	1867	26	before	before	IN
18637	1867	27	the	the	DT
18637	1867	28	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	1867	29	War	War	NNP
18637	1867	30	to	to	TO
18637	1867	31	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	1867	32	surveys	survey	NNS
18637	1867	33	of	of	IN
18637	1867	34	possible	possible	JJ
18637	1867	35	routes	route	NNS
18637	1867	36	for	for	IN
18637	1867	37	railway	railway	NN
18637	1867	38	lines	line	NNS
18637	1867	39	to	to	IN
18637	1867	40	the	the	DT
18637	1867	41	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	1867	42	;	;	:
18637	1867	43	but	but	CC
18637	1867	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1867	45	was	be	VBD
18637	1867	46	not	not	RB
18637	1867	47	until	until	IN
18637	1867	48	1862	1862	CD
18637	1867	49	,	,	,
18637	1867	50	in	in	IN
18637	1867	51	the	the	DT
18637	1867	52	midst	midst	NN
18637	1867	53	of	of	IN
18637	1867	54	war	war	NN
18637	1867	55	,	,	,
18637	1867	56	with	with	IN
18637	1867	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1867	58	menace	menace	NN
18637	1867	59	of	of	IN
18637	1867	60	a	a	DT
18637	1867	61	general	general	JJ
18637	1867	62	dissolution	dissolution	NN
18637	1867	63	of	of	IN
18637	1867	64	the	the	DT
18637	1867	65	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1867	66	,	,	,
18637	1867	67	that	that	IN
18637	1867	68	more	more	RBR
18637	1867	69	decisive	decisive	JJ
18637	1867	70	action	action	NN
18637	1867	71	was	be	VBD
18637	1867	72	taken	take	VBN
18637	1867	73	.	.	.
18637	1868	1	That	that	DT
18637	1868	2	year	year	NN
18637	1868	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1868	4	voted	vote	VBD
18637	1868	5	aid	aid	NN
18637	1868	6	in	in	IN
18637	1868	7	the	the	DT
18637	1868	8	construction	construction	NN
18637	1868	9	of	of	IN
18637	1868	10	a	a	DT
18637	1868	11	line	line	NN
18637	1868	12	from	from	IN
18637	1868	13	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	1868	14	River	River	NNP
18637	1868	15	to	to	IN
18637	1868	16	the	the	DT
18637	1868	17	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	1868	18	;	;	:
18637	1868	19	and	and	CC
18637	1868	20	four	four	CD
18637	1868	21	years	year	NNS
18637	1868	22	later	later	RB
18637	1868	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1868	24	chartered	charter	VBD
18637	1868	25	the	the	DT
18637	1868	26	Union	Union	NNP
18637	1868	27	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	1868	28	Company	Company	NNP
18637	1868	29	.	.	.
18637	1869	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1869	2	369	369	CD
18637	1869	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1869	4	First	first	JJ
18637	1869	5	and	and	CC
18637	1869	6	last	last	JJ
18637	1869	7	,	,	,
18637	1869	8	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	1869	9	growing	grow	VBG
18637	1869	10	out	out	IN
18637	1869	11	of	of	IN
18637	1869	12	this	this	DT
18637	1869	13	type	type	NN
18637	1869	14	of	of	IN
18637	1869	15	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1869	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	1869	17	resulted	result	VBN
18637	1869	18	in	in	IN
18637	1869	19	the	the	DT
18637	1869	20	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	1869	21	in	in	IN
18637	1869	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1869	23	decision	decision	NN
18637	1869	24	of	of	IN
18637	1869	25	the	the	DT
18637	1869	26	following	follow	VBG
18637	1869	27	propositions	proposition	NNS
18637	1869	28	:	:	:
18637	1869	29	_	_	NNP
18637	1869	30	First	First	NNP
18637	1869	31	_	_	NNP
18637	1869	32	,	,	,
18637	1869	33	that	that	IN
18637	1869	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1869	35	may	may	MD
18637	1869	36	provide	provide	VB
18637	1869	37	highways	highway	NNS
18637	1869	38	for	for	IN
18637	1869	39	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1869	40	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1869	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1869	42	earlier	early	RBR
18637	1869	43	,	,	,
18637	1869	44	as	as	RB
18637	1869	45	well	well	RB
18637	1869	46	as	as	IN
18637	1869	47	today	today	NN
18637	1869	48	,	,	,
18637	1869	49	this	this	DT
18637	1869	50	result	result	NN
18637	1869	51	might	may	MD
18637	1869	52	have	have	VB
18637	1869	53	followed	follow	VBN
18637	1869	54	from	from	IN
18637	1869	55	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1869	56	's	's	POS
18637	1869	57	power	power	NN
18637	1869	58	of	of	IN
18637	1869	59	spending	spending	NN
18637	1869	60	,	,	,
18637	1869	61	independently	independently	RB
18637	1869	62	of	of	IN
18637	1869	63	the	the	DT
18637	1869	64	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1869	65	clause	clause	NNP
18637	1869	66	,	,	,
18637	1869	67	as	as	RB
18637	1869	68	well	well	RB
18637	1869	69	as	as	IN
18637	1869	70	from	from	IN
18637	1869	71	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1869	72	war	war	NN
18637	1869	73	and	and	CC
18637	1869	74	postal	postal	JJ
18637	1869	75	powers	power	NNS
18637	1869	76	,	,	,
18637	1869	77	which	which	WDT
18637	1869	78	were	be	VBD
18637	1869	79	also	also	RB
18637	1869	80	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	1869	81	by	by	IN
18637	1869	82	the	the	DT
18637	1869	83	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1869	84	in	in	IN
18637	1869	85	this	this	DT
18637	1869	86	connection	connection	NN
18637	1869	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1869	88	;	;	:
18637	1869	89	_	_	NNP
18637	1869	90	second	second	JJ
18637	1869	91	_	_	NNP
18637	1869	92	,	,	,
18637	1869	93	that	that	IN
18637	1869	94	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1869	95	may	may	MD
18637	1869	96	charter	charter	VB
18637	1869	97	private	private	JJ
18637	1869	98	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	1869	99	for	for	IN
18637	1869	100	the	the	DT
18637	1869	101	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1869	102	of	of	IN
18637	1869	103	doing	do	VBG
18637	1869	104	the	the	DT
18637	1869	105	same	same	JJ
18637	1869	106	thing	thing	NN
18637	1869	107	;	;	:
18637	1869	108	_	_	NNP
18637	1869	109	third	third	JJ
18637	1869	110	_	_	NNP
18637	1869	111	,	,	,
18637	1869	112	that	that	IN
18637	1869	113	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1869	114	may	may	MD
18637	1869	115	vest	vest	VB
18637	1869	116	such	such	JJ
18637	1869	117	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	1869	118	with	with	IN
18637	1869	119	the	the	DT
18637	1869	120	power	power	NN
18637	1869	121	of	of	IN
18637	1869	122	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	1869	123	domain	domain	NN
18637	1869	124	in	in	IN
18637	1869	125	the	the	DT
18637	1869	126	States	States	NNPS
18637	1869	127	;	;	:
18637	1869	128	and	and	CC
18637	1869	129	_	_	NNP
18637	1869	130	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	1869	131	_	_	NNP
18637	1869	132	,	,	,
18637	1869	133	that	that	IN
18637	1869	134	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1869	135	may	may	MD
18637	1869	136	exempt	exempt	VB
18637	1869	137	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1869	138	franchises	franchise	NNS
18637	1869	139	from	from	IN
18637	1869	140	State	state	NN
18637	1869	141	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1869	142	.	.	.
18637	1870	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1870	2	370	370	CD
18637	1870	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1870	4	BEGINNINGS	beginning	NNS
18637	1870	5	OF	of	IN
18637	1870	6	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	1870	7	RAILWAY	RAILWAY	NNP
18637	1870	8	REGULATION	regulation	NN
18637	1870	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1870	10	began	begin	VBD
18637	1870	11	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	1870	12	the	the	DT
18637	1870	13	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	1870	14	of	of	IN
18637	1870	15	the	the	DT
18637	1870	16	country	country	NN
18637	1870	17	in	in	IN
18637	1870	18	a	a	DT
18637	1870	19	more	more	RBR
18637	1870	20	positive	positive	JJ
18637	1870	21	sense	sense	NN
18637	1870	22	in	in	IN
18637	1870	23	1866	1866	CD
18637	1870	24	.	.	.
18637	1871	1	By	by	IN
18637	1871	2	the	the	DT
18637	1871	3	so	so	RB
18637	1871	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	1871	5	called	call	VBN
18637	1871	6	Garfield	Garfield	NNP
18637	1871	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1871	8	of	of	IN
18637	1871	9	that	that	DT
18637	1871	10	year	year	NN
18637	1871	11	"	"	``
18637	1871	12	every	every	DT
18637	1871	13	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	1871	14	company	company	NN
18637	1871	15	in	in	IN
18637	1871	16	the	the	DT
18637	1871	17	United	United	NNP
18637	1871	18	States	States	NNP
18637	1871	19	,	,	,
18637	1871	20	whose	whose	WP$
18637	1871	21	road	road	NN
18637	1871	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	1871	23	operated	operate	VBN
18637	1871	24	by	by	IN
18637	1871	25	steam	steam	NN
18637	1871	26	,	,	,
18637	1871	27	"	"	''
18637	1871	28	was	be	VBD
18637	1871	29	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	1871	30	by	by	IN
18637	1871	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1871	32	"	"	''
18637	1871	33	*	*	NFP
18637	1871	34	*	*	NFP
18637	1871	35	*	*	NFP
18637	1871	36	to	to	TO
18637	1871	37	connect	connect	VB
18637	1871	38	with	with	IN
18637	1871	39	roads	road	NNS
18637	1871	40	of	of	IN
18637	1871	41	other	other	JJ
18637	1871	42	States	States	NNPS
18637	1871	43	so	so	IN
18637	1871	44	as	as	IN
18637	1871	45	to	to	TO
18637	1871	46	form	form	VB
18637	1871	47	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	1871	48	lines	line	NNS
18637	1871	49	for	for	IN
18637	1871	50	the	the	DT
18637	1871	51	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1871	52	of	of	IN
18637	1871	53	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	1871	54	,	,	,
18637	1871	55	freight	freight	NN
18637	1871	56	,	,	,
18637	1871	57	troops	troop	NNS
18637	1871	58	,	,	,
18637	1871	59	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	1871	60	supplies	supply	NNS
18637	1871	61	,	,	,
18637	1871	62	and	and	CC
18637	1871	63	mails	mail	NNS
18637	1871	64	,	,	,
18637	1871	65	to	to	IN
18637	1871	66	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1871	67	destination";[371	destination";[371	''
18637	1871	68	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1871	69	while	while	IN
18637	1871	70	by	by	IN
18637	1871	71	an	an	DT
18637	1871	72	act	act	NN
18637	1871	73	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1871	74	on	on	IN
18637	1871	75	July	July	NNP
18637	1871	76	24	24	CD
18637	1871	77	of	of	IN
18637	1871	78	the	the	DT
18637	1871	79	same	same	JJ
18637	1871	80	year	year	NN
18637	1871	81	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1871	82	was	be	VBD
18637	1871	83	ordered	order	VBN
18637	1871	84	,	,	,
18637	1871	85	"	"	``
18637	1871	86	in	in	IN
18637	1871	87	the	the	DT
18637	1871	88	interest	interest	NN
18637	1871	89	of	of	IN
18637	1871	90	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1871	91	and	and	CC
18637	1871	92	the	the	DT
18637	1871	93	convenient	convenient	JJ
18637	1871	94	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	1871	95	of	of	IN
18637	1871	96	intelligence	intelligence	NN
18637	1871	97	*	*	NFP
18637	1871	98	*	*	NFP
18637	1871	99	*	*	NFP
18637	1871	100	by	by	IN
18637	1871	101	the	the	DT
18637	1871	102	government	government	NN
18637	1871	103	of	of	IN
18637	1871	104	the	the	DT
18637	1871	105	United	United	NNP
18637	1871	106	States	States	NNP
18637	1871	107	and	and	CC
18637	1871	108	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1871	109	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	1871	110	,	,	,
18637	1871	111	that	that	IN
18637	1871	112	the	the	DT
18637	1871	113	erection	erection	NN
18637	1871	114	of	of	IN
18637	1871	115	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	1871	116	lines	line	NNS
18637	1871	117	shall	shall	MD
18637	1871	118	,	,	,
18637	1871	119	so	so	RB
18637	1871	120	far	far	RB
18637	1871	121	as	as	IN
18637	1871	122	State	state	NN
18637	1871	123	interference	interference	NN
18637	1871	124	is	be	VBZ
18637	1871	125	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	1871	126	,	,	,
18637	1871	127	be	be	VB
18637	1871	128	free	free	JJ
18637	1871	129	to	to	IN
18637	1871	130	all	all	DT
18637	1871	131	who	who	WP
18637	1871	132	will	will	MD
18637	1871	133	submit	submit	VB
18637	1871	134	to	to	IN
18637	1871	135	the	the	DT
18637	1871	136	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	1871	137	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	1871	138	by	by	IN
18637	1871	139	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1871	140	,	,	,
18637	1871	141	and	and	CC
18637	1871	142	that	that	IN
18637	1871	143	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	1871	144	organized	organize	VBN
18637	1871	145	under	under	IN
18637	1871	146	the	the	DT
18637	1871	147	laws	law	NNS
18637	1871	148	of	of	IN
18637	1871	149	one	one	CD
18637	1871	150	State	state	NN
18637	1871	151	for	for	IN
18637	1871	152	constructing	construct	VBG
18637	1871	153	and	and	CC
18637	1871	154	operating	operate	VBG
18637	1871	155	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	1871	156	lines	line	NNS
18637	1871	157	shall	shall	MD
18637	1871	158	not	not	RB
18637	1871	159	be	be	VB
18637	1871	160	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	1871	161	by	by	IN
18637	1871	162	another	another	DT
18637	1871	163	from	from	IN
18637	1871	164	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
18637	1871	165	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1871	166	business	business	NN
18637	1871	167	within	within	IN
18637	1871	168	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1871	169	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	1871	170	,	,	,
18637	1871	171	if	if	IN
18637	1871	172	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1871	173	accept	accept	VBP
18637	1871	174	the	the	DT
18637	1871	175	terms	term	NNS
18637	1871	176	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	1871	177	by	by	IN
18637	1871	178	the	the	DT
18637	1871	179	National	National	NNP
18637	1871	180	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1871	181	for	for	IN
18637	1871	182	this	this	DT
18637	1871	183	national	national	JJ
18637	1871	184	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	1871	185	.	.	.
18637	1872	1	"	"	``
18637	1872	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1872	3	372	372	CD
18637	1872	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1872	5	Another	another	DT
18637	1872	6	act	act	NN
18637	1872	7	of	of	IN
18637	1872	8	the	the	DT
18637	1872	9	same	same	JJ
18637	1872	10	period	period	NN
18637	1872	11	provided	provide	VBD
18637	1872	12	that	that	IN
18637	1872	13	"	"	``
18637	1872	14	no	no	DT
18637	1872	15	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	1872	16	company	company	NN
18637	1872	17	within	within	IN
18637	1872	18	the	the	DT
18637	1872	19	United	United	NNP
18637	1872	20	States	States	NNP
18637	1872	21	whose	whose	WP$
18637	1872	22	road	road	NN
18637	1872	23	forms	form	VBZ
18637	1872	24	any	any	DT
18637	1872	25	part	part	NN
18637	1872	26	of	of	IN
18637	1872	27	a	a	DT
18637	1872	28	line	line	NN
18637	1872	29	of	of	IN
18637	1872	30	road	road	NN
18637	1872	31	over	over	IN
18637	1872	32	which	which	WDT
18637	1872	33	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	1872	34	,	,	,
18637	1872	35	sheep	sheep	NNS
18637	1872	36	,	,	,
18637	1872	37	swine	swine	NNS
18637	1872	38	,	,	,
18637	1872	39	or	or	CC
18637	1872	40	other	other	JJ
18637	1872	41	animals	animal	NNS
18637	1872	42	are	be	VBP
18637	1872	43	conveyed	convey	VBN
18637	1872	44	from	from	IN
18637	1872	45	one	one	CD
18637	1872	46	State	state	NN
18637	1872	47	to	to	IN
18637	1872	48	another	another	DT
18637	1872	49	,	,	,
18637	1872	50	or	or	CC
18637	1872	51	the	the	DT
18637	1872	52	owners	owner	NNS
18637	1872	53	or	or	CC
18637	1872	54	masters	master	NNS
18637	1872	55	of	of	IN
18637	1872	56	steam	steam	NN
18637	1872	57	,	,	,
18637	1872	58	sailing	sailing	NN
18637	1872	59	,	,	,
18637	1872	60	or	or	CC
18637	1872	61	other	other	JJ
18637	1872	62	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	1872	63	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	1872	64	or	or	CC
18637	1872	65	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	1872	66	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	1872	67	,	,	,
18637	1872	68	sheep	sheep	NNS
18637	1872	69	,	,	,
18637	1872	70	swine	swine	NNS
18637	1872	71	,	,	,
18637	1872	72	or	or	CC
18637	1872	73	other	other	JJ
18637	1872	74	animals	animal	NNS
18637	1872	75	from	from	IN
18637	1872	76	one	one	CD
18637	1872	77	State	state	NN
18637	1872	78	to	to	IN
18637	1872	79	another	another	DT
18637	1872	80	,	,	,
18637	1872	81	shall	shall	MD
18637	1872	82	confine	confine	VB
18637	1872	83	the	the	DT
18637	1872	84	same	same	JJ
18637	1872	85	in	in	IN
18637	1872	86	cars	car	NNS
18637	1872	87	,	,	,
18637	1872	88	boats	boat	NNS
18637	1872	89	,	,	,
18637	1872	90	or	or	CC
18637	1872	91	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	1872	92	of	of	IN
18637	1872	93	any	any	DT
18637	1872	94	description	description	NN
18637	1872	95	,	,	,
18637	1872	96	for	for	IN
18637	1872	97	a	a	DT
18637	1872	98	longer	long	JJR
18637	1872	99	period	period	NN
18637	1872	100	than	than	IN
18637	1872	101	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	1872	102	-	-	HYPH
18637	1872	103	eight	eight	CD
18637	1872	104	consecutive	consecutive	JJ
18637	1872	105	hours	hour	NNS
18637	1872	106	,	,	,
18637	1872	107	without	without	IN
18637	1872	108	unloading	unload	VBG
18637	1872	109	the	the	DT
18637	1872	110	same	same	JJ
18637	1872	111	for	for	IN
18637	1872	112	rest	rest	NN
18637	1872	113	,	,	,
18637	1872	114	water	water	NN
18637	1872	115	,	,	,
18637	1872	116	and	and	CC
18637	1872	117	feeding	feeding	NN
18637	1872	118	,	,	,
18637	1872	119	for	for	IN
18637	1872	120	a	a	DT
18637	1872	121	period	period	NN
18637	1872	122	of	of	IN
18637	1872	123	at	at	RB
18637	1872	124	least	least	RBS
18637	1872	125	five	five	CD
18637	1872	126	consecutive	consecutive	JJ
18637	1872	127	hours	hour	NNS
18637	1872	128	,	,	,
18637	1872	129	unless	unless	IN
18637	1872	130	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	1872	131	from	from	IN
18637	1872	132	so	so	RB
18637	1872	133	unloading	unloading	NN
18637	1872	134	by	by	IN
18637	1872	135	storm	storm	NN
18637	1872	136	or	or	CC
18637	1872	137	other	other	JJ
18637	1872	138	accidental	accidental	JJ
18637	1872	139	causes	cause	NNS
18637	1872	140	.	.	.
18637	1873	1	"	"	``
18637	1873	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1873	3	373	373	CD
18637	1873	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1873	5	REGULATION	regulation	NN
18637	1873	6	OF	of	IN
18637	1873	7	RAILROAD	railroad	NN
18637	1873	8	RATES	rate	NNS
18637	1873	9	:	:	:
18637	1873	10	THE	the	DT
18637	1873	11	INTERSTATE	INTERSTATE	NNP
18637	1873	12	COMMERCE	COMMERCE	NNP
18637	1873	13	COMMISSION	COMMISSION	NNP
18637	1873	14	On	on	IN
18637	1873	15	account	account	NN
18637	1873	16	of	of	IN
18637	1873	17	the	the	DT
18637	1873	18	large	large	JJ
18637	1873	19	element	element	NN
18637	1873	20	of	of	IN
18637	1873	21	"	"	``
18637	1873	22	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	1873	23	charges	charge	NNS
18637	1873	24	"	"	''
18637	1873	25	which	which	WDT
18637	1873	26	enters	enter	VBZ
18637	1873	27	into	into	IN
18637	1873	28	the	the	DT
18637	1873	29	setting	setting	NN
18637	1873	30	of	of	IN
18637	1873	31	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1873	32	by	by	IN
18637	1873	33	railway	railway	NN
18637	1873	34	companies	company	NNS
18637	1873	35	,	,	,
18637	1873	36	competition	competition	NN
18637	1873	37	between	between	IN
18637	1873	38	lines	line	NNS
18637	1873	39	for	for	IN
18637	1873	40	new	new	JJ
18637	1873	41	business	business	NN
18637	1873	42	was	be	VBD
18637	1873	43	from	from	IN
18637	1873	44	the	the	DT
18637	1873	45	first	first	JJ
18637	1873	46	very	very	RB
18637	1873	47	sharp	sharp	JJ
18637	1873	48	,	,	,
18637	1873	49	and	and	CC
18637	1873	50	resulted	result	VBD
18637	1873	51	in	in	IN
18637	1873	52	many	many	JJ
18637	1873	53	evils	evil	NNS
18637	1873	54	which	which	WDT
18637	1873	55	,	,	,
18637	1873	56	in	in	IN
18637	1873	57	the	the	DT
18637	1873	58	early	early	JJ
18637	1873	59	70	70	CD
18637	1873	60	's	's	POS
18637	1873	61	,	,	,
18637	1873	62	led	lead	VBN
18637	1873	63	in	in	IN
18637	1873	64	the	the	DT
18637	1873	65	Middle	Middle	NNP
18637	1873	66	West	West	NNP
18637	1873	67	to	to	IN
18637	1873	68	the	the	DT
18637	1873	69	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	1873	70	by	by	IN
18637	1873	71	the	the	DT
18637	1873	72	State	State	NNP
18637	1873	73	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	1873	74	of	of	IN
18637	1873	75	the	the	DT
18637	1873	76	so	so	RB
18637	1873	77	-	-	HYPH
18637	1873	78	called	call	VBN
18637	1873	79	"	"	``
18637	1873	80	Granger	Granger	NNP
18637	1873	81	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	1873	82	"	"	''
18637	1873	83	;	;	:
18637	1873	84	and	and	CC
18637	1873	85	in	in	IN
18637	1873	86	the	the	DT
18637	1873	87	famous	famous	JJ
18637	1873	88	"	"	``
18637	1873	89	Granger	Granger	NNP
18637	1873	90	Cases	case	NNS
18637	1873	91	,	,	,
18637	1873	92	"	"	''
18637	1873	93	headed	head	VBN
18637	1873	94	by	by	IN
18637	1873	95	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	1873	96	_	_	NNP
18637	1873	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	1873	98	_	_	NNP
18637	1873	99	Illinois,[374	Illinois,[374	NNP
18637	1873	100	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1873	101	the	the	DT
18637	1873	102	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1873	103	at	at	IN
18637	1873	104	first	first	RB
18637	1873	105	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1873	106	this	this	DT
18637	1873	107	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1873	108	,	,	,
18637	1873	109	in	in	IN
18637	1873	110	relation	relation	NN
18637	1873	111	to	to	IN
18637	1873	112	both	both	DT
18637	1873	113	the	the	DT
18637	1873	114	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1873	115	clause	clause	NNP
18637	1873	116	and	and	CC
18637	1873	117	the	the	DT
18637	1873	118	due	due	JJ
18637	1873	119	process	process	NN
18637	1873	120	of	of	IN
18637	1873	121	law	law	NN
18637	1873	122	clause	clause	NN
18637	1873	123	of	of	IN
18637	1873	124	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1873	125	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	1873	126	.	.	.
18637	1874	1	The	the	DT
18637	1874	2	principal	principal	JJ
18637	1874	3	circumstance	circumstance	NN
18637	1874	4	,	,	,
18637	1874	5	however	however	RB
18637	1874	6	,	,	,
18637	1874	7	which	which	WDT
18637	1874	8	shaped	shape	VBD
18637	1874	9	the	the	DT
18637	1874	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1874	11	's	's	POS
18637	1874	12	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	1874	13	toward	toward	IN
18637	1874	14	the	the	DT
18637	1874	15	"	"	``
18637	1874	16	Granger	Granger	NNP
18637	1874	17	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	1874	18	"	"	''
18637	1874	19	had	have	VBD
18637	1874	20	,	,	,
18637	1874	21	by	by	IN
18637	1874	22	a	a	DT
18637	1874	23	decade	decade	NN
18637	1874	24	later	later	RB
18637	1874	25	,	,	,
18637	1874	26	disappeared	disappear	VBD
18637	1874	27	,	,	,
18637	1874	28	the	the	DT
18637	1874	29	fact	fact	NN
18637	1874	30	,	,	,
18637	1874	31	namely	namely	RB
18637	1874	32	,	,	,
18637	1874	33	that	that	IN
18637	1874	34	originally	originally	RB
18637	1874	35	the	the	DT
18637	1874	36	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	1874	37	business	business	NN
18637	1874	38	was	be	VBD
18637	1874	39	largely	largely	RB
18637	1874	40	in	in	IN
18637	1874	41	local	local	JJ
18637	1874	42	hands	hand	NNS
18637	1874	43	.	.	.
18637	1875	1	In	in	IN
18637	1875	2	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	1875	3	,	,	,
18637	1875	4	first	first	RB
18637	1875	5	,	,	,
18637	1875	6	of	of	IN
18637	1875	7	the	the	DT
18637	1875	8	panic	panic	NN
18637	1875	9	of	of	IN
18637	1875	10	1873	1873	CD
18637	1875	11	,	,	,
18637	1875	12	and	and	CC
18637	1875	13	then	then	RB
18637	1875	14	of	of	IN
18637	1875	15	the	the	DT
18637	1875	16	panic	panic	NN
18637	1875	17	of	of	IN
18637	1875	18	1885	1885	CD
18637	1875	19	,	,	,
18637	1875	20	hundreds	hundred	NNS
18637	1875	21	of	of	IN
18637	1875	22	these	these	DT
18637	1875	23	small	small	JJ
18637	1875	24	lines	line	NNS
18637	1875	25	went	go	VBD
18637	1875	26	into	into	IN
18637	1875	27	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	1875	28	,	,	,
18637	1875	29	from	from	IN
18637	1875	30	which	which	WDT
18637	1875	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1875	32	emerged	emerge	VBD
18637	1875	33	consolidated	consolidate	VBN
18637	1875	34	into	into	IN
18637	1875	35	great	great	JJ
18637	1875	36	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1875	37	systems	system	NNS
18637	1875	38	.	.	.
18637	1876	1	The	the	DT
18637	1876	2	result	result	NN
18637	1876	3	for	for	IN
18637	1876	4	the	the	DT
18637	1876	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1876	6	's	's	POS
18637	1876	7	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	1876	8	of	of	IN
18637	1876	9	the	the	DT
18637	1876	10	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1876	11	clause	clause	NNP
18637	1876	12	was	be	VBD
18637	1876	13	determinative	determinative	JJ
18637	1876	14	.	.	.
18637	1877	1	In	in	IN
18637	1877	2	the	the	DT
18637	1877	3	case	case	NN
18637	1877	4	of	of	IN
18637	1877	5	Wabash	Wabash	NNP
18637	1877	6	,	,	,
18637	1877	7	St.	St.	NNP
18637	1877	8	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	1877	9	and	and	CC
18637	1877	10	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	1877	11	R.	R.	NNP
18637	1877	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	1877	13	_	_	NNP
18637	1877	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	1877	15	_	_	NNP
18637	1877	16	Illinois,[375	Illinois,[375	NNP
18637	1877	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1877	18	decided	decide	VBD
18637	1877	19	in	in	IN
18637	1877	20	1886	1886	CD
18637	1877	21	,	,	,
18637	1877	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1877	23	was	be	VBD
18637	1877	24	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	1877	25	that	that	IN
18637	1877	26	a	a	DT
18637	1877	27	State	state	NN
18637	1877	28	may	may	MD
18637	1877	29	not	not	RB
18637	1877	30	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1877	31	charges	charge	NNS
18637	1877	32	for	for	IN
18637	1877	33	the	the	DT
18637	1877	34	carriage	carriage	NN
18637	1877	35	even	even	RB
18637	1877	36	within	within	IN
18637	1877	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1877	38	own	own	JJ
18637	1877	39	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	1877	40	of	of	IN
18637	1877	41	goods	good	NNS
18637	1877	42	brought	bring	VBN
18637	1877	43	from	from	IN
18637	1877	44	without	without	IN
18637	1877	45	the	the	DT
18637	1877	46	State	State	NNP
18637	1877	47	or	or	CC
18637	1877	48	destined	destine	VBN
18637	1877	49	to	to	IN
18637	1877	50	points	point	NNS
18637	1877	51	outside	outside	IN
18637	1877	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1877	53	;	;	:
18637	1877	54	that	that	IN
18637	1877	55	in	in	IN
18637	1877	56	this	this	DT
18637	1877	57	respect	respect	NN
18637	1877	58	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1877	59	's	's	POS
18637	1877	60	power	power	NN
18637	1877	61	over	over	IN
18637	1877	62	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1877	63	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1877	64	was	be	VBD
18637	1877	65	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	1877	66	.	.	.
18637	1878	1	The	the	DT
18637	1878	2	following	following	JJ
18637	1878	3	year	year	NN
18637	1878	4	,	,	,
18637	1878	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1878	6	,	,	,
18637	1878	7	responding	respond	VBG
18637	1878	8	to	to	IN
18637	1878	9	a	a	DT
18637	1878	10	widespread	widespread	JJ
18637	1878	11	public	public	JJ
18637	1878	12	demand	demand	NN
18637	1878	13	,	,	,
18637	1878	14	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1878	15	the	the	DT
18637	1878	16	original	original	JJ
18637	1878	17	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	1878	18	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1878	19	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1878	20	.	.	.
18637	1879	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1879	2	376	376	CD
18637	1879	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1879	4	By	by	IN
18637	1879	5	this	this	DT
18637	1879	6	measure	measure	NN
18637	1879	7	a	a	DT
18637	1879	8	commission	commission	NN
18637	1879	9	of	of	IN
18637	1879	10	five	five	CD
18637	1879	11	was	be	VBD
18637	1879	12	created	create	VBN
18637	1879	13	with	with	IN
18637	1879	14	authority	authority	NN
18637	1879	15	to	to	TO
18637	1879	16	pass	pass	VB
18637	1879	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	1879	18	the	the	DT
18637	1879	19	"	"	``
18637	1879	20	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	1879	21	"	"	''
18637	1879	22	of	of	IN
18637	1879	23	all	all	DT
18637	1879	24	charges	charge	NNS
18637	1879	25	by	by	IN
18637	1879	26	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	1879	27	for	for	IN
18637	1879	28	the	the	DT
18637	1879	29	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1879	30	of	of	IN
18637	1879	31	goods	good	NNS
18637	1879	32	or	or	CC
18637	1879	33	persons	person	NNS
18637	1879	34	in	in	IN
18637	1879	35	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1879	36	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1879	37	and	and	CC
18637	1879	38	to	to	TO
18637	1879	39	order	order	VB
18637	1879	40	the	the	DT
18637	1879	41	discontinuance	discontinuance	NN
18637	1879	42	of	of	IN
18637	1879	43	all	all	DT
18637	1879	44	such	such	JJ
18637	1879	45	charges	charge	NNS
18637	1879	46	as	as	IN
18637	1879	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1879	48	found	find	VBD
18637	1879	49	to	to	TO
18637	1879	50	be	be	VB
18637	1879	51	"	"	``
18637	1879	52	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	1879	53	,	,	,
18637	1879	54	"	"	''
18637	1879	55	or	or	CC
18637	1879	56	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	1879	57	violative	violative	JJ
18637	1879	58	of	of	IN
18637	1879	59	the	the	DT
18637	1879	60	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	1879	61	of	of	IN
18637	1879	62	the	the	DT
18637	1879	63	act	act	NN
18637	1879	64	.	.	.
18637	1880	1	In	in	IN
18637	1880	2	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	1880	3	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1880	4	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1880	5	_	_	NNP
18637	1880	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	1880	7	_	_	NNP
18637	1880	8	Brimson,[377	Brimson,[377	NNP
18637	1880	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1880	10	decided	decide	VBD
18637	1880	11	in	in	IN
18637	1880	12	1894	1894	CD
18637	1880	13	,	,	,
18637	1880	14	the	the	DT
18637	1880	15	validity	validity	NN
18637	1880	16	of	of	IN
18637	1880	17	the	the	DT
18637	1880	18	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1880	19	as	as	IN
18637	1880	20	a	a	DT
18637	1880	21	means	means	NN
18637	1880	22	"	"	``
18637	1880	23	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1880	24	and	and	CC
18637	1880	25	proper	proper	JJ
18637	1880	26	"	"	''
18637	1880	27	for	for	IN
18637	1880	28	the	the	DT
18637	1880	29	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	1880	30	of	of	IN
18637	1880	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1880	32	's	's	POS
18637	1880	33	power	power	NN
18637	1880	34	to	to	TO
18637	1880	35	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1880	36	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1880	37	among	among	IN
18637	1880	38	the	the	DT
18637	1880	39	States	States	NNP
18637	1880	40	was	be	VBD
18637	1880	41	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	1880	42	,	,	,
18637	1880	43	as	as	RB
18637	1880	44	well	well	RB
18637	1880	45	as	as	IN
18637	1880	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1880	47	right	right	NN
18637	1880	48	to	to	TO
18637	1880	49	enter	enter	VB
18637	1880	50	the	the	DT
18637	1880	51	courts	court	NNS
18637	1880	52	of	of	IN
18637	1880	53	the	the	DT
18637	1880	54	United	United	NNP
18637	1880	55	States	States	NNP
18637	1880	56	in	in	IN
18637	1880	57	order	order	NN
18637	1880	58	to	to	TO
18637	1880	59	secure	secure	VB
18637	1880	60	process	process	NN
18637	1880	61	for	for	IN
18637	1880	62	the	the	DT
18637	1880	63	execution	execution	NN
18637	1880	64	of	of	IN
18637	1880	65	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1880	66	orders	order	NNS
18637	1880	67	.	.	.
18637	1881	1	Later	later	JJ
18637	1881	2	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	1881	3	of	of	IN
18637	1881	4	the	the	DT
18637	1881	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1881	6	,	,	,
18637	1881	7	however	however	RB
18637	1881	8	,	,	,
18637	1881	9	including	include	VBG
18637	1881	10	one	one	CD
18637	1881	11	in	in	IN
18637	1881	12	which	which	WDT
18637	1881	13	the	the	DT
18637	1881	14	act	act	NN
18637	1881	15	was	be	VBD
18637	1881	16	construed	construe	VBN
18637	1881	17	not	not	RB
18637	1881	18	to	to	TO
18637	1881	19	give	give	VB
18637	1881	20	the	the	DT
18637	1881	21	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1881	22	power	power	NN
18637	1881	23	to	to	TO
18637	1881	24	set	set	VB
18637	1881	25	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	1881	26	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	1881	27	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1881	28	in	in	IN
18637	1881	29	substitution	substitution	NN
18637	1881	30	for	for	IN
18637	1881	31	those	those	DT
18637	1881	32	found	find	VBN
18637	1881	33	by	by	IN
18637	1881	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1881	35	to	to	TO
18637	1881	36	be	be	VB
18637	1881	37	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	1881	38	,	,	,
18637	1881	39	disappointed	disappoint	VBN
18637	1881	40	earlier	early	JJR
18637	1881	41	expectations	expectation	NNS
18637	1881	42	.	.	.
18637	1882	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1882	2	378	378	CD
18637	1882	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1882	4	The	the	DT
18637	1882	5	history	history	NN
18637	1882	6	of	of	IN
18637	1882	7	the	the	DT
18637	1882	8	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1882	9	as	as	IN
18637	1882	10	an	an	DT
18637	1882	11	effective	effective	JJ
18637	1882	12	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	1882	13	of	of	IN
18637	1882	14	government	government	NN
18637	1882	15	dates	date	VBZ
18637	1882	16	from	from	IN
18637	1882	17	the	the	DT
18637	1882	18	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	1882	19	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1882	20	of	of	IN
18637	1882	21	1906[379	1906[379	CD
18637	1882	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1882	23	which	which	WDT
18637	1882	24	was	be	VBD
18637	1882	25	followed	follow	VBN
18637	1882	26	four	four	CD
18637	1882	27	years	year	NNS
18637	1882	28	later	later	RB
18637	1882	29	by	by	IN
18637	1882	30	the	the	DT
18637	1882	31	Mann	Mann	NNP
18637	1882	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	1882	33	Elkins	Elkins	NNP
18637	1882	34	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1882	35	.	.	.
18637	1883	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1883	2	380	380	CD
18637	1883	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1883	4	By	by	IN
18637	1883	5	the	the	DT
18637	1883	6	former	former	JJ
18637	1883	7	the	the	DT
18637	1883	8	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1883	9	was	be	VBD
18637	1883	10	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	1883	11	endowed	endow	VBN
18637	1883	12	with	with	IN
18637	1883	13	the	the	DT
18637	1883	14	power	power	NN
18637	1883	15	,	,	,
18637	1883	16	after	after	IN
18637	1883	17	a	a	DT
18637	1883	18	full	full	JJ
18637	1883	19	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	1883	20	on	on	IN
18637	1883	21	a	a	DT
18637	1883	22	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	1883	23	made	make	VBN
18637	1883	24	to	to	IN
18637	1883	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1883	26	,	,	,
18637	1883	27	"	"	''
18637	1883	28	to	to	TO
18637	1883	29	determine	determine	VB
18637	1883	30	and	and	CC
18637	1883	31	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	1883	32	just	just	RB
18637	1883	33	and	and	CC
18637	1883	34	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	1883	35	"	"	''
18637	1883	36	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	1883	37	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1883	38	.	.	.
18637	1884	1	By	by	IN
18637	1884	2	the	the	DT
18637	1884	3	latter	latter	JJ
18637	1884	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1884	5	was	be	VBD
18637	1884	6	further	far	RBR
18637	1884	7	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	1884	8	to	to	TO
18637	1884	9	set	set	VB
18637	1884	10	such	such	JJ
18637	1884	11	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1884	12	on	on	IN
18637	1884	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1884	14	own	own	JJ
18637	1884	15	initiative	initiative	NN
18637	1884	16	,	,	,
18637	1884	17	and	and	CC
18637	1884	18	without	without	IN
18637	1884	19	waiting	wait	VBG
18637	1884	20	for	for	IN
18637	1884	21	a	a	DT
18637	1884	22	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	1884	23	;	;	:
18637	1884	24	while	while	IN
18637	1884	25	any	any	DT
18637	1884	26	increase	increase	NN
18637	1884	27	of	of	IN
18637	1884	28	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1884	29	by	by	IN
18637	1884	30	a	a	DT
18637	1884	31	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	1884	32	was	be	VBD
18637	1884	33	made	make	VBN
18637	1884	34	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1884	35	to	to	IN
18637	1884	36	suspension	suspension	NN
18637	1884	37	by	by	IN
18637	1884	38	the	the	DT
18637	1884	39	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1884	40	until	until	IN
18637	1884	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1884	42	approval	approval	NN
18637	1884	43	could	could	MD
18637	1884	44	be	be	VB
18637	1884	45	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	1884	46	.	.	.
18637	1885	1	At	at	IN
18637	1885	2	the	the	DT
18637	1885	3	same	same	JJ
18637	1885	4	time	time	NN
18637	1885	5	,	,	,
18637	1885	6	the	the	DT
18637	1885	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1885	8	's	's	POS
18637	1885	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	1885	10	was	be	VBD
18637	1885	11	extended	extend	VBN
18637	1885	12	to	to	IN
18637	1885	13	telegraphs	telegraphs	NN
18637	1885	14	,	,	,
18637	1885	15	telephones	telephone	NNS
18637	1885	16	and	and	CC
18637	1885	17	cables	cable	NNS
18637	1885	18	.	.	.
18637	1886	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1886	2	381	381	CD
18637	1886	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1886	4	THE	the	DT
18637	1886	5	INTERSTATE	INTERSTATE	NNP
18637	1886	6	COMMERCE	COMMERCE	NNP
18637	1886	7	COMMISSION	COMMISSION	NNP
18637	1886	8	TODAY	today	NN
18637	1886	9	The	the	DT
18637	1886	10	powers	power	NNS
18637	1886	11	of	of	IN
18637	1886	12	the	the	DT
18637	1886	13	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1886	14	,	,	,
18637	1886	15	which	which	WDT
18637	1886	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	1886	17	been	be	VBN
18637	1886	18	gradually	gradually	RB
18637	1886	19	increased	increase	VBN
18637	1886	20	to	to	IN
18637	1886	21	a	a	DT
18637	1886	22	body	body	NN
18637	1886	23	of	of	IN
18637	1886	24	eleven	eleven	CD
18637	1886	25	,	,	,
18637	1886	26	are	be	VBP
18637	1886	27	today	today	NN
18637	1886	28	largely	largely	RB
18637	1886	29	defined	define	VBN
18637	1886	30	in	in	IN
18637	1886	31	the	the	DT
18637	1886	32	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	1886	33	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1886	34	of	of	IN
18637	1886	35	February	February	NNP
18637	1886	36	28	28	CD
18637	1886	37	,	,	,
18637	1886	38	1920	1920	CD
18637	1886	39	.	.	.
18637	1887	1	By	by	IN
18637	1887	2	that	that	DT
18637	1887	3	act	act	NN
18637	1887	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1887	5	were	be	VBD
18637	1887	6	extended	extend	VBN
18637	1887	7	not	not	RB
18637	1887	8	only	only	RB
18637	1887	9	to	to	IN
18637	1887	10	all	all	DT
18637	1887	11	"	"	``
18637	1887	12	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	1887	13	,	,	,
18637	1887	14	"	"	''
18637	1887	15	comprehensively	comprehensively	RB
18637	1887	16	defined	define	VBN
18637	1887	17	,	,	,
18637	1887	18	but	but	CC
18637	1887	19	also	also	RB
18637	1887	20	to	to	IN
18637	1887	21	the	the	DT
18637	1887	22	following	follow	VBG
18637	1887	23	additional	additional	JJ
18637	1887	24	categories	category	NNS
18637	1887	25	of	of	IN
18637	1887	26	"	"	``
18637	1887	27	'	'	``
18637	1887	28	common	common	JJ
18637	1887	29	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	1887	30	'	'	POS
18637	1887	31	*	*	NFP
18637	1887	32	*	*	NFP
18637	1887	33	*	*	NFP
18637	1887	34	all	all	DT
18637	1887	35	pipeline	pipeline	NN
18637	1887	36	companies	company	NNS
18637	1887	37	;	;	:
18637	1887	38	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	1887	39	,	,	,
18637	1887	40	telephone	telephone	NN
18637	1887	41	,	,	,
18637	1887	42	and	and	CC
18637	1887	43	cable	cable	NN
18637	1887	44	companies	company	NNS
18637	1887	45	operating	operate	VBG
18637	1887	46	by	by	IN
18637	1887	47	wire	wire	NN
18637	1887	48	or	or	CC
18637	1887	49	wireless	wireless	NN
18637	1887	50	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1887	51	_	_	NNP
18637	1887	52	See	See	NNP
18637	1887	53	_	_	NNP
18637	1887	54	note	note	NN
18637	1887	55	3	3	CD
18637	1887	56	above][Transcriber	above][Transcriber	NNP
18637	1887	57	's	's	POS
18637	1887	58	Note	note	NN
18637	1887	59	:	:	:
18637	1887	60	Refers	refer	NNS
18637	1887	61	to	to	IN
18637	1887	62	Article	Article	NNP
18637	1887	63	I	I	NNP
18637	1887	64	,	,	,
18637	1887	65	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	1887	66	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1887	67	381	381	CD
18637	1887	68	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1887	69	.	.	.
18637	1888	1	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1888	2	;	;	:
18637	1888	3	express	express	VB
18637	1888	4	companies	company	NNS
18637	1888	5	;	;	:
18637	1888	6	sleeping	sleep	VBG
18637	1888	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	1888	8	car	car	NN
18637	1888	9	companies	company	NNS
18637	1888	10	;	;	:
18637	1888	11	and	and	CC
18637	1888	12	all	all	DT
18637	1888	13	persons	person	NNS
18637	1888	14	,	,	,
18637	1888	15	natural	natural	JJ
18637	1888	16	or	or	CC
18637	1888	17	artificial	artificial	JJ
18637	1888	18	,	,	,
18637	1888	19	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1888	20	in	in	IN
18637	1888	21	such	such	JJ
18637	1888	22	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1888	23	or	or	CC
18637	1888	24	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	1888	25	as	as	IN
18637	1888	26	aforesaid	aforesaid	JJ
18637	1888	27	as	as	IN
18637	1888	28	common	common	JJ
18637	1888	29	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	1888	30	for	for	IN
18637	1888	31	hire	hire	NN
18637	1888	32	.	.	.
18637	1888	33	"	"	''
18637	1889	1	The	the	DT
18637	1889	2	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	1889	3	of	of	IN
18637	1889	4	the	the	DT
18637	1889	5	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1889	6	covers	cover	VBZ
18637	1889	7	not	not	RB
18637	1889	8	only	only	RB
18637	1889	9	the	the	DT
18637	1889	10	characteristic	characteristic	JJ
18637	1889	11	activities	activity	NNS
18637	1889	12	of	of	IN
18637	1889	13	such	such	JJ
18637	1889	14	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	1889	15	in	in	IN
18637	1889	16	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1889	17	among	among	IN
18637	1889	18	the	the	DT
18637	1889	19	States	States	NNP
18637	1889	20	,	,	,
18637	1889	21	but	but	CC
18637	1889	22	also	also	RB
18637	1889	23	the	the	DT
18637	1889	24	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	1889	25	of	of	IN
18637	1889	26	securities	security	NNS
18637	1889	27	by	by	IN
18637	1889	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1889	29	,	,	,
18637	1889	30	and	and	CC
18637	1889	31	all	all	DT
18637	1889	32	consolidations	consolidation	NNS
18637	1889	33	of	of	IN
18637	1889	34	existing	exist	VBG
18637	1889	35	companies	company	NNS
18637	1889	36	,	,	,
18637	1889	37	or	or	CC
18637	1889	38	lines	line	NNS
18637	1889	39	.	.	.
18637	1890	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	1890	2	,	,	,
18637	1890	3	for	for	IN
18637	1890	4	the	the	DT
18637	1890	5	first	first	JJ
18637	1890	6	time	time	NN
18637	1890	7	,	,	,
18637	1890	8	the	the	DT
18637	1890	9	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1890	10	was	be	VBD
18637	1890	11	put	put	VBN
18637	1890	12	under	under	IN
18637	1890	13	the	the	DT
18637	1890	14	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	1890	15	,	,	,
18637	1890	16	in	in	IN
18637	1890	17	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	1890	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1890	19	control	control	NN
18637	1890	20	over	over	IN
18637	1890	21	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1890	22	and	and	CC
18637	1890	23	charges	charge	NNS
18637	1890	24	,	,	,
18637	1890	25	to	to	TO
18637	1890	26	"	"	``
18637	1890	27	give	give	VB
18637	1890	28	due	due	JJ
18637	1890	29	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	1890	30	,	,	,
18637	1890	31	among	among	IN
18637	1890	32	other	other	JJ
18637	1890	33	things	thing	NNS
18637	1890	34	,	,	,
18637	1890	35	to	to	IN
18637	1890	36	the	the	DT
18637	1890	37	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1890	38	needs	need	NNS
18637	1890	39	of	of	IN
18637	1890	40	the	the	DT
18637	1890	41	country	country	NN
18637	1890	42	and	and	CC
18637	1890	43	the	the	DT
18637	1890	44	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	1890	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1890	46	under	under	IN
18637	1890	47	honest	honest	JJ
18637	1890	48	,	,	,
18637	1890	49	efficient	efficient	JJ
18637	1890	50	and	and	CC
18637	1890	51	economical	economical	JJ
18637	1890	52	management	management	NN
18637	1890	53	of	of	IN
18637	1890	54	existing	exist	VBG
18637	1890	55	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1890	56	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	1890	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1890	58	of	of	IN
18637	1890	59	enlarging	enlarge	VBG
18637	1890	60	such	such	JJ
18637	1890	61	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	1890	62	in	in	IN
18637	1890	63	order	order	NN
18637	1890	64	to	to	TO
18637	1890	65	provide	provide	VB
18637	1890	66	the	the	DT
18637	1890	67	people	people	NNS
18637	1890	68	of	of	IN
18637	1890	69	the	the	DT
18637	1890	70	United	United	NNP
18637	1890	71	States	States	NNP
18637	1890	72	with	with	IN
18637	1890	73	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	1890	74	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1890	75	.	.	.
18637	1891	1	"	"	``
18637	1891	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1891	3	382	382	CD
18637	1891	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1891	5	Railway	railway	NN
18637	1891	6	rate	rate	NN
18637	1891	7	control	control	NN
18637	1891	8	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1891	9	,	,	,
18637	1891	10	which	which	WDT
18637	1891	11	was	be	VBD
18637	1891	12	originally	originally	RB
18637	1891	13	entered	enter	VBN
18637	1891	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	1891	15	by	by	IN
18637	1891	16	the	the	DT
18637	1891	17	National	National	NNP
18637	1891	18	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1891	19	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	1891	20	from	from	IN
18637	1891	21	the	the	DT
18637	1891	22	point	point	NN
18637	1891	23	of	of	IN
18637	1891	24	view	view	NN
18637	1891	25	of	of	IN
18637	1891	26	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	1891	27	,	,	,
18637	1891	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	1891	29	thus	thus	RB
18637	1891	30	been	be	VBN
18637	1891	31	assimilated	assimilate	VBN
18637	1891	32	to	to	IN
18637	1891	33	the	the	DT
18637	1891	34	idea	idea	NN
18637	1891	35	of	of	IN
18637	1891	36	"	"	``
18637	1891	37	fostering	foster	VBG
18637	1891	38	and	and	CC
18637	1891	39	promoting	promote	VBG
18637	1891	40	"	"	``
18637	1891	41	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1891	42	.	.	.
18637	1892	1	Two	two	CD
18637	1892	2	types	type	NNS
18637	1892	3	of	of	IN
18637	1892	4	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1892	5	questions	question	NNS
18637	1892	6	have	have	VBP
18637	1892	7	presented	present	VBN
18637	1892	8	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1892	9	under	under	IN
18637	1892	10	the	the	DT
18637	1892	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1892	12	just	just	RB
18637	1892	13	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1892	14	in	in	IN
18637	1892	15	review	review	NN
18637	1892	16	:	:	:
18637	1892	17	1	1	LS
18637	1892	18	.	.	.
18637	1893	1	Those	those	DT
18637	1893	2	arising	arise	VBG
18637	1893	3	out	out	IN
18637	1893	4	of	of	IN
18637	1893	5	the	the	DT
18637	1893	6	safeguards	safeguard	NNS
18637	1893	7	which	which	WDT
18637	1893	8	the	the	DT
18637	1893	9	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	1893	10	of	of	IN
18637	1893	11	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	1893	12	throws	throw	VBZ
18637	1893	13	about	about	IN
18637	1893	14	property	property	NN
18637	1893	15	rights	right	NNS
18637	1893	16	;	;	:
18637	1893	17	2	2	CD
18637	1893	18	.	.	.
18637	1894	1	Those	those	DT
18637	1894	2	arising	arise	VBG
18637	1894	3	out	out	IN
18637	1894	4	of	of	IN
18637	1894	5	the	the	DT
18637	1894	6	intermingling	intermingling	NN
18637	1894	7	of	of	IN
18637	1894	8	the	the	DT
18637	1894	9	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1894	10	and	and	CC
18637	1894	11	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	1894	12	operations	operation	NNS
18637	1894	13	of	of	IN
18637	1894	14	the	the	DT
18637	1894	15	same	same	JJ
18637	1894	16	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	1894	17	,	,	,
18637	1894	18	and	and	CC
18637	1894	19	the	the	DT
18637	1894	20	resulting	result	VBG
18637	1894	21	tangency	tangency	NN
18637	1894	22	of	of	IN
18637	1894	23	State	State	NNP
18637	1894	24	with	with	IN
18637	1894	25	national	national	JJ
18637	1894	26	power	power	NN
18637	1894	27	.	.	.
18637	1895	1	Only	only	RB
18637	1895	2	the	the	DT
18637	1895	3	latter	latter	JJ
18637	1895	4	are	be	VBP
18637	1895	5	considered	consider	VBN
18637	1895	6	at	at	IN
18637	1895	7	this	this	DT
18637	1895	8	point	point	NN
18637	1895	9	.	.	.
18637	1896	1	THE	the	DT
18637	1896	2	SHREVEPORT	SHREVEPORT	NNP
18637	1896	3	CASE	case	NN
18637	1896	4	Section	section	NN
18637	1896	5	1	1	CD
18637	1896	6	of	of	IN
18637	1896	7	the	the	DT
18637	1896	8	act	act	NN
18637	1896	9	of	of	IN
18637	1896	10	1887	1887	CD
18637	1896	11	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	1896	12	the	the	DT
18637	1896	13	proviso	proviso	NN
18637	1896	14	"	"	''
18637	1896	15	that	that	IN
18637	1896	16	the	the	DT
18637	1896	17	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	1896	18	of	of	IN
18637	1896	19	this	this	DT
18637	1896	20	act	act	NN
18637	1896	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	1896	22	not	not	RB
18637	1896	23	apply	apply	VB
18637	1896	24	to	to	IN
18637	1896	25	'	'	``
18637	1896	26	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1896	27	'	'	''
18637	1896	28	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	1896	29	within	within	IN
18637	1896	30	the	the	DT
18637	1896	31	State	State	NNP
18637	1896	32	.	.	.
18637	1896	33	"	"	''
18637	1897	1	Section	section	NN
18637	1897	2	3	3	CD
18637	1897	3	of	of	IN
18637	1897	4	the	the	DT
18637	1897	5	act	act	NN
18637	1897	6	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	1897	7	"	"	``
18637	1897	8	any	any	DT
18637	1897	9	common	common	JJ
18637	1897	10	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	1897	11	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1897	12	to	to	IN
18637	1897	13	the	the	DT
18637	1897	14	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	1897	15	"	"	''
18637	1897	16	of	of	IN
18637	1897	17	the	the	DT
18637	1897	18	act	act	NN
18637	1897	19	from	from	IN
18637	1897	20	giving	give	VBG
18637	1897	21	"	"	``
18637	1897	22	any	any	DT
18637	1897	23	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	1897	24	preference	preference	NN
18637	1897	25	or	or	CC
18637	1897	26	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	1897	27	"	"	''
18637	1897	28	to	to	IN
18637	1897	29	any	any	DT
18637	1897	30	person	person	NN
18637	1897	31	,	,	,
18637	1897	32	firm	firm	JJ
18637	1897	33	,	,	,
18637	1897	34	or	or	CC
18637	1897	35	locality	locality	NN
18637	1897	36	.	.	.
18637	1898	1	In	in	IN
18637	1898	2	the	the	DT
18637	1898	3	Shreveport	Shreveport	NNP
18637	1898	4	Case,[383	Case,[383	NNP
18637	1898	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1898	6	decided	decide	VBD
18637	1898	7	in	in	IN
18637	1898	8	1914	1914	CD
18637	1898	9	,	,	,
18637	1898	10	the	the	DT
18637	1898	11	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1898	12	,	,	,
18637	1898	13	reading	read	VBG
18637	1898	14	§	§	NNP
18637	1898	15	3	3	CD
18637	1898	16	independently	independently	RB
18637	1898	17	of	of	IN
18637	1898	18	§	§	NNP
18637	1898	19	1	1	CD
18637	1898	20	,	,	,
18637	1898	21	had	have	VBD
18637	1898	22	ordered	order	VBN
18637	1898	23	several	several	JJ
18637	1898	24	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	1898	25	lines	line	NNS
18637	1898	26	to	to	TO
18637	1898	27	increase	increase	VB
18637	1898	28	certain	certain	JJ
18637	1898	29	of	of	IN
18637	1898	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1898	31	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1898	32	between	between	IN
18637	1898	33	points	point	NNS
18637	1898	34	in	in	IN
18637	1898	35	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	1898	36	till	till	IN
18637	1898	37	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1898	38	should	should	MD
18637	1898	39	approximate	approximate	VB
18637	1898	40	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1898	41	already	already	RB
18637	1898	42	approved	approve	VBN
18637	1898	43	by	by	IN
18637	1898	44	the	the	DT
18637	1898	45	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1898	46	to	to	IN
18637	1898	47	adjoining	adjoining	JJ
18637	1898	48	points	point	NNS
18637	1898	49	in	in	IN
18637	1898	50	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	1898	51	.	.	.
18637	1899	1	The	the	DT
18637	1899	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	1899	3	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1899	4	,	,	,
18637	1899	5	being	be	VBG
18637	1899	6	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1899	7	,	,	,
18637	1899	8	were	be	VBD
18637	1899	9	admittedly	admittedly	RB
18637	1899	10	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1899	11	to	to	IN
18637	1899	12	the	the	DT
18637	1899	13	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1899	14	.	.	.
18637	1900	1	The	the	DT
18637	1900	2	local	local	JJ
18637	1900	3	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1900	4	were	be	VBD
18637	1900	5	as	as	RB
18637	1900	6	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	1900	7	within	within	IN
18637	1900	8	the	the	DT
18637	1900	9	normal	normal	JJ
18637	1900	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	1900	11	of	of	IN
18637	1900	12	the	the	DT
18637	1900	13	State	State	NNP
18637	1900	14	,	,	,
18637	1900	15	and	and	CC
18637	1900	16	had	have	VBD
18637	1900	17	in	in	IN
18637	1900	18	fact	fact	NN
18637	1900	19	been	be	VBN
18637	1900	20	set	set	VBN
18637	1900	21	by	by	IN
18637	1900	22	the	the	DT
18637	1900	23	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	1900	24	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	1900	25	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1900	26	.	.	.
18637	1901	1	The	the	DT
18637	1901	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1901	3	found	find	VBD
18637	1901	4	that	that	IN
18637	1901	5	the	the	DT
18637	1901	6	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	1901	7	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1901	8	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1901	9	had	have	VBD
18637	1901	10	not	not	RB
18637	1901	11	exceeded	exceed	VBN
18637	1901	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1901	13	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	1901	14	powers	power	NNS
18637	1901	15	.	.	.
18637	1902	1	The	the	DT
18637	1902	2	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1902	3	objection	objection	NN
18637	1902	4	to	to	IN
18637	1902	5	the	the	DT
18637	1902	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1902	7	's	's	POS
18637	1902	8	action	action	NN
18637	1902	9	was	be	VBD
18637	1902	10	stated	state	VBN
18637	1902	11	thus	thus	RB
18637	1902	12	:	:	:
18637	1902	13	"	"	``
18637	1902	14	That	that	IN
18637	1902	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1902	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	1902	17	impotent	impotent	JJ
18637	1902	18	to	to	TO
18637	1902	19	control	control	VB
18637	1902	20	the	the	DT
18637	1902	21	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	1902	22	charges	charge	NNS
18637	1902	23	of	of	IN
18637	1902	24	an	an	DT
18637	1902	25	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1902	26	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	1902	27	even	even	RB
18637	1902	28	to	to	IN
18637	1902	29	the	the	DT
18637	1902	30	extent	extent	NN
18637	1902	31	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1902	32	to	to	TO
18637	1902	33	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	1902	34	injurious	injurious	JJ
18637	1902	35	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	1902	36	against	against	IN
18637	1902	37	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1902	38	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	1902	39	.	.	.
18637	1902	40	"	"	''
18637	1903	1	This	this	DT
18637	1903	2	objection	objection	NN
18637	1903	3	the	the	DT
18637	1903	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1903	5	met	meet	VBD
18637	1903	6	,	,	,
18637	1903	7	as	as	IN
18637	1903	8	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	1903	9	:	:	:
18637	1903	10	"	"	``
18637	1903	11	Wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	1903	12	the	the	DT
18637	1903	13	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1903	14	and	and	CC
18637	1903	15	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	1903	16	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	1903	17	of	of	IN
18637	1903	18	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	1903	19	are	be	VBP
18637	1903	20	so	so	RB
18637	1903	21	related	related	JJ
18637	1903	22	that	that	IN
18637	1903	23	the	the	DT
18637	1903	24	government	government	NN
18637	1903	25	of	of	IN
18637	1903	26	the	the	DT
18637	1903	27	one	one	NN
18637	1903	28	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	1903	29	the	the	DT
18637	1903	30	control	control	NN
18637	1903	31	of	of	IN
18637	1903	32	the	the	DT
18637	1903	33	other	other	JJ
18637	1903	34	,	,	,
18637	1903	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1903	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	1903	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1903	38	,	,	,
18637	1903	39	and	and	CC
18637	1903	40	not	not	RB
18637	1903	41	the	the	DT
18637	1903	42	State	State	NNP
18637	1903	43	,	,	,
18637	1903	44	that	that	WDT
18637	1903	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	1903	46	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	1903	47	to	to	TO
18637	1903	48	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	1903	49	the	the	DT
18637	1903	50	final	final	JJ
18637	1903	51	and	and	CC
18637	1903	52	dominant	dominant	JJ
18637	1903	53	rule	rule	NN
18637	1903	54	,	,	,
18637	1903	55	for	for	IN
18637	1903	56	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	1903	57	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1903	58	would	would	MD
18637	1903	59	be	be	VB
18637	1903	60	denied	deny	VBN
18637	1903	61	the	the	DT
18637	1903	62	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1903	63	of	of	IN
18637	1903	64	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1903	65	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	1903	66	authority	authority	NN
18637	1903	67	and	and	CC
18637	1903	68	the	the	DT
18637	1903	69	State	State	NNP
18637	1903	70	,	,	,
18637	1903	71	and	and	CC
18637	1903	72	not	not	RB
18637	1903	73	the	the	DT
18637	1903	74	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	1903	75	,	,	,
18637	1903	76	would	would	MD
18637	1903	77	be	be	VB
18637	1903	78	supreme	supreme	JJ
18637	1903	79	in	in	IN
18637	1903	80	the	the	DT
18637	1903	81	national	national	JJ
18637	1903	82	field	field	NN
18637	1903	83	.	.	.
18637	1904	1	"	"	``
18637	1904	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1904	3	384	384	CD
18637	1904	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1904	5	This	this	DT
18637	1904	6	,	,	,
18637	1904	7	the	the	DT
18637	1904	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1904	9	continued	continue	VBD
18637	1904	10	,	,	,
18637	1904	11	"	"	``
18637	1904	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	1904	13	not	not	RB
18637	1904	14	to	to	TO
18637	1904	15	say	say	VB
18637	1904	16	that	that	IN
18637	1904	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1904	18	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	1904	19	the	the	DT
18637	1904	20	authority	authority	NN
18637	1904	21	to	to	TO
18637	1904	22	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1904	23	the	the	DT
18637	1904	24	internal	internal	JJ
18637	1904	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1904	26	of	of	IN
18637	1904	27	a	a	DT
18637	1904	28	State	State	NNP
18637	1904	29	as	as	IN
18637	1904	30	such	such	JJ
18637	1904	31	,	,	,
18637	1904	32	but	but	CC
18637	1904	33	that	that	IN
18637	1904	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1904	35	does	do	VBZ
18637	1904	36	possess	possess	VB
18637	1904	37	the	the	DT
18637	1904	38	power	power	NN
18637	1904	39	to	to	TO
18637	1904	40	foster	foster	VB
18637	1904	41	and	and	CC
18637	1904	42	protect	protect	VB
18637	1904	43	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1904	44	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1904	45	,	,	,
18637	1904	46	and	and	CC
18637	1904	47	to	to	TO
18637	1904	48	take	take	VB
18637	1904	49	all	all	DT
18637	1904	50	measures	measure	NNS
18637	1904	51	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1904	52	or	or	CC
18637	1904	53	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	1904	54	to	to	IN
18637	1904	55	that	that	DT
18637	1904	56	end	end	NN
18637	1904	57	,	,	,
18637	1904	58	although	although	IN
18637	1904	59	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	1904	60	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	1904	61	of	of	IN
18637	1904	62	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1904	63	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	1904	64	may	may	MD
18637	1904	65	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	1904	66	be	be	VB
18637	1904	67	controlled	control	VBN
18637	1904	68	.	.	.
18637	1905	1	"	"	``
18637	1905	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1905	3	385	385	CD
18637	1905	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1905	5	THE	the	DT
18637	1905	6	ACT	ACT	NNP
18637	1905	7	OF	of	IN
18637	1905	8	1920	1920	CD
18637	1905	9	AND	and	CC
18637	1905	10	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	1905	11	RAILWAY	railway	NN
18637	1905	12	RATE	rate	NN
18637	1905	13	REGULATION	REGULATION	VBD
18637	1905	14	The	the	DT
18637	1905	15	power	power	NN
18637	1905	16	of	of	IN
18637	1905	17	the	the	DT
18637	1905	18	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1905	19	under	under	IN
18637	1905	20	§	§	NNP
18637	1905	21	3	3	CD
18637	1905	22	of	of	IN
18637	1905	23	the	the	DT
18637	1905	24	act	act	NN
18637	1905	25	of	of	IN
18637	1905	26	1887	1887	CD
18637	1905	27	,	,	,
18637	1905	28	as	as	IN
18637	1905	29	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	1905	30	in	in	IN
18637	1905	31	the	the	DT
18637	1905	32	Shreveport	Shreveport	NNP
18637	1905	33	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1905	34	,	,	,
18637	1905	35	was	be	VBD
18637	1905	36	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	1905	37	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
18637	1905	38	by	by	IN
18637	1905	39	§	§	NNP
18637	1905	40	416	416	CD
18637	1905	41	of	of	IN
18637	1905	42	the	the	DT
18637	1905	43	act	act	NN
18637	1905	44	of	of	IN
18637	1905	45	1920	1920	CD
18637	1905	46	,	,	,
18637	1905	47	which	which	WDT
18637	1905	48	authorizes	authorize	VBZ
18637	1905	49	the	the	DT
18637	1905	50	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1905	51	to	to	TO
18637	1905	52	remove	remove	VB
18637	1905	53	"	"	``
18637	1905	54	any	any	DT
18637	1905	55	undue	undue	JJ
18637	1905	56	,	,	,
18637	1905	57	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	1905	58	,	,	,
18637	1905	59	or	or	CC
18637	1905	60	unjust	unjust	JJ
18637	1905	61	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	1905	62	against	against	IN
18637	1905	63	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1905	64	or	or	CC
18637	1905	65	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1905	66	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1905	67	.	.	.
18637	1905	68	"	"	''
18637	1906	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	1906	2	,	,	,
18637	1906	3	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1906	4	as	as	IN
18637	1906	5	a	a	DT
18637	1906	6	whole	whole	NN
18637	1906	7	,	,	,
18637	1906	8	instead	instead	RB
18637	1906	9	of	of	IN
18637	1906	10	specific	specific	JJ
18637	1906	11	firms	firm	NNS
18637	1906	12	or	or	CC
18637	1906	13	localities	locality	NNS
18637	1906	14	,	,	,
18637	1906	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	1906	16	made	make	VBN
18637	1906	17	the	the	DT
18637	1906	18	beneficiary	beneficiary	NN
18637	1906	19	of	of	IN
18637	1906	20	the	the	DT
18637	1906	21	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	1906	22	.	.	.
18637	1907	1	In	in	IN
18637	1907	2	the	the	DT
18637	1907	3	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	1907	4	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	1908	1	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	1908	2	.	.	.
18637	1909	1	_	_	NNP
18637	1909	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	1909	3	_	_	NNP
18637	1909	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	1909	5	,	,	,
18637	1909	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	1910	1	&	&	CC
18637	1910	2	Q.R.R.	Q.R.R.	NNP
18637	1911	1	Co	Co	NNS
18637	1911	2	.	.	.
18637	1911	3	,[386	,[386	NFP
18637	1911	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1911	5	the	the	DT
18637	1911	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1911	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	1911	8	that	that	IN
18637	1911	9	this	this	DT
18637	1911	10	section	section	NN
18637	1911	11	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1911	12	the	the	DT
18637	1911	13	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	1911	14	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1911	15	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1911	16	in	in	IN
18637	1911	17	annulling	annul	VBG
18637	1911	18	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	1911	19	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	1911	20	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1911	21	which	which	WDT
18637	1911	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1911	23	found	find	VBD
18637	1911	24	to	to	TO
18637	1911	25	be	be	VB
18637	1911	26	unduly	unduly	RB
18637	1911	27	low	low	JJ
18637	1911	28	,	,	,
18637	1911	29	in	in	IN
18637	1911	30	comparison	comparison	NN
18637	1911	31	with	with	IN
18637	1911	32	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1911	33	which	which	WDT
18637	1911	34	the	the	DT
18637	1911	35	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1911	36	had	have	VBD
18637	1911	37	established	establish	VBN
18637	1911	38	for	for	IN
18637	1911	39	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1911	40	travel	travel	NN
18637	1911	41	,	,	,
18637	1911	42	and	and	CC
18637	1911	43	so	so	RB
18637	1911	44	tending	tend	VBG
18637	1911	45	to	to	TO
18637	1911	46	thwart	thwart	VB
18637	1911	47	,	,	,
18637	1911	48	in	in	IN
18637	1911	49	deference	deference	NN
18637	1911	50	to	to	IN
18637	1911	51	a	a	DT
18637	1911	52	merely	merely	RB
18637	1911	53	local	local	JJ
18637	1911	54	interest	interest	NN
18637	1911	55	,	,	,
18637	1911	56	the	the	DT
18637	1911	57	general	general	JJ
18637	1911	58	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1911	59	of	of	IN
18637	1911	60	the	the	DT
18637	1911	61	act	act	NN
18637	1911	62	to	to	TO
18637	1911	63	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	1911	64	an	an	DT
18637	1911	65	efficient	efficient	JJ
18637	1911	66	transport	transport	NN
18637	1911	67	service	service	NN
18637	1911	68	for	for	IN
18637	1911	69	the	the	DT
18637	1911	70	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	1911	71	of	of	IN
18637	1911	72	the	the	DT
18637	1911	73	country	country	NN
18637	1911	74	at	at	IN
18637	1911	75	large	large	JJ
18637	1911	76	.	.	.
18637	1912	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1912	2	387	387	CD
18637	1912	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1912	4	REGULATION	regulation	NN
18637	1912	5	OF	of	IN
18637	1912	6	OTHER	other	JJ
18637	1912	7	AGENTS	agent	NNS
18637	1912	8	OF	of	IN
18637	1912	9	CARRIAGE	carriage	NN
18637	1912	10	AND	and	CC
18637	1912	11	COMMUNICATION	communication	NN
18637	1912	12	In	in	IN
18637	1912	13	the	the	DT
18637	1912	14	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	1912	15	Line	Line	NNP
18637	1912	16	Cases	case	NNS
18637	1912	17	,	,	,
18637	1912	18	decided	decide	VBD
18637	1912	19	in	in	IN
18637	1912	20	1914,[388	1914,[388	CD
18637	1912	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1912	22	the	the	DT
18637	1912	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1912	24	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	1912	25	the	the	DT
18637	1912	26	power	power	NN
18637	1912	27	of	of	IN
18637	1912	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1912	29	to	to	TO
18637	1912	30	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1912	31	the	the	DT
18637	1912	32	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1912	33	of	of	IN
18637	1912	34	oil	oil	NN
18637	1912	35	and	and	CC
18637	1912	36	gas	gas	NN
18637	1912	37	in	in	IN
18637	1912	38	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	1912	39	lines	line	NNS
18637	1912	40	from	from	IN
18637	1912	41	one	one	CD
18637	1912	42	State	state	NN
18637	1912	43	to	to	IN
18637	1912	44	another	another	DT
18637	1912	45	and	and	CC
18637	1912	46	held	hold	VBN
18637	1912	47	that	that	IN
18637	1912	48	this	this	DT
18637	1912	49	power	power	NN
18637	1912	50	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	1912	51	to	to	IN
18637	1912	52	such	such	JJ
18637	1912	53	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1912	54	even	even	RB
18637	1912	55	though	though	IN
18637	1912	56	the	the	DT
18637	1912	57	oil	oil	NN
18637	1912	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1912	59	or	or	CC
18637	1912	60	gas	gas	NN
18637	1912	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1912	62	in	in	IN
18637	1912	63	question	question	NN
18637	1912	64	was	be	VBD
18637	1912	65	the	the	DT
18637	1912	66	property	property	NN
18637	1912	67	of	of	IN
18637	1912	68	the	the	DT
18637	1912	69	owner	owner	NN
18637	1912	70	of	of	IN
18637	1912	71	the	the	DT
18637	1912	72	lines	line	NNS
18637	1912	73	.	.	.
18637	1913	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1913	2	389	389	CD
18637	1913	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1913	4	Thirteen	thirteen	CD
18637	1913	5	years	year	NNS
18637	1913	6	later	later	RB
18637	1913	7	,	,	,
18637	1913	8	in	in	IN
18637	1913	9	1927	1927	CD
18637	1913	10	,	,	,
18637	1913	11	the	the	DT
18637	1913	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1913	13	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	1913	14	that	that	IN
18637	1913	15	an	an	DT
18637	1913	16	order	order	NN
18637	1913	17	by	by	IN
18637	1913	18	a	a	DT
18637	1913	19	State	State	NNP
18637	1913	20	commission	commission	NN
18637	1913	21	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	1913	22	rates	rate	NNS
18637	1913	23	on	on	IN
18637	1913	24	electric	electric	JJ
18637	1913	25	current	current	NN
18637	1913	26	generated	generate	VBN
18637	1913	27	within	within	IN
18637	1913	28	the	the	DT
18637	1913	29	State	State	NNP
18637	1913	30	and	and	CC
18637	1913	31	sold	sell	VBN
18637	1913	32	to	to	IN
18637	1913	33	a	a	DT
18637	1913	34	distributor	distributor	NN
18637	1913	35	in	in	IN
18637	1913	36	another	another	DT
18637	1913	37	State	state	NN
18637	1913	38	was	be	VBD
18637	1913	39	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	1913	40	as	as	IN
18637	1913	41	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	1913	42	a	a	DT
18637	1913	43	burden	burden	NN
18637	1913	44	on	on	IN
18637	1913	45	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1913	46	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1913	47	,	,	,
18637	1913	48	thus	thus	RB
18637	1913	49	holding	hold	VBG
18637	1913	50	impliedly	impliedly	RB
18637	1913	51	that	that	IN
18637	1913	52	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1913	53	'	'	POS
18637	1913	54	power	power	NN
18637	1913	55	to	to	TO
18637	1913	56	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1913	57	the	the	DT
18637	1913	58	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	1913	59	of	of	IN
18637	1913	60	electric	electric	JJ
18637	1913	61	current	current	NN
18637	1913	62	from	from	IN
18637	1913	63	one	one	CD
18637	1913	64	State	state	NN
18637	1913	65	to	to	IN
18637	1913	66	another	another	DT
18637	1913	67	carried	carry	VBN
18637	1913	68	with	with	IN
18637	1913	69	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1913	70	the	the	DT
18637	1913	71	power	power	NN
18637	1913	72	to	to	TO
18637	1913	73	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1913	74	the	the	DT
18637	1913	75	price	price	NN
18637	1913	76	of	of	IN
18637	1913	77	such	such	JJ
18637	1913	78	electricity	electricity	NN
18637	1913	79	.	.	.
18637	1914	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1914	2	390	390	CD
18637	1914	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1914	4	Proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	1914	5	on	on	IN
18637	1914	6	this	this	DT
18637	1914	7	implication	implication	NN
18637	1914	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1914	9	,	,	,
18637	1914	10	in	in	IN
18637	1914	11	the	the	DT
18637	1914	12	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1914	13	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1914	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1914	15	of	of	IN
18637	1914	16	1935,[391	1935,[391	NNP
18637	1914	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1914	18	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	1914	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	1914	20	the	the	DT
18637	1914	21	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1914	22	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1914	23	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1914	24	the	the	DT
18637	1914	25	power	power	NN
18637	1914	26	to	to	TO
18637	1914	27	govern	govern	VB
18637	1914	28	the	the	DT
18637	1914	29	wholesale	wholesale	JJ
18637	1914	30	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	1914	31	of	of	IN
18637	1914	32	electricity	electricity	NN
18637	1914	33	in	in	IN
18637	1914	34	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1914	35	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1914	36	;	;	:
18637	1914	37	and	and	CC
18637	1914	38	three	three	CD
18637	1914	39	years	year	NNS
18637	1914	40	later	later	RB
18637	1914	41	vested	vest	VBN
18637	1914	42	in	in	IN
18637	1914	43	the	the	DT
18637	1914	44	same	same	JJ
18637	1914	45	body	body	NN
18637	1914	46	like	like	IN
18637	1914	47	power	power	NN
18637	1914	48	over	over	IN
18637	1914	49	natural	natural	JJ
18637	1914	50	gas	gas	NN
18637	1914	51	moving	moving	NN
18637	1914	52	in	in	IN
18637	1914	53	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1914	54	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1914	55	.	.	.
18637	1915	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1915	2	392	392	CD
18637	1915	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1915	4	In	in	IN
18637	1915	5	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1915	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	1915	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1915	8	_	_	NNP
18637	1915	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	1915	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1915	11	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	1915	12	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	1915	13	Pipeline	Pipeline	NNP
18637	1915	14	Company,[393	company,[393	NN
18637	1915	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1915	16	the	the	DT
18637	1915	17	power	power	NN
18637	1915	18	of	of	IN
18637	1915	19	the	the	DT
18637	1915	20	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1915	21	to	to	TO
18637	1915	22	set	set	VB
18637	1915	23	the	the	DT
18637	1915	24	prices	price	NNS
18637	1915	25	at	at	IN
18637	1915	26	which	which	WDT
18637	1915	27	gas	gas	NN
18637	1915	28	,	,	,
18637	1915	29	originating	originate	VBG
18637	1915	30	in	in	IN
18637	1915	31	one	one	CD
18637	1915	32	State	state	NN
18637	1915	33	and	and	CC
18637	1915	34	transported	transport	VBD
18637	1915	35	into	into	IN
18637	1915	36	another	another	DT
18637	1915	37	,	,	,
18637	1915	38	should	should	MD
18637	1915	39	be	be	VB
18637	1915	40	sold	sell	VBN
18637	1915	41	to	to	IN
18637	1915	42	distributors	distributor	NNS
18637	1915	43	wholesale	wholesale	JJ
18637	1915	44	in	in	IN
18637	1915	45	the	the	DT
18637	1915	46	latter	latter	JJ
18637	1915	47	State	State	NNP
18637	1915	48	,	,	,
18637	1915	49	was	be	VBD
18637	1915	50	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	1915	51	by	by	IN
18637	1915	52	the	the	DT
18637	1915	53	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1915	54	in	in	IN
18637	1915	55	the	the	DT
18637	1915	56	following	following	JJ
18637	1915	57	terms	term	NNS
18637	1915	58	:	:	:
18637	1915	59	"	"	``
18637	1915	60	The	the	DT
18637	1915	61	argument	argument	NN
18637	1915	62	that	that	IN
18637	1915	63	the	the	DT
18637	1915	64	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	1915	65	of	of	IN
18637	1915	66	the	the	DT
18637	1915	67	statute	statute	NN
18637	1915	68	applied	apply	VBD
18637	1915	69	in	in	IN
18637	1915	70	this	this	DT
18637	1915	71	case	case	NN
18637	1915	72	are	be	VBP
18637	1915	73	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	1915	74	on	on	IN
18637	1915	75	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1915	76	face	face	NN
18637	1915	77	is	be	VBZ
18637	1915	78	without	without	IN
18637	1915	79	merit	merit	NN
18637	1915	80	.	.	.
18637	1916	1	The	the	DT
18637	1916	2	sale	sale	NN
18637	1916	3	of	of	IN
18637	1916	4	natural	natural	JJ
18637	1916	5	gas	gas	NN
18637	1916	6	originating	originating	NN
18637	1916	7	in	in	IN
18637	1916	8	the	the	DT
18637	1916	9	State	State	NNP
18637	1916	10	and	and	CC
18637	1916	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1916	12	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1916	13	and	and	CC
18637	1916	14	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	1916	15	to	to	IN
18637	1916	16	distributors	distributor	NNS
18637	1916	17	in	in	IN
18637	1916	18	any	any	DT
18637	1916	19	other	other	JJ
18637	1916	20	State	State	NNP
18637	1916	21	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	1916	22	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1916	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1916	24	,	,	,
18637	1916	25	which	which	WDT
18637	1916	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	1916	27	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1916	28	to	to	IN
18637	1916	29	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1916	30	by	by	IN
18637	1916	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1916	32	.	.	.
18637	1917	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1917	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1917	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1917	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1917	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	1917	6	no	no	DT
18637	1917	7	objection	objection	NN
18637	1917	8	to	to	IN
18637	1917	9	the	the	DT
18637	1917	10	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1917	11	of	of	IN
18637	1917	12	the	the	DT
18637	1917	13	power	power	NN
18637	1917	14	of	of	IN
18637	1917	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1917	16	that	that	IN
18637	1917	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1917	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	1917	19	attended	attend	VBN
18637	1917	20	by	by	IN
18637	1917	21	the	the	DT
18637	1917	22	same	same	JJ
18637	1917	23	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	1917	24	which	which	WDT
18637	1917	25	attend	attend	VBP
18637	1917	26	the	the	DT
18637	1917	27	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1917	28	of	of	IN
18637	1917	29	the	the	DT
18637	1917	30	police	police	NN
18637	1917	31	power	power	NN
18637	1917	32	of	of	IN
18637	1917	33	a	a	DT
18637	1917	34	State	State	NNP
18637	1917	35	.	.	.
18637	1918	1	The	the	DT
18637	1918	2	authority	authority	NN
18637	1918	3	of	of	IN
18637	1918	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1918	5	to	to	TO
18637	1918	6	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1918	7	the	the	DT
18637	1918	8	prices	price	NNS
18637	1918	9	of	of	IN
18637	1918	10	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	1918	11	in	in	IN
18637	1918	12	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1918	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1918	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	1918	15	at	at	IN
18637	1918	16	least	least	JJS
18637	1918	17	as	as	RB
18637	1918	18	great	great	RB
18637	1918	19	under	under	IN
18637	1918	20	the	the	DT
18637	1918	21	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	1918	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1918	23	as	as	IN
18637	1918	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	1918	25	that	that	DT
18637	1918	26	of	of	IN
18637	1918	27	the	the	DT
18637	1918	28	States	States	NNPS
18637	1918	29	under	under	IN
18637	1918	30	the	the	DT
18637	1918	31	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	1918	32	to	to	TO
18637	1918	33	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1918	34	the	the	DT
18637	1918	35	prices	price	NNS
18637	1918	36	of	of	IN
18637	1918	37	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	1918	38	in	in	IN
18637	1918	39	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	1918	40	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1918	41	.	.	.
18637	1919	1	"	"	``
18637	1919	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1919	3	394	394	CD
18637	1919	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1919	5	Other	other	JJ
18637	1919	6	acts	act	NNS
18637	1919	7	regulative	regulative	JJ
18637	1919	8	of	of	IN
18637	1919	9	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1919	10	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1919	11	and	and	CC
18637	1919	12	communication	communication	NN
18637	1919	13	which	which	WDT
18637	1919	14	belong	belong	VBP
18637	1919	15	to	to	IN
18637	1919	16	this	this	DT
18637	1919	17	period	period	NN
18637	1919	18	are	be	VBP
18637	1919	19	the	the	DT
18637	1919	20	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1919	21	Communications	Communications	NNPS
18637	1919	22	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1919	23	of	of	IN
18637	1919	24	1934	1934	CD
18637	1919	25	,	,	,
18637	1919	26	which	which	WDT
18637	1919	27	regulates	regulate	VBZ
18637	1919	28	,	,	,
18637	1919	29	through	through	IN
18637	1919	30	the	the	DT
18637	1919	31	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1919	32	Communications	Communications	NNPS
18637	1919	33	Commission,[395	Commission,[395	NNP
18637	1919	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1919	35	"	"	``
18637	1919	36	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1919	37	and	and	CC
18637	1919	38	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1919	39	communication	communication	NN
18637	1919	40	by	by	IN
18637	1919	41	wire	wire	NN
18637	1919	42	and	and	CC
18637	1919	43	radio	radio	NN
18637	1919	44	"	"	''
18637	1919	45	;	;	:
18637	1919	46	the	the	DT
18637	1919	47	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1919	48	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	1919	49	Carrier	Carrier	NNP
18637	1919	50	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1919	51	of	of	IN
18637	1919	52	1935	1935	CD
18637	1919	53	,	,	,
18637	1919	54	which	which	WDT
18637	1919	55	,	,	,
18637	1919	56	through	through	IN
18637	1919	57	the	the	DT
18637	1919	58	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	1919	59	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1919	60	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	1919	61	,	,	,
18637	1919	62	governs	govern	VBZ
18637	1919	63	the	the	DT
18637	1919	64	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1919	65	of	of	IN
18637	1919	66	persons	person	NNS
18637	1919	67	and	and	CC
18637	1919	68	property	property	NN
18637	1919	69	by	by	IN
18637	1919	70	motor	motor	NN
18637	1919	71	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	1919	72	common	common	JJ
18637	1919	73	carriers;[396	carriers;[396	NNPS
18637	1919	74	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1919	75	the	the	DT
18637	1919	76	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	1919	77	Aeronautics	Aeronautics	NNP
18637	1919	78	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1919	79	of	of	IN
18637	1919	80	1938	1938	CD
18637	1919	81	,	,	,
18637	1919	82	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	1919	83	for	for	IN
18637	1919	84	the	the	DT
18637	1919	85	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1919	86	of	of	IN
18637	1919	87	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	1919	88	under	under	IN
18637	1919	89	the	the	DT
18637	1919	90	control	control	NN
18637	1919	91	of	of	IN
18637	1919	92	a	a	DT
18637	1919	93	central	central	JJ
18637	1919	94	agency	agency	NN
18637	1919	95	,	,	,
18637	1919	96	called	call	VBD
18637	1919	97	"	"	``
18637	1919	98	the	the	DT
18637	1919	99	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	1919	100	Aeronautics	Aeronautics	NNP
18637	1919	101	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	1919	102	"	"	''
18637	1919	103	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1919	104	functioning	function	VBG
18637	1919	105	through	through	IN
18637	1919	106	the	the	DT
18637	1919	107	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	1919	108	Aeronautics	Aeronautics	NNP
18637	1919	109	Administrator	Administrator	NNP
18637	1919	110	and	and	CC
18637	1919	111	the	the	DT
18637	1919	112	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	1919	113	Aeronautics	Aeronautics	NNP
18637	1919	114	Board	Board	NNP
18637	1919	115	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1919	116	all	all	DT
18637	1919	117	phases	phase	NNS
18637	1919	118	of	of	IN
18637	1919	119	airborne	airborne	JJ
18637	1919	120	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1919	121	,	,	,
18637	1919	122	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1919	123	and	and	CC
18637	1919	124	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1919	125	.	.	.
18637	1920	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1920	2	397	397	CD
18637	1920	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1920	4	None	none	NN
18637	1920	5	of	of	IN
18637	1920	6	these	these	DT
18637	1920	7	measures	measure	NNS
18637	1920	8	have	have	VBP
18637	1920	9	provoked	provoke	VBN
18637	1920	10	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	1920	11	to	to	IN
18637	1920	12	the	the	DT
18637	1920	13	power	power	NN
18637	1920	14	of	of	IN
18637	1920	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1920	16	to	to	TO
18637	1920	17	enact	enact	VB
18637	1920	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1920	19	.	.	.
18637	1921	1	ACTS	ACTS	NNP
18637	1921	2	OF	of	IN
18637	1921	3	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	1921	4	PROTECTIVE	protective	RB
18637	1921	5	OF	of	IN
18637	1921	6	LABOR	labor	NN
18637	1921	7	ENGAGED	engaged	NN
18637	1921	8	IN	in	IN
18637	1921	9	INTERSTATE	interstate	JJ
18637	1921	10	TRANSPORTATION	transportation	NN
18637	1921	11	In	in	IN
18637	1921	12	the	the	DT
18637	1921	13	course	course	NN
18637	1921	14	of	of	IN
18637	1921	15	the	the	DT
18637	1921	16	years	year	NNS
18637	1921	17	1903	1903	CD
18637	1921	18	to	to	IN
18637	1921	19	1908	1908	CD
18637	1921	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1921	21	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	1921	22	a	a	DT
18637	1921	23	series	series	NN
18637	1921	24	of	of	IN
18637	1921	25	such	such	JJ
18637	1921	26	measures	measure	NNS
18637	1921	27	which	which	WDT
18637	1921	28	were	be	VBD
18637	1921	29	notable	notable	JJ
18637	1921	30	both	both	DT
18637	1921	31	on	on	IN
18637	1921	32	account	account	NN
18637	1921	33	of	of	IN
18637	1921	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1921	35	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	1921	36	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1921	37	and	and	CC
18637	1921	38	as	as	IN
18637	1921	39	marking	mark	VBG
18637	1921	40	the	the	DT
18637	1921	41	entry	entry	NN
18637	1921	42	of	of	IN
18637	1921	43	the	the	DT
18637	1921	44	National	National	NNP
18637	1921	45	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1921	46	into	into	IN
18637	1921	47	the	the	DT
18637	1921	48	field	field	NN
18637	1921	49	of	of	IN
18637	1921	50	labor	labor	NN
18637	1921	51	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1921	52	.	.	.
18637	1922	1	The	the	DT
18637	1922	2	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	1922	3	Appliance	Appliance	NNP
18637	1922	4	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1922	5	of	of	IN
18637	1922	6	1893,[398	1893,[398	NNP
18637	1922	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1922	8	which	which	WDT
18637	1922	9	applied	apply	VBD
18637	1922	10	only	only	RB
18637	1922	11	to	to	IN
18637	1922	12	cars	car	NNS
18637	1922	13	and	and	CC
18637	1922	14	locomotives	locomotive	NNS
18637	1922	15	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1922	16	in	in	IN
18637	1922	17	moving	move	VBG
18637	1922	18	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1922	19	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	1922	20	,	,	,
18637	1922	21	was	be	VBD
18637	1922	22	amended	amend	VBN
18637	1922	23	in	in	IN
18637	1922	24	1903	1903	CD
18637	1922	25	to	to	TO
18637	1922	26	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	1922	27	"	"	``
18637	1922	28	all	all	DT
18637	1922	29	trains	train	NNS
18637	1922	30	,	,	,
18637	1922	31	locomotives	locomotive	NNS
18637	1922	32	,	,	,
18637	1922	33	tenders	tender	NNS
18637	1922	34	,	,	,
18637	1922	35	cars	car	NNS
18637	1922	36	,	,	,
18637	1922	37	"	"	''
18637	1922	38	etc	etc	FW
18637	1922	39	.	.	.
18637	1922	40	,	,	,
18637	1922	41	"	"	``
18637	1922	42	used	use	VBN
18637	1922	43	on	on	IN
18637	1922	44	any	any	DT
18637	1922	45	railway	railway	NN
18637	1922	46	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1922	47	in	in	IN
18637	1922	48	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1922	49	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1922	50	*	*	NFP
18637	1922	51	*	*	NFP
18637	1922	52	*	*	NFP
18637	1922	53	and	and	CC
18637	1922	54	to	to	IN
18637	1922	55	all	all	DT
18637	1922	56	other	other	JJ
18637	1922	57	locomotives	locomotive	NNS
18637	1922	58	*	*	NFP
18637	1922	59	*	*	NFP
18637	1922	60	*	*	NFP
18637	1922	61	cars	car	NNS
18637	1922	62	,	,	,
18637	1922	63	"	"	''
18637	1922	64	etc	etc	FW
18637	1922	65	.	.	.
18637	1922	66	,	,	,
18637	1922	67	"	"	``
18637	1922	68	used	use	VBN
18637	1922	69	in	in	IN
18637	1922	70	connection	connection	NN
18637	1922	71	therewith	therewith	NN
18637	1922	72	.	.	.
18637	1923	1	"	"	``
18637	1923	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1923	3	399	399	CD
18637	1923	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1923	5	In	in	IN
18637	1923	6	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	1923	7	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	1923	8	Company	Company	NNP
18637	1923	9	_	_	NNP
18637	1923	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	1923	11	_	_	NNP
18637	1923	12	United	United	NNP
18637	1923	13	States,[400	States,[400	NNP
18637	1923	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1923	15	the	the	DT
18637	1923	16	validity	validity	NN
18637	1923	17	of	of	IN
18637	1923	18	this	this	DT
18637	1923	19	extension	extension	NN
18637	1923	20	of	of	IN
18637	1923	21	the	the	DT
18637	1923	22	act	act	NN
18637	1923	23	was	be	VBD
18637	1923	24	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	1923	25	.	.	.
18637	1924	1	The	the	DT
18637	1924	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1924	3	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1924	4	the	the	DT
18637	1924	5	measure	measure	NN
18637	1924	6	as	as	IN
18637	1924	7	being	be	VBG
18637	1924	8	within	within	IN
18637	1924	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1924	10	's	's	POS
18637	1924	11	power	power	NN
18637	1924	12	,	,	,
18637	1924	13	saying	say	VBG
18637	1924	14	:	:	:
18637	1924	15	"	"	``
18637	1924	16	*	*	NFP
18637	1924	17	*	*	NFP
18637	1924	18	*	*	NFP
18637	1924	19	this	this	DT
18637	1924	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	1924	21	so	so	RB
18637	1924	22	,	,	,
18637	1924	23	not	not	RB
18637	1924	24	because	because	IN
18637	1924	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1924	26	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	1924	27	any	any	DT
18637	1924	28	power	power	NN
18637	1924	29	to	to	TO
18637	1924	30	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1924	31	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	1924	32	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1924	33	as	as	IN
18637	1924	34	such	such	JJ
18637	1924	35	,	,	,
18637	1924	36	but	but	CC
18637	1924	37	because	because	IN
18637	1924	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1924	39	power	power	NN
18637	1924	40	to	to	TO
18637	1924	41	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1924	42	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1924	43	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1924	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	1924	45	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	1924	46	and	and	CC
18637	1924	47	competently	competently	RB
18637	1924	48	may	may	MD
18637	1924	49	be	be	VB
18637	1924	50	exerted	exert	VBN
18637	1924	51	to	to	TO
18637	1924	52	secure	secure	VB
18637	1924	53	the	the	DT
18637	1924	54	safety	safety	NN
18637	1924	55	of	of	IN
18637	1924	56	the	the	DT
18637	1924	57	persons	person	NNS
18637	1924	58	and	and	CC
18637	1924	59	property	property	NN
18637	1924	60	transported	transport	VBN
18637	1924	61	therein	therein	RB
18637	1924	62	and	and	CC
18637	1924	63	of	of	IN
18637	1924	64	those	those	DT
18637	1924	65	who	who	WP
18637	1924	66	are	be	VBP
18637	1924	67	employed	employ	VBN
18637	1924	68	in	in	IN
18637	1924	69	such	such	JJ
18637	1924	70	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1924	71	,	,	,
18637	1924	72	no	no	RB
18637	1924	73	matter	matter	RB
18637	1924	74	what	what	WP
18637	1924	75	may	may	MD
18637	1924	76	be	be	VB
18637	1924	77	the	the	DT
18637	1924	78	source	source	NN
18637	1924	79	of	of	IN
18637	1924	80	the	the	DT
18637	1924	81	dangers	danger	NNS
18637	1924	82	which	which	WDT
18637	1924	83	threaten	threaten	VBP
18637	1924	84	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1924	85	.	.	.
18637	1925	1	That	that	DT
18637	1925	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1925	3	to	to	TO
18637	1925	4	say	say	VB
18637	1925	5	,	,	,
18637	1925	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1925	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	1925	8	no	no	DT
18637	1925	9	objection	objection	NN
18637	1925	10	to	to	IN
18637	1925	11	such	such	PDT
18637	1925	12	an	an	DT
18637	1925	13	exertion	exertion	NN
18637	1925	14	of	of	IN
18637	1925	15	this	this	DT
18637	1925	16	power	power	NN
18637	1925	17	that	that	WDT
18637	1925	18	the	the	DT
18637	1925	19	dangers	danger	NNS
18637	1925	20	intended	intend	VBN
18637	1925	21	to	to	TO
18637	1925	22	be	be	VB
18637	1925	23	avoided	avoid	VBN
18637	1925	24	arise	arise	NN
18637	1925	25	,	,	,
18637	1925	26	in	in	IN
18637	1925	27	whole	whole	NN
18637	1925	28	or	or	CC
18637	1925	29	in	in	IN
18637	1925	30	part	part	NN
18637	1925	31	,	,	,
18637	1925	32	out	out	IN
18637	1925	33	of	of	IN
18637	1925	34	matters	matter	NNS
18637	1925	35	connected	connect	VBN
18637	1925	36	with	with	IN
18637	1925	37	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	1925	38	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1925	39	.	.	.
18637	1926	1	"	"	``
18637	1926	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1926	3	401	401	CD
18637	1926	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1926	5	Four	four	CD
18637	1926	6	years	year	NNS
18637	1926	7	later	later	RBR
18637	1926	8	the	the	DT
18637	1926	9	Hours	Hours	NNPS
18637	1926	10	of	of	IN
18637	1926	11	Service	Service	NNP
18637	1926	12	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1926	13	of	of	IN
18637	1926	14	1907[402	1907[402	CD
18637	1926	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1926	16	was	be	VBD
18637	1926	17	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1926	18	,	,	,
18637	1926	19	requiring	require	VBG
18637	1926	20	,	,	,
18637	1926	21	as	as	IN
18637	1926	22	a	a	DT
18637	1926	23	safety	safety	NN
18637	1926	24	measure	measure	NN
18637	1926	25	,	,	,
18637	1926	26	that	that	IN
18637	1926	27	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	1926	28	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	1926	29	in	in	IN
18637	1926	30	the	the	DT
18637	1926	31	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1926	32	of	of	IN
18637	1926	33	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	1926	34	or	or	CC
18637	1926	35	property	property	NN
18637	1926	36	by	by	IN
18637	1926	37	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	1926	38	in	in	IN
18637	1926	39	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1926	40	or	or	CC
18637	1926	41	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1926	42	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1926	43	should	should	MD
18637	1926	44	not	not	RB
18637	1926	45	work	work	VB
18637	1926	46	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1926	47	employees	employee	NNS
18637	1926	48	for	for	IN
18637	1926	49	longer	long	JJR
18637	1926	50	periods	period	NNS
18637	1926	51	than	than	IN
18637	1926	52	those	those	DT
18637	1926	53	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	1926	54	by	by	IN
18637	1926	55	the	the	DT
18637	1926	56	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1926	57	.	.	.
18637	1927	1	In	in	IN
18637	1927	2	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	1927	3	this	this	DT
18637	1927	4	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1927	5	the	the	DT
18637	1927	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1927	7	,	,	,
18637	1927	8	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	1927	9	through	through	IN
18637	1927	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1927	11	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	1927	12	,	,	,
18637	1927	13	said	say	VBD
18637	1927	14	:	:	:
18637	1927	15	"	"	``
18637	1927	16	The	the	DT
18637	1927	17	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	1927	18	question	question	NN
18637	1927	19	here	here	RB
18637	1927	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	1927	21	whether	whether	IN
18637	1927	22	a	a	DT
18637	1927	23	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	1927	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	1927	25	the	the	DT
18637	1927	26	hours	hour	NNS
18637	1927	27	of	of	IN
18637	1927	28	labor	labor	NN
18637	1927	29	of	of	IN
18637	1927	30	employÃ	employÃ	NNP
18637	1927	31	©	©	NNP
18637	1927	32	s	s	NNPS
18637	1927	33	who	who	WP
18637	1927	34	are	be	VBP
18637	1927	35	connected	connect	VBN
18637	1927	36	with	with	IN
18637	1927	37	the	the	DT
18637	1927	38	movement	movement	NN
18637	1927	39	of	of	IN
18637	1927	40	trains	train	NNS
18637	1927	41	in	in	IN
18637	1927	42	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1927	43	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1927	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	1927	45	comprehended	comprehend	VBN
18637	1927	46	within	within	IN
18637	1927	47	this	this	DT
18637	1927	48	sphere	sphere	NN
18637	1927	49	of	of	IN
18637	1927	50	authorized	authorized	JJ
18637	1927	51	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1927	52	.	.	.
18637	1928	1	This	this	DT
18637	1928	2	question	question	NN
18637	1928	3	admits	admit	VBZ
18637	1928	4	of	of	IN
18637	1928	5	but	but	CC
18637	1928	6	one	one	CD
18637	1928	7	answer	answer	NN
18637	1928	8	.	.	.
18637	1929	1	The	the	DT
18637	1929	2	length	length	NN
18637	1929	3	of	of	IN
18637	1929	4	hours	hour	NNS
18637	1929	5	of	of	IN
18637	1929	6	service	service	NN
18637	1929	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	1929	8	direct	direct	JJ
18637	1929	9	relation	relation	NN
18637	1929	10	to	to	IN
18637	1929	11	the	the	DT
18637	1929	12	efficiency	efficiency	NN
18637	1929	13	of	of	IN
18637	1929	14	the	the	DT
18637	1929	15	human	human	JJ
18637	1929	16	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	1929	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	1929	18	which	which	WDT
18637	1929	19	protection	protection	NN
18637	1929	20	of	of	IN
18637	1929	21	life	life	NN
18637	1929	22	and	and	CC
18637	1929	23	property	property	NN
18637	1929	24	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	1929	25	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	1929	26	.	.	.
18637	1930	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1930	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1930	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1930	4	In	in	IN
18637	1930	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1930	6	power	power	NN
18637	1930	7	suitably	suitably	RB
18637	1930	8	to	to	TO
18637	1930	9	provide	provide	VB
18637	1930	10	for	for	IN
18637	1930	11	the	the	DT
18637	1930	12	safety	safety	NN
18637	1930	13	of	of	IN
18637	1930	14	the	the	DT
18637	1930	15	employÃ	employÃ	NNP
18637	1930	16	©	©	NNP
18637	1930	17	s	s	NNP
18637	1930	18	and	and	CC
18637	1930	19	travelers	traveler	NNS
18637	1930	20	,	,	,
18637	1930	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1930	22	was	be	VBD
18637	1930	23	not	not	RB
18637	1930	24	limited	limit	VBN
18637	1930	25	to	to	IN
18637	1930	26	the	the	DT
18637	1930	27	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	1930	28	of	of	IN
18637	1930	29	laws	law	NNS
18637	1930	30	relating	relate	VBG
18637	1930	31	to	to	IN
18637	1930	32	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
18637	1930	33	appliances	appliance	NNS
18637	1930	34	,	,	,
18637	1930	35	but	but	CC
18637	1930	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1930	37	was	be	VBD
18637	1930	38	also	also	RB
18637	1930	39	competent	competent	JJ
18637	1930	40	to	to	TO
18637	1930	41	consider	consider	VB
18637	1930	42	,	,	,
18637	1930	43	and	and	CC
18637	1930	44	to	to	TO
18637	1930	45	endeavor	endeavor	VB
18637	1930	46	to	to	TO
18637	1930	47	reduce	reduce	VB
18637	1930	48	,	,	,
18637	1930	49	the	the	DT
18637	1930	50	dangers	danger	NNS
18637	1930	51	incident	incident	VBP
18637	1930	52	to	to	IN
18637	1930	53	the	the	DT
18637	1930	54	strain	strain	NN
18637	1930	55	of	of	IN
18637	1930	56	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	1930	57	hours	hour	NNS
18637	1930	58	of	of	IN
18637	1930	59	duty	duty	NN
18637	1930	60	on	on	IN
18637	1930	61	the	the	DT
18637	1930	62	part	part	NN
18637	1930	63	of	of	IN
18637	1930	64	engineers	engineer	NNS
18637	1930	65	,	,	,
18637	1930	66	conductors	conductor	NNS
18637	1930	67	,	,	,
18637	1930	68	train	train	NN
18637	1930	69	dispatchers	dispatcher	NNS
18637	1930	70	,	,	,
18637	1930	71	telegraphers	telegrapher	NNS
18637	1930	72	,	,	,
18637	1930	73	and	and	CC
18637	1930	74	other	other	JJ
18637	1930	75	persons	person	NNS
18637	1930	76	embraced	embrace	VBN
18637	1930	77	within	within	IN
18637	1930	78	the	the	DT
18637	1930	79	class	class	NN
18637	1930	80	defined	define	VBN
18637	1930	81	by	by	IN
18637	1930	82	the	the	DT
18637	1930	83	act	act	NN
18637	1930	84	.	.	.
18637	1931	1	"	"	``
18637	1931	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1931	3	403	403	CD
18637	1931	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1931	5	But	but	CC
18637	1931	6	by	by	IN
18637	1931	7	far	far	RB
18637	1931	8	the	the	DT
18637	1931	9	most	most	RBS
18637	1931	10	notable	notable	JJ
18637	1931	11	of	of	IN
18637	1931	12	these	these	DT
18637	1931	13	safety	safety	NN
18637	1931	14	measures	measure	NNS
18637	1931	15	were	be	VBD
18637	1931	16	the	the	DT
18637	1931	17	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1931	18	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	1931	19	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	1931	20	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	1931	21	of	of	IN
18637	1931	22	1906	1906	CD
18637	1931	23	and	and	CC
18637	1931	24	1908,[404	1908,[404	CD
18637	1931	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1931	26	the	the	DT
18637	1931	27	second	second	NN
18637	1931	28	of	of	IN
18637	1931	29	which	which	WDT
18637	1931	30	merely	merely	RB
18637	1931	31	reenacted	reenact	VBD
18637	1931	32	the	the	DT
18637	1931	33	first	first	JJ
18637	1931	34	with	with	IN
18637	1931	35	certain	certain	JJ
18637	1931	36	"	"	``
18637	1931	37	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	1931	38	"	"	''
18637	1931	39	features	feature	NNS
18637	1931	40	eliminated	eliminate	VBN
18637	1931	41	.	.	.
18637	1932	1	What	what	WP
18637	1932	2	the	the	DT
18637	1932	3	amended	amend	VBN
18637	1932	4	act	act	NN
18637	1932	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	1932	6	,	,	,
18637	1932	7	in	in	IN
18637	1932	8	short	short	JJ
18637	1932	9	,	,	,
18637	1932	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	1932	11	to	to	TO
18637	1932	12	modify	modify	VB
18637	1932	13	,	,	,
18637	1932	14	in	in	IN
18637	1932	15	the	the	DT
18637	1932	16	case	case	NN
18637	1932	17	of	of	IN
18637	1932	18	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	1932	19	incurred	incur	VBN
18637	1932	20	by	by	IN
18637	1932	21	the	the	DT
18637	1932	22	employees	employee	NNS
18637	1932	23	of	of	IN
18637	1932	24	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1932	25	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	1932	26	while	while	IN
18637	1932	27	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1932	28	in	in	IN
18637	1932	29	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1932	30	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1932	31	,	,	,
18637	1932	32	the	the	DT
18637	1932	33	defenses	defense	NNS
18637	1932	34	that	that	WDT
18637	1932	35	had	have	VBD
18637	1932	36	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
18637	1932	37	been	be	VBN
18637	1932	38	available	available	JJ
18637	1932	39	to	to	IN
18637	1932	40	the	the	DT
18637	1932	41	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	1932	42	at	at	IN
18637	1932	43	common	common	JJ
18637	1932	44	law	law	NN
18637	1932	45	.	.	.
18637	1933	1	The	the	DT
18637	1933	2	principal	principal	JJ
18637	1933	3	argument	argument	NN
18637	1933	4	against	against	IN
18637	1933	5	the	the	DT
18637	1933	6	acts	act	NNS
18637	1933	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1933	8	that	that	IN
18637	1933	9	the	the	DT
18637	1933	10	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1933	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	1933	12	afforded	afford	VBD
18637	1933	13	no	no	DT
18637	1933	14	basis	basis	NN
18637	1933	15	for	for	IN
18637	1933	16	an	an	DT
18637	1933	17	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	1933	18	to	to	TO
18637	1933	19	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1933	20	the	the	DT
18637	1933	21	relation	relation	NN
18637	1933	22	of	of	IN
18637	1933	23	master	master	NN
18637	1933	24	and	and	CC
18637	1933	25	servant	servant	NN
18637	1933	26	,	,	,
18637	1933	27	which	which	WDT
18637	1933	28	had	have	VBD
18637	1933	29	heretofore	heretofore	RB
18637	1933	30	in	in	IN
18637	1933	31	all	all	DT
18637	1933	32	cases	case	NNS
18637	1933	33	fallen	fall	VBN
18637	1933	34	to	to	IN
18637	1933	35	the	the	DT
18637	1933	36	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	1933	37	powers	power	NNS
18637	1933	38	of	of	IN
18637	1933	39	the	the	DT
18637	1933	40	States	States	NNPS
18637	1933	41	;	;	:
18637	1933	42	that	that	IN
18637	1933	43	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	1933	44	the	the	DT
18637	1933	45	rules	rule	NNS
18637	1933	46	of	of	IN
18637	1933	47	common	common	JJ
18637	1933	48	law	law	NN
18637	1933	49	modified	modify	VBN
18637	1933	50	or	or	CC
18637	1933	51	abrogated	abrogate	VBN
18637	1933	52	by	by	IN
18637	1933	53	the	the	DT
18637	1933	54	act	act	NN
18637	1933	55	existed	exist	VBD
18637	1933	56	solely	solely	RB
18637	1933	57	under	under	IN
18637	1933	58	State	State	NNP
18637	1933	59	authority	authority	NN
18637	1933	60	,	,	,
18637	1933	61	and	and	CC
18637	1933	62	had	have	VBD
18637	1933	63	always	always	RB
18637	1933	64	been	be	VBN
18637	1933	65	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	1933	66	,	,	,
18637	1933	67	in	in	IN
18637	1933	68	the	the	DT
18637	1933	69	main	main	JJ
18637	1933	70	,	,	,
18637	1933	71	in	in	IN
18637	1933	72	the	the	DT
18637	1933	73	courts	court	NNS
18637	1933	74	of	of	IN
18637	1933	75	the	the	DT
18637	1933	76	States	States	NNP
18637	1933	77	.	.	.
18637	1934	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1934	2	405	405	CD
18637	1934	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1934	4	Countering	counter	VBG
18637	1934	5	this	this	DT
18637	1934	6	argument	argument	NN
18637	1934	7	,	,	,
18637	1934	8	the	the	DT
18637	1934	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1934	10	,	,	,
18637	1934	11	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	1934	12	by	by	IN
18637	1934	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1934	14	Van	Van	NNP
18637	1934	15	Devanter	Devanter	NNP
18637	1934	16	,	,	,
18637	1934	17	quoted	quote	VBD
18637	1934	18	the	the	DT
18637	1934	19	following	follow	VBG
18637	1934	20	passage	passage	NN
18637	1934	21	from	from	IN
18637	1934	22	the	the	DT
18637	1934	23	brief	brief	NN
18637	1934	24	of	of	IN
18637	1934	25	the	the	DT
18637	1934	26	Solicitor	Solicitor	NNP
18637	1934	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	1934	28	General	General	NNP
18637	1934	29	:	:	:
18637	1934	30	"	"	``
18637	1934	31	Interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1934	32	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1934	33	--	--	:
18637	1934	34	if	if	IN
18637	1934	35	not	not	RB
18637	1934	36	always	always	RB
18637	1934	37	,	,	,
18637	1934	38	at	at	IN
18637	1934	39	any	any	DT
18637	1934	40	rate	rate	NN
18637	1934	41	when	when	WRB
18637	1934	42	the	the	DT
18637	1934	43	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1934	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	1934	45	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1934	46	--	--	:
18637	1934	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	1934	48	an	an	DT
18637	1934	49	act	act	NN
18637	1934	50	.	.	.
18637	1935	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1935	2	,	,	,
18637	1935	3	of	of	IN
18637	1935	4	course	course	NN
18637	1935	5	,	,	,
18637	1935	6	can	can	MD
18637	1935	7	do	do	VB
18637	1935	8	anything	anything	NN
18637	1935	9	which	which	WDT
18637	1935	10	,	,	,
18637	1935	11	in	in	IN
18637	1935	12	the	the	DT
18637	1935	13	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1935	14	by	by	IN
18637	1935	15	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1935	16	of	of	IN
18637	1935	17	a	a	DT
18637	1935	18	fair	fair	JJ
18637	1935	19	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	1935	20	,	,	,
18637	1935	21	may	may	MD
18637	1935	22	be	be	VB
18637	1935	23	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	1935	24	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	1935	25	to	to	TO
18637	1935	26	save	save	VB
18637	1935	27	the	the	DT
18637	1935	28	act	act	NN
18637	1935	29	of	of	IN
18637	1935	30	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1935	31	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1935	32	from	from	IN
18637	1935	33	prevention	prevention	NN
18637	1935	34	or	or	CC
18637	1935	35	interruption	interruption	NN
18637	1935	36	,	,	,
18637	1935	37	or	or	CC
18637	1935	38	to	to	TO
18637	1935	39	make	make	VB
18637	1935	40	that	that	DT
18637	1935	41	act	act	NN
18637	1935	42	more	more	RBR
18637	1935	43	secure	secure	JJ
18637	1935	44	,	,	,
18637	1935	45	more	more	RBR
18637	1935	46	reliable	reliable	JJ
18637	1935	47	or	or	CC
18637	1935	48	more	more	RBR
18637	1935	49	efficient	efficient	JJ
18637	1935	50	.	.	.
18637	1936	1	The	the	DT
18637	1936	2	act	act	NN
18637	1936	3	of	of	IN
18637	1936	4	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1936	5	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1936	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	1936	7	done	do	VBN
18637	1936	8	by	by	IN
18637	1936	9	the	the	DT
18637	1936	10	labor	labor	NN
18637	1936	11	of	of	IN
18637	1936	12	men	man	NNS
18637	1936	13	and	and	CC
18637	1936	14	with	with	IN
18637	1936	15	the	the	DT
18637	1936	16	help	help	NN
18637	1936	17	of	of	IN
18637	1936	18	things	thing	NNS
18637	1936	19	;	;	:
18637	1936	20	and	and	CC
18637	1936	21	these	these	DT
18637	1936	22	men	man	NNS
18637	1936	23	and	and	CC
18637	1936	24	things	thing	NNS
18637	1936	25	are	be	VBP
18637	1936	26	the	the	DT
18637	1936	27	agents	agent	NNS
18637	1936	28	and	and	CC
18637	1936	29	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	1936	30	of	of	IN
18637	1936	31	the	the	DT
18637	1936	32	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1936	33	.	.	.
18637	1937	1	If	if	IN
18637	1937	2	the	the	DT
18637	1937	3	agents	agent	NNS
18637	1937	4	or	or	CC
18637	1937	5	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	1937	6	are	be	VBP
18637	1937	7	destroyed	destroy	VBN
18637	1937	8	while	while	IN
18637	1937	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1937	10	are	be	VBP
18637	1937	11	doing	do	VBG
18637	1937	12	the	the	DT
18637	1937	13	act	act	NN
18637	1937	14	,	,	,
18637	1937	15	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1937	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	1937	17	stopped	stop	VBN
18637	1937	18	;	;	:
18637	1937	19	if	if	IN
18637	1937	20	the	the	DT
18637	1937	21	agents	agent	NNS
18637	1937	22	or	or	CC
18637	1937	23	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	1937	24	are	be	VBP
18637	1937	25	interrupted	interrupt	VBN
18637	1937	26	,	,	,
18637	1937	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1937	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	1937	29	interrupted	interrupt	VBN
18637	1937	30	;	;	:
18637	1937	31	if	if	IN
18637	1937	32	the	the	DT
18637	1937	33	agents	agent	NNS
18637	1937	34	or	or	CC
18637	1937	35	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	1937	36	are	be	VBP
18637	1937	37	not	not	RB
18637	1937	38	of	of	IN
18637	1937	39	the	the	DT
18637	1937	40	right	right	JJ
18637	1937	41	kind	kind	NN
18637	1937	42	or	or	CC
18637	1937	43	quality	quality	NN
18637	1937	44	,	,	,
18637	1937	45	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1937	46	in	in	IN
18637	1937	47	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	1937	48	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	1937	49	slow	slow	JJ
18637	1937	50	or	or	CC
18637	1937	51	costly	costly	JJ
18637	1937	52	or	or	CC
18637	1937	53	unsafe	unsafe	JJ
18637	1937	54	or	or	CC
18637	1937	55	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	1937	56	inefficient	inefficient	JJ
18637	1937	57	;	;	:
18637	1937	58	and	and	CC
18637	1937	59	if	if	IN
18637	1937	60	the	the	DT
18637	1937	61	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	1937	62	under	under	IN
18637	1937	63	which	which	WDT
18637	1937	64	the	the	DT
18637	1937	65	agents	agent	NNS
18637	1937	66	or	or	CC
18637	1937	67	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	1937	68	do	do	VBP
18637	1937	69	the	the	DT
18637	1937	70	work	work	NN
18637	1937	71	of	of	IN
18637	1937	72	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1937	73	are	be	VBP
18637	1937	74	wrong	wrong	JJ
18637	1937	75	or	or	CC
18637	1937	76	disadvantageous	disadvantageous	JJ
18637	1937	77	,	,	,
18637	1937	78	those	those	DT
18637	1937	79	bad	bad	JJ
18637	1937	80	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	1937	81	may	may	MD
18637	1937	82	and	and	CC
18637	1937	83	often	often	RB
18637	1937	84	will	will	MD
18637	1937	85	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	1937	86	or	or	CC
18637	1937	87	interrupt	interrupt	VB
18637	1937	88	the	the	DT
18637	1937	89	act	act	NN
18637	1937	90	of	of	IN
18637	1937	91	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1937	92	or	or	CC
18637	1937	93	make	make	VB
18637	1937	94	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1937	95	less	less	RBR
18637	1937	96	expeditious	expeditious	JJ
18637	1937	97	,	,	,
18637	1937	98	less	less	RBR
18637	1937	99	reliable	reliable	JJ
18637	1937	100	,	,	,
18637	1937	101	less	less	RBR
18637	1937	102	economical	economical	JJ
18637	1937	103	and	and	CC
18637	1937	104	less	less	RBR
18637	1937	105	secure	secure	JJ
18637	1937	106	.	.	.
18637	1938	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
18637	1938	2	,	,	,
18637	1938	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1938	4	may	may	MD
18637	1938	5	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	1938	6	about	about	IN
18637	1938	7	the	the	DT
18637	1938	8	agents	agent	NNS
18637	1938	9	and	and	CC
18637	1938	10	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	1938	11	of	of	IN
18637	1938	12	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1938	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1938	14	,	,	,
18637	1938	15	and	and	CC
18637	1938	16	about	about	IN
18637	1938	17	the	the	DT
18637	1938	18	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	1938	19	under	under	IN
18637	1938	20	which	which	WDT
18637	1938	21	those	those	DT
18637	1938	22	agents	agent	NNS
18637	1938	23	and	and	CC
18637	1938	24	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	1938	25	perform	perform	VBP
18637	1938	26	the	the	DT
18637	1938	27	work	work	NN
18637	1938	28	of	of	IN
18637	1938	29	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1938	30	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1938	31	,	,	,
18637	1938	32	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	1938	33	such	such	JJ
18637	1938	34	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1938	35	bears	bear	VBZ
18637	1938	36	,	,	,
18637	1938	37	or	or	CC
18637	1938	38	in	in	IN
18637	1938	39	the	the	DT
18637	1938	40	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1938	41	of	of	IN
18637	1938	42	a	a	DT
18637	1938	43	fair	fair	JJ
18637	1938	44	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	1938	45	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	1938	46	can	can	MD
18637	1938	47	be	be	VB
18637	1938	48	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	1938	49	to	to	TO
18637	1938	50	bear	bear	VB
18637	1938	51	,	,	,
18637	1938	52	upon	upon	IN
18637	1938	53	the	the	DT
18637	1938	54	reliability	reliability	NN
18637	1938	55	or	or	CC
18637	1938	56	promptness	promptness	NN
18637	1938	57	or	or	CC
18637	1938	58	economy	economy	NN
18637	1938	59	or	or	CC
18637	1938	60	security	security	NN
18637	1938	61	or	or	CC
18637	1938	62	utility	utility	NN
18637	1938	63	of	of	IN
18637	1938	64	the	the	DT
18637	1938	65	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1938	66	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1938	67	act	act	NNP
18637	1938	68	.	.	.
18637	1939	1	"	"	``
18637	1939	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1939	3	406	406	CD
18637	1939	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1939	5	The	the	DT
18637	1939	6	Adair	Adair	NNP
18637	1939	7	Case	case	NN
18637	1939	8	But	but	CC
18637	1939	9	while	while	IN
18637	1939	10	the	the	DT
18637	1939	11	idea	idea	NN
18637	1939	12	expressed	express	VBD
18637	1939	13	here	here	RB
18637	1939	14	that	that	IN
18637	1939	15	the	the	DT
18637	1939	16	human	human	JJ
18637	1939	17	agents	agent	NNS
18637	1939	18	of	of	IN
18637	1939	19	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1939	20	,	,	,
18637	1939	21	in	in	IN
18637	1939	22	the	the	DT
18637	1939	23	sense	sense	NN
18637	1939	24	of	of	IN
18637	1939	25	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1939	26	,	,	,
18637	1939	27	are	be	VBP
18637	1939	28	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	1939	29	of	of	IN
18637	1939	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1939	31	,	,	,
18637	1939	32	and	and	CC
18637	1939	33	so	so	RB
18637	1939	34	,	,	,
18637	1939	35	in	in	IN
18637	1939	36	that	that	DT
18637	1939	37	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	1939	38	,	,	,
18637	1939	39	within	within	IN
18637	1939	40	the	the	DT
18637	1939	41	protective	protective	JJ
18637	1939	42	power	power	NN
18637	1939	43	of	of	IN
18637	1939	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1939	45	,	,	,
18637	1939	46	signalized	signalize	VBD
18637	1939	47	the	the	DT
18637	1939	48	entrance	entrance	NN
18637	1939	49	of	of	IN
18637	1939	50	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1939	51	into	into	IN
18637	1939	52	the	the	DT
18637	1939	53	field	field	NN
18637	1939	54	of	of	IN
18637	1939	55	labor	labor	NN
18637	1939	56	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1939	57	,	,	,
18637	1939	58	the	the	DT
18637	1939	59	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1939	60	was	be	VBD
18637	1939	61	not	not	RB
18637	1939	62	at	at	IN
18637	1939	63	the	the	DT
18637	1939	64	time	time	NN
18637	1939	65	prepared	prepare	VBD
18637	1939	66	to	to	TO
18637	1939	67	give	give	VB
18637	1939	68	the	the	DT
18637	1939	69	idea	idea	NN
18637	1939	70	any	any	DT
18637	1939	71	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	1939	72	scope	scope	NN
18637	1939	73	.	.	.
18637	1940	1	Pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	1940	2	in	in	IN
18637	1940	3	this	this	DT
18637	1940	4	connection	connection	NN
18637	1940	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	1940	6	the	the	DT
18637	1940	7	case	case	NN
18637	1940	8	of	of	IN
18637	1940	9	Adair	Adair	NNP
18637	1940	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1940	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	1940	12	_	_	NNP
18637	1940	13	United	United	NNP
18637	1940	14	States,[407	States,[407	NNP
18637	1940	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1940	16	which	which	WDT
18637	1940	17	was	be	VBD
18637	1940	18	decided	decide	VBN
18637	1940	19	between	between	IN
18637	1940	20	the	the	DT
18637	1940	21	two	two	CD
18637	1940	22	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	1940	23	'	'	POS
18637	1940	24	Liability	liability	NN
18637	1940	25	Cases	case	NNS
18637	1940	26	.	.	.
18637	1941	1	Here	here	RB
18637	1941	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1941	3	involved	involve	VBN
18637	1941	4	the	the	DT
18637	1941	5	validity	validity	NN
18637	1941	6	of	of	IN
18637	1941	7	§	§	NNP
18637	1941	8	10	10	CD
18637	1941	9	of	of	IN
18637	1941	10	the	the	DT
18637	1941	11	"	"	``
18637	1941	12	Erdman	Erdman	NNP
18637	1941	13	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1941	14	"	"	''
18637	1941	15	of	of	IN
18637	1941	16	1898,[408	1898,[408	CD
18637	1941	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1941	18	by	by	IN
18637	1941	19	which	which	WDT
18637	1941	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1941	21	was	be	VBD
18637	1941	22	made	make	VBN
18637	1941	23	a	a	DT
18637	1941	24	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
18637	1941	25	for	for	IN
18637	1941	26	a	a	DT
18637	1941	27	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	1941	28	or	or	CC
18637	1941	29	agent	agent	NN
18637	1941	30	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	1941	31	to	to	TO
18637	1941	32	require	require	VB
18637	1941	33	of	of	IN
18637	1941	34	an	an	DT
18637	1941	35	employee	employee	NN
18637	1941	36	,	,	,
18637	1941	37	as	as	IN
18637	1941	38	a	a	DT
18637	1941	39	condition	condition	NN
18637	1941	40	of	of	IN
18637	1941	41	employment	employment	NN
18637	1941	42	,	,	,
18637	1941	43	that	that	IN
18637	1941	44	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1941	45	should	should	MD
18637	1941	46	not	not	RB
18637	1941	47	become	become	VB
18637	1941	48	or	or	CC
18637	1941	49	remain	remain	VB
18637	1941	50	a	a	DT
18637	1941	51	member	member	NN
18637	1941	52	of	of	IN
18637	1941	53	a	a	DT
18637	1941	54	trade	trade	NN
18637	1941	55	union	union	NN
18637	1941	56	,	,	,
18637	1941	57	or	or	CC
18637	1941	58	to	to	TO
18637	1941	59	threaten	threaten	VB
18637	1941	60	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1941	61	with	with	IN
18637	1941	62	loss	loss	NN
18637	1941	63	of	of	IN
18637	1941	64	employment	employment	NN
18637	1941	65	if	if	IN
18637	1941	66	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1941	67	should	should	MD
18637	1941	68	become	become	VB
18637	1941	69	or	or	CC
18637	1941	70	remain	remain	VB
18637	1941	71	a	a	DT
18637	1941	72	member	member	NN
18637	1941	73	.	.	.
18637	1942	1	This	this	DT
18637	1942	2	proviso	proviso	NN
18637	1942	3	the	the	DT
18637	1942	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1942	5	held	hold	VBD
18637	1942	6	not	not	RB
18637	1942	7	to	to	TO
18637	1942	8	be	be	VB
18637	1942	9	a	a	DT
18637	1942	10	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1942	11	of	of	IN
18637	1942	12	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1942	13	,	,	,
18637	1942	14	there	there	EX
18637	1942	15	being	be	VBG
18637	1942	16	no	no	DT
18637	1942	17	connection	connection	NN
18637	1942	18	between	between	IN
18637	1942	19	an	an	DT
18637	1942	20	employee	employee	NN
18637	1942	21	's	's	POS
18637	1942	22	membership	membership	NN
18637	1942	23	in	in	IN
18637	1942	24	a	a	DT
18637	1942	25	labor	labor	NN
18637	1942	26	organization	organization	NN
18637	1942	27	and	and	CC
18637	1942	28	the	the	DT
18637	1942	29	carrying	carrying	NN
18637	1942	30	on	on	RP
18637	1942	31	of	of	IN
18637	1942	32	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1942	33	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1942	34	.	.	.
18637	1943	1	Twenty	twenty	CD
18637	1943	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	1943	3	two	two	CD
18637	1943	4	years	year	NNS
18637	1943	5	later	later	RB
18637	1943	6	,	,	,
18637	1943	7	however	however	RB
18637	1943	8	,	,	,
18637	1943	9	in	in	IN
18637	1943	10	1930	1930	CD
18637	1943	11	,	,	,
18637	1943	12	the	the	DT
18637	1943	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1943	14	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	1943	15	that	that	IN
18637	1943	16	the	the	DT
18637	1943	17	connection	connection	NN
18637	1943	18	between	between	IN
18637	1943	19	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1943	20	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1943	21	and	and	CC
18637	1943	22	union	union	NNP
18637	1943	23	membership	membership	NN
18637	1943	24	was	be	VBD
18637	1943	25	a	a	DT
18637	1943	26	real	real	JJ
18637	1943	27	and	and	CC
18637	1943	28	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	1943	29	one	one	NN
18637	1943	30	,	,	,
18637	1943	31	and	and	CC
18637	1943	32	on	on	IN
18637	1943	33	that	that	DT
18637	1943	34	ground	ground	NN
18637	1943	35	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1943	36	the	the	DT
18637	1943	37	power	power	NN
18637	1943	38	of	of	IN
18637	1943	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1943	40	in	in	IN
18637	1943	41	the	the	DT
18637	1943	42	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	1943	43	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	1943	44	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1943	45	of	of	IN
18637	1943	46	1926[409	1926[409	CD
18637	1943	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1943	48	to	to	TO
18637	1943	49	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	1943	50	employers	employer	NNS
18637	1943	51	from	from	IN
18637	1943	52	interfering	interfere	VBG
18637	1943	53	with	with	IN
18637	1943	54	the	the	DT
18637	1943	55	right	right	NN
18637	1943	56	of	of	IN
18637	1943	57	employees	employee	NNS
18637	1943	58	to	to	TO
18637	1943	59	select	select	VB
18637	1943	60	freely	freely	RB
18637	1943	61	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1943	62	own	own	JJ
18637	1943	63	collective	collective	JJ
18637	1943	64	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	1943	65	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	1943	66	.	.	.
18637	1944	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1944	2	410	410	CD
18637	1944	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1944	4	The	the	DT
18637	1944	5	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	1944	6	Retirement	Retirement	NNP
18637	1944	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1944	8	Still	still	RB
18637	1944	9	pursuing	pursue	VBG
18637	1944	10	the	the	DT
18637	1944	11	idea	idea	NN
18637	1944	12	of	of	IN
18637	1944	13	protecting	protect	VBG
18637	1944	14	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1944	15	and	and	CC
18637	1944	16	the	the	DT
18637	1944	17	labor	labor	NN
18637	1944	18	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	1944	19	in	in	IN
18637	1944	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1944	21	concurrently	concurrently	RB
18637	1944	22	,	,	,
18637	1944	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1944	24	,	,	,
18637	1944	25	by	by	IN
18637	1944	26	the	the	DT
18637	1944	27	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	1944	28	Retirement	Retirement	NNP
18637	1944	29	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1944	30	of	of	IN
18637	1944	31	June	June	NNP
18637	1944	32	27	27	CD
18637	1944	33	,	,	,
18637	1944	34	1934,[411	1934,[411	NNP
18637	1944	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1944	36	ordered	order	VBD
18637	1944	37	the	the	DT
18637	1944	38	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	1944	39	retirement	retirement	NN
18637	1944	40	of	of	IN
18637	1944	41	superannuated	superannuated	JJ
18637	1944	42	employees	employee	NNS
18637	1944	43	of	of	IN
18637	1944	44	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1944	45	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	1944	46	,	,	,
18637	1944	47	and	and	CC
18637	1944	48	provided	provide	VBD
18637	1944	49	that	that	IN
18637	1944	50	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1944	51	be	be	VB
18637	1944	52	paid	pay	VBN
18637	1944	53	pensions	pension	NNS
18637	1944	54	out	out	IN
18637	1944	55	of	of	IN
18637	1944	56	a	a	DT
18637	1944	57	fund	fund	NN
18637	1944	58	comprising	comprise	VBG
18637	1944	59	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	1944	60	contributions	contribution	NNS
18637	1944	61	from	from	IN
18637	1944	62	the	the	DT
18637	1944	63	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	1944	64	and	and	CC
18637	1944	65	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1944	66	present	present	JJ
18637	1944	67	and	and	CC
18637	1944	68	future	future	JJ
18637	1944	69	employees	employee	NNS
18637	1944	70	.	.	.
18637	1945	1	In	in	IN
18637	1945	2	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	1945	3	Retirement	Retirement	NNP
18637	1945	4	Board	Board	NNP
18637	1945	5	_	_	NNP
18637	1945	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	1945	7	_	_	NNP
18637	1945	8	Alton	Alton	NNP
18637	1945	9	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	1946	1	Company,[412	Company,[412	NNP
18637	1946	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1946	3	however	however	RB
18637	1946	4	,	,	,
18637	1946	5	a	a	DT
18637	1946	6	closely	closely	RB
18637	1946	7	divided	divide	VBN
18637	1946	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1946	9	held	hold	VBD
18637	1946	10	this	this	DT
18637	1946	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1946	12	to	to	TO
18637	1946	13	be	be	VB
18637	1946	14	in	in	IN
18637	1946	15	excess	excess	NN
18637	1946	16	of	of	IN
18637	1946	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1946	18	's	's	POS
18637	1946	19	power	power	NN
18637	1946	20	to	to	TO
18637	1946	21	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1946	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1946	23	and	and	CC
18637	1946	24	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	1946	25	to	to	IN
18637	1946	26	the	the	DT
18637	1946	27	due	due	JJ
18637	1946	28	process	process	NN
18637	1946	29	clause	clause	NN
18637	1946	30	of	of	IN
18637	1946	31	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	1946	32	V.	V.	NNP
18637	1946	33	Said	Said	NNP
18637	1946	34	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1946	35	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	1946	36	for	for	IN
18637	1946	37	the	the	DT
18637	1946	38	majority	majority	NN
18637	1946	39	:	:	:
18637	1946	40	"	"	``
18637	1946	41	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1946	42	feel	feel	VBP
18637	1946	43	bound	bind	VBN
18637	1946	44	to	to	TO
18637	1946	45	hold	hold	VB
18637	1946	46	that	that	IN
18637	1946	47	a	a	DT
18637	1946	48	pension	pension	NN
18637	1946	49	plan	plan	NN
18637	1946	50	thus	thus	RB
18637	1946	51	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	1946	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	1946	53	in	in	IN
18637	1946	54	no	no	DT
18637	1946	55	proper	proper	JJ
18637	1946	56	sense	sense	NN
18637	1946	57	a	a	DT
18637	1946	58	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1946	59	of	of	IN
18637	1946	60	the	the	DT
18637	1946	61	activity	activity	NN
18637	1946	62	of	of	IN
18637	1946	63	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1946	64	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1946	65	.	.	.
18637	1947	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1947	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1947	3	an	an	DT
18637	1947	4	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	1947	5	for	for	IN
18637	1947	6	social	social	JJ
18637	1947	7	ends	end	NNS
18637	1947	8	to	to	TO
18637	1947	9	impose	impose	VB
18637	1947	10	by	by	IN
18637	1947	11	sheer	sheer	JJ
18637	1947	12	fiat	fiat	JJ
18637	1947	13	noncontractual	noncontractual	JJ
18637	1947	14	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	1947	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	1947	16	the	the	DT
18637	1947	17	relation	relation	NN
18637	1947	18	of	of	IN
18637	1947	19	employer	employer	NN
18637	1947	20	and	and	CC
18637	1947	21	employee	employee	NN
18637	1947	22	,	,	,
18637	1947	23	not	not	RB
18637	1947	24	as	as	IN
18637	1947	25	a	a	DT
18637	1947	26	rule	rule	NN
18637	1947	27	or	or	CC
18637	1947	28	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1947	29	of	of	IN
18637	1947	30	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1947	31	and	and	CC
18637	1947	32	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1947	33	between	between	IN
18637	1947	34	the	the	DT
18637	1947	35	States	States	NNPS
18637	1947	36	,	,	,
18637	1947	37	but	but	CC
18637	1947	38	as	as	IN
18637	1947	39	a	a	DT
18637	1947	40	means	means	NN
18637	1947	41	of	of	IN
18637	1947	42	assuring	assure	VBG
18637	1947	43	a	a	DT
18637	1947	44	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1947	45	class	class	NN
18637	1947	46	of	of	IN
18637	1947	47	employees	employee	NNS
18637	1947	48	against	against	IN
18637	1947	49	old	old	JJ
18637	1947	50	age	age	NN
18637	1947	51	dependency	dependency	NN
18637	1947	52	.	.	.
18637	1948	1	This	this	DT
18637	1948	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1948	3	neither	neither	CC
18637	1948	4	a	a	DT
18637	1948	5	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1948	6	nor	nor	CC
18637	1948	7	an	an	DT
18637	1948	8	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	1948	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	1948	10	or	or	CC
18637	1948	11	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1948	12	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	1948	13	the	the	DT
18637	1948	14	due	due	JJ
18637	1948	15	fulfillment	fulfillment	NN
18637	1948	16	of	of	IN
18637	1948	17	the	the	DT
18637	1948	18	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	1948	19	'	'	POS
18637	1948	20	duty	duty	NN
18637	1948	21	to	to	TO
18637	1948	22	serve	serve	VB
18637	1948	23	the	the	DT
18637	1948	24	public	public	NN
18637	1948	25	in	in	IN
18637	1948	26	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1948	27	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1948	28	.	.	.
18637	1949	1	"	"	``
18637	1949	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1949	3	413	413	CD
18637	1949	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1949	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1949	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1949	7	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	1949	8	,	,	,
18637	1949	9	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	1949	10	for	for	IN
18637	1949	11	the	the	DT
18637	1949	12	dissenters	dissenter	NNS
18637	1949	13	,	,	,
18637	1949	14	contended	contend	VBD
18637	1949	15	,	,	,
18637	1949	16	on	on	IN
18637	1949	17	the	the	DT
18637	1949	18	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	1949	19	,	,	,
18637	1949	20	that	that	IN
18637	1949	21	"	"	``
18637	1949	22	the	the	DT
18637	1949	23	morale	morale	NN
18637	1949	24	of	of	IN
18637	1949	25	the	the	DT
18637	1949	26	employees	employee	NNS
18637	1949	27	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1949	28	had	have	VBD
18637	1949	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1949	30	an	an	DT
18637	1949	31	important	important	JJ
18637	1949	32	bearing	bearing	NN
18637	1949	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	1949	34	the	the	DT
18637	1949	35	efficiency	efficiency	NN
18637	1949	36	of	of	IN
18637	1949	37	the	the	DT
18637	1949	38	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1949	39	service	service	NN
18637	1949	40	.	.	.
18637	1949	41	"	"	''
18637	1950	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1950	2	added	add	VBD
18637	1950	3	:	:	:
18637	1950	4	"	"	``
18637	1950	5	The	the	DT
18637	1950	6	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	1950	7	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	1950	8	which	which	WDT
18637	1950	9	supports	support	VBZ
18637	1950	10	this	this	DT
18637	1950	11	type	type	NN
18637	1950	12	of	of	IN
18637	1950	13	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1950	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	1950	15	that	that	IN
18637	1950	16	industry	industry	NN
18637	1950	17	should	should	MD
18637	1950	18	take	take	VB
18637	1950	19	care	care	NN
18637	1950	20	of	of	IN
18637	1950	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1950	22	human	human	JJ
18637	1950	23	wastage	wastage	NN
18637	1950	24	,	,	,
18637	1950	25	whether	whether	IN
18637	1950	26	that	that	DT
18637	1950	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	1950	28	due	due	JJ
18637	1950	29	to	to	IN
18637	1950	30	accident	accident	NN
18637	1950	31	or	or	CC
18637	1950	32	age	age	NN
18637	1950	33	.	.	.
18637	1951	1	That	that	DT
18637	1951	2	view	view	NN
18637	1951	3	can	can	MD
18637	1951	4	not	not	RB
18637	1951	5	be	be	VB
18637	1951	6	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
18637	1951	7	as	as	IN
18637	1951	8	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	1951	9	or	or	CC
18637	1951	10	capricious	capricious	JJ
18637	1951	11	.	.	.
18637	1952	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1952	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1952	3	a	a	DT
18637	1952	4	reasoned	reasoned	JJ
18637	1952	5	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	1952	6	based	base	VBN
18637	1952	7	upon	upon	IN
18637	1952	8	abundant	abundant	JJ
18637	1952	9	experience	experience	NN
18637	1952	10	.	.	.
18637	1953	1	The	the	DT
18637	1953	2	expression	expression	NN
18637	1953	3	of	of	IN
18637	1953	4	that	that	DT
18637	1953	5	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	1953	6	in	in	IN
18637	1953	7	law	law	NN
18637	1953	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	1953	9	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1953	10	.	.	.
18637	1954	1	When	when	WRB
18637	1954	2	expressed	express	VBN
18637	1954	3	in	in	IN
18637	1954	4	the	the	DT
18637	1954	5	government	government	NN
18637	1954	6	of	of	IN
18637	1954	7	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1954	8	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	1954	9	,	,	,
18637	1954	10	with	with	IN
18637	1954	11	respect	respect	NN
18637	1954	12	to	to	IN
18637	1954	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1954	14	employees	employee	NNS
18637	1954	15	likewise	likewise	RB
18637	1954	16	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1954	17	in	in	IN
18637	1954	18	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1954	19	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1954	20	,	,	,
18637	1954	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1954	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	1954	23	a	a	DT
18637	1954	24	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1954	25	of	of	IN
18637	1954	26	that	that	DT
18637	1954	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1954	28	.	.	.
18637	1955	1	As	as	IN
18637	1955	2	such	such	JJ
18637	1955	3	,	,	,
18637	1955	4	so	so	RB
18637	1955	5	far	far	RB
18637	1955	6	as	as	IN
18637	1955	7	the	the	DT
18637	1955	8	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1955	9	matter	matter	NN
18637	1955	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	1955	11	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	1955	12	,	,	,
18637	1955	13	the	the	DT
18637	1955	14	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1955	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	1955	16	should	should	MD
18637	1955	17	be	be	VB
18637	1955	18	held	hold	VBN
18637	1955	19	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	1955	20	.	.	.
18637	1956	1	"	"	``
18637	1956	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1956	3	414	414	CD
18637	1956	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1956	5	Under	under	IN
18637	1956	6	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	1956	7	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1956	8	,	,	,
18637	1956	9	an	an	DT
18637	1956	10	excise	excise	NN
18637	1956	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	1956	12	levied	levy	VBN
18637	1956	13	on	on	IN
18637	1956	14	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1956	15	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	1956	16	and	and	CC
18637	1956	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1956	18	employees	employee	NNS
18637	1956	19	,	,	,
18637	1956	20	while	while	IN
18637	1956	21	by	by	IN
18637	1956	22	separate	separate	JJ
18637	1956	23	but	but	CC
18637	1956	24	parallel	parallel	JJ
18637	1956	25	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	1956	26	a	a	DT
18637	1956	27	fund	fund	NN
18637	1956	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	1956	29	created	create	VBN
18637	1956	30	in	in	IN
18637	1956	31	the	the	DT
18637	1956	32	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	1956	33	out	out	IN
18637	1956	34	of	of	IN
18637	1956	35	which	which	WDT
18637	1956	36	pensions	pension	NNS
18637	1956	37	are	be	VBP
18637	1956	38	paid	pay	VBN
18637	1956	39	along	along	IN
18637	1956	40	the	the	DT
18637	1956	41	lines	line	NNS
18637	1956	42	of	of	IN
18637	1956	43	the	the	DT
18637	1956	44	original	original	JJ
18637	1956	45	plan	plan	NN
18637	1956	46	.	.	.
18637	1957	1	The	the	DT
18637	1957	2	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	1957	3	of	of	IN
18637	1957	4	this	this	DT
18637	1957	5	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	1957	6	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	1957	7	to	to	TO
18637	1957	8	be	be	VB
18637	1957	9	taken	take	VBN
18637	1957	10	for	for	IN
18637	1957	11	granted	grant	VBN
18637	1957	12	in	in	IN
18637	1957	13	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	1957	14	Retirement	Retirement	NNP
18637	1957	15	Board	Board	NNP
18637	1957	16	_	_	NNP
18637	1957	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	1957	18	_	_	NNP
18637	1957	19	Duquesne	Duquesne	NNP
18637	1957	20	Warehouse	Warehouse	NNP
18637	1957	21	Company	Company	NNP
18637	1957	22	.	.	.
18637	1958	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1958	2	415	415	CD
18637	1958	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1958	4	BILLS	BILLS	NNPS
18637	1958	5	OF	of	IN
18637	1958	6	LADING	LADING	NNP
18637	1958	7	;	;	:
18637	1958	8	THE	the	DT
18637	1958	9	FERGER	FERGER	NNP
18637	1958	10	CASE	case	NN
18637	1958	11	Some	some	DT
18637	1958	12	years	year	NNS
18637	1958	13	earlier	early	RBR
18637	1958	14	the	the	DT
18637	1958	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1958	16	had	have	VBD
18637	1958	17	had	have	VBN
18637	1958	18	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	1958	19	in	in	IN
18637	1958	20	United	United	NNP
18637	1958	21	States	States	NNP
18637	1958	22	_	_	NNP
18637	1958	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	1958	24	_	_	NNP
18637	1958	25	Ferger,[416	Ferger,[416	NNP
18637	1958	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1958	27	decided	decide	VBD
18637	1958	28	in	in	IN
18637	1958	29	1919	1919	CD
18637	1958	30	,	,	,
18637	1958	31	to	to	TO
18637	1958	32	reiterate	reiterate	VB
18637	1958	33	the	the	DT
18637	1958	34	rule	rule	NN
18637	1958	35	laid	lay	VBN
18637	1958	36	down	down	RP
18637	1958	37	in	in	IN
18637	1958	38	the	the	DT
18637	1958	39	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	1958	40	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	1958	41	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1958	42	,	,	,
18637	1958	43	that	that	IN
18637	1958	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1958	45	's	's	POS
18637	1958	46	protective	protective	JJ
18637	1958	47	power	power	NN
18637	1958	48	over	over	IN
18637	1958	49	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1958	50	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1958	51	reaches	reach	VBZ
18637	1958	52	all	all	DT
18637	1958	53	kinds	kind	NNS
18637	1958	54	of	of	IN
18637	1958	55	obstructions	obstruction	NNS
18637	1958	56	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	1958	57	the	the	DT
18637	1958	58	source	source	NN
18637	1958	59	of	of	IN
18637	1958	60	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1958	61	origin	origin	NN
18637	1958	62	.	.	.
18637	1959	1	Ferger	Ferger	NNP
18637	1959	2	and	and	CC
18637	1959	3	associates	associate	NNS
18637	1959	4	had	have	VBD
18637	1959	5	been	be	VBN
18637	1959	6	indicted	indict	VBN
18637	1959	7	under	under	IN
18637	1959	8	a	a	DT
18637	1959	9	federal	federal	JJ
18637	1959	10	statute	statute	NN
18637	1959	11	for	for	IN
18637	1959	12	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	1959	13	a	a	DT
18637	1959	14	false	false	JJ
18637	1959	15	bill	bill	NN
18637	1959	16	of	of	IN
18637	1959	17	lading	lading	NN
18637	1959	18	,	,	,
18637	1959	19	to	to	TO
18637	1959	20	cover	cover	VB
18637	1959	21	a	a	DT
18637	1959	22	fictitious	fictitious	JJ
18637	1959	23	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	1959	24	in	in	IN
18637	1959	25	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1959	26	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1959	27	.	.	.
18637	1960	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1960	2	defense	defense	NN
18637	1960	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1960	4	that	that	IN
18637	1960	5	,	,	,
18637	1960	6	since	since	IN
18637	1960	7	there	there	EX
18637	1960	8	could	could	MD
18637	1960	9	be	be	VB
18637	1960	10	no	no	DT
18637	1960	11	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1960	12	in	in	IN
18637	1960	13	a	a	DT
18637	1960	14	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	1960	15	bill	bill	NN
18637	1960	16	of	of	IN
18637	1960	17	lading	lading	NN
18637	1960	18	,	,	,
18637	1960	19	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	1960	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1960	21	's	's	POS
18637	1960	22	power	power	NN
18637	1960	23	could	could	MD
18637	1960	24	not	not	RB
18637	1960	25	reach	reach	VB
18637	1960	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1960	27	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	1960	28	offense	offense	NN
18637	1960	29	,	,	,
18637	1960	30	a	a	DT
18637	1960	31	contention	contention	NN
18637	1960	32	which	which	WDT
18637	1960	33	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1960	34	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1960	35	White	White	NNP
18637	1960	36	,	,	,
18637	1960	37	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	1960	38	for	for	IN
18637	1960	39	the	the	DT
18637	1960	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1960	41	,	,	,
18637	1960	42	answered	answer	VBD
18637	1960	43	thus	thus	RB
18637	1960	44	:	:	:
18637	1960	45	"	"	``
18637	1960	46	But	but	CC
18637	1960	47	this	this	DT
18637	1960	48	mistakenly	mistakenly	RB
18637	1960	49	assumes	assume	VBZ
18637	1960	50	that	that	IN
18637	1960	51	the	the	DT
18637	1960	52	power	power	NN
18637	1960	53	of	of	IN
18637	1960	54	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1960	55	is	be	VBZ
18637	1960	56	to	to	TO
18637	1960	57	be	be	VB
18637	1960	58	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	1960	59	tested	test	VBN
18637	1960	60	by	by	IN
18637	1960	61	the	the	DT
18637	1960	62	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
18637	1960	63	existence	existence	NN
18637	1960	64	of	of	IN
18637	1960	65	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1960	66	in	in	IN
18637	1960	67	the	the	DT
18637	1960	68	particular	particular	JJ
18637	1960	69	subject	subject	NN
18637	1960	70	dealt	deal	VBD
18637	1960	71	with	with	IN
18637	1960	72	,	,	,
18637	1960	73	instead	instead	RB
18637	1960	74	of	of	IN
18637	1960	75	by	by	IN
18637	1960	76	the	the	DT
18637	1960	77	relation	relation	NN
18637	1960	78	of	of	IN
18637	1960	79	that	that	DT
18637	1960	80	subject	subject	NN
18637	1960	81	to	to	IN
18637	1960	82	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1960	83	and	and	CC
18637	1960	84	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1960	85	effect	effect	NN
18637	1960	86	upon	upon	IN
18637	1960	87	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1960	88	.	.	.
18637	1961	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1961	2	say	say	VBP
18637	1961	3	mistakenly	mistakenly	RB
18637	1961	4	assumes	assume	VBZ
18637	1961	5	,	,	,
18637	1961	6	because	because	IN
18637	1961	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1961	8	think	think	VBP
18637	1961	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1961	10	clear	clear	JJ
18637	1961	11	that	that	IN
18637	1961	12	if	if	IN
18637	1961	13	the	the	DT
18637	1961	14	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	1961	15	were	be	VBD
18637	1961	16	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	1961	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1961	18	would	would	MD
18637	1961	19	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	1961	20	the	the	DT
18637	1961	21	power	power	NN
18637	1961	22	of	of	IN
18637	1961	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1961	24	to	to	TO
18637	1961	25	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1961	26	,	,	,
18637	1961	27	as	as	RB
18637	1961	28	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	1961	29	that	that	DT
18637	1961	30	power	power	NN
18637	1961	31	,	,	,
18637	1961	32	if	if	IN
18637	1961	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1961	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	1961	35	to	to	TO
18637	1961	36	exist	exist	VB
18637	1961	37	,	,	,
18637	1961	38	must	must	MD
18637	1961	39	include	include	VB
18637	1961	40	the	the	DT
18637	1961	41	authority	authority	NN
18637	1961	42	to	to	TO
18637	1961	43	deal	deal	VB
18637	1961	44	with	with	IN
18637	1961	45	obstructions	obstruction	NNS
18637	1961	46	to	to	IN
18637	1961	47	interstate	interstate	VB
18637	1961	48	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1961	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1961	50	_	_	NNP
18637	1961	51	In	In	NNP
18637	1961	52	re	re	NN
18637	1961	53	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	1961	54	_	_	NNP
18637	1961	55	,	,	,
18637	1961	56	158	158	CD
18637	1961	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	1961	58	564	564	CD
18637	1961	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1961	60	and	and	CC
18637	1961	61	with	with	IN
18637	1961	62	a	a	DT
18637	1961	63	host	host	NN
18637	1961	64	of	of	IN
18637	1961	65	other	other	JJ
18637	1961	66	acts	act	NNS
18637	1961	67	which	which	WDT
18637	1961	68	,	,	,
18637	1961	69	because	because	IN
18637	1961	70	of	of	IN
18637	1961	71	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1961	72	relation	relation	NN
18637	1961	73	to	to	IN
18637	1961	74	and	and	CC
18637	1961	75	influence	influence	NN
18637	1961	76	upon	upon	IN
18637	1961	77	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1961	78	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1961	79	,	,	,
18637	1961	80	come	come	VBN
18637	1961	81	within	within	IN
18637	1961	82	the	the	DT
18637	1961	83	power	power	NN
18637	1961	84	of	of	IN
18637	1961	85	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1961	86	to	to	TO
18637	1961	87	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1961	88	,	,	,
18637	1961	89	although	although	IN
18637	1961	90	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1961	91	are	be	VBP
18637	1961	92	not	not	RB
18637	1961	93	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1961	94	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1961	95	in	in	IN
18637	1961	96	and	and	CC
18637	1961	97	of	of	IN
18637	1961	98	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1961	99	.	.	.
18637	1962	1	*	*	NFP
18637	1962	2	*	*	NFP
18637	1962	3	*	*	NFP
18637	1962	4	That	that	IN
18637	1962	5	as	as	IN
18637	1962	6	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	1962	7	of	of	IN
18637	1962	8	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1962	9	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1962	10	,	,	,
18637	1962	11	bills	bill	NNS
18637	1962	12	of	of	IN
18637	1962	13	lading	lading	NN
18637	1962	14	are	be	VBP
18637	1962	15	the	the	DT
18637	1962	16	efficient	efficient	JJ
18637	1962	17	means	mean	NNS
18637	1962	18	of	of	IN
18637	1962	19	credit	credit	NN
18637	1962	20	resorted	resort	VBD
18637	1962	21	to	to	IN
18637	1962	22	for	for	IN
18637	1962	23	the	the	DT
18637	1962	24	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1962	25	of	of	IN
18637	1962	26	securing	secure	VBG
18637	1962	27	and	and	CC
18637	1962	28	fructifying	fructify	VBG
18637	1962	29	the	the	DT
18637	1962	30	flow	flow	NN
18637	1962	31	of	of	IN
18637	1962	32	a	a	DT
18637	1962	33	vast	vast	JJ
18637	1962	34	volume	volume	NN
18637	1962	35	of	of	IN
18637	1962	36	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1962	37	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1962	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	1962	39	which	which	WDT
18637	1962	40	the	the	DT
18637	1962	41	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	1962	42	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	1962	43	of	of	IN
18637	1962	44	the	the	DT
18637	1962	45	country	country	NN
18637	1962	46	,	,	,
18637	1962	47	both	both	CC
18637	1962	48	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	1962	49	and	and	CC
18637	1962	50	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1962	51	,	,	,
18637	1962	52	largely	largely	RB
18637	1962	53	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	1962	54	,	,	,
18637	1962	55	is	be	VBZ
18637	1962	56	a	a	DT
18637	1962	57	matter	matter	NN
18637	1962	58	of	of	IN
18637	1962	59	common	common	JJ
18637	1962	60	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	1962	61	as	as	IN
18637	1962	62	to	to	IN
18637	1962	63	the	the	DT
18637	1962	64	course	course	NN
18637	1962	65	of	of	IN
18637	1962	66	business	business	NN
18637	1962	67	of	of	IN
18637	1962	68	which	which	WDT
18637	1962	69	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1962	70	may	may	MD
18637	1962	71	take	take	VB
18637	1962	72	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	1962	73	notice	notice	NN
18637	1962	74	.	.	.
18637	1963	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	1963	2	,	,	,
18637	1963	3	that	that	IN
18637	1963	4	such	such	JJ
18637	1963	5	bills	bill	NNS
18637	1963	6	of	of	IN
18637	1963	7	lading	lading	NN
18637	1963	8	and	and	CC
18637	1963	9	the	the	DT
18637	1963	10	faith	faith	NN
18637	1963	11	and	and	CC
18637	1963	12	credit	credit	NN
18637	1963	13	given	give	VBN
18637	1963	14	to	to	IN
18637	1963	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1963	16	genuineness	genuineness	NN
18637	1963	17	and	and	CC
18637	1963	18	the	the	DT
18637	1963	19	value	value	NN
18637	1963	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1963	21	represent	represent	VBP
18637	1963	22	are	be	VBP
18637	1963	23	the	the	DT
18637	1963	24	producing	produce	VBG
18637	1963	25	and	and	CC
18637	1963	26	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	1963	27	causes	cause	NNS
18637	1963	28	of	of	IN
18637	1963	29	the	the	DT
18637	1963	30	enormous	enormous	JJ
18637	1963	31	number	number	NN
18637	1963	32	of	of	IN
18637	1963	33	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	1963	34	in	in	IN
18637	1963	35	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	1963	36	and	and	CC
18637	1963	37	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1963	38	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	1963	39	,	,	,
18637	1963	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	1963	41	also	also	RB
18637	1963	42	so	so	RB
18637	1963	43	certain	certain	JJ
18637	1963	44	and	and	CC
18637	1963	45	well	well	RB
18637	1963	46	known	know	VBN
18637	1963	47	that	that	IN
18637	1963	48	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1963	49	may	may	MD
18637	1963	50	notice	notice	VB
18637	1963	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1963	52	without	without	IN
18637	1963	53	proof	proof	NN
18637	1963	54	.	.	.
18637	1964	1	"	"	``
18637	1964	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1964	3	417	417	CD
18637	1964	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1964	5	Congressional	Congressional	NNP
18637	1964	6	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	1964	7	of	of	IN
18637	1964	8	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1964	9	as	as	IN
18637	1964	10	Traffic	Traffic	NNP
18637	1964	11	THE	the	DT
18637	1964	12	SHERMAN	SHERMAN	NNP
18637	1964	13	ACT	ACT	NNP
18637	1964	14	;	;	:
18637	1964	15	THE	the	DT
18637	1964	16	"	"	``
18637	1964	17	SUGAR	SUGAR	NNP
18637	1964	18	TRUST	trust	NN
18637	1964	19	CASE	case	NN
18637	1964	20	"	"	``
18637	1964	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1964	22	's	's	POS
18637	1964	23	chief	chief	JJ
18637	1964	24	effort	effort	NN
18637	1964	25	to	to	TO
18637	1964	26	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	1964	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1964	28	in	in	IN
18637	1964	29	the	the	DT
18637	1964	30	primary	primary	JJ
18637	1964	31	sense	sense	NN
18637	1964	32	of	of	IN
18637	1964	33	"	"	``
18637	1964	34	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	1964	35	"	"	''
18637	1964	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	1964	37	embodied	embody	VBN
18637	1964	38	in	in	IN
18637	1964	39	the	the	DT
18637	1964	40	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	1964	41	Antitrust	Antitrust	NNP
18637	1964	42	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1964	43	of	of	IN
18637	1964	44	1890	1890	CD
18637	1964	45	,	,	,
18637	1964	46	the	the	DT
18637	1964	47	opening	opening	NN
18637	1964	48	section	section	NN
18637	1964	49	of	of	IN
18637	1964	50	which	which	WDT
18637	1964	51	declares	declare	VBZ
18637	1964	52	"	"	``
18637	1964	53	every	every	DT
18637	1964	54	contract	contract	NN
18637	1964	55	,	,	,
18637	1964	56	combination	combination	NN
18637	1964	57	in	in	IN
18637	1964	58	the	the	DT
18637	1964	59	form	form	NN
18637	1964	60	of	of	IN
18637	1964	61	trust	trust	NN
18637	1964	62	or	or	CC
18637	1964	63	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	1964	64	,	,	,
18637	1964	65	"	"	''
18637	1964	66	or	or	CC
18637	1964	67	"	"	``
18637	1964	68	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	1964	69	in	in	IN
18637	1964	70	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	1964	71	of	of	IN
18637	1964	72	trade	trade	NN
18637	1964	73	and	and	CC
18637	1964	74	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1964	75	among	among	IN
18637	1964	76	the	the	DT
18637	1964	77	several	several	JJ
18637	1964	78	States	States	NNPS
18637	1964	79	,	,	,
18637	1964	80	or	or	CC
18637	1964	81	with	with	IN
18637	1964	82	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1964	83	nations	nation	NNS
18637	1964	84	"	"	''
18637	1964	85	to	to	TO
18637	1964	86	be	be	VB
18637	1964	87	"	"	``
18637	1964	88	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	1964	89	,	,	,
18637	1964	90	"	"	''
18637	1964	91	while	while	IN
18637	1964	92	the	the	DT
18637	1964	93	second	second	JJ
18637	1964	94	section	section	NN
18637	1964	95	makes	make	VBZ
18637	1964	96	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1964	97	a	a	DT
18637	1964	98	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
18637	1964	99	for	for	IN
18637	1964	100	anybody	anybody	NN
18637	1964	101	to	to	TO
18637	1964	102	"	"	``
18637	1964	103	monopolize	monopolize	VB
18637	1964	104	or	or	CC
18637	1964	105	attempt	attempt	VB
18637	1964	106	to	to	TO
18637	1964	107	monopolize	monopolize	VB
18637	1964	108	any	any	DT
18637	1964	109	part	part	NN
18637	1964	110	of	of	IN
18637	1964	111	such	such	JJ
18637	1964	112	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1964	113	.	.	.
18637	1965	1	"	"	``
18637	1965	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1965	3	418	418	CD
18637	1965	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1965	5	The	the	DT
18637	1965	6	act	act	NN
18637	1965	7	was	be	VBD
18637	1965	8	passed	pass	VBN
18637	1965	9	to	to	TO
18637	1965	10	curb	curb	VB
18637	1965	11	the	the	DT
18637	1965	12	growing	grow	VBG
18637	1965	13	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	1965	14	to	to	TO
18637	1965	15	form	form	VB
18637	1965	16	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	1965	17	combinations	combination	NNS
18637	1965	18	and	and	CC
18637	1965	19	the	the	DT
18637	1965	20	first	first	JJ
18637	1965	21	case	case	NN
18637	1965	22	to	to	TO
18637	1965	23	reach	reach	VB
18637	1965	24	the	the	DT
18637	1965	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1965	26	under	under	IN
18637	1965	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1965	28	was	be	VBD
18637	1965	29	the	the	DT
18637	1965	30	famous	famous	JJ
18637	1965	31	"	"	``
18637	1965	32	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	1965	33	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	1965	34	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1965	35	,	,	,
18637	1965	36	"	"	''
18637	1965	37	United	United	NNP
18637	1965	38	States	States	NNP
18637	1965	39	_	_	NNP
18637	1965	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	1965	41	_	_	NNP
18637	1965	42	E.C.	E.C.	NNP
18637	1966	1	Knight	Knight	NNP
18637	1966	2	Co.[419	Co.[419	NNP
18637	1966	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1966	4	Here	here	RB
18637	1966	5	the	the	DT
18637	1966	6	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1966	7	asked	ask	VBD
18637	1966	8	for	for	IN
18637	1966	9	the	the	DT
18637	1966	10	cancellation	cancellation	NN
18637	1966	11	of	of	IN
18637	1966	12	certain	certain	JJ
18637	1966	13	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	1966	14	,	,	,
18637	1966	15	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	1966	16	,	,	,
18637	1966	17	through	through	IN
18637	1966	18	purchases	purchase	NNS
18637	1966	19	of	of	IN
18637	1966	20	stock	stock	NN
18637	1966	21	in	in	IN
18637	1966	22	other	other	JJ
18637	1966	23	companies	company	NNS
18637	1966	24	,	,	,
18637	1966	25	the	the	DT
18637	1966	26	American	American	NNP
18637	1966	27	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	1966	28	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	1966	29	Company	Company	NNP
18637	1966	30	,	,	,
18637	1966	31	had	have	VBD
18637	1966	32	"	"	``
18637	1966	33	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	1966	34	,	,	,
18637	1966	35	"	"	''
18637	1966	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1966	37	was	be	VBD
18637	1966	38	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	1966	39	,	,	,
18637	1966	40	"	"	``
18637	1966	41	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	1966	42	complete	complete	JJ
18637	1966	43	control	control	NN
18637	1966	44	of	of	IN
18637	1966	45	the	the	DT
18637	1966	46	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	1966	47	of	of	IN
18637	1966	48	refined	refined	JJ
18637	1966	49	sugars	sugar	NNS
18637	1966	50	in	in	IN
18637	1966	51	the	the	DT
18637	1966	52	United	United	NNP
18637	1966	53	States	States	NNP
18637	1966	54	.	.	.
18637	1966	55	"	"	''
18637	1967	1	The	the	DT
18637	1967	2	question	question	NN
18637	1967	3	of	of	IN
18637	1967	4	the	the	DT
18637	1967	5	validity	validity	NN
18637	1967	6	of	of	IN
18637	1967	7	the	the	DT
18637	1967	8	act	act	NN
18637	1967	9	was	be	VBD
18637	1967	10	not	not	RB
18637	1967	11	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	1967	12	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	1967	13	by	by	IN
18637	1967	14	the	the	DT
18637	1967	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1967	16	,	,	,
18637	1967	17	but	but	CC
18637	1967	18	was	be	VBD
18637	1967	19	subordinated	subordinate	VBN
18637	1967	20	to	to	IN
18637	1967	21	that	that	DT
18637	1967	22	of	of	IN
18637	1967	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1967	24	proper	proper	JJ
18637	1967	25	construction	construction	NN
18637	1967	26	.	.	.
18637	1968	1	So	so	RB
18637	1968	2	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	1968	3	,	,	,
18637	1968	4	the	the	DT
18637	1968	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1968	6	,	,	,
18637	1968	7	in	in	IN
18637	1968	8	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	1968	9	of	of	IN
18637	1968	10	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	1968	11	of	of	IN
18637	1968	12	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	1968	13	Law	Law	NNP
18637	1968	14	which	which	WDT
18637	1968	15	were	be	VBD
18637	1968	16	then	then	RB
18637	1968	17	dominant	dominant	JJ
18637	1968	18	with	with	IN
18637	1968	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1968	20	,	,	,
18637	1968	21	turned	turn	VBD
18637	1968	22	the	the	DT
18637	1968	23	act	act	NN
18637	1968	24	from	from	IN
18637	1968	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1968	26	intended	intended	JJ
18637	1968	27	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	1968	28	and	and	CC
18637	1968	29	destroyed	destroy	VBD
18637	1968	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1968	31	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
18637	1968	32	for	for	IN
18637	1968	33	several	several	JJ
18637	1968	34	years	year	NNS
18637	1968	35	,	,	,
18637	1968	36	as	as	IN
18637	1968	37	that	that	DT
18637	1968	38	of	of	IN
18637	1968	39	the	the	DT
18637	1968	40	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	1968	41	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1968	42	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1968	43	was	be	VBD
18637	1968	44	being	be	VBG
18637	1968	45	contemporaneously	contemporaneously	RB
18637	1968	46	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	1968	47	.	.	.
18637	1969	1	The	the	DT
18637	1969	2	following	follow	VBG
18637	1969	3	passage	passage	NN
18637	1969	4	early	early	RB
18637	1969	5	in	in	IN
18637	1969	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1969	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1969	8	Fuller	Fuller	NNP
18637	1969	9	's	's	POS
18637	1969	10	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	1969	11	for	for	IN
18637	1969	12	the	the	DT
18637	1969	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1969	14	,	,	,
18637	1969	15	sets	set	VBZ
18637	1969	16	forth	forth	RB
18637	1969	17	the	the	DT
18637	1969	18	conception	conception	NN
18637	1969	19	of	of	IN
18637	1969	20	the	the	DT
18637	1969	21	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	1969	22	System	System	NNP
18637	1969	23	that	that	WDT
18637	1969	24	controlled	control	VBD
18637	1969	25	the	the	DT
18637	1969	26	decision	decision	NN
18637	1969	27	:	:	:
18637	1969	28	"	"	``
18637	1969	29	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1969	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	1969	31	vital	vital	JJ
18637	1969	32	that	that	IN
18637	1969	33	the	the	DT
18637	1969	34	independence	independence	NN
18637	1969	35	of	of	IN
18637	1969	36	the	the	DT
18637	1969	37	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	1969	38	power	power	NN
18637	1969	39	and	and	CC
18637	1969	40	of	of	IN
18637	1969	41	the	the	DT
18637	1969	42	police	police	NN
18637	1969	43	power	power	NN
18637	1969	44	,	,	,
18637	1969	45	and	and	CC
18637	1969	46	the	the	DT
18637	1969	47	delimitation	delimitation	NN
18637	1969	48	between	between	IN
18637	1969	49	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1969	50	,	,	,
18637	1969	51	however	however	RB
18637	1969	52	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	1969	53	perplexing	perplex	VBG
18637	1969	54	,	,	,
18637	1969	55	should	should	MD
18637	1969	56	always	always	RB
18637	1969	57	be	be	VB
18637	1969	58	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	1969	59	and	and	CC
18637	1969	60	observed	observe	VBN
18637	1969	61	,	,	,
18637	1969	62	for	for	IN
18637	1969	63	while	while	IN
18637	1969	64	the	the	DT
18637	1969	65	one	one	NN
18637	1969	66	furnishes	furnish	VBZ
18637	1969	67	the	the	DT
18637	1969	68	strongest	strong	JJS
18637	1969	69	bond	bond	NN
18637	1969	70	of	of	IN
18637	1969	71	union	union	NN
18637	1969	72	,	,	,
18637	1969	73	the	the	DT
18637	1969	74	other	other	JJ
18637	1969	75	is	be	VBZ
18637	1969	76	essential	essential	JJ
18637	1969	77	to	to	IN
18637	1969	78	the	the	DT
18637	1969	79	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	1969	80	of	of	IN
18637	1969	81	the	the	DT
18637	1969	82	autonomy	autonomy	NN
18637	1969	83	of	of	IN
18637	1969	84	the	the	DT
18637	1969	85	States	States	NNP
18637	1969	86	as	as	IN
18637	1969	87	required	require	VBN
18637	1969	88	by	by	IN
18637	1969	89	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1969	90	dual	dual	JJ
18637	1969	91	form	form	NN
18637	1969	92	of	of	IN
18637	1969	93	government	government	NN
18637	1969	94	;	;	:
18637	1969	95	and	and	CC
18637	1969	96	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBD
18637	1969	97	evils	evil	NNS
18637	1969	98	,	,	,
18637	1969	99	however	however	RB
18637	1969	100	grave	grave	JJ
18637	1969	101	and	and	CC
18637	1969	102	urgent	urgent	JJ
18637	1969	103	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1969	104	may	may	MD
18637	1969	105	appear	appear	VB
18637	1969	106	to	to	TO
18637	1969	107	be	be	VB
18637	1969	108	,	,	,
18637	1969	109	had	have	VBD
18637	1969	110	better	well	JJR
18637	1969	111	be	be	VB
18637	1969	112	borne	bear	VBN
18637	1969	113	,	,	,
18637	1969	114	than	than	IN
18637	1969	115	risk	risk	NN
18637	1969	116	be	be	VB
18637	1969	117	run	run	VBN
18637	1969	118	,	,	,
18637	1969	119	in	in	IN
18637	1969	120	the	the	DT
18637	1969	121	effort	effort	NN
18637	1969	122	to	to	TO
18637	1969	123	suppress	suppress	VB
18637	1969	124	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1969	125	,	,	,
18637	1969	126	of	of	IN
18637	1969	127	more	more	RBR
18637	1969	128	serious	serious	JJ
18637	1969	129	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	1969	130	by	by	IN
18637	1969	131	resort	resort	NN
18637	1969	132	to	to	IN
18637	1969	133	expedients	expedient	NNS
18637	1969	134	of	of	IN
18637	1969	135	even	even	RB
18637	1969	136	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
18637	1969	137	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	1969	138	.	.	.
18637	1970	1	"	"	``
18637	1970	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1970	3	420	420	CD
18637	1970	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1970	5	In	in	IN
18637	1970	6	short	short	JJ
18637	1970	7	,	,	,
18637	1970	8	what	what	WP
18637	1970	9	was	be	VBD
18637	1970	10	needed	need	VBN
18637	1970	11	,	,	,
18637	1970	12	the	the	DT
18637	1970	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1970	14	felt	feel	VBD
18637	1970	15	,	,	,
18637	1970	16	was	be	VBD
18637	1970	17	a	a	DT
18637	1970	18	hard	hard	JJ
18637	1970	19	and	and	CC
18637	1970	20	fast	fast	JJ
18637	1970	21	line	line	NN
18637	1970	22	between	between	IN
18637	1970	23	the	the	DT
18637	1970	24	two	two	CD
18637	1970	25	spheres	sphere	NNS
18637	1970	26	of	of	IN
18637	1970	27	power	power	NN
18637	1970	28	,	,	,
18637	1970	29	and	and	CC
18637	1970	30	in	in	IN
18637	1970	31	the	the	DT
18637	1970	32	following	follow	VBG
18637	1970	33	series	series	NN
18637	1970	34	of	of	IN
18637	1970	35	propositions	proposition	NNS
18637	1970	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1970	37	endeavored	endeavor	VBD
18637	1970	38	to	to	TO
18637	1970	39	lay	lay	VB
18637	1970	40	down	down	RP
18637	1970	41	such	such	PDT
18637	1970	42	a	a	DT
18637	1970	43	line	line	NN
18637	1970	44	:	:	:
18637	1970	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1970	46	1	1	LS
18637	1970	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1970	48	production	production	NN
18637	1970	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	1970	50	always	always	RB
18637	1970	51	local	local	JJ
18637	1970	52	,	,	,
18637	1970	53	and	and	CC
18637	1970	54	under	under	IN
18637	1970	55	the	the	DT
18637	1970	56	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	1970	57	domain	domain	NN
18637	1970	58	of	of	IN
18637	1970	59	the	the	DT
18637	1970	60	States	States	NNPS
18637	1970	61	;	;	:
18637	1970	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1970	63	2	2	LS
18637	1970	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1970	65	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1970	66	among	among	IN
18637	1970	67	the	the	DT
18637	1970	68	States	States	NNP
18637	1970	69	does	do	VBZ
18637	1970	70	not	not	RB
18637	1970	71	commence	commence	VB
18637	1970	72	until	until	IN
18637	1970	73	goods	good	NNS
18637	1970	74	"	"	``
18637	1970	75	commence	commence	VBP
18637	1970	76	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1970	77	final	final	JJ
18637	1970	78	movement	movement	NN
18637	1970	79	from	from	IN
18637	1970	80	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1970	81	State	State	NNP
18637	1970	82	of	of	IN
18637	1970	83	origin	origin	NN
18637	1970	84	to	to	IN
18637	1970	85	that	that	DT
18637	1970	86	of	of	IN
18637	1970	87	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1970	88	destination	destination	NN
18637	1970	89	"	"	''
18637	1970	90	;	;	,
18637	1970	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1970	92	3	3	LS
18637	1970	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1970	94	the	the	DT
18637	1970	95	sale	sale	NN
18637	1970	96	of	of	IN
18637	1970	97	a	a	DT
18637	1970	98	product	product	NN
18637	1970	99	is	be	VBZ
18637	1970	100	merely	merely	RB
18637	1970	101	an	an	DT
18637	1970	102	incident	incident	NN
18637	1970	103	of	of	IN
18637	1970	104	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1970	105	production	production	NN
18637	1970	106	and	and	CC
18637	1970	107	while	while	IN
18637	1970	108	capable	capable	JJ
18637	1970	109	of	of	IN
18637	1970	110	"	"	``
18637	1970	111	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	1970	112	the	the	DT
18637	1970	113	operation	operation	NN
18637	1970	114	of	of	IN
18637	1970	115	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1970	116	into	into	IN
18637	1970	117	play	play	NN
18637	1970	118	,	,	,
18637	1970	119	"	"	''
18637	1970	120	affects	affect	VBZ
18637	1970	121	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1970	122	only	only	RB
18637	1970	123	incidentally	incidentally	RB
18637	1970	124	;	;	,
18637	1970	125	(	(	-LRB-
18637	1970	126	4	4	LS
18637	1970	127	)	)	-RRB-
18637	1970	128	such	such	JJ
18637	1970	129	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	1970	130	as	as	IN
18637	1970	131	would	would	MD
18637	1970	132	reach	reach	VB
18637	1970	133	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1970	134	,	,	,
18637	1970	135	as	as	IN
18637	1970	136	above	above	IN
18637	1970	137	defined	define	VBN
18637	1970	138	,	,	,
18637	1970	139	in	in	IN
18637	1970	140	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	1970	141	of	of	IN
18637	1970	142	combinations	combination	NNS
18637	1970	143	to	to	TO
18637	1970	144	control	control	VB
18637	1970	145	production	production	NN
18637	1970	146	"	"	''
18637	1970	147	in	in	IN
18637	1970	148	all	all	DT
18637	1970	149	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1970	150	forms	form	NNS
18637	1970	151	,	,	,
18637	1970	152	"	"	``
18637	1970	153	would	would	MD
18637	1970	154	be	be	VB
18637	1970	155	"	"	``
18637	1970	156	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	1970	157	,	,	,
18637	1970	158	however	however	WRB
18637	1970	159	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
18637	1970	160	and	and	CC
18637	1970	161	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	1970	162	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1970	163	extent	extent	NN
18637	1970	164	,	,	,
18637	1970	165	"	"	''
18637	1970	166	and	and	CC
18637	1970	167	as	as	IN
18637	1970	168	such	such	JJ
18637	1970	169	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	1970	170	the	the	DT
18637	1970	171	purview	purview	NN
18637	1970	172	of	of	IN
18637	1970	173	the	the	DT
18637	1970	174	act	act	NN
18637	1970	175	.	.	.
18637	1971	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1971	2	421	421	CD
18637	1971	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1971	4	Applying	apply	VBG
18637	1971	5	then	then	RB
18637	1971	6	the	the	DT
18637	1971	7	above	above	JJ
18637	1971	8	reasoning	reason	VBG
18637	1971	9	to	to	IN
18637	1971	10	the	the	DT
18637	1971	11	case	case	NN
18637	1971	12	before	before	IN
18637	1971	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1971	14	,	,	,
18637	1971	15	the	the	DT
18637	1971	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1971	17	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	1971	18	:	:	:
18637	1971	19	"	"	``
18637	1971	20	The	the	DT
18637	1971	21	object	object	NN
18637	1971	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1971	23	of	of	IN
18637	1971	24	the	the	DT
18637	1971	25	combination	combination	NN
18637	1971	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1971	27	was	be	VBD
18637	1971	28	manifestly	manifestly	RB
18637	1971	29	private	private	JJ
18637	1971	30	gain	gain	NN
18637	1971	31	in	in	IN
18637	1971	32	the	the	DT
18637	1971	33	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	1971	34	of	of	IN
18637	1971	35	the	the	DT
18637	1971	36	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	1971	37	,	,	,
18637	1971	38	but	but	CC
18637	1971	39	not	not	RB
18637	1971	40	through	through	IN
18637	1971	41	the	the	DT
18637	1971	42	control	control	NN
18637	1971	43	of	of	IN
18637	1971	44	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1971	45	or	or	CC
18637	1971	46	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1971	47	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1971	48	.	.	.
18637	1972	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1972	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	1972	3	true	true	JJ
18637	1972	4	that	that	IN
18637	1972	5	the	the	DT
18637	1972	6	bill	bill	NN
18637	1972	7	alleged	allege	VBD
18637	1972	8	that	that	IN
18637	1972	9	the	the	DT
18637	1972	10	products	product	NNS
18637	1972	11	of	of	IN
18637	1972	12	these	these	DT
18637	1972	13	refineries	refinery	NNS
18637	1972	14	were	be	VBD
18637	1972	15	sold	sell	VBN
18637	1972	16	and	and	CC
18637	1972	17	distributed	distribute	VBN
18637	1972	18	among	among	IN
18637	1972	19	the	the	DT
18637	1972	20	several	several	JJ
18637	1972	21	States	States	NNPS
18637	1972	22	,	,	,
18637	1972	23	and	and	CC
18637	1972	24	that	that	IN
18637	1972	25	all	all	PDT
18637	1972	26	the	the	DT
18637	1972	27	companies	company	NNS
18637	1972	28	were	be	VBD
18637	1972	29	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1972	30	in	in	IN
18637	1972	31	trade	trade	NN
18637	1972	32	or	or	CC
18637	1972	33	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1972	34	with	with	IN
18637	1972	35	the	the	DT
18637	1972	36	several	several	JJ
18637	1972	37	States	States	NNPS
18637	1972	38	and	and	CC
18637	1972	39	with	with	IN
18637	1972	40	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	1972	41	nations	nation	NNS
18637	1972	42	;	;	:
18637	1972	43	but	but	CC
18637	1972	44	this	this	DT
18637	1972	45	was	be	VBD
18637	1972	46	no	no	RB
18637	1972	47	more	more	JJR
18637	1972	48	than	than	IN
18637	1972	49	to	to	TO
18637	1972	50	say	say	VB
18637	1972	51	that	that	DT
18637	1972	52	trade	trade	NN
18637	1972	53	and	and	CC
18637	1972	54	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	1972	55	served	serve	VBD
18637	1972	56	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	1972	57	to	to	TO
18637	1972	58	fulfil	fulfil	VB
18637	1972	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1972	60	function	function	NN
18637	1972	61	.	.	.
18637	1973	1	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	1973	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1973	3	refined	refine	VBN
18637	1973	4	for	for	IN
18637	1973	5	sale	sale	NN
18637	1973	6	,	,	,
18637	1973	7	and	and	CC
18637	1973	8	sales	sale	NNS
18637	1973	9	were	be	VBD
18637	1973	10	probably	probably	RB
18637	1973	11	made	make	VBN
18637	1973	12	at	at	IN
18637	1973	13	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	1973	14	for	for	IN
18637	1973	15	consumption	consumption	NN
18637	1973	16	,	,	,
18637	1973	17	and	and	CC
18637	1973	18	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	1973	19	for	for	IN
18637	1973	20	resale	resale	NN
18637	1973	21	by	by	IN
18637	1973	22	the	the	DT
18637	1973	23	first	first	JJ
18637	1973	24	purchasers	purchaser	NNS
18637	1973	25	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	1973	26	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	1973	27	and	and	CC
18637	1973	28	other	other	JJ
18637	1973	29	States	States	NNP
18637	1973	30	,	,	,
18637	1973	31	and	and	CC
18637	1973	32	refined	refined	JJ
18637	1973	33	sugar	sugar	NN
18637	1973	34	was	be	VBD
18637	1973	35	also	also	RB
18637	1973	36	forwarded	forward	VBN
18637	1973	37	by	by	IN
18637	1973	38	the	the	DT
18637	1973	39	companies	company	NNS
18637	1973	40	to	to	IN
18637	1973	41	other	other	JJ
18637	1973	42	States	States	NNP
18637	1973	43	for	for	IN
18637	1973	44	sale	sale	NN
18637	1973	45	.	.	.
18637	1974	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	1974	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1974	3	does	do	VBZ
18637	1974	4	not	not	RB
18637	1974	5	follow	follow	VB
18637	1974	6	that	that	IN
18637	1974	7	an	an	DT
18637	1974	8	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	1974	9	to	to	TO
18637	1974	10	monopolize	monopolize	VB
18637	1974	11	,	,	,
18637	1974	12	or	or	CC
18637	1974	13	the	the	DT
18637	1974	14	actual	actual	JJ
18637	1974	15	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	1974	16	of	of	IN
18637	1974	17	,	,	,
18637	1974	18	the	the	DT
18637	1974	19	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	1974	20	was	be	VBD
18637	1974	21	an	an	DT
18637	1974	22	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	1974	23	,	,	,
18637	1974	24	whether	whether	IN
18637	1974	25	executory	executory	NN
18637	1974	26	or	or	CC
18637	1974	27	consummated	consummate	VBD
18637	1974	28	,	,	,
18637	1974	29	to	to	TO
18637	1974	30	monopolize	monopolize	VB
18637	1974	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1974	32	,	,	,
18637	1974	33	even	even	RB
18637	1974	34	though	though	RB
18637	1974	35	,	,	,
18637	1974	36	in	in	IN
18637	1974	37	order	order	NN
18637	1974	38	to	to	TO
18637	1974	39	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	1974	40	of	of	IN
18637	1974	41	the	the	DT
18637	1974	42	product	product	NN
18637	1974	43	,	,	,
18637	1974	44	the	the	DT
18637	1974	45	instrumentality	instrumentality	NN
18637	1974	46	of	of	IN
18637	1974	47	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1974	48	was	be	VBD
18637	1974	49	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	1974	50	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	1974	51	.	.	.
18637	1975	1	There	there	EX
18637	1975	2	was	be	VBD
18637	1975	3	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	1975	4	in	in	IN
18637	1975	5	the	the	DT
18637	1975	6	proofs	proof	NNS
18637	1975	7	to	to	TO
18637	1975	8	indicate	indicate	VB
18637	1975	9	any	any	DT
18637	1975	10	intention	intention	NN
18637	1975	11	to	to	TO
18637	1975	12	put	put	VB
18637	1975	13	a	a	DT
18637	1975	14	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	1975	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	1975	16	trade	trade	NN
18637	1975	17	or	or	CC
18637	1975	18	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1975	19	,	,	,
18637	1975	20	and	and	CC
18637	1975	21	the	the	DT
18637	1975	22	fact	fact	NN
18637	1975	23	,	,	,
18637	1975	24	as	as	IN
18637	1975	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1975	26	have	have	VBP
18637	1975	27	seen	see	VBN
18637	1975	28	that	that	DT
18637	1975	29	trade	trade	NN
18637	1975	30	or	or	CC
18637	1975	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1975	32	might	may	MD
18637	1975	33	be	be	VB
18637	1975	34	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	1975	35	affected	affect	VBN
18637	1975	36	was	be	VBD
18637	1975	37	not	not	RB
18637	1975	38	enough	enough	JJ
18637	1975	39	to	to	TO
18637	1975	40	entitle	entitle	VB
18637	1975	41	complainants	complainant	NNS
18637	1975	42	to	to	IN
18637	1975	43	a	a	DT
18637	1975	44	decree	decree	NN
18637	1975	45	.	.	.
18637	1976	1	"	"	``
18637	1976	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1976	3	422	422	CD
18637	1976	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1976	5	THE	the	DT
18637	1976	6	SHERMAN	SHERMAN	NNP
18637	1976	7	ACT	ACT	NNP
18637	1976	8	REVISED	revised	NN
18637	1976	9	Four	four	CD
18637	1976	10	years	year	NNS
18637	1976	11	later	later	RB
18637	1976	12	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	1976	13	the	the	DT
18637	1976	14	case	case	NN
18637	1976	15	of	of	IN
18637	1976	16	Addyston	Addyston	NNP
18637	1976	17	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	1976	18	and	and	CC
18637	1976	19	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	1976	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	1976	21	_	_	NNP
18637	1976	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	1976	23	_	_	NNP
18637	1976	24	United	United	NNP
18637	1976	25	States,[423	States,[423	NNP
18637	1976	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1976	27	in	in	IN
18637	1976	28	which	which	WDT
18637	1976	29	the	the	DT
18637	1976	30	Antitrust	Antitrust	NNP
18637	1976	31	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1976	32	was	be	VBD
18637	1976	33	successfully	successfully	RB
18637	1976	34	applied	apply	VBN
18637	1976	35	as	as	IN
18637	1976	36	against	against	IN
18637	1976	37	an	an	DT
18637	1976	38	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	1976	39	combination	combination	NN
18637	1976	40	for	for	IN
18637	1976	41	the	the	DT
18637	1976	42	first	first	JJ
18637	1976	43	time	time	NN
18637	1976	44	.	.	.
18637	1977	1	The	the	DT
18637	1977	2	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	1977	3	in	in	IN
18637	1977	4	the	the	DT
18637	1977	5	case	case	NN
18637	1977	6	,	,	,
18637	1977	7	the	the	DT
18637	1977	8	parties	party	NNS
18637	1977	9	to	to	TO
18637	1977	10	which	which	WDT
18637	1977	11	were	be	VBD
18637	1977	12	manufacturing	manufacture	VBG
18637	1977	13	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	1977	14	,	,	,
18637	1977	15	effected	effect	VBD
18637	1977	16	a	a	DT
18637	1977	17	division	division	NN
18637	1977	18	of	of	IN
18637	1977	19	territory	territory	NN
18637	1977	20	among	among	IN
18637	1977	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1977	22	,	,	,
18637	1977	23	and	and	CC
18637	1977	24	so	so	RB
18637	1977	25	involved	involved	JJ
18637	1977	26	,	,	,
18637	1977	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1977	28	was	be	VBD
18637	1977	29	held	hold	VBN
18637	1977	30	,	,	,
18637	1977	31	a	a	DT
18637	1977	32	"	"	``
18637	1977	33	direct	direct	JJ
18637	1977	34	"	"	''
18637	1977	35	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	1977	36	on	on	IN
18637	1977	37	the	the	DT
18637	1977	38	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	1977	39	and	and	CC
18637	1977	40	hence	hence	RB
18637	1977	41	of	of	IN
18637	1977	42	the	the	DT
18637	1977	43	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1977	44	of	of	IN
18637	1977	45	the	the	DT
18637	1977	46	products	product	NNS
18637	1977	47	of	of	IN
18637	1977	48	the	the	DT
18637	1977	49	contracting	contracting	NN
18637	1977	50	firms	firm	NNS
18637	1977	51	.	.	.
18637	1978	1	The	the	DT
18637	1978	2	holding	holding	NN
18637	1978	3	,	,	,
18637	1978	4	however	however	RB
18637	1978	5	,	,	,
18637	1978	6	did	do	VBD
18637	1978	7	not	not	RB
18637	1978	8	question	question	VB
18637	1978	9	the	the	DT
18637	1978	10	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	1978	11	of	of	IN
18637	1978	12	the	the	DT
18637	1978	13	earlier	early	JJR
18637	1978	14	case	case	NN
18637	1978	15	,	,	,
18637	1978	16	which	which	WDT
18637	1978	17	in	in	IN
18637	1978	18	fact	fact	NN
18637	1978	19	continued	continue	VBD
18637	1978	20	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	1978	21	undisturbed	undisturbed	JJ
18637	1978	22	until	until	IN
18637	1978	23	1905	1905	CD
18637	1978	24	,	,	,
18637	1978	25	when	when	WRB
18637	1978	26	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	1978	27	and	and	CC
18637	1978	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	1978	29	_	_	NNP
18637	1978	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	1978	31	_	_	NNP
18637	1978	32	United	United	NNP
18637	1978	33	States,[424	States,[424	NNP
18637	1978	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1978	35	was	be	VBD
18637	1978	36	decided	decide	VBN
18637	1978	37	.	.	.
18637	1979	1	THE	the	DT
18637	1979	2	"	"	``
18637	1979	3	CURRENT	CURRENT	NNP
18637	1979	4	OF	of	IN
18637	1979	5	COMMERCE	COMMERCE	NNP
18637	1979	6	"	"	''
18637	1979	7	CONCEPT	CONCEPT	NNP
18637	1979	8	:	:	:
18637	1979	9	THE	the	DT
18637	1979	10	SWIFT	SWIFT	NNP
18637	1979	11	CASE	case	NN
18637	1979	12	Defendants	Defendants	NNPS
18637	1979	13	in	in	IN
18637	1979	14	the	the	DT
18637	1979	15	Swift	swift	JJ
18637	1979	16	case	case	NN
18637	1979	17	were	be	VBD
18637	1979	18	some	some	DT
18637	1979	19	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	1979	20	firms	firm	NNS
18637	1979	21	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1979	22	in	in	IN
18637	1979	23	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	1979	24	and	and	CC
18637	1979	25	other	other	JJ
18637	1979	26	cities	city	NNS
18637	1979	27	in	in	IN
18637	1979	28	the	the	DT
18637	1979	29	business	business	NN
18637	1979	30	of	of	IN
18637	1979	31	buying	buy	VBG
18637	1979	32	livestock	livestock	NN
18637	1979	33	in	in	IN
18637	1979	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1979	35	stockyards	stockyard	NNS
18637	1979	36	,	,	,
18637	1979	37	in	in	IN
18637	1979	38	converting	convert	VBG
18637	1979	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1979	40	at	at	IN
18637	1979	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1979	42	packing	pack	VBG
18637	1979	43	houses	house	NNS
18637	1979	44	into	into	IN
18637	1979	45	fresh	fresh	JJ
18637	1979	46	meat	meat	NN
18637	1979	47	,	,	,
18637	1979	48	and	and	CC
18637	1979	49	in	in	IN
18637	1979	50	the	the	DT
18637	1979	51	sale	sale	NN
18637	1979	52	and	and	CC
18637	1979	53	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	1979	54	of	of	IN
18637	1979	55	such	such	JJ
18637	1979	56	fresh	fresh	JJ
18637	1979	57	meat	meat	NN
18637	1979	58	to	to	IN
18637	1979	59	purchasers	purchaser	NNS
18637	1979	60	in	in	IN
18637	1979	61	other	other	JJ
18637	1979	62	States	States	NNPS
18637	1979	63	.	.	.
18637	1980	1	The	the	DT
18637	1980	2	charge	charge	NN
18637	1980	3	against	against	IN
18637	1980	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1980	5	was	be	VBD
18637	1980	6	that	that	IN
18637	1980	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1980	8	had	have	VBD
18637	1980	9	entered	enter	VBN
18637	1980	10	into	into	IN
18637	1980	11	a	a	DT
18637	1980	12	combination	combination	NN
18637	1980	13	to	to	TO
18637	1980	14	refrain	refrain	VB
18637	1980	15	from	from	IN
18637	1980	16	bidding	bidding	NN
18637	1980	17	against	against	IN
18637	1980	18	each	each	DT
18637	1980	19	other	other	JJ
18637	1980	20	in	in	IN
18637	1980	21	the	the	DT
18637	1980	22	local	local	JJ
18637	1980	23	markets	market	NNS
18637	1980	24	,	,	,
18637	1980	25	to	to	TO
18637	1980	26	fix	fix	VB
18637	1980	27	the	the	DT
18637	1980	28	prices	price	NNS
18637	1980	29	at	at	IN
18637	1980	30	which	which	WDT
18637	1980	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1980	32	would	would	MD
18637	1980	33	sell	sell	VB
18637	1980	34	,	,	,
18637	1980	35	to	to	TO
18637	1980	36	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	1980	37	shipments	shipment	NNS
18637	1980	38	of	of	IN
18637	1980	39	meat	meat	NN
18637	1980	40	,	,	,
18637	1980	41	and	and	CC
18637	1980	42	to	to	TO
18637	1980	43	do	do	VB
18637	1980	44	other	other	JJ
18637	1980	45	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	1980	46	acts	act	NNS
18637	1980	47	.	.	.
18637	1981	1	The	the	DT
18637	1981	2	case	case	NN
18637	1981	3	was	be	VBD
18637	1981	4	appealed	appeal	VBN
18637	1981	5	to	to	IN
18637	1981	6	the	the	DT
18637	1981	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	1981	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1981	9	on	on	IN
18637	1981	10	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	1981	11	'	'	POS
18637	1981	12	contention	contention	NN
18637	1981	13	that	that	IN
18637	1981	14	certain	certain	JJ
18637	1981	15	of	of	IN
18637	1981	16	the	the	DT
18637	1981	17	acts	act	NNS
18637	1981	18	complained	complain	VBN
18637	1981	19	of	of	IN
18637	1981	20	were	be	VBD
18637	1981	21	not	not	RB
18637	1981	22	acts	act	NNS
18637	1981	23	of	of	IN
18637	1981	24	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1981	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1981	26	and	and	CC
18637	1981	27	so	so	RB
18637	1981	28	did	do	VBD
18637	1981	29	not	not	RB
18637	1981	30	fall	fall	VB
18637	1981	31	within	within	IN
18637	1981	32	a	a	DT
18637	1981	33	valid	valid	JJ
18637	1981	34	reading	reading	NN
18637	1981	35	of	of	IN
18637	1981	36	the	the	DT
18637	1981	37	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	1981	38	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1981	39	.	.	.
18637	1982	1	The	the	DT
18637	1982	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1982	3	,	,	,
18637	1982	4	however	however	RB
18637	1982	5	,	,	,
18637	1982	6	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	1982	7	the	the	DT
18637	1982	8	Government	Government	NNP
18637	1982	9	on	on	IN
18637	1982	10	the	the	DT
18637	1982	11	ground	ground	NN
18637	1982	12	that	that	IN
18637	1982	13	the	the	DT
18637	1982	14	"	"	``
18637	1982	15	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	1982	16	as	as	IN
18637	1982	17	a	a	DT
18637	1982	18	whole	whole	JJ
18637	1982	19	"	"	``
18637	1982	20	came	come	VBD
18637	1982	21	within	within	IN
18637	1982	22	the	the	DT
18637	1982	23	act	act	NN
18637	1982	24	,	,	,
18637	1982	25	and	and	CC
18637	1982	26	that	that	IN
18637	1982	27	the	the	DT
18637	1982	28	local	local	JJ
18637	1982	29	activities	activity	NNS
18637	1982	30	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	1982	31	were	be	VBD
18637	1982	32	simply	simply	RB
18637	1982	33	part	part	NN
18637	1982	34	and	and	CC
18637	1982	35	parcel	parcel	NN
18637	1982	36	of	of	IN
18637	1982	37	this	this	DT
18637	1982	38	general	general	JJ
18637	1982	39	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	1982	40	.	.	.
18637	1983	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1983	2	425	425	CD
18637	1983	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1983	4	Referring	refer	VBG
18637	1983	5	to	to	IN
18637	1983	6	the	the	DT
18637	1983	7	purchases	purchase	NNS
18637	1983	8	of	of	IN
18637	1983	9	livestock	livestock	NN
18637	1983	10	at	at	IN
18637	1983	11	the	the	DT
18637	1983	12	stockyards	stockyard	NNS
18637	1983	13	,	,	,
18637	1983	14	the	the	DT
18637	1983	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1983	16	,	,	,
18637	1983	17	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	1983	18	by	by	IN
18637	1983	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1983	20	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	1983	21	,	,	,
18637	1983	22	said	say	VBD
18637	1983	23	:	:	:
18637	1983	24	"	"	``
18637	1983	25	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	1983	26	among	among	IN
18637	1983	27	the	the	DT
18637	1983	28	States	States	NNP
18637	1983	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	1983	30	not	not	RB
18637	1983	31	a	a	DT
18637	1983	32	technical	technical	JJ
18637	1983	33	legal	legal	JJ
18637	1983	34	conception	conception	NN
18637	1983	35	,	,	,
18637	1983	36	but	but	CC
18637	1983	37	a	a	DT
18637	1983	38	practical	practical	JJ
18637	1983	39	one	one	NN
18637	1983	40	,	,	,
18637	1983	41	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	1983	42	from	from	IN
18637	1983	43	the	the	DT
18637	1983	44	course	course	NN
18637	1983	45	of	of	IN
18637	1983	46	business	business	NN
18637	1983	47	.	.	.
18637	1984	1	When	when	WRB
18637	1984	2	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	1984	3	are	be	VBP
18637	1984	4	sent	send	VBN
18637	1984	5	for	for	IN
18637	1984	6	sale	sale	NN
18637	1984	7	from	from	IN
18637	1984	8	a	a	DT
18637	1984	9	place	place	NN
18637	1984	10	in	in	IN
18637	1984	11	one	one	CD
18637	1984	12	State	State	NNP
18637	1984	13	,	,	,
18637	1984	14	with	with	IN
18637	1984	15	the	the	DT
18637	1984	16	expectation	expectation	NN
18637	1984	17	that	that	IN
18637	1984	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1984	19	will	will	MD
18637	1984	20	end	end	VB
18637	1984	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1984	22	transit	transit	NN
18637	1984	23	,	,	,
18637	1984	24	after	after	IN
18637	1984	25	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	1984	26	,	,	,
18637	1984	27	in	in	IN
18637	1984	28	another	another	DT
18637	1984	29	,	,	,
18637	1984	30	and	and	CC
18637	1984	31	when	when	WRB
18637	1984	32	in	in	IN
18637	1984	33	effect	effect	NN
18637	1984	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1984	35	do	do	VBP
18637	1984	36	so	so	RB
18637	1984	37	,	,	,
18637	1984	38	with	with	IN
18637	1984	39	only	only	RB
18637	1984	40	the	the	DT
18637	1984	41	interruption	interruption	NN
18637	1984	42	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1984	43	to	to	TO
18637	1984	44	find	find	VB
18637	1984	45	a	a	DT
18637	1984	46	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	1984	47	at	at	IN
18637	1984	48	the	the	DT
18637	1984	49	stockyards	stockyard	NNS
18637	1984	50	,	,	,
18637	1984	51	and	and	CC
18637	1984	52	when	when	WRB
18637	1984	53	this	this	DT
18637	1984	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	1984	55	a	a	DT
18637	1984	56	typical	typical	JJ
18637	1984	57	,	,	,
18637	1984	58	constantly	constantly	RB
18637	1984	59	recurring	recur	VBG
18637	1984	60	course	course	NN
18637	1984	61	,	,	,
18637	1984	62	the	the	DT
18637	1984	63	current	current	NN
18637	1984	64	thus	thus	RB
18637	1984	65	existing	exist	VBG
18637	1984	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	1984	67	a	a	DT
18637	1984	68	current	current	NN
18637	1984	69	of	of	IN
18637	1984	70	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1984	71	among	among	IN
18637	1984	72	the	the	DT
18637	1984	73	States	States	NNP
18637	1984	74	,	,	,
18637	1984	75	and	and	CC
18637	1984	76	the	the	DT
18637	1984	77	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	1984	78	of	of	IN
18637	1984	79	the	the	DT
18637	1984	80	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	1984	81	is	be	VBZ
18637	1984	82	a	a	DT
18637	1984	83	part	part	NN
18637	1984	84	and	and	CC
18637	1984	85	incident	incident	NN
18637	1984	86	of	of	IN
18637	1984	87	such	such	JJ
18637	1984	88	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1984	89	.	.	.
18637	1985	1	"	"	``
18637	1985	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1985	3	426	426	CD
18637	1985	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1985	5	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	1985	6	the	the	DT
18637	1985	7	sales	sale	NNS
18637	1985	8	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	1985	9	of	of	IN
18637	1985	10	fresh	fresh	JJ
18637	1985	11	meat	meat	NN
18637	1985	12	at	at	IN
18637	1985	13	the	the	DT
18637	1985	14	slaughtering	slaughtering	NN
18637	1985	15	places	place	NNS
18637	1985	16	fell	fall	VBD
18637	1985	17	within	within	IN
18637	1985	18	the	the	DT
18637	1985	19	general	general	JJ
18637	1985	20	design	design	NN
18637	1985	21	.	.	.
18637	1986	1	Even	even	RB
18637	1986	2	if	if	IN
18637	1986	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1986	4	imported	import	VBD
18637	1986	5	a	a	DT
18637	1986	6	technical	technical	JJ
18637	1986	7	passing	passing	NN
18637	1986	8	of	of	IN
18637	1986	9	title	title	NN
18637	1986	10	at	at	IN
18637	1986	11	the	the	DT
18637	1986	12	slaughtering	slaughtering	NN
18637	1986	13	places	place	NNS
18637	1986	14	,	,	,
18637	1986	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1986	16	also	also	RB
18637	1986	17	imported	import	VBD
18637	1986	18	that	that	IN
18637	1986	19	the	the	DT
18637	1986	20	sales	sale	NNS
18637	1986	21	were	be	VBD
18637	1986	22	to	to	IN
18637	1986	23	persons	person	NNS
18637	1986	24	in	in	IN
18637	1986	25	other	other	JJ
18637	1986	26	States	States	NNP
18637	1986	27	,	,	,
18637	1986	28	and	and	CC
18637	1986	29	that	that	IN
18637	1986	30	shipments	shipment	NNS
18637	1986	31	to	to	IN
18637	1986	32	such	such	JJ
18637	1986	33	States	States	NNPS
18637	1986	34	were	be	VBD
18637	1986	35	part	part	NN
18637	1986	36	of	of	IN
18637	1986	37	the	the	DT
18637	1986	38	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	1986	39	.	.	.
18637	1987	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1987	2	427	427	CD
18637	1987	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1987	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	1987	5	,	,	,
18637	1987	6	sales	sale	NNS
18637	1987	7	of	of	IN
18637	1987	8	the	the	DT
18637	1987	9	type	type	NN
18637	1987	10	which	which	WDT
18637	1987	11	in	in	IN
18637	1987	12	the	the	DT
18637	1987	13	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	1987	14	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	1987	15	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1987	16	were	be	VBD
18637	1987	17	thrust	thrust	VBN
18637	1987	18	to	to	IN
18637	1987	19	one	one	CD
18637	1987	20	side	side	NN
18637	1987	21	as	as	IN
18637	1987	22	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
18637	1987	23	from	from	IN
18637	1987	24	the	the	DT
18637	1987	25	point	point	NN
18637	1987	26	of	of	IN
18637	1987	27	view	view	NN
18637	1987	28	of	of	IN
18637	1987	29	the	the	DT
18637	1987	30	law	law	NN
18637	1987	31	,	,	,
18637	1987	32	because	because	IN
18637	1987	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1987	34	enabled	enable	VBD
18637	1987	35	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	1987	36	"	"	''
18637	1987	37	to	to	TO
18637	1987	38	fulfill	fulfill	VB
18637	1987	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1987	40	function	function	NN
18637	1987	41	,	,	,
18637	1987	42	"	"	''
18637	1987	43	were	be	VBD
18637	1987	44	here	here	RB
18637	1987	45	treated	treat	VBN
18637	1987	46	as	as	IN
18637	1987	47	merged	merge	VBN
18637	1987	48	in	in	IN
18637	1987	49	an	an	DT
18637	1987	50	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1987	51	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1987	52	stream	stream	NN
18637	1987	53	.	.	.
18637	1988	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	1988	2	,	,	,
18637	1988	3	the	the	DT
18637	1988	4	concept	concept	NN
18637	1988	5	of	of	IN
18637	1988	6	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1988	7	as	as	IN
18637	1988	8	_	_	NNP
18637	1988	9	trade	trade	NN
18637	1988	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1988	11	,	,	,
18637	1988	12	that	that	RB
18637	1988	13	is	is	RB
18637	1988	14	,	,	,
18637	1988	15	as	as	IN
18637	1988	16	_	_	NNP
18637	1988	17	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	1988	18	_	_	NNP
18637	1988	19	,	,	,
18637	1988	20	again	again	RB
18637	1988	21	entered	enter	VBD
18637	1988	22	the	the	DT
18637	1988	23	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	1988	24	Law	Law	NNP
18637	1988	25	picture	picture	NN
18637	1988	26	,	,	,
18637	1988	27	with	with	IN
18637	1988	28	the	the	DT
18637	1988	29	result	result	NN
18637	1988	30	that	that	IN
18637	1988	31	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	1988	32	which	which	WDT
18637	1988	33	directly	directly	RB
18637	1988	34	affected	affect	VBD
18637	1988	35	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1988	36	trade	trade	NN
18637	1988	37	could	could	MD
18637	1988	38	not	not	RB
18637	1988	39	be	be	VB
18637	1988	40	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
18637	1988	41	on	on	IN
18637	1988	42	the	the	DT
18637	1988	43	ground	ground	NN
18637	1988	44	that	that	IN
18637	1988	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1988	46	affected	affect	VBD
18637	1988	47	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	1988	48	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1988	49	,	,	,
18637	1988	50	in	in	IN
18637	1988	51	the	the	DT
18637	1988	52	sense	sense	NN
18637	1988	53	of	of	IN
18637	1988	54	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1988	55	_	_	NNP
18637	1988	56	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	1988	57	_	_	NNP
18637	1988	58	,	,	,
18637	1988	59	only	only	RB
18637	1988	60	"	"	``
18637	1988	61	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	1988	62	.	.	.
18637	1988	63	"	"	''
18637	1989	1	Lastly	lastly	RB
18637	1989	2	,	,	,
18637	1989	3	the	the	DT
18637	1989	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1989	5	added	add	VBD
18637	1989	6	these	these	DT
18637	1989	7	significant	significant	JJ
18637	1989	8	words	word	NNS
18637	1989	9	:	:	:
18637	1989	10	"	"	``
18637	1989	11	But	but	CC
18637	1989	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1989	13	do	do	VBP
18637	1989	14	not	not	RB
18637	1989	15	mean	mean	VB
18637	1989	16	to	to	TO
18637	1989	17	imply	imply	VB
18637	1989	18	that	that	IN
18637	1989	19	the	the	DT
18637	1989	20	rule	rule	NN
18637	1989	21	which	which	WDT
18637	1989	22	marks	mark	VBZ
18637	1989	23	the	the	DT
18637	1989	24	point	point	NN
18637	1989	25	at	at	IN
18637	1989	26	which	which	WDT
18637	1989	27	State	state	NN
18637	1989	28	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	1989	29	or	or	CC
18637	1989	30	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	1989	31	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	1989	32	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	1989	33	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	1989	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	1989	35	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	1989	36	the	the	DT
18637	1989	37	scope	scope	NN
18637	1989	38	of	of	IN
18637	1989	39	interference	interference	NN
18637	1989	40	by	by	IN
18637	1989	41	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1989	42	in	in	IN
18637	1989	43	cases	case	NNS
18637	1989	44	where	where	WRB
18637	1989	45	such	such	JJ
18637	1989	46	interference	interference	NN
18637	1989	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	1989	48	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	1989	49	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	1989	50	for	for	IN
18637	1989	51	the	the	DT
18637	1989	52	protection	protection	NN
18637	1989	53	of	of	IN
18637	1989	54	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1989	55	among	among	IN
18637	1989	56	the	the	DT
18637	1989	57	States	States	NNP
18637	1989	58	.	.	.
18637	1990	1	"	"	``
18637	1990	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1990	3	428	428	CD
18637	1990	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1990	5	That	that	DT
18637	1990	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	1990	7	to	to	TO
18637	1990	8	say	say	VB
18637	1990	9	,	,	,
18637	1990	10	the	the	DT
18637	1990	11	line	line	NN
18637	1990	12	that	that	WDT
18637	1990	13	confines	confine	VBZ
18637	1990	14	State	State	NNP
18637	1990	15	power	power	NN
18637	1990	16	from	from	IN
18637	1990	17	one	one	CD
18637	1990	18	side	side	NN
18637	1990	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	1990	20	not	not	RB
18637	1990	21	always	always	RB
18637	1990	22	confine	confine	VB
18637	1990	23	national	national	JJ
18637	1990	24	power	power	NN
18637	1990	25	from	from	IN
18637	1990	26	the	the	DT
18637	1990	27	other	other	JJ
18637	1990	28	.	.	.
18637	1991	1	For	for	IN
18637	1991	2	even	even	RB
18637	1991	3	though	though	IN
18637	1991	4	the	the	DT
18637	1991	5	line	line	NN
18637	1991	6	accurately	accurately	RB
18637	1991	7	divides	divide	VBZ
18637	1991	8	the	the	DT
18637	1991	9	subject	subject	JJ
18637	1991	10	matter	matter	NN
18637	1991	11	of	of	IN
18637	1991	12	the	the	DT
18637	1991	13	complementary	complementary	JJ
18637	1991	14	spheres	sphere	NNS
18637	1991	15	,	,	,
18637	1991	16	still	still	RB
18637	1991	17	national	national	JJ
18637	1991	18	power	power	NN
18637	1991	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	1991	20	always	always	RB
18637	1991	21	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	1991	22	to	to	TO
18637	1991	23	take	take	VB
18637	1991	24	on	on	RP
18637	1991	25	such	such	JJ
18637	1991	26	additional	additional	JJ
18637	1991	27	extension	extension	NN
18637	1991	28	as	as	IN
18637	1991	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	1991	30	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	1991	31	to	to	TO
18637	1991	32	guarantee	guarantee	VB
18637	1991	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1991	34	effective	effective	JJ
18637	1991	35	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	1991	36	,	,	,
18637	1991	37	and	and	CC
18637	1991	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	1991	39	furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	1991	40	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	1991	41	.	.	.
18637	1992	1	THE	the	DT
18637	1992	2	DANBURY	DANBURY	NNP
18637	1992	3	HATTERS	hatter	VBZ
18637	1992	4	CASE	case	NN
18637	1992	5	In	in	IN
18637	1992	6	this	this	DT
18637	1992	7	respect	respect	NN
18637	1992	8	,	,	,
18637	1992	9	the	the	DT
18637	1992	10	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	1992	11	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1992	12	only	only	RB
18637	1992	13	states	state	VBZ
18637	1992	14	what	what	WP
18637	1992	15	the	the	DT
18637	1992	16	Shreveport	Shreveport	NNP
18637	1992	17	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1992	18	was	be	VBD
18637	1992	19	later	later	RB
18637	1992	20	to	to	TO
18637	1992	21	declare	declare	VB
18637	1992	22	more	more	RBR
18637	1992	23	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	1992	24	;	;	:
18637	1992	25	and	and	CC
18637	1992	26	the	the	DT
18637	1992	27	same	same	JJ
18637	1992	28	may	may	MD
18637	1992	29	be	be	VB
18637	1992	30	said	say	VBN
18637	1992	31	of	of	IN
18637	1992	32	an	an	DT
18637	1992	33	ensuing	ensue	VBG
18637	1992	34	series	series	NN
18637	1992	35	of	of	IN
18637	1992	36	cases	case	NNS
18637	1992	37	in	in	IN
18637	1992	38	which	which	WDT
18637	1992	39	combinations	combination	NNS
18637	1992	40	of	of	IN
18637	1992	41	employees	employee	NNS
18637	1992	42	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	1992	43	in	in	IN
18637	1992	44	such	such	JJ
18637	1992	45	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	1992	46	activities	activity	NNS
18637	1992	47	as	as	IN
18637	1992	48	manufacturing	manufacturing	NN
18637	1992	49	,	,	,
18637	1992	50	mining	mining	NN
18637	1992	51	,	,	,
18637	1992	52	building	building	NN
18637	1992	53	construction	construction	NN
18637	1992	54	,	,	,
18637	1992	55	and	and	CC
18637	1992	56	the	the	DT
18637	1992	57	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	1992	58	of	of	IN
18637	1992	59	poultry	poultry	NN
18637	1992	60	were	be	VBD
18637	1992	61	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	1992	62	to	to	IN
18637	1992	63	the	the	DT
18637	1992	64	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	1992	65	of	of	IN
18637	1992	66	the	the	DT
18637	1992	67	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	1992	68	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1992	69	because	because	IN
18637	1992	70	of	of	IN
18637	1992	71	the	the	DT
18637	1992	72	effect	effect	NN
18637	1992	73	or	or	CC
18637	1992	74	intended	intend	VBN
18637	1992	75	effect	effect	NN
18637	1992	76	of	of	IN
18637	1992	77	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1992	78	activities	activity	NNS
18637	1992	79	on	on	IN
18637	1992	80	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	1992	81	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	1992	82	.	.	.
18637	1993	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1993	2	429	429	CD
18637	1993	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1993	4	STOCKYARDS	stockyard	NNS
18637	1993	5	AND	and	CC
18637	1993	6	GRAIN	grain	NN
18637	1993	7	FUTURES	futures	NN
18637	1993	8	ACTS	act	NNS
18637	1993	9	In	in	IN
18637	1993	10	1921	1921	CD
18637	1993	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	1993	12	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1993	13	the	the	DT
18637	1993	14	Packers	Packers	NNPS
18637	1993	15	and	and	CC
18637	1993	16	Stockyards	Stockyards	NNPS
18637	1993	17	Act[430	Act[430	NNP
18637	1993	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1993	19	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	1993	20	the	the	DT
18637	1993	21	business	business	NN
18637	1993	22	of	of	IN
18637	1993	23	commission	commission	NN
18637	1993	24	men	man	NNS
18637	1993	25	and	and	CC
18637	1993	26	livestock	livestock	NN
18637	1993	27	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	1993	28	in	in	IN
18637	1993	29	the	the	DT
18637	1993	30	chief	chief	JJ
18637	1993	31	stockyards	stockyard	NNS
18637	1993	32	of	of	IN
18637	1993	33	the	the	DT
18637	1993	34	country	country	NN
18637	1993	35	was	be	VBD
18637	1993	36	brought	bring	VBN
18637	1993	37	under	under	IN
18637	1993	38	national	national	JJ
18637	1993	39	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	1993	40	;	;	:
18637	1993	41	and	and	CC
18637	1993	42	the	the	DT
18637	1993	43	year	year	NN
18637	1993	44	following	follow	VBG
18637	1993	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1993	46	passed	pass	VBD
18637	1993	47	the	the	DT
18637	1993	48	Grain	Grain	NNP
18637	1993	49	Futures	Futures	NNPS
18637	1993	50	Act[431	Act[431	NNP
18637	1993	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1993	52	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	1993	53	exchanges	exchange	NNS
18637	1993	54	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	1993	55	in	in	IN
18637	1993	56	grain	grain	NN
18637	1993	57	futures	future	NNS
18637	1993	58	were	be	VBD
18637	1993	59	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	1993	60	to	to	IN
18637	1993	61	control	control	NN
18637	1993	62	.	.	.
18637	1994	1	The	the	DT
18637	1994	2	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	1994	3	of	of	IN
18637	1994	4	the	the	DT
18637	1994	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1994	6	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	1994	7	these	these	DT
18637	1994	8	measures	measure	NNS
18637	1994	9	both	both	DT
18637	1994	10	built	build	VBN
18637	1994	11	directly	directly	RB
18637	1994	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	1994	13	the	the	DT
18637	1994	14	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	1994	15	Case	Case	NNP
18637	1994	16	.	.	.
18637	1995	1	In	in	IN
18637	1995	2	Stafford	Stafford	NNP
18637	1995	3	_	_	NNP
18637	1995	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	1995	5	_	_	NNP
18637	1995	6	Wallace,[432	Wallace,[432	NNP
18637	1995	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1995	8	which	which	WDT
18637	1995	9	involved	involve	VBD
18637	1995	10	the	the	DT
18637	1995	11	former	former	JJ
18637	1995	12	act	act	NN
18637	1995	13	,	,	,
18637	1995	14	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	1995	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	1995	16	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	1995	17	,	,	,
18637	1995	18	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	1995	19	for	for	IN
18637	1995	20	the	the	DT
18637	1995	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	1995	22	,	,	,
18637	1995	23	said	say	VBD
18637	1995	24	:	:	:
18637	1995	25	"	"	``
18637	1995	26	The	the	DT
18637	1995	27	object	object	NN
18637	1995	28	to	to	TO
18637	1995	29	be	be	VB
18637	1995	30	secured	secure	VBN
18637	1995	31	by	by	IN
18637	1995	32	the	the	DT
18637	1995	33	act	act	NN
18637	1995	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	1995	35	the	the	DT
18637	1995	36	free	free	JJ
18637	1995	37	and	and	CC
18637	1995	38	unburdened	unburdened	JJ
18637	1995	39	flow	flow	NN
18637	1995	40	of	of	IN
18637	1995	41	livestock	livestock	NN
18637	1995	42	from	from	IN
18637	1995	43	the	the	DT
18637	1995	44	ranges	range	NNS
18637	1995	45	and	and	CC
18637	1995	46	farms	farm	NNS
18637	1995	47	of	of	IN
18637	1995	48	the	the	DT
18637	1995	49	West	West	NNP
18637	1995	50	and	and	CC
18637	1995	51	Southwest	Southwest	NNP
18637	1995	52	through	through	IN
18637	1995	53	the	the	DT
18637	1995	54	great	great	JJ
18637	1995	55	stockyards	stockyard	NNS
18637	1995	56	and	and	CC
18637	1995	57	slaughtering	slaughter	VBG
18637	1995	58	centers	center	NNS
18637	1995	59	on	on	IN
18637	1995	60	the	the	DT
18637	1995	61	borders	border	NNS
18637	1995	62	of	of	IN
18637	1995	63	that	that	DT
18637	1995	64	region	region	NN
18637	1995	65	,	,	,
18637	1995	66	and	and	CC
18637	1995	67	thence	thence	NN
18637	1995	68	in	in	IN
18637	1995	69	the	the	DT
18637	1995	70	form	form	NN
18637	1995	71	of	of	IN
18637	1995	72	meat	meat	NN
18637	1995	73	products	product	NNS
18637	1995	74	to	to	IN
18637	1995	75	the	the	DT
18637	1995	76	consuming	consume	VBG
18637	1995	77	cities	city	NNS
18637	1995	78	of	of	IN
18637	1995	79	the	the	DT
18637	1995	80	country	country	NN
18637	1995	81	in	in	IN
18637	1995	82	the	the	DT
18637	1995	83	Middle	Middle	NNP
18637	1995	84	West	West	NNP
18637	1995	85	and	and	CC
18637	1995	86	East	East	NNP
18637	1995	87	,	,	,
18637	1995	88	or	or	CC
18637	1995	89	,	,	,
18637	1995	90	still	still	RB
18637	1995	91	as	as	IN
18637	1995	92	livestock	livestock	NN
18637	1995	93	,	,	,
18637	1995	94	to	to	IN
18637	1995	95	the	the	DT
18637	1995	96	feeding	feeding	NN
18637	1995	97	places	place	NNS
18637	1995	98	and	and	CC
18637	1995	99	fattening	fatten	VBG
18637	1995	100	farms	farm	NNS
18637	1995	101	in	in	IN
18637	1995	102	the	the	DT
18637	1995	103	Middle	Middle	NNP
18637	1995	104	West	West	NNP
18637	1995	105	or	or	CC
18637	1995	106	East	East	NNP
18637	1995	107	for	for	IN
18637	1995	108	further	further	JJ
18637	1995	109	preparation	preparation	NN
18637	1995	110	for	for	IN
18637	1995	111	the	the	DT
18637	1995	112	market	market	NN
18637	1995	113	.	.	.
18637	1996	1	"	"	``
18637	1996	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1996	3	433	433	CD
18637	1996	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1996	5	The	the	DT
18637	1996	6	stockyards	stockyard	NNS
18637	1996	7	,	,	,
18637	1996	8	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	1996	9	,	,	,
18637	1996	10	were	be	VBD
18637	1996	11	"	"	``
18637	1996	12	not	not	RB
18637	1996	13	a	a	DT
18637	1996	14	place	place	NN
18637	1996	15	of	of	IN
18637	1996	16	rest	rest	NN
18637	1996	17	or	or	CC
18637	1996	18	final	final	JJ
18637	1996	19	destination	destination	NN
18637	1996	20	.	.	.
18637	1996	21	"	"	''
18637	1997	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1997	2	were	be	VBD
18637	1997	3	"	"	``
18637	1997	4	but	but	CC
18637	1997	5	a	a	DT
18637	1997	6	throat	throat	NN
18637	1997	7	through	through	IN
18637	1997	8	which	which	WDT
18637	1997	9	the	the	DT
18637	1997	10	current	current	JJ
18637	1997	11	flows	flow	VBZ
18637	1997	12	,	,	,
18637	1997	13	"	"	''
18637	1997	14	and	and	CC
18637	1997	15	the	the	DT
18637	1997	16	sales	sale	NNS
18637	1997	17	there	there	EX
18637	1997	18	were	be	VBD
18637	1997	19	not	not	RB
18637	1997	20	merely	merely	RB
18637	1997	21	local	local	JJ
18637	1997	22	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	1997	23	.	.	.
18637	1998	1	"	"	``
18637	1998	2	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	1998	3	do	do	VBP
18637	1998	4	not	not	RB
18637	1998	5	stop	stop	VB
18637	1998	6	the	the	DT
18637	1998	7	flow;--but	flow;--but	NN
18637	1998	8	,	,	,
18637	1998	9	on	on	IN
18637	1998	10	the	the	DT
18637	1998	11	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	1998	12	"	"	``
18637	1998	13	are	be	VBP
18637	1998	14	"	"	``
18637	1998	15	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
18637	1998	16	to	to	IN
18637	1998	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	1998	18	continuity	continuity	NN
18637	1998	19	.	.	.
18637	1999	1	"	"	``
18637	1999	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	1999	3	434	434	CD
18637	1999	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1999	5	In	in	IN
18637	1999	6	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	1999	7	Board	Board	NNP
18637	1999	8	of	of	IN
18637	1999	9	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	1999	10	_	_	NNP
18637	1999	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	1999	12	_	_	NNP
18637	1999	13	Olsen,[435	Olsen,[435	NNP
18637	1999	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	1999	15	involving	involve	VBG
18637	1999	16	the	the	DT
18637	1999	17	Grain	Grain	NNP
18637	1999	18	Futures	Futures	NNPS
18637	1999	19	Act	Act	NNP
18637	1999	20	,	,	,
18637	1999	21	the	the	DT
18637	1999	22	same	same	JJ
18637	1999	23	course	course	NN
18637	1999	24	of	of	IN
18637	1999	25	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	1999	26	was	be	VBD
18637	1999	27	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	1999	28	.	.	.
18637	2000	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2000	2	of	of	IN
18637	2000	3	the	the	DT
18637	2000	4	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	2000	5	Case	Case	NNP
18637	2000	6	,	,	,
18637	2000	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2000	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2000	9	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	2000	10	remarked	remark	VBD
18637	2000	11	:	:	:
18637	2000	12	"	"	``
18637	2000	13	That	that	DT
18637	2000	14	case	case	NN
18637	2000	15	was	be	VBD
18637	2000	16	a	a	DT
18637	2000	17	milestone	milestone	NN
18637	2000	18	in	in	IN
18637	2000	19	the	the	DT
18637	2000	20	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	2000	21	of	of	IN
18637	2000	22	the	the	DT
18637	2000	23	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2000	24	clause	clause	NN
18637	2000	25	of	of	IN
18637	2000	26	the	the	DT
18637	2000	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2000	28	.	.	.
18637	2001	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2001	2	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	2001	3	the	the	DT
18637	2001	4	great	great	JJ
18637	2001	5	changes	change	NNS
18637	2001	6	and	and	CC
18637	2001	7	development	development	NN
18637	2001	8	in	in	IN
18637	2001	9	the	the	DT
18637	2001	10	business	business	NN
18637	2001	11	of	of	IN
18637	2001	12	this	this	DT
18637	2001	13	vast	vast	JJ
18637	2001	14	country	country	NN
18637	2001	15	and	and	CC
18637	2001	16	drew	draw	VBD
18637	2001	17	again	again	RB
18637	2001	18	the	the	DT
18637	2001	19	dividing	divide	VBG
18637	2001	20	line	line	NN
18637	2001	21	between	between	IN
18637	2001	22	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2001	23	and	and	CC
18637	2001	24	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2001	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2001	26	where	where	WRB
18637	2001	27	the	the	DT
18637	2001	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2001	29	intended	intend	VBD
18637	2001	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2001	31	to	to	TO
18637	2001	32	be	be	VB
18637	2001	33	.	.	.
18637	2002	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2002	2	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	2002	3	to	to	TO
18637	2002	4	permit	permit	VB
18637	2002	5	local	local	JJ
18637	2002	6	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	2002	7	of	of	IN
18637	2002	8	a	a	DT
18637	2002	9	great	great	JJ
18637	2002	10	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2002	11	movement	movement	NN
18637	2002	12	,	,	,
18637	2002	13	which	which	WDT
18637	2002	14	taken	take	VBD
18637	2002	15	alone	alone	RB
18637	2002	16	were	be	VBD
18637	2002	17	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2002	18	,	,	,
18637	2002	19	to	to	TO
18637	2002	20	characterize	characterize	VB
18637	2002	21	the	the	DT
18637	2002	22	movement	movement	NN
18637	2002	23	as	as	IN
18637	2002	24	such	such	JJ
18637	2002	25	.	.	.
18637	2003	1	"	"	``
18637	2003	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2003	3	436	436	CD
18637	2003	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2003	5	Of	of	IN
18637	2003	6	special	special	JJ
18637	2003	7	significance	significance	NN
18637	2003	8	,	,	,
18637	2003	9	however	however	RB
18637	2003	10	,	,	,
18637	2003	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	2003	12	the	the	DT
18637	2003	13	part	part	NN
18637	2003	14	of	of	IN
18637	2003	15	the	the	DT
18637	2003	16	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2003	17	which	which	WDT
18637	2003	18	was	be	VBD
18637	2003	19	devoted	devoted	JJ
18637	2003	20	to	to	IN
18637	2003	21	showing	show	VBG
18637	2003	22	the	the	DT
18637	2003	23	relation	relation	NN
18637	2003	24	between	between	IN
18637	2003	25	future	future	JJ
18637	2003	26	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2003	27	and	and	CC
18637	2003	28	cash	cash	NN
18637	2003	29	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2003	30	,	,	,
18637	2003	31	and	and	CC
18637	2003	32	hence	hence	RB
18637	2003	33	the	the	DT
18637	2003	34	effect	effect	NN
18637	2003	35	of	of	IN
18637	2003	36	the	the	DT
18637	2003	37	former	former	JJ
18637	2003	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	2003	39	the	the	DT
18637	2003	40	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2003	41	grain	grain	NN
18637	2003	42	trade	trade	NN
18637	2003	43	.	.	.
18637	2004	1	The	the	DT
18637	2004	2	test	test	NN
18637	2004	3	,	,	,
18637	2004	4	said	say	VBD
18637	2004	5	the	the	DT
18637	2004	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2004	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2004	8	,	,	,
18637	2004	9	was	be	VBD
18637	2004	10	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	2004	11	by	by	IN
18637	2004	12	the	the	DT
18637	2004	13	question	question	NN
18637	2004	14	of	of	IN
18637	2004	15	price	price	NN
18637	2004	16	.	.	.
18637	2005	1	"	"	``
18637	2005	2	The	the	DT
18637	2005	3	question	question	NN
18637	2005	4	of	of	IN
18637	2005	5	price	price	NN
18637	2005	6	dominates	dominate	VBZ
18637	2005	7	trade	trade	NN
18637	2005	8	between	between	IN
18637	2005	9	the	the	DT
18637	2005	10	States	States	NNP
18637	2005	11	.	.	.
18637	2006	1	Sales	sale	NNS
18637	2006	2	of	of	IN
18637	2006	3	an	an	DT
18637	2006	4	article	article	NN
18637	2006	5	which	which	WDT
18637	2006	6	affect	affect	VBP
18637	2006	7	the	the	DT
18637	2006	8	country	country	NN
18637	2006	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	2006	10	wide	wide	JJ
18637	2006	11	price	price	NN
18637	2006	12	of	of	IN
18637	2006	13	the	the	DT
18637	2006	14	article	article	NN
18637	2006	15	directly	directly	RB
18637	2006	16	affect	affect	VBP
18637	2006	17	the	the	DT
18637	2006	18	country	country	NN
18637	2006	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	2006	20	wide	wide	JJ
18637	2006	21	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2006	22	in	in	IN
18637	2006	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2006	24	.	.	.
18637	2007	1	"	"	``
18637	2007	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2007	3	437	437	CD
18637	2007	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2007	5	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2007	6	a	a	DT
18637	2007	7	practice	practice	NN
18637	2007	8	which	which	WDT
18637	2007	9	demonstrably	demonstrably	RB
18637	2007	10	affects	affect	VBZ
18637	2007	11	prices	price	NNS
18637	2007	12	would	would	MD
18637	2007	13	also	also	RB
18637	2007	14	affect	affect	VB
18637	2007	15	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2007	16	trade	trade	NN
18637	2007	17	"	"	``
18637	2007	18	directly	directly	RB
18637	2007	19	,	,	,
18637	2007	20	"	"	''
18637	2007	21	and	and	CC
18637	2007	22	so	so	RB
18637	2007	23	,	,	,
18637	2007	24	even	even	RB
18637	2007	25	though	though	IN
18637	2007	26	local	local	JJ
18637	2007	27	in	in	IN
18637	2007	28	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2007	29	,	,	,
18637	2007	30	would	would	MD
18637	2007	31	fall	fall	VB
18637	2007	32	within	within	IN
18637	2007	33	the	the	DT
18637	2007	34	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	2007	35	power	power	NN
18637	2007	36	of	of	IN
18637	2007	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2007	38	.	.	.
18637	2008	1	In	in	IN
18637	2008	2	the	the	DT
18637	2008	3	following	follow	VBG
18637	2008	4	passage	passage	NN
18637	2008	5	,	,	,
18637	2008	6	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	2008	7	,	,	,
18637	2008	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2008	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2008	10	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	2008	11	whittles	whittle	VBZ
18637	2008	12	down	down	RB
18637	2008	13	,	,	,
18637	2008	14	in	in	IN
18637	2008	15	both	both	DT
18637	2008	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	2008	17	,	,	,
18637	2008	18	the	the	DT
18637	2008	19	"	"	``
18637	2008	20	direct	direct	JJ
18637	2008	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	2008	22	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	2008	23	"	"	''
18637	2008	24	formula	formula	NN
18637	2008	25	to	to	IN
18637	2008	26	the	the	DT
18637	2008	27	vanishing	vanishing	JJ
18637	2008	28	point	point	NN
18637	2008	29	:	:	:
18637	2008	30	"	"	``
18637	2008	31	Whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	2008	32	amounts	amount	VBZ
18637	2008	33	to	to	IN
18637	2008	34	more	more	RBR
18637	2008	35	or	or	CC
18637	2008	36	less	less	RBR
18637	2008	37	constant	constant	JJ
18637	2008	38	practice	practice	NN
18637	2008	39	,	,	,
18637	2008	40	and	and	CC
18637	2008	41	threatens	threaten	VBZ
18637	2008	42	to	to	TO
18637	2008	43	obstruct	obstruct	VB
18637	2008	44	or	or	CC
18637	2008	45	unduly	unduly	RB
18637	2008	46	to	to	TO
18637	2008	47	burden	burden	VB
18637	2008	48	the	the	DT
18637	2008	49	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	2008	50	of	of	IN
18637	2008	51	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2008	52	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2008	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	2008	54	within	within	IN
18637	2008	55	the	the	DT
18637	2008	56	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	2008	57	power	power	NN
18637	2008	58	of	of	IN
18637	2008	59	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2008	60	under	under	IN
18637	2008	61	the	the	DT
18637	2008	62	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2008	63	clause	clause	NN
18637	2008	64	,	,	,
18637	2008	65	and	and	CC
18637	2008	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2008	67	is	be	VBZ
18637	2008	68	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	2008	69	for	for	IN
18637	2008	70	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2008	71	to	to	TO
18637	2008	72	consider	consider	VB
18637	2008	73	and	and	CC
18637	2008	74	decide	decide	VB
18637	2008	75	the	the	DT
18637	2008	76	fact	fact	NN
18637	2008	77	of	of	IN
18637	2008	78	the	the	DT
18637	2008	79	danger	danger	NN
18637	2008	80	and	and	CC
18637	2008	81	meet	meet	VB
18637	2008	82	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2008	83	.	.	.
18637	2009	1	This	this	DT
18637	2009	2	court	court	NN
18637	2009	3	will	will	MD
18637	2009	4	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	2009	5	not	not	RB
18637	2009	6	substitute	substitute	VB
18637	2009	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2009	8	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	2009	9	for	for	IN
18637	2009	10	that	that	DT
18637	2009	11	of	of	IN
18637	2009	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2009	13	in	in	IN
18637	2009	14	such	such	PDT
18637	2009	15	a	a	DT
18637	2009	16	matter	matter	NN
18637	2009	17	unless	unless	IN
18637	2009	18	the	the	DT
18637	2009	19	relation	relation	NN
18637	2009	20	of	of	IN
18637	2009	21	the	the	DT
18637	2009	22	subject	subject	NN
18637	2009	23	to	to	IN
18637	2009	24	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2009	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2009	26	and	and	CC
18637	2009	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2009	28	effect	effect	NN
18637	2009	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	2009	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2009	31	are	be	VBP
18637	2009	32	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	2009	33	nonexistent	nonexistent	JJ
18637	2009	34	.	.	.
18637	2010	1	"	"	``
18637	2010	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2010	3	438	438	CD
18637	2010	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2010	5	And	and	CC
18637	2010	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2010	7	was	be	VBD
18637	2010	8	in	in	IN
18637	2010	9	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	2010	10	on	on	IN
18637	2010	11	the	the	DT
18637	2010	12	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2010	13	of	of	IN
18637	2010	14	these	these	DT
18637	2010	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	2010	16	that	that	WDT
18637	2010	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2010	18	first	first	RB
18637	2010	19	set	set	VBD
18637	2010	20	to	to	TO
18637	2010	21	work	work	VB
18637	2010	22	to	to	TO
18637	2010	23	combat	combat	VB
18637	2010	24	the	the	DT
18637	2010	25	Depression	Depression	NNP
18637	2010	26	in	in	IN
18637	2010	27	1933	1933	CD
18637	2010	28	and	and	CC
18637	2010	29	the	the	DT
18637	2010	30	years	year	NNS
18637	2010	31	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	2010	32	following	follow	VBG
18637	2010	33	.	.	.
18637	2011	1	But	but	CC
18637	2011	2	in	in	IN
18637	2011	3	fact	fact	NN
18637	2011	4	,	,	,
18637	2011	5	much	much	JJ
18637	2011	6	of	of	IN
18637	2011	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2011	8	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2011	9	at	at	IN
18637	2011	10	this	this	DT
18637	2011	11	time	time	NN
18637	2011	12	marked	mark	VBD
18637	2011	13	a	a	DT
18637	2011	14	wide	wide	JJ
18637	2011	15	advance	advance	NN
18637	2011	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	2011	17	the	the	DT
18637	2011	18	measures	measure	NNS
18637	2011	19	just	just	RB
18637	2011	20	passed	pass	VBN
18637	2011	21	in	in	IN
18637	2011	22	review	review	NN
18637	2011	23	.	.	.
18637	2012	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2012	2	did	do	VBD
18637	2012	3	not	not	RB
18637	2012	4	stop	stop	VB
18637	2012	5	with	with	IN
18637	2012	6	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	2012	7	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2012	8	among	among	IN
18637	2012	9	the	the	DT
18637	2012	10	States	States	NNP
18637	2012	11	and	and	CC
18637	2012	12	the	the	DT
18637	2012	13	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	2012	14	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	2012	15	;	;	:
18637	2012	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2012	17	also	also	RB
18637	2012	18	essayed	essay	VBD
18637	2012	19	to	to	TO
18637	2012	20	govern	govern	VB
18637	2012	21	production	production	NN
18637	2012	22	and	and	CC
18637	2012	23	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	2012	24	relations	relation	NNS
18637	2012	25	in	in	IN
18637	2012	26	the	the	DT
18637	2012	27	field	field	NN
18637	2012	28	of	of	IN
18637	2012	29	production	production	NN
18637	2012	30	.	.	.
18637	2013	1	Confronted	confront	VBN
18637	2013	2	with	with	IN
18637	2013	3	this	this	DT
18637	2013	4	revolutionary	revolutionary	JJ
18637	2013	5	claim	claim	NN
18637	2013	6	to	to	IN
18637	2013	7	power	power	NN
18637	2013	8	on	on	IN
18637	2013	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2013	10	'	'	POS
18637	2013	11	part	part	NN
18637	2013	12	,	,	,
18637	2013	13	the	the	DT
18637	2013	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2013	15	again	again	RB
18637	2013	16	deemed	deem	VBD
18637	2013	17	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2013	18	called	call	VBN
18637	2013	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	2013	20	to	to	TO
18637	2013	21	define	define	VB
18637	2013	22	a	a	DT
18637	2013	23	limit	limit	NN
18637	2013	24	to	to	IN
18637	2013	25	the	the	DT
18637	2013	26	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2013	27	power	power	NN
18637	2013	28	that	that	WDT
18637	2013	29	would	would	MD
18637	2013	30	save	save	VB
18637	2013	31	to	to	IN
18637	2013	32	the	the	DT
18637	2013	33	States	state	NNS
18637	2013	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2013	35	historical	historical	JJ
18637	2013	36	sphere	sphere	NN
18637	2013	37	,	,	,
18637	2013	38	and	and	CC
18637	2013	39	especially	especially	RB
18637	2013	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2013	41	customary	customary	JJ
18637	2013	42	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	2013	43	of	of	IN
18637	2013	44	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2013	45	power	power	NN
18637	2013	46	in	in	IN
18637	2013	47	relation	relation	NN
18637	2013	48	to	to	IN
18637	2013	49	industry	industry	NN
18637	2013	50	and	and	CC
18637	2013	51	labor	labor	NN
18637	2013	52	management	management	NN
18637	2013	53	.	.	.
18637	2014	1	THE	the	DT
18637	2014	2	SECURITIES	SECURITIES	NNP
18637	2014	3	AND	and	CC
18637	2014	4	EXCHANGE	EXCHANGE	NNP
18637	2014	5	COMMISSION	COMMISSION	NNP
18637	2014	6	Not	not	RB
18637	2014	7	all	all	DT
18637	2014	8	antidepression	antidepression	NN
18637	2014	9	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2014	10	,	,	,
18637	2014	11	however	however	RB
18637	2014	12	,	,	,
18637	2014	13	was	be	VBD
18637	2014	14	of	of	IN
18637	2014	15	this	this	DT
18637	2014	16	revolutionary	revolutionary	JJ
18637	2014	17	type	type	NN
18637	2014	18	.	.	.
18637	2015	1	The	the	DT
18637	2015	2	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	2015	3	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	2015	4	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2015	5	of	of	IN
18637	2015	6	1934[439	1934[439	CD
18637	2015	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2015	8	and	and	CC
18637	2015	9	the	the	DT
18637	2015	10	Public	Public	NNP
18637	2015	11	Utility	Utility	NNP
18637	2015	12	Company	Company	NNP
18637	2015	13	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2015	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2015	15	"	"	``
18637	2015	16	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	2015	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	2015	18	Rayburn	Rayburn	NNP
18637	2015	19	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2015	20	"	"	''
18637	2015	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2015	22	of	of	IN
18637	2015	23	1935[440	1935[440	CD
18637	2015	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2015	25	were	be	VBD
18637	2015	26	not	not	RB
18637	2015	27	.	.	.
18637	2016	1	The	the	DT
18637	2016	2	former	former	JJ
18637	2016	3	creates	create	VBZ
18637	2016	4	the	the	DT
18637	2016	5	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	2016	6	and	and	CC
18637	2016	7	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	2016	8	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2016	9	,	,	,
18637	2016	10	and	and	CC
18637	2016	11	authorizes	authorize	VBZ
18637	2016	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2016	13	to	to	TO
18637	2016	14	lay	lay	VB
18637	2016	15	down	down	RP
18637	2016	16	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2016	17	designed	design	VBN
18637	2016	18	to	to	TO
18637	2016	19	keep	keep	VB
18637	2016	20	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	2016	21	in	in	IN
18637	2016	22	securities	security	NNS
18637	2016	23	honest	honest	JJ
18637	2016	24	and	and	CC
18637	2016	25	above	above	JJ
18637	2016	26	-	-	HYPH
18637	2016	27	board	board	NN
18637	2016	28	and	and	CC
18637	2016	29	closes	close	VBZ
18637	2016	30	the	the	DT
18637	2016	31	channels	channel	NNS
18637	2016	32	of	of	IN
18637	2016	33	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2016	34	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2016	35	and	and	CC
18637	2016	36	the	the	DT
18637	2016	37	mails	mail	NNS
18637	2016	38	to	to	IN
18637	2016	39	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	2016	40	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	2016	41	to	to	TO
18637	2016	42	register	register	VB
18637	2016	43	under	under	IN
18637	2016	44	the	the	DT
18637	2016	45	act	act	NN
18637	2016	46	.	.	.
18637	2017	1	The	the	DT
18637	2017	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	2017	3	requires	require	VBZ
18637	2017	4	,	,	,
18637	2017	5	by	by	IN
18637	2017	6	sections	section	NNS
18637	2017	7	4	4	CD
18637	2017	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2017	9	a	a	NN
18637	2017	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2017	11	and	and	CC
18637	2017	12	5	5	CD
18637	2017	13	,	,	,
18637	2017	14	the	the	DT
18637	2017	15	companies	company	NNS
18637	2017	16	which	which	WDT
18637	2017	17	are	be	VBP
18637	2017	18	governed	govern	VBN
18637	2017	19	by	by	IN
18637	2017	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2017	21	to	to	TO
18637	2017	22	register	register	VB
18637	2017	23	with	with	IN
18637	2017	24	the	the	DT
18637	2017	25	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	2017	26	and	and	CC
18637	2017	27	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	2017	28	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2017	29	and	and	CC
18637	2017	30	to	to	TO
18637	2017	31	inform	inform	VB
18637	2017	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2017	33	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	2017	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2017	35	business	business	NN
18637	2017	36	,	,	,
18637	2017	37	organization	organization	NN
18637	2017	38	and	and	CC
18637	2017	39	financial	financial	JJ
18637	2017	40	structure	structure	NN
18637	2017	41	,	,	,
18637	2017	42	all	all	RB
18637	2017	43	on	on	IN
18637	2017	44	pain	pain	NN
18637	2017	45	of	of	IN
18637	2017	46	being	be	VBG
18637	2017	47	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	2017	48	use	use	NN
18637	2017	49	of	of	IN
18637	2017	50	the	the	DT
18637	2017	51	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	2017	52	of	of	IN
18637	2017	53	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2017	54	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2017	55	and	and	CC
18637	2017	56	the	the	DT
18637	2017	57	mails	mail	NNS
18637	2017	58	;	;	:
18637	2017	59	while	while	IN
18637	2017	60	by	by	IN
18637	2017	61	section	section	NN
18637	2017	62	11	11	CD
18637	2017	63	,	,	,
18637	2017	64	the	the	DT
18637	2017	65	so	so	RB
18637	2017	66	-	-	HYPH
18637	2017	67	called	call	VBN
18637	2017	68	"	"	``
18637	2017	69	death	death	NN
18637	2017	70	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	2017	71	"	"	''
18637	2017	72	clause	clause	NN
18637	2017	73	,	,	,
18637	2017	74	the	the	DT
18637	2017	75	same	same	JJ
18637	2017	76	act	act	NN
18637	2017	77	closes	close	NNS
18637	2017	78	after	after	IN
18637	2017	79	a	a	DT
18637	2017	80	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2017	81	date	date	NN
18637	2017	82	the	the	DT
18637	2017	83	channels	channel	NNS
18637	2017	84	of	of	IN
18637	2017	85	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2017	86	communication	communication	NN
18637	2017	87	to	to	IN
18637	2017	88	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2017	89	types	type	NNS
18637	2017	90	of	of	IN
18637	2017	91	public	public	JJ
18637	2017	92	utility	utility	NN
18637	2017	93	companies	company	NNS
18637	2017	94	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2017	95	operations	operation	NNS
18637	2017	96	,	,	,
18637	2017	97	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2017	98	found	find	VBD
18637	2017	99	,	,	,
18637	2017	100	were	be	VBD
18637	2017	101	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	2017	102	chiefly	chiefly	RB
18637	2017	103	to	to	TO
18637	2017	104	exploit	exploit	VB
18637	2017	105	the	the	DT
18637	2017	106	investing	invest	VBG
18637	2017	107	and	and	CC
18637	2017	108	consuming	consume	VBG
18637	2017	109	public	public	NN
18637	2017	110	.	.	.
18637	2018	1	All	all	PDT
18637	2018	2	these	these	DT
18637	2018	3	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	2018	4	have	have	VBP
18637	2018	5	been	be	VBN
18637	2018	6	sustained,[441	sustained,[441	NNP
18637	2018	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2018	8	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	2018	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2018	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	2018	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2018	12	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	2018	13	,	,	,
18637	2018	14	furnishing	furnish	VBG
18637	2018	15	the	the	DT
18637	2018	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2018	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2018	18	principal	principal	JJ
18637	2018	19	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	2018	20	.	.	.
18637	2019	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2019	2	442	442	CD
18637	2019	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2019	4	Congressional	Congressional	NNP
18637	2019	5	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	2019	6	of	of	IN
18637	2019	7	Production	Production	NNP
18637	2019	8	and	and	CC
18637	2019	9	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	2019	10	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	2019	11	ANTIDEPRESSION	ANTIDEPRESSION	NNP
18637	2019	12	LEGISLATION	LEGISLATION	NNP
18637	2019	13	In	in	IN
18637	2019	14	the	the	DT
18637	2019	15	following	follow	VBG
18637	2019	16	words	word	NNS
18637	2019	17	of	of	IN
18637	2019	18	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2019	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2019	20	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	2019	21	,	,	,
18637	2019	22	spoken	speak	VBN
18637	2019	23	in	in	IN
18637	2019	24	a	a	DT
18637	2019	25	case	case	NN
18637	2019	26	which	which	WDT
18637	2019	27	was	be	VBD
18637	2019	28	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2019	29	a	a	DT
18637	2019	30	few	few	JJ
18637	2019	31	days	day	NNS
18637	2019	32	after	after	IN
18637	2019	33	President	President	NNP
18637	2019	34	Franklin	Franklin	NNP
18637	2019	35	D.	D.	NNP
18637	2019	36	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	2019	37	's	's	POS
18637	2019	38	first	first	JJ
18637	2019	39	inauguration	inauguration	NN
18637	2019	40	,	,	,
18637	2019	41	the	the	DT
18637	2019	42	problem	problem	NN
18637	2019	43	which	which	WDT
18637	2019	44	confronted	confront	VBD
18637	2019	45	the	the	DT
18637	2019	46	new	new	JJ
18637	2019	47	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	2019	48	was	be	VBD
18637	2019	49	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	2019	50	set	set	VBN
18637	2019	51	forth	forth	RB
18637	2019	52	:	:	:
18637	2019	53	"	"	``
18637	2019	54	When	when	WRB
18637	2019	55	industry	industry	NN
18637	2019	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	2019	57	grievously	grievously	RB
18637	2019	58	hurt	hurt	VBN
18637	2019	59	,	,	,
18637	2019	60	when	when	WRB
18637	2019	61	producing	produce	VBG
18637	2019	62	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	2019	63	fail	fail	VBP
18637	2019	64	,	,	,
18637	2019	65	when	when	WRB
18637	2019	66	unemployment	unemployment	NN
18637	2019	67	mounts	mount	NNS
18637	2019	68	and	and	CC
18637	2019	69	communities	community	NNS
18637	2019	70	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	2019	71	upon	upon	IN
18637	2019	72	profitable	profitable	JJ
18637	2019	73	production	production	NN
18637	2019	74	are	be	VBP
18637	2019	75	prostrated	prostrate	VBN
18637	2019	76	,	,	,
18637	2019	77	the	the	DT
18637	2019	78	wells	well	NNS
18637	2019	79	of	of	IN
18637	2019	80	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2019	81	go	go	VBP
18637	2019	82	dry	dry	JJ
18637	2019	83	.	.	.
18637	2020	1	"	"	``
18637	2020	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2020	3	443	443	CD
18637	2020	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2020	5	THE	THE	NNP
18637	2020	6	NATIONAL	NATIONAL	NNP
18637	2020	7	INDUSTRIAL	INDUSTRIAL	NNP
18637	2020	8	RECOVERY	RECOVERY	NNP
18637	2020	9	ACT	ACT	NNP
18637	2020	10	The	the	DT
18637	2020	11	initial	initial	JJ
18637	2020	12	effort	effort	NN
18637	2020	13	of	of	IN
18637	2020	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2020	15	to	to	TO
18637	2020	16	deal	deal	VB
18637	2020	17	with	with	IN
18637	2020	18	this	this	DT
18637	2020	19	situation	situation	NN
18637	2020	20	was	be	VBD
18637	2020	21	embodied	embody	VBN
18637	2020	22	in	in	IN
18637	2020	23	the	the	DT
18637	2020	24	National	National	NNP
18637	2020	25	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	2020	26	Recovery	Recovery	NNP
18637	2020	27	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2020	28	of	of	IN
18637	2020	29	June	June	NNP
18637	2020	30	16	16	CD
18637	2020	31	,	,	,
18637	2020	32	1933	1933	CD
18637	2020	33	.	.	.
18637	2021	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2021	2	444	444	CD
18637	2021	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2021	4	The	the	DT
18637	2021	5	opening	opening	NN
18637	2021	6	section	section	NN
18637	2021	7	of	of	IN
18637	2021	8	the	the	DT
18637	2021	9	act	act	NN
18637	2021	10	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	2021	11	the	the	DT
18637	2021	12	existence	existence	NN
18637	2021	13	of	of	IN
18637	2021	14	"	"	``
18637	2021	15	a	a	DT
18637	2021	16	national	national	JJ
18637	2021	17	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	2021	18	productive	productive	JJ
18637	2021	19	of	of	IN
18637	2021	20	widespread	widespread	JJ
18637	2021	21	unemployment	unemployment	NN
18637	2021	22	and	and	CC
18637	2021	23	disorganization	disorganization	NN
18637	2021	24	of	of	IN
18637	2021	25	industry	industry	NN
18637	2021	26	which	which	WDT
18637	2021	27	"	"	``
18637	2021	28	burdened	burden	VBD
18637	2021	29	"	"	''
18637	2021	30	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2021	31	and	and	CC
18637	2021	32	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2021	33	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2021	34	,	,	,
18637	2021	35	"	"	''
18637	2021	36	affected	affect	VBD
18637	2021	37	"	"	''
18637	2021	38	the	the	DT
18637	2021	39	public	public	JJ
18637	2021	40	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	2021	41	,	,	,
18637	2021	42	"	"	''
18637	2021	43	and	and	CC
18637	2021	44	undermined	undermine	VBD
18637	2021	45	"	"	``
18637	2021	46	the	the	DT
18637	2021	47	standards	standard	NNS
18637	2021	48	of	of	IN
18637	2021	49	living	living	NN
18637	2021	50	of	of	IN
18637	2021	51	the	the	DT
18637	2021	52	American	american	JJ
18637	2021	53	people	people	NNS
18637	2021	54	.	.	.
18637	2021	55	"	"	''
18637	2022	1	To	to	TO
18637	2022	2	effect	effect	VB
18637	2022	3	the	the	DT
18637	2022	4	removal	removal	NN
18637	2022	5	of	of	IN
18637	2022	6	these	these	DT
18637	2022	7	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2022	8	the	the	DT
18637	2022	9	President	President	NNP
18637	2022	10	was	be	VBD
18637	2022	11	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	2022	12	,	,	,
18637	2022	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	2022	14	the	the	DT
18637	2022	15	application	application	NN
18637	2022	16	of	of	IN
18637	2022	17	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	2022	18	or	or	CC
18637	2022	19	trade	trade	NN
18637	2022	20	groups	group	NNS
18637	2022	21	,	,	,
18637	2022	22	to	to	TO
18637	2022	23	approve	approve	VB
18637	2022	24	"	"	``
18637	2022	25	codes	code	NNS
18637	2022	26	of	of	IN
18637	2022	27	fair	fair	JJ
18637	2022	28	competition	competition	NN
18637	2022	29	,	,	,
18637	2022	30	"	"	''
18637	2022	31	or	or	CC
18637	2022	32	to	to	TO
18637	2022	33	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	2022	34	the	the	DT
18637	2022	35	same	same	JJ
18637	2022	36	in	in	IN
18637	2022	37	cases	case	NNS
18637	2022	38	where	where	WRB
18637	2022	39	such	such	JJ
18637	2022	40	applications	application	NNS
18637	2022	41	were	be	VBD
18637	2022	42	not	not	RB
18637	2022	43	duly	duly	RB
18637	2022	44	forthcoming	forthcoming	JJ
18637	2022	45	.	.	.
18637	2023	1	Among	among	IN
18637	2023	2	other	other	JJ
18637	2023	3	things	thing	NNS
18637	2023	4	such	such	JJ
18637	2023	5	codes	code	NNS
18637	2023	6	,	,	,
18637	2023	7	of	of	IN
18637	2023	8	which	which	WDT
18637	2023	9	eventually	eventually	RB
18637	2023	10	more	more	JJR
18637	2023	11	than	than	IN
18637	2023	12	700	700	CD
18637	2023	13	were	be	VBD
18637	2023	14	promulgated	promulgate	VBN
18637	2023	15	,	,	,
18637	2023	16	were	be	VBD
18637	2023	17	required	require	VBN
18637	2023	18	to	to	TO
18637	2023	19	lay	lay	VB
18637	2023	20	down	down	RP
18637	2023	21	rules	rule	NNS
18637	2023	22	of	of	IN
18637	2023	23	fair	fair	JJ
18637	2023	24	dealing	dealing	NN
18637	2023	25	with	with	IN
18637	2023	26	customers	customer	NNS
18637	2023	27	and	and	CC
18637	2023	28	to	to	TO
18637	2023	29	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	2023	30	labor	labor	NN
18637	2023	31	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2023	32	guarantees	guarantee	NNS
18637	2023	33	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	2023	34	hours	hour	NNS
18637	2023	35	,	,	,
18637	2023	36	wages	wage	NNS
18637	2023	37	and	and	CC
18637	2023	38	collective	collective	JJ
18637	2023	39	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	2023	40	.	.	.
18637	2024	1	For	for	IN
18637	2024	2	the	the	DT
18637	2024	3	time	time	NN
18637	2024	4	being	be	VBG
18637	2024	5	business	business	NN
18637	2024	6	and	and	CC
18637	2024	7	industry	industry	NN
18637	2024	8	were	be	VBD
18637	2024	9	to	to	TO
18637	2024	10	be	be	VB
18637	2024	11	cartelized	cartelize	VBN
18637	2024	12	on	on	IN
18637	2024	13	a	a	DT
18637	2024	14	national	national	JJ
18637	2024	15	scale	scale	NN
18637	2024	16	.	.	.
18637	2025	1	THE	the	DT
18637	2025	2	SCHECHTER	SCHECHTER	NNP
18637	2025	3	CASE	case	NN
18637	2025	4	In	in	IN
18637	2025	5	the	the	DT
18637	2025	6	case	case	NN
18637	2025	7	of	of	IN
18637	2025	8	Schechter	Schechter	NNP
18637	2025	9	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	2025	10	_	_	NNP
18637	2025	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	2025	12	_	_	NNP
18637	2025	13	United	United	NNP
18637	2025	14	States,[445	States,[445	NNP
18637	2025	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2025	16	one	one	CD
18637	2025	17	of	of	IN
18637	2025	18	these	these	DT
18637	2025	19	codes	code	NNS
18637	2025	20	,	,	,
18637	2025	21	the	the	DT
18637	2025	22	Live	live	JJ
18637	2025	23	Poultry	Poultry	NNP
18637	2025	24	Code	Code	NNP
18637	2025	25	,	,	,
18637	2025	26	was	be	VBD
18637	2025	27	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
18637	2025	28	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2025	29	.	.	.
18637	2026	1	Although	although	IN
18637	2026	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2026	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2026	4	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	2026	5	that	that	IN
18637	2026	6	practically	practically	RB
18637	2026	7	all	all	DT
18637	2026	8	poultry	poultry	NN
18637	2026	9	handled	handle	VBN
18637	2026	10	by	by	IN
18637	2026	11	the	the	DT
18637	2026	12	Schechters	Schechters	NNPS
18637	2026	13	came	come	VBD
18637	2026	14	from	from	IN
18637	2026	15	outside	outside	IN
18637	2026	16	the	the	DT
18637	2026	17	State	state	NN
18637	2026	18	,	,	,
18637	2026	19	and	and	CC
18637	2026	20	hence	hence	RB
18637	2026	21	via	via	IN
18637	2026	22	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2026	23	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2026	24	,	,	,
18637	2026	25	the	the	DT
18637	2026	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2026	27	held	hold	VBD
18637	2026	28	,	,	,
18637	2026	29	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	2026	30	,	,	,
18637	2026	31	that	that	IN
18637	2026	32	once	once	IN
18637	2026	33	the	the	DT
18637	2026	34	chickens	chicken	NNS
18637	2026	35	came	come	VBD
18637	2026	36	to	to	TO
18637	2026	37	rest	rest	VB
18637	2026	38	in	in	IN
18637	2026	39	the	the	DT
18637	2026	40	Schechters	schechter	NNS
18637	2026	41	'	'	POS
18637	2026	42	wholesale	wholesale	JJ
18637	2026	43	market	market	NN
18637	2026	44	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2026	45	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2026	46	in	in	IN
18637	2026	47	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2026	48	ceased	cease	VBD
18637	2026	49	.	.	.
18637	2027	1	The	the	DT
18637	2027	2	act	act	NN
18637	2027	3	,	,	,
18637	2027	4	however	however	RB
18637	2027	5	,	,	,
18637	2027	6	also	also	RB
18637	2027	7	purported	purport	VBD
18637	2027	8	to	to	TO
18637	2027	9	govern	govern	VB
18637	2027	10	business	business	NN
18637	2027	11	activities	activity	NNS
18637	2027	12	which	which	WDT
18637	2027	13	"	"	``
18637	2027	14	affected	affect	VBD
18637	2027	15	"	"	''
18637	2027	16	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2027	17	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2027	18	.	.	.
18637	2028	1	This	this	DT
18637	2028	2	,	,	,
18637	2028	3	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2028	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2028	5	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	2028	6	held	hold	VBN
18637	2028	7	,	,	,
18637	2028	8	must	must	MD
18637	2028	9	be	be	VB
18637	2028	10	taken	take	VBN
18637	2028	11	to	to	TO
18637	2028	12	mean	mean	VB
18637	2028	13	"	"	``
18637	2028	14	directly	directly	RB
18637	2028	15	"	"	''
18637	2028	16	affect	affect	VBP
18637	2028	17	such	such	JJ
18637	2028	18	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2028	19	:	:	:
18637	2028	20	"	"	``
18637	2028	21	the	the	DT
18637	2028	22	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	2028	23	between	between	IN
18637	2028	24	direct	direct	JJ
18637	2028	25	and	and	CC
18637	2028	26	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	2028	27	effects	effect	NNS
18637	2028	28	of	of	IN
18637	2028	29	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2028	30	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	2028	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	2028	32	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2028	33	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2028	34	must	must	MD
18637	2028	35	be	be	VB
18637	2028	36	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	2028	37	as	as	IN
18637	2028	38	a	a	DT
18637	2028	39	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	2028	40	one	one	NN
18637	2028	41	,	,	,
18637	2028	42	essential	essential	JJ
18637	2028	43	to	to	IN
18637	2028	44	the	the	DT
18637	2028	45	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	2028	46	of	of	IN
18637	2028	47	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2028	48	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2028	49	system	system	NN
18637	2028	50	.	.	.
18637	2029	1	Otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2029	2	,	,	,
18637	2029	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2029	4	*	*	NFP
18637	2029	5	*	*	NFP
18637	2029	6	,	,	,
18637	2029	7	there	there	EX
18637	2029	8	would	would	MD
18637	2029	9	be	be	VB
18637	2029	10	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	2029	11	no	no	DT
18637	2029	12	limit	limit	NN
18637	2029	13	to	to	IN
18637	2029	14	the	the	DT
18637	2029	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2029	16	power	power	NN
18637	2029	17	and	and	CC
18637	2029	18	for	for	IN
18637	2029	19	all	all	DT
18637	2029	20	practical	practical	JJ
18637	2029	21	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	2029	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2029	23	should	should	MD
18637	2029	24	have	have	VB
18637	2029	25	a	a	DT
18637	2029	26	completely	completely	RB
18637	2029	27	centralized	centralize	VBN
18637	2029	28	government	government	NN
18637	2029	29	.	.	.
18637	2030	1	"	"	``
18637	2030	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2030	3	446	446	CD
18637	2030	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2030	5	In	in	IN
18637	2030	6	short	short	JJ
18637	2030	7	,	,	,
18637	2030	8	the	the	DT
18637	2030	9	case	case	NN
18637	2030	10	was	be	VBD
18637	2030	11	governed	govern	VBN
18637	2030	12	by	by	IN
18637	2030	13	the	the	DT
18637	2030	14	ideology	ideology	NN
18637	2030	15	of	of	IN
18637	2030	16	the	the	DT
18637	2030	17	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	2030	18	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	2030	19	Case	Case	NNP
18637	2030	20	,	,	,
18637	2030	21	which	which	WDT
18637	2030	22	was	be	VBD
18637	2030	23	not	not	RB
18637	2030	24	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	2030	25	in	in	IN
18637	2030	26	the	the	DT
18637	2030	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2030	28	's	's	POS
18637	2030	29	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2030	30	.	.	.
18637	2031	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2031	2	447	447	CD
18637	2031	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2031	4	THE	the	DT
18637	2031	5	AGRICULTURAL	AGRICULTURAL	NNP
18637	2031	6	ADJUSTMENT	ADJUSTMENT	NNP
18637	2031	7	ACT	ACT	NNP
18637	2031	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2031	9	'	'	POS
18637	2031	10	second	second	JJ
18637	2031	11	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	2031	12	to	to	TO
18637	2031	13	combat	combat	VB
18637	2031	14	the	the	DT
18637	2031	15	Depression	Depression	NNP
18637	2031	16	comprised	comprise	VBD
18637	2031	17	the	the	DT
18637	2031	18	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	2031	19	Adjustment	Adjustment	NNP
18637	2031	20	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2031	21	of	of	IN
18637	2031	22	1933	1933	CD
18637	2031	23	.	.	.
18637	2032	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2032	2	448	448	CD
18637	2032	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2032	4	As	as	IN
18637	2032	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	2032	6	pointed	point	VBN
18637	2032	7	out	out	RP
18637	2032	8	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	2032	9	the	the	DT
18637	2032	10	measure	measure	NN
18637	2032	11	was	be	VBD
18637	2032	12	set	set	VBN
18637	2032	13	aside	aside	RP
18637	2032	14	as	as	IN
18637	2032	15	an	an	DT
18637	2032	16	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	2032	17	to	to	TO
18637	2032	18	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2032	19	production	production	NN
18637	2032	20	,	,	,
18637	2032	21	a	a	DT
18637	2032	22	subject	subject	NN
18637	2032	23	which	which	WDT
18637	2032	24	was	be	VBD
18637	2032	25	held	hold	VBN
18637	2032	26	to	to	TO
18637	2032	27	be	be	VB
18637	2032	28	"	"	``
18637	2032	29	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	2032	30	"	"	''
18637	2032	31	to	to	IN
18637	2032	32	the	the	DT
18637	2032	33	United	United	NNP
18637	2032	34	States	States	NNP
18637	2032	35	by	by	IN
18637	2032	36	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	2032	37	X.	X.	NNP
18637	2033	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2033	2	449	449	CD
18637	2033	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2033	4	_	_	NNP
18637	2033	5	See	See	NNP
18637	2033	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2033	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	2033	8	.	.	.
18637	2034	1	917	917	CD
18637	2034	2	-	-	SYM
18637	2034	3	918	918	CD
18637	2034	4	.	.	.
18637	2035	1	THE	the	DT
18637	2035	2	BITUMINOUS	BITUMINOUS	NNP
18637	2035	3	COAL	COAL	NNP
18637	2035	4	CONSERVATION	CONSERVATION	NNP
18637	2035	5	ACT	ACT	NNP
18637	2035	6	The	the	DT
18637	2035	7	third	third	JJ
18637	2035	8	measure	measure	NN
18637	2035	9	to	to	TO
18637	2035	10	be	be	VB
18637	2035	11	disallowed	disallow	VBN
18637	2035	12	was	be	VBD
18637	2035	13	the	the	DT
18637	2035	14	Guffey	Guffey	NNP
18637	2035	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	2035	16	Snyder	Snyder	NNP
18637	2035	17	Bituminous	Bituminous	NNP
18637	2035	18	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	2035	19	Conservation	Conservation	NNP
18637	2035	20	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2035	21	of	of	IN
18637	2035	22	1935	1935	CD
18637	2035	23	.	.	.
18637	2036	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2036	2	450	450	CD
18637	2036	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2036	4	The	the	DT
18637	2036	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	2036	6	created	create	VBD
18637	2036	7	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	2036	8	for	for	IN
18637	2036	9	the	the	DT
18637	2036	10	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2036	11	of	of	IN
18637	2036	12	the	the	DT
18637	2036	13	price	price	NN
18637	2036	14	of	of	IN
18637	2036	15	soft	soft	JJ
18637	2036	16	coal	coal	NN
18637	2036	17	,	,	,
18637	2036	18	both	both	DT
18637	2036	19	that	that	WDT
18637	2036	20	sold	sell	VBD
18637	2036	21	in	in	IN
18637	2036	22	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2036	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2036	24	and	and	CC
18637	2036	25	that	that	IN
18637	2036	26	sold	sell	VBD
18637	2036	27	"	"	``
18637	2036	28	locally	locally	RB
18637	2036	29	,	,	,
18637	2036	30	"	"	''
18637	2036	31	and	and	CC
18637	2036	32	other	other	JJ
18637	2036	33	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	2036	34	for	for	IN
18637	2036	35	the	the	DT
18637	2036	36	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2036	37	of	of	IN
18637	2036	38	hours	hour	NNS
18637	2036	39	of	of	IN
18637	2036	40	labor	labor	NN
18637	2036	41	and	and	CC
18637	2036	42	wages	wage	NNS
18637	2036	43	in	in	IN
18637	2036	44	the	the	DT
18637	2036	45	mines	mine	NNS
18637	2036	46	.	.	.
18637	2037	1	The	the	DT
18637	2037	2	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	2037	3	of	of	IN
18637	2037	4	the	the	DT
18637	2037	5	act	act	NN
18637	2037	6	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	2037	7	with	with	IN
18637	2037	8	these	these	DT
18637	2037	9	two	two	CD
18637	2037	10	different	different	JJ
18637	2037	11	matters	matter	NNS
18637	2037	12	were	be	VBD
18637	2037	13	declared	declare	VBN
18637	2037	14	by	by	IN
18637	2037	15	the	the	DT
18637	2037	16	act	act	NN
18637	2037	17	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2037	18	to	to	TO
18637	2037	19	be	be	VB
18637	2037	20	separable	separable	JJ
18637	2037	21	so	so	IN
18637	2037	22	that	that	IN
18637	2037	23	the	the	DT
18637	2037	24	invalidity	invalidity	NN
18637	2037	25	of	of	IN
18637	2037	26	the	the	DT
18637	2037	27	one	one	CD
18637	2037	28	set	set	NN
18637	2037	29	would	would	MD
18637	2037	30	not	not	RB
18637	2037	31	affect	affect	VB
18637	2037	32	the	the	DT
18637	2037	33	validity	validity	NN
18637	2037	34	of	of	IN
18637	2037	35	the	the	DT
18637	2037	36	other	other	JJ
18637	2037	37	;	;	:
18637	2037	38	but	but	CC
18637	2037	39	this	this	DT
18637	2037	40	strategy	strategy	NN
18637	2037	41	was	be	VBD
18637	2037	42	ineffectual	ineffectual	JJ
18637	2037	43	.	.	.
18637	2038	1	A	a	DT
18637	2038	2	majority	majority	NN
18637	2038	3	of	of	IN
18637	2038	4	the	the	DT
18637	2038	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2038	6	,	,	,
18637	2038	7	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2038	8	by	by	IN
18637	2038	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2038	10	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	2038	11	held	hold	VBD
18637	2038	12	that	that	IN
18637	2038	13	the	the	DT
18637	2038	14	act	act	NN
18637	2038	15	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	2038	16	one	one	CD
18637	2038	17	connected	connected	JJ
18637	2038	18	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	2038	19	of	of	IN
18637	2038	20	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2038	21	which	which	WDT
18637	2038	22	,	,	,
18637	2038	23	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	2038	24	as	as	IN
18637	2038	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2038	26	invaded	invade	VBD
18637	2038	27	the	the	DT
18637	2038	28	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	2038	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	2038	30	of	of	IN
18637	2038	31	the	the	DT
18637	2038	32	States	States	NNPS
18637	2038	33	over	over	IN
18637	2038	34	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2038	35	of	of	IN
18637	2038	36	employment	employment	NN
18637	2038	37	in	in	IN
18637	2038	38	productive	productive	JJ
18637	2038	39	industry	industry	NN
18637	2038	40	,	,	,
18637	2038	41	was	be	VBD
18637	2038	42	violative	violative	JJ
18637	2038	43	of	of	IN
18637	2038	44	the	the	DT
18637	2038	45	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2038	46	and	and	CC
18637	2038	47	void	void	JJ
18637	2038	48	.	.	.
18637	2039	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2039	2	451	451	CD
18637	2039	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2039	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2039	5	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	2039	6	's	's	POS
18637	2039	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2039	8	set	set	VBD
18637	2039	9	out	out	RP
18637	2039	10	from	from	IN
18637	2039	11	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2039	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2039	13	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	2039	14	's	's	POS
18637	2039	15	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	2039	16	in	in	IN
18637	2039	17	the	the	DT
18637	2039	18	Schechter	Schechter	NNP
18637	2039	19	Case	Case	NNP
18637	2039	20	of	of	IN
18637	2039	21	the	the	DT
18637	2039	22	"	"	``
18637	2039	23	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	2039	24	"	"	''
18637	2039	25	character	character	NN
18637	2039	26	of	of	IN
18637	2039	27	the	the	DT
18637	2039	28	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	2039	29	between	between	IN
18637	2039	30	"	"	``
18637	2039	31	direct	direct	JJ
18637	2039	32	"	"	''
18637	2039	33	and	and	CC
18637	2039	34	"	"	``
18637	2039	35	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	2039	36	"	"	''
18637	2039	37	effects	effect	NNS
18637	2039	38	;	;	:
18637	2039	39	that	that	DT
18637	2039	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	2039	41	to	to	TO
18637	2039	42	say	say	VB
18637	2039	43	,	,	,
18637	2039	44	from	from	IN
18637	2039	45	the	the	DT
18637	2039	46	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2039	47	of	of	IN
18637	2039	48	the	the	DT
18637	2039	49	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	2039	50	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	2039	51	Case	Case	NNP
18637	2039	52	.	.	.
18637	2040	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2040	2	then	then	RB
18637	2040	3	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	2040	4	:	:	:
18637	2040	5	"	"	``
18637	2040	6	Much	much	JJ
18637	2040	7	stress	stress	NN
18637	2040	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	2040	9	put	put	VBN
18637	2040	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	2040	11	the	the	DT
18637	2040	12	evils	evil	NNS
18637	2040	13	which	which	WDT
18637	2040	14	come	come	VBP
18637	2040	15	from	from	IN
18637	2040	16	the	the	DT
18637	2040	17	struggle	struggle	NN
18637	2040	18	between	between	IN
18637	2040	19	employers	employer	NNS
18637	2040	20	and	and	CC
18637	2040	21	employees	employee	NNS
18637	2040	22	over	over	IN
18637	2040	23	the	the	DT
18637	2040	24	matter	matter	NN
18637	2040	25	of	of	IN
18637	2040	26	wages	wage	NNS
18637	2040	27	,	,	,
18637	2040	28	working	working	NN
18637	2040	29	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2040	30	,	,	,
18637	2040	31	the	the	DT
18637	2040	32	right	right	NN
18637	2040	33	of	of	IN
18637	2040	34	collective	collective	JJ
18637	2040	35	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	2040	36	,	,	,
18637	2040	37	etc	etc	FW
18637	2040	38	.	.	FW
18637	2040	39	,	,	,
18637	2040	40	and	and	CC
18637	2040	41	the	the	DT
18637	2040	42	resulting	result	VBG
18637	2040	43	strikes	strike	NNS
18637	2040	44	,	,	,
18637	2040	45	curtailment	curtailment	NN
18637	2040	46	and	and	CC
18637	2040	47	irregularity	irregularity	NN
18637	2040	48	of	of	IN
18637	2040	49	production	production	NN
18637	2040	50	and	and	CC
18637	2040	51	effect	effect	NN
18637	2040	52	on	on	IN
18637	2040	53	prices	price	NNS
18637	2040	54	;	;	:
18637	2040	55	and	and	CC
18637	2040	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2040	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	2040	58	insisted	insist	VBN
18637	2040	59	that	that	IN
18637	2040	60	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2040	61	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2040	62	is	be	VBZ
18637	2040	63	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	2040	64	affected	affect	VBN
18637	2040	65	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	2040	66	.	.	.
18637	2041	1	But	but	CC
18637	2041	2	,	,	,
18637	2041	3	...	...	:
18637	2041	4	,	,	,
18637	2041	5	the	the	DT
18637	2041	6	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	2041	7	answer	answer	NN
18637	2041	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	2041	9	that	that	IN
18637	2041	10	the	the	DT
18637	2041	11	evils	evil	NNS
18637	2041	12	are	be	VBP
18637	2041	13	all	all	DT
18637	2041	14	local	local	JJ
18637	2041	15	evils	evil	NNS
18637	2041	16	over	over	IN
18637	2041	17	which	which	WDT
18637	2041	18	the	the	DT
18637	2041	19	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2041	20	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2041	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	2041	22	no	no	DT
18637	2041	23	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2041	24	control	control	NN
18637	2041	25	.	.	.
18637	2042	1	The	the	DT
18637	2042	2	relation	relation	NN
18637	2042	3	of	of	IN
18637	2042	4	employer	employer	NN
18637	2042	5	and	and	CC
18637	2042	6	employee	employee	NN
18637	2042	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	2042	8	a	a	DT
18637	2042	9	local	local	JJ
18637	2042	10	relation	relation	NN
18637	2042	11	.	.	.
18637	2043	1	At	at	IN
18637	2043	2	common	common	JJ
18637	2043	3	law	law	NN
18637	2043	4	,	,	,
18637	2043	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2043	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2043	7	one	one	CD
18637	2043	8	of	of	IN
18637	2043	9	the	the	DT
18637	2043	10	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	2043	11	relations	relation	NNS
18637	2043	12	.	.	.
18637	2044	1	The	the	DT
18637	2044	2	wages	wage	NNS
18637	2044	3	are	be	VBP
18637	2044	4	paid	pay	VBN
18637	2044	5	for	for	IN
18637	2044	6	the	the	DT
18637	2044	7	doing	doing	NN
18637	2044	8	of	of	IN
18637	2044	9	local	local	JJ
18637	2044	10	work	work	NN
18637	2044	11	.	.	.
18637	2045	1	Working	working	NN
18637	2045	2	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2045	3	are	be	VBP
18637	2045	4	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	2045	5	local	local	JJ
18637	2045	6	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2045	7	.	.	.
18637	2046	1	The	the	DT
18637	2046	2	employees	employee	NNS
18637	2046	3	are	be	VBP
18637	2046	4	not	not	RB
18637	2046	5	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2046	6	in	in	IN
18637	2046	7	or	or	CC
18637	2046	8	about	about	IN
18637	2046	9	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2046	10	,	,	,
18637	2046	11	but	but	CC
18637	2046	12	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	2046	13	in	in	IN
18637	2046	14	producing	produce	VBG
18637	2046	15	a	a	DT
18637	2046	16	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	2046	17	.	.	.
18637	2047	1	And	and	CC
18637	2047	2	the	the	DT
18637	2047	3	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	2047	4	and	and	CC
18637	2047	5	evils	evil	NNS
18637	2047	6	,	,	,
18637	2047	7	which	which	WDT
18637	2047	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2047	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	2047	10	the	the	DT
18637	2047	11	object	object	NN
18637	2047	12	of	of	IN
18637	2047	13	the	the	DT
18637	2047	14	act	act	NN
18637	2047	15	to	to	TO
18637	2047	16	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2047	17	and	and	CC
18637	2047	18	minimize	minimize	VB
18637	2047	19	,	,	,
18637	2047	20	are	be	VBP
18637	2047	21	local	local	JJ
18637	2047	22	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	2047	23	and	and	CC
18637	2047	24	evils	evil	NNS
18637	2047	25	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	2047	26	local	local	JJ
18637	2047	27	work	work	NN
18637	2047	28	undertaken	undertake	VBN
18637	2047	29	to	to	TO
18637	2047	30	accomplish	accomplish	VB
18637	2047	31	that	that	IN
18637	2047	32	local	local	JJ
18637	2047	33	result	result	NN
18637	2047	34	.	.	.
18637	2048	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	2048	2	effect	effect	NN
18637	2048	3	as	as	IN
18637	2048	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2048	5	may	may	MD
18637	2048	6	have	have	VB
18637	2048	7	upon	upon	IN
18637	2048	8	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2048	9	,	,	,
18637	2048	10	however	however	RB
18637	2048	11	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	2048	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2048	13	may	may	MD
18637	2048	14	be	be	VB
18637	2048	15	,	,	,
18637	2048	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	2048	17	secondary	secondary	JJ
18637	2048	18	and	and	CC
18637	2048	19	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	2048	20	.	.	.
18637	2049	1	An	an	DT
18637	2049	2	increase	increase	NN
18637	2049	3	in	in	IN
18637	2049	4	the	the	DT
18637	2049	5	greatness	greatness	NN
18637	2049	6	of	of	IN
18637	2049	7	the	the	DT
18637	2049	8	effect	effect	NN
18637	2049	9	adds	add	VBZ
18637	2049	10	to	to	IN
18637	2049	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2049	12	importance	importance	NN
18637	2049	13	.	.	.
18637	2050	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2050	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	2050	3	not	not	RB
18637	2050	4	alter	alter	VB
18637	2050	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2050	6	character	character	NN
18637	2050	7	.	.	.
18637	2051	1	"	"	``
18637	2051	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2051	3	452	452	CD
18637	2051	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2051	5	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2051	6	again	again	RB
18637	2051	7	see	see	VBP
18637	2051	8	the	the	DT
18637	2051	9	influence	influence	NN
18637	2051	10	of	of	IN
18637	2051	11	the	the	DT
18637	2051	12	ideology	ideology	NN
18637	2051	13	of	of	IN
18637	2051	14	the	the	DT
18637	2051	15	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	2051	16	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	2051	17	Case	Case	NNP
18637	2051	18	.	.	.
18637	2052	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2052	2	453	453	CD
18637	2052	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2052	4	THE	THE	NNP
18637	2052	5	NATIONAL	NATIONAL	NNP
18637	2052	6	LABOR	LABOR	NNP
18637	2052	7	RELATIONS	RELATIONS	NNP
18637	2052	8	ACT	ACT	NNP
18637	2052	9	The	the	DT
18637	2052	10	case	case	NN
18637	2052	11	in	in	IN
18637	2052	12	which	which	WDT
18637	2052	13	the	the	DT
18637	2052	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2052	15	reduced	reduce	VBD
18637	2052	16	the	the	DT
18637	2052	17	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	2052	18	between	between	IN
18637	2052	19	"	"	``
18637	2052	20	direct	direct	JJ
18637	2052	21	"	"	''
18637	2052	22	and	and	CC
18637	2052	23	"	"	``
18637	2052	24	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	2052	25	"	"	''
18637	2052	26	effects	effect	NNS
18637	2052	27	to	to	IN
18637	2052	28	the	the	DT
18637	2052	29	vanishing	vanish	VBG
18637	2052	30	point	point	NN
18637	2052	31	,	,	,
18637	2052	32	and	and	CC
18637	2052	33	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	2052	34	put	put	VBN
18637	2052	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2052	36	in	in	IN
18637	2052	37	the	the	DT
18637	2052	38	way	way	NN
18637	2052	39	of	of	IN
18637	2052	40	governing	govern	VBG
18637	2052	41	productive	productive	JJ
18637	2052	42	industry	industry	NN
18637	2052	43	and	and	CC
18637	2052	44	labor	labor	NN
18637	2052	45	relations	relation	NNS
18637	2052	46	in	in	IN
18637	2052	47	such	such	JJ
18637	2052	48	industry	industry	NN
18637	2052	49	was	be	VBD
18637	2052	50	National	National	NNP
18637	2052	51	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	2052	52	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	2052	53	Board	Board	NNP
18637	2052	54	_	_	NNP
18637	2052	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	2052	56	_	_	NNP
18637	2052	57	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	2052	58	and	and	CC
18637	2052	59	Laughlin	Laughlin	NNP
18637	2052	60	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	2052	61	Corp	Corp	NNP
18637	2052	62	.	.	NNP
18637	2052	63	,[454	,[454	NFP
18637	2052	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2052	65	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2052	66	April	April	NNP
18637	2052	67	12	12	CD
18637	2052	68	,	,	,
18637	2052	69	1937	1937	CD
18637	2052	70	.	.	.
18637	2053	1	Here	here	RB
18637	2053	2	the	the	DT
18637	2053	3	statute	statute	NN
18637	2053	4	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2053	5	was	be	VBD
18637	2053	6	the	the	DT
18637	2053	7	National	National	NNP
18637	2053	8	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	2053	9	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	2053	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2053	11	of	of	IN
18637	2053	12	July	July	NNP
18637	2053	13	5	5	CD
18637	2053	14	,	,	,
18637	2053	15	1935,[455	1935,[455	CD
18637	2053	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2053	17	which	which	WDT
18637	2053	18	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	2053	19	"	"	``
18637	2053	20	any	any	DT
18637	2053	21	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	2053	22	labor	labor	NN
18637	2053	23	practice	practice	NN
18637	2053	24	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	2053	25	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2053	26	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2053	27	"	"	''
18637	2053	28	and	and	CC
18637	2053	29	lists	list	NNS
18637	2053	30	among	among	IN
18637	2053	31	these	these	DT
18637	2053	32	"	"	``
18637	2053	33	the	the	DT
18637	2053	34	denial	denial	NN
18637	2053	35	by	by	IN
18637	2053	36	employers	employer	NNS
18637	2053	37	of	of	IN
18637	2053	38	the	the	DT
18637	2053	39	right	right	NN
18637	2053	40	of	of	IN
18637	2053	41	employees	employee	NNS
18637	2053	42	to	to	TO
18637	2053	43	organize	organize	VB
18637	2053	44	and	and	CC
18637	2053	45	the	the	DT
18637	2053	46	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	2053	47	by	by	IN
18637	2053	48	employers	employer	NNS
18637	2053	49	to	to	TO
18637	2053	50	accept	accept	VB
18637	2053	51	the	the	DT
18637	2053	52	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	2053	53	of	of	IN
18637	2053	54	collective	collective	JJ
18637	2053	55	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	2053	56	.	.	.
18637	2053	57	"	"	''
18637	2054	1	Ignoring	ignore	VBG
18637	2054	2	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2054	3	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	2054	4	,	,	,
18637	2054	5	government	government	NN
18637	2054	6	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	2054	7	appealed	appeal	VBD
18637	2054	8	to	to	IN
18637	2054	9	the	the	DT
18637	2054	10	"	"	``
18637	2054	11	current	current	NN
18637	2054	12	of	of	IN
18637	2054	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2054	14	"	"	''
18637	2054	15	concept	concept	NN
18637	2054	16	of	of	IN
18637	2054	17	the	the	DT
18637	2054	18	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	2054	19	Case	Case	NNP
18637	2054	20	.	.	.
18637	2055	1	The	the	DT
18637	2055	2	scope	scope	NN
18637	2055	3	of	of	IN
18637	2055	4	respondent	respondent	NN
18637	2055	5	's	's	POS
18637	2055	6	activities	activity	NNS
18637	2055	7	,	,	,
18637	2055	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2055	9	pointed	point	VBD
18637	2055	10	out	out	RP
18637	2055	11	,	,	,
18637	2055	12	was	be	VBD
18637	2055	13	immense	immense	JJ
18637	2055	14	.	.	.
18637	2056	1	Besides	besides	IN
18637	2056	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2056	3	great	great	JJ
18637	2056	4	steel	steel	NN
18637	2056	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	2056	6	producing	produce	VBG
18637	2056	7	plants	plant	NNS
18637	2056	8	,	,	,
18637	2056	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2056	10	owned	own	VBD
18637	2056	11	and	and	CC
18637	2056	12	operated	operate	VBN
18637	2056	13	mines	mine	NNS
18637	2056	14	,	,	,
18637	2056	15	steamships	steamship	NNS
18637	2056	16	,	,	,
18637	2056	17	and	and	CC
18637	2056	18	terminal	terminal	JJ
18637	2056	19	railways	railway	NNS
18637	2056	20	scattered	scatter	VBN
18637	2056	21	through	through	IN
18637	2056	22	several	several	JJ
18637	2056	23	States	state	NNS
18637	2056	24	,	,	,
18637	2056	25	and	and	CC
18637	2056	26	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	2056	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2056	28	gave	give	VBD
18637	2056	29	employment	employment	NN
18637	2056	30	to	to	IN
18637	2056	31	many	many	JJ
18637	2056	32	thousands	thousand	NNS
18637	2056	33	of	of	IN
18637	2056	34	workers	worker	NNS
18637	2056	35	.	.	.
18637	2057	1	A	a	DT
18637	2057	2	vast	vast	JJ
18637	2057	3	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	2057	4	commonwealth	commonwealth	NN
18637	2057	5	such	such	JJ
18637	2057	6	as	as	IN
18637	2057	7	this	this	DT
18637	2057	8	,	,	,
18637	2057	9	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2057	10	operations	operation	NNS
18637	2057	11	constantly	constantly	RB
18637	2057	12	traversed	traverse	VBD
18637	2057	13	State	state	NN
18637	2057	14	lines	line	NNS
18637	2057	15	,	,	,
18637	2057	16	comprised	comprise	VBN
18637	2057	17	,	,	,
18637	2057	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2057	19	contended	contend	VBD
18637	2057	20	,	,	,
18637	2057	21	a	a	DT
18637	2057	22	species	species	NN
18637	2057	23	of	of	IN
18637	2057	24	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	2057	25	enclave	enclave	NN
18637	2057	26	which	which	WDT
18637	2057	27	was	be	VBD
18637	2057	28	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2057	29	in	in	IN
18637	2057	30	all	all	DT
18637	2057	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2057	32	parts	part	NNS
18637	2057	33	to	to	IN
18637	2057	34	the	the	DT
18637	2057	35	only	only	JJ
18637	2057	36	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	2057	37	power	power	NN
18637	2057	38	capable	capable	JJ
18637	2057	39	of	of	IN
18637	2057	40	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	2057	41	with	with	IN
18637	2057	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2057	43	as	as	IN
18637	2057	44	an	an	DT
18637	2057	45	entity	entity	NN
18637	2057	46	,	,	,
18637	2057	47	that	that	RB
18637	2057	48	is	is	RB
18637	2057	49	,	,	,
18637	2057	50	the	the	DT
18637	2057	51	National	National	NNP
18637	2057	52	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2057	53	.	.	.
18637	2058	1	Yet	yet	RB
18637	2058	2	even	even	RB
18637	2058	3	if	if	IN
18637	2058	4	this	this	DT
18637	2058	5	were	be	VBD
18637	2058	6	not	not	RB
18637	2058	7	so	so	RB
18637	2058	8	,	,	,
18637	2058	9	still	still	RB
18637	2058	10	the	the	DT
18637	2058	11	protective	protective	JJ
18637	2058	12	power	power	NN
18637	2058	13	of	of	IN
18637	2058	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2058	15	over	over	IN
18637	2058	16	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2058	17	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2058	18	must	must	MD
18637	2058	19	be	be	VB
18637	2058	20	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	2058	21	to	to	TO
18637	2058	22	extend	extend	VB
18637	2058	23	to	to	TO
18637	2058	24	disruptive	disruptive	VB
18637	2058	25	strikes	strike	NNS
18637	2058	26	by	by	IN
18637	2058	27	employees	employee	NNS
18637	2058	28	of	of	IN
18637	2058	29	such	such	PDT
18637	2058	30	an	an	DT
18637	2058	31	immense	immense	JJ
18637	2058	32	concern	concern	NN
18637	2058	33	,	,	,
18637	2058	34	and	and	CC
18637	2058	35	hence	hence	RB
18637	2058	36	to	to	TO
18637	2058	37	include	include	VB
18637	2058	38	power	power	NN
18637	2058	39	to	to	TO
18637	2058	40	remove	remove	VB
18637	2058	41	the	the	DT
18637	2058	42	causes	cause	NNS
18637	2058	43	of	of	IN
18637	2058	44	such	such	JJ
18637	2058	45	strikes	strike	NNS
18637	2058	46	.	.	.
18637	2059	1	The	the	DT
18637	2059	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2059	3	,	,	,
18637	2059	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2059	5	through	through	IN
18637	2059	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2059	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2059	8	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	2059	9	,	,	,
18637	2059	10	held	hold	VBD
18637	2059	11	the	the	DT
18637	2059	12	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2059	13	to	to	TO
18637	2059	14	be	be	VB
18637	2059	15	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2059	16	to	to	IN
18637	2059	17	the	the	DT
18637	2059	18	act	act	NN
18637	2059	19	on	on	IN
18637	2059	20	the	the	DT
18637	2059	21	latter	latter	JJ
18637	2059	22	ground	ground	NN
18637	2059	23	.	.	.
18637	2060	1	"	"	``
18637	2060	2	The	the	DT
18637	2060	3	close	close	JJ
18637	2060	4	and	and	CC
18637	2060	5	intimate	intimate	JJ
18637	2060	6	effect	effect	NN
18637	2060	7	,	,	,
18637	2060	8	"	"	''
18637	2060	9	said	say	VBD
18637	2060	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2060	11	,	,	,
18637	2060	12	"	"	``
18637	2060	13	which	which	WDT
18637	2060	14	brings	bring	VBZ
18637	2060	15	the	the	DT
18637	2060	16	subject	subject	NN
18637	2060	17	within	within	IN
18637	2060	18	the	the	DT
18637	2060	19	reach	reach	NN
18637	2060	20	of	of	IN
18637	2060	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2060	22	power	power	NN
18637	2060	23	may	may	MD
18637	2060	24	be	be	VB
18637	2060	25	due	due	IN
18637	2060	26	to	to	IN
18637	2060	27	activities	activity	NNS
18637	2060	28	in	in	IN
18637	2060	29	relation	relation	NN
18637	2060	30	to	to	TO
18637	2060	31	productive	productive	JJ
18637	2060	32	industry	industry	NN
18637	2060	33	although	although	IN
18637	2060	34	the	the	DT
18637	2060	35	industry	industry	NN
18637	2060	36	when	when	WRB
18637	2060	37	separately	separately	RB
18637	2060	38	viewed	view	VBN
18637	2060	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	2060	40	local	local	JJ
18637	2060	41	.	.	.
18637	2060	42	"	"	''
18637	2061	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	2061	2	will	will	MD
18637	2061	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2061	4	do	do	VB
18637	2061	5	to	to	TO
18637	2061	6	say	say	VB
18637	2061	7	that	that	IN
18637	2061	8	such	such	JJ
18637	2061	9	effect	effect	NN
18637	2061	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	2061	11	"	"	``
18637	2061	12	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	2061	13	.	.	.
18637	2061	14	"	"	''
18637	2062	1	Considering	consider	VBG
18637	2062	2	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	2062	3	's	's	POS
18637	2062	4	"	"	``
18637	2062	5	far	far	RB
18637	2062	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	2062	7	flung	flung	JJ
18637	2062	8	activities	activity	NNS
18637	2062	9	,	,	,
18637	2062	10	"	"	''
18637	2062	11	the	the	DT
18637	2062	12	effect	effect	NN
18637	2062	13	of	of	IN
18637	2062	14	strife	strife	NN
18637	2062	15	between	between	IN
18637	2062	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2062	17	and	and	CC
18637	2062	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2062	19	employees	employee	NNS
18637	2062	20	"	"	''
18637	2062	21	*	*	NFP
18637	2062	22	*	*	NFP
18637	2062	23	*	*	NFP
18637	2062	24	would	would	MD
18637	2062	25	be	be	VB
18637	2062	26	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	2062	27	and	and	CC
18637	2062	28	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2062	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2062	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2062	31	might	may	MD
18637	2062	32	be	be	VB
18637	2062	33	catastrophic	catastrophic	JJ
18637	2062	34	.	.	.
18637	2063	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2063	2	are	be	VBP
18637	2063	3	asked	ask	VBN
18637	2063	4	to	to	TO
18637	2063	5	shut	shut	VB
18637	2063	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2063	7	eyes	eye	NNS
18637	2063	8	to	to	IN
18637	2063	9	the	the	DT
18637	2063	10	plainest	plain	JJS
18637	2063	11	facts	fact	NNS
18637	2063	12	of	of	IN
18637	2063	13	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2063	14	national	national	JJ
18637	2063	15	life	life	NN
18637	2063	16	and	and	CC
18637	2063	17	to	to	TO
18637	2063	18	deal	deal	VB
18637	2063	19	with	with	IN
18637	2063	20	the	the	DT
18637	2063	21	question	question	NN
18637	2063	22	of	of	IN
18637	2063	23	direct	direct	JJ
18637	2063	24	and	and	CC
18637	2063	25	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	2063	26	effects	effect	NNS
18637	2063	27	in	in	IN
18637	2063	28	an	an	DT
18637	2063	29	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
18637	2063	30	vacuum	vacuum	NN
18637	2063	31	.	.	.
18637	2064	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2064	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2064	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2064	4	When	when	WRB
18637	2064	5	industries	industry	NNS
18637	2064	6	organize	organize	VBP
18637	2064	7	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2064	8	on	on	IN
18637	2064	9	a	a	DT
18637	2064	10	national	national	JJ
18637	2064	11	scale	scale	NN
18637	2064	12	,	,	,
18637	2064	13	making	make	VBG
18637	2064	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2064	15	relation	relation	NN
18637	2064	16	to	to	IN
18637	2064	17	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2064	18	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2064	19	the	the	DT
18637	2064	20	dominant	dominant	JJ
18637	2064	21	factor	factor	NN
18637	2064	22	in	in	IN
18637	2064	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2064	24	activities	activity	NNS
18637	2064	25	,	,	,
18637	2064	26	how	how	WRB
18637	2064	27	can	can	MD
18637	2064	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2064	29	be	be	VB
18637	2064	30	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	2064	31	that	that	IN
18637	2064	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2064	33	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	2064	34	labor	labor	NN
18637	2064	35	relations	relation	NNS
18637	2064	36	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	2064	37	a	a	DT
18637	2064	38	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	2064	39	field	field	NN
18637	2064	40	into	into	IN
18637	2064	41	which	which	WDT
18637	2064	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2064	43	may	may	MD
18637	2064	44	not	not	RB
18637	2064	45	enter	enter	VB
18637	2064	46	when	when	WRB
18637	2064	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2064	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	2064	49	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2064	50	to	to	TO
18637	2064	51	protect	protect	VB
18637	2064	52	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2064	53	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2064	54	from	from	IN
18637	2064	55	the	the	DT
18637	2064	56	paralyzing	paralyze	VBG
18637	2064	57	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	2064	58	of	of	IN
18637	2064	59	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	2064	60	war	war	NN
18637	2064	61	?	?	.
18637	2065	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2065	2	have	have	VBP
18637	2065	3	often	often	RB
18637	2065	4	said	say	VBN
18637	2065	5	that	that	IN
18637	2065	6	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2065	7	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2065	8	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2065	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	2065	10	a	a	DT
18637	2065	11	practical	practical	JJ
18637	2065	12	conception	conception	NN
18637	2065	13	.	.	.
18637	2066	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2066	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2066	3	equally	equally	RB
18637	2066	4	true	true	JJ
18637	2066	5	that	that	IN
18637	2066	6	interferences	interference	NNS
18637	2066	7	with	with	IN
18637	2066	8	that	that	DT
18637	2066	9	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2066	10	must	must	MD
18637	2066	11	be	be	VB
18637	2066	12	appraised	appraise	VBN
18637	2066	13	by	by	IN
18637	2066	14	a	a	DT
18637	2066	15	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	2066	16	that	that	WDT
18637	2066	17	does	do	VBZ
18637	2066	18	not	not	RB
18637	2066	19	ignore	ignore	VB
18637	2066	20	actual	actual	JJ
18637	2066	21	experience	experience	NN
18637	2066	22	.	.	.
18637	2067	1	"	"	``
18637	2067	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2067	3	456	456	CD
18637	2067	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2067	5	While	while	IN
18637	2067	6	the	the	DT
18637	2067	7	act	act	NN
18637	2067	8	was	be	VBD
18637	2067	9	thus	thus	RB
18637	2067	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	2067	11	to	to	TO
18637	2067	12	be	be	VB
18637	2067	13	within	within	IN
18637	2067	14	the	the	DT
18637	2067	15	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2067	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	2067	17	of	of	IN
18637	2067	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2067	19	in	in	IN
18637	2067	20	relation	relation	NN
18637	2067	21	to	to	IN
18637	2067	22	a	a	DT
18637	2067	23	productive	productive	JJ
18637	2067	24	concern	concern	NN
18637	2067	25	,	,	,
18637	2067	26	the	the	DT
18637	2067	27	interruption	interruption	NN
18637	2067	28	of	of	IN
18637	2067	29	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2067	30	business	business	NN
18637	2067	31	by	by	IN
18637	2067	32	strike	strike	NN
18637	2067	33	"	"	''
18637	2067	34	might	may	MD
18637	2067	35	be	be	VB
18637	2067	36	catastrophic	catastrophic	JJ
18637	2067	37	,	,	,
18637	2067	38	"	"	''
18637	2067	39	the	the	DT
18637	2067	40	decision	decision	NN
18637	2067	41	was	be	VBD
18637	2067	42	forthwith	forthwith	NNP
18637	2067	43	held	hold	VBN
18637	2067	44	to	to	TO
18637	2067	45	apply	apply	VB
18637	2067	46	also	also	RB
18637	2067	47	to	to	IN
18637	2067	48	two	two	CD
18637	2067	49	minor	minor	JJ
18637	2067	50	concerns;[457	concerns;[457	NNS
18637	2067	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2067	52	and	and	CC
18637	2067	53	in	in	IN
18637	2067	54	a	a	DT
18637	2067	55	later	later	JJ
18637	2067	56	case	case	NN
18637	2067	57	the	the	DT
18637	2067	58	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2067	59	stated	state	VBD
18637	2067	60	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	2067	61	that	that	IN
18637	2067	62	"	"	``
18637	2067	63	the	the	DT
18637	2067	64	smallness	smallness	NN
18637	2067	65	of	of	IN
18637	2067	66	the	the	DT
18637	2067	67	volume	volume	NN
18637	2067	68	of	of	IN
18637	2067	69	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2067	70	affected	affect	VBN
18637	2067	71	in	in	IN
18637	2067	72	any	any	DT
18637	2067	73	particular	particular	JJ
18637	2067	74	case	case	NN
18637	2067	75	"	"	``
18637	2067	76	is	be	VBZ
18637	2067	77	not	not	RB
18637	2067	78	a	a	DT
18637	2067	79	material	material	JJ
18637	2067	80	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	2067	81	.	.	.
18637	2068	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2068	2	458	458	CD
18637	2068	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2068	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	2068	5	,	,	,
18637	2068	6	the	the	DT
18637	2068	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2068	8	of	of	IN
18637	2068	9	the	the	DT
18637	2068	10	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	2068	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	2068	12	Laughlin	Laughlin	NNP
18637	2068	13	Case	Case	NNP
18637	2068	14	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	2068	15	equally	equally	RB
18637	2068	16	to	to	IN
18637	2068	17	"	"	``
18637	2068	18	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2068	19	"	"	''
18637	2068	20	products	product	NNS
18637	2068	21	,	,	,
18637	2068	22	to	to	IN
18637	2068	23	coal	coal	NN
18637	2068	24	mined	mine	VBN
18637	2068	25	,	,	,
18637	2068	26	to	to	TO
18637	2068	27	stone	stone	VB
18637	2068	28	quarried	quarry	VBD
18637	2068	29	,	,	,
18637	2068	30	to	to	IN
18637	2068	31	fruit	fruit	NN
18637	2068	32	and	and	CC
18637	2068	33	vegetables	vegetable	NNS
18637	2068	34	grown	grow	VBN
18637	2068	35	.	.	.
18637	2069	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2069	2	459	459	CD
18637	2069	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2069	4	THE	the	DT
18637	2069	5	FAIR	FAIR	NNP
18637	2069	6	LABOR	LABOR	NNP
18637	2069	7	STANDARDS	STANDARDS	NNP
18637	2069	8	ACT	ACT	NNP
18637	2069	9	;	;	:
18637	2069	10	THE	the	DT
18637	2069	11	DARBY	DARBY	NNP
18637	2069	12	CASE	case	NN
18637	2069	13	In	in	IN
18637	2069	14	1938	1938	CD
18637	2069	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2069	16	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	2069	17	the	the	DT
18637	2069	18	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	2069	19	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	2069	20	Standards	Standards	NNP
18637	2069	21	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2069	22	.	.	.
18637	2070	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2070	2	460	460	CD
18637	2070	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2070	4	The	the	DT
18637	2070	5	measure	measure	NN
18637	2070	6	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	2070	7	not	not	RB
18637	2070	8	only	only	RB
18637	2070	9	the	the	DT
18637	2070	10	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2070	11	in	in	IN
18637	2070	12	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2070	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2070	14	of	of	IN
18637	2070	15	goods	good	NNS
18637	2070	16	manufactured	manufacture	VBN
18637	2070	17	by	by	IN
18637	2070	18	employees	employee	NNS
18637	2070	19	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2070	20	wages	wage	NNS
18637	2070	21	are	be	VBP
18637	2070	22	less	less	JJR
18637	2070	23	than	than	IN
18637	2070	24	the	the	DT
18637	2070	25	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	2070	26	minimum	minimum	NN
18637	2070	27	or	or	CC
18637	2070	28	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2070	29	weekly	weekly	JJ
18637	2070	30	hours	hour	NNS
18637	2070	31	of	of	IN
18637	2070	32	labor	labor	NN
18637	2070	33	are	be	VBP
18637	2070	34	greater	great	JJR
18637	2070	35	than	than	IN
18637	2070	36	the	the	DT
18637	2070	37	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	2070	38	maximum	maximum	NN
18637	2070	39	,	,	,
18637	2070	40	but	but	CC
18637	2070	41	also	also	RB
18637	2070	42	the	the	DT
18637	2070	43	employment	employment	NN
18637	2070	44	of	of	IN
18637	2070	45	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	2070	46	in	in	IN
18637	2070	47	the	the	DT
18637	2070	48	production	production	NN
18637	2070	49	of	of	IN
18637	2070	50	goods	good	NNS
18637	2070	51	for	for	IN
18637	2070	52	such	such	JJ
18637	2070	53	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2070	54	at	at	IN
18637	2070	55	other	other	JJ
18637	2070	56	than	than	IN
18637	2070	57	the	the	DT
18637	2070	58	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	2070	59	wages	wage	NNS
18637	2070	60	and	and	CC
18637	2070	61	hours	hour	NNS
18637	2070	62	.	.	.
18637	2071	1	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2071	2	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2071	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	2071	4	defined	define	VBN
18637	2071	5	by	by	IN
18637	2071	6	the	the	DT
18637	2071	7	act	act	NN
18637	2071	8	to	to	TO
18637	2071	9	mean	mean	VB
18637	2071	10	"	"	``
18637	2071	11	trade	trade	NN
18637	2071	12	,	,	,
18637	2071	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2071	14	,	,	,
18637	2071	15	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2071	16	,	,	,
18637	2071	17	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	2071	18	,	,	,
18637	2071	19	or	or	CC
18637	2071	20	communication	communication	NN
18637	2071	21	among	among	IN
18637	2071	22	the	the	DT
18637	2071	23	several	several	JJ
18637	2071	24	States	state	NNS
18637	2071	25	or	or	CC
18637	2071	26	from	from	IN
18637	2071	27	any	any	DT
18637	2071	28	State	State	NNP
18637	2071	29	to	to	IN
18637	2071	30	any	any	DT
18637	2071	31	place	place	NN
18637	2071	32	outside	outside	IN
18637	2071	33	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	2071	34	.	.	.
18637	2071	35	"	"	''
18637	2072	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2072	2	was	be	VBD
18637	2072	3	further	further	RB
18637	2072	4	provided	provide	VBN
18637	2072	5	that	that	IN
18637	2072	6	"	"	``
18637	2072	7	for	for	IN
18637	2072	8	the	the	DT
18637	2072	9	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	2072	10	of	of	IN
18637	2072	11	this	this	DT
18637	2072	12	act	act	NN
18637	2072	13	an	an	DT
18637	2072	14	employee	employee	NN
18637	2072	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	2072	16	be	be	VB
18637	2072	17	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	2072	18	to	to	TO
18637	2072	19	have	have	VB
18637	2072	20	been	be	VBN
18637	2072	21	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2072	22	in	in	IN
18637	2072	23	the	the	DT
18637	2072	24	production	production	NN
18637	2072	25	of	of	IN
18637	2072	26	goods	good	NNS
18637	2072	27	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2072	28	that	that	RB
18637	2072	29	is	is	RB
18637	2072	30	,	,	,
18637	2072	31	for	for	IN
18637	2072	32	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2072	33	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2072	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2072	35	if	if	IN
18637	2072	36	such	such	JJ
18637	2072	37	employee	employee	NN
18637	2072	38	was	be	VBD
18637	2072	39	employed	employ	VBN
18637	2072	40	*	*	NFP
18637	2072	41	*	*	NFP
18637	2072	42	*	*	NFP
18637	2072	43	,	,	,
18637	2072	44	or	or	CC
18637	2072	45	in	in	IN
18637	2072	46	any	any	DT
18637	2072	47	process	process	NN
18637	2072	48	or	or	CC
18637	2072	49	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	2072	50	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2072	51	to	to	IN
18637	2072	52	the	the	DT
18637	2072	53	production	production	NN
18637	2072	54	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	2072	55	,	,	,
18637	2072	56	in	in	IN
18637	2072	57	any	any	DT
18637	2072	58	State	State	NNP
18637	2072	59	.	.	.
18637	2072	60	"	"	''
18637	2073	1	Sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	2073	2	an	an	DT
18637	2073	3	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	2073	4	under	under	IN
18637	2073	5	the	the	DT
18637	2073	6	act	act	NN
18637	2073	7	,	,	,
18637	2073	8	a	a	DT
18637	2073	9	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	2073	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2073	11	,	,	,
18637	2073	12	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2073	13	by	by	IN
18637	2073	14	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2073	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2073	16	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	2073	17	,	,	,
18637	2073	18	said	say	VBD
18637	2073	19	:	:	:
18637	2073	20	"	"	``
18637	2073	21	The	the	DT
18637	2073	22	motive	motive	NN
18637	2073	23	and	and	CC
18637	2073	24	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2073	25	of	of	IN
18637	2073	26	the	the	DT
18637	2073	27	present	present	JJ
18637	2073	28	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2073	29	are	be	VBP
18637	2073	30	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	2073	31	to	to	TO
18637	2073	32	make	make	VB
18637	2073	33	effective	effective	JJ
18637	2073	34	the	the	DT
18637	2073	35	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2073	36	conception	conception	NN
18637	2073	37	of	of	IN
18637	2073	38	public	public	JJ
18637	2073	39	policy	policy	NN
18637	2073	40	that	that	WDT
18637	2073	41	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2073	42	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2073	43	should	should	MD
18637	2073	44	not	not	RB
18637	2073	45	be	be	VB
18637	2073	46	made	make	VBN
18637	2073	47	the	the	DT
18637	2073	48	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	2073	49	of	of	IN
18637	2073	50	competition	competition	NN
18637	2073	51	in	in	IN
18637	2073	52	the	the	DT
18637	2073	53	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	2073	54	of	of	IN
18637	2073	55	goods	good	NNS
18637	2073	56	produced	produce	VBN
18637	2073	57	under	under	IN
18637	2073	58	substandard	substandard	JJ
18637	2073	59	labor	labor	NN
18637	2073	60	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2073	61	,	,	,
18637	2073	62	which	which	WDT
18637	2073	63	competition	competition	NN
18637	2073	64	is	be	VBZ
18637	2073	65	injurious	injurious	JJ
18637	2073	66	to	to	IN
18637	2073	67	the	the	DT
18637	2073	68	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2073	69	and	and	CC
18637	2073	70	to	to	IN
18637	2073	71	the	the	DT
18637	2073	72	States	States	NNPS
18637	2073	73	from	from	IN
18637	2073	74	and	and	CC
18637	2073	75	to	to	TO
18637	2073	76	which	which	WDT
18637	2073	77	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2073	78	flows	flow	NNS
18637	2073	79	.	.	.
18637	2074	1	"	"	``
18637	2074	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2074	3	461	461	CD
18637	2074	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2074	5	In	in	IN
18637	2074	6	support	support	NN
18637	2074	7	of	of	IN
18637	2074	8	the	the	DT
18637	2074	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	2074	10	the	the	DT
18637	2074	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2074	12	invokes	invoke	VBZ
18637	2074	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2074	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2074	15	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2074	16	's	's	POS
18637	2074	17	reading	reading	NN
18637	2074	18	of	of	IN
18637	2074	19	the	the	DT
18637	2074	20	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2074	21	and	and	CC
18637	2074	22	proper	proper	JJ
18637	2074	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	2074	24	in	in	IN
18637	2074	25	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	2074	26	_	_	NNP
18637	2074	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	2074	28	_	_	NNP
18637	2074	29	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	2074	30	and	and	CC
18637	2074	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2074	32	reading	reading	NN
18637	2074	33	of	of	IN
18637	2074	34	the	the	DT
18637	2074	35	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2074	36	clause	clause	NN
18637	2074	37	in	in	IN
18637	2074	38	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	2074	39	_	_	NNP
18637	2074	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	2074	41	_	_	NNP
18637	2074	42	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	2074	43	.	.	.
18637	2075	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2075	2	462	462	CD
18637	2075	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2075	4	Objections	objection	NNS
18637	2075	5	purporting	purporting	NN
18637	2075	6	to	to	TO
18637	2075	7	be	be	VB
18637	2075	8	based	base	VBN
18637	2075	9	on	on	IN
18637	2075	10	the	the	DT
18637	2075	11	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	2075	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	2075	13	are	be	VBP
18637	2075	14	met	meet	VBN
18637	2075	15	from	from	IN
18637	2075	16	the	the	DT
18637	2075	17	same	same	JJ
18637	2075	18	point	point	NN
18637	2075	19	of	of	IN
18637	2075	20	view	view	NN
18637	2075	21	:	:	:
18637	2075	22	"	"	``
18637	2075	23	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2075	24	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	2075	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	2075	26	unaffected	unaffected	JJ
18637	2075	27	by	by	IN
18637	2075	28	the	the	DT
18637	2075	29	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	2075	30	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	2075	31	which	which	WDT
18637	2075	32	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	2075	33	:	:	:
18637	2075	34	'	'	''
18637	2075	35	The	the	DT
18637	2075	36	powers	power	NNS
18637	2075	37	not	not	RB
18637	2075	38	delegated	delegate	VBD
18637	2075	39	to	to	IN
18637	2075	40	the	the	DT
18637	2075	41	United	United	NNP
18637	2075	42	States	States	NNP
18637	2075	43	by	by	IN
18637	2075	44	the	the	DT
18637	2075	45	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2075	46	,	,	,
18637	2075	47	nor	nor	CC
18637	2075	48	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	2075	49	by	by	IN
18637	2075	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2075	51	to	to	IN
18637	2075	52	the	the	DT
18637	2075	53	States	States	NNP
18637	2075	54	,	,	,
18637	2075	55	are	be	VBP
18637	2075	56	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	2075	57	to	to	IN
18637	2075	58	the	the	DT
18637	2075	59	States	States	NNP
18637	2075	60	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	2075	61	,	,	,
18637	2075	62	or	or	CC
18637	2075	63	to	to	IN
18637	2075	64	the	the	DT
18637	2075	65	people	people	NNS
18637	2075	66	.	.	.
18637	2075	67	'	'	''
18637	2076	1	The	the	DT
18637	2076	2	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	2076	3	states	state	NNS
18637	2076	4	but	but	CC
18637	2076	5	a	a	DT
18637	2076	6	truism	truism	NN
18637	2076	7	that	that	WDT
18637	2076	8	all	all	DT
18637	2076	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	2076	10	retained	retain	VBN
18637	2076	11	which	which	WDT
18637	2076	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	2076	13	not	not	RB
18637	2076	14	been	be	VBN
18637	2076	15	surrendered	surrender	VBN
18637	2076	16	.	.	.
18637	2077	1	There	there	EX
18637	2077	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2077	3	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	2077	4	in	in	IN
18637	2077	5	the	the	DT
18637	2077	6	history	history	NN
18637	2077	7	of	of	IN
18637	2077	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2077	9	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	2077	10	to	to	TO
18637	2077	11	suggest	suggest	VB
18637	2077	12	that	that	IN
18637	2077	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2077	14	was	be	VBD
18637	2077	15	more	more	JJR
18637	2077	16	than	than	IN
18637	2077	17	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	2077	18	of	of	IN
18637	2077	19	the	the	DT
18637	2077	20	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	2077	21	between	between	IN
18637	2077	22	the	the	DT
18637	2077	23	national	national	JJ
18637	2077	24	and	and	CC
18637	2077	25	State	State	NNP
18637	2077	26	governments	government	NNS
18637	2077	27	as	as	IN
18637	2077	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2077	29	had	have	VBD
18637	2077	30	been	be	VBN
18637	2077	31	established	establish	VBN
18637	2077	32	by	by	IN
18637	2077	33	the	the	DT
18637	2077	34	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2077	35	before	before	IN
18637	2077	36	the	the	DT
18637	2077	37	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	2077	38	or	or	CC
18637	2077	39	that	that	IN
18637	2077	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2077	41	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2077	42	was	be	VBD
18637	2077	43	other	other	JJ
18637	2077	44	than	than	IN
18637	2077	45	to	to	TO
18637	2077	46	allay	allay	VB
18637	2077	47	fears	fear	NNS
18637	2077	48	that	that	IN
18637	2077	49	the	the	DT
18637	2077	50	new	new	JJ
18637	2077	51	National	National	NNP
18637	2077	52	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2077	53	might	may	MD
18637	2077	54	seek	seek	VB
18637	2077	55	to	to	TO
18637	2077	56	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	2077	57	powers	power	NNS
18637	2077	58	not	not	RB
18637	2077	59	granted	grant	VBN
18637	2077	60	,	,	,
18637	2077	61	and	and	CC
18637	2077	62	that	that	IN
18637	2077	63	the	the	DT
18637	2077	64	States	States	NNPS
18637	2077	65	might	may	MD
18637	2077	66	not	not	RB
18637	2077	67	be	be	VB
18637	2077	68	able	able	JJ
18637	2077	69	to	to	TO
18637	2077	70	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	2077	71	fully	fully	RB
18637	2077	72	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2077	73	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	2077	74	powers	power	NNS
18637	2077	75	.	.	.
18637	2078	1	_	_	NNP
18637	2078	2	See	See	NNP
18637	2078	3	_	_	NNP
18637	2078	4	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	2078	5	,	,	,
18637	2078	6	II	II	NNP
18637	2078	7	Elliot	Elliot	NNP
18637	2078	8	's	's	POS
18637	2078	9	Debates	debate	NNS
18637	2078	10	,	,	,
18637	2078	11	123	123	CD
18637	2078	12	,	,	,
18637	2078	13	131	131	CD
18637	2078	14	;	;	:
18637	2078	15	III	III	NNP
18637	2078	16	i	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2078	17	d	d	VBN
18637	2078	18	.	.	.
18637	2079	1	450	450	CD
18637	2079	2	,	,	,
18637	2079	3	464	464	CD
18637	2079	4	,	,	,
18637	2079	5	600	600	CD
18637	2079	6	;	;	:
18637	2079	7	IV	IV	NNP
18637	2079	8	i	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2079	9	d	d	NN
18637	2079	10	.	.	.
18637	2080	1	140	140	CD
18637	2080	2	,	,	,
18637	2080	3	149	149	CD
18637	2080	4	;	;	:
18637	2080	5	I	I	NNP
18637	2080	6	Annals	Annals	NNPS
18637	2080	7	of	of	IN
18637	2080	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2080	9	,	,	,
18637	2080	10	432	432	CD
18637	2080	11	,	,	,
18637	2080	12	761	761	CD
18637	2080	13	,	,	,
18637	2080	14	767	767	CD
18637	2080	15	-	-	SYM
18637	2080	16	768	768	CD
18637	2080	17	;	;	:
18637	2080	18	Story	story	NN
18637	2080	19	,	,	,
18637	2080	20	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	2080	21	on	on	IN
18637	2080	22	the	the	DT
18637	2080	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2080	24	,	,	,
18637	2080	25	§§	â§â§	XX
18637	2080	26	1907	1907	CD
18637	2080	27	-	-	SYM
18637	2080	28	1908	1908	CD
18637	2080	29	.	.	.
18637	2081	1	"	"	``
18637	2081	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2081	3	463	463	CD
18637	2081	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2081	5	Commenting	comment	VBG
18637	2081	6	recently	recently	RB
18637	2081	7	on	on	IN
18637	2081	8	this	this	DT
18637	2081	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	2081	10	,	,	,
18637	2081	11	former	former	JJ
18637	2081	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2081	13	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	2081	14	said	say	VBD
18637	2081	15	:	:	:
18637	2081	16	"	"	``
18637	2081	17	Of	of	RB
18637	2081	18	course	course	RB
18637	2081	19	,	,	,
18637	2081	20	the	the	DT
18637	2081	21	effect	effect	NN
18637	2081	22	of	of	IN
18637	2081	23	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	2081	24	the	the	DT
18637	2081	25	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	2081	26	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	2081	27	Standards	Standards	NNP
18637	2081	28	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2081	29	was	be	VBD
18637	2081	30	to	to	TO
18637	2081	31	place	place	VB
18637	2081	32	the	the	DT
18637	2081	33	whole	whole	JJ
18637	2081	34	matter	matter	NN
18637	2081	35	of	of	IN
18637	2081	36	wages	wage	NNS
18637	2081	37	and	and	CC
18637	2081	38	hours	hour	NNS
18637	2081	39	of	of	IN
18637	2081	40	persons	person	NNS
18637	2081	41	employed	employ	VBN
18637	2081	42	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	2081	43	the	the	DT
18637	2081	44	United	United	NNP
18637	2081	45	States	States	NNP
18637	2081	46	,	,	,
18637	2081	47	with	with	IN
18637	2081	48	slight	slight	JJ
18637	2081	49	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	2081	50	,	,	,
18637	2081	51	under	under	IN
18637	2081	52	a	a	DT
18637	2081	53	single	single	JJ
18637	2081	54	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2081	55	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	2081	56	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	2081	57	and	and	CC
18637	2081	58	in	in	IN
18637	2081	59	this	this	DT
18637	2081	60	way	way	NN
18637	2081	61	completely	completely	RB
18637	2081	62	to	to	TO
18637	2081	63	supersede	supersede	VB
18637	2081	64	state	state	NN
18637	2081	65	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2081	66	of	of	IN
18637	2081	67	the	the	DT
18637	2081	68	police	police	NN
18637	2081	69	power	power	NN
18637	2081	70	in	in	IN
18637	2081	71	this	this	DT
18637	2081	72	field	field	NN
18637	2081	73	.	.	.
18637	2082	1	"	"	``
18637	2082	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2082	3	464	464	CD
18637	2082	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2082	5	In	in	IN
18637	2082	6	a	a	DT
18637	2082	7	series	series	NN
18637	2082	8	of	of	IN
18637	2082	9	later	later	JJ
18637	2082	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	2082	11	construing	construe	VBG
18637	2082	12	terms	term	NNS
18637	2082	13	of	of	IN
18637	2082	14	the	the	DT
18637	2082	15	act	act	NN
18637	2082	16	,	,	,
18637	2082	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2082	18	had	have	VBD
18637	2082	19	been	be	VBN
18637	2082	20	given	give	VBN
18637	2082	21	wide	wide	JJ
18637	2082	22	application	application	NN
18637	2082	23	.	.	.
18637	2083	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2083	2	465	465	CD
18637	2083	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2083	4	THE	the	DT
18637	2083	5	AGRICULTURAL	AGRICULTURAL	NNP
18637	2083	6	MARKETING	MARKETING	NNP
18637	2083	7	AGREEMENT	AGREEMENT	NNP
18637	2083	8	ACT	ACT	NNP
18637	2083	9	Meantime	Meantime	NNP
18637	2083	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2083	11	had	have	VBD
18637	2083	12	returned	return	VBN
18637	2083	13	to	to	IN
18637	2083	14	the	the	DT
18637	2083	15	task	task	NN
18637	2083	16	of	of	IN
18637	2083	17	bolstering	bolster	VBG
18637	2083	18	agriculture	agriculture	NN
18637	2083	19	by	by	IN
18637	2083	20	passing	pass	VBG
18637	2083	21	the	the	DT
18637	2083	22	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	2083	23	Marketing	Marketing	NNP
18637	2083	24	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	2083	25	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2083	26	of	of	IN
18637	2083	27	June	June	NNP
18637	2083	28	3	3	CD
18637	2083	29	,	,	,
18637	2083	30	1937,[466	1937,[466	NNP
18637	2083	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2083	32	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	2083	33	the	the	DT
18637	2083	34	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	2083	35	of	of	IN
18637	2083	36	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	2083	37	to	to	TO
18637	2083	38	fix	fix	VB
18637	2083	39	the	the	DT
18637	2083	40	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	2083	41	prices	price	NNS
18637	2083	42	of	of	IN
18637	2083	43	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2083	44	agricultural	agricultural	JJ
18637	2083	45	products	product	NNS
18637	2083	46	,	,	,
18637	2083	47	when	when	WRB
18637	2083	48	the	the	DT
18637	2083	49	handling	handling	NN
18637	2083	50	of	of	IN
18637	2083	51	such	such	JJ
18637	2083	52	products	product	NNS
18637	2083	53	occurs	occur	VBZ
18637	2083	54	"	"	``
18637	2083	55	in	in	IN
18637	2083	56	the	the	DT
18637	2083	57	current	current	NN
18637	2083	58	of	of	IN
18637	2083	59	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2083	60	or	or	CC
18637	2083	61	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2083	62	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2083	63	or	or	CC
18637	2083	64	*	*	NFP
18637	2083	65	*	*	NFP
18637	2083	66	*	*	NFP
18637	2083	67	directly	directly	RB
18637	2083	68	burdens	burden	VBZ
18637	2083	69	,	,	,
18637	2083	70	obstructs	obstruct	NNS
18637	2083	71	or	or	CC
18637	2083	72	affects	affect	VBZ
18637	2083	73	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2083	74	or	or	CC
18637	2083	75	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2083	76	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2083	77	in	in	IN
18637	2083	78	such	such	JJ
18637	2083	79	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	2083	80	or	or	CC
18637	2083	81	product	product	NN
18637	2083	82	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	2083	83	.	.	.
18637	2083	84	"	"	''
18637	2084	1	In	in	IN
18637	2084	2	United	United	NNP
18637	2084	3	States	States	NNP
18637	2084	4	_	_	NNP
18637	2084	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	2084	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2084	7	Wrightwood	Wrightwood	NNP
18637	2084	8	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
18637	2084	9	Company[467	Company[467	NNP
18637	2084	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2084	11	the	the	DT
18637	2084	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2084	13	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	2084	14	an	an	DT
18637	2084	15	order	order	NN
18637	2084	16	of	of	IN
18637	2084	17	the	the	DT
18637	2084	18	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	2084	19	of	of	IN
18637	2084	20	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	2084	21	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	2084	22	the	the	DT
18637	2084	23	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	2084	24	prices	price	NNS
18637	2084	25	to	to	TO
18637	2084	26	be	be	VB
18637	2084	27	paid	pay	VBN
18637	2084	28	to	to	IN
18637	2084	29	producers	producer	NNS
18637	2084	30	of	of	IN
18637	2084	31	milk	milk	NN
18637	2084	32	in	in	IN
18637	2084	33	the	the	DT
18637	2084	34	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	2084	35	"	"	''
18637	2084	36	marketing	marketing	NN
18637	2084	37	area	area	NN
18637	2084	38	.	.	.
18637	2084	39	"	"	''
18637	2085	1	The	the	DT
18637	2085	2	dairy	dairy	NN
18637	2085	3	company	company	NN
18637	2085	4	demurred	demur	VBD
18637	2085	5	to	to	IN
18637	2085	6	the	the	DT
18637	2085	7	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2085	8	on	on	IN
18637	2085	9	the	the	DT
18637	2085	10	ground	ground	NN
18637	2085	11	of	of	IN
18637	2085	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2085	13	applying	applying	NN
18637	2085	14	to	to	IN
18637	2085	15	milk	milk	NN
18637	2085	16	produced	produce	VBN
18637	2085	17	and	and	CC
18637	2085	18	sold	sell	VBN
18637	2085	19	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2085	20	.	.	.
18637	2086	1	Sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	2086	2	the	the	DT
18637	2086	3	order	order	NN
18637	2086	4	the	the	DT
18637	2086	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2086	6	said	say	VBD
18637	2086	7	:	:	:
18637	2086	8	"	"	``
18637	2086	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2086	10	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	2086	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	2086	12	power	power	NN
18637	2086	13	to	to	TO
18637	2086	14	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2086	15	the	the	DT
18637	2086	16	price	price	NN
18637	2086	17	of	of	IN
18637	2086	18	milk	milk	NN
18637	2086	19	distributed	distribute	VBN
18637	2086	20	through	through	IN
18637	2086	21	the	the	DT
18637	2086	22	medium	medium	NN
18637	2086	23	of	of	IN
18637	2086	24	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2086	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2086	26	,	,	,
18637	2086	27	*	*	NFP
18637	2086	28	*	*	NFP
18637	2086	29	*	*	NFP
18637	2086	30	,	,	,
18637	2086	31	and	and	CC
18637	2086	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2086	33	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	2086	34	every	every	DT
18637	2086	35	power	power	NN
18637	2086	36	needed	need	VBN
18637	2086	37	to	to	TO
18637	2086	38	make	make	VB
18637	2086	39	that	that	DT
18637	2086	40	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2086	41	effective	effective	JJ
18637	2086	42	.	.	.
18637	2087	1	The	the	DT
18637	2087	2	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2087	3	power	power	NN
18637	2087	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	2087	5	not	not	RB
18637	2087	6	confined	confine	VBN
18637	2087	7	in	in	IN
18637	2087	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2087	9	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2087	10	to	to	IN
18637	2087	11	the	the	DT
18637	2087	12	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2087	13	of	of	IN
18637	2087	14	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2087	15	among	among	IN
18637	2087	16	the	the	DT
18637	2087	17	States	States	NNP
18637	2087	18	.	.	.
18637	2088	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2088	2	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	2088	3	to	to	IN
18637	2088	4	those	those	DT
18637	2088	5	activities	activity	NNS
18637	2088	6	intrastate	intrastate	VB
18637	2088	7	which	which	WDT
18637	2088	8	so	so	RB
18637	2088	9	affect	affect	VBP
18637	2088	10	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2088	11	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2088	12	,	,	,
18637	2088	13	or	or	CC
18637	2088	14	the	the	DT
18637	2088	15	exertion	exertion	NN
18637	2088	16	of	of	IN
18637	2088	17	the	the	DT
18637	2088	18	power	power	NN
18637	2088	19	of	of	IN
18637	2088	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2088	21	over	over	IN
18637	2088	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2088	23	,	,	,
18637	2088	24	as	as	IN
18637	2088	25	to	to	TO
18637	2088	26	make	make	VB
18637	2088	27	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2088	28	of	of	IN
18637	2088	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2088	30	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	2088	31	means	mean	VBZ
18637	2088	32	to	to	IN
18637	2088	33	the	the	DT
18637	2088	34	attainment	attainment	NN
18637	2088	35	of	of	IN
18637	2088	36	a	a	DT
18637	2088	37	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	2088	38	end	end	NN
18637	2088	39	,	,	,
18637	2088	40	the	the	DT
18637	2088	41	effective	effective	JJ
18637	2088	42	execution	execution	NN
18637	2088	43	of	of	IN
18637	2088	44	the	the	DT
18637	2088	45	granted	grant	VBN
18637	2088	46	power	power	NN
18637	2088	47	to	to	TO
18637	2088	48	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2088	49	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2088	50	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2088	51	.	.	.
18637	2089	1	_	_	NNP
18637	2089	2	See	See	NNP
18637	2089	3	_	_	NNP
18637	2089	4	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	2089	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2089	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	2089	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2089	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	2089	9	,	,	,
18637	2089	10	4	4	CD
18637	2089	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	2089	12	.	.	.
18637	2090	1	316	316	CD
18637	2090	2	,	,	,
18637	2090	3	421	421	CD
18637	2090	4	;	;	:
18637	2090	5	*	*	NFP
18637	2090	6	*	*	NFP
18637	2090	7	*	*	NFP
18637	2090	8	The	the	DT
18637	2090	9	power	power	NN
18637	2090	10	of	of	IN
18637	2090	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2090	12	over	over	IN
18637	2090	13	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2090	14	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2090	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	2090	16	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	2090	17	and	and	CC
18637	2090	18	complete	complete	JJ
18637	2090	19	in	in	IN
18637	2090	20	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2090	21	,	,	,
18637	2090	22	may	may	MD
18637	2090	23	be	be	VB
18637	2090	24	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	2090	25	to	to	IN
18637	2090	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2090	27	utmost	utmost	JJ
18637	2090	28	extent	extent	NN
18637	2090	29	,	,	,
18637	2090	30	and	and	CC
18637	2090	31	acknowledges	acknowledge	VBZ
18637	2090	32	no	no	DT
18637	2090	33	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	2090	34	other	other	JJ
18637	2090	35	than	than	IN
18637	2090	36	are	be	VBP
18637	2090	37	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	2090	38	in	in	IN
18637	2090	39	the	the	DT
18637	2090	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2090	41	.	.	.
18637	2091	1	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	2091	2	_	_	NNP
18637	2091	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	2091	4	_	_	NNP
18637	2091	5	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	2091	6	,	,	,
18637	2091	7	9	9	CD
18637	2091	8	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	2091	9	.	.	.
18637	2092	1	1	1	CD
18637	2092	2	,	,	,
18637	2092	3	196	196	CD
18637	2092	4	.	.	.
18637	2093	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2093	2	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	2093	3	that	that	IN
18637	2093	4	no	no	DT
18637	2093	5	form	form	NN
18637	2093	6	of	of	IN
18637	2093	7	State	state	NN
18637	2093	8	activity	activity	NN
18637	2093	9	can	can	MD
18637	2093	10	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	2093	11	thwart	thwart	VB
18637	2093	12	the	the	DT
18637	2093	13	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	2093	14	power	power	NN
18637	2093	15	granted	grant	VBN
18637	2093	16	by	by	IN
18637	2093	17	the	the	DT
18637	2093	18	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2093	19	clause	clause	NN
18637	2093	20	to	to	IN
18637	2093	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2093	22	.	.	.
18637	2094	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	2094	2	the	the	DT
18637	2094	3	reach	reach	NN
18637	2094	4	of	of	IN
18637	2094	5	that	that	DT
18637	2094	6	power	power	NN
18637	2094	7	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	2094	8	to	to	IN
18637	2094	9	those	those	DT
18637	2094	10	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2094	11	activities	activity	NNS
18637	2094	12	which	which	WDT
18637	2094	13	in	in	IN
18637	2094	14	a	a	DT
18637	2094	15	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	2094	16	way	way	NN
18637	2094	17	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	2094	18	with	with	IN
18637	2094	19	or	or	CC
18637	2094	20	obstruct	obstruct	VB
18637	2094	21	the	the	DT
18637	2094	22	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2094	23	of	of	IN
18637	2094	24	the	the	DT
18637	2094	25	granted	grant	VBN
18637	2094	26	power	power	NN
18637	2094	27	.	.	.
18637	2095	1	"	"	``
18637	2095	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2095	3	468	468	CD
18637	2095	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2095	5	In	in	IN
18637	2095	6	Wickard	Wickard	NNP
18637	2095	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2095	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	2095	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2095	10	Filburn[469	Filburn[469	NNP
18637	2095	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2095	12	a	a	DT
18637	2095	13	still	still	RB
18637	2095	14	deeper	deep	JJR
18637	2095	15	penetration	penetration	NN
18637	2095	16	by	by	IN
18637	2095	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2095	18	into	into	IN
18637	2095	19	the	the	DT
18637	2095	20	field	field	NN
18637	2095	21	of	of	IN
18637	2095	22	production	production	NN
18637	2095	23	was	be	VBD
18637	2095	24	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2095	25	.	.	.
18637	2096	1	As	as	IN
18637	2096	2	amended	amend	VBN
18637	2096	3	by	by	IN
18637	2096	4	the	the	DT
18637	2096	5	act	act	NN
18637	2096	6	of	of	IN
18637	2096	7	1941	1941	CD
18637	2096	8	,	,	,
18637	2096	9	the	the	DT
18637	2096	10	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	2096	11	Adjustment	Adjustment	NNP
18637	2096	12	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2096	13	of	of	IN
18637	2096	14	1938,[470	1938,[470	CD
18637	2096	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2096	16	regulates	regulate	VBZ
18637	2096	17	production	production	NN
18637	2096	18	even	even	RB
18637	2096	19	when	when	WRB
18637	2096	20	not	not	RB
18637	2096	21	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2096	22	for	for	IN
18637	2096	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2096	24	but	but	CC
18637	2096	25	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	2096	26	for	for	IN
18637	2096	27	consumption	consumption	NN
18637	2096	28	on	on	IN
18637	2096	29	the	the	DT
18637	2096	30	producer	producer	NN
18637	2096	31	's	's	POS
18637	2096	32	farm	farm	NN
18637	2096	33	.	.	.
18637	2097	1	Sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	2097	2	this	this	DT
18637	2097	3	extension	extension	NN
18637	2097	4	of	of	IN
18637	2097	5	the	the	DT
18637	2097	6	act	act	NN
18637	2097	7	,	,	,
18637	2097	8	the	the	DT
18637	2097	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2097	10	pointed	point	VBD
18637	2097	11	out	out	RP
18637	2097	12	that	that	IN
18637	2097	13	the	the	DT
18637	2097	14	effect	effect	NN
18637	2097	15	of	of	IN
18637	2097	16	the	the	DT
18637	2097	17	statute	statute	NN
18637	2097	18	was	be	VBD
18637	2097	19	to	to	TO
18637	2097	20	support	support	VB
18637	2097	21	the	the	DT
18637	2097	22	market	market	NN
18637	2097	23	.	.	.
18637	2098	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2098	2	said	say	VBD
18637	2098	3	:	:	:
18637	2098	4	"	"	``
18637	2098	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2098	6	can	can	MD
18637	2098	7	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	2098	8	be	be	VB
18637	2098	9	denied	deny	VBN
18637	2098	10	that	that	IN
18637	2098	11	a	a	DT
18637	2098	12	factor	factor	NN
18637	2098	13	of	of	IN
18637	2098	14	such	such	JJ
18637	2098	15	volume	volume	NN
18637	2098	16	and	and	CC
18637	2098	17	variability	variability	NN
18637	2098	18	as	as	IN
18637	2098	19	home	home	NN
18637	2098	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	2098	21	consumed	consume	VBN
18637	2098	22	wheat	wheat	NN
18637	2098	23	would	would	MD
18637	2098	24	have	have	VB
18637	2098	25	a	a	DT
18637	2098	26	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	2098	27	influence	influence	NN
18637	2098	28	on	on	IN
18637	2098	29	price	price	NN
18637	2098	30	and	and	CC
18637	2098	31	market	market	NN
18637	2098	32	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2098	33	.	.	.
18637	2099	1	This	this	DT
18637	2099	2	may	may	MD
18637	2099	3	arise	arise	VB
18637	2099	4	because	because	IN
18637	2099	5	being	be	VBG
18637	2099	6	in	in	IN
18637	2099	7	marketable	marketable	JJ
18637	2099	8	condition	condition	NN
18637	2099	9	such	such	JJ
18637	2099	10	wheat	wheat	NN
18637	2099	11	overhangs	overhang	VBZ
18637	2099	12	the	the	DT
18637	2099	13	market	market	NN
18637	2099	14	and	and	CC
18637	2099	15	,	,	,
18637	2099	16	if	if	IN
18637	2099	17	induced	induce	VBN
18637	2099	18	by	by	IN
18637	2099	19	rising	rise	VBG
18637	2099	20	prices	price	NNS
18637	2099	21	,	,	,
18637	2099	22	tends	tend	VBZ
18637	2099	23	to	to	TO
18637	2099	24	flow	flow	VB
18637	2099	25	into	into	IN
18637	2099	26	the	the	DT
18637	2099	27	market	market	NN
18637	2099	28	and	and	CC
18637	2099	29	check	check	VB
18637	2099	30	price	price	NN
18637	2099	31	increases	increase	NNS
18637	2099	32	.	.	.
18637	2100	1	But	but	CC
18637	2100	2	if	if	IN
18637	2100	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2100	4	assume	assume	VBP
18637	2100	5	that	that	IN
18637	2100	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2100	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	2100	8	never	never	RB
18637	2100	9	marketed	market	VBN
18637	2100	10	,	,	,
18637	2100	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2100	12	supplies	supply	VBZ
18637	2100	13	a	a	DT
18637	2100	14	need	need	NN
18637	2100	15	of	of	IN
18637	2100	16	the	the	DT
18637	2100	17	man	man	NN
18637	2100	18	who	who	WP
18637	2100	19	grew	grow	VBD
18637	2100	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2100	21	which	which	WDT
18637	2100	22	would	would	MD
18637	2100	23	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2100	24	be	be	VB
18637	2100	25	reflected	reflect	VBN
18637	2100	26	by	by	IN
18637	2100	27	purchases	purchase	NNS
18637	2100	28	in	in	IN
18637	2100	29	the	the	DT
18637	2100	30	open	open	JJ
18637	2100	31	market	market	NN
18637	2100	32	.	.	.
18637	2101	1	Home	home	RB
18637	2101	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	2101	3	grown	grow	VBN
18637	2101	4	wheat	wheat	NN
18637	2101	5	in	in	IN
18637	2101	6	this	this	DT
18637	2101	7	sense	sense	NN
18637	2101	8	competes	compete	VBZ
18637	2101	9	with	with	IN
18637	2101	10	wheat	wheat	NN
18637	2101	11	in	in	IN
18637	2101	12	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2101	13	.	.	.
18637	2102	1	The	the	DT
18637	2102	2	stimulation	stimulation	NN
18637	2102	3	of	of	IN
18637	2102	4	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2102	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	2102	6	a	a	DT
18637	2102	7	use	use	NN
18637	2102	8	of	of	IN
18637	2102	9	the	the	DT
18637	2102	10	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	2102	11	function	function	NN
18637	2102	12	quite	quite	RB
18637	2102	13	as	as	RB
18637	2102	14	definitely	definitely	RB
18637	2102	15	as	as	IN
18637	2102	16	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
18637	2102	17	or	or	CC
18637	2102	18	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	2102	19	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	2102	20	.	.	.
18637	2103	1	This	this	DT
18637	2103	2	record	record	NN
18637	2103	3	leaves	leave	VBZ
18637	2103	4	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2103	5	in	in	IN
18637	2103	6	no	no	DT
18637	2103	7	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	2103	8	that	that	IN
18637	2103	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2103	10	may	may	MD
18637	2103	11	properly	properly	RB
18637	2103	12	have	have	VB
18637	2103	13	considered	consider	VBN
18637	2103	14	that	that	DT
18637	2103	15	wheat	wheat	NN
18637	2103	16	consumed	consume	VBN
18637	2103	17	on	on	IN
18637	2103	18	the	the	DT
18637	2103	19	farm	farm	NN
18637	2103	20	where	where	WRB
18637	2103	21	grown	grow	VBN
18637	2103	22	,	,	,
18637	2103	23	if	if	IN
18637	2103	24	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	2103	25	outside	outside	IN
18637	2103	26	the	the	DT
18637	2103	27	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	2103	28	of	of	IN
18637	2103	29	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2103	30	,	,	,
18637	2103	31	would	would	MD
18637	2103	32	have	have	VB
18637	2103	33	a	a	DT
18637	2103	34	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	2103	35	effect	effect	NN
18637	2103	36	in	in	IN
18637	2103	37	defeating	defeat	VBG
18637	2103	38	and	and	CC
18637	2103	39	obstructing	obstruct	VBG
18637	2103	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2103	41	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2103	42	to	to	TO
18637	2103	43	stimulate	stimulate	VB
18637	2103	44	trade	trade	NN
18637	2103	45	therein	therein	RB
18637	2103	46	at	at	IN
18637	2103	47	increased	increase	VBN
18637	2103	48	prices	price	NNS
18637	2103	49	.	.	.
18637	2104	1	"	"	``
18637	2104	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2104	3	471	471	CD
18637	2104	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2104	5	And	and	CC
18637	2104	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2104	7	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	2104	8	stated	state	VBD
18637	2104	9	:	:	:
18637	2104	10	"	"	``
18637	2104	11	Questions	question	NNS
18637	2104	12	of	of	IN
18637	2104	13	the	the	DT
18637	2104	14	power	power	NN
18637	2104	15	of	of	IN
18637	2104	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2104	17	are	be	VBP
18637	2104	18	not	not	RB
18637	2104	19	to	to	TO
18637	2104	20	be	be	VB
18637	2104	21	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2104	22	by	by	IN
18637	2104	23	reference	reference	NN
18637	2104	24	to	to	IN
18637	2104	25	any	any	DT
18637	2104	26	formula	formula	NN
18637	2104	27	which	which	WDT
18637	2104	28	would	would	MD
18637	2104	29	give	give	VB
18637	2104	30	controlling	control	VBG
18637	2104	31	force	force	NN
18637	2104	32	to	to	TO
18637	2104	33	nomenclature	nomenclature	VB
18637	2104	34	such	such	JJ
18637	2104	35	as	as	IN
18637	2104	36	'	'	``
18637	2104	37	production	production	NN
18637	2104	38	'	'	''
18637	2104	39	and	and	CC
18637	2104	40	'	'	``
18637	2104	41	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	2104	42	'	'	''
18637	2104	43	and	and	CC
18637	2104	44	foreclose	foreclose	VB
18637	2104	45	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	2104	46	of	of	IN
18637	2104	47	the	the	DT
18637	2104	48	actual	actual	JJ
18637	2104	49	effects	effect	NNS
18637	2104	50	of	of	IN
18637	2104	51	the	the	DT
18637	2104	52	activity	activity	NN
18637	2104	53	in	in	IN
18637	2104	54	question	question	NN
18637	2104	55	upon	upon	IN
18637	2104	56	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2104	57	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2104	58	.	.	.
18637	2105	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2105	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2105	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2105	4	The	the	DT
18637	2105	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2105	6	's	's	POS
18637	2105	7	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	2105	8	of	of	IN
18637	2105	9	the	the	DT
18637	2105	10	relevance	relevance	NN
18637	2105	11	of	of	IN
18637	2105	12	the	the	DT
18637	2105	13	economic	economic	JJ
18637	2105	14	effects	effect	NNS
18637	2105	15	in	in	IN
18637	2105	16	the	the	DT
18637	2105	17	application	application	NN
18637	2105	18	of	of	IN
18637	2105	19	the	the	DT
18637	2105	20	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2105	21	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	2105	22	,	,	,
18637	2105	23	*	*	NFP
18637	2105	24	*	*	NFP
18637	2105	25	*	*	NFP
18637	2105	26	,	,	,
18637	2105	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	2105	28	made	make	VBN
18637	2105	29	the	the	DT
18637	2105	30	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
18637	2105	31	application	application	NN
18637	2105	32	of	of	IN
18637	2105	33	legal	legal	JJ
18637	2105	34	formulas	formula	NNS
18637	2105	35	no	no	RB
18637	2105	36	longer	long	RBR
18637	2105	37	feasible	feasible	JJ
18637	2105	38	.	.	.
18637	2106	1	"	"	``
18637	2106	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2106	3	472	472	CD
18637	2106	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2106	5	Acts	act	NNS
18637	2106	6	of	of	IN
18637	2106	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2106	8	Prohibiting	Prohibiting	NNP
18637	2106	9	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2106	10	FOREIGN	foreign	JJ
18637	2106	11	COMMERCE	COMMERCE	NNP
18637	2106	12	;	;	:
18637	2106	13	JEFFERSON	JEFFERSON	NNP
18637	2106	14	'S	be	VBZ
18637	2106	15	EMBARGO	embargo	NN
18637	2106	16	"	"	``
18637	2106	17	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	2106	18	's	's	POS
18637	2106	19	Embargo	Embargo	NNP
18637	2106	20	"	"	''
18637	2106	21	of	of	IN
18637	2106	22	1807	1807	CD
18637	2106	23	-	-	SYM
18637	2106	24	1808	1808	CD
18637	2106	25	,	,	,
18637	2106	26	which	which	WDT
18637	2106	27	cut	cut	VBD
18637	2106	28	all	all	DT
18637	2106	29	trade	trade	NN
18637	2106	30	with	with	IN
18637	2106	31	Europe	Europe	NNP
18637	2106	32	,	,	,
18637	2106	33	was	be	VBD
18637	2106	34	attacked	attack	VBN
18637	2106	35	on	on	IN
18637	2106	36	the	the	DT
18637	2106	37	ground	ground	NN
18637	2106	38	that	that	IN
18637	2106	39	the	the	DT
18637	2106	40	power	power	NN
18637	2106	41	to	to	TO
18637	2106	42	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2106	43	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2106	44	was	be	VBD
18637	2106	45	the	the	DT
18637	2106	46	power	power	NN
18637	2106	47	to	to	TO
18637	2106	48	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	2106	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2106	50	,	,	,
18637	2106	51	not	not	RB
18637	2106	52	the	the	DT
18637	2106	53	power	power	NN
18637	2106	54	to	to	TO
18637	2106	55	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	2106	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2106	57	.	.	.
18637	2107	1	This	this	DT
18637	2107	2	argument	argument	NN
18637	2107	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2107	4	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	2107	5	by	by	IN
18637	2107	6	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	2107	7	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	2107	8	of	of	IN
18637	2107	9	the	the	DT
18637	2107	10	United	United	NNP
18637	2107	11	States	States	NNP
18637	2107	12	District	District	NNP
18637	2107	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2107	14	for	for	IN
18637	2107	15	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	2107	16	in	in	IN
18637	2107	17	the	the	DT
18637	2107	18	following	follow	VBG
18637	2107	19	words	word	NNS
18637	2107	20	:	:	:
18637	2107	21	"	"	``
18637	2107	22	A	a	DT
18637	2107	23	national	national	JJ
18637	2107	24	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	2107	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	2107	26	created	create	VBN
18637	2107	27	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2107	28	by	by	IN
18637	2107	29	the	the	DT
18637	2107	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2107	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2107	32	.	.	.
18637	2108	1	Not	not	RB
18637	2108	2	an	an	DT
18637	2108	3	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	2108	4	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	2108	5	,	,	,
18637	2108	6	but	but	CC
18637	2108	7	a	a	DT
18637	2108	8	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	2108	9	,	,	,
18637	2108	10	as	as	IN
18637	2108	11	to	to	IN
18637	2108	12	the	the	DT
18637	2108	13	objects	object	NNS
18637	2108	14	surrendered	surrender	VBN
18637	2108	15	and	and	CC
18637	2108	16	specified	specify	VBD
18637	2108	17	,	,	,
18637	2108	18	limited	limit	VBN
18637	2108	19	only	only	RB
18637	2108	20	by	by	IN
18637	2108	21	the	the	DT
18637	2108	22	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	2108	23	and	and	CC
18637	2108	24	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	2108	25	,	,	,
18637	2108	26	expressed	express	VBN
18637	2108	27	in	in	IN
18637	2108	28	the	the	DT
18637	2108	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2108	30	.	.	.
18637	2109	1	Commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2109	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2109	3	one	one	CD
18637	2109	4	of	of	IN
18637	2109	5	those	those	DT
18637	2109	6	objects	object	NNS
18637	2109	7	.	.	.
18637	2110	1	The	the	DT
18637	2110	2	care	care	NN
18637	2110	3	,	,	,
18637	2110	4	protection	protection	NN
18637	2110	5	,	,	,
18637	2110	6	management	management	NN
18637	2110	7	and	and	CC
18637	2110	8	control	control	NN
18637	2110	9	,	,	,
18637	2110	10	of	of	IN
18637	2110	11	this	this	DT
18637	2110	12	great	great	JJ
18637	2110	13	national	national	JJ
18637	2110	14	concern	concern	NN
18637	2110	15	,	,	,
18637	2110	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	2110	17	,	,	,
18637	2110	18	in	in	IN
18637	2110	19	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2110	20	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2110	21	,	,	,
18637	2110	22	vested	vest	VBN
18637	2110	23	by	by	IN
18637	2110	24	the	the	DT
18637	2110	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2110	26	,	,	,
18637	2110	27	in	in	IN
18637	2110	28	the	the	DT
18637	2110	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2110	30	of	of	IN
18637	2110	31	the	the	DT
18637	2110	32	United	United	NNP
18637	2110	33	States	States	NNP
18637	2110	34	;	;	:
18637	2110	35	and	and	CC
18637	2110	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2110	37	power	power	NN
18637	2110	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	2110	39	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	2110	40	,	,	,
18637	2110	41	relative	relative	JJ
18637	2110	42	to	to	IN
18637	2110	43	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	2110	44	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	2110	45	,	,	,
18637	2110	46	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	2110	47	by	by	IN
18637	2110	48	the	the	DT
18637	2110	49	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	2110	50	and	and	CC
18637	2110	51	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	2110	52	,	,	,
18637	2110	53	expressed	express	VBN
18637	2110	54	in	in	IN
18637	2110	55	that	that	DT
18637	2110	56	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	2110	57	,	,	,
18637	2110	58	and	and	CC
18637	2110	59	by	by	IN
18637	2110	60	the	the	DT
18637	2110	61	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	2110	62	making	make	VBG
18637	2110	63	power	power	NN
18637	2110	64	of	of	IN
18637	2110	65	the	the	DT
18637	2110	66	President	President	NNP
18637	2110	67	and	and	CC
18637	2110	68	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	2110	69	.	.	.
18637	2111	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2111	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2111	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2111	4	Power	power	NN
18637	2111	5	to	to	TO
18637	2111	6	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2111	7	,	,	,
18637	2111	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2111	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	2111	10	said	say	VBN
18637	2111	11	,	,	,
18637	2111	12	can	can	MD
18637	2111	13	not	not	RB
18637	2111	14	be	be	VB
18637	2111	15	understood	understand	VBN
18637	2111	16	to	to	TO
18637	2111	17	give	give	VB
18637	2111	18	a	a	DT
18637	2111	19	power	power	NN
18637	2111	20	to	to	TO
18637	2111	21	annihilate	annihilate	VB
18637	2111	22	.	.	.
18637	2112	1	To	to	IN
18637	2112	2	this	this	DT
18637	2112	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2112	4	may	may	MD
18637	2112	5	be	be	VB
18637	2112	6	replied	reply	VBN
18637	2112	7	,	,	,
18637	2112	8	that	that	IN
18637	2112	9	the	the	DT
18637	2112	10	acts	act	NNS
18637	2112	11	under	under	IN
18637	2112	12	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	2112	13	,	,	,
18637	2112	14	though	though	IN
18637	2112	15	of	of	IN
18637	2112	16	very	very	RB
18637	2112	17	ample	ample	JJ
18637	2112	18	extent	extent	NN
18637	2112	19	,	,	,
18637	2112	20	do	do	VBP
18637	2112	21	not	not	RB
18637	2112	22	operate	operate	VB
18637	2112	23	as	as	IN
18637	2112	24	a	a	DT
18637	2112	25	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	2112	26	of	of	IN
18637	2112	27	all	all	DT
18637	2112	28	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2112	29	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2112	30	.	.	.
18637	2113	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2113	2	will	will	MD
18637	2113	3	be	be	VB
18637	2113	4	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	2113	5	that	that	IN
18637	2113	6	partial	partial	JJ
18637	2113	7	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
18637	2113	8	are	be	VBP
18637	2113	9	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	2113	10	by	by	IN
18637	2113	11	the	the	DT
18637	2113	12	expression	expression	NN
18637	2113	13	;	;	:
18637	2113	14	and	and	CC
18637	2113	15	how	how	WRB
18637	2113	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	2113	17	the	the	DT
18637	2113	18	degree	degree	NN
18637	2113	19	,	,	,
18637	2113	20	or	or	CC
18637	2113	21	extent	extent	NN
18637	2113	22	,	,	,
18637	2113	23	of	of	IN
18637	2113	24	the	the	DT
18637	2113	25	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	2113	26	be	be	VB
18637	2113	27	adjusted	adjust	VBN
18637	2113	28	,	,	,
18637	2113	29	but	but	CC
18637	2113	30	by	by	IN
18637	2113	31	the	the	DT
18637	2113	32	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	2113	33	of	of	IN
18637	2113	34	the	the	DT
18637	2113	35	National	National	NNP
18637	2113	36	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2113	37	,	,	,
18637	2113	38	to	to	TO
18637	2113	39	whom	whom	WP
18637	2113	40	the	the	DT
18637	2113	41	subject	subject	NN
18637	2113	42	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	2113	43	to	to	TO
18637	2113	44	be	be	VB
18637	2113	45	committed	commit	VBN
18637	2113	46	?	?	.
18637	2114	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2114	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2114	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2114	4	The	the	DT
18637	2114	5	term	term	NN
18637	2114	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	2114	7	not	not	RB
18637	2114	8	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	2114	9	include	include	VB
18637	2114	10	shipping	shipping	NN
18637	2114	11	or	or	CC
18637	2114	12	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	2114	13	;	;	:
18637	2114	14	much	much	RB
18637	2114	15	less	less	JJR
18637	2114	16	does	do	VBZ
18637	2114	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2114	18	include	include	VB
18637	2114	19	the	the	DT
18637	2114	20	fisheries	fishery	NNS
18637	2114	21	.	.	.
18637	2115	1	Yet	yet	CC
18637	2115	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2115	3	never	never	RB
18637	2115	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	2115	5	been	be	VBN
18637	2115	6	contended	contend	VBN
18637	2115	7	,	,	,
18637	2115	8	that	that	IN
18637	2115	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2115	10	are	be	VBP
18637	2115	11	not	not	RB
18637	2115	12	the	the	DT
18637	2115	13	proper	proper	JJ
18637	2115	14	objects	object	NNS
18637	2115	15	of	of	IN
18637	2115	16	national	national	JJ
18637	2115	17	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2115	18	;	;	:
18637	2115	19	and	and	CC
18637	2115	20	several	several	JJ
18637	2115	21	acts	act	NNS
18637	2115	22	of	of	IN
18637	2115	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2115	24	have	have	VBP
18637	2115	25	been	be	VBN
18637	2115	26	made	make	VBN
18637	2115	27	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	2115	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2115	29	.	.	.
18637	2116	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2116	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2116	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2116	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2116	5	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	2116	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2116	7	if	if	IN
18637	2116	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2116	9	be	be	VB
18637	2116	10	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	2116	11	that	that	IN
18637	2116	12	national	national	JJ
18637	2116	13	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2116	14	relative	relative	JJ
18637	2116	15	to	to	IN
18637	2116	16	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2116	17	,	,	,
18637	2116	18	may	may	MD
18637	2116	19	apply	apply	VB
18637	2116	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2116	21	as	as	IN
18637	2116	22	an	an	DT
18637	2116	23	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	2116	24	,	,	,
18637	2116	25	and	and	CC
18637	2116	26	are	be	VBP
18637	2116	27	not	not	RB
18637	2116	28	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	2116	29	confined	confine	VBN
18637	2116	30	to	to	IN
18637	2116	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2116	32	direct	direct	JJ
18637	2116	33	aid	aid	NN
18637	2116	34	and	and	CC
18637	2116	35	advancement	advancement	NN
18637	2116	36	,	,	,
18637	2116	37	the	the	DT
18637	2116	38	sphere	sphere	NN
18637	2116	39	of	of	IN
18637	2116	40	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2116	41	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	2116	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	2116	43	,	,	,
18637	2116	44	of	of	IN
18637	2116	45	course	course	NN
18637	2116	46	,	,	,
18637	2116	47	more	more	RBR
18637	2116	48	widely	widely	RB
18637	2116	49	extended	extended	JJ
18637	2116	50	;	;	:
18637	2116	51	and	and	CC
18637	2116	52	,	,	,
18637	2116	53	in	in	IN
18637	2116	54	time	time	NN
18637	2116	55	of	of	IN
18637	2116	56	war	war	NN
18637	2116	57	,	,	,
18637	2116	58	or	or	CC
18637	2116	59	of	of	IN
18637	2116	60	great	great	JJ
18637	2116	61	impending	impending	JJ
18637	2116	62	peril	peril	NN
18637	2116	63	,	,	,
18637	2116	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2116	65	must	must	MD
18637	2116	66	take	take	VB
18637	2116	67	a	a	DT
18637	2116	68	still	still	RB
18637	2116	69	more	more	RBR
18637	2116	70	expanded	expand	VBN
18637	2116	71	range	range	NN
18637	2116	72	.	.	.
18637	2117	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2117	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	2117	3	power	power	NN
18637	2117	4	to	to	TO
18637	2117	5	declare	declare	VB
18637	2117	6	war	war	NN
18637	2117	7	.	.	.
18637	2118	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2118	2	,	,	,
18637	2118	3	of	of	IN
18637	2118	4	course	course	NN
18637	2118	5	,	,	,
18637	2118	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	2118	7	power	power	NN
18637	2118	8	to	to	TO
18637	2118	9	prepare	prepare	VB
18637	2118	10	for	for	IN
18637	2118	11	war	war	NN
18637	2118	12	;	;	,
18637	2118	13	and	and	CC
18637	2118	14	the	the	DT
18637	2118	15	time	time	NN
18637	2118	16	,	,	,
18637	2118	17	the	the	DT
18637	2118	18	manner	manner	NN
18637	2118	19	,	,	,
18637	2118	20	and	and	CC
18637	2118	21	the	the	DT
18637	2118	22	measure	measure	NN
18637	2118	23	,	,	,
18637	2118	24	in	in	IN
18637	2118	25	the	the	DT
18637	2118	26	application	application	NN
18637	2118	27	of	of	IN
18637	2118	28	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2118	29	means	mean	NNS
18637	2118	30	,	,	,
18637	2118	31	seem	seem	VBP
18637	2118	32	to	to	TO
18637	2118	33	be	be	VB
18637	2118	34	left	leave	VBN
18637	2118	35	to	to	IN
18637	2118	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2118	37	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	2118	38	and	and	CC
18637	2118	39	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	2118	40	.	.	.
18637	2119	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2119	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2119	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2119	4	Under	under	IN
18637	2119	5	the	the	DT
18637	2119	6	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	2119	7	,	,	,
18637	2119	8	*	*	NFP
18637	2119	9	*	*	NFP
18637	2119	10	*	*	NFP
18637	2119	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2119	12	find	find	VBP
18637	2119	13	an	an	DT
18637	2119	14	express	express	JJ
18637	2119	15	reservation	reservation	NN
18637	2119	16	to	to	IN
18637	2119	17	the	the	DT
18637	2119	18	State	State	NNP
18637	2119	19	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	2119	20	of	of	IN
18637	2119	21	the	the	DT
18637	2119	22	power	power	NN
18637	2119	23	to	to	TO
18637	2119	24	pass	pass	VB
18637	2119	25	prohibitory	prohibitory	JJ
18637	2119	26	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	2119	27	laws	law	NNS
18637	2119	28	,	,	,
18637	2119	29	and	and	CC
18637	2119	30	,	,	,
18637	2119	31	as	as	IN
18637	2119	32	respects	respect	VBZ
18637	2119	33	exportations	exportation	NNS
18637	2119	34	,	,	,
18637	2119	35	without	without	IN
18637	2119	36	any	any	DT
18637	2119	37	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	2119	38	.	.	.
18637	2120	1	Some	some	DT
18637	2120	2	of	of	IN
18637	2120	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2120	4	exercised	exercise	VBD
18637	2120	5	this	this	DT
18637	2120	6	power	power	NN
18637	2120	7	.	.	.
18637	2121	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2121	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2121	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2121	4	Unless	unless	IN
18637	2121	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2121	6	,	,	,
18637	2121	7	by	by	IN
18637	2121	8	the	the	DT
18637	2121	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2121	10	,	,	,
18637	2121	11	possess	possess	VB
18637	2121	12	the	the	DT
18637	2121	13	power	power	NN
18637	2121	14	in	in	IN
18637	2121	15	question	question	NN
18637	2121	16	,	,	,
18637	2121	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2121	18	still	still	RB
18637	2121	19	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	2121	20	in	in	IN
18637	2121	21	the	the	DT
18637	2121	22	State	state	NN
18637	2121	23	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	2121	24	--	--	:
18637	2121	25	but	but	CC
18637	2121	26	this	this	DT
18637	2121	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	2121	28	never	never	RB
18637	2121	29	been	be	VBN
18637	2121	30	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	2121	31	or	or	CC
18637	2121	32	pretended	pretend	VBN
18637	2121	33	,	,	,
18637	2121	34	since	since	IN
18637	2121	35	the	the	DT
18637	2121	36	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	2121	37	of	of	IN
18637	2121	38	the	the	DT
18637	2121	39	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2121	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2121	41	;	;	:
18637	2121	42	and	and	CC
18637	2121	43	the	the	DT
18637	2121	44	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2121	45	of	of	IN
18637	2121	46	such	such	PDT
18637	2121	47	a	a	DT
18637	2121	48	power	power	NN
18637	2121	49	by	by	IN
18637	2121	50	the	the	DT
18637	2121	51	States	States	NNP
18637	2121	52	,	,	,
18637	2121	53	would	would	MD
18637	2121	54	be	be	VB
18637	2121	55	manifestly	manifestly	RB
18637	2121	56	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	2121	57	with	with	IN
18637	2121	58	the	the	DT
18637	2121	59	power	power	NN
18637	2121	60	,	,	,
18637	2121	61	vested	vest	VBN
18637	2121	62	by	by	IN
18637	2121	63	the	the	DT
18637	2121	64	people	people	NNS
18637	2121	65	in	in	IN
18637	2121	66	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2121	67	,	,	,
18637	2121	68	'	'	''
18637	2121	69	to	to	TO
18637	2121	70	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2121	71	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2121	72	.	.	.
18637	2121	73	'	'	''
18637	2122	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	2122	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2122	3	infer	infer	VBP
18637	2122	4	,	,	,
18637	2122	5	that	that	IN
18637	2122	6	the	the	DT
18637	2122	7	power	power	NN
18637	2122	8	,	,	,
18637	2122	9	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	2122	10	to	to	IN
18637	2122	11	the	the	DT
18637	2122	12	States	States	NNP
18637	2122	13	by	by	IN
18637	2122	14	the	the	DT
18637	2122	15	articles	article	NNS
18637	2122	16	of	of	IN
18637	2122	17	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	2122	18	,	,	,
18637	2122	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	2122	20	surrendered	surrender	VBN
18637	2122	21	to	to	IN
18637	2122	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2122	23	,	,	,
18637	2122	24	by	by	IN
18637	2122	25	the	the	DT
18637	2122	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2122	27	;	;	:
18637	2122	28	unless	unless	IN
18637	2122	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2122	30	suppose	suppose	VBP
18637	2122	31	,	,	,
18637	2122	32	that	that	IN
18637	2122	33	,	,	,
18637	2122	34	by	by	IN
18637	2122	35	some	some	DT
18637	2122	36	strange	strange	JJ
18637	2122	37	process	process	NN
18637	2122	38	,	,	,
18637	2122	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2122	40	has	have	VBZ
18637	2122	41	been	be	VBN
18637	2122	42	merged	merge	VBN
18637	2122	43	or	or	CC
18637	2122	44	extinguished	extinguish	VBN
18637	2122	45	,	,	,
18637	2122	46	and	and	CC
18637	2122	47	now	now	RB
18637	2122	48	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	2122	49	no	no	UH
18637	2122	50	where	where	WRB
18637	2122	51	.	.	.
18637	2123	1	"	"	``
18637	2123	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2123	3	473	473	CD
18637	2123	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2123	5	FOREIGN	foreign	JJ
18637	2123	6	COMMERCE	COMMERCE	NNS
18637	2123	7	;	;	:
18637	2123	8	PROTECTIVE	protective	JJ
18637	2123	9	TARIFFS	tariffs	NN
18637	2123	10	Tariff	tariff	NN
18637	2123	11	laws	law	NNS
18637	2123	12	have	have	VBP
18637	2123	13	customarily	customarily	RB
18637	2123	14	contained	contain	VBN
18637	2123	15	prohibitory	prohibitory	NN
18637	2123	16	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	2123	17	,	,	,
18637	2123	18	and	and	CC
18637	2123	19	such	such	JJ
18637	2123	20	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	2123	21	have	have	VBP
18637	2123	22	been	be	VBN
18637	2123	23	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2123	24	by	by	IN
18637	2123	25	the	the	DT
18637	2123	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2123	27	under	under	IN
18637	2123	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2123	29	's	's	POS
18637	2123	30	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	2123	31	powers	power	NNS
18637	2123	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2123	33	_	_	NNP
18637	2123	34	see	see	VBP
18637	2123	35	above	above	IN
18637	2123	36	_	_	NNP
18637	2123	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2123	38	and	and	CC
18637	2123	39	under	under	IN
18637	2123	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2123	41	power	power	NN
18637	2123	42	to	to	TO
18637	2123	43	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2123	44	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2123	45	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2123	46	.	.	.
18637	2124	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2124	2	for	for	IN
18637	2124	3	the	the	DT
18637	2124	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2124	5	in	in	IN
18637	2124	6	University	University	NNP
18637	2124	7	of	of	IN
18637	2124	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	2124	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2124	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	2124	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2124	12	United	United	NNP
18637	2124	13	States,[474	States,[474	NNP
18637	2124	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2124	15	in	in	IN
18637	2124	16	1933	1933	CD
18637	2124	17	,	,	,
18637	2124	18	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2124	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2124	20	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	2124	21	said	say	VBD
18637	2124	22	:	:	:
18637	2124	23	"	"	``
18637	2124	24	The	the	DT
18637	2124	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2124	26	may	may	MD
18637	2124	27	determine	determine	VB
18637	2124	28	what	what	WP
18637	2124	29	articles	article	NNS
18637	2124	30	may	may	MD
18637	2124	31	be	be	VB
18637	2124	32	imported	import	VBN
18637	2124	33	into	into	IN
18637	2124	34	this	this	DT
18637	2124	35	country	country	NN
18637	2124	36	and	and	CC
18637	2124	37	the	the	DT
18637	2124	38	terms	term	NNS
18637	2124	39	upon	upon	IN
18637	2124	40	which	which	WDT
18637	2124	41	importation	importation	NN
18637	2124	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	2124	43	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	2124	44	.	.	.
18637	2125	1	No	no	DT
18637	2125	2	one	one	NN
18637	2125	3	can	can	MD
18637	2125	4	be	be	VB
18637	2125	5	said	say	VBN
18637	2125	6	to	to	TO
18637	2125	7	have	have	VB
18637	2125	8	a	a	DT
18637	2125	9	vested	vested	JJ
18637	2125	10	right	right	NN
18637	2125	11	to	to	TO
18637	2125	12	carry	carry	VB
18637	2125	13	on	on	IN
18637	2125	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2125	15	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2125	16	with	with	IN
18637	2125	17	the	the	DT
18637	2125	18	United	United	NNP
18637	2125	19	States	States	NNP
18637	2125	20	.	.	.
18637	2126	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2126	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2126	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2126	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2126	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	2126	6	true	true	JJ
18637	2126	7	that	that	IN
18637	2126	8	the	the	DT
18637	2126	9	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2126	10	power	power	NN
18637	2126	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	2126	12	a	a	DT
18637	2126	13	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	2126	14	power	power	NN
18637	2126	15	;	;	:
18637	2126	16	that	that	IN
18637	2126	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2126	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	2126	19	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	2126	20	from	from	IN
18637	2126	21	the	the	DT
18637	2126	22	power	power	NN
18637	2126	23	to	to	TO
18637	2126	24	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2126	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2126	26	.	.	.
18637	2127	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2127	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2127	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2127	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2127	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	2127	6	also	also	RB
18637	2127	7	true	true	JJ
18637	2127	8	that	that	IN
18637	2127	9	the	the	DT
18637	2127	10	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2127	11	power	power	NN
18637	2127	12	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	2127	13	the	the	DT
18637	2127	14	power	power	NN
18637	2127	15	to	to	TO
18637	2127	16	lay	lay	VB
18637	2127	17	duties	duty	NNS
18637	2127	18	.	.	.
18637	2128	1	Art	art	NN
18637	2128	2	.	.	.
18637	2129	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2129	2	,	,	,
18637	2129	3	§	§	NNP
18637	2129	4	8	8	CD
18637	2129	5	,	,	,
18637	2129	6	cl	cl	IN
18637	2129	7	.	.	.
18637	2130	1	1	1	LS
18637	2130	2	.	.	.
18637	2131	1	But	but	CC
18637	2131	2	because	because	IN
18637	2131	3	the	the	DT
18637	2131	4	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2131	5	power	power	NN
18637	2131	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2131	7	a	a	DT
18637	2131	8	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	2131	9	power	power	NN
18637	2131	10	and	and	CC
18637	2131	11	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	2131	12	the	the	DT
18637	2131	13	power	power	NN
18637	2131	14	to	to	TO
18637	2131	15	lay	lay	VB
18637	2131	16	duties	duty	NNS
18637	2131	17	,	,	,
18637	2131	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2131	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	2131	20	not	not	RB
18637	2131	21	follow	follow	VB
18637	2131	22	that	that	IN
18637	2131	23	duties	duty	NNS
18637	2131	24	may	may	MD
18637	2131	25	not	not	RB
18637	2131	26	be	be	VB
18637	2131	27	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2131	28	in	in	IN
18637	2131	29	the	the	DT
18637	2131	30	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2131	31	of	of	IN
18637	2131	32	the	the	DT
18637	2131	33	power	power	NN
18637	2131	34	to	to	TO
18637	2131	35	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2131	36	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2131	37	.	.	.
18637	2132	1	The	the	DT
18637	2132	2	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	2132	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	2132	4	well	well	RB
18637	2132	5	established	establish	VBN
18637	2132	6	.	.	.
18637	2133	1	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	2133	2	_	_	NNP
18637	2133	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	2133	4	_	_	NNP
18637	2133	5	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	2133	6	,	,	,
18637	2133	7	9	9	CD
18637	2133	8	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	2133	9	.	.	.
18637	2134	1	1	1	CD
18637	2134	2	,	,	,
18637	2134	3	202	202	CD
18637	2134	4	.	.	.
18637	2135	1	'	'	``
18637	2135	2	Under	under	IN
18637	2135	3	the	the	DT
18637	2135	4	power	power	NN
18637	2135	5	to	to	TO
18637	2135	6	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2135	7	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2135	8	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2135	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2135	10	impose	impose	VB
18637	2135	11	duties	duty	NNS
18637	2135	12	on	on	IN
18637	2135	13	importations	importation	NNS
18637	2135	14	,	,	,
18637	2135	15	give	give	VB
18637	2135	16	drawbacks	drawback	NNS
18637	2135	17	,	,	,
18637	2135	18	pass	pass	VB
18637	2135	19	embargo	embargo	NN
18637	2135	20	and	and	CC
18637	2135	21	nonintercourse	nonintercourse	JJ
18637	2135	22	laws	law	NNS
18637	2135	23	,	,	,
18637	2135	24	and	and	CC
18637	2135	25	make	make	VB
18637	2135	26	all	all	DT
18637	2135	27	other	other	JJ
18637	2135	28	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2135	29	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2135	30	to	to	IN
18637	2135	31	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	2135	32	,	,	,
18637	2135	33	to	to	IN
18637	2135	34	the	the	DT
18637	2135	35	safety	safety	NN
18637	2135	36	of	of	IN
18637	2135	37	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	2135	38	,	,	,
18637	2135	39	and	and	CC
18637	2135	40	the	the	DT
18637	2135	41	protection	protection	NN
18637	2135	42	of	of	IN
18637	2135	43	property	property	NN
18637	2135	44	.	.	.
18637	2135	45	'	'	''
18637	2136	1	Groves	grove	NNS
18637	2136	2	_	_	NNP
18637	2136	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	2136	4	_	_	NNP
18637	2136	5	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	2136	6	,	,	,
18637	2136	7	15	15	CD
18637	2136	8	Pet	pet	NN
18637	2136	9	.	.	.
18637	2137	1	449	449	CD
18637	2137	2	,	,	,
18637	2137	3	505	505	CD
18637	2137	4	.	.	.
18637	2138	1	The	the	DT
18637	2138	2	laying	laying	NN
18637	2138	3	of	of	IN
18637	2138	4	duties	duty	NNS
18637	2138	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	2138	6	'	'	``
18637	2138	7	a	a	DT
18637	2138	8	common	common	JJ
18637	2138	9	means	mean	NNS
18637	2138	10	of	of	IN
18637	2138	11	executing	execute	VBG
18637	2138	12	the	the	DT
18637	2138	13	power	power	NN
18637	2138	14	.	.	.
18637	2138	15	'	'	''
18637	2139	1	2	2	CD
18637	2139	2	Story	story	NN
18637	2139	3	on	on	IN
18637	2139	4	the	the	DT
18637	2139	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2139	6	,	,	,
18637	2139	7	§	â§	NN
18637	2139	8	1088	1088	CD
18637	2139	9	.	.	.
18637	2140	1	"	"	``
18637	2140	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2140	3	475	475	CD
18637	2140	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2140	5	FOREIGN	foreign	JJ
18637	2140	6	COMMERCE	COMMERCE	NNS
18637	2140	7	;	;	:
18637	2140	8	BANNED	banned	VB
18637	2140	9	ARTICLES	articles	NN
18637	2140	10	The	the	DT
18637	2140	11	forerunners	forerunner	NNS
18637	2140	12	of	of	IN
18637	2140	13	more	more	JJR
18637	2140	14	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2140	15	acts	act	NNS
18637	2140	16	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	2140	17	objectionable	objectionable	JJ
18637	2140	18	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	2140	19	from	from	IN
18637	2140	20	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2140	21	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2140	22	are	be	VBP
18637	2140	23	the	the	DT
18637	2140	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	2140	25	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	2140	26	the	the	DT
18637	2140	27	importation	importation	NN
18637	2140	28	of	of	IN
18637	2140	29	like	like	JJ
18637	2140	30	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	2140	31	from	from	IN
18637	2140	32	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	2140	33	.	.	.
18637	2141	1	This	this	DT
18637	2141	2	power	power	NN
18637	2141	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2141	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	2141	5	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	2141	6	since	since	IN
18637	2141	7	1842	1842	CD
18637	2141	8	.	.	.
18637	2142	1	In	in	IN
18637	2142	2	that	that	DT
18637	2142	3	year	year	NN
18637	2142	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2142	5	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	2142	6	the	the	DT
18637	2142	7	importation	importation	NN
18637	2142	8	of	of	IN
18637	2142	9	obscene	obscene	JJ
18637	2142	10	literature	literature	NN
18637	2142	11	or	or	CC
18637	2142	12	pictures	picture	NNS
18637	2142	13	from	from	IN
18637	2142	14	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	2142	15	.	.	.
18637	2143	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2143	2	476	476	CD
18637	2143	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2143	4	Six	six	CD
18637	2143	5	years	year	NNS
18637	2143	6	later	later	RB
18637	2143	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2143	8	passed	pass	VBD
18637	2143	9	an	an	DT
18637	2143	10	act	act	NN
18637	2143	11	"	"	``
18637	2143	12	to	to	TO
18637	2143	13	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2143	14	the	the	DT
18637	2143	15	importation	importation	NN
18637	2143	16	of	of	IN
18637	2143	17	spurious	spurious	JJ
18637	2143	18	and	and	CC
18637	2143	19	adulterated	adulterated	JJ
18637	2143	20	drugs	drug	NNS
18637	2143	21	"	"	''
18637	2143	22	and	and	CC
18637	2143	23	to	to	TO
18637	2143	24	provide	provide	VB
18637	2143	25	a	a	DT
18637	2143	26	system	system	NN
18637	2143	27	of	of	IN
18637	2143	28	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	2143	29	to	to	TO
18637	2143	30	make	make	VB
18637	2143	31	the	the	DT
18637	2143	32	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	2143	33	effective	effective	JJ
18637	2143	34	.	.	.
18637	2144	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2144	2	477	477	CD
18637	2144	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2144	4	Such	such	JJ
18637	2144	5	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2144	6	guarding	guard	VBG
18637	2144	7	against	against	IN
18637	2144	8	the	the	DT
18637	2144	9	importation	importation	NN
18637	2144	10	of	of	IN
18637	2144	11	noxiously	noxiously	RB
18637	2144	12	adulterated	adulterate	VBN
18637	2144	13	foods	food	NNS
18637	2144	14	,	,	,
18637	2144	15	drugs	drug	NNS
18637	2144	16	,	,	,
18637	2144	17	or	or	CC
18637	2144	18	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	2144	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	2144	20	been	be	VBN
18637	2144	21	on	on	IN
18637	2144	22	the	the	DT
18637	2144	23	statute	statute	NN
18637	2144	24	books	book	NNS
18637	2144	25	ever	ever	RB
18637	2144	26	since	since	RB
18637	2144	27	.	.	.
18637	2145	1	In	in	IN
18637	2145	2	1887	1887	CD
18637	2145	3	the	the	DT
18637	2145	4	importation	importation	NN
18637	2145	5	by	by	IN
18637	2145	6	Chinese	chinese	JJ
18637	2145	7	nationals	national	NNS
18637	2145	8	of	of	IN
18637	2145	9	smoking	smoking	NN
18637	2145	10	opium	opium	NN
18637	2145	11	was	be	VBD
18637	2145	12	prohibited,[478	prohibited,[478	NN
18637	2145	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2145	14	and	and	CC
18637	2145	15	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	2145	16	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	2145	17	passed	pass	VBN
18637	2145	18	in	in	IN
18637	2145	19	1909	1909	CD
18637	2145	20	and	and	CC
18637	2145	21	1914	1914	CD
18637	2145	22	made	make	VBD
18637	2145	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2145	24	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	2145	25	for	for	IN
18637	2145	26	anyone	anyone	NN
18637	2145	27	to	to	TO
18637	2145	28	import	import	VB
18637	2145	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2145	30	.	.	.
18637	2146	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2146	2	479	479	CD
18637	2146	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2146	4	In	in	IN
18637	2146	5	1897	1897	CD
18637	2146	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2146	7	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	2146	8	the	the	DT
18637	2146	9	importation	importation	NN
18637	2146	10	of	of	IN
18637	2146	11	any	any	DT
18637	2146	12	tea	tea	NN
18637	2146	13	"	"	``
18637	2146	14	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	2146	15	in	in	IN
18637	2146	16	purity	purity	NN
18637	2146	17	,	,	,
18637	2146	18	quality	quality	NN
18637	2146	19	,	,	,
18637	2146	20	and	and	CC
18637	2146	21	fitness	fitness	NN
18637	2146	22	for	for	IN
18637	2146	23	consumption	consumption	NN
18637	2146	24	"	"	''
18637	2146	25	as	as	IN
18637	2146	26	compared	compare	VBN
18637	2146	27	with	with	IN
18637	2146	28	a	a	DT
18637	2146	29	legal	legal	JJ
18637	2146	30	standard	standard	NN
18637	2146	31	.	.	.
18637	2147	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2147	2	480	480	CD
18637	2147	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2147	4	The	the	DT
18637	2147	5	act	act	NN
18637	2147	6	was	be	VBD
18637	2147	7	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2147	8	in	in	IN
18637	2147	9	1904	1904	CD
18637	2147	10	,	,	,
18637	2147	11	in	in	IN
18637	2147	12	the	the	DT
18637	2147	13	leading	leading	JJ
18637	2147	14	case	case	NN
18637	2147	15	of	of	IN
18637	2147	16	Buttfield	Buttfield	NNP
18637	2147	17	_	_	NNP
18637	2147	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	2147	19	_	_	NNP
18637	2147	20	Stranahan	Stranahan	NNP
18637	2147	21	.	.	.
18637	2148	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2148	2	481	481	CD
18637	2148	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2148	4	In	in	IN
18637	2148	5	"	"	``
18637	2148	6	The	the	DT
18637	2148	7	Abby	Abby	NNP
18637	2148	8	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	2148	9	"	"	''
18637	2148	10	case	case	NN
18637	2148	11	an	an	DT
18637	2148	12	act	act	NN
18637	2148	13	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	2148	14	sponges	sponge	NNS
18637	2148	15	taken	take	VBN
18637	2148	16	by	by	IN
18637	2148	17	means	mean	NNS
18637	2148	18	of	of	IN
18637	2148	19	diving	diving	NN
18637	2148	20	or	or	CC
18637	2148	21	diving	diving	NN
18637	2148	22	apparatus	apparatus	NN
18637	2148	23	from	from	IN
18637	2148	24	the	the	DT
18637	2148	25	waters	water	NNS
18637	2148	26	of	of	IN
18637	2148	27	the	the	DT
18637	2148	28	Gulf	Gulf	NNP
18637	2148	29	of	of	IN
18637	2148	30	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	2148	31	or	or	CC
18637	2148	32	Straits	Straits	NNPS
18637	2148	33	of	of	IN
18637	2148	34	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	2148	35	was	be	VBD
18637	2148	36	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2148	37	,	,	,
18637	2148	38	but	but	CC
18637	2148	39	construed	construe	VBN
18637	2148	40	as	as	IN
18637	2148	41	not	not	RB
18637	2148	42	applying	apply	VBG
18637	2148	43	to	to	IN
18637	2148	44	sponges	sponge	NNS
18637	2148	45	taken	take	VBN
18637	2148	46	from	from	IN
18637	2148	47	the	the	DT
18637	2148	48	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	2148	49	waters	water	NNS
18637	2148	50	of	of	IN
18637	2148	51	a	a	DT
18637	2148	52	State	state	NN
18637	2148	53	.	.	.
18637	2149	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2149	2	482	482	CD
18637	2149	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2149	4	In	in	IN
18637	2149	5	Weber	Weber	NNP
18637	2149	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2149	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	2149	8	_	_	NNP
18637	2149	9	Freed[483	Freed[483	NNP
18637	2149	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2149	11	an	an	DT
18637	2149	12	act	act	NN
18637	2149	13	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	2149	14	the	the	DT
18637	2149	15	importation	importation	NN
18637	2149	16	and	and	CC
18637	2149	17	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2149	18	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2149	19	of	of	IN
18637	2149	20	prize	prize	NN
18637	2149	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	2149	22	fight	fight	NN
18637	2149	23	films	film	NNS
18637	2149	24	or	or	CC
18637	2149	25	of	of	IN
18637	2149	26	pictorial	pictorial	JJ
18637	2149	27	representation	representation	NN
18637	2149	28	of	of	IN
18637	2149	29	prize	prize	NN
18637	2149	30	fights	fight	NNS
18637	2149	31	was	be	VBD
18637	2149	32	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	2149	33	.	.	.
18637	2150	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2150	2	for	for	IN
18637	2150	3	the	the	DT
18637	2150	4	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	2150	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2150	6	,	,	,
18637	2150	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2150	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2150	9	White	White	NNP
18637	2150	10	said	say	VBD
18637	2150	11	:	:	:
18637	2150	12	"	"	``
18637	2150	13	In	in	IN
18637	2150	14	view	view	NN
18637	2150	15	of	of	IN
18637	2150	16	the	the	DT
18637	2150	17	complete	complete	JJ
18637	2150	18	power	power	NN
18637	2150	19	of	of	IN
18637	2150	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2150	21	over	over	IN
18637	2150	22	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2150	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2150	24	and	and	CC
18637	2150	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2150	26	authority	authority	NN
18637	2150	27	to	to	TO
18637	2150	28	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2150	29	the	the	DT
18637	2150	30	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	2150	31	of	of	IN
18637	2150	32	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2150	33	articles	article	NNS
18637	2150	34	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	2150	35	and	and	CC
18637	2150	36	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	2150	37	by	by	IN
18637	2150	38	many	many	JJ
18637	2150	39	previous	previous	JJ
18637	2150	40	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	2150	41	of	of	IN
18637	2150	42	this	this	DT
18637	2150	43	court	court	NN
18637	2150	44	,	,	,
18637	2150	45	the	the	DT
18637	2150	46	contentions	contention	NNS
18637	2150	47	are	be	VBP
18637	2150	48	so	so	RB
18637	2150	49	devoid	devoid	JJ
18637	2150	50	of	of	IN
18637	2150	51	merit	merit	NN
18637	2150	52	as	as	IN
18637	2150	53	to	to	TO
18637	2150	54	cause	cause	VB
18637	2150	55	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2150	56	to	to	TO
18637	2150	57	be	be	VB
18637	2150	58	frivolous	frivolous	JJ
18637	2150	59	.	.	.
18637	2151	1	"	"	``
18637	2151	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2151	3	484	484	CD
18637	2151	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2151	5	In	in	IN
18637	2151	6	Brolan	Brolan	NNP
18637	2151	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2151	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	2151	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2151	10	United	United	NNP
18637	2151	11	States[485	States[485	NNP
18637	2151	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2151	13	the	the	DT
18637	2151	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2151	15	again	again	RB
18637	2151	16	stressed	stress	VBD
18637	2151	17	the	the	DT
18637	2151	18	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	2151	19	nature	nature	NN
18637	2151	20	of	of	IN
18637	2151	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2151	22	's	's	POS
18637	2151	23	power	power	NN
18637	2151	24	over	over	IN
18637	2151	25	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2151	26	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2151	27	,	,	,
18637	2151	28	saying	say	VBG
18637	2151	29	:	:	:
18637	2151	30	"	"	``
18637	2151	31	In	in	IN
18637	2151	32	the	the	DT
18637	2151	33	argument	argument	NN
18637	2151	34	reference	reference	NN
18637	2151	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	2151	36	made	make	VBN
18637	2151	37	to	to	IN
18637	2151	38	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	2151	39	of	of	IN
18637	2151	40	this	this	DT
18637	2151	41	court	court	NN
18637	2151	42	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	2151	43	with	with	IN
18637	2151	44	the	the	DT
18637	2151	45	subject	subject	NN
18637	2151	46	of	of	IN
18637	2151	47	the	the	DT
18637	2151	48	power	power	NN
18637	2151	49	of	of	IN
18637	2151	50	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2151	51	to	to	TO
18637	2151	52	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2151	53	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2151	54	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2151	55	,	,	,
18637	2151	56	but	but	CC
18637	2151	57	the	the	DT
18637	2151	58	very	very	JJ
18637	2151	59	postulate	postulate	NN
18637	2151	60	upon	upon	IN
18637	2151	61	which	which	WDT
18637	2151	62	the	the	DT
18637	2151	63	authority	authority	NN
18637	2151	64	of	of	IN
18637	2151	65	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2151	66	to	to	TO
18637	2151	67	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	2151	68	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2151	69	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2151	70	importations	importation	NNS
18637	2151	71	as	as	IN
18637	2151	72	expounded	expound	VBN
18637	2151	73	by	by	IN
18637	2151	74	the	the	DT
18637	2151	75	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	2151	76	of	of	IN
18637	2151	77	this	this	DT
18637	2151	78	court	court	NN
18637	2151	79	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	2151	80	is	be	VBZ
18637	2151	81	the	the	DT
18637	2151	82	broad	broad	JJ
18637	2151	83	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	2151	84	which	which	WDT
18637	2151	85	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	2151	86	between	between	IN
18637	2151	87	the	the	DT
18637	2151	88	two	two	CD
18637	2151	89	powers	power	NNS
18637	2151	90	and	and	CC
18637	2151	91	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	2151	92	the	the	DT
18637	2151	93	cases	case	NNS
18637	2151	94	cited	cite	VBN
18637	2151	95	and	and	CC
18637	2151	96	many	many	JJ
18637	2151	97	more	more	JJR
18637	2151	98	which	which	WDT
18637	2151	99	might	may	MD
18637	2151	100	be	be	VB
18637	2151	101	cited	cite	VBN
18637	2151	102	announcing	announce	VBG
18637	2151	103	the	the	DT
18637	2151	104	principles	principle	NNS
18637	2151	105	which	which	WDT
18637	2151	106	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2151	107	uphold	uphold	VBP
18637	2151	108	have	have	VBP
18637	2151	109	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	2151	110	no	no	DT
18637	2151	111	relation	relation	NN
18637	2151	112	to	to	IN
18637	2151	113	the	the	DT
18637	2151	114	question	question	NN
18637	2151	115	in	in	IN
18637	2151	116	hand	hand	NN
18637	2151	117	.	.	.
18637	2152	1	"	"	``
18637	2152	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2152	3	486	486	CD
18637	2152	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2152	5	INTERSTATE	interstate	JJ
18637	2152	6	COMMERCE	COMMERCE	NNS
18637	2152	7	;	;	:
18637	2152	8	CONFLICT	conflict	NN
18637	2152	9	OF	of	IN
18637	2152	10	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNP
18637	2152	11	AND	and	CC
18637	2152	12	OPINION	opinion	VB
18637	2152	13	The	the	DT
18637	2152	14	question	question	NN
18637	2152	15	whether	whether	IN
18637	2152	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2152	17	's	's	POS
18637	2152	18	power	power	NN
18637	2152	19	to	to	TO
18637	2152	20	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2152	21	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2152	22	"	"	''
18637	2152	23	among	among	IN
18637	2152	24	the	the	DT
18637	2152	25	several	several	JJ
18637	2152	26	States	state	NNS
18637	2152	27	"	"	''
18637	2152	28	embraced	embrace	VBD
18637	2152	29	the	the	DT
18637	2152	30	power	power	NN
18637	2152	31	to	to	TO
18637	2152	32	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2152	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2152	34	furnished	furnish	VBD
18637	2152	35	the	the	DT
18637	2152	36	topic	topic	NN
18637	2152	37	of	of	IN
18637	2152	38	one	one	CD
18637	2152	39	of	of	IN
18637	2152	40	the	the	DT
18637	2152	41	most	most	RBS
18637	2152	42	protracted	protracted	JJ
18637	2152	43	debates	debate	NNS
18637	2152	44	in	in	IN
18637	2152	45	the	the	DT
18637	2152	46	entire	entire	JJ
18637	2152	47	history	history	NN
18637	2152	48	of	of	IN
18637	2152	49	the	the	DT
18637	2152	50	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2152	51	's	's	POS
18637	2152	52	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	2152	53	,	,	,
18637	2152	54	a	a	DT
18637	2152	55	debate	debate	NN
18637	2152	56	the	the	DT
18637	2152	57	final	final	JJ
18637	2152	58	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	2152	59	of	of	IN
18637	2152	60	which	which	WDT
18637	2152	61	in	in	IN
18637	2152	62	favor	favor	NN
18637	2152	63	of	of	IN
18637	2152	64	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2152	65	power	power	NN
18637	2152	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	2152	67	an	an	DT
18637	2152	68	event	event	NN
18637	2152	69	of	of	IN
18637	2152	70	first	first	JJ
18637	2152	71	importance	importance	NN
18637	2152	72	for	for	IN
18637	2152	73	the	the	DT
18637	2152	74	future	future	NN
18637	2152	75	of	of	IN
18637	2152	76	American	american	JJ
18637	2152	77	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	2152	78	.	.	.
18637	2153	1	The	the	DT
18637	2153	2	issue	issue	NN
18637	2153	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2153	4	as	as	RB
18637	2153	5	early	early	JJ
18637	2153	6	as	as	IN
18637	2153	7	1841	1841	CD
18637	2153	8	brought	bring	VBD
18637	2153	9	forward	forward	RP
18637	2153	10	by	by	IN
18637	2153	11	Henry	Henry	NNP
18637	2153	12	Clay	Clay	NNP
18637	2153	13	,	,	,
18637	2153	14	in	in	IN
18637	2153	15	an	an	DT
18637	2153	16	argument	argument	NN
18637	2153	17	before	before	IN
18637	2153	18	the	the	DT
18637	2153	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2153	20	in	in	IN
18637	2153	21	which	which	WDT
18637	2153	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2153	23	raised	raise	VBD
18637	2153	24	the	the	DT
18637	2153	25	specter	specter	NN
18637	2153	26	of	of	IN
18637	2153	27	an	an	DT
18637	2153	28	act	act	NN
18637	2153	29	of	of	IN
18637	2153	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2153	31	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	2153	32	the	the	DT
18637	2153	33	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2153	34	slave	slave	NN
18637	2153	35	trade	trade	NN
18637	2153	36	.	.	.
18637	2154	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2154	2	487	487	CD
18637	2154	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2154	4	The	the	DT
18637	2154	5	debate	debate	NN
18637	2154	6	was	be	VBD
18637	2154	7	concluded	conclude	VBN
18637	2154	8	ninety	ninety	CD
18637	2154	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	2154	10	nine	nine	CD
18637	2154	11	years	year	NNS
18637	2154	12	later	later	RB
18637	2154	13	by	by	IN
18637	2154	14	the	the	DT
18637	2154	15	decision	decision	NN
18637	2154	16	in	in	IN
18637	2154	17	United	United	NNP
18637	2154	18	States	States	NNP
18637	2154	19	_	_	NNP
18637	2154	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	2154	21	_	_	NNP
18637	2154	22	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	2154	23	,	,	,
18637	2154	24	in	in	IN
18637	2154	25	which	which	WDT
18637	2154	26	the	the	DT
18637	2154	27	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	2154	28	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	2154	29	Standards	Standards	NNP
18637	2154	30	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2154	31	was	be	VBD
18637	2154	32	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2154	33	.	.	.
18637	2155	1	The	the	DT
18637	2155	2	rÃ	rÃ	NNP
18637	2155	3	©	©	NN
18637	2155	4	sumÃ	sumã	CD
18637	2155	5	©	©	NNP
18637	2155	6	of	of	IN
18637	2155	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2155	8	which	which	WDT
18637	2155	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	2155	10	given	give	VBN
18637	2155	11	below	below	RB
18637	2155	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	2155	13	based	base	VBN
18637	2155	14	on	on	IN
18637	2155	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	2155	16	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	2155	17	,	,	,
18637	2155	18	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	2155	19	of	of	IN
18637	2155	20	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	2155	21	,	,	,
18637	2155	22	and	and	CC
18637	2155	23	the	the	DT
18637	2155	24	writings	writing	NNS
18637	2155	25	of	of	IN
18637	2155	26	jurists	jurist	NNS
18637	2155	27	and	and	CC
18637	2155	28	political	political	JJ
18637	2155	29	scientists	scientist	NNS
18637	2155	30	.	.	.
18637	2156	1	Much	much	JJ
18637	2156	2	of	of	IN
18637	2156	3	this	this	DT
18637	2156	4	material	material	NN
18637	2156	5	was	be	VBD
18637	2156	6	evoked	evoke	VBN
18637	2156	7	by	by	IN
18637	2156	8	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	2156	9	of	of	IN
18637	2156	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2156	11	,	,	,
18637	2156	12	from	from	IN
18637	2156	13	about	about	IN
18637	2156	14	1905	1905	CD
18637	2156	15	onward	onward	RB
18637	2156	16	,	,	,
18637	2156	17	to	to	TO
18637	2156	18	stop	stop	VB
18637	2156	19	the	the	DT
18637	2156	20	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2156	21	interstate	interstate	NN
18637	2156	22	of	of	IN
18637	2156	23	the	the	DT
18637	2156	24	products	product	NNS
18637	2156	25	of	of	IN
18637	2156	26	child	child	NN
18637	2156	27	labor	labor	NN
18637	2156	28	.	.	.
18637	2157	1	ACTS	ACTS	NNP
18637	2157	2	OF	of	IN
18637	2157	3	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	2157	4	PROHIBITIVE	PROHIBITIVE	NNP
18637	2157	5	OF	of	IN
18637	2157	6	INTERSTATE	INTERSTATE	NNP
18637	2157	7	COMMERCE	COMMERCE	.
18637	2157	8	The	the	DT
18637	2157	9	earliest	early	JJS
18637	2157	10	such	such	JJ
18637	2157	11	acts	act	NNS
18637	2157	12	were	be	VBD
18637	2157	13	in	in	IN
18637	2157	14	the	the	DT
18637	2157	15	nature	nature	NN
18637	2157	16	of	of	IN
18637	2157	17	quarantine	quarantine	NN
18637	2157	18	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2157	19	and	and	CC
18637	2157	20	usually	usually	RB
18637	2157	21	dealt	deal	VBD
18637	2157	22	solely	solely	RB
18637	2157	23	with	with	IN
18637	2157	24	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2157	25	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2157	26	.	.	.
18637	2158	1	In	in	IN
18637	2158	2	1884	1884	CD
18637	2158	3	the	the	DT
18637	2158	4	exportation	exportation	NN
18637	2158	5	or	or	CC
18637	2158	6	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2158	7	in	in	IN
18637	2158	8	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2158	9	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2158	10	of	of	IN
18637	2158	11	livestock	livestock	NN
18637	2158	12	having	have	VBG
18637	2158	13	any	any	DT
18637	2158	14	infectious	infectious	JJ
18637	2158	15	disease	disease	NN
18637	2158	16	was	be	VBD
18637	2158	17	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	2158	18	.	.	.
18637	2159	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2159	2	488	488	CD
18637	2159	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2159	4	In	in	IN
18637	2159	5	1903	1903	CD
18637	2159	6	power	power	NN
18637	2159	7	was	be	VBD
18637	2159	8	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	2159	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	2159	10	the	the	DT
18637	2159	11	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	2159	12	of	of	IN
18637	2159	13	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	2159	14	to	to	TO
18637	2159	15	establish	establish	VB
18637	2159	16	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2159	17	to	to	TO
18637	2159	18	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2159	19	the	the	DT
18637	2159	20	spread	spread	NN
18637	2159	21	of	of	IN
18637	2159	22	such	such	JJ
18637	2159	23	diseases	disease	NNS
18637	2159	24	through	through	IN
18637	2159	25	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2159	26	or	or	CC
18637	2159	27	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2159	28	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2159	29	.	.	.
18637	2160	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2160	2	489	489	CD
18637	2160	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2160	4	In	in	IN
18637	2160	5	1905	1905	CD
18637	2160	6	the	the	DT
18637	2160	7	same	same	JJ
18637	2160	8	official	official	NN
18637	2160	9	was	be	VBD
18637	2160	10	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	2160	11	to	to	TO
18637	2160	12	lay	lay	VB
18637	2160	13	an	an	DT
18637	2160	14	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	2160	15	embargo	embargo	NN
18637	2160	16	or	or	CC
18637	2160	17	quarantine	quarantine	NN
18637	2160	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	2160	19	all	all	DT
18637	2160	20	shipments	shipment	NNS
18637	2160	21	of	of	IN
18637	2160	22	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	2160	23	from	from	IN
18637	2160	24	one	one	CD
18637	2160	25	State	state	NN
18637	2160	26	to	to	IN
18637	2160	27	another	another	DT
18637	2160	28	when	when	WRB
18637	2160	29	the	the	DT
18637	2160	30	public	public	JJ
18637	2160	31	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	2160	32	might	may	MD
18637	2160	33	demand	demand	VB
18637	2160	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2160	35	.	.	.
18637	2161	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2161	2	490	490	CD
18637	2161	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2161	4	A	a	DT
18637	2161	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	2161	6	passed	pass	VBD
18637	2161	7	in	in	IN
18637	2161	8	1905	1905	CD
18637	2161	9	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	2161	10	the	the	DT
18637	2161	11	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2161	12	in	in	IN
18637	2161	13	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2161	14	and	and	CC
18637	2161	15	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2161	16	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2161	17	and	and	CC
18637	2161	18	the	the	DT
18637	2161	19	mails	mail	NNS
18637	2161	20	of	of	IN
18637	2161	21	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2161	22	varieties	variety	NNS
18637	2161	23	of	of	IN
18637	2161	24	moths	moth	NNS
18637	2161	25	,	,	,
18637	2161	26	plant	plant	NN
18637	2161	27	lice	lice	NN
18637	2161	28	,	,	,
18637	2161	29	and	and	CC
18637	2161	30	other	other	JJ
18637	2161	31	insect	insect	NN
18637	2161	32	pests	pest	NNS
18637	2161	33	injurious	injurious	JJ
18637	2161	34	to	to	TO
18637	2161	35	plant	plant	VB
18637	2161	36	crops	crop	NNS
18637	2161	37	,	,	,
18637	2161	38	trees	tree	NNS
18637	2161	39	,	,	,
18637	2161	40	and	and	CC
18637	2161	41	other	other	JJ
18637	2161	42	vegetation	vegetation	NN
18637	2161	43	.	.	.
18637	2162	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2162	2	491	491	CD
18637	2162	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2162	4	In	in	IN
18637	2162	5	1912	1912	CD
18637	2162	6	a	a	DT
18637	2162	7	similar	similar	JJ
18637	2162	8	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	2162	9	of	of	IN
18637	2162	10	diseased	diseased	JJ
18637	2162	11	nursery	nursery	NN
18637	2162	12	stock	stock	NN
18637	2162	13	was	be	VBD
18637	2162	14	decreed,[492	decreed,[492	NNS
18637	2162	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2162	16	while	while	IN
18637	2162	17	by	by	IN
18637	2162	18	the	the	DT
18637	2162	19	same	same	JJ
18637	2162	20	act	act	NN
18637	2162	21	,	,	,
18637	2162	22	and	and	CC
18637	2162	23	again	again	RB
18637	2162	24	by	by	IN
18637	2162	25	an	an	DT
18637	2162	26	act	act	NN
18637	2162	27	of	of	IN
18637	2162	28	1917,[493	1917,[493	CD
18637	2162	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2162	30	the	the	DT
18637	2162	31	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	2162	32	of	of	IN
18637	2162	33	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	2162	34	was	be	VBD
18637	2162	35	invested	invest	VBN
18637	2162	36	with	with	IN
18637	2162	37	powers	power	NNS
18637	2162	38	of	of	IN
18637	2162	39	quarantine	quarantine	NN
18637	2162	40	on	on	IN
18637	2162	41	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2162	42	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2162	43	for	for	IN
18637	2162	44	the	the	DT
18637	2162	45	protection	protection	NN
18637	2162	46	of	of	IN
18637	2162	47	plant	plant	NN
18637	2162	48	life	life	NN
18637	2162	49	from	from	IN
18637	2162	50	disease	disease	NN
18637	2162	51	similar	similar	JJ
18637	2162	52	to	to	IN
18637	2162	53	those	those	DT
18637	2162	54	above	above	RB
18637	2162	55	described	describe	VBN
18637	2162	56	for	for	IN
18637	2162	57	the	the	DT
18637	2162	58	prevention	prevention	NN
18637	2162	59	of	of	IN
18637	2162	60	the	the	DT
18637	2162	61	spread	spread	NN
18637	2162	62	of	of	IN
18637	2162	63	animal	animal	NN
18637	2162	64	disease	disease	NN
18637	2162	65	.	.	.
18637	2163	1	While	while	IN
18637	2163	2	the	the	DT
18637	2163	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2163	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2163	5	originally	originally	RB
18637	2163	6	held	hold	VBD
18637	2163	7	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2163	8	quarantine	quarantine	NN
18637	2163	9	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2163	10	of	of	IN
18637	2163	11	this	this	DT
18637	2163	12	sort	sort	NN
18637	2163	13	to	to	TO
18637	2163	14	be	be	VB
18637	2163	15	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	2163	16	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	2163	17	to	to	IN
18637	2163	18	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2163	19	shipments	shipment	NNS
18637	2163	20	of	of	IN
18637	2163	21	livestock	livestock	NN
18637	2163	22	,	,	,
18637	2163	23	on	on	IN
18637	2163	24	the	the	DT
18637	2163	25	ground	ground	NN
18637	2163	26	that	that	IN
18637	2163	27	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2163	28	authority	authority	NN
18637	2163	29	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	2163	30	only	only	RB
18637	2163	31	to	to	IN
18637	2163	32	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2163	33	and	and	CC
18637	2163	34	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2163	35	commerce,[494	commerce,[494	NNP
18637	2163	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2163	37	this	this	DT
18637	2163	38	view	view	NN
18637	2163	39	has	have	VBZ
18637	2163	40	today	today	NN
18637	2163	41	been	be	VBN
18637	2163	42	abandoned	abandon	VBN
18637	2163	43	.	.	.
18637	2164	1	_	_	NNP
18637	2164	2	See	See	NNP
18637	2164	3	_	_	NNP
18637	2164	4	pp	pp	NNP
18637	2164	5	.	.	.
18637	2165	1	248	248	CD
18637	2165	2	-	-	SYM
18637	2165	3	249	249	CD
18637	2165	4	.	.	.
18637	2166	1	THE	the	DT
18637	2166	2	LOTTERY	LOTTERY	NNP
18637	2166	3	CASE	case	NN
18637	2166	4	The	the	DT
18637	2166	5	first	first	JJ
18637	2166	6	case	case	NN
18637	2166	7	to	to	TO
18637	2166	8	come	come	VB
18637	2166	9	before	before	IN
18637	2166	10	the	the	DT
18637	2166	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2166	12	in	in	IN
18637	2166	13	which	which	WDT
18637	2166	14	the	the	DT
18637	2166	15	issues	issue	NNS
18637	2166	16	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	2166	17	above	above	RB
18637	2166	18	were	be	VBD
18637	2166	19	canvassed	canvass	VBN
18637	2166	20	at	at	RB
18637	2166	21	all	all	RB
18637	2166	22	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
18637	2166	23	was	be	VBD
18637	2166	24	Champion	Champion	NNP
18637	2166	25	_	_	NNP
18637	2166	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	2166	27	_	_	NNP
18637	2166	28	Ames,[495	Ames,[495	NNP
18637	2166	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2166	30	involving	involve	VBG
18637	2166	31	the	the	DT
18637	2166	32	act	act	NN
18637	2166	33	of	of	IN
18637	2166	34	1895	1895	CD
18637	2166	35	"	"	``
18637	2166	36	for	for	IN
18637	2166	37	the	the	DT
18637	2166	38	suppression	suppression	NN
18637	2166	39	of	of	IN
18637	2166	40	lotteries	lottery	NNS
18637	2166	41	.	.	.
18637	2167	1	"	"	``
18637	2167	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2167	3	496	496	CD
18637	2167	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2167	5	An	an	DT
18637	2167	6	earlier	early	JJR
18637	2167	7	act	act	NN
18637	2167	8	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	2167	9	lottery	lottery	NN
18637	2167	10	tickets	ticket	NNS
18637	2167	11	from	from	IN
18637	2167	12	the	the	DT
18637	2167	13	mails	mail	NNS
18637	2167	14	had	have	VBD
18637	2167	15	been	be	VBN
18637	2167	16	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	2167	17	in	in	IN
18637	2167	18	the	the	DT
18637	2167	19	earlier	early	JJR
18637	2167	20	case	case	NN
18637	2167	21	of	of	IN
18637	2167	22	In	in	IN
18637	2167	23	re	re	NN
18637	2167	24	Rapier,[497	rapier,[497	NN
18637	2167	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2167	26	on	on	IN
18637	2167	27	the	the	DT
18637	2167	28	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	2167	29	that	that	WDT
18637	2167	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2167	31	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	2167	32	had	have	VBD
18637	2167	33	the	the	DT
18637	2167	34	power	power	NN
18637	2167	35	to	to	TO
18637	2167	36	see	see	VB
18637	2167	37	that	that	IN
18637	2167	38	the	the	DT
18637	2167	39	very	very	JJ
18637	2167	40	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	2167	41	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	2167	42	by	by	IN
18637	2167	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2167	44	were	be	VBD
18637	2167	45	not	not	RB
18637	2167	46	put	put	VBN
18637	2167	47	to	to	IN
18637	2167	48	bad	bad	JJ
18637	2167	49	uses	use	NNS
18637	2167	50	.	.	.
18637	2168	1	But	but	CC
18637	2168	2	in	in	IN
18637	2168	3	the	the	DT
18637	2168	4	case	case	NN
18637	2168	5	of	of	IN
18637	2168	6	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2168	7	the	the	DT
18637	2168	8	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	2168	9	are	be	VBP
18637	2168	10	not	not	RB
18637	2168	11	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	2168	12	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	2168	13	by	by	IN
18637	2168	14	the	the	DT
18637	2168	15	National	National	NNP
18637	2168	16	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2168	17	,	,	,
18637	2168	18	and	and	CC
18637	2168	19	the	the	DT
18637	2168	20	right	right	NN
18637	2168	21	to	to	TO
18637	2168	22	engage	engage	VB
18637	2168	23	in	in	IN
18637	2168	24	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2168	25	and	and	CC
18637	2168	26	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2168	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2168	28	comes	come	VBZ
18637	2168	29	from	from	IN
18637	2168	30	the	the	DT
18637	2168	31	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2168	32	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2168	33	,	,	,
18637	2168	34	or	or	CC
18637	2168	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	2168	36	anterior	anterior	JJ
18637	2168	37	to	to	IN
18637	2168	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2168	39	.	.	.
18637	2169	1	How	how	WRB
18637	2169	2	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	2169	3	the	the	DT
18637	2169	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2169	5	found	find	VBD
18637	2169	6	the	the	DT
18637	2169	7	question	question	NN
18637	2169	8	produced	produce	VBN
18637	2169	9	by	by	IN
18637	2169	10	the	the	DT
18637	2169	11	act	act	NN
18637	2169	12	of	of	IN
18637	2169	13	1895	1895	CD
18637	2169	14	,	,	,
18637	2169	15	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	2169	16	any	any	DT
18637	2169	17	person	person	NN
18637	2169	18	to	to	TO
18637	2169	19	bring	bring	VB
18637	2169	20	within	within	IN
18637	2169	21	the	the	DT
18637	2169	22	United	United	NNP
18637	2169	23	States	States	NNP
18637	2169	24	or	or	CC
18637	2169	25	to	to	TO
18637	2169	26	cause	cause	VB
18637	2169	27	to	to	TO
18637	2169	28	be	be	VB
18637	2169	29	"	"	``
18637	2169	30	carried	carry	VBN
18637	2169	31	from	from	IN
18637	2169	32	one	one	CD
18637	2169	33	State	state	NN
18637	2169	34	to	to	IN
18637	2169	35	another	another	DT
18637	2169	36	"	"	``
18637	2169	37	any	any	DT
18637	2169	38	lottery	lottery	NN
18637	2169	39	ticket	ticket	NN
18637	2169	40	,	,	,
18637	2169	41	or	or	CC
18637	2169	42	an	an	DT
18637	2169	43	equivalent	equivalent	NN
18637	2169	44	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	2169	45	,	,	,
18637	2169	46	"	"	``
18637	2169	47	for	for	IN
18637	2169	48	the	the	DT
18637	2169	49	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2169	50	of	of	IN
18637	2169	51	disposing	dispose	VBG
18637	2169	52	of	of	IN
18637	2169	53	the	the	DT
18637	2169	54	same	same	JJ
18637	2169	55	,	,	,
18637	2169	56	"	"	''
18637	2169	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	2169	58	shown	show	VBN
18637	2169	59	by	by	IN
18637	2169	60	the	the	DT
18637	2169	61	fact	fact	NN
18637	2169	62	that	that	IN
18637	2169	63	the	the	DT
18637	2169	64	case	case	NN
18637	2169	65	was	be	VBD
18637	2169	66	thrice	thrice	NN
18637	2169	67	argued	argue	VBN
18637	2169	68	before	before	IN
18637	2169	69	the	the	DT
18637	2169	70	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2169	71	,	,	,
18637	2169	72	and	and	CC
18637	2169	73	the	the	DT
18637	2169	74	fact	fact	NN
18637	2169	75	that	that	IN
18637	2169	76	the	the	DT
18637	2169	77	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2169	78	's	's	POS
18637	2169	79	decision	decision	NN
18637	2169	80	finally	finally	RB
18637	2169	81	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	2169	82	the	the	DT
18637	2169	83	act	act	NN
18637	2169	84	was	be	VBD
18637	2169	85	a	a	DT
18637	2169	86	five	five	CD
18637	2169	87	-	-	HYPH
18637	2169	88	to	to	IN
18637	2169	89	-	-	HYPH
18637	2169	90	four	four	CD
18637	2169	91	decision	decision	NN
18637	2169	92	.	.	.
18637	2170	1	The	the	DT
18637	2170	2	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2170	3	of	of	IN
18637	2170	4	the	the	DT
18637	2170	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2170	6	,	,	,
18637	2170	7	on	on	IN
18637	2170	8	the	the	DT
18637	2170	9	other	other	JJ
18637	2170	10	hand	hand	NN
18637	2170	11	,	,	,
18637	2170	12	prepared	prepare	VBN
18637	2170	13	by	by	IN
18637	2170	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2170	15	Harlan	Harlan	NNP
18637	2170	16	,	,	,
18637	2170	17	marked	mark	VBD
18637	2170	18	an	an	DT
18637	2170	19	almost	almost	RB
18637	2170	20	unqualified	unqualified	JJ
18637	2170	21	triumph	triumph	NN
18637	2170	22	at	at	IN
18637	2170	23	the	the	DT
18637	2170	24	time	time	NN
18637	2170	25	for	for	IN
18637	2170	26	the	the	DT
18637	2170	27	view	view	NN
18637	2170	28	that	that	IN
18637	2170	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2170	30	's	's	POS
18637	2170	31	power	power	NN
18637	2170	32	to	to	TO
18637	2170	33	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2170	34	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2170	35	among	among	IN
18637	2170	36	the	the	DT
18637	2170	37	States	States	NNP
18637	2170	38	includes	include	VBZ
18637	2170	39	the	the	DT
18637	2170	40	power	power	NN
18637	2170	41	to	to	TO
18637	2170	42	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2170	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2170	44	,	,	,
18637	2170	45	especially	especially	RB
18637	2170	46	to	to	TO
18637	2170	47	supplement	supplement	VB
18637	2170	48	and	and	CC
18637	2170	49	support	support	VB
18637	2170	50	State	State	NNP
18637	2170	51	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2170	52	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	2170	53	under	under	IN
18637	2170	54	the	the	DT
18637	2170	55	police	police	NN
18637	2170	56	power	power	NN
18637	2170	57	.	.	.
18637	2171	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2171	2	498	498	CD
18637	2171	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2171	4	Early	early	RB
18637	2171	5	in	in	IN
18637	2171	6	the	the	DT
18637	2171	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2171	8	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	2171	9	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	2171	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	2171	11	made	make	VBN
18637	2171	12	from	from	IN
18637	2171	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2171	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2171	15	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2171	16	's	's	POS
18637	2171	17	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2171	18	in	in	IN
18637	2171	19	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	2171	20	_	_	NNP
18637	2171	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	2171	22	_	_	NNP
18637	2171	23	Ogden,[499	Ogden,[499	NNP
18637	2171	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2171	25	with	with	IN
18637	2171	26	special	special	JJ
18637	2171	27	stress	stress	NN
18637	2171	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	2171	29	the	the	DT
18637	2171	30	definition	definition	NN
18637	2171	31	there	there	RB
18637	2171	32	given	give	VBN
18637	2171	33	of	of	IN
18637	2171	34	the	the	DT
18637	2171	35	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	2171	36	"	"	''
18637	2171	37	to	to	TO
18637	2171	38	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2171	39	.	.	.
18637	2171	40	"	"	''
18637	2172	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2172	2	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	2172	3	's	's	POS
18637	2172	4	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	2172	5	on	on	IN
18637	2172	6	the	the	DT
18637	2172	7	same	same	JJ
18637	2172	8	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	2172	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	2172	10	also	also	RB
18637	2172	11	given	give	VBN
18637	2172	12	:	:	:
18637	2172	13	"	"	``
18637	2172	14	The	the	DT
18637	2172	15	power	power	NN
18637	2172	16	of	of	IN
18637	2172	17	a	a	DT
18637	2172	18	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	2172	19	State	State	NNP
18637	2172	20	over	over	IN
18637	2172	21	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2172	22	,	,	,
18637	2172	23	*	*	NFP
18637	2172	24	*	*	NFP
18637	2172	25	*	*	NFP
18637	2172	26	,	,	,
18637	2172	27	amounts	amount	VBZ
18637	2172	28	to	to	IN
18637	2172	29	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	2172	30	more	more	JJR
18637	2172	31	than	than	IN
18637	2172	32	,	,	,
18637	2172	33	a	a	DT
18637	2172	34	power	power	NN
18637	2172	35	to	to	TO
18637	2172	36	limit	limit	VB
18637	2172	37	and	and	CC
18637	2172	38	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	2172	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2172	40	at	at	IN
18637	2172	41	pleasure	pleasure	NN
18637	2172	42	.	.	.
18637	2172	43	"	"	''
18637	2173	1	Further	further	RB
18637	2173	2	along	along	RB
18637	2173	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	2173	4	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	2173	5	with	with	IN
18637	2173	6	evident	evident	JJ
18637	2173	7	approval	approval	NN
18637	2173	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2173	9	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	2173	10	's	's	POS
18637	2173	11	statement	statement	NN
18637	2173	12	in	in	IN
18637	2173	13	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	2173	14	_	_	NNP
18637	2173	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	2173	16	_	_	NNP
18637	2173	17	Houston,[500	Houston,[500	NNP
18637	2173	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2173	19	that	that	IN
18637	2173	20	"	"	``
18637	2173	21	the	the	DT
18637	2173	22	power	power	NN
18637	2173	23	to	to	TO
18637	2173	24	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2173	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2173	26	among	among	IN
18637	2173	27	the	the	DT
18637	2173	28	several	several	JJ
18637	2173	29	States	States	NNP
18637	2173	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	2173	31	granted	grant	VBN
18637	2173	32	to	to	IN
18637	2173	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2173	34	in	in	IN
18637	2173	35	terms	term	NNS
18637	2173	36	as	as	RB
18637	2173	37	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	2173	38	as	as	IN
18637	2173	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	2173	40	the	the	DT
18637	2173	41	power	power	NN
18637	2173	42	to	to	TO
18637	2173	43	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2173	44	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2173	45	with	with	IN
18637	2173	46	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2173	47	nations	nation	NNS
18637	2173	48	.	.	.
18637	2173	49	"	"	''
18637	2174	1	NATIONAL	NATIONAL	NNP
18637	2174	2	PROHIBITIONS	PROHIBITIONS	NNP
18637	2174	3	AND	and	CC
18637	2174	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2174	5	POLICE	police	NN
18637	2174	6	POWER	power	NN
18637	2174	7	Following	follow	VBG
18637	2174	8	in	in	IN
18637	2174	9	the	the	DT
18637	2174	10	wake	wake	NN
18637	2174	11	of	of	IN
18637	2174	12	Champion	Champion	NNP
18637	2174	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2174	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	2174	15	_	_	NNP
18637	2174	16	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	2174	17	,	,	,
18637	2174	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2174	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	2174	20	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	2174	21	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2174	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2174	23	prohibitory	prohibitory	JJ
18637	2174	24	powers	power	NNS
18637	2174	25	over	over	IN
18637	2174	26	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2174	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2174	28	and	and	CC
18637	2174	29	communications	communication	NNS
18637	2174	30	to	to	IN
18637	2174	31	the	the	DT
18637	2174	32	support	support	NN
18637	2174	33	of	of	IN
18637	2174	34	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2174	35	local	local	JJ
18637	2174	36	policies	policy	NNS
18637	2174	37	of	of	IN
18637	2174	38	the	the	DT
18637	2174	39	States	States	NNPS
18637	2174	40	in	in	IN
18637	2174	41	the	the	DT
18637	2174	42	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2174	43	of	of	IN
18637	2174	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2174	45	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	2174	46	powers	power	NNS
18637	2174	47	,	,	,
18637	2174	48	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	2174	49	aiding	aid	VBG
18637	2174	50	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2174	51	in	in	IN
18637	2174	52	the	the	DT
18637	2174	53	repression	repression	NN
18637	2174	54	of	of	IN
18637	2174	55	the	the	DT
18637	2174	56	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	2174	57	traffic,[501	traffic,[501	NN
18637	2174	58	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2174	59	of	of	IN
18637	2174	60	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2174	61	in	in	IN
18637	2174	62	game	game	NN
18637	2174	63	taken	take	VBN
18637	2174	64	in	in	IN
18637	2174	65	violation	violation	NN
18637	2174	66	of	of	IN
18637	2174	67	State	State	NNP
18637	2174	68	laws,[502	laws,[502	NNP
18637	2174	69	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2174	70	of	of	IN
18637	2174	71	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2174	72	in	in	IN
18637	2174	73	convict	convict	NN
18637	2174	74	-	-	HYPH
18637	2174	75	made	make	VBN
18637	2174	76	goods,[503	goods,[503	NN
18637	2174	77	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2174	78	of	of	IN
18637	2174	79	the	the	DT
18637	2174	80	white	white	JJ
18637	2174	81	slave	slave	NN
18637	2174	82	traffic,[504	traffic,[504	NN
18637	2174	83	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2174	84	of	of	IN
18637	2174	85	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2174	86	in	in	IN
18637	2174	87	stolen	steal	VBN
18637	2174	88	motor	motor	NNP
18637	2174	89	vehicles,[505	vehicles,[505	NN
18637	2174	90	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2174	91	of	of	IN
18637	2174	92	kidnapping,[506	kidnapping,[506	NN
18637	2174	93	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2174	94	of	of	IN
18637	2174	95	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2174	96	in	in	IN
18637	2174	97	stolen	steal	VBN
18637	2174	98	property,[507	property,[507	NN
18637	2174	99	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2174	100	of	of	IN
18637	2174	101	racketeering,[508	racketeering,[508	NNS
18637	2174	102	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2174	103	of	of	IN
18637	2174	104	prize	prize	NN
18637	2174	105	-	-	HYPH
18637	2174	106	fight	fight	NN
18637	2174	107	films	film	NNS
18637	2174	108	or	or	CC
18637	2174	109	other	other	JJ
18637	2174	110	pictorial	pictorial	JJ
18637	2174	111	representation	representation	NN
18637	2174	112	of	of	IN
18637	2174	113	encounters	encounter	NNS
18637	2174	114	of	of	IN
18637	2174	115	pugilists	pugilist	NNS
18637	2174	116	.	.	.
18637	2175	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2175	2	509	509	CD
18637	2175	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2175	4	The	the	DT
18637	2175	5	conception	conception	NN
18637	2175	6	of	of	IN
18637	2175	7	the	the	DT
18637	2175	8	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2175	9	System	System	NNP
18637	2175	10	on	on	IN
18637	2175	11	which	which	WDT
18637	2175	12	the	the	DT
18637	2175	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2175	14	based	base	VBD
18637	2175	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2175	16	validation	validation	NN
18637	2175	17	of	of	IN
18637	2175	18	this	this	DT
18637	2175	19	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2175	20	was	be	VBD
18637	2175	21	stated	state	VBN
18637	2175	22	by	by	IN
18637	2175	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2175	24	in	in	IN
18637	2175	25	1913	1913	CD
18637	2175	26	in	in	IN
18637	2175	27	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	2175	28	the	the	DT
18637	2175	29	Mann	Mann	NNP
18637	2175	30	"	"	``
18637	2175	31	White	White	NNP
18637	2175	32	Slave	Slave	NNP
18637	2175	33	"	"	''
18637	2175	34	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2175	35	in	in	IN
18637	2175	36	the	the	DT
18637	2175	37	following	follow	VBG
18637	2175	38	words	word	NNS
18637	2175	39	:	:	:
18637	2175	40	"	"	``
18637	2175	41	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2175	42	dual	dual	JJ
18637	2175	43	form	form	NN
18637	2175	44	of	of	IN
18637	2175	45	government	government	NN
18637	2175	46	has	have	VBZ
18637	2175	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2175	48	perplexities	perplexity	NNS
18637	2175	49	,	,	,
18637	2175	50	State	State	NNP
18637	2175	51	and	and	CC
18637	2175	52	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	2175	53	having	have	VBG
18637	2175	54	different	different	JJ
18637	2175	55	spheres	sphere	NNS
18637	2175	56	of	of	IN
18637	2175	57	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2175	58	,	,	,
18637	2175	59	*	*	NFP
18637	2175	60	*	*	NFP
18637	2175	61	*	*	NFP
18637	2175	62	,	,	,
18637	2175	63	but	but	CC
18637	2175	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2175	65	must	must	MD
18637	2175	66	be	be	VB
18637	2175	67	kept	keep	VBN
18637	2175	68	in	in	IN
18637	2175	69	mind	mind	NN
18637	2175	70	that	that	IN
18637	2175	71	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2175	72	are	be	VBP
18637	2175	73	one	one	CD
18637	2175	74	people	people	NNS
18637	2175	75	;	;	:
18637	2175	76	and	and	CC
18637	2175	77	the	the	DT
18637	2175	78	powers	power	NNS
18637	2175	79	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	2175	80	to	to	IN
18637	2175	81	the	the	DT
18637	2175	82	States	States	NNPS
18637	2175	83	and	and	CC
18637	2175	84	those	those	DT
18637	2175	85	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	2175	86	on	on	IN
18637	2175	87	the	the	DT
18637	2175	88	Nation	nation	NN
18637	2175	89	are	be	VBP
18637	2175	90	adapted	adapt	VBN
18637	2175	91	to	to	TO
18637	2175	92	be	be	VB
18637	2175	93	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	2175	94	,	,	,
18637	2175	95	whether	whether	CC
18637	2175	96	independently	independently	RB
18637	2175	97	or	or	CC
18637	2175	98	concurrently	concurrently	RB
18637	2175	99	,	,	,
18637	2175	100	to	to	TO
18637	2175	101	promote	promote	VB
18637	2175	102	the	the	DT
18637	2175	103	general	general	JJ
18637	2175	104	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	2175	105	,	,	,
18637	2175	106	material	material	NN
18637	2175	107	,	,	,
18637	2175	108	and	and	CC
18637	2175	109	moral	moral	JJ
18637	2175	110	.	.	.
18637	2176	1	"	"	``
18637	2176	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2176	3	510	510	CD
18637	2176	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2176	5	At	at	IN
18637	2176	6	the	the	DT
18637	2176	7	same	same	JJ
18637	2176	8	time	time	NN
18637	2176	9	,	,	,
18637	2176	10	the	the	DT
18637	2176	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2176	12	made	make	VBD
18637	2176	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2176	14	plain	plain	JJ
18637	2176	15	that	that	IN
18637	2176	16	in	in	IN
18637	2176	17	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	2176	18	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2176	19	among	among	IN
18637	2176	20	the	the	DT
18637	2176	21	States	States	NNPS
18637	2176	22	,	,	,
18637	2176	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2176	24	was	be	VBD
18637	2176	25	equally	equally	RB
18637	2176	26	free	free	JJ
18637	2176	27	to	to	TO
18637	2176	28	support	support	VB
18637	2176	29	State	state	NN
18637	2176	30	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2176	31	policy	policy	NN
18637	2176	32	or	or	CC
18637	2176	33	to	to	TO
18637	2176	34	devise	devise	VB
18637	2176	35	a	a	DT
18637	2176	36	policy	policy	NN
18637	2176	37	of	of	IN
18637	2176	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2176	39	own	own	JJ
18637	2176	40	.	.	.
18637	2177	1	"	"	``
18637	2177	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2177	3	,	,	,
18637	2177	4	"	"	''
18637	2177	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2177	6	said	say	VBD
18637	2177	7	,	,	,
18637	2177	8	"	"	``
18637	2177	9	may	may	MD
18637	2177	10	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	2177	11	this	this	DT
18637	2177	12	authority	authority	NN
18637	2177	13	in	in	IN
18637	2177	14	aid	aid	NN
18637	2177	15	of	of	IN
18637	2177	16	the	the	DT
18637	2177	17	policy	policy	NN
18637	2177	18	of	of	IN
18637	2177	19	the	the	DT
18637	2177	20	State	State	NNP
18637	2177	21	,	,	,
18637	2177	22	if	if	IN
18637	2177	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2177	24	sees	see	VBZ
18637	2177	25	fit	fit	JJ
18637	2177	26	to	to	TO
18637	2177	27	do	do	VB
18637	2177	28	so	so	RB
18637	2177	29	.	.	.
18637	2178	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2178	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2178	3	equally	equally	RB
18637	2178	4	clear	clear	JJ
18637	2178	5	that	that	IN
18637	2178	6	the	the	DT
18637	2178	7	policy	policy	NN
18637	2178	8	of	of	IN
18637	2178	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2178	10	acting	act	VBG
18637	2178	11	independently	independently	RB
18637	2178	12	of	of	IN
18637	2178	13	the	the	DT
18637	2178	14	States	States	NNPS
18637	2178	15	may	may	MD
18637	2178	16	induce	induce	VB
18637	2178	17	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2178	18	without	without	IN
18637	2178	19	reference	reference	NN
18637	2178	20	to	to	IN
18637	2178	21	the	the	DT
18637	2178	22	particular	particular	JJ
18637	2178	23	policy	policy	NN
18637	2178	24	or	or	CC
18637	2178	25	law	law	NN
18637	2178	26	of	of	IN
18637	2178	27	any	any	DT
18637	2178	28	given	give	VBN
18637	2178	29	State	state	NN
18637	2178	30	.	.	.
18637	2179	1	Acting	act	VBG
18637	2179	2	within	within	IN
18637	2179	3	the	the	DT
18637	2179	4	authority	authority	NN
18637	2179	5	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	2179	6	by	by	IN
18637	2179	7	the	the	DT
18637	2179	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2179	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2179	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	2179	11	for	for	IN
18637	2179	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2179	13	to	to	TO
18637	2179	14	determine	determine	VB
18637	2179	15	what	what	WDT
18637	2179	16	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2179	17	will	will	MD
18637	2179	18	attain	attain	VB
18637	2179	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2179	20	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	2179	21	.	.	.
18637	2180	1	The	the	DT
18637	2180	2	control	control	NN
18637	2180	3	of	of	IN
18637	2180	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2180	5	over	over	IN
18637	2180	6	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2180	7	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2180	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	2180	9	not	not	RB
18637	2180	10	to	to	TO
18637	2180	11	be	be	VB
18637	2180	12	limited	limit	VBN
18637	2180	13	by	by	IN
18637	2180	14	State	State	NNP
18637	2180	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	2180	16	.	.	.
18637	2181	1	"	"	``
18637	2181	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2181	3	511	511	CD
18637	2181	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2181	5	HAMMER	HAMMER	NNP
18637	2181	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2181	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	2181	8	_	_	NNP
18637	2181	9	DAGENHART	DAGENHART	NNP
18637	2181	10	However	however	RB
18637	2181	11	,	,	,
18637	2181	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2181	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	2181	14	to	to	TO
18637	2181	15	be	be	VB
18637	2181	16	noted	note	VBN
18637	2181	17	that	that	IN
18637	2181	18	none	none	NN
18637	2181	19	of	of	IN
18637	2181	20	this	this	DT
18637	2181	21	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2181	22	operated	operate	VBN
18637	2181	23	in	in	IN
18637	2181	24	the	the	DT
18637	2181	25	field	field	NN
18637	2181	26	of	of	IN
18637	2181	27	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	2181	28	relations	relation	NNS
18637	2181	29	.	.	.
18637	2182	1	So	so	RB
18637	2182	2	when	when	WRB
18637	2182	3	the	the	DT
18637	2182	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2182	5	was	be	VBD
18637	2182	6	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	2182	7	in	in	IN
18637	2182	8	1918	1918	CD
18637	2182	9	,	,	,
18637	2182	10	in	in	IN
18637	2182	11	the	the	DT
18637	2182	12	case	case	NN
18637	2182	13	of	of	IN
18637	2182	14	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	2182	15	_	_	NNP
18637	2182	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	2182	17	_	_	NNP
18637	2182	18	Dagenhart,[512	Dagenhart,[512	NNP
18637	2182	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2182	20	with	with	IN
18637	2182	21	an	an	DT
18637	2182	22	act	act	NN
18637	2182	23	which	which	WDT
18637	2182	24	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	2182	25	manufacturers	manufacturer	NNS
18637	2182	26	and	and	CC
18637	2182	27	others	other	NNS
18637	2182	28	to	to	TO
18637	2182	29	offer	offer	VB
18637	2182	30	child	child	NN
18637	2182	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	2182	32	made	make	VBN
18637	2182	33	goods	good	NNS
18637	2182	34	for	for	IN
18637	2182	35	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2182	36	in	in	IN
18637	2182	37	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2182	38	commerce,[513	commerce,[513	NN
18637	2182	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2182	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2182	41	held	hold	VBD
18637	2182	42	the	the	DT
18637	2182	43	act	act	NN
18637	2182	44	,	,	,
18637	2182	45	by	by	IN
18637	2182	46	the	the	DT
18637	2182	47	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	2182	48	vote	vote	NN
18637	2182	49	of	of	IN
18637	2182	50	five	five	CD
18637	2182	51	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	2182	52	to	to	IN
18637	2182	53	four	four	CD
18637	2182	54	,	,	,
18637	2182	55	to	to	TO
18637	2182	56	be	be	VB
18637	2182	57	not	not	RB
18637	2182	58	an	an	DT
18637	2182	59	act	act	NN
18637	2182	60	regulative	regulative	NN
18637	2182	61	of	of	IN
18637	2182	62	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2182	63	among	among	IN
18637	2182	64	the	the	DT
18637	2182	65	States	States	NNP
18637	2182	66	,	,	,
18637	2182	67	but	but	CC
18637	2182	68	one	one	CD
18637	2182	69	which	which	WDT
18637	2182	70	invaded	invade	VBD
18637	2182	71	the	the	DT
18637	2182	72	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	2182	73	powers	power	NNS
18637	2182	74	of	of	IN
18637	2182	75	the	the	DT
18637	2182	76	States	States	NNP
18637	2182	77	.	.	.
18637	2183	1	"	"	``
18637	2183	2	The	the	DT
18637	2183	3	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	2183	4	of	of	IN
18637	2183	5	the	the	DT
18637	2183	6	authority	authority	NN
18637	2183	7	of	of	IN
18637	2183	8	the	the	DT
18637	2183	9	States	States	NNPS
18637	2183	10	over	over	IN
18637	2183	11	matters	matter	NNS
18637	2183	12	purely	purely	RB
18637	2183	13	local	local	JJ
18637	2183	14	,	,	,
18637	2183	15	"	"	''
18637	2183	16	said	say	VBD
18637	2183	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2183	18	Day	Day	NNP
18637	2183	19	for	for	IN
18637	2183	20	the	the	DT
18637	2183	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2183	22	,	,	,
18637	2183	23	"	"	''
18637	2183	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	2183	25	as	as	RB
18637	2183	26	essential	essential	JJ
18637	2183	27	to	to	IN
18637	2183	28	the	the	DT
18637	2183	29	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	2183	30	of	of	IN
18637	2183	31	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2183	32	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	2183	33	as	as	IN
18637	2183	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	2183	35	the	the	DT
18637	2183	36	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	2183	37	of	of	IN
18637	2183	38	the	the	DT
18637	2183	39	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	2183	40	of	of	IN
18637	2183	41	the	the	DT
18637	2183	42	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2183	43	power	power	NN
18637	2183	44	in	in	IN
18637	2183	45	all	all	DT
18637	2183	46	matters	matter	NNS
18637	2183	47	entrusted	entrust	VBD
18637	2183	48	to	to	IN
18637	2183	49	the	the	DT
18637	2183	50	Nation	nation	NN
18637	2183	51	by	by	IN
18637	2183	52	the	the	DT
18637	2183	53	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2183	54	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2183	55	.	.	.
18637	2184	1	"	"	``
18637	2184	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2184	3	514	514	CD
18637	2184	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2184	5	As	as	IN
18637	2184	6	to	to	IN
18637	2184	7	earlier	early	JJR
18637	2184	8	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	2184	9	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	2184	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2184	11	's	's	POS
18637	2184	12	prohibitory	prohibitory	JJ
18637	2184	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	2184	14	,	,	,
18637	2184	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2184	16	Day	Day	NNP
18637	2184	17	said	say	VBD
18637	2184	18	:	:	:
18637	2184	19	"	"	``
18637	2184	20	In	in	IN
18637	2184	21	each	each	DT
18637	2184	22	of	of	IN
18637	2184	23	these	these	DT
18637	2184	24	instances	instance	NNS
18637	2184	25	the	the	DT
18637	2184	26	use	use	NN
18637	2184	27	of	of	IN
18637	2184	28	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2184	29	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2184	30	was	be	VBD
18637	2184	31	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2184	32	to	to	IN
18637	2184	33	the	the	DT
18637	2184	34	accomplishment	accomplishment	NN
18637	2184	35	of	of	IN
18637	2184	36	harmful	harmful	JJ
18637	2184	37	results	result	NNS
18637	2184	38	.	.	.
18637	2185	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2185	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2185	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2185	4	This	this	DT
18637	2185	5	element	element	NN
18637	2185	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2185	7	wanting	want	VBG
18637	2185	8	in	in	IN
18637	2185	9	the	the	DT
18637	2185	10	present	present	JJ
18637	2185	11	case	case	NN
18637	2185	12	.	.	.
18637	2186	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2186	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2186	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2186	4	The	the	DT
18637	2186	5	goods	good	NNS
18637	2186	6	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	2186	7	are	be	VBP
18637	2186	8	in	in	IN
18637	2186	9	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2186	10	harmless	harmless	JJ
18637	2186	11	.	.	.
18637	2187	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2187	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2187	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2187	4	When	when	WRB
18637	2187	5	offered	offer	VBN
18637	2187	6	for	for	IN
18637	2187	7	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2187	8	,	,	,
18637	2187	9	and	and	CC
18637	2187	10	before	before	IN
18637	2187	11	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2187	12	begins	begin	VBZ
18637	2187	13	,	,	,
18637	2187	14	the	the	DT
18637	2187	15	labor	labor	NN
18637	2187	16	of	of	IN
18637	2187	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2187	18	production	production	NN
18637	2187	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	2187	20	over	over	RB
18637	2187	21	,	,	,
18637	2187	22	and	and	CC
18637	2187	23	the	the	DT
18637	2187	24	mere	mere	JJ
18637	2187	25	fact	fact	NN
18637	2187	26	that	that	IN
18637	2187	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2187	28	were	be	VBD
18637	2187	29	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2187	30	for	for	IN
18637	2187	31	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2187	32	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2187	33	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2187	34	does	do	VBZ
18637	2187	35	not	not	RB
18637	2187	36	make	make	VB
18637	2187	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2187	38	production	production	NN
18637	2187	39	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2187	40	to	to	IN
18637	2187	41	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2187	42	control	control	NN
18637	2187	43	under	under	IN
18637	2187	44	the	the	DT
18637	2187	45	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2187	46	power	power	NN
18637	2187	47	.	.	.
18637	2188	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2188	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2188	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2188	4	'	'	''
18637	2188	5	When	when	WRB
18637	2188	6	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2188	7	begins	begin	VBZ
18637	2188	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	2188	9	determined	determine	VBN
18637	2188	10	,	,	,
18637	2188	11	not	not	RB
18637	2188	12	by	by	IN
18637	2188	13	the	the	DT
18637	2188	14	character	character	NN
18637	2188	15	of	of	IN
18637	2188	16	the	the	DT
18637	2188	17	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	2188	18	,	,	,
18637	2188	19	nor	nor	CC
18637	2188	20	by	by	IN
18637	2188	21	the	the	DT
18637	2188	22	intention	intention	NN
18637	2188	23	of	of	IN
18637	2188	24	the	the	DT
18637	2188	25	owner	owner	NN
18637	2188	26	to	to	TO
18637	2188	27	transfer	transfer	VB
18637	2188	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2188	29	to	to	IN
18637	2188	30	another	another	DT
18637	2188	31	State	State	NNP
18637	2188	32	for	for	IN
18637	2188	33	sale	sale	NN
18637	2188	34	,	,	,
18637	2188	35	*	*	NFP
18637	2188	36	*	*	NFP
18637	2188	37	*	*	NFP
18637	2188	38	,	,	,
18637	2188	39	but	but	CC
18637	2188	40	by	by	IN
18637	2188	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2188	42	actual	actual	JJ
18637	2188	43	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	2188	44	to	to	IN
18637	2188	45	a	a	DT
18637	2188	46	common	common	JJ
18637	2188	47	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2188	48	for	for	IN
18637	2188	49	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2188	50	,	,	,
18637	2188	51	*	*	NFP
18637	2188	52	*	*	NFP
18637	2188	53	*	*	NFP
18637	2188	54	'	'	''
18637	2188	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2188	56	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	2188	57	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2188	58	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	2188	59	in	in	IN
18637	2188	60	_	_	NNP
18637	2188	61	In	in	IN
18637	2188	62	re	re	IN
18637	2188	63	Greene	Greene	NNP
18637	2188	64	_	_	NNP
18637	2188	65	,	,	,
18637	2188	66	52	52	CD
18637	2188	67	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	2188	68	.	.	.
18637	2189	1	Rep.	Rep.	NNP
18637	2189	2	113	113	CD
18637	2189	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2189	4	.	.	.
18637	2190	1	This	this	DT
18637	2190	2	principle	principle	NN
18637	2190	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	2190	4	been	be	VBN
18637	2190	5	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	2190	6	often	often	RB
18637	2190	7	in	in	IN
18637	2190	8	this	this	DT
18637	2190	9	court	court	NN
18637	2190	10	.	.	.
18637	2191	1	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	2191	2	_	_	NNP
18637	2191	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	2191	4	_	_	NNP
18637	2191	5	Errol	Errol	NNP
18637	2191	6	,	,	,
18637	2191	7	116	116	CD
18637	2191	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	2191	9	517	517	CD
18637	2191	10	*	*	NFP
18637	2191	11	*	*	NFP
18637	2191	12	*	*	NFP
18637	2191	13	.	.	.
18637	2192	1	"	"	``
18637	2192	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2192	3	515	515	CD
18637	2192	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2192	5	The	the	DT
18637	2192	6	decision	decision	NN
18637	2192	7	in	in	IN
18637	2192	8	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	2192	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2192	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	2192	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2192	12	Dagenhart	Dagenhart	NNP
18637	2192	13	was	be	VBD
18637	2192	14	,	,	,
18637	2192	15	in	in	IN
18637	2192	16	short	short	JJ
18637	2192	17	,	,	,
18637	2192	18	governed	govern	VBN
18637	2192	19	by	by	IN
18637	2192	20	the	the	DT
18637	2192	21	same	same	JJ
18637	2192	22	general	general	JJ
18637	2192	23	conception	conception	NN
18637	2192	24	of	of	IN
18637	2192	25	the	the	DT
18637	2192	26	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2192	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2192	28	process	process	NN
18637	2192	29	as	as	IN
18637	2192	30	that	that	DT
18637	2192	31	which	which	WDT
18637	2192	32	governed	govern	VBD
18637	2192	33	the	the	DT
18637	2192	34	decision	decision	NN
18637	2192	35	in	in	IN
18637	2192	36	the	the	DT
18637	2192	37	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	2192	38	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	2192	39	Case	Case	NNP
18637	2192	40	.	.	.
18637	2193	1	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2193	2	was	be	VBD
18637	2193	3	envisaged	envisage	VBN
18637	2193	4	as	as	IN
18637	2193	5	beginning	begin	VBG
18637	2193	6	only	only	RB
18637	2193	7	with	with	IN
18637	2193	8	an	an	DT
18637	2193	9	act	act	NN
18637	2193	10	of	of	IN
18637	2193	11	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2193	12	from	from	IN
18637	2193	13	one	one	CD
18637	2193	14	State	state	NN
18637	2193	15	to	to	IN
18637	2193	16	another	another	DT
18637	2193	17	.	.	.
18637	2194	1	And	and	CC
18637	2194	2	from	from	IN
18637	2194	3	this	this	DT
18637	2194	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2194	5	was	be	VBD
18637	2194	6	deduced	deduce	VBN
18637	2194	7	that	that	IN
18637	2194	8	the	the	DT
18637	2194	9	only	only	JJ
18637	2194	10	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2194	11	which	which	WDT
18637	2194	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2194	13	may	may	MD
18637	2194	14	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2194	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	2194	16	an	an	DT
18637	2194	17	act	act	NN
18637	2194	18	of	of	IN
18637	2194	19	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2194	20	from	from	IN
18637	2194	21	one	one	CD
18637	2194	22	State	state	NN
18637	2194	23	to	to	IN
18637	2194	24	the	the	DT
18637	2194	25	other	other	JJ
18637	2194	26	which	which	WDT
18637	2194	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	2194	28	followed	follow	VBN
18637	2194	29	in	in	IN
18637	2194	30	the	the	DT
18637	2194	31	latter	latter	JJ
18637	2194	32	by	by	IN
18637	2194	33	an	an	DT
18637	2194	34	act	act	NN
18637	2194	35	within	within	IN
18637	2194	36	the	the	DT
18637	2194	37	normal	normal	JJ
18637	2194	38	powers	power	NNS
18637	2194	39	of	of	IN
18637	2194	40	government	government	NN
18637	2194	41	to	to	TO
18637	2194	42	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2194	43	.	.	.
18637	2195	1	Commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2195	2	,	,	,
18637	2195	3	however	however	RB
18637	2195	4	,	,	,
18637	2195	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	2195	6	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	2195	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2195	8	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2195	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2195	10	;	;	:
18637	2195	11	and	and	CC
18637	2195	12	the	the	DT
18637	2195	13	theory	theory	NN
18637	2195	14	of	of	IN
18637	2195	15	the	the	DT
18637	2195	16	Child	Child	NNP
18637	2195	17	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	2195	18	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2195	19	was	be	VBD
18637	2195	20	that	that	IN
18637	2195	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2195	22	was	be	VBD
18637	2195	23	designed	design	VBN
18637	2195	24	to	to	TO
18637	2195	25	discourage	discourage	VB
18637	2195	26	a	a	DT
18637	2195	27	widespread	widespread	JJ
18637	2195	28	and	and	CC
18637	2195	29	pernicious	pernicious	JJ
18637	2195	30	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2195	31	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2195	32	in	in	IN
18637	2195	33	the	the	DT
18637	2195	34	products	product	NNS
18637	2195	35	of	of	IN
18637	2195	36	child	child	NN
18637	2195	37	labor	labor	NN
18637	2195	38	--	--	:
18637	2195	39	pernicious	pernicious	JJ
18637	2195	40	because	because	IN
18637	2195	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2195	42	bore	bear	VBD
18637	2195	43	"	"	``
18637	2195	44	a	a	DT
18637	2195	45	real	real	JJ
18637	2195	46	and	and	CC
18637	2195	47	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	2195	48	relation	relation	NN
18637	2195	49	"	"	''
18637	2195	50	to	to	IN
18637	2195	51	the	the	DT
18637	2195	52	existence	existence	NN
18637	2195	53	of	of	IN
18637	2195	54	child	child	NN
18637	2195	55	labor	labor	NN
18637	2195	56	employment	employment	NN
18637	2195	57	in	in	IN
18637	2195	58	some	some	DT
18637	2195	59	States	States	NNP
18637	2195	60	and	and	CC
18637	2195	61	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	2195	62	a	a	DT
18637	2195	63	direct	direct	JJ
18637	2195	64	inducement	inducement	NN
18637	2195	65	to	to	IN
18637	2195	66	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2195	67	spread	spread	NN
18637	2195	68	to	to	IN
18637	2195	69	other	other	JJ
18637	2195	70	States	States	NNPS
18637	2195	71	.	.	.
18637	2196	1	Deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	2196	2	of	of	IN
18637	2196	3	the	the	DT
18637	2196	4	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2196	5	market	market	NN
18637	2196	6	which	which	WDT
18637	2196	7	this	this	DT
18637	2196	8	decision	decision	NN
18637	2196	9	secured	secure	VBN
18637	2196	10	to	to	IN
18637	2196	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2196	12	,	,	,
18637	2196	13	child	child	NN
18637	2196	14	labor	labor	NN
18637	2196	15	could	could	MD
18637	2196	16	not	not	RB
18637	2196	17	exist	exist	VB
18637	2196	18	.	.	.
18637	2197	1	INTERSTATE	INTERSTATE	NNP
18637	2197	2	COMMERCE	COMMERCE	NNS
18637	2197	3	IN	in	IN
18637	2197	4	STOLEN	STOLEN	NNP
18637	2197	5	GOODS	GOODS	NNP
18637	2197	6	BANNED	BANNED	NNS
18637	2197	7	In	in	IN
18637	2197	8	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
18637	2197	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2197	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	2197	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2197	12	United	United	NNP
18637	2197	13	States,[516	States,[516	NNP
18637	2197	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2197	15	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2197	16	in	in	IN
18637	2197	17	1925	1925	CD
18637	2197	18	,	,	,
18637	2197	19	the	the	DT
18637	2197	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2197	21	,	,	,
18637	2197	22	in	in	IN
18637	2197	23	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	2197	24	the	the	DT
18637	2197	25	National	National	NNP
18637	2197	26	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	2197	27	Vehicle	Vehicle	NNP
18637	2197	28	Theft	Theft	NNP
18637	2197	29	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2197	30	of	of	IN
18637	2197	31	1919,[517	1919,[517	NNP
18637	2197	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2197	33	materially	materially	RB
18637	2197	34	impaired	impair	VBD
18637	2197	35	the	the	DT
18637	2197	36	_	_	NNP
18637	2197	37	ratio	ratio	NN
18637	2197	38	decidendi	decidendi	NNP
18637	2197	39	_	_	NNP
18637	2197	40	of	of	IN
18637	2197	41	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	2197	42	_	_	NNP
18637	2197	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	2197	44	_	_	NNP
18637	2197	45	Dagenhart	Dagenhart	NNP
18637	2197	46	.	.	.
18637	2198	1	At	at	IN
18637	2198	2	the	the	DT
18637	2198	3	outset	outset	NN
18637	2198	4	of	of	IN
18637	2198	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2198	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2198	7	for	for	IN
18637	2198	8	the	the	DT
18637	2198	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2198	10	,	,	,
18637	2198	11	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2198	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2198	13	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	2198	14	stated	state	VBD
18637	2198	15	the	the	DT
18637	2198	16	general	general	JJ
18637	2198	17	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	2198	18	that	that	IN
18637	2198	19	"	"	``
18637	2198	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2198	21	can	can	MD
18637	2198	22	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	2198	23	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2198	24	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2198	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2198	26	to	to	IN
18637	2198	27	the	the	DT
18637	2198	28	extent	extent	NN
18637	2198	29	of	of	IN
18637	2198	30	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	2198	31	and	and	CC
18637	2198	32	punishing	punish	VBG
18637	2198	33	the	the	DT
18637	2198	34	use	use	NN
18637	2198	35	of	of	IN
18637	2198	36	such	such	JJ
18637	2198	37	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2198	38	as	as	IN
18637	2198	39	an	an	DT
18637	2198	40	agency	agency	NN
18637	2198	41	to	to	TO
18637	2198	42	promote	promote	VB
18637	2198	43	immorality	immorality	NN
18637	2198	44	,	,	,
18637	2198	45	dishonesty	dishonesty	NN
18637	2198	46	or	or	CC
18637	2198	47	the	the	DT
18637	2198	48	spread	spread	NN
18637	2198	49	of	of	IN
18637	2198	50	any	any	DT
18637	2198	51	evil	evil	NN
18637	2198	52	or	or	CC
18637	2198	53	harm	harm	NN
18637	2198	54	to	to	IN
18637	2198	55	the	the	DT
18637	2198	56	people	people	NNS
18637	2198	57	of	of	IN
18637	2198	58	other	other	JJ
18637	2198	59	States	States	NNPS
18637	2198	60	from	from	IN
18637	2198	61	the	the	DT
18637	2198	62	State	State	NNP
18637	2198	63	of	of	IN
18637	2198	64	origin	origin	NN
18637	2198	65	.	.	.
18637	2198	66	"	"	''
18637	2199	1	This	this	DT
18637	2199	2	statement	statement	NN
18637	2199	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2199	4	buttressed	buttress	VBN
18637	2199	5	by	by	IN
18637	2199	6	a	a	DT
18637	2199	7	review	review	NN
18637	2199	8	of	of	IN
18637	2199	9	previous	previous	JJ
18637	2199	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	2199	11	,	,	,
18637	2199	12	including	include	VBG
18637	2199	13	the	the	DT
18637	2199	14	explanation	explanation	NN
18637	2199	15	that	that	IN
18637	2199	16	the	the	DT
18637	2199	17	goods	good	NNS
18637	2199	18	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2199	19	in	in	IN
18637	2199	20	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	2199	21	_	_	NNP
18637	2199	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	2199	23	_	_	NNP
18637	2199	24	Dagenhart	Dagenhart	NNP
18637	2199	25	were	be	VBD
18637	2199	26	"	"	``
18637	2199	27	harmless	harmless	JJ
18637	2199	28	"	"	''
18637	2199	29	and	and	CC
18637	2199	30	did	do	VBD
18637	2199	31	not	not	RB
18637	2199	32	spread	spread	VB
18637	2199	33	harm	harm	NN
18637	2199	34	to	to	IN
18637	2199	35	persons	person	NNS
18637	2199	36	in	in	IN
18637	2199	37	other	other	JJ
18637	2199	38	States	States	NNPS
18637	2199	39	.	.	.
18637	2200	1	Passing	pass	VBG
18637	2200	2	then	then	RB
18637	2200	3	to	to	IN
18637	2200	4	the	the	DT
18637	2200	5	measure	measure	NN
18637	2200	6	before	before	IN
18637	2200	7	the	the	DT
18637	2200	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2200	9	,	,	,
18637	2200	10	the	the	DT
18637	2200	11	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2200	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2200	13	noted	note	VBD
18637	2200	14	"	"	``
18637	2200	15	the	the	DT
18637	2200	16	radical	radical	JJ
18637	2200	17	change	change	NN
18637	2200	18	in	in	IN
18637	2200	19	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2200	20	"	"	``
18637	2200	21	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2200	22	about	about	RP
18637	2200	23	by	by	IN
18637	2200	24	the	the	DT
18637	2200	25	automobile	automobile	NN
18637	2200	26	,	,	,
18637	2200	27	and	and	CC
18637	2200	28	the	the	DT
18637	2200	29	rise	rise	NN
18637	2200	30	of	of	IN
18637	2200	31	"	"	``
18637	2200	32	elaborately	elaborately	RB
18637	2200	33	organized	organize	VBN
18637	2200	34	conspiracies	conspiracy	NNS
18637	2200	35	for	for	IN
18637	2200	36	the	the	DT
18637	2200	37	theft	theft	NN
18637	2200	38	of	of	IN
18637	2200	39	automobiles	automobile	NNS
18637	2200	40	*	*	NFP
18637	2200	41	*	*	NFP
18637	2200	42	*	*	NFP
18637	2200	43	,	,	,
18637	2200	44	and	and	CC
18637	2200	45	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2200	46	sale	sale	NN
18637	2200	47	or	or	CC
18637	2200	48	other	other	JJ
18637	2200	49	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	2200	50	"	"	''
18637	2200	51	in	in	IN
18637	2200	52	another	another	DT
18637	2200	53	police	police	NN
18637	2200	54	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2200	55	from	from	IN
18637	2200	56	the	the	DT
18637	2200	57	owner	owner	NN
18637	2200	58	's	's	POS
18637	2200	59	.	.	.
18637	2201	1	This	this	DT
18637	2201	2	,	,	,
18637	2201	3	the	the	DT
18637	2201	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2201	5	declared	declare	VBD
18637	2201	6	,	,	,
18637	2201	7	"	"	``
18637	2201	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	2201	9	a	a	DT
18637	2201	10	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2201	11	misuse	misuse	NN
18637	2201	12	of	of	IN
18637	2201	13	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2201	14	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2201	15	.	.	.
18637	2202	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2202	2	may	may	MD
18637	2202	3	properly	properly	RB
18637	2202	4	punish	punish	VB
18637	2202	5	such	such	JJ
18637	2202	6	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2202	7	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2202	8	by	by	IN
18637	2202	9	anyone	anyone	NN
18637	2202	10	with	with	IN
18637	2202	11	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	2202	12	of	of	IN
18637	2202	13	the	the	DT
18637	2202	14	theft	theft	NN
18637	2202	15	,	,	,
18637	2202	16	because	because	IN
18637	2202	17	of	of	IN
18637	2202	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2202	19	harmful	harmful	JJ
18637	2202	20	result	result	NN
18637	2202	21	and	and	CC
18637	2202	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2202	23	defeat	defeat	NN
18637	2202	24	of	of	IN
18637	2202	25	the	the	DT
18637	2202	26	property	property	NN
18637	2202	27	rights	right	NNS
18637	2202	28	of	of	IN
18637	2202	29	those	those	DT
18637	2202	30	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2202	31	machines	machine	NNS
18637	2202	32	against	against	IN
18637	2202	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2202	34	will	will	NN
18637	2202	35	are	be	VBP
18637	2202	36	taken	take	VBN
18637	2202	37	into	into	IN
18637	2202	38	other	other	JJ
18637	2202	39	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NNS
18637	2202	40	.	.	.
18637	2203	1	"	"	``
18637	2203	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2203	3	518	518	CD
18637	2203	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2203	5	The	the	DT
18637	2203	6	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	2203	7	Vehicle	Vehicle	NNP
18637	2203	8	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2203	9	was	be	VBD
18637	2203	10	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2203	11	,	,	,
18637	2203	12	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	2203	13	,	,	,
18637	2203	14	mainly	mainly	RB
18637	2203	15	as	as	IN
18637	2203	16	protective	protective	JJ
18637	2203	17	of	of	IN
18637	2203	18	owners	owner	NNS
18637	2203	19	of	of	IN
18637	2203	20	automobiles	automobile	NNS
18637	2203	21	,	,	,
18637	2203	22	that	that	DT
18637	2203	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	2203	24	to	to	TO
18637	2203	25	say	say	VB
18637	2203	26	,	,	,
18637	2203	27	of	of	IN
18637	2203	28	interests	interest	NNS
18637	2203	29	in	in	IN
18637	2203	30	"	"	``
18637	2203	31	the	the	DT
18637	2203	32	State	State	NNP
18637	2203	33	of	of	IN
18637	2203	34	origin	origin	NN
18637	2203	35	.	.	.
18637	2203	36	"	"	''
18637	2204	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2204	2	was	be	VBD
18637	2204	3	designed	design	VBN
18637	2204	4	to	to	TO
18637	2204	5	repress	repress	VB
18637	2204	6	automobile	automobile	NN
18637	2204	7	thefts	theft	NNS
18637	2204	8	,	,	,
18637	2204	9	and	and	CC
18637	2204	10	that	that	IN
18637	2204	11	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	2204	12	the	the	DT
18637	2204	13	obvious	obvious	JJ
18637	2204	14	fact	fact	NN
18637	2204	15	that	that	IN
18637	2204	16	such	such	JJ
18637	2204	17	thefts	theft	NNS
18637	2204	18	must	must	MD
18637	2204	19	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	2204	20	occur	occur	VB
18637	2204	21	before	before	IN
18637	2204	22	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2204	23	of	of	IN
18637	2204	24	the	the	DT
18637	2204	25	thing	thing	NN
18637	2204	26	stolen	steal	VBN
18637	2204	27	can	can	MD
18637	2204	28	take	take	VB
18637	2204	29	place	place	NN
18637	2204	30	,	,	,
18637	2204	31	that	that	RB
18637	2204	32	is	is	RB
18637	2204	33	,	,	,
18637	2204	34	under	under	IN
18637	2204	35	the	the	DT
18637	2204	36	formula	formula	NN
18637	2204	37	followed	follow	VBN
18637	2204	38	in	in	IN
18637	2204	39	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	2204	40	_	_	NNP
18637	2204	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	2204	42	_	_	NNP
18637	2204	43	Dagenhart	Dagenhart	NNP
18637	2204	44	,	,	,
18637	2204	45	before	before	IN
18637	2204	46	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2204	47	's	's	POS
18637	2204	48	power	power	NN
18637	2204	49	over	over	IN
18637	2204	50	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2204	51	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2204	52	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	2204	53	operative	operative	JJ
18637	2204	54	.	.	.
18637	2205	1	Also	also	RB
18637	2205	2	,	,	,
18637	2205	3	the	the	DT
18637	2205	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2205	5	took	take	VBD
18637	2205	6	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	2205	7	of	of	IN
18637	2205	8	"	"	``
18637	2205	9	elaborately	elaborately	RB
18637	2205	10	organized	organized	JJ
18637	2205	11	conspiracies	conspiracy	NNS
18637	2205	12	"	"	''
18637	2205	13	for	for	IN
18637	2205	14	the	the	DT
18637	2205	15	theft	theft	NN
18637	2205	16	and	and	CC
18637	2205	17	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	2205	18	of	of	IN
18637	2205	19	automobiles	automobile	NNS
18637	2205	20	across	across	IN
18637	2205	21	State	State	NNP
18637	2205	22	lines	line	NNS
18637	2205	23	--	--	:
18637	2205	24	that	that	IN
18637	2205	25	,	,	,
18637	2205	26	to	to	TO
18637	2205	27	say	say	VB
18637	2205	28	,	,	,
18637	2205	29	of	of	IN
18637	2205	30	a	a	DT
18637	2205	31	widespread	widespread	JJ
18637	2205	32	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2205	33	in	in	IN
18637	2205	34	such	such	JJ
18637	2205	35	property	property	NN
18637	2205	36	.	.	.
18637	2206	1	THE	the	DT
18637	2206	2	DARBY	DARBY	NNP
18637	2206	3	CASE	case	NN
18637	2206	4	The	the	DT
18637	2206	5	formal	formal	JJ
18637	2206	6	overruling	overruling	NN
18637	2206	7	of	of	IN
18637	2206	8	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	2206	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2206	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	2206	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2206	12	Dagenhart	Dagenhart	NNP
18637	2206	13	,	,	,
18637	2206	14	however	however	RB
18637	2206	15	,	,	,
18637	2206	16	did	do	VBD
18637	2206	17	not	not	RB
18637	2206	18	occur	occur	VB
18637	2206	19	until	until	IN
18637	2206	20	1941	1941	CD
18637	2206	21	when	when	WRB
18637	2206	22	,	,	,
18637	2206	23	in	in	IN
18637	2206	24	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	2206	25	the	the	DT
18637	2206	26	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	2206	27	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	2206	28	Standards	Standards	NNP
18637	2206	29	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2206	30	,	,	,
18637	2206	31	a	a	DT
18637	2206	32	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	2206	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2206	34	,	,	,
18637	2206	35	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2206	36	by	by	IN
18637	2206	37	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2206	38	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	2206	39	,	,	,
18637	2206	40	said	say	VBD
18637	2206	41	:	:	:
18637	2206	42	"	"	``
18637	2206	43	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	2206	44	_	_	NNP
18637	2206	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	2206	46	_	_	NNP
18637	2206	47	Dagenhart	Dagenhart	NNP
18637	2206	48	has	have	VBZ
18637	2206	49	not	not	RB
18637	2206	50	been	be	VBN
18637	2206	51	followed	follow	VBN
18637	2206	52	.	.	.
18637	2207	1	The	the	DT
18637	2207	2	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	2207	3	on	on	IN
18637	2207	4	which	which	WDT
18637	2207	5	the	the	DT
18637	2207	6	decision	decision	NN
18637	2207	7	was	be	VBD
18637	2207	8	rested	rest	VBN
18637	2207	9	that	that	IN
18637	2207	10	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2207	11	power	power	NN
18637	2207	12	to	to	TO
18637	2207	13	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2207	14	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2207	15	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2207	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	2207	17	limited	limit	VBN
18637	2207	18	to	to	IN
18637	2207	19	articles	article	NNS
18637	2207	20	which	which	WDT
18637	2207	21	in	in	IN
18637	2207	22	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2207	23	have	have	VBP
18637	2207	24	some	some	DT
18637	2207	25	harmful	harmful	JJ
18637	2207	26	or	or	CC
18637	2207	27	deleterious	deleterious	JJ
18637	2207	28	property	property	NN
18637	2207	29	--	--	:
18637	2207	30	a	a	DT
18637	2207	31	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	2207	32	which	which	WDT
18637	2207	33	was	be	VBD
18637	2207	34	novel	novel	JJ
18637	2207	35	when	when	WRB
18637	2207	36	made	make	VBN
18637	2207	37	and	and	CC
18637	2207	38	unsupported	unsupporte	VBN
18637	2207	39	by	by	IN
18637	2207	40	any	any	DT
18637	2207	41	provision	provision	NN
18637	2207	42	of	of	IN
18637	2207	43	the	the	DT
18637	2207	44	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2207	45	--	--	:
18637	2207	46	has	have	VBZ
18637	2207	47	long	long	RB
18637	2207	48	since	since	RB
18637	2207	49	been	be	VBN
18637	2207	50	abandoned	abandon	VBN
18637	2207	51	.	.	.
18637	2208	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2208	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2208	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2208	4	The	the	DT
18637	2208	5	thesis	thesis	NN
18637	2208	6	of	of	IN
18637	2208	7	the	the	DT
18637	2208	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2208	9	that	that	IN
18637	2208	10	the	the	DT
18637	2208	11	motive	motive	NN
18637	2208	12	of	of	IN
18637	2208	13	the	the	DT
18637	2208	14	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	2208	15	or	or	CC
18637	2208	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2208	17	effect	effect	NN
18637	2208	18	to	to	TO
18637	2208	19	control	control	VB
18637	2208	20	in	in	IN
18637	2208	21	some	some	DT
18637	2208	22	measure	measure	NN
18637	2208	23	the	the	DT
18637	2208	24	use	use	NN
18637	2208	25	or	or	CC
18637	2208	26	production	production	NN
18637	2208	27	within	within	IN
18637	2208	28	the	the	DT
18637	2208	29	States	States	NNPS
18637	2208	30	of	of	IN
18637	2208	31	the	the	DT
18637	2208	32	article	article	NN
18637	2208	33	thus	thus	RB
18637	2208	34	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	2208	35	from	from	IN
18637	2208	36	the	the	DT
18637	2208	37	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2208	38	can	can	MD
18637	2208	39	operate	operate	VB
18637	2208	40	to	to	TO
18637	2208	41	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	2208	42	the	the	DT
18637	2208	43	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2208	44	of	of	IN
18637	2208	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2208	46	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2208	47	authority	authority	NN
18637	2208	48	has	have	VBZ
18637	2208	49	long	long	RB
18637	2208	50	since	since	IN
18637	2208	51	ceased	cease	VBN
18637	2208	52	to	to	TO
18637	2208	53	have	have	VB
18637	2208	54	force	force	NN
18637	2208	55	.	.	.
18637	2209	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2209	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2209	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2209	4	And	and	CC
18637	2209	5	finally	finally	RB
18637	2209	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2209	7	have	have	VBP
18637	2209	8	declared	declare	VBN
18637	2209	9	'	'	''
18637	2209	10	The	the	DT
18637	2209	11	authority	authority	NN
18637	2209	12	of	of	IN
18637	2209	13	the	the	DT
18637	2209	14	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2209	15	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2209	16	over	over	IN
18637	2209	17	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2209	18	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2209	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	2209	20	not	not	RB
18637	2209	21	differ	differ	VB
18637	2209	22	in	in	IN
18637	2209	23	extent	extent	NN
18637	2209	24	or	or	CC
18637	2209	25	character	character	NN
18637	2209	26	from	from	IN
18637	2209	27	that	that	DT
18637	2209	28	retained	retain	VBN
18637	2209	29	by	by	IN
18637	2209	30	the	the	DT
18637	2209	31	States	States	NNP
18637	2209	32	over	over	IN
18637	2209	33	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2209	34	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2209	35	.	.	.
18637	2209	36	'	'	''
18637	2210	1	United	United	NNP
18637	2210	2	States	States	NNP
18637	2210	3	_	_	NNP
18637	2210	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	2210	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2210	6	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	2210	7	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	2210	8	Co	Co	NNP
18637	2210	9	-	-	NN
18637	2210	10	operative	operative	NNP
18637	2210	11	,	,	,
18637	2210	12	307	307	CD
18637	2210	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	2210	14	533	533	CD
18637	2210	15	,	,	,
18637	2210	16	569	569	CD
18637	2210	17	.	.	.
18637	2211	1	The	the	DT
18637	2211	2	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	2211	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	2211	4	inescapable	inescapable	JJ
18637	2211	5	that	that	IN
18637	2211	6	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	2211	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2211	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	2211	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2211	10	Dagenhart	Dagenhart	NNP
18637	2211	11	,	,	,
18637	2211	12	was	be	VBD
18637	2211	13	a	a	DT
18637	2211	14	departure	departure	NN
18637	2211	15	from	from	IN
18637	2211	16	the	the	DT
18637	2211	17	principles	principle	NNS
18637	2211	18	which	which	WDT
18637	2211	19	have	have	VBP
18637	2211	20	prevailed	prevail	VBN
18637	2211	21	in	in	IN
18637	2211	22	the	the	DT
18637	2211	23	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	2211	24	of	of	IN
18637	2211	25	the	the	DT
18637	2211	26	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2211	27	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	2211	28	both	both	CC
18637	2211	29	before	before	IN
18637	2211	30	and	and	CC
18637	2211	31	since	since	IN
18637	2211	32	the	the	DT
18637	2211	33	decision	decision	NN
18637	2211	34	and	and	CC
18637	2211	35	that	that	IN
18637	2211	36	such	such	JJ
18637	2211	37	vitality	vitality	NN
18637	2211	38	,	,	,
18637	2211	39	as	as	IN
18637	2211	40	a	a	DT
18637	2211	41	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	2211	42	,	,	,
18637	2211	43	as	as	IN
18637	2211	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2211	45	then	then	RB
18637	2211	46	had	have	VBD
18637	2211	47	has	have	VBZ
18637	2211	48	long	long	RB
18637	2211	49	since	since	RB
18637	2211	50	been	be	VBN
18637	2211	51	exhausted	exhaust	VBN
18637	2211	52	.	.	.
18637	2212	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2212	2	should	should	MD
18637	2212	3	be	be	VB
18637	2212	4	and	and	CC
18637	2212	5	now	now	RB
18637	2212	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2212	7	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	2212	8	.	.	.
18637	2213	1	"	"	``
18637	2213	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2213	3	519	519	CD
18637	2213	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2213	5	And	and	CC
18637	2213	6	commenting	comment	VBG
18637	2213	7	in	in	IN
18637	2213	8	a	a	DT
18637	2213	9	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2213	10	case	case	NN
18637	2213	11	on	on	IN
18637	2213	12	the	the	DT
18637	2213	13	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	2213	14	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	2213	15	Standards	Standards	NNP
18637	2213	16	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2213	17	,	,	,
18637	2213	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2213	19	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	2213	20	,	,	,
18637	2213	21	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2213	22	for	for	IN
18637	2213	23	the	the	DT
18637	2213	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2213	25	said	say	VBD
18637	2213	26	:	:	:
18637	2213	27	"	"	``
18637	2213	28	The	the	DT
18637	2213	29	primary	primary	JJ
18637	2213	30	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2213	31	of	of	IN
18637	2213	32	the	the	DT
18637	2213	33	act	act	NN
18637	2213	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	2213	35	not	not	RB
18637	2213	36	so	so	RB
18637	2213	37	much	much	JJ
18637	2213	38	to	to	TO
18637	2213	39	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2213	40	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2213	41	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2213	42	as	as	IN
18637	2213	43	such	such	JJ
18637	2213	44	,	,	,
18637	2213	45	as	as	IN
18637	2213	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2213	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	2213	48	,	,	,
18637	2213	49	through	through	IN
18637	2213	50	the	the	DT
18637	2213	51	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2213	52	of	of	IN
18637	2213	53	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2213	54	power	power	NN
18637	2213	55	,	,	,
18637	2213	56	to	to	TO
18637	2213	57	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2213	58	the	the	DT
18637	2213	59	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2213	60	of	of	IN
18637	2213	61	goods	good	NNS
18637	2213	62	in	in	IN
18637	2213	63	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2213	64	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2213	65	if	if	IN
18637	2213	66	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2213	67	are	be	VBP
18637	2213	68	produced	produce	VBN
18637	2213	69	under	under	IN
18637	2213	70	substandard	substandard	JJ
18637	2213	71	labor	labor	NN
18637	2213	72	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2213	73	.	.	.
18637	2214	1	"	"	``
18637	2214	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2214	3	520	520	CD
18637	2214	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2214	5	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	2214	6	AND	and	CC
18637	2214	7	THE	the	DT
18637	2214	8	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	2214	9	SYSTEM	system	NN
18637	2214	10	In	in	IN
18637	2214	11	view	view	NN
18637	2214	12	of	of	IN
18637	2214	13	these	these	DT
18637	2214	14	developments	development	NNS
18637	2214	15	the	the	DT
18637	2214	16	following	follow	VBG
18637	2214	17	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	2214	18	by	by	IN
18637	2214	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2214	20	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	2214	21	,	,	,
18637	2214	22	was	be	VBD
18637	2214	23	no	no	RB
18637	2214	24	doubt	doubt	RB
18637	2214	25	,	,	,
18637	2214	26	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2214	27	to	to	TO
18637	2214	28	be	be	VB
18637	2214	29	reassuring	reassure	VBG
18637	2214	30	as	as	IN
18637	2214	31	to	to	IN
18637	2214	32	the	the	DT
18637	2214	33	future	future	NN
18637	2214	34	of	of	IN
18637	2214	35	the	the	DT
18637	2214	36	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2214	37	System	System	NNP
18637	2214	38	:	:	:
18637	2214	39	"	"	``
18637	2214	40	The	the	DT
18637	2214	41	interpenetrations	interpenetration	NNS
18637	2214	42	of	of	IN
18637	2214	43	modern	modern	JJ
18637	2214	44	society	society	NN
18637	2214	45	have	have	VBP
18637	2214	46	not	not	RB
18637	2214	47	wiped	wipe	VBN
18637	2214	48	out	out	RP
18637	2214	49	State	state	NN
18637	2214	50	lines	line	NNS
18637	2214	51	.	.	.
18637	2215	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2215	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2215	3	not	not	RB
18637	2215	4	for	for	IN
18637	2215	5	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2215	6	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2215	7	the	the	DT
18637	2215	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2215	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2215	10	to	to	TO
18637	2215	11	make	make	VB
18637	2215	12	inroads	inroad	NNS
18637	2215	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	2215	14	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2215	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2215	16	system	system	NN
18637	2215	17	either	either	CC
18637	2215	18	by	by	IN
18637	2215	19	indifference	indifference	NN
18637	2215	20	to	to	IN
18637	2215	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2215	22	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	2215	23	or	or	CC
18637	2215	24	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	2215	25	regard	regard	NN
18637	2215	26	for	for	IN
18637	2215	27	the	the	DT
18637	2215	28	unifying	unifying	JJ
18637	2215	29	forces	force	NNS
18637	2215	30	of	of	IN
18637	2215	31	modern	modern	JJ
18637	2215	32	technology	technology	NN
18637	2215	33	.	.	.
18637	2216	1	Scholastic	scholastic	JJ
18637	2216	2	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	2216	3	may	may	MD
18637	2216	4	prove	prove	VB
18637	2216	5	that	that	IN
18637	2216	6	no	no	DT
18637	2216	7	activity	activity	NN
18637	2216	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	2216	9	isolated	isolate	VBN
18637	2216	10	within	within	IN
18637	2216	11	the	the	DT
18637	2216	12	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	2216	13	of	of	IN
18637	2216	14	a	a	DT
18637	2216	15	single	single	JJ
18637	2216	16	State	state	NN
18637	2216	17	,	,	,
18637	2216	18	but	but	CC
18637	2216	19	that	that	DT
18637	2216	20	can	can	MD
18637	2216	21	not	not	RB
18637	2216	22	justify	justify	VB
18637	2216	23	absorption	absorption	NN
18637	2216	24	of	of	IN
18637	2216	25	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2216	26	power	power	NN
18637	2216	27	by	by	IN
18637	2216	28	the	the	DT
18637	2216	29	United	United	NNP
18637	2216	30	States	States	NNP
18637	2216	31	over	over	IN
18637	2216	32	every	every	DT
18637	2216	33	activity	activity	NN
18637	2216	34	.	.	.
18637	2217	1	"	"	``
18637	2217	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2217	3	521	521	CD
18637	2217	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2217	5	While	while	IN
18637	2217	6	this	this	DT
18637	2217	7	may	may	MD
18637	2217	8	be	be	VB
18637	2217	9	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	2217	10	,	,	,
18637	2217	11	the	the	DT
18637	2217	12	unmistakable	unmistakable	JJ
18637	2217	13	lesson	lesson	NN
18637	2217	14	of	of	IN
18637	2217	15	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2217	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	2217	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	2217	18	that	that	IN
18637	2217	19	the	the	DT
18637	2217	20	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	2217	21	of	of	IN
18637	2217	22	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2217	23	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2217	24	System	System	NNP
18637	2217	25	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	2217	26	today	today	NN
18637	2217	27	mainly	mainly	RB
18637	2217	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	2217	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2217	30	.	.	.
18637	2218	1	The	the	DT
18637	2218	2	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2218	3	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	2218	4	as	as	IN
18637	2218	5	a	a	DT
18637	2218	6	Restraint	Restraint	NNP
18637	2218	7	on	on	IN
18637	2218	8	State	State	NNP
18637	2218	9	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	2218	10	DOCTRINAL	DOCTRINAL	NNP
18637	2218	11	BACKGROUND	background	NN
18637	2218	12	The	the	DT
18637	2218	13	grant	grant	NN
18637	2218	14	of	of	IN
18637	2218	15	power	power	NN
18637	2218	16	to	to	IN
18637	2218	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2218	18	over	over	IN
18637	2218	19	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2218	20	,	,	,
18637	2218	21	unlike	unlike	IN
18637	2218	22	that	that	DT
18637	2218	23	of	of	IN
18637	2218	24	power	power	NN
18637	2218	25	to	to	TO
18637	2218	26	levy	levy	VB
18637	2218	27	customs	customs	NNP
18637	2218	28	duties	duty	NNS
18637	2218	29	,	,	,
18637	2218	30	the	the	DT
18637	2218	31	power	power	NN
18637	2218	32	to	to	TO
18637	2218	33	raise	raise	VB
18637	2218	34	armies	army	NNS
18637	2218	35	,	,	,
18637	2218	36	and	and	CC
18637	2218	37	some	some	DT
18637	2218	38	others	other	NNS
18637	2218	39	,	,	,
18637	2218	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	2218	41	unaccompanied	unaccompanied	JJ
18637	2218	42	by	by	IN
18637	2218	43	correlative	correlative	JJ
18637	2218	44	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	2218	45	on	on	IN
18637	2218	46	State	State	NNP
18637	2218	47	power	power	NN
18637	2218	48	.	.	.
18637	2219	1	This	this	DT
18637	2219	2	circumstance	circumstance	NN
18637	2219	3	does	do	VBZ
18637	2219	4	not	not	RB
18637	2219	5	,	,	,
18637	2219	6	however	however	RB
18637	2219	7	,	,	,
18637	2219	8	of	of	IN
18637	2219	9	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2219	10	signify	signify	VB
18637	2219	11	that	that	IN
18637	2219	12	the	the	DT
18637	2219	13	States	States	NNPS
18637	2219	14	were	be	VBD
18637	2219	15	expected	expect	VBN
18637	2219	16	still	still	RB
18637	2219	17	to	to	TO
18637	2219	18	participate	participate	VB
18637	2219	19	in	in	IN
18637	2219	20	the	the	DT
18637	2219	21	power	power	NN
18637	2219	22	thus	thus	RB
18637	2219	23	granted	grant	VBN
18637	2219	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2219	25	,	,	,
18637	2219	26	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2219	27	only	only	RB
18637	2219	28	to	to	IN
18637	2219	29	the	the	DT
18637	2219	30	operation	operation	NN
18637	2219	31	of	of	IN
18637	2219	32	the	the	DT
18637	2219	33	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	2219	34	clause	clause	NN
18637	2219	35	.	.	.
18637	2220	1	As	as	IN
18637	2220	2	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	2220	3	points	point	VBZ
18637	2220	4	out	out	RP
18637	2220	5	in	in	IN
18637	2220	6	The	the	DT
18637	2220	7	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	2220	8	,	,	,
18637	2220	9	while	while	IN
18637	2220	10	some	some	DT
18637	2220	11	of	of	IN
18637	2220	12	the	the	DT
18637	2220	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	2220	14	which	which	WDT
18637	2220	15	are	be	VBP
18637	2220	16	vested	vest	VBN
18637	2220	17	in	in	IN
18637	2220	18	the	the	DT
18637	2220	19	National	National	NNP
18637	2220	20	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2220	21	admit	admit	NN
18637	2220	22	of	of	IN
18637	2220	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2220	24	"	"	``
18637	2220	25	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	2220	26	"	"	''
18637	2220	27	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2220	28	by	by	IN
18637	2220	29	the	the	DT
18637	2220	30	States	States	NNPS
18637	2220	31	,	,	,
18637	2220	32	others	other	NNS
18637	2220	33	are	be	VBP
18637	2220	34	of	of	IN
18637	2220	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2220	36	very	very	JJ
18637	2220	37	nature	nature	NN
18637	2220	38	"	"	``
18637	2220	39	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	2220	40	,	,	,
18637	2220	41	"	"	''
18637	2220	42	and	and	CC
18637	2220	43	hence	hence	RB
18637	2220	44	render	render	VB
18637	2220	45	the	the	DT
18637	2220	46	notion	notion	NN
18637	2220	47	of	of	IN
18637	2220	48	a	a	DT
18637	2220	49	like	like	JJ
18637	2220	50	power	power	NN
18637	2220	51	in	in	IN
18637	2220	52	the	the	DT
18637	2220	53	States	States	NNP
18637	2220	54	"	"	``
18637	2220	55	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
18637	2220	56	and	and	CC
18637	2220	57	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	2220	58	.	.	.
18637	2221	1	"	"	``
18637	2221	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2221	3	522	522	CD
18637	2221	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2221	5	As	as	IN
18637	2221	6	an	an	DT
18637	2221	7	example	example	NN
18637	2221	8	of	of	IN
18637	2221	9	the	the	DT
18637	2221	10	latter	latter	JJ
18637	2221	11	kind	kind	NN
18637	2221	12	of	of	IN
18637	2221	13	power	power	NN
18637	2221	14	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	2221	15	mentioned	mention	VBD
18637	2221	16	the	the	DT
18637	2221	17	power	power	NN
18637	2221	18	of	of	IN
18637	2221	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2221	20	to	to	TO
18637	2221	21	pass	pass	VB
18637	2221	22	a	a	DT
18637	2221	23	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2221	24	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2221	25	law	law	NN
18637	2221	26	.	.	.
18637	2222	1	Was	be	VBD
18637	2222	2	the	the	DT
18637	2222	3	same	same	JJ
18637	2222	4	principle	principle	NN
18637	2222	5	expected	expect	VBN
18637	2222	6	to	to	TO
18637	2222	7	apply	apply	VB
18637	2222	8	to	to	IN
18637	2222	9	the	the	DT
18637	2222	10	power	power	NN
18637	2222	11	over	over	IN
18637	2222	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2222	13	and	and	CC
18637	2222	14	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2222	15	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2222	16	?	?	.
18637	2223	1	Unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
18637	2223	2	one	one	CD
18637	2223	3	of	of	IN
18637	2223	4	the	the	DT
18637	2223	5	great	great	JJ
18637	2223	6	advantages	advantage	NNS
18637	2223	7	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
18637	2223	8	from	from	IN
18637	2223	9	the	the	DT
18637	2223	10	grant	grant	NN
18637	2223	11	to	to	IN
18637	2223	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2223	13	of	of	IN
18637	2223	14	power	power	NN
18637	2223	15	over	over	IN
18637	2223	16	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2223	17	was	be	VBD
18637	2223	18	that	that	IN
18637	2223	19	State	State	NNP
18637	2223	20	interferences	interference	NNS
18637	2223	21	with	with	IN
18637	2223	22	trade	trade	NN
18637	2223	23	,	,	,
18637	2223	24	which	which	WDT
18637	2223	25	had	have	VBD
18637	2223	26	become	become	VBN
18637	2223	27	a	a	DT
18637	2223	28	source	source	NN
18637	2223	29	of	of	IN
18637	2223	30	sharp	sharp	JJ
18637	2223	31	discontent	discontent	NN
18637	2223	32	under	under	IN
18637	2223	33	the	the	DT
18637	2223	34	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	2223	35	of	of	IN
18637	2223	36	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	2223	37	,	,	,
18637	2223	38	would	would	MD
18637	2223	39	be	be	VB
18637	2223	40	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	2223	41	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2223	42	to	to	IN
18637	2223	43	an	an	DT
18637	2223	44	end	end	NN
18637	2223	45	.	.	.
18637	2224	1	As	as	IN
18637	2224	2	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	2224	3	stated	state	VBD
18637	2224	4	in	in	IN
18637	2224	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2224	6	argument	argument	NN
18637	2224	7	for	for	IN
18637	2224	8	appellant	appellant	NN
18637	2224	9	in	in	IN
18637	2224	10	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	2224	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2224	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	2224	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2224	14	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	2224	15	:	:	:
18637	2224	16	"	"	``
18637	2224	17	The	the	DT
18637	2224	18	prevailing	prevail	VBG
18637	2224	19	motive	motive	NN
18637	2224	20	was	be	VBD
18637	2224	21	to	to	TO
18637	2224	22	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2224	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2224	24	;	;	:
18637	2224	25	to	to	TO
18637	2224	26	rescue	rescue	VB
18637	2224	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2224	28	from	from	IN
18637	2224	29	the	the	DT
18637	2224	30	embarrassing	embarrassing	JJ
18637	2224	31	and	and	CC
18637	2224	32	destructive	destructive	JJ
18637	2224	33	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	2224	34	,	,	,
18637	2224	35	resulting	result	VBG
18637	2224	36	from	from	IN
18637	2224	37	the	the	DT
18637	2224	38	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2224	39	of	of	IN
18637	2224	40	so	so	RB
18637	2224	41	many	many	JJ
18637	2224	42	different	different	JJ
18637	2224	43	States	state	NNS
18637	2224	44	,	,	,
18637	2224	45	and	and	CC
18637	2224	46	to	to	TO
18637	2224	47	place	place	VB
18637	2224	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2224	49	under	under	IN
18637	2224	50	the	the	DT
18637	2224	51	protection	protection	NN
18637	2224	52	of	of	IN
18637	2224	53	a	a	DT
18637	2224	54	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2224	55	law	law	NN
18637	2224	56	.	.	.
18637	2224	57	"	"	''
18637	2225	1	In	in	IN
18637	2225	2	other	other	JJ
18637	2225	3	words	word	NNS
18637	2225	4	,	,	,
18637	2225	5	the	the	DT
18637	2225	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2225	7	grant	grant	NN
18637	2225	8	was	be	VBD
18637	2225	9	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2225	10	a	a	DT
18637	2225	11	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2225	12	of	of	IN
18637	2225	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2225	14	in	in	IN
18637	2225	15	the	the	DT
18637	2225	16	interest	interest	NN
18637	2225	17	of	of	IN
18637	2225	18	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	2225	19	.	.	.
18637	2226	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2226	2	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	2226	3	's	's	POS
18637	2226	4	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	2226	5	in	in	IN
18637	2226	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2226	7	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	2226	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2226	9	in	in	IN
18637	2226	10	the	the	DT
18637	2226	11	same	same	JJ
18637	2226	12	case	case	NN
18637	2226	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	2226	14	to	to	TO
18637	2226	15	like	like	UH
18637	2226	16	effect	effect	NN
18637	2226	17	:	:	:
18637	2226	18	"	"	``
18637	2226	19	There	there	EX
18637	2226	20	was	be	VBD
18637	2226	21	not	not	RB
18637	2226	22	a	a	DT
18637	2226	23	State	state	NN
18637	2226	24	in	in	IN
18637	2226	25	the	the	DT
18637	2226	26	Union	Union	NNP
18637	2226	27	,	,	,
18637	2226	28	in	in	IN
18637	2226	29	which	which	WDT
18637	2226	30	there	there	EX
18637	2226	31	did	do	VBD
18637	2226	32	not	not	RB
18637	2226	33	,	,	,
18637	2226	34	at	at	IN
18637	2226	35	that	that	DT
18637	2226	36	time	time	NN
18637	2226	37	,	,	,
18637	2226	38	exist	exist	VBP
18637	2226	39	a	a	DT
18637	2226	40	variety	variety	NN
18637	2226	41	of	of	IN
18637	2226	42	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	2226	43	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2226	44	;	;	:
18637	2226	45	*	*	NFP
18637	2226	46	*	*	NFP
18637	2226	47	*	*	NFP
18637	2226	48	By	by	IN
18637	2226	49	common	common	JJ
18637	2226	50	consent	consent	NN
18637	2226	51	,	,	,
18637	2226	52	those	those	DT
18637	2226	53	laws	law	NNS
18637	2226	54	dropped	drop	VBD
18637	2226	55	lifeless	lifeless	JJ
18637	2226	56	from	from	IN
18637	2226	57	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2226	58	statute	statute	NN
18637	2226	59	books	book	NNS
18637	2226	60	,	,	,
18637	2226	61	for	for	IN
18637	2226	62	want	want	NN
18637	2226	63	of	of	IN
18637	2226	64	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	2226	65	power	power	NN
18637	2226	66	that	that	WDT
18637	2226	67	had	have	VBD
18637	2226	68	been	be	VBN
18637	2226	69	relinquished	relinquish	VBN
18637	2226	70	to	to	IN
18637	2226	71	Congress";[523	Congress";[523	NNP
18637	2226	72	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2226	73	and	and	CC
18637	2226	74	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	2226	75	's	's	POS
18637	2226	76	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	2226	77	,	,	,
18637	2226	78	late	late	RB
18637	2226	79	in	in	IN
18637	2226	80	life	life	NN
18637	2226	81	,	,	,
18637	2226	82	that	that	DT
18637	2226	83	power	power	NN
18637	2226	84	had	have	VBD
18637	2226	85	been	be	VBN
18637	2226	86	granted	grant	VBN
18637	2226	87	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2226	88	over	over	IN
18637	2226	89	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2226	90	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2226	91	mainly	mainly	RB
18637	2226	92	as	as	IN
18637	2226	93	"	"	``
18637	2226	94	a	a	DT
18637	2226	95	negative	negative	JJ
18637	2226	96	and	and	CC
18637	2226	97	preventive	preventive	JJ
18637	2226	98	provision	provision	NN
18637	2226	99	against	against	IN
18637	2226	100	injustice	injustice	NN
18637	2226	101	among	among	IN
18637	2226	102	the	the	DT
18637	2226	103	States,"[524	states,"[524	NN
18637	2226	104	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2226	105	carries	carry	VBZ
18637	2226	106	a	a	DT
18637	2226	107	like	like	JJ
18637	2226	108	implication	implication	NN
18637	2226	109	.	.	.
18637	2227	1	That	that	IN
18637	2227	2	,	,	,
18637	2227	3	however	however	RB
18637	2227	4	,	,	,
18637	2227	5	the	the	DT
18637	2227	6	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2227	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	2227	8	,	,	,
18637	2227	9	unimplemented	unimplemente	VBN
18637	2227	10	by	by	IN
18637	2227	11	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2227	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2227	13	,	,	,
18637	2227	14	took	take	VBD
18637	2227	15	from	from	IN
18637	2227	16	the	the	DT
18637	2227	17	States	States	NNP
18637	2227	18	any	any	DT
18637	2227	19	and	and	CC
18637	2227	20	all	all	DT
18637	2227	21	power	power	NN
18637	2227	22	over	over	IN
18637	2227	23	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2227	24	and	and	CC
18637	2227	25	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2227	26	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2227	27	was	be	VBD
18637	2227	28	by	by	IN
18637	2227	29	no	no	DT
18637	2227	30	means	means	NN
18637	2227	31	universally	universally	RB
18637	2227	32	conceded	conceded	JJ
18637	2227	33	;	;	:
18637	2227	34	and	and	CC
18637	2227	35	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	2227	36	's	's	POS
18637	2227	37	attorneys	attorney	NNS
18637	2227	38	directly	directly	RB
18637	2227	39	challenged	challenge	VBD
18637	2227	40	the	the	DT
18637	2227	41	idea	idea	NN
18637	2227	42	.	.	.
18637	2228	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	2228	2	,	,	,
18637	2228	3	as	as	IN
18637	2228	4	was	be	VBD
18637	2228	5	pointed	point	VBN
18637	2228	6	out	out	RP
18637	2228	7	on	on	IN
18637	2228	8	both	both	DT
18637	2228	9	sides	side	NNS
18637	2228	10	in	in	IN
18637	2228	11	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	2228	12	_	_	NNP
18637	2228	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	2228	14	_	_	NNP
18637	2228	15	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	2228	16	,	,	,
18637	2228	17	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2228	18	by	by	IN
18637	2228	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2228	20	regulative	regulative	JJ
18637	2228	21	of	of	IN
18637	2228	22	any	any	DT
18637	2228	23	particular	particular	JJ
18637	2228	24	phase	phase	NN
18637	2228	25	of	of	IN
18637	2228	26	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2228	27	would	would	MD
18637	2228	28	still	still	RB
18637	2228	29	leave	leave	VB
18637	2228	30	many	many	JJ
18637	2228	31	other	other	JJ
18637	2228	32	phases	phase	NNS
18637	2228	33	unregulated	unregulated	JJ
18637	2228	34	and	and	CC
18637	2228	35	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	2228	36	raise	raise	VB
18637	2228	37	the	the	DT
18637	2228	38	question	question	NN
18637	2228	39	whether	whether	IN
18637	2228	40	the	the	DT
18637	2228	41	States	States	NNPS
18637	2228	42	were	be	VBD
18637	2228	43	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	2228	44	to	to	TO
18637	2228	45	fill	fill	VB
18637	2228	46	the	the	DT
18637	2228	47	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	2228	48	gaps	gap	NNS
18637	2228	49	,	,	,
18637	2228	50	if	if	IN
18637	2228	51	not	not	RB
18637	2228	52	by	by	IN
18637	2228	53	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	2228	54	of	of	IN
18637	2228	55	a	a	DT
18637	2228	56	"	"	``
18637	2228	57	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	2228	58	"	"	''
18637	2228	59	power	power	NN
18637	2228	60	over	over	IN
18637	2228	61	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2228	62	and	and	CC
18637	2228	63	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2228	64	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2228	65	,	,	,
18637	2228	66	then	then	RB
18637	2228	67	by	by	IN
18637	2228	68	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	2228	69	of	of	IN
18637	2228	70	"	"	``
18637	2228	71	that	that	IN
18637	2228	72	immense	immense	JJ
18637	2228	73	mass	mass	NN
18637	2228	74	of	of	IN
18637	2228	75	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2228	76	,	,	,
18637	2228	77	"	"	''
18637	2228	78	as	as	IN
18637	2228	79	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2228	80	termed	term	VBD
18637	2228	81	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2228	82	,	,	,
18637	2228	83	"	"	''
18637	2228	84	which	which	WDT
18637	2228	85	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	2228	86	everything	everything	NN
18637	2228	87	within	within	IN
18637	2228	88	the	the	DT
18637	2228	89	territory	territory	NN
18637	2228	90	of	of	IN
18637	2228	91	a	a	DT
18637	2228	92	State	State	NNP
18637	2228	93	,	,	,
18637	2228	94	not	not	RB
18637	2228	95	surrendered	surrender	VBN
18637	2228	96	to	to	IN
18637	2228	97	the	the	DT
18637	2228	98	general	general	JJ
18637	2228	99	government,"[525]--in	government,"[525]--in	NNP
18637	2228	100	a	a	DT
18637	2228	101	word	word	NN
18637	2228	102	,	,	,
18637	2228	103	the	the	DT
18637	2228	104	"	"	``
18637	2228	105	police	police	NN
18637	2228	106	power	power	NN
18637	2228	107	.	.	.
18637	2228	108	"	"	''
18637	2229	1	The	the	DT
18637	2229	2	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2229	3	clause	clause	NN
18637	2229	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	2229	5	not	not	RB
18637	2229	6	,	,	,
18637	2229	7	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	2229	8	,	,	,
18637	2229	9	without	without	IN
18637	2229	10	more	more	JJR
18637	2229	11	ado	ado	NN
18637	2229	12	,	,	,
18637	2229	13	settle	settle	VB
18637	2229	14	the	the	DT
18637	2229	15	question	question	NN
18637	2229	16	of	of	IN
18637	2229	17	what	what	WDT
18637	2229	18	power	power	NN
18637	2229	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	2229	20	left	leave	VBN
18637	2229	21	to	to	IN
18637	2229	22	the	the	DT
18637	2229	23	States	States	NNPS
18637	2229	24	to	to	TO
18637	2229	25	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	2229	26	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2229	27	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	2229	28	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2229	29	or	or	CC
18637	2229	30	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2229	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2229	32	in	in	IN
18637	2229	33	greater	great	JJR
18637	2229	34	or	or	CC
18637	2229	35	less	less	JJR
18637	2229	36	measure	measure	NN
18637	2229	37	.	.	.
18637	2230	1	To	to	TO
18637	2230	2	be	be	VB
18637	2230	3	sure	sure	JJ
18637	2230	4	,	,	,
18637	2230	5	in	in	IN
18637	2230	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	2230	7	of	of	IN
18637	2230	8	flat	flat	JJ
18637	2230	9	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	2230	10	between	between	IN
18637	2230	11	an	an	DT
18637	2230	12	act	act	NN
18637	2230	13	or	or	CC
18637	2230	14	acts	act	NNS
18637	2230	15	of	of	IN
18637	2230	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2230	17	regulative	regulative	JJ
18637	2230	18	of	of	IN
18637	2230	19	such	such	JJ
18637	2230	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2230	21	and	and	CC
18637	2230	22	a	a	DT
18637	2230	23	State	State	NNP
18637	2230	24	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2230	25	act	act	NN
18637	2230	26	or	or	CC
18637	2230	27	acts	act	NNS
18637	2230	28	,	,	,
18637	2230	29	from	from	IN
18637	2230	30	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	2230	31	State	state	NN
18637	2230	32	power	power	NN
18637	2230	33	ensuing	ensue	VBG
18637	2230	34	,	,	,
18637	2230	35	the	the	DT
18637	2230	36	act	act	NN
18637	2230	37	of	of	IN
18637	2230	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2230	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	2230	40	today	today	NN
18637	2230	41	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	2230	42	,	,	,
18637	2230	43	and	and	CC
18637	2230	44	was	be	VBD
18637	2230	45	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	2230	46	by	by	IN
18637	2230	47	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2230	48	,	,	,
18637	2230	49	as	as	IN
18637	2230	50	enjoying	enjoy	VBG
18637	2230	51	an	an	DT
18637	2230	52	unquestionable	unquestionable	JJ
18637	2230	53	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	2230	54	.	.	.
18637	2231	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2231	2	526	526	CD
18637	2231	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2231	4	But	but	CC
18637	2231	5	suppose	suppose	VB
18637	2231	6	,	,	,
18637	2231	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2231	8	first	first	JJ
18637	2231	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2231	10	,	,	,
18637	2231	11	that	that	IN
18637	2231	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2231	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	2231	14	passed	pass	VBN
18637	2231	15	no	no	DT
18637	2231	16	act	act	NN
18637	2231	17	;	;	:
18637	2231	18	or	or	CC
18637	2231	19	_	_	NNP
18637	2231	20	secondly	secondly	RB
18637	2231	21	_	_	NNP
18637	2231	22	,	,	,
18637	2231	23	that	that	IN
18637	2231	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2231	25	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2231	26	does	do	VBZ
18637	2231	27	not	not	RB
18637	2231	28	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	2231	29	cover	cover	VB
18637	2231	30	the	the	DT
18637	2231	31	ground	ground	NN
18637	2231	32	which	which	WDT
18637	2231	33	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2231	34	State	State	NNP
18637	2231	35	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2231	36	before	before	IN
18637	2231	37	the	the	DT
18637	2231	38	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2231	39	attempts	attempt	VBZ
18637	2231	40	to	to	TO
18637	2231	41	cover	cover	VB
18637	2231	42	--	--	:
18637	2231	43	what	what	WP
18637	2231	44	rules	rule	NNS
18637	2231	45	then	then	RB
18637	2231	46	apply	apply	VBP
18637	2231	47	?	?	.
18637	2232	1	Since	since	IN
18637	2232	2	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	2232	3	_	_	NNP
18637	2232	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	2232	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2232	6	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	2232	7	both	both	DT
18637	2232	8	of	of	IN
18637	2232	9	these	these	DT
18637	2232	10	situations	situation	NNS
18637	2232	11	have	have	VBP
18637	2232	12	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	2232	13	the	the	DT
18637	2232	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2232	15	,	,	,
18637	2232	16	especially	especially	RB
18637	2232	17	as	as	IN
18637	2232	18	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	2232	19	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2232	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2232	21	,	,	,
18637	2232	22	hundreds	hundred	NNS
18637	2232	23	of	of	IN
18637	2232	24	times	time	NNS
18637	2232	25	,	,	,
18637	2232	26	and	and	CC
18637	2232	27	in	in	IN
18637	2232	28	meeting	meet	VBG
18637	2232	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2232	30	the	the	DT
18637	2232	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2232	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	2232	33	,	,	,
18637	2232	34	first	first	JJ
18637	2232	35	and	and	CC
18637	2232	36	last	last	JJ
18637	2232	37	,	,	,
18637	2232	38	coined	coin	VBD
18637	2232	39	or	or	CC
18637	2232	40	given	give	VBN
18637	2232	41	currency	currency	NN
18637	2232	42	to	to	IN
18637	2232	43	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	2232	44	formulas	formula	NNS
18637	2232	45	,	,	,
18637	2232	46	some	some	DT
18637	2232	47	of	of	IN
18637	2232	48	which	which	WDT
18637	2232	49	still	still	RB
18637	2232	50	guide	guide	VBP
18637	2232	51	,	,	,
18637	2232	52	even	even	RB
18637	2232	53	when	when	WRB
18637	2232	54	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2232	55	do	do	VBP
18637	2232	56	not	not	RB
18637	2232	57	govern	govern	VB
18637	2232	58	,	,	,
18637	2232	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2232	60	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	2232	61	.	.	.
18637	2233	1	DOCTRINAL	doctrinal	NN
18637	2233	2	BACKGROUND	background	NN
18637	2233	3	;	;	:
18637	2233	4	WEBSTER	WEBSTER	NNP
18637	2233	5	'S	be	VBZ
18637	2233	6	CONTRIBUTION	contribution	NN
18637	2233	7	The	the	DT
18637	2233	8	earliest	early	JJS
18637	2233	9	,	,	,
18637	2233	10	and	and	CC
18637	2233	11	the	the	DT
18637	2233	12	most	most	RBS
18637	2233	13	successful	successful	JJ
18637	2233	14	,	,	,
18637	2233	15	attempt	attempt	VB
18637	2233	16	to	to	TO
18637	2233	17	set	set	VB
18637	2233	18	forth	forth	RP
18637	2233	19	a	a	DT
18637	2233	20	principle	principle	NN
18637	2233	21	capable	capable	JJ
18637	2233	22	of	of	IN
18637	2233	23	guiding	guide	VBG
18637	2233	24	the	the	DT
18637	2233	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2233	26	in	in	IN
18637	2233	27	adjusting	adjust	VBG
18637	2233	28	the	the	DT
18637	2233	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	2233	30	of	of	IN
18637	2233	31	the	the	DT
18637	2233	32	States	States	NNPS
18637	2233	33	to	to	IN
18637	2233	34	unexercised	unexercised	JJ
18637	2233	35	power	power	NN
18637	2233	36	of	of	IN
18637	2233	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2233	38	under	under	IN
18637	2233	39	the	the	DT
18637	2233	40	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2233	41	clause	clause	NN
18637	2233	42	was	be	VBD
18637	2233	43	that	that	DT
18637	2233	44	which	which	WDT
18637	2233	45	was	be	VBD
18637	2233	46	made	make	VBN
18637	2233	47	by	by	IN
18637	2233	48	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	2233	49	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	2233	50	in	in	IN
18637	2233	51	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2233	52	argument	argument	NN
18637	2233	53	in	in	IN
18637	2233	54	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	2233	55	_	_	NNP
18637	2233	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	2233	57	_	_	NNP
18637	2233	58	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	2233	59	,	,	,
18637	2233	60	in	in	IN
18637	2233	61	the	the	DT
18637	2233	62	following	follow	VBG
18637	2233	63	words	word	NNS
18637	2233	64	:	:	:
18637	2233	65	"	"	''
18637	2233	66	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2233	67	contended	contend	VBD
18637	2233	68	,	,	,
18637	2233	69	*	*	NFP
18637	2233	70	*	*	NFP
18637	2233	71	*	*	NFP
18637	2233	72	,	,	,
18637	2233	73	that	that	IN
18637	2233	74	the	the	DT
18637	2233	75	people	people	NNS
18637	2233	76	intended	intend	VBD
18637	2233	77	,	,	,
18637	2233	78	in	in	IN
18637	2233	79	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	2233	80	the	the	DT
18637	2233	81	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2233	82	,	,	,
18637	2233	83	to	to	TO
18637	2233	84	transfer	transfer	VB
18637	2233	85	from	from	IN
18637	2233	86	the	the	DT
18637	2233	87	several	several	JJ
18637	2233	88	States	state	NNS
18637	2233	89	to	to	IN
18637	2233	90	a	a	DT
18637	2233	91	general	general	JJ
18637	2233	92	government	government	NN
18637	2233	93	,	,	,
18637	2233	94	those	those	DT
18637	2233	95	high	high	JJ
18637	2233	96	and	and	CC
18637	2233	97	important	important	JJ
18637	2233	98	powers	power	NNS
18637	2233	99	over	over	IN
18637	2233	100	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2233	101	,	,	,
18637	2233	102	which	which	WDT
18637	2233	103	,	,	,
18637	2233	104	in	in	IN
18637	2233	105	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2233	106	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2233	107	,	,	,
18637	2233	108	were	be	VBD
18637	2233	109	to	to	TO
18637	2233	110	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	2233	111	a	a	DT
18637	2233	112	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2233	113	and	and	CC
18637	2233	114	general	general	JJ
18637	2233	115	system	system	NN
18637	2233	116	.	.	.
18637	2234	1	From	from	IN
18637	2234	2	the	the	DT
18637	2234	3	very	very	JJ
18637	2234	4	nature	nature	NN
18637	2234	5	of	of	IN
18637	2234	6	the	the	DT
18637	2234	7	case	case	NN
18637	2234	8	,	,	,
18637	2234	9	these	these	DT
18637	2234	10	powers	power	NNS
18637	2234	11	must	must	MD
18637	2234	12	be	be	VB
18637	2234	13	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	2234	14	;	;	:
18637	2234	15	that	that	RB
18637	2234	16	is	is	RB
18637	2234	17	,	,	,
18637	2234	18	the	the	DT
18637	2234	19	higher	high	JJR
18637	2234	20	branches	branch	NNS
18637	2234	21	of	of	IN
18637	2234	22	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	2234	23	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2234	24	must	must	MD
18637	2234	25	be	be	VB
18637	2234	26	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	2234	27	committed	commit	VBN
18637	2234	28	to	to	IN
18637	2234	29	a	a	DT
18637	2234	30	single	single	JJ
18637	2234	31	hand	hand	NN
18637	2234	32	.	.	.
18637	2235	1	What	what	WP
18637	2235	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2235	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2235	4	that	that	WDT
18637	2235	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	2235	6	to	to	TO
18637	2235	7	be	be	VB
18637	2235	8	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	2235	9	?	?	.
18637	2236	1	Not	not	RB
18637	2236	2	the	the	DT
18637	2236	3	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2236	4	of	of	IN
18637	2236	5	the	the	DT
18637	2236	6	several	several	JJ
18637	2236	7	States	States	NNPS
18637	2236	8	,	,	,
18637	2236	9	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	2236	10	,	,	,
18637	2236	11	but	but	CC
18637	2236	12	the	the	DT
18637	2236	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2236	14	of	of	IN
18637	2236	15	the	the	DT
18637	2236	16	United	United	NNP
18637	2236	17	States	States	NNP
18637	2236	18	.	.	.
18637	2237	1	Henceforth	henceforth	RB
18637	2237	2	,	,	,
18637	2237	3	the	the	DT
18637	2237	4	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2237	5	of	of	IN
18637	2237	6	the	the	DT
18637	2237	7	States	States	NNP
18637	2237	8	was	be	VBD
18637	2237	9	to	to	TO
18637	2237	10	be	be	VB
18637	2237	11	a	a	DT
18637	2237	12	unit	unit	NN
18637	2237	13	;	;	:
18637	2237	14	and	and	CC
18637	2237	15	the	the	DT
18637	2237	16	system	system	NN
18637	2237	17	by	by	IN
18637	2237	18	which	which	WDT
18637	2237	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2237	20	was	be	VBD
18637	2237	21	to	to	TO
18637	2237	22	exist	exist	VB
18637	2237	23	and	and	CC
18637	2237	24	be	be	VB
18637	2237	25	governed	govern	VBN
18637	2237	26	,	,	,
18637	2237	27	must	must	MD
18637	2237	28	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	2237	29	be	be	VB
18637	2237	30	complete	complete	JJ
18637	2237	31	,	,	,
18637	2237	32	entire	entire	JJ
18637	2237	33	and	and	CC
18637	2237	34	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2237	35	.	.	.
18637	2237	36	"	"	''
18637	2238	1	At	at	IN
18637	2238	2	the	the	DT
18637	2238	3	same	same	JJ
18637	2238	4	time	time	NN
18637	2238	5	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	2238	6	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	2238	7	"	"	``
18637	2238	8	that	that	IN
18637	2238	9	the	the	DT
18637	2238	10	words	word	NNS
18637	2238	11	used	use	VBN
18637	2238	12	in	in	IN
18637	2238	13	the	the	DT
18637	2238	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2238	15	,	,	,
18637	2238	16	'	'	''
18637	2238	17	to	to	TO
18637	2238	18	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2238	19	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2238	20	,	,	,
18637	2238	21	'	'	''
18637	2238	22	are	be	VBP
18637	2238	23	so	so	RB
18637	2238	24	very	very	RB
18637	2238	25	general	general	JJ
18637	2238	26	and	and	CC
18637	2238	27	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	2238	28	,	,	,
18637	2238	29	that	that	IN
18637	2238	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2238	31	might	may	MD
18637	2238	32	be	be	VB
18637	2238	33	construed	construe	VBN
18637	2238	34	to	to	TO
18637	2238	35	cover	cover	VB
18637	2238	36	a	a	DT
18637	2238	37	vast	vast	JJ
18637	2238	38	field	field	NN
18637	2238	39	of	of	IN
18637	2238	40	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2238	41	,	,	,
18637	2238	42	part	part	NN
18637	2238	43	of	of	IN
18637	2238	44	which	which	WDT
18637	2238	45	has	have	VBZ
18637	2238	46	always	always	RB
18637	2238	47	been	be	VBN
18637	2238	48	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	2238	49	by	by	IN
18637	2238	50	State	state	NN
18637	2238	51	laws	law	NNS
18637	2238	52	;	;	:
18637	2238	53	and	and	CC
18637	2238	54	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	2238	55	,	,	,
18637	2238	56	the	the	DT
18637	2238	57	words	word	NNS
18637	2238	58	must	must	MD
18637	2238	59	have	have	VB
18637	2238	60	a	a	DT
18637	2238	61	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2238	62	construction	construction	NN
18637	2238	63	,	,	,
18637	2238	64	and	and	CC
18637	2238	65	the	the	DT
18637	2238	66	power	power	NN
18637	2238	67	should	should	MD
18637	2238	68	be	be	VB
18637	2238	69	considered	consider	VBN
18637	2238	70	as	as	IN
18637	2238	71	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	2238	72	vested	vest	VBN
18637	2238	73	in	in	IN
18637	2238	74	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2238	75	,	,	,
18637	2238	76	so	so	RB
18637	2238	77	far	far	RB
18637	2238	78	,	,	,
18637	2238	79	and	and	CC
18637	2238	80	so	so	RB
18637	2238	81	far	far	RB
18637	2238	82	only	only	RB
18637	2238	83	,	,	,
18637	2238	84	as	as	IN
18637	2238	85	the	the	DT
18637	2238	86	nature	nature	NN
18637	2238	87	of	of	IN
18637	2238	88	the	the	DT
18637	2238	89	power	power	NN
18637	2238	90	requires	require	VBZ
18637	2238	91	.	.	.
18637	2239	1	"	"	``
18637	2239	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2239	3	527	527	CD
18637	2239	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2239	5	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	2239	6	also	also	RB
18637	2239	7	dealt	deal	VBD
18637	2239	8	with	with	IN
18637	2239	9	the	the	DT
18637	2239	10	problem	problem	NN
18637	2239	11	which	which	WDT
18637	2239	12	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	2239	13	when	when	WRB
18637	2239	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2239	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	2239	16	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	2239	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2239	18	power	power	NN
18637	2239	19	.	.	.
18637	2240	1	The	the	DT
18637	2240	2	results	result	NNS
18637	2240	3	of	of	IN
18637	2240	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2240	5	act	act	NN
18637	2240	6	,	,	,
18637	2240	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2240	8	contended	contend	VBD
18637	2240	9	,	,	,
18637	2240	10	must	must	MD
18637	2240	11	be	be	VB
18637	2240	12	treated	treat	VBN
18637	2240	13	as	as	IN
18637	2240	14	a	a	DT
18637	2240	15	unit	unit	NN
18637	2240	16	,	,	,
18637	2240	17	so	so	IN
18637	2240	18	that	that	IN
18637	2240	19	when	when	WRB
18637	2240	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2240	21	had	have	VBD
18637	2240	22	left	leave	VBN
18637	2240	23	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2240	24	matter	matter	NN
18637	2240	25	within	within	IN
18637	2240	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2240	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2240	28	unregulated	unregulated	JJ
18637	2240	29	,	,	,
18637	2240	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2240	31	must	must	MD
18637	2240	32	be	be	VB
18637	2240	33	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	2240	34	to	to	TO
18637	2240	35	have	have	VB
18637	2240	36	done	do	VBN
18637	2240	37	so	so	RB
18637	2240	38	of	of	IN
18637	2240	39	design	design	NN
18637	2240	40	,	,	,
18637	2240	41	and	and	CC
18637	2240	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2240	43	omissions	omission	NNS
18637	2240	44	,	,	,
18637	2240	45	or	or	CC
18637	2240	46	silences	silence	NNS
18637	2240	47	,	,	,
18637	2240	48	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	2240	49	be	be	VB
18637	2240	50	left	leave	VBN
18637	2240	51	undisturbed	undisturbed	JJ
18637	2240	52	by	by	IN
18637	2240	53	State	state	NN
18637	2240	54	action	action	NN
18637	2240	55	.	.	.
18637	2241	1	Although	although	IN
18637	2241	2	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2241	3	,	,	,
18637	2241	4	because	because	IN
18637	2241	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2241	6	thought	think	VBD
18637	2241	7	the	the	DT
18637	2241	8	New	New	NNP
18637	2241	9	York	York	NNP
18637	2241	10	act	act	NN
18637	2241	11	creating	create	VBG
18637	2241	12	the	the	DT
18637	2241	13	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
18637	2241	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	2241	15	Fulton	Fulton	NNP
18637	2241	16	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	2241	17	to	to	TO
18637	2241	18	be	be	VB
18637	2241	19	in	in	IN
18637	2241	20	direct	direct	JJ
18637	2241	21	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	2241	22	with	with	IN
18637	2241	23	the	the	DT
18637	2241	24	Enrolling	Enrolling	NNP
18637	2241	25	and	and	CC
18637	2241	26	Licensing	Licensing	NNP
18637	2241	27	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2241	28	of	of	IN
18637	2241	29	1793	1793	CD
18637	2241	30	,	,	,
18637	2241	31	was	be	VBD
18637	2241	32	not	not	RB
18637	2241	33	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	2241	34	to	to	TO
18637	2241	35	pass	pass	VB
18637	2241	36	on	on	RP
18637	2241	37	either	either	DT
18637	2241	38	of	of	IN
18637	2241	39	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	2241	40	's	's	POS
18637	2241	41	theories	theory	NNS
18637	2241	42	,	,	,
18637	2241	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2241	44	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	2241	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2241	46	sympathy	sympathy	NN
18637	2241	47	with	with	IN
18637	2241	48	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2241	49	.	.	.
18637	2242	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2242	2	528	528	CD
18637	2242	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2242	4	COOLEY	COOLEY	NNP
18637	2242	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2242	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	2242	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2242	8	BOARD	BOARD	NNP
18637	2242	9	OF	of	IN
18637	2242	10	PORT	PORT	NNP
18637	2242	11	WARDENS	warden	VBD
18637	2242	12	Aside	aside	RB
18637	2242	13	from	from	IN
18637	2242	14	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2242	15	's	's	POS
18637	2242	16	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2242	17	in	in	IN
18637	2242	18	1827	1827	CD
18637	2242	19	in	in	IN
18637	2242	20	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	2242	21	_	_	NNP
18637	2242	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	2242	23	_	_	NNP
18637	2242	24	Maryland,[529	Maryland,[529	NNP
18637	2242	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2242	26	in	in	IN
18637	2242	27	which	which	WDT
18637	2242	28	the	the	DT
18637	2242	29	famous	famous	JJ
18637	2242	30	"	"	``
18637	2242	31	original	original	JJ
18637	2242	32	package	package	NN
18637	2242	33	"	"	''
18637	2242	34	formula	formula	NN
18637	2242	35	made	make	VBD
18637	2242	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2242	37	debut	debut	NN
18637	2242	38	,	,	,
18637	2242	39	the	the	DT
18637	2242	40	most	most	RBS
18637	2242	41	important	important	JJ
18637	2242	42	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	2242	43	of	of	IN
18637	2242	44	the	the	DT
18637	2242	45	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2242	46	touching	touch	VBG
18637	2242	47	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	2242	48	of	of	IN
18637	2242	49	the	the	DT
18637	2242	50	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2242	51	clause	clause	NN
18637	2242	52	as	as	IN
18637	2242	53	a	a	DT
18637	2242	54	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	2242	55	on	on	IN
18637	2242	56	State	State	NNP
18637	2242	57	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2242	58	power	power	NN
18637	2242	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	2242	60	that	that	IN
18637	2242	61	for	for	IN
18637	2242	62	which	which	WDT
18637	2242	63	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	2242	64	_	_	NNP
18637	2242	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	2242	66	_	_	NNP
18637	2242	67	Board	Board	NNP
18637	2242	68	of	of	IN
18637	2242	69	Wardens	Wardens	NNP
18637	2242	70	of	of	IN
18637	2242	71	Port	Port	NNP
18637	2242	72	of	of	IN
18637	2242	73	Philadelphia,[530	Philadelphia,[530	NNP
18637	2242	74	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2242	75	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2242	76	in	in	IN
18637	2242	77	1851	1851	CD
18637	2242	78	,	,	,
18637	2242	79	is	be	VBZ
18637	2242	80	usually	usually	RB
18637	2242	81	cited	cite	VBN
18637	2242	82	.	.	.
18637	2243	1	The	the	DT
18637	2243	2	question	question	NN
18637	2243	3	at	at	IN
18637	2243	4	issue	issue	NN
18637	2243	5	was	be	VBD
18637	2243	6	the	the	DT
18637	2243	7	validity	validity	NN
18637	2243	8	of	of	IN
18637	2243	9	a	a	DT
18637	2243	10	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2243	11	pilotage	pilotage	NN
18637	2243	12	act	act	NN
18637	2243	13	so	so	RB
18637	2243	14	far	far	RB
18637	2243	15	as	as	IN
18637	2243	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2243	17	applied	apply	VBD
18637	2243	18	to	to	IN
18637	2243	19	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2243	20	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2243	21	in	in	IN
18637	2243	22	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2243	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2243	24	and	and	CC
18637	2243	25	the	the	DT
18637	2243	26	coastwise	coastwise	NNP
18637	2243	27	trade	trade	NN
18637	2243	28	.	.	.
18637	2244	1	The	the	DT
18637	2244	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2244	3	,	,	,
18637	2244	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2244	5	through	through	IN
18637	2244	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2244	7	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	2244	8	,	,	,
18637	2244	9	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	2244	10	the	the	DT
18637	2244	11	act	act	NN
18637	2244	12	on	on	IN
18637	2244	13	the	the	DT
18637	2244	14	basis	basis	NN
18637	2244	15	of	of	IN
18637	2244	16	a	a	DT
18637	2244	17	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	2244	18	between	between	IN
18637	2244	19	those	those	DT
18637	2244	20	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	2244	21	of	of	IN
18637	2244	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2244	23	which	which	WDT
18637	2244	24	"	"	``
18637	2244	25	imperatively	imperatively	RB
18637	2244	26	demand	demand	VBP
18637	2244	27	a	a	DT
18637	2244	28	single	single	JJ
18637	2244	29	uniform	uniform	NN
18637	2244	30	rule	rule	NN
18637	2244	31	"	"	''
18637	2244	32	operating	operate	VBG
18637	2244	33	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	2244	34	the	the	DT
18637	2244	35	country	country	NN
18637	2244	36	and	and	CC
18637	2244	37	those	those	DT
18637	2244	38	which	which	WDT
18637	2244	39	"	"	``
18637	2244	40	as	as	IN
18637	2244	41	imperatively	imperatively	RB
18637	2244	42	"	"	``
18637	2244	43	demand	demand	NN
18637	2244	44	"	"	''
18637	2244	45	that	that	DT
18637	2244	46	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	2244	47	which	which	WDT
18637	2244	48	alone	alone	RB
18637	2244	49	can	can	MD
18637	2244	50	meet	meet	VB
18637	2244	51	the	the	DT
18637	2244	52	local	local	JJ
18637	2244	53	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	2244	54	of	of	IN
18637	2244	55	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	2244	56	,	,	,
18637	2244	57	"	"	''
18637	2244	58	that	that	DT
18637	2244	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	2244	60	to	to	TO
18637	2244	61	say	say	VB
18637	2244	62	,	,	,
18637	2244	63	of	of	IN
18637	2244	64	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2244	65	.	.	.
18637	2245	1	As	as	IN
18637	2245	2	to	to	IN
18637	2245	3	the	the	DT
18637	2245	4	former	former	JJ
18637	2245	5	the	the	DT
18637	2245	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2245	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	2245	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2245	9	's	's	POS
18637	2245	10	power	power	NN
18637	2245	11	to	to	TO
18637	2245	12	be	be	VB
18637	2245	13	"	"	``
18637	2245	14	exclusive"--as	exclusive"--as	JJ
18637	2245	15	to	to	IN
18637	2245	16	the	the	DT
18637	2245	17	latter	latter	JJ
18637	2245	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2245	19	held	hold	VBD
18637	2245	20	that	that	IN
18637	2245	21	the	the	DT
18637	2245	22	States	States	NNPS
18637	2245	23	enjoyed	enjoy	VBD
18637	2245	24	a	a	DT
18637	2245	25	power	power	NN
18637	2245	26	of	of	IN
18637	2245	27	"	"	``
18637	2245	28	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	2245	29	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2245	30	.	.	.
18637	2245	31	"	"	''
18637	2246	1	While	while	IN
18637	2246	2	this	this	DT
18637	2246	3	formula	formula	NN
18637	2246	4	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	2246	5	stems	stem	VBZ
18637	2246	6	directly	directly	RB
18637	2246	7	from	from	IN
18637	2246	8	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	2246	9	's	's	POS
18637	2246	10	argument	argument	NN
18637	2246	11	in	in	IN
18637	2246	12	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	2246	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2246	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	2246	15	_	_	NNP
18637	2246	16	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	2246	17	,	,	,
18637	2246	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2246	19	covers	cover	VBZ
18637	2246	20	considerably	considerably	RB
18637	2246	21	less	less	JJR
18637	2246	22	ground	ground	NN
18637	2246	23	.	.	.
18637	2247	1	Citation	citation	NN
18637	2247	2	,	,	,
18637	2247	3	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	2247	4	,	,	,
18637	2247	5	of	of	IN
18637	2247	6	the	the	DT
18637	2247	7	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	2247	8	case	case	NN
18637	2247	9	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	2247	10	the	the	DT
18637	2247	11	next	next	JJ
18637	2247	12	half	half	JJ
18637	2247	13	century	century	NN
18637	2247	14	eliminated	eliminate	VBD
18637	2247	15	the	the	DT
18637	2247	16	difference	difference	NN
18637	2247	17	and	and	CC
18637	2247	18	brought	bring	VBD
18637	2247	19	the	the	DT
18637	2247	20	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	2247	21	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	2247	22	abreast	abreast	NN
18637	2247	23	of	of	IN
18637	2247	24	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	2247	25	's	's	POS
18637	2247	26	earlier	early	JJR
18637	2247	27	argument	argument	NN
18637	2247	28	.	.	.
18637	2248	1	The	the	DT
18637	2248	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2248	3	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	2248	4	came	come	VBD
18637	2248	5	to	to	TO
18637	2248	6	be	be	VB
18637	2248	7	established	establish	VBN
18637	2248	8	,	,	,
18637	2248	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2248	10	first	first	JJ
18637	2248	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2248	12	,	,	,
18637	2248	13	that	that	IN
18637	2248	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2248	15	's	's	POS
18637	2248	16	power	power	NN
18637	2248	17	over	over	IN
18637	2248	18	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2248	19	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2248	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	2248	21	"	"	``
18637	2248	22	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	2248	23	"	"	''
18637	2248	24	as	as	IN
18637	2248	25	to	to	IN
18637	2248	26	those	those	DT
18637	2248	27	phases	phase	NNS
18637	2248	28	of	of	IN
18637	2248	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2248	30	which	which	WDT
18637	2248	31	require	require	VBP
18637	2248	32	"	"	``
18637	2248	33	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2248	34	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2248	35	"	"	''
18637	2248	36	;	;	:
18637	2248	37	_	_	NNP
18637	2248	38	second	second	JJ
18637	2248	39	_	_	NNP
18637	2248	40	,	,	,
18637	2248	41	that	that	IN
18637	2248	42	outside	outside	IN
18637	2248	43	this	this	DT
18637	2248	44	field	field	NN
18637	2248	45	,	,	,
18637	2248	46	as	as	IN
18637	2248	47	plotted	plot	VBN
18637	2248	48	by	by	IN
18637	2248	49	the	the	DT
18637	2248	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2248	51	,	,	,
18637	2248	52	the	the	DT
18637	2248	53	States	state	NNS
18637	2248	54	enjoyed	enjoy	VBD
18637	2248	55	a	a	DT
18637	2248	56	"	"	``
18637	2248	57	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	2248	58	"	"	''
18637	2248	59	power	power	NN
18637	2248	60	of	of	IN
18637	2248	61	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2248	62	,	,	,
18637	2248	63	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2248	64	to	to	IN
18637	2248	65	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2248	66	's	's	POS
18637	2248	67	overriding	override	VBG
18637	2248	68	power	power	NN
18637	2248	69	.	.	.
18637	2249	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2249	2	531	531	CD
18637	2249	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2249	4	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	2249	5	FORMULAS	FORMULAS	NNP
18637	2249	6	But	but	CC
18637	2249	7	meantime	meantime	RB
18637	2249	8	other	other	JJ
18637	2249	9	formulas	formula	NNS
18637	2249	10	had	have	VBD
18637	2249	11	emerged	emerge	VBN
18637	2249	12	from	from	IN
18637	2249	13	the	the	DT
18637	2249	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	2249	15	smithy	smithy	NN
18637	2249	16	,	,	,
18637	2249	17	several	several	JJ
18637	2249	18	of	of	IN
18637	2249	19	which	which	WDT
18637	2249	20	are	be	VBP
18637	2249	21	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2249	22	together	together	RB
18637	2249	23	into	into	IN
18637	2249	24	something	something	NN
18637	2249	25	like	like	IN
18637	2249	26	a	a	DT
18637	2249	27	doctrinal	doctrinal	JJ
18637	2249	28	system	system	NN
18637	2249	29	,	,	,
18637	2249	30	in	in	IN
18637	2249	31	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2249	32	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	2249	33	'	'	POS
18637	2249	34	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	2249	35	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2249	36	for	for	IN
18637	2249	37	the	the	DT
18637	2249	38	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2249	39	in	in	IN
18637	2249	40	the	the	DT
18637	2249	41	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	2249	42	Rate	Rate	NNP
18637	2249	43	Cases,[532	Cases,[532	NNP
18637	2249	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2249	45	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2249	46	in	in	IN
18637	2249	47	1913	1913	CD
18637	2249	48	.	.	.
18637	2250	1	"	"	``
18637	2250	2	Direct	direct	JJ
18637	2250	3	"	"	''
18637	2250	4	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2250	5	of	of	IN
18637	2250	6	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2250	7	or	or	CC
18637	2250	8	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2250	9	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2250	10	by	by	IN
18637	2250	11	a	a	DT
18637	2250	12	State	state	NN
18637	2250	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	2250	14	here	here	RB
18637	2250	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	2250	16	to	to	TO
18637	2250	17	be	be	VB
18637	2250	18	out	out	IN
18637	2250	19	of	of	IN
18637	2250	20	the	the	DT
18637	2250	21	question	question	NN
18637	2250	22	.	.	.
18637	2251	1	At	at	IN
18637	2251	2	the	the	DT
18637	2251	3	same	same	JJ
18637	2251	4	time	time	NN
18637	2251	5	,	,	,
18637	2251	6	the	the	DT
18637	2251	7	States	state	NNS
18637	2251	8	have	have	VBP
18637	2251	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2251	10	police	police	NNS
18637	2251	11	and	and	CC
18637	2251	12	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2251	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	2251	14	,	,	,
18637	2251	15	and	and	CC
18637	2251	16	may	may	MD
18637	2251	17	use	use	VB
18637	2251	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2251	19	as	as	IN
18637	2251	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2251	21	own	own	JJ
18637	2251	22	views	view	NNS
18637	2251	23	of	of	IN
18637	2251	24	sound	sound	JJ
18637	2251	25	public	public	JJ
18637	2251	26	policy	policy	NN
18637	2251	27	may	may	MD
18637	2251	28	dictate	dictate	VB
18637	2251	29	even	even	RB
18637	2251	30	though	though	IN
18637	2251	31	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2251	32	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2251	33	may	may	MD
18637	2251	34	be	be	VB
18637	2251	35	"	"	``
18637	2251	36	incidentally	incidentally	RB
18637	2251	37	"	"	''
18637	2251	38	or	or	CC
18637	2251	39	"	"	``
18637	2251	40	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	2251	41	"	"	''
18637	2251	42	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	2251	43	,	,	,
18637	2251	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2251	45	being	be	VBG
18637	2251	46	understood	understand	VBN
18637	2251	47	that	that	IN
18637	2251	48	such	such	JJ
18637	2251	49	"	"	``
18637	2251	50	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	2251	51	"	"	''
18637	2251	52	or	or	CC
18637	2251	53	"	"	``
18637	2251	54	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	2251	55	"	"	''
18637	2251	56	effects	effect	NNS
18637	2251	57	are	be	VBP
18637	2251	58	always	always	RB
18637	2251	59	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2251	60	to	to	IN
18637	2251	61	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2251	62	disallowance	disallowance	NN
18637	2251	63	.	.	.
18637	2252	1	"	"	``
18637	2252	2	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2252	3	system	system	NN
18637	2252	4	of	of	IN
18637	2252	5	government	government	NN
18637	2252	6	,	,	,
18637	2252	7	"	"	''
18637	2252	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2252	9	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	2252	10	reflects	reflect	VBZ
18637	2252	11	,	,	,
18637	2252	12	"	"	``
18637	2252	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	2252	14	a	a	DT
18637	2252	15	practical	practical	JJ
18637	2252	16	adjustment	adjustment	NN
18637	2252	17	by	by	IN
18637	2252	18	which	which	WDT
18637	2252	19	the	the	DT
18637	2252	20	National	National	NNP
18637	2252	21	authority	authority	NN
18637	2252	22	as	as	IN
18637	2252	23	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	2252	24	by	by	IN
18637	2252	25	the	the	DT
18637	2252	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2252	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	2252	28	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	2252	29	in	in	IN
18637	2252	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2252	31	fall	fall	NN
18637	2252	32	scope	scope	NN
18637	2252	33	without	without	IN
18637	2252	34	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	2252	35	loss	loss	NN
18637	2252	36	of	of	IN
18637	2252	37	local	local	JJ
18637	2252	38	efficiency	efficiency	NN
18637	2252	39	.	.	.
18637	2253	1	"	"	``
18637	2253	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2253	3	533	533	CD
18637	2253	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2253	5	In	in	IN
18637	2253	6	more	more	JJR
18637	2253	7	concrete	concrete	JJ
18637	2253	8	terms	term	NNS
18637	2253	9	,	,	,
18637	2253	10	the	the	DT
18637	2253	11	varied	varied	JJ
18637	2253	12	formulas	formula	NNS
18637	2253	13	which	which	WDT
18637	2253	14	characterize	characterize	VBP
18637	2253	15	this	this	DT
18637	2253	16	branch	branch	NN
18637	2253	17	of	of	IN
18637	2253	18	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2253	19	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	2253	20	Law	Law	NNP
18637	2253	21	have	have	VBP
18637	2253	22	been	be	VBN
18637	2253	23	devised	devise	VBN
18637	2253	24	by	by	IN
18637	2253	25	the	the	DT
18637	2253	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2253	27	from	from	IN
18637	2253	28	time	time	NN
18637	2253	29	to	to	IN
18637	2253	30	time	time	NN
18637	2253	31	in	in	IN
18637	2253	32	an	an	DT
18637	2253	33	endeavor	endeavor	NN
18637	2253	34	to	to	TO
18637	2253	35	effect	effect	VB
18637	2253	36	"	"	``
18637	2253	37	a	a	DT
18637	2253	38	practical	practical	JJ
18637	2253	39	adjustment	adjustment	NN
18637	2253	40	"	"	''
18637	2253	41	between	between	IN
18637	2253	42	two	two	CD
18637	2253	43	great	great	JJ
18637	2253	44	interests	interest	NNS
18637	2253	45	,	,	,
18637	2253	46	the	the	DT
18637	2253	47	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	2253	48	of	of	IN
18637	2253	49	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	2253	50	of	of	IN
18637	2253	51	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2253	52	except	except	IN
18637	2253	53	so	so	RB
18637	2253	54	far	far	RB
18637	2253	55	as	as	IN
18637	2253	56	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2253	57	may	may	MD
18637	2253	58	choose	choose	VB
18637	2253	59	to	to	TO
18637	2253	60	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	2253	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2253	62	,	,	,
18637	2253	63	and	and	CC
18637	2253	64	the	the	DT
18637	2253	65	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	2253	66	in	in	IN
18637	2253	67	the	the	DT
18637	2253	68	States	States	NNPS
18637	2253	69	of	of	IN
18637	2253	70	efficient	efficient	JJ
18637	2253	71	local	local	JJ
18637	2253	72	governments	government	NNS
18637	2253	73	.	.	.
18637	2254	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2254	2	,	,	,
18637	2254	3	while	while	IN
18637	2254	4	formulas	formula	NNS
18637	2254	5	may	may	MD
18637	2254	6	serve	serve	VB
18637	2254	7	to	to	IN
18637	2254	8	steady	steady	JJ
18637	2254	9	and	and	CC
18637	2254	10	guide	guide	VB
18637	2254	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2254	12	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	2254	13	,	,	,
18637	2254	14	the	the	DT
18637	2254	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2254	16	's	's	POS
18637	2254	17	real	real	JJ
18637	2254	18	function	function	NN
18637	2254	19	in	in	IN
18637	2254	20	this	this	DT
18637	2254	21	area	area	NN
18637	2254	22	of	of	IN
18637	2254	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	2254	24	review	review	NN
18637	2254	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	2254	26	essentially	essentially	RB
18637	2254	27	that	that	DT
18637	2254	28	of	of	IN
18637	2254	29	an	an	DT
18637	2254	30	arbitral	arbitral	JJ
18637	2254	31	or	or	CC
18637	2254	32	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	2254	33	-	-	JJ
18637	2254	34	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2254	35	body	body	NN
18637	2254	36	.	.	.
18637	2255	1	So	so	RB
18637	2255	2	much	much	RB
18637	2255	3	so	so	RB
18637	2255	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	2255	5	this	this	DT
18637	2255	6	the	the	DT
18637	2255	7	case	case	NN
18637	2255	8	that	that	IN
18637	2255	9	in	in	IN
18637	2255	10	1940	1940	CD
18637	2255	11	three	three	CD
18637	2255	12	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	2255	13	joined	join	VBD
18637	2255	14	in	in	IN
18637	2255	15	an	an	DT
18637	2255	16	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2255	17	in	in	IN
18637	2255	18	which	which	WDT
18637	2255	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2255	20	urged	urge	VBD
18637	2255	21	that	that	IN
18637	2255	22	the	the	DT
18637	2255	23	business	business	NN
18637	2255	24	of	of	IN
18637	2255	25	drawing	draw	VBG
18637	2255	26	the	the	DT
18637	2255	27	line	line	NN
18637	2255	28	between	between	IN
18637	2255	29	the	the	DT
18637	2255	30	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	2255	31	of	of	IN
18637	2255	32	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2255	33	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2255	34	and	and	CC
18637	2255	35	the	the	DT
18637	2255	36	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2255	37	power	power	NN
18637	2255	38	of	of	IN
18637	2255	39	the	the	DT
18637	2255	40	States	States	NNP
18637	2255	41	"	"	''
18637	2255	42	should	should	MD
18637	2255	43	be	be	VB
18637	2255	44	left	leave	VBN
18637	2255	45	to	to	IN
18637	2255	46	the	the	DT
18637	2255	47	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	2255	48	of	of	IN
18637	2255	49	the	the	DT
18637	2255	50	States	States	NNP
18637	2255	51	and	and	CC
18637	2255	52	the	the	DT
18637	2255	53	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2255	54	,	,	,
18637	2255	55	"	"	''
18637	2255	56	with	with	IN
18637	2255	57	the	the	DT
18637	2255	58	final	final	JJ
18637	2255	59	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	2255	60	in	in	IN
18637	2255	61	the	the	DT
18637	2255	62	hands	hand	NNS
18637	2255	63	of	of	IN
18637	2255	64	the	the	DT
18637	2255	65	latter	latter	JJ
18637	2255	66	.	.	.
18637	2256	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2256	2	534	534	CD
18637	2256	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2256	4	State	State	NNP
18637	2256	5	Taxing	Taxing	NNP
18637	2256	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	2256	7	and	and	CC
18637	2256	8	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	2256	9	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2256	10	BROWN	BROWN	NNP
18637	2256	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2256	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	2256	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2256	14	MARYLAND	MARYLAND	NNP
18637	2256	15	;	;	:
18637	2256	16	THE	the	DT
18637	2256	17	ORIGINAL	original	JJ
18637	2256	18	PACKAGE	package	NN
18637	2256	19	DOCTRINE	doctrine	NN
18637	2256	20	The	the	DT
18637	2256	21	leading	lead	VBG
18637	2256	22	case	case	NN
18637	2256	23	under	under	IN
18637	2256	24	this	this	DT
18637	2256	25	heading	heading	NN
18637	2256	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	2256	27	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	2256	28	_	_	NNP
18637	2256	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	2256	30	_	_	NNP
18637	2256	31	Maryland,[535	Maryland,[535	NNP
18637	2256	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2256	33	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2256	34	in	in	IN
18637	2256	35	1827	1827	CD
18637	2256	36	,	,	,
18637	2256	37	the	the	DT
18637	2256	38	issue	issue	NN
18637	2256	39	in	in	IN
18637	2256	40	which	which	WDT
18637	2256	41	was	be	VBD
18637	2256	42	the	the	DT
18637	2256	43	validity	validity	NN
18637	2256	44	of	of	IN
18637	2256	45	a	a	DT
18637	2256	46	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	2256	47	statute	statute	NN
18637	2256	48	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2256	49	"	"	``
18637	2256	50	all	all	DT
18637	2256	51	importers	importer	NNS
18637	2256	52	of	of	IN
18637	2256	53	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2256	54	articles	article	NNS
18637	2256	55	or	or	CC
18637	2256	56	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	2256	57	,	,	,
18637	2256	58	"	"	''
18637	2256	59	preparatory	preparatory	JJ
18637	2256	60	to	to	IN
18637	2256	61	selling	sell	VBG
18637	2256	62	the	the	DT
18637	2256	63	same	same	JJ
18637	2256	64	,	,	,
18637	2256	65	to	to	TO
18637	2256	66	take	take	VB
18637	2256	67	out	out	RP
18637	2256	68	a	a	DT
18637	2256	69	license	license	NN
18637	2256	70	.	.	.
18637	2257	1	Holding	hold	VBG
18637	2257	2	this	this	DT
18637	2257	3	act	act	NN
18637	2257	4	to	to	TO
18637	2257	5	be	be	VB
18637	2257	6	void	void	JJ
18637	2257	7	under	under	IN
18637	2257	8	both	both	DT
18637	2257	9	article	article	NN
18637	2257	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2257	11	,	,	,
18637	2257	12	sec	sec	NNP
18637	2257	13	.	.	.
18637	2258	1	10	10	CD
18637	2258	2	,	,	,
18637	2258	3	and	and	CC
18637	2258	4	the	the	DT
18637	2258	5	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2258	6	clause	clause	NNP
18637	2258	7	,	,	,
18637	2258	8	the	the	DT
18637	2258	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2258	10	,	,	,
18637	2258	11	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2258	12	through	through	IN
18637	2258	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2258	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2258	15	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2258	16	,	,	,
18637	2258	17	advanced	advance	VBD
18637	2258	18	the	the	DT
18637	2258	19	following	follow	VBG
18637	2258	20	propositions	proposition	NNS
18637	2258	21	:	:	:
18637	2258	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2258	23	1	1	LS
18637	2258	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2258	25	that	that	IN
18637	2258	26	"	"	``
18637	2258	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2258	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	2258	29	intercourse	intercourse	JJ
18637	2258	30	;	;	:
18637	2258	31	one	one	CD
18637	2258	32	of	of	IN
18637	2258	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2258	34	most	most	RBS
18637	2258	35	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	2258	36	ingredients	ingredient	NNS
18637	2258	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	2258	38	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2258	39	"	"	''
18637	2258	40	;	;	,
18637	2258	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2258	42	2	2	LS
18637	2258	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2258	44	that	that	IN
18637	2258	45	the	the	DT
18637	2258	46	right	right	NN
18637	2258	47	to	to	TO
18637	2258	48	import	import	VB
18637	2258	49	includes	include	VBZ
18637	2258	50	the	the	DT
18637	2258	51	right	right	NN
18637	2258	52	to	to	TO
18637	2258	53	sell	sell	VB
18637	2258	54	;	;	:
18637	2258	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2258	56	3	3	LS
18637	2258	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2258	58	that	that	IN
18637	2258	59	a	a	DT
18637	2258	60	tax	tax	NN
18637	2258	61	on	on	IN
18637	2258	62	the	the	DT
18637	2258	63	sale	sale	NN
18637	2258	64	of	of	IN
18637	2258	65	an	an	DT
18637	2258	66	article	article	NN
18637	2258	67	is	be	VBZ
18637	2258	68	a	a	DT
18637	2258	69	tax	tax	NN
18637	2258	70	on	on	IN
18637	2258	71	the	the	DT
18637	2258	72	article	article	NN
18637	2258	73	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2258	74	--	--	:
18637	2258	75	a	a	DT
18637	2258	76	conception	conception	NN
18637	2258	77	of	of	IN
18637	2258	78	the	the	DT
18637	2258	79	incidence	incidence	NN
18637	2258	80	of	of	IN
18637	2258	81	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2258	82	which	which	WDT
18637	2258	83	has	have	VBZ
18637	2258	84	at	at	IN
18637	2258	85	times	time	NNS
18637	2258	86	had	have	VBD
18637	2258	87	important	important	JJ
18637	2258	88	repercussions	repercussion	NNS
18637	2258	89	in	in	IN
18637	2258	90	other	other	JJ
18637	2258	91	fields	field	NNS
18637	2258	92	of	of	IN
18637	2258	93	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	2258	94	Law	Law	NNP
18637	2258	95	;	;	:
18637	2258	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2258	97	4	4	LS
18637	2258	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2258	99	that	that	IN
18637	2258	100	the	the	DT
18637	2258	101	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2258	102	power	power	NN
18637	2258	103	of	of	IN
18637	2258	104	the	the	DT
18637	2258	105	State	State	NNP
18637	2258	106	does	do	VBZ
18637	2258	107	not	not	RB
18637	2258	108	extend	extend	VB
18637	2258	109	in	in	IN
18637	2258	110	any	any	DT
18637	2258	111	form	form	NN
18637	2258	112	to	to	IN
18637	2258	113	imports	import	NNS
18637	2258	114	from	from	IN
18637	2258	115	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	2258	116	so	so	RB
18637	2258	117	long	long	RB
18637	2258	118	as	as	IN
18637	2258	119	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2258	120	remain	remain	VBP
18637	2258	121	"	"	``
18637	2258	122	the	the	DT
18637	2258	123	property	property	NN
18637	2258	124	of	of	IN
18637	2258	125	the	the	DT
18637	2258	126	importer	importer	NN
18637	2258	127	,	,	,
18637	2258	128	in	in	IN
18637	2258	129	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2258	130	warehouse	warehouse	NN
18637	2258	131	,	,	,
18637	2258	132	in	in	IN
18637	2258	133	the	the	DT
18637	2258	134	original	original	JJ
18637	2258	135	form	form	NN
18637	2258	136	or	or	CC
18637	2258	137	package	package	VB
18637	2258	138	"	"	''
18637	2258	139	in	in	IN
18637	2258	140	which	which	WDT
18637	2258	141	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2258	142	were	be	VBD
18637	2258	143	imported	import	VBN
18637	2258	144	--	--	:
18637	2258	145	the	the	DT
18637	2258	146	famous	famous	JJ
18637	2258	147	"	"	``
18637	2258	148	original	original	JJ
18637	2258	149	package	package	NN
18637	2258	150	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2258	151	"	"	''
18637	2258	152	;	;	,
18637	2258	153	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2258	154	5	5	LS
18637	2258	155	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2258	156	that	that	IN
18637	2258	157	once	once	RB
18637	2258	158	,	,	,
18637	2258	159	however	however	RB
18637	2258	160	,	,	,
18637	2258	161	the	the	DT
18637	2258	162	importer	importer	JJ
18637	2258	163	parts	part	NNS
18637	2258	164	with	with	IN
18637	2258	165	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2258	166	importations	importation	NNS
18637	2258	167	"	"	''
18637	2258	168	or	or	CC
18637	2258	169	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2258	170	mixes	mix	VBZ
18637	2258	171	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2258	172	with	with	IN
18637	2258	173	the	the	DT
18637	2258	174	general	general	JJ
18637	2258	175	property	property	NN
18637	2258	176	of	of	IN
18637	2258	177	the	the	DT
18637	2258	178	State	State	NNP
18637	2258	179	by	by	IN
18637	2258	180	breaking	break	VBG
18637	2258	181	up	up	RP
18637	2258	182	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2258	183	packages	package	NNS
18637	2258	184	,	,	,
18637	2258	185	"	"	''
18637	2258	186	the	the	DT
18637	2258	187	law	law	NN
18637	2258	188	may	may	MD
18637	2258	189	treat	treat	VB
18637	2258	190	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2258	191	as	as	IN
18637	2258	192	part	part	NN
18637	2258	193	and	and	CC
18637	2258	194	parcel	parcel	NN
18637	2258	195	of	of	IN
18637	2258	196	such	such	JJ
18637	2258	197	property	property	NN
18637	2258	198	;	;	:
18637	2258	199	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2258	200	6	6	LS
18637	2258	201	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2258	202	that	that	IN
18637	2258	203	even	even	RB
18637	2258	204	while	while	IN
18637	2258	205	in	in	IN
18637	2258	206	the	the	DT
18637	2258	207	original	original	JJ
18637	2258	208	package	package	NN
18637	2258	209	imports	import	NNS
18637	2258	210	are	be	VBP
18637	2258	211	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2258	212	to	to	IN
18637	2258	213	the	the	DT
18637	2258	214	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	2258	215	operation	operation	NN
18637	2258	216	of	of	IN
18637	2258	217	police	police	NN
18637	2258	218	measures	measure	NNS
18637	2258	219	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	2258	220	by	by	IN
18637	2258	221	the	the	DT
18637	2258	222	State	State	NNP
18637	2258	223	in	in	IN
18637	2258	224	good	good	JJ
18637	2258	225	faith	faith	NN
18637	2258	226	for	for	IN
18637	2258	227	the	the	DT
18637	2258	228	protection	protection	NN
18637	2258	229	of	of	IN
18637	2258	230	the	the	DT
18637	2258	231	public	public	NN
18637	2258	232	against	against	IN
18637	2258	233	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	2258	234	dangers	danger	NNS
18637	2258	235	.	.	.
18637	2259	1	Lastly	lastly	RB
18637	2259	2	,	,	,
18637	2259	3	in	in	IN
18637	2259	4	determining	determine	VBG
18637	2259	5	whether	whether	IN
18637	2259	6	a	a	DT
18637	2259	7	State	State	NNP
18637	2259	8	law	law	NN
18637	2259	9	amounts	amount	VBZ
18637	2259	10	to	to	IN
18637	2259	11	a	a	DT
18637	2259	12	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2259	13	of	of	IN
18637	2259	14	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2259	15	the	the	DT
18637	2259	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2259	17	would	would	MD
18637	2259	18	,	,	,
18637	2259	19	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2259	20	announced	announce	VBD
18637	2259	21	,	,	,
18637	2259	22	be	be	VB
18637	2259	23	guided	guide	VBN
18637	2259	24	by	by	IN
18637	2259	25	"	"	``
18637	2259	26	substance	substance	NN
18637	2259	27	"	"	''
18637	2259	28	and	and	CC
18637	2259	29	not	not	RB
18637	2259	30	by	by	IN
18637	2259	31	"	"	``
18637	2259	32	form"--a	form"--a	NNS
18637	2259	33	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	2259	34	which	which	WDT
18637	2259	35	has	have	VBZ
18637	2259	36	many	many	JJ
18637	2259	37	times	time	NNS
18637	2259	38	opened	open	VBD
18637	2259	39	the	the	DT
18637	2259	40	way	way	NN
18637	2259	41	to	to	IN
18637	2259	42	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	2259	43	inquiries	inquiry	NNS
18637	2259	44	by	by	IN
18637	2259	45	the	the	DT
18637	2259	46	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2259	47	into	into	IN
18637	2259	48	the	the	DT
18637	2259	49	actualities	actuality	NNS
18637	2259	50	both	both	DT
18637	2259	51	of	of	IN
18637	2259	52	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	2259	53	practice	practice	NN
18637	2259	54	and	and	CC
18637	2259	55	of	of	IN
18637	2259	56	State	State	NNP
18637	2259	57	administration	administration	NN
18637	2259	58	.	.	.
18637	2260	1	The	the	DT
18637	2260	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	2260	3	in	in	IN
18637	2260	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	2260	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2260	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	2260	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2260	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	2260	9	,	,	,
18637	2260	10	but	but	CC
18637	2260	11	more	more	RBR
18637	2260	12	especially	especially	RB
18637	2260	13	the	the	DT
18637	2260	14	"	"	``
18637	2260	15	original	original	JJ
18637	2260	16	package	package	NN
18637	2260	17	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2260	18	"	"	''
18637	2260	19	there	there	RB
18637	2260	20	laid	lay	VBD
18637	2260	21	down	down	RP
18637	2260	22	,	,	,
18637	2260	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	2260	24	been	be	VBN
18637	2260	25	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	2260	26	criticised	criticise	VBN
18637	2260	27	as	as	IN
18637	2260	28	going	go	VBG
18637	2260	29	too	too	RB
18637	2260	30	far	far	RB
18637	2260	31	.	.	.
18637	2261	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2261	2	would	would	MD
18637	2261	3	have	have	VB
18637	2261	4	been	be	VBN
18637	2261	5	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	2261	6	,	,	,
18637	2261	7	the	the	DT
18637	2261	8	critics	critic	NNS
18637	2261	9	contend	contend	VBP
18637	2261	10	,	,	,
18637	2261	11	for	for	IN
18637	2261	12	the	the	DT
18637	2261	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2261	14	to	to	TO
18637	2261	15	have	have	VB
18637	2261	16	held	hold	VBN
18637	2261	17	the	the	DT
18637	2261	18	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	2261	19	act	act	NN
18637	2261	20	void	void	NN
18637	2261	21	on	on	IN
18637	2261	22	account	account	NN
18637	2261	23	of	of	IN
18637	2261	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2261	25	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	2261	26	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	2261	27	character	character	NN
18637	2261	28	;	;	,
18637	2261	29	and	and	CC
18637	2261	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2261	31	urge	urge	VBP
18637	2261	32	that	that	IN
18637	2261	33	original	original	JJ
18637	2261	34	packages	package	NNS
18637	2261	35	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	2261	36	the	the	DT
18637	2261	37	protection	protection	NN
18637	2261	38	of	of	IN
18637	2261	39	the	the	DT
18637	2261	40	State	State	NNP
18637	2261	41	ought	ought	MD
18637	2261	42	to	to	TO
18637	2261	43	be	be	VB
18637	2261	44	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2261	45	to	to	IN
18637	2261	46	nondiscriminatory	nondiscriminatory	JJ
18637	2261	47	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2261	48	by	by	IN
18637	2261	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2261	50	.	.	.
18637	2262	1	The	the	DT
18637	2262	2	criticism	criticism	NN
18637	2262	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2262	4	partially	partially	RB
18637	2262	5	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
18637	2262	6	by	by	IN
18637	2262	7	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2262	8	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2262	9	in	in	IN
18637	2262	10	the	the	DT
18637	2262	11	apprehensions	apprehension	NNS
18637	2262	12	which	which	WDT
18637	2262	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2262	14	voiced	voice	VBD
18637	2262	15	that	that	IN
18637	2262	16	any	any	DT
18637	2262	17	concession	concession	NN
18637	2262	18	to	to	TO
18637	2262	19	"	"	``
18637	2262	20	the	the	DT
18637	2262	21	great	great	JJ
18637	2262	22	importing	import	VBG
18637	2262	23	States	States	NNP
18637	2262	24	"	"	''
18637	2262	25	might	may	MD
18637	2262	26	be	be	VB
18637	2262	27	turned	turn	VBN
18637	2262	28	by	by	IN
18637	2262	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2262	30	against	against	IN
18637	2262	31	the	the	DT
18637	2262	32	rest	rest	NN
18637	2262	33	of	of	IN
18637	2262	34	the	the	DT
18637	2262	35	country	country	NN
18637	2262	36	.	.	.
18637	2263	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	2263	2	,	,	,
18637	2263	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2263	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	2263	5	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
18637	2263	6	whether	whether	IN
18637	2263	7	the	the	DT
18637	2263	8	original	original	JJ
18637	2263	9	package	package	NN
18637	2263	10	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2263	11	will	will	MD
18637	2263	12	prove	prove	VB
18637	2263	13	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	2263	14	for	for	IN
18637	2263	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2263	16	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	2263	17	and	and	CC
18637	2263	18	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	2263	19	offers	offer	VBZ
18637	2263	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2263	21	not	not	RB
18637	2263	22	as	as	IN
18637	2263	23	a	a	DT
18637	2263	24	rule	rule	NN
18637	2263	25	"	"	``
18637	2263	26	universal	universal	JJ
18637	2263	27	in	in	IN
18637	2263	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2263	29	application	application	NN
18637	2263	30	,	,	,
18637	2263	31	"	"	''
18637	2263	32	but	but	CC
18637	2263	33	rather	rather	RB
18637	2263	34	as	as	IN
18637	2263	35	a	a	DT
18637	2263	36	stop	stop	NN
18637	2263	37	-	-	HYPH
18637	2263	38	gap	gap	NN
18637	2263	39	principle	principle	NN
18637	2263	40	.	.	.
18637	2264	1	History	history	NN
18637	2264	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	2264	3	proved	prove	VBN
18637	2264	4	,	,	,
18637	2264	5	however	however	RB
18637	2264	6	,	,	,
18637	2264	7	that	that	IN
18637	2264	8	in	in	IN
18637	2264	9	this	this	DT
18637	2264	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2264	11	builded	build	VBD
18637	2264	12	better	well	RBR
18637	2264	13	than	than	IN
18637	2264	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2264	15	knew	know	VBD
18637	2264	16	.	.	.
18637	2265	1	For	for	IN
18637	2265	2	in	in	IN
18637	2265	3	the	the	DT
18637	2265	4	field	field	NN
18637	2265	5	of	of	IN
18637	2265	6	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2265	7	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2265	8	the	the	DT
18637	2265	9	original	original	JJ
18637	2265	10	package	package	NN
18637	2265	11	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2265	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	2265	13	never	never	RB
18637	2265	14	been	be	VBN
18637	2265	15	disturbed	disturb	VBN
18637	2265	16	,	,	,
18637	2265	17	and	and	CC
18637	2265	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2265	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	2265	20	scarcely	scarcely	RB
18637	2265	21	been	be	VBN
18637	2265	22	added	add	VBN
18637	2265	23	to	to	IN
18637	2265	24	;	;	:
18637	2265	25	and	and	CC
18637	2265	26	so	so	RB
18637	2265	27	confined	confine	VBN
18637	2265	28	,	,	,
18637	2265	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2265	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	2265	31	never	never	RB
18637	2265	32	been	be	VBN
18637	2265	33	surpassed	surpass	VBN
18637	2265	34	by	by	IN
18637	2265	35	any	any	DT
18637	2265	36	later	later	JJ
18637	2265	37	piece	piece	NN
18637	2265	38	of	of	IN
18637	2265	39	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	2265	40	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2265	41	,	,	,
18637	2265	42	whether	whether	IN
18637	2265	43	in	in	IN
18637	2265	44	point	point	NN
18637	2265	45	of	of	IN
18637	2265	46	durability	durability	NN
18637	2265	47	or	or	CC
18637	2265	48	in	in	IN
18637	2265	49	that	that	DT
18637	2265	50	of	of	IN
18637	2265	51	definiteness	definiteness	NN
18637	2265	52	and	and	CC
18637	2265	53	easy	easy	JJ
18637	2265	54	comprehensibility	comprehensibility	NN
18637	2265	55	.	.	.
18637	2266	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2266	2	536	536	CD
18637	2266	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2266	4	State	State	NNP
18637	2266	5	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	2266	6	of	of	IN
18637	2266	7	the	the	DT
18637	2266	8	Subject	subject	JJ
18637	2266	9	Matter	Matter	NNP
18637	2266	10	of	of	IN
18637	2266	11	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2266	12	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2266	13	GENERAL	GENERAL	NNP
18637	2266	14	CONSIDERATIONS	considerations	VB
18637	2266	15	The	the	DT
18637	2266	16	task	task	NN
18637	2266	17	of	of	IN
18637	2266	18	drawing	draw	VBG
18637	2266	19	the	the	DT
18637	2266	20	line	line	NN
18637	2266	21	between	between	IN
18637	2266	22	State	State	NNP
18637	2266	23	power	power	NN
18637	2266	24	and	and	CC
18637	2266	25	the	the	DT
18637	2266	26	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	2266	27	interest	interest	NN
18637	2266	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	2266	29	proved	prove	VBN
18637	2266	30	a	a	DT
18637	2266	31	comparatively	comparatively	RB
18637	2266	32	simple	simple	JJ
18637	2266	33	one	one	NN
18637	2266	34	in	in	IN
18637	2266	35	the	the	DT
18637	2266	36	field	field	NN
18637	2266	37	of	of	IN
18637	2266	38	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2266	39	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2266	40	,	,	,
18637	2266	41	the	the	DT
18637	2266	42	two	two	CD
18637	2266	43	things	thing	NNS
18637	2266	44	being	be	VBG
18637	2266	45	in	in	IN
18637	2266	46	great	great	JJ
18637	2266	47	part	part	NN
18637	2266	48	territorially	territorially	RB
18637	2266	49	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	2266	50	.	.	.
18637	2267	1	With	with	IN
18637	2267	2	"	"	``
18637	2267	3	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2267	4	among	among	IN
18637	2267	5	the	the	DT
18637	2267	6	States	States	NNPS
18637	2267	7	"	"	``
18637	2267	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2267	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	2267	10	very	very	RB
18637	2267	11	different	different	JJ
18637	2267	12	.	.	.
18637	2268	1	This	this	DT
18637	2268	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2268	3	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	2268	4	in	in	IN
18637	2268	5	the	the	DT
18637	2268	6	interior	interior	NN
18637	2268	7	of	of	IN
18637	2268	8	the	the	DT
18637	2268	9	country	country	NN
18637	2268	10	,	,	,
18637	2268	11	by	by	IN
18637	2268	12	persons	person	NNS
18637	2268	13	and	and	CC
18637	2268	14	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2268	15	that	that	WDT
18637	2268	16	are	be	VBP
18637	2268	17	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	2268	18	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2268	19	also	also	RB
18637	2268	20	in	in	IN
18637	2268	21	local	local	JJ
18637	2268	22	business	business	NN
18637	2268	23	;	;	:
18637	2268	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2268	25	usual	usual	JJ
18637	2268	26	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	2268	27	are	be	VBP
18637	2268	28	acts	act	NNS
18637	2268	29	which	which	WDT
18637	2268	30	,	,	,
18637	2268	31	if	if	IN
18637	2268	32	unconnected	unconnected	JJ
18637	2268	33	with	with	IN
18637	2268	34	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2268	35	among	among	IN
18637	2268	36	the	the	DT
18637	2268	37	States	States	NNP
18637	2268	38	,	,	,
18637	2268	39	would	would	MD
18637	2268	40	fall	fall	VB
18637	2268	41	within	within	IN
18637	2268	42	the	the	DT
18637	2268	43	State	State	NNP
18637	2268	44	's	's	POS
18637	2268	45	powers	power	NNS
18637	2268	46	of	of	IN
18637	2268	47	police	police	NNS
18637	2268	48	and	and	CC
18637	2268	49	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2268	50	;	;	:
18637	2268	51	while	while	IN
18637	2268	52	the	the	DT
18637	2268	53	things	thing	NNS
18637	2268	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2268	55	deals	deal	VBZ
18637	2268	56	in	in	IN
18637	2268	57	and	and	CC
18637	2268	58	the	the	DT
18637	2268	59	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	2268	60	by	by	IN
18637	2268	61	which	which	WDT
18637	2268	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2268	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	2268	64	carried	carry	VBN
18637	2268	65	on	on	IN
18637	2268	66	comprise	comprise	NN
18637	2268	67	the	the	DT
18637	2268	68	most	most	RBS
18637	2268	69	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	2268	70	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2268	71	matter	matter	NN
18637	2268	72	of	of	IN
18637	2268	73	State	State	NNP
18637	2268	74	power	power	NN
18637	2268	75	.	.	.
18637	2269	1	In	in	IN
18637	2269	2	this	this	DT
18637	2269	3	field	field	NN
18637	2269	4	the	the	DT
18637	2269	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2269	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	2269	7	,	,	,
18637	2269	8	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	2269	9	,	,	,
18637	2269	10	been	be	VBN
18637	2269	11	unable	unable	JJ
18637	2269	12	to	to	TO
18637	2269	13	rely	rely	VB
18637	2269	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	2269	15	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	2269	16	solutions	solution	NNS
18637	2269	17	.	.	.
18637	2270	1	To	to	IN
18637	2270	2	the	the	DT
18637	2270	3	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	2270	4	,	,	,
18637	2270	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2270	6	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	2270	7	have	have	VBP
18637	2270	8	often	often	RB
18637	2270	9	been	be	VBN
18637	2270	10	fluctuating	fluctuate	VBG
18637	2270	11	and	and	CC
18637	2270	12	tentative	tentative	JJ
18637	2270	13	,	,	,
18637	2270	14	even	even	RB
18637	2270	15	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
18637	2270	16	;	;	:
18637	2270	17	and	and	CC
18637	2270	18	this	this	DT
18637	2270	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	2270	20	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	2270	21	the	the	DT
18637	2270	22	case	case	NN
18637	2270	23	as	as	IN
18637	2270	24	respects	respect	VBZ
18637	2270	25	the	the	DT
18637	2270	26	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	2270	27	of	of	IN
18637	2270	28	the	the	DT
18637	2270	29	State	State	NNP
18637	2270	30	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2270	31	power	power	NN
18637	2270	32	on	on	IN
18637	2270	33	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2270	34	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2270	35	.	.	.
18637	2271	1	In	in	IN
18637	2271	2	the	the	DT
18637	2271	3	words	word	NNS
18637	2271	4	of	of	IN
18637	2271	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2271	6	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	2271	7	:	:	:
18637	2271	8	"	"	``
18637	2271	9	The	the	DT
18637	2271	10	power	power	NN
18637	2271	11	of	of	IN
18637	2271	12	the	the	DT
18637	2271	13	States	States	NNPS
18637	2271	14	to	to	TO
18637	2271	15	tax	tax	VB
18637	2271	16	and	and	CC
18637	2271	17	the	the	DT
18637	2271	18	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	2271	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	2271	20	that	that	DT
18637	2271	21	power	power	NN
18637	2271	22	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2271	23	by	by	IN
18637	2271	24	the	the	DT
18637	2271	25	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2271	26	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	2271	27	have	have	VBP
18637	2271	28	necessitated	necessitate	VBN
18637	2271	29	a	a	DT
18637	2271	30	long	long	JJ
18637	2271	31	,	,	,
18637	2271	32	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	2271	33	process	process	NN
18637	2271	34	of	of	IN
18637	2271	35	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	2271	36	adjustment	adjustment	NN
18637	2271	37	.	.	.
18637	2272	1	The	the	DT
18637	2272	2	need	need	NN
18637	2272	3	for	for	IN
18637	2272	4	such	such	JJ
18637	2272	5	adjustment	adjustment	NN
18637	2272	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2272	7	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	2272	8	in	in	IN
18637	2272	9	a	a	DT
18637	2272	10	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2272	11	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2272	12	like	like	IN
18637	2272	13	ours	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2272	14	,	,	,
18637	2272	15	where	where	WRB
18637	2272	16	the	the	DT
18637	2272	17	same	same	JJ
18637	2272	18	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	2272	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	2272	20	aspects	aspect	NNS
18637	2272	21	that	that	WDT
18637	2272	22	may	may	MD
18637	2272	23	concern	concern	VB
18637	2272	24	the	the	DT
18637	2272	25	interests	interest	NNS
18637	2272	26	and	and	CC
18637	2272	27	involve	involve	VBP
18637	2272	28	the	the	DT
18637	2272	29	authority	authority	NN
18637	2272	30	of	of	IN
18637	2272	31	both	both	CC
18637	2272	32	the	the	DT
18637	2272	33	central	central	JJ
18637	2272	34	government	government	NN
18637	2272	35	and	and	CC
18637	2272	36	the	the	DT
18637	2272	37	constituent	constituent	NN
18637	2272	38	States	States	NNP
18637	2272	39	.	.	.
18637	2273	1	The	the	DT
18637	2273	2	history	history	NN
18637	2273	3	of	of	IN
18637	2273	4	this	this	DT
18637	2273	5	problem	problem	NN
18637	2273	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2273	7	spread	spread	VBN
18637	2273	8	over	over	IN
18637	2273	9	hundreds	hundred	NNS
18637	2273	10	of	of	IN
18637	2273	11	volumes	volume	NNS
18637	2273	12	of	of	IN
18637	2273	13	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2273	14	Reports	report	NNS
18637	2273	15	.	.	.
18637	2274	1	To	to	TO
18637	2274	2	attempt	attempt	VB
18637	2274	3	to	to	TO
18637	2274	4	harmonize	harmonize	VB
18637	2274	5	all	all	DT
18637	2274	6	that	that	WDT
18637	2274	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	2274	8	been	be	VBN
18637	2274	9	said	say	VBN
18637	2274	10	in	in	IN
18637	2274	11	the	the	DT
18637	2274	12	past	past	NN
18637	2274	13	would	would	MD
18637	2274	14	neither	neither	CC
18637	2274	15	clarify	clarify	VB
18637	2274	16	what	what	WP
18637	2274	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	2274	18	gone	go	VBN
18637	2274	19	before	before	RB
18637	2274	20	nor	nor	CC
18637	2274	21	guide	guide	VB
18637	2274	22	the	the	DT
18637	2274	23	future	future	NN
18637	2274	24	.	.	.
18637	2275	1	Suffice	suffice	VB
18637	2275	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2275	3	to	to	TO
18637	2275	4	say	say	VB
18637	2275	5	that	that	IN
18637	2275	6	especially	especially	RB
18637	2275	7	in	in	IN
18637	2275	8	this	this	DT
18637	2275	9	field	field	NN
18637	2275	10	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	2275	11	must	must	MD
18637	2275	12	be	be	VB
18637	2275	13	read	read	VBN
18637	2275	14	in	in	IN
18637	2275	15	the	the	DT
18637	2275	16	setting	setting	NN
18637	2275	17	of	of	IN
18637	2275	18	the	the	DT
18637	2275	19	particular	particular	JJ
18637	2275	20	cases	case	NNS
18637	2275	21	and	and	CC
18637	2275	22	as	as	IN
18637	2275	23	the	the	DT
18637	2275	24	product	product	NN
18637	2275	25	of	of	IN
18637	2275	26	preoccupation	preoccupation	NN
18637	2275	27	with	with	IN
18637	2275	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2275	29	special	special	JJ
18637	2275	30	facts	fact	NNS
18637	2275	31	.	.	.
18637	2276	1	"	"	``
18637	2276	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2276	3	537	537	CD
18637	2276	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2276	5	THE	the	DT
18637	2276	6	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2276	7	FREIGHT	FREIGHT	NNP
18637	2276	8	TAX	tax	NN
18637	2276	9	CASE	case	NN
18637	2276	10	The	the	DT
18637	2276	11	great	great	JJ
18637	2276	12	leading	leading	JJ
18637	2276	13	case	case	NN
18637	2276	14	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	2276	15	with	with	IN
18637	2276	16	the	the	DT
18637	2276	17	relation	relation	NN
18637	2276	18	of	of	IN
18637	2276	19	the	the	DT
18637	2276	20	State	State	NNP
18637	2276	21	's	's	POS
18637	2276	22	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2276	23	power	power	NN
18637	2276	24	to	to	TO
18637	2276	25	interstate	interstate	VB
18637	2276	26	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2276	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	2276	28	that	that	DT
18637	2276	29	of	of	IN
18637	2276	30	the	the	DT
18637	2276	31	State	State	NNP
18637	2276	32	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	2276	33	Tax,[538	Tax,[538	NNP
18637	2276	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2276	35	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2276	36	in	in	IN
18637	2276	37	1873	1873	CD
18637	2276	38	.	.	.
18637	2277	1	The	the	DT
18637	2277	2	question	question	NN
18637	2277	3	before	before	IN
18637	2277	4	the	the	DT
18637	2277	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2277	6	was	be	VBD
18637	2277	7	the	the	DT
18637	2277	8	validity	validity	NN
18637	2277	9	of	of	IN
18637	2277	10	a	a	DT
18637	2277	11	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2277	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	2277	13	,	,	,
18637	2277	14	passed	pass	VBD
18637	2277	15	eight	eight	CD
18637	2277	16	years	year	NNS
18637	2277	17	earlier	early	RBR
18637	2277	18	,	,	,
18637	2277	19	which	which	WDT
18637	2277	20	required	require	VBD
18637	2277	21	every	every	DT
18637	2277	22	company	company	NN
18637	2277	23	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	2277	24	freight	freight	NN
18637	2277	25	within	within	IN
18637	2277	26	the	the	DT
18637	2277	27	State	State	NNP
18637	2277	28	,	,	,
18637	2277	29	with	with	IN
18637	2277	30	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2277	31	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	2277	32	,	,	,
18637	2277	33	to	to	TO
18637	2277	34	pay	pay	VB
18637	2277	35	a	a	DT
18637	2277	36	tax	tax	NN
18637	2277	37	at	at	IN
18637	2277	38	specified	specified	JJ
18637	2277	39	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2277	40	on	on	IN
18637	2277	41	each	each	DT
18637	2277	42	ton	ton	NN
18637	2277	43	of	of	IN
18637	2277	44	freight	freight	NN
18637	2277	45	carried	carry	VBN
18637	2277	46	by	by	IN
18637	2277	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2277	48	.	.	.
18637	2278	1	Overturning	overturn	VBG
18637	2278	2	the	the	DT
18637	2278	3	act	act	NN
18637	2278	4	,	,	,
18637	2278	5	the	the	DT
18637	2278	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2278	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	2278	8	:	:	:
18637	2278	9	"	"	``
18637	2278	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2278	11	1	1	LS
18637	2278	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2278	13	The	the	DT
18637	2278	14	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2278	15	of	of	IN
18637	2278	16	freight	freight	NN
18637	2278	17	,	,	,
18637	2278	18	or	or	CC
18637	2278	19	of	of	IN
18637	2278	20	the	the	DT
18637	2278	21	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	2278	22	of	of	IN
18637	2278	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2278	24	,	,	,
18637	2278	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	2278	26	a	a	DT
18637	2278	27	constituent	constituent	JJ
18637	2278	28	part	part	NN
18637	2278	29	of	of	IN
18637	2278	30	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2278	31	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2278	32	;	;	:
18637	2278	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2278	34	2	2	LS
18637	2278	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2278	36	a	a	DT
18637	2278	37	tax	tax	NN
18637	2278	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	2278	39	freight	freight	NN
18637	2278	40	,	,	,
18637	2278	41	transported	transport	VBN
18637	2278	42	from	from	IN
18637	2278	43	State	State	NNP
18637	2278	44	to	to	IN
18637	2278	45	State	State	NNP
18637	2278	46	,	,	,
18637	2278	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	2278	48	a	a	DT
18637	2278	49	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2278	50	of	of	IN
18637	2278	51	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2278	52	among	among	IN
18637	2278	53	the	the	DT
18637	2278	54	States	States	NNPS
18637	2278	55	;	;	:
18637	2278	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2278	57	3	3	LS
18637	2278	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2278	59	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	2278	60	the	the	DT
18637	2278	61	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	2278	62	in	in	IN
18637	2278	63	regard	regard	NN
18637	2278	64	to	to	TO
18637	2278	65	which	which	WDT
18637	2278	66	a	a	DT
18637	2278	67	power	power	NN
18637	2278	68	to	to	TO
18637	2278	69	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2278	70	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2278	71	is	be	VBZ
18637	2278	72	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	2278	73	are	be	VBP
18637	2278	74	in	in	IN
18637	2278	75	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2278	76	nature	nature	NN
18637	2278	77	National	National	NNP
18637	2278	78	,	,	,
18637	2278	79	or	or	CC
18637	2278	80	admit	admit	NN
18637	2278	81	of	of	IN
18637	2278	82	one	one	CD
18637	2278	83	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2278	84	system	system	NN
18637	2278	85	or	or	CC
18637	2278	86	plan	plan	NN
18637	2278	87	of	of	IN
18637	2278	88	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2278	89	,	,	,
18637	2278	90	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2278	91	are	be	VBP
18637	2278	92	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	2278	93	within	within	IN
18637	2278	94	the	the	DT
18637	2278	95	regulating	regulating	NN
18637	2278	96	control	control	NN
18637	2278	97	of	of	IN
18637	2278	98	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2278	99	;	;	:
18637	2278	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2278	101	4	4	LS
18637	2278	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2278	103	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2278	104	of	of	IN
18637	2278	105	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	2278	106	or	or	CC
18637	2278	107	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	2278	108	through	through	IN
18637	2278	109	a	a	DT
18637	2278	110	State	state	NN
18637	2278	111	,	,	,
18637	2278	112	or	or	CC
18637	2278	113	from	from	IN
18637	2278	114	one	one	CD
18637	2278	115	State	state	NN
18637	2278	116	to	to	IN
18637	2278	117	another	another	DT
18637	2278	118	,	,	,
18637	2278	119	is	be	VBZ
18637	2278	120	of	of	IN
18637	2278	121	this	this	DT
18637	2278	122	nature	nature	NN
18637	2278	123	;	;	:
18637	2278	124	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2278	125	5	5	LS
18637	2278	126	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2278	127	hence	hence	RB
18637	2278	128	a	a	DT
18637	2278	129	statute	statute	NN
18637	2278	130	of	of	IN
18637	2278	131	a	a	DT
18637	2278	132	State	state	NN
18637	2278	133	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	2278	134	a	a	DT
18637	2278	135	tax	tax	NN
18637	2278	136	upon	upon	IN
18637	2278	137	freight	freight	NN
18637	2278	138	,	,	,
18637	2278	139	taken	take	VBN
18637	2278	140	up	up	RP
18637	2278	141	within	within	IN
18637	2278	142	the	the	DT
18637	2278	143	State	State	NNP
18637	2278	144	and	and	CC
18637	2278	145	carried	carry	VBD
18637	2278	146	out	out	IN
18637	2278	147	of	of	IN
18637	2278	148	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2278	149	,	,	,
18637	2278	150	or	or	CC
18637	2278	151	taken	take	VBN
18637	2278	152	up	up	RP
18637	2278	153	without	without	IN
18637	2278	154	the	the	DT
18637	2278	155	State	State	NNP
18637	2278	156	and	and	CC
18637	2278	157	brought	bring	VBD
18637	2278	158	within	within	IN
18637	2278	159	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2278	160	,	,	,
18637	2278	161	is	be	VBZ
18637	2278	162	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	2278	163	to	to	IN
18637	2278	164	that	that	DT
18637	2278	165	provision	provision	NN
18637	2278	166	of	of	IN
18637	2278	167	the	the	DT
18637	2278	168	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2278	169	of	of	IN
18637	2278	170	the	the	DT
18637	2278	171	United	United	NNP
18637	2278	172	States	States	NNP
18637	2278	173	,	,	,
18637	2278	174	which	which	WDT
18637	2278	175	ordains	ordain	VBZ
18637	2278	176	that	that	IN
18637	2278	177	'	'	``
18637	2278	178	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2278	179	shall	shall	MD
18637	2278	180	have	have	VB
18637	2278	181	power	power	NN
18637	2278	182	to	to	TO
18637	2278	183	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2278	184	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2278	185	with	with	IN
18637	2278	186	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2278	187	nations	nation	NNS
18637	2278	188	and	and	CC
18637	2278	189	among	among	IN
18637	2278	190	the	the	DT
18637	2278	191	several	several	JJ
18637	2278	192	States	States	NNPS
18637	2278	193	,	,	,
18637	2278	194	and	and	CC
18637	2278	195	with	with	IN
18637	2278	196	the	the	DT
18637	2278	197	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	2278	198	tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	2278	199	.	.	.
18637	2279	1	'	'	``
18637	2279	2	"	"	``
18637	2279	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2279	4	539	539	CD
18637	2279	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2279	6	GOODS	goods	NN
18637	2279	7	IN	in	IN
18637	2279	8	TRANSIT	TRANSIT	NNP
18637	2279	9	States	States	NNPS
18637	2279	10	,	,	,
18637	2279	11	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	2279	12	,	,	,
18637	2279	13	may	may	MD
18637	2279	14	not	not	RB
18637	2279	15	tax	tax	VB
18637	2279	16	property	property	NN
18637	2279	17	in	in	IN
18637	2279	18	transit	transit	NN
18637	2279	19	in	in	IN
18637	2279	20	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2279	21	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2279	22	.	.	.
18637	2280	1	A	a	DT
18637	2280	2	nondiscriminatory	nondiscriminatory	JJ
18637	2280	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	2280	4	,	,	,
18637	2280	5	however	however	RB
18637	2280	6	,	,	,
18637	2280	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	2280	8	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	2280	9	if	if	IN
18637	2280	10	the	the	DT
18637	2280	11	goods	good	NNS
18637	2280	12	have	have	VBP
18637	2280	13	not	not	RB
18637	2280	14	yet	yet	RB
18637	2280	15	started	start	VBN
18637	2280	16	in	in	IN
18637	2280	17	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2280	18	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2280	19	,	,	,
18637	2280	20	or	or	CC
18637	2280	21	have	have	VBP
18637	2280	22	completed	complete	VBN
18637	2280	23	the	the	DT
18637	2280	24	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2280	25	transit	transit	NN
18637	2280	26	even	even	RB
18637	2280	27	though	though	IN
18637	2280	28	still	still	RB
18637	2280	29	in	in	IN
18637	2280	30	the	the	DT
18637	2280	31	original	original	JJ
18637	2280	32	package	package	NN
18637	2280	33	,	,	,
18637	2280	34	unless	unless	IN
18637	2280	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2280	36	are	be	VBP
18637	2280	37	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2280	38	imports	import	NNS
18637	2280	39	in	in	IN
18637	2280	40	the	the	DT
18637	2280	41	original	original	JJ
18637	2280	42	package	package	NN
18637	2280	43	;	;	:
18637	2280	44	and	and	CC
18637	2280	45	States	States	NNP
18637	2280	46	may	may	MD
18637	2280	47	also	also	RB
18637	2280	48	impose	impose	VB
18637	2280	49	a	a	DT
18637	2280	50	nondiscriminatory	nondiscriminatory	JJ
18637	2280	51	tax	tax	NN
18637	2280	52	when	when	WRB
18637	2280	53	there	there	EX
18637	2280	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	2280	55	a	a	DT
18637	2280	56	break	break	NN
18637	2280	57	in	in	IN
18637	2280	58	an	an	DT
18637	2280	59	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2280	60	transit	transit	NN
18637	2280	61	,	,	,
18637	2280	62	and	and	CC
18637	2280	63	the	the	DT
18637	2280	64	goods	good	NNS
18637	2280	65	have	have	VBP
18637	2280	66	not	not	RB
18637	2280	67	been	be	VBN
18637	2280	68	restored	restore	VBN
18637	2280	69	to	to	IN
18637	2280	70	the	the	DT
18637	2280	71	current	current	NN
18637	2280	72	of	of	IN
18637	2280	73	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2280	74	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2280	75	.	.	.
18637	2281	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	2281	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2281	3	the	the	DT
18637	2281	4	law	law	NN
18637	2281	5	in	in	IN
18637	2281	6	brief	brief	NN
18637	2281	7	.	.	.
18637	2282	1	Two	two	CD
18637	2282	2	questions	question	NNS
18637	2282	3	arise	arise	VBP
18637	2282	4	,	,	,
18637	2282	5	first	first	RB
18637	2282	6	,	,	,
18637	2282	7	when	when	WRB
18637	2282	8	do	do	VB
18637	2282	9	goods	good	NNS
18637	2282	10	originating	originate	VBG
18637	2282	11	in	in	IN
18637	2282	12	a	a	DT
18637	2282	13	State	state	NN
18637	2282	14	pass	pass	NN
18637	2282	15	from	from	IN
18637	2282	16	under	under	IN
18637	2282	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2282	18	power	power	NN
18637	2282	19	to	to	IN
18637	2282	20	tax	tax	NN
18637	2282	21	;	;	:
18637	2282	22	and	and	CC
18637	2282	23	,	,	,
18637	2282	24	second	second	RB
18637	2282	25	,	,	,
18637	2282	26	when	when	WRB
18637	2282	27	do	do	VBP
18637	2282	28	goods	good	NNS
18637	2282	29	arriving	arrive	VBG
18637	2282	30	from	from	IN
18637	2282	31	another	another	DT
18637	2282	32	State	state	NN
18637	2282	33	lose	lose	VB
18637	2282	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2282	35	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	2282	36	?	?	.
18637	2283	1	The	the	DT
18637	2283	2	leading	leading	JJ
18637	2283	3	case	case	NN
18637	2283	4	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	2283	5	with	with	IN
18637	2283	6	the	the	DT
18637	2283	7	first	first	JJ
18637	2283	8	of	of	IN
18637	2283	9	these	these	DT
18637	2283	10	questions	question	NNS
18637	2283	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	2283	12	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	2283	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2283	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	2283	15	_	_	NNP
18637	2283	16	Errol,[540	Errol,[540	NNP
18637	2283	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2283	18	in	in	IN
18637	2283	19	which	which	WDT
18637	2283	20	the	the	DT
18637	2283	21	matter	matter	NN
18637	2283	22	at	at	IN
18637	2283	23	issue	issue	NN
18637	2283	24	was	be	VBD
18637	2283	25	the	the	DT
18637	2283	26	right	right	NN
18637	2283	27	of	of	IN
18637	2283	28	the	the	DT
18637	2283	29	town	town	NN
18637	2283	30	of	of	IN
18637	2283	31	Errol	Errol	NNP
18637	2283	32	,	,	,
18637	2283	33	New	New	NNP
18637	2283	34	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	2283	35	,	,	,
18637	2283	36	to	to	TO
18637	2283	37	tax	tax	VB
18637	2283	38	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2283	39	logs	log	NNS
18637	2283	40	on	on	IN
18637	2283	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2283	42	way	way	NN
18637	2283	43	to	to	IN
18637	2283	44	points	point	NNS
18637	2283	45	in	in	IN
18637	2283	46	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	2283	47	,	,	,
18637	2283	48	while	while	IN
18637	2283	49	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2283	50	lay	lie	VBD
18637	2283	51	in	in	IN
18637	2283	52	the	the	DT
18637	2283	53	river	river	NN
18637	2283	54	before	before	IN
18637	2283	55	the	the	DT
18637	2283	56	town	town	NN
18637	2283	57	or	or	CC
18637	2283	58	along	along	IN
18637	2283	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2283	60	shore	shore	NN
18637	2283	61	awaiting	await	VBG
18637	2283	62	the	the	DT
18637	2283	63	spring	spring	NN
18637	2283	64	freshets	freshet	NNS
18637	2283	65	and	and	CC
18637	2283	66	consequent	consequent	JJ
18637	2283	67	rise	rise	NN
18637	2283	68	of	of	IN
18637	2283	69	the	the	DT
18637	2283	70	river	river	NN
18637	2283	71	.	.	.
18637	2284	1	As	as	IN
18637	2284	2	to	to	IN
18637	2284	3	the	the	DT
18637	2284	4	logs	log	NNS
18637	2284	5	in	in	IN
18637	2284	6	the	the	DT
18637	2284	7	river	river	NN
18637	2284	8	,	,	,
18637	2284	9	which	which	WDT
18637	2284	10	had	have	VBD
18637	2284	11	come	come	VBN
18637	2284	12	from	from	IN
18637	2284	13	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	2284	14	on	on	IN
18637	2284	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2284	16	way	way	NN
18637	2284	17	to	to	IN
18637	2284	18	Lewiston	Lewiston	NNP
18637	2284	19	in	in	IN
18637	2284	20	the	the	DT
18637	2284	21	same	same	JJ
18637	2284	22	State	state	NN
18637	2284	23	,	,	,
18637	2284	24	but	but	CC
18637	2284	25	had	have	VBD
18637	2284	26	been	be	VBN
18637	2284	27	detained	detain	VBN
18637	2284	28	at	at	IN
18637	2284	29	Errol	Errol	NNP
18637	2284	30	by	by	IN
18637	2284	31	low	low	JJ
18637	2284	32	water	water	NN
18637	2284	33	,	,	,
18637	2284	34	the	the	DT
18637	2284	35	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2284	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2284	37	of	of	IN
18637	2284	38	New	New	NNP
18637	2284	39	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	2284	40	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2284	41	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	2284	42	that	that	IN
18637	2284	43	the	the	DT
18637	2284	44	local	local	JJ
18637	2284	45	tax	tax	NN
18637	2284	46	did	do	VBD
18637	2284	47	not	not	RB
18637	2284	48	apply	apply	VB
18637	2284	49	,	,	,
18637	2284	50	the	the	DT
18637	2284	51	logs	log	NNS
18637	2284	52	being	be	VBG
18637	2284	53	still	still	RB
18637	2284	54	in	in	IN
18637	2284	55	transit	transit	NN
18637	2284	56	.	.	.
18637	2285	1	As	as	IN
18637	2285	2	to	to	IN
18637	2285	3	the	the	DT
18637	2285	4	logs	log	NNS
18637	2285	5	which	which	WDT
18637	2285	6	had	have	VBD
18637	2285	7	been	be	VBN
18637	2285	8	cut	cut	VBN
18637	2285	9	in	in	IN
18637	2285	10	New	New	NNP
18637	2285	11	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	2285	12	and	and	CC
18637	2285	13	lay	lie	VBD
18637	2285	14	on	on	IN
18637	2285	15	the	the	DT
18637	2285	16	shore	shore	NN
18637	2285	17	or	or	CC
18637	2285	18	in	in	IN
18637	2285	19	tributaries	tributary	NNS
18637	2285	20	of	of	IN
18637	2285	21	the	the	DT
18637	2285	22	river	river	NN
18637	2285	23	,	,	,
18637	2285	24	both	both	DT
18637	2285	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	2285	26	were	be	VBD
18637	2285	27	again	again	RB
18637	2285	28	in	in	IN
18637	2285	29	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	2285	30	that	that	WDT
18637	2285	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2285	32	were	be	VBD
18637	2285	33	still	still	RB
18637	2285	34	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2285	35	to	to	IN
18637	2285	36	local	local	JJ
18637	2285	37	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2285	38	,	,	,
18637	2285	39	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	2285	40	the	the	DT
18637	2285	41	intention	intention	NN
18637	2285	42	of	of	IN
18637	2285	43	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2285	44	owners	owner	NNS
18637	2285	45	to	to	TO
18637	2285	46	send	send	VB
18637	2285	47	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2285	48	out	out	IN
18637	2285	49	of	of	IN
18637	2285	50	the	the	DT
18637	2285	51	State	State	NNP
18637	2285	52	.	.	.
18637	2286	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	2286	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2286	3	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	2286	4	:	:	:
18637	2286	5	"	"	``
18637	2286	6	*	*	NFP
18637	2286	7	*	*	NFP
18637	2286	8	*	*	NFP
18637	2286	9	goods	good	NNS
18637	2286	10	do	do	VBP
18637	2286	11	not	not	RB
18637	2286	12	cease	cease	VB
18637	2286	13	to	to	TO
18637	2286	14	be	be	VB
18637	2286	15	part	part	NN
18637	2286	16	of	of	IN
18637	2286	17	the	the	DT
18637	2286	18	general	general	JJ
18637	2286	19	mass	mass	NN
18637	2286	20	of	of	IN
18637	2286	21	property	property	NN
18637	2286	22	in	in	IN
18637	2286	23	the	the	DT
18637	2286	24	State	State	NNP
18637	2286	25	,	,	,
18637	2286	26	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2286	27	,	,	,
18637	2286	28	as	as	IN
18637	2286	29	such	such	JJ
18637	2286	30	,	,	,
18637	2286	31	to	to	IN
18637	2286	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2286	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2286	34	,	,	,
18637	2286	35	and	and	CC
18637	2286	36	to	to	IN
18637	2286	37	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2286	38	in	in	IN
18637	2286	39	the	the	DT
18637	2286	40	usual	usual	JJ
18637	2286	41	way	way	NN
18637	2286	42	,	,	,
18637	2286	43	until	until	IN
18637	2286	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2286	45	have	have	VBP
18637	2286	46	been	be	VBN
18637	2286	47	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	2286	48	,	,	,
18637	2286	49	or	or	CC
18637	2286	50	entered	enter	VBN
18637	2286	51	with	with	IN
18637	2286	52	a	a	DT
18637	2286	53	common	common	JJ
18637	2286	54	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2286	55	for	for	IN
18637	2286	56	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2286	57	to	to	IN
18637	2286	58	another	another	DT
18637	2286	59	State	state	NN
18637	2286	60	,	,	,
18637	2286	61	or	or	CC
18637	2286	62	have	have	VBP
18637	2286	63	been	be	VBN
18637	2286	64	started	start	VBN
18637	2286	65	upon	upon	IN
18637	2286	66	such	such	JJ
18637	2286	67	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2286	68	in	in	IN
18637	2286	69	a	a	DT
18637	2286	70	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	2286	71	route	route	NN
18637	2286	72	or	or	CC
18637	2286	73	journey	journey	NN
18637	2286	74	.	.	.
18637	2287	1	"	"	``
18637	2287	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2287	3	541	541	CD
18637	2287	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2287	5	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2287	6	TAXATION	TAXATION	NNP
18637	2287	7	OF	of	IN
18637	2287	8	MANUFACTURING	manufacturing	NN
18637	2287	9	AND	and	CC
18637	2287	10	MINING	MINING	NNP
18637	2287	11	Under	under	IN
18637	2287	12	the	the	DT
18637	2287	13	above	above	JJ
18637	2287	14	rule	rule	NN
18637	2287	15	,	,	,
18637	2287	16	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	2287	17	,	,	,
18637	2287	18	production	production	NN
18637	2287	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	2287	20	not	not	RB
18637	2287	21	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2287	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2287	23	even	even	RB
18637	2287	24	though	though	IN
18637	2287	25	the	the	DT
18637	2287	26	thing	thing	NN
18637	2287	27	produced	produce	VBN
18637	2287	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	2287	29	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2287	30	for	for	IN
18637	2287	31	the	the	DT
18637	2287	32	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2287	33	market	market	NN
18637	2287	34	.	.	.
18637	2288	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2288	2	a	a	DT
18637	2288	3	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2288	4	_	_	NNP
18637	2288	5	ad	ad	NN
18637	2288	6	valorem	valorem	NN
18637	2288	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2288	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	2288	9	on	on	IN
18637	2288	10	anthracite	anthracite	NN
18637	2288	11	coal	coal	NN
18637	2288	12	when	when	WRB
18637	2288	13	prepared	prepared	JJ
18637	2288	14	and	and	CC
18637	2288	15	ready	ready	JJ
18637	2288	16	for	for	IN
18637	2288	17	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2288	18	was	be	VBD
18637	2288	19	held	hold	VBN
18637	2288	20	not	not	RB
18637	2288	21	to	to	TO
18637	2288	22	be	be	VB
18637	2288	23	an	an	DT
18637	2288	24	interference	interference	NN
18637	2288	25	with	with	IN
18637	2288	26	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2288	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2288	28	although	although	IN
18637	2288	29	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2288	30	to	to	IN
18637	2288	31	coal	coal	NN
18637	2288	32	destined	destine	VBN
18637	2288	33	for	for	IN
18637	2288	34	a	a	DT
18637	2288	35	market	market	NN
18637	2288	36	in	in	IN
18637	2288	37	other	other	JJ
18637	2288	38	States;[542	states;[542	NN
18637	2288	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2288	40	and	and	CC
18637	2288	41	in	in	IN
18637	2288	42	Oliver	Oliver	NNP
18637	2288	43	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	2288	44	Company	Company	NNP
18637	2288	45	_	_	NNP
18637	2288	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	2288	47	_	_	NNP
18637	2288	48	Lord[543	Lord[543	NNP
18637	2288	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2288	50	an	an	DT
18637	2288	51	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	2288	52	tax	tax	NN
18637	2288	53	on	on	IN
18637	2288	54	the	the	DT
18637	2288	55	mining	mining	NN
18637	2288	56	of	of	IN
18637	2288	57	iron	iron	NNP
18637	2288	58	ore	ore	NNP
18637	2288	59	was	be	VBD
18637	2288	60	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	2288	61	,	,	,
18637	2288	62	although	although	IN
18637	2288	63	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	2288	64	all	all	DT
18637	2288	65	of	of	IN
18637	2288	66	the	the	DT
18637	2288	67	ore	ore	NN
18637	2288	68	was	be	VBD
18637	2288	69	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	2288	70	and	and	CC
18637	2288	71	continuously	continuously	RB
18637	2288	72	loaded	load	VBN
18637	2288	73	on	on	IN
18637	2288	74	cars	car	NNS
18637	2288	75	and	and	CC
18637	2288	76	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	2288	77	into	into	IN
18637	2288	78	other	other	JJ
18637	2288	79	States	state	NNS
18637	2288	80	.	.	.
18637	2289	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	2289	2	the	the	DT
18637	2289	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2289	4	:	:	:
18637	2289	5	"	"	``
18637	2289	6	Mining	mining	NN
18637	2289	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	2289	8	not	not	RB
18637	2289	9	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2289	10	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2289	11	,	,	,
18637	2289	12	but	but	CC
18637	2289	13	,	,	,
18637	2289	14	*	*	NFP
18637	2289	15	*	*	NFP
18637	2289	16	*	*	NFP
18637	2289	17	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2289	18	to	to	IN
18637	2289	19	local	local	JJ
18637	2289	20	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2289	21	and	and	CC
18637	2289	22	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2289	23	.	.	.
18637	2290	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2290	2	character	character	NN
18637	2290	3	in	in	IN
18637	2290	4	this	this	DT
18637	2290	5	regard	regard	NN
18637	2290	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2290	7	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
18637	2290	8	,	,	,
18637	2290	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	2290	10	not	not	RB
18637	2290	11	affected	affect	VBN
18637	2290	12	by	by	IN
18637	2290	13	the	the	DT
18637	2290	14	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2290	15	use	use	NN
18637	2290	16	or	or	CC
18637	2290	17	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	2290	18	of	of	IN
18637	2290	19	the	the	DT
18637	2290	20	product	product	NN
18637	2290	21	,	,	,
18637	2290	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	2290	23	not	not	RB
18637	2290	24	controlled	control	VBN
18637	2290	25	by	by	IN
18637	2290	26	contractual	contractual	JJ
18637	2290	27	engagements	engagement	NNS
18637	2290	28	,	,	,
18637	2290	29	and	and	CC
18637	2290	30	persists	persist	VBZ
18637	2290	31	even	even	RB
18637	2290	32	though	though	IN
18637	2290	33	the	the	DT
18637	2290	34	business	business	NN
18637	2290	35	be	be	VB
18637	2290	36	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	2290	37	in	in	IN
18637	2290	38	close	close	JJ
18637	2290	39	connection	connection	NN
18637	2290	40	with	with	IN
18637	2290	41	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2290	42	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2290	43	.	.	.
18637	2291	1	"	"	``
18637	2291	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2291	3	544	544	CD
18637	2291	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2291	5	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	2291	6	an	an	DT
18637	2291	7	annual	annual	JJ
18637	2291	8	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2291	9	tax	tax	NN
18637	2291	10	on	on	IN
18637	2291	11	the	the	DT
18637	2291	12	business	business	NN
18637	2291	13	of	of	IN
18637	2291	14	producing	produce	VBG
18637	2291	15	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2291	16	gas	gas	NN
18637	2291	17	in	in	IN
18637	2291	18	the	the	DT
18637	2291	19	State	State	NNP
18637	2291	20	,	,	,
18637	2291	21	computed	compute	VBD
18637	2291	22	on	on	IN
18637	2291	23	the	the	DT
18637	2291	24	value	value	NN
18637	2291	25	of	of	IN
18637	2291	26	the	the	DT
18637	2291	27	gas	gas	NN
18637	2291	28	produced	produce	VBN
18637	2291	29	"	"	``
18637	2291	30	as	as	IN
18637	2291	31	shown	show	VBN
18637	2291	32	by	by	IN
18637	2291	33	the	the	DT
18637	2291	34	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2291	35	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	2291	36	derived	derive	VBN
18637	2291	37	from	from	IN
18637	2291	38	the	the	DT
18637	2291	39	sale	sale	NN
18637	2291	40	thereof	thereof	VBN
18637	2291	41	by	by	IN
18637	2291	42	the	the	DT
18637	2291	43	producer	producer	NN
18637	2291	44	,	,	,
18637	2291	45	"	"	''
18637	2291	46	was	be	VBD
18637	2291	47	held	hold	VBN
18637	2291	48	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2291	49	even	even	RB
18637	2291	50	though	though	IN
18637	2291	51	most	most	JJS
18637	2291	52	of	of	IN
18637	2291	53	the	the	DT
18637	2291	54	gas	gas	NN
18637	2291	55	passed	pass	VBN
18637	2291	56	into	into	IN
18637	2291	57	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2291	58	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2291	59	in	in	IN
18637	2291	60	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	2291	61	movement	movement	NN
18637	2291	62	from	from	IN
18637	2291	63	the	the	DT
18637	2291	64	wells	well	NNS
18637	2291	65	.	.	.
18637	2292	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2292	2	545	545	CD
18637	2292	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2292	4	And	and	CC
18637	2292	5	in	in	IN
18637	2292	6	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	2292	7	Power	Power	NNP
18637	2292	8	and	and	CC
18637	2292	9	Light	Light	NNP
18637	2292	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2292	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2292	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	2292	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2292	14	Pfost[546	Pfost[546	NNP
18637	2292	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2292	16	the	the	DT
18637	2292	17	generation	generation	NN
18637	2292	18	of	of	IN
18637	2292	19	electricity	electricity	NN
18637	2292	20	in	in	IN
18637	2292	21	a	a	DT
18637	2292	22	State	state	NN
18637	2292	23	was	be	VBD
18637	2292	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	2292	25	to	to	TO
18637	2292	26	be	be	VB
18637	2292	27	distinguishable	distinguishable	JJ
18637	2292	28	from	from	IN
18637	2292	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2292	30	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	2292	31	over	over	IN
18637	2292	32	wires	wire	NNS
18637	2292	33	to	to	IN
18637	2292	34	consumers	consumer	NNS
18637	2292	35	in	in	IN
18637	2292	36	another	another	DT
18637	2292	37	State	state	NN
18637	2292	38	,	,	,
18637	2292	39	and	and	CC
18637	2292	40	hence	hence	RB
18637	2292	41	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	2292	42	by	by	IN
18637	2292	43	the	the	DT
18637	2292	44	former	former	JJ
18637	2292	45	State	State	NNP
18637	2292	46	.	.	.
18637	2293	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	2293	2	,	,	,
18637	2293	3	a	a	DT
18637	2293	4	State	state	NN
18637	2293	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	2293	6	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	2293	7	a	a	DT
18637	2293	8	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2293	9	tax	tax	NN
18637	2293	10	on	on	IN
18637	2293	11	the	the	DT
18637	2293	12	production	production	NN
18637	2293	13	of	of	IN
18637	2293	14	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
18637	2293	15	power	power	NN
18637	2293	16	for	for	IN
18637	2293	17	sale	sale	NN
18637	2293	18	or	or	CC
18637	2293	19	use	use	NN
18637	2293	20	did	do	VBD
18637	2293	21	not	not	RB
18637	2293	22	contravene	contravene	VB
18637	2293	23	the	the	DT
18637	2293	24	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2293	25	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2293	26	clause	clause	NN
18637	2293	27	although	although	IN
18637	2293	28	applied	apply	VBD
18637	2293	29	to	to	IN
18637	2293	30	an	an	DT
18637	2293	31	engine	engine	NN
18637	2293	32	operating	operate	VBG
18637	2293	33	a	a	DT
18637	2293	34	compressor	compressor	NN
18637	2293	35	to	to	TO
18637	2293	36	increase	increase	VB
18637	2293	37	the	the	DT
18637	2293	38	pressure	pressure	NN
18637	2293	39	of	of	IN
18637	2293	40	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2293	41	gas	gas	NN
18637	2293	42	and	and	CC
18637	2293	43	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	2293	44	permit	permit	VBP
18637	2293	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2293	46	to	to	TO
18637	2293	47	be	be	VB
18637	2293	48	transported	transport	VBN
18637	2293	49	to	to	IN
18637	2293	50	purchasers	purchaser	NNS
18637	2293	51	in	in	IN
18637	2293	52	other	other	JJ
18637	2293	53	States	States	NNPS
18637	2293	54	.	.	.
18637	2294	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2294	2	547	547	CD
18637	2294	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2294	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	2294	5	,	,	,
18637	2294	6	a	a	DT
18637	2294	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	2294	8	so	so	RB
18637	2294	9	much	much	JJ
18637	2294	10	per	per	IN
18637	2294	11	pound	pound	NN
18637	2294	12	on	on	IN
18637	2294	13	shrimp	shrimp	NN
18637	2294	14	taken	take	VBN
18637	2294	15	within	within	IN
18637	2294	16	the	the	DT
18637	2294	17	three	three	CD
18637	2294	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	2294	19	mile	mile	NN
18637	2294	20	belt	belt	NN
18637	2294	21	of	of	IN
18637	2294	22	the	the	DT
18637	2294	23	coast	coast	NN
18637	2294	24	of	of	IN
18637	2294	25	the	the	DT
18637	2294	26	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2294	27	State	state	NN
18637	2294	28	was	be	VBD
18637	2294	29	valid	valid	JJ
18637	2294	30	,	,	,
18637	2294	31	since	since	IN
18637	2294	32	the	the	DT
18637	2294	33	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	2294	34	event	event	NN
18637	2294	35	,	,	,
18637	2294	36	the	the	DT
18637	2294	37	taking	taking	NN
18637	2294	38	of	of	IN
18637	2294	39	the	the	DT
18637	2294	40	shrimp	shrimp	NN
18637	2294	41	,	,	,
18637	2294	42	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	2294	43	before	before	IN
18637	2294	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2294	45	could	could	MD
18637	2294	46	be	be	VB
18637	2294	47	said	say	VBN
18637	2294	48	to	to	TO
18637	2294	49	have	have	VB
18637	2294	50	entered	enter	VBN
18637	2294	51	the	the	DT
18637	2294	52	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2294	53	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2294	54	stream	stream	NN
18637	2294	55	.	.	.
18637	2295	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2295	2	548	548	CD
18637	2295	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2295	4	PRODUCTION	production	NN
18637	2295	5	FOR	for	IN
18637	2295	6	AN	an	DT
18637	2295	7	ESTABLISHED	established	NN
18637	2295	8	MARKET	market	NN
18637	2295	9	But	but	CC
18637	2295	10	while	while	IN
18637	2295	11	the	the	DT
18637	2295	12	production	production	NN
18637	2295	13	of	of	IN
18637	2295	14	goods	good	NNS
18637	2295	15	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2295	16	for	for	IN
18637	2295	17	the	the	DT
18637	2295	18	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2295	19	market	market	NN
18637	2295	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	2295	21	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	2295	22	by	by	IN
18637	2295	23	the	the	DT
18637	2295	24	State	state	NN
18637	2295	25	where	where	WRB
18637	2295	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2295	27	takes	take	VBZ
18637	2295	28	place	place	NN
18637	2295	29	,	,	,
18637	2295	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2295	31	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	2295	32	for	for	IN
18637	2295	33	an	an	DT
18637	2295	34	established	established	JJ
18637	2295	35	market	market	NN
18637	2295	36	in	in	IN
18637	2295	37	another	another	DT
18637	2295	38	State	state	NN
18637	2295	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	2295	40	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2295	41	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2295	42	and	and	CC
18637	2295	43	as	as	IN
18637	2295	44	such	such	JJ
18637	2295	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	2295	46	neither	neither	CC
18637	2295	47	regulatable	regulatable	JJ
18637	2295	48	nor	nor	CC
18637	2295	49	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	2295	50	by	by	IN
18637	2295	51	the	the	DT
18637	2295	52	State	State	NNP
18637	2295	53	of	of	IN
18637	2295	54	origin	origin	NN
18637	2295	55	,	,	,
18637	2295	56	provided	provide	VBN
18637	2295	57	at	at	IN
18637	2295	58	any	any	DT
18637	2295	59	rate	rate	NN
18637	2295	60	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2295	61	trans	trans	JJ
18637	2295	62	-	-	NN
18637	2295	63	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2295	64	is	be	VBZ
18637	2295	65	not	not	RB
18637	2295	66	unduly	unduly	RB
18637	2295	67	delayed	delay	VBN
18637	2295	68	.	.	.
18637	2296	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2296	2	549	549	CD
18637	2296	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2296	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2296	5	,	,	,
18637	2296	6	oil	oil	NN
18637	2296	7	gathered	gather	VBD
18637	2296	8	into	into	IN
18637	2296	9	the	the	DT
18637	2296	10	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	2296	11	lines	line	NNS
18637	2296	12	of	of	IN
18637	2296	13	a	a	DT
18637	2296	14	distributing	distribute	VBG
18637	2296	15	company	company	NN
18637	2296	16	and	and	CC
18637	2296	17	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2296	18	for	for	IN
18637	2296	19	the	the	DT
18637	2296	20	most	most	JJS
18637	2296	21	part	part	NN
18637	2296	22	for	for	IN
18637	2296	23	customers	customer	NNS
18637	2296	24	outside	outside	IN
18637	2296	25	the	the	DT
18637	2296	26	State	State	NNP
18637	2296	27	,	,	,
18637	2296	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	2296	29	in	in	IN
18637	2296	30	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2296	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2296	32	from	from	IN
18637	2296	33	the	the	DT
18637	2296	34	moment	moment	NN
18637	2296	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2296	36	leaves	leave	VBZ
18637	2296	37	the	the	DT
18637	2296	38	wells;[550	wells;[550	CD
18637	2296	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2296	40	and	and	CC
18637	2296	41	a	a	DT
18637	2296	42	like	like	JJ
18637	2296	43	result	result	NN
18637	2296	44	has	have	VBZ
18637	2296	45	been	be	VBN
18637	2296	46	reached	reach	VBN
18637	2296	47	as	as	IN
18637	2296	48	to	to	IN
18637	2296	49	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2296	50	gas	gas	NN
18637	2296	51	.	.	.
18637	2297	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2297	2	551	551	CD
18637	2297	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2297	4	"	"	``
18637	2297	5	The	the	DT
18637	2297	6	typical	typical	JJ
18637	2297	7	and	and	CC
18637	2297	8	actual	actual	JJ
18637	2297	9	course	course	NN
18637	2297	10	of	of	IN
18637	2297	11	events	event	NNS
18637	2297	12	,	,	,
18637	2297	13	"	"	''
18637	2297	14	says	say	VBZ
18637	2297	15	the	the	DT
18637	2297	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2297	17	,	,	,
18637	2297	18	"	"	''
18637	2297	19	marks	mark	VBZ
18637	2297	20	the	the	DT
18637	2297	21	carriage	carriage	NN
18637	2297	22	of	of	IN
18637	2297	23	the	the	DT
18637	2297	24	greater	great	JJR
18637	2297	25	part	part	NN
18637	2297	26	as	as	IN
18637	2297	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2297	28	among	among	IN
18637	2297	29	the	the	DT
18637	2297	30	States	States	NNPS
18637	2297	31	and	and	CC
18637	2297	32	theoretical	theoretical	JJ
18637	2297	33	possibilities	possibility	NNS
18637	2297	34	may	may	MD
18637	2297	35	be	be	VB
18637	2297	36	left	leave	VBN
18637	2297	37	out	out	IN
18637	2297	38	of	of	IN
18637	2297	39	account	account	NN
18637	2297	40	.	.	.
18637	2298	1	"	"	``
18637	2298	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2298	3	552	552	CD
18637	2298	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2298	5	REJECTION	rejection	NN
18637	2298	6	OF	of	IN
18637	2298	7	THE	the	DT
18637	2298	8	ORIGINAL	original	JJ
18637	2298	9	PACKAGE	package	NN
18637	2298	10	CONCEPT	CONCEPT	NNS
18637	2298	11	IN	in	IN
18637	2298	12	INTERSTATE	interstate	JJ
18637	2298	13	COMMERCE	COMMERCE	NNS
18637	2298	14	But	but	CC
18637	2298	15	the	the	DT
18637	2298	16	question	question	NN
18637	2298	17	also	also	RB
18637	2298	18	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	2298	19	as	as	IN
18637	2298	20	to	to	IN
18637	2298	21	when	when	WRB
18637	2298	22	goods	good	NNS
18637	2298	23	entering	enter	VBG
18637	2298	24	a	a	DT
18637	2298	25	State	state	NN
18637	2298	26	from	from	IN
18637	2298	27	another	another	DT
18637	2298	28	State	state	NN
18637	2298	29	become	become	VBD
18637	2298	30	part	part	NN
18637	2298	31	of	of	IN
18637	2298	32	the	the	DT
18637	2298	33	mass	mass	NN
18637	2298	34	of	of	IN
18637	2298	35	property	property	NN
18637	2298	36	of	of	IN
18637	2298	37	the	the	DT
18637	2298	38	former	former	JJ
18637	2298	39	and	and	CC
18637	2298	40	hence	hence	RB
18637	2298	41	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	2298	42	by	by	IN
18637	2298	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2298	44	?	?	.
18637	2299	1	In	in	IN
18637	2299	2	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	2299	3	_	_	NNP
18637	2299	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	2299	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2299	6	Maryland,[553	Maryland,[553	NNP
18637	2299	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2299	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2299	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2299	10	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2299	11	,	,	,
18637	2299	12	had	have	VBD
18637	2299	13	remarked	remark	VBN
18637	2299	14	at	at	IN
18637	2299	15	the	the	DT
18637	2299	16	close	close	NN
18637	2299	17	of	of	IN
18637	2299	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2299	19	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2299	20	,	,	,
18637	2299	21	"	"	``
18637	2299	22	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2299	23	suppose	suppose	VBP
18637	2299	24	the	the	DT
18637	2299	25	principles	principle	NNS
18637	2299	26	laid	lay	VBN
18637	2299	27	down	down	RP
18637	2299	28	in	in	IN
18637	2299	29	this	this	DT
18637	2299	30	case	case	NN
18637	2299	31	,	,	,
18637	2299	32	apply	apply	VBP
18637	2299	33	equally	equally	RB
18637	2299	34	to	to	IN
18637	2299	35	importations	importation	NNS
18637	2299	36	from	from	IN
18637	2299	37	a	a	DT
18637	2299	38	sister	sister	NN
18637	2299	39	State	State	NNP
18637	2299	40	.	.	.
18637	2300	1	"	"	``
18637	2300	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2300	3	554	554	CD
18637	2300	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2300	5	Forty	forty	CD
18637	2300	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	2300	7	two	two	CD
18637	2300	8	years	year	NNS
18637	2300	9	later	later	RB
18637	2300	10	,	,	,
18637	2300	11	in	in	IN
18637	2300	12	Woodruff	Woodruff	NNP
18637	2300	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2300	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	2300	15	_	_	NNP
18637	2300	16	Parham,[555	Parham,[555	NNP
18637	2300	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2300	18	an	an	DT
18637	2300	19	effort	effort	NN
18637	2300	20	was	be	VBD
18637	2300	21	made	make	VBN
18637	2300	22	to	to	TO
18637	2300	23	induce	induce	VB
18637	2300	24	the	the	DT
18637	2300	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2300	26	,	,	,
18637	2300	27	in	in	IN
18637	2300	28	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	2300	29	on	on	IN
18637	2300	30	this	this	DT
18637	2300	31	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	2300	32	,	,	,
18637	2300	33	to	to	TO
18637	2300	34	apply	apply	VB
18637	2300	35	the	the	DT
18637	2300	36	original	original	JJ
18637	2300	37	package	package	NN
18637	2300	38	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2300	39	against	against	IN
18637	2300	40	a	a	DT
18637	2300	41	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	2300	42	,	,	,
18637	2300	43	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	2300	44	tax	tax	NN
18637	2300	45	on	on	IN
18637	2300	46	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2300	47	at	at	IN
18637	2300	48	auction	auction	NN
18637	2300	49	,	,	,
18637	2300	50	so	so	RB
18637	2300	51	far	far	RB
18637	2300	52	as	as	IN
18637	2300	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2300	54	reached	reach	VBD
18637	2300	55	"	"	``
18637	2300	56	imports	import	NNS
18637	2300	57	"	"	''
18637	2300	58	from	from	IN
18637	2300	59	sister	sister	NN
18637	2300	60	States	States	NNP
18637	2300	61	.	.	.
18637	2301	1	The	the	DT
18637	2301	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2301	3	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	2301	4	the	the	DT
18637	2301	5	invitation	invitation	NN
18637	2301	6	;	;	:
18637	2301	7	first	first	RB
18637	2301	8	on	on	IN
18637	2301	9	the	the	DT
18637	2301	10	ground	ground	NN
18637	2301	11	that	that	IN
18637	2301	12	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2301	13	's	's	POS
18637	2301	14	statement	statement	NN
18637	2301	15	was	be	VBD
18637	2301	16	_	_	NNP
18637	2301	17	obiter	obiter	NN
18637	2301	18	_	_	NNP
18637	2301	19	,	,	,
18637	2301	20	the	the	DT
18637	2301	21	point	point	NN
18637	2301	22	not	not	RB
18637	2301	23	having	have	VBG
18637	2301	24	been	be	VBN
18637	2301	25	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2301	26	in	in	IN
18637	2301	27	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	2301	28	_	_	NNP
18637	2301	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	2301	30	_	_	NNP
18637	2301	31	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	2301	32	;	;	:
18637	2301	33	second	second	RB
18637	2301	34	,	,	,
18637	2301	35	because	because	IN
18637	2301	36	usage	usage	NN
18637	2301	37	contemporary	contemporary	JJ
18637	2301	38	with	with	IN
18637	2301	39	the	the	DT
18637	2301	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2301	41	and	and	CC
18637	2301	42	of	of	IN
18637	2301	43	the	the	DT
18637	2301	44	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2301	45	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2301	46	confined	confine	VBD
18637	2301	47	the	the	DT
18637	2301	48	term	term	NN
18637	2301	49	"	"	``
18637	2301	50	imports	import	NNS
18637	2301	51	"	"	''
18637	2301	52	as	as	IN
18637	2301	53	employed	employ	VBN
18637	2301	54	in	in	IN
18637	2301	55	article	article	NN
18637	2301	56	I	i	NN
18637	2301	57	,	,	,
18637	2301	58	section	section	NN
18637	2301	59	10	10	CD
18637	2301	60	to	to	IN
18637	2301	61	imports	import	NNS
18637	2301	62	from	from	IN
18637	2301	63	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	2301	64	;	;	:
18637	2301	65	third	third	RB
18637	2301	66	,	,	,
18637	2301	67	because	because	IN
18637	2301	68	the	the	DT
18637	2301	69	tax	tax	NN
18637	2301	70	in	in	IN
18637	2301	71	question	question	NN
18637	2301	72	was	be	VBD
18637	2301	73	nondiscriminatory	nondiscriminatory	JJ
18637	2301	74	.	.	.
18637	2302	1	At	at	IN
18637	2302	2	the	the	DT
18637	2302	3	same	same	JJ
18637	2302	4	time	time	NN
18637	2302	5	,	,	,
18637	2302	6	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	2302	7	,	,	,
18637	2302	8	reference	reference	NN
18637	2302	9	was	be	VBD
18637	2302	10	made	make	VBN
18637	2302	11	to	to	IN
18637	2302	12	the	the	DT
18637	2302	13	power	power	NN
18637	2302	14	of	of	IN
18637	2302	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2302	16	to	to	TO
18637	2302	17	interpose	interpose	VB
18637	2302	18	at	at	IN
18637	2302	19	any	any	DT
18637	2302	20	time	time	NN
18637	2302	21	in	in	IN
18637	2302	22	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2302	23	of	of	IN
18637	2302	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2302	25	power	power	NN
18637	2302	26	over	over	IN
18637	2302	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2302	28	,	,	,
18637	2302	29	"	"	''
18637	2302	30	in	in	IN
18637	2302	31	such	such	PDT
18637	2302	32	a	a	DT
18637	2302	33	manner	manner	NN
18637	2302	34	as	as	IN
18637	2302	35	to	to	TO
18637	2302	36	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2302	37	the	the	DT
18637	2302	38	States	States	NNPS
18637	2302	39	from	from	IN
18637	2302	40	any	any	DT
18637	2302	41	oppressive	oppressive	JJ
18637	2302	42	interference	interference	NN
18637	2302	43	with	with	IN
18637	2302	44	the	the	DT
18637	2302	45	free	free	JJ
18637	2302	46	interchange	interchange	NN
18637	2302	47	of	of	IN
18637	2302	48	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	2302	49	by	by	IN
18637	2302	50	the	the	DT
18637	2302	51	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	2302	52	of	of	IN
18637	2302	53	one	one	CD
18637	2302	54	State	state	NN
18637	2302	55	with	with	IN
18637	2302	56	those	those	DT
18637	2302	57	of	of	IN
18637	2302	58	another	another	DT
18637	2302	59	.	.	.
18637	2303	1	"	"	``
18637	2303	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2303	3	556	556	CD
18637	2303	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2303	5	The	the	DT
18637	2303	6	same	same	JJ
18637	2303	7	result	result	NN
18637	2303	8	was	be	VBD
18637	2303	9	reached	reach	VBN
18637	2303	10	a	a	DT
18637	2303	11	few	few	JJ
18637	2303	12	years	year	NNS
18637	2303	13	later	later	RB
18637	2303	14	in	in	IN
18637	2303	15	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	2303	16	_	_	NNP
18637	2303	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	2303	18	_	_	NNP
18637	2303	19	Houston,[557	Houston,[557	NNP
18637	2303	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2303	21	where	where	WRB
18637	2303	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2303	23	was	be	VBD
18637	2303	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	2303	25	that	that	IN
18637	2303	26	coal	coal	NN
18637	2303	27	transported	transport	VBD
18637	2303	28	down	down	RP
18637	2303	29	the	the	DT
18637	2303	30	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	2303	31	from	from	IN
18637	2303	32	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2303	33	had	have	VBD
18637	2303	34	been	be	VBN
18637	2303	35	validly	validly	RB
18637	2303	36	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	2303	37	by	by	IN
18637	2303	38	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	2303	39	to	to	IN
18637	2303	40	a	a	DT
18637	2303	41	general	general	JJ
18637	2303	42	_	_	NNP
18637	2303	43	ad	ad	NN
18637	2303	44	valorem	valorem	NN
18637	2303	45	_	_	NNP
18637	2303	46	property	property	NN
18637	2303	47	tax	tax	NN
18637	2303	48	,	,	,
18637	2303	49	having	have	VBG
18637	2303	50	"	"	``
18637	2303	51	come	come	VB
18637	2303	52	to	to	IN
18637	2303	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2303	54	place	place	NN
18637	2303	55	of	of	IN
18637	2303	56	rest	rest	NN
18637	2303	57	,	,	,
18637	2303	58	for	for	IN
18637	2303	59	final	final	JJ
18637	2303	60	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	2303	61	or	or	CC
18637	2303	62	use	use	NN
18637	2303	63	,	,	,
18637	2303	64	"	"	''
18637	2303	65	and	and	CC
18637	2303	66	hence	hence	RB
18637	2303	67	become	become	VB
18637	2303	68	"	"	``
18637	2303	69	a	a	DT
18637	2303	70	part	part	NN
18637	2303	71	of	of	IN
18637	2303	72	the	the	DT
18637	2303	73	general	general	JJ
18637	2303	74	mass	mass	NN
18637	2303	75	of	of	IN
18637	2303	76	property	property	NN
18637	2303	77	in	in	IN
18637	2303	78	the	the	DT
18637	2303	79	State	State	NNP
18637	2303	80	.	.	.
18637	2304	1	"	"	``
18637	2304	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2304	3	558	558	CD
18637	2304	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2304	5	Again	again	RB
18637	2304	6	,	,	,
18637	2304	7	however	however	RB
18637	2304	8	,	,	,
18637	2304	9	a	a	DT
18637	2304	10	caveat	caveat	NN
18637	2304	11	was	be	VBD
18637	2304	12	entered	enter	VBN
18637	2304	13	in	in	IN
18637	2304	14	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	2304	15	of	of	IN
18637	2304	16	the	the	DT
18637	2304	17	power	power	NN
18637	2304	18	of	of	IN
18637	2304	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2304	20	to	to	TO
18637	2304	21	impose	impose	VB
18637	2304	22	a	a	DT
18637	2304	23	different	different	JJ
18637	2304	24	rule	rule	NN
18637	2304	25	affording	afford	VBG
18637	2304	26	"	"	``
18637	2304	27	a	a	DT
18637	2304	28	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	2304	29	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	2304	30	"	"	''
18637	2304	31	of	of	IN
18637	2304	32	property	property	NN
18637	2304	33	transported	transport	VBN
18637	2304	34	from	from	IN
18637	2304	35	one	one	CD
18637	2304	36	State	state	NN
18637	2304	37	to	to	IN
18637	2304	38	another	another	DT
18637	2304	39	from	from	IN
18637	2304	40	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2304	41	by	by	IN
18637	2304	42	the	the	DT
18637	2304	43	latter	latter	JJ
18637	2304	44	.	.	.
18637	2305	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2305	2	559	559	CD
18637	2305	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2305	4	INSPECTION	inspection	NN
18637	2305	5	CHARGES	CHARGES	NNP
18637	2305	6	Woodruff	Woodruff	NNP
18637	2305	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2305	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	2305	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2305	10	Parham	Parham	NNP
18637	2305	11	and	and	CC
18637	2305	12	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	2305	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2305	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	2305	15	_	_	NNP
18637	2305	16	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	2305	17	are	be	VBP
18637	2305	18	still	still	RB
18637	2305	19	good	good	JJ
18637	2305	20	law	law	NN
18637	2305	21	for	for	IN
18637	2305	22	the	the	DT
18637	2305	23	most	most	JJS
18637	2305	24	part	part	NN
18637	2305	25	.	.	.
18637	2306	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2306	2	560	560	CD
18637	2306	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2306	4	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	2306	5	,	,	,
18637	2306	6	there	there	EX
18637	2306	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	2306	8	one	one	CD
18637	2306	9	respect	respect	NN
18637	2306	10	in	in	IN
18637	2306	11	which	which	WDT
18637	2306	12	imports	import	NNS
18637	2306	13	from	from	IN
18637	2306	14	sister	sister	NN
18637	2306	15	States	state	NNS
18637	2306	16	are	be	VBP
18637	2306	17	treated	treat	VBN
18637	2306	18	as	as	IN
18637	2306	19	"	"	``
18637	2306	20	imports	import	NNS
18637	2306	21	"	"	''
18637	2306	22	in	in	IN
18637	2306	23	the	the	DT
18637	2306	24	sense	sense	NN
18637	2306	25	of	of	IN
18637	2306	26	the	the	DT
18637	2306	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2306	28	,	,	,
18637	2306	29	and	and	CC
18637	2306	30	that	that	DT
18637	2306	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	2306	32	in	in	IN
18637	2306	33	being	be	VBG
18637	2306	34	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	2306	35	from	from	IN
18637	2306	36	"	"	``
18637	2306	37	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	2306	38	"	"	''
18637	2306	39	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	2306	40	charges	charge	NNS
18637	2306	41	.	.	.
18637	2307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2307	2	561	561	CD
18637	2307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2307	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2307	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	2307	6	true	true	JJ
18637	2307	7	,	,	,
18637	2307	8	also	also	RB
18637	2307	9	,	,	,
18637	2307	10	that	that	IN
18637	2307	11	in	in	IN
18637	2307	12	a	a	DT
18637	2307	13	series	series	NN
18637	2307	14	of	of	IN
18637	2307	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	2307	16	involving	involve	VBG
18637	2307	17	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2307	18	of	of	IN
18637	2307	19	oil	oil	NN
18637	2307	20	about	about	IN
18637	2307	21	1920	1920	CD
18637	2307	22	the	the	DT
18637	2307	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2307	24	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	2307	25	to	to	TO
18637	2307	26	be	be	VB
18637	2307	27	contemplating	contemplate	VBG
18637	2307	28	reviving	revive	VBG
18637	2307	29	the	the	DT
18637	2307	30	original	original	JJ
18637	2307	31	package	package	NN
18637	2307	32	doctrine,[562	doctrine,[562	NN
18637	2307	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2307	34	but	but	CC
18637	2307	35	these	these	DT
18637	2307	36	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	2307	37	were	be	VBD
18637	2307	38	presently	presently	RB
18637	2307	39	"	"	``
18637	2307	40	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	2307	41	"	"	''
18637	2307	42	in	in	IN
18637	2307	43	a	a	DT
18637	2307	44	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	2307	45	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2307	46	by	by	IN
18637	2307	47	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2307	48	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2307	49	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	2307	50	,	,	,
18637	2307	51	reviewing	review	VBG
18637	2307	52	the	the	DT
18637	2307	53	cases	case	NNS
18637	2307	54	.	.	.
18637	2308	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2308	2	563	563	CD
18637	2308	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2308	4	But	but	CC
18637	2308	5	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2308	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2308	7	one	one	CD
18637	2308	8	thing	thing	NN
18637	2308	9	,	,	,
18637	2308	10	prohibition	prohibition	VB
18637	2308	11	another	another	DT
18637	2308	12	.	.	.
18637	2309	1	In	in	IN
18637	2309	2	the	the	DT
18637	2309	3	field	field	NN
18637	2309	4	of	of	IN
18637	2309	5	the	the	DT
18637	2309	6	police	police	NN
18637	2309	7	power	power	NN
18637	2309	8	,	,	,
18637	2309	9	where	where	WRB
18637	2309	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2309	11	applicability	applicability	NN
18637	2309	12	was	be	VBD
18637	2309	13	not	not	RB
18637	2309	14	so	so	RB
18637	2309	15	much	much	RB
18637	2309	16	as	as	IN
18637	2309	17	suggested	suggest	VBN
18637	2309	18	in	in	IN
18637	2309	19	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	2309	20	_	_	NNP
18637	2309	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	2309	22	_	_	NNP
18637	2309	23	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	2309	24	,	,	,
18637	2309	25	the	the	DT
18637	2309	26	original	original	JJ
18637	2309	27	package	package	NN
18637	2309	28	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2309	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	2309	30	been	be	VBN
18637	2309	31	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	2309	32	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	2309	33	by	by	IN
18637	2309	34	the	the	DT
18637	2309	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2309	36	against	against	IN
18637	2309	37	State	State	NNP
18637	2309	38	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2309	39	,	,	,
18637	2309	40	and	and	CC
18637	2309	41	even	even	RB
18637	2309	42	today	today	NN
18637	2309	43	,	,	,
18637	2309	44	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	2309	45	retains	retain	VBZ
18637	2309	46	a	a	DT
18637	2309	47	spark	spark	NN
18637	2309	48	of	of	IN
18637	2309	49	life	life	NN
18637	2309	50	.	.	.
18637	2310	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2310	2	564	564	CD
18637	2310	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2310	4	LOCAL	local	NN
18637	2310	5	SALES	sale	NNS
18637	2310	6	:	:	:
18637	2310	7	PEDDLERS	peddler	NNS
18637	2310	8	By	by	IN
18637	2310	9	the	the	DT
18637	2310	10	same	same	JJ
18637	2310	11	token	token	JJ
18637	2310	12	,	,	,
18637	2310	13	local	local	JJ
18637	2310	14	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2310	15	of	of	IN
18637	2310	16	goods	good	NNS
18637	2310	17	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2310	18	into	into	IN
18637	2310	19	a	a	DT
18637	2310	20	State	state	NN
18637	2310	21	from	from	IN
18637	2310	22	another	another	DT
18637	2310	23	State	state	NN
18637	2310	24	are	be	VBP
18637	2310	25	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2310	26	to	to	IN
18637	2310	27	a	a	DT
18637	2310	28	nondiscriminatory	nondiscriminatory	JJ
18637	2310	29	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2310	30	of	of	IN
18637	2310	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2310	32	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2310	33	power	power	NN
18637	2310	34	.	.	.
18637	2311	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	2311	2	a	a	DT
18637	2311	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	2311	4	,	,	,
18637	2311	5	the	the	DT
18637	2311	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2311	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	2311	8	said	say	VBN
18637	2311	9	,	,	,
18637	2311	10	"	"	``
18637	2311	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	2311	12	never	never	RB
18637	2311	13	been	be	VBN
18637	2311	14	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	2311	15	as	as	IN
18637	2311	16	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	2311	17	a	a	DT
18637	2311	18	direct	direct	JJ
18637	2311	19	burden	burden	NN
18637	2311	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	2311	21	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2311	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2311	23	and	and	CC
18637	2311	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	2311	25	no	no	DT
18637	2311	26	greater	great	JJR
18637	2311	27	or	or	CC
18637	2311	28	different	different	JJ
18637	2311	29	effect	effect	NN
18637	2311	30	upon	upon	IN
18637	2311	31	that	that	DT
18637	2311	32	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2311	33	than	than	IN
18637	2311	34	a	a	DT
18637	2311	35	general	general	JJ
18637	2311	36	property	property	NN
18637	2311	37	tax	tax	NN
18637	2311	38	to	to	TO
18637	2311	39	which	which	WDT
18637	2311	40	all	all	PDT
18637	2311	41	those	those	DT
18637	2311	42	enjoying	enjoy	VBG
18637	2311	43	the	the	DT
18637	2311	44	protection	protection	NN
18637	2311	45	of	of	IN
18637	2311	46	the	the	DT
18637	2311	47	State	State	NNP
18637	2311	48	may	may	MD
18637	2311	49	be	be	VB
18637	2311	50	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	2311	51	"	"	''
18637	2311	52	;	;	:
18637	2311	53	and	and	CC
18637	2311	54	this	this	DT
18637	2311	55	is	be	VBZ
18637	2311	56	true	true	JJ
18637	2311	57	,	,	,
18637	2311	58	even	even	RB
18637	2311	59	of	of	IN
18637	2311	60	goods	good	NNS
18637	2311	61	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	2311	62	to	to	TO
18637	2311	63	be	be	VB
18637	2311	64	used	use	VBN
18637	2311	65	in	in	IN
18637	2311	66	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2311	67	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2311	68	.	.	.
18637	2312	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2312	2	565	565	CD
18637	2312	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2312	4	The	the	DT
18637	2312	5	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2312	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	2312	7	,	,	,
18637	2312	8	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	2312	9	,	,	,
18637	2312	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	2312	11	not	not	RB
18637	2312	12	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2312	13	a	a	DT
18637	2312	14	State	state	NN
18637	2312	15	from	from	IN
18637	2312	16	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	2312	17	special	special	JJ
18637	2312	18	license	license	NN
18637	2312	19	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2312	20	on	on	IN
18637	2312	21	merchants	merchant	NNS
18637	2312	22	using	use	VBG
18637	2312	23	profit	profit	NN
18637	2312	24	sharing	sharing	NN
18637	2312	25	coupons	coupon	NNS
18637	2312	26	and	and	CC
18637	2312	27	trading	trading	NN
18637	2312	28	stamps	stamp	NNS
18637	2312	29	although	although	IN
18637	2312	30	the	the	DT
18637	2312	31	coupons	coupon	NNS
18637	2312	32	may	may	MD
18637	2312	33	have	have	VB
18637	2312	34	been	be	VBN
18637	2312	35	inserted	insert	VBN
18637	2312	36	in	in	IN
18637	2312	37	retail	retail	JJ
18637	2312	38	packages	package	NNS
18637	2312	39	by	by	IN
18637	2312	40	the	the	DT
18637	2312	41	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
18637	2312	42	or	or	CC
18637	2312	43	shipper	shipper	NN
18637	2312	44	outside	outside	IN
18637	2312	45	the	the	DT
18637	2312	46	State	state	NN
18637	2312	47	and	and	CC
18637	2312	48	are	be	VBP
18637	2312	49	redeemable	redeemable	JJ
18637	2312	50	outside	outside	IN
18637	2312	51	the	the	DT
18637	2312	52	State	State	NNP
18637	2312	53	,	,	,
18637	2312	54	either	either	CC
18637	2312	55	by	by	IN
18637	2312	56	such	such	JJ
18637	2312	57	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
18637	2312	58	or	or	CC
18637	2312	59	shipper	shipper	NN
18637	2312	60	,	,	,
18637	2312	61	or	or	CC
18637	2312	62	by	by	IN
18637	2312	63	some	some	DT
18637	2312	64	other	other	JJ
18637	2312	65	agency	agency	NN
18637	2312	66	outside	outside	IN
18637	2312	67	the	the	DT
18637	2312	68	State;[566	state;[566	NN
18637	2312	69	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2312	70	nor	nor	CC
18637	2312	71	yet	yet	RB
18637	2312	72	a	a	DT
18637	2312	73	nondiscriminatory	nondiscriminatory	JJ
18637	2312	74	tax	tax	NN
18637	2312	75	upon	upon	IN
18637	2312	76	local	local	JJ
18637	2312	77	peddling	peddling	NN
18637	2312	78	of	of	IN
18637	2312	79	goods	good	NNS
18637	2312	80	and	and	CC
18637	2312	81	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2312	82	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	2312	83	by	by	IN
18637	2312	84	peddlers	peddler	NNS
18637	2312	85	even	even	RB
18637	2312	86	though	though	IN
18637	2312	87	the	the	DT
18637	2312	88	goods	good	NNS
18637	2312	89	are	be	VBP
18637	2312	90	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2312	91	or	or	CC
18637	2312	92	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2312	93	imports	import	NNS
18637	2312	94	,	,	,
18637	2312	95	since	since	IN
18637	2312	96	the	the	DT
18637	2312	97	sale	sale	NN
18637	2312	98	occurs	occur	VBZ
18637	2312	99	after	after	IN
18637	2312	100	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2312	101	or	or	CC
18637	2312	102	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2312	103	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2312	104	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	2312	105	has	have	VBZ
18637	2312	106	ended	end	VBN
18637	2312	107	.	.	.
18637	2313	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2313	2	567	567	CD
18637	2313	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2313	4	And	and	CC
18637	2313	5	in	in	IN
18637	2313	6	Kehrer	Kehrer	NNP
18637	2313	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2313	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	2313	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2313	10	Stewart[568	Stewart[568	NNP
18637	2313	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2313	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2313	13	was	be	VBD
18637	2313	14	held	hold	VBN
18637	2313	15	that	that	IN
18637	2313	16	a	a	DT
18637	2313	17	State	State	NNP
18637	2313	18	tax	tax	NN
18637	2313	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	2313	20	resident	resident	JJ
18637	2313	21	managing	manage	VBG
18637	2313	22	agents	agent	NNS
18637	2313	23	of	of	IN
18637	2313	24	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	2313	25	meatpacking	meatpacking	NN
18637	2313	26	houses	house	NNS
18637	2313	27	did	do	VBD
18637	2313	28	not	not	RB
18637	2313	29	conflict	conflict	VB
18637	2313	30	with	with	IN
18637	2313	31	the	the	DT
18637	2313	32	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2313	33	clause	clause	NN
18637	2313	34	,	,	,
18637	2313	35	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	2313	36	of	of	IN
18637	2313	37	the	the	DT
18637	2313	38	fact	fact	NN
18637	2313	39	that	that	IN
18637	2313	40	the	the	DT
18637	2313	41	greater	great	JJR
18637	2313	42	portion	portion	NN
18637	2313	43	of	of	IN
18637	2313	44	the	the	DT
18637	2313	45	business	business	NN
18637	2313	46	was	be	VBD
18637	2313	47	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2313	48	in	in	IN
18637	2313	49	character	character	NN
18637	2313	50	,	,	,
18637	2313	51	the	the	DT
18637	2313	52	tax	tax	NN
18637	2313	53	having	have	VBG
18637	2313	54	been	be	VBN
18637	2313	55	construed	construe	VBN
18637	2313	56	by	by	IN
18637	2313	57	the	the	DT
18637	2313	58	highest	high	JJS
18637	2313	59	court	court	NN
18637	2313	60	of	of	IN
18637	2313	61	the	the	DT
18637	2313	62	State	State	NNP
18637	2313	63	as	as	IN
18637	2313	64	applying	apply	VBG
18637	2313	65	only	only	RB
18637	2313	66	to	to	IN
18637	2313	67	the	the	DT
18637	2313	68	business	business	NN
18637	2313	69	of	of	IN
18637	2313	70	selling	sell	VBG
18637	2313	71	to	to	IN
18637	2313	72	local	local	JJ
18637	2313	73	customers	customer	NNS
18637	2313	74	from	from	IN
18637	2313	75	the	the	DT
18637	2313	76	stock	stock	NN
18637	2313	77	of	of	IN
18637	2313	78	"	"	``
18637	2313	79	original	original	JJ
18637	2313	80	packages	package	NNS
18637	2313	81	"	"	''
18637	2313	82	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	2313	83	into	into	IN
18637	2313	84	the	the	DT
18637	2313	85	State	State	NNP
18637	2313	86	without	without	IN
18637	2313	87	a	a	DT
18637	2313	88	previous	previous	JJ
18637	2313	89	sale	sale	NN
18637	2313	90	or	or	CC
18637	2313	91	contract	contract	NN
18637	2313	92	to	to	TO
18637	2313	93	sell	sell	VB
18637	2313	94	,	,	,
18637	2313	95	and	and	CC
18637	2313	96	kept	keep	VBD
18637	2313	97	and	and	CC
18637	2313	98	held	hold	VBN
18637	2313	99	for	for	IN
18637	2313	100	sale	sale	NN
18637	2313	101	in	in	IN
18637	2313	102	the	the	DT
18637	2313	103	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	2313	104	course	course	NN
18637	2313	105	of	of	IN
18637	2313	106	trade	trade	NN
18637	2313	107	.	.	.
18637	2314	1	Contrariwise	contrariwise	NN
18637	2314	2	,	,	,
18637	2314	3	a	a	DT
18637	2314	4	tax	tax	NN
18637	2314	5	on	on	IN
18637	2314	6	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2314	7	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	2314	8	in	in	IN
18637	2314	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2314	10	incidence	incidence	NN
18637	2314	11	against	against	IN
18637	2314	12	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	2314	13	because	because	IN
18637	2314	14	of	of	IN
18637	2314	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2314	16	origin	origin	NN
18637	2314	17	in	in	IN
18637	2314	18	another	another	DT
18637	2314	19	State	State	NNP
18637	2314	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	2314	21	_	_	NNP
18637	2314	22	ipso	ipso	FW
18637	2314	23	facto	facto	FW
18637	2314	24	_	_	NNP
18637	2314	25	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	NN
18637	2314	26	.	.	.
18637	2315	1	The	the	DT
18637	2315	2	leading	leading	JJ
18637	2315	3	case	case	NN
18637	2315	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	2315	5	Welton	Welton	NNP
18637	2315	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2315	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	2315	8	_	_	NNP
18637	2315	9	Missouri,[569	Missouri,[569	NNP
18637	2315	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2315	11	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2315	12	in	in	IN
18637	2315	13	1876	1876	CD
18637	2315	14	,	,	,
18637	2315	15	in	in	IN
18637	2315	16	which	which	WDT
18637	2315	17	a	a	DT
18637	2315	18	peddler	peddler	NN
18637	2315	19	's	's	POS
18637	2315	20	license	license	NN
18637	2315	21	tax	tax	NN
18637	2315	22	confined	confine	VBN
18637	2315	23	to	to	IN
18637	2315	24	the	the	DT
18637	2315	25	sale	sale	NN
18637	2315	26	of	of	IN
18637	2315	27	goods	good	NNS
18637	2315	28	manufactured	manufacture	VBN
18637	2315	29	outside	outside	IN
18637	2315	30	the	the	DT
18637	2315	31	State	state	NN
18637	2315	32	was	be	VBD
18637	2315	33	set	set	VBN
18637	2315	34	aside	aside	RB
18637	2315	35	.	.	.
18637	2316	1	The	the	DT
18637	2316	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2316	3	of	of	IN
18637	2316	4	Welton	Welton	NNP
18637	2316	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2316	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	2316	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2316	8	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	2316	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	2316	10	been	be	VBN
18637	2316	11	reiterated	reiterate	VBN
18637	2316	12	many	many	JJ
18637	2316	13	times	time	NNS
18637	2316	14	.	.	.
18637	2317	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2317	2	570	570	CD
18637	2317	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2317	4	STOPPAGE	stoppage	NN
18637	2317	5	IN	in	IN
18637	2317	6	TRANSIT	transit	NN
18637	2317	7	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2317	8	also	also	RB
18637	2317	9	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	2317	10	logically	logically	RB
18637	2317	11	from	from	IN
18637	2317	12	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	2317	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2317	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	2317	15	_	_	NNP
18637	2317	16	Errol,[571	Errol,[571	NNP
18637	2317	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2317	18	and	and	CC
18637	2317	19	the	the	DT
18637	2317	20	cases	case	NNS
18637	2317	21	deriving	derive	VBG
18637	2317	22	from	from	IN
18637	2317	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2317	24	,	,	,
18637	2317	25	that	that	IN
18637	2317	26	a	a	DT
18637	2317	27	State	state	NN
18637	2317	28	may	may	MD
18637	2317	29	impose	impose	VB
18637	2317	30	a	a	DT
18637	2317	31	nondiscriminatory	nondiscriminatory	JJ
18637	2317	32	tax	tax	NN
18637	2317	33	when	when	WRB
18637	2317	34	there	there	EX
18637	2317	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	2317	36	a	a	DT
18637	2317	37	break	break	NN
18637	2317	38	in	in	IN
18637	2317	39	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2317	40	transit	transit	NN
18637	2317	41	,	,	,
18637	2317	42	and	and	CC
18637	2317	43	the	the	DT
18637	2317	44	goods	good	NNS
18637	2317	45	have	have	VBP
18637	2317	46	not	not	RB
18637	2317	47	been	be	VBN
18637	2317	48	restored	restore	VBN
18637	2317	49	to	to	IN
18637	2317	50	the	the	DT
18637	2317	51	current	current	NN
18637	2317	52	of	of	IN
18637	2317	53	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2317	54	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2317	55	.	.	.
18637	2318	1	The	the	DT
18637	2318	2	effect	effect	NN
18637	2318	3	of	of	IN
18637	2318	4	an	an	DT
18637	2318	5	interruption	interruption	NN
18637	2318	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	2318	7	the	the	DT
18637	2318	8	continuity	continuity	NN
18637	2318	9	of	of	IN
18637	2318	10	an	an	DT
18637	2318	11	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2318	12	movement	movement	NN
18637	2318	13	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	2318	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	2318	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2318	16	causes	cause	NNS
18637	2318	17	and	and	CC
18637	2318	18	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	2318	19	.	.	.
18637	2319	1	If	if	IN
18637	2319	2	the	the	DT
18637	2319	3	delay	delay	NN
18637	2319	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	2319	5	due	due	JJ
18637	2319	6	to	to	IN
18637	2319	7	the	the	DT
18637	2319	8	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	2319	9	of	of	IN
18637	2319	10	the	the	DT
18637	2319	11	journey	journey	NN
18637	2319	12	,	,	,
18637	2319	13	as	as	IN
18637	2319	14	in	in	IN
18637	2319	15	the	the	DT
18637	2319	16	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	2319	17	case	case	NN
18637	2319	18	,	,	,
18637	2319	19	where	where	WRB
18637	2319	20	the	the	DT
18637	2319	21	logs	log	NNS
18637	2319	22	were	be	VBD
18637	2319	23	detained	detain	VBN
18637	2319	24	for	for	IN
18637	2319	25	a	a	DT
18637	2319	26	time	time	NN
18637	2319	27	within	within	IN
18637	2319	28	the	the	DT
18637	2319	29	State	State	NNP
18637	2319	30	by	by	IN
18637	2319	31	low	low	JJ
18637	2319	32	water	water	NN
18637	2319	33	,	,	,
18637	2319	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2319	35	are	be	VBP
18637	2319	36	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	2319	37	"	"	''
18637	2319	38	in	in	IN
18637	2319	39	the	the	DT
18637	2319	40	course	course	NN
18637	2319	41	of	of	IN
18637	2319	42	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	2319	43	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2319	44	,	,	,
18637	2319	45	and	and	CC
18637	2319	46	*	*	NFP
18637	2319	47	*	*	NFP
18637	2319	48	*	*	NFP
18637	2319	49	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	2319	50	under	under	IN
18637	2319	51	the	the	DT
18637	2319	52	protection	protection	NN
18637	2319	53	of	of	IN
18637	2319	54	the	the	DT
18637	2319	55	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2319	56	.	.	.
18637	2320	1	"	"	``
18637	2320	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2320	3	572	572	CD
18637	2320	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2320	5	Intention	intention	NN
18637	2320	6	thus	thus	RB
18637	2320	7	often	often	RB
18637	2320	8	enters	enter	VBZ
18637	2320	9	into	into	IN
18637	2320	10	the	the	DT
18637	2320	11	determination	determination	NN
18637	2320	12	of	of	IN
18637	2320	13	the	the	DT
18637	2320	14	question	question	NN
18637	2320	15	whether	whether	IN
18637	2320	16	goods	good	NNS
18637	2320	17	from	from	IN
18637	2320	18	another	another	DT
18637	2320	19	State	state	NN
18637	2320	20	have	have	VBP
18637	2320	21	come	come	VBN
18637	2320	22	to	to	TO
18637	2320	23	rest	rest	VB
18637	2320	24	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	2320	25	to	to	TO
18637	2320	26	subject	subject	VB
18637	2320	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2320	28	to	to	IN
18637	2320	29	the	the	DT
18637	2320	30	local	local	JJ
18637	2320	31	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2320	32	power	power	NN
18637	2320	33	.	.	.
18637	2321	1	In	in	IN
18637	2321	2	a	a	DT
18637	2321	3	typical	typical	JJ
18637	2321	4	case	case	NN
18637	2321	5	the	the	DT
18637	2321	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2321	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	2321	8	that	that	IN
18637	2321	9	oil	oil	NN
18637	2321	10	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	2321	11	from	from	IN
18637	2321	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2321	13	and	and	CC
18637	2321	14	held	hold	VBN
18637	2321	15	in	in	IN
18637	2321	16	tanks	tank	NNS
18637	2321	17	in	in	IN
18637	2321	18	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	2321	19	,	,	,
18637	2321	20	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	2321	21	for	for	IN
18637	2321	22	separation	separation	NN
18637	2321	23	,	,	,
18637	2321	24	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	2321	25	and	and	CC
18637	2321	26	reshipment	reshipment	NN
18637	2321	27	,	,	,
18637	2321	28	was	be	VBD
18637	2321	29	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2321	30	to	to	IN
18637	2321	31	the	the	DT
18637	2321	32	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2321	33	power	power	NN
18637	2321	34	of	of	IN
18637	2321	35	the	the	DT
18637	2321	36	latter	latter	JJ
18637	2321	37	State	State	NNP
18637	2321	38	.	.	.
18637	2322	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2322	2	573	573	CD
18637	2322	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2322	4	The	the	DT
18637	2322	5	delay	delay	NN
18637	2322	6	in	in	IN
18637	2322	7	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2322	8	resulting	result	VBG
18637	2322	9	from	from	IN
18637	2322	10	these	these	DT
18637	2322	11	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	2322	12	on	on	IN
18637	2322	13	the	the	DT
18637	2322	14	part	part	NN
18637	2322	15	of	of	IN
18637	2322	16	the	the	DT
18637	2322	17	owners	owner	NNS
18637	2322	18	,	,	,
18637	2322	19	the	the	DT
18637	2322	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2322	21	pointed	point	VBD
18637	2322	22	out	out	RP
18637	2322	23	,	,	,
18637	2322	24	was	be	VBD
18637	2322	25	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	2322	26	designed	design	VBN
18637	2322	27	for	for	IN
18637	2322	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2322	29	own	own	JJ
18637	2322	30	profit	profit	NN
18637	2322	31	and	and	CC
18637	2322	32	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	2322	33	and	and	CC
18637	2322	34	was	be	VBD
18637	2322	35	not	not	RB
18637	2322	36	a	a	DT
18637	2322	37	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2322	38	incident	incident	NN
18637	2322	39	to	to	IN
18637	2322	40	the	the	DT
18637	2322	41	method	method	NN
18637	2322	42	of	of	IN
18637	2322	43	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2322	44	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	2322	45	,	,	,
18637	2322	46	as	as	IN
18637	2322	47	had	have	VBD
18637	2322	48	been	be	VBN
18637	2322	49	the	the	DT
18637	2322	50	delay	delay	NN
18637	2322	51	of	of	IN
18637	2322	52	the	the	DT
18637	2322	53	logs	log	NNS
18637	2322	54	coming	come	VBG
18637	2322	55	from	from	IN
18637	2322	56	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	2322	57	in	in	IN
18637	2322	58	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	2322	59	_	_	NNP
18637	2322	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	2322	61	_	_	NNP
18637	2322	62	Errol	Errol	NNP
18637	2322	63	.	.	.
18637	2323	1	The	the	DT
18637	2323	2	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	2323	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	2323	4	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	2323	5	.	.	.
18637	2324	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2324	2	574	574	CD
18637	2324	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2324	4	Applying	apply	VBG
18637	2324	5	this	this	DT
18637	2324	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	2324	7	in	in	IN
18637	2324	8	more	more	JJR
18637	2324	9	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2324	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	2324	11	,	,	,
18637	2324	12	the	the	DT
18637	2324	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2324	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	2324	15	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	2324	16	State	state	NN
18637	2324	17	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2324	18	:	:	:
18637	2324	19	on	on	IN
18637	2324	20	the	the	DT
18637	2324	21	use	use	NN
18637	2324	22	and	and	CC
18637	2324	23	storage	storage	NN
18637	2324	24	of	of	IN
18637	2324	25	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	2324	26	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2324	27	into	into	IN
18637	2324	28	the	the	DT
18637	2324	29	State	state	NN
18637	2324	30	by	by	IN
18637	2324	31	a	a	DT
18637	2324	32	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2324	33	company	company	NN
18637	2324	34	and	and	CC
18637	2324	35	unloaded	unloaded	JJ
18637	2324	36	and	and	CC
18637	2324	37	stored	store	VBN
18637	2324	38	there	there	RB
18637	2324	39	,	,	,
18637	2324	40	to	to	TO
18637	2324	41	be	be	VB
18637	2324	42	used	use	VBN
18637	2324	43	for	for	IN
18637	2324	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2324	45	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2324	46	trains;[575	trains;[575	CD
18637	2324	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2324	48	on	on	IN
18637	2324	49	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	2324	50	imported	import	VBN
18637	2324	51	and	and	CC
18637	2324	52	stored	store	VBN
18637	2324	53	by	by	IN
18637	2324	54	an	an	DT
18637	2324	55	airplane	airplane	NN
18637	2324	56	company	company	NN
18637	2324	57	and	and	CC
18637	2324	58	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	2324	59	to	to	TO
18637	2324	60	fill	fill	VB
18637	2324	61	airplanes	airplane	NNS
18637	2324	62	that	that	WDT
18637	2324	63	use	use	VBP
18637	2324	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2324	65	in	in	IN
18637	2324	66	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2324	67	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2324	68	travel;[576	travel;[576	NNS
18637	2324	69	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2324	70	on	on	IN
18637	2324	71	supplies	supply	NNS
18637	2324	72	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2324	73	into	into	IN
18637	2324	74	the	the	DT
18637	2324	75	State	State	NNP
18637	2324	76	by	by	IN
18637	2324	77	an	an	DT
18637	2324	78	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2324	79	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2324	80	company	company	NN
18637	2324	81	to	to	TO
18637	2324	82	be	be	VB
18637	2324	83	used	use	VBN
18637	2324	84	in	in	IN
18637	2324	85	replacements	replacement	NNS
18637	2324	86	,	,	,
18637	2324	87	repairs	repair	NNS
18637	2324	88	and	and	CC
18637	2324	89	extensions	extension	NNS
18637	2324	90	,	,	,
18637	2324	91	and	and	CC
18637	2324	92	installed	instal	VBD
18637	2324	93	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	2324	94	upon	upon	IN
18637	2324	95	arrival	arrival	NN
18637	2324	96	in	in	IN
18637	2324	97	the	the	DT
18637	2324	98	taxing	taxing	NN
18637	2324	99	State;[577	state;[577	NN
18637	2324	100	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2324	101	on	on	IN
18637	2324	102	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	2324	103	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2324	104	into	into	IN
18637	2324	105	the	the	DT
18637	2324	106	State	state	NN
18637	2324	107	by	by	IN
18637	2324	108	a	a	DT
18637	2324	109	telephone	telephone	NN
18637	2324	110	and	and	CC
18637	2324	111	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	2324	112	company	company	NN
18637	2324	113	for	for	IN
18637	2324	114	operation	operation	NN
18637	2324	115	,	,	,
18637	2324	116	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	2324	117	,	,	,
18637	2324	118	and	and	CC
18637	2324	119	repair	repair	NN
18637	2324	120	of	of	IN
18637	2324	121	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2324	122	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2324	123	system	system	NN
18637	2324	124	.	.	.
18637	2325	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2325	2	578	578	CD
18637	2325	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2325	4	In	in	IN
18637	2325	5	all	all	PDT
18637	2325	6	these	these	DT
18637	2325	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	2325	8	the	the	DT
18637	2325	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2325	10	applied	apply	VBD
18637	2325	11	the	the	DT
18637	2325	12	principle	principle	NN
18637	2325	13	that	that	IN
18637	2325	14	"	"	``
18637	2325	15	use	use	NN
18637	2325	16	and	and	CC
18637	2325	17	storage	storage	NN
18637	2325	18	"	"	''
18637	2325	19	are	be	VBP
18637	2325	20	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2325	21	to	to	IN
18637	2325	22	local	local	JJ
18637	2325	23	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2325	24	when	when	WRB
18637	2325	25	"	"	``
18637	2325	26	there	there	EX
18637	2325	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	2325	28	an	an	DT
18637	2325	29	interval	interval	NN
18637	2325	30	after	after	IN
18637	2325	31	the	the	DT
18637	2325	32	articles	article	NNS
18637	2325	33	have	have	VBP
18637	2325	34	reached	reach	VBN
18637	2325	35	the	the	DT
18637	2325	36	end	end	NN
18637	2325	37	of	of	IN
18637	2325	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2325	39	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2325	40	movement	movement	NN
18637	2325	41	and	and	CC
18637	2325	42	before	before	IN
18637	2325	43	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2325	44	consumption	consumption	NN
18637	2325	45	in	in	IN
18637	2325	46	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2325	47	operation	operation	NN
18637	2325	48	has	have	VBZ
18637	2325	49	begun	begin	VBN
18637	2325	50	.	.	.
18637	2326	1	"	"	``
18637	2326	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2326	3	579	579	CD
18637	2326	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2326	5	On	on	IN
18637	2326	6	the	the	DT
18637	2326	7	other	other	JJ
18637	2326	8	hand	hand	NN
18637	2326	9	,	,	,
18637	2326	10	in	in	IN
18637	2326	11	the	the	DT
18637	2326	12	absence	absence	NN
18637	2326	13	of	of	IN
18637	2326	14	such	such	PDT
18637	2326	15	an	an	DT
18637	2326	16	"	"	``
18637	2326	17	interval	interval	NN
18637	2326	18	,	,	,
18637	2326	19	"	"	''
18637	2326	20	the	the	DT
18637	2326	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2326	22	declared	declare	VBD
18637	2326	23	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	2326	24	State	State	NNP
18637	2326	25	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	2326	26	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2326	27	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2326	28	per	per	IN
18637	2326	29	gallon	gallon	NN
18637	2326	30	of	of	IN
18637	2326	31	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	2326	32	imported	import	VBN
18637	2326	33	by	by	IN
18637	2326	34	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2326	35	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	2326	36	as	as	IN
18637	2326	37	fuel	fuel	NN
18637	2326	38	for	for	IN
18637	2326	39	use	use	NN
18637	2326	40	in	in	IN
18637	2326	41	such	such	JJ
18637	2326	42	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2326	43	,	,	,
18637	2326	44	and	and	CC
18637	2326	45	used	use	VBN
18637	2326	46	within	within	IN
18637	2326	47	the	the	DT
18637	2326	48	State	State	NNP
18637	2326	49	as	as	RB
18637	2326	50	well	well	RB
18637	2326	51	as	as	IN
18637	2326	52	in	in	IN
18637	2326	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2326	54	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2326	55	travel	travel	NN
18637	2326	56	.	.	.
18637	2327	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2327	2	580	580	CD
18637	2327	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2327	4	THE	the	DT
18637	2327	5	DRUMMER	drummer	NN
18637	2327	6	CASES	case	NNS
18637	2327	7	;	;	:
18637	2327	8	ROBBINS	ROBBINS	NNP
18637	2327	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2327	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	2327	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2327	12	SHELBY	SHELBY	NNP
18637	2327	13	COUNTY	COUNTY	NNP
18637	2327	14	TAXING	tax	VBG
18637	2327	15	DISTRICT	DISTRICT	NNS
18637	2327	16	But	but	CC
18637	2327	17	there	there	EX
18637	2327	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	2327	19	one	one	CD
18637	2327	20	situation	situation	NN
18637	2327	21	in	in	IN
18637	2327	22	which	which	WDT
18637	2327	23	goods	good	NNS
18637	2327	24	introduced	introduce	VBN
18637	2327	25	into	into	IN
18637	2327	26	one	one	CD
18637	2327	27	State	state	NN
18637	2327	28	from	from	IN
18637	2327	29	another	another	DT
18637	2327	30	have	have	NN
18637	2327	31	until	until	IN
18637	2327	32	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2327	33	years	year	NNS
18637	2327	34	enjoyed	enjoy	VBD
18637	2327	35	a	a	DT
18637	2327	36	special	special	JJ
18637	2327	37	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	2327	38	from	from	IN
18637	2327	39	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2327	40	by	by	IN
18637	2327	41	the	the	DT
18637	2327	42	former	former	JJ
18637	2327	43	,	,	,
18637	2327	44	and	and	CC
18637	2327	45	that	that	DT
18637	2327	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	2327	47	when	when	WRB
18637	2327	48	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2327	49	were	be	VBD
18637	2327	50	introduced	introduce	VBN
18637	2327	51	in	in	IN
18637	2327	52	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	2327	53	of	of	IN
18637	2327	54	a	a	DT
18637	2327	55	contract	contract	NN
18637	2327	56	of	of	IN
18637	2327	57	sale	sale	NN
18637	2327	58	.	.	.
18637	2328	1	The	the	DT
18637	2328	2	leading	leading	JJ
18637	2328	3	case	case	NN
18637	2328	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	2328	5	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	2328	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2328	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	2328	8	_	_	NNP
18637	2328	9	Shelby	Shelby	NNP
18637	2328	10	County	County	NNP
18637	2328	11	Taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2328	12	District,[581	District,[581	NNP
18637	2328	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2328	14	in	in	IN
18637	2328	15	which	which	WDT
18637	2328	16	the	the	DT
18637	2328	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2328	18	,	,	,
18637	2328	19	after	after	IN
18637	2328	20	a	a	DT
18637	2328	21	penetrating	penetrating	NN
18637	2328	22	survey	survey	NN
18637	2328	23	of	of	IN
18637	2328	24	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	2328	25	practices	practice	NNS
18637	2328	26	,	,	,
18637	2328	27	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	2328	28	that	that	IN
18637	2328	29	"	"	``
18637	2328	30	the	the	DT
18637	2328	31	negotiation	negotiation	NN
18637	2328	32	of	of	IN
18637	2328	33	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2328	34	of	of	IN
18637	2328	35	goods"--in	goods"--in	NNP
18637	2328	36	this	this	DT
18637	2328	37	instance	instance	NN
18637	2328	38	by	by	RB
18637	2328	39	sample--"which	sample--"which	XX
18637	2328	40	are	be	VBP
18637	2328	41	in	in	IN
18637	2328	42	another	another	DT
18637	2328	43	State	State	NNP
18637	2328	44	,	,	,
18637	2328	45	for	for	IN
18637	2328	46	the	the	DT
18637	2328	47	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2328	48	of	of	IN
18637	2328	49	introducing	introduce	VBG
18637	2328	50	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2328	51	into	into	IN
18637	2328	52	the	the	DT
18637	2328	53	State	State	NNP
18637	2328	54	in	in	IN
18637	2328	55	which	which	WDT
18637	2328	56	the	the	DT
18637	2328	57	negotiation	negotiation	NN
18637	2328	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	2328	59	made	make	VBN
18637	2328	60	,	,	,
18637	2328	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	2328	62	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2328	63	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2328	64	.	.	.
18637	2328	65	"	"	''
18637	2329	1	In	in	IN
18637	2329	2	short	short	JJ
18637	2329	3	,	,	,
18637	2329	4	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	2329	5	in	in	IN
18637	2329	6	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2329	7	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2329	8	,	,	,
18637	2329	9	importation	importation	NN
18637	2329	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	2329	11	succeeded	succeed	VBN
18637	2329	12	by	by	IN
18637	2329	13	the	the	DT
18637	2329	14	right	right	NN
18637	2329	15	to	to	TO
18637	2329	16	sell	sell	VB
18637	2329	17	in	in	IN
18637	2329	18	the	the	DT
18637	2329	19	original	original	JJ
18637	2329	20	package	package	NN
18637	2329	21	,	,	,
18637	2329	22	in	in	IN
18637	2329	23	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2329	24	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2329	25	sale	sale	NN
18637	2329	26	was	be	VBD
18637	2329	27	succeeded	succeed	VBN
18637	2329	28	by	by	IN
18637	2329	29	the	the	DT
18637	2329	30	right	right	NN
18637	2329	31	of	of	IN
18637	2329	32	importation	importation	NN
18637	2329	33	,	,	,
18637	2329	34	which	which	WDT
18637	2329	35	continued	continue	VBD
18637	2329	36	until	until	IN
18637	2329	37	the	the	DT
18637	2329	38	goods	good	NNS
18637	2329	39	reached	reach	VBD
18637	2329	40	the	the	DT
18637	2329	41	hands	hand	NNS
18637	2329	42	of	of	IN
18637	2329	43	the	the	DT
18637	2329	44	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	2329	45	.	.	.
18637	2330	1	The	the	DT
18637	2330	2	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	2330	3	of	of	IN
18637	2330	4	this	this	DT
18637	2330	5	holding	holding	NN
18637	2330	6	were	be	VBD
18637	2330	7	extended	extend	VBN
18637	2330	8	in	in	IN
18637	2330	9	a	a	DT
18637	2330	10	series	series	NN
18637	2330	11	of	of	IN
18637	2330	12	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	2330	13	in	in	IN
18637	2330	14	which	which	WDT
18637	2330	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2330	16	was	be	VBD
18637	2330	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	2330	18	to	to	TO
18637	2330	19	apply	apply	VB
18637	2330	20	whether	whether	IN
18637	2330	21	solicitation	solicitation	NN
18637	2330	22	of	of	IN
18637	2330	23	orders	order	NNS
18637	2330	24	was	be	VBD
18637	2330	25	or	or	CC
18637	2330	26	was	be	VBD
18637	2330	27	not	not	RB
18637	2330	28	made	make	VBN
18637	2330	29	with	with	IN
18637	2330	30	sample,[582	sample,[582	NN
18637	2330	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2330	32	and	and	CC
18637	2330	33	to	to	IN
18637	2330	34	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2330	35	which	which	WDT
18637	2330	36	were	be	VBD
18637	2330	37	not	not	RB
18637	2330	38	,	,	,
18637	2330	39	accurately	accurately	RB
18637	2330	40	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2330	41	,	,	,
18637	2330	42	consummated	consummate	VBN
18637	2330	43	until	until	IN
18637	2330	44	the	the	DT
18637	2330	45	actual	actual	JJ
18637	2330	46	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	2330	47	of	of	IN
18637	2330	48	the	the	DT
18637	2330	49	goods	good	NNS
18637	2330	50	,	,	,
18637	2330	51	which	which	WDT
18637	2330	52	was	be	VBD
18637	2330	53	attended	attend	VBN
18637	2330	54	by	by	IN
18637	2330	55	local	local	JJ
18637	2330	56	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	2330	57	.	.	.
18637	2331	1	So	so	CC
18637	2331	2	,	,	,
18637	2331	3	where	where	WRB
18637	2331	4	a	a	DT
18637	2331	5	North	North	NNP
18637	2331	6	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	2331	7	agent	agent	NN
18637	2331	8	of	of	IN
18637	2331	9	a	a	DT
18637	2331	10	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	2331	11	firm	firm	NN
18637	2331	12	took	take	VBD
18637	2331	13	orders	order	NNS
18637	2331	14	for	for	IN
18637	2331	15	framed	framed	JJ
18637	2331	16	pictures	picture	NNS
18637	2331	17	,	,	,
18637	2331	18	which	which	WDT
18637	2331	19	were	be	VBD
18637	2331	20	then	then	RB
18637	2331	21	sent	send	VBN
18637	2331	22	to	to	IN
18637	2331	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2331	24	packed	pack	VBN
18637	2331	25	separately	separately	RB
18637	2331	26	from	from	IN
18637	2331	27	the	the	DT
18637	2331	28	frames	frame	NNS
18637	2331	29	and	and	CC
18637	2331	30	then	then	RB
18637	2331	31	framed	frame	VBN
18637	2331	32	by	by	IN
18637	2331	33	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2331	34	before	before	IN
18637	2331	35	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	2331	36	,	,	,
18637	2331	37	the	the	DT
18637	2331	38	rule	rule	NN
18637	2331	39	laid	lay	VBD
18637	2331	40	down	down	RP
18637	2331	41	in	in	IN
18637	2331	42	the	the	DT
18637	2331	43	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	2331	44	case	case	NN
18637	2331	45	was	be	VBD
18637	2331	46	held	hold	VBN
18637	2331	47	to	to	TO
18637	2331	48	apply	apply	VB
18637	2331	49	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	2331	50	,	,	,
18637	2331	51	with	with	IN
18637	2331	52	the	the	DT
18637	2331	53	result	result	NN
18637	2331	54	that	that	IN
18637	2331	55	North	North	NNP
18637	2331	56	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	2331	57	could	could	MD
18637	2331	58	tax	tax	VB
18637	2331	59	or	or	CC
18637	2331	60	license	license	VB
18637	2331	61	no	no	DT
18637	2331	62	part	part	NN
18637	2331	63	of	of	IN
18637	2331	64	the	the	DT
18637	2331	65	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	2331	66	described;[583	described;[583	''
18637	2331	67	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2331	68	so	so	RB
18637	2331	69	also	also	RB
18637	2331	70	as	as	IN
18637	2331	71	to	to	IN
18637	2331	72	a	a	DT
18637	2331	73	sewing	sewing	NN
18637	2331	74	machine	machine	NN
18637	2331	75	ordered	order	VBN
18637	2331	76	by	by	IN
18637	2331	77	a	a	DT
18637	2331	78	customer	customer	NN
18637	2331	79	in	in	IN
18637	2331	80	North	North	NNP
18637	2331	81	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	2331	82	and	and	CC
18637	2331	83	sent	send	VBN
18637	2331	84	to	to	IN
18637	2331	85	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2331	86	C.O.D.	C.O.D.	NNP
18637	2332	1	;	;	:
18637	2332	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2332	3	584	584	CD
18637	2332	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2332	5	so	so	RB
18637	2332	6	also	also	RB
18637	2332	7	as	as	IN
18637	2332	8	to	to	IN
18637	2332	9	brooms	broom	NNS
18637	2332	10	sent	send	VBN
18637	2332	11	in	in	IN
18637	2332	12	quantity	quantity	NN
18637	2332	13	for	for	IN
18637	2332	14	the	the	DT
18637	2332	15	fulfillment	fulfillment	NN
18637	2332	16	of	of	IN
18637	2332	17	a	a	DT
18637	2332	18	number	number	NN
18637	2332	19	of	of	IN
18637	2332	20	orders	order	NNS
18637	2332	21	,	,	,
18637	2332	22	and	and	CC
18637	2332	23	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2332	24	to	to	IN
18637	2332	25	rejection	rejection	NN
18637	2332	26	by	by	IN
18637	2332	27	the	the	DT
18637	2332	28	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	2332	29	if	if	IN
18637	2332	30	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	2332	31	by	by	IN
18637	2332	32	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2332	33	not	not	RB
18637	2332	34	up	up	RB
18637	2332	35	to	to	TO
18637	2332	36	sample	sample	VB
18637	2332	37	.	.	.
18637	2333	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2333	2	585	585	CD
18637	2333	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2333	4	Said	Said	NNP
18637	2333	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2333	6	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	2333	7	in	in	IN
18637	2333	8	the	the	DT
18637	2333	9	case	case	NN
18637	2333	10	last	last	RB
18637	2333	11	referred	refer	VBD
18637	2333	12	to	to	IN
18637	2333	13	:	:	:
18637	2333	14	"	"	``
18637	2333	15	'	'	``
18637	2333	16	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2333	17	among	among	IN
18637	2333	18	the	the	DT
18637	2333	19	States	States	NNP
18637	2333	20	'	'	POS
18637	2333	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	2333	22	a	a	DT
18637	2333	23	practical	practical	JJ
18637	2333	24	conception	conception	NN
18637	2333	25	not	not	RB
18637	2333	26	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	2333	27	from	from	IN
18637	2333	28	the	the	DT
18637	2333	29	'	'	``
18637	2333	30	witty	witty	JJ
18637	2333	31	diversities	diversity	NNS
18637	2333	32	'	'	POS
18637	2333	33	*	*	NFP
18637	2333	34	*	*	NFP
18637	2333	35	*	*	NFP
18637	2333	36	of	of	IN
18637	2333	37	the	the	DT
18637	2333	38	law	law	NN
18637	2333	39	of	of	IN
18637	2333	40	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2333	41	.	.	.
18637	2334	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2334	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2334	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2334	4	The	the	DT
18637	2334	5	brooms	broom	NNS
18637	2334	6	were	be	VBD
18637	2334	7	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	2334	8	appropriated	appropriate	VBN
18637	2334	9	to	to	IN
18637	2334	10	specific	specific	JJ
18637	2334	11	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	2334	12	,	,	,
18637	2334	13	in	in	IN
18637	2334	14	a	a	DT
18637	2334	15	practical	practical	JJ
18637	2334	16	,	,	,
18637	2334	17	if	if	IN
18637	2334	18	not	not	RB
18637	2334	19	in	in	IN
18637	2334	20	a	a	DT
18637	2334	21	technical	technical	JJ
18637	2334	22	,	,	,
18637	2334	23	sense	sense	NN
18637	2334	24	.	.	.
18637	2335	1	Under	under	IN
18637	2335	2	such	such	JJ
18637	2335	3	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	2335	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2335	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	2335	6	plain	plain	JJ
18637	2335	7	that	that	IN
18637	2335	8	,	,	,
18637	2335	9	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	2335	10	might	may	MD
18637	2335	11	have	have	VB
18637	2335	12	been	be	VBN
18637	2335	13	the	the	DT
18637	2335	14	title	title	NN
18637	2335	15	,	,	,
18637	2335	16	the	the	DT
18637	2335	17	transport	transport	NN
18637	2335	18	of	of	IN
18637	2335	19	the	the	DT
18637	2335	20	brooms	broom	NNS
18637	2335	21	for	for	IN
18637	2335	22	the	the	DT
18637	2335	23	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2335	24	of	of	IN
18637	2335	25	fulfilling	fulfil	VBG
18637	2335	26	the	the	DT
18637	2335	27	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	2335	28	was	be	VBD
18637	2335	29	protected	protect	VBN
18637	2335	30	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2335	31	.	.	.
18637	2336	1	"	"	``
18637	2336	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2336	3	586	586	CD
18637	2336	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2336	5	Nor	nor	CC
18637	2336	6	did	do	VBD
18637	2336	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2336	8	make	make	VB
18637	2336	9	any	any	DT
18637	2336	10	difference	difference	NN
18637	2336	11	that	that	WDT
18637	2336	12	the	the	DT
18637	2336	13	solicitor	solicitor	NN
18637	2336	14	received	receive	VBD
18637	2336	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2336	16	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	2336	17	in	in	IN
18637	2336	18	form	form	NN
18637	2336	19	of	of	IN
18637	2336	20	down	down	JJ
18637	2336	21	payment	payment	NN
18637	2336	22	by	by	IN
18637	2336	23	the	the	DT
18637	2336	24	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	2336	25	.	.	.
18637	2337	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2337	2	587	587	CD
18637	2337	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2337	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	2337	5	,	,	,
18637	2337	6	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2337	7	under	under	IN
18637	2337	8	a	a	DT
18637	2337	9	mail	mail	NN
18637	2337	10	order	order	NN
18637	2337	11	business	business	NN
18637	2337	12	,	,	,
18637	2337	13	with	with	IN
18637	2337	14	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	2337	15	taking	take	VBG
18637	2337	16	place	place	NN
18637	2337	17	within	within	IN
18637	2337	18	the	the	DT
18637	2337	19	State	State	NNP
18637	2337	20	to	to	IN
18637	2337	21	a	a	DT
18637	2337	22	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2337	23	for	for	IN
18637	2337	24	through	through	IN
18637	2337	25	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2337	26	to	to	IN
18637	2337	27	another	another	DT
18637	2337	28	State	state	NN
18637	2337	29	to	to	TO
18637	2337	30	fill	fill	VB
18637	2337	31	orders	order	NNS
18637	2337	32	,	,	,
18637	2337	33	was	be	VBD
18637	2337	34	held	hold	VBN
18637	2337	35	to	to	TO
18637	2337	36	be	be	VB
18637	2337	37	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	2337	38	the	the	DT
18637	2337	39	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2337	40	power	power	NN
18637	2337	41	of	of	IN
18637	2337	42	the	the	DT
18637	2337	43	first	first	JJ
18637	2337	44	State	State	NNP
18637	2337	45	.	.	.
18637	2338	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2338	2	588	588	CD
18637	2338	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2338	4	The	the	DT
18637	2338	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	2338	6	that	that	IN
18637	2338	7	a	a	DT
18637	2338	8	concern	concern	NN
18637	2338	9	doing	do	VBG
18637	2338	10	a	a	DT
18637	2338	11	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	2338	12	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2338	13	business	business	NN
18637	2338	14	had	have	VBD
18637	2338	15	goods	good	NNS
18637	2338	16	on	on	IN
18637	2338	17	hand	hand	NN
18637	2338	18	within	within	IN
18637	2338	19	the	the	DT
18637	2338	20	State	State	NNP
18637	2338	21	which	which	WDT
18637	2338	22	were	be	VBD
18637	2338	23	capable	capable	JJ
18637	2338	24	of	of	IN
18637	2338	25	being	be	VBG
18637	2338	26	used	use	VBN
18637	2338	27	in	in	IN
18637	2338	28	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2338	29	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2338	30	,	,	,
18637	2338	31	did	do	VBD
18637	2338	32	not	not	RB
18637	2338	33	,	,	,
18637	2338	34	the	the	DT
18637	2338	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2338	36	declared	declare	VBD
18637	2338	37	,	,	,
18637	2338	38	take	take	VB
18637	2338	39	the	the	DT
18637	2338	40	business	business	NN
18637	2338	41	out	out	IN
18637	2338	42	of	of	IN
18637	2338	43	the	the	DT
18637	2338	44	protection	protection	NN
18637	2338	45	of	of	IN
18637	2338	46	the	the	DT
18637	2338	47	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2338	48	clause	clause	NNP
18637	2338	49	and	and	CC
18637	2338	50	allow	allow	VB
18637	2338	51	the	the	DT
18637	2338	52	State	State	NNP
18637	2338	53	to	to	TO
18637	2338	54	impose	impose	VB
18637	2338	55	a	a	DT
18637	2338	56	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2338	57	tax	tax	NN
18637	2338	58	on	on	IN
18637	2338	59	such	such	JJ
18637	2338	60	concern	concern	NN
18637	2338	61	.	.	.
18637	2339	1	LIMITATION	limitation	NN
18637	2339	2	OF	of	IN
18637	2339	3	THE	the	DT
18637	2339	4	ROBBINS	robbin	NNS
18637	2339	5	CASE	case	NN
18637	2339	6	On	on	IN
18637	2339	7	the	the	DT
18637	2339	8	other	other	JJ
18637	2339	9	hand	hand	NN
18637	2339	10	,	,	,
18637	2339	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2339	12	was	be	VBD
18637	2339	13	early	early	RB
18637	2339	14	held	hold	VBN
18637	2339	15	that	that	IN
18637	2339	16	the	the	DT
18637	2339	17	rule	rule	NN
18637	2339	18	laid	lay	VBD
18637	2339	19	down	down	RP
18637	2339	20	in	in	IN
18637	2339	21	the	the	DT
18637	2339	22	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	2339	23	case	case	NN
18637	2339	24	did	do	VBD
18637	2339	25	not	not	RB
18637	2339	26	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2339	27	a	a	DT
18637	2339	28	State	state	NN
18637	2339	29	from	from	IN
18637	2339	30	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2339	31	a	a	DT
18637	2339	32	resident	resident	JJ
18637	2339	33	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2339	34	who	who	WP
18637	2339	35	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	2339	36	in	in	IN
18637	2339	37	a	a	DT
18637	2339	38	general	general	JJ
18637	2339	39	commission	commission	NN
18637	2339	40	business	business	NN
18637	2339	41	,	,	,
18637	2339	42	on	on	IN
18637	2339	43	the	the	DT
18637	2339	44	profits	profit	NNS
18637	2339	45	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	2339	46	,	,	,
18637	2339	47	although	although	IN
18637	2339	48	the	the	DT
18637	2339	49	business	business	NN
18637	2339	50	consisted	consist	VBD
18637	2339	51	"	"	''
18637	2339	52	for	for	IN
18637	2339	53	the	the	DT
18637	2339	54	time	time	NN
18637	2339	55	being	being	NN
18637	2339	56	,	,	,
18637	2339	57	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	2339	58	or	or	CC
18637	2339	59	partially	partially	RB
18637	2339	60	in	in	IN
18637	2339	61	negotiating	negotiate	VBG
18637	2339	62	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2339	63	between	between	IN
18637	2339	64	resident	resident	NN
18637	2339	65	and	and	CC
18637	2339	66	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	2339	67	merchants	merchant	NNS
18637	2339	68	,	,	,
18637	2339	69	of	of	IN
18637	2339	70	goods	good	NNS
18637	2339	71	situated	situate	VBN
18637	2339	72	in	in	IN
18637	2339	73	another	another	DT
18637	2339	74	State	state	NN
18637	2339	75	.	.	.
18637	2340	1	"	"	``
18637	2340	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2340	3	589	589	CD
18637	2340	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2340	5	Also	also	RB
18637	2340	6	,	,	,
18637	2340	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2340	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	2340	9	been	be	VBN
18637	2340	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	2340	11	that	that	IN
18637	2340	12	a	a	DT
18637	2340	13	stamp	stamp	NN
18637	2340	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	2340	15	on	on	IN
18637	2340	16	transfers	transfer	NNS
18637	2340	17	of	of	IN
18637	2340	18	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	2340	19	stock	stock	NN
18637	2340	20	,	,	,
18637	2340	21	as	as	IN
18637	2340	22	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2340	23	to	to	IN
18637	2340	24	a	a	DT
18637	2340	25	sale	sale	NN
18637	2340	26	between	between	IN
18637	2340	27	two	two	CD
18637	2340	28	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	2340	29	,	,	,
18637	2340	30	of	of	IN
18637	2340	31	the	the	DT
18637	2340	32	stock	stock	NN
18637	2340	33	of	of	IN
18637	2340	34	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2340	35	railway	railway	NN
18637	2340	36	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2340	37	,	,	,
18637	2340	38	was	be	VBD
18637	2340	39	not	not	RB
18637	2340	40	an	an	DT
18637	2340	41	interference	interference	NN
18637	2340	42	with	with	IN
18637	2340	43	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2340	44	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2340	45	.	.	.
18637	2341	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2341	2	590	590	CD
18637	2341	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2341	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	2341	5	,	,	,
18637	2341	6	the	the	DT
18637	2341	7	business	business	NN
18637	2341	8	of	of	IN
18637	2341	9	taking	take	VBG
18637	2341	10	orders	order	NNS
18637	2341	11	on	on	IN
18637	2341	12	commission	commission	NN
18637	2341	13	for	for	IN
18637	2341	14	the	the	DT
18637	2341	15	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	2341	16	and	and	CC
18637	2341	17	sale	sale	NN
18637	2341	18	of	of	IN
18637	2341	19	grain	grain	NN
18637	2341	20	and	and	CC
18637	2341	21	cotton	cotton	NN
18637	2341	22	for	for	IN
18637	2341	23	future	future	JJ
18637	2341	24	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	2341	25	not	not	RB
18637	2341	26	necessitating	necessitate	VBG
18637	2341	27	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2341	28	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2341	29	was	be	VBD
18637	2341	30	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	2341	31	not	not	RB
18637	2341	32	to	to	TO
18637	2341	33	be	be	VB
18637	2341	34	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2341	35	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2341	36	,	,	,
18637	2341	37	and	and	CC
18637	2341	38	as	as	IN
18637	2341	39	such	such	JJ
18637	2341	40	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	2341	41	from	from	IN
18637	2341	42	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2341	43	,	,	,
18637	2341	44	although	although	IN
18637	2341	45	deliveries	delivery	NNS
18637	2341	46	were	be	VBD
18637	2341	47	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	2341	48	made	make	VBN
18637	2341	49	by	by	IN
18637	2341	50	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2341	51	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2341	52	.	.	.
18637	2342	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2342	2	591	591	CD
18637	2342	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2342	4	And	and	CC
18637	2342	5	in	in	IN
18637	2342	6	Banker	Banker	NNP
18637	2342	7	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	2342	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2342	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2342	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	2342	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2342	12	Pennsylvania[592	Pennsylvania[592	NNP
18637	2342	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2342	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2342	15	was	be	VBD
18637	2342	16	held	hold	VBN
18637	2342	17	that	that	IN
18637	2342	18	a	a	DT
18637	2342	19	tax	tax	NN
18637	2342	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	2342	21	a	a	DT
18637	2342	22	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	2342	23	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2342	24	selling	sell	VBG
18637	2342	25	automobiles	automobile	NNS
18637	2342	26	built	build	VBN
18637	2342	27	by	by	IN
18637	2342	28	a	a	DT
18637	2342	29	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2342	30	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2342	31	under	under	IN
18637	2342	32	an	an	DT
18637	2342	33	arrangement	arrangement	NN
18637	2342	34	by	by	IN
18637	2342	35	which	which	WDT
18637	2342	36	the	the	DT
18637	2342	37	latter	latter	NN
18637	2342	38	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	2342	39	to	to	TO
18637	2342	40	build	build	VB
18637	2342	41	for	for	IN
18637	2342	42	and	and	CC
18637	2342	43	sell	sell	VB
18637	2342	44	to	to	IN
18637	2342	45	the	the	DT
18637	2342	46	former	former	JJ
18637	2342	47	,	,	,
18637	2342	48	for	for	IN
18637	2342	49	cash	cash	NN
18637	2342	50	,	,	,
18637	2342	51	at	at	IN
18637	2342	52	a	a	DT
18637	2342	53	specified	specify	VBN
18637	2342	54	price	price	NN
18637	2342	55	less	less	JJR
18637	2342	56	than	than	IN
18637	2342	57	list	list	NN
18637	2342	58	price	price	NN
18637	2342	59	,	,	,
18637	2342	60	was	be	VBD
18637	2342	61	not	not	RB
18637	2342	62	a	a	DT
18637	2342	63	tax	tax	NN
18637	2342	64	on	on	IN
18637	2342	65	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2342	66	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	2342	67	,	,	,
18637	2342	68	there	there	EX
18637	2342	69	being	be	VBG
18637	2342	70	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	2342	71	which	which	WDT
18637	2342	72	connected	connect	VBD
18637	2342	73	the	the	DT
18637	2342	74	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	2342	75	buyer	buyer	NN
18637	2342	76	with	with	IN
18637	2342	77	the	the	DT
18637	2342	78	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
18637	2342	79	but	but	CC
18637	2342	80	a	a	DT
18637	2342	81	warranty	warranty	NN
18637	2342	82	and	and	CC
18637	2342	83	the	the	DT
18637	2342	84	buyer	buyer	NN
18637	2342	85	's	's	POS
18637	2342	86	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	2342	87	to	to	TO
18637	2342	88	pay	pay	VB
18637	2342	89	the	the	DT
18637	2342	90	list	list	NN
18637	2342	91	price	price	NN
18637	2342	92	f.o.b	f.o.b	JJ
18637	2342	93	.	.	.
18637	2343	1	factory	factory	NN
18637	2343	2	.	.	.
18637	2344	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	2344	2	,	,	,
18637	2344	3	in	in	IN
18637	2344	4	Browning	Browning	NNP
18637	2344	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2344	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	2344	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2344	8	Waycross[593	Waycross[593	NNP
18637	2344	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2344	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2344	11	was	be	VBD
18637	2344	12	held	hold	VBN
18637	2344	13	that	that	IN
18637	2344	14	the	the	DT
18637	2344	15	business	business	NN
18637	2344	16	of	of	IN
18637	2344	17	erecting	erect	VBG
18637	2344	18	lightning	lightning	NN
18637	2344	19	rods	rod	NNS
18637	2344	20	within	within	IN
18637	2344	21	the	the	DT
18637	2344	22	limits	limit	NNS
18637	2344	23	of	of	IN
18637	2344	24	a	a	DT
18637	2344	25	town	town	NN
18637	2344	26	by	by	IN
18637	2344	27	the	the	DT
18637	2344	28	agent	agent	NN
18637	2344	29	of	of	IN
18637	2344	30	a	a	DT
18637	2344	31	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	2344	32	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
18637	2344	33	on	on	IN
18637	2344	34	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2344	35	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	2344	36	such	such	JJ
18637	2344	37	agent	agent	NN
18637	2344	38	had	have	VBD
18637	2344	39	solicited	solicit	VBN
18637	2344	40	orders	order	NNS
18637	2344	41	for	for	IN
18637	2344	42	the	the	DT
18637	2344	43	sale	sale	NN
18637	2344	44	of	of	IN
18637	2344	45	the	the	DT
18637	2344	46	rods	rod	NNS
18637	2344	47	,	,	,
18637	2344	48	and	and	CC
18637	2344	49	from	from	IN
18637	2344	50	whom	whom	WP
18637	2344	51	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2344	52	had	have	VBD
18637	2344	53	received	receive	VBN
18637	2344	54	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2344	55	when	when	WRB
18637	2344	56	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	2344	57	into	into	IN
18637	2344	58	the	the	DT
18637	2344	59	State	State	NNP
18637	2344	60	,	,	,
18637	2344	61	was	be	VBD
18637	2344	62	validly	validly	RB
18637	2344	63	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	2344	64	to	to	IN
18637	2344	65	a	a	DT
18637	2344	66	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	2344	67	license	license	NN
18637	2344	68	tax	tax	NN
18637	2344	69	.	.	.
18637	2345	1	"	"	``
18637	2345	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2345	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2345	4	not	not	RB
18637	2345	5	,	,	,
18637	2345	6	"	"	''
18637	2345	7	said	say	VBD
18637	2345	8	the	the	DT
18637	2345	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2345	10	,	,	,
18637	2345	11	"	"	''
18637	2345	12	within	within	IN
18637	2345	13	the	the	DT
18637	2345	14	power	power	NN
18637	2345	15	of	of	IN
18637	2345	16	the	the	DT
18637	2345	17	parties	party	NNS
18637	2345	18	by	by	IN
18637	2345	19	the	the	DT
18637	2345	20	form	form	NN
18637	2345	21	of	of	IN
18637	2345	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2345	23	contract	contract	NN
18637	2345	24	to	to	TO
18637	2345	25	convert	convert	VB
18637	2345	26	what	what	WP
18637	2345	27	was	be	VBD
18637	2345	28	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	2345	29	a	a	DT
18637	2345	30	local	local	JJ
18637	2345	31	business	business	NN
18637	2345	32	,	,	,
18637	2345	33	*	*	NFP
18637	2345	34	*	*	NFP
18637	2345	35	*	*	NFP
18637	2345	36	,	,	,
18637	2345	37	into	into	IN
18637	2345	38	an	an	DT
18637	2345	39	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2345	40	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2345	41	business	business	NN
18637	2345	42	*	*	NFP
18637	2345	43	*	*	NFP
18637	2345	44	*	*	NFP
18637	2345	45	"	"	''
18637	2345	46	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2345	47	594	594	CD
18637	2345	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2345	49	Also	also	RB
18637	2345	50	,	,	,
18637	2345	51	a	a	DT
18637	2345	52	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	2345	53	license	license	NN
18637	2345	54	tax	tax	NN
18637	2345	55	upon	upon	IN
18637	2345	56	persons	person	NNS
18637	2345	57	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2345	58	in	in	IN
18637	2345	59	the	the	DT
18637	2345	60	business	business	NN
18637	2345	61	of	of	IN
18637	2345	62	buying	buy	VBG
18637	2345	63	or	or	CC
18637	2345	64	selling	sell	VBG
18637	2345	65	cotton	cotton	NN
18637	2345	66	for	for	IN
18637	2345	67	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2345	68	was	be	VBD
18637	2345	69	found	find	VBN
18637	2345	70	not	not	RB
18637	2345	71	to	to	TO
18637	2345	72	impose	impose	VB
18637	2345	73	a	a	DT
18637	2345	74	forbidden	forbidden	JJ
18637	2345	75	burden	burden	NN
18637	2345	76	upon	upon	IN
18637	2345	77	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2345	78	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2345	79	even	even	RB
18637	2345	80	though	though	IN
18637	2345	81	the	the	DT
18637	2345	82	cotton	cotton	NN
18637	2345	83	was	be	VBD
18637	2345	84	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	2345	85	with	with	IN
18637	2345	86	a	a	DT
18637	2345	87	view	view	NN
18637	2345	88	to	to	TO
18637	2345	89	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	2345	90	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2345	91	in	in	IN
18637	2345	92	some	some	DT
18637	2345	93	other	other	JJ
18637	2345	94	State	State	NNP
18637	2345	95	or	or	CC
18637	2345	96	country	country	NN
18637	2345	97	.	.	.
18637	2346	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2346	2	595	595	CD
18637	2346	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2346	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	2346	5	was	be	VBD
18637	2346	6	a	a	DT
18637	2346	7	gallonage	gallonage	NN
18637	2346	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	2346	9	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2346	10	by	by	IN
18637	2346	11	a	a	DT
18637	2346	12	State	state	NN
18637	2346	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	2346	14	a	a	DT
18637	2346	15	distributor	distributor	NN
18637	2346	16	of	of	IN
18637	2346	17	liquid	liquid	JJ
18637	2346	18	fuel	fuel	NN
18637	2346	19	rendered	render	VBN
18637	2346	20	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	2346	21	to	to	IN
18637	2346	22	the	the	DT
18637	2346	23	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2346	24	clause	clause	NN
18637	2346	25	by	by	IN
18637	2346	26	the	the	DT
18637	2346	27	fact	fact	NN
18637	2346	28	that	that	IN
18637	2346	29	the	the	DT
18637	2346	30	distributor	distributor	NN
18637	2346	31	caused	cause	VBD
18637	2346	32	fuel	fuel	NN
18637	2346	33	sold	sell	VBN
18637	2346	34	to	to	IN
18637	2346	35	customers	customer	NNS
18637	2346	36	in	in	IN
18637	2346	37	the	the	DT
18637	2346	38	State	State	NNP
18637	2346	39	to	to	TO
18637	2346	40	be	be	VB
18637	2346	41	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	2346	42	from	from	IN
18637	2346	43	another	another	DT
18637	2346	44	State	state	NN
18637	2346	45	for	for	IN
18637	2346	46	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	2346	47	in	in	IN
18637	2346	48	tank	tank	NN
18637	2346	49	cars--"deemed	cars--"deemed	CC
18637	2346	50	original	original	JJ
18637	2346	51	packages"--on	packages"--on	NNP
18637	2346	52	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	2346	53	's	's	POS
18637	2346	54	siding	siding	NN
18637	2346	55	,	,	,
18637	2346	56	as	as	IN
18637	2346	57	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	2346	58	.	.	.
18637	2347	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	2347	2	the	the	DT
18637	2347	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2347	4	:	:	:
18637	2347	5	"	"	``
18637	2347	6	The	the	DT
18637	2347	7	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	2347	8	were	be	VBD
18637	2347	9	executory	executory	JJ
18637	2347	10	and	and	CC
18637	2347	11	related	relate	VBN
18637	2347	12	to	to	IN
18637	2347	13	unascertained	unascertained	JJ
18637	2347	14	goods	good	NNS
18637	2347	15	.	.	.
18637	2348	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2348	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2348	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2348	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2348	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	2348	6	not	not	RB
18637	2348	7	appear	appear	VB
18637	2348	8	that	that	IN
18637	2348	9	when	when	WRB
18637	2348	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2348	11	were	be	VBD
18637	2348	12	made	make	VBN
18637	2348	13	appellant	appellant	JJ
18637	2348	14	had	have	VBD
18637	2348	15	any	any	DT
18637	2348	16	fuels	fuel	NNS
18637	2348	17	of	of	IN
18637	2348	18	the	the	DT
18637	2348	19	kinds	kind	NNS
18637	2348	20	covered	cover	VBN
18637	2348	21	,	,	,
18637	2348	22	or	or	CC
18637	2348	23	that	that	IN
18637	2348	24	those	those	DT
18637	2348	25	to	to	TO
18637	2348	26	be	be	VB
18637	2348	27	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	2348	28	were	be	VBD
18637	2348	29	then	then	RB
18637	2348	30	in	in	IN
18637	2348	31	existence	existence	NN
18637	2348	32	.	.	.
18637	2349	1	There	there	EX
18637	2349	2	was	be	VBD
18637	2349	3	no	no	DT
18637	2349	4	selection	selection	NN
18637	2349	5	of	of	IN
18637	2349	6	goods	good	NNS
18637	2349	7	by	by	IN
18637	2349	8	purchasers	purchaser	NNS
18637	2349	9	.	.	.
18637	2350	1	Appellant	Appellant	NNP
18637	2350	2	was	be	VBD
18637	2350	3	not	not	RB
18637	2350	4	required	require	VBN
18637	2350	5	by	by	IN
18637	2350	6	the	the	DT
18637	2350	7	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	2350	8	to	to	TO
18637	2350	9	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	2350	10	the	the	DT
18637	2350	11	fuels	fuel	NNS
18637	2350	12	at	at	IN
18637	2350	13	Wilmington	Wilmington	NNP
18637	2350	14	but	but	CC
18637	2350	15	was	be	VBD
18637	2350	16	free	free	JJ
18637	2350	17	to	to	TO
18637	2350	18	effect	effect	VB
18637	2350	19	performance	performance	NN
18637	2350	20	by	by	IN
18637	2350	21	shipping	ship	VBG
18637	2350	22	from	from	IN
18637	2350	23	,	,	,
18637	2350	24	any	any	DT
18637	2350	25	place	place	NN
18637	2350	26	within	within	IN
18637	2350	27	or	or	CC
18637	2350	28	without	without	IN
18637	2350	29	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2350	30	.	.	.
18637	2351	1	"	"	``
18637	2351	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2351	3	596	596	CD
18637	2351	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2351	5	THE	the	DT
18637	2351	6	ROBBINS	robbin	NNS
18637	2351	7	CASE	case	NN
18637	2351	8	TODAY	today	NN
18637	2351	9	In	in	IN
18637	2351	10	the	the	DT
18637	2351	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	2351	12	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	2351	13	in	in	IN
18637	2351	14	the	the	DT
18637	2351	15	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	2351	16	paragraph	paragraph	NN
18637	2351	17	protestants	protestant	NNS
18637	2351	18	against	against	IN
18637	2351	19	local	local	JJ
18637	2351	20	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2351	21	appealed	appeal	VBD
18637	2351	22	,	,	,
18637	2351	23	but	but	CC
18637	2351	24	unavailingly	unavailingly	RB
18637	2351	25	,	,	,
18637	2351	26	to	to	IN
18637	2351	27	the	the	DT
18637	2351	28	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	2351	29	case	case	NN
18637	2351	30	.	.	.
18637	2352	1	So	so	RB
18637	2352	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2352	3	would	would	MD
18637	2352	4	seem	seem	VB
18637	2352	5	that	that	IN
18637	2352	6	the	the	DT
18637	2352	7	generative	generative	JJ
18637	2352	8	powers	power	NNS
18637	2352	9	of	of	IN
18637	2352	10	that	that	DT
18637	2352	11	prolific	prolific	JJ
18637	2352	12	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	2352	13	had	have	VBD
18637	2352	14	begun	begin	VBN
18637	2352	15	to	to	IN
18637	2352	16	wane	wane	VB
18637	2352	17	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	2352	18	even	even	RB
18637	2352	19	before	before	IN
18637	2352	20	the	the	DT
18637	2352	21	Depression	Depression	NNP
18637	2352	22	,	,	,
18637	2352	23	an	an	DT
18637	2352	24	event	event	NN
18637	2352	25	which	which	WDT
18637	2352	26	rendered	render	VBD
18637	2352	27	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	2352	28	reaction	reaction	NN
18637	2352	29	against	against	IN
18637	2352	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2352	31	still	still	RB
18637	2352	32	more	more	RBR
18637	2352	33	pronounced	pronounced	JJ
18637	2352	34	.	.	.
18637	2353	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	2353	2	,	,	,
18637	2353	3	by	by	IN
18637	2353	4	the	the	DT
18637	2353	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2353	6	's	's	POS
18637	2353	7	decision	decision	NN
18637	2353	8	in	in	IN
18637	2353	9	McGoldrick	McGoldrick	NNP
18637	2353	10	_	_	NNP
18637	2353	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	2353	12	_	_	NNP
18637	2353	13	Berwind	Berwind	NNP
18637	2353	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	2353	15	White	White	NNP
18637	2353	16	Co	Co	NNP
18637	2353	17	.	.	.
18637	2353	18	,[597	,[597	NFP
18637	2353	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2353	20	in	in	IN
18637	2353	21	1940	1940	CD
18637	2353	22	,	,	,
18637	2353	23	the	the	DT
18637	2353	24	authority	authority	NN
18637	2353	25	of	of	IN
18637	2353	26	the	the	DT
18637	2353	27	entire	entire	JJ
18637	2353	28	line	line	NN
18637	2353	29	of	of	IN
18637	2353	30	cases	case	NNS
18637	2353	31	descending	descend	VBG
18637	2353	32	from	from	IN
18637	2353	33	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	2353	34	_	_	NNP
18637	2353	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	2353	36	_	_	NNP
18637	2353	37	Shelby	Shelby	NNP
18637	2353	38	County	County	NNP
18637	2353	39	Taxing	Taxing	NNP
18637	2353	40	District	District	NNP
18637	2353	41	was	be	VBD
18637	2353	42	seriously	seriously	RB
18637	2353	43	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	2353	44	,	,	,
18637	2353	45	for	for	IN
18637	2353	46	the	the	DT
18637	2353	47	time	time	NN
18637	2353	48	being	be	VBG
18637	2353	49	,	,	,
18637	2353	50	while	while	IN
18637	2353	51	a	a	DT
18637	2353	52	second	second	JJ
18637	2353	53	holding	hold	VBG
18637	2353	54	the	the	DT
18637	2353	55	same	same	JJ
18637	2353	56	year	year	NN
18637	2353	57	seemed	seem	VBD
18637	2353	58	to	to	TO
18637	2353	59	reduce	reduce	VB
18637	2353	60	the	the	DT
18637	2353	61	significance	significance	NN
18637	2353	62	of	of	IN
18637	2353	63	the	the	DT
18637	2353	64	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	2353	65	case	case	NN
18637	2353	66	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2353	67	to	to	IN
18637	2353	68	that	that	DT
18637	2353	69	of	of	IN
18637	2353	70	a	a	DT
18637	2353	71	reassertion	reassertion	NN
18637	2353	72	of	of	IN
18637	2353	73	the	the	DT
18637	2353	74	elementary	elementary	JJ
18637	2353	75	rule	rule	NN
18637	2353	76	against	against	IN
18637	2353	77	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	2353	78	.	.	.
18637	2354	1	"	"	``
18637	2354	2	The	the	DT
18637	2354	3	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2354	4	clause	clause	NN
18637	2354	5	,	,	,
18637	2354	6	"	"	''
18637	2354	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2354	8	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	2354	9	remarked	remark	VBD
18637	2354	10	sententiously	sententiously	RB
18637	2354	11	,	,	,
18637	2354	12	"	"	``
18637	2354	13	forbids	forbid	NNS
18637	2354	14	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	2354	15	,	,	,
18637	2354	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	2354	17	forthright	forthright	JJ
18637	2354	18	or	or	CC
18637	2354	19	ingenious	ingenious	JJ
18637	2354	20	.	.	.
18637	2355	1	"	"	``
18637	2355	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2355	3	598	598	CD
18637	2355	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2355	5	DEPRESSION	depression	NN
18637	2355	6	CASES	case	NNS
18637	2355	7	:	:	:
18637	2355	8	USE	use	VB
18637	2355	9	TAXES	tax	VBZ
18637	2355	10	With	with	IN
18637	2355	11	a	a	DT
18637	2355	12	majority	majority	NN
18637	2355	13	of	of	IN
18637	2355	14	the	the	DT
18637	2355	15	States	States	NNP
18637	2355	16	on	on	IN
18637	2355	17	the	the	DT
18637	2355	18	verge	verge	NN
18637	2355	19	of	of	IN
18637	2355	20	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2355	21	,	,	,
18637	2355	22	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	2355	23	recourse	recourse	NN
18637	2355	24	was	be	VBD
18637	2355	25	had	have	VBN
18637	2355	26	to	to	IN
18637	2355	27	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2355	28	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2355	29	and	and	CC
18637	2355	30	,	,	,
18637	2355	31	as	as	IN
18637	2355	32	an	an	DT
18637	2355	33	offset	offset	NN
18637	2355	34	to	to	IN
18637	2355	35	these	these	DT
18637	2355	36	in	in	IN
18637	2355	37	favor	favor	NN
18637	2355	38	of	of	IN
18637	2355	39	the	the	DT
18637	2355	40	local	local	JJ
18637	2355	41	economy	economy	NN
18637	2355	42	,	,	,
18637	2355	43	"	"	``
18637	2355	44	use	use	VB
18637	2355	45	"	"	''
18637	2355	46	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2355	47	on	on	IN
18637	2355	48	competing	compete	VBG
18637	2355	49	products	product	NNS
18637	2355	50	coming	come	VBG
18637	2355	51	from	from	IN
18637	2355	52	sister	sister	NN
18637	2355	53	States	States	NNP
18637	2355	54	.	.	.
18637	2356	1	The	the	DT
18637	2356	2	basic	basic	JJ
18637	2356	3	decision	decision	NN
18637	2356	4	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	2356	5	the	the	DT
18637	2356	6	use	use	NN
18637	2356	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	2356	8	,	,	,
18637	2356	9	in	in	IN
18637	2356	10	this	this	DT
18637	2356	11	novel	novel	JJ
18637	2356	12	employment	employment	NN
18637	2356	13	of	of	IN
18637	2356	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2356	15	,	,	,
18637	2356	16	was	be	VBD
18637	2356	17	Henneford	Henneford	NNP
18637	2356	18	_	_	NNP
18637	2356	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	2356	20	_	_	NNP
18637	2356	21	Silas	Silas	NNP
18637	2356	22	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	2356	23	Co	Co	NNP
18637	2356	24	.	.	.
18637	2356	25	,[599	,[599	,
18637	2356	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2356	27	in	in	IN
18637	2356	28	which	which	WDT
18637	2356	29	was	be	VBD
18637	2356	30	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2356	31	a	a	DT
18637	2356	32	State	State	NNP
18637	2356	33	of	of	IN
18637	2356	34	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	2356	35	two	two	CD
18637	2356	36	per	per	IN
18637	2356	37	cent	cent	NN
18637	2356	38	tax	tax	NN
18637	2356	39	on	on	IN
18637	2356	40	the	the	DT
18637	2356	41	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2356	42	of	of	IN
18637	2356	43	using	use	VBG
18637	2356	44	products	product	NNS
18637	2356	45	coming	come	VBG
18637	2356	46	from	from	IN
18637	2356	47	sister	sister	NN
18637	2356	48	States	States	NNP
18637	2356	49	.	.	.
18637	2357	1	Excepted	except	VBN
18637	2357	2	from	from	IN
18637	2357	3	the	the	DT
18637	2357	4	tax	tax	NN
18637	2357	5	,	,	,
18637	2357	6	on	on	IN
18637	2357	7	the	the	DT
18637	2357	8	other	other	JJ
18637	2357	9	hand	hand	NN
18637	2357	10	,	,	,
18637	2357	11	was	be	VBD
18637	2357	12	any	any	DT
18637	2357	13	property	property	NN
18637	2357	14	the	the	DT
18637	2357	15	sole	sole	JJ
18637	2357	16	use	use	NN
18637	2357	17	of	of	IN
18637	2357	18	which	which	WDT
18637	2357	19	had	have	VBD
18637	2357	20	already	already	RB
18637	2357	21	been	be	VBN
18637	2357	22	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	2357	23	to	to	IN
18637	2357	24	an	an	DT
18637	2357	25	equal	equal	JJ
18637	2357	26	or	or	CC
18637	2357	27	greater	great	JJR
18637	2357	28	tax	tax	NN
18637	2357	29	,	,	,
18637	2357	30	whether	whether	IN
18637	2357	31	under	under	IN
18637	2357	32	the	the	DT
18637	2357	33	laws	law	NNS
18637	2357	34	of	of	IN
18637	2357	35	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	2357	36	or	or	CC
18637	2357	37	any	any	DT
18637	2357	38	other	other	JJ
18637	2357	39	State	State	NNP
18637	2357	40	.	.	.
18637	2358	1	Stressing	stress	VBG
18637	2358	2	this	this	DT
18637	2358	3	provision	provision	NN
18637	2358	4	in	in	IN
18637	2358	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2358	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2358	7	,	,	,
18637	2358	8	the	the	DT
18637	2358	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2358	10	said	say	VBD
18637	2358	11	:	:	:
18637	2358	12	"	"	``
18637	2358	13	Equality	equality	NN
18637	2358	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	2358	15	the	the	DT
18637	2358	16	theme	theme	NN
18637	2358	17	that	that	WDT
18637	2358	18	runs	run	VBZ
18637	2358	19	through	through	IN
18637	2358	20	all	all	PDT
18637	2358	21	the	the	DT
18637	2358	22	sections	section	NNS
18637	2358	23	of	of	IN
18637	2358	24	the	the	DT
18637	2358	25	statute	statute	NN
18637	2358	26	.	.	.
18637	2359	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2359	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2359	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2359	4	When	when	WRB
18637	2359	5	the	the	DT
18637	2359	6	account	account	NN
18637	2359	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	2359	8	made	make	VBN
18637	2359	9	up	up	RP
18637	2359	10	,	,	,
18637	2359	11	the	the	DT
18637	2359	12	stranger	stranger	NN
18637	2359	13	from	from	IN
18637	2359	14	afar	afar	RB
18637	2359	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	2359	16	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2359	17	to	to	IN
18637	2359	18	no	no	DT
18637	2359	19	greater	great	JJR
18637	2359	20	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	2359	21	as	as	IN
18637	2359	22	a	a	DT
18637	2359	23	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	2359	24	of	of	IN
18637	2359	25	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	2359	26	than	than	IN
18637	2359	27	the	the	DT
18637	2359	28	dweller	dweller	NN
18637	2359	29	within	within	IN
18637	2359	30	the	the	DT
18637	2359	31	gates	gate	NNS
18637	2359	32	.	.	.
18637	2360	1	"	"	``
18637	2360	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2360	3	600	600	CD
18637	2360	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2360	5	There	there	EX
18637	2360	6	being	be	VBG
18637	2360	7	no	no	DT
18637	2360	8	actual	actual	JJ
18637	2360	9	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	2360	10	in	in	IN
18637	2360	11	favor	favor	NN
18637	2360	12	of	of	IN
18637	2360	13	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	2360	14	products	product	NNS
18637	2360	15	,	,	,
18637	2360	16	the	the	DT
18637	2360	17	tax	tax	NN
18637	2360	18	was	be	VBD
18637	2360	19	valid	valid	JJ
18637	2360	20	.	.	.
18637	2361	1	DEPRESSION	depression	NN
18637	2361	2	CASES	case	NNS
18637	2361	3	:	:	:
18637	2361	4	SALES	sale	NNS
18637	2361	5	TAXES	taxes	VBP
18637	2361	6	A	a	DT
18637	2361	7	companion	companion	NN
18637	2361	8	piece	piece	NN
18637	2361	9	of	of	IN
18637	2361	10	the	the	DT
18637	2361	11	Henneford	Henneford	NNP
18637	2361	12	case	case	NN
18637	2361	13	in	in	IN
18637	2361	14	motivation	motivation	NN
18637	2361	15	,	,	,
18637	2361	16	although	although	IN
18637	2361	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2361	18	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	2361	19	three	three	CD
18637	2361	20	years	year	NNS
18637	2361	21	later	later	RB
18637	2361	22	,	,	,
18637	2361	23	was	be	VBD
18637	2361	24	McGoldrick	McGoldrick	NNP
18637	2361	25	_	_	NNP
18637	2361	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	2361	27	_	_	NNP
18637	2361	28	Berwind	Berwind	NNP
18637	2361	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	2361	30	White	White	NNP
18637	2361	31	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	2361	32	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	2361	33	Company,[601	Company,[601	NNP
18637	2361	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2361	35	in	in	IN
18637	2361	36	which	which	WDT
18637	2361	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2361	38	was	be	VBD
18637	2361	39	held	hold	VBN
18637	2361	40	that	that	IN
18637	2361	41	in	in	IN
18637	2361	42	the	the	DT
18637	2361	43	absence	absence	NN
18637	2361	44	of	of	IN
18637	2361	45	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2361	46	action	action	NN
18637	2361	47	,	,	,
18637	2361	48	a	a	DT
18637	2361	49	New	New	NNP
18637	2361	50	York	York	NNP
18637	2361	51	City	City	NNP
18637	2361	52	general	general	JJ
18637	2361	53	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2361	54	tax	tax	NN
18637	2361	55	was	be	VBD
18637	2361	56	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	2361	57	to	to	IN
18637	2361	58	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2361	59	of	of	IN
18637	2361	60	coal	coal	NN
18637	2361	61	under	under	IN
18637	2361	62	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	2361	63	entered	enter	VBD
18637	2361	64	into	into	IN
18637	2361	65	within	within	IN
18637	2361	66	the	the	DT
18637	2361	67	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	2361	68	and	and	CC
18637	2361	69	calling	call	VBG
18637	2361	70	for	for	IN
18637	2361	71	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	2361	72	therein	therein	RB
18637	2361	73	.	.	.
18637	2362	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2362	2	for	for	IN
18637	2362	3	the	the	DT
18637	2362	4	majority	majority	NN
18637	2362	5	,	,	,
18637	2362	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2362	7	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	2362	8	declared	declare	VBD
18637	2362	9	any	any	DT
18637	2362	10	"	"	``
18637	2362	11	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	2362	12	*	*	NFP
18637	2362	13	*	*	NFP
18637	2362	14	*	*	NFP
18637	2362	15	between	between	IN
18637	2362	16	a	a	DT
18637	2362	17	tax	tax	NN
18637	2362	18	laid	lay	VBN
18637	2362	19	on	on	IN
18637	2362	20	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2362	21	made	make	VBN
18637	2362	22	,	,	,
18637	2362	23	without	without	IN
18637	2362	24	previous	previous	JJ
18637	2362	25	contract	contract	NN
18637	2362	26	,	,	,
18637	2362	27	after	after	IN
18637	2362	28	the	the	DT
18637	2362	29	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	2362	30	had	have	VBD
18637	2362	31	crossed	cross	VBN
18637	2362	32	the	the	DT
18637	2362	33	State	State	NNP
18637	2362	34	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	2362	35	,	,	,
18637	2362	36	and	and	CC
18637	2362	37	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2362	38	,	,	,
18637	2362	39	the	the	DT
18637	2362	40	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	2362	41	for	for	IN
18637	2362	42	which	which	WDT
18637	2362	43	when	when	WRB
18637	2362	44	made	make	VBN
18637	2362	45	contemplate	contemplate	JJ
18637	2362	46	or	or	CC
18637	2362	47	require	require	VB
18637	2362	48	the	the	DT
18637	2362	49	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2362	50	of	of	IN
18637	2362	51	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	2362	52	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2362	53	to	to	IN
18637	2362	54	the	the	DT
18637	2362	55	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2362	56	State	state	NN
18637	2362	57	,	,	,
18637	2362	58	"	"	''
18637	2362	59	to	to	TO
18637	2362	60	be	be	VB
18637	2362	61	"	"	``
18637	2362	62	without	without	IN
18637	2362	63	the	the	DT
18637	2362	64	support	support	NN
18637	2362	65	of	of	IN
18637	2362	66	reason	reason	NN
18637	2362	67	or	or	CC
18637	2362	68	authority";[602	authority";[602	FW
18637	2362	69	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2362	70	and	and	CC
18637	2362	71	the	the	DT
18637	2362	72	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	2362	73	case	case	NN
18637	2362	74	was	be	VBD
18637	2362	75	held	hold	VBN
18637	2362	76	to	to	TO
18637	2362	77	be	be	VB
18637	2362	78	"	"	``
18637	2362	79	narrowly	narrowly	RB
18637	2362	80	limited	limited	JJ
18637	2362	81	to	to	IN
18637	2362	82	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	2362	83	-	-	HYPH
18637	2362	84	sum	sum	NN
18637	2362	85	license	license	NN
18637	2362	86	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2362	87	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2362	88	on	on	IN
18637	2362	89	the	the	DT
18637	2362	90	business	business	NN
18637	2362	91	of	of	IN
18637	2362	92	soliciting	solicit	VBG
18637	2362	93	order	order	NN
18637	2362	94	for	for	IN
18637	2362	95	the	the	DT
18637	2362	96	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	2362	97	of	of	IN
18637	2362	98	goods	good	NNS
18637	2362	99	to	to	TO
18637	2362	100	be	be	VB
18637	2362	101	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	2362	102	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2362	103	,	,	,
18637	2362	104	*	*	NFP
18637	2362	105	*	*	NFP
18637	2362	106	*	*	NFP
18637	2362	107	"	"	''
18637	2362	108	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2362	109	603	603	CD
18637	2362	110	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2362	111	Three	three	CD
18637	2362	112	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	2362	113	,	,	,
18637	2362	114	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2362	115	by	by	IN
18637	2362	116	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2362	117	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2362	118	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	2362	119	,	,	,
18637	2362	120	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	2362	121	.	.	.
18637	2363	1	Three	three	CD
18637	2363	2	companion	companion	NN
18637	2363	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	2363	4	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2363	5	the	the	DT
18637	2363	6	same	same	JJ
18637	2363	7	day	day	NN
18637	2363	8	were	be	VBD
18637	2363	9	found	find	VBN
18637	2363	10	to	to	TO
18637	2363	11	follow	follow	VB
18637	2363	12	the	the	DT
18637	2363	13	Berwind	Berwind	NNP
18637	2363	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	2363	15	White	white	JJ
18637	2363	16	pattern,[604	pattern,[604	NNS
18637	2363	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2363	18	while	while	IN
18637	2363	19	a	a	DT
18637	2363	20	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	2363	21	was	be	VBD
18637	2363	22	held	hold	VBN
18637	2363	23	not	not	RB
18637	2363	24	to	to	TO
18637	2363	25	,	,	,
18637	2363	26	on	on	IN
18637	2363	27	the	the	DT
18637	2363	28	ground	ground	NN
18637	2363	29	that	that	IN
18637	2363	30	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2363	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2363	32	was	be	VBD
18637	2363	33	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2363	34	.	.	.
18637	2364	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2364	2	605	605	CD
18637	2364	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2364	4	For	for	IN
18637	2364	5	the	the	DT
18637	2364	6	time	time	NN
18637	2364	7	being	be	VBG
18637	2364	8	Robbins	robbin	NNS
18637	2364	9	and	and	CC
18637	2364	10	family	family	NN
18637	2364	11	looked	look	VBD
18637	2364	12	to	to	TO
18637	2364	13	be	be	VB
18637	2364	14	on	on	IN
18637	2364	15	the	the	DT
18637	2364	16	way	way	NN
18637	2364	17	out	out	RB
18637	2364	18	.	.	.
18637	2365	1	END	END	NNP
18637	2365	2	OF	of	IN
18637	2365	3	THE	the	DT
18637	2365	4	DEPRESSION	DEPRESSION	NNP
18637	2365	5	CASES	cases	NN
18637	2365	6	Two	two	CD
18637	2365	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	2365	8	,	,	,
18637	2365	9	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2365	10	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	2365	11	in	in	IN
18637	2365	12	1944	1944	CD
18637	2365	13	and	and	CC
18637	2365	14	1946	1946	CD
18637	2365	15	,	,	,
18637	2365	16	signalized	signalize	VBD
18637	2365	17	the	the	DT
18637	2365	18	end	end	NN
18637	2365	19	of	of	IN
18637	2365	20	the	the	DT
18637	2365	21	Depression	Depression	NNP
18637	2365	22	.	.	.
18637	2366	1	In	in	IN
18637	2366	2	McLeod	McLeod	NNP
18637	2366	3	_	_	NNP
18637	2366	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	2366	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2366	6	Dilworth	Dilworth	NNP
18637	2366	7	Co	Co	NNP
18637	2366	8	.	.	.
18637	2366	9	,[606	,[606	NFP
18637	2366	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2366	11	a	a	DT
18637	2366	12	divided	divide	VBN
18637	2366	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2366	14	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	2366	15	that	that	IN
18637	2366	16	a	a	DT
18637	2366	17	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2366	18	tax	tax	NN
18637	2366	19	could	could	MD
18637	2366	20	not	not	RB
18637	2366	21	be	be	VB
18637	2366	22	validly	validly	RB
18637	2366	23	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2366	24	by	by	IN
18637	2366	25	a	a	DT
18637	2366	26	State	state	NN
18637	2366	27	on	on	IN
18637	2366	28	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2366	29	to	to	IN
18637	2366	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2366	31	residents	resident	NNS
18637	2366	32	which	which	WDT
18637	2366	33	were	be	VBD
18637	2366	34	consummated	consummate	VBN
18637	2366	35	by	by	IN
18637	2366	36	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	2366	37	of	of	IN
18637	2366	38	orders	order	NNS
18637	2366	39	in	in	RP
18637	2366	40	,	,	,
18637	2366	41	and	and	CC
18637	2366	42	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2366	43	of	of	IN
18637	2366	44	goods	good	NNS
18637	2366	45	from	from	IN
18637	2366	46	another	another	DT
18637	2366	47	State	state	NN
18637	2366	48	,	,	,
18637	2366	49	in	in	IN
18637	2366	50	which	which	WDT
18637	2366	51	title	title	NN
18637	2366	52	passed	pass	VBD
18637	2366	53	upon	upon	IN
18637	2366	54	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	2366	55	to	to	IN
18637	2366	56	the	the	DT
18637	2366	57	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2366	58	.	.	.
18637	2367	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	2367	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2367	3	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	2367	4	for	for	IN
18637	2367	5	the	the	DT
18637	2367	6	majority	majority	NN
18637	2367	7	:	:	:
18637	2367	8	"	"	``
18637	2367	9	A	a	DT
18637	2367	10	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2367	11	tax	tax	NN
18637	2367	12	and	and	CC
18637	2367	13	a	a	DT
18637	2367	14	use	use	NN
18637	2367	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	2367	16	in	in	IN
18637	2367	17	many	many	JJ
18637	2367	18	instances	instance	NNS
18637	2367	19	may	may	MD
18637	2367	20	bring	bring	VB
18637	2367	21	about	about	RP
18637	2367	22	the	the	DT
18637	2367	23	same	same	JJ
18637	2367	24	result	result	NN
18637	2367	25	.	.	.
18637	2368	1	But	but	CC
18637	2368	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2368	3	are	be	VBP
18637	2368	4	different	different	JJ
18637	2368	5	in	in	IN
18637	2368	6	conception	conception	NN
18637	2368	7	,	,	,
18637	2368	8	are	be	VBP
18637	2368	9	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	2368	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	2368	11	different	different	JJ
18637	2368	12	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	2368	13	,	,	,
18637	2368	14	*	*	NFP
18637	2368	15	*	*	NFP
18637	2368	16	*	*	NFP
18637	2368	17	A	a	DT
18637	2368	18	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2368	19	tax	tax	NN
18637	2368	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	2368	21	a	a	DT
18637	2368	22	tax	tax	NN
18637	2368	23	on	on	IN
18637	2368	24	the	the	DT
18637	2368	25	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	2368	26	of	of	IN
18637	2368	27	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	2368	28	*	*	NFP
18637	2368	29	*	*	NFP
18637	2368	30	*	*	NFP
18637	2368	31	A	a	DT
18637	2368	32	use	use	NN
18637	2368	33	tax	tax	NN
18637	2368	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	2368	35	a	a	DT
18637	2368	36	tax	tax	NN
18637	2368	37	on	on	IN
18637	2368	38	the	the	DT
18637	2368	39	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	2368	40	of	of	IN
18637	2368	41	that	that	DT
18637	2368	42	which	which	WDT
18637	2368	43	was	be	VBD
18637	2368	44	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	2368	45	.	.	.
18637	2369	1	In	in	IN
18637	2369	2	view	view	NN
18637	2369	3	of	of	IN
18637	2369	4	the	the	DT
18637	2369	5	differences	difference	NNS
18637	2369	6	in	in	IN
18637	2369	7	the	the	DT
18637	2369	8	basis	basis	NN
18637	2369	9	of	of	IN
18637	2369	10	these	these	DT
18637	2369	11	two	two	CD
18637	2369	12	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2369	13	and	and	CC
18637	2369	14	the	the	DT
18637	2369	15	differences	difference	NNS
18637	2369	16	in	in	IN
18637	2369	17	the	the	DT
18637	2369	18	relation	relation	NN
18637	2369	19	of	of	IN
18637	2369	20	the	the	DT
18637	2369	21	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2369	22	State	state	NN
18637	2369	23	to	to	IN
18637	2369	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2369	25	,	,	,
18637	2369	26	a	a	DT
18637	2369	27	tax	tax	NN
18637	2369	28	on	on	IN
18637	2369	29	an	an	DT
18637	2369	30	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2369	31	sale	sale	NN
18637	2369	32	like	like	IN
18637	2369	33	the	the	DT
18637	2369	34	one	one	NN
18637	2369	35	before	before	IN
18637	2369	36	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2369	37	and	and	CC
18637	2369	38	unlike	unlike	IN
18637	2369	39	the	the	DT
18637	2369	40	tax	tax	NN
18637	2369	41	on	on	IN
18637	2369	42	the	the	DT
18637	2369	43	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	2369	44	of	of	IN
18637	2369	45	the	the	DT
18637	2369	46	goods	good	NNS
18637	2369	47	sold	sell	VBN
18637	2369	48	,	,	,
18637	2369	49	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	2369	50	an	an	DT
18637	2369	51	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	2369	52	of	of	IN
18637	2369	53	power	power	NN
18637	2369	54	by	by	IN
18637	2369	55	a	a	DT
18637	2369	56	State	state	NN
18637	2369	57	which	which	WDT
18637	2369	58	the	the	DT
18637	2369	59	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2369	60	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	2369	61	was	be	VBD
18637	2369	62	meant	mean	VBN
18637	2369	63	to	to	TO
18637	2369	64	end	end	VB
18637	2369	65	.	.	.
18637	2370	1	"	"	``
18637	2370	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2370	3	607	607	CD
18637	2370	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2370	5	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2370	6	also	also	RB
18637	2370	7	"	"	``
18637	2370	8	distinguished	distinguish	VBD
18637	2370	9	"	"	''
18637	2370	10	the	the	DT
18637	2370	11	Berwind	Berwind	NNP
18637	2370	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	2370	13	White	white	JJ
18637	2370	14	case	case	NN
18637	2370	15	--	--	:
18637	2370	16	just	just	RB
18637	2370	17	as	as	IN
18637	2370	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2370	19	had	have	VBD
18637	2370	20	"	"	``
18637	2370	21	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	2370	22	"	"	''
18637	2370	23	the	the	DT
18637	2370	24	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	2370	25	case	case	NN
18637	2370	26	--	--	:
18637	2370	27	but	but	CC
18637	2370	28	not	not	RB
18637	2370	29	to	to	IN
18637	2370	30	the	the	DT
18637	2370	31	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
18637	2370	32	of	of	IN
18637	2370	33	three	three	CD
18637	2370	34	of	of	IN
18637	2370	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2370	36	brethren	brother	NNS
18637	2370	37	,	,	,
18637	2370	38	who	who	WP
18637	2370	39	found	find	VBD
18637	2370	40	the	the	DT
18637	2370	41	decision	decision	NN
18637	2370	42	to	to	TO
18637	2370	43	mark	mark	VB
18637	2370	44	a	a	DT
18637	2370	45	retreat	retreat	NN
18637	2370	46	from	from	IN
18637	2370	47	the	the	DT
18637	2370	48	Berwind	Berwind	NNP
18637	2370	49	-	-	HYPH
18637	2370	50	White	White	NNP
18637	2370	51	case	case	NN
18637	2370	52	.	.	.
18637	2371	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2371	2	608	608	CD
18637	2371	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2371	4	The	the	DT
18637	2371	5	second	second	JJ
18637	2371	6	case	case	NN
18637	2371	7	,	,	,
18637	2371	8	Nippert	Nippert	NNP
18637	2371	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2371	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	2371	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2371	12	Richmond,[609	Richmond,[609	NNP
18637	2371	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2371	14	involved	involve	VBD
18637	2371	15	a	a	DT
18637	2371	16	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	2371	17	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	2371	18	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	2371	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	2371	20	solicitors	solicitor	NNS
18637	2371	21	of	of	IN
18637	2371	22	orders	order	NNS
18637	2371	23	for	for	IN
18637	2371	24	goods	good	NNS
18637	2371	25	a	a	DT
18637	2371	26	license	license	NN
18637	2371	27	tax	tax	NN
18637	2371	28	of	of	IN
18637	2371	29	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	2371	30	dollars	dollar	NNS
18637	2371	31	and	and	CC
18637	2371	32	one	one	CD
18637	2371	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	2371	34	half	half	NN
18637	2371	35	of	of	IN
18637	2371	36	one	one	CD
18637	2371	37	per	per	IN
18637	2371	38	cent	cent	NN
18637	2371	39	of	of	IN
18637	2371	40	the	the	DT
18637	2371	41	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2371	42	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	2371	43	,	,	,
18637	2371	44	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	2371	45	,	,	,
18637	2371	46	etc	etc	FW
18637	2371	47	.	.	FW
18637	2371	48	,	,	,
18637	2371	49	for	for	IN
18637	2371	50	the	the	DT
18637	2371	51	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	2371	52	year	year	NN
18637	2371	53	in	in	IN
18637	2371	54	excess	excess	NN
18637	2371	55	of	of	IN
18637	2371	56	$	$	$
18637	2371	57	1,000	1,000	CD
18637	2371	58	.	.	.
18637	2372	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2372	2	for	for	IN
18637	2372	3	the	the	DT
18637	2372	4	same	same	JJ
18637	2372	5	majority	majority	NN
18637	2372	6	that	that	WDT
18637	2372	7	had	have	VBD
18637	2372	8	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2372	9	McLeod	McLeod	NNP
18637	2372	10	_	_	NNP
18637	2372	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	2372	12	_	_	NNP
18637	2372	13	Dilworth	Dilworth	NNP
18637	2372	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2372	15	,	,	,
18637	2372	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2372	17	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	2372	18	found	find	VBD
18637	2372	19	that	that	IN
18637	2372	20	"	"	``
18637	2372	21	as	as	IN
18637	2372	22	the	the	DT
18637	2372	23	case	case	NN
18637	2372	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	2372	25	been	be	VBN
18637	2372	26	made	make	VBN
18637	2372	27	,	,	,
18637	2372	28	the	the	DT
18637	2372	29	issue	issue	NN
18637	2372	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	2372	31	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	2372	32	whether	whether	IN
18637	2372	33	the	the	DT
18637	2372	34	long	long	JJ
18637	2372	35	line	line	NN
18637	2372	36	of	of	IN
18637	2372	37	so	so	RB
18637	2372	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	2372	39	called	call	VBN
18637	2372	40	'	'	``
18637	2372	41	drummer	drummer	NN
18637	2372	42	cases	case	NNS
18637	2372	43	'	'	POS
18637	2372	44	beginning	begin	VBG
18637	2372	45	with	with	IN
18637	2372	46	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	2372	47	_	_	NNP
18637	2372	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	2372	49	_	_	NNP
18637	2372	50	Shelby	Shelby	NNP
18637	2372	51	County	County	NNP
18637	2372	52	Taxing	Taxing	NNP
18637	2372	53	District	District	NNP
18637	2372	54	,	,	,
18637	2372	55	120	120	CD
18637	2372	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	2372	57	489	489	CD
18637	2372	58	,	,	,
18637	2372	59	shall	shall	MD
18637	2372	60	be	be	VB
18637	2372	61	adhered	adhere	VBN
18637	2372	62	to	to	IN
18637	2372	63	in	in	IN
18637	2372	64	result	result	NN
18637	2372	65	or	or	CC
18637	2372	66	shall	shall	MD
18637	2372	67	now	now	RB
18637	2372	68	be	be	VB
18637	2372	69	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	2372	70	in	in	IN
18637	2372	71	the	the	DT
18637	2372	72	light	light	NN
18637	2372	73	of	of	IN
18637	2372	74	what	what	WP
18637	2372	75	attorneys	attorney	NNS
18637	2372	76	for	for	IN
18637	2372	77	the	the	DT
18637	2372	78	city	city	NN
18637	2372	79	say	say	VBP
18637	2372	80	are	be	VBP
18637	2372	81	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2372	82	trends	trend	NNS
18637	2372	83	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2372	84	that	that	DT
18637	2372	85	outcome	outcome	NN
18637	2372	86	.	.	.
18637	2373	1	"	"	``
18637	2373	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2373	3	610	610	CD
18637	2373	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2373	5	The	the	DT
18637	2373	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	2373	7	was	be	VBD
18637	2373	8	held	hold	VBN
18637	2373	9	void	void	JJ
18637	2373	10	,	,	,
18637	2373	11	Berwind	Berwind	NNP
18637	2373	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	2373	13	White	White	NNP
18637	2373	14	being	be	VBG
18637	2373	15	not	not	RB
18637	2373	16	only	only	RB
18637	2373	17	"	"	``
18637	2373	18	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	2373	19	"	"	''
18637	2373	20	this	this	DT
18637	2373	21	time	time	NN
18637	2373	22	,	,	,
18637	2373	23	but	but	CC
18637	2373	24	also	also	RB
18637	2373	25	"	"	``
18637	2373	26	explained	explain	VBD
18637	2373	27	.	.	.
18637	2373	28	"	"	''
18637	2374	1	"	"	``
18637	2374	2	The	the	DT
18637	2374	3	drummer	drummer	NN
18637	2374	4	,	,	,
18637	2374	5	"	"	''
18637	2374	6	said	say	VBD
18637	2374	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2374	8	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	2374	9	,	,	,
18637	2374	10	"	"	``
18637	2374	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	2374	12	a	a	DT
18637	2374	13	figure	figure	NN
18637	2374	14	representative	representative	NN
18637	2374	15	of	of	IN
18637	2374	16	a	a	DT
18637	2374	17	by	by	RB
18637	2374	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	2374	19	gone	go	VBN
18637	2374	20	day	day	NN
18637	2374	21	,	,	,
18637	2374	22	"	"	''
18637	2374	23	citing	cite	VBG
18637	2374	24	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	2374	25	,	,	,
18637	2374	26	Hawkers	Hawkers	NNPS
18637	2374	27	and	and	CC
18637	2374	28	Walkers	Walkers	NNPS
18637	2374	29	in	in	IN
18637	2374	30	Early	Early	NNP
18637	2374	31	America	America	NNP
18637	2374	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2374	33	1927	1927	CD
18637	2374	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2374	35	.	.	.
18637	2375	1	"	"	``
18637	2375	2	But	but	CC
18637	2375	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2375	4	modern	modern	JJ
18637	2375	5	prototype	prototype	NN
18637	2375	6	persists	persist	VBZ
18637	2375	7	under	under	IN
18637	2375	8	more	more	JJR
18637	2375	9	euphonious	euphonious	JJ
18637	2375	10	appellations	appellation	NNS
18637	2375	11	.	.	.
18637	2376	1	So	so	RB
18637	2376	2	endure	endure	VB
18637	2376	3	the	the	DT
18637	2376	4	basic	basic	JJ
18637	2376	5	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	2376	6	which	which	WDT
18637	2376	7	brought	bring	VBD
18637	2376	8	about	about	RP
18637	2376	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2376	10	protection	protection	NN
18637	2376	11	from	from	IN
18637	2376	12	the	the	DT
18637	2376	13	kind	kind	NN
18637	2376	14	of	of	IN
18637	2376	15	local	local	JJ
18637	2376	16	favoritism	favoritism	NN
18637	2376	17	the	the	DT
18637	2376	18	facts	fact	NNS
18637	2376	19	of	of	IN
18637	2376	20	this	this	DT
18637	2376	21	case	case	NN
18637	2376	22	typify	typify	VBD
18637	2376	23	.	.	.
18637	2377	1	"	"	``
18637	2377	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2377	3	611	611	CD
18637	2377	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2377	5	A	a	DT
18637	2377	6	year	year	NN
18637	2377	7	later	later	RB
18637	2377	8	a	a	DT
18637	2377	9	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	2377	10	"	"	''
18637	2377	11	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2377	12	tax	tax	NN
18637	2377	13	"	"	''
18637	2377	14	laid	lay	VBN
18637	2377	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	2377	16	each	each	DT
18637	2377	17	person	person	NN
18637	2377	18	soliciting	solicit	VBG
18637	2377	19	business	business	NN
18637	2377	20	for	for	IN
18637	2377	21	a	a	DT
18637	2377	22	laundry	laundry	NN
18637	2377	23	not	not	RB
18637	2377	24	licensed	license	VBN
18637	2377	25	in	in	IN
18637	2377	26	the	the	DT
18637	2377	27	State	State	NNP
18637	2377	28	,	,	,
18637	2377	29	was	be	VBD
18637	2377	30	set	set	VBN
18637	2377	31	aside	aside	RB
18637	2377	32	directly	directly	RB
18637	2377	33	on	on	IN
18637	2377	34	the	the	DT
18637	2377	35	authority	authority	NN
18637	2377	36	of	of	IN
18637	2377	37	the	the	DT
18637	2377	38	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	2377	39	case	case	NN
18637	2377	40	.	.	.
18637	2378	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2378	2	612	612	CD
18637	2378	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2378	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2378	5	would	would	MD
18637	2378	6	appear	appear	VB
18637	2378	7	that	that	IN
18637	2378	8	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	2378	9	and	and	CC
18637	2378	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2378	11	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	2378	12	progeny	progeny	NN
18637	2378	13	can	can	MD
18637	2378	14	once	once	RB
18637	2378	15	more	more	JJR
18637	2378	16	claim	claim	NN
18637	2378	17	full	full	JJ
18637	2378	18	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2378	19	status	status	NN
18637	2378	20	.	.	.
18637	2379	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2379	2	613	613	CD
18637	2379	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2379	4	TAXATION	TAXATION	NNP
18637	2379	5	OF	of	IN
18637	2379	6	CARRIAGE	carriage	NN
18637	2379	7	OF	of	IN
18637	2379	8	PERSONS	PERSONS	NNP
18637	2379	9	Whether	whether	IN
18637	2379	10	the	the	DT
18637	2379	11	carriage	carriage	NN
18637	2379	12	of	of	IN
18637	2379	13	persons	person	NNS
18637	2379	14	from	from	IN
18637	2379	15	one	one	CD
18637	2379	16	State	state	NN
18637	2379	17	to	to	IN
18637	2379	18	another	another	DT
18637	2379	19	was	be	VBD
18637	2379	20	a	a	DT
18637	2379	21	branch	branch	NN
18637	2379	22	of	of	IN
18637	2379	23	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2379	24	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2379	25	was	be	VBD
18637	2379	26	a	a	DT
18637	2379	27	question	question	NN
18637	2379	28	which	which	WDT
18637	2379	29	the	the	DT
18637	2379	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2379	31	was	be	VBD
18637	2379	32	able	able	JJ
18637	2379	33	to	to	TO
18637	2379	34	side	side	VB
18637	2379	35	-	-	HYPH
18637	2379	36	step	step	NN
18637	2379	37	in	in	IN
18637	2379	38	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	2379	39	_	_	NNP
18637	2379	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	2379	41	_	_	NNP
18637	2379	42	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	2379	43	.	.	.
18637	2380	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2380	2	614	614	CD
18637	2380	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2380	4	A	a	DT
18637	2380	5	quarter	quarter	NN
18637	2380	6	of	of	IN
18637	2380	7	a	a	DT
18637	2380	8	century	century	NN
18637	2380	9	later	later	RB
18637	2380	10	,	,	,
18637	2380	11	however	however	RB
18637	2380	12	,	,	,
18637	2380	13	an	an	DT
18637	2380	14	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	2380	15	answer	answer	NN
18637	2380	16	was	be	VBD
18637	2380	17	suggested	suggest	VBN
18637	2380	18	in	in	IN
18637	2380	19	the	the	DT
18637	2380	20	Passenger	Passenger	NNP
18637	2380	21	Cases,[615	Cases,[615	NNP
18637	2380	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2380	23	in	in	IN
18637	2380	24	which	which	WDT
18637	2380	25	a	a	DT
18637	2380	26	State	state	NN
18637	2380	27	tax	tax	NN
18637	2380	28	on	on	IN
18637	2380	29	each	each	DT
18637	2380	30	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	2380	31	arriving	arrive	VBG
18637	2380	32	on	on	IN
18637	2380	33	a	a	DT
18637	2380	34	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	2380	35	from	from	IN
18637	2380	36	a	a	DT
18637	2380	37	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2380	38	country	country	NN
18637	2380	39	was	be	VBD
18637	2380	40	set	set	VBN
18637	2380	41	aside	aside	RB
18637	2380	42	,	,	,
18637	2380	43	though	though	IN
18637	2380	44	chiefly	chiefly	RB
18637	2380	45	in	in	IN
18637	2380	46	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	2380	47	on	on	IN
18637	2380	48	existing	exist	VBG
18637	2380	49	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	2380	50	and	and	CC
18637	2380	51	acts	act	NNS
18637	2380	52	of	of	IN
18637	2380	53	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2380	54	.	.	.
18637	2381	1	But	but	CC
18637	2381	2	similar	similar	JJ
18637	2381	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	2381	4	arising	arise	VBG
18637	2381	5	after	after	IN
18637	2381	6	the	the	DT
18637	2381	7	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	2381	8	War	War	NNP
18637	2381	9	were	be	VBD
18637	2381	10	disposed	dispose	VBN
18637	2381	11	of	of	IN
18637	2381	12	by	by	IN
18637	2381	13	direct	direct	JJ
18637	2381	14	recourse	recourse	NN
18637	2381	15	to	to	IN
18637	2381	16	the	the	DT
18637	2381	17	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2381	18	clause	clause	NN
18637	2381	19	.	.	.
18637	2382	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2382	2	616	616	CD
18637	2382	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2382	4	Meantime	meantime	RB
18637	2382	5	,	,	,
18637	2382	6	in	in	IN
18637	2382	7	1865	1865	CD
18637	2382	8	,	,	,
18637	2382	9	the	the	DT
18637	2382	10	newly	newly	RB
18637	2382	11	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	2382	12	State	State	NNP
18637	2382	13	of	of	IN
18637	2382	14	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	2382	15	,	,	,
18637	2382	16	in	in	IN
18637	2382	17	an	an	DT
18637	2382	18	endeavor	endeavor	NN
18637	2382	19	to	to	TO
18637	2382	20	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2382	21	a	a	DT
18637	2382	22	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	2382	23	dissipation	dissipation	NN
18637	2382	24	of	of	IN
18637	2382	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2382	26	population	population	NN
18637	2382	27	,	,	,
18637	2382	28	levied	levy	VBD
18637	2382	29	a	a	DT
18637	2382	30	special	special	JJ
18637	2382	31	tax	tax	NN
18637	2382	32	on	on	IN
18637	2382	33	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2382	34	and	and	CC
18637	2382	35	stage	stage	NN
18637	2382	36	companies	company	NNS
18637	2382	37	for	for	IN
18637	2382	38	every	every	DT
18637	2382	39	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	2382	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2382	41	carried	carry	VBD
18637	2382	42	out	out	IN
18637	2382	43	of	of	IN
18637	2382	44	the	the	DT
18637	2382	45	State	State	NNP
18637	2382	46	,	,	,
18637	2382	47	and	and	CC
18637	2382	48	in	in	IN
18637	2382	49	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	2382	50	_	_	NNP
18637	2382	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	2382	52	_	_	NNP
18637	2382	53	Nevada[617	Nevada[617	NNP
18637	2382	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2382	55	this	this	DT
18637	2382	56	act	act	NN
18637	2382	57	was	be	VBD
18637	2382	58	held	hold	VBN
18637	2382	59	void	void	JJ
18637	2382	60	on	on	IN
18637	2382	61	the	the	DT
18637	2382	62	general	general	JJ
18637	2382	63	ground	ground	NN
18637	2382	64	that	that	IN
18637	2382	65	the	the	DT
18637	2382	66	National	National	NNP
18637	2382	67	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2382	68	had	have	VBD
18637	2382	69	at	at	IN
18637	2382	70	all	all	DT
18637	2382	71	times	time	NNS
18637	2382	72	the	the	DT
18637	2382	73	right	right	NN
18637	2382	74	to	to	TO
18637	2382	75	require	require	VB
18637	2382	76	the	the	DT
18637	2382	77	services	service	NNS
18637	2382	78	of	of	IN
18637	2382	79	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2382	80	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	2382	81	at	at	IN
18637	2382	82	the	the	DT
18637	2382	83	seat	seat	NN
18637	2382	84	of	of	IN
18637	2382	85	government	government	NN
18637	2382	86	and	and	CC
18637	2382	87	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2382	88	the	the	DT
18637	2382	89	correlative	correlative	JJ
18637	2382	90	right	right	NN
18637	2382	91	to	to	TO
18637	2382	92	visit	visit	VB
18637	2382	93	the	the	DT
18637	2382	94	seat	seat	NN
18637	2382	95	of	of	IN
18637	2382	96	government	government	NN
18637	2382	97	,	,	,
18637	2382	98	rights	right	NNS
18637	2382	99	which	which	WDT
18637	2382	100	,	,	,
18637	2382	101	if	if	IN
18637	2382	102	the	the	DT
18637	2382	103	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	2382	104	tax	tax	NN
18637	2382	105	was	be	VBD
18637	2382	106	valid	valid	JJ
18637	2382	107	,	,	,
18637	2382	108	were	be	VBD
18637	2382	109	at	at	IN
18637	2382	110	the	the	DT
18637	2382	111	mercy	mercy	NN
18637	2382	112	of	of	IN
18637	2382	113	any	any	DT
18637	2382	114	State	State	NNP
18637	2382	115	,	,	,
18637	2382	116	the	the	DT
18637	2382	117	power	power	NN
18637	2382	118	to	to	TO
18637	2382	119	tax	tax	NN
18637	2382	120	being	being	NN
18637	2382	121	without	without	IN
18637	2382	122	limit	limit	NN
18637	2382	123	.	.	.
18637	2383	1	Reference	reference	NN
18637	2383	2	was	be	VBD
18637	2383	3	also	also	RB
18637	2383	4	made	make	VBN
18637	2383	5	to	to	IN
18637	2383	6	the	the	DT
18637	2383	7	right	right	NN
18637	2383	8	of	of	IN
18637	2383	9	the	the	DT
18637	2383	10	government	government	NN
18637	2383	11	to	to	TO
18637	2383	12	transport	transport	VB
18637	2383	13	troops	troop	NNS
18637	2383	14	at	at	IN
18637	2383	15	all	all	DT
18637	2383	16	times	time	NNS
18637	2383	17	by	by	IN
18637	2383	18	the	the	DT
18637	2383	19	most	most	RBS
18637	2383	20	expeditious	expeditious	JJ
18637	2383	21	method	method	NN
18637	2383	22	.	.	.
18637	2384	1	Two	two	CD
18637	2384	2	of	of	IN
18637	2384	3	the	the	DT
18637	2384	4	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	2384	5	,	,	,
18637	2384	6	however	however	RB
18637	2384	7	,	,	,
18637	2384	8	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	2384	9	this	this	DT
18637	2384	10	line	line	NN
18637	2384	11	of	of	IN
18637	2384	12	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	2384	13	and	and	CC
18637	2384	14	held	hold	VBD
18637	2384	15	the	the	DT
18637	2384	16	act	act	NN
18637	2384	17	to	to	TO
18637	2384	18	be	be	VB
18637	2384	19	void	void	JJ
18637	2384	20	under	under	IN
18637	2384	21	the	the	DT
18637	2384	22	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2384	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	2384	24	.	.	.
18637	2385	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2385	2	618	618	CD
18637	2385	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2385	4	But	but	CC
18637	2385	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2385	6	was	be	VBD
18637	2385	7	not	not	RB
18637	2385	8	until	until	IN
18637	2385	9	1885	1885	CD
18637	2385	10	that	that	IN
18637	2385	11	the	the	DT
18637	2385	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2385	13	,	,	,
18637	2385	14	in	in	IN
18637	2385	15	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	2385	16	Gloucester	Gloucester	NNP
18637	2385	17	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	2385	18	Company	Company	NNP
18637	2385	19	_	_	NNP
18637	2385	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	2385	21	_	_	NNP
18637	2385	22	Pennsylvania,[619	Pennsylvania,[619	NNP
18637	2385	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2385	24	stated	state	VBN
18637	2385	25	flatly	flatly	RB
18637	2385	26	that	that	IN
18637	2385	27	"	"	``
18637	2385	28	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2385	29	among	among	IN
18637	2385	30	the	the	DT
18637	2385	31	States	States	NNP
18637	2385	32	*	*	NFP
18637	2385	33	*	*	NFP
18637	2385	34	*	*	NFP
18637	2385	35	includes	include	VBZ
18637	2385	36	the	the	DT
18637	2385	37	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2385	38	of	of	IN
18637	2385	39	persons,"[620	persons,"[620	NN
18637	2385	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2385	41	and	and	CC
18637	2385	42	hence	hence	RB
18637	2385	43	was	be	VBD
18637	2385	44	not	not	RB
18637	2385	45	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	2385	46	by	by	IN
18637	2385	47	the	the	DT
18637	2385	48	States	States	NNP
18637	2385	49	,	,	,
18637	2385	50	a	a	DT
18637	2385	51	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	2385	52	which	which	WDT
18637	2385	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	2385	54	still	still	RB
18637	2385	55	good	good	JJ
18637	2385	56	law	law	NN
18637	2385	57	.	.	.
18637	2386	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2386	2	621	621	CD
18637	2386	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2386	4	Four	four	CD
18637	2386	5	years	year	NNS
18637	2386	6	earlier	early	RBR
18637	2386	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2386	8	had	have	VBD
18637	2386	9	been	be	VBN
18637	2386	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	2386	11	that	that	IN
18637	2386	12	the	the	DT
18637	2386	13	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	2386	14	of	of	IN
18637	2386	15	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	2386	16	messages	message	NNS
18637	2386	17	from	from	IN
18637	2386	18	one	one	CD
18637	2386	19	State	state	NN
18637	2386	20	to	to	IN
18637	2386	21	another	another	DT
18637	2386	22	,	,	,
18637	2386	23	being	be	VBG
18637	2386	24	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2386	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2386	26	,	,	,
18637	2386	27	was	be	VBD
18637	2386	28	something	something	NN
18637	2386	29	that	that	WDT
18637	2386	30	the	the	DT
18637	2386	31	State	State	NNP
18637	2386	32	of	of	IN
18637	2386	33	origin	origin	NN
18637	2386	34	could	could	MD
18637	2386	35	not	not	RB
18637	2386	36	tax	tax	VB
18637	2386	37	.	.	.
18637	2387	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2387	2	622	622	CD
18637	2387	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2387	4	State	State	NNP
18637	2387	5	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	2387	6	of	of	IN
18637	2387	7	the	the	DT
18637	2387	8	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2387	9	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2387	10	Privilege	Privilege	NNP
18637	2387	11	:	:	:
18637	2387	12	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	2387	13	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2387	14	DOCTRINAL	doctrinal	VBP
18637	2387	15	HISTORY	history	NN
18637	2387	16	In	in	IN
18637	2387	17	the	the	DT
18637	2387	18	famous	famous	JJ
18637	2387	19	case	case	NN
18637	2387	20	of	of	IN
18637	2387	21	Paul	Paul	NNP
18637	2387	22	_	_	NNP
18637	2387	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	2387	24	_	_	NNP
18637	2387	25	Virginia,[623	Virginia,[623	NNP
18637	2387	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2387	27	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2387	28	in	in	IN
18637	2387	29	1869	1869	CD
18637	2387	30	,	,	,
18637	2387	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2387	32	was	be	VBD
18637	2387	33	held	hold	VBN
18637	2387	34	that	that	IN
18637	2387	35	a	a	DT
18637	2387	36	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2387	37	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	2387	38	by	by	IN
18637	2387	39	one	one	CD
18637	2387	40	State	State	NNP
18637	2387	41	could	could	MD
18637	2387	42	enter	enter	VB
18637	2387	43	other	other	JJ
18637	2387	44	States	state	NNS
18637	2387	45	only	only	RB
18637	2387	46	with	with	IN
18637	2387	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2387	48	assent	assent	NN
18637	2387	49	,	,	,
18637	2387	50	which	which	WDT
18637	2387	51	might	may	MD
18637	2387	52	"	"	``
18637	2387	53	be	be	VB
18637	2387	54	granted	grant	VBN
18637	2387	55	upon	upon	IN
18637	2387	56	such	such	JJ
18637	2387	57	terms	term	NNS
18637	2387	58	and	and	CC
18637	2387	59	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2387	60	as	as	IN
18637	2387	61	those	those	DT
18637	2387	62	States	state	NNS
18637	2387	63	may	may	MD
18637	2387	64	think	think	VB
18637	2387	65	proper	proper	JJ
18637	2387	66	to	to	IN
18637	2387	67	impose";[624	impose";[624	''
18637	2387	68	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2387	69	but	but	CC
18637	2387	70	along	along	IN
18637	2387	71	with	with	IN
18637	2387	72	this	this	DT
18637	2387	73	holding	holding	NN
18637	2387	74	went	go	VBD
18637	2387	75	the	the	DT
18637	2387	76	statement	statement	NN
18637	2387	77	that	that	IN
18637	2387	78	"	"	``
18637	2387	79	the	the	DT
18637	2387	80	power	power	NN
18637	2387	81	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	2387	82	upon	upon	IN
18637	2387	83	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2387	84	to	to	TO
18637	2387	85	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2387	86	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2387	87	includes	include	VBZ
18637	2387	88	as	as	IN
18637	2387	89	well	well	RB
18637	2387	90	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2387	91	carried	carry	VBN
18637	2387	92	on	on	RP
18637	2387	93	by	by	IN
18637	2387	94	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2387	95	as	as	IN
18637	2387	96	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2387	97	carried	carry	VBN
18637	2387	98	on	on	RP
18637	2387	99	by	by	IN
18637	2387	100	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	2387	101	.	.	.
18637	2388	1	"	"	``
18637	2388	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2388	3	625	625	CD
18637	2388	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2388	5	And	and	CC
18637	2388	6	in	in	IN
18637	2388	7	the	the	DT
18637	2388	8	State	State	NNP
18637	2388	9	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	2388	10	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	2388	11	Case	Case	NNP
18637	2388	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2388	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	2388	14	implied	imply	VBN
18637	2388	15	that	that	IN
18637	2388	16	no	no	DT
18637	2388	17	State	state	NN
18637	2388	18	can	can	MD
18637	2388	19	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2388	20	or	or	CC
18637	2388	21	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	2388	22	the	the	DT
18637	2388	23	right	right	NN
18637	2388	24	of	of	IN
18637	2388	25	a	a	DT
18637	2388	26	"	"	``
18637	2388	27	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2388	28	"	"	''
18637	2388	29	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2388	30	--	--	:
18637	2388	31	one	one	CD
18637	2388	32	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	2388	33	by	by	IN
18637	2388	34	another	another	DT
18637	2388	35	State	state	NN
18637	2388	36	--	--	:
18637	2388	37	to	to	TO
18637	2388	38	carry	carry	VB
18637	2388	39	on	on	IN
18637	2388	40	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2388	41	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2388	42	within	within	IN
18637	2388	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2388	44	borders,[626	borders,[626	NNS
18637	2388	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2388	46	an	an	DT
18637	2388	47	implication	implication	NN
18637	2388	48	which	which	WDT
18637	2388	49	soon	soon	RB
18637	2388	50	became	become	VBD
18637	2388	51	explicit	explicit	JJ
18637	2388	52	.	.	.
18637	2389	1	In	in	IN
18637	2389	2	Leloup	Leloup	NNP
18637	2389	3	_	_	NNP
18637	2389	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	2389	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2389	6	Port	Port	NNP
18637	2389	7	of	of	IN
18637	2389	8	Mobile,[627	Mobile,[627	NNP
18637	2389	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2389	10	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2389	11	in	in	IN
18637	2389	12	1888	1888	CD
18637	2389	13	,	,	,
18637	2389	14	the	the	DT
18637	2389	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2389	16	had	have	VBD
18637	2389	17	before	before	IN
18637	2389	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2389	19	a	a	DT
18637	2389	20	license	license	NN
18637	2389	21	tax	tax	NN
18637	2389	22	on	on	IN
18637	2389	23	a	a	DT
18637	2389	24	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	2389	25	company	company	NN
18637	2389	26	which	which	WDT
18637	2389	27	was	be	VBD
18637	2389	28	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2389	29	in	in	IN
18637	2389	30	both	both	CC
18637	2389	31	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	2389	32	and	and	CC
18637	2389	33	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2389	34	business	business	NN
18637	2389	35	.	.	.
18637	2390	1	The	the	DT
18637	2390	2	general	general	JJ
18637	2390	3	nature	nature	NN
18637	2390	4	of	of	IN
18637	2390	5	the	the	DT
18637	2390	6	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	2390	7	did	do	VBD
18637	2390	8	not	not	RB
18637	2390	9	suffice	suffice	VB
18637	2390	10	to	to	TO
18637	2390	11	save	save	VB
18637	2390	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2390	13	.	.	.
18637	2391	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	2391	2	the	the	DT
18637	2391	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2391	4	:	:	:
18637	2391	5	"	"	``
18637	2391	6	The	the	DT
18637	2391	7	question	question	NN
18637	2391	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	2391	9	squarely	squarely	RB
18637	2391	10	presented	present	VBN
18637	2391	11	to	to	IN
18637	2391	12	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2391	13	,	,	,
18637	2391	14	*	*	NFP
18637	2391	15	*	*	NFP
18637	2391	16	*	*	NFP
18637	2391	17	,	,	,
18637	2391	18	whether	whether	IN
18637	2391	19	a	a	DT
18637	2391	20	State	State	NNP
18637	2391	21	,	,	,
18637	2391	22	as	as	IN
18637	2391	23	a	a	DT
18637	2391	24	condition	condition	NN
18637	2391	25	of	of	IN
18637	2391	26	doing	do	VBG
18637	2391	27	business	business	NN
18637	2391	28	within	within	IN
18637	2391	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2391	30	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2391	31	,	,	,
18637	2391	32	may	may	MD
18637	2391	33	exact	exact	VB
18637	2391	34	a	a	DT
18637	2391	35	license	license	NN
18637	2391	36	tax	tax	NN
18637	2391	37	from	from	IN
18637	2391	38	a	a	DT
18637	2391	39	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	2391	40	company	company	NN
18637	2391	41	,	,	,
18637	2391	42	a	a	DT
18637	2391	43	large	large	JJ
18637	2391	44	part	part	NN
18637	2391	45	of	of	IN
18637	2391	46	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2391	47	business	business	NN
18637	2391	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	2391	49	the	the	DT
18637	2391	50	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	2391	51	of	of	IN
18637	2391	52	messages	message	NNS
18637	2391	53	from	from	IN
18637	2391	54	one	one	CD
18637	2391	55	State	state	NN
18637	2391	56	to	to	IN
18637	2391	57	another	another	DT
18637	2391	58	and	and	CC
18637	2391	59	between	between	IN
18637	2391	60	the	the	DT
18637	2391	61	United	United	NNP
18637	2391	62	States	States	NNP
18637	2391	63	and	and	CC
18637	2391	64	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2391	65	countries	country	NNS
18637	2391	66	,	,	,
18637	2391	67	and	and	CC
18637	2391	68	which	which	WDT
18637	2391	69	is	be	VBZ
18637	2391	70	invested	invest	VBN
18637	2391	71	with	with	IN
18637	2391	72	the	the	DT
18637	2391	73	powers	power	NNS
18637	2391	74	and	and	CC
18637	2391	75	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	2391	76	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	2391	77	by	by	IN
18637	2391	78	the	the	DT
18637	2391	79	act	act	NN
18637	2391	80	of	of	IN
18637	2391	81	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2391	82	passed	pass	VBD
18637	2391	83	July	July	NNP
18637	2391	84	24	24	CD
18637	2391	85	,	,	,
18637	2391	86	1866	1866	CD
18637	2391	87	,	,	,
18637	2391	88	and	and	CC
18637	2391	89	other	other	JJ
18637	2391	90	acts	act	NNS
18637	2391	91	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	2391	92	in	in	IN
18637	2391	93	Title	Title	NNP
18637	2391	94	LXV	LXV	NNP
18637	2391	95	of	of	IN
18637	2391	96	the	the	DT
18637	2391	97	Revised	revise	VBN
18637	2391	98	Statutes	statute	NNS
18637	2391	99	?	?	.
18637	2392	1	Can	Can	MD
18637	2392	2	a	a	DT
18637	2392	3	State	state	NN
18637	2392	4	prohibit	prohibit	NN
18637	2392	5	such	such	PDT
18637	2392	6	a	a	DT
18637	2392	7	company	company	NN
18637	2392	8	from	from	IN
18637	2392	9	doing	do	VBG
18637	2392	10	such	such	PDT
18637	2392	11	a	a	DT
18637	2392	12	business	business	NN
18637	2392	13	within	within	IN
18637	2392	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2392	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2392	16	,	,	,
18637	2392	17	unless	unless	IN
18637	2392	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2392	19	will	will	MD
18637	2392	20	pay	pay	VB
18637	2392	21	a	a	DT
18637	2392	22	tax	tax	NN
18637	2392	23	and	and	CC
18637	2392	24	procure	procure	VB
18637	2392	25	a	a	DT
18637	2392	26	license	license	NN
18637	2392	27	for	for	IN
18637	2392	28	the	the	DT
18637	2392	29	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2392	30	?	?	.
18637	2393	1	If	if	IN
18637	2393	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2393	3	can	can	MD
18637	2393	4	,	,	,
18637	2393	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2393	6	can	can	MD
18637	2393	7	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	2393	8	such	such	JJ
18637	2393	9	companies	company	NNS
18637	2393	10	,	,	,
18637	2393	11	and	and	CC
18637	2393	12	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2393	13	the	the	DT
18637	2393	14	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	2393	15	of	of	IN
18637	2393	16	such	such	JJ
18637	2393	17	business	business	NN
18637	2393	18	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	2393	19	.	.	.
18637	2394	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2394	2	are	be	VBP
18637	2394	3	not	not	RB
18637	2394	4	prepared	prepared	JJ
18637	2394	5	to	to	TO
18637	2394	6	say	say	VB
18637	2394	7	that	that	IN
18637	2394	8	this	this	DT
18637	2394	9	can	can	MD
18637	2394	10	be	be	VB
18637	2394	11	done	do	VBN
18637	2394	12	.	.	.
18637	2395	1	"	"	``
18637	2395	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2395	3	628	628	CD
18637	2395	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2395	5	In	in	IN
18637	2395	6	Crutcher	Crutcher	NNP
18637	2395	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2395	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	2395	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2395	10	Kentucky[629	Kentucky[629	NNP
18637	2395	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2395	12	a	a	DT
18637	2395	13	like	like	JJ
18637	2395	14	result	result	NN
18637	2395	15	was	be	VBD
18637	2395	16	reached	reach	VBN
18637	2395	17	,	,	,
18637	2395	18	without	without	IN
18637	2395	19	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	2395	20	from	from	IN
18637	2395	21	an	an	DT
18637	2395	22	act	act	NN
18637	2395	23	of	of	IN
18637	2395	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2395	25	,	,	,
18637	2395	26	with	with	IN
18637	2395	27	respect	respect	NN
18637	2395	28	to	to	IN
18637	2395	29	a	a	DT
18637	2395	30	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	2395	31	statute	statute	NN
18637	2395	32	which	which	WDT
18637	2395	33	provided	provide	VBD
18637	2395	34	that	that	IN
18637	2395	35	the	the	DT
18637	2395	36	agent	agent	NN
18637	2395	37	of	of	IN
18637	2395	38	an	an	DT
18637	2395	39	express	express	JJ
18637	2395	40	company	company	NN
18637	2395	41	not	not	RB
18637	2395	42	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	2395	43	by	by	IN
18637	2395	44	the	the	DT
18637	2395	45	laws	law	NNS
18637	2395	46	of	of	IN
18637	2395	47	that	that	DT
18637	2395	48	State	State	NNP
18637	2395	49	should	should	MD
18637	2395	50	not	not	RB
18637	2395	51	carry	carry	VB
18637	2395	52	on	on	IN
18637	2395	53	business	business	NN
18637	2395	54	there	there	RB
18637	2395	55	without	without	IN
18637	2395	56	first	first	RB
18637	2395	57	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	2395	58	a	a	DT
18637	2395	59	license	license	NN
18637	2395	60	from	from	IN
18637	2395	61	the	the	DT
18637	2395	62	State	State	NNP
18637	2395	63	,	,	,
18637	2395	64	and	and	CC
18637	2395	65	that	that	IN
18637	2395	66	,	,	,
18637	2395	67	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	2395	68	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	2395	69	,	,	,
18637	2395	70	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2395	71	must	must	MD
18637	2395	72	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	2395	73	the	the	DT
18637	2395	74	auditor	auditor	NN
18637	2395	75	of	of	IN
18637	2395	76	the	the	DT
18637	2395	77	State	State	NNP
18637	2395	78	that	that	WDT
18637	2395	79	the	the	DT
18637	2395	80	company	company	NN
18637	2395	81	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2395	82	represented	represent	VBD
18637	2395	83	was	be	VBD
18637	2395	84	possessed	possess	VBN
18637	2395	85	of	of	IN
18637	2395	86	an	an	DT
18637	2395	87	actual	actual	JJ
18637	2395	88	capital	capital	NN
18637	2395	89	of	of	IN
18637	2395	90	at	at	RB
18637	2395	91	least	least	RBS
18637	2395	92	$	$	$
18637	2395	93	150,000	150,000	CD
18637	2395	94	.	.	.
18637	2396	1	The	the	DT
18637	2396	2	act	act	NN
18637	2396	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2396	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	2396	5	to	to	TO
18637	2396	6	be	be	VB
18637	2396	7	a	a	DT
18637	2396	8	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2396	9	of	of	IN
18637	2396	10	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2396	11	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2396	12	so	so	RB
18637	2396	13	far	far	RB
18637	2396	14	as	as	IN
18637	2396	15	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2396	16	to	to	IN
18637	2396	17	a	a	DT
18637	2396	18	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2396	19	of	of	IN
18637	2396	20	another	another	DT
18637	2396	21	State	State	NNP
18637	2396	22	in	in	IN
18637	2396	23	that	that	DT
18637	2396	24	business	business	NN
18637	2396	25	.	.	.
18637	2397	1	"	"	``
18637	2397	2	To	to	TO
18637	2397	3	carry	carry	VB
18637	2397	4	on	on	IN
18637	2397	5	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2397	6	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2397	7	,	,	,
18637	2397	8	"	"	''
18637	2397	9	said	say	VBD
18637	2397	10	the	the	DT
18637	2397	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2397	12	,	,	,
18637	2397	13	"	"	''
18637	2397	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	2397	15	not	not	RB
18637	2397	16	a	a	DT
18637	2397	17	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	2397	18	or	or	CC
18637	2397	19	a	a	DT
18637	2397	20	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2397	21	granted	grant	VBN
18637	2397	22	by	by	IN
18637	2397	23	the	the	DT
18637	2397	24	State	state	NN
18637	2397	25	;	;	:
18637	2397	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2397	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	2397	28	a	a	DT
18637	2397	29	right	right	JJ
18637	2397	30	which	which	WDT
18637	2397	31	every	every	DT
18637	2397	32	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2397	33	of	of	IN
18637	2397	34	the	the	DT
18637	2397	35	United	United	NNP
18637	2397	36	States	States	NNP
18637	2397	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	2397	38	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	2397	39	to	to	TO
18637	2397	40	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	2397	41	under	under	IN
18637	2397	42	the	the	DT
18637	2397	43	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2397	44	and	and	CC
18637	2397	45	laws	law	NNS
18637	2397	46	of	of	IN
18637	2397	47	the	the	DT
18637	2397	48	United	United	NNP
18637	2397	49	States	States	NNP
18637	2397	50	;	;	:
18637	2397	51	and	and	CC
18637	2397	52	the	the	DT
18637	2397	53	accession	accession	NN
18637	2397	54	of	of	IN
18637	2397	55	mere	mere	JJ
18637	2397	56	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	2397	57	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	2397	58	,	,	,
18637	2397	59	as	as	IN
18637	2397	60	a	a	DT
18637	2397	61	matter	matter	NN
18637	2397	62	of	of	IN
18637	2397	63	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	2397	64	in	in	IN
18637	2397	65	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	2397	66	on	on	IN
18637	2397	67	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2397	68	business	business	NN
18637	2397	69	,	,	,
18637	2397	70	can	can	MD
18637	2397	71	not	not	RB
18637	2397	72	have	have	VB
18637	2397	73	the	the	DT
18637	2397	74	effect	effect	NN
18637	2397	75	of	of	IN
18637	2397	76	depriving	deprive	VBG
18637	2397	77	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2397	78	of	of	IN
18637	2397	79	such	such	JJ
18637	2397	80	right	right	NN
18637	2397	81	,	,	,
18637	2397	82	unless	unless	IN
18637	2397	83	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2397	84	should	should	MD
18637	2397	85	see	see	VB
18637	2397	86	fit	fit	JJ
18637	2397	87	to	to	TO
18637	2397	88	interpose	interpose	VB
18637	2397	89	some	some	DT
18637	2397	90	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	2397	91	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2397	92	on	on	IN
18637	2397	93	the	the	DT
18637	2397	94	subject	subject	NN
18637	2397	95	.	.	.
18637	2398	1	"	"	``
18637	2398	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2398	3	630	630	CD
18637	2398	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2398	5	LICENSE	license	NN
18637	2398	6	TAXES	taxis	NNS
18637	2398	7	The	the	DT
18637	2398	8	demand	demand	NN
18637	2398	9	for	for	IN
18637	2398	10	what	what	WP
18637	2398	11	in	in	IN
18637	2398	12	effect	effect	NN
18637	2398	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	2398	14	a	a	DT
18637	2398	15	license	license	NN
18637	2398	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	2398	17	,	,	,
18637	2398	18	of	of	IN
18637	2398	19	course	course	NN
18637	2398	20	,	,	,
18637	2398	21	capable	capable	JJ
18637	2398	22	of	of	IN
18637	2398	23	assuming	assume	VBG
18637	2398	24	various	various	JJ
18637	2398	25	guises	guise	NNS
18637	2398	26	.	.	.
18637	2399	1	In	in	IN
18637	2399	2	Ozark	Ozark	NNP
18637	2399	3	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	2399	4	Line	Line	NNP
18637	2399	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2399	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	2399	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2399	8	Monier[631	Monier[631	NNP
18637	2399	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2399	10	an	an	DT
18637	2399	11	annual	annual	JJ
18637	2399	12	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	2399	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	2399	14	on	on	IN
18637	2399	15	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2399	16	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2399	17	equal	equal	JJ
18637	2399	18	to	to	IN
18637	2399	19	one	one	CD
18637	2399	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	2399	21	tenth	tenth	NN
18637	2399	22	of	of	IN
18637	2399	23	one	one	CD
18637	2399	24	per	per	IN
18637	2399	25	cent	cent	NN
18637	2399	26	of	of	IN
18637	2399	27	the	the	DT
18637	2399	28	par	par	NN
18637	2399	29	value	value	NN
18637	2399	30	of	of	IN
18637	2399	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2399	32	capital	capital	NN
18637	2399	33	stock	stock	NN
18637	2399	34	and	and	CC
18637	2399	35	surplus	surplus	NN
18637	2399	36	employed	employ	VBN
18637	2399	37	in	in	IN
18637	2399	38	business	business	NN
18637	2399	39	in	in	IN
18637	2399	40	the	the	DT
18637	2399	41	State	State	NNP
18637	2399	42	was	be	VBD
18637	2399	43	found	find	VBN
18637	2399	44	to	to	TO
18637	2399	45	be	be	VB
18637	2399	46	a	a	DT
18637	2399	47	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2399	48	tax	tax	NN
18637	2399	49	,	,	,
18637	2399	50	and	and	CC
18637	2399	51	hence	hence	RB
18637	2399	52	one	one	CD
18637	2399	53	which	which	WDT
18637	2399	54	could	could	MD
18637	2399	55	not	not	RB
18637	2399	56	be	be	VB
18637	2399	57	exacted	exact	VBN
18637	2399	58	of	of	IN
18637	2399	59	a	a	DT
18637	2399	60	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2399	61	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2399	62	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2399	63	business	business	NN
18637	2399	64	in	in	IN
18637	2399	65	the	the	DT
18637	2399	66	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2399	67	State	state	NN
18637	2399	68	consisted	consist	VBD
18637	2399	69	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	2399	70	of	of	IN
18637	2399	71	the	the	DT
18637	2399	72	operation	operation	NN
18637	2399	73	of	of	IN
18637	2399	74	a	a	DT
18637	2399	75	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	2399	76	line	line	NN
18637	2399	77	for	for	IN
18637	2399	78	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	2399	79	petroleum	petroleum	NN
18637	2399	80	through	through	IN
18637	2399	81	the	the	DT
18637	2399	82	State	State	NNP
18637	2399	83	in	in	IN
18637	2399	84	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2399	85	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2399	86	,	,	,
18637	2399	87	and	and	CC
18637	2399	88	of	of	IN
18637	2399	89	activities	activity	NNS
18637	2399	90	the	the	DT
18637	2399	91	sole	sole	JJ
18637	2399	92	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2399	93	of	of	IN
18637	2399	94	which	which	WDT
18637	2399	95	was	be	VBD
18637	2399	96	the	the	DT
18637	2399	97	furtherance	furtherance	NN
18637	2399	98	of	of	IN
18637	2399	99	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2399	100	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2399	101	business	business	NN
18637	2399	102	.	.	.
18637	2400	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	2400	2	a	a	DT
18637	2400	3	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	2400	4	tax	tax	NN
18637	2400	5	based	base	VBN
18637	2400	6	on	on	IN
18637	2400	7	"	"	``
18637	2400	8	the	the	DT
18637	2400	9	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	2400	10	surplus	surplus	NN
18637	2400	11	"	"	''
18637	2400	12	of	of	IN
18637	2400	13	a	a	DT
18637	2400	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2400	15	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2400	16	having	have	VBG
18637	2400	17	only	only	RB
18637	2400	18	an	an	DT
18637	2400	19	office	office	NN
18637	2400	20	in	in	IN
18637	2400	21	the	the	DT
18637	2400	22	State	State	NNP
18637	2400	23	for	for	IN
18637	2400	24	the	the	DT
18637	2400	25	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	2400	26	of	of	IN
18637	2400	27	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2400	28	business	business	NN
18637	2400	29	was	be	VBD
18637	2400	30	held	hold	VBN
18637	2400	31	in	in	IN
18637	2400	32	Alpha	Alpha	NNP
18637	2400	33	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	2400	34	Cement	Cement	NNP
18637	2400	35	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2400	36	_	_	NNP
18637	2400	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	2400	38	_	_	NNP
18637	2400	39	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	2400	40	to	to	TO
18637	2400	41	be	be	VB
18637	2400	42	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	2400	43	an	an	DT
18637	2400	44	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	2400	45	to	to	TO
18637	2400	46	license	license	VB
18637	2400	47	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2400	48	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2400	49	.	.	.
18637	2401	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2401	2	632	632	CD
18637	2401	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2401	4	In	in	IN
18637	2401	5	the	the	DT
18637	2401	6	same	same	JJ
18637	2401	7	category	category	NN
18637	2401	8	of	of	IN
18637	2401	9	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2401	10	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2401	11	of	of	IN
18637	2401	12	the	the	DT
18637	2401	13	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2401	14	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2401	15	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2401	16	,	,	,
18637	2401	17	the	the	DT
18637	2401	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2401	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	2401	20	also	also	RB
18637	2401	21	included	include	VBN
18637	2401	22	the	the	DT
18637	2401	23	following	follow	VBG
18637	2401	24	:	:	:
18637	2401	25	a	a	DT
18637	2401	26	State	State	NNP
18637	2401	27	"	"	``
18637	2401	28	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	2401	29	"	"	''
18637	2401	30	tax	tax	NN
18637	2401	31	on	on	IN
18637	2401	32	a	a	DT
18637	2401	33	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2401	34	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2401	35	,	,	,
18637	2401	36	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2401	37	sole	sole	JJ
18637	2401	38	business	business	NN
18637	2401	39	in	in	IN
18637	2401	40	the	the	DT
18637	2401	41	State	State	NNP
18637	2401	42	consisted	consist	VBD
18637	2401	43	in	in	IN
18637	2401	44	landing	landing	NN
18637	2401	45	,	,	,
18637	2401	46	storing	store	VBG
18637	2401	47	and	and	CC
18637	2401	48	selling	sell	VBG
18637	2401	49	in	in	IN
18637	2401	50	the	the	DT
18637	2401	51	original	original	JJ
18637	2401	52	package	package	NN
18637	2401	53	goods	good	NNS
18637	2401	54	imported	import	VBN
18637	2401	55	by	by	IN
18637	2401	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2401	57	from	from	IN
18637	2401	58	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	2401	59	,	,	,
18637	2401	60	the	the	DT
18637	2401	61	tax	tax	NN
18637	2401	62	being	being	NN
18637	2401	63	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2401	64	annually	annually	RB
18637	2401	65	on	on	IN
18637	2401	66	the	the	DT
18637	2401	67	doing	doing	NN
18637	2401	68	of	of	IN
18637	2401	69	such	such	JJ
18637	2401	70	business	business	NN
18637	2401	71	and	and	CC
18637	2401	72	measured	measure	VBN
18637	2401	73	by	by	IN
18637	2401	74	the	the	DT
18637	2401	75	value	value	NN
18637	2401	76	of	of	IN
18637	2401	77	the	the	DT
18637	2401	78	goods	good	NNS
18637	2401	79	on	on	IN
18637	2401	80	hand;[633	hand;[633	NNPS
18637	2401	81	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2401	82	a	a	DT
18637	2401	83	State	state	NN
18637	2401	84	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2401	85	or	or	CC
18637	2401	86	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	2401	87	tax	tax	NN
18637	2401	88	on	on	IN
18637	2401	89	every	every	DT
18637	2401	90	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2401	91	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2401	92	in	in	IN
18637	2401	93	the	the	DT
18637	2401	94	business	business	NN
18637	2401	95	of	of	IN
18637	2401	96	operating	operate	VBG
18637	2401	97	and	and	CC
18637	2401	98	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	2401	99	telephone	telephone	NN
18637	2401	100	lines	line	NNS
18637	2401	101	and	and	CC
18637	2401	102	furnishing	furnish	VBG
18637	2401	103	telephone	telephone	NN
18637	2401	104	service	service	NN
18637	2401	105	in	in	IN
18637	2401	106	the	the	DT
18637	2401	107	State	State	NNP
18637	2401	108	,	,	,
18637	2401	109	of	of	IN
18637	2401	110	so	so	RB
18637	2401	111	much	much	JJ
18637	2401	112	for	for	IN
18637	2401	113	each	each	DT
18637	2401	114	telephonic	telephonic	JJ
18637	2401	115	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	2401	116	controlled	control	VBN
18637	2401	117	and	and	CC
18637	2401	118	operated	operate	VBN
18637	2401	119	by	by	IN
18637	2401	120	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2401	121	,	,	,
18637	2401	122	as	as	IN
18637	2401	123	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2401	124	to	to	IN
18637	2401	125	a	a	DT
18637	2401	126	company	company	NN
18637	2401	127	furnishing	furnish	VBG
18637	2401	128	both	both	CC
18637	2401	129	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2401	130	and	and	CC
18637	2401	131	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2401	132	service	service	NN
18637	2401	133	,	,	,
18637	2401	134	and	and	CC
18637	2401	135	employing	employ	VBG
18637	2401	136	the	the	DT
18637	2401	137	same	same	JJ
18637	2401	138	telephones	telephone	NNS
18637	2401	139	,	,	,
18637	2401	140	wires	wire	NNS
18637	2401	141	,	,	,
18637	2401	142	etc	etc	FW
18637	2401	143	.	.	FW
18637	2401	144	,	,	,
18637	2401	145	in	in	IN
18637	2401	146	both	both	DT
18637	2401	147	as	as	IN
18637	2401	148	integrated	integrated	JJ
18637	2401	149	parts	part	NNS
18637	2401	150	of	of	IN
18637	2401	151	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2401	152	system;[634	system;[634	CD
18637	2401	153	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2401	154	a	a	DT
18637	2401	155	State	state	NN
18637	2401	156	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	2401	157	tax	tax	NN
18637	2401	158	measured	measure	VBN
18637	2401	159	by	by	IN
18637	2401	160	the	the	DT
18637	2401	161	entire	entire	JJ
18637	2401	162	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2401	163	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2401	164	of	of	IN
18637	2401	165	the	the	DT
18637	2401	166	business	business	NN
18637	2401	167	of	of	IN
18637	2401	168	a	a	DT
18637	2401	169	radio	radio	NN
18637	2401	170	broadcasting	broadcasting	NN
18637	2401	171	station	station	NN
18637	2401	172	,	,	,
18637	2401	173	licensed	license	VBN
18637	2401	174	by	by	IN
18637	2401	175	the	the	DT
18637	2401	176	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2401	177	Communications	Communications	NNPS
18637	2401	178	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2401	179	,	,	,
18637	2401	180	and	and	CC
18637	2401	181	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	2401	182	in	in	IN
18637	2401	183	broadcasting	broadcast	VBG
18637	2401	184	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	2401	185	"	"	``
18637	2401	186	programs	program	NNS
18637	2401	187	"	"	''
18637	2401	188	for	for	IN
18637	2401	189	customers	customer	NNS
18637	2401	190	for	for	IN
18637	2401	191	hire	hire	NN
18637	2401	192	to	to	IN
18637	2401	193	listeners	listener	NNS
18637	2401	194	within	within	IN
18637	2401	195	and	and	CC
18637	2401	196	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	2401	197	the	the	DT
18637	2401	198	State	State	NNP
18637	2401	199	,	,	,
18637	2401	200	since	since	IN
18637	2401	201	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2401	202	did	do	VBD
18637	2401	203	not	not	RB
18637	2401	204	"	"	``
18637	2401	205	appear	appear	VB
18637	2401	206	that	that	IN
18637	2401	207	any	any	DT
18637	2401	208	of	of	IN
18637	2401	209	the	the	DT
18637	2401	210	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	2401	211	income	income	NN
18637	2401	212	...	...	:
18637	2401	213	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2401	214	was	be	VBD
18637	2401	215	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2401	216	allocable	allocable	JJ
18637	2401	217	to	to	TO
18637	2401	218	interstate	interstate	VB
18637	2401	219	commerce";[635	commerce";[635	.
18637	2401	220	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2401	221	a	a	DT
18637	2401	222	State	state	NN
18637	2401	223	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	2401	224	tax	tax	NN
18637	2401	225	on	on	IN
18637	2401	226	the	the	DT
18637	2401	227	business	business	NN
18637	2401	228	of	of	IN
18637	2401	229	loading	loading	NN
18637	2401	230	and	and	CC
18637	2401	231	unloading	unloading	NN
18637	2401	232	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2401	233	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2401	234	in	in	IN
18637	2401	235	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2401	236	and	and	CC
18637	2401	237	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2401	238	commerce;[636	commerce;[636	:
18637	2401	239	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2401	240	an	an	DT
18637	2401	241	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	2401	242	income	income	NN
18637	2401	243	tax	tax	NN
18637	2401	244	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2401	245	on	on	IN
18637	2401	246	the	the	DT
18637	2401	247	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2401	248	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2401	249	from	from	IN
18637	2401	250	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2401	251	inasmuch	inasmuch	NNP
18637	2401	252	as	as	IN
18637	2401	253	the	the	DT
18637	2401	254	tax	tax	NN
18637	2401	255	reached	reach	VBD
18637	2401	256	indiscriminately	indiscriminately	RB
18637	2401	257	and	and	CC
18637	2401	258	without	without	IN
18637	2401	259	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	2401	260	the	the	DT
18637	2401	261	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2401	262	income	income	NN
18637	2401	263	from	from	IN
18637	2401	264	both	both	DT
18637	2401	265	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2401	266	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2401	267	and	and	CC
18637	2401	268	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2401	269	activities;[637	activities;[637	NNP
18637	2401	270	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2401	271	an	an	DT
18637	2401	272	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	2401	273	statute	statute	NN
18637	2401	274	making	make	VBG
18637	2401	275	entry	entry	NN
18637	2401	276	into	into	IN
18637	2401	277	the	the	DT
18637	2401	278	State	State	NNP
18637	2401	279	of	of	IN
18637	2401	280	motor	motor	NN
18637	2401	281	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2401	282	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	2401	283	more	more	JJR
18637	2401	284	than	than	IN
18637	2401	285	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	2401	286	gallons	gallon	NNS
18637	2401	287	of	of	IN
18637	2401	288	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	2401	289	conditional	conditional	JJ
18637	2401	290	on	on	IN
18637	2401	291	the	the	DT
18637	2401	292	payment	payment	NN
18637	2401	293	of	of	IN
18637	2401	294	an	an	DT
18637	2401	295	excise	excise	NN
18637	2401	296	on	on	IN
18637	2401	297	the	the	DT
18637	2401	298	excess	excess	NN
18637	2401	299	.	.	.
18637	2402	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2402	2	638	638	CD
18637	2402	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2402	4	DOCTRINE	doctrine	NN
18637	2402	5	OF	of	IN
18637	2402	6	WESTERN	WESTERN	NNP
18637	2402	7	UNION	UNION	NNP
18637	2402	8	TELEGRAPH	TELEGRAPH	NNP
18637	2402	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2402	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	2402	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2402	12	KANSAS	KANSAS	NNP
18637	2402	13	EX	EX	NNP
18637	2402	14	REL	REL	NNP
18637	2402	15	.	.	.
18637	2403	1	COLEMAN	COLEMAN	NNP
18637	2403	2	One	one	CD
18637	2403	3	of	of	IN
18637	2403	4	the	the	DT
18637	2403	5	most	most	RBS
18637	2403	6	striking	striking	JJ
18637	2403	7	concessions	concession	NNS
18637	2403	8	ever	ever	RB
18637	2403	9	made	make	VBN
18637	2403	10	by	by	IN
18637	2403	11	the	the	DT
18637	2403	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2403	13	to	to	IN
18637	2403	14	the	the	DT
18637	2403	15	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2403	16	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	2403	17	interest	interest	NN
18637	2403	18	at	at	IN
18637	2403	19	the	the	DT
18637	2403	20	expense	expense	NN
18637	2403	21	of	of	IN
18637	2403	22	the	the	DT
18637	2403	23	State	State	NNP
18637	2403	24	's	's	POS
18637	2403	25	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2403	26	power	power	NN
18637	2403	27	was	be	VBD
18637	2403	28	that	that	IN
18637	2403	29	which	which	WDT
18637	2403	30	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	2403	31	originally	originally	RB
18637	2403	32	in	in	IN
18637	2403	33	1910	1910	CD
18637	2403	34	,	,	,
18637	2403	35	in	in	IN
18637	2403	36	Western	Western	NNP
18637	2403	37	Union	Union	NNP
18637	2403	38	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	2403	39	.	.	.
18637	2404	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2404	2	_	_	NNP
18637	2404	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	2404	4	_	_	NNP
18637	2404	5	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	2404	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	2404	7	rel	rel	NNP
18637	2404	8	.	.	.
18637	2405	1	Coleman,[639	coleman,[639	LS
18637	2405	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2405	3	which	which	WDT
18637	2405	4	involved	involve	VBD
18637	2405	5	a	a	DT
18637	2405	6	percentage	percentage	NN
18637	2405	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	2405	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	2405	9	the	the	DT
18637	2405	10	total	total	JJ
18637	2405	11	capitalization	capitalization	NN
18637	2405	12	of	of	IN
18637	2405	13	all	all	DT
18637	2405	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2405	15	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2405	16	doing	do	VBG
18637	2405	17	or	or	CC
18637	2405	18	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	2405	19	to	to	TO
18637	2405	20	do	do	VB
18637	2405	21	a	a	DT
18637	2405	22	local	local	JJ
18637	2405	23	business	business	NN
18637	2405	24	in	in	IN
18637	2405	25	the	the	DT
18637	2405	26	State	State	NNP
18637	2405	27	.	.	.
18637	2406	1	The	the	DT
18637	2406	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2406	3	pronounced	pronounce	VBD
18637	2406	4	the	the	DT
18637	2406	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	2406	6	,	,	,
18637	2406	7	as	as	IN
18637	2406	8	to	to	IN
18637	2406	9	the	the	DT
18637	2406	10	Western	Western	NNP
18637	2406	11	Union	Union	NNP
18637	2406	12	,	,	,
18637	2406	13	a	a	DT
18637	2406	14	burden	burden	NN
18637	2406	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	2406	16	the	the	DT
18637	2406	17	company	company	NN
18637	2406	18	's	's	POS
18637	2406	19	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2406	20	business	business	NN
18637	2406	21	and	and	CC
18637	2406	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	2406	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2406	24	property	property	NN
18637	2406	25	located	locate	VBN
18637	2406	26	and	and	CC
18637	2406	27	used	use	VBN
18637	2406	28	outside	outside	IN
18637	2406	29	the	the	DT
18637	2406	30	State	state	NN
18637	2406	31	,	,	,
18637	2406	32	and	and	CC
18637	2406	33	hence	hence	RB
18637	2406	34	void	void	JJ
18637	2406	35	under	under	IN
18637	2406	36	both	both	CC
18637	2406	37	the	the	DT
18637	2406	38	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2406	39	clause	clause	NNP
18637	2406	40	and	and	CC
18637	2406	41	the	the	DT
18637	2406	42	due	due	JJ
18637	2406	43	process	process	NN
18637	2406	44	of	of	IN
18637	2406	45	law	law	NN
18637	2406	46	clause	clause	NN
18637	2406	47	of	of	IN
18637	2406	48	the	the	DT
18637	2406	49	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	2406	50	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	2406	51	.	.	.
18637	2407	1	The	the	DT
18637	2407	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	2407	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2407	4	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	2407	5	aided	aid	VBN
18637	2407	6	by	by	IN
18637	2407	7	the	the	DT
18637	2407	8	fact	fact	NN
18637	2407	9	that	that	IN
18637	2407	10	the	the	DT
18637	2407	11	company	company	NN
18637	2407	12	had	have	VBD
18637	2407	13	been	be	VBN
18637	2407	14	doing	do	VBG
18637	2407	15	a	a	DT
18637	2407	16	general	general	JJ
18637	2407	17	telegraphic	telegraphic	JJ
18637	2407	18	business	business	NN
18637	2407	19	within	within	IN
18637	2407	20	the	the	DT
18637	2407	21	State	State	NNP
18637	2407	22	for	for	IN
18637	2407	23	more	more	JJR
18637	2407	24	than	than	IN
18637	2407	25	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	2407	26	years	year	NNS
18637	2407	27	without	without	IN
18637	2407	28	having	have	VBG
18637	2407	29	been	be	VBN
18637	2407	30	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	2407	31	to	to	IN
18637	2407	32	such	such	PDT
18637	2407	33	an	an	DT
18637	2407	34	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	2407	35	.	.	.
18637	2408	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2408	2	640	640	CD
18637	2408	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2408	4	SPREAD	SPREAD	NNP
18637	2408	5	OF	of	IN
18637	2408	6	THE	the	DT
18637	2408	7	DOCTRINE	doctrine	NN
18637	2408	8	The	the	DT
18637	2408	9	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2408	10	of	of	IN
18637	2408	11	the	the	DT
18637	2408	12	case	case	NN
18637	2408	13	,	,	,
18637	2408	14	however	however	RB
18637	2408	15	,	,	,
18637	2408	16	soon	soon	RB
18637	2408	17	cast	cast	VBD
18637	2408	18	off	off	RP
18637	2408	19	these	these	DT
18637	2408	20	initial	initial	JJ
18637	2408	21	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	2408	22	.	.	.
18637	2409	1	In	in	IN
18637	2409	2	Looney	Looney	NNP
18637	2409	3	_	_	NNP
18637	2409	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	2409	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2409	6	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	2409	7	Company[641	Company[641	NNP
18637	2409	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2409	9	a	a	DT
18637	2409	10	similar	similar	JJ
18637	2409	11	tax	tax	NN
18637	2409	12	by	by	IN
18637	2409	13	the	the	DT
18637	2409	14	State	State	NNP
18637	2409	15	of	of	IN
18637	2409	16	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	2409	17	was	be	VBD
18637	2409	18	disallowed	disallow	VBN
18637	2409	19	as	as	IN
18637	2409	20	to	to	IN
18637	2409	21	an	an	DT
18637	2409	22	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	2409	23	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2409	24	,	,	,
18637	2409	25	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2409	26	in	in	IN
18637	2409	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2409	28	home	home	NN
18637	2409	29	State	State	NNP
18637	2409	30	in	in	IN
18637	2409	31	the	the	DT
18637	2409	32	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	2409	33	of	of	IN
18637	2409	34	hardware	hardware	NN
18637	2409	35	,	,	,
18637	2409	36	but	but	CC
18637	2409	37	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	2409	38	in	in	IN
18637	2409	39	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	2409	40	depots	depot	VBZ
18637	2409	41	and	and	CC
18637	2409	42	warehouses	warehouse	NNS
18637	2409	43	from	from	IN
18637	2409	44	which	which	WDT
18637	2409	45	orders	order	NNS
18637	2409	46	were	be	VBD
18637	2409	47	filled	fill	VBN
18637	2409	48	and	and	CC
18637	2409	49	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2409	50	made	make	VBN
18637	2409	51	,	,	,
18637	2409	52	likewise	likewise	RB
18637	2409	53	,	,	,
18637	2409	54	in	in	IN
18637	2409	55	International	International	NNP
18637	2409	56	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	2409	57	Company	Company	NNP
18637	2409	58	_	_	NNP
18637	2409	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	2409	60	_	_	NNP
18637	2409	61	Massachusetts,[642	Massachusetts,[642	NNP
18637	2409	62	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2409	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2409	64	was	be	VBD
18637	2409	65	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	2409	66	stated	state	VBN
18637	2409	67	that	that	IN
18637	2409	68	"	"	``
18637	2409	69	the	the	DT
18637	2409	70	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	2409	71	of	of	IN
18637	2409	72	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2409	73	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2409	74	from	from	IN
18637	2409	75	State	State	NNP
18637	2409	76	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2409	77	"	"	``
18637	2409	78	is	be	VBZ
18637	2409	79	not	not	RB
18637	2409	80	confined	confine	VBN
18637	2409	81	to	to	IN
18637	2409	82	what	what	WP
18637	2409	83	is	be	VBZ
18637	2409	84	done	do	VBN
18637	2409	85	by	by	IN
18637	2409	86	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	2409	87	in	in	IN
18637	2409	88	such	such	JJ
18637	2409	89	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2409	90	,	,	,
18637	2409	91	but	but	CC
18637	2409	92	"	"	``
18637	2409	93	is	be	VBZ
18637	2409	94	universal	universal	JJ
18637	2409	95	and	and	CC
18637	2409	96	covers	cover	VBZ
18637	2409	97	every	every	DT
18637	2409	98	class	class	NN
18637	2409	99	of	of	IN
18637	2409	100	...	...	NFP
18637	2409	101	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2409	102	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2409	103	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2409	104	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2409	105	,	,	,
18637	2409	106	including	include	VBG
18637	2409	107	that	that	DT
18637	2409	108	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	2409	109	by	by	IN
18637	2409	110	merchants	merchant	NNS
18637	2409	111	and	and	CC
18637	2409	112	trading	trading	NN
18637	2409	113	companies	company	NNS
18637	2409	114	.	.	.
18637	2409	115	"	"	''
18637	2410	1	On	on	IN
18637	2410	2	the	the	DT
18637	2410	3	same	same	JJ
18637	2410	4	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	2410	5	the	the	DT
18637	2410	6	general	general	JJ
18637	2410	7	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	2410	8	was	be	VBD
18637	2410	9	laid	lay	VBN
18637	2410	10	down	down	RP
18637	2410	11	that	that	IN
18637	2410	12	"	"	``
18637	2410	13	the	the	DT
18637	2410	14	power	power	NN
18637	2410	15	of	of	IN
18637	2410	16	a	a	DT
18637	2410	17	State	State	NNP
18637	2410	18	to	to	TO
18637	2410	19	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2410	20	the	the	DT
18637	2410	21	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	2410	22	of	of	IN
18637	2410	23	a	a	DT
18637	2410	24	local	local	JJ
18637	2410	25	business	business	NN
18637	2410	26	within	within	IN
18637	2410	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2410	28	borders	border	NNS
18637	2410	29	by	by	IN
18637	2410	30	a	a	DT
18637	2410	31	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2410	32	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2410	33	,	,	,
18637	2410	34	...	...	:
18637	2410	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	2410	36	not	not	RB
18637	2410	37	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
18637	2410	38	or	or	CC
18637	2410	39	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	2410	40	,	,	,
18637	2410	41	but	but	CC
18637	2410	42	must	must	MD
18637	2410	43	be	be	VB
18637	2410	44	exerted	exert	VBN
18637	2410	45	in	in	IN
18637	2410	46	subordination	subordination	NN
18637	2410	47	to	to	IN
18637	2410	48	the	the	DT
18637	2410	49	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	2410	50	which	which	WDT
18637	2410	51	the	the	DT
18637	2410	52	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2410	53	places	place	VBZ
18637	2410	54	on	on	IN
18637	2410	55	State	state	NN
18637	2410	56	action	action	NN
18637	2410	57	.	.	.
18637	2411	1	"	"	``
18637	2411	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2411	3	643	643	CD
18637	2411	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2411	5	STATUS	STATUS	NNP
18637	2411	6	OF	of	IN
18637	2411	7	THE	the	DT
18637	2411	8	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNP
18637	2411	9	TODAY	TODAY	NNP
18637	2411	10	The	the	DT
18637	2411	11	precise	precise	JJ
18637	2411	12	standing	standing	NN
18637	2411	13	of	of	IN
18637	2411	14	this	this	DT
18637	2411	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2411	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	2411	17	,	,	,
18637	2411	18	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	2411	19	,	,	,
18637	2411	20	seriously	seriously	RB
18637	2411	21	clouded	cloud	VBN
18637	2411	22	by	by	IN
18637	2411	23	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2411	24	more	more	RBR
18637	2411	25	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2411	26	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	2411	27	.	.	.
18637	2412	1	In	in	IN
18637	2412	2	Sprout	Sprout	NNP
18637	2412	3	_	_	NNP
18637	2412	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	2412	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2412	6	South	South	NNP
18637	2412	7	Bend,[644	Bend,[644	NNP
18637	2412	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2412	9	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2412	10	in	in	IN
18637	2412	11	1928	1928	CD
18637	2412	12	,	,	,
18637	2412	13	the	the	DT
18637	2412	14	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2412	15	was	be	VBD
18637	2412	16	still	still	RB
18637	2412	17	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2412	18	,	,	,
18637	2412	19	to	to	TO
18637	2412	20	disallow	disallow	VB
18637	2412	21	a	a	DT
18637	2412	22	license	license	NN
18637	2412	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	2412	24	on	on	IN
18637	2412	25	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	2412	26	operating	operate	VBG
18637	2412	27	a	a	DT
18637	2412	28	bus	bus	NN
18637	2412	29	interstate	interstate	NN
18637	2412	30	.	.	.
18637	2413	1	Pointing	point	VBG
18637	2413	2	to	to	IN
18637	2413	3	the	the	DT
18637	2413	4	fact	fact	NN
18637	2413	5	that	that	IN
18637	2413	6	the	the	DT
18637	2413	7	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	2413	8	made	make	VBD
18637	2413	9	no	no	DT
18637	2413	10	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	2413	11	between	between	IN
18637	2413	12	busses	bus	NNS
18637	2413	13	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	2413	14	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	2413	15	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2413	16	and	and	CC
18637	2413	17	those	those	DT
18637	2413	18	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2413	19	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2413	20	or	or	CC
18637	2413	21	both	both	CC
18637	2413	22	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2413	23	and	and	CC
18637	2413	24	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2413	25	,	,	,
18637	2413	26	the	the	DT
18637	2413	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2413	28	said	say	VBD
18637	2413	29	:	:	:
18637	2413	30	"	"	``
18637	2413	31	In	in	IN
18637	2413	32	order	order	NN
18637	2413	33	that	that	IN
18637	2413	34	the	the	DT
18637	2413	35	fee	fee	NN
18637	2413	36	or	or	CC
18637	2413	37	tax	tax	NN
18637	2413	38	shall	shall	MD
18637	2413	39	be	be	VB
18637	2413	40	valid	valid	JJ
18637	2413	41	,	,	,
18637	2413	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2413	43	must	must	MD
18637	2413	44	appear	appear	VB
18637	2413	45	that	that	IN
18637	2413	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2413	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	2413	48	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2413	49	solely	solely	RB
18637	2413	50	on	on	IN
18637	2413	51	account	account	NN
18637	2413	52	of	of	IN
18637	2413	53	the	the	DT
18637	2413	54	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2413	55	business	business	NN
18637	2413	56	;	;	:
18637	2413	57	that	that	IN
18637	2413	58	the	the	DT
18637	2413	59	amount	amount	NN
18637	2413	60	exacted	exact	VBN
18637	2413	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	2413	62	not	not	RB
18637	2413	63	increased	increase	VBN
18637	2413	64	because	because	IN
18637	2413	65	of	of	IN
18637	2413	66	the	the	DT
18637	2413	67	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2413	68	business	business	NN
18637	2413	69	done	do	VBN
18637	2413	70	;	;	:
18637	2413	71	that	that	DT
18637	2413	72	one	one	NN
18637	2413	73	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	2413	74	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	2413	75	in	in	IN
18637	2413	76	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2413	77	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2413	78	would	would	MD
18637	2413	79	not	not	RB
18637	2413	80	be	be	VB
18637	2413	81	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2413	82	to	to	IN
18637	2413	83	the	the	DT
18637	2413	84	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	2413	85	;	;	:
18637	2413	86	and	and	CC
18637	2413	87	that	that	IN
18637	2413	88	the	the	DT
18637	2413	89	person	person	NN
18637	2413	90	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	2413	91	could	could	MD
18637	2413	92	discontinue	discontinue	VB
18637	2413	93	the	the	DT
18637	2413	94	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2413	95	business	business	NN
18637	2413	96	without	without	IN
18637	2413	97	withdrawing	withdraw	VBG
18637	2413	98	also	also	RB
18637	2413	99	from	from	IN
18637	2413	100	the	the	DT
18637	2413	101	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2413	102	business	business	NN
18637	2413	103	.	.	.
18637	2414	1	"	"	``
18637	2414	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2414	3	645	645	CD
18637	2414	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2414	5	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	2414	6	,	,	,
18637	2414	7	in	in	IN
18637	2414	8	Cooney	Cooney	NNP
18637	2414	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2414	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	2414	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2414	12	Mountain	Mountain	NNP
18637	2414	13	States	States	NNP
18637	2414	14	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	2414	15	and	and	CC
18637	2414	16	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	2414	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2414	18	,	,	,
18637	2414	19	the	the	DT
18637	2414	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2414	21	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	2414	22	that	that	DT
18637	2414	23	to	to	TO
18637	2414	24	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	2414	25	a	a	DT
18637	2414	26	State	state	NN
18637	2414	27	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	2414	28	tax	tax	NN
18637	2414	29	on	on	IN
18637	2414	30	one	one	CD
18637	2414	31	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2414	32	business	business	NN
18637	2414	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	2414	34	both	both	CC
18637	2414	35	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2414	36	and	and	CC
18637	2414	37	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2414	38	,	,	,
18637	2414	39	"	"	''
18637	2414	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2414	41	must	must	MD
18637	2414	42	appear	appear	VB
18637	2414	43	*	*	NFP
18637	2414	44	*	*	NFP
18637	2414	45	*	*	NFP
18637	2414	46	,	,	,
18637	2414	47	and	and	CC
18637	2414	48	that	that	IN
18637	2414	49	the	the	DT
18637	2414	50	one	one	NN
18637	2414	51	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2414	52	who	who	WP
18637	2414	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	2414	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2414	55	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	2414	56	could	could	MD
18637	2414	57	discontinue	discontinue	VB
18637	2414	58	the	the	DT
18637	2414	59	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2414	60	business	business	NN
18637	2414	61	without	without	IN
18637	2414	62	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2414	63	also	also	RB
18637	2414	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2414	65	withdrawing	withdraw	VBG
18637	2414	66	from	from	IN
18637	2414	67	the	the	DT
18637	2414	68	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2414	69	business	business	NN
18637	2414	70	.	.	.
18637	2415	1	"	"	``
18637	2415	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2415	3	646	646	CD
18637	2415	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2415	5	A	a	DT
18637	2415	6	year	year	NN
18637	2415	7	later	later	RB
18637	2415	8	,	,	,
18637	2415	9	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	2415	10	,	,	,
18637	2415	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2415	12	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	2415	13	,	,	,
18637	2415	14	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2415	15	for	for	IN
18637	2415	16	the	the	DT
18637	2415	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2415	18	in	in	IN
18637	2415	19	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	2415	20	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	2415	21	and	and	CC
18637	2415	22	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	2415	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2415	24	_	_	NNP
18637	2415	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	2415	26	_	_	NNP
18637	2415	27	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	2415	28	Commission,[647	Commission,[647	NNP
18637	2415	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2415	30	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	2415	31	flatly	flatly	RB
18637	2415	32	:	:	:
18637	2415	33	"	"	``
18637	2415	34	No	no	DT
18637	2415	35	decision	decision	NN
18637	2415	36	of	of	IN
18637	2415	37	this	this	DT
18637	2415	38	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2415	39	lends	lend	NNS
18637	2415	40	support	support	NN
18637	2415	41	to	to	IN
18637	2415	42	the	the	DT
18637	2415	43	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	2415	44	that	that	IN
18637	2415	45	an	an	DT
18637	2415	46	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	2415	47	tax	tax	NN
18637	2415	48	upon	upon	IN
18637	2415	49	local	local	JJ
18637	2415	50	business	business	NN
18637	2415	51	,	,	,
18637	2415	52	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2415	53	valid	valid	JJ
18637	2415	54	,	,	,
18637	2415	55	must	must	MD
18637	2415	56	be	be	VB
18637	2415	57	held	hold	VBN
18637	2415	58	void	void	JJ
18637	2415	59	merely	merely	RB
18637	2415	60	because	because	IN
18637	2415	61	the	the	DT
18637	2415	62	local	local	JJ
18637	2415	63	and	and	CC
18637	2415	64	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2415	65	branches	branch	NNS
18637	2415	66	are	be	VBP
18637	2415	67	for	for	IN
18637	2415	68	some	some	DT
18637	2415	69	reason	reason	NN
18637	2415	70	inseparable	inseparable	JJ
18637	2415	71	.	.	.
18637	2416	1	"	"	``
18637	2416	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2416	3	648	648	CD
18637	2416	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2416	5	An	an	DT
18637	2416	6	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	2416	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	2416	8	,	,	,
18637	2416	9	like	like	IN
18637	2416	10	other	other	JJ
18637	2416	11	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2416	12	and	and	CC
18637	2416	13	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	2416	14	,	,	,
18637	2416	15	lessens	lessen	VBZ
18637	2416	16	the	the	DT
18637	2416	17	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	2416	18	derived	derive	VBN
18637	2416	19	by	by	IN
18637	2416	20	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2416	21	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2416	22	from	from	IN
18637	2416	23	the	the	DT
18637	2416	24	joint	joint	JJ
18637	2416	25	operation	operation	NN
18637	2416	26	with	with	IN
18637	2416	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2416	28	of	of	IN
18637	2416	29	the	the	DT
18637	2416	30	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2416	31	business	business	NN
18637	2416	32	of	of	IN
18637	2416	33	the	the	DT
18637	2416	34	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2416	35	;	;	:
18637	2416	36	but	but	CC
18637	2416	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2416	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	2416	39	not	not	RB
18637	2416	40	an	an	DT
18637	2416	41	undue	undue	JJ
18637	2416	42	burden	burden	NN
18637	2416	43	on	on	IN
18637	2416	44	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2416	45	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2416	46	where	where	WRB
18637	2416	47	,	,	,
18637	2416	48	as	as	IN
18637	2416	49	in	in	IN
18637	2416	50	this	this	DT
18637	2416	51	case	case	NN
18637	2416	52	,	,	,
18637	2416	53	the	the	DT
18637	2416	54	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	2416	55	to	to	IN
18637	2416	56	the	the	DT
18637	2416	57	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2416	58	,	,	,
18637	2416	59	and	and	CC
18637	2416	60	to	to	IN
18637	2416	61	the	the	DT
18637	2416	62	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2416	63	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2416	64	,	,	,
18637	2416	65	of	of	IN
18637	2416	66	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	2416	67	the	the	DT
18637	2416	68	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2416	69	business	business	NN
18637	2416	70	is	be	VBZ
18637	2416	71	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	2416	72	in	in	IN
18637	2416	73	excess	excess	NN
18637	2416	74	of	of	IN
18637	2416	75	the	the	DT
18637	2416	76	tax	tax	NN
18637	2416	77	.	.	.
18637	2417	1	And	and	CC
18637	2417	2	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	2417	3	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	2417	4	in	in	IN
18637	2417	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	2417	6	involving	involve	VBG
18637	2417	7	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2417	8	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2417	9	doing	do	VBG
18637	2417	10	a	a	DT
18637	2417	11	mixed	mix	VBN
18637	2417	12	business	business	NN
18637	2417	13	,	,	,
18637	2417	14	comprising	comprise	VBG
18637	2417	15	both	both	CC
18637	2417	16	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2417	17	and	and	CC
18637	2417	18	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2417	19	elements	element	NNS
18637	2417	20	,	,	,
18637	2417	21	have	have	VBP
18637	2417	22	tended	tend	VBN
18637	2417	23	on	on	IN
18637	2417	24	the	the	DT
18637	2417	25	whole	whole	NN
18637	2417	26	to	to	TO
18637	2417	27	restore	restore	VB
18637	2417	28	the	the	DT
18637	2417	29	rule	rule	NN
18637	2417	30	stated	state	VBN
18637	2417	31	in	in	IN
18637	2417	32	Paul	Paul	NNP
18637	2417	33	_	_	NNP
18637	2417	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	2417	35	_	_	NNP
18637	2417	36	Virginia[649	Virginia[649	NNP
18637	2417	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2417	38	shortly	shortly	RB
18637	2417	39	after	after	IN
18637	2417	40	the	the	DT
18637	2417	41	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	2417	42	War	War	NNP
18637	2417	43	,	,	,
18637	2417	44	that	that	IN
18637	2417	45	the	the	DT
18637	2417	46	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2417	47	does	do	VBZ
18637	2417	48	not	not	RB
18637	2417	49	confer	confer	VB
18637	2417	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	2417	51	a	a	DT
18637	2417	52	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2417	53	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2417	54	the	the	DT
18637	2417	55	right	right	NN
18637	2417	56	to	to	TO
18637	2417	57	engage	engage	VB
18637	2417	58	in	in	IN
18637	2417	59	local	local	JJ
18637	2417	60	business	business	NN
18637	2417	61	in	in	IN
18637	2417	62	a	a	DT
18637	2417	63	State	State	NNP
18637	2417	64	without	without	IN
18637	2417	65	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2417	66	assent	assent	NN
18637	2417	67	,	,	,
18637	2417	68	which	which	WDT
18637	2417	69	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2417	70	may	may	MD
18637	2417	71	give	give	VB
18637	2417	72	on	on	IN
18637	2417	73	such	such	JJ
18637	2417	74	terms	term	NNS
18637	2417	75	as	as	IN
18637	2417	76	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2417	77	chooses	choose	VBZ
18637	2417	78	.	.	.
18637	2418	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2418	2	650	650	CD
18637	2418	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2418	4	State	State	NNP
18637	2418	5	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	2418	6	of	of	IN
18637	2418	7	Property	Property	NNP
18637	2418	8	Engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2418	9	in	in	IN
18637	2418	10	,	,	,
18637	2418	11	and	and	CC
18637	2418	12	of	of	IN
18637	2418	13	the	the	DT
18637	2418	14	Proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	2418	15	From	from	IN
18637	2418	16	,	,	,
18637	2418	17	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2418	18	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2418	19	GENERAL	GENERAL	NNP
18637	2418	20	ISSUE	ISSUE	VBD
18637	2418	21	In	in	IN
18637	2418	22	this	this	DT
18637	2418	23	area	area	NN
18637	2418	24	of	of	IN
18637	2418	25	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	2418	26	Law	Law	NNP
18637	2418	27	the	the	DT
18637	2418	28	principle	principle	NN
18637	2418	29	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	2418	30	in	in	IN
18637	2418	31	the	the	DT
18637	2418	32	State	State	NNP
18637	2418	33	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	2418	34	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	2418	35	Case,[651	Case,[651	NNP
18637	2418	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2418	37	that	that	IN
18637	2418	38	a	a	DT
18637	2418	39	State	state	NN
18637	2418	40	may	may	MD
18637	2418	41	not	not	RB
18637	2418	42	tax	tax	VB
18637	2418	43	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2418	44	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2418	45	,	,	,
18637	2418	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	2418	47	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	2418	48	with	with	IN
18637	2418	49	the	the	DT
18637	2418	50	principle	principle	NN
18637	2418	51	that	that	IN
18637	2418	52	a	a	DT
18637	2418	53	State	state	NN
18637	2418	54	may	may	MD
18637	2418	55	tax	tax	VB
18637	2418	56	all	all	DT
18637	2418	57	purely	purely	RB
18637	2418	58	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	2418	59	business	business	NN
18637	2418	60	within	within	IN
18637	2418	61	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2418	62	borders	border	NNS
18637	2418	63	and	and	CC
18637	2418	64	all	all	DT
18637	2418	65	property	property	NN
18637	2418	66	"	"	''
18637	2418	67	within	within	IN
18637	2418	68	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2418	69	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2418	70	.	.	.
18637	2418	71	"	"	''
18637	2419	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	2419	2	as	as	IN
18637	2419	3	most	most	JJS
18637	2419	4	large	large	JJ
18637	2419	5	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	2419	6	prosecute	prosecute	VBP
18637	2419	7	both	both	CC
18637	2419	8	an	an	DT
18637	2419	9	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2419	10	and	and	CC
18637	2419	11	a	a	DT
18637	2419	12	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	2419	13	business	business	NN
18637	2419	14	,	,	,
18637	2419	15	while	while	IN
18637	2419	16	the	the	DT
18637	2419	17	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	2419	18	of	of	IN
18637	2419	19	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2419	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2419	21	and	and	CC
18637	2419	22	the	the	DT
18637	2419	23	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
18637	2419	24	returns	return	NNS
18637	2419	25	from	from	IN
18637	2419	26	such	such	JJ
18637	2419	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2419	28	are	be	VBP
18637	2419	29	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	2419	30	property	property	NN
18637	2419	31	within	within	IN
18637	2419	32	the	the	DT
18637	2419	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2419	34	of	of	IN
18637	2419	35	some	some	DT
18637	2419	36	State	State	NNP
18637	2419	37	or	or	CC
18637	2419	38	other	other	JJ
18637	2419	39	,	,	,
18637	2419	40	the	the	DT
18637	2419	41	task	task	NN
18637	2419	42	before	before	IN
18637	2419	43	the	the	DT
18637	2419	44	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2419	45	in	in	IN
18637	2419	46	drawing	draw	VBG
18637	2419	47	the	the	DT
18637	2419	48	line	line	NN
18637	2419	49	between	between	IN
18637	2419	50	the	the	DT
18637	2419	51	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	2419	52	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	2419	53	by	by	IN
18637	2419	54	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2419	55	business	business	NN
18637	2419	56	on	on	IN
18637	2419	57	the	the	DT
18637	2419	58	one	one	CD
18637	2419	59	hand	hand	NN
18637	2419	60	and	and	CC
18637	2419	61	the	the	DT
18637	2419	62	prerogatives	prerogative	NNS
18637	2419	63	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	2419	64	by	by	IN
18637	2419	65	local	local	JJ
18637	2419	66	power	power	NN
18637	2419	67	on	on	IN
18637	2419	68	the	the	DT
18637	2419	69	other	other	JJ
18637	2419	70	has	have	VBZ
18637	2419	71	at	at	IN
18637	2419	72	times	time	NNS
18637	2419	73	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2419	74	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2419	75	in	in	IN
18637	2419	76	self	self	NN
18637	2419	77	-	-	HYPH
18637	2419	78	contradiction	contradiction	NN
18637	2419	79	,	,	,
18637	2419	80	as	as	IN
18637	2419	81	successive	successive	JJ
18637	2419	82	developments	development	NNS
18637	2419	83	have	have	VBP
18637	2419	84	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2419	85	into	into	IN
18637	2419	86	prominence	prominence	NN
18637	2419	87	novel	novel	NN
18637	2419	88	aspects	aspect	NNS
18637	2419	89	of	of	IN
18637	2419	90	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2419	91	complex	complex	JJ
18637	2419	92	problem	problem	NN
18637	2419	93	or	or	CC
18637	2419	94	have	have	VBP
18637	2419	95	altered	alter	VBN
18637	2419	96	the	the	DT
18637	2419	97	perspective	perspective	NN
18637	2419	98	in	in	IN
18637	2419	99	which	which	WDT
18637	2419	100	the	the	DT
18637	2419	101	interests	interest	NNS
18637	2419	102	competing	compete	VBG
18637	2419	103	for	for	IN
18637	2419	104	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2419	105	protection	protection	NN
18637	2419	106	have	have	VBP
18637	2419	107	appeared	appear	VBN
18637	2419	108	.	.	.
18637	2420	1	In	in	IN
18637	2420	2	this	this	DT
18637	2420	3	field	field	NN
18637	2420	4	words	word	NNS
18637	2420	5	of	of	IN
18637	2420	6	the	the	DT
18637	2420	7	late	late	JJ
18637	2420	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2420	9	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	2420	10	,	,	,
18637	2420	11	spoken	speak	VBN
18637	2420	12	in	in	IN
18637	2420	13	1946	1946	CD
18637	2420	14	,	,	,
18637	2420	15	are	be	VBP
18637	2420	16	especially	especially	RB
18637	2420	17	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	2420	18	:	:	:
18637	2420	19	"	"	``
18637	2420	20	For	for	IN
18637	2420	21	cleanly	cleanly	RB
18637	2420	22	as	as	IN
18637	2420	23	the	the	DT
18637	2420	24	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2420	25	clause	clause	NN
18637	2420	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	2420	27	worked	work	VBN
18637	2420	28	affirmatively	affirmatively	RB
18637	2420	29	on	on	IN
18637	2420	30	the	the	DT
18637	2420	31	whole	whole	NN
18637	2420	32	,	,	,
18637	2420	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2420	34	implied	implied	JJ
18637	2420	35	negative	negative	JJ
18637	2420	36	operation	operation	NN
18637	2420	37	on	on	IN
18637	2420	38	State	State	NNP
18637	2420	39	power	power	NN
18637	2420	40	has	have	VBZ
18637	2420	41	been	be	VBN
18637	2420	42	uneven	uneven	JJ
18637	2420	43	,	,	,
18637	2420	44	at	at	IN
18637	2420	45	times	time	NNS
18637	2420	46	highly	highly	RB
18637	2420	47	variable	variable	JJ
18637	2420	48	.	.	.
18637	2421	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2421	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2421	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2421	4	Into	into	IN
18637	2421	5	what	what	WP
18637	2421	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2421	7	thus	thus	RB
18637	2421	8	left	leave	VBN
18637	2421	9	open	open	JJ
18637	2421	10	for	for	IN
18637	2421	11	inference	inference	NN
18637	2421	12	to	to	TO
18637	2421	13	fill	fill	VB
18637	2421	14	,	,	,
18637	2421	15	divergent	divergent	JJ
18637	2421	16	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	2421	17	of	of	IN
18637	2421	18	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	2421	19	may	may	MD
18637	2421	20	be	be	VB
18637	2421	21	read	read	VBN
18637	2421	22	much	much	RB
18637	2421	23	more	more	RBR
18637	2421	24	readily	readily	RB
18637	2421	25	than	than	IN
18637	2421	26	into	into	IN
18637	2421	27	what	what	WP
18637	2421	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	2421	29	been	be	VBN
18637	2421	30	made	make	VBN
18637	2421	31	explicit	explicit	JJ
18637	2421	32	by	by	IN
18637	2421	33	affirmation	affirmation	NN
18637	2421	34	.	.	.
18637	2422	1	That	that	DT
18637	2422	2	possibility	possibility	NN
18637	2422	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	2422	4	broadened	broaden	VBN
18637	2422	5	immeasurably	immeasurably	RB
18637	2422	6	when	when	WRB
18637	2422	7	not	not	RB
18637	2422	8	logic	logic	VB
18637	2422	9	alone	alone	RB
18637	2422	10	,	,	,
18637	2422	11	but	but	CC
18637	2422	12	large	large	JJ
18637	2422	13	choices	choice	NNS
18637	2422	14	of	of	IN
18637	2422	15	policy	policy	NN
18637	2422	16	,	,	,
18637	2422	17	affected	affect	VBN
18637	2422	18	in	in	IN
18637	2422	19	this	this	DT
18637	2422	20	instance	instance	NN
18637	2422	21	by	by	IN
18637	2422	22	evolving	evolve	VBG
18637	2422	23	experience	experience	NN
18637	2422	24	of	of	IN
18637	2422	25	federalism	federalism	NN
18637	2422	26	,	,	,
18637	2422	27	control	control	NN
18637	2422	28	in	in	IN
18637	2422	29	giving	give	VBG
18637	2422	30	content	content	NN
18637	2422	31	to	to	IN
18637	2422	32	the	the	DT
18637	2422	33	implied	implied	JJ
18637	2422	34	negation	negation	NN
18637	2422	35	.	.	.
18637	2423	1	"	"	``
18637	2423	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2423	3	652	652	CD
18637	2423	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2423	5	DEVELOPMENT	development	NN
18637	2423	6	OF	of	IN
18637	2423	7	THE	the	DT
18637	2423	8	APPORTIONMENT	APPORTIONMENT	NNP
18637	2423	9	RULE	RULE	NNP
18637	2423	10	At	at	IN
18637	2423	11	the	the	DT
18637	2423	12	outset	outset	NN
18637	2423	13	the	the	DT
18637	2423	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2423	15	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	2423	16	to	to	TO
18637	2423	17	have	have	VB
18637	2423	18	thought	think	VBN
18637	2423	19	that	that	IN
18637	2423	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2423	21	could	could	MD
18637	2423	22	solve	solve	VB
18637	2423	23	all	all	DT
18637	2423	24	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	2423	25	by	by	IN
18637	2423	26	the	the	DT
18637	2423	27	simple	simple	JJ
18637	2423	28	device	device	NN
18637	2423	29	of	of	IN
18637	2423	30	falling	fall	VBG
18637	2423	31	back	back	RB
18637	2423	32	on	on	IN
18637	2423	33	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2423	34	's	's	POS
18637	2423	35	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2423	36	in	in	IN
18637	2423	37	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	2423	38	_	_	NNP
18637	2423	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	2423	40	_	_	NNP
18637	2423	41	Maryland;[653	Maryland;[653	NNP
18637	2423	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2423	43	and	and	CC
18637	2423	44	on	on	IN
18637	2423	45	the	the	DT
18637	2423	46	same	same	JJ
18637	2423	47	day	day	NN
18637	2423	48	that	that	WDT
18637	2423	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2423	50	set	set	VBD
18637	2423	51	aside	aside	RP
18637	2423	52	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2423	53	's	's	POS
18637	2423	54	freight	freight	NN
18637	2423	55	tax	tax	NN
18637	2423	56	by	by	IN
18637	2423	57	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	2423	58	to	to	IN
18637	2423	59	that	that	DT
18637	2423	60	transcendent	transcendent	NN
18637	2423	61	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	2423	62	,	,	,
18637	2423	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2423	64	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	2423	65	,	,	,
18637	2423	66	by	by	IN
18637	2423	67	reference	reference	NN
18637	2423	68	to	to	IN
18637	2423	69	the	the	DT
18637	2423	70	same	same	JJ
18637	2423	71	authority	authority	NN
18637	2423	72	,	,	,
18637	2423	73	a	a	DT
18637	2423	74	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2423	75	tax	tax	NN
18637	2423	76	on	on	IN
18637	2423	77	the	the	DT
18637	2423	78	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2423	79	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2423	80	of	of	IN
18637	2423	81	all	all	DT
18637	2423	82	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	2423	83	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	2423	84	by	by	IN
18637	2423	85	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2423	86	,	,	,
18637	2423	87	the	the	DT
18637	2423	88	theory	theory	NN
18637	2423	89	being	be	VBG
18637	2423	90	that	that	IN
18637	2423	91	such	such	JJ
18637	2423	92	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2423	93	had	have	VBD
18637	2423	94	,	,	,
18637	2423	95	by	by	IN
18637	2423	96	tax	tax	NN
18637	2423	97	time	time	NN
18637	2423	98	,	,	,
18637	2423	99	become	become	VB
18637	2423	100	"	"	``
18637	2423	101	part	part	NN
18637	2423	102	of	of	IN
18637	2423	103	the	the	DT
18637	2423	104	mass	mass	NN
18637	2423	105	of	of	IN
18637	2423	106	property	property	NN
18637	2423	107	of	of	IN
18637	2423	108	the	the	DT
18637	2423	109	State	State	NNP
18637	2423	110	.	.	.
18637	2424	1	"	"	``
18637	2424	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2424	3	654	654	CD
18637	2424	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2424	5	This	this	DT
18637	2424	6	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	2424	7	stood	stand	VBD
18637	2424	8	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	2424	9	years	year	NNS
18637	2424	10	,	,	,
18637	2424	11	being	be	VBG
18637	2424	12	at	at	IN
18637	2424	13	last	last	JJ
18637	2424	14	superseded	superseded	JJ
18637	2424	15	by	by	IN
18637	2424	16	a	a	DT
18637	2424	17	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	2424	18	in	in	IN
18637	2424	19	which	which	WDT
18637	2424	20	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	2424	21	the	the	DT
18637	2424	22	same	same	JJ
18637	2424	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	2424	24	was	be	VBD
18637	2424	25	held	hold	VBN
18637	2424	26	void	void	JJ
18637	2424	27	as	as	IN
18637	2424	28	to	to	IN
18637	2424	29	a	a	DT
18637	2424	30	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2424	31	chartered	charter	VBD
18637	2424	32	steamship	steamship	NN
18637	2424	33	company	company	NN
18637	2424	34	.	.	.
18637	2425	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2425	2	655	655	CD
18637	2425	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2425	4	A	a	DT
18637	2425	5	year	year	NN
18637	2425	6	later	later	RB
18637	2425	7	the	the	DT
18637	2425	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2425	9	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	2425	10	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	2425	11	in	in	IN
18637	2425	12	levying	levy	VBG
18637	2425	13	a	a	DT
18637	2425	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	2425	15	on	on	IN
18637	2425	16	Western	Western	NNP
18637	2425	17	Union	Union	NNP
18637	2425	18	,	,	,
18637	2425	19	a	a	DT
18637	2425	20	New	New	NNP
18637	2425	21	York	York	NNP
18637	2425	22	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2425	23	,	,	,
18637	2425	24	on	on	IN
18637	2425	25	account	account	NN
18637	2425	26	of	of	IN
18637	2425	27	property	property	NN
18637	2425	28	owned	own	VBN
18637	2425	29	and	and	CC
18637	2425	30	used	use	VBN
18637	2425	31	by	by	IN
18637	2425	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2425	33	in	in	IN
18637	2425	34	the	the	DT
18637	2425	35	State	State	NNP
18637	2425	36	,	,	,
18637	2425	37	taking	take	VBG
18637	2425	38	as	as	IN
18637	2425	39	the	the	DT
18637	2425	40	basis	basis	NN
18637	2425	41	of	of	IN
18637	2425	42	the	the	DT
18637	2425	43	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	2425	44	such	such	JJ
18637	2425	45	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	2425	46	of	of	IN
18637	2425	47	the	the	DT
18637	2425	48	value	value	NN
18637	2425	49	of	of	IN
18637	2425	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2425	51	capital	capital	NN
18637	2425	52	stock	stock	NN
18637	2425	53	as	as	IN
18637	2425	54	the	the	DT
18637	2425	55	length	length	NN
18637	2425	56	of	of	IN
18637	2425	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2425	58	lines	line	NNS
18637	2425	59	within	within	IN
18637	2425	60	the	the	DT
18637	2425	61	State	State	NNP
18637	2425	62	bore	bear	VBD
18637	2425	63	to	to	IN
18637	2425	64	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2425	65	entire	entire	JJ
18637	2425	66	length	length	NN
18637	2425	67	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	2425	68	the	the	DT
18637	2425	69	country	country	NN
18637	2425	70	.	.	.
18637	2426	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2426	2	656	656	CD
18637	2426	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2426	4	The	the	DT
18637	2426	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	2426	6	was	be	VBD
18637	2426	7	characterized	characterize	VBN
18637	2426	8	by	by	IN
18637	2426	9	the	the	DT
18637	2426	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2426	11	as	as	IN
18637	2426	12	an	an	DT
18637	2426	13	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	2426	14	by	by	IN
18637	2426	15	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	2426	16	"	"	''
18637	2426	17	to	to	TO
18637	2426	18	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	2426	19	the	the	DT
18637	2426	20	just	just	JJ
18637	2426	21	amount	amount	NN
18637	2426	22	which	which	WDT
18637	2426	23	any	any	DT
18637	2426	24	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2426	25	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	2426	26	in	in	IN
18637	2426	27	business	business	NN
18637	2426	28	within	within	IN
18637	2426	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2426	30	limits	limit	NNS
18637	2426	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	2426	32	pay	pay	VB
18637	2426	33	as	as	IN
18637	2426	34	a	a	DT
18637	2426	35	contribution	contribution	NN
18637	2426	36	to	to	IN
18637	2426	37	the	the	DT
18637	2426	38	support	support	NN
18637	2426	39	of	of	IN
18637	2426	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2426	41	government	government	NN
18637	2426	42	upon	upon	IN
18637	2426	43	the	the	DT
18637	2426	44	amount	amount	NN
18637	2426	45	and	and	CC
18637	2426	46	value	value	NN
18637	2426	47	of	of	IN
18637	2426	48	the	the	DT
18637	2426	49	capital	capital	NN
18637	2426	50	so	so	RB
18637	2426	51	employed	employ	VBN
18637	2426	52	by	by	IN
18637	2426	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2426	54	therein	therein	RB
18637	2426	55	.	.	.
18637	2427	1	"	"	``
18637	2427	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2427	3	657	657	CD
18637	2427	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2427	5	And	and	CC
18637	2427	6	drawing	draw	VBG
18637	2427	7	on	on	IN
18637	2427	8	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2427	9	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	2427	10	in	in	IN
18637	2427	11	which	which	WDT
18637	2427	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2427	13	had	have	VBD
18637	2427	14	sought	seek	VBN
18637	2427	15	to	to	TO
18637	2427	16	limit	limit	VB
18637	2427	17	the	the	DT
18637	2427	18	principle	principle	NN
18637	2427	19	of	of	IN
18637	2427	20	tax	tax	NN
18637	2427	21	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	2427	22	as	as	IN
18637	2427	23	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2427	24	in	in	IN
18637	2427	25	the	the	DT
18637	2427	26	case	case	NN
18637	2427	27	of	of	IN
18637	2427	28	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	2427	29	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	2427	30	by	by	IN
18637	2427	31	the	the	DT
18637	2427	32	United	United	NNP
18637	2427	33	States	States	NNP
18637	2427	34	,	,	,
18637	2427	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2427	36	expressed	express	VBD
18637	2427	37	concern	concern	NN
18637	2427	38	that	that	IN
18637	2427	39	"	"	``
18637	2427	40	the	the	DT
18637	2427	41	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2427	42	powers	power	NNS
18637	2427	43	of	of	IN
18637	2427	44	the	the	DT
18637	2427	45	States	States	NNPS
18637	2427	46	"	"	''
18637	2427	47	should	should	MD
18637	2427	48	not	not	RB
18637	2427	49	be	be	VB
18637	2427	50	destroyed	destroy	VBN
18637	2427	51	or	or	CC
18637	2427	52	"	"	``
18637	2427	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2427	54	efficient	efficient	JJ
18637	2427	55	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2427	56	"	"	''
18637	2427	57	be	be	VB
18637	2427	58	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	2427	59	.	.	.
18637	2428	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2428	2	658	658	CD
18637	2428	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2428	4	Three	three	CD
18637	2428	5	years	year	NNS
18637	2428	6	later	later	RB
18637	2428	7	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2428	8	,	,	,
18637	2428	9	still	still	RB
18637	2428	10	in	in	IN
18637	2428	11	quest	quest	NN
18637	2428	12	of	of	IN
18637	2428	13	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	2428	14	,	,	,
18637	2428	15	was	be	VBD
18637	2428	16	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2428	17	in	in	IN
18637	2428	18	applying	apply	VBG
18637	2428	19	the	the	DT
18637	2428	20	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	2428	21	idea	idea	NN
18637	2428	22	to	to	IN
18637	2428	23	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	2428	24	's	's	POS
18637	2428	25	Palace	Palace	NNP
18637	2428	26	Car	Car	NNP
18637	2428	27	Company	Company	NNP
18637	2428	28	,	,	,
18637	2428	29	a	a	DT
18637	2428	30	"	"	``
18637	2428	31	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2428	32	"	"	''
18637	2428	33	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2428	34	.	.	.
18637	2429	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2429	2	659	659	CD
18637	2429	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2429	4	Pointing	point	VBG
18637	2429	5	to	to	IN
18637	2429	6	the	the	DT
18637	2429	7	fact	fact	NN
18637	2429	8	that	that	IN
18637	2429	9	the	the	DT
18637	2429	10	company	company	NN
18637	2429	11	had	have	VBD
18637	2429	12	at	at	IN
18637	2429	13	all	all	DT
18637	2429	14	times	time	NNS
18637	2429	15	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	2429	16	the	the	DT
18637	2429	17	same	same	JJ
18637	2429	18	number	number	NN
18637	2429	19	of	of	IN
18637	2429	20	cars	car	NNS
18637	2429	21	within	within	IN
18637	2429	22	the	the	DT
18637	2429	23	State	State	NNP
18637	2429	24	and	and	CC
18637	2429	25	continuously	continuously	RB
18637	2429	26	and	and	CC
18637	2429	27	constantly	constantly	RB
18637	2429	28	used	use	VBD
18637	2429	29	there	there	RB
18637	2429	30	a	a	DT
18637	2429	31	portion	portion	NN
18637	2429	32	of	of	IN
18637	2429	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2429	34	property	property	NN
18637	2429	35	,	,	,
18637	2429	36	the	the	DT
18637	2429	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2429	38	commended	commend	VBD
18637	2429	39	the	the	DT
18637	2429	40	State	State	NNP
18637	2429	41	for	for	IN
18637	2429	42	taking	take	VBG
18637	2429	43	"	"	``
18637	2429	44	as	as	IN
18637	2429	45	a	a	DT
18637	2429	46	basis	basis	NN
18637	2429	47	of	of	IN
18637	2429	48	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	2429	49	such	such	JJ
18637	2429	50	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	2429	51	of	of	IN
18637	2429	52	the	the	DT
18637	2429	53	capital	capital	NN
18637	2429	54	stock	stock	NN
18637	2429	55	of	of	IN
18637	2429	56	the	the	DT
18637	2429	57	company	company	NN
18637	2429	58	as	as	IN
18637	2429	59	the	the	DT
18637	2429	60	number	number	NN
18637	2429	61	of	of	IN
18637	2429	62	miles	mile	NNS
18637	2429	63	over	over	IN
18637	2429	64	which	which	WDT
18637	2429	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2429	66	ran	run	VBD
18637	2429	67	cars	car	NNS
18637	2429	68	within	within	IN
18637	2429	69	the	the	DT
18637	2429	70	State	State	NNP
18637	2429	71	bore	bear	VBD
18637	2429	72	to	to	IN
18637	2429	73	the	the	DT
18637	2429	74	whole	whole	JJ
18637	2429	75	number	number	NN
18637	2429	76	of	of	IN
18637	2429	77	miles	mile	NNS
18637	2429	78	,	,	,
18637	2429	79	in	in	IN
18637	2429	80	that	that	DT
18637	2429	81	and	and	CC
18637	2429	82	other	other	JJ
18637	2429	83	States	States	NNPS
18637	2429	84	,	,	,
18637	2429	85	*	*	NFP
18637	2429	86	*	*	NFP
18637	2429	87	*	*	NFP
18637	2429	88	"	"	``
18637	2429	89	This	this	DT
18637	2429	90	,	,	,
18637	2429	91	said	say	VBD
18637	2429	92	the	the	DT
18637	2429	93	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2429	94	,	,	,
18637	2429	95	was	be	VBD
18637	2429	96	"	"	``
18637	2429	97	a	a	DT
18637	2429	98	just	just	RB
18637	2429	99	and	and	CC
18637	2429	100	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	2429	101	method	method	NN
18637	2429	102	of	of	IN
18637	2429	103	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	2429	104	;	;	:
18637	2429	105	"	"	``
18637	2429	106	one	one	CD
18637	2429	107	which	which	WDT
18637	2429	108	,	,	,
18637	2429	109	"	"	``
18637	2429	110	if	if	IN
18637	2429	111	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2429	112	were	be	VBD
18637	2429	113	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	2429	114	by	by	IN
18637	2429	115	all	all	PDT
18637	2429	116	the	the	DT
18637	2429	117	States	States	NNPS
18637	2429	118	through	through	IN
18637	2429	119	which	which	WDT
18637	2429	120	these	these	DT
18637	2429	121	cars	car	NNS
18637	2429	122	ran	run	VBD
18637	2429	123	,	,	,
18637	2429	124	the	the	DT
18637	2429	125	company	company	NN
18637	2429	126	would	would	MD
18637	2429	127	be	be	VB
18637	2429	128	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	2429	129	upon	upon	IN
18637	2429	130	the	the	DT
18637	2429	131	whole	whole	JJ
18637	2429	132	value	value	NN
18637	2429	133	of	of	IN
18637	2429	134	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2429	135	capital	capital	NN
18637	2429	136	stock	stock	NN
18637	2429	137	,	,	,
18637	2429	138	and	and	CC
18637	2429	139	no	no	RB
18637	2429	140	more	more	JJR
18637	2429	141	.	.	.
18637	2430	1	"	"	``
18637	2430	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2430	3	660	660	CD
18637	2430	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2430	5	THE	the	DT
18637	2430	6	UNIT	UNIT	NNP
18637	2430	7	RULE	rule	NN
18637	2430	8	And	and	CC
18637	2430	9	pursuing	pursue	VBG
18637	2430	10	the	the	DT
18637	2430	11	same	same	JJ
18637	2430	12	course	course	NN
18637	2430	13	of	of	IN
18637	2430	14	thought	thought	NN
18637	2430	15	,	,	,
18637	2430	16	the	the	DT
18637	2430	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2430	18	,	,	,
18637	2430	19	in	in	IN
18637	2430	20	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	2430	21	Express	Express	NNP
18637	2430	22	Company	Company	NNP
18637	2430	23	_	_	NNP
18637	2430	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	2430	25	_	_	NNP
18637	2430	26	Ohio,[661	Ohio,[661	NNP
18637	2430	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2430	28	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2430	29	in	in	IN
18637	2430	30	1897	1897	CD
18637	2430	31	,	,	,
18637	2430	32	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	2430	33	that	that	IN
18637	2430	34	State	State	NNP
18637	2430	35	in	in	IN
18637	2430	36	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2430	37	property	property	NN
18637	2430	38	worth	worth	JJ
18637	2430	39	less	less	JJR
18637	2430	40	than	than	IN
18637	2430	41	$	$	$
18637	2430	42	70,000.00	70,000.00	CD
18637	2430	43	at	at	IN
18637	2430	44	a	a	DT
18637	2430	45	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	2430	46	of	of	IN
18637	2430	47	more	more	JJR
18637	2430	48	than	than	IN
18637	2430	49	half	half	PDT
18637	2430	50	a	a	DT
18637	2430	51	million	million	CD
18637	2430	52	,	,	,
18637	2430	53	on	on	IN
18637	2430	54	the	the	DT
18637	2430	55	ground	ground	NN
18637	2430	56	that	that	IN
18637	2430	57	the	the	DT
18637	2430	58	latter	latter	JJ
18637	2430	59	figure	figure	NN
18637	2430	60	did	do	VBD
18637	2430	61	not	not	RB
18637	2430	62	exceed	exceed	VB
18637	2430	63	,	,	,
18637	2430	64	in	in	IN
18637	2430	65	relation	relation	NN
18637	2430	66	to	to	IN
18637	2430	67	the	the	DT
18637	2430	68	total	total	JJ
18637	2430	69	capital	capital	NN
18637	2430	70	value	value	NN
18637	2430	71	of	of	IN
18637	2430	72	the	the	DT
18637	2430	73	company	company	NN
18637	2430	74	,	,	,
18637	2430	75	the	the	DT
18637	2430	76	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	2430	77	borne	bear	VBN
18637	2430	78	by	by	IN
18637	2430	79	the	the	DT
18637	2430	80	railway	railway	NN
18637	2430	81	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2430	82	which	which	WDT
18637	2430	83	the	the	DT
18637	2430	84	company	company	NN
18637	2430	85	covered	cover	VBN
18637	2430	86	in	in	IN
18637	2430	87	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	2430	88	to	to	IN
18637	2430	89	the	the	DT
18637	2430	90	total	total	JJ
18637	2430	91	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2430	92	which	which	WDT
18637	2430	93	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2430	94	covered	cover	VBD
18637	2430	95	in	in	IN
18637	2430	96	all	all	DT
18637	2430	97	States	state	NNS
18637	2430	98	.	.	.
18637	2431	1	To	to	IN
18637	2431	2	the	the	DT
18637	2431	3	objection	objection	NN
18637	2431	4	that	that	IN
18637	2431	5	"	"	``
18637	2431	6	the	the	DT
18637	2431	7	intangible	intangible	JJ
18637	2431	8	values	value	NNS
18637	2431	9	"	"	``
18637	2431	10	reached	reach	VBN
18637	2431	11	by	by	IN
18637	2431	12	the	the	DT
18637	2431	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	2431	14	were	be	VBD
18637	2431	15	derived	derive	VBN
18637	2431	16	from	from	IN
18637	2431	17	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2431	18	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2431	19	,	,	,
18637	2431	20	the	the	DT
18637	2431	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2431	22	replied	reply	VBD
18637	2431	23	with	with	IN
18637	2431	24	the	the	DT
18637	2431	25	"	"	``
18637	2431	26	cardinal	cardinal	JJ
18637	2431	27	rule	rule	NN
18637	2431	28	*	*	NFP
18637	2431	29	*	*	NFP
18637	2431	30	*	*	NFP
18637	2431	31	that	that	IN
18637	2431	32	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	2431	33	property	property	NN
18637	2431	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	2431	35	worth	worth	JJ
18637	2431	36	for	for	IN
18637	2431	37	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	2431	38	of	of	IN
18637	2431	39	income	income	NN
18637	2431	40	and	and	CC
18637	2431	41	sale	sale	NN
18637	2431	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2431	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	2431	44	also	also	RB
18637	2431	45	worth	worth	JJ
18637	2431	46	for	for	IN
18637	2431	47	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	2431	48	of	of	IN
18637	2431	49	taxation,"[662	taxation,"[662	NN
18637	2431	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2431	51	which	which	WDT
18637	2431	52	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	2431	53	does	do	VBZ
18637	2431	54	not	not	RB
18637	2431	55	meet	meet	VB
18637	2431	56	the	the	DT
18637	2431	57	issue	issue	NN
18637	2431	58	.	.	.
18637	2432	1	What	what	WP
18637	2432	2	the	the	DT
18637	2432	3	case	case	NN
18637	2432	4	indubitably	indubitably	RB
18637	2432	5	establishes	establish	VBZ
18637	2432	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2432	7	that	that	IN
18637	2432	8	a	a	DT
18637	2432	9	State	state	NN
18637	2432	10	may	may	MD
18637	2432	11	tax	tax	VB
18637	2432	12	property	property	NN
18637	2432	13	within	within	IN
18637	2432	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2432	15	limits	limit	NNS
18637	2432	16	"	"	''
18637	2432	17	as	as	IN
18637	2432	18	part	part	NN
18637	2432	19	of	of	IN
18637	2432	20	a	a	DT
18637	2432	21	going	go	VBG
18637	2432	22	concern	concern	NN
18637	2432	23	"	"	''
18637	2432	24	and	and	CC
18637	2432	25	hence	hence	RB
18637	2432	26	"	"	``
18637	2432	27	at	at	IN
18637	2432	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2432	29	value	value	NN
18637	2432	30	as	as	IN
18637	2432	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2432	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	2432	33	in	in	IN
18637	2432	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2432	35	organic	organic	JJ
18637	2432	36	relations	relation	NNS
18637	2432	37	,	,	,
18637	2432	38	"	"	''
18637	2432	39	although	although	IN
18637	2432	40	those	those	DT
18637	2432	41	relations	relation	NNS
18637	2432	42	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	2432	43	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2432	44	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2432	45	.	.	.
18637	2433	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2433	2	663	663	CD
18637	2433	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2433	4	In	in	IN
18637	2433	5	short	short	JJ
18637	2433	6	,	,	,
18637	2433	7	values	value	NNS
18637	2433	8	created	create	VBN
18637	2433	9	by	by	IN
18637	2433	10	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2433	11	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2433	12	_	_	NNP
18637	2433	13	are	be	VBP
18637	2433	14	_	_	NNP
18637	2433	15	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	2433	16	.	.	.
18637	2434	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2434	2	emerged	emerge	VBD
18637	2434	3	the	the	DT
18637	2434	4	concept	concept	NN
18637	2434	5	of	of	IN
18637	2434	6	an	an	DT
18637	2434	7	"	"	``
18637	2434	8	apportioned	apportioned	JJ
18637	2434	9	"	"	''
18637	2434	10	tax	tax	NN
18637	2434	11	,	,	,
18637	2434	12	or	or	CC
18637	2434	13	as	as	IN
18637	2434	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2434	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	2434	16	called	call	VBN
18637	2434	17	when	when	WRB
18637	2434	18	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2434	19	to	to	IN
18637	2434	20	the	the	DT
18637	2434	21	problem	problem	NN
18637	2434	22	of	of	IN
18637	2434	23	property	property	NN
18637	2434	24	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	2434	25	,	,	,
18637	2434	26	the	the	DT
18637	2434	27	"	"	``
18637	2434	28	unit	unit	NN
18637	2434	29	rule	rule	NN
18637	2434	30	,	,	,
18637	2434	31	"	"	''
18637	2434	32	which	which	WDT
18637	2434	33	till	till	IN
18637	2434	34	1938	1938	CD
18637	2434	35	afforded	afford	VBD
18637	2434	36	the	the	DT
18637	2434	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2434	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2434	39	chief	chief	JJ
18637	2434	40	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	2434	41	in	in	IN
18637	2434	42	the	the	DT
18637	2434	43	field	field	NN
18637	2434	44	of	of	IN
18637	2434	45	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	2434	46	Law	Law	NNP
18637	2434	47	now	now	RB
18637	2434	48	under	under	IN
18637	2434	49	review	review	NN
18637	2434	50	.	.	.
18637	2435	1	The	the	DT
18637	2435	2	theory	theory	NN
18637	2435	3	underlying	underlie	VBG
18637	2435	4	the	the	DT
18637	2435	5	concept	concept	NN
18637	2435	6	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	2435	7	to	to	TO
18637	2435	8	be	be	VB
18637	2435	9	that	that	IN
18637	2435	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2435	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	2435	12	always	always	RB
18637	2435	13	possible	possible	JJ
18637	2435	14	for	for	IN
18637	2435	15	a	a	DT
18637	2435	16	State	State	NNP
18637	2435	17	to	to	TO
18637	2435	18	devise	devise	VB
18637	2435	19	a	a	DT
18637	2435	20	formula	formula	NN
18637	2435	21	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	2435	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2435	23	may	may	MD
18637	2435	24	assign	assign	VB
18637	2435	25	to	to	IN
18637	2435	26	the	the	DT
18637	2435	27	property	property	NN
18637	2435	28	employed	employ	VBN
18637	2435	29	in	in	IN
18637	2435	30	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2435	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2435	32	within	within	IN
18637	2435	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2435	34	limits	limit	NNS
18637	2435	35	,	,	,
18637	2435	36	or	or	CC
18637	2435	37	to	to	IN
18637	2435	38	the	the	DT
18637	2435	39	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	2435	40	from	from	IN
18637	2435	41	such	such	JJ
18637	2435	42	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2435	43	,	,	,
18637	2435	44	a	a	DT
18637	2435	45	value	value	NN
18637	2435	46	which	which	WDT
18637	2435	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2435	48	may	may	MD
18637	2435	49	tax	tax	VB
18637	2435	50	or	or	CC
18637	2435	51	by	by	IN
18637	2435	52	which	which	WDT
18637	2435	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2435	54	may	may	MD
18637	2435	55	"	"	``
18637	2435	56	measure	measure	VB
18637	2435	57	"	"	''
18637	2435	58	a	a	DT
18637	2435	59	tax	tax	NN
18637	2435	60	,	,	,
18637	2435	61	without	without	IN
18637	2435	62	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	RB
18637	2435	63	burdening	burden	VBG
18637	2435	64	or	or	CC
18637	2435	65	interfering	interfere	VBG
18637	2435	66	with	with	IN
18637	2435	67	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2435	68	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2435	69	,	,	,
18637	2435	70	while	while	IN
18637	2435	71	at	at	IN
18637	2435	72	the	the	DT
18637	2435	73	same	same	JJ
18637	2435	74	time	time	NN
18637	2435	75	exacting	exact	VBG
18637	2435	76	from	from	IN
18637	2435	77	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2435	78	a	a	DT
18637	2435	79	fair	fair	JJ
18637	2435	80	return	return	NN
18637	2435	81	for	for	IN
18637	2435	82	the	the	DT
18637	2435	83	protection	protection	NN
18637	2435	84	which	which	WDT
18637	2435	85	the	the	DT
18637	2435	86	State	State	NNP
18637	2435	87	gives	give	VBZ
18637	2435	88	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2435	89	.	.	.
18637	2436	1	The	the	DT
18637	2436	2	question	question	NN
18637	2436	3	in	in	IN
18637	2436	4	each	each	DT
18637	2436	5	case	case	NN
18637	2436	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2436	7	,	,	,
18637	2436	8	of	of	IN
18637	2436	9	course	course	NN
18637	2436	10	,	,	,
18637	2436	11	whether	whether	IN
18637	2436	12	the	the	DT
18637	2436	13	State	State	NNP
18637	2436	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	2436	15	guessed	guess	VBN
18637	2436	16	right	right	RB
18637	2436	17	.	.	.
18637	2437	1	APPORTIONED	apportioned	NN
18637	2437	2	PROPERTY	property	NN
18637	2437	3	TAXES	taxes	VBP
18637	2437	4	In	in	IN
18637	2437	5	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	2437	6	on	on	IN
18637	2437	7	the	the	DT
18637	2437	8	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	2437	9	concept	concept	NN
18637	2437	10	the	the	DT
18637	2437	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2437	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	2437	13	at	at	IN
18637	2437	14	various	various	JJ
18637	2437	15	times	time	NNS
18637	2437	16	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2437	17	,	,	,
18637	2437	18	in	in	IN
18637	2437	19	the	the	DT
18637	2437	20	case	case	NN
18637	2437	21	of	of	IN
18637	2437	22	a	a	DT
18637	2437	23	sleeping	sleep	VBG
18637	2437	24	car	car	NN
18637	2437	25	company	company	NN
18637	2437	26	,	,	,
18637	2437	27	as	as	IN
18637	2437	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2437	29	have	have	VBP
18637	2437	30	seen	see	VBN
18637	2437	31	,	,	,
18637	2437	32	a	a	DT
18637	2437	33	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	2437	34	based	base	VBN
18637	2437	35	on	on	IN
18637	2437	36	the	the	DT
18637	2437	37	ratio	ratio	NN
18637	2437	38	of	of	IN
18637	2437	39	the	the	DT
18637	2437	40	miles	mile	NNS
18637	2437	41	of	of	IN
18637	2437	42	track	track	NN
18637	2437	43	over	over	IN
18637	2437	44	which	which	WDT
18637	2437	45	the	the	DT
18637	2437	46	company	company	NN
18637	2437	47	runs	run	VBZ
18637	2437	48	within	within	IN
18637	2437	49	the	the	DT
18637	2437	50	State	State	NNP
18637	2437	51	to	to	IN
18637	2437	52	the	the	DT
18637	2437	53	whole	whole	JJ
18637	2437	54	track	track	NN
18637	2437	55	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2437	56	over	over	IN
18637	2437	57	which	which	WDT
18637	2437	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2437	59	runs;[664	runs;[664	VBZ
18637	2437	60	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2437	61	in	in	IN
18637	2437	62	the	the	DT
18637	2437	63	case	case	NN
18637	2437	64	of	of	IN
18637	2437	65	a	a	DT
18637	2437	66	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2437	67	company	company	NN
18637	2437	68	,	,	,
18637	2437	69	a	a	DT
18637	2437	70	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	2437	71	based	base	VBN
18637	2437	72	on	on	IN
18637	2437	73	the	the	DT
18637	2437	74	ratio	ratio	NN
18637	2437	75	of	of	IN
18637	2437	76	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2437	77	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2437	78	within	within	IN
18637	2437	79	the	the	DT
18637	2437	80	State	State	NNP
18637	2437	81	to	to	IN
18637	2437	82	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2437	83	total	total	JJ
18637	2437	84	mileage;[665	mileage;[665	NNS
18637	2437	85	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2437	86	in	in	IN
18637	2437	87	the	the	DT
18637	2437	88	case	case	NN
18637	2437	89	of	of	IN
18637	2437	90	a	a	DT
18637	2437	91	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	2437	92	company	company	NN
18637	2437	93	,	,	,
18637	2437	94	a	a	DT
18637	2437	95	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	2437	96	based	base	VBN
18637	2437	97	upon	upon	IN
18637	2437	98	the	the	DT
18637	2437	99	ratio	ratio	NN
18637	2437	100	of	of	IN
18637	2437	101	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2437	102	length	length	NN
18637	2437	103	of	of	IN
18637	2437	104	line	line	NN
18637	2437	105	within	within	IN
18637	2437	106	the	the	DT
18637	2437	107	State	State	NNP
18637	2437	108	to	to	IN
18637	2437	109	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2437	110	total	total	JJ
18637	2437	111	length;[666	length;[666	NNS
18637	2437	112	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2437	113	in	in	IN
18637	2437	114	the	the	DT
18637	2437	115	case	case	NN
18637	2437	116	of	of	IN
18637	2437	117	an	an	DT
18637	2437	118	express	express	JJ
18637	2437	119	company	company	NN
18637	2437	120	,	,	,
18637	2437	121	as	as	IN
18637	2437	122	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2437	123	have	have	VBP
18637	2437	124	just	just	RB
18637	2437	125	seen	see	VBN
18637	2437	126	,	,	,
18637	2437	127	a	a	DT
18637	2437	128	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	2437	129	based	base	VBN
18637	2437	130	upon	upon	IN
18637	2437	131	the	the	DT
18637	2437	132	ratio	ratio	NN
18637	2437	133	of	of	IN
18637	2437	134	miles	mile	NNS
18637	2437	135	covered	cover	VBN
18637	2437	136	by	by	IN
18637	2437	137	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2437	138	in	in	IN
18637	2437	139	the	the	DT
18637	2437	140	State	State	NNP
18637	2437	141	to	to	IN
18637	2437	142	the	the	DT
18637	2437	143	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2437	144	covered	cover	VBN
18637	2437	145	by	by	IN
18637	2437	146	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2437	147	in	in	IN
18637	2437	148	all	all	DT
18637	2437	149	States	state	NNS
18637	2437	150	.	.	.
18637	2438	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2438	2	667	667	CD
18637	2438	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2438	4	Also	also	RB
18637	2438	5	,	,	,
18637	2438	6	a	a	DT
18637	2438	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	2438	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	2438	9	been	be	VBN
18637	2438	10	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	2438	11	as	as	IN
18637	2438	12	to	to	IN
18637	2438	13	a	a	DT
18637	2438	14	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2438	15	line	line	NN
18637	2438	16	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2438	17	principal	principal	JJ
18637	2438	18	business	business	NN
18637	2438	19	was	be	VBD
18637	2438	20	hauling	haul	VBG
18637	2438	21	ore	ore	NN
18637	2438	22	from	from	IN
18637	2438	23	mines	mine	NNS
18637	2438	24	in	in	IN
18637	2438	25	the	the	DT
18637	2438	26	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2438	27	State	state	NN
18637	2438	28	to	to	IN
18637	2438	29	terminal	terminal	JJ
18637	2438	30	docks	dock	NNS
18637	2438	31	outside	outside	IN
18637	2438	32	the	the	DT
18637	2438	33	State	State	NNP
18637	2438	34	,	,	,
18637	2438	35	where	where	WRB
18637	2438	36	the	the	DT
18637	2438	37	line	line	NN
18637	2438	38	and	and	CC
18637	2438	39	the	the	DT
18637	2438	40	docks	dock	NNS
18637	2438	41	were	be	VBD
18637	2438	42	treated	treat	VBN
18637	2438	43	by	by	IN
18637	2438	44	the	the	DT
18637	2438	45	railway	railway	NN
18637	2438	46	as	as	IN
18637	2438	47	a	a	DT
18637	2438	48	unit	unit	NN
18637	2438	49	,	,	,
18637	2438	50	the	the	DT
18637	2438	51	charge	charge	NN
18637	2438	52	for	for	IN
18637	2438	53	the	the	DT
18637	2438	54	dock	dock	NN
18637	2438	55	service	service	NN
18637	2438	56	being	be	VBG
18637	2438	57	absorbed	absorb	VBN
18637	2438	58	in	in	IN
18637	2438	59	the	the	DT
18637	2438	60	charge	charge	NN
18637	2438	61	per	per	IN
18637	2438	62	ton	ton	NN
18637	2438	63	transported	transport	VBN
18637	2438	64	;	;	:
18637	2438	65	and	and	CC
18637	2438	66	where	where	WRB
18637	2438	67	the	the	DT
18637	2438	68	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	2438	69	did	do	VBD
18637	2438	70	not	not	RB
18637	2438	71	show	show	VB
18637	2438	72	that	that	IN
18637	2438	73	the	the	DT
18637	2438	74	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2438	75	value	value	NN
18637	2438	76	of	of	IN
18637	2438	77	the	the	DT
18637	2438	78	part	part	NN
18637	2438	79	of	of	IN
18637	2438	80	the	the	DT
18637	2438	81	line	line	NN
18637	2438	82	outside	outside	IN
18637	2438	83	of	of	IN
18637	2438	84	the	the	DT
18637	2438	85	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2438	86	State	State	NNP
18637	2438	87	,	,	,
18637	2438	88	with	with	IN
18637	2438	89	the	the	DT
18637	2438	90	docks	dock	NNS
18637	2438	91	included	include	VBN
18637	2438	92	,	,	,
18637	2438	93	was	be	VBD
18637	2438	94	greater	great	JJR
18637	2438	95	than	than	IN
18637	2438	96	the	the	DT
18637	2438	97	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2438	98	value	value	NN
18637	2438	99	of	of	IN
18637	2438	100	part	part	NN
18637	2438	101	within	within	IN
18637	2438	102	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2438	103	.	.	.
18637	2439	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2439	2	668	668	CD
18637	2439	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2439	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	2439	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	2439	6	the	the	DT
18637	2439	7	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2439	8	clause	clause	NN
18637	2439	9	preclude	preclude	IN
18637	2439	10	the	the	DT
18637	2439	11	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	2439	12	of	of	IN
18637	2439	13	an	an	DT
18637	2439	14	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2439	15	railway	railway	NN
18637	2439	16	within	within	IN
18637	2439	17	a	a	DT
18637	2439	18	State	state	NN
18637	2439	19	by	by	IN
18637	2439	20	taking	take	VBG
18637	2439	21	such	such	JJ
18637	2439	22	part	part	NN
18637	2439	23	of	of	IN
18637	2439	24	the	the	DT
18637	2439	25	value	value	NN
18637	2439	26	of	of	IN
18637	2439	27	the	the	DT
18637	2439	28	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2439	29	's	's	POS
18637	2439	30	entire	entire	JJ
18637	2439	31	system	system	NN
18637	2439	32	,	,	,
18637	2439	33	less	less	CC
18637	2439	34	the	the	DT
18637	2439	35	value	value	NN
18637	2439	36	of	of	IN
18637	2439	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2439	38	localized	localized	JJ
18637	2439	39	property	property	NN
18637	2439	40	,	,	,
18637	2439	41	such	such	JJ
18637	2439	42	as	as	IN
18637	2439	43	terminal	terminal	JJ
18637	2439	44	buildings	building	NNS
18637	2439	45	,	,	,
18637	2439	46	shops	shop	NNS
18637	2439	47	and	and	CC
18637	2439	48	nonoperating	nonoperate	VBG
18637	2439	49	real	real	JJ
18637	2439	50	estate	estate	NN
18637	2439	51	,	,	,
18637	2439	52	as	as	IN
18637	2439	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	2439	54	represented	represent	VBN
18637	2439	55	by	by	IN
18637	2439	56	the	the	DT
18637	2439	57	ratio	ratio	NN
18637	2439	58	which	which	WDT
18637	2439	59	the	the	DT
18637	2439	60	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2439	61	's	's	POS
18637	2439	62	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2439	63	within	within	IN
18637	2439	64	the	the	DT
18637	2439	65	State	state	NN
18637	2439	66	bears	bear	VBZ
18637	2439	67	to	to	IN
18637	2439	68	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2439	69	total	total	JJ
18637	2439	70	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2439	71	.	.	.
18637	2440	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2440	2	669	669	CD
18637	2440	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2440	4	To	to	IN
18637	2440	5	the	the	DT
18637	2440	6	objection	objection	NN
18637	2440	7	that	that	IN
18637	2440	8	the	the	DT
18637	2440	9	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2440	10	formula	formula	NN
18637	2440	11	was	be	VBD
18637	2440	12	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	2440	13	in	in	IN
18637	2440	14	this	this	DT
18637	2440	15	instance	instance	NN
18637	2440	16	because	because	IN
18637	2440	17	of	of	IN
18637	2440	18	the	the	DT
18637	2440	19	disparity	disparity	NN
18637	2440	20	of	of	IN
18637	2440	21	the	the	DT
18637	2440	22	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	2440	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	2440	24	producing	produce	VBG
18637	2440	25	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	2440	26	between	between	IN
18637	2440	27	the	the	DT
18637	2440	28	lines	line	NNS
18637	2440	29	in	in	IN
18637	2440	30	and	and	CC
18637	2440	31	out	out	IN
18637	2440	32	of	of	IN
18637	2440	33	the	the	DT
18637	2440	34	State	State	NNP
18637	2440	35	,	,	,
18637	2440	36	the	the	DT
18637	2440	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2440	38	answered	answer	VBD
18637	2440	39	that	that	IN
18637	2440	40	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
18637	2440	41	exactitude	exactitude	NN
18637	2440	42	in	in	IN
18637	2440	43	making	make	VBG
18637	2440	44	an	an	DT
18637	2440	45	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	2440	46	had	have	VBD
18637	2440	47	never	never	RB
18637	2440	48	been	be	VBN
18637	2440	49	a	a	DT
18637	2440	50	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2440	51	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	2440	52	.	.	.
18637	2441	1	"	"	``
18637	2441	2	Wherever	wherever	NN
18637	2441	3	,	,	,
18637	2441	4	"	"	''
18637	2441	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2441	6	explained	explain	VBD
18637	2441	7	,	,	,
18637	2441	8	"	"	''
18637	2441	9	the	the	DT
18637	2441	10	State	State	NNP
18637	2441	11	's	's	POS
18637	2441	12	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2441	13	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	2441	14	have	have	VBP
18637	2441	15	been	be	VBN
18637	2441	16	held	hold	VBN
18637	2441	17	to	to	TO
18637	2441	18	have	have	VB
18637	2441	19	intruded	intrude	VBN
18637	2441	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	2441	21	the	the	DT
18637	2441	22	protected	protected	JJ
18637	2441	23	domain	domain	NN
18637	2441	24	of	of	IN
18637	2441	25	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2441	26	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2441	27	in	in	IN
18637	2441	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2441	29	use	use	NN
18637	2441	30	of	of	IN
18637	2441	31	a	a	DT
18637	2441	32	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2441	33	formula	formula	NN
18637	2441	34	,	,	,
18637	2441	35	the	the	DT
18637	2441	36	special	special	JJ
18637	2441	37	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	2441	38	of	of	IN
18637	2441	39	the	the	DT
18637	2441	40	particular	particular	JJ
18637	2441	41	situation	situation	NN
18637	2441	42	,	,	,
18637	2441	43	in	in	IN
18637	2441	44	the	the	DT
18637	2441	45	view	view	NN
18637	2441	46	which	which	WDT
18637	2441	47	this	this	DT
18637	2441	48	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2441	49	took	take	VBD
18637	2441	50	of	of	IN
18637	2441	51	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2441	52	,	,	,
18637	2441	53	precluded	preclude	VBD
18637	2441	54	a	a	DT
18637	2441	55	defensible	defensible	JJ
18637	2441	56	utilization	utilization	NN
18637	2441	57	of	of	IN
18637	2441	58	the	the	DT
18637	2441	59	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2441	60	basis	basis	NN
18637	2441	61	.	.	.
18637	2442	1	"	"	``
18637	2442	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2442	3	670	670	CD
18637	2442	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2442	5	The	the	DT
18637	2442	6	principle	principle	NN
18637	2442	7	of	of	IN
18637	2442	8	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	2442	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	2442	10	,	,	,
18637	2442	11	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	2442	12	,	,	,
18637	2442	13	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	2442	14	to	to	IN
18637	2442	15	the	the	DT
18637	2442	16	intangible	intangible	JJ
18637	2442	17	property	property	NN
18637	2442	18	of	of	IN
18637	2442	19	a	a	DT
18637	2442	20	company	company	NN
18637	2442	21	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2442	22	in	in	IN
18637	2442	23	both	both	CC
18637	2442	24	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2442	25	and	and	CC
18637	2442	26	local	local	JJ
18637	2442	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2442	28	,	,	,
18637	2442	29	as	as	RB
18637	2442	30	well	well	RB
18637	2442	31	as	as	IN
18637	2442	32	to	to	IN
18637	2442	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2442	34	tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	2442	35	property	property	NN
18637	2442	36	.	.	.
18637	2443	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2443	2	671	671	CD
18637	2443	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2443	4	APPORTIONED	apportion	VBD
18637	2443	5	GROSS	gross	JJ
18637	2443	6	RECEIPTS	receipt	NNS
18637	2443	7	TAXES	taxes	VBP
18637	2443	8	The	the	DT
18637	2443	9	first	first	JJ
18637	2443	10	State	state	NN
18637	2443	11	to	to	TO
18637	2443	12	attempt	attempt	VB
18637	2443	13	to	to	TO
18637	2443	14	employ	employ	VB
18637	2443	15	the	the	DT
18637	2443	16	apportionment	apportionment	JJ
18637	2443	17	device	device	NN
18637	2443	18	in	in	IN
18637	2443	19	order	order	NN
18637	2443	20	to	to	TO
18637	2443	21	tax	tax	VB
18637	2443	22	the	the	DT
18637	2443	23	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2443	24	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2443	25	of	of	IN
18637	2443	26	companies	company	NNS
18637	2443	27	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2443	28	in	in	IN
18637	2443	29	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2443	30	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2443	31	was	be	VBD
18637	2443	32	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	2443	33	,	,	,
18637	2443	34	in	in	IN
18637	2443	35	connection	connection	NN
18637	2443	36	with	with	IN
18637	2443	37	a	a	DT
18637	2443	38	so	so	RB
18637	2443	39	-	-	HYPH
18637	2443	40	called	call	VBN
18637	2443	41	"	"	``
18637	2443	42	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	2443	43	tax	tax	NN
18637	2443	44	,	,	,
18637	2443	45	"	"	''
18637	2443	46	which	which	WDT
18637	2443	47	was	be	VBD
18637	2443	48	levied	levy	VBN
18637	2443	49	on	on	IN
18637	2443	50	such	such	JJ
18637	2443	51	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	2443	52	of	of	IN
18637	2443	53	the	the	DT
18637	2443	54	revenues	revenue	NNS
18637	2443	55	of	of	IN
18637	2443	56	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	2443	57	operating	operate	VBG
18637	2443	58	in	in	IN
18637	2443	59	the	the	DT
18637	2443	60	State	State	NNP
18637	2443	61	as	as	IN
18637	2443	62	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2443	63	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2443	64	there	there	RB
18637	2443	65	bore	bear	VBD
18637	2443	66	to	to	IN
18637	2443	67	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2443	68	total	total	JJ
18637	2443	69	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2443	70	.	.	.
18637	2444	1	In	in	IN
18637	2444	2	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	2444	3	_	_	NNP
18637	2444	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	2444	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2444	6	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	2444	7	Trunk	Trunk	NNP
18637	2444	8	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	2444	9	Company,[672	Company,[672	NNP
18637	2444	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2444	11	a	a	DT
18637	2444	12	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	2444	13	divided	divide	VBN
18637	2444	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2444	15	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	2444	16	the	the	DT
18637	2444	17	tax	tax	NN
18637	2444	18	on	on	IN
18637	2444	19	the	the	DT
18637	2444	20	basis	basis	NN
18637	2444	21	of	of	IN
18637	2444	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2444	23	designation	designation	NN
18637	2444	24	,	,	,
18637	2444	25	giving	give	VBG
18637	2444	26	scant	scant	JJ
18637	2444	27	attention	attention	NN
18637	2444	28	to	to	IN
18637	2444	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2444	30	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	2444	31	feature	feature	NN
18637	2444	32	.	.	.
18637	2445	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	2445	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2445	3	Field	Field	NNP
18637	2445	4	for	for	IN
18637	2445	5	the	the	DT
18637	2445	6	majority	majority	NN
18637	2445	7	:	:	:
18637	2445	8	"	"	``
18637	2445	9	The	the	DT
18637	2445	10	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2445	11	of	of	IN
18637	2445	12	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	2445	13	the	the	DT
18637	2445	14	franchises	franchise	NNS
18637	2445	15	of	of	IN
18637	2445	16	a	a	DT
18637	2445	17	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2445	18	within	within	IN
18637	2445	19	a	a	DT
18637	2445	20	State	state	NN
18637	2445	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	2445	22	generally	generally	RB
18637	2445	23	one	one	CD
18637	2445	24	of	of	IN
18637	2445	25	value	value	NN
18637	2445	26	,	,	,
18637	2445	27	and	and	CC
18637	2445	28	often	often	RB
18637	2445	29	of	of	IN
18637	2445	30	great	great	JJ
18637	2445	31	value	value	NN
18637	2445	32	,	,	,
18637	2445	33	and	and	CC
18637	2445	34	the	the	DT
18637	2445	35	subject	subject	NN
18637	2445	36	of	of	IN
18637	2445	37	earnest	earnest	JJ
18637	2445	38	contention	contention	NN
18637	2445	39	.	.	.
18637	2446	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2446	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2446	3	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2446	4	,	,	,
18637	2446	5	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	2446	6	,	,	,
18637	2446	7	that	that	IN
18637	2446	8	the	the	DT
18637	2446	9	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2446	10	should	should	MD
18637	2446	11	be	be	VB
18637	2446	12	made	make	VBN
18637	2446	13	to	to	TO
18637	2446	14	bear	bear	VB
18637	2446	15	some	some	DT
18637	2446	16	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	2446	17	of	of	IN
18637	2446	18	the	the	DT
18637	2446	19	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	2446	20	of	of	IN
18637	2446	21	government	government	NN
18637	2446	22	.	.	.
18637	2447	1	As	as	IN
18637	2447	2	the	the	DT
18637	2447	3	granting	granting	NN
18637	2447	4	of	of	IN
18637	2447	5	the	the	DT
18637	2447	6	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2447	7	rests	rest	NNS
18637	2447	8	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	2447	9	in	in	IN
18637	2447	10	the	the	DT
18637	2447	11	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	2447	12	of	of	IN
18637	2447	13	the	the	DT
18637	2447	14	State	State	NNP
18637	2447	15	,	,	,
18637	2447	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	2447	17	the	the	DT
18637	2447	18	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2447	19	be	be	VB
18637	2447	20	of	of	IN
18637	2447	21	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	2447	22	or	or	CC
18637	2447	23	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2447	24	origin	origin	NN
18637	2447	25	,	,	,
18637	2447	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2447	27	may	may	MD
18637	2447	28	be	be	VB
18637	2447	29	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	2447	30	upon	upon	IN
18637	2447	31	such	such	JJ
18637	2447	32	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2447	33	,	,	,
18637	2447	34	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
18637	2447	35	or	or	CC
18637	2447	36	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2447	37	,	,	,
18637	2447	38	as	as	IN
18637	2447	39	the	the	DT
18637	2447	40	State	State	NNP
18637	2447	41	in	in	IN
18637	2447	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2447	43	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	2447	44	may	may	MD
18637	2447	45	deem	deem	VB
18637	2447	46	most	most	RBS
18637	2447	47	conducive	conducive	JJ
18637	2447	48	to	to	IN
18637	2447	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2447	50	interests	interest	NNS
18637	2447	51	or	or	CC
18637	2447	52	policy	policy	NN
18637	2447	53	.	.	.
18637	2448	1	"	"	``
18637	2448	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2448	3	673	673	CD
18637	2448	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2448	5	Four	four	CD
18637	2448	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	2448	7	,	,	,
18637	2448	8	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2448	9	by	by	IN
18637	2448	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2448	11	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	2448	12	,	,	,
18637	2448	13	protested	protest	VBD
18637	2448	14	forcefully	forcefully	RB
18637	2448	15	that	that	IN
18637	2448	16	the	the	DT
18637	2448	17	decision	decision	NN
18637	2448	18	directly	directly	RB
18637	2448	19	contradicted	contradict	VBD
18637	2448	20	a	a	DT
18637	2448	21	whole	whole	JJ
18637	2448	22	series	series	NN
18637	2448	23	of	of	IN
18637	2448	24	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	2448	25	holding	hold	VBG
18637	2448	26	that	that	IN
18637	2448	27	the	the	DT
18637	2448	28	States	state	NNS
18637	2448	29	are	be	VBP
18637	2448	30	without	without	IN
18637	2448	31	power	power	NN
18637	2448	32	to	to	TO
18637	2448	33	tax	tax	VB
18637	2448	34	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2448	35	commerce;[674	commerce;[674	NNPS
18637	2448	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2448	37	and	and	CC
18637	2448	38	seventeen	seventeen	CD
18637	2448	39	years	year	NNS
18637	2448	40	later	later	RB
18637	2448	41	another	another	DT
18637	2448	42	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	2448	43	divided	divide	VBN
18637	2448	44	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2448	45	endorsed	endorse	VBD
18637	2448	46	this	this	DT
18637	2448	47	contention	contention	NN
18637	2448	48	when	when	WRB
18637	2448	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2448	50	overturned	overturn	VBD
18637	2448	51	a	a	DT
18637	2448	52	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	2448	53	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2448	54	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2448	55	tax	tax	NN
18637	2448	56	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	2448	57	on	on	IN
18637	2448	58	the	the	DT
18637	2448	59	lines	line	NNS
18637	2448	60	of	of	IN
18637	2448	61	the	the	DT
18637	2448	62	earlier	early	JJR
18637	2448	63	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	2448	64	statute	statute	NN
18637	2448	65	.	.	.
18637	2449	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2449	2	675	675	CD
18637	2449	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2449	4	The	the	DT
18637	2449	5	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	2449	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	2449	7	,	,	,
18637	2449	8	however	however	RB
18637	2449	9	,	,	,
18637	2449	10	the	the	DT
18637	2449	11	later	later	JJ
18637	2449	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2449	13	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	2449	14	,	,	,
18637	2449	15	had	have	VBD
18637	2449	16	been	be	VBN
18637	2449	17	in	in	IN
18637	2449	18	the	the	DT
18637	2449	19	nature	nature	NN
18637	2449	20	of	of	IN
18637	2449	21	a	a	DT
18637	2449	22	commutation	commutation	NN
18637	2449	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	2449	24	in	in	IN
18637	2449	25	lieu	lieu	NN
18637	2449	26	of	of	IN
18637	2449	27	all	all	DT
18637	2449	28	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2449	29	,	,	,
18637	2449	30	which	which	WDT
18637	2449	31	the	the	DT
18637	2449	32	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	2449	33	tax	tax	NN
18637	2449	34	was	be	VBD
18637	2449	35	not	not	RB
18637	2449	36	.	.	.
18637	2450	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2450	2	676	676	CD
18637	2450	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2450	4	FRANCHISE	franchise	NN
18637	2450	5	TAXES	taxis	NNS
18637	2450	6	Today	today	NN
18637	2450	7	the	the	DT
18637	2450	8	term	term	NN
18637	2450	9	,	,	,
18637	2450	10	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	2450	11	tax	tax	NN
18637	2450	12	,	,	,
18637	2450	13	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	2450	14	no	no	DT
18637	2450	15	specific	specific	JJ
18637	2450	16	saving	save	VBG
18637	2450	17	quality	quality	NN
18637	2450	18	of	of	IN
18637	2450	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2450	20	own	own	JJ
18637	2450	21	.	.	.
18637	2451	1	If	if	IN
18637	2451	2	the	the	DT
18637	2451	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	2451	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	2451	5	merely	merely	RB
18637	2451	6	a	a	DT
18637	2451	7	"	"	``
18637	2451	8	just	just	RB
18637	2451	9	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
18637	2451	10	"	"	''
18637	2451	11	of	of	IN
18637	2451	12	other	other	JJ
18637	2451	13	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2451	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2451	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	2451	16	valid	valid	JJ
18637	2451	17	however	however	RB
18637	2451	18	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	2451	19	.	.	.
18637	2452	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2452	2	677	677	CD
18637	2452	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2452	4	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	2452	5	,	,	,
18637	2452	6	when	when	WRB
18637	2452	7	such	such	JJ
18637	2452	8	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2452	9	are	be	VBP
18637	2452	10	in	in	IN
18637	2452	11	addition	addition	NN
18637	2452	12	to	to	IN
18637	2452	13	other	other	JJ
18637	2452	14	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2452	15	then	then	RB
18637	2452	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2452	17	fate	fate	NN
18637	2452	18	will	will	MD
18637	2452	19	be	be	VB
18637	2452	20	determined	determine	VBN
18637	2452	21	by	by	IN
18637	2452	22	the	the	DT
18637	2452	23	same	same	JJ
18637	2452	24	rules	rule	NNS
18637	2452	25	as	as	IN
18637	2452	26	would	would	MD
18637	2452	27	apply	apply	VB
18637	2452	28	had	have	VBD
18637	2452	29	the	the	DT
18637	2452	30	label	label	NN
18637	2452	31	been	be	VBN
18637	2452	32	omitted	omit	VBN
18637	2452	33	.	.	.
18637	2453	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2453	2	678	678	CD
18637	2453	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2453	4	More	more	RBR
18637	2453	5	precisely	precisely	RB
18637	2453	6	,	,	,
18637	2453	7	the	the	DT
18637	2453	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	2453	9	governing	govern	VBG
18637	2453	10	this	this	DT
18637	2453	11	species	specie	NNS
18637	2453	12	of	of	IN
18637	2453	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	2453	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	2453	15	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	2453	16	the	the	DT
18637	2453	17	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	2453	18	concept	concept	NN
18637	2453	19	,	,	,
18637	2453	20	and	and	CC
18637	2453	21	if	if	IN
18637	2453	22	the	the	DT
18637	2453	23	basis	basis	NN
18637	2453	24	of	of	IN
18637	2453	25	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	2453	26	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	2453	27	by	by	IN
18637	2453	28	the	the	DT
18637	2453	29	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2453	30	State	State	NNP
18637	2453	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	2453	32	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	2453	33	by	by	IN
18637	2453	34	the	the	DT
18637	2453	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2453	36	to	to	TO
18637	2453	37	be	be	VB
18637	2453	38	a	a	DT
18637	2453	39	fair	fair	JJ
18637	2453	40	and	and	CC
18637	2453	41	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2453	42	one	one	CD
18637	2453	43	,	,	,
18637	2453	44	the	the	DT
18637	2453	45	tax	tax	NN
18637	2453	46	will	will	MD
18637	2453	47	be	be	VB
18637	2453	48	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2453	49	;	;	:
18637	2453	50	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2453	51	,	,	,
18637	2453	52	not	not	RB
18637	2453	53	.	.	.
18637	2454	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2454	2	a	a	DT
18637	2454	3	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	2454	4	tax	tax	NN
18637	2454	5	may	may	MD
18637	2454	6	be	be	VB
18637	2454	7	measured	measure	VBN
18637	2454	8	by	by	IN
18637	2454	9	such	such	JJ
18637	2454	10	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	2454	11	of	of	IN
18637	2454	12	the	the	DT
18637	2454	13	company	company	NN
18637	2454	14	's	's	POS
18637	2454	15	net	net	JJ
18637	2454	16	income	income	NN
18637	2454	17	as	as	IN
18637	2454	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2454	19	capital	capital	NN
18637	2454	20	invested	invest	VBN
18637	2454	21	in	in	IN
18637	2454	22	the	the	DT
18637	2454	23	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2454	24	State	state	NN
18637	2454	25	and	and	CC
18637	2454	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2454	27	business	business	NN
18637	2454	28	carried	carry	VBN
18637	2454	29	on	on	RB
18637	2454	30	there	there	RB
18637	2454	31	bear	bear	NN
18637	2454	32	to	to	IN
18637	2454	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2454	34	total	total	JJ
18637	2454	35	capital	capital	NN
18637	2454	36	and	and	CC
18637	2454	37	business;[679	business;[679	NNS
18637	2454	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2454	39	also	also	RB
18637	2454	40	by	by	IN
18637	2454	41	the	the	DT
18637	2454	42	net	net	JJ
18637	2454	43	income	income	NN
18637	2454	44	justly	justly	RB
18637	2454	45	attributable	attributable	JJ
18637	2454	46	to	to	TO
18637	2454	47	business	business	NN
18637	2454	48	done	do	VBN
18637	2454	49	within	within	IN
18637	2454	50	the	the	DT
18637	2454	51	State	State	NNP
18637	2454	52	although	although	IN
18637	2454	53	a	a	DT
18637	2454	54	part	part	NN
18637	2454	55	of	of	IN
18637	2454	56	this	this	DT
18637	2454	57	was	be	VBD
18637	2454	58	derived	derive	VBN
18637	2454	59	from	from	IN
18637	2454	60	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2454	61	or	or	CC
18637	2454	62	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2454	63	commerce;[680	commerce;[680	NNS
18637	2454	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2454	65	also	also	RB
18637	2454	66	by	by	IN
18637	2454	67	such	such	JJ
18637	2454	68	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	2454	69	of	of	IN
18637	2454	70	the	the	DT
18637	2454	71	company	company	NN
18637	2454	72	's	's	POS
18637	2454	73	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	2454	74	capital	capital	NN
18637	2454	75	stock	stock	NN
18637	2454	76	,	,	,
18637	2454	77	surplus	surplus	NN
18637	2454	78	and	and	CC
18637	2454	79	undivided	undivided	JJ
18637	2454	80	profits	profit	NNS
18637	2454	81	,	,	,
18637	2454	82	plus	plus	CC
18637	2454	83	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2454	84	long	long	JJ
18637	2454	85	-	-	HYPH
18637	2454	86	term	term	NN
18637	2454	87	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	2454	88	,	,	,
18637	2454	89	as	as	IN
18637	2454	90	the	the	DT
18637	2454	91	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2454	92	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2454	93	of	of	IN
18637	2454	94	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2454	95	local	local	JJ
18637	2454	96	business	business	NN
18637	2454	97	bear	bear	NN
18637	2454	98	to	to	IN
18637	2454	99	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2454	100	total	total	JJ
18637	2454	101	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2454	102	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2454	103	from	from	IN
18637	2454	104	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2454	105	entire	entire	JJ
18637	2454	106	business;[681	business;[681	NNP
18637	2454	107	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2454	108	also	also	RB
18637	2454	109	by	by	IN
18637	2454	110	such	such	JJ
18637	2454	111	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	2454	112	of	of	IN
18637	2454	113	the	the	DT
18637	2454	114	company	company	NN
18637	2454	115	's	's	POS
18637	2454	116	total	total	JJ
18637	2454	117	capital	capital	NN
18637	2454	118	stock	stock	NN
18637	2454	119	as	as	IN
18637	2454	120	the	the	DT
18637	2454	121	value	value	NN
18637	2454	122	of	of	IN
18637	2454	123	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2454	124	property	property	NN
18637	2454	125	in	in	IN
18637	2454	126	the	the	DT
18637	2454	127	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2454	128	State	state	NN
18637	2454	129	and	and	CC
18637	2454	130	of	of	IN
18637	2454	131	the	the	DT
18637	2454	132	business	business	NN
18637	2454	133	done	do	VBN
18637	2454	134	there	there	RB
18637	2454	135	bears	bear	VBZ
18637	2454	136	to	to	IN
18637	2454	137	the	the	DT
18637	2454	138	total	total	JJ
18637	2454	139	value	value	NN
18637	2454	140	of	of	IN
18637	2454	141	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2454	142	property	property	NN
18637	2454	143	and	and	CC
18637	2454	144	of	of	IN
18637	2454	145	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2454	146	business	business	NN
18637	2454	147	.	.	.
18637	2455	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2455	2	682	682	CD
18637	2455	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2455	4	On	on	IN
18637	2455	5	the	the	DT
18637	2455	6	other	other	JJ
18637	2455	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	2455	8	,	,	,
18637	2455	9	a	a	DT
18637	2455	10	"	"	``
18637	2455	11	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	2455	12	"	"	''
18637	2455	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	2455	14	on	on	IN
18637	2455	15	the	the	DT
18637	2455	16	unapportioned	unapportioned	JJ
18637	2455	17	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2455	18	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2455	19	of	of	IN
18637	2455	20	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2455	21	companies	company	NNS
18637	2455	22	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2455	23	in	in	IN
18637	2455	24	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2455	25	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2455	26	,	,	,
18637	2455	27	was	be	VBD
18637	2455	28	,	,	,
18637	2455	29	as	as	IN
18637	2455	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2455	31	saw	see	VBD
18637	2455	32	above	above	RB
18637	2455	33	,	,	,
18637	2455	34	held	hold	VBD
18637	2455	35	void;[683	void;[683	NNPS
18637	2455	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2455	37	as	as	IN
18637	2455	38	was	be	VBD
18637	2455	39	also	also	RB
18637	2455	40	one	one	CD
18637	2455	41	which	which	WDT
18637	2455	42	was	be	VBD
18637	2455	43	measured	measure	VBN
18637	2455	44	by	by	IN
18637	2455	45	assigning	assign	VBG
18637	2455	46	to	to	IN
18637	2455	47	the	the	DT
18637	2455	48	company	company	NN
18637	2455	49	's	's	POS
18637	2455	50	property	property	NN
18637	2455	51	in	in	IN
18637	2455	52	the	the	DT
18637	2455	53	State	State	NNP
18637	2455	54	the	the	DT
18637	2455	55	same	same	JJ
18637	2455	56	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	2455	57	of	of	IN
18637	2455	58	the	the	DT
18637	2455	59	total	total	JJ
18637	2455	60	value	value	NN
18637	2455	61	of	of	IN
18637	2455	62	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2455	63	stocks	stock	NNS
18637	2455	64	and	and	CC
18637	2455	65	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	2455	66	as	as	IN
18637	2455	67	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2455	68	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2455	69	in	in	IN
18637	2455	70	the	the	DT
18637	2455	71	State	State	NNP
18637	2455	72	bore	bear	VBD
18637	2455	73	to	to	IN
18637	2455	74	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2455	75	total	total	JJ
18637	2455	76	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2455	77	,	,	,
18637	2455	78	no	no	DT
18637	2455	79	account	account	NN
18637	2455	80	being	be	VBG
18637	2455	81	taken	take	VBN
18637	2455	82	of	of	IN
18637	2455	83	the	the	DT
18637	2455	84	greater	great	JJR
18637	2455	85	cost	cost	NN
18637	2455	86	of	of	IN
18637	2455	87	construction	construction	NN
18637	2455	88	of	of	IN
18637	2455	89	the	the	DT
18637	2455	90	company	company	NN
18637	2455	91	's	's	POS
18637	2455	92	lines	line	NNS
18637	2455	93	in	in	IN
18637	2455	94	other	other	JJ
18637	2455	95	States	States	NNPS
18637	2455	96	or	or	CC
18637	2455	97	of	of	IN
18637	2455	98	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2455	99	valuable	valuable	JJ
18637	2455	100	terminals	terminal	NNS
18637	2455	101	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	2455	102	.	.	.
18637	2456	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2456	2	684	684	CD
18637	2456	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2456	4	Other	other	JJ
18637	2456	5	examples	example	NNS
18637	2456	6	were	be	VBD
18637	2456	7	given	give	VBN
18637	2456	8	earlier	early	RBR
18637	2456	9	.	.	.
18637	2457	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2457	2	685	685	CD
18637	2457	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2457	4	GROSS	gross	JJ
18637	2457	5	RECEIPTS	receipt	NNS
18637	2457	6	TAXES	taxes	VBP
18637	2457	7	,	,	,
18637	2457	8	CLASSES	class	NNS
18637	2457	9	OF	of	IN
18637	2457	10	The	the	DT
18637	2457	11	late	late	JJ
18637	2457	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2457	13	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	2457	14	classified	classify	VBD
18637	2457	15	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2457	16	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2457	17	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2457	18	which	which	WDT
18637	2457	19	have	have	VBP
18637	2457	20	been	be	VBN
18637	2457	21	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2457	22	by	by	IN
18637	2457	23	the	the	DT
18637	2457	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2457	25	as	as	IN
18637	2457	26	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	2457	27	:	:	:
18637	2457	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2457	29	a	a	LS
18637	2457	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2457	31	those	those	DT
18637	2457	32	which	which	WDT
18637	2457	33	were	be	VBD
18637	2457	34	judged	judge	VBN
18637	2457	35	to	to	TO
18637	2457	36	be	be	VB
18637	2457	37	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	2457	38	apportioned;[686	apportioned;[686	NNS
18637	2457	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2457	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2457	41	b	b	LS
18637	2457	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2457	43	those	those	DT
18637	2457	44	which	which	WDT
18637	2457	45	were	be	VBD
18637	2457	46	justified	justify	VBN
18637	2457	47	on	on	IN
18637	2457	48	a	a	DT
18637	2457	49	"	"	``
18637	2457	50	local	local	JJ
18637	2457	51	incidence	incidence	NN
18637	2457	52	"	"	''
18637	2457	53	theory	theory	NN
18637	2457	54	,	,	,
18637	2457	55	or	or	CC
18637	2457	56	the	the	DT
18637	2457	57	burden	burden	NN
18637	2457	58	of	of	IN
18637	2457	59	which	which	WDT
18637	2457	60	on	on	IN
18637	2457	61	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2457	62	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2457	63	was	be	VBD
18637	2457	64	held	hold	VBN
18637	2457	65	to	to	TO
18637	2457	66	be	be	VB
18637	2457	67	"	"	``
18637	2457	68	remote";[687	remote";[687	NNP
18637	2457	69	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2457	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2457	71	c	c	NN
18637	2457	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2457	73	those	those	DT
18637	2457	74	which	which	WDT
18637	2457	75	were	be	VBD
18637	2457	76	justified	justify	VBN
18637	2457	77	as	as	IN
18637	2457	78	not	not	RB
18637	2457	79	inviting	invite	VBG
18637	2457	80	the	the	DT
18637	2457	81	danger	danger	NN
18637	2457	82	of	of	IN
18637	2457	83	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	2457	84	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2457	85	of	of	IN
18637	2457	86	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2457	87	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2457	88	.	.	.
18637	2458	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2458	2	688	688	CD
18637	2458	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2458	4	Gross	Gross	NNP
18637	2458	5	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2458	6	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2458	7	which	which	WDT
18637	2458	8	,	,	,
18637	2458	9	on	on	IN
18637	2458	10	the	the	DT
18637	2458	11	other	other	JJ
18637	2458	12	hand	hand	NN
18637	2458	13	,	,	,
18637	2458	14	have	have	VBP
18637	2458	15	been	be	VBN
18637	2458	16	invalidated	invalidate	VBN
18637	2458	17	under	under	IN
18637	2458	18	the	the	DT
18637	2458	19	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2458	20	clause	clause	NN
18637	2458	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2458	22	placed	place	VBD
18637	2458	23	in	in	IN
18637	2458	24	the	the	DT
18637	2458	25	following	follow	VBG
18637	2458	26	groups	group	NNS
18637	2458	27	:	:	:
18637	2458	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2458	29	a	a	LS
18637	2458	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2458	31	those	those	DT
18637	2458	32	which	which	WDT
18637	2458	33	were	be	VBD
18637	2458	34	held	hold	VBN
18637	2458	35	not	not	RB
18637	2458	36	to	to	TO
18637	2458	37	be	be	VB
18637	2458	38	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	2458	39	apportioned;[689	apportioned;[689	CD
18637	2458	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2458	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2458	42	b	b	LS
18637	2458	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2458	44	those	those	DT
18637	2458	45	which	which	WDT
18637	2458	46	were	be	VBD
18637	2458	47	not	not	RB
18637	2458	48	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	2458	49	at	at	RB
18637	2458	50	all	all	RB
18637	2458	51	and	and	CC
18637	2458	52	were	be	VBD
18637	2458	53	bound	bind	VBN
18637	2458	54	to	to	IN
18637	2458	55	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2458	56	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2458	57	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2458	58	to	to	IN
18637	2458	59	the	the	DT
18637	2458	60	risk	risk	NN
18637	2458	61	of	of	IN
18637	2458	62	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	2458	63	taxation;[690	taxation;[690	NNS
18637	2458	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2458	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2458	66	c	c	NN
18637	2458	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2458	68	those	those	DT
18637	2458	69	in	in	IN
18637	2458	70	which	which	WDT
18637	2458	71	a	a	DT
18637	2458	72	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	2458	73	element	element	NN
18637	2458	74	was	be	VBD
18637	2458	75	detected	detect	VBN
18637	2458	76	in	in	IN
18637	2458	77	that	that	IN
18637	2458	78	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2458	79	were	be	VBD
18637	2458	80	directed	direct	VBN
18637	2458	81	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	2458	82	at	at	IN
18637	2458	83	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2458	84	or	or	CC
18637	2458	85	communication;[691	communication;[691	NNS
18637	2458	86	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2458	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2458	88	d	d	NN
18637	2458	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2458	90	those	those	DT
18637	2458	91	in	in	IN
18637	2458	92	which	which	WDT
18637	2458	93	there	there	EX
18637	2458	94	was	be	VBD
18637	2458	95	no	no	DT
18637	2458	96	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	2458	97	but	but	IN
18637	2458	98	a	a	DT
18637	2458	99	possible	possible	JJ
18637	2458	100	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	2458	101	burden;[692	burden;[692	NNS
18637	2458	102	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2458	103	and	and	CC
18637	2458	104	,	,	,
18637	2458	105	of	of	IN
18637	2458	106	course	course	NN
18637	2458	107	,	,	,
18637	2458	108	any	any	DT
18637	2458	109	tax	tax	NN
18637	2458	110	which	which	WDT
18637	2458	111	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2458	112	disallows	disallow	VBZ
18637	2458	113	the	the	DT
18637	2458	114	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2458	115	is	be	VBZ
18637	2458	116	always	always	RB
18637	2458	117	free	free	JJ
18637	2458	118	to	to	TO
18637	2458	119	stigmatize	stigmatize	VB
18637	2458	120	as	as	IN
18637	2458	121	an	an	DT
18637	2458	122	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2458	123	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	2458	124	to	to	TO
18637	2458	125	tax	tax	VB
18637	2458	126	or	or	CC
18637	2458	127	license	license	VB
18637	2458	128	the	the	DT
18637	2458	129	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2458	130	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2458	131	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2458	132	.	.	.
18637	2459	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2459	2	693	693	CD
18637	2459	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2459	4	"	"	``
18637	2459	5	MULTIPLE	multiple	JJ
18637	2459	6	TAXATION	taxation	NN
18637	2459	7	"	"	''
18637	2459	8	TEST	test	NN
18637	2459	9	That	that	WDT
18637	2459	10	the	the	DT
18637	2459	11	Depression	Depression	NNP
18637	2459	12	--	--	:
18637	2459	13	allowing	allow	VBG
18637	2459	14	for	for	IN
18637	2459	15	the	the	DT
18637	2459	16	customary	customary	JJ
18637	2459	17	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	2459	18	lag	lag	NN
18637	2459	19	--	--	:
18637	2459	20	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	2459	21	altered	alter	VBD
18637	2459	22	the	the	DT
18637	2459	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2459	24	's	's	POS
18637	2459	25	conception	conception	NN
18637	2459	26	of	of	IN
18637	2459	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2459	28	's	's	POS
18637	2459	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	2459	30	under	under	IN
18637	2459	31	the	the	DT
18637	2459	32	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2459	33	clause	clause	NN
18637	2459	34	,	,	,
18637	2459	35	was	be	VBD
18637	2459	36	pointed	point	VBN
18637	2459	37	out	out	RP
18637	2459	38	earlier	early	RBR
18637	2459	39	.	.	.
18637	2460	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2460	2	694	694	CD
18637	2460	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2460	4	To	to	IN
18637	2460	5	a	a	DT
18637	2460	6	less	less	JJR
18637	2460	7	,	,	,
18637	2460	8	but	but	CC
18637	2460	9	appreciable	appreciable	JJ
18637	2460	10	degree	degree	NN
18637	2460	11	,	,	,
18637	2460	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2460	13	also	also	RB
18637	2460	14	affected	affect	VBD
18637	2460	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2460	16	views	view	NNS
18637	2460	17	as	as	IN
18637	2460	18	to	to	IN
18637	2460	19	the	the	DT
18637	2460	20	allowable	allowable	JJ
18637	2460	21	scope	scope	NN
18637	2460	22	under	under	IN
18637	2460	23	the	the	DT
18637	2460	24	clause	clause	NN
18637	2460	25	of	of	IN
18637	2460	26	the	the	DT
18637	2460	27	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2460	28	power	power	NN
18637	2460	29	of	of	IN
18637	2460	30	the	the	DT
18637	2460	31	States	States	NNP
18637	2460	32	,	,	,
18637	2460	33	a	a	DT
18637	2460	34	majority	majority	NN
18637	2460	35	of	of	IN
18637	2460	36	which	which	WDT
18637	2460	37	were	be	VBD
18637	2460	38	on	on	IN
18637	2460	39	the	the	DT
18637	2460	40	verge	verge	NN
18637	2460	41	of	of	IN
18637	2460	42	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2460	43	.	.	.
18637	2461	1	The	the	DT
18637	2461	2	more	more	RBR
18637	2461	3	evident	evident	JJ
18637	2461	4	proofs	proof	NNS
18637	2461	5	of	of	IN
18637	2461	6	this	this	DT
18637	2461	7	fact	fact	NN
18637	2461	8	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	2461	9	in	in	IN
18637	2461	10	relation	relation	NN
18637	2461	11	to	to	IN
18637	2461	12	State	state	NN
18637	2461	13	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2461	14	of	of	IN
18637	2461	15	the	the	DT
18637	2461	16	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2461	17	matter	matter	NN
18637	2461	18	of	of	IN
18637	2461	19	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2461	20	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2461	21	,	,	,
18637	2461	22	as	as	IN
18637	2461	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	2461	24	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	2461	25	above	above	RB
18637	2461	26	.	.	.
18637	2462	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2462	2	695	695	CD
18637	2462	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2462	4	But	but	CC
18637	2462	5	a	a	DT
18637	2462	6	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2462	7	revision	revision	NN
18637	2462	8	of	of	IN
18637	2462	9	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2462	10	,	,	,
18637	2462	11	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	2462	12	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	2462	13	in	in	IN
18637	2462	14	nature	nature	NN
18637	2462	15	,	,	,
18637	2462	16	however	however	RB
18637	2462	17	,	,	,
18637	2462	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	2462	19	to	to	TO
18637	2462	20	be	be	VB
18637	2462	21	seen	see	VBN
18637	2462	22	in	in	IN
18637	2462	23	the	the	DT
18637	2462	24	connection	connection	NN
18637	2462	25	with	with	IN
18637	2462	26	State	State	NNP
18637	2462	27	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2462	28	impinging	impinge	VBG
18637	2462	29	on	on	IN
18637	2462	30	property	property	NN
18637	2462	31	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2462	32	in	in	IN
18637	2462	33	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2462	34	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2462	35	and	and	CC
18637	2462	36	the	the	DT
18637	2462	37	revenues	revenue	NNS
18637	2462	38	from	from	IN
18637	2462	39	such	such	JJ
18637	2462	40	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2462	41	,	,	,
18637	2462	42	the	the	DT
18637	2462	43	principal	principal	JJ
18637	2462	44	manifestation	manifestation	NN
18637	2462	45	of	of	IN
18637	2462	46	which	which	WDT
18637	2462	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	2462	48	to	to	TO
18637	2462	49	be	be	VB
18637	2462	50	seen	see	VBN
18637	2462	51	in	in	IN
18637	2462	52	the	the	DT
18637	2462	53	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	2462	54	which	which	WDT
18637	2462	55	was	be	VBD
18637	2462	56	for	for	IN
18637	2462	57	a	a	DT
18637	2462	58	time	time	NN
18637	2462	59	given	give	VBN
18637	2462	60	the	the	DT
18637	2462	61	"	"	``
18637	2462	62	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	2462	63	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2462	64	"	"	''
18637	2462	65	test	test	NN
18637	2462	66	.	.	.
18637	2463	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2463	2	in	in	IN
18637	2463	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2463	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2463	5	in	in	IN
18637	2463	6	the	the	DT
18637	2463	7	Western	Western	NNP
18637	2463	8	Live	Live	NNP
18637	2463	9	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	2463	10	Case,[696	Case,[696	NNP
18637	2463	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2463	12	cited	cite	VBN
18637	2463	13	above	above	IN
18637	2463	14	,	,	,
18637	2463	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2463	16	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	2463	17	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	2463	18	to	to	TO
18637	2463	19	be	be	VB
18637	2463	20	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2463	21	in	in	IN
18637	2463	22	an	an	DT
18637	2463	23	endeavor	endeavor	NN
18637	2463	24	to	to	TO
18637	2463	25	erect	erect	VB
18637	2463	26	this	this	DT
18637	2463	27	into	into	IN
18637	2463	28	an	an	DT
18637	2463	29	almost	almost	RB
18637	2463	30	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	2463	31	test	test	NN
18637	2463	32	of	of	IN
18637	2463	33	the	the	DT
18637	2463	34	validity	validity	NN
18637	2463	35	,	,	,
18637	2463	36	or	or	CC
18637	2463	37	invalidity	invalidity	NN
18637	2463	38	of	of	IN
18637	2463	39	State	State	NNP
18637	2463	40	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2463	41	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	2463	42	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2463	43	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2463	44	.	.	.
18637	2464	1	"	"	``
18637	2464	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2464	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2464	4	not	not	RB
18637	2464	5	,	,	,
18637	2464	6	"	"	''
18637	2464	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2464	8	there	there	EX
18637	2464	9	remarks	remark	VBZ
18637	2464	10	,	,	,
18637	2464	11	"	"	''
18637	2464	12	the	the	DT
18637	2464	13	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2464	14	of	of	IN
18637	2464	15	the	the	DT
18637	2464	16	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2464	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	2464	18	to	to	TO
18637	2464	19	relieve	relieve	VB
18637	2464	20	those	those	DT
18637	2464	21	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2464	22	in	in	IN
18637	2464	23	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2464	24	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2464	25	from	from	IN
18637	2464	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2464	27	just	just	JJ
18637	2464	28	share	share	NN
18637	2464	29	of	of	IN
18637	2464	30	State	state	NN
18637	2464	31	tax	tax	NN
18637	2464	32	burden	burden	NN
18637	2464	33	even	even	RB
18637	2464	34	though	though	IN
18637	2464	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2464	36	increases	increase	VBZ
18637	2464	37	the	the	DT
18637	2464	38	cost	cost	NN
18637	2464	39	of	of	IN
18637	2464	40	doing	do	VBG
18637	2464	41	the	the	DT
18637	2464	42	business	business	NN
18637	2464	43	.	.	.
18637	2465	1	'	'	``
18637	2465	2	Even	even	RB
18637	2465	3	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2465	4	business	business	NN
18637	2465	5	must	must	MD
18637	2465	6	pay	pay	VB
18637	2465	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2465	8	way	way	NN
18637	2465	9	,	,	,
18637	2465	10	'	'	''
18637	2465	11	*	*	NFP
18637	2465	12	*	*	NFP
18637	2465	13	*	*	NFP
18637	2465	14	and	and	CC
18637	2465	15	the	the	DT
18637	2465	16	bare	bare	JJ
18637	2465	17	fact	fact	NN
18637	2465	18	that	that	IN
18637	2465	19	one	one	NN
18637	2465	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	2465	21	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	2465	22	on	on	IN
18637	2465	23	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2465	24	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2465	25	does	do	VBZ
18637	2465	26	not	not	RB
18637	2465	27	relieve	relieve	VB
18637	2465	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2465	29	from	from	IN
18637	2465	30	many	many	JJ
18637	2465	31	forms	form	NNS
18637	2465	32	of	of	IN
18637	2465	33	State	state	NN
18637	2465	34	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2465	35	which	which	WDT
18637	2465	36	add	add	VBP
18637	2465	37	to	to	IN
18637	2465	38	the	the	DT
18637	2465	39	cost	cost	NN
18637	2465	40	of	of	IN
18637	2465	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2465	42	business	business	NN
18637	2465	43	.	.	.
18637	2466	1	"	"	``
18637	2466	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2466	3	697	697	CD
18637	2466	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2466	5	Then	then	RB
18637	2466	6	citing	cite	VBG
18637	2466	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	2466	8	,	,	,
18637	2466	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2466	10	continues	continue	VBZ
18637	2466	11	:	:	:
18637	2466	12	"	"	``
18637	2466	13	All	all	DT
18637	2466	14	of	of	IN
18637	2466	15	these	these	DT
18637	2466	16	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2466	17	in	in	IN
18637	2466	18	one	one	CD
18637	2466	19	way	way	NN
18637	2466	20	or	or	CC
18637	2466	21	another	another	DT
18637	2466	22	add	add	NN
18637	2466	23	to	to	IN
18637	2466	24	the	the	DT
18637	2466	25	expense	expense	NN
18637	2466	26	of	of	IN
18637	2466	27	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	2466	28	on	on	IN
18637	2466	29	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2466	30	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2466	31	,	,	,
18637	2466	32	and	and	CC
18637	2466	33	in	in	IN
18637	2466	34	that	that	DT
18637	2466	35	sense	sense	NN
18637	2466	36	burden	burden	VBP
18637	2466	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2466	38	;	;	:
18637	2466	39	but	but	CC
18637	2466	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2466	41	are	be	VBP
18637	2466	42	not	not	RB
18637	2466	43	for	for	IN
18637	2466	44	that	that	DT
18637	2466	45	reason	reason	NN
18637	2466	46	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	2466	47	.	.	.
18637	2467	1	On	on	IN
18637	2467	2	the	the	DT
18637	2467	3	other	other	JJ
18637	2467	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	2467	5	,	,	,
18637	2467	6	local	local	JJ
18637	2467	7	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2467	8	,	,	,
18637	2467	9	measured	measure	VBN
18637	2467	10	by	by	IN
18637	2467	11	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2467	12	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2467	13	from	from	IN
18637	2467	14	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2467	15	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2467	16	,	,	,
18637	2467	17	have	have	VBP
18637	2467	18	often	often	RB
18637	2467	19	been	be	VBN
18637	2467	20	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
18637	2467	21	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2467	22	.	.	.
18637	2468	1	The	the	DT
18637	2468	2	vice	vice	NN
18637	2468	3	characteristic	characteristic	NN
18637	2468	4	of	of	IN
18637	2468	5	those	those	DT
18637	2468	6	which	which	WDT
18637	2468	7	have	have	VBP
18637	2468	8	been	be	VBN
18637	2468	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	2468	10	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	2468	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	2468	12	that	that	IN
18637	2468	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2468	14	have	have	VBP
18637	2468	15	placed	place	VBN
18637	2468	16	on	on	IN
18637	2468	17	the	the	DT
18637	2468	18	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2468	19	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	2468	20	of	of	IN
18637	2468	21	such	such	PDT
18637	2468	22	a	a	DT
18637	2468	23	nature	nature	NN
18637	2468	24	as	as	IN
18637	2468	25	to	to	TO
18637	2468	26	be	be	VB
18637	2468	27	capable	capable	JJ
18637	2468	28	,	,	,
18637	2468	29	in	in	IN
18637	2468	30	point	point	NN
18637	2468	31	of	of	IN
18637	2468	32	substance	substance	NN
18637	2468	33	,	,	,
18637	2468	34	of	of	IN
18637	2468	35	being	be	VBG
18637	2468	36	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2468	37	*	*	NFP
18637	2468	38	*	*	NFP
18637	2468	39	*	*	NFP
18637	2468	40	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2468	41	or	or	CC
18637	2468	42	added	add	VBN
18637	2468	43	to	to	IN
18637	2468	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2468	45	with	with	IN
18637	2468	46	equal	equal	JJ
18637	2468	47	right	right	NN
18637	2468	48	by	by	IN
18637	2468	49	every	every	DT
18637	2468	50	State	State	NNP
18637	2468	51	which	which	WDT
18637	2468	52	the	the	DT
18637	2468	53	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2468	54	touches	touch	NNS
18637	2468	55	,	,	,
18637	2468	56	merely	merely	RB
18637	2468	57	because	because	IN
18637	2468	58	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2468	59	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2468	60	is	be	VBZ
18637	2468	61	being	be	VBG
18637	2468	62	done	do	VBN
18637	2468	63	,	,	,
18637	2468	64	so	so	IN
18637	2468	65	that	that	IN
18637	2468	66	without	without	IN
18637	2468	67	the	the	DT
18637	2468	68	protection	protection	NN
18637	2468	69	of	of	IN
18637	2468	70	the	the	DT
18637	2468	71	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2468	72	clause	clause	NN
18637	2468	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2468	74	would	would	MD
18637	2468	75	bear	bear	VB
18637	2468	76	cumulative	cumulative	JJ
18637	2468	77	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	2468	78	not	not	RB
18637	2468	79	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2468	80	on	on	IN
18637	2468	81	local	local	JJ
18637	2468	82	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2468	83	.	.	.
18637	2469	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2469	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2469	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2469	4	The	the	DT
18637	2469	5	multiplication	multiplication	NN
18637	2469	6	of	of	IN
18637	2469	7	State	state	NN
18637	2469	8	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2469	9	measured	measure	VBN
18637	2469	10	by	by	IN
18637	2469	11	the	the	DT
18637	2469	12	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2469	13	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2469	14	from	from	IN
18637	2469	15	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2469	16	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	2469	17	would	would	MD
18637	2469	18	spell	spell	VB
18637	2469	19	the	the	DT
18637	2469	20	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	2469	21	of	of	IN
18637	2469	22	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2469	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2469	24	and	and	CC
18637	2469	25	renew	renew	VB
18637	2469	26	the	the	DT
18637	2469	27	barriers	barrier	NNS
18637	2469	28	to	to	IN
18637	2469	29	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2469	30	trade	trade	NN
18637	2469	31	which	which	WDT
18637	2469	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2469	33	was	be	VBD
18637	2469	34	the	the	DT
18637	2469	35	object	object	NN
18637	2469	36	of	of	IN
18637	2469	37	the	the	DT
18637	2469	38	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2469	39	clause	clause	NN
18637	2469	40	to	to	TO
18637	2469	41	remove	remove	VB
18637	2469	42	,	,	,
18637	2469	43	"	"	``
18637	2469	44	citing	cite	VBG
18637	2469	45	cases	case	NNS
18637	2469	46	,	,	,
18637	2469	47	most	most	JJS
18637	2469	48	of	of	IN
18637	2469	49	which	which	WDT
18637	2469	50	have	have	VBP
18637	2469	51	been	be	VBN
18637	2469	52	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	2469	53	above	above	RB
18637	2469	54	.	.	.
18637	2470	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2470	2	698	698	CD
18637	2470	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2470	4	And	and	CC
18637	2470	5	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2470	6	again	again	RB
18637	2470	7	for	for	IN
18637	2470	8	the	the	DT
18637	2470	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2470	10	eleven	eleven	CD
18637	2470	11	months	month	NNS
18637	2470	12	later	later	RB
18637	2470	13	,	,	,
18637	2470	14	in	in	IN
18637	2470	15	Gwin	Gwin	NNP
18637	2470	16	,	,	,
18637	2470	17	White	White	NNP
18637	2470	18	and	and	CC
18637	2470	19	Prince	Prince	NNP
18637	2470	20	_	_	NNP
18637	2470	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	2470	22	_	_	NNP
18637	2470	23	Henneford,[699	Henneford,[699	NNP
18637	2470	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2470	25	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2470	26	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	2470	27	applied	apply	VBD
18637	2470	28	the	the	DT
18637	2470	29	test	test	NN
18637	2470	30	to	to	TO
18637	2470	31	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	2470	32	a	a	DT
18637	2470	33	State	State	NNP
18637	2470	34	of	of	IN
18637	2470	35	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	2470	36	tax	tax	NN
18637	2470	37	.	.	.
18637	2471	1	"	"	``
18637	2471	2	Such	such	PDT
18637	2471	3	a	a	DT
18637	2471	4	tax	tax	NN
18637	2471	5	,	,	,
18637	2471	6	"	"	''
18637	2471	7	said	say	VBD
18637	2471	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2471	9	,	,	,
18637	2471	10	"	"	``
18637	2471	11	at	at	IN
18637	2471	12	least	least	JJS
18637	2471	13	when	when	WRB
18637	2471	14	not	not	RB
18637	2471	15	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	2471	16	to	to	IN
18637	2471	17	the	the	DT
18637	2471	18	activities	activity	NNS
18637	2471	19	carried	carry	VBN
18637	2471	20	on	on	RP
18637	2471	21	within	within	IN
18637	2471	22	the	the	DT
18637	2471	23	State	State	NNP
18637	2471	24	,	,	,
18637	2471	25	*	*	NFP
18637	2471	26	*	*	NFP
18637	2471	27	*	*	NFP
18637	2471	28	would	would	MD
18637	2471	29	,	,	,
18637	2471	30	if	if	IN
18637	2471	31	sustained	sustained	JJ
18637	2471	32	,	,	,
18637	2471	33	expose	expose	VB
18637	2471	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2471	35	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2471	36	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2471	37	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2471	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2471	39	to	to	IN
18637	2471	40	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	2471	41	tax	tax	NN
18637	2471	42	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	2471	43	,	,	,
18637	2471	44	each	each	DT
18637	2471	45	measured	measure	VBN
18637	2471	46	by	by	IN
18637	2471	47	the	the	DT
18637	2471	48	entire	entire	JJ
18637	2471	49	amount	amount	NN
18637	2471	50	of	of	IN
18637	2471	51	the	the	DT
18637	2471	52	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2471	53	,	,	,
18637	2471	54	to	to	IN
18637	2471	55	which	which	WDT
18637	2471	56	local	local	JJ
18637	2471	57	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2471	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	2471	59	not	not	RB
18637	2471	60	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2471	61	.	.	.
18637	2471	62	"	"	''
18637	2472	1	The	the	DT
18637	2472	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	2472	3	thus	thus	RB
18637	2472	4	discriminated	discriminate	VBN
18637	2472	5	against	against	IN
18637	2472	6	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2472	7	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2472	8	;	;	:
18637	2472	9	and	and	CC
18637	2472	10	threatened	threaten	VBD
18637	2472	11	to	to	TO
18637	2472	12	"	"	``
18637	2472	13	reestablish	reestablish	VB
18637	2472	14	the	the	DT
18637	2472	15	barriers	barrier	NNS
18637	2472	16	to	to	IN
18637	2472	17	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2472	18	trade	trade	NN
18637	2472	19	which	which	WDT
18637	2472	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2472	21	was	be	VBD
18637	2472	22	the	the	DT
18637	2472	23	object	object	NN
18637	2472	24	of	of	IN
18637	2472	25	the	the	DT
18637	2472	26	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2472	27	clause	clause	NN
18637	2472	28	to	to	TO
18637	2472	29	remove	remove	VB
18637	2472	30	.	.	.
18637	2473	1	"	"	``
18637	2473	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2473	3	700	700	CD
18637	2473	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2473	5	The	the	DT
18637	2473	6	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	2473	7	by	by	IN
18637	2473	8	the	the	DT
18637	2473	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2473	10	of	of	IN
18637	2473	11	the	the	DT
18637	2473	12	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	2473	13	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2473	14	principle	principle	NN
18637	2473	15	as	as	IN
18637	2473	16	an	an	DT
18637	2473	17	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	2473	18	test	test	NN
18637	2473	19	of	of	IN
18637	2473	20	State	state	NN
18637	2473	21	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2473	22	power	power	NN
18637	2473	23	in	in	IN
18637	2473	24	relation	relation	NN
18637	2473	25	to	to	IN
18637	2473	26	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2473	27	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2473	28	would	would	MD
18637	2473	29	have	have	VB
18637	2473	30	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
18637	2473	31	the	the	DT
18637	2473	32	former	former	JJ
18637	2473	33	;	;	:
18637	2473	34	but	but	CC
18637	2473	35	this	this	DT
18637	2473	36	was	be	VBD
18637	2473	37	not	not	RB
18637	2473	38	the	the	DT
18637	2473	39	sole	sole	JJ
18637	2473	40	reason	reason	NN
18637	2473	41	for	for	IN
18637	2473	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2473	43	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	2473	44	vogue	vogue	NN
18637	2473	45	with	with	IN
18637	2473	46	the	the	DT
18637	2473	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2473	48	,	,	,
18637	2473	49	or	or	CC
18637	2473	50	at	at	IN
18637	2473	51	least	least	JJS
18637	2473	52	a	a	DT
18637	2473	53	section	section	NN
18637	2473	54	of	of	IN
18637	2473	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2473	56	.	.	.
18637	2474	1	Discontent	discontent	NN
18637	2474	2	with	with	IN
18637	2474	3	the	the	DT
18637	2474	4	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	2474	5	and	and	CC
18637	2474	6	uncertainties	uncertainty	NNS
18637	2474	7	of	of	IN
18637	2474	8	the	the	DT
18637	2474	9	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	2474	10	rule	rule	NN
18637	2474	11	also	also	RB
18637	2474	12	played	play	VBD
18637	2474	13	a	a	DT
18637	2474	14	great	great	JJ
18637	2474	15	part	part	NN
18637	2474	16	.	.	.
18637	2475	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2475	2	in	in	IN
18637	2475	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2475	4	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	2475	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2475	6	in	in	IN
18637	2475	7	the	the	DT
18637	2475	8	Gwin	Gwin	NNP
18637	2475	9	case	case	NN
18637	2475	10	,	,	,
18637	2475	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2475	12	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	2475	13	,	,	,
18637	2475	14	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2475	15	for	for	IN
18637	2475	16	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2475	17	and	and	CC
18637	2475	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2475	19	McReynolds	McReynolds	NNP
18637	2475	20	after	after	IN
18637	2475	21	showing	show	VBG
18637	2475	22	the	the	DT
18637	2475	23	instability	instability	NN
18637	2475	24	of	of	IN
18637	2475	25	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	2475	26	in	in	IN
18637	2475	27	this	this	DT
18637	2475	28	area	area	NN
18637	2475	29	of	of	IN
18637	2475	30	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	2475	31	Law	Law	NNP
18637	2475	32	,	,	,
18637	2475	33	contend	contend	VBP
18637	2475	34	that	that	IN
18637	2475	35	"	"	``
18637	2475	36	the	the	DT
18637	2475	37	problems	problem	NNS
18637	2475	38	of	of	IN
18637	2475	39	conjectured	conjecture	VBN
18637	2475	40	'	'	``
18637	2475	41	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	2475	42	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2475	43	'	'	''
18637	2475	44	or	or	CC
18637	2475	45	'	'	``
18637	2475	46	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	2475	47	'	'	''
18637	2475	48	"	"	''
18637	2475	49	should	should	MD
18637	2475	50	be	be	VB
18637	2475	51	left	leave	VBN
18637	2475	52	to	to	IN
18637	2475	53	Congress,[701	congress,[701	CD
18637	2475	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2475	55	a	a	DT
18637	2475	56	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	2475	57	which	which	WDT
18637	2475	58	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2475	59	Black	Black	NNP
18637	2475	60	,	,	,
18637	2475	61	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2475	62	also	also	RB
18637	2475	63	for	for	IN
18637	2475	64	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	2475	65	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	2475	66	and	and	CC
18637	2475	67	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	2475	68	a	a	DT
18637	2475	69	year	year	NN
18637	2475	70	later	later	RB
18637	2475	71	,	,	,
18637	2475	72	made	make	VBD
18637	2475	73	the	the	DT
18637	2475	74	basis	basis	NN
18637	2475	75	of	of	IN
18637	2475	76	a	a	DT
18637	2475	77	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	2475	78	opinion,[702	opinion,[702	NN
18637	2475	79	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2475	80	from	from	IN
18637	2475	81	the	the	DT
18637	2475	82	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	2475	83	of	of	IN
18637	2475	84	which	which	WDT
18637	2475	85	,	,	,
18637	2475	86	however	however	RB
18637	2475	87	,	,	,
18637	2475	88	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2475	89	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	2475	90	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	2475	91	since	since	RB
18637	2475	92	to	to	TO
18637	2475	93	have	have	VB
18637	2475	94	recanted	recant	VBN
18637	2475	95	.	.	.
18637	2476	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2476	2	703	703	CD
18637	2476	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2476	4	RECENT	recent	JJ
18637	2476	5	CASES	cases	NN
18637	2476	6	In	in	IN
18637	2476	7	Freedman	Freedman	NNP
18637	2476	8	_	_	NNP
18637	2476	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	2476	10	_	_	NNP
18637	2476	11	Hewit,[704	Hewit,[704	NNP
18637	2476	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2476	13	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2476	14	in	in	IN
18637	2476	15	1946	1946	CD
18637	2476	16	,	,	,
18637	2476	17	the	the	DT
18637	2476	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2476	19	held	hold	VBD
18637	2476	20	void	void	JJ
18637	2476	21	as	as	IN
18637	2476	22	an	an	DT
18637	2476	23	"	"	``
18637	2476	24	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2476	25	burden	burden	NN
18637	2476	26	on	on	IN
18637	2476	27	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2476	28	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2476	29	"	"	''
18637	2476	30	an	an	DT
18637	2476	31	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	2476	32	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2476	33	income	income	NN
18637	2476	34	tax	tax	NN
18637	2476	35	of	of	IN
18637	2476	36	the	the	DT
18637	2476	37	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	2476	38	from	from	IN
18637	2476	39	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2476	40	securities	security	NNS
18637	2476	41	sent	send	VBN
18637	2476	42	outside	outside	IN
18637	2476	43	the	the	DT
18637	2476	44	State	state	NN
18637	2476	45	to	to	TO
18637	2476	46	be	be	VB
18637	2476	47	sold	sell	VBN
18637	2476	48	.	.	.
18637	2477	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2477	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	2477	3	spoke	speak	VBD
18637	2477	4	for	for	IN
18637	2477	5	the	the	DT
18637	2477	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2477	7	;	;	:
18637	2477	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2477	9	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	2477	10	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	2477	11	in	in	IN
18637	2477	12	an	an	DT
18637	2477	13	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2477	14	deploring	deplore	VBG
18637	2477	15	the	the	DT
18637	2477	16	majority	majority	NN
18637	2477	17	's	's	POS
18637	2477	18	failure	failure	NN
18637	2477	19	to	to	TO
18637	2477	20	employ	employ	VB
18637	2477	21	the	the	DT
18637	2477	22	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	2477	23	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2477	24	test;[705	test;[705	NNS
18637	2477	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2477	26	three	three	CD
18637	2477	27	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	2477	28	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	2477	29	.	.	.
18637	2478	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2478	2	706	706	CD
18637	2478	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2478	4	In	in	IN
18637	2478	5	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
18637	2478	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2478	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	2478	8	_	_	NNP
18637	2478	9	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	2478	10	and	and	CC
18637	2478	11	Weekes	Weekes	NNP
18637	2478	12	Stevedoring	Stevedoring	NNP
18637	2478	13	Co	Co	NNP
18637	2478	14	.	.	.
18637	2478	15	,[707	,[707	ADD
18637	2478	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2478	17	also	also	RB
18637	2478	18	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2478	19	in	in	IN
18637	2478	20	1947	1947	CD
18637	2478	21	,	,	,
18637	2478	22	the	the	DT
18637	2478	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2478	24	,	,	,
18637	2478	25	reaffirming	reaffirm	VBG
18637	2478	26	an	an	DT
18637	2478	27	earlier	early	JJR
18637	2478	28	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	2478	29	,	,	,
18637	2478	30	held	hold	VBD
18637	2478	31	void	void	RB
18637	2478	32	the	the	DT
18637	2478	33	application	application	NN
18637	2478	34	of	of	IN
18637	2478	35	a	a	DT
18637	2478	36	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	2478	37	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2478	38	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2478	39	tax	tax	NN
18637	2478	40	to	to	IN
18637	2478	41	the	the	DT
18637	2478	42	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2478	43	of	of	IN
18637	2478	44	a	a	DT
18637	2478	45	stevedoring	stevedore	VBG
18637	2478	46	company	company	NN
18637	2478	47	from	from	IN
18637	2478	48	loading	loading	NN
18637	2478	49	and	and	CC
18637	2478	50	unloading	unloading	NN
18637	2478	51	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2478	52	employed	employ	VBN
18637	2478	53	in	in	IN
18637	2478	54	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2478	55	and	and	CC
18637	2478	56	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2478	57	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2478	58	,	,	,
18637	2478	59	or	or	CC
18637	2478	60	to	to	IN
18637	2478	61	the	the	DT
18637	2478	62	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2478	63	of	of	IN
18637	2478	64	engaging	engage	VBG
18637	2478	65	in	in	IN
18637	2478	66	such	such	JJ
18637	2478	67	business	business	NN
18637	2478	68	measured	measure	VBN
18637	2478	69	by	by	IN
18637	2478	70	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2478	71	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2478	72	.	.	.
18637	2479	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	2479	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2479	3	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	2479	4	for	for	IN
18637	2479	5	the	the	DT
18637	2479	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2479	7	:	:	:
18637	2479	8	"	"	``
18637	2479	9	Although	although	IN
18637	2479	10	State	State	NNP
18637	2479	11	laws	law	NNS
18637	2479	12	do	do	VBP
18637	2479	13	not	not	RB
18637	2479	14	discriminate	discriminate	VB
18637	2479	15	against	against	IN
18637	2479	16	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2479	17	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2479	18	or	or	CC
18637	2479	19	*	*	NFP
18637	2479	20	*	*	NFP
18637	2479	21	*	*	NFP
18637	2479	22	subject	subject	VBP
18637	2479	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2479	24	to	to	IN
18637	2479	25	the	the	DT
18637	2479	26	cumulative	cumulative	JJ
18637	2479	27	burden	burden	NN
18637	2479	28	of	of	IN
18637	2479	29	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	2479	30	levies	levy	NNS
18637	2479	31	,	,	,
18637	2479	32	those	those	DT
18637	2479	33	laws	law	NNS
18637	2479	34	may	may	MD
18637	2479	35	be	be	VB
18637	2479	36	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2479	37	because	because	IN
18637	2479	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2479	39	burden	burden	VBP
18637	2479	40	or	or	CC
18637	2479	41	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	2479	42	with	with	IN
18637	2479	43	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2479	44	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2479	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2479	46	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2479	47	.	.	.
18637	2480	1	"	"	``
18637	2480	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2480	3	708	708	CD
18637	2480	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2480	5	This	this	DT
18637	2480	6	time	time	NN
18637	2480	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2480	8	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	2480	9	was	be	VBD
18637	2480	10	among	among	IN
18637	2480	11	the	the	DT
18637	2480	12	dissenters	dissenter	NNS
18637	2480	13	so	so	RB
18637	2480	14	far	far	RB
18637	2480	15	as	as	IN
18637	2480	16	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2480	17	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2480	18	was	be	VBD
18637	2480	19	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	2480	20	.	.	.
18637	2481	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2481	2	709	709	CD
18637	2481	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2481	4	In	in	IN
18637	2481	5	Central	Central	NNP
18637	2481	6	Greyhound	Greyhound	NNP
18637	2481	7	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	2481	8	,	,	,
18637	2481	9	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	2481	10	_	_	NNP
18637	2481	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	2481	12	_	_	NNP
18637	2481	13	Mealey,[710	Mealey,[710	NNP
18637	2481	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2481	15	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2481	16	in	in	IN
18637	2481	17	1948	1948	CD
18637	2481	18	,	,	,
18637	2481	19	five	five	CD
18637	2481	20	members	member	NNS
18637	2481	21	of	of	IN
18637	2481	22	the	the	DT
18637	2481	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2481	24	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	2481	25	that	that	IN
18637	2481	26	a	a	DT
18637	2481	27	New	New	NNP
18637	2481	28	York	York	NNP
18637	2481	29	tax	tax	NN
18637	2481	30	on	on	IN
18637	2481	31	the	the	DT
18637	2481	32	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2481	33	income	income	NN
18637	2481	34	of	of	IN
18637	2481	35	public	public	JJ
18637	2481	36	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	2481	37	doing	do	VBG
18637	2481	38	business	business	NN
18637	2481	39	in	in	IN
18637	2481	40	the	the	DT
18637	2481	41	State	State	NNP
18637	2481	42	could	could	MD
18637	2481	43	not	not	RB
18637	2481	44	be	be	VB
18637	2481	45	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	2481	46	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2481	47	on	on	IN
18637	2481	48	a	a	DT
18637	2481	49	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2481	50	's	's	POS
18637	2481	51	unapportioned	unapportioned	JJ
18637	2481	52	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2481	53	from	from	IN
18637	2481	54	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	2481	55	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2481	56	between	between	IN
18637	2481	57	termini	termini	NN
18637	2481	58	in	in	IN
18637	2481	59	the	the	DT
18637	2481	60	State	State	NNP
18637	2481	61	over	over	IN
18637	2481	62	a	a	DT
18637	2481	63	route	route	NN
18637	2481	64	a	a	DT
18637	2481	65	material	material	JJ
18637	2481	66	part	part	NN
18637	2481	67	of	of	IN
18637	2481	68	which	which	WDT
18637	2481	69	passes	pass	VBZ
18637	2481	70	through	through	IN
18637	2481	71	other	other	JJ
18637	2481	72	States	state	NNS
18637	2481	73	.	.	.
18637	2482	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2482	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	2482	3	,	,	,
18637	2482	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2482	5	for	for	IN
18637	2482	6	the	the	DT
18637	2482	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2482	8	,	,	,
18637	2482	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	2482	10	,	,	,
18637	2482	11	however	however	RB
18637	2482	12	,	,	,
18637	2482	13	that	that	IN
18637	2482	14	the	the	DT
18637	2482	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	2482	16	was	be	VBD
18637	2482	17	sustainable	sustainable	JJ
18637	2482	18	as	as	IN
18637	2482	19	to	to	IN
18637	2482	20	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2482	21	apportioned	apportion	VBD
18637	2482	22	as	as	IN
18637	2482	23	to	to	IN
18637	2482	24	the	the	DT
18637	2482	25	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2482	26	within	within	IN
18637	2482	27	the	the	DT
18637	2482	28	State	State	NNP
18637	2482	29	.	.	.
18637	2483	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2483	2	711	711	CD
18637	2483	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2483	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2483	5	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	2483	6	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	2483	7	without	without	IN
18637	2483	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2483	9	.	.	.
18637	2484	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2484	2	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	2484	3	,	,	,
18637	2484	4	for	for	IN
18637	2484	5	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2484	6	and	and	CC
18637	2484	7	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	2484	8	Black	Black	NNP
18637	2484	9	and	and	CC
18637	2484	10	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	2484	11	,	,	,
18637	2484	12	thought	think	VBD
18637	2484	13	the	the	DT
18637	2484	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	2484	15	was	be	VBD
18637	2484	16	on	on	IN
18637	2484	17	an	an	DT
18637	2484	18	essentially	essentially	RB
18637	2484	19	local	local	JJ
18637	2484	20	activity	activity	NN
18637	2484	21	and	and	CC
18637	2484	22	that	that	IN
18637	2484	23	the	the	DT
18637	2484	24	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2484	25	through	through	IN
18637	2484	26	other	other	JJ
18637	2484	27	States	States	NNP
18637	2484	28	was	be	VBD
18637	2484	29	"	"	``
18637	2484	30	a	a	DT
18637	2484	31	mere	mere	JJ
18637	2484	32	geographic	geographic	JJ
18637	2484	33	incident	incident	NN
18637	2484	34	,	,	,
18637	2484	35	"	"	''
18637	2484	36	conceding	concede	VBG
18637	2484	37	at	at	IN
18637	2484	38	the	the	DT
18637	2484	39	same	same	JJ
18637	2484	40	time	time	NN
18637	2484	41	,	,	,
18637	2484	42	that	that	IN
18637	2484	43	this	this	DT
18637	2484	44	view	view	NN
18637	2484	45	invited	invite	VBD
18637	2484	46	the	the	DT
18637	2484	47	other	other	JJ
18637	2484	48	States	States	NNPS
18637	2484	49	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2484	50	to	to	TO
18637	2484	51	levy	levy	VB
18637	2484	52	similar	similar	JJ
18637	2484	53	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2484	54	and	and	CC
18637	2484	55	exposed	expose	VBD
18637	2484	56	the	the	DT
18637	2484	57	company	company	NN
18637	2484	58	to	to	IN
18637	2484	59	the	the	DT
18637	2484	60	danger	danger	NN
18637	2484	61	of	of	IN
18637	2484	62	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	2484	63	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2484	64	.	.	.
18637	2485	1	In	in	IN
18637	2485	2	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	2485	3	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	2485	4	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	2485	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2485	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2485	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	2485	8	_	_	NNP
18637	2485	9	Stone,[712	Stone,[712	NNP
18637	2485	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2485	11	also	also	RB
18637	2485	12	of	of	IN
18637	2485	13	the	the	DT
18637	2485	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	2485	15	grist	grist	NN
18637	2485	16	,	,	,
18637	2485	17	a	a	DT
18637	2485	18	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	2485	19	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	2485	20	tax	tax	NN
18637	2485	21	,	,	,
18637	2485	22	measured	measure	VBN
18637	2485	23	by	by	IN
18637	2485	24	the	the	DT
18637	2485	25	value	value	NN
18637	2485	26	of	of	IN
18637	2485	27	capital	capital	NN
18637	2485	28	invested	invest	VBN
18637	2485	29	or	or	CC
18637	2485	30	employed	employ	VBN
18637	2485	31	in	in	IN
18637	2485	32	the	the	DT
18637	2485	33	State	State	NNP
18637	2485	34	,	,	,
18637	2485	35	was	be	VBD
18637	2485	36	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2485	37	in	in	IN
18637	2485	38	the	the	DT
18637	2485	39	case	case	NN
18637	2485	40	of	of	IN
18637	2485	41	a	a	DT
18637	2485	42	gas	gas	NN
18637	2485	43	pipeline	pipeline	NN
18637	2485	44	company	company	NN
18637	2485	45	a	a	DT
18637	2485	46	portion	portion	NN
18637	2485	47	of	of	IN
18637	2485	48	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2485	49	line	line	NN
18637	2485	50	passed	pass	VBD
18637	2485	51	through	through	IN
18637	2485	52	the	the	DT
18637	2485	53	State	State	NNP
18637	2485	54	but	but	CC
18637	2485	55	which	which	WDT
18637	2485	56	did	do	VBD
18637	2485	57	no	no	DT
18637	2485	58	local	local	JJ
18637	2485	59	business	business	NN
18637	2485	60	there	there	RB
18637	2485	61	.	.	.
18637	2486	1	Three	three	CD
18637	2486	2	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	2486	3	,	,	,
18637	2486	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2486	5	by	by	IN
18637	2486	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2486	7	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	2486	8	,	,	,
18637	2486	9	held	hold	VBD
18637	2486	10	that	that	IN
18637	2486	11	the	the	DT
18637	2486	12	tax	tax	NN
18637	2486	13	was	be	VBD
18637	2486	14	on	on	IN
18637	2486	15	the	the	DT
18637	2486	16	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2486	17	activities	activity	NNS
18637	2486	18	of	of	IN
18637	2486	19	the	the	DT
18637	2486	20	company	company	NN
18637	2486	21	in	in	IN
18637	2486	22	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	2486	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2486	24	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	2486	25	there	there	RB
18637	2486	26	,	,	,
18637	2486	27	and	and	CC
18637	2486	28	was	be	VBD
18637	2486	29	no	no	DT
18637	2486	30	more	more	RBR
18637	2486	31	burdensome	burdensome	JJ
18637	2486	32	than	than	IN
18637	2486	33	the	the	DT
18637	2486	34	concededly	concededly	RB
18637	2486	35	valid	valid	JJ
18637	2486	36	_	_	NNP
18637	2486	37	ad	ad	NN
18637	2486	38	valorem	valorem	NN
18637	2486	39	_	_	NNP
18637	2486	40	tax	tax	NN
18637	2486	41	on	on	IN
18637	2486	42	the	the	DT
18637	2486	43	company	company	NN
18637	2486	44	's	's	POS
18637	2486	45	property	property	NN
18637	2486	46	in	in	IN
18637	2486	47	the	the	DT
18637	2486	48	State	State	NNP
18637	2486	49	.	.	.
18637	2487	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2487	2	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	2487	3	held	hold	VBD
18637	2487	4	that	that	IN
18637	2487	5	the	the	DT
18637	2487	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	2487	7	was	be	VBD
18637	2487	8	valid	valid	JJ
18637	2487	9	because	because	IN
18637	2487	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2487	11	did	do	VBD
18637	2487	12	not	not	RB
18637	2487	13	discriminate	discriminate	VB
18637	2487	14	against	against	IN
18637	2487	15	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2487	16	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2487	17	nor	nor	CC
18637	2487	18	invite	invite	VB
18637	2487	19	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	2487	20	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2487	21	,	,	,
18637	2487	22	while	while	IN
18637	2487	23	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2487	24	Black	Black	NNP
18637	2487	25	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	2487	26	without	without	IN
18637	2487	27	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2487	28	.	.	.
18637	2488	1	Four	four	CD
18637	2488	2	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	2488	3	,	,	,
18637	2488	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2488	5	by	by	IN
18637	2488	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2488	7	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	2488	8	,	,	,
18637	2488	9	contended	contend	VBD
18637	2488	10	that	that	IN
18637	2488	11	the	the	DT
18637	2488	12	pipeline	pipeline	NN
18637	2488	13	already	already	RB
18637	2488	14	paid	pay	VBD
18637	2488	15	the	the	DT
18637	2488	16	_	_	NNP
18637	2488	17	ad	ad	NN
18637	2488	18	valorem	valorem	NN
18637	2488	19	_	_	NNP
18637	2488	20	tax	tax	NN
18637	2488	21	to	to	IN
18637	2488	22	which	which	WDT
18637	2488	23	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2488	24	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	2488	25	had	have	VBD
18637	2488	26	adverted	advert	VBN
18637	2488	27	,	,	,
18637	2488	28	and	and	CC
18637	2488	29	that	that	IN
18637	2488	30	the	the	DT
18637	2488	31	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	2488	32	tax	tax	NN
18637	2488	33	must	must	MD
18637	2488	34	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	2488	35	be	be	VB
18637	2488	36	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	2488	37	as	as	IN
18637	2488	38	being	be	VBG
18637	2488	39	on	on	IN
18637	2488	40	the	the	DT
18637	2488	41	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2488	42	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2488	43	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2488	44	.	.	.
18637	2489	1	This	this	DT
18637	2489	2	survey	survey	NN
18637	2489	3	of	of	IN
18637	2489	4	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2489	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	2489	6	leaves	leave	VBZ
18637	2489	7	the	the	DT
18637	2489	8	impression	impression	NN
18637	2489	9	that	that	IN
18637	2489	10	the	the	DT
18637	2489	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2489	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	2489	13	at	at	IN
18637	2489	14	loose	loose	JJ
18637	2489	15	ends	end	NNS
18637	2489	16	for	for	IN
18637	2489	17	intermediate	intermediate	JJ
18637	2489	18	guiding	guide	VBG
18637	2489	19	principles	principle	NNS
18637	2489	20	in	in	IN
18637	2489	21	this	this	DT
18637	2489	22	field	field	NN
18637	2489	23	of	of	IN
18637	2489	24	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	2489	25	Law	Law	NNP
18637	2489	26	.	.	.
18637	2490	1	The	the	DT
18637	2490	2	"	"	``
18637	2490	3	leave	leave	VB
18637	2490	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2490	5	to	to	IN
18637	2490	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2490	7	"	"	''
18637	2490	8	formula	formula	NN
18637	2490	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	2490	10	evidently	evidently	RB
18637	2490	11	in	in	IN
18637	2490	12	the	the	DT
18637	2490	13	discard	discard	NN
18637	2490	14	,	,	,
18637	2490	15	although	although	IN
18637	2490	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2490	17	Black	Black	NNP
18637	2490	18	's	's	POS
18637	2490	19	successive	successive	JJ
18637	2490	20	dissents	dissent	NNS
18637	2490	21	without	without	IN
18637	2490	22	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2490	23	may	may	MD
18637	2490	24	indicate	indicate	VB
18637	2490	25	that	that	IN
18637	2490	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2490	27	still	still	RB
18637	2490	28	thinks	think	VBZ
18637	2490	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2490	30	sound	sound	JJ
18637	2490	31	.	.	.
18637	2491	1	The	the	DT
18637	2491	2	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	2491	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	2491	4	test	test	NN
18637	2491	5	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	2491	6	to	to	TO
18637	2491	7	be	be	VB
18637	2491	8	in	in	IN
18637	2491	9	an	an	DT
18637	2491	10	equally	equally	RB
18637	2491	11	bad	bad	JJ
18637	2491	12	way	way	NN
18637	2491	13	,	,	,
18637	2491	14	with	with	IN
18637	2491	15	both	both	CC
18637	2491	16	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2491	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2491	18	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	2491	19	and	and	CC
18637	2491	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2491	21	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	2491	22	in	in	IN
18637	2491	23	the	the	DT
18637	2491	24	grave	grave	NN
18637	2491	25	.	.	.
18637	2492	1	The	the	DT
18637	2492	2	concept	concept	NN
18637	2492	3	of	of	IN
18637	2492	4	an	an	DT
18637	2492	5	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	2492	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	2492	7	still	still	RB
18637	2492	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	2492	9	some	some	DT
18637	2492	10	vitality	vitality	NN
18637	2492	11	however	however	RB
18637	2492	12	,	,	,
18637	2492	13	although	although	IN
18637	2492	14	just	just	RB
18637	2492	15	how	how	WRB
18637	2492	16	much	much	JJ
18637	2492	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	2492	18	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	2492	19	to	to	TO
18637	2492	20	assess	assess	VB
18637	2492	21	.	.	.
18637	2493	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2493	2	in	in	IN
18637	2493	3	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2493	4	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	2493	5	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	2493	6	Line	Line	NNP
18637	2493	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2493	8	_	_	NNP
18637	2493	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	2493	10	_	_	NNP
18637	2493	11	Stone,[713	Stone,[713	NNP
18637	2493	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2493	13	which	which	WDT
18637	2493	14	was	be	VBD
18637	2493	15	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2493	16	in	in	IN
18637	2493	17	1949	1949	CD
18637	2493	18	,	,	,
18637	2493	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2493	20	find	find	VBP
18637	2493	21	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2493	22	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	2493	23	,	,	,
18637	2493	24	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2493	25	for	for	IN
18637	2493	26	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2493	27	and	and	CC
18637	2493	28	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	2493	29	Black	Black	NNP
18637	2493	30	,	,	,
18637	2493	31	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	2493	32	,	,	,
18637	2493	33	and	and	CC
18637	2493	34	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	2493	35	,	,	,
18637	2493	36	endorsing	endorse	VBG
18637	2493	37	the	the	DT
18637	2493	38	view	view	NN
18637	2493	39	that	that	IN
18637	2493	40	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	2493	41	was	be	VBD
18637	2493	42	within	within	IN
18637	2493	43	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2493	44	rights	right	NNS
18637	2493	45	in	in	IN
18637	2493	46	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	2493	47	on	on	IN
18637	2493	48	a	a	DT
18637	2493	49	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	2493	50	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2493	51	,	,	,
18637	2493	52	as	as	IN
18637	2493	53	a	a	DT
18637	2493	54	condition	condition	NN
18637	2493	55	of	of	IN
18637	2493	56	doing	do	VBG
18637	2493	57	a	a	DT
18637	2493	58	local	local	JJ
18637	2493	59	business	business	NN
18637	2493	60	,	,	,
18637	2493	61	a	a	DT
18637	2493	62	"	"	``
18637	2493	63	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2493	64	"	"	''
18637	2493	65	tax	tax	NN
18637	2493	66	equal	equal	JJ
18637	2493	67	to	to	IN
18637	2493	68	two	two	CD
18637	2493	69	per	per	IN
18637	2493	70	cent	cent	NN
18637	2493	71	of	of	IN
18637	2493	72	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2493	73	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2493	74	business	business	NN
18637	2493	75	even	even	RB
18637	2493	76	though	though	IN
18637	2493	77	the	the	DT
18637	2493	78	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	2493	79	amounted	amount	VBD
18637	2493	80	to	to	IN
18637	2493	81	"	"	``
18637	2493	82	a	a	DT
18637	2493	83	'	'	``
18637	2493	84	direct	direct	JJ
18637	2493	85	'	'	''
18637	2493	86	tax	tax	NN
18637	2493	87	on	on	IN
18637	2493	88	the	the	DT
18637	2493	89	'	'	``
18637	2493	90	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2493	91	'	'	''
18637	2493	92	of	of	IN
18637	2493	93	engaging	engage	VBG
18637	2493	94	in	in	IN
18637	2493	95	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2493	96	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2493	97	,	,	,
18637	2493	98	"	"	''
18637	2493	99	an	an	DT
18637	2493	100	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	2493	101	which	which	WDT
18637	2493	102	was	be	VBD
18637	2493	103	countered	counter	VBN
18637	2493	104	by	by	IN
18637	2493	105	one	one	CD
18637	2493	106	just	just	RB
18637	2493	107	as	as	IN
18637	2493	108	positive	positive	JJ
18637	2493	109	,	,	,
18637	2493	110	and	and	CC
18637	2493	111	also	also	RB
18637	2493	112	endorsed	endorse	VBN
18637	2493	113	by	by	IN
18637	2493	114	four	four	CD
18637	2493	115	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	2493	116	,	,	,
18637	2493	117	that	that	IN
18637	2493	118	no	no	DT
18637	2493	119	State	state	NN
18637	2493	120	may	may	MD
18637	2493	121	"	"	``
18637	2493	122	levy	levy	VB
18637	2493	123	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2493	124	,	,	,
18637	2493	125	excise	excise	VB
18637	2493	126	or	or	CC
18637	2493	127	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	2493	128	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2493	129	on	on	IN
18637	2493	130	a	a	DT
18637	2493	131	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2493	132	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2493	133	for	for	IN
18637	2493	134	the	the	DT
18637	2493	135	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2493	136	of	of	IN
18637	2493	137	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	2493	138	on	on	RP
18637	2493	139	or	or	CC
18637	2493	140	the	the	DT
18637	2493	141	actual	actual	JJ
18637	2493	142	doing	doing	NN
18637	2493	143	of	of	IN
18637	2493	144	solely	solely	RB
18637	2493	145	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2493	146	business	business	NN
18637	2493	147	,	,	,
18637	2493	148	"	"	''
18637	2493	149	even	even	RB
18637	2493	150	though	though	IN
18637	2493	151	the	the	DT
18637	2493	152	tax	tax	NN
18637	2493	153	is	be	VBZ
18637	2493	154	not	not	RB
18637	2493	155	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	2493	156	and	and	CC
18637	2493	157	is	be	VBZ
18637	2493	158	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	2493	159	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	2493	160	between	between	IN
18637	2493	161	the	the	DT
18637	2493	162	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2493	163	's	's	POS
18637	2493	164	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2493	165	and	and	CC
18637	2493	166	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2493	167	business	business	NN
18637	2493	168	.	.	.
18637	2494	1	The	the	DT
18637	2494	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	2494	3	in	in	IN
18637	2494	4	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	2494	5	was	be	VBD
18637	2494	6	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2494	7	by	by	IN
18637	2494	8	the	the	DT
18637	2494	9	vote	vote	NN
18637	2494	10	of	of	IN
18637	2494	11	the	the	DT
18637	2494	12	ninth	ninth	JJ
18637	2494	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2494	14	,	,	,
18637	2494	15	who	who	WP
18637	2494	16	construed	construe	VBD
18637	2494	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2494	18	as	as	IN
18637	2494	19	being	be	VBG
18637	2494	20	levied	levy	VBN
18637	2494	21	only	only	RB
18637	2494	22	on	on	IN
18637	2494	23	the	the	DT
18637	2494	24	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2494	25	of	of	IN
18637	2494	26	engaging	engage	VBG
18637	2494	27	in	in	IN
18637	2494	28	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2494	29	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2494	30	,	,	,
18637	2494	31	a	a	DT
18637	2494	32	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	2494	33	which	which	WDT
18637	2494	34	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	2494	35	ignores	ignore	VBZ
18637	2494	36	the	the	DT
18637	2494	37	question	question	NN
18637	2494	38	of	of	IN
18637	2494	39	the	the	DT
18637	2494	40	tax	tax	NN
18637	2494	41	's	's	POS
18637	2494	42	actual	actual	JJ
18637	2494	43	impact	impact	NN
18637	2494	44	on	on	IN
18637	2494	45	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2494	46	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2494	47	,	,	,
18637	2494	48	the	the	DT
18637	2494	49	precise	precise	JJ
18637	2494	50	question	question	NN
18637	2494	51	on	on	IN
18637	2494	52	which	which	WDT
18637	2494	53	many	many	JJ
18637	2494	54	previous	previous	JJ
18637	2494	55	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	2494	56	have	have	VBP
18637	2494	57	turned	turn	VBN
18637	2494	58	.	.	.
18637	2495	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2495	2	714	714	CD
18637	2495	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2495	4	TAXES	taxes	VB
18637	2495	5	ON	on	IN
18637	2495	6	NET	NET	NNP
18637	2495	7	INCOME	INCOME	NNP
18637	2495	8	The	the	DT
18637	2495	9	leading	leading	JJ
18637	2495	10	case	case	NN
18637	2495	11	under	under	IN
18637	2495	12	this	this	DT
18637	2495	13	caption	caption	NN
18637	2495	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	2495	15	United	United	NNP
18637	2495	16	States	States	NNP
18637	2495	17	Glue	Glue	NNP
18637	2495	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2495	19	_	_	NNP
18637	2495	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	2495	21	_	_	NNP
18637	2495	22	Oak	Oak	NNP
18637	2495	23	Creek[715	Creek[715	NNP
18637	2495	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2495	25	where	where	WRB
18637	2495	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2495	27	was	be	VBD
18637	2495	28	held	hold	VBN
18637	2495	29	that	that	IN
18637	2495	30	the	the	DT
18637	2495	31	State	State	NNP
18637	2495	32	of	of	IN
18637	2495	33	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	2495	34	,	,	,
18637	2495	35	in	in	IN
18637	2495	36	laying	lay	VBG
18637	2495	37	a	a	DT
18637	2495	38	general	general	JJ
18637	2495	39	income	income	NN
18637	2495	40	tax	tax	NN
18637	2495	41	upon	upon	IN
18637	2495	42	the	the	DT
18637	2495	43	gains	gain	NNS
18637	2495	44	and	and	CC
18637	2495	45	profits	profit	NNS
18637	2495	46	of	of	IN
18637	2495	47	a	a	DT
18637	2495	48	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	2495	49	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2495	50	,	,	,
18637	2495	51	was	be	VBD
18637	2495	52	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	2495	53	to	to	TO
18637	2495	54	include	include	VB
18637	2495	55	in	in	IN
18637	2495	56	the	the	DT
18637	2495	57	computation	computation	NN
18637	2495	58	the	the	DT
18637	2495	59	net	net	JJ
18637	2495	60	income	income	NN
18637	2495	61	derived	derive	VBN
18637	2495	62	from	from	IN
18637	2495	63	transportations	transportation	NNS
18637	2495	64	in	in	IN
18637	2495	65	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2495	66	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2495	67	.	.	.
18637	2496	1	Pointing	point	VBG
18637	2496	2	out	out	RP
18637	2496	3	the	the	DT
18637	2496	4	difference	difference	NN
18637	2496	5	between	between	IN
18637	2496	6	such	such	PDT
18637	2496	7	a	a	DT
18637	2496	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	2496	9	and	and	CC
18637	2496	10	one	one	CD
18637	2496	11	on	on	IN
18637	2496	12	gross	gross	JJ
18637	2496	13	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	2496	14	,	,	,
18637	2496	15	the	the	DT
18637	2496	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2496	17	said	say	VBD
18637	2496	18	the	the	DT
18637	2496	19	latter	latter	JJ
18637	2496	20	"	"	``
18637	2496	21	affects	affect	VBZ
18637	2496	22	each	each	DT
18637	2496	23	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	2496	24	in	in	IN
18637	2496	25	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	2496	26	to	to	IN
18637	2496	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2496	28	magnitude	magnitude	NN
18637	2496	29	and	and	CC
18637	2496	30	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	2496	31	of	of	IN
18637	2496	32	whether	whether	IN
18637	2496	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2496	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	2496	35	profitable	profitable	JJ
18637	2496	36	or	or	CC
18637	2496	37	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2496	38	.	.	.
18637	2497	1	Conceivably	conceivably	RB
18637	2497	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2497	3	may	may	MD
18637	2497	4	be	be	VB
18637	2497	5	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	2497	6	to	to	TO
18637	2497	7	make	make	VB
18637	2497	8	the	the	DT
18637	2497	9	difference	difference	NN
18637	2497	10	between	between	IN
18637	2497	11	profit	profit	NN
18637	2497	12	and	and	CC
18637	2497	13	loss	loss	NN
18637	2497	14	,	,	,
18637	2497	15	or	or	CC
18637	2497	16	to	to	TO
18637	2497	17	so	so	RB
18637	2497	18	diminish	diminish	VB
18637	2497	19	the	the	DT
18637	2497	20	profit	profit	NN
18637	2497	21	as	as	IN
18637	2497	22	to	to	TO
18637	2497	23	impede	impede	VB
18637	2497	24	or	or	CC
18637	2497	25	discourage	discourage	VB
18637	2497	26	the	the	DT
18637	2497	27	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	2497	28	of	of	IN
18637	2497	29	the	the	DT
18637	2497	30	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2497	31	.	.	.
18637	2498	1	A	a	DT
18637	2498	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	2498	3	upon	upon	IN
18637	2498	4	the	the	DT
18637	2498	5	net	net	JJ
18637	2498	6	profits	profit	NNS
18637	2498	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	2498	8	not	not	RB
18637	2498	9	the	the	DT
18637	2498	10	same	same	JJ
18637	2498	11	deterrent	deterrent	NN
18637	2498	12	effect	effect	NN
18637	2498	13	,	,	,
18637	2498	14	since	since	IN
18637	2498	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2498	16	does	do	VBZ
18637	2498	17	not	not	RB
18637	2498	18	arise	arise	VB
18637	2498	19	at	at	RB
18637	2498	20	all	all	RB
18637	2498	21	unless	unless	IN
18637	2498	22	a	a	DT
18637	2498	23	gain	gain	NN
18637	2498	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	2498	25	shown	show	VBN
18637	2498	26	over	over	IN
18637	2498	27	and	and	CC
18637	2498	28	above	above	IN
18637	2498	29	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	2498	30	and	and	CC
18637	2498	31	losses	loss	NNS
18637	2498	32	,	,	,
18637	2498	33	and	and	CC
18637	2498	34	the	the	DT
18637	2498	35	tax	tax	NN
18637	2498	36	can	can	MD
18637	2498	37	not	not	RB
18637	2498	38	be	be	VB
18637	2498	39	heavy	heavy	JJ
18637	2498	40	unless	unless	IN
18637	2498	41	the	the	DT
18637	2498	42	profits	profit	NNS
18637	2498	43	are	be	VBP
18637	2498	44	large	large	JJ
18637	2498	45	.	.	.
18637	2498	46	"	"	''
18637	2499	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	2499	2	a	a	DT
18637	2499	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	2499	4	"	"	``
18637	2499	5	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	2499	6	one	one	CD
18637	2499	7	of	of	IN
18637	2499	8	the	the	DT
18637	2499	9	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	2499	10	and	and	CC
18637	2499	11	general	general	JJ
18637	2499	12	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	2499	13	of	of	IN
18637	2499	14	government	government	NN
18637	2499	15	,	,	,
18637	2499	16	from	from	IN
18637	2499	17	which	which	WDT
18637	2499	18	persons	person	NNS
18637	2499	19	and	and	CC
18637	2499	20	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2499	21	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2499	22	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2499	23	to	to	IN
18637	2499	24	the	the	DT
18637	2499	25	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2499	26	of	of	IN
18637	2499	27	the	the	DT
18637	2499	28	States	States	NNPS
18637	2499	29	are	be	VBP
18637	2499	30	not	not	RB
18637	2499	31	exempted	exempt	VBN
18637	2499	32	*	*	NFP
18637	2499	33	*	*	NFP
18637	2499	34	*	*	NFP
18637	2499	35	because	because	IN
18637	2499	36	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2499	37	happen	happen	VBP
18637	2499	38	to	to	TO
18637	2499	39	be	be	VB
18637	2499	40	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2499	41	in	in	IN
18637	2499	42	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2499	43	among	among	IN
18637	2499	44	the	the	DT
18637	2499	45	States	States	NNP
18637	2499	46	.	.	.
18637	2500	1	"	"	``
18637	2500	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2500	3	716	716	CD
18637	2500	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2500	5	Adhering	adhere	VBG
18637	2500	6	to	to	IN
18637	2500	7	this	this	DT
18637	2500	8	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	2500	9	,	,	,
18637	2500	10	the	the	DT
18637	2500	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2500	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	2500	13	held	hold	VBN
18637	2500	14	that	that	IN
18637	2500	15	a	a	DT
18637	2500	16	tax	tax	NN
18637	2500	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	2500	18	the	the	DT
18637	2500	19	net	net	JJ
18637	2500	20	income	income	NN
18637	2500	21	of	of	IN
18637	2500	22	a	a	DT
18637	2500	23	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	2500	24	from	from	IN
18637	2500	25	business	business	NN
18637	2500	26	carried	carry	VBN
18637	2500	27	on	on	RP
18637	2500	28	by	by	IN
18637	2500	29	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2500	30	in	in	IN
18637	2500	31	the	the	DT
18637	2500	32	State	State	NNP
18637	2500	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	2500	34	not	not	RB
18637	2500	35	a	a	DT
18637	2500	36	burden	burden	NN
18637	2500	37	on	on	IN
18637	2500	38	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2500	39	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2500	40	merely	merely	RB
18637	2500	41	because	because	IN
18637	2500	42	the	the	DT
18637	2500	43	products	product	NNS
18637	2500	44	of	of	IN
18637	2500	45	the	the	DT
18637	2500	46	business	business	NN
18637	2500	47	are	be	VBP
18637	2500	48	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	2500	49	out	out	IN
18637	2500	50	of	of	IN
18637	2500	51	the	the	DT
18637	2500	52	State;[717	state;[717	NN
18637	2500	53	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2500	54	also	also	RB
18637	2500	55	that	that	IN
18637	2500	56	a	a	DT
18637	2500	57	tax	tax	NN
18637	2500	58	which	which	WDT
18637	2500	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	2500	60	levied	levy	VBN
18637	2500	61	upon	upon	IN
18637	2500	62	the	the	DT
18637	2500	63	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	2500	64	of	of	IN
18637	2500	65	the	the	DT
18637	2500	66	net	net	JJ
18637	2500	67	profits	profit	NNS
18637	2500	68	of	of	IN
18637	2500	69	a	a	DT
18637	2500	70	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2500	71	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2500	72	earned	earn	VBN
18637	2500	73	by	by	IN
18637	2500	74	operations	operation	NNS
18637	2500	75	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	2500	76	within	within	IN
18637	2500	77	the	the	DT
18637	2500	78	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2500	79	State	state	NN
18637	2500	80	is	be	VBZ
18637	2500	81	valid	valid	JJ
18637	2500	82	,	,	,
18637	2500	83	if	if	IN
18637	2500	84	the	the	DT
18637	2500	85	method	method	NN
18637	2500	86	of	of	IN
18637	2500	87	allocation	allocation	NN
18637	2500	88	employed	employ	VBN
18637	2500	89	be	be	VB
18637	2500	90	not	not	RB
18637	2500	91	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	2500	92	or	or	CC
18637	2500	93	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	2500	94	.	.	.
18637	2501	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2501	2	718	718	CD
18637	2501	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2501	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	2501	5	,	,	,
18637	2501	6	however	however	RB
18637	2501	7	,	,	,
18637	2501	8	the	the	DT
18637	2501	9	method	method	NN
18637	2501	10	of	of	IN
18637	2501	11	allocating	allocate	VBG
18637	2501	12	the	the	DT
18637	2501	13	net	net	JJ
18637	2501	14	income	income	NN
18637	2501	15	of	of	IN
18637	2501	16	a	a	DT
18637	2501	17	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2501	18	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2501	19	attributed	attribute	VBN
18637	2501	20	to	to	IN
18637	2501	21	the	the	DT
18637	2501	22	State	State	NNP
18637	2501	23	an	an	DT
18637	2501	24	amount	amount	NN
18637	2501	25	of	of	IN
18637	2501	26	income	income	NN
18637	2501	27	out	out	IN
18637	2501	28	of	of	IN
18637	2501	29	all	all	DT
18637	2501	30	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	2501	31	to	to	IN
18637	2501	32	the	the	DT
18637	2501	33	business	business	NN
18637	2501	34	there	there	RB
18637	2501	35	transacted	transact	VBN
18637	2501	36	by	by	IN
18637	2501	37	the	the	DT
18637	2501	38	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2501	39	,	,	,
18637	2501	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2501	41	was	be	VBD
18637	2501	42	held	hold	VBN
18637	2501	43	void	void	JJ
18637	2501	44	.	.	.
18637	2502	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2502	2	719	719	CD
18637	2502	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2502	4	Also	also	RB
18637	2502	5	,	,	,
18637	2502	6	a	a	DT
18637	2502	7	State	state	NN
18637	2502	8	may	may	MD
18637	2502	9	impose	impose	VB
18637	2502	10	a	a	DT
18637	2502	11	tax	tax	NN
18637	2502	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	2502	13	the	the	DT
18637	2502	14	net	net	JJ
18637	2502	15	income	income	NN
18637	2502	16	of	of	IN
18637	2502	17	property	property	NN
18637	2502	18	,	,	,
18637	2502	19	as	as	IN
18637	2502	20	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	2502	21	from	from	IN
18637	2502	22	the	the	DT
18637	2502	23	net	net	JJ
18637	2502	24	income	income	NN
18637	2502	25	of	of	IN
18637	2502	26	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2502	27	who	who	WP
18637	2502	28	owns	own	VBZ
18637	2502	29	or	or	CC
18637	2502	30	operates	operate	VBZ
18637	2502	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2502	32	,	,	,
18637	2502	33	although	although	IN
18637	2502	34	the	the	DT
18637	2502	35	property	property	NN
18637	2502	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	2502	37	used	use	VBN
18637	2502	38	in	in	IN
18637	2502	39	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2502	40	commerce;[720	commerce;[720	NNPS
18637	2502	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2502	42	also	also	RB
18637	2502	43	a	a	DT
18637	2502	44	"	"	``
18637	2502	45	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	2502	46	tax	tax	NN
18637	2502	47	"	"	''
18637	2502	48	measured	measure	VBN
18637	2502	49	by	by	IN
18637	2502	50	the	the	DT
18637	2502	51	net	net	JJ
18637	2502	52	income	income	NN
18637	2502	53	justly	justly	RB
18637	2502	54	attributable	attributable	JJ
18637	2502	55	to	to	TO
18637	2502	56	business	business	NN
18637	2502	57	done	do	VBN
18637	2502	58	by	by	IN
18637	2502	59	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2502	60	within	within	IN
18637	2502	61	the	the	DT
18637	2502	62	State	State	NNP
18637	2502	63	,	,	,
18637	2502	64	although	although	IN
18637	2502	65	part	part	NN
18637	2502	66	of	of	IN
18637	2502	67	the	the	DT
18637	2502	68	income	income	NN
18637	2502	69	so	so	RB
18637	2502	70	attributable	attributable	JJ
18637	2502	71	comes	come	VBZ
18637	2502	72	from	from	IN
18637	2502	73	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2502	74	and	and	CC
18637	2502	75	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2502	76	commerce;[721	commerce;[721	NNS
18637	2502	77	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2502	78	also	also	RB
18637	2502	79	a	a	DT
18637	2502	80	tax	tax	NN
18637	2502	81	on	on	IN
18637	2502	82	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	2502	83	net	net	JJ
18637	2502	84	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	2502	85	derived	derive	VBN
18637	2502	86	from	from	IN
18637	2502	87	business	business	NN
18637	2502	88	done	do	VBN
18637	2502	89	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	2502	90	within	within	IN
18637	2502	91	the	the	DT
18637	2502	92	State	State	NNP
18637	2502	93	may	may	MD
18637	2502	94	be	be	VB
18637	2502	95	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2502	96	to	to	IN
18637	2502	97	the	the	DT
18637	2502	98	income	income	NN
18637	2502	99	of	of	IN
18637	2502	100	a	a	DT
18637	2502	101	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2502	102	pipeline	pipeline	NN
18637	2502	103	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2502	104	which	which	WDT
18637	2502	105	is	be	VBZ
18637	2502	106	commercially	commercially	RB
18637	2502	107	domiciled	domiciled	JJ
18637	2502	108	there	there	RB
18637	2502	109	and	and	CC
18637	2502	110	which	which	WDT
18637	2502	111	pipes	pipe	VBZ
18637	2502	112	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2502	113	gas	gas	NN
18637	2502	114	into	into	IN
18637	2502	115	that	that	DT
18637	2502	116	State	state	NN
18637	2502	117	for	for	IN
18637	2502	118	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	2502	119	to	to	IN
18637	2502	120	,	,	,
18637	2502	121	and	and	CC
18637	2502	122	sale	sale	NN
18637	2502	123	by	by	IN
18637	2502	124	,	,	,
18637	2502	125	a	a	DT
18637	2502	126	local	local	JJ
18637	2502	127	distributing	distribute	VBG
18637	2502	128	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2502	129	to	to	IN
18637	2502	130	local	local	JJ
18637	2502	131	consumers	consumer	NNS
18637	2502	132	.	.	.
18637	2503	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2503	2	722	722	CD
18637	2503	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2503	4	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	2503	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2503	6	was	be	VBD
18637	2503	7	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	2503	8	that	that	IN
18637	2503	9	even	even	RB
18637	2503	10	if	if	IN
18637	2503	11	the	the	DT
18637	2503	12	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	2503	13	's	's	POS
18637	2503	14	business	business	NN
18637	2503	15	were	be	VBD
18637	2503	16	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	2503	17	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2503	18	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2503	19	,	,	,
18637	2503	20	such	such	PDT
18637	2503	21	a	a	DT
18637	2503	22	nondiscriminatory	nondiscriminatory	JJ
18637	2503	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	2503	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	2503	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2503	26	net	net	JJ
18637	2503	27	income	income	NN
18637	2503	28	"	"	''
18637	2503	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	2503	30	not	not	RB
18637	2503	31	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	2503	32	by	by	IN
18637	2503	33	the	the	DT
18637	2503	34	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2503	35	clause	clause	NNP
18637	2503	36	,	,	,
18637	2503	37	"	"	``
18637	2503	38	there	there	EX
18637	2503	39	being	be	VBG
18637	2503	40	no	no	DT
18637	2503	41	showing	showing	NN
18637	2503	42	that	that	IN
18637	2503	43	the	the	DT
18637	2503	44	income	income	NN
18637	2503	45	was	be	VBD
18637	2503	46	not	not	RB
18637	2503	47	on	on	IN
18637	2503	48	net	net	JJ
18637	2503	49	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	2503	50	partly	partly	RB
18637	2503	51	attributable	attributable	JJ
18637	2503	52	to	to	IN
18637	2503	53	the	the	DT
18637	2503	54	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2503	55	State;[723	state;[723	NN
18637	2503	56	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2503	57	but	but	CC
18637	2503	58	a	a	DT
18637	2503	59	more	more	RBR
18637	2503	60	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2503	61	holding	holding	NN
18637	2503	62	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	2503	63	to	to	TO
18637	2503	64	contradict	contradict	VB
18637	2503	65	this	this	DT
18637	2503	66	position	position	NN
18637	2503	67	.	.	.
18637	2504	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2504	2	724	724	CD
18637	2504	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2504	4	MISCELLANEOUS	miscellaneous	JJ
18637	2504	5	TAXES	taxis	NNS
18637	2504	6	AFFECTING	affect	VBG
18637	2504	7	INTERSTATE	interstate	JJ
18637	2504	8	COMMERCE	COMMERCE	NNS
18637	2504	9	Vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2504	10	In	in	IN
18637	2504	11	Gloucester	Gloucester	NNP
18637	2504	12	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	2504	13	Company	Company	NNP
18637	2504	14	_	_	NNP
18637	2504	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	2504	16	_	_	NNP
18637	2504	17	Pennsylvania,[725	Pennsylvania,[725	NNP
18637	2504	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2504	19	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2504	20	in	in	IN
18637	2504	21	1885	1885	CD
18637	2504	22	,	,	,
18637	2504	23	the	the	DT
18637	2504	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2504	25	held	hold	VBD
18637	2504	26	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	2504	27	to	to	IN
18637	2504	28	a	a	DT
18637	2504	29	New	New	NNP
18637	2504	30	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	2504	31	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2504	32	which	which	WDT
18637	2504	33	was	be	VBD
18637	2504	34	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2504	35	solely	solely	RB
18637	2504	36	in	in	IN
18637	2504	37	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	2504	38	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	2504	39	across	across	IN
18637	2504	40	the	the	DT
18637	2504	41	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	2504	42	River	River	NNP
18637	2504	43	and	and	CC
18637	2504	44	entered	enter	VBD
18637	2504	45	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2504	46	only	only	RB
18637	2504	47	to	to	TO
18637	2504	48	discharge	discharge	VB
18637	2504	49	and	and	CC
18637	2504	50	receive	receive	VB
18637	2504	51	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	2504	52	and	and	CC
18637	2504	53	freight	freight	NN
18637	2504	54	,	,	,
18637	2504	55	a	a	DT
18637	2504	56	statute	statute	NN
18637	2504	57	which	which	WDT
18637	2504	58	taxed	tax	VBD
18637	2504	59	the	the	DT
18637	2504	60	capital	capital	NN
18637	2504	61	stock	stock	NN
18637	2504	62	of	of	IN
18637	2504	63	all	all	DT
18637	2504	64	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2504	65	doing	do	VBG
18637	2504	66	business	business	NN
18637	2504	67	within	within	IN
18637	2504	68	the	the	DT
18637	2504	69	State	State	NNP
18637	2504	70	.	.	.
18637	2505	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	2505	2	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	2505	3	,	,	,
18637	2505	4	the	the	DT
18637	2505	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2505	6	held	hold	VBD
18637	2505	7	,	,	,
18637	2505	8	were	be	VBD
18637	2505	9	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2505	10	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2505	11	;	;	:
18637	2505	12	nor	nor	CC
18637	2505	13	were	be	VBD
18637	2505	14	the	the	DT
18637	2505	15	company	company	NN
18637	2505	16	's	's	POS
18637	2505	17	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2505	18	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2505	19	to	to	IN
18637	2505	20	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2505	21	by	by	IN
18637	2505	22	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2505	23	,	,	,
18637	2505	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2505	25	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2505	26	_	_	NNP
18637	2505	27	situs	situs	NN
18637	2505	28	_	_	NNP
18637	2505	29	being	be	VBG
18637	2505	30	in	in	IN
18637	2505	31	the	the	DT
18637	2505	32	company	company	NN
18637	2505	33	's	's	POS
18637	2505	34	home	home	NN
18637	2505	35	State	state	NN
18637	2505	36	.	.	.
18637	2506	1	The	the	DT
18637	2506	2	only	only	JJ
18637	2506	3	property	property	NN
18637	2506	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	2506	5	by	by	IN
18637	2506	6	the	the	DT
18637	2506	7	company	company	NN
18637	2506	8	in	in	IN
18637	2506	9	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2506	10	was	be	VBD
18637	2506	11	the	the	DT
18637	2506	12	lease	lease	NN
18637	2506	13	there	there	RB
18637	2506	14	of	of	IN
18637	2506	15	a	a	DT
18637	2506	16	wharf	wharf	NN
18637	2506	17	which	which	WDT
18637	2506	18	could	could	MD
18637	2506	19	be	be	VB
18637	2506	20	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	2506	21	by	by	IN
18637	2506	22	the	the	DT
18637	2506	23	State	State	NNP
18637	2506	24	according	accord	VBG
18637	2506	25	to	to	IN
18637	2506	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2506	27	appraised	appraise	VBN
18637	2506	28	value	value	NN
18637	2506	29	;	;	:
18637	2506	30	and	and	CC
18637	2506	31	the	the	DT
18637	2506	32	State	State	NNP
18637	2506	33	could	could	MD
18637	2506	34	also	also	RB
18637	2506	35	levy	levy	VB
18637	2506	36	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2506	37	charges	charge	NNS
18637	2506	38	by	by	IN
18637	2506	39	way	way	NN
18637	2506	40	of	of	IN
18637	2506	41	tolls	toll	NNS
18637	2506	42	for	for	IN
18637	2506	43	the	the	DT
18637	2506	44	use	use	NN
18637	2506	45	of	of	IN
18637	2506	46	such	such	JJ
18637	2506	47	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	2506	48	as	as	IN
18637	2506	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2506	50	might	may	MD
18637	2506	51	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2506	52	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	2506	53	for	for	IN
18637	2506	54	the	the	DT
18637	2506	55	carrying	carrying	NN
18637	2506	56	on	on	RP
18637	2506	57	of	of	IN
18637	2506	58	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2506	59	.	.	.
18637	2507	1	This	this	DT
18637	2507	2	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	2507	3	rested	rest	VBD
18637	2507	4	on	on	IN
18637	2507	5	two	two	CD
18637	2507	6	earlier	early	JJR
18637	2507	7	ones	one	NNS
18637	2507	8	.	.	.
18637	2508	1	In	in	IN
18637	2508	2	1855	1855	CD
18637	2508	3	,	,	,
18637	2508	4	the	the	DT
18637	2508	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2508	6	had	have	VBD
18637	2508	7	held	hold	VBN
18637	2508	8	that	that	IN
18637	2508	9	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2508	10	registered	register	VBN
18637	2508	11	in	in	IN
18637	2508	12	New	New	NNP
18637	2508	13	York	York	NNP
18637	2508	14	,	,	,
18637	2508	15	owned	own	VBN
18637	2508	16	by	by	IN
18637	2508	17	a	a	DT
18637	2508	18	New	New	NNP
18637	2508	19	York	York	NNP
18637	2508	20	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2508	21	,	,	,
18637	2508	22	and	and	CC
18637	2508	23	plying	ply	VBG
18637	2508	24	between	between	IN
18637	2508	25	New	New	NNP
18637	2508	26	York	York	NNP
18637	2508	27	City	City	NNP
18637	2508	28	and	and	CC
18637	2508	29	San	San	NNP
18637	2508	30	Francisco	Francisco	NNP
18637	2508	31	had	have	VBD
18637	2508	32	the	the	DT
18637	2508	33	former	former	JJ
18637	2508	34	city	city	NN
18637	2508	35	for	for	IN
18637	2508	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2508	37	home	home	NN
18637	2508	38	port	port	NN
18637	2508	39	,	,	,
18637	2508	40	and	and	CC
18637	2508	41	were	be	VBD
18637	2508	42	not	not	RB
18637	2508	43	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	2508	44	by	by	IN
18637	2508	45	California	California	NNP
18637	2508	46	where	where	WRB
18637	2508	47	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2508	48	remained	remain	VBD
18637	2508	49	no	no	RB
18637	2508	50	longer	long	RBR
18637	2508	51	than	than	IN
18637	2508	52	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2508	53	to	to	TO
18637	2508	54	discharge	discharge	VB
18637	2508	55	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	2508	56	and	and	CC
18637	2508	57	freight;[726	freight;[726	NNS
18637	2508	58	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2508	59	and	and	CC
18637	2508	60	in	in	IN
18637	2508	61	1877	1877	CD
18637	2508	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2508	63	had	have	VBD
18637	2508	64	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2508	65	Keokuk	Keokuk	NNP
18637	2508	66	,	,	,
18637	2508	67	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	2508	68	in	in	IN
18637	2508	69	charging	charge	VBG
18637	2508	70	tolls	toll	NNS
18637	2508	71	for	for	IN
18637	2508	72	the	the	DT
18637	2508	73	use	use	NN
18637	2508	74	by	by	IN
18637	2508	75	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2508	76	plying	ply	VBG
18637	2508	77	the	the	DT
18637	2508	78	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	2508	79	of	of	IN
18637	2508	80	wharves	wharf	NNS
18637	2508	81	owned	own	VBN
18637	2508	82	by	by	IN
18637	2508	83	the	the	DT
18637	2508	84	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	2508	85	,	,	,
18637	2508	86	said	say	VBD
18637	2508	87	tolls	toll	NNS
18637	2508	88	being	be	VBG
18637	2508	89	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2508	90	and	and	CC
18637	2508	91	not	not	RB
18637	2508	92	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	2508	93	as	as	IN
18637	2508	94	between	between	IN
18637	2508	95	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2508	96	and	and	CC
18637	2508	97	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2508	98	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2508	99	.	.	.
18637	2509	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2509	2	727	727	CD
18637	2509	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2509	4	Today	today	NN
18637	2509	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2509	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2509	7	still	still	RB
18637	2509	8	the	the	DT
18637	2509	9	general	general	JJ
18637	2509	10	rule	rule	NN
18637	2509	11	as	as	IN
18637	2509	12	to	to	IN
18637	2509	13	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2509	14	plying	ply	VBG
18637	2509	15	between	between	IN
18637	2509	16	ports	port	NNS
18637	2509	17	of	of	IN
18637	2509	18	different	different	JJ
18637	2509	19	States	state	NNS
18637	2509	20	and	and	CC
18637	2509	21	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	2509	22	in	in	IN
18637	2509	23	the	the	DT
18637	2509	24	coastwise	coastwise	NN
18637	2509	25	trade	trade	NN
18637	2509	26	,	,	,
18637	2509	27	that	that	IN
18637	2509	28	the	the	DT
18637	2509	29	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	2509	30	of	of	IN
18637	2509	31	the	the	DT
18637	2509	32	owner	owner	NN
18637	2509	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	2509	34	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	2509	35	to	to	TO
18637	2509	36	be	be	VB
18637	2509	37	the	the	DT
18637	2509	38	_	_	NNP
18637	2509	39	situs	situs	NN
18637	2509	40	_	_	NNP
18637	2509	41	of	of	IN
18637	2509	42	the	the	DT
18637	2509	43	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	2509	44	for	for	IN
18637	2509	45	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	2509	46	of	of	IN
18637	2509	47	taxation,[728	taxation,[728	NN
18637	2509	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2509	49	unless	unless	IN
18637	2509	50	the	the	DT
18637	2509	51	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	2509	52	has	have	VBZ
18637	2509	53	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	2509	54	actual	actual	JJ
18637	2509	55	_	_	NNP
18637	2509	56	situs	situs	NN
18637	2509	57	_	_	NNP
18637	2509	58	in	in	IN
18637	2509	59	another	another	DT
18637	2509	60	State	state	NN
18637	2509	61	,	,	,
18637	2509	62	by	by	IN
18637	2509	63	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	2509	64	employment	employment	NN
18637	2509	65	there	there	RB
18637	2509	66	,	,	,
18637	2509	67	in	in	IN
18637	2509	68	which	which	WDT
18637	2509	69	event	event	NN
18637	2509	70	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2509	71	may	may	MD
18637	2509	72	be	be	VB
18637	2509	73	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	2509	74	there	there	RB
18637	2509	75	.	.	.
18637	2510	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2510	2	729	729	CD
18637	2510	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2510	4	Recently	recently	RB
18637	2510	5	,	,	,
18637	2510	6	however	however	RB
18637	2510	7	,	,	,
18637	2510	8	this	this	DT
18637	2510	9	long	long	JJ
18637	2510	10	standing	standing	NN
18637	2510	11	rule	rule	NN
18637	2510	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	2510	13	been	be	VBN
18637	2510	14	amended	amend	VBN
18637	2510	15	by	by	IN
18637	2510	16	the	the	DT
18637	2510	17	addition	addition	NN
18637	2510	18	to	to	IN
18637	2510	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2510	20	of	of	IN
18637	2510	21	the	the	DT
18637	2510	22	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	2510	23	rule	rule	NN
18637	2510	24	as	as	IN
18637	2510	25	developed	develop	VBN
18637	2510	26	in	in	IN
18637	2510	27	the	the	DT
18637	2510	28	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	2510	29	case	case	NN
18637	2510	30	.	.	.
18637	2511	1	This	this	DT
18637	2511	2	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	2511	3	in	in	IN
18637	2511	4	Ott	Ott	NNP
18637	2511	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2511	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	2511	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2511	8	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	2511	9	Barge	Barge	NNP
18637	2511	10	Line	Line	NNP
18637	2511	11	Co	Co	NNP
18637	2511	12	.	.	.
18637	2511	13	,[730	,[730	NFP
18637	2511	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2511	15	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2511	16	in	in	IN
18637	2511	17	1949	1949	CD
18637	2511	18	,	,	,
18637	2511	19	in	in	IN
18637	2511	20	which	which	WDT
18637	2511	21	the	the	DT
18637	2511	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2511	23	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	2511	24	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	2511	25	in	in	IN
18637	2511	26	levying	levy	VBG
18637	2511	27	an	an	DT
18637	2511	28	_	_	NNP
18637	2511	29	ad	ad	NN
18637	2511	30	valorem	valorem	NN
18637	2511	31	_	_	NNP
18637	2511	32	tax	tax	NN
18637	2511	33	on	on	IN
18637	2511	34	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2511	35	owned	own	VBN
18637	2511	36	by	by	IN
18637	2511	37	an	an	DT
18637	2511	38	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2511	39	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2511	40	and	and	CC
18637	2511	41	used	use	VBN
18637	2511	42	within	within	IN
18637	2511	43	the	the	DT
18637	2511	44	State	State	NNP
18637	2511	45	,	,	,
18637	2511	46	the	the	DT
18637	2511	47	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	2511	48	for	for	IN
18637	2511	49	the	the	DT
18637	2511	50	tax	tax	NN
18637	2511	51	being	be	VBG
18637	2511	52	based	base	VBN
18637	2511	53	on	on	IN
18637	2511	54	the	the	DT
18637	2511	55	ratio	ratio	NN
18637	2511	56	between	between	IN
18637	2511	57	the	the	DT
18637	2511	58	number	number	NN
18637	2511	59	of	of	IN
18637	2511	60	miles	mile	NNS
18637	2511	61	of	of	IN
18637	2511	62	the	the	DT
18637	2511	63	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2511	64	's	's	POS
18637	2511	65	lines	line	NNS
18637	2511	66	within	within	IN
18637	2511	67	the	the	DT
18637	2511	68	State	State	NNP
18637	2511	69	and	and	CC
18637	2511	70	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2511	71	total	total	JJ
18637	2511	72	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2511	73	.	.	.
18637	2512	1	Airplanes	airplane	NNS
18637	2512	2	When	when	WRB
18637	2512	3	,	,	,
18637	2512	4	however	however	RB
18637	2512	5	,	,	,
18637	2512	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2512	7	was	be	VBD
18637	2512	8	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	2512	9	by	by	IN
18637	2512	10	an	an	DT
18637	2512	11	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	2512	12	on	on	IN
18637	2512	13	the	the	DT
18637	2512	14	part	part	NN
18637	2512	15	of	of	IN
18637	2512	16	the	the	DT
18637	2512	17	State	State	NNP
18637	2512	18	of	of	IN
18637	2512	19	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	2512	20	to	to	TO
18637	2512	21	impose	impose	VB
18637	2512	22	a	a	DT
18637	2512	23	personal	personal	JJ
18637	2512	24	property	property	NN
18637	2512	25	tax	tax	NN
18637	2512	26	on	on	IN
18637	2512	27	the	the	DT
18637	2512	28	entire	entire	JJ
18637	2512	29	air	air	NN
18637	2512	30	fleet	fleet	NN
18637	2512	31	owned	own	VBN
18637	2512	32	and	and	CC
18637	2512	33	operated	operate	VBN
18637	2512	34	by	by	IN
18637	2512	35	a	a	DT
18637	2512	36	company	company	NN
18637	2512	37	in	in	IN
18637	2512	38	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2512	39	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2512	40	although	although	IN
18637	2512	41	only	only	RB
18637	2512	42	a	a	DT
18637	2512	43	part	part	NN
18637	2512	44	of	of	IN
18637	2512	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2512	46	was	be	VBD
18637	2512	47	in	in	IN
18637	2512	48	the	the	DT
18637	2512	49	State	State	NNP
18637	2512	50	on	on	IN
18637	2512	51	tax	tax	NN
18637	2512	52	day	day	NN
18637	2512	53	,	,	,
18637	2512	54	the	the	DT
18637	2512	55	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2512	56	found	find	VBD
18637	2512	57	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2512	58	unable	unable	JJ
18637	2512	59	to	to	TO
18637	2512	60	recruit	recruit	VB
18637	2512	61	a	a	DT
18637	2512	62	majority	majority	NN
18637	2512	63	for	for	IN
18637	2512	64	any	any	DT
18637	2512	65	of	of	IN
18637	2512	66	the	the	DT
18637	2512	67	above	above	JJ
18637	2512	68	formulas	formula	NNS
18637	2512	69	.	.	.
18637	2513	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2513	2	731	731	CD
18637	2513	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2513	4	Pointing	point	VBG
18637	2513	5	to	to	IN
18637	2513	6	the	the	DT
18637	2513	7	fact	fact	NN
18637	2513	8	that	that	IN
18637	2513	9	the	the	DT
18637	2513	10	company	company	NN
18637	2513	11	was	be	VBD
18637	2513	12	a	a	DT
18637	2513	13	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	2513	14	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2513	15	and	and	CC
18637	2513	16	that	that	IN
18637	2513	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2513	18	principal	principal	JJ
18637	2513	19	place	place	NN
18637	2513	20	of	of	IN
18637	2513	21	business	business	NN
18637	2513	22	was	be	VBD
18637	2513	23	located	locate	VBN
18637	2513	24	in	in	IN
18637	2513	25	the	the	DT
18637	2513	26	State	State	NNP
18637	2513	27	,	,	,
18637	2513	28	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2513	29	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	2513	30	for	for	IN
18637	2513	31	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2513	32	and	and	CC
18637	2513	33	three	three	CD
18637	2513	34	others	other	NNS
18637	2513	35	wished	wish	VBD
18637	2513	36	to	to	TO
18637	2513	37	stress	stress	VB
18637	2513	38	the	the	DT
18637	2513	39	prerogatives	prerogative	NNS
18637	2513	40	of	of	IN
18637	2513	41	the	the	DT
18637	2513	42	State	State	NNP
18637	2513	43	of	of	IN
18637	2513	44	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	2513	45	.	.	.
18637	2514	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2514	2	732	732	CD
18637	2514	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2514	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2514	5	Black	Black	NNP
18637	2514	6	,	,	,
18637	2514	7	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	2514	8	in	in	IN
18637	2514	9	this	this	DT
18637	2514	10	view	view	NN
18637	2514	11	,	,	,
18637	2514	12	added	add	VBD
18637	2514	13	the	the	DT
18637	2514	14	caveat	caveat	NN
18637	2514	15	that	that	IN
18637	2514	16	the	the	DT
18637	2514	17	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2514	18	rights	right	NNS
18637	2514	19	of	of	IN
18637	2514	20	other	other	JJ
18637	2514	21	States	States	NNPS
18637	2514	22	should	should	MD
18637	2514	23	not	not	RB
18637	2514	24	be	be	VB
18637	2514	25	foreclosed	foreclose	VBN
18637	2514	26	and	and	CC
18637	2514	27	made	make	VBN
18637	2514	28	reference	reference	NN
18637	2514	29	to	to	IN
18637	2514	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2514	31	"	"	``
18637	2514	32	leave	leave	VB
18637	2514	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2514	34	to	to	IN
18637	2514	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2514	36	"	"	''
18637	2514	37	notion	notion	NN
18637	2514	38	.	.	.
18637	2515	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2515	2	733	733	CD
18637	2515	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2515	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2515	5	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	2515	6	,	,	,
18637	2515	7	after	after	IN
18637	2515	8	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2515	9	lightly	lightly	RB
18637	2515	10	of	of	IN
18637	2515	11	the	the	DT
18637	2515	12	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	2515	13	theory,[734	theory,[734	NNS
18637	2515	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2515	15	joined	join	VBD
18637	2515	16	the	the	DT
18637	2515	17	affirming	affirming	NN
18637	2515	18	brethren	brother	NNS
18637	2515	19	on	on	IN
18637	2515	20	the	the	DT
18637	2515	21	ground	ground	NN
18637	2515	22	that	that	IN
18637	2515	23	the	the	DT
18637	2515	24	record	record	NN
18637	2515	25	seemed	seem	VBD
18637	2515	26	"	"	``
18637	2515	27	to	to	TO
18637	2515	28	establish	establish	VB
18637	2515	29	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	2515	30	as	as	IN
18637	2515	31	a	a	DT
18637	2515	32	'	'	``
18637	2515	33	home	home	NN
18637	2515	34	port	port	NN
18637	2515	35	'	'	''
18637	2515	36	within	within	IN
18637	2515	37	the	the	DT
18637	2515	38	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	2515	39	of	of	IN
18637	2515	40	the	the	DT
18637	2515	41	old	old	JJ
18637	2515	42	and	and	CC
18637	2515	43	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	2515	44	neglected	neglected	JJ
18637	2515	45	but	but	CC
18637	2515	46	to	to	IN
18637	2515	47	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2515	48	wise	wise	JJ
18637	2515	49	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	2515	50	cited	cite	VBD
18637	2515	51	,	,	,
18637	2515	52	"	"	``
18637	2515	53	to	to	IN
18637	2515	54	wit	wit	NN
18637	2515	55	,	,	,
18637	2515	56	the	the	DT
18637	2515	57	Hays	Hays	NNP
18637	2515	58	case	case	NN
18637	2515	59	and	and	CC
18637	2515	60	those	those	DT
18637	2515	61	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2515	62	by	by	IN
18637	2515	63	analogy	analogy	NN
18637	2515	64	to	to	IN
18637	2515	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2515	66	.	.	.
18637	2516	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2516	2	735	735	CD
18637	2516	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2516	4	Four	four	CD
18637	2516	5	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	2516	6	,	,	,
18637	2516	7	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2516	8	by	by	IN
18637	2516	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2516	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2516	11	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	2516	12	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	2516	13	,	,	,
18637	2516	14	urging	urge	VBG
18637	2516	15	the	the	DT
18637	2516	16	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	2516	17	Case[736	case[736	NN
18637	2516	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2516	19	as	as	IN
18637	2516	20	an	an	DT
18637	2516	21	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	2516	22	model	model	NN
18637	2516	23	and	and	CC
18637	2516	24	the	the	DT
18637	2516	25	fact	fact	NN
18637	2516	26	that	that	IN
18637	2516	27	"	"	``
18637	2516	28	the	the	DT
18637	2516	29	rationale	rationale	NN
18637	2516	30	found	find	VBD
18637	2516	31	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2516	32	to	to	TO
18637	2516	33	support	support	VB
18637	2516	34	the	the	DT
18637	2516	35	present	present	JJ
18637	2516	36	tax	tax	NN
18637	2516	37	leaves	leave	VBZ
18637	2516	38	other	other	JJ
18637	2516	39	States	States	NNPS
18637	2516	40	free	free	JJ
18637	2516	41	to	to	TO
18637	2516	42	impose	impose	VB
18637	2516	43	comparable	comparable	JJ
18637	2516	44	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2516	45	on	on	IN
18637	2516	46	the	the	DT
18637	2516	47	same	same	JJ
18637	2516	48	property	property	NN
18637	2516	49	.	.	.
18637	2517	1	"	"	``
18637	2517	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2517	3	737	737	CD
18637	2517	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2517	5	Evidently	evidently	RB
18637	2517	6	in	in	IN
18637	2517	7	this	this	DT
18637	2517	8	area	area	NN
18637	2517	9	of	of	IN
18637	2517	10	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	2517	11	Law	Law	NNP
18637	2517	12	the	the	DT
18637	2517	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2517	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	2517	15	still	still	RB
18637	2517	16	much	much	RB
18637	2517	17	at	at	IN
18637	2517	18	sea	sea	NN
18637	2517	19	or	or	CC
18637	2517	20	better	well	JJR
18637	2517	21	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	2517	22	,	,	,
18637	2517	23	"	"	''
18637	2517	24	up	up	RB
18637	2517	25	in	in	IN
18637	2517	26	the	the	DT
18637	2517	27	air	air	NN
18637	2517	28	.	.	.
18637	2517	29	"	"	''
18637	2518	1	Motor	motor	NN
18637	2518	2	Vehicles	Vehicles	NNPS
18637	2518	3	In	in	IN
18637	2518	4	the	the	DT
18637	2518	5	matter	matter	NN
18637	2518	6	of	of	IN
18637	2518	7	motor	motor	NN
18637	2518	8	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	2518	9	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2518	10	,	,	,
18637	2518	11	on	on	IN
18637	2518	12	the	the	DT
18637	2518	13	other	other	JJ
18637	2518	14	hand	hand	NN
18637	2518	15	,	,	,
18637	2518	16	durable	durable	JJ
18637	2518	17	and	and	CC
18637	2518	18	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	2518	19	results	result	NNS
18637	2518	20	have	have	VBP
18637	2518	21	been	be	VBN
18637	2518	22	achieved	achieve	VBN
18637	2518	23	.	.	.
18637	2519	1	This	this	DT
18637	2519	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2519	3	because	because	IN
18637	2519	4	most	most	JJS
18637	2519	5	such	such	JJ
18637	2519	6	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2519	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	2519	8	been	be	VBN
18637	2519	9	readily	readily	RB
18637	2519	10	classifiable	classifiable	JJ
18637	2519	11	as	as	IN
18637	2519	12	the	the	DT
18637	2519	13	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	2519	14	of	of	IN
18637	2519	15	a	a	DT
18637	2519	16	toll	toll	NN
18637	2519	17	for	for	IN
18637	2519	18	the	the	DT
18637	2519	19	use	use	NN
18637	2519	20	of	of	IN
18637	2519	21	the	the	DT
18637	2519	22	State	State	NNP
18637	2519	23	's	's	POS
18637	2519	24	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2519	25	,	,	,
18637	2519	26	and	and	CC
18637	2519	27	the	the	DT
18637	2519	28	only	only	JJ
18637	2519	29	question	question	NN
18637	2519	30	was	be	VBD
18637	2519	31	whether	whether	IN
18637	2519	32	the	the	DT
18637	2519	33	toll	toll	NN
18637	2519	34	was	be	VBD
18637	2519	35	exorbitant	exorbitant	JJ
18637	2519	36	.	.	.
18637	2520	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	2520	2	,	,	,
18637	2520	3	such	such	JJ
18637	2520	4	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2520	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	2520	6	apt	apt	JJ
18637	2520	7	to	to	TO
18637	2520	8	be	be	VB
18637	2520	9	designed	design	VBN
18637	2520	10	not	not	RB
18637	2520	11	merely	merely	RB
18637	2520	12	to	to	TO
18637	2520	13	raise	raise	VB
18637	2520	14	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	2520	15	but	but	CC
18637	2520	16	to	to	TO
18637	2520	17	promote	promote	VB
18637	2520	18	safety	safety	NN
18637	2520	19	on	on	IN
18637	2520	20	the	the	DT
18637	2520	21	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2520	22	.	.	.
18637	2521	1	In	in	IN
18637	2521	2	the	the	DT
18637	2521	3	leading	leading	JJ
18637	2521	4	case	case	NN
18637	2521	5	,	,	,
18637	2521	6	Hendrick	Hendrick	NNP
18637	2521	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2521	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	2521	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2521	10	Maryland,[738	Maryland,[738	NNP
18637	2521	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2521	12	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2521	13	in	in	IN
18637	2521	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	2521	15	,	,	,
18637	2521	16	the	the	DT
18637	2521	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2521	18	took	take	VBD
18637	2521	19	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	2521	20	of	of	IN
18637	2521	21	the	the	DT
18637	2521	22	fact	fact	NN
18637	2521	23	that	that	IN
18637	2521	24	"	"	``
18637	2521	25	the	the	DT
18637	2521	26	movement	movement	NN
18637	2521	27	of	of	IN
18637	2521	28	motor	motor	NN
18637	2521	29	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2521	30	over	over	IN
18637	2521	31	the	the	DT
18637	2521	32	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2521	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	2521	34	attended	attend	VBN
18637	2521	35	by	by	IN
18637	2521	36	constant	constant	JJ
18637	2521	37	and	and	CC
18637	2521	38	serious	serious	JJ
18637	2521	39	dangers	danger	NNS
18637	2521	40	to	to	IN
18637	2521	41	the	the	DT
18637	2521	42	public	public	NN
18637	2521	43	,	,	,
18637	2521	44	and	and	CC
18637	2521	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	2521	46	also	also	RB
18637	2521	47	abnormally	abnormally	RB
18637	2521	48	destructive	destructive	JJ
18637	2521	49	to	to	IN
18637	2521	50	the	the	DT
18637	2521	51	ways	way	NNS
18637	2521	52	themselves";[739	themselves";[739	.
18637	2521	53	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2521	54	and	and	CC
18637	2521	55	on	on	IN
18637	2521	56	this	this	DT
18637	2521	57	factual	factual	JJ
18637	2521	58	basis	basis	NN
18637	2521	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2521	60	has	have	VBZ
18637	2521	61	held	hold	VBN
18637	2521	62	that	that	IN
18637	2521	63	registration	registration	NN
18637	2521	64	may	may	MD
18637	2521	65	be	be	VB
18637	2521	66	required	require	VBN
18637	2521	67	by	by	IN
18637	2521	68	a	a	DT
18637	2521	69	State	state	NN
18637	2521	70	for	for	IN
18637	2521	71	out	out	RB
18637	2521	72	-	-	HYPH
18637	2521	73	of	of	IN
18637	2521	74	-	-	HYPH
18637	2521	75	State	state	NN
18637	2521	76	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2521	77	operated	operate	VBD
18637	2521	78	therein,[740	therein,[740	NN
18637	2521	79	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2521	80	or	or	CC
18637	2521	81	passing	pass	VBG
18637	2521	82	through	through	RB
18637	2521	83	from	from	IN
18637	2521	84	one	one	CD
18637	2521	85	State	State	NNP
18637	2521	86	to	to	IN
18637	2521	87	another;[741	another;[741	LS
18637	2521	88	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2521	89	that	that	IN
18637	2521	90	a	a	DT
18637	2521	91	special	special	JJ
18637	2521	92	fee	fee	NN
18637	2521	93	may	may	MD
18637	2521	94	be	be	VB
18637	2521	95	exacted	exact	VBN
18637	2521	96	for	for	IN
18637	2521	97	the	the	DT
18637	2521	98	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2521	99	of	of	IN
18637	2521	100	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	2521	101	motor	motor	NN
18637	2521	102	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2521	103	on	on	IN
18637	2521	104	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2521	105	own	own	JJ
18637	2521	106	wheels	wheel	NNS
18637	2521	107	in	in	IN
18637	2521	108	caravans,[742	caravans,[742	NN
18637	2521	109	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2521	110	unless	unless	IN
18637	2521	111	excessive;[743	excessive;[743	NNS
18637	2521	112	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2521	113	that	that	IN
18637	2521	114	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2521	115	may	may	MD
18637	2521	116	also	also	RB
18637	2521	117	be	be	VB
18637	2521	118	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2521	119	on	on	IN
18637	2521	120	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	2521	121	based	base	VBN
18637	2521	122	on	on	IN
18637	2521	123	capacity[744	capacity[744	NNP
18637	2521	124	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2521	125	or	or	CC
18637	2521	126	mileage,[745	mileage,[745	NN
18637	2521	127	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2521	128	or	or	CC
18637	2521	129	as	as	IN
18637	2521	130	a	a	DT
18637	2521	131	flat	flat	JJ
18637	2521	132	fee;[746	fee;[746	NNP
18637	2521	133	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2521	134	but	but	CC
18637	2521	135	that	that	IN
18637	2521	136	a	a	DT
18637	2521	137	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2521	138	tax	tax	NN
18637	2521	139	on	on	IN
18637	2521	140	motor	motor	NN
18637	2521	141	busses	bus	NNS
18637	2521	142	operated	operate	VBD
18637	2521	143	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	2521	144	in	in	IN
18637	2521	145	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2521	146	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2521	147	,	,	,
18637	2521	148	can	can	MD
18637	2521	149	not	not	RB
18637	2521	150	be	be	VB
18637	2521	151	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2521	152	unless	unless	IN
18637	2521	153	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2521	154	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	2521	155	affirmatively	affirmatively	RB
18637	2521	156	in	in	IN
18637	2521	157	some	some	DT
18637	2521	158	way	way	NN
18637	2521	159	,	,	,
18637	2521	160	that	that	IN
18637	2521	161	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2521	162	is	be	VBZ
18637	2521	163	levied	levy	VBN
18637	2521	164	only	only	RB
18637	2521	165	as	as	IN
18637	2521	166	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	2521	167	for	for	IN
18637	2521	168	use	use	NN
18637	2521	169	of	of	IN
18637	2521	170	the	the	DT
18637	2521	171	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2521	172	in	in	IN
18637	2521	173	the	the	DT
18637	2521	174	State	State	NNP
18637	2521	175	or	or	CC
18637	2521	176	to	to	TO
18637	2521	177	defray	defray	VB
18637	2521	178	the	the	DT
18637	2521	179	expense	expense	NN
18637	2521	180	of	of	IN
18637	2521	181	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	2521	182	motor	motor	NN
18637	2521	183	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2521	184	.	.	.
18637	2522	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2522	2	747	747	CD
18637	2522	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2522	4	Later	late	JJR
18637	2522	5	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	2522	6	follow	follow	VBP
18637	2522	7	in	in	IN
18637	2522	8	the	the	DT
18637	2522	9	same	same	JJ
18637	2522	10	general	general	JJ
18637	2522	11	track,[748	track,[748	NNP
18637	2522	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2522	13	the	the	DT
18637	2522	14	most	most	RBS
18637	2522	15	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2522	16	one	one	CD
18637	2522	17	being	be	VBG
18637	2522	18	Capitol	Capitol	NNP
18637	2522	19	Greyhound	Greyhound	NNP
18637	2522	20	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	2522	21	_	_	NNP
18637	2522	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	2522	23	_	_	NNP
18637	2522	24	Brice,[749	Brice,[749	NNP
18637	2522	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2522	26	in	in	IN
18637	2522	27	which	which	WDT
18637	2522	28	the	the	DT
18637	2522	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2522	30	,	,	,
18637	2522	31	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2522	32	by	by	IN
18637	2522	33	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2522	34	Black	Black	NNP
18637	2522	35	passed	pass	VBD
18637	2522	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	2522	37	a	a	DT
18637	2522	38	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	2522	39	excise	excise	NN
18637	2522	40	tax	tax	NN
18637	2522	41	on	on	IN
18637	2522	42	the	the	DT
18637	2522	43	fair	fair	JJ
18637	2522	44	market	market	NN
18637	2522	45	value	value	NN
18637	2522	46	of	of	IN
18637	2522	47	motor	motor	NN
18637	2522	48	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2522	49	used	use	VBN
18637	2522	50	in	in	IN
18637	2522	51	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2522	52	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2522	53	as	as	IN
18637	2522	54	a	a	DT
18637	2522	55	condition	condition	NN
18637	2522	56	to	to	IN
18637	2522	57	the	the	DT
18637	2522	58	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	2522	59	of	of	IN
18637	2522	60	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	2522	61	of	of	IN
18637	2522	62	title	title	NN
18637	2522	63	as	as	IN
18637	2522	64	prerequisites	prerequisite	NNS
18637	2522	65	to	to	IN
18637	2522	66	the	the	DT
18637	2522	67	registration	registration	NN
18637	2522	68	and	and	CC
18637	2522	69	operation	operation	NN
18637	2522	70	of	of	IN
18637	2522	71	motor	motor	NN
18637	2522	72	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2522	73	in	in	IN
18637	2522	74	the	the	DT
18637	2522	75	State	State	NNP
18637	2522	76	.	.	.
18637	2523	1	Because	because	IN
18637	2523	2	the	the	DT
18637	2523	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	2523	4	was	be	VBD
18637	2523	5	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2523	6	to	to	IN
18637	2523	7	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2523	8	used	use	VBN
18637	2523	9	in	in	IN
18637	2523	10	both	both	CC
18637	2523	11	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2523	12	and	and	CC
18637	2523	13	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2523	14	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2523	15	and	and	CC
18637	2523	16	the	the	DT
18637	2523	17	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	2523	18	were	be	VBD
18637	2523	19	used	use	VBN
18637	2523	20	for	for	IN
18637	2523	21	road	road	NN
18637	2523	22	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	2523	23	and	and	CC
18637	2523	24	because	because	IN
18637	2523	25	the	the	DT
18637	2523	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2523	27	considered	consider	VBD
18637	2523	28	the	the	DT
18637	2523	29	tax	tax	NN
18637	2523	30	,	,	,
18637	2523	31	though	though	IN
18637	2523	32	actually	actually	RB
18637	2523	33	separate	separate	JJ
18637	2523	34	,	,	,
18637	2523	35	to	to	TO
18637	2523	36	be	be	VB
18637	2523	37	an	an	DT
18637	2523	38	adjunct	adjunct	NN
18637	2523	39	of	of	IN
18637	2523	40	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	2523	41	's	's	POS
18637	2523	42	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2523	43	tax	tax	NN
18637	2523	44	,	,	,
18637	2523	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2523	46	was	be	VBD
18637	2523	47	able	able	JJ
18637	2523	48	to	to	TO
18637	2523	49	find	find	VB
18637	2523	50	that	that	IN
18637	2523	51	the	the	DT
18637	2523	52	total	total	JJ
18637	2523	53	charge	charge	NN
18637	2523	54	varied	vary	VBD
18637	2523	55	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	2523	56	with	with	IN
18637	2523	57	the	the	DT
18637	2523	58	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	2523	59	travelled	travel	VBN
18637	2523	60	,	,	,
18637	2523	61	and	and	CC
18637	2523	62	on	on	IN
18637	2523	63	that	that	DT
18637	2523	64	ground	ground	NN
18637	2523	65	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	2523	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2523	67	,	,	,
18637	2523	68	being	be	VBG
18637	2523	69	constant	constant	JJ
18637	2523	70	,	,	,
18637	2523	71	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2523	72	said	say	VBD
18637	2523	73	with	with	IN
18637	2523	74	"	"	``
18637	2523	75	rough	rough	JJ
18637	2523	76	approximation	approximation	NN
18637	2523	77	rather	rather	RB
18637	2523	78	than	than	IN
18637	2523	79	precision	precision	NN
18637	2523	80	,	,	,
18637	2523	81	"	"	''
18637	2523	82	no	no	DT
18637	2523	83	showing	showing	NN
18637	2523	84	having	have	VBG
18637	2523	85	been	be	VBN
18637	2523	86	made	make	VBN
18637	2523	87	that	that	IN
18637	2523	88	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	2523	89	's	's	POS
18637	2523	90	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2523	91	considered	consider	VBN
18637	2523	92	as	as	IN
18637	2523	93	a	a	DT
18637	2523	94	whole	whole	NN
18637	2523	95	exceeded	exceed	VBD
18637	2523	96	"	"	``
18637	2523	97	fair	fair	JJ
18637	2523	98	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	2523	99	for	for	IN
18637	2523	100	the	the	DT
18637	2523	101	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2523	102	of	of	IN
18637	2523	103	using	use	VBG
18637	2523	104	State	State	NNP
18637	2523	105	roads	road	NNS
18637	2523	106	.	.	.
18637	2523	107	"	"	''
18637	2524	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2524	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	2524	3	,	,	,
18637	2524	4	who	who	WP
18637	2524	5	was	be	VBD
18637	2524	6	joined	join	VBN
18637	2524	7	by	by	IN
18637	2524	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2524	9	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	2524	10	,	,	,
18637	2524	11	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	2524	12	,	,	,
18637	2524	13	and	and	CC
18637	2524	14	in	in	IN
18637	2524	15	so	so	RB
18637	2524	16	doing	do	VBG
18637	2524	17	contributed	contribute	VBD
18637	2524	18	as	as	IN
18637	2524	19	an	an	DT
18637	2524	20	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
18637	2524	21	to	to	IN
18637	2524	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2524	23	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2524	24	a	a	DT
18637	2524	25	useful	useful	JJ
18637	2524	26	analysis	analysis	NN
18637	2524	27	of	of	IN
18637	2524	28	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	2524	29	involving	involve	VBG
18637	2524	30	State	state	NN
18637	2524	31	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2524	32	of	of	IN
18637	2524	33	motor	motor	NN
18637	2524	34	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2524	35	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2524	36	in	in	IN
18637	2524	37	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2524	38	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2524	39	,	,	,
18637	2524	40	for	for	IN
18637	2524	41	highway	highway	NN
18637	2524	42	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	2524	43	.	.	.
18637	2525	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2525	2	750	750	CD
18637	2525	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2525	4	Public	Public	NNP
18637	2525	5	Utilities	Utilities	NNPS
18637	2525	6	;	;	:
18637	2525	7	Regulatory	Regulatory	NNP
18637	2525	8	Charges	charge	NNS
18637	2525	9	"	"	``
18637	2525	10	The	the	DT
18637	2525	11	principles	principle	NNS
18637	2525	12	governing	govern	VBG
18637	2525	13	decision	decision	NN
18637	2525	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2525	15	in	in	IN
18637	2525	16	this	this	DT
18637	2525	17	class	class	NN
18637	2525	18	of	of	IN
18637	2525	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	2525	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2525	21	have	have	VBP
18637	2525	22	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	2525	23	been	be	VBN
18637	2525	24	announced	announce	VBN
18637	2525	25	and	and	CC
18637	2525	26	were	be	VBD
18637	2525	27	not	not	RB
18637	2525	28	questioned	question	VBN
18637	2525	29	below	below	RB
18637	2525	30	.	.	.
18637	2526	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2526	2	751	751	CD
18637	2526	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2526	4	In	in	IN
18637	2526	5	the	the	DT
18637	2526	6	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2526	7	of	of	IN
18637	2526	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2526	9	police	police	NN
18637	2526	10	power	power	NN
18637	2526	11	the	the	DT
18637	2526	12	State	state	NN
18637	2526	13	may	may	MD
18637	2526	14	provide	provide	VB
18637	2526	15	for	for	IN
18637	2526	16	the	the	DT
18637	2526	17	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	2526	18	and	and	CC
18637	2526	19	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2526	20	of	of	IN
18637	2526	21	public	public	JJ
18637	2526	22	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	2526	23	,	,	,
18637	2526	24	such	such	JJ
18637	2526	25	as	as	IN
18637	2526	26	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	2526	27	;	;	:
18637	2526	28	may	may	MD
18637	2526	29	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	2526	30	the	the	DT
18637	2526	31	duty	duty	NN
18637	2526	32	to	to	IN
18637	2526	33	an	an	DT
18637	2526	34	officer	officer	NN
18637	2526	35	or	or	CC
18637	2526	36	commission	commission	NN
18637	2526	37	;	;	:
18637	2526	38	and	and	CC
18637	2526	39	may	may	MD
18637	2526	40	exact	exact	VB
18637	2526	41	the	the	DT
18637	2526	42	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2526	43	cost	cost	NN
18637	2526	44	of	of	IN
18637	2526	45	such	such	JJ
18637	2526	46	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	2526	47	and	and	CC
18637	2526	48	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2526	49	from	from	IN
18637	2526	50	the	the	DT
18637	2526	51	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	2526	52	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	2526	53	and	and	CC
18637	2526	54	allocate	allocate	VB
18637	2526	55	the	the	DT
18637	2526	56	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	2526	57	amongst	amongst	IN
18637	2526	58	the	the	DT
18637	2526	59	members	member	NNS
18637	2526	60	of	of	IN
18637	2526	61	the	the	DT
18637	2526	62	affected	affect	VBN
18637	2526	63	class	class	NN
18637	2526	64	without	without	IN
18637	2526	65	violating	violate	VBG
18637	2526	66	the	the	DT
18637	2526	67	rule	rule	NN
18637	2526	68	of	of	IN
18637	2526	69	equality	equality	NN
18637	2526	70	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2526	71	by	by	IN
18637	2526	72	the	the	DT
18637	2526	73	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	2526	74	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	2526	75	.	.	.
18637	2527	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2527	2	752	752	CD
18637	2527	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2527	4	The	the	DT
18637	2527	5	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	2527	6	and	and	CC
18637	2527	7	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2527	8	of	of	IN
18637	2527	9	the	the	DT
18637	2527	10	local	local	JJ
18637	2527	11	structures	structure	NNS
18637	2527	12	and	and	CC
18637	2527	13	activities	activity	NNS
18637	2527	14	of	of	IN
18637	2527	15	a	a	DT
18637	2527	16	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2527	17	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2527	18	in	in	IN
18637	2527	19	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2527	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2527	21	,	,	,
18637	2527	22	and	and	CC
18637	2527	23	the	the	DT
18637	2527	24	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	2527	25	of	of	IN
18637	2527	26	the	the	DT
18637	2527	27	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2527	28	expense	expense	NN
18637	2527	29	thereof	thereof	VBN
18637	2527	30	upon	upon	IN
18637	2527	31	such	such	JJ
18637	2527	32	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2527	33	,	,	,
18637	2527	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	2527	35	not	not	RB
18637	2527	36	a	a	DT
18637	2527	37	burden	burden	NN
18637	2527	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	2527	39	,	,	,
18637	2527	40	or	or	CC
18637	2527	41	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2527	42	of	of	IN
18637	2527	43	,	,	,
18637	2527	44	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2527	45	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2527	46	in	in	IN
18637	2527	47	violation	violation	NN
18637	2527	48	of	of	IN
18637	2527	49	the	the	DT
18637	2527	50	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2527	51	clause	clause	NN
18637	2527	52	of	of	IN
18637	2527	53	the	the	DT
18637	2527	54	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2527	55	.	.	.
18637	2528	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2528	2	753	753	CD
18637	2528	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2528	4	A	a	DT
18637	2528	5	law	law	NN
18637	2528	6	exhibiting	exhibit	VBG
18637	2528	7	the	the	DT
18637	2528	8	intent	intent	NN
18637	2528	9	to	to	TO
18637	2528	10	impose	impose	VB
18637	2528	11	a	a	DT
18637	2528	12	compensatory	compensatory	JJ
18637	2528	13	fee	fee	NN
18637	2528	14	for	for	IN
18637	2528	15	such	such	PDT
18637	2528	16	a	a	DT
18637	2528	17	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	2528	18	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2528	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	2528	20	_	_	NNP
18637	2528	21	prima	prima	NN
18637	2528	22	facie	facie	NNP
18637	2528	23	_	_	NNP
18637	2528	24	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2528	25	.	.	.
18637	2529	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2529	2	754	754	CD
18637	2529	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2529	4	If	if	IN
18637	2529	5	the	the	DT
18637	2529	6	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	2529	7	be	be	VBP
18637	2529	8	so	so	RB
18637	2529	9	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	2529	10	and	and	CC
18637	2529	11	disproportionate	disproportionate	JJ
18637	2529	12	to	to	IN
18637	2529	13	the	the	DT
18637	2529	14	service	service	NN
18637	2529	15	as	as	IN
18637	2529	16	to	to	TO
18637	2529	17	impugn	impugn	VB
18637	2529	18	the	the	DT
18637	2529	19	good	good	JJ
18637	2529	20	faith	faith	NN
18637	2529	21	of	of	IN
18637	2529	22	the	the	DT
18637	2529	23	law[755	law[755	NNPS
18637	2529	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2529	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2529	26	can	can	MD
18637	2529	27	not	not	RB
18637	2529	28	stand	stand	VB
18637	2529	29	either	either	CC
18637	2529	30	under	under	IN
18637	2529	31	the	the	DT
18637	2529	32	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2529	33	clause	clause	NN
18637	2529	34	or	or	CC
18637	2529	35	the	the	DT
18637	2529	36	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	2529	37	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	2529	38	.	.	.
18637	2530	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2530	2	756	756	CD
18637	2530	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2530	4	The	the	DT
18637	2530	5	State	State	NNP
18637	2530	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2530	7	not	not	RB
18637	2530	8	bound	bind	VBN
18637	2530	9	to	to	TO
18637	2530	10	adjust	adjust	VB
18637	2530	11	the	the	DT
18637	2530	12	charge	charge	NN
18637	2530	13	after	after	IN
18637	2530	14	the	the	DT
18637	2530	15	fact	fact	NN
18637	2530	16	,	,	,
18637	2530	17	but	but	CC
18637	2530	18	may	may	MD
18637	2530	19	,	,	,
18637	2530	20	in	in	IN
18637	2530	21	anticipation	anticipation	NN
18637	2530	22	,	,	,
18637	2530	23	fix	fix	VB
18637	2530	24	what	what	WP
18637	2530	25	the	the	DT
18637	2530	26	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	2530	27	deems	deem	VBZ
18637	2530	28	to	to	TO
18637	2530	29	be	be	VB
18637	2530	30	a	a	DT
18637	2530	31	fair	fair	JJ
18637	2530	32	fee	fee	NN
18637	2530	33	for	for	IN
18637	2530	34	the	the	DT
18637	2530	35	expected	expected	JJ
18637	2530	36	service	service	NN
18637	2530	37	,	,	,
18637	2530	38	the	the	DT
18637	2530	39	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	2530	40	being	be	VBG
18637	2530	41	that	that	IN
18637	2530	42	if	if	IN
18637	2530	43	,	,	,
18637	2530	44	in	in	IN
18637	2530	45	practice	practice	NN
18637	2530	46	,	,	,
18637	2530	47	the	the	DT
18637	2530	48	sum	sum	NN
18637	2530	49	charged	charge	VBD
18637	2530	50	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	2530	51	inordinate	inordinate	VBP
18637	2530	52	the	the	DT
18637	2530	53	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2530	54	body	body	NN
18637	2530	55	will	will	MD
18637	2530	56	reduce	reduce	VB
18637	2530	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2530	58	in	in	IN
18637	2530	59	the	the	DT
18637	2530	60	light	light	NN
18637	2530	61	of	of	IN
18637	2530	62	experience	experience	NN
18637	2530	63	.	.	.
18637	2531	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2531	2	757	757	CD
18637	2531	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2531	4	Such	such	PDT
18637	2531	5	a	a	DT
18637	2531	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	2531	7	may	may	MD
18637	2531	8	,	,	,
18637	2531	9	in	in	IN
18637	2531	10	spite	spite	NN
18637	2531	11	of	of	IN
18637	2531	12	the	the	DT
18637	2531	13	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	2531	14	of	of	IN
18637	2531	15	validity	validity	NN
18637	2531	16	,	,	,
18637	2531	17	show	show	VB
18637	2531	18	on	on	IN
18637	2531	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2531	20	face	face	NN
18637	2531	21	that	that	IN
18637	2531	22	some	some	DT
18637	2531	23	part	part	NN
18637	2531	24	of	of	IN
18637	2531	25	the	the	DT
18637	2531	26	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	2531	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	2531	28	to	to	TO
18637	2531	29	be	be	VB
18637	2531	30	used	use	VBN
18637	2531	31	for	for	IN
18637	2531	32	a	a	DT
18637	2531	33	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2531	34	other	other	JJ
18637	2531	35	than	than	IN
18637	2531	36	the	the	DT
18637	2531	37	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	2531	38	one	one	CD
18637	2531	39	of	of	IN
18637	2531	40	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	2531	41	and	and	CC
18637	2531	42	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2531	43	and	and	CC
18637	2531	44	may	may	MD
18637	2531	45	,	,	,
18637	2531	46	for	for	IN
18637	2531	47	that	that	DT
18637	2531	48	reason	reason	NN
18637	2531	49	,	,	,
18637	2531	50	be	be	VB
18637	2531	51	void	void	JJ
18637	2531	52	.	.	.
18637	2532	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2532	2	758	758	CD
18637	2532	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2532	4	And	and	CC
18637	2532	5	a	a	DT
18637	2532	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	2532	7	fair	fair	JJ
18637	2532	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	2532	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2532	10	face	face	NN
18637	2532	11	may	may	MD
18637	2532	12	be	be	VB
18637	2532	13	shown	show	VBN
18637	2532	14	to	to	TO
18637	2532	15	be	be	VB
18637	2532	16	void	void	JJ
18637	2532	17	and	and	CC
18637	2532	18	unenforceable	unenforceable	JJ
18637	2532	19	on	on	IN
18637	2532	20	account	account	NN
18637	2532	21	of	of	IN
18637	2532	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2532	23	actual	actual	JJ
18637	2532	24	operation	operation	NN
18637	2532	25	.	.	.
18637	2533	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2533	2	759	759	CD
18637	2533	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2533	4	If	if	IN
18637	2533	5	the	the	DT
18637	2533	6	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	2533	7	be	be	VB
18637	2533	8	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	2533	9	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	2533	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2533	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	2533	12	bad	bad	JJ
18637	2533	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2533	14	in	in	IN
18637	2533	15	toto	toto	NN
18637	2533	16	_	_	NNP
18637	2533	17	and	and	CC
18637	2533	18	the	the	DT
18637	2533	19	State	State	NNP
18637	2533	20	can	can	MD
18637	2533	21	not	not	RB
18637	2533	22	collect	collect	VB
18637	2533	23	any	any	DT
18637	2533	24	part	part	NN
18637	2533	25	of	of	IN
18637	2533	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2533	27	.	.	.
18637	2534	1	"	"	``
18637	2534	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2534	3	760	760	CD
18637	2534	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2534	5	Dominance	dominance	NN
18637	2534	6	of	of	IN
18637	2534	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2534	8	The	the	DT
18637	2534	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2534	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2534	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	2534	12	never	never	RB
18637	2534	13	forgotten	forget	VBN
18637	2534	14	the	the	DT
18637	2534	15	lesson	lesson	NN
18637	2534	16	which	which	WDT
18637	2534	17	was	be	VBD
18637	2534	18	administered	administer	VBN
18637	2534	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2534	20	by	by	IN
18637	2534	21	the	the	DT
18637	2534	22	act	act	NN
18637	2534	23	of	of	IN
18637	2534	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2534	25	of	of	IN
18637	2534	26	August	August	NNP
18637	2534	27	31	31	CD
18637	2534	28	,	,	,
18637	2534	29	1852,[761	1852,[761	CD
18637	2534	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2534	31	which	which	WDT
18637	2534	32	pronounced	pronounce	VBD
18637	2534	33	the	the	DT
18637	2534	34	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	2534	35	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	2534	36	"	"	''
18637	2534	37	a	a	DT
18637	2534	38	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	2534	39	structure	structure	NN
18637	2534	40	,	,	,
18637	2534	41	"	"	''
18637	2534	42	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	2534	43	setting	set	VBG
18637	2534	44	aside	aside	RP
18637	2534	45	the	the	DT
18637	2534	46	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2534	47	's	's	POS
18637	2534	48	determination	determination	NN
18637	2534	49	to	to	IN
18637	2534	50	the	the	DT
18637	2534	51	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	2534	52	earlier	early	RBR
18637	2534	53	the	the	DT
18637	2534	54	same	same	JJ
18637	2534	55	year	year	NN
18637	2534	56	.	.	.
18637	2535	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2535	2	762	762	CD
18637	2535	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2535	4	This	this	DT
18637	2535	5	lesson	lesson	NN
18637	2535	6	,	,	,
18637	2535	7	stated	state	VBN
18637	2535	8	in	in	IN
18637	2535	9	the	the	DT
18637	2535	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2535	11	's	's	POS
18637	2535	12	own	own	JJ
18637	2535	13	language	language	NN
18637	2535	14	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	2535	15	years	year	NNS
18637	2535	16	later	later	RB
18637	2535	17	,	,	,
18637	2535	18	was	be	VBD
18637	2535	19	,	,	,
18637	2535	20	"	"	``
18637	2535	21	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2535	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	2535	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2535	24	,	,	,
18637	2535	25	and	and	CC
18637	2535	26	not	not	RB
18637	2535	27	the	the	DT
18637	2535	28	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	2535	29	Department	Department	NNP
18637	2535	30	,	,	,
18637	2535	31	to	to	TO
18637	2535	32	which	which	WDT
18637	2535	33	the	the	DT
18637	2535	34	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2535	35	has	have	VBZ
18637	2535	36	given	give	VBN
18637	2535	37	the	the	DT
18637	2535	38	power	power	NN
18637	2535	39	to	to	TO
18637	2535	40	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2535	41	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2535	42	*	*	NFP
18637	2535	43	*	*	NFP
18637	2535	44	*	*	NFP
18637	2535	45	.	.	.
18637	2536	1	"	"	``
18637	2536	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2536	3	763	763	CD
18637	2536	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2536	5	A	a	DT
18637	2536	6	parallel	parallel	NN
18637	2536	7	to	to	IN
18637	2536	8	the	the	DT
18637	2536	9	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	2536	10	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	2536	11	episode	episode	NN
18637	2536	12	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	2536	13	in	in	IN
18637	2536	14	1945	1945	CD
18637	2536	15	.	.	.
18637	2537	1	THE	the	DT
18637	2537	2	McCARRAN	McCARRAN	NNP
18637	2537	3	ACT	ACT	NNP
18637	2537	4	:	:	:
18637	2537	5	REGULATION	regulation	NN
18637	2537	6	OF	of	IN
18637	2537	7	INSURANCE	INSURANCE	NNP
18637	2537	8	Less	Less	JJR
18637	2537	9	than	than	IN
18637	2537	10	a	a	DT
18637	2537	11	year	year	NN
18637	2537	12	after	after	IN
18637	2537	13	the	the	DT
18637	2537	14	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	2537	15	in	in	IN
18637	2537	16	United	United	NNP
18637	2537	17	States	States	NNP
18637	2537	18	_	_	NNP
18637	2537	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	2537	20	_	_	NNP
18637	2537	21	South	South	NNP
18637	2537	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	2537	23	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	2537	24	Underwriters	Underwriters	NNPS
18637	2537	25	Association[764	association[764	NN
18637	2537	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2537	27	that	that	IN
18637	2537	28	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	2537	29	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	2537	30	across	across	IN
18637	2537	31	State	State	NNP
18637	2537	32	lines	line	NNS
18637	2537	33	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	2537	34	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2537	35	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2537	36	,	,	,
18637	2537	37	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	2537	38	logically	logically	RB
18637	2537	39	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	2537	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2537	41	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	2537	42	from	from	IN
18637	2537	43	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	2537	44	State	state	NN
18637	2537	45	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2537	46	,	,	,
18637	2537	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2537	48	passed	pass	VBD
18637	2537	49	the	the	DT
18637	2537	50	McCarran	McCarran	NNP
18637	2537	51	Act[765	Act[765	NNP
18637	2537	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2537	53	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	2537	54	State	State	NNP
18637	2537	55	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2537	56	and	and	CC
18637	2537	57	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2537	58	of	of	IN
18637	2537	59	the	the	DT
18637	2537	60	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	2537	61	business	business	NN
18637	2537	62	;	;	:
18637	2537	63	and	and	CC
18637	2537	64	in	in	IN
18637	2537	65	Prudential	Prudential	NNP
18637	2537	66	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	2537	67	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2537	68	_	_	NNP
18637	2537	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	2537	70	_	_	NNP
18637	2537	71	Benjamin,[766	Benjamin,[766	NNP
18637	2537	72	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2537	73	a	a	DT
18637	2537	74	statute	statute	NN
18637	2537	75	of	of	IN
18637	2537	76	South	South	NNP
18637	2537	77	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	2537	78	which	which	WDT
18637	2537	79	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	2537	80	on	on	IN
18637	2537	81	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2537	82	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	2537	83	companies	company	NNS
18637	2537	84	,	,	,
18637	2537	85	as	as	IN
18637	2537	86	a	a	DT
18637	2537	87	condition	condition	NN
18637	2537	88	of	of	IN
18637	2537	89	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2537	90	doing	do	VBG
18637	2537	91	business	business	NN
18637	2537	92	in	in	IN
18637	2537	93	the	the	DT
18637	2537	94	State	State	NNP
18637	2537	95	,	,	,
18637	2537	96	an	an	DT
18637	2537	97	annual	annual	JJ
18637	2537	98	tax	tax	NN
18637	2537	99	of	of	IN
18637	2537	100	three	three	CD
18637	2537	101	per	per	IN
18637	2537	102	cent	cent	NN
18637	2537	103	of	of	IN
18637	2537	104	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	2537	105	from	from	IN
18637	2537	106	business	business	NN
18637	2537	107	done	do	VBN
18637	2537	108	in	in	IN
18637	2537	109	South	South	NNP
18637	2537	110	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	2537	111	,	,	,
18637	2537	112	while	while	IN
18637	2537	113	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	2537	114	no	no	DT
18637	2537	115	similar	similar	JJ
18637	2537	116	tax	tax	NN
18637	2537	117	on	on	IN
18637	2537	118	local	local	JJ
18637	2537	119	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2537	120	,	,	,
18637	2537	121	was	be	VBD
18637	2537	122	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2537	123	.	.	.
18637	2538	1	"	"	``
18637	2538	2	Obviously	obviously	RB
18637	2538	3	,	,	,
18637	2538	4	"	"	''
18637	2538	5	said	say	VBD
18637	2538	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2538	7	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	2538	8	for	for	IN
18637	2538	9	the	the	DT
18637	2538	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2538	11	,	,	,
18637	2538	12	"	"	``
18637	2538	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2538	14	'	'	POS
18637	2538	15	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2538	16	was	be	VBD
18637	2538	17	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	2538	18	to	to	TO
18637	2538	19	give	give	VB
18637	2538	20	support	support	NN
18637	2538	21	to	to	IN
18637	2538	22	the	the	DT
18637	2538	23	existing	exist	VBG
18637	2538	24	and	and	CC
18637	2538	25	future	future	JJ
18637	2538	26	State	State	NNP
18637	2538	27	systems	system	NNS
18637	2538	28	for	for	IN
18637	2538	29	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	2538	30	and	and	CC
18637	2538	31	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2538	32	the	the	DT
18637	2538	33	business	business	NN
18637	2538	34	of	of	IN
18637	2538	35	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	2538	36	.	.	.
18637	2539	1	This	this	DT
18637	2539	2	was	be	VBD
18637	2539	3	done	do	VBN
18637	2539	4	in	in	IN
18637	2539	5	two	two	CD
18637	2539	6	ways	way	NNS
18637	2539	7	.	.	.
18637	2540	1	One	one	CD
18637	2540	2	was	be	VBD
18637	2540	3	by	by	IN
18637	2540	4	removing	remove	VBG
18637	2540	5	obstructions	obstruction	NNS
18637	2540	6	which	which	WDT
18637	2540	7	might	may	MD
18637	2540	8	be	be	VB
18637	2540	9	thought	think	VBN
18637	2540	10	to	to	TO
18637	2540	11	flow	flow	VB
18637	2540	12	from	from	IN
18637	2540	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2540	14	own	own	JJ
18637	2540	15	power	power	NN
18637	2540	16	,	,	,
18637	2540	17	whether	whether	IN
18637	2540	18	dormant	dormant	JJ
18637	2540	19	or	or	CC
18637	2540	20	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	2540	21	,	,	,
18637	2540	22	except	except	IN
18637	2540	23	as	as	IN
18637	2540	24	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2540	25	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	2540	26	provided	provide	VBN
18637	2540	27	in	in	IN
18637	2540	28	the	the	DT
18637	2540	29	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2540	30	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2540	31	or	or	CC
18637	2540	32	in	in	IN
18637	2540	33	future	future	JJ
18637	2540	34	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2540	35	.	.	.
18637	2541	1	The	the	DT
18637	2541	2	other	other	JJ
18637	2541	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2541	4	by	by	IN
18637	2541	5	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	2541	6	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	2541	7	and	and	CC
18637	2541	8	affirmatively	affirmatively	RB
18637	2541	9	that	that	IN
18637	2541	10	continued	continue	VBN
18637	2541	11	State	State	NNP
18637	2541	12	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2541	13	and	and	CC
18637	2541	14	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2541	15	of	of	IN
18637	2541	16	this	this	DT
18637	2541	17	business	business	NN
18637	2541	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	2541	19	in	in	IN
18637	2541	20	the	the	DT
18637	2541	21	public	public	JJ
18637	2541	22	interest	interest	NN
18637	2541	23	and	and	CC
18637	2541	24	that	that	IN
18637	2541	25	the	the	DT
18637	2541	26	business	business	NN
18637	2541	27	and	and	CC
18637	2541	28	all	all	DT
18637	2541	29	who	who	WP
18637	2541	30	engage	engage	VBP
18637	2541	31	in	in	IN
18637	2541	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2541	33	'	'	''
18637	2541	34	shall	shall	MD
18637	2541	35	be	be	VB
18637	2541	36	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2541	37	to	to	IN
18637	2541	38	'	'	''
18637	2541	39	the	the	DT
18637	2541	40	laws	law	NNS
18637	2541	41	of	of	IN
18637	2541	42	the	the	DT
18637	2541	43	several	several	JJ
18637	2541	44	States	state	NNS
18637	2541	45	in	in	IN
18637	2541	46	these	these	DT
18637	2541	47	respects	respect	NNS
18637	2541	48	.	.	.
18637	2542	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2542	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2542	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2542	4	The	the	DT
18637	2542	5	power	power	NN
18637	2542	6	of	of	IN
18637	2542	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2542	8	over	over	IN
18637	2542	9	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2542	10	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	2542	11	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	2542	12	without	without	IN
18637	2542	13	reference	reference	NN
18637	2542	14	to	to	IN
18637	2542	15	coordinated	coordinated	JJ
18637	2542	16	action	action	NN
18637	2542	17	of	of	IN
18637	2542	18	the	the	DT
18637	2542	19	States	States	NNP
18637	2542	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	2542	21	not	not	RB
18637	2542	22	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	2542	23	,	,	,
18637	2542	24	except	except	IN
18637	2542	25	as	as	IN
18637	2542	26	the	the	DT
18637	2542	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2542	28	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	2542	29	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	2542	30	,	,	,
18637	2542	31	by	by	IN
18637	2542	32	any	any	DT
18637	2542	33	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	2542	34	which	which	WDT
18637	2542	35	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	2542	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2542	37	to	to	TO
18637	2542	38	discriminate	discriminate	VB
18637	2542	39	against	against	IN
18637	2542	40	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2542	41	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2542	42	and	and	CC
18637	2542	43	in	in	IN
18637	2542	44	favor	favor	NN
18637	2542	45	of	of	IN
18637	2542	46	local	local	JJ
18637	2542	47	trade	trade	NN
18637	2542	48	.	.	.
18637	2543	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2543	2	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	2543	3	scope	scope	NN
18637	2543	4	enables	enable	VBZ
18637	2543	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2543	6	not	not	RB
18637	2543	7	only	only	RB
18637	2543	8	to	to	TO
18637	2543	9	promote	promote	VB
18637	2543	10	but	but	CC
18637	2543	11	also	also	RB
18637	2543	12	to	to	TO
18637	2543	13	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2543	14	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2543	15	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2543	16	,	,	,
18637	2543	17	as	as	IN
18637	2543	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2543	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	2543	20	done	do	VBN
18637	2543	21	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	2543	22	and	and	CC
18637	2543	23	for	for	IN
18637	2543	24	a	a	DT
18637	2543	25	great	great	JJ
18637	2543	26	variety	variety	NN
18637	2543	27	of	of	IN
18637	2543	28	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	2543	29	.	.	.
18637	2544	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2544	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2544	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2544	4	This	this	DT
18637	2544	5	broad	broad	JJ
18637	2544	6	authority	authority	NN
18637	2544	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2544	8	may	may	MD
18637	2544	9	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	2544	10	alone	alone	RB
18637	2544	11	,	,	,
18637	2544	12	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2544	13	to	to	IN
18637	2544	14	those	those	DT
18637	2544	15	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	2544	16	,	,	,
18637	2544	17	or	or	CC
18637	2544	18	in	in	IN
18637	2544	19	conjunction	conjunction	NN
18637	2544	20	with	with	IN
18637	2544	21	coordinated	coordinated	JJ
18637	2544	22	action	action	NN
18637	2544	23	by	by	IN
18637	2544	24	the	the	DT
18637	2544	25	States	States	NNP
18637	2544	26	,	,	,
18637	2544	27	in	in	IN
18637	2544	28	which	which	WDT
18637	2544	29	case	case	NN
18637	2544	30	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	2544	31	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2544	32	for	for	IN
18637	2544	33	the	the	DT
18637	2544	34	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	2544	35	of	of	IN
18637	2544	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2544	37	powers	power	NNS
18637	2544	38	become	become	VBP
18637	2544	39	inoperative	inoperative	JJ
18637	2544	40	and	and	CC
18637	2544	41	only	only	RB
18637	2544	42	those	those	DT
18637	2544	43	designed	design	VBN
18637	2544	44	to	to	TO
18637	2544	45	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	2544	46	action	action	NN
18637	2544	47	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	2544	48	by	by	IN
18637	2544	49	any	any	DT
18637	2544	50	power	power	NN
18637	2544	51	or	or	CC
18637	2544	52	combination	combination	NN
18637	2544	53	of	of	IN
18637	2544	54	powers	power	NNS
18637	2544	55	in	in	IN
18637	2544	56	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2544	57	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	2544	58	system	system	NN
18637	2544	59	remain	remain	VBP
18637	2544	60	effective	effective	JJ
18637	2544	61	.	.	.
18637	2545	1	"	"	``
18637	2545	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2545	3	767	767	CD
18637	2545	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2545	5	The	the	DT
18637	2545	6	generality	generality	NN
18637	2545	7	of	of	IN
18637	2545	8	this	this	DT
18637	2545	9	language	language	NN
18637	2545	10	enforces	enforce	VBZ
18637	2545	11	again	again	RB
18637	2545	12	the	the	DT
18637	2545	13	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	2545	14	nature	nature	NN
18637	2545	15	of	of	IN
18637	2545	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2545	17	's	's	POS
18637	2545	18	power	power	NN
18637	2545	19	to	to	TO
18637	2545	20	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2545	21	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2545	22	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2545	23	.	.	.
18637	2546	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2546	2	768	768	CD
18637	2546	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2546	4	The	the	DT
18637	2546	5	Police	Police	NNP
18637	2546	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	2546	7	and	and	CC
18637	2546	8	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	2546	9	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2546	10	ORIGIN	ORIGIN	VBZ
18637	2546	11	OF	of	IN
18637	2546	12	POLICE	police	NN
18637	2546	13	POWER	POWER	NNP
18637	2546	14	In	in	IN
18637	2546	15	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	2546	16	_	_	NNP
18637	2546	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	2546	18	_	_	NNP
18637	2546	19	Ogden[769	Ogden[769	NNP
18637	2546	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2546	21	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	2546	22	was	be	VBD
18637	2546	23	taken	take	VBN
18637	2546	24	of	of	IN
18637	2546	25	the	the	DT
18637	2546	26	existence	existence	NN
18637	2546	27	in	in	IN
18637	2546	28	the	the	DT
18637	2546	29	States	States	NNP
18637	2546	30	of	of	IN
18637	2546	31	an	an	DT
18637	2546	32	"	"	``
18637	2546	33	immense	immense	JJ
18637	2546	34	mass	mass	NN
18637	2546	35	"	"	''
18637	2546	36	of	of	IN
18637	2546	37	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2546	38	power	power	NN
18637	2546	39	to	to	TO
18637	2546	40	be	be	VB
18637	2546	41	used	use	VBN
18637	2546	42	for	for	IN
18637	2546	43	the	the	DT
18637	2546	44	protection	protection	NN
18637	2546	45	of	of	IN
18637	2546	46	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2546	47	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	2546	48	and	and	CC
18637	2546	49	the	the	DT
18637	2546	50	promotion	promotion	NN
18637	2546	51	of	of	IN
18637	2546	52	local	local	JJ
18637	2546	53	interests	interest	NNS
18637	2546	54	.	.	.
18637	2547	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2547	2	770	770	CD
18637	2547	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2547	4	In	in	IN
18637	2547	5	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2547	6	's	's	POS
18637	2547	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2547	8	in	in	IN
18637	2547	9	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	2547	10	_	_	NNP
18637	2547	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	2547	12	_	_	NNP
18637	2547	13	Maryland[771	Maryland[771	NNP
18637	2547	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2547	15	this	this	DT
18637	2547	16	power	power	NN
18637	2547	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	2547	18	christened	christen	VBN
18637	2547	19	"	"	``
18637	2547	20	the	the	DT
18637	2547	21	Police	Police	NNP
18637	2547	22	Power	Power	NNP
18637	2547	23	,	,	,
18637	2547	24	"	"	''
18637	2547	25	a	a	DT
18637	2547	26	name	name	NN
18637	2547	27	which	which	WDT
18637	2547	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	2547	29	since	since	IN
18637	2547	30	come	come	VBN
18637	2547	31	to	to	TO
18637	2547	32	supply	supply	VB
18637	2547	33	one	one	CD
18637	2547	34	of	of	IN
18637	2547	35	the	the	DT
18637	2547	36	great	great	JJ
18637	2547	37	titles	title	NNS
18637	2547	38	of	of	IN
18637	2547	39	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	2547	40	Law	Law	NNP
18637	2547	41	.	.	.
18637	2548	1	Counsel	Counsel	NNP
18637	2548	2	for	for	IN
18637	2548	3	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	2548	4	had	have	VBD
18637	2548	5	argued	argue	VBN
18637	2548	6	that	that	IN
18637	2548	7	if	if	IN
18637	2548	8	the	the	DT
18637	2548	9	State	State	NNP
18637	2548	10	was	be	VBD
18637	2548	11	not	not	RB
18637	2548	12	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	2548	13	to	to	IN
18637	2548	14	_	_	NNP
18637	2548	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	2548	16	_	_	NNP
18637	2548	17	imports	import	NNS
18637	2548	18	in	in	IN
18637	2548	19	the	the	DT
18637	2548	20	original	original	JJ
18637	2548	21	package	package	NN
18637	2548	22	before	before	IN
18637	2548	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2548	24	left	leave	VBD
18637	2548	25	the	the	DT
18637	2548	26	hands	hand	NNS
18637	2548	27	of	of	IN
18637	2548	28	the	the	DT
18637	2548	29	importer	importer	NN
18637	2548	30	,	,	,
18637	2548	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2548	32	would	would	MD
18637	2548	33	also	also	RB
18637	2548	34	be	be	VB
18637	2548	35	unable	unable	JJ
18637	2548	36	to	to	TO
18637	2548	37	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2548	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2548	39	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	2548	40	into	into	IN
18637	2548	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2548	42	midst	midst	NN
18637	2548	43	although	although	IN
18637	2548	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2548	45	might	may	MD
18637	2548	46	comprise	comprise	VB
18637	2548	47	articles	article	NNS
18637	2548	48	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	2548	49	to	to	IN
18637	2548	50	the	the	DT
18637	2548	51	public	public	JJ
18637	2548	52	health	health	NN
18637	2548	53	and	and	CC
18637	2548	54	safety	safety	NN
18637	2548	55	.	.	.
18637	2549	1	"	"	``
18637	2549	2	The	the	DT
18637	2549	3	power	power	NN
18637	2549	4	to	to	TO
18637	2549	5	direct	direct	VB
18637	2549	6	the	the	DT
18637	2549	7	removal	removal	NN
18637	2549	8	of	of	IN
18637	2549	9	gunpowder	gunpowder	NN
18637	2549	10	,	,	,
18637	2549	11	"	"	''
18637	2549	12	the	the	DT
18637	2549	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2549	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2549	15	answered	answer	VBD
18637	2549	16	,	,	,
18637	2549	17	"	"	``
18637	2549	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	2549	19	a	a	DT
18637	2549	20	branch	branch	NN
18637	2549	21	of	of	IN
18637	2549	22	the	the	DT
18637	2549	23	police	police	NN
18637	2549	24	power	power	NN
18637	2549	25	,	,	,
18637	2549	26	which	which	WDT
18637	2549	27	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
18637	2549	28	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	2549	29	,	,	,
18637	2549	30	and	and	CC
18637	2549	31	ought	ought	MD
18637	2549	32	to	to	TO
18637	2549	33	remain	remain	VB
18637	2549	34	,	,	,
18637	2549	35	with	with	IN
18637	2549	36	the	the	DT
18637	2549	37	States	States	NNPS
18637	2549	38	;	;	:
18637	2549	39	"	"	''
18637	2549	40	and	and	CC
18637	2549	41	the	the	DT
18637	2549	42	power	power	NN
18637	2549	43	to	to	TO
18637	2549	44	direct	direct	VB
18637	2549	45	"	"	``
18637	2549	46	the	the	DT
18637	2549	47	removal	removal	NN
18637	2549	48	or	or	CC
18637	2549	49	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	2549	50	of	of	IN
18637	2549	51	infectious	infectious	JJ
18637	2549	52	or	or	CC
18637	2549	53	unsound	unsound	JJ
18637	2549	54	articles	article	NNS
18637	2549	55	"	"	''
18637	2549	56	fell	fall	VBD
18637	2549	57	within	within	IN
18637	2549	58	the	the	DT
18637	2549	59	same	same	JJ
18637	2549	60	category	category	NN
18637	2549	61	.	.	.
18637	2550	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2550	2	772	772	CD
18637	2550	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2550	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2550	5	CURBS	curbs	NN
18637	2550	6	ON	on	IN
18637	2550	7	ENTRY	ENTRY	NNP
18637	2550	8	OF	of	IN
18637	2550	9	FOREIGNERS	foreigner	NNS
18637	2550	10	In	in	IN
18637	2550	11	short	short	JJ
18637	2550	12	,	,	,
18637	2550	13	the	the	DT
18637	2550	14	power	power	NN
18637	2550	15	to	to	IN
18637	2550	16	tax	tax	NN
18637	2550	17	was	be	VBD
18637	2550	18	one	one	CD
18637	2550	19	thing	thing	NN
18637	2550	20	,	,	,
18637	2550	21	the	the	DT
18637	2550	22	police	police	NN
18637	2550	23	power	power	NN
18637	2550	24	something	something	NN
18637	2550	25	quite	quite	RB
18637	2550	26	different	different	JJ
18637	2550	27	.	.	.
18637	2551	1	To	to	TO
18637	2551	2	concede	concede	VB
18637	2551	3	the	the	DT
18637	2551	4	former	former	JJ
18637	2551	5	would	would	MD
18637	2551	6	be	be	VB
18637	2551	7	to	to	TO
18637	2551	8	concede	concede	VB
18637	2551	9	a	a	DT
18637	2551	10	power	power	NN
18637	2551	11	which	which	WDT
18637	2551	12	could	could	MD
18637	2551	13	be	be	VB
18637	2551	14	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	2551	15	to	to	IN
18637	2551	16	any	any	DT
18637	2551	17	extent	extent	NN
18637	2551	18	and	and	CC
18637	2551	19	at	at	IN
18637	2551	20	the	the	DT
18637	2551	21	will	will	NN
18637	2551	22	of	of	IN
18637	2551	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2551	24	possessor;[773	possessor;[773	NNS
18637	2551	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2551	26	to	to	TO
18637	2551	27	concede	concede	VB
18637	2551	28	the	the	DT
18637	2551	29	latter	latter	NN
18637	2551	30	was	be	VBD
18637	2551	31	to	to	TO
18637	2551	32	concede	concede	VB
18637	2551	33	a	a	DT
18637	2551	34	power	power	NN
18637	2551	35	which	which	WDT
18637	2551	36	was	be	VBD
18637	2551	37	limited	limit	VBN
18637	2551	38	of	of	IN
18637	2551	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2551	40	own	own	JJ
18637	2551	41	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	2551	42	nature	nature	NN
18637	2551	43	to	to	IN
18637	2551	44	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2551	45	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2551	46	objectives	objective	NNS
18637	2551	47	.	.	.
18637	2552	1	In	in	IN
18637	2552	2	New	New	NNP
18637	2552	3	York	York	NNP
18637	2552	4	_	_	NNP
18637	2552	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	2552	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2552	7	Miln,[774	Miln,[774	NNP
18637	2552	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2552	9	however	however	RB
18637	2552	10	,	,	,
18637	2552	11	the	the	DT
18637	2552	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2552	13	which	which	WDT
18637	2552	14	came	come	VBD
18637	2552	15	after	after	IN
18637	2552	16	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2552	17	inclined	incline	VBD
18637	2552	18	toward	toward	IN
18637	2552	19	the	the	DT
18637	2552	20	notion	notion	NN
18637	2552	21	of	of	IN
18637	2552	22	a	a	DT
18637	2552	23	power	power	NN
18637	2552	24	of	of	IN
18637	2552	25	internal	internal	JJ
18637	2552	26	police	police	NNS
18637	2552	27	which	which	WDT
18637	2552	28	was	be	VBD
18637	2552	29	also	also	RB
18637	2552	30	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	2552	31	;	;	:
18637	2552	32	and	and	CC
18637	2552	33	on	on	IN
18637	2552	34	this	this	DT
18637	2552	35	ground	ground	NN
18637	2552	36	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	2552	37	a	a	DT
18637	2552	38	New	New	NNP
18637	2552	39	York	York	NNP
18637	2552	40	statute	statute	NN
18637	2552	41	which	which	WDT
18637	2552	42	required	require	VBD
18637	2552	43	masters	master	NNS
18637	2552	44	of	of	IN
18637	2552	45	all	all	DT
18637	2552	46	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2552	47	arriving	arrive	VBG
18637	2552	48	at	at	IN
18637	2552	49	the	the	DT
18637	2552	50	port	port	NN
18637	2552	51	of	of	IN
18637	2552	52	New	New	NNP
18637	2552	53	York	York	NNP
18637	2552	54	to	to	TO
18637	2552	55	make	make	VB
18637	2552	56	reports	report	NNS
18637	2552	57	as	as	IN
18637	2552	58	to	to	IN
18637	2552	59	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	2552	60	carried	carry	VBD
18637	2552	61	,	,	,
18637	2552	62	and	and	CC
18637	2552	63	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	2552	64	fines	fine	NNS
18637	2552	65	for	for	IN
18637	2552	66	failure	failure	NN
18637	2552	67	to	to	TO
18637	2552	68	do	do	VB
18637	2552	69	so	so	RB
18637	2552	70	.	.	.
18637	2553	1	"	"	``
18637	2553	2	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2553	3	are	be	VBP
18637	2553	4	of	of	IN
18637	2553	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2553	6	,	,	,
18637	2553	7	"	"	''
18637	2553	8	the	the	DT
18637	2553	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2553	10	said	say	VBD
18637	2553	11	,	,	,
18637	2553	12	"	"	``
18637	2553	13	that	that	IN
18637	2553	14	the	the	DT
18637	2553	15	act	act	NN
18637	2553	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	2553	17	not	not	RB
18637	2553	18	a	a	DT
18637	2553	19	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2553	20	of	of	IN
18637	2553	21	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2553	22	,	,	,
18637	2553	23	but	but	CC
18637	2553	24	of	of	IN
18637	2553	25	police	police	NNS
18637	2553	26	.	.	.
18637	2553	27	"	"	''
18637	2554	1	But	but	CC
18637	2554	2	,	,	,
18637	2554	3	when	when	WRB
18637	2554	4	New	New	NNP
18637	2554	5	York	York	NNP
18637	2554	6	,	,	,
18637	2554	7	venturing	venture	VBG
18637	2554	8	a	a	DT
18637	2554	9	step	step	NN
18637	2554	10	further	far	RBR
18637	2554	11	,	,	,
18637	2554	12	passed	pass	VBD
18637	2554	13	an	an	DT
18637	2554	14	act	act	NN
18637	2554	15	to	to	TO
18637	2554	16	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	2554	17	State	State	NNP
18637	2554	18	health	health	NN
18637	2554	19	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	2554	20	to	to	TO
18637	2554	21	collect	collect	VB
18637	2554	22	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2554	23	fees	fee	NNS
18637	2554	24	from	from	IN
18637	2554	25	captains	captain	NNS
18637	2554	26	arriving	arrive	VBG
18637	2554	27	in	in	IN
18637	2554	28	ports	port	NNS
18637	2554	29	of	of	IN
18637	2554	30	that	that	DT
18637	2554	31	State	State	NNP
18637	2554	32	,	,	,
18637	2554	33	and	and	CC
18637	2554	34	when	when	WRB
18637	2554	35	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	2554	36	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	2554	37	a	a	DT
18637	2554	38	statute	statute	NN
18637	2554	39	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2554	40	captains	captain	NNS
18637	2554	41	of	of	IN
18637	2554	42	ships	ship	NNS
18637	2554	43	to	to	TO
18637	2554	44	give	give	VB
18637	2554	45	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	2554	46	as	as	IN
18637	2554	47	to	to	IN
18637	2554	48	immigrants	immigrant	NNS
18637	2554	49	landed	land	VBD
18637	2554	50	,	,	,
18637	2554	51	both	both	DT
18637	2554	52	measures	measure	NNS
18637	2554	53	were	be	VBD
18637	2554	54	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
18637	2554	55	void	void	JJ
18637	2554	56	,	,	,
18637	2554	57	either	either	CC
18637	2554	58	as	as	IN
18637	2554	59	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	2554	60	with	with	IN
18637	2554	61	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	2554	62	and	and	CC
18637	2554	63	laws	law	NNS
18637	2554	64	of	of	IN
18637	2554	65	the	the	DT
18637	2554	66	United	United	NNP
18637	2554	67	States	States	NNP
18637	2554	68	or	or	CC
18637	2554	69	as	as	IN
18637	2554	70	invading	invade	VBG
18637	2554	71	the	the	DT
18637	2554	72	"	"	``
18637	2554	73	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	2554	74	"	"	''
18637	2554	75	power	power	NN
18637	2554	76	of	of	IN
18637	2554	77	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2554	78	to	to	TO
18637	2554	79	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2554	80	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2554	81	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2554	82	.	.	.
18637	2555	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2555	2	775	775	CD
18637	2555	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2555	4	Following	follow	VBG
18637	2555	5	the	the	DT
18637	2555	6	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	2555	7	War	War	NNP
18637	2555	8	,	,	,
18637	2555	9	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	2555	10	,	,	,
18637	2555	11	New	New	NNP
18637	2555	12	York	York	NNP
18637	2555	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2555	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	2555	15	_	_	NNP
18637	2555	16	Miln	Miln	NNP
18637	2555	17	was	be	VBD
18637	2555	18	flatly	flatly	RB
18637	2555	19	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	2555	20	,	,	,
18637	2555	21	and	and	CC
18637	2555	22	a	a	DT
18637	2555	23	New	New	NNP
18637	2555	24	York	York	NNP
18637	2555	25	statute	statute	NN
18637	2555	26	similar	similar	JJ
18637	2555	27	to	to	IN
18637	2555	28	the	the	DT
18637	2555	29	one	one	NN
18637	2555	30	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2555	31	in	in	IN
18637	2555	32	1837	1837	CD
18637	2555	33	was	be	VBD
18637	2555	34	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
18637	2555	35	void	void	JJ
18637	2555	36	as	as	IN
18637	2555	37	intruding	intrude	VBG
18637	2555	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	2555	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2555	40	's	's	POS
18637	2555	41	powers	power	NNS
18637	2555	42	.	.	.
18637	2556	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2556	2	776	776	CD
18637	2556	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2556	4	Nothing	nothing	NN
18637	2556	5	was	be	VBD
18637	2556	6	gained	gain	VBN
18637	2556	7	,	,	,
18637	2556	8	said	say	VBD
18637	2556	9	the	the	DT
18637	2556	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2556	11	,	,	,
18637	2556	12	by	by	IN
18637	2556	13	invoking	invoke	VBG
18637	2556	14	"	"	''
18637	2556	15	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2556	16	the	the	DT
18637	2556	17	police	police	NN
18637	2556	18	power	power	NN
18637	2556	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2556	20	*	*	NFP
18637	2556	21	*	*	NFP
18637	2556	22	*	*	NFP
18637	2556	23	,	,	,
18637	2556	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2556	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	2556	26	clear	clear	JJ
18637	2556	27	,	,	,
18637	2556	28	from	from	IN
18637	2556	29	the	the	DT
18637	2556	30	nature	nature	NN
18637	2556	31	of	of	IN
18637	2556	32	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2556	33	complex	complex	JJ
18637	2556	34	form	form	NN
18637	2556	35	of	of	IN
18637	2556	36	government	government	NN
18637	2556	37	,	,	,
18637	2556	38	that	that	IN
18637	2556	39	,	,	,
18637	2556	40	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	2556	41	the	the	DT
18637	2556	42	statute	statute	NN
18637	2556	43	of	of	IN
18637	2556	44	a	a	DT
18637	2556	45	State	State	NNP
18637	2556	46	invades	invade	VBZ
18637	2556	47	the	the	DT
18637	2556	48	domain	domain	NN
18637	2556	49	of	of	IN
18637	2556	50	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2556	51	which	which	WDT
18637	2556	52	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	2556	53	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	2556	54	to	to	IN
18637	2556	55	the	the	DT
18637	2556	56	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2556	57	of	of	IN
18637	2556	58	the	the	DT
18637	2556	59	United	United	NNP
18637	2556	60	States	States	NNP
18637	2556	61	,	,	,
18637	2556	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2556	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	2556	64	void	void	JJ
18637	2556	65	,	,	,
18637	2556	66	no	no	RB
18637	2556	67	matter	matter	RB
18637	2556	68	under	under	IN
18637	2556	69	what	what	WDT
18637	2556	70	class	class	NN
18637	2556	71	of	of	IN
18637	2556	72	powers	power	NNS
18637	2556	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2556	74	may	may	MD
18637	2556	75	fall	fall	VB
18637	2556	76	,	,	,
18637	2556	77	or	or	CC
18637	2556	78	how	how	WRB
18637	2556	79	closely	closely	RB
18637	2556	80	allied	allied	JJ
18637	2556	81	to	to	IN
18637	2556	82	powers	power	NNS
18637	2556	83	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	2556	84	to	to	TO
18637	2556	85	belong	belong	VB
18637	2556	86	to	to	IN
18637	2556	87	the	the	DT
18637	2556	88	States	States	NNP
18637	2556	89	.	.	.
18637	2557	1	"	"	``
18637	2557	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2557	3	777	777	CD
18637	2557	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2557	5	At	at	IN
18637	2557	6	the	the	DT
18637	2557	7	same	same	JJ
18637	2557	8	time	time	NN
18637	2557	9	a	a	DT
18637	2557	10	California	California	NNP
18637	2557	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	2557	12	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2557	13	a	a	DT
18637	2557	14	bond	bond	NN
18637	2557	15	from	from	IN
18637	2557	16	shipowners	shipowner	NNS
18637	2557	17	as	as	IN
18637	2557	18	a	a	DT
18637	2557	19	condition	condition	NN
18637	2557	20	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	2557	21	to	to	IN
18637	2557	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2557	23	being	be	VBG
18637	2557	24	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	2557	25	to	to	IN
18637	2557	26	land	land	NN
18637	2557	27	persons	person	NNS
18637	2557	28	whom	whom	WP
18637	2557	29	a	a	DT
18637	2557	30	State	state	NN
18637	2557	31	commissioner	commissioner	NN
18637	2557	32	of	of	IN
18637	2557	33	immigration	immigration	NN
18637	2557	34	might	may	MD
18637	2557	35	choose	choose	VB
18637	2557	36	to	to	TO
18637	2557	37	consider	consider	VB
18637	2557	38	as	as	IN
18637	2557	39	coming	come	VBG
18637	2557	40	within	within	IN
18637	2557	41	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2557	42	enumerated	enumerated	JJ
18637	2557	43	classes	class	NNS
18637	2557	44	,	,	,
18637	2557	45	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	2557	46	,	,	,
18637	2557	47	"	"	``
18637	2557	48	debauched	debauched	JJ
18637	2557	49	women	woman	NNS
18637	2557	50	,	,	,
18637	2557	51	"	"	''
18637	2557	52	was	be	VBD
18637	2557	53	also	also	RB
18637	2557	54	disallowed	disallow	VBN
18637	2557	55	.	.	.
18637	2558	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	2558	2	the	the	DT
18637	2558	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2558	4	:	:	:
18637	2558	5	"	"	``
18637	2558	6	If	if	IN
18637	2558	7	the	the	DT
18637	2558	8	right	right	NN
18637	2558	9	of	of	IN
18637	2558	10	the	the	DT
18637	2558	11	States	States	NNPS
18637	2558	12	to	to	TO
18637	2558	13	pass	pass	VB
18637	2558	14	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	2558	15	to	to	TO
18637	2558	16	protect	protect	VB
18637	2558	17	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2558	18	in	in	IN
18637	2558	19	regard	regard	NN
18637	2558	20	to	to	IN
18637	2558	21	the	the	DT
18637	2558	22	criminal	criminal	NN
18637	2558	23	,	,	,
18637	2558	24	the	the	DT
18637	2558	25	pauper	pauper	NN
18637	2558	26	,	,	,
18637	2558	27	and	and	CC
18637	2558	28	the	the	DT
18637	2558	29	diseased	diseased	JJ
18637	2558	30	foreigner	foreigner	NN
18637	2558	31	,	,	,
18637	2558	32	landing	land	VBG
18637	2558	33	within	within	IN
18637	2558	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2558	35	borders	border	NNS
18637	2558	36	,	,	,
18637	2558	37	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	2558	38	at	at	RB
18637	2558	39	all	all	RB
18637	2558	40	,	,	,
18637	2558	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2558	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	2558	43	limited	limit	VBN
18637	2558	44	to	to	IN
18637	2558	45	such	such	JJ
18637	2558	46	laws	law	NNS
18637	2558	47	as	as	IN
18637	2558	48	are	be	VBP
18637	2558	49	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	2558	50	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2558	51	for	for	IN
18637	2558	52	that	that	DT
18637	2558	53	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2558	54	;	;	:
18637	2558	55	and	and	CC
18637	2558	56	this	this	DT
18637	2558	57	mere	mere	JJ
18637	2558	58	police	police	NN
18637	2558	59	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2558	60	can	can	MD
18637	2558	61	not	not	RB
18637	2558	62	extend	extend	VB
18637	2558	63	so	so	RB
18637	2558	64	far	far	RB
18637	2558	65	as	as	IN
18637	2558	66	to	to	TO
18637	2558	67	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2558	68	or	or	CC
18637	2558	69	obstruct	obstruct	VB
18637	2558	70	other	other	JJ
18637	2558	71	classes	class	NNS
18637	2558	72	of	of	IN
18637	2558	73	persons	person	NNS
18637	2558	74	from	from	IN
18637	2558	75	the	the	DT
18637	2558	76	right	right	NN
18637	2558	77	to	to	TO
18637	2558	78	hold	hold	VB
18637	2558	79	personal	personal	JJ
18637	2558	80	and	and	CC
18637	2558	81	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	2558	82	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	2558	83	with	with	IN
18637	2558	84	the	the	DT
18637	2558	85	people	people	NNS
18637	2558	86	of	of	IN
18637	2558	87	the	the	DT
18637	2558	88	United	United	NNP
18637	2558	89	States	States	NNP
18637	2558	90	.	.	.
18637	2559	1	"	"	``
18637	2559	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2559	3	778	778	CD
18637	2559	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2559	5	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2559	6	QUARANTINE	QUARANTINE	NNP
18637	2559	7	LAWS	LAWS	NNP
18637	2559	8	On	on	IN
18637	2559	9	the	the	DT
18637	2559	10	other	other	JJ
18637	2559	11	hand	hand	NN
18637	2559	12	,	,	,
18637	2559	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2559	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	2559	15	been	be	VBN
18637	2559	16	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	2559	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	2559	18	that	that	IN
18637	2559	19	the	the	DT
18637	2559	20	States	States	NNP
18637	2559	21	may	may	MD
18637	2559	22	,	,	,
18637	2559	23	in	in	IN
18637	2559	24	the	the	DT
18637	2559	25	absence	absence	NN
18637	2559	26	of	of	IN
18637	2559	27	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2559	28	by	by	IN
18637	2559	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2559	30	,	,	,
18637	2559	31	enact	enact	VB
18637	2559	32	quarantine	quarantine	NN
18637	2559	33	laws	law	NNS
18637	2559	34	,	,	,
18637	2559	35	even	even	RB
18637	2559	36	though	though	IN
18637	2559	37	in	in	IN
18637	2559	38	effect	effect	NN
18637	2559	39	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2559	40	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	2559	41	regulate	regulate	VBP
18637	2559	42	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2559	43	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2559	44	;	;	:
18637	2559	45	and	and	CC
18637	2559	46	furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	2559	47	that	that	IN
18637	2559	48	such	such	JJ
18637	2559	49	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2559	50	may	may	MD
18637	2559	51	be	be	VB
18637	2559	52	,	,	,
18637	2559	53	in	in	IN
18637	2559	54	the	the	DT
18637	2559	55	interest	interest	NN
18637	2559	56	of	of	IN
18637	2559	57	effective	effective	JJ
18637	2559	58	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	2559	59	,	,	,
18637	2559	60	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2559	61	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	2559	62	the	the	DT
18637	2559	63	mere	mere	JJ
18637	2559	64	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	2559	65	of	of	IN
18637	2559	66	diseased	diseased	JJ
18637	2559	67	persons	person	NNS
18637	2559	68	.	.	.
18637	2560	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2560	2	in	in	IN
18637	2560	3	the	the	DT
18637	2560	4	leading	leading	JJ
18637	2560	5	case	case	NN
18637	2560	6	the	the	DT
18637	2560	7	State	State	NNP
18637	2560	8	of	of	IN
18637	2560	9	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	2560	10	was	be	VBD
18637	2560	11	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2560	12	in	in	IN
18637	2560	13	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	2560	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2560	15	Board	Board	NNP
18637	2560	16	of	of	IN
18637	2560	17	Health	Health	NNP
18637	2560	18	in	in	IN
18637	2560	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2560	20	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	2560	21	to	to	TO
18637	2560	22	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2560	23	the	the	DT
18637	2560	24	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	2560	25	into	into	IN
18637	2560	26	any	any	DT
18637	2560	27	infected	infected	JJ
18637	2560	28	portion	portion	NN
18637	2560	29	of	of	IN
18637	2560	30	the	the	DT
18637	2560	31	State	State	NNP
18637	2560	32	of	of	IN
18637	2560	33	"	"	``
18637	2560	34	persons	person	NNS
18637	2560	35	acclimated	acclimate	VBN
18637	2560	36	,	,	,
18637	2560	37	unacclimated	unacclimated	JJ
18637	2560	38	or	or	CC
18637	2560	39	said	say	VBD
18637	2560	40	to	to	TO
18637	2560	41	be	be	VB
18637	2560	42	immune	immune	JJ
18637	2560	43	,	,	,
18637	2560	44	when	when	WRB
18637	2560	45	in	in	IN
18637	2560	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2560	47	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	2560	48	the	the	DT
18637	2560	49	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	2560	50	of	of	IN
18637	2560	51	such	such	JJ
18637	2560	52	persons	person	NNS
18637	2560	53	would	would	MD
18637	2560	54	add	add	VB
18637	2560	55	to	to	IN
18637	2560	56	or	or	CC
18637	2560	57	increase	increase	VB
18637	2560	58	the	the	DT
18637	2560	59	prevalence	prevalence	NN
18637	2560	60	of	of	IN
18637	2560	61	the	the	DT
18637	2560	62	disease	disease	NN
18637	2560	63	.	.	.
18637	2561	1	"	"	``
18637	2561	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2561	3	779	779	CD
18637	2561	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2561	5	At	at	IN
18637	2561	6	the	the	DT
18637	2561	7	same	same	JJ
18637	2561	8	time	time	NN
18637	2561	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2561	10	was	be	VBD
18637	2561	11	emphasized	emphasize	VBN
18637	2561	12	that	that	IN
18637	2561	13	all	all	DT
18637	2561	14	such	such	JJ
18637	2561	15	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2561	16	was	be	VBD
18637	2561	17	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2561	18	to	to	TO
18637	2561	19	be	be	VB
18637	2561	20	supplanted	supplant	VBN
18637	2561	21	by	by	IN
18637	2561	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2561	23	at	at	IN
18637	2561	24	any	any	DT
18637	2561	25	time	time	NN
18637	2561	26	.	.	.
18637	2562	1	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2562	2	GAME	GAME	NNP
18637	2562	3	PROTECTION	protection	NN
18637	2562	4	AND	and	CC
18637	2562	5	FOREIGN	foreign	JJ
18637	2562	6	COMMERCE	COMMERCE	NNP
18637	2562	7	The	the	DT
18637	2562	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2562	9	's	's	POS
18637	2562	10	tolerance	tolerance	NN
18637	2562	11	of	of	IN
18637	2562	12	legal	legal	JJ
18637	2562	13	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	2562	14	which	which	WDT
18637	2562	15	might	may	MD
18637	2562	16	not	not	RB
18637	2562	17	standing	stand	VBG
18637	2562	18	alone	alone	RB
18637	2562	19	be	be	VB
18637	2562	20	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2562	21	,	,	,
18637	2562	22	when	when	WRB
18637	2562	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2562	24	are	be	VBP
18637	2562	25	designed	design	VBN
18637	2562	26	to	to	TO
18637	2562	27	make	make	VB
18637	2562	28	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2562	29	within	within	IN
18637	2562	30	the	the	DT
18637	2562	31	police	police	NN
18637	2562	32	power	power	NN
18637	2562	33	practically	practically	RB
18637	2562	34	enforceable	enforceable	JJ
18637	2562	35	,	,	,
18637	2562	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	2562	37	also	also	RB
18637	2562	38	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
18637	2562	39	in	in	IN
18637	2562	40	connection	connection	NN
18637	2562	41	with	with	IN
18637	2562	42	State	State	NNP
18637	2562	43	game	game	NN
18637	2562	44	laws	law	NNS
18637	2562	45	.	.	.
18637	2563	1	In	in	IN
18637	2563	2	the	the	DT
18637	2563	3	case	case	NN
18637	2563	4	of	of	IN
18637	2563	5	Silz	Silz	NNP
18637	2563	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2563	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	2563	8	_	_	NNP
18637	2563	9	Hesterberg[780	Hesterberg[780	NNP
18637	2563	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2563	11	the	the	DT
18637	2563	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2563	13	was	be	VBD
18637	2563	14	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	2563	15	with	with	IN
18637	2563	16	a	a	DT
18637	2563	17	New	New	NNP
18637	2563	18	York	York	NNP
18637	2563	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	2563	20	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	2563	21	a	a	DT
18637	2563	22	closed	close	VBN
18637	2563	23	season	season	NN
18637	2563	24	for	for	IN
18637	2563	25	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2563	26	game	game	NN
18637	2563	27	,	,	,
18637	2563	28	during	during	IN
18637	2563	29	which	which	WDT
18637	2563	30	season	season	NN
18637	2563	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2563	32	was	be	VBD
18637	2563	33	a	a	DT
18637	2563	34	penal	penal	JJ
18637	2563	35	offense	offense	NN
18637	2563	36	to	to	TO
18637	2563	37	take	take	VB
18637	2563	38	or	or	CC
18637	2563	39	possess	possess	VB
18637	2563	40	any	any	DT
18637	2563	41	of	of	IN
18637	2563	42	the	the	DT
18637	2563	43	protected	protect	VBN
18637	2563	44	animals	animal	NNS
18637	2563	45	,	,	,
18637	2563	46	fish	fish	NNS
18637	2563	47	or	or	CC
18637	2563	48	birds	bird	NNS
18637	2563	49	;	;	:
18637	2563	50	and	and	CC
18637	2563	51	providing	provide	VBG
18637	2563	52	farther	farther	RB
18637	2563	53	that	that	IN
18637	2563	54	the	the	DT
18637	2563	55	ban	ban	NN
18637	2563	56	should	should	MD
18637	2563	57	equally	equally	RB
18637	2563	58	apply	apply	VB
18637	2563	59	"	"	''
18637	2563	60	to	to	IN
18637	2563	61	such	such	JJ
18637	2563	62	fish	fish	NN
18637	2563	63	,	,	,
18637	2563	64	game	game	NN
18637	2563	65	or	or	CC
18637	2563	66	flesh	flesh	NN
18637	2563	67	coming	come	VBG
18637	2563	68	from	from	IN
18637	2563	69	without	without	IN
18637	2563	70	the	the	DT
18637	2563	71	State	State	NNP
18637	2563	72	as	as	IN
18637	2563	73	to	to	IN
18637	2563	74	that	that	DT
18637	2563	75	taken	take	VBN
18637	2563	76	within	within	IN
18637	2563	77	the	the	DT
18637	2563	78	State	State	NNP
18637	2563	79	.	.	.
18637	2563	80	"	"	''
18637	2564	1	This	this	DT
18637	2564	2	provision	provision	NN
18637	2564	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2564	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	2564	5	to	to	TO
18637	2564	6	have	have	VB
18637	2564	7	been	be	VBN
18637	2564	8	validly	validly	RB
18637	2564	9	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2564	10	in	in	IN
18637	2564	11	the	the	DT
18637	2564	12	case	case	NN
18637	2564	13	of	of	IN
18637	2564	14	a	a	DT
18637	2564	15	dealer	dealer	NN
18637	2564	16	in	in	IN
18637	2564	17	imported	import	VBN
18637	2564	18	game	game	NN
18637	2564	19	who	who	WP
18637	2564	20	had	have	VBD
18637	2564	21	in	in	IN
18637	2564	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2564	23	possession	possession	NN
18637	2564	24	during	during	IN
18637	2564	25	the	the	DT
18637	2564	26	closed	closed	JJ
18637	2564	27	season	season	NN
18637	2564	28	"	"	''
18637	2564	29	one	one	CD
18637	2564	30	dead	dead	JJ
18637	2564	31	body	body	NN
18637	2564	32	of	of	IN
18637	2564	33	an	an	DT
18637	2564	34	imported	import	VBN
18637	2564	35	grouse	grouse	NN
18637	2564	36	,	,	,
18637	2564	37	...	...	:
18637	2564	38	,	,	,
18637	2564	39	and	and	CC
18637	2564	40	taken	take	VBN
18637	2564	41	in	in	IN
18637	2564	42	Russia	Russia	NNP
18637	2564	43	.	.	.
18637	2564	44	"	"	''
18637	2565	1	Again	again	RB
18637	2565	2	the	the	DT
18637	2565	3	absence	absence	NN
18637	2565	4	of	of	IN
18637	2565	5	conflicting	conflicting	JJ
18637	2565	6	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2565	7	by	by	IN
18637	2565	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2565	9	was	be	VBD
18637	2565	10	adverted	advert	VBN
18637	2565	11	to	to	IN
18637	2565	12	.	.	.
18637	2566	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2566	2	781	781	CD
18637	2566	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2566	4	The	the	DT
18637	2566	5	Police	Police	NNP
18637	2566	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	2566	7	and	and	CC
18637	2566	8	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2566	9	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2566	10	GENERAL	GENERAL	VBZ
18637	2566	11	PRINCIPLES	principle	NNS
18637	2566	12	In	in	IN
18637	2566	13	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	2566	14	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	2566	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2566	16	_	_	NNP
18637	2566	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	2566	18	_	_	NNP
18637	2566	19	Arizona,[782	Arizona,[782	NNP
18637	2566	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2566	21	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2566	22	in	in	IN
18637	2566	23	1945	1945	CD
18637	2566	24	,	,	,
18637	2566	25	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2566	26	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2566	27	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	2566	28	made	make	VBD
18637	2566	29	the	the	DT
18637	2566	30	following	follow	VBG
18637	2566	31	systematic	systematic	JJ
18637	2566	32	statement	statement	NN
18637	2566	33	of	of	IN
18637	2566	34	principles	principle	NNS
18637	2566	35	which	which	WDT
18637	2566	36	have	have	VBP
18637	2566	37	guided	guide	VBN
18637	2566	38	the	the	DT
18637	2566	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2566	40	in	in	IN
18637	2566	41	the	the	DT
18637	2566	42	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2566	43	of	of	IN
18637	2566	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2566	45	power	power	NN
18637	2566	46	of	of	IN
18637	2566	47	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	2566	48	review	review	NN
18637	2566	49	of	of	IN
18637	2566	50	State	State	NNP
18637	2566	51	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2566	52	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	2566	53	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2566	54	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2566	55	:	:	:
18637	2566	56	"	"	``
18637	2566	57	Although	although	IN
18637	2566	58	the	the	DT
18637	2566	59	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2566	60	clause	clause	NN
18637	2566	61	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	2566	62	on	on	IN
18637	2566	63	the	the	DT
18637	2566	64	national	national	JJ
18637	2566	65	government	government	NN
18637	2566	66	power	power	NN
18637	2566	67	to	to	TO
18637	2566	68	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2566	69	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2566	70	,	,	,
18637	2566	71	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2566	72	possession	possession	NN
18637	2566	73	of	of	IN
18637	2566	74	the	the	DT
18637	2566	75	power	power	NN
18637	2566	76	does	do	VBZ
18637	2566	77	not	not	RB
18637	2566	78	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	2566	79	all	all	DT
18637	2566	80	state	state	NN
18637	2566	81	power	power	NN
18637	2566	82	of	of	IN
18637	2566	83	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2566	84	.	.	.
18637	2567	1	Ever	ever	RB
18637	2567	2	since	since	IN
18637	2567	3	Willson	Willson	NNP
18637	2567	4	_	_	NNP
18637	2567	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	2567	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2567	7	Black	Black	NNP
18637	2567	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	2567	9	Bird	Bird	NNP
18637	2567	10	Creek	Creek	NNP
18637	2567	11	Marsh	Marsh	NNP
18637	2567	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2567	13	,	,	,
18637	2567	14	2	2	CD
18637	2567	15	Pet	pet	NN
18637	2567	16	.	.	.
18637	2568	1	245	245	CD
18637	2568	2	,	,	,
18637	2568	3	and	and	CC
18637	2568	4	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	2568	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2568	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	2568	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2568	8	Board	Board	NNP
18637	2568	9	of	of	IN
18637	2568	10	Wardens	Wardens	NNP
18637	2568	11	,	,	,
18637	2568	12	12	12	CD
18637	2568	13	How	how	WRB
18637	2568	14	.	.	.
18637	2569	1	299	299	CD
18637	2569	2	,	,	,
18637	2569	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2569	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	2569	5	been	be	VBN
18637	2569	6	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	2569	7	that	that	IN
18637	2569	8	,	,	,
18637	2569	9	in	in	IN
18637	2569	10	the	the	DT
18637	2569	11	absence	absence	NN
18637	2569	12	of	of	IN
18637	2569	13	conflicting	conflicting	JJ
18637	2569	14	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2569	15	by	by	IN
18637	2569	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2569	17	,	,	,
18637	2569	18	there	there	EX
18637	2569	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	2569	20	a	a	DT
18637	2569	21	residuum	residuum	NN
18637	2569	22	of	of	IN
18637	2569	23	power	power	NN
18637	2569	24	in	in	IN
18637	2569	25	the	the	DT
18637	2569	26	state	state	NN
18637	2569	27	to	to	TO
18637	2569	28	make	make	VB
18637	2569	29	laws	law	NNS
18637	2569	30	governing	govern	VBG
18637	2569	31	matters	matter	NNS
18637	2569	32	of	of	IN
18637	2569	33	local	local	JJ
18637	2569	34	concern	concern	NN
18637	2569	35	which	which	WDT
18637	2569	36	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	2569	37	in	in	IN
18637	2569	38	some	some	DT
18637	2569	39	measure	measure	NN
18637	2569	40	affect	affect	VBP
18637	2569	41	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2569	42	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2569	43	or	or	CC
18637	2569	44	even	even	RB
18637	2569	45	,	,	,
18637	2569	46	to	to	IN
18637	2569	47	some	some	DT
18637	2569	48	extent	extent	NN
18637	2569	49	,	,	,
18637	2569	50	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2569	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2569	52	.	.	.
18637	2570	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2570	2	783	783	CD
18637	2570	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2570	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2570	5	the	the	DT
18637	2570	6	states	state	NNS
18637	2570	7	may	may	MD
18637	2570	8	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2570	9	matters	matter	NNS
18637	2570	10	which	which	WDT
18637	2570	11	,	,	,
18637	2570	12	because	because	IN
18637	2570	13	of	of	IN
18637	2570	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2570	15	number	number	NN
18637	2570	16	and	and	CC
18637	2570	17	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	2570	18	,	,	,
18637	2570	19	may	may	MD
18637	2570	20	never	never	RB
18637	2570	21	be	be	VB
18637	2570	22	adequately	adequately	RB
18637	2570	23	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	2570	24	with	with	IN
18637	2570	25	by	by	IN
18637	2570	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2570	27	.	.	.
18637	2571	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2571	2	784	784	CD
18637	2571	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2571	4	When	when	WRB
18637	2571	5	the	the	DT
18637	2571	6	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2571	7	of	of	IN
18637	2571	8	matters	matter	NNS
18637	2571	9	of	of	IN
18637	2571	10	local	local	JJ
18637	2571	11	concern	concern	NN
18637	2571	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	2571	13	local	local	JJ
18637	2571	14	in	in	IN
18637	2571	15	character	character	NN
18637	2571	16	and	and	CC
18637	2571	17	effect	effect	NN
18637	2571	18	,	,	,
18637	2571	19	and	and	CC
18637	2571	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2571	21	impact	impact	NN
18637	2571	22	on	on	IN
18637	2571	23	the	the	DT
18637	2571	24	national	national	NNP
18637	2571	25	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2571	26	does	do	VBZ
18637	2571	27	not	not	RB
18637	2571	28	seriously	seriously	RB
18637	2571	29	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	2571	30	with	with	IN
18637	2571	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2571	32	operation	operation	NN
18637	2571	33	,	,	,
18637	2571	34	and	and	CC
18637	2571	35	the	the	DT
18637	2571	36	consequent	consequent	JJ
18637	2571	37	incentive	incentive	NN
18637	2571	38	to	to	TO
18637	2571	39	deal	deal	VB
18637	2571	40	with	with	IN
18637	2571	41	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2571	42	nationally	nationally	RB
18637	2571	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	2571	44	slight	slight	JJ
18637	2571	45	,	,	,
18637	2571	46	such	such	JJ
18637	2571	47	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2571	48	has	have	VBZ
18637	2571	49	been	be	VBN
18637	2571	50	generally	generally	RB
18637	2571	51	held	hold	VBN
18637	2571	52	to	to	TO
18637	2571	53	be	be	VB
18637	2571	54	within	within	IN
18637	2571	55	state	state	NN
18637	2571	56	authority	authority	NN
18637	2571	57	.	.	.
18637	2572	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2572	2	785	785	CD
18637	2572	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2572	4	"	"	''
18637	2572	5	But	but	CC
18637	2572	6	ever	ever	RB
18637	2572	7	since	since	IN
18637	2572	8	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	2572	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2572	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	2572	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2572	12	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	2572	13	,	,	,
18637	2572	14	9	9	CD
18637	2572	15	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	2572	16	.	.	.
18637	2573	1	1	1	CD
18637	2573	2	,	,	,
18637	2573	3	the	the	DT
18637	2573	4	states	state	NNS
18637	2573	5	have	have	VBP
18637	2573	6	not	not	RB
18637	2573	7	been	be	VBN
18637	2573	8	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	2573	9	to	to	TO
18637	2573	10	have	have	VB
18637	2573	11	authority	authority	NN
18637	2573	12	to	to	TO
18637	2573	13	impede	impede	VB
18637	2573	14	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	2573	15	the	the	DT
18637	2573	16	free	free	JJ
18637	2573	17	flow	flow	NN
18637	2573	18	of	of	IN
18637	2573	19	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2573	20	from	from	IN
18637	2573	21	state	state	NN
18637	2573	22	to	to	IN
18637	2573	23	state	state	NN
18637	2573	24	,	,	,
18637	2573	25	or	or	CC
18637	2573	26	to	to	TO
18637	2573	27	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2573	28	those	those	DT
18637	2573	29	phases	phase	NNS
18637	2573	30	of	of	IN
18637	2573	31	the	the	DT
18637	2573	32	national	national	NNP
18637	2573	33	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2573	34	which	which	WDT
18637	2573	35	,	,	,
18637	2573	36	because	because	IN
18637	2573	37	of	of	IN
18637	2573	38	the	the	DT
18637	2573	39	need	need	NN
18637	2573	40	of	of	IN
18637	2573	41	national	national	JJ
18637	2573	42	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	2573	43	,	,	,
18637	2573	44	demand	demand	VBP
18637	2573	45	that	that	IN
18637	2573	46	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2573	47	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2573	48	,	,	,
18637	2573	49	if	if	IN
18637	2573	50	any	any	DT
18637	2573	51	,	,	,
18637	2573	52	be	be	VB
18637	2573	53	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	2573	54	by	by	IN
18637	2573	55	a	a	DT
18637	2573	56	single	single	JJ
18637	2573	57	authority	authority	NN
18637	2573	58	.	.	.
18637	2574	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2574	2	786	786	CD
18637	2574	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2574	4	Whether	whether	IN
18637	2574	5	or	or	CC
18637	2574	6	not	not	RB
18637	2574	7	this	this	DT
18637	2574	8	long	long	RB
18637	2574	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	2574	10	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	2574	11	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	2574	12	of	of	IN
18637	2574	13	power	power	NN
18637	2574	14	between	between	IN
18637	2574	15	the	the	DT
18637	2574	16	national	national	JJ
18637	2574	17	and	and	CC
18637	2574	18	the	the	DT
18637	2574	19	state	state	NN
18637	2574	20	governments	government	NNS
18637	2574	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	2574	22	predicated	predicate	VBN
18637	2574	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	2574	24	the	the	DT
18637	2574	25	implications	implication	NNS
18637	2574	26	of	of	IN
18637	2574	27	the	the	DT
18637	2574	28	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2574	29	clause	clause	NNP
18637	2574	30	itself,[787	itself,[787	NNP
18637	2574	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2574	32	or	or	CC
18637	2574	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	2574	34	the	the	DT
18637	2574	35	presumed	presumed	JJ
18637	2574	36	intention	intention	NN
18637	2574	37	of	of	IN
18637	2574	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2574	39	,	,	,
18637	2574	40	where	where	WRB
18637	2574	41	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2574	42	has	have	VBZ
18637	2574	43	not	not	RB
18637	2574	44	spoken,[788	spoken,[788	VBN
18637	2574	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2574	46	the	the	DT
18637	2574	47	result	result	NN
18637	2574	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	2574	49	the	the	DT
18637	2574	50	same	same	JJ
18637	2574	51	.	.	.
18637	2575	1	"	"	``
18637	2575	2	In	in	IN
18637	2575	3	the	the	DT
18637	2575	4	application	application	NN
18637	2575	5	of	of	IN
18637	2575	6	these	these	DT
18637	2575	7	principles	principle	NNS
18637	2575	8	some	some	DT
18637	2575	9	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	2575	10	may	may	MD
18637	2575	11	be	be	VB
18637	2575	12	found	find	VBN
18637	2575	13	to	to	TO
18637	2575	14	be	be	VB
18637	2575	15	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	2575	16	within	within	IN
18637	2575	17	and	and	CC
18637	2575	18	others	other	NNS
18637	2575	19	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	2575	20	without	without	IN
18637	2575	21	state	state	NN
18637	2575	22	power	power	NN
18637	2575	23	.	.	.
18637	2576	1	But	but	CC
18637	2576	2	between	between	IN
18637	2576	3	these	these	DT
18637	2576	4	extremes	extreme	NNS
18637	2576	5	lies	lie	VBZ
18637	2576	6	the	the	DT
18637	2576	7	infinite	infinite	JJ
18637	2576	8	variety	variety	NN
18637	2576	9	of	of	IN
18637	2576	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	2576	11	,	,	,
18637	2576	12	in	in	IN
18637	2576	13	which	which	WDT
18637	2576	14	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2576	15	of	of	IN
18637	2576	16	local	local	JJ
18637	2576	17	matters	matter	NNS
18637	2576	18	may	may	MD
18637	2576	19	also	also	RB
18637	2576	20	operate	operate	VB
18637	2576	21	as	as	IN
18637	2576	22	a	a	DT
18637	2576	23	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2576	24	of	of	IN
18637	2576	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2576	26	,	,	,
18637	2576	27	in	in	IN
18637	2576	28	which	which	WDT
18637	2576	29	reconciliation	reconciliation	NN
18637	2576	30	of	of	IN
18637	2576	31	the	the	DT
18637	2576	32	conflicting	conflicting	JJ
18637	2576	33	claims	claim	NNS
18637	2576	34	of	of	IN
18637	2576	35	state	state	NN
18637	2576	36	and	and	CC
18637	2576	37	national	national	JJ
18637	2576	38	power	power	NN
18637	2576	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	2576	40	to	to	TO
18637	2576	41	be	be	VB
18637	2576	42	attained	attain	VBN
18637	2576	43	only	only	RB
18637	2576	44	by	by	IN
18637	2576	45	some	some	DT
18637	2576	46	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	2576	47	and	and	CC
18637	2576	48	accommodation	accommodation	NN
18637	2576	49	of	of	IN
18637	2576	50	the	the	DT
18637	2576	51	competing	compete	VBG
18637	2576	52	demands	demand	NNS
18637	2576	53	of	of	IN
18637	2576	54	the	the	DT
18637	2576	55	state	state	NN
18637	2576	56	and	and	CC
18637	2576	57	national	national	JJ
18637	2576	58	interests	interest	NNS
18637	2576	59	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2576	60	.	.	.
18637	2577	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2577	2	789	789	CD
18637	2577	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2577	4	"	"	``
18637	2577	5	For	for	IN
18637	2577	6	a	a	DT
18637	2577	7	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	2577	8	years	year	NNS
18637	2577	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2577	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	2577	11	been	be	VBN
18637	2577	12	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	2577	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2577	14	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2577	15	that	that	IN
18637	2577	16	the	the	DT
18637	2577	17	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2577	18	clause	clause	NNP
18637	2577	19	,	,	,
18637	2577	20	without	without	IN
18637	2577	21	the	the	DT
18637	2577	22	aid	aid	NN
18637	2577	23	of	of	IN
18637	2577	24	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2577	25	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2577	26	,	,	,
18637	2577	27	thus	thus	RB
18637	2577	28	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	2577	29	some	some	DT
18637	2577	30	protection	protection	NN
18637	2577	31	from	from	IN
18637	2577	32	state	state	NN
18637	2577	33	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2577	34	inimical	inimical	JJ
18637	2577	35	to	to	IN
18637	2577	36	the	the	DT
18637	2577	37	national	national	NNP
18637	2577	38	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2577	39	,	,	,
18637	2577	40	and	and	CC
18637	2577	41	that	that	IN
18637	2577	42	in	in	IN
18637	2577	43	such	such	JJ
18637	2577	44	cases	case	NNS
18637	2577	45	,	,	,
18637	2577	46	where	where	WRB
18637	2577	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2577	48	has	have	VBZ
18637	2577	49	not	not	RB
18637	2577	50	acted	act	VBN
18637	2577	51	,	,	,
18637	2577	52	this	this	DT
18637	2577	53	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2577	54	,	,	,
18637	2577	55	and	and	CC
18637	2577	56	not	not	RB
18637	2577	57	the	the	DT
18637	2577	58	state	state	NN
18637	2577	59	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	2577	60	,	,	,
18637	2577	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	2577	62	under	under	IN
18637	2577	63	the	the	DT
18637	2577	64	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2577	65	clause	clause	NN
18637	2577	66	the	the	DT
18637	2577	67	final	final	JJ
18637	2577	68	arbiter	arbiter	NN
18637	2577	69	of	of	IN
18637	2577	70	the	the	DT
18637	2577	71	competing	compete	VBG
18637	2577	72	demands	demand	NNS
18637	2577	73	of	of	IN
18637	2577	74	state	state	NN
18637	2577	75	and	and	CC
18637	2577	76	national	national	JJ
18637	2577	77	interests	interest	NNS
18637	2577	78	.	.	.
18637	2578	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2578	2	790	790	CD
18637	2578	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2578	4	"	"	``
18637	2578	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2578	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	2578	7	undoubted	undoubted	JJ
18637	2578	8	power	power	NN
18637	2578	9	to	to	TO
18637	2578	10	redefine	redefine	VB
18637	2578	11	the	the	DT
18637	2578	12	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	2578	13	of	of	IN
18637	2578	14	power	power	NN
18637	2578	15	over	over	IN
18637	2578	16	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2578	17	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2578	18	.	.	.
18637	2579	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2579	2	may	may	MD
18637	2579	3	either	either	CC
18637	2579	4	permit	permit	VB
18637	2579	5	the	the	DT
18637	2579	6	states	state	NNS
18637	2579	7	to	to	TO
18637	2579	8	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2579	9	the	the	DT
18637	2579	10	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2579	11	in	in	IN
18637	2579	12	a	a	DT
18637	2579	13	manner	manner	NN
18637	2579	14	which	which	WDT
18637	2579	15	would	would	MD
18637	2579	16	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2579	17	not	not	RB
18637	2579	18	be	be	VB
18637	2579	19	permissible,[791	permissible,[791	JJ
18637	2579	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2579	21	or	or	CC
18637	2579	22	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	2579	23	state	state	NN
18637	2579	24	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2579	25	even	even	RB
18637	2579	26	of	of	IN
18637	2579	27	matters	matter	NNS
18637	2579	28	of	of	IN
18637	2579	29	peculiarly	peculiarly	JJ
18637	2579	30	local	local	JJ
18637	2579	31	concern	concern	NN
18637	2579	32	which	which	WDT
18637	2579	33	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	2579	34	affect	affect	VBP
18637	2579	35	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2579	36	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2579	37	.	.	.
18637	2580	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2580	2	792	792	CD
18637	2580	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2580	4	"	"	``
18637	2580	5	But	but	CC
18637	2580	6	in	in	IN
18637	2580	7	general	general	JJ
18637	2580	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2580	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	2580	10	left	leave	VBN
18637	2580	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2580	12	to	to	IN
18637	2580	13	the	the	DT
18637	2580	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	2580	15	to	to	TO
18637	2580	16	formulate	formulate	VB
18637	2580	17	the	the	DT
18637	2580	18	rules	rule	NNS
18637	2580	19	thus	thus	RB
18637	2580	20	interpreting	interpret	VBG
18637	2580	21	the	the	DT
18637	2580	22	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2580	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	2580	24	in	in	IN
18637	2580	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2580	26	application	application	NN
18637	2580	27	,	,	,
18637	2580	28	doubtless	doubtless	RB
18637	2580	29	because	because	IN
18637	2580	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2580	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	2580	32	appreciated	appreciate	VBN
18637	2580	33	the	the	DT
18637	2580	34	destructive	destructive	JJ
18637	2580	35	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	2580	36	to	to	IN
18637	2580	37	the	the	DT
18637	2580	38	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2580	39	of	of	IN
18637	2580	40	the	the	DT
18637	2580	41	nation	nation	NN
18637	2580	42	if	if	IN
18637	2580	43	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2580	44	protection	protection	NN
18637	2580	45	were	be	VBD
18637	2580	46	withdrawn,[793	withdrawn,[793	NNP
18637	2580	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2580	48	and	and	CC
18637	2580	49	has	have	VBZ
18637	2580	50	been	be	VBN
18637	2580	51	aware	aware	JJ
18637	2580	52	that	that	IN
18637	2580	53	in	in	IN
18637	2580	54	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2580	55	application	application	NN
18637	2580	56	state	state	NN
18637	2580	57	laws	law	NNS
18637	2580	58	will	will	MD
18637	2580	59	not	not	RB
18637	2580	60	be	be	VB
18637	2580	61	invalidated	invalidate	VBN
18637	2580	62	without	without	IN
18637	2580	63	the	the	DT
18637	2580	64	support	support	NN
18637	2580	65	of	of	IN
18637	2580	66	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	2580	67	factual	factual	JJ
18637	2580	68	material	material	NN
18637	2580	69	which	which	WDT
18637	2580	70	will	will	MD
18637	2580	71	'	'	``
18637	2580	72	afford	afford	VB
18637	2580	73	a	a	DT
18637	2580	74	sure	sure	JJ
18637	2580	75	basis	basis	NN
18637	2580	76	'	'	''
18637	2580	77	for	for	IN
18637	2580	78	an	an	DT
18637	2580	79	informed	informed	JJ
18637	2580	80	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	2580	81	.	.	.
18637	2581	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2581	2	794	794	CD
18637	2581	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2581	4	Meanwhile	meanwhile	RB
18637	2581	5	,	,	,
18637	2581	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2581	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	2581	8	accommodated	accommodate	VBN
18637	2581	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2581	10	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2581	11	,	,	,
18637	2581	12	as	as	IN
18637	2581	13	have	have	VBP
18637	2581	14	the	the	DT
18637	2581	15	states	state	NNS
18637	2581	16	,	,	,
18637	2581	17	to	to	IN
18637	2581	18	these	these	DT
18637	2581	19	rules	rule	NNS
18637	2581	20	as	as	IN
18637	2581	21	an	an	DT
18637	2581	22	established	establish	VBN
18637	2581	23	feature	feature	NN
18637	2581	24	of	of	IN
18637	2581	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2581	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2581	27	system	system	NN
18637	2581	28	.	.	.
18637	2582	1	There	there	EX
18637	2582	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	2582	3	thus	thus	RB
18637	2582	4	been	be	VBN
18637	2582	5	left	leave	VBN
18637	2582	6	to	to	IN
18637	2582	7	the	the	DT
18637	2582	8	states	state	NNS
18637	2582	9	wide	wide	JJ
18637	2582	10	scope	scope	NN
18637	2582	11	for	for	IN
18637	2582	12	the	the	DT
18637	2582	13	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2582	14	of	of	IN
18637	2582	15	matters	matter	NNS
18637	2582	16	of	of	IN
18637	2582	17	local	local	JJ
18637	2582	18	state	state	NN
18637	2582	19	concern	concern	NN
18637	2582	20	,	,	,
18637	2582	21	even	even	RB
18637	2582	22	though	though	IN
18637	2582	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2582	24	in	in	IN
18637	2582	25	some	some	DT
18637	2582	26	measure	measure	NN
18637	2582	27	affects	affect	VBZ
18637	2582	28	the	the	DT
18637	2582	29	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2582	30	,	,	,
18637	2582	31	provided	provide	VBN
18637	2582	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2582	33	does	do	VBZ
18637	2582	34	not	not	RB
18637	2582	35	materially	materially	RB
18637	2582	36	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	2582	37	the	the	DT
18637	2582	38	free	free	JJ
18637	2582	39	flow	flow	NN
18637	2582	40	of	of	IN
18637	2582	41	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2582	42	across	across	IN
18637	2582	43	state	state	NN
18637	2582	44	lines	line	NNS
18637	2582	45	,	,	,
18637	2582	46	or	or	CC
18637	2582	47	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	2582	48	with	with	IN
18637	2582	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2582	50	in	in	IN
18637	2582	51	matters	matter	NNS
18637	2582	52	with	with	IN
18637	2582	53	respect	respect	NN
18637	2582	54	to	to	IN
18637	2582	55	which	which	WDT
18637	2582	56	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	2582	57	of	of	IN
18637	2582	58	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2582	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	2582	60	of	of	IN
18637	2582	61	predominant	predominant	JJ
18637	2582	62	national	national	JJ
18637	2582	63	concern	concern	NN
18637	2582	64	.	.	.
18637	2582	65	"	"	''
18637	2583	1	State	State	NNP
18637	2583	2	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	2583	3	of	of	IN
18637	2583	4	Agencies	Agencies	NNPS
18637	2583	5	of	of	IN
18637	2583	6	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2583	7	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2583	8	RAILWAY	railway	NN
18637	2583	9	RATE	rate	NN
18637	2583	10	REGULATION	REGULATION	VBN
18637	2583	11	In	in	IN
18637	2583	12	one	one	CD
18637	2583	13	of	of	IN
18637	2583	14	the	the	DT
18637	2583	15	Granger	Granger	NNP
18637	2583	16	Cases	case	NNS
18637	2583	17	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2583	18	in	in	IN
18637	2583	19	1877	1877	CD
18637	2583	20	the	the	DT
18637	2583	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2583	22	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	2583	23	the	the	DT
18637	2583	24	power	power	NN
18637	2583	25	of	of	IN
18637	2583	26	the	the	DT
18637	2583	27	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	2583	28	of	of	IN
18637	2583	29	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	2583	30	in	in	IN
18637	2583	31	the	the	DT
18637	2583	32	absence	absence	NN
18637	2583	33	of	of	IN
18637	2583	34	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2583	35	by	by	IN
18637	2583	36	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2583	37	,	,	,
18637	2583	38	to	to	TO
18637	2583	39	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	2583	40	by	by	IN
18637	2583	41	law	law	NN
18637	2583	42	the	the	DT
18637	2583	43	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	2583	44	charges	charge	NNS
18637	2583	45	to	to	TO
18637	2583	46	be	be	VB
18637	2583	47	made	make	VBN
18637	2583	48	by	by	IN
18637	2583	49	a	a	DT
18637	2583	50	railway	railway	NN
18637	2583	51	company	company	NN
18637	2583	52	for	for	IN
18637	2583	53	fare	fare	NN
18637	2583	54	and	and	CC
18637	2583	55	freight	freight	NN
18637	2583	56	upon	upon	IN
18637	2583	57	the	the	DT
18637	2583	58	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2583	59	of	of	IN
18637	2583	60	persons	person	NNS
18637	2583	61	and	and	CC
18637	2583	62	property	property	NN
18637	2583	63	within	within	IN
18637	2583	64	the	the	DT
18637	2583	65	State	State	NNP
18637	2583	66	,	,	,
18637	2583	67	or	or	CC
18637	2583	68	taken	take	VBN
18637	2583	69	up	up	RP
18637	2583	70	outside	outside	IN
18637	2583	71	the	the	DT
18637	2583	72	State	state	NN
18637	2583	73	and	and	CC
18637	2583	74	brought	bring	VBD
18637	2583	75	within	within	IN
18637	2583	76	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2583	77	,	,	,
18637	2583	78	or	or	CC
18637	2583	79	taken	take	VBN
18637	2583	80	up	up	RP
18637	2583	81	inside	inside	RB
18637	2583	82	and	and	CC
18637	2583	83	carried	carry	VBN
18637	2583	84	without	without	IN
18637	2583	85	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2583	86	.	.	.
18637	2584	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2584	2	795	795	CD
18637	2584	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2584	4	Ten	ten	CD
18637	2584	5	years	year	NNS
18637	2584	6	later	later	RB
18637	2584	7	,	,	,
18637	2584	8	in	in	IN
18637	2584	9	Wabash	Wabash	NNP
18637	2584	10	,	,	,
18637	2584	11	St.	St.	NNP
18637	2584	12	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	2584	13	and	and	CC
18637	2584	14	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	2584	15	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	2584	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2584	17	_	_	NNP
18637	2584	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	2584	19	_	_	NNP
18637	2584	20	Illinois[796	Illinois[796	NNP
18637	2584	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2584	22	this	this	DT
18637	2584	23	decision	decision	NN
18637	2584	24	was	be	VBD
18637	2584	25	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	2584	26	as	as	IN
18637	2584	27	to	to	IN
18637	2584	28	persons	person	NNS
18637	2584	29	and	and	CC
18637	2584	30	property	property	NN
18637	2584	31	taken	take	VBN
18637	2584	32	up	up	RP
18637	2584	33	within	within	IN
18637	2584	34	the	the	DT
18637	2584	35	State	state	NN
18637	2584	36	and	and	CC
18637	2584	37	transported	transport	VBD
18637	2584	38	out	out	IN
18637	2584	39	of	of	IN
18637	2584	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2584	41	and	and	CC
18637	2584	42	as	as	IN
18637	2584	43	to	to	IN
18637	2584	44	persons	person	NNS
18637	2584	45	and	and	CC
18637	2584	46	property	property	NN
18637	2584	47	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2584	48	into	into	IN
18637	2584	49	the	the	DT
18637	2584	50	State	State	NNP
18637	2584	51	from	from	IN
18637	2584	52	outside	outside	RB
18637	2584	53	.	.	.
18637	2585	1	As	as	IN
18637	2585	2	to	to	IN
18637	2585	3	these	these	DT
18637	2585	4	,	,	,
18637	2585	5	the	the	DT
18637	2585	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2585	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	2585	8	that	that	IN
18637	2585	9	the	the	DT
18637	2585	10	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2585	11	of	of	IN
18637	2585	12	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2585	13	and	and	CC
18637	2585	14	charges	charge	NNS
18637	2585	15	must	must	MD
18637	2585	16	be	be	VB
18637	2585	17	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2585	18	and	and	CC
18637	2585	19	that	that	IN
18637	2585	20	,	,	,
18637	2585	21	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	2585	22	,	,	,
18637	2585	23	the	the	DT
18637	2585	24	States	States	NNPS
18637	2585	25	had	have	VBD
18637	2585	26	no	no	DT
18637	2585	27	power	power	NN
18637	2585	28	to	to	TO
18637	2585	29	deal	deal	VB
18637	2585	30	with	with	IN
18637	2585	31	the	the	DT
18637	2585	32	subject	subject	NN
18637	2585	33	even	even	RB
18637	2585	34	when	when	WRB
18637	2585	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2585	36	had	have	VBD
18637	2585	37	not	not	RB
18637	2585	38	acted	act	VBN
18637	2585	39	.	.	.
18637	2586	1	The	the	DT
18637	2586	2	following	following	JJ
18637	2586	3	year	year	NN
18637	2586	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2586	5	passed	pass	VBD
18637	2586	6	the	the	DT
18637	2586	7	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2586	8	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2586	9	Act[797	Act[797	NNP
18637	2586	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2586	11	to	to	TO
18637	2586	12	fill	fill	VB
18637	2586	13	the	the	DT
18637	2586	14	gap	gap	NN
18637	2586	15	created	create	VBN
18637	2586	16	by	by	IN
18637	2586	17	the	the	DT
18637	2586	18	Wabash	Wabash	NNP
18637	2586	19	decision	decision	NN
18637	2586	20	.	.	.
18637	2587	1	Today	today	NN
18637	2587	2	,	,	,
18637	2587	3	the	the	DT
18637	2587	4	States	state	NNS
18637	2587	5	still	still	RB
18637	2587	6	exercise	exercise	VBP
18637	2587	7	the	the	DT
18637	2587	8	power	power	NN
18637	2587	9	to	to	TO
18637	2587	10	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2587	11	railway	railway	NN
18637	2587	12	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2587	13	for	for	IN
18637	2587	14	the	the	DT
18637	2587	15	carriage	carriage	NN
18637	2587	16	of	of	IN
18637	2587	17	persons	person	NNS
18637	2587	18	and	and	CC
18637	2587	19	property	property	NN
18637	2587	20	taken	take	VBN
18637	2587	21	up	up	RP
18637	2587	22	and	and	CC
18637	2587	23	put	put	VB
18637	2587	24	down	down	RP
18637	2587	25	within	within	IN
18637	2587	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2587	27	borders	border	NNS
18637	2587	28	,	,	,
18637	2587	29	but	but	CC
18637	2587	30	do	do	VB
18637	2587	31	so	so	RB
18637	2587	32	subject	subject	VB
18637	2587	33	to	to	IN
18637	2587	34	the	the	DT
18637	2587	35	rule	rule	NN
18637	2587	36	,	,	,
18637	2587	37	which	which	WDT
18637	2587	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	2587	39	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	2587	40	by	by	IN
18637	2587	41	the	the	DT
18637	2587	42	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2587	43	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2587	44	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2587	45	,	,	,
18637	2587	46	that	that	IN
18637	2587	47	such	such	JJ
18637	2587	48	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2587	49	may	may	MD
18637	2587	50	not	not	RB
18637	2587	51	discriminate	discriminate	VB
18637	2587	52	against	against	IN
18637	2587	53	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2587	54	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2587	55	.	.	.
18637	2588	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2588	2	798	798	CD
18637	2588	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2588	4	ADEQUATE	adequate	JJ
18637	2588	5	SERVICE	service	NN
18637	2588	6	REGULATIONS	regulation	NNS
18637	2588	7	In	in	IN
18637	2588	8	many	many	JJ
18637	2588	9	other	other	JJ
18637	2588	10	respects	respect	NNS
18637	2588	11	the	the	DT
18637	2588	12	power	power	NN
18637	2588	13	still	still	RB
18637	2588	14	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	2588	15	with	with	IN
18637	2588	16	the	the	DT
18637	2588	17	States	States	NNPS
18637	2588	18	to	to	TO
18637	2588	19	require	require	VB
18637	2588	20	by	by	IN
18637	2588	21	statute	statute	NN
18637	2588	22	or	or	CC
18637	2588	23	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	2588	24	order	order	NN
18637	2588	25	a	a	DT
18637	2588	26	fair	fair	JJ
18637	2588	27	and	and	CC
18637	2588	28	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	2588	29	service	service	NN
18637	2588	30	for	for	IN
18637	2588	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2588	32	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	2588	33	from	from	IN
18637	2588	34	railway	railway	NN
18637	2588	35	companies	company	NNS
18637	2588	36	,	,	,
18637	2588	37	including	include	VBG
18637	2588	38	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2588	39	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	2588	40	operating	operate	VBG
18637	2588	41	within	within	IN
18637	2588	42	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2588	43	borders	border	NNS
18637	2588	44	,	,	,
18637	2588	45	so	so	RB
18637	2588	46	long	long	RB
18637	2588	47	as	as	IN
18637	2588	48	the	the	DT
18637	2588	49	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	2588	50	thus	thus	RB
18637	2588	51	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2588	52	upon	upon	IN
18637	2588	53	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2588	54	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2588	55	are	be	VBP
18637	2588	56	,	,	,
18637	2588	57	in	in	IN
18637	2588	58	the	the	DT
18637	2588	59	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	2588	60	of	of	IN
18637	2588	61	the	the	DT
18637	2588	62	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2588	63	,	,	,
18637	2588	64	"	"	''
18637	2588	65	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2588	66	.	.	.
18637	2588	67	"	"	''
18637	2589	1	In	in	IN
18637	2589	2	an	an	DT
18637	2589	3	instructive	instructive	JJ
18637	2589	4	brace	brace	NN
18637	2589	5	of	of	IN
18637	2589	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	2589	7	the	the	DT
18637	2589	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2589	9	was	be	VBD
18637	2589	10	asked	ask	VBN
18637	2589	11	to	to	TO
18637	2589	12	say	say	VB
18637	2589	13	whether	whether	IN
18637	2589	14	a	a	DT
18637	2589	15	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2589	16	,	,	,
18637	2589	17	in	in	IN
18637	2589	18	the	the	DT
18637	2589	19	interest	interest	NN
18637	2589	20	of	of	IN
18637	2589	21	providing	provide	VBG
18637	2589	22	proper	proper	JJ
18637	2589	23	local	local	JJ
18637	2589	24	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	2589	25	of	of	IN
18637	2589	26	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2589	27	,	,	,
18637	2589	28	could	could	MD
18637	2589	29	be	be	VB
18637	2589	30	required	require	VBN
18637	2589	31	to	to	TO
18637	2589	32	stop	stop	VB
18637	2589	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2589	34	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2589	35	trains	train	NNS
18637	2589	36	.	.	.
18637	2590	1	In	in	IN
18637	2590	2	one	one	CD
18637	2590	3	case	case	NN
18637	2590	4	a	a	DT
18637	2590	5	State	state	NN
18637	2590	6	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2590	7	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2590	8	all	all	DT
18637	2590	9	regular	regular	JJ
18637	2590	10	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	2590	11	trains	train	NNS
18637	2590	12	operating	operate	VBG
18637	2590	13	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	2590	14	within	within	IN
18637	2590	15	the	the	DT
18637	2590	16	State	State	NNP
18637	2590	17	to	to	TO
18637	2590	18	stop	stop	VB
18637	2590	19	at	at	RB
18637	2590	20	all	all	DT
18637	2590	21	county	county	NN
18637	2590	22	seats	seat	NNS
18637	2590	23	was	be	VBD
18637	2590	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	2590	25	to	to	TO
18637	2590	26	have	have	VB
18637	2590	27	been	be	VBN
18637	2590	28	validly	validly	RB
18637	2590	29	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2590	30	to	to	IN
18637	2590	31	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2590	32	connection	connection	NN
18637	2590	33	trains;[799	trains;[799	,
18637	2590	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2590	35	while	while	IN
18637	2590	36	in	in	IN
18637	2590	37	the	the	DT
18637	2590	38	other	other	JJ
18637	2590	39	case	case	NN
18637	2590	40	a	a	DT
18637	2590	41	statute	statute	NN
18637	2590	42	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2590	43	_	_	NNP
18637	2590	44	all	all	DT
18637	2590	45	_	_	NNP
18637	2590	46	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	2590	47	trains	train	NNS
18637	2590	48	to	to	TO
18637	2590	49	stop	stop	VB
18637	2590	50	at	at	IN
18637	2590	51	county	county	NN
18637	2590	52	seats	seat	NNS
18637	2590	53	was	be	VBD
18637	2590	54	held	hold	VBN
18637	2590	55	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	2590	56	,	,	,
18637	2590	57	there	there	EX
18637	2590	58	being	be	VBG
18637	2590	59	"	"	``
18637	2590	60	other	other	JJ
18637	2590	61	and	and	CC
18637	2590	62	ample	ample	JJ
18637	2590	63	accommodation	accommodation	NN
18637	2590	64	.	.	.
18637	2591	1	"	"	``
18637	2591	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2591	3	800	800	CD
18637	2591	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2591	5	Comparing	compare	VBG
18637	2591	6	these	these	DT
18637	2591	7	and	and	CC
18637	2591	8	other	other	JJ
18637	2591	9	like	like	JJ
18637	2591	10	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	2591	11	,	,	,
18637	2591	12	the	the	DT
18637	2591	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2591	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	2591	15	stated	state	VBN
18637	2591	16	"	"	``
18637	2591	17	the	the	DT
18637	2591	18	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	2591	19	general	general	JJ
18637	2591	20	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2591	21	"	"	''
18637	2591	22	to	to	TO
18637	2591	23	be	be	VB
18637	2591	24	as	as	IN
18637	2591	25	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	2591	26	:	:	:
18637	2591	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2591	28	1	1	LS
18637	2591	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2591	30	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2591	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	2591	32	competent	competent	JJ
18637	2591	33	for	for	IN
18637	2591	34	a	a	DT
18637	2591	35	State	State	NNP
18637	2591	36	to	to	TO
18637	2591	37	require	require	VB
18637	2591	38	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	2591	39	local	local	JJ
18637	2591	40	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	2591	41	,	,	,
18637	2591	42	even	even	RB
18637	2591	43	to	to	IN
18637	2591	44	the	the	DT
18637	2591	45	stoppage	stoppage	NN
18637	2591	46	of	of	IN
18637	2591	47	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2591	48	trains	train	NNS
18637	2591	49	or	or	CC
18637	2591	50	the	the	DT
18637	2591	51	rearrangement	rearrangement	NN
18637	2591	52	of	of	IN
18637	2591	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2591	54	schedules	schedule	NNS
18637	2591	55	.	.	.
18637	2592	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2592	2	2	2	LS
18637	2592	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2592	4	Such	such	JJ
18637	2592	5	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	2592	6	existing	exist	VBG
18637	2592	7	--	--	:
18637	2592	8	that	that	RB
18637	2592	9	is	is	RB
18637	2592	10	,	,	,
18637	2592	11	the	the	DT
18637	2592	12	local	local	JJ
18637	2592	13	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2592	14	being	be	VBG
18637	2592	15	adequately	adequately	RB
18637	2592	16	met	meet	VBN
18637	2592	17	--	--	:
18637	2592	18	the	the	DT
18637	2592	19	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	2592	20	of	of	IN
18637	2592	21	the	the	DT
18637	2592	22	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2592	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	2592	24	performed	perform	VBN
18637	2592	25	,	,	,
18637	2592	26	and	and	CC
18637	2592	27	the	the	DT
18637	2592	28	stoppage	stoppage	NN
18637	2592	29	of	of	IN
18637	2592	30	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2592	31	trains	train	NNS
18637	2592	32	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	2592	33	an	an	DT
18637	2592	34	improper	improper	JJ
18637	2592	35	and	and	CC
18637	2592	36	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	2592	37	interference	interference	NN
18637	2592	38	with	with	IN
18637	2592	39	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2592	40	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2592	41	.	.	.
18637	2593	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2593	2	3	3	LS
18637	2593	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2593	4	And	and	CC
18637	2593	5	this	this	DT
18637	2593	6	,	,	,
18637	2593	7	whether	whether	IN
18637	2593	8	the	the	DT
18637	2593	9	interference	interference	NN
18637	2593	10	be	be	VB
18637	2593	11	directly	directly	RB
18637	2593	12	by	by	IN
18637	2593	13	the	the	DT
18637	2593	14	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	2593	15	or	or	CC
18637	2593	16	by	by	IN
18637	2593	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2593	18	command	command	NN
18637	2593	19	through	through	IN
18637	2593	20	the	the	DT
18637	2593	21	orders	order	NNS
18637	2593	22	of	of	IN
18637	2593	23	an	an	DT
18637	2593	24	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	2593	25	body	body	NN
18637	2593	26	.	.	.
18637	2594	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2594	2	4	4	LS
18637	2594	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2594	4	The	the	DT
18637	2594	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	2594	6	of	of	IN
18637	2594	7	local	local	JJ
18637	2594	8	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	2594	9	this	this	DT
18637	2594	10	court	court	NN
18637	2594	11	may	may	MD
18637	2594	12	determine	determine	VB
18637	2594	13	,	,	,
18637	2594	14	such	such	JJ
18637	2594	15	fact	fact	NN
18637	2594	16	being	be	VBG
18637	2594	17	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	2594	18	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2594	19	in	in	IN
18637	2594	20	the	the	DT
18637	2594	21	determination	determination	NN
18637	2594	22	of	of	IN
18637	2594	23	the	the	DT
18637	2594	24	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2594	25	question	question	NN
18637	2594	26	whether	whether	IN
18637	2594	27	an	an	DT
18637	2594	28	order	order	NN
18637	2594	29	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	2594	30	an	an	DT
18637	2594	31	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2594	32	train	train	NN
18637	2594	33	does	do	VBZ
18637	2594	34	or	or	CC
18637	2594	35	does	do	VBZ
18637	2594	36	not	not	RB
18637	2594	37	directly	directly	RB
18637	2594	38	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2594	39	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2594	40	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2594	41	,	,	,
18637	2594	42	by	by	IN
18637	2594	43	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	2594	44	an	an	DT
18637	2594	45	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	2594	46	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	2594	47	.	.	.
18637	2595	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2595	2	801	801	CD
18637	2595	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2595	4	"	"	``
18637	2595	5	There	there	EX
18637	2595	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2595	7	,	,	,
18637	2595	8	however	however	RB
18637	2595	9	,	,	,
18637	2595	10	"	"	''
18637	2595	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2595	12	later	later	RB
18637	2595	13	added	add	VBD
18637	2595	14	,	,	,
18637	2595	15	"	"	``
18637	2595	16	no	no	DT
18637	2595	17	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
18637	2595	18	test	test	NN
18637	2595	19	of	of	IN
18637	2595	20	the	the	DT
18637	2595	21	instances	instance	NNS
18637	2595	22	;	;	:
18637	2595	23	the	the	DT
18637	2595	24	facts	fact	NNS
18637	2595	25	in	in	IN
18637	2595	26	each	each	DT
18637	2595	27	must	must	MD
18637	2595	28	be	be	VB
18637	2595	29	considered	consider	VBN
18637	2595	30	.	.	.
18637	2596	1	"	"	``
18637	2596	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2596	3	802	802	CD
18637	2596	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2596	5	In	in	IN
18637	2596	6	the	the	DT
18637	2596	7	same	same	JJ
18637	2596	8	way	way	NN
18637	2596	9	a	a	DT
18637	2596	10	State	state	NN
18637	2596	11	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2596	12	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2596	13	intersecting	intersect	VBG
18637	2596	14	railways	railway	NNS
18637	2596	15	to	to	TO
18637	2596	16	make	make	VB
18637	2596	17	track	track	NN
18637	2596	18	connections	connection	NNS
18637	2596	19	was	be	VBD
18637	2596	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	2596	21	valid,[803	valid,[803	NNP
18637	2596	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2596	23	as	as	IN
18637	2596	24	was	be	VBD
18637	2596	25	also	also	RB
18637	2596	26	a	a	DT
18637	2596	27	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2596	28	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2596	29	equality	equality	NN
18637	2596	30	of	of	IN
18637	2596	31	car	car	NN
18637	2596	32	service	service	NN
18637	2596	33	between	between	IN
18637	2596	34	shippers;[804	shippers;[804	NNP
18637	2596	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2596	36	while	while	IN
18637	2596	37	a	a	DT
18637	2596	38	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2596	39	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2596	40	the	the	DT
18637	2596	41	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	2596	42	of	of	IN
18637	2596	43	shipments	shipment	NNS
18637	2596	44	on	on	IN
18637	2596	45	private	private	JJ
18637	2596	46	sideways[805	sideways[805	NN
18637	2596	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2596	48	and	and	CC
18637	2596	49	one	one	CD
18637	2596	50	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2596	51	cars	car	NNS
18637	2596	52	for	for	IN
18637	2596	53	local	local	JJ
18637	2596	54	shipments	shipment	NNS
18637	2596	55	to	to	TO
18637	2596	56	be	be	VB
18637	2596	57	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	2596	58	on	on	IN
18637	2596	59	demand	demand	NN
18637	2596	60	,	,	,
18637	2596	61	were	be	VBD
18637	2596	62	held	hold	VBN
18637	2596	63	to	to	TO
18637	2596	64	be	be	VB
18637	2596	65	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	2596	66	.	.	.
18637	2597	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2597	2	806	806	CD
18637	2597	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2597	4	In	in	IN
18637	2597	5	the	the	DT
18637	2597	6	first	first	JJ
18637	2597	7	brace	brace	NN
18637	2597	8	of	of	IN
18637	2597	9	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	2597	10	,	,	,
18637	2597	11	the	the	DT
18637	2597	12	application	application	NN
18637	2597	13	of	of	IN
18637	2597	14	the	the	DT
18637	2597	15	local	local	JJ
18637	2597	16	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2597	17	to	to	IN
18637	2597	18	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2597	19	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2597	20	was	be	VBD
18637	2597	21	found	find	VBN
18637	2597	22	not	not	RB
18637	2597	23	to	to	TO
18637	2597	24	be	be	VB
18637	2597	25	"	"	``
18637	2597	26	unduly	unduly	RB
18637	2597	27	"	"	''
18637	2597	28	burdensome	burdensome	JJ
18637	2597	29	;	;	:
18637	2597	30	in	in	IN
18637	2597	31	the	the	DT
18637	2597	32	second	second	JJ
18637	2597	33	brace	brace	NN
18637	2597	34	the	the	DT
18637	2597	35	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	2597	36	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	2597	37	was	be	VBD
18637	2597	38	reached	reach	VBN
18637	2597	39	.	.	.
18637	2598	1	SAFETY	SAFETY	NNP
18637	2598	2	AND	and	CC
18637	2598	3	OTHER	other	JJ
18637	2598	4	REGULATIONS	regulation	NNS
18637	2598	5	A	a	DT
18637	2598	6	class	class	NN
18637	2598	7	of	of	IN
18637	2598	8	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2598	9	as	as	IN
18637	2598	10	to	to	IN
18637	2598	11	which	which	WDT
18637	2598	12	the	the	DT
18637	2598	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2598	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	2598	15	exhibited	exhibit	VBN
18637	2598	16	marked	mark	VBN
18637	2598	17	tolerance	tolerance	NN
18637	2598	18	although	although	IN
18637	2598	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2598	20	"	"	``
18637	2598	21	incidentally	incidentally	RB
18637	2598	22	"	"	''
18637	2598	23	embrace	embrace	JJ
18637	2598	24	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2598	25	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2598	26	within	within	IN
18637	2598	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2598	28	operation	operation	NN
18637	2598	29	are	be	VBP
18637	2598	30	those	those	DT
18637	2598	31	which	which	WDT
18637	2598	32	purport	purport	VBP
18637	2598	33	to	to	TO
18637	2598	34	be	be	VB
18637	2598	35	in	in	IN
18637	2598	36	furtherance	furtherance	NN
18637	2598	37	of	of	IN
18637	2598	38	"	"	``
18637	2598	39	public	public	JJ
18637	2598	40	safety	safety	NN
18637	2598	41	.	.	.
18637	2599	1	"	"	``
18637	2599	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2599	3	807	807	CD
18637	2599	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2599	5	The	the	DT
18637	2599	6	leading	leading	JJ
18637	2599	7	case	case	NN
18637	2599	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	2599	9	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	2599	10	_	_	NNP
18637	2599	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	2599	12	_	_	NNP
18637	2599	13	Alabama,[808	Alabama,[808	NNP
18637	2599	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2599	15	in	in	IN
18637	2599	16	which	which	WDT
18637	2599	17	the	the	DT
18637	2599	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2599	19	held	hold	VBD
18637	2599	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2599	21	to	to	TO
18637	2599	22	be	be	VB
18637	2599	23	within	within	IN
18637	2599	24	the	the	DT
18637	2599	25	police	police	NN
18637	2599	26	power	power	NN
18637	2599	27	of	of	IN
18637	2599	28	the	the	DT
18637	2599	29	State	State	NNP
18637	2599	30	to	to	TO
18637	2599	31	require	require	VB
18637	2599	32	locomotive	locomotive	JJ
18637	2599	33	engineers	engineer	NNS
18637	2599	34	to	to	TO
18637	2599	35	be	be	VB
18637	2599	36	examined	examine	VBN
18637	2599	37	and	and	CC
18637	2599	38	licensed	license	VBN
18637	2599	39	,	,	,
18637	2599	40	and	and	CC
18637	2599	41	to	to	TO
18637	2599	42	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	2599	43	this	this	DT
18637	2599	44	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	2599	45	until	until	IN
18637	2599	46	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2599	47	should	should	MD
18637	2599	48	decree	decree	VB
18637	2599	49	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2599	50	in	in	IN
18637	2599	51	the	the	DT
18637	2599	52	case	case	NN
18637	2599	53	of	of	IN
18637	2599	54	an	an	DT
18637	2599	55	engineer	engineer	NN
18637	2599	56	employed	employ	VBN
18637	2599	57	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	2599	58	in	in	IN
18637	2599	59	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2599	60	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2599	61	.	.	.
18637	2600	1	Also	also	RB
18637	2600	2	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	2600	3	as	as	IN
18637	2600	4	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	2600	5	to	to	IN
18637	2600	6	interstate	interstate	VB
18637	2600	7	trains	train	NNS
18637	2600	8	were	be	VBD
18637	2600	9	a	a	DT
18637	2600	10	statute	statute	NN
18637	2600	11	which	which	WDT
18637	2600	12	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	2600	13	the	the	DT
18637	2600	14	heating	heating	NN
18637	2600	15	of	of	IN
18637	2600	16	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	2600	17	cars	car	NNS
18637	2600	18	by	by	IN
18637	2600	19	stoves;[809	stoves;[809	NNP
18637	2600	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2600	21	a	a	DT
18637	2600	22	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	2600	23	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	2600	24	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	2600	25	the	the	DT
18637	2600	26	speed	speed	NN
18637	2600	27	of	of	IN
18637	2600	28	trains	train	NNS
18637	2600	29	within	within	IN
18637	2600	30	city	city	NN
18637	2600	31	limits;[810	limits;[810	:
18637	2600	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2600	33	the	the	DT
18637	2600	34	order	order	NN
18637	2600	35	of	of	IN
18637	2600	36	a	a	DT
18637	2600	37	public	public	JJ
18637	2600	38	utility	utility	NN
18637	2600	39	commission	commission	NN
18637	2600	40	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2600	41	the	the	DT
18637	2600	42	elimination	elimination	NN
18637	2600	43	of	of	IN
18637	2600	44	grade	grade	NN
18637	2600	45	crossings;[811	crossings;[811	HYPH
18637	2600	46	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2600	47	a	a	DT
18637	2600	48	statute	statute	NN
18637	2600	49	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2600	50	electric	electric	JJ
18637	2600	51	headlights	headlight	NNS
18637	2600	52	of	of	IN
18637	2600	53	a	a	DT
18637	2600	54	specified	specify	VBN
18637	2600	55	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	2600	56	capacity;[812	capacity;[812	NNS
18637	2600	57	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2600	58	a	a	DT
18637	2600	59	statute	statute	NN
18637	2600	60	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2600	61	three	three	CD
18637	2600	62	brakemen	brakeman	NNS
18637	2600	63	on	on	IN
18637	2600	64	freight	freight	NN
18637	2600	65	trains	train	NNS
18637	2600	66	of	of	IN
18637	2600	67	over	over	IN
18637	2600	68	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	2600	69	-	-	HYPH
18637	2600	70	five	five	CD
18637	2600	71	cars	car	NNS
18637	2600	72	.	.	.
18637	2601	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2601	2	813	813	CD
18637	2601	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2601	4	In	in	IN
18637	2601	5	the	the	DT
18637	2601	6	last	last	JJ
18637	2601	7	case	case	NN
18637	2601	8	the	the	DT
18637	2601	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2601	10	admitted	admit	VBD
18637	2601	11	that	that	IN
18637	2601	12	"	"	``
18637	2601	13	under	under	IN
18637	2601	14	the	the	DT
18637	2601	15	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	2601	16	,	,	,
18637	2601	17	"	"	``
18637	2601	18	there	there	EX
18637	2601	19	was	be	VBD
18637	2601	20	"	"	``
18637	2601	21	some	some	DT
18637	2601	22	room	room	NN
18637	2601	23	for	for	IN
18637	2601	24	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	2601	25	"	"	''
18637	2601	26	as	as	IN
18637	2601	27	to	to	IN
18637	2601	28	whether	whether	IN
18637	2601	29	the	the	DT
18637	2601	30	statute	statute	NN
18637	2601	31	was	be	VBD
18637	2601	32	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2601	33	,	,	,
18637	2601	34	but	but	CC
18637	2601	35	thought	think	VBD
18637	2601	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2601	37	"	"	``
18637	2601	38	not	not	RB
18637	2601	39	so	so	RB
18637	2601	40	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	2601	41	as	as	IN
18637	2601	42	to	to	TO
18637	2601	43	justify	justify	VB
18637	2601	44	the	the	DT
18637	2601	45	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2601	46	in	in	IN
18637	2601	47	adjudging	adjudge	VBG
18637	2601	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2601	49	"	"	``
18637	2601	50	to	to	TO
18637	2601	51	be	be	VB
18637	2601	52	"	"	``
18637	2601	53	merely	merely	RB
18637	2601	54	an	an	DT
18637	2601	55	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	2601	56	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2601	57	of	of	IN
18637	2601	58	power	power	NN
18637	2601	59	"	"	''
18637	2601	60	and	and	CC
18637	2601	61	"	"	``
18637	2601	62	not	not	RB
18637	2601	63	germane	germane	NN
18637	2601	64	"	"	''
18637	2601	65	to	to	IN
18637	2601	66	objects	object	NNS
18637	2601	67	which	which	WDT
18637	2601	68	the	the	DT
18637	2601	69	State	State	NNP
18637	2601	70	was	be	VBD
18637	2601	71	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	2601	72	to	to	TO
18637	2601	73	accomplish	accomplish	VB
18637	2601	74	.	.	.
18637	2602	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2602	2	814	814	CD
18637	2602	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2602	4	And	and	CC
18637	2602	5	in	in	IN
18637	2602	6	1943	1943	CD
18637	2602	7	the	the	DT
18637	2602	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2602	9	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	2602	10	,	,	,
18637	2602	11	though	though	RB
18637	2602	12	again	again	RB
18637	2602	13	in	in	IN
18637	2602	14	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	2602	15	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
18637	2602	16	terms	term	NNS
18637	2602	17	,	,	,
18637	2602	18	the	the	DT
18637	2602	19	order	order	NN
18637	2602	20	of	of	IN
18637	2602	21	a	a	DT
18637	2602	22	State	State	NNP
18637	2602	23	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2602	24	commission	commission	NN
18637	2602	25	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2602	26	a	a	DT
18637	2602	27	terminal	terminal	JJ
18637	2602	28	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2602	29	which	which	WDT
18637	2602	30	served	serve	VBD
18637	2602	31	both	both	CC
18637	2602	32	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2602	33	and	and	CC
18637	2602	34	local	local	JJ
18637	2602	35	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2602	36	to	to	TO
18637	2602	37	provide	provide	VB
18637	2602	38	caboose	caboose	NN
18637	2602	39	cars	car	NNS
18637	2602	40	for	for	IN
18637	2602	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2602	42	employees	employee	NNS
18637	2602	43	.	.	.
18637	2603	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2603	2	815	815	CD
18637	2603	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2603	4	At	at	IN
18637	2603	5	times	time	NNS
18637	2603	6	,	,	,
18637	2603	7	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	2603	8	,	,	,
18637	2603	9	the	the	DT
18637	2603	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2603	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	2603	12	made	make	VBN
18637	2603	13	surprising	surprising	JJ
18637	2603	14	concession	concession	NN
18637	2603	15	to	to	IN
18637	2603	16	local	local	JJ
18637	2603	17	views	view	NNS
18637	2603	18	that	that	WDT
18637	2603	19	had	have	VBD
18637	2603	20	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	2603	21	to	to	TO
18637	2603	22	do	do	VB
18637	2603	23	with	with	IN
18637	2603	24	safety	safety	NN
18637	2603	25	.	.	.
18637	2604	1	Hennington	Hennington	NNP
18637	2604	2	_	_	NNP
18637	2604	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	2604	4	_	_	NNP
18637	2604	5	Georgia,[816	Georgia,[816	NNP
18637	2604	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2604	7	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2604	8	in	in	IN
18637	2604	9	1896	1896	CD
18637	2604	10	,	,	,
18637	2604	11	where	where	WRB
18637	2604	12	was	be	VBD
18637	2604	13	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2604	14	a	a	DT
18637	2604	15	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	2604	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	2604	17	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	2604	18	freight	freight	NN
18637	2604	19	trains	train	NNS
18637	2604	20	to	to	TO
18637	2604	21	run	run	VB
18637	2604	22	on	on	IN
18637	2604	23	Sunday	Sunday	NNP
18637	2604	24	,	,	,
18637	2604	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	2604	26	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	2604	27	the	the	DT
18637	2604	28	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	2604	29	example	example	NNP
18637	2604	30	.	.	.
18637	2605	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	2605	2	such	such	PDT
18637	2605	3	an	an	DT
18637	2605	4	act	act	NN
18637	2605	5	would	would	MD
18637	2605	6	pass	pass	VB
18637	2605	7	muster	muster	NN
18637	2605	8	today	today	NN
18637	2605	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	2605	10	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
18637	2605	11	.	.	.
18637	2606	1	And	and	CC
18637	2606	2	earlier	early	JJR
18637	2606	3	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	2606	4	reinforcing	reinforce	VBG
18637	2606	5	the	the	DT
18637	2606	6	legal	legal	JJ
18637	2606	7	liability	liability	NN
18637	2606	8	of	of	IN
18637	2606	9	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	2606	10	as	as	IN
18637	2606	11	common	common	JJ
18637	2606	12	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	2606	13	and	and	CC
18637	2606	14	the	the	DT
18637	2606	15	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	2606	16	of	of	IN
18637	2606	17	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	2606	18	were	be	VBD
18637	2606	19	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2606	20	in	in	IN
18637	2606	21	the	the	DT
18637	2606	22	absence	absence	NN
18637	2606	23	of	of	IN
18637	2606	24	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2606	25	by	by	IN
18637	2606	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2606	27	.	.	.
18637	2607	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2607	2	817	817	CD
18637	2607	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2607	4	INVALID	INVALID	NNP
18637	2607	5	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2607	6	REGULATIONS	regulation	NNS
18637	2607	7	"	"	``
18637	2607	8	The	the	DT
18637	2607	9	principle	principle	NN
18637	2607	10	that	that	WDT
18637	2607	11	,	,	,
18637	2607	12	without	without	IN
18637	2607	13	controlling	control	VBG
18637	2607	14	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2607	15	action	action	NN
18637	2607	16	,	,	,
18637	2607	17	a	a	DT
18637	2607	18	State	state	NN
18637	2607	19	may	may	MD
18637	2607	20	not	not	RB
18637	2607	21	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2607	22	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2607	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2607	24	so	so	IN
18637	2607	25	as	as	IN
18637	2607	26	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	2607	27	to	to	TO
18637	2607	28	affect	affect	VB
18637	2607	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2607	30	flow	flow	NN
18637	2607	31	or	or	CC
18637	2607	32	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	2607	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2607	34	of	of	IN
18637	2607	35	needed	need	VBN
18637	2607	36	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	2607	37	in	in	IN
18637	2607	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2607	39	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2607	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	2607	41	not	not	RB
18637	2607	42	to	to	TO
18637	2607	43	be	be	VB
18637	2607	44	avoided	avoid	VBN
18637	2607	45	by	by	IN
18637	2607	46	'	'	''
18637	2607	47	simply	simply	RB
18637	2607	48	invoking	invoke	VBG
18637	2607	49	the	the	DT
18637	2607	50	convenient	convenient	JJ
18637	2607	51	apologetics	apologetic	NNS
18637	2607	52	of	of	IN
18637	2607	53	the	the	DT
18637	2607	54	police	police	NN
18637	2607	55	power	power	NN
18637	2607	56	.	.	.
18637	2607	57	'	'	''
18637	2607	58	"	"	''
18637	2608	1	So	so	RB
18637	2608	2	remarks	remark	VBZ
18637	2608	3	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2608	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2608	5	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	2608	6	in	in	IN
18637	2608	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2608	8	summarizing	summarizing	NN
18637	2608	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2608	10	cited	cite	VBD
18637	2608	11	above	above	IN
18637	2608	12	,	,	,
18637	2608	13	in	in	IN
18637	2608	14	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	2608	15	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	2608	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2608	17	_	_	NNP
18637	2608	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	2608	19	_	_	NNP
18637	2608	20	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	2608	21	.	.	.
18637	2609	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2609	2	818	818	CD
18637	2609	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2609	4	Among	among	IN
18637	2609	5	others	other	NNS
18637	2609	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2609	7	lists	list	VBZ
18637	2609	8	the	the	DT
18637	2609	9	following	follow	VBG
18637	2609	10	instances	instance	NNS
18637	2609	11	in	in	IN
18637	2609	12	which	which	WDT
18637	2609	13	State	State	NNP
18637	2609	14	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2609	15	was	be	VBD
18637	2609	16	invalidated	invalidate	VBN
18637	2609	17	on	on	IN
18637	2609	18	the	the	DT
18637	2609	19	basis	basis	NN
18637	2609	20	of	of	IN
18637	2609	21	this	this	DT
18637	2609	22	rule	rule	NN
18637	2609	23	:	:	:
18637	2609	24	"	"	``
18637	2609	25	In	in	IN
18637	2609	26	the	the	DT
18637	2609	27	Kaw	Kaw	NNP
18637	2609	28	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	2609	29	case[819	case[819	NN
18637	2609	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2609	31	the	the	DT
18637	2609	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2609	33	held	hold	VBD
18637	2609	34	that	that	IN
18637	2609	35	the	the	DT
18637	2609	36	State	State	NNP
18637	2609	37	was	be	VBD
18637	2609	38	without	without	IN
18637	2609	39	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2609	40	power	power	NN
18637	2609	41	to	to	TO
18637	2609	42	order	order	VB
18637	2609	43	a	a	DT
18637	2609	44	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2609	45	to	to	TO
18637	2609	46	remove	remove	VB
18637	2609	47	a	a	DT
18637	2609	48	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2609	49	bridge	bridge	NN
18637	2609	50	over	over	IN
18637	2609	51	which	which	WDT
18637	2609	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2609	53	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2609	54	trains	train	NNS
18637	2609	55	passed	pass	VBD
18637	2609	56	,	,	,
18637	2609	57	as	as	IN
18637	2609	58	a	a	DT
18637	2609	59	means	means	NN
18637	2609	60	of	of	IN
18637	2609	61	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	2609	62	floods	flood	NNS
18637	2609	63	in	in	IN
18637	2609	64	the	the	DT
18637	2609	65	district	district	NN
18637	2609	66	and	and	CC
18637	2609	67	of	of	IN
18637	2609	68	improving	improve	VBG
18637	2609	69	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2609	70	drainage	drainage	NN
18637	2609	71	,	,	,
18637	2609	72	because	because	IN
18637	2609	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2609	74	was	be	VBD
18637	2609	75	'	'	``
18637	2609	76	not	not	RB
18637	2609	77	pretended	pretend	VBN
18637	2609	78	that	that	IN
18637	2609	79	local	local	JJ
18637	2609	80	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	2609	81	needs	need	VBZ
18637	2609	82	the	the	DT
18637	2609	83	removal	removal	NN
18637	2609	84	of	of	IN
18637	2609	85	the	the	DT
18637	2609	86	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	2609	87	'	'	POS
18637	2609	88	bridges	bridge	NNS
18637	2609	89	at	at	IN
18637	2609	90	the	the	DT
18637	2609	91	expense	expense	NN
18637	2609	92	of	of	IN
18637	2609	93	the	the	DT
18637	2609	94	dominant	dominant	JJ
18637	2609	95	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	2609	96	of	of	IN
18637	2609	97	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2609	98	with	with	IN
18637	2609	99	other	other	JJ
18637	2609	100	States	States	NNPS
18637	2609	101	,	,	,
18637	2609	102	but	but	CC
18637	2609	103	merely	merely	RB
18637	2609	104	that	that	IN
18637	2609	105	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2609	106	would	would	MD
18637	2609	107	be	be	VB
18637	2609	108	helped	help	VBN
18637	2609	109	by	by	IN
18637	2609	110	raising	raise	VBG
18637	2609	111	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2609	112	.	.	.
18637	2609	113	'	'	''
18637	2610	1	And	and	CC
18637	2610	2	in	in	IN
18637	2610	3	Seaboard	Seaboard	NNP
18637	2610	4	Air	Air	NNP
18637	2610	5	Line	Line	NNP
18637	2610	6	R.	R.	NNP
18637	2610	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2610	8	_	_	NNP
18637	2610	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	2610	10	_	_	NNP
18637	2610	11	Blackwell,[820	blackwell,[820	CD
18637	2610	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2610	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2610	14	was	be	VBD
18637	2610	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	2610	16	that	that	IN
18637	2610	17	the	the	DT
18637	2610	18	interference	interference	NN
18637	2610	19	with	with	IN
18637	2610	20	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2610	21	rail	rail	NN
18637	2610	22	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2610	23	resulting	result	VBG
18637	2610	24	from	from	IN
18637	2610	25	a	a	DT
18637	2610	26	State	State	NNP
18637	2610	27	statute	statute	NN
18637	2610	28	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2610	29	as	as	IN
18637	2610	30	a	a	DT
18637	2610	31	safety	safety	NN
18637	2610	32	measure	measure	NN
18637	2610	33	that	that	WDT
18637	2610	34	trains	train	NNS
18637	2610	35	come	come	VBP
18637	2610	36	almost	almost	RB
18637	2610	37	to	to	IN
18637	2610	38	a	a	DT
18637	2610	39	stop	stop	NN
18637	2610	40	at	at	IN
18637	2610	41	grade	grade	NN
18637	2610	42	crossings	crossing	NNS
18637	2610	43	,	,	,
18637	2610	44	outweigh	outweigh	VBP
18637	2610	45	the	the	DT
18637	2610	46	local	local	JJ
18637	2610	47	interest	interest	NN
18637	2610	48	in	in	IN
18637	2610	49	safety	safety	NN
18637	2610	50	,	,	,
18637	2610	51	when	when	WRB
18637	2610	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2610	53	appealed	appeal	VBD
18637	2610	54	that	that	IN
18637	2610	55	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	2610	56	increased	increase	VBD
18637	2610	57	the	the	DT
18637	2610	58	scheduled	schedule	VBN
18637	2610	59	running	running	NN
18637	2610	60	time	time	NN
18637	2610	61	more	more	JJR
18637	2610	62	than	than	IN
18637	2610	63	six	six	CD
18637	2610	64	hours	hour	NNS
18637	2610	65	in	in	IN
18637	2610	66	a	a	DT
18637	2610	67	distance	distance	NN
18637	2610	68	of	of	IN
18637	2610	69	one	one	CD
18637	2610	70	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	2610	71	and	and	CC
18637	2610	72	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	2610	73	-	-	HYPH
18637	2610	74	three	three	CD
18637	2610	75	miles	mile	NNS
18637	2610	76	.	.	.
18637	2611	1	"	"	``
18637	2611	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2611	3	821	821	CD
18637	2611	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2611	5	And	and	CC
18637	2611	6	"	"	``
18637	2611	7	more	more	RBR
18637	2611	8	recently	recently	RB
18637	2611	9	in	in	IN
18637	2611	10	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
18637	2611	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2611	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	2611	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2611	14	Washington,"[822	washington,"[822	ADD
18637	2611	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2611	16	the	the	DT
18637	2611	17	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2611	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2611	19	continued	continue	VBD
18637	2611	20	,	,	,
18637	2611	21	"	"	``
18637	2611	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2611	23	have	have	VBP
18637	2611	24	pointed	point	VBN
18637	2611	25	out	out	RP
18637	2611	26	that	that	IN
18637	2611	27	when	when	WRB
18637	2611	28	a	a	DT
18637	2611	29	State	state	NN
18637	2611	30	goes	go	VBZ
18637	2611	31	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	2611	32	safety	safety	NN
18637	2611	33	measures	measure	NNS
18637	2611	34	which	which	WDT
18637	2611	35	are	be	VBP
18637	2611	36	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	2611	37	because	because	IN
18637	2611	38	only	only	RB
18637	2611	39	local	local	JJ
18637	2611	40	in	in	IN
18637	2611	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2611	42	effect	effect	NN
18637	2611	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	2611	44	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2611	45	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2611	46	,	,	,
18637	2611	47	and	and	CC
18637	2611	48	'	'	``
18637	2611	49	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	2611	50	to	to	TO
18637	2611	51	impose	impose	VB
18637	2611	52	particular	particular	JJ
18637	2611	53	standards	standard	NNS
18637	2611	54	as	as	IN
18637	2611	55	to	to	IN
18637	2611	56	structure	structure	NN
18637	2611	57	,	,	,
18637	2611	58	design	design	NN
18637	2611	59	,	,	,
18637	2611	60	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	2611	61	and	and	CC
18637	2611	62	operation	operation	NN
18637	2611	63	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2611	64	of	of	IN
18637	2611	65	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2611	66	plying	ply	VBG
18637	2611	67	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2611	68	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2611	69	which	which	WDT
18637	2611	70	in	in	IN
18637	2611	71	the	the	DT
18637	2611	72	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	2611	73	of	of	IN
18637	2611	74	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2611	75	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	2611	76	may	may	MD
18637	2611	77	be	be	VB
18637	2611	78	desirable	desirable	JJ
18637	2611	79	but	but	CC
18637	2611	80	pass	pass	VB
18637	2611	81	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	2611	82	what	what	WP
18637	2611	83	is	be	VBZ
18637	2611	84	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	2611	85	essential	essential	JJ
18637	2611	86	to	to	IN
18637	2611	87	safety	safety	NN
18637	2611	88	and	and	CC
18637	2611	89	seaworthiness	seaworthiness	NN
18637	2611	90	,	,	,
18637	2611	91	the	the	DT
18637	2611	92	State	State	NNP
18637	2611	93	will	will	MD
18637	2611	94	encounter	encounter	VB
18637	2611	95	the	the	DT
18637	2611	96	principle	principle	NN
18637	2611	97	that	that	IN
18637	2611	98	such	such	JJ
18637	2611	99	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	2611	100	,	,	,
18637	2611	101	if	if	IN
18637	2611	102	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2611	103	at	at	RB
18637	2611	104	all	all	RB
18637	2611	105	,	,	,
18637	2611	106	must	must	MD
18637	2611	107	be	be	VB
18637	2611	108	through	through	IN
18637	2611	109	the	the	DT
18637	2611	110	action	action	NN
18637	2611	111	of	of	IN
18637	2611	112	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2611	113	which	which	WDT
18637	2611	114	can	can	MD
18637	2611	115	establish	establish	VB
18637	2611	116	a	a	DT
18637	2611	117	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2611	118	rule	rule	NN
18637	2611	119	.	.	.
18637	2612	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	2612	2	the	the	DT
18637	2612	3	State	State	NNP
18637	2612	4	in	in	IN
18637	2612	5	a	a	DT
18637	2612	6	particular	particular	JJ
18637	2612	7	matter	matter	NN
18637	2612	8	goes	go	VBZ
18637	2612	9	too	too	RB
18637	2612	10	far	far	RB
18637	2612	11	must	must	MD
18637	2612	12	be	be	VB
18637	2612	13	left	leave	VBN
18637	2612	14	to	to	TO
18637	2612	15	be	be	VB
18637	2612	16	determined	determine	VBN
18637	2612	17	when	when	WRB
18637	2612	18	the	the	DT
18637	2612	19	precise	precise	JJ
18637	2612	20	question	question	NN
18637	2612	21	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	2612	22	.	.	.
18637	2612	23	'	'	''
18637	2612	24	"	"	''
18637	2613	1	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2613	2	REGULATION	regulation	NN
18637	2613	3	OF	of	IN
18637	2613	4	LENGTH	LENGTH	NNP
18637	2613	5	OF	of	IN
18637	2613	6	TRAINS	train	NNS
18637	2613	7	Applying	apply	VBG
18637	2613	8	the	the	DT
18637	2613	9	test	test	NN
18637	2613	10	of	of	IN
18637	2613	11	these	these	DT
18637	2613	12	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	2613	13	,	,	,
18637	2613	14	the	the	DT
18637	2613	15	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2613	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2613	17	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	2613	18	that	that	IN
18637	2613	19	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	2613	20	,	,	,
18637	2613	21	in	in	IN
18637	2613	22	making	make	VBG
18637	2613	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2613	24	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	2613	25	to	to	TO
18637	2613	26	operate	operate	VB
18637	2613	27	within	within	IN
18637	2613	28	the	the	DT
18637	2613	29	State	State	NNP
18637	2613	30	a	a	DT
18637	2613	31	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2613	32	train	train	NN
18637	2613	33	of	of	IN
18637	2613	34	more	more	JJR
18637	2613	35	than	than	IN
18637	2613	36	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	2613	37	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	2613	38	or	or	CC
18637	2613	39	seventy	seventy	CD
18637	2613	40	freight	freight	NN
18637	2613	41	cars	car	NNS
18637	2613	42	,	,	,
18637	2613	43	had	have	VBD
18637	2613	44	gone	go	VBN
18637	2613	45	"	"	``
18637	2613	46	too	too	RB
18637	2613	47	far	far	RB
18637	2613	48	"	"	''
18637	2613	49	;	;	:
18637	2613	50	and	and	CC
18637	2613	51	in	in	IN
18637	2613	52	support	support	NN
18637	2613	53	of	of	IN
18637	2613	54	this	this	DT
18637	2613	55	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	2613	56	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2613	57	recites	recite	VBZ
18637	2613	58	the	the	DT
18637	2613	59	following	follow	VBG
18637	2613	60	facts	fact	NNS
18637	2613	61	:	:	:
18637	2613	62	"	"	``
18637	2613	63	In	in	IN
18637	2613	64	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	2613	65	,	,	,
18637	2613	66	approximately	approximately	RB
18637	2613	67	93	93	CD
18637	2613	68	%	%	NN
18637	2613	69	of	of	IN
18637	2613	70	the	the	DT
18637	2613	71	freight	freight	NN
18637	2613	72	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2613	73	and	and	CC
18637	2613	74	95	95	CD
18637	2613	75	%	%	NN
18637	2613	76	of	of	IN
18637	2613	77	the	the	DT
18637	2613	78	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	2613	79	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2613	80	is	be	VBZ
18637	2613	81	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2613	82	.	.	.
18637	2614	1	Because	because	IN
18637	2614	2	of	of	IN
18637	2614	3	the	the	DT
18637	2614	4	Train	Train	NNP
18637	2614	5	Limit	Limit	NNP
18637	2614	6	Law	Law	NNP
18637	2614	7	appellant	appellant	NN
18637	2614	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	2614	9	required	require	VBN
18637	2614	10	to	to	TO
18637	2614	11	haul	haul	VB
18637	2614	12	over	over	IN
18637	2614	13	30	30	CD
18637	2614	14	%	%	NN
18637	2614	15	more	more	JJR
18637	2614	16	trains	train	NNS
18637	2614	17	in	in	IN
18637	2614	18	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	2614	19	than	than	IN
18637	2614	20	would	would	MD
18637	2614	21	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2614	22	have	have	VB
18637	2614	23	been	be	VBN
18637	2614	24	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2614	25	.	.	.
18637	2615	1	The	the	DT
18637	2615	2	record	record	NN
18637	2615	3	shows	show	VBZ
18637	2615	4	a	a	DT
18637	2615	5	definite	definite	JJ
18637	2615	6	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	2615	7	between	between	IN
18637	2615	8	operating	operate	VBG
18637	2615	9	costs	cost	NNS
18637	2615	10	and	and	CC
18637	2615	11	the	the	DT
18637	2615	12	length	length	NN
18637	2615	13	of	of	IN
18637	2615	14	trains	train	NNS
18637	2615	15	,	,	,
18637	2615	16	the	the	DT
18637	2615	17	increase	increase	NN
18637	2615	18	in	in	IN
18637	2615	19	length	length	NN
18637	2615	20	resulting	result	VBG
18637	2615	21	in	in	IN
18637	2615	22	a	a	DT
18637	2615	23	reduction	reduction	NN
18637	2615	24	of	of	IN
18637	2615	25	operating	operating	NN
18637	2615	26	costs	cost	NNS
18637	2615	27	per	per	IN
18637	2615	28	car	car	NN
18637	2615	29	.	.	.
18637	2616	1	The	the	DT
18637	2616	2	additional	additional	JJ
18637	2616	3	cost	cost	NN
18637	2616	4	of	of	IN
18637	2616	5	operation	operation	NN
18637	2616	6	of	of	IN
18637	2616	7	trains	train	NNS
18637	2616	8	complying	comply	VBG
18637	2616	9	with	with	IN
18637	2616	10	the	the	DT
18637	2616	11	Train	Train	NNP
18637	2616	12	Limit	Limit	NNP
18637	2616	13	Law	Law	NNP
18637	2616	14	in	in	IN
18637	2616	15	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	2616	16	amounts	amount	VBZ
18637	2616	17	for	for	IN
18637	2616	18	the	the	DT
18637	2616	19	two	two	CD
18637	2616	20	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	2616	21	traversing	traverse	VBG
18637	2616	22	that	that	IN
18637	2616	23	State	State	NNP
18637	2616	24	to	to	IN
18637	2616	25	about	about	IN
18637	2616	26	$	$	$
18637	2616	27	1,000,000	1,000,000	CD
18637	2616	28	a	a	DT
18637	2616	29	year	year	NN
18637	2616	30	.	.	.
18637	2617	1	The	the	DT
18637	2617	2	reduction	reduction	NN
18637	2617	3	in	in	IN
18637	2617	4	train	train	NN
18637	2617	5	lengths	length	NNS
18637	2617	6	also	also	RB
18637	2617	7	impedes	impede	VBZ
18637	2617	8	efficient	efficient	JJ
18637	2617	9	operation	operation	NN
18637	2617	10	.	.	.
18637	2618	1	More	More	JJR
18637	2618	2	locomotives	locomotive	NNS
18637	2618	3	and	and	CC
18637	2618	4	more	more	JJR
18637	2618	5	manpower	manpower	NN
18637	2618	6	are	be	VBP
18637	2618	7	required	require	VBN
18637	2618	8	;	;	:
18637	2618	9	the	the	DT
18637	2618	10	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2618	11	conversion	conversion	NN
18637	2618	12	and	and	CC
18637	2618	13	reconversion	reconversion	NN
18637	2618	14	of	of	IN
18637	2618	15	train	train	NN
18637	2618	16	lengths	length	NNS
18637	2618	17	at	at	IN
18637	2618	18	terminals	terminal	NNS
18637	2618	19	and	and	CC
18637	2618	20	the	the	DT
18637	2618	21	delay	delay	NN
18637	2618	22	caused	cause	VBN
18637	2618	23	by	by	IN
18637	2618	24	breaking	break	VBG
18637	2618	25	up	up	RP
18637	2618	26	and	and	CC
18637	2618	27	remaking	remake	VBG
18637	2618	28	long	long	JJ
18637	2618	29	trains	train	NNS
18637	2618	30	upon	upon	IN
18637	2618	31	entering	enter	VBG
18637	2618	32	and	and	CC
18637	2618	33	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	2618	34	the	the	DT
18637	2618	35	state	state	NN
18637	2618	36	in	in	IN
18637	2618	37	order	order	NN
18637	2618	38	to	to	TO
18637	2618	39	comply	comply	VB
18637	2618	40	with	with	IN
18637	2618	41	the	the	DT
18637	2618	42	law	law	NN
18637	2618	43	,	,	,
18637	2618	44	delays	delay	VBZ
18637	2618	45	the	the	DT
18637	2618	46	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2618	47	and	and	CC
18637	2618	48	diminishes	diminish	VBZ
18637	2618	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2618	50	volume	volume	NN
18637	2618	51	moved	move	VBN
18637	2618	52	in	in	IN
18637	2618	53	a	a	DT
18637	2618	54	given	give	VBN
18637	2618	55	time	time	NN
18637	2618	56	,	,	,
18637	2618	57	especially	especially	RB
18637	2618	58	when	when	WRB
18637	2618	59	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2618	60	is	be	VBZ
18637	2618	61	heavy	heavy	JJ
18637	2618	62	.	.	.
18637	2619	1	"	"	``
18637	2619	2	At	at	IN
18637	2619	3	present	present	JJ
18637	2619	4	the	the	DT
18637	2619	5	seventy	seventy	CD
18637	2619	6	freight	freight	NN
18637	2619	7	car	car	NN
18637	2619	8	laws	law	NNS
18637	2619	9	are	be	VBP
18637	2619	10	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	2619	11	only	only	RB
18637	2619	12	in	in	IN
18637	2619	13	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	2619	14	and	and	CC
18637	2619	15	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	2619	16	,	,	,
18637	2619	17	with	with	IN
18637	2619	18	a	a	DT
18637	2619	19	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	2619	20	car	car	NN
18637	2619	21	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	2619	22	car	car	NN
18637	2619	23	limit	limit	NN
18637	2619	24	in	in	IN
18637	2619	25	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	2619	26	.	.	.
18637	2620	1	The	the	DT
18637	2620	2	record	record	NN
18637	2620	3	here	here	RB
18637	2620	4	shows	show	VBZ
18637	2620	5	that	that	IN
18637	2620	6	the	the	DT
18637	2620	7	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	2620	8	of	of	IN
18637	2620	9	the	the	DT
18637	2620	10	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	2620	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	2620	12	results	result	NNS
18637	2620	13	in	in	IN
18637	2620	14	freight	freight	NN
18637	2620	15	trains	train	NNS
18637	2620	16	being	be	VBG
18637	2620	17	broken	break	VBN
18637	2620	18	up	up	RP
18637	2620	19	and	and	CC
18637	2620	20	reformed	reform	VBD
18637	2620	21	at	at	IN
18637	2620	22	the	the	DT
18637	2620	23	California	California	NNP
18637	2620	24	border	border	NN
18637	2620	25	and	and	CC
18637	2620	26	in	in	IN
18637	2620	27	New	New	NNP
18637	2620	28	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	2620	29	,	,	,
18637	2620	30	some	some	DT
18637	2620	31	distance	distance	NN
18637	2620	32	from	from	IN
18637	2620	33	the	the	DT
18637	2620	34	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	2620	35	line	line	NN
18637	2620	36	.	.	.
18637	2621	1	Frequently	frequently	RB
18637	2621	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2621	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	2621	4	not	not	RB
18637	2621	5	feasible	feasible	JJ
18637	2621	6	to	to	TO
18637	2621	7	operate	operate	VB
18637	2621	8	a	a	DT
18637	2621	9	newly	newly	RB
18637	2621	10	assembled	assemble	VBN
18637	2621	11	train	train	NN
18637	2621	12	from	from	IN
18637	2621	13	the	the	DT
18637	2621	14	New	New	NNP
18637	2621	15	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	2621	16	yard	yard	NN
18637	2621	17	nearest	nearest	NN
18637	2621	18	to	to	IN
18637	2621	19	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	2621	20	,	,	,
18637	2621	21	with	with	IN
18637	2621	22	the	the	DT
18637	2621	23	result	result	NN
18637	2621	24	that	that	IN
18637	2621	25	the	the	DT
18637	2621	26	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	2621	27	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	2621	28	governs	govern	VBZ
18637	2621	29	the	the	DT
18637	2621	30	flow	flow	NN
18637	2621	31	of	of	IN
18637	2621	32	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2621	33	as	as	IN
18637	2621	34	far	far	RB
18637	2621	35	east	east	RB
18637	2621	36	as	as	IN
18637	2621	37	El	El	NNP
18637	2621	38	Paso	Paso	NNP
18637	2621	39	,	,	,
18637	2621	40	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	2621	41	.	.	.
18637	2622	1	For	for	IN
18637	2622	2	similar	similar	JJ
18637	2622	3	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	2622	4	the	the	DT
18637	2622	5	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	2622	6	law	law	NN
18637	2622	7	often	often	RB
18637	2622	8	controls	control	VBZ
18637	2622	9	the	the	DT
18637	2622	10	length	length	NN
18637	2622	11	of	of	IN
18637	2622	12	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	2622	13	trains	train	NNS
18637	2622	14	all	all	PDT
18637	2622	15	the	the	DT
18637	2622	16	way	way	NN
18637	2622	17	from	from	IN
18637	2622	18	Los	Los	NNP
18637	2622	19	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	2622	20	to	to	IN
18637	2622	21	El	El	NNP
18637	2622	22	Paso	Paso	NNP
18637	2622	23	.	.	.
18637	2623	1	"	"	``
18637	2623	2	If	if	IN
18637	2623	3	one	one	CD
18637	2623	4	State	State	NNP
18637	2623	5	may	may	MD
18637	2623	6	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2623	7	train	train	NN
18637	2623	8	lengths	length	NNS
18637	2623	9	,	,	,
18637	2623	10	so	so	RB
18637	2623	11	may	may	MD
18637	2623	12	all	all	PDT
18637	2623	13	the	the	DT
18637	2623	14	others	other	NNS
18637	2623	15	,	,	,
18637	2623	16	and	and	CC
18637	2623	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2623	18	need	nee	MD
18637	2623	19	not	not	RB
18637	2623	20	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	2623	21	the	the	DT
18637	2623	22	same	same	JJ
18637	2623	23	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	2623	24	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	2623	25	.	.	.
18637	2624	1	The	the	DT
18637	2624	2	practical	practical	JJ
18637	2624	3	effect	effect	NN
18637	2624	4	of	of	IN
18637	2624	5	such	such	JJ
18637	2624	6	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2624	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	2624	8	to	to	TO
18637	2624	9	control	control	VB
18637	2624	10	train	train	NN
18637	2624	11	operations	operation	NNS
18637	2624	12	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	2624	13	the	the	DT
18637	2624	14	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	2624	15	of	of	IN
18637	2624	16	the	the	DT
18637	2624	17	State	State	NNP
18637	2624	18	exacting	exact	VBG
18637	2624	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2624	20	because	because	IN
18637	2624	21	of	of	IN
18637	2624	22	the	the	DT
18637	2624	23	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	2624	24	of	of	IN
18637	2624	25	breaking	break	VBG
18637	2624	26	up	up	RP
18637	2624	27	and	and	CC
18637	2624	28	reassembling	reassemble	VBG
18637	2624	29	long	long	JJ
18637	2624	30	trains	train	NNS
18637	2624	31	at	at	IN
18637	2624	32	the	the	DT
18637	2624	33	nearest	near	JJS
18637	2624	34	terminal	terminal	JJ
18637	2624	35	points	point	NNS
18637	2624	36	before	before	IN
18637	2624	37	entering	enter	VBG
18637	2624	38	and	and	CC
18637	2624	39	after	after	IN
18637	2624	40	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	2624	41	the	the	DT
18637	2624	42	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	2624	43	State	State	NNP
18637	2624	44	.	.	.
18637	2625	1	The	the	DT
18637	2625	2	serious	serious	JJ
18637	2625	3	impediment	impediment	NN
18637	2625	4	to	to	IN
18637	2625	5	the	the	DT
18637	2625	6	free	free	JJ
18637	2625	7	flow	flow	NN
18637	2625	8	of	of	IN
18637	2625	9	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2625	10	by	by	IN
18637	2625	11	the	the	DT
18637	2625	12	local	local	JJ
18637	2625	13	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2625	14	of	of	IN
18637	2625	15	train	train	NN
18637	2625	16	lengths	length	NNS
18637	2625	17	and	and	CC
18637	2625	18	the	the	DT
18637	2625	19	practical	practical	JJ
18637	2625	20	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	2625	21	that	that	IN
18637	2625	22	such	such	JJ
18637	2625	23	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2625	24	,	,	,
18637	2625	25	if	if	IN
18637	2625	26	any	any	DT
18637	2625	27	,	,	,
18637	2625	28	must	must	MD
18637	2625	29	be	be	VB
18637	2625	30	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	2625	31	by	by	IN
18637	2625	32	a	a	DT
18637	2625	33	single	single	JJ
18637	2625	34	body	body	NN
18637	2625	35	having	have	VBG
18637	2625	36	a	a	DT
18637	2625	37	nation	nation	NN
18637	2625	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	2625	39	wide	wide	JJ
18637	2625	40	authority	authority	NN
18637	2625	41	are	be	VBP
18637	2625	42	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	2625	43	.	.	.
18637	2626	1	"	"	``
18637	2626	2	The	the	DT
18637	2626	3	trial	trial	NN
18637	2626	4	court	court	NN
18637	2626	5	found	find	VBD
18637	2626	6	that	that	IN
18637	2626	7	the	the	DT
18637	2626	8	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	2626	9	law	law	NN
18637	2626	10	had	have	VBD
18637	2626	11	no	no	DT
18637	2626	12	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2626	13	relation	relation	NN
18637	2626	14	to	to	IN
18637	2626	15	safety	safety	NN
18637	2626	16	,	,	,
18637	2626	17	and	and	CC
18637	2626	18	made	make	VBD
18637	2626	19	train	train	NN
18637	2626	20	operation	operation	NN
18637	2626	21	more	more	RBR
18637	2626	22	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	2626	23	.	.	.
18637	2627	1	Examination	examination	NN
18637	2627	2	of	of	IN
18637	2627	3	the	the	DT
18637	2627	4	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	2627	5	and	and	CC
18637	2627	6	the	the	DT
18637	2627	7	detailed	detailed	JJ
18637	2627	8	findings	finding	NNS
18637	2627	9	makes	make	VBZ
18637	2627	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2627	11	clear	clear	JJ
18637	2627	12	that	that	IN
18637	2627	13	this	this	DT
18637	2627	14	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	2627	15	was	be	VBD
18637	2627	16	rested	rest	VBN
18637	2627	17	on	on	IN
18637	2627	18	facts	fact	NNS
18637	2627	19	found	find	VBD
18637	2627	20	which	which	WDT
18637	2627	21	indicate	indicate	VBP
18637	2627	22	that	that	IN
18637	2627	23	such	such	JJ
18637	2627	24	increased	increase	VBN
18637	2627	25	danger	danger	NN
18637	2627	26	of	of	IN
18637	2627	27	accident	accident	NN
18637	2627	28	and	and	CC
18637	2627	29	personal	personal	JJ
18637	2627	30	injury	injury	NN
18637	2627	31	as	as	IN
18637	2627	32	may	may	MD
18637	2627	33	result	result	VB
18637	2627	34	from	from	IN
18637	2627	35	the	the	DT
18637	2627	36	greater	great	JJR
18637	2627	37	length	length	NN
18637	2627	38	of	of	IN
18637	2627	39	trains	train	NNS
18637	2627	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	2627	41	more	more	JJR
18637	2627	42	than	than	IN
18637	2627	43	offset	offset	VBN
18637	2627	44	by	by	IN
18637	2627	45	the	the	DT
18637	2627	46	increase	increase	NN
18637	2627	47	in	in	IN
18637	2627	48	the	the	DT
18637	2627	49	number	number	NN
18637	2627	50	of	of	IN
18637	2627	51	accidents	accident	NNS
18637	2627	52	resulting	result	VBG
18637	2627	53	from	from	IN
18637	2627	54	the	the	DT
18637	2627	55	larger	large	JJR
18637	2627	56	number	number	NN
18637	2627	57	of	of	IN
18637	2627	58	trains	train	NNS
18637	2627	59	when	when	WRB
18637	2627	60	train	train	NN
18637	2627	61	lengths	length	NNS
18637	2627	62	are	be	VBP
18637	2627	63	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	2627	64	.	.	.
18637	2628	1	In	in	IN
18637	2628	2	considering	consider	VBG
18637	2628	3	the	the	DT
18637	2628	4	effect	effect	NN
18637	2628	5	of	of	IN
18637	2628	6	the	the	DT
18637	2628	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	2628	8	as	as	IN
18637	2628	9	a	a	DT
18637	2628	10	safety	safety	NN
18637	2628	11	measure	measure	NN
18637	2628	12	,	,	,
18637	2628	13	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	2628	14	,	,	,
18637	2628	15	the	the	DT
18637	2628	16	factor	factor	NN
18637	2628	17	of	of	IN
18637	2628	18	controlling	control	VBG
18637	2628	19	significance	significance	NN
18637	2628	20	for	for	IN
18637	2628	21	present	present	JJ
18637	2628	22	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	2628	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	2628	24	not	not	RB
18637	2628	25	whether	whether	IN
18637	2628	26	there	there	EX
18637	2628	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	2628	28	basis	basis	NN
18637	2628	29	for	for	IN
18637	2628	30	the	the	DT
18637	2628	31	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	2628	32	of	of	IN
18637	2628	33	the	the	DT
18637	2628	34	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	2628	35	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2628	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2628	37	that	that	IN
18637	2628	38	the	the	DT
18637	2628	39	increase	increase	NN
18637	2628	40	in	in	IN
18637	2628	41	length	length	NN
18637	2628	42	of	of	IN
18637	2628	43	trains	train	NNS
18637	2628	44	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	2628	45	the	the	DT
18637	2628	46	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	2628	47	maximum	maximum	NN
18637	2628	48	has	have	VBZ
18637	2628	49	an	an	DT
18637	2628	50	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	2628	51	effect	effect	NN
18637	2628	52	upon	upon	IN
18637	2628	53	safety	safety	NN
18637	2628	54	of	of	IN
18637	2628	55	operation	operation	NN
18637	2628	56	.	.	.
18637	2629	1	The	the	DT
18637	2629	2	decisive	decisive	JJ
18637	2629	3	question	question	NN
18637	2629	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	2629	5	whether	whether	IN
18637	2629	6	in	in	IN
18637	2629	7	the	the	DT
18637	2629	8	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	2629	9	the	the	DT
18637	2629	10	total	total	JJ
18637	2629	11	effect	effect	NN
18637	2629	12	of	of	IN
18637	2629	13	the	the	DT
18637	2629	14	law	law	NN
18637	2629	15	as	as	IN
18637	2629	16	a	a	DT
18637	2629	17	safety	safety	NN
18637	2629	18	measure	measure	NN
18637	2629	19	in	in	IN
18637	2629	20	reducing	reduce	VBG
18637	2629	21	accidents	accident	NNS
18637	2629	22	and	and	CC
18637	2629	23	casualties	casualty	NNS
18637	2629	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	2629	25	so	so	RB
18637	2629	26	slight	slight	JJ
18637	2629	27	or	or	CC
18637	2629	28	problematical	problematical	JJ
18637	2629	29	as	as	IN
18637	2629	30	not	not	RB
18637	2629	31	to	to	TO
18637	2629	32	outweigh	outweigh	VB
18637	2629	33	the	the	DT
18637	2629	34	national	national	JJ
18637	2629	35	interest	interest	NN
18637	2629	36	in	in	IN
18637	2629	37	keeping	keep	VBG
18637	2629	38	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2629	39	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2629	40	free	free	JJ
18637	2629	41	from	from	IN
18637	2629	42	interferences	interference	NNS
18637	2629	43	which	which	WDT
18637	2629	44	seriously	seriously	RB
18637	2629	45	impede	impede	VBP
18637	2629	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2629	47	and	and	CC
18637	2629	48	subject	subject	VB
18637	2629	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2629	50	to	to	IN
18637	2629	51	local	local	JJ
18637	2629	52	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2629	53	which	which	WDT
18637	2629	54	does	do	VBZ
18637	2629	55	not	not	RB
18637	2629	56	have	have	VB
18637	2629	57	a	a	DT
18637	2629	58	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2629	59	effect	effect	NN
18637	2629	60	on	on	IN
18637	2629	61	the	the	DT
18637	2629	62	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2629	63	train	train	NN
18637	2629	64	journey	journey	NN
18637	2629	65	which	which	WDT
18637	2629	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2629	67	interrupts	interrupt	VBZ
18637	2629	68	.	.	.
18637	2630	1	"	"	``
18637	2630	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2630	3	823	823	CD
18637	2630	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2630	5	THE	the	DT
18637	2630	6	LESSON	LESSON	NNP
18637	2630	7	OF	of	IN
18637	2630	8	SOUTHERN	SOUTHERN	NNP
18637	2630	9	PACIFIC	PACIFIC	NNP
18637	2630	10	CO	CO	NNP
18637	2630	11	.	.	.
18637	2630	12	_	_	NNP
18637	2630	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	2630	14	_	_	NNP
18637	2630	15	ARIZONA	ARIZONA	NNP
18637	2630	16	The	the	DT
18637	2630	17	lesson	lesson	NN
18637	2630	18	to	to	TO
18637	2630	19	be	be	VB
18637	2630	20	extracted	extract	VBN
18637	2630	21	from	from	IN
18637	2630	22	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	2630	23	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	2630	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2630	25	_	_	NNP
18637	2630	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	2630	27	_	_	NNP
18637	2630	28	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	2630	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	2630	30	a	a	DT
18637	2630	31	threefold	threefold	JJ
18637	2630	32	one	one	CD
18637	2630	33	:	:	:
18637	2630	34	1	1	LS
18637	2630	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2630	36	Where	where	WRB
18637	2630	37	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	2630	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	2630	39	judged	judge	VBN
18637	2630	40	by	by	IN
18637	2630	41	the	the	DT
18637	2630	42	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2630	43	to	to	TO
18637	2630	44	be	be	VB
18637	2630	45	"	"	``
18637	2630	46	essential	essential	JJ
18637	2630	47	for	for	IN
18637	2630	48	the	the	DT
18637	2630	49	functioning	functioning	NN
18637	2630	50	of	of	IN
18637	2630	51	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2630	52	,	,	,
18637	2630	53	a	a	DT
18637	2630	54	State	State	NNP
18637	2630	55	may	may	MD
18637	2630	56	not	not	RB
18637	2630	57	interpose	interpose	VB
18637	2630	58	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2630	59	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2630	60	"	"	''
18637	2630	61	;	;	:
18637	2630	62	2	2	LS
18637	2630	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2630	64	in	in	IN
18637	2630	65	resolving	resolve	VBG
18637	2630	66	this	this	DT
18637	2630	67	question	question	NN
18637	2630	68	the	the	DT
18637	2630	69	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2630	70	will	will	MD
18637	2630	71	canvass	canvass	VB
18637	2630	72	what	what	WP
18637	2630	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2630	74	considers	consider	VBZ
18637	2630	75	to	to	TO
18637	2630	76	be	be	VB
18637	2630	77	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	2630	78	facts	fact	NNS
18637	2630	79	extensively	extensively	RB
18637	2630	80	;	;	:
18637	2630	81	3	3	LS
18637	2630	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2630	83	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2630	84	task	task	NN
18637	2630	85	is	be	VBZ
18637	2630	86	,	,	,
18637	2630	87	however	however	RB
18637	2630	88	,	,	,
18637	2630	89	in	in	IN
18637	2630	90	the	the	DT
18637	2630	91	last	last	JJ
18637	2630	92	analysis	analysis	NN
18637	2630	93	,	,	,
18637	2630	94	one	one	CD
18637	2630	95	of	of	IN
18637	2630	96	weighing	weigh	VBG
18637	2630	97	competing	compete	VBG
18637	2630	98	values	value	NNS
18637	2630	99	,	,	,
18637	2630	100	in	in	IN
18637	2630	101	brief	brief	JJ
18637	2630	102	,	,	,
18637	2630	103	arbitral	arbitral	JJ
18637	2630	104	rather	rather	RB
18637	2630	105	than	than	IN
18637	2630	106	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	2630	107	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	2630	108	.	.	.
18637	2631	1	The	the	DT
18637	2631	2	lesson	lesson	NN
18637	2631	3	of	of	IN
18637	2631	4	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	2631	5	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	2631	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2631	7	further	further	RB
18637	2631	8	exemplified	exemplify	VBN
18637	2631	9	by	by	IN
18637	2631	10	the	the	DT
18637	2631	11	more	more	RBR
18637	2631	12	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2631	13	holding	holding	NN
18637	2631	14	in	in	IN
18637	2631	15	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	2631	16	_	_	NNP
18637	2631	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	2631	18	_	_	NNP
18637	2631	19	Virginia,[824	Virginia,[824	NNP
18637	2631	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2631	21	in	in	IN
18637	2631	22	which	which	WDT
18637	2631	23	the	the	DT
18637	2631	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2631	25	was	be	VBD
18637	2631	26	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	2631	27	with	with	IN
18637	2631	28	a	a	DT
18637	2631	29	State	State	NNP
18637	2631	30	statute	statute	NN
18637	2631	31	which	which	WDT
18637	2631	32	,	,	,
18637	2631	33	in	in	IN
18637	2631	34	providing	provide	VBG
18637	2631	35	for	for	IN
18637	2631	36	the	the	DT
18637	2631	37	segregation	segregation	NN
18637	2631	38	of	of	IN
18637	2631	39	white	white	JJ
18637	2631	40	and	and	CC
18637	2631	41	colored	colored	JJ
18637	2631	42	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	2631	43	,	,	,
18637	2631	44	required	require	VBN
18637	2631	45	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	2631	46	to	to	TO
18637	2631	47	change	change	VB
18637	2631	48	seats	seat	NNS
18637	2631	49	from	from	IN
18637	2631	50	time	time	NN
18637	2631	51	to	to	IN
18637	2631	52	time	time	NN
18637	2631	53	as	as	IN
18637	2631	54	might	may	MD
18637	2631	55	become	become	VB
18637	2631	56	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2631	57	to	to	TO
18637	2631	58	increase	increase	VB
18637	2631	59	the	the	DT
18637	2631	60	number	number	NN
18637	2631	61	of	of	IN
18637	2631	62	seats	seat	NNS
18637	2631	63	available	available	JJ
18637	2631	64	to	to	IN
18637	2631	65	the	the	DT
18637	2631	66	one	one	CD
18637	2631	67	race	race	NN
18637	2631	68	or	or	CC
18637	2631	69	the	the	DT
18637	2631	70	other	other	JJ
18637	2631	71	.	.	.
18637	2632	1	First	first	RB
18637	2632	2	,	,	,
18637	2632	3	reciting	recite	VBG
18637	2632	4	the	the	DT
18637	2632	5	rule	rule	NN
18637	2632	6	of	of	IN
18637	2632	7	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	2632	8	,	,	,
18637	2632	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2632	10	Heed	Heed	NNP
18637	2632	11	,	,	,
18637	2632	12	for	for	IN
18637	2632	13	the	the	DT
18637	2632	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2632	15	,	,	,
18637	2632	16	said	say	VBD
18637	2632	17	:	:	:
18637	2632	18	"	"	``
18637	2632	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2632	20	,	,	,
18637	2632	21	within	within	IN
18637	2632	22	the	the	DT
18637	2632	23	limits	limit	NNS
18637	2632	24	of	of	IN
18637	2632	25	the	the	DT
18637	2632	26	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	2632	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	2632	28	,	,	,
18637	2632	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	2632	30	authority	authority	NN
18637	2632	31	to	to	IN
18637	2632	32	burden	burden	NN
18637	2632	33	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2632	34	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2632	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2632	36	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2632	37	if	if	IN
18637	2632	38	that	that	DT
18637	2632	39	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	2632	40	to	to	IN
18637	2632	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2632	42	a	a	DT
18637	2632	43	desirable	desirable	JJ
18637	2632	44	means	mean	NNS
18637	2632	45	of	of	IN
18637	2632	46	accomplishing	accomplish	VBG
18637	2632	47	a	a	DT
18637	2632	48	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	2632	49	end	end	NN
18637	2632	50	.	.	.
18637	2633	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2633	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2633	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2633	4	As	as	IN
18637	2633	5	no	no	DT
18637	2633	6	State	State	NNP
18637	2633	7	law	law	NN
18637	2633	8	can	can	MD
18637	2633	9	reach	reach	VB
18637	2633	10	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	2633	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2633	12	own	own	JJ
18637	2633	13	border	border	NN
18637	2633	14	nor	nor	CC
18637	2633	15	bar	bar	NN
18637	2633	16	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2633	17	of	of	IN
18637	2633	18	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	2633	19	across	across	IN
18637	2633	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2633	21	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	2633	22	,	,	,
18637	2633	23	diverse	diverse	JJ
18637	2633	24	seating	seating	NN
18637	2633	25	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	2633	26	for	for	IN
18637	2633	27	the	the	DT
18637	2633	28	races	race	NNS
18637	2633	29	in	in	IN
18637	2633	30	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2633	31	journeys	journey	NNS
18637	2633	32	result	result	VBP
18637	2633	33	.	.	.
18637	2634	1	As	as	IN
18637	2634	2	there	there	EX
18637	2634	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	2634	4	no	no	DT
18637	2634	5	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2634	6	act	act	NN
18637	2634	7	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	2634	8	with	with	IN
18637	2634	9	the	the	DT
18637	2634	10	separation	separation	NN
18637	2634	11	of	of	IN
18637	2634	12	races	race	NNS
18637	2634	13	in	in	IN
18637	2634	14	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2634	15	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2634	16	,	,	,
18637	2634	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2634	18	must	must	MD
18637	2634	19	decide	decide	VB
18637	2634	20	the	the	DT
18637	2634	21	validity	validity	NN
18637	2634	22	of	of	IN
18637	2634	23	this	this	DT
18637	2634	24	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	2634	25	statute	statute	NN
18637	2634	26	on	on	IN
18637	2634	27	the	the	DT
18637	2634	28	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	2634	29	that	that	WDT
18637	2634	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2634	31	interferes	interfere	VBZ
18637	2634	32	with	with	IN
18637	2634	33	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2634	34	,	,	,
18637	2634	35	as	as	IN
18637	2634	36	a	a	DT
18637	2634	37	matter	matter	NN
18637	2634	38	of	of	IN
18637	2634	39	balance	balance	NN
18637	2634	40	between	between	IN
18637	2634	41	the	the	DT
18637	2634	42	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2634	43	of	of	IN
18637	2634	44	the	the	DT
18637	2634	45	local	local	JJ
18637	2634	46	police	police	NN
18637	2634	47	power	power	NN
18637	2634	48	and	and	CC
18637	2634	49	the	the	DT
18637	2634	50	need	need	NN
18637	2634	51	for	for	IN
18637	2634	52	national	national	JJ
18637	2634	53	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	2634	54	in	in	IN
18637	2634	55	the	the	DT
18637	2634	56	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2634	57	for	for	IN
18637	2634	58	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2634	59	travel	travel	NN
18637	2634	60	.	.	.
18637	2635	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2635	2	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	2635	3	clear	clear	JJ
18637	2635	4	to	to	IN
18637	2635	5	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2635	6	that	that	IN
18637	2635	7	seating	seat	VBG
18637	2635	8	arrangements	arrangement	NNS
18637	2635	9	for	for	IN
18637	2635	10	the	the	DT
18637	2635	11	different	different	JJ
18637	2635	12	races	race	NNS
18637	2635	13	in	in	IN
18637	2635	14	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2635	15	motor	motor	NN
18637	2635	16	travel	travel	NN
18637	2635	17	require	require	VBP
18637	2635	18	a	a	DT
18637	2635	19	single	single	JJ
18637	2635	20	,	,	,
18637	2635	21	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2635	22	rule	rule	NN
18637	2635	23	to	to	TO
18637	2635	24	promote	promote	VB
18637	2635	25	and	and	CC
18637	2635	26	protect	protect	VB
18637	2635	27	national	national	JJ
18637	2635	28	travel	travel	NN
18637	2635	29	.	.	.
18637	2636	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	2636	2	,	,	,
18637	2636	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2636	4	hold	hold	VBP
18637	2636	5	the	the	DT
18637	2636	6	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	2636	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	2636	8	in	in	IN
18637	2636	9	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	2636	10	invalid	invalid	NNP
18637	2636	11	.	.	.
18637	2636	12	"	"	''
18637	2637	1	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2637	2	REGULATION	REGULATION	NNP
18637	2637	3	OF	of	IN
18637	2637	4	MOTOR	MOTOR	NNP
18637	2637	5	VEHICLES	VEHICLES	NNP
18637	2637	6	;	;	:
18637	2637	7	VALID	VALID	NNP
18637	2637	8	REGULATIONS	regulation	NNS
18637	2637	9	Cases	case	NNS
18637	2637	10	arising	arise	VBG
18637	2637	11	under	under	IN
18637	2637	12	this	this	DT
18637	2637	13	caption	caption	NN
18637	2637	14	further	further	RB
18637	2637	15	illustrate	illustrate	VB
18637	2637	16	the	the	DT
18637	2637	17	competition	competition	NN
18637	2637	18	for	for	IN
18637	2637	19	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	2637	20	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	2637	21	between	between	IN
18637	2637	22	the	the	DT
18637	2637	23	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2637	24	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2637	25	interest	interest	NN
18637	2637	26	and	and	CC
18637	2637	27	local	local	JJ
18637	2637	28	interests	interest	NNS
18637	2637	29	,	,	,
18637	2637	30	especially	especially	RB
18637	2637	31	that	that	DT
18637	2637	32	of	of	IN
18637	2637	33	public	public	JJ
18637	2637	34	safety	safety	NN
18637	2637	35	.	.	.
18637	2638	1	A	a	DT
18637	2638	2	new	new	JJ
18637	2638	3	element	element	NN
18637	2638	4	enters	enter	VBZ
18637	2638	5	the	the	DT
18637	2638	6	problem	problem	NN
18637	2638	7	,	,	,
18637	2638	8	however	however	RB
18637	2638	9	,	,	,
18637	2638	10	which	which	WDT
18637	2638	11	lends	lend	VBZ
18637	2638	12	some	some	DT
18637	2638	13	added	add	VBN
18637	2638	14	weight	weight	NN
18637	2638	15	to	to	IN
18637	2638	16	the	the	DT
18637	2638	17	claims	claim	NNS
18637	2638	18	of	of	IN
18637	2638	19	the	the	DT
18637	2638	20	police	police	NN
18637	2638	21	power	power	NN
18637	2638	22	,	,	,
18637	2638	23	the	the	DT
18637	2638	24	fact	fact	NN
18637	2638	25	,	,	,
18637	2638	26	namely	namely	RB
18637	2638	27	,	,	,
18637	2638	28	that	that	DT
18637	2638	29	motor	motor	NN
18637	2638	30	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2638	31	use	use	VBP
18637	2638	32	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2638	33	furnished	furnish	VBD
18637	2638	34	and	and	CC
18637	2638	35	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	2638	36	by	by	IN
18637	2638	37	the	the	DT
18637	2638	38	State	State	NNP
18637	2638	39	.	.	.
18637	2639	1	A	a	DT
18637	2639	2	State	state	NN
18637	2639	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	2639	4	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	2639	5	to	to	TO
18637	2639	6	enact	enact	VB
18637	2639	7	a	a	DT
18637	2639	8	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	2639	9	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	2639	10	for	for	IN
18637	2639	11	the	the	DT
18637	2639	12	licensing	licensing	NN
18637	2639	13	and	and	CC
18637	2639	14	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2639	15	of	of	IN
18637	2639	16	motor	motor	NN
18637	2639	17	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2639	18	using	use	VBG
18637	2639	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2639	20	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2639	21	with	with	IN
18637	2639	22	a	a	DT
18637	2639	23	view	view	NN
18637	2639	24	to	to	IN
18637	2639	25	insuring	insure	VBG
18637	2639	26	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2639	27	of	of	IN
18637	2639	28	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2639	29	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	2639	30	for	for	IN
18637	2639	31	the	the	DT
18637	2639	32	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	2639	33	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	2639	34	and	and	CC
18637	2639	35	to	to	IN
18637	2639	36	providing	provide	VBG
18637	2639	37	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	2639	38	protection	protection	NN
18637	2639	39	of	of	IN
18637	2639	40	the	the	DT
18637	2639	41	public	public	JJ
18637	2639	42	safety	safety	NN
18637	2639	43	;	;	:
18637	2639	44	and	and	CC
18637	2639	45	such	such	JJ
18637	2639	46	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	2639	47	may	may	MD
18637	2639	48	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	2639	49	out	out	RP
18637	2639	50	-	-	HYPH
18637	2639	51	of	of	IN
18637	2639	52	-	-	HYPH
18637	2639	53	State	state	NN
18637	2639	54	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2639	55	using	use	VBG
18637	2639	56	the	the	DT
18637	2639	57	State	State	NNP
18637	2639	58	's	's	POS
18637	2639	59	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2639	60	.	.	.
18637	2640	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2640	2	825	825	CD
18637	2640	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2640	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2640	5	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2640	6	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	2640	7	the	the	DT
18637	2640	8	net	net	JJ
18637	2640	9	loads	load	NNS
18637	2640	10	of	of	IN
18637	2640	11	trucks	truck	NNS
18637	2640	12	using	use	VBG
18637	2640	13	the	the	DT
18637	2640	14	State	State	NNP
18637	2640	15	's	's	POS
18637	2640	16	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2640	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	2640	18	valid;[826	valid;[826	NNS
18637	2640	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2640	20	as	as	IN
18637	2640	21	are	be	VBP
18637	2640	22	also	also	RB
18637	2640	23	,	,	,
18637	2640	24	in	in	IN
18637	2640	25	the	the	DT
18637	2640	26	absence	absence	NN
18637	2640	27	of	of	IN
18637	2640	28	national	national	JJ
18637	2640	29	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2640	30	on	on	IN
18637	2640	31	the	the	DT
18637	2640	32	subject	subject	NN
18637	2640	33	,	,	,
18637	2640	34	State	State	NNP
18637	2640	35	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2640	36	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	2640	37	the	the	DT
18637	2640	38	weight	weight	NN
18637	2640	39	and	and	CC
18637	2640	40	width	width	NN
18637	2640	41	of	of	IN
18637	2640	42	the	the	DT
18637	2640	43	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2640	44	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2640	45	,	,	,
18637	2640	46	provided	provide	VBD
18637	2640	47	such	such	JJ
18637	2640	48	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2640	49	are	be	VBP
18637	2640	50	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2640	51	without	without	IN
18637	2640	52	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	2640	53	as	as	IN
18637	2640	54	between	between	IN
18637	2640	55	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2640	56	moving	move	VBG
18637	2640	57	in	in	IN
18637	2640	58	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2640	59	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2640	60	and	and	CC
18637	2640	61	those	those	DT
18637	2640	62	operating	operate	VBG
18637	2640	63	only	only	RB
18637	2640	64	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2640	65	.	.	.
18637	2641	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2641	2	827	827	CD
18637	2641	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2641	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	2641	5	,	,	,
18637	2641	6	a	a	DT
18637	2641	7	State	state	NN
18637	2641	8	may	may	MD
18637	2641	9	deny	deny	VB
18637	2641	10	a	a	DT
18637	2641	11	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	2641	12	of	of	IN
18637	2641	13	public	public	JJ
18637	2641	14	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	2641	15	and	and	CC
18637	2641	16	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	2641	17	to	to	IN
18637	2641	18	one	one	CD
18637	2641	19	desiring	desire	VBG
18637	2641	20	to	to	TO
18637	2641	21	operate	operate	VB
18637	2641	22	a	a	DT
18637	2641	23	common	common	JJ
18637	2641	24	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2641	25	over	over	IN
18637	2641	26	a	a	DT
18637	2641	27	particular	particular	JJ
18637	2641	28	highway	highway	NN
18637	2641	29	to	to	IN
18637	2641	30	an	an	DT
18637	2641	31	out	out	JJ
18637	2641	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	2641	33	of	of	IN
18637	2641	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	2641	35	State	state	NN
18637	2641	36	destination	destination	NN
18637	2641	37	in	in	IN
18637	2641	38	an	an	DT
18637	2641	39	adjacent	adjacent	JJ
18637	2641	40	State	State	NNP
18637	2641	41	,	,	,
18637	2641	42	on	on	IN
18637	2641	43	the	the	DT
18637	2641	44	ground	ground	NN
18637	2641	45	that	that	IN
18637	2641	46	the	the	DT
18637	2641	47	specified	specify	VBN
18637	2641	48	route	route	NN
18637	2641	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	2641	50	already	already	RB
18637	2641	51	congested	congest	VBN
18637	2641	52	.	.	.
18637	2642	1	So	so	RB
18637	2642	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2642	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2642	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	2642	5	in	in	IN
18637	2642	6	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	2642	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2642	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	2642	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2642	10	Public	Public	NNP
18637	2642	11	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	2642	12	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2642	13	of	of	IN
18637	2642	14	Ohio,[828	Ohio,[828	NNP
18637	2642	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2642	16	in	in	IN
18637	2642	17	which	which	WDT
18637	2642	18	the	the	DT
18637	2642	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2642	20	took	take	VBD
18637	2642	21	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	2642	22	of	of	IN
18637	2642	23	the	the	DT
18637	2642	24	full	full	JJ
18637	2642	25	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	2642	26	accorded	accord	VBD
18637	2642	27	the	the	DT
18637	2642	28	appellant	appellant	NN
18637	2642	29	,	,	,
18637	2642	30	and	and	CC
18637	2642	31	of	of	IN
18637	2642	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2642	33	failure	failure	NN
18637	2642	34	to	to	TO
18637	2642	35	choose	choose	VB
18637	2642	36	another	another	DT
18637	2642	37	route	route	NN
18637	2642	38	,	,	,
18637	2642	39	although	although	IN
18637	2642	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2642	41	was	be	VBD
18637	2642	42	at	at	IN
18637	2642	43	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	2642	44	to	to	TO
18637	2642	45	do	do	VB
18637	2642	46	so	so	RB
18637	2642	47	.	.	.
18637	2643	1	And	and	CC
18637	2643	2	in	in	IN
18637	2643	3	Maurer	Maurer	NNP
18637	2643	4	_	_	NNP
18637	2643	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	2643	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2643	7	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	2643	8	a	a	DT
18637	2643	9	Pennsylvania[829	Pennsylvania[829	NNP
18637	2643	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2643	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	2643	12	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	2643	13	the	the	DT
18637	2643	14	operation	operation	NN
18637	2643	15	over	over	IN
18637	2643	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2643	17	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2643	18	of	of	IN
18637	2643	19	any	any	DT
18637	2643	20	motor	motor	NN
18637	2643	21	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	2643	22	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	2643	23	any	any	DT
18637	2643	24	other	other	JJ
18637	2643	25	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	2643	26	over	over	IN
18637	2643	27	the	the	DT
18637	2643	28	head	head	NN
18637	2643	29	of	of	IN
18637	2643	30	the	the	DT
18637	2643	31	operator	operator	NN
18637	2643	32	was	be	VBD
18637	2643	33	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	2643	34	in	in	IN
18637	2643	35	the	the	DT
18637	2643	36	absence	absence	NN
18637	2643	37	of	of	IN
18637	2643	38	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	2643	39	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2643	40	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2643	41	.	.	.
18637	2644	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	2644	2	,	,	,
18637	2644	3	in	in	IN
18637	2644	4	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	2644	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2644	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	2644	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2644	8	New	New	NNP
18637	2644	9	Hampshire[830	Hampshire[830	NNP
18637	2644	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2644	11	a	a	DT
18637	2644	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	2644	13	of	of	IN
18637	2644	14	that	that	DT
18637	2644	15	State	State	NNP
18637	2644	16	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	2644	17	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	2644	18	hours	hour	NNS
18637	2644	19	for	for	IN
18637	2644	20	drivers	driver	NNS
18637	2644	21	of	of	IN
18637	2644	22	motor	motor	NN
18637	2644	23	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2644	24	was	be	VBD
18637	2644	25	held	hold	VBN
18637	2644	26	not	not	RB
18637	2644	27	to	to	TO
18637	2644	28	be	be	VB
18637	2644	29	superseded	supersede	VBN
18637	2644	30	by	by	IN
18637	2644	31	the	the	DT
18637	2644	32	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2644	33	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	2644	34	Carrier	Carrier	NNP
18637	2644	35	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2644	36	prior	prior	RB
18637	2644	37	to	to	IN
18637	2644	38	the	the	DT
18637	2644	39	effective	effective	JJ
18637	2644	40	date	date	NN
18637	2644	41	of	of	IN
18637	2644	42	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2644	43	by	by	IN
18637	2644	44	the	the	DT
18637	2644	45	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2644	46	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2644	47	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2644	48	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	2644	49	with	with	IN
18637	2644	50	the	the	DT
18637	2644	51	subject	subject	NN
18637	2644	52	.	.	.
18637	2645	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	2645	2	was	be	VBD
18637	2645	3	pendency	pendency	NN
18637	2645	4	before	before	IN
18637	2645	5	the	the	DT
18637	2645	6	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2645	7	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2645	8	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2645	9	of	of	IN
18637	2645	10	an	an	DT
18637	2645	11	application	application	NN
18637	2645	12	under	under	IN
18637	2645	13	the	the	DT
18637	2645	14	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	2645	15	Carrier	Carrier	NNP
18637	2645	16	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2645	17	for	for	IN
18637	2645	18	a	a	DT
18637	2645	19	license	license	NN
18637	2645	20	to	to	TO
18637	2645	21	operate	operate	VB
18637	2645	22	a	a	DT
18637	2645	23	motor	motor	NN
18637	2645	24	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2645	25	in	in	IN
18637	2645	26	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2645	27	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2645	28	found	find	VBD
18637	2645	29	to	to	TO
18637	2645	30	supersede	supersede	VB
18637	2645	31	as	as	IN
18637	2645	32	to	to	IN
18637	2645	33	the	the	DT
18637	2645	34	applicant	applicant	NN
18637	2645	35	the	the	DT
18637	2645	36	authority	authority	NN
18637	2645	37	of	of	IN
18637	2645	38	a	a	DT
18637	2645	39	State	State	NNP
18637	2645	40	to	to	TO
18637	2645	41	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	2645	42	"	"	``
18637	2645	43	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2645	44	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2645	45	"	"	''
18637	2645	46	of	of	IN
18637	2645	47	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2645	48	upon	upon	IN
18637	2645	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2645	50	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2645	51	.	.	.
18637	2646	1	"	"	``
18637	2646	2	In	in	IN
18637	2646	3	the	the	DT
18637	2646	4	absence	absence	NN
18637	2646	5	of	of	IN
18637	2646	6	the	the	DT
18637	2646	7	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2646	8	of	of	IN
18637	2646	9	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2646	10	authority	authority	NN
18637	2646	11	,	,	,
18637	2646	12	"	"	''
18637	2646	13	said	say	VBD
18637	2646	14	the	the	DT
18637	2646	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2646	16	,	,	,
18637	2646	17	"	"	''
18637	2646	18	and	and	CC
18637	2646	19	in	in	IN
18637	2646	20	the	the	DT
18637	2646	21	light	light	NN
18637	2646	22	of	of	IN
18637	2646	23	local	local	JJ
18637	2646	24	exigencies	exigency	NNS
18637	2646	25	,	,	,
18637	2646	26	the	the	DT
18637	2646	27	State	state	NN
18637	2646	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	2646	29	free	free	JJ
18637	2646	30	to	to	TO
18637	2646	31	act	act	VB
18637	2646	32	in	in	IN
18637	2646	33	order	order	NN
18637	2646	34	to	to	TO
18637	2646	35	protect	protect	VB
18637	2646	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2646	37	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	2646	38	interests	interest	NNS
18637	2646	39	even	even	RB
18637	2646	40	though	though	IN
18637	2646	41	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2646	42	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2646	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	2646	44	directly	directly	RB
18637	2646	45	affected	affect	VBN
18637	2646	46	.	.	.
18637	2647	1	"	"	``
18637	2647	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2647	3	831	831	CD
18637	2647	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2647	5	And	and	CC
18637	2647	6	for	for	IN
18637	2647	7	the	the	DT
18637	2647	8	same	same	JJ
18637	2647	9	reason	reason	NN
18637	2647	10	New	New	NNP
18637	2647	11	York	York	NNP
18637	2647	12	City	City	NNP
18637	2647	13	was	be	VBD
18637	2647	14	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	2647	15	to	to	TO
18637	2647	16	apply	apply	VB
18637	2647	17	to	to	IN
18637	2647	18	trucks	truck	NNS
18637	2647	19	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2647	20	in	in	IN
18637	2647	21	the	the	DT
18637	2647	22	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	2647	23	of	of	IN
18637	2647	24	goods	good	NNS
18637	2647	25	from	from	IN
18637	2647	26	New	New	NNP
18637	2647	27	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	2647	28	a	a	DT
18637	2647	29	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2647	30	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2647	31	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	2647	32	the	the	DT
18637	2647	33	operation	operation	NN
18637	2647	34	on	on	IN
18637	2647	35	the	the	DT
18637	2647	36	streets	street	NNS
18637	2647	37	of	of	IN
18637	2647	38	an	an	DT
18637	2647	39	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	2647	40	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	2647	41	.	.	.
18637	2648	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2648	2	832	832	CD
18637	2648	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2648	4	Said	Said	NNP
18637	2648	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2648	6	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	2648	7	for	for	IN
18637	2648	8	the	the	DT
18637	2648	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2648	10	:	:	:
18637	2648	11	"	"	``
18637	2648	12	Many	many	JJ
18637	2648	13	of	of	IN
18637	2648	14	these	these	DT
18637	2648	15	trucks	truck	NNS
18637	2648	16	are	be	VBP
18637	2648	17	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2648	18	in	in	IN
18637	2648	19	delivering	deliver	VBG
18637	2648	20	goods	good	NNS
18637	2648	21	in	in	IN
18637	2648	22	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2648	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2648	24	from	from	IN
18637	2648	25	New	New	NNP
18637	2648	26	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	2648	27	to	to	IN
18637	2648	28	New	New	NNP
18637	2648	29	York	York	NNP
18637	2648	30	.	.	.
18637	2649	1	Where	where	WRB
18637	2649	2	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2649	3	control	control	NN
18637	2649	4	and	and	CC
18637	2649	5	the	the	DT
18637	2649	6	use	use	NN
18637	2649	7	of	of	IN
18637	2649	8	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2649	9	are	be	VBP
18637	2649	10	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2649	11	and	and	CC
18637	2649	12	where	where	WRB
18637	2649	13	there	there	EX
18637	2649	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	2649	15	no	no	DT
18637	2649	16	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	2649	17	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2649	18	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2649	19	,	,	,
18637	2649	20	great	great	JJ
18637	2649	21	leeway	leeway	NN
18637	2649	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	2649	23	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	2649	24	local	local	JJ
18637	2649	25	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	2649	26	,	,	,
18637	2649	27	even	even	RB
18637	2649	28	though	though	IN
18637	2649	29	the	the	DT
18637	2649	30	local	local	JJ
18637	2649	31	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2649	32	materially	materially	RB
18637	2649	33	interferes	interfere	VBZ
18637	2649	34	with	with	IN
18637	2649	35	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2649	36	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2649	37	.	.	.
18637	2650	1	"	"	``
18637	2650	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2650	3	833	833	CD
18637	2650	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2650	5	Also	also	RB
18637	2650	6	,	,	,
18637	2650	7	the	the	DT
18637	2650	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2650	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	2650	10	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	2650	11	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2650	12	State	State	NNP
18637	2650	13	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2650	14	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2650	15	motor	motor	NN
18637	2650	16	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	2650	17	to	to	TO
18637	2650	18	provide	provide	VB
18637	2650	19	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	2650	20	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	2650	21	protection	protection	NN
18637	2650	22	for	for	IN
18637	2650	23	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	2650	24	caused	cause	VBN
18637	2650	25	by	by	IN
18637	2650	26	the	the	DT
18637	2650	27	negligent	negligent	JJ
18637	2650	28	operation	operation	NN
18637	2650	29	of	of	IN
18637	2650	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2650	31	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2650	32	.	.	.
18637	2651	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2651	2	834	834	CD
18637	2651	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2651	4	INVALID	INVALID	NNP
18637	2651	5	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2651	6	ACTS	ACTS	NNP
18637	2651	7	AFFECTING	AFFECTING	NNP
18637	2651	8	MOTOR	MOTOR	NNP
18637	2651	9	CARRIERS	CARRIERS	NNPS
18637	2651	10	A	a	DT
18637	2651	11	State	State	NNP
18637	2651	12	law	law	NN
18637	2651	13	which	which	WDT
18637	2651	14	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	2651	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	2651	16	all	all	DT
18637	2651	17	persons	person	NNS
18637	2651	18	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2651	19	in	in	IN
18637	2651	20	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	2651	21	for	for	IN
18637	2651	22	hire	hire	NN
18637	2651	23	by	by	IN
18637	2651	24	motor	motor	NN
18637	2651	25	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	2651	26	over	over	IN
18637	2651	27	the	the	DT
18637	2651	28	public	public	JJ
18637	2651	29	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2651	30	of	of	IN
18637	2651	31	the	the	DT
18637	2651	32	State	State	NNP
18637	2651	33	the	the	DT
18637	2651	34	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	2651	35	and	and	CC
18637	2651	36	duties	duty	NNS
18637	2651	37	of	of	IN
18637	2651	38	common	common	JJ
18637	2651	39	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	2651	40	and	and	CC
18637	2651	41	requires	require	VBZ
18637	2651	42	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2651	43	to	to	TO
18637	2651	44	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	2651	45	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	2651	46	to	to	TO
18637	2651	47	secure	secure	VB
18637	2651	48	the	the	DT
18637	2651	49	payment	payment	NN
18637	2651	50	of	of	IN
18637	2651	51	claims	claim	NNS
18637	2651	52	and	and	CC
18637	2651	53	liabilities	liability	NNS
18637	2651	54	resulting	result	VBG
18637	2651	55	from	from	IN
18637	2651	56	injury	injury	NN
18637	2651	57	to	to	IN
18637	2651	58	property	property	NN
18637	2651	59	carried	carry	VBN
18637	2651	60	,	,	,
18637	2651	61	may	may	MD
18637	2651	62	not	not	RB
18637	2651	63	be	be	VB
18637	2651	64	validly	validly	RB
18637	2651	65	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2651	66	to	to	IN
18637	2651	67	a	a	DT
18637	2651	68	private	private	JJ
18637	2651	69	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2651	70	which	which	WDT
18637	2651	71	is	be	VBZ
18637	2651	72	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2651	73	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	2651	74	in	in	IN
18637	2651	75	hauling	haul	VBG
18637	2651	76	from	from	IN
18637	2651	77	one	one	CD
18637	2651	78	State	state	NN
18637	2651	79	to	to	IN
18637	2651	80	another	another	DT
18637	2651	81	State	state	NN
18637	2651	82	the	the	DT
18637	2651	83	goods	good	NNS
18637	2651	84	of	of	IN
18637	2651	85	particular	particular	JJ
18637	2651	86	factories	factory	NNS
18637	2651	87	under	under	IN
18637	2651	88	standing	stand	VBG
18637	2651	89	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	2651	90	with	with	IN
18637	2651	91	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2651	92	owners	owner	NNS
18637	2651	93	,	,	,
18637	2651	94	the	the	DT
18637	2651	95	said	said	JJ
18637	2651	96	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2651	97	enjoying	enjoy	VBG
18637	2651	98	neither	neither	CC
18637	2651	99	a	a	DT
18637	2651	100	special	special	JJ
18637	2651	101	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	2651	102	nor	nor	CC
18637	2651	103	using	use	VBG
18637	2651	104	the	the	DT
18637	2651	105	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	2651	106	domain	domain	NN
18637	2651	107	power	power	NN
18637	2651	108	.	.	.
18637	2652	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2652	2	835	835	CD
18637	2652	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2652	4	On	on	IN
18637	2652	5	the	the	DT
18637	2652	6	other	other	JJ
18637	2652	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	2652	8	,	,	,
18637	2652	9	a	a	DT
18637	2652	10	State	State	NNP
18637	2652	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	2652	12	which	which	WDT
18637	2652	13	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	2652	14	common	common	JJ
18637	2652	15	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	2652	16	for	for	IN
18637	2652	17	hire	hire	NN
18637	2652	18	from	from	IN
18637	2652	19	using	use	VBG
18637	2652	20	the	the	DT
18637	2652	21	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2652	22	of	of	IN
18637	2652	23	the	the	DT
18637	2652	24	State	State	NNP
18637	2652	25	between	between	IN
18637	2652	26	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	2652	27	termini	termini	NN
18637	2652	28	or	or	CC
18637	2652	29	over	over	IN
18637	2652	30	regular	regular	JJ
18637	2652	31	routes	route	NNS
18637	2652	32	without	without	IN
18637	2652	33	having	have	VBG
18637	2652	34	first	first	RB
18637	2652	35	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	2652	36	from	from	IN
18637	2652	37	a	a	DT
18637	2652	38	director	director	NN
18637	2652	39	of	of	IN
18637	2652	40	public	public	JJ
18637	2652	41	works	work	VBZ
18637	2652	42	a	a	DT
18637	2652	43	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	2652	44	of	of	IN
18637	2652	45	public	public	JJ
18637	2652	46	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	2652	47	,	,	,
18637	2652	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	2652	49	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	2652	50	not	not	RB
18637	2652	51	a	a	DT
18637	2652	52	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2652	53	to	to	TO
18637	2652	54	secure	secure	VB
18637	2652	55	safety	safety	NN
18637	2652	56	on	on	IN
18637	2652	57	the	the	DT
18637	2652	58	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2652	59	or	or	CC
18637	2652	60	to	to	TO
18637	2652	61	conserve	conserve	VB
18637	2652	62	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2652	63	,	,	,
18637	2652	64	but	but	CC
18637	2652	65	a	a	DT
18637	2652	66	ban	ban	NN
18637	2652	67	on	on	IN
18637	2652	68	competition	competition	NN
18637	2652	69	and	and	CC
18637	2652	70	,	,	,
18637	2652	71	as	as	IN
18637	2652	72	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2652	73	to	to	IN
18637	2652	74	a	a	DT
18637	2652	75	common	common	JJ
18637	2652	76	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2652	77	by	by	IN
18637	2652	78	motor	motor	NN
18637	2652	79	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	2652	80	of	of	IN
18637	2652	81	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	2652	82	and	and	CC
18637	2652	83	express	express	VBP
18637	2652	84	purely	purely	RB
18637	2652	85	in	in	IN
18637	2652	86	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2652	87	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2652	88	,	,	,
18637	2652	89	is	be	VBZ
18637	2652	90	both	both	DT
18637	2652	91	violation	violation	NN
18637	2652	92	of	of	IN
18637	2652	93	the	the	DT
18637	2652	94	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2652	95	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	2652	96	and	and	CC
18637	2652	97	defeats	defeat	VBZ
18637	2652	98	the	the	DT
18637	2652	99	express	express	JJ
18637	2652	100	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2652	101	of	of	IN
18637	2652	102	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2652	103	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2652	104	rendering	render	VBG
18637	2652	105	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2652	106	aid	aid	NN
18637	2652	107	for	for	IN
18637	2652	108	the	the	DT
18637	2652	109	construction	construction	NN
18637	2652	110	of	of	IN
18637	2652	111	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2652	112	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2652	113	.	.	.
18637	2653	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2653	2	836	836	CD
18637	2653	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2653	4	TRANSPORTATION	transportation	NN
18637	2653	5	AGENCIES	agency	NNS
18637	2653	6	The	the	DT
18637	2653	7	special	special	JJ
18637	2653	8	characteristics	characteristic	NNS
18637	2653	9	of	of	IN
18637	2653	10	motor	motor	NN
18637	2653	11	travel	travel	NN
18637	2653	12	have	have	VBP
18637	2653	13	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2653	14	about	about	RP
18637	2653	15	a	a	DT
18637	2653	16	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	2653	17	of	of	IN
18637	2653	18	the	the	DT
18637	2653	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2653	20	's	's	POS
18637	2653	21	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	2653	22	toward	toward	IN
18637	2653	23	State	state	NN
18637	2653	24	control	control	NN
18637	2653	25	of	of	IN
18637	2653	26	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2653	27	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	2653	28	.	.	.
18637	2654	1	Sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	2654	2	in	in	IN
18637	2654	3	1941	1941	CD
18637	2654	4	a	a	DT
18637	2654	5	California	California	NNP
18637	2654	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	2654	7	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2654	8	that	that	IN
18637	2654	9	agents	agent	NNS
18637	2654	10	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2654	11	in	in	IN
18637	2654	12	negotiating	negotiate	VBG
18637	2654	13	for	for	IN
18637	2654	14	the	the	DT
18637	2654	15	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2654	16	of	of	IN
18637	2654	17	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	2654	18	in	in	IN
18637	2654	19	motor	motor	NN
18637	2654	20	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	2654	21	over	over	IN
18637	2654	22	the	the	DT
18637	2654	23	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2654	24	of	of	IN
18637	2654	25	the	the	DT
18637	2654	26	State	State	NNP
18637	2654	27	take	take	VB
18637	2654	28	out	out	RP
18637	2654	29	a	a	DT
18637	2654	30	license	license	NN
18637	2654	31	,	,	,
18637	2654	32	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2654	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2654	34	later	later	RB
18637	2654	35	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2654	36	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2654	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2654	38	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	2654	39	,	,	,
18637	2654	40	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2654	41	for	for	IN
18637	2654	42	the	the	DT
18637	2654	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2654	44	,	,	,
18637	2654	45	said	say	VBD
18637	2654	46	:	:	:
18637	2654	47	"	"	``
18637	2654	48	In	in	IN
18637	2654	49	Di	Di	NNP
18637	2654	50	Santo	Santo	NNP
18637	2654	51	_	_	NNP
18637	2654	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	2654	53	_	_	NNP
18637	2654	54	Pennsylvania,[837	Pennsylvania,[837	NNP
18637	2654	55	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2654	56	this	this	DT
18637	2654	57	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2654	58	took	take	VBD
18637	2654	59	a	a	DT
18637	2654	60	different	different	JJ
18637	2654	61	view	view	NN
18637	2654	62	*	*	NFP
18637	2654	63	*	*	NFP
18637	2654	64	*	*	NFP
18637	2654	65	,	,	,
18637	2654	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2654	67	held	hold	VBD
18637	2654	68	that	that	IN
18637	2654	69	a	a	DT
18637	2654	70	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2654	71	statute	statute	NN
18637	2654	72	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2654	73	others	other	NNS
18637	2654	74	than	than	IN
18637	2654	75	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2654	76	or	or	CC
18637	2654	77	steamship	steamship	NN
18637	2654	78	companies	company	NNS
18637	2654	79	,	,	,
18637	2654	80	who	who	WP
18637	2654	81	engage	engage	VBP
18637	2654	82	in	in	IN
18637	2654	83	the	the	DT
18637	2654	84	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2654	85	sale	sale	NN
18637	2654	86	of	of	IN
18637	2654	87	steamship	steamship	NN
18637	2654	88	tickets	ticket	NNS
18637	2654	89	or	or	CC
18637	2654	90	of	of	IN
18637	2654	91	orders	order	NNS
18637	2654	92	for	for	IN
18637	2654	93	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2654	94	to	to	IN
18637	2654	95	and	and	CC
18637	2654	96	from	from	IN
18637	2654	97	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2654	98	countries	country	NNS
18637	2654	99	,	,	,
18637	2654	100	to	to	TO
18637	2654	101	procure	procure	VB
18637	2654	102	a	a	DT
18637	2654	103	license	license	NN
18637	2654	104	by	by	IN
18637	2654	105	giving	give	VBG
18637	2654	106	proof	proof	NN
18637	2654	107	of	of	IN
18637	2654	108	good	good	JJ
18637	2654	109	moral	moral	JJ
18637	2654	110	character	character	NN
18637	2654	111	and	and	CC
18637	2654	112	filing	file	VBG
18637	2654	113	a	a	DT
18637	2654	114	bond	bond	NN
18637	2654	115	as	as	IN
18637	2654	116	security	security	NN
18637	2654	117	against	against	IN
18637	2654	118	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	2654	119	and	and	CC
18637	2654	120	misrepresentation	misrepresentation	NN
18637	2654	121	to	to	IN
18637	2654	122	purchasers	purchaser	NNS
18637	2654	123	,	,	,
18637	2654	124	was	be	VBD
18637	2654	125	an	an	DT
18637	2654	126	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	2654	127	of	of	IN
18637	2654	128	the	the	DT
18637	2654	129	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2654	130	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	2654	131	.	.	.
18637	2655	1	Since	since	IN
18637	2655	2	the	the	DT
18637	2655	3	decision	decision	NN
18637	2655	4	in	in	IN
18637	2655	5	that	that	DT
18637	2655	6	case	case	NN
18637	2655	7	this	this	DT
18637	2655	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2655	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	2655	10	been	be	VBN
18637	2655	11	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	2655	12	called	call	VBN
18637	2655	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	2655	14	to	to	TO
18637	2655	15	examine	examine	VB
18637	2655	16	the	the	DT
18637	2655	17	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	2655	18	of	of	IN
18637	2655	19	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	2655	20	local	local	JJ
18637	2655	21	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2655	22	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	2655	23	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2655	24	motor	motor	NN
18637	2655	25	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	2655	26	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2655	27	.	.	.
18637	2656	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2656	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	2656	3	uniformly	uniformly	RB
18637	2656	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	2656	5	that	that	IN
18637	2656	6	in	in	IN
18637	2656	7	the	the	DT
18637	2656	8	absence	absence	NN
18637	2656	9	of	of	IN
18637	2656	10	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	2656	11	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2656	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2656	13	there	there	EX
18637	2656	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	2656	15	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2656	16	power	power	NN
18637	2656	17	in	in	IN
18637	2656	18	the	the	DT
18637	2656	19	States	States	NNP
18637	2656	20	to	to	TO
18637	2656	21	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2656	22	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2656	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2656	24	by	by	IN
18637	2656	25	motor	motor	NN
18637	2656	26	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	2656	27	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	2656	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2656	29	affects	affect	VBZ
18637	2656	30	the	the	DT
18637	2656	31	safety	safety	NN
18637	2656	32	of	of	IN
18637	2656	33	the	the	DT
18637	2656	34	public	public	NN
18637	2656	35	or	or	CC
18637	2656	36	the	the	DT
18637	2656	37	safety	safety	NN
18637	2656	38	and	and	CC
18637	2656	39	convenient	convenient	JJ
18637	2656	40	use	use	NN
18637	2656	41	of	of	IN
18637	2656	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2656	43	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2656	44	,	,	,
18637	2656	45	provided	provide	VBN
18637	2656	46	only	only	RB
18637	2656	47	that	that	IN
18637	2656	48	the	the	DT
18637	2656	49	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2656	50	does	do	VBZ
18637	2656	51	not	not	RB
18637	2656	52	in	in	IN
18637	2656	53	any	any	DT
18637	2656	54	other	other	JJ
18637	2656	55	respect	respect	NN
18637	2656	56	unnecessarily	unnecessarily	RB
18637	2656	57	obstruct	obstruct	VBP
18637	2656	58	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2656	59	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2656	60	.	.	.
18637	2657	1	"	"	``
18637	2657	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2657	3	838	838	CD
18637	2657	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2657	5	NAVIGATION	NAVIGATION	NNP
18637	2657	6	;	;	,
18637	2657	7	GENERAL	GENERAL	NNP
18637	2657	8	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNP
18637	2657	9	In	in	IN
18637	2657	10	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	2657	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2657	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	2657	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2657	14	Ogden[839	Ogden[839	NNP
18637	2657	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2657	16	the	the	DT
18637	2657	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2657	18	,	,	,
18637	2657	19	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2657	20	by	by	IN
18637	2657	21	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2657	22	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2657	23	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2657	24	,	,	,
18637	2657	25	held	hold	VBD
18637	2657	26	that	that	IN
18637	2657	27	New	New	NNP
18637	2657	28	York	York	NNP
18637	2657	29	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2657	30	which	which	WDT
18637	2657	31	excluded	exclude	VBD
18637	2657	32	from	from	IN
18637	2657	33	the	the	DT
18637	2657	34	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	2657	35	waters	water	NNS
18637	2657	36	of	of	IN
18637	2657	37	that	that	DT
18637	2657	38	State	State	NNP
18637	2657	39	steam	steam	NN
18637	2657	40	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2657	41	enrolled	enrol	VBN
18637	2657	42	and	and	CC
18637	2657	43	licensed	license	VBN
18637	2657	44	under	under	IN
18637	2657	45	an	an	DT
18637	2657	46	act	act	NN
18637	2657	47	of	of	IN
18637	2657	48	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2657	49	to	to	TO
18637	2657	50	engage	engage	VB
18637	2657	51	in	in	IN
18637	2657	52	the	the	DT
18637	2657	53	coasting	coasting	JJ
18637	2657	54	trade	trade	NN
18637	2657	55	was	be	VBD
18637	2657	56	in	in	IN
18637	2657	57	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	2657	58	with	with	IN
18637	2657	59	the	the	DT
18637	2657	60	act	act	NN
18637	2657	61	of	of	IN
18637	2657	62	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2657	63	and	and	CC
18637	2657	64	hence	hence	RB
18637	2657	65	void	void	JJ
18637	2657	66	.	.	.
18637	2658	1	In	in	IN
18637	2658	2	Willson	Willson	NNP
18637	2658	3	_	_	NNP
18637	2658	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	2658	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2658	6	Blackbird	Blackbird	NNP
18637	2658	7	Creek	Creek	NNP
18637	2658	8	and	and	CC
18637	2658	9	Marsh	Marsh	NNP
18637	2658	10	Co.[840	Co.[840	NNP
18637	2658	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2658	12	the	the	DT
18637	2658	13	same	same	JJ
18637	2658	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2658	15	held	hold	VBD
18637	2658	16	that	that	IN
18637	2658	17	in	in	IN
18637	2658	18	the	the	DT
18637	2658	19	absence	absence	NN
18637	2658	20	of	of	IN
18637	2658	21	an	an	DT
18637	2658	22	act	act	NN
18637	2658	23	of	of	IN
18637	2658	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2658	25	,	,	,
18637	2658	26	"	"	''
18637	2658	27	the	the	DT
18637	2658	28	object	object	NN
18637	2658	29	of	of	IN
18637	2658	30	which	which	WDT
18637	2658	31	was	be	VBD
18637	2658	32	to	to	TO
18637	2658	33	control	control	VB
18637	2658	34	State	State	NNP
18637	2658	35	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2658	36	over	over	IN
18637	2658	37	those	those	DT
18637	2658	38	small	small	JJ
18637	2658	39	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	2658	40	creeks	creek	NNS
18637	2658	41	into	into	IN
18637	2658	42	which	which	WDT
18637	2658	43	the	the	DT
18637	2658	44	tide	tide	NN
18637	2658	45	flows	flow	VBZ
18637	2658	46	,	,	,
18637	2658	47	"	"	''
18637	2658	48	the	the	DT
18637	2658	49	State	State	NNP
18637	2658	50	of	of	IN
18637	2658	51	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	2658	52	was	be	VBD
18637	2658	53	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	2658	54	to	to	TO
18637	2658	55	incorporate	incorporate	VB
18637	2658	56	a	a	DT
18637	2658	57	company	company	NN
18637	2658	58	vested	vest	VBN
18637	2658	59	with	with	IN
18637	2658	60	the	the	DT
18637	2658	61	right	right	NN
18637	2658	62	to	to	TO
18637	2658	63	erect	erect	VB
18637	2658	64	a	a	DT
18637	2658	65	dam	dam	NN
18637	2658	66	across	across	IN
18637	2658	67	such	such	PDT
18637	2658	68	a	a	DT
18637	2658	69	creek	creek	NN
18637	2658	70	.	.	.
18637	2659	1	From	from	IN
18637	2659	2	these	these	DT
18637	2659	3	two	two	CD
18637	2659	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	2659	5	the	the	DT
18637	2659	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2659	7	in	in	IN
18637	2659	8	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	2659	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2659	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	2659	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2659	12	the	the	DT
18637	2659	13	Board	Board	NNP
18637	2659	14	of	of	IN
18637	2659	15	Wardens,[841	Wardens,[841	NNP
18637	2659	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2659	17	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2659	18	in	in	IN
18637	2659	19	1851	1851	CD
18637	2659	20	,	,	,
18637	2659	21	extracted	extract	VBD
18637	2659	22	the	the	DT
18637	2659	23	rule	rule	NN
18637	2659	24	that	that	IN
18637	2659	25	in	in	IN
18637	2659	26	the	the	DT
18637	2659	27	absence	absence	NN
18637	2659	28	of	of	IN
18637	2659	29	conflicting	conflicting	JJ
18637	2659	30	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2659	31	by	by	IN
18637	2659	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2659	33	States	States	NNP
18637	2659	34	were	be	VBD
18637	2659	35	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	2659	36	to	to	TO
18637	2659	37	enact	enact	VB
18637	2659	38	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2659	39	adapted	adapt	VBN
18637	2659	40	to	to	IN
18637	2659	41	the	the	DT
18637	2659	42	local	local	JJ
18637	2659	43	needs	need	NNS
18637	2659	44	of	of	IN
18637	2659	45	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2659	46	and	and	CC
18637	2659	47	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2659	48	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2659	49	,	,	,
18637	2659	50	that	that	IN
18637	2659	51	a	a	DT
18637	2659	52	pilotage	pilotage	NN
18637	2659	53	law	law	NN
18637	2659	54	was	be	VBD
18637	2659	55	of	of	IN
18637	2659	56	this	this	DT
18637	2659	57	description	description	NN
18637	2659	58	,	,	,
18637	2659	59	and	and	CC
18637	2659	60	was	be	VBD
18637	2659	61	,	,	,
18637	2659	62	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	2659	63	,	,	,
18637	2659	64	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	2659	65	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	2659	66	until	until	IN
18637	2659	67	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2659	68	acted	act	VBD
18637	2659	69	to	to	IN
18637	2659	70	the	the	DT
18637	2659	71	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	2659	72	to	to	IN
18637	2659	73	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2659	74	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2659	75	in	in	IN
18637	2659	76	the	the	DT
18637	2659	77	coasting	coasting	JJ
18637	2659	78	trade	trade	NN
18637	2659	79	.	.	.
18637	2660	1	In	in	IN
18637	2660	2	the	the	DT
18637	2660	3	main	main	JJ
18637	2660	4	,	,	,
18637	2660	5	these	these	DT
18637	2660	6	three	three	CD
18637	2660	7	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	2660	8	have	have	VBP
18637	2660	9	controlled	control	VBN
18637	2660	10	the	the	DT
18637	2660	11	decision	decision	NN
18637	2660	12	of	of	IN
18637	2660	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	2660	14	under	under	IN
18637	2660	15	the	the	DT
18637	2660	16	above	above	JJ
18637	2660	17	and	and	CC
18637	2660	18	the	the	DT
18637	2660	19	following	follow	VBG
18637	2660	20	caption	caption	NN
18637	2660	21	,	,	,
18637	2660	22	there	there	EX
18637	2660	23	being	be	VBG
18637	2660	24	generally	generally	RB
18637	2660	25	no	no	DT
18637	2660	26	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	2660	27	act	act	NN
18637	2660	28	of	of	IN
18637	2660	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2660	30	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2660	31	.	.	.
18637	2661	1	But	but	CC
18637	2661	2	the	the	DT
18637	2661	3	power	power	NN
18637	2661	4	which	which	WDT
18637	2661	5	the	the	DT
18637	2661	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	2661	7	attributed	attribute	VBN
18637	2661	8	to	to	IN
18637	2661	9	the	the	DT
18637	2661	10	States	States	NNPS
18637	2661	11	,	,	,
18637	2661	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2661	13	must	must	MD
18637	2661	14	use	use	VB
18637	2661	15	"	"	``
18637	2661	16	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	2661	17	,	,	,
18637	2661	18	"	"	''
18637	2661	19	something	something	NN
18637	2661	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2661	21	have	have	VBP
18637	2661	22	not	not	RB
18637	2661	23	always	always	RB
18637	2661	24	done	do	VBN
18637	2661	25	in	in	IN
18637	2661	26	the	the	DT
18637	2661	27	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	2661	28	of	of	IN
18637	2661	29	the	the	DT
18637	2661	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2661	31	.	.	.
18637	2662	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2662	2	an	an	DT
18637	2662	3	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	2662	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	2662	5	which	which	WDT
18637	2662	6	required	require	VBD
18637	2662	7	that	that	IN
18637	2662	8	owners	owner	NNS
18637	2662	9	of	of	IN
18637	2662	10	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2662	11	using	use	VBG
18637	2662	12	the	the	DT
18637	2662	13	public	public	JJ
18637	2662	14	waters	water	NNS
18637	2662	15	of	of	IN
18637	2662	16	the	the	DT
18637	2662	17	enacting	enact	VBG
18637	2662	18	State	state	NN
18637	2662	19	be	be	VB
18637	2662	20	enrolled	enrol	VBN
18637	2662	21	,	,	,
18637	2662	22	pay	pay	VB
18637	2662	23	fees	fee	NNS
18637	2662	24	,	,	,
18637	2662	25	file	file	NN
18637	2662	26	statements	statement	NNS
18637	2662	27	as	as	IN
18637	2662	28	to	to	IN
18637	2662	29	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	2662	30	,	,	,
18637	2662	31	etc	etc	FW
18637	2662	32	.	.	.
18637	2662	33	,	,	,
18637	2662	34	was	be	VBD
18637	2662	35	held	hold	VBN
18637	2662	36	to	to	TO
18637	2662	37	be	be	VB
18637	2662	38	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	2662	39	to	to	IN
18637	2662	40	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2662	41	licensed	license	VBN
18637	2662	42	under	under	IN
18637	2662	43	the	the	DT
18637	2662	44	act	act	NN
18637	2662	45	of	of	IN
18637	2662	46	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2662	47	to	to	TO
18637	2662	48	engage	engage	VB
18637	2662	49	in	in	IN
18637	2662	50	the	the	DT
18637	2662	51	coasting	coasting	JJ
18637	2662	52	trade;[842	trade;[842	CD
18637	2662	53	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2662	54	as	as	IN
18637	2662	55	was	be	VBD
18637	2662	56	also	also	RB
18637	2662	57	a	a	DT
18637	2662	58	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	2662	59	statute	statute	NN
18637	2662	60	ordering	ordering	NN
18637	2662	61	masters	master	NNS
18637	2662	62	and	and	CC
18637	2662	63	wardens	warden	NNS
18637	2662	64	of	of	IN
18637	2662	65	the	the	DT
18637	2662	66	port	port	NN
18637	2662	67	of	of	IN
18637	2662	68	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	2662	69	to	to	TO
18637	2662	70	survey	survey	VB
18637	2662	71	the	the	DT
18637	2662	72	hatches	hatch	NNS
18637	2662	73	of	of	IN
18637	2662	74	all	all	DT
18637	2662	75	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2662	76	arriving	arrive	VBG
18637	2662	77	there	there	RB
18637	2662	78	and	and	CC
18637	2662	79	to	to	TO
18637	2662	80	enact	enact	VB
18637	2662	81	a	a	DT
18637	2662	82	fee	fee	NN
18637	2662	83	for	for	IN
18637	2662	84	so	so	RB
18637	2662	85	doing	do	VBG
18637	2662	86	.	.	.
18637	2663	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2663	2	843	843	CD
18637	2663	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2663	4	"	"	``
18637	2663	5	The	the	DT
18637	2663	6	unreason	unreason	NN
18637	2663	7	and	and	CC
18637	2663	8	the	the	DT
18637	2663	9	oppressive	oppressive	JJ
18637	2663	10	character	character	NN
18637	2663	11	of	of	IN
18637	2663	12	the	the	DT
18637	2663	13	act	act	NN
18637	2663	14	"	"	''
18637	2663	15	was	be	VBD
18637	2663	16	held	hold	VBN
18637	2663	17	to	to	TO
18637	2663	18	take	take	VB
18637	2663	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2663	20	out	out	IN
18637	2663	21	of	of	IN
18637	2663	22	the	the	DT
18637	2663	23	class	class	NN
18637	2663	24	of	of	IN
18637	2663	25	local	local	JJ
18637	2663	26	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2663	27	protected	protect	VBN
18637	2663	28	by	by	IN
18637	2663	29	the	the	DT
18637	2663	30	rule	rule	NN
18637	2663	31	of	of	IN
18637	2663	32	the	the	DT
18637	2663	33	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	2663	34	case	case	NN
18637	2663	35	.	.	.
18637	2664	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2664	2	844	844	CD
18637	2664	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2664	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	2664	5	,	,	,
18637	2664	6	while	while	IN
18637	2664	7	control	control	NN
18637	2664	8	by	by	IN
18637	2664	9	a	a	DT
18637	2664	10	State	State	NNP
18637	2664	11	of	of	IN
18637	2664	12	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	2664	13	waters	water	NNS
18637	2664	14	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	2664	15	within	within	IN
18637	2664	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2664	17	borders	border	NNS
18637	2664	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	2664	19	been	be	VBN
18637	2664	20	often	often	RB
18637	2664	21	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	2664	22	to	to	TO
18637	2664	23	be	be	VB
18637	2664	24	complete	complete	JJ
18637	2664	25	in	in	IN
18637	2664	26	the	the	DT
18637	2664	27	absence	absence	NN
18637	2664	28	of	of	IN
18637	2664	29	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2664	30	by	by	IN
18637	2664	31	Congress,[845	Congress,[845	NNP
18637	2664	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2664	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2664	34	may	may	MD
18637	2664	35	assume	assume	VB
18637	2664	36	control	control	NN
18637	2664	37	at	at	IN
18637	2664	38	any	any	DT
18637	2664	39	time;[846	time;[846	NNPS
18637	2664	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2664	41	and	and	CC
18637	2664	42	when	when	WRB
18637	2664	43	such	such	JJ
18637	2664	44	waters	water	NNS
18637	2664	45	connect	connect	VBP
18637	2664	46	with	with	IN
18637	2664	47	other	other	JJ
18637	2664	48	similar	similar	JJ
18637	2664	49	waters	water	NNS
18637	2664	50	"	"	''
18637	2664	51	so	so	IN
18637	2664	52	as	as	IN
18637	2664	53	to	to	TO
18637	2664	54	form	form	VB
18637	2664	55	a	a	DT
18637	2664	56	waterway	waterway	NN
18637	2664	57	to	to	IN
18637	2664	58	other	other	JJ
18637	2664	59	States	States	NNPS
18637	2664	60	or	or	CC
18637	2664	61	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2664	62	nations	nation	NNS
18637	2664	63	,	,	,
18637	2664	64	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2664	65	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2664	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2664	67	can	can	MD
18637	2664	68	not	not	RB
18637	2664	69	be	be	VB
18637	2664	70	obstructed	obstruct	VBN
18637	2664	71	or	or	CC
18637	2664	72	impeded	impede	VBN
18637	2664	73	so	so	IN
18637	2664	74	as	as	IN
18637	2664	75	to	to	TO
18637	2664	76	impair	impair	VB
18637	2664	77	,	,	,
18637	2664	78	defeat	defeat	VB
18637	2664	79	,	,	,
18637	2664	80	or	or	CC
18637	2664	81	place	place	VB
18637	2664	82	any	any	DT
18637	2664	83	burden	burden	NN
18637	2664	84	upon	upon	IN
18637	2664	85	a	a	DT
18637	2664	86	right	right	NN
18637	2664	87	to	to	IN
18637	2664	88	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2664	89	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	2664	90	granted	grant	VBN
18637	2664	91	by	by	IN
18637	2664	92	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2664	93	.	.	.
18637	2665	1	"	"	``
18637	2665	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2665	3	847	847	CD
18637	2665	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2665	5	On	on	IN
18637	2665	6	the	the	DT
18637	2665	7	other	other	JJ
18637	2665	8	hand	hand	NN
18637	2665	9	,	,	,
18637	2665	10	in	in	IN
18637	2665	11	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
18637	2665	12	_	_	NNP
18637	2665	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	2665	14	_	_	NNP
18637	2665	15	Washington,[848	Washington,[848	NNP
18637	2665	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2665	17	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2665	18	in	in	IN
18637	2665	19	1937	1937	CD
18637	2665	20	,	,	,
18637	2665	21	the	the	DT
18637	2665	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2665	23	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	2665	24	the	the	DT
18637	2665	25	State	State	NNP
18637	2665	26	in	in	IN
18637	2665	27	applying	apply	VBG
18637	2665	28	to	to	IN
18637	2665	29	motor	motor	NN
18637	2665	30	-	-	HYPH
18637	2665	31	driven	drive	VBN
18637	2665	32	tugs	tug	NNS
18637	2665	33	operating	operate	VBG
18637	2665	34	in	in	IN
18637	2665	35	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	2665	36	waters	water	NNS
18637	2665	37	of	of	IN
18637	2665	38	the	the	DT
18637	2665	39	United	United	NNP
18637	2665	40	States	States	NNP
18637	2665	41	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2665	42	which	which	WDT
18637	2665	43	provided	provide	VBD
18637	2665	44	for	for	IN
18637	2665	45	the	the	DT
18637	2665	46	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	2665	47	and	and	CC
18637	2665	48	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2665	49	of	of	IN
18637	2665	50	every	every	DT
18637	2665	51	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	2665	52	operated	operate	VBN
18637	2665	53	by	by	IN
18637	2665	54	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	2665	55	if	if	IN
18637	2665	56	the	the	DT
18637	2665	57	same	same	JJ
18637	2665	58	was	be	VBD
18637	2665	59	not	not	RB
18637	2665	60	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2665	61	to	to	IN
18637	2665	62	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	2665	63	under	under	IN
18637	2665	64	the	the	DT
18637	2665	65	laws	law	NNS
18637	2665	66	of	of	IN
18637	2665	67	the	the	DT
18637	2665	68	United	United	NNP
18637	2665	69	States	States	NNP
18637	2665	70	.	.	.
18637	2666	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2666	2	was	be	VBD
18637	2666	3	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	2666	4	that	that	IN
18637	2666	5	there	there	EX
18637	2666	6	was	be	VBD
18637	2666	7	"	"	``
18637	2666	8	elaborate	elaborate	JJ
18637	2666	9	"	"	''
18637	2666	10	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2666	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2666	12	in	in	IN
18637	2666	13	the	the	DT
18637	2666	14	field	field	NN
18637	2666	15	,	,	,
18637	2666	16	but	but	CC
18637	2666	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2666	18	was	be	VBD
18637	2666	19	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	2666	20	that	that	IN
18637	2666	21	the	the	DT
18637	2666	22	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	2666	23	statute	statute	NN
18637	2666	24	filled	fill	VBD
18637	2666	25	a	a	DT
18637	2666	26	gap	gap	NN
18637	2666	27	.	.	.
18637	2667	1	"	"	``
18637	2667	2	The	the	DT
18637	2667	3	principle	principle	NN
18637	2667	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	2667	5	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
18637	2667	6	established	establish	VBN
18637	2667	7	,	,	,
18637	2667	8	"	"	''
18637	2667	9	said	say	VBD
18637	2667	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2667	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2667	12	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	2667	13	for	for	IN
18637	2667	14	the	the	DT
18637	2667	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2667	16	,	,	,
18637	2667	17	"	"	''
18637	2667	18	that	that	IN
18637	2667	19	the	the	DT
18637	2667	20	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2667	21	by	by	IN
18637	2667	22	the	the	DT
18637	2667	23	State	State	NNP
18637	2667	24	of	of	IN
18637	2667	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2667	26	police	police	NN
18637	2667	27	power	power	NN
18637	2667	28	,	,	,
18637	2667	29	which	which	WDT
18637	2667	30	would	would	MD
18637	2667	31	be	be	VB
18637	2667	32	valid	valid	JJ
18637	2667	33	if	if	IN
18637	2667	34	not	not	RB
18637	2667	35	superseded	supersede	VBN
18637	2667	36	by	by	IN
18637	2667	37	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2667	38	action	action	NN
18637	2667	39	,	,	,
18637	2667	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	2667	41	superseded	superseded	JJ
18637	2667	42	only	only	RB
18637	2667	43	where	where	WRB
18637	2667	44	the	the	DT
18637	2667	45	repugnance	repugnance	NN
18637	2667	46	or	or	CC
18637	2667	47	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	2667	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	2667	49	so	so	RB
18637	2667	50	'	'	``
18637	2667	51	direct	direct	JJ
18637	2667	52	and	and	CC
18637	2667	53	positive	positive	JJ
18637	2667	54	'	'	''
18637	2667	55	that	that	IN
18637	2667	56	the	the	DT
18637	2667	57	two	two	CD
18637	2667	58	acts	act	NNS
18637	2667	59	can	can	MD
18637	2667	60	not	not	RB
18637	2667	61	'	'	''
18637	2667	62	be	be	VB
18637	2667	63	reconciled	reconcile	VBN
18637	2667	64	or	or	CC
18637	2667	65	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	2667	66	stand	stand	VB
18637	2667	67	together	together	RB
18637	2667	68	.	.	.
18637	2668	1	'	'	``
18637	2668	2	"	"	``
18637	2668	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2668	4	849	849	CD
18637	2668	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2668	6	And	and	CC
18637	2668	7	in	in	IN
18637	2668	8	Bob	Bob	NNP
18637	2668	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	2668	10	Lo	Lo	NNP
18637	2668	11	Excursion	Excursion	NNP
18637	2668	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2668	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2668	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	2668	15	_	_	NNP
18637	2668	16	Michigan,[850	Michigan,[850	NNP
18637	2668	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2668	18	the	the	DT
18637	2668	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2668	20	,	,	,
18637	2668	21	elbowing	elbow	VBG
18637	2668	22	aside	aside	RB
18637	2668	23	a	a	DT
18637	2668	24	decision	decision	NN
18637	2668	25	of	of	IN
18637	2668	26	many	many	JJ
18637	2668	27	years	year	NNS
18637	2668	28	standing,[851	standing,[851	VBN
18637	2668	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2668	30	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	2668	31	that	that	IN
18637	2668	32	the	the	DT
18637	2668	33	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2668	34	clause	clause	NN
18637	2668	35	does	do	VBZ
18637	2668	36	not	not	RB
18637	2668	37	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	2668	38	a	a	DT
18637	2668	39	State	state	NN
18637	2668	40	,	,	,
18637	2668	41	in	in	IN
18637	2668	42	the	the	DT
18637	2668	43	absence	absence	NN
18637	2668	44	of	of	IN
18637	2668	45	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2668	46	statute	statute	NN
18637	2668	47	or	or	CC
18637	2668	48	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	2668	49	,	,	,
18637	2668	50	from	from	IN
18637	2668	51	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	2668	52	racial	racial	JJ
18637	2668	53	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	2668	54	by	by	IN
18637	2668	55	one	one	CD
18637	2668	56	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	2668	57	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	2668	58	by	by	IN
18637	2668	59	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	2668	60	to	to	IN
18637	2668	61	and	and	CC
18637	2668	62	from	from	IN
18637	2668	63	a	a	DT
18637	2668	64	port	port	NN
18637	2668	65	in	in	IN
18637	2668	66	the	the	DT
18637	2668	67	United	United	NNP
18637	2668	68	States	States	NNP
18637	2668	69	to	to	IN
18637	2668	70	an	an	DT
18637	2668	71	island	island	NN
18637	2668	72	situated	situate	VBN
18637	2668	73	in	in	IN
18637	2668	74	Canadian	canadian	JJ
18637	2668	75	territory	territory	NN
18637	2668	76	.	.	.
18637	2669	1	BRIDGES	bridge	NNS
18637	2669	2	,	,	,
18637	2669	3	DAMS	dams	NN
18637	2669	4	,	,	,
18637	2669	5	FERRIES	FERRIES	NNP
18637	2669	6	,	,	,
18637	2669	7	WHARVES	wharve	VBD
18637	2669	8	The	the	DT
18637	2669	9	holding	holding	NN
18637	2669	10	in	in	IN
18637	2669	11	Willson	Willson	NNP
18637	2669	12	_	_	NNP
18637	2669	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	2669	14	_	_	NNP
18637	2669	15	Blackbird	Blackbird	NNP
18637	2669	16	Creek	Creek	NNP
18637	2669	17	Marsh	Marsh	NNP
18637	2669	18	Co.[852	Co.[852	NNP
18637	2669	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2669	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	2669	21	been	be	VBN
18637	2669	22	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	2669	23	by	by	IN
18637	2669	24	the	the	DT
18637	2669	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2669	26	many	many	JJ
18637	2669	27	times	time	NNS
18637	2669	28	in	in	IN
18637	2669	29	support	support	NN
18637	2669	30	of	of	IN
18637	2669	31	State	State	NNP
18637	2669	32	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2669	33	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	2669	34	the	the	DT
18637	2669	35	construction	construction	NN
18637	2669	36	across	across	IN
18637	2669	37	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	2669	38	streams	stream	NNS
18637	2669	39	of	of	IN
18637	2669	40	dams	dam	NNS
18637	2669	41	,	,	,
18637	2669	42	booms	boom	NNS
18637	2669	43	,	,	,
18637	2669	44	and	and	CC
18637	2669	45	other	other	JJ
18637	2669	46	shore	shore	NN
18637	2669	47	protections,[853	protections,[853	NNS
18637	2669	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2669	49	as	as	RB
18637	2669	50	well	well	RB
18637	2669	51	as	as	IN
18637	2669	52	in	in	IN
18637	2669	53	support	support	NN
18637	2669	54	of	of	IN
18637	2669	55	State	State	NNP
18637	2669	56	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2669	57	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	2669	58	the	the	DT
18637	2669	59	erection	erection	NN
18637	2669	60	of	of	IN
18637	2669	61	bridges	bridge	NNS
18637	2669	62	and	and	CC
18637	2669	63	the	the	DT
18637	2669	64	operation	operation	NN
18637	2669	65	of	of	IN
18637	2669	66	ferries	ferry	NNS
18637	2669	67	across	across	IN
18637	2669	68	such	such	JJ
18637	2669	69	streams	stream	NNS
18637	2669	70	.	.	.
18637	2670	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2670	2	854	854	CD
18637	2670	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2670	4	Bridges	Bridges	NNPS
18637	2670	5	,	,	,
18637	2670	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2670	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	2670	8	true	true	JJ
18637	2670	9	,	,	,
18637	2670	10	may	may	MD
18637	2670	11	obstruct	obstruct	VB
18637	2670	12	some	some	DT
18637	2670	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2670	14	,	,	,
18637	2670	15	but	but	CC
18637	2670	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2670	17	may	may	MD
18637	2670	18	more	more	RBR
18637	2670	19	than	than	IN
18637	2670	20	compensate	compensate	VB
18637	2670	21	for	for	IN
18637	2670	22	this	this	DT
18637	2670	23	by	by	IN
18637	2670	24	aiding	aid	VBG
18637	2670	25	other	other	JJ
18637	2670	26	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2670	27	.	.	.
18637	2671	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2671	2	855	855	CD
18637	2671	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2671	4	In	in	IN
18637	2671	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2671	6	Field	Field	NNP
18637	2671	7	's	's	POS
18637	2671	8	words	word	NNS
18637	2671	9	in	in	IN
18637	2671	10	Huse	Huse	NNP
18637	2671	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2671	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	2671	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2671	14	Glover,[856	Glover,[856	NNP
18637	2671	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2671	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2671	17	should	should	MD
18637	2671	18	not	not	RB
18637	2671	19	be	be	VB
18637	2671	20	forgotten	forget	VBN
18637	2671	21	that	that	DT
18637	2671	22	:	:	:
18637	2671	23	"	"	``
18637	2671	24	the	the	DT
18637	2671	25	State	State	NNP
18637	2671	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	2671	27	interested	interested	JJ
18637	2671	28	in	in	IN
18637	2671	29	the	the	DT
18637	2671	30	domestic	domestic	NN
18637	2671	31	as	as	RB
18637	2671	32	well	well	RB
18637	2671	33	as	as	IN
18637	2671	34	in	in	IN
18637	2671	35	the	the	DT
18637	2671	36	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2671	37	and	and	CC
18637	2671	38	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2671	39	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2671	40	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	2671	41	on	on	IN
18637	2671	42	the	the	DT
18637	2671	43	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	2671	44	River	River	NNP
18637	2671	45	,	,	,
18637	2671	46	and	and	CC
18637	2671	47	to	to	TO
18637	2671	48	increase	increase	VB
18637	2671	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2671	50	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	2671	51	,	,	,
18637	2671	52	and	and	CC
18637	2671	53	thus	thus	RB
18637	2671	54	augment	augment	VBD
18637	2671	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2671	56	growth	growth	NN
18637	2671	57	,	,	,
18637	2671	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2671	59	has	have	VBZ
18637	2671	60	full	full	JJ
18637	2671	61	power	power	NN
18637	2671	62	.	.	.
18637	2672	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2672	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2672	3	only	only	RB
18637	2672	4	when	when	WRB
18637	2672	5	,	,	,
18637	2672	6	in	in	IN
18637	2672	7	the	the	DT
18637	2672	8	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	2672	9	of	of	IN
18637	2672	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2672	11	,	,	,
18637	2672	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2672	13	action	action	NN
18637	2672	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	2672	15	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	2672	16	to	to	TO
18637	2672	17	encroach	encroach	VB
18637	2672	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	2672	19	the	the	DT
18637	2672	20	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	2672	21	of	of	IN
18637	2672	22	the	the	DT
18637	2672	23	river	river	NN
18637	2672	24	as	as	IN
18637	2672	25	a	a	DT
18637	2672	26	means	means	NN
18637	2672	27	of	of	IN
18637	2672	28	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2672	29	and	and	CC
18637	2672	30	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2672	31	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2672	32	,	,	,
18637	2672	33	that	that	IN
18637	2672	34	that	that	DT
18637	2672	35	body	body	NN
18637	2672	36	may	may	MD
18637	2672	37	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	2672	38	and	and	CC
18637	2672	39	control	control	VB
18637	2672	40	or	or	CC
18637	2672	41	supersede	supersede	VB
18637	2672	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2672	43	.	.	.
18637	2673	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2673	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2673	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2673	4	How	how	WRB
18637	2673	5	the	the	DT
18637	2673	6	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2673	7	of	of	IN
18637	2673	8	a	a	DT
18637	2673	9	State	State	NNP
18637	2673	10	,	,	,
18637	2673	11	whether	whether	IN
18637	2673	12	on	on	IN
18637	2673	13	land	land	NN
18637	2673	14	or	or	CC
18637	2673	15	by	by	IN
18637	2673	16	water	water	NN
18637	2673	17	,	,	,
18637	2673	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	2673	19	be	be	VB
18637	2673	20	best	well	RBS
18637	2673	21	improved	improve	VBN
18637	2673	22	for	for	IN
18637	2673	23	the	the	DT
18637	2673	24	public	public	JJ
18637	2673	25	good	good	NN
18637	2673	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	2673	27	a	a	DT
18637	2673	28	matter	matter	NN
18637	2673	29	for	for	IN
18637	2673	30	State	state	NN
18637	2673	31	determination	determination	NN
18637	2673	32	,	,	,
18637	2673	33	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2673	34	always	always	RB
18637	2673	35	to	to	IN
18637	2673	36	the	the	DT
18637	2673	37	right	right	NN
18637	2673	38	of	of	IN
18637	2673	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2673	40	to	to	TO
18637	2673	41	interpose	interpose	VB
18637	2673	42	in	in	IN
18637	2673	43	the	the	DT
18637	2673	44	cases	case	NNS
18637	2673	45	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	2673	46	.	.	.
18637	2674	1	"	"	``
18637	2674	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2674	3	857	857	CD
18637	2674	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2674	5	The	the	DT
18637	2674	6	same	same	JJ
18637	2674	7	principle	principle	NN
18637	2674	8	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	2674	9	to	to	IN
18637	2674	10	the	the	DT
18637	2674	11	construction	construction	NN
18637	2674	12	of	of	IN
18637	2674	13	piers	pier	NNS
18637	2674	14	and	and	CC
18637	2674	15	wharves	wharf	NNS
18637	2674	16	in	in	IN
18637	2674	17	a	a	DT
18637	2674	18	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	2674	19	stream,[858	stream,[858	NN
18637	2674	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2674	21	as	as	RB
18637	2674	22	well	well	RB
18637	2674	23	as	as	IN
18637	2674	24	to	to	TO
18637	2674	25	harbor	harbor	VB
18637	2674	26	improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	2674	27	by	by	IN
18637	2674	28	a	a	DT
18637	2674	29	State	state	NN
18637	2674	30	for	for	IN
18637	2674	31	the	the	DT
18637	2674	32	aid	aid	NN
18637	2674	33	and	and	CC
18637	2674	34	protection	protection	NN
18637	2674	35	of	of	IN
18637	2674	36	navigation;[859	navigation;[859	NNP
18637	2674	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2674	38	and	and	CC
18637	2674	39	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2674	40	tolls	toll	NNS
18637	2674	41	may	may	MD
18637	2674	42	be	be	VB
18637	2674	43	charged	charge	VBN
18637	2674	44	for	for	IN
18637	2674	45	the	the	DT
18637	2674	46	use	use	NN
18637	2674	47	of	of	IN
18637	2674	48	such	such	JJ
18637	2674	49	aids	aid	NNS
18637	2674	50	,	,	,
18637	2674	51	and	and	CC
18637	2674	52	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2674	53	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2674	54	laid	lay	VBD
18637	2674	55	down	down	RP
18637	2674	56	governing	govern	VBG
18637	2674	57	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2674	58	employment	employment	NN
18637	2674	59	.	.	.
18637	2675	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2675	2	860	860	CD
18637	2675	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2675	4	Ferries	Ferries	NNP
18637	2675	5	A	a	DT
18637	2675	6	State	State	NNP
18637	2675	7	may	may	MD
18637	2675	8	license	license	VB
18637	2675	9	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	2675	10	to	to	TO
18637	2675	11	operate	operate	VB
18637	2675	12	a	a	DT
18637	2675	13	ferry	ferry	NN
18637	2675	14	across	across	IN
18637	2675	15	an	an	DT
18637	2675	16	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2675	17	river	river	NN
18637	2675	18	bounding	bound	VBG
18637	2675	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2675	20	territory	territory	NN
18637	2675	21	,	,	,
18637	2675	22	or	or	CC
18637	2675	23	may	may	MD
18637	2675	24	incorporate	incorporate	VB
18637	2675	25	a	a	DT
18637	2675	26	company	company	NN
18637	2675	27	for	for	IN
18637	2675	28	the	the	DT
18637	2675	29	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2675	30	.	.	.
18637	2676	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2676	2	861	861	CD
18637	2676	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2676	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	2676	5	may	may	MD
18637	2676	6	a	a	DT
18637	2676	7	neighbor	neighbor	NN
18637	2676	8	State	state	NN
18637	2676	9	make	make	VB
18637	2676	10	the	the	DT
18637	2676	11	securing	securing	NN
18637	2676	12	of	of	IN
18637	2676	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2676	14	consent	consent	NN
18637	2676	15	and	and	CC
18637	2676	16	license	license	VBP
18637	2676	17	a	a	DT
18637	2676	18	condition	condition	NN
18637	2676	19	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	2676	20	to	to	IN
18637	2676	21	the	the	DT
18637	2676	22	operation	operation	NN
18637	2676	23	of	of	IN
18637	2676	24	such	such	PDT
18637	2676	25	a	a	DT
18637	2676	26	ferry	ferry	NN
18637	2676	27	to	to	IN
18637	2676	28	one	one	CD
18637	2676	29	of	of	IN
18637	2676	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2676	31	towns	town	NNS
18637	2676	32	.	.	.
18637	2677	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2677	2	862	862	CD
18637	2677	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2677	4	Earlier	early	RBR
18637	2677	5	the	the	DT
18637	2677	6	right	right	NN
18637	2677	7	of	of	IN
18637	2677	8	a	a	DT
18637	2677	9	State	State	NNP
18637	2677	10	to	to	TO
18637	2677	11	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2677	12	the	the	DT
18637	2677	13	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2677	14	to	to	TO
18637	2677	15	be	be	VB
18637	2677	16	charged	charge	VBN
18637	2677	17	by	by	IN
18637	2677	18	an	an	DT
18637	2677	19	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2677	20	bridge	bridge	NN
18637	2677	21	company	company	NN
18637	2677	22	for	for	IN
18637	2677	23	passage	passage	NN
18637	2677	24	across	across	IN
18637	2677	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2677	26	structure	structure	NN
18637	2677	27	was	be	VBD
18637	2677	28	denied	deny	VBN
18637	2677	29	by	by	IN
18637	2677	30	a	a	DT
18637	2677	31	closely	closely	RB
18637	2677	32	divided	divide	VBN
18637	2677	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2677	34	.	.	.
18637	2678	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2678	2	863	863	CD
18637	2678	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2678	4	The	the	DT
18637	2678	5	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	2678	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	2678	7	not	not	RB
18637	2678	8	,	,	,
18637	2678	9	however	however	RB
18637	2678	10	,	,	,
18637	2678	11	control	control	VB
18637	2678	12	the	the	DT
18637	2678	13	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2678	14	of	of	IN
18637	2678	15	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2678	16	to	to	TO
18637	2678	17	be	be	VB
18637	2678	18	charged	charge	VBN
18637	2678	19	by	by	IN
18637	2678	20	an	an	DT
18637	2678	21	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2678	22	ferry	ferry	NN
18637	2678	23	company	company	NN
18637	2678	24	.	.	.
18637	2679	1	These	these	DT
18637	2679	2	the	the	DT
18637	2679	3	chartering	charter	VBG
18637	2679	4	State	state	NN
18637	2679	5	may	may	MD
18637	2679	6	,	,	,
18637	2679	7	in	in	IN
18637	2679	8	the	the	DT
18637	2679	9	absence	absence	NN
18637	2679	10	of	of	IN
18637	2679	11	action	action	NN
18637	2679	12	by	by	IN
18637	2679	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2679	14	,	,	,
18637	2679	15	regulate	regulate	VBP
18637	2679	16	except	except	IN
18637	2679	17	in	in	IN
18637	2679	18	the	the	DT
18637	2679	19	case	case	NN
18637	2679	20	of	of	IN
18637	2679	21	ferries	ferry	NNS
18637	2679	22	operated	operate	VBN
18637	2679	23	in	in	IN
18637	2679	24	connection	connection	NN
18637	2679	25	with	with	IN
18637	2679	26	railroads,[864	railroads,[864	NNP
18637	2679	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2679	28	as	as	IN
18637	2679	29	to	to	IN
18637	2679	30	which	which	WDT
18637	2679	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2679	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	2679	33	acted	act	VBN
18637	2679	34	with	with	IN
18637	2679	35	the	the	DT
18637	2679	36	result	result	NN
18637	2679	37	of	of	IN
18637	2679	38	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	2679	39	all	all	DT
18637	2679	40	State	State	NNP
18637	2679	41	action	action	NN
18637	2679	42	.	.	.
18637	2680	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2680	2	865	865	CD
18637	2680	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2680	4	A	a	DT
18637	2680	5	State	state	NN
18637	2680	6	may	may	MD
18637	2680	7	also	also	RB
18637	2680	8	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2680	9	the	the	DT
18637	2680	10	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2680	11	of	of	IN
18637	2680	12	a	a	DT
18637	2680	13	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	2680	14	plying	ply	VBG
18637	2680	15	between	between	IN
18637	2680	16	two	two	CD
18637	2680	17	points	point	NNS
18637	2680	18	within	within	IN
18637	2680	19	the	the	DT
18637	2680	20	State	State	NNP
18637	2680	21	although	although	IN
18637	2680	22	the	the	DT
18637	2680	23	journey	journey	NN
18637	2680	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	2680	25	over	over	IN
18637	2680	26	the	the	DT
18637	2680	27	high	high	JJ
18637	2680	28	seas	sea	NNS
18637	2680	29	;	;	:
18637	2680	30	although	although	IN
18637	2680	31	again	again	RB
18637	2680	32	action	action	NN
18637	2680	33	by	by	IN
18637	2680	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2680	35	may	may	MD
18637	2680	36	supersede	supersede	VB
18637	2680	37	State	State	NNP
18637	2680	38	action	action	NN
18637	2680	39	at	at	IN
18637	2680	40	any	any	DT
18637	2680	41	time	time	NN
18637	2680	42	.	.	.
18637	2681	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2681	2	866	866	CD
18637	2681	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2681	4	TELEGRAPHS	TELEGRAPHS	NNP
18637	2681	5	AND	and	CC
18637	2681	6	TELEPHONES	TELEPHONES	NNP
18637	2681	7	An	an	DT
18637	2681	8	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	2681	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	2681	10	which	which	WDT
18637	2681	11	required	require	VBD
18637	2681	12	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	2681	13	companies	company	NNS
18637	2681	14	to	to	TO
18637	2681	15	deliver	deliver	VB
18637	2681	16	dispatches	dispatch	NNS
18637	2681	17	by	by	IN
18637	2681	18	messenger	messenger	NN
18637	2681	19	to	to	IN
18637	2681	20	the	the	DT
18637	2681	21	persons	person	NNS
18637	2681	22	to	to	IN
18637	2681	23	whom	whom	WP
18637	2681	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2681	25	were	be	VBD
18637	2681	26	addressed	address	VBN
18637	2681	27	if	if	IN
18637	2681	28	the	the	DT
18637	2681	29	latter	latter	NN
18637	2681	30	resided	reside	VBD
18637	2681	31	within	within	IN
18637	2681	32	one	one	CD
18637	2681	33	mile	mile	NN
18637	2681	34	of	of	IN
18637	2681	35	the	the	DT
18637	2681	36	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	2681	37	station	station	NN
18637	2681	38	or	or	CC
18637	2681	39	within	within	IN
18637	2681	40	the	the	DT
18637	2681	41	city	city	NN
18637	2681	42	or	or	CC
18637	2681	43	town	town	NN
18637	2681	44	where	where	WRB
18637	2681	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2681	46	was	be	VBD
18637	2681	47	located	locate	VBN
18637	2681	48	,	,	,
18637	2681	49	and	and	CC
18637	2681	50	which	which	WDT
18637	2681	51	prescribed	prescribe	VBD
18637	2681	52	the	the	DT
18637	2681	53	order	order	NN
18637	2681	54	of	of	IN
18637	2681	55	preference	preference	NN
18637	2681	56	to	to	TO
18637	2681	57	be	be	VB
18637	2681	58	given	give	VBN
18637	2681	59	various	various	JJ
18637	2681	60	kinds	kind	NNS
18637	2681	61	of	of	IN
18637	2681	62	messages	message	NNS
18637	2681	63	,	,	,
18637	2681	64	was	be	VBD
18637	2681	65	held	hold	VBN
18637	2681	66	to	to	TO
18637	2681	67	be	be	VB
18637	2681	68	an	an	DT
18637	2681	69	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2681	70	interference	interference	NN
18637	2681	71	with	with	IN
18637	2681	72	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2681	73	commerce;[867	commerce;[867	NNS
18637	2681	74	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2681	75	as	as	IN
18637	2681	76	was	be	VBD
18637	2681	77	also	also	RB
18637	2681	78	the	the	DT
18637	2681	79	order	order	NN
18637	2681	80	of	of	IN
18637	2681	81	the	the	DT
18637	2681	82	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	2681	83	Public	Public	NNP
18637	2681	84	Service	Service	NNP
18637	2681	85	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2681	86	interfering	interfere	VBG
18637	2681	87	with	with	IN
18637	2681	88	the	the	DT
18637	2681	89	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	2681	90	to	to	IN
18637	2681	91	firms	firm	NNS
18637	2681	92	within	within	IN
18637	2681	93	the	the	DT
18637	2681	94	State	State	NNP
18637	2681	95	's	's	POS
18637	2681	96	borders	border	NNS
18637	2681	97	of	of	IN
18637	2681	98	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	2681	99	quotations	quotation	NNS
18637	2681	100	of	of	IN
18637	2681	101	the	the	DT
18637	2681	102	New	New	NNP
18637	2681	103	York	York	NNP
18637	2681	104	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	2681	105	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	2681	106	by	by	IN
18637	2681	107	means	mean	NNS
18637	2681	108	of	of	IN
18637	2681	109	ticker	ticker	JJ
18637	2681	110	service	service	NN
18637	2681	111	.	.	.
18637	2682	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2682	2	868	868	CD
18637	2682	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2682	4	But	but	CC
18637	2682	5	a	a	DT
18637	2682	6	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	2682	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	2682	8	which	which	WDT
18637	2682	9	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	2682	10	a	a	DT
18637	2682	11	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	2682	12	on	on	IN
18637	2682	13	a	a	DT
18637	2682	14	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	2682	15	company	company	NN
18637	2682	16	for	for	IN
18637	2682	17	failure	failure	NN
18637	2682	18	in	in	IN
18637	2682	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2682	20	"	"	``
18637	2682	21	clear	clear	JJ
18637	2682	22	common	common	JJ
18637	2682	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	2682	24	law	law	NN
18637	2682	25	duty	duty	NN
18637	2682	26	"	"	''
18637	2682	27	of	of	IN
18637	2682	28	transmitting	transmit	VBG
18637	2682	29	messages	message	NNS
18637	2682	30	without	without	IN
18637	2682	31	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	2682	32	delay	delay	NN
18637	2682	33	,	,	,
18637	2682	34	was	be	VBD
18637	2682	35	held	hold	VBN
18637	2682	36	,	,	,
18637	2682	37	in	in	IN
18637	2682	38	the	the	DT
18637	2682	39	absence	absence	NN
18637	2682	40	of	of	IN
18637	2682	41	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2682	42	by	by	IN
18637	2682	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2682	44	,	,	,
18637	2682	45	to	to	TO
18637	2682	46	be	be	VB
18637	2682	47	valid;[869	valid;[869	NNPS
18637	2682	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2682	49	as	as	IN
18637	2682	50	was	be	VBD
18637	2682	51	also	also	RB
18637	2682	52	a	a	DT
18637	2682	53	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	2682	54	statute	statute	NN
18637	2682	55	which	which	WDT
18637	2682	56	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	2682	57	the	the	DT
18637	2682	58	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	2682	59	by	by	IN
18637	2682	60	a	a	DT
18637	2682	61	company	company	NN
18637	2682	62	against	against	IN
18637	2682	63	liability	liability	NN
18637	2682	64	for	for	IN
18637	2682	65	nonperformance	nonperformance	NN
18637	2682	66	of	of	IN
18637	2682	67	such	such	JJ
18637	2682	68	duty	duty	NN
18637	2682	69	.	.	.
18637	2683	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2683	2	870	870	CD
18637	2683	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2683	4	However	however	RB
18637	2683	5	,	,	,
18637	2683	6	a	a	DT
18637	2683	7	South	South	NNP
18637	2683	8	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	2683	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	2683	10	which	which	WDT
18637	2683	11	sought	seek	VBD
18637	2683	12	to	to	TO
18637	2683	13	make	make	VB
18637	2683	14	mental	mental	JJ
18637	2683	15	anguish	anguish	NN
18637	2683	16	caused	cause	VBN
18637	2683	17	by	by	IN
18637	2683	18	the	the	DT
18637	2683	19	negligent	negligent	JJ
18637	2683	20	nondelivery	nondelivery	NN
18637	2683	21	of	of	IN
18637	2683	22	a	a	DT
18637	2683	23	telegram	telegram	NN
18637	2683	24	a	a	DT
18637	2683	25	cause	cause	NN
18637	2683	26	of	of	IN
18637	2683	27	action	action	NN
18637	2683	28	,	,	,
18637	2683	29	was	be	VBD
18637	2683	30	held	hold	VBN
18637	2683	31	to	to	TO
18637	2683	32	be	be	VB
18637	2683	33	,	,	,
18637	2683	34	as	as	IN
18637	2683	35	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2683	36	to	to	IN
18637	2683	37	messages	message	NNS
18637	2683	38	transmitted	transmit	VBN
18637	2683	39	from	from	IN
18637	2683	40	one	one	CD
18637	2683	41	State	state	NN
18637	2683	42	to	to	IN
18637	2683	43	another	another	DT
18637	2683	44	or	or	CC
18637	2683	45	to	to	IN
18637	2683	46	the	the	DT
18637	2683	47	District	District	NNP
18637	2683	48	of	of	IN
18637	2683	49	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	2683	50	,	,	,
18637	2683	51	an	an	DT
18637	2683	52	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2683	53	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	2683	54	to	to	TO
18637	2683	55	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2683	56	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2683	57	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2683	58	.	.	.
18637	2684	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2684	2	871	871	CD
18637	2684	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2684	4	A	a	DT
18637	2684	5	State	state	NN
18637	2684	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	2684	7	no	no	DT
18637	2684	8	authority	authority	NN
18637	2684	9	to	to	TO
18637	2684	10	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	2684	11	with	with	IN
18637	2684	12	the	the	DT
18637	2684	13	operation	operation	NN
18637	2684	14	of	of	IN
18637	2684	15	the	the	DT
18637	2684	16	lines	line	NNS
18637	2684	17	of	of	IN
18637	2684	18	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	2684	19	companies	company	NNS
18637	2684	20	constructed	construct	VBN
18637	2684	21	along	along	IN
18637	2684	22	postal	postal	JJ
18637	2684	23	routes	route	NNS
18637	2684	24	within	within	IN
18637	2684	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2684	26	borders	border	NNS
18637	2684	27	under	under	IN
18637	2684	28	the	the	DT
18637	2684	29	authority	authority	NN
18637	2684	30	of	of	IN
18637	2684	31	the	the	DT
18637	2684	32	Post	Post	NNP
18637	2684	33	Road	Road	NNP
18637	2684	34	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2684	35	of	of	IN
18637	2684	36	1866,[872	1866,[872	NNP
18637	2684	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2684	38	nor	nor	CC
18637	2684	39	to	to	TO
18637	2684	40	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	2684	41	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	2684	42	a	a	DT
18637	2684	43	company	company	NN
18637	2684	44	proposing	propose	VBG
18637	2684	45	to	to	TO
18637	2684	46	take	take	VB
18637	2684	47	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	2684	48	of	of	IN
18637	2684	49	the	the	DT
18637	2684	50	act;[873	act;[873	NNP
18637	2684	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2684	52	but	but	CC
18637	2684	53	that	that	DT
18637	2684	54	act	act	NN
18637	2684	55	does	do	VBZ
18637	2684	56	not	not	RB
18637	2684	57	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	2684	58	the	the	DT
18637	2684	59	State	state	NN
18637	2684	60	or	or	CC
18637	2684	61	a	a	DT
18637	2684	62	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	2684	63	of	of	IN
18637	2684	64	the	the	DT
18637	2684	65	right	right	NN
18637	2684	66	to	to	TO
18637	2684	67	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2684	68	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	2684	69	companies	company	NNS
18637	2684	70	to	to	IN
18637	2684	71	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2684	72	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2684	73	,	,	,
18637	2684	74	and	and	CC
18637	2684	75	an	an	DT
18637	2684	76	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	2684	77	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	2684	78	the	the	DT
18637	2684	79	erection	erection	NN
18637	2684	80	and	and	CC
18637	2684	81	use	use	NN
18637	2684	82	of	of	IN
18637	2684	83	poles	pole	NNS
18637	2684	84	and	and	CC
18637	2684	85	wires	wire	NNS
18637	2684	86	in	in	IN
18637	2684	87	the	the	DT
18637	2684	88	streets	street	NNS
18637	2684	89	does	do	VBZ
18637	2684	90	not	not	RB
18637	2684	91	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	2684	92	with	with	IN
18637	2684	93	the	the	DT
18637	2684	94	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2684	95	of	of	IN
18637	2684	96	authority	authority	NN
18637	2684	97	under	under	IN
18637	2684	98	that	that	DT
18637	2684	99	act	act	NN
18637	2684	100	.	.	.
18637	2685	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2685	2	874	874	CD
18637	2685	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2685	4	The	the	DT
18637	2685	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2685	6	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	2685	7	by	by	IN
18637	2685	8	The	the	DT
18637	2685	9	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	2685	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2685	11	of	of	IN
18637	2685	12	1920	1920	CD
18637	2685	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	2685	14	the	the	DT
18637	2685	15	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2685	16	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2685	17	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2685	18	,	,	,
18637	2685	19	and	and	CC
18637	2685	20	since	since	IN
18637	2685	21	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	2685	22	to	to	IN
18637	2685	23	the	the	DT
18637	2685	24	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2685	25	Communications	Communications	NNPS
18637	2685	26	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2685	27	,	,	,
18637	2685	28	over	over	IN
18637	2685	29	accounts	account	NNS
18637	2685	30	and	and	CC
18637	2685	31	depreciation	depreciation	NN
18637	2685	32	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2685	33	of	of	IN
18637	2685	34	telephone	telephone	NN
18637	2685	35	companies	company	NNS
18637	2685	36	does	do	VBZ
18637	2685	37	not	not	RB
18637	2685	38	,	,	,
18637	2685	39	in	in	IN
18637	2685	40	the	the	DT
18637	2685	41	absence	absence	NN
18637	2685	42	of	of	IN
18637	2685	43	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2685	44	by	by	IN
18637	2685	45	the	the	DT
18637	2685	46	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2685	47	agency	agency	NN
18637	2685	48	of	of	IN
18637	2685	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2685	50	power	power	NN
18637	2685	51	,	,	,
18637	2685	52	operate	operate	VBP
18637	2685	53	to	to	TO
18637	2685	54	curtail	curtail	VB
18637	2685	55	the	the	DT
18637	2685	56	analogous	analogous	JJ
18637	2685	57	State	State	NNP
18637	2685	58	authority;[875	authority;[875	NNPS
18637	2685	59	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2685	60	nor	nor	CC
18637	2685	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	2685	62	an	an	DT
18637	2685	63	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2685	64	burden	burden	NN
18637	2685	65	laid	lay	VBN
18637	2685	66	upon	upon	IN
18637	2685	67	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2685	68	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2685	69	by	by	IN
18637	2685	70	the	the	DT
18637	2685	71	action	action	NN
18637	2685	72	of	of	IN
18637	2685	73	a	a	DT
18637	2685	74	State	State	NNP
18637	2685	75	agency	agency	NN
18637	2685	76	in	in	IN
18637	2685	77	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2685	78	a	a	DT
18637	2685	79	telephone	telephone	NN
18637	2685	80	company	company	NN
18637	2685	81	to	to	TO
18637	2685	82	revise	revise	VB
18637	2685	83	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2685	84	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	2685	85	toll	toll	NN
18637	2685	86	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2685	87	so	so	IN
18637	2685	88	as	as	IN
18637	2685	89	to	to	TO
18637	2685	90	conform	conform	VB
18637	2685	91	to	to	IN
18637	2685	92	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2685	93	charged	charge	VBN
18637	2685	94	for	for	IN
18637	2685	95	comparable	comparable	JJ
18637	2685	96	distances	distance	NNS
18637	2685	97	in	in	IN
18637	2685	98	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2685	99	service	service	NN
18637	2685	100	.	.	.
18637	2686	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2686	2	876	876	CD
18637	2686	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2686	4	GAS	GAS	NNP
18637	2686	5	AND	and	CC
18637	2686	6	ELECTRICITY	electricity	VB
18637	2686	7	The	the	DT
18637	2686	8	business	business	NN
18637	2686	9	of	of	IN
18637	2686	10	piping	pipe	VBG
18637	2686	11	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2686	12	gas	gas	NN
18637	2686	13	from	from	IN
18637	2686	14	one	one	CD
18637	2686	15	State	state	NN
18637	2686	16	to	to	IN
18637	2686	17	another	another	DT
18637	2686	18	to	to	IN
18637	2686	19	local	local	JJ
18637	2686	20	distributors	distributor	NNS
18637	2686	21	which	which	WDT
18637	2686	22	sell	sell	VBP
18637	2686	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2686	24	locally	locally	RB
18637	2686	25	to	to	IN
18637	2686	26	consumers	consumer	NNS
18637	2686	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	2686	28	a	a	DT
18637	2686	29	branch	branch	NN
18637	2686	30	of	of	IN
18637	2686	31	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2686	32	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2686	33	which	which	WDT
18637	2686	34	a	a	DT
18637	2686	35	State	state	NN
18637	2686	36	may	may	MD
18637	2686	37	not	not	RB
18637	2686	38	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2686	39	.	.	.
18637	2687	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2687	2	877	877	CD
18637	2687	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2687	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	2687	5	,	,	,
18637	2687	6	an	an	DT
18637	2687	7	order	order	NN
18637	2687	8	by	by	IN
18637	2687	9	a	a	DT
18637	2687	10	State	State	NNP
18637	2687	11	commission	commission	NN
18637	2687	12	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	2687	13	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2687	14	on	on	IN
18637	2687	15	electric	electric	JJ
18637	2687	16	current	current	NN
18637	2687	17	generated	generate	VBN
18637	2687	18	within	within	IN
18637	2687	19	the	the	DT
18637	2687	20	States	States	NNPS
18637	2687	21	and	and	CC
18637	2687	22	sold	sell	VBD
18637	2687	23	to	to	IN
18637	2687	24	a	a	DT
18637	2687	25	distributor	distributor	NN
18637	2687	26	in	in	IN
18637	2687	27	another	another	DT
18637	2687	28	State	State	NNP
18637	2687	29	,	,	,
18637	2687	30	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	2687	31	an	an	DT
18637	2687	32	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2687	33	burden	burden	NN
18637	2687	34	on	on	IN
18637	2687	35	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2687	36	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2687	37	,	,	,
18637	2687	38	although	although	IN
18637	2687	39	the	the	DT
18637	2687	40	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2687	41	of	of	IN
18637	2687	42	such	such	JJ
18637	2687	43	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2687	44	would	would	MD
18637	2687	45	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	2687	46	benefit	benefit	VB
18637	2687	47	local	local	JJ
18637	2687	48	consumers	consumer	NNS
18637	2687	49	of	of	IN
18637	2687	50	electricity	electricity	NN
18637	2687	51	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	2687	52	by	by	IN
18637	2687	53	the	the	DT
18637	2687	54	same	same	JJ
18637	2687	55	company	company	NN
18637	2687	56	.	.	.
18637	2688	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2688	2	878	878	CD
18637	2688	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2688	4	In	in	IN
18637	2688	5	the	the	DT
18637	2688	6	absence	absence	NN
18637	2688	7	,	,	,
18637	2688	8	on	on	IN
18637	2688	9	the	the	DT
18637	2688	10	other	other	JJ
18637	2688	11	hand	hand	NN
18637	2688	12	,	,	,
18637	2688	13	of	of	IN
18637	2688	14	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	2688	15	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2688	16	by	by	IN
18637	2688	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2688	18	a	a	DT
18637	2688	19	State	State	NNP
18637	2688	20	may	may	MD
18637	2688	21	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2688	22	the	the	DT
18637	2688	23	sale	sale	NN
18637	2688	24	to	to	IN
18637	2688	25	consumers	consumer	NNS
18637	2688	26	in	in	IN
18637	2688	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2688	28	cities	city	NNS
18637	2688	29	of	of	IN
18637	2688	30	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2688	31	gas	gas	NN
18637	2688	32	produced	produce	VBN
18637	2688	33	in	in	IN
18637	2688	34	and	and	CC
18637	2688	35	transmitted	transmit	VBN
18637	2688	36	from	from	IN
18637	2688	37	another	another	DT
18637	2688	38	State;[879	state;[879	NN
18637	2688	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2688	40	nor	nor	CC
18637	2688	41	did	do	VBD
18637	2688	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2688	43	,	,	,
18637	2688	44	by	by	IN
18637	2688	45	the	the	DT
18637	2688	46	National	National	NNP
18637	2688	47	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	2688	48	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2688	49	of	of	IN
18637	2688	50	1938	1938	CD
18637	2688	51	,	,	,
18637	2688	52	impose	impose	VB
18637	2688	53	any	any	DT
18637	2688	54	such	such	JJ
18637	2688	55	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	2688	56	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2688	57	.	.	.
18637	2689	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2689	2	880	880	CD
18637	2689	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2689	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	2689	5	,	,	,
18637	2689	6	a	a	DT
18637	2689	7	State	state	NN
18637	2689	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	2689	9	left	leave	VBN
18637	2689	10	free	free	JJ
18637	2689	11	by	by	IN
18637	2689	12	the	the	DT
18637	2689	13	same	same	JJ
18637	2689	14	act	act	NN
18637	2689	15	to	to	TO
18637	2689	16	require	require	VB
18637	2689	17	a	a	DT
18637	2689	18	gas	gas	NN
18637	2689	19	company	company	NN
18637	2689	20	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2689	21	in	in	IN
18637	2689	22	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2689	23	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2689	24	to	to	TO
18637	2689	25	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	2689	26	a	a	DT
18637	2689	27	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	2689	28	of	of	IN
18637	2689	29	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	2689	30	before	before	IN
18637	2689	31	selling	sell	VBG
18637	2689	32	directly	directly	RB
18637	2689	33	to	to	IN
18637	2689	34	customers	customer	NNS
18637	2689	35	in	in	IN
18637	2689	36	the	the	DT
18637	2689	37	State	State	NNP
18637	2689	38	.	.	.
18637	2690	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2690	2	881	881	CD
18637	2690	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2690	4	And	and	CC
18637	2690	5	where	where	WRB
18637	2690	6	a	a	DT
18637	2690	7	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	2690	8	line	line	NN
18637	2690	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	2690	10	used	use	VBN
18637	2690	11	to	to	TO
18637	2690	12	distribute	distribute	VB
18637	2690	13	both	both	DT
18637	2690	14	gas	gas	NN
18637	2690	15	that	that	WDT
18637	2690	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	2690	17	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2690	18	in	in	RP
18637	2690	19	from	from	IN
18637	2690	20	without	without	IN
18637	2690	21	the	the	DT
18637	2690	22	State	state	NN
18637	2690	23	and	and	CC
18637	2690	24	gas	gas	NN
18637	2690	25	that	that	WDT
18637	2690	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	2690	27	produced	produce	VBN
18637	2690	28	and	and	CC
18637	2690	29	used	use	VBN
18637	2690	30	within	within	IN
18637	2690	31	the	the	DT
18637	2690	32	State	State	NNP
18637	2690	33	,	,	,
18637	2690	34	and	and	CC
18637	2690	35	the	the	DT
18637	2690	36	two	two	CD
18637	2690	37	are	be	VBP
18637	2690	38	commingled	commingle	VBN
18637	2690	39	,	,	,
18637	2690	40	but	but	CC
18637	2690	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2690	42	proportionate	proportionate	JJ
18637	2690	43	quantities	quantity	NNS
18637	2690	44	are	be	VBP
18637	2690	45	known	know	VBN
18637	2690	46	,	,	,
18637	2690	47	an	an	DT
18637	2690	48	order	order	NN
18637	2690	49	by	by	IN
18637	2690	50	the	the	DT
18637	2690	51	State	State	NNP
18637	2690	52	commission	commission	NN
18637	2690	53	directing	direct	VBG
18637	2690	54	the	the	DT
18637	2690	55	gas	gas	NN
18637	2690	56	company	company	NN
18637	2690	57	to	to	TO
18637	2690	58	continue	continue	VB
18637	2690	59	supplying	supply	VBG
18637	2690	60	gas	gas	NN
18637	2690	61	from	from	IN
18637	2690	62	the	the	DT
18637	2690	63	line	line	NN
18637	2690	64	to	to	IN
18637	2690	65	a	a	DT
18637	2690	66	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2690	67	community	community	NN
18637	2690	68	does	do	VBZ
18637	2690	69	not	not	RB
18637	2690	70	burden	burden	VB
18637	2690	71	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2690	72	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2690	73	.	.	.
18637	2691	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2691	2	882	882	CD
18637	2691	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2691	4	The	the	DT
18637	2691	5	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2691	6	of	of	IN
18637	2691	7	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2691	8	gas	gas	NN
18637	2691	9	from	from	IN
18637	2691	10	sources	source	NNS
18637	2691	11	outside	outside	IN
18637	2691	12	the	the	DT
18637	2691	13	State	State	NNP
18637	2691	14	to	to	IN
18637	2691	15	local	local	JJ
18637	2691	16	consumers	consumer	NNS
18637	2691	17	in	in	IN
18637	2691	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2691	19	municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	2691	20	ceases	cease	VBZ
18637	2691	21	to	to	TO
18637	2691	22	be	be	VB
18637	2691	23	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2691	24	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2691	25	at	at	IN
18637	2691	26	the	the	DT
18637	2691	27	point	point	NN
18637	2691	28	where	where	WRB
18637	2691	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2691	30	passes	pass	VBZ
18637	2691	31	from	from	IN
18637	2691	32	a	a	DT
18637	2691	33	pressure	pressure	NN
18637	2691	34	producing	produce	VBG
18637	2691	35	station	station	NN
18637	2691	36	into	into	IN
18637	2691	37	local	local	JJ
18637	2691	38	distributing	distribute	VBG
18637	2691	39	stations	station	NNS
18637	2691	40	,	,	,
18637	2691	41	and	and	CC
18637	2691	42	from	from	IN
18637	2691	43	that	that	DT
18637	2691	44	point	point	NN
18637	2691	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	2691	46	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2691	47	to	to	IN
18637	2691	48	State	State	NNP
18637	2691	49	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2691	50	.	.	.
18637	2692	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2692	2	883	883	CD
18637	2692	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2692	4	A	a	DT
18637	2692	5	State	State	NNP
18637	2692	6	public	public	JJ
18637	2692	7	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	2692	8	commission	commission	NN
18637	2692	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	2692	10	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	2692	11	to	to	TO
18637	2692	12	require	require	VB
18637	2692	13	a	a	DT
18637	2692	14	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2692	15	gas	gas	NN
18637	2692	16	distributing	distribute	VBG
18637	2692	17	company	company	NN
18637	2692	18	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	2692	19	an	an	DT
18637	2692	20	increase	increase	NN
18637	2692	21	of	of	IN
18637	2692	22	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2692	23	to	to	TO
18637	2692	24	show	show	VB
18637	2692	25	the	the	DT
18637	2692	26	fairness	fairness	NN
18637	2692	27	and	and	CC
18637	2692	28	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	2692	29	of	of	IN
18637	2692	30	the	the	DT
18637	2692	31	rate	rate	NN
18637	2692	32	paid	pay	VBN
18637	2692	33	by	by	IN
18637	2692	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2692	35	to	to	IN
18637	2692	36	the	the	DT
18637	2692	37	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	2692	38	line	line	NN
18637	2692	39	company	company	NN
18637	2692	40	from	from	IN
18637	2692	41	which	which	WDT
18637	2692	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2692	43	obtains	obtain	VBZ
18637	2692	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2692	45	supplies	supply	NNS
18637	2692	46	,	,	,
18637	2692	47	both	both	DT
18637	2692	48	companies	company	NNS
18637	2692	49	being	be	VBG
18637	2692	50	subsidiaries	subsidiary	NNS
18637	2692	51	of	of	IN
18637	2692	52	a	a	DT
18637	2692	53	third	third	NN
18637	2692	54	.	.	.
18637	2693	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2693	2	884	884	CD
18637	2693	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2693	4	A	a	DT
18637	2693	5	State	State	NNP
18637	2693	6	agency	agency	NN
18637	2693	7	may	may	MD
18637	2693	8	require	require	VB
18637	2693	9	a	a	DT
18637	2693	10	company	company	NN
18637	2693	11	which	which	WDT
18637	2693	12	sells	sell	VBZ
18637	2693	13	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2693	14	gas	gas	NN
18637	2693	15	to	to	IN
18637	2693	16	local	local	JJ
18637	2693	17	consumers	consumer	NNS
18637	2693	18	and	and	CC
18637	2693	19	distributing	distribute	VBG
18637	2693	20	companies	company	NNS
18637	2693	21	,	,	,
18637	2693	22	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	2693	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2693	24	in	in	IN
18637	2693	25	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	2693	26	lines	line	NNS
18637	2693	27	from	from	IN
18637	2693	28	other	other	JJ
18637	2693	29	States	States	NNPS
18637	2693	30	,	,	,
18637	2693	31	to	to	TO
18637	2693	32	file	file	VB
18637	2693	33	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	2693	34	,	,	,
18637	2693	35	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	2693	36	,	,	,
18637	2693	37	etc	etc	FW
18637	2693	38	.	.	FW
18637	2693	39	,	,	,
18637	2693	40	for	for	IN
18637	2693	41	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2693	42	and	and	CC
18637	2693	43	deliveries	delivery	NNS
18637	2693	44	to	to	IN
18637	2693	45	the	the	DT
18637	2693	46	distributing	distributing	NN
18637	2693	47	companies;[885	companies;[885	ADD
18637	2693	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2693	49	nor	nor	CC
18637	2693	50	does	do	VBZ
18637	2693	51	the	the	DT
18637	2693	52	fact	fact	NN
18637	2693	53	that	that	IN
18637	2693	54	a	a	DT
18637	2693	55	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2693	56	gas	gas	NN
18637	2693	57	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	2693	58	line	line	NN
18637	2693	59	from	from	IN
18637	2693	60	the	the	DT
18637	2693	61	place	place	NN
18637	2693	62	of	of	IN
18637	2693	63	production	production	NN
18637	2693	64	to	to	IN
18637	2693	65	the	the	DT
18637	2693	66	distributing	distribute	VBG
18637	2693	67	points	point	NNS
18637	2693	68	in	in	IN
18637	2693	69	the	the	DT
18637	2693	70	same	same	JJ
18637	2693	71	State	State	NNP
18637	2693	72	cuts	cut	VBZ
18637	2693	73	across	across	IN
18637	2693	74	a	a	DT
18637	2693	75	corner	corner	NN
18637	2693	76	of	of	IN
18637	2693	77	another	another	DT
18637	2693	78	State	state	NN
18637	2693	79	render	render	VB
18637	2693	80	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2693	81	improper	improper	JJ
18637	2693	82	,	,	,
18637	2693	83	in	in	IN
18637	2693	84	determining	determine	VBG
18637	2693	85	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	2693	86	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2693	87	for	for	IN
18637	2693	88	gas	gas	NN
18637	2693	89	sold	sell	VBN
18637	2693	90	by	by	IN
18637	2693	91	the	the	DT
18637	2693	92	owner	owner	NN
18637	2693	93	of	of	IN
18637	2693	94	the	the	DT
18637	2693	95	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	2693	96	line	line	NN
18637	2693	97	to	to	IN
18637	2693	98	distributing	distribute	VBG
18637	2693	99	companies	company	NNS
18637	2693	100	,	,	,
18637	2693	101	to	to	TO
18637	2693	102	include	include	VB
18637	2693	103	the	the	DT
18637	2693	104	value	value	NN
18637	2693	105	of	of	IN
18637	2693	106	the	the	DT
18637	2693	107	total	total	JJ
18637	2693	108	line	line	NN
18637	2693	109	in	in	IN
18637	2693	110	the	the	DT
18637	2693	111	rate	rate	NN
18637	2693	112	base	base	NN
18637	2693	113	.	.	.
18637	2694	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2694	2	886	886	CD
18637	2694	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2694	4	A	a	DT
18637	2694	5	State	state	NN
18637	2694	6	may	may	MD
18637	2694	7	,	,	,
18637	2694	8	as	as	IN
18637	2694	9	a	a	DT
18637	2694	10	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	2694	11	measure	measure	NN
18637	2694	12	,	,	,
18637	2694	13	fix	fix	VB
18637	2694	14	the	the	DT
18637	2694	15	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	2694	16	prices	price	NNS
18637	2694	17	at	at	IN
18637	2694	18	the	the	DT
18637	2694	19	wellhead	wellhead	NN
18637	2694	20	on	on	IN
18637	2694	21	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2694	22	gas	gas	NN
18637	2694	23	produced	produce	VBN
18637	2694	24	in	in	IN
18637	2694	25	the	the	DT
18637	2694	26	State	State	NNP
18637	2694	27	and	and	CC
18637	2694	28	sold	sell	VBD
18637	2694	29	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2694	30	.	.	.
18637	2695	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2695	2	887	887	CD
18637	2695	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2695	4	FOREIGN	foreign	JJ
18637	2695	5	CORPORATIONS	corporations	NN
18637	2695	6	A	a	DT
18637	2695	7	State	state	NN
18637	2695	8	may	may	MD
18637	2695	9	require	require	VB
18637	2695	10	that	that	IN
18637	2695	11	a	a	DT
18637	2695	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2695	13	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2695	14	as	as	IN
18637	2695	15	a	a	DT
18637	2695	16	condition	condition	NN
18637	2695	17	of	of	IN
18637	2695	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2695	19	being	be	VBG
18637	2695	20	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	2695	21	to	to	TO
18637	2695	22	do	do	VB
18637	2695	23	a	a	DT
18637	2695	24	local	local	JJ
18637	2695	25	business	business	NN
18637	2695	26	or	or	CC
18637	2695	27	to	to	IN
18637	2695	28	having	have	VBG
18637	2695	29	access	access	NN
18637	2695	30	to	to	IN
18637	2695	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2695	32	courts	court	NNS
18637	2695	33	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	2695	34	a	a	DT
18637	2695	35	license	license	NN
18637	2695	36	,	,	,
18637	2695	37	and	and	CC
18637	2695	38	in	in	IN
18637	2695	39	connection	connection	NN
18637	2695	40	therewith	therewith	NNP
18637	2695	41	furnish	furnish	JJ
18637	2695	42	information	information	NN
18637	2695	43	as	as	IN
18637	2695	44	to	to	IN
18637	2695	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2695	46	home	home	NN
18637	2695	47	State	State	NNP
18637	2695	48	or	or	CC
18637	2695	49	country	country	NN
18637	2695	50	,	,	,
18637	2695	51	the	the	DT
18637	2695	52	location	location	NN
18637	2695	53	of	of	IN
18637	2695	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2695	55	principal	principal	JJ
18637	2695	56	office	office	NN
18637	2695	57	,	,	,
18637	2695	58	the	the	DT
18637	2695	59	names	name	NNS
18637	2695	60	of	of	IN
18637	2695	61	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2695	62	officers	officer	NNS
18637	2695	63	and	and	CC
18637	2695	64	directors	director	NNS
18637	2695	65	,	,	,
18637	2695	66	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2695	67	authorized	authorized	JJ
18637	2695	68	capitalization	capitalization	NN
18637	2695	69	,	,	,
18637	2695	70	and	and	CC
18637	2695	71	the	the	DT
18637	2695	72	like	like	JJ
18637	2695	73	,	,	,
18637	2695	74	and	and	CC
18637	2695	75	that	that	IN
18637	2695	76	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2695	77	pay	pay	VB
18637	2695	78	a	a	DT
18637	2695	79	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2695	80	license	license	NN
18637	2695	81	fee;[888	fee;[888	NNP
18637	2695	82	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2695	83	nor	nor	CC
18637	2695	84	is	be	VBZ
18637	2695	85	a	a	DT
18637	2695	86	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2695	87	licensed	license	VBN
18637	2695	88	by	by	IN
18637	2695	89	the	the	DT
18637	2695	90	National	National	NNP
18637	2695	91	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2695	92	to	to	TO
18637	2695	93	act	act	VB
18637	2695	94	as	as	IN
18637	2695	95	a	a	DT
18637	2695	96	customs	custom	NNS
18637	2695	97	broker	broker	NN
18637	2695	98	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	2695	99	relieved	relieve	VBD
18637	2695	100	from	from	IN
18637	2695	101	meeting	meet	VBG
18637	2695	102	such	such	JJ
18637	2695	103	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2695	104	.	.	.
18637	2696	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2696	2	889	889	CD
18637	2696	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2696	4	So	so	RB
18637	2696	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2696	6	was	be	VBD
18637	2696	7	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2696	8	in	in	IN
18637	2696	9	1944	1944	CD
18637	2696	10	.	.	.
18637	2697	1	The	the	DT
18637	2697	2	holding	holding	NN
18637	2697	3	does	do	VBZ
18637	2697	4	not	not	RB
18637	2697	5	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	2697	6	disturb	disturb	VB
18637	2697	7	one	one	CD
18637	2697	8	made	make	VBD
18637	2697	9	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	2697	10	years	year	NNS
18637	2697	11	earlier	early	RBR
18637	2697	12	in	in	IN
18637	2697	13	which	which	WDT
18637	2697	14	the	the	DT
18637	2697	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2697	16	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	2697	17	that	that	IN
18637	2697	18	a	a	DT
18637	2697	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	2697	20	which	which	WDT
18637	2697	21	closed	close	VBD
18637	2697	22	the	the	DT
18637	2697	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	2697	24	of	of	IN
18637	2697	25	the	the	DT
18637	2697	26	enacting	enact	VBG
18637	2697	27	State	state	NN
18637	2697	28	to	to	IN
18637	2697	29	any	any	DT
18637	2697	30	action	action	NN
18637	2697	31	on	on	IN
18637	2697	32	any	any	DT
18637	2697	33	contract	contract	NN
18637	2697	34	in	in	IN
18637	2697	35	the	the	DT
18637	2697	36	State	State	NNP
18637	2697	37	by	by	IN
18637	2697	38	a	a	DT
18637	2697	39	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2697	40	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2697	41	unless	unless	IN
18637	2697	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2697	43	had	have	VBD
18637	2697	44	previously	previously	RB
18637	2697	45	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	2697	46	a	a	DT
18637	2697	47	resident	resident	JJ
18637	2697	48	agent	agent	NN
18637	2697	49	to	to	TO
18637	2697	50	accept	accept	VB
18637	2697	51	process	process	NN
18637	2697	52	,	,	,
18637	2697	53	could	could	MD
18637	2697	54	not	not	RB
18637	2697	55	be	be	VB
18637	2697	56	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	2697	57	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2697	58	to	to	IN
18637	2697	59	the	the	DT
18637	2697	60	right	right	NN
18637	2697	61	of	of	IN
18637	2697	62	a	a	DT
18637	2697	63	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2697	64	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2697	65	to	to	TO
18637	2697	66	sue	sue	VB
18637	2697	67	on	on	IN
18637	2697	68	an	an	DT
18637	2697	69	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2697	70	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	2697	71	.	.	.
18637	2698	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2698	2	890	890	CD
18637	2698	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2698	4	A	a	DT
18637	2698	5	suit	suit	NN
18637	2698	6	brought	bring	VBD
18637	2698	7	in	in	RP
18637	2698	8	a	a	DT
18637	2698	9	State	State	NNP
18637	2698	10	court	court	NN
18637	2698	11	by	by	IN
18637	2698	12	a	a	DT
18637	2698	13	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2698	14	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2698	15	having	have	VBG
18637	2698	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2698	17	principal	principal	JJ
18637	2698	18	place	place	NN
18637	2698	19	of	of	IN
18637	2698	20	business	business	NN
18637	2698	21	in	in	IN
18637	2698	22	the	the	DT
18637	2698	23	State	State	NNP
18637	2698	24	against	against	IN
18637	2698	25	another	another	DT
18637	2698	26	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2698	27	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2698	28	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2698	29	in	in	IN
18637	2698	30	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2698	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2698	32	on	on	IN
18637	2698	33	a	a	DT
18637	2698	34	cause	cause	NN
18637	2698	35	of	of	IN
18637	2698	36	action	action	NN
18637	2698	37	arising	arise	VBG
18637	2698	38	outside	outside	IN
18637	2698	39	the	the	DT
18637	2698	40	State	state	NN
18637	2698	41	does	do	VBZ
18637	2698	42	not	not	RB
18637	2698	43	impose	impose	VB
18637	2698	44	an	an	DT
18637	2698	45	undue	undue	JJ
18637	2698	46	burden	burden	NN
18637	2698	47	on	on	IN
18637	2698	48	such	such	JJ
18637	2698	49	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2698	50	;	;	:
18637	2698	51	and	and	CC
18637	2698	52	the	the	DT
18637	2698	53	forum	forum	NN
18637	2698	54	being	be	VBG
18637	2698	55	in	in	IN
18637	2698	56	other	other	JJ
18637	2698	57	respects	respect	NNS
18637	2698	58	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	2698	59	,	,	,
18637	2698	60	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2698	61	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2698	62	is	be	VBZ
18637	2698	63	not	not	RB
18637	2698	64	forfeited	forfeit	VBN
18637	2698	65	because	because	IN
18637	2698	66	the	the	DT
18637	2698	67	property	property	NN
18637	2698	68	attached	attach	VBN
18637	2698	69	is	be	VBZ
18637	2698	70	an	an	DT
18637	2698	71	instrumentality	instrumentality	NN
18637	2698	72	of	of	IN
18637	2698	73	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2698	74	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2698	75	.	.	.
18637	2699	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2699	2	891	891	CD
18637	2699	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2699	4	There	there	EX
18637	2699	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	2699	6	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	2699	7	in	in	IN
18637	2699	8	the	the	DT
18637	2699	9	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2699	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	2699	11	which	which	WDT
18637	2699	12	immunizes	immunize	VBZ
18637	2699	13	a	a	DT
18637	2699	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2699	15	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2699	16	doing	do	VBG
18637	2699	17	business	business	NN
18637	2699	18	in	in	IN
18637	2699	19	a	a	DT
18637	2699	20	State	state	NN
18637	2699	21	from	from	IN
18637	2699	22	any	any	DT
18637	2699	23	fair	fair	JJ
18637	2699	24	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	2699	25	,	,	,
18637	2699	26	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	2699	27	or	or	CC
18637	2699	28	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2699	29	,	,	,
18637	2699	30	that	that	WDT
18637	2699	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	2699	32	required	require	VBN
18637	2699	33	by	by	IN
18637	2699	34	local	local	JJ
18637	2699	35	laws	law	NNS
18637	2699	36	.	.	.
18637	2700	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2700	2	892	892	CD
18637	2700	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2700	4	MISCELLANEOUS	MISCELLANEOUS	NNP
18637	2700	5	Banks	Banks	NNPS
18637	2700	6	and	and	CC
18637	2700	7	Banking	Banking	NNP
18637	2700	8	A	a	DT
18637	2700	9	State	State	NNP
18637	2700	10	statute	statute	NN
18637	2700	11	which	which	WDT
18637	2700	12	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	2700	13	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	2700	14	or	or	CC
18637	2700	15	partnerships	partnership	NNS
18637	2700	16	to	to	TO
18637	2700	17	engage	engage	VB
18637	2700	18	in	in	IN
18637	2700	19	the	the	DT
18637	2700	20	banking	banking	NN
18637	2700	21	business	business	NN
18637	2700	22	without	without	IN
18637	2700	23	a	a	DT
18637	2700	24	license	license	NN
18637	2700	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	2700	26	not	not	RB
18637	2700	27	,	,	,
18637	2700	28	as	as	IN
18637	2700	29	to	to	IN
18637	2700	30	one	one	CD
18637	2700	31	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2700	32	business	business	NN
18637	2700	33	chiefly	chiefly	RB
18637	2700	34	consists	consist	VBZ
18637	2700	35	in	in	IN
18637	2700	36	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	2700	37	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	2700	38	for	for	IN
18637	2700	39	periodic	periodic	JJ
18637	2700	40	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2700	41	to	to	IN
18637	2700	42	other	other	JJ
18637	2700	43	States	States	NNPS
18637	2700	44	and	and	CC
18637	2700	45	to	to	IN
18637	2700	46	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2700	47	countries	country	NNS
18637	2700	48	,	,	,
18637	2700	49	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	2700	50	as	as	IN
18637	2700	51	a	a	DT
18637	2700	52	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2700	53	of	of	IN
18637	2700	54	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2700	55	and	and	CC
18637	2700	56	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2700	57	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2700	58	.	.	.
18637	2701	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2701	2	893	893	CD
18637	2701	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2701	4	Brokers	broker	NNS
18637	2701	5	A	a	DT
18637	2701	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	2701	7	which	which	WDT
18637	2701	8	requires	require	VBZ
18637	2701	9	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	2701	10	in	in	IN
18637	2701	11	securities	security	NNS
18637	2701	12	evidencing	evidence	VBG
18637	2701	13	title	title	NN
18637	2701	14	or	or	CC
18637	2701	15	interest	interest	NN
18637	2701	16	in	in	IN
18637	2701	17	property	property	NN
18637	2701	18	to	to	TO
18637	2701	19	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	2701	20	a	a	DT
18637	2701	21	license	license	NN
18637	2701	22	from	from	IN
18637	2701	23	a	a	DT
18637	2701	24	State	state	NN
18637	2701	25	officer	officer	NN
18637	2701	26	,	,	,
18637	2701	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	2701	28	not	not	RB
18637	2701	29	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	2701	30	as	as	IN
18637	2701	31	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2701	32	to	to	IN
18637	2701	33	dispositions	disposition	NNS
18637	2701	34	within	within	IN
18637	2701	35	the	the	DT
18637	2701	36	State	State	NNP
18637	2701	37	securities	security	NNS
18637	2701	38	transported	transport	VBN
18637	2701	39	from	from	IN
18637	2701	40	other	other	JJ
18637	2701	41	States	state	NNS
18637	2701	42	.	.	.
18637	2702	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2702	2	894	894	CD
18637	2702	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2702	4	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2702	5	Men	Men	NNP
18637	2702	6	A	a	DT
18637	2702	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	2702	8	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2702	9	commission	commission	NN
18637	2702	10	merchants	merchant	NNS
18637	2702	11	to	to	TO
18637	2702	12	give	give	VB
18637	2702	13	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	2702	14	for	for	IN
18637	2702	15	the	the	DT
18637	2702	16	protection	protection	NN
18637	2702	17	of	of	IN
18637	2702	18	consignees	consignee	NNS
18637	2702	19	may	may	MD
18637	2702	20	be	be	VB
18637	2702	21	validly	validly	RB
18637	2702	22	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2702	23	to	to	IN
18637	2702	24	commission	commission	NN
18637	2702	25	merchants	merchant	NNS
18637	2702	26	handling	handle	VBG
18637	2702	27	produce	produce	NN
18637	2702	28	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	2702	29	to	to	IN
18637	2702	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2702	31	from	from	IN
18637	2702	32	without	without	IN
18637	2702	33	the	the	DT
18637	2702	34	State	State	NNP
18637	2702	35	.	.	.
18637	2703	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2703	2	895	895	CD
18637	2703	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2703	4	Attachment	Attachment	NNP
18637	2703	5	and	and	CC
18637	2703	6	Garnishment	Garnishment	NNP
18637	2703	7	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	2703	8	cars	car	NNS
18637	2703	9	are	be	VBP
18637	2703	10	not	not	RB
18637	2703	11	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	2703	12	from	from	IN
18637	2703	13	attachment	attachment	NN
18637	2703	14	under	under	IN
18637	2703	15	State	State	NNP
18637	2703	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	2703	17	,	,	,
18637	2703	18	although	although	IN
18637	2703	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2703	20	may	may	MD
18637	2703	21	have	have	VB
18637	2703	22	been	be	VBN
18637	2703	23	or	or	CC
18637	2703	24	are	be	VBP
18637	2703	25	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2703	26	to	to	TO
18637	2703	27	be	be	VB
18637	2703	28	used	use	VBN
18637	2703	29	in	in	IN
18637	2703	30	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2703	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2703	32	.	.	.
18637	2704	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2704	2	896	896	CD
18637	2704	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2704	4	Statutory	Statutory	NNP
18637	2704	5	Liens	Liens	NNP
18637	2704	6	A	a	DT
18637	2704	7	State	State	NNP
18637	2704	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	2704	9	which	which	WDT
18637	2704	10	gives	give	VBZ
18637	2704	11	a	a	DT
18637	2704	12	lien	lien	NN
18637	2704	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	2704	14	all	all	DT
18637	2704	15	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	2704	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	2704	17	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	2704	18	or	or	CC
18637	2704	19	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2704	20	,	,	,
18637	2704	21	and	and	CC
18637	2704	22	whether	whether	IN
18637	2704	23	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2704	24	in	in	IN
18637	2704	25	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2704	26	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2704	27	or	or	CC
18637	2704	28	not	not	RB
18637	2704	29	,	,	,
18637	2704	30	for	for	IN
18637	2704	31	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	2704	32	to	to	IN
18637	2704	33	persons	person	NNS
18637	2704	34	and	and	CC
18637	2704	35	property	property	NN
18637	2704	36	within	within	IN
18637	2704	37	the	the	DT
18637	2704	38	State	State	NNP
18637	2704	39	,	,	,
18637	2704	40	does	do	VBZ
18637	2704	41	not	not	RB
18637	2704	42	as	as	RB
18637	2704	43	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2704	44	to	to	IN
18637	2704	45	nonmaritime	nonmaritime	NN
18637	2704	46	torts	tort	NNS
18637	2704	47	offend	offend	VBP
18637	2704	48	the	the	DT
18637	2704	49	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2704	50	clause	clause	NN
18637	2704	51	,	,	,
18637	2704	52	there	there	EX
18637	2704	53	being	be	VBG
18637	2704	54	no	no	DT
18637	2704	55	act	act	NN
18637	2704	56	of	of	IN
18637	2704	57	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2704	58	in	in	IN
18637	2704	59	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	2704	60	.	.	.
18637	2705	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2705	2	897	897	CD
18637	2705	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2705	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	2705	5	can	can	MD
18637	2705	6	the	the	DT
18637	2705	7	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	2705	8	of	of	IN
18637	2705	9	a	a	DT
18637	2705	10	lien	lien	NN
18637	2705	11	for	for	IN
18637	2705	12	materials	material	NNS
18637	2705	13	used	use	VBN
18637	2705	14	in	in	IN
18637	2705	15	the	the	DT
18637	2705	16	construction	construction	NN
18637	2705	17	of	of	IN
18637	2705	18	a	a	DT
18637	2705	19	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	2705	20	be	be	VB
18637	2705	21	avoided	avoid	VBN
18637	2705	22	because	because	IN
18637	2705	23	the	the	DT
18637	2705	24	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	2705	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	2705	26	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2705	27	in	in	IN
18637	2705	28	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2705	29	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2705	30	.	.	.
18637	2706	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2706	2	898	898	CD
18637	2706	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2706	4	The	the	DT
18637	2706	5	Police	Police	NNP
18637	2706	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	2706	7	and	and	CC
18637	2706	8	the	the	DT
18637	2706	9	Subject	Subject	NNP
18637	2706	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	2706	11	Matter	Matter	NNP
18637	2706	12	of	of	IN
18637	2706	13	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2706	14	SCOPE	SCOPE	NNP
18637	2706	15	OF	of	IN
18637	2706	16	THE	the	DT
18637	2706	17	POLICE	POLICE	NNP
18637	2706	18	POWER	POWER	NNP
18637	2706	19	"	"	``
18637	2706	20	Quarantine	Quarantine	NNP
18637	2706	21	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2706	22	are	be	VBP
18637	2706	23	essential	essential	JJ
18637	2706	24	measures	measure	NNS
18637	2706	25	of	of	IN
18637	2706	26	protection	protection	NN
18637	2706	27	which	which	WDT
18637	2706	28	the	the	DT
18637	2706	29	States	state	NNS
18637	2706	30	are	be	VBP
18637	2706	31	free	free	JJ
18637	2706	32	to	to	TO
18637	2706	33	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	2706	34	when	when	WRB
18637	2706	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2706	36	do	do	VBP
18637	2706	37	not	not	RB
18637	2706	38	come	come	VB
18637	2706	39	into	into	IN
18637	2706	40	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	2706	41	with	with	IN
18637	2706	42	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	2706	43	action	action	NN
18637	2706	44	.	.	.
18637	2707	1	In	in	IN
18637	2707	2	view	view	NN
18637	2707	3	of	of	IN
18637	2707	4	the	the	DT
18637	2707	5	need	need	NN
18637	2707	6	of	of	IN
18637	2707	7	conforming	conform	VBG
18637	2707	8	such	such	JJ
18637	2707	9	measures	measure	NNS
18637	2707	10	to	to	IN
18637	2707	11	local	local	JJ
18637	2707	12	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2707	13	,	,	,
18637	2707	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2707	15	from	from	IN
18637	2707	16	the	the	DT
18637	2707	17	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	2707	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	2707	19	been	be	VBN
18637	2707	20	content	content	JJ
18637	2707	21	to	to	TO
18637	2707	22	leave	leave	VB
18637	2707	23	the	the	DT
18637	2707	24	matter	matter	NN
18637	2707	25	for	for	IN
18637	2707	26	the	the	DT
18637	2707	27	most	most	JJS
18637	2707	28	part	part	NN
18637	2707	29	,	,	,
18637	2707	30	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	2707	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2707	32	vast	vast	JJ
18637	2707	33	importance	importance	NN
18637	2707	34	,	,	,
18637	2707	35	to	to	IN
18637	2707	36	the	the	DT
18637	2707	37	States	States	NNPS
18637	2707	38	and	and	CC
18637	2707	39	has	have	VBZ
18637	2707	40	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	2707	41	acquiesced	acquiesce	VBN
18637	2707	42	in	in	IN
18637	2707	43	the	the	DT
18637	2707	44	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	2707	45	of	of	IN
18637	2707	46	State	State	NNP
18637	2707	47	laws	law	NNS
18637	2707	48	.	.	.
18637	2708	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2708	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2708	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2708	4	Such	such	JJ
18637	2708	5	laws	law	NNS
18637	2708	6	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	2708	7	operate	operate	VBP
18637	2708	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	2708	9	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2708	10	and	and	CC
18637	2708	11	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2708	12	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2708	13	.	.	.
18637	2709	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2709	2	could	could	MD
18637	2709	3	not	not	RB
18637	2709	4	be	be	VB
18637	2709	5	effective	effective	JJ
18637	2709	6	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2709	7	.	.	.
18637	2710	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2710	2	can	can	MD
18637	2710	3	not	not	RB
18637	2710	4	,	,	,
18637	2710	5	of	of	IN
18637	2710	6	course	course	NN
18637	2710	7	,	,	,
18637	2710	8	be	be	VB
18637	2710	9	made	make	VBN
18637	2710	10	the	the	DT
18637	2710	11	cover	cover	NN
18637	2710	12	for	for	IN
18637	2710	13	discriminations	discrimination	NNS
18637	2710	14	and	and	CC
18637	2710	15	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	2710	16	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	2710	17	having	have	VBG
18637	2710	18	no	no	DT
18637	2710	19	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2710	20	relation	relation	NN
18637	2710	21	to	to	IN
18637	2710	22	health	health	NN
18637	2710	23	*	*	NFP
18637	2710	24	*	*	NFP
18637	2710	25	*	*	NFP
18637	2710	26	;	;	:
18637	2710	27	but	but	CC
18637	2710	28	the	the	DT
18637	2710	29	power	power	NN
18637	2710	30	of	of	IN
18637	2710	31	the	the	DT
18637	2710	32	State	State	NNP
18637	2710	33	to	to	TO
18637	2710	34	take	take	VB
18637	2710	35	steps	step	NNS
18637	2710	36	to	to	TO
18637	2710	37	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2710	38	the	the	DT
18637	2710	39	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	2710	40	or	or	CC
18637	2710	41	spread	spread	NN
18637	2710	42	of	of	IN
18637	2710	43	disease	disease	NN
18637	2710	44	,	,	,
18637	2710	45	although	although	IN
18637	2710	46	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2710	47	and	and	CC
18637	2710	48	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2710	49	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2710	50	are	be	VBP
18637	2710	51	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2710	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2710	53	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2710	54	to	to	IN
18637	2710	55	the	the	DT
18637	2710	56	paramount	paramount	NNP
18637	2710	57	authority	authority	NN
18637	2710	58	of	of	IN
18637	2710	59	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2710	60	if	if	IN
18637	2710	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2710	62	decides	decide	VBZ
18637	2710	63	to	to	TO
18637	2710	64	assume	assume	VB
18637	2710	65	control	control	NN
18637	2710	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2710	67	,	,	,
18637	2710	68	is	be	VBZ
18637	2710	69	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	2710	70	question	question	NN
18637	2710	71	.	.	.
18637	2711	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2711	2	899	899	CD
18637	2711	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2711	4	*	*	NFP
18637	2711	5	*	*	NFP
18637	2711	6	*	*	NFP
18637	2711	7	State	state	NN
18637	2711	8	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	2711	9	laws	law	NNS
18637	2711	10	and	and	CC
18637	2711	11	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	2711	12	designed	design	VBN
18637	2711	13	to	to	TO
18637	2711	14	safeguard	safeguard	VB
18637	2711	15	the	the	DT
18637	2711	16	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	2711	17	of	of	IN
18637	2711	18	a	a	DT
18637	2711	19	State	state	NN
18637	2711	20	from	from	IN
18637	2711	21	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	2711	22	and	and	CC
18637	2711	23	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	2711	24	are	be	VBP
18637	2711	25	valid	valid	JJ
18637	2711	26	when	when	WRB
18637	2711	27	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2711	28	in	in	IN
18637	2711	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2711	30	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	2711	31	and	and	CC
18637	2711	32	not	not	RB
18637	2711	33	in	in	IN
18637	2711	34	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	2711	35	with	with	IN
18637	2711	36	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	2711	37	rules	rule	NNS
18637	2711	38	,	,	,
18637	2711	39	although	although	IN
18637	2711	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2711	41	may	may	MD
18637	2711	42	affect	affect	VB
18637	2711	43	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2711	44	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2711	45	in	in	IN
18637	2711	46	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2711	47	relation	relation	NN
18637	2711	48	to	to	IN
18637	2711	49	articles	article	NNS
18637	2711	50	prepared	prepare	VBN
18637	2711	51	for	for	IN
18637	2711	52	export	export	NN
18637	2711	53	or	or	CC
18637	2711	54	by	by	IN
18637	2711	55	including	include	VBG
18637	2711	56	incidentally	incidentally	RB
18637	2711	57	those	those	DT
18637	2711	58	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2711	59	into	into	IN
18637	2711	60	the	the	DT
18637	2711	61	State	state	NN
18637	2711	62	and	and	CC
18637	2711	63	held	hold	VBN
18637	2711	64	for	for	IN
18637	2711	65	sale	sale	NN
18637	2711	66	in	in	IN
18637	2711	67	the	the	DT
18637	2711	68	original	original	JJ
18637	2711	69	imported	import	VBN
18637	2711	70	packages	package	NNS
18637	2711	71	.	.	.
18637	2712	1	"	"	``
18637	2712	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2712	3	900	900	CD
18637	2712	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2712	5	QUARANTINE	QUARANTINE	NNP
18637	2712	6	LAWS	LAWS	NNP
18637	2712	7	In	in	IN
18637	2712	8	two	two	CD
18637	2712	9	earlier	early	JJR
18637	2712	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	2712	11	a	a	DT
18637	2712	12	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	2712	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	2712	14	which	which	WDT
18637	2712	15	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	2712	16	the	the	DT
18637	2712	17	driving	driving	NN
18637	2712	18	of	of	IN
18637	2712	19	all	all	DT
18637	2712	20	Texan	Texan	NNP
18637	2712	21	,	,	,
18637	2712	22	Mexican	Mexican	NNP
18637	2712	23	,	,	,
18637	2712	24	and	and	CC
18637	2712	25	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	2712	26	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	2712	27	into	into	IN
18637	2712	28	the	the	DT
18637	2712	29	state	state	NN
18637	2712	30	during	during	IN
18637	2712	31	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2712	32	seasons	season	NNS
18637	2712	33	of	of	IN
18637	2712	34	the	the	DT
18637	2712	35	year	year	NN
18637	2712	36	was	be	VBD
18637	2712	37	held	hold	VBN
18637	2712	38	void;[901	void;[901	NNPS
18637	2712	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2712	40	while	while	IN
18637	2712	41	a	a	DT
18637	2712	42	statute	statute	NN
18637	2712	43	making	make	VBG
18637	2712	44	anybody	anybody	NN
18637	2712	45	in	in	IN
18637	2712	46	the	the	DT
18637	2712	47	State	State	NNP
18637	2712	48	who	who	WP
18637	2712	49	had	have	VBD
18637	2712	50	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	2712	51	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	2712	52	which	which	WDT
18637	2712	53	had	have	VBD
18637	2712	54	not	not	RB
18637	2712	55	wintered	winter	VBN
18637	2712	56	north	north	RB
18637	2712	57	of	of	IN
18637	2712	58	a	a	DT
18637	2712	59	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2712	60	line	line	NN
18637	2712	61	liable	liable	JJ
18637	2712	62	for	for	IN
18637	2712	63	damage	damage	NN
18637	2712	64	through	through	IN
18637	2712	65	the	the	DT
18637	2712	66	communication	communication	NN
18637	2712	67	of	of	IN
18637	2712	68	disease	disease	NN
18637	2712	69	from	from	IN
18637	2712	70	these	these	DT
18637	2712	71	to	to	IN
18637	2712	72	other	other	JJ
18637	2712	73	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	2712	74	was	be	VBD
18637	2712	75	sustained;[902	sustained;[902	CD
18637	2712	76	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2712	77	as	as	IN
18637	2712	78	were	be	VBD
18637	2712	79	also	also	RB
18637	2712	80	the	the	DT
18637	2712	81	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2712	82	of	of	IN
18637	2712	83	a	a	DT
18637	2712	84	sanitary	sanitary	JJ
18637	2712	85	commission	commission	NN
18637	2712	86	which	which	WDT
18637	2712	87	excluded	exclude	VBD
18637	2712	88	all	all	DT
18637	2712	89	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	2712	90	,	,	,
18637	2712	91	horses	horse	NNS
18637	2712	92	,	,	,
18637	2712	93	and	and	CC
18637	2712	94	mules	mule	NNS
18637	2712	95	,	,	,
18637	2712	96	from	from	IN
18637	2712	97	the	the	DT
18637	2712	98	State	State	NNP
18637	2712	99	at	at	IN
18637	2712	100	a	a	DT
18637	2712	101	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2712	102	period	period	NN
18637	2712	103	when	when	WRB
18637	2712	104	anthrax	anthrax	NN
18637	2712	105	was	be	VBD
18637	2712	106	prevalent	prevalent	JJ
18637	2712	107	.	.	.
18637	2713	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2713	2	903	903	CD
18637	2713	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2713	4	Reviewing	review	VBG
18637	2713	5	previous	previous	JJ
18637	2713	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	2713	7	in	in	IN
18637	2713	8	the	the	DT
18637	2713	9	one	one	NN
18637	2713	10	last	last	JJ
18637	2713	11	cited	cite	VBD
18637	2713	12	,	,	,
18637	2713	13	the	the	DT
18637	2713	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2713	15	declared	declare	VBD
18637	2713	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2713	17	controlling	control	VBG
18637	2713	18	principle	principle	NN
18637	2713	19	to	to	TO
18637	2713	20	be	be	VB
18637	2713	21	simply	simply	RB
18637	2713	22	whether	whether	IN
18637	2713	23	the	the	DT
18637	2713	24	police	police	NN
18637	2713	25	power	power	NN
18637	2713	26	of	of	IN
18637	2713	27	the	the	DT
18637	2713	28	State	State	NNP
18637	2713	29	had	have	VBD
18637	2713	30	been	be	VBN
18637	2713	31	exerted	exert	VBN
18637	2713	32	to	to	TO
18637	2713	33	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	2713	34	"	"	``
18637	2713	35	_	_	NNP
18637	2713	36	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	2713	37	what	what	WP
18637	2713	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	2713	39	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2713	40	for	for	IN
18637	2713	41	any	any	DT
18637	2713	42	proper	proper	JJ
18637	2713	43	quarantine	quarantine	NN
18637	2713	44	_	_	NNP
18637	2713	45	,	,	,
18637	2713	46	"	"	''
18637	2713	47	a	a	DT
18637	2713	48	question	question	NN
18637	2713	49	predominantly	predominantly	RB
18637	2713	50	of	of	IN
18637	2713	51	fact	fact	NN
18637	2713	52	,	,	,
18637	2713	53	and	and	CC
18637	2713	54	one	one	NN
18637	2713	55	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	2713	56	to	to	TO
18637	2713	57	be	be	VB
18637	2713	58	determined	determine	VBN
18637	2713	59	for	for	IN
18637	2713	60	each	each	DT
18637	2713	61	case	case	NN
18637	2713	62	with	with	IN
18637	2713	63	only	only	JJ
18637	2713	64	general	general	JJ
18637	2713	65	guidance	guidance	NN
18637	2713	66	from	from	IN
18637	2713	67	earlier	early	JJR
18637	2713	68	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	2713	69	.	.	.
18637	2714	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2714	2	904	904	CD
18637	2714	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2714	4	More	more	RBR
18637	2714	5	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2714	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	2714	7	conform	conform	VBP
18637	2714	8	to	to	IN
18637	2714	9	the	the	DT
18637	2714	10	same	same	JJ
18637	2714	11	pattern	pattern	NN
18637	2714	12	.	.	.
18637	2715	1	Among	among	IN
18637	2715	2	measures	measure	NNS
18637	2715	3	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2715	4	are	be	VBP
18637	2715	5	the	the	DT
18637	2715	6	following	follow	VBG
18637	2715	7	:	:	:
18637	2715	8	an	an	DT
18637	2715	9	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	2715	10	statute	statute	NN
18637	2715	11	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	2715	12	the	the	DT
18637	2715	13	sale	sale	NN
18637	2715	14	in	in	IN
18637	2715	15	that	that	DT
18637	2715	16	State	State	NNP
18637	2715	17	of	of	IN
18637	2715	18	condensed	condense	VBN
18637	2715	19	milk	milk	NN
18637	2715	20	unless	unless	IN
18637	2715	21	made	make	VBN
18637	2715	22	from	from	IN
18637	2715	23	unadulterated	unadulterated	JJ
18637	2715	24	milk;[905	milk;[905	NNS
18637	2715	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2715	26	a	a	DT
18637	2715	27	New	New	NNP
18637	2715	28	York	York	NNP
18637	2715	29	statute	statute	NN
18637	2715	30	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	2715	31	the	the	DT
18637	2715	32	sale	sale	NN
18637	2715	33	with	with	IN
18637	2715	34	intent	intent	NN
18637	2715	35	to	to	TO
18637	2715	36	defraud	defraud	VB
18637	2715	37	of	of	IN
18637	2715	38	preparations	preparation	NNS
18637	2715	39	falsely	falsely	RB
18637	2715	40	represented	represent	VBN
18637	2715	41	to	to	TO
18637	2715	42	be	be	VB
18637	2715	43	Kosher;[906	kosher;[906	IN
18637	2715	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2715	45	a	a	DT
18637	2715	46	New	New	NNP
18637	2715	47	York	York	NNP
18637	2715	48	statute	statute	NN
18637	2715	49	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2715	50	that	that	IN
18637	2715	51	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	2715	52	shall	shall	MD
18637	2715	53	not	not	RB
18637	2715	54	be	be	VB
18637	2715	55	imported	import	VBN
18637	2715	56	for	for	IN
18637	2715	57	dairy	dairy	NN
18637	2715	58	or	or	CC
18637	2715	59	breeding	breeding	NN
18637	2715	60	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	2715	61	unless	unless	IN
18637	2715	62	accompanied	accompany	VBN
18637	2715	63	by	by	IN
18637	2715	64	the	the	DT
18637	2715	65	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	2715	66	of	of	IN
18637	2715	67	a	a	DT
18637	2715	68	proper	proper	JJ
18637	2715	69	sanitary	sanitary	JJ
18637	2715	70	official	official	NN
18637	2715	71	in	in	IN
18637	2715	72	the	the	DT
18637	2715	73	State	State	NNP
18637	2715	74	of	of	IN
18637	2715	75	origin	origin	NN
18637	2715	76	,	,	,
18637	2715	77	in	in	IN
18637	2715	78	order	order	NN
18637	2715	79	to	to	TO
18637	2715	80	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2715	81	the	the	DT
18637	2715	82	spread	spread	NN
18637	2715	83	of	of	IN
18637	2715	84	an	an	DT
18637	2715	85	infectious	infectious	JJ
18637	2715	86	disease;[907	disease;[907	NNS
18637	2715	87	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2715	88	an	an	DT
18637	2715	89	order	order	NN
18637	2715	90	of	of	IN
18637	2715	91	a	a	DT
18637	2715	92	State	State	NNP
18637	2715	93	Department	Department	NNP
18637	2715	94	of	of	IN
18637	2715	95	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	2715	96	,	,	,
18637	2715	97	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	2715	98	to	to	IN
18637	2715	99	a	a	DT
18637	2715	100	State	State	NNP
18637	2715	101	law	law	NN
18637	2715	102	,	,	,
18637	2715	103	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	2715	104	the	the	DT
18637	2715	105	standards	standard	NNS
18637	2715	106	of	of	IN
18637	2715	107	containers	container	NNS
18637	2715	108	in	in	IN
18637	2715	109	which	which	WDT
18637	2715	110	agricultural	agricultural	JJ
18637	2715	111	products	product	NNS
18637	2715	112	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2715	113	berries	berry	NNS
18637	2715	114	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2715	115	may	may	MD
18637	2715	116	be	be	VB
18637	2715	117	marketed	market	VBN
18637	2715	118	within	within	IN
18637	2715	119	the	the	DT
18637	2715	120	State;[908	state;[908	NN
18637	2715	121	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2715	122	a	a	DT
18637	2715	123	State	State	NNP
18637	2715	124	statute	statute	NN
18637	2715	125	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	2715	126	the	the	DT
18637	2715	127	processing	processing	NN
18637	2715	128	of	of	IN
18637	2715	129	fish	fish	NN
18637	2715	130	found	find	VBN
18637	2715	131	within	within	IN
18637	2715	132	the	the	DT
18637	2715	133	waters	water	NNS
18637	2715	134	of	of	IN
18637	2715	135	the	the	DT
18637	2715	136	State	State	NNP
18637	2715	137	with	with	IN
18637	2715	138	the	the	DT
18637	2715	139	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2715	140	of	of	IN
18637	2715	141	conserving	conserve	VBG
18637	2715	142	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2715	143	for	for	IN
18637	2715	144	food	food	NN
18637	2715	145	,	,	,
18637	2715	146	even	even	RB
18637	2715	147	though	though	IN
18637	2715	148	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2715	149	also	also	RB
18637	2715	150	operates	operate	VBZ
18637	2715	151	upon	upon	IN
18637	2715	152	fish	fish	NN
18637	2715	153	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2715	154	into	into	IN
18637	2715	155	the	the	DT
18637	2715	156	State	State	NNP
18637	2715	157	from	from	IN
18637	2715	158	without;[909	without;[909	LS
18637	2715	159	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2715	160	the	the	DT
18637	2715	161	price	price	NN
18637	2715	162	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	2715	163	and	and	CC
18637	2715	164	licensing	license	VBG
18637	2715	165	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	2715	166	of	of	IN
18637	2715	167	a	a	DT
18637	2715	168	State	State	NNP
18637	2715	169	Milk	Milk	NNP
18637	2715	170	and	and	CC
18637	2715	171	Cream	Cream	NNP
18637	2715	172	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2715	173	,	,	,
18637	2715	174	not	not	RB
18637	2715	175	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	2715	176	to	to	IN
18637	2715	177	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	2715	178	in	in	IN
18637	2715	179	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2715	180	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2715	181	,	,	,
18637	2715	182	by	by	IN
18637	2715	183	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	2715	184	of	of	IN
18637	2715	185	the	the	DT
18637	2715	186	act;[910	act;[910	NNP
18637	2715	187	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2715	188	a	a	DT
18637	2715	189	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	2715	190	statute	statute	NN
18637	2715	191	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2715	192	the	the	DT
18637	2715	193	registration	registration	NN
18637	2715	194	with	with	IN
18637	2715	195	the	the	DT
18637	2715	196	State	State	NNP
18637	2715	197	Health	Health	NNP
18637	2715	198	Department	Department	NNP
18637	2715	199	of	of	IN
18637	2715	200	cosmetic	cosmetic	JJ
18637	2715	201	preparations	preparation	NNS
18637	2715	202	for	for	IN
18637	2715	203	the	the	DT
18637	2715	204	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2715	205	of	of	IN
18637	2715	206	ascertaining	ascertaining	NN
18637	2715	207	whether	whether	IN
18637	2715	208	the	the	DT
18637	2715	209	products	product	NNS
18637	2715	210	are	be	VBP
18637	2715	211	harmless;[911	harmless;[911	ADD
18637	2715	212	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2715	213	an	an	DT
18637	2715	214	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	2715	215	Animals	Animals	NNPS
18637	2715	216	Disposal	Disposal	NNP
18637	2715	217	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2715	218	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2715	219	that	that	IN
18637	2715	220	animal	animal	NN
18637	2715	221	carcasses	carcass	NNS
18637	2715	222	,	,	,
18637	2715	223	not	not	RB
18637	2715	224	promptly	promptly	RB
18637	2715	225	disposed	dispose	VBN
18637	2715	226	of	of	IN
18637	2715	227	by	by	IN
18637	2715	228	the	the	DT
18637	2715	229	owner	owner	NN
18637	2715	230	,	,	,
18637	2715	231	be	be	VB
18637	2715	232	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	2715	233	to	to	IN
18637	2715	234	the	the	DT
18637	2715	235	representative	representative	NN
18637	2715	236	of	of	IN
18637	2715	237	a	a	DT
18637	2715	238	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	2715	239	plant	plant	NN
18637	2715	240	licensed	license	VBN
18637	2715	241	by	by	IN
18637	2715	242	the	the	DT
18637	2715	243	State	State	NNP
18637	2715	244	,	,	,
18637	2715	245	and	and	CC
18637	2715	246	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	2715	247	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2715	248	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2715	249	on	on	IN
18637	2715	250	the	the	DT
18637	2715	251	public	public	JJ
18637	2715	252	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2715	253	for	for	IN
18637	2715	254	any	any	DT
18637	2715	255	other	other	JJ
18637	2715	256	purpose;[912	purpose;[912	.
18637	2715	257	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2715	258	a	a	DT
18637	2715	259	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2715	260	statute	statute	NN
18637	2715	261	providing	provide	VBG
18637	2715	262	for	for	IN
18637	2715	263	the	the	DT
18637	2715	264	licensing	licensing	NN
18637	2715	265	and	and	CC
18637	2715	266	bonding	bonding	NN
18637	2715	267	of	of	IN
18637	2715	268	all	all	DT
18637	2715	269	milk	milk	NN
18637	2715	270	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	2715	271	and	and	CC
18637	2715	272	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	2715	273	a	a	DT
18637	2715	274	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	2715	275	price	price	NN
18637	2715	276	to	to	TO
18637	2715	277	be	be	VB
18637	2715	278	paid	pay	VBN
18637	2715	279	producers	producer	NNS
18637	2715	280	,	,	,
18637	2715	281	as	as	IN
18637	2715	282	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2715	283	to	to	IN
18637	2715	284	a	a	DT
18637	2715	285	dealer	dealer	NN
18637	2715	286	purchasing	purchase	VBG
18637	2715	287	milk	milk	NN
18637	2715	288	within	within	IN
18637	2715	289	the	the	DT
18637	2715	290	State	State	NNP
18637	2715	291	for	for	IN
18637	2715	292	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2715	293	to	to	TO
18637	2715	294	points	point	NNS
18637	2715	295	outside	outside	IN
18637	2715	296	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2715	297	.	.	.
18637	2716	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2716	2	913	913	CD
18637	2716	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2716	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2716	5	INSPECTION	inspection	NN
18637	2716	6	LAWS	LAWS	NNP
18637	2716	7	The	the	DT
18637	2716	8	application	application	NN
18637	2716	9	of	of	IN
18637	2716	10	State	state	NN
18637	2716	11	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	2716	12	laws	law	NNS
18637	2716	13	to	to	IN
18637	2716	14	imports	import	NNS
18637	2716	15	from	from	IN
18637	2716	16	outside	outside	IN
18637	2716	17	the	the	DT
18637	2716	18	State	state	NN
18637	2716	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	2716	20	been	be	VBN
18637	2716	21	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2716	22	as	as	IN
18637	2716	23	warranted	warrant	VBN
18637	2716	24	by	by	IN
18637	2716	25	local	local	JJ
18637	2716	26	interests	interest	NNS
18637	2716	27	and	and	CC
18637	2716	28	as	as	IN
18637	2716	29	not	not	RB
18637	2716	30	discriminating	discriminate	VBG
18637	2716	31	against	against	IN
18637	2716	32	out	out	RB
18637	2716	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	2716	34	of	of	IN
18637	2716	35	-	-	HYPH
18637	2716	36	state	state	NN
18637	2716	37	products	product	NNS
18637	2716	38	,	,	,
18637	2716	39	in	in	IN
18637	2716	40	the	the	DT
18637	2716	41	following	follow	VBG
18637	2716	42	instances	instance	NNS
18637	2716	43	:	:	:
18637	2716	44	A	a	DT
18637	2716	45	North	North	NNP
18637	2716	46	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	2716	47	statute	statute	NN
18637	2716	48	providing	provide	VBG
18637	2716	49	that	that	IN
18637	2716	50	"	"	``
18637	2716	51	every	every	DT
18637	2716	52	bag	bag	NN
18637	2716	53	,	,	,
18637	2716	54	barrel	barrel	NN
18637	2716	55	,	,	,
18637	2716	56	or	or	CC
18637	2716	57	other	other	JJ
18637	2716	58	package	package	NN
18637	2716	59	"	"	''
18637	2716	60	of	of	IN
18637	2716	61	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	2716	62	fertilizer	fertilizer	NN
18637	2716	63	offered	offer	VBN
18637	2716	64	for	for	IN
18637	2716	65	sale	sale	NN
18637	2716	66	in	in	IN
18637	2716	67	the	the	DT
18637	2716	68	State	State	NNP
18637	2716	69	should	should	MD
18637	2716	70	bear	bear	VB
18637	2716	71	a	a	DT
18637	2716	72	label	label	NN
18637	2716	73	truly	truly	RB
18637	2716	74	describing	describe	VBG
18637	2716	75	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2716	76	chemical	chemical	JJ
18637	2716	77	composition	composition	NN
18637	2716	78	,	,	,
18637	2716	79	which	which	WDT
18637	2716	80	must	must	MD
18637	2716	81	comply	comply	VB
18637	2716	82	with	with	IN
18637	2716	83	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2716	84	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	2716	85	,	,	,
18637	2716	86	and	and	CC
18637	2716	87	charging	charge	VBG
18637	2716	88	25	25	CD
18637	2716	89	cents	cent	NNS
18637	2716	90	per	per	IN
18637	2716	91	ton	ton	NN
18637	2716	92	to	to	TO
18637	2716	93	meet	meet	VB
18637	2716	94	the	the	DT
18637	2716	95	cost	cost	NN
18637	2716	96	of	of	IN
18637	2716	97	inspection;[914	inspection;[914	NNPS
18637	2716	98	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2716	99	an	an	DT
18637	2716	100	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	2716	101	statute	statute	NN
18637	2716	102	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	2716	103	the	the	DT
18637	2716	104	sale	sale	NN
18637	2716	105	in	in	IN
18637	2716	106	the	the	DT
18637	2716	107	original	original	JJ
18637	2716	108	package	package	NN
18637	2716	109	of	of	IN
18637	2716	110	concentrated	concentrated	JJ
18637	2716	111	feeding	feeding	NN
18637	2716	112	stuffs	stuff	NNS
18637	2716	113	prior	prior	RB
18637	2716	114	to	to	IN
18637	2716	115	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	2716	116	and	and	CC
18637	2716	117	analysis	analysis	NN
18637	2716	118	for	for	IN
18637	2716	119	the	the	DT
18637	2716	120	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2716	121	of	of	IN
18637	2716	122	ascertaining	ascertain	VBG
18637	2716	123	whether	whether	IN
18637	2716	124	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2716	125	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	2716	126	standards	standard	NNS
18637	2716	127	as	as	IN
18637	2716	128	to	to	IN
18637	2716	129	composition	composition	NN
18637	2716	130	had	have	VBD
18637	2716	131	been	be	VBN
18637	2716	132	met;[915	met;[915	NNP
18637	2716	133	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2716	134	a	a	DT
18637	2716	135	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	2716	136	statute	statute	NN
18637	2716	137	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2716	138	as	as	IN
18637	2716	139	a	a	DT
18637	2716	140	precondition	precondition	NN
18637	2716	141	of	of	IN
18637	2716	142	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2716	143	being	be	VBG
18637	2716	144	offered	offer	VBN
18637	2716	145	for	for	IN
18637	2716	146	sale	sale	NN
18637	2716	147	in	in	IN
18637	2716	148	the	the	DT
18637	2716	149	State	State	NNP
18637	2716	150	,	,	,
18637	2716	151	the	the	DT
18637	2716	152	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	2716	153	of	of	IN
18637	2716	154	illuminating	illuminate	VBG
18637	2716	155	oil	oil	NN
18637	2716	156	and	and	CC
18637	2716	157	gasoline;[916	gasoline;[916	ADD
18637	2716	158	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2716	159	a	a	DT
18637	2716	160	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	2716	161	statute	statute	NN
18637	2716	162	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	2716	163	any	any	DT
18637	2716	164	moving	move	VBG
18637	2716	165	picture	picture	NN
18637	2716	166	film	film	NN
18637	2716	167	or	or	CC
18637	2716	168	reel	reel	VBP
18637	2716	169	to	to	TO
18637	2716	170	be	be	VB
18637	2716	171	exhibited	exhibit	VBN
18637	2716	172	in	in	IN
18637	2716	173	the	the	DT
18637	2716	174	State	State	NNP
18637	2716	175	unless	unless	IN
18637	2716	176	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2716	177	had	have	VBD
18637	2716	178	been	be	VBN
18637	2716	179	examined	examine	VBN
18637	2716	180	by	by	IN
18637	2716	181	the	the	DT
18637	2716	182	State	State	NNP
18637	2716	183	Superintendent	Superintendent	NNP
18637	2716	184	of	of	IN
18637	2716	185	Instruction	Instruction	NNP
18637	2716	186	and	and	CC
18637	2716	187	certified	certify	VBN
18637	2716	188	by	by	IN
18637	2716	189	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2716	190	as	as	IN
18637	2716	191	moral	moral	JJ
18637	2716	192	and	and	CC
18637	2716	193	instructive	instructive	JJ
18637	2716	194	and	and	CC
18637	2716	195	not	not	RB
18637	2716	196	tending	tend	VBG
18637	2716	197	to	to	TO
18637	2716	198	debase	debase	VB
18637	2716	199	or	or	CC
18637	2716	200	corrupt	corrupt	VB
18637	2716	201	the	the	DT
18637	2716	202	morals	moral	NNS
18637	2716	203	.	.	.
18637	2717	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2717	2	917	917	CD
18637	2717	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2717	4	A	a	DT
18637	2717	5	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	2717	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	2717	7	,	,	,
18637	2717	8	on	on	IN
18637	2717	9	the	the	DT
18637	2717	10	other	other	JJ
18637	2717	11	hand	hand	NN
18637	2717	12	,	,	,
18637	2717	13	which	which	WDT
18637	2717	14	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	2717	15	the	the	DT
18637	2717	16	sale	sale	NN
18637	2717	17	in	in	IN
18637	2717	18	any	any	DT
18637	2717	19	city	city	NN
18637	2717	20	of	of	IN
18637	2717	21	the	the	DT
18637	2717	22	State	State	NNP
18637	2717	23	of	of	IN
18637	2717	24	any	any	DT
18637	2717	25	beef	beef	NN
18637	2717	26	,	,	,
18637	2717	27	mutton	mutton	NN
18637	2717	28	,	,	,
18637	2717	29	lamb	lamb	NN
18637	2717	30	,	,	,
18637	2717	31	or	or	CC
18637	2717	32	pork	pork	NN
18637	2717	33	which	which	WDT
18637	2717	34	,	,	,
18637	2717	35	had	have	VBD
18637	2717	36	not	not	RB
18637	2717	37	been	be	VBN
18637	2717	38	inspected	inspect	VBN
18637	2717	39	on	on	IN
18637	2717	40	the	the	DT
18637	2717	41	hoof	hoof	NN
18637	2717	42	by	by	IN
18637	2717	43	local	local	JJ
18637	2717	44	inspectors	inspector	NNS
18637	2717	45	within	within	IN
18637	2717	46	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	2717	47	-	-	HYPH
18637	2717	48	four	four	CD
18637	2717	49	hours	hour	NNS
18637	2717	50	of	of	IN
18637	2717	51	slaughter	slaughter	NN
18637	2717	52	,	,	,
18637	2717	53	was	be	VBD
18637	2717	54	held	hold	VBN
18637	2717	55	void	void	JJ
18637	2717	56	.	.	.
18637	2718	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2718	2	918	918	CD
18637	2718	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2718	4	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2718	5	"	"	``
18637	2718	6	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2718	7	operation	operation	NN
18637	2718	8	,	,	,
18637	2718	9	"	"	''
18637	2718	10	said	say	VBD
18637	2718	11	the	the	DT
18637	2718	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2718	13	,	,	,
18637	2718	14	was	be	VBD
18637	2718	15	to	to	TO
18637	2718	16	ban	ban	VB
18637	2718	17	from	from	IN
18637	2718	18	the	the	DT
18637	2718	19	State	State	NNP
18637	2718	20	wholesome	wholesome	JJ
18637	2718	21	and	and	CC
18637	2718	22	properly	properly	RB
18637	2718	23	inspected	inspect	VBN
18637	2718	24	meat	meat	NN
18637	2718	25	from	from	IN
18637	2718	26	other	other	JJ
18637	2718	27	States	States	NNPS
18637	2718	28	.	.	.
18637	2719	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2719	2	919	919	CD
18637	2719	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2719	4	Also	also	RB
18637	2719	5	a	a	DT
18637	2719	6	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	2719	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	2719	8	which	which	WDT
18637	2719	9	required	require	VBD
18637	2719	10	the	the	DT
18637	2719	11	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	2719	12	and	and	CC
18637	2719	13	labelling	labelling	NN
18637	2719	14	of	of	IN
18637	2719	15	all	all	DT
18637	2719	16	flour	flour	NN
18637	2719	17	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2719	18	into	into	IN
18637	2719	19	the	the	DT
18637	2719	20	State	State	NNP
18637	2719	21	for	for	IN
18637	2719	22	sale	sale	NN
18637	2719	23	was	be	VBD
18637	2719	24	disallowed	disallow	VBN
18637	2719	25	because	because	IN
18637	2719	26	flour	flour	NN
18637	2719	27	produced	produce	VBN
18637	2719	28	in	in	IN
18637	2719	29	the	the	DT
18637	2719	30	State	State	NNP
18637	2719	31	was	be	VBD
18637	2719	32	not	not	RB
18637	2719	33	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2719	34	to	to	IN
18637	2719	35	inspection;[920	inspection;[920	NNPS
18637	2719	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2719	37	likewise	likewise	RB
18637	2719	38	a	a	DT
18637	2719	39	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	2719	40	statute	statute	NN
18637	2719	41	providing	provide	VBG
18637	2719	42	for	for	IN
18637	2719	43	the	the	DT
18637	2719	44	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	2719	45	of	of	IN
18637	2719	46	all	all	DT
18637	2719	47	cement	cement	NN
18637	2719	48	imported	import	VBN
18637	2719	49	into	into	IN
18637	2719	50	the	the	DT
18637	2719	51	State	State	NNP
18637	2719	52	and	and	CC
18637	2719	53	enacting	enact	VBG
18637	2719	54	a	a	DT
18637	2719	55	fee	fee	NN
18637	2719	56	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	2719	57	,	,	,
18637	2719	58	but	but	CC
18637	2719	59	making	make	VBG
18637	2719	60	no	no	DT
18637	2719	61	provision	provision	NN
18637	2719	62	for	for	IN
18637	2719	63	the	the	DT
18637	2719	64	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	2719	65	of	of	IN
18637	2719	66	the	the	DT
18637	2719	67	local	local	JJ
18637	2719	68	product	product	NN
18637	2719	69	,	,	,
18637	2719	70	met	meet	VBD
18637	2719	71	a	a	DT
18637	2719	72	like	like	JJ
18637	2719	73	fate;[921	fate;[921	NNS
18637	2719	74	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2719	75	as	as	IN
18637	2719	76	did	do	VBD
18637	2719	77	also	also	RB
18637	2719	78	a	a	DT
18637	2719	79	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	2719	80	,	,	,
18637	2719	81	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	2719	82	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	2719	83	which	which	WDT
18637	2719	84	sought	seek	VBD
18637	2719	85	to	to	TO
18637	2719	86	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	2719	87	a	a	DT
18637	2719	88	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2719	89	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2719	90	from	from	IN
18637	2719	91	selling	sell	VBG
18637	2719	92	milk	milk	NN
18637	2719	93	in	in	IN
18637	2719	94	that	that	DT
18637	2719	95	city	city	NN
18637	2719	96	solely	solely	RB
18637	2719	97	because	because	IN
18637	2719	98	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2719	99	pasteurization	pasteurization	NN
18637	2719	100	plants	plant	NNS
18637	2719	101	were	be	VBD
18637	2719	102	more	more	JJR
18637	2719	103	than	than	IN
18637	2719	104	five	five	CD
18637	2719	105	miles	mile	NNS
18637	2719	106	away	away	RB
18637	2719	107	.	.	.
18637	2720	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2720	2	922	922	CD
18637	2720	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2720	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2720	5	PROHIBITION	prohibition	NN
18637	2720	6	LAWS	LAWS	NNP
18637	2720	7	;	;	:
18637	2720	8	THE	the	DT
18637	2720	9	ORIGINAL	original	JJ
18637	2720	10	PACKAGE	package	NN
18637	2720	11	DOCTRINE	doctrine	NN
18637	2720	12	The	the	DT
18637	2720	13	original	original	JJ
18637	2720	14	package	package	NN
18637	2720	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2720	16	made	make	VBD
18637	2720	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2720	18	debut	debut	NN
18637	2720	19	in	in	IN
18637	2720	20	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	2720	21	_	_	NNP
18637	2720	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	2720	23	_	_	NNP
18637	2720	24	Maryland,[923	Maryland,[923	NNP
18637	2720	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2720	26	where	where	WRB
18637	2720	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2720	28	was	be	VBD
18637	2720	29	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2720	30	to	to	TO
18637	2720	31	remove	remove	VB
18637	2720	32	imports	import	NNS
18637	2720	33	from	from	IN
18637	2720	34	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	2720	35	which	which	WDT
18637	2720	36	were	be	VBD
18637	2720	37	still	still	RB
18637	2720	38	in	in	IN
18637	2720	39	the	the	DT
18637	2720	40	hands	hand	NNS
18637	2720	41	of	of	IN
18637	2720	42	the	the	DT
18637	2720	43	importer	importer	NN
18637	2720	44	in	in	IN
18637	2720	45	the	the	DT
18637	2720	46	original	original	JJ
18637	2720	47	package	package	NN
18637	2720	48	,	,	,
18637	2720	49	out	out	IN
18637	2720	50	of	of	IN
18637	2720	51	the	the	DT
18637	2720	52	reach	reach	NN
18637	2720	53	of	of	IN
18637	2720	54	the	the	DT
18637	2720	55	State	State	NNP
18637	2720	56	's	's	POS
18637	2720	57	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2720	58	power	power	NN
18637	2720	59	.	.	.
18637	2721	1	This	this	DT
18637	2721	2	rule	rule	NN
18637	2721	3	the	the	DT
18637	2721	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2721	5	,	,	,
18637	2721	6	overriding	override	VBG
18637	2721	7	a	a	DT
18637	2721	8	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	2721	9	in	in	IN
18637	2721	10	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2721	11	's	's	POS
18637	2721	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2721	13	in	in	IN
18637	2721	14	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	2721	15	_	_	NNP
18637	2721	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	2721	17	_	_	NNP
18637	2721	18	Maryland,[924	Maryland,[924	NNP
18637	2721	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2721	20	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	2721	21	outright	outright	RB
18637	2721	22	after	after	IN
18637	2721	23	the	the	DT
18637	2721	24	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	2721	25	War	War	NNP
18637	2721	26	as	as	IN
18637	2721	27	to	to	IN
18637	2721	28	imports	import	NNS
18637	2721	29	from	from	IN
18637	2721	30	sister	sister	NN
18637	2721	31	States	States	NNP
18637	2721	32	.	.	.
18637	2722	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2722	2	925	925	CD
18637	2722	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2722	4	However	however	RB
18637	2722	5	,	,	,
18637	2722	6	when	when	WRB
18637	2722	7	in	in	IN
18637	2722	8	the	the	DT
18637	2722	9	late	late	JJ
18637	2722	10	eighties	eighty	NNS
18637	2722	11	and	and	CC
18637	2722	12	early	early	JJ
18637	2722	13	nineties	ninety	NNS
18637	2722	14	State	state	NN
18637	2722	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	2722	16	wide	wide	JJ
18637	2722	17	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	2722	18	laws	law	NNS
18637	2722	19	began	begin	VBD
18637	2722	20	making	make	VBG
18637	2722	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2722	22	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	2722	23	,	,	,
18637	2722	24	the	the	DT
18637	2722	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2722	26	seized	seize	VBD
18637	2722	27	on	on	IN
18637	2722	28	the	the	DT
18637	2722	29	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	2722	30	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	2722	31	and	and	CC
18637	2722	32	began	begin	VBD
18637	2722	33	applying	apply	VBG
18637	2722	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2722	35	as	as	IN
18637	2722	36	a	a	DT
18637	2722	37	brake	brake	NN
18637	2722	38	on	on	IN
18637	2722	39	the	the	DT
18637	2722	40	operation	operation	NN
18637	2722	41	of	of	IN
18637	2722	42	such	such	JJ
18637	2722	43	laws	law	NNS
18637	2722	44	with	with	IN
18637	2722	45	respect	respect	NN
18637	2722	46	to	to	IN
18637	2722	47	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2722	48	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2722	49	in	in	IN
18637	2722	50	intoxicants	intoxicant	NNS
18637	2722	51	,	,	,
18637	2722	52	which	which	WDT
18637	2722	53	the	the	DT
18637	2722	54	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2722	55	denominated	denominate	VBD
18637	2722	56	"	"	``
18637	2722	57	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	2722	58	articles	article	NNS
18637	2722	59	of	of	IN
18637	2722	60	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2722	61	.	.	.
18637	2722	62	"	"	''
18637	2723	1	While	while	IN
18637	2723	2	holding	hold	VBG
18637	2723	3	that	that	IN
18637	2723	4	a	a	DT
18637	2723	5	State	state	NN
18637	2723	6	was	be	VBD
18637	2723	7	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	2723	8	to	to	TO
18637	2723	9	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2723	10	the	the	DT
18637	2723	11	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	2723	12	and	and	CC
18637	2723	13	sale	sale	NN
18637	2723	14	within	within	IN
18637	2723	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2723	16	limits	limit	NNS
18637	2723	17	of	of	IN
18637	2723	18	intoxicants,[926	intoxicants,[926	NN
18637	2723	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2723	20	even	even	RB
18637	2723	21	for	for	IN
18637	2723	22	an	an	DT
18637	2723	23	outside	outside	JJ
18637	2723	24	market	market	NN
18637	2723	25	--	--	:
18637	2723	26	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	2723	27	being	be	VBG
18637	2723	28	no	no	DT
18637	2723	29	part	part	NN
18637	2723	30	of	of	IN
18637	2723	31	commerce[927]--it	commerce[927]--it	NNP
18637	2723	32	contemporaneously	contemporaneously	RB
18637	2723	33	laid	lay	VBN
18637	2723	34	down	down	RP
18637	2723	35	the	the	DT
18637	2723	36	rule	rule	NN
18637	2723	37	,	,	,
18637	2723	38	in	in	IN
18637	2723	39	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	2723	40	_	_	NNP
18637	2723	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	2723	42	_	_	NNP
18637	2723	43	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	2723	44	and	and	CC
18637	2723	45	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	2723	46	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	2723	47	Co	Co	NNP
18637	2723	48	.	.	.
18637	2723	49	,[928	,[928	NFP
18637	2723	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2723	51	that	that	IN
18637	2723	52	so	so	RB
18637	2723	53	long	long	RB
18637	2723	54	as	as	IN
18637	2723	55	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2723	56	remained	remain	VBD
18637	2723	57	silent	silent	JJ
18637	2723	58	in	in	IN
18637	2723	59	the	the	DT
18637	2723	60	matter	matter	NN
18637	2723	61	,	,	,
18637	2723	62	a	a	DT
18637	2723	63	State	state	NN
18637	2723	64	lacked	lack	VBD
18637	2723	65	the	the	DT
18637	2723	66	power	power	NN
18637	2723	67	,	,	,
18637	2723	68	even	even	RB
18637	2723	69	as	as	IN
18637	2723	70	part	part	NN
18637	2723	71	and	and	CC
18637	2723	72	parcel	parcel	NN
18637	2723	73	of	of	IN
18637	2723	74	a	a	DT
18637	2723	75	program	program	NN
18637	2723	76	of	of	IN
18637	2723	77	Statewide	statewide	JJ
18637	2723	78	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	2723	79	of	of	IN
18637	2723	80	the	the	DT
18637	2723	81	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2723	82	in	in	IN
18637	2723	83	intoxicants	intoxicant	NNS
18637	2723	84	,	,	,
18637	2723	85	to	to	TO
18637	2723	86	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2723	87	the	the	DT
18637	2723	88	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2723	89	into	into	IN
18637	2723	90	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2723	91	of	of	IN
18637	2723	92	intoxicants	intoxicant	NNS
18637	2723	93	from	from	IN
18637	2723	94	a	a	DT
18637	2723	95	sister	sister	NN
18637	2723	96	State	state	NN
18637	2723	97	;	;	:
18637	2723	98	and	and	CC
18637	2723	99	this	this	DT
18637	2723	100	holding	holding	NN
18637	2723	101	was	be	VBD
18637	2723	102	soon	soon	RB
18637	2723	103	followed	follow	VBN
18637	2723	104	by	by	IN
18637	2723	105	another	another	DT
18637	2723	106	to	to	IN
18637	2723	107	the	the	DT
18637	2723	108	effect	effect	NN
18637	2723	109	that	that	IN
18637	2723	110	,	,	,
18637	2723	111	so	so	RB
18637	2723	112	long	long	RB
18637	2723	113	as	as	IN
18637	2723	114	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2723	115	remained	remain	VBD
18637	2723	116	silent	silent	JJ
18637	2723	117	,	,	,
18637	2723	118	a	a	DT
18637	2723	119	State	state	NN
18637	2723	120	had	have	VBD
18637	2723	121	no	no	DT
18637	2723	122	power	power	NN
18637	2723	123	to	to	TO
18637	2723	124	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2723	125	the	the	DT
18637	2723	126	sale	sale	NN
18637	2723	127	in	in	IN
18637	2723	128	the	the	DT
18637	2723	129	original	original	JJ
18637	2723	130	package	package	NN
18637	2723	131	of	of	IN
18637	2723	132	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	2723	133	introduced	introduce	VBN
18637	2723	134	from	from	IN
18637	2723	135	another	another	DT
18637	2723	136	State	state	NN
18637	2723	137	.	.	.
18637	2724	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2724	2	929	929	CD
18637	2724	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2724	4	The	the	DT
18637	2724	5	effect	effect	NN
18637	2724	6	of	of	IN
18637	2724	7	the	the	DT
18637	2724	8	latter	latter	JJ
18637	2724	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	2724	10	was	be	VBD
18637	2724	11	soon	soon	RB
18637	2724	12	overcome	overcome	VBN
18637	2724	13	by	by	IN
18637	2724	14	an	an	DT
18637	2724	15	act	act	NN
18637	2724	16	of	of	IN
18637	2724	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2724	18	,	,	,
18637	2724	19	the	the	DT
18637	2724	20	so	so	RB
18637	2724	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	2724	22	called	call	VBN
18637	2724	23	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	2724	24	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2724	25	,	,	,
18637	2724	26	repealing	repeal	VBG
18637	2724	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2724	28	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	2724	29	silence,[930	silence,[930	NN
18637	2724	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2724	31	but	but	CC
18637	2724	32	the	the	DT
18637	2724	33	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	2724	34	decision	decision	NN
18637	2724	35	still	still	RB
18637	2724	36	stood	stand	VBD
18637	2724	37	,	,	,
18637	2724	38	the	the	DT
18637	2724	39	act	act	NN
18637	2724	40	in	in	IN
18637	2724	41	question	question	NN
18637	2724	42	being	be	VBG
18637	2724	43	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	2724	44	by	by	IN
18637	2724	45	the	the	DT
18637	2724	46	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2724	47	not	not	RB
18637	2724	48	to	to	TO
18637	2724	49	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2724	50	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	2724	51	from	from	IN
18637	2724	52	sister	sister	NN
18637	2724	53	States	States	NNP
18637	2724	54	to	to	IN
18637	2724	55	local	local	JJ
18637	2724	56	authority	authority	NN
18637	2724	57	until	until	IN
18637	2724	58	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2724	59	arrival	arrival	NN
18637	2724	60	in	in	IN
18637	2724	61	the	the	DT
18637	2724	62	hands	hand	NNS
18637	2724	63	of	of	IN
18637	2724	64	the	the	DT
18637	2724	65	person	person	NN
18637	2724	66	to	to	IN
18637	2724	67	whom	whom	WP
18637	2724	68	consigned	consigned	JJ
18637	2724	69	.	.	.
18637	2725	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2725	2	931	931	CD
18637	2725	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2725	4	Not	not	RB
18637	2725	5	till	till	IN
18637	2725	6	1913	1913	CD
18637	2725	7	was	be	VBD
18637	2725	8	the	the	DT
18637	2725	9	effect	effect	NN
18637	2725	10	of	of	IN
18637	2725	11	the	the	DT
18637	2725	12	decision	decision	NN
18637	2725	13	in	in	IN
18637	2725	14	the	the	DT
18637	2725	15	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	2725	16	case	case	NN
18637	2725	17	fully	fully	RB
18637	2725	18	nullified	nullify	VBN
18637	2725	19	by	by	IN
18637	2725	20	the	the	DT
18637	2725	21	Webb	Webb	NNP
18637	2725	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	2725	23	Kenyon	Kenyon	NNP
18637	2725	24	Act,[932	Act,[932	NNP
18637	2725	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2725	26	which	which	WDT
18637	2725	27	placed	place	VBD
18637	2725	28	intoxicants	intoxicant	NNS
18637	2725	29	entering	enter	VBG
18637	2725	30	a	a	DT
18637	2725	31	State	state	NN
18637	2725	32	from	from	IN
18637	2725	33	another	another	DT
18637	2725	34	State	state	NN
18637	2725	35	under	under	IN
18637	2725	36	the	the	DT
18637	2725	37	control	control	NN
18637	2725	38	of	of	IN
18637	2725	39	the	the	DT
18637	2725	40	former	former	JJ
18637	2725	41	for	for	IN
18637	2725	42	all	all	DT
18637	2725	43	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	2725	44	whatsoever	whatsoever	RB
18637	2725	45	.	.	.
18637	2726	1	OLEOMARGARINE	OLEOMARGARINE	NNP
18637	2726	2	AND	and	CC
18637	2726	3	CIGARETTES	CIGARETTES	NNP
18637	2726	4	Long	long	RB
18637	2726	5	before	before	IN
18637	2726	6	this	this	DT
18637	2726	7	the	the	DT
18637	2726	8	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	2726	9	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	2726	10	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	2726	11	by	by	IN
18637	2726	12	the	the	DT
18637	2726	13	original	original	JJ
18637	2726	14	package	package	NN
18637	2726	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2726	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	2726	17	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	2726	18	had	have	VBD
18637	2726	19	been	be	VBN
18637	2726	20	extended	extend	VBN
18637	2726	21	to	to	IN
18637	2726	22	cigarettes[933	cigarettes[933	NNS
18637	2726	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2726	24	and	and	CC
18637	2726	25	,	,	,
18637	2726	26	with	with	IN
18637	2726	27	an	an	DT
18637	2726	28	instructive	instructive	JJ
18637	2726	29	exception	exception	NN
18637	2726	30	,	,	,
18637	2726	31	to	to	IN
18637	2726	32	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	VB
18637	2726	33	.	.	.
18637	2727	1	The	the	DT
18637	2727	2	exception	exception	NN
18637	2727	3	referred	refer	VBD
18637	2727	4	to	to	IN
18637	2727	5	was	be	VBD
18637	2727	6	made	make	VBN
18637	2727	7	in	in	IN
18637	2727	8	Plumley	Plumley	NNP
18637	2727	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2727	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	2727	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2727	12	Massachusetts,[934	Massachusetts,[934	NNP
18637	2727	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2727	14	where	where	WRB
18637	2727	15	the	the	DT
18637	2727	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2727	17	held	hold	VBD
18637	2727	18	that	that	IN
18637	2727	19	a	a	DT
18637	2727	20	statute	statute	NN
18637	2727	21	of	of	IN
18637	2727	22	that	that	DT
18637	2727	23	State	State	NNP
18637	2727	24	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	2727	25	the	the	DT
18637	2727	26	sale	sale	NN
18637	2727	27	of	of	IN
18637	2727	28	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
18637	2727	29	colored	color	VBN
18637	2727	30	to	to	TO
18637	2727	31	look	look	VB
18637	2727	32	like	like	IN
18637	2727	33	butter	butter	NN
18637	2727	34	could	could	MD
18637	2727	35	validly	validly	RB
18637	2727	36	be	be	VB
18637	2727	37	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2727	38	to	to	IN
18637	2727	39	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
18637	2727	40	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2727	41	from	from	IN
18637	2727	42	another	another	DT
18637	2727	43	State	state	NN
18637	2727	44	and	and	CC
18637	2727	45	still	still	RB
18637	2727	46	in	in	IN
18637	2727	47	the	the	DT
18637	2727	48	original	original	JJ
18637	2727	49	package	package	NN
18637	2727	50	.	.	.
18637	2728	1	The	the	DT
18637	2728	2	justification	justification	NN
18637	2728	3	of	of	IN
18637	2728	4	the	the	DT
18637	2728	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	2728	6	to	to	IN
18637	2728	7	the	the	DT
18637	2728	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2728	9	's	's	POS
18637	2728	10	mind	mind	NN
18637	2728	11	was	be	VBD
18637	2728	12	that	that	IN
18637	2728	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2728	14	sought	seek	VBD
18637	2728	15	"	"	``
18637	2728	16	to	to	TO
18637	2728	17	suppress	suppress	VB
18637	2728	18	false	false	JJ
18637	2728	19	pretenses	pretense	NNS
18637	2728	20	and	and	CC
18637	2728	21	promote	promote	VB
18637	2728	22	fair	fair	JJ
18637	2728	23	dealing	dealing	NN
18637	2728	24	in	in	IN
18637	2728	25	the	the	DT
18637	2728	26	sale	sale	NN
18637	2728	27	of	of	IN
18637	2728	28	an	an	DT
18637	2728	29	article	article	NN
18637	2728	30	of	of	IN
18637	2728	31	food	food	NN
18637	2728	32	.	.	.
18637	2728	33	"	"	''
18637	2729	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	2729	2	did	do	VBD
18637	2729	3	Leisy	Leisy	NNP
18637	2729	4	and	and	CC
18637	2729	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2729	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2729	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	2729	8	_	_	NNP
18637	2729	9	Hardin[935	Hardin[935	NNP
18637	2729	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2729	11	apply	apply	VBP
18637	2729	12	,	,	,
18637	2729	13	said	say	VBD
18637	2729	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2729	15	Harlan	Harlan	NNP
18637	2729	16	for	for	IN
18637	2729	17	the	the	DT
18637	2729	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2729	19	,	,	,
18637	2729	20	because	because	IN
18637	2729	21	the	the	DT
18637	2729	22	beer	beer	NN
18637	2729	23	in	in	IN
18637	2729	24	that	that	DT
18637	2729	25	case	case	NN
18637	2729	26	was	be	VBD
18637	2729	27	"	"	``
18637	2729	28	genuine	genuine	JJ
18637	2729	29	beer	beer	NN
18637	2729	30	,	,	,
18637	2729	31	and	and	CC
18637	2729	32	not	not	RB
18637	2729	33	a	a	DT
18637	2729	34	liquid	liquid	NN
18637	2729	35	or	or	CC
18637	2729	36	drink	drink	NN
18637	2729	37	colored	color	VBN
18637	2729	38	artificially	artificially	RB
18637	2729	39	so	so	IN
18637	2729	40	as	as	IN
18637	2729	41	to	to	TO
18637	2729	42	cause	cause	VB
18637	2729	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2729	44	to	to	TO
18637	2729	45	look	look	VB
18637	2729	46	like	like	IN
18637	2729	47	beer	beer	NN
18637	2729	48	.	.	.
18637	2729	49	"	"	''
18637	2730	1	That	that	DT
18637	2730	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	2730	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2730	4	never	never	RB
18637	2730	5	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2730	6	,	,	,
18637	2730	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2730	8	continued	continue	VBD
18637	2730	9	,	,	,
18637	2730	10	to	to	TO
18637	2730	11	hold	hold	VB
18637	2730	12	that	that	IN
18637	2730	13	"	"	``
18637	2730	14	a	a	DT
18637	2730	15	State	state	NN
18637	2730	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	2730	17	powerless	powerless	JJ
18637	2730	18	to	to	TO
18637	2730	19	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2730	20	the	the	DT
18637	2730	21	sale	sale	NN
18637	2730	22	of	of	IN
18637	2730	23	articles	article	NNS
18637	2730	24	manufactured	manufacture	VBN
18637	2730	25	in	in	IN
18637	2730	26	or	or	CC
18637	2730	27	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2730	28	from	from	IN
18637	2730	29	another	another	DT
18637	2730	30	State	state	NN
18637	2730	31	,	,	,
18637	2730	32	and	and	CC
18637	2730	33	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	2730	34	of	of	IN
18637	2730	35	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2730	36	and	and	CC
18637	2730	37	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2730	38	,	,	,
18637	2730	39	if	if	IN
18637	2730	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2730	41	sale	sale	NN
18637	2730	42	may	may	MD
18637	2730	43	cheat	cheat	VB
18637	2730	44	the	the	DT
18637	2730	45	people	people	NNS
18637	2730	46	into	into	IN
18637	2730	47	purchasing	purchase	VBG
18637	2730	48	something	something	NN
18637	2730	49	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2730	50	do	do	VBP
18637	2730	51	not	not	RB
18637	2730	52	intend	intend	VB
18637	2730	53	to	to	TO
18637	2730	54	buy	buy	VB
18637	2730	55	*	*	NFP
18637	2730	56	*	*	NFP
18637	2730	57	*	*	NFP
18637	2730	58	.	.	.
18637	2731	1	"	"	``
18637	2731	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2731	3	936	936	CD
18637	2731	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2731	5	Obviously	obviously	RB
18637	2731	6	,	,	,
18637	2731	7	the	the	DT
18637	2731	8	argument	argument	NN
18637	2731	9	was	be	VBD
18637	2731	10	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	2731	11	only	only	RB
18637	2731	12	on	on	IN
18637	2731	13	the	the	DT
18637	2731	14	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	2731	15	that	that	IN
18637	2731	16	a	a	DT
18637	2731	17	State	state	NN
18637	2731	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	2731	19	a	a	DT
18637	2731	20	better	well	JJR
18637	2731	21	right	right	NN
18637	2731	22	to	to	TO
18637	2731	23	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2731	24	frauds	fraud	NNS
18637	2731	25	than	than	IN
18637	2731	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2731	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	2731	28	to	to	TO
18637	2731	29	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2731	30	drunkenness	drunkenness	NN
18637	2731	31	and	and	CC
18637	2731	32	like	like	IN
18637	2731	33	evils	evil	NNS
18637	2731	34	;	;	:
18637	2731	35	and	and	CC
18637	2731	36	doubtless	doubtless	RB
18637	2731	37	that	that	DT
18637	2731	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	2731	39	the	the	DT
18637	2731	40	way	way	NN
18637	2731	41	the	the	DT
18637	2731	42	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2731	43	felt	feel	VBD
18637	2731	44	about	about	IN
18637	2731	45	the	the	DT
18637	2731	46	matter	matter	NN
18637	2731	47	at	at	IN
18637	2731	48	that	that	DT
18637	2731	49	date	date	NN
18637	2731	50	.	.	.
18637	2732	1	On	on	IN
18637	2732	2	the	the	DT
18637	2732	3	one	one	CD
18637	2732	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	2732	5	,	,	,
18637	2732	6	the	the	DT
18637	2732	7	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	2732	8	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2732	9	was	be	VBD
18637	2732	10	a	a	DT
18637	2732	11	very	very	RB
18637	2732	12	ancient	ancient	JJ
18637	2732	13	,	,	,
18637	2732	14	if	if	IN
18637	2732	15	not	not	RB
18637	2732	16	an	an	DT
18637	2732	17	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	2732	18	,	,	,
18637	2732	19	venerable	venerable	JJ
18637	2732	20	institution	institution	NN
18637	2732	21	,	,	,
18637	2732	22	while	while	IN
18637	2732	23	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
18637	2732	24	was	be	VBD
18637	2732	25	then	then	RB
18637	2732	26	a	a	DT
18637	2732	27	relatively	relatively	RB
18637	2732	28	novel	novel	JJ
18637	2732	29	article	article	NN
18637	2732	30	of	of	IN
18637	2732	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2732	32	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2732	33	wholesomeness	wholesomeness	NN
18637	2732	34	was	be	VBD
18637	2732	35	suspect	suspect	JJ
18637	2732	36	.	.	.
18637	2733	1	On	on	IN
18637	2733	2	the	the	DT
18637	2733	3	other	other	JJ
18637	2733	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	2733	5	,	,	,
18637	2733	6	laws	law	NNS
18637	2733	7	designed	design	VBN
18637	2733	8	to	to	TO
18637	2733	9	secure	secure	VB
18637	2733	10	fair	fair	JJ
18637	2733	11	dealing	dealing	NN
18637	2733	12	and	and	CC
18637	2733	13	condemnatory	condemnatory	NN
18637	2733	14	of	of	IN
18637	2733	15	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	2733	16	followed	follow	VBD
18637	2733	17	closely	closely	RB
18637	2733	18	the	the	DT
18637	2733	19	track	track	NN
18637	2733	20	of	of	IN
18637	2733	21	the	the	DT
18637	2733	22	common	common	JJ
18637	2733	23	law	law	NN
18637	2733	24	,	,	,
18637	2733	25	while	while	IN
18637	2733	26	anti	anti	JJ
18637	2733	27	-	-	JJ
18637	2733	28	liquor	liquor	JJ
18637	2733	29	laws	law	NNS
18637	2733	30	most	most	RBS
18637	2733	31	decidedly	decidedly	RB
18637	2733	32	did	do	VBD
18637	2733	33	not	not	RB
18637	2733	34	.	.	.
18637	2734	1	The	the	DT
18637	2734	2	real	real	JJ
18637	2734	3	differentiation	differentiation	NN
18637	2734	4	of	of	IN
18637	2734	5	the	the	DT
18637	2734	6	two	two	CD
18637	2734	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	2734	8	had	have	VBD
18637	2734	9	to	to	TO
18637	2734	10	be	be	VB
18637	2734	11	sought	seek	VBN
18637	2734	12	in	in	IN
18637	2734	13	historical	historical	JJ
18637	2734	14	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	2734	15	.	.	.
18637	2735	1	Yet	yet	CC
18637	2735	2	the	the	DT
18637	2735	3	State	State	NNP
18637	2735	4	must	must	MD
18637	2735	5	not	not	RB
18637	2735	6	put	put	VB
18637	2735	7	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	2735	8	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	2735	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	2735	10	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2735	11	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2735	12	even	even	RB
18637	2735	13	in	in	IN
18637	2735	14	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
18637	2735	15	.	.	.
18637	2736	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2736	2	a	a	DT
18637	2736	3	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2736	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	2736	5	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	2736	6	the	the	DT
18637	2736	7	sale	sale	NN
18637	2736	8	of	of	IN
18637	2736	9	this	this	DT
18637	2736	10	product	product	NN
18637	2736	11	even	even	RB
18637	2736	12	in	in	IN
18637	2736	13	the	the	DT
18637	2736	14	unadulterated	unadulterated	JJ
18637	2736	15	condition	condition	NN
18637	2736	16	was	be	VBD
18637	2736	17	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
18637	2736	18	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	2736	19	so	so	RB
18637	2736	20	far	far	RB
18637	2736	21	as	as	IN
18637	2736	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2736	23	operated	operate	VBD
18637	2736	24	to	to	TO
18637	2736	25	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2736	26	the	the	DT
18637	2736	27	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	2736	28	of	of	IN
18637	2736	29	such	such	JJ
18637	2736	30	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
18637	2736	31	from	from	IN
18637	2736	32	another	another	DT
18637	2736	33	State	State	NNP
18637	2736	34	and	and	CC
18637	2736	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2736	36	sale	sale	NN
18637	2736	37	in	in	IN
18637	2736	38	the	the	DT
18637	2736	39	original	original	JJ
18637	2736	40	package;[937	package;[937	NNPS
18637	2736	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2736	42	as	as	IN
18637	2736	43	was	be	VBD
18637	2736	44	also	also	RB
18637	2736	45	a	a	DT
18637	2736	46	New	New	NNP
18637	2736	47	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	2736	48	statute	statute	NN
18637	2736	49	which	which	WDT
18637	2736	50	required	require	VBD
18637	2736	51	that	that	IN
18637	2736	52	all	all	DT
18637	2736	53	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
18637	2736	54	marketed	market	VBN
18637	2736	55	in	in	IN
18637	2736	56	the	the	DT
18637	2736	57	State	State	NNP
18637	2736	58	be	be	VB
18637	2736	59	colored	color	VBN
18637	2736	60	pink	pink	NN
18637	2736	61	.	.	.
18637	2737	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2737	2	938	938	CD
18637	2737	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2737	4	A	a	DT
18637	2737	5	little	little	JJ
18637	2737	6	later	later	RB
18637	2737	7	in	in	IN
18637	2737	8	the	the	DT
18637	2737	9	case	case	NN
18637	2737	10	above	above	IN
18637	2737	11	mentioned	mention	VBD
18637	2737	12	involving	involve	VBG
18637	2737	13	cigarettes	cigarette	NNS
18637	2737	14	,	,	,
18637	2737	15	the	the	DT
18637	2737	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2737	17	discovered	discover	VBD
18637	2737	18	some	some	DT
18637	2737	19	of	of	IN
18637	2737	20	the	the	DT
18637	2737	21	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	2737	22	of	of	IN
18637	2737	23	the	the	DT
18637	2737	24	original	original	JJ
18637	2737	25	package	package	NN
18637	2737	26	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2737	27	when	when	WRB
18637	2737	28	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2737	29	to	to	IN
18637	2737	30	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2737	31	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2737	32	,	,	,
18637	2737	33	in	in	IN
18637	2737	34	which	which	WDT
18637	2737	35	the	the	DT
18637	2737	36	package	package	NN
18637	2737	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	2737	38	not	not	RB
18637	2737	39	so	so	RB
18637	2737	40	apt	apt	JJ
18637	2737	41	to	to	TO
18637	2737	42	be	be	VB
18637	2737	43	standardized	standardize	VBN
18637	2737	44	as	as	IN
18637	2737	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2737	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	2737	47	in	in	IN
18637	2737	48	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2737	49	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2737	50	.	.	.
18637	2738	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2738	2	939	939	CD
18637	2738	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2738	4	DEMISE	DEMISE	NNS
18637	2738	5	OF	of	IN
18637	2738	6	THE	the	DT
18637	2738	7	ORIGINAL	original	JJ
18637	2738	8	PACKAGE	package	NN
18637	2738	9	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNS
18637	2738	10	What	what	WDT
18637	2738	11	importance	importance	NN
18637	2738	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	2738	13	the	the	DT
18637	2738	14	original	original	JJ
18637	2738	15	package	package	NN
18637	2738	16	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2738	17	today	today	NN
18637	2738	18	as	as	IN
18637	2738	19	a	a	DT
18637	2738	20	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	2738	21	on	on	IN
18637	2738	22	State	State	NNP
18637	2738	23	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2738	24	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	2738	25	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2738	26	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2738	27	?	?	.
18637	2739	1	The	the	DT
18637	2739	2	answer	answer	NN
18637	2739	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	2739	4	,	,	,
18637	2739	5	very	very	RB
18637	2739	6	little	little	JJ
18637	2739	7	,	,	,
18637	2739	8	if	if	IN
18637	2739	9	any	any	DT
18637	2739	10	.	.	.
18637	2740	1	State	state	NN
18637	2740	2	laws	law	NNS
18637	2740	3	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	2740	4	the	the	DT
18637	2740	5	importation	importation	NN
18637	2740	6	of	of	IN
18637	2740	7	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	2740	8	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	2740	9	,	,	,
18637	2740	10	have	have	VBP
18637	2740	11	since	since	IN
18637	2740	12	the	the	DT
18637	2740	13	passage	passage	NN
18637	2740	14	of	of	IN
18637	2740	15	the	the	DT
18637	2740	16	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	2740	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	2740	18	first	first	NNP
18637	2740	19	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	2740	20	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	2740	21	been	be	VBN
18637	2740	22	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	2740	23	,	,	,
18637	2740	24	even	even	RB
18637	2740	25	when	when	WRB
18637	2740	26	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	2740	27	a	a	DT
18637	2740	28	burden	burden	NN
18637	2740	29	on	on	IN
18637	2740	30	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2740	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2740	32	or	or	CC
18637	2740	33	discriminating	discriminate	VBG
18637	2740	34	against	against	IN
18637	2740	35	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	2740	36	imported	import	VBN
18637	2740	37	from	from	IN
18637	2740	38	another	another	DT
18637	2740	39	State	state	NN
18637	2740	40	.	.	.
18637	2741	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2741	2	940	940	CD
18637	2741	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2741	4	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	2741	5	the	the	DT
18637	2741	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2741	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	2741	8	,	,	,
18637	2741	9	without	without	IN
18637	2741	10	appealing	appeal	VBG
18637	2741	11	to	to	IN
18637	2741	12	the	the	DT
18637	2741	13	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	2741	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	2741	15	first	first	NNP
18637	2741	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	2741	17	,	,	,
18637	2741	18	even	even	RB
18637	2741	19	gone	go	VBN
18637	2741	20	so	so	RB
18637	2741	21	far	far	RB
18637	2741	22	as	as	IN
18637	2741	23	to	to	TO
18637	2741	24	uphold	uphold	VB
18637	2741	25	a	a	DT
18637	2741	26	statute	statute	NN
18637	2741	27	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2741	28	a	a	DT
18637	2741	29	permit	permit	NN
18637	2741	30	for	for	IN
18637	2741	31	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2741	32	of	of	IN
18637	2741	33	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	2741	34	through	through	IN
18637	2741	35	the	the	DT
18637	2741	36	enacting	enact	VBG
18637	2741	37	State	State	NNP
18637	2741	38	.	.	.
18637	2742	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2742	2	941	941	CD
18637	2742	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2742	4	In	in	IN
18637	2742	5	Whitfield	Whitfield	NNP
18637	2742	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2742	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	2742	8	_	_	NNP
18637	2742	9	Ohio,[942	Ohio,[942	NNP
18637	2742	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2742	11	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	2742	12	,	,	,
18637	2742	13	the	the	DT
18637	2742	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2742	15	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	2742	16	a	a	DT
18637	2742	17	State	State	NNP
18637	2742	18	law	law	NN
18637	2742	19	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	2742	20	the	the	DT
18637	2742	21	sale	sale	NN
18637	2742	22	in	in	IN
18637	2742	23	open	open	JJ
18637	2742	24	market	market	NN
18637	2742	25	of	of	IN
18637	2742	26	convict	convict	NN
18637	2742	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	2742	28	made	make	VBN
18637	2742	29	goods	good	NNS
18637	2742	30	including	include	VBG
18637	2742	31	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2742	32	of	of	IN
18637	2742	33	goods	good	NNS
18637	2742	34	imported	import	VBN
18637	2742	35	from	from	IN
18637	2742	36	other	other	JJ
18637	2742	37	States	States	NNPS
18637	2742	38	and	and	CC
18637	2742	39	still	still	RB
18637	2742	40	in	in	IN
18637	2742	41	the	the	DT
18637	2742	42	original	original	JJ
18637	2742	43	package	package	NN
18637	2742	44	.	.	.
18637	2743	1	While	while	IN
18637	2743	2	the	the	DT
18637	2743	3	decision	decision	NN
18637	2743	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	2743	5	based	base	VBN
18637	2743	6	on	on	IN
18637	2743	7	the	the	DT
18637	2743	8	Hawes	Hawes	NNP
18637	2743	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	2743	10	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	2743	11	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2743	12	of	of	IN
18637	2743	13	1929,[943	1929,[943	NNP
18637	2743	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2743	15	which	which	WDT
18637	2743	16	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	2743	17	the	the	DT
18637	2743	18	pattern	pattern	NN
18637	2743	19	of	of	IN
18637	2743	20	the	the	DT
18637	2743	21	Webb	Webb	NNP
18637	2743	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	2743	23	Kenyon	Kenyon	NNP
18637	2743	24	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2743	25	,	,	,
18637	2743	26	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2743	27	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	2743	28	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2743	29	for	for	IN
18637	2743	30	the	the	DT
18637	2743	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2743	32	,	,	,
18637	2743	33	takes	take	VBZ
18637	2743	34	pains	pain	NNS
18637	2743	35	to	to	TO
18637	2743	36	disparage	disparage	VB
18637	2743	37	the	the	DT
18637	2743	38	"	"	``
18637	2743	39	unbroken	unbroken	JJ
18637	2743	40	-	-	HYPH
18637	2743	41	package	package	NN
18637	2743	42	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2743	43	,	,	,
18637	2743	44	as	as	IN
18637	2743	45	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2743	46	to	to	IN
18637	2743	47	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2743	48	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2743	49	,	,	,
18637	2743	50	*	*	NFP
18637	2743	51	*	*	NFP
18637	2743	52	*	*	NFP
18637	2743	53	,	,	,
18637	2743	54	as	as	IN
18637	2743	55	more	more	RBR
18637	2743	56	artificial	artificial	JJ
18637	2743	57	than	than	IN
18637	2743	58	sound	sound	NN
18637	2743	59	.	.	.
18637	2744	1	"	"	``
18637	2744	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2744	3	944	944	CD
18637	2744	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2744	5	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	2744	6	,	,	,
18637	2744	7	earlier	early	JJR
18637	2744	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	2744	9	make	make	VBP
18637	2744	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2744	11	clear	clear	JJ
18637	2744	12	that	that	IN
18637	2744	13	the	the	DT
18637	2744	14	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	2744	15	of	of	IN
18637	2744	16	State	State	NNP
18637	2744	17	quarantine	quarantine	NN
18637	2744	18	and	and	CC
18637	2744	19	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	2744	20	acts	act	NNS
18637	2744	21	,	,	,
18637	2744	22	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2744	23	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2744	24	,	,	,
18637	2744	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	2744	26	not	not	RB
18637	2744	27	to	to	TO
18637	2744	28	be	be	VB
18637	2744	29	impeded	impede	VBN
18637	2744	30	by	by	IN
18637	2744	31	the	the	DT
18637	2744	32	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2744	33	in	in	IN
18637	2744	34	any	any	DT
18637	2744	35	way	way	NN
18637	2744	36	.	.	.
18637	2745	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2745	2	945	945	NN
18637	2745	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2745	4	CURBS	CURBS	NNP
18637	2745	5	ON	on	IN
18637	2745	6	THE	the	DT
18637	2745	7	INTERSTATE	interstate	JJ
18637	2745	8	MOVEMENT	movement	NN
18637	2745	9	OF	of	IN
18637	2745	10	PERSONS	PERSONS	NNP
18637	2745	11	Prior	prior	RB
18637	2745	12	to	to	IN
18637	2745	13	the	the	DT
18637	2745	14	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	2745	15	War	War	NNP
18637	2745	16	the	the	DT
18637	2745	17	slaveholding	slaveholde	VBG
18637	2745	18	States	States	NNP
18637	2745	19	,	,	,
18637	2745	20	ever	ever	RB
18637	2745	21	fearful	fearful	JJ
18637	2745	22	of	of	IN
18637	2745	23	a	a	DT
18637	2745	24	slave	slave	NN
18637	2745	25	uprising	uprising	NN
18637	2745	26	,	,	,
18637	2745	27	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	2745	28	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2745	29	meant	mean	VBD
18637	2745	30	to	to	TO
18637	2745	31	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	2745	32	from	from	IN
18637	2745	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2745	34	borders	border	NNS
18637	2745	35	free	free	JJ
18637	2745	36	Negroes	Negroes	NNPS
18637	2745	37	whether	whether	IN
18637	2745	38	hailing	hail	VBG
18637	2745	39	from	from	IN
18637	2745	40	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	2745	41	or	or	CC
18637	2745	42	from	from	IN
18637	2745	43	sister	sister	NN
18637	2745	44	States	States	NNP
18637	2745	45	,	,	,
18637	2745	46	and	and	CC
18637	2745	47	in	in	IN
18637	2745	48	1823	1823	CD
18637	2745	49	a	a	DT
18637	2745	50	South	South	NNP
18637	2745	51	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	2745	52	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	2745	53	Seamen	Seamen	NNP
18637	2745	54	's	's	POS
18637	2745	55	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2745	56	embodying	embody	VBG
18637	2745	57	this	this	DT
18637	2745	58	objective	objective	NN
18637	2745	59	was	be	VBD
18637	2745	60	held	hold	VBN
18637	2745	61	void	void	JJ
18637	2745	62	by	by	IN
18637	2745	63	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2745	64	William	William	NNP
18637	2745	65	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	2745	66	,	,	,
18637	2745	67	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2745	68	a	a	DT
18637	2745	69	South	South	NNP
18637	2745	70	Carolinian	Carolinian	NNP
18637	2745	71	,	,	,
18637	2745	72	in	in	IN
18637	2745	73	a	a	DT
18637	2745	74	case	case	NN
18637	2745	75	arising	arise	VBG
18637	2745	76	in	in	IN
18637	2745	77	the	the	DT
18637	2745	78	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	2745	79	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	2745	80	and	and	CC
18637	2745	81	involving	involve	VBG
18637	2745	82	a	a	DT
18637	2745	83	colored	colored	JJ
18637	2745	84	British	british	JJ
18637	2745	85	sailor	sailor	NN
18637	2745	86	.	.	.
18637	2746	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2746	2	946	946	CD
18637	2746	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2746	4	The	the	DT
18637	2746	5	basis	basis	NN
18637	2746	6	of	of	IN
18637	2746	7	the	the	DT
18637	2746	8	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	2746	9	,	,	,
18637	2746	10	which	which	WDT
18637	2746	11	created	create	VBD
18637	2746	12	tremendous	tremendous	JJ
18637	2746	13	uproar	uproar	NN
18637	2746	14	in	in	IN
18637	2746	15	Charleston,[947	Charleston,[947	NNP
18637	2746	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2746	17	was	be	VBD
18637	2746	18	the	the	DT
18637	2746	19	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2746	20	clause	clause	NN
18637	2746	21	and	and	CC
18637	2746	22	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2746	23	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	2746	24	of	of	IN
18637	2746	25	the	the	DT
18637	2746	26	United	United	NNP
18637	2746	27	States	States	NNP
18637	2746	28	.	.	.
18637	2747	1	There	there	EX
18637	2747	2	followed	follow	VBD
18637	2747	3	two	two	CD
18637	2747	4	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	2747	5	of	of	IN
18637	2747	6	Attorneys	Attorneys	NNP
18637	2747	7	General	General	NNP
18637	2747	8	,	,	,
18637	2747	9	the	the	DT
18637	2747	10	earlier	early	RBR
18637	2747	11	by	by	IN
18637	2747	12	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	2747	13	General	General	NNP
18637	2747	14	Wirt	Wirt	NNP
18637	2747	15	,	,	,
18637	2747	16	denouncing	denounce	VBG
18637	2747	17	such	such	JJ
18637	2747	18	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2747	19	as	as	IN
18637	2747	20	unconstitutional;[948	unconstitutional;[948	LS
18637	2747	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2747	22	the	the	DT
18637	2747	23	latter	latter	JJ
18637	2747	24	by	by	IN
18637	2747	25	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	2747	26	General	General	NNP
18637	2747	27	Berrien	Berrien	NNP
18637	2747	28	,	,	,
18637	2747	29	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	2747	30	it;[949	it;[949	CD
18637	2747	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2747	32	and	and	CC
18637	2747	33	in	in	IN
18637	2747	34	City	City	NNP
18637	2747	35	of	of	IN
18637	2747	36	New	New	NNP
18637	2747	37	York	York	NNP
18637	2747	38	_	_	NNP
18637	2747	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	2747	40	_	_	NNP
18637	2747	41	Miln[950	miln[950	CD
18637	2747	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2747	43	the	the	DT
18637	2747	44	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2747	45	,	,	,
18637	2747	46	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2747	47	by	by	IN
18637	2747	48	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2747	49	Barbour	Barbour	NNP
18637	2747	50	of	of	IN
18637	2747	51	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	2747	52	,	,	,
18637	2747	53	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	2747	54	,	,	,
18637	2747	55	six	six	CD
18637	2747	56	years	year	NNS
18637	2747	57	after	after	IN
18637	2747	58	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	2747	59	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	2747	60	's	's	POS
18637	2747	61	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	2747	62	,	,	,
18637	2747	63	the	the	DT
18637	2747	64	power	power	NN
18637	2747	65	of	of	IN
18637	2747	66	the	the	DT
18637	2747	67	States	States	NNPS
18637	2747	68	to	to	TO
18637	2747	69	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	2747	70	undesirables	undesirable	NNS
18637	2747	71	in	in	IN
18637	2747	72	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	2747	73	terms	term	NNS
18637	2747	74	,	,	,
18637	2747	75	which	which	WDT
18637	2747	76	in	in	IN
18637	2747	77	the	the	DT
18637	2747	78	Passenger	Passenger	NNP
18637	2747	79	Cases,[951	Cases,[951	NNP
18637	2747	80	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2747	81	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2747	82	in	in	IN
18637	2747	83	1840	1840	CD
18637	2747	84	,	,	,
18637	2747	85	a	a	DT
18637	2747	86	narrowly	narrowly	RB
18637	2747	87	divided	divide	VBN
18637	2747	88	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2747	89	considerably	considerably	RB
18637	2747	90	qualified	qualify	VBD
18637	2747	91	.	.	.
18637	2748	1	Shortly	shortly	RB
18637	2748	2	after	after	IN
18637	2748	3	the	the	DT
18637	2748	4	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	2748	5	War	War	NNP
18637	2748	6	the	the	DT
18637	2748	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2748	8	overturned	overturn	VBD
18637	2748	9	a	a	DT
18637	2748	10	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	2748	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	2748	12	which	which	WDT
18637	2748	13	sought	seek	VBD
18637	2748	14	to	to	TO
18637	2748	15	halt	halt	VB
18637	2748	16	the	the	DT
18637	2748	17	further	further	JJ
18637	2748	18	loss	loss	NN
18637	2748	19	of	of	IN
18637	2748	20	population	population	NN
18637	2748	21	by	by	IN
18637	2748	22	a	a	DT
18637	2748	23	special	special	JJ
18637	2748	24	tax	tax	NN
18637	2748	25	on	on	IN
18637	2748	26	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	2748	27	on	on	IN
18637	2748	28	every	every	DT
18637	2748	29	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	2748	30	carried	carry	VBD
18637	2748	31	out	out	IN
18637	2748	32	of	of	IN
18637	2748	33	the	the	DT
18637	2748	34	State	State	NNP
18637	2748	35	.	.	.
18637	2749	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2749	2	952	952	CD
18637	2749	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2749	4	This	this	DT
18637	2749	5	time	time	NN
18637	2749	6	only	only	RB
18637	2749	7	two	two	CD
18637	2749	8	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	2749	9	invoked	invoke	VBD
18637	2749	10	the	the	DT
18637	2749	11	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2749	12	clause	clause	NN
18637	2749	13	;	;	:
18637	2749	14	the	the	DT
18637	2749	15	majority	majority	NN
18637	2749	16	,	,	,
18637	2749	17	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2749	18	by	by	IN
18637	2749	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2749	20	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	2749	21	held	hold	VBD
18637	2749	22	the	the	DT
18637	2749	23	measure	measure	NN
18637	2749	24	to	to	TO
18637	2749	25	be	be	VB
18637	2749	26	an	an	DT
18637	2749	27	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2749	28	interference	interference	NN
18637	2749	29	with	with	IN
18637	2749	30	a	a	DT
18637	2749	31	right	right	NN
18637	2749	32	of	of	IN
18637	2749	33	national	national	JJ
18637	2749	34	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	2749	35	--	--	:
18637	2749	36	a	a	DT
18637	2749	37	holding	hold	VBG
18637	2749	38	today	today	NN
18637	2749	39	translatable	translatable	NN
18637	2749	40	,	,	,
18637	2749	41	in	in	IN
18637	2749	42	the	the	DT
18637	2749	43	terminology	terminology	NN
18637	2749	44	of	of	IN
18637	2749	45	the	the	DT
18637	2749	46	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	2749	47	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	2749	48	,	,	,
18637	2749	49	as	as	IN
18637	2749	50	an	an	DT
18637	2749	51	abridgment	abridgment	NN
18637	2749	52	of	of	IN
18637	2749	53	a	a	DT
18637	2749	54	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2749	55	or	or	CC
18637	2749	56	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	2749	57	of	of	IN
18637	2749	58	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	2749	59	of	of	IN
18637	2749	60	the	the	DT
18637	2749	61	United	United	NNP
18637	2749	62	States	States	NNP
18637	2749	63	.	.	.
18637	2750	1	Against	against	IN
18637	2750	2	this	this	DT
18637	2750	3	background	background	NN
18637	2750	4	the	the	DT
18637	2750	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2750	6	in	in	IN
18637	2750	7	1941	1941	CD
18637	2750	8	,	,	,
18637	2750	9	in	in	IN
18637	2750	10	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	2750	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2750	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	2750	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2750	14	California,[953	California,[953	NNP
18637	2750	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2750	16	held	hold	VBD
18637	2750	17	void	void	RB
18637	2750	18	a	a	DT
18637	2750	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	2750	20	which	which	WDT
18637	2750	21	penalized	penalize	VBD
18637	2750	22	the	the	DT
18637	2750	23	bringing	bringing	NN
18637	2750	24	into	into	IN
18637	2750	25	that	that	DT
18637	2750	26	State	state	NN
18637	2750	27	,	,	,
18637	2750	28	or	or	CC
18637	2750	29	the	the	DT
18637	2750	30	assisting	assisting	NN
18637	2750	31	to	to	TO
18637	2750	32	bring	bring	VB
18637	2750	33	into	into	IN
18637	2750	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2750	35	,	,	,
18637	2750	36	any	any	DT
18637	2750	37	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	2750	38	knowing	know	VBG
18637	2750	39	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2750	40	to	to	TO
18637	2750	41	be	be	VB
18637	2750	42	"	"	``
18637	2750	43	an	an	DT
18637	2750	44	indigent	indigent	JJ
18637	2750	45	person	person	NN
18637	2750	46	.	.	.
18637	2750	47	"	"	''
18637	2751	1	Five	five	CD
18637	2751	2	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	2751	3	,	,	,
18637	2751	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2751	5	by	by	IN
18637	2751	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2751	7	Byrnes	Byrnes	NNP
18637	2751	8	,	,	,
18637	2751	9	held	hold	VBD
18637	2751	10	the	the	DT
18637	2751	11	act	act	NN
18637	2751	12	to	to	TO
18637	2751	13	be	be	VB
18637	2751	14	even	even	RB
18637	2751	15	as	as	IN
18637	2751	16	to	to	IN
18637	2751	17	"	"	``
18637	2751	18	persons	person	NNS
18637	2751	19	who	who	WP
18637	2751	20	are	be	VBP
18637	2751	21	presently	presently	RB
18637	2751	22	destitute	destitute	JJ
18637	2751	23	of	of	IN
18637	2751	24	property	property	NN
18637	2751	25	and	and	CC
18637	2751	26	without	without	IN
18637	2751	27	resources	resource	NNS
18637	2751	28	to	to	TO
18637	2751	29	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	2751	30	the	the	DT
18637	2751	31	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	2751	32	of	of	IN
18637	2751	33	life	life	NN
18637	2751	34	,	,	,
18637	2751	35	and	and	CC
18637	2751	36	who	who	WP
18637	2751	37	have	have	VBP
18637	2751	38	no	no	DT
18637	2751	39	relatives	relative	NNS
18637	2751	40	or	or	CC
18637	2751	41	friends	friend	NNS
18637	2751	42	able	able	JJ
18637	2751	43	and	and	CC
18637	2751	44	willing	willing	JJ
18637	2751	45	to	to	TO
18637	2751	46	support	support	VB
18637	2751	47	them,"[954	them,"[954	NN
18637	2751	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2751	49	an	an	DT
18637	2751	50	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2751	51	interference	interference	NN
18637	2751	52	with	with	IN
18637	2751	53	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2751	54	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2751	55	.	.	.
18637	2752	1	"	"	``
18637	2752	2	The	the	DT
18637	2752	3	State	State	NNP
18637	2752	4	asserts	assert	VBZ
18637	2752	5	,	,	,
18637	2752	6	"	"	``
18637	2752	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2752	8	Byrnes	Byrnes	NNP
18637	2752	9	recites	recite	VBZ
18637	2752	10	,	,	,
18637	2752	11	"	"	``
18637	2752	12	that	that	IN
18637	2752	13	the	the	DT
18637	2752	14	huge	huge	JJ
18637	2752	15	influx	influx	NN
18637	2752	16	of	of	IN
18637	2752	17	migrants	migrant	NNS
18637	2752	18	into	into	IN
18637	2752	19	California	California	NNP
18637	2752	20	in	in	IN
18637	2752	21	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2752	22	years	year	NNS
18637	2752	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	2752	24	resulted	result	VBN
18637	2752	25	in	in	IN
18637	2752	26	problems	problem	NNS
18637	2752	27	of	of	IN
18637	2752	28	health	health	NN
18637	2752	29	,	,	,
18637	2752	30	morals	moral	NNS
18637	2752	31	,	,	,
18637	2752	32	and	and	CC
18637	2752	33	especially	especially	RB
18637	2752	34	finance	finance	NN
18637	2752	35	,	,	,
18637	2752	36	the	the	DT
18637	2752	37	proportions	proportion	NNS
18637	2752	38	of	of	IN
18637	2752	39	which	which	WDT
18637	2752	40	are	be	VBP
18637	2752	41	staggering	staggering	JJ
18637	2752	42	.	.	.
18637	2753	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2753	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2753	3	not	not	RB
18637	2753	4	for	for	IN
18637	2753	5	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2753	6	to	to	TO
18637	2753	7	say	say	VB
18637	2753	8	that	that	IN
18637	2753	9	this	this	DT
18637	2753	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	2753	11	not	not	RB
18637	2753	12	true	true	JJ
18637	2753	13	.	.	.
18637	2754	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2754	2	have	have	VBP
18637	2754	3	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	2754	4	and	and	CC
18637	2754	5	recently	recently	RB
18637	2754	6	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	2754	7	,	,	,
18637	2754	8	and	and	CC
18637	2754	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2754	10	now	now	RB
18637	2754	11	reaffirm	reaffirm	VBP
18637	2754	12	,	,	,
18637	2754	13	that	that	IN
18637	2754	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2754	15	do	do	VBP
18637	2754	16	not	not	RB
18637	2754	17	conceive	conceive	VB
18637	2754	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2754	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2754	20	function	function	NN
18637	2754	21	to	to	TO
18637	2754	22	pass	pass	VB
18637	2754	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	2754	24	'	'	''
18637	2754	25	the	the	DT
18637	2754	26	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	2754	27	,	,	,
18637	2754	28	need	need	VBP
18637	2754	29	,	,	,
18637	2754	30	or	or	CC
18637	2754	31	appropriateness	appropriateness	NN
18637	2754	32	'	'	''
18637	2754	33	of	of	IN
18637	2754	34	the	the	DT
18637	2754	35	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2754	36	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	2754	37	of	of	IN
18637	2754	38	the	the	DT
18637	2754	39	States	States	NNPS
18637	2754	40	to	to	TO
18637	2754	41	solve	solve	VB
18637	2754	42	such	such	JJ
18637	2754	43	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	2754	44	.	.	.
18637	2755	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2755	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2755	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2755	4	But	but	CC
18637	2755	5	this	this	DT
18637	2755	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	2755	7	not	not	RB
18637	2755	8	mean	mean	VB
18637	2755	9	that	that	IN
18637	2755	10	there	there	EX
18637	2755	11	are	be	VBP
18637	2755	12	no	no	DT
18637	2755	13	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	2755	14	to	to	IN
18637	2755	15	the	the	DT
18637	2755	16	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	2755	17	area	area	NN
18637	2755	18	of	of	IN
18637	2755	19	State	state	NN
18637	2755	20	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2755	21	activity	activity	NN
18637	2755	22	.	.	.
18637	2756	1	There	there	EX
18637	2756	2	are	be	VBP
18637	2756	3	.	.	.
18637	2757	1	And	and	CC
18637	2757	2	none	none	NN
18637	2757	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	2757	4	more	more	RBR
18637	2757	5	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2757	6	than	than	IN
18637	2757	7	the	the	DT
18637	2757	8	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	2757	9	against	against	IN
18637	2757	10	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	2757	11	on	on	IN
18637	2757	12	the	the	DT
18637	2757	13	part	part	NN
18637	2757	14	of	of	IN
18637	2757	15	any	any	DT
18637	2757	16	single	single	JJ
18637	2757	17	State	State	NNP
18637	2757	18	to	to	TO
18637	2757	19	isolate	isolate	VB
18637	2757	20	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2757	21	from	from	IN
18637	2757	22	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	2757	23	common	common	JJ
18637	2757	24	to	to	IN
18637	2757	25	all	all	DT
18637	2757	26	of	of	IN
18637	2757	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2757	28	by	by	IN
18637	2757	29	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	2757	30	the	the	DT
18637	2757	31	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2757	32	of	of	IN
18637	2757	33	persons	person	NNS
18637	2757	34	and	and	CC
18637	2757	35	property	property	NN
18637	2757	36	across	across	IN
18637	2757	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2757	38	borders	border	NNS
18637	2757	39	.	.	.
18637	2758	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2758	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2758	3	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	2758	4	the	the	DT
18637	2758	5	case	case	NN
18637	2758	6	that	that	IN
18637	2758	7	a	a	DT
18637	2758	8	State	state	NN
18637	2758	9	might	may	MD
18637	2758	10	gain	gain	VB
18637	2758	11	a	a	DT
18637	2758	12	momentary	momentary	JJ
18637	2758	13	respite	respite	NN
18637	2758	14	from	from	IN
18637	2758	15	the	the	DT
18637	2758	16	pressure	pressure	NN
18637	2758	17	of	of	IN
18637	2758	18	events	event	NNS
18637	2758	19	by	by	IN
18637	2758	20	the	the	DT
18637	2758	21	simple	simple	JJ
18637	2758	22	expedient	expedient	NN
18637	2758	23	of	of	IN
18637	2758	24	shutting	shut	VBG
18637	2758	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2758	26	gates	gate	NNS
18637	2758	27	to	to	IN
18637	2758	28	the	the	DT
18637	2758	29	outside	outside	JJ
18637	2758	30	world	world	NN
18637	2758	31	.	.	.
18637	2759	1	But	but	CC
18637	2759	2	,	,	,
18637	2759	3	in	in	IN
18637	2759	4	the	the	DT
18637	2759	5	words	word	NNS
18637	2759	6	of	of	IN
18637	2759	7	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	2759	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2759	9	Cardozo	Cardozo	NNP
18637	2759	10	:	:	:
18637	2759	11	'	'	''
18637	2759	12	The	the	DT
18637	2759	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2759	14	was	be	VBD
18637	2759	15	framed	frame	VBN
18637	2759	16	under	under	IN
18637	2759	17	the	the	DT
18637	2759	18	dominion	dominion	NN
18637	2759	19	of	of	IN
18637	2759	20	a	a	DT
18637	2759	21	political	political	JJ
18637	2759	22	philosophy	philosophy	NN
18637	2759	23	less	less	RBR
18637	2759	24	parochial	parochial	JJ
18637	2759	25	in	in	IN
18637	2759	26	range	range	NN
18637	2759	27	.	.	.
18637	2760	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2760	2	was	be	VBD
18637	2760	3	framed	frame	VBN
18637	2760	4	upon	upon	IN
18637	2760	5	the	the	DT
18637	2760	6	theory	theory	NN
18637	2760	7	that	that	IN
18637	2760	8	the	the	DT
18637	2760	9	peoples	people	NNS
18637	2760	10	of	of	IN
18637	2760	11	the	the	DT
18637	2760	12	several	several	JJ
18637	2760	13	States	state	NNS
18637	2760	14	must	must	MD
18637	2760	15	sink	sink	VB
18637	2760	16	or	or	CC
18637	2760	17	swim	swim	VB
18637	2760	18	together	together	RB
18637	2760	19	,	,	,
18637	2760	20	and	and	CC
18637	2760	21	that	that	IN
18637	2760	22	in	in	IN
18637	2760	23	the	the	DT
18637	2760	24	long	long	JJ
18637	2760	25	run	run	NN
18637	2760	26	prosperity	prosperity	NN
18637	2760	27	and	and	CC
18637	2760	28	salvation	salvation	NN
18637	2760	29	are	be	VBP
18637	2760	30	in	in	IN
18637	2760	31	union	union	NN
18637	2760	32	and	and	CC
18637	2760	33	not	not	RB
18637	2760	34	division	division	NN
18637	2760	35	'	'	''
18637	2760	36	.	.	.
18637	2761	1	"	"	``
18637	2761	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2761	3	955	955	CD
18637	2761	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2761	5	Four	four	CD
18637	2761	6	of	of	IN
18637	2761	7	the	the	DT
18637	2761	8	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	2761	9	would	would	MD
18637	2761	10	have	have	VB
18637	2761	11	preferred	prefer	VBN
18637	2761	12	to	to	TO
18637	2761	13	rest	rest	VB
18637	2761	14	the	the	DT
18637	2761	15	holding	holding	NN
18637	2761	16	of	of	IN
18637	2761	17	unconstitutionality	unconstitutionality	NN
18637	2761	18	on	on	IN
18637	2761	19	the	the	DT
18637	2761	20	rights	right	NNS
18637	2761	21	of	of	IN
18637	2761	22	national	national	JJ
18637	2761	23	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	2761	24	under	under	IN
18637	2761	25	the	the	DT
18637	2761	26	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	2761	27	and	and	CC
18637	2761	28	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	2761	29	clause	clause	NN
18637	2761	30	of	of	IN
18637	2761	31	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	2761	32	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	2761	33	.	.	.
18637	2762	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2762	2	956	956	CD
18637	2762	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2762	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2762	5	CONSERVATION	conservation	NN
18637	2762	6	AND	and	CC
18637	2762	7	EMBARGO	embargo	NN
18637	2762	8	MEASURES	MEASURES	NNP
18637	2762	9	In	in	IN
18637	2762	10	Geer	Geer	NNP
18637	2762	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2762	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	2762	13	_	_	NNP
18637	2762	14	Connecticut[957	Connecticut[957	NNP
18637	2762	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2762	16	the	the	DT
18637	2762	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2762	18	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	2762	19	the	the	DT
18637	2762	20	right	right	NN
18637	2762	21	of	of	IN
18637	2762	22	the	the	DT
18637	2762	23	State	State	NNP
18637	2762	24	to	to	TO
18637	2762	25	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	2762	26	the	the	DT
18637	2762	27	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2762	28	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	2762	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2762	30	borders	border	NNS
18637	2762	31	of	of	IN
18637	2762	32	game	game	NN
18637	2762	33	taken	take	VBN
18637	2762	34	within	within	IN
18637	2762	35	the	the	DT
18637	2762	36	State	state	NN
18637	2762	37	--	--	:
18637	2762	38	this	this	DT
18637	2762	39	on	on	IN
18637	2762	40	the	the	DT
18637	2762	41	ground	ground	NN
18637	2762	42	,	,	,
18637	2762	43	in	in	IN
18637	2762	44	part	part	NN
18637	2762	45	,	,	,
18637	2762	46	that	that	IN
18637	2762	47	a	a	DT
18637	2762	48	State	state	NN
18637	2762	49	has	have	VBZ
18637	2762	50	an	an	DT
18637	2762	51	underlying	underlie	VBG
18637	2762	52	property	property	NN
18637	2762	53	right	right	NN
18637	2762	54	to	to	IN
18637	2762	55	wild	wild	JJ
18637	2762	56	things	thing	NNS
18637	2762	57	found	find	VBN
18637	2762	58	within	within	IN
18637	2762	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2762	60	limits	limit	NNS
18637	2762	61	,	,	,
18637	2762	62	and	and	CC
18637	2762	63	so	so	RB
18637	2762	64	is	be	VBZ
18637	2762	65	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	2762	66	to	to	TO
18637	2762	67	qualify	qualify	VB
18637	2762	68	the	the	DT
18637	2762	69	right	right	NN
18637	2762	70	of	of	IN
18637	2762	71	individual	individual	JJ
18637	2762	72	takers	taker	NNS
18637	2762	73	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	2762	74	to	to	IN
18637	2762	75	any	any	DT
18637	2762	76	extent	extent	NN
18637	2762	77	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2762	78	chooses	choose	VBZ
18637	2762	79	;	;	:
18637	2762	80	and	and	CC
18637	2762	81	a	a	DT
18637	2762	82	similar	similar	JJ
18637	2762	83	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	2762	84	was	be	VBD
18637	2762	85	laid	lay	VBN
18637	2762	86	down	down	RP
18637	2762	87	in	in	IN
18637	2762	88	a	a	DT
18637	2762	89	later	later	JJ
18637	2762	90	case	case	NN
18637	2762	91	as	as	IN
18637	2762	92	to	to	IN
18637	2762	93	the	the	DT
18637	2762	94	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	2762	95	by	by	IN
18637	2762	96	a	a	DT
18637	2762	97	State	state	NN
18637	2762	98	of	of	IN
18637	2762	99	the	the	DT
18637	2762	100	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2762	101	out	out	IN
18637	2762	102	of	of	IN
18637	2762	103	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2762	104	of	of	IN
18637	2762	105	water	water	NN
18637	2762	106	from	from	IN
18637	2762	107	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2762	108	important	important	JJ
18637	2762	109	streams	stream	NNS
18637	2762	110	.	.	.
18637	2763	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2763	2	958	958	CD
18637	2763	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2763	4	In	in	IN
18637	2763	5	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	2763	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2763	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	2763	8	_	_	NNP
18637	2763	9	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	2763	10	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	2763	11	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	2763	12	Co	Co	NNP
18637	2763	13	.	.	.
18637	2763	14	,[959	,[959	,
18637	2763	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2763	16	however	however	RB
18637	2763	17	,	,	,
18637	2763	18	this	this	DT
18637	2763	19	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2763	20	was	be	VBD
18637	2763	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	2763	22	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	2763	23	to	to	IN
18637	2763	24	the	the	DT
18637	2763	25	case	case	NN
18637	2763	26	of	of	IN
18637	2763	27	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2763	28	gas	gas	NN
18637	2763	29	,	,	,
18637	2763	30	on	on	IN
18637	2763	31	the	the	DT
18637	2763	32	ground	ground	NN
18637	2763	33	:	:	:
18637	2763	34	first	first	RB
18637	2763	35	,	,	,
18637	2763	36	that	that	IN
18637	2763	37	"	"	``
18637	2763	38	gas	gas	NN
18637	2763	39	,	,	,
18637	2763	40	when	when	WRB
18637	2763	41	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	2763	42	to	to	IN
18637	2763	43	possession	possession	NN
18637	2763	44	,	,	,
18637	2763	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	2763	46	a	a	DT
18637	2763	47	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	2763	48	,	,	,
18637	2763	49	the	the	DT
18637	2763	50	individual	individual	JJ
18637	2763	51	property	property	NN
18637	2763	52	"	"	''
18637	2763	53	of	of	IN
18637	2763	54	the	the	DT
18637	2763	55	owner	owner	NN
18637	2763	56	;	;	:
18637	2763	57	and	and	CC
18637	2763	58	secondly	secondly	RB
18637	2763	59	,	,	,
18637	2763	60	that	that	IN
18637	2763	61	"	"	``
18637	2763	62	the	the	DT
18637	2763	63	business	business	NN
18637	2763	64	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	2763	65	of	of	IN
18637	2763	66	the	the	DT
18637	2763	67	State	State	NNP
18637	2763	68	,	,	,
18637	2763	69	"	"	''
18637	2763	70	is	be	VBZ
18637	2763	71	subordinated	subordinate	VBN
18637	2763	72	by	by	IN
18637	2763	73	the	the	DT
18637	2763	74	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2763	75	clause	clause	NN
18637	2763	76	to	to	IN
18637	2763	77	that	that	DT
18637	2763	78	of	of	IN
18637	2763	79	the	the	DT
18637	2763	80	nation	nation	NN
18637	2763	81	as	as	IN
18637	2763	82	a	a	DT
18637	2763	83	whole	whole	NN
18637	2763	84	.	.	.
18637	2764	1	If	if	IN
18637	2764	2	the	the	DT
18637	2764	3	States	States	NNPS
18637	2764	4	had	have	VBD
18637	2764	5	the	the	DT
18637	2764	6	power	power	NN
18637	2764	7	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	2764	8	in	in	IN
18637	2764	9	the	the	DT
18637	2764	10	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	2764	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	2764	12	,	,	,
18637	2764	13	said	say	VBD
18637	2764	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2764	15	McKenna	McKenna	NNP
18637	2764	16	,	,	,
18637	2764	17	"	"	''
18637	2764	18	a	a	DT
18637	2764	19	singular	singular	JJ
18637	2764	20	situation	situation	NN
18637	2764	21	might	may	MD
18637	2764	22	result	result	VB
18637	2764	23	.	.	.
18637	2765	1	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2765	2	might	may	MD
18637	2765	3	keep	keep	VB
18637	2765	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2765	5	coal	coal	NN
18637	2765	6	,	,	,
18637	2765	7	the	the	DT
18637	2765	8	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	2765	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2765	10	timber	timber	NN
18637	2765	11	,	,	,
18637	2765	12	the	the	DT
18637	2765	13	mining	mining	NN
18637	2765	14	States	state	VBZ
18637	2765	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2765	16	minerals	mineral	NNS
18637	2765	17	.	.	.
18637	2766	1	And	and	CC
18637	2766	2	why	why	WRB
18637	2766	3	may	may	MD
18637	2766	4	not	not	RB
18637	2766	5	the	the	DT
18637	2766	6	products	product	NNS
18637	2766	7	of	of	IN
18637	2766	8	the	the	DT
18637	2766	9	field	field	NN
18637	2766	10	be	be	VB
18637	2766	11	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2766	12	within	within	IN
18637	2766	13	the	the	DT
18637	2766	14	principle	principle	NN
18637	2766	15	?	?	.
18637	2767	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2767	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2767	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2767	4	And	and	CC
18637	2767	5	yet	yet	RB
18637	2767	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2767	7	have	have	VBP
18637	2767	8	said	say	VBN
18637	2767	9	that	that	IN
18637	2767	10	'	'	``
18637	2767	11	in	in	IN
18637	2767	12	matters	matter	NNS
18637	2767	13	of	of	IN
18637	2767	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2767	15	and	and	CC
18637	2767	16	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2767	17	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2767	18	there	there	EX
18637	2767	19	are	be	VBP
18637	2767	20	no	no	DT
18637	2767	21	State	state	NN
18637	2767	22	lines	line	NNS
18637	2767	23	.	.	.
18637	2767	24	'	'	''
18637	2768	1	In	in	IN
18637	2768	2	such	such	JJ
18637	2768	3	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2768	4	,	,	,
18637	2768	5	instead	instead	RB
18637	2768	6	of	of	IN
18637	2768	7	the	the	DT
18637	2768	8	States	States	NNP
18637	2768	9	,	,	,
18637	2768	10	a	a	DT
18637	2768	11	new	new	JJ
18637	2768	12	power	power	NN
18637	2768	13	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	2768	14	and	and	CC
18637	2768	15	a	a	DT
18637	2768	16	new	new	JJ
18637	2768	17	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	2768	18	,	,	,
18637	2768	19	a	a	DT
18637	2768	20	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	2768	21	which	which	WDT
18637	2768	22	transcends	transcend	VBZ
18637	2768	23	that	that	DT
18637	2768	24	of	of	IN
18637	2768	25	any	any	DT
18637	2768	26	State	State	NNP
18637	2768	27	.	.	.
18637	2769	1	But	but	CC
18637	2769	2	rather	rather	RB
18637	2769	3	let	let	VB
18637	2769	4	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2769	5	say	say	VB
18637	2769	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2769	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	2769	8	constituted	constituted	JJ
18637	2769	9	of	of	IN
18637	2769	10	the	the	DT
18637	2769	11	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	2769	12	of	of	IN
18637	2769	13	all	all	PDT
18637	2769	14	the	the	DT
18637	2769	15	States	States	NNPS
18637	2769	16	and	and	CC
18637	2769	17	that	that	DT
18637	2769	18	of	of	IN
18637	2769	19	each	each	DT
18637	2769	20	State	State	NNP
18637	2769	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	2769	22	made	make	VBN
18637	2769	23	greater	great	JJR
18637	2769	24	by	by	IN
18637	2769	25	a	a	DT
18637	2769	26	division	division	NN
18637	2769	27	of	of	IN
18637	2769	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2769	29	resources	resource	NNS
18637	2769	30	,	,	,
18637	2769	31	*	*	NFP
18637	2769	32	*	*	NFP
18637	2769	33	*	*	NFP
18637	2769	34	,	,	,
18637	2769	35	with	with	IN
18637	2769	36	every	every	DT
18637	2769	37	other	other	JJ
18637	2769	38	State	State	NNP
18637	2769	39	,	,	,
18637	2769	40	and	and	CC
18637	2769	41	those	those	DT
18637	2769	42	of	of	IN
18637	2769	43	every	every	DT
18637	2769	44	other	other	JJ
18637	2769	45	State	State	NNP
18637	2769	46	with	with	IN
18637	2769	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2769	48	.	.	.
18637	2770	1	This	this	DT
18637	2770	2	was	be	VBD
18637	2770	3	the	the	DT
18637	2770	4	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2770	5	,	,	,
18637	2770	6	as	as	IN
18637	2770	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2770	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	2770	9	the	the	DT
18637	2770	10	result	result	NN
18637	2770	11	,	,	,
18637	2770	12	of	of	IN
18637	2770	13	the	the	DT
18637	2770	14	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2770	15	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2770	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	2770	17	of	of	IN
18637	2770	18	the	the	DT
18637	2770	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2770	20	of	of	IN
18637	2770	21	the	the	DT
18637	2770	22	United	United	NNP
18637	2770	23	States	States	NNP
18637	2770	24	.	.	.
18637	2771	1	"	"	``
18637	2771	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2771	3	960	960	CD
18637	2771	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2771	5	In	in	IN
18637	2771	6	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2771	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2771	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	2771	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2771	10	West	West	NNP
18637	2771	11	Virginia[961	Virginia[961	NNP
18637	2771	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2771	13	the	the	DT
18637	2771	14	same	same	JJ
18637	2771	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2771	16	was	be	VBD
18637	2771	17	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	2771	18	in	in	IN
18637	2771	19	disallowance	disallowance	NN
18637	2771	20	of	of	IN
18637	2771	21	a	a	DT
18637	2771	22	West	West	NNP
18637	2771	23	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	2771	24	statute	statute	NN
18637	2771	25	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	2771	26	that	that	IN
18637	2771	27	State	state	NN
18637	2771	28	sought	seek	VBD
18637	2771	29	to	to	TO
18637	2771	30	require	require	VB
18637	2771	31	that	that	IN
18637	2771	32	a	a	DT
18637	2771	33	preference	preference	NN
18637	2771	34	be	be	VB
18637	2771	35	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	2771	36	local	local	JJ
18637	2771	37	consumers	consumer	NNS
18637	2771	38	of	of	IN
18637	2771	39	gas	gas	NN
18637	2771	40	produced	produce	VBN
18637	2771	41	within	within	IN
18637	2771	42	the	the	DT
18637	2771	43	State	State	NNP
18637	2771	44	.	.	.
18637	2772	1	West	West	NNP
18637	2772	2	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	2772	3	's	's	POS
18637	2772	4	argument	argument	NN
18637	2772	5	that	that	IN
18637	2772	6	the	the	DT
18637	2772	7	supply	supply	NN
18637	2772	8	of	of	IN
18637	2772	9	gas	gas	NN
18637	2772	10	within	within	IN
18637	2772	11	the	the	DT
18637	2772	12	State	state	NN
18637	2772	13	was	be	VBD
18637	2772	14	waning	wane	VBG
18637	2772	15	and	and	CC
18637	2772	16	no	no	RB
18637	2772	17	longer	longer	RB
18637	2772	18	sufficed	suffice	VBD
18637	2772	19	for	for	IN
18637	2772	20	both	both	CC
18637	2772	21	the	the	DT
18637	2772	22	local	local	JJ
18637	2772	23	and	and	CC
18637	2772	24	the	the	DT
18637	2772	25	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2772	26	markets	market	NNS
18637	2772	27	,	,	,
18637	2772	28	and	and	CC
18637	2772	29	that	that	IN
18637	2772	30	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	2772	31	the	the	DT
18637	2772	32	statute	statute	NN
18637	2772	33	was	be	VBD
18637	2772	34	a	a	DT
18637	2772	35	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	2772	36	measure	measure	NN
18637	2772	37	of	of	IN
18637	2772	38	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	2772	39	in	in	IN
18637	2772	40	the	the	DT
18637	2772	41	interest	interest	NN
18637	2772	42	of	of	IN
18637	2772	43	the	the	DT
18637	2772	44	people	people	NNS
18637	2772	45	of	of	IN
18637	2772	46	the	the	DT
18637	2772	47	State	State	NNP
18637	2772	48	,	,	,
18637	2772	49	was	be	VBD
18637	2772	50	answered	answer	VBN
18637	2772	51	in	in	IN
18637	2772	52	the	the	DT
18637	2772	53	words	word	NNS
18637	2772	54	just	just	RB
18637	2772	55	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	2772	56	.	.	.
18637	2773	1	In	in	IN
18637	2773	2	the	the	DT
18637	2773	3	above	above	JJ
18637	2773	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	2773	5	the	the	DT
18637	2773	6	State	State	NNP
18637	2773	7	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	2773	8	overturned	overturn	VBD
18637	2773	9	was	be	VBD
18637	2773	10	directed	direct	VBN
18637	2773	11	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	2773	12	to	to	IN
18637	2773	13	shipments	shipment	NNS
18637	2773	14	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	2773	15	the	the	DT
18637	2773	16	State	State	NNP
18637	2773	17	.	.	.
18637	2774	1	In	in	IN
18637	2774	2	two	two	CD
18637	2774	3	other	other	JJ
18637	2774	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	2774	5	the	the	DT
18637	2774	6	State	state	NN
18637	2774	7	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	2774	8	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2774	9	reached	reach	VBD
18637	2774	10	all	all	DT
18637	2774	11	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2774	12	,	,	,
18637	2774	13	both	both	CC
18637	2774	14	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	2774	15	and	and	CC
18637	2774	16	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2774	17	without	without	IN
18637	2774	18	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	2774	19	.	.	.
18637	2775	1	In	in	IN
18637	2775	2	the	the	DT
18637	2775	3	first	first	JJ
18637	2775	4	of	of	IN
18637	2775	5	these	these	DT
18637	2775	6	,	,	,
18637	2775	7	Sligh	Sligh	NNP
18637	2775	8	_	_	NNP
18637	2775	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	2775	10	_	_	NNP
18637	2775	11	Kirkwood,[962	Kirkwood,[962	NNP
18637	2775	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2775	13	the	the	DT
18637	2775	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2775	15	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	2775	16	the	the	DT
18637	2775	17	application	application	NN
18637	2775	18	to	to	IN
18637	2775	19	oranges	orange	NNS
18637	2775	20	which	which	WDT
18637	2775	21	were	be	VBD
18637	2775	22	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2775	23	for	for	IN
18637	2775	24	the	the	DT
18637	2775	25	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2775	26	market	market	NN
18637	2775	27	of	of	IN
18637	2775	28	a	a	DT
18637	2775	29	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	2775	30	statute	statute	NN
18637	2775	31	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	2775	32	the	the	DT
18637	2775	33	sale	sale	NN
18637	2775	34	,	,	,
18637	2775	35	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2775	36	,	,	,
18637	2775	37	or	or	CC
18637	2775	38	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	2775	39	for	for	IN
18637	2775	40	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2775	41	of	of	IN
18637	2775	42	any	any	DT
18637	2775	43	citrus	citrus	NN
18637	2775	44	fruits	fruit	NNS
18637	2775	45	which	which	WDT
18637	2775	46	were	be	VBD
18637	2775	47	immature	immature	JJ
18637	2775	48	or	or	CC
18637	2775	49	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2775	50	unfit	unfit	JJ
18637	2775	51	for	for	IN
18637	2775	52	consumption	consumption	NN
18637	2775	53	.	.	.
18637	2776	1	The	the	DT
18637	2776	2	burden	burden	NN
18637	2776	3	thus	thus	RB
18637	2776	4	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2776	5	upon	upon	IN
18637	2776	6	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2776	7	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2776	8	was	be	VBD
18637	2776	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	2776	10	by	by	IN
18637	2776	11	the	the	DT
18637	2776	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2776	13	to	to	TO
18637	2776	14	be	be	VB
18637	2776	15	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	2776	16	merely	merely	RB
18637	2776	17	to	to	IN
18637	2776	18	the	the	DT
18637	2776	19	effective	effective	JJ
18637	2776	20	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	2776	21	of	of	IN
18637	2776	22	a	a	DT
18637	2776	23	measure	measure	NN
18637	2776	24	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2776	25	to	to	TO
18637	2776	26	safeguard	safeguard	VB
18637	2776	27	the	the	DT
18637	2776	28	health	health	NN
18637	2776	29	of	of	IN
18637	2776	30	the	the	DT
18637	2776	31	people	people	NNS
18637	2776	32	of	of	IN
18637	2776	33	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	2776	34	.	.	.
18637	2777	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	2777	2	,	,	,
18637	2777	3	said	say	VBD
18637	2777	4	the	the	DT
18637	2777	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2777	6	,	,	,
18637	2777	7	"	"	``
18637	2777	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2777	9	may	may	MD
18637	2777	10	take	take	VB
18637	2777	11	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	2777	12	notice	notice	NN
18637	2777	13	of	of	IN
18637	2777	14	the	the	DT
18637	2777	15	fact	fact	NN
18637	2777	16	that	that	IN
18637	2777	17	the	the	DT
18637	2777	18	raising	raising	NN
18637	2777	19	of	of	IN
18637	2777	20	citrus	citrus	JJ
18637	2777	21	fruits	fruit	NNS
18637	2777	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	2777	23	one	one	CD
18637	2777	24	of	of	IN
18637	2777	25	the	the	DT
18637	2777	26	great	great	JJ
18637	2777	27	industries	industry	NNS
18637	2777	28	of	of	IN
18637	2777	29	the	the	DT
18637	2777	30	State	State	NNP
18637	2777	31	of	of	IN
18637	2777	32	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	2777	33	.	.	.
18637	2778	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2778	2	was	be	VBD
18637	2778	3	competent	competent	JJ
18637	2778	4	for	for	IN
18637	2778	5	the	the	DT
18637	2778	6	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	2778	7	to	to	TO
18637	2778	8	find	find	VB
18637	2778	9	that	that	IN
18637	2778	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2778	11	was	be	VBD
18637	2778	12	essential	essential	JJ
18637	2778	13	for	for	IN
18637	2778	14	the	the	DT
18637	2778	15	success	success	NN
18637	2778	16	of	of	IN
18637	2778	17	that	that	DT
18637	2778	18	industry	industry	NN
18637	2778	19	that	that	IN
18637	2778	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2778	21	reputation	reputation	NN
18637	2778	22	be	be	VB
18637	2778	23	preserved	preserve	VBN
18637	2778	24	in	in	IN
18637	2778	25	other	other	JJ
18637	2778	26	States	States	NNP
18637	2778	27	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	2778	28	such	such	JJ
18637	2778	29	fruits	fruit	NNS
18637	2778	30	find	find	VBP
18637	2778	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2778	32	most	most	RBS
18637	2778	33	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	2778	34	market	market	NN
18637	2778	35	.	.	.
18637	2779	1	"	"	``
18637	2779	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2779	3	963	963	CD
18637	2779	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2779	5	In	in	IN
18637	2779	6	Lemke	Lemke	NNP
18637	2779	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2779	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	2779	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2779	10	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	2779	11	Grain	Grain	NNP
18637	2779	12	Co	Co	NNP
18637	2779	13	.	.	.
18637	2779	14	,[964	,[964	NFP
18637	2779	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2779	16	on	on	IN
18637	2779	17	the	the	DT
18637	2779	18	other	other	JJ
18637	2779	19	hand	hand	NN
18637	2779	20	,	,	,
18637	2779	21	a	a	DT
18637	2779	22	North	North	NNP
18637	2779	23	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	2779	24	statute	statute	NN
18637	2779	25	which	which	WDT
18637	2779	26	confined	confine	VBD
18637	2779	27	the	the	DT
18637	2779	28	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	2779	29	of	of	IN
18637	2779	30	grain	grain	NN
18637	2779	31	within	within	IN
18637	2779	32	that	that	DT
18637	2779	33	State	state	NN
18637	2779	34	to	to	IN
18637	2779	35	those	those	DT
18637	2779	36	holding	hold	VBG
18637	2779	37	licenses	license	NNS
18637	2779	38	from	from	IN
18637	2779	39	the	the	DT
18637	2779	40	State	State	NNP
18637	2779	41	and	and	CC
18637	2779	42	which	which	WDT
18637	2779	43	regulated	regulate	VBD
18637	2779	44	prices	price	NNS
18637	2779	45	,	,	,
18637	2779	46	was	be	VBD
18637	2779	47	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
18637	2779	48	void	void	JJ
18637	2779	49	under	under	IN
18637	2779	50	the	the	DT
18637	2779	51	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2779	52	clause	clause	NN
18637	2779	53	.	.	.
18637	2780	1	To	to	IN
18637	2780	2	the	the	DT
18637	2780	3	argument	argument	NN
18637	2780	4	that	that	IN
18637	2780	5	such	such	JJ
18637	2780	6	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2780	7	was	be	VBD
18637	2780	8	"	"	``
18637	2780	9	in	in	IN
18637	2780	10	the	the	DT
18637	2780	11	interest	interest	NN
18637	2780	12	of	of	IN
18637	2780	13	the	the	DT
18637	2780	14	grain	grain	NN
18637	2780	15	growers	grower	NNS
18637	2780	16	and	and	CC
18637	2780	17	essential	essential	JJ
18637	2780	18	to	to	TO
18637	2780	19	protect	protect	VB
18637	2780	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2780	21	from	from	IN
18637	2780	22	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	2780	23	purchases	purchase	NNS
18637	2780	24	,	,	,
18637	2780	25	and	and	CC
18637	2780	26	to	to	TO
18637	2780	27	secure	secure	VB
18637	2780	28	payment	payment	NN
18637	2780	29	to	to	IN
18637	2780	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2780	31	of	of	IN
18637	2780	32	fair	fair	JJ
18637	2780	33	prices	price	NNS
18637	2780	34	for	for	IN
18637	2780	35	the	the	DT
18637	2780	36	grain	grain	NN
18637	2780	37	actually	actually	RB
18637	2780	38	sold	sell	VBN
18637	2780	39	,	,	,
18637	2780	40	"	"	''
18637	2780	41	the	the	DT
18637	2780	42	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2780	43	answered	answer	VBD
18637	2780	44	that	that	IN
18637	2780	45	,	,	,
18637	2780	46	"	"	``
18637	2780	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2780	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	2780	49	amply	amply	RB
18637	2780	50	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	2780	51	to	to	TO
18637	2780	52	pass	pass	VB
18637	2780	53	measures	measure	NNS
18637	2780	54	to	to	TO
18637	2780	55	protect	protect	VB
18637	2780	56	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2780	57	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2780	58	if	if	IN
18637	2780	59	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2780	60	of	of	IN
18637	2780	61	that	that	DT
18637	2780	62	character	character	NN
18637	2780	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	2780	64	needed	need	VBN
18637	2780	65	.	.	.
18637	2780	66	"	"	''
18637	2781	1	The	the	DT
18637	2781	2	differentiation	differentiation	NN
18637	2781	3	of	of	IN
18637	2781	4	the	the	DT
18637	2781	5	above	above	JJ
18637	2781	6	two	two	CD
18637	2781	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	2781	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	2781	9	twofold	twofold	JJ
18637	2781	10	.	.	.
18637	2782	1	The	the	DT
18637	2782	2	statute	statute	NN
18637	2782	3	under	under	IN
18637	2782	4	review	review	NN
18637	2782	5	in	in	IN
18637	2782	6	the	the	DT
18637	2782	7	earlier	early	JJR
18637	2782	8	one	one	CD
18637	2782	9	was	be	VBD
18637	2782	10	of	of	IN
18637	2782	11	the	the	DT
18637	2782	12	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	2782	13	type	type	NN
18637	2782	14	of	of	IN
18637	2782	15	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	2782	16	law	law	NN
18637	2782	17	and	and	CC
18637	2782	18	was	be	VBD
18637	2782	19	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2782	20	without	without	IN
18637	2782	21	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	2782	22	to	to	TO
18637	2782	23	fruits	fruit	NNS
18637	2782	24	designed	design	VBN
18637	2782	25	for	for	IN
18637	2782	26	the	the	DT
18637	2782	27	home	home	NN
18637	2782	28	and	and	CC
18637	2782	29	the	the	DT
18637	2782	30	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2782	31	market	market	NN
18637	2782	32	.	.	.
18637	2783	1	The	the	DT
18637	2783	2	North	North	NNP
18637	2783	3	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	2783	4	act	act	NN
18637	2783	5	was	be	VBD
18637	2783	6	far	far	RB
18637	2783	7	more	more	RBR
18637	2783	8	drastic	drastic	JJ
18637	2783	9	,	,	,
18637	2783	10	approximating	approximate	VBG
18637	2783	11	an	an	DT
18637	2783	12	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	2783	13	on	on	IN
18637	2783	14	the	the	DT
18637	2783	15	part	part	NN
18637	2783	16	of	of	IN
18637	2783	17	the	the	DT
18637	2783	18	State	State	NNP
18637	2783	19	to	to	TO
18637	2783	20	license	license	VB
18637	2783	21	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2783	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2783	23	.	.	.
18637	2784	1	What	what	WP
18637	2784	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2784	3	even	even	RB
18637	2784	4	more	more	RBR
18637	2784	5	important	important	JJ
18637	2784	6	,	,	,
18637	2784	7	however	however	RB
18637	2784	8	,	,	,
18637	2784	9	the	the	DT
18637	2784	10	later	later	JJ
18637	2784	11	case	case	NN
18637	2784	12	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	2784	13	a	a	DT
18637	2784	14	new	new	JJ
18637	2784	15	rule	rule	NN
18637	2784	16	of	of	IN
18637	2784	17	law	law	NN
18637	2784	18	,	,	,
18637	2784	19	and	and	CC
18637	2784	20	one	one	CD
18637	2784	21	which	which	WDT
18637	2784	22	at	at	IN
18637	2784	23	the	the	DT
18637	2784	24	time	time	NN
18637	2784	25	the	the	DT
18637	2784	26	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	2784	27	act	act	NN
18637	2784	28	was	be	VBD
18637	2784	29	before	before	IN
18637	2784	30	the	the	DT
18637	2784	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2784	32	had	have	VBD
18637	2784	33	not	not	RB
18637	2784	34	yet	yet	RB
18637	2784	35	been	be	VBN
18637	2784	36	heard	hear	VBN
18637	2784	37	of	of	IN
18637	2784	38	.	.	.
18637	2785	1	This	this	DT
18637	2785	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2785	3	embodied	embody	VBN
18637	2785	4	in	in	IN
18637	2785	5	the	the	DT
18637	2785	6	head	head	NN
18637	2785	7	note	note	NN
18637	2785	8	of	of	IN
18637	2785	9	the	the	DT
18637	2785	10	case	case	NN
18637	2785	11	in	in	IN
18637	2785	12	the	the	DT
18637	2785	13	following	follow	VBG
18637	2785	14	words	word	NNS
18637	2785	15	:	:	:
18637	2785	16	"	"	``
18637	2785	17	The	the	DT
18637	2785	18	business	business	NN
18637	2785	19	of	of	IN
18637	2785	20	buying	buy	VBG
18637	2785	21	grain	grain	NN
18637	2785	22	in	in	IN
18637	2785	23	North	North	NNP
18637	2785	24	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	2785	25	,	,	,
18637	2785	26	practically	practically	RB
18637	2785	27	all	all	DT
18637	2785	28	of	of	IN
18637	2785	29	which	which	WDT
18637	2785	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	2785	31	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2785	32	for	for	IN
18637	2785	33	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2785	34	to	to	IN
18637	2785	35	,	,	,
18637	2785	36	and	and	CC
18637	2785	37	sale	sale	NN
18637	2785	38	at	at	IN
18637	2785	39	,	,	,
18637	2785	40	terminal	terminal	JJ
18637	2785	41	markets	market	NNS
18637	2785	42	in	in	IN
18637	2785	43	other	other	JJ
18637	2785	44	States	States	NNP
18637	2785	45	,	,	,
18637	2785	46	conformably	conformably	RB
18637	2785	47	to	to	IN
18637	2785	48	the	the	DT
18637	2785	49	usual	usual	JJ
18637	2785	50	and	and	CC
18637	2785	51	general	general	JJ
18637	2785	52	course	course	NN
18637	2785	53	of	of	IN
18637	2785	54	business	business	NN
18637	2785	55	in	in	IN
18637	2785	56	the	the	DT
18637	2785	57	grain	grain	NN
18637	2785	58	trade	trade	NN
18637	2785	59	,	,	,
18637	2785	60	is	be	VBZ
18637	2785	61	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2785	62	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2785	63	.	.	.
18637	2786	1	"	"	``
18637	2786	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2786	3	965	965	CD
18637	2786	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2786	5	The	the	DT
18637	2786	6	application	application	NN
18637	2786	7	of	of	IN
18637	2786	8	this	this	DT
18637	2786	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	2786	10	in	in	IN
18637	2786	11	the	the	DT
18637	2786	12	field	field	NN
18637	2786	13	of	of	IN
18637	2786	14	state	state	NN
18637	2786	15	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	2786	16	was	be	VBD
18637	2786	17	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	2786	18	on	on	IN
18637	2786	19	a	a	DT
18637	2786	20	previous	previous	JJ
18637	2786	21	page	page	NN
18637	2786	22	.	.	.
18637	2787	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2787	2	966	966	CD
18637	2787	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2787	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2787	5	CONSERVATION	conservation	NN
18637	2787	6	AND	and	CC
18637	2787	7	EMBARGO	EMBARGO	NNP
18637	2787	8	MEASURES	MEASURES	NNP
18637	2787	9	:	:	:
18637	2787	10	THE	the	DT
18637	2787	11	MILK	milk	NN
18637	2787	12	CASES	case	NNS
18637	2787	13	Certain	certain	JJ
18637	2787	14	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2787	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	2787	16	have	have	VBP
18637	2787	17	had	have	VBN
18637	2787	18	to	to	TO
18637	2787	19	deal	deal	VB
18637	2787	20	with	with	IN
18637	2787	21	State	State	NNP
18637	2787	22	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2787	23	of	of	IN
18637	2787	24	the	the	DT
18637	2787	25	milk	milk	NN
18637	2787	26	business	business	NN
18637	2787	27	.	.	.
18637	2788	1	In	in	IN
18637	2788	2	Nebbia	Nebbia	NNP
18637	2788	3	_	_	NNP
18637	2788	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	2788	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2788	6	New	New	NNP
18637	2788	7	York,[967	York,[967	NNP
18637	2788	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2788	9	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2788	10	in	in	IN
18637	2788	11	1934	1934	CD
18637	2788	12	,	,	,
18637	2788	13	that	that	IN
18637	2788	14	State	State	NNP
18637	2788	15	's	's	POS
18637	2788	16	law	law	NN
18637	2788	17	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	2788	18	the	the	DT
18637	2788	19	price	price	NN
18637	2788	20	of	of	IN
18637	2788	21	milk	milk	NN
18637	2788	22	was	be	VBD
18637	2788	23	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2788	24	by	by	IN
18637	2788	25	the	the	DT
18637	2788	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2788	27	against	against	IN
18637	2788	28	objections	objection	NNS
18637	2788	29	based	base	VBN
18637	2788	30	on	on	IN
18637	2788	31	the	the	DT
18637	2788	32	due	due	JJ
18637	2788	33	process	process	NN
18637	2788	34	clause	clause	NN
18637	2788	35	of	of	IN
18637	2788	36	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	2788	37	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	2788	38	.	.	.
18637	2789	1	A	a	DT
18637	2789	2	year	year	NN
18637	2789	3	later	later	RB
18637	2789	4	,	,	,
18637	2789	5	in	in	IN
18637	2789	6	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	2789	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2789	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	2789	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2789	10	Seelig[968	Seelig[968	NNP
18637	2789	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2789	12	the	the	DT
18637	2789	13	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	2789	14	of	of	IN
18637	2789	15	a	a	DT
18637	2789	16	license	license	NN
18637	2789	17	under	under	IN
18637	2789	18	the	the	DT
18637	2789	19	same	same	JJ
18637	2789	20	act	act	NN
18637	2789	21	to	to	IN
18637	2789	22	a	a	DT
18637	2789	23	dealer	dealer	NN
18637	2789	24	who	who	WP
18637	2789	25	had	have	VBD
18637	2789	26	procured	procure	VBN
18637	2789	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2789	28	milk	milk	NN
18637	2789	29	at	at	IN
18637	2789	30	a	a	DT
18637	2789	31	lower	low	JJR
18637	2789	32	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	2789	33	price	price	NN
18637	2789	34	than	than	IN
18637	2789	35	producers	producer	NNS
18637	2789	36	were	be	VBD
18637	2789	37	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	2789	38	in	in	IN
18637	2789	39	New	New	NNP
18637	2789	40	York	York	NNP
18637	2789	41	,	,	,
18637	2789	42	was	be	VBD
18637	2789	43	set	set	VBN
18637	2789	44	aside	aside	RB
18637	2789	45	as	as	IN
18637	2789	46	an	an	DT
18637	2789	47	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2789	48	interference	interference	NN
18637	2789	49	with	with	IN
18637	2789	50	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2789	51	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2789	52	.	.	.
18637	2790	1	However	however	RB
18637	2790	2	,	,	,
18637	2790	3	a	a	DT
18637	2790	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2790	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	2790	6	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2790	7	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	2790	8	to	to	TO
18637	2790	9	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	2790	10	licenses	license	NNS
18637	2790	11	was	be	VBD
18637	2790	12	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2790	13	as	as	IN
18637	2790	14	to	to	IN
18637	2790	15	one	one	CD
18637	2790	16	who	who	WP
18637	2790	17	procured	procure	VBD
18637	2790	18	milk	milk	NN
18637	2790	19	from	from	IN
18637	2790	20	neighboring	neighbor	VBG
18637	2790	21	farms	farm	NNS
18637	2790	22	and	and	CC
18637	2790	23	shipped	ship	VBD
18637	2790	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2790	25	all	all	DT
18637	2790	26	into	into	IN
18637	2790	27	a	a	DT
18637	2790	28	neighboring	neighbor	VBG
18637	2790	29	State	State	NNP
18637	2790	30	for	for	IN
18637	2790	31	sale	sale	NN
18637	2790	32	.	.	.
18637	2791	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2791	2	969	969	CD
18637	2791	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2791	4	The	the	DT
18637	2791	5	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2791	6	of	of	IN
18637	2791	7	the	the	DT
18637	2791	8	act	act	NN
18637	2791	9	,	,	,
18637	2791	10	explained	explain	VBD
18637	2791	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2791	12	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	2791	13	,	,	,
18637	2791	14	was	be	VBD
18637	2791	15	to	to	TO
18637	2791	16	control	control	VB
18637	2791	17	"	"	``
18637	2791	18	a	a	DT
18637	2791	19	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	2791	20	situation	situation	NN
18637	2791	21	in	in	IN
18637	2791	22	the	the	DT
18637	2791	23	interest	interest	NN
18637	2791	24	of	of	IN
18637	2791	25	the	the	DT
18637	2791	26	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	2791	27	of	of	IN
18637	2791	28	the	the	DT
18637	2791	29	producers	producer	NNS
18637	2791	30	and	and	CC
18637	2791	31	consumers	consumer	NNS
18637	2791	32	,	,	,
18637	2791	33	"	"	''
18637	2791	34	and	and	CC
18637	2791	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2791	36	application	application	NN
18637	2791	37	to	to	IN
18637	2791	38	the	the	DT
18637	2791	39	kind	kind	NN
18637	2791	40	of	of	IN
18637	2791	41	case	case	NN
18637	2791	42	before	before	IN
18637	2791	43	the	the	DT
18637	2791	44	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2791	45	was	be	VBD
18637	2791	46	essential	essential	JJ
18637	2791	47	to	to	IN
18637	2791	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2791	49	effective	effective	JJ
18637	2791	50	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	2791	51	and	and	CC
18637	2791	52	affected	affect	VBN
18637	2791	53	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2791	54	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2791	55	only	only	RB
18637	2791	56	incidentally	incidentally	RB
18637	2791	57	.	.	.
18637	2792	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2792	2	970	970	CD
18637	2792	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2792	4	But	but	CC
18637	2792	5	when	when	WRB
18637	2792	6	a	a	DT
18637	2792	7	distributor	distributor	NN
18637	2792	8	of	of	IN
18637	2792	9	milk	milk	NN
18637	2792	10	in	in	IN
18637	2792	11	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	2792	12	,	,	,
18637	2792	13	who	who	WP
18637	2792	14	already	already	RB
18637	2792	15	had	have	VBD
18637	2792	16	two	two	CD
18637	2792	17	milk	milk	NN
18637	2792	18	stations	station	NNS
18637	2792	19	in	in	IN
18637	2792	20	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	2792	21	New	New	NNP
18637	2792	22	York	York	NNP
18637	2792	23	,	,	,
18637	2792	24	was	be	VBD
18637	2792	25	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	2792	26	a	a	DT
18637	2792	27	license	license	NN
18637	2792	28	for	for	IN
18637	2792	29	a	a	DT
18637	2792	30	third	third	NN
18637	2792	31	on	on	IN
18637	2792	32	the	the	DT
18637	2792	33	ground	ground	NN
18637	2792	34	,	,	,
18637	2792	35	among	among	IN
18637	2792	36	others	other	NNS
18637	2792	37	,	,	,
18637	2792	38	that	that	IN
18637	2792	39	the	the	DT
18637	2792	40	further	further	JJ
18637	2792	41	diversion	diversion	NN
18637	2792	42	of	of	IN
18637	2792	43	milk	milk	NN
18637	2792	44	to	to	IN
18637	2792	45	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	2792	46	would	would	MD
18637	2792	47	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	2792	48	the	the	DT
18637	2792	49	local	local	JJ
18637	2792	50	market	market	NN
18637	2792	51	of	of	IN
18637	2792	52	a	a	DT
18637	2792	53	supply	supply	NN
18637	2792	54	needed	need	VBN
18637	2792	55	during	during	IN
18637	2792	56	the	the	DT
18637	2792	57	short	short	JJ
18637	2792	58	season	season	NN
18637	2792	59	,	,	,
18637	2792	60	a	a	DT
18637	2792	61	narrowly	narrowly	RB
18637	2792	62	divided	divide	VBN
18637	2792	63	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2792	64	interposed	interpose	VBD
18637	2792	65	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2792	66	veto	veto	NN
18637	2792	67	on	on	IN
18637	2792	68	the	the	DT
18637	2792	69	basis	basis	NN
18637	2792	70	of	of	IN
18637	2792	71	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	2792	72	_	_	NNP
18637	2792	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	2792	74	_	_	NNP
18637	2792	75	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	2792	76	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	2792	77	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	2792	78	Co.[971	Co.[971	NNP
18637	2792	79	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2792	80	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2792	81	CONSERVATION	conservation	NN
18637	2792	82	AND	and	CC
18637	2792	83	EMBARGO	EMBARGO	NNP
18637	2792	84	MEASURES	MEASURES	NNP
18637	2792	85	:	:	:
18637	2792	86	THE	the	DT
18637	2792	87	SHRIMP	SHRIMP	NNP
18637	2792	88	CASES	case	NNS
18637	2792	89	Meantime	meantime	RB
18637	2792	90	,	,	,
18637	2792	91	Geer	Geer	NNP
18637	2792	92	_	_	NNP
18637	2792	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	2792	94	_	_	NNP
18637	2792	95	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	2792	96	has	have	VBZ
18637	2792	97	been	be	VBN
18637	2792	98	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	2792	99	overcast	overcast	JJ
18637	2792	100	by	by	IN
18637	2792	101	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	2792	102	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	2792	103	.	.	.
18637	2793	1	In	in	IN
18637	2793	2	a	a	DT
18637	2793	3	case	case	NN
18637	2793	4	,	,	,
18637	2793	5	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2793	6	in	in	IN
18637	2793	7	1928	1928	CD
18637	2793	8	,	,	,
18637	2793	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2793	10	was	be	VBD
18637	2793	11	held	hold	VBN
18637	2793	12	that	that	IN
18637	2793	13	a	a	DT
18637	2793	14	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	2793	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	2793	16	which	which	WDT
18637	2793	17	permitted	permit	VBD
18637	2793	18	the	the	DT
18637	2793	19	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	2793	20	of	of	IN
18637	2793	21	shrimp	shrimp	NN
18637	2793	22	taken	take	VBN
18637	2793	23	in	in	IN
18637	2793	24	the	the	DT
18637	2793	25	tidal	tidal	JJ
18637	2793	26	waters	water	NNS
18637	2793	27	of	of	IN
18637	2793	28	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	2793	29	marshes	marshe	VBZ
18637	2793	30	only	only	RB
18637	2793	31	if	if	IN
18637	2793	32	the	the	DT
18637	2793	33	heads	head	NNS
18637	2793	34	and	and	CC
18637	2793	35	hulls	hull	NNS
18637	2793	36	have	have	VBP
18637	2793	37	been	be	VBN
18637	2793	38	previously	previously	RB
18637	2793	39	removed	remove	VBN
18637	2793	40	was	be	VBD
18637	2793	41	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2793	42	.	.	.
18637	2794	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2794	2	972	972	CD
18637	2794	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2794	4	Distinguishing	Distinguishing	NNP
18637	2794	5	Geer	Geer	NNP
18637	2794	6	_	_	NNP
18637	2794	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	2794	8	_	_	NNP
18637	2794	9	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	2794	10	the	the	DT
18637	2794	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2794	12	said	say	VBD
18637	2794	13	:	:	:
18637	2794	14	"	"	``
18637	2794	15	As	as	IN
18637	2794	16	the	the	DT
18637	2794	17	representative	representative	NN
18637	2794	18	of	of	IN
18637	2794	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2794	20	people	people	NNS
18637	2794	21	,	,	,
18637	2794	22	the	the	DT
18637	2794	23	State	state	NN
18637	2794	24	might	may	MD
18637	2794	25	have	have	VB
18637	2794	26	retained	retain	VBN
18637	2794	27	the	the	DT
18637	2794	28	shrimp	shrimp	NN
18637	2794	29	for	for	IN
18637	2794	30	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2794	31	local	local	JJ
18637	2794	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2794	33	consumption	consumption	NN
18637	2794	34	and	and	CC
18637	2794	35	use	use	VB
18637	2794	36	therein	therein	RB
18637	2794	37	.	.	.
18637	2794	38	"	"	''
18637	2795	1	But	but	CC
18637	2795	2	the	the	DT
18637	2795	3	object	object	NN
18637	2795	4	of	of	IN
18637	2795	5	the	the	DT
18637	2795	6	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	2795	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	2795	8	was	be	VBD
18637	2795	9	in	in	IN
18637	2795	10	direct	direct	JJ
18637	2795	11	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	2795	12	to	to	IN
18637	2795	13	the	the	DT
18637	2795	14	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	2795	15	of	of	IN
18637	2795	16	a	a	DT
18637	2795	17	local	local	JJ
18637	2795	18	food	food	NN
18637	2795	19	supply	supply	NN
18637	2795	20	.	.	.
18637	2796	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2796	2	object	object	NN
18637	2796	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2796	4	to	to	TO
18637	2796	5	favor	favor	VB
18637	2796	6	the	the	DT
18637	2796	7	canning	canning	NN
18637	2796	8	of	of	IN
18637	2796	9	shrimp	shrimp	NN
18637	2796	10	for	for	IN
18637	2796	11	the	the	DT
18637	2796	12	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2796	13	market	market	NN
18637	2796	14	.	.	.
18637	2797	1	"	"	``
18637	2797	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2797	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2797	4	*	*	NFP
18637	2797	5	by	by	IN
18637	2797	6	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	2797	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2797	8	shrimp	shrimp	NN
18637	2797	9	to	to	TO
18637	2797	10	be	be	VB
18637	2797	11	taken	take	VBN
18637	2797	12	and	and	CC
18637	2797	13	all	all	PDT
18637	2797	14	the	the	DT
18637	2797	15	products	product	NNS
18637	2797	16	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	2797	17	to	to	TO
18637	2797	18	be	be	VB
18637	2797	19	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	2797	20	and	and	CC
18637	2797	21	sold	sell	VBN
18637	2797	22	in	in	IN
18637	2797	23	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2797	24	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2797	25	,	,	,
18637	2797	26	the	the	DT
18637	2797	27	State	State	NNP
18637	2797	28	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	2797	29	releases	release	VBZ
18637	2797	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2797	31	hold	hold	NN
18637	2797	32	and	and	CC
18637	2797	33	,	,	,
18637	2797	34	as	as	IN
18637	2797	35	to	to	IN
18637	2797	36	the	the	DT
18637	2797	37	shrimp	shrimp	NN
18637	2797	38	so	so	RB
18637	2797	39	taken	take	VBN
18637	2797	40	,	,	,
18637	2797	41	definitely	definitely	RB
18637	2797	42	terminates	terminate	VBZ
18637	2797	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2797	44	control	control	NN
18637	2797	45	.	.	.
18637	2798	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2798	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2798	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2798	4	And	and	CC
18637	2798	5	those	those	DT
18637	2798	6	taking	take	VBG
18637	2798	7	the	the	DT
18637	2798	8	shrimp	shrimp	NN
18637	2798	9	under	under	IN
18637	2798	10	the	the	DT
18637	2798	11	authority	authority	NN
18637	2798	12	of	of	IN
18637	2798	13	the	the	DT
18637	2798	14	act	act	NN
18637	2798	15	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	2798	16	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	2798	17	become	become	VBN
18637	2798	18	entitled	entitled	JJ
18637	2798	19	to	to	IN
18637	2798	20	the	the	DT
18637	2798	21	rights	right	NNS
18637	2798	22	of	of	IN
18637	2798	23	private	private	JJ
18637	2798	24	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	2798	25	and	and	CC
18637	2798	26	the	the	DT
18637	2798	27	protection	protection	NN
18637	2798	28	of	of	IN
18637	2798	29	the	the	DT
18637	2798	30	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2798	31	clause	clause	NN
18637	2798	32	.	.	.
18637	2799	1	"	"	``
18637	2799	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2799	3	973	973	CD
18637	2799	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2799	5	On	on	IN
18637	2799	6	the	the	DT
18637	2799	7	same	same	JJ
18637	2799	8	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	2799	9	a	a	DT
18637	2799	10	South	South	NNP
18637	2799	11	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	2799	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	2799	13	which	which	WDT
18637	2799	14	required	require	VBD
18637	2799	15	that	that	IN
18637	2799	16	owners	owner	NNS
18637	2799	17	of	of	IN
18637	2799	18	shrimp	shrimp	NN
18637	2799	19	boats	boat	NNS
18637	2799	20	,	,	,
18637	2799	21	fishing	fish	VBG
18637	2799	22	in	in	IN
18637	2799	23	the	the	DT
18637	2799	24	marine	marine	JJ
18637	2799	25	waters	water	NNS
18637	2799	26	off	off	IN
18637	2799	27	the	the	DT
18637	2799	28	coast	coast	NN
18637	2799	29	of	of	IN
18637	2799	30	the	the	DT
18637	2799	31	State	State	NNP
18637	2799	32	,	,	,
18637	2799	33	dock	dock	VBP
18637	2799	34	at	at	IN
18637	2799	35	a	a	DT
18637	2799	36	State	State	NNP
18637	2799	37	port	port	NN
18637	2799	38	and	and	CC
18637	2799	39	unload	unload	NN
18637	2799	40	,	,	,
18637	2799	41	pack	pack	VBP
18637	2799	42	and	and	CC
18637	2799	43	stamp	stamp	VB
18637	2799	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2799	45	catch	catch	NN
18637	2799	46	with	with	IN
18637	2799	47	a	a	DT
18637	2799	48	tax	tax	NN
18637	2799	49	stamp	stamp	NN
18637	2799	50	before	before	IN
18637	2799	51	shipping	ship	VBG
18637	2799	52	or	or	CC
18637	2799	53	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	2799	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2799	55	to	to	IN
18637	2799	56	another	another	DT
18637	2799	57	State	State	NNP
18637	2799	58	,	,	,
18637	2799	59	was	be	VBD
18637	2799	60	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
18637	2799	61	void	void	JJ
18637	2799	62	in	in	IN
18637	2799	63	1948	1948	CD
18637	2799	64	.	.	.
18637	2800	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2800	2	974	974	CD
18637	2800	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2800	4	However	however	RB
18637	2800	5	,	,	,
18637	2800	6	a	a	DT
18637	2800	7	California	California	NNP
18637	2800	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	2800	9	which	which	WDT
18637	2800	10	restricted	restrict	VBD
18637	2800	11	the	the	DT
18637	2800	12	processing	processing	NN
18637	2800	13	of	of	IN
18637	2800	14	fish	fish	NN
18637	2800	15	,	,	,
18637	2800	16	both	both	CC
18637	2800	17	that	that	WDT
18637	2800	18	taken	take	VBD
18637	2800	19	in	in	RP
18637	2800	20	the	the	DT
18637	2800	21	waters	water	NNS
18637	2800	22	of	of	IN
18637	2800	23	the	the	DT
18637	2800	24	State	State	NNP
18637	2800	25	and	and	CC
18637	2800	26	that	that	WDT
18637	2800	27	brought	bring	VBD
18637	2800	28	into	into	IN
18637	2800	29	the	the	DT
18637	2800	30	State	state	NN
18637	2800	31	in	in	IN
18637	2800	32	a	a	DT
18637	2800	33	fresh	fresh	JJ
18637	2800	34	condition	condition	NN
18637	2800	35	,	,	,
18637	2800	36	was	be	VBD
18637	2800	37	found	find	VBN
18637	2800	38	by	by	IN
18637	2800	39	the	the	DT
18637	2800	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2800	41	to	to	TO
18637	2800	42	be	be	VB
18637	2800	43	purely	purely	RB
18637	2800	44	a	a	DT
18637	2800	45	food	food	NN
18637	2800	46	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	2800	47	measure	measure	NN
18637	2800	48	,	,	,
18637	2800	49	and	and	CC
18637	2800	50	hence	hence	RB
18637	2800	51	valid	valid	JJ
18637	2800	52	.	.	.
18637	2801	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2801	2	975	975	CD
18637	2801	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2801	4	The	the	DT
18637	2801	5	application	application	NN
18637	2801	6	of	of	IN
18637	2801	7	the	the	DT
18637	2801	8	act	act	NN
18637	2801	9	to	to	TO
18637	2801	10	fish	fish	NN
18637	2801	11	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2801	12	from	from	IN
18637	2801	13	outside	outside	RB
18637	2801	14	was	be	VBD
18637	2801	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	2801	16	to	to	TO
18637	2801	17	be	be	VB
18637	2801	18	justified	justify	VBN
18637	2801	19	"	"	''
18637	2801	20	by	by	IN
18637	2801	21	rendering	render	VBG
18637	2801	22	evasion	evasion	NN
18637	2801	23	of	of	IN
18637	2801	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2801	25	less	less	RBR
18637	2801	26	easy	easy	JJ
18637	2801	27	.	.	.
18637	2802	1	"	"	``
18637	2802	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2802	3	976	976	CD
18637	2802	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2802	5	Concurrent	Concurrent	NNP
18637	2802	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2802	7	and	and	CC
18637	2802	8	State	State	NNP
18637	2802	9	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
18637	2802	10	THE	the	DT
18637	2802	11	GENERAL	GENERAL	NNP
18637	2802	12	ISSUE	ISSUE	VBD
18637	2802	13	Since	since	IN
18637	2802	14	the	the	DT
18637	2802	15	turn	turn	NN
18637	2802	16	of	of	IN
18637	2802	17	the	the	DT
18637	2802	18	century	century	NN
18637	2802	19	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2802	20	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2802	21	under	under	IN
18637	2802	22	the	the	DT
18637	2802	23	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2802	24	clause	clause	NN
18637	2802	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	2802	26	penetrated	penetrate	VBN
18637	2802	27	more	more	RBR
18637	2802	28	and	and	CC
18637	2802	29	more	more	RBR
18637	2802	30	deeply	deeply	RB
18637	2802	31	into	into	IN
18637	2802	32	areas	area	NNS
18637	2802	33	once	once	IN
18637	2802	34	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	2802	35	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	2802	36	by	by	IN
18637	2802	37	the	the	DT
18637	2802	38	police	police	NN
18637	2802	39	power	power	NN
18637	2802	40	of	of	IN
18637	2802	41	the	the	DT
18637	2802	42	States	States	NNP
18637	2802	43	.	.	.
18637	2803	1	The	the	DT
18637	2803	2	result	result	NN
18637	2803	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	2803	4	been	be	VBN
18637	2803	5	that	that	IN
18637	2803	6	State	State	NNP
18637	2803	7	laws	law	NNS
18637	2803	8	have	have	VBP
18637	2803	9	come	come	VBN
18637	2803	10	under	under	IN
18637	2803	11	increasingly	increasingly	RB
18637	2803	12	frequent	frequent	JJ
18637	2803	13	attack	attack	NN
18637	2803	14	as	as	IN
18637	2803	15	being	be	VBG
18637	2803	16	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
18637	2803	17	with	with	IN
18637	2803	18	acts	act	NNS
18637	2803	19	of	of	IN
18637	2803	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2803	21	operating	operate	VBG
18637	2803	22	in	in	IN
18637	2803	23	the	the	DT
18637	2803	24	same	same	JJ
18637	2803	25	general	general	JJ
18637	2803	26	field	field	NN
18637	2803	27	.	.	.
18637	2804	1	The	the	DT
18637	2804	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2804	3	's	's	POS
18637	2804	4	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	2804	5	resolving	resolve	VBG
18637	2804	6	such	such	JJ
18637	2804	7	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	2804	8	conflicts	conflict	NNS
18637	2804	9	fall	fall	VBP
18637	2804	10	into	into	IN
18637	2804	11	three	three	CD
18637	2804	12	groups	group	NNS
18637	2804	13	:	:	:
18637	2804	14	_	_	NNP
18637	2804	15	first	first	NNP
18637	2804	16	_	_	NNP
18637	2804	17	,	,	,
18637	2804	18	those	those	DT
18637	2804	19	which	which	WDT
18637	2804	20	follow	follow	VBP
18637	2804	21	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	2804	22	's	's	POS
18637	2804	23	theory	theory	NN
18637	2804	24	,	,	,
18637	2804	25	advanced	advanced	JJ
18637	2804	26	in	in	IN
18637	2804	27	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	2804	28	_	_	NNP
18637	2804	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	2804	30	_	_	NNP
18637	2804	31	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	2804	32	,	,	,
18637	2804	33	that	that	IN
18637	2804	34	when	when	WRB
18637	2804	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2804	36	acts	act	VBZ
18637	2804	37	upon	upon	IN
18637	2804	38	a	a	DT
18637	2804	39	particular	particular	JJ
18637	2804	40	phase	phase	NN
18637	2804	41	of	of	IN
18637	2804	42	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2804	43	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2804	44	,	,	,
18637	2804	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2804	46	designs	design	VBZ
18637	2804	47	to	to	TO
18637	2804	48	appropriate	appropriate	VB
18637	2804	49	the	the	DT
18637	2804	50	entire	entire	JJ
18637	2804	51	field	field	NN
18637	2804	52	with	with	IN
18637	2804	53	the	the	DT
18637	2804	54	result	result	NN
18637	2804	55	that	that	IN
18637	2804	56	no	no	DT
18637	2804	57	room	room	NN
18637	2804	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	2804	59	left	leave	VBN
18637	2804	60	for	for	IN
18637	2804	61	supplementary	supplementary	JJ
18637	2804	62	State	State	NNP
18637	2804	63	action	action	NN
18637	2804	64	;	;	:
18637	2804	65	_	_	NNP
18637	2804	66	second	second	JJ
18637	2804	67	_	_	NNP
18637	2804	68	,	,	,
18637	2804	69	those	those	DT
18637	2804	70	in	in	IN
18637	2804	71	which	which	WDT
18637	2804	72	,	,	,
18637	2804	73	in	in	IN
18637	2804	74	the	the	DT
18637	2804	75	absence	absence	NN
18637	2804	76	of	of	IN
18637	2804	77	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	2804	78	between	between	IN
18637	2804	79	specific	specific	JJ
18637	2804	80	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	2804	81	of	of	IN
18637	2804	82	the	the	DT
18637	2804	83	State	State	NNP
18637	2804	84	and	and	CC
18637	2804	85	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2804	86	measures	measure	NNS
18637	2804	87	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2804	88	,	,	,
18637	2804	89	the	the	DT
18637	2804	90	opposite	opposite	JJ
18637	2804	91	result	result	NN
18637	2804	92	is	be	VBZ
18637	2804	93	reached	reach	VBN
18637	2804	94	;	;	:
18637	2804	95	_	_	NNP
18637	2804	96	third	third	JJ
18637	2804	97	_	_	NNP
18637	2804	98	,	,	,
18637	2804	99	those	those	DT
18637	2804	100	in	in	IN
18637	2804	101	which	which	WDT
18637	2804	102	the	the	DT
18637	2804	103	State	State	NNP
18637	2804	104	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2804	105	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2804	106	is	be	VBZ
18637	2804	107	found	find	VBN
18637	2804	108	to	to	TO
18637	2804	109	conflict	conflict	VB
18637	2804	110	with	with	IN
18637	2804	111	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2804	112	acts	act	NNS
18637	2804	113	of	of	IN
18637	2804	114	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2804	115	,	,	,
18637	2804	116	and	and	CC
18637	2804	117	in	in	IN
18637	2804	118	which	which	WDT
18637	2804	119	the	the	DT
18637	2804	120	principle	principle	NN
18637	2804	121	of	of	IN
18637	2804	122	national	national	JJ
18637	2804	123	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	2804	124	is	be	VBZ
18637	2804	125	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	2804	126	by	by	IN
18637	2804	127	the	the	DT
18637	2804	128	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2804	129	.	.	.
18637	2805	1	Most	Most	JJS
18637	2805	2	of	of	IN
18637	2805	3	the	the	DT
18637	2805	4	earlier	early	JJR
18637	2805	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	2805	6	stemming	stem	VBG
18637	2805	7	from	from	IN
18637	2805	8	State	State	NNP
18637	2805	9	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2805	10	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	2805	11	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2805	12	railway	railway	NN
18637	2805	13	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2805	14	fall	fall	NN
18637	2805	15	in	in	IN
18637	2805	16	the	the	DT
18637	2805	17	first	first	JJ
18637	2805	18	class	class	NN
18637	2805	19	;	;	:
18637	2805	20	while	while	IN
18637	2805	21	illustrations	illustration	NNS
18637	2805	22	of	of	IN
18637	2805	23	the	the	DT
18637	2805	24	second	second	JJ
18637	2805	25	category	category	NN
18637	2805	26	usually	usually	RB
18637	2805	27	comprise	comprise	VBP
18637	2805	28	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2805	29	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2805	30	to	to	TO
18637	2805	31	promote	promote	VB
18637	2805	32	the	the	DT
18637	2805	33	public	public	JJ
18637	2805	34	health	health	NN
18637	2805	35	and	and	CC
18637	2805	36	fair	fair	JJ
18637	2805	37	dealing	dealing	NN
18637	2805	38	.	.	.
18637	2806	1	More	more	RBR
18637	2806	2	recent	recent	JJ
18637	2806	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	2806	4	are	be	VBP
18637	2806	5	more	more	RBR
18637	2806	6	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	2806	7	to	to	TO
18637	2806	8	classify	classify	VB
18637	2806	9	,	,	,
18637	2806	10	especially	especially	RB
18637	2806	11	as	as	IN
18637	2806	12	between	between	IN
18637	2806	13	the	the	DT
18637	2806	14	first	first	JJ
18637	2806	15	and	and	CC
18637	2806	16	third	third	JJ
18637	2806	17	categories	category	NNS
18637	2806	18	.	.	.
18637	2807	1	THE	the	DT
18637	2807	2	HEPBURN	HEPBURN	NNP
18637	2807	3	ACT	ACT	NNP
18637	2807	4	No	no	DT
18637	2807	5	act	act	NN
18637	2807	6	ever	ever	RB
18637	2807	7	passed	pass	VBN
18637	2807	8	by	by	IN
18637	2807	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2807	10	was	be	VBD
18637	2807	11	more	more	RBR
18637	2807	12	destructive	destructive	JJ
18637	2807	13	of	of	IN
18637	2807	14	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2807	15	on	on	IN
18637	2807	16	the	the	DT
18637	2807	17	State	State	NNP
18637	2807	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	2807	19	books	book	NNS
18637	2807	20	than	than	IN
18637	2807	21	the	the	DT
18637	2807	22	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	2807	23	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2807	24	of	of	IN
18637	2807	25	1906,[977	1906,[977	NNP
18637	2807	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2807	27	amending	amend	VBG
18637	2807	28	the	the	DT
18637	2807	29	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2807	30	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2807	31	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2807	32	.	.	.
18637	2808	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2808	2	a	a	DT
18637	2808	3	State	state	NN
18637	2808	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	2808	5	which	which	WDT
18637	2808	6	,	,	,
18637	2808	7	while	while	IN
18637	2808	8	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	2808	9	a	a	DT
18637	2808	10	railway	railway	NN
18637	2808	11	from	from	IN
18637	2808	12	giving	give	VBG
18637	2808	13	free	free	JJ
18637	2808	14	passes	pass	NNS
18637	2808	15	or	or	CC
18637	2808	16	free	free	JJ
18637	2808	17	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2808	18	,	,	,
18637	2808	19	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	2808	20	the	the	DT
18637	2808	21	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	2808	22	of	of	IN
18637	2808	23	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2808	24	in	in	IN
18637	2808	25	payment	payment	NN
18637	2808	26	for	for	IN
18637	2808	27	printing	printing	NN
18637	2808	28	and	and	CC
18637	2808	29	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	2808	30	,	,	,
18637	2808	31	was	be	VBD
18637	2808	32	found	find	VBN
18637	2808	33	to	to	TO
18637	2808	34	conflict	conflict	VB
18637	2808	35	with	with	IN
18637	2808	36	the	the	DT
18637	2808	37	unqualified	unqualified	JJ
18637	2808	38	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	2808	39	by	by	IN
18637	2808	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2808	41	of	of	IN
18637	2808	42	free	free	JJ
18637	2808	43	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2808	44	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2808	45	.	.	.
18637	2809	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2809	2	978	978	CD
18637	2809	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2809	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	2809	5	,	,	,
18637	2809	6	a	a	DT
18637	2809	7	State	State	NNP
18637	2809	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	2809	9	which	which	WDT
18637	2809	10	penalized	penalize	VBD
18637	2809	11	a	a	DT
18637	2809	12	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2809	13	for	for	IN
18637	2809	14	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	2809	15	to	to	TO
18637	2809	16	receive	receive	VB
18637	2809	17	freight	freight	NN
18637	2809	18	for	for	IN
18637	2809	19	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2809	20	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	2809	21	tendered	tender	VBN
18637	2809	22	at	at	IN
18637	2809	23	a	a	DT
18637	2809	24	regular	regular	JJ
18637	2809	25	station	station	NN
18637	2809	26	was	be	VBD
18637	2809	27	found	find	VBN
18637	2809	28	to	to	TO
18637	2809	29	conflict	conflict	VB
18637	2809	30	with	with	IN
18637	2809	31	the	the	DT
18637	2809	32	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2809	33	provision	provision	NN
18637	2809	34	that	that	IN
18637	2809	35	no	no	DT
18637	2809	36	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2809	37	"	"	``
18637	2809	38	shall	shall	MD
18637	2809	39	engage	engage	VB
18637	2809	40	or	or	CC
18637	2809	41	participate	participate	VB
18637	2809	42	in	in	IN
18637	2809	43	the	the	DT
18637	2809	44	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2809	45	of	of	IN
18637	2809	46	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	2809	47	or	or	CC
18637	2809	48	property	property	NN
18637	2809	49	,	,	,
18637	2809	50	as	as	IN
18637	2809	51	defined	define	VBN
18637	2809	52	in	in	IN
18637	2809	53	this	this	DT
18637	2809	54	act	act	NN
18637	2809	55	,	,	,
18637	2809	56	unless	unless	IN
18637	2809	57	the	the	DT
18637	2809	58	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2809	59	,	,	,
18637	2809	60	fares	fare	NNS
18637	2809	61	,	,	,
18637	2809	62	and	and	CC
18637	2809	63	charges	charge	NNS
18637	2809	64	upon	upon	IN
18637	2809	65	which	which	WDT
18637	2809	66	the	the	DT
18637	2809	67	same	same	JJ
18637	2809	68	are	be	VBP
18637	2809	69	transported	transport	VBN
18637	2809	70	by	by	IN
18637	2809	71	said	said	JJ
18637	2809	72	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2809	73	have	have	VBP
18637	2809	74	been	be	VBN
18637	2809	75	filed	file	VBN
18637	2809	76	and	and	CC
18637	2809	77	published	publish	VBN
18637	2809	78	in	in	IN
18637	2809	79	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	2809	80	with	with	IN
18637	2809	81	the	the	DT
18637	2809	82	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	2809	83	of	of	IN
18637	2809	84	this	this	DT
18637	2809	85	act	act	NN
18637	2809	86	.	.	.
18637	2810	1	"	"	``
18637	2810	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2810	3	979	979	CD
18637	2810	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2810	5	In	in	IN
18637	2810	6	enacting	enact	VBG
18637	2810	7	this	this	DT
18637	2810	8	provision	provision	NN
18637	2810	9	,	,	,
18637	2810	10	the	the	DT
18637	2810	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2810	12	found	find	VBD
18637	2810	13	,	,	,
18637	2810	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2810	15	had	have	VBD
18637	2810	16	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2810	17	to	to	TO
18637	2810	18	occupy	occupy	VB
18637	2810	19	the	the	DT
18637	2810	20	entire	entire	JJ
18637	2810	21	field	field	NN
18637	2810	22	.	.	.
18637	2811	1	In	in	IN
18637	2811	2	a	a	DT
18637	2811	3	third	third	JJ
18637	2811	4	case	case	NN
18637	2811	5	,	,	,
18637	2811	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2811	7	was	be	VBD
18637	2811	8	held	hold	VBN
18637	2811	9	that	that	IN
18637	2811	10	the	the	DT
18637	2811	11	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	2811	12	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2811	13	had	have	VBD
18637	2811	14	put	put	VBN
18637	2811	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2811	16	outside	outside	IN
18637	2811	17	the	the	DT
18637	2811	18	power	power	NN
18637	2811	19	of	of	IN
18637	2811	20	a	a	DT
18637	2811	21	State	State	NNP
18637	2811	22	to	to	TO
18637	2811	23	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2811	24	the	the	DT
18637	2811	25	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	2811	26	of	of	IN
18637	2811	27	cars	car	NNS
18637	2811	28	for	for	IN
18637	2811	29	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2811	30	shipments;[980	shipments;[980	CD
18637	2811	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2811	32	and	and	CC
18637	2811	33	on	on	IN
18637	2811	34	the	the	DT
18637	2811	35	same	same	JJ
18637	2811	36	ground	ground	NN
18637	2811	37	,	,	,
18637	2811	38	a	a	DT
18637	2811	39	State	state	NN
18637	2811	40	statute	statute	NN
18637	2811	41	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	2811	42	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	2811	43	of	of	IN
18637	2811	44	a	a	DT
18637	2811	45	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	2811	46	for	for	IN
18637	2811	47	delay	delay	NN
18637	2811	48	in	in	IN
18637	2811	49	giving	give	VBG
18637	2811	50	notice	notice	NN
18637	2811	51	of	of	IN
18637	2811	52	the	the	DT
18637	2811	53	arrival	arrival	NN
18637	2811	54	of	of	IN
18637	2811	55	freight	freight	NN
18637	2811	56	was	be	VBD
18637	2811	57	disallowed;[981	disallowed;[981	CD
18637	2811	58	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2811	59	as	as	IN
18637	2811	60	was	be	VBD
18637	2811	61	also	also	RB
18637	2811	62	the	the	DT
18637	2811	63	similar	similar	JJ
18637	2811	64	rule	rule	NN
18637	2811	65	of	of	IN
18637	2811	66	a	a	DT
18637	2811	67	State	State	NNP
18637	2811	68	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2811	69	commission	commission	NN
18637	2811	70	with	with	IN
18637	2811	71	respect	respect	NN
18637	2811	72	to	to	IN
18637	2811	73	failure	failure	NN
18637	2811	74	to	to	TO
18637	2811	75	deliver	deliver	VB
18637	2811	76	freight	freight	NN
18637	2811	77	at	at	IN
18637	2811	78	depots	depot	NNS
18637	2811	79	and	and	CC
18637	2811	80	warehouses	warehouse	NNS
18637	2811	81	within	within	IN
18637	2811	82	a	a	DT
18637	2811	83	stated	state	VBN
18637	2811	84	time	time	NN
18637	2811	85	limit	limit	NN
18637	2811	86	.	.	.
18637	2812	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2812	2	982	982	CD
18637	2812	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2812	4	And	and	CC
18637	2812	5	in	in	IN
18637	2812	6	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	2812	7	Express	Express	NNP
18637	2812	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2812	9	_	_	NNP
18637	2812	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	2812	11	_	_	NNP
18637	2812	12	Croninger[983	Croninger[983	NNP
18637	2812	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2812	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2812	15	was	be	VBD
18637	2812	16	sweepingly	sweepingly	RB
18637	2812	17	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	2812	18	that	that	IN
18637	2812	19	the	the	DT
18637	2812	20	so	so	RB
18637	2812	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	2812	22	called	call	VBN
18637	2812	23	Carmack	Carmack	NNP
18637	2812	24	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	2812	25	to	to	IN
18637	2812	26	the	the	DT
18637	2812	27	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	2812	28	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2812	29	,	,	,
18637	2812	30	which	which	WDT
18637	2812	31	puts	put	VBZ
18637	2812	32	the	the	DT
18637	2812	33	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	2812	34	for	for	IN
18637	2812	35	loss	loss	NN
18637	2812	36	of	of	IN
18637	2812	37	,	,	,
18637	2812	38	or	or	CC
18637	2812	39	injury	injury	NN
18637	2812	40	to	to	TO
18637	2812	41	,	,	,
18637	2812	42	cargo	cargo	NN
18637	2812	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	2812	44	the	the	DT
18637	2812	45	initial	initial	JJ
18637	2812	46	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2812	47	,	,	,
18637	2812	48	had	have	VBD
18637	2812	49	superseded	supersede	VBN
18637	2812	50	all	all	DT
18637	2812	51	State	state	NN
18637	2812	52	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	2812	53	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	2812	54	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	2812	55	for	for	IN
18637	2812	56	loss	loss	NN
18637	2812	57	or	or	CC
18637	2812	58	injury	injury	NN
18637	2812	59	to	to	IN
18637	2812	60	goods	good	NNS
18637	2812	61	in	in	IN
18637	2812	62	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2812	63	to	to	IN
18637	2812	64	an	an	DT
18637	2812	65	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	2812	66	or	or	CC
18637	2812	67	declared	declare	VBN
18637	2812	68	value	value	NN
18637	2812	69	.	.	.
18637	2813	1	Substantially	substantially	RB
18637	2813	2	contemporaneous	contemporaneous	JJ
18637	2813	3	with	with	IN
18637	2813	4	these	these	DT
18637	2813	5	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	2813	6	were	be	VBD
18637	2813	7	others	other	NNS
18637	2813	8	in	in	IN
18637	2813	9	which	which	WDT
18637	2813	10	the	the	DT
18637	2813	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2813	12	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	2813	13	that	that	IN
18637	2813	14	the	the	DT
18637	2813	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2813	16	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	2813	17	'	'	POS
18637	2813	18	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	2813	19	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2813	20	of	of	IN
18637	2813	21	1908	1908	CD
18637	2813	22	,	,	,
18637	2813	23	as	as	IN
18637	2813	24	amended	amend	VBN
18637	2813	25	in	in	IN
18637	2813	26	1910;[984	1910;[984	CD
18637	2813	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2813	28	the	the	DT
18637	2813	29	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2813	30	Hours	Hours	NNPS
18637	2813	31	of	of	IN
18637	2813	32	Service	Service	NNP
18637	2813	33	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2813	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2813	35	Railroads	Railroads	NNP
18637	2813	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2813	37	of	of	IN
18637	2813	38	1907;[985	1907;[985	NNP
18637	2813	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2813	40	and	and	CC
18637	2813	41	the	the	DT
18637	2813	42	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2813	43	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	2813	44	Appliance	Appliance	NNP
18637	2813	45	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	2813	46	of	of	IN
18637	2813	47	1893	1893	CD
18637	2813	48	,	,	,
18637	2813	49	as	as	IN
18637	2813	50	amended	amend	VBN
18637	2813	51	in	in	IN
18637	2813	52	1903[986	1903[986	CD
18637	2813	53	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2813	54	superseded	supersede	VBN
18637	2813	55	all	all	DT
18637	2813	56	State	State	NNP
18637	2813	57	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2813	58	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	2813	59	with	with	IN
18637	2813	60	the	the	DT
18637	2813	61	same	same	JJ
18637	2813	62	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	2813	63	so	so	RB
18637	2813	64	far	far	RB
18637	2813	65	as	as	IN
18637	2813	66	such	such	JJ
18637	2813	67	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2813	68	affected	affect	VBD
18637	2813	69	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2813	70	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2813	71	.	.	.
18637	2814	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2814	2	987	987	CD
18637	2814	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2814	4	However	however	RB
18637	2814	5	,	,	,
18637	2814	6	the	the	DT
18637	2814	7	States	States	NNPS
18637	2814	8	were	be	VBD
18637	2814	9	still	still	RB
18637	2814	10	able	able	JJ
18637	2814	11	to	to	TO
18637	2814	12	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2814	13	the	the	DT
18637	2814	14	time	time	NN
18637	2814	15	and	and	CC
18637	2814	16	manner	manner	NN
18637	2814	17	of	of	IN
18637	2814	18	payment	payment	NN
18637	2814	19	of	of	IN
18637	2814	20	the	the	DT
18637	2814	21	employees	employee	NNS
18637	2814	22	of	of	IN
18637	2814	23	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	2814	24	,	,	,
18637	2814	25	including	include	VBG
18637	2814	26	those	those	DT
18637	2814	27	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2814	28	in	in	IN
18637	2814	29	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2814	30	commerce,[988	commerce,[988	NN
18637	2814	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2814	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2814	33	having	have	VBG
18637	2814	34	not	not	RB
18637	2814	35	legislated	legislate	VBN
18637	2814	36	on	on	IN
18637	2814	37	the	the	DT
18637	2814	38	subject	subject	NN
18637	2814	39	.	.	.
18637	2815	1	QUARANTINE	quarantine	NN
18637	2815	2	CASES	case	NNS
18637	2815	3	In	in	IN
18637	2815	4	1904	1904	CD
18637	2815	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2815	6	was	be	VBD
18637	2815	7	held	hold	VBN
18637	2815	8	that	that	IN
18637	2815	9	a	a	DT
18637	2815	10	New	New	NNP
18637	2815	11	York	York	NNP
18637	2815	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	2815	13	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	2815	14	the	the	DT
18637	2815	15	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	2815	16	or	or	CC
18637	2815	17	sale	sale	NN
18637	2815	18	of	of	IN
18637	2815	19	any	any	DT
18637	2815	20	adulterated	adulterate	VBN
18637	2815	21	food	food	NN
18637	2815	22	or	or	CC
18637	2815	23	drug	drug	NN
18637	2815	24	,	,	,
18637	2815	25	or	or	CC
18637	2815	26	the	the	DT
18637	2815	27	coloring	coloring	NN
18637	2815	28	or	or	CC
18637	2815	29	coating	coating	NN
18637	2815	30	of	of	IN
18637	2815	31	food	food	NN
18637	2815	32	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	2815	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2815	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	2815	35	made	make	VBN
18637	2815	36	to	to	TO
18637	2815	37	appear	appear	VB
18637	2815	38	better	well	JJR
18637	2815	39	than	than	IN
18637	2815	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2815	41	really	really	RB
18637	2815	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	2815	43	,	,	,
18637	2815	44	was	be	VBD
18637	2815	45	not	not	RB
18637	2815	46	,	,	,
18637	2815	47	as	as	IN
18637	2815	48	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2815	49	to	to	IN
18637	2815	50	imported	import	VBN
18637	2815	51	coffee	coffee	NN
18637	2815	52	,	,	,
18637	2815	53	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	2815	54	to	to	IN
18637	2815	55	either	either	CC
18637	2815	56	the	the	DT
18637	2815	57	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2815	58	clause	clause	NN
18637	2815	59	or	or	CC
18637	2815	60	the	the	DT
18637	2815	61	Meat	Meat	NNP
18637	2815	62	Inspection	Inspection	NNP
18637	2815	63	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2815	64	of	of	IN
18637	2815	65	1890,[989	1890,[989	NNP
18637	2815	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2815	67	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	2815	68	the	the	DT
18637	2815	69	importation	importation	NN
18637	2815	70	into	into	IN
18637	2815	71	the	the	DT
18637	2815	72	United	United	NNP
18637	2815	73	States	States	NNP
18637	2815	74	of	of	IN
18637	2815	75	adulterated	adulterated	JJ
18637	2815	76	and	and	CC
18637	2815	77	unwholesome	unwholesome	JJ
18637	2815	78	food	food	NN
18637	2815	79	,	,	,
18637	2815	80	but	but	CC
18637	2815	81	as	as	IN
18637	2815	82	exertion	exertion	NN
18637	2815	83	by	by	IN
18637	2815	84	the	the	DT
18637	2815	85	State	State	NNP
18637	2815	86	of	of	IN
18637	2815	87	power	power	NN
18637	2815	88	to	to	TO
18637	2815	89	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	2815	90	for	for	IN
18637	2815	91	the	the	DT
18637	2815	92	protection	protection	NN
18637	2815	93	of	of	IN
18637	2815	94	the	the	DT
18637	2815	95	health	health	NN
18637	2815	96	and	and	CC
18637	2815	97	safety	safety	NN
18637	2815	98	of	of	IN
18637	2815	99	the	the	DT
18637	2815	100	community	community	NN
18637	2815	101	and	and	CC
18637	2815	102	to	to	TO
18637	2815	103	provide	provide	VB
18637	2815	104	against	against	IN
18637	2815	105	deception	deception	NN
18637	2815	106	and	and	CC
18637	2815	107	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	2815	108	.	.	.
18637	2816	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2816	2	990	990	CD
18637	2816	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2816	4	And	and	CC
18637	2816	5	in	in	IN
18637	2816	6	1912	1912	CD
18637	2816	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2816	8	was	be	VBD
18637	2816	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	2816	10	that	that	IN
18637	2816	11	an	an	DT
18637	2816	12	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	2816	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	2816	14	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	2816	15	the	the	DT
18637	2816	16	sale	sale	NN
18637	2816	17	of	of	IN
18637	2816	18	concentrated	concentrated	JJ
18637	2816	19	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	2816	20	feeding	feeding	NN
18637	2816	21	stuff	stuff	NN
18637	2816	22	and	and	CC
18637	2816	23	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2816	24	the	the	DT
18637	2816	25	disclosure	disclosure	NN
18637	2816	26	of	of	IN
18637	2816	27	ingredients	ingredient	NNS
18637	2816	28	by	by	IN
18637	2816	29	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	2816	30	and	and	CC
18637	2816	31	label	label	NN
18637	2816	32	,	,	,
18637	2816	33	and	and	CC
18637	2816	34	providing	provide	VBG
18637	2816	35	for	for	IN
18637	2816	36	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	2816	37	and	and	CC
18637	2816	38	analysis	analysis	NN
18637	2816	39	,	,	,
18637	2816	40	was	be	VBD
18637	2816	41	not	not	RB
18637	2816	42	in	in	IN
18637	2816	43	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	2816	44	with	with	IN
18637	2816	45	the	the	DT
18637	2816	46	Pure	Pure	NNP
18637	2816	47	Food	Food	NNP
18637	2816	48	and	and	CC
18637	2816	49	Drugs	Drugs	NNP
18637	2816	50	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2816	51	of	of	IN
18637	2816	52	1906	1906	CD
18637	2816	53	.	.	.
18637	2817	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2817	2	991	991	CD
18637	2817	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2817	4	However	however	RB
18637	2817	5	,	,	,
18637	2817	6	when	when	WRB
18637	2817	7	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	2817	8	about	about	IN
18637	2817	9	the	the	DT
18637	2817	10	same	same	JJ
18637	2817	11	time	time	NN
18637	2817	12	passed	pass	VBD
18637	2817	13	an	an	DT
18637	2817	14	act	act	NN
18637	2817	15	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2817	16	that	that	IN
18637	2817	17	when	when	WRB
18637	2817	18	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2817	19	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	2817	20	were	be	VBD
18637	2817	21	offered	offer	VBN
18637	2817	22	for	for	IN
18637	2817	23	sale	sale	NN
18637	2817	24	in	in	IN
18637	2817	25	that	that	DT
18637	2817	26	State	State	NNP
18637	2817	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2817	28	should	should	MD
18637	2817	29	bear	bear	VB
18637	2817	30	the	the	DT
18637	2817	31	label	label	NN
18637	2817	32	required	require	VBN
18637	2817	33	by	by	IN
18637	2817	34	State	State	NNP
18637	2817	35	law	law	NN
18637	2817	36	and	and	CC
18637	2817	37	no	no	DT
18637	2817	38	other	other	JJ
18637	2817	39	,	,	,
18637	2817	40	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2817	41	was	be	VBD
18637	2817	42	informed	inform	VBN
18637	2817	43	that	that	IN
18637	2817	44	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2817	45	could	could	MD
18637	2817	46	not	not	RB
18637	2817	47	validly	validly	RB
18637	2817	48	apply	apply	VB
18637	2817	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2817	50	to	to	IN
18637	2817	51	articles	article	NNS
18637	2817	52	which	which	WDT
18637	2817	53	had	have	VBD
18637	2817	54	been	be	VBN
18637	2817	55	labeled	label	VBN
18637	2817	56	in	in	IN
18637	2817	57	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	2817	58	with	with	IN
18637	2817	59	the	the	DT
18637	2817	60	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2817	61	statute	statute	NN
18637	2817	62	nor	nor	CC
18637	2817	63	did	do	VBD
18637	2817	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2817	65	make	make	VB
18637	2817	66	any	any	DT
18637	2817	67	difference	difference	NN
18637	2817	68	that	that	WDT
18637	2817	69	the	the	DT
18637	2817	70	goods	good	NNS
18637	2817	71	in	in	IN
18637	2817	72	question	question	NN
18637	2817	73	had	have	VBD
18637	2817	74	been	be	VBN
18637	2817	75	removed	remove	VBN
18637	2817	76	from	from	IN
18637	2817	77	the	the	DT
18637	2817	78	container	container	NN
18637	2817	79	in	in	IN
18637	2817	80	which	which	WDT
18637	2817	81	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2817	82	had	have	VBD
18637	2817	83	been	be	VBN
18637	2817	84	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	2817	85	into	into	IN
18637	2817	86	the	the	DT
18637	2817	87	State	State	NNP
18637	2817	88	,	,	,
18637	2817	89	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	2817	90	as	as	IN
18637	2817	91	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2817	92	could	could	MD
18637	2817	93	still	still	RB
18637	2817	94	be	be	VB
18637	2817	95	proceeded	proceed	VBN
18637	2817	96	against	against	IN
18637	2817	97	under	under	IN
18637	2817	98	the	the	DT
18637	2817	99	act	act	NN
18637	2817	100	of	of	IN
18637	2817	101	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2817	102	.	.	.
18637	2818	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2818	2	992	992	CD
18637	2818	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2818	4	The	the	DT
18637	2818	5	original	original	JJ
18637	2818	6	package	package	NN
18637	2818	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2818	8	,	,	,
18637	2818	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2818	10	was	be	VBD
18637	2818	11	added	add	VBN
18637	2818	12	,	,	,
18637	2818	13	"	"	``
18637	2818	14	was	be	VBD
18637	2818	15	not	not	RB
18637	2818	16	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2818	17	to	to	TO
18637	2818	18	limit	limit	VB
18637	2818	19	the	the	DT
18637	2818	20	right	right	NN
18637	2818	21	of	of	IN
18637	2818	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2818	23	,	,	,
18637	2818	24	*	*	NFP
18637	2818	25	*	*	NFP
18637	2818	26	*	*	NFP
18637	2818	27	,	,	,
18637	2818	28	to	to	TO
18637	2818	29	keep	keep	VB
18637	2818	30	the	the	DT
18637	2818	31	channels	channel	NNS
18637	2818	32	of	of	IN
18637	2818	33	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2818	34	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2818	35	free	free	JJ
18637	2818	36	from	from	IN
18637	2818	37	the	the	DT
18637	2818	38	carriage	carriage	NN
18637	2818	39	of	of	IN
18637	2818	40	injurious	injurious	JJ
18637	2818	41	or	or	CC
18637	2818	42	fraudulently	fraudulently	RB
18637	2818	43	branded	brand	VBN
18637	2818	44	articles	article	NNS
18637	2818	45	and	and	CC
18637	2818	46	to	to	TO
18637	2818	47	choose	choose	VB
18637	2818	48	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	2818	49	means	mean	NNS
18637	2818	50	to	to	IN
18637	2818	51	that	that	DT
18637	2818	52	end	end	NN
18637	2818	53	.	.	.
18637	2819	1	"	"	``
18637	2819	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2819	3	993	993	CD
18637	2819	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2819	5	But	but	CC
18637	2819	6	a	a	DT
18637	2819	7	North	North	NNP
18637	2819	8	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	2819	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	2819	10	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2819	11	that	that	IN
18637	2819	12	lard	lard	NN
18637	2819	13	compound	compound	NN
18637	2819	14	or	or	CC
18637	2819	15	substitutes	substitute	NNS
18637	2819	16	,	,	,
18637	2819	17	unless	unless	IN
18637	2819	18	sold	sell	VBN
18637	2819	19	in	in	IN
18637	2819	20	bulk	bulk	NN
18637	2819	21	,	,	,
18637	2819	22	should	should	MD
18637	2819	23	be	be	VB
18637	2819	24	put	put	VBN
18637	2819	25	up	up	RP
18637	2819	26	in	in	IN
18637	2819	27	pails	pail	NNS
18637	2819	28	or	or	CC
18637	2819	29	containers	container	NNS
18637	2819	30	holding	hold	VBG
18637	2819	31	one	one	CD
18637	2819	32	,	,	,
18637	2819	33	three	three	CD
18637	2819	34	,	,	,
18637	2819	35	or	or	CC
18637	2819	36	five	five	CD
18637	2819	37	pounds	pound	NNS
18637	2819	38	net	net	JJ
18637	2819	39	weight	weight	NN
18637	2819	40	,	,	,
18637	2819	41	or	or	CC
18637	2819	42	some	some	DT
18637	2819	43	multiple	multiple	NN
18637	2819	44	of	of	IN
18637	2819	45	these	these	DT
18637	2819	46	numbers	number	NNS
18637	2819	47	,	,	,
18637	2819	48	was	be	VBD
18637	2819	49	held	hold	VBN
18637	2819	50	not	not	RB
18637	2819	51	to	to	TO
18637	2819	52	be	be	VB
18637	2819	53	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	2819	54	to	to	IN
18637	2819	55	the	the	DT
18637	2819	56	Pure	Pure	NNP
18637	2819	57	Food	Food	NNP
18637	2819	58	and	and	CC
18637	2819	59	Drugs	Drugs	NNP
18637	2819	60	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2819	61	.	.	.
18637	2820	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2820	2	994	994	CD
18637	2820	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2820	4	On	on	IN
18637	2820	5	the	the	DT
18637	2820	6	other	other	JJ
18637	2820	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	2820	8	,	,	,
18637	2820	9	a	a	DT
18637	2820	10	decade	decade	NN
18637	2820	11	later	later	RBR
18637	2820	12	the	the	DT
18637	2820	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2820	14	found	find	VBD
18637	2820	15	that	that	IN
18637	2820	16	the	the	DT
18637	2820	17	Plant	Plant	NNP
18637	2820	18	Quarantine	Quarantine	NNP
18637	2820	19	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2820	20	of	of	IN
18637	2820	21	1912	1912	CD
18637	2820	22	,	,	,
18637	2820	23	as	as	IN
18637	2820	24	amended	amend	VBN
18637	2820	25	in	in	IN
18637	2820	26	1917,[995	1917,[995	CD
18637	2820	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2820	28	had	have	VBD
18637	2820	29	so	so	RB
18637	2820	30	completely	completely	RB
18637	2820	31	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	2820	32	the	the	DT
18637	2820	33	field	field	NN
18637	2820	34	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	2820	35	by	by	IN
18637	2820	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2820	37	title	title	NN
18637	2820	38	that	that	IN
18637	2820	39	a	a	DT
18637	2820	40	State	state	NN
18637	2820	41	was	be	VBD
18637	2820	42	left	leave	VBN
18637	2820	43	without	without	IN
18637	2820	44	power	power	NN
18637	2820	45	to	to	TO
18637	2820	46	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2820	47	the	the	DT
18637	2820	48	importation	importation	NN
18637	2820	49	of	of	IN
18637	2820	50	plants	plant	NNS
18637	2820	51	infected	infect	VBN
18637	2820	52	by	by	IN
18637	2820	53	a	a	DT
18637	2820	54	particular	particular	JJ
18637	2820	55	disease	disease	NN
18637	2820	56	to	to	TO
18637	2820	57	which	which	WDT
18637	2820	58	the	the	DT
18637	2820	59	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	2820	60	of	of	IN
18637	2820	61	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	2820	62	's	's	POS
18637	2820	63	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2820	64	did	do	VBD
18637	2820	65	not	not	RB
18637	2820	66	apply	apply	VB
18637	2820	67	.	.	.
18637	2821	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2821	2	996	996	CD
18637	2821	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2821	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2821	5	promptly	promptly	RB
18637	2821	6	intervened	intervene	VBD
18637	2821	7	by	by	IN
18637	2821	8	further	further	RB
18637	2821	9	amending	amend	VBG
18637	2821	10	the	the	DT
18637	2821	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2821	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	2821	13	to	to	TO
18637	2821	14	permit	permit	VB
18637	2821	15	the	the	DT
18637	2821	16	States	States	NNPS
18637	2821	17	to	to	TO
18637	2821	18	impose	impose	VB
18637	2821	19	quarantines	quarantine	NNS
18637	2821	20	in	in	IN
18637	2821	21	such	such	JJ
18637	2821	22	overlooked	overlooked	JJ
18637	2821	23	cases	case	NNS
18637	2821	24	.	.	.
18637	2822	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2822	2	997	997	CD
18637	2822	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2822	4	RECENT	recent	JJ
18637	2822	5	CASES	case	NNS
18637	2822	6	SUSTAINING	sustain	VBG
18637	2822	7	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2822	8	LEGISLATION	LEGISLATION	NNP
18637	2822	9	In	in	IN
18637	2822	10	1935	1935	CD
18637	2822	11	,	,	,
18637	2822	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2822	13	was	be	VBD
18637	2822	14	held[998	held[998	JJ
18637	2822	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2822	16	that	that	IN
18637	2822	17	an	an	DT
18637	2822	18	order	order	NN
18637	2822	19	of	of	IN
18637	2822	20	the	the	DT
18637	2822	21	New	New	NNP
18637	2822	22	York	York	NNP
18637	2822	23	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	2822	24	of	of	IN
18637	2822	25	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	2822	26	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	2822	27	the	the	DT
18637	2822	28	importation	importation	NN
18637	2822	29	of	of	IN
18637	2822	30	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	2822	31	for	for	IN
18637	2822	32	dairy	dairy	NN
18637	2822	33	or	or	CC
18637	2822	34	breeding	breeding	NN
18637	2822	35	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	2822	36	unless	unless	IN
18637	2822	37	such	such	JJ
18637	2822	38	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	2822	39	and	and	CC
18637	2822	40	the	the	DT
18637	2822	41	herds	herd	NNS
18637	2822	42	from	from	IN
18637	2822	43	which	which	WDT
18637	2822	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2822	45	come	come	VBP
18637	2822	46	had	have	VBD
18637	2822	47	been	be	VBN
18637	2822	48	certified	certify	VBN
18637	2822	49	by	by	IN
18637	2822	50	the	the	DT
18637	2822	51	chief	chief	JJ
18637	2822	52	sanitary	sanitary	JJ
18637	2822	53	officer	officer	NN
18637	2822	54	of	of	IN
18637	2822	55	the	the	DT
18637	2822	56	State	State	NNP
18637	2822	57	of	of	IN
18637	2822	58	origin	origin	NN
18637	2822	59	as	as	IN
18637	2822	60	being	be	VBG
18637	2822	61	free	free	JJ
18637	2822	62	from	from	IN
18637	2822	63	Bang	Bang	NNP
18637	2822	64	's	's	POS
18637	2822	65	disease	disease	NN
18637	2822	66	,	,	,
18637	2822	67	was	be	VBD
18637	2822	68	not	not	RB
18637	2822	69	in	in	IN
18637	2822	70	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	2822	71	with	with	IN
18637	2822	72	the	the	DT
18637	2822	73	Cattle	Cattle	NNP
18637	2822	74	Contagious	Contagious	NNP
18637	2822	75	Diseases	Diseases	NNPS
18637	2822	76	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	2822	77	.	.	.
18637	2823	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2823	2	999	999	CD
18637	2823	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2823	4	In	in	IN
18637	2823	5	1937	1937	CD
18637	2823	6	,	,	,
18637	2823	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2823	8	was	be	VBD
18637	2823	9	ruled[1000	ruled[1000	NNP
18637	2823	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2823	11	that	that	IN
18637	2823	12	a	a	DT
18637	2823	13	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	2823	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	2823	15	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	2823	16	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	2823	17	charges	charge	NNS
18637	2823	18	for	for	IN
18637	2823	19	handling	handling	NN
18637	2823	20	and	and	CC
18637	2823	21	selling	sell	VBG
18637	2823	22	leaf	leaf	NN
18637	2823	23	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	2823	24	did	do	VBD
18637	2823	25	not	not	RB
18637	2823	26	,	,	,
18637	2823	27	as	as	IN
18637	2823	28	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2823	29	to	to	IN
18637	2823	30	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2823	31	of	of	IN
18637	2823	32	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	2823	33	destined	destine	VBN
18637	2823	34	for	for	IN
18637	2823	35	export	export	NN
18637	2823	36	,	,	,
18637	2823	37	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	2823	38	with	with	IN
18637	2823	39	the	the	DT
18637	2823	40	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	2823	41	Inspection	Inspection	NNP
18637	2823	42	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2823	43	.	.	.
18637	2824	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2824	2	1001	1001	CD
18637	2824	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2824	4	In	in	IN
18637	2824	5	1942,[1002	1942,[1002	CD
18637	2824	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2824	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2824	8	was	be	VBD
18637	2824	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	2824	10	that	that	IN
18637	2824	11	an	an	DT
18637	2824	12	order	order	NN
18637	2824	13	of	of	IN
18637	2824	14	the	the	DT
18637	2824	15	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	2824	16	Employment	Employment	NNP
18637	2824	17	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	2824	18	Board	Board	NNP
18637	2824	19	which	which	WDT
18637	2824	20	commanded	command	VBD
18637	2824	21	a	a	DT
18637	2824	22	union	union	NN
18637	2824	23	,	,	,
18637	2824	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2824	25	agents	agent	NNS
18637	2824	26	,	,	,
18637	2824	27	and	and	CC
18637	2824	28	members	member	NNS
18637	2824	29	,	,	,
18637	2824	30	to	to	TO
18637	2824	31	desist	desist	VB
18637	2824	32	from	from	IN
18637	2824	33	mass	mass	JJ
18637	2824	34	picketing	picketing	NN
18637	2824	35	of	of	IN
18637	2824	36	a	a	DT
18637	2824	37	factory	factory	NN
18637	2824	38	,	,	,
18637	2824	39	threatening	threaten	VBG
18637	2824	40	personal	personal	JJ
18637	2824	41	injury	injury	NN
18637	2824	42	or	or	CC
18637	2824	43	property	property	NN
18637	2824	44	damage	damage	NN
18637	2824	45	to	to	IN
18637	2824	46	employees	employee	NNS
18637	2824	47	desiring	desire	VBG
18637	2824	48	to	to	TO
18637	2824	49	work	work	VB
18637	2824	50	,	,	,
18637	2824	51	obstructing	obstruct	VBG
18637	2824	52	the	the	DT
18637	2824	53	streets	street	NNS
18637	2824	54	about	about	IN
18637	2824	55	the	the	DT
18637	2824	56	factory	factory	NN
18637	2824	57	,	,	,
18637	2824	58	and	and	CC
18637	2824	59	picketing	picket	VBG
18637	2824	60	the	the	DT
18637	2824	61	homes	home	NNS
18637	2824	62	of	of	IN
18637	2824	63	employees	employee	NNS
18637	2824	64	,	,	,
18637	2824	65	was	be	VBD
18637	2824	66	not	not	RB
18637	2824	67	in	in	IN
18637	2824	68	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	2824	69	with	with	IN
18637	2824	70	the	the	DT
18637	2824	71	National	National	NNP
18637	2824	72	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	2824	73	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	2824	74	Act,[1003	Act,[1003	NNP
18637	2824	75	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2824	76	to	to	TO
18637	2824	77	which	which	WDT
18637	2824	78	the	the	DT
18637	2824	79	employer	employer	NN
18637	2824	80	was	be	VBD
18637	2824	81	admittedly	admittedly	RB
18637	2824	82	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2824	83	but	but	CC
18637	2824	84	which	which	WDT
18637	2824	85	had	have	VBD
18637	2824	86	not	not	RB
18637	2824	87	been	be	VBN
18637	2824	88	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	2824	89	.	.	.
18637	2825	1	An	an	DT
18637	2825	2	"	"	``
18637	2825	3	intention	intention	NN
18637	2825	4	of	of	IN
18637	2825	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2825	6	,	,	,
18637	2825	7	"	"	''
18637	2825	8	said	say	VBD
18637	2825	9	the	the	DT
18637	2825	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2825	11	,	,	,
18637	2825	12	"	"	''
18637	2825	13	to	to	TO
18637	2825	14	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	2825	15	States	States	NNP
18637	2825	16	from	from	IN
18637	2825	17	exerting	exert	VBG
18637	2825	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2825	19	police	police	NN
18637	2825	20	power	power	NN
18637	2825	21	must	must	MD
18637	2825	22	be	be	VB
18637	2825	23	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	2825	24	manifested	manifest	VBN
18637	2825	25	.	.	.
18637	2826	1	"	"	``
18637	2826	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2826	3	1004	1004	CD
18637	2826	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2826	5	In	in	IN
18637	2826	6	1943,[1005	1943,[1005	CD
18637	2826	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2826	8	the	the	DT
18637	2826	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2826	10	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	2826	11	the	the	DT
18637	2826	12	marketing	marketing	NN
18637	2826	13	program	program	NN
18637	2826	14	for	for	IN
18637	2826	15	the	the	DT
18637	2826	16	1940	1940	CD
18637	2826	17	California	California	NNP
18637	2826	18	raisin	raisin	NN
18637	2826	19	crop	crop	NN
18637	2826	20	,	,	,
18637	2826	21	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	2826	22	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	2826	23	to	to	IN
18637	2826	24	the	the	DT
18637	2826	25	California	California	NNP
18637	2826	26	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	2826	27	Prorate	Prorate	NNP
18637	2826	28	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2826	29	.	.	.
18637	2827	1	Although	although	IN
18637	2827	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2827	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2827	4	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	2827	5	that	that	IN
18637	2827	6	the	the	DT
18637	2827	7	program	program	NN
18637	2827	8	and	and	CC
18637	2827	9	act	act	NN
18637	2827	10	operated	operate	VBD
18637	2827	11	to	to	TO
18637	2827	12	eliminate	eliminate	VB
18637	2827	13	competition	competition	NN
18637	2827	14	among	among	IN
18637	2827	15	producers	producer	NNS
18637	2827	16	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	2827	17	terms	term	NNS
18637	2827	18	of	of	IN
18637	2827	19	sale	sale	NN
18637	2827	20	and	and	CC
18637	2827	21	price	price	NN
18637	2827	22	as	as	IN
18637	2827	23	to	to	IN
18637	2827	24	product	product	NN
18637	2827	25	destined	destine	VBN
18637	2827	26	for	for	IN
18637	2827	27	the	the	DT
18637	2827	28	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2827	29	market	market	NN
18637	2827	30	,	,	,
18637	2827	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2827	32	were	be	VBD
18637	2827	33	held	hold	VBN
18637	2827	34	not	not	RB
18637	2827	35	to	to	TO
18637	2827	36	conflict	conflict	VB
18637	2827	37	with	with	IN
18637	2827	38	the	the	DT
18637	2827	39	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2827	40	clause	clause	NN
18637	2827	41	or	or	CC
18637	2827	42	with	with	IN
18637	2827	43	the	the	DT
18637	2827	44	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	2827	45	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2827	46	or	or	CC
18637	2827	47	the	the	DT
18637	2827	48	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	2827	49	Marketing	Marketing	NNP
18637	2827	50	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	2827	51	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2827	52	.	.	.
18637	2828	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2828	2	1006	1006	CD
18637	2828	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2828	4	To	to	IN
18637	2828	5	the	the	DT
18637	2828	6	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	2828	7	,	,	,
18637	2828	8	said	say	VBD
18637	2828	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2828	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2828	11	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	2828	12	,	,	,
18637	2828	13	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2828	14	for	for	IN
18637	2828	15	the	the	DT
18637	2828	16	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	2828	17	court	court	NN
18637	2828	18	,	,	,
18637	2828	19	the	the	DT
18637	2828	20	program	program	NN
18637	2828	21	"	"	``
18637	2828	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	2828	23	one	one	CD
18637	2828	24	which	which	WDT
18637	2828	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2828	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	2828	27	been	be	VBN
18637	2828	28	the	the	DT
18637	2828	29	policy	policy	NN
18637	2828	30	of	of	IN
18637	2828	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2828	32	to	to	TO
18637	2828	33	aid	aid	VB
18637	2828	34	and	and	CC
18637	2828	35	encourage	encourage	VB
18637	2828	36	through	through	IN
18637	2828	37	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2828	38	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	2828	39	"	"	''
18637	2828	40	under	under	IN
18637	2828	41	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2828	42	act	act	NN
18637	2828	43	.	.	.
18637	2829	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2829	2	1007	1007	CD
18637	2829	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2829	4	The	the	DT
18637	2829	5	case	case	NN
18637	2829	6	was	be	VBD
18637	2829	7	not	not	RB
18637	2829	8	one	one	CD
18637	2829	9	,	,	,
18637	2829	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2829	11	further	further	RB
18637	2829	12	observed	observe	VBD
18637	2829	13	,	,	,
18637	2829	14	which	which	WDT
18637	2829	15	was	be	VBD
18637	2829	16	to	to	TO
18637	2829	17	be	be	VB
18637	2829	18	resolved	resolve	VBN
18637	2829	19	by	by	IN
18637	2829	20	"	"	``
18637	2829	21	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
18637	2829	22	test	test	NN
18637	2829	23	,	,	,
18637	2829	24	"	"	''
18637	2829	25	but	but	CC
18637	2829	26	with	with	IN
18637	2829	27	the	the	DT
18637	2829	28	object	object	NN
18637	2829	29	in	in	IN
18637	2829	30	view	view	NN
18637	2829	31	of	of	IN
18637	2829	32	accommodating	accommodate	VBG
18637	2829	33	"	"	``
18637	2829	34	the	the	DT
18637	2829	35	competing	compete	VBG
18637	2829	36	demands	demand	NNS
18637	2829	37	of	of	IN
18637	2829	38	the	the	DT
18637	2829	39	State	State	NNP
18637	2829	40	and	and	CC
18637	2829	41	national	national	JJ
18637	2829	42	interests	interest	NNS
18637	2829	43	involved	involve	VBN
18637	2829	44	.	.	.
18637	2830	1	"	"	``
18637	2830	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2830	3	1008	1008	CD
18637	2830	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2830	5	In	in	IN
18637	2830	6	1944,[1009	1944,[1009	CD
18637	2830	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2830	8	the	the	DT
18637	2830	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2830	10	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	2830	11	the	the	DT
18637	2830	12	right	right	NN
18637	2830	13	of	of	IN
18637	2830	14	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	2830	15	to	to	TO
18637	2830	16	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	2830	17	from	from	IN
18637	2830	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2830	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	2830	20	a	a	DT
18637	2830	21	firm	firm	NN
18637	2830	22	licensed	license	VBN
18637	2830	23	by	by	IN
18637	2830	24	the	the	DT
18637	2830	25	National	National	NNP
18637	2830	26	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2830	27	to	to	TO
18637	2830	28	carry	carry	VB
18637	2830	29	on	on	RP
18637	2830	30	the	the	DT
18637	2830	31	business	business	NN
18637	2830	32	of	of	IN
18637	2830	33	customs	custom	NNS
18637	2830	34	broker	broker	NN
18637	2830	35	because	because	IN
18637	2830	36	of	of	IN
18637	2830	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2830	38	failure	failure	NN
18637	2830	39	to	to	TO
18637	2830	40	comply	comply	VB
18637	2830	41	with	with	IN
18637	2830	42	a	a	DT
18637	2830	43	State	State	NNP
18637	2830	44	statute	statute	NN
18637	2830	45	requiring	require	VBG
18637	2830	46	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2830	47	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2830	48	to	to	TO
18637	2830	49	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	2830	50	a	a	DT
18637	2830	51	license	license	NN
18637	2830	52	to	to	TO
18637	2830	53	do	do	VB
18637	2830	54	business	business	NN
18637	2830	55	in	in	IN
18637	2830	56	the	the	DT
18637	2830	57	State	State	NNP
18637	2830	58	.	.	.
18637	2831	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2831	2	for	for	IN
18637	2831	3	the	the	DT
18637	2831	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2831	5	,	,	,
18637	2831	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2831	7	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	2831	8	,	,	,
18637	2831	9	again	again	RB
18637	2831	10	disparaged	disparage	VBD
18637	2831	11	"	"	``
18637	2831	12	the	the	DT
18637	2831	13	generalities	generality	NNS
18637	2831	14	"	"	''
18637	2831	15	to	to	TO
18637	2831	16	which	which	WDT
18637	2831	17	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2831	18	cases	case	NNS
18637	2831	19	had	have	VBD
18637	2831	20	given	give	VBN
18637	2831	21	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	2831	22	.	.	.
18637	2832	1	Actually	actually	RB
18637	2832	2	,	,	,
18637	2832	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2832	4	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	2832	5	,	,	,
18637	2832	6	"	"	''
18637	2832	7	the	the	DT
18637	2832	8	fate	fate	NN
18637	2832	9	of	of	IN
18637	2832	10	State	State	NNP
18637	2832	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2832	12	in	in	IN
18637	2832	13	these	these	DT
18637	2832	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	2832	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	2832	16	not	not	RB
18637	2832	17	been	be	VBN
18637	2832	18	determined	determine	VBN
18637	2832	19	by	by	IN
18637	2832	20	these	these	DT
18637	2832	21	generalities	generality	NNS
18637	2832	22	but	but	CC
18637	2832	23	by	by	IN
18637	2832	24	the	the	DT
18637	2832	25	weight	weight	NN
18637	2832	26	of	of	IN
18637	2832	27	the	the	DT
18637	2832	28	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	2832	29	and	and	CC
18637	2832	30	the	the	DT
18637	2832	31	practical	practical	JJ
18637	2832	32	and	and	CC
18637	2832	33	experienced	experienced	JJ
18637	2832	34	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	2832	35	in	in	IN
18637	2832	36	applying	apply	VBG
18637	2832	37	these	these	DT
18637	2832	38	generalities	generality	NNS
18637	2832	39	to	to	IN
18637	2832	40	the	the	DT
18637	2832	41	particular	particular	JJ
18637	2832	42	instances	instance	NNS
18637	2832	43	.	.	.
18637	2833	1	"	"	``
18637	2833	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2833	3	1010	1010	CD
18637	2833	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2833	5	In	in	IN
18637	2833	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	2833	7	,	,	,
18637	2833	8	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2833	9	in	in	IN
18637	2833	10	1947,[1011	1947,[1011	CD
18637	2833	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2833	12	the	the	DT
18637	2833	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2833	14	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	2833	15	that	that	IN
18637	2833	16	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	2833	17	had	have	VBD
18637	2833	18	not	not	RB
18637	2833	19	violated	violate	VBN
18637	2833	20	the	the	DT
18637	2833	21	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	2833	22	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	2833	23	Act[1012	Act[1012	NNPS
18637	2833	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2833	25	by	by	IN
18637	2833	26	attempting	attempt	VBG
18637	2833	27	to	to	TO
18637	2833	28	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2833	29	the	the	DT
18637	2833	30	rates	rate	NNS
18637	2833	31	for	for	IN
18637	2833	32	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2833	33	gas	gas	NN
18637	2833	34	sold	sell	VBN
18637	2833	35	within	within	IN
18637	2833	36	the	the	DT
18637	2833	37	State	State	NNP
18637	2833	38	by	by	IN
18637	2833	39	an	an	DT
18637	2833	40	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	2833	41	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	2833	42	line	line	NN
18637	2833	43	company	company	NN
18637	2833	44	to	to	IN
18637	2833	45	local	local	JJ
18637	2833	46	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	2833	47	consumers	consumer	NNS
18637	2833	48	;	;	:
18637	2833	49	and	and	CC
18637	2833	50	that	that	IN
18637	2833	51	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	2833	52	was	be	VBD
18637	2833	53	not	not	RB
18637	2833	54	precluded	preclude	VBN
18637	2833	55	by	by	IN
18637	2833	56	the	the	DT
18637	2833	57	Commodity	Commodity	NNP
18637	2833	58	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	2833	59	Act[1013	Act[1013	NNP
18637	2833	60	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2833	61	from	from	IN
18637	2833	62	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	2833	63	upon	upon	IN
18637	2833	64	grain	grain	NN
18637	2833	65	exchanges	exchange	NNS
18637	2833	66	doing	do	VBG
18637	2833	67	business	business	NN
18637	2833	68	within	within	IN
18637	2833	69	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2833	70	borders	border	NNS
18637	2833	71	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2833	72	not	not	RB
18637	2833	73	at	at	IN
18637	2833	74	variance	variance	NN
18637	2833	75	with	with	IN
18637	2833	76	the	the	DT
18637	2833	77	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	2833	78	of	of	IN
18637	2833	79	the	the	DT
18637	2833	80	act	act	NN
18637	2833	81	or	or	CC
18637	2833	82	with	with	IN
18637	2833	83	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2833	84	promulgated	promulgate	VBN
18637	2833	85	under	under	IN
18637	2833	86	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2833	87	by	by	IN
18637	2833	88	the	the	DT
18637	2833	89	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	2833	90	of	of	IN
18637	2833	91	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	2833	92	.	.	.
18637	2834	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	2834	2	,	,	,
18637	2834	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2834	4	was	be	VBD
18637	2834	5	held	hold	VBN
18637	2834	6	by	by	IN
18637	2834	7	a	a	DT
18637	2834	8	bare	bare	JJ
18637	2834	9	majority	majority	NN
18637	2834	10	of	of	IN
18637	2834	11	the	the	DT
18637	2834	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2834	13	in	in	IN
18637	2834	14	1949	1949	CD
18637	2834	15	,	,	,
18637	2834	16	did	do	VBD
18637	2834	17	the	the	DT
18637	2834	18	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	2834	19	Carrier	Carrier	NNP
18637	2834	20	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2834	21	of	of	IN
18637	2834	22	1935	1935	CD
18637	2834	23	,	,	,
18637	2834	24	as	as	IN
18637	2834	25	amended	amend	VBN
18637	2834	26	in	in	IN
18637	2834	27	1942,[1014	1942,[1014	CD
18637	2834	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2834	29	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	2834	30	California	California	NNP
18637	2834	31	from	from	IN
18637	2834	32	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	2834	33	the	the	DT
18637	2834	34	sale	sale	NN
18637	2834	35	or	or	CC
18637	2834	36	arrangement	arrangement	NN
18637	2834	37	of	of	IN
18637	2834	38	any	any	DT
18637	2834	39	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2834	40	over	over	IN
18637	2834	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2834	42	public	public	JJ
18637	2834	43	highways	highway	NNS
18637	2834	44	if	if	IN
18637	2834	45	the	the	DT
18637	2834	46	transporting	transporting	JJ
18637	2834	47	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	2834	48	has	have	VBZ
18637	2834	49	no	no	DT
18637	2834	50	permit	permit	NN
18637	2834	51	from	from	IN
18637	2834	52	the	the	DT
18637	2834	53	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2834	54	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2834	55	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2834	56	.	.	.
18637	2835	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2835	2	1015	1015	CD
18637	2835	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2835	4	The	the	DT
18637	2835	5	opposed	oppose	VBN
18637	2835	6	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	2835	7	line	line	VBP
18637	2835	8	up	up	IN
18637	2835	9	most	most	JJS
18637	2835	10	of	of	IN
18637	2835	11	the	the	DT
18637	2835	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	2835	13	on	on	IN
18637	2835	14	either	either	DT
18637	2835	15	side	side	NN
18637	2835	16	of	of	IN
18637	2835	17	the	the	DT
18637	2835	18	question	question	NN
18637	2835	19	.	.	.
18637	2836	1	RECENT	recent	JJ
18637	2836	2	CASES	case	NNS
18637	2836	3	NULLIFYING	nullify	VBG
18637	2836	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2836	5	ACTION	action	NN
18637	2836	6	On	on	IN
18637	2836	7	the	the	DT
18637	2836	8	other	other	JJ
18637	2836	9	side	side	NN
18637	2836	10	of	of	IN
18637	2836	11	the	the	DT
18637	2836	12	ledger	ledger	NNP
18637	2836	13	appear	appear	VBP
18637	2836	14	the	the	DT
18637	2836	15	following	follow	VBG
18637	2836	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	2836	17	,	,	,
18637	2836	18	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2836	19	contemporaneously	contemporaneously	RB
18637	2836	20	with	with	IN
18637	2836	21	those	those	DT
18637	2836	22	just	just	RB
18637	2836	23	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	2836	24	:	:	:
18637	2836	25	one	one	CD
18637	2836	26	in	in	IN
18637	2836	27	1942	1942	CD
18637	2836	28	in	in	IN
18637	2836	29	which	which	WDT
18637	2836	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2836	31	was	be	VBD
18637	2836	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	2836	33	that	that	IN
18637	2836	34	a	a	DT
18637	2836	35	gas	gas	NN
18637	2836	36	company	company	NN
18637	2836	37	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	2836	38	in	in	IN
18637	2836	39	the	the	DT
18637	2836	40	business	business	NN
18637	2836	41	of	of	IN
18637	2836	42	piping	pipe	VBG
18637	2836	43	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2836	44	gas	gas	NN
18637	2836	45	from	from	IN
18637	2836	46	without	without	IN
18637	2836	47	the	the	DT
18637	2836	48	State	State	NNP
18637	2836	49	of	of	IN
18637	2836	50	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	2836	51	and	and	CC
18637	2836	52	selling	sell	VBG
18637	2836	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2836	54	wholesale	wholesale	JJ
18637	2836	55	to	to	IN
18637	2836	56	distributors	distributor	NNS
18637	2836	57	in	in	IN
18637	2836	58	that	that	DT
18637	2836	59	State	state	NN
18637	2836	60	was	be	VBD
18637	2836	61	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2836	62	to	to	IN
18637	2836	63	the	the	DT
18637	2836	64	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2836	65	of	of	IN
18637	2836	66	the	the	DT
18637	2836	67	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2836	68	Power	Power	NNP
18637	2836	69	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2836	70	under	under	IN
18637	2836	71	the	the	DT
18637	2836	72	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	2836	73	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	2836	74	Act,[1016	act,[1016	RB
18637	2836	75	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2836	76	and	and	CC
18637	2836	77	hence	hence	RB
18637	2836	78	could	could	MD
18637	2836	79	not	not	RB
18637	2836	80	be	be	VB
18637	2836	81	required	require	VBN
18637	2836	82	by	by	IN
18637	2836	83	the	the	DT
18637	2836	84	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	2836	85	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2836	86	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2836	87	to	to	TO
18637	2836	88	extend	extend	VB
18637	2836	89	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2836	90	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	2836	91	in	in	IN
18637	2836	92	the	the	DT
18637	2836	93	absence	absence	NN
18637	2836	94	of	of	IN
18637	2836	95	a	a	DT
18637	2836	96	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	2836	97	of	of	IN
18637	2836	98	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	2836	99	from	from	IN
18637	2836	100	the	the	DT
18637	2836	101	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2836	102	Power	Power	NNP
18637	2836	103	Commission;[1017	Commission;[1017	NNP
18637	2836	104	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2836	105	one	one	CD
18637	2836	106	,	,	,
18637	2836	107	in	in	IN
18637	2836	108	the	the	DT
18637	2836	109	same	same	JJ
18637	2836	110	year	year	NN
18637	2836	111	,	,	,
18637	2836	112	in	in	IN
18637	2836	113	which	which	WDT
18637	2836	114	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2836	115	was	be	VBD
18637	2836	116	held	hold	VBN
18637	2836	117	,	,	,
18637	2836	118	by	by	IN
18637	2836	119	a	a	DT
18637	2836	120	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	2836	121	divided	divide	VBN
18637	2836	122	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2836	123	,	,	,
18637	2836	124	that	that	DT
18637	2836	125	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2836	126	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2836	127	of	of	IN
18637	2836	128	the	the	DT
18637	2836	129	production	production	NN
18637	2836	130	of	of	IN
18637	2836	131	renovated	renovate	VBN
18637	2836	132	butter	butter	NN
18637	2836	133	under	under	IN
18637	2836	134	the	the	DT
18637	2836	135	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	2836	136	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	2836	137	Code[1018	Code[1018	NNP
18637	2836	138	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2836	139	prevented	prevent	VBD
18637	2836	140	the	the	DT
18637	2836	141	State	State	NNP
18637	2836	142	of	of	IN
18637	2836	143	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	2836	144	from	from	IN
18637	2836	145	inspecting	inspect	VBG
18637	2836	146	,	,	,
18637	2836	147	seizing	seize	VBG
18637	2836	148	and	and	CC
18637	2836	149	detaining	detain	VBG
18637	2836	150	stock	stock	NN
18637	2836	151	butter	butter	NN
18637	2836	152	from	from	IN
18637	2836	153	which	which	WDT
18637	2836	154	such	such	JJ
18637	2836	155	butter	butter	NN
18637	2836	156	was	be	VBD
18637	2836	157	made	make	VBN
18637	2836	158	,	,	,
18637	2836	159	some	some	DT
18637	2836	160	of	of	IN
18637	2836	161	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2836	162	being	be	VBG
18637	2836	163	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2836	164	for	for	IN
18637	2836	165	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2836	166	commerce;[1019	commerce;[1019	NNP
18637	2836	167	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2836	168	one	one	CD
18637	2836	169	in	in	IN
18637	2836	170	1947	1947	CD
18637	2836	171	holding	hold	VBG
18637	2836	172	that	that	IN
18637	2836	173	the	the	DT
18637	2836	174	United	United	NNP
18637	2836	175	States	States	NNP
18637	2836	176	Warehouse	Warehouse	NNP
18637	2836	177	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2836	178	,	,	,
18637	2836	179	as	as	IN
18637	2836	180	amended,[1020	amended,[1020	NNP
18637	2836	181	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2836	182	must	must	MD
18637	2836	183	be	be	VB
18637	2836	184	construed	construe	VBN
18637	2836	185	as	as	IN
18637	2836	186	superseding	supersede	VBG
18637	2836	187	State	State	NNP
18637	2836	188	authority	authority	NN
18637	2836	189	to	to	TO
18637	2836	190	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2836	191	licenses	license	NNS
18637	2836	192	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	2836	193	,	,	,
18637	2836	194	and	and	CC
18637	2836	195	hence	hence	RB
18637	2836	196	overruled	overrule	VBD
18637	2836	197	the	the	DT
18637	2836	198	stricter	strict	JJR
18637	2836	199	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	2836	200	of	of	IN
18637	2836	201	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	2836	202	law	law	NN
18637	2836	203	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	2836	204	with	with	IN
18637	2836	205	such	such	JJ
18637	2836	206	subject	subject	NN
18637	2836	207	as	as	IN
18637	2836	208	rate	rate	NN
18637	2836	209	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	2836	210	,	,	,
18637	2836	211	the	the	DT
18637	2836	212	dual	dual	JJ
18637	2836	213	position	position	NN
18637	2836	214	of	of	IN
18637	2836	215	grain	grain	NN
18637	2836	216	warehousemen	warehouseman	NNS
18637	2836	217	storing	store	VBG
18637	2836	218	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2836	219	own	own	JJ
18637	2836	220	grain	grain	NN
18637	2836	221	,	,	,
18637	2836	222	the	the	DT
18637	2836	223	mixing	mixing	NN
18637	2836	224	of	of	IN
18637	2836	225	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	2836	226	grain	grain	NN
18637	2836	227	owned	own	VBN
18637	2836	228	by	by	IN
18637	2836	229	the	the	DT
18637	2836	230	warehousemen	warehouseman	NNS
18637	2836	231	with	with	IN
18637	2836	232	superior	superior	JJ
18637	2836	233	grain	grain	NN
18637	2836	234	of	of	IN
18637	2836	235	other	other	JJ
18637	2836	236	users	user	NNS
18637	2836	237	of	of	IN
18637	2836	238	the	the	DT
18637	2836	239	facility	facility	NN
18637	2836	240	,	,	,
18637	2836	241	delay	delay	VB
18637	2836	242	in	in	IN
18637	2836	243	loading	loading	NN
18637	2836	244	grain	grain	NN
18637	2836	245	,	,	,
18637	2836	246	the	the	DT
18637	2836	247	sacrificing	sacrificing	NN
18637	2836	248	or	or	CC
18637	2836	249	rebating	rebating	NN
18637	2836	250	of	of	IN
18637	2836	251	storage	storage	NN
18637	2836	252	charges	charge	NNS
18637	2836	253	,	,	,
18637	2836	254	retraining	retrain	VBG
18637	2836	255	desirable	desirable	JJ
18637	2836	256	transit	transit	NN
18637	2836	257	tonnage	tonnage	NN
18637	2836	258	,	,	,
18637	2836	259	utilizing	utilize	VBG
18637	2836	260	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	2836	261	storage	storage	NN
18637	2836	262	space	space	NN
18637	2836	263	,	,	,
18637	2836	264	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	2836	265	of	of	IN
18637	2836	266	unsafe	unsafe	JJ
18637	2836	267	and	and	CC
18637	2836	268	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
18637	2836	269	grain	grain	NN
18637	2836	270	elevators	elevator	NNS
18637	2836	271	,	,	,
18637	2836	272	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
18637	2836	273	and	and	CC
18637	2836	274	ineffectual	ineffectual	JJ
18637	2836	275	warehouse	warehouse	NN
18637	2836	276	service	service	NN
18637	2836	277	,	,	,
18637	2836	278	the	the	DT
18637	2836	279	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	2836	280	of	of	IN
18637	2836	281	a	a	DT
18637	2836	282	license	license	NN
18637	2836	283	,	,	,
18637	2836	284	the	the	DT
18637	2836	285	abandonment	abandonment	NN
18637	2836	286	of	of	IN
18637	2836	287	warehousing	warehousing	JJ
18637	2836	288	service	service	NN
18637	2836	289	,	,	,
18637	2836	290	and	and	CC
18637	2836	291	the	the	DT
18637	2836	292	rendition	rendition	NN
18637	2836	293	of	of	IN
18637	2836	294	warehousing	warehousing	JJ
18637	2836	295	service	service	NN
18637	2836	296	without	without	IN
18637	2836	297	filing	filing	NN
18637	2836	298	and	and	CC
18637	2836	299	publishing	publishing	NN
18637	2836	300	rate	rate	NN
18637	2836	301	schedules;[1021	schedules;[1021	.
18637	2836	302	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2836	303	one	one	CD
18637	2836	304	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2836	305	the	the	DT
18637	2836	306	same	same	JJ
18637	2836	307	year	year	NN
18637	2836	308	in	in	IN
18637	2836	309	which	which	WDT
18637	2836	310	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2836	311	was	be	VBD
18637	2836	312	held	hold	VBN
18637	2836	313	that	that	IN
18637	2836	314	the	the	DT
18637	2836	315	authority	authority	NN
18637	2836	316	of	of	IN
18637	2836	317	the	the	DT
18637	2836	318	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2836	319	Power	Power	NNP
18637	2836	320	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2836	321	under	under	IN
18637	2836	322	the	the	DT
18637	2836	323	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	2836	324	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	2836	325	Act[1022	Act[1022	NNP
18637	2836	326	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2836	327	extended	extend	VBN
18637	2836	328	to	to	IN
18637	2836	329	and	and	CC
18637	2836	330	superseded	superseded	JJ
18637	2836	331	State	State	NNP
18637	2836	332	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	2836	333	power	power	NN
18637	2836	334	over	over	IN
18637	2836	335	sales	sale	NNS
18637	2836	336	made	make	VBN
18637	2836	337	within	within	IN
18637	2836	338	a	a	DT
18637	2836	339	State	state	NN
18637	2836	340	by	by	IN
18637	2836	341	a	a	DT
18637	2836	342	natural	natural	JJ
18637	2836	343	gas	gas	NN
18637	2836	344	producing	produce	VBG
18637	2836	345	company	company	NN
18637	2836	346	to	to	IN
18637	2836	347	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	2836	348	line	line	NN
18637	2836	349	companies	company	NNS
18637	2836	350	which	which	WDT
18637	2836	351	transported	transport	VBD
18637	2836	352	the	the	DT
18637	2836	353	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	2836	354	gas	gas	NN
18637	2836	355	to	to	IN
18637	2836	356	markets	market	NNS
18637	2836	357	in	in	IN
18637	2836	358	other	other	JJ
18637	2836	359	States;[1023	states;[1023	NN
18637	2836	360	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2836	361	one	one	CD
18637	2836	362	in	in	IN
18637	2836	363	1948	1948	CD
18637	2836	364	,	,	,
18637	2836	365	in	in	IN
18637	2836	366	which	which	WDT
18637	2836	367	a	a	DT
18637	2836	368	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	2836	369	divided	divide	VBN
18637	2836	370	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2836	371	held	hold	VBD
18637	2836	372	that	that	IN
18637	2836	373	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	2836	374	law	law	NN
18637	2836	375	governing	govern	VBG
18637	2836	376	the	the	DT
18637	2836	377	rights	right	NNS
18637	2836	378	of	of	IN
18637	2836	379	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	2836	380	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	2836	381	could	could	MD
18637	2836	382	not	not	RB
18637	2836	383	be	be	VB
18637	2836	384	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2836	385	to	to	TO
18637	2836	386	embarrass	embarrass	VB
18637	2836	387	a	a	DT
18637	2836	388	merger	merger	NN
18637	2836	389	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	2836	390	between	between	IN
18637	2836	391	two	two	CD
18637	2836	392	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2836	393	companies	company	NNS
18637	2836	394	which	which	WDT
18637	2836	395	had	have	VBD
18637	2836	396	been	be	VBN
18637	2836	397	approved	approve	VBN
18637	2836	398	by	by	IN
18637	2836	399	the	the	DT
18637	2836	400	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2836	401	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2836	402	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2836	403	under	under	IN
18637	2836	404	the	the	DT
18637	2836	405	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2836	406	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2836	407	Act[1024	Act[1024	NNP
18637	2836	408	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2836	409	as	as	IN
18637	2836	410	"	"	``
18637	2836	411	just	just	RB
18637	2836	412	and	and	CC
18637	2836	413	reasonable";[1025	reasonable";[1025	.
18637	2836	414	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2836	415	and	and	CC
18637	2836	416	finally	finally	RB
18637	2836	417	one	one	CD
18637	2836	418	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2836	419	the	the	DT
18637	2836	420	same	same	JJ
18637	2836	421	year	year	NN
18637	2836	422	in	in	IN
18637	2836	423	which	which	WDT
18637	2836	424	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2836	425	was	be	VBD
18637	2836	426	held	hold	VBN
18637	2836	427	by	by	IN
18637	2836	428	a	a	DT
18637	2836	429	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	2836	430	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2836	431	that	that	WDT
18637	2836	432	the	the	DT
18637	2836	433	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	2836	434	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2836	435	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	2836	436	may	may	MD
18637	2836	437	,	,	,
18637	2836	438	in	in	IN
18637	2836	439	approving	approve	VBG
18637	2836	440	the	the	DT
18637	2836	441	acquisition	acquisition	NN
18637	2836	442	by	by	IN
18637	2836	443	a	a	DT
18637	2836	444	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2836	445	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2836	446	of	of	IN
18637	2836	447	one	one	CD
18637	2836	448	State	State	NNP
18637	2836	449	of	of	IN
18637	2836	450	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	2836	451	lines	line	NNS
18637	2836	452	in	in	IN
18637	2836	453	another	another	DT
18637	2836	454	,	,	,
18637	2836	455	relieve	relieve	VBP
18637	2836	456	such	such	JJ
18637	2836	457	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2836	458	from	from	IN
18637	2836	459	being	be	VBG
18637	2836	460	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	2836	461	under	under	IN
18637	2836	462	the	the	DT
18637	2836	463	laws	law	NNS
18637	2836	464	of	of	IN
18637	2836	465	the	the	DT
18637	2836	466	latter	latter	JJ
18637	2836	467	State	State	NNP
18637	2836	468	.	.	.
18637	2837	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2837	2	1026	1026	CD
18637	2837	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2837	4	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	2837	5	VERSUS	versu	NNS
18637	2837	6	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2837	7	LABOR	LABOR	NNP
18637	2837	8	LAWS	LAWS	NNP
18637	2837	9	One	one	CD
18637	2837	10	group	group	NN
18637	2837	11	of	of	IN
18637	2837	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	2837	13	,	,	,
18637	2837	14	which	which	WDT
18637	2837	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	2837	16	caused	cause	VBN
18637	2837	17	the	the	DT
18637	2837	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2837	19	some	some	DT
18637	2837	20	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	2837	21	and	and	CC
18637	2837	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2837	23	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	2837	24	in	in	IN
18637	2837	25	which	which	WDT
18637	2837	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	2837	27	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	2837	28	shifted	shift	VBN
18637	2837	29	in	in	IN
18637	2837	30	some	some	DT
18637	2837	31	measure	measure	NN
18637	2837	32	,	,	,
18637	2837	33	deals	deal	NNS
18637	2837	34	with	with	IN
18637	2837	35	the	the	DT
18637	2837	36	question	question	NN
18637	2837	37	of	of	IN
18637	2837	38	the	the	DT
18637	2837	39	effect	effect	NN
18637	2837	40	of	of	IN
18637	2837	41	the	the	DT
18637	2837	42	Wagner	Wagner	NNP
18637	2837	43	,	,	,
18637	2837	44	and	and	CC
18637	2837	45	,	,	,
18637	2837	46	latterly	latterly	RB
18637	2837	47	,	,	,
18637	2837	48	of	of	IN
18637	2837	49	the	the	DT
18637	2837	50	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	2837	51	-	-	HYPH
18637	2837	52	Hartley	Hartley	NNP
18637	2837	53	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2837	54	on	on	IN
18637	2837	55	State	State	NNP
18637	2837	56	power	power	NN
18637	2837	57	to	to	TO
18637	2837	58	govern	govern	VB
18637	2837	59	labor	labor	NN
18637	2837	60	union	union	NN
18637	2837	61	activities	activity	NNS
18637	2837	62	.	.	.
18637	2838	1	In	in	IN
18637	2838	2	a	a	DT
18637	2838	3	case	case	NN
18637	2838	4	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2838	5	in	in	IN
18637	2838	6	1945[1027	1945[1027	NNP
18637	2838	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2838	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2838	9	was	be	VBD
18637	2838	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	2838	11	that	that	IN
18637	2838	12	a	a	DT
18637	2838	13	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	2838	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	2838	15	which	which	WDT
18637	2838	16	required	require	VBD
18637	2838	17	business	business	NN
18637	2838	18	agents	agent	NNS
18637	2838	19	of	of	IN
18637	2838	20	a	a	DT
18637	2838	21	union	union	NN
18637	2838	22	operating	operate	VBG
18637	2838	23	in	in	IN
18637	2838	24	the	the	DT
18637	2838	25	State	State	NNP
18637	2838	26	to	to	TO
18637	2838	27	file	file	VB
18637	2838	28	annual	annual	JJ
18637	2838	29	reports	report	NNS
18637	2838	30	and	and	CC
18637	2838	31	pay	pay	VB
18637	2838	32	an	an	DT
18637	2838	33	annual	annual	JJ
18637	2838	34	fee	fee	NN
18637	2838	35	of	of	IN
18637	2838	36	one	one	CD
18637	2838	37	dollar	dollar	NN
18637	2838	38	conflicted	conflict	VBN
18637	2838	39	with	with	IN
18637	2838	40	the	the	DT
18637	2838	41	Wagner	Wagner	NNP
18637	2838	42	Act,[1028	act,[1028	XX
18637	2838	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2838	44	standing	standing	NN
18637	2838	45	,	,	,
18637	2838	46	as	as	IN
18637	2838	47	the	the	DT
18637	2838	48	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2838	49	put	put	VBD
18637	2838	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2838	51	,	,	,
18637	2838	52	"	"	''
18637	2838	53	'	'	''
18637	2838	54	as	as	IN
18637	2838	55	an	an	DT
18637	2838	56	obstacle	obstacle	NN
18637	2838	57	to	to	IN
18637	2838	58	the	the	DT
18637	2838	59	accomplishment	accomplishment	NN
18637	2838	60	and	and	CC
18637	2838	61	execution	execution	NN
18637	2838	62	of	of	IN
18637	2838	63	the	the	DT
18637	2838	64	full	full	JJ
18637	2838	65	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	2838	66	and	and	CC
18637	2838	67	objectives	objective	NNS
18637	2838	68	of	of	IN
18637	2838	69	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2838	70	.	.	.
18637	2839	1	'	'	``
18637	2839	2	"	"	``
18637	2839	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2839	4	1029	1029	CD
18637	2839	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2839	6	In	in	IN
18637	2839	7	two	two	CD
18637	2839	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	2839	9	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2839	10	in	in	IN
18637	2839	11	1949	1949	CD
18637	2839	12	,	,	,
18637	2839	13	however	however	RB
18637	2839	14	,	,	,
18637	2839	15	State	State	NNP
18637	2839	16	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2839	17	regulative	regulative	NN
18637	2839	18	of	of	IN
18637	2839	19	labor	labor	NN
18637	2839	20	relations	relation	NNS
18637	2839	21	was	be	VBD
18637	2839	22	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2839	23	.	.	.
18637	2840	1	In	in	IN
18637	2840	2	one	one	CD
18637	2840	3	a	a	DT
18637	2840	4	"	"	``
18637	2840	5	cease	cease	NN
18637	2840	6	and	and	CC
18637	2840	7	desist	desist	VB
18637	2840	8	"	"	''
18637	2840	9	order	order	NN
18637	2840	10	of	of	IN
18637	2840	11	the	the	DT
18637	2840	12	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	2840	13	Employment	Employment	NNP
18637	2840	14	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	2840	15	Board[1030	Board[1030	NNP
18637	2840	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2840	17	implementing	implement	VBG
18637	2840	18	the	the	DT
18637	2840	19	State	State	NNP
18637	2840	20	Employment	Employment	NNP
18637	2840	21	Peace	Peace	NNP
18637	2840	22	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2840	23	,	,	,
18637	2840	24	which	which	WDT
18637	2840	25	made	make	VBD
18637	2840	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2840	27	an	an	DT
18637	2840	28	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	2840	29	labor	labor	NN
18637	2840	30	practice	practice	NN
18637	2840	31	for	for	IN
18637	2840	32	an	an	DT
18637	2840	33	employee	employee	NN
18637	2840	34	to	to	TO
18637	2840	35	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	2840	36	with	with	IN
18637	2840	37	production	production	NN
18637	2840	38	except	except	IN
18637	2840	39	by	by	IN
18637	2840	40	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	2840	41	the	the	DT
18637	2840	42	premises	premise	NNS
18637	2840	43	in	in	IN
18637	2840	44	an	an	DT
18637	2840	45	orderly	orderly	JJ
18637	2840	46	manner	manner	NN
18637	2840	47	for	for	IN
18637	2840	48	the	the	DT
18637	2840	49	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2840	50	of	of	IN
18637	2840	51	going	go	VBG
18637	2840	52	on	on	IN
18637	2840	53	strike	strike	NN
18637	2840	54	,	,	,
18637	2840	55	was	be	VBD
18637	2840	56	found	find	VBN
18637	2840	57	not	not	RB
18637	2840	58	to	to	TO
18637	2840	59	conflict	conflict	VB
18637	2840	60	with	with	IN
18637	2840	61	either	either	CC
18637	2840	62	the	the	DT
18637	2840	63	Wagner	Wagner	NNP
18637	2840	64	or	or	CC
18637	2840	65	the	the	DT
18637	2840	66	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	2840	67	-	-	HYPH
18637	2840	68	Hartley	Hartley	NNP
18637	2840	69	Act,[1031	Act,[1031	NNP
18637	2840	70	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2840	71	both	both	DT
18637	2840	72	of	of	IN
18637	2840	73	which	which	WDT
18637	2840	74	,	,	,
18637	2840	75	the	the	DT
18637	2840	76	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2840	77	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	2840	78	,	,	,
18637	2840	79	designedly	designedly	RB
18637	2840	80	left	leave	VBD
18637	2840	81	open	open	RP
18637	2840	82	an	an	DT
18637	2840	83	area	area	NN
18637	2840	84	for	for	IN
18637	2840	85	State	State	NNP
18637	2840	86	control	control	NN
18637	2840	87	.	.	.
18637	2841	1	In	in	IN
18637	2841	2	the	the	DT
18637	2841	3	other,[1032	other,[1032	NNP
18637	2841	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2841	5	the	the	DT
18637	2841	6	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	2841	7	board	board	NN
18637	2841	8	,	,	,
18637	2841	9	acting	act	VBG
18637	2841	10	under	under	IN
18637	2841	11	the	the	DT
18637	2841	12	same	same	JJ
18637	2841	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	2841	14	,	,	,
18637	2841	15	was	be	VBD
18637	2841	16	held	hold	VBN
18637	2841	17	to	to	TO
18637	2841	18	be	be	VB
18637	2841	19	within	within	IN
18637	2841	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2841	21	powers	power	NNS
18637	2841	22	in	in	IN
18637	2841	23	labelling	labelling	NN
18637	2841	24	as	as	IN
18637	2841	25	"	"	``
18637	2841	26	an	an	DT
18637	2841	27	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	2841	28	labor	labor	NN
18637	2841	29	practice	practice	NN
18637	2841	30	"	"	``
18637	2841	31	the	the	DT
18637	2841	32	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	2841	33	by	by	IN
18637	2841	34	an	an	DT
18637	2841	35	employer	employer	NN
18637	2841	36	of	of	IN
18637	2841	37	an	an	DT
18637	2841	38	employee	employee	NN
18637	2841	39	under	under	IN
18637	2841	40	a	a	DT
18637	2841	41	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	2841	42	of	of	IN
18637	2841	43	membership	membership	NN
18637	2841	44	clause	clause	NN
18637	2841	45	which	which	WDT
18637	2841	46	had	have	VBD
18637	2841	47	been	be	VBN
18637	2841	48	inserted	insert	VBN
18637	2841	49	in	in	IN
18637	2841	50	the	the	DT
18637	2841	51	contract	contract	NN
18637	2841	52	of	of	IN
18637	2841	53	employment	employment	NN
18637	2841	54	in	in	IN
18637	2841	55	1943	1943	CD
18637	2841	56	under	under	IN
18637	2841	57	pressure	pressure	NN
18637	2841	58	from	from	IN
18637	2841	59	the	the	DT
18637	2841	60	National	National	NNP
18637	2841	61	War	War	NNP
18637	2841	62	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	2841	63	Board	Board	NNP
18637	2841	64	,	,	,
18637	2841	65	but	but	CC
18637	2841	66	which	which	WDT
18637	2841	67	was	be	VBD
18637	2841	68	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	2841	69	to	to	IN
18637	2841	70	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	2841	71	of	of	IN
18637	2841	72	the	the	DT
18637	2841	73	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	2841	74	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2841	75	.	.	.
18637	2842	1	On	on	IN
18637	2842	2	the	the	DT
18637	2842	3	other	other	JJ
18637	2842	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	2842	5	,	,	,
18637	2842	6	in	in	IN
18637	2842	7	1950	1950	CD
18637	2842	8	,	,	,
18637	2842	9	the	the	DT
18637	2842	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2842	11	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
18637	2842	12	a	a	DT
18637	2842	13	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	2842	14	mediation	mediation	NN
18637	2842	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	2842	16	,	,	,
18637	2842	17	and	and	CC
18637	2842	18	in	in	IN
18637	2842	19	1951	1951	CD
18637	2842	20	,	,	,
18637	2842	21	a	a	DT
18637	2842	22	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	2842	23	Public	Public	NNP
18637	2842	24	Utility	Utility	NNP
18637	2842	25	Anti	Anti	NNP
18637	2842	26	-	-	NNP
18637	2842	27	Strike	Strike	NNP
18637	2842	28	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2842	29	,	,	,
18637	2842	30	on	on	IN
18637	2842	31	the	the	DT
18637	2842	32	ground	ground	NN
18637	2842	33	that	that	IN
18637	2842	34	these	these	DT
18637	2842	35	matters	matter	NNS
18637	2842	36	were	be	VBD
18637	2842	37	governed	govern	VBN
18637	2842	38	by	by	IN
18637	2842	39	the	the	DT
18637	2842	40	policies	policy	NNS
18637	2842	41	embodied	embody	VBN
18637	2842	42	in	in	IN
18637	2842	43	the	the	DT
18637	2842	44	Wagner	Wagner	NNP
18637	2842	45	and	and	CC
18637	2842	46	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	2842	47	-	-	HYPH
18637	2842	48	Hartley	Hartley	NNP
18637	2842	49	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	2842	50	.	.	.
18637	2843	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2843	2	1033	1033	CD
18637	2843	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2843	4	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	2843	5	With	with	IN
18637	2843	6	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	2843	7	Tribes	Tribes	NNP
18637	2843	8	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	2843	9	STATES	STATES	NNP
18637	2843	10	_	_	NNP
18637	2843	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	2843	12	_	_	NNP
18637	2843	13	KAGAMA	KAGAMA	NNP
18637	2843	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2843	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	2843	16	given	give	VBN
18637	2843	17	power	power	NN
18637	2843	18	to	to	TO
18637	2843	19	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2843	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2843	21	"	"	''
18637	2843	22	with	with	IN
18637	2843	23	the	the	DT
18637	2843	24	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	2843	25	tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	2843	26	.	.	.
18637	2843	27	"	"	''
18637	2844	1	Faced	face	VBN
18637	2844	2	in	in	IN
18637	2844	3	1886	1886	CD
18637	2844	4	with	with	IN
18637	2844	5	a	a	DT
18637	2844	6	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2844	7	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	2844	8	which	which	WDT
18637	2844	9	prescribed	prescribe	VBD
18637	2844	10	a	a	DT
18637	2844	11	system	system	NN
18637	2844	12	of	of	IN
18637	2844	13	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	2844	14	laws	law	NNS
18637	2844	15	for	for	IN
18637	2844	16	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	2844	17	living	live	VBG
18637	2844	18	on	on	IN
18637	2844	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2844	20	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	2844	21	,	,	,
18637	2844	22	the	the	DT
18637	2844	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2844	24	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	2844	25	the	the	DT
18637	2844	26	government	government	NN
18637	2844	27	's	's	POS
18637	2844	28	argument	argument	NN
18637	2844	29	which	which	WDT
18637	2844	30	sought	seek	VBD
18637	2844	31	to	to	TO
18637	2844	32	base	base	VB
18637	2844	33	the	the	DT
18637	2844	34	act	act	NN
18637	2844	35	on	on	IN
18637	2844	36	the	the	DT
18637	2844	37	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2844	38	clause	clause	NN
18637	2844	39	.	.	.
18637	2845	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2845	2	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	2845	3	the	the	DT
18637	2845	4	act	act	NN
18637	2845	5	,	,	,
18637	2845	6	however	however	RB
18637	2845	7	,	,	,
18637	2845	8	on	on	IN
18637	2845	9	the	the	DT
18637	2845	10	following	following	JJ
18637	2845	11	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	2845	12	:	:	:
18637	2845	13	"	"	``
18637	2845	14	From	from	IN
18637	2845	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2845	16	very	very	JJ
18637	2845	17	weakness	weakness	NN
18637	2845	18	and	and	CC
18637	2845	19	helplessness	helplessness	NN
18637	2845	20	,	,	,
18637	2845	21	so	so	RB
18637	2845	22	largely	largely	RB
18637	2845	23	due	due	JJ
18637	2845	24	to	to	IN
18637	2845	25	the	the	DT
18637	2845	26	course	course	NN
18637	2845	27	of	of	IN
18637	2845	28	dealing	dealing	NN
18637	2845	29	of	of	IN
18637	2845	30	the	the	DT
18637	2845	31	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	2845	32	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2845	33	with	with	IN
18637	2845	34	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2845	35	and	and	CC
18637	2845	36	the	the	DT
18637	2845	37	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	2845	38	in	in	IN
18637	2845	39	which	which	WDT
18637	2845	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2845	41	has	have	VBZ
18637	2845	42	been	be	VBN
18637	2845	43	promised	promise	VBN
18637	2845	44	,	,	,
18637	2845	45	there	there	EX
18637	2845	46	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	2845	47	the	the	DT
18637	2845	48	duty	duty	NN
18637	2845	49	of	of	IN
18637	2845	50	protection	protection	NN
18637	2845	51	,	,	,
18637	2845	52	and	and	CC
18637	2845	53	with	with	IN
18637	2845	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2845	55	the	the	DT
18637	2845	56	power	power	NN
18637	2845	57	.	.	.
18637	2846	1	This	this	DT
18637	2846	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	2846	3	always	always	RB
18637	2846	4	been	be	VBN
18637	2846	5	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	2846	6	by	by	IN
18637	2846	7	the	the	DT
18637	2846	8	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	2846	9	and	and	CC
18637	2846	10	by	by	IN
18637	2846	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2846	12	,	,	,
18637	2846	13	and	and	CC
18637	2846	14	by	by	IN
18637	2846	15	this	this	DT
18637	2846	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2846	17	,	,	,
18637	2846	18	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	2846	19	the	the	DT
18637	2846	20	question	question	NN
18637	2846	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	2846	22	arisen	arise	VBN
18637	2846	23	.	.	.
18637	2847	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2847	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2847	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2847	4	The	the	DT
18637	2847	5	power	power	NN
18637	2847	6	of	of	IN
18637	2847	7	the	the	DT
18637	2847	8	General	General	NNP
18637	2847	9	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2847	10	over	over	IN
18637	2847	11	these	these	DT
18637	2847	12	remnants	remnant	NNS
18637	2847	13	of	of	IN
18637	2847	14	a	a	DT
18637	2847	15	race	race	NN
18637	2847	16	once	once	RB
18637	2847	17	powerful	powerful	JJ
18637	2847	18	,	,	,
18637	2847	19	now	now	RB
18637	2847	20	weak	weak	JJ
18637	2847	21	and	and	CC
18637	2847	22	diminished	diminish	VBN
18637	2847	23	in	in	IN
18637	2847	24	numbers	number	NNS
18637	2847	25	,	,	,
18637	2847	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	2847	27	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2847	28	to	to	IN
18637	2847	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2847	30	protection	protection	NN
18637	2847	31	,	,	,
18637	2847	32	as	as	RB
18637	2847	33	well	well	RB
18637	2847	34	as	as	IN
18637	2847	35	to	to	IN
18637	2847	36	the	the	DT
18637	2847	37	safety	safety	NN
18637	2847	38	of	of	IN
18637	2847	39	those	those	DT
18637	2847	40	among	among	IN
18637	2847	41	whom	whom	WP
18637	2847	42	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2847	43	dwell	dwell	VBP
18637	2847	44	.	.	.
18637	2848	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2848	2	must	must	MD
18637	2848	3	exist	exist	VB
18637	2848	4	in	in	IN
18637	2848	5	that	that	DT
18637	2848	6	government	government	NN
18637	2848	7	,	,	,
18637	2848	8	because	because	IN
18637	2848	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2848	10	never	never	RB
18637	2848	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	2848	12	existed	exist	VBN
18637	2848	13	anywhere	anywhere	RB
18637	2848	14	else	else	RB
18637	2848	15	,	,	,
18637	2848	16	because	because	IN
18637	2848	17	the	the	DT
18637	2848	18	theatre	theatre	NN
18637	2848	19	of	of	IN
18637	2848	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2848	21	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2848	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	2848	23	within	within	IN
18637	2848	24	the	the	DT
18637	2848	25	geographical	geographical	JJ
18637	2848	26	limits	limit	NNS
18637	2848	27	of	of	IN
18637	2848	28	the	the	DT
18637	2848	29	United	United	NNP
18637	2848	30	States	States	NNP
18637	2848	31	,	,	,
18637	2848	32	because	because	IN
18637	2848	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2848	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	2848	35	never	never	RB
18637	2848	36	been	be	VBN
18637	2848	37	denied	deny	VBN
18637	2848	38	,	,	,
18637	2848	39	and	and	CC
18637	2848	40	because	because	IN
18637	2848	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2848	42	alone	alone	RB
18637	2848	43	can	can	MD
18637	2848	44	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	2848	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2848	46	laws	law	NNS
18637	2848	47	on	on	IN
18637	2848	48	all	all	PDT
18637	2848	49	the	the	DT
18637	2848	50	tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	2848	51	.	.	.
18637	2848	52	"	"	''
18637	2849	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	2849	2	,	,	,
18637	2849	3	such	such	JJ
18637	2849	4	power	power	NN
18637	2849	5	was	be	VBD
18637	2849	6	operative	operative	JJ
18637	2849	7	within	within	IN
18637	2849	8	the	the	DT
18637	2849	9	States	States	NNP
18637	2849	10	.	.	.
18637	2850	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2850	2	1034	1034	CD
18637	2850	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2850	4	Obviously	obviously	RB
18637	2850	5	,	,	,
18637	2850	6	this	this	DT
18637	2850	7	line	line	NN
18637	2850	8	of	of	IN
18637	2850	9	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	2850	10	renders	render	NNS
18637	2850	11	the	the	DT
18637	2850	12	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2850	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	2850	14	superfluous	superfluous	JJ
18637	2850	15	as	as	IN
18637	2850	16	a	a	DT
18637	2850	17	source	source	NN
18637	2850	18	of	of	IN
18637	2850	19	power	power	NN
18637	2850	20	over	over	IN
18637	2850	21	the	the	DT
18637	2850	22	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	2850	23	tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	2850	24	;	;	:
18637	2850	25	and	and	CC
18637	2850	26	some	some	DT
18637	2850	27	years	year	NNS
18637	2850	28	earlier	early	RBR
18637	2850	29	,	,	,
18637	2850	30	in	in	IN
18637	2850	31	1871	1871	CD
18637	2850	32	,	,	,
18637	2850	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2850	34	had	have	VBD
18637	2850	35	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	2850	36	the	the	DT
18637	2850	37	further	further	JJ
18637	2850	38	making	making	NN
18637	2850	39	of	of	IN
18637	2850	40	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	2850	41	with	with	IN
18637	2850	42	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2850	43	.	.	.
18637	2851	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2851	2	1035	1035	CD
18637	2851	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2851	4	However	however	RB
18637	2851	5	,	,	,
18637	2851	6	by	by	IN
18637	2851	7	a	a	DT
18637	2851	8	characteristic	characteristic	JJ
18637	2851	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	2851	10	device	device	NN
18637	2851	11	the	the	DT
18637	2851	12	effort	effort	NN
18637	2851	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	2851	14	been	be	VBN
18637	2851	15	made	make	VBN
18637	2851	16	at	at	IN
18637	2851	17	times	time	NNS
18637	2851	18	to	to	TO
18637	2851	19	absorb	absorb	VB
18637	2851	20	the	the	DT
18637	2851	21	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2851	22	of	of	IN
18637	2851	23	the	the	DT
18637	2851	24	Kagama	Kagama	NNP
18637	2851	25	case	case	NN
18637	2851	26	into	into	IN
18637	2851	27	the	the	DT
18637	2851	28	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2851	29	clause,[1036	clause,[1036	NNP
18637	2851	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2851	31	although	although	IN
18637	2851	32	more	more	JJR
18637	2851	33	commonly	commonly	RB
18637	2851	34	the	the	DT
18637	2851	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2851	36	,	,	,
18637	2851	37	in	in	IN
18637	2851	38	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	2851	39	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2851	40	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2851	41	,	,	,
18637	2851	42	prefers	prefer	VBZ
18637	2851	43	to	to	TO
18637	2851	44	treat	treat	VB
18637	2851	45	the	the	DT
18637	2851	46	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2851	47	clause	clause	NNP
18637	2851	48	and	and	CC
18637	2851	49	"	"	``
18637	2851	50	the	the	DT
18637	2851	51	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	2851	52	relations	relation	NNS
18637	2851	53	of	of	IN
18637	2851	54	tribal	tribal	JJ
18637	2851	55	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	2851	56	,	,	,
18637	2851	57	"	"	''
18637	2851	58	as	as	IN
18637	2851	59	joint	joint	JJ
18637	2851	60	sources	source	NNS
18637	2851	61	of	of	IN
18637	2851	62	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2851	63	's	's	POS
18637	2851	64	power	power	NN
18637	2851	65	.	.	.
18637	2852	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2852	2	1037	1037	CD
18637	2852	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2852	4	Most	Most	JJS
18637	2852	5	of	of	IN
18637	2852	6	the	the	DT
18637	2852	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	2852	8	have	have	VBP
18637	2852	9	arisen	arise	VBN
18637	2852	10	,	,	,
18637	2852	11	in	in	IN
18637	2852	12	fact	fact	NN
18637	2852	13	,	,	,
18637	2852	14	in	in	IN
18637	2852	15	connection	connection	NN
18637	2852	16	with	with	IN
18637	2852	17	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	2852	18	by	by	IN
18637	2852	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2852	20	to	to	TO
18637	2852	21	ban	ban	VB
18637	2852	22	the	the	DT
18637	2852	23	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2852	24	in	in	IN
18637	2852	25	"	"	``
18637	2852	26	fire	fire	NN
18637	2852	27	water	water	NN
18637	2852	28	"	"	''
18637	2852	29	with	with	IN
18637	2852	30	tribal	tribal	JJ
18637	2852	31	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	2852	32	.	.	.
18637	2853	1	In	in	IN
18637	2853	2	this	this	DT
18637	2853	3	connection	connection	NN
18637	2853	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2853	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	2853	6	been	be	VBN
18637	2853	7	held	hold	VBN
18637	2853	8	that	that	IN
18637	2853	9	even	even	RB
18637	2853	10	though	though	IN
18637	2853	11	an	an	DT
18637	2853	12	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	2853	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	2853	14	become	become	VBN
18637	2853	15	a	a	DT
18637	2853	16	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2853	17	,	,	,
18637	2853	18	yet	yet	CC
18637	2853	19	so	so	RB
18637	2853	20	long	long	RB
18637	2853	21	as	as	IN
18637	2853	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2853	23	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	2853	24	a	a	DT
18637	2853	25	member	member	NN
18637	2853	26	of	of	IN
18637	2853	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2853	28	tribe	tribe	NN
18637	2853	29	,	,	,
18637	2853	30	under	under	IN
18637	2853	31	the	the	DT
18637	2853	32	charge	charge	NN
18637	2853	33	of	of	IN
18637	2853	34	an	an	DT
18637	2853	35	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	2853	36	agent	agent	NN
18637	2853	37	,	,	,
18637	2853	38	and	and	CC
18637	2853	39	so	so	RB
18637	2853	40	long	long	RB
18637	2853	41	as	as	IN
18637	2853	42	the	the	DT
18637	2853	43	United	United	NNP
18637	2853	44	States	States	NNP
18637	2853	45	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	2853	46	in	in	IN
18637	2853	47	trust	trust	NN
18637	2853	48	the	the	DT
18637	2853	49	title	title	NN
18637	2853	50	to	to	TO
18637	2853	51	land	land	NN
18637	2853	52	which	which	WDT
18637	2853	53	has	have	VBZ
18637	2853	54	been	be	VBN
18637	2853	55	allotted	allot	VBN
18637	2853	56	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2853	57	,	,	,
18637	2853	58	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2853	59	can	can	MD
18637	2853	60	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	2853	61	the	the	DT
18637	2853	62	sale	sale	NN
18637	2853	63	of	of	IN
18637	2853	64	intoxicants	intoxicant	NNS
18637	2853	65	to	to	IN
18637	2853	66	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2853	67	.	.	.
18637	2854	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2854	2	1038	1038	CD
18637	2854	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2854	4	Also	also	RB
18637	2854	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2854	6	can	can	MD
18637	2854	7	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2854	8	the	the	DT
18637	2854	9	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	2854	10	of	of	IN
18637	2854	11	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	2854	12	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	2854	13	into	into	IN
18637	2854	14	land	land	NN
18637	2854	15	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	2854	16	by	by	IN
18637	2854	17	a	a	DT
18637	2854	18	tribe	tribe	NN
18637	2854	19	of	of	IN
18637	2854	20	uncivilized	uncivilized	JJ
18637	2854	21	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	2854	22	within	within	IN
18637	2854	23	territory	territory	NN
18637	2854	24	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	2854	25	to	to	IN
18637	2854	26	statehood	statehood	NN
18637	2854	27	.	.	.
18637	2855	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2855	2	1039	1039	CD
18637	2855	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2855	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	2855	5	can	can	MD
18637	2855	6	a	a	DT
18637	2855	7	State	state	NN
18637	2855	8	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	2855	9	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	2855	10	within	within	IN
18637	2855	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2855	12	borders	border	NNS
18637	2855	13	from	from	IN
18637	2855	14	the	the	DT
18637	2855	15	operation	operation	NN
18637	2855	16	of	of	IN
18637	2855	17	acts	act	NNS
18637	2855	18	of	of	IN
18637	2855	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2855	20	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	2855	21	trade	trade	NN
18637	2855	22	with	with	IN
18637	2855	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2855	24	by	by	IN
18637	2855	25	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	2855	26	on	on	IN
18637	2855	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2855	28	rights	right	NNS
18637	2855	29	of	of	IN
18637	2855	30	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	2855	31	and	and	CC
18637	2855	32	suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	2855	33	,	,	,
18637	2855	34	whether	whether	IN
18637	2855	35	by	by	IN
18637	2855	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2855	37	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	2855	38	or	or	CC
18637	2855	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2855	40	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	2855	41	.	.	.
18637	2856	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2856	2	1040	1040	CD
18637	2856	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2856	4	And	and	CC
18637	2856	5	when	when	WRB
18637	2856	6	a	a	DT
18637	2856	7	State	state	NN
18637	2856	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	2856	9	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	2856	10	into	into	IN
18637	2856	11	the	the	DT
18637	2856	12	Union	Union	NNP
18637	2856	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2856	14	may	may	MD
18637	2856	15	,	,	,
18637	2856	16	in	in	IN
18637	2856	17	the	the	DT
18637	2856	18	enabling	enable	VBG
18637	2856	19	act	act	NN
18637	2856	20	,	,	,
18637	2856	21	reserve	reserve	NN
18637	2856	22	authority	authority	NN
18637	2856	23	to	to	TO
18637	2856	24	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	2856	25	in	in	IN
18637	2856	26	the	the	DT
18637	2856	27	future	future	NN
18637	2856	28	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	2856	29	the	the	DT
18637	2856	30	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	2856	31	residing	reside	VBG
18637	2856	32	within	within	IN
18637	2856	33	the	the	DT
18637	2856	34	new	new	JJ
18637	2856	35	State	State	NNP
18637	2856	36	,	,	,
18637	2856	37	and	and	CC
18637	2856	38	may	may	MD
18637	2856	39	declare	declare	VB
18637	2856	40	that	that	IN
18637	2856	41	existing	exist	VBG
18637	2856	42	acts	act	NNS
18637	2856	43	of	of	IN
18637	2856	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2856	45	relating	relate	VBG
18637	2856	46	to	to	IN
18637	2856	47	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	2856	48	and	and	CC
18637	2856	49	intercourse	intercourse	VB
18637	2856	50	with	with	IN
18637	2856	51	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2856	52	shall	shall	MD
18637	2856	53	remain	remain	VB
18637	2856	54	in	in	IN
18637	2856	55	force	force	NN
18637	2856	56	.	.	.
18637	2857	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2857	2	1041	1041	CD
18637	2857	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2857	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	2857	5	4	4	CD
18637	2857	6	.	.	.
18637	2858	1	_	_	NNP
18637	2858	2	The	the	DT
18637	2858	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2858	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	2858	5	have	have	VB
18637	2858	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	2858	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2858	8	*	*	NFP
18637	2858	9	*	*	NFP
18637	2858	10	*	*	NFP
18637	2858	11	To	to	TO
18637	2858	12	establish	establish	VB
18637	2858	13	an	an	DT
18637	2858	14	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2858	15	Rule	rule	NN
18637	2858	16	of	of	IN
18637	2858	17	Naturalization	Naturalization	NNP
18637	2858	18	,	,	,
18637	2858	19	and	and	CC
18637	2858	20	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2858	21	Laws	law	NNS
18637	2858	22	on	on	IN
18637	2858	23	the	the	DT
18637	2858	24	subject	subject	NN
18637	2858	25	of	of	IN
18637	2858	26	Bankruptcies	Bankruptcies	NNPS
18637	2858	27	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	2858	28	the	the	DT
18637	2858	29	United	United	NNP
18637	2858	30	States	States	NNP
18637	2858	31	.	.	.
18637	2859	1	Naturalization	Naturalization	NNP
18637	2859	2	and	and	CC
18637	2859	3	Citizenship	Citizenship	NNP
18637	2859	4	CATEGORIES	category	NNS
18637	2859	5	OF	of	IN
18637	2859	6	NATURALIZED	NATURALIZED	NNP
18637	2859	7	PERSONS	PERSONS	NNP
18637	2859	8	Naturalization	Naturalization	NNP
18637	2859	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	2859	10	been	be	VBN
18637	2859	11	defined	define	VBN
18637	2859	12	by	by	IN
18637	2859	13	the	the	DT
18637	2859	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2859	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2859	16	as	as	IN
18637	2859	17	"	"	``
18637	2859	18	the	the	DT
18637	2859	19	act	act	NN
18637	2859	20	of	of	IN
18637	2859	21	adopting	adopt	VBG
18637	2859	22	a	a	DT
18637	2859	23	foreigner	foreigner	NN
18637	2859	24	,	,	,
18637	2859	25	and	and	CC
18637	2859	26	clothing	clothe	VBG
18637	2859	27	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2859	28	with	with	IN
18637	2859	29	the	the	DT
18637	2859	30	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	2859	31	of	of	IN
18637	2859	32	a	a	DT
18637	2859	33	native	native	JJ
18637	2859	34	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2859	35	,	,	,
18637	2859	36	*	*	NFP
18637	2859	37	*	*	NFP
18637	2859	38	*	*	NFP
18637	2859	39	"	"	''
18637	2859	40	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2859	41	1042	1042	CD
18637	2859	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2859	43	In	in	IN
18637	2859	44	the	the	DT
18637	2859	45	Dred	Dred	NNP
18637	2859	46	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	2859	47	Case,[1043	Case,[1043	NNP
18637	2859	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2859	49	the	the	DT
18637	2859	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2859	51	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	2859	52	that	that	IN
18637	2859	53	the	the	DT
18637	2859	54	power	power	NN
18637	2859	55	of	of	IN
18637	2859	56	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2859	57	under	under	IN
18637	2859	58	this	this	DT
18637	2859	59	clause	clause	NN
18637	2859	60	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	2859	61	only	only	RB
18637	2859	62	to	to	TO
18637	2859	63	"	"	``
18637	2859	64	persons	person	NNS
18637	2859	65	born	bear	VBN
18637	2859	66	in	in	IN
18637	2859	67	a	a	DT
18637	2859	68	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2859	69	country	country	NN
18637	2859	70	,	,	,
18637	2859	71	under	under	IN
18637	2859	72	a	a	DT
18637	2859	73	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2859	74	government	government	NN
18637	2859	75	.	.	.
18637	2860	1	"	"	``
18637	2860	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2860	3	1044	1044	CD
18637	2860	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2860	5	These	these	DT
18637	2860	6	dicta	dictum	NNS
18637	2860	7	are	be	VBP
18637	2860	8	much	much	RB
18637	2860	9	too	too	RB
18637	2860	10	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	2860	11	to	to	TO
18637	2860	12	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	2860	13	the	the	DT
18637	2860	14	power	power	NN
18637	2860	15	which	which	WDT
18637	2860	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2860	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	2860	18	actually	actually	RB
18637	2860	19	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	2860	20	on	on	IN
18637	2860	21	the	the	DT
18637	2860	22	subject	subject	NN
18637	2860	23	.	.	.
18637	2861	1	The	the	DT
18637	2861	2	competence	competence	NN
18637	2861	3	of	of	IN
18637	2861	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2861	5	in	in	IN
18637	2861	6	this	this	DT
18637	2861	7	field	field	NN
18637	2861	8	merges	merge	NNS
18637	2861	9	,	,	,
18637	2861	10	in	in	IN
18637	2861	11	fact	fact	NN
18637	2861	12	,	,	,
18637	2861	13	with	with	IN
18637	2861	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2861	15	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	2861	16	,	,	,
18637	2861	17	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	2861	18	powers	power	NNS
18637	2861	19	in	in	IN
18637	2861	20	the	the	DT
18637	2861	21	field	field	NN
18637	2861	22	of	of	IN
18637	2861	23	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2861	24	relations	relation	NNS
18637	2861	25	.	.	.
18637	2862	1	In	in	IN
18637	2862	2	the	the	DT
18637	2862	3	words	word	NNS
18637	2862	4	of	of	IN
18637	2862	5	the	the	DT
18637	2862	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2862	7	:	:	:
18637	2862	8	"	"	``
18637	2862	9	As	as	IN
18637	2862	10	a	a	DT
18637	2862	11	government	government	NN
18637	2862	12	,	,	,
18637	2862	13	the	the	DT
18637	2862	14	United	United	NNP
18637	2862	15	States	States	NNP
18637	2862	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	2862	17	invested	invest	VBN
18637	2862	18	with	with	IN
18637	2862	19	all	all	PDT
18637	2862	20	the	the	DT
18637	2862	21	attributes	attribute	NNS
18637	2862	22	of	of	IN
18637	2862	23	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	2862	24	.	.	.
18637	2863	1	As	as	IN
18637	2863	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2863	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	2863	4	the	the	DT
18637	2863	5	character	character	NN
18637	2863	6	of	of	IN
18637	2863	7	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	2863	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2863	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	2863	10	the	the	DT
18637	2863	11	powers	power	NNS
18637	2863	12	of	of	IN
18637	2863	13	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	2863	14	,	,	,
18637	2863	15	especially	especially	RB
18637	2863	16	those	those	DT
18637	2863	17	which	which	WDT
18637	2863	18	concern	concern	VBP
18637	2863	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2863	20	relations	relation	NNS
18637	2863	21	and	and	CC
18637	2863	22	intercourse	intercourse	VB
18637	2863	23	with	with	IN
18637	2863	24	other	other	JJ
18637	2863	25	countries	country	NNS
18637	2863	26	.	.	.
18637	2864	1	"	"	``
18637	2864	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2864	3	1045	1045	CD
18637	2864	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2864	5	By	by	IN
18637	2864	6	the	the	DT
18637	2864	7	Immigration	Immigration	NNP
18637	2864	8	and	and	CC
18637	2864	9	Nationality	Nationality	NNP
18637	2864	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2864	11	of	of	IN
18637	2864	12	June	June	NNP
18637	2864	13	27	27	CD
18637	2864	14	,	,	,
18637	2864	15	1952,[1046	1952,[1046	CD
18637	2864	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2864	17	which	which	WDT
18637	2864	18	codifies	codify	VBZ
18637	2864	19	much	much	JJ
18637	2864	20	previous	previous	JJ
18637	2864	21	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2864	22	,	,	,
18637	2864	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2864	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	2864	25	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	2864	26	that	that	IN
18637	2864	27	the	the	DT
18637	2864	28	following	follow	VBG
18637	2864	29	shall	shall	MD
18637	2864	30	be	be	VB
18637	2864	31	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	2864	32	of	of	IN
18637	2864	33	the	the	DT
18637	2864	34	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	35	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	36	at	at	IN
18637	2864	37	birth	birth	NN
18637	2864	38	:	:	:
18637	2864	39	"	"	''
18637	2864	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2864	41	1	1	LS
18637	2864	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2864	43	a	a	DT
18637	2864	44	person	person	NN
18637	2864	45	born	bear	VBN
18637	2864	46	in	in	IN
18637	2864	47	the	the	DT
18637	2864	48	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	49	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	50	,	,	,
18637	2864	51	and	and	CC
18637	2864	52	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2864	53	to	to	IN
18637	2864	54	the	the	DT
18637	2864	55	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2864	56	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	2864	57	;	;	:
18637	2864	58	"	"	''
18637	2864	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2864	60	2	2	LS
18637	2864	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2864	62	a	a	DT
18637	2864	63	person	person	NN
18637	2864	64	born	bear	VBN
18637	2864	65	in	in	IN
18637	2864	66	the	the	DT
18637	2864	67	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	68	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	69	to	to	IN
18637	2864	70	a	a	DT
18637	2864	71	member	member	NN
18637	2864	72	of	of	IN
18637	2864	73	an	an	DT
18637	2864	74	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	2864	75	,	,	,
18637	2864	76	Eskimo	Eskimo	NNP
18637	2864	77	,	,	,
18637	2864	78	Aleutian	Aleutian	NNP
18637	2864	79	,	,	,
18637	2864	80	or	or	CC
18637	2864	81	other	other	JJ
18637	2864	82	aboriginal	aboriginal	JJ
18637	2864	83	tribe	tribe	NN
18637	2864	84	:	:	:
18637	2864	85	_	_	NNP
18637	2864	86	Provided	Provided	NNP
18637	2864	87	_	_	NNP
18637	2864	88	,	,	,
18637	2864	89	That	that	IN
18637	2864	90	the	the	DT
18637	2864	91	granting	granting	NN
18637	2864	92	of	of	IN
18637	2864	93	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	2864	94	under	under	IN
18637	2864	95	this	this	DT
18637	2864	96	subsection	subsection	NN
18637	2864	97	shall	shall	MD
18637	2864	98	not	not	RB
18637	2864	99	in	in	IN
18637	2864	100	any	any	DT
18637	2864	101	manner	manner	NN
18637	2864	102	impair	impair	NN
18637	2864	103	or	or	CC
18637	2864	104	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	2864	105	affect	affect	VB
18637	2864	106	the	the	DT
18637	2864	107	right	right	NN
18637	2864	108	of	of	IN
18637	2864	109	such	such	JJ
18637	2864	110	person	person	NN
18637	2864	111	to	to	IN
18637	2864	112	tribal	tribal	JJ
18637	2864	113	or	or	CC
18637	2864	114	other	other	JJ
18637	2864	115	property	property	NN
18637	2864	116	;	;	:
18637	2864	117	"	"	''
18637	2864	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2864	119	3	3	LS
18637	2864	120	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2864	121	a	a	DT
18637	2864	122	person	person	NN
18637	2864	123	born	bear	VBN
18637	2864	124	outside	outside	RB
18637	2864	125	of	of	IN
18637	2864	126	the	the	DT
18637	2864	127	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	128	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	129	and	and	CC
18637	2864	130	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2864	131	outlying	outlying	JJ
18637	2864	132	possessions	possession	NNS
18637	2864	133	of	of	IN
18637	2864	134	parents	parent	NNS
18637	2864	135	both	both	DT
18637	2864	136	of	of	IN
18637	2864	137	whom	whom	WP
18637	2864	138	are	be	VBP
18637	2864	139	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	2864	140	of	of	IN
18637	2864	141	the	the	DT
18637	2864	142	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	143	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	144	and	and	CC
18637	2864	145	one	one	CD
18637	2864	146	of	of	IN
18637	2864	147	whom	whom	WP
18637	2864	148	has	have	VBZ
18637	2864	149	had	have	VBN
18637	2864	150	a	a	DT
18637	2864	151	residence	residence	NN
18637	2864	152	in	in	IN
18637	2864	153	the	the	DT
18637	2864	154	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	155	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	156	or	or	CC
18637	2864	157	one	one	CD
18637	2864	158	of	of	IN
18637	2864	159	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2864	160	outlying	outlying	JJ
18637	2864	161	possessions	possession	NNS
18637	2864	162	,	,	,
18637	2864	163	prior	prior	RB
18637	2864	164	to	to	IN
18637	2864	165	the	the	DT
18637	2864	166	birth	birth	NN
18637	2864	167	of	of	IN
18637	2864	168	such	such	JJ
18637	2864	169	person	person	NN
18637	2864	170	;	;	:
18637	2864	171	"	"	''
18637	2864	172	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2864	173	4	4	LS
18637	2864	174	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2864	175	a	a	DT
18637	2864	176	person	person	NN
18637	2864	177	born	bear	VBN
18637	2864	178	outside	outside	RB
18637	2864	179	of	of	IN
18637	2864	180	the	the	DT
18637	2864	181	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	182	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	183	and	and	CC
18637	2864	184	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2864	185	outlying	outlying	JJ
18637	2864	186	possessions	possession	NNS
18637	2864	187	of	of	IN
18637	2864	188	parents	parent	NNS
18637	2864	189	one	one	CD
18637	2864	190	of	of	IN
18637	2864	191	whom	whom	WP
18637	2864	192	is	be	VBZ
18637	2864	193	a	a	DT
18637	2864	194	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2864	195	of	of	IN
18637	2864	196	the	the	DT
18637	2864	197	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	198	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	199	who	who	WP
18637	2864	200	has	have	VBZ
18637	2864	201	been	be	VBN
18637	2864	202	physically	physically	RB
18637	2864	203	present	present	JJ
18637	2864	204	in	in	IN
18637	2864	205	the	the	DT
18637	2864	206	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	207	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	208	or	or	CC
18637	2864	209	one	one	CD
18637	2864	210	of	of	IN
18637	2864	211	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2864	212	outlying	outlying	JJ
18637	2864	213	possessions	possession	NNS
18637	2864	214	for	for	IN
18637	2864	215	a	a	DT
18637	2864	216	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	2864	217	period	period	NN
18637	2864	218	of	of	IN
18637	2864	219	one	one	CD
18637	2864	220	year	year	NN
18637	2864	221	prior	prior	RB
18637	2864	222	to	to	IN
18637	2864	223	the	the	DT
18637	2864	224	birth	birth	NN
18637	2864	225	of	of	IN
18637	2864	226	such	such	JJ
18637	2864	227	person	person	NN
18637	2864	228	,	,	,
18637	2864	229	and	and	CC
18637	2864	230	the	the	DT
18637	2864	231	other	other	JJ
18637	2864	232	of	of	IN
18637	2864	233	whom	whom	WP
18637	2864	234	is	be	VBZ
18637	2864	235	a	a	DT
18637	2864	236	national	national	JJ
18637	2864	237	,	,	,
18637	2864	238	but	but	CC
18637	2864	239	not	not	RB
18637	2864	240	a	a	DT
18637	2864	241	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2864	242	of	of	IN
18637	2864	243	the	the	DT
18637	2864	244	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	245	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	246	;	;	:
18637	2864	247	"	"	''
18637	2864	248	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2864	249	5	5	LS
18637	2864	250	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2864	251	a	a	DT
18637	2864	252	person	person	NN
18637	2864	253	born	bear	VBN
18637	2864	254	in	in	IN
18637	2864	255	an	an	DT
18637	2864	256	outlying	outlying	JJ
18637	2864	257	possession	possession	NN
18637	2864	258	of	of	IN
18637	2864	259	the	the	DT
18637	2864	260	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	261	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	262	of	of	IN
18637	2864	263	parents	parent	NNS
18637	2864	264	one	one	CD
18637	2864	265	of	of	IN
18637	2864	266	whom	whom	WP
18637	2864	267	is	be	VBZ
18637	2864	268	a	a	DT
18637	2864	269	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2864	270	of	of	IN
18637	2864	271	the	the	DT
18637	2864	272	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	273	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	274	who	who	WP
18637	2864	275	has	have	VBZ
18637	2864	276	been	be	VBN
18637	2864	277	physically	physically	RB
18637	2864	278	present	present	JJ
18637	2864	279	in	in	IN
18637	2864	280	the	the	DT
18637	2864	281	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	282	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	283	or	or	CC
18637	2864	284	one	one	CD
18637	2864	285	of	of	IN
18637	2864	286	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2864	287	outlying	outlying	JJ
18637	2864	288	possessions	possession	NNS
18637	2864	289	for	for	IN
18637	2864	290	a	a	DT
18637	2864	291	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	2864	292	period	period	NN
18637	2864	293	of	of	IN
18637	2864	294	one	one	CD
18637	2864	295	year	year	NN
18637	2864	296	at	at	IN
18637	2864	297	any	any	DT
18637	2864	298	time	time	NN
18637	2864	299	prior	prior	RB
18637	2864	300	to	to	IN
18637	2864	301	the	the	DT
18637	2864	302	birth	birth	NN
18637	2864	303	of	of	IN
18637	2864	304	such	such	JJ
18637	2864	305	person	person	NN
18637	2864	306	;	;	:
18637	2864	307	"	"	''
18637	2864	308	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2864	309	6	6	LS
18637	2864	310	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2864	311	a	a	DT
18637	2864	312	person	person	NN
18637	2864	313	of	of	IN
18637	2864	314	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	2864	315	parentage	parentage	NN
18637	2864	316	found	find	VBN
18637	2864	317	in	in	IN
18637	2864	318	the	the	DT
18637	2864	319	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	320	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	321	while	while	IN
18637	2864	322	under	under	IN
18637	2864	323	the	the	DT
18637	2864	324	age	age	NN
18637	2864	325	of	of	IN
18637	2864	326	five	five	CD
18637	2864	327	years	year	NNS
18637	2864	328	,	,	,
18637	2864	329	until	until	IN
18637	2864	330	shown	show	VBN
18637	2864	331	,	,	,
18637	2864	332	prior	prior	RB
18637	2864	333	to	to	IN
18637	2864	334	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2864	335	attaining	attaining	NN
18637	2864	336	the	the	DT
18637	2864	337	age	age	NN
18637	2864	338	of	of	IN
18637	2864	339	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	2864	340	-	-	HYPH
18637	2864	341	one	one	CD
18637	2864	342	years	year	NNS
18637	2864	343	,	,	,
18637	2864	344	not	not	RB
18637	2864	345	to	to	TO
18637	2864	346	have	have	VB
18637	2864	347	been	be	VBN
18637	2864	348	born	bear	VBN
18637	2864	349	in	in	IN
18637	2864	350	the	the	DT
18637	2864	351	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	352	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	353	;	;	:
18637	2864	354	"	"	''
18637	2864	355	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2864	356	7	7	LS
18637	2864	357	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2864	358	a	a	DT
18637	2864	359	person	person	NN
18637	2864	360	born	bear	VBN
18637	2864	361	outside	outside	IN
18637	2864	362	the	the	DT
18637	2864	363	geographical	geographical	JJ
18637	2864	364	limits	limit	NNS
18637	2864	365	of	of	IN
18637	2864	366	the	the	DT
18637	2864	367	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	368	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	369	and	and	CC
18637	2864	370	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2864	371	outlying	outlying	JJ
18637	2864	372	possessions	possession	NNS
18637	2864	373	of	of	IN
18637	2864	374	parents	parent	NNS
18637	2864	375	one	one	CD
18637	2864	376	of	of	IN
18637	2864	377	whom	whom	WP
18637	2864	378	is	be	VBZ
18637	2864	379	an	an	DT
18637	2864	380	alien	alien	NN
18637	2864	381	,	,	,
18637	2864	382	and	and	CC
18637	2864	383	the	the	DT
18637	2864	384	other	other	JJ
18637	2864	385	a	a	DT
18637	2864	386	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2864	387	of	of	IN
18637	2864	388	the	the	DT
18637	2864	389	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	390	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	391	who	who	WP
18637	2864	392	,	,	,
18637	2864	393	prior	prior	RB
18637	2864	394	to	to	IN
18637	2864	395	the	the	DT
18637	2864	396	birth	birth	NN
18637	2864	397	of	of	IN
18637	2864	398	such	such	JJ
18637	2864	399	person	person	NN
18637	2864	400	,	,	,
18637	2864	401	was	be	VBD
18637	2864	402	physically	physically	RB
18637	2864	403	present	present	JJ
18637	2864	404	in	in	IN
18637	2864	405	the	the	DT
18637	2864	406	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	407	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	408	or	or	CC
18637	2864	409	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2864	410	outlying	outlying	JJ
18637	2864	411	possessions	possession	NNS
18637	2864	412	for	for	IN
18637	2864	413	a	a	DT
18637	2864	414	period	period	NN
18637	2864	415	or	or	CC
18637	2864	416	periods	period	NNS
18637	2864	417	totaling	total	VBG
18637	2864	418	not	not	RB
18637	2864	419	less	less	JJR
18637	2864	420	than	than	IN
18637	2864	421	ten	ten	CD
18637	2864	422	years	year	NNS
18637	2864	423	,	,	,
18637	2864	424	at	at	RB
18637	2864	425	least	least	JJS
18637	2864	426	five	five	CD
18637	2864	427	of	of	IN
18637	2864	428	which	which	WDT
18637	2864	429	were	be	VBD
18637	2864	430	after	after	IN
18637	2864	431	attaining	attain	VBG
18637	2864	432	the	the	DT
18637	2864	433	age	age	NN
18637	2864	434	of	of	IN
18637	2864	435	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	2864	436	years	year	NNS
18637	2864	437	:	:	:
18637	2864	438	_	_	NNP
18637	2864	439	Provided	Provided	NNP
18637	2864	440	_	_	NNP
18637	2864	441	,	,	,
18637	2864	442	That	that	IN
18637	2864	443	any	any	DT
18637	2864	444	periods	period	NNS
18637	2864	445	of	of	IN
18637	2864	446	honorable	honorable	JJ
18637	2864	447	service	service	NN
18637	2864	448	in	in	IN
18637	2864	449	the	the	DT
18637	2864	450	Armed	Armed	NNP
18637	2864	451	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	2864	452	of	of	IN
18637	2864	453	the	the	DT
18637	2864	454	United	United	NNP
18637	2864	455	States	States	NNP
18637	2864	456	by	by	IN
18637	2864	457	such	such	JJ
18637	2864	458	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2864	459	parent	parent	NN
18637	2864	460	may	may	MD
18637	2864	461	be	be	VB
18637	2864	462	included	include	VBN
18637	2864	463	in	in	IN
18637	2864	464	computing	compute	VBG
18637	2864	465	the	the	DT
18637	2864	466	physical	physical	JJ
18637	2864	467	presence	presence	NN
18637	2864	468	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	2864	469	of	of	IN
18637	2864	470	this	this	DT
18637	2864	471	paragraph	paragraph	NN
18637	2864	472	.	.	.
18637	2865	1	"	"	``
18637	2865	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2865	3	1047	1047	CD
18637	2865	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2865	5	By	by	IN
18637	2865	6	the	the	DT
18637	2865	7	same	same	JJ
18637	2865	8	act	act	NN
18637	2865	9	,	,	,
18637	2865	10	"	"	''
18637	2865	11	persons	person	NNS
18637	2865	12	born	bear	VBN
18637	2865	13	in	in	IN
18637	2865	14	the	the	DT
18637	2865	15	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	2865	16	Zone	Zone	NNP
18637	2865	17	and	and	CC
18637	2865	18	Panama	Panama	NNP
18637	2865	19	after	after	IN
18637	2865	20	February	February	NNP
18637	2865	21	26	26	CD
18637	2865	22	,	,	,
18637	2865	23	1904	1904	CD
18637	2865	24	,	,	,
18637	2865	25	one	one	CD
18637	2865	26	or	or	CC
18637	2865	27	both	both	DT
18637	2865	28	of	of	IN
18637	2865	29	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2865	30	parents	parent	NNS
18637	2865	31	were	be	VBD
18637	2865	32	at	at	IN
18637	2865	33	the	the	DT
18637	2865	34	time	time	NN
18637	2865	35	of	of	IN
18637	2865	36	birth	birth	NN
18637	2865	37	of	of	IN
18637	2865	38	such	such	JJ
18637	2865	39	person	person	NN
18637	2865	40	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	2865	41	of	of	IN
18637	2865	42	the	the	DT
18637	2865	43	United	United	NNP
18637	2865	44	States	States	NNP
18637	2865	45	,	,	,
18637	2865	46	are	be	VBP
18637	2865	47	declared	declare	VBN
18637	2865	48	to	to	TO
18637	2865	49	be	be	VB
18637	2865	50	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	2865	51	of	of	IN
18637	2865	52	the	the	DT
18637	2865	53	United	United	NNP
18637	2865	54	States	States	NNP
18637	2865	55	;	;	:
18637	2865	56	as	as	IN
18637	2865	57	likewise	likewise	RB
18637	2865	58	are	be	VBP
18637	2865	59	of	of	IN
18637	2865	60	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2865	61	categories	category	NNS
18637	2865	62	of	of	IN
18637	2865	63	persons	person	NNS
18637	2865	64	born	bear	VBN
18637	2865	65	in	in	IN
18637	2865	66	Puerto	Puerto	NNP
18637	2865	67	Rico	Rico	NNP
18637	2865	68	,	,	,
18637	2865	69	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	2865	70	,	,	,
18637	2865	71	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	2865	72	,	,	,
18637	2865	73	the	the	DT
18637	2865	74	Virgin	Virgin	NNP
18637	2865	75	Islands	Islands	NNP
18637	2865	76	and	and	CC
18637	2865	77	Guam	Guam	NNP
18637	2865	78	on	on	IN
18637	2865	79	or	or	CC
18637	2865	80	after	after	IN
18637	2865	81	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2865	82	stated	state	VBN
18637	2865	83	dates	date	NNS
18637	2865	84	.	.	.
18637	2866	1	"	"	``
18637	2866	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2866	3	1048	1048	CD
18637	2866	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2866	5	WHO	who	WP
18637	2866	6	ARE	are	VBP
18637	2866	7	ELIGIBLE	ELIGIBLE	NNP
18637	2866	8	FOR	for	IN
18637	2866	9	NATURALIZATION	NATURALIZATION	NNP
18637	2866	10	Naturalization	Naturalization	NNP
18637	2866	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	2866	12	a	a	DT
18637	2866	13	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2866	14	to	to	TO
18637	2866	15	be	be	VB
18637	2866	16	given	give	VBN
18637	2866	17	,	,	,
18637	2866	18	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	2866	19	,	,	,
18637	2866	20	or	or	CC
18637	2866	21	withheld	withhold	VBN
18637	2866	22	as	as	IN
18637	2866	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2866	24	may	may	MD
18637	2866	25	determine	determine	VB
18637	2866	26	,	,	,
18637	2866	27	which	which	WDT
18637	2866	28	an	an	DT
18637	2866	29	alien	alien	NN
18637	2866	30	may	may	MD
18637	2866	31	claim	claim	VB
18637	2866	32	only	only	RB
18637	2866	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	2866	34	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	2866	35	with	with	IN
18637	2866	36	the	the	DT
18637	2866	37	terms	term	NNS
18637	2866	38	which	which	WDT
18637	2866	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2866	40	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	2866	41	.	.	.
18637	2867	1	Earlier	early	RBR
18637	2867	2	the	the	DT
18637	2867	3	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2867	4	was	be	VBD
18637	2867	5	confined	confine	VBN
18637	2867	6	to	to	IN
18637	2867	7	white	white	JJ
18637	2867	8	persons	person	NNS
18637	2867	9	and	and	CC
18637	2867	10	persons	person	NNS
18637	2867	11	of	of	IN
18637	2867	12	African	african	JJ
18637	2867	13	descent	descent	NN
18637	2867	14	,	,	,
18637	2867	15	but	but	CC
18637	2867	16	was	be	VBD
18637	2867	17	extended	extend	VBN
18637	2867	18	by	by	IN
18637	2867	19	the	the	DT
18637	2867	20	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2867	21	of	of	IN
18637	2867	22	December	December	NNP
18637	2867	23	17	17	CD
18637	2867	24	,	,	,
18637	2867	25	1943	1943	CD
18637	2867	26	,	,	,
18637	2867	27	to	to	IN
18637	2867	28	descendants	descendant	NNS
18637	2867	29	of	of	IN
18637	2867	30	races	race	NNS
18637	2867	31	indigenous	indigenous	JJ
18637	2867	32	to	to	IN
18637	2867	33	the	the	DT
18637	2867	34	Western	western	JJ
18637	2867	35	Hemisphere	Hemisphere	NNP
18637	2867	36	and	and	CC
18637	2867	37	Chinese	chinese	JJ
18637	2867	38	persons	person	NNS
18637	2867	39	or	or	CC
18637	2867	40	persons	person	NNS
18637	2867	41	of	of	IN
18637	2867	42	Chinese	Chinese	NNP
18637	2867	43	descent;[1049	descent;[1049	NNP
18637	2867	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2867	45	and	and	CC
18637	2867	46	by	by	IN
18637	2867	47	the	the	DT
18637	2867	48	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2867	49	of	of	IN
18637	2867	50	June	June	NNP
18637	2867	51	27	27	CD
18637	2867	52	,	,	,
18637	2867	53	1952	1952	CD
18637	2867	54	,	,	,
18637	2867	55	"	"	``
18637	2867	56	the	the	DT
18637	2867	57	rights	right	NNS
18637	2867	58	of	of	IN
18637	2867	59	a	a	DT
18637	2867	60	person	person	NN
18637	2867	61	to	to	TO
18637	2867	62	become	become	VB
18637	2867	63	a	a	DT
18637	2867	64	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	2867	65	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2867	66	of	of	IN
18637	2867	67	the	the	DT
18637	2867	68	United	United	NNP
18637	2867	69	States	States	NNP
18637	2867	70	shall	shall	MD
18637	2867	71	not	not	RB
18637	2867	72	be	be	VB
18637	2867	73	denied	deny	VBN
18637	2867	74	or	or	CC
18637	2867	75	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	2867	76	because	because	RB
18637	2867	77	of	of	IN
18637	2867	78	race	race	NN
18637	2867	79	or	or	CC
18637	2867	80	sex	sex	NN
18637	2867	81	or	or	CC
18637	2867	82	because	because	IN
18637	2867	83	the	the	DT
18637	2867	84	person	person	NN
18637	2867	85	is	be	VBZ
18637	2867	86	married	married	JJ
18637	2867	87	.	.	.
18637	2868	1	"	"	``
18637	2868	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2868	3	1050	1050	CD
18637	2868	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2868	5	But	but	CC
18637	2868	6	,	,	,
18637	2868	7	any	any	DT
18637	2868	8	person	person	NN
18637	2868	9	"	"	``
18637	2868	10	who	who	WP
18637	2868	11	advocates	advocate	VBZ
18637	2868	12	or	or	CC
18637	2868	13	teaches	teach	VBZ
18637	2868	14	or	or	CC
18637	2868	15	who	who	WP
18637	2868	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	2868	17	a	a	DT
18637	2868	18	member	member	NN
18637	2868	19	of	of	IN
18637	2868	20	or	or	CC
18637	2868	21	affiliated	affiliate	VBN
18637	2868	22	with	with	IN
18637	2868	23	any	any	DT
18637	2868	24	organization	organization	NN
18637	2868	25	that	that	WDT
18637	2868	26	advocates	advocate	VBZ
18637	2868	27	or	or	CC
18637	2868	28	teaches	teach	VBZ
18637	2868	29	*	*	NFP
18637	2868	30	*	*	NFP
18637	2868	31	*	*	NFP
18637	2868	32	"	"	``
18637	2868	33	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	2868	34	to	to	IN
18637	2868	35	all	all	DT
18637	2868	36	organized	organize	VBN
18637	2868	37	government	government	NN
18637	2868	38	,	,	,
18637	2868	39	or	or	CC
18637	2868	40	"	"	``
18637	2868	41	who	who	WP
18637	2868	42	advocates	advocate	VBZ
18637	2868	43	or	or	CC
18637	2868	44	teaches	teach	VBZ
18637	2868	45	or	or	CC
18637	2868	46	who	who	WP
18637	2868	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	2868	48	a	a	DT
18637	2868	49	member	member	NN
18637	2868	50	of	of	IN
18637	2868	51	or	or	CC
18637	2868	52	affiliated	affiliate	VBN
18637	2868	53	with	with	IN
18637	2868	54	any	any	DT
18637	2868	55	organization	organization	NN
18637	2868	56	that	that	WDT
18637	2868	57	advocates	advocate	VBZ
18637	2868	58	or	or	CC
18637	2868	59	teaches	teach	VBZ
18637	2868	60	the	the	DT
18637	2868	61	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	2868	62	by	by	IN
18637	2868	63	force	force	NN
18637	2868	64	or	or	CC
18637	2868	65	violence	violence	NN
18637	2868	66	or	or	CC
18637	2868	67	other	other	JJ
18637	2868	68	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2868	69	means	mean	NNS
18637	2868	70	of	of	IN
18637	2868	71	the	the	DT
18637	2868	72	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2868	73	of	of	IN
18637	2868	74	the	the	DT
18637	2868	75	United	United	NNP
18637	2868	76	States	States	NNP
18637	2868	77	"	"	``
18637	2868	78	may	may	MD
18637	2868	79	not	not	RB
18637	2868	80	be	be	VB
18637	2868	81	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	2868	82	as	as	IN
18637	2868	83	a	a	DT
18637	2868	84	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2868	85	of	of	IN
18637	2868	86	the	the	DT
18637	2868	87	United	United	NNP
18637	2868	88	States	States	NNP
18637	2868	89	.	.	.
18637	2869	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2869	2	1051	1051	CD
18637	2869	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2869	4	These	these	DT
18637	2869	5	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	2869	6	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	2869	7	are	be	VBP
18637	2869	8	,	,	,
18637	2869	9	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	2869	10	,	,	,
18637	2869	11	"	"	``
18637	2869	12	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	2869	13	to	to	IN
18637	2869	14	any	any	DT
18637	2869	15	applicant	applicant	NN
18637	2869	16	for	for	IN
18637	2869	17	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2869	18	who	who	WP
18637	2869	19	at	at	IN
18637	2869	20	any	any	DT
18637	2869	21	time	time	NN
18637	2869	22	within	within	IN
18637	2869	23	a	a	DT
18637	2869	24	period	period	NN
18637	2869	25	of	of	IN
18637	2869	26	ten	ten	CD
18637	2869	27	years	year	NNS
18637	2869	28	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	2869	29	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	2869	30	the	the	DT
18637	2869	31	filing	filing	NN
18637	2869	32	of	of	IN
18637	2869	33	the	the	DT
18637	2869	34	petition	petition	NN
18637	2869	35	for	for	IN
18637	2869	36	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2869	37	or	or	CC
18637	2869	38	after	after	IN
18637	2869	39	such	such	JJ
18637	2869	40	filing	filing	NN
18637	2869	41	and	and	CC
18637	2869	42	before	before	IN
18637	2869	43	taking	take	VBG
18637	2869	44	the	the	DT
18637	2869	45	final	final	JJ
18637	2869	46	oath	oath	NN
18637	2869	47	of	of	IN
18637	2869	48	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	2869	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	2869	50	,	,	,
18637	2869	51	or	or	CC
18637	2869	52	has	have	VBZ
18637	2869	53	been	be	VBN
18637	2869	54	found	find	VBN
18637	2869	55	to	to	TO
18637	2869	56	be	be	VB
18637	2869	57	within	within	IN
18637	2869	58	any	any	DT
18637	2869	59	of	of	IN
18637	2869	60	the	the	DT
18637	2869	61	classes	class	NNS
18637	2869	62	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	2869	63	within	within	IN
18637	2869	64	this	this	DT
18637	2869	65	section	section	NN
18637	2869	66	,	,	,
18637	2869	67	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	2869	68	that	that	IN
18637	2869	69	at	at	IN
18637	2869	70	the	the	DT
18637	2869	71	time	time	NN
18637	2869	72	the	the	DT
18637	2869	73	petition	petition	NN
18637	2869	74	is	be	VBZ
18637	2869	75	filed	file	VBN
18637	2869	76	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2869	77	may	may	MD
18637	2869	78	not	not	RB
18637	2869	79	be	be	VB
18637	2869	80	included	include	VBN
18637	2869	81	within	within	IN
18637	2869	82	such	such	JJ
18637	2869	83	classes	class	NNS
18637	2869	84	.	.	.
18637	2870	1	"	"	``
18637	2870	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2870	3	1052	1052	CD
18637	2870	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2870	5	THE	the	DT
18637	2870	6	PROCEDURE	PROCEDURE	NNP
18637	2870	7	OF	of	IN
18637	2870	8	NATURALIZATION	NATURALIZATION	NNP
18637	2870	9	This	this	DT
18637	2870	10	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	2870	11	as	as	IN
18637	2870	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2870	13	principal	principal	NN
18637	2870	14	and	and	CC
18637	2870	15	culminating	culminate	VBG
18637	2870	16	event	event	NN
18637	2870	17	the	the	DT
18637	2870	18	taking	taking	NN
18637	2870	19	in	in	RP
18637	2870	20	open	open	JJ
18637	2870	21	court	court	NN
18637	2870	22	by	by	IN
18637	2870	23	the	the	DT
18637	2870	24	applicant	applicant	NN
18637	2870	25	of	of	IN
18637	2870	26	an	an	DT
18637	2870	27	oath	oath	NN
18637	2870	28	:	:	:
18637	2870	29	"	"	''
18637	2870	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2870	31	1	1	CD
18637	2870	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2870	33	to	to	TO
18637	2870	34	support	support	VB
18637	2870	35	the	the	DT
18637	2870	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2870	37	of	of	IN
18637	2870	38	the	the	DT
18637	2870	39	United	United	NNP
18637	2870	40	States	States	NNP
18637	2870	41	;	;	:
18637	2870	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2870	43	2	2	LS
18637	2870	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2870	45	to	to	TO
18637	2870	46	renounce	renounce	VB
18637	2870	47	and	and	CC
18637	2870	48	abjure	abjure	VB
18637	2870	49	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	2870	50	and	and	CC
18637	2870	51	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	2870	52	all	all	DT
18637	2870	53	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	2870	54	and	and	CC
18637	2870	55	fidelity	fidelity	NN
18637	2870	56	to	to	IN
18637	2870	57	any	any	DT
18637	2870	58	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2870	59	prince	prince	NN
18637	2870	60	,	,	,
18637	2870	61	potentate	potentate	JJ
18637	2870	62	,	,	,
18637	2870	63	state	state	NN
18637	2870	64	,	,	,
18637	2870	65	or	or	CC
18637	2870	66	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	2870	67	of	of	IN
18637	2870	68	whom	whom	WP
18637	2870	69	or	or	CC
18637	2870	70	which	which	WDT
18637	2870	71	the	the	DT
18637	2870	72	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	2870	73	was	be	VBD
18637	2870	74	before	before	IN
18637	2870	75	a	a	DT
18637	2870	76	subject	subject	NN
18637	2870	77	or	or	CC
18637	2870	78	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2870	79	;	;	:
18637	2870	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2870	81	3	3	LS
18637	2870	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2870	83	to	to	TO
18637	2870	84	support	support	VB
18637	2870	85	and	and	CC
18637	2870	86	defend	defend	VB
18637	2870	87	the	the	DT
18637	2870	88	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2870	89	and	and	CC
18637	2870	90	the	the	DT
18637	2870	91	laws	law	NNS
18637	2870	92	of	of	IN
18637	2870	93	the	the	DT
18637	2870	94	United	United	NNP
18637	2870	95	States	States	NNP
18637	2870	96	against	against	IN
18637	2870	97	all	all	DT
18637	2870	98	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	2870	99	,	,	,
18637	2870	100	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2870	101	and	and	CC
18637	2870	102	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	2870	103	;	;	:
18637	2870	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2870	105	4	4	LS
18637	2870	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2870	107	to	to	TO
18637	2870	108	bear	bear	VB
18637	2870	109	true	true	JJ
18637	2870	110	faith	faith	NN
18637	2870	111	and	and	CC
18637	2870	112	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	2870	113	to	to	IN
18637	2870	114	the	the	DT
18637	2870	115	same	same	JJ
18637	2870	116	;	;	:
18637	2870	117	and	and	CC
18637	2870	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2870	119	5)(A	5)(a	NN
18637	2870	120	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2870	121	to	to	TO
18637	2870	122	bear	bear	VB
18637	2870	123	arms	arm	NNS
18637	2870	124	on	on	IN
18637	2870	125	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	2870	126	of	of	IN
18637	2870	127	the	the	DT
18637	2870	128	United	United	NNP
18637	2870	129	States	States	NNP
18637	2870	130	when	when	WRB
18637	2870	131	required	require	VBN
18637	2870	132	by	by	IN
18637	2870	133	the	the	DT
18637	2870	134	law	law	NN
18637	2870	135	,	,	,
18637	2870	136	or	or	CC
18637	2870	137	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2870	138	B	b	NN
18637	2870	139	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2870	140	to	to	TO
18637	2870	141	perform	perform	VB
18637	2870	142	noncombatant	noncombatant	JJ
18637	2870	143	service	service	NN
18637	2870	144	in	in	IN
18637	2870	145	the	the	DT
18637	2870	146	Armed	Armed	NNP
18637	2870	147	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	2870	148	of	of	IN
18637	2870	149	the	the	DT
18637	2870	150	United	United	NNP
18637	2870	151	States	States	NNP
18637	2870	152	when	when	WRB
18637	2870	153	required	require	VBN
18637	2870	154	by	by	IN
18637	2870	155	the	the	DT
18637	2870	156	law	law	NN
18637	2870	157	,	,	,
18637	2870	158	or	or	CC
18637	2870	159	(	(	-LRB-
18637	2870	160	C	C	NNP
18637	2870	161	)	)	-RRB-
18637	2870	162	to	to	TO
18637	2870	163	perform	perform	VB
18637	2870	164	work	work	NN
18637	2870	165	of	of	IN
18637	2870	166	national	national	JJ
18637	2870	167	importance	importance	NN
18637	2870	168	under	under	IN
18637	2870	169	civilian	civilian	JJ
18637	2870	170	direction	direction	NN
18637	2870	171	when	when	WRB
18637	2870	172	required	require	VBN
18637	2870	173	by	by	IN
18637	2870	174	law	law	NN
18637	2870	175	.	.	.
18637	2871	1	"	"	``
18637	2871	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2871	3	1053	1053	CD
18637	2871	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2871	5	Any	any	DT
18637	2871	6	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	2871	7	person	person	NN
18637	2871	8	who	who	WP
18637	2871	9	takes	take	VBZ
18637	2871	10	this	this	DT
18637	2871	11	oath	oath	NN
18637	2871	12	with	with	IN
18637	2871	13	mental	mental	JJ
18637	2871	14	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	2871	15	or	or	CC
18637	2871	16	conceals	conceal	NNS
18637	2871	17	beliefs	belief	NNS
18637	2871	18	and	and	CC
18637	2871	19	affiliations	affiliation	NNS
18637	2871	20	which	which	WDT
18637	2871	21	under	under	IN
18637	2871	22	the	the	DT
18637	2871	23	statute	statute	NN
18637	2871	24	disqualify	disqualify	VB
18637	2871	25	one	one	CD
18637	2871	26	for	for	IN
18637	2871	27	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2871	28	,	,	,
18637	2871	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	2871	30	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2871	31	,	,	,
18637	2871	32	upon	upon	IN
18637	2871	33	these	these	DT
18637	2871	34	facts	fact	NNS
18637	2871	35	being	be	VBG
18637	2871	36	shown	show	VBN
18637	2871	37	in	in	IN
18637	2871	38	a	a	DT
18637	2871	39	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	2871	40	brought	bring	VBN
18637	2871	41	for	for	IN
18637	2871	42	the	the	DT
18637	2871	43	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2871	44	,	,	,
18637	2871	45	to	to	TO
18637	2871	46	have	have	VB
18637	2871	47	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2871	48	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	2871	49	of	of	IN
18637	2871	50	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2871	51	cancelled	cancel	VBD
18637	2871	52	.	.	.
18637	2872	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2872	2	1054	1054	CD
18637	2872	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2872	4	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	2872	5	,	,	,
18637	2872	6	if	if	IN
18637	2872	7	a	a	DT
18637	2872	8	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	2872	9	person	person	NN
18637	2872	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	2872	11	within	within	IN
18637	2872	12	five	five	CD
18637	2872	13	years	year	NNS
18637	2872	14	"	"	''
18637	2872	15	following	follow	VBG
18637	2872	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2872	17	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2872	18	become	become	VB
18637	2872	19	a	a	DT
18637	2872	20	member	member	NN
18637	2872	21	of	of	IN
18637	2872	22	or	or	CC
18637	2872	23	affiliated	affiliate	VBN
18637	2872	24	with	with	IN
18637	2872	25	any	any	DT
18637	2872	26	organization	organization	NN
18637	2872	27	,	,	,
18637	2872	28	membership	membership	NN
18637	2872	29	in	in	IN
18637	2872	30	or	or	CC
18637	2872	31	affiliation	affiliation	NN
18637	2872	32	with	with	IN
18637	2872	33	which	which	WDT
18637	2872	34	at	at	IN
18637	2872	35	the	the	DT
18637	2872	36	time	time	NN
18637	2872	37	of	of	IN
18637	2872	38	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2872	39	would	would	MD
18637	2872	40	have	have	VB
18637	2872	41	precluded	preclude	VBN
18637	2872	42	such	such	JJ
18637	2872	43	person	person	NN
18637	2872	44	from	from	IN
18637	2872	45	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2872	46	under	under	IN
18637	2872	47	the	the	DT
18637	2872	48	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	2872	49	of	of	IN
18637	2872	50	section	section	NN
18637	2872	51	313	313	CD
18637	2872	52	,	,	,
18637	2872	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2872	54	shall	shall	MD
18637	2872	55	be	be	VB
18637	2872	56	considered	consider	VBN
18637	2872	57	prima	prima	NN
18637	2872	58	facie	facie	JJ
18637	2872	59	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	2872	60	that	that	IN
18637	2872	61	such	such	JJ
18637	2872	62	person	person	NN
18637	2872	63	was	be	VBD
18637	2872	64	not	not	RB
18637	2872	65	attached	attach	VBN
18637	2872	66	to	to	IN
18637	2872	67	the	the	DT
18637	2872	68	principles	principle	NNS
18637	2872	69	of	of	IN
18637	2872	70	the	the	DT
18637	2872	71	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2872	72	of	of	IN
18637	2872	73	the	the	DT
18637	2872	74	United	United	NNP
18637	2872	75	States	States	NNP
18637	2872	76	and	and	CC
18637	2872	77	was	be	VBD
18637	2872	78	not	not	RB
18637	2872	79	well	well	RB
18637	2872	80	disposed	disposed	JJ
18637	2872	81	to	to	IN
18637	2872	82	the	the	DT
18637	2872	83	good	good	JJ
18637	2872	84	order	order	NN
18637	2872	85	and	and	CC
18637	2872	86	happiness	happiness	NN
18637	2872	87	of	of	IN
18637	2872	88	the	the	DT
18637	2872	89	United	United	NNP
18637	2872	90	States	States	NNP
18637	2872	91	at	at	IN
18637	2872	92	the	the	DT
18637	2872	93	time	time	NN
18637	2872	94	of	of	IN
18637	2872	95	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2872	96	,	,	,
18637	2872	97	and	and	CC
18637	2872	98	,	,	,
18637	2872	99	in	in	IN
18637	2872	100	the	the	DT
18637	2872	101	absence	absence	NN
18637	2872	102	of	of	IN
18637	2872	103	countervailing	countervail	VBG
18637	2872	104	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	2872	105	,	,	,
18637	2872	106	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2872	107	shall	shall	MD
18637	2872	108	be	be	VB
18637	2872	109	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	2872	110	in	in	IN
18637	2872	111	the	the	DT
18637	2872	112	proper	proper	JJ
18637	2872	113	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	2872	114	to	to	TO
18637	2872	115	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	2872	116	the	the	DT
18637	2872	117	revocation	revocation	NN
18637	2872	118	and	and	CC
18637	2872	119	setting	set	VBG
18637	2872	120	aside	aside	RB
18637	2872	121	of	of	IN
18637	2872	122	the	the	DT
18637	2872	123	order	order	NN
18637	2872	124	admitting	admit	VBG
18637	2872	125	such	such	JJ
18637	2872	126	person	person	NN
18637	2872	127	to	to	TO
18637	2872	128	citizenship	citizenship	VB
18637	2872	129	and	and	CC
18637	2872	130	the	the	DT
18637	2872	131	cancellation	cancellation	NN
18637	2872	132	of	of	IN
18637	2872	133	the	the	DT
18637	2872	134	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	2872	135	of	of	IN
18637	2872	136	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2872	137	as	as	IN
18637	2872	138	having	have	VBG
18637	2872	139	been	be	VBN
18637	2872	140	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	2872	141	by	by	IN
18637	2872	142	concealment	concealment	NN
18637	2872	143	of	of	IN
18637	2872	144	a	a	DT
18637	2872	145	material	material	JJ
18637	2872	146	fact	fact	NN
18637	2872	147	or	or	CC
18637	2872	148	by	by	IN
18637	2872	149	willful	willful	JJ
18637	2872	150	misrepresentation	misrepresentation	NN
18637	2872	151	.	.	.
18637	2873	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2873	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2873	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2873	4	"	"	''
18637	2873	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2873	6	1055	1055	CD
18637	2873	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2873	8	RIGHTS	RIGHTS	NNP
18637	2873	9	OF	of	IN
18637	2873	10	NATURALIZED	NATURALIZED	NNP
18637	2873	11	PERSONS	PERSONS	NNP
18637	2873	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2873	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2873	14	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	2873	15	early	early	RB
18637	2873	16	stated	state	VBD
18637	2873	17	the	the	DT
18637	2873	18	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	2873	19	that	that	IN
18637	2873	20	"	"	``
18637	2873	21	a	a	DT
18637	2873	22	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	2873	23	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2873	24	*	*	NFP
18637	2873	25	*	*	NFP
18637	2873	26	*	*	NFP
18637	2873	27	become[s	become[s	IN
18637	2873	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2873	29	a	a	DT
18637	2873	30	member	member	NN
18637	2873	31	of	of	IN
18637	2873	32	the	the	DT
18637	2873	33	society	society	NN
18637	2873	34	,	,	,
18637	2873	35	possessing	possess	VBG
18637	2873	36	all	all	PDT
18637	2873	37	the	the	DT
18637	2873	38	rights	right	NNS
18637	2873	39	of	of	IN
18637	2873	40	a	a	DT
18637	2873	41	native	native	JJ
18637	2873	42	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2873	43	,	,	,
18637	2873	44	and	and	CC
18637	2873	45	standing	standing	NN
18637	2873	46	,	,	,
18637	2873	47	in	in	IN
18637	2873	48	the	the	DT
18637	2873	49	view	view	NN
18637	2873	50	of	of	IN
18637	2873	51	the	the	DT
18637	2873	52	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2873	53	,	,	,
18637	2873	54	on	on	IN
18637	2873	55	the	the	DT
18637	2873	56	footing	footing	NN
18637	2873	57	of	of	IN
18637	2873	58	a	a	DT
18637	2873	59	native	native	NN
18637	2873	60	.	.	.
18637	2874	1	The	the	DT
18637	2874	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2874	3	does	do	VBZ
18637	2874	4	not	not	RB
18637	2874	5	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	2874	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2874	7	to	to	TO
18637	2874	8	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	2874	9	or	or	CC
18637	2874	10	abridge	abridge	VB
18637	2874	11	those	those	DT
18637	2874	12	rights	right	NNS
18637	2874	13	.	.	.
18637	2875	1	The	the	DT
18637	2875	2	simple	simple	JJ
18637	2875	3	power	power	NN
18637	2875	4	of	of	IN
18637	2875	5	the	the	DT
18637	2875	6	national	national	JJ
18637	2875	7	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	2875	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	2875	9	,	,	,
18637	2875	10	to	to	TO
18637	2875	11	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	2875	12	a	a	DT
18637	2875	13	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2875	14	rule	rule	NN
18637	2875	15	of	of	IN
18637	2875	16	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2875	17	,	,	,
18637	2875	18	and	and	CC
18637	2875	19	the	the	DT
18637	2875	20	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2875	21	of	of	IN
18637	2875	22	this	this	DT
18637	2875	23	power	power	NN
18637	2875	24	exhausts	exhaust	VBZ
18637	2875	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2875	26	,	,	,
18637	2875	27	so	so	RB
18637	2875	28	far	far	RB
18637	2875	29	as	as	IN
18637	2875	30	respects	respect	VBZ
18637	2875	31	the	the	DT
18637	2875	32	individual	individual	NN
18637	2875	33	.	.	.
18637	2876	1	"	"	``
18637	2876	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2876	3	1056	1056	CD
18637	2876	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2876	5	A	a	DT
18637	2876	6	similar	similar	JJ
18637	2876	7	idea	idea	NN
18637	2876	8	was	be	VBD
18637	2876	9	expressed	express	VBN
18637	2876	10	in	in	IN
18637	2876	11	1946	1946	CD
18637	2876	12	in	in	IN
18637	2876	13	Knauer	Knauer	NNP
18637	2876	14	_	_	NNP
18637	2876	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	2876	16	_	_	NNP
18637	2876	17	United	United	NNP
18637	2876	18	States:[1057	States:[1057	NNP
18637	2876	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2876	20	"	"	``
18637	2876	21	Citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	2876	22	obtained	obtain	VBD
18637	2876	23	through	through	IN
18637	2876	24	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2876	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	2876	26	not	not	RB
18637	2876	27	a	a	DT
18637	2876	28	second	second	JJ
18637	2876	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	2876	30	class	class	NN
18637	2876	31	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	2876	32	.	.	.
18637	2877	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2877	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2877	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2877	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2877	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2877	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2877	7	carries	carry	VBZ
18637	2877	8	with	with	IN
18637	2877	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2877	10	the	the	DT
18637	2877	11	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2877	12	of	of	IN
18637	2877	13	full	full	JJ
18637	2877	14	participation	participation	NN
18637	2877	15	in	in	IN
18637	2877	16	the	the	DT
18637	2877	17	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	2877	18	of	of	IN
18637	2877	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2877	20	society	society	NN
18637	2877	21	,	,	,
18637	2877	22	including	include	VBG
18637	2877	23	the	the	DT
18637	2877	24	right	right	NN
18637	2877	25	to	to	TO
18637	2877	26	speak	speak	VB
18637	2877	27	freely	freely	RB
18637	2877	28	,	,	,
18637	2877	29	to	to	TO
18637	2877	30	criticize	criticize	VB
18637	2877	31	officials	official	NNS
18637	2877	32	and	and	CC
18637	2877	33	administrators	administrator	NNS
18637	2877	34	,	,	,
18637	2877	35	and	and	CC
18637	2877	36	to	to	TO
18637	2877	37	promote	promote	VB
18637	2877	38	changes	change	NNS
18637	2877	39	in	in	IN
18637	2877	40	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2877	41	laws	law	NNS
18637	2877	42	including	include	VBG
18637	2877	43	the	the	DT
18637	2877	44	very	very	RB
18637	2877	45	Charter	Charter	NNP
18637	2877	46	of	of	IN
18637	2877	47	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2877	48	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2877	49	.	.	.
18637	2878	1	"	"	``
18637	2878	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2878	3	1058	1058	CD
18637	2878	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2878	5	But	but	CC
18637	2878	6	,	,	,
18637	2878	7	as	as	IN
18637	2878	8	shown	show	VBN
18637	2878	9	above	above	RB
18637	2878	10	,	,	,
18637	2878	11	a	a	DT
18637	2878	12	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	2878	13	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2878	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	2878	15	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2878	16	at	at	IN
18637	2878	17	any	any	DT
18637	2878	18	time	time	NN
18637	2878	19	to	to	TO
18637	2878	20	have	have	VB
18637	2878	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2878	22	good	good	JJ
18637	2878	23	faith	faith	NN
18637	2878	24	in	in	IN
18637	2878	25	taking	take	VBG
18637	2878	26	the	the	DT
18637	2878	27	oath	oath	NN
18637	2878	28	of	of	IN
18637	2878	29	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	2878	30	to	to	IN
18637	2878	31	the	the	DT
18637	2878	32	United	United	NNP
18637	2878	33	States	States	NNP
18637	2878	34	inquired	inquire	VBD
18637	2878	35	into	into	IN
18637	2878	36	,	,	,
18637	2878	37	and	and	CC
18637	2878	38	to	to	TO
18637	2878	39	lose	lose	VB
18637	2878	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2878	41	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	2878	42	if	if	IN
18637	2878	43	lack	lack	NN
18637	2878	44	of	of	IN
18637	2878	45	such	such	JJ
18637	2878	46	faith	faith	NN
18637	2878	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	2878	48	shown	show	VBN
18637	2878	49	in	in	IN
18637	2878	50	proper	proper	JJ
18637	2878	51	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	2878	52	.	.	.
18637	2879	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2879	2	1059	1059	CD
18637	2879	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2879	4	Also	also	RB
18637	2879	5	,	,	,
18637	2879	6	"	"	''
18637	2879	7	a	a	DT
18637	2879	8	person	person	NN
18637	2879	9	who	who	WP
18637	2879	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	2879	11	become	become	VBN
18637	2879	12	a	a	DT
18637	2879	13	national	national	JJ
18637	2879	14	by	by	IN
18637	2879	15	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2879	16	"	"	``
18637	2879	17	may	may	MD
18637	2879	18	lose	lose	VB
18637	2879	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2879	20	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	2879	21	by	by	IN
18637	2879	22	"	"	``
18637	2879	23	having	have	VBG
18637	2879	24	a	a	DT
18637	2879	25	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	2879	26	residence	residence	NN
18637	2879	27	for	for	IN
18637	2879	28	three	three	CD
18637	2879	29	years	year	NNS
18637	2879	30	in	in	IN
18637	2879	31	the	the	DT
18637	2879	32	territory	territory	NN
18637	2879	33	of	of	IN
18637	2879	34	a	a	DT
18637	2879	35	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2879	36	state	state	NN
18637	2879	37	of	of	IN
18637	2879	38	which	which	WDT
18637	2879	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2879	40	was	be	VBD
18637	2879	41	formerly	formerly	RB
18637	2879	42	a	a	DT
18637	2879	43	national	national	JJ
18637	2879	44	or	or	CC
18637	2879	45	in	in	IN
18637	2879	46	which	which	WDT
18637	2879	47	the	the	DT
18637	2879	48	place	place	NN
18637	2879	49	of	of	IN
18637	2879	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2879	51	birth	birth	NN
18637	2879	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	2879	53	situated	situate	VBN
18637	2879	54	,	,	,
18637	2879	55	"	"	''
18637	2879	56	or	or	CC
18637	2879	57	by	by	IN
18637	2879	58	"	"	``
18637	2879	59	having	have	VBG
18637	2879	60	a	a	DT
18637	2879	61	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	2879	62	residence	residence	NN
18637	2879	63	for	for	IN
18637	2879	64	five	five	CD
18637	2879	65	years	year	NNS
18637	2879	66	in	in	IN
18637	2879	67	any	any	DT
18637	2879	68	other	other	JJ
18637	2879	69	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2879	70	state	state	NN
18637	2879	71	or	or	CC
18637	2879	72	states	state	NNS
18637	2879	73	.	.	.
18637	2880	1	"	"	``
18637	2880	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2880	3	1060	1060	CD
18637	2880	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2880	5	However	however	RB
18637	2880	6	,	,	,
18637	2880	7	in	in	IN
18637	2880	8	the	the	DT
18637	2880	9	absence	absence	NN
18637	2880	10	of	of	IN
18637	2880	11	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	2880	12	or	or	CC
18637	2880	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	2880	14	to	to	IN
18637	2880	15	the	the	DT
18637	2880	16	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	2880	17	effect	effect	NN
18637	2880	18	,	,	,
18637	2880	19	a	a	DT
18637	2880	20	child	child	NN
18637	2880	21	born	bear	VBN
18637	2880	22	in	in	IN
18637	2880	23	the	the	DT
18637	2880	24	United	United	NNP
18637	2880	25	States	States	NNP
18637	2880	26	who	who	WP
18637	2880	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	2880	28	taken	take	VBN
18637	2880	29	during	during	IN
18637	2880	30	minority	minority	NN
18637	2880	31	to	to	IN
18637	2880	32	the	the	DT
18637	2880	33	country	country	NN
18637	2880	34	of	of	IN
18637	2880	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2880	36	parents	parent	NNS
18637	2880	37	'	'	POS
18637	2880	38	origin	origin	NN
18637	2880	39	,	,	,
18637	2880	40	where	where	WRB
18637	2880	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2880	42	parents	parent	NNS
18637	2880	43	resume	resume	VBP
18637	2880	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2880	45	former	former	JJ
18637	2880	46	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	2880	47	,	,	,
18637	2880	48	does	do	VBZ
18637	2880	49	not	not	RB
18637	2880	50	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	2880	51	lose	lose	VB
18637	2880	52	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2880	53	American	american	JJ
18637	2880	54	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	2880	55	provided	provide	VBD
18637	2880	56	that	that	IN
18637	2880	57	on	on	IN
18637	2880	58	attaining	attain	VBG
18637	2880	59	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2880	60	majority	majority	NN
18637	2880	61	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2880	62	elects	elect	VBZ
18637	2880	63	to	to	TO
18637	2880	64	retain	retain	VB
18637	2880	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2880	66	and	and	CC
18637	2880	67	returns	return	VBZ
18637	2880	68	to	to	IN
18637	2880	69	the	the	DT
18637	2880	70	United	United	NNP
18637	2880	71	States	States	NNP
18637	2880	72	to	to	TO
18637	2880	73	assume	assume	VB
18637	2880	74	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2880	75	duties	duty	NNS
18637	2880	76	.	.	.
18637	2881	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2881	2	1061	1061	CD
18637	2881	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2881	4	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	2881	5	'	'	POS
18637	2881	6	POWER	power	NN
18637	2881	7	EXCLUSIVE	exclusive	NN
18637	2881	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2881	9	'	'	POS
18637	2881	10	power	power	NN
18637	2881	11	over	over	IN
18637	2881	12	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2881	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	2881	14	an	an	DT
18637	2881	15	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	2881	16	power	power	NN
18637	2881	17	.	.	.
18637	2882	1	A	a	DT
18637	2882	2	State	state	NN
18637	2882	3	can	can	MD
18637	2882	4	not	not	RB
18637	2882	5	denationalize	denationalize	VB
18637	2882	6	a	a	DT
18637	2882	7	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2882	8	subject	subject	NN
18637	2882	9	who	who	WP
18637	2882	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	2882	11	not	not	RB
18637	2882	12	complied	comply	VBN
18637	2882	13	with	with	IN
18637	2882	14	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2882	15	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2882	16	law	law	NN
18637	2882	17	and	and	CC
18637	2882	18	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	2882	19	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2882	20	a	a	DT
18637	2882	21	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2882	22	of	of	IN
18637	2882	23	the	the	DT
18637	2882	24	United	United	NNP
18637	2882	25	States	States	NNP
18637	2882	26	,	,	,
18637	2882	27	or	or	CC
18637	2882	28	of	of	IN
18637	2882	29	the	the	DT
18637	2882	30	State	State	NNP
18637	2882	31	,	,	,
18637	2882	32	so	so	IN
18637	2882	33	as	as	IN
18637	2882	34	to	to	TO
18637	2882	35	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	2882	36	the	the	DT
18637	2882	37	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2882	38	courts	court	NNS
18637	2882	39	of	of	IN
18637	2882	40	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2882	41	over	over	IN
18637	2882	42	a	a	DT
18637	2882	43	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	2882	44	between	between	IN
18637	2882	45	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2882	46	and	and	CC
18637	2882	47	a	a	DT
18637	2882	48	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2882	49	of	of	IN
18637	2882	50	a	a	DT
18637	2882	51	State	state	NN
18637	2882	52	.	.	.
18637	2883	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2883	2	1062	1062	CD
18637	2883	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2883	4	But	but	CC
18637	2883	5	power	power	NN
18637	2883	6	to	to	TO
18637	2883	7	naturalize	naturalize	VB
18637	2883	8	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2883	9	may	may	MD
18637	2883	10	be	be	VB
18637	2883	11	,	,	,
18637	2883	12	and	and	CC
18637	2883	13	early	early	RB
18637	2883	14	was	be	VBD
18637	2883	15	,	,	,
18637	2883	16	devolved	devolve	VBN
18637	2883	17	by	by	IN
18637	2883	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2883	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	2883	20	state	state	NN
18637	2883	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	2883	22	having	have	VBG
18637	2883	23	a	a	DT
18637	2883	24	common	common	JJ
18637	2883	25	law	law	NN
18637	2883	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2883	27	.	.	.
18637	2884	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2884	2	1063	1063	CD
18637	2884	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2884	4	Also	also	RB
18637	2884	5	States	States	NNP
18637	2884	6	may	may	MD
18637	2884	7	confer	confer	VB
18637	2884	8	the	the	DT
18637	2884	9	right	right	NN
18637	2884	10	of	of	IN
18637	2884	11	suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	2884	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	2884	13	resident	resident	JJ
18637	2884	14	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2884	15	who	who	WP
18637	2884	16	have	have	VBP
18637	2884	17	declared	declare	VBN
18637	2884	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2884	19	intention	intention	NN
18637	2884	20	to	to	TO
18637	2884	21	become	become	VB
18637	2884	22	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	2884	23	,	,	,
18637	2884	24	and	and	CC
18637	2884	25	have	have	VBP
18637	2884	26	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	2884	27	done	do	VBN
18637	2884	28	so	so	RB
18637	2884	29	.	.	.
18637	2885	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2885	2	1064	1064	CD
18637	2885	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2885	4	RIGHT	right	NN
18637	2885	5	OF	of	IN
18637	2885	6	EXPATRIATION	expatriation	NN
18637	2885	7	:	:	:
18637	2885	8	LOSS	los	VBN
18637	2885	9	OF	of	IN
18637	2885	10	CITIZENSHIP	citizenship	NN
18637	2885	11	Notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	2885	12	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	2885	13	in	in	IN
18637	2885	14	early	early	JJ
18637	2885	15	court	court	NN
18637	2885	16	decisions[1065	decisions[1065	NNP
18637	2885	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2885	18	and	and	CC
18637	2885	19	in	in	IN
18637	2885	20	the	the	DT
18637	2885	21	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	2885	22	of	of	IN
18637	2885	23	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
18637	2885	24	Kent	Kent	NNP
18637	2885	25	of	of	IN
18637	2885	26	a	a	DT
18637	2885	27	brief	brief	JJ
18637	2885	28	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	2885	29	of	of	IN
18637	2885	30	the	the	DT
18637	2885	31	ancient	ancient	JJ
18637	2885	32	English	english	JJ
18637	2885	33	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	2885	34	of	of	IN
18637	2885	35	perpetual	perpetual	JJ
18637	2885	36	and	and	CC
18637	2885	37	unchangeable	unchangeable	JJ
18637	2885	38	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	2885	39	to	to	IN
18637	2885	40	the	the	DT
18637	2885	41	government	government	NN
18637	2885	42	of	of	IN
18637	2885	43	one	one	PRP
18637	2885	44	's	's	POS
18637	2885	45	birth	birth	NN
18637	2885	46	,	,	,
18637	2885	47	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	2885	48	a	a	DT
18637	2885	49	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2885	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	2885	51	precluded	preclude	VBN
18637	2885	52	from	from	IN
18637	2885	53	renouncing	renounce	VBG
18637	2885	54	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2885	55	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	2885	56	without	without	IN
18637	2885	57	permission	permission	NN
18637	2885	58	of	of	IN
18637	2885	59	that	that	DT
18637	2885	60	government	government	NN
18637	2885	61	,	,	,
18637	2885	62	the	the	DT
18637	2885	63	United	United	NNP
18637	2885	64	States	States	NNP
18637	2885	65	,	,	,
18637	2885	66	since	since	IN
18637	2885	67	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	2885	68	of	of	IN
18637	2885	69	the	the	DT
18637	2885	70	act	act	NN
18637	2885	71	of	of	IN
18637	2885	72	1868,[1066	1868,[1066	CD
18637	2885	73	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2885	74	if	if	IN
18637	2885	75	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	2885	76	not	not	RB
18637	2885	77	earlier	early	RBR
18637	2885	78	,	,	,
18637	2885	79	has	have	VBZ
18637	2885	80	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	2885	81	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	2885	82	the	the	DT
18637	2885	83	right	right	NN
18637	2885	84	of	of	IN
18637	2885	85	everyone	everyone	NN
18637	2885	86	to	to	TO
18637	2885	87	expatriate	expatriate	VB
18637	2885	88	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2885	89	and	and	CC
18637	2885	90	choose	choose	VB
18637	2885	91	another	another	DT
18637	2885	92	country	country	NN
18637	2885	93	.	.	.
18637	2886	1	Retention	retention	NN
18637	2886	2	of	of	IN
18637	2886	3	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	2886	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	2886	5	not	not	RB
18637	2886	6	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	2886	7	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	2886	8	,	,	,
18637	2886	9	however	however	RB
18637	2886	10	,	,	,
18637	2886	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	2886	12	the	the	DT
18637	2886	13	desires	desire	NNS
18637	2886	14	of	of	IN
18637	2886	15	the	the	DT
18637	2886	16	individual	individual	NN
18637	2886	17	;	;	:
18637	2886	18	for	for	IN
18637	2886	19	,	,	,
18637	2886	20	although	although	IN
18637	2886	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2886	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	2886	23	been	be	VBN
18637	2886	24	"	"	``
18637	2886	25	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	2886	26	that	that	IN
18637	2886	27	a	a	DT
18637	2886	28	change	change	NN
18637	2886	29	of	of	IN
18637	2886	30	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	2886	31	can	can	MD
18637	2886	32	not	not	RB
18637	2886	33	be	be	VB
18637	2886	34	arbitrarily	arbitrarily	RB
18637	2886	35	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2886	36	,	,	,
18637	2886	37	that	that	RB
18637	2886	38	is	is	RB
18637	2886	39	,	,	,
18637	2886	40	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2886	41	without	without	IN
18637	2886	42	the	the	DT
18637	2886	43	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	2886	44	of	of	IN
18637	2886	45	the	the	DT
18637	2886	46	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	2886	47	,	,	,
18637	2886	48	"	"	''
18637	2886	49	the	the	DT
18637	2886	50	United	United	NNP
18637	2886	51	States	States	NNP
18637	2886	52	,	,	,
18637	2886	53	by	by	IN
18637	2886	54	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	2886	55	of	of	IN
18637	2886	56	the	the	DT
18637	2886	57	powers	power	NNS
18637	2886	58	which	which	WDT
18637	2886	59	inhere	inhere	VBP
18637	2886	60	in	in	IN
18637	2886	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2886	62	as	as	IN
18637	2886	63	a	a	DT
18637	2886	64	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	2886	65	nation	nation	NN
18637	2886	66	,	,	,
18637	2886	67	has	have	VBZ
18637	2886	68	been	be	VBN
18637	2886	69	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	2886	70	competent	competent	JJ
18637	2886	71	to	to	TO
18637	2886	72	provide	provide	VB
18637	2886	73	that	that	IN
18637	2886	74	an	an	DT
18637	2886	75	individual	individual	JJ
18637	2886	76	voluntarily	voluntarily	RB
18637	2886	77	entering	enter	VBG
18637	2886	78	into	into	IN
18637	2886	79	certain	certain	JJ
18637	2886	80	designated	designate	VBN
18637	2886	81	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2886	82	shall	shall	MD
18637	2886	83	,	,	,
18637	2886	84	as	as	IN
18637	2886	85	a	a	DT
18637	2886	86	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	2886	87	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	2886	88	,	,	,
18637	2886	89	suffer	suffer	VB
18637	2886	90	the	the	DT
18637	2886	91	loss	loss	NN
18637	2886	92	of	of	IN
18637	2886	93	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	2886	94	.	.	.
18637	2887	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2887	2	1067	1067	CD
18637	2887	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2887	4	Exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	2887	5	of	of	IN
18637	2887	6	Aliens	Aliens	NNP
18637	2887	7	The	the	DT
18637	2887	8	power	power	NN
18637	2887	9	of	of	IN
18637	2887	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2887	11	"	"	''
18637	2887	12	to	to	TO
18637	2887	13	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	2887	14	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2887	15	from	from	IN
18637	2887	16	the	the	DT
18637	2887	17	United	United	NNP
18637	2887	18	States	States	NNP
18637	2887	19	and	and	CC
18637	2887	20	to	to	TO
18637	2887	21	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	2887	22	the	the	DT
18637	2887	23	terms	term	NNS
18637	2887	24	and	and	CC
18637	2887	25	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2887	26	on	on	IN
18637	2887	27	which	which	WDT
18637	2887	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2887	29	come	come	VBP
18637	2887	30	in	in	RP
18637	2887	31	"	"	``
18637	2887	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	2887	33	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	2887	34	,	,	,
18637	2887	35	being	be	VBG
18637	2887	36	an	an	DT
18637	2887	37	attribute	attribute	NN
18637	2887	38	of	of	IN
18637	2887	39	the	the	DT
18637	2887	40	United	United	NNP
18637	2887	41	States	States	NNP
18637	2887	42	as	as	IN
18637	2887	43	a	a	DT
18637	2887	44	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	2887	45	nation	nation	NN
18637	2887	46	.	.	.
18637	2888	1	In	in	IN
18637	2888	2	the	the	DT
18637	2888	3	words	word	NNS
18637	2888	4	of	of	IN
18637	2888	5	the	the	DT
18637	2888	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2888	7	:	:	:
18637	2888	8	"	"	``
18637	2888	9	That	that	IN
18637	2888	10	the	the	DT
18637	2888	11	government	government	NN
18637	2888	12	of	of	IN
18637	2888	13	the	the	DT
18637	2888	14	United	United	NNP
18637	2888	15	States	States	NNP
18637	2888	16	,	,	,
18637	2888	17	through	through	IN
18637	2888	18	the	the	DT
18637	2888	19	action	action	NN
18637	2888	20	of	of	IN
18637	2888	21	the	the	DT
18637	2888	22	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2888	23	department	department	NN
18637	2888	24	,	,	,
18637	2888	25	can	can	MD
18637	2888	26	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	2888	27	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2888	28	from	from	IN
18637	2888	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2888	30	territory	territory	NN
18637	2888	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	2888	32	a	a	DT
18637	2888	33	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	2888	34	which	which	WDT
18637	2888	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2888	36	do	do	VBP
18637	2888	37	not	not	RB
18637	2888	38	think	think	VB
18637	2888	39	open	open	JJ
18637	2888	40	to	to	IN
18637	2888	41	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	2888	42	.	.	.
18637	2889	1	Jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2889	2	over	over	IN
18637	2889	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2889	4	own	own	JJ
18637	2889	5	territory	territory	NN
18637	2889	6	to	to	IN
18637	2889	7	that	that	DT
18637	2889	8	extent	extent	NN
18637	2889	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	2889	10	an	an	DT
18637	2889	11	incident	incident	NN
18637	2889	12	of	of	IN
18637	2889	13	every	every	DT
18637	2889	14	independent	independent	JJ
18637	2889	15	nation	nation	NN
18637	2889	16	.	.	.
18637	2890	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2890	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2890	3	a	a	DT
18637	2890	4	part	part	NN
18637	2890	5	of	of	IN
18637	2890	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2890	7	independence	independence	NN
18637	2890	8	.	.	.
18637	2891	1	If	if	IN
18637	2891	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2891	3	could	could	MD
18637	2891	4	not	not	RB
18637	2891	5	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	2891	6	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2891	7	,	,	,
18637	2891	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2891	9	would	would	MD
18637	2891	10	be	be	VB
18637	2891	11	to	to	IN
18637	2891	12	that	that	DT
18637	2891	13	extent	extent	NN
18637	2891	14	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2891	15	to	to	IN
18637	2891	16	the	the	DT
18637	2891	17	control	control	NN
18637	2891	18	of	of	IN
18637	2891	19	another	another	DT
18637	2891	20	power	power	NN
18637	2891	21	.	.	.
18637	2892	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2892	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2892	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2892	4	The	the	DT
18637	2892	5	United	United	NNP
18637	2892	6	States	States	NNP
18637	2892	7	,	,	,
18637	2892	8	in	in	IN
18637	2892	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2892	10	relation	relation	NN
18637	2892	11	to	to	IN
18637	2892	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2892	13	countries	country	NNS
18637	2892	14	and	and	CC
18637	2892	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2892	16	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	2892	17	or	or	CC
18637	2892	18	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	2892	19	are	be	VBP
18637	2892	20	one	one	CD
18637	2892	21	nation	nation	NN
18637	2892	22	,	,	,
18637	2892	23	invested	invest	VBN
18637	2892	24	with	with	IN
18637	2892	25	powers	power	NNS
18637	2892	26	which	which	WDT
18637	2892	27	belong	belong	VBP
18637	2892	28	to	to	IN
18637	2892	29	independent	independent	JJ
18637	2892	30	nations	nation	NNS
18637	2892	31	,	,	,
18637	2892	32	the	the	DT
18637	2892	33	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2892	34	of	of	IN
18637	2892	35	which	which	WDT
18637	2892	36	can	can	MD
18637	2892	37	be	be	VB
18637	2892	38	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	2892	39	for	for	IN
18637	2892	40	the	the	DT
18637	2892	41	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	2892	42	of	of	IN
18637	2892	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2892	44	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	2892	45	independence	independence	NN
18637	2892	46	and	and	CC
18637	2892	47	security	security	NN
18637	2892	48	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	2892	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2892	50	entire	entire	JJ
18637	2892	51	territory	territory	NN
18637	2892	52	.	.	.
18637	2893	1	"	"	``
18637	2893	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2893	3	1068	1068	CD
18637	2893	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2893	5	By	by	IN
18637	2893	6	the	the	DT
18637	2893	7	Immigration	Immigration	NNP
18637	2893	8	and	and	CC
18637	2893	9	Nationality	Nationality	NNP
18637	2893	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2893	11	of	of	IN
18637	2893	12	June	June	NNP
18637	2893	13	27	27	CD
18637	2893	14	,	,	,
18637	2893	15	1952	1952	CD
18637	2893	16	,	,	,
18637	2893	17	some	some	DT
18637	2893	18	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	2893	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	2893	20	one	one	CD
18637	2893	21	categories	category	NNS
18637	2893	22	of	of	IN
18637	2893	23	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2893	24	are	be	VBP
18637	2893	25	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	2893	26	from	from	IN
18637	2893	27	the	the	DT
18637	2893	28	United	United	NNP
18637	2893	29	States[1069	States[1069	NNP
18637	2893	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2893	31	including	include	VBG
18637	2893	32	"	"	``
18637	2893	33	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2893	34	who	who	WP
18637	2893	35	are	be	VBP
18637	2893	36	,	,	,
18637	2893	37	or	or	CC
18637	2893	38	at	at	IN
18637	2893	39	any	any	DT
18637	2893	40	time	time	NN
18637	2893	41	have	have	VBP
18637	2893	42	been	be	VBN
18637	2893	43	,	,	,
18637	2893	44	members	member	NNS
18637	2893	45	*	*	NFP
18637	2893	46	*	*	NFP
18637	2893	47	*	*	NFP
18637	2893	48	of	of	IN
18637	2893	49	or	or	CC
18637	2893	50	affiliated	affiliate	VBN
18637	2893	51	with	with	IN
18637	2893	52	any	any	DT
18637	2893	53	organization	organization	NN
18637	2893	54	that	that	WDT
18637	2893	55	advocates	advocate	VBZ
18637	2893	56	or	or	CC
18637	2893	57	teaches	teach	VBZ
18637	2893	58	*	*	NFP
18637	2893	59	*	*	NFP
18637	2893	60	*	*	NFP
18637	2893	61	the	the	DT
18637	2893	62	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	2893	63	by	by	IN
18637	2893	64	force	force	NN
18637	2893	65	,	,	,
18637	2893	66	violence	violence	NN
18637	2893	67	,	,	,
18637	2893	68	or	or	CC
18637	2893	69	other	other	JJ
18637	2893	70	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2893	71	means	mean	NNS
18637	2893	72	of	of	IN
18637	2893	73	the	the	DT
18637	2893	74	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2893	75	of	of	IN
18637	2893	76	the	the	DT
18637	2893	77	United	United	NNP
18637	2893	78	States	States	NNP
18637	2893	79	*	*	NFP
18637	2893	80	*	*	NFP
18637	2893	81	*	*	NFP
18637	2893	82	"	"	''
18637	2893	83	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2893	84	1070	1070	CD
18637	2893	85	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2893	86	With	with	IN
18637	2893	87	this	this	DT
18637	2893	88	power	power	NN
18637	2893	89	of	of	IN
18637	2893	90	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	2893	91	goes	go	VBZ
18637	2893	92	also	also	RB
18637	2893	93	the	the	DT
18637	2893	94	power	power	NN
18637	2893	95	to	to	TO
18637	2893	96	assert	assert	VB
18637	2893	97	a	a	DT
18637	2893	98	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	2893	99	degree	degree	NN
18637	2893	100	of	of	IN
18637	2893	101	control	control	NN
18637	2893	102	over	over	IN
18637	2893	103	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2893	104	after	after	IN
18637	2893	105	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2893	106	admission	admission	NN
18637	2893	107	to	to	IN
18637	2893	108	the	the	DT
18637	2893	109	country	country	NN
18637	2893	110	.	.	.
18637	2894	1	By	by	IN
18637	2894	2	the	the	DT
18637	2894	3	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	2894	4	Registration	Registration	NNP
18637	2894	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2894	6	of	of	IN
18637	2894	7	1940[1071	1940[1071	NNP
18637	2894	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2894	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2894	10	was	be	VBD
18637	2894	11	provided	provide	VBN
18637	2894	12	that	that	IN
18637	2894	13	all	all	DT
18637	2894	14	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2894	15	in	in	IN
18637	2894	16	the	the	DT
18637	2894	17	United	United	NNP
18637	2894	18	States	States	NNP
18637	2894	19	,	,	,
18637	2894	20	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	2894	21	years	year	NNS
18637	2894	22	of	of	IN
18637	2894	23	age	age	NN
18637	2894	24	and	and	CC
18637	2894	25	over	over	RB
18637	2894	26	,	,	,
18637	2894	27	should	should	MD
18637	2894	28	submit	submit	VB
18637	2894	29	to	to	IN
18637	2894	30	registration	registration	NN
18637	2894	31	and	and	CC
18637	2894	32	finger	finger	NN
18637	2894	33	printing	printing	NN
18637	2894	34	,	,	,
18637	2894	35	and	and	CC
18637	2894	36	wilful	wilful	JJ
18637	2894	37	failure	failure	NN
18637	2894	38	to	to	TO
18637	2894	39	do	do	VB
18637	2894	40	so	so	RB
18637	2894	41	was	be	VBD
18637	2894	42	made	make	VBN
18637	2894	43	a	a	DT
18637	2894	44	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	2894	45	offense	offense	NN
18637	2894	46	against	against	IN
18637	2894	47	the	the	DT
18637	2894	48	United	United	NNP
18637	2894	49	States	States	NNP
18637	2894	50	.	.	.
18637	2895	1	This	this	DT
18637	2895	2	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2895	3	,	,	,
18637	2895	4	taken	take	VBN
18637	2895	5	in	in	IN
18637	2895	6	conjunction	conjunction	NN
18637	2895	7	with	with	IN
18637	2895	8	other	other	JJ
18637	2895	9	laws	law	NNS
18637	2895	10	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	2895	11	immigration	immigration	NN
18637	2895	12	and	and	CC
18637	2895	13	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2895	14	,	,	,
18637	2895	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	2895	16	constituted	constitute	VBN
18637	2895	17	a	a	DT
18637	2895	18	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	2895	19	and	and	CC
18637	2895	20	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2895	21	system	system	NN
18637	2895	22	for	for	IN
18637	2895	23	the	the	DT
18637	2895	24	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2895	25	of	of	IN
18637	2895	26	all	all	DT
18637	2895	27	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2895	28	and	and	CC
18637	2895	29	precludes	preclude	VBZ
18637	2895	30	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	2895	31	of	of	IN
18637	2895	32	a	a	DT
18637	2895	33	State	State	NNP
18637	2895	34	registration	registration	NN
18637	2895	35	act	act	NN
18637	2895	36	.	.	.
18637	2896	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	2896	2	the	the	DT
18637	2896	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2896	4	,	,	,
18637	2896	5	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2896	6	by	by	IN
18637	2896	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2896	8	Black	Black	NNP
18637	2896	9	:	:	:
18637	2896	10	"	"	``
18637	2896	11	With	with	IN
18637	2896	12	a	a	DT
18637	2896	13	view	view	NN
18637	2896	14	to	to	IN
18637	2896	15	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	2896	16	prospective	prospective	JJ
18637	2896	17	residents	resident	NNS
18637	2896	18	from	from	IN
18637	2896	19	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2896	20	lands	land	NNS
18637	2896	21	to	to	IN
18637	2896	22	those	those	DT
18637	2896	23	possessing	possess	VBG
18637	2896	24	the	the	DT
18637	2896	25	qualities	quality	NNS
18637	2896	26	deemed	deem	VBD
18637	2896	27	essential	essential	JJ
18637	2896	28	to	to	IN
18637	2896	29	good	good	JJ
18637	2896	30	and	and	CC
18637	2896	31	useful	useful	JJ
18637	2896	32	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	2896	33	in	in	IN
18637	2896	34	America	America	NNP
18637	2896	35	,	,	,
18637	2896	36	carefully	carefully	RB
18637	2896	37	defined	define	VBN
18637	2896	38	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	2896	39	are	be	VBP
18637	2896	40	required	require	VBN
18637	2896	41	to	to	TO
18637	2896	42	be	be	VB
18637	2896	43	met	meet	VBN
18637	2896	44	before	before	IN
18637	2896	45	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2896	46	may	may	MD
18637	2896	47	enter	enter	VB
18637	2896	48	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2896	49	country	country	NN
18637	2896	50	.	.	.
18637	2897	1	These	these	DT
18637	2897	2	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	2897	3	include	include	VBP
18637	2897	4	rigid	rigid	JJ
18637	2897	5	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	2897	6	as	as	IN
18637	2897	7	to	to	IN
18637	2897	8	health	health	NN
18637	2897	9	,	,	,
18637	2897	10	education	education	NN
18637	2897	11	,	,	,
18637	2897	12	integrity	integrity	NN
18637	2897	13	,	,	,
18637	2897	14	character	character	NN
18637	2897	15	,	,	,
18637	2897	16	and	and	CC
18637	2897	17	adaptability	adaptability	NN
18637	2897	18	to	to	IN
18637	2897	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2897	20	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	2897	21	.	.	.
18637	2898	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	2898	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2898	3	the	the	DT
18637	2898	4	alien	alien	NN
18637	2898	5	left	leave	VBN
18637	2898	6	free	free	JJ
18637	2898	7	from	from	IN
18637	2898	8	the	the	DT
18637	2898	9	application	application	NN
18637	2898	10	of	of	IN
18637	2898	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2898	12	laws	law	NNS
18637	2898	13	after	after	IN
18637	2898	14	entry	entry	NN
18637	2898	15	and	and	CC
18637	2898	16	before	before	IN
18637	2898	17	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	2898	18	.	.	.
18637	2899	1	If	if	IN
18637	2899	2	during	during	IN
18637	2899	3	the	the	DT
18637	2899	4	time	time	NN
18637	2899	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2899	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2899	7	residing	reside	VBG
18637	2899	8	here	here	RB
18637	2899	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2899	10	should	should	MD
18637	2899	11	be	be	VB
18637	2899	12	found	find	VBN
18637	2899	13	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	2899	14	of	of	IN
18637	2899	15	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	2899	16	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	2899	17	to	to	IN
18637	2899	18	the	the	DT
18637	2899	19	rules	rule	NNS
18637	2899	20	and	and	CC
18637	2899	21	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2899	22	laid	lay	VBN
18637	2899	23	down	down	RP
18637	2899	24	by	by	IN
18637	2899	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2899	26	,	,	,
18637	2899	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2899	28	can	can	MD
18637	2899	29	be	be	VB
18637	2899	30	deported	deport	VBN
18637	2899	31	.	.	.
18637	2900	1	At	at	IN
18637	2900	2	the	the	DT
18637	2900	3	time	time	NN
18637	2900	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2900	5	enters	enter	VBZ
18637	2900	6	the	the	DT
18637	2900	7	country	country	NN
18637	2900	8	,	,	,
18637	2900	9	at	at	IN
18637	2900	10	the	the	DT
18637	2900	11	time	time	NN
18637	2900	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2900	13	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	2900	14	for	for	IN
18637	2900	15	permission	permission	NN
18637	2900	16	to	to	TO
18637	2900	17	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	2900	18	the	the	DT
18637	2900	19	full	full	JJ
18637	2900	20	status	status	NN
18637	2900	21	of	of	IN
18637	2900	22	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	2900	23	,	,	,
18637	2900	24	and	and	CC
18637	2900	25	during	during	IN
18637	2900	26	the	the	DT
18637	2900	27	intervening	intervene	VBG
18637	2900	28	years	year	NNS
18637	2900	29	,	,	,
18637	2900	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2900	31	can	can	MD
18637	2900	32	be	be	VB
18637	2900	33	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	2900	34	to	to	IN
18637	2900	35	searching	search	VBG
18637	2900	36	investigations	investigation	NNS
18637	2900	37	as	as	IN
18637	2900	38	to	to	TO
18637	2900	39	conduct	conduct	VB
18637	2900	40	and	and	CC
18637	2900	41	suitability	suitability	NN
18637	2900	42	for	for	IN
18637	2900	43	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	2900	44	.	.	.
18637	2901	1	"	"	``
18637	2901	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2901	3	1072	1072	CD
18637	2901	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2901	5	The	the	DT
18637	2901	6	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2901	7	of	of	IN
18637	2901	8	June	June	NNP
18637	2901	9	27	27	CD
18637	2901	10	,	,	,
18637	2901	11	1952	1952	CD
18637	2901	12	,	,	,
18637	2901	13	repeats	repeat	VBZ
18637	2901	14	these	these	DT
18637	2901	15	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	2901	16	of	of	IN
18637	2901	17	the	the	DT
18637	2901	18	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2901	19	of	of	IN
18637	2901	20	1940	1940	CD
18637	2901	21	.	.	.
18637	2902	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2902	2	1073	1073	CD
18637	2902	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2902	4	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	2902	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	2902	6	underscore	underscore	VBP
18637	2902	7	the	the	DT
18637	2902	8	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	2902	9	nature	nature	NN
18637	2902	10	of	of	IN
18637	2902	11	the	the	DT
18637	2902	12	powers	power	NNS
18637	2902	13	of	of	IN
18637	2902	14	the	the	DT
18637	2902	15	National	National	NNP
18637	2902	16	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2902	17	to	to	TO
18637	2902	18	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	2902	19	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2902	20	from	from	IN
18637	2902	21	the	the	DT
18637	2902	22	United	United	NNP
18637	2902	23	States	States	NNP
18637	2902	24	and	and	CC
18637	2902	25	to	to	TO
18637	2902	26	deport	deport	VB
18637	2902	27	by	by	IN
18637	2902	28	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	2902	29	process	process	NN
18637	2902	30	members	member	NNS
18637	2902	31	of	of	IN
18637	2902	32	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	2902	33	classes	class	NNS
18637	2902	34	.	.	.
18637	2903	1	In	in	IN
18637	2903	2	Knauff	Knauff	NNP
18637	2903	3	_	_	NNP
18637	2903	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	2903	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2903	6	Shaughnessy,[1074	shaughnessy,[1074	CD
18637	2903	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2903	8	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2903	9	early	early	RB
18637	2903	10	in	in	IN
18637	2903	11	1950	1950	CD
18637	2903	12	,	,	,
18637	2903	13	an	an	DT
18637	2903	14	order	order	NN
18637	2903	15	of	of	IN
18637	2903	16	the	the	DT
18637	2903	17	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	2903	18	General	General	NNP
18637	2903	19	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	2903	20	,	,	,
18637	2903	21	on	on	IN
18637	2903	22	the	the	DT
18637	2903	23	basis	basis	NN
18637	2903	24	of	of	IN
18637	2903	25	confidential	confidential	JJ
18637	2903	26	information	information	NN
18637	2903	27	,	,	,
18637	2903	28	a	a	DT
18637	2903	29	wartime	wartime	JJ
18637	2903	30	bride	bride	NN
18637	2903	31	who	who	WP
18637	2903	32	was	be	VBD
18637	2903	33	prima	prima	NN
18637	2903	34	facie	facie	NNP
18637	2903	35	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	2903	36	to	to	TO
18637	2903	37	enter	enter	VB
18637	2903	38	the	the	DT
18637	2903	39	United	United	NNP
18637	2903	40	States	States	NNP
18637	2903	41	under	under	IN
18637	2903	42	The	the	DT
18637	2903	43	War	War	NNP
18637	2903	44	Brides	Brides	NNPS
18637	2903	45	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2903	46	of	of	IN
18637	2903	47	1945,[1075	1945,[1075	CD
18637	2903	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2903	49	was	be	VBD
18637	2903	50	held	hold	VBN
18637	2903	51	to	to	TO
18637	2903	52	be	be	VB
18637	2903	53	not	not	RB
18637	2903	54	reviewable	reviewable	JJ
18637	2903	55	by	by	IN
18637	2903	56	the	the	DT
18637	2903	57	courts	court	NNS
18637	2903	58	;	;	:
18637	2903	59	nor	nor	CC
18637	2903	60	were	be	VBD
18637	2903	61	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2903	62	on	on	IN
18637	2903	63	which	which	WDT
18637	2903	64	the	the	DT
18637	2903	65	order	order	NN
18637	2903	66	was	be	VBD
18637	2903	67	based	base	VBN
18637	2903	68	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	2903	69	as	as	IN
18637	2903	70	representing	represent	VBG
18637	2903	71	an	an	DT
18637	2903	72	undue	undue	JJ
18637	2903	73	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	2903	74	of	of	IN
18637	2903	75	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2903	76	power	power	NN
18637	2903	77	.	.	.
18637	2904	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	2904	2	the	the	DT
18637	2904	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2904	4	:	:	:
18637	2904	5	"	"	``
18637	2904	6	Normally	Normally	NNP
18637	2904	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2904	8	supplies	supply	VBZ
18637	2904	9	the	the	DT
18637	2904	10	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2904	11	of	of	IN
18637	2904	12	the	the	DT
18637	2904	13	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2904	14	of	of	IN
18637	2904	15	entry	entry	NN
18637	2904	16	into	into	IN
18637	2904	17	the	the	DT
18637	2904	18	United	United	NNP
18637	2904	19	States	States	NNP
18637	2904	20	.	.	.
18637	2905	1	But	but	CC
18637	2905	2	because	because	IN
18637	2905	3	the	the	DT
18637	2905	4	power	power	NN
18637	2905	5	of	of	IN
18637	2905	6	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	2905	7	of	of	IN
18637	2905	8	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2905	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	2905	10	also	also	RB
18637	2905	11	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	2905	12	in	in	IN
18637	2905	13	the	the	DT
18637	2905	14	executive	executive	JJ
18637	2905	15	department	department	NN
18637	2905	16	of	of	IN
18637	2905	17	the	the	DT
18637	2905	18	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	2905	19	,	,	,
18637	2905	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2905	21	may	may	MD
18637	2905	22	in	in	IN
18637	2905	23	broad	broad	JJ
18637	2905	24	terms	term	NNS
18637	2905	25	authorize	authorize	VBP
18637	2905	26	the	the	DT
18637	2905	27	executive	executive	NN
18637	2905	28	to	to	TO
18637	2905	29	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	2905	30	the	the	DT
18637	2905	31	power	power	NN
18637	2905	32	,	,	,
18637	2905	33	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	2905	34	,	,	,
18637	2905	35	as	as	IN
18637	2905	36	was	be	VBD
18637	2905	37	done	do	VBN
18637	2905	38	here	here	RB
18637	2905	39	,	,	,
18637	2905	40	for	for	IN
18637	2905	41	the	the	DT
18637	2905	42	best	good	JJS
18637	2905	43	interests	interest	NNS
18637	2905	44	of	of	IN
18637	2905	45	the	the	DT
18637	2905	46	country	country	NN
18637	2905	47	during	during	IN
18637	2905	48	a	a	DT
18637	2905	49	time	time	NN
18637	2905	50	of	of	IN
18637	2905	51	national	national	JJ
18637	2905	52	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	2905	53	.	.	.
18637	2906	1	Executive	executive	JJ
18637	2906	2	officers	officer	NNS
18637	2906	3	may	may	MD
18637	2906	4	be	be	VB
18637	2906	5	entrusted	entrust	VBN
18637	2906	6	with	with	IN
18637	2906	7	the	the	DT
18637	2906	8	duty	duty	NN
18637	2906	9	of	of	IN
18637	2906	10	specifying	specify	VBG
18637	2906	11	the	the	DT
18637	2906	12	procedures	procedure	NNS
18637	2906	13	for	for	IN
18637	2906	14	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	2906	15	out	out	RP
18637	2906	16	the	the	DT
18637	2906	17	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2906	18	intent	intent	NN
18637	2906	19	.	.	.
18637	2907	1	"	"	``
18637	2907	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2907	3	1076	1076	CD
18637	2907	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2907	5	In	in	IN
18637	2907	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	2907	7	decided	decide	VBN
18637	2907	8	in	in	IN
18637	2907	9	March	March	NNP
18637	2907	10	and	and	CC
18637	2907	11	April	April	NNP
18637	2907	12	,	,	,
18637	2907	13	1952	1952	CD
18637	2907	14	,	,	,
18637	2907	15	comparable	comparable	JJ
18637	2907	16	results	result	NNS
18637	2907	17	were	be	VBD
18637	2907	18	reached	reach	VBN
18637	2907	19	:	:	:
18637	2907	20	The	the	DT
18637	2907	21	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	2907	22	Security	Security	NNP
18637	2907	23	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2907	24	of	of	IN
18637	2907	25	1950	1950	CD
18637	2907	26	,	,	,
18637	2907	27	section	section	NN
18637	2907	28	23	23	CD
18637	2907	29	,	,	,
18637	2907	30	in	in	IN
18637	2907	31	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	2907	32	the	the	DT
18637	2907	33	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	2907	34	General	General	NNP
18637	2907	35	to	to	TO
18637	2907	36	hold	hold	VB
18637	2907	37	in	in	IN
18637	2907	38	custody	custody	NN
18637	2907	39	,	,	,
18637	2907	40	without	without	IN
18637	2907	41	bail	bail	NN
18637	2907	42	,	,	,
18637	2907	43	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2907	44	who	who	WP
18637	2907	45	are	be	VBP
18637	2907	46	members	member	NNS
18637	2907	47	of	of	IN
18637	2907	48	the	the	DT
18637	2907	49	Communist	Communist	NNP
18637	2907	50	Party	Party	NNP
18637	2907	51	of	of	IN
18637	2907	52	the	the	DT
18637	2907	53	United	United	NNP
18637	2907	54	States	States	NNP
18637	2907	55	,	,	,
18637	2907	56	pending	pende	VBG
18637	2907	57	determination	determination	NN
18637	2907	58	as	as	IN
18637	2907	59	to	to	IN
18637	2907	60	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2907	61	deportability	deportability	NN
18637	2907	62	,	,	,
18637	2907	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	2907	64	not	not	RB
18637	2907	65	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2907	66	.	.	.
18637	2908	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2908	2	1077	1077	CD
18637	2908	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2908	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	2908	5	was	be	VBD
18637	2908	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2908	7	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	2908	8	to	to	TO
18637	2908	9	deport	deport	VB
18637	2908	10	under	under	IN
18637	2908	11	the	the	DT
18637	2908	12	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	2908	13	Registration	Registration	NNP
18637	2908	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2908	15	of	of	IN
18637	2908	16	1940[1078	1940[1078	NNP
18637	2908	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2908	18	a	a	DT
18637	2908	19	legally	legally	RB
18637	2908	20	resident	resident	JJ
18637	2908	21	alien	alien	NN
18637	2908	22	because	because	IN
18637	2908	23	of	of	IN
18637	2908	24	membership	membership	NN
18637	2908	25	in	in	IN
18637	2908	26	the	the	DT
18637	2908	27	Communist	Communist	NNP
18637	2908	28	Party	Party	NNP
18637	2908	29	,	,	,
18637	2908	30	although	although	IN
18637	2908	31	such	such	JJ
18637	2908	32	membership	membership	NN
18637	2908	33	ended	end	VBD
18637	2908	34	before	before	IN
18637	2908	35	the	the	DT
18637	2908	36	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	2908	37	of	of	IN
18637	2908	38	the	the	DT
18637	2908	39	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2908	40	.	.	.
18637	2909	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	2909	2	application	application	NN
18637	2909	3	of	of	IN
18637	2909	4	the	the	DT
18637	2909	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2909	6	did	do	VBD
18637	2909	7	not	not	RB
18637	2909	8	make	make	VB
18637	2909	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2909	10	_	_	NNP
18637	2909	11	ex	ex	FW
18637	2909	12	post	post	FW
18637	2909	13	facto	facto	FW
18637	2909	14	_	_	NNP
18637	2909	15	,	,	,
18637	2909	16	being	be	VBG
18637	2909	17	but	but	CC
18637	2909	18	an	an	DT
18637	2909	19	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2909	20	of	of	IN
18637	2909	21	the	the	DT
18637	2909	22	power	power	NN
18637	2909	23	of	of	IN
18637	2909	24	the	the	DT
18637	2909	25	United	United	NNP
18637	2909	26	States	States	NNP
18637	2909	27	to	to	TO
18637	2909	28	terminate	terminate	VB
18637	2909	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2909	30	hospitality	hospitality	NN
18637	2909	31	_	_	NNP
18637	2909	32	ad	ad	NN
18637	2909	33	libitum	libitum	NN
18637	2909	34	_	_	NNP
18637	2909	35	.	.	.
18637	2910	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2910	2	1079	1079	CD
18637	2910	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2910	4	And	and	CC
18637	2910	5	a	a	DT
18637	2910	6	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	2910	7	provision[1080	provision[1080	NNP
18637	2910	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2910	9	which	which	WDT
18637	2910	10	makes	make	VBZ
18637	2910	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2910	12	a	a	DT
18637	2910	13	felony	felony	NN
18637	2910	14	for	for	IN
18637	2910	15	an	an	DT
18637	2910	16	alien	alien	NN
18637	2910	17	against	against	IN
18637	2910	18	whom	whom	WP
18637	2910	19	a	a	DT
18637	2910	20	specified	specify	VBN
18637	2910	21	order	order	NN
18637	2910	22	of	of	IN
18637	2910	23	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	2910	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	2910	25	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	2910	26	"	"	''
18637	2910	27	to	to	TO
18637	2910	28	willfully	willfully	RB
18637	2910	29	fail	fail	VB
18637	2910	30	or	or	CC
18637	2910	31	refuse	refuse	VBP
18637	2910	32	to	to	TO
18637	2910	33	make	make	VB
18637	2910	34	timely	timely	JJ
18637	2910	35	application	application	NN
18637	2910	36	for	for	IN
18637	2910	37	travel	travel	NN
18637	2910	38	or	or	CC
18637	2910	39	other	other	JJ
18637	2910	40	documents	document	NNS
18637	2910	41	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2910	42	to	to	IN
18637	2910	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2910	44	departure	departure	NN
18637	2910	45	"	"	``
18637	2910	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	2910	47	not	not	RB
18637	2910	48	on	on	IN
18637	2910	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2910	50	face	face	NN
18637	2910	51	void	void	JJ
18637	2910	52	for	for	IN
18637	2910	53	"	"	``
18637	2910	54	vagueness	vagueness	NN
18637	2910	55	.	.	.
18637	2911	1	"	"	``
18637	2911	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2911	3	1081	1081	CD
18637	2911	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2911	5	The	the	DT
18637	2911	6	power	power	NN
18637	2911	7	of	of	IN
18637	2911	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2911	9	to	to	TO
18637	2911	10	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	2911	11	with	with	IN
18637	2911	12	respect	respect	NN
18637	2911	13	to	to	IN
18637	2911	14	the	the	DT
18637	2911	15	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	2911	16	of	of	IN
18637	2911	17	alien	alien	JJ
18637	2911	18	residents	resident	NNS
18637	2911	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	2911	20	,	,	,
18637	2911	21	however	however	RB
18637	2911	22	,	,	,
18637	2911	23	a	a	DT
18637	2911	24	concomitant	concomitant	NN
18637	2911	25	of	of	IN
18637	2911	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2911	27	power	power	NN
18637	2911	28	to	to	TO
18637	2911	29	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	2911	30	the	the	DT
18637	2911	31	terms	term	NNS
18637	2911	32	and	and	CC
18637	2911	33	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2911	34	on	on	IN
18637	2911	35	which	which	WDT
18637	2911	36	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2911	37	may	may	MD
18637	2911	38	enter	enter	VB
18637	2911	39	the	the	DT
18637	2911	40	United	United	NNP
18637	2911	41	States	States	NNP
18637	2911	42	;	;	:
18637	2911	43	to	to	TO
18637	2911	44	establish	establish	VB
18637	2911	45	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2911	46	for	for	IN
18637	2911	47	sending	send	VBG
18637	2911	48	out	out	IN
18637	2911	49	of	of	IN
18637	2911	50	the	the	DT
18637	2911	51	country	country	NN
18637	2911	52	such	such	JJ
18637	2911	53	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2911	54	as	as	IN
18637	2911	55	have	have	VBP
18637	2911	56	entered	enter	VBN
18637	2911	57	in	in	IN
18637	2911	58	violation	violation	NN
18637	2911	59	of	of	IN
18637	2911	60	law	law	NN
18637	2911	61	;	;	:
18637	2911	62	and	and	CC
18637	2911	63	to	to	TO
18637	2911	64	commit	commit	VB
18637	2911	65	the	the	DT
18637	2911	66	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	2911	67	of	of	IN
18637	2911	68	such	such	JJ
18637	2911	69	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2911	70	and	and	CC
18637	2911	71	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2911	72	to	to	IN
18637	2911	73	executive	executive	NN
18637	2911	74	officers	officer	NNS
18637	2911	75	.	.	.
18637	2912	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2912	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	2912	3	not	not	RB
18637	2912	4	a	a	DT
18637	2912	5	power	power	NN
18637	2912	6	to	to	TO
18637	2912	7	lay	lay	VB
18637	2912	8	down	down	RP
18637	2912	9	a	a	DT
18637	2912	10	special	special	JJ
18637	2912	11	code	code	NN
18637	2912	12	of	of	IN
18637	2912	13	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	2912	14	for	for	IN
18637	2912	15	alien	alien	JJ
18637	2912	16	residents	resident	NNS
18637	2912	17	or	or	CC
18637	2912	18	to	to	TO
18637	2912	19	govern	govern	VB
18637	2912	20	private	private	JJ
18637	2912	21	relations	relation	NNS
18637	2912	22	with	with	IN
18637	2912	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2912	24	.	.	.
18637	2913	1	Purporting	purport	VBG
18637	2913	2	to	to	TO
18637	2913	3	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	2913	4	the	the	DT
18637	2913	5	above	above	JJ
18637	2913	6	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	2913	7	,	,	,
18637	2913	8	the	the	DT
18637	2913	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2913	10	,	,	,
18637	2913	11	in	in	IN
18637	2913	12	1909	1909	CD
18637	2913	13	,	,	,
18637	2913	14	held	hold	VBD
18637	2913	15	void	void	RB
18637	2913	16	a	a	DT
18637	2913	17	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	2913	18	provision	provision	NN
18637	2913	19	which	which	WDT
18637	2913	20	,	,	,
18637	2913	21	in	in	IN
18637	2913	22	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	2913	23	the	the	DT
18637	2913	24	importation	importation	NN
18637	2913	25	of	of	IN
18637	2913	26	"	"	``
18637	2913	27	any	any	DT
18637	2913	28	alien	alien	JJ
18637	2913	29	woman	woman	NN
18637	2913	30	or	or	CC
18637	2913	31	girl	girl	NN
18637	2913	32	for	for	IN
18637	2913	33	the	the	DT
18637	2913	34	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2913	35	of	of	IN
18637	2913	36	prostitution	prostitution	NN
18637	2913	37	,	,	,
18637	2913	38	"	"	''
18637	2913	39	provided	provide	VBN
18637	2913	40	further	further	RB
18637	2913	41	that	that	IN
18637	2913	42	whoever	whoever	WP
18637	2913	43	should	should	MD
18637	2913	44	keep	keep	VB
18637	2913	45	for	for	IN
18637	2913	46	the	the	DT
18637	2913	47	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2913	48	of	of	IN
18637	2913	49	prostitution	prostitution	NN
18637	2913	50	"	"	``
18637	2913	51	any	any	DT
18637	2913	52	alien	alien	JJ
18637	2913	53	woman	woman	NN
18637	2913	54	or	or	CC
18637	2913	55	girl	girl	NN
18637	2913	56	within	within	IN
18637	2913	57	three	three	CD
18637	2913	58	years	year	NNS
18637	2913	59	after	after	IN
18637	2913	60	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2913	61	shall	shall	MD
18637	2913	62	have	have	VB
18637	2913	63	entered	enter	VBN
18637	2913	64	the	the	DT
18637	2913	65	United	United	NNP
18637	2913	66	States	States	NNP
18637	2913	67	"	"	''
18637	2913	68	should	should	MD
18637	2913	69	be	be	VB
18637	2913	70	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	2913	71	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	2913	72	of	of	IN
18637	2913	73	a	a	DT
18637	2913	74	felony	felony	NN
18637	2913	75	and	and	CC
18637	2913	76	punished	punish	VBD
18637	2913	77	therefor	therefor	RB
18637	2913	78	.	.	.
18637	2914	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2914	2	1082	1082	CD
18637	2914	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2914	4	Three	three	CD
18637	2914	5	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	2914	6	,	,	,
18637	2914	7	however	however	RB
18637	2914	8	,	,	,
18637	2914	9	thought	think	VBD
18637	2914	10	the	the	DT
18637	2914	11	measure	measure	NN
18637	2914	12	justifiable	justifiable	JJ
18637	2914	13	on	on	IN
18637	2914	14	the	the	DT
18637	2914	15	principle	principle	NN
18637	2914	16	that	that	IN
18637	2914	17	"	"	``
18637	2914	18	for	for	IN
18637	2914	19	the	the	DT
18637	2914	20	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2914	21	of	of	IN
18637	2914	22	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	2914	23	those	those	DT
18637	2914	24	who	who	WP
18637	2914	25	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	2914	26	enter	enter	VBP
18637	2914	27	this	this	DT
18637	2914	28	country	country	NN
18637	2914	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2914	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	2914	31	power	power	NN
18637	2914	32	to	to	TO
18637	2914	33	retain	retain	VB
18637	2914	34	control	control	NN
18637	2914	35	over	over	IN
18637	2914	36	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	2914	37	long	long	RB
18637	2914	38	enough	enough	RB
18637	2914	39	to	to	TO
18637	2914	40	make	make	VB
18637	2914	41	sure	sure	JJ
18637	2914	42	of	of	IN
18637	2914	43	the	the	DT
18637	2914	44	facts	fact	NNS
18637	2914	45	.	.	.
18637	2915	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2915	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2915	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2915	4	To	to	IN
18637	2915	5	this	this	DT
18637	2915	6	end	end	NN
18637	2915	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2915	8	may	may	MD
18637	2915	9	make	make	VB
18637	2915	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2915	11	admission	admission	NN
18637	2915	12	conditional	conditional	JJ
18637	2915	13	for	for	IN
18637	2915	14	three	three	CD
18637	2915	15	years	year	NNS
18637	2915	16	.	.	.
18637	2916	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2916	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2916	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2916	4	"	"	''
18637	2916	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2916	6	And	and	CC
18637	2916	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2916	8	"	"	``
18637	2916	9	if	if	IN
18637	2916	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2916	11	can	can	MD
18637	2916	12	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	2916	13	the	the	DT
18637	2916	14	entry	entry	NN
18637	2916	15	*	*	NFP
18637	2916	16	*	*	NFP
18637	2916	17	*	*	NFP
18637	2916	18	,	,	,
18637	2916	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2916	20	can	can	MD
18637	2916	21	punish	punish	VB
18637	2916	22	those	those	DT
18637	2916	23	who	who	WP
18637	2916	24	cooperate	cooperate	VBP
18637	2916	25	in	in	IN
18637	2916	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2916	27	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	2916	28	entry	entry	NN
18637	2916	29	.	.	.
18637	2917	1	"	"	``
18637	2917	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2917	3	1083	1083	CD
18637	2917	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2917	5	Bankruptcy	Bankruptcy	NNP
18637	2917	6	PERSONS	PERSONS	NNP
18637	2917	7	WHO	who	WP
18637	2917	8	MAY	MAY	MD
18637	2917	9	BE	be	VB
18637	2917	10	RELEASED	released	NN
18637	2917	11	FROM	from	IN
18637	2917	12	DEBT	debt	NN
18637	2917	13	In	in	IN
18637	2917	14	an	an	DT
18637	2917	15	early	early	JJ
18637	2917	16	case	case	NN
18637	2917	17	on	on	IN
18637	2917	18	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	2917	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2917	20	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
18637	2917	21	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	2917	22	that	that	IN
18637	2917	23	inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	2917	24	as	as	IN
18637	2917	25	the	the	DT
18637	2917	26	English	English	NNP
18637	2917	27	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	2917	28	on	on	IN
18637	2917	29	the	the	DT
18637	2917	30	subject	subject	NN
18637	2917	31	of	of	IN
18637	2917	32	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2917	33	from	from	IN
18637	2917	34	the	the	DT
18637	2917	35	time	time	NN
18637	2917	36	of	of	IN
18637	2917	37	Henry	Henry	NNP
18637	2917	38	VIII	VIII	NNP
18637	2917	39	down	down	RB
18637	2917	40	had	have	VBD
18637	2917	41	applied	apply	VBN
18637	2917	42	only	only	RB
18637	2917	43	to	to	IN
18637	2917	44	traders	trader	NNS
18637	2917	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2917	46	might	may	MD
18637	2917	47	"	"	``
18637	2917	48	well	well	RB
18637	2917	49	be	be	VB
18637	2917	50	doubted	doubt	VBN
18637	2917	51	,	,	,
18637	2917	52	whether	whether	IN
18637	2917	53	an	an	DT
18637	2917	54	act	act	NN
18637	2917	55	of	of	IN
18637	2917	56	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2917	57	subjecting	subject	VBG
18637	2917	58	to	to	IN
18637	2917	59	such	such	PDT
18637	2917	60	a	a	DT
18637	2917	61	law	law	NN
18637	2917	62	every	every	DT
18637	2917	63	description	description	NN
18637	2917	64	of	of	IN
18637	2917	65	persons	person	NNS
18637	2917	66	within	within	IN
18637	2917	67	the	the	DT
18637	2917	68	United	United	NNP
18637	2917	69	States	States	NNP
18637	2917	70	,	,	,
18637	2917	71	would	would	MD
18637	2917	72	comport	comport	VB
18637	2917	73	with	with	IN
18637	2917	74	the	the	DT
18637	2917	75	spirit	spirit	NN
18637	2917	76	of	of	IN
18637	2917	77	the	the	DT
18637	2917	78	powers	power	NNS
18637	2917	79	vested	vest	VBN
18637	2917	80	in	in	IN
18637	2917	81	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2917	82	in	in	IN
18637	2917	83	relation	relation	NN
18637	2917	84	to	to	IN
18637	2917	85	this	this	DT
18637	2917	86	subject	subject	NN
18637	2917	87	.	.	.
18637	2918	1	"	"	``
18637	2918	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2918	3	1084	1084	CD
18637	2918	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2918	5	Neither	neither	CC
18637	2918	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2918	7	nor	nor	CC
18637	2918	8	the	the	DT
18637	2918	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2918	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2918	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	2918	12	ever	ever	RB
18637	2918	13	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	2918	14	this	this	DT
18637	2918	15	limited	limited	JJ
18637	2918	16	view	view	NN
18637	2918	17	.	.	.
18637	2919	1	The	the	DT
18637	2919	2	first	first	JJ
18637	2919	3	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2919	4	law	law	NN
18637	2919	5	,	,	,
18637	2919	6	passed	pass	VBN
18637	2919	7	in	in	IN
18637	2919	8	1800	1800	CD
18637	2919	9	,	,	,
18637	2919	10	departed	depart	VBN
18637	2919	11	from	from	IN
18637	2919	12	the	the	DT
18637	2919	13	English	english	JJ
18637	2919	14	practice	practice	NN
18637	2919	15	to	to	IN
18637	2919	16	the	the	DT
18637	2919	17	extent	extent	NN
18637	2919	18	of	of	IN
18637	2919	19	including	include	VBG
18637	2919	20	bankers	banker	NNS
18637	2919	21	,	,	,
18637	2919	22	brokers	broker	NNS
18637	2919	23	,	,	,
18637	2919	24	factors	factor	NNS
18637	2919	25	and	and	CC
18637	2919	26	underwriters	underwriter	NNS
18637	2919	27	as	as	RB
18637	2919	28	well	well	RB
18637	2919	29	as	as	IN
18637	2919	30	traders	trader	NNS
18637	2919	31	.	.	.
18637	2920	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2920	2	1085	1085	CD
18637	2920	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2920	4	Asserting	assert	VBG
18637	2920	5	that	that	IN
18637	2920	6	the	the	DT
18637	2920	7	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	2920	8	scope	scope	NN
18637	2920	9	of	of	IN
18637	2920	10	the	the	DT
18637	2920	11	English	english	JJ
18637	2920	12	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	2920	13	was	be	VBD
18637	2920	14	a	a	DT
18637	2920	15	mere	mere	JJ
18637	2920	16	matter	matter	NN
18637	2920	17	of	of	IN
18637	2920	18	policy	policy	NN
18637	2920	19	,	,	,
18637	2920	20	which	which	WDT
18637	2920	21	by	by	IN
18637	2920	22	no	no	DT
18637	2920	23	means	means	NN
18637	2920	24	entered	enter	VBN
18637	2920	25	into	into	IN
18637	2920	26	the	the	DT
18637	2920	27	nature	nature	NN
18637	2920	28	of	of	IN
18637	2920	29	such	such	JJ
18637	2920	30	laws	law	NNS
18637	2920	31	,	,	,
18637	2920	32	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2920	33	Story	Story	NNP
18637	2920	34	defined	define	VBD
18637	2920	35	a	a	DT
18637	2920	36	law	law	NN
18637	2920	37	on	on	IN
18637	2920	38	the	the	DT
18637	2920	39	subject	subject	NN
18637	2920	40	of	of	IN
18637	2920	41	bankruptcies	bankruptcy	NNS
18637	2920	42	in	in	IN
18637	2920	43	the	the	DT
18637	2920	44	sense	sense	NN
18637	2920	45	of	of	IN
18637	2920	46	the	the	DT
18637	2920	47	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2920	48	as	as	IN
18637	2920	49	a	a	DT
18637	2920	50	law	law	NN
18637	2920	51	making	make	VBG
18637	2920	52	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	2920	53	for	for	IN
18637	2920	54	cases	case	NNS
18637	2920	55	of	of	IN
18637	2920	56	persons	person	NNS
18637	2920	57	failing	fail	VBG
18637	2920	58	to	to	TO
18637	2920	59	pay	pay	VB
18637	2920	60	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2920	61	debts	debt	NNS
18637	2920	62	.	.	.
18637	2921	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2921	2	1086	1086	CD
18637	2921	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2921	4	This	this	DT
18637	2921	5	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	2921	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	2921	7	been	be	VBN
18637	2921	8	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	2921	9	by	by	IN
18637	2921	10	the	the	DT
18637	2921	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2921	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2921	13	.	.	.
18637	2922	1	In	in	IN
18637	2922	2	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
18637	2922	3	National	National	NNP
18637	2922	4	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	2922	5	_	_	NNP
18637	2922	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	2922	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2922	8	Moyses,[1087	moyses,[1087	CD
18637	2922	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2922	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2922	11	held	hold	VBD
18637	2922	12	valid	valid	JJ
18637	2922	13	the	the	DT
18637	2922	14	Bankruptcy	Bankruptcy	NNP
18637	2922	15	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2922	16	of	of	IN
18637	2922	17	1898	1898	CD
18637	2922	18	which	which	WDT
18637	2922	19	provided	provide	VBD
18637	2922	20	that	that	IN
18637	2922	21	persons	person	NNS
18637	2922	22	other	other	JJ
18637	2922	23	than	than	IN
18637	2922	24	traders	trader	NNS
18637	2922	25	might	may	MD
18637	2922	26	become	become	VB
18637	2922	27	bankrupts	bankrupt	NNS
18637	2922	28	and	and	CC
18637	2922	29	that	that	IN
18637	2922	30	this	this	DT
18637	2922	31	might	may	MD
18637	2922	32	be	be	VB
18637	2922	33	done	do	VBN
18637	2922	34	on	on	IN
18637	2922	35	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	2922	36	petition	petition	NN
18637	2922	37	.	.	.
18637	2923	1	The	the	DT
18637	2923	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2923	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	2923	4	given	give	VBN
18637	2923	5	tacit	tacit	JJ
18637	2923	6	approval	approval	NN
18637	2923	7	to	to	IN
18637	2923	8	the	the	DT
18637	2923	9	extension	extension	NN
18637	2923	10	of	of	IN
18637	2923	11	the	the	DT
18637	2923	12	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2923	13	laws	law	NNS
18637	2923	14	to	to	TO
18637	2923	15	cover	cover	VB
18637	2923	16	practically	practically	RB
18637	2923	17	all	all	DT
18637	2923	18	classes	class	NNS
18637	2923	19	of	of	IN
18637	2923	20	persons	person	NNS
18637	2923	21	and	and	CC
18637	2923	22	corporations,[1088	corporations,[1088	NNP
18637	2923	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2923	24	including	include	VBG
18637	2923	25	even	even	RB
18637	2923	26	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	2923	27	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2923	28	.	.	.
18637	2924	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2924	2	1089	1089	CD
18637	2924	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2924	4	LIBERALIZATION	liberalization	NN
18637	2924	5	OF	of	IN
18637	2924	6	RELIEF	relief	NN
18637	2924	7	GRANTED	grant	VBD
18637	2924	8	As	as	IN
18637	2924	9	the	the	DT
18637	2924	10	coverage	coverage	NN
18637	2924	11	of	of	IN
18637	2924	12	the	the	DT
18637	2924	13	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2924	14	laws	law	NNS
18637	2924	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	2924	16	been	be	VBN
18637	2924	17	expanded	expand	VBN
18637	2924	18	,	,	,
18637	2924	19	the	the	DT
18637	2924	20	scope	scope	NN
18637	2924	21	of	of	IN
18637	2924	22	the	the	DT
18637	2924	23	relief	relief	NN
18637	2924	24	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	2924	25	to	to	IN
18637	2924	26	debtors	debtor	NNS
18637	2924	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	2924	28	been	be	VBN
18637	2924	29	correspondingly	correspondingly	RB
18637	2924	30	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
18637	2924	31	.	.	.
18637	2925	1	The	the	DT
18637	2925	2	act	act	NN
18637	2925	3	of	of	IN
18637	2925	4	1800	1800	CD
18637	2925	5	,	,	,
18637	2925	6	like	like	IN
18637	2925	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2925	8	English	english	JJ
18637	2925	9	antecedents	antecedent	NNS
18637	2925	10	,	,	,
18637	2925	11	was	be	VBD
18637	2925	12	designed	design	VBN
18637	2925	13	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	2925	14	for	for	IN
18637	2925	15	the	the	DT
18637	2925	16	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	2925	17	of	of	IN
18637	2925	18	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	2925	19	.	.	.
18637	2926	1	Beginning	begin	VBG
18637	2926	2	with	with	IN
18637	2926	3	the	the	DT
18637	2926	4	act	act	NN
18637	2926	5	of	of	IN
18637	2926	6	1841	1841	CD
18637	2926	7	,	,	,
18637	2926	8	which	which	WDT
18637	2926	9	opened	open	VBD
18637	2926	10	the	the	DT
18637	2926	11	door	door	NN
18637	2926	12	to	to	IN
18637	2926	13	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	2926	14	petitions	petition	NNS
18637	2926	15	,	,	,
18637	2926	16	rehabilitation	rehabilitation	NN
18637	2926	17	of	of	IN
18637	2926	18	the	the	DT
18637	2926	19	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	2926	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	2926	21	become	become	VBN
18637	2926	22	an	an	DT
18637	2926	23	object	object	NN
18637	2926	24	of	of	IN
18637	2926	25	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	2926	26	concern	concern	NN
18637	2926	27	to	to	IN
18637	2926	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2926	29	.	.	.
18637	2927	1	An	an	DT
18637	2927	2	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	2927	3	in	in	IN
18637	2927	4	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2927	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	2927	6	no	no	DT
18637	2927	7	longer	longer	RB
18637	2927	8	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	2927	9	to	to	IN
18637	2927	10	the	the	DT
18637	2927	11	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2927	12	of	of	IN
18637	2927	13	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2927	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	2927	15	.	.	.
18637	2928	1	In	in	IN
18637	2928	2	1867	1867	CD
18637	2928	3	the	the	DT
18637	2928	4	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	2928	5	for	for	IN
18637	2928	6	the	the	DT
18637	2928	7	first	first	JJ
18637	2928	8	time	time	NN
18637	2928	9	was	be	VBD
18637	2928	10	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	2928	11	,	,	,
18637	2928	12	either	either	CC
18637	2928	13	before	before	IN
18637	2928	14	or	or	CC
18637	2928	15	after	after	IN
18637	2928	16	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	2928	17	of	of	IN
18637	2928	18	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2928	19	,	,	,
18637	2928	20	to	to	TO
18637	2928	21	propose	propose	VB
18637	2928	22	terms	term	NNS
18637	2928	23	of	of	IN
18637	2928	24	composition	composition	NN
18637	2928	25	which	which	WDT
18637	2928	26	would	would	MD
18637	2928	27	become	become	VB
18637	2928	28	binding	bind	VBG
18637	2928	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	2928	30	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	2928	31	by	by	IN
18637	2928	32	a	a	DT
18637	2928	33	designated	designate	VBN
18637	2928	34	majority	majority	NN
18637	2928	35	of	of	IN
18637	2928	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2928	37	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	2928	38	and	and	CC
18637	2928	39	confirmation	confirmation	NN
18637	2928	40	by	by	IN
18637	2928	41	a	a	DT
18637	2928	42	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2928	43	court	court	NN
18637	2928	44	.	.	.
18637	2929	1	This	this	DT
18637	2929	2	measure	measure	NN
18637	2929	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2929	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	2929	5	constitutional,[1090	constitutional,[1090	NNP
18637	2929	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2929	7	as	as	IN
18637	2929	8	were	be	VBD
18637	2929	9	later	later	RB
18637	2929	10	acts	act	NNS
18637	2929	11	which	which	WDT
18637	2929	12	provided	provide	VBN
18637	2929	13	for	for	IN
18637	2929	14	the	the	DT
18637	2929	15	reorganization	reorganization	NN
18637	2929	16	of	of	IN
18637	2929	17	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2929	18	which	which	WDT
18637	2929	19	are	be	VBP
18637	2929	20	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
18637	2929	21	or	or	CC
18637	2929	22	unable	unable	JJ
18637	2929	23	to	to	TO
18637	2929	24	meet	meet	VB
18637	2929	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2929	26	debts	debt	NNS
18637	2929	27	as	as	IN
18637	2929	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2929	29	mature,[1091	mature,[1091	NNP
18637	2929	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2929	31	and	and	CC
18637	2929	32	for	for	IN
18637	2929	33	the	the	DT
18637	2929	34	composition	composition	NN
18637	2929	35	and	and	CC
18637	2929	36	extension	extension	NN
18637	2929	37	of	of	IN
18637	2929	38	debts	debt	NNS
18637	2929	39	in	in	IN
18637	2929	40	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	2929	41	for	for	IN
18637	2929	42	the	the	DT
18637	2929	43	relief	relief	NN
18637	2929	44	of	of	IN
18637	2929	45	individual	individual	JJ
18637	2929	46	farmer	farmer	NN
18637	2929	47	-	-	HYPH
18637	2929	48	debtors	debtor	NNS
18637	2929	49	.	.	.
18637	2930	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2930	2	1092	1092	CD
18637	2930	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2930	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	2930	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	2930	6	the	the	DT
18637	2930	7	power	power	NN
18637	2930	8	of	of	IN
18637	2930	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2930	10	limited	limit	VBN
18637	2930	11	to	to	IN
18637	2930	12	adjustment	adjustment	NN
18637	2930	13	of	of	IN
18637	2930	14	the	the	DT
18637	2930	15	rights	right	NNS
18637	2930	16	of	of	IN
18637	2930	17	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	2930	18	.	.	.
18637	2931	1	The	the	DT
18637	2931	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2931	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2931	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	2931	5	also	also	RB
18637	2931	6	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	2931	7	that	that	IN
18637	2931	8	the	the	DT
18637	2931	9	rights	right	NNS
18637	2931	10	of	of	IN
18637	2931	11	a	a	DT
18637	2931	12	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	2931	13	at	at	IN
18637	2931	14	a	a	DT
18637	2931	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	2931	16	sale	sale	NN
18637	2931	17	of	of	IN
18637	2931	18	the	the	DT
18637	2931	19	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	2931	20	's	's	POS
18637	2931	21	property	property	NN
18637	2931	22	are	be	VBP
18637	2931	23	within	within	IN
18637	2931	24	reach	reach	NN
18637	2931	25	of	of	IN
18637	2931	26	the	the	DT
18637	2931	27	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2931	28	power	power	NN
18637	2931	29	,	,	,
18637	2931	30	and	and	CC
18637	2931	31	may	may	MD
18637	2931	32	be	be	VB
18637	2931	33	modified	modify	VBN
18637	2931	34	by	by	IN
18637	2931	35	a	a	DT
18637	2931	36	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	2931	37	extension	extension	NN
18637	2931	38	of	of	IN
18637	2931	39	the	the	DT
18637	2931	40	period	period	NN
18637	2931	41	for	for	IN
18637	2931	42	redemption	redemption	NN
18637	2931	43	from	from	IN
18637	2931	44	such	such	JJ
18637	2931	45	sale	sale	NN
18637	2931	46	.	.	.
18637	2932	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2932	2	1093	1093	CD
18637	2932	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2932	4	The	the	DT
18637	2932	5	sympathetic	sympathetic	JJ
18637	2932	6	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	2932	7	with	with	IN
18637	2932	8	which	which	WDT
18637	2932	9	the	the	DT
18637	2932	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2932	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	2932	12	viewed	view	VBN
18637	2932	13	these	these	DT
18637	2932	14	developments	development	NNS
18637	2932	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	2932	16	reflected	reflect	VBN
18637	2932	17	in	in	IN
18637	2932	18	the	the	DT
18637	2932	19	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2932	20	in	in	IN
18637	2932	21	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	2932	22	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	2932	23	National	National	NNP
18637	2932	24	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	2932	25	and	and	CC
18637	2932	26	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	2932	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2932	28	_	_	NNP
18637	2932	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	2932	30	_	_	NNP
18637	2932	31	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	2932	32	,	,	,
18637	2932	33	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	2932	34	and	and	CC
18637	2932	35	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	2933	1	Co	co	NN
18637	2933	2	.	.	.
18637	2933	3	,[1094	,[1094	NFP
18637	2933	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2933	5	where	where	WRB
18637	2933	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2933	7	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	2933	8	wrote	write	VBD
18637	2933	9	,	,	,
18637	2933	10	on	on	IN
18637	2933	11	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	2933	12	of	of	IN
18637	2933	13	a	a	DT
18637	2933	14	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	2933	15	court	court	NN
18637	2933	16	:	:	:
18637	2933	17	"	"	``
18637	2933	18	*	*	NFP
18637	2933	19	*	*	NFP
18637	2933	20	*	*	NFP
18637	2933	21	these	these	DT
18637	2933	22	acts	act	NNS
18637	2933	23	,	,	,
18637	2933	24	far	far	RB
18637	2933	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	2933	26	reaching	reach	VBG
18637	2933	27	though	though	IN
18637	2933	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2933	29	may	may	MD
18637	2933	30	be	be	VB
18637	2933	31	,	,	,
18637	2933	32	have	have	VBP
18637	2933	33	not	not	RB
18637	2933	34	gone	go	VBN
18637	2933	35	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	2933	36	the	the	DT
18637	2933	37	limit	limit	NN
18637	2933	38	of	of	IN
18637	2933	39	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2933	40	power	power	NN
18637	2933	41	;	;	:
18637	2933	42	but	but	CC
18637	2933	43	rather	rather	RB
18637	2933	44	have	have	VBP
18637	2933	45	constituted	constitute	VBN
18637	2933	46	extensions	extension	NNS
18637	2933	47	into	into	IN
18637	2933	48	a	a	DT
18637	2933	49	field	field	NN
18637	2933	50	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2933	51	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	2933	52	may	may	MD
18637	2933	53	not	not	RB
18637	2933	54	yet	yet	RB
18637	2933	55	be	be	VB
18637	2933	56	fully	fully	RB
18637	2933	57	revealed	reveal	VBN
18637	2933	58	.	.	.
18637	2934	1	"	"	``
18637	2934	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2934	3	1095	1095	CD
18637	2934	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2934	5	CONSTITUTIONAL	constitutional	JJ
18637	2934	6	LIMITATIONS	limitation	NNS
18637	2934	7	ON	on	IN
18637	2934	8	THE	the	DT
18637	2934	9	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	2934	10	In	in	IN
18637	2934	11	the	the	DT
18637	2934	12	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2934	13	of	of	IN
18637	2934	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2934	15	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2934	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	2934	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2934	18	must	must	MD
18637	2934	19	not	not	RB
18637	2934	20	transgress	transgress	VB
18637	2934	21	the	the	DT
18637	2934	22	Fifth	fifth	JJ
18637	2934	23	and	and	CC
18637	2934	24	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	2934	25	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	2934	26	.	.	.
18637	2935	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2935	2	may	may	MD
18637	2935	3	not	not	RB
18637	2935	4	take	take	VB
18637	2935	5	from	from	IN
18637	2935	6	a	a	DT
18637	2935	7	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	2935	8	specific	specific	JJ
18637	2935	9	property	property	NN
18637	2935	10	previously	previously	RB
18637	2935	11	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	2935	12	from	from	IN
18637	2935	13	a	a	DT
18637	2935	14	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	2935	15	nor	nor	CC
18637	2935	16	circumscribe	circumscribe	VB
18637	2935	17	the	the	DT
18637	2935	18	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	2935	19	's	's	POS
18637	2935	20	right	right	NN
18637	2935	21	to	to	IN
18637	2935	22	such	such	PDT
18637	2935	23	an	an	DT
18637	2935	24	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	2935	25	extent	extent	NN
18637	2935	26	as	as	IN
18637	2935	27	to	to	TO
18637	2935	28	deny	deny	VB
18637	2935	29	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2935	30	due	due	JJ
18637	2935	31	process	process	NN
18637	2935	32	of	of	IN
18637	2935	33	law;[1096	law;[1096	NNP
18637	2935	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2935	35	neither	neither	CC
18637	2935	36	may	may	MD
18637	2935	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2935	38	subject	subject	VB
18637	2935	39	the	the	DT
18637	2935	40	fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	2935	41	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	2935	42	of	of	IN
18637	2935	43	a	a	DT
18637	2935	44	political	political	JJ
18637	2935	45	subdivision	subdivision	NN
18637	2935	46	of	of	IN
18637	2935	47	a	a	DT
18637	2935	48	State	state	NN
18637	2935	49	to	to	IN
18637	2935	50	the	the	DT
18637	2935	51	control	control	NN
18637	2935	52	of	of	IN
18637	2935	53	a	a	DT
18637	2935	54	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2935	55	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2935	56	court	court	NN
18637	2935	57	.	.	.
18637	2936	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2936	2	1097	1097	CD
18637	2936	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2936	4	Since	since	IN
18637	2936	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2936	6	may	may	MD
18637	2936	7	not	not	RB
18637	2936	8	supersede	supersede	VB
18637	2936	9	the	the	DT
18637	2936	10	power	power	NN
18637	2936	11	of	of	IN
18637	2936	12	a	a	DT
18637	2936	13	State	State	NNP
18637	2936	14	to	to	TO
18637	2936	15	determine	determine	VB
18637	2936	16	how	how	WRB
18637	2936	17	a	a	DT
18637	2936	18	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2936	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	2936	20	be	be	VB
18637	2936	21	formed	form	VBN
18637	2936	22	,	,	,
18637	2936	23	supervised	supervise	VBN
18637	2936	24	and	and	CC
18637	2936	25	dissolved	dissolve	VBN
18637	2936	26	,	,	,
18637	2936	27	a	a	DT
18637	2936	28	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	2936	29	which	which	WDT
18637	2936	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	2936	31	been	be	VBN
18637	2936	32	dissolved	dissolve	VBN
18637	2936	33	by	by	IN
18637	2936	34	a	a	DT
18637	2936	35	decree	decree	NN
18637	2936	36	of	of	IN
18637	2936	37	a	a	DT
18637	2936	38	State	State	NNP
18637	2936	39	court	court	NN
18637	2936	40	may	may	MD
18637	2936	41	not	not	RB
18637	2936	42	file	file	VB
18637	2936	43	a	a	DT
18637	2936	44	petition	petition	NN
18637	2936	45	for	for	IN
18637	2936	46	reorganization	reorganization	NN
18637	2936	47	under	under	IN
18637	2936	48	the	the	DT
18637	2936	49	Bankruptcy	Bankruptcy	NNP
18637	2936	50	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	2936	51	.	.	.
18637	2937	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2937	2	1098	1098	CD
18637	2937	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2937	4	But	but	CC
18637	2937	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2937	6	may	may	MD
18637	2937	7	impair	impair	VB
18637	2937	8	the	the	DT
18637	2937	9	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	2937	10	of	of	IN
18637	2937	11	a	a	DT
18637	2937	12	contract	contract	NN
18637	2937	13	and	and	CC
18637	2937	14	may	may	MD
18637	2937	15	extend	extend	VB
18637	2937	16	the	the	DT
18637	2937	17	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	2937	18	of	of	IN
18637	2937	19	the	the	DT
18637	2937	20	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2937	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	2937	22	to	to	IN
18637	2937	23	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	2937	24	already	already	RB
18637	2937	25	entered	enter	VBN
18637	2937	26	into	into	IN
18637	2937	27	at	at	IN
18637	2937	28	the	the	DT
18637	2937	29	time	time	NN
18637	2937	30	of	of	IN
18637	2937	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2937	32	passage	passage	NN
18637	2937	33	.	.	.
18637	2938	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2938	2	1099	1099	CD
18637	2938	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2938	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2938	5	may	may	MD
18637	2938	6	also	also	RB
18637	2938	7	empower	empower	VB
18637	2938	8	courts	court	NNS
18637	2938	9	of	of	IN
18637	2938	10	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2938	11	to	to	TO
18637	2938	12	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	2938	13	petitions	petition	NNS
18637	2938	14	by	by	IN
18637	2938	15	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	2938	16	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	2938	17	or	or	CC
18637	2938	18	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	2938	19	for	for	IN
18637	2938	20	a	a	DT
18637	2938	21	composition	composition	NN
18637	2938	22	of	of	IN
18637	2938	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2938	24	indebtedness	indebtedness	NN
18637	2938	25	where	where	WRB
18637	2938	26	the	the	DT
18637	2938	27	State	State	NNP
18637	2938	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	2938	29	consented	consent	VBN
18637	2938	30	to	to	IN
18637	2938	31	the	the	DT
18637	2938	32	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	2938	33	and	and	CC
18637	2938	34	the	the	DT
18637	2938	35	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2938	36	court	court	NN
18637	2938	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	2938	38	not	not	RB
18637	2938	39	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	2938	40	to	to	TO
18637	2938	41	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	2938	42	with	with	IN
18637	2938	43	the	the	DT
18637	2938	44	fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	2938	45	or	or	CC
18637	2938	46	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	2938	47	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	2938	48	of	of	IN
18637	2938	49	the	the	DT
18637	2938	50	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	2938	51	.	.	.
18637	2939	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2939	2	1100	1100	CD
18637	2939	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2939	4	Also	also	RB
18637	2939	5	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2939	6	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2939	7	must	must	MD
18637	2939	8	be	be	VB
18637	2939	9	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2939	10	,	,	,
18637	2939	11	but	but	CC
18637	2939	12	the	the	DT
18637	2939	13	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	2939	14	required	require	VBN
18637	2939	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	2939	16	geographic	geographic	JJ
18637	2939	17	,	,	,
18637	2939	18	not	not	RB
18637	2939	19	personal	personal	JJ
18637	2939	20	.	.	.
18637	2940	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2940	2	may	may	MD
18637	2940	3	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	2940	4	the	the	DT
18637	2940	5	laws	law	NNS
18637	2940	6	of	of	IN
18637	2940	7	the	the	DT
18637	2940	8	States	States	NNPS
18637	2940	9	relating	relate	VBG
18637	2940	10	to	to	IN
18637	2940	11	dower	dower	NN
18637	2940	12	,	,	,
18637	2940	13	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	2940	14	,	,	,
18637	2940	15	the	the	DT
18637	2940	16	validity	validity	NN
18637	2940	17	of	of	IN
18637	2940	18	mortgages	mortgage	NNS
18637	2940	19	,	,	,
18637	2940	20	priorities	priority	NNS
18637	2940	21	of	of	IN
18637	2940	22	payment	payment	NN
18637	2940	23	and	and	CC
18637	2940	24	similar	similar	JJ
18637	2940	25	matters	matter	NNS
18637	2940	26	,	,	,
18637	2940	27	even	even	RB
18637	2940	28	though	though	IN
18637	2940	29	such	such	JJ
18637	2940	30	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	2940	31	leads	lead	VBZ
18637	2940	32	to	to	IN
18637	2940	33	different	different	JJ
18637	2940	34	results	result	NNS
18637	2940	35	from	from	IN
18637	2940	36	State	State	NNP
18637	2940	37	to	to	IN
18637	2940	38	State	State	NNP
18637	2940	39	.	.	.
18637	2941	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2941	2	1101	1101	CD
18637	2941	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2941	4	THE	the	DT
18637	2941	5	POWER	power	NN
18637	2941	6	NOT	not	RB
18637	2941	7	EXCLUSIVE	exclusive	VBP
18637	2941	8	Prior	prior	RB
18637	2941	9	to	to	IN
18637	2941	10	1898	1898	CD
18637	2941	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2941	12	exercised	exercise	VBD
18637	2941	13	the	the	DT
18637	2941	14	power	power	NN
18637	2941	15	to	to	TO
18637	2941	16	establish	establish	VB
18637	2941	17	"	"	``
18637	2941	18	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	2941	19	laws	law	NNS
18637	2941	20	on	on	IN
18637	2941	21	the	the	DT
18637	2941	22	subject	subject	NN
18637	2941	23	of	of	IN
18637	2941	24	bankruptcies	bankruptcy	NNS
18637	2941	25	"	"	``
18637	2941	26	only	only	RB
18637	2941	27	very	very	RB
18637	2941	28	intermittently	intermittently	RB
18637	2941	29	.	.	.
18637	2942	1	The	the	DT
18637	2942	2	first	first	JJ
18637	2942	3	national	national	JJ
18637	2942	4	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2942	5	law	law	NN
18637	2942	6	was	be	VBD
18637	2942	7	not	not	RB
18637	2942	8	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	2942	9	until	until	IN
18637	2942	10	1800	1800	CD
18637	2942	11	to	to	TO
18637	2942	12	be	be	VB
18637	2942	13	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	2942	14	in	in	IN
18637	2942	15	1803	1803	CD
18637	2942	16	;	;	:
18637	2942	17	the	the	DT
18637	2942	18	second	second	JJ
18637	2942	19	was	be	VBD
18637	2942	20	passed	pass	VBN
18637	2942	21	in	in	IN
18637	2942	22	1841	1841	CD
18637	2942	23	and	and	CC
18637	2942	24	repealed	repeal	VBD
18637	2942	25	two	two	CD
18637	2942	26	years	year	NNS
18637	2942	27	later	later	RB
18637	2942	28	;	;	:
18637	2942	29	the	the	DT
18637	2942	30	third	third	JJ
18637	2942	31	was	be	VBD
18637	2942	32	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	2942	33	in	in	IN
18637	2942	34	1867	1867	CD
18637	2942	35	and	and	CC
18637	2942	36	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	2942	37	in	in	IN
18637	2942	38	1878	1878	CD
18637	2942	39	.	.	.
18637	2943	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2943	2	1102	1102	CD
18637	2943	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2943	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	2943	5	during	during	IN
18637	2943	6	the	the	DT
18637	2943	7	first	first	JJ
18637	2943	8	89	89	CD
18637	2943	9	years	year	NNS
18637	2943	10	under	under	IN
18637	2943	11	the	the	DT
18637	2943	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	2943	13	a	a	DT
18637	2943	14	national	national	JJ
18637	2943	15	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2943	16	law	law	NN
18637	2943	17	was	be	VBD
18637	2943	18	in	in	IN
18637	2943	19	existence	existence	NN
18637	2943	20	only	only	RB
18637	2943	21	sixteen	sixteen	CD
18637	2943	22	years	year	NNS
18637	2943	23	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	2943	24	.	.	.
18637	2944	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	2944	2	the	the	DT
18637	2944	3	most	most	RBS
18637	2944	4	important	important	JJ
18637	2944	5	problems	problem	NNS
18637	2944	6	of	of	IN
18637	2944	7	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	2944	8	which	which	WDT
18637	2944	9	arose	arise	VBD
18637	2944	10	during	during	IN
18637	2944	11	that	that	DT
18637	2944	12	period	period	NN
18637	2944	13	concerned	concern	VBD
18637	2944	14	the	the	DT
18637	2944	15	effect	effect	NN
18637	2944	16	of	of	IN
18637	2944	17	this	this	DT
18637	2944	18	clause	clause	NN
18637	2944	19	on	on	IN
18637	2944	20	State	State	NNP
18637	2944	21	law	law	NN
18637	2944	22	.	.	.
18637	2945	1	The	the	DT
18637	2945	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2945	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2945	4	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	2945	5	at	at	IN
18637	2945	6	an	an	DT
18637	2945	7	early	early	JJ
18637	2945	8	date	date	NN
18637	2945	9	that	that	IN
18637	2945	10	in	in	IN
18637	2945	11	the	the	DT
18637	2945	12	absence	absence	NN
18637	2945	13	of	of	IN
18637	2945	14	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	2945	15	action	action	NN
18637	2945	16	the	the	DT
18637	2945	17	States	state	NNS
18637	2945	18	may	may	MD
18637	2945	19	enact	enact	VB
18637	2945	20	insolvency	insolvency	NN
18637	2945	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	2945	22	since	since	IN
18637	2945	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2945	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	2945	25	not	not	RB
18637	2945	26	the	the	DT
18637	2945	27	mere	mere	JJ
18637	2945	28	existence	existence	NN
18637	2945	29	of	of	IN
18637	2945	30	the	the	DT
18637	2945	31	power	power	NN
18637	2945	32	but	but	CC
18637	2945	33	rather	rather	RB
18637	2945	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2945	35	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2945	36	which	which	WDT
18637	2945	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	2945	38	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
18637	2945	39	with	with	IN
18637	2945	40	the	the	DT
18637	2945	41	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2945	42	of	of	IN
18637	2945	43	the	the	DT
18637	2945	44	same	same	JJ
18637	2945	45	power	power	NN
18637	2945	46	by	by	IN
18637	2945	47	the	the	DT
18637	2945	48	States	States	NNP
18637	2945	49	.	.	.
18637	2946	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2946	2	1103	1103	CD
18637	2946	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2946	4	Later	late	JJR
18637	2946	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	2946	6	were	be	VBD
18637	2946	7	to	to	TO
18637	2946	8	settle	settle	VB
18637	2946	9	further	further	RB
18637	2946	10	that	that	IN
18637	2946	11	the	the	DT
18637	2946	12	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	2946	13	of	of	IN
18637	2946	14	a	a	DT
18637	2946	15	national	national	JJ
18637	2946	16	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2946	17	law	law	NN
18637	2946	18	does	do	VBZ
18637	2946	19	not	not	RB
18637	2946	20	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	2946	21	State	State	NNP
18637	2946	22	laws	law	NNS
18637	2946	23	in	in	IN
18637	2946	24	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	2946	25	therewith	therewith	NNP
18637	2946	26	but	but	CC
18637	2946	27	serves	serve	VBZ
18637	2946	28	only	only	RB
18637	2946	29	to	to	TO
18637	2946	30	relegate	relegate	VB
18637	2946	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2946	32	to	to	IN
18637	2946	33	a	a	DT
18637	2946	34	state	state	NN
18637	2946	35	of	of	IN
18637	2946	36	suspended	suspend	VBN
18637	2946	37	animation	animation	NN
18637	2946	38	with	with	IN
18637	2946	39	the	the	DT
18637	2946	40	result	result	NN
18637	2946	41	that	that	IN
18637	2946	42	upon	upon	IN
18637	2946	43	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	2946	44	of	of	IN
18637	2946	45	the	the	DT
18637	2946	46	national	national	JJ
18637	2946	47	statute	statute	NN
18637	2946	48	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2946	49	again	again	RB
18637	2946	50	come	come	VBP
18637	2946	51	into	into	IN
18637	2946	52	operation	operation	NN
18637	2946	53	without	without	IN
18637	2946	54	reenactment	reenactment	NN
18637	2946	55	.	.	.
18637	2947	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2947	2	1104	1104	CD
18637	2947	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2947	4	CONSTITUTIONAL	constitutional	JJ
18637	2947	5	STATUS	status	NN
18637	2947	6	OF	of	IN
18637	2947	7	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2947	8	INSOLVENCY	INSOLVENCY	VBD
18637	2947	9	LAWS	LAWS	NNP
18637	2947	10	A	a	DT
18637	2947	11	State	state	NN
18637	2947	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	2947	13	,	,	,
18637	2947	14	of	of	IN
18637	2947	15	course	course	NN
18637	2947	16	,	,	,
18637	2947	17	without	without	IN
18637	2947	18	power	power	NN
18637	2947	19	to	to	TO
18637	2947	20	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	2947	21	any	any	DT
18637	2947	22	law	law	NN
18637	2947	23	governing	govern	VBG
18637	2947	24	bankruptcies	bankruptcy	NNS
18637	2947	25	which	which	WDT
18637	2947	26	impairs	impairs	VBP
18637	2947	27	the	the	DT
18637	2947	28	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	2947	29	of	of	IN
18637	2947	30	contracts,[1105	contracts,[1105	NNP
18637	2947	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2947	32	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	2947	33	to	to	IN
18637	2947	34	persons	person	NNS
18637	2947	35	or	or	CC
18637	2947	36	property	property	NN
18637	2947	37	outside	outside	IN
18637	2947	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2947	39	jurisdiction,[1106	jurisdiction,[1106	NNP
18637	2947	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2947	41	or	or	CC
18637	2947	42	conflicts	conflict	NNS
18637	2947	43	with	with	IN
18637	2947	44	the	the	DT
18637	2947	45	national	national	JJ
18637	2947	46	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2947	47	laws	law	NNS
18637	2947	48	.	.	.
18637	2948	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2948	2	1107	1107	CD
18637	2948	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2948	4	Giving	give	VBG
18637	2948	5	effect	effect	NN
18637	2948	6	to	to	IN
18637	2948	7	the	the	DT
18637	2948	8	policy	policy	NN
18637	2948	9	of	of	IN
18637	2948	10	the	the	DT
18637	2948	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2948	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	2948	13	,	,	,
18637	2948	14	the	the	DT
18637	2948	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2948	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2948	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	2948	18	held	hold	VBN
18637	2948	19	that	that	IN
18637	2948	20	a	a	DT
18637	2948	21	State	State	NNP
18637	2948	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	2948	23	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	2948	24	the	the	DT
18637	2948	25	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	2948	26	of	of	IN
18637	2948	27	property	property	NN
18637	2948	28	of	of	IN
18637	2948	29	an	an	DT
18637	2948	30	insolvent	insolvent	NN
18637	2948	31	was	be	VBD
18637	2948	32	suspended	suspend	VBN
18637	2948	33	by	by	IN
18637	2948	34	that	that	DT
18637	2948	35	law,[1108	law,[1108	ADD
18637	2948	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2948	37	and	and	CC
18637	2948	38	that	that	IN
18637	2948	39	a	a	DT
18637	2948	40	State	State	NNP
18637	2948	41	court	court	NN
18637	2948	42	was	be	VBD
18637	2948	43	without	without	IN
18637	2948	44	power	power	NN
18637	2948	45	to	to	TO
18637	2948	46	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	2948	47	with	with	IN
18637	2948	48	pending	pende	VBG
18637	2948	49	foreclosure	foreclosure	NN
18637	2948	50	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	2948	51	after	after	IN
18637	2948	52	a	a	DT
18637	2948	53	farmer	farmer	NN
18637	2948	54	-	-	HYPH
18637	2948	55	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	2948	56	had	have	VBD
18637	2948	57	filed	file	VBN
18637	2948	58	a	a	DT
18637	2948	59	petition	petition	NN
18637	2948	60	in	in	IN
18637	2948	61	the	the	DT
18637	2948	62	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2948	63	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2948	64	court	court	NNP
18637	2948	65	for	for	IN
18637	2948	66	a	a	DT
18637	2948	67	composition	composition	NN
18637	2948	68	or	or	CC
18637	2948	69	extension	extension	NN
18637	2948	70	of	of	IN
18637	2948	71	time	time	NN
18637	2948	72	to	to	TO
18637	2948	73	pay	pay	VB
18637	2948	74	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2948	75	debts	debt	NNS
18637	2948	76	.	.	.
18637	2949	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2949	2	1109	1109	CD
18637	2949	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2949	4	A	a	DT
18637	2949	5	State	State	NNP
18637	2949	6	law	law	NN
18637	2949	7	governing	govern	VBG
18637	2949	8	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	2949	9	transfers	transfer	NNS
18637	2949	10	was	be	VBD
18637	2949	11	found	find	VBN
18637	2949	12	to	to	TO
18637	2949	13	be	be	VB
18637	2949	14	compatible	compatible	JJ
18637	2949	15	with	with	IN
18637	2949	16	the	the	DT
18637	2949	17	act	act	NN
18637	2949	18	of	of	IN
18637	2949	19	Congress,[1110	Congress,[1110	NNP
18637	2949	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2949	21	as	as	IN
18637	2949	22	was	be	VBD
18637	2949	23	a	a	DT
18637	2949	24	statute	statute	NN
18637	2949	25	which	which	WDT
18637	2949	26	provided	provide	VBD
18637	2949	27	that	that	IN
18637	2949	28	a	a	DT
18637	2949	29	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	2949	30	in	in	IN
18637	2949	31	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	2949	32	should	should	MD
18637	2949	33	be	be	VB
18637	2949	34	unavailing	unavaile	VBG
18637	2949	35	to	to	TO
18637	2949	36	terminate	terminate	VB
18637	2949	37	the	the	DT
18637	2949	38	suspension	suspension	NN
18637	2949	39	of	of	IN
18637	2949	40	the	the	DT
18637	2949	41	driver	driver	NN
18637	2949	42	's	's	POS
18637	2949	43	license	license	NN
18637	2949	44	of	of	IN
18637	2949	45	a	a	DT
18637	2949	46	person	person	NN
18637	2949	47	who	who	WP
18637	2949	48	failed	fail	VBD
18637	2949	49	to	to	TO
18637	2949	50	pay	pay	VB
18637	2949	51	a	a	DT
18637	2949	52	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	2949	53	rendered	render	VBN
18637	2949	54	against	against	IN
18637	2949	55	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2949	56	for	for	IN
18637	2949	57	damages	damage	NNS
18637	2949	58	resulting	result	VBG
18637	2949	59	from	from	IN
18637	2949	60	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2949	61	negligent	negligent	JJ
18637	2949	62	operation	operation	NN
18637	2949	63	of	of	IN
18637	2949	64	a	a	DT
18637	2949	65	motor	motor	NN
18637	2949	66	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	2949	67	.	.	.
18637	2950	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2950	2	1111	1111	CD
18637	2950	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2950	4	If	if	IN
18637	2950	5	a	a	DT
18637	2950	6	State	state	NN
18637	2950	7	desires	desire	NNS
18637	2950	8	to	to	TO
18637	2950	9	participate	participate	VB
18637	2950	10	in	in	IN
18637	2950	11	the	the	DT
18637	2950	12	assets	asset	NNS
18637	2950	13	of	of	IN
18637	2950	14	a	a	DT
18637	2950	15	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
18637	2950	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2950	17	must	must	MD
18637	2950	18	submit	submit	VB
18637	2950	19	to	to	IN
18637	2950	20	the	the	DT
18637	2950	21	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	2950	22	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	2950	23	of	of	IN
18637	2950	24	the	the	DT
18637	2950	25	Bankruptcy	Bankruptcy	NNP
18637	2950	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2950	27	with	with	IN
18637	2950	28	respect	respect	NN
18637	2950	29	to	to	IN
18637	2950	30	the	the	DT
18637	2950	31	filing	filing	NN
18637	2950	32	of	of	IN
18637	2950	33	claims	claim	NNS
18637	2950	34	by	by	IN
18637	2950	35	a	a	DT
18637	2950	36	designated	designate	VBN
18637	2950	37	date	date	NN
18637	2950	38	;	;	:
18637	2950	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2950	40	can	can	MD
18637	2950	41	not	not	RB
18637	2950	42	assert	assert	VB
18637	2950	43	a	a	DT
18637	2950	44	claim	claim	NN
18637	2950	45	for	for	IN
18637	2950	46	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2950	47	by	by	IN
18637	2950	48	filing	file	VBG
18637	2950	49	a	a	DT
18637	2950	50	demand	demand	NN
18637	2950	51	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	2950	52	at	at	IN
18637	2950	53	a	a	DT
18637	2950	54	later	later	JJ
18637	2950	55	date	date	NN
18637	2950	56	.	.	.
18637	2951	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2951	2	1112	1112	CD
18637	2951	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2951	4	Clauses	Clauses	NNP
18637	2951	5	5	5	CD
18637	2951	6	and	and	CC
18637	2951	7	6	6	CD
18637	2951	8	.	.	.
18637	2952	1	_	_	NNP
18637	2952	2	The	the	DT
18637	2952	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2952	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	2952	5	have	have	VB
18637	2952	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	2952	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2952	8	*	*	NFP
18637	2952	9	*	*	NFP
18637	2952	10	*	*	NFP
18637	2952	11	To	to	TO
18637	2952	12	coin	coin	VB
18637	2952	13	Money	money	NN
18637	2952	14	,	,	,
18637	2952	15	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2952	16	the	the	DT
18637	2952	17	Value	Value	NNP
18637	2952	18	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	2952	19	,	,	,
18637	2952	20	and	and	CC
18637	2952	21	of	of	IN
18637	2952	22	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	2952	23	Coin	Coin	NNP
18637	2952	24	,	,	,
18637	2952	25	and	and	CC
18637	2952	26	fix	fix	VB
18637	2952	27	the	the	DT
18637	2952	28	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	2952	29	of	of	IN
18637	2952	30	Weights	Weights	NNPS
18637	2952	31	and	and	CC
18637	2952	32	Measures	Measures	NNPS
18637	2952	33	.	.	.
18637	2953	1	*	*	NFP
18637	2953	2	*	*	NFP
18637	2953	3	*	*	NFP
18637	2953	4	To	to	TO
18637	2953	5	provide	provide	VB
18637	2953	6	for	for	IN
18637	2953	7	the	the	DT
18637	2953	8	Punishment	punishment	NN
18637	2953	9	of	of	IN
18637	2953	10	counterfeiting	counterfeit	VBG
18637	2953	11	the	the	DT
18637	2953	12	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	2953	13	and	and	CC
18637	2953	14	current	current	JJ
18637	2953	15	Coin	coin	NN
18637	2953	16	of	of	IN
18637	2953	17	the	the	DT
18637	2953	18	United	United	NNP
18637	2953	19	States	States	NNP
18637	2953	20	.	.	.
18637	2954	1	Fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	2954	2	and	and	CC
18637	2954	3	Monetary	Monetary	NNP
18637	2954	4	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	2954	5	of	of	IN
18637	2954	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2954	7	COINAGE	COINAGE	NNP
18637	2954	8	,	,	,
18637	2954	9	WEIGHTS	WEIGHTS	NNP
18637	2954	10	AND	and	CC
18637	2954	11	MEASURES	MEASURES	NNP
18637	2954	12	The	the	DT
18637	2954	13	power	power	NN
18637	2954	14	"	"	''
18637	2954	15	to	to	TO
18637	2954	16	coin	coin	VB
18637	2954	17	money	money	NN
18637	2954	18	"	"	''
18637	2954	19	and	and	CC
18637	2954	20	"	"	``
18637	2954	21	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2954	22	the	the	DT
18637	2954	23	value	value	NN
18637	2954	24	thereof	thereof	IN
18637	2954	25	"	"	''
18637	2954	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	2954	27	been	be	VBN
18637	2954	28	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	2954	29	construed	construe	VBN
18637	2954	30	to	to	TO
18637	2954	31	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	2954	32	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	2954	33	of	of	IN
18637	2954	34	every	every	DT
18637	2954	35	phase	phase	NN
18637	2954	36	of	of	IN
18637	2954	37	the	the	DT
18637	2954	38	subject	subject	NN
18637	2954	39	of	of	IN
18637	2954	40	currency	currency	NN
18637	2954	41	.	.	.
18637	2955	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2955	2	may	may	MD
18637	2955	3	charter	charter	VB
18637	2955	4	banks	bank	NNS
18637	2955	5	and	and	CC
18637	2955	6	endow	endow	VB
18637	2955	7	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2955	8	with	with	IN
18637	2955	9	the	the	DT
18637	2955	10	right	right	NN
18637	2955	11	to	to	TO
18637	2955	12	issue	issue	VB
18637	2955	13	circulating	circulate	VBG
18637	2955	14	notes,[1113	notes,[1113	NNP
18637	2955	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2955	16	and	and	CC
18637	2955	17	may	may	MD
18637	2955	18	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	2955	19	the	the	DT
18637	2955	20	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	2955	21	of	of	IN
18637	2955	22	notes	note	NNS
18637	2955	23	not	not	RB
18637	2955	24	issued	issue	VBN
18637	2955	25	under	under	IN
18637	2955	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2955	27	own	own	JJ
18637	2955	28	authority	authority	NN
18637	2955	29	.	.	.
18637	2956	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2956	2	1114	1114	CD
18637	2956	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2956	4	To	to	IN
18637	2956	5	this	this	DT
18637	2956	6	end	end	NN
18637	2956	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2956	8	may	may	MD
18637	2956	9	impose	impose	VB
18637	2956	10	a	a	DT
18637	2956	11	prohibitive	prohibitive	JJ
18637	2956	12	tax	tax	NN
18637	2956	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	2956	14	the	the	DT
18637	2956	15	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	2956	16	of	of	IN
18637	2956	17	the	the	DT
18637	2956	18	notes	note	NNS
18637	2956	19	of	of	IN
18637	2956	20	State	State	NNP
18637	2956	21	banks[1115	banks[1115	NNP
18637	2956	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2956	23	or	or	CC
18637	2956	24	of	of	IN
18637	2956	25	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	2956	26	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2956	27	.	.	.
18637	2957	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2957	2	1116	1116	CD
18637	2957	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2957	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2957	5	may	may	MD
18637	2957	6	require	require	VB
18637	2957	7	the	the	DT
18637	2957	8	surrender	surrender	NN
18637	2957	9	of	of	IN
18637	2957	10	gold	gold	JJ
18637	2957	11	coin	coin	NN
18637	2957	12	and	and	CC
18637	2957	13	of	of	IN
18637	2957	14	gold	gold	NN
18637	2957	15	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	2957	16	in	in	IN
18637	2957	17	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	2957	18	for	for	IN
18637	2957	19	other	other	JJ
18637	2957	20	currency	currency	NN
18637	2957	21	not	not	RB
18637	2957	22	redeemable	redeemable	JJ
18637	2957	23	in	in	IN
18637	2957	24	gold	gold	NN
18637	2957	25	.	.	.
18637	2958	1	A	a	DT
18637	2958	2	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	2958	3	who	who	WP
18637	2958	4	sought	seek	VBD
18637	2958	5	payment	payment	NN
18637	2958	6	for	for	IN
18637	2958	7	the	the	DT
18637	2958	8	gold	gold	JJ
18637	2958	9	coin	coin	NN
18637	2958	10	and	and	CC
18637	2958	11	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	2958	12	thus	thus	RB
18637	2958	13	surrendered	surrender	VBD
18637	2958	14	in	in	IN
18637	2958	15	an	an	DT
18637	2958	16	amount	amount	NN
18637	2958	17	measured	measure	VBN
18637	2958	18	by	by	IN
18637	2958	19	the	the	DT
18637	2958	20	higher	high	JJR
18637	2958	21	market	market	NN
18637	2958	22	value	value	NN
18637	2958	23	of	of	IN
18637	2958	24	gold	gold	NN
18637	2958	25	,	,	,
18637	2958	26	was	be	VBD
18637	2958	27	denied	deny	VBN
18637	2958	28	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	2958	29	on	on	IN
18637	2958	30	the	the	DT
18637	2958	31	ground	ground	NN
18637	2958	32	that	that	IN
18637	2958	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2958	34	had	have	VBD
18637	2958	35	not	not	RB
18637	2958	36	proved	prove	VBN
18637	2958	37	that	that	IN
18637	2958	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2958	39	would	would	MD
18637	2958	40	suffer	suffer	VB
18637	2958	41	any	any	DT
18637	2958	42	actual	actual	JJ
18637	2958	43	loss	loss	NN
18637	2958	44	by	by	IN
18637	2958	45	being	be	VBG
18637	2958	46	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	2958	47	to	to	TO
18637	2958	48	accept	accept	VB
18637	2958	49	an	an	DT
18637	2958	50	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
18637	2958	51	amount	amount	NN
18637	2958	52	of	of	IN
18637	2958	53	other	other	JJ
18637	2958	54	currency	currency	NN
18637	2958	55	.	.	.
18637	2959	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2959	2	1117	1117	CD
18637	2959	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2959	4	Inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	2959	5	as	as	IN
18637	2959	6	"	"	``
18637	2959	7	every	every	DT
18637	2959	8	contract	contract	NN
18637	2959	9	for	for	IN
18637	2959	10	the	the	DT
18637	2959	11	payment	payment	NN
18637	2959	12	of	of	IN
18637	2959	13	money	money	NN
18637	2959	14	,	,	,
18637	2959	15	simply	simply	RB
18637	2959	16	,	,	,
18637	2959	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	2959	18	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	2959	19	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2959	20	to	to	IN
18637	2959	21	the	the	DT
18637	2959	22	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2959	23	power	power	NN
18637	2959	24	of	of	IN
18637	2959	25	the	the	DT
18637	2959	26	government	government	NN
18637	2959	27	over	over	IN
18637	2959	28	the	the	DT
18637	2959	29	currency	currency	NN
18637	2959	30	,	,	,
18637	2959	31	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	2959	32	that	that	DT
18637	2959	33	power	power	NN
18637	2959	34	may	may	MD
18637	2959	35	be	be	VB
18637	2959	36	,	,	,
18637	2959	37	and	and	CC
18637	2959	38	the	the	DT
18637	2959	39	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	2959	40	of	of	IN
18637	2959	41	the	the	DT
18637	2959	42	parties	party	NNS
18637	2959	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	2959	44	,	,	,
18637	2959	45	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	2959	46	,	,	,
18637	2959	47	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	2959	48	with	with	IN
18637	2959	49	reference	reference	NN
18637	2959	50	to	to	IN
18637	2959	51	that	that	DT
18637	2959	52	power,"[1118	power,"[1118	NN
18637	2959	53	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2959	54	the	the	DT
18637	2959	55	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2959	56	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2959	57	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	2959	58	the	the	DT
18637	2959	59	power	power	NN
18637	2959	60	of	of	IN
18637	2959	61	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2959	62	to	to	TO
18637	2959	63	make	make	VB
18637	2959	64	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	2959	65	notes	note	NNS
18637	2959	66	legal	legal	JJ
18637	2959	67	tender	tender	NN
18637	2959	68	in	in	IN
18637	2959	69	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
18637	2959	70	of	of	IN
18637	2959	71	antecedent	antecedent	NN
18637	2959	72	debts,[1119	debts,[1119	NNP
18637	2959	73	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2959	74	and	and	CC
18637	2959	75	,	,	,
18637	2959	76	many	many	JJ
18637	2959	77	years	year	NNS
18637	2959	78	later	later	RB
18637	2959	79	,	,	,
18637	2959	80	to	to	TO
18637	2959	81	abrogate	abrogate	VB
18637	2959	82	the	the	DT
18637	2959	83	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	2959	84	in	in	IN
18637	2959	85	private	private	JJ
18637	2959	86	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	2959	87	calling	call	VBG
18637	2959	88	for	for	IN
18637	2959	89	payment	payment	NN
18637	2959	90	in	in	IN
18637	2959	91	gold	gold	NN
18637	2959	92	coin	coin	NN
18637	2959	93	,	,	,
18637	2959	94	even	even	RB
18637	2959	95	though	though	IN
18637	2959	96	such	such	JJ
18637	2959	97	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	2959	98	were	be	VBD
18637	2959	99	executed	execute	VBN
18637	2959	100	before	before	IN
18637	2959	101	the	the	DT
18637	2959	102	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	2959	103	was	be	VBD
18637	2959	104	passed	pass	VBN
18637	2959	105	.	.	.
18637	2960	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2960	2	1120	1120	CD
18637	2960	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2960	4	The	the	DT
18637	2960	5	power	power	NN
18637	2960	6	to	to	TO
18637	2960	7	coin	coin	VB
18637	2960	8	money	money	NN
18637	2960	9	also	also	RB
18637	2960	10	imports	import	VBZ
18637	2960	11	authority	authority	NN
18637	2960	12	to	to	TO
18637	2960	13	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	2960	14	such	such	JJ
18637	2960	15	coinage	coinage	NN
18637	2960	16	as	as	IN
18637	2960	17	a	a	DT
18637	2960	18	medium	medium	NN
18637	2960	19	of	of	IN
18637	2960	20	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	2960	21	at	at	IN
18637	2960	22	home	home	NN
18637	2960	23	,	,	,
18637	2960	24	and	and	CC
18637	2960	25	to	to	TO
18637	2960	26	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	2960	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2960	28	diversion	diversion	NN
18637	2960	29	to	to	IN
18637	2960	30	other	other	JJ
18637	2960	31	uses	use	NNS
18637	2960	32	by	by	IN
18637	2960	33	defacement	defacement	NN
18637	2960	34	,	,	,
18637	2960	35	melting	melting	NN
18637	2960	36	or	or	CC
18637	2960	37	exportation	exportation	NN
18637	2960	38	.	.	.
18637	2961	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2961	2	1121	1121	CD
18637	2961	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2961	4	THE	the	DT
18637	2961	5	PUNISHMENTS	punishment	NNS
18637	2961	6	OF	of	IN
18637	2961	7	COUNTERFEITING	counterfeiting	NN
18637	2961	8	In	in	IN
18637	2961	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2961	10	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	2961	11	aspect	aspect	NN
18637	2961	12	this	this	DT
18637	2961	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	2961	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	2961	15	been	be	VBN
18637	2961	16	given	give	VBN
18637	2961	17	a	a	DT
18637	2961	18	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	2961	19	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	2961	20	;	;	:
18637	2961	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2961	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	2961	23	been	be	VBN
18637	2961	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	2961	25	not	not	RB
18637	2961	26	to	to	TO
18637	2961	27	cover	cover	VB
18637	2961	28	the	the	DT
18637	2961	29	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	2961	30	of	of	IN
18637	2961	31	counterfeit	counterfeit	JJ
18637	2961	32	coin	coin	NN
18637	2961	33	or	or	CC
18637	2961	34	the	the	DT
18637	2961	35	possession	possession	NN
18637	2961	36	of	of	IN
18637	2961	37	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	2961	38	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
18637	2961	39	of	of	IN
18637	2961	40	use	use	NN
18637	2961	41	for	for	IN
18637	2961	42	making	make	VBG
18637	2961	43	counterfeit	counterfeit	JJ
18637	2961	44	coin	coin	NN
18637	2961	45	.	.	.
18637	2962	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2962	2	1122	1122	CD
18637	2962	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2962	4	At	at	IN
18637	2962	5	the	the	DT
18637	2962	6	same	same	JJ
18637	2962	7	time	time	NN
18637	2962	8	the	the	DT
18637	2962	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2962	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2962	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	2962	12	rebuffed	rebuff	VBN
18637	2962	13	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	2962	14	to	to	TO
18637	2962	15	read	read	VB
18637	2962	16	into	into	IN
18637	2962	17	this	this	DT
18637	2962	18	provision	provision	NN
18637	2962	19	a	a	DT
18637	2962	20	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	2962	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	2962	22	either	either	CC
18637	2962	23	the	the	DT
18637	2962	24	power	power	NN
18637	2962	25	of	of	IN
18637	2962	26	the	the	DT
18637	2962	27	States	States	NNPS
18637	2962	28	or	or	CC
18637	2962	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	2962	30	the	the	DT
18637	2962	31	powers	power	NNS
18637	2962	32	of	of	IN
18637	2962	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2962	34	under	under	IN
18637	2962	35	the	the	DT
18637	2962	36	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	2962	37	clause	clause	NN
18637	2962	38	.	.	.
18637	2963	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2963	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	2963	3	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	2963	4	that	that	IN
18637	2963	5	a	a	DT
18637	2963	6	State	state	NN
18637	2963	7	may	may	MD
18637	2963	8	punish	punish	VB
18637	2963	9	the	the	DT
18637	2963	10	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	2963	11	of	of	IN
18637	2963	12	forged	forge	VBN
18637	2963	13	coins	coin	NNS
18637	2963	14	.	.	.
18637	2964	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2964	2	1123	1123	CD
18637	2964	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2964	4	On	on	IN
18637	2964	5	the	the	DT
18637	2964	6	ground	ground	NN
18637	2964	7	that	that	IN
18637	2964	8	the	the	DT
18637	2964	9	power	power	NN
18637	2964	10	of	of	IN
18637	2964	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2964	12	to	to	TO
18637	2964	13	coin	coin	VB
18637	2964	14	money	money	NN
18637	2964	15	imports	import	NNS
18637	2964	16	"	"	''
18637	2964	17	the	the	DT
18637	2964	18	correspondent	correspondent	NN
18637	2964	19	and	and	CC
18637	2964	20	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2964	21	power	power	NN
18637	2964	22	and	and	CC
18637	2964	23	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	2964	24	to	to	TO
18637	2964	25	protect	protect	VB
18637	2964	26	and	and	CC
18637	2964	27	to	to	TO
18637	2964	28	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	2964	29	in	in	IN
18637	2964	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2964	31	purity	purity	NN
18637	2964	32	this	this	DT
18637	2964	33	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2964	34	currency	currency	NN
18637	2964	35	for	for	IN
18637	2964	36	the	the	DT
18637	2964	37	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	2964	38	of	of	IN
18637	2964	39	the	the	DT
18637	2964	40	nation,"[1124	nation,"[1124	NN
18637	2964	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2964	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2964	43	has	have	VBZ
18637	2964	44	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	2964	45	federal	federal	JJ
18637	2964	46	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	2964	47	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	2964	48	the	the	DT
18637	2964	49	importation	importation	NN
18637	2964	50	or	or	CC
18637	2964	51	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	2964	52	of	of	IN
18637	2964	53	counterfeit	counterfeit	JJ
18637	2964	54	coin,[1125	coin,[1125	NNP
18637	2964	55	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2964	56	or	or	CC
18637	2964	57	the	the	DT
18637	2964	58	willing	willing	JJ
18637	2964	59	and	and	CC
18637	2964	60	conscious	conscious	JJ
18637	2964	61	possession	possession	NN
18637	2964	62	of	of	IN
18637	2964	63	dies	die	NNS
18637	2964	64	in	in	IN
18637	2964	65	the	the	DT
18637	2964	66	likeness	likeness	NN
18637	2964	67	of	of	IN
18637	2964	68	those	those	DT
18637	2964	69	used	use	VBN
18637	2964	70	for	for	IN
18637	2964	71	making	make	VBG
18637	2964	72	coins	coin	NNS
18637	2964	73	of	of	IN
18637	2964	74	the	the	DT
18637	2964	75	United	United	NNP
18637	2964	76	States	States	NNP
18637	2964	77	.	.	.
18637	2965	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2965	2	1126	1126	CD
18637	2965	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2965	4	In	in	IN
18637	2965	5	short	short	JJ
18637	2965	6	,	,	,
18637	2965	7	the	the	DT
18637	2965	8	above	above	JJ
18637	2965	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	2965	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	2965	11	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	2965	12	superfluous	superfluous	JJ
18637	2965	13	.	.	.
18637	2966	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2966	2	would	would	MD
18637	2966	3	have	have	VB
18637	2966	4	had	have	VBN
18637	2966	5	the	the	DT
18637	2966	6	power	power	NN
18637	2966	7	which	which	WDT
18637	2966	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2966	9	purports	purport	VBZ
18637	2966	10	to	to	TO
18637	2966	11	confer	confer	VB
18637	2966	12	under	under	IN
18637	2966	13	the	the	DT
18637	2966	14	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2966	15	and	and	CC
18637	2966	16	proper	proper	JJ
18637	2966	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	2966	18	;	;	:
18637	2966	19	and	and	CC
18637	2966	20	the	the	DT
18637	2966	21	same	same	JJ
18637	2966	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	2966	23	the	the	DT
18637	2966	24	case	case	NN
18637	2966	25	with	with	IN
18637	2966	26	the	the	DT
18637	2966	27	other	other	JJ
18637	2966	28	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	2966	29	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	2966	30	which	which	WDT
18637	2966	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2966	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	2966	33	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	2966	34	to	to	TO
18637	2966	35	punish	punish	VB
18637	2966	36	.	.	.
18637	2967	1	The	the	DT
18637	2967	2	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	2967	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2967	4	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	2967	5	and	and	CC
18637	2967	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	2967	7	not	not	RB
18637	2967	8	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	2967	9	.	.	.
18637	2968	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2968	2	1127	1127	CD
18637	2968	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2968	4	THE	the	DT
18637	2968	5	BORROWING	borrowing	NN
18637	2968	6	POWER	power	NN
18637	2968	7	VERSUS	versu	VBZ
18637	2968	8	THE	the	DT
18637	2968	9	FISCAL	fiscal	JJ
18637	2968	10	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	2968	11	Usually	usually	RB
18637	2968	12	the	the	DT
18637	2968	13	aggregate	aggregate	NN
18637	2968	14	of	of	IN
18637	2968	15	the	the	DT
18637	2968	16	fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	2968	17	and	and	CC
18637	2968	18	monetary	monetary	JJ
18637	2968	19	powers	power	NNS
18637	2968	20	of	of	IN
18637	2968	21	the	the	DT
18637	2968	22	National	National	NNP
18637	2968	23	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2968	24	--	--	:
18637	2968	25	to	to	TO
18637	2968	26	lay	lay	VB
18637	2968	27	and	and	CC
18637	2968	28	collect	collect	VB
18637	2968	29	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	2968	30	,	,	,
18637	2968	31	to	to	TO
18637	2968	32	borrow	borrow	VB
18637	2968	33	money	money	NN
18637	2968	34	and	and	CC
18637	2968	35	to	to	TO
18637	2968	36	coin	coin	VB
18637	2968	37	money	money	NN
18637	2968	38	and	and	CC
18637	2968	39	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2968	40	the	the	DT
18637	2968	41	value	value	NN
18637	2968	42	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	2968	43	--	--	:
18637	2968	44	have	have	VBP
18637	2968	45	reinforced	reinforce	VBN
18637	2968	46	each	each	DT
18637	2968	47	other	other	JJ
18637	2968	48	,	,	,
18637	2968	49	and	and	CC
18637	2968	50	,	,	,
18637	2968	51	cemented	cement	VBN
18637	2968	52	by	by	IN
18637	2968	53	the	the	DT
18637	2968	54	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2968	55	and	and	CC
18637	2968	56	proper	proper	JJ
18637	2968	57	clause	clause	NN
18637	2968	58	,	,	,
18637	2968	59	have	have	VBP
18637	2968	60	provided	provide	VBN
18637	2968	61	a	a	DT
18637	2968	62	secure	secure	JJ
18637	2968	63	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	2968	64	for	for	IN
18637	2968	65	acts	act	NNS
18637	2968	66	of	of	IN
18637	2968	67	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2968	68	chartering	charter	VBG
18637	2968	69	banks	bank	NNS
18637	2968	70	and	and	CC
18637	2968	71	other	other	JJ
18637	2968	72	financial	financial	JJ
18637	2968	73	institutions,[1128	institutions,[1128	NNP
18637	2968	74	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2968	75	or	or	CC
18637	2968	76	making	make	VBG
18637	2968	77	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2968	78	treasury	treasury	NNP
18637	2968	79	notes	note	NNS
18637	2968	80	legal	legal	JJ
18637	2968	81	tender	tender	NN
18637	2968	82	in	in	IN
18637	2968	83	the	the	DT
18637	2968	84	payment	payment	NN
18637	2968	85	of	of	IN
18637	2968	86	antecedent	antecedent	NN
18637	2968	87	debts	debt	NNS
18637	2968	88	.	.	.
18637	2969	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2969	2	1129	1129	CD
18637	2969	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2969	4	But	but	CC
18637	2969	5	in	in	IN
18637	2969	6	1935	1935	CD
18637	2969	7	the	the	DT
18637	2969	8	opposite	opposite	JJ
18637	2969	9	situation	situation	NN
18637	2969	10	arose	arise	VBD
18637	2969	11	--	--	:
18637	2969	12	one	one	CD
18637	2969	13	in	in	IN
18637	2969	14	which	which	WDT
18637	2969	15	the	the	DT
18637	2969	16	power	power	NN
18637	2969	17	to	to	TO
18637	2969	18	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2969	19	the	the	DT
18637	2969	20	value	value	NN
18637	2969	21	of	of	IN
18637	2969	22	money	money	NN
18637	2969	23	collided	collide	VBN
18637	2969	24	with	with	IN
18637	2969	25	the	the	DT
18637	2969	26	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	2969	27	incurred	incur	VBN
18637	2969	28	in	in	IN
18637	2969	29	the	the	DT
18637	2969	30	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2969	31	of	of	IN
18637	2969	32	the	the	DT
18637	2969	33	power	power	NN
18637	2969	34	to	to	TO
18637	2969	35	borrow	borrow	VB
18637	2969	36	money	money	NN
18637	2969	37	.	.	.
18637	2970	1	By	by	IN
18637	2970	2	a	a	DT
18637	2970	3	vote	vote	NN
18637	2970	4	of	of	IN
18637	2970	5	eight	eight	CD
18637	2970	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	2970	7	to	to	IN
18637	2970	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	2970	9	one	one	CD
18637	2970	10	the	the	DT
18637	2970	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2970	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2970	13	held	hold	VBD
18637	2970	14	that	that	IN
18637	2970	15	the	the	DT
18637	2970	16	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	2970	17	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	2970	18	by	by	IN
18637	2970	19	the	the	DT
18637	2970	20	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2970	21	of	of	IN
18637	2970	22	the	the	DT
18637	2970	23	latter	latter	NN
18637	2970	24	was	be	VBD
18637	2970	25	paramount	paramount	JJ
18637	2970	26	,	,	,
18637	2970	27	and	and	CC
18637	2970	28	could	could	MD
18637	2970	29	not	not	RB
18637	2970	30	be	be	VB
18637	2970	31	repudiated	repudiate	VBN
18637	2970	32	to	to	TO
18637	2970	33	effectuate	effectuate	VB
18637	2970	34	the	the	DT
18637	2970	35	monetary	monetary	JJ
18637	2970	36	policies	policy	NNS
18637	2970	37	of	of	IN
18637	2970	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2970	39	.	.	.
18637	2971	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2971	2	1130	1130	CD
18637	2971	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2971	4	In	in	IN
18637	2971	5	a	a	DT
18637	2971	6	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	2971	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2971	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2971	9	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	2971	10	declined	decline	VBD
18637	2971	11	to	to	TO
18637	2971	12	join	join	VB
18637	2971	13	with	with	IN
18637	2971	14	the	the	DT
18637	2971	15	majority	majority	NN
18637	2971	16	in	in	IN
18637	2971	17	suggesting	suggest	VBG
18637	2971	18	that	that	IN
18637	2971	19	"	"	``
18637	2971	20	the	the	DT
18637	2971	21	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2971	22	of	of	IN
18637	2971	23	the	the	DT
18637	2971	24	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	2971	25	power	power	NN
18637	2971	26	to	to	TO
18637	2971	27	borrow	borrow	VB
18637	2971	28	money	money	NN
18637	2971	29	on	on	IN
18637	2971	30	credit	credit	NN
18637	2971	31	,	,	,
18637	2971	32	which	which	WDT
18637	2971	33	does	do	VBZ
18637	2971	34	not	not	RB
18637	2971	35	override	override	VB
18637	2971	36	the	the	DT
18637	2971	37	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	2971	38	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	2971	39	from	from	IN
18637	2971	40	suit	suit	NN
18637	2971	41	,	,	,
18637	2971	42	may	may	MD
18637	2971	43	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	2971	44	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	2971	45	or	or	CC
18637	2971	46	impede	impede	VB
18637	2971	47	the	the	DT
18637	2971	48	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	2971	49	of	of	IN
18637	2971	50	another	another	DT
18637	2971	51	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	2971	52	power	power	NN
18637	2971	53	,	,	,
18637	2971	54	to	to	TO
18637	2971	55	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2971	56	the	the	DT
18637	2971	57	value	value	NN
18637	2971	58	of	of	IN
18637	2971	59	money	money	NN
18637	2971	60	;	;	:
18637	2971	61	or	or	CC
18637	2971	62	to	to	TO
18637	2971	63	suggest	suggest	VB
18637	2971	64	that	that	IN
18637	2971	65	although	although	IN
18637	2971	66	there	there	EX
18637	2971	67	is	be	VBZ
18637	2971	68	and	and	CC
18637	2971	69	can	can	MD
18637	2971	70	be	be	VB
18637	2971	71	no	no	DT
18637	2971	72	present	present	JJ
18637	2971	73	cause	cause	NN
18637	2971	74	of	of	IN
18637	2971	75	action	action	NN
18637	2971	76	upon	upon	IN
18637	2971	77	the	the	DT
18637	2971	78	repudiated	repudiated	JJ
18637	2971	79	gold	gold	NN
18637	2971	80	clause	clause	NN
18637	2971	81	,	,	,
18637	2971	82	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2971	83	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	2971	84	is	be	VBZ
18637	2971	85	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	2971	86	,	,	,
18637	2971	87	in	in	IN
18637	2971	88	some	some	DT
18637	2971	89	manner	manner	NN
18637	2971	90	and	and	CC
18637	2971	91	to	to	IN
18637	2971	92	some	some	DT
18637	2971	93	extent	extent	NN
18637	2971	94	,	,	,
18637	2971	95	not	not	RB
18637	2971	96	stated	state	VBN
18637	2971	97	,	,	,
18637	2971	98	superior	superior	JJ
18637	2971	99	to	to	IN
18637	2971	100	the	the	DT
18637	2971	101	power	power	NN
18637	2971	102	to	to	TO
18637	2971	103	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	2971	104	the	the	DT
18637	2971	105	currency	currency	NN
18637	2971	106	which	which	WDT
18637	2971	107	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2971	108	now	now	RB
18637	2971	109	hold	hold	VBP
18637	2971	110	to	to	TO
18637	2971	111	be	be	VB
18637	2971	112	superior	superior	JJ
18637	2971	113	to	to	IN
18637	2971	114	the	the	DT
18637	2971	115	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	2971	116	of	of	IN
18637	2971	117	the	the	DT
18637	2971	118	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	2971	119	.	.	.
18637	2972	1	"	"	``
18637	2972	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2972	3	1131	1131	CD
18637	2972	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2972	5	Clause	clause	NN
18637	2972	6	7	7	CD
18637	2972	7	.	.	.
18637	2973	1	_	_	NNP
18637	2973	2	The	the	DT
18637	2973	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2973	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	2973	5	have	have	VB
18637	2973	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	2973	7	_	_	NNP
18637	2973	8	*	*	NFP
18637	2973	9	*	*	NFP
18637	2973	10	*	*	NFP
18637	2973	11	To	to	TO
18637	2973	12	establish	establish	VB
18637	2973	13	Post	Post	NNP
18637	2973	14	Offices	Offices	NNP
18637	2973	15	and	and	CC
18637	2973	16	post	post	VB
18637	2973	17	Roads	road	NNS
18637	2973	18	.	.	.
18637	2974	1	The	the	DT
18637	2974	2	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	2974	3	Power	Power	NNP
18637	2974	4	"	"	''
18637	2974	5	ESTABLISH	ESTABLISH	NNP
18637	2974	6	"	"	''
18637	2974	7	The	the	DT
18637	2974	8	great	great	JJ
18637	2974	9	question	question	NN
18637	2974	10	raised	raise	VBN
18637	2974	11	in	in	IN
18637	2974	12	the	the	DT
18637	2974	13	early	early	JJ
18637	2974	14	days	day	NNS
18637	2974	15	with	with	IN
18637	2974	16	reference	reference	NN
18637	2974	17	to	to	IN
18637	2974	18	the	the	DT
18637	2974	19	postal	postal	JJ
18637	2974	20	clause	clause	NN
18637	2974	21	concerned	concern	VBD
18637	2974	22	the	the	DT
18637	2974	23	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	2974	24	to	to	TO
18637	2974	25	be	be	VB
18637	2974	26	given	give	VBN
18637	2974	27	to	to	IN
18637	2974	28	the	the	DT
18637	2974	29	word	word	NN
18637	2974	30	"	"	``
18637	2974	31	establish"--did	establish"--did	VBD
18637	2974	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2974	33	confer	confer	VB
18637	2974	34	upon	upon	IN
18637	2974	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2974	36	the	the	DT
18637	2974	37	power	power	NN
18637	2974	38	to	to	IN
18637	2974	39	_	_	NNP
18637	2974	40	construct	construct	VB
18637	2974	41	_	_	NNP
18637	2974	42	post	post	NN
18637	2974	43	offices	office	NNS
18637	2974	44	and	and	CC
18637	2974	45	post	post	NN
18637	2974	46	roads	road	NNS
18637	2974	47	,	,	,
18637	2974	48	or	or	CC
18637	2974	49	only	only	RB
18637	2974	50	the	the	DT
18637	2974	51	power	power	NN
18637	2974	52	to	to	IN
18637	2974	53	_	_	NNP
18637	2974	54	designate	designate	JJ
18637	2974	55	_	_	NNP
18637	2974	56	from	from	IN
18637	2974	57	existing	exist	VBG
18637	2974	58	places	place	NNS
18637	2974	59	and	and	CC
18637	2974	60	routes	route	VBZ
18637	2974	61	those	those	DT
18637	2974	62	that	that	WDT
18637	2974	63	should	should	MD
18637	2974	64	serve	serve	VB
18637	2974	65	as	as	IN
18637	2974	66	post	post	NN
18637	2974	67	offices	office	NNS
18637	2974	68	and	and	CC
18637	2974	69	post	post	VB
18637	2974	70	roads	road	NNS
18637	2974	71	?	?	.
18637	2975	1	As	as	RB
18637	2975	2	late	late	RB
18637	2975	3	as	as	IN
18637	2975	4	1855	1855	CD
18637	2975	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2975	6	McLean	McLean	NNP
18637	2975	7	stated	state	VBD
18637	2975	8	that	that	IN
18637	2975	9	this	this	DT
18637	2975	10	power	power	NN
18637	2975	11	"	"	``
18637	2975	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	2975	13	generally	generally	RB
18637	2975	14	been	be	VBN
18637	2975	15	considered	consider	VBN
18637	2975	16	as	as	IN
18637	2975	17	exhausted	exhausted	JJ
18637	2975	18	in	in	IN
18637	2975	19	the	the	DT
18637	2975	20	designation	designation	NN
18637	2975	21	of	of	IN
18637	2975	22	roads	road	NNS
18637	2975	23	on	on	IN
18637	2975	24	which	which	WDT
18637	2975	25	the	the	DT
18637	2975	26	mails	mail	NNS
18637	2975	27	are	be	VBP
18637	2975	28	to	to	TO
18637	2975	29	be	be	VB
18637	2975	30	transported	transport	VBN
18637	2975	31	,	,	,
18637	2975	32	"	"	''
18637	2975	33	and	and	CC
18637	2975	34	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	2975	35	that	that	IN
18637	2975	36	neither	neither	CC
18637	2975	37	under	under	IN
18637	2975	38	the	the	DT
18637	2975	39	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	2975	40	power	power	NN
18637	2975	41	nor	nor	CC
18637	2975	42	the	the	DT
18637	2975	43	power	power	NN
18637	2975	44	to	to	TO
18637	2975	45	establish	establish	VB
18637	2975	46	post	post	JJ
18637	2975	47	roads	road	NNS
18637	2975	48	could	could	MD
18637	2975	49	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2975	50	construct	construct	VB
18637	2975	51	a	a	DT
18637	2975	52	bridge	bridge	NN
18637	2975	53	over	over	IN
18637	2975	54	a	a	DT
18637	2975	55	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	2975	56	water	water	NN
18637	2975	57	.	.	.
18637	2976	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2976	2	1132	1132	CD
18637	2976	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2976	4	A	a	DT
18637	2976	5	decade	decade	NN
18637	2976	6	earlier	early	RBR
18637	2976	7	,	,	,
18637	2976	8	however	however	RB
18637	2976	9	,	,	,
18637	2976	10	the	the	DT
18637	2976	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2976	12	,	,	,
18637	2976	13	without	without	IN
18637	2976	14	passing	pass	VBG
18637	2976	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	2976	16	the	the	DT
18637	2976	17	validity	validity	NN
18637	2976	18	of	of	IN
18637	2976	19	the	the	DT
18637	2976	20	original	original	JJ
18637	2976	21	construction	construction	NN
18637	2976	22	of	of	IN
18637	2976	23	the	the	DT
18637	2976	24	Cumberland	Cumberland	NNP
18637	2976	25	Road	Road	NNP
18637	2976	26	,	,	,
18637	2976	27	held	hold	VBD
18637	2976	28	that	that	IN
18637	2976	29	being	be	VBG
18637	2976	30	"	"	``
18637	2976	31	charged	charge	VBN
18637	2976	32	,	,	,
18637	2976	33	*	*	NFP
18637	2976	34	*	*	NFP
18637	2976	35	*	*	NFP
18637	2976	36	,	,	,
18637	2976	37	with	with	IN
18637	2976	38	the	the	DT
18637	2976	39	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	2976	40	of	of	IN
18637	2976	41	the	the	DT
18637	2976	42	mails	mail	NNS
18637	2976	43	,	,	,
18637	2976	44	"	"	``
18637	2976	45	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2976	46	could	could	MD
18637	2976	47	enter	enter	VB
18637	2976	48	a	a	DT
18637	2976	49	valid	valid	JJ
18637	2976	50	compact	compact	NN
18637	2976	51	with	with	IN
18637	2976	52	the	the	DT
18637	2976	53	State	State	NNP
18637	2976	54	of	of	IN
18637	2976	55	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	2976	56	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	2976	57	the	the	DT
18637	2976	58	use	use	NN
18637	2976	59	and	and	CC
18637	2976	60	upkeep	upkeep	NN
18637	2976	61	of	of	IN
18637	2976	62	the	the	DT
18637	2976	63	portion	portion	NN
18637	2976	64	of	of	IN
18637	2976	65	the	the	DT
18637	2976	66	road	road	NN
18637	2976	67	lying	lie	VBG
18637	2976	68	in	in	IN
18637	2976	69	that	that	DT
18637	2976	70	State	State	NNP
18637	2976	71	.	.	.
18637	2977	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2977	2	1133	1133	CD
18637	2977	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2977	4	The	the	DT
18637	2977	5	debate	debate	NN
18637	2977	6	on	on	IN
18637	2977	7	the	the	DT
18637	2977	8	question	question	NN
18637	2977	9	was	be	VBD
18637	2977	10	terminated	terminate	VBN
18637	2977	11	in	in	IN
18637	2977	12	1876	1876	CD
18637	2977	13	by	by	IN
18637	2977	14	the	the	DT
18637	2977	15	decision	decision	NN
18637	2977	16	in	in	IN
18637	2977	17	Kohl	Kohl	NNP
18637	2977	18	_	_	NNP
18637	2977	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	2977	20	_	_	NNP
18637	2977	21	United	United	NNP
18637	2977	22	States[1134	States[1134	NNP
18637	2977	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2977	24	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	2977	25	a	a	DT
18637	2977	26	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	2977	27	by	by	IN
18637	2977	28	the	the	DT
18637	2977	29	United	United	NNP
18637	2977	30	States	States	NNP
18637	2977	31	to	to	TO
18637	2977	32	appropriate	appropriate	VB
18637	2977	33	a	a	DT
18637	2977	34	parcel	parcel	NN
18637	2977	35	of	of	IN
18637	2977	36	land	land	NN
18637	2977	37	in	in	IN
18637	2977	38	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	2977	39	as	as	IN
18637	2977	40	a	a	DT
18637	2977	41	site	site	NN
18637	2977	42	for	for	IN
18637	2977	43	a	a	DT
18637	2977	44	post	post	NN
18637	2977	45	office	office	NN
18637	2977	46	and	and	CC
18637	2977	47	courthouse	courthouse	NN
18637	2977	48	.	.	.
18637	2978	1	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	2978	2	TO	to	TO
18637	2978	3	PROTECT	protect	VB
18637	2978	4	THE	the	DT
18637	2978	5	MAILS	mail	NNS
18637	2978	6	The	the	DT
18637	2978	7	postal	postal	JJ
18637	2978	8	powers	power	NNS
18637	2978	9	of	of	IN
18637	2978	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2978	11	embrace	embrace	VBP
18637	2978	12	all	all	DT
18637	2978	13	measures	measure	NNS
18637	2978	14	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	2978	15	to	to	TO
18637	2978	16	insure	insure	VB
18637	2978	17	the	the	DT
18637	2978	18	safe	safe	JJ
18637	2978	19	and	and	CC
18637	2978	20	speedy	speedy	JJ
18637	2978	21	transit	transit	NN
18637	2978	22	and	and	CC
18637	2978	23	prompt	prompt	VB
18637	2978	24	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	2978	25	of	of	IN
18637	2978	26	the	the	DT
18637	2978	27	mails	mail	NNS
18637	2978	28	.	.	.
18637	2979	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2979	2	1135	1135	CD
18637	2979	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2979	4	And	and	CC
18637	2979	5	not	not	RB
18637	2979	6	only	only	RB
18637	2979	7	are	be	VBP
18637	2979	8	the	the	DT
18637	2979	9	mails	mail	NNS
18637	2979	10	under	under	IN
18637	2979	11	the	the	DT
18637	2979	12	protection	protection	NN
18637	2979	13	of	of	IN
18637	2979	14	the	the	DT
18637	2979	15	National	National	NNP
18637	2979	16	Government	Government	NNP
18637	2979	17	,	,	,
18637	2979	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2979	19	are	be	VBP
18637	2979	20	in	in	IN
18637	2979	21	contemplation	contemplation	NN
18637	2979	22	of	of	IN
18637	2979	23	law	law	NN
18637	2979	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2979	25	property	property	NN
18637	2979	26	.	.	.
18637	2980	1	This	this	DT
18637	2980	2	principle	principle	NN
18637	2980	3	was	be	VBD
18637	2980	4	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	2980	5	by	by	IN
18637	2980	6	the	the	DT
18637	2980	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2980	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2980	9	in	in	IN
18637	2980	10	1845	1845	CD
18637	2980	11	in	in	IN
18637	2980	12	holding	hold	VBG
18637	2980	13	that	that	IN
18637	2980	14	wagons	wagon	NNS
18637	2980	15	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	2980	16	United	United	NNP
18637	2980	17	States	States	NNP
18637	2980	18	mail	mail	NN
18637	2980	19	were	be	VBD
18637	2980	20	not	not	RB
18637	2980	21	subject	subject	JJ
18637	2980	22	to	to	IN
18637	2980	23	a	a	DT
18637	2980	24	State	State	NNP
18637	2980	25	toll	toll	NN
18637	2980	26	tax	tax	NN
18637	2980	27	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	2980	28	for	for	IN
18637	2980	29	use	use	NN
18637	2980	30	of	of	IN
18637	2980	31	the	the	DT
18637	2980	32	Cumberland	Cumberland	NNP
18637	2980	33	Road	Road	NNP
18637	2980	34	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	2980	35	to	to	IN
18637	2980	36	a	a	DT
18637	2980	37	compact	compact	NN
18637	2980	38	with	with	IN
18637	2980	39	the	the	DT
18637	2980	40	United	United	NNP
18637	2980	41	States	States	NNP
18637	2980	42	.	.	.
18637	2981	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2981	2	1136	1136	CD
18637	2981	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2981	4	Half	half	PDT
18637	2981	5	a	a	DT
18637	2981	6	century	century	NN
18637	2981	7	later	later	RB
18637	2981	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2981	9	was	be	VBD
18637	2981	10	availed	avail	VBN
18637	2981	11	of	of	IN
18637	2981	12	as	as	IN
18637	2981	13	one	one	CD
18637	2981	14	of	of	IN
18637	2981	15	the	the	DT
18637	2981	16	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	2981	17	on	on	IN
18637	2981	18	which	which	WDT
18637	2981	19	the	the	DT
18637	2981	20	national	national	JJ
18637	2981	21	executive	executive	NN
18637	2981	22	was	be	VBD
18637	2981	23	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	2981	24	the	the	DT
18637	2981	25	right	right	NN
18637	2981	26	to	to	TO
18637	2981	27	enter	enter	VB
18637	2981	28	the	the	DT
18637	2981	29	national	national	JJ
18637	2981	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	2981	31	and	and	CC
18637	2981	32	demand	demand	VB
18637	2981	33	an	an	DT
18637	2981	34	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	2981	35	against	against	IN
18637	2981	36	the	the	DT
18637	2981	37	authors	author	NNS
18637	2981	38	of	of	IN
18637	2981	39	any	any	DT
18637	2981	40	wide	wide	JJ
18637	2981	41	-	-	HYPH
18637	2981	42	spread	spread	NN
18637	2981	43	disorder	disorder	NN
18637	2981	44	interfering	interfere	VBG
18637	2981	45	with	with	IN
18637	2981	46	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	2981	47	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	2981	48	and	and	CC
18637	2981	49	the	the	DT
18637	2981	50	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	2981	51	of	of	IN
18637	2981	52	the	the	DT
18637	2981	53	mails	mail	NNS
18637	2981	54	.	.	.
18637	2982	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2982	2	1137	1137	CD
18637	2982	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2982	4	ANTI	anti	NN
18637	2982	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	2982	6	SLAVERY	slavery	NN
18637	2982	7	AND	and	CC
18637	2982	8	THE	the	DT
18637	2982	9	MAILS	mail	NNS
18637	2982	10	Prompted	prompt	VBN
18637	2982	11	by	by	IN
18637	2982	12	the	the	DT
18637	2982	13	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	2982	14	of	of	IN
18637	2982	15	Northern	northern	JJ
18637	2982	16	anti	anti	JJ
18637	2982	17	-	-	JJ
18637	2982	18	slavery	slavery	JJ
18637	2982	19	elements	element	NNS
18637	2982	20	to	to	TO
18637	2982	21	disseminate	disseminate	VB
18637	2982	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2982	23	propaganda	propaganda	NN
18637	2982	24	in	in	IN
18637	2982	25	the	the	DT
18637	2982	26	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	2982	27	States	States	NNPS
18637	2982	28	through	through	IN
18637	2982	29	the	the	DT
18637	2982	30	mails	mail	NNS
18637	2982	31	,	,	,
18637	2982	32	President	President	NNP
18637	2982	33	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	2982	34	,	,	,
18637	2982	35	in	in	IN
18637	2982	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2982	37	annual	annual	JJ
18637	2982	38	message	message	NN
18637	2982	39	to	to	IN
18637	2982	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2982	41	in	in	IN
18637	2982	42	1835	1835	CD
18637	2982	43	,	,	,
18637	2982	44	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	2982	45	"	"	``
18637	2982	46	the	the	DT
18637	2982	47	propriety	propriety	NN
18637	2982	48	of	of	IN
18637	2982	49	passing	pass	VBG
18637	2982	50	such	such	PDT
18637	2982	51	a	a	DT
18637	2982	52	law	law	NN
18637	2982	53	as	as	IN
18637	2982	54	will	will	MD
18637	2982	55	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	2982	56	,	,	,
18637	2982	57	under	under	IN
18637	2982	58	severe	severe	JJ
18637	2982	59	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	2982	60	,	,	,
18637	2982	61	the	the	DT
18637	2982	62	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	2982	63	in	in	IN
18637	2982	64	the	the	DT
18637	2982	65	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	2982	66	States	States	NNP
18637	2982	67	,	,	,
18637	2982	68	through	through	IN
18637	2982	69	the	the	DT
18637	2982	70	mail	mail	NN
18637	2982	71	,	,	,
18637	2982	72	of	of	IN
18637	2982	73	incendiary	incendiary	JJ
18637	2982	74	publications	publication	NNS
18637	2982	75	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2982	76	to	to	TO
18637	2982	77	instigate	instigate	VB
18637	2982	78	the	the	DT
18637	2982	79	slaves	slave	NNS
18637	2982	80	to	to	IN
18637	2982	81	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	2982	82	.	.	.
18637	2983	1	"	"	``
18637	2983	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2983	3	1138	1138	CD
18637	2983	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2983	5	In	in	IN
18637	2983	6	the	the	DT
18637	2983	7	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	2983	8	John	John	NNP
18637	2983	9	C.	C.	NNP
18637	2983	10	Calhoun	Calhoun	NNP
18637	2983	11	resisted	resist	VBD
18637	2983	12	this	this	DT
18637	2983	13	recommendation	recommendation	NN
18637	2983	14	,	,	,
18637	2983	15	taking	take	VBG
18637	2983	16	the	the	DT
18637	2983	17	position	position	NN
18637	2983	18	that	that	IN
18637	2983	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2983	20	belonged	belong	VBD
18637	2983	21	to	to	IN
18637	2983	22	the	the	DT
18637	2983	23	States	States	NNPS
18637	2983	24	and	and	CC
18637	2983	25	not	not	RB
18637	2983	26	to	to	IN
18637	2983	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2983	28	to	to	TO
18637	2983	29	determine	determine	VB
18637	2983	30	what	what	WP
18637	2983	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	2983	32	and	and	CC
18637	2983	33	what	what	WP
18637	2983	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	2983	35	not	not	RB
18637	2983	36	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	2983	37	to	to	TO
18637	2983	38	disturb	disturb	VB
18637	2983	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2983	40	security	security	NN
18637	2983	41	.	.	.
18637	2984	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2984	2	expressed	express	VBD
18637	2984	3	the	the	DT
18637	2984	4	fear	fear	NN
18637	2984	5	that	that	IN
18637	2984	6	if	if	IN
18637	2984	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2984	8	might	may	MD
18637	2984	9	determine	determine	VB
18637	2984	10	what	what	WP
18637	2984	11	papers	paper	NNS
18637	2984	12	were	be	VBD
18637	2984	13	incendiary	incendiary	JJ
18637	2984	14	,	,	,
18637	2984	15	and	and	CC
18637	2984	16	as	as	IN
18637	2984	17	such	such	JJ
18637	2984	18	prohibit	prohibit	NN
18637	2984	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2984	20	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	2984	21	through	through	IN
18637	2984	22	the	the	DT
18637	2984	23	mail	mail	NN
18637	2984	24	,	,	,
18637	2984	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2984	26	might	may	MD
18637	2984	27	also	also	RB
18637	2984	28	determine	determine	VB
18637	2984	29	what	what	WP
18637	2984	30	were	be	VBD
18637	2984	31	not	not	RB
18637	2984	32	incendiary	incendiary	JJ
18637	2984	33	and	and	CC
18637	2984	34	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	2984	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2984	36	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	2984	37	.	.	.
18637	2985	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2985	2	1139	1139	CD
18637	2985	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2985	4	POWER	power	NN
18637	2985	5	TO	to	TO
18637	2985	6	PREVENT	prevent	VB
18637	2985	7	HARMFUL	harmful	VB
18637	2985	8	USE	use	NN
18637	2985	9	OF	of	IN
18637	2985	10	THE	the	DT
18637	2985	11	POSTAL	POSTAL	NNP
18637	2985	12	FACILITIES	facility	NNS
18637	2985	13	Some	some	DT
18637	2985	14	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	2985	15	years	year	NNS
18637	2985	16	later	later	RBR
18637	2985	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2985	18	passed	pass	VBD
18637	2985	19	the	the	DT
18637	2985	20	first	first	JJ
18637	2985	21	of	of	IN
18637	2985	22	a	a	DT
18637	2985	23	series	series	NN
18637	2985	24	of	of	IN
18637	2985	25	acts	act	NNS
18637	2985	26	to	to	TO
18637	2985	27	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	2985	28	from	from	IN
18637	2985	29	the	the	DT
18637	2985	30	mails	mail	NNS
18637	2985	31	publications	publication	NNS
18637	2985	32	designed	design	VBN
18637	2985	33	to	to	TO
18637	2985	34	defraud	defraud	VB
18637	2985	35	the	the	DT
18637	2985	36	public	public	JJ
18637	2985	37	or	or	CC
18637	2985	38	corrupt	corrupt	JJ
18637	2985	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2985	40	morals	moral	NNS
18637	2985	41	.	.	.
18637	2986	1	In	in	IN
18637	2986	2	the	the	DT
18637	2986	3	pioneer	pioneer	NN
18637	2986	4	case	case	NN
18637	2986	5	of	of	IN
18637	2986	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	2986	7	parte	parte	NNP
18637	2986	8	Jackson,[1140	jackson,[1140	NN
18637	2986	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2986	10	the	the	DT
18637	2986	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2986	12	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	2986	13	the	the	DT
18637	2986	14	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	2986	15	of	of	IN
18637	2986	16	circulars	circular	NNS
18637	2986	17	relating	relate	VBG
18637	2986	18	to	to	IN
18637	2986	19	lotteries	lottery	NNS
18637	2986	20	on	on	IN
18637	2986	21	the	the	DT
18637	2986	22	general	general	JJ
18637	2986	23	ground	ground	NN
18637	2986	24	that	that	IN
18637	2986	25	"	"	``
18637	2986	26	the	the	DT
18637	2986	27	right	right	NN
18637	2986	28	to	to	TO
18637	2986	29	designate	designate	VB
18637	2986	30	what	what	WP
18637	2986	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	2986	32	be	be	VB
18637	2986	33	carried	carry	VBN
18637	2986	34	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	2986	35	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	2986	36	the	the	DT
18637	2986	37	right	right	NN
18637	2986	38	to	to	TO
18637	2986	39	determine	determine	VB
18637	2986	40	what	what	WP
18637	2986	41	shall	shall	MD
18637	2986	42	be	be	VB
18637	2986	43	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	2986	44	.	.	.
18637	2987	1	"	"	``
18637	2987	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2987	3	1141	1141	CD
18637	2987	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2987	5	The	the	DT
18637	2987	6	leading	lead	VBG
18637	2987	7	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	2987	8	order	order	NN
18637	2987	9	case	case	NN
18637	2987	10	,	,	,
18637	2987	11	decided	decide	VBD
18637	2987	12	in	in	IN
18637	2987	13	1904	1904	CD
18637	2987	14	,	,	,
18637	2987	15	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	2987	16	to	to	IN
18637	2987	17	the	the	DT
18637	2987	18	same	same	JJ
18637	2987	19	effect	effect	NN
18637	2987	20	.	.	.
18637	2988	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2988	2	1142	1142	CD
18637	2988	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2988	4	Pointing	point	VBG
18637	2988	5	out	out	RP
18637	2988	6	that	that	IN
18637	2988	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2988	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	2988	9	"	"	``
18637	2988	10	an	an	DT
18637	2988	11	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
18637	2988	12	adjunct	adjunct	NN
18637	2988	13	to	to	IN
18637	2988	14	a	a	DT
18637	2988	15	civil	civil	JJ
18637	2988	16	government	government	NN
18637	2988	17	,	,	,
18637	2988	18	"	"	''
18637	2988	19	to	to	TO
18637	2988	20	supply	supply	VB
18637	2988	21	postal	postal	JJ
18637	2988	22	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	2988	23	,	,	,
18637	2988	24	the	the	DT
18637	2988	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2988	26	restated	restate	VBD
18637	2988	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2988	28	premise	premise	NN
18637	2988	29	that	that	IN
18637	2988	30	the	the	DT
18637	2988	31	"	"	``
18637	2988	32	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	2988	33	body	body	NN
18637	2988	34	in	in	IN
18637	2988	35	thus	thus	RB
18637	2988	36	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	2988	37	a	a	DT
18637	2988	38	postal	postal	JJ
18637	2988	39	service	service	NN
18637	2988	40	,	,	,
18637	2988	41	may	may	MD
18637	2988	42	annex	annex	VB
18637	2988	43	such	such	JJ
18637	2988	44	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	2988	45	to	to	IN
18637	2988	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2988	47	as	as	IN
18637	2988	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2988	49	chooses	choose	VBZ
18637	2988	50	.	.	.
18637	2989	1	"	"	``
18637	2989	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2989	3	1143	1143	CD
18637	2989	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2989	5	Later	late	JJR
18637	2989	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	2989	7	appear	appear	VBP
18637	2989	8	to	to	TO
18637	2989	9	have	have	VB
18637	2989	10	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	2989	11	these	these	DT
18637	2989	12	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	2989	13	declarations	declaration	NNS
18637	2989	14	.	.	.
18637	2990	1	In	in	IN
18637	2990	2	upholding	upholding	NN
18637	2990	3	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	2990	4	that	that	IN
18637	2990	5	publishers	publisher	NNS
18637	2990	6	of	of	IN
18637	2990	7	newspapers	newspaper	NNS
18637	2990	8	and	and	CC
18637	2990	9	periodicals	periodical	NNS
18637	2990	10	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	2990	11	second	second	JJ
18637	2990	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	2990	13	class	class	NN
18637	2990	14	mailing	mailing	NN
18637	2990	15	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	2990	16	file	file	VBP
18637	2990	17	complete	complete	JJ
18637	2990	18	information	information	NN
18637	2990	19	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	2990	20	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	2990	21	,	,	,
18637	2990	22	indebtedness	indebtedness	NN
18637	2990	23	and	and	CC
18637	2990	24	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	2990	25	and	and	CC
18637	2990	26	that	that	IN
18637	2990	27	all	all	DT
18637	2990	28	paid	pay	VBN
18637	2990	29	advertisements	advertisement	NNS
18637	2990	30	in	in	IN
18637	2990	31	such	such	JJ
18637	2990	32	publications	publication	NNS
18637	2990	33	be	be	VB
18637	2990	34	marked	mark	VBN
18637	2990	35	as	as	IN
18637	2990	36	such	such	JJ
18637	2990	37	,	,	,
18637	2990	38	the	the	DT
18637	2990	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2990	40	emphasized	emphasize	VBD
18637	2990	41	that	that	IN
18637	2990	42	these	these	DT
18637	2990	43	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	2990	44	were	be	VBD
18637	2990	45	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	2990	46	designed	design	VBN
18637	2990	47	to	to	TO
18637	2990	48	safeguard	safeguard	VB
18637	2990	49	the	the	DT
18637	2990	50	second	second	JJ
18637	2990	51	-	-	HYPH
18637	2990	52	class	class	NN
18637	2990	53	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2990	54	from	from	IN
18637	2990	55	exploitation	exploitation	NN
18637	2990	56	by	by	IN
18637	2990	57	mere	mere	JJ
18637	2990	58	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	2990	59	publications	publication	NNS
18637	2990	60	.	.	.
18637	2991	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	2991	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2991	3	White	White	NNP
18637	2991	4	warned	warn	VBD
18637	2991	5	that	that	IN
18637	2991	6	the	the	DT
18637	2991	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2991	8	by	by	IN
18637	2991	9	no	no	DT
18637	2991	10	means	means	NN
18637	2991	11	intended	intend	VBN
18637	2991	12	to	to	TO
18637	2991	13	imply	imply	VB
18637	2991	14	that	that	IN
18637	2991	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2991	16	endorsed	endorse	VBD
18637	2991	17	the	the	DT
18637	2991	18	government	government	NN
18637	2991	19	's	's	POS
18637	2991	20	"	"	``
18637	2991	21	broad	broad	JJ
18637	2991	22	contentions	contention	NNS
18637	2991	23	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	2991	24	the	the	DT
18637	2991	25	existence	existence	NN
18637	2991	26	of	of	IN
18637	2991	27	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	2991	28	power	power	NN
18637	2991	29	through	through	IN
18637	2991	30	the	the	DT
18637	2991	31	classification	classification	NN
18637	2991	32	of	of	IN
18637	2991	33	the	the	DT
18637	2991	34	mails	mail	NNS
18637	2991	35	,	,	,
18637	2991	36	or	or	CC
18637	2991	37	by	by	IN
18637	2991	38	way	way	NN
18637	2991	39	of	of	IN
18637	2991	40	condition	condition	NN
18637	2991	41	*	*	NFP
18637	2991	42	*	*	NFP
18637	2991	43	*	*	NFP
18637	2991	44	"	"	''
18637	2991	45	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2991	46	1144	1144	CD
18637	2991	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2991	48	Again	again	RB
18637	2991	49	,	,	,
18637	2991	50	in	in	IN
18637	2991	51	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	2991	52	Social	Social	NNP
18637	2991	53	Democratic	Democratic	NNP
18637	2991	54	Publishing	Publishing	NNP
18637	2991	55	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	2991	56	_	_	NNP
18637	2991	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	2991	58	_	_	NNP
18637	2991	59	Burleson,[1145	Burleson,[1145	NNP
18637	2991	60	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2991	61	where	where	WRB
18637	2991	62	the	the	DT
18637	2991	63	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2991	64	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	2991	65	an	an	DT
18637	2991	66	order	order	NN
18637	2991	67	of	of	IN
18637	2991	68	the	the	DT
18637	2991	69	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
18637	2991	70	General	General	NNP
18637	2991	71	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	2991	72	from	from	IN
18637	2991	73	the	the	DT
18637	2991	74	second	second	JJ
18637	2991	75	-	-	HYPH
18637	2991	76	class	class	NN
18637	2991	77	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2991	78	a	a	DT
18637	2991	79	newspaper	newspaper	NN
18637	2991	80	which	which	WDT
18637	2991	81	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2991	82	found	find	VBD
18637	2991	83	to	to	TO
18637	2991	84	have	have	VB
18637	2991	85	systematically	systematically	RB
18637	2991	86	published	publish	VBN
18637	2991	87	matter	matter	NN
18637	2991	88	banned	ban	VBN
18637	2991	89	by	by	IN
18637	2991	90	the	the	DT
18637	2991	91	Espionage	Espionage	NNP
18637	2991	92	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2991	93	of	of	IN
18637	2991	94	1917	1917	CD
18637	2991	95	,	,	,
18637	2991	96	the	the	DT
18637	2991	97	claim	claim	NN
18637	2991	98	of	of	IN
18637	2991	99	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	2991	100	power	power	NN
18637	2991	101	in	in	IN
18637	2991	102	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2991	103	to	to	TO
18637	2991	104	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	2991	105	this	this	DT
18637	2991	106	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2991	107	was	be	VBD
18637	2991	108	sedulously	sedulously	RB
18637	2991	109	avoided	avoid	VBN
18637	2991	110	.	.	.
18637	2992	1	More	more	RBR
18637	2992	2	recently	recently	RB
18637	2992	3	,	,	,
18637	2992	4	when	when	WRB
18637	2992	5	reversing	reverse	VBG
18637	2992	6	an	an	DT
18637	2992	7	order	order	NN
18637	2992	8	denying	deny	VBG
18637	2992	9	the	the	DT
18637	2992	10	second	second	JJ
18637	2992	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	2992	12	class	class	NN
18637	2992	13	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2992	14	to	to	IN
18637	2992	15	a	a	DT
18637	2992	16	mailable	mailable	NN
18637	2992	17	publication	publication	NN
18637	2992	18	because	because	IN
18637	2992	19	of	of	IN
18637	2992	20	the	the	DT
18637	2992	21	poor	poor	JJ
18637	2992	22	taste	taste	NN
18637	2992	23	and	and	CC
18637	2992	24	vulgarity	vulgarity	NN
18637	2992	25	of	of	IN
18637	2992	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2992	27	contents	content	NNS
18637	2992	28	,	,	,
18637	2992	29	on	on	IN
18637	2992	30	the	the	DT
18637	2992	31	ground	ground	NN
18637	2992	32	that	that	IN
18637	2992	33	the	the	DT
18637	2992	34	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
18637	2992	35	General	General	NNP
18637	2992	36	exceeding	exceed	VBG
18637	2992	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2992	38	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	2992	39	authority	authority	NN
18637	2992	40	,	,	,
18637	2992	41	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	2992	42	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	2992	43	assumed	assume	VBD
18637	2992	44	,	,	,
18637	2992	45	in	in	IN
18637	2992	46	the	the	DT
18637	2992	47	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	2992	48	of	of	IN
18637	2992	49	the	the	DT
18637	2992	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2992	51	,	,	,
18637	2992	52	"	"	''
18637	2992	53	that	that	IN
18637	2992	54	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2992	55	has	have	VBZ
18637	2992	56	a	a	DT
18637	2992	57	broad	broad	JJ
18637	2992	58	power	power	NN
18637	2992	59	of	of	IN
18637	2992	60	classification	classification	NN
18637	2992	61	and	and	CC
18637	2992	62	need	need	VBP
18637	2992	63	not	not	RB
18637	2992	64	open	open	VB
18637	2992	65	second	second	JJ
18637	2992	66	-	-	HYPH
18637	2992	67	class	class	NN
18637	2992	68	mail	mail	NN
18637	2992	69	to	to	IN
18637	2992	70	publications	publication	NNS
18637	2992	71	of	of	IN
18637	2992	72	all	all	DT
18637	2992	73	types	type	NNS
18637	2992	74	.	.	.
18637	2993	1	"	"	``
18637	2993	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2993	3	1146	1146	CD
18637	2993	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2993	5	THE	the	DT
18637	2993	6	EXCLUSION	EXCLUSION	NNP
18637	2993	7	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	2993	8	AS	as	IN
18637	2993	9	AN	an	DT
18637	2993	10	ADJUNCT	adjunct	NN
18637	2993	11	TO	to	IN
18637	2993	12	OTHER	other	JJ
18637	2993	13	POWERS	power	NNS
18637	2993	14	In	in	IN
18637	2993	15	the	the	DT
18637	2993	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	2993	17	just	just	RB
18637	2993	18	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	2993	19	the	the	DT
18637	2993	20	mails	mail	NNS
18637	2993	21	were	be	VBD
18637	2993	22	closed	close	VBN
18637	2993	23	to	to	IN
18637	2993	24	particular	particular	JJ
18637	2993	25	types	type	NNS
18637	2993	26	of	of	IN
18637	2993	27	communication	communication	NN
18637	2993	28	which	which	WDT
18637	2993	29	were	be	VBD
18637	2993	30	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	2993	31	to	to	TO
18637	2993	32	be	be	VB
18637	2993	33	harmful	harmful	JJ
18637	2993	34	.	.	.
18637	2994	1	A	a	DT
18637	2994	2	much	much	RB
18637	2994	3	broader	broad	JJR
18637	2994	4	power	power	NN
18637	2994	5	of	of	IN
18637	2994	6	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	2994	7	was	be	VBD
18637	2994	8	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	2994	9	in	in	IN
18637	2994	10	the	the	DT
18637	2994	11	Public	Public	NNP
18637	2994	12	Utility	Utility	NNP
18637	2994	13	Holding	Holding	NNP
18637	2994	14	Company	Company	NNP
18637	2994	15	Act	Act	NNP
18637	2994	16	of	of	IN
18637	2994	17	1935	1935	CD
18637	2994	18	.	.	.
18637	2995	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2995	2	1147	1147	CD
18637	2995	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2995	4	To	to	TO
18637	2995	5	induce	induce	VB
18637	2995	6	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	2995	7	with	with	IN
18637	2995	8	the	the	DT
18637	2995	9	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	2995	10	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	2995	11	of	of	IN
18637	2995	12	that	that	DT
18637	2995	13	act	act	NN
18637	2995	14	,	,	,
18637	2995	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2995	16	denied	deny	VBD
18637	2995	17	the	the	DT
18637	2995	18	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	2995	19	of	of	IN
18637	2995	20	using	use	VBG
18637	2995	21	the	the	DT
18637	2995	22	mails	mail	NNS
18637	2995	23	for	for	IN
18637	2995	24	any	any	DT
18637	2995	25	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	2995	26	to	to	IN
18637	2995	27	holding	hold	VBG
18637	2995	28	companies	company	NNS
18637	2995	29	which	which	WDT
18637	2995	30	failed	fail	VBD
18637	2995	31	to	to	TO
18637	2995	32	obey	obey	VB
18637	2995	33	that	that	DT
18637	2995	34	law	law	NN
18637	2995	35	,	,	,
18637	2995	36	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	2995	37	of	of	IN
18637	2995	38	the	the	DT
18637	2995	39	character	character	NN
18637	2995	40	of	of	IN
18637	2995	41	the	the	DT
18637	2995	42	material	material	NN
18637	2995	43	to	to	TO
18637	2995	44	be	be	VB
18637	2995	45	carried	carry	VBN
18637	2995	46	.	.	.
18637	2996	1	Viewing	view	VBG
18637	2996	2	the	the	DT
18637	2996	3	matter	matter	NN
18637	2996	4	realistically	realistically	RB
18637	2996	5	,	,	,
18637	2996	6	the	the	DT
18637	2996	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2996	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2996	9	treated	treat	VBD
18637	2996	10	this	this	DT
18637	2996	11	provision	provision	NN
18637	2996	12	as	as	IN
18637	2996	13	a	a	DT
18637	2996	14	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	2996	15	.	.	.
18637	2997	1	While	while	IN
18637	2997	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2997	3	held	hold	VBD
18637	2997	4	this	this	DT
18637	2997	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	2997	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2997	7	because	because	IN
18637	2997	8	the	the	DT
18637	2997	9	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2997	10	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2997	11	infractions	infraction	NNS
18637	2997	12	were	be	VBD
18637	2997	13	thus	thus	RB
18637	2997	14	penalized	penalize	VBN
18637	2997	15	were	be	VBD
18637	2997	16	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2997	17	valid,[1148	valid,[1148	NNP
18637	2997	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2997	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2997	20	declared	declare	VBD
18637	2997	21	that	that	IN
18637	2997	22	"	"	``
18637	2997	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2997	24	may	may	MD
18637	2997	25	not	not	RB
18637	2997	26	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	2997	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2997	28	control	control	NN
18637	2997	29	over	over	IN
18637	2997	30	the	the	DT
18637	2997	31	mails	mail	NNS
18637	2997	32	to	to	TO
18637	2997	33	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	2997	34	a	a	DT
18637	2997	35	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	2997	36	which	which	WDT
18637	2997	37	lies	lie	VBZ
18637	2997	38	outside	outside	IN
18637	2997	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2997	40	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	2997	41	province	province	NN
18637	2997	42	,	,	,
18637	2997	43	*	*	NFP
18637	2997	44	*	*	NFP
18637	2997	45	*	*	NFP
18637	2997	46	.	.	.
18637	2998	1	"	"	``
18637	2998	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	2998	3	1149	1149	CD
18637	2998	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	2998	5	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	2998	6	REGULATIONS	regulation	NNS
18637	2998	7	AFFECTING	affect	VBG
18637	2998	8	THE	the	DT
18637	2998	9	MAILS	mail	NNS
18637	2998	10	In	in	IN
18637	2998	11	determining	determine	VBG
18637	2998	12	the	the	DT
18637	2998	13	extent	extent	NN
18637	2998	14	to	to	IN
18637	2998	15	which	which	WDT
18637	2998	16	State	state	NN
18637	2998	17	laws	law	NNS
18637	2998	18	may	may	MD
18637	2998	19	impinge	impinge	VB
18637	2998	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	2998	21	persons	person	NNS
18637	2998	22	or	or	CC
18637	2998	23	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	2998	24	whose	whose	WP$
18637	2998	25	services	service	NNS
18637	2998	26	are	be	VBP
18637	2998	27	utilized	utilize	VBN
18637	2998	28	by	by	IN
18637	2998	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2998	30	in	in	IN
18637	2998	31	executing	execute	VBG
18637	2998	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	2998	33	postal	postal	JJ
18637	2998	34	powers	power	NNS
18637	2998	35	,	,	,
18637	2998	36	the	the	DT
18637	2998	37	task	task	NN
18637	2998	38	of	of	IN
18637	2998	39	the	the	DT
18637	2998	40	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	2998	41	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2998	42	has	have	VBZ
18637	2998	43	been	be	VBN
18637	2998	44	to	to	TO
18637	2998	45	determine	determine	VB
18637	2998	46	whether	whether	IN
18637	2998	47	particular	particular	JJ
18637	2998	48	measures	measure	NNS
18637	2998	49	are	be	VBP
18637	2998	50	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	2998	51	with	with	IN
18637	2998	52	the	the	DT
18637	2998	53	general	general	JJ
18637	2998	54	policies	policy	NNS
18637	2998	55	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	2998	56	by	by	IN
18637	2998	57	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	2998	58	.	.	.
18637	2999	1	Broadly	broadly	RB
18637	2999	2	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	2999	3	,	,	,
18637	2999	4	the	the	DT
18637	2999	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	2999	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	2999	7	approved	approve	VBN
18637	2999	8	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	2999	9	which	which	WDT
18637	2999	10	have	have	VBP
18637	2999	11	a	a	DT
18637	2999	12	trivial	trivial	JJ
18637	2999	13	or	or	CC
18637	2999	14	remote	remote	JJ
18637	2999	15	relation	relation	NN
18637	2999	16	to	to	IN
18637	2999	17	the	the	DT
18637	2999	18	operation	operation	NN
18637	2999	19	of	of	IN
18637	2999	20	the	the	DT
18637	2999	21	postal	postal	JJ
18637	2999	22	service	service	NN
18637	2999	23	,	,	,
18637	2999	24	while	while	IN
18637	2999	25	disallowing	disallow	VBG
18637	2999	26	those	those	DT
18637	2999	27	which	which	WDT
18637	2999	28	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	2999	29	a	a	DT
18637	2999	30	serious	serious	JJ
18637	2999	31	impediment	impediment	NN
18637	2999	32	to	to	IN
18637	2999	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	2999	34	.	.	.
18637	3000	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	3000	2	a	a	DT
18637	3000	3	State	state	NN
18637	3000	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	3000	5	which	which	WDT
18637	3000	6	granted	grant	VBD
18637	3000	7	to	to	IN
18637	3000	8	one	one	CD
18637	3000	9	company	company	NN
18637	3000	10	an	an	DT
18637	3000	11	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3000	12	right	right	NN
18637	3000	13	to	to	TO
18637	3000	14	operate	operate	VB
18637	3000	15	a	a	DT
18637	3000	16	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	3000	17	business	business	NN
18637	3000	18	in	in	IN
18637	3000	19	the	the	DT
18637	3000	20	State	State	NNP
18637	3000	21	was	be	VBD
18637	3000	22	found	find	VBN
18637	3000	23	to	to	TO
18637	3000	24	be	be	VB
18637	3000	25	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
18637	3000	26	with	with	IN
18637	3000	27	a	a	DT
18637	3000	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3000	29	law	law	NN
18637	3000	30	which	which	WDT
18637	3000	31	,	,	,
18637	3000	32	in	in	IN
18637	3000	33	granting	grant	VBG
18637	3000	34	to	to	IN
18637	3000	35	any	any	DT
18637	3000	36	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	3000	37	company	company	NN
18637	3000	38	the	the	DT
18637	3000	39	right	right	NN
18637	3000	40	to	to	TO
18637	3000	41	construct	construct	VB
18637	3000	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3000	43	lines	line	NNS
18637	3000	44	upon	upon	IN
18637	3000	45	post	post	JJ
18637	3000	46	roads	road	NNS
18637	3000	47	,	,	,
18637	3000	48	was	be	VBD
18637	3000	49	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	3000	50	as	as	IN
18637	3000	51	a	a	DT
18637	3000	52	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3000	53	of	of	IN
18637	3000	54	State	State	NNP
18637	3000	55	monopolies	monopoly	NNS
18637	3000	56	in	in	IN
18637	3000	57	a	a	DT
18637	3000	58	field	field	NN
18637	3000	59	which	which	WDT
18637	3000	60	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3000	61	was	be	VBD
18637	3000	62	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	3000	63	to	to	TO
18637	3000	64	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	3000	65	in	in	IN
18637	3000	66	the	the	DT
18637	3000	67	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3000	68	of	of	IN
18637	3000	69	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3000	70	combined	combined	JJ
18637	3000	71	power	power	NN
18637	3000	72	over	over	IN
18637	3000	73	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	3000	74	and	and	CC
18637	3000	75	post	post	NN
18637	3000	76	roads	road	NNS
18637	3000	77	.	.	.
18637	3001	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3001	2	1150	1150	CD
18637	3001	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3001	4	An	an	DT
18637	3001	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	3001	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	3001	7	which	which	WDT
18637	3001	8	,	,	,
18637	3001	9	as	as	IN
18637	3001	10	construed	construe	VBN
18637	3001	11	by	by	IN
18637	3001	12	the	the	DT
18637	3001	13	State	State	NNP
18637	3001	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	3001	15	,	,	,
18637	3001	16	required	require	VBD
18637	3001	17	an	an	DT
18637	3001	18	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	3001	19	mail	mail	NN
18637	3001	20	train	train	NN
18637	3001	21	to	to	TO
18637	3001	22	make	make	VB
18637	3001	23	a	a	DT
18637	3001	24	detour	detour	NN
18637	3001	25	of	of	IN
18637	3001	26	seven	seven	CD
18637	3001	27	miles	mile	NNS
18637	3001	28	in	in	IN
18637	3001	29	order	order	NN
18637	3001	30	to	to	TO
18637	3001	31	stop	stop	VB
18637	3001	32	at	at	IN
18637	3001	33	a	a	DT
18637	3001	34	designated	designate	VBN
18637	3001	35	station	station	NN
18637	3001	36	,	,	,
18637	3001	37	also	also	RB
18637	3001	38	was	be	VBD
18637	3001	39	held	hold	VBN
18637	3001	40	to	to	TO
18637	3001	41	be	be	VB
18637	3001	42	an	an	DT
18637	3001	43	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	3001	44	interference	interference	NN
18637	3001	45	with	with	IN
18637	3001	46	the	the	DT
18637	3001	47	power	power	NN
18637	3001	48	of	of	IN
18637	3001	49	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3001	50	under	under	IN
18637	3001	51	this	this	DT
18637	3001	52	clause	clause	NN
18637	3001	53	.	.	.
18637	3002	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3002	2	1151	1151	CD
18637	3002	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3002	4	But	but	CC
18637	3002	5	a	a	DT
18637	3002	6	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	3002	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	3002	8	which	which	WDT
18637	3002	9	required	require	VBD
18637	3002	10	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	3002	11	trains	train	NNS
18637	3002	12	to	to	TO
18637	3002	13	stop	stop	VB
18637	3002	14	at	at	IN
18637	3002	15	county	county	NN
18637	3002	16	seats	seat	NNS
18637	3002	17	was	be	VBD
18637	3002	18	found	find	VBN
18637	3002	19	to	to	TO
18637	3002	20	be	be	VB
18637	3002	21	unobjectionable	unobjectionable	JJ
18637	3002	22	.	.	.
18637	3003	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3003	2	1152	1152	CD
18637	3003	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3003	4	Local	local	JJ
18637	3003	5	laws	law	NNS
18637	3003	6	classifying	classify	VBG
18637	3003	7	postal	postal	JJ
18637	3003	8	workers	worker	NNS
18637	3003	9	with	with	IN
18637	3003	10	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	3003	11	employees	employee	NNS
18637	3003	12	for	for	IN
18637	3003	13	the	the	DT
18637	3003	14	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3003	15	of	of	IN
18637	3003	16	determining	determine	VBG
18637	3003	17	a	a	DT
18637	3003	18	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	3003	19	's	's	POS
18637	3003	20	liability	liability	NN
18637	3003	21	for	for	IN
18637	3003	22	personal	personal	JJ
18637	3003	23	injuries,[1153	injuries,[1153	NNP
18637	3003	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3003	25	or	or	CC
18637	3003	26	subjecting	subject	VBG
18637	3003	27	a	a	DT
18637	3003	28	union	union	NN
18637	3003	29	of	of	IN
18637	3003	30	railway	railway	NN
18637	3003	31	mail	mail	NN
18637	3003	32	clerks	clerk	VBZ
18637	3003	33	to	to	IN
18637	3003	34	a	a	DT
18637	3003	35	general	general	JJ
18637	3003	36	law	law	NN
18637	3003	37	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	3003	38	any	any	DT
18637	3003	39	"	"	``
18637	3003	40	labor	labor	NN
18637	3003	41	organization	organization	NN
18637	3003	42	"	"	''
18637	3003	43	to	to	TO
18637	3003	44	deny	deny	VB
18637	3003	45	any	any	DT
18637	3003	46	person	person	NN
18637	3003	47	membership	membership	NN
18637	3003	48	because	because	IN
18637	3003	49	of	of	IN
18637	3003	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3003	51	race	race	NN
18637	3003	52	,	,	,
18637	3003	53	color	color	NN
18637	3003	54	or	or	CC
18637	3003	55	creed,[1154	creed,[1154	NNP
18637	3003	56	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3003	57	have	have	VBP
18637	3003	58	been	be	VBN
18637	3003	59	held	hold	VBN
18637	3003	60	not	not	RB
18637	3003	61	to	to	TO
18637	3003	62	conflict	conflict	VB
18637	3003	63	with	with	IN
18637	3003	64	national	national	JJ
18637	3003	65	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3003	66	or	or	CC
18637	3003	67	policy	policy	NN
18637	3003	68	in	in	IN
18637	3003	69	this	this	DT
18637	3003	70	field	field	NN
18637	3003	71	.	.	.
18637	3004	1	Despite	despite	IN
18637	3004	2	the	the	DT
18637	3004	3	interference	interference	NN
18637	3004	4	_	_	NNP
18637	3004	5	pro	pro	JJ
18637	3004	6	tanto	tanto	IN
18637	3004	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3004	8	with	with	IN
18637	3004	9	the	the	DT
18637	3004	10	performance	performance	NN
18637	3004	11	of	of	IN
18637	3004	12	a	a	DT
18637	3004	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3004	14	function	function	NN
18637	3004	15	,	,	,
18637	3004	16	a	a	DT
18637	3004	17	State	state	NN
18637	3004	18	may	may	MD
18637	3004	19	arrest	arrest	VB
18637	3004	20	a	a	DT
18637	3004	21	postal	postal	JJ
18637	3004	22	employee	employee	NN
18637	3004	23	charged	charge	VBN
18637	3004	24	with	with	IN
18637	3004	25	murder	murder	NN
18637	3004	26	while	while	IN
18637	3004	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3004	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	3004	29	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	3004	30	in	in	IN
18637	3004	31	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	3004	32	out	out	RP
18637	3004	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3004	34	official	official	JJ
18637	3004	35	duties,[1155	duties,[1155	NNP
18637	3004	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3004	37	but	but	CC
18637	3004	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3004	39	can	can	MD
18637	3004	40	not	not	RB
18637	3004	41	punish	punish	VB
18637	3004	42	a	a	DT
18637	3004	43	person	person	NN
18637	3004	44	for	for	IN
18637	3004	45	operating	operate	VBG
18637	3004	46	a	a	DT
18637	3004	47	mail	mail	NN
18637	3004	48	truck	truck	NN
18637	3004	49	over	over	IN
18637	3004	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3004	51	highways	highway	NNS
18637	3004	52	without	without	IN
18637	3004	53	procuring	procure	VBG
18637	3004	54	a	a	DT
18637	3004	55	driver	driver	NN
18637	3004	56	's	's	POS
18637	3004	57	license	license	NN
18637	3004	58	from	from	IN
18637	3004	59	State	State	NNP
18637	3004	60	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	3004	61	.	.	.
18637	3005	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3005	2	1156	1156	CD
18637	3005	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3005	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3005	5	8	8	CD
18637	3005	6	.	.	.
18637	3006	1	_	_	NNP
18637	3006	2	The	the	DT
18637	3006	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3006	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	3006	5	have	have	VB
18637	3006	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	3006	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3006	8	*	*	NFP
18637	3006	9	*	*	NFP
18637	3006	10	*	*	NFP
18637	3006	11	To	to	TO
18637	3006	12	promote	promote	VB
18637	3006	13	the	the	DT
18637	3006	14	Progress	Progress	NNP
18637	3006	15	of	of	IN
18637	3006	16	Science	Science	NNP
18637	3006	17	and	and	CC
18637	3006	18	useful	useful	JJ
18637	3006	19	Arts	art	NNS
18637	3006	20	,	,	,
18637	3006	21	by	by	IN
18637	3006	22	securing	secure	VBG
18637	3006	23	for	for	IN
18637	3006	24	limited	limited	JJ
18637	3006	25	Times	Times	NNP
18637	3006	26	to	to	IN
18637	3006	27	Authors	Authors	NNPS
18637	3006	28	and	and	CC
18637	3006	29	Inventors	inventor	NNS
18637	3006	30	the	the	DT
18637	3006	31	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3006	32	Right	right	NN
18637	3006	33	to	to	IN
18637	3006	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3006	35	respective	respective	JJ
18637	3006	36	Writings	Writings	NNPS
18637	3006	37	and	and	CC
18637	3006	38	Discoveries	Discoveries	NNPS
18637	3006	39	.	.	.
18637	3007	1	Copyrights	Copyrights	NNPS
18637	3007	2	and	and	CC
18637	3007	3	Patents	Patents	NNPS
18637	3007	4	SCOPE	SCOPE	NNP
18637	3007	5	OF	of	IN
18637	3007	6	THE	the	DT
18637	3007	7	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	3007	8	This	this	DT
18637	3007	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	3007	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	3007	11	the	the	DT
18637	3007	12	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	3007	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	3007	14	which	which	WDT
18637	3007	15	the	the	DT
18637	3007	16	national	national	JJ
18637	3007	17	patent	patent	NN
18637	3007	18	and	and	CC
18637	3007	19	copyright	copyright	NN
18637	3007	20	laws	law	NNS
18637	3007	21	rest	rest	VBP
18637	3007	22	,	,	,
18637	3007	23	although	although	IN
18637	3007	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3007	25	uses	use	VBZ
18637	3007	26	neither	neither	DT
18637	3007	27	of	of	IN
18637	3007	28	those	those	DT
18637	3007	29	terms	term	NNS
18637	3007	30	.	.	.
18637	3008	1	So	so	RB
18637	3008	2	far	far	RB
18637	3008	3	as	as	IN
18637	3008	4	patents	patent	NNS
18637	3008	5	are	be	VBP
18637	3008	6	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	3008	7	,	,	,
18637	3008	8	modern	modern	JJ
18637	3008	9	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3008	10	harks	hark	VBZ
18637	3008	11	back	back	RB
18637	3008	12	to	to	IN
18637	3008	13	the	the	DT
18637	3008	14	Statute	Statute	NNP
18637	3008	15	of	of	IN
18637	3008	16	Monopolies	Monopolies	NNPS
18637	3008	17	of	of	IN
18637	3008	18	1624	1624	CD
18637	3008	19	,	,	,
18637	3008	20	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	3008	21	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
18637	3008	22	endowed	endow	VBD
18637	3008	23	inventors	inventor	NNS
18637	3008	24	with	with	IN
18637	3008	25	the	the	DT
18637	3008	26	sole	sole	JJ
18637	3008	27	right	right	NN
18637	3008	28	to	to	IN
18637	3008	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3008	30	inventions	invention	NNS
18637	3008	31	for	for	IN
18637	3008	32	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	3008	33	years	year	NNS
18637	3008	34	.	.	.
18637	3009	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3009	2	1157	1157	CD
18637	3009	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3009	4	Copyright	copyright	NN
18637	3009	5	law	law	NN
18637	3009	6	,	,	,
18637	3009	7	in	in	IN
18637	3009	8	turn	turn	NN
18637	3009	9	,	,	,
18637	3009	10	traces	trace	VBZ
18637	3009	11	back	back	RB
18637	3009	12	to	to	IN
18637	3009	13	the	the	DT
18637	3009	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	3009	15	of	of	IN
18637	3009	16	1710	1710	CD
18637	3009	17	which	which	WDT
18637	3009	18	secured	secure	VBD
18637	3009	19	to	to	IN
18637	3009	20	authors	author	NNS
18637	3009	21	of	of	IN
18637	3009	22	books	book	NNS
18637	3009	23	the	the	DT
18637	3009	24	sole	sole	JJ
18637	3009	25	right	right	NN
18637	3009	26	of	of	IN
18637	3009	27	publishing	publish	VBG
18637	3009	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3009	29	for	for	IN
18637	3009	30	designated	designate	VBN
18637	3009	31	periods	period	NNS
18637	3009	32	.	.	.
18637	3010	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3010	2	1158	1158	CD
18637	3010	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3010	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3010	5	was	be	VBD
18637	3010	6	not	not	RB
18637	3010	7	,	,	,
18637	3010	8	however	however	RB
18637	3010	9	,	,	,
18637	3010	10	by	by	IN
18637	3010	11	this	this	DT
18637	3010	12	provision	provision	NN
18637	3010	13	,	,	,
18637	3010	14	vested	vest	VBN
18637	3010	15	with	with	IN
18637	3010	16	anything	anything	NN
18637	3010	17	akin	akin	JJ
18637	3010	18	to	to	IN
18637	3010	19	the	the	DT
18637	3010	20	royal	royal	JJ
18637	3010	21	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	3010	22	in	in	IN
18637	3010	23	the	the	DT
18637	3010	24	creation	creation	NN
18637	3010	25	and	and	CC
18637	3010	26	bestowal	bestowal	NN
18637	3010	27	of	of	IN
18637	3010	28	monopolistic	monopolistic	JJ
18637	3010	29	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3010	30	.	.	.
18637	3011	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3011	2	power	power	NN
18637	3011	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	3011	4	limited	limit	VBN
18637	3011	5	as	as	IN
18637	3011	6	to	to	IN
18637	3011	7	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3011	8	matter	matter	NN
18637	3011	9	,	,	,
18637	3011	10	and	and	CC
18637	3011	11	as	as	IN
18637	3011	12	to	to	IN
18637	3011	13	the	the	DT
18637	3011	14	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3011	15	and	and	CC
18637	3011	16	duration	duration	NN
18637	3011	17	of	of	IN
18637	3011	18	the	the	DT
18637	3011	19	rights	right	NNS
18637	3011	20	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3011	21	.	.	.
18637	3012	1	Only	only	RB
18637	3012	2	the	the	DT
18637	3012	3	writings	writing	NNS
18637	3012	4	and	and	CC
18637	3012	5	discoveries	discovery	NNS
18637	3012	6	of	of	IN
18637	3012	7	authors	author	NNS
18637	3012	8	and	and	CC
18637	3012	9	inventors	inventor	NNS
18637	3012	10	may	may	MD
18637	3012	11	be	be	VB
18637	3012	12	protected	protect	VBN
18637	3012	13	,	,	,
18637	3012	14	and	and	CC
18637	3012	15	then	then	RB
18637	3012	16	only	only	RB
18637	3012	17	to	to	IN
18637	3012	18	the	the	DT
18637	3012	19	end	end	NN
18637	3012	20	of	of	IN
18637	3012	21	promoting	promote	VBG
18637	3012	22	science	science	NN
18637	3012	23	and	and	CC
18637	3012	24	the	the	DT
18637	3012	25	useful	useful	JJ
18637	3012	26	arts	art	NNS
18637	3012	27	.	.	.
18637	3013	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3013	2	1159	1159	CD
18637	3013	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3013	4	While	while	IN
18637	3013	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3013	6	may	may	MD
18637	3013	7	grant	grant	VB
18637	3013	8	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3013	9	rights	right	NNS
18637	3013	10	only	only	RB
18637	3013	11	for	for	IN
18637	3013	12	a	a	DT
18637	3013	13	limited	limited	JJ
18637	3013	14	period	period	NN
18637	3013	15	,	,	,
18637	3013	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3013	17	may	may	MD
18637	3013	18	extend	extend	VB
18637	3013	19	the	the	DT
18637	3013	20	term	term	NN
18637	3013	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	3013	22	the	the	DT
18637	3013	23	expiration	expiration	NN
18637	3013	24	of	of	IN
18637	3013	25	the	the	DT
18637	3013	26	period	period	NN
18637	3013	27	originally	originally	RB
18637	3013	28	specified	specify	VBD
18637	3013	29	,	,	,
18637	3013	30	and	and	CC
18637	3013	31	in	in	IN
18637	3013	32	so	so	RB
18637	3013	33	doing	do	VBG
18637	3013	34	may	may	MD
18637	3013	35	protect	protect	VB
18637	3013	36	the	the	DT
18637	3013	37	rights	right	NNS
18637	3013	38	of	of	IN
18637	3013	39	purchasers	purchaser	NNS
18637	3013	40	and	and	CC
18637	3013	41	assignees	assignee	NNS
18637	3013	42	.	.	.
18637	3014	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3014	2	1160	1160	CD
18637	3014	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3014	4	The	the	DT
18637	3014	5	copyright	copyright	NN
18637	3014	6	and	and	CC
18637	3014	7	patent	patent	NN
18637	3014	8	laws	law	NNS
18637	3014	9	do	do	VBP
18637	3014	10	not	not	RB
18637	3014	11	have	have	VB
18637	3014	12	,	,	,
18637	3014	13	of	of	IN
18637	3014	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3014	15	own	own	JJ
18637	3014	16	force	force	NN
18637	3014	17	,	,	,
18637	3014	18	any	any	DT
18637	3014	19	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	JJ
18637	3014	20	operation	operation	NN
18637	3014	21	.	.	.
18637	3015	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3015	2	1161	1161	CD
18637	3015	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3015	4	PATENTABLE	PATENTABLE	NNP
18637	3015	5	DISCOVERIES	discovery	NNS
18637	3015	6	The	the	DT
18637	3015	7	protection	protection	NN
18637	3015	8	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	3015	9	by	by	IN
18637	3015	10	acts	act	NNS
18637	3015	11	of	of	IN
18637	3015	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3015	13	under	under	IN
18637	3015	14	this	this	DT
18637	3015	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	3015	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	3015	17	limited	limit	VBN
18637	3015	18	to	to	IN
18637	3015	19	new	new	JJ
18637	3015	20	and	and	CC
18637	3015	21	useful	useful	JJ
18637	3015	22	inventions,[1162	inventions,[1162	NNP
18637	3015	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3015	24	and	and	CC
18637	3015	25	while	while	IN
18637	3015	26	a	a	DT
18637	3015	27	patentable	patentable	JJ
18637	3015	28	invention	invention	NN
18637	3015	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	3015	30	a	a	DT
18637	3015	31	mental	mental	JJ
18637	3015	32	achievement,[1163	achievement,[1163	NNP
18637	3015	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3015	34	yet	yet	CC
18637	3015	35	for	for	IN
18637	3015	36	an	an	DT
18637	3015	37	idea	idea	NN
18637	3015	38	to	to	TO
18637	3015	39	be	be	VB
18637	3015	40	patentable	patentable	JJ
18637	3015	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3015	42	must	must	MD
18637	3015	43	have	have	VB
18637	3015	44	first	first	JJ
18637	3015	45	taken	take	VBN
18637	3015	46	physical	physical	JJ
18637	3015	47	form	form	NN
18637	3015	48	.	.	.
18637	3016	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3016	2	1164	1164	CD
18637	3016	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3016	4	Despite	despite	IN
18637	3016	5	the	the	DT
18637	3016	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	3016	7	that	that	IN
18637	3016	8	the	the	DT
18637	3016	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3016	10	uses	use	VBZ
18637	3016	11	the	the	DT
18637	3016	12	term	term	NN
18637	3016	13	"	"	``
18637	3016	14	discovery	discovery	NN
18637	3016	15	"	"	''
18637	3016	16	rather	rather	RB
18637	3016	17	than	than	IN
18637	3016	18	"	"	``
18637	3016	19	invention	invention	NN
18637	3016	20	,	,	,
18637	3016	21	"	"	''
18637	3016	22	a	a	DT
18637	3016	23	patent	patent	NN
18637	3016	24	may	may	MD
18637	3016	25	not	not	RB
18637	3016	26	issue	issue	VB
18637	3016	27	for	for	IN
18637	3016	28	the	the	DT
18637	3016	29	discovery	discovery	NN
18637	3016	30	of	of	IN
18637	3016	31	a	a	DT
18637	3016	32	hitherto	hitherto	JJ
18637	3016	33	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	3016	34	phenomenon	phenomenon	NN
18637	3016	35	of	of	IN
18637	3016	36	nature	nature	NN
18637	3016	37	;	;	:
18637	3016	38	"	"	``
18637	3016	39	if	if	IN
18637	3016	40	there	there	EX
18637	3016	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	3016	42	to	to	TO
18637	3016	43	be	be	VB
18637	3016	44	invention	invention	NN
18637	3016	45	from	from	IN
18637	3016	46	such	such	PDT
18637	3016	47	a	a	DT
18637	3016	48	discovery	discovery	NN
18637	3016	49	,	,	,
18637	3016	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3016	51	must	must	MD
18637	3016	52	come	come	VB
18637	3016	53	from	from	IN
18637	3016	54	the	the	DT
18637	3016	55	application	application	NN
18637	3016	56	of	of	IN
18637	3016	57	the	the	DT
18637	3016	58	law	law	NN
18637	3016	59	of	of	IN
18637	3016	60	nature	nature	NN
18637	3016	61	to	to	IN
18637	3016	62	a	a	DT
18637	3016	63	new	new	JJ
18637	3016	64	and	and	CC
18637	3016	65	useful	useful	JJ
18637	3016	66	end	end	NN
18637	3016	67	.	.	.
18637	3017	1	"	"	``
18637	3017	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3017	3	1165	1165	CD
18637	3017	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3017	5	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	3017	6	,	,	,
18637	3017	7	the	the	DT
18637	3017	8	mental	mental	JJ
18637	3017	9	processes	process	NNS
18637	3017	10	which	which	WDT
18637	3017	11	are	be	VBP
18637	3017	12	thus	thus	RB
18637	3017	13	applied	apply	VBN
18637	3017	14	must	must	MD
18637	3017	15	display	display	VB
18637	3017	16	"	"	``
18637	3017	17	more	more	JJR
18637	3017	18	ingenuity	ingenuity	NN
18637	3017	19	*	*	NFP
18637	3017	20	*	*	NFP
18637	3017	21	*	*	NFP
18637	3017	22	than	than	IN
18637	3017	23	the	the	DT
18637	3017	24	work	work	NN
18637	3017	25	of	of	IN
18637	3017	26	a	a	DT
18637	3017	27	mechanic	mechanic	JJ
18637	3017	28	skilled	skilled	JJ
18637	3017	29	in	in	IN
18637	3017	30	the	the	DT
18637	3017	31	art";[1166	art";[1166	NN
18637	3017	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3017	33	and	and	CC
18637	3017	34	while	while	IN
18637	3017	35	combination	combination	NN
18637	3017	36	patents	patent	NNS
18637	3017	37	have	have	VBP
18637	3017	38	been	be	VBN
18637	3017	39	at	at	IN
18637	3017	40	times	time	NNS
18637	3017	41	sustained,[1167	sustained,[1167	NNP
18637	3017	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3017	43	the	the	DT
18637	3017	44	accumulation	accumulation	NN
18637	3017	45	of	of	IN
18637	3017	46	old	old	JJ
18637	3017	47	devices	device	NNS
18637	3017	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	3017	49	patentable	patentable	JJ
18637	3017	50	"	"	``
18637	3017	51	only	only	RB
18637	3017	52	when	when	WRB
18637	3017	53	the	the	DT
18637	3017	54	whole	whole	NN
18637	3017	55	in	in	IN
18637	3017	56	some	some	DT
18637	3017	57	way	way	NN
18637	3017	58	exceeds	exceed	VBZ
18637	3017	59	the	the	DT
18637	3017	60	sum	sum	NN
18637	3017	61	of	of	IN
18637	3017	62	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3017	63	parts	part	NNS
18637	3017	64	.	.	.
18637	3018	1	"	"	``
18637	3018	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3018	3	1168	1168	CD
18637	3018	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3018	5	The	the	DT
18637	3018	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3018	7	's	's	POS
18637	3018	8	insistence	insistence	NN
18637	3018	9	on	on	IN
18637	3018	10	the	the	DT
18637	3018	11	presence	presence	NN
18637	3018	12	of	of	IN
18637	3018	13	"	"	``
18637	3018	14	inventive	inventive	JJ
18637	3018	15	genius	genius	NN
18637	3018	16	"	"	''
18637	3018	17	as	as	IN
18637	3018	18	the	the	DT
18637	3018	19	test	test	NN
18637	3018	20	of	of	IN
18637	3018	21	patentability	patentability	NN
18637	3018	22	goes	go	VBZ
18637	3018	23	far	far	RB
18637	3018	24	back	back	RB
18637	3018	25	and	and	CC
18637	3018	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	3018	27	been	be	VBN
18637	3018	28	reiterated	reiterate	VBN
18637	3018	29	again	again	RB
18637	3018	30	and	and	CC
18637	3018	31	again	again	RB
18637	3018	32	in	in	IN
18637	3018	33	slightly	slightly	RB
18637	3018	34	varying	vary	VBG
18637	3018	35	language,[1169	language,[1169	NNP
18637	3018	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3018	37	although	although	IN
18637	3018	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3018	39	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	3018	40	to	to	TO
18637	3018	41	have	have	VB
18637	3018	42	had	have	VBN
18637	3018	43	little	little	JJ
18637	3018	44	effect	effect	NN
18637	3018	45	on	on	IN
18637	3018	46	the	the	DT
18637	3018	47	point	point	NN
18637	3018	48	of	of	IN
18637	3018	49	view	view	NN
18637	3018	50	of	of	IN
18637	3018	51	the	the	DT
18637	3018	52	Patent	Patent	NNP
18637	3018	53	Office	Office	NNP
18637	3018	54	.	.	.
18637	3019	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3019	2	1170	1170	CD
18637	3019	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3019	4	PROCEDURE	PROCEDURE	NNP
18637	3019	5	IN	in	IN
18637	3019	6	ISSUING	issuing	NN
18637	3019	7	PATENTS	PATENTS	NNP
18637	3019	8	The	the	DT
18637	3019	9	standard	standard	NN
18637	3019	10	of	of	IN
18637	3019	11	patentability	patentability	NN
18637	3019	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	3019	13	a	a	DT
18637	3019	14	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3019	15	standard	standard	NN
18637	3019	16	,	,	,
18637	3019	17	and	and	CC
18637	3019	18	the	the	DT
18637	3019	19	question	question	NN
18637	3019	20	of	of	IN
18637	3019	21	the	the	DT
18637	3019	22	validity	validity	NN
18637	3019	23	of	of	IN
18637	3019	24	a	a	DT
18637	3019	25	patent	patent	NN
18637	3019	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	3019	27	a	a	DT
18637	3019	28	question	question	NN
18637	3019	29	of	of	IN
18637	3019	30	law	law	NN
18637	3019	31	.	.	.
18637	3020	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3020	2	1171	1171	CD
18637	3020	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3020	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3020	5	may	may	MD
18637	3020	6	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	3020	7	the	the	DT
18637	3020	8	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	3020	9	of	of	IN
18637	3020	10	a	a	DT
18637	3020	11	patent	patent	NN
18637	3020	12	for	for	IN
18637	3020	13	an	an	DT
18637	3020	14	invention	invention	NN
18637	3020	15	by	by	IN
18637	3020	16	a	a	DT
18637	3020	17	special	special	JJ
18637	3020	18	,	,	,
18637	3020	19	as	as	RB
18637	3020	20	well	well	RB
18637	3020	21	as	as	IN
18637	3020	22	by	by	IN
18637	3020	23	general	general	JJ
18637	3020	24	law	law	NN
18637	3020	25	,	,	,
18637	3020	26	provided	provide	VBD
18637	3020	27	the	the	DT
18637	3020	28	question	question	NN
18637	3020	29	as	as	IN
18637	3020	30	to	to	IN
18637	3020	31	whether	whether	IN
18637	3020	32	the	the	DT
18637	3020	33	patentees	patentee	NNS
18637	3020	34	device	device	NN
18637	3020	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	3020	36	in	in	IN
18637	3020	37	truth	truth	NN
18637	3020	38	an	an	DT
18637	3020	39	invention	invention	NN
18637	3020	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	3020	41	left	leave	VBN
18637	3020	42	open	open	JJ
18637	3020	43	to	to	IN
18637	3020	44	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	3020	45	under	under	IN
18637	3020	46	the	the	DT
18637	3020	47	general	general	JJ
18637	3020	48	law	law	NN
18637	3020	49	.	.	.
18637	3021	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3021	2	1172	1172	CD
18637	3021	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3021	4	The	the	DT
18637	3021	5	function	function	NN
18637	3021	6	of	of	IN
18637	3021	7	the	the	DT
18637	3021	8	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	3021	9	of	of	IN
18637	3021	10	Patents	Patents	NNPS
18637	3021	11	in	in	IN
18637	3021	12	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	3021	13	letters	letter	NNS
18637	3021	14	patent	patent	NN
18637	3021	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	3021	16	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	3021	17	to	to	TO
18637	3021	18	be	be	VB
18637	3021	19	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	3021	20	-	-	JJ
18637	3021	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3021	22	in	in	IN
18637	3021	23	character	character	NN
18637	3021	24	.	.	.
18637	3022	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	3022	2	an	an	DT
18637	3022	3	act	act	NN
18637	3022	4	granting	grant	VBG
18637	3022	5	a	a	DT
18637	3022	6	right	right	NN
18637	3022	7	of	of	IN
18637	3022	8	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	3022	9	from	from	IN
18637	3022	10	the	the	DT
18637	3022	11	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	3022	12	to	to	IN
18637	3022	13	the	the	DT
18637	3022	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3022	15	of	of	IN
18637	3022	16	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	3022	17	for	for	IN
18637	3022	18	the	the	DT
18637	3022	19	District	District	NNP
18637	3022	20	of	of	IN
18637	3022	21	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3022	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	3022	23	not	not	RB
18637	3022	24	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	3022	25	as	as	IN
18637	3022	26	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	3022	27	executive	executive	JJ
18637	3022	28	power	power	NN
18637	3022	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	3022	30	a	a	DT
18637	3022	31	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3022	32	body	body	NN
18637	3022	33	.	.	.
18637	3023	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3023	2	1173	1173	CD
18637	3023	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3023	4	NATURE	NATURE	NNP
18637	3023	5	AND	and	CC
18637	3023	6	SCOPE	scope	NN
18637	3023	7	OF	of	IN
18637	3023	8	THE	the	DT
18637	3023	9	RIGHT	right	NN
18637	3023	10	SECURED	SECURED	.
18637	3023	11	The	the	DT
18637	3023	12	leading	lead	VBG
18637	3023	13	case	case	NN
18637	3023	14	bearing	bear	VBG
18637	3023	15	on	on	IN
18637	3023	16	the	the	DT
18637	3023	17	nature	nature	NN
18637	3023	18	of	of	IN
18637	3023	19	the	the	DT
18637	3023	20	rights	right	NNS
18637	3023	21	which	which	WDT
18637	3023	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3023	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	3023	24	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	3023	25	to	to	IN
18637	3023	26	_	_	NNP
18637	3023	27	secure	secure	JJ
18637	3023	28	_	_	NNP
18637	3023	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	3023	30	that	that	DT
18637	3023	31	of	of	IN
18637	3023	32	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
18637	3023	33	_	_	NNP
18637	3023	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	3023	35	_	_	NNP
18637	3023	36	Peters	Peters	NNP
18637	3023	37	.	.	.
18637	3024	1	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
18637	3024	2	charged	charge	VBD
18637	3024	3	Peters	Peters	NNP
18637	3024	4	with	with	IN
18637	3024	5	having	have	VBG
18637	3024	6	infringed	infringe	VBN
18637	3024	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3024	8	copyright	copyright	NN
18637	3024	9	on	on	IN
18637	3024	10	the	the	DT
18637	3024	11	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	3024	12	volumes	volume	NNS
18637	3024	13	of	of	IN
18637	3024	14	"	"	``
18637	3024	15	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
18637	3024	16	's	's	POS
18637	3024	17	Reports	Reports	NNPS
18637	3024	18	"	"	``
18637	3024	19	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	3024	20	are	be	VBP
18637	3024	21	reported	report	VBN
18637	3024	22	the	the	DT
18637	3024	23	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3024	24	of	of	IN
18637	3024	25	the	the	DT
18637	3024	26	United	United	NNP
18637	3024	27	States	States	NNP
18637	3024	28	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3024	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3024	30	for	for	IN
18637	3024	31	the	the	DT
18637	3024	32	years	year	NNS
18637	3024	33	from	from	IN
18637	3024	34	1816	1816	CD
18637	3024	35	to	to	IN
18637	3024	36	1827	1827	CD
18637	3024	37	inclusive	inclusive	JJ
18637	3024	38	.	.	.
18637	3025	1	Peters	Peters	NNP
18637	3025	2	's	's	POS
18637	3025	3	defense	defense	NN
18637	3025	4	turned	turn	VBD
18637	3025	5	on	on	RP
18637	3025	6	the	the	DT
18637	3025	7	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	3025	8	that	that	WDT
18637	3025	9	inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	3025	10	as	as	IN
18637	3025	11	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
18637	3025	12	had	have	VBD
18637	3025	13	not	not	RB
18637	3025	14	complied	comply	VBN
18637	3025	15	with	with	IN
18637	3025	16	all	all	DT
18637	3025	17	of	of	IN
18637	3025	18	the	the	DT
18637	3025	19	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	3025	20	of	of	IN
18637	3025	21	the	the	DT
18637	3025	22	act	act	NN
18637	3025	23	of	of	IN
18637	3025	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3025	25	,	,	,
18637	3025	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3025	27	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	3025	28	copyright	copyright	NN
18637	3025	29	was	be	VBD
18637	3025	30	void	void	JJ
18637	3025	31	.	.	.
18637	3026	1	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
18637	3026	2	,	,	,
18637	3026	3	while	while	IN
18637	3026	4	denying	deny	VBG
18637	3026	5	this	this	DT
18637	3026	6	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	3026	7	of	of	IN
18637	3026	8	fact	fact	NN
18637	3026	9	,	,	,
18637	3026	10	further	further	RB
18637	3026	11	contended	contend	VBD
18637	3026	12	that	that	IN
18637	3026	13	the	the	DT
18637	3026	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	3026	15	was	be	VBD
18637	3026	16	only	only	RB
18637	3026	17	intended	intend	VBN
18637	3026	18	to	to	IN
18637	3026	19	_	_	NNP
18637	3026	20	secure	secure	JJ
18637	3026	21	_	_	IN
18637	3026	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3026	23	in	in	IN
18637	3026	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3026	25	pre	pre	JJ
18637	3026	26	-	-	JJ
18637	3026	27	existent	existent	JJ
18637	3026	28	rights	right	NNS
18637	3026	29	at	at	IN
18637	3026	30	common	common	JJ
18637	3026	31	law	law	NN
18637	3026	32	.	.	.
18637	3027	1	These	these	DT
18637	3027	2	at	at	IN
18637	3027	3	least	least	JJS
18637	3027	4	,	,	,
18637	3027	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3027	6	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	3027	7	,	,	,
18637	3027	8	the	the	DT
18637	3027	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3027	10	should	should	MD
18637	3027	11	protect	protect	VB
18637	3027	12	.	.	.
18637	3028	1	A	a	DT
18637	3028	2	divided	divide	VBN
18637	3028	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3028	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	3028	5	in	in	IN
18637	3028	6	favor	favor	NN
18637	3028	7	of	of	IN
18637	3028	8	Peters	Peters	NNP
18637	3028	9	on	on	IN
18637	3028	10	the	the	DT
18637	3028	11	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3028	12	question	question	NN
18637	3028	13	.	.	.
18637	3029	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3029	2	denied	deny	VBD
18637	3029	3	,	,	,
18637	3029	4	in	in	IN
18637	3029	5	the	the	DT
18637	3029	6	first	first	JJ
18637	3029	7	place	place	NN
18637	3029	8	,	,	,
18637	3029	9	that	that	IN
18637	3029	10	there	there	EX
18637	3029	11	was	be	VBD
18637	3029	12	any	any	DT
18637	3029	13	principle	principle	NN
18637	3029	14	of	of	IN
18637	3029	15	the	the	DT
18637	3029	16	common	common	JJ
18637	3029	17	law	law	NN
18637	3029	18	which	which	WDT
18637	3029	19	protected	protect	VBD
18637	3029	20	an	an	DT
18637	3029	21	author	author	NN
18637	3029	22	in	in	IN
18637	3029	23	the	the	DT
18637	3029	24	sole	sole	JJ
18637	3029	25	right	right	NN
18637	3029	26	to	to	TO
18637	3029	27	continue	continue	VB
18637	3029	28	to	to	TO
18637	3029	29	publish	publish	VB
18637	3029	30	a	a	DT
18637	3029	31	work	work	NN
18637	3029	32	once	once	RB
18637	3029	33	published	publish	VBN
18637	3029	34	.	.	.
18637	3030	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3030	2	denied	deny	VBD
18637	3030	3	,	,	,
18637	3030	4	in	in	IN
18637	3030	5	the	the	DT
18637	3030	6	second	second	JJ
18637	3030	7	place	place	NN
18637	3030	8	,	,	,
18637	3030	9	that	that	IN
18637	3030	10	there	there	EX
18637	3030	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	3030	12	any	any	DT
18637	3030	13	principle	principle	NN
18637	3030	14	of	of	IN
18637	3030	15	law	law	NN
18637	3030	16	,	,	,
18637	3030	17	common	common	JJ
18637	3030	18	or	or	CC
18637	3030	19	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	3030	20	,	,	,
18637	3030	21	which	which	WDT
18637	3030	22	pervades	pervade	VBZ
18637	3030	23	the	the	DT
18637	3030	24	Union	Union	NNP
18637	3030	25	except	except	IN
18637	3030	26	such	such	JJ
18637	3030	27	as	as	IN
18637	3030	28	are	be	VBP
18637	3030	29	embodied	embody	VBN
18637	3030	30	in	in	IN
18637	3030	31	the	the	DT
18637	3030	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3030	33	and	and	CC
18637	3030	34	the	the	DT
18637	3030	35	acts	act	NNS
18637	3030	36	of	of	IN
18637	3030	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3030	38	.	.	.
18637	3031	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	3031	2	,	,	,
18637	3031	3	in	in	IN
18637	3031	4	the	the	DT
18637	3031	5	third	third	JJ
18637	3031	6	place	place	NN
18637	3031	7	,	,	,
18637	3031	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3031	9	held	hold	VBD
18637	3031	10	,	,	,
18637	3031	11	did	do	VBD
18637	3031	12	the	the	DT
18637	3031	13	word	word	NN
18637	3031	14	"	"	``
18637	3031	15	securing	securing	NN
18637	3031	16	"	"	''
18637	3031	17	in	in	IN
18637	3031	18	the	the	DT
18637	3031	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3031	20	recognize	recognize	VBP
18637	3031	21	the	the	DT
18637	3031	22	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	3031	23	common	common	JJ
18637	3031	24	law	law	NN
18637	3031	25	principle	principle	NN
18637	3031	26	which	which	WDT
18637	3031	27	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
18637	3031	28	invoked	invoke	VBD
18637	3031	29	.	.	.
18637	3032	1	The	the	DT
18637	3032	2	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3032	3	right	right	NN
18637	3032	4	which	which	WDT
18637	3032	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3032	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	3032	7	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	3032	8	to	to	IN
18637	3032	9	_	_	NNP
18637	3032	10	secure	secure	JJ
18637	3032	11	_	_	NNP
18637	3032	12	to	to	IN
18637	3032	13	authors	author	NNS
18637	3032	14	and	and	CC
18637	3032	15	inventors	inventor	NNS
18637	3032	16	owes	owe	VBZ
18637	3032	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3032	18	existence	existence	NN
18637	3032	19	solely	solely	RB
18637	3032	20	to	to	IN
18637	3032	21	the	the	DT
18637	3032	22	acts	act	NNS
18637	3032	23	of	of	IN
18637	3032	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3032	25	securing	secure	VBG
18637	3032	26	it,[1174	it,[1174	CD
18637	3032	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3032	28	from	from	IN
18637	3032	29	which	which	WDT
18637	3032	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3032	31	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	3032	32	that	that	IN
18637	3032	33	the	the	DT
18637	3032	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	3032	35	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3032	36	by	by	IN
18637	3032	37	a	a	DT
18637	3032	38	patent	patent	NN
18637	3032	39	or	or	CC
18637	3032	40	copyright	copyright	NN
18637	3032	41	are	be	VBP
18637	3032	42	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3032	43	to	to	IN
18637	3032	44	such	such	JJ
18637	3032	45	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	3032	46	and	and	CC
18637	3032	47	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	3032	48	as	as	IN
18637	3032	49	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3032	50	,	,	,
18637	3032	51	in	in	IN
18637	3032	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3032	53	unhampered	unhampered	JJ
18637	3032	54	consultation	consultation	NN
18637	3032	55	of	of	IN
18637	3032	56	the	the	DT
18637	3032	57	public	public	JJ
18637	3032	58	interest	interest	NN
18637	3032	59	,	,	,
18637	3032	60	sees	see	VBZ
18637	3032	61	fit	fit	JJ
18637	3032	62	to	to	TO
18637	3032	63	impose	impose	VB
18637	3032	64	.	.	.
18637	3033	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3033	2	1175	1175	CD
18637	3033	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3033	4	In	in	IN
18637	3033	5	giving	give	VBG
18637	3033	6	to	to	IN
18637	3033	7	authors	author	NNS
18637	3033	8	the	the	DT
18637	3033	9	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3033	10	right	right	NN
18637	3033	11	to	to	TO
18637	3033	12	dramatize	dramatize	VB
18637	3033	13	any	any	DT
18637	3033	14	of	of	IN
18637	3033	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3033	16	works	work	NNS
18637	3033	17	,	,	,
18637	3033	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3033	19	did	do	VBD
18637	3033	20	not	not	RB
18637	3033	21	exceed	exceed	VB
18637	3033	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3033	23	powers	power	NNS
18637	3033	24	under	under	IN
18637	3033	25	this	this	DT
18637	3033	26	clause	clause	NN
18637	3033	27	.	.	.
18637	3034	1	Even	even	RB
18637	3034	2	as	as	IN
18637	3034	3	applied	apply	VBN
18637	3034	4	to	to	IN
18637	3034	5	pantomime	pantomime	JJ
18637	3034	6	dramatization	dramatization	NN
18637	3034	7	by	by	IN
18637	3034	8	means	mean	NNS
18637	3034	9	of	of	IN
18637	3034	10	silent	silent	JJ
18637	3034	11	motion	motion	NN
18637	3034	12	pictures	picture	NNS
18637	3034	13	,	,	,
18637	3034	14	the	the	DT
18637	3034	15	act	act	NN
18637	3034	16	was	be	VBD
18637	3034	17	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	3034	18	against	against	IN
18637	3034	19	the	the	DT
18637	3034	20	objection	objection	NN
18637	3034	21	that	that	WDT
18637	3034	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3034	23	extended	extend	VBD
18637	3034	24	the	the	DT
18637	3034	25	copyright	copyright	NN
18637	3034	26	to	to	IN
18637	3034	27	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	3034	28	rather	rather	RB
18637	3034	29	than	than	IN
18637	3034	30	to	to	IN
18637	3034	31	the	the	DT
18637	3034	32	words	word	NNS
18637	3034	33	in	in	IN
18637	3034	34	which	which	WDT
18637	3034	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3034	36	were	be	VBD
18637	3034	37	clothed	clothe	VBN
18637	3034	38	.	.	.
18637	3035	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3035	2	1176	1176	CD
18637	3035	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3035	4	But	but	CC
18637	3035	5	the	the	DT
18637	3035	6	copyright	copyright	NN
18637	3035	7	of	of	IN
18637	3035	8	the	the	DT
18637	3035	9	description	description	NN
18637	3035	10	of	of	IN
18637	3035	11	an	an	DT
18637	3035	12	art	art	NN
18637	3035	13	in	in	IN
18637	3035	14	a	a	DT
18637	3035	15	book	book	NN
18637	3035	16	was	be	VBD
18637	3035	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	3035	18	not	not	RB
18637	3035	19	to	to	TO
18637	3035	20	lay	lay	VB
18637	3035	21	a	a	DT
18637	3035	22	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	3035	23	for	for	IN
18637	3035	24	an	an	DT
18637	3035	25	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3035	26	claim	claim	NN
18637	3035	27	to	to	IN
18637	3035	28	the	the	DT
18637	3035	29	art	art	NN
18637	3035	30	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3035	31	.	.	.
18637	3036	1	The	the	DT
18637	3036	2	latter	latter	NN
18637	3036	3	can	can	MD
18637	3036	4	be	be	VB
18637	3036	5	protected	protect	VBN
18637	3036	6	,	,	,
18637	3036	7	if	if	IN
18637	3036	8	at	at	RB
18637	3036	9	all	all	RB
18637	3036	10	,	,	,
18637	3036	11	only	only	RB
18637	3036	12	by	by	IN
18637	3036	13	letters	letter	NNS
18637	3036	14	patent	patent	NN
18637	3036	15	.	.	.
18637	3037	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3037	2	1177	1177	CD
18637	3037	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3037	4	Since	since	IN
18637	3037	5	copyright	copyright	NN
18637	3037	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	3037	7	a	a	DT
18637	3037	8	species	species	NN
18637	3037	9	of	of	IN
18637	3037	10	property	property	NN
18637	3037	11	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	3037	12	from	from	IN
18637	3037	13	the	the	DT
18637	3037	14	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	3037	15	of	of	IN
18637	3037	16	the	the	DT
18637	3037	17	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	3037	18	used	use	VBN
18637	3037	19	in	in	IN
18637	3037	20	making	make	VBG
18637	3037	21	copies	copy	NNS
18637	3037	22	of	of	IN
18637	3037	23	the	the	DT
18637	3037	24	matter	matter	NN
18637	3037	25	copyrighted	copyright	VBN
18637	3037	26	,	,	,
18637	3037	27	the	the	DT
18637	3037	28	sale	sale	NN
18637	3037	29	of	of	IN
18637	3037	30	a	a	DT
18637	3037	31	copperplate	copperplate	NN
18637	3037	32	under	under	IN
18637	3037	33	execution	execution	NN
18637	3037	34	did	do	VBD
18637	3037	35	not	not	RB
18637	3037	36	pass	pass	VB
18637	3037	37	any	any	DT
18637	3037	38	right	right	NN
18637	3037	39	to	to	TO
18637	3037	40	print	print	VB
18637	3037	41	and	and	CC
18637	3037	42	publish	publish	VB
18637	3037	43	the	the	DT
18637	3037	44	map	map	NN
18637	3037	45	which	which	WDT
18637	3037	46	the	the	DT
18637	3037	47	copperplate	copperplate	NN
18637	3037	48	was	be	VBD
18637	3037	49	designed	design	VBN
18637	3037	50	to	to	TO
18637	3037	51	produce	produce	VB
18637	3037	52	.	.	.
18637	3038	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3038	2	1178	1178	CD
18637	3038	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3038	4	A	a	DT
18637	3038	5	patent	patent	NN
18637	3038	6	right	right	NN
18637	3038	7	may	may	MD
18637	3038	8	,	,	,
18637	3038	9	however	however	RB
18637	3038	10	,	,	,
18637	3038	11	be	be	VB
18637	3038	12	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	3038	13	,	,	,
18637	3038	14	by	by	IN
18637	3038	15	bill	bill	NN
18637	3038	16	in	in	IN
18637	3038	17	equity	equity	NN
18637	3038	18	,	,	,
18637	3038	19	to	to	IN
18637	3038	20	payment	payment	NN
18637	3038	21	of	of	IN
18637	3038	22	a	a	DT
18637	3038	23	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	3038	24	debt	debt	NN
18637	3038	25	of	of	IN
18637	3038	26	the	the	DT
18637	3038	27	patentee	patentee	NN
18637	3038	28	.	.	.
18637	3039	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3039	2	1179	1179	CD
18637	3039	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3039	4	POWER	power	NN
18637	3039	5	OF	of	IN
18637	3039	6	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	3039	7	OVER	over	IN
18637	3039	8	PATENT	patent	DT
18637	3039	9	RIGHTS	right	NNS
18637	3039	10	Letters	letter	NNS
18637	3039	11	patent	patent	VBP
18637	3039	12	for	for	IN
18637	3039	13	a	a	DT
18637	3039	14	new	new	JJ
18637	3039	15	invention	invention	NN
18637	3039	16	or	or	CC
18637	3039	17	discovery	discovery	NN
18637	3039	18	in	in	IN
18637	3039	19	the	the	DT
18637	3039	20	arts	art	NNS
18637	3039	21	confer	confer	VBP
18637	3039	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	3039	23	the	the	DT
18637	3039	24	patentee	patentee	NN
18637	3039	25	an	an	DT
18637	3039	26	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3039	27	property	property	NN
18637	3039	28	in	in	IN
18637	3039	29	the	the	DT
18637	3039	30	patented	patented	JJ
18637	3039	31	invention	invention	NN
18637	3039	32	which	which	WDT
18637	3039	33	can	can	MD
18637	3039	34	not	not	RB
18637	3039	35	be	be	VB
18637	3039	36	appropriated	appropriate	VBN
18637	3039	37	or	or	CC
18637	3039	38	used	use	VBN
18637	3039	39	by	by	IN
18637	3039	40	the	the	DT
18637	3039	41	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3039	42	without	without	IN
18637	3039	43	just	just	RB
18637	3039	44	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	3039	45	.	.	.
18637	3040	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3040	2	1180	1180	CD
18637	3040	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3040	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3040	5	may	may	MD
18637	3040	6	,	,	,
18637	3040	7	however	however	RB
18637	3040	8	,	,	,
18637	3040	9	modify	modify	VB
18637	3040	10	rights	right	NNS
18637	3040	11	under	under	IN
18637	3040	12	an	an	DT
18637	3040	13	existing	exist	VBG
18637	3040	14	patent	patent	NN
18637	3040	15	,	,	,
18637	3040	16	provided	provide	VBN
18637	3040	17	vested	vested	JJ
18637	3040	18	property	property	NN
18637	3040	19	rights	right	NNS
18637	3040	20	are	be	VBP
18637	3040	21	not	not	RB
18637	3040	22	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	3040	23	impaired,[1181	impaired,[1181	NNP
18637	3040	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3040	25	but	but	CC
18637	3040	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3040	27	does	do	VBZ
18637	3040	28	not	not	RB
18637	3040	29	follow	follow	VB
18637	3040	30	that	that	IN
18637	3040	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3040	32	may	may	MD
18637	3040	33	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	3040	34	an	an	DT
18637	3040	35	inventor	inventor	NN
18637	3040	36	to	to	TO
18637	3040	37	recall	recall	VB
18637	3040	38	rights	right	NNS
18637	3040	39	which	which	WDT
18637	3040	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3040	41	has	have	VBZ
18637	3040	42	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3040	43	to	to	IN
18637	3040	44	others	other	NNS
18637	3040	45	or	or	CC
18637	3040	46	reinvest	reinvest	VB
18637	3040	47	in	in	IN
18637	3040	48	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3040	49	rights	right	NNS
18637	3040	50	of	of	IN
18637	3040	51	property	property	NN
18637	3040	52	which	which	WDT
18637	3040	53	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3040	54	had	have	VBD
18637	3040	55	previously	previously	RB
18637	3040	56	conveyed	convey	VBN
18637	3040	57	for	for	IN
18637	3040	58	a	a	DT
18637	3040	59	valuable	valuable	JJ
18637	3040	60	and	and	CC
18637	3040	61	fair	fair	JJ
18637	3040	62	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	3040	63	.	.	.
18637	3041	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3041	2	1182	1182	CD
18637	3041	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3041	4	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	3041	5	,	,	,
18637	3041	6	the	the	DT
18637	3041	7	rights	right	NNS
18637	3041	8	which	which	WDT
18637	3041	9	the	the	DT
18637	3041	10	present	present	JJ
18637	3041	11	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3041	12	confer	confer	VBP
18637	3041	13	are	be	VBP
18637	3041	14	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3041	15	to	to	IN
18637	3041	16	the	the	DT
18637	3041	17	Anti	Anti	NNP
18637	3041	18	-	-	NNP
18637	3041	19	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	3041	20	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	3041	21	,	,	,
18637	3041	22	though	though	IN
18637	3041	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3041	24	can	can	MD
18637	3041	25	be	be	VB
18637	3041	26	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	3041	27	said	say	VBN
18637	3041	28	that	that	IN
18637	3041	29	the	the	DT
18637	3041	30	cases	case	NNS
18637	3041	31	in	in	IN
18637	3041	32	which	which	WDT
18637	3041	33	the	the	DT
18637	3041	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3041	35	has	have	VBZ
18637	3041	36	endeavored	endeavor	VBN
18637	3041	37	to	to	TO
18637	3041	38	draw	draw	VB
18637	3041	39	the	the	DT
18637	3041	40	line	line	NN
18637	3041	41	between	between	IN
18637	3041	42	the	the	DT
18637	3041	43	rights	right	NNS
18637	3041	44	claimable	claimable	JJ
18637	3041	45	by	by	IN
18637	3041	46	patentees	patentee	NNS
18637	3041	47	and	and	CC
18637	3041	48	the	the	DT
18637	3041	49	kind	kind	NN
18637	3041	50	of	of	IN
18637	3041	51	monopolistic	monopolistic	JJ
18637	3041	52	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3041	53	which	which	WDT
18637	3041	54	are	be	VBP
18637	3041	55	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	3041	56	by	by	IN
18637	3041	57	those	those	DT
18637	3041	58	acts	act	NNS
18637	3041	59	exhibit	exhibit	VB
18637	3041	60	entire	entire	JJ
18637	3041	61	consistency	consistency	NN
18637	3041	62	in	in	IN
18637	3041	63	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3041	64	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	3041	65	.	.	.
18637	3042	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3042	2	1183	1183	CD
18637	3042	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3042	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	3042	5	POWER	power	NN
18637	3042	6	AFFECTING	affect	VBG
18637	3042	7	PATENTS	patent	NNS
18637	3042	8	AND	and	CC
18637	3042	9	COPYRIGHTS	COPYRIGHTS	NNP
18637	3042	10	Nor	nor	CC
18637	3042	11	do	do	VBP
18637	3042	12	the	the	DT
18637	3042	13	patent	patent	NN
18637	3042	14	laws	law	NNS
18637	3042	15	displace	displace	VB
18637	3042	16	the	the	DT
18637	3042	17	police	police	NN
18637	3042	18	or	or	CC
18637	3042	19	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	3042	20	powers	power	NNS
18637	3042	21	of	of	IN
18637	3042	22	the	the	DT
18637	3042	23	States	States	NNP
18637	3042	24	.	.	.
18637	3043	1	Whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	3043	2	rights	right	NNS
18637	3043	3	are	be	VBP
18637	3043	4	secured	secure	VBN
18637	3043	5	to	to	IN
18637	3043	6	inventors	inventor	NNS
18637	3043	7	must	must	MD
18637	3043	8	be	be	VB
18637	3043	9	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
18637	3043	10	in	in	IN
18637	3043	11	subordination	subordination	NN
18637	3043	12	to	to	IN
18637	3043	13	the	the	DT
18637	3043	14	general	general	NNP
18637	3043	15	authority	authority	NNP
18637	3043	16	of	of	IN
18637	3043	17	the	the	DT
18637	3043	18	State	State	NNP
18637	3043	19	over	over	IN
18637	3043	20	all	all	DT
18637	3043	21	property	property	NN
18637	3043	22	within	within	IN
18637	3043	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3043	24	limits	limit	NNS
18637	3043	25	.	.	.
18637	3044	1	A	a	DT
18637	3044	2	statute	statute	NN
18637	3044	3	of	of	IN
18637	3044	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	3044	5	requiring	require	VBG
18637	3044	6	the	the	DT
18637	3044	7	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	3044	8	of	of	IN
18637	3044	9	illuminating	illuminate	VBG
18637	3044	10	oils	oil	NNS
18637	3044	11	which	which	WDT
18637	3044	12	were	be	VBD
18637	3044	13	inflammable	inflammable	JJ
18637	3044	14	at	at	IN
18637	3044	15	less	less	JJR
18637	3044	16	than	than	IN
18637	3044	17	130	130	CD
18637	3044	18	degrees	degree	NNS
18637	3044	19	Fahrenheit	Fahrenheit	NNP
18637	3044	20	,	,	,
18637	3044	21	was	be	VBD
18637	3044	22	held	hold	VBN
18637	3044	23	not	not	RB
18637	3044	24	to	to	TO
18637	3044	25	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	3044	26	with	with	IN
18637	3044	27	any	any	DT
18637	3044	28	right	right	JJ
18637	3044	29	secured	secure	VBN
18637	3044	30	by	by	IN
18637	3044	31	the	the	DT
18637	3044	32	patent	patent	NN
18637	3044	33	laws	law	NNS
18637	3044	34	,	,	,
18637	3044	35	although	although	IN
18637	3044	36	the	the	DT
18637	3044	37	oil	oil	NN
18637	3044	38	for	for	IN
18637	3044	39	which	which	WDT
18637	3044	40	the	the	DT
18637	3044	41	patent	patent	NN
18637	3044	42	was	be	VBD
18637	3044	43	issued	issue	VBN
18637	3044	44	could	could	MD
18637	3044	45	not	not	RB
18637	3044	46	be	be	VB
18637	3044	47	made	make	VBN
18637	3044	48	to	to	TO
18637	3044	49	comply	comply	VB
18637	3044	50	with	with	IN
18637	3044	51	State	State	NNP
18637	3044	52	specifications	specification	NNS
18637	3044	53	.	.	.
18637	3045	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3045	2	1184	1184	CD
18637	3045	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3045	4	In	in	IN
18637	3045	5	the	the	DT
18637	3045	6	absence	absence	NN
18637	3045	7	of	of	IN
18637	3045	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3045	9	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3045	10	,	,	,
18637	3045	11	a	a	DT
18637	3045	12	State	State	NNP
18637	3045	13	may	may	MD
18637	3045	14	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	3045	15	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	3045	16	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	3045	17	for	for	IN
18637	3045	18	the	the	DT
18637	3045	19	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	3045	20	of	of	IN
18637	3045	21	patent	patent	NN
18637	3045	22	rights	right	NNS
18637	3045	23	so	so	IN
18637	3045	24	as	as	IN
18637	3045	25	to	to	TO
18637	3045	26	protect	protect	VB
18637	3045	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3045	28	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	3045	29	from	from	IN
18637	3045	30	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	3045	31	.	.	.
18637	3046	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	3046	2	a	a	DT
18637	3046	3	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	3046	4	of	of	IN
18637	3046	5	State	State	NNP
18637	3046	6	law	law	NN
18637	3046	7	that	that	IN
18637	3046	8	the	the	DT
18637	3046	9	words	word	NNS
18637	3046	10	"	"	``
18637	3046	11	given	give	VBN
18637	3046	12	for	for	IN
18637	3046	13	a	a	DT
18637	3046	14	patent	patent	NN
18637	3046	15	right	right	NN
18637	3046	16	"	"	''
18637	3046	17	appear	appear	VB
18637	3046	18	on	on	IN
18637	3046	19	the	the	DT
18637	3046	20	face	face	NN
18637	3046	21	of	of	IN
18637	3046	22	notes	note	NNS
18637	3046	23	given	give	VBN
18637	3046	24	in	in	IN
18637	3046	25	payment	payment	NN
18637	3046	26	for	for	IN
18637	3046	27	such	such	JJ
18637	3046	28	right	right	NN
18637	3046	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	3046	30	not	not	RB
18637	3046	31	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	3046	32	.	.	.
18637	3047	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3047	2	1185	1185	CD
18637	3047	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3047	4	Royalties	royalty	NNS
18637	3047	5	received	receive	VBN
18637	3047	6	from	from	IN
18637	3047	7	patents	patent	NNS
18637	3047	8	or	or	CC
18637	3047	9	copyrights	copyright	NNS
18637	3047	10	are	be	VBP
18637	3047	11	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3047	12	to	to	IN
18637	3047	13	a	a	DT
18637	3047	14	nondiscriminating	nondiscriminate	VBG
18637	3047	15	State	State	NNP
18637	3047	16	income	income	NN
18637	3047	17	tax	tax	NN
18637	3047	18	,	,	,
18637	3047	19	a	a	DT
18637	3047	20	holding	holding	NN
18637	3047	21	to	to	IN
18637	3047	22	the	the	DT
18637	3047	23	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	3047	24	in	in	IN
18637	3047	25	1928	1928	CD
18637	3047	26	having	have	VBG
18637	3047	27	been	be	VBN
18637	3047	28	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	3047	29	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	3047	30	.	.	.
18637	3048	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3048	2	1186	1186	CD
18637	3048	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3048	4	TRADE	TRADE	NNP
18637	3048	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	3048	6	MARKS	marks	NN
18637	3048	7	AND	and	CC
18637	3048	8	ADVERTISEMENTS	advertisement	NNS
18637	3048	9	In	in	IN
18637	3048	10	the	the	DT
18637	3048	11	famous	famous	JJ
18637	3048	12	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	3048	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	3048	14	Mark	Mark	NNP
18637	3048	15	Cases,[1187	cases,[1187	CD
18637	3048	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3048	17	decided	decide	VBN
18637	3048	18	in	in	IN
18637	3048	19	1879	1879	CD
18637	3048	20	,	,	,
18637	3048	21	the	the	DT
18637	3048	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3048	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3048	24	held	hold	VBD
18637	3048	25	void	void	JJ
18637	3048	26	acts	act	NNS
18637	3048	27	of	of	IN
18637	3048	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3048	29	which	which	WDT
18637	3048	30	,	,	,
18637	3048	31	in	in	IN
18637	3048	32	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	3048	33	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	3048	34	upon	upon	IN
18637	3048	35	this	this	DT
18637	3048	36	clause	clause	NN
18637	3048	37	,	,	,
18637	3048	38	extended	extend	VBD
18637	3048	39	the	the	DT
18637	3048	40	protection	protection	NN
18637	3048	41	of	of	IN
18637	3048	42	the	the	DT
18637	3048	43	law	law	NN
18637	3048	44	to	to	IN
18637	3048	45	trade	trade	NN
18637	3048	46	-	-	HYPH
18637	3048	47	marks	mark	NNS
18637	3048	48	registered	register	VBN
18637	3048	49	in	in	IN
18637	3048	50	the	the	DT
18637	3048	51	Patent	Patent	NNP
18637	3048	52	Office	Office	NNP
18637	3048	53	.	.	.
18637	3049	1	"	"	``
18637	3049	2	The	the	DT
18637	3049	3	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	3049	4	trade	trade	NN
18637	3049	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	3049	6	mark	mark	NN
18637	3049	7	"	"	''
18637	3049	8	said	say	VBD
18637	3049	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3049	10	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	3049	11	for	for	IN
18637	3049	12	the	the	DT
18637	3049	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3049	14	,	,	,
18637	3049	15	"	"	''
18637	3049	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	3049	17	no	no	DT
18637	3049	18	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3049	19	relation	relation	NN
18637	3049	20	to	to	IN
18637	3049	21	invention	invention	NN
18637	3049	22	or	or	CC
18637	3049	23	discovery	discovery	NN
18637	3049	24	"	"	''
18637	3049	25	;	;	:
18637	3049	26	nor	nor	CC
18637	3049	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	3049	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3049	29	to	to	TO
18637	3049	30	be	be	VB
18637	3049	31	classified	classify	VBN
18637	3049	32	"	"	''
18637	3049	33	under	under	IN
18637	3049	34	the	the	DT
18637	3049	35	head	head	NN
18637	3049	36	of	of	IN
18637	3049	37	writings	writing	NNS
18637	3049	38	of	of	IN
18637	3049	39	authors	author	NNS
18637	3049	40	.	.	.
18637	3049	41	"	"	''
18637	3050	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3050	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	3050	3	not	not	RB
18637	3050	4	"	"	``
18637	3050	5	depend	depend	VB
18637	3050	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	3050	7	novelty	novelty	NN
18637	3050	8	,	,	,
18637	3050	9	invention	invention	NN
18637	3050	10	,	,	,
18637	3050	11	discovery	discovery	NN
18637	3050	12	,	,	,
18637	3050	13	or	or	CC
18637	3050	14	any	any	DT
18637	3050	15	work	work	NN
18637	3050	16	of	of	IN
18637	3050	17	the	the	DT
18637	3050	18	brain	brain	NN
18637	3050	19	.	.	.
18637	3051	1	"	"	``
18637	3051	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3051	3	1188	1188	CD
18637	3051	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3051	5	Not	not	RB
18637	3051	6	many	many	JJ
18637	3051	7	years	year	NNS
18637	3051	8	later	later	RBR
18637	3051	9	the	the	DT
18637	3051	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3051	11	,	,	,
18637	3051	12	again	again	RB
18637	3051	13	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	3051	14	through	through	IN
18637	3051	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3051	16	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	3051	17	,	,	,
18637	3051	18	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	3051	19	that	that	IN
18637	3051	20	a	a	DT
18637	3051	21	photograph	photograph	NN
18637	3051	22	may	may	MD
18637	3051	23	be	be	VB
18637	3051	24	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	3051	25	copyright,[1189	copyright,[1189	NNP
18637	3051	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3051	27	while	while	IN
18637	3051	28	still	still	RB
18637	3051	29	more	more	RBR
18637	3051	30	recently	recently	RB
18637	3051	31	a	a	DT
18637	3051	32	circus	circus	NN
18637	3051	33	poster	poster	NN
18637	3051	34	was	be	VBD
18637	3051	35	held	hold	VBN
18637	3051	36	to	to	TO
18637	3051	37	be	be	VB
18637	3051	38	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	3051	39	to	to	IN
18637	3051	40	the	the	DT
18637	3051	41	same	same	JJ
18637	3051	42	protection	protection	NN
18637	3051	43	.	.	.
18637	3052	1	In	in	IN
18637	3052	2	answer	answer	NN
18637	3052	3	to	to	IN
18637	3052	4	the	the	DT
18637	3052	5	objection	objection	NN
18637	3052	6	of	of	IN
18637	3052	7	the	the	DT
18637	3052	8	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
18637	3052	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3052	10	that	that	IN
18637	3052	11	a	a	DT
18637	3052	12	lithograph	lithograph	NN
18637	3052	13	which	which	WDT
18637	3052	14	"	"	``
18637	3052	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	3052	16	no	no	DT
18637	3052	17	other	other	JJ
18637	3052	18	use	use	NN
18637	3052	19	than	than	IN
18637	3052	20	that	that	DT
18637	3052	21	of	of	IN
18637	3052	22	a	a	DT
18637	3052	23	mere	mere	JJ
18637	3052	24	advertisement	advertisement	NN
18637	3052	25	*	*	NFP
18637	3052	26	*	*	NFP
18637	3052	27	*	*	NFP
18637	3052	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3052	29	would	would	MD
18637	3052	30	not	not	RB
18637	3052	31	be	be	VB
18637	3052	32	within	within	IN
18637	3052	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3052	34	the	the	DT
18637	3052	35	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	3052	36	of	of	IN
18637	3052	37	the	the	DT
18637	3052	38	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3052	39	,	,	,
18637	3052	40	"	"	''
18637	3052	41	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3052	42	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	3052	43	summoned	summon	VBD
18637	3052	44	forth	forth	RP
18637	3052	45	the	the	DT
18637	3052	46	shades	shade	NNS
18637	3052	47	of	of	IN
18637	3052	48	Velasquez	Velasquez	NNP
18637	3052	49	,	,	,
18637	3052	50	Whistler	Whistler	NNP
18637	3052	51	,	,	,
18637	3052	52	Rembrandt	Rembrandt	NNP
18637	3052	53	,	,	,
18637	3052	54	Ruskin	Ruskin	NNP
18637	3052	55	,	,	,
18637	3052	56	Degas	Degas	NNP
18637	3052	57	,	,	,
18637	3052	58	and	and	CC
18637	3052	59	others	other	NNS
18637	3052	60	in	in	IN
18637	3052	61	support	support	NN
18637	3052	62	of	of	IN
18637	3052	63	the	the	DT
18637	3052	64	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	3052	65	that	that	IN
18637	3052	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3052	67	is	be	VBZ
18637	3052	68	not	not	RB
18637	3052	69	for	for	IN
18637	3052	70	the	the	DT
18637	3052	71	courts	court	NNS
18637	3052	72	to	to	TO
18637	3052	73	attempt	attempt	VB
18637	3052	74	to	to	TO
18637	3052	75	judge	judge	VB
18637	3052	76	the	the	DT
18637	3052	77	worth	worth	NN
18637	3052	78	of	of	IN
18637	3052	79	pictorial	pictorial	JJ
18637	3052	80	illustrations	illustration	NNS
18637	3052	81	outside	outside	IN
18637	3052	82	the	the	DT
18637	3052	83	narrowest	narrow	JJS
18637	3052	84	and	and	CC
18637	3052	85	most	most	RBS
18637	3052	86	obvious	obvious	JJ
18637	3052	87	limits	limit	NNS
18637	3052	88	.	.	.
18637	3053	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3053	2	1190	1190	CD
18637	3053	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3053	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3053	5	9	9	CD
18637	3053	6	.	.	.
18637	3054	1	_	_	NNP
18637	3054	2	The	the	DT
18637	3054	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3054	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	3054	5	have	have	VB
18637	3054	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	3054	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3054	8	*	*	NFP
18637	3054	9	*	*	NFP
18637	3054	10	*	*	NFP
18637	3054	11	To	to	TO
18637	3054	12	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	3054	13	Tribunals	Tribunals	NNP
18637	3054	14	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	3054	15	to	to	IN
18637	3054	16	the	the	DT
18637	3054	17	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	3054	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3054	19	;	;	:
18637	3054	20	_	_	NNP
18637	3054	21	See	See	NNP
18637	3054	22	_	_	NNP
18637	3054	23	article	article	NN
18637	3054	24	III	III	NNP
18637	3054	25	,	,	,
18637	3054	26	p.	p.	NN
18637	3054	27	528	528	CD
18637	3054	28	.	.	.
18637	3055	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3055	2	10	10	CD
18637	3055	3	.	.	.
18637	3056	1	_	_	NNP
18637	3056	2	The	the	DT
18637	3056	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3056	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	3056	5	have	have	VB
18637	3056	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	3056	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3056	8	*	*	NFP
18637	3056	9	*	*	NFP
18637	3056	10	*	*	NFP
18637	3056	11	To	to	TO
18637	3056	12	define	define	VB
18637	3056	13	and	and	CC
18637	3056	14	punish	punish	VB
18637	3056	15	Piracies	Piracies	NNPS
18637	3056	16	and	and	CC
18637	3056	17	Felonies	Felonies	NNPS
18637	3056	18	committed	commit	VBD
18637	3056	19	on	on	IN
18637	3056	20	the	the	DT
18637	3056	21	high	high	JJ
18637	3056	22	Seas	Seas	NNPS
18637	3056	23	,	,	,
18637	3056	24	and	and	CC
18637	3056	25	Offences	offence	NNS
18637	3056	26	against	against	IN
18637	3056	27	the	the	DT
18637	3056	28	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3056	29	of	of	IN
18637	3056	30	Nations	Nations	NNP
18637	3056	31	.	.	.
18637	3057	1	Piracies	Piracies	NNP
18637	3057	2	,	,	,
18637	3057	3	Felonies	Felonies	NNPS
18637	3057	4	,	,	,
18637	3057	5	and	and	CC
18637	3057	6	Offenses	Offenses	NNP
18637	3057	7	Against	against	IN
18637	3057	8	the	the	DT
18637	3057	9	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3057	10	of	of	IN
18637	3057	11	Nations	Nations	NNP
18637	3057	12	ORIGIN	ORIGIN	NNP
18637	3057	13	OF	of	IN
18637	3057	14	THE	the	DT
18637	3057	15	CLAUSE	CLAUSE	NNP
18637	3057	16	"	"	''
18637	3057	17	When	when	WRB
18637	3057	18	the	the	DT
18637	3057	19	United	United	NNP
18637	3057	20	States	States	NNP
18637	3057	21	ceased	cease	VBD
18637	3057	22	to	to	TO
18637	3057	23	be	be	VB
18637	3057	24	a	a	DT
18637	3057	25	part	part	NN
18637	3057	26	of	of	IN
18637	3057	27	the	the	DT
18637	3057	28	British	british	JJ
18637	3057	29	empire	empire	NN
18637	3057	30	,	,	,
18637	3057	31	and	and	CC
18637	3057	32	assumed	assume	VBD
18637	3057	33	the	the	DT
18637	3057	34	character	character	NN
18637	3057	35	of	of	IN
18637	3057	36	an	an	DT
18637	3057	37	independent	independent	JJ
18637	3057	38	nation	nation	NN
18637	3057	39	,	,	,
18637	3057	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3057	41	became	become	VBD
18637	3057	42	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3057	43	to	to	IN
18637	3057	44	that	that	DT
18637	3057	45	system	system	NN
18637	3057	46	of	of	IN
18637	3057	47	rules	rule	NNS
18637	3057	48	which	which	WDT
18637	3057	49	reason	reason	NN
18637	3057	50	,	,	,
18637	3057	51	morality	morality	NN
18637	3057	52	,	,	,
18637	3057	53	and	and	CC
18637	3057	54	custom	custom	NN
18637	3057	55	had	have	VBD
18637	3057	56	established	establish	VBN
18637	3057	57	among	among	IN
18637	3057	58	civilized	civilized	JJ
18637	3057	59	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3057	60	of	of	IN
18637	3057	61	Europe	Europe	NNP
18637	3057	62	,	,	,
18637	3057	63	as	as	IN
18637	3057	64	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3057	65	public	public	JJ
18637	3057	66	law	law	NN
18637	3057	67	.	.	.
18637	3058	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3058	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3058	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3058	4	The	the	DT
18637	3058	5	faithful	faithful	JJ
18637	3058	6	observance	observance	NN
18637	3058	7	of	of	IN
18637	3058	8	this	this	DT
18637	3058	9	law	law	NN
18637	3058	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	3058	11	essential	essential	JJ
18637	3058	12	to	to	IN
18637	3058	13	national	national	JJ
18637	3058	14	character	character	NN
18637	3058	15	,	,	,
18637	3058	16	*	*	NFP
18637	3058	17	*	*	NFP
18637	3058	18	*	*	NFP
18637	3058	19	"	"	''
18637	3058	20	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3058	21	1191	1191	CD
18637	3058	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3058	23	These	these	DT
18637	3058	24	words	word	NNS
18637	3058	25	of	of	IN
18637	3058	26	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
18637	3058	27	Kent	Kent	NNP
18637	3058	28	expressed	express	VBD
18637	3058	29	the	the	DT
18637	3058	30	view	view	NN
18637	3058	31	of	of	IN
18637	3058	32	the	the	DT
18637	3058	33	binding	bind	VBG
18637	3058	34	character	character	NN
18637	3058	35	of	of	IN
18637	3058	36	International	International	NNP
18637	3058	37	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3058	38	which	which	WDT
18637	3058	39	was	be	VBD
18637	3058	40	generally	generally	RB
18637	3058	41	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	3058	42	at	at	IN
18637	3058	43	the	the	DT
18637	3058	44	time	time	NN
18637	3058	45	the	the	DT
18637	3058	46	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3058	47	was	be	VBD
18637	3058	48	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	3058	49	.	.	.
18637	3059	1	During	during	IN
18637	3059	2	the	the	DT
18637	3059	3	Revolutionary	Revolutionary	NNP
18637	3059	4	War	War	NNP
18637	3059	5	,	,	,
18637	3059	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3059	7	took	take	VBD
18637	3059	8	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	3059	9	of	of	IN
18637	3059	10	all	all	DT
18637	3059	11	matters	matter	NNS
18637	3059	12	arising	arise	VBG
18637	3059	13	under	under	IN
18637	3059	14	the	the	DT
18637	3059	15	law	law	NN
18637	3059	16	of	of	IN
18637	3059	17	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3059	18	and	and	CC
18637	3059	19	professed	profess	VBD
18637	3059	20	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	3059	21	to	to	IN
18637	3059	22	that	that	DT
18637	3059	23	law	law	NN
18637	3059	24	.	.	.
18637	3060	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3060	2	1192	1192	CD
18637	3060	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3060	4	Under	under	IN
18637	3060	5	the	the	DT
18637	3060	6	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	3060	7	of	of	IN
18637	3060	8	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	3060	9	,	,	,
18637	3060	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3060	11	was	be	VBD
18637	3060	12	given	give	VBN
18637	3060	13	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3060	14	power	power	NN
18637	3060	15	to	to	TO
18637	3060	16	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	3060	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	3060	18	for	for	IN
18637	3060	19	the	the	DT
18637	3060	20	trial	trial	NN
18637	3060	21	of	of	IN
18637	3060	22	piracies	piracy	NNS
18637	3060	23	and	and	CC
18637	3060	24	felonies	felony	NNS
18637	3060	25	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3060	26	on	on	IN
18637	3060	27	the	the	DT
18637	3060	28	high	high	JJ
18637	3060	29	seas	sea	NNS
18637	3060	30	,	,	,
18637	3060	31	but	but	CC
18637	3060	32	no	no	DT
18637	3060	33	provision	provision	NN
18637	3060	34	was	be	VBD
18637	3060	35	made	make	VBN
18637	3060	36	for	for	IN
18637	3060	37	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	3060	38	with	with	IN
18637	3060	39	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3060	40	against	against	IN
18637	3060	41	the	the	DT
18637	3060	42	law	law	NN
18637	3060	43	of	of	IN
18637	3060	44	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3060	45	.	.	.
18637	3061	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3061	2	1193	1193	CD
18637	3061	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3061	4	The	the	DT
18637	3061	5	draft	draft	NN
18637	3061	6	of	of	IN
18637	3061	7	the	the	DT
18637	3061	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3061	9	submitted	submit	VBD
18637	3061	10	to	to	IN
18637	3061	11	the	the	DT
18637	3061	12	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	3061	13	of	of	IN
18637	3061	14	1787	1787	CD
18637	3061	15	by	by	IN
18637	3061	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3061	17	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	3061	18	of	of	IN
18637	3061	19	Detail	Detail	NNP
18637	3061	20	empowered	empower	VBD
18637	3061	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3061	22	"	"	''
18637	3061	23	to	to	TO
18637	3061	24	declare	declare	VB
18637	3061	25	the	the	DT
18637	3061	26	law	law	NN
18637	3061	27	and	and	CC
18637	3061	28	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	3061	29	of	of	IN
18637	3061	30	piracies	piracy	NNS
18637	3061	31	and	and	CC
18637	3061	32	felonies	felony	NNS
18637	3061	33	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3061	34	on	on	IN
18637	3061	35	the	the	DT
18637	3061	36	high	high	JJ
18637	3061	37	seas	sea	NNS
18637	3061	38	,	,	,
18637	3061	39	and	and	CC
18637	3061	40	the	the	DT
18637	3061	41	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	3061	42	of	of	IN
18637	3061	43	counterfeiting	counterfeit	VBG
18637	3061	44	the	the	DT
18637	3061	45	coin	coin	NN
18637	3061	46	of	of	IN
18637	3061	47	the	the	DT
18637	3061	48	United	United	NNP
18637	3061	49	States	States	NNP
18637	3061	50	,	,	,
18637	3061	51	and	and	CC
18637	3061	52	of	of	IN
18637	3061	53	offences	offence	NNS
18637	3061	54	against	against	IN
18637	3061	55	the	the	DT
18637	3061	56	law	law	NN
18637	3061	57	of	of	IN
18637	3061	58	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3061	59	.	.	.
18637	3062	1	"	"	``
18637	3062	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3062	3	1194	1194	CD
18637	3062	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3062	5	In	in	IN
18637	3062	6	the	the	DT
18637	3062	7	debate	debate	NN
18637	3062	8	on	on	IN
18637	3062	9	the	the	DT
18637	3062	10	floor	floor	NN
18637	3062	11	of	of	IN
18637	3062	12	the	the	DT
18637	3062	13	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	3062	14	the	the	DT
18637	3062	15	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	3062	16	turned	turn	VBD
18637	3062	17	on	on	RP
18637	3062	18	the	the	DT
18637	3062	19	question	question	NN
18637	3062	20	as	as	IN
18637	3062	21	to	to	IN
18637	3062	22	whether	whether	IN
18637	3062	23	the	the	DT
18637	3062	24	terms	term	NNS
18637	3062	25	,	,	,
18637	3062	26	"	"	``
18637	3062	27	felonies	felony	NNS
18637	3062	28	"	"	''
18637	3062	29	and	and	CC
18637	3062	30	the	the	DT
18637	3062	31	"	"	``
18637	3062	32	law	law	NN
18637	3062	33	of	of	IN
18637	3062	34	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3062	35	,	,	,
18637	3062	36	"	"	''
18637	3062	37	were	be	VBD
18637	3062	38	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	3062	39	precise	precise	JJ
18637	3062	40	to	to	TO
18637	3062	41	be	be	VB
18637	3062	42	generally	generally	RB
18637	3062	43	understood	understand	VBN
18637	3062	44	.	.	.
18637	3063	1	The	the	DT
18637	3063	2	view	view	NN
18637	3063	3	that	that	IN
18637	3063	4	these	these	DT
18637	3063	5	terms	term	NNS
18637	3063	6	were	be	VBD
18637	3063	7	often	often	RB
18637	3063	8	so	so	RB
18637	3063	9	vague	vague	JJ
18637	3063	10	and	and	CC
18637	3063	11	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	3063	12	as	as	IN
18637	3063	13	to	to	TO
18637	3063	14	require	require	VB
18637	3063	15	definition	definition	NN
18637	3063	16	eventually	eventually	RB
18637	3063	17	prevailed	prevail	VBN
18637	3063	18	and	and	CC
18637	3063	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3063	20	was	be	VBD
18637	3063	21	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	3063	22	to	to	TO
18637	3063	23	define	define	VB
18637	3063	24	as	as	RB
18637	3063	25	well	well	RB
18637	3063	26	as	as	IN
18637	3063	27	punish	punish	JJ
18637	3063	28	piracies	piracy	NNS
18637	3063	29	,	,	,
18637	3063	30	felonies	felony	NNS
18637	3063	31	and	and	CC
18637	3063	32	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3063	33	against	against	IN
18637	3063	34	the	the	DT
18637	3063	35	law	law	NN
18637	3063	36	of	of	IN
18637	3063	37	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3063	38	.	.	.
18637	3064	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3064	2	1195	1195	CD
18637	3064	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3064	4	DEFINITION	DEFINITION	VBN
18637	3064	5	OF	of	IN
18637	3064	6	OFFENSES	offenses	NN
18637	3064	7	The	the	DT
18637	3064	8	fact	fact	NN
18637	3064	9	that	that	IN
18637	3064	10	the	the	DT
18637	3064	11	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	3064	12	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	3064	13	considered	consider	VBD
18637	3064	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3064	15	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3064	16	to	to	TO
18637	3064	17	give	give	VB
18637	3064	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3064	19	authority	authority	NN
18637	3064	20	to	to	TO
18637	3064	21	define	define	VB
18637	3064	22	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3064	23	against	against	IN
18637	3064	24	the	the	DT
18637	3064	25	law	law	NN
18637	3064	26	of	of	IN
18637	3064	27	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3064	28	does	do	VBZ
18637	3064	29	not	not	RB
18637	3064	30	mean	mean	VB
18637	3064	31	that	that	IN
18637	3064	32	in	in	IN
18637	3064	33	every	every	DT
18637	3064	34	case	case	NN
18637	3064	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3064	36	must	must	MD
18637	3064	37	undertake	undertake	VB
18637	3064	38	to	to	TO
18637	3064	39	codify	codify	VB
18637	3064	40	that	that	DT
18637	3064	41	law	law	NN
18637	3064	42	or	or	CC
18637	3064	43	mark	mark	VB
18637	3064	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3064	45	precise	precise	JJ
18637	3064	46	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	3064	47	before	before	IN
18637	3064	48	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	3064	49	punishments	punishment	NNS
18637	3064	50	for	for	IN
18637	3064	51	infractions	infraction	NNS
18637	3064	52	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	3064	53	.	.	.
18637	3065	1	An	an	DT
18637	3065	2	act	act	NN
18637	3065	3	punishing	punish	VBG
18637	3065	4	"	"	``
18637	3065	5	the	the	DT
18637	3065	6	crime	crime	NN
18637	3065	7	of	of	IN
18637	3065	8	piracy	piracy	NN
18637	3065	9	,	,	,
18637	3065	10	as	as	IN
18637	3065	11	defined	define	VBN
18637	3065	12	by	by	IN
18637	3065	13	the	the	DT
18637	3065	14	law	law	NN
18637	3065	15	of	of	IN
18637	3065	16	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3065	17	"	"	''
18637	3065	18	was	be	VBD
18637	3065	19	held	hold	VBN
18637	3065	20	to	to	TO
18637	3065	21	be	be	VB
18637	3065	22	an	an	DT
18637	3065	23	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	3065	24	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3065	25	of	of	IN
18637	3065	26	the	the	DT
18637	3065	27	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3065	28	authority	authority	NN
18637	3065	29	to	to	TO
18637	3065	30	"	"	``
18637	3065	31	define	define	VB
18637	3065	32	and	and	CC
18637	3065	33	punish	punish	VB
18637	3065	34	"	"	''
18637	3065	35	the	the	DT
18637	3065	36	offense	offense	NN
18637	3065	37	,	,	,
18637	3065	38	since	since	IN
18637	3065	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3065	40	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	3065	41	by	by	IN
18637	3065	42	reference	reference	NN
18637	3065	43	the	the	DT
18637	3065	44	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	3065	45	precise	precise	JJ
18637	3065	46	definition	definition	NN
18637	3065	47	of	of	IN
18637	3065	48	International	International	NNP
18637	3065	49	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3065	50	.	.	.
18637	3066	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3066	2	1196	1196	CD
18637	3066	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3066	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	3066	5	,	,	,
18637	3066	6	in	in	IN
18637	3066	7	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	3066	8	parte	parte	NNP
18637	3066	9	Quirin,[1197	Quirin,[1197	NNP
18637	3066	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3066	11	the	the	DT
18637	3066	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3066	13	found	find	VBD
18637	3066	14	that	that	IN
18637	3066	15	by	by	IN
18637	3066	16	the	the	DT
18637	3066	17	reference	reference	NN
18637	3066	18	in	in	IN
18637	3066	19	the	the	DT
18637	3066	20	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	3066	21	Article	Article	NNP
18637	3066	22	of	of	IN
18637	3066	23	War	War	NNP
18637	3066	24	to	to	TO
18637	3066	25	"	"	''
18637	3066	26	offenders	offender	NNS
18637	3066	27	or	or	CC
18637	3066	28	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3066	29	that	that	WDT
18637	3066	30	*	*	NFP
18637	3066	31	*	*	NFP
18637	3066	32	*	*	NFP
18637	3066	33	by	by	IN
18637	3066	34	the	the	DT
18637	3066	35	law	law	NN
18637	3066	36	of	of	IN
18637	3066	37	war	war	NN
18637	3066	38	may	may	MD
18637	3066	39	be	be	VB
18637	3066	40	triable	triable	JJ
18637	3066	41	by	by	IN
18637	3066	42	such	such	JJ
18637	3066	43	military	military	JJ
18637	3066	44	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	3066	45	*	*	NFP
18637	3066	46	*	*	NFP
18637	3066	47	*	*	NFP
18637	3066	48	,	,	,
18637	3066	49	"	"	``
18637	3066	50	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3066	51	had	have	VBD
18637	3066	52	"	"	``
18637	3066	53	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	3066	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3066	55	authority	authority	NN
18637	3066	56	to	to	TO
18637	3066	57	define	define	VB
18637	3066	58	and	and	CC
18637	3066	59	punish	punish	VB
18637	3066	60	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3066	61	against	against	IN
18637	3066	62	the	the	DT
18637	3066	63	law	law	NN
18637	3066	64	of	of	IN
18637	3066	65	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3066	66	by	by	IN
18637	3066	67	sanctioning	sanction	VBG
18637	3066	68	,	,	,
18637	3066	69	within	within	IN
18637	3066	70	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3066	71	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	3066	72	,	,	,
18637	3066	73	the	the	DT
18637	3066	74	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3066	75	of	of	IN
18637	3066	76	military	military	JJ
18637	3066	77	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	3066	78	to	to	TO
18637	3066	79	try	try	VB
18637	3066	80	persons	person	NNS
18637	3066	81	for	for	IN
18637	3066	82	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3066	83	which	which	WDT
18637	3066	84	,	,	,
18637	3066	85	according	accord	VBG
18637	3066	86	to	to	IN
18637	3066	87	the	the	DT
18637	3066	88	rules	rule	NNS
18637	3066	89	and	and	CC
18637	3066	90	precepts	precept	NNS
18637	3066	91	of	of	IN
18637	3066	92	the	the	DT
18637	3066	93	law	law	NN
18637	3066	94	of	of	IN
18637	3066	95	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3066	96	,	,	,
18637	3066	97	and	and	CC
18637	3066	98	more	more	RBR
18637	3066	99	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	3066	100	the	the	DT
18637	3066	101	law	law	NN
18637	3066	102	of	of	IN
18637	3066	103	war	war	NN
18637	3066	104	,	,	,
18637	3066	105	are	be	VBP
18637	3066	106	cognizable	cognizable	JJ
18637	3066	107	by	by	IN
18637	3066	108	such	such	JJ
18637	3066	109	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	3066	110	.	.	.
18637	3067	1	"	"	``
18637	3067	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3067	3	1198	1198	CD
18637	3067	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3067	5	Where	where	WRB
18637	3067	6	,	,	,
18637	3067	7	conversely	conversely	RB
18637	3067	8	,	,	,
18637	3067	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3067	10	defines	define	VBZ
18637	3067	11	with	with	IN
18637	3067	12	particularity	particularity	NN
18637	3067	13	a	a	DT
18637	3067	14	crime	crime	NN
18637	3067	15	which	which	WDT
18637	3067	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	3067	17	"	"	``
18637	3067	18	an	an	DT
18637	3067	19	offense	offense	NN
18637	3067	20	against	against	IN
18637	3067	21	the	the	DT
18637	3067	22	law	law	NN
18637	3067	23	of	of	IN
18637	3067	24	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3067	25	,	,	,
18637	3067	26	"	"	''
18637	3067	27	the	the	DT
18637	3067	28	law	law	NN
18637	3067	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	3067	30	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3067	31	,	,	,
18637	3067	32	even	even	RB
18637	3067	33	if	if	IN
18637	3067	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3067	35	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	3067	36	no	no	DT
18637	3067	37	recital	recital	JJ
18637	3067	38	disclosing	disclosing	NN
18637	3067	39	that	that	IN
18637	3067	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3067	41	was	be	VBD
18637	3067	42	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	3067	43	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	3067	44	to	to	IN
18637	3067	45	this	this	DT
18637	3067	46	clause	clause	NN
18637	3067	47	.	.	.
18637	3068	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	3068	2	the	the	DT
18637	3068	3	duty	duty	NN
18637	3068	4	which	which	WDT
18637	3068	5	the	the	DT
18637	3068	6	law	law	NN
18637	3068	7	of	of	IN
18637	3068	8	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3068	9	casts	cast	VBZ
18637	3068	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	3068	11	every	every	DT
18637	3068	12	government	government	NN
18637	3068	13	to	to	TO
18637	3068	14	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	3068	15	a	a	DT
18637	3068	16	wrong	wrong	JJ
18637	3068	17	being	be	VBG
18637	3068	18	done	do	VBN
18637	3068	19	within	within	IN
18637	3068	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3068	21	own	own	JJ
18637	3068	22	dominion	dominion	NN
18637	3068	23	to	to	IN
18637	3068	24	another	another	DT
18637	3068	25	nation	nation	NN
18637	3068	26	with	with	IN
18637	3068	27	which	which	WDT
18637	3068	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3068	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	3068	30	at	at	IN
18637	3068	31	peace	peace	NN
18637	3068	32	,	,	,
18637	3068	33	or	or	CC
18637	3068	34	to	to	IN
18637	3068	35	the	the	DT
18637	3068	36	people	people	NNS
18637	3068	37	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	3068	38	,	,	,
18637	3068	39	was	be	VBD
18637	3068	40	found	find	VBN
18637	3068	41	to	to	TO
18637	3068	42	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	3068	43	a	a	DT
18637	3068	44	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	3068	45	justification	justification	NN
18637	3068	46	for	for	IN
18637	3068	47	the	the	DT
18637	3068	48	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	3068	49	of	of	IN
18637	3068	50	the	the	DT
18637	3068	51	counterfeiting	counterfeiting	NN
18637	3068	52	within	within	IN
18637	3068	53	the	the	DT
18637	3068	54	United	United	NNP
18637	3068	55	States	States	NNP
18637	3068	56	,	,	,
18637	3068	57	of	of	IN
18637	3068	58	notes	note	NNS
18637	3068	59	,	,	,
18637	3068	60	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	3068	61	and	and	CC
18637	3068	62	other	other	JJ
18637	3068	63	securities	security	NNS
18637	3068	64	of	of	IN
18637	3068	65	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3068	66	governments	government	NNS
18637	3068	67	.	.	.
18637	3069	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3069	2	1199	1199	CD
18637	3069	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3069	4	EXTRATERRITORIAL	extraterritorial	NN
18637	3069	5	REACH	REACH	NNS
18637	3069	6	OF	of	IN
18637	3069	7	THE	the	DT
18637	3069	8	POWER	power	NN
18637	3069	9	Since	since	IN
18637	3069	10	this	this	DT
18637	3069	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	3069	12	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	3069	13	the	the	DT
18637	3069	14	only	only	JJ
18637	3069	15	specific	specific	JJ
18637	3069	16	grant	grant	NN
18637	3069	17	of	of	IN
18637	3069	18	power	power	NN
18637	3069	19	to	to	TO
18637	3069	20	be	be	VB
18637	3069	21	found	find	VBN
18637	3069	22	in	in	IN
18637	3069	23	the	the	DT
18637	3069	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3069	25	for	for	IN
18637	3069	26	the	the	DT
18637	3069	27	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	3069	28	of	of	IN
18637	3069	29	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3069	30	outside	outside	IN
18637	3069	31	the	the	DT
18637	3069	32	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	3069	33	limits	limit	NNS
18637	3069	34	of	of	IN
18637	3069	35	the	the	DT
18637	3069	36	United	United	NNP
18637	3069	37	States	States	NNP
18637	3069	38	,	,	,
18637	3069	39	a	a	DT
18637	3069	40	lower	low	JJR
18637	3069	41	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3069	42	court	court	NN
18637	3069	43	held	hold	VBN
18637	3069	44	in	in	IN
18637	3069	45	1932[1200	1932[1200	NNP
18637	3069	46	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3069	47	that	that	IN
18637	3069	48	the	the	DT
18637	3069	49	general	general	JJ
18637	3069	50	grant	grant	NN
18637	3069	51	of	of	IN
18637	3069	52	admiralty	admiralty	NNP
18637	3069	53	and	and	CC
18637	3069	54	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	3069	55	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3069	56	by	by	IN
18637	3069	57	article	article	NN
18637	3069	58	III	III	NNP
18637	3069	59	,	,	,
18637	3069	60	section	section	NN
18637	3069	61	2	2	CD
18637	3069	62	,	,	,
18637	3069	63	could	could	MD
18637	3069	64	not	not	RB
18637	3069	65	be	be	VB
18637	3069	66	construed	construe	VBN
18637	3069	67	as	as	IN
18637	3069	68	extending	extend	VBG
18637	3069	69	either	either	CC
18637	3069	70	the	the	DT
18637	3069	71	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3069	72	or	or	CC
18637	3069	73	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3069	74	power	power	NN
18637	3069	75	of	of	IN
18637	3069	76	the	the	DT
18637	3069	77	United	United	NNP
18637	3069	78	States	States	NNP
18637	3069	79	to	to	TO
18637	3069	80	cover	cover	VB
18637	3069	81	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3069	82	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3069	83	on	on	IN
18637	3069	84	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	3069	85	outside	outside	IN
18637	3069	86	the	the	DT
18637	3069	87	United	United	NNP
18637	3069	88	States	States	NNP
18637	3069	89	but	but	CC
18637	3069	90	not	not	RB
18637	3069	91	on	on	IN
18637	3069	92	the	the	DT
18637	3069	93	high	high	JJ
18637	3069	94	seas	sea	NNS
18637	3069	95	.	.	.
18637	3070	1	Reversing	reverse	VBG
18637	3070	2	that	that	DT
18637	3070	3	decision	decision	NN
18637	3070	4	,	,	,
18637	3070	5	the	the	DT
18637	3070	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3070	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3070	8	held	hold	VBD
18637	3070	9	that	that	IN
18637	3070	10	this	this	DT
18637	3070	11	provision	provision	NN
18637	3070	12	"	"	``
18637	3070	13	can	can	MD
18637	3070	14	not	not	RB
18637	3070	15	be	be	VB
18637	3070	16	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	3070	17	to	to	TO
18637	3070	18	be	be	VB
18637	3070	19	a	a	DT
18637	3070	20	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	3070	21	on	on	IN
18637	3070	22	the	the	DT
18637	3070	23	powers	power	NNS
18637	3070	24	,	,	,
18637	3070	25	either	either	CC
18637	3070	26	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3070	27	or	or	CC
18637	3070	28	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3070	29	,	,	,
18637	3070	30	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	3070	31	on	on	IN
18637	3070	32	the	the	DT
18637	3070	33	National	National	NNP
18637	3070	34	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3070	35	by	by	IN
18637	3070	36	article	article	NN
18637	3070	37	III	III	NNP
18637	3070	38	,	,	,
18637	3070	39	§	â§	NN
18637	3070	40	2	2	CD
18637	3070	41	.	.	.
18637	3071	1	The	the	DT
18637	3071	2	two	two	CD
18637	3071	3	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	3071	4	are	be	VBP
18637	3071	5	the	the	DT
18637	3071	6	result	result	NN
18637	3071	7	of	of	IN
18637	3071	8	separate	separate	JJ
18637	3071	9	steps	step	NNS
18637	3071	10	independently	independently	RB
18637	3071	11	taken	take	VBN
18637	3071	12	in	in	IN
18637	3071	13	the	the	DT
18637	3071	14	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	3071	15	,	,	,
18637	3071	16	by	by	IN
18637	3071	17	which	which	WDT
18637	3071	18	the	the	DT
18637	3071	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3071	20	in	in	IN
18637	3071	21	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	3071	22	,	,	,
18637	3071	23	previously	previously	RB
18637	3071	24	divided	divide	VBN
18637	3071	25	between	between	IN
18637	3071	26	the	the	DT
18637	3071	27	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	3071	28	and	and	CC
18637	3071	29	the	the	DT
18637	3071	30	States	States	NNP
18637	3071	31	,	,	,
18637	3071	32	was	be	VBD
18637	3071	33	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	3071	34	to	to	IN
18637	3071	35	the	the	DT
18637	3071	36	National	National	NNP
18637	3071	37	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3071	38	.	.	.
18637	3072	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3072	2	would	would	MD
18637	3072	3	be	be	VB
18637	3072	4	a	a	DT
18637	3072	5	surprising	surprising	JJ
18637	3072	6	result	result	NN
18637	3072	7	,	,	,
18637	3072	8	and	and	CC
18637	3072	9	one	one	CD
18637	3072	10	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	3072	11	not	not	RB
18637	3072	12	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
18637	3072	13	by	by	IN
18637	3072	14	the	the	DT
18637	3072	15	framers	framer	NNS
18637	3072	16	or	or	CC
18637	3072	17	justified	justify	VBN
18637	3072	18	by	by	IN
18637	3072	19	principles	principle	NNS
18637	3072	20	which	which	WDT
18637	3072	21	ought	ought	MD
18637	3072	22	to	to	TO
18637	3072	23	govern	govern	VB
18637	3072	24	the	the	DT
18637	3072	25	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	3072	26	of	of	IN
18637	3072	27	a	a	DT
18637	3072	28	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	3072	29	devoted	devote	VBN
18637	3072	30	to	to	IN
18637	3072	31	the	the	DT
18637	3072	32	redistribution	redistribution	NN
18637	3072	33	of	of	IN
18637	3072	34	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	3072	35	powers	power	NNS
18637	3072	36	,	,	,
18637	3072	37	if	if	IN
18637	3072	38	part	part	NN
18637	3072	39	of	of	IN
18637	3072	40	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3072	41	were	be	VBD
18637	3072	42	lost	lose	VBN
18637	3072	43	in	in	IN
18637	3072	44	the	the	DT
18637	3072	45	process	process	NN
18637	3072	46	of	of	IN
18637	3072	47	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	3072	48	.	.	.
18637	3073	1	To	to	TO
18637	3073	2	construe	construe	VB
18637	3073	3	the	the	DT
18637	3073	4	one	one	CD
18637	3073	5	clause	clause	NN
18637	3073	6	as	as	IN
18637	3073	7	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	3073	8	rather	rather	RB
18637	3073	9	than	than	IN
18637	3073	10	supplementing	supplement	VBG
18637	3073	11	the	the	DT
18637	3073	12	other	other	JJ
18637	3073	13	would	would	MD
18637	3073	14	be	be	VB
18637	3073	15	to	to	TO
18637	3073	16	ignore	ignore	VB
18637	3073	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3073	18	history	history	NN
18637	3073	19	,	,	,
18637	3073	20	and	and	CC
18637	3073	21	without	without	IN
18637	3073	22	effecting	effect	VBG
18637	3073	23	any	any	DT
18637	3073	24	discernible	discernible	JJ
18637	3073	25	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3073	26	of	of	IN
18637	3073	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3073	28	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	3073	29	,	,	,
18637	3073	30	to	to	TO
18637	3073	31	deny	deny	VB
18637	3073	32	to	to	IN
18637	3073	33	both	both	CC
18637	3073	34	the	the	DT
18637	3073	35	States	States	NNPS
18637	3073	36	and	and	CC
18637	3073	37	the	the	DT
18637	3073	38	National	National	NNP
18637	3073	39	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3073	40	powers	power	NNS
18637	3073	41	which	which	WDT
18637	3073	42	were	be	VBD
18637	3073	43	common	common	JJ
18637	3073	44	attributes	attribute	NNS
18637	3073	45	of	of	IN
18637	3073	46	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	3073	47	before	before	IN
18637	3073	48	the	the	DT
18637	3073	49	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	3073	50	of	of	IN
18637	3073	51	the	the	DT
18637	3073	52	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3073	53	.	.	.
18637	3074	1	The	the	DT
18637	3074	2	result	result	NN
18637	3074	3	would	would	MD
18637	3074	4	be	be	VB
18637	3074	5	to	to	TO
18637	3074	6	deny	deny	VB
18637	3074	7	to	to	IN
18637	3074	8	both	both	DT
18637	3074	9	the	the	DT
18637	3074	10	power	power	NN
18637	3074	11	to	to	TO
18637	3074	12	define	define	VB
18637	3074	13	and	and	CC
18637	3074	14	punish	punish	VB
18637	3074	15	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	3074	16	of	of	IN
18637	3074	17	less	less	JJR
18637	3074	18	gravity	gravity	NN
18637	3074	19	than	than	IN
18637	3074	20	felonies	felony	NNS
18637	3074	21	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3074	22	on	on	IN
18637	3074	23	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	3074	24	of	of	IN
18637	3074	25	the	the	DT
18637	3074	26	United	United	NNP
18637	3074	27	States	States	NNP
18637	3074	28	while	while	IN
18637	3074	29	on	on	IN
18637	3074	30	the	the	DT
18637	3074	31	high	high	JJ
18637	3074	32	seas	sea	NNS
18637	3074	33	,	,	,
18637	3074	34	and	and	CC
18637	3074	35	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	3074	36	of	of	IN
18637	3074	37	every	every	DT
18637	3074	38	grade	grade	NN
18637	3074	39	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3074	40	on	on	IN
18637	3074	41	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3074	42	while	while	IN
18637	3074	43	in	in	IN
18637	3074	44	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3074	45	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	3074	46	waters	water	NNS
18637	3074	47	.	.	.
18637	3075	1	"	"	``
18637	3075	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3075	3	1201	1201	CD
18637	3075	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3075	5	Within	within	IN
18637	3075	6	the	the	DT
18637	3075	7	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	3075	8	of	of	IN
18637	3075	9	this	this	DT
18637	3075	10	section	section	NN
18637	3075	11	an	an	DT
18637	3075	12	offense	offense	NN
18637	3075	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	3075	14	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3075	15	on	on	IN
18637	3075	16	the	the	DT
18637	3075	17	high	high	JJ
18637	3075	18	seas	sea	NNS
18637	3075	19	even	even	RB
18637	3075	20	where	where	WRB
18637	3075	21	the	the	DT
18637	3075	22	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	3075	23	on	on	IN
18637	3075	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3075	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3075	26	occurs	occur	VBZ
18637	3075	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	3075	28	lying	lie	VBG
18637	3075	29	at	at	IN
18637	3075	30	anchor	anchor	NN
18637	3075	31	on	on	IN
18637	3075	32	the	the	DT
18637	3075	33	road	road	NN
18637	3075	34	in	in	IN
18637	3075	35	the	the	DT
18637	3075	36	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	3075	37	waters	water	NNS
18637	3075	38	of	of	IN
18637	3075	39	another	another	DT
18637	3075	40	country	country	NN
18637	3075	41	.	.	.
18637	3076	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3076	2	1202	1202	CD
18637	3076	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3076	4	Clauses	Clauses	NNP
18637	3076	5	11	11	CD
18637	3076	6	,	,	,
18637	3076	7	12	12	CD
18637	3076	8	,	,	,
18637	3076	9	13	13	CD
18637	3076	10	,	,	,
18637	3076	11	and	and	CC
18637	3076	12	14	14	CD
18637	3076	13	.	.	.
18637	3077	1	_	_	NNP
18637	3077	2	The	the	DT
18637	3077	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3077	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	3077	5	have	have	VB
18637	3077	6	power	power	NN
18637	3077	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3077	8	*	*	NFP
18637	3077	9	*	*	NFP
18637	3077	10	*	*	NFP
18637	3077	11	:	:	:
18637	3077	12	To	to	TO
18637	3077	13	declare	declare	VB
18637	3077	14	War	war	NN
18637	3077	15	,	,	,
18637	3077	16	grant	grant	VB
18637	3077	17	Letters	letter	NNS
18637	3077	18	of	of	IN
18637	3077	19	Marque	Marque	NNP
18637	3077	20	and	and	CC
18637	3077	21	Reprisal	Reprisal	NNP
18637	3077	22	,	,	,
18637	3077	23	and	and	CC
18637	3077	24	make	make	VB
18637	3077	25	Rules	rule	NNS
18637	3077	26	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	3077	27	Captures	capture	NNS
18637	3077	28	on	on	IN
18637	3077	29	Land	Land	NNP
18637	3077	30	and	and	CC
18637	3077	31	Water	Water	NNP
18637	3077	32	.	.	.
18637	3078	1	To	to	TO
18637	3078	2	raise	raise	VB
18637	3078	3	and	and	CC
18637	3078	4	support	support	VB
18637	3078	5	Armies	army	NNS
18637	3078	6	,	,	,
18637	3078	7	but	but	CC
18637	3078	8	no	no	DT
18637	3078	9	Appropriation	Appropriation	NNP
18637	3078	10	of	of	IN
18637	3078	11	Money	Money	NNP
18637	3078	12	to	to	IN
18637	3078	13	that	that	DT
18637	3078	14	Use	Use	NNP
18637	3078	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	3078	16	be	be	VB
18637	3078	17	for	for	IN
18637	3078	18	a	a	DT
18637	3078	19	longer	long	JJR
18637	3078	20	Term	term	NN
18637	3078	21	than	than	IN
18637	3078	22	two	two	CD
18637	3078	23	Years	year	NNS
18637	3078	24	.	.	.
18637	3079	1	To	to	TO
18637	3079	2	provide	provide	VB
18637	3079	3	and	and	CC
18637	3079	4	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	3079	5	a	a	DT
18637	3079	6	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	3079	7	.	.	.
18637	3080	1	To	to	TO
18637	3080	2	make	make	VB
18637	3080	3	Rules	rule	NNS
18637	3080	4	for	for	IN
18637	3080	5	the	the	DT
18637	3080	6	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3080	7	and	and	CC
18637	3080	8	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	3080	9	of	of	IN
18637	3080	10	the	the	DT
18637	3080	11	land	land	NN
18637	3080	12	and	and	CC
18637	3080	13	naval	naval	JJ
18637	3080	14	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	3080	15	.	.	.
18637	3081	1	The	the	DT
18637	3081	2	War	War	NNP
18637	3081	3	Power	Power	NNP
18637	3081	4	SOURCE	SOURCE	NNP
18637	3081	5	AND	and	CC
18637	3081	6	SCOPE	SCOPE	NNP
18637	3081	7	Three	three	CD
18637	3081	8	different	different	JJ
18637	3081	9	views	view	NNS
18637	3081	10	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	3081	11	the	the	DT
18637	3081	12	source	source	NN
18637	3081	13	of	of	IN
18637	3081	14	the	the	DT
18637	3081	15	war	war	NN
18637	3081	16	power	power	NN
18637	3081	17	found	find	VBD
18637	3081	18	expression	expression	NN
18637	3081	19	in	in	IN
18637	3081	20	the	the	DT
18637	3081	21	early	early	JJ
18637	3081	22	years	year	NNS
18637	3081	23	of	of	IN
18637	3081	24	the	the	DT
18637	3081	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3081	26	and	and	CC
18637	3081	27	continued	continue	VBD
18637	3081	28	to	to	IN
18637	3081	29	vie	vie	NNP
18637	3081	30	for	for	IN
18637	3081	31	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	3081	32	for	for	IN
18637	3081	33	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	3081	34	a	a	DT
18637	3081	35	century	century	NN
18637	3081	36	and	and	CC
18637	3081	37	a	a	DT
18637	3081	38	half	half	NN
18637	3081	39	.	.	.
18637	3082	1	Writing	write	VBG
18637	3082	2	in	in	IN
18637	3082	3	The	the	DT
18637	3082	4	Federalist,[1203	Federalist,[1203	NNS
18637	3082	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3082	6	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	3082	7	elaborated	elaborate	VBD
18637	3082	8	the	the	DT
18637	3082	9	theory	theory	NN
18637	3082	10	that	that	IN
18637	3082	11	the	the	DT
18637	3082	12	war	war	NN
18637	3082	13	power	power	NN
18637	3082	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	3082	15	an	an	DT
18637	3082	16	aggregate	aggregate	NN
18637	3082	17	of	of	IN
18637	3082	18	the	the	DT
18637	3082	19	particular	particular	JJ
18637	3082	20	powers	power	NNS
18637	3082	21	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3082	22	by	by	IN
18637	3082	23	article	article	NN
18637	3082	24	I	i	NN
18637	3082	25	,	,	,
18637	3082	26	section	section	NN
18637	3082	27	8	8	CD
18637	3082	28	.	.	.
18637	3083	1	Not	not	RB
18637	3083	2	many	many	JJ
18637	3083	3	years	year	NNS
18637	3083	4	later	later	RB
18637	3083	5	,	,	,
18637	3083	6	in	in	IN
18637	3083	7	1795	1795	CD
18637	3083	8	,	,	,
18637	3083	9	the	the	DT
18637	3083	10	argument	argument	NN
18637	3083	11	was	be	VBD
18637	3083	12	advanced	advanced	JJ
18637	3083	13	that	that	IN
18637	3083	14	the	the	DT
18637	3083	15	war	war	NN
18637	3083	16	power	power	NN
18637	3083	17	of	of	IN
18637	3083	18	the	the	DT
18637	3083	19	National	National	NNP
18637	3083	20	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3083	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	3083	22	an	an	DT
18637	3083	23	attribute	attribute	NN
18637	3083	24	of	of	IN
18637	3083	25	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	3083	26	and	and	CC
18637	3083	27	hence	hence	RB
18637	3083	28	not	not	RB
18637	3083	29	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	3083	30	upon	upon	IN
18637	3083	31	the	the	DT
18637	3083	32	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	3083	33	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3083	34	of	of	IN
18637	3083	35	the	the	DT
18637	3083	36	written	write	VBN
18637	3083	37	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3083	38	.	.	.
18637	3084	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3084	2	1204	1204	CD
18637	3084	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3084	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3084	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3084	6	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3084	7	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	3084	8	to	to	TO
18637	3084	9	have	have	VB
18637	3084	10	taken	take	VBN
18637	3084	11	a	a	DT
18637	3084	12	still	still	RB
18637	3084	13	different	different	JJ
18637	3084	14	view	view	NN
18637	3084	15	,	,	,
18637	3084	16	namely	namely	RB
18637	3084	17	that	that	IN
18637	3084	18	the	the	DT
18637	3084	19	power	power	NN
18637	3084	20	to	to	TO
18637	3084	21	wage	wage	VB
18637	3084	22	war	war	NN
18637	3084	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	3084	24	implied	imply	VBN
18637	3084	25	from	from	IN
18637	3084	26	the	the	DT
18637	3084	27	power	power	NN
18637	3084	28	to	to	TO
18637	3084	29	declare	declare	VB
18637	3084	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3084	31	.	.	.
18637	3085	1	In	in	IN
18637	3085	2	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	3085	3	_	_	NNP
18637	3085	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	3085	5	_	_	NNP
18637	3085	6	Maryland[1205	Maryland[1205	NNP
18637	3085	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3085	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3085	9	listed	list	VBD
18637	3085	10	the	the	DT
18637	3085	11	power	power	NN
18637	3085	12	"	"	''
18637	3085	13	to	to	TO
18637	3085	14	declare	declare	VB
18637	3085	15	_	_	NNP
18637	3085	16	and	and	CC
18637	3085	17	conduct	conduct	VB
18637	3085	18	_	_	NNP
18637	3085	19	a	a	DT
18637	3085	20	war"[1206	war"[1206	NN
18637	3085	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3085	22	as	as	IN
18637	3085	23	one	one	CD
18637	3085	24	of	of	IN
18637	3085	25	the	the	DT
18637	3085	26	"	"	``
18637	3085	27	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	3085	28	powers	power	NNS
18637	3085	29	"	"	''
18637	3085	30	from	from	IN
18637	3085	31	which	which	WDT
18637	3085	32	the	the	DT
18637	3085	33	authority	authority	NN
18637	3085	34	to	to	TO
18637	3085	35	charter	charter	VB
18637	3085	36	the	the	DT
18637	3085	37	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	3085	38	of	of	IN
18637	3085	39	the	the	DT
18637	3085	40	United	United	NNP
18637	3085	41	States	States	NNP
18637	3085	42	was	be	VBD
18637	3085	43	deduced	deduce	VBN
18637	3085	44	.	.	.
18637	3086	1	During	during	IN
18637	3086	2	the	the	DT
18637	3086	3	era	era	NN
18637	3086	4	of	of	IN
18637	3086	5	the	the	DT
18637	3086	6	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3086	7	War	War	NNP
18637	3086	8	the	the	DT
18637	3086	9	two	two	CD
18637	3086	10	latter	latter	JJ
18637	3086	11	theories	theory	NNS
18637	3086	12	were	be	VBD
18637	3086	13	both	both	DT
18637	3086	14	given	give	VBN
18637	3086	15	countenance	countenance	NN
18637	3086	16	by	by	IN
18637	3086	17	the	the	DT
18637	3086	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3086	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3086	20	.	.	.
18637	3087	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	3087	2	for	for	IN
18637	3087	3	four	four	CD
18637	3087	4	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	3087	5	in	in	IN
18637	3087	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	3087	7	Parte	Parte	NNP
18637	3087	8	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
18637	3087	9	,	,	,
18637	3087	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3087	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3087	12	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	3087	13	described	describe	VBD
18637	3087	14	the	the	DT
18637	3087	15	power	power	NN
18637	3087	16	to	to	TO
18637	3087	17	declare	declare	VB
18637	3087	18	war	war	NN
18637	3087	19	as	as	IN
18637	3087	20	"	"	``
18637	3087	21	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	3087	22	"	"	``
18637	3087	23	extending	extending	NN
18637	3087	24	"	"	''
18637	3087	25	to	to	IN
18637	3087	26	all	all	DT
18637	3087	27	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3087	28	essential	essential	JJ
18637	3087	29	to	to	IN
18637	3087	30	the	the	DT
18637	3087	31	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	3087	32	of	of	IN
18637	3087	33	war	war	NN
18637	3087	34	with	with	IN
18637	3087	35	vigor	vigor	NN
18637	3087	36	and	and	CC
18637	3087	37	success	success	NN
18637	3087	38	,	,	,
18637	3087	39	except	except	IN
18637	3087	40	such	such	JJ
18637	3087	41	as	as	IN
18637	3087	42	interferes	interfere	NNS
18637	3087	43	with	with	IN
18637	3087	44	the	the	DT
18637	3087	45	command	command	NN
18637	3087	46	of	of	IN
18637	3087	47	the	the	DT
18637	3087	48	forces	force	NNS
18637	3087	49	and	and	CC
18637	3087	50	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	3087	51	of	of	IN
18637	3087	52	campaigns	campaign	NNS
18637	3087	53	.	.	.
18637	3088	1	"	"	``
18637	3088	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3088	3	1207	1207	CD
18637	3088	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3088	5	In	in	IN
18637	3088	6	another	another	DT
18637	3088	7	case	case	NN
18637	3088	8	,	,	,
18637	3088	9	adopting	adopt	VBG
18637	3088	10	the	the	DT
18637	3088	11	terminology	terminology	NN
18637	3088	12	used	use	VBN
18637	3088	13	by	by	IN
18637	3088	14	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	3088	15	in	in	IN
18637	3088	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3088	17	Message	message	NN
18637	3088	18	to	to	IN
18637	3088	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3088	20	on	on	IN
18637	3088	21	July	July	NNP
18637	3088	22	4	4	CD
18637	3088	23	,	,	,
18637	3088	24	1861,[1208	1861,[1208	CD
18637	3088	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3088	26	the	the	DT
18637	3088	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3088	28	referred	refer	VBD
18637	3088	29	to	to	IN
18637	3088	30	"	"	``
18637	3088	31	the	the	DT
18637	3088	32	war	war	NN
18637	3088	33	power	power	NN
18637	3088	34	"	"	''
18637	3088	35	as	as	IN
18637	3088	36	a	a	DT
18637	3088	37	single	single	JJ
18637	3088	38	unified	unified	JJ
18637	3088	39	power	power	NN
18637	3088	40	.	.	.
18637	3089	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3089	2	1209	1209	CD
18637	3089	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3089	4	AN	an	DT
18637	3089	5	INHERENT	inherent	JJ
18637	3089	6	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	3089	7	Thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	3089	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3089	9	find	find	VBP
18637	3089	10	the	the	DT
18637	3089	11	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	3089	12	,	,	,
18637	3089	13	"	"	``
18637	3089	14	the	the	DT
18637	3089	15	war	war	NN
18637	3089	16	power	power	NN
18637	3089	17	,	,	,
18637	3089	18	"	"	''
18637	3089	19	being	be	VBG
18637	3089	20	used	use	VBN
18637	3089	21	by	by	IN
18637	3089	22	both	both	DT
18637	3089	23	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3089	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3089	25	White[1210	White[1210	NNP
18637	3089	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3089	27	and	and	CC
18637	3089	28	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3089	29	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3089	30	Hughes,[1211	hughes,[1211	CD
18637	3089	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3089	32	the	the	DT
18637	3089	33	former	former	JJ
18637	3089	34	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	3089	35	the	the	DT
18637	3089	36	power	power	NN
18637	3089	37	to	to	TO
18637	3089	38	be	be	VB
18637	3089	39	"	"	``
18637	3089	40	complete	complete	JJ
18637	3089	41	and	and	CC
18637	3089	42	undivided	undivided	JJ
18637	3089	43	.	.	.
18637	3090	1	"	"	``
18637	3090	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3090	3	1212	1212	CD
18637	3090	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3090	5	Not	not	RB
18637	3090	6	until	until	IN
18637	3090	7	1936	1936	CD
18637	3090	8	however	however	RB
18637	3090	9	did	do	VBD
18637	3090	10	the	the	DT
18637	3090	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3090	12	explain	explain	VB
18637	3090	13	the	the	DT
18637	3090	14	logical	logical	JJ
18637	3090	15	basis	basis	NN
18637	3090	16	for	for	IN
18637	3090	17	imputing	impute	VBG
18637	3090	18	such	such	PDT
18637	3090	19	an	an	DT
18637	3090	20	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	3090	21	power	power	NN
18637	3090	22	to	to	IN
18637	3090	23	the	the	DT
18637	3090	24	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3090	25	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3090	26	.	.	.
18637	3091	1	In	in	IN
18637	3091	2	United	United	NNP
18637	3091	3	States	States	NNP
18637	3091	4	_	_	NNP
18637	3091	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	3091	6	_	_	NNP
18637	3091	7	Curtiss	Curtiss	NNP
18637	3091	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	3091	9	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	3091	10	Export	Export	NNP
18637	3091	11	Corp	Corp	NNP
18637	3091	12	.	.	NNP
18637	3091	13	,[1213	,[1213	NFP
18637	3091	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3091	15	the	the	DT
18637	3091	16	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	3091	17	for	for	IN
18637	3091	18	this	this	DT
18637	3091	19	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	3091	20	were	be	VBD
18637	3091	21	stated	state	VBN
18637	3091	22	by	by	IN
18637	3091	23	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3091	24	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	3091	25	as	as	IN
18637	3091	26	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	3091	27	:	:	:
18637	3091	28	"	"	``
18637	3091	29	As	as	IN
18637	3091	30	a	a	DT
18637	3091	31	result	result	NN
18637	3091	32	of	of	IN
18637	3091	33	the	the	DT
18637	3091	34	separation	separation	NN
18637	3091	35	from	from	IN
18637	3091	36	Great	Great	NNP
18637	3091	37	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	3091	38	by	by	IN
18637	3091	39	the	the	DT
18637	3091	40	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	3091	41	acting	act	VBG
18637	3091	42	as	as	IN
18637	3091	43	a	a	DT
18637	3091	44	unit	unit	NN
18637	3091	45	,	,	,
18637	3091	46	the	the	DT
18637	3091	47	powers	power	NNS
18637	3091	48	of	of	IN
18637	3091	49	external	external	JJ
18637	3091	50	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	3091	51	passed	pass	VBD
18637	3091	52	from	from	IN
18637	3091	53	the	the	DT
18637	3091	54	Crown	Crown	NNP
18637	3091	55	not	not	RB
18637	3091	56	to	to	IN
18637	3091	57	the	the	DT
18637	3091	58	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	3091	59	severally	severally	RB
18637	3091	60	,	,	,
18637	3091	61	but	but	CC
18637	3091	62	to	to	IN
18637	3091	63	the	the	DT
18637	3091	64	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	3091	65	in	in	IN
18637	3091	66	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3091	67	collective	collective	JJ
18637	3091	68	and	and	CC
18637	3091	69	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	3091	70	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	3091	71	as	as	IN
18637	3091	72	the	the	DT
18637	3091	73	United	United	NNP
18637	3091	74	States	States	NNP
18637	3091	75	of	of	IN
18637	3091	76	America	America	NNP
18637	3091	77	.	.	.
18637	3092	1	Even	even	RB
18637	3092	2	before	before	IN
18637	3092	3	the	the	DT
18637	3092	4	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
18637	3092	5	,	,	,
18637	3092	6	the	the	DT
18637	3092	7	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	3092	8	were	be	VBD
18637	3092	9	a	a	DT
18637	3092	10	unit	unit	NN
18637	3092	11	in	in	IN
18637	3092	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3092	13	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	3092	14	,	,	,
18637	3092	15	acting	act	VBG
18637	3092	16	through	through	IN
18637	3092	17	a	a	DT
18637	3092	18	common	common	JJ
18637	3092	19	agency	agency	NN
18637	3092	20	--	--	:
18637	3092	21	namely	namely	RB
18637	3092	22	the	the	DT
18637	3092	23	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	3092	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3092	25	,	,	,
18637	3092	26	composed	compose	VBN
18637	3092	27	of	of	IN
18637	3092	28	delegates	delegate	NNS
18637	3092	29	from	from	IN
18637	3092	30	the	the	DT
18637	3092	31	thirteen	thirteen	CD
18637	3092	32	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	3092	33	.	.	.
18637	3093	1	That	that	DT
18637	3093	2	agency	agency	NN
18637	3093	3	exercised	exercise	VBD
18637	3093	4	the	the	DT
18637	3093	5	powers	power	NNS
18637	3093	6	of	of	IN
18637	3093	7	war	war	NN
18637	3093	8	and	and	CC
18637	3093	9	peace	peace	NN
18637	3093	10	,	,	,
18637	3093	11	raised	raise	VBD
18637	3093	12	an	an	DT
18637	3093	13	army	army	NN
18637	3093	14	,	,	,
18637	3093	15	created	create	VBD
18637	3093	16	a	a	DT
18637	3093	17	navy	navy	NN
18637	3093	18	,	,	,
18637	3093	19	and	and	CC
18637	3093	20	finally	finally	RB
18637	3093	21	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	3093	22	the	the	DT
18637	3093	23	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
18637	3093	24	of	of	IN
18637	3093	25	Independence	Independence	NNP
18637	3093	26	.	.	.
18637	3094	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3094	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3094	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3094	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3094	5	results	result	VBZ
18637	3094	6	that	that	IN
18637	3094	7	the	the	DT
18637	3094	8	investment	investment	NN
18637	3094	9	of	of	IN
18637	3094	10	the	the	DT
18637	3094	11	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3094	12	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3094	13	with	with	IN
18637	3094	14	the	the	DT
18637	3094	15	powers	power	NNS
18637	3094	16	of	of	IN
18637	3094	17	external	external	JJ
18637	3094	18	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	3094	19	did	do	VBD
18637	3094	20	not	not	RB
18637	3094	21	depend	depend	VB
18637	3094	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	3094	23	the	the	DT
18637	3094	24	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	3094	25	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3094	26	of	of	IN
18637	3094	27	the	the	DT
18637	3094	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3094	29	.	.	.
18637	3095	1	The	the	DT
18637	3095	2	power	power	NN
18637	3095	3	to	to	TO
18637	3095	4	declare	declare	VB
18637	3095	5	and	and	CC
18637	3095	6	wage	wage	VB
18637	3095	7	war	war	NN
18637	3095	8	,	,	,
18637	3095	9	to	to	TO
18637	3095	10	conclude	conclude	VB
18637	3095	11	peace	peace	NN
18637	3095	12	,	,	,
18637	3095	13	to	to	TO
18637	3095	14	make	make	VB
18637	3095	15	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	3095	16	,	,	,
18637	3095	17	to	to	TO
18637	3095	18	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	3095	19	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	3095	20	relations	relation	NNS
18637	3095	21	with	with	IN
18637	3095	22	other	other	JJ
18637	3095	23	sovereignties	sovereignty	NNS
18637	3095	24	,	,	,
18637	3095	25	if	if	IN
18637	3095	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3095	27	had	have	VBD
18637	3095	28	never	never	RB
18637	3095	29	been	be	VBN
18637	3095	30	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	3095	31	in	in	IN
18637	3095	32	the	the	DT
18637	3095	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3095	34	,	,	,
18637	3095	35	would	would	MD
18637	3095	36	have	have	VB
18637	3095	37	vested	vest	VBN
18637	3095	38	in	in	IN
18637	3095	39	the	the	DT
18637	3095	40	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3095	41	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3095	42	as	as	IN
18637	3095	43	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3095	44	concomitants	concomitant	NNS
18637	3095	45	of	of	IN
18637	3095	46	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	3095	47	.	.	.
18637	3096	1	"	"	``
18637	3096	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3096	3	1214	1214	CD
18637	3096	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3096	5	A	a	DT
18637	3096	6	COMPLEXUS	complexu	NNS
18637	3096	7	OF	of	IN
18637	3096	8	GRANTED	grant	VBN
18637	3096	9	POWERS	power	NNS
18637	3096	10	In	in	IN
18637	3096	11	the	the	DT
18637	3096	12	more	more	RBR
18637	3096	13	recent	recent	JJ
18637	3096	14	case	case	NN
18637	3096	15	of	of	IN
18637	3096	16	Lichter	Lichter	NNP
18637	3096	17	_	_	NNP
18637	3096	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	3096	19	_	_	NNP
18637	3096	20	United	United	NNP
18637	3096	21	States,[1215	states,[1215	CD
18637	3096	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3096	23	on	on	IN
18637	3096	24	the	the	DT
18637	3096	25	other	other	JJ
18637	3096	26	hand	hand	NN
18637	3096	27	,	,	,
18637	3096	28	the	the	DT
18637	3096	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3096	30	speaks	speak	VBZ
18637	3096	31	of	of	IN
18637	3096	32	the	the	DT
18637	3096	33	"	"	``
18637	3096	34	war	war	NN
18637	3096	35	powers	power	NNS
18637	3096	36	"	"	''
18637	3096	37	of	of	IN
18637	3096	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3096	39	.	.	.
18637	3097	1	Upholding	uphold	VBG
18637	3097	2	the	the	DT
18637	3097	3	Renegotiation	Renegotiation	NNP
18637	3097	4	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3097	5	,	,	,
18637	3097	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3097	7	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3097	8	that	that	DT
18637	3097	9	:	:	:
18637	3097	10	"	"	``
18637	3097	11	In	in	IN
18637	3097	12	view	view	NN
18637	3097	13	of	of	IN
18637	3097	14	this	this	DT
18637	3097	15	power	power	NN
18637	3097	16	'	'	''
18637	3097	17	To	to	TO
18637	3097	18	raise	raise	VB
18637	3097	19	and	and	CC
18637	3097	20	support	support	VB
18637	3097	21	Armies	army	NNS
18637	3097	22	,	,	,
18637	3097	23	*	*	NFP
18637	3097	24	*	*	NFP
18637	3097	25	*	*	NFP
18637	3097	26	'	'	''
18637	3097	27	and	and	CC
18637	3097	28	the	the	DT
18637	3097	29	power	power	NN
18637	3097	30	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3097	31	in	in	IN
18637	3097	32	the	the	DT
18637	3097	33	same	same	JJ
18637	3097	34	Article	Article	NNP
18637	3097	35	of	of	IN
18637	3097	36	the	the	DT
18637	3097	37	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3097	38	'	'	''
18637	3097	39	to	to	TO
18637	3097	40	make	make	VB
18637	3097	41	all	all	DT
18637	3097	42	Laws	law	NNS
18637	3097	43	which	which	WDT
18637	3097	44	shall	shall	MD
18637	3097	45	be	be	VB
18637	3097	46	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3097	47	and	and	CC
18637	3097	48	proper	proper	JJ
18637	3097	49	for	for	IN
18637	3097	50	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	3097	51	into	into	IN
18637	3097	52	Execution	execution	NN
18637	3097	53	the	the	DT
18637	3097	54	foregoing	forego	VBG
18637	3097	55	Powers	power	NNS
18637	3097	56	,	,	,
18637	3097	57	*	*	NFP
18637	3097	58	*	*	NFP
18637	3097	59	*	*	NFP
18637	3097	60	'	'	''
18637	3097	61	the	the	DT
18637	3097	62	only	only	JJ
18637	3097	63	question	question	NN
18637	3097	64	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	3097	65	is	be	VBZ
18637	3097	66	whether	whether	IN
18637	3097	67	the	the	DT
18637	3097	68	Renegotiation	Renegotiation	NNP
18637	3097	69	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3097	70	was	be	VBD
18637	3097	71	a	a	DT
18637	3097	72	law	law	NN
18637	3097	73	'	'	``
18637	3097	74	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3097	75	and	and	CC
18637	3097	76	proper	proper	JJ
18637	3097	77	for	for	IN
18637	3097	78	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	3097	79	into	into	IN
18637	3097	80	Execution	execution	NN
18637	3097	81	'	'	''
18637	3097	82	the	the	DT
18637	3097	83	war	war	NN
18637	3097	84	powers	power	NNS
18637	3097	85	of	of	IN
18637	3097	86	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3097	87	and	and	CC
18637	3097	88	especially	especially	RB
18637	3097	89	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3097	90	power	power	NN
18637	3097	91	to	to	TO
18637	3097	92	support	support	VB
18637	3097	93	armies	army	NNS
18637	3097	94	.	.	.
18637	3098	1	"	"	``
18637	3098	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3098	3	1216	1216	CD
18637	3098	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3098	5	In	in	IN
18637	3098	6	a	a	DT
18637	3098	7	footnote	footnote	NN
18637	3098	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3098	9	listed	list	VBD
18637	3098	10	the	the	DT
18637	3098	11	Preamble	Preamble	NNP
18637	3098	12	,	,	,
18637	3098	13	the	the	DT
18637	3098	14	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3098	15	and	and	CC
18637	3098	16	proper	proper	JJ
18637	3098	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	3098	18	,	,	,
18637	3098	19	the	the	DT
18637	3098	20	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	3098	21	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	3098	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3098	23	to	to	TO
18637	3098	24	lay	lay	VB
18637	3098	25	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3098	26	and	and	CC
18637	3098	27	provide	provide	VB
18637	3098	28	for	for	IN
18637	3098	29	the	the	DT
18637	3098	30	common	common	JJ
18637	3098	31	defense	defense	NN
18637	3098	32	,	,	,
18637	3098	33	to	to	TO
18637	3098	34	declare	declare	VB
18637	3098	35	war	war	NN
18637	3098	36	,	,	,
18637	3098	37	and	and	CC
18637	3098	38	to	to	TO
18637	3098	39	provide	provide	VB
18637	3098	40	and	and	CC
18637	3098	41	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	3098	42	a	a	DT
18637	3098	43	navy	navy	NN
18637	3098	44	,	,	,
18637	3098	45	together	together	RB
18637	3098	46	with	with	IN
18637	3098	47	the	the	DT
18637	3098	48	clause	clause	NN
18637	3098	49	designating	designate	VBG
18637	3098	50	the	the	DT
18637	3098	51	President	President	NNP
18637	3098	52	as	as	IN
18637	3098	53	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	3098	54	in	in	IN
18637	3098	55	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3098	56	of	of	IN
18637	3098	57	the	the	DT
18637	3098	58	Army	Army	NNP
18637	3098	59	and	and	CC
18637	3098	60	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	3098	61	,	,	,
18637	3098	62	as	as	IN
18637	3098	63	being	be	VBG
18637	3098	64	"	"	``
18637	3098	65	among	among	IN
18637	3098	66	the	the	DT
18637	3098	67	many	many	JJ
18637	3098	68	other	other	JJ
18637	3098	69	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	3098	70	implementing	implement	VBG
18637	3098	71	the	the	DT
18637	3098	72	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3098	73	and	and	CC
18637	3098	74	the	the	DT
18637	3098	75	President	President	NNP
18637	3098	76	with	with	IN
18637	3098	77	powers	power	NNS
18637	3098	78	to	to	TO
18637	3098	79	meet	meet	VB
18637	3098	80	the	the	DT
18637	3098	81	varied	varied	JJ
18637	3098	82	demands	demand	NNS
18637	3098	83	of	of	IN
18637	3098	84	war	war	NN
18637	3098	85	,	,	,
18637	3098	86	*	*	NFP
18637	3098	87	*	*	NFP
18637	3098	88	*	*	NFP
18637	3098	89	"	"	''
18637	3098	90	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3098	91	1217	1217	CD
18637	3098	92	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3098	93	A	a	DT
18637	3098	94	DECLARATION	DECLARATION	NNP
18637	3098	95	OF	of	IN
18637	3098	96	WAR	WAR	NNP
18637	3098	97	,	,	,
18637	3098	98	WHEN	when	WRB
18637	3098	99	REQUIRED	REQUIRED	NNP
18637	3098	100	In	in	IN
18637	3098	101	the	the	DT
18637	3098	102	first	first	JJ
18637	3098	103	draft	draft	NN
18637	3098	104	of	of	IN
18637	3098	105	the	the	DT
18637	3098	106	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3098	107	presented	present	VBD
18637	3098	108	to	to	IN
18637	3098	109	the	the	DT
18637	3098	110	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	3098	111	of	of	IN
18637	3098	112	1787	1787	CD
18637	3098	113	by	by	IN
18637	3098	114	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3098	115	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	3098	116	of	of	IN
18637	3098	117	Detail	Detail	NNP
18637	3098	118	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3098	119	was	be	VBD
18637	3098	120	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	3098	121	"	"	``
18637	3098	122	to	to	TO
18637	3098	123	make	make	VB
18637	3098	124	war	war	NN
18637	3098	125	.	.	.
18637	3099	1	"	"	``
18637	3099	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3099	3	1218	1218	CD
18637	3099	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3099	5	On	on	IN
18637	3099	6	the	the	DT
18637	3099	7	floor	floor	NN
18637	3099	8	of	of	IN
18637	3099	9	the	the	DT
18637	3099	10	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	3099	11	according	accord	VBG
18637	3099	12	to	to	IN
18637	3099	13	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	3099	14	's	's	POS
18637	3099	15	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	3099	16	"	"	''
18637	3099	17	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	3099	18	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	3099	19	and	and	CC
18637	3099	20	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	3099	21	Gerry	Gerry	NNP
18637	3099	22	,	,	,
18637	3099	23	moved	move	VBD
18637	3099	24	to	to	TO
18637	3099	25	insert	insert	VB
18637	3099	26	'	'	''
18637	3099	27	_	_	NNP
18637	3099	28	declare	declare	NN
18637	3099	29	_	_	NNP
18637	3099	30	'	'	''
18637	3099	31	striking	strike	VBG
18637	3099	32	out	out	RP
18637	3099	33	'	'	''
18637	3099	34	_	_	NNP
18637	3099	35	make	make	VB
18637	3099	36	_	_	NNP
18637	3099	37	'	'	POS
18637	3099	38	war	war	NN
18637	3099	39	;	;	,
18637	3099	40	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	3099	41	to	to	IN
18637	3099	42	the	the	DT
18637	3099	43	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	3099	44	the	the	DT
18637	3099	45	power	power	NN
18637	3099	46	to	to	TO
18637	3099	47	repel	repel	VB
18637	3099	48	sudden	sudden	JJ
18637	3099	49	attacks"[1219	attacks"[1219	NNS
18637	3099	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3099	51	and	and	CC
18637	3099	52	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3099	53	motion	motion	NN
18637	3099	54	was	be	VBD
18637	3099	55	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	3099	56	.	.	.
18637	3100	1	When	when	WRB
18637	3100	2	the	the	DT
18637	3100	3	Bey	Bey	NNP
18637	3100	4	of	of	IN
18637	3100	5	Tripoli	Tripoli	NNP
18637	3100	6	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3100	7	war	war	NN
18637	3100	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	3100	9	the	the	DT
18637	3100	10	United	United	NNP
18637	3100	11	States	States	NNP
18637	3100	12	in	in	IN
18637	3100	13	1801	1801	CD
18637	3100	14	a	a	DT
18637	3100	15	sharp	sharp	JJ
18637	3100	16	debate	debate	NN
18637	3100	17	was	be	VBD
18637	3100	18	precipitated	precipitate	VBN
18637	3100	19	as	as	IN
18637	3100	20	to	to	IN
18637	3100	21	whether	whether	IN
18637	3100	22	a	a	DT
18637	3100	23	formal	formal	JJ
18637	3100	24	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	3100	25	of	of	IN
18637	3100	26	war	war	NN
18637	3100	27	by	by	IN
18637	3100	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3100	29	was	be	VBD
18637	3100	30	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	3100	31	to	to	TO
18637	3100	32	create	create	VB
18637	3100	33	the	the	DT
18637	3100	34	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3100	35	status	status	NN
18637	3100	36	of	of	IN
18637	3100	37	war	war	NN
18637	3100	38	.	.	.
18637	3101	1	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	3101	2	sent	send	VBD
18637	3101	3	a	a	DT
18637	3101	4	squadron	squadron	NN
18637	3101	5	of	of	IN
18637	3101	6	frigates	frigate	NNS
18637	3101	7	to	to	IN
18637	3101	8	the	the	DT
18637	3101	9	Mediterranean	Mediterranean	NNP
18637	3101	10	to	to	TO
18637	3101	11	protect	protect	VB
18637	3101	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3101	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	3101	14	but	but	CC
18637	3101	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3101	16	mission	mission	NN
18637	3101	17	was	be	VBD
18637	3101	18	limited	limit	VBN
18637	3101	19	to	to	IN
18637	3101	20	defense	defense	NN
18637	3101	21	in	in	IN
18637	3101	22	the	the	DT
18637	3101	23	narrowest	narrow	JJS
18637	3101	24	sense	sense	NN
18637	3101	25	of	of	IN
18637	3101	26	the	the	DT
18637	3101	27	term	term	NN
18637	3101	28	.	.	.
18637	3102	1	After	after	IN
18637	3102	2	one	one	CD
18637	3102	3	of	of	IN
18637	3102	4	the	the	DT
18637	3102	5	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	3102	6	in	in	IN
18637	3102	7	this	this	DT
18637	3102	8	squadron	squadron	NN
18637	3102	9	had	have	VBD
18637	3102	10	been	be	VBN
18637	3102	11	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	3102	12	by	by	IN
18637	3102	13	,	,	,
18637	3102	14	and	and	CC
18637	3102	15	had	have	VBD
18637	3102	16	defeated	defeat	VBN
18637	3102	17	,	,	,
18637	3102	18	a	a	DT
18637	3102	19	Tripolitan	Tripolitan	NNP
18637	3102	20	cruiser	cruiser	NN
18637	3102	21	,	,	,
18637	3102	22	the	the	DT
18637	3102	23	latter	latter	JJ
18637	3102	24	was	be	VBD
18637	3102	25	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	3102	26	to	to	TO
18637	3102	27	return	return	VB
18637	3102	28	home	home	RB
18637	3102	29	.	.	.
18637	3103	1	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	3103	2	defended	defend	VBD
18637	3103	3	this	this	DT
18637	3103	4	course	course	NN
18637	3103	5	in	in	IN
18637	3103	6	a	a	DT
18637	3103	7	message	message	NN
18637	3103	8	to	to	IN
18637	3103	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3103	10	saying	say	VBG
18637	3103	11	,	,	,
18637	3103	12	"	"	``
18637	3103	13	Unauthorized	unauthorize	VBN
18637	3103	14	by	by	IN
18637	3103	15	the	the	DT
18637	3103	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3103	17	,	,	,
18637	3103	18	without	without	IN
18637	3103	19	the	the	DT
18637	3103	20	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	3103	21	of	of	IN
18637	3103	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3103	23	,	,	,
18637	3103	24	to	to	TO
18637	3103	25	go	go	VB
18637	3103	26	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	3103	27	the	the	DT
18637	3103	28	line	line	NN
18637	3103	29	of	of	IN
18637	3103	30	defence	defence	NN
18637	3103	31	,	,	,
18637	3103	32	the	the	DT
18637	3103	33	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	3103	34	being	be	VBG
18637	3103	35	disabled	disable	VBN
18637	3103	36	from	from	IN
18637	3103	37	committing	commit	VBG
18637	3103	38	further	further	JJ
18637	3103	39	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	3103	40	,	,	,
18637	3103	41	was	be	VBD
18637	3103	42	liberated	liberate	VBN
18637	3103	43	with	with	IN
18637	3103	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3103	45	crew	crew	NN
18637	3103	46	.	.	.
18637	3104	1	"	"	``
18637	3104	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3104	3	1220	1220	CD
18637	3104	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3104	5	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	3104	6	promptly	promptly	RB
18637	3104	7	espoused	espouse	VBD
18637	3104	8	a	a	DT
18637	3104	9	different	different	JJ
18637	3104	10	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	3104	11	of	of	IN
18637	3104	12	the	the	DT
18637	3104	13	power	power	NN
18637	3104	14	given	give	VBN
18637	3104	15	to	to	IN
18637	3104	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3104	17	to	to	TO
18637	3104	18	declare	declare	VB
18637	3104	19	war	war	NN
18637	3104	20	.	.	.
18637	3105	1	"	"	``
18637	3105	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3105	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	3105	4	the	the	DT
18637	3105	5	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	3105	6	and	and	CC
18637	3105	7	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3105	8	province	province	NN
18637	3105	9	of	of	IN
18637	3105	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3105	11	,	,	,
18637	3105	12	"	"	''
18637	3105	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3105	14	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3105	15	"	"	``
18637	3105	16	_	_	NNP
18637	3105	17	when	when	WRB
18637	3105	18	the	the	DT
18637	3105	19	nation	nation	NN
18637	3105	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	3105	21	at	at	IN
18637	3105	22	peace	peace	NN
18637	3105	23	_	_	NNP
18637	3105	24	to	to	TO
18637	3105	25	change	change	VB
18637	3105	26	that	that	DT
18637	3105	27	state	state	NN
18637	3105	28	into	into	IN
18637	3105	29	a	a	DT
18637	3105	30	state	state	NN
18637	3105	31	of	of	IN
18637	3105	32	war	war	NN
18637	3105	33	;	;	:
18637	3105	34	whether	whether	IN
18637	3105	35	from	from	IN
18637	3105	36	calculations	calculation	NNS
18637	3105	37	of	of	IN
18637	3105	38	policy	policy	NN
18637	3105	39	,	,	,
18637	3105	40	or	or	CC
18637	3105	41	from	from	IN
18637	3105	42	provocations	provocation	NNS
18637	3105	43	,	,	,
18637	3105	44	or	or	CC
18637	3105	45	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	3105	46	received	receive	VBD
18637	3105	47	;	;	:
18637	3105	48	in	in	IN
18637	3105	49	other	other	JJ
18637	3105	50	words	word	NNS
18637	3105	51	,	,	,
18637	3105	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3105	53	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	3105	54	to	to	IN
18637	3105	55	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3105	56	only	only	RB
18637	3105	57	_	_	NNP
18637	3105	58	to	to	TO
18637	3105	59	go	go	VB
18637	3105	60	to	to	IN
18637	3105	61	War	War	NNP
18637	3105	62	_	_	NNP
18637	3105	63	.	.	.
18637	3106	1	But	but	CC
18637	3106	2	when	when	WRB
18637	3106	3	a	a	DT
18637	3106	4	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3106	5	nation	nation	NN
18637	3106	6	declares	declare	NNS
18637	3106	7	or	or	CC
18637	3106	8	openly	openly	RB
18637	3106	9	and	and	CC
18637	3106	10	avowedly	avowedly	RB
18637	3106	11	makes	make	VBZ
18637	3106	12	war	war	NN
18637	3106	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	3106	14	the	the	DT
18637	3106	15	United	United	NNP
18637	3106	16	States	States	NNP
18637	3106	17	,	,	,
18637	3106	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3106	19	are	be	VBP
18637	3106	20	then	then	RB
18637	3106	21	by	by	IN
18637	3106	22	the	the	DT
18637	3106	23	very	very	JJ
18637	3106	24	fact	fact	NN
18637	3106	25	_	_	NNP
18637	3106	26	already	already	RB
18637	3106	27	at	at	IN
18637	3106	28	war	war	NN
18637	3106	29	_	_	NNP
18637	3106	30	,	,	,
18637	3106	31	and	and	CC
18637	3106	32	any	any	DT
18637	3106	33	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	3106	34	on	on	IN
18637	3106	35	the	the	DT
18637	3106	36	part	part	NN
18637	3106	37	of	of	IN
18637	3106	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3106	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	3106	40	nugatory	nugatory	JJ
18637	3106	41	;	;	:
18637	3106	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3106	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	3106	44	at	at	IN
18637	3106	45	least	least	JJS
18637	3106	46	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	3106	47	.	.	.
18637	3107	1	"	"	``
18637	3107	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3107	3	1221	1221	CD
18637	3107	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3107	5	Apparently	apparently	RB
18637	3107	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3107	7	shared	share	VBD
18637	3107	8	the	the	DT
18637	3107	9	view	view	NN
18637	3107	10	that	that	IN
18637	3107	11	a	a	DT
18637	3107	12	formal	formal	JJ
18637	3107	13	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	3107	14	of	of	IN
18637	3107	15	war	war	NN
18637	3107	16	was	be	VBD
18637	3107	17	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	3107	18	.	.	.
18637	3108	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3108	2	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	3108	3	a	a	DT
18637	3108	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	3108	5	which	which	WDT
18637	3108	6	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	3108	7	the	the	DT
18637	3108	8	President	President	NNP
18637	3108	9	to	to	TO
18637	3108	10	instruct	instruct	VB
18637	3108	11	the	the	DT
18637	3108	12	commanders	commander	NNS
18637	3108	13	of	of	IN
18637	3108	14	armed	armed	JJ
18637	3108	15	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	3108	16	of	of	IN
18637	3108	17	the	the	DT
18637	3108	18	United	United	NNP
18637	3108	19	States	States	NNP
18637	3108	20	to	to	TO
18637	3108	21	"	"	``
18637	3108	22	seize	seize	VB
18637	3108	23	and	and	CC
18637	3108	24	make	make	VB
18637	3108	25	prize	prize	NN
18637	3108	26	of	of	IN
18637	3108	27	all	all	DT
18637	3108	28	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	3108	29	,	,	,
18637	3108	30	goods	good	NNS
18637	3108	31	and	and	CC
18637	3108	32	effects	effect	NNS
18637	3108	33	,	,	,
18637	3108	34	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	3108	35	to	to	IN
18637	3108	36	the	the	DT
18637	3108	37	Bey	Bey	NNP
18637	3108	38	of	of	IN
18637	3108	39	Tripoli	Tripoli	NNP
18637	3108	40	,	,	,
18637	3108	41	*	*	NFP
18637	3108	42	*	*	NFP
18637	3108	43	*	*	NFP
18637	3108	44	;	;	:
18637	3108	45	and	and	CC
18637	3108	46	also	also	RB
18637	3108	47	to	to	TO
18637	3108	48	cause	cause	VB
18637	3108	49	to	to	TO
18637	3108	50	be	be	VB
18637	3108	51	done	do	VBN
18637	3108	52	all	all	DT
18637	3108	53	such	such	JJ
18637	3108	54	other	other	JJ
18637	3108	55	acts	act	NNS
18637	3108	56	of	of	IN
18637	3108	57	precaution	precaution	NN
18637	3108	58	or	or	CC
18637	3108	59	hostility	hostility	NN
18637	3108	60	as	as	IN
18637	3108	61	_	_	NNP
18637	3108	62	the	the	DT
18637	3108	63	state	state	NN
18637	3108	64	of	of	IN
18637	3108	65	war	war	NN
18637	3108	66	_	_	NNP
18637	3108	67	will	will	MD
18637	3108	68	justify	justify	VB
18637	3108	69	,	,	,
18637	3108	70	*	*	NFP
18637	3108	71	*	*	NFP
18637	3108	72	*	*	NFP
18637	3108	73	"	"	''
18637	3108	74	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3108	75	1222	1222	CD
18637	3108	76	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3108	77	THE	the	DT
18637	3108	78	PRIZE	PRIZE	NNP
18637	3108	79	CASES	case	NNS
18637	3108	80	,	,	,
18637	3108	81	1863	1863	CD
18637	3108	82	Sixty	sixty	CD
18637	3108	83	years	year	NNS
18637	3108	84	later	later	RBR
18637	3108	85	the	the	DT
18637	3108	86	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3108	87	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3108	88	,	,	,
18637	3108	89	in	in	IN
18637	3108	90	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	3108	91	the	the	DT
18637	3108	92	blockade	blockade	NN
18637	3108	93	of	of	IN
18637	3108	94	the	the	DT
18637	3108	95	Southern	southern	JJ
18637	3108	96	ports	port	NNS
18637	3108	97	which	which	WDT
18637	3108	98	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	3108	99	had	have	VBD
18637	3108	100	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	3108	101	in	in	IN
18637	3108	102	April	April	NNP
18637	3108	103	1861	1861	CD
18637	3108	104	,	,	,
18637	3108	105	at	at	IN
18637	3108	106	a	a	DT
18637	3108	107	time	time	NN
18637	3108	108	when	when	WRB
18637	3108	109	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3108	110	was	be	VBD
18637	3108	111	not	not	RB
18637	3108	112	in	in	IN
18637	3108	113	session	session	NN
18637	3108	114	,	,	,
18637	3108	115	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	3108	116	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	3108	117	the	the	DT
18637	3108	118	same	same	JJ
18637	3108	119	line	line	NN
18637	3108	120	of	of	IN
18637	3108	121	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	3108	122	as	as	IN
18637	3108	123	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	3108	124	had	have	VBD
18637	3108	125	advanced	advance	VBN
18637	3108	126	.	.	.
18637	3109	1	"	"	``
18637	3109	2	This	this	DT
18637	3109	3	greatest	great	JJS
18637	3109	4	of	of	IN
18637	3109	5	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3109	6	wars	war	NNS
18637	3109	7	"	"	''
18637	3109	8	said	say	VBD
18637	3109	9	the	the	DT
18637	3109	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3109	11	"	"	``
18637	3109	12	was	be	VBD
18637	3109	13	not	not	RB
18637	3109	14	gradually	gradually	RB
18637	3109	15	developed	develop	VBN
18637	3109	16	*	*	NFP
18637	3109	17	*	*	NFP
18637	3109	18	*	*	NFP
18637	3109	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3109	20	*	*	NFP
18637	3109	21	*	*	NFP
18637	3109	22	*	*	NFP
18637	3109	23	sprung	spring	VBD
18637	3109	24	forth	forth	RB
18637	3109	25	suddenly	suddenly	RB
18637	3109	26	from	from	IN
18637	3109	27	the	the	DT
18637	3109	28	parent	parent	NN
18637	3109	29	brain	brain	NN
18637	3109	30	,	,	,
18637	3109	31	a	a	DT
18637	3109	32	Minerva	Minerva	NNP
18637	3109	33	in	in	IN
18637	3109	34	the	the	DT
18637	3109	35	full	full	JJ
18637	3109	36	panoply	panoply	NN
18637	3109	37	of	of	IN
18637	3109	38	_	_	NNP
18637	3109	39	war	war	NN
18637	3109	40	_	_	NNP
18637	3109	41	.	.	.
18637	3110	1	The	the	DT
18637	3110	2	President	President	NNP
18637	3110	3	was	be	VBD
18637	3110	4	bound	bind	VBN
18637	3110	5	to	to	TO
18637	3110	6	meet	meet	VB
18637	3110	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3110	8	in	in	IN
18637	3110	9	the	the	DT
18637	3110	10	shape	shape	NN
18637	3110	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3110	12	presented	present	VBD
18637	3110	13	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3110	14	,	,	,
18637	3110	15	without	without	IN
18637	3110	16	waiting	wait	VBG
18637	3110	17	for	for	IN
18637	3110	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3110	19	to	to	TO
18637	3110	20	baptize	baptize	VB
18637	3110	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3110	22	with	with	IN
18637	3110	23	a	a	DT
18637	3110	24	name	name	NN
18637	3110	25	;	;	:
18637	3110	26	and	and	CC
18637	3110	27	no	no	DT
18637	3110	28	name	name	NN
18637	3110	29	given	give	VBN
18637	3110	30	to	to	IN
18637	3110	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3110	32	by	by	IN
18637	3110	33	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3110	34	or	or	CC
18637	3110	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3110	36	could	could	MD
18637	3110	37	change	change	VB
18637	3110	38	the	the	DT
18637	3110	39	fact	fact	NN
18637	3110	40	.	.	.
18637	3111	1	"	"	``
18637	3111	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3111	3	1223	1223	CD
18637	3111	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3111	5	This	this	DT
18637	3111	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3111	7	was	be	VBD
18637	3111	8	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	3111	9	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	3111	10	by	by	IN
18637	3111	11	a	a	DT
18637	3111	12	powerful	powerful	JJ
18637	3111	13	minority	minority	NN
18637	3111	14	of	of	IN
18637	3111	15	the	the	DT
18637	3111	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3111	17	on	on	IN
18637	3111	18	the	the	DT
18637	3111	19	ground	ground	NN
18637	3111	20	that	that	IN
18637	3111	21	while	while	IN
18637	3111	22	the	the	DT
18637	3111	23	President	President	NNP
18637	3111	24	could	could	MD
18637	3111	25	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
18637	3111	26	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	3111	27	such	such	JJ
18637	3111	28	measures	measure	NNS
18637	3111	29	as	as	IN
18637	3111	30	the	the	DT
18637	3111	31	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3111	32	permitted	permit	VBD
18637	3111	33	for	for	IN
18637	3111	34	the	the	DT
18637	3111	35	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	3111	36	of	of	IN
18637	3111	37	the	the	DT
18637	3111	38	laws	law	NNS
18637	3111	39	against	against	IN
18637	3111	40	insurgents	insurgent	NNS
18637	3111	41	,	,	,
18637	3111	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3111	43	alone	alone	RB
18637	3111	44	could	could	MD
18637	3111	45	stamp	stamp	VB
18637	3111	46	an	an	DT
18637	3111	47	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	3111	48	with	with	IN
18637	3111	49	the	the	DT
18637	3111	50	character	character	NN
18637	3111	51	of	of	IN
18637	3111	52	war	war	NN
18637	3111	53	and	and	CC
18637	3111	54	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	3111	55	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	3111	56	the	the	DT
18637	3111	57	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3111	58	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	3111	59	which	which	WDT
18637	3111	60	ensue	ensue	VBP
18637	3111	61	a	a	DT
18637	3111	62	state	state	NN
18637	3111	63	of	of	IN
18637	3111	64	war	war	NN
18637	3111	65	.	.	.
18637	3112	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3112	2	1224	1224	CD
18637	3112	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3112	4	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	3112	5	as	as	IN
18637	3112	6	the	the	DT
18637	3112	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3112	8	finally	finally	RB
18637	3112	9	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	3112	10	that	that	IN
18637	3112	11	the	the	DT
18637	3112	12	blockade	blockade	NN
18637	3112	13	had	have	VBD
18637	3112	14	been	be	VBN
18637	3112	15	retroactively	retroactively	RB
18637	3112	16	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
18637	3112	17	by	by	IN
18637	3112	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3112	19	,	,	,
18637	3112	20	that	that	DT
18637	3112	21	part	part	NN
18637	3112	22	of	of	IN
18637	3112	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3112	24	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3112	25	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	3112	26	with	with	IN
18637	3112	27	the	the	DT
18637	3112	28	power	power	NN
18637	3112	29	of	of	IN
18637	3112	30	the	the	DT
18637	3112	31	President	President	NNP
18637	3112	32	,	,	,
18637	3112	33	acting	act	VBG
18637	3112	34	alone	alone	RB
18637	3112	35	,	,	,
18637	3112	36	was	be	VBD
18637	3112	37	really	really	RB
18637	3112	38	_	_	NNP
18637	3112	39	obiter	obiter	NN
18637	3112	40	_	_	NNP
18637	3112	41	.	.	.
18637	3113	1	But	but	CC
18637	3113	2	a	a	DT
18637	3113	3	similar	similar	JJ
18637	3113	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3113	5	was	be	VBD
18637	3113	6	voiced	voice	VBN
18637	3113	7	by	by	IN
18637	3113	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3113	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3113	10	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	3113	11	on	on	IN
18637	3113	12	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	3113	13	of	of	IN
18637	3113	14	a	a	DT
18637	3113	15	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	3113	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3113	17	,	,	,
18637	3113	18	after	after	IN
18637	3113	19	the	the	DT
18637	3113	20	war	war	NN
18637	3113	21	was	be	VBD
18637	3113	22	over	over	RB
18637	3113	23	.	.	.
18637	3114	1	In	in	IN
18637	3114	2	Freeborn	Freeborn	NNP
18637	3114	3	_	_	NNP
18637	3114	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	3114	5	_	_	NNP
18637	3114	6	The	the	DT
18637	3114	7	"	"	``
18637	3114	8	Protector,"[1225	protector,"[1225	NN
18637	3114	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3114	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3114	11	became	become	VBD
18637	3114	12	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3114	13	to	to	TO
18637	3114	14	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	3114	15	the	the	DT
18637	3114	16	exact	exact	JJ
18637	3114	17	dates	date	NNS
18637	3114	18	on	on	IN
18637	3114	19	which	which	WDT
18637	3114	20	the	the	DT
18637	3114	21	war	war	NN
18637	3114	22	began	begin	VBD
18637	3114	23	and	and	CC
18637	3114	24	ended	end	VBD
18637	3114	25	in	in	IN
18637	3114	26	order	order	NN
18637	3114	27	to	to	TO
18637	3114	28	determine	determine	VB
18637	3114	29	whether	whether	IN
18637	3114	30	the	the	DT
18637	3114	31	statute	statute	NN
18637	3114	32	of	of	IN
18637	3114	33	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	3114	34	had	have	VBD
18637	3114	35	run	run	VBN
18637	3114	36	against	against	IN
18637	3114	37	the	the	DT
18637	3114	38	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	3114	39	claim	claim	NN
18637	3114	40	.	.	.
18637	3115	1	To	to	TO
18637	3115	2	answer	answer	VB
18637	3115	3	this	this	DT
18637	3115	4	question	question	NN
18637	3115	5	the	the	DT
18637	3115	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3115	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3115	8	said	say	VBD
18637	3115	9	that	that	IN
18637	3115	10	"	"	``
18637	3115	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3115	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	3115	13	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3115	14	,	,	,
18637	3115	15	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	3115	16	,	,	,
18637	3115	17	to	to	TO
18637	3115	18	refer	refer	VB
18637	3115	19	to	to	IN
18637	3115	20	some	some	DT
18637	3115	21	public	public	JJ
18637	3115	22	act	act	NN
18637	3115	23	of	of	IN
18637	3115	24	the	the	DT
18637	3115	25	political	political	JJ
18637	3115	26	departments	department	NNS
18637	3115	27	of	of	IN
18637	3115	28	the	the	DT
18637	3115	29	government	government	NN
18637	3115	30	to	to	TO
18637	3115	31	fix	fix	VB
18637	3115	32	the	the	DT
18637	3115	33	dates	date	NNS
18637	3115	34	;	;	:
18637	3115	35	and	and	CC
18637	3115	36	,	,	,
18637	3115	37	for	for	IN
18637	3115	38	obvious	obvious	JJ
18637	3115	39	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	3115	40	,	,	,
18637	3115	41	those	those	DT
18637	3115	42	of	of	IN
18637	3115	43	the	the	DT
18637	3115	44	executive	executive	JJ
18637	3115	45	department	department	NN
18637	3115	46	,	,	,
18637	3115	47	which	which	WDT
18637	3115	48	may	may	MD
18637	3115	49	be	be	VB
18637	3115	50	,	,	,
18637	3115	51	and	and	CC
18637	3115	52	,	,	,
18637	3115	53	in	in	IN
18637	3115	54	fact	fact	NN
18637	3115	55	,	,	,
18637	3115	56	was	be	VBD
18637	3115	57	,	,	,
18637	3115	58	at	at	IN
18637	3115	59	the	the	DT
18637	3115	60	commencement	commencement	NN
18637	3115	61	of	of	IN
18637	3115	62	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	3115	63	,	,	,
18637	3115	64	obliged	oblige	VBD
18637	3115	65	to	to	TO
18637	3115	66	act	act	VB
18637	3115	67	during	during	IN
18637	3115	68	the	the	DT
18637	3115	69	recess	recess	NN
18637	3115	70	of	of	IN
18637	3115	71	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3115	72	,	,	,
18637	3115	73	must	must	MD
18637	3115	74	be	be	VB
18637	3115	75	taken	take	VBN
18637	3115	76	.	.	.
18637	3116	1	The	the	DT
18637	3116	2	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	3116	3	of	of	IN
18637	3116	4	intended	intend	VBN
18637	3116	5	blockade	blockade	NN
18637	3116	6	by	by	IN
18637	3116	7	the	the	DT
18637	3116	8	President	President	NNP
18637	3116	9	may	may	MD
18637	3116	10	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	3116	11	be	be	VB
18637	3116	12	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	3116	13	as	as	IN
18637	3116	14	marking	mark	VBG
18637	3116	15	the	the	DT
18637	3116	16	first	first	JJ
18637	3116	17	of	of	IN
18637	3116	18	these	these	DT
18637	3116	19	dates	date	NNS
18637	3116	20	,	,	,
18637	3116	21	and	and	CC
18637	3116	22	the	the	DT
18637	3116	23	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	3116	24	that	that	IN
18637	3116	25	the	the	DT
18637	3116	26	war	war	NN
18637	3116	27	had	have	VBD
18637	3116	28	closed	close	VBN
18637	3116	29	,	,	,
18637	3116	30	as	as	IN
18637	3116	31	marking	mark	VBG
18637	3116	32	the	the	DT
18637	3116	33	second	second	JJ
18637	3116	34	.	.	.
18637	3117	1	"	"	``
18637	3117	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3117	3	1226	1226	CD
18637	3117	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3117	5	The	the	DT
18637	3117	6	Power	power	NN
18637	3117	7	To	to	TO
18637	3117	8	Raise	raise	VB
18637	3117	9	and	and	CC
18637	3117	10	Maintain	maintain	VB
18637	3117	11	Armed	Armed	NNP
18637	3117	12	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	3117	13	PURPOSE	PURPOSE	NNP
18637	3117	14	OF	of	IN
18637	3117	15	SPECIFIC	specific	NN
18637	3117	16	GRANTS	grant	NNS
18637	3117	17	The	the	DT
18637	3117	18	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	3117	19	of	of	IN
18637	3117	20	the	the	DT
18637	3117	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3117	22	which	which	WDT
18637	3117	23	give	give	VBP
18637	3117	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3117	25	authority	authority	NN
18637	3117	26	"	"	''
18637	3117	27	to	to	TO
18637	3117	28	raise	raise	VB
18637	3117	29	and	and	CC
18637	3117	30	support	support	VB
18637	3117	31	armies	army	NNS
18637	3117	32	,	,	,
18637	3117	33	to	to	TO
18637	3117	34	provide	provide	VB
18637	3117	35	and	and	CC
18637	3117	36	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	3117	37	a	a	DT
18637	3117	38	navy	navy	NN
18637	3117	39	"	"	''
18637	3117	40	and	and	CC
18637	3117	41	so	so	RB
18637	3117	42	forth	forth	RB
18637	3117	43	,	,	,
18637	3117	44	were	be	VBD
18637	3117	45	not	not	RB
18637	3117	46	inserted	insert	VBN
18637	3117	47	for	for	IN
18637	3117	48	the	the	DT
18637	3117	49	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3117	50	of	of	IN
18637	3117	51	endowing	endow	VBG
18637	3117	52	the	the	DT
18637	3117	53	National	National	NNP
18637	3117	54	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3117	55	with	with	IN
18637	3117	56	power	power	NN
18637	3117	57	to	to	TO
18637	3117	58	do	do	VB
18637	3117	59	these	these	DT
18637	3117	60	things	thing	NNS
18637	3117	61	,	,	,
18637	3117	62	but	but	CC
18637	3117	63	rather	rather	RB
18637	3117	64	to	to	TO
18637	3117	65	designate	designate	VB
18637	3117	66	the	the	DT
18637	3117	67	department	department	NN
18637	3117	68	of	of	IN
18637	3117	69	government	government	NN
18637	3117	70	which	which	WDT
18637	3117	71	should	should	MD
18637	3117	72	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	3117	73	such	such	JJ
18637	3117	74	powers	power	NNS
18637	3117	75	.	.	.
18637	3118	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	3118	2	,	,	,
18637	3118	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3118	4	permit	permit	VBP
18637	3118	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3118	6	to	to	TO
18637	3118	7	take	take	VB
18637	3118	8	measures	measure	NNS
18637	3118	9	essential	essential	JJ
18637	3118	10	to	to	IN
18637	3118	11	the	the	DT
18637	3118	12	national	national	JJ
18637	3118	13	defense	defense	NN
18637	3118	14	in	in	IN
18637	3118	15	time	time	NN
18637	3118	16	of	of	IN
18637	3118	17	peace	peace	NN
18637	3118	18	as	as	RB
18637	3118	19	well	well	RB
18637	3118	20	as	as	IN
18637	3118	21	during	during	IN
18637	3118	22	a	a	DT
18637	3118	23	period	period	NN
18637	3118	24	of	of	IN
18637	3118	25	actual	actual	JJ
18637	3118	26	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	3118	27	.	.	.
18637	3119	1	That	that	IN
18637	3119	2	these	these	DT
18637	3119	3	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	3119	4	grew	grow	VBD
18637	3119	5	out	out	IN
18637	3119	6	of	of	IN
18637	3119	7	the	the	DT
18637	3119	8	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	3119	9	that	that	IN
18637	3119	10	the	the	DT
18637	3119	11	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	3119	12	should	should	MD
18637	3119	13	be	be	VB
18637	3119	14	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	3119	15	of	of	IN
18637	3119	16	the	the	DT
18637	3119	17	"	"	``
18637	3119	18	sole	sole	JJ
18637	3119	19	power	power	NN
18637	3119	20	of	of	IN
18637	3119	21	raising	raise	VBG
18637	3119	22	and	and	CC
18637	3119	23	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	3119	24	fleets	fleet	NNS
18637	3119	25	and	and	CC
18637	3119	26	armies	army	NNS
18637	3119	27	"	"	''
18637	3119	28	which	which	WDT
18637	3119	29	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
18637	3119	30	attributed	attribute	VBD
18637	3119	31	to	to	IN
18637	3119	32	the	the	DT
18637	3119	33	King	King	NNP
18637	3119	34	under	under	IN
18637	3119	35	the	the	DT
18637	3119	36	British	british	JJ
18637	3119	37	Constitution,[1227	constitution,[1227	NN
18637	3119	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3119	39	was	be	VBD
18637	3119	40	emphasized	emphasize	VBN
18637	3119	41	by	by	IN
18637	3119	42	Story	story	NN
18637	3119	43	in	in	IN
18637	3119	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3119	45	Commentaries	commentary	NNS
18637	3119	46	.	.	.
18637	3120	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3120	2	wrote	write	VBD
18637	3120	3	:	:	:
18637	3120	4	"	"	``
18637	3120	5	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3120	6	notions	notion	NNS
18637	3120	7	,	,	,
18637	3120	8	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	3120	9	,	,	,
18637	3120	10	of	of	IN
18637	3120	11	the	the	DT
18637	3120	12	dangers	danger	NNS
18637	3120	13	of	of	IN
18637	3120	14	standing	stand	VBG
18637	3120	15	armies	army	NNS
18637	3120	16	,	,	,
18637	3120	17	in	in	IN
18637	3120	18	time	time	NN
18637	3120	19	of	of	IN
18637	3120	20	peace	peace	NN
18637	3120	21	,	,	,
18637	3120	22	are	be	VBP
18637	3120	23	derived	derive	VBN
18637	3120	24	in	in	IN
18637	3120	25	a	a	DT
18637	3120	26	great	great	JJ
18637	3120	27	measure	measure	NN
18637	3120	28	from	from	IN
18637	3120	29	the	the	DT
18637	3120	30	principles	principle	NNS
18637	3120	31	and	and	CC
18637	3120	32	examples	example	NNS
18637	3120	33	of	of	IN
18637	3120	34	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3120	35	English	english	JJ
18637	3120	36	ancestors	ancestor	NNS
18637	3120	37	.	.	.
18637	3121	1	In	in	IN
18637	3121	2	England	England	NNP
18637	3121	3	,	,	,
18637	3121	4	the	the	DT
18637	3121	5	King	King	NNP
18637	3121	6	possessed	possess	VBD
18637	3121	7	the	the	DT
18637	3121	8	power	power	NN
18637	3121	9	of	of	IN
18637	3121	10	raising	raise	VBG
18637	3121	11	armies	army	NNS
18637	3121	12	in	in	IN
18637	3121	13	the	the	DT
18637	3121	14	time	time	NN
18637	3121	15	of	of	IN
18637	3121	16	peace	peace	NN
18637	3121	17	according	accord	VBG
18637	3121	18	to	to	IN
18637	3121	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3121	20	own	own	JJ
18637	3121	21	good	good	JJ
18637	3121	22	pleasure	pleasure	NN
18637	3121	23	.	.	.
18637	3122	1	And	and	CC
18637	3122	2	this	this	DT
18637	3122	3	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	3122	4	was	be	VBD
18637	3122	5	justly	justly	RB
18637	3122	6	esteemed	esteem	VBN
18637	3122	7	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	3122	8	to	to	IN
18637	3122	9	the	the	DT
18637	3122	10	public	public	JJ
18637	3122	11	liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	3122	12	.	.	.
18637	3123	1	Upon	upon	IN
18637	3123	2	the	the	DT
18637	3123	3	revolution	revolution	NN
18637	3123	4	of	of	IN
18637	3123	5	1688	1688	CD
18637	3123	6	,	,	,
18637	3123	7	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
18637	3123	8	wisely	wisely	RB
18637	3123	9	insisted	insist	VBD
18637	3123	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	3123	11	a	a	DT
18637	3123	12	bill	bill	NN
18637	3123	13	of	of	IN
18637	3123	14	rights	right	NNS
18637	3123	15	,	,	,
18637	3123	16	which	which	WDT
18637	3123	17	should	should	MD
18637	3123	18	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	3123	19	an	an	DT
18637	3123	20	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	3123	21	security	security	NN
18637	3123	22	for	for	IN
18637	3123	23	the	the	DT
18637	3123	24	future	future	NN
18637	3123	25	.	.	.
18637	3124	1	But	but	CC
18637	3124	2	how	how	WRB
18637	3124	3	was	be	VBD
18637	3124	4	this	this	DT
18637	3124	5	done	do	VBN
18637	3124	6	?	?	.
18637	3125	1	Not	not	RB
18637	3125	2	by	by	IN
18637	3125	3	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	3125	4	standing	standing	NN
18637	3125	5	armies	army	NNS
18637	3125	6	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	3125	7	in	in	IN
18637	3125	8	time	time	NN
18637	3125	9	of	of	IN
18637	3125	10	peace	peace	NN
18637	3125	11	;	;	:
18637	3125	12	but	but	CC
18637	3125	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3125	14	as	as	IN
18637	3125	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	3125	16	been	be	VBN
18637	3125	17	already	already	RB
18637	3125	18	seen	see	VBN
18637	3125	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3125	20	by	by	IN
18637	3125	21	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	3125	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3125	23	_	_	NNP
18637	3125	24	without	without	IN
18637	3125	25	the	the	DT
18637	3125	26	consent	consent	NN
18637	3125	27	of	of	IN
18637	3125	28	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
18637	3125	29	_	_	NNP
18637	3125	30	.	.	.
18637	3126	1	This	this	DT
18637	3126	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	3126	3	the	the	DT
18637	3126	4	very	very	JJ
18637	3126	5	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	3126	6	contained	contain	VBN
18637	3126	7	in	in	IN
18637	3126	8	the	the	DT
18637	3126	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3126	10	;	;	:
18637	3126	11	for	for	IN
18637	3126	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3126	13	can	can	MD
18637	3126	14	alone	alone	RB
18637	3126	15	raise	raise	VB
18637	3126	16	armies	army	NNS
18637	3126	17	;	;	:
18637	3126	18	and	and	CC
18637	3126	19	may	may	MD
18637	3126	20	put	put	VB
18637	3126	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3126	22	down	down	RP
18637	3126	23	,	,	,
18637	3126	24	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	3126	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3126	26	choose	choose	VBP
18637	3126	27	.	.	.
18637	3127	1	"	"	``
18637	3127	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3127	3	1228	1228	CD
18637	3127	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3127	5	THE	the	DT
18637	3127	6	TIME	time	NN
18637	3127	7	LIMIT	limit	NN
18637	3127	8	ON	on	IN
18637	3127	9	APPROPRIATIONS	APPROPRIATIONS	NNP
18637	3127	10	FOR	for	IN
18637	3127	11	THE	the	DT
18637	3127	12	ARMY	ARMY	NNP
18637	3127	13	Prompted	prompt	VBN
18637	3127	14	by	by	IN
18637	3127	15	the	the	DT
18637	3127	16	fear	fear	NN
18637	3127	17	of	of	IN
18637	3127	18	standing	stand	VBG
18637	3127	19	armies	army	NNS
18637	3127	20	to	to	IN
18637	3127	21	which	which	WDT
18637	3127	22	Story	story	NN
18637	3127	23	alluded	allude	VBD
18637	3127	24	,	,	,
18637	3127	25	the	the	DT
18637	3127	26	framers	framer	NNS
18637	3127	27	inserted	insert	VBD
18637	3127	28	the	the	DT
18637	3127	29	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	3127	30	that	that	IN
18637	3127	31	"	"	``
18637	3127	32	no	no	DT
18637	3127	33	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	3127	34	of	of	IN
18637	3127	35	money	money	NN
18637	3127	36	to	to	IN
18637	3127	37	that	that	DT
18637	3127	38	use	use	NN
18637	3127	39	shall	shall	MD
18637	3127	40	be	be	VB
18637	3127	41	for	for	IN
18637	3127	42	a	a	DT
18637	3127	43	longer	long	JJR
18637	3127	44	term	term	NN
18637	3127	45	than	than	IN
18637	3127	46	two	two	CD
18637	3127	47	years	year	NNS
18637	3127	48	.	.	.
18637	3127	49	"	"	''
18637	3128	1	In	in	IN
18637	3128	2	1904	1904	CD
18637	3128	3	the	the	DT
18637	3128	4	question	question	NN
18637	3128	5	arose	arise	VBD
18637	3128	6	whether	whether	IN
18637	3128	7	this	this	DT
18637	3128	8	provision	provision	NN
18637	3128	9	would	would	MD
18637	3128	10	be	be	VB
18637	3128	11	violated	violate	VBN
18637	3128	12	if	if	IN
18637	3128	13	the	the	DT
18637	3128	14	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3128	15	contracted	contract	VBD
18637	3128	16	to	to	TO
18637	3128	17	pay	pay	VB
18637	3128	18	a	a	DT
18637	3128	19	royalty	royalty	NN
18637	3128	20	for	for	IN
18637	3128	21	use	use	NN
18637	3128	22	of	of	IN
18637	3128	23	a	a	DT
18637	3128	24	patent	patent	NN
18637	3128	25	in	in	IN
18637	3128	26	constructing	construct	VBG
18637	3128	27	guns	gun	NNS
18637	3128	28	and	and	CC
18637	3128	29	other	other	JJ
18637	3128	30	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	3128	31	where	where	WRB
18637	3128	32	the	the	DT
18637	3128	33	payments	payment	NNS
18637	3128	34	were	be	VBD
18637	3128	35	likely	likely	JJ
18637	3128	36	to	to	TO
18637	3128	37	continue	continue	VB
18637	3128	38	for	for	IN
18637	3128	39	more	more	JJR
18637	3128	40	than	than	IN
18637	3128	41	two	two	CD
18637	3128	42	years	year	NNS
18637	3128	43	.	.	.
18637	3129	1	Solicitor	Solicitor	NNP
18637	3129	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	3129	3	General	General	NNP
18637	3129	4	Hoyt	Hoyt	NNP
18637	3129	5	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	3129	6	that	that	IN
18637	3129	7	such	such	PDT
18637	3129	8	a	a	DT
18637	3129	9	contract	contract	NN
18637	3129	10	would	would	MD
18637	3129	11	be	be	VB
18637	3129	12	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	3129	13	;	;	:
18637	3129	14	that	that	IN
18637	3129	15	the	the	DT
18637	3129	16	appropriations	appropriation	NNS
18637	3129	17	limited	limit	VBN
18637	3129	18	by	by	IN
18637	3129	19	the	the	DT
18637	3129	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3129	21	"	"	``
18637	3129	22	are	be	VBP
18637	3129	23	those	those	DT
18637	3129	24	only	only	JJ
18637	3129	25	which	which	WDT
18637	3129	26	are	be	VBP
18637	3129	27	to	to	TO
18637	3129	28	raise	raise	VB
18637	3129	29	and	and	CC
18637	3129	30	support	support	VB
18637	3129	31	armies	army	NNS
18637	3129	32	in	in	IN
18637	3129	33	the	the	DT
18637	3129	34	strict	strict	JJ
18637	3129	35	sense	sense	NN
18637	3129	36	of	of	IN
18637	3129	37	the	the	DT
18637	3129	38	word	word	NN
18637	3129	39	'	'	''
18637	3129	40	support	support	NN
18637	3129	41	,	,	,
18637	3129	42	'	'	''
18637	3129	43	and	and	CC
18637	3129	44	that	that	IN
18637	3129	45	the	the	DT
18637	3129	46	inhibition	inhibition	NN
18637	3129	47	of	of	IN
18637	3129	48	that	that	DT
18637	3129	49	clause	clause	NN
18637	3129	50	does	do	VBZ
18637	3129	51	not	not	RB
18637	3129	52	extend	extend	VB
18637	3129	53	to	to	IN
18637	3129	54	appropriations	appropriation	NNS
18637	3129	55	for	for	IN
18637	3129	56	the	the	DT
18637	3129	57	various	various	JJ
18637	3129	58	means	mean	NNS
18637	3129	59	which	which	WDT
18637	3129	60	an	an	DT
18637	3129	61	army	army	NN
18637	3129	62	may	may	MD
18637	3129	63	use	use	VB
18637	3129	64	in	in	IN
18637	3129	65	military	military	JJ
18637	3129	66	operations	operation	NNS
18637	3129	67	,	,	,
18637	3129	68	or	or	CC
18637	3129	69	which	which	WDT
18637	3129	70	are	be	VBP
18637	3129	71	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	3129	72	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3129	73	for	for	IN
18637	3129	74	the	the	DT
18637	3129	75	common	common	JJ
18637	3129	76	defense	defense	NN
18637	3129	77	,	,	,
18637	3129	78	*	*	NFP
18637	3129	79	*	*	NFP
18637	3129	80	*	*	NFP
18637	3129	81	"	"	''
18637	3129	82	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3129	83	1229	1229	CD
18637	3129	84	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3129	85	Relying	rely	VBG
18637	3129	86	on	on	IN
18637	3129	87	this	this	DT
18637	3129	88	earlier	early	JJR
18637	3129	89	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3129	90	,	,	,
18637	3129	91	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	3129	92	General	General	NNP
18637	3129	93	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	3129	94	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	3129	95	in	in	IN
18637	3129	96	1948	1948	CD
18637	3129	97	that	that	IN
18637	3129	98	there	there	EX
18637	3129	99	was	be	VBD
18637	3129	100	"	"	``
18637	3129	101	no	no	DT
18637	3129	102	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3129	103	objection	objection	NN
18637	3129	104	to	to	IN
18637	3129	105	a	a	DT
18637	3129	106	request	request	NN
18637	3129	107	to	to	IN
18637	3129	108	the	the	DT
18637	3129	109	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3129	110	to	to	TO
18637	3129	111	appropriate	appropriate	VB
18637	3129	112	funds	fund	NNS
18637	3129	113	to	to	IN
18637	3129	114	the	the	DT
18637	3129	115	Air	Air	NNP
18637	3129	116	Force	Force	NNP
18637	3129	117	for	for	IN
18637	3129	118	the	the	DT
18637	3129	119	procurement	procurement	NN
18637	3129	120	of	of	IN
18637	3129	121	aircraft	aircraft	NN
18637	3129	122	and	and	CC
18637	3129	123	aeronautical	aeronautical	JJ
18637	3129	124	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	3129	125	to	to	TO
18637	3129	126	remain	remain	VB
18637	3129	127	available	available	JJ
18637	3129	128	until	until	IN
18637	3129	129	expended	expend	VBN
18637	3129	130	.	.	.
18637	3130	1	"	"	``
18637	3130	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3130	3	1230	1230	CD
18637	3130	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3130	5	ESTABLISHMENT	ESTABLISHMENT	NNP
18637	3130	6	OF	of	IN
18637	3130	7	THE	the	DT
18637	3130	8	AIR	AIR	NNP
18637	3130	9	FORCE	FORCE	NNP
18637	3130	10	By	by	IN
18637	3130	11	the	the	DT
18637	3130	12	National	National	NNP
18637	3130	13	Security	Security	NNP
18637	3130	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3130	15	of	of	IN
18637	3130	16	1947[1231	1947[1231	NNP
18637	3130	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3130	18	there	there	EX
18637	3130	19	was	be	VBD
18637	3130	20	established	establish	VBN
18637	3130	21	within	within	IN
18637	3130	22	the	the	DT
18637	3130	23	National	National	NNP
18637	3130	24	Military	Military	NNP
18637	3130	25	Establishment	Establishment	NNP
18637	3130	26	"	"	''
18637	3130	27	an	an	DT
18637	3130	28	executive	executive	JJ
18637	3130	29	department	department	NN
18637	3130	30	to	to	TO
18637	3130	31	be	be	VB
18637	3130	32	known	know	VBN
18637	3130	33	as	as	IN
18637	3130	34	the	the	DT
18637	3130	35	Department	Department	NNP
18637	3130	36	of	of	IN
18637	3130	37	the	the	DT
18637	3130	38	Air	Air	NNP
18637	3130	39	Force	Force	NNP
18637	3130	40	"	"	''
18637	3130	41	which	which	WDT
18637	3130	42	was	be	VBD
18637	3130	43	made	make	VBN
18637	3130	44	coordinate	coordinate	JJ
18637	3130	45	with	with	IN
18637	3130	46	the	the	DT
18637	3130	47	Departments	Departments	NNPS
18637	3130	48	of	of	IN
18637	3130	49	the	the	DT
18637	3130	50	Army	Army	NNP
18637	3130	51	and	and	CC
18637	3130	52	the	the	DT
18637	3130	53	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	3130	54	.	.	.
18637	3131	1	Shortly	shortly	RB
18637	3131	2	after	after	IN
18637	3131	3	the	the	DT
18637	3131	4	passage	passage	NN
18637	3131	5	of	of	IN
18637	3131	6	this	this	DT
18637	3131	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3131	8	a	a	DT
18637	3131	9	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	3131	10	Resolution	Resolution	NNP
18637	3131	11	was	be	VBD
18637	3131	12	offered	offer	VBN
18637	3131	13	in	in	IN
18637	3131	14	the	the	DT
18637	3131	15	House	House	NNP
18637	3131	16	of	of	IN
18637	3131	17	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	3131	18	,	,	,
18637	3131	19	proposing	propose	VBG
18637	3131	20	an	an	DT
18637	3131	21	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	3131	22	to	to	IN
18637	3131	23	the	the	DT
18637	3131	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3131	25	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	3131	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3131	27	would	would	MD
18637	3131	28	be	be	VB
18637	3131	29	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	3131	30	to	to	TO
18637	3131	31	"	"	``
18637	3131	32	provide	provide	VB
18637	3131	33	and	and	CC
18637	3131	34	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	3131	35	an	an	DT
18637	3131	36	Air	Air	NNP
18637	3131	37	Force	Force	NNP
18637	3131	38	and	and	CC
18637	3131	39	to	to	TO
18637	3131	40	make	make	VB
18637	3131	41	rules	rule	NNS
18637	3131	42	for	for	IN
18637	3131	43	the	the	DT
18637	3131	44	government	government	NN
18637	3131	45	and	and	CC
18637	3131	46	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	3131	47	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	3131	48	,	,	,
18637	3131	49	"	"	''
18637	3131	50	and	and	CC
18637	3131	51	the	the	DT
18637	3131	52	President	President	NNP
18637	3131	53	would	would	MD
18637	3131	54	be	be	VB
18637	3131	55	designated	designate	VBN
18637	3131	56	as	as	IN
18637	3131	57	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	3131	58	in	in	IN
18637	3131	59	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3131	60	of	of	IN
18637	3131	61	the	the	DT
18637	3131	62	Air	Air	NNP
18637	3131	63	Force	Force	NNP
18637	3131	64	.	.	.
18637	3132	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3132	2	1232	1232	CD
18637	3132	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3132	4	Apparently	apparently	RB
18637	3132	5	in	in	IN
18637	3132	6	the	the	DT
18637	3132	7	belief	belief	NN
18637	3132	8	that	that	IN
18637	3132	9	the	the	DT
18637	3132	10	broad	broad	JJ
18637	3132	11	sweep	sweep	NN
18637	3132	12	of	of	IN
18637	3132	13	the	the	DT
18637	3132	14	war	war	NN
18637	3132	15	power	power	NN
18637	3132	16	warranted	warrant	VBD
18637	3132	17	the	the	DT
18637	3132	18	creation	creation	NN
18637	3132	19	of	of	IN
18637	3132	20	the	the	DT
18637	3132	21	Air	Air	NNP
18637	3132	22	Force	Force	NNP
18637	3132	23	,	,	,
18637	3132	24	without	without	IN
18637	3132	25	a	a	DT
18637	3132	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3132	27	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	3132	28	,	,	,
18637	3132	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3132	30	took	take	VBD
18637	3132	31	no	no	DT
18637	3132	32	action	action	NN
18637	3132	33	on	on	IN
18637	3132	34	this	this	DT
18637	3132	35	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	3132	36	.	.	.
18637	3133	1	CONSCRIPTION	conscription	VB
18637	3133	2	The	the	DT
18637	3133	3	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	3133	4	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	3133	5	during	during	IN
18637	3133	6	the	the	DT
18637	3133	7	Revolutionary	Revolutionary	NNP
18637	3133	8	War	War	NNP
18637	3133	9	by	by	IN
18637	3133	10	at	at	RB
18637	3133	11	least	least	RBS
18637	3133	12	nine	nine	CD
18637	3133	13	of	of	IN
18637	3133	14	the	the	DT
18637	3133	15	States	States	NNPS
18637	3133	16	sanctioned	sanction	VBD
18637	3133	17	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	3133	18	military	military	JJ
18637	3133	19	service	service	NN
18637	3133	20	.	.	.
18637	3134	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3134	2	1233	1233	CD
18637	3134	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3134	4	Towards	towards	IN
18637	3134	5	the	the	DT
18637	3134	6	end	end	NN
18637	3134	7	of	of	IN
18637	3134	8	the	the	DT
18637	3134	9	War	War	NNP
18637	3134	10	of	of	IN
18637	3134	11	1812	1812	CD
18637	3134	12	,	,	,
18637	3134	13	conscription	conscription	NN
18637	3134	14	of	of	IN
18637	3134	15	men	man	NNS
18637	3134	16	for	for	IN
18637	3134	17	the	the	DT
18637	3134	18	army	army	NN
18637	3134	19	was	be	VBD
18637	3134	20	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	3134	21	by	by	IN
18637	3134	22	James	James	NNP
18637	3134	23	Monroe	Monroe	NNP
18637	3134	24	,	,	,
18637	3134	25	then	then	RB
18637	3134	26	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	3134	27	of	of	IN
18637	3134	28	War	War	NNP
18637	3134	29	,	,	,
18637	3134	30	but	but	CC
18637	3134	31	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	3134	32	developed	develop	VBN
18637	3134	33	and	and	CC
18637	3134	34	peace	peace	NN
18637	3134	35	came	come	VBD
18637	3134	36	before	before	IN
18637	3134	37	the	the	DT
18637	3134	38	bill	bill	NN
18637	3134	39	could	could	MD
18637	3134	40	be	be	VB
18637	3134	41	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	3134	42	.	.	.
18637	3135	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3135	2	1234	1234	CD
18637	3135	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3135	4	In	in	IN
18637	3135	5	1863	1863	CD
18637	3135	6	a	a	DT
18637	3135	7	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	3135	8	draft	draft	NN
18637	3135	9	law	law	NN
18637	3135	10	was	be	VBD
18637	3135	11	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	3135	12	and	and	CC
18637	3135	13	put	put	VBN
18637	3135	14	into	into	IN
18637	3135	15	operation	operation	NN
18637	3135	16	without	without	IN
18637	3135	17	being	be	VBG
18637	3135	18	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	3135	19	in	in	IN
18637	3135	20	the	the	DT
18637	3135	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3135	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	3135	23	.	.	.
18637	3136	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3136	2	1235	1235	CD
18637	3136	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3136	4	Not	not	RB
18637	3136	5	so	so	IN
18637	3136	6	the	the	DT
18637	3136	7	Selective	Selective	NNP
18637	3136	8	Service	Service	NNP
18637	3136	9	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3136	10	of	of	IN
18637	3136	11	1917	1917	CD
18637	3136	12	.	.	.
18637	3137	1	This	this	DT
18637	3137	2	measure	measure	NN
18637	3137	3	was	be	VBD
18637	3137	4	attacked	attack	VBN
18637	3137	5	on	on	IN
18637	3137	6	the	the	DT
18637	3137	7	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	3137	8	that	that	IN
18637	3137	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3137	10	tended	tend	VBD
18637	3137	11	to	to	TO
18637	3137	12	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	3137	13	the	the	DT
18637	3137	14	States	States	NNPS
18637	3137	15	of	of	IN
18637	3137	16	the	the	DT
18637	3137	17	right	right	NN
18637	3137	18	to	to	TO
18637	3137	19	"	"	``
18637	3137	20	a	a	DT
18637	3137	21	well	well	RB
18637	3137	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	3137	23	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	3137	24	militia	militia	NN
18637	3137	25	,	,	,
18637	3137	26	"	"	''
18637	3137	27	that	that	IN
18637	3137	28	the	the	DT
18637	3137	29	only	only	JJ
18637	3137	30	power	power	NN
18637	3137	31	of	of	IN
18637	3137	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3137	33	to	to	TO
18637	3137	34	exact	exact	VB
18637	3137	35	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	3137	36	service	service	NN
18637	3137	37	was	be	VBD
18637	3137	38	the	the	DT
18637	3137	39	power	power	NN
18637	3137	40	to	to	TO
18637	3137	41	provide	provide	VB
18637	3137	42	for	for	IN
18637	3137	43	calling	call	VBG
18637	3137	44	forth	forth	RP
18637	3137	45	the	the	DT
18637	3137	46	militia	militia	NN
18637	3137	47	for	for	IN
18637	3137	48	the	the	DT
18637	3137	49	three	three	CD
18637	3137	50	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	3137	51	specified	specify	VBN
18637	3137	52	in	in	IN
18637	3137	53	the	the	DT
18637	3137	54	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3137	55	,	,	,
18637	3137	56	which	which	WDT
18637	3137	57	did	do	VBD
18637	3137	58	not	not	RB
18637	3137	59	comprehend	comprehend	VB
18637	3137	60	service	service	NN
18637	3137	61	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	3137	62	,	,	,
18637	3137	63	and	and	CC
18637	3137	64	finally	finally	RB
18637	3137	65	that	that	IN
18637	3137	66	the	the	DT
18637	3137	67	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	3137	68	draft	draft	NN
18637	3137	69	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	3137	70	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	3137	71	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	3137	72	in	in	IN
18637	3137	73	violation	violation	NN
18637	3137	74	of	of	IN
18637	3137	75	the	the	DT
18637	3137	76	Thirteenth	Thirteenth	NNP
18637	3137	77	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3137	78	.	.	.
18637	3138	1	The	the	DT
18637	3138	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3138	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3138	4	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	3138	5	all	all	DT
18637	3138	6	of	of	IN
18637	3138	7	these	these	DT
18637	3138	8	contentions	contention	NNS
18637	3138	9	.	.	.
18637	3139	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3139	2	held	hold	VBD
18637	3139	3	that	that	IN
18637	3139	4	the	the	DT
18637	3139	5	powers	power	NNS
18637	3139	6	of	of	IN
18637	3139	7	the	the	DT
18637	3139	8	States	States	NNPS
18637	3139	9	with	with	IN
18637	3139	10	respect	respect	NN
18637	3139	11	to	to	IN
18637	3139	12	the	the	DT
18637	3139	13	militia	militia	NN
18637	3139	14	were	be	VBD
18637	3139	15	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	3139	16	in	in	IN
18637	3139	17	subordination	subordination	NN
18637	3139	18	to	to	IN
18637	3139	19	the	the	DT
18637	3139	20	paramount	paramount	JJ
18637	3139	21	power	power	NN
18637	3139	22	of	of	IN
18637	3139	23	the	the	DT
18637	3139	24	National	National	NNP
18637	3139	25	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3139	26	to	to	TO
18637	3139	27	raise	raise	VB
18637	3139	28	and	and	CC
18637	3139	29	support	support	VB
18637	3139	30	armies	army	NNS
18637	3139	31	,	,	,
18637	3139	32	and	and	CC
18637	3139	33	that	that	IN
18637	3139	34	the	the	DT
18637	3139	35	power	power	NN
18637	3139	36	of	of	IN
18637	3139	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3139	38	to	to	TO
18637	3139	39	mobilize	mobilize	VB
18637	3139	40	an	an	DT
18637	3139	41	army	army	NN
18637	3139	42	was	be	VBD
18637	3139	43	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	3139	44	from	from	IN
18637	3139	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3139	46	authority	authority	NN
18637	3139	47	to	to	TO
18637	3139	48	provide	provide	VB
18637	3139	49	for	for	IN
18637	3139	50	calling	call	VBG
18637	3139	51	the	the	DT
18637	3139	52	militia	militia	NN
18637	3139	53	and	and	CC
18637	3139	54	was	be	VBD
18637	3139	55	not	not	RB
18637	3139	56	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	3139	57	or	or	CC
18637	3139	58	in	in	IN
18637	3139	59	any	any	DT
18637	3139	60	wise	wise	JJ
18637	3139	61	limited	limited	JJ
18637	3139	62	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	3139	63	.	.	.
18637	3140	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3140	2	1236	1236	CD
18637	3140	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3140	4	Before	before	IN
18637	3140	5	the	the	DT
18637	3140	6	United	United	NNP
18637	3140	7	States	States	NNP
18637	3140	8	entered	enter	VBD
18637	3140	9	the	the	DT
18637	3140	10	first	first	JJ
18637	3140	11	World	World	NNP
18637	3140	12	War	War	NNP
18637	3140	13	,	,	,
18637	3140	14	the	the	DT
18637	3140	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3140	16	had	have	VBD
18637	3140	17	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
18637	3140	18	the	the	DT
18637	3140	19	objection	objection	NN
18637	3140	20	that	that	IN
18637	3140	21	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	3140	22	military	military	JJ
18637	3140	23	service	service	NN
18637	3140	24	would	would	MD
18637	3140	25	violate	violate	VB
18637	3140	26	the	the	DT
18637	3140	27	Thirteenth	Thirteenth	NNP
18637	3140	28	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3140	29	and	and	CC
18637	3140	30	had	have	VBD
18637	3140	31	answered	answer	VBN
18637	3140	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3140	33	in	in	IN
18637	3140	34	the	the	DT
18637	3140	35	following	follow	VBG
18637	3140	36	words	word	NNS
18637	3140	37	:	:	:
18637	3140	38	"	"	``
18637	3140	39	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3140	40	introduced	introduce	VBD
18637	3140	41	no	no	DT
18637	3140	42	novel	novel	JJ
18637	3140	43	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3140	44	with	with	IN
18637	3140	45	respect	respect	NN
18637	3140	46	of	of	IN
18637	3140	47	services	service	NNS
18637	3140	48	always	always	RB
18637	3140	49	treated	treat	VBN
18637	3140	50	as	as	IN
18637	3140	51	exceptional	exceptional	JJ
18637	3140	52	,	,	,
18637	3140	53	and	and	CC
18637	3140	54	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	3140	55	was	be	VBD
18637	3140	56	not	not	RB
18637	3140	57	intended	intend	VBN
18637	3140	58	to	to	TO
18637	3140	59	interdict	interdict	VB
18637	3140	60	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	3140	61	of	of	IN
18637	3140	62	those	those	DT
18637	3140	63	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3140	64	which	which	WDT
18637	3140	65	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	3140	66	owe	owe	VBP
18637	3140	67	to	to	IN
18637	3140	68	the	the	DT
18637	3140	69	State	State	NNP
18637	3140	70	,	,	,
18637	3140	71	such	such	JJ
18637	3140	72	as	as	IN
18637	3140	73	services	service	NNS
18637	3140	74	in	in	IN
18637	3140	75	the	the	DT
18637	3140	76	army	army	NN
18637	3140	77	,	,	,
18637	3140	78	militia	militia	NN
18637	3140	79	,	,	,
18637	3140	80	on	on	IN
18637	3140	81	the	the	DT
18637	3140	82	jury	jury	NN
18637	3140	83	,	,	,
18637	3140	84	etc	etc	FW
18637	3140	85	.	.	.
18637	3141	1	The	the	DT
18637	3141	2	great	great	JJ
18637	3141	3	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3141	4	in	in	IN
18637	3141	5	view	view	NN
18637	3141	6	was	be	VBD
18637	3141	7	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	3141	8	under	under	IN
18637	3141	9	the	the	DT
18637	3141	10	protection	protection	NN
18637	3141	11	of	of	IN
18637	3141	12	effective	effective	JJ
18637	3141	13	government	government	NN
18637	3141	14	,	,	,
18637	3141	15	not	not	RB
18637	3141	16	the	the	DT
18637	3141	17	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	3141	18	of	of	IN
18637	3141	19	the	the	DT
18637	3141	20	latter	latter	JJ
18637	3141	21	by	by	IN
18637	3141	22	depriving	deprive	VBG
18637	3141	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3141	24	of	of	IN
18637	3141	25	essential	essential	JJ
18637	3141	26	powers	power	NNS
18637	3141	27	.	.	.
18637	3142	1	"	"	``
18637	3142	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3142	3	1237	1237	CD
18637	3142	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3142	5	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	3142	6	,	,	,
18637	3142	7	in	in	IN
18637	3142	8	the	the	DT
18637	3142	9	Selective	Selective	NNP
18637	3142	10	Draft	Draft	NNP
18637	3142	11	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3142	12	Cases[1238	Cases[1238	NNP
18637	3142	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3142	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3142	15	dismissed	dismiss	VBD
18637	3142	16	the	the	DT
18637	3142	17	objection	objection	NN
18637	3142	18	under	under	IN
18637	3142	19	that	that	DT
18637	3142	20	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	3142	21	as	as	IN
18637	3142	22	a	a	DT
18637	3142	23	contention	contention	NN
18637	3142	24	that	that	WDT
18637	3142	25	was	be	VBD
18637	3142	26	"	"	``
18637	3142	27	refuted	refute	VBN
18637	3142	28	by	by	IN
18637	3142	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3142	30	mere	mere	JJ
18637	3142	31	statement	statement	NN
18637	3142	32	.	.	.
18637	3143	1	"	"	``
18637	3143	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3143	3	1239	1239	CD
18637	3143	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3143	5	CARE	care	NN
18637	3143	6	OF	of	IN
18637	3143	7	ARMED	ARMED	NNP
18637	3143	8	FORCES	FORCES	NNP
18637	3143	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3143	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	3143	11	a	a	DT
18637	3143	12	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	3143	13	and	and	CC
18637	3143	14	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3143	15	power	power	NN
18637	3143	16	to	to	TO
18637	3143	17	determine	determine	VB
18637	3143	18	the	the	DT
18637	3143	19	age	age	NN
18637	3143	20	at	at	IN
18637	3143	21	which	which	WDT
18637	3143	22	a	a	DT
18637	3143	23	soldier	soldier	NN
18637	3143	24	or	or	CC
18637	3143	25	seaman	seaman	NN
18637	3143	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	3143	27	be	be	VB
18637	3143	28	received	receive	VBN
18637	3143	29	,	,	,
18637	3143	30	the	the	DT
18637	3143	31	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	3143	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3143	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	3143	34	be	be	VB
18637	3143	35	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	3143	36	and	and	CC
18637	3143	37	the	the	DT
18637	3143	38	service	service	NN
18637	3143	39	to	to	TO
18637	3143	40	which	which	WDT
18637	3143	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3143	42	shall	shall	MD
18637	3143	43	be	be	VB
18637	3143	44	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	3143	45	.	.	.
18637	3144	1	This	this	DT
18637	3144	2	power	power	NN
18637	3144	3	may	may	MD
18637	3144	4	be	be	VB
18637	3144	5	exerted	exert	VBN
18637	3144	6	to	to	TO
18637	3144	7	supersede	supersede	VB
18637	3144	8	parents	parent	NNS
18637	3144	9	'	'	POS
18637	3144	10	control	control	NN
18637	3144	11	of	of	IN
18637	3144	12	minor	minor	JJ
18637	3144	13	sons	son	NNS
18637	3144	14	who	who	WP
18637	3144	15	are	be	VBP
18637	3144	16	needed	need	VBN
18637	3144	17	for	for	IN
18637	3144	18	military	military	JJ
18637	3144	19	service	service	NN
18637	3144	20	.	.	.
18637	3145	1	Where	where	WRB
18637	3145	2	the	the	DT
18637	3145	3	statute	statute	NN
18637	3145	4	which	which	WDT
18637	3145	5	required	require	VBD
18637	3145	6	the	the	DT
18637	3145	7	consent	consent	NN
18637	3145	8	of	of	IN
18637	3145	9	parents	parent	NNS
18637	3145	10	for	for	IN
18637	3145	11	enlistment	enlistment	NN
18637	3145	12	of	of	IN
18637	3145	13	a	a	DT
18637	3145	14	minor	minor	JJ
18637	3145	15	son	son	NN
18637	3145	16	did	do	VBD
18637	3145	17	not	not	RB
18637	3145	18	permit	permit	VB
18637	3145	19	such	such	JJ
18637	3145	20	consent	consent	NN
18637	3145	21	to	to	TO
18637	3145	22	be	be	VB
18637	3145	23	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	3145	24	,	,	,
18637	3145	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3145	26	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	3145	27	to	to	TO
18637	3145	28	impose	impose	VB
18637	3145	29	a	a	DT
18637	3145	30	condition	condition	NN
18637	3145	31	that	that	IN
18637	3145	32	the	the	DT
18637	3145	33	son	son	NN
18637	3145	34	carry	carry	NNP
18637	3145	35	war	war	NN
18637	3145	36	risk	risk	NN
18637	3145	37	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	3145	38	for	for	IN
18637	3145	39	the	the	DT
18637	3145	40	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	3145	41	of	of	IN
18637	3145	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3145	43	mother	mother	NN
18637	3145	44	was	be	VBD
18637	3145	45	not	not	RB
18637	3145	46	binding	bind	VBG
18637	3145	47	on	on	IN
18637	3145	48	the	the	DT
18637	3145	49	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3145	50	.	.	.
18637	3146	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3146	2	1240	1240	CD
18637	3146	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3146	4	Since	since	IN
18637	3146	5	the	the	DT
18637	3146	6	possession	possession	NN
18637	3146	7	of	of	IN
18637	3146	8	government	government	NN
18637	3146	9	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	3146	10	payable	payable	JJ
18637	3146	11	to	to	IN
18637	3146	12	the	the	DT
18637	3146	13	person	person	NN
18637	3146	14	of	of	IN
18637	3146	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3146	16	choice	choice	NN
18637	3146	17	,	,	,
18637	3146	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	3146	19	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	3146	20	to	to	TO
18637	3146	21	enhance	enhance	VB
18637	3146	22	the	the	DT
18637	3146	23	morale	morale	NN
18637	3146	24	of	of	IN
18637	3146	25	the	the	DT
18637	3146	26	serviceman	serviceman	NN
18637	3146	27	,	,	,
18637	3146	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3146	29	may	may	MD
18637	3146	30	permit	permit	VB
18637	3146	31	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3146	32	to	to	TO
18637	3146	33	designate	designate	VB
18637	3146	34	any	any	DT
18637	3146	35	beneficiary	beneficiary	NN
18637	3146	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3146	37	desires	desire	VBZ
18637	3146	38	,	,	,
18637	3146	39	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	3146	40	of	of	IN
18637	3146	41	State	State	NNP
18637	3146	42	law	law	NN
18637	3146	43	,	,	,
18637	3146	44	and	and	CC
18637	3146	45	may	may	MD
18637	3146	46	exempt	exempt	VB
18637	3146	47	the	the	DT
18637	3146	48	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	3146	49	from	from	IN
18637	3146	50	the	the	DT
18637	3146	51	claims	claim	NNS
18637	3146	52	of	of	IN
18637	3146	53	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	3146	54	.	.	.
18637	3147	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3147	2	1241	1241	CD
18637	3147	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3147	4	To	to	TO
18637	3147	5	safeguard	safeguard	VB
18637	3147	6	the	the	DT
18637	3147	7	health	health	NN
18637	3147	8	and	and	CC
18637	3147	9	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	3147	10	of	of	IN
18637	3147	11	the	the	DT
18637	3147	12	armed	armed	JJ
18637	3147	13	forces	force	NNS
18637	3147	14	,	,	,
18637	3147	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3147	16	may	may	MD
18637	3147	17	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	3147	18	the	the	DT
18637	3147	19	suppression	suppression	NN
18637	3147	20	of	of	IN
18637	3147	21	houses	house	NNS
18637	3147	22	of	of	IN
18637	3147	23	ill	ill	JJ
18637	3147	24	fame	fame	NN
18637	3147	25	in	in	IN
18637	3147	26	the	the	DT
18637	3147	27	vicinity	vicinity	NN
18637	3147	28	of	of	IN
18637	3147	29	the	the	DT
18637	3147	30	places	place	NNS
18637	3147	31	where	where	WRB
18637	3147	32	such	such	JJ
18637	3147	33	forces	force	NNS
18637	3147	34	are	be	VBP
18637	3147	35	stationed	station	VBN
18637	3147	36	.	.	.
18637	3148	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3148	2	1242	1242	CD
18637	3148	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3148	4	TRIAL	trial	NN
18637	3148	5	AND	and	CC
18637	3148	6	PUNISHMENT	punishment	NN
18637	3148	7	OF	of	IN
18637	3148	8	OFFENSES	offenses	NN
18637	3148	9	Under	under	IN
18637	3148	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3148	11	power	power	NN
18637	3148	12	to	to	TO
18637	3148	13	make	make	VB
18637	3148	14	rules	rule	NNS
18637	3148	15	for	for	IN
18637	3148	16	the	the	DT
18637	3148	17	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3148	18	and	and	CC
18637	3148	19	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	3148	20	of	of	IN
18637	3148	21	the	the	DT
18637	3148	22	land	land	NN
18637	3148	23	and	and	CC
18637	3148	24	naval	naval	JJ
18637	3148	25	forces	force	NNS
18637	3148	26	,	,	,
18637	3148	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3148	28	may	may	MD
18637	3148	29	provide	provide	VB
18637	3148	30	for	for	IN
18637	3148	31	the	the	DT
18637	3148	32	trial	trial	NN
18637	3148	33	and	and	CC
18637	3148	34	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	3148	35	of	of	IN
18637	3148	36	military	military	NN
18637	3148	37	and	and	CC
18637	3148	38	naval	naval	JJ
18637	3148	39	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3148	40	in	in	IN
18637	3148	41	the	the	DT
18637	3148	42	manner	manner	NN
18637	3148	43	practiced	practice	VBN
18637	3148	44	by	by	IN
18637	3148	45	civilized	civilized	JJ
18637	3148	46	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3148	47	.	.	.
18637	3149	1	This	this	DT
18637	3149	2	authority	authority	NN
18637	3149	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	3149	4	independent	independent	JJ
18637	3149	5	of	of	IN
18637	3149	6	the	the	DT
18637	3149	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3149	8	power	power	NN
18637	3149	9	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	3149	10	by	by	IN
18637	3149	11	article	article	NN
18637	3149	12	III	iii	CD
18637	3149	13	.	.	.
18637	3150	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3150	2	1243	1243	CD
18637	3150	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3150	4	"	"	``
18637	3150	5	Cases	case	NNS
18637	3150	6	arising	arise	VBG
18637	3150	7	in	in	IN
18637	3150	8	the	the	DT
18637	3150	9	land	land	NN
18637	3150	10	and	and	CC
18637	3150	11	naval	naval	JJ
18637	3150	12	forces	force	NNS
18637	3150	13	"	"	``
18637	3150	14	are	be	VBP
18637	3150	15	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	3150	16	excepted	except	VBN
18637	3150	17	from	from	IN
18637	3150	18	the	the	DT
18637	3150	19	provision	provision	NN
18637	3150	20	of	of	IN
18637	3150	21	the	the	DT
18637	3150	22	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	3150	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3150	24	requiring	require	VBG
18637	3150	25	presentment	presentment	NN
18637	3150	26	by	by	IN
18637	3150	27	a	a	DT
18637	3150	28	grand	grand	JJ
18637	3150	29	jury	jury	NN
18637	3150	30	for	for	IN
18637	3150	31	capital	capital	NN
18637	3150	32	or	or	CC
18637	3150	33	infamous	infamous	JJ
18637	3150	34	and	and	CC
18637	3150	35	by	by	IN
18637	3150	36	implication	implication	NN
18637	3150	37	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3150	38	are	be	VBP
18637	3150	39	also	also	RB
18637	3150	40	excepted	except	VBN
18637	3150	41	from	from	IN
18637	3150	42	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3150	43	VI,[1244	VI,[1244	NNP
18637	3150	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3150	45	which	which	WDT
18637	3150	46	relates	relate	VBZ
18637	3150	47	to	to	IN
18637	3150	48	the	the	DT
18637	3150	49	trial	trial	NN
18637	3150	50	of	of	IN
18637	3150	51	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	3150	52	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3150	53	.	.	.
18637	3151	1	Also	also	RB
18637	3151	2	the	the	DT
18637	3151	3	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	3151	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3151	5	's	's	POS
18637	3151	6	provision	provision	NN
18637	3151	7	against	against	IN
18637	3151	8	double	double	JJ
18637	3151	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	3151	10	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	3151	11	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	3151	12	does	do	VBZ
18637	3151	13	not	not	RB
18637	3151	14	apply	apply	VB
18637	3151	15	to	to	IN
18637	3151	16	military	military	JJ
18637	3151	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	3151	18	.	.	.
18637	3152	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3152	2	1245	1245	CD
18637	3152	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3152	4	A	a	DT
18637	3152	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	3152	6	which	which	WDT
18637	3152	7	provided	provide	VBD
18637	3152	8	that	that	IN
18637	3152	9	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3152	10	not	not	RB
18637	3152	11	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	3152	12	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	3152	13	therein	therein	RB
18637	3152	14	should	should	MD
18637	3152	15	be	be	VB
18637	3152	16	punished	punish	VBN
18637	3152	17	"	"	``
18637	3152	18	according	accord	VBG
18637	3152	19	to	to	IN
18637	3152	20	the	the	DT
18637	3152	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	3152	22	and	and	CC
18637	3152	23	customs	custom	NNS
18637	3152	24	of	of	IN
18637	3152	25	such	such	JJ
18637	3152	26	cases	case	NNS
18637	3152	27	at	at	IN
18637	3152	28	sea	sea	NN
18637	3152	29	"	"	''
18637	3152	30	was	be	VBD
18637	3152	31	held	hold	VBN
18637	3152	32	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	3152	33	to	to	TO
18637	3152	34	give	give	VB
18637	3152	35	a	a	DT
18637	3152	36	naval	naval	JJ
18637	3152	37	court	court	NN
18637	3152	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	3152	39	martial	martial	JJ
18637	3152	40	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3152	41	to	to	TO
18637	3152	42	try	try	VB
18637	3152	43	a	a	DT
18637	3152	44	seaman	seaman	NN
18637	3152	45	of	of	IN
18637	3152	46	the	the	DT
18637	3152	47	United	United	NNP
18637	3152	48	States	States	NNP
18637	3152	49	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	3152	50	for	for	IN
18637	3152	51	the	the	DT
18637	3152	52	unspecified	unspecified	JJ
18637	3152	53	offense	offense	NN
18637	3152	54	of	of	IN
18637	3152	55	attempted	attempt	VBN
18637	3152	56	desertion	desertion	NN
18637	3152	57	.	.	.
18637	3153	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3153	2	1246	1246	CD
18637	3153	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3153	4	In	in	IN
18637	3153	5	_	_	NNP
18637	3153	6	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	3153	7	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	3153	8	_	_	NNP
18637	3153	9	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	3153	10	a	a	DT
18637	3153	11	court	court	NN
18637	3153	12	can	can	MD
18637	3153	13	consider	consider	VB
18637	3153	14	only	only	RB
18637	3153	15	whether	whether	IN
18637	3153	16	the	the	DT
18637	3153	17	military	military	JJ
18637	3153	18	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	3153	19	had	have	VBD
18637	3153	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3153	21	to	to	TO
18637	3153	22	act	act	VB
18637	3153	23	in	in	IN
18637	3153	24	the	the	DT
18637	3153	25	case	case	NN
18637	3153	26	under	under	IN
18637	3153	27	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	3153	28	.	.	.
18637	3154	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3154	2	1247	1247	CD
18637	3154	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3154	4	The	the	DT
18637	3154	5	acts	act	NNS
18637	3154	6	of	of	IN
18637	3154	7	a	a	DT
18637	3154	8	court	court	NN
18637	3154	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	3154	10	martial	martial	JJ
18637	3154	11	,	,	,
18637	3154	12	within	within	IN
18637	3154	13	the	the	DT
18637	3154	14	scope	scope	NN
18637	3154	15	of	of	IN
18637	3154	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3154	17	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3154	18	and	and	CC
18637	3154	19	duty	duty	NN
18637	3154	20	,	,	,
18637	3154	21	can	can	MD
18637	3154	22	not	not	RB
18637	3154	23	be	be	VB
18637	3154	24	controlled	control	VBN
18637	3154	25	or	or	CC
18637	3154	26	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	3154	27	in	in	IN
18637	3154	28	the	the	DT
18637	3154	29	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3154	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	3154	31	,	,	,
18637	3154	32	by	by	IN
18637	3154	33	a	a	DT
18637	3154	34	writ	writ	NN
18637	3154	35	of	of	IN
18637	3154	36	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3154	37	or	or	CC
18637	3154	38	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	3154	39	.	.	.
18637	3155	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3155	2	1248	1248	CD
18637	3155	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3155	4	War	War	NNP
18637	3155	5	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
18637	3155	6	THE	the	DT
18637	3155	7	REVOLUTIONARY	REVOLUTIONARY	NNP
18637	3155	8	WAR	WAR	NNP
18637	3155	9	LEGISLATION	LEGISLATION	NNP
18637	3155	10	The	the	DT
18637	3155	11	American	American	NNP
18637	3155	12	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
18637	3155	13	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	3155	14	many	many	JJ
18637	3155	15	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	3155	16	for	for	IN
18637	3155	17	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	3155	18	and	and	CC
18637	3155	19	detailed	detailed	JJ
18637	3155	20	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	3155	21	of	of	IN
18637	3155	22	the	the	DT
18637	3155	23	nation	nation	NN
18637	3155	24	's	's	POS
18637	3155	25	economy	economy	NN
18637	3155	26	in	in	IN
18637	3155	27	time	time	NN
18637	3155	28	of	of	IN
18637	3155	29	war	war	NN
18637	3155	30	.	.	.
18637	3156	1	But	but	CC
18637	3156	2	since	since	IN
18637	3156	3	the	the	DT
18637	3156	4	resolves	resolve	NNS
18637	3156	5	of	of	IN
18637	3156	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3156	7	under	under	IN
18637	3156	8	the	the	DT
18637	3156	9	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	3156	10	of	of	IN
18637	3156	11	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	3156	12	were	be	VBD
18637	3156	13	in	in	IN
18637	3156	14	practical	practical	JJ
18637	3156	15	effect	effect	NN
18637	3156	16	mere	mere	JJ
18637	3156	17	recommendations	recommendation	NNS
18637	3156	18	to	to	IN
18637	3156	19	the	the	DT
18637	3156	20	State	State	NNP
18637	3156	21	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	3156	22	,	,	,
18637	3156	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3156	24	was	be	VBD
18637	3156	25	the	the	DT
18637	3156	26	action	action	NN
18637	3156	27	of	of	IN
18637	3156	28	the	the	DT
18637	3156	29	latter	latter	JJ
18637	3156	30	which	which	WDT
18637	3156	31	made	make	VBD
18637	3156	32	these	these	DT
18637	3156	33	policies	policy	NNS
18637	3156	34	effective	effective	JJ
18637	3156	35	.	.	.
18637	3157	1	On	on	IN
18637	3157	2	November	November	NNP
18637	3157	3	22	22	CD
18637	3157	4	,	,	,
18637	3157	5	1777	1777	CD
18637	3157	6	,	,	,
18637	3157	7	for	for	IN
18637	3157	8	example	example	NN
18637	3157	9	,	,	,
18637	3157	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3157	11	recommended	recommend	VBD
18637	3157	12	to	to	IN
18637	3157	13	the	the	DT
18637	3157	14	States	States	NNPS
18637	3157	15	that	that	IN
18637	3157	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3157	17	take	take	VBP
18637	3157	18	steps	step	NNS
18637	3157	19	"	"	''
18637	3157	20	to	to	TO
18637	3157	21	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	3157	22	and	and	CC
18637	3157	23	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	3157	24	the	the	DT
18637	3157	25	price	price	NN
18637	3157	26	of	of	IN
18637	3157	27	labour	labour	NN
18637	3157	28	,	,	,
18637	3157	29	manufactures	manufacture	NNS
18637	3157	30	,	,	,
18637	3157	31	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3157	32	and	and	CC
18637	3157	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3157	34	internal	internal	JJ
18637	3157	35	produce	produce	NN
18637	3157	36	.	.	.
18637	3158	1	"	"	``
18637	3158	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3158	3	1249	1249	CD
18637	3158	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3158	5	A	a	DT
18637	3158	6	month	month	NN
18637	3158	7	later	later	RB
18637	3158	8	the	the	DT
18637	3158	9	same	same	JJ
18637	3158	10	body	body	NN
18637	3158	11	further	further	RB
18637	3158	12	recommended	recommend	VBD
18637	3158	13	"	"	''
18637	3158	14	to	to	IN
18637	3158	15	the	the	DT
18637	3158	16	respective	respective	JJ
18637	3158	17	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	3158	18	of	of	IN
18637	3158	19	the	the	DT
18637	3158	20	United	United	NNP
18637	3158	21	States	States	NNP
18637	3158	22	,	,	,
18637	3158	23	forthwith	forthwith	JJ
18637	3158	24	to	to	TO
18637	3158	25	enact	enact	VB
18637	3158	26	laws	law	NNS
18637	3158	27	,	,	,
18637	3158	28	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	3158	29	suitable	suitable	JJ
18637	3158	30	persons	person	NNS
18637	3158	31	to	to	TO
18637	3158	32	seize	seize	VB
18637	3158	33	and	and	CC
18637	3158	34	take	take	VB
18637	3158	35	,	,	,
18637	3158	36	for	for	IN
18637	3158	37	the	the	DT
18637	3158	38	use	use	NN
18637	3158	39	of	of	IN
18637	3158	40	the	the	DT
18637	3158	41	continental	continental	NNP
18637	3158	42	army	army	NNP
18637	3158	43	of	of	IN
18637	3158	44	the	the	DT
18637	3158	45	said	say	VBN
18637	3158	46	States	States	NNP
18637	3158	47	,	,	,
18637	3158	48	all	all	DT
18637	3158	49	woolen	woolen	VBN
18637	3158	50	cloths	cloth	NNS
18637	3158	51	,	,	,
18637	3158	52	blankets	blanket	NNS
18637	3158	53	,	,	,
18637	3158	54	linens	linen	NNS
18637	3158	55	,	,	,
18637	3158	56	shoes	shoe	NNS
18637	3158	57	,	,	,
18637	3158	58	stockings	stocking	NNS
18637	3158	59	,	,	,
18637	3158	60	hats	hat	NNS
18637	3158	61	,	,	,
18637	3158	62	and	and	CC
18637	3158	63	other	other	JJ
18637	3158	64	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3158	65	articles	article	NNS
18637	3158	66	of	of	IN
18637	3158	67	clothing	clothing	NN
18637	3158	68	,	,	,
18637	3158	69	*	*	NFP
18637	3158	70	*	*	NFP
18637	3158	71	*	*	NFP
18637	3158	72	"	"	''
18637	3158	73	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3158	74	1250	1250	CD
18637	3158	75	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3158	76	Responding	respond	VBG
18637	3158	77	to	to	IN
18637	3158	78	such	such	JJ
18637	3158	79	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	3158	80	,	,	,
18637	3158	81	or	or	CC
18637	3158	82	acting	act	VBG
18637	3158	83	on	on	IN
18637	3158	84	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3158	85	own	own	JJ
18637	3158	86	initiative	initiative	NN
18637	3158	87	,	,	,
18637	3158	88	the	the	DT
18637	3158	89	State	state	NN
18637	3158	90	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	3158	91	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	3158	92	measure	measure	NN
18637	3158	93	after	after	IN
18637	3158	94	measure	measure	NN
18637	3158	95	which	which	WDT
18637	3158	96	entrenched	entrench	VBD
18637	3158	97	upon	upon	IN
18637	3158	98	the	the	DT
18637	3158	99	normal	normal	JJ
18637	3158	100	life	life	NN
18637	3158	101	of	of	IN
18637	3158	102	the	the	DT
18637	3158	103	community	community	NN
18637	3158	104	very	very	RB
18637	3158	105	drastically	drastically	RB
18637	3158	106	.	.	.
18637	3159	1	Laws	law	NNS
18637	3159	2	were	be	VBD
18637	3159	3	passed	pass	VBN
18637	3159	4	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	3159	5	the	the	DT
18637	3159	6	distillation	distillation	NN
18637	3159	7	of	of	IN
18637	3159	8	whiskey	whiskey	NN
18637	3159	9	and	and	CC
18637	3159	10	other	other	JJ
18637	3159	11	spirits	spirit	NNS
18637	3159	12	in	in	IN
18637	3159	13	order	order	NN
18637	3159	14	to	to	TO
18637	3159	15	conserve	conserve	VB
18637	3159	16	grain	grain	NN
18637	3159	17	supplies;[1251	supplies;[1251	NNP
18637	3159	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3159	19	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	3159	20	prices	price	NNS
18637	3159	21	of	of	IN
18637	3159	22	labor	labor	NN
18637	3159	23	and	and	CC
18637	3159	24	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	3159	25	,	,	,
18637	3159	26	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	3159	27	in	in	IN
18637	3159	28	greatest	great	JJS
18637	3159	29	detail;[1252	detail;[1252	XX
18637	3159	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3159	31	levying	levy	VBG
18637	3159	32	requisitions	requisition	NNS
18637	3159	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	3159	34	the	the	DT
18637	3159	35	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	3159	36	for	for	IN
18637	3159	37	supplies	supply	NNS
18637	3159	38	needed	need	VBN
18637	3159	39	by	by	IN
18637	3159	40	the	the	DT
18637	3159	41	army;[1253	army;[1253	NNPS
18637	3159	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3159	43	and	and	CC
18637	3159	44	so	so	RB
18637	3159	45	on	on	RB
18637	3159	46	.	.	.
18637	3160	1	In	in	IN
18637	3160	2	one	one	CD
18637	3160	3	instance	instance	NN
18637	3160	4	a	a	DT
18637	3160	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	3160	6	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	3160	7	the	the	DT
18637	3160	8	erection	erection	NN
18637	3160	9	of	of	IN
18637	3160	10	an	an	DT
18637	3160	11	arms	arm	NNS
18637	3160	12	manufactory	manufactory	NN
18637	3160	13	for	for	IN
18637	3160	14	the	the	DT
18637	3160	15	United	United	NNP
18637	3160	16	States;[1254	States;[1254	NNP
18637	3160	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3160	18	in	in	IN
18637	3160	19	another	another	DT
18637	3160	20	,	,	,
18637	3160	21	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	3160	22	Slaves	Slaves	NNPS
18637	3160	23	were	be	VBD
18637	3160	24	impressed	impress	VBN
18637	3160	25	for	for	IN
18637	3160	26	labor	labor	NN
18637	3160	27	on	on	IN
18637	3160	28	fortifications	fortification	NNS
18637	3160	29	.	.	.
18637	3161	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3161	2	1255	1255	CD
18637	3161	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3161	4	The	the	DT
18637	3161	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	3161	6	that	that	IN
18637	3161	7	all	all	PDT
18637	3161	8	this	this	DT
18637	3161	9	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3161	10	came	come	VBD
18637	3161	11	from	from	IN
18637	3161	12	the	the	DT
18637	3161	13	State	State	NNP
18637	3161	14	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	3161	15	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	3161	16	the	the	DT
18637	3161	17	war	war	NN
18637	3161	18	power	power	NN
18637	3161	19	was	be	VBD
18637	3161	20	attributed	attribute	VBN
18637	3161	21	to	to	IN
18637	3161	22	the	the	DT
18637	3161	23	"	"	``
18637	3161	24	United	United	NNP
18637	3161	25	States	States	NNP
18637	3161	26	in	in	IN
18637	3161	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3161	28	assembled	assemble	VBD
18637	3161	29	"	"	``
18637	3161	30	served	serve	VBD
18637	3161	31	to	to	TO
18637	3161	32	obscure	obscure	VB
18637	3161	33	the	the	DT
18637	3161	34	fact	fact	NN
18637	3161	35	that	that	IN
18637	3161	36	the	the	DT
18637	3161	37	former	former	JJ
18637	3161	38	was	be	VBD
18637	3161	39	really	really	RB
18637	3161	40	an	an	DT
18637	3161	41	outgrowth	outgrowth	NN
18637	3161	42	of	of	IN
18637	3161	43	the	the	DT
18637	3161	44	latter	latter	JJ
18637	3161	45	.	.	.
18637	3162	1	CIVIL	CIVIL	NNP
18637	3162	2	WAR	WAR	NNP
18637	3162	3	LEGISLATION	LEGISLATION	NNP
18637	3162	4	The	the	DT
18637	3162	5	most	most	RBS
18637	3162	6	pressing	pressing	JJ
18637	3162	7	economic	economic	JJ
18637	3162	8	problem	problem	NN
18637	3162	9	of	of	IN
18637	3162	10	the	the	DT
18637	3162	11	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3162	12	War	War	NNP
18637	3162	13	was	be	VBD
18637	3162	14	that	that	DT
18637	3162	15	of	of	IN
18637	3162	16	finance	finance	NN
18637	3162	17	.	.	.
18637	3163	1	When	when	WRB
18637	3163	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3163	3	found	find	VBD
18637	3163	4	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3163	5	unable	unable	JJ
18637	3163	6	to	to	TO
18637	3163	7	raise	raise	VB
18637	3163	8	money	money	NN
18637	3163	9	to	to	TO
18637	3163	10	pay	pay	VB
18637	3163	11	the	the	DT
18637	3163	12	soldiers	soldier	NNS
18637	3163	13	in	in	IN
18637	3163	14	the	the	DT
18637	3163	15	field	field	NN
18637	3163	16	,	,	,
18637	3163	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3163	18	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	3163	19	the	the	DT
18637	3163	20	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	3163	21	of	of	IN
18637	3163	22	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	3163	23	notes	note	NNS
18637	3163	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3163	25	,	,	,
18637	3163	26	although	although	IN
18637	3163	27	not	not	RB
18637	3163	28	redeemable	redeemable	JJ
18637	3163	29	in	in	IN
18637	3163	30	specie	specie	NNP
18637	3163	31	,	,	,
18637	3163	32	were	be	VBD
18637	3163	33	made	make	VBN
18637	3163	34	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3163	35	tender	tender	NN
18637	3163	36	in	in	IN
18637	3163	37	payment	payment	NN
18637	3163	38	of	of	IN
18637	3163	39	private	private	JJ
18637	3163	40	debts	debt	NNS
18637	3163	41	.	.	.
18637	3164	1	Upon	upon	IN
18637	3164	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3164	3	first	first	JJ
18637	3164	4	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	3164	5	of	of	IN
18637	3164	6	this	this	DT
18637	3164	7	measure	measure	NN
18637	3164	8	,	,	,
18637	3164	9	the	the	DT
18637	3164	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3164	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3164	12	held	hold	VBD
18637	3164	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3164	14	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	3164	15	.	.	.
18637	3165	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3165	2	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	3165	3	that	that	IN
18637	3165	4	even	even	RB
18637	3165	5	if	if	IN
18637	3165	6	the	the	DT
18637	3165	7	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	3165	8	of	of	IN
18637	3165	9	such	such	JJ
18637	3165	10	notes	note	NNS
18637	3165	11	was	be	VBD
18637	3165	12	facilitated	facilitate	VBN
18637	3165	13	by	by	IN
18637	3165	14	giving	give	VBG
18637	3165	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3165	16	the	the	DT
18637	3165	17	quality	quality	NN
18637	3165	18	of	of	IN
18637	3165	19	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3165	20	tender	tender	NN
18637	3165	21	,	,	,
18637	3165	22	that	that	DT
18637	3165	23	result	result	NN
18637	3165	24	did	do	VBD
18637	3165	25	not	not	RB
18637	3165	26	suffice	suffice	VB
18637	3165	27	to	to	TO
18637	3165	28	make	make	VB
18637	3165	29	the	the	DT
18637	3165	30	expedient	expedient	NN
18637	3165	31	an	an	DT
18637	3165	32	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	3165	33	and	and	CC
18637	3165	34	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	3165	35	adapted	adapt	VBN
18637	3165	36	means	mean	NNS
18637	3165	37	for	for	IN
18637	3165	38	the	the	DT
18637	3165	39	execution	execution	NN
18637	3165	40	of	of	IN
18637	3165	41	the	the	DT
18637	3165	42	power	power	NN
18637	3165	43	to	to	TO
18637	3165	44	declare	declare	VB
18637	3165	45	and	and	CC
18637	3165	46	carry	carry	VB
18637	3165	47	on	on	IN
18637	3165	48	war	war	NN
18637	3165	49	.	.	.
18637	3166	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3166	2	1256	1256	CD
18637	3166	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3166	4	Three	three	CD
18637	3166	5	of	of	IN
18637	3166	6	the	the	DT
18637	3166	7	seven	seven	CD
18637	3166	8	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	3166	9	then	then	RB
18637	3166	10	constituting	constitute	VBG
18637	3166	11	the	the	DT
18637	3166	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3166	13	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	3166	14	from	from	IN
18637	3166	15	this	this	DT
18637	3166	16	decision,[1257	decision,[1257	NN
18637	3166	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3166	18	and	and	CC
18637	3166	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3166	20	was	be	VBD
18637	3166	21	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	3166	22	within	within	IN
18637	3166	23	a	a	DT
18637	3166	24	little	little	JJ
18637	3166	25	more	more	JJR
18637	3166	26	than	than	IN
18637	3166	27	a	a	DT
18637	3166	28	year	year	NN
18637	3166	29	,	,	,
18637	3166	30	after	after	IN
18637	3166	31	two	two	CD
18637	3166	32	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	3166	33	in	in	IN
18637	3166	34	the	the	DT
18637	3166	35	membership	membership	NN
18637	3166	36	of	of	IN
18637	3166	37	the	the	DT
18637	3166	38	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3166	39	had	have	VBD
18637	3166	40	been	be	VBN
18637	3166	41	filled	fill	VBN
18637	3166	42	.	.	.
18637	3167	1	One	one	CD
18637	3167	2	of	of	IN
18637	3167	3	the	the	DT
18637	3167	4	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	3167	5	relied	rely	VBN
18637	3167	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	3167	7	by	by	IN
18637	3167	8	the	the	DT
18637	3167	9	new	new	JJ
18637	3167	10	majority	majority	NN
18637	3167	11	to	to	TO
18637	3167	12	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	3167	13	the	the	DT
18637	3167	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	3167	15	was	be	VBD
18637	3167	16	that	that	IN
18637	3167	17	the	the	DT
18637	3167	18	exigencies	exigency	NNS
18637	3167	19	of	of	IN
18637	3167	20	war	war	NN
18637	3167	21	justified	justify	VBD
18637	3167	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3167	23	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	3167	24	under	under	IN
18637	3167	25	the	the	DT
18637	3167	26	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3167	27	and	and	CC
18637	3167	28	proper	proper	JJ
18637	3167	29	clause	clause	NN
18637	3167	30	.	.	.
18637	3168	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3168	2	1258	1258	CD
18637	3168	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3168	4	WORLD	world	NN
18637	3168	5	WAR	WAR	NNP
18637	3168	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3168	7	LEGISLATION	legislation	VBP
18637	3168	8	In	in	IN
18637	3168	9	meeting	meet	VBG
18637	3168	10	the	the	DT
18637	3168	11	strain	strain	NN
18637	3168	12	which	which	WDT
18637	3168	13	World	World	NNP
18637	3168	14	War	War	NNP
18637	3168	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3168	16	put	put	VBD
18637	3168	17	on	on	RP
18637	3168	18	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3168	19	national	national	JJ
18637	3168	20	resources	resource	NNS
18637	3168	21	of	of	IN
18637	3168	22	men	man	NNS
18637	3168	23	and	and	CC
18637	3168	24	material	material	NN
18637	3168	25	,	,	,
18637	3168	26	the	the	DT
18637	3168	27	economic	economic	JJ
18637	3168	28	activities	activity	NNS
18637	3168	29	of	of	IN
18637	3168	30	the	the	DT
18637	3168	31	people	people	NNS
18637	3168	32	were	be	VBD
18637	3168	33	directed	direct	VBN
18637	3168	34	or	or	CC
18637	3168	35	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	3168	36	by	by	IN
18637	3168	37	the	the	DT
18637	3168	38	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3168	39	on	on	IN
18637	3168	40	a	a	DT
18637	3168	41	scale	scale	NN
18637	3168	42	previously	previously	RB
18637	3168	43	unparalleled	unparalleled	JJ
18637	3168	44	.	.	.
18637	3169	1	The	the	DT
18637	3169	2	most	most	RBS
18637	3169	3	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	3169	4	measure	measure	NN
18637	3169	5	of	of	IN
18637	3169	6	control	control	NN
18637	3169	7	was	be	VBD
18637	3169	8	the	the	DT
18637	3169	9	Lever	Lever	NNP
18637	3169	10	Food	Food	NNP
18637	3169	11	and	and	CC
18637	3169	12	Fuel	Fuel	NNP
18637	3169	13	Control	Control	NNP
18637	3169	14	Act,[1259	Act,[1259	NNP
18637	3169	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3169	16	which	which	WDT
18637	3169	17	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	3169	18	the	the	DT
18637	3169	19	President	President	NNP
18637	3169	20	to	to	TO
18637	3169	21	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	3169	22	by	by	IN
18637	3169	23	license	license	NN
18637	3169	24	the	the	DT
18637	3169	25	importation	importation	NN
18637	3169	26	,	,	,
18637	3169	27	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	3169	28	,	,	,
18637	3169	29	storage	storage	NN
18637	3169	30	,	,	,
18637	3169	31	mining	mining	NN
18637	3169	32	or	or	CC
18637	3169	33	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	3169	34	of	of	IN
18637	3169	35	necessaries	necessary	NNS
18637	3169	36	;	;	:
18637	3169	37	to	to	TO
18637	3169	38	requisition	requisition	VB
18637	3169	39	foods	food	NNS
18637	3169	40	,	,	,
18637	3169	41	feeds	feed	VBZ
18637	3169	42	,	,	,
18637	3169	43	and	and	CC
18637	3169	44	fuels	fuel	NNS
18637	3169	45	;	;	:
18637	3169	46	to	to	TO
18637	3169	47	take	take	VB
18637	3169	48	over	over	RP
18637	3169	49	and	and	CC
18637	3169	50	operate	operate	VB
18637	3169	51	factories	factory	NNS
18637	3169	52	,	,	,
18637	3169	53	packinghouses	packinghouse	NNS
18637	3169	54	,	,	,
18637	3169	55	pipelines	pipeline	NNS
18637	3169	56	,	,	,
18637	3169	57	mines	mine	NNS
18637	3169	58	or	or	CC
18637	3169	59	other	other	JJ
18637	3169	60	plants	plant	NNS
18637	3169	61	;	;	:
18637	3169	62	to	to	TO
18637	3169	63	fix	fix	VB
18637	3169	64	a	a	DT
18637	3169	65	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	3169	66	price	price	NN
18637	3169	67	for	for	IN
18637	3169	68	wheat	wheat	NN
18637	3169	69	;	;	:
18637	3169	70	to	to	TO
18637	3169	71	limit	limit	VB
18637	3169	72	,	,	,
18637	3169	73	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	3169	74	or	or	CC
18637	3169	75	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	3169	76	the	the	DT
18637	3169	77	use	use	NN
18637	3169	78	of	of	IN
18637	3169	79	food	food	NN
18637	3169	80	materials	material	NNS
18637	3169	81	in	in	IN
18637	3169	82	the	the	DT
18637	3169	83	production	production	NN
18637	3169	84	of	of	IN
18637	3169	85	alcoholic	alcoholic	JJ
18637	3169	86	beverages	beverage	NNS
18637	3169	87	;	;	:
18637	3169	88	and	and	CC
18637	3169	89	to	to	TO
18637	3169	90	fix	fix	VB
18637	3169	91	the	the	DT
18637	3169	92	price	price	NN
18637	3169	93	of	of	IN
18637	3169	94	coal	coal	NN
18637	3169	95	and	and	CC
18637	3169	96	coke	coke	NN
18637	3169	97	and	and	CC
18637	3169	98	to	to	TO
18637	3169	99	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	3169	100	the	the	DT
18637	3169	101	production	production	NN
18637	3169	102	,	,	,
18637	3169	103	sale	sale	NN
18637	3169	104	and	and	CC
18637	3169	105	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	3169	106	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	3169	107	.	.	.
18637	3170	1	Other	other	JJ
18637	3170	2	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3170	3	clothed	clothe	VBD
18637	3170	4	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3170	5	with	with	IN
18637	3170	6	power	power	NN
18637	3170	7	to	to	TO
18637	3170	8	determine	determine	VB
18637	3170	9	priority	priority	NN
18637	3170	10	in	in	IN
18637	3170	11	car	car	NN
18637	3170	12	service,[1260	service,[1260	NN
18637	3170	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3170	14	to	to	TO
18637	3170	15	license	license	VB
18637	3170	16	trade	trade	NN
18637	3170	17	with	with	IN
18637	3170	18	the	the	DT
18637	3170	19	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	3170	20	and	and	CC
18637	3170	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3170	22	allies,[1261	allies,[1261	NNPS
18637	3170	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3170	24	and	and	CC
18637	3170	25	to	to	TO
18637	3170	26	take	take	VB
18637	3170	27	over	over	RP
18637	3170	28	and	and	CC
18637	3170	29	operate	operate	VB
18637	3170	30	the	the	DT
18637	3170	31	rail	rail	NN
18637	3170	32	and	and	CC
18637	3170	33	water	water	NN
18637	3170	34	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	3170	35	system,[1262	system,[1262	NNP
18637	3170	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3170	37	and	and	CC
18637	3170	38	the	the	DT
18637	3170	39	telephonic	telephonic	JJ
18637	3170	40	and	and	CC
18637	3170	41	telegraphic	telegraphic	JJ
18637	3170	42	communication	communication	NN
18637	3170	43	systems,[1263	systems,[1263	NNP
18637	3170	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3170	45	of	of	IN
18637	3170	46	the	the	DT
18637	3170	47	country	country	NN
18637	3170	48	.	.	.
18637	3171	1	WORLD	WORLD	NNP
18637	3171	2	WAR	WAR	NNP
18637	3171	3	II	II	NNP
18637	3171	4	LEGISLATION	LEGISLATION	NNP
18637	3171	5	Several	several	JJ
18637	3171	6	of	of	IN
18637	3171	7	these	these	DT
18637	3171	8	World	World	NNP
18637	3171	9	War	War	NNP
18637	3171	10	I	I	NNP
18637	3171	11	measures	measure	NNS
18637	3171	12	were	be	VBD
18637	3171	13	still	still	RB
18637	3171	14	on	on	IN
18637	3171	15	the	the	DT
18637	3171	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	3171	17	books	book	NNS
18637	3171	18	when	when	WRB
18637	3171	19	World	World	NNP
18637	3171	20	War	War	NNP
18637	3171	21	II	II	NNP
18637	3171	22	broke	break	VBD
18637	3171	23	out	out	RP
18637	3171	24	.	.	.
18637	3172	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	3172	2	,	,	,
18637	3172	3	in	in	IN
18637	3172	4	the	the	DT
18637	3172	5	period	period	NN
18637	3172	6	of	of	IN
18637	3172	7	preparation	preparation	NN
18637	3172	8	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	3172	9	the	the	DT
18637	3172	10	latter	latter	JJ
18637	3172	11	,	,	,
18637	3172	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3172	13	had	have	VBD
18637	3172	14	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	3172	15	the	the	DT
18637	3172	16	Priorities	Priorities	NNPS
18637	3172	17	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3172	18	of	of	IN
18637	3172	19	May	May	NNP
18637	3172	20	31	31	CD
18637	3172	21	,	,	,
18637	3172	22	1941[1264	1941[1264	CD
18637	3172	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3172	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3172	25	gave	give	VBD
18637	3172	26	the	the	DT
18637	3172	27	President	President	NNP
18637	3172	28	power	power	NN
18637	3172	29	to	to	TO
18637	3172	30	allocate	allocate	VB
18637	3172	31	any	any	DT
18637	3172	32	material	material	NN
18637	3172	33	where	where	WRB
18637	3172	34	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3172	35	to	to	TO
18637	3172	36	facilitate	facilitate	VB
18637	3172	37	the	the	DT
18637	3172	38	defense	defense	NN
18637	3172	39	effort	effort	NN
18637	3172	40	.	.	.
18637	3173	1	By	by	IN
18637	3173	2	the	the	DT
18637	3173	3	Second	Second	NNP
18637	3173	4	War	War	NNP
18637	3173	5	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	3173	6	Act,[1265	act,[1265	NN
18637	3173	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3173	8	passed	pass	VBD
18637	3173	9	early	early	RB
18637	3173	10	in	in	IN
18637	3173	11	1942	1942	CD
18637	3173	12	,	,	,
18637	3173	13	the	the	DT
18637	3173	14	authority	authority	NN
18637	3173	15	to	to	TO
18637	3173	16	allocate	allocate	VB
18637	3173	17	materials	material	NNS
18637	3173	18	was	be	VBD
18637	3173	19	extended	extend	VBN
18637	3173	20	to	to	IN
18637	3173	21	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	3173	22	.	.	.
18637	3174	1	These	these	DT
18637	3174	2	two	two	CD
18637	3174	3	acts	act	NNS
18637	3174	4	furnished	furnish	VBD
18637	3174	5	the	the	DT
18637	3174	6	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	3174	7	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	3174	8	for	for	IN
18637	3174	9	the	the	DT
18637	3174	10	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	3174	11	system	system	NN
18637	3174	12	of	of	IN
18637	3174	13	consumer	consumer	NN
18637	3174	14	rationing	rationing	NN
18637	3174	15	administered	administer	VBN
18637	3174	16	by	by	IN
18637	3174	17	the	the	DT
18637	3174	18	Office	Office	NNP
18637	3174	19	of	of	IN
18637	3174	20	Price	Price	NNP
18637	3174	21	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	3174	22	,	,	,
18637	3174	23	as	as	RB
18637	3174	24	well	well	RB
18637	3174	25	as	as	IN
18637	3174	26	for	for	IN
18637	3174	27	the	the	DT
18637	3174	28	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	3174	29	control	control	NN
18637	3174	30	of	of	IN
18637	3174	31	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	3174	32	materials	material	NNS
18637	3174	33	and	and	CC
18637	3174	34	output	output	NN
18637	3174	35	which	which	WDT
18637	3174	36	was	be	VBD
18637	3174	37	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	3174	38	by	by	IN
18637	3174	39	the	the	DT
18637	3174	40	War	War	NNP
18637	3174	41	Production	Production	NNP
18637	3174	42	Board	Board	NNP
18637	3174	43	.	.	.
18637	3175	1	Under	under	IN
18637	3175	2	the	the	DT
18637	3175	3	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	3175	4	Price	Price	NNP
18637	3175	5	Control	Control	NNP
18637	3175	6	Act[1266	Act[1266	NNP
18637	3175	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3175	8	the	the	DT
18637	3175	9	Office	Office	NNP
18637	3175	10	of	of	IN
18637	3175	11	Price	Price	NNP
18637	3175	12	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	3175	13	regulated	regulate	VBD
18637	3175	14	the	the	DT
18637	3175	15	price	price	NN
18637	3175	16	of	of	IN
18637	3175	17	almost	almost	RB
18637	3175	18	all	all	DT
18637	3175	19	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	3175	20	,	,	,
18637	3175	21	as	as	RB
18637	3175	22	well	well	RB
18637	3175	23	as	as	IN
18637	3175	24	the	the	DT
18637	3175	25	rentals	rental	NNS
18637	3175	26	for	for	IN
18637	3175	27	housing	housing	NN
18637	3175	28	accommodations	accommodation	NNS
18637	3175	29	in	in	IN
18637	3175	30	scores	score	NNS
18637	3175	31	of	of	IN
18637	3175	32	defense	defense	NN
18637	3175	33	rental	rental	NN
18637	3175	34	areas	area	NNS
18637	3175	35	.	.	.
18637	3176	1	The	the	DT
18637	3176	2	War	War	NNP
18637	3176	3	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	3176	4	Disputes	Disputes	NNP
18637	3176	5	Act[1267	Act[1267	NNP
18637	3176	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3176	7	permitted	permit	VBD
18637	3176	8	the	the	DT
18637	3176	9	President	President	NNP
18637	3176	10	to	to	TO
18637	3176	11	commandeer	commandeer	NN
18637	3176	12	plants	plant	NNS
18637	3176	13	which	which	WDT
18637	3176	14	were	be	VBD
18637	3176	15	closed	close	VBN
18637	3176	16	by	by	IN
18637	3176	17	strikes	strike	NNS
18637	3176	18	.	.	.
18637	3177	1	MOBILIZATION	mobilization	NN
18637	3177	2	OF	of	IN
18637	3177	3	INDUSTRIAL	INDUSTRIAL	NNP
18637	3177	4	RESOURCES	resource	NNS
18637	3177	5	While	while	IN
18637	3177	6	the	the	DT
18637	3177	7	validity	validity	NN
18637	3177	8	of	of	IN
18637	3177	9	several	several	JJ
18637	3177	10	of	of	IN
18637	3177	11	the	the	DT
18637	3177	12	measures	measure	NNS
18637	3177	13	just	just	RB
18637	3177	14	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	3177	15	was	be	VBD
18637	3177	16	assailed	assail	VBN
18637	3177	17	on	on	IN
18637	3177	18	one	one	CD
18637	3177	19	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3177	20	ground	ground	NN
18637	3177	21	or	or	CC
18637	3177	22	another	another	DT
18637	3177	23	,	,	,
18637	3177	24	the	the	DT
18637	3177	25	general	general	JJ
18637	3177	26	power	power	NN
18637	3177	27	of	of	IN
18637	3177	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3177	29	to	to	TO
18637	3177	30	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	3177	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3177	32	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3177	33	matter	matter	NN
18637	3177	34	in	in	IN
18637	3177	35	time	time	NN
18637	3177	36	of	of	IN
18637	3177	37	war	war	NN
18637	3177	38	was	be	VBD
18637	3177	39	not	not	RB
18637	3177	40	disputed	dispute	VBN
18637	3177	41	.	.	.
18637	3178	1	Not	not	RB
18637	3178	2	until	until	IN
18637	3178	3	the	the	DT
18637	3178	4	Government	government	NN
18637	3178	5	sought	seek	VBD
18637	3178	6	to	to	TO
18637	3178	7	recover	recover	VB
18637	3178	8	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	3178	9	profits	profit	NNS
18637	3178	10	realized	realize	VBN
18637	3178	11	on	on	IN
18637	3178	12	war	war	NN
18637	3178	13	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3178	14	did	do	VBD
18637	3178	15	the	the	DT
18637	3178	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3178	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3178	18	have	have	VBP
18637	3178	19	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	3178	20	to	to	TO
18637	3178	21	affirm	affirm	VB
18637	3178	22	the	the	DT
18637	3178	23	broad	broad	JJ
18637	3178	24	authority	authority	NN
18637	3178	25	of	of	IN
18637	3178	26	the	the	DT
18637	3178	27	National	National	NNP
18637	3178	28	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3178	29	to	to	TO
18637	3178	30	mobilize	mobilize	VB
18637	3178	31	the	the	DT
18637	3178	32	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	3178	33	resources	resource	NNS
18637	3178	34	of	of	IN
18637	3178	35	the	the	DT
18637	3178	36	nation	nation	NN
18637	3178	37	in	in	IN
18637	3178	38	time	time	NN
18637	3178	39	of	of	IN
18637	3178	40	war	war	NN
18637	3178	41	.	.	.
18637	3179	1	Using	use	VBG
18637	3179	2	the	the	DT
18637	3179	3	power	power	NN
18637	3179	4	of	of	IN
18637	3179	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3179	6	to	to	TO
18637	3179	7	conscript	conscript	VB
18637	3179	8	men	man	NNS
18637	3179	9	for	for	IN
18637	3179	10	the	the	DT
18637	3179	11	armed	armed	JJ
18637	3179	12	forces	force	NNS
18637	3179	13	as	as	IN
18637	3179	14	a	a	DT
18637	3179	15	measure	measure	NN
18637	3179	16	of	of	IN
18637	3179	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3179	18	power	power	NN
18637	3179	19	to	to	TO
18637	3179	20	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	3179	21	industry	industry	NN
18637	3179	22	,	,	,
18637	3179	23	the	the	DT
18637	3179	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3179	25	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	3179	26	the	the	DT
18637	3179	27	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3179	28	,	,	,
18637	3179	29	saying	say	VBG
18637	3179	30	:	:	:
18637	3179	31	"	"	``
18637	3179	32	The	the	DT
18637	3179	33	Renegotiation	Renegotiation	NNP
18637	3179	34	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3179	35	was	be	VBD
18637	3179	36	developed	develop	VBN
18637	3179	37	as	as	IN
18637	3179	38	a	a	DT
18637	3179	39	major	major	JJ
18637	3179	40	wartime	wartime	JJ
18637	3179	41	policy	policy	NN
18637	3179	42	of	of	IN
18637	3179	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3179	44	comparable	comparable	JJ
18637	3179	45	to	to	IN
18637	3179	46	that	that	DT
18637	3179	47	of	of	IN
18637	3179	48	the	the	DT
18637	3179	49	Selective	Selective	NNP
18637	3179	50	Service	Service	NNP
18637	3179	51	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3179	52	.	.	.
18637	3180	1	The	the	DT
18637	3180	2	authority	authority	NN
18637	3180	3	of	of	IN
18637	3180	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3180	5	to	to	TO
18637	3180	6	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	3180	7	each	each	DT
18637	3180	8	of	of	IN
18637	3180	9	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3180	10	sprang	spring	VBD
18637	3180	11	from	from	IN
18637	3180	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3180	13	war	war	NN
18637	3180	14	powers	power	NNS
18637	3180	15	.	.	.
18637	3181	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3181	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3181	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3181	4	With	with	IN
18637	3181	5	the	the	DT
18637	3181	6	advent	advent	NN
18637	3181	7	of	of	IN
18637	3181	8	*	*	NFP
18637	3181	9	*	*	NFP
18637	3181	10	*	*	NFP
18637	3181	11	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3181	12	global	global	JJ
18637	3181	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3181	14	warfare	warfare	NN
18637	3181	15	,	,	,
18637	3181	16	mobilized	mobilize	VBD
18637	3181	17	property	property	NN
18637	3181	18	in	in	IN
18637	3181	19	the	the	DT
18637	3181	20	form	form	NN
18637	3181	21	of	of	IN
18637	3181	22	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	3181	23	and	and	CC
18637	3181	24	supplies	supply	NNS
18637	3181	25	became	become	VBD
18637	3181	26	as	as	RB
18637	3181	27	essential	essential	JJ
18637	3181	28	as	as	IN
18637	3181	29	mobilized	mobilized	JJ
18637	3181	30	manpower	manpower	NN
18637	3181	31	.	.	.
18637	3182	1	Mobilization	mobilization	NN
18637	3182	2	of	of	IN
18637	3182	3	effort	effort	NN
18637	3182	4	extended	extend	VBD
18637	3182	5	not	not	RB
18637	3182	6	only	only	RB
18637	3182	7	to	to	IN
18637	3182	8	the	the	DT
18637	3182	9	uniformed	uniformed	JJ
18637	3182	10	armed	armed	JJ
18637	3182	11	services	service	NNS
18637	3182	12	but	but	CC
18637	3182	13	to	to	IN
18637	3182	14	the	the	DT
18637	3182	15	entire	entire	JJ
18637	3182	16	population	population	NN
18637	3182	17	.	.	.
18637	3183	1	Both	both	DT
18637	3183	2	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	3183	3	were	be	VBD
18637	3183	4	a	a	DT
18637	3183	5	form	form	NN
18637	3183	6	of	of	IN
18637	3183	7	mobilization	mobilization	NN
18637	3183	8	.	.	.
18637	3184	1	The	the	DT
18637	3184	2	language	language	NN
18637	3184	3	of	of	IN
18637	3184	4	the	the	DT
18637	3184	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3184	6	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	3184	7	such	such	JJ
18637	3184	8	measures	measure	NNS
18637	3184	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	3184	10	broad	broad	JJ
18637	3184	11	rather	rather	RB
18637	3184	12	than	than	IN
18637	3184	13	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	3184	14	.	.	.
18637	3185	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3185	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3185	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3185	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3185	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3185	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3185	7	*	*	NFP
18637	3185	8	*	*	NFP
18637	3185	9	*	*	NFP
18637	3185	10	places	place	VBZ
18637	3185	11	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	3185	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	3185	13	the	the	DT
18637	3185	14	supporting	supporting	NN
18637	3185	15	as	as	RB
18637	3185	16	well	well	RB
18637	3185	17	as	as	IN
18637	3185	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	3185	19	the	the	DT
18637	3185	20	raising	raising	NN
18637	3185	21	of	of	IN
18637	3185	22	armies	army	NNS
18637	3185	23	.	.	.
18637	3186	1	The	the	DT
18637	3186	2	power	power	NN
18637	3186	3	of	of	IN
18637	3186	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3186	5	as	as	IN
18637	3186	6	to	to	IN
18637	3186	7	both	both	DT
18637	3186	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	3186	9	inescapably	inescapably	RB
18637	3186	10	express	express	JJ
18637	3186	11	,	,	,
18637	3186	12	not	not	RB
18637	3186	13	merely	merely	RB
18637	3186	14	implied	imply	VBN
18637	3186	15	.	.	.
18637	3187	1	"	"	``
18637	3187	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3187	3	1268	1268	CD
18637	3187	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3187	5	DELEGATION	delegation	NN
18637	3187	6	OF	of	IN
18637	3187	7	LEGISLATIVE	legislative	JJ
18637	3187	8	POWER	POWER	NNP
18637	3187	9	IN	in	IN
18637	3187	10	WARTIME	wartime	NN
18637	3187	11	While	while	IN
18637	3187	12	insisting	insist	VBG
18637	3187	13	that	that	IN
18637	3187	14	,	,	,
18637	3187	15	"	"	``
18637	3187	16	in	in	IN
18637	3187	17	peace	peace	NN
18637	3187	18	or	or	CC
18637	3187	19	in	in	IN
18637	3187	20	war	war	NN
18637	3187	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3187	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	3187	23	essential	essential	JJ
18637	3187	24	that	that	IN
18637	3187	25	the	the	DT
18637	3187	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3187	27	be	be	VB
18637	3187	28	scrupulously	scrupulously	RB
18637	3187	29	obeyed	obey	VBN
18637	3187	30	,	,	,
18637	3187	31	and	and	CC
18637	3187	32	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	3187	33	that	that	IN
18637	3187	34	the	the	DT
18637	3187	35	respective	respective	JJ
18637	3187	36	branches	branch	NNS
18637	3187	37	of	of	IN
18637	3187	38	the	the	DT
18637	3187	39	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3187	40	keep	keep	VB
18637	3187	41	within	within	IN
18637	3187	42	the	the	DT
18637	3187	43	powers	power	NNS
18637	3187	44	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	3187	45	to	to	IN
18637	3187	46	each,"[1269	each,"[1269	NNP
18637	3187	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3187	48	the	the	DT
18637	3187	49	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3187	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3187	51	has	have	VBZ
18637	3187	52	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	3187	53	that	that	IN
18637	3187	54	in	in	IN
18637	3187	55	the	the	DT
18637	3187	56	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	3187	57	of	of	IN
18637	3187	58	a	a	DT
18637	3187	59	war	war	NN
18637	3187	60	delegations	delegation	NNS
18637	3187	61	of	of	IN
18637	3187	62	power	power	NN
18637	3187	63	may	may	MD
18637	3187	64	be	be	VB
18637	3187	65	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3187	66	which	which	WDT
18637	3187	67	would	would	MD
18637	3187	68	not	not	RB
18637	3187	69	be	be	VB
18637	3187	70	admissible	admissible	JJ
18637	3187	71	in	in	IN
18637	3187	72	other	other	JJ
18637	3187	73	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	3187	74	.	.	.
18637	3188	1	The	the	DT
18637	3188	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	3188	3	in	in	IN
18637	3188	4	which	which	WDT
18637	3188	5	this	this	DT
18637	3188	6	issue	issue	NN
18637	3188	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	3188	8	been	be	VBN
18637	3188	9	raised	raise	VBN
18637	3188	10	have	have	VBP
18637	3188	11	been	be	VBN
18637	3188	12	few	few	JJ
18637	3188	13	in	in	IN
18637	3188	14	number	number	NN
18637	3188	15	.	.	.
18637	3189	1	In	in	IN
18637	3189	2	one	one	CD
18637	3189	3	,	,	,
18637	3189	4	the	the	DT
18637	3189	5	Selective	Selective	NNP
18637	3189	6	Draft	Draft	NNP
18637	3189	7	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3189	8	cases,[1270	cases,[1270	NNP
18637	3189	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3189	10	the	the	DT
18637	3189	11	objection	objection	NN
18637	3189	12	was	be	VBD
18637	3189	13	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
18637	3189	14	without	without	IN
18637	3189	15	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	3189	16	.	.	.
18637	3190	1	In	in	IN
18637	3190	2	a	a	DT
18637	3190	3	second	second	JJ
18637	3190	4	,	,	,
18637	3190	5	the	the	DT
18637	3190	6	price	price	NN
18637	3190	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	3190	8	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	3190	9	authority	authority	NN
18637	3190	10	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	3190	11	by	by	IN
18637	3190	12	the	the	DT
18637	3190	13	Office	Office	NNP
18637	3190	14	of	of	IN
18637	3190	15	Price	Price	NNP
18637	3190	16	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	3190	17	during	during	IN
18637	3190	18	the	the	DT
18637	3190	19	second	second	JJ
18637	3190	20	world	world	NNP
18637	3190	21	war	war	NNP
18637	3190	22	,	,	,
18637	3190	23	was	be	VBD
18637	3190	24	,	,	,
18637	3190	25	on	on	IN
18637	3190	26	the	the	DT
18637	3190	27	issue	issue	NN
18637	3190	28	of	of	IN
18637	3190	29	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	3190	30	of	of	IN
18637	3190	31	power	power	NN
18637	3190	32	,	,	,
18637	3190	33	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	3190	34	by	by	IN
18637	3190	35	reference	reference	NN
18637	3190	36	to	to	IN
18637	3190	37	peace	peace	NN
18637	3190	38	time	time	NN
18637	3190	39	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	3190	40	.	.	.
18637	3191	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3191	2	1271	1271	CD
18637	3191	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3191	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	3191	5	the	the	DT
18637	3191	6	war	war	NN
18637	3191	7	power	power	NN
18637	3191	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	3191	9	been	be	VBN
18637	3191	10	the	the	DT
18637	3191	11	basis	basis	NN
18637	3191	12	of	of	IN
18637	3191	13	decision	decision	NN
18637	3191	14	,	,	,
18637	3191	15	two	two	CD
18637	3191	16	different	different	JJ
18637	3191	17	theories	theory	NNS
18637	3191	18	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	3191	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3191	20	significance	significance	NN
18637	3191	21	can	can	MD
18637	3191	22	be	be	VB
18637	3191	23	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	3191	24	.	.	.
18637	3192	1	The	the	DT
18637	3192	2	first	first	JJ
18637	3192	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	3192	4	that	that	IN
18637	3192	5	since	since	IN
18637	3192	6	the	the	DT
18637	3192	7	war	war	NN
18637	3192	8	power	power	NN
18637	3192	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	3192	10	an	an	DT
18637	3192	11	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	3192	12	power	power	NN
18637	3192	13	shared	share	VBN
18637	3192	14	by	by	IN
18637	3192	15	the	the	DT
18637	3192	16	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3192	17	and	and	CC
18637	3192	18	executive	executive	JJ
18637	3192	19	departments	department	NNS
18637	3192	20	rather	rather	RB
18637	3192	21	than	than	IN
18637	3192	22	an	an	DT
18637	3192	23	enumerated	enumerated	JJ
18637	3192	24	power	power	NN
18637	3192	25	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3192	26	to	to	IN
18637	3192	27	the	the	DT
18637	3192	28	former	former	JJ
18637	3192	29	,	,	,
18637	3192	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3192	31	does	do	VBZ
18637	3192	32	not	not	RB
18637	3192	33	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	3192	34	_	_	NNP
18637	3192	35	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3192	36	_	_	NNP
18637	3192	37	power	power	NN
18637	3192	38	when	when	WRB
18637	3192	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3192	40	authorizes	authorize	VBZ
18637	3192	41	the	the	DT
18637	3192	42	President	President	NNP
18637	3192	43	to	to	TO
18637	3192	44	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	3192	45	the	the	DT
18637	3192	46	war	war	NN
18637	3192	47	power	power	NN
18637	3192	48	in	in	IN
18637	3192	49	a	a	DT
18637	3192	50	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	3192	51	manner	manner	NN
18637	3192	52	.	.	.
18637	3193	1	Opposed	oppose	VBN
18637	3193	2	to	to	IN
18637	3193	3	this	this	DT
18637	3193	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	3193	5	the	the	DT
18637	3193	6	view	view	NN
18637	3193	7	that	that	IN
18637	3193	8	the	the	DT
18637	3193	9	right	right	NN
18637	3193	10	of	of	IN
18637	3193	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3193	12	to	to	TO
18637	3193	13	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	3193	14	power	power	NN
18637	3193	15	to	to	IN
18637	3193	16	the	the	DT
18637	3193	17	President	President	NNP
18637	3193	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	3193	19	limited	limit	VBN
18637	3193	20	in	in	IN
18637	3193	21	this	this	DT
18637	3193	22	as	as	IN
18637	3193	23	in	in	IN
18637	3193	24	other	other	JJ
18637	3193	25	cases	case	NNS
18637	3193	26	but	but	CC
18637	3193	27	that	that	IN
18637	3193	28	where	where	WRB
18637	3193	29	the	the	DT
18637	3193	30	validity	validity	NN
18637	3193	31	of	of	IN
18637	3193	32	the	the	DT
18637	3193	33	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	3193	34	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	3193	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	3193	36	whether	whether	IN
18637	3193	37	or	or	CC
18637	3193	38	not	not	RB
18637	3193	39	too	too	RB
18637	3193	40	great	great	JJ
18637	3193	41	a	a	DT
18637	3193	42	latitude	latitude	NN
18637	3193	43	of	of	IN
18637	3193	44	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	3193	45	has	have	VBZ
18637	3193	46	been	be	VBN
18637	3193	47	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	3193	48	upon	upon	IN
18637	3193	49	the	the	DT
18637	3193	50	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	3193	51	,	,	,
18637	3193	52	the	the	DT
18637	3193	53	existence	existence	NN
18637	3193	54	of	of	IN
18637	3193	55	a	a	DT
18637	3193	56	state	state	NN
18637	3193	57	of	of	IN
18637	3193	58	war	war	NN
18637	3193	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	3193	60	a	a	DT
18637	3193	61	factor	factor	NN
18637	3193	62	to	to	TO
18637	3193	63	be	be	VB
18637	3193	64	considered	consider	VBN
18637	3193	65	in	in	IN
18637	3193	66	determining	determine	VBG
18637	3193	67	whether	whether	IN
18637	3193	68	the	the	DT
18637	3193	69	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	3193	70	in	in	IN
18637	3193	71	the	the	DT
18637	3193	72	particular	particular	JJ
18637	3193	73	case	case	NN
18637	3193	74	is	be	VBZ
18637	3193	75	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3193	76	and	and	CC
18637	3193	77	hence	hence	RB
18637	3193	78	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	3193	79	.	.	.
18637	3194	1	The	the	DT
18637	3194	2	idea	idea	NN
18637	3194	3	that	that	IN
18637	3194	4	a	a	DT
18637	3194	5	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	3194	6	of	of	IN
18637	3194	7	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	3194	8	in	in	IN
18637	3194	9	the	the	DT
18637	3194	10	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3194	11	of	of	IN
18637	3194	12	the	the	DT
18637	3194	13	war	war	NN
18637	3194	14	power	power	NN
18637	3194	15	stands	stand	VBZ
18637	3194	16	on	on	IN
18637	3194	17	a	a	DT
18637	3194	18	different	different	JJ
18637	3194	19	footing	footing	NN
18637	3194	20	than	than	IN
18637	3194	21	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	3194	22	of	of	IN
18637	3194	23	authority	authority	NN
18637	3194	24	to	to	TO
18637	3194	25	levy	levy	VB
18637	3194	26	a	a	DT
18637	3194	27	tax	tax	NN
18637	3194	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	3194	29	implicit	implicit	JJ
18637	3194	30	in	in	IN
18637	3194	31	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3194	32	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	3194	33	's	's	POS
18637	3194	34	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3194	35	in	in	IN
18637	3194	36	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	3194	37	_	_	NNP
18637	3194	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	3194	39	_	_	NNP
18637	3194	40	Dillin	Dillin	NNP
18637	3194	41	.	.	.
18637	3195	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3195	2	1272	1272	CD
18637	3195	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3195	4	The	the	DT
18637	3195	5	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
18637	3195	6	in	in	IN
18637	3195	7	that	that	DT
18637	3195	8	case	case	NN
18637	3195	9	contended	contend	VBD
18637	3195	10	that	that	IN
18637	3195	11	the	the	DT
18637	3195	12	sum	sum	NN
18637	3195	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3195	14	were	be	VBD
18637	3195	15	required	require	VBN
18637	3195	16	to	to	TO
18637	3195	17	pay	pay	VB
18637	3195	18	for	for	IN
18637	3195	19	the	the	DT
18637	3195	20	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3195	21	of	of	IN
18637	3195	22	buying	buy	VBG
18637	3195	23	cotton	cotton	NN
18637	3195	24	in	in	IN
18637	3195	25	the	the	DT
18637	3195	26	South	South	NNP
18637	3195	27	was	be	VBD
18637	3195	28	a	a	DT
18637	3195	29	tax	tax	NN
18637	3195	30	,	,	,
18637	3195	31	which	which	WDT
18637	3195	32	,	,	,
18637	3195	33	since	since	IN
18637	3195	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3195	35	was	be	VBD
18637	3195	36	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	3195	37	by	by	IN
18637	3195	38	the	the	DT
18637	3195	39	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	3195	40	of	of	IN
18637	3195	41	the	the	DT
18637	3195	42	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	3195	43	,	,	,
18637	3195	44	was	be	VBD
18637	3195	45	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	3195	46	because	because	IN
18637	3195	47	the	the	DT
18637	3195	48	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	3195	49	power	power	NN
18637	3195	50	was	be	VBD
18637	3195	51	not	not	RB
18637	3195	52	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
18637	3195	53	of	of	IN
18637	3195	54	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	3195	55	to	to	IN
18637	3195	56	the	the	DT
18637	3195	57	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	3195	58	Department	Department	NNP
18637	3195	59	.	.	.
18637	3196	1	To	to	IN
18637	3196	2	this	this	DT
18637	3196	3	argument	argument	NN
18637	3196	4	the	the	DT
18637	3196	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3196	6	replied	reply	VBD
18637	3196	7	:	:	:
18637	3196	8	"	"	``
18637	3196	9	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3196	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	3196	11	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	3196	12	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3196	13	,	,	,
18637	3196	14	under	under	IN
18637	3196	15	the	the	DT
18637	3196	16	view	view	NN
18637	3196	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3196	18	have	have	VBP
18637	3196	19	taken	take	VBN
18637	3196	20	of	of	IN
18637	3196	21	the	the	DT
18637	3196	22	character	character	NN
18637	3196	23	of	of	IN
18637	3196	24	the	the	DT
18637	3196	25	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	3196	26	in	in	IN
18637	3196	27	question	question	NN
18637	3196	28	,	,	,
18637	3196	29	*	*	NFP
18637	3196	30	*	*	NFP
18637	3196	31	*	*	NFP
18637	3196	32	,	,	,
18637	3196	33	to	to	TO
18637	3196	34	discuss	discuss	VB
18637	3196	35	the	the	DT
18637	3196	36	question	question	NN
18637	3196	37	of	of	IN
18637	3196	38	the	the	DT
18637	3196	39	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	3196	40	of	of	IN
18637	3196	41	the	the	DT
18637	3196	42	act	act	NN
18637	3196	43	of	of	IN
18637	3196	44	July	July	NNP
18637	3196	45	13th	13th	NN
18637	3196	46	,	,	,
18637	3196	47	1861	1861	CD
18637	3196	48	,	,	,
18637	3196	49	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	3196	50	as	as	IN
18637	3196	51	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	3196	52	such	such	JJ
18637	3196	53	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	3196	54	.	.	.
18637	3197	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3197	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3197	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3197	4	,	,	,
18637	3197	5	the	the	DT
18637	3197	6	power	power	NN
18637	3197	7	of	of	IN
18637	3197	8	the	the	DT
18637	3197	9	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3197	10	to	to	TO
18637	3197	11	impose	impose	VB
18637	3197	12	such	such	JJ
18637	3197	13	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	3197	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	3197	15	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	3197	16	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	3197	17	with	with	IN
18637	3197	18	an	an	DT
18637	3197	19	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	3197	20	in	in	IN
18637	3197	21	time	time	NN
18637	3197	22	of	of	IN
18637	3197	23	war	war	NN
18637	3197	24	*	*	NFP
18637	3197	25	*	*	NFP
18637	3197	26	*	*	NFP
18637	3197	27	does	do	VBZ
18637	3197	28	not	not	RB
18637	3197	29	belong	belong	VB
18637	3197	30	to	to	IN
18637	3197	31	the	the	DT
18637	3197	32	same	same	JJ
18637	3197	33	category	category	NN
18637	3197	34	as	as	IN
18637	3197	35	the	the	DT
18637	3197	36	power	power	NN
18637	3197	37	to	to	TO
18637	3197	38	levy	levy	VB
18637	3197	39	and	and	CC
18637	3197	40	collect	collect	VB
18637	3197	41	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3197	42	,	,	,
18637	3197	43	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3197	44	,	,	,
18637	3197	45	and	and	CC
18637	3197	46	excises	excise	NNS
18637	3197	47	.	.	.
18637	3198	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3198	2	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	3198	3	to	to	IN
18637	3198	4	the	the	DT
18637	3198	5	war	war	NN
18637	3198	6	powers	power	NNS
18637	3198	7	of	of	IN
18637	3198	8	the	the	DT
18637	3198	9	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3198	10	*	*	NFP
18637	3198	11	*	*	NFP
18637	3198	12	*	*	NFP
18637	3198	13	.	.	.
18637	3199	1	"	"	``
18637	3199	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3199	3	1273	1273	CD
18637	3199	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3199	5	The	the	DT
18637	3199	6	Mergence	Mergence	NNP
18637	3199	7	of	of	IN
18637	3199	8	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	3199	9	and	and	CC
18637	3199	10	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	3199	11	in	in	IN
18637	3199	12	Wartime	Wartime	NNP
18637	3199	13	Both	both	DT
18637	3199	14	theories	theory	NNS
18637	3199	15	receive	receive	VBP
18637	3199	16	countenance	countenance	NN
18637	3199	17	in	in	IN
18637	3199	18	different	different	JJ
18637	3199	19	passages	passage	NNS
18637	3199	20	in	in	IN
18637	3199	21	the	the	DT
18637	3199	22	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3199	23	of	of	IN
18637	3199	24	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3199	25	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3199	26	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	3199	27	in	in	IN
18637	3199	28	Hirabayashi	Hirabayashi	NNP
18637	3199	29	_	_	NNP
18637	3199	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	3199	31	_	_	NNP
18637	3199	32	United	United	NNP
18637	3199	33	States	States	NNP
18637	3199	34	.	.	.
18637	3200	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3200	2	1274	1274	CD
18637	3200	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3200	4	In	in	IN
18637	3200	5	disposing	dispose	VBG
18637	3200	6	of	of	IN
18637	3200	7	the	the	DT
18637	3200	8	contention	contention	NN
18637	3200	9	that	that	IN
18637	3200	10	the	the	DT
18637	3200	11	curfew	curfew	NN
18637	3200	12	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	3200	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	3200	14	a	a	DT
18637	3200	15	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	3200	16	of	of	IN
18637	3200	17	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	3200	18	descent	descent	NN
18637	3200	19	involved	involve	VBD
18637	3200	20	an	an	DT
18637	3200	21	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	3200	22	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	3200	23	of	of	IN
18637	3200	24	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3200	25	power	power	NN
18637	3200	26	,	,	,
18637	3200	27	the	the	DT
18637	3200	28	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3200	29	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3200	30	said	say	VBD
18637	3200	31	:	:	:
18637	3200	32	"	"	``
18637	3200	33	The	the	DT
18637	3200	34	question	question	NN
18637	3200	35	then	then	RB
18637	3200	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	3200	37	not	not	RB
18637	3200	38	one	one	CD
18637	3200	39	of	of	IN
18637	3200	40	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	3200	41	power	power	NN
18637	3200	42	to	to	TO
18637	3200	43	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	3200	44	to	to	IN
18637	3200	45	the	the	DT
18637	3200	46	President	President	NNP
18637	3200	47	the	the	DT
18637	3200	48	promulgation	promulgation	NN
18637	3200	49	of	of	IN
18637	3200	50	the	the	DT
18637	3200	51	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	3200	52	Order	Order	NNP
18637	3200	53	,	,	,
18637	3200	54	but	but	CC
18637	3200	55	whether	whether	IN
18637	3200	56	,	,	,
18637	3200	57	acting	act	VBG
18637	3200	58	in	in	IN
18637	3200	59	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	3200	60	,	,	,
18637	3200	61	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3200	62	and	and	CC
18637	3200	63	the	the	DT
18637	3200	64	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	3200	65	have	have	VBP
18637	3200	66	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3200	67	authority	authority	NN
18637	3200	68	to	to	TO
18637	3200	69	impose	impose	VB
18637	3200	70	the	the	DT
18637	3200	71	curfew	curfew	NN
18637	3200	72	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	3200	73	here	here	RB
18637	3200	74	complained	complain	VBD
18637	3200	75	of	of	IN
18637	3200	76	.	.	.
18637	3201	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3201	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3201	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3201	4	,	,	,
18637	3201	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3201	6	conclude	conclude	VBP
18637	3201	7	that	that	IN
18637	3201	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3201	9	was	be	VBD
18637	3201	10	within	within	IN
18637	3201	11	the	the	DT
18637	3201	12	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3201	13	power	power	NN
18637	3201	14	of	of	IN
18637	3201	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3201	16	and	and	CC
18637	3201	17	the	the	DT
18637	3201	18	executive	executive	JJ
18637	3201	19	arm	arm	NN
18637	3201	20	of	of	IN
18637	3201	21	the	the	DT
18637	3201	22	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3201	23	to	to	TO
18637	3201	24	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	3201	25	this	this	DT
18637	3201	26	curfew	curfew	NN
18637	3201	27	order	order	NN
18637	3201	28	for	for	IN
18637	3201	29	the	the	DT
18637	3201	30	period	period	NN
18637	3201	31	under	under	IN
18637	3201	32	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	3201	33	and	and	CC
18637	3201	34	that	that	IN
18637	3201	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3201	36	promulgation	promulgation	NN
18637	3201	37	by	by	IN
18637	3201	38	the	the	DT
18637	3201	39	military	military	JJ
18637	3201	40	commander	commander	NN
18637	3201	41	involved	involve	VBD
18637	3201	42	no	no	DT
18637	3201	43	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	3201	44	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	3201	45	of	of	IN
18637	3201	46	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3201	47	power	power	NN
18637	3201	48	.	.	.
18637	3202	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3202	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3202	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3202	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	3202	5	,	,	,
18637	3202	6	as	as	IN
18637	3202	7	in	in	IN
18637	3202	8	the	the	DT
18637	3202	9	present	present	JJ
18637	3202	10	case	case	NN
18637	3202	11	,	,	,
18637	3202	12	the	the	DT
18637	3202	13	standard	standard	NN
18637	3202	14	set	set	VBN
18637	3202	15	up	up	RP
18637	3202	16	for	for	IN
18637	3202	17	the	the	DT
18637	3202	18	guidance	guidance	NN
18637	3202	19	of	of	IN
18637	3202	20	the	the	DT
18637	3202	21	military	military	JJ
18637	3202	22	commander	commander	NN
18637	3202	23	,	,	,
18637	3202	24	and	and	CC
18637	3202	25	the	the	DT
18637	3202	26	action	action	NN
18637	3202	27	taken	take	VBN
18637	3202	28	and	and	CC
18637	3202	29	the	the	DT
18637	3202	30	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	3202	31	for	for	IN
18637	3202	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3202	33	,	,	,
18637	3202	34	are	be	VBP
18637	3202	35	in	in	IN
18637	3202	36	fact	fact	NN
18637	3202	37	recorded	record	VBN
18637	3202	38	in	in	IN
18637	3202	39	the	the	DT
18637	3202	40	military	military	JJ
18637	3202	41	orders	order	NNS
18637	3202	42	,	,	,
18637	3202	43	so	so	IN
18637	3202	44	that	that	IN
18637	3202	45	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3202	46	,	,	,
18637	3202	47	the	the	DT
18637	3202	48	courts	court	NNS
18637	3202	49	and	and	CC
18637	3202	50	the	the	DT
18637	3202	51	public	public	NN
18637	3202	52	are	be	VBP
18637	3202	53	assured	assure	VBN
18637	3202	54	that	that	IN
18637	3202	55	the	the	DT
18637	3202	56	orders	order	NNS
18637	3202	57	,	,	,
18637	3202	58	in	in	IN
18637	3202	59	the	the	DT
18637	3202	60	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	3202	61	of	of	IN
18637	3202	62	the	the	DT
18637	3202	63	commander	commander	NN
18637	3202	64	,	,	,
18637	3202	65	conform	conform	VB
18637	3202	66	to	to	IN
18637	3202	67	the	the	DT
18637	3202	68	standards	standard	NNS
18637	3202	69	approved	approve	VBN
18637	3202	70	by	by	IN
18637	3202	71	the	the	DT
18637	3202	72	President	President	NNP
18637	3202	73	and	and	CC
18637	3202	74	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3202	75	,	,	,
18637	3202	76	there	there	EX
18637	3202	77	is	be	VBZ
18637	3202	78	no	no	DT
18637	3202	79	failure	failure	NN
18637	3202	80	in	in	IN
18637	3202	81	the	the	DT
18637	3202	82	performance	performance	NN
18637	3202	83	of	of	IN
18637	3202	84	the	the	DT
18637	3202	85	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3202	86	function	function	NN
18637	3202	87	.	.	.
18637	3203	1	"	"	``
18637	3203	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3203	3	1275	1275	CD
18637	3203	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3203	5	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3203	6	went	go	VBD
18637	3203	7	on	on	RP
18637	3203	8	to	to	TO
18637	3203	9	say	say	VB
18637	3203	10	,	,	,
18637	3203	11	however	however	RB
18637	3203	12	,	,	,
18637	3203	13	that	that	DT
18637	3203	14	:	:	:
18637	3203	15	"	"	``
18637	3203	16	The	the	DT
18637	3203	17	essentials	essential	NNS
18637	3203	18	of	of	IN
18637	3203	19	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3203	20	the	the	DT
18637	3203	21	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3203	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3203	23	*	*	NFP
18637	3203	24	*	*	NFP
18637	3203	25	*	*	NFP
18637	3203	26	function	function	NN
18637	3203	27	are	be	VBP
18637	3203	28	the	the	DT
18637	3203	29	determination	determination	NN
18637	3203	30	by	by	IN
18637	3203	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3203	32	of	of	IN
18637	3203	33	the	the	DT
18637	3203	34	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3203	35	policy	policy	NN
18637	3203	36	and	and	CC
18637	3203	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3203	38	approval	approval	NN
18637	3203	39	of	of	IN
18637	3203	40	a	a	DT
18637	3203	41	rule	rule	NN
18637	3203	42	of	of	IN
18637	3203	43	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	3203	44	to	to	TO
18637	3203	45	carry	carry	VB
18637	3203	46	that	that	DT
18637	3203	47	policy	policy	NN
18637	3203	48	into	into	IN
18637	3203	49	execution	execution	NN
18637	3203	50	.	.	.
18637	3204	1	The	the	DT
18637	3204	2	very	very	JJ
18637	3204	3	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	3204	4	which	which	WDT
18637	3204	5	attend	attend	VBP
18637	3204	6	the	the	DT
18637	3204	7	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	3204	8	of	of	IN
18637	3204	9	military	military	JJ
18637	3204	10	operations	operation	NNS
18637	3204	11	in	in	IN
18637	3204	12	time	time	NN
18637	3204	13	of	of	IN
18637	3204	14	war	war	NN
18637	3204	15	in	in	IN
18637	3204	16	this	this	DT
18637	3204	17	instance	instance	NN
18637	3204	18	as	as	IN
18637	3204	19	in	in	IN
18637	3204	20	many	many	JJ
18637	3204	21	others	other	NNS
18637	3204	22	preclude	preclude	VBP
18637	3204	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3204	24	from	from	IN
18637	3204	25	holding	hold	VBG
18637	3204	26	committee	committee	NN
18637	3204	27	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	3204	28	to	to	TO
18637	3204	29	determine	determine	VB
18637	3204	30	whether	whether	IN
18637	3204	31	there	there	EX
18637	3204	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	3204	33	danger	danger	NN
18637	3204	34	,	,	,
18637	3204	35	before	before	IN
18637	3204	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3204	37	enacts	enact	VBZ
18637	3204	38	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3204	39	to	to	TO
18637	3204	40	combat	combat	VB
18637	3204	41	the	the	DT
18637	3204	42	danger	danger	NN
18637	3204	43	.	.	.
18637	3205	1	"	"	``
18637	3205	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3205	3	1276	1276	CD
18637	3205	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3205	5	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	3205	6	of	of	IN
18637	3205	7	Lichter	Lichter	NNP
18637	3205	8	_	_	NNP
18637	3205	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	3205	10	_	_	NNP
18637	3205	11	United	United	NNP
18637	3205	12	States	States	NNP
18637	3205	13	A	a	DT
18637	3205	14	similar	similar	JJ
18637	3205	15	ambiguity	ambiguity	NN
18637	3205	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	3205	17	found	find	VBN
18637	3205	18	in	in	IN
18637	3205	19	Lichter	Lichter	NNP
18637	3205	20	_	_	NNP
18637	3205	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	3205	22	_	_	NNP
18637	3205	23	United	United	NNP
18637	3205	24	States,[1277	States,[1277	NNP
18637	3205	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3205	26	but	but	CC
18637	3205	27	on	on	IN
18637	3205	28	the	the	DT
18637	3205	29	whole	whole	NN
18637	3205	30	the	the	DT
18637	3205	31	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3205	32	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	3205	33	to	to	TO
18637	3205	34	espouse	espouse	VB
18637	3205	35	the	the	DT
18637	3205	36	second	second	JJ
18637	3205	37	theory	theory	NN
18637	3205	38	,	,	,
18637	3205	39	as	as	IN
18637	3205	40	the	the	DT
18637	3205	41	following	follow	VBG
18637	3205	42	excerpts	excerpt	NNS
18637	3205	43	indicate	indicate	VBP
18637	3205	44	:	:	:
18637	3205	45	"	"	``
18637	3205	46	_	_	NNP
18637	3205	47	A	a	DT
18637	3205	48	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3205	49	power	power	NN
18637	3205	50	implies	imply	VBZ
18637	3205	51	a	a	DT
18637	3205	52	power	power	NN
18637	3205	53	of	of	IN
18637	3205	54	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	3205	55	of	of	IN
18637	3205	56	authority	authority	NN
18637	3205	57	under	under	IN
18637	3205	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3205	59	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	3205	60	to	to	TO
18637	3205	61	effect	effect	VB
18637	3205	62	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3205	63	purposes_.--This	purposes_.--This	NNP
18637	3205	64	power	power	NN
18637	3205	65	is	be	VBZ
18637	3205	66	especially	especially	RB
18637	3205	67	significant	significant	JJ
18637	3205	68	in	in	IN
18637	3205	69	connection	connection	NN
18637	3205	70	with	with	IN
18637	3205	71	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3205	72	war	war	NN
18637	3205	73	powers	power	NNS
18637	3205	74	under	under	IN
18637	3205	75	which	which	WDT
18637	3205	76	the	the	DT
18637	3205	77	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3205	78	of	of	IN
18637	3205	79	broad	broad	JJ
18637	3205	80	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	3205	81	as	as	IN
18637	3205	82	to	to	IN
18637	3205	83	methods	method	NNS
18637	3205	84	to	to	TO
18637	3205	85	be	be	VB
18637	3205	86	employed	employ	VBN
18637	3205	87	may	may	MD
18637	3205	88	be	be	VB
18637	3205	89	essential	essential	JJ
18637	3205	90	to	to	IN
18637	3205	91	an	an	DT
18637	3205	92	effective	effective	JJ
18637	3205	93	use	use	NN
18637	3205	94	of	of	IN
18637	3205	95	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3205	96	war	war	NN
18637	3205	97	powers	power	NNS
18637	3205	98	by	by	IN
18637	3205	99	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3205	100	.	.	.
18637	3206	1	The	the	DT
18637	3206	2	degree	degree	NN
18637	3206	3	to	to	TO
18637	3206	4	which	which	WDT
18637	3206	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3206	6	must	must	MD
18637	3206	7	specify	specify	VB
18637	3206	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3206	9	policies	policy	NNS
18637	3206	10	and	and	CC
18637	3206	11	standards	standard	NNS
18637	3206	12	in	in	IN
18637	3206	13	order	order	NN
18637	3206	14	that	that	IN
18637	3206	15	the	the	DT
18637	3206	16	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	3206	17	authority	authority	NN
18637	3206	18	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3206	19	may	may	MD
18637	3206	20	not	not	RB
18637	3206	21	be	be	VB
18637	3206	22	an	an	DT
18637	3206	23	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	3206	24	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	3206	25	of	of	IN
18637	3206	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3206	27	own	own	JJ
18637	3206	28	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3206	29	power	power	NN
18637	3206	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	3206	31	not	not	RB
18637	3206	32	capable	capable	JJ
18637	3206	33	of	of	IN
18637	3206	34	precise	precise	JJ
18637	3206	35	definition	definition	NN
18637	3206	36	.	.	.
18637	3207	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3207	2	1278	1278	CD
18637	3207	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3207	4	*	*	NFP
18637	3207	5	*	*	NFP
18637	3207	6	*	*	NFP
18637	3207	7	Thus	thus	RB
18637	3207	8	,	,	,
18637	3207	9	while	while	IN
18637	3207	10	the	the	DT
18637	3207	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3207	12	structure	structure	NN
18637	3207	13	and	and	CC
18637	3207	14	controls	control	NNS
18637	3207	15	of	of	IN
18637	3207	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3207	17	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3207	18	are	be	VBP
18637	3207	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3207	20	guides	guide	NNS
18637	3207	21	equally	equally	RB
18637	3207	22	in	in	IN
18637	3207	23	war	war	NN
18637	3207	24	and	and	CC
18637	3207	25	in	in	IN
18637	3207	26	peace	peace	NN
18637	3207	27	,	,	,
18637	3207	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3207	29	must	must	MD
18637	3207	30	be	be	VB
18637	3207	31	read	read	VBN
18637	3207	32	with	with	IN
18637	3207	33	the	the	DT
18637	3207	34	realistic	realistic	JJ
18637	3207	35	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	3207	36	of	of	IN
18637	3207	37	the	the	DT
18637	3207	38	entire	entire	JJ
18637	3207	39	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	3207	40	fully	fully	RB
18637	3207	41	in	in	IN
18637	3207	42	mind	mind	NN
18637	3207	43	.	.	.
18637	3208	1	In	in	IN
18637	3208	2	1942	1942	CD
18637	3208	3	,	,	,
18637	3208	4	in	in	IN
18637	3208	5	the	the	DT
18637	3208	6	early	early	JJ
18637	3208	7	stages	stage	NNS
18637	3208	8	of	of	IN
18637	3208	9	total	total	JJ
18637	3208	10	global	global	JJ
18637	3208	11	warfare	warfare	NN
18637	3208	12	,	,	,
18637	3208	13	the	the	DT
18637	3208	14	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3208	15	of	of	IN
18637	3208	16	a	a	DT
18637	3208	17	war	war	NN
18637	3208	18	power	power	NN
18637	3208	19	such	such	JJ
18637	3208	20	as	as	IN
18637	3208	21	the	the	DT
18637	3208	22	power	power	NN
18637	3208	23	'	'	``
18637	3208	24	To	to	TO
18637	3208	25	raise	raise	VB
18637	3208	26	and	and	CC
18637	3208	27	support	support	VB
18637	3208	28	Armies	army	NNS
18637	3208	29	,	,	,
18637	3208	30	*	*	NFP
18637	3208	31	*	*	NFP
18637	3208	32	*	*	NFP
18637	3208	33	'	'	''
18637	3208	34	and	and	CC
18637	3208	35	'	'	``
18637	3208	36	To	to	TO
18637	3208	37	provide	provide	VB
18637	3208	38	and	and	CC
18637	3208	39	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	3208	40	a	a	DT
18637	3208	41	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	3208	42	;	;	:
18637	3208	43	*	*	NFP
18637	3208	44	*	*	NFP
18637	3208	45	*	*	NFP
18637	3208	46	,	,	,
18637	3208	47	'	'	''
18637	3208	48	called	call	VBD
18637	3208	49	for	for	IN
18637	3208	50	the	the	DT
18637	3208	51	production	production	NN
18637	3208	52	by	by	IN
18637	3208	53	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3208	54	of	of	IN
18637	3208	55	war	war	NN
18637	3208	56	goods	good	NNS
18637	3208	57	in	in	IN
18637	3208	58	unprecedented	unprecedented	JJ
18637	3208	59	volume	volume	NN
18637	3208	60	with	with	IN
18637	3208	61	the	the	DT
18637	3208	62	utmost	utmost	JJ
18637	3208	63	speed	speed	NN
18637	3208	64	,	,	,
18637	3208	65	combined	combine	VBN
18637	3208	66	with	with	IN
18637	3208	67	flexibility	flexibility	NN
18637	3208	68	of	of	IN
18637	3208	69	control	control	NN
18637	3208	70	over	over	IN
18637	3208	71	the	the	DT
18637	3208	72	product	product	NN
18637	3208	73	and	and	CC
18637	3208	74	with	with	IN
18637	3208	75	a	a	DT
18637	3208	76	high	high	JJ
18637	3208	77	degree	degree	NN
18637	3208	78	of	of	IN
18637	3208	79	initiative	initiative	NN
18637	3208	80	on	on	IN
18637	3208	81	the	the	DT
18637	3208	82	part	part	NN
18637	3208	83	of	of	IN
18637	3208	84	the	the	DT
18637	3208	85	producers	producer	NNS
18637	3208	86	.	.	.
18637	3209	1	Faced	face	VBN
18637	3209	2	with	with	IN
18637	3209	3	the	the	DT
18637	3209	4	need	need	NN
18637	3209	5	to	to	TO
18637	3209	6	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	3209	7	that	that	DT
18637	3209	8	power	power	NN
18637	3209	9	,	,	,
18637	3209	10	the	the	DT
18637	3209	11	question	question	NN
18637	3209	12	was	be	VBD
18637	3209	13	whether	whether	IN
18637	3209	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3209	15	was	be	VBD
18637	3209	16	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	3209	17	the	the	DT
18637	3209	18	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3209	19	power	power	NN
18637	3209	20	of	of	IN
18637	3209	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3209	22	to	to	TO
18637	3209	23	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	3209	24	to	to	IN
18637	3209	25	the	the	DT
18637	3209	26	high	high	JJ
18637	3209	27	officials	official	NNS
18637	3209	28	named	name	VBN
18637	3209	29	therein	therein	RB
18637	3209	30	the	the	DT
18637	3209	31	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	3209	32	contained	contain	VBN
18637	3209	33	in	in	IN
18637	3209	34	the	the	DT
18637	3209	35	Original	Original	NNP
18637	3209	36	Renegotiation	Renegotiation	NNP
18637	3209	37	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3209	38	of	of	IN
18637	3209	39	April	April	NNP
18637	3209	40	28	28	CD
18637	3209	41	,	,	,
18637	3209	42	1942	1942	CD
18637	3209	43	,	,	,
18637	3209	44	and	and	CC
18637	3209	45	the	the	DT
18637	3209	46	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	3209	47	of	of	IN
18637	3209	48	October	October	NNP
18637	3209	49	21	21	CD
18637	3209	50	,	,	,
18637	3209	51	1942	1942	CD
18637	3209	52	.	.	.
18637	3210	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3210	2	believe	believe	VBP
18637	3210	3	that	that	IN
18637	3210	4	the	the	DT
18637	3210	5	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	3210	6	authority	authority	NN
18637	3210	7	there	there	RB
18637	3210	8	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3210	9	was	be	VBD
18637	3210	10	well	well	RB
18637	3210	11	within	within	IN
18637	3210	12	the	the	DT
18637	3210	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3210	14	war	war	NN
18637	3210	15	powers	power	NNS
18637	3210	16	then	then	RB
18637	3210	17	being	be	VBG
18637	3210	18	put	put	VBN
18637	3210	19	to	to	IN
18637	3210	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3210	21	predestined	predestine	VBN
18637	3210	22	uses	use	NNS
18637	3210	23	.	.	.
18637	3211	1	"	"	``
18637	3211	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3211	3	1279	1279	CD
18637	3211	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3211	5	WAR	WAR	NNP
18637	3211	6	POWERS	power	NNS
18637	3211	7	IN	in	IN
18637	3211	8	TIME	time	NN
18637	3211	9	OF	of	IN
18637	3211	10	PEACE	peace	NN
18637	3211	11	To	to	IN
18637	3211	12	some	some	DT
18637	3211	13	indeterminate	indeterminate	JJ
18637	3211	14	extent	extent	NN
18637	3211	15	the	the	DT
18637	3211	16	power	power	NN
18637	3211	17	to	to	TO
18637	3211	18	wage	wage	VB
18637	3211	19	war	war	NN
18637	3211	20	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	3211	21	the	the	DT
18637	3211	22	power	power	NN
18637	3211	23	to	to	TO
18637	3211	24	prepare	prepare	VB
18637	3211	25	for	for	IN
18637	3211	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3211	27	and	and	CC
18637	3211	28	the	the	DT
18637	3211	29	further	further	JJ
18637	3211	30	power	power	NN
18637	3211	31	to	to	TO
18637	3211	32	deal	deal	VB
18637	3211	33	with	with	IN
18637	3211	34	the	the	DT
18637	3211	35	problem	problem	NN
18637	3211	36	of	of	IN
18637	3211	37	adjustment	adjustment	NN
18637	3211	38	after	after	IN
18637	3211	39	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	3211	40	have	have	VBP
18637	3211	41	ceased	cease	VBN
18637	3211	42	.	.	.
18637	3212	1	In	in	IN
18637	3212	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3212	3	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	3212	4	,	,	,
18637	3212	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3212	6	Story	Story	NNP
18637	3212	7	wrote	write	VBD
18637	3212	8	as	as	IN
18637	3212	9	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	3212	10	with	with	IN
18637	3212	11	specific	specific	JJ
18637	3212	12	reference	reference	NN
18637	3212	13	to	to	IN
18637	3212	14	the	the	DT
18637	3212	15	question	question	NN
18637	3212	16	of	of	IN
18637	3212	17	preparation	preparation	NN
18637	3212	18	for	for	IN
18637	3212	19	war	war	NN
18637	3212	20	:	:	:
18637	3212	21	"	"	``
18637	3212	22	'	'	``
18637	3212	23	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3212	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	3212	25	important	important	JJ
18637	3212	26	also	also	RB
18637	3212	27	to	to	TO
18637	3212	28	consider	consider	VB
18637	3212	29	,	,	,
18637	3212	30	that	that	IN
18637	3212	31	the	the	DT
18637	3212	32	surest	sure	JJS
18637	3212	33	means	mean	NNS
18637	3212	34	of	of	IN
18637	3212	35	avoiding	avoid	VBG
18637	3212	36	war	war	NN
18637	3212	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	3212	38	to	to	TO
18637	3212	39	be	be	VB
18637	3212	40	prepared	prepare	VBN
18637	3212	41	for	for	IN
18637	3212	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3212	43	in	in	IN
18637	3212	44	peace	peace	NN
18637	3212	45	.	.	.
18637	3213	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3213	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3213	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3213	4	How	how	WRB
18637	3213	5	could	could	MD
18637	3213	6	a	a	DT
18637	3213	7	readiness	readiness	NN
18637	3213	8	for	for	IN
18637	3213	9	war	war	NN
18637	3213	10	in	in	IN
18637	3213	11	time	time	NN
18637	3213	12	of	of	IN
18637	3213	13	peace	peace	NN
18637	3213	14	be	be	VB
18637	3213	15	safely	safely	RB
18637	3213	16	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	3213	17	,	,	,
18637	3213	18	unless	unless	IN
18637	3213	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3213	20	could	could	MD
18637	3213	21	in	in	IN
18637	3213	22	like	like	UH
18637	3213	23	manner	manner	NN
18637	3213	24	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	3213	25	the	the	DT
18637	3213	26	preparations	preparation	NNS
18637	3213	27	and	and	CC
18637	3213	28	establishments	establishment	NNS
18637	3213	29	of	of	IN
18637	3213	30	every	every	DT
18637	3213	31	hostile	hostile	JJ
18637	3213	32	nation	nation	NN
18637	3213	33	?	?	.
18637	3214	1	The	the	DT
18637	3214	2	means	mean	NNS
18637	3214	3	of	of	IN
18637	3214	4	security	security	NN
18637	3214	5	can	can	MD
18637	3214	6	be	be	VB
18637	3214	7	only	only	RB
18637	3214	8	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	3214	9	by	by	IN
18637	3214	10	the	the	DT
18637	3214	11	means	mean	NNS
18637	3214	12	and	and	CC
18637	3214	13	the	the	DT
18637	3214	14	danger	danger	NN
18637	3214	15	of	of	IN
18637	3214	16	attack	attack	NN
18637	3214	17	.	.	.
18637	3215	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3215	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3215	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3215	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3215	5	will	will	MD
18637	3215	6	be	be	VB
18637	3215	7	in	in	IN
18637	3215	8	vain	vain	JJ
18637	3215	9	to	to	TO
18637	3215	10	oppose	oppose	VB
18637	3215	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3215	12	barriers	barrier	NNS
18637	3215	13	to	to	IN
18637	3215	14	the	the	DT
18637	3215	15	impulse	impulse	NN
18637	3215	16	of	of	IN
18637	3215	17	self	self	NN
18637	3215	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	3215	19	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	3215	20	.	.	.
18637	3216	1	'	'	``
18637	3216	2	"	"	``
18637	3216	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3216	4	1280	1280	CD
18637	3216	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3216	6	Authoritative	authoritative	JJ
18637	3216	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3216	8	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	3216	9	of	of	IN
18637	3216	10	the	the	DT
18637	3216	11	power	power	NN
18637	3216	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	3216	13	found	find	VBN
18637	3216	14	in	in	IN
18637	3216	15	Ashwander	Ashwander	NNP
18637	3216	16	_	_	NNP
18637	3216	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	3216	18	_	_	NNP
18637	3216	19	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	3216	20	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	3216	21	Authority,[1281	authority,[1281	CD
18637	3216	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3216	23	where	where	WRB
18637	3216	24	,	,	,
18637	3216	25	in	in	IN
18637	3216	26	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	3216	27	the	the	DT
18637	3216	28	power	power	NN
18637	3216	29	of	of	IN
18637	3216	30	the	the	DT
18637	3216	31	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3216	32	to	to	TO
18637	3216	33	construct	construct	VB
18637	3216	34	and	and	CC
18637	3216	35	operate	operate	VB
18637	3216	36	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	3216	37	Dam	Dam	NNP
18637	3216	38	and	and	CC
18637	3216	39	the	the	DT
18637	3216	40	power	power	NN
18637	3216	41	plant	plant	NN
18637	3216	42	connected	connect	VBN
18637	3216	43	with	with	IN
18637	3216	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3216	45	,	,	,
18637	3216	46	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	3216	47	to	to	IN
18637	3216	48	the	the	DT
18637	3216	49	National	National	NNP
18637	3216	50	Defense	Defense	NNP
18637	3216	51	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3216	52	of	of	IN
18637	3216	53	June	June	NNP
18637	3216	54	3	3	CD
18637	3216	55	,	,	,
18637	3216	56	1916,[1282	1916,[1282	CD
18637	3216	57	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3216	58	the	the	DT
18637	3216	59	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3216	60	said	say	VBD
18637	3216	61	:	:	:
18637	3216	62	"	"	``
18637	3216	63	While	while	IN
18637	3216	64	the	the	DT
18637	3216	65	District	District	NNP
18637	3216	66	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3216	67	found	find	VBD
18637	3216	68	that	that	IN
18637	3216	69	there	there	EX
18637	3216	70	is	be	VBZ
18637	3216	71	no	no	DT
18637	3216	72	intention	intention	NN
18637	3216	73	to	to	TO
18637	3216	74	use	use	VB
18637	3216	75	the	the	DT
18637	3216	76	nitrate	nitrate	JJ
18637	3216	77	plants	plant	NNS
18637	3216	78	or	or	CC
18637	3216	79	the	the	DT
18637	3216	80	hydroelectric	hydroelectric	JJ
18637	3216	81	units	unit	NNS
18637	3216	82	installed	instal	VBN
18637	3216	83	at	at	IN
18637	3216	84	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	3216	85	Dam	Dam	NNP
18637	3216	86	for	for	IN
18637	3216	87	the	the	DT
18637	3216	88	production	production	NN
18637	3216	89	of	of	IN
18637	3216	90	war	war	NN
18637	3216	91	materials	material	NNS
18637	3216	92	in	in	IN
18637	3216	93	time	time	NN
18637	3216	94	of	of	IN
18637	3216	95	peace	peace	NN
18637	3216	96	,	,	,
18637	3216	97	'	'	''
18637	3216	98	the	the	DT
18637	3216	99	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	3216	100	of	of	IN
18637	3216	101	said	say	VBD
18637	3216	102	properties	property	NNS
18637	3216	103	in	in	IN
18637	3216	104	operating	operating	NN
18637	3216	105	condition	condition	NN
18637	3216	106	and	and	CC
18637	3216	107	the	the	DT
18637	3216	108	assurance	assurance	NN
18637	3216	109	of	of	IN
18637	3216	110	an	an	DT
18637	3216	111	abundant	abundant	JJ
18637	3216	112	supply	supply	NN
18637	3216	113	of	of	IN
18637	3216	114	electric	electric	JJ
18637	3216	115	energy	energy	NN
18637	3216	116	in	in	IN
18637	3216	117	the	the	DT
18637	3216	118	event	event	NN
18637	3216	119	of	of	IN
18637	3216	120	war	war	NN
18637	3216	121	,	,	,
18637	3216	122	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	3216	123	national	national	JJ
18637	3216	124	defense	defense	NN
18637	3216	125	assets	asset	NNS
18637	3216	126	.	.	.
18637	3216	127	'	'	''
18637	3217	1	This	this	DT
18637	3217	2	finding	finding	NN
18637	3217	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	3217	4	ample	ample	JJ
18637	3217	5	support	support	NN
18637	3217	6	.	.	.
18637	3218	1	"	"	``
18637	3218	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3218	3	1283	1283	CD
18637	3218	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3218	5	Atomic	Atomic	NNP
18637	3218	6	Energy	Energy	NNP
18637	3218	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3218	8	By	by	IN
18637	3218	9	far	far	RB
18637	3218	10	the	the	DT
18637	3218	11	most	most	RBS
18637	3218	12	significant	significant	JJ
18637	3218	13	example	example	NN
18637	3218	14	of	of	IN
18637	3218	15	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3218	16	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	3218	17	at	at	IN
18637	3218	18	a	a	DT
18637	3218	19	time	time	NN
18637	3218	20	when	when	WRB
18637	3218	21	no	no	DT
18637	3218	22	actual	actual	JJ
18637	3218	23	"	"	``
18637	3218	24	shooting	shoot	VBG
18637	3218	25	war	war	NN
18637	3218	26	"	"	''
18637	3218	27	was	be	VBD
18637	3218	28	in	in	IN
18637	3218	29	progress	progress	NN
18637	3218	30	,	,	,
18637	3218	31	with	with	IN
18637	3218	32	the	the	DT
18637	3218	33	object	object	NN
18637	3218	34	of	of	IN
18637	3218	35	providing	provide	VBG
18637	3218	36	for	for	IN
18637	3218	37	the	the	DT
18637	3218	38	national	national	JJ
18637	3218	39	defense	defense	NN
18637	3218	40	,	,	,
18637	3218	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	3218	42	the	the	DT
18637	3218	43	Atomic	Atomic	NNP
18637	3218	44	Energy	Energy	NNP
18637	3218	45	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3218	46	of	of	IN
18637	3218	47	1946	1946	CD
18637	3218	48	.	.	.
18637	3219	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3219	2	1284	1284	CD
18637	3219	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3219	4	That	that	DT
18637	3219	5	law	law	NN
18637	3219	6	establishes	establish	VBZ
18637	3219	7	an	an	DT
18637	3219	8	Atomic	Atomic	NNP
18637	3219	9	Energy	Energy	NNP
18637	3219	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	3219	11	of	of	IN
18637	3219	12	five	five	CD
18637	3219	13	members	member	NNS
18637	3219	14	which	which	WDT
18637	3219	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	3219	16	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	3219	17	to	to	TO
18637	3219	18	conduct	conduct	VB
18637	3219	19	through	through	IN
18637	3219	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3219	21	own	own	JJ
18637	3219	22	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	3219	23	,	,	,
18637	3219	24	or	or	CC
18637	3219	25	by	by	IN
18637	3219	26	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3219	27	with	with	IN
18637	3219	28	,	,	,
18637	3219	29	or	or	CC
18637	3219	30	loans	loan	NNS
18637	3219	31	to	to	IN
18637	3219	32	private	private	JJ
18637	3219	33	persons	person	NNS
18637	3219	34	,	,	,
18637	3219	35	research	research	NN
18637	3219	36	and	and	CC
18637	3219	37	developmental	developmental	JJ
18637	3219	38	activity	activity	NN
18637	3219	39	relating	relate	VBG
18637	3219	40	to	to	IN
18637	3219	41	nuclear	nuclear	JJ
18637	3219	42	processes	process	NNS
18637	3219	43	,	,	,
18637	3219	44	the	the	DT
18637	3219	45	theory	theory	NN
18637	3219	46	and	and	CC
18637	3219	47	production	production	NN
18637	3219	48	of	of	IN
18637	3219	49	atomic	atomic	JJ
18637	3219	50	energy	energy	NN
18637	3219	51	and	and	CC
18637	3219	52	the	the	DT
18637	3219	53	utilization	utilization	NN
18637	3219	54	of	of	IN
18637	3219	55	fissionable	fissionable	JJ
18637	3219	56	and	and	CC
18637	3219	57	radioactive	radioactive	JJ
18637	3219	58	materials	material	NNS
18637	3219	59	for	for	IN
18637	3219	60	medical	medical	JJ
18637	3219	61	,	,	,
18637	3219	62	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	3219	63	and	and	CC
18637	3219	64	other	other	JJ
18637	3219	65	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	3219	66	.	.	.
18637	3220	1	The	the	DT
18637	3220	2	act	act	NN
18637	3220	3	further	further	RB
18637	3220	4	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	3220	5	that	that	IN
18637	3220	6	the	the	DT
18637	3220	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	3220	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	3220	9	be	be	VB
18637	3220	10	the	the	DT
18637	3220	11	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3220	12	owner	owner	NN
18637	3220	13	of	of	IN
18637	3220	14	all	all	DT
18637	3220	15	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	3220	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3220	17	with	with	IN
18637	3220	18	minor	minor	JJ
18637	3220	19	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	3220	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3220	21	for	for	IN
18637	3220	22	the	the	DT
18637	3220	23	production	production	NN
18637	3220	24	of	of	IN
18637	3220	25	fissionable	fissionable	JJ
18637	3220	26	materials	material	NNS
18637	3220	27	;	;	:
18637	3220	28	that	that	IN
18637	3220	29	all	all	DT
18637	3220	30	fissionable	fissionable	JJ
18637	3220	31	material	material	NN
18637	3220	32	produced	produce	VBN
18637	3220	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	3220	34	become	become	VB
18637	3220	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3220	36	property	property	NN
18637	3220	37	;	;	:
18637	3220	38	that	that	IN
18637	3220	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3220	40	shall	shall	MD
18637	3220	41	allocate	allocate	VB
18637	3220	42	such	such	JJ
18637	3220	43	materials	material	NNS
18637	3220	44	for	for	IN
18637	3220	45	research	research	NN
18637	3220	46	and	and	CC
18637	3220	47	developmental	developmental	JJ
18637	3220	48	activities	activity	NNS
18637	3220	49	,	,	,
18637	3220	50	and	and	CC
18637	3220	51	shall	shall	MD
18637	3220	52	license	license	VB
18637	3220	53	all	all	DT
18637	3220	54	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	3220	55	of	of	IN
18637	3220	56	source	source	NN
18637	3220	57	materials	material	NNS
18637	3220	58	.	.	.
18637	3221	1	The	the	DT
18637	3221	2	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	3221	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	3221	4	charged	charge	VBN
18637	3221	5	with	with	IN
18637	3221	6	the	the	DT
18637	3221	7	duty	duty	NN
18637	3221	8	of	of	IN
18637	3221	9	producing	produce	VBG
18637	3221	10	atomic	atomic	JJ
18637	3221	11	bombs	bomb	NNS
18637	3221	12	,	,	,
18637	3221	13	bomb	bomb	NN
18637	3221	14	parts	part	NNS
18637	3221	15	,	,	,
18637	3221	16	and	and	CC
18637	3221	17	other	other	JJ
18637	3221	18	atomic	atomic	JJ
18637	3221	19	military	military	JJ
18637	3221	20	weapons	weapon	NNS
18637	3221	21	at	at	IN
18637	3221	22	the	the	DT
18637	3221	23	direction	direction	NN
18637	3221	24	of	of	IN
18637	3221	25	the	the	DT
18637	3221	26	President	President	NNP
18637	3221	27	.	.	.
18637	3222	1	Patents	patent	NNS
18637	3222	2	relating	relate	VBG
18637	3222	3	to	to	IN
18637	3222	4	fissionable	fissionable	JJ
18637	3222	5	materials	material	NNS
18637	3222	6	must	must	MD
18637	3222	7	be	be	VB
18637	3222	8	filed	file	VBN
18637	3222	9	with	with	IN
18637	3222	10	the	the	DT
18637	3222	11	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	3222	12	,	,	,
18637	3222	13	the	the	DT
18637	3222	14	"	"	``
18637	3222	15	just	just	RB
18637	3222	16	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	3222	17	"	"	''
18637	3222	18	payable	payable	JJ
18637	3222	19	to	to	IN
18637	3222	20	the	the	DT
18637	3222	21	owners	owner	NNS
18637	3222	22	to	to	TO
18637	3222	23	be	be	VB
18637	3222	24	determined	determine	VBN
18637	3222	25	by	by	IN
18637	3222	26	a	a	DT
18637	3222	27	Patent	Patent	NNP
18637	3222	28	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	3222	29	Board	Board	NNP
18637	3222	30	designated	designate	VBN
18637	3222	31	by	by	IN
18637	3222	32	the	the	DT
18637	3222	33	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	3222	34	from	from	IN
18637	3222	35	among	among	IN
18637	3222	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3222	37	employees	employee	NNS
18637	3222	38	.	.	.
18637	3223	1	POSTWAR	POSTWAR	NNP
18637	3223	2	LEGISLATION	LEGISLATION	NNP
18637	3223	3	The	the	DT
18637	3223	4	war	war	NN
18637	3223	5	power	power	NN
18637	3223	6	"	"	''
18637	3223	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	3223	8	not	not	RB
18637	3223	9	limited	limit	VBN
18637	3223	10	to	to	IN
18637	3223	11	victories	victory	NNS
18637	3223	12	in	in	IN
18637	3223	13	the	the	DT
18637	3223	14	field	field	NN
18637	3223	15	.	.	.
18637	3224	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3224	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3224	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3224	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3224	5	carries	carry	VBZ
18637	3224	6	with	with	IN
18637	3224	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3224	8	inherently	inherently	RB
18637	3224	9	the	the	DT
18637	3224	10	power	power	NN
18637	3224	11	to	to	TO
18637	3224	12	guard	guard	VB
18637	3224	13	against	against	IN
18637	3224	14	the	the	DT
18637	3224	15	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	3224	16	renewal	renewal	NN
18637	3224	17	of	of	IN
18637	3224	18	the	the	DT
18637	3224	19	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	3224	20	,	,	,
18637	3224	21	and	and	CC
18637	3224	22	to	to	TO
18637	3224	23	remedy	remedy	VB
18637	3224	24	the	the	DT
18637	3224	25	evils	evil	NNS
18637	3224	26	which	which	WDT
18637	3224	27	have	have	VBP
18637	3224	28	arisen	arise	VBN
18637	3224	29	from	from	IN
18637	3224	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3224	31	rise	rise	NN
18637	3224	32	and	and	CC
18637	3224	33	progress	progress	NN
18637	3224	34	.	.	.
18637	3225	1	"	"	``
18637	3225	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3225	3	1285	1285	CD
18637	3225	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3225	5	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	3225	6	,	,	,
18637	3225	7	the	the	DT
18637	3225	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3225	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3225	10	held	hold	VBD
18637	3225	11	in	in	IN
18637	3225	12	1871	1871	CD
18637	3225	13	that	that	IN
18637	3225	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3225	15	was	be	VBD
18637	3225	16	within	within	IN
18637	3225	17	the	the	DT
18637	3225	18	competence	competence	NN
18637	3225	19	of	of	IN
18637	3225	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3225	21	to	to	TO
18637	3225	22	deduct	deduct	VB
18637	3225	23	from	from	IN
18637	3225	24	the	the	DT
18637	3225	25	period	period	NN
18637	3225	26	limited	limit	VBN
18637	3225	27	by	by	IN
18637	3225	28	statute	statute	NN
18637	3225	29	for	for	IN
18637	3225	30	the	the	DT
18637	3225	31	bringing	bringing	NN
18637	3225	32	of	of	IN
18637	3225	33	an	an	DT
18637	3225	34	action	action	NN
18637	3225	35	the	the	DT
18637	3225	36	time	time	NN
18637	3225	37	during	during	IN
18637	3225	38	which	which	WDT
18637	3225	39	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	3225	40	had	have	VBD
18637	3225	41	been	be	VBN
18637	3225	42	unable	unable	JJ
18637	3225	43	to	to	TO
18637	3225	44	prosecute	prosecute	VB
18637	3225	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3225	46	suit	suit	NN
18637	3225	47	in	in	IN
18637	3225	48	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	3225	49	of	of	IN
18637	3225	50	the	the	DT
18637	3225	51	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3225	52	War	War	NNP
18637	3225	53	.	.	.
18637	3226	1	This	this	DT
18637	3226	2	principle	principle	NN
18637	3226	3	was	be	VBD
18637	3226	4	given	give	VBN
18637	3226	5	a	a	DT
18637	3226	6	much	much	RB
18637	3226	7	broader	broad	JJR
18637	3226	8	application	application	NN
18637	3226	9	after	after	IN
18637	3226	10	the	the	DT
18637	3226	11	first	first	JJ
18637	3226	12	world	world	NN
18637	3226	13	war	war	NN
18637	3226	14	in	in	IN
18637	3226	15	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	3226	16	_	_	NNP
18637	3226	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	3226	18	_	_	NNP
18637	3226	19	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	3226	20	Distilleries	Distilleries	NNP
18637	3226	21	and	and	CC
18637	3226	22	Wine	Wine	NNP
18637	3226	23	Co	Co	NNP
18637	3226	24	.	.	.
18637	3226	25	,[1286	,[1286	NFP
18637	3226	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3226	27	where	where	WRB
18637	3226	28	the	the	DT
18637	3226	29	War	War	NNP
18637	3226	30	Time	Time	NNP
18637	3226	31	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	3226	32	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3226	33	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	3226	34	after	after	IN
18637	3226	35	the	the	DT
18637	3226	36	signing	signing	NN
18637	3226	37	of	of	IN
18637	3226	38	the	the	DT
18637	3226	39	Armistice	Armistice	NNP
18637	3226	40	was	be	VBD
18637	3226	41	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	3226	42	as	as	IN
18637	3226	43	an	an	DT
18637	3226	44	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	3226	45	measure	measure	NN
18637	3226	46	for	for	IN
18637	3226	47	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	3226	48	war	war	NN
18637	3226	49	efficiency	efficiency	NN
18637	3226	50	.	.	.
18637	3227	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3227	2	was	be	VBD
18637	3227	3	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	3227	4	that	that	IN
18637	3227	5	the	the	DT
18637	3227	6	measure	measure	NN
18637	3227	7	was	be	VBD
18637	3227	8	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3227	9	when	when	WRB
18637	3227	10	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	3227	11	,	,	,
18637	3227	12	since	since	IN
18637	3227	13	the	the	DT
18637	3227	14	mere	mere	JJ
18637	3227	15	cessation	cessation	NN
18637	3227	16	of	of	IN
18637	3227	17	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	3227	18	did	do	VBD
18637	3227	19	not	not	RB
18637	3227	20	end	end	VB
18637	3227	21	the	the	DT
18637	3227	22	war	war	NN
18637	3227	23	or	or	CC
18637	3227	24	terminate	terminate	VB
18637	3227	25	the	the	DT
18637	3227	26	war	war	NN
18637	3227	27	powers	power	NNS
18637	3227	28	of	of	IN
18637	3227	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3227	30	.	.	.
18637	3228	1	The	the	DT
18637	3228	2	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	3228	3	contended	contend	VBD
18637	3228	4	however	however	RB
18637	3228	5	that	that	IN
18637	3228	6	in	in	IN
18637	3228	7	October	October	NNP
18637	3228	8	1919	1919	CD
18637	3228	9	,	,	,
18637	3228	10	when	when	WRB
18637	3228	11	the	the	DT
18637	3228	12	suit	suit	NN
18637	3228	13	was	be	VBD
18637	3228	14	brought	bring	VBN
18637	3228	15	,	,	,
18637	3228	16	the	the	DT
18637	3228	17	war	war	NN
18637	3228	18	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	3228	19	had	have	VBD
18637	3228	20	in	in	IN
18637	3228	21	fact	fact	NN
18637	3228	22	passed	pass	VBN
18637	3228	23	,	,	,
18637	3228	24	and	and	CC
18637	3228	25	that	that	IN
18637	3228	26	the	the	DT
18637	3228	27	law	law	NN
18637	3228	28	was	be	VBD
18637	3228	29	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	3228	30	obsolete	obsolete	JJ
18637	3228	31	.	.	.
18637	3229	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	3229	2	as	as	IN
18637	3229	3	the	the	DT
18637	3229	4	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	3229	5	of	of	IN
18637	3229	6	peace	peace	NN
18637	3229	7	had	have	VBD
18637	3229	8	not	not	RB
18637	3229	9	yet	yet	RB
18637	3229	10	been	be	VBN
18637	3229	11	concluded	conclude	VBN
18637	3229	12	and	and	CC
18637	3229	13	other	other	JJ
18637	3229	14	war	war	NN
18637	3229	15	activities	activity	NNS
18637	3229	16	had	have	VBD
18637	3229	17	not	not	RB
18637	3229	18	been	be	VBN
18637	3229	19	brought	bring	VBN
18637	3229	20	to	to	IN
18637	3229	21	a	a	DT
18637	3229	22	close	close	NN
18637	3229	23	,	,	,
18637	3229	24	the	the	DT
18637	3229	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3229	26	said	say	VBD
18637	3229	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3229	28	was	be	VBD
18637	3229	29	"	"	``
18637	3229	30	unable	unable	JJ
18637	3229	31	to	to	TO
18637	3229	32	conclude	conclude	VB
18637	3229	33	"	"	''
18637	3229	34	that	that	IN
18637	3229	35	the	the	DT
18637	3229	36	act	act	NN
18637	3229	37	had	have	VBD
18637	3229	38	ceased	cease	VBN
18637	3229	39	to	to	TO
18637	3229	40	be	be	VB
18637	3229	41	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3229	42	.	.	.
18637	3230	1	But	but	CC
18637	3230	2	in	in	IN
18637	3230	3	1924	1924	CD
18637	3230	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3230	5	held	hold	VBD
18637	3230	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	3230	7	the	the	DT
18637	3230	8	facts	fact	NNS
18637	3230	9	that	that	WDT
18637	3230	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3230	11	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	3230	12	know	know	VBP
18637	3230	13	that	that	IN
18637	3230	14	the	the	DT
18637	3230	15	rent	rent	NN
18637	3230	16	control	control	NN
18637	3230	17	law	law	NN
18637	3230	18	for	for	IN
18637	3230	19	the	the	DT
18637	3230	20	District	District	NNP
18637	3230	21	of	of	IN
18637	3230	22	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3230	23	,	,	,
18637	3230	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3230	25	had	have	VBD
18637	3230	26	previously	previously	RB
18637	3230	27	been	be	VBN
18637	3230	28	upheld,[1287	upheld,[1287	NNP
18637	3230	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3230	30	had	have	VBD
18637	3230	31	ceased	cease	VBN
18637	3230	32	to	to	TO
18637	3230	33	operate	operate	VB
18637	3230	34	because	because	IN
18637	3230	35	the	the	DT
18637	3230	36	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	3230	37	which	which	WDT
18637	3230	38	justified	justify	VBD
18637	3230	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3230	40	had	have	VBD
18637	3230	41	come	come	VBN
18637	3230	42	to	to	IN
18637	3230	43	an	an	DT
18637	3230	44	end	end	NN
18637	3230	45	.	.	.
18637	3231	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3231	2	1288	1288	CD
18637	3231	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3231	4	A	a	DT
18637	3231	5	similar	similar	JJ
18637	3231	6	issue	issue	NN
18637	3231	7	was	be	VBD
18637	3231	8	present	present	JJ
18637	3231	9	after	after	IN
18637	3231	10	World	World	NNP
18637	3231	11	War	War	NNP
18637	3231	12	II	II	NNP
18637	3231	13	in	in	IN
18637	3231	14	Woods	Woods	NNP
18637	3231	15	_	_	NNP
18637	3231	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	3231	17	_	_	NNP
18637	3231	18	Miller,[1289	miller,[1289	CD
18637	3231	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3231	20	where	where	WRB
18637	3231	21	the	the	DT
18637	3231	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3231	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3231	24	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	3231	25	a	a	DT
18637	3231	26	decision	decision	NN
18637	3231	27	of	of	IN
18637	3231	28	a	a	DT
18637	3231	29	lower	low	JJR
18637	3231	30	court	court	NN
18637	3231	31	to	to	IN
18637	3231	32	the	the	DT
18637	3231	33	effect	effect	NN
18637	3231	34	that	that	IN
18637	3231	35	the	the	DT
18637	3231	36	authority	authority	NN
18637	3231	37	of	of	IN
18637	3231	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3231	39	to	to	TO
18637	3231	40	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	3231	41	rents	rent	NNS
18637	3231	42	by	by	IN
18637	3231	43	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	3231	44	of	of	IN
18637	3231	45	the	the	DT
18637	3231	46	war	war	NN
18637	3231	47	power	power	NN
18637	3231	48	ended	end	VBD
18637	3231	49	with	with	IN
18637	3231	50	the	the	DT
18637	3231	51	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	3231	52	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	3231	53	terminating	terminate	VBG
18637	3231	54	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	3231	55	on	on	IN
18637	3231	56	December	December	NNP
18637	3231	57	31	31	CD
18637	3231	58	,	,	,
18637	3231	59	1946	1946	CD
18637	3231	60	.	.	.
18637	3232	1	This	this	DT
18637	3232	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	3232	3	was	be	VBD
18637	3232	4	coupled	couple	VBN
18637	3232	5	with	with	IN
18637	3232	6	a	a	DT
18637	3232	7	warning	warning	NN
18637	3232	8	that	that	WDT
18637	3232	9	:	:	:
18637	3232	10	"	"	``
18637	3232	11	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3232	12	recognize	recognize	VBP
18637	3232	13	the	the	DT
18637	3232	14	force	force	NN
18637	3232	15	of	of	IN
18637	3232	16	the	the	DT
18637	3232	17	argument	argument	NN
18637	3232	18	that	that	IN
18637	3232	19	the	the	DT
18637	3232	20	effects	effect	NNS
18637	3232	21	of	of	IN
18637	3232	22	war	war	NN
18637	3232	23	under	under	IN
18637	3232	24	modern	modern	JJ
18637	3232	25	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	3232	26	may	may	MD
18637	3232	27	be	be	VB
18637	3232	28	felt	feel	VBN
18637	3232	29	in	in	IN
18637	3232	30	the	the	DT
18637	3232	31	economy	economy	NN
18637	3232	32	for	for	IN
18637	3232	33	years	year	NNS
18637	3232	34	and	and	CC
18637	3232	35	years	year	NNS
18637	3232	36	,	,	,
18637	3232	37	and	and	CC
18637	3232	38	that	that	IN
18637	3232	39	if	if	IN
18637	3232	40	the	the	DT
18637	3232	41	war	war	NN
18637	3232	42	power	power	NN
18637	3232	43	can	can	MD
18637	3232	44	be	be	VB
18637	3232	45	used	use	VBN
18637	3232	46	in	in	IN
18637	3232	47	days	day	NNS
18637	3232	48	of	of	IN
18637	3232	49	peace	peace	NN
18637	3232	50	to	to	TO
18637	3232	51	treat	treat	VB
18637	3232	52	all	all	PDT
18637	3232	53	the	the	DT
18637	3232	54	wounds	wound	NNS
18637	3232	55	which	which	WDT
18637	3232	56	war	war	NN
18637	3232	57	inflicts	inflict	VBZ
18637	3232	58	on	on	IN
18637	3232	59	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3232	60	society	society	NN
18637	3232	61	,	,	,
18637	3232	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3232	63	may	may	MD
18637	3232	64	not	not	RB
18637	3232	65	only	only	RB
18637	3232	66	swallow	swallow	VB
18637	3232	67	up	up	RP
18637	3232	68	all	all	DT
18637	3232	69	other	other	JJ
18637	3232	70	powers	power	NNS
18637	3232	71	of	of	IN
18637	3232	72	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3232	73	but	but	CC
18637	3232	74	largely	largely	RB
18637	3232	75	obliterate	obliterate	VBP
18637	3232	76	the	the	DT
18637	3232	77	Ninth	Ninth	NNP
18637	3232	78	and	and	CC
18637	3232	79	the	the	DT
18637	3232	80	Tenth	tenth	JJ
18637	3232	81	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	3232	82	as	as	RB
18637	3232	83	well	well	RB
18637	3232	84	.	.	.
18637	3233	1	There	there	EX
18637	3233	2	are	be	VBP
18637	3233	3	no	no	DT
18637	3233	4	such	such	JJ
18637	3233	5	implications	implication	NNS
18637	3233	6	in	in	IN
18637	3233	7	today	today	NN
18637	3233	8	's	's	POS
18637	3233	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	3233	10	.	.	.
18637	3234	1	"	"	``
18637	3234	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3234	3	1290	1290	CD
18637	3234	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3234	5	In	in	IN
18637	3234	6	1948	1948	CD
18637	3234	7	,	,	,
18637	3234	8	a	a	DT
18637	3234	9	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	3234	10	divided	divide	VBN
18637	3234	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3234	12	further	further	RB
18637	3234	13	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	3234	14	that	that	IN
18637	3234	15	the	the	DT
18637	3234	16	power	power	NN
18637	3234	17	which	which	WDT
18637	3234	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3234	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	3234	20	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	3234	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	3234	22	the	the	DT
18637	3234	23	President	President	NNP
18637	3234	24	to	to	TO
18637	3234	25	deport	deport	VB
18637	3234	26	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	3234	27	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	3234	28	in	in	IN
18637	3234	29	time	time	NN
18637	3234	30	of	of	IN
18637	3234	31	a	a	DT
18637	3234	32	declared	declare	VBN
18637	3234	33	war	war	NN
18637	3234	34	was	be	VBD
18637	3234	35	not	not	RB
18637	3234	36	exhausted	exhaust	VBN
18637	3234	37	when	when	WRB
18637	3234	38	the	the	DT
18637	3234	39	shooting	shoot	VBG
18637	3234	40	war	war	NN
18637	3234	41	stopped	stop	VBD
18637	3234	42	.	.	.
18637	3235	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	3235	2	for	for	IN
18637	3235	3	the	the	DT
18637	3235	4	majority	majority	NN
18637	3235	5	of	of	IN
18637	3235	6	five	five	CD
18637	3235	7	,	,	,
18637	3235	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3235	9	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	3235	10	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3235	11	:	:	:
18637	3235	12	"	"	``
18637	3235	13	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3235	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	3235	15	not	not	RB
18637	3235	16	for	for	IN
18637	3235	17	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3235	18	to	to	TO
18637	3235	19	question	question	VB
18637	3235	20	a	a	DT
18637	3235	21	belief	belief	NN
18637	3235	22	by	by	IN
18637	3235	23	the	the	DT
18637	3235	24	President	President	NNP
18637	3235	25	that	that	IN
18637	3235	26	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	3235	27	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	3235	28	who	who	WP
18637	3235	29	were	be	VBD
18637	3235	30	justifiably	justifiably	RB
18637	3235	31	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	3235	32	fit	fit	JJ
18637	3235	33	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	3235	34	for	for	IN
18637	3235	35	internment	internment	NN
18637	3235	36	during	during	IN
18637	3235	37	active	active	JJ
18637	3235	38	hostilites	hostilite	NNS
18637	3235	39	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3235	40	sic	sic	NN
18637	3235	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3235	42	do	do	VBP
18637	3235	43	not	not	RB
18637	3235	44	lose	lose	VB
18637	3235	45	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3235	46	potency	potency	NN
18637	3235	47	for	for	IN
18637	3235	48	mischief	mischief	NN
18637	3235	49	during	during	IN
18637	3235	50	the	the	DT
18637	3235	51	period	period	NN
18637	3235	52	of	of	IN
18637	3235	53	confusion	confusion	NN
18637	3235	54	and	and	CC
18637	3235	55	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	3235	56	which	which	WDT
18637	3235	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	3235	58	characteristic	characteristic	JJ
18637	3235	59	of	of	IN
18637	3235	60	a	a	DT
18637	3235	61	state	state	NN
18637	3235	62	of	of	IN
18637	3235	63	war	war	NN
18637	3235	64	even	even	RB
18637	3235	65	when	when	WRB
18637	3235	66	the	the	DT
18637	3235	67	guns	gun	NNS
18637	3235	68	are	be	VBP
18637	3235	69	silent	silent	JJ
18637	3235	70	but	but	CC
18637	3235	71	the	the	DT
18637	3235	72	peace	peace	NN
18637	3235	73	of	of	IN
18637	3235	74	Peace	Peace	NNP
18637	3235	75	has	have	VBZ
18637	3235	76	not	not	RB
18637	3235	77	come	come	VBN
18637	3235	78	.	.	.
18637	3236	1	"	"	``
18637	3236	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3236	3	1291	1291	CD
18637	3236	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3236	5	Private	Private	NNP
18637	3236	6	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	3236	7	in	in	IN
18637	3236	8	Wartime	wartime	JJ
18637	3236	9	ENEMY	enemy	NN
18637	3236	10	COUNTRY	country	NN
18637	3236	11	Although	although	IN
18637	3236	12	,	,	,
18637	3236	13	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	3236	14	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	3236	15	,	,	,
18637	3236	16	the	the	DT
18637	3236	17	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3236	18	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	3236	19	designed	design	VBN
18637	3236	20	for	for	IN
18637	3236	21	the	the	DT
18637	3236	22	protection	protection	NN
18637	3236	23	of	of	IN
18637	3236	24	individual	individual	JJ
18637	3236	25	rights	right	NNS
18637	3236	26	are	be	VBP
18637	3236	27	operative	operative	JJ
18637	3236	28	in	in	IN
18637	3236	29	war	war	NN
18637	3236	30	as	as	RB
18637	3236	31	well	well	RB
18637	3236	32	as	as	IN
18637	3236	33	in	in	IN
18637	3236	34	peace	peace	NN
18637	3236	35	,	,	,
18637	3236	36	the	the	DT
18637	3236	37	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	3236	38	of	of	IN
18637	3236	39	war	war	NN
18637	3236	40	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	3236	41	give	give	VBP
18637	3236	42	rise	rise	NN
18637	3236	43	to	to	IN
18637	3236	44	situations	situation	NNS
18637	3236	45	in	in	IN
18637	3236	46	which	which	WDT
18637	3236	47	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	3236	48	enforceable	enforceable	JJ
18637	3236	49	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3236	50	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	3236	51	are	be	VBP
18637	3236	52	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	3236	53	.	.	.
18637	3237	1	In	in	IN
18637	3237	2	the	the	DT
18637	3237	3	first	first	JJ
18637	3237	4	place	place	NN
18637	3237	5	persons	person	NNS
18637	3237	6	in	in	IN
18637	3237	7	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	3237	8	territory	territory	NN
18637	3237	9	are	be	VBP
18637	3237	10	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	3237	11	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	3237	12	the	the	DT
18637	3237	13	reach	reach	NN
18637	3237	14	of	of	IN
18637	3237	15	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3237	16	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	3237	17	.	.	.
18637	3238	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3238	2	are	be	VBP
18637	3238	3	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3238	4	,	,	,
18637	3238	5	in	in	IN
18637	3238	6	relation	relation	NN
18637	3238	7	to	to	IN
18637	3238	8	the	the	DT
18637	3238	9	war	war	NN
18637	3238	10	powers	power	NNS
18637	3238	11	of	of	IN
18637	3238	12	the	the	DT
18637	3238	13	National	National	NNP
18637	3238	14	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3238	15	,	,	,
18637	3238	16	to	to	IN
18637	3238	17	the	the	DT
18637	3238	18	laws	law	NNS
18637	3238	19	of	of	IN
18637	3238	20	war	war	NN
18637	3238	21	as	as	IN
18637	3238	22	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	3238	23	and	and	CC
18637	3238	24	applied	apply	VBN
18637	3238	25	by	by	IN
18637	3238	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3238	27	and	and	CC
18637	3238	28	by	by	IN
18637	3238	29	the	the	DT
18637	3238	30	President	President	NNP
18637	3238	31	as	as	IN
18637	3238	32	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	3238	33	in	in	IN
18637	3238	34	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3238	35	.	.	.
18637	3239	1	To	to	IN
18637	3239	2	the	the	DT
18637	3239	3	question	question	NN
18637	3239	4	:	:	:
18637	3239	5	"	"	``
18637	3239	6	What	what	WP
18637	3239	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	3239	8	the	the	DT
18637	3239	9	law	law	NN
18637	3239	10	which	which	WDT
18637	3239	11	governs	govern	VBZ
18637	3239	12	an	an	DT
18637	3239	13	army	army	NN
18637	3239	14	invading	invade	VBG
18637	3239	15	an	an	DT
18637	3239	16	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	3239	17	's	's	POS
18637	3239	18	country	country	NN
18637	3239	19	?	?	.
18637	3239	20	"	"	''
18637	3240	1	the	the	DT
18637	3240	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3240	3	gave	give	VBD
18637	3240	4	the	the	DT
18637	3240	5	following	follow	VBG
18637	3240	6	answer	answer	NN
18637	3240	7	in	in	IN
18637	3240	8	Dow	Dow	NNP
18637	3240	9	_	_	NNP
18637	3240	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	3240	11	_	_	NNP
18637	3240	12	Johnson:[1292	Johnson:[1292	,
18637	3240	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3240	14	"	"	``
18637	3240	15	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3240	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	3240	17	not	not	RB
18637	3240	18	the	the	DT
18637	3240	19	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3240	20	law	law	NN
18637	3240	21	of	of	IN
18637	3240	22	the	the	DT
18637	3240	23	invaded	invade	VBN
18637	3240	24	country	country	NN
18637	3240	25	;	;	:
18637	3240	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3240	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	3240	28	not	not	RB
18637	3240	29	the	the	DT
18637	3240	30	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3240	31	law	law	NN
18637	3240	32	of	of	IN
18637	3240	33	the	the	DT
18637	3240	34	conquering	conquer	VBG
18637	3240	35	country	country	NN
18637	3240	36	:	:	:
18637	3240	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3240	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	3240	39	military	military	JJ
18637	3240	40	law,--the	law,--the	JJR
18637	3240	41	law	law	NN
18637	3240	42	of	of	IN
18637	3240	43	war,--and	war,--and	NNP
18637	3240	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3240	45	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	3240	46	for	for	IN
18637	3240	47	the	the	DT
18637	3240	48	protection	protection	NN
18637	3240	49	of	of	IN
18637	3240	50	the	the	DT
18637	3240	51	officers	officer	NNS
18637	3240	52	and	and	CC
18637	3240	53	soldiers	soldier	NNS
18637	3240	54	of	of	IN
18637	3240	55	the	the	DT
18637	3240	56	army	army	NN
18637	3240	57	,	,	,
18637	3240	58	when	when	WRB
18637	3240	59	in	in	IN
18637	3240	60	service	service	NN
18637	3240	61	in	in	IN
18637	3240	62	the	the	DT
18637	3240	63	field	field	NN
18637	3240	64	in	in	IN
18637	3240	65	the	the	DT
18637	3240	66	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	3240	67	's	's	POS
18637	3240	68	country	country	NN
18637	3240	69	,	,	,
18637	3240	70	is	be	VBZ
18637	3240	71	as	as	RB
18637	3240	72	essential	essential	JJ
18637	3240	73	to	to	IN
18637	3240	74	the	the	DT
18637	3240	75	efficiency	efficiency	NN
18637	3240	76	of	of	IN
18637	3240	77	the	the	DT
18637	3240	78	army	army	NN
18637	3240	79	as	as	IN
18637	3240	80	the	the	DT
18637	3240	81	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	3240	82	of	of	IN
18637	3240	83	the	the	DT
18637	3240	84	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3240	85	law	law	NN
18637	3240	86	at	at	IN
18637	3240	87	home	home	NN
18637	3240	88	,	,	,
18637	3240	89	and	and	CC
18637	3240	90	,	,	,
18637	3240	91	in	in	IN
18637	3240	92	time	time	NN
18637	3240	93	of	of	IN
18637	3240	94	peace	peace	NN
18637	3240	95	,	,	,
18637	3240	96	is	be	VBZ
18637	3240	97	essential	essential	JJ
18637	3240	98	to	to	IN
18637	3240	99	the	the	DT
18637	3240	100	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	3240	101	of	of	IN
18637	3240	102	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	3240	103	.	.	.
18637	3241	1	"	"	``
18637	3241	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3241	3	1293	1293	CD
18637	3241	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3241	5	THEATRE	THEATRE	NNP
18637	3241	6	OF	of	IN
18637	3241	7	MILITARY	MILITARY	NNP
18637	3241	8	OPERATIONS	OPERATIONS	NNP
18637	3241	9	That	that	IN
18637	3241	10	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	3241	11	the	the	DT
18637	3241	12	same	same	JJ
18637	3241	13	rule	rule	NN
18637	3241	14	,	,	,
18637	3241	15	resting	rest	VBG
18637	3241	16	on	on	IN
18637	3241	17	the	the	DT
18637	3241	18	same	same	JJ
18637	3241	19	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	3241	20	,	,	,
18637	3241	21	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	3241	22	in	in	IN
18637	3241	23	the	the	DT
18637	3241	24	field	field	NN
18637	3241	25	of	of	IN
18637	3241	26	active	active	JJ
18637	3241	27	military	military	JJ
18637	3241	28	operations	operation	NNS
18637	3241	29	,	,	,
18637	3241	30	was	be	VBD
18637	3241	31	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	3241	32	by	by	IN
18637	3241	33	all	all	DT
18637	3241	34	members	member	NNS
18637	3241	35	of	of	IN
18637	3241	36	the	the	DT
18637	3241	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3241	38	in	in	IN
18637	3241	39	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	3241	40	parte	parte	NN
18637	3241	41	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
18637	3241	42	.	.	.
18637	3242	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3242	2	1294	1294	CD
18637	3242	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3242	4	There	there	RB
18637	3242	5	the	the	DT
18637	3242	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3242	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	3242	8	that	that	IN
18637	3242	9	the	the	DT
18637	3242	10	trial	trial	NN
18637	3242	11	by	by	IN
18637	3242	12	a	a	DT
18637	3242	13	military	military	JJ
18637	3242	14	commission	commission	NN
18637	3242	15	of	of	IN
18637	3242	16	a	a	DT
18637	3242	17	civilian	civilian	NN
18637	3242	18	charged	charge	VBN
18637	3242	19	with	with	IN
18637	3242	20	acts	act	NNS
18637	3242	21	of	of	IN
18637	3242	22	disloyalty	disloyalty	NN
18637	3242	23	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3242	24	in	in	IN
18637	3242	25	a	a	DT
18637	3242	26	part	part	NN
18637	3242	27	of	of	IN
18637	3242	28	the	the	DT
18637	3242	29	country	country	NN
18637	3242	30	which	which	WDT
18637	3242	31	was	be	VBD
18637	3242	32	remote	remote	JJ
18637	3242	33	from	from	IN
18637	3242	34	the	the	DT
18637	3242	35	theatre	theatre	NN
18637	3242	36	of	of	IN
18637	3242	37	military	military	JJ
18637	3242	38	operations	operation	NNS
18637	3242	39	,	,	,
18637	3242	40	and	and	CC
18637	3242	41	in	in	IN
18637	3242	42	which	which	WDT
18637	3242	43	the	the	DT
18637	3242	44	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3242	45	courts	court	NNS
18637	3242	46	were	be	VBD
18637	3242	47	open	open	JJ
18637	3242	48	and	and	CC
18637	3242	49	functioning	functioning	JJ
18637	3242	50	,	,	,
18637	3242	51	was	be	VBD
18637	3242	52	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	3242	53	under	under	IN
18637	3242	54	the	the	DT
18637	3242	55	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	3242	56	and	and	CC
18637	3242	57	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	3242	58	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	3242	59	.	.	.
18637	3243	1	Although	although	IN
18637	3243	2	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	3243	3	in	in	IN
18637	3243	4	holding	hold	VBG
18637	3243	5	that	that	IN
18637	3243	6	the	the	DT
18637	3243	7	military	military	JJ
18637	3243	8	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	3243	9	lacked	lack	VBD
18637	3243	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3243	11	to	to	TO
18637	3243	12	try	try	VB
18637	3243	13	the	the	DT
18637	3243	14	case	case	NN
18637	3243	15	,	,	,
18637	3243	16	the	the	DT
18637	3243	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3243	18	divided	divide	VBD
18637	3243	19	,	,	,
18637	3243	20	five	five	CD
18637	3243	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	3243	22	to	to	IN
18637	3243	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	3243	24	four	four	CD
18637	3243	25	,	,	,
18637	3243	26	as	as	IN
18637	3243	27	to	to	IN
18637	3243	28	the	the	DT
18637	3243	29	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	3243	30	of	of	IN
18637	3243	31	the	the	DT
18637	3243	32	decision	decision	NN
18637	3243	33	.	.	.
18637	3244	1	The	the	DT
18637	3244	2	point	point	NN
18637	3244	3	on	on	IN
18637	3244	4	which	which	WDT
18637	3244	5	the	the	DT
18637	3244	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	3244	7	differed	differ	VBD
18637	3244	8	was	be	VBD
18637	3244	9	which	which	WDT
18637	3244	10	department	department	NN
18637	3244	11	of	of	IN
18637	3244	12	the	the	DT
18637	3244	13	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3244	14	had	have	VBD
18637	3244	15	authority	authority	NN
18637	3244	16	to	to	TO
18637	3244	17	say	say	VB
18637	3244	18	with	with	IN
18637	3244	19	finality	finality	NN
18637	3244	20	what	what	WDT
18637	3244	21	regions	region	NNS
18637	3244	22	lie	lie	VBP
18637	3244	23	within	within	IN
18637	3244	24	the	the	DT
18637	3244	25	theatre	theatre	NNP
18637	3244	26	of	of	IN
18637	3244	27	military	military	JJ
18637	3244	28	operation	operation	NN
18637	3244	29	.	.	.
18637	3245	1	Claiming	claim	VBG
18637	3245	2	this	this	DT
18637	3245	3	as	as	IN
18637	3245	4	a	a	DT
18637	3245	5	function	function	NN
18637	3245	6	of	of	IN
18637	3245	7	the	the	DT
18637	3245	8	courts	court	NNS
18637	3245	9	,	,	,
18637	3245	10	the	the	DT
18637	3245	11	majority	majority	NN
18637	3245	12	held	hold	VBD
18637	3245	13	that	that	IN
18637	3245	14	the	the	DT
18637	3245	15	theatre	theatre	NNP
18637	3245	16	of	of	IN
18637	3245	17	war	war	NNP
18637	3245	18	did	do	VBD
18637	3245	19	not	not	RB
18637	3245	20	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	3245	21	an	an	DT
18637	3245	22	area	area	NN
18637	3245	23	in	in	IN
18637	3245	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3245	25	the	the	DT
18637	3245	26	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3245	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	3245	28	were	be	VBD
18637	3245	29	open	open	JJ
18637	3245	30	and	and	CC
18637	3245	31	functioning	functioning	JJ
18637	3245	32	.	.	.
18637	3246	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3246	2	1295	1295	CD
18637	3246	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3246	4	The	the	DT
18637	3246	5	minority	minority	NN
18637	3246	6	argued	argue	VBD
18637	3246	7	that	that	IN
18637	3246	8	this	this	DT
18637	3246	9	was	be	VBD
18637	3246	10	a	a	DT
18637	3246	11	question	question	NN
18637	3246	12	to	to	TO
18637	3246	13	be	be	VB
18637	3246	14	determined	determine	VBN
18637	3246	15	by	by	IN
18637	3246	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3246	17	.	.	.
18637	3247	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3247	2	1296	1296	CD
18637	3247	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3247	4	All	all	DT
18637	3247	5	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	3247	6	the	the	DT
18637	3247	7	argument	argument	NN
18637	3247	8	of	of	IN
18637	3247	9	the	the	DT
18637	3247	10	government	government	NN
18637	3247	11	that	that	WDT
18637	3247	12	the	the	DT
18637	3247	13	President	President	NNP
18637	3247	14	's	's	POS
18637	3247	15	determination	determination	NN
18637	3247	16	was	be	VBD
18637	3247	17	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	3247	18	in	in	IN
18637	3247	19	the	the	DT
18637	3247	20	absence	absence	NN
18637	3247	21	of	of	IN
18637	3247	22	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	3247	23	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3247	24	.	.	.
18637	3248	1	A	a	DT
18637	3248	2	similar	similar	JJ
18637	3248	3	result	result	NN
18637	3248	4	was	be	VBD
18637	3248	5	reached	reach	VBN
18637	3248	6	in	in	IN
18637	3248	7	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	3248	8	_	_	NNP
18637	3248	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	3248	10	_	_	NNP
18637	3248	11	Kahanamoku[1297	Kahanamoku[1297	NNP
18637	3248	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3248	13	where	where	WRB
18637	3248	14	,	,	,
18637	3248	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	3248	16	an	an	DT
18637	3248	17	examination	examination	NN
18637	3248	18	of	of	IN
18637	3248	19	the	the	DT
18637	3248	20	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	3248	21	existing	exist	VBG
18637	3248	22	in	in	IN
18637	3248	23	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	3248	24	after	after	IN
18637	3248	25	Pearl	Pearl	NNP
18637	3248	26	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	3248	27	,	,	,
18637	3248	28	a	a	DT
18637	3248	29	divided	divide	VBN
18637	3248	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3248	31	found	find	VBD
18637	3248	32	that	that	IN
18637	3248	33	the	the	DT
18637	3248	34	authority	authority	NN
18637	3248	35	which	which	WDT
18637	3248	36	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3248	37	had	have	VBD
18637	3248	38	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3248	39	to	to	IN
18637	3248	40	the	the	DT
18637	3248	41	Territorial	Territorial	NNP
18637	3248	42	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	3248	43	to	to	TO
18637	3248	44	declare	declare	VB
18637	3248	45	martial	martial	JJ
18637	3248	46	law	law	NN
18637	3248	47	"	"	''
18637	3248	48	in	in	IN
18637	3248	49	case	case	NN
18637	3248	50	of	of	IN
18637	3248	51	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	3248	52	or	or	CC
18637	3248	53	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	3248	54	,	,	,
18637	3248	55	or	or	CC
18637	3248	56	imminent	imminent	JJ
18637	3248	57	danger	danger	NN
18637	3248	58	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	3248	59	,	,	,
18637	3248	60	"	"	``
18637	3248	61	did	do	VBD
18637	3248	62	not	not	RB
18637	3248	63	warrant	warrant	VB
18637	3248	64	the	the	DT
18637	3248	65	trial	trial	NN
18637	3248	66	of	of	IN
18637	3248	67	civilians	civilian	NNS
18637	3248	68	by	by	IN
18637	3248	69	military	military	JJ
18637	3248	70	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	3248	71	.	.	.
18637	3249	1	ENEMY	enemy	NN
18637	3249	2	PROPERTY	property	NN
18637	3249	3	The	the	DT
18637	3249	4	position	position	NN
18637	3249	5	of	of	IN
18637	3249	6	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	3249	7	property	property	NN
18637	3249	8	was	be	VBD
18637	3249	9	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	3249	10	with	with	IN
18637	3249	11	by	by	IN
18637	3249	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3249	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3249	14	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3249	15	in	in	IN
18637	3249	16	the	the	DT
18637	3249	17	early	early	JJ
18637	3249	18	case	case	NN
18637	3249	19	of	of	IN
18637	3249	20	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	3249	21	_	_	NNP
18637	3249	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	3249	23	_	_	NNP
18637	3249	24	United	United	NNP
18637	3249	25	States	States	NNP
18637	3249	26	.	.	.
18637	3250	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3250	2	1298	1298	CD
18637	3250	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3250	4	Here	here	RB
18637	3250	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3250	6	was	be	VBD
18637	3250	7	held	hold	VBN
18637	3250	8	that	that	IN
18637	3250	9	the	the	DT
18637	3250	10	mere	mere	JJ
18637	3250	11	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	3250	12	of	of	IN
18637	3250	13	war	war	NN
18637	3250	14	by	by	IN
18637	3250	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3250	16	does	do	VBZ
18637	3250	17	not	not	RB
18637	3250	18	effect	effect	VB
18637	3250	19	a	a	DT
18637	3250	20	confiscation	confiscation	NN
18637	3250	21	of	of	IN
18637	3250	22	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	3250	23	property	property	NN
18637	3250	24	situated	situate	VBN
18637	3250	25	within	within	IN
18637	3250	26	the	the	DT
18637	3250	27	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	3250	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3250	29	of	of	IN
18637	3250	30	the	the	DT
18637	3250	31	United	United	NNP
18637	3250	32	States	States	NNP
18637	3250	33	,	,	,
18637	3250	34	but	but	CC
18637	3250	35	the	the	DT
18637	3250	36	right	right	NN
18637	3250	37	of	of	IN
18637	3250	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3250	39	by	by	IN
18637	3250	40	further	further	JJ
18637	3250	41	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	3250	42	to	to	TO
18637	3250	43	subject	subject	VB
18637	3250	44	such	such	JJ
18637	3250	45	property	property	NN
18637	3250	46	to	to	IN
18637	3250	47	confiscation	confiscation	NN
18637	3250	48	was	be	VBD
18637	3250	49	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	3250	50	in	in	IN
18637	3250	51	the	the	DT
18637	3250	52	most	most	RBS
18637	3250	53	positive	positive	JJ
18637	3250	54	terms	term	NNS
18637	3250	55	.	.	.
18637	3251	1	Being	be	VBG
18637	3251	2	an	an	DT
18637	3251	3	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3251	4	of	of	IN
18637	3251	5	the	the	DT
18637	3251	6	war	war	NN
18637	3251	7	powers	power	NNS
18637	3251	8	of	of	IN
18637	3251	9	the	the	DT
18637	3251	10	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3251	11	,	,	,
18637	3251	12	such	such	JJ
18637	3251	13	confiscation	confiscation	NN
18637	3251	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	3251	15	not	not	RB
18637	3251	16	affected	affect	VBN
18637	3251	17	by	by	IN
18637	3251	18	the	the	DT
18637	3251	19	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	3251	20	of	of	IN
18637	3251	21	the	the	DT
18637	3251	22	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	3251	23	and	and	CC
18637	3251	24	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	3251	25	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	3251	26	.	.	.
18637	3252	1	Since	since	IN
18637	3252	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3252	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	3252	4	no	no	DT
18637	3252	5	relation	relation	NN
18637	3252	6	to	to	IN
18637	3252	7	the	the	DT
18637	3252	8	personal	personal	JJ
18637	3252	9	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	3252	10	of	of	IN
18637	3252	11	the	the	DT
18637	3252	12	owner	owner	NN
18637	3252	13	,	,	,
18637	3252	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3252	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	3252	16	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
18637	3252	17	whether	whether	IN
18637	3252	18	the	the	DT
18637	3252	19	property	property	NN
18637	3252	20	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	3252	21	to	to	IN
18637	3252	22	an	an	DT
18637	3252	23	alien	alien	NN
18637	3252	24	,	,	,
18637	3252	25	a	a	DT
18637	3252	26	neutral	neutral	JJ
18637	3252	27	,	,	,
18637	3252	28	or	or	CC
18637	3252	29	even	even	RB
18637	3252	30	to	to	IN
18637	3252	31	a	a	DT
18637	3252	32	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	3252	33	of	of	IN
18637	3252	34	the	the	DT
18637	3252	35	United	United	NNP
18637	3252	36	States	States	NNP
18637	3252	37	.	.	.
18637	3253	1	The	the	DT
18637	3253	2	whole	whole	JJ
18637	3253	3	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3253	4	of	of	IN
18637	3253	5	confiscation	confiscation	NN
18637	3253	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	3253	7	built	build	VBN
18637	3253	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	3253	9	the	the	DT
18637	3253	10	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	3253	11	that	that	IN
18637	3253	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3253	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	3253	14	an	an	DT
18637	3253	15	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	3253	16	of	of	IN
18637	3253	17	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	3253	18	,	,	,
18637	3253	19	which	which	WDT
18637	3253	20	,	,	,
18637	3253	21	by	by	IN
18637	3253	22	depriving	deprive	VBG
18637	3253	23	an	an	DT
18637	3253	24	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	3253	25	of	of	IN
18637	3253	26	property	property	NN
18637	3253	27	within	within	IN
18637	3253	28	the	the	DT
18637	3253	29	reach	reach	NN
18637	3253	30	of	of	IN
18637	3253	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3253	32	power	power	NN
18637	3253	33	,	,	,
18637	3253	34	whether	whether	IN
18637	3253	35	within	within	IN
18637	3253	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3253	37	territory	territory	NN
18637	3253	38	or	or	CC
18637	3253	39	without	without	IN
18637	3253	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3253	41	,	,	,
18637	3253	42	impairs	impairs	VB
18637	3253	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3253	44	ability	ability	NN
18637	3253	45	to	to	TO
18637	3253	46	resist	resist	VB
18637	3253	47	the	the	DT
18637	3253	48	confiscating	confiscate	VBG
18637	3253	49	government	government	NN
18637	3253	50	,	,	,
18637	3253	51	while	while	IN
18637	3253	52	at	at	IN
18637	3253	53	the	the	DT
18637	3253	54	same	same	JJ
18637	3253	55	time	time	NN
18637	3253	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3253	57	furnishes	furnish	VBZ
18637	3253	58	to	to	IN
18637	3253	59	that	that	DT
18637	3253	60	government	government	NN
18637	3253	61	means	mean	VBZ
18637	3253	62	for	for	IN
18637	3253	63	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	3253	64	on	on	IN
18637	3253	65	the	the	DT
18637	3253	66	war	war	NN
18637	3253	67	.	.	.
18637	3254	1	Any	any	DT
18637	3254	2	property	property	NN
18637	3254	3	which	which	WDT
18637	3254	4	the	the	DT
18637	3254	5	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	3254	6	can	can	MD
18637	3254	7	use	use	VB
18637	3254	8	,	,	,
18637	3254	9	either	either	CC
18637	3254	10	by	by	IN
18637	3254	11	actual	actual	JJ
18637	3254	12	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	3254	13	,	,	,
18637	3254	14	or	or	CC
18637	3254	15	by	by	IN
18637	3254	16	the	the	DT
18637	3254	17	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3254	18	of	of	IN
18637	3254	19	control	control	NN
18637	3254	20	over	over	IN
18637	3254	21	the	the	DT
18637	3254	22	owner	owner	NN
18637	3254	23	,	,	,
18637	3254	24	no	no	RB
18637	3254	25	matter	matter	RB
18637	3254	26	what	what	WP
18637	3254	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3254	28	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	3254	29	,	,	,
18637	3254	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	3254	31	a	a	DT
18637	3254	32	proper	proper	JJ
18637	3254	33	subject	subject	NN
18637	3254	34	of	of	IN
18637	3254	35	confiscation	confiscation	NN
18637	3254	36	.	.	.
18637	3255	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3255	2	may	may	MD
18637	3255	3	provide	provide	VB
18637	3255	4	for	for	IN
18637	3255	5	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	3255	6	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	3255	7	of	of	IN
18637	3255	8	property	property	NN
18637	3255	9	which	which	WDT
18637	3255	10	the	the	DT
18637	3255	11	President	President	NNP
18637	3255	12	or	or	CC
18637	3255	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3255	14	agent	agent	NN
18637	3255	15	determines	determine	VBZ
18637	3255	16	to	to	TO
18637	3255	17	be	be	VB
18637	3255	18	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	3255	19	property	property	NN
18637	3255	20	,	,	,
18637	3255	21	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	3255	22	the	the	DT
18637	3255	23	question	question	NN
18637	3255	24	of	of	IN
18637	3255	25	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	3255	26	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	3255	27	to	to	TO
18637	3255	28	be	be	VB
18637	3255	29	settled	settle	VBN
18637	3255	30	later	later	RBR
18637	3255	31	at	at	IN
18637	3255	32	the	the	DT
18637	3255	33	suit	suit	NN
18637	3255	34	of	of	IN
18637	3255	35	a	a	DT
18637	3255	36	claimant	claimant	NN
18637	3255	37	.	.	.
18637	3256	1	For	for	IN
18637	3256	2	these	these	DT
18637	3256	3	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	3256	4	the	the	DT
18637	3256	5	Confiscation	Confiscation	NNP
18637	3256	6	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3256	7	of	of	IN
18637	3256	8	1862,[1299	1862,[1299	CD
18637	3256	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3256	10	and	and	CC
18637	3256	11	the	the	DT
18637	3256	12	Trading	trading	NN
18637	3256	13	with	with	IN
18637	3256	14	the	the	DT
18637	3256	15	Enemy	Enemy	NNP
18637	3256	16	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3256	17	of	of	IN
18637	3256	18	1917	1917	CD
18637	3256	19	and	and	CC
18637	3256	20	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	3256	21	thereto	thereto	NNP
18637	3256	22	,	,	,
18637	3256	23	were	be	VBD
18637	3256	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	3256	25	to	to	TO
18637	3256	26	be	be	VB
18637	3256	27	within	within	IN
18637	3256	28	the	the	DT
18637	3256	29	power	power	NN
18637	3256	30	of	of	IN
18637	3256	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3256	32	to	to	TO
18637	3256	33	"	"	``
18637	3256	34	make	make	VB
18637	3256	35	rules	rule	NNS
18637	3256	36	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	3256	37	captures	capture	NNS
18637	3256	38	on	on	IN
18637	3256	39	land	land	NN
18637	3256	40	and	and	CC
18637	3256	41	water	water	NN
18637	3256	42	.	.	.
18637	3257	1	"	"	``
18637	3257	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3257	3	1300	1300	CD
18637	3257	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3257	5	PRIZES	PRIZES	NNP
18637	3257	6	OF	of	IN
18637	3257	7	WAR	WAR	NNP
18637	3257	8	The	the	DT
18637	3257	9	power	power	NN
18637	3257	10	of	of	IN
18637	3257	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3257	12	with	with	IN
18637	3257	13	respect	respect	NN
18637	3257	14	to	to	IN
18637	3257	15	prizes	prize	NNS
18637	3257	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	3257	17	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	3257	18	;	;	:
18637	3257	19	no	no	DT
18637	3257	20	one	one	NN
18637	3257	21	can	can	MD
18637	3257	22	have	have	VB
18637	3257	23	any	any	DT
18637	3257	24	interest	interest	NN
18637	3257	25	in	in	IN
18637	3257	26	prizes	prize	NNS
18637	3257	27	captured	capture	VBN
18637	3257	28	except	except	IN
18637	3257	29	by	by	IN
18637	3257	30	permission	permission	NN
18637	3257	31	of	of	IN
18637	3257	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3257	33	.	.	.
18637	3258	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3258	2	1301	1301	CD
18637	3258	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3258	4	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	3258	5	,	,	,
18637	3258	6	since	since	IN
18637	3258	7	International	International	NNP
18637	3258	8	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3258	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	3258	10	a	a	DT
18637	3258	11	part	part	NN
18637	3258	12	of	of	IN
18637	3258	13	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3258	14	law	law	NN
18637	3258	15	,	,	,
18637	3258	16	the	the	DT
18637	3258	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3258	18	will	will	MD
18637	3258	19	administer	administer	VB
18637	3258	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3258	21	so	so	RB
18637	3258	22	long	long	RB
18637	3258	23	as	as	IN
18637	3258	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3258	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	3258	26	not	not	RB
18637	3258	27	been	be	VBN
18637	3258	28	modified	modify	VBN
18637	3258	29	by	by	IN
18637	3258	30	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	3258	31	or	or	CC
18637	3258	32	by	by	IN
18637	3258	33	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3258	34	or	or	CC
18637	3258	35	executive	executive	JJ
18637	3258	36	action	action	NN
18637	3258	37	.	.	.
18637	3259	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	3259	2	,	,	,
18637	3259	3	during	during	IN
18637	3259	4	the	the	DT
18637	3259	5	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3259	6	War	War	NNP
18637	3259	7	,	,	,
18637	3259	8	the	the	DT
18637	3259	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3259	10	found	find	VBD
18637	3259	11	that	that	IN
18637	3259	12	the	the	DT
18637	3259	13	Confiscation	Confiscation	NNP
18637	3259	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3259	15	of	of	IN
18637	3259	16	1861	1861	CD
18637	3259	17	,	,	,
18637	3259	18	and	and	CC
18637	3259	19	the	the	DT
18637	3259	20	Supplementary	Supplementary	NNP
18637	3259	21	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3259	22	of	of	IN
18637	3259	23	1863	1863	CD
18637	3259	24	,	,	,
18637	3259	25	which	which	WDT
18637	3259	26	,	,	,
18637	3259	27	in	in	IN
18637	3259	28	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	3259	29	the	the	DT
18637	3259	30	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	3259	31	of	of	IN
18637	3259	32	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	3259	33	,	,	,
18637	3259	34	made	make	VBD
18637	3259	35	provision	provision	NN
18637	3259	36	for	for	IN
18637	3259	37	the	the	DT
18637	3259	38	protection	protection	NN
18637	3259	39	of	of	IN
18637	3259	40	interests	interest	NNS
18637	3259	41	of	of	IN
18637	3259	42	loyal	loyal	JJ
18637	3259	43	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	3259	44	,	,	,
18637	3259	45	merely	merely	RB
18637	3259	46	created	create	VBD
18637	3259	47	a	a	DT
18637	3259	48	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	3259	49	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	3259	50	and	and	CC
18637	3259	51	did	do	VBD
18637	3259	52	not	not	RB
18637	3259	53	override	override	VB
18637	3259	54	or	or	CC
18637	3259	55	displace	displace	VB
18637	3259	56	the	the	DT
18637	3259	57	law	law	NN
18637	3259	58	of	of	IN
18637	3259	59	prize	prize	NN
18637	3259	60	.	.	.
18637	3260	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3260	2	decided	decide	VBD
18637	3260	3	,	,	,
18637	3260	4	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	3260	5	,	,	,
18637	3260	6	that	that	IN
18637	3260	7	when	when	WRB
18637	3260	8	a	a	DT
18637	3260	9	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	3260	10	was	be	VBD
18637	3260	11	liable	liable	JJ
18637	3260	12	to	to	IN
18637	3260	13	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	3260	14	under	under	IN
18637	3260	15	either	either	DT
18637	3260	16	law	law	NN
18637	3260	17	,	,	,
18637	3260	18	the	the	DT
18637	3260	19	government	government	NN
18637	3260	20	was	be	VBD
18637	3260	21	at	at	IN
18637	3260	22	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	3260	23	to	to	TO
18637	3260	24	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	3260	25	under	under	IN
18637	3260	26	the	the	DT
18637	3260	27	more	more	RBR
18637	3260	28	stringent	stringent	JJ
18637	3260	29	rules	rule	NNS
18637	3260	30	of	of	IN
18637	3260	31	International	International	NNP
18637	3260	32	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3260	33	,	,	,
18637	3260	34	with	with	IN
18637	3260	35	the	the	DT
18637	3260	36	result	result	NN
18637	3260	37	that	that	IN
18637	3260	38	the	the	DT
18637	3260	39	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	3260	40	would	would	MD
18637	3260	41	be	be	VB
18637	3260	42	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	3260	43	of	of	IN
18637	3260	44	the	the	DT
18637	3260	45	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	3260	46	of	of	IN
18637	3260	47	the	the	DT
18637	3260	48	protective	protective	JJ
18637	3260	49	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	3260	50	of	of	IN
18637	3260	51	the	the	DT
18637	3260	52	statute	statute	NN
18637	3260	53	.	.	.
18637	3261	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3261	2	1302	1302	CD
18637	3261	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3261	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	3261	5	,	,	,
18637	3261	6	when	when	WRB
18637	3261	7	Cuban	cuban	JJ
18637	3261	8	ports	port	NNS
18637	3261	9	were	be	VBD
18637	3261	10	blockaded	blockade	VBN
18637	3261	11	during	during	IN
18637	3261	12	the	the	DT
18637	3261	13	Spanish	spanish	JJ
18637	3261	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	3261	15	American	American	NNP
18637	3261	16	War	War	NNP
18637	3261	17	,	,	,
18637	3261	18	the	the	DT
18637	3261	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3261	20	held	hold	VBD
18637	3261	21	,	,	,
18637	3261	22	over	over	IN
18637	3261	23	the	the	DT
18637	3261	24	vigorous	vigorous	JJ
18637	3261	25	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	3261	26	of	of	IN
18637	3261	27	three	three	CD
18637	3261	28	of	of	IN
18637	3261	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3261	30	members	member	NNS
18637	3261	31	,	,	,
18637	3261	32	that	that	IN
18637	3261	33	the	the	DT
18637	3261	34	rule	rule	NN
18637	3261	35	of	of	IN
18637	3261	36	International	International	NNP
18637	3261	37	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3261	38	exempting	exempt	VBG
18637	3261	39	unarmed	unarmed	JJ
18637	3261	40	fishing	fishing	NN
18637	3261	41	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	3261	42	from	from	IN
18637	3261	43	capture	capture	NN
18637	3261	44	was	be	VBD
18637	3261	45	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	3261	46	in	in	IN
18637	3261	47	the	the	DT
18637	3261	48	absence	absence	NN
18637	3261	49	of	of	IN
18637	3261	50	any	any	DT
18637	3261	51	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	3261	52	provision	provision	NN
18637	3261	53	,	,	,
18637	3261	54	or	or	CC
18637	3261	55	other	other	JJ
18637	3261	56	public	public	JJ
18637	3261	57	act	act	NN
18637	3261	58	of	of	IN
18637	3261	59	the	the	DT
18637	3261	60	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3261	61	in	in	IN
18637	3261	62	relation	relation	NN
18637	3261	63	to	to	IN
18637	3261	64	the	the	DT
18637	3261	65	subject	subject	NN
18637	3261	66	.	.	.
18637	3262	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3262	2	1303	1303	CD
18637	3262	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3262	4	POLICE	police	NN
18637	3262	5	REGULATIONS	regulation	NNS
18637	3262	6	;	;	:
18637	3262	7	RENT	rent	NN
18637	3262	8	CONTROL	control	NN
18637	3262	9	In	in	IN
18637	3262	10	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	3262	11	the	the	DT
18637	3262	12	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	3262	13	of	of	IN
18637	3262	14	due	due	JJ
18637	3262	15	process	process	NN
18637	3262	16	of	of	IN
18637	3262	17	law	law	NN
18637	3262	18	in	in	IN
18637	3262	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3262	20	modern	modern	JJ
18637	3262	21	expanded	expand	VBN
18637	3262	22	sense	sense	NN
18637	3262	23	of	of	IN
18637	3262	24	"	"	``
18637	3262	25	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	3262	26	law	law	NN
18637	3262	27	"	"	''
18637	3262	28	the	the	DT
18637	3262	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3262	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	3262	31	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	3262	32	that	that	IN
18637	3262	33	a	a	DT
18637	3262	34	war	war	NN
18637	3262	35	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	3262	36	may	may	MD
18637	3262	37	justify	justify	VB
18637	3262	38	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3262	39	which	which	WDT
18637	3262	40	would	would	MD
18637	3262	41	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	3262	42	be	be	VB
18637	3262	43	an	an	DT
18637	3262	44	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	3262	45	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	3262	46	of	of	IN
18637	3262	47	private	private	JJ
18637	3262	48	rights	right	NNS
18637	3262	49	.	.	.
18637	3263	1	Shortly	shortly	RB
18637	3263	2	after	after	IN
18637	3263	3	the	the	DT
18637	3263	4	first	first	JJ
18637	3263	5	world	world	NN
18637	3263	6	war	war	NN
18637	3263	7	,	,	,
18637	3263	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3263	9	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	3263	10	,	,	,
18637	3263	11	by	by	IN
18637	3263	12	a	a	DT
18637	3263	13	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	3263	14	margin	margin	NN
18637	3263	15	,	,	,
18637	3263	16	a	a	DT
18637	3263	17	rent	rent	NN
18637	3263	18	control	control	NN
18637	3263	19	law	law	NN
18637	3263	20	for	for	IN
18637	3263	21	the	the	DT
18637	3263	22	District	District	NNP
18637	3263	23	of	of	IN
18637	3263	24	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3263	25	,	,	,
18637	3263	26	which	which	WDT
18637	3263	27	not	not	RB
18637	3263	28	merely	merely	RB
18637	3263	29	limited	limit	VBD
18637	3263	30	the	the	DT
18637	3263	31	rents	rent	NNS
18637	3263	32	which	which	WDT
18637	3263	33	might	may	MD
18637	3263	34	be	be	VB
18637	3263	35	charged	charge	VBN
18637	3263	36	but	but	CC
18637	3263	37	which	which	WDT
18637	3263	38	also	also	RB
18637	3263	39	gave	give	VBD
18637	3263	40	the	the	DT
18637	3263	41	existing	exist	VBG
18637	3263	42	tenants	tenant	NNS
18637	3263	43	the	the	DT
18637	3263	44	right	right	NN
18637	3263	45	to	to	TO
18637	3263	46	continue	continue	VB
18637	3263	47	in	in	IN
18637	3263	48	occupancy	occupancy	NN
18637	3263	49	of	of	IN
18637	3263	50	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3263	51	dwellings	dwelling	NNS
18637	3263	52	at	at	IN
18637	3263	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3263	54	own	own	JJ
18637	3263	55	option	option	NN
18637	3263	56	,	,	,
18637	3263	57	provided	provide	VBN
18637	3263	58	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3263	59	paid	pay	VBD
18637	3263	60	rent	rent	NN
18637	3263	61	and	and	CC
18637	3263	62	performed	perform	VBD
18637	3263	63	other	other	JJ
18637	3263	64	stipulated	stipulate	VBN
18637	3263	65	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	3263	66	.	.	.
18637	3264	1	The	the	DT
18637	3264	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3264	3	,	,	,
18637	3264	4	while	while	IN
18637	3264	5	conceding	concede	VBG
18637	3264	6	that	that	IN
18637	3264	7	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	3264	8	such	such	JJ
18637	3264	9	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3264	10	would	would	MD
18637	3264	11	transcend	transcend	VB
18637	3264	12	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3264	13	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	3264	14	,	,	,
18637	3264	15	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3264	16	that	that	IN
18637	3264	17	"	"	``
18637	3264	18	a	a	DT
18637	3264	19	public	public	JJ
18637	3264	20	exigency	exigency	NN
18637	3264	21	will	will	MD
18637	3264	22	justify	justify	VB
18637	3264	23	the	the	DT
18637	3264	24	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3264	25	in	in	IN
18637	3264	26	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	3264	27	property	property	NN
18637	3264	28	rights	right	NNS
18637	3264	29	in	in	IN
18637	3264	30	land	land	NN
18637	3264	31	to	to	IN
18637	3264	32	a	a	DT
18637	3264	33	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3264	34	extent	extent	NN
18637	3264	35	without	without	IN
18637	3264	36	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	3264	37	.	.	.
18637	3265	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3265	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3265	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3265	4	A	a	DT
18637	3265	5	limit	limit	NN
18637	3265	6	in	in	IN
18637	3265	7	time	time	NN
18637	3265	8	,	,	,
18637	3265	9	to	to	TO
18637	3265	10	tide	tide	VB
18637	3265	11	over	over	RP
18637	3265	12	a	a	DT
18637	3265	13	passing	pass	VBG
18637	3265	14	trouble	trouble	NN
18637	3265	15	,	,	,
18637	3265	16	well	well	RB
18637	3265	17	may	may	MD
18637	3265	18	justify	justify	VB
18637	3265	19	a	a	DT
18637	3265	20	law	law	NN
18637	3265	21	that	that	WDT
18637	3265	22	could	could	MD
18637	3265	23	not	not	RB
18637	3265	24	be	be	VB
18637	3265	25	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	3265	26	as	as	IN
18637	3265	27	a	a	DT
18637	3265	28	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	3265	29	change	change	NN
18637	3265	30	.	.	.
18637	3266	1	"	"	``
18637	3266	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3266	3	1304	1304	CD
18637	3266	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3266	5	During	during	IN
18637	3266	6	World	World	NNP
18637	3266	7	War	War	NNP
18637	3266	8	II	II	NNP
18637	3266	9	an	an	DT
18637	3266	10	apartment	apartment	NN
18637	3266	11	house	house	NN
18637	3266	12	owner	owner	NN
18637	3266	13	who	who	WP
18637	3266	14	complained	complain	VBD
18637	3266	15	that	that	IN
18637	3266	16	the	the	DT
18637	3266	17	rentals	rental	NNS
18637	3266	18	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	3266	19	by	by	IN
18637	3266	20	the	the	DT
18637	3266	21	Office	Office	NNP
18637	3266	22	of	of	IN
18637	3266	23	Price	Price	NNP
18637	3266	24	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	3266	25	did	do	VBD
18637	3266	26	not	not	RB
18637	3266	27	afford	afford	VB
18637	3266	28	a	a	DT
18637	3266	29	"	"	``
18637	3266	30	fair	fair	JJ
18637	3266	31	return	return	NN
18637	3266	32	"	"	''
18637	3266	33	on	on	IN
18637	3266	34	the	the	DT
18637	3266	35	property	property	NN
18637	3266	36	was	be	VBD
18637	3266	37	told	tell	VBN
18637	3266	38	by	by	IN
18637	3266	39	the	the	DT
18637	3266	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3266	41	that	that	IN
18637	3266	42	,	,	,
18637	3266	43	"	"	``
18637	3266	44	a	a	DT
18637	3266	45	nation	nation	NN
18637	3266	46	which	which	WDT
18637	3266	47	can	can	MD
18637	3266	48	demand	demand	VB
18637	3266	49	the	the	DT
18637	3266	50	lives	life	NNS
18637	3266	51	of	of	IN
18637	3266	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3266	53	men	man	NNS
18637	3266	54	and	and	CC
18637	3266	55	women	woman	NNS
18637	3266	56	in	in	IN
18637	3266	57	the	the	DT
18637	3266	58	waging	waging	NN
18637	3266	59	of	of	IN
18637	3266	60	*	*	NFP
18637	3266	61	*	*	NFP
18637	3266	62	*	*	NFP
18637	3266	63	war	war	NN
18637	3266	64	is	be	VBZ
18637	3266	65	under	under	IN
18637	3266	66	no	no	DT
18637	3266	67	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3266	68	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	3266	69	of	of	IN
18637	3266	70	providing	provide	VBG
18637	3266	71	a	a	DT
18637	3266	72	system	system	NN
18637	3266	73	of	of	IN
18637	3266	74	price	price	NN
18637	3266	75	control	control	NN
18637	3266	76	*	*	NFP
18637	3266	77	*	*	NFP
18637	3266	78	*	*	NFP
18637	3266	79	which	which	WDT
18637	3266	80	will	will	MD
18637	3266	81	assure	assure	VB
18637	3266	82	each	each	DT
18637	3266	83	landlord	landlord	NN
18637	3266	84	a	a	DT
18637	3266	85	'	'	``
18637	3266	86	fair	fair	JJ
18637	3266	87	return	return	NN
18637	3266	88	'	'	''
18637	3266	89	on	on	IN
18637	3266	90	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3266	91	property	property	NN
18637	3266	92	.	.	.
18637	3267	1	"	"	``
18637	3267	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3267	3	1305	1305	CD
18637	3267	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3267	5	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	3267	6	,	,	,
18637	3267	7	such	such	JJ
18637	3267	8	rentals	rental	NNS
18637	3267	9	may	may	MD
18637	3267	10	be	be	VB
18637	3267	11	established	establish	VBN
18637	3267	12	without	without	IN
18637	3267	13	a	a	DT
18637	3267	14	prior	prior	JJ
18637	3267	15	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	3267	16	because	because	IN
18637	3267	17	"	"	``
18637	3267	18	national	national	JJ
18637	3267	19	security	security	NN
18637	3267	20	might	may	MD
18637	3267	21	not	not	RB
18637	3267	22	be	be	VB
18637	3267	23	able	able	JJ
18637	3267	24	to	to	TO
18637	3267	25	afford	afford	VB
18637	3267	26	the	the	DT
18637	3267	27	luxuries	luxury	NNS
18637	3267	28	of	of	IN
18637	3267	29	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	3267	30	and	and	CC
18637	3267	31	the	the	DT
18637	3267	32	long	long	JJ
18637	3267	33	delays	delay	NNS
18637	3267	34	which	which	WDT
18637	3267	35	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	3267	36	hearings	hearing	NNS
18637	3267	37	traditionally	traditionally	RB
18637	3267	38	have	have	VBP
18637	3267	39	entailed	entail	VBN
18637	3267	40	.	.	.
18637	3268	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3268	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3268	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3268	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	3268	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3268	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	3268	7	provided	provide	VBN
18637	3268	8	for	for	IN
18637	3268	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3268	10	review	review	NN
18637	3268	11	after	after	IN
18637	3268	12	the	the	DT
18637	3268	13	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	3268	14	or	or	CC
18637	3268	15	orders	order	NNS
18637	3268	16	have	have	VBP
18637	3268	17	been	be	VBN
18637	3268	18	made	make	VBN
18637	3268	19	effective	effective	JJ
18637	3268	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3268	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	3268	22	done	do	VBN
18637	3268	23	all	all	PDT
18637	3268	24	that	that	DT
18637	3268	25	due	due	JJ
18637	3268	26	process	process	NN
18637	3268	27	under	under	IN
18637	3268	28	the	the	DT
18637	3268	29	war	war	NN
18637	3268	30	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	3268	31	requires	require	VBZ
18637	3268	32	.	.	.
18637	3269	1	"	"	``
18637	3269	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3269	3	1306	1306	CD
18637	3269	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3269	5	The	the	DT
18637	3269	6	more	more	RBR
18637	3269	7	specific	specific	JJ
18637	3269	8	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	3269	9	of	of	IN
18637	3269	10	the	the	DT
18637	3269	11	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	3269	12	of	of	IN
18637	3269	13	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	3269	14	yield	yield	VBP
18637	3269	15	less	less	RBR
18637	3269	16	readily	readily	RB
18637	3269	17	,	,	,
18637	3269	18	however	however	RB
18637	3269	19	,	,	,
18637	3269	20	to	to	IN
18637	3269	21	the	the	DT
18637	3269	22	impact	impact	NN
18637	3269	23	of	of	IN
18637	3269	24	a	a	DT
18637	3269	25	war	war	NN
18637	3269	26	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	3269	27	.	.	.
18637	3270	1	In	in	IN
18637	3270	2	United	United	NNP
18637	3270	3	States	States	NNP
18637	3270	4	_	_	NNP
18637	3270	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	3270	6	_	_	NNP
18637	3270	7	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
18637	3270	8	Grocery	Grocery	NNP
18637	3270	9	Company,[1307	Company,[1307	NNP
18637	3270	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3270	11	the	the	DT
18637	3270	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3270	13	held	hold	VBD
18637	3270	14	that	that	IN
18637	3270	15	a	a	DT
18637	3270	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	3270	17	which	which	WDT
18637	3270	18	penalized	penalize	VBD
18637	3270	19	the	the	DT
18637	3270	20	making	making	NN
18637	3270	21	of	of	IN
18637	3270	22	"	"	``
18637	3270	23	'	'	''
18637	3270	24	any	any	DT
18637	3270	25	unjust	unjust	JJ
18637	3270	26	or	or	CC
18637	3270	27	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	3270	28	rate	rate	NN
18637	3270	29	or	or	CC
18637	3270	30	charge	charge	NN
18637	3270	31	in	in	IN
18637	3270	32	handling	handling	NN
18637	3270	33	*	*	NFP
18637	3270	34	*	*	NFP
18637	3270	35	*	*	NFP
18637	3270	36	any	any	DT
18637	3270	37	necessaries	necessary	NNS
18637	3270	38	,	,	,
18637	3270	39	'	'	''
18637	3270	40	"	"	''
18637	3270	41	was	be	VBD
18637	3270	42	void	void	JJ
18637	3270	43	on	on	IN
18637	3270	44	the	the	DT
18637	3270	45	ground	ground	NN
18637	3270	46	that	that	IN
18637	3270	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3270	48	set	set	VBD
18637	3270	49	up	up	RP
18637	3270	50	no	no	DT
18637	3270	51	"	"	``
18637	3270	52	ascertainable	ascertainable	JJ
18637	3270	53	standard	standard	NN
18637	3270	54	of	of	IN
18637	3270	55	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	3270	56	"	"	''
18637	3270	57	and	and	CC
18637	3270	58	so	so	RB
18637	3270	59	was	be	VBD
18637	3270	60	"	"	``
18637	3270	61	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	3270	62	to	to	IN
18637	3270	63	the	the	DT
18637	3270	64	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	3270	65	and	and	CC
18637	3270	66	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	3270	67	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	3270	68	*	*	NFP
18637	3270	69	*	*	NFP
18637	3270	70	*	*	NFP
18637	3270	71	which	which	WDT
18637	3270	72	require	require	VBP
18637	3270	73	due	due	JJ
18637	3270	74	process	process	NN
18637	3270	75	of	of	IN
18637	3270	76	law	law	NN
18637	3270	77	and	and	CC
18637	3270	78	that	that	IN
18637	3270	79	persons	person	NNS
18637	3270	80	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	3270	81	of	of	IN
18637	3270	82	crime	crime	NN
18637	3270	83	shall	shall	MD
18637	3270	84	be	be	VB
18637	3270	85	adequately	adequately	RB
18637	3270	86	informed	inform	VBN
18637	3270	87	of	of	IN
18637	3270	88	the	the	DT
18637	3270	89	nature	nature	NN
18637	3270	90	and	and	CC
18637	3270	91	cause	cause	NN
18637	3270	92	of	of	IN
18637	3270	93	the	the	DT
18637	3270	94	accusation	accusation	NN
18637	3270	95	.	.	.
18637	3271	1	"	"	``
18637	3271	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3271	3	1308	1308	CD
18637	3271	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3271	5	PERSONAL	personal	JJ
18637	3271	6	LIBERTY	LIBERTY	NNP
18637	3271	7	IN	in	IN
18637	3271	8	WARTIME	WARTIME	NNP
18637	3271	9	That	that	IN
18637	3271	10	the	the	DT
18637	3271	11	power	power	NN
18637	3271	12	of	of	IN
18637	3271	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3271	14	to	to	TO
18637	3271	15	punish	punish	VB
18637	3271	16	seditious	seditious	JJ
18637	3271	17	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	3271	18	in	in	IN
18637	3271	19	time	time	NN
18637	3271	20	of	of	IN
18637	3271	21	war	war	NN
18637	3271	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	3271	23	limited	limit	VBN
18637	3271	24	by	by	IN
18637	3271	25	the	the	DT
18637	3271	26	First	First	NNP
18637	3271	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3271	28	was	be	VBD
18637	3271	29	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	3271	30	by	by	IN
18637	3271	31	the	the	DT
18637	3271	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3271	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3271	34	in	in	IN
18637	3271	35	the	the	DT
18637	3271	36	series	series	NN
18637	3271	37	of	of	IN
18637	3271	38	cases[1309	cases[1309	NNP
18637	3271	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3271	40	in	in	IN
18637	3271	41	which	which	WDT
18637	3271	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3271	43	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	3271	44	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	3271	45	for	for	IN
18637	3271	46	violation	violation	NN
18637	3271	47	of	of	IN
18637	3271	48	the	the	DT
18637	3271	49	Espionage	Espionage	NNP
18637	3271	50	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3271	51	of	of	IN
18637	3271	52	1917	1917	CD
18637	3271	53	.	.	.
18637	3272	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3272	2	1310	1310	CD
18637	3272	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3272	4	But	but	CC
18637	3272	5	in	in	IN
18637	3272	6	the	the	DT
18637	3272	7	famous	famous	JJ
18637	3272	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3272	9	of	of	IN
18637	3272	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3272	11	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	3272	12	in	in	IN
18637	3272	13	Schenck	Schenck	NNP
18637	3272	14	_	_	NNP
18637	3272	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	3272	16	_	_	NNP
18637	3272	17	United	United	NNP
18637	3272	18	States,[1311	States,[1311	NNP
18637	3272	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3272	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3272	21	held	hold	VBD
18637	3272	22	that	that	DT
18637	3272	23	:	:	:
18637	3272	24	"	"	``
18637	3272	25	When	when	WRB
18637	3272	26	a	a	DT
18637	3272	27	nation	nation	NN
18637	3272	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	3272	29	at	at	IN
18637	3272	30	war	war	NN
18637	3272	31	many	many	JJ
18637	3272	32	things	thing	NNS
18637	3272	33	that	that	WDT
18637	3272	34	might	may	MD
18637	3272	35	be	be	VB
18637	3272	36	said	say	VBN
18637	3272	37	in	in	IN
18637	3272	38	time	time	NN
18637	3272	39	of	of	IN
18637	3272	40	peace	peace	NN
18637	3272	41	are	be	VBP
18637	3272	42	such	such	PDT
18637	3272	43	a	a	DT
18637	3272	44	hindrance	hindrance	NN
18637	3272	45	to	to	IN
18637	3272	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3272	47	effort	effort	NN
18637	3272	48	that	that	IN
18637	3272	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3272	50	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	3272	51	will	will	MD
18637	3272	52	not	not	RB
18637	3272	53	be	be	VB
18637	3272	54	endured	endure	VBN
18637	3272	55	so	so	RB
18637	3272	56	long	long	RB
18637	3272	57	as	as	IN
18637	3272	58	men	man	NNS
18637	3272	59	fight	fight	VBP
18637	3272	60	and	and	CC
18637	3272	61	that	that	IN
18637	3272	62	no	no	DT
18637	3272	63	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3272	64	could	could	MD
18637	3272	65	regard	regard	VB
18637	3272	66	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3272	67	as	as	IN
18637	3272	68	protected	protect	VBN
18637	3272	69	by	by	IN
18637	3272	70	any	any	DT
18637	3272	71	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3272	72	right	right	NN
18637	3272	73	.	.	.
18637	3273	1	"	"	``
18637	3273	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3273	3	1312	1312	CD
18637	3273	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3273	5	A	a	DT
18637	3273	6	State	State	NNP
18637	3273	7	also	also	RB
18637	3273	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	3273	9	power	power	NN
18637	3273	10	to	to	TO
18637	3273	11	make	make	VB
18637	3273	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3273	13	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	3273	14	to	to	TO
18637	3273	15	advocate	advocate	VB
18637	3273	16	that	that	IN
18637	3273	17	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	3273	18	of	of	IN
18637	3273	19	the	the	DT
18637	3273	20	State	State	NNP
18637	3273	21	should	should	MD
18637	3273	22	not	not	RB
18637	3273	23	assist	assist	VB
18637	3273	24	in	in	IN
18637	3273	25	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
18637	3273	26	a	a	DT
18637	3273	27	war	war	NN
18637	3273	28	against	against	IN
18637	3273	29	public	public	JJ
18637	3273	30	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	3273	31	of	of	IN
18637	3273	32	the	the	DT
18637	3273	33	United	United	NNP
18637	3273	34	States	States	NNP
18637	3273	35	.	.	.
18637	3274	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3274	2	1313	1313	CD
18637	3274	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3274	4	The	the	DT
18637	3274	5	most	most	RBS
18637	3274	6	drastic	drastic	JJ
18637	3274	7	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	3274	8	of	of	IN
18637	3274	9	personal	personal	JJ
18637	3274	10	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	3274	11	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	3274	12	during	during	IN
18637	3274	13	World	World	NNP
18637	3274	14	War	War	NNP
18637	3274	15	II	II	NNP
18637	3274	16	was	be	VBD
18637	3274	17	the	the	DT
18637	3274	18	detention	detention	NN
18637	3274	19	and	and	CC
18637	3274	20	relocation	relocation	NN
18637	3274	21	of	of	IN
18637	3274	22	the	the	DT
18637	3274	23	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	3274	24	residents	resident	NNS
18637	3274	25	of	of	IN
18637	3274	26	the	the	DT
18637	3274	27	Western	Western	NNP
18637	3274	28	States	States	NNP
18637	3274	29	,	,	,
18637	3274	30	including	include	VBG
18637	3274	31	those	those	DT
18637	3274	32	who	who	WP
18637	3274	33	were	be	VBD
18637	3274	34	native	native	JJ
18637	3274	35	-	-	HYPH
18637	3274	36	born	bear	VBN
18637	3274	37	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	3274	38	of	of	IN
18637	3274	39	the	the	DT
18637	3274	40	United	United	NNP
18637	3274	41	States	States	NNP
18637	3274	42	.	.	.
18637	3275	1	When	when	WRB
18637	3275	2	various	various	JJ
18637	3275	3	phases	phase	NNS
18637	3275	4	of	of	IN
18637	3275	5	this	this	DT
18637	3275	6	program	program	NN
18637	3275	7	were	be	VBD
18637	3275	8	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	3275	9	,	,	,
18637	3275	10	the	the	DT
18637	3275	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3275	12	held	hold	VBD
18637	3275	13	that	that	IN
18637	3275	14	in	in	IN
18637	3275	15	order	order	NN
18637	3275	16	to	to	TO
18637	3275	17	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	3275	18	espionage	espionage	NN
18637	3275	19	and	and	CC
18637	3275	20	sabotage	sabotage	NN
18637	3275	21	,	,	,
18637	3275	22	the	the	DT
18637	3275	23	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	3275	24	of	of	IN
18637	3275	25	movement	movement	NN
18637	3275	26	of	of	IN
18637	3275	27	such	such	JJ
18637	3275	28	persons	person	NNS
18637	3275	29	could	could	MD
18637	3275	30	be	be	VB
18637	3275	31	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	3275	32	by	by	IN
18637	3275	33	a	a	DT
18637	3275	34	curfew	curfew	NN
18637	3275	35	order,[1314	order,[1314	NNP
18637	3275	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3275	37	even	even	RB
18637	3275	38	by	by	IN
18637	3275	39	a	a	DT
18637	3275	40	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	3275	41	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	3275	42	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3275	43	from	from	IN
18637	3275	44	a	a	DT
18637	3275	45	defined	define	VBN
18637	3275	46	area,[1315	area,[1315	NNP
18637	3275	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3275	48	but	but	CC
18637	3275	49	that	that	IN
18637	3275	50	a	a	DT
18637	3275	51	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	3275	52	of	of	IN
18637	3275	53	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	3275	54	ancestry	ancestry	NN
18637	3275	55	whose	whose	WP$
18637	3275	56	loyalty	loyalty	NN
18637	3275	57	was	be	VBD
18637	3275	58	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	3275	59	could	could	MD
18637	3275	60	not	not	RB
18637	3275	61	be	be	VB
18637	3275	62	detained	detain	VBN
18637	3275	63	against	against	IN
18637	3275	64	her	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3275	65	will	will	NN
18637	3275	66	in	in	IN
18637	3275	67	a	a	DT
18637	3275	68	relocation	relocation	NN
18637	3275	69	camp	camp	NN
18637	3275	70	.	.	.
18637	3276	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3276	2	1316	1316	CD
18637	3276	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3276	4	ALIEN	ALIEN	NNP
18637	3276	5	ENEMIES	enemy	NNS
18637	3276	6	The	the	DT
18637	3276	7	status	status	NN
18637	3276	8	of	of	IN
18637	3276	9	alien	alien	JJ
18637	3276	10	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	3276	11	was	be	VBD
18637	3276	12	first	first	RB
18637	3276	13	considered	consider	VBN
18637	3276	14	in	in	IN
18637	3276	15	connection	connection	NN
18637	3276	16	with	with	IN
18637	3276	17	the	the	DT
18637	3276	18	passage	passage	NN
18637	3276	19	of	of	IN
18637	3276	20	the	the	DT
18637	3276	21	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	3276	22	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3276	23	of	of	IN
18637	3276	24	1798,[1317	1798,[1317	CD
18637	3276	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3276	26	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	3276	27	the	the	DT
18637	3276	28	President	President	NNP
18637	3276	29	was	be	VBD
18637	3276	30	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	3276	31	to	to	TO
18637	3276	32	deport	deport	VB
18637	3276	33	any	any	DT
18637	3276	34	alien	alien	NN
18637	3276	35	or	or	CC
18637	3276	36	to	to	TO
18637	3276	37	license	license	VB
18637	3276	38	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3276	39	to	to	TO
18637	3276	40	reside	reside	VB
18637	3276	41	within	within	IN
18637	3276	42	the	the	DT
18637	3276	43	United	United	NNP
18637	3276	44	States	States	NNP
18637	3276	45	at	at	IN
18637	3276	46	any	any	DT
18637	3276	47	place	place	NN
18637	3276	48	to	to	TO
18637	3276	49	be	be	VB
18637	3276	50	designated	designate	VBN
18637	3276	51	by	by	IN
18637	3276	52	the	the	DT
18637	3276	53	President	President	NNP
18637	3276	54	.	.	.
18637	3277	1	Critics	critic	NNS
18637	3277	2	of	of	IN
18637	3277	3	the	the	DT
18637	3277	4	measure	measure	NN
18637	3277	5	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	3277	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3277	7	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	3277	8	so	so	RB
18637	3277	9	far	far	RB
18637	3277	10	as	as	IN
18637	3277	11	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	3277	12	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	3277	13	were	be	VBD
18637	3277	14	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	3277	15	,	,	,
18637	3277	16	because	because	IN
18637	3277	17	,	,	,
18637	3277	18	as	as	IN
18637	3277	19	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	3277	20	wrote	write	VBD
18637	3277	21	,	,	,
18637	3277	22	"	"	``
18637	3277	23	The	the	DT
18637	3277	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3277	25	having	have	VBG
18637	3277	26	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	3277	27	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	3277	28	to	to	IN
18637	3277	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3277	30	the	the	DT
18637	3277	31	power	power	NN
18637	3277	32	to	to	TO
18637	3277	33	declare	declare	VB
18637	3277	34	war	war	NN
18637	3277	35	against	against	IN
18637	3277	36	any	any	DT
18637	3277	37	nation	nation	NN
18637	3277	38	,	,	,
18637	3277	39	and	and	CC
18637	3277	40	,	,	,
18637	3277	41	of	of	IN
18637	3277	42	course	course	NN
18637	3277	43	,	,	,
18637	3277	44	to	to	TO
18637	3277	45	treat	treat	VB
18637	3277	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3277	47	and	and	CC
18637	3277	48	all	all	PDT
18637	3277	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3277	50	members	member	NNS
18637	3277	51	as	as	IN
18637	3277	52	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	3277	53	.	.	.
18637	3278	1	"	"	``
18637	3278	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3278	3	1318	1318	CD
18637	3278	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3278	5	The	the	DT
18637	3278	6	substance	substance	NN
18637	3278	7	of	of	IN
18637	3278	8	this	this	DT
18637	3278	9	early	early	JJ
18637	3278	10	law	law	NN
18637	3278	11	was	be	VBD
18637	3278	12	reenacted	reenact	VBN
18637	3278	13	during	during	IN
18637	3278	14	the	the	DT
18637	3278	15	first	first	JJ
18637	3278	16	world	world	NNP
18637	3278	17	war	war	NN
18637	3278	18	.	.	.
18637	3279	1	Under	under	IN
18637	3279	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3279	3	the	the	DT
18637	3279	4	President	President	NNP
18637	3279	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	3279	6	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	3279	7	,	,	,
18637	3279	8	in	in	IN
18637	3279	9	time	time	NN
18637	3279	10	of	of	IN
18637	3279	11	war	war	NN
18637	3279	12	,	,	,
18637	3279	13	to	to	TO
18637	3279	14	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	3279	15	"	"	``
18637	3279	16	the	the	DT
18637	3279	17	manner	manner	NN
18637	3279	18	and	and	CC
18637	3279	19	degree	degree	NN
18637	3279	20	of	of	IN
18637	3279	21	the	the	DT
18637	3279	22	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	3279	23	to	to	IN
18637	3279	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3279	25	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3279	26	alien	alien	JJ
18637	3279	27	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	3279	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3279	29	shall	shall	MD
18637	3279	30	be	be	VB
18637	3279	31	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3279	32	and	and	CC
18637	3279	33	in	in	IN
18637	3279	34	what	what	WDT
18637	3279	35	cases	case	NNS
18637	3279	36	,	,	,
18637	3279	37	and	and	CC
18637	3279	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	3279	39	what	what	WP
18637	3279	40	security	security	NN
18637	3279	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3279	42	residence	residence	NN
18637	3279	43	shall	shall	MD
18637	3279	44	be	be	VB
18637	3279	45	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	3279	46	,	,	,
18637	3279	47	"	"	''
18637	3279	48	or	or	CC
18637	3279	49	to	to	TO
18637	3279	50	provide	provide	VB
18637	3279	51	for	for	IN
18637	3279	52	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3279	53	removal	removal	NN
18637	3279	54	from	from	IN
18637	3279	55	the	the	DT
18637	3279	56	United	United	NNP
18637	3279	57	States	States	NNP
18637	3279	58	.	.	.
18637	3280	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3280	2	1319	1319	CD
18637	3280	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3280	4	This	this	DT
18637	3280	5	measure	measure	NN
18637	3280	6	was	be	VBD
18637	3280	7	held	hold	VBN
18637	3280	8	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3280	9	in	in	IN
18637	3280	10	Ludecke	Ludecke	NNP
18637	3280	11	_	_	NNP
18637	3280	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	3280	13	_	_	NNP
18637	3280	14	Watkins	Watkins	NNP
18637	3280	15	.	.	.
18637	3281	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3281	2	1320	1320	CD
18637	3281	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3281	4	EMINENT	EMINENT	NNP
18637	3281	5	DOMAIN	domain	NN
18637	3281	6	An	an	DT
18637	3281	7	often	often	RB
18637	3281	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	3281	9	cited	cite	VBN
18637	3281	10	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	3281	11	uttered	utter	VBN
18637	3281	12	shortly	shortly	RB
18637	3281	13	after	after	IN
18637	3281	14	the	the	DT
18637	3281	15	Mexican	Mexican	NNP
18637	3281	16	War	War	NNP
18637	3281	17	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	3281	18	the	the	DT
18637	3281	19	right	right	NN
18637	3281	20	of	of	IN
18637	3281	21	an	an	DT
18637	3281	22	owner	owner	NN
18637	3281	23	to	to	IN
18637	3281	24	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	3281	25	for	for	IN
18637	3281	26	property	property	NN
18637	3281	27	destroyed	destroy	VBN
18637	3281	28	to	to	TO
18637	3281	29	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	3281	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3281	31	falling	falling	NN
18637	3281	32	into	into	IN
18637	3281	33	the	the	DT
18637	3281	34	hands	hand	NNS
18637	3281	35	of	of	IN
18637	3281	36	the	the	DT
18637	3281	37	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	3281	38	,	,	,
18637	3281	39	or	or	CC
18637	3281	40	for	for	IN
18637	3281	41	that	that	DT
18637	3281	42	taken	take	VBN
18637	3281	43	for	for	IN
18637	3281	44	public	public	JJ
18637	3281	45	use	use	NN
18637	3281	46	.	.	.
18637	3282	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3282	2	1321	1321	CD
18637	3282	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3282	4	In	in	IN
18637	3282	5	United	United	NNP
18637	3282	6	States	States	NNP
18637	3282	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3282	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	3282	9	_	_	NNP
18637	3282	10	Russell,[1322	Russell,[1322	NNP
18637	3282	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3282	12	decided	decide	VBD
18637	3282	13	following	follow	VBG
18637	3282	14	the	the	DT
18637	3282	15	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3282	16	War	War	NNP
18637	3282	17	,	,	,
18637	3282	18	a	a	DT
18637	3282	19	similar	similar	JJ
18637	3282	20	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	3282	21	was	be	VBD
18637	3282	22	based	base	VBN
18637	3282	23	squarely	squarely	RB
18637	3282	24	on	on	IN
18637	3282	25	the	the	DT
18637	3282	26	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	3282	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3282	28	,	,	,
18637	3282	29	although	although	IN
18637	3282	30	the	the	DT
18637	3282	31	case	case	NN
18637	3282	32	did	do	VBD
18637	3282	33	not	not	RB
18637	3282	34	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	3282	35	involve	involve	VB
18637	3282	36	the	the	DT
18637	3282	37	point	point	NN
18637	3282	38	.	.	.
18637	3283	1	Finally	finally	RB
18637	3283	2	,	,	,
18637	3283	3	in	in	IN
18637	3283	4	United	United	NNP
18637	3283	5	States	States	NNP
18637	3283	6	_	_	NNP
18637	3283	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	3283	8	_	_	NNP
18637	3283	9	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	3283	10	Railroad,[1323	Railroad,[1323	NNP
18637	3283	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3283	12	also	also	RB
18637	3283	13	a	a	DT
18637	3283	14	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3283	15	War	War	NNP
18637	3283	16	case	case	NN
18637	3283	17	,	,	,
18637	3283	18	the	the	DT
18637	3283	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3283	20	held	hold	VBD
18637	3283	21	that	that	IN
18637	3283	22	the	the	DT
18637	3283	23	United	United	NNP
18637	3283	24	States	States	NNP
18637	3283	25	was	be	VBD
18637	3283	26	not	not	RB
18637	3283	27	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	3283	28	for	for	IN
18637	3283	29	the	the	DT
18637	3283	30	injury	injury	NN
18637	3283	31	or	or	CC
18637	3283	32	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	3283	33	of	of	IN
18637	3283	34	private	private	JJ
18637	3283	35	property	property	NN
18637	3283	36	by	by	IN
18637	3283	37	military	military	JJ
18637	3283	38	operations	operation	NNS
18637	3283	39	,	,	,
18637	3283	40	but	but	CC
18637	3283	41	added	add	VBD
18637	3283	42	that	that	IN
18637	3283	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3283	44	did	do	VBD
18637	3283	45	not	not	RB
18637	3283	46	have	have	VB
18637	3283	47	in	in	IN
18637	3283	48	mind	mind	NN
18637	3283	49	claims	claim	NNS
18637	3283	50	for	for	IN
18637	3283	51	property	property	NN
18637	3283	52	of	of	IN
18637	3283	53	loyal	loyal	JJ
18637	3283	54	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	3283	55	which	which	WDT
18637	3283	56	was	be	VBD
18637	3283	57	taken	take	VBN
18637	3283	58	for	for	IN
18637	3283	59	the	the	DT
18637	3283	60	use	use	NN
18637	3283	61	of	of	IN
18637	3283	62	the	the	DT
18637	3283	63	national	national	JJ
18637	3283	64	forces	force	NNS
18637	3283	65	.	.	.
18637	3284	1	"	"	``
18637	3284	2	In	in	IN
18637	3284	3	such	such	JJ
18637	3284	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	3284	5	,	,	,
18637	3284	6	"	"	''
18637	3284	7	the	the	DT
18637	3284	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3284	9	said	say	VBD
18637	3284	10	,	,	,
18637	3284	11	"	"	``
18637	3284	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3284	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	3284	14	been	be	VBN
18637	3284	15	the	the	DT
18637	3284	16	practice	practice	NN
18637	3284	17	of	of	IN
18637	3284	18	the	the	DT
18637	3284	19	government	government	NN
18637	3284	20	to	to	TO
18637	3284	21	make	make	VB
18637	3284	22	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	3284	23	for	for	IN
18637	3284	24	the	the	DT
18637	3284	25	property	property	NN
18637	3284	26	taken	take	VBN
18637	3284	27	.	.	.
18637	3285	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3285	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3285	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3285	4	,	,	,
18637	3285	5	although	although	IN
18637	3285	6	the	the	DT
18637	3285	7	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	3285	8	and	and	CC
18637	3285	9	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	3285	10	of	of	IN
18637	3285	11	private	private	JJ
18637	3285	12	property	property	NN
18637	3285	13	under	under	IN
18637	3285	14	such	such	JJ
18637	3285	15	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	3285	16	by	by	IN
18637	3285	17	the	the	DT
18637	3285	18	military	military	JJ
18637	3285	19	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	3285	20	may	may	MD
18637	3285	21	not	not	RB
18637	3285	22	be	be	VB
18637	3285	23	within	within	IN
18637	3285	24	the	the	DT
18637	3285	25	terms	term	NNS
18637	3285	26	of	of	IN
18637	3285	27	the	the	DT
18637	3285	28	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3285	29	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	3285	30	.	.	.
18637	3286	1	"	"	``
18637	3286	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3286	3	1324	1324	CD
18637	3286	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3286	5	Meantime	meantime	RB
18637	3286	6	,	,	,
18637	3286	7	however	however	RB
18637	3286	8	,	,	,
18637	3286	9	in	in	IN
18637	3286	10	1874	1874	CD
18637	3286	11	,	,	,
18637	3286	12	a	a	DT
18637	3286	13	committee	committee	NN
18637	3286	14	of	of	IN
18637	3286	15	the	the	DT
18637	3286	16	House	House	NNP
18637	3286	17	of	of	IN
18637	3286	18	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	3286	19	,	,	,
18637	3286	20	in	in	IN
18637	3286	21	an	an	DT
18637	3286	22	elaborate	elaborate	JJ
18637	3286	23	report	report	NN
18637	3286	24	on	on	IN
18637	3286	25	war	war	NN
18637	3286	26	claims	claim	NNS
18637	3286	27	growing	grow	VBG
18637	3286	28	out	out	IN
18637	3286	29	of	of	IN
18637	3286	30	the	the	DT
18637	3286	31	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3286	32	War	War	NNP
18637	3286	33	,	,	,
18637	3286	34	had	have	VBD
18637	3286	35	voiced	voice	VBN
18637	3286	36	the	the	DT
18637	3286	37	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3286	38	that	that	IN
18637	3286	39	the	the	DT
18637	3286	40	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	3286	41	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3286	42	embodied	embody	VBD
18637	3286	43	the	the	DT
18637	3286	44	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	3286	45	between	between	IN
18637	3286	46	a	a	DT
18637	3286	47	taking	taking	NN
18637	3286	48	of	of	IN
18637	3286	49	property	property	NN
18637	3286	50	in	in	IN
18637	3286	51	the	the	DT
18637	3286	52	course	course	NN
18637	3286	53	of	of	IN
18637	3286	54	military	military	JJ
18637	3286	55	operations	operation	NNS
18637	3286	56	or	or	CC
18637	3286	57	other	other	JJ
18637	3286	58	urgent	urgent	JJ
18637	3286	59	military	military	JJ
18637	3286	60	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	3286	61	,	,	,
18637	3286	62	and	and	CC
18637	3286	63	other	other	JJ
18637	3286	64	takings	taking	NNS
18637	3286	65	for	for	IN
18637	3286	66	war	war	NN
18637	3286	67	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	3286	68	,	,	,
18637	3286	69	and	and	CC
18637	3286	70	required	require	VBN
18637	3286	71	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	3286	72	of	of	IN
18637	3286	73	owners	owner	NNS
18637	3286	74	in	in	IN
18637	3286	75	the	the	DT
18637	3286	76	latter	latter	JJ
18637	3286	77	class	class	NN
18637	3286	78	of	of	IN
18637	3286	79	cases	case	NNS
18637	3286	80	.	.	.
18637	3287	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3287	2	1325	1325	CD
18637	3287	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3287	4	In	in	IN
18637	3287	5	determining	determine	VBG
18637	3287	6	what	what	WP
18637	3287	7	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	3287	8	just	just	RB
18637	3287	9	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	3287	10	for	for	IN
18637	3287	11	property	property	NN
18637	3287	12	requisitioned	requisition	VBN
18637	3287	13	for	for	IN
18637	3287	14	war	war	NN
18637	3287	15	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	3287	16	during	during	IN
18637	3287	17	World	World	NNP
18637	3287	18	War	War	NNP
18637	3287	19	II	II	NNP
18637	3287	20	,	,	,
18637	3287	21	the	the	DT
18637	3287	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3287	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	3287	24	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	3287	25	that	that	IN
18637	3287	26	the	the	DT
18637	3287	27	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	3287	28	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3287	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	3287	30	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	3287	31	to	to	IN
18637	3287	32	such	such	JJ
18637	3287	33	takings	taking	NNS
18637	3287	34	.	.	.
18637	3288	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3288	2	1326	1326	CD
18637	3288	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3288	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3288	5	15	15	CD
18637	3288	6	.	.	.
18637	3289	1	_	_	NNP
18637	3289	2	The	the	DT
18637	3289	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3289	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	3289	5	have	have	VB
18637	3289	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	3289	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3289	8	*	*	NFP
18637	3289	9	*	*	NFP
18637	3289	10	*	*	NFP
18637	3289	11	To	to	TO
18637	3289	12	provide	provide	VB
18637	3289	13	for	for	IN
18637	3289	14	calling	call	VBG
18637	3289	15	forth	forth	RP
18637	3289	16	the	the	DT
18637	3289	17	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	3289	18	to	to	TO
18637	3289	19	execute	execute	VB
18637	3289	20	the	the	DT
18637	3289	21	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	3289	22	of	of	IN
18637	3289	23	the	the	DT
18637	3289	24	Union	Union	NNP
18637	3289	25	,	,	,
18637	3289	26	suppress	suppress	NN
18637	3289	27	Insurrections	insurrection	NNS
18637	3289	28	and	and	CC
18637	3289	29	repel	repel	JJ
18637	3289	30	Invasions	invasion	NNS
18637	3289	31	.	.	.
18637	3290	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3290	2	16	16	CD
18637	3290	3	.	.	.
18637	3291	1	_	_	NNP
18637	3291	2	The	the	DT
18637	3291	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3291	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	3291	5	have	have	VB
18637	3291	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	3291	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3291	8	*	*	NFP
18637	3291	9	*	*	NFP
18637	3291	10	*	*	NFP
18637	3291	11	To	to	TO
18637	3291	12	provide	provide	VB
18637	3291	13	for	for	IN
18637	3291	14	organizing	organizing	NN
18637	3291	15	,	,	,
18637	3291	16	arming	arm	VBG
18637	3291	17	,	,	,
18637	3291	18	and	and	CC
18637	3291	19	disciplining	discipline	VBG
18637	3291	20	,	,	,
18637	3291	21	the	the	DT
18637	3291	22	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	3291	23	,	,	,
18637	3291	24	and	and	CC
18637	3291	25	for	for	IN
18637	3291	26	governing	govern	VBG
18637	3291	27	such	such	JJ
18637	3291	28	Part	part	NN
18637	3291	29	of	of	IN
18637	3291	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3291	31	as	as	IN
18637	3291	32	may	may	MD
18637	3291	33	be	be	VB
18637	3291	34	employed	employ	VBN
18637	3291	35	in	in	IN
18637	3291	36	the	the	DT
18637	3291	37	Service	Service	NNP
18637	3291	38	of	of	IN
18637	3291	39	the	the	DT
18637	3291	40	United	United	NNP
18637	3291	41	States	States	NNP
18637	3291	42	,	,	,
18637	3291	43	reserving	reserve	VBG
18637	3291	44	to	to	IN
18637	3291	45	the	the	DT
18637	3291	46	States	States	NNP
18637	3291	47	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	3291	48	,	,	,
18637	3291	49	the	the	DT
18637	3291	50	Appointment	Appointment	NNP
18637	3291	51	of	of	IN
18637	3291	52	the	the	DT
18637	3291	53	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	3291	54	,	,	,
18637	3291	55	and	and	CC
18637	3291	56	the	the	DT
18637	3291	57	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	3291	58	of	of	IN
18637	3291	59	training	train	VBG
18637	3291	60	the	the	DT
18637	3291	61	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	3291	62	according	accord	VBG
18637	3291	63	to	to	IN
18637	3291	64	the	the	DT
18637	3291	65	discipline	discipline	NN
18637	3291	66	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	3291	67	by	by	IN
18637	3291	68	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3291	69	.	.	.
18637	3292	1	The	the	DT
18637	3292	2	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	3292	3	Clauses	clause	NNS
18637	3292	4	CALLING	call	VBG
18637	3292	5	OUT	out	RP
18637	3292	6	THE	the	DT
18637	3292	7	MILITIA	MILITIA	NNP
18637	3292	8	The	the	DT
18637	3292	9	States	States	NNPS
18637	3292	10	as	as	RB
18637	3292	11	well	well	RB
18637	3292	12	as	as	IN
18637	3292	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3292	14	may	may	MD
18637	3292	15	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	3292	16	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	3292	17	for	for	IN
18637	3292	18	failure	failure	NN
18637	3292	19	to	to	TO
18637	3292	20	obey	obey	VB
18637	3292	21	the	the	DT
18637	3292	22	President	President	NNP
18637	3292	23	's	's	POS
18637	3292	24	call	call	NN
18637	3292	25	of	of	IN
18637	3292	26	the	the	DT
18637	3292	27	militia	militia	NN
18637	3292	28	.	.	.
18637	3293	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3293	2	also	also	RB
18637	3293	3	have	have	VBP
18637	3293	4	a	a	DT
18637	3293	5	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	3293	6	power	power	NN
18637	3293	7	to	to	TO
18637	3293	8	aid	aid	VB
18637	3293	9	the	the	DT
18637	3293	10	National	National	NNP
18637	3293	11	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3293	12	by	by	IN
18637	3293	13	calls	call	NNS
18637	3293	14	under	under	IN
18637	3293	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3293	16	own	own	JJ
18637	3293	17	authority	authority	NN
18637	3293	18	,	,	,
18637	3293	19	and	and	CC
18637	3293	20	in	in	IN
18637	3293	21	emergencies	emergency	NNS
18637	3293	22	may	may	MD
18637	3293	23	use	use	VB
18637	3293	24	the	the	DT
18637	3293	25	militia	militia	NN
18637	3293	26	to	to	TO
18637	3293	27	put	put	VB
18637	3293	28	down	down	RP
18637	3293	29	armed	armed	JJ
18637	3293	30	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	3293	31	.	.	.
18637	3294	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3294	2	1327	1327	CD
18637	3294	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3294	4	The	the	DT
18637	3294	5	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3294	6	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3294	7	may	may	MD
18637	3294	8	call	call	VB
18637	3294	9	out	out	RP
18637	3294	10	the	the	DT
18637	3294	11	militia	militia	NN
18637	3294	12	in	in	IN
18637	3294	13	case	case	NN
18637	3294	14	of	of	IN
18637	3294	15	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3294	16	war	war	NN
18637	3294	17	;	;	:
18637	3294	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3294	19	authority	authority	NN
18637	3294	20	to	to	TO
18637	3294	21	suppress	suppress	VB
18637	3294	22	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	3294	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	3294	24	found	find	VBN
18637	3294	25	in	in	IN
18637	3294	26	the	the	DT
18637	3294	27	power	power	NN
18637	3294	28	to	to	TO
18637	3294	29	suppress	suppress	VB
18637	3294	30	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	3294	31	and	and	CC
18637	3294	32	to	to	TO
18637	3294	33	carry	carry	VB
18637	3294	34	on	on	IN
18637	3294	35	war	war	NN
18637	3294	36	.	.	.
18637	3295	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3295	2	1328	1328	CD
18637	3295	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3295	4	The	the	DT
18637	3295	5	act	act	NN
18637	3295	6	of	of	IN
18637	3295	7	February	February	NNP
18637	3295	8	28	28	CD
18637	3295	9	,	,	,
18637	3295	10	1795,[1329	1795,[1329	CD
18637	3295	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3295	12	which	which	WDT
18637	3295	13	delegated	delegate	VBD
18637	3295	14	to	to	IN
18637	3295	15	the	the	DT
18637	3295	16	President	President	NNP
18637	3295	17	the	the	DT
18637	3295	18	power	power	NN
18637	3295	19	to	to	TO
18637	3295	20	call	call	VB
18637	3295	21	out	out	RP
18637	3295	22	the	the	DT
18637	3295	23	militia	militia	NN
18637	3295	24	,	,	,
18637	3295	25	was	be	VBD
18637	3295	26	held	hold	VBN
18637	3295	27	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3295	28	.	.	.
18637	3296	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3296	2	1330	1330	CD
18637	3296	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3296	4	A	a	DT
18637	3296	5	militiaman	militiaman	NN
18637	3296	6	who	who	WP
18637	3296	7	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	3296	8	to	to	TO
18637	3296	9	obey	obey	VB
18637	3296	10	such	such	PDT
18637	3296	11	a	a	DT
18637	3296	12	call	call	NN
18637	3296	13	was	be	VBD
18637	3296	14	not	not	RB
18637	3296	15	"	"	``
18637	3296	16	employed	employ	VBN
18637	3296	17	in	in	IN
18637	3296	18	the	the	DT
18637	3296	19	service	service	NN
18637	3296	20	of	of	IN
18637	3296	21	the	the	DT
18637	3296	22	United	United	NNP
18637	3296	23	States	States	NNP
18637	3296	24	so	so	IN
18637	3296	25	as	as	IN
18637	3296	26	to	to	TO
18637	3296	27	be	be	VB
18637	3296	28	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3296	29	to	to	IN
18637	3296	30	the	the	DT
18637	3296	31	article	article	NN
18637	3296	32	of	of	IN
18637	3296	33	war	war	NN
18637	3296	34	,	,	,
18637	3296	35	"	"	''
18637	3296	36	but	but	CC
18637	3296	37	was	be	VBD
18637	3296	38	liable	liable	JJ
18637	3296	39	to	to	TO
18637	3296	40	be	be	VB
18637	3296	41	tried	try	VBN
18637	3296	42	for	for	IN
18637	3296	43	disobedience	disobedience	NN
18637	3296	44	of	of	IN
18637	3296	45	the	the	DT
18637	3296	46	act	act	NN
18637	3296	47	of	of	IN
18637	3296	48	1795	1795	CD
18637	3296	49	.	.	.
18637	3297	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3297	2	1331	1331	CD
18637	3297	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3297	4	REGULATION	regulation	NN
18637	3297	5	OF	of	IN
18637	3297	6	THE	the	DT
18637	3297	7	MILITIA	MILITIA	NNP
18637	3297	8	The	the	DT
18637	3297	9	power	power	NN
18637	3297	10	of	of	IN
18637	3297	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3297	12	over	over	IN
18637	3297	13	the	the	DT
18637	3297	14	militia	militia	NN
18637	3297	15	"	"	''
18637	3297	16	being	be	VBG
18637	3297	17	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	3297	18	,	,	,
18637	3297	19	except	except	IN
18637	3297	20	in	in	IN
18637	3297	21	the	the	DT
18637	3297	22	two	two	CD
18637	3297	23	particulars	particular	NNS
18637	3297	24	of	of	IN
18637	3297	25	officering	officering	NN
18637	3297	26	and	and	CC
18637	3297	27	training	train	VBG
18637	3297	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3297	29	,	,	,
18637	3297	30	*	*	NFP
18637	3297	31	*	*	NFP
18637	3297	32	*	*	NFP
18637	3297	33	,	,	,
18637	3297	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3297	35	may	may	MD
18637	3297	36	be	be	VB
18637	3297	37	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	3297	38	to	to	IN
18637	3297	39	any	any	DT
18637	3297	40	extent	extent	NN
18637	3297	41	that	that	WDT
18637	3297	42	may	may	MD
18637	3297	43	be	be	VB
18637	3297	44	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	3297	45	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3297	46	by	by	IN
18637	3297	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3297	48	.	.	.
18637	3298	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3298	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3298	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3298	4	The	the	DT
18637	3298	5	power	power	NN
18637	3298	6	of	of	IN
18637	3298	7	the	the	DT
18637	3298	8	State	State	NNP
18637	3298	9	government	government	NN
18637	3298	10	to	to	TO
18637	3298	11	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	3298	12	on	on	IN
18637	3298	13	the	the	DT
18637	3298	14	same	same	JJ
18637	3298	15	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	3298	16	,	,	,
18637	3298	17	having	have	VBG
18637	3298	18	existed	exist	VBN
18637	3298	19	prior	prior	RB
18637	3298	20	to	to	IN
18637	3298	21	the	the	DT
18637	3298	22	formation	formation	NN
18637	3298	23	of	of	IN
18637	3298	24	the	the	DT
18637	3298	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3298	26	,	,	,
18637	3298	27	and	and	CC
18637	3298	28	not	not	RB
18637	3298	29	having	have	VBG
18637	3298	30	been	be	VBN
18637	3298	31	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	3298	32	by	by	IN
18637	3298	33	that	that	DT
18637	3298	34	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	3298	35	,	,	,
18637	3298	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3298	37	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	3298	38	with	with	IN
18637	3298	39	the	the	DT
18637	3298	40	States	States	NNPS
18637	3298	41	,	,	,
18637	3298	42	subordinate	subordinate	JJ
18637	3298	43	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	3298	44	to	to	IN
18637	3298	45	the	the	DT
18637	3298	46	paramount	paramount	JJ
18637	3298	47	law	law	NN
18637	3298	48	of	of	IN
18637	3298	49	the	the	DT
18637	3298	50	General	General	NNP
18637	3298	51	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3298	52	,	,	,
18637	3298	53	*	*	NFP
18637	3298	54	*	*	NFP
18637	3298	55	*	*	NFP
18637	3298	56	"	"	''
18637	3298	57	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3298	58	1332	1332	CD
18637	3298	59	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3298	60	Under	under	IN
18637	3298	61	the	the	DT
18637	3298	62	National	National	NNP
18637	3298	63	Defense	Defense	NNP
18637	3298	64	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3298	65	of	of	IN
18637	3298	66	1916,[1333	1916,[1333	CD
18637	3298	67	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3298	68	the	the	DT
18637	3298	69	militia	militia	NN
18637	3298	70	,	,	,
18637	3298	71	which	which	WDT
18637	3298	72	hitherto	hitherto	NNP
18637	3298	73	had	have	VBD
18637	3298	74	been	be	VBN
18637	3298	75	an	an	DT
18637	3298	76	almost	almost	RB
18637	3298	77	purely	purely	RB
18637	3298	78	State	state	NN
18637	3298	79	institution	institution	NN
18637	3298	80	,	,	,
18637	3298	81	was	be	VBD
18637	3298	82	brought	bring	VBN
18637	3298	83	under	under	IN
18637	3298	84	the	the	DT
18637	3298	85	control	control	NN
18637	3298	86	of	of	IN
18637	3298	87	the	the	DT
18637	3298	88	National	National	NNP
18637	3298	89	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3298	90	.	.	.
18637	3299	1	The	the	DT
18637	3299	2	term	term	NN
18637	3299	3	"	"	``
18637	3299	4	militia	militia	NN
18637	3299	5	of	of	IN
18637	3299	6	the	the	DT
18637	3299	7	United	United	NNP
18637	3299	8	States	States	NNP
18637	3299	9	"	"	''
18637	3299	10	was	be	VBD
18637	3299	11	defined	define	VBN
18637	3299	12	to	to	TO
18637	3299	13	comprehend	comprehend	VB
18637	3299	14	"	"	``
18637	3299	15	all	all	DT
18637	3299	16	able	able	JJ
18637	3299	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	3299	18	bodied	bodied	JJ
18637	3299	19	male	male	JJ
18637	3299	20	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	3299	21	of	of	IN
18637	3299	22	the	the	DT
18637	3299	23	United	United	NNP
18637	3299	24	States	States	NNP
18637	3299	25	and	and	CC
18637	3299	26	all	all	DT
18637	3299	27	other	other	JJ
18637	3299	28	able	able	JJ
18637	3299	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	3299	30	bodied	bodied	JJ
18637	3299	31	males	male	NNS
18637	3299	32	who	who	WP
18637	3299	33	have	have	VBP
18637	3299	34	*	*	NFP
18637	3299	35	*	*	NFP
18637	3299	36	*	*	NFP
18637	3299	37	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3299	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3299	39	intention	intention	NN
18637	3299	40	to	to	TO
18637	3299	41	become	become	VB
18637	3299	42	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	3299	43	of	of	IN
18637	3299	44	the	the	DT
18637	3299	45	United	United	NNP
18637	3299	46	States	States	NNP
18637	3299	47	,	,	,
18637	3299	48	"	"	''
18637	3299	49	between	between	IN
18637	3299	50	the	the	DT
18637	3299	51	ages	age	NNS
18637	3299	52	of	of	IN
18637	3299	53	eighteen	eighteen	CD
18637	3299	54	and	and	CC
18637	3299	55	forty	forty	CD
18637	3299	56	-	-	HYPH
18637	3299	57	five	five	CD
18637	3299	58	.	.	.
18637	3300	1	The	the	DT
18637	3300	2	act	act	NN
18637	3300	3	reorganized	reorganize	VBD
18637	3300	4	the	the	DT
18637	3300	5	National	National	NNP
18637	3300	6	Guard	Guard	NNP
18637	3300	7	,	,	,
18637	3300	8	determined	determine	VBD
18637	3300	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3300	10	size	size	NN
18637	3300	11	in	in	IN
18637	3300	12	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	3300	13	to	to	IN
18637	3300	14	the	the	DT
18637	3300	15	population	population	NN
18637	3300	16	of	of	IN
18637	3300	17	the	the	DT
18637	3300	18	several	several	JJ
18637	3300	19	States	States	NNPS
18637	3300	20	,	,	,
18637	3300	21	required	require	VBD
18637	3300	22	that	that	IN
18637	3300	23	all	all	DT
18637	3300	24	enlistments	enlistment	NNS
18637	3300	25	be	be	VB
18637	3300	26	for	for	IN
18637	3300	27	"	"	``
18637	3300	28	three	three	CD
18637	3300	29	years	year	NNS
18637	3300	30	in	in	IN
18637	3300	31	service	service	NN
18637	3300	32	and	and	CC
18637	3300	33	three	three	CD
18637	3300	34	years	year	NNS
18637	3300	35	in	in	IN
18637	3300	36	reserve	reserve	NN
18637	3300	37	,	,	,
18637	3300	38	"	"	''
18637	3300	39	limited	limit	VBD
18637	3300	40	the	the	DT
18637	3300	41	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	3300	42	of	of	IN
18637	3300	43	officers	officer	NNS
18637	3300	44	to	to	IN
18637	3300	45	those	those	DT
18637	3300	46	who	who	WP
18637	3300	47	"	"	``
18637	3300	48	shall	shall	MD
18637	3300	49	have	have	VB
18637	3300	50	successfully	successfully	RB
18637	3300	51	passed	pass	VBN
18637	3300	52	such	such	JJ
18637	3300	53	tests	test	NNS
18637	3300	54	as	as	IN
18637	3300	55	to	to	IN
18637	3300	56	*	*	NFP
18637	3300	57	*	*	NFP
18637	3300	58	*	*	NFP
18637	3300	59	physical	physical	JJ
18637	3300	60	,	,	,
18637	3300	61	moral	moral	JJ
18637	3300	62	and	and	CC
18637	3300	63	professional	professional	JJ
18637	3300	64	fitness	fitness	NN
18637	3300	65	as	as	IN
18637	3300	66	the	the	DT
18637	3300	67	President	President	NNP
18637	3300	68	shall	shall	MD
18637	3300	69	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	3300	70	,	,	,
18637	3300	71	"	"	''
18637	3300	72	and	and	CC
18637	3300	73	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	3300	74	the	the	DT
18637	3300	75	President	President	NNP
18637	3300	76	in	in	IN
18637	3300	77	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3300	78	emergencies	emergency	NNS
18637	3300	79	to	to	TO
18637	3300	80	"	"	``
18637	3300	81	draft	draft	VB
18637	3300	82	into	into	IN
18637	3300	83	the	the	DT
18637	3300	84	military	military	JJ
18637	3300	85	service	service	NN
18637	3300	86	of	of	IN
18637	3300	87	the	the	DT
18637	3300	88	United	United	NNP
18637	3300	89	States	States	NNP
18637	3300	90	to	to	TO
18637	3300	91	serve	serve	VB
18637	3300	92	therein	therein	RB
18637	3300	93	for	for	IN
18637	3300	94	the	the	DT
18637	3300	95	period	period	NN
18637	3300	96	of	of	IN
18637	3300	97	the	the	DT
18637	3300	98	war	war	NN
18637	3300	99	unless	unless	IN
18637	3300	100	sooner	soon	RBR
18637	3300	101	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	3300	102	,	,	,
18637	3300	103	any	any	DT
18637	3300	104	and	and	CC
18637	3300	105	all	all	DT
18637	3300	106	members	member	NNS
18637	3300	107	of	of	IN
18637	3300	108	the	the	DT
18637	3300	109	National	National	NNP
18637	3300	110	Guard	Guard	NNP
18637	3300	111	and	and	CC
18637	3300	112	National	National	NNP
18637	3300	113	Guard	Guard	NNP
18637	3300	114	Reserve	Reserve	NNP
18637	3300	115	,	,	,
18637	3300	116	"	"	''
18637	3300	117	who	who	WP
18637	3300	118	thereupon	thereupon	RB
18637	3300	119	should	should	MD
18637	3300	120	"	"	``
18637	3300	121	stand	stand	VB
18637	3300	122	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	3300	123	from	from	IN
18637	3300	124	the	the	DT
18637	3300	125	militia	militia	NN
18637	3300	126	.	.	.
18637	3300	127	"	"	''
18637	3301	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3301	2	17	17	CD
18637	3301	3	.	.	.
18637	3302	1	_	_	NNP
18637	3302	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3302	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	3302	4	have	have	VB
18637	3302	5	power	power	NN
18637	3302	6	_	_	NNP
18637	3302	7	*	*	NFP
18637	3302	8	*	*	NFP
18637	3302	9	*	*	NFP
18637	3302	10	To	to	TO
18637	3302	11	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	3302	12	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3302	13	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
18637	3302	14	in	in	IN
18637	3302	15	all	all	DT
18637	3302	16	Cases	case	NNS
18637	3302	17	whatsoever	whatsoever	RB
18637	3302	18	,	,	,
18637	3302	19	over	over	IN
18637	3302	20	such	such	JJ
18637	3302	21	District	District	NNP
18637	3302	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3302	23	not	not	RB
18637	3302	24	exceeding	exceed	VBG
18637	3302	25	ten	ten	CD
18637	3302	26	Miles	Miles	NNP
18637	3302	27	square	square	JJ
18637	3302	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3302	29	as	as	IN
18637	3302	30	may	may	NNP
18637	3302	31	,	,	,
18637	3302	32	by	by	IN
18637	3302	33	Cession	cession	NN
18637	3302	34	of	of	IN
18637	3302	35	particular	particular	JJ
18637	3302	36	States	States	NNP
18637	3302	37	,	,	,
18637	3302	38	and	and	CC
18637	3302	39	the	the	DT
18637	3302	40	Acceptance	Acceptance	NNP
18637	3302	41	of	of	IN
18637	3302	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3302	43	,	,	,
18637	3302	44	become	become	VB
18637	3302	45	the	the	DT
18637	3302	46	Seat	Seat	NNP
18637	3302	47	of	of	IN
18637	3302	48	the	the	DT
18637	3302	49	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3302	50	of	of	IN
18637	3302	51	the	the	DT
18637	3302	52	United	United	NNP
18637	3302	53	States	States	NNP
18637	3302	54	,	,	,
18637	3302	55	and	and	CC
18637	3302	56	to	to	TO
18637	3302	57	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	3302	58	like	like	IN
18637	3302	59	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	3302	60	over	over	IN
18637	3302	61	all	all	DT
18637	3302	62	Places	Places	NNPS
18637	3302	63	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	3302	64	by	by	IN
18637	3302	65	the	the	DT
18637	3302	66	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	3302	67	of	of	IN
18637	3302	68	the	the	DT
18637	3302	69	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	3302	70	of	of	IN
18637	3302	71	the	the	DT
18637	3302	72	State	State	NNP
18637	3302	73	in	in	IN
18637	3302	74	which	which	WDT
18637	3302	75	the	the	DT
18637	3302	76	Same	same	JJ
18637	3302	77	shall	shall	MD
18637	3302	78	be	be	VB
18637	3302	79	,	,	,
18637	3302	80	for	for	IN
18637	3302	81	the	the	DT
18637	3302	82	Erection	Erection	NNP
18637	3302	83	of	of	IN
18637	3302	84	Forts	Forts	NNPS
18637	3302	85	,	,	,
18637	3302	86	Magazines	Magazines	NNPS
18637	3302	87	,	,	,
18637	3302	88	Arsenals	Arsenals	NNPS
18637	3302	89	,	,	,
18637	3302	90	dock	dock	NN
18637	3302	91	-	-	HYPH
18637	3302	92	Yards	Yards	NNPS
18637	3302	93	,	,	,
18637	3302	94	and	and	CC
18637	3302	95	other	other	JJ
18637	3302	96	needful	needful	JJ
18637	3302	97	Buildings;--And	buildings;--and	IN
18637	3302	98	The	the	DT
18637	3302	99	Seat	Seat	NNP
18637	3302	100	of	of	IN
18637	3302	101	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3302	102	The	the	DT
18637	3302	103	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3302	104	of	of	IN
18637	3302	105	the	the	DT
18637	3302	106	United	United	NNP
18637	3302	107	States	States	NNP
18637	3302	108	over	over	IN
18637	3302	109	the	the	DT
18637	3302	110	District	District	NNP
18637	3302	111	of	of	IN
18637	3302	112	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3302	113	vested	vest	VBD
18637	3302	114	on	on	IN
18637	3302	115	the	the	DT
18637	3302	116	first	first	JJ
18637	3302	117	Monday	Monday	NNP
18637	3302	118	of	of	IN
18637	3302	119	December	December	NNP
18637	3302	120	,	,	,
18637	3302	121	1800	1800	CD
18637	3302	122	.	.	.
18637	3303	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3303	2	1334	1334	CD
18637	3303	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3303	4	By	by	IN
18637	3303	5	the	the	DT
18637	3303	6	act	act	NN
18637	3303	7	of	of	IN
18637	3303	8	February	February	NNP
18637	3303	9	27	27	CD
18637	3303	10	,	,	,
18637	3303	11	1801,[1335	1801,[1335	CD
18637	3303	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3303	13	the	the	DT
18637	3303	14	District	District	NNP
18637	3303	15	was	be	VBD
18637	3303	16	divided	divide	VBN
18637	3303	17	into	into	IN
18637	3303	18	two	two	CD
18637	3303	19	counties	county	NNS
18637	3303	20	and	and	CC
18637	3303	21	in	in	IN
18637	3303	22	the	the	DT
18637	3303	23	following	following	JJ
18637	3303	24	year	year	NN
18637	3303	25	the	the	DT
18637	3303	26	city	city	NN
18637	3303	27	of	of	IN
18637	3303	28	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	3303	29	was	be	VBD
18637	3303	30	erected	erect	VBN
18637	3303	31	into	into	IN
18637	3303	32	a	a	DT
18637	3303	33	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	3303	34	.	.	.
18637	3304	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3304	2	1336	1336	CD
18637	3304	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3304	4	The	the	DT
18637	3304	5	present	present	JJ
18637	3304	6	form	form	NN
18637	3304	7	of	of	IN
18637	3304	8	government	government	NN
18637	3304	9	dates	date	VBZ
18637	3304	10	from	from	IN
18637	3304	11	1876	1876	CD
18637	3304	12	;	;	:
18637	3304	13	all	all	DT
18637	3304	14	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3304	15	powers	power	NNS
18637	3304	16	with	with	IN
18637	3304	17	respect	respect	NN
18637	3304	18	to	to	IN
18637	3304	19	District	District	NNP
18637	3304	20	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	3304	21	are	be	VBP
18637	3304	22	retained	retain	VBN
18637	3304	23	by	by	IN
18637	3304	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3304	25	,	,	,
18637	3304	26	while	while	IN
18637	3304	27	an	an	DT
18637	3304	28	executive	executive	JJ
18637	3304	29	board	board	NN
18637	3304	30	of	of	IN
18637	3304	31	three	three	CD
18637	3304	32	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	3304	33	vested	vest	VBN
18637	3304	34	with	with	IN
18637	3304	35	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	3304	36	powers	power	NNS
18637	3304	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	3304	38	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	3304	39	by	by	IN
18637	3304	40	the	the	DT
18637	3304	41	President	President	NNP
18637	3304	42	.	.	.
18637	3305	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3305	2	1337	1337	CD
18637	3305	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3305	4	As	as	IN
18637	3305	5	a	a	DT
18637	3305	6	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	3305	7	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3305	8	,	,	,
18637	3305	9	the	the	DT
18637	3305	10	District	District	NNP
18637	3305	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	3305	12	the	the	DT
18637	3305	13	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3305	14	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	3305	15	to	to	TO
18637	3305	16	sue	sue	VB
18637	3305	17	and	and	CC
18637	3305	18	be	be	VB
18637	3305	19	sued	sue	VBN
18637	3305	20	.	.	.
18637	3306	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3306	2	1338	1338	CD
18637	3306	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3306	4	But	but	CC
18637	3306	5	the	the	DT
18637	3306	6	District	District	NNP
18637	3306	7	Commissioners	Commissioners	NNPS
18637	3306	8	are	be	VBP
18637	3306	9	merely	merely	RB
18637	3306	10	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	3306	11	officers	officer	NNS
18637	3306	12	,	,	,
18637	3306	13	having	have	VBG
18637	3306	14	only	only	RB
18637	3306	15	the	the	DT
18637	3306	16	ministerial	ministerial	JJ
18637	3306	17	powers	power	NNS
18637	3306	18	given	give	VBN
18637	3306	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3306	20	by	by	IN
18637	3306	21	statute	statute	NN
18637	3306	22	;	;	:
18637	3306	23	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	3306	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3306	25	were	be	VBD
18637	3306	26	found	find	VBN
18637	3306	27	to	to	TO
18637	3306	28	have	have	VB
18637	3306	29	no	no	DT
18637	3306	30	power	power	NN
18637	3306	31	to	to	TO
18637	3306	32	submit	submit	VB
18637	3306	33	a	a	DT
18637	3306	34	claim	claim	NN
18637	3306	35	against	against	IN
18637	3306	36	the	the	DT
18637	3306	37	District	District	NNP
18637	3306	38	to	to	IN
18637	3306	39	arbitration	arbitration	VB
18637	3306	40	.	.	.
18637	3307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3307	2	1339	1339	CD
18637	3307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3307	4	NATURE	NATURE	NNP
18637	3307	5	AND	and	CC
18637	3307	6	EXTENT	extent	NN
18637	3307	7	OF	of	IN
18637	3307	8	RIGHTS	right	NNS
18637	3307	9	CEDED	cede	VBN
18637	3307	10	TO	to	IN
18637	3307	11	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	3307	12	STATES	STATES	NNP
18637	3307	13	In	in	IN
18637	3307	14	ceding	cede	VBG
18637	3307	15	the	the	DT
18637	3307	16	territory	territory	NN
18637	3307	17	which	which	WDT
18637	3307	18	became	become	VBD
18637	3307	19	the	the	DT
18637	3307	20	District	District	NNP
18637	3307	21	of	of	IN
18637	3307	22	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3307	23	,	,	,
18637	3307	24	both	both	CC
18637	3307	25	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	3307	26	and	and	CC
18637	3307	27	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	3307	28	provided	provide	VBD
18637	3307	29	that	that	IN
18637	3307	30	the	the	DT
18637	3307	31	United	United	NNP
18637	3307	32	States	States	NNP
18637	3307	33	should	should	MD
18637	3307	34	not	not	RB
18637	3307	35	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	3307	36	any	any	DT
18637	3307	37	right	right	NN
18637	3307	38	of	of	IN
18637	3307	39	property	property	NN
18637	3307	40	in	in	IN
18637	3307	41	the	the	DT
18637	3307	42	soil	soil	NN
18637	3307	43	except	except	IN
18637	3307	44	by	by	IN
18637	3307	45	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	3307	46	by	by	IN
18637	3307	47	the	the	DT
18637	3307	48	individual	individual	JJ
18637	3307	49	owner	owner	NN
18637	3307	50	.	.	.
18637	3308	1	This	this	DT
18637	3308	2	proviso	proviso	NN
18637	3308	3	was	be	VBD
18637	3308	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	3308	5	not	not	RB
18637	3308	6	to	to	TO
18637	3308	7	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	3308	8	the	the	DT
18637	3308	9	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3308	10	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3308	11	from	from	IN
18637	3308	12	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	3308	13	the	the	DT
18637	3308	14	power	power	NN
18637	3308	15	of	of	IN
18637	3308	16	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	3308	17	domain	domain	NN
18637	3308	18	within	within	IN
18637	3308	19	the	the	DT
18637	3308	20	District	District	NNP
18637	3308	21	.	.	.
18637	3309	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3309	2	1340	1340	CD
18637	3309	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3309	4	Under	under	IN
18637	3309	5	the	the	DT
18637	3309	6	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3309	7	made	make	VBN
18637	3309	8	between	between	IN
18637	3309	9	the	the	DT
18637	3309	10	original	original	JJ
18637	3309	11	proprietors	proprietor	NNS
18637	3309	12	of	of	IN
18637	3309	13	the	the	DT
18637	3309	14	land	land	NN
18637	3309	15	on	on	IN
18637	3309	16	which	which	WDT
18637	3309	17	the	the	DT
18637	3309	18	city	city	NN
18637	3309	19	of	of	IN
18637	3309	20	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	3309	21	was	be	VBD
18637	3309	22	laid	lay	VBN
18637	3309	23	out	out	RP
18637	3309	24	,	,	,
18637	3309	25	and	and	CC
18637	3309	26	the	the	DT
18637	3309	27	Commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	3309	28	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	3309	29	by	by	IN
18637	3309	30	the	the	DT
18637	3309	31	President	President	NNP
18637	3309	32	to	to	TO
18637	3309	33	survey	survey	VB
18637	3309	34	,	,	,
18637	3309	35	define	define	VB
18637	3309	36	and	and	CC
18637	3309	37	locate	locate	VB
18637	3309	38	the	the	DT
18637	3309	39	district	district	NN
18637	3309	40	for	for	IN
18637	3309	41	the	the	DT
18637	3309	42	seat	seat	NN
18637	3309	43	of	of	IN
18637	3309	44	government	government	NN
18637	3309	45	,	,	,
18637	3309	46	the	the	DT
18637	3309	47	United	United	NNP
18637	3309	48	States	States	NNP
18637	3309	49	became	become	VBD
18637	3309	50	the	the	DT
18637	3309	51	owner	owner	NN
18637	3309	52	in	in	IN
18637	3309	53	fee	fee	NN
18637	3309	54	of	of	IN
18637	3309	55	the	the	DT
18637	3309	56	streets	street	NNS
18637	3309	57	of	of	IN
18637	3309	58	the	the	DT
18637	3309	59	city	city	NN
18637	3309	60	although	although	IN
18637	3309	61	the	the	DT
18637	3309	62	trustees	trustee	NNS
18637	3309	63	never	never	RB
18637	3309	64	carried	carry	VBD
18637	3309	65	out	out	RP
18637	3309	66	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3309	67	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3309	68	to	to	TO
18637	3309	69	convey	convey	VB
18637	3309	70	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3309	71	.	.	.
18637	3310	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3310	2	1341	1341	CD
18637	3310	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3310	4	Both	both	CC
18637	3310	5	the	the	DT
18637	3310	6	right	right	NN
18637	3310	7	of	of	IN
18637	3310	8	dominion	dominion	NN
18637	3310	9	and	and	CC
18637	3310	10	of	of	IN
18637	3310	11	property	property	NN
18637	3310	12	of	of	IN
18637	3310	13	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	3310	14	waters	water	NNS
18637	3310	15	and	and	CC
18637	3310	16	of	of	IN
18637	3310	17	the	the	DT
18637	3310	18	soil	soil	NN
18637	3310	19	under	under	IN
18637	3310	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3310	21	in	in	IN
18637	3310	22	the	the	DT
18637	3310	23	District	District	NNP
18637	3310	24	,	,	,
18637	3310	25	which	which	WDT
18637	3310	26	originally	originally	RB
18637	3310	27	had	have	VBD
18637	3310	28	been	be	VBN
18637	3310	29	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3310	30	by	by	IN
18637	3310	31	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	3310	32	I	I	NNP
18637	3310	33	,	,	,
18637	3310	34	King	King	NNP
18637	3310	35	of	of	IN
18637	3310	36	England	England	NNP
18637	3310	37	to	to	IN
18637	3310	38	the	the	DT
18637	3310	39	Lord	Lord	NNP
18637	3310	40	Proprietary	Proprietary	NNP
18637	3310	41	of	of	IN
18637	3310	42	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	3310	43	,	,	,
18637	3310	44	and	and	CC
18637	3310	45	to	to	TO
18637	3310	46	which	which	WDT
18637	3310	47	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	3310	48	succeeded	succeed	VBD
18637	3310	49	upon	upon	IN
18637	3310	50	the	the	DT
18637	3310	51	American	American	NNP
18637	3310	52	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
18637	3310	53	,	,	,
18637	3310	54	became	become	VBD
18637	3310	55	vested	vest	VBN
18637	3310	56	in	in	IN
18637	3310	57	the	the	DT
18637	3310	58	United	United	NNP
18637	3310	59	States	States	NNP
18637	3310	60	by	by	IN
18637	3310	61	the	the	DT
18637	3310	62	cession	cession	NN
18637	3310	63	from	from	IN
18637	3310	64	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	3310	65	.	.	.
18637	3311	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3311	2	1342	1342	CD
18637	3311	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3311	4	RETROCESSION	retrocession	NN
18637	3311	5	OF	of	IN
18637	3311	6	ALEXANDRIA	ALEXANDRIA	NNP
18637	3311	7	COUNTY	COUNTY	NNP
18637	3311	8	Originally	originally	RB
18637	3311	9	the	the	DT
18637	3311	10	District	District	NNP
18637	3311	11	of	of	IN
18637	3311	12	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3311	13	embraced	embrace	VBD
18637	3311	14	the	the	DT
18637	3311	15	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	3311	16	area	area	NN
18637	3311	17	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	3311	18	by	by	IN
18637	3311	19	the	the	DT
18637	3311	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3311	21	.	.	.
18637	3312	1	In	in	IN
18637	3312	2	1846	1846	CD
18637	3312	3	,	,	,
18637	3312	4	however	however	RB
18637	3312	5	,	,	,
18637	3312	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3312	7	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	3312	8	a	a	DT
18637	3312	9	referendum	referendum	NN
18637	3312	10	on	on	IN
18637	3312	11	the	the	DT
18637	3312	12	question	question	NN
18637	3312	13	of	of	IN
18637	3312	14	retroceding	retrocede	VBG
18637	3312	15	Alexandria	Alexandria	NNP
18637	3312	16	County	County	NNP
18637	3312	17	to	to	IN
18637	3312	18	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	3312	19	,	,	,
18637	3312	20	and	and	CC
18637	3312	21	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3312	22	that	that	IN
18637	3312	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3312	24	should	should	MD
18637	3312	25	be	be	VB
18637	3312	26	relinquished	relinquish	VBN
18637	3312	27	to	to	IN
18637	3312	28	that	that	DT
18637	3312	29	State	State	NNP
18637	3312	30	if	if	IN
18637	3312	31	a	a	DT
18637	3312	32	majority	majority	NN
18637	3312	33	of	of	IN
18637	3312	34	the	the	DT
18637	3312	35	voters	voter	NNS
18637	3312	36	in	in	IN
18637	3312	37	the	the	DT
18637	3312	38	county	county	NN
18637	3312	39	voted	vote	VBD
18637	3312	40	in	in	IN
18637	3312	41	favor	favor	NN
18637	3312	42	of	of	IN
18637	3312	43	the	the	DT
18637	3312	44	change	change	NN
18637	3312	45	.	.	.
18637	3313	1	The	the	DT
18637	3313	2	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	3313	3	was	be	VBD
18637	3313	4	approved	approve	VBN
18637	3313	5	,	,	,
18637	3313	6	whereupon	whereupon	NNS
18637	3313	7	,	,	,
18637	3313	8	without	without	IN
18637	3313	9	any	any	DT
18637	3313	10	further	further	JJ
18637	3313	11	action	action	NN
18637	3313	12	by	by	IN
18637	3313	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3313	14	,	,	,
18637	3313	15	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	3313	16	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3313	17	the	the	DT
18637	3313	18	county	county	NN
18637	3313	19	annexed	annex	VBN
18637	3313	20	and	and	CC
18637	3313	21	resumed	resume	VBD
18637	3313	22	full	full	JJ
18637	3313	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3313	24	over	over	IN
18637	3313	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3313	26	.	.	.
18637	3314	1	Thirty	thirty	CD
18637	3314	2	years	year	NNS
18637	3314	3	later	later	RB
18637	3314	4	,	,	,
18637	3314	5	in	in	IN
18637	3314	6	a	a	DT
18637	3314	7	suit	suit	NN
18637	3314	8	to	to	TO
18637	3314	9	recover	recover	VB
18637	3314	10	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3314	11	paid	pay	VBN
18637	3314	12	to	to	IN
18637	3314	13	the	the	DT
18637	3314	14	State	State	NNP
18637	3314	15	,	,	,
18637	3314	16	the	the	DT
18637	3314	17	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3314	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3314	19	called	call	VBD
18637	3314	20	the	the	DT
18637	3314	21	retrocession	retrocession	NN
18637	3314	22	"	"	``
18637	3314	23	a	a	DT
18637	3314	24	violation	violation	NN
18637	3314	25	of	of	IN
18637	3314	26	the	the	DT
18637	3314	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3314	28	"	"	''
18637	3314	29	but	but	CC
18637	3314	30	held	hold	VBD
18637	3314	31	that	that	IN
18637	3314	32	since	since	IN
18637	3314	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3314	34	had	have	VBD
18637	3314	35	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	3314	36	the	the	DT
18637	3314	37	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	3314	38	as	as	IN
18637	3314	39	a	a	DT
18637	3314	40	settled	settle	VBN
18637	3314	41	fact	fact	NN
18637	3314	42	,	,	,
18637	3314	43	a	a	DT
18637	3314	44	resident	resident	NN
18637	3314	45	of	of	IN
18637	3314	46	the	the	DT
18637	3314	47	county	county	NN
18637	3314	48	was	be	VBD
18637	3314	49	estopped	estop	VBN
18637	3314	50	from	from	IN
18637	3314	51	challenging	challenge	VBG
18637	3314	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3314	53	.	.	.
18637	3315	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3315	2	1343	1343	CD
18637	3315	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3315	4	CONTINUANCE	continuance	NN
18637	3315	5	OF	of	IN
18637	3315	6	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	3315	7	LAWS	LAWS	NNP
18637	3315	8	Under	under	IN
18637	3315	9	the	the	DT
18637	3315	10	act	act	NN
18637	3315	11	of	of	IN
18637	3315	12	July	July	NNP
18637	3315	13	16	16	CD
18637	3315	14	,	,	,
18637	3315	15	1790,[1344	1790,[1344	CD
18637	3315	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3315	17	which	which	WDT
18637	3315	18	provided	provide	VBD
18637	3315	19	for	for	IN
18637	3315	20	the	the	DT
18637	3315	21	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	3315	22	of	of	IN
18637	3315	23	the	the	DT
18637	3315	24	seat	seat	NN
18637	3315	25	of	of	IN
18637	3315	26	government	government	NN
18637	3315	27	,	,	,
18637	3315	28	State	state	NN
18637	3315	29	laws	law	NNS
18637	3315	30	were	be	VBD
18637	3315	31	continued	continue	VBN
18637	3315	32	in	in	IN
18637	3315	33	operation	operation	NN
18637	3315	34	until	until	IN
18637	3315	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3315	36	created	create	VBD
18637	3315	37	a	a	DT
18637	3315	38	government	government	NN
18637	3315	39	for	for	IN
18637	3315	40	the	the	DT
18637	3315	41	District	District	NNP
18637	3315	42	.	.	.
18637	3316	1	The	the	DT
18637	3316	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3316	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3316	4	intimated	intimate	VBD
18637	3316	5	that	that	IN
18637	3316	6	this	this	DT
18637	3316	7	was	be	VBD
18637	3316	8	"	"	``
18637	3316	9	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	3316	10	,	,	,
18637	3316	11	only	only	RB
18637	3316	12	declaratory	declaratory	RB
18637	3316	13	of	of	IN
18637	3316	14	a	a	DT
18637	3316	15	principle	principle	NN
18637	3316	16	which	which	WDT
18637	3316	17	would	would	MD
18637	3316	18	have	have	VB
18637	3316	19	been	be	VBN
18637	3316	20	in	in	IN
18637	3316	21	full	full	JJ
18637	3316	22	operation	operation	NN
18637	3316	23	without	without	IN
18637	3316	24	such	such	JJ
18637	3316	25	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	3316	26	.	.	.
18637	3317	1	"	"	``
18637	3317	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3317	3	1345	1345	CD
18637	3317	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3317	5	In	in	IN
18637	3317	6	1801	1801	CD
18637	3317	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3317	8	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3317	9	that	that	IN
18637	3317	10	the	the	DT
18637	3317	11	laws	law	NNS
18637	3317	12	of	of	IN
18637	3317	13	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	3317	14	and	and	CC
18637	3317	15	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	3317	16	"	"	''
18637	3317	17	as	as	IN
18637	3317	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3317	19	now	now	RB
18637	3317	20	exist	exist	VBP
18637	3317	21	,	,	,
18637	3317	22	shall	shall	MD
18637	3317	23	be	be	VB
18637	3317	24	and	and	CC
18637	3317	25	continue	continue	VB
18637	3317	26	in	in	IN
18637	3317	27	force	force	NN
18637	3317	28	"	"	''
18637	3317	29	in	in	IN
18637	3317	30	the	the	DT
18637	3317	31	respective	respective	JJ
18637	3317	32	portions	portion	NNS
18637	3317	33	of	of	IN
18637	3317	34	the	the	DT
18637	3317	35	District	District	NNP
18637	3317	36	ceded	cede	VBN
18637	3317	37	by	by	IN
18637	3317	38	those	those	DT
18637	3317	39	States	state	NNS
18637	3317	40	.	.	.
18637	3318	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3318	2	1346	1346	CD
18637	3318	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3318	4	The	the	DT
18637	3318	5	only	only	JJ
18637	3318	6	effect	effect	NN
18637	3318	7	of	of	IN
18637	3318	8	the	the	DT
18637	3318	9	cession	cession	NN
18637	3318	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	3318	11	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	3318	12	was	be	VBD
18637	3318	13	to	to	TO
18637	3318	14	terminate	terminate	VB
18637	3318	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3318	16	State	State	NNP
18637	3318	17	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	3318	18	and	and	CC
18637	3318	19	the	the	DT
18637	3318	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3318	21	of	of	IN
18637	3318	22	the	the	DT
18637	3318	23	State	State	NNP
18637	3318	24	governments	government	NNS
18637	3318	25	over	over	IN
18637	3318	26	them;[1347	them;[1347	NNP
18637	3318	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3318	28	contract	contract	NN
18637	3318	29	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	3318	30	were	be	VBD
18637	3318	31	not	not	RB
18637	3318	32	affected,[1348	affected,[1348	NNP
18637	3318	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3318	34	and	and	CC
18637	3318	35	liens	lien	VBZ
18637	3318	36	on	on	IN
18637	3318	37	property	property	NN
18637	3318	38	for	for	IN
18637	3318	39	debt	debt	NN
18637	3318	40	were	be	VBD
18637	3318	41	continued	continue	VBN
18637	3318	42	.	.	.
18637	3319	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3319	2	1349	1349	CD
18637	3319	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3319	4	STATUS	STATUS	NNP
18637	3319	5	OF	of	IN
18637	3319	6	THE	the	DT
18637	3319	7	DISTRICT	district	NN
18637	3319	8	TODAY	TODAY	NNP
18637	3319	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3319	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3319	11	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3319	12	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	3319	13	in	in	IN
18637	3319	14	the	the	DT
18637	3319	15	early	early	JJ
18637	3319	16	case	case	NN
18637	3319	17	of	of	IN
18637	3319	18	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	3319	19	_	_	NNP
18637	3319	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	3319	21	_	_	NNP
18637	3319	22	Ellzey[1350	Ellzey[1350	NNP
18637	3319	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3319	24	that	that	IN
18637	3319	25	the	the	DT
18637	3319	26	District	District	NNP
18637	3319	27	of	of	IN
18637	3319	28	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3319	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	3319	30	not	not	RB
18637	3319	31	a	a	DT
18637	3319	32	State	state	NN
18637	3319	33	within	within	IN
18637	3319	34	the	the	DT
18637	3319	35	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	3319	36	of	of	IN
18637	3319	37	the	the	DT
18637	3319	38	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	3319	39	of	of	IN
18637	3319	40	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	3319	41	clause	clause	NN
18637	3319	42	of	of	IN
18637	3319	43	article	article	NN
18637	3319	44	III	iii	CD
18637	3319	45	.	.	.
18637	3320	1	This	this	DT
18637	3320	2	view	view	NN
18637	3320	3	was	be	VBD
18637	3320	4	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	3320	5	adhered	adhere	VBN
18637	3320	6	to	to	IN
18637	3320	7	for	for	IN
18637	3320	8	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	3320	9	a	a	DT
18637	3320	10	century	century	NN
18637	3320	11	and	and	CC
18637	3320	12	a	a	DT
18637	3320	13	half	half	NN
18637	3320	14	in	in	IN
18637	3320	15	the	the	DT
18637	3320	16	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	3320	17	of	of	IN
18637	3320	18	later	later	JJ
18637	3320	19	acts	act	NNS
18637	3320	20	of	of	IN
18637	3320	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3320	22	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	3320	23	the	the	DT
18637	3320	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3320	25	of	of	IN
18637	3320	26	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3320	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	3320	28	.	.	.
18637	3321	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3321	2	1351	1351	CD
18637	3321	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3321	4	In	in	IN
18637	3321	5	1940	1940	CD
18637	3321	6	,	,	,
18637	3321	7	however	however	RB
18637	3321	8	,	,	,
18637	3321	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3321	10	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	3321	11	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	3321	12	those	those	DT
18637	3321	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	3321	14	to	to	TO
18637	3321	15	take	take	VB
18637	3321	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3321	17	of	of	IN
18637	3321	18	nonfederal	nonfederal	JJ
18637	3321	19	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	3321	20	between	between	IN
18637	3321	21	residents	resident	NNS
18637	3321	22	of	of	IN
18637	3321	23	the	the	DT
18637	3321	24	District	District	NNP
18637	3321	25	of	of	IN
18637	3321	26	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3321	27	and	and	CC
18637	3321	28	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	3321	29	of	of	IN
18637	3321	30	a	a	DT
18637	3321	31	State	state	NN
18637	3321	32	.	.	.
18637	3322	1	By	by	IN
18637	3322	2	a	a	DT
18637	3322	3	five	five	CD
18637	3322	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	3322	5	to	to	IN
18637	3322	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	3322	7	four	four	CD
18637	3322	8	decision	decision	NN
18637	3322	9	that	that	DT
18637	3322	10	statute	statute	NN
18637	3322	11	was	be	VBD
18637	3322	12	held	hold	VBN
18637	3322	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3322	14	,	,	,
18637	3322	15	but	but	CC
18637	3322	16	the	the	DT
18637	3322	17	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	3322	18	who	who	WP
18637	3322	19	voted	vote	VBD
18637	3322	20	to	to	TO
18637	3322	21	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	3322	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3322	23	were	be	VBD
18637	3322	24	not	not	RB
18637	3322	25	in	in	IN
18637	3322	26	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3322	27	as	as	IN
18637	3322	28	to	to	IN
18637	3322	29	the	the	DT
18637	3322	30	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	3322	31	of	of	IN
18637	3322	32	the	the	DT
18637	3322	33	decision	decision	NN
18637	3322	34	.	.	.
18637	3323	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3323	2	1352	1352	CD
18637	3323	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3323	4	Three	three	CD
18637	3323	5	found	find	VBD
18637	3323	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3323	7	to	to	TO
18637	3323	8	be	be	VB
18637	3323	9	an	an	DT
18637	3323	10	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	3323	11	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3323	12	of	of	IN
18637	3323	13	the	the	DT
18637	3323	14	power	power	NN
18637	3323	15	of	of	IN
18637	3323	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3323	17	to	to	TO
18637	3323	18	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	3323	19	for	for	IN
18637	3323	20	the	the	DT
18637	3323	21	District	District	NNP
18637	3323	22	of	of	IN
18637	3323	23	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3323	24	without	without	IN
18637	3323	25	reference	reference	NN
18637	3323	26	to	to	IN
18637	3323	27	article	article	NN
18637	3323	28	III	iii	CD
18637	3323	29	.	.	.
18637	3324	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3324	2	1353	1353	CD
18637	3324	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3324	4	Six	six	CD
18637	3324	5	members	member	NNS
18637	3324	6	of	of	IN
18637	3324	7	the	the	DT
18637	3324	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3324	9	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	3324	10	this	this	DT
18637	3324	11	theory	theory	NN
18637	3324	12	,	,	,
18637	3324	13	but	but	CC
18637	3324	14	two	two	CD
18637	3324	15	of	of	IN
18637	3324	16	the	the	DT
18637	3324	17	six	six	CD
18637	3324	18	joined	join	VBN
18637	3324	19	in	in	IN
18637	3324	20	upholding	uphold	VBG
18637	3324	21	the	the	DT
18637	3324	22	act	act	NN
18637	3324	23	on	on	IN
18637	3324	24	another	another	DT
18637	3324	25	ground	ground	NN
18637	3324	26	which	which	WDT
18637	3324	27	seven	seven	CD
18637	3324	28	of	of	IN
18637	3324	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3324	30	brethren	brother	NNS
18637	3324	31	considered	consider	VBD
18637	3324	32	untenable,--namely	untenable,--namely	RB
18637	3324	33	,	,	,
18637	3324	34	that	that	IN
18637	3324	35	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	3324	36	_	_	NNP
18637	3324	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	3324	38	_	_	NNP
18637	3324	39	Ellzey	Ellzey	NNP
18637	3324	40	was	be	VBD
18637	3324	41	erroneously	erroneously	RB
18637	3324	42	decided	decide	VBN
18637	3324	43	and	and	CC
18637	3324	44	that	that	IN
18637	3324	45	the	the	DT
18637	3324	46	District	District	NNP
18637	3324	47	of	of	IN
18637	3324	48	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3324	49	should	should	MD
18637	3324	50	be	be	VB
18637	3324	51	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	3324	52	to	to	TO
18637	3324	53	be	be	VB
18637	3324	54	a	a	DT
18637	3324	55	"	"	``
18637	3324	56	State	state	NN
18637	3324	57	"	"	''
18637	3324	58	within	within	IN
18637	3324	59	the	the	DT
18637	3324	60	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	3324	61	of	of	IN
18637	3324	62	article	article	NN
18637	3324	63	III	III	NNP
18637	3324	64	,	,	,
18637	3324	65	section	section	NN
18637	3324	66	2	2	CD
18637	3324	67	.	.	.
18637	3325	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3325	2	1354	1354	CD
18637	3325	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3325	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3325	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	3325	6	not	not	RB
18637	3325	7	disputed	dispute	VBN
18637	3325	8	that	that	IN
18637	3325	9	the	the	DT
18637	3325	10	District	District	NNP
18637	3325	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	3325	12	a	a	DT
18637	3325	13	part	part	NN
18637	3325	14	of	of	IN
18637	3325	15	"	"	``
18637	3325	16	the	the	DT
18637	3325	17	United	United	NNP
18637	3325	18	States	States	NNP
18637	3325	19	,	,	,
18637	3325	20	"	"	''
18637	3325	21	and	and	CC
18637	3325	22	that	that	IN
18637	3325	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3325	24	residents	resident	NNS
18637	3325	25	are	be	VBP
18637	3325	26	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	3325	27	to	to	IN
18637	3325	28	the	the	DT
18637	3325	29	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	3325	30	of	of	IN
18637	3325	31	trial	trial	NN
18637	3325	32	by	by	IN
18637	3325	33	jury	jury	NN
18637	3325	34	,	,	,
18637	3325	35	whether	whether	IN
18637	3325	36	in	in	IN
18637	3325	37	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3325	38	or	or	CC
18637	3325	39	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	3325	40	cases,[1355	cases,[1355	NN
18637	3325	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3325	42	and	and	CC
18637	3325	43	of	of	IN
18637	3325	44	presentment	presentment	NN
18637	3325	45	by	by	IN
18637	3325	46	a	a	DT
18637	3325	47	grand	grand	JJ
18637	3325	48	jury	jury	NN
18637	3325	49	.	.	.
18637	3326	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3326	2	1356	1356	CD
18637	3326	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3326	4	Legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3326	5	which	which	WDT
18637	3326	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	3326	7	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	3326	8	of	of	IN
18637	3326	9	the	the	DT
18637	3326	10	rights	right	NNS
18637	3326	11	of	of	IN
18637	3326	12	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	3326	13	and	and	CC
18637	3326	14	property	property	NN
18637	3326	15	in	in	IN
18637	3326	16	the	the	DT
18637	3326	17	District	District	NNP
18637	3326	18	must	must	MD
18637	3326	19	find	find	VB
18637	3326	20	justification	justification	NN
18637	3326	21	in	in	IN
18637	3326	22	facts	fact	NNS
18637	3326	23	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	3326	24	to	to	TO
18637	3326	25	support	support	VB
18637	3326	26	like	like	IN
18637	3326	27	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3326	28	by	by	IN
18637	3326	29	a	a	DT
18637	3326	30	State	state	NN
18637	3326	31	in	in	IN
18637	3326	32	the	the	DT
18637	3326	33	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3326	34	of	of	IN
18637	3326	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3326	36	police	police	NN
18637	3326	37	power	power	NN
18637	3326	38	.	.	.
18637	3327	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3327	2	1357	1357	CD
18637	3327	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3327	4	LEGISLATIVE	legislative	JJ
18637	3327	5	POWER	power	NN
18637	3327	6	OVER	over	IN
18637	3327	7	DISTRICT	district	NN
18637	3327	8	OF	of	IN
18637	3327	9	COLUMBIA	COLUMBIA	NNP
18637	3327	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3327	11	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	3327	12	over	over	IN
18637	3327	13	the	the	DT
18637	3327	14	District	District	NNP
18637	3327	15	of	of	IN
18637	3327	16	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3327	17	the	the	DT
18637	3327	18	blended	blend	VBN
18637	3327	19	powers	power	NNS
18637	3327	20	of	of	IN
18637	3327	21	a	a	DT
18637	3327	22	local	local	JJ
18637	3327	23	and	and	CC
18637	3327	24	national	national	JJ
18637	3327	25	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3327	26	.	.	.
18637	3328	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3328	2	1358	1358	CD
18637	3328	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3328	4	Even	even	RB
18637	3328	5	when	when	WRB
18637	3328	6	legislating	legislate	VBG
18637	3328	7	for	for	IN
18637	3328	8	the	the	DT
18637	3328	9	District	District	NNP
18637	3328	10	,	,	,
18637	3328	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3328	12	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	3328	13	the	the	DT
18637	3328	14	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3328	15	of	of	IN
18637	3328	16	the	the	DT
18637	3328	17	Union	Union	NNP
18637	3328	18	,	,	,
18637	3328	19	with	with	IN
18637	3328	20	the	the	DT
18637	3328	21	result	result	NN
18637	3328	22	that	that	IN
18637	3328	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3328	24	may	may	MD
18637	3328	25	give	give	VB
18637	3328	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3328	27	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	3328	28	nation	nation	NN
18637	3328	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	3328	30	wide	wide	JJ
18637	3328	31	operations	operation	NNS
18637	3328	32	so	so	RB
18637	3328	33	far	far	RB
18637	3328	34	as	as	IN
18637	3328	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	3328	36	"	"	``
18637	3328	37	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3328	38	and	and	CC
18637	3328	39	proper	proper	JJ
18637	3328	40	"	"	''
18637	3328	41	in	in	IN
18637	3328	42	order	order	NN
18637	3328	43	to	to	TO
18637	3328	44	make	make	VB
18637	3328	45	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3328	46	locally	locally	RB
18637	3328	47	effective	effective	JJ
18637	3328	48	.	.	.
18637	3329	1	As	as	IN
18637	3329	2	was	be	VBD
18637	3329	3	pointed	point	VBN
18637	3329	4	out	out	RP
18637	3329	5	in	in	IN
18637	3329	6	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	3329	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3329	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	3329	9	_	_	NNP
18637	3329	10	Virginia,[1359	Virginia,[1359	NNP
18637	3329	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3329	12	if	if	IN
18637	3329	13	a	a	DT
18637	3329	14	felon	felon	NN
18637	3329	15	escapes	escape	VBZ
18637	3329	16	from	from	IN
18637	3329	17	the	the	DT
18637	3329	18	State	State	NNP
18637	3329	19	in	in	IN
18637	3329	20	which	which	WDT
18637	3329	21	the	the	DT
18637	3329	22	crime	crime	NN
18637	3329	23	was	be	VBD
18637	3329	24	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3329	25	,	,	,
18637	3329	26	the	the	DT
18637	3329	27	government	government	NN
18637	3329	28	of	of	IN
18637	3329	29	such	such	JJ
18637	3329	30	State	State	NNP
18637	3329	31	can	can	MD
18637	3329	32	not	not	RB
18637	3329	33	pursue	pursue	VB
18637	3329	34	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3329	35	into	into	IN
18637	3329	36	another	another	DT
18637	3329	37	State	state	NN
18637	3329	38	and	and	CC
18637	3329	39	there	there	RB
18637	3329	40	apprehend	apprehend	VB
18637	3329	41	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3329	42	,	,	,
18637	3329	43	"	"	''
18637	3329	44	but	but	CC
18637	3329	45	must	must	MD
18637	3329	46	demand	demand	VB
18637	3329	47	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3329	48	from	from	IN
18637	3329	49	the	the	DT
18637	3329	50	executive	executive	JJ
18637	3329	51	power	power	NN
18637	3329	52	of	of	IN
18637	3329	53	that	that	DT
18637	3329	54	other	other	JJ
18637	3329	55	State	State	NNP
18637	3329	56	.	.	.
18637	3329	57	"	"	''
18637	3330	1	On	on	IN
18637	3330	2	the	the	DT
18637	3330	3	other	other	JJ
18637	3330	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	3330	5	,	,	,
18637	3330	6	a	a	DT
18637	3330	7	felon	felon	NN
18637	3330	8	escaping	escape	VBG
18637	3330	9	from	from	IN
18637	3330	10	the	the	DT
18637	3330	11	District	District	NNP
18637	3330	12	of	of	IN
18637	3330	13	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3330	14	or	or	CC
18637	3330	15	any	any	DT
18637	3330	16	other	other	JJ
18637	3330	17	place	place	NN
18637	3330	18	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3330	19	to	to	IN
18637	3330	20	the	the	DT
18637	3330	21	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3330	22	power	power	NN
18637	3330	23	of	of	IN
18637	3330	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3330	25	,	,	,
18637	3330	26	may	may	MD
18637	3330	27	be	be	VB
18637	3330	28	apprehended	apprehend	VBN
18637	3330	29	by	by	IN
18637	3330	30	the	the	DT
18637	3330	31	National	National	NNP
18637	3330	32	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3330	33	anywhere	anywhere	RB
18637	3330	34	in	in	IN
18637	3330	35	the	the	DT
18637	3330	36	United	United	NNP
18637	3330	37	States	States	NNP
18637	3330	38	.	.	.
18637	3331	1	"	"	``
18637	3331	2	And	and	CC
18637	3331	3	the	the	DT
18637	3331	4	reason	reason	NN
18637	3331	5	,	,	,
18637	3331	6	"	"	''
18637	3331	7	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3331	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3331	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3331	10	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3331	11	,	,	,
18637	3331	12	"	"	``
18637	3331	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	3331	14	,	,	,
18637	3331	15	that	that	IN
18637	3331	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3331	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	3331	18	not	not	RB
18637	3331	19	a	a	DT
18637	3331	20	local	local	JJ
18637	3331	21	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3331	22	,	,	,
18637	3331	23	but	but	CC
18637	3331	24	exercises	exercise	VBZ
18637	3331	25	this	this	DT
18637	3331	26	particular	particular	JJ
18637	3331	27	power	power	NN
18637	3331	28	,	,	,
18637	3331	29	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3331	30	of	of	IN
18637	3331	31	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3331	32	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3331	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3331	34	,	,	,
18637	3331	35	like	like	IN
18637	3331	36	all	all	DT
18637	3331	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3331	38	other	other	JJ
18637	3331	39	powers	power	NNS
18637	3331	40	,	,	,
18637	3331	41	in	in	IN
18637	3331	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3331	43	high	high	JJ
18637	3331	44	character	character	NN
18637	3331	45	,	,	,
18637	3331	46	as	as	IN
18637	3331	47	the	the	DT
18637	3331	48	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3331	49	of	of	IN
18637	3331	50	the	the	DT
18637	3331	51	Union	Union	NNP
18637	3331	52	.	.	.
18637	3332	1	"	"	``
18637	3332	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3332	3	1360	1360	CD
18637	3332	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3332	5	TAXATION	taxation	NN
18637	3332	6	IN	in	IN
18637	3332	7	THE	the	DT
18637	3332	8	DISTRICT	DISTRICT	NNP
18637	3332	9	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	3332	10	and	and	CC
18637	3332	11	property	property	NN
18637	3332	12	within	within	IN
18637	3332	13	the	the	DT
18637	3332	14	District	District	NNP
18637	3332	15	of	of	IN
18637	3332	16	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3332	17	are	be	VBP
18637	3332	18	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3332	19	to	to	IN
18637	3332	20	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3332	21	by	by	IN
18637	3332	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3332	23	under	under	IN
18637	3332	24	both	both	CC
18637	3332	25	the	the	DT
18637	3332	26	first	first	JJ
18637	3332	27	and	and	CC
18637	3332	28	seventeenth	seventeenth	JJ
18637	3332	29	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	3332	30	of	of	IN
18637	3332	31	this	this	DT
18637	3332	32	section	section	NN
18637	3332	33	.	.	.
18637	3333	1	A	a	DT
18637	3333	2	general	general	JJ
18637	3333	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	3333	4	levied	levy	VBN
18637	3333	5	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	3333	6	the	the	DT
18637	3333	7	United	United	NNP
18637	3333	8	States	States	NNP
18637	3333	9	may	may	MD
18637	3333	10	be	be	VB
18637	3333	11	applied	apply	VBN
18637	3333	12	to	to	IN
18637	3333	13	the	the	DT
18637	3333	14	District	District	NNP
18637	3333	15	of	of	IN
18637	3333	16	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3333	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	3333	18	the	the	DT
18637	3333	19	same	same	JJ
18637	3333	20	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	3333	21	as	as	IN
18637	3333	22	elsewhere;--e.g	elsewhere;--e.g	NNP
18637	3333	23	.	.	.
18637	3333	24	,	,	,
18637	3333	25	if	if	IN
18637	3333	26	a	a	DT
18637	3333	27	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3333	28	tax	tax	NN
18637	3333	29	,	,	,
18637	3333	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3333	31	must	must	MD
18637	3333	32	be	be	VB
18637	3333	33	levied	levy	VBN
18637	3333	34	in	in	IN
18637	3333	35	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	3333	36	to	to	IN
18637	3333	37	the	the	DT
18637	3333	38	census	census	NN
18637	3333	39	.	.	.
18637	3334	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3334	2	1361	1361	CD
18637	3334	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3334	4	But	but	CC
18637	3334	5	in	in	IN
18637	3334	6	laying	lay	VBG
18637	3334	7	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3334	8	for	for	IN
18637	3334	9	District	District	NNP
18637	3334	10	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	3334	11	only	only	RB
18637	3334	12	,	,	,
18637	3334	13	"	"	''
18637	3334	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3334	15	,	,	,
18637	3334	16	like	like	IN
18637	3334	17	any	any	DT
18637	3334	18	State	State	NNP
18637	3334	19	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3334	20	unrestricted	unrestricte	VBN
18637	3334	21	by	by	IN
18637	3334	22	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3334	23	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	3334	24	,	,	,
18637	3334	25	may	may	MD
18637	3334	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3334	27	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	3334	28	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	3334	29	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	3334	30	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3334	31	classes	class	NNS
18637	3334	32	of	of	IN
18637	3334	33	property	property	NN
18637	3334	34	from	from	IN
18637	3334	35	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3334	36	,	,	,
18637	3334	37	or	or	CC
18637	3334	38	may	may	MD
18637	3334	39	tax	tax	VB
18637	3334	40	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3334	41	at	at	IN
18637	3334	42	a	a	DT
18637	3334	43	lower	low	JJR
18637	3334	44	rate	rate	NN
18637	3334	45	than	than	IN
18637	3334	46	other	other	JJ
18637	3334	47	property	property	NN
18637	3334	48	.	.	.
18637	3335	1	"	"	``
18637	3335	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3335	3	1362	1362	CD
18637	3335	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3335	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3335	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	3335	7	no	no	DT
18637	3335	8	impediment	impediment	NN
18637	3335	9	to	to	IN
18637	3335	10	the	the	DT
18637	3335	11	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3335	12	of	of	IN
18637	3335	13	either	either	DT
18637	3335	14	power	power	NN
18637	3335	15	that	that	WDT
18637	3335	16	residents	resident	NNS
18637	3335	17	of	of	IN
18637	3335	18	the	the	DT
18637	3335	19	District	District	NNP
18637	3335	20	lack	lack	VBP
18637	3335	21	the	the	DT
18637	3335	22	suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	3335	23	and	and	CC
18637	3335	24	have	have	VBP
18637	3335	25	politically	politically	RB
18637	3335	26	no	no	DT
18637	3335	27	voice	voice	NN
18637	3335	28	in	in	IN
18637	3335	29	the	the	DT
18637	3335	30	expenditure	expenditure	NN
18637	3335	31	of	of	IN
18637	3335	32	the	the	DT
18637	3335	33	money	money	NN
18637	3335	34	raised	raise	VBN
18637	3335	35	by	by	IN
18637	3335	36	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3335	37	.	.	.
18637	3336	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3336	2	1363	1363	CD
18637	3336	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3336	4	DELEGATION	delegation	NN
18637	3336	5	OF	of	IN
18637	3336	6	LEGISLATIVE	legislative	JJ
18637	3336	7	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	3336	8	TO	to	IN
18637	3336	9	MUNICIPAL	municipal	VB
18637	3336	10	OFFICERS	OFFICERS	NNP
18637	3336	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3336	12	may	may	MD
18637	3336	13	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	3336	14	to	to	IN
18637	3336	15	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	3336	16	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	3336	17	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3336	18	functions	function	NNS
18637	3336	19	which	which	WDT
18637	3336	20	are	be	VBP
18637	3336	21	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	3336	22	local	local	JJ
18637	3336	23	in	in	IN
18637	3336	24	character	character	NN
18637	3336	25	.	.	.
18637	3337	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3337	2	1364	1364	CD
18637	3337	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3337	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3337	5	may	may	MD
18637	3337	6	confer	confer	VB
18637	3337	7	upon	upon	IN
18637	3337	8	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3337	9	the	the	DT
18637	3337	10	power	power	NN
18637	3337	11	to	to	TO
18637	3337	12	improve	improve	VB
18637	3337	13	or	or	CC
18637	3337	14	repair	repair	VB
18637	3337	15	streets	street	NNS
18637	3337	16	,	,	,
18637	3337	17	to	to	TO
18637	3337	18	assess	assess	VB
18637	3337	19	adjacent	adjacent	JJ
18637	3337	20	property	property	NN
18637	3337	21	therefor,[1365	therefor,[1365	NNP
18637	3337	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3337	23	and	and	CC
18637	3337	24	to	to	TO
18637	3337	25	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	3337	26	public	public	JJ
18637	3337	27	markets	market	NNS
18637	3337	28	.	.	.
18637	3338	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3338	2	1366	1366	CD
18637	3338	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3338	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3338	5	may	may	MD
18637	3338	6	confirm	confirm	VB
18637	3338	7	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	3338	8	previously	previously	RB
18637	3338	9	made	make	VBN
18637	3338	10	by	by	IN
18637	3338	11	the	the	DT
18637	3338	12	District	District	NNP
18637	3338	13	government	government	NN
18637	3338	14	without	without	IN
18637	3338	15	authority	authority	NN
18637	3338	16	of	of	IN
18637	3338	17	law	law	NN
18637	3338	18	.	.	.
18637	3339	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3339	2	1367	1367	CD
18637	3339	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3339	4	But	but	CC
18637	3339	5	in	in	IN
18637	3339	6	Stoutenburgh	Stoutenburgh	NNP
18637	3339	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3339	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	3339	9	_	_	NNP
18637	3339	10	Hennick,[1368	hennick,[1368	CD
18637	3339	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3339	12	the	the	DT
18637	3339	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3339	14	held	hold	VBD
18637	3339	15	that	that	IN
18637	3339	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3339	17	would	would	MD
18637	3339	18	not	not	RB
18637	3339	19	,	,	,
18637	3339	20	and	and	CC
18637	3339	21	did	do	VBD
18637	3339	22	not	not	RB
18637	3339	23	intend	intend	VB
18637	3339	24	to	to	TO
18637	3339	25	,	,	,
18637	3339	26	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	3339	27	to	to	IN
18637	3339	28	the	the	DT
18637	3339	29	District	District	NNP
18637	3339	30	the	the	DT
18637	3339	31	power	power	NN
18637	3339	32	to	to	TO
18637	3339	33	impose	impose	VB
18637	3339	34	a	a	DT
18637	3339	35	license	license	NN
18637	3339	36	tax	tax	NN
18637	3339	37	on	on	IN
18637	3339	38	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	3339	39	agents	agent	NNS
18637	3339	40	who	who	WP
18637	3339	41	offered	offer	VBD
18637	3339	42	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	3339	43	for	for	IN
18637	3339	44	sale	sale	NN
18637	3339	45	by	by	IN
18637	3339	46	sample	sample	NN
18637	3339	47	,	,	,
18637	3339	48	since	since	IN
18637	3339	49	such	such	PDT
18637	3339	50	a	a	DT
18637	3339	51	license	license	NN
18637	3339	52	amounted	amount	VBD
18637	3339	53	to	to	IN
18637	3339	54	a	a	DT
18637	3339	55	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	3339	56	of	of	IN
18637	3339	57	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	3339	58	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	3339	59	.	.	.
18637	3340	1	COURTS	court	NNS
18637	3340	2	OF	of	IN
18637	3340	3	THE	the	DT
18637	3340	4	DISTRICT	DISTRICT	NNS
18637	3340	5	In	in	IN
18637	3340	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3340	7	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	3340	8	as	as	IN
18637	3340	9	a	a	DT
18637	3340	10	local	local	JJ
18637	3340	11	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3340	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3340	13	may	may	MD
18637	3340	14	create	create	VB
18637	3340	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	3340	16	for	for	IN
18637	3340	17	the	the	DT
18637	3340	18	District	District	NNP
18637	3340	19	of	of	IN
18637	3340	20	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3340	21	and	and	CC
18637	3340	22	may	may	MD
18637	3340	23	confer	confer	VB
18637	3340	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	3340	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3340	26	powers	power	NNS
18637	3340	27	and	and	CC
18637	3340	28	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3340	29	which	which	WDT
18637	3340	30	lie	lie	VBP
18637	3340	31	outside	outside	IN
18637	3340	32	the	the	DT
18637	3340	33	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3340	34	power	power	NN
18637	3340	35	vested	vest	VBN
18637	3340	36	in	in	IN
18637	3340	37	"	"	``
18637	3340	38	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3340	39	"	"	''
18637	3340	40	courts	court	NNS
18637	3340	41	.	.	.
18637	3341	1	On	on	IN
18637	3341	2	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	3341	3	from	from	IN
18637	3341	4	an	an	DT
18637	3341	5	order	order	NN
18637	3341	6	of	of	IN
18637	3341	7	the	the	DT
18637	3341	8	District	District	NNP
18637	3341	9	Public	Public	NNP
18637	3341	10	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	3341	11	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	3341	12	,	,	,
18637	3341	13	a	a	DT
18637	3341	14	court	court	NN
18637	3341	15	for	for	IN
18637	3341	16	the	the	DT
18637	3341	17	District	District	NNP
18637	3341	18	of	of	IN
18637	3341	19	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3341	20	may	may	MD
18637	3341	21	be	be	VB
18637	3341	22	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	3341	23	to	to	TO
18637	3341	24	modify	modify	VB
18637	3341	25	valuations	valuation	NNS
18637	3341	26	,	,	,
18637	3341	27	rates	rate	NNS
18637	3341	28	and	and	CC
18637	3341	29	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	3341	30	established	establish	VBN
18637	3341	31	by	by	IN
18637	3341	32	the	the	DT
18637	3341	33	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	3341	34	and	and	CC
18637	3341	35	to	to	TO
18637	3341	36	make	make	VB
18637	3341	37	such	such	JJ
18637	3341	38	orders	order	NNS
18637	3341	39	as	as	IN
18637	3341	40	in	in	IN
18637	3341	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3341	42	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	3341	43	the	the	DT
18637	3341	44	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	3341	45	should	should	MD
18637	3341	46	have	have	VB
18637	3341	47	made	make	VBN
18637	3341	48	.	.	.
18637	3342	1	But	but	CC
18637	3342	2	inasmuch	inasmuch	VB
18637	3342	3	as	as	IN
18637	3342	4	the	the	DT
18637	3342	5	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	3342	6	of	of	IN
18637	3342	7	such	such	JJ
18637	3342	8	orders	order	NNS
18637	3342	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	3342	10	a	a	DT
18637	3342	11	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3342	12	as	as	IN
18637	3342	13	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	3342	14	from	from	IN
18637	3342	15	a	a	DT
18637	3342	16	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3342	17	function	function	NN
18637	3342	18	,	,	,
18637	3342	19	the	the	DT
18637	3342	20	provision	provision	NN
18637	3342	21	for	for	IN
18637	3342	22	an	an	DT
18637	3342	23	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	3342	24	from	from	IN
18637	3342	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3342	26	to	to	IN
18637	3342	27	the	the	DT
18637	3342	28	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3342	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3342	30	was	be	VBD
18637	3342	31	held	hold	VBN
18637	3342	32	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	3342	33	.	.	.
18637	3343	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3343	2	1369	1369	CD
18637	3343	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3343	4	Despite	despite	IN
18637	3343	5	the	the	DT
18637	3343	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	3343	7	that	that	IN
18637	3343	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3343	9	,	,	,
18637	3343	10	acting	act	VBG
18637	3343	11	under	under	IN
18637	3343	12	this	this	DT
18637	3343	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	3343	14	,	,	,
18637	3343	15	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	3343	16	nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	3343	17	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3343	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	3343	19	the	the	DT
18637	3343	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3343	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3343	22	and	and	CC
18637	3343	23	the	the	DT
18637	3343	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3343	25	of	of	IN
18637	3343	26	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	3343	27	for	for	IN
18637	3343	28	the	the	DT
18637	3343	29	District	District	NNP
18637	3343	30	of	of	IN
18637	3343	31	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3343	32	,	,	,
18637	3343	33	those	those	DT
18637	3343	34	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	3343	35	were	be	VBD
18637	3343	36	held	hold	VBN
18637	3343	37	to	to	TO
18637	3343	38	be	be	VB
18637	3343	39	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3343	40	courts	court	NNS
18637	3343	41	,	,	,
18637	3343	42	established	establish	VBN
18637	3343	43	under	under	IN
18637	3343	44	article	article	NN
18637	3343	45	III	iii	CD
18637	3343	46	,	,	,
18637	3343	47	with	with	IN
18637	3343	48	the	the	DT
18637	3343	49	result	result	NN
18637	3343	50	that	that	IN
18637	3343	51	the	the	DT
18637	3343	52	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	3343	53	of	of	IN
18637	3343	54	the	the	DT
18637	3343	55	judges	judge	NNS
18637	3343	56	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	3343	57	may	may	MD
18637	3343	58	not	not	RB
18637	3343	59	be	be	VB
18637	3343	60	diminished	diminish	VBN
18637	3343	61	during	during	IN
18637	3343	62	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3343	63	continuance	continuance	NN
18637	3343	64	in	in	IN
18637	3343	65	office	office	NN
18637	3343	66	.	.	.
18637	3344	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3344	2	1370	1370	CD
18637	3344	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3344	4	Since	since	IN
18637	3344	5	the	the	DT
18637	3344	6	courts	court	NNS
18637	3344	7	established	establish	VBN
18637	3344	8	for	for	IN
18637	3344	9	the	the	DT
18637	3344	10	District	District	NNP
18637	3344	11	are	be	VBP
18637	3344	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	3344	13	of	of	IN
18637	3344	14	the	the	DT
18637	3344	15	United	United	NNP
18637	3344	16	States	States	NNP
18637	3344	17	,	,	,
18637	3344	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3344	19	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	3344	20	stand	stand	VBP
18637	3344	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	3344	22	the	the	DT
18637	3344	23	same	same	JJ
18637	3344	24	footing	footing	NN
18637	3344	25	,	,	,
18637	3344	26	so	so	RB
18637	3344	27	far	far	RB
18637	3344	28	as	as	IN
18637	3344	29	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	3344	30	the	the	DT
18637	3344	31	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	3344	32	created	create	VBN
18637	3344	33	by	by	IN
18637	3344	34	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3344	35	,	,	,
18637	3344	36	as	as	IN
18637	3344	37	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	3344	38	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	3344	39	of	of	IN
18637	3344	40	the	the	DT
18637	3344	41	States	States	NNPS
18637	3344	42	,	,	,
18637	3344	43	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	3344	44	rendered	render	VBN
18637	3344	45	and	and	CC
18637	3344	46	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	3344	47	sought	seek	VBD
18637	3344	48	to	to	TO
18637	3344	49	be	be	VB
18637	3344	50	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	3344	51	.	.	.
18637	3345	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3345	2	1371	1371	CD
18637	3345	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3345	4	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	3345	5	Over	over	IN
18637	3345	6	Places	Places	NNPS
18637	3345	7	Purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	3345	8	"	"	``
18637	3345	9	PLACES	place	NNS
18637	3345	10	"	"	''
18637	3345	11	This	this	DT
18637	3345	12	clause	clause	NN
18637	3345	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	3345	14	been	be	VBN
18637	3345	15	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	3345	16	construed	construe	VBN
18637	3345	17	to	to	TO
18637	3345	18	cover	cover	VB
18637	3345	19	all	all	DT
18637	3345	20	structures	structure	NNS
18637	3345	21	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3345	22	for	for	IN
18637	3345	23	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	3345	24	on	on	IN
18637	3345	25	the	the	DT
18637	3345	26	business	business	NN
18637	3345	27	of	of	IN
18637	3345	28	the	the	DT
18637	3345	29	National	National	NNP
18637	3345	30	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3345	31	.	.	.
18637	3346	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3346	2	1372	1372	CD
18637	3346	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3346	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3346	5	includes	include	VBZ
18637	3346	6	post	post	NN
18637	3346	7	offices,[1373	offices,[1373	NNP
18637	3346	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3346	9	a	a	DT
18637	3346	10	hospital	hospital	NN
18637	3346	11	and	and	CC
18637	3346	12	a	a	DT
18637	3346	13	hotel	hotel	NN
18637	3346	14	located	locate	VBN
18637	3346	15	in	in	IN
18637	3346	16	a	a	DT
18637	3346	17	national	national	JJ
18637	3346	18	park,[1374	park,[1374	NNP
18637	3346	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3346	20	and	and	CC
18637	3346	21	locks	lock	NNS
18637	3346	22	and	and	CC
18637	3346	23	dams	dam	NNS
18637	3346	24	for	for	IN
18637	3346	25	the	the	DT
18637	3346	26	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	3346	27	of	of	IN
18637	3346	28	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	3346	29	.	.	.
18637	3347	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3347	2	1375	1375	CD
18637	3347	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3347	4	But	but	CC
18637	3347	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3347	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	3347	7	not	not	RB
18637	3347	8	cover	cover	VB
18637	3347	9	lands	land	NNS
18637	3347	10	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	3347	11	for	for	IN
18637	3347	12	forests	forest	NNS
18637	3347	13	,	,	,
18637	3347	14	parks	park	NNS
18637	3347	15	,	,	,
18637	3347	16	ranges	range	VBZ
18637	3347	17	,	,	,
18637	3347	18	wild	wild	JJ
18637	3347	19	life	life	NN
18637	3347	20	sanctuaries	sanctuary	NNS
18637	3347	21	or	or	CC
18637	3347	22	flood	flood	NN
18637	3347	23	control	control	NN
18637	3347	24	.	.	.
18637	3348	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3348	2	1376	1376	CD
18637	3348	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3348	4	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	3348	5	the	the	DT
18637	3348	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3348	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3348	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	3348	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	3348	10	that	that	IN
18637	3348	11	a	a	DT
18637	3348	12	State	state	NN
18637	3348	13	may	may	MD
18637	3348	14	convey	convey	VB
18637	3348	15	,	,	,
18637	3348	16	and	and	CC
18637	3348	17	that	that	IN
18637	3348	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3348	19	may	may	MD
18637	3348	20	accept	accept	VB
18637	3348	21	,	,	,
18637	3348	22	either	either	CC
18637	3348	23	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3348	24	or	or	CC
18637	3348	25	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	3348	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3348	27	over	over	IN
18637	3348	28	property	property	NN
18637	3348	29	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	3348	30	within	within	IN
18637	3348	31	the	the	DT
18637	3348	32	geographical	geographical	JJ
18637	3348	33	limits	limit	NNS
18637	3348	34	of	of	IN
18637	3348	35	a	a	DT
18637	3348	36	State	State	NNP
18637	3348	37	,	,	,
18637	3348	38	for	for	IN
18637	3348	39	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	3348	40	other	other	JJ
18637	3348	41	than	than	IN
18637	3348	42	those	those	DT
18637	3348	43	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	3348	44	in	in	IN
18637	3348	45	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3348	46	17	17	CD
18637	3348	47	.	.	.
18637	3349	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3349	2	1377	1377	CD
18637	3349	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3349	4	After	after	IN
18637	3349	5	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3349	6	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3349	7	over	over	IN
18637	3349	8	lands	land	NNS
18637	3349	9	within	within	IN
18637	3349	10	a	a	DT
18637	3349	11	State	state	NN
18637	3349	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	3349	13	been	be	VBN
18637	3349	14	ceded	cede	VBN
18637	3349	15	to	to	IN
18637	3349	16	the	the	DT
18637	3349	17	United	United	NNP
18637	3349	18	States	States	NNP
18637	3349	19	,	,	,
18637	3349	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3349	21	alone	alone	RB
18637	3349	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	3349	23	the	the	DT
18637	3349	24	power	power	NN
18637	3349	25	to	to	TO
18637	3349	26	punish	punish	VB
18637	3349	27	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	3349	28	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3349	29	within	within	IN
18637	3349	30	the	the	DT
18637	3349	31	ceded	cede	VBN
18637	3349	32	territory	territory	NN
18637	3349	33	.	.	.
18637	3350	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3350	2	1378	1378	CD
18637	3350	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3350	4	Private	private	JJ
18637	3350	5	property	property	NN
18637	3350	6	located	locate	VBN
18637	3350	7	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	3350	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	3350	9	not	not	RB
18637	3350	10	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3350	11	to	to	IN
18637	3350	12	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3350	13	by	by	IN
18637	3350	14	the	the	DT
18637	3350	15	State,[1379	state,[1379	CD
18637	3350	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3350	17	nor	nor	CC
18637	3350	18	can	can	MD
18637	3350	19	State	state	NN
18637	3350	20	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3350	21	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	3350	22	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	3350	23	to	to	IN
18637	3350	24	the	the	DT
18637	3350	25	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	3350	26	have	have	VB
18637	3350	27	any	any	DT
18637	3350	28	operation	operation	NN
18637	3350	29	therein	therein	RB
18637	3350	30	.	.	.
18637	3351	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3351	2	1380	1380	CD
18637	3351	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3351	4	But	but	CC
18637	3351	5	the	the	DT
18637	3351	6	local	local	JJ
18637	3351	7	laws	law	NNS
18637	3351	8	in	in	IN
18637	3351	9	force	force	NN
18637	3351	10	at	at	IN
18637	3351	11	the	the	DT
18637	3351	12	date	date	NN
18637	3351	13	of	of	IN
18637	3351	14	cession	cession	NN
18637	3351	15	which	which	WDT
18637	3351	16	are	be	VBP
18637	3351	17	protective	protective	JJ
18637	3351	18	of	of	IN
18637	3351	19	private	private	JJ
18637	3351	20	rights	right	NNS
18637	3351	21	continue	continue	VBP
18637	3351	22	in	in	IN
18637	3351	23	force	force	NN
18637	3351	24	until	until	IN
18637	3351	25	abrogated	abrogate	VBN
18637	3351	26	by	by	IN
18637	3351	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3351	28	.	.	.
18637	3352	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3352	2	1381	1381	CD
18637	3352	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3352	4	DURATION	DURATION	NNP
18637	3352	5	OF	of	IN
18637	3352	6	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	3352	7	JURISDICTION	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3352	8	A	A	NNP
18637	3352	9	State	State	NNP
18637	3352	10	may	may	MD
18637	3352	11	qualify	qualify	VB
18637	3352	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3352	13	cession	cession	NN
18637	3352	14	of	of	IN
18637	3352	15	territory	territory	NN
18637	3352	16	by	by	IN
18637	3352	17	a	a	DT
18637	3352	18	condition	condition	NN
18637	3352	19	that	that	IN
18637	3352	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3352	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	3352	22	be	be	VB
18637	3352	23	retained	retain	VBN
18637	3352	24	by	by	IN
18637	3352	25	the	the	DT
18637	3352	26	United	United	NNP
18637	3352	27	States	States	NNP
18637	3352	28	only	only	RB
18637	3352	29	so	so	RB
18637	3352	30	long	long	RB
18637	3352	31	as	as	IN
18637	3352	32	the	the	DT
18637	3352	33	place	place	NN
18637	3352	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	3352	35	used	use	VBN
18637	3352	36	for	for	IN
18637	3352	37	specified	specified	JJ
18637	3352	38	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	3352	39	.	.	.
18637	3353	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3353	2	1382	1382	CD
18637	3353	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3353	4	Such	such	PDT
18637	3353	5	a	a	DT
18637	3353	6	provision	provision	NN
18637	3353	7	operates	operate	VBZ
18637	3353	8	prospectively	prospectively	RB
18637	3353	9	and	and	CC
18637	3353	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	3353	11	not	not	RB
18637	3353	12	except	except	IN
18637	3353	13	from	from	IN
18637	3353	14	the	the	DT
18637	3353	15	grant	grant	NN
18637	3353	16	that	that	DT
18637	3353	17	portion	portion	NN
18637	3353	18	of	of	IN
18637	3353	19	a	a	DT
18637	3353	20	described	describe	VBN
18637	3353	21	tract	tract	NN
18637	3353	22	which	which	WDT
18637	3353	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	3353	24	then	then	RB
18637	3353	25	used	use	VBN
18637	3353	26	as	as	IN
18637	3353	27	a	a	DT
18637	3353	28	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	3353	29	right	right	NN
18637	3353	30	of	of	IN
18637	3353	31	way	way	NN
18637	3353	32	.	.	.
18637	3354	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3354	2	1383	1383	CD
18637	3354	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3354	4	In	in	IN
18637	3354	5	1892	1892	CD
18637	3354	6	,	,	,
18637	3354	7	the	the	DT
18637	3354	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3354	9	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	3354	10	the	the	DT
18637	3354	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3354	12	of	of	IN
18637	3354	13	the	the	DT
18637	3354	14	United	United	NNP
18637	3354	15	States	States	NNP
18637	3354	16	to	to	TO
18637	3354	17	try	try	VB
18637	3354	18	a	a	DT
18637	3354	19	person	person	NN
18637	3354	20	charged	charge	VBN
18637	3354	21	with	with	IN
18637	3354	22	murder	murder	NN
18637	3354	23	on	on	IN
18637	3354	24	a	a	DT
18637	3354	25	military	military	JJ
18637	3354	26	reservation	reservation	NN
18637	3354	27	,	,	,
18637	3354	28	over	over	IN
18637	3354	29	the	the	DT
18637	3354	30	objection	objection	NN
18637	3354	31	that	that	IN
18637	3354	32	the	the	DT
18637	3354	33	State	State	NNP
18637	3354	34	had	have	VBD
18637	3354	35	ceded	cede	VBN
18637	3354	36	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3354	37	only	only	RB
18637	3354	38	over	over	IN
18637	3354	39	such	such	JJ
18637	3354	40	portions	portion	NNS
18637	3354	41	of	of	IN
18637	3354	42	the	the	DT
18637	3354	43	area	area	NN
18637	3354	44	as	as	IN
18637	3354	45	were	be	VBD
18637	3354	46	used	use	VBN
18637	3354	47	for	for	IN
18637	3354	48	military	military	JJ
18637	3354	49	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	3354	50	,	,	,
18637	3354	51	and	and	CC
18637	3354	52	that	that	IN
18637	3354	53	the	the	DT
18637	3354	54	particular	particular	JJ
18637	3354	55	place	place	NN
18637	3354	56	on	on	IN
18637	3354	57	which	which	WDT
18637	3354	58	the	the	DT
18637	3354	59	murder	murder	NN
18637	3354	60	was	be	VBD
18637	3354	61	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3354	62	was	be	VBD
18637	3354	63	used	use	VBN
18637	3354	64	solely	solely	RB
18637	3354	65	for	for	IN
18637	3354	66	farming	farming	NN
18637	3354	67	.	.	.
18637	3355	1	The	the	DT
18637	3355	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3355	3	held	hold	VBD
18637	3355	4	that	that	IN
18637	3355	5	the	the	DT
18637	3355	6	character	character	NN
18637	3355	7	and	and	CC
18637	3355	8	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3355	9	of	of	IN
18637	3355	10	the	the	DT
18637	3355	11	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	3355	12	having	have	VBG
18637	3355	13	been	be	VBN
18637	3355	14	officially	officially	RB
18637	3355	15	established	establish	VBN
18637	3355	16	by	by	IN
18637	3355	17	the	the	DT
18637	3355	18	political	political	JJ
18637	3355	19	department	department	NN
18637	3355	20	of	of	IN
18637	3355	21	the	the	DT
18637	3355	22	government	government	NN
18637	3355	23	,	,	,
18637	3355	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3355	25	was	be	VBD
18637	3355	26	not	not	RB
18637	3355	27	open	open	JJ
18637	3355	28	to	to	IN
18637	3355	29	the	the	DT
18637	3355	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3355	31	to	to	TO
18637	3355	32	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	3355	33	into	into	IN
18637	3355	34	the	the	DT
18637	3355	35	actual	actual	JJ
18637	3355	36	uses	use	NNS
18637	3355	37	to	to	TO
18637	3355	38	which	which	WDT
18637	3355	39	any	any	DT
18637	3355	40	portion	portion	NN
18637	3355	41	of	of	IN
18637	3355	42	the	the	DT
18637	3355	43	area	area	NN
18637	3355	44	was	be	VBD
18637	3355	45	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	3355	46	put	put	VBN
18637	3355	47	.	.	.
18637	3356	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3356	2	1384	1384	CD
18637	3356	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3356	4	A	a	DT
18637	3356	5	few	few	JJ
18637	3356	6	years	year	NNS
18637	3356	7	later	later	RB
18637	3356	8	,	,	,
18637	3356	9	however	however	RB
18637	3356	10	,	,	,
18637	3356	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3356	12	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	3356	13	that	that	IN
18637	3356	14	the	the	DT
18637	3356	15	lease	lease	NN
18637	3356	16	to	to	IN
18637	3356	17	a	a	DT
18637	3356	18	city	city	NN
18637	3356	19	,	,	,
18637	3356	20	for	for	IN
18637	3356	21	use	use	NN
18637	3356	22	as	as	IN
18637	3356	23	a	a	DT
18637	3356	24	market	market	NN
18637	3356	25	,	,	,
18637	3356	26	of	of	IN
18637	3356	27	a	a	DT
18637	3356	28	portion	portion	NN
18637	3356	29	of	of	IN
18637	3356	30	an	an	DT
18637	3356	31	area	area	NN
18637	3356	32	which	which	WDT
18637	3356	33	had	have	VBD
18637	3356	34	been	be	VBN
18637	3356	35	ceded	cede	VBN
18637	3356	36	to	to	IN
18637	3356	37	the	the	DT
18637	3356	38	United	United	NNP
18637	3356	39	States	States	NNP
18637	3356	40	for	for	IN
18637	3356	41	a	a	DT
18637	3356	42	particular	particular	JJ
18637	3356	43	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3356	44	,	,	,
18637	3356	45	suspended	suspend	VBD
18637	3356	46	the	the	DT
18637	3356	47	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3356	48	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3356	49	of	of	IN
18637	3356	50	the	the	DT
18637	3356	51	United	United	NNP
18637	3356	52	States	States	NNP
18637	3356	53	.	.	.
18637	3357	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3357	2	1385	1385	CD
18637	3357	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3357	4	Recently	recently	RB
18637	3357	5	the	the	DT
18637	3357	6	question	question	NN
18637	3357	7	arose	arise	VBD
18637	3357	8	whether	whether	IN
18637	3357	9	the	the	DT
18637	3357	10	United	United	NNP
18637	3357	11	States	States	NNP
18637	3357	12	retains	retain	VBZ
18637	3357	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3357	14	over	over	IN
18637	3357	15	a	a	DT
18637	3357	16	place	place	NN
18637	3357	17	which	which	WDT
18637	3357	18	was	be	VBD
18637	3357	19	ceded	cede	VBN
18637	3357	20	to	to	IN
18637	3357	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3357	22	unconditionally	unconditionally	RB
18637	3357	23	after	after	IN
18637	3357	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3357	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	3357	26	abandoned	abandon	VBN
18637	3357	27	the	the	DT
18637	3357	28	use	use	NN
18637	3357	29	of	of	IN
18637	3357	30	the	the	DT
18637	3357	31	property	property	NN
18637	3357	32	for	for	IN
18637	3357	33	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	3357	34	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	3357	35	and	and	CC
18637	3357	36	entered	enter	VBD
18637	3357	37	into	into	IN
18637	3357	38	a	a	DT
18637	3357	39	contract	contract	NN
18637	3357	40	for	for	IN
18637	3357	41	the	the	DT
18637	3357	42	sale	sale	NN
18637	3357	43	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	3357	44	to	to	IN
18637	3357	45	private	private	JJ
18637	3357	46	persons	person	NNS
18637	3357	47	.	.	.
18637	3358	1	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	3358	2	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	3358	3	the	the	DT
18637	3358	4	right	right	NN
18637	3358	5	to	to	TO
18637	3358	6	tax	tax	VB
18637	3358	7	the	the	DT
18637	3358	8	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	3358	9	interest	interest	NN
18637	3358	10	of	of	IN
18637	3358	11	the	the	DT
18637	3358	12	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	3358	13	in	in	IN
18637	3358	14	such	such	JJ
18637	3358	15	land	land	NN
18637	3358	16	,	,	,
18637	3358	17	and	and	CC
18637	3358	18	the	the	DT
18637	3358	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3358	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3358	21	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	3358	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3358	23	right	right	NN
18637	3358	24	to	to	TO
18637	3358	25	do	do	VB
18637	3358	26	so	so	RB
18637	3358	27	.	.	.
18637	3359	1	The	the	DT
18637	3359	2	majority	majority	NN
18637	3359	3	assumed	assume	VBD
18637	3359	4	that	that	IN
18637	3359	5	"	"	``
18637	3359	6	the	the	DT
18637	3359	7	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3359	8	's	's	POS
18637	3359	9	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
18637	3359	10	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	3359	11	of	of	IN
18637	3359	12	property	property	NN
18637	3359	13	to	to	IN
18637	3359	14	nonfederal	nonfederal	JJ
18637	3359	15	hands	hand	NNS
18637	3359	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	3359	17	a	a	DT
18637	3359	18	relinquishment	relinquishment	NN
18637	3359	19	of	of	IN
18637	3359	20	the	the	DT
18637	3359	21	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3359	22	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3359	23	power	power	NN
18637	3359	24	.	.	.
18637	3360	1	"	"	``
18637	3360	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3360	3	1386	1386	CD
18637	3360	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3360	5	In	in	IN
18637	3360	6	separate	separate	JJ
18637	3360	7	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	3360	8	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	3360	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3360	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3360	11	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	3360	12	and	and	CC
18637	3360	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3360	14	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	3360	15	reserved	reserve	VBD
18637	3360	16	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	3360	17	on	on	IN
18637	3360	18	the	the	DT
18637	3360	19	question	question	NN
18637	3360	20	of	of	IN
18637	3360	21	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	3360	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3360	23	.	.	.
18637	3361	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3361	2	1387	1387	CD
18637	3361	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3361	4	RESERVATION	RESERVATION	NNP
18637	3361	5	OF	of	IN
18637	3361	6	JURISDICTION	JURISDICTION	NNP
18637	3361	7	BY	by	IN
18637	3361	8	STATES	state	NNS
18637	3361	9	For	for	IN
18637	3361	10	more	more	JJR
18637	3361	11	than	than	IN
18637	3361	12	a	a	DT
18637	3361	13	century	century	NN
18637	3361	14	the	the	DT
18637	3361	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3361	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3361	17	kept	keep	VBD
18637	3361	18	alive	alive	JJ
18637	3361	19	,	,	,
18637	3361	20	by	by	IN
18637	3361	21	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	3361	22	dicta,[1388	dicta,[1388	NNP
18637	3361	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3361	24	the	the	DT
18637	3361	25	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	3361	26	expressed	express	VBN
18637	3361	27	by	by	IN
18637	3361	28	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3361	29	Story	Story	NNP
18637	3361	30	"	"	''
18637	3361	31	whether	whether	IN
18637	3361	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3361	33	are	be	VBP
18637	3361	34	by	by	IN
18637	3361	35	the	the	DT
18637	3361	36	terms	term	NNS
18637	3361	37	of	of	IN
18637	3361	38	the	the	DT
18637	3361	39	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3361	40	,	,	,
18637	3361	41	at	at	IN
18637	3361	42	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	3361	43	to	to	TO
18637	3361	44	purchase	purchase	VB
18637	3361	45	lands	land	NNS
18637	3361	46	for	for	IN
18637	3361	47	forts	fort	NNS
18637	3361	48	,	,	,
18637	3361	49	dockyards	dockyard	NNS
18637	3361	50	,	,	,
18637	3361	51	etc	etc	FW
18637	3361	52	.	.	FW
18637	3361	53	,	,	,
18637	3361	54	with	with	IN
18637	3361	55	the	the	DT
18637	3361	56	consent	consent	NN
18637	3361	57	of	of	IN
18637	3361	58	a	a	DT
18637	3361	59	State	State	NNP
18637	3361	60	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3361	61	,	,	,
18637	3361	62	where	where	WRB
18637	3361	63	such	such	JJ
18637	3361	64	consent	consent	NN
18637	3361	65	is	be	VBZ
18637	3361	66	so	so	RB
18637	3361	67	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	3361	68	that	that	IN
18637	3361	69	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3361	70	will	will	MD
18637	3361	71	not	not	RB
18637	3361	72	justify	justify	VB
18637	3361	73	the	the	DT
18637	3361	74	'	'	``
18637	3361	75	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3361	76	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3361	77	'	'	''
18637	3361	78	of	of	IN
18637	3361	79	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3361	80	there	there	RB
18637	3361	81	.	.	.
18637	3362	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3362	2	may	may	MD
18637	3362	3	well	well	RB
18637	3362	4	be	be	VB
18637	3362	5	doubted	doubt	VBN
18637	3362	6	if	if	IN
18637	3362	7	such	such	JJ
18637	3362	8	consent	consent	NN
18637	3362	9	be	be	VBP
18637	3362	10	not	not	RB
18637	3362	11	utterly	utterly	RB
18637	3362	12	void	void	JJ
18637	3362	13	.	.	.
18637	3363	1	"	"	``
18637	3363	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3363	3	1389	1389	CD
18637	3363	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3363	5	But	but	CC
18637	3363	6	when	when	WRB
18637	3363	7	the	the	DT
18637	3363	8	issue	issue	NN
18637	3363	9	was	be	VBD
18637	3363	10	squarely	squarely	RB
18637	3363	11	presented	present	VBN
18637	3363	12	in	in	IN
18637	3363	13	1937	1937	CD
18637	3363	14	,	,	,
18637	3363	15	the	the	DT
18637	3363	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3363	17	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	3363	18	that	that	IN
18637	3363	19	where	where	WRB
18637	3363	20	the	the	DT
18637	3363	21	United	United	NNP
18637	3363	22	States	States	NNP
18637	3363	23	purchases	purchase	VBZ
18637	3363	24	property	property	NN
18637	3363	25	within	within	IN
18637	3363	26	a	a	DT
18637	3363	27	State	state	NN
18637	3363	28	with	with	IN
18637	3363	29	the	the	DT
18637	3363	30	consent	consent	NN
18637	3363	31	of	of	IN
18637	3363	32	the	the	DT
18637	3363	33	latter	latter	JJ
18637	3363	34	,	,	,
18637	3363	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3363	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	3363	37	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3363	38	for	for	IN
18637	3363	39	the	the	DT
18637	3363	40	State	State	NNP
18637	3363	41	to	to	TO
18637	3363	42	convey	convey	VB
18637	3363	43	,	,	,
18637	3363	44	and	and	CC
18637	3363	45	for	for	IN
18637	3363	46	the	the	DT
18637	3363	47	United	United	NNP
18637	3363	48	States	States	NNP
18637	3363	49	to	to	TO
18637	3363	50	accept	accept	VB
18637	3363	51	,	,	,
18637	3363	52	"	"	``
18637	3363	53	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	3363	54	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3363	55	"	"	''
18637	3363	56	over	over	IN
18637	3363	57	such	such	JJ
18637	3363	58	land	land	NN
18637	3363	59	,	,	,
18637	3363	60	the	the	DT
18637	3363	61	State	State	NNP
18637	3363	62	reserving	reserve	VBG
18637	3363	63	to	to	IN
18637	3363	64	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3363	65	the	the	DT
18637	3363	66	right	right	NN
18637	3363	67	to	to	TO
18637	3363	68	execute	execute	VB
18637	3363	69	process	process	NN
18637	3363	70	"	"	''
18637	3363	71	and	and	CC
18637	3363	72	such	such	JJ
18637	3363	73	other	other	JJ
18637	3363	74	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3363	75	and	and	CC
18637	3363	76	authority	authority	NN
18637	3363	77	over	over	IN
18637	3363	78	the	the	DT
18637	3363	79	same	same	JJ
18637	3363	80	as	as	IN
18637	3363	81	is	be	VBZ
18637	3363	82	not	not	RB
18637	3363	83	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	3363	84	with	with	IN
18637	3363	85	the	the	DT
18637	3363	86	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3363	87	ceded	cede	VBN
18637	3363	88	to	to	IN
18637	3363	89	the	the	DT
18637	3363	90	United	United	NNP
18637	3363	91	States	States	NNP
18637	3363	92	.	.	.
18637	3364	1	"	"	``
18637	3364	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3364	3	1390	1390	CD
18637	3364	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3364	5	The	the	DT
18637	3364	6	holding	hold	VBG
18637	3364	7	logically	logically	RB
18637	3364	8	renders	render	VBZ
18637	3364	9	the	the	DT
18637	3364	10	second	second	JJ
18637	3364	11	half	half	NN
18637	3364	12	of	of	IN
18637	3364	13	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3364	14	17	17	CD
18637	3364	15	superfluous	superfluous	JJ
18637	3364	16	.	.	.
18637	3365	1	In	in	IN
18637	3365	2	a	a	DT
18637	3365	3	companion	companion	NN
18637	3365	4	case	case	NN
18637	3365	5	,	,	,
18637	3365	6	the	the	DT
18637	3365	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3365	8	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	3365	9	further	further	RB
18637	3365	10	that	that	IN
18637	3365	11	even	even	RB
18637	3365	12	if	if	IN
18637	3365	13	a	a	DT
18637	3365	14	general	general	JJ
18637	3365	15	State	State	NNP
18637	3365	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	3365	17	purports	purport	VBZ
18637	3365	18	to	to	TO
18637	3365	19	cede	cede	VB
18637	3365	20	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3365	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3365	22	,	,	,
18637	3365	23	such	such	JJ
18637	3365	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3365	25	does	do	VBZ
18637	3365	26	not	not	RB
18637	3365	27	pass	pass	VB
18637	3365	28	unless	unless	IN
18637	3365	29	the	the	DT
18637	3365	30	United	United	NNP
18637	3365	31	States	States	NNP
18637	3365	32	accepts	accept	VBZ
18637	3365	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3365	34	.	.	.
18637	3366	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3366	2	1391	1391	CD
18637	3366	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3366	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3366	5	18	18	CD
18637	3366	6	.	.	.
18637	3367	1	_	_	NNP
18637	3367	2	The	the	DT
18637	3367	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3367	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	3367	5	have	have	VB
18637	3367	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	3367	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3367	8	*	*	NFP
18637	3367	9	*	*	NFP
18637	3367	10	*	*	NFP
18637	3367	11	To	to	TO
18637	3367	12	make	make	VB
18637	3367	13	all	all	DT
18637	3367	14	Laws	law	NNS
18637	3367	15	which	which	WDT
18637	3367	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	3367	17	be	be	VB
18637	3367	18	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3367	19	and	and	CC
18637	3367	20	proper	proper	JJ
18637	3367	21	for	for	IN
18637	3367	22	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	3367	23	into	into	IN
18637	3367	24	Execution	execution	NN
18637	3367	25	the	the	DT
18637	3367	26	foregoing	forego	VBG
18637	3367	27	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	3367	28	,	,	,
18637	3367	29	and	and	CC
18637	3367	30	all	all	DT
18637	3367	31	other	other	JJ
18637	3367	32	Powers	power	NNS
18637	3367	33	vested	vest	VBN
18637	3367	34	by	by	IN
18637	3367	35	this	this	DT
18637	3367	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3367	37	in	in	IN
18637	3367	38	the	the	DT
18637	3367	39	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3367	40	of	of	IN
18637	3367	41	the	the	DT
18637	3367	42	United	United	NNP
18637	3367	43	States	States	NNP
18637	3367	44	,	,	,
18637	3367	45	or	or	CC
18637	3367	46	in	in	IN
18637	3367	47	any	any	DT
18637	3367	48	Department	Department	NNP
18637	3367	49	or	or	CC
18637	3367	50	Officer	Officer	NNP
18637	3367	51	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	3367	52	.	.	.
18637	3368	1	The	the	DT
18637	3368	2	Coefficient	Coefficient	NNP
18637	3368	3	or	or	CC
18637	3368	4	Elastic	Elastic	NNP
18637	3368	5	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	3368	6	SCOPE	SCOPE	NNS
18637	3368	7	OF	of	IN
18637	3368	8	INCIDENTAL	INCIDENTAL	NNP
18637	3368	9	POWERS	power	NNS
18637	3368	10	That	that	IN
18637	3368	11	this	this	DT
18637	3368	12	clause	clause	NN
18637	3368	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	3368	14	an	an	DT
18637	3368	15	enlargement	enlargement	NN
18637	3368	16	,	,	,
18637	3368	17	not	not	RB
18637	3368	18	a	a	DT
18637	3368	19	constriction	constriction	NN
18637	3368	20	,	,	,
18637	3368	21	of	of	IN
18637	3368	22	the	the	DT
18637	3368	23	powers	power	NNS
18637	3368	24	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	3368	25	granted	grant	VBD
18637	3368	26	to	to	IN
18637	3368	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3368	28	,	,	,
18637	3368	29	that	that	IN
18637	3368	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3368	31	enables	enable	VBZ
18637	3368	32	the	the	DT
18637	3368	33	lawmakers	lawmaker	NNS
18637	3368	34	to	to	TO
18637	3368	35	select	select	VB
18637	3368	36	any	any	DT
18637	3368	37	means	mean	NNS
18637	3368	38	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	3368	39	adapted	adapt	VBN
18637	3368	40	to	to	TO
18637	3368	41	effectuate	effectuate	VB
18637	3368	42	those	those	DT
18637	3368	43	powers	power	NNS
18637	3368	44	,	,	,
18637	3368	45	was	be	VBD
18637	3368	46	established	establish	VBN
18637	3368	47	by	by	IN
18637	3368	48	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3368	49	's	's	POS
18637	3368	50	classic	classic	JJ
18637	3368	51	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3368	52	in	in	IN
18637	3368	53	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	3368	54	_	_	NNP
18637	3368	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	3368	56	_	_	NNP
18637	3368	57	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	3368	58	.	.	.
18637	3369	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3369	2	1392	1392	CD
18637	3369	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3369	4	"	"	``
18637	3369	5	Let	let	VB
18637	3369	6	the	the	DT
18637	3369	7	end	end	NN
18637	3369	8	be	be	VB
18637	3369	9	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	3369	10	,	,	,
18637	3369	11	"	"	''
18637	3369	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3369	13	wrote	write	VBD
18637	3369	14	,	,	,
18637	3369	15	"	"	``
18637	3369	16	let	let	VB
18637	3369	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3369	18	be	be	VB
18637	3369	19	within	within	IN
18637	3369	20	the	the	DT
18637	3369	21	scope	scope	NN
18637	3369	22	of	of	IN
18637	3369	23	the	the	DT
18637	3369	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3369	25	,	,	,
18637	3369	26	and	and	CC
18637	3369	27	all	all	DT
18637	3369	28	means	mean	NNS
18637	3369	29	which	which	WDT
18637	3369	30	are	be	VBP
18637	3369	31	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	3369	32	,	,	,
18637	3369	33	which	which	WDT
18637	3369	34	are	be	VBP
18637	3369	35	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	3369	36	adapted	adapt	VBN
18637	3369	37	to	to	IN
18637	3369	38	that	that	DT
18637	3369	39	end	end	NN
18637	3369	40	,	,	,
18637	3369	41	which	which	WDT
18637	3369	42	are	be	VBP
18637	3369	43	not	not	RB
18637	3369	44	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	3369	45	,	,	,
18637	3369	46	but	but	CC
18637	3369	47	consist	consist	VB
18637	3369	48	with	with	IN
18637	3369	49	the	the	DT
18637	3369	50	letter	letter	NN
18637	3369	51	and	and	CC
18637	3369	52	spirit	spirit	NN
18637	3369	53	of	of	IN
18637	3369	54	the	the	DT
18637	3369	55	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3369	56	,	,	,
18637	3369	57	are	be	VBP
18637	3369	58	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3369	59	.	.	.
18637	3370	1	"	"	``
18637	3370	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3370	3	1393	1393	CD
18637	3370	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3370	5	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	3370	6	,	,	,
18637	3370	7	this	this	DT
18637	3370	8	provision	provision	NN
18637	3370	9	gives	give	VBZ
18637	3370	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3370	11	a	a	DT
18637	3370	12	share	share	NN
18637	3370	13	in	in	IN
18637	3370	14	the	the	DT
18637	3370	15	responsibilities	responsibility	NNS
18637	3370	16	lodged	lodge	VBN
18637	3370	17	in	in	IN
18637	3370	18	other	other	JJ
18637	3370	19	departments	department	NNS
18637	3370	20	,	,	,
18637	3370	21	by	by	IN
18637	3370	22	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	3370	23	of	of	IN
18637	3370	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3370	25	right	right	NN
18637	3370	26	to	to	TO
18637	3370	27	enact	enact	VB
18637	3370	28	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3370	29	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3370	30	to	to	TO
18637	3370	31	carry	carry	VB
18637	3370	32	into	into	IN
18637	3370	33	execution	execution	NN
18637	3370	34	all	all	DT
18637	3370	35	powers	power	NNS
18637	3370	36	vested	vest	VBN
18637	3370	37	in	in	IN
18637	3370	38	the	the	DT
18637	3370	39	National	National	NNP
18637	3370	40	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3370	41	.	.	.
18637	3371	1	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	3371	2	,	,	,
18637	3371	3	where	where	WRB
18637	3371	4	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3371	5	for	for	IN
18637	3371	6	the	the	DT
18637	3371	7	efficient	efficient	JJ
18637	3371	8	execution	execution	NN
18637	3371	9	of	of	IN
18637	3371	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3371	11	own	own	JJ
18637	3371	12	powers	power	NNS
18637	3371	13	,	,	,
18637	3371	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3371	15	may	may	MD
18637	3371	16	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	3371	17	some	some	DT
18637	3371	18	measure	measure	NN
18637	3371	19	of	of	IN
18637	3371	20	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3371	21	power	power	NN
18637	3371	22	to	to	IN
18637	3371	23	other	other	JJ
18637	3371	24	departments	department	NNS
18637	3371	25	.	.	.
18637	3372	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3372	2	1394	1394	CD
18637	3372	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3372	4	OPERATION	operation	FW
18637	3372	5	OF	of	IN
18637	3372	6	COEFFICIENT	COEFFICIENT	NNP
18637	3372	7	CLAUSE	CLAUSE	NNP
18637	3372	8	Practically	practically	RB
18637	3372	9	every	every	DT
18637	3372	10	power	power	NN
18637	3372	11	of	of	IN
18637	3372	12	the	the	DT
18637	3372	13	National	National	NNP
18637	3372	14	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3372	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	3372	16	been	be	VBN
18637	3372	17	expanded	expand	VBN
18637	3372	18	in	in	IN
18637	3372	19	some	some	DT
18637	3372	20	degree	degree	NN
18637	3372	21	by	by	IN
18637	3372	22	the	the	DT
18637	3372	23	coefficient	coefficient	NN
18637	3372	24	clause	clause	NN
18637	3372	25	.	.	.
18637	3373	1	Under	under	IN
18637	3373	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3373	3	authority	authority	NN
18637	3373	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3373	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	3373	6	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	3373	7	measures	measure	NNS
18637	3373	8	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	3373	9	to	to	TO
18637	3373	10	discharge	discharge	VB
18637	3373	11	the	the	DT
18637	3373	12	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	3373	13	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	3373	14	of	of	IN
18637	3373	15	the	the	DT
18637	3373	16	nation;[1395	nation;[1395	NNPS
18637	3373	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3373	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3373	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	3373	20	organized	organize	VBN
18637	3373	21	the	the	DT
18637	3373	22	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3373	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3373	24	system	system	NN
18637	3373	25	and	and	CC
18637	3373	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	3373	27	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	3373	28	a	a	DT
18637	3373	29	large	large	JJ
18637	3373	30	body	body	NN
18637	3373	31	of	of	IN
18637	3373	32	law	law	NN
18637	3373	33	defining	define	VBG
18637	3373	34	and	and	CC
18637	3373	35	punishing	punish	VBG
18637	3373	36	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	3373	37	.	.	.
18637	3374	1	Effective	effective	JJ
18637	3374	2	control	control	NN
18637	3374	3	of	of	IN
18637	3374	4	the	the	DT
18637	3374	5	national	national	JJ
18637	3374	6	economy	economy	NN
18637	3374	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	3374	8	been	be	VBN
18637	3374	9	made	make	VBN
18637	3374	10	possible	possible	JJ
18637	3374	11	by	by	IN
18637	3374	12	the	the	DT
18637	3374	13	authority	authority	NN
18637	3374	14	to	to	TO
18637	3374	15	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	3374	16	the	the	DT
18637	3374	17	internal	internal	JJ
18637	3374	18	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	3374	19	of	of	IN
18637	3374	20	a	a	DT
18637	3374	21	State	State	NNP
18637	3374	22	to	to	IN
18637	3374	23	the	the	DT
18637	3374	24	extent	extent	NN
18637	3374	25	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3374	26	to	to	TO
18637	3374	27	protect	protect	VB
18637	3374	28	and	and	CC
18637	3374	29	promote	promote	VB
18637	3374	30	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	3374	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	3374	32	.	.	.
18637	3375	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3375	2	1396	1396	CD
18637	3375	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3375	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	3375	5	the	the	DT
18637	3375	6	right	right	NN
18637	3375	7	of	of	IN
18637	3375	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3375	9	to	to	TO
18637	3375	10	utilize	utilize	VB
18637	3375	11	all	all	DT
18637	3375	12	known	known	JJ
18637	3375	13	and	and	CC
18637	3375	14	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	3375	15	means	mean	NNS
18637	3375	16	for	for	IN
18637	3375	17	collecting	collect	VBG
18637	3375	18	the	the	DT
18637	3375	19	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	3375	20	,	,	,
18637	3375	21	including	include	VBG
18637	3375	22	the	the	DT
18637	3375	23	distraint	distraint	NN
18637	3375	24	of	of	IN
18637	3375	25	property	property	NN
18637	3375	26	for	for	IN
18637	3375	27	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3375	28	taxes,[1397	taxes,[1397	NNP
18637	3375	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3375	30	and	and	CC
18637	3375	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3375	32	power	power	NN
18637	3375	33	to	to	TO
18637	3375	34	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	3375	35	property	property	NN
18637	3375	36	needed	need	VBN
18637	3375	37	for	for	IN
18637	3375	38	the	the	DT
18637	3375	39	operation	operation	NN
18637	3375	40	of	of	IN
18637	3375	41	the	the	DT
18637	3375	42	government	government	NN
18637	3375	43	by	by	IN
18637	3375	44	the	the	DT
18637	3375	45	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3375	46	of	of	IN
18637	3375	47	the	the	DT
18637	3375	48	power	power	NN
18637	3375	49	of	of	IN
18637	3375	50	eminent	eminent	NNP
18637	3375	51	domain,[1398	domain,[1398	NNP
18637	3375	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3375	53	have	have	VBP
18637	3375	54	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	3375	55	extended	extend	VBN
18637	3375	56	the	the	DT
18637	3375	57	range	range	NN
18637	3375	58	of	of	IN
18637	3375	59	national	national	JJ
18637	3375	60	power	power	NN
18637	3375	61	.	.	.
18637	3376	1	But	but	CC
18637	3376	2	the	the	DT
18637	3376	3	widest	wide	JJS
18637	3376	4	application	application	NN
18637	3376	5	of	of	IN
18637	3376	6	the	the	DT
18637	3376	7	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3376	8	and	and	CC
18637	3376	9	proper	proper	JJ
18637	3376	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	3376	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	3376	12	occurred	occur	VBN
18637	3376	13	in	in	IN
18637	3376	14	the	the	DT
18637	3376	15	field	field	NN
18637	3376	16	of	of	IN
18637	3376	17	monetary	monetary	JJ
18637	3376	18	and	and	CC
18637	3376	19	fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	3376	20	controls	control	NNS
18637	3376	21	.	.	.
18637	3377	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	3377	2	as	as	IN
18637	3377	3	the	the	DT
18637	3377	4	various	various	JJ
18637	3377	5	specific	specific	JJ
18637	3377	6	powers	power	NNS
18637	3377	7	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3377	8	by	by	IN
18637	3377	9	article	article	NN
18637	3377	10	I	i	NN
18637	3377	11	,	,	,
18637	3377	12	section	section	NN
18637	3377	13	8	8	CD
18637	3377	14	,	,	,
18637	3377	15	do	do	VBP
18637	3377	16	not	not	RB
18637	3377	17	add	add	VB
18637	3377	18	up	up	RP
18637	3377	19	to	to	IN
18637	3377	20	a	a	DT
18637	3377	21	general	general	JJ
18637	3377	22	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3377	23	power	power	NN
18637	3377	24	over	over	IN
18637	3377	25	such	such	JJ
18637	3377	26	matters	matter	NNS
18637	3377	27	,	,	,
18637	3377	28	the	the	DT
18637	3377	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3377	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	3377	31	relied	rely	VBN
18637	3377	32	heavily	heavily	RB
18637	3377	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	3377	34	this	this	DT
18637	3377	35	clause	clause	NN
18637	3377	36	in	in	IN
18637	3377	37	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	3377	38	the	the	DT
18637	3377	39	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	3377	40	control	control	NN
18637	3377	41	which	which	WDT
18637	3377	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3377	43	has	have	VBZ
18637	3377	44	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	3377	45	over	over	IN
18637	3377	46	this	this	DT
18637	3377	47	subject	subject	NN
18637	3377	48	.	.	.
18637	3378	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3378	2	1399	1399	CD
18637	3378	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3378	4	DEFINITION	DEFINITION	VBN
18637	3378	5	AND	and	CC
18637	3378	6	PUNISHMENT	punishment	NN
18637	3378	7	OF	of	IN
18637	3378	8	CRIMES	CRIMES	NNP
18637	3378	9	Although	although	IN
18637	3378	10	the	the	DT
18637	3378	11	only	only	JJ
18637	3378	12	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	3378	13	which	which	WDT
18637	3378	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3378	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	3378	16	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	3378	17	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	3378	18	to	to	TO
18637	3378	19	punish	punish	VB
18637	3378	20	are	be	VBP
18637	3378	21	piracies	piracy	NNS
18637	3378	22	,	,	,
18637	3378	23	felonies	felony	NNS
18637	3378	24	on	on	IN
18637	3378	25	the	the	DT
18637	3378	26	high	high	JJ
18637	3378	27	seas	sea	NNS
18637	3378	28	,	,	,
18637	3378	29	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3378	30	against	against	IN
18637	3378	31	the	the	DT
18637	3378	32	law	law	NN
18637	3378	33	of	of	IN
18637	3378	34	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3378	35	,	,	,
18637	3378	36	treason	treason	NN
18637	3378	37	and	and	CC
18637	3378	38	counterfeiting	counterfeiting	NN
18637	3378	39	of	of	IN
18637	3378	40	the	the	DT
18637	3378	41	securities	security	NNS
18637	3378	42	and	and	CC
18637	3378	43	current	current	JJ
18637	3378	44	coin	coin	NN
18637	3378	45	of	of	IN
18637	3378	46	the	the	DT
18637	3378	47	United	United	NNP
18637	3378	48	States	States	NNP
18637	3378	49	,	,	,
18637	3378	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3378	51	power	power	NN
18637	3378	52	to	to	TO
18637	3378	53	create	create	VB
18637	3378	54	,	,	,
18637	3378	55	define	define	VB
18637	3378	56	and	and	CC
18637	3378	57	punish	punish	JJ
18637	3378	58	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	3378	59	and	and	CC
18637	3378	60	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3378	61	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	3378	62	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3378	63	to	to	TO
18637	3378	64	effectuate	effectuate	VB
18637	3378	65	the	the	DT
18637	3378	66	objects	object	NNS
18637	3378	67	of	of	IN
18637	3378	68	the	the	DT
18637	3378	69	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3378	70	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3378	71	is	be	VBZ
18637	3378	72	universally	universally	RB
18637	3378	73	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	3378	74	.	.	.
18637	3379	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3379	2	1400	1400	CD
18637	3379	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3379	4	Illustrative	illustrative	JJ
18637	3379	5	of	of	IN
18637	3379	6	the	the	DT
18637	3379	7	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3379	8	which	which	WDT
18637	3379	9	have	have	VBP
18637	3379	10	been	be	VBN
18637	3379	11	punished	punish	VBN
18637	3379	12	under	under	IN
18637	3379	13	this	this	DT
18637	3379	14	power	power	NN
18637	3379	15	are	be	VBP
18637	3379	16	the	the	DT
18637	3379	17	alteration	alteration	NN
18637	3379	18	of	of	IN
18637	3379	19	registered	register	VBN
18637	3379	20	bonds;[1401	bonds;[1401	.
18637	3379	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3379	22	the	the	DT
18637	3379	23	bringing	bringing	NN
18637	3379	24	of	of	IN
18637	3379	25	counterfeit	counterfeit	JJ
18637	3379	26	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	3379	27	into	into	IN
18637	3379	28	the	the	DT
18637	3379	29	country;[1402	country;[1402	JJ
18637	3379	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3379	31	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	3379	32	to	to	TO
18637	3379	33	injure	injure	VB
18637	3379	34	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
18637	3379	35	in	in	IN
18637	3379	36	custody	custody	NN
18637	3379	37	of	of	IN
18637	3379	38	a	a	DT
18637	3379	39	United	United	NNP
18637	3379	40	States	States	NNP
18637	3379	41	marshal;[1403	marshal;[1403	NNP
18637	3379	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3379	43	impersonation	impersonation	NN
18637	3379	44	of	of	IN
18637	3379	45	a	a	DT
18637	3379	46	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3379	47	officer	officer	NN
18637	3379	48	with	with	IN
18637	3379	49	intent	intent	NN
18637	3379	50	to	to	IN
18637	3379	51	defraud;[1404	defraud;[1404	ADD
18637	3379	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3379	53	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	3379	54	to	to	TO
18637	3379	55	injure	injure	VB
18637	3379	56	a	a	DT
18637	3379	57	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	3379	58	in	in	IN
18637	3379	59	the	the	DT
18637	3379	60	free	free	JJ
18637	3379	61	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3379	62	or	or	CC
18637	3379	63	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	3379	64	of	of	IN
18637	3379	65	any	any	DT
18637	3379	66	right	right	NN
18637	3379	67	or	or	CC
18637	3379	68	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	3379	69	secured	secure	VBN
18637	3379	70	by	by	IN
18637	3379	71	the	the	DT
18637	3379	72	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3379	73	or	or	CC
18637	3379	74	laws	law	NNS
18637	3379	75	of	of	IN
18637	3379	76	the	the	DT
18637	3379	77	United	United	NNP
18637	3379	78	States;[1405	States;[1405	NNP
18637	3379	79	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3379	80	the	the	DT
18637	3379	81	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	3379	82	by	by	IN
18637	3379	83	government	government	NN
18637	3379	84	officials	official	NNS
18637	3379	85	of	of	IN
18637	3379	86	contributions	contribution	NNS
18637	3379	87	from	from	IN
18637	3379	88	government	government	NN
18637	3379	89	employees	employee	NNS
18637	3379	90	for	for	IN
18637	3379	91	political	political	JJ
18637	3379	92	purposes;[1406	purposes;[1406	CD
18637	3379	93	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3379	94	advocating	advocate	VBG
18637	3379	95	,	,	,
18637	3379	96	etc	etc	FW
18637	3379	97	.	.	FW
18637	3379	98	,	,	,
18637	3379	99	the	the	DT
18637	3379	100	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	3379	101	of	of	IN
18637	3379	102	the	the	DT
18637	3379	103	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3379	104	by	by	IN
18637	3379	105	force	force	NN
18637	3379	106	.	.	.
18637	3380	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3380	2	1407	1407	CD
18637	3380	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3380	4	Part	Part	NNP
18637	3380	5	I	I	NNP
18637	3380	6	of	of	IN
18637	3380	7	Title	title	NN
18637	3380	8	18	18	CD
18637	3380	9	of	of	IN
18637	3380	10	the	the	DT
18637	3380	11	United	United	NNP
18637	3380	12	States	States	NNP
18637	3380	13	Code	Code	NNP
18637	3380	14	comprises	comprise	VBZ
18637	3380	15	more	more	JJR
18637	3380	16	than	than	IN
18637	3380	17	500	500	CD
18637	3380	18	sections	section	NNS
18637	3380	19	defining	define	VBG
18637	3380	20	penal	penal	JJ
18637	3380	21	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3380	22	against	against	IN
18637	3380	23	the	the	DT
18637	3380	24	United	United	NNP
18637	3380	25	States	States	NNP
18637	3380	26	.	.	.
18637	3381	1	CHARTERING	charter	VBG
18637	3381	2	OF	of	IN
18637	3381	3	BANKS	bank	NNS
18637	3381	4	As	as	IN
18637	3381	5	an	an	DT
18637	3381	6	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	3381	7	means	mean	VBZ
18637	3381	8	for	for	IN
18637	3381	9	executing	execute	VBG
18637	3381	10	"	"	``
18637	3381	11	the	the	DT
18637	3381	12	great	great	JJ
18637	3381	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	3381	14	,	,	,
18637	3381	15	to	to	TO
18637	3381	16	lay	lay	VB
18637	3381	17	and	and	CC
18637	3381	18	collect	collect	VB
18637	3381	19	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3381	20	;	;	:
18637	3381	21	to	to	TO
18637	3381	22	borrow	borrow	VB
18637	3381	23	money	money	NN
18637	3381	24	;	;	:
18637	3381	25	to	to	TO
18637	3381	26	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	3381	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	3381	28	;	;	:
18637	3381	29	to	to	TO
18637	3381	30	declare	declare	VB
18637	3381	31	and	and	CC
18637	3381	32	conduct	conduct	VB
18637	3381	33	a	a	DT
18637	3381	34	war	war	NN
18637	3381	35	;	;	,
18637	3381	36	and	and	CC
18637	3381	37	to	to	TO
18637	3381	38	raise	raise	VB
18637	3381	39	and	and	CC
18637	3381	40	support	support	VB
18637	3381	41	armies	army	NNS
18637	3381	42	*	*	NFP
18637	3381	43	*	*	NFP
18637	3381	44	*	*	NFP
18637	3381	45	"	"	``
18637	3381	46	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3381	47	may	may	MD
18637	3381	48	incorporate	incorporate	VB
18637	3381	49	banks	bank	NNS
18637	3381	50	and	and	CC
18637	3381	51	kindred	kindred	JJ
18637	3381	52	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	3381	53	.	.	.
18637	3382	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3382	2	1408	1408	CD
18637	3382	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3382	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	3382	5	,	,	,
18637	3382	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3382	7	may	may	MD
18637	3382	8	confer	confer	VB
18637	3382	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	3382	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3382	11	private	private	JJ
18637	3382	12	powers	power	NNS
18637	3382	13	which	which	WDT
18637	3382	14	,	,	,
18637	3382	15	standing	stand	VBG
18637	3382	16	alone	alone	RB
18637	3382	17	,	,	,
18637	3382	18	have	have	VBP
18637	3382	19	no	no	DT
18637	3382	20	relation	relation	NN
18637	3382	21	to	to	IN
18637	3382	22	the	the	DT
18637	3382	23	functions	function	NNS
18637	3382	24	of	of	IN
18637	3382	25	the	the	DT
18637	3382	26	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3382	27	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3382	28	,	,	,
18637	3382	29	if	if	IN
18637	3382	30	those	those	DT
18637	3382	31	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3382	32	are	be	VBP
18637	3382	33	essential	essential	JJ
18637	3382	34	to	to	IN
18637	3382	35	the	the	DT
18637	3382	36	effective	effective	JJ
18637	3382	37	operation	operation	NN
18637	3382	38	of	of	IN
18637	3382	39	such	such	JJ
18637	3382	40	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	3382	41	.	.	.
18637	3383	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3383	2	1409	1409	CD
18637	3383	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3383	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	3383	5	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3383	6	to	to	TO
18637	3383	7	meet	meet	VB
18637	3383	8	the	the	DT
18637	3383	9	competition	competition	NN
18637	3383	10	of	of	IN
18637	3383	11	State	State	NNP
18637	3383	12	banks	bank	NNS
18637	3383	13	,	,	,
18637	3383	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3383	15	may	may	MD
18637	3383	16	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	3383	17	national	national	JJ
18637	3383	18	banks	bank	NNS
18637	3383	19	to	to	TO
18637	3383	20	perform	perform	VB
18637	3383	21	fiduciary	fiduciary	JJ
18637	3383	22	functions	function	NNS
18637	3383	23	,	,	,
18637	3383	24	even	even	RB
18637	3383	25	though	though	RB
18637	3383	26	,	,	,
18637	3383	27	apart	apart	RB
18637	3383	28	from	from	IN
18637	3383	29	the	the	DT
18637	3383	30	competitive	competitive	JJ
18637	3383	31	situation	situation	NN
18637	3383	32	,	,	,
18637	3383	33	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3383	34	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	3383	35	might	may	MD
18637	3383	36	not	not	RB
18637	3383	37	be	be	VB
18637	3383	38	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	3383	39	to	to	TO
18637	3383	40	engage	engage	VB
18637	3383	41	in	in	IN
18637	3383	42	such	such	JJ
18637	3383	43	business	business	NN
18637	3383	44	.	.	.
18637	3384	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3384	2	1410	1410	CD
18637	3384	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3384	4	The	the	DT
18637	3384	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3384	6	will	will	MD
18637	3384	7	not	not	RB
18637	3384	8	undertake	undertake	VB
18637	3384	9	to	to	TO
18637	3384	10	assess	assess	VB
18637	3384	11	the	the	DT
18637	3384	12	relative	relative	JJ
18637	3384	13	importance	importance	NN
18637	3384	14	of	of	IN
18637	3384	15	the	the	DT
18637	3384	16	public	public	JJ
18637	3384	17	and	and	CC
18637	3384	18	private	private	JJ
18637	3384	19	functions	function	NNS
18637	3384	20	of	of	IN
18637	3384	21	a	a	DT
18637	3384	22	financial	financial	JJ
18637	3384	23	institution	institution	NN
18637	3384	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3384	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3384	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	3384	27	seen	see	VBN
18637	3384	28	fit	fit	JJ
18637	3384	29	to	to	TO
18637	3384	30	create	create	VB
18637	3384	31	.	.	.
18637	3385	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3385	2	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	3385	3	the	the	DT
18637	3385	4	act	act	NN
18637	3385	5	setting	set	VBG
18637	3385	6	up	up	RP
18637	3385	7	the	the	DT
18637	3385	8	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3385	9	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	3385	10	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	3385	11	Banks	Banks	NNPS
18637	3385	12	to	to	TO
18637	3385	13	provide	provide	VB
18637	3385	14	funds	fund	NNS
18637	3385	15	for	for	IN
18637	3385	16	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	3385	17	loans	loan	NNS
18637	3385	18	on	on	IN
18637	3385	19	agricultural	agricultural	JJ
18637	3385	20	land	land	NN
18637	3385	21	against	against	IN
18637	3385	22	the	the	DT
18637	3385	23	contention	contention	NN
18637	3385	24	that	that	IN
18637	3385	25	the	the	DT
18637	3385	26	right	right	NN
18637	3385	27	of	of	IN
18637	3385	28	the	the	DT
18637	3385	29	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	3385	30	of	of	IN
18637	3385	31	the	the	DT
18637	3385	32	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	3385	33	,	,	,
18637	3385	34	which	which	WDT
18637	3385	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3385	36	had	have	VBD
18637	3385	37	not	not	RB
18637	3385	38	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	3385	39	,	,	,
18637	3385	40	to	to	TO
18637	3385	41	use	use	VB
18637	3385	42	these	these	DT
18637	3385	43	banks	bank	NNS
18637	3385	44	as	as	IN
18637	3385	45	depositaries	depositary	NNS
18637	3385	46	of	of	IN
18637	3385	47	public	public	JJ
18637	3385	48	funds	fund	NNS
18637	3385	49	,	,	,
18637	3385	50	was	be	VBD
18637	3385	51	merely	merely	RB
18637	3385	52	a	a	DT
18637	3385	53	pretext	pretext	NN
18637	3385	54	for	for	IN
18637	3385	55	chartering	charter	VBG
18637	3385	56	these	these	DT
18637	3385	57	banks	bank	NNS
18637	3385	58	for	for	IN
18637	3385	59	private	private	JJ
18637	3385	60	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	3385	61	.	.	.
18637	3386	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3386	2	1411	1411	CD
18637	3386	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3386	4	CURRENCY	CURRENCY	VBN
18637	3386	5	REGULATIONS	regulation	NNS
18637	3386	6	Reinforced	reinforce	VBN
18637	3386	7	by	by	IN
18637	3386	8	the	the	DT
18637	3386	9	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3386	10	and	and	CC
18637	3386	11	proper	proper	JJ
18637	3386	12	clause	clause	NN
18637	3386	13	,	,	,
18637	3386	14	the	the	DT
18637	3386	15	powers	power	NNS
18637	3386	16	"	"	``
18637	3386	17	'	'	``
18637	3386	18	to	to	TO
18637	3386	19	lay	lay	VB
18637	3386	20	and	and	CC
18637	3386	21	collect	collect	VB
18637	3386	22	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3386	23	,	,	,
18637	3386	24	to	to	TO
18637	3386	25	pay	pay	VB
18637	3386	26	the	the	DT
18637	3386	27	debts	debt	NNS
18637	3386	28	and	and	CC
18637	3386	29	provide	provide	VB
18637	3386	30	for	for	IN
18637	3386	31	the	the	DT
18637	3386	32	common	common	JJ
18637	3386	33	defence	defence	NN
18637	3386	34	and	and	CC
18637	3386	35	general	general	JJ
18637	3386	36	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	3386	37	of	of	IN
18637	3386	38	the	the	DT
18637	3386	39	United	United	NNP
18637	3386	40	States	States	NNP
18637	3386	41	,	,	,
18637	3386	42	'	'	''
18637	3386	43	and	and	CC
18637	3386	44	'	'	``
18637	3386	45	to	to	TO
18637	3386	46	borrow	borrow	VB
18637	3386	47	money	money	NN
18637	3386	48	on	on	IN
18637	3386	49	the	the	DT
18637	3386	50	credit	credit	NN
18637	3386	51	of	of	IN
18637	3386	52	the	the	DT
18637	3386	53	United	United	NNP
18637	3386	54	States	States	NNP
18637	3386	55	and	and	CC
18637	3386	56	to	to	TO
18637	3386	57	coin	coin	VB
18637	3386	58	money	money	NN
18637	3386	59	and	and	CC
18637	3386	60	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	3386	61	the	the	DT
18637	3386	62	value	value	NN
18637	3386	63	thereof	thereof	IN
18637	3386	64	*	*	NFP
18637	3386	65	*	*	NFP
18637	3386	66	*	*	NFP
18637	3386	67	'	'	''
18637	3386	68	"	"	''
18637	3386	69	;	;	,
18637	3386	70	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3386	71	1412	1412	CD
18637	3386	72	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3386	73	have	have	VBP
18637	3386	74	been	be	VBN
18637	3386	75	held	hold	VBN
18637	3386	76	to	to	TO
18637	3386	77	give	give	VB
18637	3386	78	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3386	79	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	3386	80	complete	complete	JJ
18637	3386	81	control	control	NN
18637	3386	82	over	over	IN
18637	3386	83	money	money	NN
18637	3386	84	and	and	CC
18637	3386	85	currency	currency	NN
18637	3386	86	.	.	.
18637	3387	1	A	a	DT
18637	3387	2	prohibitive	prohibitive	JJ
18637	3387	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	3387	4	on	on	IN
18637	3387	5	the	the	DT
18637	3387	6	notes	note	NNS
18637	3387	7	of	of	IN
18637	3387	8	State	State	NNP
18637	3387	9	banks;[1413	banks;[1413	XX
18637	3387	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3387	11	the	the	DT
18637	3387	12	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	3387	13	of	of	IN
18637	3387	14	treasury	treasury	NNP
18637	3387	15	notes	note	NNS
18637	3387	16	impressed	impressed	JJ
18637	3387	17	with	with	IN
18637	3387	18	the	the	DT
18637	3387	19	quality	quality	NN
18637	3387	20	of	of	IN
18637	3387	21	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3387	22	tender	tender	NN
18637	3387	23	in	in	IN
18637	3387	24	payment	payment	NN
18637	3387	25	of	of	IN
18637	3387	26	private	private	JJ
18637	3387	27	debts[1414	debts[1414	NNP
18637	3387	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3387	29	and	and	CC
18637	3387	30	the	the	DT
18637	3387	31	abrogation	abrogation	NN
18637	3387	32	of	of	IN
18637	3387	33	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	3387	34	in	in	IN
18637	3387	35	private	private	JJ
18637	3387	36	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3387	37	which	which	WDT
18637	3387	38	called	call	VBD
18637	3387	39	for	for	IN
18637	3387	40	payment	payment	NN
18637	3387	41	in	in	IN
18637	3387	42	gold	gold	NN
18637	3387	43	coin,[1415	coin,[1415	NNP
18637	3387	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3387	45	were	be	VBD
18637	3387	46	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	3387	47	as	as	IN
18637	3387	48	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	3387	49	measures	measure	NNS
18637	3387	50	for	for	IN
18637	3387	51	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	3387	52	into	into	IN
18637	3387	53	effect	effect	NN
18637	3387	54	some	some	DT
18637	3387	55	or	or	CC
18637	3387	56	all	all	DT
18637	3387	57	of	of	IN
18637	3387	58	the	the	DT
18637	3387	59	foregoing	forego	VBG
18637	3387	60	powers	power	NNS
18637	3387	61	.	.	.
18637	3388	1	POWER	power	NN
18637	3388	2	TO	to	TO
18637	3388	3	CHARTER	charter	NN
18637	3388	4	CORPORATIONS	corporations	NN
18637	3388	5	In	in	IN
18637	3388	6	addition	addition	NN
18637	3388	7	to	to	IN
18637	3388	8	the	the	DT
18637	3388	9	creation	creation	NN
18637	3388	10	of	of	IN
18637	3388	11	banks	bank	NNS
18637	3388	12	,	,	,
18637	3388	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3388	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	3388	15	been	be	VBN
18637	3388	16	held	hold	VBN
18637	3388	17	to	to	TO
18637	3388	18	have	have	VB
18637	3388	19	authority	authority	NN
18637	3388	20	to	to	TO
18637	3388	21	charter	charter	VB
18637	3388	22	a	a	DT
18637	3388	23	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	3388	24	corporation,[1416	corporation,[1416	NNP
18637	3388	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3388	26	or	or	CC
18637	3388	27	a	a	DT
18637	3388	28	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3388	29	to	to	TO
18637	3388	30	construct	construct	VB
18637	3388	31	an	an	DT
18637	3388	32	interstate	interstate	NN
18637	3388	33	bridge,[1417	bridge,[1417	NN
18637	3388	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3388	35	as	as	IN
18637	3388	36	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	3388	37	for	for	IN
18637	3388	38	promoting	promote	VBG
18637	3388	39	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	3388	40	among	among	IN
18637	3388	41	the	the	DT
18637	3388	42	States	States	NNP
18637	3388	43	,	,	,
18637	3388	44	and	and	CC
18637	3388	45	to	to	TO
18637	3388	46	create	create	VB
18637	3388	47	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	3388	48	to	to	TO
18637	3388	49	manufacture	manufacture	VB
18637	3388	50	aircraft[1418	aircraft[1418	NNP
18637	3388	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3388	52	or	or	CC
18637	3388	53	merchant	merchant	VB
18637	3388	54	vessels[1419	vessels[1419	NNP
18637	3388	55	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3388	56	as	as	IN
18637	3388	57	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	3388	58	to	to	IN
18637	3388	59	the	the	DT
18637	3388	60	war	war	NN
18637	3388	61	power	power	NN
18637	3388	62	.	.	.
18637	3389	1	COURTS	courts	NN
18637	3389	2	AND	and	CC
18637	3389	3	JUDICIAL	judicial	NN
18637	3389	4	PROCEEDINGS	proceeding	NNS
18637	3389	5	Inasmuch	Inasmuch	NNP
18637	3389	6	as	as	IN
18637	3389	7	the	the	DT
18637	3389	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3389	9	"	"	''
18637	3389	10	delineated	delineate	VBD
18637	3389	11	only	only	RB
18637	3389	12	the	the	DT
18637	3389	13	great	great	JJ
18637	3389	14	outlines	outline	NNS
18637	3389	15	of	of	IN
18637	3389	16	the	the	DT
18637	3389	17	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3389	18	power	power	NN
18637	3389	19	*	*	NFP
18637	3389	20	*	*	NFP
18637	3389	21	*	*	NFP
18637	3389	22	,	,	,
18637	3389	23	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	3389	24	the	the	DT
18637	3389	25	details	detail	NNS
18637	3389	26	to	to	IN
18637	3389	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3389	28	,	,	,
18637	3389	29	*	*	NFP
18637	3389	30	*	*	NFP
18637	3389	31	*	*	NFP
18637	3389	32	The	the	DT
18637	3389	33	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	3389	34	and	and	CC
18637	3389	35	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	3389	36	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3389	37	of	of	IN
18637	3389	38	the	the	DT
18637	3389	39	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3389	40	power	power	NN
18637	3389	41	must	must	MD
18637	3389	42	*	*	NFP
18637	3389	43	*	*	NFP
18637	3389	44	*	*	NFP
18637	3389	45	be	be	VB
18637	3389	46	made	make	VBN
18637	3389	47	by	by	IN
18637	3389	48	laws	law	NNS
18637	3389	49	passed	pass	VBN
18637	3389	50	by	by	IN
18637	3389	51	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3389	52	,	,	,
18637	3389	53	*	*	NFP
18637	3389	54	*	*	NFP
18637	3389	55	*	*	NFP
18637	3389	56	"	"	''
18637	3389	57	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3389	58	1420	1420	CD
18637	3389	59	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3389	60	As	as	IN
18637	3389	61	a	a	DT
18637	3389	62	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3389	63	and	and	CC
18637	3389	64	proper	proper	JJ
18637	3389	65	provision	provision	NN
18637	3389	66	for	for	IN
18637	3389	67	the	the	DT
18637	3389	68	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3389	69	of	of	IN
18637	3389	70	the	the	DT
18637	3389	71	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3389	72	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	3389	73	by	by	IN
18637	3389	74	article	article	NN
18637	3389	75	III	III	NNP
18637	3389	76	,	,	,
18637	3389	77	section	section	NN
18637	3389	78	2	2	CD
18637	3389	79	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3389	80	may	may	MD
18637	3389	81	direct	direct	VB
18637	3389	82	the	the	DT
18637	3389	83	removal	removal	NN
18637	3389	84	from	from	IN
18637	3389	85	a	a	DT
18637	3389	86	State	state	NN
18637	3389	87	to	to	IN
18637	3389	88	a	a	DT
18637	3389	89	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3389	90	court	court	NN
18637	3389	91	of	of	IN
18637	3389	92	a	a	DT
18637	3389	93	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	3389	94	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	3389	95	against	against	IN
18637	3389	96	a	a	DT
18637	3389	97	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3389	98	officer	officer	NN
18637	3389	99	for	for	IN
18637	3389	100	acts	act	NNS
18637	3389	101	done	do	VBN
18637	3389	102	under	under	IN
18637	3389	103	color	color	NN
18637	3389	104	of	of	IN
18637	3389	105	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3389	106	law,[1421	law,[1421	ADD
18637	3389	107	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3389	108	and	and	CC
18637	3389	109	may	may	MD
18637	3389	110	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	3389	111	the	the	DT
18637	3389	112	removal	removal	NN
18637	3389	113	before	before	IN
18637	3389	114	trial	trial	NN
18637	3389	115	of	of	IN
18637	3389	116	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3389	117	cases	case	NNS
18637	3389	118	arising	arise	VBG
18637	3389	119	under	under	IN
18637	3389	120	the	the	DT
18637	3389	121	laws	law	NNS
18637	3389	122	of	of	IN
18637	3389	123	the	the	DT
18637	3389	124	United	United	NNP
18637	3389	125	States	States	NNP
18637	3389	126	.	.	.
18637	3390	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3390	2	1422	1422	CD
18637	3390	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3390	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3390	5	may	may	MD
18637	3390	6	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	3390	7	the	the	DT
18637	3390	8	effect	effect	NN
18637	3390	9	to	to	TO
18637	3390	10	be	be	VB
18637	3390	11	given	give	VBN
18637	3390	12	to	to	IN
18637	3390	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3390	14	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	3390	15	of	of	IN
18637	3390	16	the	the	DT
18637	3390	17	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3390	18	courts,[1423	courts,[1423	NNP
18637	3390	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3390	20	and	and	CC
18637	3390	21	may	may	MD
18637	3390	22	make	make	VB
18637	3390	23	all	all	DT
18637	3390	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	3390	25	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3390	26	for	for	IN
18637	3390	27	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	3390	28	into	into	IN
18637	3390	29	execution	execution	NN
18637	3390	30	the	the	DT
18637	3390	31	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	3390	32	of	of	IN
18637	3390	33	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3390	34	courts	court	NNS
18637	3390	35	.	.	.
18637	3391	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3391	2	1424	1424	CD
18637	3391	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3391	4	When	when	WRB
18637	3391	5	a	a	DT
18637	3391	6	territory	territory	NN
18637	3391	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	3391	8	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	3391	9	as	as	IN
18637	3391	10	a	a	DT
18637	3391	11	State	State	NNP
18637	3391	12	,	,	,
18637	3391	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3391	14	may	may	MD
18637	3391	15	designate	designate	VB
18637	3391	16	the	the	DT
18637	3391	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3391	18	to	to	TO
18637	3391	19	which	which	WDT
18637	3391	20	the	the	DT
18637	3391	21	records	record	NNS
18637	3391	22	of	of	IN
18637	3391	23	the	the	DT
18637	3391	24	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	3391	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	3391	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	3391	27	be	be	VB
18637	3391	28	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	3391	29	,	,	,
18637	3391	30	and	and	CC
18637	3391	31	may	may	MD
18637	3391	32	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	3391	33	the	the	DT
18637	3391	34	mode	mode	NN
18637	3391	35	for	for	IN
18637	3391	36	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	3391	37	and	and	CC
18637	3391	38	review	review	NN
18637	3391	39	of	of	IN
18637	3391	40	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	3391	41	rendered	render	VBN
18637	3391	42	by	by	IN
18637	3391	43	those	those	DT
18637	3391	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	3391	45	.	.	.
18637	3392	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3392	2	1425	1425	CD
18637	3392	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3392	4	In	in	IN
18637	3392	5	the	the	DT
18637	3392	6	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3392	7	of	of	IN
18637	3392	8	other	other	JJ
18637	3392	9	powers	power	NNS
18637	3392	10	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	3392	11	by	by	IN
18637	3392	12	the	the	DT
18637	3392	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3392	14	,	,	,
18637	3392	15	apart	apart	RB
18637	3392	16	from	from	IN
18637	3392	17	article	article	NN
18637	3392	18	III	III	NNP
18637	3392	19	,	,	,
18637	3392	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3392	21	may	may	MD
18637	3392	22	create	create	VB
18637	3392	23	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3392	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	3392	25	and	and	CC
18637	3392	26	"	"	``
18637	3392	27	clothe	clothe	VB
18637	3392	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3392	29	with	with	IN
18637	3392	30	functions	function	NNS
18637	3392	31	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	3392	32	essential	essential	JJ
18637	3392	33	or	or	CC
18637	3392	34	helpful	helpful	JJ
18637	3392	35	in	in	IN
18637	3392	36	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	3392	37	those	those	DT
18637	3392	38	powers	power	NNS
18637	3392	39	into	into	IN
18637	3392	40	execution	execution	NN
18637	3392	41	.	.	.
18637	3393	1	"	"	``
18637	3393	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3393	3	1426	1426	CD
18637	3393	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3393	5	SPECIAL	special	NN
18637	3393	6	ACTS	acts	NN
18637	3393	7	CONCERNING	concerning	NN
18637	3393	8	CLAIMS	claim	NNS
18637	3393	9	This	this	DT
18637	3393	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	3393	11	enables	enable	VBZ
18637	3393	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3393	13	to	to	TO
18637	3393	14	pass	pass	VB
18637	3393	15	special	special	JJ
18637	3393	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	3393	17	to	to	TO
18637	3393	18	require	require	VB
18637	3393	19	other	other	JJ
18637	3393	20	departments	department	NNS
18637	3393	21	of	of	IN
18637	3393	22	the	the	DT
18637	3393	23	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3393	24	to	to	TO
18637	3393	25	prosecute	prosecute	VB
18637	3393	26	or	or	CC
18637	3393	27	adjudicate	adjudicate	VB
18637	3393	28	particular	particular	JJ
18637	3393	29	claims	claim	NNS
18637	3393	30	,	,	,
18637	3393	31	whether	whether	IN
18637	3393	32	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	3393	33	by	by	IN
18637	3393	34	the	the	DT
18637	3393	35	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3393	36	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3393	37	or	or	CC
18637	3393	38	by	by	IN
18637	3393	39	private	private	JJ
18637	3393	40	persons	person	NNS
18637	3393	41	.	.	.
18637	3394	1	In	in	IN
18637	3394	2	1924,[1427	1924,[1427	CD
18637	3394	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3394	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3394	5	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	3394	6	a	a	DT
18637	3394	7	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	3394	8	Resolution	Resolution	NNP
18637	3394	9	directing	direct	VBG
18637	3394	10	the	the	DT
18637	3394	11	President	President	NNP
18637	3394	12	to	to	TO
18637	3394	13	cause	cause	VB
18637	3394	14	suit	suit	NN
18637	3394	15	to	to	TO
18637	3394	16	be	be	VB
18637	3394	17	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	3394	18	for	for	IN
18637	3394	19	the	the	DT
18637	3394	20	cancellation	cancellation	NN
18637	3394	21	of	of	IN
18637	3394	22	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3394	23	oil	oil	NN
18637	3394	24	leases	lease	NNS
18637	3394	25	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	3394	26	to	to	TO
18637	3394	27	have	have	VB
18637	3394	28	been	be	VBN
18637	3394	29	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	3394	30	from	from	IN
18637	3394	31	the	the	DT
18637	3394	32	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3394	33	by	by	IN
18637	3394	34	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	3394	35	,	,	,
18637	3394	36	and	and	CC
18637	3394	37	to	to	TO
18637	3394	38	prosecute	prosecute	VB
18637	3394	39	such	such	JJ
18637	3394	40	other	other	JJ
18637	3394	41	actions	action	NNS
18637	3394	42	and	and	CC
18637	3394	43	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	3394	44	,	,	,
18637	3394	45	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3394	46	and	and	CC
18637	3394	47	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	3394	48	,	,	,
18637	3394	49	as	as	IN
18637	3394	50	were	be	VBD
18637	3394	51	warranted	warrant	VBN
18637	3394	52	by	by	IN
18637	3394	53	the	the	DT
18637	3394	54	facts	fact	NNS
18637	3394	55	.	.	.
18637	3395	1	This	this	DT
18637	3395	2	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	3395	3	also	also	RB
18637	3395	4	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	3395	5	the	the	DT
18637	3395	6	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	3395	7	of	of	IN
18637	3395	8	special	special	JJ
18637	3395	9	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	3395	10	to	to	TO
18637	3395	11	have	have	VB
18637	3395	12	charge	charge	NN
18637	3395	13	of	of	IN
18637	3395	14	such	such	JJ
18637	3395	15	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	3395	16	.	.	.
18637	3396	1	Private	private	JJ
18637	3396	2	acts	act	NNS
18637	3396	3	providing	provide	VBG
18637	3396	4	for	for	IN
18637	3396	5	a	a	DT
18637	3396	6	review	review	NN
18637	3396	7	of	of	IN
18637	3396	8	an	an	DT
18637	3396	9	order	order	NN
18637	3396	10	for	for	IN
18637	3396	11	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	3396	12	under	under	IN
18637	3396	13	the	the	DT
18637	3396	14	Longshoreman	Longshoreman	NNP
18637	3396	15	's	's	POS
18637	3396	16	and	and	CC
18637	3396	17	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	3396	18	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	3396	19	'	'	POS
18637	3396	20	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	3396	21	Act,[1428	Act,[1428	NNP
18637	3396	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3396	23	or	or	CC
18637	3396	24	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	3396	25	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3396	26	upon	upon	IN
18637	3396	27	the	the	DT
18637	3396	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3396	29	of	of	IN
18637	3396	30	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	3396	31	to	to	TO
18637	3396	32	hear	hear	VB
18637	3396	33	and	and	CC
18637	3396	34	determine	determine	VB
18637	3396	35	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3396	36	claims	claim	NNS
18637	3396	37	of	of	IN
18637	3396	38	a	a	DT
18637	3396	39	contractor	contractor	NN
18637	3396	40	against	against	IN
18637	3396	41	the	the	DT
18637	3396	42	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3396	43	,	,	,
18637	3396	44	in	in	IN
18637	3396	45	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	3396	46	with	with	IN
18637	3396	47	directions	direction	NNS
18637	3396	48	given	give	VBN
18637	3396	49	by	by	IN
18637	3396	50	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3396	51	,	,	,
18637	3396	52	after	after	IN
18637	3396	53	that	that	DT
18637	3396	54	court	court	NN
18637	3396	55	had	have	VBD
18637	3396	56	denied	deny	VBN
18637	3396	57	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	3396	58	on	on	IN
18637	3396	59	such	such	JJ
18637	3396	60	claims	claim	NNS
18637	3396	61	,	,	,
18637	3396	62	have	have	VBP
18637	3396	63	been	be	VBN
18637	3396	64	held	hold	VBN
18637	3396	65	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3396	66	.	.	.
18637	3397	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3397	2	1429	1429	CD
18637	3397	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3397	4	MARITIME	MARITIME	NNP
18637	3397	5	LAW	LAW	NNP
18637	3397	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3397	7	may	may	MD
18637	3397	8	implement	implement	VB
18637	3397	9	the	the	DT
18637	3397	10	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	3397	11	and	and	CC
18637	3397	12	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	3397	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3397	14	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	3397	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	3397	16	the	the	DT
18637	3397	17	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3397	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	3397	19	by	by	IN
18637	3397	20	revising	revise	VBG
18637	3397	21	and	and	CC
18637	3397	22	amending	amend	VBG
18637	3397	23	the	the	DT
18637	3397	24	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	3397	25	law	law	NN
18637	3397	26	which	which	WDT
18637	3397	27	existed	exist	VBD
18637	3397	28	at	at	IN
18637	3397	29	the	the	DT
18637	3397	30	time	time	NN
18637	3397	31	the	the	DT
18637	3397	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3397	33	was	be	VBD
18637	3397	34	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	3397	35	,	,	,
18637	3397	36	but	but	CC
18637	3397	37	in	in	IN
18637	3397	38	so	so	RB
18637	3397	39	doing	do	VBG
18637	3397	40	,	,	,
18637	3397	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3397	42	can	can	MD
18637	3397	43	not	not	RB
18637	3397	44	go	go	VB
18637	3397	45	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	3397	46	the	the	DT
18637	3397	47	reach	reach	NN
18637	3397	48	of	of	IN
18637	3397	49	that	that	DT
18637	3397	50	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3397	51	.	.	.
18637	3398	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3398	2	1430	1430	CD
18637	3398	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3398	4	This	this	DT
18637	3398	5	power	power	NN
18637	3398	6	can	can	MD
18637	3398	7	not	not	RB
18637	3398	8	be	be	VB
18637	3398	9	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	3398	10	to	to	IN
18637	3398	11	the	the	DT
18637	3398	12	States	States	NNPS
18637	3398	13	;	;	:
18637	3398	14	hence	hence	RB
18637	3398	15	acts	act	NNS
18637	3398	16	of	of	IN
18637	3398	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3398	18	which	which	WDT
18637	3398	19	purported	purport	VBD
18637	3398	20	to	to	TO
18637	3398	21	make	make	VB
18637	3398	22	State	State	NNP
18637	3398	23	Workmen	Workmen	NNP
18637	3398	24	's	's	POS
18637	3398	25	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	3398	26	laws	law	NNS
18637	3398	27	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	3398	28	to	to	IN
18637	3398	29	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	3398	30	cases	case	NNS
18637	3398	31	were	be	VBD
18637	3398	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	3398	33	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	3398	34	.	.	.
18637	3399	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3399	2	1431	1431	CD
18637	3399	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3399	4	Section	section	NN
18637	3399	5	9	9	CD
18637	3399	6	.	.	.
18637	3400	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3400	2	1	1	CD
18637	3400	3	.	.	.
18637	3401	1	The	the	DT
18637	3401	2	Migration	Migration	NNP
18637	3401	3	or	or	CC
18637	3401	4	Importation	Importation	NNP
18637	3401	5	of	of	IN
18637	3401	6	such	such	JJ
18637	3401	7	Persons	Persons	NNP
18637	3401	8	as	as	IN
18637	3401	9	any	any	DT
18637	3401	10	of	of	IN
18637	3401	11	the	the	DT
18637	3401	12	States	States	NNP
18637	3401	13	now	now	RB
18637	3401	14	existing	exist	VBG
18637	3401	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	3401	16	think	think	VB
18637	3401	17	proper	proper	JJ
18637	3401	18	to	to	TO
18637	3401	19	admit	admit	VB
18637	3401	20	,	,	,
18637	3401	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	3401	22	not	not	RB
18637	3401	23	be	be	VB
18637	3401	24	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	3401	25	by	by	IN
18637	3401	26	the	the	DT
18637	3401	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3401	28	prior	prior	RB
18637	3401	29	to	to	IN
18637	3401	30	the	the	DT
18637	3401	31	Year	Year	NNP
18637	3401	32	one	one	CD
18637	3401	33	thousand	thousand	CD
18637	3401	34	eight	eight	CD
18637	3401	35	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	3401	36	and	and	CC
18637	3401	37	eight	eight	CD
18637	3401	38	,	,	,
18637	3401	39	but	but	CC
18637	3401	40	a	a	DT
18637	3401	41	Tax	tax	NN
18637	3401	42	or	or	CC
18637	3401	43	duty	duty	NN
18637	3401	44	may	may	MD
18637	3401	45	be	be	VB
18637	3401	46	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	3401	47	on	on	IN
18637	3401	48	such	such	JJ
18637	3401	49	Importation	Importation	NNP
18637	3401	50	,	,	,
18637	3401	51	not	not	RB
18637	3401	52	exceeding	exceed	VBG
18637	3401	53	ten	ten	CD
18637	3401	54	dollars	dollar	NNS
18637	3401	55	for	for	IN
18637	3401	56	each	each	DT
18637	3401	57	Person	person	NN
18637	3401	58	.	.	.
18637	3402	1	Powers	power	NNS
18637	3402	2	Denied	deny	VBN
18637	3402	3	to	to	IN
18637	3402	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3402	5	GENERAL	GENERAL	NNP
18637	3402	6	PURPOSE	PURPOSE	NNP
18637	3402	7	OF	of	IN
18637	3402	8	THE	the	DT
18637	3402	9	SECTION	section	NN
18637	3402	10	This	this	DT
18637	3402	11	section	section	NN
18637	3402	12	of	of	IN
18637	3402	13	the	the	DT
18637	3402	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3402	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3402	16	containing	contain	VBG
18637	3402	17	eight	eight	CD
18637	3402	18	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	3402	19	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	3402	20	or	or	CC
18637	3402	21	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	3402	22	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3402	23	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	3402	24	the	the	DT
18637	3402	25	importation	importation	NN
18637	3402	26	of	of	IN
18637	3402	27	slaves	slave	NNS
18637	3402	28	,	,	,
18637	3402	29	the	the	DT
18637	3402	30	suspension	suspension	NN
18637	3402	31	of	of	IN
18637	3402	32	the	the	DT
18637	3402	33	writ	writ	NNP
18637	3402	34	of	of	IN
18637	3402	35	_	_	NNP
18637	3402	36	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	3402	37	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	3402	38	_	_	NNP
18637	3402	39	,	,	,
18637	3402	40	the	the	DT
18637	3402	41	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	3402	42	of	of	IN
18637	3402	43	bills	bill	NNS
18637	3402	44	of	of	IN
18637	3402	45	attainder	attainder	NN
18637	3402	46	or	or	CC
18637	3402	47	_	_	NNP
18637	3402	48	ex	ex	FW
18637	3402	49	post	post	FW
18637	3402	50	facto	facto	FW
18637	3402	51	_	_	NNP
18637	3402	52	laws	law	NNS
18637	3402	53	,	,	,
18637	3402	54	the	the	DT
18637	3402	55	levying	levying	NN
18637	3402	56	of	of	IN
18637	3402	57	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3402	58	on	on	IN
18637	3402	59	exports	export	NNS
18637	3402	60	,	,	,
18637	3402	61	the	the	DT
18637	3402	62	granting	granting	NN
18637	3402	63	of	of	IN
18637	3402	64	preference	preference	NN
18637	3402	65	to	to	IN
18637	3402	66	ports	port	NNS
18637	3402	67	of	of	IN
18637	3402	68	one	one	CD
18637	3402	69	State	State	NNP
18637	3402	70	over	over	IN
18637	3402	71	another	another	DT
18637	3402	72	,	,	,
18637	3402	73	the	the	DT
18637	3402	74	granting	granting	NN
18637	3402	75	of	of	IN
18637	3402	76	titles	title	NNS
18637	3402	77	of	of	IN
18637	3402	78	nobility	nobility	NN
18637	3402	79	,	,	,
18637	3402	80	etc	etc	FW
18637	3402	81	.	.	.
18637	3402	82	,	,	,
18637	3402	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3402	84	is	be	VBZ
18637	3402	85	devoted	devote	VBN
18637	3402	86	to	to	IN
18637	3402	87	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	3402	88	upon	upon	IN
18637	3402	89	the	the	DT
18637	3402	90	power	power	NN
18637	3402	91	of	of	IN
18637	3402	92	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3402	93	and	and	CC
18637	3402	94	of	of	IN
18637	3402	95	the	the	DT
18637	3402	96	National	National	NNP
18637	3402	97	Government,[1432	government,[1432	CD
18637	3402	98	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3402	99	and	and	CC
18637	3402	100	in	in	IN
18637	3402	101	no	no	DT
18637	3402	102	respect	respect	NN
18637	3402	103	affects	affect	VBZ
18637	3402	104	the	the	DT
18637	3402	105	States	States	NNPS
18637	3402	106	in	in	IN
18637	3402	107	the	the	DT
18637	3402	108	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	3402	109	of	of	IN
18637	3402	110	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3402	111	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	3402	112	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	3402	113	.	.	.
18637	3403	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3403	2	1433	1433	CD
18637	3403	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3403	4	The	the	DT
18637	3403	5	above	above	JJ
18637	3403	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	3403	7	,	,	,
18637	3403	8	which	which	WDT
18637	3403	9	sanctioned	sanction	VBD
18637	3403	10	the	the	DT
18637	3403	11	importation	importation	NN
18637	3403	12	of	of	IN
18637	3403	13	slaves	slave	NNS
18637	3403	14	by	by	IN
18637	3403	15	the	the	DT
18637	3403	16	States	States	NNP
18637	3403	17	for	for	IN
18637	3403	18	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	3403	19	years	year	NNS
18637	3403	20	after	after	IN
18637	3403	21	the	the	DT
18637	3403	22	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	3403	23	of	of	IN
18637	3403	24	the	the	DT
18637	3403	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3403	26	,	,	,
18637	3403	27	when	when	WRB
18637	3403	28	considered	consider	VBN
18637	3403	29	with	with	IN
18637	3403	30	the	the	DT
18637	3403	31	section	section	NN
18637	3403	32	requiring	require	VBG
18637	3403	33	escaped	escape	VBN
18637	3403	34	slaves	slave	NNS
18637	3403	35	to	to	TO
18637	3403	36	be	be	VB
18637	3403	37	returned	return	VBN
18637	3403	38	to	to	IN
18637	3403	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3403	40	masters	master	NNS
18637	3403	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3403	42	art	art	NN
18637	3403	43	.	.	.
18637	3404	1	IV	IV	NNP
18637	3404	2	,	,	,
18637	3404	3	§	§	NNP
18637	3404	4	1	1	CD
18637	3404	5	,	,	,
18637	3404	6	cl	cl	IN
18637	3404	7	.	.	.
18637	3405	1	3	3	LS
18637	3405	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3405	3	,	,	,
18637	3405	4	was	be	VBD
18637	3405	5	held	hold	VBN
18637	3405	6	by	by	IN
18637	3405	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3405	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3405	9	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	3405	10	in	in	IN
18637	3405	11	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	3405	12	_	_	NNP
18637	3405	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	3405	14	_	_	NNP
18637	3405	15	Sanford,[1434	Sanford,[1434	NNP
18637	3405	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3405	17	to	to	TO
18637	3405	18	show	show	VB
18637	3405	19	conclusively	conclusively	RB
18637	3405	20	that	that	IN
18637	3405	21	such	such	JJ
18637	3405	22	persons	person	NNS
18637	3405	23	and	and	CC
18637	3405	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3405	25	descendants	descendant	NNS
18637	3405	26	were	be	VBD
18637	3405	27	not	not	RB
18637	3405	28	embraced	embrace	VBN
18637	3405	29	within	within	IN
18637	3405	30	the	the	DT
18637	3405	31	term	term	NN
18637	3405	32	"	"	``
18637	3405	33	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	3405	34	"	"	''
18637	3405	35	as	as	IN
18637	3405	36	used	use	VBN
18637	3405	37	in	in	IN
18637	3405	38	the	the	DT
18637	3405	39	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3405	40	.	.	.
18637	3406	1	Today	today	NN
18637	3406	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	3406	3	interesting	interesting	JJ
18637	3406	4	only	only	RB
18637	3406	5	as	as	IN
18637	3406	6	an	an	DT
18637	3406	7	historical	historical	JJ
18637	3406	8	curiosity	curiosity	NN
18637	3406	9	.	.	.
18637	3407	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3407	2	2	2	CD
18637	3407	3	.	.	.
18637	3408	1	The	the	DT
18637	3408	2	Privilege	Privilege	NNP
18637	3408	3	of	of	IN
18637	3408	4	the	the	DT
18637	3408	5	Writ	Writ	NNP
18637	3408	6	of	of	IN
18637	3408	7	Habeas	Habeas	NNP
18637	3408	8	Corpus	Corpus	NNP
18637	3408	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	3408	10	not	not	RB
18637	3408	11	be	be	VB
18637	3408	12	suspended	suspend	VBN
18637	3408	13	,	,	,
18637	3408	14	unless	unless	IN
18637	3408	15	when	when	WRB
18637	3408	16	in	in	IN
18637	3408	17	Cases	case	NNS
18637	3408	18	of	of	IN
18637	3408	19	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
18637	3408	20	or	or	CC
18637	3408	21	Invasion	Invasion	NNP
18637	3408	22	the	the	DT
18637	3408	23	public	public	JJ
18637	3408	24	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	3408	25	may	may	MD
18637	3408	26	require	require	VB
18637	3408	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3408	28	.	.	.
18637	3409	1	HABEAS	HABEAS	NNP
18637	3409	2	CORPUS	CORPUS	NNP
18637	3409	3	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	3409	4	of	of	IN
18637	3409	5	the	the	DT
18637	3409	6	Writ	Writ	NNP
18637	3409	7	This	this	DT
18637	3409	8	section	section	NN
18637	3409	9	,	,	,
18637	3409	10	which	which	WDT
18637	3409	11	restricts	restrict	VBZ
18637	3409	12	only	only	RB
18637	3409	13	the	the	DT
18637	3409	14	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3409	15	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3409	16	and	and	CC
18637	3409	17	not	not	RB
18637	3409	18	the	the	DT
18637	3409	19	States,[1435	states,[1435	CD
18637	3409	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3409	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	3409	22	the	the	DT
18637	3409	23	only	only	JJ
18637	3409	24	place	place	NN
18637	3409	25	in	in	IN
18637	3409	26	the	the	DT
18637	3409	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3409	28	where	where	WRB
18637	3409	29	the	the	DT
18637	3409	30	writ	writ	NN
18637	3409	31	of	of	IN
18637	3409	32	_	_	NNP
18637	3409	33	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	3409	34	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	3409	35	_	_	NNP
18637	3409	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	3409	37	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	3409	38	.	.	.
18637	3410	1	The	the	DT
18637	3410	2	framers	framer	NNS
18637	3410	3	took	take	VBD
18637	3410	4	for	for	IN
18637	3410	5	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3410	6	that	that	IN
18637	3410	7	the	the	DT
18637	3410	8	courts	court	NNS
18637	3410	9	of	of	IN
18637	3410	10	the	the	DT
18637	3410	11	United	United	NNP
18637	3410	12	States	States	NNP
18637	3410	13	would	would	MD
18637	3410	14	be	be	VB
18637	3410	15	given	give	VBN
18637	3410	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3410	17	to	to	TO
18637	3410	18	issue	issue	VB
18637	3410	19	this	this	DT
18637	3410	20	,	,	,
18637	3410	21	the	the	DT
18637	3410	22	greatest	great	JJS
18637	3410	23	of	of	IN
18637	3410	24	the	the	DT
18637	3410	25	safeguards	safeguard	NNS
18637	3410	26	of	of	IN
18637	3410	27	personal	personal	JJ
18637	3410	28	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	3410	29	embodied	embody	VBN
18637	3410	30	in	in	IN
18637	3410	31	the	the	DT
18637	3410	32	common	common	JJ
18637	3410	33	law	law	NN
18637	3410	34	,	,	,
18637	3410	35	and	and	CC
18637	3410	36	the	the	DT
18637	3410	37	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	3410	38	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3410	39	of	of	IN
18637	3410	40	1789[1436	1789[1436	NNP
18637	3410	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3410	42	provided	provide	VBN
18637	3410	43	for	for	IN
18637	3410	44	the	the	DT
18637	3410	45	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	3410	46	of	of	IN
18637	3410	47	the	the	DT
18637	3410	48	writ	writ	VBN
18637	3410	49	according	accord	VBG
18637	3410	50	to	to	IN
18637	3410	51	"	"	``
18637	3410	52	the	the	DT
18637	3410	53	usages	usage	NNS
18637	3410	54	and	and	CC
18637	3410	55	principles	principle	NNS
18637	3410	56	of	of	IN
18637	3410	57	law	law	NN
18637	3410	58	.	.	.
18637	3410	59	"	"	''
18637	3411	1	At	at	IN
18637	3411	2	common	common	JJ
18637	3411	3	law	law	NN
18637	3411	4	the	the	DT
18637	3411	5	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3411	6	of	of	IN
18637	3411	7	such	such	PDT
18637	3411	8	a	a	DT
18637	3411	9	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	3411	10	was	be	VBD
18637	3411	11	to	to	TO
18637	3411	12	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	3411	13	the	the	DT
18637	3411	14	liberation	liberation	NN
18637	3411	15	of	of	IN
18637	3411	16	persons	person	NNS
18637	3411	17	who	who	WP
18637	3411	18	were	be	VBD
18637	3411	19	imprisoned	imprison	VBN
18637	3411	20	without	without	IN
18637	3411	21	just	just	RB
18637	3411	22	cause	cause	NN
18637	3411	23	.	.	.
18637	3412	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3412	2	1437	1437	CD
18637	3412	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3412	4	While	while	IN
18637	3412	5	the	the	DT
18637	3412	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3412	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3412	8	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	3412	9	at	at	IN
18637	3412	10	an	an	DT
18637	3412	11	early	early	JJ
18637	3412	12	date	date	NN
18637	3412	13	that	that	IN
18637	3412	14	the	the	DT
18637	3412	15	authority	authority	NN
18637	3412	16	of	of	IN
18637	3412	17	the	the	DT
18637	3412	18	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3412	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	3412	20	to	to	TO
18637	3412	21	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	3412	22	petitions	petition	NNS
18637	3412	23	for	for	IN
18637	3412	24	_	_	NNP
18637	3412	25	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	3412	26	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	3412	27	_	_	NNP
18637	3412	28	derived	derive	VBD
18637	3412	29	solely	solely	RB
18637	3412	30	from	from	IN
18637	3412	31	acts	act	NNS
18637	3412	32	of	of	IN
18637	3412	33	Congress,[1438	congress,[1438	CD
18637	3412	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3412	35	a	a	DT
18637	3412	36	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	3412	37	majority	majority	NN
18637	3412	38	recently	recently	RB
18637	3412	39	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	3412	40	the	the	DT
18637	3412	41	right	right	NN
18637	3412	42	to	to	TO
18637	3412	43	expand	expand	VB
18637	3412	44	the	the	DT
18637	3412	45	scope	scope	NN
18637	3412	46	of	of	IN
18637	3412	47	the	the	DT
18637	3412	48	writ	writ	NNP
18637	3412	49	by	by	IN
18637	3412	50	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3412	51	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	3412	52	and	and	CC
18637	3412	53	to	to	TO
18637	3412	54	sanction	sanction	VB
18637	3412	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3412	56	use	use	NN
18637	3412	57	for	for	IN
18637	3412	58	a	a	DT
18637	3412	59	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3412	60	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	3412	61	to	to	IN
18637	3412	62	the	the	DT
18637	3412	63	common	common	JJ
18637	3412	64	law	law	NN
18637	3412	65	,	,	,
18637	3412	66	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	3412	67	,	,	,
18637	3412	68	to	to	TO
18637	3412	69	bring	bring	VB
18637	3412	70	a	a	DT
18637	3412	71	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	3412	72	into	into	IN
18637	3412	73	court	court	NN
18637	3412	74	to	to	TO
18637	3412	75	argue	argue	VB
18637	3412	76	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3412	77	own	own	JJ
18637	3412	78	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	3412	79	.	.	.
18637	3413	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	3413	2	for	for	IN
18637	3413	3	the	the	DT
18637	3413	4	majority	majority	NN
18637	3413	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3413	6	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	3413	7	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3413	8	that	that	DT
18637	3413	9	:	:	:
18637	3413	10	"	"	``
18637	3413	11	However	however	RB
18637	3413	12	,	,	,
18637	3413	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3413	14	do	do	VBP
18637	3413	15	not	not	RB
18637	3413	16	conceive	conceive	VB
18637	3413	17	that	that	IN
18637	3413	18	a	a	DT
18637	3413	19	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	3413	20	court	court	NN
18637	3413	21	of	of	IN
18637	3413	22	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	3413	23	,	,	,
18637	3413	24	in	in	IN
18637	3413	25	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	3413	26	a	a	DT
18637	3413	27	writ	writ	NN
18637	3413	28	of	of	IN
18637	3413	29	_	_	NNP
18637	3413	30	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	3413	31	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	3413	32	_	_	NNP
18637	3413	33	under	under	IN
18637	3413	34	§	§	NNP
18637	3413	35	262	262	CD
18637	3413	36	of	of	IN
18637	3413	37	the	the	DT
18637	3413	38	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	3413	39	Code	Code	NNP
18637	3413	40	,	,	,
18637	3413	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	3413	42	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	3413	43	confined	confine	VBN
18637	3413	44	to	to	IN
18637	3413	45	the	the	DT
18637	3413	46	precise	precise	JJ
18637	3413	47	forms	form	NNS
18637	3413	48	of	of	IN
18637	3413	49	that	that	DT
18637	3413	50	writ	writ	VBN
18637	3413	51	in	in	IN
18637	3413	52	vogue	vogue	NN
18637	3413	53	at	at	IN
18637	3413	54	the	the	DT
18637	3413	55	common	common	JJ
18637	3413	56	law	law	NN
18637	3413	57	or	or	CC
18637	3413	58	in	in	IN
18637	3413	59	the	the	DT
18637	3413	60	English	english	JJ
18637	3413	61	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3413	62	system	system	NN
18637	3413	63	.	.	.
18637	3414	1	Section	section	NN
18637	3414	2	262	262	CD
18637	3414	3	says	say	VBZ
18637	3414	4	that	that	IN
18637	3414	5	the	the	DT
18637	3414	6	writ	writ	NNP
18637	3414	7	must	must	MD
18637	3414	8	be	be	VB
18637	3414	9	agreeable	agreeable	JJ
18637	3414	10	to	to	IN
18637	3414	11	the	the	DT
18637	3414	12	usages	usage	NNS
18637	3414	13	and	and	CC
18637	3414	14	principles	principle	NNS
18637	3414	15	of	of	IN
18637	3414	16	'	'	``
18637	3414	17	law	law	NN
18637	3414	18	,	,	,
18637	3414	19	'	'	''
18637	3414	20	a	a	DT
18637	3414	21	term	term	NN
18637	3414	22	which	which	WDT
18637	3414	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	3414	24	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	3414	25	by	by	IN
18637	3414	26	the	the	DT
18637	3414	27	common	common	JJ
18637	3414	28	law	law	NN
18637	3414	29	or	or	CC
18637	3414	30	the	the	DT
18637	3414	31	English	english	JJ
18637	3414	32	law	law	NN
18637	3414	33	.	.	.
18637	3415	1	And	and	CC
18637	3415	2	since	since	IN
18637	3415	3	'	'	``
18637	3415	4	law	law	NN
18637	3415	5	'	'	''
18637	3415	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	3415	7	not	not	RB
18637	3415	8	a	a	DT
18637	3415	9	static	static	JJ
18637	3415	10	concept	concept	NN
18637	3415	11	,	,	,
18637	3415	12	but	but	CC
18637	3415	13	expands	expand	VBZ
18637	3415	14	and	and	CC
18637	3415	15	develops	develop	VBZ
18637	3415	16	as	as	IN
18637	3415	17	new	new	JJ
18637	3415	18	problems	problem	NNS
18637	3415	19	arise	arise	VBP
18637	3415	20	,	,	,
18637	3415	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3415	22	do	do	VBP
18637	3415	23	not	not	RB
18637	3415	24	believe	believe	VB
18637	3415	25	that	that	IN
18637	3415	26	the	the	DT
18637	3415	27	forms	form	NNS
18637	3415	28	of	of	IN
18637	3415	29	the	the	DT
18637	3415	30	_	_	NNP
18637	3415	31	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	3415	32	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	3415	33	_	_	NNP
18637	3415	34	writ	writ	NN
18637	3415	35	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	3415	36	by	by	IN
18637	3415	37	§	§	NNP
18637	3415	38	262	262	CD
18637	3415	39	are	be	VBP
18637	3415	40	only	only	RB
18637	3415	41	those	those	DT
18637	3415	42	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	3415	43	in	in	IN
18637	3415	44	this	this	DT
18637	3415	45	country	country	NN
18637	3415	46	in	in	IN
18637	3415	47	1789	1789	CD
18637	3415	48	,	,	,
18637	3415	49	when	when	WRB
18637	3415	50	the	the	DT
18637	3415	51	original	original	JJ
18637	3415	52	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	3415	53	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3415	54	containing	contain	VBG
18637	3415	55	the	the	DT
18637	3415	56	substance	substance	NN
18637	3415	57	of	of	IN
18637	3415	58	this	this	DT
18637	3415	59	section	section	NN
18637	3415	60	came	come	VBD
18637	3415	61	into	into	IN
18637	3415	62	existence	existence	NN
18637	3415	63	.	.	.
18637	3416	1	"	"	``
18637	3416	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3416	3	1439	1439	CD
18637	3416	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3416	5	Errors	error	NNS
18637	3416	6	Which	which	WDT
18637	3416	7	May	May	MD
18637	3416	8	Be	be	VB
18637	3416	9	Corrected	correct	VBN
18637	3416	10	on	on	IN
18637	3416	11	Habeas	Habeas	NNP
18637	3416	12	Corpus	Corpus	NNP
18637	3416	13	The	the	DT
18637	3416	14	writ	writ	NN
18637	3416	15	of	of	IN
18637	3416	16	_	_	NNP
18637	3416	17	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	3416	18	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	3416	19	_	_	NNP
18637	3416	20	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	3416	21	a	a	DT
18637	3416	22	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	3416	23	for	for	IN
18637	3416	24	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	3416	25	and	and	CC
18637	3416	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3416	27	errors	error	NNS
18637	3416	28	at	at	IN
18637	3416	29	the	the	DT
18637	3416	30	trial	trial	NN
18637	3416	31	without	without	IN
18637	3416	32	limit	limit	NN
18637	3416	33	as	as	IN
18637	3416	34	to	to	IN
18637	3416	35	time	time	NN
18637	3416	36	.	.	.
18637	3417	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3417	2	1440	1440	CD
18637	3417	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3417	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3417	5	may	may	MD
18637	3417	6	be	be	VB
18637	3417	7	used	use	VBN
18637	3417	8	to	to	TO
18637	3417	9	correct	correct	VB
18637	3417	10	errors	error	NNS
18637	3417	11	of	of	IN
18637	3417	12	that	that	DT
18637	3417	13	order	order	NN
18637	3417	14	made	make	VBN
18637	3417	15	by	by	IN
18637	3417	16	military	military	NN
18637	3417	17	as	as	RB
18637	3417	18	well	well	RB
18637	3417	19	as	as	IN
18637	3417	20	by	by	IN
18637	3417	21	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3417	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	3417	23	.	.	.
18637	3418	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3418	2	1441	1441	CD
18637	3418	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3418	4	Under	under	IN
18637	3418	5	the	the	DT
18637	3418	6	common	common	JJ
18637	3418	7	law	law	NN
18637	3418	8	and	and	CC
18637	3418	9	the	the	DT
18637	3418	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3418	11	31	31	CD
18637	3418	12	Car	car	NN
18637	3418	13	.	.	.
18637	3419	1	II	II	NNP
18637	3419	2	c.	c.	NN
18637	3419	3	2	2	CD
18637	3419	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3419	5	1679	1679	CD
18637	3419	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3419	7	,	,	,
18637	3419	8	where	where	WRB
18637	3419	9	a	a	DT
18637	3419	10	person	person	NN
18637	3419	11	was	be	VBD
18637	3419	12	detained	detain	VBN
18637	3419	13	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	3419	14	to	to	IN
18637	3419	15	a	a	DT
18637	3419	16	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	3419	17	by	by	IN
18637	3419	18	a	a	DT
18637	3419	19	court	court	NN
18637	3419	20	having	have	VBG
18637	3419	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3419	22	of	of	IN
18637	3419	23	the	the	DT
18637	3419	24	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3419	25	matter	matter	NN
18637	3419	26	,	,	,
18637	3419	27	_	_	NNP
18637	3419	28	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	3419	29	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	3419	30	_	_	NNP
18637	3419	31	was	be	VBD
18637	3419	32	available	available	JJ
18637	3419	33	only	only	RB
18637	3419	34	if	if	IN
18637	3419	35	a	a	DT
18637	3419	36	want	want	NN
18637	3419	37	of	of	IN
18637	3419	38	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3419	39	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	3419	40	on	on	IN
18637	3419	41	the	the	DT
18637	3419	42	face	face	NN
18637	3419	43	of	of	IN
18637	3419	44	the	the	DT
18637	3419	45	record	record	NN
18637	3419	46	of	of	IN
18637	3419	47	the	the	DT
18637	3419	48	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3419	49	which	which	WDT
18637	3419	50	convicted	convict	VBD
18637	3419	51	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3419	52	.	.	.
18637	3420	1	A	a	DT
18637	3420	2	showing	showing	NN
18637	3420	3	in	in	IN
18637	3420	4	a	a	DT
18637	3420	5	return	return	NN
18637	3420	6	to	to	IN
18637	3420	7	a	a	DT
18637	3420	8	writ	writ	NN
18637	3420	9	that	that	IN
18637	3420	10	the	the	DT
18637	3420	11	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	3420	12	was	be	VBD
18637	3420	13	held	hold	VBN
18637	3420	14	under	under	IN
18637	3420	15	final	final	JJ
18637	3420	16	process	process	NN
18637	3420	17	based	base	VBN
18637	3420	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	3420	19	a	a	DT
18637	3420	20	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	3420	21	of	of	IN
18637	3420	22	a	a	DT
18637	3420	23	court	court	NN
18637	3420	24	of	of	IN
18637	3420	25	competent	competent	JJ
18637	3420	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3420	27	closed	close	VBD
18637	3420	28	the	the	DT
18637	3420	29	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	3420	30	.	.	.
18637	3421	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3421	2	1442	1442	CD
18637	3421	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3421	4	Under	under	IN
18637	3421	5	the	the	DT
18637	3421	6	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	3421	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3421	8	of	of	IN
18637	3421	9	1789[1443	1789[1443	NNP
18637	3421	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3421	11	the	the	DT
18637	3421	12	same	same	JJ
18637	3421	13	rule	rule	NN
18637	3421	14	obtained	obtain	VBD
18637	3421	15	.	.	.
18637	3422	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3422	2	1444	1444	CD
18637	3422	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3422	4	But	but	CC
18637	3422	5	by	by	IN
18637	3422	6	the	the	DT
18637	3422	7	act	act	NN
18637	3422	8	of	of	IN
18637	3422	9	February	February	NNP
18637	3422	10	5	5	CD
18637	3422	11	,	,	,
18637	3422	12	1867,[1445	1867,[1445	CD
18637	3422	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3422	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3422	15	extended	extend	VBD
18637	3422	16	the	the	DT
18637	3422	17	writ	writ	NN
18637	3422	18	to	to	IN
18637	3422	19	all	all	DT
18637	3422	20	persons	person	NNS
18637	3422	21	restrained	restrain	VBN
18637	3422	22	of	of	IN
18637	3422	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3422	24	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	3422	25	in	in	IN
18637	3422	26	violation	violation	NN
18637	3422	27	of	of	IN
18637	3422	28	the	the	DT
18637	3422	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3422	30	or	or	CC
18637	3422	31	a	a	DT
18637	3422	32	law	law	NN
18637	3422	33	or	or	CC
18637	3422	34	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	3422	35	of	of	IN
18637	3422	36	the	the	DT
18637	3422	37	United	United	NNP
18637	3422	38	States	States	NNP
18637	3422	39	,	,	,
18637	3422	40	and	and	CC
18637	3422	41	required	require	VBD
18637	3422	42	the	the	DT
18637	3422	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3422	44	to	to	TO
18637	3422	45	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	3422	46	the	the	DT
18637	3422	47	facts	fact	NNS
18637	3422	48	and	and	CC
18637	3422	49	to	to	TO
18637	3422	50	"	"	``
18637	3422	51	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	3422	52	of	of	IN
18637	3422	53	the	the	DT
18637	3422	54	party	party	NN
18637	3422	55	as	as	IN
18637	3422	56	law	law	NN
18637	3422	57	and	and	CC
18637	3422	58	justice	justice	NN
18637	3422	59	require	require	VBP
18637	3422	60	.	.	.
18637	3422	61	"	"	''
18637	3423	1	This	this	DT
18637	3423	2	gave	give	VBD
18637	3423	3	the	the	DT
18637	3423	4	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	3423	5	a	a	DT
18637	3423	6	right	right	NN
18637	3423	7	to	to	TO
18637	3423	8	have	have	VB
18637	3423	9	a	a	DT
18637	3423	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3423	11	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	3423	12	in	in	IN
18637	3423	13	a	a	DT
18637	3423	14	court	court	NN
18637	3423	15	of	of	IN
18637	3423	16	the	the	DT
18637	3423	17	United	United	NNP
18637	3423	18	States	States	NNP
18637	3423	19	into	into	IN
18637	3423	20	the	the	DT
18637	3423	21	very	very	JJ
18637	3423	22	truth	truth	NN
18637	3423	23	and	and	CC
18637	3423	24	substance	substance	NN
18637	3423	25	of	of	IN
18637	3423	26	the	the	DT
18637	3423	27	causes	cause	NNS
18637	3423	28	of	of	IN
18637	3423	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3423	30	detention	detention	NN
18637	3423	31	.	.	.
18637	3424	1	The	the	DT
18637	3424	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3424	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3424	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	3424	5	said	say	VBN
18637	3424	6	that	that	IN
18637	3424	7	there	there	EX
18637	3424	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	3424	9	"	"	``
18637	3424	10	no	no	DT
18637	3424	11	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	3424	12	of	of	IN
18637	3424	13	the	the	DT
18637	3424	14	authority	authority	NN
18637	3424	15	of	of	IN
18637	3424	16	the	the	DT
18637	3424	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3424	18	to	to	TO
18637	3424	19	thus	thus	RB
18637	3424	20	liberalize	liberalize	VB
18637	3424	21	the	the	DT
18637	3424	22	common	common	JJ
18637	3424	23	law	law	NN
18637	3424	24	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	3424	25	on	on	IN
18637	3424	26	_	_	NNP
18637	3424	27	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	3424	28	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	3424	29	_	_	NNP
18637	3424	30	*	*	NFP
18637	3424	31	*	*	NFP
18637	3424	32	*	*	NFP
18637	3424	33	"	"	''
18637	3424	34	.	.	.
18637	3425	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3425	2	1446	1446	CD
18637	3425	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3425	4	Habeas	Habeas	NNP
18637	3425	5	Corpus	Corpus	NNP
18637	3425	6	Not	not	RB
18637	3425	7	a	a	DT
18637	3425	8	Substitute	substitute	NN
18637	3425	9	for	for	IN
18637	3425	10	Appeal	appeal	NN
18637	3425	11	Since	since	IN
18637	3425	12	the	the	DT
18637	3425	13	writ	writ	NN
18637	3425	14	of	of	IN
18637	3425	15	_	_	NNP
18637	3425	16	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	3425	17	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	3425	18	_	_	NNP
18637	3425	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	3425	20	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	3425	21	in	in	IN
18637	3425	22	nature	nature	NN
18637	3425	23	,	,	,
18637	3425	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3425	25	may	may	MD
18637	3425	26	confer	confer	VB
18637	3425	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3425	28	to	to	TO
18637	3425	29	issue	issue	VB
18637	3425	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3425	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	3425	32	the	the	DT
18637	3425	33	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3425	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3425	35	as	as	RB
18637	3425	36	well	well	RB
18637	3425	37	as	as	IN
18637	3425	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	3425	39	the	the	DT
18637	3425	40	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	3425	41	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3425	42	courts	court	NNS
18637	3425	43	.	.	.
18637	3426	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3426	2	1447	1447	CD
18637	3426	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3426	4	The	the	DT
18637	3426	5	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	3426	6	may	may	MD
18637	3426	7	not	not	RB
18637	3426	8	,	,	,
18637	3426	9	however	however	RB
18637	3426	10	,	,	,
18637	3426	11	be	be	VB
18637	3426	12	used	use	VBN
18637	3426	13	as	as	IN
18637	3426	14	a	a	DT
18637	3426	15	substitute	substitute	NN
18637	3426	16	for	for	IN
18637	3426	17	an	an	DT
18637	3426	18	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	3426	19	or	or	CC
18637	3426	20	writ	writ	NN
18637	3426	21	of	of	IN
18637	3426	22	error	error	NN
18637	3426	23	.	.	.
18637	3427	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3427	2	1448	1448	CD
18637	3427	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3427	4	But	but	CC
18637	3427	5	if	if	IN
18637	3427	6	special	special	JJ
18637	3427	7	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	3427	8	make	make	VBP
18637	3427	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3427	10	advantageous	advantageous	JJ
18637	3427	11	to	to	TO
18637	3427	12	use	use	VB
18637	3427	13	this	this	DT
18637	3427	14	writ	writ	VBN
18637	3427	15	in	in	IN
18637	3427	16	aid	aid	NN
18637	3427	17	of	of	IN
18637	3427	18	a	a	DT
18637	3427	19	just	just	JJ
18637	3427	20	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	3427	21	of	of	IN
18637	3427	22	a	a	DT
18637	3427	23	cause	cause	NN
18637	3427	24	pending	pende	VBG
18637	3427	25	on	on	IN
18637	3427	26	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	3427	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3427	28	may	may	MD
18637	3427	29	be	be	VB
18637	3427	30	used	use	VBN
18637	3427	31	for	for	IN
18637	3427	32	that	that	DT
18637	3427	33	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3427	34	.	.	.
18637	3428	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3428	2	1449	1449	CD
18637	3428	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3428	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	3428	5	facts	fact	NNS
18637	3428	6	dehors	dehor	VBZ
18637	3428	7	the	the	DT
18637	3428	8	record	record	NN
18637	3428	9	,	,	,
18637	3428	10	which	which	WDT
18637	3428	11	are	be	VBP
18637	3428	12	not	not	RB
18637	3428	13	open	open	JJ
18637	3428	14	to	to	IN
18637	3428	15	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	3428	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	3428	17	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	3428	18	,	,	,
18637	3428	19	are	be	VBP
18637	3428	20	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	3428	21	to	to	TO
18637	3428	22	show	show	VB
18637	3428	23	a	a	DT
18637	3428	24	denial	denial	NN
18637	3428	25	of	of	IN
18637	3428	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3428	27	rights	right	NNS
18637	3428	28	,	,	,
18637	3428	29	a	a	DT
18637	3428	30	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3428	31	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	3428	32	must	must	MD
18637	3428	33	be	be	VB
18637	3428	34	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3428	35	to	to	TO
18637	3428	36	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	3428	37	the	the	DT
18637	3428	38	truth	truth	NN
18637	3428	39	or	or	CC
18637	3428	40	falsity	falsity	NN
18637	3428	41	of	of	IN
18637	3428	42	the	the	DT
18637	3428	43	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	3428	44	.	.	.
18637	3429	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3429	2	1450	1450	CD
18637	3429	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3429	4	Issuance	issuance	NN
18637	3429	5	of	of	IN
18637	3429	6	the	the	DT
18637	3429	7	Writ	Writ	NNP
18637	3429	8	On	on	IN
18637	3429	9	application	application	NN
18637	3429	10	for	for	IN
18637	3429	11	a	a	DT
18637	3429	12	writ	writ	NN
18637	3429	13	of	of	IN
18637	3429	14	_	_	NNP
18637	3429	15	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	3429	16	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	3429	17	_	_	NNP
18637	3429	18	,	,	,
18637	3429	19	the	the	DT
18637	3429	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3429	21	may	may	MD
18637	3429	22	either	either	CC
18637	3429	23	issue	issue	VB
18637	3429	24	the	the	DT
18637	3429	25	writ	writ	JJ
18637	3429	26	,	,	,
18637	3429	27	and	and	CC
18637	3429	28	,	,	,
18637	3429	29	on	on	IN
18637	3429	30	the	the	DT
18637	3429	31	return	return	NN
18637	3429	32	,	,	,
18637	3429	33	dispose	dispose	JJ
18637	3429	34	of	of	IN
18637	3429	35	the	the	DT
18637	3429	36	case	case	NN
18637	3429	37	,	,	,
18637	3429	38	or	or	CC
18637	3429	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3429	40	may	may	MD
18637	3429	41	waive	waive	VB
18637	3429	42	the	the	DT
18637	3429	43	issuing	issuing	NN
18637	3429	44	of	of	IN
18637	3429	45	the	the	DT
18637	3429	46	writ	writ	NN
18637	3429	47	and	and	CC
18637	3429	48	consider	consider	VB
18637	3429	49	whether	whether	IN
18637	3429	50	,	,	,
18637	3429	51	upon	upon	IN
18637	3429	52	the	the	DT
18637	3429	53	facts	fact	NNS
18637	3429	54	presented	present	VBN
18637	3429	55	in	in	IN
18637	3429	56	the	the	DT
18637	3429	57	petition	petition	NN
18637	3429	58	,	,	,
18637	3429	59	the	the	DT
18637	3429	60	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	3429	61	,	,	,
18637	3429	62	if	if	IN
18637	3429	63	brought	bring	VBN
18637	3429	64	before	before	IN
18637	3429	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3429	66	,	,	,
18637	3429	67	could	could	MD
18637	3429	68	be	be	VB
18637	3429	69	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	3429	70	.	.	.
18637	3430	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3430	2	1451	1451	CD
18637	3430	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3430	4	The	the	DT
18637	3430	5	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	3430	6	may	may	MD
18637	3430	7	not	not	RB
18637	3430	8	be	be	VB
18637	3430	9	used	use	VBN
18637	3430	10	to	to	TO
18637	3430	11	secure	secure	VB
18637	3430	12	an	an	DT
18637	3430	13	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	3430	14	of	of	IN
18637	3430	15	a	a	DT
18637	3430	16	question	question	NN
18637	3430	17	which	which	WDT
18637	3430	18	,	,	,
18637	3430	19	if	if	IN
18637	3430	20	determined	determine	VBN
18637	3430	21	in	in	IN
18637	3430	22	the	the	DT
18637	3430	23	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	3430	24	's	's	POS
18637	3430	25	favor	favor	NN
18637	3430	26	,	,	,
18637	3430	27	could	could	MD
18637	3430	28	not	not	RB
18637	3430	29	result	result	VB
18637	3430	30	in	in	IN
18637	3430	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3430	32	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	3430	33	release	release	NN
18637	3430	34	.	.	.
18637	3431	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3431	2	1452	1452	CD
18637	3431	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3431	4	A	a	DT
18637	3431	5	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	3431	6	of	of	IN
18637	3431	7	a	a	DT
18637	3431	8	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	3431	9	on	on	IN
18637	3431	10	_	_	NNP
18637	3431	11	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	3431	12	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	3431	13	_	_	NNP
18637	3431	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	3431	15	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3431	16	only	only	RB
18637	3431	17	in	in	IN
18637	3431	18	the	the	DT
18637	3431	19	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3431	20	of	of	IN
18637	3431	21	a	a	DT
18637	3431	22	sound	sound	JJ
18637	3431	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3431	24	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	3431	25	.	.	.
18637	3432	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3432	2	1453	1453	CD
18637	3432	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3432	4	While	while	IN
18637	3432	5	the	the	DT
18637	3432	6	strict	strict	JJ
18637	3432	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3432	8	of	of	IN
18637	3432	9	_	_	NNP
18637	3432	10	res	res	NNP
18637	3432	11	judicata	judicata	NNP
18637	3432	12	_	_	NNP
18637	3432	13	does	do	VBZ
18637	3432	14	not	not	RB
18637	3432	15	apply	apply	VB
18637	3432	16	to	to	IN
18637	3432	17	this	this	DT
18637	3432	18	proceeding,[1454	proceeding,[1454	NNP
18637	3432	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3432	20	the	the	DT
18637	3432	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3432	22	may	may	MD
18637	3432	23	,	,	,
18637	3432	24	in	in	IN
18637	3432	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3432	26	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	3432	27	,	,	,
18637	3432	28	dismiss	dismiss	VB
18637	3432	29	a	a	DT
18637	3432	30	petition	petition	NN
18637	3432	31	for	for	IN
18637	3432	32	_	_	NNP
18637	3432	33	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	3432	34	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	3432	35	_	_	NNP
18637	3432	36	where	where	WRB
18637	3432	37	the	the	DT
18637	3432	38	ground	ground	NN
18637	3432	39	on	on	IN
18637	3432	40	which	which	WDT
18637	3432	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3432	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	3432	43	sought	seek	VBN
18637	3432	44	had	have	VBD
18637	3432	45	been	be	VBN
18637	3432	46	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	3432	47	in	in	IN
18637	3432	48	a	a	DT
18637	3432	49	prior	prior	JJ
18637	3432	50	application	application	NN
18637	3432	51	,	,	,
18637	3432	52	but	but	CC
18637	3432	53	the	the	DT
18637	3432	54	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	3432	55	to	to	TO
18637	3432	56	support	support	VB
18637	3432	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3432	58	had	have	VBD
18637	3432	59	been	be	VBN
18637	3432	60	unjustifiably	unjustifiably	RB
18637	3432	61	withheld	withhold	VBN
18637	3432	62	for	for	IN
18637	3432	63	use	use	NN
18637	3432	64	on	on	IN
18637	3432	65	a	a	DT
18637	3432	66	second	second	JJ
18637	3432	67	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	3432	68	if	if	IN
18637	3432	69	the	the	DT
18637	3432	70	first	first	JJ
18637	3432	71	failed	fail	VBD
18637	3432	72	.	.	.
18637	3433	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3433	2	1455	1455	CD
18637	3433	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3433	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	3433	5	the	the	DT
18637	3433	6	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3433	7	did	do	VBD
18637	3433	8	not	not	RB
18637	3433	9	deny	deny	VB
18637	3433	10	the	the	DT
18637	3433	11	allegation	allegation	NN
18637	3433	12	in	in	IN
18637	3433	13	a	a	DT
18637	3433	14	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	3433	15	's	's	POS
18637	3433	16	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	3433	17	petition	petition	NN
18637	3433	18	for	for	IN
18637	3433	19	_	_	NNP
18637	3433	20	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	3433	21	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	3433	22	_	_	NNP
18637	3433	23	,	,	,
18637	3433	24	but	but	CC
18637	3433	25	sought	seek	VBD
18637	3433	26	dismissal	dismissal	NN
18637	3433	27	of	of	IN
18637	3433	28	the	the	DT
18637	3433	29	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	3433	30	on	on	IN
18637	3433	31	the	the	DT
18637	3433	32	ground	ground	NN
18637	3433	33	that	that	IN
18637	3433	34	the	the	DT
18637	3433	35	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	3433	36	had	have	VBD
18637	3433	37	abused	abuse	VBN
18637	3433	38	the	the	DT
18637	3433	39	writ	writ	NNP
18637	3433	40	,	,	,
18637	3433	41	the	the	DT
18637	3433	42	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	3433	43	was	be	VBD
18637	3433	44	held	hold	VBN
18637	3433	45	to	to	TO
18637	3433	46	be	be	VB
18637	3433	47	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	3433	48	to	to	IN
18637	3433	49	a	a	DT
18637	3433	50	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	3433	51	to	to	TO
18637	3433	52	determine	determine	VB
18637	3433	53	whether	whether	IN
18637	3433	54	the	the	DT
18637	3433	55	charge	charge	NN
18637	3433	56	of	of	IN
18637	3433	57	abusive	abusive	JJ
18637	3433	58	use	use	NN
18637	3433	59	of	of	IN
18637	3433	60	the	the	DT
18637	3433	61	writ	writ	NNP
18637	3433	62	was	be	VBD
18637	3433	63	well	well	RB
18637	3433	64	founded	found	VBN
18637	3433	65	.	.	.
18637	3434	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3434	2	1456	1456	CD
18637	3434	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3434	4	Suspension	suspension	NN
18637	3434	5	of	of	IN
18637	3434	6	the	the	DT
18637	3434	7	Privilege	Privilege	NNP
18637	3434	8	A	a	DT
18637	3434	9	critical	critical	JJ
18637	3434	10	question	question	NN
18637	3434	11	under	under	IN
18637	3434	12	this	this	DT
18637	3434	13	section	section	NN
18637	3434	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	3434	15	who	who	WP
18637	3434	16	determines	determine	VBZ
18637	3434	17	with	with	IN
18637	3434	18	finality	finality	NN
18637	3434	19	whether	whether	IN
18637	3434	20	the	the	DT
18637	3434	21	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	3434	22	warrant	warrant	VBP
18637	3434	23	suspension	suspension	NN
18637	3434	24	of	of	IN
18637	3434	25	the	the	DT
18637	3434	26	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	3434	27	of	of	IN
18637	3434	28	the	the	DT
18637	3434	29	writ	writ	NNP
18637	3434	30	.	.	.
18637	3435	1	In	in	IN
18637	3435	2	England	England	NNP
18637	3435	3	the	the	DT
18637	3435	4	writ	writ	NNP
18637	3435	5	may	may	MD
18637	3435	6	be	be	VB
18637	3435	7	suspended	suspend	VBN
18637	3435	8	only	only	RB
18637	3435	9	by	by	IN
18637	3435	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3435	11	of	of	IN
18637	3435	12	Parliament,[1457	Parliament,[1457	NNP
18637	3435	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3435	14	and	and	CC
18637	3435	15	in	in	IN
18637	3435	16	an	an	DT
18637	3435	17	early	early	JJ
18637	3435	18	case	case	NN
18637	3435	19	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3435	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3435	21	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3435	22	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	3435	23	that	that	IN
18637	3435	24	the	the	DT
18637	3435	25	decision	decision	NN
18637	3435	26	as	as	IN
18637	3435	27	to	to	IN
18637	3435	28	when	when	WRB
18637	3435	29	public	public	JJ
18637	3435	30	safety	safety	NN
18637	3435	31	calls	call	VBZ
18637	3435	32	for	for	IN
18637	3435	33	this	this	DT
18637	3435	34	drastic	drastic	JJ
18637	3435	35	action	action	NN
18637	3435	36	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	3435	37	"	"	``
18637	3435	38	on	on	IN
18637	3435	39	political	political	JJ
18637	3435	40	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	3435	41	,	,	,
18637	3435	42	on	on	IN
18637	3435	43	which	which	WDT
18637	3435	44	the	the	DT
18637	3435	45	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3435	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	3435	47	to	to	TO
18637	3435	48	decide	decide	VB
18637	3435	49	.	.	.
18637	3436	1	"	"	``
18637	3436	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3436	3	1458	1458	CD
18637	3436	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3436	5	At	at	IN
18637	3436	6	the	the	DT
18637	3436	7	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	3436	8	of	of	IN
18637	3436	9	the	the	DT
18637	3436	10	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3436	11	War	War	NNP
18637	3436	12	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	3436	13	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	3436	14	the	the	DT
18637	3436	15	Commanding	Commanding	NNP
18637	3436	16	General	General	NNP
18637	3436	17	of	of	IN
18637	3436	18	the	the	DT
18637	3436	19	Army	Army	NNP
18637	3436	20	of	of	IN
18637	3436	21	the	the	DT
18637	3436	22	United	United	NNP
18637	3436	23	States	States	NNP
18637	3436	24	to	to	TO
18637	3436	25	suspend	suspend	VB
18637	3436	26	the	the	DT
18637	3436	27	writ	writ	NNP
18637	3436	28	along	along	IN
18637	3436	29	any	any	DT
18637	3436	30	military	military	JJ
18637	3436	31	line	line	NN
18637	3436	32	between	between	IN
18637	3436	33	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	3436	34	and	and	CC
18637	3436	35	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	3436	36	.	.	.
18637	3437	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3437	2	1459	1459	CD
18637	3437	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3437	4	In	in	IN
18637	3437	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	3437	6	parte	parte	NN
18637	3437	7	Merryman,[1460	merryman,[1460	NN
18637	3437	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3437	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3437	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3437	11	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	3437	12	strongly	strongly	RB
18637	3437	13	denounced	denounce	VBD
18637	3437	14	the	the	DT
18637	3437	15	President	President	NNP
18637	3437	16	's	's	POS
18637	3437	17	action	action	NN
18637	3437	18	and	and	CC
18637	3437	19	reasserted	reassert	VBD
18637	3437	20	the	the	DT
18637	3437	21	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	3437	22	that	that	WDT
18637	3437	23	only	only	RB
18637	3437	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3437	25	could	could	MD
18637	3437	26	suspend	suspend	VB
18637	3437	27	the	the	DT
18637	3437	28	writ	writ	NNP
18637	3437	29	.	.	.
18637	3438	1	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	3438	2	General	General	NNP
18637	3438	3	Bates	Bates	NNP
18637	3438	4	promptly	promptly	RB
18637	3438	5	challenged	challenge	VBD
18637	3438	6	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	3438	7	's	's	POS
18637	3438	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3438	9	.	.	.
18637	3439	1	Noting	note	VBG
18637	3439	2	that	that	IN
18637	3439	3	in	in	IN
18637	3439	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	3439	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	3439	6	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	3439	7	,	,	,
18637	3439	8	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3439	9	did	do	VBD
18637	3439	10	"	"	``
18637	3439	11	not	not	RB
18637	3439	12	speak	speak	VB
18637	3439	13	of	of	IN
18637	3439	14	suspending	suspend	VBG
18637	3439	15	the	the	DT
18637	3439	16	_	_	NNP
18637	3439	17	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	3439	18	_	_	NNP
18637	3439	19	of	of	IN
18637	3439	20	the	the	DT
18637	3439	21	writ	writ	NNP
18637	3439	22	,	,	,
18637	3439	23	but	but	CC
18637	3439	24	of	of	IN
18637	3439	25	suspending	suspend	VBG
18637	3439	26	the	the	DT
18637	3439	27	_	_	NNP
18637	3439	28	powers	power	NNS
18637	3439	29	vested	vest	VBN
18637	3439	30	in	in	IN
18637	3439	31	the	the	DT
18637	3439	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3439	33	_	_	NNP
18637	3439	34	by	by	IN
18637	3439	35	the	the	DT
18637	3439	36	act	act	NN
18637	3439	37	,	,	,
18637	3439	38	"	"	''
18637	3439	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3439	40	took	take	VBD
18637	3439	41	the	the	DT
18637	3439	42	position	position	NN
18637	3439	43	that	that	IN
18637	3439	44	the	the	DT
18637	3439	45	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3439	46	provision	provision	NN
18637	3439	47	was	be	VBD
18637	3439	48	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3439	49	the	the	DT
18637	3439	50	equivalent	equivalent	NN
18637	3439	51	of	of	IN
18637	3439	52	an	an	DT
18637	3439	53	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3439	54	of	of	IN
18637	3439	55	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
18637	3439	56	.	.	.
18637	3440	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3440	2	1461	1461	CD
18637	3440	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3440	4	Thereafter	Thereafter	NNP
18637	3440	5	,	,	,
18637	3440	6	by	by	IN
18637	3440	7	an	an	DT
18637	3440	8	express	express	JJ
18637	3440	9	provision	provision	NN
18637	3440	10	of	of	IN
18637	3440	11	the	the	DT
18637	3440	12	act	act	NN
18637	3440	13	of	of	IN
18637	3440	14	March	March	NNP
18637	3440	15	3	3	CD
18637	3440	16	,	,	,
18637	3440	17	1863	1863	CD
18637	3440	18	,	,	,
18637	3440	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3440	20	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3440	21	,	,	,
18637	3440	22	"	"	``
18637	3440	23	That	that	IN
18637	3440	24	,	,	,
18637	3440	25	during	during	IN
18637	3440	26	the	the	DT
18637	3440	27	present	present	JJ
18637	3440	28	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	3440	29	,	,	,
18637	3440	30	the	the	DT
18637	3440	31	President	President	NNP
18637	3440	32	of	of	IN
18637	3440	33	the	the	DT
18637	3440	34	United	United	NNP
18637	3440	35	States	States	NNP
18637	3440	36	,	,	,
18637	3440	37	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	3440	38	,	,	,
18637	3440	39	in	in	IN
18637	3440	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3440	41	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	3440	42	,	,	,
18637	3440	43	the	the	DT
18637	3440	44	public	public	JJ
18637	3440	45	safety	safety	NN
18637	3440	46	may	may	MD
18637	3440	47	require	require	VB
18637	3440	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3440	49	,	,	,
18637	3440	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	3440	51	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	3440	52	to	to	TO
18637	3440	53	suspend	suspend	VB
18637	3440	54	the	the	DT
18637	3440	55	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	3440	56	of	of	IN
18637	3440	57	the	the	DT
18637	3440	58	writ	writ	NNP
18637	3440	59	of	of	IN
18637	3440	60	_	_	NNP
18637	3440	61	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	3440	62	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	3440	63	_	_	NNP
18637	3440	64	in	in	IN
18637	3440	65	any	any	DT
18637	3440	66	case	case	NN
18637	3440	67	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	3440	68	the	the	DT
18637	3440	69	United	United	NNP
18637	3440	70	States	States	NNP
18637	3440	71	,	,	,
18637	3440	72	or	or	CC
18637	3440	73	any	any	DT
18637	3440	74	part	part	NN
18637	3440	75	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	3440	76	.	.	.
18637	3441	1	"	"	``
18637	3441	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3441	3	1462	1462	CD
18637	3441	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3441	5	The	the	DT
18637	3441	6	validity	validity	NN
18637	3441	7	of	of	IN
18637	3441	8	this	this	DT
18637	3441	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	3441	10	was	be	VBD
18637	3441	11	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	3441	12	in	in	IN
18637	3441	13	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	3441	14	parte	parte	NNP
18637	3441	15	Milligan,[1463	milligan,[1463	CD
18637	3441	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3441	17	but	but	CC
18637	3441	18	a	a	DT
18637	3441	19	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	3441	20	majority	majority	NN
18637	3441	21	of	of	IN
18637	3441	22	the	the	DT
18637	3441	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3441	24	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3441	25	that	that	IN
18637	3441	26	the	the	DT
18637	3441	27	suspension	suspension	NN
18637	3441	28	of	of	IN
18637	3441	29	the	the	DT
18637	3441	30	writ	writ	NNP
18637	3441	31	did	do	VBD
18637	3441	32	not	not	RB
18637	3441	33	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	3441	34	the	the	DT
18637	3441	35	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	3441	36	of	of	IN
18637	3441	37	any	any	DT
18637	3441	38	one	one	CD
18637	3441	39	,	,	,
18637	3441	40	but	but	CC
18637	3441	41	simply	simply	RB
18637	3441	42	denied	deny	VBN
18637	3441	43	to	to	IN
18637	3441	44	one	one	CD
18637	3441	45	arrested	arrest	VBN
18637	3441	46	the	the	DT
18637	3441	47	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	3441	48	of	of	IN
18637	3441	49	the	the	DT
18637	3441	50	writ	writ	NNP
18637	3441	51	in	in	IN
18637	3441	52	order	order	NN
18637	3441	53	to	to	TO
18637	3441	54	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	3441	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3441	56	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	3441	57	.	.	.
18637	3442	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3442	2	1464	1464	CD
18637	3442	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3442	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3442	5	3	3	CD
18637	3442	6	.	.	.
18637	3443	1	No	no	DT
18637	3443	2	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	3443	3	of	of	IN
18637	3443	4	Attainder	Attainder	NNP
18637	3443	5	or	or	CC
18637	3443	6	ex	ex	FW
18637	3443	7	post	post	FW
18637	3443	8	facto	facto	FW
18637	3443	9	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3443	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	3443	11	be	be	VB
18637	3443	12	passed	pass	VBN
18637	3443	13	.	.	.
18637	3444	1	BILLS	bill	NNS
18637	3444	2	OF	of	IN
18637	3444	3	ATTAINDER	ATTAINDER	NNP
18637	3444	4	Historically	historically	RB
18637	3444	5	,	,	,
18637	3444	6	the	the	DT
18637	3444	7	term	term	NN
18637	3444	8	"	"	``
18637	3444	9	bills	bill	NNS
18637	3444	10	of	of	IN
18637	3444	11	attainder	attainder	NN
18637	3444	12	"	"	''
18637	3444	13	was	be	VBD
18637	3444	14	applied	apply	VBN
18637	3444	15	to	to	IN
18637	3444	16	"	"	``
18637	3444	17	such	such	JJ
18637	3444	18	special	special	JJ
18637	3444	19	acts	act	NNS
18637	3444	20	of	of	IN
18637	3444	21	the	the	DT
18637	3444	22	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3444	23	as	as	IN
18637	3444	24	inflict	inflict	VB
18637	3444	25	capital	capital	NN
18637	3444	26	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	3444	27	upon	upon	IN
18637	3444	28	persons	person	NNS
18637	3444	29	supposed	suppose	VBN
18637	3444	30	to	to	TO
18637	3444	31	be	be	VB
18637	3444	32	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	3444	33	of	of	IN
18637	3444	34	high	high	JJ
18637	3444	35	offences	offence	NNS
18637	3444	36	,	,	,
18637	3444	37	such	such	JJ
18637	3444	38	as	as	IN
18637	3444	39	treason	treason	NN
18637	3444	40	and	and	CC
18637	3444	41	felony	felony	NN
18637	3444	42	,	,	,
18637	3444	43	without	without	IN
18637	3444	44	any	any	DT
18637	3444	45	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	3444	46	in	in	IN
18637	3444	47	the	the	DT
18637	3444	48	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	3444	49	course	course	NN
18637	3444	50	of	of	IN
18637	3444	51	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3444	52	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	3444	53	.	.	.
18637	3444	54	"	"	''
18637	3445	1	An	an	DT
18637	3445	2	act	act	NN
18637	3445	3	which	which	WDT
18637	3445	4	inflicted	inflict	VBD
18637	3445	5	a	a	DT
18637	3445	6	milder	milder	NN
18637	3445	7	degree	degree	NN
18637	3445	8	of	of	IN
18637	3445	9	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	3445	10	was	be	VBD
18637	3445	11	called	call	VBN
18637	3445	12	a	a	DT
18637	3445	13	bill	bill	NN
18637	3445	14	of	of	IN
18637	3445	15	pains	pain	NNS
18637	3445	16	and	and	CC
18637	3445	17	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	3445	18	.	.	.
18637	3446	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3446	2	1465	1465	CD
18637	3446	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3446	4	Within	within	IN
18637	3446	5	the	the	DT
18637	3446	6	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	3446	7	of	of	IN
18637	3446	8	the	the	DT
18637	3446	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3446	10	,	,	,
18637	3446	11	however	however	RB
18637	3446	12	,	,	,
18637	3446	13	bills	bill	NNS
18637	3446	14	of	of	IN
18637	3446	15	attainder	attainder	NN
18637	3446	16	include	include	VBP
18637	3446	17	bills	bill	NNS
18637	3446	18	of	of	IN
18637	3446	19	pains	pain	NNS
18637	3446	20	and	and	CC
18637	3446	21	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	3446	22	.	.	.
18637	3447	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3447	2	1466	1466	CD
18637	3447	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3447	4	As	as	IN
18637	3447	5	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	3447	6	by	by	IN
18637	3447	7	the	the	DT
18637	3447	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3447	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3447	10	,	,	,
18637	3447	11	this	this	DT
18637	3447	12	clause	clause	NN
18637	3447	13	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	3447	14	all	all	DT
18637	3447	15	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3447	16	acts	act	NNS
18637	3447	17	,	,	,
18637	3447	18	"	"	``
18637	3447	19	no	no	RB
18637	3447	20	matter	matter	RB
18637	3447	21	what	what	WP
18637	3447	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3447	23	form	form	NN
18637	3447	24	,	,	,
18637	3447	25	that	that	WDT
18637	3447	26	apply	apply	VBP
18637	3447	27	either	either	CC
18637	3447	28	to	to	IN
18637	3447	29	named	name	VBN
18637	3447	30	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	3447	31	or	or	CC
18637	3447	32	to	to	TO
18637	3447	33	easily	easily	RB
18637	3447	34	ascertainable	ascertainable	JJ
18637	3447	35	members	member	NNS
18637	3447	36	of	of	IN
18637	3447	37	a	a	DT
18637	3447	38	group	group	NN
18637	3447	39	in	in	IN
18637	3447	40	such	such	PDT
18637	3447	41	a	a	DT
18637	3447	42	way	way	NN
18637	3447	43	as	as	IN
18637	3447	44	to	to	TO
18637	3447	45	inflict	inflict	VB
18637	3447	46	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	3447	47	on	on	IN
18637	3447	48	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3447	49	without	without	IN
18637	3447	50	a	a	DT
18637	3447	51	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3447	52	trial	trial	NN
18637	3447	53	*	*	NFP
18637	3447	54	*	*	NFP
18637	3447	55	*	*	NFP
18637	3447	56	"	"	''
18637	3447	57	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3447	58	1467	1467	CD
18637	3447	59	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3447	60	Two	two	CD
18637	3447	61	acts	act	NNS
18637	3447	62	of	of	IN
18637	3447	63	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3447	64	--	--	:
18637	3447	65	one	one	CD
18637	3447	66	which	which	WDT
18637	3447	67	required	require	VBD
18637	3447	68	attorneys	attorney	NNS
18637	3447	69	practicing	practice	VBG
18637	3447	70	in	in	IN
18637	3447	71	the	the	DT
18637	3447	72	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3447	73	courts	court	NNS
18637	3447	74	to	to	TO
18637	3447	75	take	take	VB
18637	3447	76	an	an	DT
18637	3447	77	oath	oath	NN
18637	3447	78	that	that	IN
18637	3447	79	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3447	80	had	have	VBD
18637	3447	81	never	never	RB
18637	3447	82	given	give	VBN
18637	3447	83	aid	aid	NN
18637	3447	84	to	to	IN
18637	3447	85	persons	person	NNS
18637	3447	86	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	3447	87	in	in	IN
18637	3447	88	hostility	hostility	NN
18637	3447	89	to	to	IN
18637	3447	90	the	the	DT
18637	3447	91	United	United	NNP
18637	3447	92	States,[1468	states,[1468	CD
18637	3447	93	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3447	94	and	and	CC
18637	3447	95	another	another	DT
18637	3447	96	which	which	WDT
18637	3447	97	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	3447	98	the	the	DT
18637	3447	99	payment	payment	NN
18637	3447	100	of	of	IN
18637	3447	101	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	3447	102	to	to	IN
18637	3447	103	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3447	104	named	name	VBN
18637	3447	105	government	government	NN
18637	3447	106	employees	employee	NNS
18637	3447	107	who	who	WP
18637	3447	108	have	have	VBP
18637	3447	109	been	be	VBN
18637	3447	110	charged	charge	VBN
18637	3447	111	with	with	IN
18637	3447	112	subversive	subversive	JJ
18637	3447	113	activity,[1469]--have	activity,[1469]--have	NN
18637	3447	114	been	be	VBN
18637	3447	115	held	hold	VBN
18637	3447	116	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	3447	117	on	on	IN
18637	3447	118	the	the	DT
18637	3447	119	ground	ground	NN
18637	3447	120	that	that	IN
18637	3447	121	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3447	122	amounted	amount	VBD
18637	3447	123	to	to	IN
18637	3447	124	bills	bill	NNS
18637	3447	125	of	of	IN
18637	3447	126	attainder	attainder	NN
18637	3447	127	.	.	.
18637	3448	1	EX	EX	NNP
18637	3448	2	POST	POST	NNP
18637	3448	3	FACTO	FACTO	VBD
18637	3448	4	LAWS	LAWS	NNP
18637	3448	5	Definition	definition	NN
18637	3448	6	At	at	IN
18637	3448	7	the	the	DT
18637	3448	8	time	time	NN
18637	3448	9	the	the	DT
18637	3448	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3448	11	was	be	VBD
18637	3448	12	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	3448	13	,	,	,
18637	3448	14	many	many	JJ
18637	3448	15	persons	person	NNS
18637	3448	16	understood	understand	VBD
18637	3448	17	the	the	DT
18637	3448	18	terms	term	NNS
18637	3448	19	_	_	NNP
18637	3448	20	ex	ex	FW
18637	3448	21	post	post	FW
18637	3448	22	facto	facto	FW
18637	3448	23	_	_	NNP
18637	3448	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	3448	25	,	,	,
18637	3448	26	to	to	TO
18637	3448	27	"	"	``
18637	3448	28	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	3448	29	all	all	DT
18637	3448	30	retrospective	retrospective	JJ
18637	3448	31	laws	law	NNS
18637	3448	32	,	,	,
18637	3448	33	or	or	CC
18637	3448	34	laws	law	NNS
18637	3448	35	governing	govern	VBG
18637	3448	36	or	or	CC
18637	3448	37	controlling	control	VBG
18637	3448	38	past	past	JJ
18637	3448	39	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	3448	40	,	,	,
18637	3448	41	whether	whether	IN
18637	3448	42	*	*	NFP
18637	3448	43	*	*	NFP
18637	3448	44	*	*	NFP
18637	3448	45	of	of	IN
18637	3448	46	a	a	DT
18637	3448	47	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3448	48	or	or	CC
18637	3448	49	a	a	DT
18637	3448	50	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	3448	51	nature	nature	NN
18637	3448	52	.	.	.
18637	3449	1	"	"	``
18637	3449	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3449	3	1470	1470	CD
18637	3449	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3449	5	But	but	CC
18637	3449	6	in	in	IN
18637	3449	7	the	the	DT
18637	3449	8	early	early	JJ
18637	3449	9	case	case	NN
18637	3449	10	of	of	IN
18637	3449	11	Calder	Calder	NNP
18637	3449	12	_	_	NNP
18637	3449	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	3449	14	_	_	NNP
18637	3449	15	Bull,[1471	Bull,[1471	NNP
18637	3449	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3449	17	the	the	DT
18637	3449	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3449	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3449	20	decided	decide	VBD
18637	3449	21	that	that	IN
18637	3449	22	the	the	DT
18637	3449	23	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	3449	24	,	,	,
18637	3449	25	as	as	IN
18637	3449	26	used	use	VBN
18637	3449	27	in	in	IN
18637	3449	28	the	the	DT
18637	3449	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3449	30	,	,	,
18637	3449	31	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	3449	32	only	only	RB
18637	3449	33	to	to	IN
18637	3449	34	penal	penal	JJ
18637	3449	35	and	and	CC
18637	3449	36	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	3449	37	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3449	38	.	.	.
18637	3450	1	But	but	CC
18637	3450	2	although	although	IN
18637	3450	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3450	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	3450	5	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	3450	6	to	to	TO
18637	3450	7	retroactive	retroactive	VB
18637	3450	8	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3450	9	of	of	IN
18637	3450	10	any	any	DT
18637	3450	11	other	other	JJ
18637	3450	12	kind,[1472	kind,[1472	NNP
18637	3450	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3450	14	the	the	DT
18637	3450	15	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3450	16	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3450	17	may	may	MD
18637	3450	18	not	not	RB
18637	3450	19	be	be	VB
18637	3450	20	evaded	evade	VBN
18637	3450	21	by	by	IN
18637	3450	22	giving	give	VBG
18637	3450	23	a	a	DT
18637	3450	24	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3450	25	form	form	NN
18637	3450	26	to	to	IN
18637	3450	27	a	a	DT
18637	3450	28	measure	measure	NN
18637	3450	29	which	which	WDT
18637	3450	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	3450	31	essentially	essentially	RB
18637	3450	32	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	3450	33	.	.	.
18637	3451	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3451	2	1473	1473	CD
18637	3451	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3451	4	Every	every	DT
18637	3451	5	law	law	NN
18637	3451	6	which	which	WDT
18637	3451	7	makes	make	VBZ
18637	3451	8	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	3451	9	an	an	DT
18637	3451	10	act	act	NN
18637	3451	11	which	which	WDT
18637	3451	12	was	be	VBD
18637	3451	13	innocent	innocent	JJ
18637	3451	14	when	when	WRB
18637	3451	15	done	do	VBN
18637	3451	16	,	,	,
18637	3451	17	or	or	CC
18637	3451	18	which	which	WDT
18637	3451	19	inflicts	inflict	VBZ
18637	3451	20	a	a	DT
18637	3451	21	greater	great	JJR
18637	3451	22	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	3451	23	than	than	IN
18637	3451	24	the	the	DT
18637	3451	25	law	law	NN
18637	3451	26	annexed	annex	VBN
18637	3451	27	to	to	IN
18637	3451	28	the	the	DT
18637	3451	29	crime	crime	NN
18637	3451	30	when	when	WRB
18637	3451	31	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3451	32	,	,	,
18637	3451	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	3451	34	an	an	DT
18637	3451	35	_	_	NNP
18637	3451	36	ex	ex	FW
18637	3451	37	post	post	FW
18637	3451	38	facto	facto	FW
18637	3451	39	_	_	NNP
18637	3451	40	law	law	NN
18637	3451	41	within	within	IN
18637	3451	42	the	the	DT
18637	3451	43	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3451	44	of	of	IN
18637	3451	45	the	the	DT
18637	3451	46	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3451	47	.	.	.
18637	3452	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3452	2	1474	1474	CD
18637	3452	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3452	4	A	a	DT
18637	3452	5	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	3452	6	under	under	IN
18637	3452	7	a	a	DT
18637	3452	8	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	3452	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	3452	10	which	which	WDT
18637	3452	11	was	be	VBD
18637	3452	12	extended	extend	VBN
18637	3452	13	before	before	IN
18637	3452	14	the	the	DT
18637	3452	15	date	date	NN
18637	3452	16	originally	originally	RB
18637	3452	17	set	set	VBN
18637	3452	18	for	for	IN
18637	3452	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3452	20	expiration	expiration	NN
18637	3452	21	does	do	VBZ
18637	3452	22	not	not	RB
18637	3452	23	offend	offend	VB
18637	3452	24	this	this	DT
18637	3452	25	provision	provision	NN
18637	3452	26	even	even	RB
18637	3452	27	though	though	IN
18637	3452	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3452	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	3452	30	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	3452	31	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	3452	32	to	to	IN
18637	3452	33	the	the	DT
18637	3452	34	extension	extension	NN
18637	3452	35	of	of	IN
18637	3452	36	the	the	DT
18637	3452	37	statute	statute	NN
18637	3452	38	's	's	POS
18637	3452	39	duration	duration	NN
18637	3452	40	for	for	IN
18637	3452	41	a	a	DT
18637	3452	42	violation	violation	NN
18637	3452	43	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3452	44	prior	prior	JJ
18637	3452	45	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	3452	46	.	.	.
18637	3453	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3453	2	1475	1475	CD
18637	3453	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3453	4	Since	since	IN
18637	3453	5	this	this	DT
18637	3453	6	provision	provision	NN
18637	3453	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	3453	8	no	no	DT
18637	3453	9	application	application	NN
18637	3453	10	to	to	IN
18637	3453	11	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	3453	12	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3453	13	outside	outside	IN
18637	3453	14	the	the	DT
18637	3453	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3453	16	of	of	IN
18637	3453	17	the	the	DT
18637	3453	18	United	United	NNP
18637	3453	19	States	States	NNP
18637	3453	20	against	against	IN
18637	3453	21	the	the	DT
18637	3453	22	laws	law	NNS
18637	3453	23	of	of	IN
18637	3453	24	a	a	DT
18637	3453	25	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3453	26	country	country	NN
18637	3453	27	,	,	,
18637	3453	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3453	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	3453	30	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
18637	3453	31	in	in	IN
18637	3453	32	extradition	extradition	NN
18637	3453	33	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	3453	34	whether	whether	IN
18637	3453	35	the	the	DT
18637	3453	36	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3453	37	law	law	NN
18637	3453	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	3453	39	_	_	NNP
18637	3453	40	ex	ex	FW
18637	3453	41	post	post	FW
18637	3453	42	facto	facto	FW
18637	3453	43	_	_	NNP
18637	3453	44	or	or	CC
18637	3453	45	not	not	RB
18637	3453	46	.	.	.
18637	3454	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3454	2	1476	1476	CD
18637	3454	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3454	4	What	what	WP
18637	3454	5	Constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	3454	6	Punishment	Punishment	NNP
18637	3454	7	An	an	DT
18637	3454	8	act	act	NN
18637	3454	9	of	of	IN
18637	3454	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3454	11	which	which	WDT
18637	3454	12	prescribed	prescribe	VBD
18637	3454	13	as	as	IN
18637	3454	14	a	a	DT
18637	3454	15	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	3454	16	for	for	IN
18637	3454	17	practice	practice	NN
18637	3454	18	before	before	IN
18637	3454	19	the	the	DT
18637	3454	20	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3454	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	3454	22	an	an	DT
18637	3454	23	oath	oath	NN
18637	3454	24	that	that	IN
18637	3454	25	the	the	DT
18637	3454	26	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	3454	27	had	have	VBD
18637	3454	28	not	not	RB
18637	3454	29	participated	participate	VBN
18637	3454	30	in	in	IN
18637	3454	31	the	the	DT
18637	3454	32	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
18637	3454	33	was	be	VBD
18637	3454	34	found	find	VBN
18637	3454	35	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	3454	36	since	since	IN
18637	3454	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3454	38	operated	operate	VBD
18637	3454	39	as	as	IN
18637	3454	40	a	a	DT
18637	3454	41	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	3454	42	for	for	IN
18637	3454	43	past	past	JJ
18637	3454	44	acts	act	NNS
18637	3454	45	.	.	.
18637	3455	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3455	2	1477	1477	CD
18637	3455	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3455	4	But	but	CC
18637	3455	5	a	a	DT
18637	3455	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	3455	7	which	which	WDT
18637	3455	8	denied	deny	VBD
18637	3455	9	to	to	IN
18637	3455	10	polygamists	polygamist	NNS
18637	3455	11	the	the	DT
18637	3455	12	right	right	NN
18637	3455	13	to	to	TO
18637	3455	14	vote	vote	VB
18637	3455	15	in	in	IN
18637	3455	16	a	a	DT
18637	3455	17	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	3455	18	election	election	NN
18637	3455	19	,	,	,
18637	3455	20	was	be	VBD
18637	3455	21	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	3455	22	even	even	RB
18637	3455	23	as	as	IN
18637	3455	24	applied	apply	VBN
18637	3455	25	to	to	IN
18637	3455	26	a	a	DT
18637	3455	27	person	person	NN
18637	3455	28	who	who	WP
18637	3455	29	had	have	VBD
18637	3455	30	not	not	RB
18637	3455	31	practiced	practice	VBN
18637	3455	32	polygamy	polygamy	NNP
18637	3455	33	since	since	IN
18637	3455	34	the	the	DT
18637	3455	35	act	act	NN
18637	3455	36	was	be	VBD
18637	3455	37	passed	pass	VBN
18637	3455	38	,	,	,
18637	3455	39	because	because	IN
18637	3455	40	the	the	DT
18637	3455	41	law	law	NN
18637	3455	42	did	do	VBD
18637	3455	43	not	not	RB
18637	3455	44	operate	operate	VB
18637	3455	45	as	as	IN
18637	3455	46	an	an	DT
18637	3455	47	additional	additional	JJ
18637	3455	48	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	3455	49	for	for	IN
18637	3455	50	the	the	DT
18637	3455	51	offense	offense	NN
18637	3455	52	of	of	IN
18637	3455	53	polygamy	polygamy	NN
18637	3455	54	but	but	CC
18637	3455	55	merely	merely	RB
18637	3455	56	defined	define	VBD
18637	3455	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3455	58	as	as	IN
18637	3455	59	a	a	DT
18637	3455	60	disqualification	disqualification	NN
18637	3455	61	of	of	IN
18637	3455	62	a	a	DT
18637	3455	63	voter	voter	NN
18637	3455	64	.	.	.
18637	3456	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3456	2	1478	1478	CD
18637	3456	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3456	4	A	a	DT
18637	3456	5	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	3456	6	law	law	NN
18637	3456	7	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	3456	8	the	the	DT
18637	3456	9	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	3456	10	of	of	IN
18637	3456	11	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	3456	12	to	to	TO
18637	3456	13	expel	expel	VB
18637	3456	14	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	3456	15	for	for	IN
18637	3456	16	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	3456	17	acts	act	NNS
18637	3456	18	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3456	19	before	before	IN
18637	3456	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3456	21	passage	passage	NN
18637	3456	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	3456	23	not	not	RB
18637	3456	24	_	_	NNP
18637	3456	25	ex	ex	FW
18637	3456	26	post	post	FW
18637	3456	27	facto	facto	FW
18637	3456	28	_	_	NNP
18637	3456	29	since	since	IN
18637	3456	30	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	3456	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	3456	32	not	not	RB
18637	3456	33	a	a	DT
18637	3456	34	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	3456	35	.	.	.
18637	3457	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3457	2	1479	1479	CD
18637	3457	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3457	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	3457	5	an	an	DT
18637	3457	6	act	act	NN
18637	3457	7	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	3457	8	the	the	DT
18637	3457	9	cancellation	cancellation	NN
18637	3457	10	of	of	IN
18637	3457	11	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	3457	12	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	3457	13	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	3457	14	by	by	IN
18637	3457	15	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	3457	16	prior	prior	RB
18637	3457	17	to	to	IN
18637	3457	18	the	the	DT
18637	3457	19	passage	passage	NN
18637	3457	20	of	of	IN
18637	3457	21	the	the	DT
18637	3457	22	law	law	NN
18637	3457	23	was	be	VBD
18637	3457	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	3457	25	not	not	RB
18637	3457	26	to	to	TO
18637	3457	27	impose	impose	VB
18637	3457	28	a	a	DT
18637	3457	29	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	3457	30	but	but	CC
18637	3457	31	simply	simply	RB
18637	3457	32	to	to	TO
18637	3457	33	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	3457	34	the	the	DT
18637	3457	35	alien	alien	NN
18637	3457	36	of	of	IN
18637	3457	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3457	38	ill	ill	RB
18637	3457	39	-	-	HYPH
18637	3457	40	gotten	get	VBN
18637	3457	41	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3457	42	.	.	.
18637	3458	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3458	2	1480	1480	CD
18637	3458	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3458	4	Change	change	VB
18637	3458	5	in	in	IN
18637	3458	6	Place	Place	NNP
18637	3458	7	or	or	CC
18637	3458	8	Mode	Mode	NNP
18637	3458	9	of	of	IN
18637	3458	10	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	3458	11	A	A	NNP
18637	3458	12	change	change	NN
18637	3458	13	of	of	IN
18637	3458	14	the	the	DT
18637	3458	15	place	place	NN
18637	3458	16	of	of	IN
18637	3458	17	trial	trial	NN
18637	3458	18	of	of	IN
18637	3458	19	an	an	DT
18637	3458	20	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	3458	21	offense	offense	NN
18637	3458	22	after	after	IN
18637	3458	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3458	24	commission	commission	NN
18637	3458	25	,	,	,
18637	3458	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	3458	27	not	not	RB
18637	3458	28	an	an	DT
18637	3458	29	_	_	NNP
18637	3458	30	ex	ex	FW
18637	3458	31	post	post	FW
18637	3458	32	facto	facto	FW
18637	3458	33	_	_	NNP
18637	3458	34	law	law	NN
18637	3458	35	.	.	.
18637	3459	1	If	if	IN
18637	3459	2	no	no	DT
18637	3459	3	place	place	NN
18637	3459	4	of	of	IN
18637	3459	5	trial	trial	NN
18637	3459	6	was	be	VBD
18637	3459	7	provided	provide	VBN
18637	3459	8	when	when	WRB
18637	3459	9	the	the	DT
18637	3459	10	offense	offense	NN
18637	3459	11	was	be	VBD
18637	3459	12	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3459	13	,	,	,
18637	3459	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3459	15	may	may	MD
18637	3459	16	designate	designate	VB
18637	3459	17	the	the	DT
18637	3459	18	place	place	NN
18637	3459	19	of	of	IN
18637	3459	20	trial	trial	NN
18637	3459	21	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	3459	22	.	.	.
18637	3460	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3460	2	1481	1481	CD
18637	3460	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3460	4	A	a	DT
18637	3460	5	law	law	NN
18637	3460	6	which	which	WDT
18637	3460	7	alters	alter	VBZ
18637	3460	8	the	the	DT
18637	3460	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	3460	10	of	of	IN
18637	3460	11	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	3460	12	to	to	TO
18637	3460	13	permit	permit	VB
18637	3460	14	a	a	DT
18637	3460	15	person	person	NN
18637	3460	16	to	to	TO
18637	3460	17	be	be	VB
18637	3460	18	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	3460	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	3460	20	less	less	JJR
18637	3460	21	or	or	CC
18637	3460	22	different	different	JJ
18637	3460	23	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	3460	24	than	than	IN
18637	3460	25	was	be	VBD
18637	3460	26	required	require	VBN
18637	3460	27	when	when	WRB
18637	3460	28	the	the	DT
18637	3460	29	offense	offense	NN
18637	3460	30	was	be	VBD
18637	3460	31	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3460	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	3460	33	invalid,[1482	invalid,[1482	NNP
18637	3460	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3460	35	but	but	CC
18637	3460	36	a	a	DT
18637	3460	37	statute	statute	NN
18637	3460	38	which	which	WDT
18637	3460	39	simply	simply	RB
18637	3460	40	enlarges	enlarge	VBZ
18637	3460	41	the	the	DT
18637	3460	42	class	class	NN
18637	3460	43	of	of	IN
18637	3460	44	persons	person	NNS
18637	3460	45	who	who	WP
18637	3460	46	may	may	MD
18637	3460	47	be	be	VB
18637	3460	48	competent	competent	JJ
18637	3460	49	to	to	TO
18637	3460	50	testify	testify	VB
18637	3460	51	in	in	IN
18637	3460	52	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	3460	53	cases	case	NNS
18637	3460	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	3460	55	not	not	RB
18637	3460	56	_	_	NNP
18637	3460	57	ex	ex	FW
18637	3460	58	post	post	FW
18637	3460	59	facto	facto	FW
18637	3460	60	_	_	NNP
18637	3460	61	as	as	IN
18637	3460	62	applied	apply	VBN
18637	3460	63	to	to	IN
18637	3460	64	a	a	DT
18637	3460	65	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	3460	66	for	for	IN
18637	3460	67	a	a	DT
18637	3460	68	crime	crime	NN
18637	3460	69	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3460	70	prior	prior	RB
18637	3460	71	to	to	IN
18637	3460	72	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3460	73	passage	passage	NN
18637	3460	74	.	.	.
18637	3461	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3461	2	1483	1483	CD
18637	3461	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3461	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3461	5	4	4	CD
18637	3461	6	.	.	.
18637	3462	1	No	no	DT
18637	3462	2	Capitation	Capitation	NNP
18637	3462	3	,	,	,
18637	3462	4	or	or	CC
18637	3462	5	other	other	JJ
18637	3462	6	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3462	7	,	,	,
18637	3462	8	Tax	tax	NN
18637	3462	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	3462	10	be	be	VB
18637	3462	11	laid	lay	VBN
18637	3462	12	,	,	,
18637	3462	13	unless	unless	IN
18637	3462	14	in	in	IN
18637	3462	15	Proportion	proportion	NN
18637	3462	16	to	to	IN
18637	3462	17	the	the	DT
18637	3462	18	Census	Census	NNP
18637	3462	19	or	or	CC
18637	3462	20	Enumeration	Enumeration	NNP
18637	3462	21	herein	herein	NNP
18637	3462	22	before	before	IN
18637	3462	23	directed	direct	VBN
18637	3462	24	to	to	TO
18637	3462	25	be	be	VB
18637	3462	26	taken	take	VBN
18637	3462	27	.	.	.
18637	3463	1	DIRECT	DIRECT	NNS
18637	3463	2	TAXES	taxis	NNS
18637	3463	3	The	the	DT
18637	3463	4	Hylton	Hylton	NNP
18637	3463	5	Case	Case	NNP
18637	3463	6	The	the	DT
18637	3463	7	crucial	crucial	JJ
18637	3463	8	problem	problem	NN
18637	3463	9	under	under	IN
18637	3463	10	this	this	DT
18637	3463	11	section	section	NN
18637	3463	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	3463	13	to	to	TO
18637	3463	14	distinguish	distinguish	VB
18637	3463	15	"	"	``
18637	3463	16	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3463	17	"	"	''
18637	3463	18	from	from	IN
18637	3463	19	other	other	JJ
18637	3463	20	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3463	21	.	.	.
18637	3464	1	In	in	IN
18637	3464	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3464	3	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3464	4	in	in	IN
18637	3464	5	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	3464	6	_	_	NNP
18637	3464	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	3464	8	_	_	NNP
18637	3464	9	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	3464	10	'	'	POS
18637	3464	11	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	3464	12	and	and	CC
18637	3464	13	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	3464	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	3464	15	,	,	,
18637	3464	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3464	17	find	find	VBP
18637	3464	18	the	the	DT
18637	3464	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3464	20	declaring	declaring	NN
18637	3464	21	:	:	:
18637	3464	22	"	"	``
18637	3464	23	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3464	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	3464	25	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	3464	26	*	*	NFP
18637	3464	27	*	*	NFP
18637	3464	28	*	*	NFP
18637	3464	29	that	that	IN
18637	3464	30	the	the	DT
18637	3464	31	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	3464	32	between	between	IN
18637	3464	33	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3464	34	and	and	CC
18637	3464	35	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	3464	36	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3464	37	was	be	VBD
18637	3464	38	well	well	RB
18637	3464	39	understood	understand	VBN
18637	3464	40	by	by	IN
18637	3464	41	the	the	DT
18637	3464	42	framers	framer	NNS
18637	3464	43	of	of	IN
18637	3464	44	the	the	DT
18637	3464	45	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3464	46	and	and	CC
18637	3464	47	those	those	DT
18637	3464	48	who	who	WP
18637	3464	49	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	3464	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3464	51	.	.	.
18637	3465	1	"	"	``
18637	3465	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3465	3	1484	1484	CD
18637	3465	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3465	5	Against	against	IN
18637	3465	6	this	this	DT
18637	3465	7	confident	confident	JJ
18637	3465	8	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	3465	9	may	may	MD
18637	3465	10	be	be	VB
18637	3465	11	set	set	VBN
18637	3465	12	the	the	DT
18637	3465	13	following	follow	VBG
18637	3465	14	brief	brief	JJ
18637	3465	15	excerpt	excerpt	NN
18637	3465	16	from	from	IN
18637	3465	17	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	3465	18	's	's	POS
18637	3465	19	Notes	Notes	NNPS
18637	3465	20	on	on	IN
18637	3465	21	the	the	DT
18637	3465	22	Convention	convention	NN
18637	3465	23	:	:	:
18637	3465	24	"	"	''
18637	3465	25	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	3465	26	King	King	NNP
18637	3465	27	asked	ask	VBD
18637	3465	28	what	what	WP
18637	3465	29	was	be	VBD
18637	3465	30	the	the	DT
18637	3465	31	precise	precise	JJ
18637	3465	32	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	3465	33	of	of	IN
18637	3465	34	_	_	NNP
18637	3465	35	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3465	36	_	_	NNP
18637	3465	37	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3465	38	?	?	.
18637	3466	1	No	no	DT
18637	3466	2	one	one	NN
18637	3466	3	answered	answer	VBD
18637	3466	4	.	.	.
18637	3467	1	"	"	``
18637	3467	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3467	3	1485	1485	CD
18637	3467	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3467	5	The	the	DT
18637	3467	6	first	first	JJ
18637	3467	7	case	case	NN
18637	3467	8	to	to	TO
18637	3467	9	come	come	VB
18637	3467	10	before	before	IN
18637	3467	11	the	the	DT
18637	3467	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3467	13	on	on	IN
18637	3467	14	this	this	DT
18637	3467	15	issue	issue	NN
18637	3467	16	was	be	VBD
18637	3467	17	Hylton	Hylton	NNP
18637	3467	18	_	_	NNP
18637	3467	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	3467	20	_	_	NNP
18637	3467	21	United	United	NNP
18637	3467	22	States,[1486	States,[1486	NNP
18637	3467	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3467	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3467	25	was	be	VBD
18637	3467	26	decided	decide	VBN
18637	3467	27	early	early	RB
18637	3467	28	in	in	IN
18637	3467	29	1796	1796	CD
18637	3467	30	.	.	.
18637	3468	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3468	2	had	have	VBD
18637	3468	3	levied	levy	VBN
18637	3468	4	,	,	,
18637	3468	5	according	accord	VBG
18637	3468	6	to	to	IN
18637	3468	7	the	the	DT
18637	3468	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	3468	9	of	of	IN
18637	3468	10	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	3468	11	,	,	,
18637	3468	12	a	a	DT
18637	3468	13	specific	specific	JJ
18637	3468	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	3468	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	3468	16	all	all	DT
18637	3468	17	carriages	carriage	NNS
18637	3468	18	,	,	,
18637	3468	19	for	for	IN
18637	3468	20	the	the	DT
18637	3468	21	conveyance	conveyance	NN
18637	3468	22	of	of	IN
18637	3468	23	persons	person	NNS
18637	3468	24	,	,	,
18637	3468	25	which	which	WDT
18637	3468	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	3468	27	be	be	VB
18637	3468	28	kept	keep	VBN
18637	3468	29	by	by	RP
18637	3468	30	,	,	,
18637	3468	31	or	or	CC
18637	3468	32	for	for	IN
18637	3468	33	any	any	DT
18637	3468	34	person	person	NN
18637	3468	35	,	,	,
18637	3468	36	for	for	IN
18637	3468	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3468	38	own	own	JJ
18637	3468	39	use	use	NN
18637	3468	40	,	,	,
18637	3468	41	or	or	CC
18637	3468	42	to	to	TO
18637	3468	43	be	be	VB
18637	3468	44	let	let	VBN
18637	3468	45	out	out	RP
18637	3468	46	for	for	IN
18637	3468	47	hire	hire	NN
18637	3468	48	,	,	,
18637	3468	49	or	or	CC
18637	3468	50	for	for	IN
18637	3468	51	the	the	DT
18637	3468	52	conveying	conveying	NN
18637	3468	53	of	of	IN
18637	3468	54	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	3468	55	.	.	.
18637	3469	1	In	in	IN
18637	3469	2	a	a	DT
18637	3469	3	fictitious	fictitious	JJ
18637	3469	4	statement	statement	NN
18637	3469	5	of	of	IN
18637	3469	6	facts	fact	NNS
18637	3469	7	,	,	,
18637	3469	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3469	9	was	be	VBD
18637	3469	10	stipulated	stipulate	VBN
18637	3469	11	that	that	IN
18637	3469	12	the	the	DT
18637	3469	13	carriages	carriage	NNS
18637	3469	14	involved	involve	VBN
18637	3469	15	in	in	IN
18637	3469	16	the	the	DT
18637	3469	17	case	case	NN
18637	3469	18	were	be	VBD
18637	3469	19	kept	keep	VBN
18637	3469	20	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	3469	21	for	for	IN
18637	3469	22	the	the	DT
18637	3469	23	personal	personal	JJ
18637	3469	24	use	use	NN
18637	3469	25	of	of	IN
18637	3469	26	the	the	DT
18637	3469	27	owner	owner	NN
18637	3469	28	and	and	CC
18637	3469	29	not	not	RB
18637	3469	30	for	for	IN
18637	3469	31	hire	hire	NN
18637	3469	32	.	.	.
18637	3470	1	The	the	DT
18637	3470	2	principal	principal	JJ
18637	3470	3	argument	argument	NN
18637	3470	4	for	for	IN
18637	3470	5	the	the	DT
18637	3470	6	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	3470	7	of	of	IN
18637	3470	8	the	the	DT
18637	3470	9	measure	measure	NN
18637	3470	10	was	be	VBD
18637	3470	11	made	make	VBN
18637	3470	12	by	by	IN
18637	3470	13	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	3470	14	,	,	,
18637	3470	15	who	who	WP
18637	3470	16	treated	treat	VBD
18637	3470	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3470	18	as	as	IN
18637	3470	19	an	an	DT
18637	3470	20	"	"	``
18637	3470	21	excise	excise	NN
18637	3470	22	tax,"[1487	tax,"[1487	.
18637	3470	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3470	24	while	while	IN
18637	3470	25	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	3470	26	both	both	DT
18637	3470	27	on	on	IN
18637	3470	28	the	the	DT
18637	3470	29	floors	floor	NNS
18637	3470	30	of	of	IN
18637	3470	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3470	32	and	and	CC
18637	3470	33	in	in	IN
18637	3470	34	correspondence	correspondence	NN
18637	3470	35	attacked	attack	VBD
18637	3470	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3470	37	as	as	IN
18637	3470	38	"	"	``
18637	3470	39	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3470	40	"	"	''
18637	3470	41	and	and	CC
18637	3470	42	so	so	RB
18637	3470	43	void	void	JJ
18637	3470	44	,	,	,
18637	3470	45	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	3470	46	as	as	IN
18637	3470	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3470	48	was	be	VBD
18637	3470	49	levied	levy	VBN
18637	3470	50	without	without	IN
18637	3470	51	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	3470	52	.	.	.
18637	3471	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3471	2	1488	1488	CD
18637	3471	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3471	4	The	the	DT
18637	3471	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3471	6	,	,	,
18637	3471	7	taking	take	VBG
18637	3471	8	the	the	DT
18637	3471	9	position	position	NN
18637	3471	10	that	that	IN
18637	3471	11	the	the	DT
18637	3471	12	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3471	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	3471	14	clause	clause	NN
18637	3471	15	constituted	constitute	VBN
18637	3471	16	in	in	IN
18637	3471	17	practical	practical	JJ
18637	3471	18	operation	operation	NN
18637	3471	19	an	an	DT
18637	3471	20	exception	exception	NN
18637	3471	21	to	to	IN
18637	3471	22	the	the	DT
18637	3471	23	general	general	JJ
18637	3471	24	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	3471	25	powers	power	NNS
18637	3471	26	of	of	IN
18637	3471	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3471	28	,	,	,
18637	3471	29	held	hold	VBD
18637	3471	30	that	that	IN
18637	3471	31	no	no	DT
18637	3471	32	tax	tax	NN
18637	3471	33	ought	ought	MD
18637	3471	34	to	to	TO
18637	3471	35	be	be	VB
18637	3471	36	classified	classify	VBN
18637	3471	37	as	as	IN
18637	3471	38	"	"	``
18637	3471	39	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3471	40	"	"	''
18637	3471	41	which	which	WDT
18637	3471	42	could	could	MD
18637	3471	43	not	not	RB
18637	3471	44	be	be	VB
18637	3471	45	conveniently	conveniently	RB
18637	3471	46	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	3471	47	,	,	,
18637	3471	48	and	and	CC
18637	3471	49	on	on	IN
18637	3471	50	this	this	DT
18637	3471	51	basis	basis	NN
18637	3471	52	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	3471	53	the	the	DT
18637	3471	54	tax	tax	NN
18637	3471	55	on	on	IN
18637	3471	56	carriages	carriage	NNS
18637	3471	57	as	as	IN
18637	3471	58	one	one	CD
18637	3471	59	on	on	IN
18637	3471	60	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3471	61	"	"	``
18637	3471	62	use	use	NN
18637	3471	63	"	"	''
18637	3471	64	and	and	CC
18637	3471	65	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	3471	66	an	an	DT
18637	3471	67	"	"	``
18637	3471	68	excise	excise	NN
18637	3471	69	.	.	.
18637	3471	70	"	"	''
18637	3472	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	3472	2	,	,	,
18637	3472	3	each	each	DT
18637	3472	4	of	of	IN
18637	3472	5	the	the	DT
18637	3472	6	judges	judge	NNS
18637	3472	7	advanced	advance	VBD
18637	3472	8	the	the	DT
18637	3472	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3472	10	that	that	IN
18637	3472	11	the	the	DT
18637	3472	12	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3472	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	3472	14	clause	clause	NN
18637	3472	15	should	should	MD
18637	3472	16	be	be	VB
18637	3472	17	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	3472	18	to	to	TO
18637	3472	19	capitation	capitation	VB
18637	3472	20	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3472	21	and	and	CC
18637	3472	22	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3472	23	on	on	IN
18637	3472	24	land	land	NN
18637	3472	25	,	,	,
18637	3472	26	or	or	CC
18637	3472	27	that	that	IN
18637	3472	28	at	at	IN
18637	3472	29	most	most	RBS
18637	3472	30	,	,	,
18637	3472	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3472	32	might	may	MD
18637	3472	33	cover	cover	VB
18637	3472	34	a	a	DT
18637	3472	35	general	general	JJ
18637	3472	36	tax	tax	NN
18637	3472	37	on	on	IN
18637	3472	38	the	the	DT
18637	3472	39	aggregate	aggregate	NN
18637	3472	40	or	or	CC
18637	3472	41	mass	mass	NN
18637	3472	42	of	of	IN
18637	3472	43	things	thing	NNS
18637	3472	44	which	which	WDT
18637	3472	45	generally	generally	RB
18637	3472	46	pervade	pervade	VBP
18637	3472	47	all	all	PDT
18637	3472	48	the	the	DT
18637	3472	49	States	States	NNPS
18637	3472	50	,	,	,
18637	3472	51	especially	especially	RB
18637	3472	52	if	if	IN
18637	3472	53	an	an	DT
18637	3472	54	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	3472	55	should	should	MD
18637	3472	56	intervene	intervene	VB
18637	3472	57	;	;	:
18637	3472	58	while	while	IN
18637	3472	59	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3472	60	Paterson	Paterson	NNP
18637	3472	61	,	,	,
18637	3472	62	who	who	WP
18637	3472	63	had	have	VBD
18637	3472	64	been	be	VBN
18637	3472	65	a	a	DT
18637	3472	66	member	member	NN
18637	3472	67	of	of	IN
18637	3472	68	the	the	DT
18637	3472	69	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3472	70	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	3472	71	,	,	,
18637	3472	72	testified	testify	VBD
18637	3472	73	to	to	IN
18637	3472	74	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3472	75	recollection	recollection	NN
18637	3472	76	that	that	IN
18637	3472	77	the	the	DT
18637	3472	78	principal	principal	JJ
18637	3472	79	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3472	80	of	of	IN
18637	3472	81	the	the	DT
18637	3472	82	provision	provision	NN
18637	3472	83	had	have	VBD
18637	3472	84	been	be	VBN
18637	3472	85	to	to	TO
18637	3472	86	allay	allay	VB
18637	3472	87	the	the	DT
18637	3472	88	fear	fear	NN
18637	3472	89	of	of	IN
18637	3472	90	the	the	DT
18637	3472	91	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	3472	92	States	States	NNPS
18637	3472	93	lest	lest	VBD
18637	3472	94	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3472	95	Negroes	Negroes	NNPS
18637	3472	96	and	and	CC
18637	3472	97	lands	land	NNS
18637	3472	98	should	should	MD
18637	3472	99	be	be	VB
18637	3472	100	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	3472	101	to	to	IN
18637	3472	102	a	a	DT
18637	3472	103	specific	specific	JJ
18637	3472	104	tax	tax	NN
18637	3472	105	.	.	.
18637	3473	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3473	2	1489	1489	CD
18637	3473	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3473	4	From	from	IN
18637	3473	5	the	the	DT
18637	3473	6	Hylton	Hylton	NNP
18637	3473	7	to	to	IN
18637	3473	8	the	the	DT
18637	3473	9	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	3473	10	Case	Case	NNP
18637	3473	11	The	the	DT
18637	3473	12	result	result	NN
18637	3473	13	of	of	IN
18637	3473	14	the	the	DT
18637	3473	15	Hylton	Hylton	NNP
18637	3473	16	case	case	NN
18637	3473	17	was	be	VBD
18637	3473	18	not	not	RB
18637	3473	19	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	3473	20	until	until	IN
18637	3473	21	after	after	IN
18637	3473	22	the	the	DT
18637	3473	23	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3473	24	War	War	NNP
18637	3473	25	.	.	.
18637	3474	1	A	a	DT
18637	3474	2	number	number	NN
18637	3474	3	of	of	IN
18637	3474	4	the	the	DT
18637	3474	5	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3474	6	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	3474	7	to	to	TO
18637	3474	8	meet	meet	VB
18637	3474	9	the	the	DT
18637	3474	10	demands	demand	NNS
18637	3474	11	of	of	IN
18637	3474	12	that	that	DT
18637	3474	13	war	war	NN
18637	3474	14	were	be	VBD
18637	3474	15	assailed	assail	VBN
18637	3474	16	during	during	IN
18637	3474	17	the	the	DT
18637	3474	18	postwar	postwar	JJ
18637	3474	19	period	period	NN
18637	3474	20	as	as	IN
18637	3474	21	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3474	22	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3474	23	,	,	,
18637	3474	24	but	but	CC
18637	3474	25	without	without	IN
18637	3474	26	result	result	NN
18637	3474	27	.	.	.
18637	3475	1	The	the	DT
18637	3475	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3475	3	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	3475	4	successively	successively	RB
18637	3475	5	as	as	IN
18637	3475	6	"	"	``
18637	3475	7	excises	excise	VBZ
18637	3475	8	"	"	''
18637	3475	9	or	or	CC
18637	3475	10	"	"	``
18637	3475	11	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3475	12	,	,	,
18637	3475	13	"	"	''
18637	3475	14	a	a	DT
18637	3475	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	3475	16	on	on	IN
18637	3475	17	an	an	DT
18637	3475	18	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	3475	19	company	company	NN
18637	3475	20	's	's	POS
18637	3475	21	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	3475	22	for	for	IN
18637	3475	23	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	3475	24	and	and	CC
18637	3475	25	assessments;[1490	assessments;[1490	LS
18637	3475	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3475	27	a	a	DT
18637	3475	28	tax	tax	NN
18637	3475	29	on	on	IN
18637	3475	30	the	the	DT
18637	3475	31	circulating	circulate	VBG
18637	3475	32	notes	note	NNS
18637	3475	33	of	of	IN
18637	3475	34	State	State	NNP
18637	3475	35	banks,[1491	banks,[1491	NNP
18637	3475	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3475	37	an	an	DT
18637	3475	38	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	3475	39	tax	tax	NN
18637	3475	40	on	on	IN
18637	3475	41	real	real	JJ
18637	3475	42	estate,[1492	estate,[1492	NNP
18637	3475	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3475	44	and	and	CC
18637	3475	45	finally	finally	RB
18637	3475	46	a	a	DT
18637	3475	47	general	general	JJ
18637	3475	48	tax	tax	NN
18637	3475	49	on	on	IN
18637	3475	50	incomes	income	NNS
18637	3475	51	.	.	.
18637	3476	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3476	2	1493	1493	CD
18637	3476	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3476	4	In	in	IN
18637	3476	5	the	the	DT
18637	3476	6	last	last	JJ
18637	3476	7	case	case	NN
18637	3476	8	,	,	,
18637	3476	9	the	the	DT
18637	3476	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3476	11	took	take	VBD
18637	3476	12	pains	pain	NNS
18637	3476	13	to	to	IN
18637	3476	14	state	state	VB
18637	3476	15	that	that	IN
18637	3476	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3476	17	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	3476	18	the	the	DT
18637	3476	19	term	term	NN
18637	3476	20	"	"	``
18637	3476	21	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3476	22	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3476	23	"	"	''
18637	3476	24	as	as	IN
18637	3476	25	having	have	VBG
18637	3476	26	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	3476	27	a	a	DT
18637	3476	28	definite	definite	JJ
18637	3476	29	and	and	CC
18637	3476	30	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	3476	31	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	3476	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	3476	33	to	to	IN
18637	3476	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	3476	35	wit	wit	NN
18637	3476	36	,	,	,
18637	3476	37	capitation	capitation	NN
18637	3476	38	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3476	39	,	,	,
18637	3476	40	and	and	CC
18637	3476	41	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3476	42	on	on	IN
18637	3476	43	hand	hand	NN
18637	3476	44	.	.	.
18637	3477	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3477	2	1494	1494	CD
18637	3477	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3477	4	Then	then	RB
18637	3477	5	,	,	,
18637	3477	6	almost	almost	RB
18637	3477	7	one	one	CD
18637	3477	8	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	3477	9	years	year	NNS
18637	3477	10	after	after	IN
18637	3477	11	the	the	DT
18637	3477	12	Hylton	Hylton	NNP
18637	3477	13	case	case	NN
18637	3477	14	,	,	,
18637	3477	15	the	the	DT
18637	3477	16	famous	famous	JJ
18637	3477	17	case	case	NN
18637	3477	18	of	of	IN
18637	3477	19	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	3477	20	_	_	NNP
18637	3477	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	3477	22	_	_	NNP
18637	3477	23	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	3477	24	'	'	POS
18637	3477	25	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	3477	26	and	and	CC
18637	3477	27	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	3477	28	Company[1495	Company[1495	NNP
18637	3477	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3477	30	arose	arise	VBD
18637	3477	31	under	under	IN
18637	3477	32	the	the	DT
18637	3477	33	Income	Income	NNP
18637	3477	34	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	3477	35	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3477	36	of	of	IN
18637	3477	37	1894	1894	CD
18637	3477	38	.	.	.
18637	3478	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3478	2	1496	1496	CD
18637	3478	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3478	4	Undertaking	undertake	VBG
18637	3478	5	to	to	TO
18637	3478	6	correct	correct	VB
18637	3478	7	"	"	``
18637	3478	8	a	a	DT
18637	3478	9	century	century	NN
18637	3478	10	of	of	IN
18637	3478	11	error	error	NN
18637	3478	12	"	"	''
18637	3478	13	the	the	DT
18637	3478	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3478	15	held	hold	VBD
18637	3478	16	,	,	,
18637	3478	17	by	by	IN
18637	3478	18	a	a	DT
18637	3478	19	vote	vote	NN
18637	3478	20	of	of	IN
18637	3478	21	five	five	CD
18637	3478	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	3478	23	to	to	IN
18637	3478	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	3478	25	four	four	CD
18637	3478	26	,	,	,
18637	3478	27	that	that	IN
18637	3478	28	a	a	DT
18637	3478	29	tax	tax	NN
18637	3478	30	on	on	IN
18637	3478	31	income	income	NN
18637	3478	32	from	from	IN
18637	3478	33	property	property	NN
18637	3478	34	was	be	VBD
18637	3478	35	a	a	DT
18637	3478	36	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3478	37	tax	tax	NN
18637	3478	38	within	within	IN
18637	3478	39	the	the	DT
18637	3478	40	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	3478	41	of	of	IN
18637	3478	42	the	the	DT
18637	3478	43	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3478	44	and	and	CC
18637	3478	45	hence	hence	RB
18637	3478	46	void	void	JJ
18637	3478	47	because	because	IN
18637	3478	48	not	not	RB
18637	3478	49	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	3478	50	according	accord	VBG
18637	3478	51	to	to	IN
18637	3478	52	the	the	DT
18637	3478	53	census	census	NN
18637	3478	54	.	.	.
18637	3479	1	Restriction	restriction	NN
18637	3479	2	of	of	IN
18637	3479	3	the	the	DT
18637	3479	4	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	3479	5	Decision	Decision	NNP
18637	3479	6	The	the	DT
18637	3479	7	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	3479	8	decision	decision	NN
18637	3479	9	encouraged	encourage	VBD
18637	3479	10	taxpayers	taxpayer	NNS
18637	3479	11	to	to	TO
18637	3479	12	challenge	challenge	VB
18637	3479	13	the	the	DT
18637	3479	14	right	right	NN
18637	3479	15	of	of	IN
18637	3479	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3479	17	to	to	TO
18637	3479	18	levy	levy	VB
18637	3479	19	by	by	IN
18637	3479	20	the	the	DT
18637	3479	21	rule	rule	NN
18637	3479	22	of	of	IN
18637	3479	23	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	3479	24	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	3479	25	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3479	26	which	which	WDT
18637	3479	27	had	have	VBD
18637	3479	28	always	always	RB
18637	3479	29	been	be	VBN
18637	3479	30	reckoned	reckon	VBN
18637	3479	31	to	to	TO
18637	3479	32	be	be	VB
18637	3479	33	excises	excise	NNS
18637	3479	34	.	.	.
18637	3480	1	But	but	CC
18637	3480	2	the	the	DT
18637	3480	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3480	4	evinced	evince	VBD
18637	3480	5	a	a	DT
18637	3480	6	strong	strong	JJ
18637	3480	7	reluctance	reluctance	NN
18637	3480	8	to	to	TO
18637	3480	9	extend	extend	VB
18637	3480	10	the	the	DT
18637	3480	11	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3480	12	to	to	IN
18637	3480	13	such	such	JJ
18637	3480	14	exactions	exaction	NNS
18637	3480	15	.	.	.
18637	3481	1	Purporting	purporting	NN
18637	3481	2	to	to	TO
18637	3481	3	distinguish	distinguish	VB
18637	3481	4	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3481	5	levied	levy	VBN
18637	3481	6	"	"	''
18637	3481	7	because	because	IN
18637	3481	8	of	of	IN
18637	3481	9	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	3481	10	"	"	''
18637	3481	11	or	or	CC
18637	3481	12	"	"	``
18637	3481	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	3481	14	property	property	NN
18637	3481	15	as	as	IN
18637	3481	16	such	such	JJ
18637	3481	17	"	"	``
18637	3481	18	from	from	IN
18637	3481	19	those	those	DT
18637	3481	20	laid	lay	VBN
18637	3481	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	3481	22	"	"	``
18637	3481	23	privileges,"[1497	privileges,"[1497	NN
18637	3481	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3481	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3481	26	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	3481	27	as	as	IN
18637	3481	28	"	"	``
18637	3481	29	excises	excise	VBZ
18637	3481	30	"	"	``
18637	3481	31	a	a	DT
18637	3481	32	tax	tax	NN
18637	3481	33	on	on	IN
18637	3481	34	sales	sale	NNS
18637	3481	35	on	on	IN
18637	3481	36	business	business	NN
18637	3481	37	exchanges;[1498	exchanges;[1498	NNP
18637	3481	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3481	39	a	a	DT
18637	3481	40	succession	succession	NN
18637	3481	41	tax	tax	NN
18637	3481	42	which	which	WDT
18637	3481	43	was	be	VBD
18637	3481	44	construed	construe	VBN
18637	3481	45	to	to	TO
18637	3481	46	fall	fall	VB
18637	3481	47	on	on	IN
18637	3481	48	the	the	DT
18637	3481	49	recipients	recipient	NNS
18637	3481	50	of	of	IN
18637	3481	51	the	the	DT
18637	3481	52	property	property	NN
18637	3481	53	transmitted	transmit	VBN
18637	3481	54	,	,	,
18637	3481	55	rather	rather	RB
18637	3481	56	than	than	IN
18637	3481	57	on	on	IN
18637	3481	58	the	the	DT
18637	3481	59	estate	estate	NN
18637	3481	60	of	of	IN
18637	3481	61	the	the	DT
18637	3481	62	decedent,[1499	decedent,[1499	NNP
18637	3481	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3481	64	and	and	CC
18637	3481	65	a	a	DT
18637	3481	66	tax	tax	NN
18637	3481	67	on	on	IN
18637	3481	68	manufactured	manufactured	JJ
18637	3481	69	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	3481	70	in	in	IN
18637	3481	71	the	the	DT
18637	3481	72	hands	hand	NNS
18637	3481	73	of	of	IN
18637	3481	74	a	a	DT
18637	3481	75	dealer	dealer	NN
18637	3481	76	,	,	,
18637	3481	77	after	after	IN
18637	3481	78	an	an	DT
18637	3481	79	excise	excise	NN
18637	3481	80	tax	tax	NN
18637	3481	81	had	have	VBD
18637	3481	82	been	be	VBN
18637	3481	83	paid	pay	VBN
18637	3481	84	by	by	IN
18637	3481	85	the	the	DT
18637	3481	86	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
18637	3481	87	.	.	.
18637	3482	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3482	2	1500	1500	CD
18637	3482	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3482	4	Again	again	RB
18637	3482	5	,	,	,
18637	3482	6	in	in	IN
18637	3482	7	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	3482	8	_	_	NNP
18637	3482	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	3482	10	_	_	NNP
18637	3482	11	United	United	NNP
18637	3482	12	States,[1501	states,[1501	CD
18637	3482	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3482	14	the	the	DT
18637	3482	15	validity	validity	NN
18637	3482	16	of	of	IN
18637	3482	17	a	a	DT
18637	3482	18	stamp	stamp	NN
18637	3482	19	tax	tax	NN
18637	3482	20	on	on	IN
18637	3482	21	sales	sale	NNS
18637	3482	22	of	of	IN
18637	3482	23	stock	stock	NN
18637	3482	24	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	3482	25	was	be	VBD
18637	3482	26	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	3482	27	on	on	IN
18637	3482	28	the	the	DT
18637	3482	29	basis	basis	NN
18637	3482	30	of	of	IN
18637	3482	31	a	a	DT
18637	3482	32	definition	definition	NN
18637	3482	33	of	of	IN
18637	3482	34	"	"	``
18637	3482	35	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3482	36	,	,	,
18637	3482	37	imposts	impost	NNS
18637	3482	38	and	and	CC
18637	3482	39	excises	excise	NNS
18637	3482	40	.	.	.
18637	3482	41	"	"	''
18637	3483	1	These	these	DT
18637	3483	2	terms	term	NNS
18637	3483	3	,	,	,
18637	3483	4	according	accord	VBG
18637	3483	5	to	to	IN
18637	3483	6	the	the	DT
18637	3483	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3483	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3483	9	,	,	,
18637	3483	10	"	"	''
18637	3483	11	were	be	VBD
18637	3483	12	used	use	VBN
18637	3483	13	comprehensively	comprehensively	RB
18637	3483	14	to	to	TO
18637	3483	15	cover	cover	VB
18637	3483	16	customs	custom	NNS
18637	3483	17	and	and	CC
18637	3483	18	excise	excise	VB
18637	3483	19	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3483	20	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	3483	21	on	on	IN
18637	3483	22	importation	importation	NN
18637	3483	23	,	,	,
18637	3483	24	consumption	consumption	NN
18637	3483	25	,	,	,
18637	3483	26	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	3483	27	and	and	CC
18637	3483	28	sale	sale	NN
18637	3483	29	of	of	IN
18637	3483	30	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3483	31	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	3483	32	,	,	,
18637	3483	33	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3483	34	,	,	,
18637	3483	35	particular	particular	JJ
18637	3483	36	business	business	NN
18637	3483	37	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	3483	38	,	,	,
18637	3483	39	vocations	vocation	NNS
18637	3483	40	,	,	,
18637	3483	41	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	3483	42	and	and	CC
18637	3483	43	the	the	DT
18637	3483	44	like	like	JJ
18637	3483	45	.	.	.
18637	3484	1	"	"	``
18637	3484	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3484	3	1502	1502	CD
18637	3484	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3484	5	On	on	IN
18637	3484	6	the	the	DT
18637	3484	7	same	same	JJ
18637	3484	8	day	day	NN
18637	3484	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3484	10	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	3484	11	,	,	,
18637	3484	12	in	in	IN
18637	3484	13	Spreckels	Spreckels	NNP
18637	3484	14	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	3484	15	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	3484	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	3484	17	_	_	NNP
18637	3484	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	3484	19	_	_	NNP
18637	3484	20	McClain,[1503	McClain,[1503	NNP
18637	3484	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3484	22	that	that	IN
18637	3484	23	an	an	DT
18637	3484	24	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	3484	25	denominated	denominate	VBD
18637	3484	26	a	a	DT
18637	3484	27	special	special	JJ
18637	3484	28	excise	excise	NN
18637	3484	29	tax	tax	NN
18637	3484	30	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	3484	31	on	on	IN
18637	3484	32	the	the	DT
18637	3484	33	business	business	NN
18637	3484	34	of	of	IN
18637	3484	35	refining	refining	NN
18637	3484	36	sugar	sugar	NN
18637	3484	37	and	and	CC
18637	3484	38	measured	measure	VBN
18637	3484	39	by	by	IN
18637	3484	40	the	the	DT
18637	3484	41	gross	gross	JJ
18637	3484	42	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	3484	43	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	3484	44	,	,	,
18637	3484	45	was	be	VBD
18637	3484	46	in	in	IN
18637	3484	47	truth	truth	NN
18637	3484	48	an	an	DT
18637	3484	49	excise	excise	NN
18637	3484	50	and	and	CC
18637	3484	51	hence	hence	RB
18637	3484	52	properly	properly	RB
18637	3484	53	levied	levy	VBN
18637	3484	54	by	by	IN
18637	3484	55	the	the	DT
18637	3484	56	rule	rule	NN
18637	3484	57	of	of	IN
18637	3484	58	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	3484	59	.	.	.
18637	3485	1	The	the	DT
18637	3485	2	lesson	lesson	NN
18637	3485	3	of	of	IN
18637	3485	4	Flint	Flint	NNP
18637	3485	5	_	_	NNP
18637	3485	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	3485	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3485	8	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	3485	9	Tracy	Tracy	NNP
18637	3485	10	Co.[1504	Co.[1504	NNP
18637	3485	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3485	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	3485	13	the	the	DT
18637	3485	14	same	same	JJ
18637	3485	15	.	.	.
18637	3486	1	Here	here	RB
18637	3486	2	what	what	WP
18637	3486	3	was	be	VBD
18637	3486	4	in	in	IN
18637	3486	5	form	form	NN
18637	3486	6	an	an	DT
18637	3486	7	income	income	NN
18637	3486	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	3486	9	was	be	VBD
18637	3486	10	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	3486	11	as	as	IN
18637	3486	12	a	a	DT
18637	3486	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	3486	14	on	on	IN
18637	3486	15	the	the	DT
18637	3486	16	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	3486	17	of	of	IN
18637	3486	18	doing	do	VBG
18637	3486	19	business	business	NN
18637	3486	20	as	as	IN
18637	3486	21	a	a	DT
18637	3486	22	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3486	23	,	,	,
18637	3486	24	the	the	DT
18637	3486	25	value	value	NN
18637	3486	26	of	of	IN
18637	3486	27	the	the	DT
18637	3486	28	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	3486	29	being	be	VBG
18637	3486	30	measured	measure	VBN
18637	3486	31	by	by	IN
18637	3486	32	the	the	DT
18637	3486	33	income	income	NN
18637	3486	34	,	,	,
18637	3486	35	including	include	VBG
18637	3486	36	income	income	NN
18637	3486	37	from	from	IN
18637	3486	38	investments	investment	NNS
18637	3486	39	.	.	.
18637	3487	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	3487	2	,	,	,
18637	3487	3	in	in	IN
18637	3487	4	Stanton	Stanton	NNP
18637	3487	5	_	_	NNP
18637	3487	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	3487	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3487	8	Baltic	Baltic	NNP
18637	3487	9	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	3487	10	Co.[1505	Co.[1505	NNP
18637	3487	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3487	12	a	a	DT
18637	3487	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	3487	14	on	on	IN
18637	3487	15	the	the	DT
18637	3487	16	annual	annual	JJ
18637	3487	17	production	production	NN
18637	3487	18	of	of	IN
18637	3487	19	mines	mine	NNS
18637	3487	20	was	be	VBD
18637	3487	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	3487	22	to	to	TO
18637	3487	23	be	be	VB
18637	3487	24	"	"	``
18637	3487	25	independently	independently	RB
18637	3487	26	of	of	IN
18637	3487	27	the	the	DT
18637	3487	28	effect	effect	NN
18637	3487	29	of	of	IN
18637	3487	30	the	the	DT
18637	3487	31	operation	operation	NN
18637	3487	32	of	of	IN
18637	3487	33	the	the	DT
18637	3487	34	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	3487	35	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3487	36	*	*	NFP
18637	3487	37	*	*	NFP
18637	3487	38	*	*	NFP
18637	3487	39	not	not	RB
18637	3487	40	a	a	DT
18637	3487	41	tax	tax	NN
18637	3487	42	upon	upon	IN
18637	3487	43	property	property	NN
18637	3487	44	as	as	IN
18637	3487	45	such	such	JJ
18637	3487	46	because	because	IN
18637	3487	47	of	of	IN
18637	3487	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3487	49	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	3487	50	,	,	,
18637	3487	51	but	but	CC
18637	3487	52	a	a	DT
18637	3487	53	true	true	JJ
18637	3487	54	excise	excise	NN
18637	3487	55	levied	levy	VBN
18637	3487	56	on	on	IN
18637	3487	57	the	the	DT
18637	3487	58	results	result	NNS
18637	3487	59	of	of	IN
18637	3487	60	the	the	DT
18637	3487	61	business	business	NN
18637	3487	62	of	of	IN
18637	3487	63	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	3487	64	on	on	IN
18637	3487	65	mining	mining	NN
18637	3487	66	operations	operation	NNS
18637	3487	67	.	.	.
18637	3488	1	"	"	``
18637	3488	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3488	3	1506	1506	CD
18637	3488	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3488	5	A	a	DT
18637	3488	6	convincing	convincing	JJ
18637	3488	7	demonstration	demonstration	NN
18637	3488	8	of	of	IN
18637	3488	9	the	the	DT
18637	3488	10	extent	extent	NN
18637	3488	11	to	to	TO
18637	3488	12	which	which	WDT
18637	3488	13	the	the	DT
18637	3488	14	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	3488	15	decision	decision	NN
18637	3488	16	had	have	VBD
18637	3488	17	been	be	VBN
18637	3488	18	whittled	whittle	VBN
18637	3488	19	down	down	RP
18637	3488	20	by	by	IN
18637	3488	21	the	the	DT
18637	3488	22	time	time	NN
18637	3488	23	the	the	DT
18637	3488	24	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	3488	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3488	26	was	be	VBD
18637	3488	27	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	3488	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	3488	29	found	find	VBN
18637	3488	30	in	in	IN
18637	3488	31	Billings	Billings	NNP
18637	3488	32	_	_	NNP
18637	3488	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	3488	34	_	_	NNP
18637	3488	35	United	United	NNP
18637	3488	36	States	States	NNP
18637	3488	37	.	.	.
18637	3489	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3489	2	1507	1507	CD
18637	3489	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3489	4	In	in	IN
18637	3489	5	challenging	challenge	VBG
18637	3489	6	an	an	DT
18637	3489	7	annual	annual	JJ
18637	3489	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	3489	9	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	3489	10	for	for	IN
18637	3489	11	the	the	DT
18637	3489	12	year	year	NN
18637	3489	13	1909	1909	CD
18637	3489	14	on	on	IN
18637	3489	15	the	the	DT
18637	3489	16	use	use	NN
18637	3489	17	of	of	IN
18637	3489	18	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3489	19	built	build	VBN
18637	3489	20	yachts	yacht	NNS
18637	3489	21	--	--	:
18637	3489	22	a	a	DT
18637	3489	23	levy	levy	NN
18637	3489	24	not	not	RB
18637	3489	25	distinguishable	distinguishable	JJ
18637	3489	26	in	in	IN
18637	3489	27	substance	substance	NN
18637	3489	28	from	from	IN
18637	3489	29	the	the	DT
18637	3489	30	carriage	carriage	NN
18637	3489	31	tax	tax	NN
18637	3489	32	involved	involve	VBN
18637	3489	33	in	in	IN
18637	3489	34	the	the	DT
18637	3489	35	Hylton	Hylton	NNP
18637	3489	36	case	case	NN
18637	3489	37	as	as	IN
18637	3489	38	construed	construe	VBN
18637	3489	39	by	by	IN
18637	3489	40	the	the	DT
18637	3489	41	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3489	42	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3489	43	-	-	HYPH
18637	3489	44	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	3489	45	did	do	VBD
18637	3489	46	not	not	RB
18637	3489	47	even	even	RB
18637	3489	48	suggest	suggest	VB
18637	3489	49	that	that	IN
18637	3489	50	the	the	DT
18637	3489	51	tax	tax	NN
18637	3489	52	should	should	MD
18637	3489	53	be	be	VB
18637	3489	54	classed	class	VBN
18637	3489	55	as	as	IN
18637	3489	56	a	a	DT
18637	3489	57	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3489	58	tax	tax	NN
18637	3489	59	.	.	.
18637	3490	1	Instead	instead	RB
18637	3490	2	,	,	,
18637	3490	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3490	4	based	base	VBD
18637	3490	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3490	6	argument	argument	NN
18637	3490	7	that	that	IN
18637	3490	8	the	the	DT
18637	3490	9	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	3490	10	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	3490	11	a	a	DT
18637	3490	12	taking	taking	NN
18637	3490	13	of	of	IN
18637	3490	14	property	property	NN
18637	3490	15	without	without	IN
18637	3490	16	due	due	JJ
18637	3490	17	process	process	NN
18637	3490	18	of	of	IN
18637	3490	19	law	law	NN
18637	3490	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	3490	21	the	the	DT
18637	3490	22	premise	premise	NN
18637	3490	23	that	that	IN
18637	3490	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3490	25	was	be	VBD
18637	3490	26	an	an	DT
18637	3490	27	excise	excise	NN
18637	3490	28	,	,	,
18637	3490	29	and	and	CC
18637	3490	30	the	the	DT
18637	3490	31	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3490	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3490	33	disposed	dispose	VBD
18637	3490	34	of	of	IN
18637	3490	35	the	the	DT
18637	3490	36	case	case	NN
18637	3490	37	upon	upon	IN
18637	3490	38	the	the	DT
18637	3490	39	same	same	JJ
18637	3490	40	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	3490	41	.	.	.
18637	3491	1	In	in	IN
18637	3491	2	1921	1921	CD
18637	3491	3	the	the	DT
18637	3491	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3491	5	cast	cast	VBD
18637	3491	6	aside	aside	RB
18637	3491	7	the	the	DT
18637	3491	8	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	3491	9	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	3491	10	in	in	IN
18637	3491	11	Knowlton	Knowlton	NNP
18637	3491	12	_	_	NNP
18637	3491	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	3491	14	_	_	NNP
18637	3491	15	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	3491	16	between	between	IN
18637	3491	17	the	the	DT
18637	3491	18	right	right	NN
18637	3491	19	to	to	TO
18637	3491	20	transmit	transmit	VB
18637	3491	21	property	property	NN
18637	3491	22	on	on	IN
18637	3491	23	the	the	DT
18637	3491	24	one	one	CD
18637	3491	25	hand	hand	NN
18637	3491	26	and	and	CC
18637	3491	27	the	the	DT
18637	3491	28	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	3491	29	of	of	IN
18637	3491	30	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	3491	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3491	32	on	on	IN
18637	3491	33	the	the	DT
18637	3491	34	other	other	JJ
18637	3491	35	,	,	,
18637	3491	36	and	and	CC
18637	3491	37	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	3491	38	an	an	DT
18637	3491	39	estate	estate	NN
18637	3491	40	tax	tax	NN
18637	3491	41	as	as	IN
18637	3491	42	an	an	DT
18637	3491	43	excise	excise	NN
18637	3491	44	.	.	.
18637	3492	1	"	"	``
18637	3492	2	Upon	upon	IN
18637	3492	3	this	this	DT
18637	3492	4	point	point	NN
18637	3492	5	"	"	''
18637	3492	6	wrote	write	VBD
18637	3492	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3492	8	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	3492	9	for	for	IN
18637	3492	10	a	a	DT
18637	3492	11	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	3492	12	court	court	NN
18637	3492	13	,	,	,
18637	3492	14	"	"	''
18637	3492	15	a	a	DT
18637	3492	16	page	page	NN
18637	3492	17	of	of	IN
18637	3492	18	history	history	NN
18637	3492	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	3492	20	worth	worth	JJ
18637	3492	21	a	a	DT
18637	3492	22	volume	volume	NN
18637	3492	23	of	of	IN
18637	3492	24	logic	logic	NN
18637	3492	25	.	.	.
18637	3493	1	"	"	``
18637	3493	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3493	3	1508	1508	CD
18637	3493	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3493	5	This	this	DT
18637	3493	6	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	3493	7	being	be	VBG
18637	3493	8	established	establish	VBN
18637	3493	9	,	,	,
18637	3493	10	the	the	DT
18637	3493	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3493	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	3493	13	had	have	VBN
18637	3493	14	no	no	DT
18637	3493	15	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	3493	16	in	in	IN
18637	3493	17	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	3493	18	that	that	IN
18637	3493	19	the	the	DT
18637	3493	20	inclusion	inclusion	NN
18637	3493	21	in	in	IN
18637	3493	22	the	the	DT
18637	3493	23	computation	computation	NN
18637	3493	24	of	of	IN
18637	3493	25	the	the	DT
18637	3493	26	estate	estate	NN
18637	3493	27	tax	tax	NN
18637	3493	28	of	of	IN
18637	3493	29	property	property	NN
18637	3493	30	held	hold	VBN
18637	3493	31	as	as	IN
18637	3493	32	joint	joint	JJ
18637	3493	33	tenants,[1509	tenants,[1509	NNP
18637	3493	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3493	35	or	or	CC
18637	3493	36	as	as	IN
18637	3493	37	tenants	tenant	NNS
18637	3493	38	by	by	IN
18637	3493	39	the	the	DT
18637	3493	40	entirety,[1510	entirety,[1510	NNP
18637	3493	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3493	42	or	or	CC
18637	3493	43	the	the	DT
18637	3493	44	entire	entire	JJ
18637	3493	45	value	value	NN
18637	3493	46	of	of	IN
18637	3493	47	community	community	NN
18637	3493	48	property	property	NN
18637	3493	49	owned	own	VBN
18637	3493	50	by	by	IN
18637	3493	51	husband	husband	NN
18637	3493	52	and	and	CC
18637	3493	53	wife,[1511	wife,[1511	NNP
18637	3493	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3493	55	or	or	CC
18637	3493	56	the	the	DT
18637	3493	57	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	3493	58	of	of	IN
18637	3493	59	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	3493	60	upon	upon	IN
18637	3493	61	the	the	DT
18637	3493	62	life	life	NN
18637	3493	63	of	of	IN
18637	3493	64	the	the	DT
18637	3493	65	decedent,[1512	decedent,[1512	NNP
18637	3493	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3493	67	did	do	VBD
18637	3493	68	not	not	RB
18637	3493	69	amount	amount	VB
18637	3493	70	to	to	IN
18637	3493	71	direct	direct	VB
18637	3493	72	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3493	73	of	of	IN
18637	3493	74	such	such	JJ
18637	3493	75	property	property	NN
18637	3493	76	.	.	.
18637	3494	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	3494	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3494	3	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	3494	4	a	a	DT
18637	3494	5	graduated	graduate	VBN
18637	3494	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	3494	7	on	on	IN
18637	3494	8	gifts	gift	NNS
18637	3494	9	as	as	IN
18637	3494	10	an	an	DT
18637	3494	11	excise	excise	NN
18637	3494	12	,	,	,
18637	3494	13	saying	say	VBG
18637	3494	14	that	that	IN
18637	3494	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3494	16	was	be	VBD
18637	3494	17	"	"	``
18637	3494	18	a	a	DT
18637	3494	19	tax	tax	NN
18637	3494	20	laid	lay	VBN
18637	3494	21	only	only	RB
18637	3494	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	3494	23	the	the	DT
18637	3494	24	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3494	25	of	of	IN
18637	3494	26	a	a	DT
18637	3494	27	single	single	JJ
18637	3494	28	one	one	CD
18637	3494	29	of	of	IN
18637	3494	30	those	those	DT
18637	3494	31	powers	power	NNS
18637	3494	32	incident	incident	VBP
18637	3494	33	to	to	IN
18637	3494	34	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	3494	35	,	,	,
18637	3494	36	the	the	DT
18637	3494	37	power	power	NN
18637	3494	38	to	to	TO
18637	3494	39	give	give	VB
18637	3494	40	the	the	DT
18637	3494	41	property	property	NN
18637	3494	42	owned	own	VBN
18637	3494	43	to	to	IN
18637	3494	44	another	another	DT
18637	3494	45	.	.	.
18637	3495	1	"	"	``
18637	3495	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3495	3	1513	1513	CD
18637	3495	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3495	5	In	in	IN
18637	3495	6	vain	vain	JJ
18637	3495	7	did	do	VBD
18637	3495	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3495	9	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	3495	10	,	,	,
18637	3495	11	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	3495	12	for	for	IN
18637	3495	13	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3495	14	and	and	CC
18637	3495	15	two	two	CD
18637	3495	16	associates	associate	NNS
18637	3495	17	,	,	,
18637	3495	18	urge	urge	VBP
18637	3495	19	that	that	IN
18637	3495	20	"	"	``
18637	3495	21	the	the	DT
18637	3495	22	right	right	NN
18637	3495	23	to	to	TO
18637	3495	24	give	give	VB
18637	3495	25	away	away	RP
18637	3495	26	one	one	NN
18637	3495	27	's	's	POS
18637	3495	28	property	property	NN
18637	3495	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	3495	30	as	as	RB
18637	3495	31	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	3495	32	as	as	IN
18637	3495	33	the	the	DT
18637	3495	34	right	right	NN
18637	3495	35	to	to	TO
18637	3495	36	sell	sell	VB
18637	3495	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3495	38	or	or	CC
18637	3495	39	,	,	,
18637	3495	40	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	3495	41	,	,	,
18637	3495	42	to	to	TO
18637	3495	43	possess	possess	VB
18637	3495	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3495	45	.	.	.
18637	3496	1	"	"	``
18637	3496	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3496	3	1514	1514	CD
18637	3496	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3496	5	Miscellaneous	miscellaneous	JJ
18637	3496	6	The	the	DT
18637	3496	7	power	power	NN
18637	3496	8	of	of	IN
18637	3496	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3496	10	to	to	TO
18637	3496	11	levy	levy	VB
18637	3496	12	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3496	13	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3496	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	3496	15	not	not	RB
18637	3496	16	confined	confine	VBN
18637	3496	17	to	to	IN
18637	3496	18	the	the	DT
18637	3496	19	States	state	NNS
18637	3496	20	which	which	WDT
18637	3496	21	are	be	VBP
18637	3496	22	represented	represent	VBN
18637	3496	23	in	in	IN
18637	3496	24	that	that	DT
18637	3496	25	body	body	NN
18637	3496	26	.	.	.
18637	3497	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	3497	2	a	a	DT
18637	3497	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	3497	4	may	may	MD
18637	3497	5	be	be	VB
18637	3497	6	levied	levy	VBN
18637	3497	7	in	in	IN
18637	3497	8	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	3497	9	to	to	IN
18637	3497	10	population	population	NN
18637	3497	11	in	in	IN
18637	3497	12	the	the	DT
18637	3497	13	District	District	NNP
18637	3497	14	of	of	IN
18637	3497	15	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	3497	16	.	.	.
18637	3498	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3498	2	1515	1515	CD
18637	3498	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3498	4	A	a	DT
18637	3498	5	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	3498	6	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	3498	7	for	for	IN
18637	3498	8	nonpayment	nonpayment	NN
18637	3498	9	of	of	IN
18637	3498	10	a	a	DT
18637	3498	11	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3498	12	tax	tax	NN
18637	3498	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	3498	14	not	not	RB
18637	3498	15	a	a	DT
18637	3498	16	part	part	NN
18637	3498	17	of	of	IN
18637	3498	18	the	the	DT
18637	3498	19	tax	tax	NN
18637	3498	20	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3498	21	and	and	CC
18637	3498	22	hence	hence	RB
18637	3498	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	3498	24	not	not	RB
18637	3498	25	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3498	26	to	to	IN
18637	3498	27	the	the	DT
18637	3498	28	rule	rule	NN
18637	3498	29	of	of	IN
18637	3498	30	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	3498	31	.	.	.
18637	3499	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	3499	2	,	,	,
18637	3499	3	the	the	DT
18637	3499	4	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3499	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3499	6	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	3499	7	the	the	DT
18637	3499	8	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	3499	9	of	of	IN
18637	3499	10	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	3499	11	percent	percent	NN
18637	3499	12	which	which	WDT
18637	3499	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3499	14	exacted	exact	VBD
18637	3499	15	for	for	IN
18637	3499	16	default	default	NN
18637	3499	17	in	in	IN
18637	3499	18	the	the	DT
18637	3499	19	payment	payment	NN
18637	3499	20	of	of	IN
18637	3499	21	the	the	DT
18637	3499	22	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3499	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	3499	24	on	on	IN
18637	3499	25	land	land	NN
18637	3499	26	in	in	IN
18637	3499	27	the	the	DT
18637	3499	28	aggregate	aggregate	JJ
18637	3499	29	amount	amount	NN
18637	3499	30	of	of	IN
18637	3499	31	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	3499	32	million	million	CD
18637	3499	33	dollars	dollar	NNS
18637	3499	34	which	which	WDT
18637	3499	35	was	be	VBD
18637	3499	36	levied	levy	VBN
18637	3499	37	and	and	CC
18637	3499	38	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	3499	39	among	among	IN
18637	3499	40	the	the	DT
18637	3499	41	States	States	NNP
18637	3499	42	during	during	IN
18637	3499	43	the	the	DT
18637	3499	44	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3499	45	War	War	NNP
18637	3499	46	.	.	.
18637	3500	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3500	2	1516	1516	CD
18637	3500	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3500	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3500	5	5	5	CD
18637	3500	6	.	.	.
18637	3501	1	No	no	DT
18637	3501	2	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	3501	3	or	or	CC
18637	3501	4	Duty	Duty	NNP
18637	3501	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	3501	6	be	be	VB
18637	3501	7	laid	lay	VBN
18637	3501	8	on	on	IN
18637	3501	9	Articles	article	NNS
18637	3501	10	exported	export	VBN
18637	3501	11	from	from	IN
18637	3501	12	any	any	DT
18637	3501	13	State	State	NNP
18637	3501	14	.	.	.
18637	3502	1	TAXES	taxis	NNS
18637	3502	2	ON	on	IN
18637	3502	3	EXPORTS	exports	RB
18637	3502	4	This	this	DT
18637	3502	5	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3502	6	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	3502	7	only	only	RB
18637	3502	8	to	to	IN
18637	3502	9	the	the	DT
18637	3502	10	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	3502	11	of	of	IN
18637	3502	12	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3502	13	on	on	IN
18637	3502	14	goods	good	NNS
18637	3502	15	by	by	IN
18637	3502	16	reason	reason	NN
18637	3502	17	of	of	IN
18637	3502	18	exportation	exportation	NN
18637	3502	19	.	.	.
18637	3503	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3503	2	1517	1517	CD
18637	3503	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3503	4	The	the	DT
18637	3503	5	word	word	NN
18637	3503	6	"	"	``
18637	3503	7	export	export	NN
18637	3503	8	"	"	''
18637	3503	9	signifies	signifie	NNS
18637	3503	10	goods	good	NNS
18637	3503	11	exported	export	VBN
18637	3503	12	to	to	IN
18637	3503	13	a	a	DT
18637	3503	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3503	15	country	country	NN
18637	3503	16	,	,	,
18637	3503	17	not	not	RB
18637	3503	18	to	to	IN
18637	3503	19	an	an	DT
18637	3503	20	unincorporated	unincorporated	JJ
18637	3503	21	territory	territory	NN
18637	3503	22	of	of	IN
18637	3503	23	the	the	DT
18637	3503	24	United	United	NNP
18637	3503	25	States	States	NNP
18637	3503	26	.	.	.
18637	3504	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3504	2	1518	1518	CD
18637	3504	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3504	4	A	a	DT
18637	3504	5	general	general	JJ
18637	3504	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	3504	7	laid	lay	VBN
18637	3504	8	on	on	IN
18637	3504	9	all	all	DT
18637	3504	10	property	property	NN
18637	3504	11	alike	alike	RB
18637	3504	12	,	,	,
18637	3504	13	including	include	VBG
18637	3504	14	that	that	IN
18637	3504	15	intended	intend	VBN
18637	3504	16	for	for	IN
18637	3504	17	export	export	NN
18637	3504	18	,	,	,
18637	3504	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	3504	20	not	not	RB
18637	3504	21	within	within	IN
18637	3504	22	the	the	DT
18637	3504	23	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3504	24	,	,	,
18637	3504	25	if	if	IN
18637	3504	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3504	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	3504	28	not	not	RB
18637	3504	29	levied	levy	VBN
18637	3504	30	on	on	IN
18637	3504	31	goods	good	NNS
18637	3504	32	in	in	IN
18637	3504	33	course	course	NN
18637	3504	34	of	of	IN
18637	3504	35	exportation	exportation	NN
18637	3504	36	nor	nor	CC
18637	3504	37	because	because	IN
18637	3504	38	of	of	IN
18637	3504	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3504	40	intended	intend	VBN
18637	3504	41	exportation	exportation	NN
18637	3504	42	.	.	.
18637	3505	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3505	2	1519	1519	CD
18637	3505	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3505	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	3505	5	the	the	DT
18637	3505	6	sale	sale	NN
18637	3505	7	to	to	IN
18637	3505	8	a	a	DT
18637	3505	9	commission	commission	NN
18637	3505	10	merchant	merchant	NN
18637	3505	11	for	for	IN
18637	3505	12	a	a	DT
18637	3505	13	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3505	14	consignee	consignee	NN
18637	3505	15	was	be	VBD
18637	3505	16	consummated	consummate	VBN
18637	3505	17	by	by	IN
18637	3505	18	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	3505	19	of	of	IN
18637	3505	20	the	the	DT
18637	3505	21	goods	good	NNS
18637	3505	22	to	to	IN
18637	3505	23	an	an	DT
18637	3505	24	exporting	export	VBG
18637	3505	25	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	3505	26	,	,	,
18637	3505	27	the	the	DT
18637	3505	28	sale	sale	NN
18637	3505	29	was	be	VBD
18637	3505	30	held	hold	VBN
18637	3505	31	to	to	TO
18637	3505	32	be	be	VB
18637	3505	33	a	a	DT
18637	3505	34	step	step	NN
18637	3505	35	in	in	IN
18637	3505	36	the	the	DT
18637	3505	37	exportation	exportation	NN
18637	3505	38	and	and	CC
18637	3505	39	hence	hence	RB
18637	3505	40	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	3505	41	from	from	IN
18637	3505	42	a	a	DT
18637	3505	43	general	general	JJ
18637	3505	44	tax	tax	NN
18637	3505	45	on	on	IN
18637	3505	46	sales	sale	NNS
18637	3505	47	of	of	IN
18637	3505	48	such	such	JJ
18637	3505	49	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	3505	50	.	.	.
18637	3506	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3506	2	1520	1520	CD
18637	3506	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3506	4	The	the	DT
18637	3506	5	giving	giving	NN
18637	3506	6	of	of	IN
18637	3506	7	a	a	DT
18637	3506	8	bond	bond	NN
18637	3506	9	for	for	IN
18637	3506	10	exportation	exportation	NN
18637	3506	11	of	of	IN
18637	3506	12	distilled	distil	VBN
18637	3506	13	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	3506	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	3506	15	not	not	RB
18637	3506	16	the	the	DT
18637	3506	17	commencement	commencement	NN
18637	3506	18	of	of	IN
18637	3506	19	exportation	exportation	NN
18637	3506	20	so	so	IN
18637	3506	21	as	as	IN
18637	3506	22	to	to	TO
18637	3506	23	exempt	exempt	VB
18637	3506	24	from	from	IN
18637	3506	25	an	an	DT
18637	3506	26	excise	excise	NN
18637	3506	27	tax	tax	NN
18637	3506	28	spirits	spirit	NNS
18637	3506	29	which	which	WDT
18637	3506	30	were	be	VBD
18637	3506	31	not	not	RB
18637	3506	32	exported	export	VBN
18637	3506	33	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	3506	34	to	to	IN
18637	3506	35	such	such	JJ
18637	3506	36	bond	bond	NN
18637	3506	37	.	.	.
18637	3507	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3507	2	1521	1521	CD
18637	3507	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3507	4	A	a	DT
18637	3507	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	3507	6	on	on	IN
18637	3507	7	the	the	DT
18637	3507	8	income	income	NN
18637	3507	9	of	of	IN
18637	3507	10	a	a	DT
18637	3507	11	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3507	12	derived	derive	VBN
18637	3507	13	from	from	IN
18637	3507	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3507	15	export	export	NN
18637	3507	16	trade	trade	NN
18637	3507	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	3507	18	not	not	RB
18637	3507	19	a	a	DT
18637	3507	20	tax	tax	NN
18637	3507	21	on	on	IN
18637	3507	22	"	"	``
18637	3507	23	articles	article	NNS
18637	3507	24	exported	export	VBN
18637	3507	25	"	"	''
18637	3507	26	within	within	IN
18637	3507	27	the	the	DT
18637	3507	28	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	3507	29	of	of	IN
18637	3507	30	the	the	DT
18637	3507	31	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3507	32	.	.	.
18637	3508	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3508	2	1522	1522	CD
18637	3508	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3508	4	Stamp	Stamp	NNP
18637	3508	5	Taxes	Taxes	NNP
18637	3508	6	A	a	DT
18637	3508	7	stamp	stamp	NN
18637	3508	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	3508	9	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	3508	10	on	on	IN
18637	3508	11	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3508	12	bills	bill	NNS
18637	3508	13	of	of	IN
18637	3508	14	lading,[1523	lading,[1523	NNP
18637	3508	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3508	16	charter	charter	NN
18637	3508	17	parties,[1524	parties,[1524	NNP
18637	3508	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3508	19	or	or	CC
18637	3508	20	marine	marine	JJ
18637	3508	21	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	3508	22	policies,[1525	policies,[1525	NNP
18637	3508	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3508	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	3508	25	in	in	IN
18637	3508	26	effect	effect	NN
18637	3508	27	a	a	DT
18637	3508	28	tax	tax	NN
18637	3508	29	or	or	CC
18637	3508	30	duty	duty	NN
18637	3508	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	3508	32	exports	export	NNS
18637	3508	33	,	,	,
18637	3508	34	and	and	CC
18637	3508	35	so	so	RB
18637	3508	36	void	void	JJ
18637	3508	37	;	;	:
18637	3508	38	but	but	CC
18637	3508	39	an	an	DT
18637	3508	40	act	act	NN
18637	3508	41	requiring	require	VBG
18637	3508	42	the	the	DT
18637	3508	43	stamping	stamping	NN
18637	3508	44	of	of	IN
18637	3508	45	all	all	DT
18637	3508	46	packages	package	NNS
18637	3508	47	of	of	IN
18637	3508	48	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	3508	49	intended	intend	VBN
18637	3508	50	for	for	IN
18637	3508	51	export	export	NN
18637	3508	52	in	in	IN
18637	3508	53	order	order	NN
18637	3508	54	to	to	TO
18637	3508	55	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	3508	56	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	3508	57	was	be	VBD
18637	3508	58	held	hold	VBN
18637	3508	59	not	not	RB
18637	3508	60	to	to	TO
18637	3508	61	be	be	VB
18637	3508	62	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	3508	63	as	as	IN
18637	3508	64	a	a	DT
18637	3508	65	tax	tax	NN
18637	3508	66	on	on	IN
18637	3508	67	exports	export	NNS
18637	3508	68	.	.	.
18637	3509	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3509	2	1526	1526	CD
18637	3509	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3509	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3509	5	6	6	CD
18637	3509	6	.	.	.
18637	3510	1	No	no	DT
18637	3510	2	Preference	Preference	NNP
18637	3510	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	3510	4	be	be	VB
18637	3510	5	given	give	VBN
18637	3510	6	by	by	IN
18637	3510	7	any	any	DT
18637	3510	8	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	3510	9	of	of	IN
18637	3510	10	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	3510	11	or	or	CC
18637	3510	12	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	3510	13	to	to	IN
18637	3510	14	the	the	DT
18637	3510	15	Ports	Ports	NNPS
18637	3510	16	of	of	IN
18637	3510	17	one	one	CD
18637	3510	18	State	state	NN
18637	3510	19	over	over	IN
18637	3510	20	those	those	DT
18637	3510	21	of	of	IN
18637	3510	22	another	another	DT
18637	3510	23	:	:	:
18637	3510	24	nor	nor	CC
18637	3510	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	3510	26	Vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	3510	27	bound	bind	VBN
18637	3510	28	to	to	IN
18637	3510	29	,	,	,
18637	3510	30	or	or	CC
18637	3510	31	from	from	IN
18637	3510	32	,	,	,
18637	3510	33	one	one	CD
18637	3510	34	State	state	NN
18637	3510	35	,	,	,
18637	3510	36	be	be	VB
18637	3510	37	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	3510	38	to	to	TO
18637	3510	39	enter	enter	VB
18637	3510	40	,	,	,
18637	3510	41	clear	clear	JJ
18637	3510	42	,	,	,
18637	3510	43	or	or	CC
18637	3510	44	pay	pay	VB
18637	3510	45	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3510	46	in	in	IN
18637	3510	47	another	another	DT
18637	3510	48	.	.	.
18637	3511	1	THE	the	DT
18637	3511	2	"	"	``
18637	3511	3	NO	no	DT
18637	3511	4	PREFERENCE	PREFERENCE	NNP
18637	3511	5	"	"	''
18637	3511	6	CLAUSE	clause	NN
18637	3511	7	The	the	DT
18637	3511	8	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	3511	9	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	3511	10	by	by	IN
18637	3511	11	this	this	DT
18637	3511	12	section	section	NN
18637	3511	13	were	be	VBD
18637	3511	14	designed	design	VBN
18637	3511	15	to	to	TO
18637	3511	16	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	3511	17	preferences	preference	NNS
18637	3511	18	as	as	IN
18637	3511	19	between	between	IN
18637	3511	20	ports	port	NNS
18637	3511	21	on	on	IN
18637	3511	22	account	account	NN
18637	3511	23	of	of	IN
18637	3511	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3511	25	location	location	NN
18637	3511	26	in	in	IN
18637	3511	27	different	different	JJ
18637	3511	28	States	state	NNS
18637	3511	29	.	.	.
18637	3512	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3512	2	do	do	VBP
18637	3512	3	not	not	RB
18637	3512	4	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	3512	5	such	such	JJ
18637	3512	6	discriminations	discrimination	NNS
18637	3512	7	as	as	IN
18637	3512	8	between	between	IN
18637	3512	9	individual	individual	JJ
18637	3512	10	ports	port	NNS
18637	3512	11	.	.	.
18637	3513	1	Acting	act	VBG
18637	3513	2	under	under	IN
18637	3513	3	the	the	DT
18637	3513	4	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	3513	5	clause	clause	NN
18637	3513	6	,	,	,
18637	3513	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3513	8	may	may	MD
18637	3513	9	do	do	VB
18637	3513	10	many	many	JJ
18637	3513	11	things	thing	NNS
18637	3513	12	which	which	WDT
18637	3513	13	benefit	benefit	VBP
18637	3513	14	particular	particular	JJ
18637	3513	15	ports	port	NNS
18637	3513	16	and	and	CC
18637	3513	17	which	which	WDT
18637	3513	18	incidentally	incidentally	RB
18637	3513	19	result	result	VBP
18637	3513	20	to	to	IN
18637	3513	21	the	the	DT
18637	3513	22	disadvantage	disadvantage	NN
18637	3513	23	of	of	IN
18637	3513	24	other	other	JJ
18637	3513	25	ports	port	NNS
18637	3513	26	in	in	IN
18637	3513	27	the	the	DT
18637	3513	28	same	same	JJ
18637	3513	29	or	or	CC
18637	3513	30	neighboring	neighboring	JJ
18637	3513	31	States	state	NNS
18637	3513	32	.	.	.
18637	3514	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3514	2	may	may	MD
18637	3514	3	establish	establish	VB
18637	3514	4	ports	port	NNS
18637	3514	5	of	of	IN
18637	3514	6	entry	entry	NN
18637	3514	7	,	,	,
18637	3514	8	erect	erect	NN
18637	3514	9	and	and	CC
18637	3514	10	operate	operate	VBP
18637	3514	11	lighthouses	lighthouse	NNS
18637	3514	12	,	,	,
18637	3514	13	improve	improve	VB
18637	3514	14	rivers	river	NNS
18637	3514	15	and	and	CC
18637	3514	16	harbors	harbor	NNS
18637	3514	17	,	,	,
18637	3514	18	and	and	CC
18637	3514	19	provide	provide	VB
18637	3514	20	structures	structure	NNS
18637	3514	21	for	for	IN
18637	3514	22	the	the	DT
18637	3514	23	convenient	convenient	JJ
18637	3514	24	and	and	CC
18637	3514	25	economical	economical	JJ
18637	3514	26	handling	handling	NN
18637	3514	27	of	of	IN
18637	3514	28	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	3514	29	.	.	.
18637	3515	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3515	2	1527	1527	CD
18637	3515	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3515	4	A	a	DT
18637	3515	5	rate	rate	NN
18637	3515	6	order	order	NN
18637	3515	7	of	of	IN
18637	3515	8	the	the	DT
18637	3515	9	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	3515	10	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	3515	11	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	3515	12	which	which	WDT
18637	3515	13	allowed	allow	VBD
18637	3515	14	an	an	DT
18637	3515	15	additional	additional	JJ
18637	3515	16	charge	charge	NN
18637	3515	17	to	to	TO
18637	3515	18	be	be	VB
18637	3515	19	made	make	VBN
18637	3515	20	for	for	IN
18637	3515	21	ferrying	ferry	VBG
18637	3515	22	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	3515	23	across	across	IN
18637	3515	24	the	the	DT
18637	3515	25	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	3515	26	to	to	IN
18637	3515	27	cities	city	NNS
18637	3515	28	on	on	IN
18637	3515	29	the	the	DT
18637	3515	30	east	east	NNP
18637	3515	31	bank	bank	NNP
18637	3515	32	of	of	IN
18637	3515	33	the	the	DT
18637	3515	34	river	river	NN
18637	3515	35	was	be	VBD
18637	3515	36	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	3515	37	over	over	IN
18637	3515	38	the	the	DT
18637	3515	39	objection	objection	NN
18637	3515	40	that	that	IN
18637	3515	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3515	42	gave	give	VBD
18637	3515	43	an	an	DT
18637	3515	44	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	3515	45	preference	preference	NN
18637	3515	46	to	to	IN
18637	3515	47	ports	port	NNS
18637	3515	48	in	in	IN
18637	3515	49	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	3515	50	.	.	.
18637	3516	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3516	2	1528	1528	CD
18637	3516	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3516	4	Although	although	IN
18637	3516	5	there	there	EX
18637	3516	6	were	be	VBD
18637	3516	7	a	a	DT
18637	3516	8	few	few	JJ
18637	3516	9	early	early	JJ
18637	3516	10	intimations	intimation	NNS
18637	3516	11	that	that	IN
18637	3516	12	this	this	DT
18637	3516	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	3516	14	was	be	VBD
18637	3516	15	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	3516	16	to	to	IN
18637	3516	17	the	the	DT
18637	3516	18	States	state	NNS
18637	3516	19	as	as	RB
18637	3516	20	well	well	RB
18637	3516	21	as	as	IN
18637	3516	22	to	to	IN
18637	3516	23	Congress,[1529	congress,[1529	CD
18637	3516	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3516	25	the	the	DT
18637	3516	26	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3516	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3516	28	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3516	29	emphatically	emphatically	RB
18637	3516	30	in	in	IN
18637	3516	31	1886	1886	CD
18637	3516	32	that	that	IN
18637	3516	33	State	State	NNP
18637	3516	34	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3516	35	was	be	VBD
18637	3516	36	unaffected	unaffected	JJ
18637	3516	37	by	by	IN
18637	3516	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3516	39	.	.	.
18637	3517	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3517	2	1530	1530	CD
18637	3517	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3517	4	After	after	IN
18637	3517	5	more	more	JJR
18637	3517	6	than	than	IN
18637	3517	7	a	a	DT
18637	3517	8	century	century	NN
18637	3517	9	the	the	DT
18637	3517	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3517	11	confirmed	confirm	VBD
18637	3517	12	,	,	,
18637	3517	13	over	over	IN
18637	3517	14	the	the	DT
18637	3517	15	objection	objection	NN
18637	3517	16	that	that	IN
18637	3517	17	this	this	DT
18637	3517	18	clause	clause	NN
18637	3517	19	was	be	VBD
18637	3517	20	offended	offend	VBN
18637	3517	21	,	,	,
18637	3517	22	the	the	DT
18637	3517	23	power	power	NN
18637	3517	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3517	25	the	the	DT
18637	3517	26	First	First	NNP
18637	3517	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3517	28	had	have	VBD
18637	3517	29	exercised[1531	exercised[1531	NNP
18637	3517	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3517	31	in	in	IN
18637	3517	32	sanctioning	sanction	VBG
18637	3517	33	the	the	DT
18637	3517	34	continued	continued	JJ
18637	3517	35	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	3517	36	and	and	CC
18637	3517	37	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	3517	38	of	of	IN
18637	3517	39	pilots	pilot	NNS
18637	3517	40	by	by	IN
18637	3517	41	the	the	DT
18637	3517	42	States	States	NNP
18637	3517	43	.	.	.
18637	3518	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3518	2	1532	1532	CD
18637	3518	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3518	4	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	3518	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	3518	6	not	not	RB
18637	3518	7	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	3518	8	to	to	TO
18637	3518	9	be	be	VB
18637	3518	10	a	a	DT
18637	3518	11	State	state	NN
18637	3518	12	within	within	IN
18637	3518	13	the	the	DT
18637	3518	14	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	3518	15	of	of	IN
18637	3518	16	this	this	DT
18637	3518	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	3518	18	.	.	.
18637	3519	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3519	2	1533	1533	CD
18637	3519	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3519	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3519	5	7	7	CD
18637	3519	6	.	.	.
18637	3520	1	No	no	DT
18637	3520	2	Money	money	NN
18637	3520	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	3520	4	be	be	VB
18637	3520	5	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	3520	6	from	from	IN
18637	3520	7	the	the	DT
18637	3520	8	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	3520	9	,	,	,
18637	3520	10	but	but	CC
18637	3520	11	in	in	IN
18637	3520	12	Consequence	Consequence	NNP
18637	3520	13	of	of	IN
18637	3520	14	Appropriations	Appropriations	NNPS
18637	3520	15	made	make	VBN
18637	3520	16	by	by	IN
18637	3520	17	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3520	18	;	;	:
18637	3520	19	and	and	CC
18637	3520	20	a	a	DT
18637	3520	21	regular	regular	JJ
18637	3520	22	Statement	Statement	NNP
18637	3520	23	and	and	CC
18637	3520	24	Account	Account	NNP
18637	3520	25	of	of	IN
18637	3520	26	the	the	DT
18637	3520	27	Receipts	Receipts	NNPS
18637	3520	28	and	and	CC
18637	3520	29	Expenditures	Expenditures	NNPS
18637	3520	30	of	of	IN
18637	3520	31	all	all	DT
18637	3520	32	public	public	JJ
18637	3520	33	Money	money	NN
18637	3520	34	shall	shall	MD
18637	3520	35	be	be	VB
18637	3520	36	published	publish	VBN
18637	3520	37	from	from	IN
18637	3520	38	time	time	NN
18637	3520	39	to	to	IN
18637	3520	40	time	time	NN
18637	3520	41	.	.	.
18637	3521	1	APPROPRIATIONS	APPROPRIATIONS	NNP
18637	3521	2	This	this	DT
18637	3521	3	clause	clause	NN
18637	3521	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	3521	5	a	a	DT
18637	3521	6	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	3521	7	upon	upon	IN
18637	3521	8	the	the	DT
18637	3521	9	power	power	NN
18637	3521	10	of	of	IN
18637	3521	11	the	the	DT
18637	3521	12	executive	executive	JJ
18637	3521	13	department	department	NN
18637	3521	14	and	and	CC
18637	3521	15	does	do	VBZ
18637	3521	16	not	not	RB
18637	3521	17	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	3521	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3521	19	in	in	IN
18637	3521	20	appropriating	appropriate	VBG
18637	3521	21	moneys	money	NNS
18637	3521	22	in	in	IN
18637	3521	23	the	the	DT
18637	3521	24	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	3521	25	.	.	.
18637	3522	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3522	2	1534	1534	CD
18637	3522	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3522	4	That	that	DT
18637	3522	5	body	body	NN
18637	3522	6	may	may	MD
18637	3522	7	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	3522	8	and	and	CC
18637	3522	9	pay	pay	VB
18637	3522	10	a	a	DT
18637	3522	11	claim	claim	NN
18637	3522	12	of	of	IN
18637	3522	13	an	an	DT
18637	3522	14	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	3522	15	,	,	,
18637	3522	16	moral	moral	JJ
18637	3522	17	or	or	CC
18637	3522	18	honorary	honorary	JJ
18637	3522	19	nature	nature	NN
18637	3522	20	.	.	.
18637	3523	1	Where	where	WRB
18637	3523	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3523	3	directs	direct	VBZ
18637	3523	4	a	a	DT
18637	3523	5	specific	specific	JJ
18637	3523	6	sum	sum	NN
18637	3523	7	to	to	TO
18637	3523	8	be	be	VB
18637	3523	9	paid	pay	VBN
18637	3523	10	to	to	IN
18637	3523	11	a	a	DT
18637	3523	12	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3523	13	person	person	NN
18637	3523	14	,	,	,
18637	3523	15	neither	neither	CC
18637	3523	16	the	the	DT
18637	3523	17	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	3523	18	of	of	IN
18637	3523	19	the	the	DT
18637	3523	20	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	3523	21	nor	nor	CC
18637	3523	22	any	any	DT
18637	3523	23	court	court	NN
18637	3523	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	3523	25	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	3523	26	to	to	TO
18637	3523	27	determine	determine	VB
18637	3523	28	whether	whether	IN
18637	3523	29	the	the	DT
18637	3523	30	person	person	NN
18637	3523	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	3523	32	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	3523	33	to	to	TO
18637	3523	34	receive	receive	VB
18637	3523	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3523	36	.	.	.
18637	3524	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3524	2	1535	1535	CD
18637	3524	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3524	4	In	in	IN
18637	3524	5	making	make	VBG
18637	3524	6	appropriations	appropriation	NNS
18637	3524	7	to	to	TO
18637	3524	8	pay	pay	VB
18637	3524	9	claims	claim	NNS
18637	3524	10	arising	arise	VBG
18637	3524	11	out	out	IN
18637	3524	12	of	of	IN
18637	3524	13	the	the	DT
18637	3524	14	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3524	15	War	War	NNP
18637	3524	16	,	,	,
18637	3524	17	the	the	DT
18637	3524	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3524	19	held	hold	VBD
18637	3524	20	that	that	IN
18637	3524	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3524	22	was	be	VBD
18637	3524	23	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	3524	24	to	to	TO
18637	3524	25	provide	provide	VB
18637	3524	26	that	that	IN
18637	3524	27	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3524	28	persons	person	NNS
18637	3524	29	,	,	,
18637	3524	30	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	3524	31	,	,	,
18637	3524	32	those	those	DT
18637	3524	33	who	who	WP
18637	3524	34	had	have	VBD
18637	3524	35	aided	aid	VBN
18637	3524	36	the	the	DT
18637	3524	37	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	3524	38	,	,	,
18637	3524	39	should	should	MD
18637	3524	40	not	not	RB
18637	3524	41	be	be	VB
18637	3524	42	paid	pay	VBN
18637	3524	43	out	out	IN
18637	3524	44	of	of	IN
18637	3524	45	the	the	DT
18637	3524	46	funds	fund	NNS
18637	3524	47	made	make	VBN
18637	3524	48	available	available	JJ
18637	3524	49	by	by	IN
18637	3524	50	the	the	DT
18637	3524	51	general	general	JJ
18637	3524	52	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	3524	53	,	,	,
18637	3524	54	but	but	CC
18637	3524	55	that	that	IN
18637	3524	56	such	such	JJ
18637	3524	57	persons	person	NNS
18637	3524	58	should	should	MD
18637	3524	59	seek	seek	VB
18637	3524	60	relief	relief	NN
18637	3524	61	from	from	IN
18637	3524	62	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3524	63	.	.	.
18637	3525	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3525	2	1536	1536	CD
18637	3525	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3525	4	The	the	DT
18637	3525	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3525	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	3525	7	also	also	RB
18637	3525	8	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	3525	9	that	that	IN
18637	3525	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3525	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	3525	12	a	a	DT
18637	3525	13	wide	wide	JJ
18637	3525	14	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	3525	15	as	as	IN
18637	3525	16	to	to	IN
18637	3525	17	the	the	DT
18637	3525	18	extent	extent	NN
18637	3525	19	to	to	TO
18637	3525	20	which	which	WDT
18637	3525	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3525	22	shall	shall	MD
18637	3525	23	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	3525	24	details	detail	NNS
18637	3525	25	of	of	IN
18637	3525	26	expenditures	expenditure	NNS
18637	3525	27	for	for	IN
18637	3525	28	which	which	WDT
18637	3525	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3525	30	appropriates	appropriate	VBZ
18637	3525	31	funds	fund	NNS
18637	3525	32	and	and	CC
18637	3525	33	has	have	VBZ
18637	3525	34	approved	approve	VBN
18637	3525	35	the	the	DT
18637	3525	36	frequent	frequent	JJ
18637	3525	37	practice	practice	NN
18637	3525	38	of	of	IN
18637	3525	39	making	make	VBG
18637	3525	40	general	general	JJ
18637	3525	41	appropriations	appropriation	NNS
18637	3525	42	of	of	IN
18637	3525	43	large	large	JJ
18637	3525	44	amounts	amount	NNS
18637	3525	45	to	to	TO
18637	3525	46	be	be	VB
18637	3525	47	allotted	allot	VBN
18637	3525	48	and	and	CC
18637	3525	49	expended	expend	VBN
18637	3525	50	as	as	IN
18637	3525	51	directed	direct	VBN
18637	3525	52	by	by	IN
18637	3525	53	designated	designate	VBN
18637	3525	54	government	government	NN
18637	3525	55	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	3525	56	.	.	.
18637	3526	1	Citing	cite	VBG
18637	3526	2	as	as	IN
18637	3526	3	an	an	DT
18637	3526	4	example	example	NN
18637	3526	5	the	the	DT
18637	3526	6	act	act	NN
18637	3526	7	of	of	IN
18637	3526	8	June	June	NNP
18637	3526	9	17	17	CD
18637	3526	10	,	,	,
18637	3526	11	1902[1537	1902[1537	CD
18637	3526	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3526	13	where	where	WRB
18637	3526	14	all	all	DT
18637	3526	15	moneys	money	NNS
18637	3526	16	received	receive	VBN
18637	3526	17	from	from	IN
18637	3526	18	the	the	DT
18637	3526	19	sale	sale	NN
18637	3526	20	and	and	CC
18637	3526	21	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	3526	22	of	of	IN
18637	3526	23	public	public	JJ
18637	3526	24	lands	land	NNS
18637	3526	25	in	in	IN
18637	3526	26	a	a	DT
18637	3526	27	large	large	JJ
18637	3526	28	number	number	NN
18637	3526	29	of	of	IN
18637	3526	30	States	state	NNS
18637	3526	31	and	and	CC
18637	3526	32	territories	territory	NNS
18637	3526	33	were	be	VBD
18637	3526	34	set	set	VBN
18637	3526	35	aside	aside	RB
18637	3526	36	as	as	IN
18637	3526	37	a	a	DT
18637	3526	38	special	special	JJ
18637	3526	39	fund	fund	NN
18637	3526	40	to	to	TO
18637	3526	41	be	be	VB
18637	3526	42	expended	expend	VBN
18637	3526	43	under	under	IN
18637	3526	44	the	the	DT
18637	3526	45	direction	direction	NN
18637	3526	46	of	of	IN
18637	3526	47	the	the	DT
18637	3526	48	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	3526	49	of	of	IN
18637	3526	50	the	the	DT
18637	3526	51	Interior	Interior	NNP
18637	3526	52	upon	upon	IN
18637	3526	53	such	such	JJ
18637	3526	54	projects	project	NNS
18637	3526	55	as	as	IN
18637	3526	56	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3526	57	determined	determine	VBD
18637	3526	58	to	to	TO
18637	3526	59	be	be	VB
18637	3526	60	practicable	practicable	JJ
18637	3526	61	and	and	CC
18637	3526	62	advisable	advisable	JJ
18637	3526	63	for	for	IN
18637	3526	64	the	the	DT
18637	3526	65	reclamation	reclamation	NN
18637	3526	66	of	of	IN
18637	3526	67	arid	arid	NNP
18637	3526	68	and	and	CC
18637	3526	69	semi	semi	JJ
18637	3526	70	-	-	JJ
18637	3526	71	arid	arid	JJ
18637	3526	72	lands	land	NNS
18637	3526	73	within	within	IN
18637	3526	74	those	those	DT
18637	3526	75	States	state	NNS
18637	3526	76	and	and	CC
18637	3526	77	territories	territory	NNS
18637	3526	78	,	,	,
18637	3526	79	the	the	DT
18637	3526	80	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3526	81	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3526	82	:	:	:
18637	3526	83	"	"	``
18637	3526	84	The	the	DT
18637	3526	85	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	3526	86	of	of	IN
18637	3526	87	this	this	DT
18637	3526	88	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	3526	89	of	of	IN
18637	3526	90	authority	authority	NN
18637	3526	91	has	have	VBZ
18637	3526	92	never	never	RB
18637	3526	93	been	be	VBN
18637	3526	94	seriously	seriously	RB
18637	3526	95	questioned	question	VBN
18637	3526	96	.	.	.
18637	3527	1	"	"	``
18637	3527	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3527	3	1538	1538	CD
18637	3527	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3527	5	PAYMENT	payment	NN
18637	3527	6	OF	of	IN
18637	3527	7	CLAIMS	claim	NNS
18637	3527	8	No	no	DT
18637	3527	9	officer	officer	NN
18637	3527	10	of	of	IN
18637	3527	11	the	the	DT
18637	3527	12	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3527	13	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3527	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	3527	15	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	3527	16	to	to	TO
18637	3527	17	pay	pay	VB
18637	3527	18	a	a	DT
18637	3527	19	debt	debt	NN
18637	3527	20	due	due	JJ
18637	3527	21	from	from	IN
18637	3527	22	the	the	DT
18637	3527	23	United	United	NNP
18637	3527	24	States	States	NNP
18637	3527	25	,	,	,
18637	3527	26	whether	whether	IN
18637	3527	27	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	3527	28	to	to	IN
18637	3527	29	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	3527	30	or	or	CC
18637	3527	31	not	not	RB
18637	3527	32	,	,	,
18637	3527	33	without	without	IN
18637	3527	34	an	an	DT
18637	3527	35	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	3527	36	for	for	IN
18637	3527	37	that	that	DT
18637	3527	38	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3527	39	.	.	.
18637	3528	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3528	2	1539	1539	CD
18637	3528	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3528	4	After	after	IN
18637	3528	5	the	the	DT
18637	3528	6	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3528	7	War	War	NNP
18637	3528	8	,	,	,
18637	3528	9	a	a	DT
18637	3528	10	number	number	NN
18637	3528	11	of	of	IN
18637	3528	12	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	3528	13	arose	arise	VBN
18637	3528	14	out	out	IN
18637	3528	15	of	of	IN
18637	3528	16	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	3528	17	by	by	IN
18637	3528	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3528	19	to	to	TO
18637	3528	20	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	3528	21	the	the	DT
18637	3528	22	payment	payment	NN
18637	3528	23	of	of	IN
18637	3528	24	the	the	DT
18637	3528	25	claims	claim	NNS
18637	3528	26	of	of	IN
18637	3528	27	persons	person	NNS
18637	3528	28	who	who	WP
18637	3528	29	had	have	VBD
18637	3528	30	aided	aid	VBN
18637	3528	31	the	the	DT
18637	3528	32	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
18637	3528	33	,	,	,
18637	3528	34	but	but	CC
18637	3528	35	had	have	VBD
18637	3528	36	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	3528	37	received	receive	VBN
18637	3528	38	a	a	DT
18637	3528	39	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	3528	40	from	from	IN
18637	3528	41	the	the	DT
18637	3528	42	President	President	NNP
18637	3528	43	.	.	.
18637	3529	1	The	the	DT
18637	3529	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3529	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3529	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	3529	5	that	that	IN
18637	3529	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3529	7	could	could	MD
18637	3529	8	not	not	RB
18637	3529	9	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	3529	10	the	the	DT
18637	3529	11	evidentiary	evidentiary	JJ
18637	3529	12	effect	effect	NN
18637	3529	13	of	of	IN
18637	3529	14	a	a	DT
18637	3529	15	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	3529	16	in	in	IN
18637	3529	17	a	a	DT
18637	3529	18	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	3529	19	in	in	IN
18637	3529	20	the	the	DT
18637	3529	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3529	22	of	of	IN
18637	3529	23	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	3529	24	for	for	IN
18637	3529	25	property	property	NN
18637	3529	26	confiscated	confiscate	VBN
18637	3529	27	during	during	IN
18637	3529	28	the	the	DT
18637	3529	29	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3529	30	War,[1540	war,[1540	NN
18637	3529	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3529	32	but	but	CC
18637	3529	33	that	that	IN
18637	3529	34	where	where	WRB
18637	3529	35	the	the	DT
18637	3529	36	confiscated	confiscate	VBN
18637	3529	37	property	property	NN
18637	3529	38	had	have	VBD
18637	3529	39	been	be	VBN
18637	3529	40	sold	sell	VBN
18637	3529	41	and	and	CC
18637	3529	42	the	the	DT
18637	3529	43	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	3529	44	paid	pay	VBN
18637	3529	45	into	into	IN
18637	3529	46	the	the	DT
18637	3529	47	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	3529	48	,	,	,
18637	3529	49	a	a	DT
18637	3529	50	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	3529	51	did	do	VBD
18637	3529	52	not	not	RB
18637	3529	53	of	of	IN
18637	3529	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3529	55	own	own	JJ
18637	3529	56	force	force	NN
18637	3529	57	authorize	authorize	VBP
18637	3529	58	the	the	DT
18637	3529	59	restoration	restoration	NN
18637	3529	60	of	of	IN
18637	3529	61	such	such	JJ
18637	3529	62	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	3529	63	.	.	.
18637	3530	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3530	2	1541	1541	CD
18637	3530	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3530	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3530	5	was	be	VBD
18637	3530	6	within	within	IN
18637	3530	7	the	the	DT
18637	3530	8	competence	competence	NN
18637	3530	9	of	of	IN
18637	3530	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3530	11	to	to	TO
18637	3530	12	declare	declare	VB
18637	3530	13	that	that	IN
18637	3530	14	the	the	DT
18637	3530	15	amounts	amount	NNS
18637	3530	16	due	due	JJ
18637	3530	17	to	to	IN
18637	3530	18	persons	person	NNS
18637	3530	19	thus	thus	RB
18637	3530	20	pardoned	pardon	VBN
18637	3530	21	should	should	MD
18637	3530	22	not	not	RB
18637	3530	23	be	be	VB
18637	3530	24	paid	pay	VBN
18637	3530	25	out	out	IN
18637	3530	26	of	of	IN
18637	3530	27	the	the	DT
18637	3530	28	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	3530	29	and	and	CC
18637	3530	30	that	that	IN
18637	3530	31	no	no	DT
18637	3530	32	general	general	JJ
18637	3530	33	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	3530	34	should	should	MD
18637	3530	35	extend	extend	VB
18637	3530	36	to	to	IN
18637	3530	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3530	38	claims	claim	NNS
18637	3530	39	.	.	.
18637	3531	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3531	2	1542	1542	CD
18637	3531	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3531	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3531	5	8	8	CD
18637	3531	6	.	.	.
18637	3532	1	No	no	DT
18637	3532	2	Title	title	NN
18637	3532	3	of	of	IN
18637	3532	4	Nobility	Nobility	NNP
18637	3532	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	3532	6	be	be	VB
18637	3532	7	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3532	8	by	by	IN
18637	3532	9	the	the	DT
18637	3532	10	United	United	NNP
18637	3532	11	States	States	NNP
18637	3532	12	:	:	:
18637	3532	13	And	and	CC
18637	3532	14	no	no	DT
18637	3532	15	Person	person	NN
18637	3532	16	holding	hold	VBG
18637	3532	17	any	any	DT
18637	3532	18	Office	Office	NNP
18637	3532	19	of	of	IN
18637	3532	20	Profit	Profit	NNP
18637	3532	21	or	or	CC
18637	3532	22	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	3532	23	under	under	IN
18637	3532	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3532	25	,	,	,
18637	3532	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	3532	27	,	,	,
18637	3532	28	without	without	IN
18637	3532	29	the	the	DT
18637	3532	30	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	3532	31	of	of	IN
18637	3532	32	the	the	DT
18637	3532	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3532	34	,	,	,
18637	3532	35	accept	accept	VB
18637	3532	36	of	of	IN
18637	3532	37	any	any	DT
18637	3532	38	present	present	NN
18637	3532	39	,	,	,
18637	3532	40	Emolument	Emolument	NNP
18637	3532	41	,	,	,
18637	3532	42	Office	Office	NNP
18637	3532	43	,	,	,
18637	3532	44	or	or	CC
18637	3532	45	Title	Title	NNP
18637	3532	46	,	,	,
18637	3532	47	of	of	IN
18637	3532	48	any	any	DT
18637	3532	49	kind	kind	NN
18637	3532	50	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	3532	51	,	,	,
18637	3532	52	from	from	IN
18637	3532	53	any	any	DT
18637	3532	54	King	King	NNP
18637	3532	55	,	,	,
18637	3532	56	Prince	Prince	NNP
18637	3532	57	,	,	,
18637	3532	58	or	or	CC
18637	3532	59	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3532	60	State	state	NN
18637	3532	61	.	.	.
18637	3533	1	In	in	IN
18637	3533	2	1871	1871	CD
18637	3533	3	the	the	DT
18637	3533	4	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	3533	5	General	General	NNP
18637	3533	6	of	of	IN
18637	3533	7	the	the	DT
18637	3533	8	United	United	NNP
18637	3533	9	States	States	NNP
18637	3533	10	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	3533	11	that	that	DT
18637	3533	12	:	:	:
18637	3533	13	"	"	``
18637	3533	14	A	a	DT
18637	3533	15	minister	minister	NN
18637	3533	16	of	of	IN
18637	3533	17	the	the	DT
18637	3533	18	United	United	NNP
18637	3533	19	States	States	NNP
18637	3533	20	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	3533	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	3533	22	not	not	RB
18637	3533	23	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	3533	24	by	by	IN
18637	3533	25	the	the	DT
18637	3533	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3533	27	from	from	IN
18637	3533	28	rendering	render	VBG
18637	3533	29	a	a	DT
18637	3533	30	friendly	friendly	JJ
18637	3533	31	service	service	NN
18637	3533	32	to	to	IN
18637	3533	33	a	a	DT
18637	3533	34	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3533	35	power	power	NN
18637	3533	36	,	,	,
18637	3533	37	even	even	RB
18637	3533	38	that	that	DT
18637	3533	39	of	of	IN
18637	3533	40	negotiating	negotiate	VBG
18637	3533	41	a	a	DT
18637	3533	42	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	3533	43	for	for	IN
18637	3533	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3533	45	,	,	,
18637	3533	46	provided	provide	VBN
18637	3533	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3533	48	does	do	VBZ
18637	3533	49	not	not	RB
18637	3533	50	become	become	VB
18637	3533	51	an	an	DT
18637	3533	52	officer	officer	NN
18637	3533	53	of	of	IN
18637	3533	54	that	that	DT
18637	3533	55	power	power	NN
18637	3533	56	,	,	,
18637	3533	57	but	but	CC
18637	3533	58	the	the	DT
18637	3533	59	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	3533	60	of	of	IN
18637	3533	61	a	a	DT
18637	3533	62	formal	formal	JJ
18637	3533	63	commission	commission	NN
18637	3533	64	,	,	,
18637	3533	65	as	as	IN
18637	3533	66	minister	minister	NNP
18637	3533	67	plenipotentiary	plenipotentiary	NNP
18637	3533	68	,	,	,
18637	3533	69	creates	create	VBZ
18637	3533	70	an	an	DT
18637	3533	71	official	official	JJ
18637	3533	72	relation	relation	NN
18637	3533	73	between	between	IN
18637	3533	74	the	the	DT
18637	3533	75	individual	individual	NN
18637	3533	76	thus	thus	RB
18637	3533	77	commissioned	commission	VBN
18637	3533	78	and	and	CC
18637	3533	79	the	the	DT
18637	3533	80	government	government	NN
18637	3533	81	which	which	WDT
18637	3533	82	in	in	IN
18637	3533	83	this	this	DT
18637	3533	84	way	way	NN
18637	3533	85	accredits	accredit	VBZ
18637	3533	86	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3533	87	as	as	IN
18637	3533	88	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3533	89	representative	representative	NN
18637	3533	90	,	,	,
18637	3533	91	which	which	WDT
18637	3533	92	is	be	VBZ
18637	3533	93	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	3533	94	by	by	IN
18637	3533	95	this	this	DT
18637	3533	96	clause	clause	NN
18637	3533	97	of	of	IN
18637	3533	98	the	the	DT
18637	3533	99	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3533	100	.	.	.
18637	3534	1	"	"	``
18637	3534	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3534	3	1543	1543	CD
18637	3534	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3534	5	Section	section	NN
18637	3534	6	10	10	CD
18637	3534	7	.	.	.
18637	3535	1	No	no	DT
18637	3535	2	State	State	NNP
18637	3535	3	Shall	Shall	MD
18637	3535	4	enter	enter	VB
18637	3535	5	into	into	IN
18637	3535	6	any	any	DT
18637	3535	7	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	3535	8	,	,	,
18637	3535	9	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	3535	10	,	,	,
18637	3535	11	or	or	CC
18637	3535	12	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	3535	13	;	;	:
18637	3535	14	grant	grant	VBP
18637	3535	15	Letters	letter	NNS
18637	3535	16	of	of	IN
18637	3535	17	Marque	Marque	NNP
18637	3535	18	and	and	CC
18637	3535	19	Reprisal	Reprisal	NNP
18637	3535	20	;	;	,
18637	3535	21	coin	coin	NN
18637	3535	22	Money	money	NN
18637	3535	23	;	;	:
18637	3535	24	emit	emit	NN
18637	3535	25	Bills	Bills	NNPS
18637	3535	26	of	of	IN
18637	3535	27	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	3535	28	;	;	:
18637	3535	29	make	make	VB
18637	3535	30	any	any	DT
18637	3535	31	Thing	thing	NN
18637	3535	32	but	but	CC
18637	3535	33	gold	gold	NN
18637	3535	34	and	and	CC
18637	3535	35	silver	silver	NN
18637	3535	36	Coin	Coin	NNP
18637	3535	37	a	a	DT
18637	3535	38	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	3535	39	in	in	IN
18637	3535	40	Payment	Payment	NNP
18637	3535	41	of	of	IN
18637	3535	42	Debts	Debts	NNP
18637	3535	43	;	;	:
18637	3535	44	pass	pass	VB
18637	3535	45	any	any	DT
18637	3535	46	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	3535	47	of	of	IN
18637	3535	48	Attainder	Attainder	NNP
18637	3535	49	,	,	,
18637	3535	50	ex	ex	FW
18637	3535	51	post	post	FW
18637	3535	52	facto	facto	FW
18637	3535	53	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3535	54	,	,	,
18637	3535	55	or	or	CC
18637	3535	56	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3535	57	impairing	impair	VBG
18637	3535	58	the	the	DT
18637	3535	59	Obligation	Obligation	NNP
18637	3535	60	of	of	IN
18637	3535	61	Contracts	Contracts	NNPS
18637	3535	62	,	,	,
18637	3535	63	or	or	CC
18637	3535	64	grant	grant	VB
18637	3535	65	any	any	DT
18637	3535	66	Title	title	NN
18637	3535	67	of	of	IN
18637	3535	68	Nobility	Nobility	NNP
18637	3535	69	.	.	.
18637	3536	1	Powers	power	NNS
18637	3536	2	Denied	deny	VBN
18637	3536	3	to	to	IN
18637	3536	4	the	the	DT
18637	3536	5	States	States	NNP
18637	3536	6	TREATIES	TREATIES	NNP
18637	3536	7	,	,	,
18637	3536	8	ALLIANCES	alliances	NN
18637	3536	9	OR	or	CC
18637	3536	10	CONFEDERATIONS	confederation	NNS
18637	3536	11	At	at	IN
18637	3536	12	the	the	DT
18637	3536	13	time	time	NN
18637	3536	14	of	of	IN
18637	3536	15	the	the	DT
18637	3536	16	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3536	17	War	War	NNP
18637	3536	18	this	this	DT
18637	3536	19	clause	clause	NN
18637	3536	20	was	be	VBD
18637	3536	21	one	one	CD
18637	3536	22	of	of	IN
18637	3536	23	the	the	DT
18637	3536	24	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	3536	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	3536	26	which	which	WDT
18637	3536	27	the	the	DT
18637	3536	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3536	29	relied	rely	VBD
18637	3536	30	in	in	IN
18637	3536	31	holding	hold	VBG
18637	3536	32	that	that	IN
18637	3536	33	the	the	DT
18637	3536	34	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	3536	35	formed	form	VBN
18637	3536	36	by	by	IN
18637	3536	37	the	the	DT
18637	3536	38	seceding	seceding	NN
18637	3536	39	States	States	NNP
18637	3536	40	could	could	MD
18637	3536	41	not	not	RB
18637	3536	42	be	be	VB
18637	3536	43	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	3536	44	as	as	IN
18637	3536	45	having	have	VBG
18637	3536	46	any	any	DT
18637	3536	47	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3536	48	existence	existence	NN
18637	3536	49	.	.	.
18637	3537	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3537	2	1544	1544	CD
18637	3537	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3537	4	Today	today	NN
18637	3537	5	,	,	,
18637	3537	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3537	7	practical	practical	JJ
18637	3537	8	significance	significance	NN
18637	3537	9	lies	lie	VBZ
18637	3537	10	in	in	IN
18637	3537	11	the	the	DT
18637	3537	12	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	3537	13	which	which	WDT
18637	3537	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3537	15	implies	imply	VBZ
18637	3537	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	3537	17	the	the	DT
18637	3537	18	power	power	NN
18637	3537	19	of	of	IN
18637	3537	20	the	the	DT
18637	3537	21	States	States	NNPS
18637	3537	22	to	to	TO
18637	3537	23	deal	deal	VB
18637	3537	24	with	with	IN
18637	3537	25	matters	matter	NNS
18637	3537	26	having	have	VBG
18637	3537	27	a	a	DT
18637	3537	28	bearing	bearing	NN
18637	3537	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	3537	30	international	international	JJ
18637	3537	31	relations	relation	NNS
18637	3537	32	.	.	.
18637	3538	1	In	in	IN
18637	3538	2	the	the	DT
18637	3538	3	early	early	JJ
18637	3538	4	case	case	NN
18637	3538	5	of	of	IN
18637	3538	6	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	3538	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3538	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	3538	9	_	_	NNP
18637	3538	10	Jennison,[1545	Jennison,[1545	NNP
18637	3538	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3538	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3538	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3538	14	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	3538	15	invoked	invoke	VBD
18637	3538	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3538	17	as	as	IN
18637	3538	18	a	a	DT
18637	3538	19	reason	reason	NN
18637	3538	20	for	for	IN
18637	3538	21	holding	hold	VBG
18637	3538	22	that	that	IN
18637	3538	23	a	a	DT
18637	3538	24	State	state	NN
18637	3538	25	had	have	VBD
18637	3538	26	no	no	DT
18637	3538	27	power	power	NN
18637	3538	28	to	to	TO
18637	3538	29	deliver	deliver	VB
18637	3538	30	up	up	RP
18637	3538	31	a	a	DT
18637	3538	32	fugitive	fugitive	NN
18637	3538	33	from	from	IN
18637	3538	34	justice	justice	NN
18637	3538	35	to	to	IN
18637	3538	36	a	a	DT
18637	3538	37	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3538	38	State	state	NN
18637	3538	39	.	.	.
18637	3539	1	Recently	recently	RB
18637	3539	2	the	the	DT
18637	3539	3	kindred	kindred	JJ
18637	3539	4	idea	idea	NN
18637	3539	5	that	that	IN
18637	3539	6	the	the	DT
18637	3539	7	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	3539	8	for	for	IN
18637	3539	9	the	the	DT
18637	3539	10	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	3539	11	of	of	IN
18637	3539	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3539	13	relations	relation	NNS
18637	3539	14	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	3539	15	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	3539	16	with	with	IN
18637	3539	17	the	the	DT
18637	3539	18	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3539	19	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3539	20	prompted	prompt	VBD
18637	3539	21	the	the	DT
18637	3539	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3539	23	to	to	TO
18637	3539	24	hold	hold	VB
18637	3539	25	that	that	DT
18637	3539	26	,	,	,
18637	3539	27	since	since	IN
18637	3539	28	the	the	DT
18637	3539	29	oil	oil	NN
18637	3539	30	under	under	IN
18637	3539	31	the	the	DT
18637	3539	32	three	three	CD
18637	3539	33	mile	mile	NN
18637	3539	34	marginal	marginal	JJ
18637	3539	35	belt	belt	NN
18637	3539	36	along	along	IN
18637	3539	37	the	the	DT
18637	3539	38	California	California	NNP
18637	3539	39	coast	coast	NN
18637	3539	40	might	may	MD
18637	3539	41	well	well	RB
18637	3539	42	become	become	VB
18637	3539	43	the	the	DT
18637	3539	44	subject	subject	NN
18637	3539	45	of	of	IN
18637	3539	46	international	international	JJ
18637	3539	47	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	3539	48	and	and	CC
18637	3539	49	since	since	IN
18637	3539	50	the	the	DT
18637	3539	51	ocean	ocean	NN
18637	3539	52	,	,	,
18637	3539	53	including	include	VBG
18637	3539	54	this	this	DT
18637	3539	55	three	three	CD
18637	3539	56	mile	mile	NN
18637	3539	57	belt	belt	NN
18637	3539	58	,	,	,
18637	3539	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	3539	60	of	of	IN
18637	3539	61	vital	vital	JJ
18637	3539	62	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	3539	63	to	to	IN
18637	3539	64	the	the	DT
18637	3539	65	nation	nation	NN
18637	3539	66	in	in	IN
18637	3539	67	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3539	68	desire	desire	NN
18637	3539	69	to	to	TO
18637	3539	70	engage	engage	VB
18637	3539	71	in	in	IN
18637	3539	72	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	3539	73	and	and	CC
18637	3539	74	to	to	TO
18637	3539	75	live	live	VB
18637	3539	76	in	in	IN
18637	3539	77	peace	peace	NN
18637	3539	78	with	with	IN
18637	3539	79	the	the	DT
18637	3539	80	world	world	NN
18637	3539	81	,	,	,
18637	3539	82	the	the	DT
18637	3539	83	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3539	84	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3539	85	has	have	VBZ
18637	3539	86	paramount	paramount	JJ
18637	3539	87	rights	right	NNS
18637	3539	88	in	in	IN
18637	3539	89	and	and	CC
18637	3539	90	power	power	NN
18637	3539	91	over	over	IN
18637	3539	92	that	that	DT
18637	3539	93	belt	belt	NN
18637	3539	94	,	,	,
18637	3539	95	including	include	VBG
18637	3539	96	full	full	JJ
18637	3539	97	dominion	dominion	NN
18637	3539	98	over	over	IN
18637	3539	99	the	the	DT
18637	3539	100	resources	resource	NNS
18637	3539	101	of	of	IN
18637	3539	102	the	the	DT
18637	3539	103	soil	soil	NN
18637	3539	104	under	under	IN
18637	3539	105	the	the	DT
18637	3539	106	water	water	NN
18637	3539	107	area	area	NN
18637	3539	108	.	.	.
18637	3540	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3540	2	1546	1546	CD
18637	3540	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3540	4	In	in	IN
18637	3540	5	Skiriotes	Skiriotes	NNP
18637	3540	6	_	_	NNP
18637	3540	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	3540	8	_	_	NNP
18637	3540	9	Florida,[1547	florida,[1547	CD
18637	3540	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3540	11	the	the	DT
18637	3540	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3540	13	,	,	,
18637	3540	14	on	on	IN
18637	3540	15	the	the	DT
18637	3540	16	other	other	JJ
18637	3540	17	hand	hand	NN
18637	3540	18	,	,	,
18637	3540	19	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	3540	20	that	that	IN
18637	3540	21	this	this	DT
18637	3540	22	clause	clause	NN
18637	3540	23	did	do	VBD
18637	3540	24	not	not	RB
18637	3540	25	disable	disable	VB
18637	3540	26	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	3540	27	from	from	IN
18637	3540	28	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	3540	29	the	the	DT
18637	3540	30	manner	manner	NN
18637	3540	31	in	in	IN
18637	3540	32	which	which	WDT
18637	3540	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3540	34	own	own	JJ
18637	3540	35	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	3540	36	may	may	MD
18637	3540	37	engage	engage	VB
18637	3540	38	in	in	IN
18637	3540	39	sponge	sponge	JJ
18637	3540	40	fishing	fishing	NN
18637	3540	41	outside	outside	IN
18637	3540	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3540	43	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	3540	44	waters	water	NNS
18637	3540	45	.	.	.
18637	3541	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	3541	2	for	for	IN
18637	3541	3	a	a	DT
18637	3541	4	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	3541	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3541	6	,	,	,
18637	3541	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3541	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3541	9	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	3541	10	declared	declare	VBD
18637	3541	11	:	:	:
18637	3541	12	"	"	``
18637	3541	13	When	when	WRB
18637	3541	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3541	15	action	action	NN
18637	3541	16	does	do	VBZ
18637	3541	17	not	not	RB
18637	3541	18	conflict	conflict	VB
18637	3541	19	with	with	IN
18637	3541	20	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3541	21	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3541	22	,	,	,
18637	3541	23	the	the	DT
18637	3541	24	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	3541	25	authority	authority	NN
18637	3541	26	of	of	IN
18637	3541	27	the	the	DT
18637	3541	28	State	State	NNP
18637	3541	29	over	over	IN
18637	3541	30	the	the	DT
18637	3541	31	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	3541	32	of	of	IN
18637	3541	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3541	34	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	3541	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	3541	36	the	the	DT
18637	3541	37	high	high	JJ
18637	3541	38	seas	sea	NNS
18637	3541	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	3541	40	analogous	analogous	JJ
18637	3541	41	to	to	IN
18637	3541	42	the	the	DT
18637	3541	43	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	3541	44	authority	authority	NN
18637	3541	45	of	of	IN
18637	3541	46	the	the	DT
18637	3541	47	United	United	NNP
18637	3541	48	States	States	NNP
18637	3541	49	over	over	IN
18637	3541	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3541	51	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	3541	52	in	in	IN
18637	3541	53	like	like	JJ
18637	3541	54	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	3541	55	.	.	.
18637	3542	1	"	"	``
18637	3542	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3542	3	1548	1548	CD
18637	3542	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3542	5	BILLS	BILLS	NNPS
18637	3542	6	OF	of	IN
18637	3542	7	CREDIT	credit	NN
18637	3542	8	Within	within	IN
18637	3542	9	the	the	DT
18637	3542	10	sense	sense	NN
18637	3542	11	of	of	IN
18637	3542	12	the	the	DT
18637	3542	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3542	14	,	,	,
18637	3542	15	bills	bill	NNS
18637	3542	16	of	of	IN
18637	3542	17	credit	credit	NN
18637	3542	18	signify	signify	VBP
18637	3542	19	a	a	DT
18637	3542	20	paper	paper	NN
18637	3542	21	medium	medium	NN
18637	3542	22	of	of	IN
18637	3542	23	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	3542	24	,	,	,
18637	3542	25	intended	intend	VBN
18637	3542	26	to	to	TO
18637	3542	27	circulate	circulate	VB
18637	3542	28	between	between	IN
18637	3542	29	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	3542	30	;	;	:
18637	3542	31	and	and	CC
18637	3542	32	between	between	IN
18637	3542	33	the	the	DT
18637	3542	34	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3542	35	and	and	CC
18637	3542	36	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	3542	37	,	,	,
18637	3542	38	for	for	IN
18637	3542	39	the	the	DT
18637	3542	40	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	3542	41	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	3542	42	of	of	IN
18637	3542	43	society	society	NN
18637	3542	44	.	.	.
18637	3543	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3543	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	3543	3	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
18637	3543	4	whether	whether	IN
18637	3543	5	the	the	DT
18637	3543	6	quality	quality	NN
18637	3543	7	of	of	IN
18637	3543	8	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3543	9	tender	tender	NN
18637	3543	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	3543	11	imparted	impart	VBN
18637	3543	12	to	to	IN
18637	3543	13	such	such	JJ
18637	3543	14	paper	paper	NN
18637	3543	15	.	.	.
18637	3544	1	Interest	interest	NN
18637	3544	2	bearing	bearing	NN
18637	3544	3	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	3544	4	,	,	,
18637	3544	5	in	in	IN
18637	3544	6	denominations	denomination	NNS
18637	3544	7	not	not	RB
18637	3544	8	exceeding	exceed	VBG
18637	3544	9	ten	ten	CD
18637	3544	10	dollars	dollar	NNS
18637	3544	11	,	,	,
18637	3544	12	which	which	WDT
18637	3544	13	were	be	VBD
18637	3544	14	issued	issue	VBN
18637	3544	15	by	by	IN
18637	3544	16	loan	loan	NN
18637	3544	17	offices	office	NNS
18637	3544	18	established	establish	VBN
18637	3544	19	by	by	IN
18637	3544	20	the	the	DT
18637	3544	21	State	State	NNP
18637	3544	22	of	of	IN
18637	3544	23	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	3544	24	,	,	,
18637	3544	25	and	and	CC
18637	3544	26	made	make	VBN
18637	3544	27	receivable	receivable	JJ
18637	3544	28	in	in	IN
18637	3544	29	payment	payment	NN
18637	3544	30	of	of	IN
18637	3544	31	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3544	32	or	or	CC
18637	3544	33	other	other	JJ
18637	3544	34	moneys	money	NNS
18637	3544	35	due	due	IN
18637	3544	36	to	to	IN
18637	3544	37	the	the	DT
18637	3544	38	State	State	NNP
18637	3544	39	,	,	,
18637	3544	40	and	and	CC
18637	3544	41	in	in	IN
18637	3544	42	payment	payment	NN
18637	3544	43	of	of	IN
18637	3544	44	the	the	DT
18637	3544	45	fees	fee	NNS
18637	3544	46	and	and	CC
18637	3544	47	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	3544	48	of	of	IN
18637	3544	49	State	State	NNP
18637	3544	50	officers	officer	NNS
18637	3544	51	,	,	,
18637	3544	52	were	be	VBD
18637	3544	53	held	hold	VBN
18637	3544	54	to	to	TO
18637	3544	55	be	be	VB
18637	3544	56	bills	bill	NNS
18637	3544	57	of	of	IN
18637	3544	58	credit	credit	NN
18637	3544	59	whose	whose	WP$
18637	3544	60	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	3544	61	was	be	VBD
18637	3544	62	banned	ban	VBN
18637	3544	63	by	by	IN
18637	3544	64	this	this	DT
18637	3544	65	section	section	NN
18637	3544	66	.	.	.
18637	3545	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3545	2	1549	1549	CD
18637	3545	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3545	4	The	the	DT
18637	3545	5	States	state	NNS
18637	3545	6	are	be	VBP
18637	3545	7	not	not	RB
18637	3545	8	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	3545	9	,	,	,
18637	3545	10	however	however	RB
18637	3545	11	,	,	,
18637	3545	12	to	to	TO
18637	3545	13	issue	issue	VB
18637	3545	14	coupons	coupon	NNS
18637	3545	15	receivable	receivable	JJ
18637	3545	16	for	for	IN
18637	3545	17	taxes,[1550	taxes,[1550	NNP
18637	3545	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3545	19	nor	nor	CC
18637	3545	20	to	to	TO
18637	3545	21	execute	execute	VB
18637	3545	22	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	3545	23	binding	bind	VBG
18637	3545	24	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3545	25	to	to	TO
18637	3545	26	pay	pay	VB
18637	3545	27	money	money	NN
18637	3545	28	at	at	IN
18637	3545	29	a	a	DT
18637	3545	30	future	future	JJ
18637	3545	31	day	day	NN
18637	3545	32	for	for	IN
18637	3545	33	services	service	NNS
18637	3545	34	rendered	render	VBN
18637	3545	35	or	or	CC
18637	3545	36	money	money	NN
18637	3545	37	borrowed	borrow	VBN
18637	3545	38	.	.	.
18637	3546	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3546	2	1551	1551	CD
18637	3546	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3546	4	Bills	bill	NNS
18637	3546	5	issued	issue	VBN
18637	3546	6	by	by	IN
18637	3546	7	State	state	NN
18637	3546	8	banks	bank	NNS
18637	3546	9	are	be	VBP
18637	3546	10	not	not	RB
18637	3546	11	bills	bill	NNS
18637	3546	12	of	of	IN
18637	3546	13	credit;[1552	credit;[1552	NNPS
18637	3546	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3546	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3546	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	3546	17	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
18637	3546	18	that	that	IN
18637	3546	19	the	the	DT
18637	3546	20	State	State	NNP
18637	3546	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	3546	22	the	the	DT
18637	3546	23	sole	sole	JJ
18637	3546	24	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	3546	25	of	of	IN
18637	3546	26	the	the	DT
18637	3546	27	bank,[1553	bank,[1553	NNP
18637	3546	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3546	29	that	that	IN
18637	3546	30	the	the	DT
18637	3546	31	officers	officer	NNS
18637	3546	32	of	of	IN
18637	3546	33	the	the	DT
18637	3546	34	bank	bank	NN
18637	3546	35	were	be	VBD
18637	3546	36	elected	elect	VBN
18637	3546	37	by	by	IN
18637	3546	38	the	the	DT
18637	3546	39	State	State	NNP
18637	3546	40	legislature,[1554	legislature,[1554	NNP
18637	3546	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3546	42	or	or	CC
18637	3546	43	that	that	IN
18637	3546	44	the	the	DT
18637	3546	45	capital	capital	NN
18637	3546	46	of	of	IN
18637	3546	47	the	the	DT
18637	3546	48	bank	bank	NN
18637	3546	49	was	be	VBD
18637	3546	50	raised	raise	VBN
18637	3546	51	by	by	IN
18637	3546	52	the	the	DT
18637	3546	53	sale	sale	NN
18637	3546	54	of	of	IN
18637	3546	55	State	State	NNP
18637	3546	56	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	3546	57	.	.	.
18637	3547	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3547	2	1555	1555	CD
18637	3547	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3547	4	LEGAL	LEGAL	NNP
18637	3547	5	TENDER	TENDER	NNP
18637	3547	6	Relying	rely	VBG
18637	3547	7	on	on	IN
18637	3547	8	this	this	DT
18637	3547	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	3547	10	,	,	,
18637	3547	11	which	which	WDT
18637	3547	12	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	3547	13	only	only	RB
18637	3547	14	to	to	IN
18637	3547	15	the	the	DT
18637	3547	16	States	States	NNPS
18637	3547	17	and	and	CC
18637	3547	18	not	not	RB
18637	3547	19	to	to	IN
18637	3547	20	the	the	DT
18637	3547	21	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3547	22	Government,[1556	government,[1556	CD
18637	3547	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3547	24	the	the	DT
18637	3547	25	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3547	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3547	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	3547	28	held	hold	VBN
18637	3547	29	that	that	IN
18637	3547	30	where	where	WRB
18637	3547	31	the	the	DT
18637	3547	32	marshal	marshal	NN
18637	3547	33	of	of	IN
18637	3547	34	a	a	DT
18637	3547	35	State	State	NNP
18637	3547	36	court	court	NN
18637	3547	37	received	receive	VBD
18637	3547	38	State	State	NNP
18637	3547	39	bank	bank	NN
18637	3547	40	notes	note	NNS
18637	3547	41	in	in	IN
18637	3547	42	payment	payment	NN
18637	3547	43	and	and	CC
18637	3547	44	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	3547	45	of	of	IN
18637	3547	46	an	an	DT
18637	3547	47	execution	execution	NN
18637	3547	48	,	,	,
18637	3547	49	the	the	DT
18637	3547	50	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	3547	51	was	be	VBD
18637	3547	52	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	3547	53	to	to	TO
18637	3547	54	demand	demand	VB
18637	3547	55	payment	payment	NN
18637	3547	56	in	in	IN
18637	3547	57	gold	gold	NN
18637	3547	58	or	or	CC
18637	3547	59	silver	silver	NN
18637	3547	60	.	.	.
18637	3548	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3548	2	1557	1557	CD
18637	3548	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3548	4	Since	since	IN
18637	3548	5	,	,	,
18637	3548	6	however	however	RB
18637	3548	7	,	,	,
18637	3548	8	there	there	EX
18637	3548	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	3548	10	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	3548	11	in	in	IN
18637	3548	12	the	the	DT
18637	3548	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3548	14	which	which	WDT
18637	3548	15	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	3548	16	a	a	DT
18637	3548	17	bank	bank	NN
18637	3548	18	depositor	depositor	NN
18637	3548	19	from	from	IN
18637	3548	20	consenting	consent	VBG
18637	3548	21	when	when	WRB
18637	3548	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3548	23	draws	draw	VBZ
18637	3548	24	a	a	DT
18637	3548	25	check	check	NN
18637	3548	26	,	,	,
18637	3548	27	that	that	DT
18637	3548	28	payment	payment	NN
18637	3548	29	may	may	MD
18637	3548	30	be	be	VB
18637	3548	31	made	make	VBN
18637	3548	32	by	by	IN
18637	3548	33	draft	draft	NN
18637	3548	34	,	,	,
18637	3548	35	a	a	DT
18637	3548	36	State	State	NNP
18637	3548	37	law	law	NN
18637	3548	38	which	which	WDT
18637	3548	39	provided	provide	VBD
18637	3548	40	that	that	IN
18637	3548	41	checks	check	NNS
18637	3548	42	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	3548	43	on	on	IN
18637	3548	44	local	local	JJ
18637	3548	45	banks	bank	NNS
18637	3548	46	should	should	MD
18637	3548	47	,	,	,
18637	3548	48	at	at	IN
18637	3548	49	the	the	DT
18637	3548	50	option	option	NN
18637	3548	51	of	of	IN
18637	3548	52	the	the	DT
18637	3548	53	bank	bank	NN
18637	3548	54	,	,	,
18637	3548	55	be	be	VB
18637	3548	56	payable	payable	JJ
18637	3548	57	in	in	IN
18637	3548	58	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	3548	59	drafts	draft	NNS
18637	3548	60	was	be	VBD
18637	3548	61	held	hold	VBN
18637	3548	62	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3548	63	.	.	.
18637	3549	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3549	2	1558	1558	CD
18637	3549	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3549	4	BILLS	BILLS	NNPS
18637	3549	5	OF	of	IN
18637	3549	6	ATTAINDER	ATTAINDER	NNP
18637	3549	7	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	3549	8	passed	pass	VBD
18637	3549	9	after	after	IN
18637	3549	10	the	the	DT
18637	3549	11	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3549	12	War	War	NNP
18637	3549	13	with	with	IN
18637	3549	14	the	the	DT
18637	3549	15	intent	intent	NN
18637	3549	16	and	and	CC
18637	3549	17	result	result	NN
18637	3549	18	of	of	IN
18637	3549	19	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	3549	20	persons	person	NNS
18637	3549	21	who	who	WP
18637	3549	22	had	have	VBD
18637	3549	23	aided	aid	VBN
18637	3549	24	the	the	DT
18637	3549	25	Confederacy	Confederacy	NNP
18637	3549	26	from	from	IN
18637	3549	27	following	follow	VBG
18637	3549	28	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3549	29	callings	calling	NNS
18637	3549	30	,	,	,
18637	3549	31	by	by	IN
18637	3549	32	the	the	DT
18637	3549	33	device	device	NN
18637	3549	34	of	of	IN
18637	3549	35	requiring	require	VBG
18637	3549	36	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3549	37	to	to	TO
18637	3549	38	take	take	VB
18637	3549	39	an	an	DT
18637	3549	40	oath	oath	NN
18637	3549	41	that	that	IN
18637	3549	42	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3549	43	had	have	VBD
18637	3549	44	never	never	RB
18637	3549	45	given	give	VBN
18637	3549	46	such	such	JJ
18637	3549	47	aid	aid	NN
18637	3549	48	,	,	,
18637	3549	49	were	be	VBD
18637	3549	50	held	hold	VBN
18637	3549	51	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	3549	52	as	as	IN
18637	3549	53	being	be	VBG
18637	3549	54	bills	bill	NNS
18637	3549	55	of	of	IN
18637	3549	56	attainder	attainder	NN
18637	3549	57	,	,	,
18637	3549	58	as	as	RB
18637	3549	59	well	well	RB
18637	3549	60	as	as	IN
18637	3549	61	_	_	NNP
18637	3549	62	ex	ex	FW
18637	3549	63	post	post	FW
18637	3549	64	facto	facto	FW
18637	3549	65	_	_	NNP
18637	3549	66	laws	law	NNS
18637	3549	67	.	.	.
18637	3550	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3550	2	1559	1559	CD
18637	3550	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3550	4	EX	EX	NNP
18637	3550	5	POST	POST	NNP
18637	3550	6	FACTO	FACTO	VBD
18637	3550	7	LAWS	LAWS	NNP
18637	3550	8	Scope	scope	NN
18637	3550	9	of	of	IN
18637	3550	10	Provision	Provision	NNP
18637	3550	11	This	this	DT
18637	3550	12	clause	clause	NN
18637	3550	13	,	,	,
18637	3550	14	like	like	IN
18637	3550	15	the	the	DT
18637	3550	16	cognate	cognate	NN
18637	3550	17	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	3550	18	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	3550	19	on	on	IN
18637	3550	20	the	the	DT
18637	3550	21	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3550	22	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3550	23	by	by	IN
18637	3550	24	section	section	NN
18637	3550	25	9	9	CD
18637	3550	26	,	,	,
18637	3550	27	relates	relate	VBZ
18637	3550	28	only	only	RB
18637	3550	29	to	to	IN
18637	3550	30	penal	penal	JJ
18637	3550	31	and	and	CC
18637	3550	32	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	3550	33	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3550	34	and	and	CC
18637	3550	35	not	not	RB
18637	3550	36	to	to	IN
18637	3550	37	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3550	38	laws	law	NNS
18637	3550	39	which	which	WDT
18637	3550	40	affect	affect	VBP
18637	3550	41	private	private	JJ
18637	3550	42	rights	right	NNS
18637	3550	43	adversely	adversely	RB
18637	3550	44	.	.	.
18637	3551	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3551	2	1560	1560	CD
18637	3551	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3551	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3551	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	3551	6	directed	direct	VBN
18637	3551	7	only	only	RB
18637	3551	8	against	against	IN
18637	3551	9	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3551	10	action	action	NN
18637	3551	11	and	and	CC
18637	3551	12	does	do	VBZ
18637	3551	13	not	not	RB
18637	3551	14	touch	touch	VB
18637	3551	15	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
18637	3551	16	or	or	CC
18637	3551	17	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	3551	18	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3551	19	by	by	IN
18637	3551	20	the	the	DT
18637	3551	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	3551	22	.	.	.
18637	3552	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3552	2	1561	1561	CD
18637	3552	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3552	4	Even	even	RB
18637	3552	5	though	though	IN
18637	3552	6	a	a	DT
18637	3552	7	law	law	NN
18637	3552	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	3552	9	_	_	NNP
18637	3552	10	ex	ex	FW
18637	3552	11	post	post	FW
18637	3552	12	facto	facto	FW
18637	3552	13	_	_	NNP
18637	3552	14	and	and	CC
18637	3552	15	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	3552	16	as	as	IN
18637	3552	17	to	to	IN
18637	3552	18	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	3552	19	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3552	20	prior	prior	RB
18637	3552	21	to	to	IN
18637	3552	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3552	23	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	3552	24	,	,	,
18637	3552	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3552	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	3552	27	nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
18637	3552	28	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3552	29	as	as	IN
18637	3552	30	to	to	IN
18637	3552	31	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	3552	32	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3552	33	.	.	.
18637	3553	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3553	2	1562	1562	CD
18637	3553	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3553	4	If	if	IN
18637	3553	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3553	6	mitigates	mitigate	VBZ
18637	3553	7	the	the	DT
18637	3553	8	rigor	rigor	NN
18637	3553	9	of	of	IN
18637	3553	10	the	the	DT
18637	3553	11	law	law	NN
18637	3553	12	in	in	IN
18637	3553	13	force	force	NN
18637	3553	14	at	at	IN
18637	3553	15	the	the	DT
18637	3553	16	time	time	NN
18637	3553	17	the	the	DT
18637	3553	18	crime	crime	NN
18637	3553	19	was	be	VBD
18637	3553	20	committed,[1563	committed,[1563	NNP
18637	3553	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3553	22	or	or	CC
18637	3553	23	if	if	IN
18637	3553	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3553	25	merely	merely	RB
18637	3553	26	penalizes	penalize	VBZ
18637	3553	27	the	the	DT
18637	3553	28	continuance	continuance	NN
18637	3553	29	of	of	IN
18637	3553	30	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	3553	31	which	which	WDT
18637	3553	32	was	be	VBD
18637	3553	33	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	3553	34	begun	begin	VBN
18637	3553	35	before	before	IN
18637	3553	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3553	37	passage	passage	NN
18637	3553	38	,	,	,
18637	3553	39	the	the	DT
18637	3553	40	statute	statute	NN
18637	3553	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	3553	42	not	not	RB
18637	3553	43	_	_	NNP
18637	3553	44	ex	ex	FW
18637	3553	45	post	post	FW
18637	3553	46	facto	facto	FW
18637	3553	47	_	_	NNP
18637	3553	48	.	.	.
18637	3554	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	3554	2	measures	measure	NNS
18637	3554	3	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	3554	4	the	the	DT
18637	3554	5	failure	failure	NN
18637	3554	6	of	of	IN
18637	3554	7	a	a	DT
18637	3554	8	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	3554	9	to	to	TO
18637	3554	10	cut	cut	VB
18637	3554	11	drains	drain	NNS
18637	3554	12	through	through	IN
18637	3554	13	existing	exist	VBG
18637	3554	14	embankments,[1564	embankments,[1564	NNP
18637	3554	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3554	16	or	or	CC
18637	3554	17	making	make	VBG
18637	3554	18	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	3554	19	the	the	DT
18637	3554	20	continued	continue	VBN
18637	3554	21	possession	possession	NN
18637	3554	22	of	of	IN
18637	3554	23	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	3554	24	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	3554	25	which	which	WDT
18637	3554	26	were	be	VBD
18637	3554	27	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	3554	28	acquired,[1565	acquired,[1565	NNP
18637	3554	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3554	30	have	have	VBP
18637	3554	31	been	be	VBN
18637	3554	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	3554	33	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3554	34	.	.	.
18637	3555	1	Denial	Denial	NNP
18637	3555	2	of	of	IN
18637	3555	3	Future	Future	NNP
18637	3555	4	Privileges	Privileges	NNPS
18637	3555	5	to	to	IN
18637	3555	6	Past	past	VB
18637	3555	7	Offenders	offender	NNS
18637	3555	8	The	the	DT
18637	3555	9	right	right	NN
18637	3555	10	to	to	TO
18637	3555	11	practice	practice	VB
18637	3555	12	a	a	DT
18637	3555	13	profession	profession	NN
18637	3555	14	may	may	MD
18637	3555	15	be	be	VB
18637	3555	16	denied	deny	VBN
18637	3555	17	to	to	IN
18637	3555	18	one	one	CD
18637	3555	19	who	who	WP
18637	3555	20	was	be	VBD
18637	3555	21	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	3555	22	of	of	IN
18637	3555	23	an	an	DT
18637	3555	24	offense	offense	NN
18637	3555	25	before	before	IN
18637	3555	26	the	the	DT
18637	3555	27	statute	statute	NN
18637	3555	28	was	be	VBD
18637	3555	29	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	3555	30	if	if	IN
18637	3555	31	the	the	DT
18637	3555	32	offense	offense	NN
18637	3555	33	may	may	MD
18637	3555	34	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	3555	35	be	be	VB
18637	3555	36	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	3555	37	as	as	IN
18637	3555	38	a	a	DT
18637	3555	39	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	3555	40	disqualification	disqualification	NN
18637	3555	41	for	for	IN
18637	3555	42	the	the	DT
18637	3555	43	profession	profession	NN
18637	3555	44	.	.	.
18637	3556	1	Without	without	IN
18637	3556	2	offending	offend	VBG
18637	3556	3	the	the	DT
18637	3556	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3556	5	,	,	,
18637	3556	6	a	a	DT
18637	3556	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	3556	8	making	make	VBG
18637	3556	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3556	10	a	a	DT
18637	3556	11	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
18637	3556	12	to	to	TO
18637	3556	13	practice	practice	VB
18637	3556	14	medicine	medicine	NN
18637	3556	15	after	after	IN
18637	3556	16	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	3556	17	of	of	IN
18637	3556	18	a	a	DT
18637	3556	19	felony	felony	NN
18637	3556	20	may	may	MD
18637	3556	21	be	be	VB
18637	3556	22	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	3556	23	against	against	IN
18637	3556	24	a	a	DT
18637	3556	25	person	person	NN
18637	3556	26	so	so	RB
18637	3556	27	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	3556	28	before	before	IN
18637	3556	29	the	the	DT
18637	3556	30	act	act	NN
18637	3556	31	was	be	VBD
18637	3556	32	passed	pass	VBN
18637	3556	33	.	.	.
18637	3557	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3557	2	1566	1566	CD
18637	3557	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3557	4	But	but	CC
18637	3557	5	the	the	DT
18637	3557	6	test	test	NN
18637	3557	7	oath	oath	NN
18637	3557	8	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	3557	9	after	after	IN
18637	3557	10	the	the	DT
18637	3557	11	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3557	12	War	War	NNP
18637	3557	13	,	,	,
18637	3557	14	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	3557	15	office	office	NN
18637	3557	16	holders	holder	NNS
18637	3557	17	,	,	,
18637	3557	18	teachers	teacher	NNS
18637	3557	19	,	,	,
18637	3557	20	or	or	CC
18637	3557	21	preachers	preacher	NNS
18637	3557	22	were	be	VBD
18637	3557	23	required	require	VBN
18637	3557	24	to	to	TO
18637	3557	25	swear	swear	VB
18637	3557	26	that	that	IN
18637	3557	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3557	28	had	have	VBD
18637	3557	29	not	not	RB
18637	3557	30	participated	participate	VBN
18637	3557	31	in	in	IN
18637	3557	32	the	the	DT
18637	3557	33	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
18637	3557	34	,	,	,
18637	3557	35	were	be	VBD
18637	3557	36	held	hold	VBN
18637	3557	37	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	3557	38	on	on	IN
18637	3557	39	the	the	DT
18637	3557	40	ground	ground	NN
18637	3557	41	that	that	IN
18637	3557	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3557	43	had	have	VBD
18637	3557	44	no	no	DT
18637	3557	45	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	3557	46	relation	relation	NN
18637	3557	47	to	to	IN
18637	3557	48	fitness	fitness	NN
18637	3557	49	to	to	TO
18637	3557	50	perform	perform	VB
18637	3557	51	official	official	JJ
18637	3557	52	or	or	CC
18637	3557	53	professional	professional	JJ
18637	3557	54	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3557	55	,	,	,
18637	3557	56	but	but	CC
18637	3557	57	rather	rather	RB
18637	3557	58	was	be	VBD
18637	3557	59	a	a	DT
18637	3557	60	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	3557	61	for	for	IN
18637	3557	62	past	past	JJ
18637	3557	63	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3557	64	.	.	.
18637	3558	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3558	2	1567	1567	CD
18637	3558	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3558	4	A	a	DT
18637	3558	5	similar	similar	JJ
18637	3558	6	oath	oath	NN
18637	3558	7	required	require	VBN
18637	3558	8	of	of	IN
18637	3558	9	suitors	suitor	NNS
18637	3558	10	in	in	IN
18637	3558	11	the	the	DT
18637	3558	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	3558	13	also	also	RB
18637	3558	14	was	be	VBD
18637	3558	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	3558	16	void	void	JJ
18637	3558	17	.	.	.
18637	3559	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3559	2	1568	1568	CD
18637	3559	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3559	4	Changes	change	NNS
18637	3559	5	in	in	IN
18637	3559	6	Punishment	Punishment	NNP
18637	3559	7	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	3559	8	which	which	WDT
18637	3559	9	changed	change	VBD
18637	3559	10	an	an	DT
18637	3559	11	indeterminate	indeterminate	JJ
18637	3559	12	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	3559	13	law	law	NN
18637	3559	14	to	to	TO
18637	3559	15	require	require	VB
18637	3559	16	a	a	DT
18637	3559	17	judge	judge	NN
18637	3559	18	to	to	TO
18637	3559	19	impose	impose	VB
18637	3559	20	the	the	DT
18637	3559	21	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	3559	22	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	3559	23	,	,	,
18637	3559	24	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	3559	25	formerly	formerly	RB
18637	3559	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3559	27	could	could	MD
18637	3559	28	impose	impose	VB
18637	3559	29	a	a	DT
18637	3559	30	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	3559	31	between	between	IN
18637	3559	32	the	the	DT
18637	3559	33	minimum	minimum	NN
18637	3559	34	and	and	CC
18637	3559	35	maximum;[1569	maximum;[1569	NNP
18637	3559	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3559	37	abolished	abolish	VBD
18637	3559	38	a	a	DT
18637	3559	39	rule	rule	NN
18637	3559	40	which	which	WDT
18637	3559	41	prevented	prevent	VBD
18637	3559	42	a	a	DT
18637	3559	43	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	3559	44	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	3559	45	of	of	IN
18637	3559	46	first	first	JJ
18637	3559	47	-	-	HYPH
18637	3559	48	degree	degree	NN
18637	3559	49	murder	murder	NN
18637	3559	50	after	after	IN
18637	3559	51	a	a	DT
18637	3559	52	jury	jury	NN
18637	3559	53	had	have	VBD
18637	3559	54	found	find	VBN
18637	3559	55	the	the	DT
18637	3559	56	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	3559	57	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	3559	58	in	in	IN
18637	3559	59	the	the	DT
18637	3559	60	second	second	JJ
18637	3559	61	-	-	HYPH
18637	3559	62	degree	degree	NN
18637	3559	63	by	by	IN
18637	3559	64	a	a	DT
18637	3559	65	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	3559	66	which	which	WDT
18637	3559	67	had	have	VBD
18637	3559	68	been	be	VBN
18637	3559	69	set	set	VBN
18637	3559	70	aside;[1570	aside;[1570	.
18637	3559	71	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3559	72	required	require	VBN
18637	3559	73	criminals	criminal	NNS
18637	3559	74	sentenced	sentence	VBN
18637	3559	75	to	to	IN
18637	3559	76	death	death	NN
18637	3559	77	to	to	TO
18637	3559	78	be	be	VB
18637	3559	79	kept	keep	VBN
18637	3559	80	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	3559	81	in	in	IN
18637	3559	82	solitary	solitary	JJ
18637	3559	83	confinement,[1571	confinement,[1571	NNP
18637	3559	84	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3559	85	or	or	CC
18637	3559	86	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	3559	87	a	a	DT
18637	3559	88	warden	warden	NN
18637	3559	89	to	to	TO
18637	3559	90	fix	fix	VB
18637	3559	91	,	,	,
18637	3559	92	within	within	IN
18637	3559	93	limits	limit	NNS
18637	3559	94	of	of	IN
18637	3559	95	one	one	CD
18637	3559	96	week	week	NN
18637	3559	97	,	,	,
18637	3559	98	and	and	CC
18637	3559	99	keep	keep	VB
18637	3559	100	secret	secret	JJ
18637	3559	101	the	the	DT
18637	3559	102	time	time	NN
18637	3559	103	of	of	IN
18637	3559	104	execution,[1572	execution,[1572	NNP
18637	3559	105	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3559	106	were	be	VBD
18637	3559	107	held	hold	VBN
18637	3559	108	to	to	TO
18637	3559	109	be	be	VB
18637	3559	110	_	_	NNP
18637	3559	111	ex	ex	FW
18637	3559	112	post	post	FW
18637	3559	113	facto	facto	FW
18637	3559	114	_	_	NNP
18637	3559	115	as	as	IN
18637	3559	116	applied	apply	VBN
18637	3559	117	to	to	IN
18637	3559	118	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	3559	119	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3559	120	prior	prior	RB
18637	3559	121	to	to	IN
18637	3559	122	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3559	123	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	3559	124	.	.	.
18637	3560	1	But	but	CC
18637	3560	2	laws	law	NNS
18637	3560	3	providing	provide	VBG
18637	3560	4	heavier	heavy	JJR
18637	3560	5	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	3560	6	for	for	IN
18637	3560	7	new	new	JJ
18637	3560	8	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	3560	9	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	3560	10	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3560	11	by	by	IN
18637	3560	12	habitual	habitual	JJ
18637	3560	13	criminals;[1573	criminals;[1573	.
18637	3560	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3560	15	changing	change	VBG
18637	3560	16	the	the	DT
18637	3560	17	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	3560	18	from	from	IN
18637	3560	19	hanging	hang	VBG
18637	3560	20	to	to	IN
18637	3560	21	electrocution	electrocution	NN
18637	3560	22	,	,	,
18637	3560	23	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	3560	24	the	the	DT
18637	3560	25	place	place	NN
18637	3560	26	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	3560	27	in	in	IN
18637	3560	28	the	the	DT
18637	3560	29	penitentiary	penitentiary	NN
18637	3560	30	,	,	,
18637	3560	31	and	and	CC
18637	3560	32	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	3560	33	the	the	DT
18637	3560	34	presence	presence	NN
18637	3560	35	of	of	IN
18637	3560	36	a	a	DT
18637	3560	37	greater	great	JJR
18637	3560	38	number	number	NN
18637	3560	39	of	of	IN
18637	3560	40	invited	invite	VBN
18637	3560	41	witnesses;[1574	witnesses;[1574	NNPS
18637	3560	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3560	43	or	or	CC
18637	3560	44	providing	provide	VBG
18637	3560	45	for	for	IN
18637	3560	46	close	close	JJ
18637	3560	47	confinement	confinement	NN
18637	3560	48	of	of	IN
18637	3560	49	six	six	CD
18637	3560	50	to	to	TO
18637	3560	51	nine	nine	CD
18637	3560	52	months	month	NNS
18637	3560	53	in	in	IN
18637	3560	54	the	the	DT
18637	3560	55	penitentiary	penitentiary	NN
18637	3560	56	,	,	,
18637	3560	57	in	in	IN
18637	3560	58	lieu	lieu	NN
18637	3560	59	of	of	IN
18637	3560	60	three	three	CD
18637	3560	61	to	to	TO
18637	3560	62	six	six	CD
18637	3560	63	months	month	NNS
18637	3560	64	in	in	IN
18637	3560	65	jail	jail	NN
18637	3560	66	prior	prior	RB
18637	3560	67	to	to	IN
18637	3560	68	execution	execution	NN
18637	3560	69	,	,	,
18637	3560	70	and	and	CC
18637	3560	71	substituting	substitute	VBG
18637	3560	72	the	the	DT
18637	3560	73	warden	warden	NN
18637	3560	74	for	for	IN
18637	3560	75	the	the	DT
18637	3560	76	sheriff	sheriff	NN
18637	3560	77	as	as	IN
18637	3560	78	hangman	hangman	NNP
18637	3560	79	,	,	,
18637	3560	80	have	have	VBP
18637	3560	81	been	be	VBN
18637	3560	82	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	3560	83	.	.	.
18637	3561	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3561	2	1575	1575	CD
18637	3561	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3561	4	Changes	change	NNS
18637	3561	5	in	in	IN
18637	3561	6	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	3561	7	An	an	DT
18637	3561	8	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	3561	9	person	person	NN
18637	3561	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	3561	11	not	not	RB
18637	3561	12	have	have	VB
18637	3561	13	a	a	DT
18637	3561	14	right	right	NN
18637	3561	15	to	to	TO
18637	3561	16	be	be	VB
18637	3561	17	tried	try	VBN
18637	3561	18	in	in	IN
18637	3561	19	all	all	DT
18637	3561	20	respects	respect	NNS
18637	3561	21	in	in	IN
18637	3561	22	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	3561	23	with	with	IN
18637	3561	24	the	the	DT
18637	3561	25	law	law	NN
18637	3561	26	in	in	IN
18637	3561	27	force	force	NN
18637	3561	28	when	when	WRB
18637	3561	29	the	the	DT
18637	3561	30	crime	crime	NN
18637	3561	31	charged	charge	VBN
18637	3561	32	was	be	VBD
18637	3561	33	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3561	34	.	.	.
18637	3562	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3562	2	1576	1576	CD
18637	3562	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3562	4	The	the	DT
18637	3562	5	mode	mode	NN
18637	3562	6	of	of	IN
18637	3562	7	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	3562	8	may	may	MD
18637	3562	9	be	be	VB
18637	3562	10	changed	change	VBN
18637	3562	11	so	so	RB
18637	3562	12	long	long	RB
18637	3562	13	as	as	IN
18637	3562	14	the	the	DT
18637	3562	15	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	3562	16	rights	right	NNS
18637	3562	17	of	of	IN
18637	3562	18	the	the	DT
18637	3562	19	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	3562	20	are	be	VBP
18637	3562	21	not	not	RB
18637	3562	22	curtailed	curtail	VBN
18637	3562	23	.	.	.
18637	3563	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3563	2	1577	1577	CD
18637	3563	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3563	4	Laws	law	NNS
18637	3563	5	shifting	shift	VBG
18637	3563	6	the	the	DT
18637	3563	7	place	place	NN
18637	3563	8	of	of	IN
18637	3563	9	trial	trial	NN
18637	3563	10	from	from	IN
18637	3563	11	one	one	CD
18637	3563	12	county	county	NN
18637	3563	13	to	to	IN
18637	3563	14	another,[1578	another,[1578	NNP
18637	3563	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3563	16	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	3563	17	the	the	DT
18637	3563	18	number	number	NN
18637	3563	19	of	of	IN
18637	3563	20	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	3563	21	judges	judge	NNS
18637	3563	22	and	and	CC
18637	3563	23	dividing	divide	VBG
18637	3563	24	the	the	DT
18637	3563	25	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	3563	26	court	court	NN
18637	3563	27	into	into	IN
18637	3563	28	divisions,[1579	divisions,[1579	NNP
18637	3563	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3563	30	granting	grant	VBG
18637	3563	31	a	a	DT
18637	3563	32	right	right	NN
18637	3563	33	of	of	IN
18637	3563	34	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	3563	35	to	to	IN
18637	3563	36	the	the	DT
18637	3563	37	State,[1580	state,[1580	NN
18637	3563	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3563	39	changing	change	VBG
18637	3563	40	the	the	DT
18637	3563	41	method	method	NN
18637	3563	42	of	of	IN
18637	3563	43	selecting	select	VBG
18637	3563	44	and	and	CC
18637	3563	45	summoning	summon	VBG
18637	3563	46	jurors,[1581	jurors,[1581	NNP
18637	3563	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3563	48	making	make	VBG
18637	3563	49	separate	separate	JJ
18637	3563	50	trials	trial	NNS
18637	3563	51	for	for	IN
18637	3563	52	persons	person	NNS
18637	3563	53	jointly	jointly	RB
18637	3563	54	indicted	indict	VBD
18637	3563	55	a	a	DT
18637	3563	56	matter	matter	NN
18637	3563	57	of	of	IN
18637	3563	58	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	3563	59	for	for	IN
18637	3563	60	the	the	DT
18637	3563	61	trial	trial	NN
18637	3563	62	court	court	NN
18637	3563	63	rather	rather	RB
18637	3563	64	than	than	IN
18637	3563	65	a	a	DT
18637	3563	66	matter	matter	NN
18637	3563	67	of	of	IN
18637	3563	68	right,[1582	right,[1582	NNP
18637	3563	69	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3563	70	and	and	CC
18637	3563	71	allowing	allow	VBG
18637	3563	72	a	a	DT
18637	3563	73	comparison	comparison	NN
18637	3563	74	of	of	IN
18637	3563	75	handwriting	handwrite	VBG
18637	3563	76	experts[1583	experts[1583	NNP
18637	3563	77	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3563	78	have	have	VBP
18637	3563	79	been	be	VBN
18637	3563	80	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	3563	81	over	over	IN
18637	3563	82	the	the	DT
18637	3563	83	objection	objection	NN
18637	3563	84	that	that	IN
18637	3563	85	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3563	86	were	be	VBD
18637	3563	87	_	_	NNP
18637	3563	88	ex	ex	FW
18637	3563	89	post	post	FW
18637	3563	90	facto	facto	FW
18637	3563	91	_	_	NNP
18637	3563	92	.	.	.
18637	3564	1	The	the	DT
18637	3564	2	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	3564	3	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	3564	4	was	be	VBD
18637	3564	5	reached	reach	VBN
18637	3564	6	with	with	IN
18637	3564	7	respect	respect	NN
18637	3564	8	to	to	IN
18637	3564	9	the	the	DT
18637	3564	10	application	application	NN
18637	3564	11	to	to	IN
18637	3564	12	felonies	felony	NNS
18637	3564	13	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3564	14	before	before	IN
18637	3564	15	a	a	DT
18637	3564	16	Territory	territory	NN
18637	3564	17	was	be	VBD
18637	3564	18	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	3564	19	to	to	IN
18637	3564	20	the	the	DT
18637	3564	21	Union	Union	NNP
18637	3564	22	,	,	,
18637	3564	23	of	of	IN
18637	3564	24	the	the	DT
18637	3564	25	provision	provision	NN
18637	3564	26	in	in	IN
18637	3564	27	the	the	DT
18637	3564	28	State	State	NNP
18637	3564	29	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	3564	30	which	which	WDT
18637	3564	31	permitted	permit	VBD
18637	3564	32	the	the	DT
18637	3564	33	trial	trial	NN
18637	3564	34	of	of	IN
18637	3564	35	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	3564	36	cases	case	NNS
18637	3564	37	by	by	IN
18637	3564	38	a	a	DT
18637	3564	39	jury	jury	NN
18637	3564	40	of	of	IN
18637	3564	41	eight	eight	CD
18637	3564	42	persons	person	NNS
18637	3564	43	,	,	,
18637	3564	44	instead	instead	RB
18637	3564	45	of	of	IN
18637	3564	46	the	the	DT
18637	3564	47	common	common	JJ
18637	3564	48	law	law	NN
18637	3564	49	jury	jury	NN
18637	3564	50	of	of	IN
18637	3564	51	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	3564	52	which	which	WDT
18637	3564	53	was	be	VBD
18637	3564	54	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	3564	55	by	by	IN
18637	3564	56	the	the	DT
18637	3564	57	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	3564	58	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3564	59	during	during	IN
18637	3564	60	the	the	DT
18637	3564	61	period	period	NN
18637	3564	62	of	of	IN
18637	3564	63	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	3564	64	government	government	NN
18637	3564	65	.	.	.
18637	3565	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3565	2	1584	1584	CD
18637	3565	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3565	4	OBLIGATION	OBLIGATION	NNP
18637	3565	5	OF	of	IN
18637	3565	6	CONTRACTS	CONTRACTS	NNP
18637	3565	7	Definition	Definition	NNP
18637	3565	8	of	of	IN
18637	3565	9	Terms	Terms	NNP
18637	3565	10	"	"	``
18637	3565	11	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3565	12	.	.	.
18637	3565	13	"	"	''
18637	3566	1	--The	--The	:
18637	3566	2	term	term	NN
18637	3566	3	comprises	comprise	VBZ
18637	3566	4	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3566	5	,	,	,
18637	3566	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3566	7	provisions,[1585	provisions,[1585	NNP
18637	3566	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3566	9	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	3566	10	ordinances,[1586	ordinances,[1586	NNP
18637	3566	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3566	12	and	and	CC
18637	3566	13	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	3566	14	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	3566	15	having	have	VBG
18637	3566	16	the	the	DT
18637	3566	17	force	force	NN
18637	3566	18	and	and	CC
18637	3566	19	operation	operation	NN
18637	3566	20	of	of	IN
18637	3566	21	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3566	22	.	.	.
18637	3567	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3567	2	1587	1587	CD
18637	3567	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3567	4	How	how	WRB
18637	3567	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	3567	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3567	7	as	as	IN
18637	3567	8	to	to	IN
18637	3567	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3567	10	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3567	11	?	?	.
18637	3568	1	Not	not	RB
18637	3568	2	only	only	RB
18637	3568	3	does	do	VBZ
18637	3568	4	the	the	DT
18637	3568	5	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	3568	6	principle	principle	NN
18637	3568	7	of	of	IN
18637	3568	8	the	the	DT
18637	3568	9	separation	separation	NN
18637	3568	10	of	of	IN
18637	3568	11	powers	power	NNS
18637	3568	12	forbid	forbid	VBP
18637	3568	13	the	the	DT
18637	3568	14	idea	idea	NN
18637	3568	15	that	that	IN
18637	3568	16	the	the	DT
18637	3568	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	3568	18	"	"	``
18637	3568	19	make	make	VBP
18637	3568	20	"	"	''
18637	3568	21	law	law	NN
18637	3568	22	,	,	,
18637	3568	23	but	but	CC
18637	3568	24	the	the	DT
18637	3568	25	word	word	NN
18637	3568	26	"	"	``
18637	3568	27	pass	pass	NN
18637	3568	28	"	"	''
18637	3568	29	in	in	IN
18637	3568	30	the	the	DT
18637	3568	31	above	above	JJ
18637	3568	32	clause	clause	NN
18637	3568	33	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	3568	34	to	to	TO
18637	3568	35	confine	confine	VB
18637	3568	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3568	37	to	to	IN
18637	3568	38	the	the	DT
18637	3568	39	formal	formal	JJ
18637	3568	40	and	and	CC
18637	3568	41	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	3568	42	methods	method	NNS
18637	3568	43	of	of	IN
18637	3568	44	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3568	45	of	of	IN
18637	3568	46	the	the	DT
18637	3568	47	law	law	NN
18637	3568	48	-	-	HYPH
18637	3568	49	making	make	VBG
18637	3568	50	function	function	NN
18637	3568	51	.	.	.
18637	3569	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	3569	2	,	,	,
18637	3569	3	the	the	DT
18637	3569	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3569	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	3569	6	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	3569	7	said	say	VBN
18637	3569	8	that	that	IN
18637	3569	9	the	the	DT
18637	3569	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	3569	11	does	do	VBZ
18637	3569	12	not	not	RB
18637	3569	13	cover	cover	VB
18637	3569	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3569	15	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3569	16	,	,	,
18637	3569	17	however	however	RB
18637	3569	18	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
18637	3569	19	,	,	,
18637	3569	20	or	or	CC
18637	3569	21	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	3569	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3569	23	effect	effect	NN
18637	3569	24	on	on	IN
18637	3569	25	existing	exist	VBG
18637	3569	26	contract	contract	NN
18637	3569	27	rights	right	NNS
18637	3569	28	.	.	.
18637	3570	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3570	2	1588	1588	CD
18637	3570	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3570	4	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	3570	5	,	,	,
18637	3570	6	there	there	EX
18637	3570	7	are	be	VBP
18637	3570	8	important	important	JJ
18637	3570	9	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	3570	10	to	to	IN
18637	3570	11	this	this	DT
18637	3570	12	rule	rule	NN
18637	3570	13	which	which	WDT
18637	3570	14	are	be	VBP
18637	3570	15	hereinafter	hereinafter	NN
18637	3570	16	set	set	VBN
18637	3570	17	forth	forth	RB
18637	3570	18	.	.	.
18637	3571	1	Status	Status	NNP
18637	3571	2	of	of	IN
18637	3571	3	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	3571	4	Decisions.--Also	Decisions.--Also	,
18637	3571	5	,	,	,
18637	3571	6	while	while	IN
18637	3571	7	the	the	DT
18637	3571	8	highest	high	JJS
18637	3571	9	State	State	NNP
18637	3571	10	court	court	NN
18637	3571	11	usually	usually	RB
18637	3571	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	3571	13	final	final	JJ
18637	3571	14	authority	authority	NN
18637	3571	15	in	in	IN
18637	3571	16	determining	determine	VBG
18637	3571	17	the	the	DT
18637	3571	18	construction	construction	NN
18637	3571	19	as	as	RB
18637	3571	20	well	well	RB
18637	3571	21	as	as	IN
18637	3571	22	the	the	DT
18637	3571	23	validity	validity	NN
18637	3571	24	of	of	IN
18637	3571	25	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3571	26	entered	enter	VBN
18637	3571	27	into	into	IN
18637	3571	28	under	under	IN
18637	3571	29	the	the	DT
18637	3571	30	laws	law	NNS
18637	3571	31	of	of	IN
18637	3571	32	the	the	DT
18637	3571	33	State	State	NNP
18637	3571	34	,	,	,
18637	3571	35	and	and	CC
18637	3571	36	the	the	DT
18637	3571	37	national	national	JJ
18637	3571	38	courts	court	NNS
18637	3571	39	will	will	MD
18637	3571	40	be	be	VB
18637	3571	41	bound	bind	VBN
18637	3571	42	by	by	IN
18637	3571	43	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3571	44	decision	decision	NN
18637	3571	45	of	of	IN
18637	3571	46	such	such	JJ
18637	3571	47	matters	matter	NNS
18637	3571	48	,	,	,
18637	3571	49	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	3571	50	,	,	,
18637	3571	51	for	for	IN
18637	3571	52	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	3571	53	which	which	WDT
18637	3571	54	are	be	VBP
18637	3571	55	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	3571	56	obvious	obvious	JJ
18637	3571	57	,	,	,
18637	3571	58	this	this	DT
18637	3571	59	rule	rule	NN
18637	3571	60	does	do	VBZ
18637	3571	61	not	not	RB
18637	3571	62	hold	hold	VB
18637	3571	63	when	when	WRB
18637	3571	64	the	the	DT
18637	3571	65	contract	contract	NN
18637	3571	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	3571	67	one	one	CD
18637	3571	68	whose	whose	WP$
18637	3571	69	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3571	70	is	be	VBZ
18637	3571	71	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	3571	72	to	to	TO
18637	3571	73	have	have	VB
18637	3571	74	been	be	VBN
18637	3571	75	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	3571	76	by	by	IN
18637	3571	77	State	State	NNP
18637	3571	78	law	law	NN
18637	3571	79	.	.	.
18637	3572	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3572	2	1589	1589	CD
18637	3572	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3572	4	Otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	3572	5	,	,	,
18637	3572	6	the	the	DT
18637	3572	7	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	3572	8	State	State	NNP
18637	3572	9	authority	authority	NN
18637	3572	10	could	could	MD
18637	3572	11	be	be	VB
18637	3572	12	vindicated	vindicate	VBN
18637	3572	13	through	through	IN
18637	3572	14	the	the	DT
18637	3572	15	simple	simple	JJ
18637	3572	16	device	device	NN
18637	3572	17	of	of	IN
18637	3572	18	a	a	DT
18637	3572	19	modification	modification	NN
18637	3572	20	or	or	CC
18637	3572	21	outright	outright	JJ
18637	3572	22	nullification	nullification	NN
18637	3572	23	by	by	IN
18637	3572	24	the	the	DT
18637	3572	25	State	State	NNP
18637	3572	26	court	court	NN
18637	3572	27	of	of	IN
18637	3572	28	the	the	DT
18637	3572	29	contract	contract	NN
18637	3572	30	rights	right	NNS
18637	3572	31	in	in	IN
18637	3572	32	issue	issue	NN
18637	3572	33	.	.	.
18637	3573	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	3573	2	,	,	,
18637	3573	3	the	the	DT
18637	3573	4	highest	high	JJS
18637	3573	5	State	State	NNP
18637	3573	6	court	court	NN
18637	3573	7	usually	usually	RB
18637	3573	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	3573	9	final	final	JJ
18637	3573	10	authority	authority	NN
18637	3573	11	in	in	IN
18637	3573	12	construing	construe	VBG
18637	3573	13	State	state	NN
18637	3573	14	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3573	15	and	and	CC
18637	3573	16	determining	determine	VBG
18637	3573	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3573	18	validity	validity	NN
18637	3573	19	in	in	IN
18637	3573	20	relation	relation	NN
18637	3573	21	to	to	IN
18637	3573	22	the	the	DT
18637	3573	23	State	State	NNP
18637	3573	24	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	3573	25	.	.	.
18637	3574	1	But	but	CC
18637	3574	2	this	this	DT
18637	3574	3	rule	rule	NN
18637	3574	4	too	too	RB
18637	3574	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	3574	6	had	have	VBN
18637	3574	7	to	to	TO
18637	3574	8	bend	bend	VB
18637	3574	9	to	to	IN
18637	3574	10	some	some	DT
18637	3574	11	extent	extent	NN
18637	3574	12	to	to	IN
18637	3574	13	the	the	DT
18637	3574	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3574	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3574	16	's	's	POS
18637	3574	17	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	3574	18	of	of	IN
18637	3574	19	the	the	DT
18637	3574	20	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3574	21	of	of	IN
18637	3574	22	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3574	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	3574	24	.	.	.
18637	3575	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3575	2	1590	1590	CD
18637	3575	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3575	4	Suppose	suppose	VB
18637	3575	5	the	the	DT
18637	3575	6	following	follow	VBG
18637	3575	7	situation	situation	NN
18637	3575	8	:	:	:
18637	3575	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3575	10	1	1	LS
18637	3575	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3575	12	a	a	DT
18637	3575	13	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	3575	14	,	,	,
18637	3575	15	acting	act	VBG
18637	3575	16	under	under	IN
18637	3575	17	authority	authority	NN
18637	3575	18	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	3575	19	by	by	IN
18637	3575	20	a	a	DT
18637	3575	21	State	State	NNP
18637	3575	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	3575	23	,	,	,
18637	3575	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	3575	25	issued	issue	VBN
18637	3575	26	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	3575	27	in	in	IN
18637	3575	28	aid	aid	NN
18637	3575	29	of	of	IN
18637	3575	30	a	a	DT
18637	3575	31	railway	railway	NN
18637	3575	32	company	company	NN
18637	3575	33	;	;	:
18637	3575	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3575	35	2	2	LS
18637	3575	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3575	37	the	the	DT
18637	3575	38	validity	validity	NN
18637	3575	39	of	of	IN
18637	3575	40	this	this	DT
18637	3575	41	statute	statute	NN
18637	3575	42	has	have	VBZ
18637	3575	43	been	be	VBN
18637	3575	44	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	3575	45	by	by	IN
18637	3575	46	the	the	DT
18637	3575	47	highest	high	JJS
18637	3575	48	State	State	NNP
18637	3575	49	court	court	NN
18637	3575	50	;	;	:
18637	3575	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3575	52	3	3	LS
18637	3575	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3575	54	later	later	RB
18637	3575	55	the	the	DT
18637	3575	56	State	State	NNP
18637	3575	57	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3575	58	passes	pass	VBZ
18637	3575	59	an	an	DT
18637	3575	60	act	act	NN
18637	3575	61	to	to	TO
18637	3575	62	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	3575	63	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3575	64	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3575	65	to	to	TO
18637	3575	66	meet	meet	VB
18637	3575	67	the	the	DT
18637	3575	68	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	3575	69	;	;	:
18637	3575	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3575	71	4	4	LS
18637	3575	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3575	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3575	74	is	be	VBZ
18637	3575	75	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	3575	76	in	in	IN
18637	3575	77	doing	do	VBG
18637	3575	78	so	so	RB
18637	3575	79	by	by	IN
18637	3575	80	a	a	DT
18637	3575	81	decision	decision	NN
18637	3575	82	of	of	IN
18637	3575	83	the	the	DT
18637	3575	84	highest	high	JJS
18637	3575	85	State	State	NNP
18637	3575	86	court	court	NN
18637	3575	87	holding	hold	VBG
18637	3575	88	that	that	IN
18637	3575	89	the	the	DT
18637	3575	90	statute	statute	NN
18637	3575	91	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	3575	92	the	the	DT
18637	3575	93	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	3575	94	was	be	VBD
18637	3575	95	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	3575	96	_	_	NNP
18637	3575	97	ab	ab	NNP
18637	3575	98	initio	initio	NNP
18637	3575	99	_	_	NNP
18637	3575	100	.	.	.
18637	3576	1	In	in	IN
18637	3576	2	such	such	PDT
18637	3576	3	a	a	DT
18637	3576	4	case	case	NN
18637	3576	5	the	the	DT
18637	3576	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3576	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3576	8	would	would	MD
18637	3576	9	take	take	VB
18637	3576	10	an	an	DT
18637	3576	11	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	3576	12	from	from	IN
18637	3576	13	the	the	DT
18637	3576	14	State	State	NNP
18637	3576	15	court	court	NN
18637	3576	16	and	and	CC
18637	3576	17	would	would	MD
18637	3576	18	reverse	reverse	VB
18637	3576	19	the	the	DT
18637	3576	20	latter	latter	NN
18637	3576	21	's	's	POS
18637	3576	22	decision	decision	NN
18637	3576	23	of	of	IN
18637	3576	24	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	RB
18637	3576	25	because	because	IN
18637	3576	26	of	of	IN
18637	3576	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3576	28	effect	effect	NN
18637	3576	29	in	in	IN
18637	3576	30	rendering	render	VBG
18637	3576	31	operative	operative	JJ
18637	3576	32	the	the	DT
18637	3576	33	act	act	NN
18637	3576	34	to	to	TO
18637	3576	35	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	3576	36	the	the	DT
18637	3576	37	tax	tax	NN
18637	3576	38	.	.	.
18637	3577	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3577	2	1591	1591	CD
18637	3577	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3577	4	Suppose	suppose	VB
18637	3577	5	further	further	RB
18637	3577	6	,	,	,
18637	3577	7	however	however	RB
18637	3577	8	,	,	,
18637	3577	9	that	that	IN
18637	3577	10	the	the	DT
18637	3577	11	State	State	NNP
18637	3577	12	court	court	NN
18637	3577	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	3577	14	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	3577	15	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3577	16	on	on	IN
18637	3577	17	the	the	DT
18637	3577	18	question	question	NN
18637	3577	19	of	of	IN
18637	3577	20	the	the	DT
18637	3577	21	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	3577	22	of	of	IN
18637	3577	23	the	the	DT
18637	3577	24	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	3577	25	in	in	IN
18637	3577	26	a	a	DT
18637	3577	27	suit	suit	NN
18637	3577	28	by	by	IN
18637	3577	29	a	a	DT
18637	3577	30	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	3577	31	for	for	IN
18637	3577	32	payment	payment	NN
18637	3577	33	without	without	IN
18637	3577	34	there	there	EX
18637	3577	35	having	have	VBG
18637	3577	36	been	be	VBN
18637	3577	37	an	an	DT
18637	3577	38	act	act	NN
18637	3577	39	of	of	IN
18637	3577	40	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	3577	41	.	.	.
18637	3578	1	In	in	IN
18637	3578	2	this	this	DT
18637	3578	3	situation	situation	NN
18637	3578	4	,	,	,
18637	3578	5	as	as	IN
18637	3578	6	the	the	DT
18637	3578	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	3578	8	stand	stand	VBP
18637	3578	9	today	today	NN
18637	3578	10	,	,	,
18637	3578	11	the	the	DT
18637	3578	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3578	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3578	14	will	will	MD
18637	3578	15	still	still	RB
18637	3578	16	afford	afford	VB
18637	3578	17	relief	relief	NN
18637	3578	18	if	if	IN
18637	3578	19	the	the	DT
18637	3578	20	case	case	NN
18637	3578	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	3578	22	one	one	CD
18637	3578	23	between	between	IN
18637	3578	24	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	3578	25	of	of	IN
18637	3578	26	different	different	JJ
18637	3578	27	States	state	NNS
18637	3578	28	,	,	,
18637	3578	29	which	which	WDT
18637	3578	30	reaches	reach	VBZ
18637	3578	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3578	32	via	via	IN
18637	3578	33	a	a	DT
18637	3578	34	lower	low	JJR
18637	3578	35	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3578	36	court	court	NN
18637	3578	37	.	.	.
18637	3579	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3579	2	1592	1592	CD
18637	3579	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3579	4	This	this	DT
18637	3579	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	3579	6	because	because	IN
18637	3579	7	in	in	IN
18637	3579	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	3579	9	of	of	IN
18637	3579	10	this	this	DT
18637	3579	11	nature	nature	NN
18637	3579	12	the	the	DT
18637	3579	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3579	14	formerly	formerly	RB
18637	3579	15	felt	feel	VBD
18637	3579	16	free	free	JJ
18637	3579	17	to	to	TO
18637	3579	18	determine	determine	VB
18637	3579	19	questions	question	NNS
18637	3579	20	of	of	IN
18637	3579	21	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	3579	22	justice	justice	NN
18637	3579	23	for	for	IN
18637	3579	24	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3579	25	.	.	.
18637	3580	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	3580	2	,	,	,
18637	3580	3	in	in	IN
18637	3580	4	such	such	PDT
18637	3580	5	a	a	DT
18637	3580	6	case	case	NN
18637	3580	7	,	,	,
18637	3580	8	the	the	DT
18637	3580	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3580	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	3580	11	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	3580	12	in	in	IN
18637	3580	13	the	the	DT
18637	3580	14	past	past	NN
18637	3580	15	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	3580	16	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3580	17	as	as	RB
18637	3580	18	free	free	JJ
18637	3580	19	to	to	TO
18637	3580	20	pass	pass	VB
18637	3580	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	3580	22	the	the	DT
18637	3580	23	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	3580	24	of	of	IN
18637	3580	25	the	the	DT
18637	3580	26	State	State	NNP
18637	3580	27	law	law	NN
18637	3580	28	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	3580	29	the	the	DT
18637	3580	30	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	3580	31	even	even	RB
18637	3580	32	though	though	IN
18637	3580	33	there	there	EX
18637	3580	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	3580	35	been	be	VBN
18637	3580	36	no	no	DT
18637	3580	37	prior	prior	JJ
18637	3580	38	decision	decision	NN
18637	3580	39	by	by	IN
18637	3580	40	the	the	DT
18637	3580	41	highest	high	JJS
18637	3580	42	State	State	NNP
18637	3580	43	court	court	NN
18637	3580	44	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	3580	45	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3580	46	,	,	,
18637	3580	47	the	the	DT
18637	3580	48	idea	idea	NN
18637	3580	49	being	be	VBG
18637	3580	50	that	that	IN
18637	3580	51	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3580	52	entered	enter	VBD
18637	3580	53	into	into	IN
18637	3580	54	simply	simply	RB
18637	3580	55	on	on	IN
18637	3580	56	the	the	DT
18637	3580	57	faith	faith	NN
18637	3580	58	of	of	IN
18637	3580	59	the	the	DT
18637	3580	60	_	_	NNP
18637	3580	61	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	3580	62	_	_	NNP
18637	3580	63	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	3580	64	of	of	IN
18637	3580	65	a	a	DT
18637	3580	66	State	State	NNP
18637	3580	67	statute	statute	NN
18637	3580	68	are	be	VBP
18637	3580	69	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	3580	70	to	to	IN
18637	3580	71	this	this	DT
18637	3580	72	protection	protection	NN
18637	3580	73	.	.	.
18637	3581	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3581	2	1593	1593	CD
18637	3581	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3581	4	In	in	IN
18637	3581	5	other	other	JJ
18637	3581	6	words	word	NNS
18637	3581	7	,	,	,
18637	3581	8	in	in	IN
18637	3581	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	3581	10	of	of	IN
18637	3581	11	which	which	WDT
18637	3581	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3581	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	3581	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3581	15	because	because	IN
18637	3581	16	of	of	IN
18637	3581	17	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	3581	18	of	of	IN
18637	3581	19	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	3581	20	,	,	,
18637	3581	21	the	the	DT
18637	3581	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3581	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	3581	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	3581	25	that	that	IN
18637	3581	26	the	the	DT
18637	3581	27	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3581	28	of	of	IN
18637	3581	29	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3581	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	3581	31	capable	capable	JJ
18637	3581	32	of	of	IN
18637	3581	33	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	3581	34	by	by	IN
18637	3581	35	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	3581	36	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3581	37	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3581	38	no	no	DT
18637	3581	39	less	less	JJR
18637	3581	40	than	than	IN
18637	3581	41	by	by	IN
18637	3581	42	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	3581	43	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3581	44	and	and	CC
18637	3581	45	that	that	IN
18637	3581	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3581	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	3581	48	able	able	JJ
18637	3581	49	to	to	TO
18637	3581	50	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	3581	51	such	such	JJ
18637	3581	52	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	3581	53	.	.	.
18637	3582	1	In	in	IN
18637	3582	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	3582	3	,	,	,
18637	3582	4	on	on	IN
18637	3582	5	the	the	DT
18637	3582	6	other	other	JJ
18637	3582	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	3582	8	,	,	,
18637	3582	9	of	of	IN
18637	3582	10	which	which	WDT
18637	3582	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3582	12	obtains	obtain	VBZ
18637	3582	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3582	14	only	only	RB
18637	3582	15	on	on	IN
18637	3582	16	the	the	DT
18637	3582	17	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3582	18	ground	ground	NN
18637	3582	19	,	,	,
18637	3582	20	and	and	CC
18637	3582	21	by	by	IN
18637	3582	22	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	3582	23	from	from	IN
18637	3582	24	a	a	DT
18637	3582	25	State	State	NNP
18637	3582	26	court	court	NN
18637	3582	27	,	,	,
18637	3582	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3582	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	3582	30	always	always	RB
18637	3582	31	adhered	adhere	VBN
18637	3582	32	in	in	IN
18637	3582	33	terms	term	NNS
18637	3582	34	to	to	IN
18637	3582	35	the	the	DT
18637	3582	36	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3582	37	that	that	IN
18637	3582	38	the	the	DT
18637	3582	39	word	word	NN
18637	3582	40	"	"	``
18637	3582	41	laws	law	NNS
18637	3582	42	"	"	''
18637	3582	43	as	as	IN
18637	3582	44	used	use	VBN
18637	3582	45	in	in	IN
18637	3582	46	article	article	NN
18637	3582	47	I	i	NN
18637	3582	48	,	,	,
18637	3582	49	section	section	NN
18637	3582	50	10	10	CD
18637	3582	51	,	,	,
18637	3582	52	does	do	VBZ
18637	3582	53	not	not	RB
18637	3582	54	comprehend	comprehend	VB
18637	3582	55	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3582	56	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3582	57	.	.	.
18637	3583	1	Yet	yet	RB
18637	3583	2	even	even	RB
18637	3583	3	in	in	IN
18637	3583	4	these	these	DT
18637	3583	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	3583	6	,	,	,
18637	3583	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3583	8	will	will	MD
18637	3583	9	intervene	intervene	VB
18637	3583	10	to	to	TO
18637	3583	11	protect	protect	VB
18637	3583	12	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3583	13	entered	enter	VBN
18637	3583	14	into	into	IN
18637	3583	15	on	on	IN
18637	3583	16	the	the	DT
18637	3583	17	faith	faith	NN
18637	3583	18	of	of	IN
18637	3583	19	existing	exist	VBG
18637	3583	20	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3583	21	from	from	IN
18637	3583	22	an	an	DT
18637	3583	23	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	3583	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3583	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	3583	26	the	the	DT
18637	3583	27	direct	direct	JJ
18637	3583	28	result	result	NN
18637	3583	29	of	of	IN
18637	3583	30	a	a	DT
18637	3583	31	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	3583	32	of	of	IN
18637	3583	33	such	such	JJ
18637	3583	34	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3583	35	,	,	,
18637	3583	36	but	but	CC
18637	3583	37	there	there	EX
18637	3583	38	must	must	MD
18637	3583	39	be	be	VB
18637	3583	40	in	in	IN
18637	3583	41	the	the	DT
18637	3583	42	offing	offing	NN
18637	3583	43	,	,	,
18637	3583	44	as	as	IN
18637	3583	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3583	46	were	be	VBD
18637	3583	47	,	,	,
18637	3583	48	a	a	DT
18637	3583	49	statute	statute	NN
18637	3583	50	of	of	IN
18637	3583	51	some	some	DT
18637	3583	52	kind	kind	NN
18637	3583	53	--	--	:
18637	3583	54	one	one	CD
18637	3583	55	possibly	possibly	RB
18637	3583	56	many	many	JJ
18637	3583	57	years	year	NNS
18637	3583	58	older	old	JJR
18637	3583	59	than	than	IN
18637	3583	60	the	the	DT
18637	3583	61	contract	contract	NN
18637	3583	62	rights	right	NNS
18637	3583	63	involved	involve	VBN
18637	3583	64	--	--	:
18637	3583	65	on	on	IN
18637	3583	66	which	which	WDT
18637	3583	67	to	to	TO
18637	3583	68	pin	pin	VB
18637	3583	69	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3583	70	decision	decision	NN
18637	3583	71	.	.	.
18637	3584	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3584	2	1594	1594	CD
18637	3584	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3584	4	In	in	IN
18637	3584	5	1922	1922	CD
18637	3584	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3584	7	,	,	,
18637	3584	8	through	through	IN
18637	3584	9	an	an	DT
18637	3584	10	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	3584	11	to	to	IN
18637	3584	12	the	the	DT
18637	3584	13	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	3584	14	Code	Code	NNP
18637	3584	15	,	,	,
18637	3584	16	endeavored	endeavor	VBD
18637	3584	17	to	to	TO
18637	3584	18	extend	extend	VB
18637	3584	19	the	the	DT
18637	3584	20	reviewing	review	VBG
18637	3584	21	power	power	NN
18637	3584	22	of	of	IN
18637	3584	23	the	the	DT
18637	3584	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3584	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3584	26	to	to	IN
18637	3584	27	suits	suit	NNS
18637	3584	28	involving	involve	VBG
18637	3584	29	"	"	``
18637	3584	30	'	'	''
18637	3584	31	*	*	NFP
18637	3584	32	*	*	NFP
18637	3584	33	*	*	NFP
18637	3584	34	the	the	DT
18637	3584	35	validity	validity	NN
18637	3584	36	of	of	IN
18637	3584	37	a	a	DT
18637	3584	38	contract	contract	NN
18637	3584	39	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	3584	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3584	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	3584	42	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	3584	43	that	that	IN
18637	3584	44	a	a	DT
18637	3584	45	change	change	NN
18637	3584	46	in	in	IN
18637	3584	47	the	the	DT
18637	3584	48	rule	rule	NN
18637	3584	49	of	of	IN
18637	3584	50	law	law	NN
18637	3584	51	or	or	CC
18637	3584	52	construction	construction	NN
18637	3584	53	of	of	IN
18637	3584	54	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3584	55	by	by	IN
18637	3584	56	the	the	DT
18637	3584	57	highest	high	JJS
18637	3584	58	court	court	NN
18637	3584	59	of	of	IN
18637	3584	60	a	a	DT
18637	3584	61	State	State	NNP
18637	3584	62	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	3584	63	to	to	IN
18637	3584	64	such	such	JJ
18637	3584	65	contract	contract	NN
18637	3584	66	would	would	MD
18637	3584	67	be	be	VB
18637	3584	68	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	3584	69	to	to	IN
18637	3584	70	the	the	DT
18637	3584	71	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3584	72	of	of	IN
18637	3584	73	the	the	DT
18637	3584	74	United	United	NNP
18637	3584	75	States	States	NNP
18637	3584	76	*	*	NFP
18637	3584	77	*	*	NFP
18637	3584	78	*	*	NFP
18637	3584	79	'	'	''
18637	3584	80	"	"	``
18637	3584	81	This	this	DT
18637	3584	82	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	3584	83	to	to	TO
18637	3584	84	be	be	VB
18637	3584	85	an	an	DT
18637	3584	86	invitation	invitation	NN
18637	3584	87	to	to	IN
18637	3584	88	the	the	DT
18637	3584	89	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3584	90	to	to	TO
18637	3584	91	say	say	VB
18637	3584	92	frankly	frankly	RB
18637	3584	93	that	that	IN
18637	3584	94	the	the	DT
18637	3584	95	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3584	96	of	of	IN
18637	3584	97	a	a	DT
18637	3584	98	contract	contract	NN
18637	3584	99	can	can	MD
18637	3584	100	be	be	VB
18637	3584	101	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	3584	102	as	as	RB
18637	3584	103	well	well	RB
18637	3584	104	by	by	IN
18637	3584	105	a	a	DT
18637	3584	106	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	3584	107	decision	decision	NN
18637	3584	108	as	as	IN
18637	3584	109	by	by	IN
18637	3584	110	a	a	DT
18637	3584	111	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	3584	112	statute	statute	NN
18637	3584	113	.	.	.
18637	3585	1	The	the	DT
18637	3585	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3585	3	,	,	,
18637	3585	4	however	however	RB
18637	3585	5	,	,	,
18637	3585	6	declined	decline	VBD
18637	3585	7	the	the	DT
18637	3585	8	invitation	invitation	NN
18637	3585	9	in	in	IN
18637	3585	10	an	an	DT
18637	3585	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3585	12	by	by	IN
18637	3585	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3585	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3585	15	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	3585	16	which	which	WDT
18637	3585	17	reviewed	review	VBD
18637	3585	18	many	many	JJ
18637	3585	19	of	of	IN
18637	3585	20	the	the	DT
18637	3585	21	cases	case	NNS
18637	3585	22	covered	cover	VBN
18637	3585	23	in	in	IN
18637	3585	24	the	the	DT
18637	3585	25	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	3585	26	paragraphs	paragraph	NNS
18637	3585	27	.	.	.
18637	3586	1	Dealing	deal	VBG
18637	3586	2	with	with	IN
18637	3586	3	the	the	DT
18637	3586	4	Gelpcke	Gelpcke	NNP
18637	3586	5	and	and	CC
18637	3586	6	adherent	adherent	JJ
18637	3586	7	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3586	8	,	,	,
18637	3586	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3586	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3586	11	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	3586	12	said	say	VBD
18637	3586	13	:	:	:
18637	3586	14	"	"	``
18637	3586	15	These	these	DT
18637	3586	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	3586	17	were	be	VBD
18637	3586	18	not	not	RB
18637	3586	19	writs	writ	NNS
18637	3586	20	of	of	IN
18637	3586	21	error	error	NN
18637	3586	22	to	to	IN
18637	3586	23	the	the	DT
18637	3586	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3586	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3586	26	of	of	IN
18637	3586	27	a	a	DT
18637	3586	28	State	state	NN
18637	3586	29	.	.	.
18637	3587	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3587	2	were	be	VBD
18637	3587	3	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	3587	4	or	or	CC
18637	3587	5	writs	writ	NNS
18637	3587	6	of	of	IN
18637	3587	7	error	error	NN
18637	3587	8	to	to	IN
18637	3587	9	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3587	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	3587	11	where	where	WRB
18637	3587	12	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	3587	13	was	be	VBD
18637	3587	14	sought	seek	VBN
18637	3587	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	3587	16	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	3587	17	or	or	CC
18637	3587	18	county	county	NN
18637	3587	19	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	3587	20	or	or	CC
18637	3587	21	some	some	DT
18637	3587	22	other	other	JJ
18637	3587	23	form	form	NN
18637	3587	24	of	of	IN
18637	3587	25	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3587	26	,	,	,
18637	3587	27	the	the	DT
18637	3587	28	validity	validity	NN
18637	3587	29	of	of	IN
18637	3587	30	which	which	WDT
18637	3587	31	had	have	VBD
18637	3587	32	been	be	VBN
18637	3587	33	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	3587	34	by	by	IN
18637	3587	35	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3587	36	of	of	IN
18637	3587	37	the	the	DT
18637	3587	38	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3587	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3587	40	of	of	IN
18637	3587	41	a	a	DT
18637	3587	42	State	state	NN
18637	3587	43	prior	prior	RB
18637	3587	44	to	to	IN
18637	3587	45	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3587	46	execution	execution	NN
18637	3587	47	,	,	,
18637	3587	48	and	and	CC
18637	3587	49	had	have	VBD
18637	3587	50	been	be	VBN
18637	3587	51	denied	deny	VBN
18637	3587	52	by	by	IN
18637	3587	53	the	the	DT
18637	3587	54	same	same	JJ
18637	3587	55	court	court	NN
18637	3587	56	after	after	IN
18637	3587	57	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3587	58	issue	issue	NN
18637	3587	59	or	or	CC
18637	3587	60	making	make	VBG
18637	3587	61	.	.	.
18637	3588	1	In	in	IN
18637	3588	2	such	such	JJ
18637	3588	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	3588	4	the	the	DT
18637	3588	5	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3588	6	courts	court	NNS
18637	3588	7	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	3588	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3588	9	between	between	IN
18637	3588	10	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	3588	11	of	of	IN
18637	3588	12	different	different	JJ
18637	3588	13	States	States	NNPS
18637	3588	14	held	hold	VBD
18637	3588	15	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3588	16	free	free	JJ
18637	3588	17	to	to	TO
18637	3588	18	decide	decide	VB
18637	3588	19	what	what	WP
18637	3588	20	the	the	DT
18637	3588	21	State	State	NNP
18637	3588	22	law	law	NN
18637	3588	23	was	be	VBD
18637	3588	24	,	,	,
18637	3588	25	and	and	CC
18637	3588	26	to	to	TO
18637	3588	27	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	3588	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3588	29	as	as	RB
18637	3588	30	laid	lay	VBN
18637	3588	31	down	down	RP
18637	3588	32	by	by	IN
18637	3588	33	the	the	DT
18637	3588	34	State	State	NNP
18637	3588	35	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3588	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3588	37	before	before	IN
18637	3588	38	the	the	DT
18637	3588	39	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3588	40	were	be	VBD
18637	3588	41	made	make	VBN
18637	3588	42	rather	rather	RB
18637	3588	43	than	than	IN
18637	3588	44	in	in	IN
18637	3588	45	later	later	JJ
18637	3588	46	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3588	47	.	.	.
18637	3589	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3589	2	did	do	VBD
18637	3589	3	not	not	RB
18637	3589	4	base	base	VB
18637	3589	5	this	this	DT
18637	3589	6	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	3589	7	on	on	IN
18637	3589	8	Article	Article	NNP
18637	3589	9	I	I	NNP
18637	3589	10	,	,	,
18637	3589	11	§	§	NNP
18637	3589	12	10	10	CD
18637	3589	13	,	,	,
18637	3589	14	of	of	IN
18637	3589	15	the	the	DT
18637	3589	16	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3589	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3589	18	,	,	,
18637	3589	19	but	but	CC
18637	3589	20	on	on	IN
18637	3589	21	the	the	DT
18637	3589	22	State	State	NNP
18637	3589	23	law	law	NN
18637	3589	24	as	as	IN
18637	3589	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3589	26	determined	determine	VBD
18637	3589	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3589	28	,	,	,
18637	3589	29	which	which	WDT
18637	3589	30	,	,	,
18637	3589	31	in	in	IN
18637	3589	32	diverse	diverse	JJ
18637	3589	33	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	3589	34	cases	case	NNS
18637	3589	35	,	,	,
18637	3589	36	under	under	IN
18637	3589	37	the	the	DT
18637	3589	38	third	third	JJ
18637	3589	39	Article	Article	NNP
18637	3589	40	of	of	IN
18637	3589	41	the	the	DT
18637	3589	42	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	3589	43	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3589	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3589	45	were	be	VBD
18637	3589	46	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	3589	47	to	to	TO
18637	3589	48	do	do	VB
18637	3589	49	.	.	.
18637	3590	1	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
18637	3590	2	_	_	NNP
18637	3590	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	3590	4	_	_	NNP
18637	3590	5	Seligman	Seligman	NNP
18637	3590	6	,	,	,
18637	3590	7	107	107	CD
18637	3590	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	3590	9	20	20	CD
18637	3590	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3590	11	1883	1883	CD
18637	3590	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3590	13	.	.	.
18637	3591	1	"	"	``
18637	3591	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3591	3	1595	1595	CD
18637	3591	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3591	5	While	while	IN
18637	3591	6	doubtless	doubtless	RB
18637	3591	7	this	this	DT
18637	3591	8	was	be	VBD
18637	3591	9	an	an	DT
18637	3591	10	available	available	JJ
18637	3591	11	explanation	explanation	NN
18637	3591	12	in	in	IN
18637	3591	13	1924	1924	CD
18637	3591	14	,	,	,
18637	3591	15	the	the	DT
18637	3591	16	decision	decision	NN
18637	3591	17	in	in	IN
18637	3591	18	1938	1938	CD
18637	3591	19	in	in	IN
18637	3591	20	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	3591	21	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	3591	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	3591	23	_	_	NNP
18637	3591	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	3591	25	_	_	NNP
18637	3591	26	Tompkins	Tompkins	NNP
18637	3591	27	,	,	,
18637	3591	28	304	304	CD
18637	3591	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	3591	30	64	64	CD
18637	3591	31	,	,	,
18637	3591	32	so	so	RB
18637	3591	33	cuts	cut	VBZ
18637	3591	34	down	down	RP
18637	3591	35	the	the	DT
18637	3591	36	power	power	NN
18637	3591	37	of	of	IN
18637	3591	38	the	the	DT
18637	3591	39	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3591	40	courts	court	NNS
18637	3591	41	to	to	TO
18637	3591	42	decide	decide	VB
18637	3591	43	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	3591	44	of	of	IN
18637	3591	45	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	3591	46	cases	case	NNS
18637	3591	47	according	accord	VBG
18637	3591	48	to	to	IN
18637	3591	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3591	50	own	own	JJ
18637	3591	51	notions	notion	NNS
18637	3591	52	of	of	IN
18637	3591	53	"	"	``
18637	3591	54	general	general	JJ
18637	3591	55	principles	principle	NNS
18637	3591	56	of	of	IN
18637	3591	57	common	common	JJ
18637	3591	58	law	law	NN
18637	3591	59	"	"	''
18637	3591	60	as	as	IN
18637	3591	61	to	to	TO
18637	3591	62	raise	raise	VB
18637	3591	63	the	the	DT
18637	3591	64	question	question	NN
18637	3591	65	whether	whether	IN
18637	3591	66	the	the	DT
18637	3591	67	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3591	68	will	will	MD
18637	3591	69	not	not	RB
18637	3591	70	be	be	VB
18637	3591	71	required	require	VBN
18637	3591	72	eventually	eventually	RB
18637	3591	73	to	to	TO
18637	3591	74	put	put	VB
18637	3591	75	Gelpcke	Gelpcke	NNP
18637	3591	76	and	and	CC
18637	3591	77	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3591	78	companions	companion	NNS
18637	3591	79	and	and	CC
18637	3591	80	descendants	descendant	NNS
18637	3591	81	squarely	squarely	RB
18637	3591	82	on	on	IN
18637	3591	83	the	the	DT
18637	3591	84	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3591	85	of	of	IN
18637	3591	86	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3591	87	clause	clause	NN
18637	3591	88	,	,	,
18637	3591	89	or	or	CC
18637	3591	90	else	else	RB
18637	3591	91	abandon	abandon	VB
18637	3591	92	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3591	93	.	.	.
18637	3592	1	"	"	``
18637	3592	2	Obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3592	3	.	.	.
18637	3592	4	"	"	''
18637	3593	1	--A	--A	:
18637	3593	2	contract	contract	NN
18637	3593	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	3593	4	analyzable	analyzable	JJ
18637	3593	5	into	into	IN
18637	3593	6	two	two	CD
18637	3593	7	elements	element	NNS
18637	3593	8	:	:	:
18637	3593	9	the	the	DT
18637	3593	10	_	_	NNP
18637	3593	11	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3593	12	_	_	NNP
18637	3593	13	,	,	,
18637	3593	14	which	which	WDT
18637	3593	15	comes	come	VBZ
18637	3593	16	from	from	IN
18637	3593	17	the	the	DT
18637	3593	18	parties	party	NNS
18637	3593	19	,	,	,
18637	3593	20	and	and	CC
18637	3593	21	the	the	DT
18637	3593	22	_	_	NNP
18637	3593	23	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3593	24	_	_	NNP
18637	3593	25	which	which	WDT
18637	3593	26	comes	come	VBZ
18637	3593	27	from	from	IN
18637	3593	28	the	the	DT
18637	3593	29	law	law	NN
18637	3593	30	and	and	CC
18637	3593	31	makes	make	VBZ
18637	3593	32	the	the	DT
18637	3593	33	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3593	34	binding	bind	VBG
18637	3593	35	on	on	IN
18637	3593	36	the	the	DT
18637	3593	37	parties	party	NNS
18637	3593	38	.	.	.
18637	3594	1	The	the	DT
18637	3594	2	concept	concept	NN
18637	3594	3	of	of	IN
18637	3594	4	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3594	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	3594	6	an	an	DT
18637	3594	7	importation	importation	NN
18637	3594	8	from	from	IN
18637	3594	9	the	the	DT
18637	3594	10	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3594	11	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3594	12	and	and	CC
18637	3594	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3594	14	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	3594	15	in	in	IN
18637	3594	16	the	the	DT
18637	3594	17	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3594	18	clause	clause	NN
18637	3594	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	3594	20	supposed	suppose	VBN
18637	3594	21	to	to	TO
18637	3594	22	have	have	VB
18637	3594	23	been	be	VBN
18637	3594	24	due	due	JJ
18637	3594	25	to	to	IN
18637	3594	26	James	James	NNP
18637	3594	27	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	3594	28	,	,	,
18637	3594	29	a	a	DT
18637	3594	30	graduate	graduate	NN
18637	3594	31	of	of	IN
18637	3594	32	Scottish	scottish	JJ
18637	3594	33	universities	university	NNS
18637	3594	34	and	and	CC
18637	3594	35	a	a	DT
18637	3594	36	Civilian	Civilian	NNP
18637	3594	37	.	.	.
18637	3595	1	Actually	actually	RB
18637	3595	2	the	the	DT
18637	3595	3	term	term	NN
18637	3595	4	as	as	IN
18637	3595	5	used	use	VBN
18637	3595	6	in	in	IN
18637	3595	7	the	the	DT
18637	3595	8	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3595	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	3595	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	3595	11	been	be	VBN
18637	3595	12	rendered	render	VBN
18637	3595	13	more	more	RBR
18637	3595	14	or	or	CC
18637	3595	15	less	less	RBR
18637	3595	16	superfluous	superfluous	JJ
18637	3595	17	by	by	IN
18637	3595	18	the	the	DT
18637	3595	19	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3595	20	that	that	IN
18637	3595	21	the	the	DT
18637	3595	22	law	law	NN
18637	3595	23	in	in	IN
18637	3595	24	force	force	NN
18637	3595	25	when	when	WRB
18637	3595	26	a	a	DT
18637	3595	27	contract	contract	NN
18637	3595	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	3595	29	made	make	VBN
18637	3595	30	enters	enter	NNS
18637	3595	31	into	into	IN
18637	3595	32	and	and	CC
18637	3595	33	comprises	comprise	VBZ
18637	3595	34	a	a	DT
18637	3595	35	part	part	NN
18637	3595	36	of	of	IN
18637	3595	37	the	the	DT
18637	3595	38	contract	contract	NN
18637	3595	39	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3595	40	.	.	.
18637	3596	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3596	2	1596	1596	CD
18637	3596	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3596	4	Hence	hence	RB
18637	3596	5	the	the	DT
18637	3596	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3596	7	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	3596	8	recognizes	recognize	VBZ
18637	3596	9	the	the	DT
18637	3596	10	term	term	NN
18637	3596	11	in	in	IN
18637	3596	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3596	13	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3596	14	applying	apply	VBG
18637	3596	15	the	the	DT
18637	3596	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	3596	17	,	,	,
18637	3596	18	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	3596	19	ignores	ignore	VBZ
18637	3596	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3596	21	.	.	.
18637	3597	1	In	in	IN
18637	3597	2	Sturges	Sturges	NNP
18637	3597	3	_	_	NNP
18637	3597	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	3597	5	_	_	NNP
18637	3597	6	Crowninshield,[1597	Crowninshield,[1597	NNP
18637	3597	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3597	8	decided	decide	VBN
18637	3597	9	in	in	IN
18637	3597	10	1819	1819	CD
18637	3597	11	,	,	,
18637	3597	12	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3597	13	defines	define	VBZ
18637	3597	14	"	"	``
18637	3597	15	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3597	16	of	of	IN
18637	3597	17	contract	contract	NN
18637	3597	18	"	"	''
18637	3597	19	as	as	IN
18637	3597	20	"	"	``
18637	3597	21	the	the	DT
18637	3597	22	law	law	NN
18637	3597	23	which	which	WDT
18637	3597	24	binds	bind	VBZ
18637	3597	25	the	the	DT
18637	3597	26	parties	party	NNS
18637	3597	27	to	to	TO
18637	3597	28	perform	perform	VB
18637	3597	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3597	30	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3597	31	"	"	''
18637	3597	32	;	;	:
18637	3597	33	but	but	CC
18637	3597	34	a	a	DT
18637	3597	35	little	little	JJ
18637	3597	36	later	later	RB
18637	3597	37	the	the	DT
18637	3597	38	same	same	JJ
18637	3597	39	year	year	NN
18637	3597	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3597	41	sets	set	VBZ
18637	3597	42	forth	forth	RB
18637	3597	43	the	the	DT
18637	3597	44	points	point	NNS
18637	3597	45	presented	present	VBN
18637	3597	46	for	for	IN
18637	3597	47	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	3597	48	in	in	IN
18637	3597	49	Trustees	Trustees	NNP
18637	3597	50	of	of	IN
18637	3597	51	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	3597	52	College	College	NNP
18637	3597	53	_	_	NNP
18637	3597	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	3597	55	_	_	NNP
18637	3597	56	Woodward[1598	Woodward[1598	NNP
18637	3597	57	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3597	58	to	to	TO
18637	3597	59	be	be	VB
18637	3597	60	:	:	:
18637	3597	61	"	"	``
18637	3597	62	1	1	CD
18637	3597	63	.	.	.
18637	3598	1	Is	be	VBZ
18637	3598	2	this	this	DT
18637	3598	3	contract	contract	NN
18637	3598	4	protected	protect	VBN
18637	3598	5	by	by	IN
18637	3598	6	the	the	DT
18637	3598	7	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3598	8	of	of	IN
18637	3598	9	the	the	DT
18637	3598	10	United	United	NNP
18637	3598	11	States	States	NNP
18637	3598	12	?	?	.
18637	3599	1	2	2	LS
18637	3599	2	.	.	.
18637	3600	1	Is	be	VBZ
18637	3600	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3600	3	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	3600	4	by	by	IN
18637	3600	5	the	the	DT
18637	3600	6	acts	act	NNS
18637	3600	7	under	under	IN
18637	3600	8	which	which	WDT
18637	3600	9	the	the	DT
18637	3600	10	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	3600	11	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	3600	12	?	?	.
18637	3601	1	"	"	``
18637	3601	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3601	3	1599	1599	CD
18637	3601	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3601	5	The	the	DT
18637	3601	6	word	word	NN
18637	3601	7	"	"	``
18637	3601	8	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3601	9	"	"	''
18637	3601	10	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	3601	11	does	do	VBZ
18637	3601	12	carry	carry	VB
18637	3601	13	the	the	DT
18637	3601	14	implication	implication	NN
18637	3601	15	that	that	IN
18637	3601	16	the	the	DT
18637	3601	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3601	18	was	be	VBD
18637	3601	19	intended	intend	VBN
18637	3601	20	to	to	TO
18637	3601	21	protect	protect	VB
18637	3601	22	only	only	RB
18637	3601	23	_	_	NNP
18637	3601	24	executory	executory	NN
18637	3601	25	_	_	NNP
18637	3601	26	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3601	27	--	--	:
18637	3601	28	i.e	i.e	NNP
18637	3601	29	.	.	NNP
18637	3601	30	,	,	,
18637	3601	31	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3601	32	still	still	RB
18637	3601	33	awaiting	await	VBG
18637	3601	34	performance	performance	NN
18637	3601	35	;	;	:
18637	3601	36	but	but	CC
18637	3601	37	as	as	IN
18637	3601	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	3601	39	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	3601	40	in	in	IN
18637	3601	41	a	a	DT
18637	3601	42	moment	moment	NN
18637	3601	43	,	,	,
18637	3601	44	this	this	DT
18637	3601	45	implication	implication	NN
18637	3601	46	was	be	VBD
18637	3601	47	early	early	RB
18637	3601	48	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	3601	49	for	for	IN
18637	3601	50	a	a	DT
18637	3601	51	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3601	52	class	class	NN
18637	3601	53	of	of	IN
18637	3601	54	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3601	55	,	,	,
18637	3601	56	with	with	IN
18637	3601	57	immensely	immensely	RB
18637	3601	58	important	important	JJ
18637	3601	59	result	result	NN
18637	3601	60	for	for	IN
18637	3601	61	the	the	DT
18637	3601	62	clause	clause	NN
18637	3601	63	.	.	.
18637	3602	1	"	"	``
18637	3602	2	Impair	impair	JJ
18637	3602	3	.	.	.
18637	3602	4	"	"	''
18637	3603	1	--"The	--"The	:
18637	3603	2	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	3603	3	of	of	IN
18637	3603	4	a	a	DT
18637	3603	5	contract	contract	NN
18637	3603	6	,	,	,
18637	3603	7	"	"	''
18637	3603	8	says	say	VBZ
18637	3603	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3603	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3603	11	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	3603	12	for	for	IN
18637	3603	13	the	the	DT
18637	3603	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3603	15	in	in	IN
18637	3603	16	Home	Home	NNP
18637	3603	17	Building	Building	NNP
18637	3603	18	and	and	CC
18637	3603	19	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	3603	20	Association	Association	NNP
18637	3603	21	_	_	NNP
18637	3603	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	3603	23	_	_	NNP
18637	3603	24	Blaisdell,[1600	Blaisdell,[1600	NNP
18637	3603	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3603	26	"	"	``
18637	3603	27	are	be	VBP
18637	3603	28	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	3603	29	by	by	IN
18637	3603	30	a	a	DT
18637	3603	31	law	law	NN
18637	3603	32	which	which	WDT
18637	3603	33	renders	render	VBZ
18637	3603	34	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3603	35	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	3603	36	,	,	,
18637	3603	37	or	or	CC
18637	3603	38	releases	release	NNS
18637	3603	39	or	or	CC
18637	3603	40	extinguishes	extinguish	VBZ
18637	3603	41	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3603	42	*	*	NFP
18637	3603	43	*	*	NFP
18637	3603	44	*	*	NFP
18637	3603	45	and	and	CC
18637	3603	46	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	3603	47	,	,	,
18637	3603	48	*	*	NFP
18637	3603	49	*	*	NFP
18637	3603	50	*	*	NFP
18637	3603	51	,	,	,
18637	3603	52	has	have	VBZ
18637	3603	53	been	be	VBN
18637	3603	54	predicated	predicate	VBN
18637	3603	55	of	of	IN
18637	3603	56	laws	law	NNS
18637	3603	57	which	which	WDT
18637	3603	58	without	without	IN
18637	3603	59	destroying	destroy	VBG
18637	3603	60	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3603	61	derogate	derogate	VBP
18637	3603	62	from	from	IN
18637	3603	63	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	3603	64	contractual	contractual	JJ
18637	3603	65	rights	right	NNS
18637	3603	66	.	.	.
18637	3604	1	"	"	``
18637	3604	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3604	3	1601	1601	CD
18637	3604	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3604	5	But	but	CC
18637	3604	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3604	7	straight	straight	RB
18637	3604	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	3604	9	away	away	RB
18637	3604	10	adds	add	VBZ
18637	3604	11	:	:	:
18637	3604	12	"	"	``
18637	3604	13	Not	not	RB
18637	3604	14	only	only	RB
18637	3604	15	are	be	VBP
18637	3604	16	existing	exist	VBG
18637	3604	17	laws	law	NNS
18637	3604	18	read	read	VBP
18637	3604	19	into	into	IN
18637	3604	20	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3604	21	in	in	IN
18637	3604	22	order	order	NN
18637	3604	23	to	to	TO
18637	3604	24	fix	fix	VB
18637	3604	25	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	3604	26	as	as	IN
18637	3604	27	between	between	IN
18637	3604	28	the	the	DT
18637	3604	29	parties	party	NNS
18637	3604	30	,	,	,
18637	3604	31	but	but	CC
18637	3604	32	the	the	DT
18637	3604	33	reservation	reservation	NN
18637	3604	34	of	of	IN
18637	3604	35	essential	essential	JJ
18637	3604	36	attributes	attribute	NNS
18637	3604	37	of	of	IN
18637	3604	38	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	3604	39	power	power	NN
18637	3604	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	3604	41	also	also	RB
18637	3604	42	read	read	VBN
18637	3604	43	into	into	IN
18637	3604	44	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3604	45	as	as	IN
18637	3604	46	a	a	DT
18637	3604	47	postulate	postulate	NN
18637	3604	48	of	of	IN
18637	3604	49	the	the	DT
18637	3604	50	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3604	51	order	order	NN
18637	3604	52	.	.	.
18637	3605	1	The	the	DT
18637	3605	2	policy	policy	NN
18637	3605	3	of	of	IN
18637	3605	4	protecting	protect	VBG
18637	3605	5	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3605	6	against	against	IN
18637	3605	7	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	3605	8	presupposes	presuppose	VBZ
18637	3605	9	the	the	DT
18637	3605	10	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	3605	11	of	of	IN
18637	3605	12	a	a	DT
18637	3605	13	government	government	NN
18637	3605	14	by	by	IN
18637	3605	15	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	3605	16	of	of	IN
18637	3605	17	which	which	WDT
18637	3605	18	contractual	contractual	JJ
18637	3605	19	relations	relation	NNS
18637	3605	20	are	be	VBP
18637	3605	21	worth	worth	JJ
18637	3605	22	while,--a	while,--a	NNP
18637	3605	23	government	government	NN
18637	3605	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3605	25	retains	retain	VBZ
18637	3605	26	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	3605	27	authority	authority	NN
18637	3605	28	to	to	TO
18637	3605	29	secure	secure	VB
18637	3605	30	the	the	DT
18637	3605	31	peace	peace	NN
18637	3605	32	and	and	CC
18637	3605	33	good	good	JJ
18637	3605	34	order	order	NN
18637	3605	35	of	of	IN
18637	3605	36	society	society	NN
18637	3605	37	.	.	.
18637	3606	1	This	this	DT
18637	3606	2	principle	principle	NN
18637	3606	3	of	of	IN
18637	3606	4	harmonizing	harmonize	VBG
18637	3606	5	the	the	DT
18637	3606	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3606	7	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3606	8	with	with	IN
18637	3606	9	the	the	DT
18637	3606	10	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3606	11	residuum	residuum	NN
18637	3606	12	of	of	IN
18637	3606	13	State	State	NNP
18637	3606	14	power	power	NN
18637	3606	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	3606	16	had	have	VBN
18637	3606	17	progressive	progressive	JJ
18637	3606	18	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	3606	19	in	in	IN
18637	3606	20	the	the	DT
18637	3606	21	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3606	22	of	of	IN
18637	3606	23	this	this	DT
18637	3606	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3606	25	.	.	.
18637	3607	1	"	"	``
18637	3607	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3607	3	1602	1602	CD
18637	3607	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3607	5	In	in	IN
18637	3607	6	short	short	JJ
18637	3607	7	,	,	,
18637	3607	8	the	the	DT
18637	3607	9	law	law	NN
18637	3607	10	from	from	IN
18637	3607	11	which	which	WDT
18637	3607	12	the	the	DT
18637	3607	13	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3607	14	stems	stem	NNS
18637	3607	15	must	must	MD
18637	3607	16	be	be	VB
18637	3607	17	understood	understand	VBN
18637	3607	18	to	to	TO
18637	3607	19	include	include	VB
18637	3607	20	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	3607	21	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3607	22	and	and	CC
18637	3607	23	,	,	,
18637	3607	24	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	3607	25	,	,	,
18637	3607	26	a	a	DT
18637	3607	27	"	"	``
18637	3607	28	progressive	progressive	JJ
18637	3607	29	"	"	''
18637	3607	30	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	3607	31	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3607	32	.	.	.
18637	3608	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3608	2	1603	1603	CD
18637	3608	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3608	4	"	"	``
18637	3608	5	Contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3608	6	,	,	,
18637	3608	7	"	"	''
18637	3608	8	Extended	extended	JJ
18637	3608	9	to	to	TO
18637	3608	10	Cover	cover	VB
18637	3608	11	Public	Public	NNP
18637	3608	12	Contracts.--Throughout	contracts.--throughout	NN
18637	3608	13	the	the	DT
18637	3608	14	first	first	JJ
18637	3608	15	century	century	NN
18637	3608	16	of	of	IN
18637	3608	17	government	government	NN
18637	3608	18	under	under	IN
18637	3608	19	the	the	DT
18637	3608	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3608	21	,	,	,
18637	3608	22	according	accord	VBG
18637	3608	23	to	to	IN
18637	3608	24	Benjamin	Benjamin	NNP
18637	3608	25	F.	F.	NNP
18637	3608	26	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	3608	27	,	,	,
18637	3608	28	the	the	DT
18637	3608	29	contract	contract	NN
18637	3608	30	clause	clause	NN
18637	3608	31	had	have	VBD
18637	3608	32	been	be	VBN
18637	3608	33	considered	consider	VBN
18637	3608	34	in	in	IN
18637	3608	35	almost	almost	RB
18637	3608	36	forty	forty	CD
18637	3608	37	per	per	IN
18637	3608	38	cent	cent	NN
18637	3608	39	of	of	IN
18637	3608	40	all	all	DT
18637	3608	41	cases	case	NNS
18637	3608	42	involving	involve	VBG
18637	3608	43	the	the	DT
18637	3608	44	validity	validity	NN
18637	3608	45	of	of	IN
18637	3608	46	State	State	NNP
18637	3608	47	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3608	48	,	,	,
18637	3608	49	and	and	CC
18637	3608	50	of	of	IN
18637	3608	51	these	these	DT
18637	3608	52	the	the	DT
18637	3608	53	vast	vast	JJ
18637	3608	54	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	3608	55	involved	involve	VBD
18637	3608	56	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3608	57	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3608	58	of	of	IN
18637	3608	59	one	one	CD
18637	3608	60	type	type	NN
18637	3608	61	or	or	CC
18637	3608	62	other	other	JJ
18637	3608	63	,	,	,
18637	3608	64	the	the	DT
18637	3608	65	most	most	RBS
18637	3608	66	important	important	JJ
18637	3608	67	category	category	NN
18637	3608	68	being	be	VBG
18637	3608	69	charters	charter	NNS
18637	3608	70	of	of	IN
18637	3608	71	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	3608	72	.	.	.
18637	3609	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3609	2	1604	1604	CD
18637	3609	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3609	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	3609	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	3609	6	this	this	DT
18637	3609	7	numerical	numerical	JJ
18637	3609	8	prominence	prominence	NN
18637	3609	9	of	of	IN
18637	3609	10	such	such	JJ
18637	3609	11	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3609	12	in	in	IN
18637	3609	13	the	the	DT
18637	3609	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	3609	15	overrate	overrate	VBP
18637	3609	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3609	17	relative	relative	JJ
18637	3609	18	importance	importance	NN
18637	3609	19	from	from	IN
18637	3609	20	the	the	DT
18637	3609	21	point	point	NN
18637	3609	22	of	of	IN
18637	3609	23	view	view	NN
18637	3609	24	of	of	IN
18637	3609	25	public	public	JJ
18637	3609	26	interest	interest	NN
18637	3609	27	.	.	.
18637	3610	1	The	the	DT
18637	3610	2	question	question	NN
18637	3610	3	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	3610	4	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	3610	5	whether	whether	IN
18637	3610	6	the	the	DT
18637	3610	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	3610	8	was	be	VBD
18637	3610	9	intended	intend	VBN
18637	3610	10	to	to	TO
18637	3610	11	be	be	VB
18637	3610	12	applied	apply	VBN
18637	3610	13	solely	solely	RB
18637	3610	14	in	in	IN
18637	3610	15	protection	protection	NN
18637	3610	16	of	of	IN
18637	3610	17	private	private	JJ
18637	3610	18	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3610	19	,	,	,
18637	3610	20	or	or	CC
18637	3610	21	in	in	IN
18637	3610	22	the	the	DT
18637	3610	23	protection	protection	NN
18637	3610	24	also	also	RB
18637	3610	25	of	of	IN
18637	3610	26	public	public	JJ
18637	3610	27	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3610	28	or	or	CC
18637	3610	29	,	,	,
18637	3610	30	more	more	RBR
18637	3610	31	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	3610	32	,	,	,
18637	3610	33	in	in	IN
18637	3610	34	protection	protection	NN
18637	3610	35	of	of	IN
18637	3610	36	public	public	JJ
18637	3610	37	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3610	38	,	,	,
18637	3610	39	in	in	IN
18637	3610	40	short	short	JJ
18637	3610	41	,	,	,
18637	3610	42	those	those	DT
18637	3610	43	to	to	TO
18637	3610	44	which	which	WDT
18637	3610	45	a	a	DT
18637	3610	46	State	state	NN
18637	3610	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	3610	48	party	party	NN
18637	3610	49	?	?	.
18637	3611	1	Writing	write	VBG
18637	3611	2	late	late	RB
18637	3611	3	in	in	IN
18637	3611	4	life	life	NN
18637	3611	5	,	,	,
18637	3611	6	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	3611	7	explained	explain	VBD
18637	3611	8	the	the	DT
18637	3611	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	3611	10	by	by	IN
18637	3611	11	allusion	allusion	NN
18637	3611	12	to	to	IN
18637	3611	13	what	what	WP
18637	3611	14	had	have	VBD
18637	3611	15	occurred	occur	VBN
18637	3611	16	"	"	''
18637	3611	17	in	in	IN
18637	3611	18	the	the	DT
18637	3611	19	internal	internal	JJ
18637	3611	20	administration	administration	NN
18637	3611	21	of	of	IN
18637	3611	22	the	the	DT
18637	3611	23	States	States	NNP
18637	3611	24	,	,	,
18637	3611	25	"	"	''
18637	3611	26	in	in	IN
18637	3611	27	the	the	DT
18637	3611	28	years	year	NNS
18637	3611	29	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	3611	30	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	3611	31	the	the	DT
18637	3611	32	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	3611	33	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	3611	34	,	,	,
18637	3611	35	in	in	IN
18637	3611	36	regard	regard	NN
18637	3611	37	to	to	IN
18637	3611	38	private	private	JJ
18637	3611	39	debts	debt	NNS
18637	3611	40	.	.	.
18637	3612	1	"	"	``
18637	3612	2	A	a	DT
18637	3612	3	violation	violation	NN
18637	3612	4	of	of	IN
18637	3612	5	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3612	6	,	,	,
18637	3612	7	"	"	''
18637	3612	8	said	say	VBD
18637	3612	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3612	10	,	,	,
18637	3612	11	"	"	``
18637	3612	12	had	have	VBD
18637	3612	13	become	become	VBN
18637	3612	14	familiar	familiar	JJ
18637	3612	15	in	in	IN
18637	3612	16	the	the	DT
18637	3612	17	form	form	NN
18637	3612	18	of	of	IN
18637	3612	19	depreciated	depreciate	VBN
18637	3612	20	paper	paper	NN
18637	3612	21	made	make	VBD
18637	3612	22	a	a	DT
18637	3612	23	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3612	24	tender	tender	NN
18637	3612	25	,	,	,
18637	3612	26	of	of	IN
18637	3612	27	property	property	NN
18637	3612	28	substituted	substitute	VBN
18637	3612	29	for	for	IN
18637	3612	30	money	money	NN
18637	3612	31	,	,	,
18637	3612	32	and	and	CC
18637	3612	33	installment	installment	NN
18637	3612	34	laws	law	NNS
18637	3612	35	,	,	,
18637	3612	36	and	and	CC
18637	3612	37	the	the	DT
18637	3612	38	occlusions	occlusion	NNS
18637	3612	39	of	of	IN
18637	3612	40	the	the	DT
18637	3612	41	courts	court	NNS
18637	3612	42	of	of	IN
18637	3612	43	justice	justice	NN
18637	3612	44	.	.	.
18637	3613	1	"	"	``
18637	3613	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3613	3	1605	1605	CD
18637	3613	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3613	5	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3613	6	had	have	VBD
18637	3613	7	,	,	,
18637	3613	8	in	in	IN
18637	3613	9	fact	fact	NN
18637	3613	10	,	,	,
18637	3613	11	written	write	VBN
18637	3613	12	to	to	IN
18637	3613	13	the	the	DT
18637	3613	14	same	same	JJ
18637	3613	15	effect	effect	NN
18637	3613	16	in	in	IN
18637	3613	17	The	the	DT
18637	3613	18	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	3613	19	,	,	,
18637	3613	20	while	while	IN
18637	3613	21	the	the	DT
18637	3613	22	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	3613	23	of	of	IN
18637	3613	24	the	the	DT
18637	3613	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3613	26	was	be	VBD
18637	3613	27	pending	pende	VBG
18637	3613	28	.	.	.
18637	3614	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3614	2	1606	1606	CD
18637	3614	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3614	4	The	the	DT
18637	3614	5	broader	broad	JJR
18637	3614	6	view	view	NN
18637	3614	7	of	of	IN
18637	3614	8	the	the	DT
18637	3614	9	intended	intended	JJ
18637	3614	10	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3614	11	of	of	IN
18637	3614	12	the	the	DT
18637	3614	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	3614	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	3614	15	,	,	,
18637	3614	16	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	3614	17	,	,	,
18637	3614	18	not	not	RB
18637	3614	19	without	without	IN
18637	3614	20	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	3614	21	support	support	NN
18637	3614	22	.	.	.
18637	3615	1	For	for	IN
18637	3615	2	one	one	CD
18637	3615	3	thing	thing	NN
18637	3615	4	,	,	,
18637	3615	5	the	the	DT
18637	3615	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	3615	7	departs	depart	VBZ
18637	3615	8	from	from	IN
18637	3615	9	the	the	DT
18637	3615	10	comparable	comparable	JJ
18637	3615	11	provision	provision	NN
18637	3615	12	in	in	IN
18637	3615	13	the	the	DT
18637	3615	14	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	3615	15	Ordinance	Ordinance	NNP
18637	3615	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3615	17	1787	1787	CD
18637	3615	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3615	19	in	in	IN
18637	3615	20	two	two	CD
18637	3615	21	respects	respect	NNS
18637	3615	22	:	:	:
18637	3615	23	First	first	RB
18637	3615	24	,	,	,
18637	3615	25	in	in	IN
18637	3615	26	the	the	DT
18637	3615	27	_	_	NNP
18637	3615	28	presence	presence	NN
18637	3615	29	_	_	NNP
18637	3615	30	of	of	IN
18637	3615	31	the	the	DT
18637	3615	32	word	word	NN
18637	3615	33	"	"	``
18637	3615	34	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3615	35	"	"	''
18637	3615	36	;	;	:
18637	3615	37	secondly	secondly	RB
18637	3615	38	,	,	,
18637	3615	39	in	in	IN
18637	3615	40	the	the	DT
18637	3615	41	_	_	NNP
18637	3615	42	absence	absence	NN
18637	3615	43	_	_	NNP
18637	3615	44	of	of	IN
18637	3615	45	the	the	DT
18637	3615	46	word	word	NN
18637	3615	47	"	"	``
18637	3615	48	private	private	JJ
18637	3615	49	"	"	''
18637	3615	50	;	;	:
18637	3615	51	and	and	CC
18637	3615	52	there	there	EX
18637	3615	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	3615	54	good	good	JJ
18637	3615	55	reason	reason	NN
18637	3615	56	for	for	IN
18637	3615	57	believing	believe	VBG
18637	3615	58	that	that	IN
18637	3615	59	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	3615	60	may	may	MD
18637	3615	61	have	have	VB
18637	3615	62	been	be	VBN
18637	3615	63	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	3615	64	for	for	IN
18637	3615	65	both	both	DT
18637	3615	66	alterations	alteration	NNS
18637	3615	67	,	,	,
18637	3615	68	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	3615	69	as	as	IN
18637	3615	70	two	two	CD
18637	3615	71	years	year	NNS
18637	3615	72	earlier	early	RBR
18637	3615	73	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3615	74	had	have	VBD
18637	3615	75	denounced	denounce	VBN
18637	3615	76	a	a	DT
18637	3615	77	current	current	JJ
18637	3615	78	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	3615	79	to	to	TO
18637	3615	80	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	3615	81	the	the	DT
18637	3615	82	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	3615	83	of	of	IN
18637	3615	84	North	North	NNP
18637	3615	85	America	America	NNP
18637	3615	86	's	's	POS
18637	3615	87	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	3615	88	charter	charter	NN
18637	3615	89	,	,	,
18637	3615	90	in	in	IN
18637	3615	91	the	the	DT
18637	3615	92	following	follow	VBG
18637	3615	93	words	word	NNS
18637	3615	94	:	:	:
18637	3615	95	"	"	``
18637	3615	96	If	if	IN
18637	3615	97	the	the	DT
18637	3615	98	act	act	NN
18637	3615	99	for	for	IN
18637	3615	100	incorporating	incorporate	VBG
18637	3615	101	the	the	DT
18637	3615	102	subscribers	subscriber	NNS
18637	3615	103	to	to	IN
18637	3615	104	the	the	DT
18637	3615	105	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	3615	106	of	of	IN
18637	3615	107	North	North	NNP
18637	3615	108	America	America	NNP
18637	3615	109	shall	shall	MD
18637	3615	110	be	be	VB
18637	3615	111	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	3615	112	in	in	IN
18637	3615	113	this	this	DT
18637	3615	114	manner	manner	NN
18637	3615	115	,	,	,
18637	3615	116	a	a	DT
18637	3615	117	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	3615	118	will	will	MD
18637	3615	119	be	be	VB
18637	3615	120	established	establish	VBN
18637	3615	121	for	for	IN
18637	3615	122	repealing	repealing	NN
18637	3615	123	,	,	,
18637	3615	124	in	in	IN
18637	3615	125	the	the	DT
18637	3615	126	same	same	JJ
18637	3615	127	manner	manner	NN
18637	3615	128	,	,	,
18637	3615	129	every	every	DT
18637	3615	130	other	other	JJ
18637	3615	131	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3615	132	charter	charter	NN
18637	3615	133	in	in	IN
18637	3615	134	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	3615	135	.	.	.
18637	3616	1	A	a	DT
18637	3616	2	pretence	pretence	NN
18637	3616	3	,	,	,
18637	3616	4	as	as	RB
18637	3616	5	specious	specious	JJ
18637	3616	6	as	as	IN
18637	3616	7	any	any	DT
18637	3616	8	that	that	WDT
18637	3616	9	can	can	MD
18637	3616	10	be	be	VB
18637	3616	11	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	3616	12	on	on	IN
18637	3616	13	this	this	DT
18637	3616	14	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	3616	15	,	,	,
18637	3616	16	will	will	MD
18637	3616	17	never	never	RB
18637	3616	18	be	be	VB
18637	3616	19	wanting	want	VBG
18637	3616	20	on	on	IN
18637	3616	21	any	any	DT
18637	3616	22	future	future	JJ
18637	3616	23	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	3616	24	.	.	.
18637	3617	1	Those	those	DT
18637	3617	2	acts	act	NNS
18637	3617	3	of	of	IN
18637	3617	4	the	the	DT
18637	3617	5	State	State	NNP
18637	3617	6	,	,	,
18637	3617	7	which	which	WDT
18637	3617	8	have	have	VBP
18637	3617	9	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
18637	3617	10	been	be	VBN
18637	3617	11	considered	consider	VBN
18637	3617	12	as	as	IN
18637	3617	13	the	the	DT
18637	3617	14	sure	sure	JJ
18637	3617	15	anchors	anchor	NNS
18637	3617	16	of	of	IN
18637	3617	17	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	3617	18	and	and	CC
18637	3617	19	of	of	IN
18637	3617	20	property	property	NN
18637	3617	21	,	,	,
18637	3617	22	will	will	MD
18637	3617	23	become	become	VB
18637	3617	24	the	the	DT
18637	3617	25	sport	sport	NN
18637	3617	26	of	of	IN
18637	3617	27	every	every	DT
18637	3617	28	varying	varying	NN
18637	3617	29	gust	gust	NN
18637	3617	30	of	of	IN
18637	3617	31	politics	politic	NNS
18637	3617	32	,	,	,
18637	3617	33	and	and	CC
18637	3617	34	will	will	MD
18637	3617	35	float	float	VB
18637	3617	36	wildly	wildly	RB
18637	3617	37	backwards	backwards	RB
18637	3617	38	and	and	CC
18637	3617	39	forwards	forwards	RB
18637	3617	40	on	on	IN
18637	3617	41	the	the	DT
18637	3617	42	irregular	irregular	JJ
18637	3617	43	and	and	CC
18637	3617	44	impetuous	impetuous	JJ
18637	3617	45	tides	tide	NNS
18637	3617	46	of	of	IN
18637	3617	47	party	party	NN
18637	3617	48	and	and	CC
18637	3617	49	faction	faction	NN
18637	3617	50	.	.	.
18637	3618	1	"	"	``
18637	3618	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3618	3	1607	1607	CD
18637	3618	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3618	5	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	3618	6	,	,	,
18637	3618	7	in	in	IN
18637	3618	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3618	9	first	first	JJ
18637	3618	10	important	important	JJ
18637	3618	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3618	12	case	case	NN
18637	3618	13	,	,	,
18637	3618	14	that	that	DT
18637	3618	15	of	of	IN
18637	3618	16	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
18637	3618	17	_	_	NNP
18637	3618	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	3618	19	_	_	NNP
18637	3618	20	Georgia,[1608	Georgia,[1608	NNP
18637	3618	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3618	22	the	the	DT
18637	3618	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3618	24	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	3618	25	that	that	IN
18637	3618	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3618	27	original	original	JJ
18637	3618	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3618	29	extended	extend	VBN
18637	3618	30	to	to	IN
18637	3618	31	an	an	DT
18637	3618	32	action	action	NN
18637	3618	33	in	in	IN
18637	3618	34	assumpsit	assumpsit	NN
18637	3618	35	brought	bring	VBN
18637	3618	36	by	by	IN
18637	3618	37	a	a	DT
18637	3618	38	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	3618	39	of	of	IN
18637	3618	40	South	South	NNP
18637	3618	41	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	3618	42	against	against	IN
18637	3618	43	the	the	DT
18637	3618	44	State	State	NNP
18637	3618	45	of	of	IN
18637	3618	46	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	3618	47	.	.	.
18637	3619	1	This	this	DT
18637	3619	2	construction	construction	NN
18637	3619	3	of	of	IN
18637	3619	4	the	the	DT
18637	3619	5	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3619	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3619	7	power	power	NN
18637	3619	8	was	be	VBD
18637	3619	9	,	,	,
18637	3619	10	to	to	TO
18637	3619	11	be	be	VB
18637	3619	12	sure	sure	JJ
18637	3619	13	,	,	,
18637	3619	14	promptly	promptly	RB
18637	3619	15	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	3619	16	by	by	IN
18637	3619	17	the	the	DT
18637	3619	18	Eleventh	Eleventh	NNP
18637	3619	19	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3619	20	,	,	,
18637	3619	21	but	but	CC
18637	3619	22	without	without	IN
18637	3619	23	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	3619	24	the	the	DT
18637	3619	25	implication	implication	NN
18637	3619	26	that	that	IN
18637	3619	27	the	the	DT
18637	3619	28	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3619	29	protected	protect	VBN
18637	3619	30	by	by	IN
18637	3619	31	the	the	DT
18637	3619	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3619	33	included	include	VBD
18637	3619	34	public	public	JJ
18637	3619	35	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3619	36	.	.	.
18637	3620	1	One	one	CD
18637	3620	2	important	important	JJ
18637	3620	3	source	source	NN
18637	3620	4	of	of	IN
18637	3620	5	this	this	DT
18637	3620	6	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	3620	7	of	of	IN
18637	3620	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3620	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	3620	10	to	to	TO
18637	3620	11	be	be	VB
18637	3620	12	found	find	VBN
18637	3620	13	in	in	IN
18637	3620	14	that	that	DT
18637	3620	15	ever	ever	RB
18637	3620	16	welling	well	VBG
18637	3620	17	spring	spring	NN
18637	3620	18	of	of	IN
18637	3620	19	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3620	20	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3620	21	in	in	IN
18637	3620	22	early	early	JJ
18637	3620	23	days	day	NNS
18637	3620	24	,	,	,
18637	3620	25	the	the	DT
18637	3620	26	prevalence	prevalence	NN
18637	3620	27	of	of	IN
18637	3620	28	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	3620	29	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3620	30	notions	notion	NNS
18637	3620	31	and	and	CC
18637	3620	32	the	the	DT
18637	3620	33	resulting	result	VBG
18637	3620	34	vague	vague	JJ
18637	3620	35	significance	significance	NN
18637	3620	36	of	of	IN
18637	3620	37	the	the	DT
18637	3620	38	term	term	NN
18637	3620	39	"	"	``
18637	3620	40	law	law	NN
18637	3620	41	.	.	.
18637	3620	42	"	"	''
18637	3621	1	In	in	IN
18637	3621	2	Sturges	Sturges	NNP
18637	3621	3	_	_	NNP
18637	3621	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	3621	5	_	_	NNP
18637	3621	6	Crowninshield	Crowninshield	NNP
18637	3621	7	,	,	,
18637	3621	8	as	as	IN
18637	3621	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3621	10	saw	see	VBD
18637	3621	11	,	,	,
18637	3621	12	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3621	13	defined	define	VBD
18637	3621	14	the	the	DT
18637	3621	15	_	_	NNP
18637	3621	16	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3621	17	of	of	IN
18637	3621	18	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3621	19	_	_	NNP
18637	3621	20	as	as	IN
18637	3621	21	"	"	``
18637	3621	22	the	the	DT
18637	3621	23	law	law	NN
18637	3621	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3621	25	binds	bind	VBZ
18637	3621	26	the	the	DT
18637	3621	27	parties	party	NNS
18637	3621	28	to	to	TO
18637	3621	29	perform	perform	VB
18637	3621	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3621	31	undertaking	undertaking	NN
18637	3621	32	.	.	.
18637	3621	33	"	"	''
18637	3622	1	Whence	whence	UH
18637	3622	2	,	,	,
18637	3622	3	however	however	RB
18637	3622	4	,	,	,
18637	3622	5	comes	come	VBZ
18637	3622	6	this	this	DT
18637	3622	7	law	law	NN
18637	3622	8	?	?	.
18637	3623	1	If	if	IN
18637	3623	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3623	3	comes	come	VBZ
18637	3623	4	from	from	IN
18637	3623	5	the	the	DT
18637	3623	6	State	state	NN
18637	3623	7	alone	alone	RB
18637	3623	8	,	,	,
18637	3623	9	which	which	WDT
18637	3623	10	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3623	11	was	be	VBD
18637	3623	12	later	later	RB
18637	3623	13	to	to	TO
18637	3623	14	deny	deny	VB
18637	3623	15	even	even	RB
18637	3623	16	as	as	IN
18637	3623	17	to	to	IN
18637	3623	18	private	private	JJ
18637	3623	19	contracts,[1609	contracts,[1609	NNP
18637	3623	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3623	21	then	then	RB
18637	3623	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3623	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	3623	24	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	3623	25	possible	possible	JJ
18637	3623	26	to	to	TO
18637	3623	27	hold	hold	VB
18637	3623	28	that	that	IN
18637	3623	29	the	the	DT
18637	3623	30	States	States	NNPS
18637	3623	31	'	'	POS
18637	3623	32	own	own	JJ
18637	3623	33	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3623	34	are	be	VBP
18637	3623	35	covered	cover	VBN
18637	3623	36	by	by	IN
18637	3623	37	the	the	DT
18637	3623	38	clause	clause	NN
18637	3623	39	,	,	,
18637	3623	40	which	which	WDT
18637	3623	41	manifestly	manifestly	RB
18637	3623	42	does	do	VBZ
18637	3623	43	not	not	RB
18637	3623	44	_	_	NNP
18637	3623	45	create	create	VB
18637	3623	46	_	_	NNP
18637	3623	47	an	an	DT
18637	3623	48	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3623	49	for	for	IN
18637	3623	50	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3623	51	but	but	CC
18637	3623	52	only	only	RB
18637	3623	53	protects	protect	VBZ
18637	3623	54	such	such	JJ
18637	3623	55	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3623	56	as	as	IN
18637	3623	57	already	already	RB
18637	3623	58	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	3623	59	.	.	.
18637	3624	1	But	but	CC
18637	3624	2	if	if	IN
18637	3624	3	,	,	,
18637	3624	4	on	on	IN
18637	3624	5	the	the	DT
18637	3624	6	other	other	JJ
18637	3624	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	3624	8	,	,	,
18637	3624	9	the	the	DT
18637	3624	10	law	law	NN
18637	3624	11	furnishing	furnish	VBG
18637	3624	12	the	the	DT
18637	3624	13	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3624	14	of	of	IN
18637	3624	15	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3624	16	comprises	comprise	VBZ
18637	3624	17	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	3624	18	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3624	19	and	and	CC
18637	3624	20	kindred	kindred	JJ
18637	3624	21	principles	principle	NNS
18637	3624	22	,	,	,
18637	3624	23	as	as	RB
18637	3624	24	well	well	RB
18637	3624	25	as	as	IN
18637	3624	26	law	law	NN
18637	3624	27	which	which	WDT
18637	3624	28	springs	spring	NNS
18637	3624	29	from	from	IN
18637	3624	30	State	State	NNP
18637	3624	31	authority	authority	NN
18637	3624	32	,	,	,
18637	3624	33	then	then	RB
18637	3624	34	,	,	,
18637	3624	35	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	3624	36	as	as	IN
18637	3624	37	the	the	DT
18637	3624	38	State	State	NNP
18637	3624	39	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3624	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	3624	41	presumably	presumably	RB
18637	3624	42	bound	bind	VBN
18637	3624	43	by	by	IN
18637	3624	44	such	such	JJ
18637	3624	45	principles	principle	NNS
18637	3624	46	,	,	,
18637	3624	47	the	the	DT
18637	3624	48	State	State	NNP
18637	3624	49	's	's	POS
18637	3624	50	own	own	JJ
18637	3624	51	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	3624	52	,	,	,
18637	3624	53	so	so	RB
18637	3624	54	far	far	RB
18637	3624	55	as	as	RB
18637	3624	56	harmonious	harmonious	JJ
18637	3624	57	with	with	IN
18637	3624	58	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3624	59	,	,	,
18637	3624	60	are	be	VBP
18637	3624	61	covered	cover	VBN
18637	3624	62	by	by	IN
18637	3624	63	the	the	DT
18637	3624	64	clause	clause	NN
18637	3624	65	.	.	.
18637	3625	1	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	3625	2	_	_	NNP
18637	3625	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	3625	4	_	_	NNP
18637	3625	5	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	3625	6	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	3625	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3625	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	3625	9	_	_	NNP
18637	3625	10	Peck,[1610	Peck,[1610	NNP
18637	3625	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3625	12	which	which	WDT
18637	3625	13	was	be	VBD
18637	3625	14	decided	decide	VBN
18637	3625	15	in	in	IN
18637	3625	16	1810	1810	CD
18637	3625	17	,	,	,
18637	3625	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	3625	19	the	the	DT
18637	3625	20	double	double	JJ
18637	3625	21	claim	claim	NN
18637	3625	22	to	to	IN
18637	3625	23	fame	fame	NN
18637	3625	24	that	that	IN
18637	3625	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3625	26	was	be	VBD
18637	3625	27	the	the	DT
18637	3625	28	first	first	JJ
18637	3625	29	case	case	NN
18637	3625	30	in	in	IN
18637	3625	31	which	which	WDT
18637	3625	32	the	the	DT
18637	3625	33	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3625	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3625	35	held	hold	VBD
18637	3625	36	a	a	DT
18637	3625	37	State	state	NN
18637	3625	38	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	3625	39	to	to	TO
18637	3625	40	be	be	VB
18637	3625	41	in	in	IN
18637	3625	42	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	3625	43	with	with	IN
18637	3625	44	the	the	DT
18637	3625	45	Constitution,[1611	constitution,[1611	CD
18637	3625	46	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3625	47	and	and	CC
18637	3625	48	also	also	RB
18637	3625	49	the	the	DT
18637	3625	50	first	first	JJ
18637	3625	51	case	case	NN
18637	3625	52	to	to	TO
18637	3625	53	hold	hold	VB
18637	3625	54	that	that	IN
18637	3625	55	the	the	DT
18637	3625	56	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3625	57	clause	clause	NN
18637	3625	58	protected	protect	VBD
18637	3625	59	public	public	JJ
18637	3625	60	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3625	61	.	.	.
18637	3626	1	By	by	IN
18637	3626	2	an	an	DT
18637	3626	3	act	act	NN
18637	3626	4	passed	pass	VBN
18637	3626	5	on	on	IN
18637	3626	6	January	January	NNP
18637	3626	7	7	7	CD
18637	3626	8	,	,	,
18637	3626	9	1795	1795	CD
18637	3626	10	,	,	,
18637	3626	11	the	the	DT
18637	3626	12	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	3626	13	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	3626	14	directed	direct	VBD
18637	3626	15	the	the	DT
18637	3626	16	sale	sale	NN
18637	3626	17	to	to	IN
18637	3626	18	four	four	CD
18637	3626	19	land	land	NN
18637	3626	20	companies	company	NNS
18637	3626	21	of	of	IN
18637	3626	22	public	public	JJ
18637	3626	23	lands	land	NNS
18637	3626	24	comprising	comprise	VBG
18637	3626	25	most	most	JJS
18637	3626	26	of	of	IN
18637	3626	27	what	what	WP
18637	3626	28	are	be	VBP
18637	3626	29	now	now	RB
18637	3626	30	the	the	DT
18637	3626	31	States	States	NNP
18637	3626	32	of	of	IN
18637	3626	33	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	3626	34	and	and	CC
18637	3626	35	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	3626	36	.	.	.
18637	3627	1	As	as	IN
18637	3627	2	soon	soon	RB
18637	3627	3	became	become	VBD
18637	3627	4	known	know	VBN
18637	3627	5	,	,	,
18637	3627	6	the	the	DT
18637	3627	7	passage	passage	NN
18637	3627	8	of	of	IN
18637	3627	9	the	the	DT
18637	3627	10	measure	measure	NN
18637	3627	11	had	have	VBD
18637	3627	12	been	be	VBN
18637	3627	13	secured	secure	VBN
18637	3627	14	by	by	IN
18637	3627	15	open	open	JJ
18637	3627	16	and	and	CC
18637	3627	17	wholesale	wholesale	JJ
18637	3627	18	bribery	bribery	NN
18637	3627	19	.	.	.
18637	3628	1	So	so	RB
18637	3628	2	when	when	WRB
18637	3628	3	a	a	DT
18637	3628	4	new	new	JJ
18637	3628	5	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3628	6	took	take	VBD
18637	3628	7	over	over	RP
18637	3628	8	in	in	IN
18637	3628	9	the	the	DT
18637	3628	10	winter	winter	NN
18637	3628	11	of	of	IN
18637	3628	12	1795	1795	CD
18637	3628	13	-	-	SYM
18637	3628	14	1796	1796	CD
18637	3628	15	,	,	,
18637	3628	16	almost	almost	RB
18637	3628	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3628	18	first	first	JJ
18637	3628	19	act	act	NN
18637	3628	20	was	be	VBD
18637	3628	21	to	to	TO
18637	3628	22	revoke	revoke	VB
18637	3628	23	the	the	DT
18637	3628	24	sale	sale	NN
18637	3628	25	made	make	VBD
18637	3628	26	the	the	DT
18637	3628	27	previous	previous	JJ
18637	3628	28	year	year	NN
18637	3628	29	.	.	.
18637	3629	1	Meantime	meantime	RB
18637	3629	2	,	,	,
18637	3629	3	however	however	RB
18637	3629	4	,	,	,
18637	3629	5	the	the	DT
18637	3629	6	land	land	NN
18637	3629	7	companies	company	NNS
18637	3629	8	had	have	VBD
18637	3629	9	disposed	dispose	VBN
18637	3629	10	of	of	IN
18637	3629	11	several	several	JJ
18637	3629	12	millions	million	NNS
18637	3629	13	of	of	IN
18637	3629	14	acres	acre	NNS
18637	3629	15	of	of	IN
18637	3629	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3629	17	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	3629	18	to	to	IN
18637	3629	19	speculators	speculator	NNS
18637	3629	20	and	and	CC
18637	3629	21	prospective	prospective	JJ
18637	3629	22	settlers	settler	NNS
18637	3629	23	,	,	,
18637	3629	24	and	and	CC
18637	3629	25	following	follow	VBG
18637	3629	26	the	the	DT
18637	3629	27	rescinding	rescinding	JJ
18637	3629	28	act	act	NN
18637	3629	29	some	some	DT
18637	3629	30	of	of	IN
18637	3629	31	these	these	DT
18637	3629	32	took	take	VBD
18637	3629	33	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	3629	34	with	with	IN
18637	3629	35	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	3629	36	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	3629	37	as	as	IN
18637	3629	38	to	to	IN
18637	3629	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3629	40	rights	right	NNS
18637	3629	41	.	.	.
18637	3630	1	In	in	IN
18637	3630	2	an	an	DT
18637	3630	3	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3630	4	which	which	WDT
18637	3630	5	was	be	VBD
18637	3630	6	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	3630	7	known	know	VBN
18637	3630	8	to	to	IN
18637	3630	9	the	the	DT
18637	3630	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3630	11	when	when	WRB
18637	3630	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3630	13	decided	decide	VBD
18637	3630	14	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	3630	15	_	_	NNP
18637	3630	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	3630	17	_	_	NNP
18637	3630	18	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	3630	19	,	,	,
18637	3630	20	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	3630	21	characterized	characterize	VBD
18637	3630	22	the	the	DT
18637	3630	23	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	3630	24	as	as	IN
18637	3630	25	contravening	contravene	VBG
18637	3630	26	"	"	``
18637	3630	27	the	the	DT
18637	3630	28	first	first	JJ
18637	3630	29	principles	principle	NNS
18637	3630	30	of	of	IN
18637	3630	31	natural	natural	JJ
18637	3630	32	justice	justice	NN
18637	3630	33	and	and	CC
18637	3630	34	social	social	JJ
18637	3630	35	policy	policy	NN
18637	3630	36	,	,	,
18637	3630	37	"	"	''
18637	3630	38	especially	especially	RB
18637	3630	39	so	so	RB
18637	3630	40	far	far	RB
18637	3630	41	as	as	IN
18637	3630	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3630	43	was	be	VBD
18637	3630	44	made	make	VBN
18637	3630	45	,	,	,
18637	3630	46	"	"	''
18637	3630	47	to	to	IN
18637	3630	48	the	the	DT
18637	3630	49	prejudice	prejudice	NN
18637	3630	50	*	*	NFP
18637	3630	51	*	*	NFP
18637	3630	52	*	*	NFP
18637	3630	53	of	of	IN
18637	3630	54	third	third	JJ
18637	3630	55	persons	person	NNS
18637	3630	56	*	*	NFP
18637	3630	57	*	*	NFP
18637	3630	58	*	*	NFP
18637	3630	59	innocent	innocent	JJ
18637	3630	60	of	of	IN
18637	3630	61	the	the	DT
18637	3630	62	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	3630	63	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	3630	64	or	or	CC
18637	3630	65	corruption	corruption	NN
18637	3630	66	;	;	,
18637	3630	67	*	*	NFP
18637	3630	68	*	*	NFP
18637	3630	69	*	*	NFP
18637	3630	70	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3630	71	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	3630	72	,	,	,
18637	3630	73	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3630	74	added	add	VBD
18637	3630	75	,	,	,
18637	3630	76	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3630	77	the	the	DT
18637	3630	78	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3630	79	of	of	IN
18637	3630	80	the	the	DT
18637	3630	81	United	United	NNP
18637	3630	82	States	States	NNP
18637	3630	83	,	,	,
18637	3630	84	article	article	NN
18637	3630	85	first	first	RB
18637	3630	86	,	,	,
18637	3630	87	section	section	NN
18637	3630	88	tenth	tenth	NN
18637	3630	89	,	,	,
18637	3630	90	declares	declare	VBZ
18637	3630	91	that	that	IN
18637	3630	92	no	no	DT
18637	3630	93	State	state	NN
18637	3630	94	shall	shall	MD
18637	3630	95	pass	pass	VB
18637	3630	96	a	a	DT
18637	3630	97	law	law	NN
18637	3630	98	impairing	impair	VBG
18637	3630	99	the	the	DT
18637	3630	100	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	3630	101	of	of	IN
18637	3630	102	contract	contract	NN
18637	3630	103	.	.	.
18637	3631	1	This	this	DT
18637	3631	2	must	must	MD
18637	3631	3	be	be	VB
18637	3631	4	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
18637	3631	5	to	to	IN
18637	3631	6	saying	say	VBG
18637	3631	7	no	no	DT
18637	3631	8	State	state	NN
18637	3631	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	3631	10	pass	pass	VB
18637	3631	11	a	a	DT
18637	3631	12	law	law	NN
18637	3631	13	revoking	revoking	NN
18637	3631	14	,	,	,
18637	3631	15	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
18637	3631	16	,	,	,
18637	3631	17	or	or	CC
18637	3631	18	altering	alter	VBG
18637	3631	19	a	a	DT
18637	3631	20	contract	contract	NN
18637	3631	21	.	.	.
18637	3632	1	Every	every	DT
18637	3632	2	grant	grant	NN
18637	3632	3	from	from	IN
18637	3632	4	one	one	CD
18637	3632	5	to	to	IN
18637	3632	6	another	another	DT
18637	3632	7	,	,	,
18637	3632	8	whether	whether	IN
18637	3632	9	the	the	DT
18637	3632	10	grantor	grantor	NN
18637	3632	11	be	be	VB
18637	3632	12	a	a	DT
18637	3632	13	State	state	NN
18637	3632	14	or	or	CC
18637	3632	15	an	an	DT
18637	3632	16	individual	individual	NN
18637	3632	17	,	,	,
18637	3632	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	3632	19	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	3632	20	a	a	DT
18637	3632	21	contract	contract	NN
18637	3632	22	that	that	IN
18637	3632	23	the	the	DT
18637	3632	24	grantee	grantee	NN
18637	3632	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	3632	26	hold	hold	VB
18637	3632	27	and	and	CC
18637	3632	28	enjoy	enjoy	VB
18637	3632	29	the	the	DT
18637	3632	30	thing	thing	NN
18637	3632	31	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3632	32	against	against	IN
18637	3632	33	the	the	DT
18637	3632	34	grantor	grantor	NN
18637	3632	35	,	,	,
18637	3632	36	and	and	CC
18637	3632	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3632	38	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	3632	39	.	.	.
18637	3633	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3633	2	,	,	,
18637	3633	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	3633	4	,	,	,
18637	3633	5	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	3633	6	to	to	IN
18637	3633	7	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3633	8	that	that	IN
18637	3633	9	taking	take	VBG
18637	3633	10	the	the	DT
18637	3633	11	terms	term	NNS
18637	3633	12	of	of	IN
18637	3633	13	the	the	DT
18637	3633	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3633	15	in	in	IN
18637	3633	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3633	17	large	large	JJ
18637	3633	18	sense	sense	NN
18637	3633	19	,	,	,
18637	3633	20	and	and	CC
18637	3633	21	giving	give	VBG
18637	3633	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3633	23	effect	effect	NN
18637	3633	24	according	accord	VBG
18637	3633	25	to	to	IN
18637	3633	26	the	the	DT
18637	3633	27	general	general	NNP
18637	3633	28	spirit	spirit	NN
18637	3633	29	and	and	CC
18637	3633	30	policy	policy	NN
18637	3633	31	of	of	IN
18637	3633	32	the	the	DT
18637	3633	33	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	3633	34	,	,	,
18637	3633	35	the	the	DT
18637	3633	36	revocation	revocation	NN
18637	3633	37	of	of	IN
18637	3633	38	the	the	DT
18637	3633	39	grant	grant	NN
18637	3633	40	by	by	IN
18637	3633	41	the	the	DT
18637	3633	42	act	act	NN
18637	3633	43	of	of	IN
18637	3633	44	the	the	DT
18637	3633	45	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3633	46	of	of	IN
18637	3633	47	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	3633	48	may	may	MD
18637	3633	49	justly	justly	RB
18637	3633	50	be	be	VB
18637	3633	51	considered	consider	VBN
18637	3633	52	as	as	RB
18637	3633	53	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	3633	54	to	to	IN
18637	3633	55	the	the	DT
18637	3633	56	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3633	57	of	of	IN
18637	3633	58	the	the	DT
18637	3633	59	United	United	NNP
18637	3633	60	States	States	NNP
18637	3633	61	,	,	,
18637	3633	62	and	and	CC
18637	3633	63	,	,	,
18637	3633	64	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	3633	65	null	null	JJ
18637	3633	66	.	.	.
18637	3634	1	And	and	CC
18637	3634	2	that	that	IN
18637	3634	3	the	the	DT
18637	3634	4	courts	court	NNS
18637	3634	5	of	of	IN
18637	3634	6	the	the	DT
18637	3634	7	United	United	NNP
18637	3634	8	States	States	NNP
18637	3634	9	,	,	,
18637	3634	10	in	in	IN
18637	3634	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	3634	12	within	within	IN
18637	3634	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3634	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3634	15	,	,	,
18637	3634	16	will	will	MD
18637	3634	17	be	be	VB
18637	3634	18	likely	likely	JJ
18637	3634	19	to	to	TO
18637	3634	20	pronounce	pronounce	VB
18637	3634	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3634	22	so	so	RB
18637	3634	23	.	.	.
18637	3635	1	"	"	``
18637	3635	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3635	3	1612	1612	CD
18637	3635	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3635	5	In	in	IN
18637	3635	6	the	the	DT
18637	3635	7	debate	debate	NN
18637	3635	8	to	to	TO
18637	3635	9	which	which	WDT
18637	3635	10	the	the	DT
18637	3635	11	"	"	``
18637	3635	12	Yazoo	Yazoo	NNP
18637	3635	13	Land	Land	NNP
18637	3635	14	Frauds	Frauds	NNP
18637	3635	15	,	,	,
18637	3635	16	"	"	''
18637	3635	17	as	as	IN
18637	3635	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3635	19	were	be	VBD
18637	3635	20	contemporaneously	contemporaneously	RB
18637	3635	21	known	know	VBN
18637	3635	22	,	,	,
18637	3635	23	gave	give	VBD
18637	3635	24	rise	rise	NN
18637	3635	25	in	in	IN
18637	3635	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3635	27	,	,	,
18637	3635	28	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	3635	29	's	's	POS
18637	3635	30	views	view	NNS
18637	3635	31	were	be	VBD
18637	3635	32	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	3635	33	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	3635	34	.	.	.
18637	3636	1	So	so	RB
18637	3636	2	far	far	RB
18637	3636	3	as	as	IN
18637	3636	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3636	5	invokes	invoke	VBZ
18637	3636	6	the	the	DT
18637	3636	7	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3636	8	of	of	IN
18637	3636	9	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3636	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	3636	11	,	,	,
18637	3636	12	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3636	13	's	's	POS
18637	3636	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3636	15	in	in	IN
18637	3636	16	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	3636	17	_	_	NNP
18637	3636	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	3636	19	_	_	NNP
18637	3636	20	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	3636	21	performs	perform	VBZ
18637	3636	22	two	two	CD
18637	3636	23	creative	creative	JJ
18637	3636	24	acts	act	NNS
18637	3636	25	.	.	.
18637	3637	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3637	2	recognizes	recognize	VBZ
18637	3637	3	that	that	IN
18637	3637	4	an	an	DT
18637	3637	5	obligatory	obligatory	JJ
18637	3637	6	contract	contract	NN
18637	3637	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	3637	8	one	one	CD
18637	3637	9	still	still	RB
18637	3637	10	to	to	TO
18637	3637	11	be	be	VB
18637	3637	12	performed	perform	VBN
18637	3637	13	--	--	:
18637	3637	14	in	in	IN
18637	3637	15	other	other	JJ
18637	3637	16	words	word	NNS
18637	3637	17	,	,	,
18637	3637	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	3637	19	an	an	DT
18637	3637	20	executory	executory	JJ
18637	3637	21	contract	contract	NN
18637	3637	22	;	;	:
18637	3637	23	also	also	RB
18637	3637	24	that	that	IN
18637	3637	25	a	a	DT
18637	3637	26	grant	grant	NN
18637	3637	27	of	of	IN
18637	3637	28	land	land	NN
18637	3637	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	3637	30	an	an	DT
18637	3637	31	executed	execute	VBN
18637	3637	32	contract	contract	NN
18637	3637	33	--	--	:
18637	3637	34	a	a	DT
18637	3637	35	conveyance	conveyance	NN
18637	3637	36	.	.	.
18637	3638	1	But	but	CC
18637	3638	2	,	,	,
18637	3638	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3638	4	asserts	assert	VBZ
18637	3638	5	,	,	,
18637	3638	6	every	every	DT
18637	3638	7	grant	grant	NN
18637	3638	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	3638	9	attended	attend	VBN
18637	3638	10	by	by	IN
18637	3638	11	"	"	``
18637	3638	12	an	an	DT
18637	3638	13	implied	imply	VBN
18637	3638	14	contract	contract	NN
18637	3638	15	"	"	''
18637	3638	16	on	on	IN
18637	3638	17	the	the	DT
18637	3638	18	part	part	NN
18637	3638	19	of	of	IN
18637	3638	20	the	the	DT
18637	3638	21	grantor	grantor	NN
18637	3638	22	not	not	RB
18637	3638	23	to	to	TO
18637	3638	24	claim	claim	VB
18637	3638	25	again	again	RB
18637	3638	26	the	the	DT
18637	3638	27	thing	thing	NN
18637	3638	28	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3638	29	.	.	.
18637	3639	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	3639	2	,	,	,
18637	3639	3	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3639	4	are	be	VBP
18637	3639	5	brought	bring	VBN
18637	3639	6	within	within	IN
18637	3639	7	the	the	DT
18637	3639	8	category	category	NN
18637	3639	9	of	of	IN
18637	3639	10	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3639	11	having	have	VBG
18637	3639	12	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	3639	13	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3639	14	and	and	CC
18637	3639	15	so	so	RB
18637	3639	16	within	within	IN
18637	3639	17	article	article	NN
18637	3639	18	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3639	19	,	,	,
18637	3639	20	§	§	NNP
18637	3639	21	10	10	CD
18637	3639	22	.	.	.
18637	3640	1	But	but	CC
18637	3640	2	the	the	DT
18637	3640	3	question	question	NN
18637	3640	4	still	still	RB
18637	3640	5	remained	remain	VBD
18637	3640	6	of	of	IN
18637	3640	7	the	the	DT
18637	3640	8	nature	nature	NN
18637	3640	9	of	of	IN
18637	3640	10	this	this	DT
18637	3640	11	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3640	12	.	.	.
18637	3641	1	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3641	2	's	's	POS
18637	3641	3	answer	answer	NN
18637	3641	4	to	to	IN
18637	3641	5	this	this	DT
18637	3641	6	can	can	MD
18637	3641	7	only	only	RB
18637	3641	8	be	be	VB
18637	3641	9	inferred	infer	VBN
18637	3641	10	from	from	IN
18637	3641	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3641	12	statement	statement	NN
18637	3641	13	at	at	IN
18637	3641	14	the	the	DT
18637	3641	15	end	end	NN
18637	3641	16	of	of	IN
18637	3641	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3641	18	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3641	19	.	.	.
18637	3642	1	The	the	DT
18637	3642	2	State	State	NNP
18637	3642	3	of	of	IN
18637	3642	4	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	3642	5	,	,	,
18637	3642	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3642	7	says	say	VBZ
18637	3642	8	,	,	,
18637	3642	9	"	"	``
18637	3642	10	was	be	VBD
18637	3642	11	restrained	restrain	VBN
18637	3642	12	"	"	''
18637	3642	13	from	from	IN
18637	3642	14	the	the	DT
18637	3642	15	passing	passing	NN
18637	3642	16	of	of	IN
18637	3642	17	the	the	DT
18637	3642	18	rescinding	rescinding	JJ
18637	3642	19	act	act	NN
18637	3642	20	"	"	''
18637	3642	21	either	either	CC
18637	3642	22	by	by	IN
18637	3642	23	general	general	JJ
18637	3642	24	principles	principle	NNS
18637	3642	25	which	which	WDT
18637	3642	26	are	be	VBP
18637	3642	27	common	common	JJ
18637	3642	28	to	to	IN
18637	3642	29	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3642	30	free	free	JJ
18637	3642	31	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	3642	32	,	,	,
18637	3642	33	or	or	CC
18637	3642	34	by	by	IN
18637	3642	35	particular	particular	JJ
18637	3642	36	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	3642	37	of	of	IN
18637	3642	38	the	the	DT
18637	3642	39	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3642	40	of	of	IN
18637	3642	41	the	the	DT
18637	3642	42	United	United	NNP
18637	3642	43	States	States	NNP
18637	3642	44	.	.	.
18637	3643	1	"	"	``
18637	3643	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3643	3	1613	1613	CD
18637	3643	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3643	5	New	New	NNP
18637	3643	6	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	3643	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3643	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	3643	9	_	_	NNP
18637	3643	10	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	3643	11	The	the	DT
18637	3643	12	protection	protection	NN
18637	3643	13	thus	thus	RB
18637	3643	14	thrown	throw	VBN
18637	3643	15	about	about	IN
18637	3643	16	land	land	NN
18637	3643	17	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3643	18	was	be	VBD
18637	3643	19	presently	presently	RB
18637	3643	20	extended	extend	VBN
18637	3643	21	,	,	,
18637	3643	22	in	in	IN
18637	3643	23	the	the	DT
18637	3643	24	case	case	NN
18637	3643	25	of	of	IN
18637	3643	26	New	New	NNP
18637	3643	27	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	3643	28	_	_	NNP
18637	3643	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	3643	30	_	_	NNP
18637	3643	31	Wilson,[1614	Wilson,[1614	NNP
18637	3643	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3643	33	to	to	IN
18637	3643	34	a	a	DT
18637	3643	35	grant	grant	NN
18637	3643	36	of	of	IN
18637	3643	37	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	3643	38	from	from	IN
18637	3643	39	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3643	40	which	which	WDT
18637	3643	41	the	the	DT
18637	3643	42	State	State	NNP
18637	3643	43	of	of	IN
18637	3643	44	New	New	NNP
18637	3643	45	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	3643	46	had	have	VBD
18637	3643	47	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	3643	48	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3643	49	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	3643	50	lands	land	NNS
18637	3643	51	;	;	:
18637	3643	52	and	and	CC
18637	3643	53	several	several	JJ
18637	3643	54	years	year	NNS
18637	3643	55	after	after	IN
18637	3643	56	that	that	DT
18637	3643	57	,	,	,
18637	3643	58	in	in	IN
18637	3643	59	the	the	DT
18637	3643	60	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	3643	61	College	College	NNP
18637	3643	62	Case,[1615	Case,[1615	NNP
18637	3643	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3643	64	to	to	IN
18637	3643	65	the	the	DT
18637	3643	66	charter	charter	NN
18637	3643	67	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3643	68	of	of	IN
18637	3643	69	an	an	DT
18637	3643	70	eleemosynary	eleemosynary	JJ
18637	3643	71	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3643	72	.	.	.
18637	3644	1	Corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	3644	2	Charters	charter	NNS
18637	3644	3	,	,	,
18637	3644	4	Different	different	JJ
18637	3644	5	Ways	way	NNS
18637	3644	6	of	of	IN
18637	3644	7	Regarding	regard	VBG
18637	3644	8	There	there	EX
18637	3644	9	are	be	VBP
18637	3644	10	three	three	CD
18637	3644	11	ways	way	NNS
18637	3644	12	in	in	IN
18637	3644	13	which	which	WDT
18637	3644	14	the	the	DT
18637	3644	15	charter	charter	NN
18637	3644	16	of	of	IN
18637	3644	17	a	a	DT
18637	3644	18	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3644	19	may	may	MD
18637	3644	20	be	be	VB
18637	3644	21	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	3644	22	.	.	.
18637	3645	1	In	in	IN
18637	3645	2	the	the	DT
18637	3645	3	first	first	JJ
18637	3645	4	place	place	NN
18637	3645	5	,	,	,
18637	3645	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3645	7	may	may	MD
18637	3645	8	be	be	VB
18637	3645	9	thought	think	VBN
18637	3645	10	of	of	IN
18637	3645	11	simply	simply	RB
18637	3645	12	as	as	IN
18637	3645	13	a	a	DT
18637	3645	14	license	license	NN
18637	3645	15	terminable	terminable	NN
18637	3645	16	at	at	IN
18637	3645	17	will	will	NN
18637	3645	18	by	by	IN
18637	3645	19	the	the	DT
18637	3645	20	State	State	NNP
18637	3645	21	,	,	,
18637	3645	22	like	like	IN
18637	3645	23	a	a	DT
18637	3645	24	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	3645	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	3645	26	seller	seller	NN
18637	3645	27	's	's	POS
18637	3645	28	license	license	NN
18637	3645	29	or	or	CC
18637	3645	30	an	an	DT
18637	3645	31	auctioneer	auctioneer	NN
18637	3645	32	's	's	POS
18637	3645	33	license	license	NN
18637	3645	34	,	,	,
18637	3645	35	but	but	CC
18637	3645	36	affording	afford	VBG
18637	3645	37	the	the	DT
18637	3645	38	incorporators	incorporator	NNS
18637	3645	39	,	,	,
18637	3645	40	so	so	RB
18637	3645	41	long	long	RB
18637	3645	42	as	as	IN
18637	3645	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3645	44	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	3645	45	in	in	IN
18637	3645	46	force	force	NN
18637	3645	47	,	,	,
18637	3645	48	the	the	DT
18637	3645	49	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3645	50	and	and	CC
18637	3645	51	advantages	advantage	NNS
18637	3645	52	of	of	IN
18637	3645	53	doing	do	VBG
18637	3645	54	business	business	NN
18637	3645	55	in	in	IN
18637	3645	56	the	the	DT
18637	3645	57	form	form	NN
18637	3645	58	of	of	IN
18637	3645	59	a	a	DT
18637	3645	60	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3645	61	.	.	.
18637	3646	1	Nowadays	nowadays	RB
18637	3646	2	,	,	,
18637	3646	3	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	3646	4	,	,	,
18637	3646	5	when	when	WRB
18637	3646	6	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	3646	7	charters	charter	NNS
18637	3646	8	are	be	VBP
18637	3646	9	usually	usually	RB
18637	3646	10	issued	issue	VBN
18637	3646	11	to	to	IN
18637	3646	12	all	all	DT
18637	3646	13	legally	legally	RB
18637	3646	14	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	3646	15	applicants	applicant	NNS
18637	3646	16	by	by	IN
18637	3646	17	an	an	DT
18637	3646	18	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	3646	19	officer	officer	NN
18637	3646	20	who	who	WP
18637	3646	21	acts	act	VBZ
18637	3646	22	under	under	IN
18637	3646	23	a	a	DT
18637	3646	24	general	general	JJ
18637	3646	25	statute	statute	NN
18637	3646	26	,	,	,
18637	3646	27	this	this	DT
18637	3646	28	would	would	MD
18637	3646	29	probably	probably	RB
18637	3646	30	seem	seem	VB
18637	3646	31	to	to	TO
18637	3646	32	be	be	VB
18637	3646	33	the	the	DT
18637	3646	34	natural	natural	JJ
18637	3646	35	way	way	NN
18637	3646	36	of	of	IN
18637	3646	37	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	3646	38	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3646	39	were	be	VBD
18637	3646	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3646	41	not	not	RB
18637	3646	42	for	for	IN
18637	3646	43	the	the	DT
18637	3646	44	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	3646	45	College	College	NNP
18637	3646	46	decision	decision	NN
18637	3646	47	.	.	.
18637	3647	1	But	but	CC
18637	3647	2	in	in	IN
18637	3647	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	3647	4	charters	charter	NNS
18637	3647	5	were	be	VBD
18637	3647	6	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3647	7	directly	directly	RB
18637	3647	8	by	by	IN
18637	3647	9	the	the	DT
18637	3647	10	State	State	NNP
18637	3647	11	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	3647	12	in	in	IN
18637	3647	13	the	the	DT
18637	3647	14	form	form	NN
18637	3647	15	of	of	IN
18637	3647	16	special	special	JJ
18637	3647	17	acts	act	NNS
18637	3647	18	,	,	,
18637	3647	19	and	and	CC
18637	3647	20	there	there	EX
18637	3647	21	were	be	VBD
18637	3647	22	very	very	RB
18637	3647	23	few	few	JJ
18637	3647	24	profit	profit	NN
18637	3647	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	3647	26	taking	take	VBG
18637	3647	27	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	3647	28	in	in	IN
18637	3647	29	the	the	DT
18637	3647	30	country	country	NN
18637	3647	31	.	.	.
18637	3648	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3648	2	1616	1616	CD
18637	3648	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3648	4	The	the	DT
18637	3648	5	later	later	JJ
18637	3648	6	extension	extension	NN
18637	3648	7	of	of	IN
18637	3648	8	the	the	DT
18637	3648	9	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	3648	10	of	of	IN
18637	3648	11	the	the	DT
18637	3648	12	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	3648	13	College	College	NNP
18637	3648	14	decision	decision	NN
18637	3648	15	to	to	IN
18637	3648	16	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	3648	17	organized	organize	VBN
18637	3648	18	under	under	IN
18637	3648	19	general	general	JJ
18637	3648	20	law	law	NN
18637	3648	21	took	take	VBD
18637	3648	22	place	place	NN
18637	3648	23	without	without	IN
18637	3648	24	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	3648	25	.	.	.
18637	3649	1	Secondly	secondly	RB
18637	3649	2	,	,	,
18637	3649	3	a	a	DT
18637	3649	4	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	3649	5	charter	charter	NN
18637	3649	6	may	may	MD
18637	3649	7	be	be	VB
18637	3649	8	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	3649	9	as	as	IN
18637	3649	10	a	a	DT
18637	3649	11	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	3649	12	constituting	constitute	VBG
18637	3649	13	a	a	DT
18637	3649	14	vested	vested	JJ
18637	3649	15	or	or	CC
18637	3649	16	property	property	NN
18637	3649	17	interest	interest	NN
18637	3649	18	in	in	IN
18637	3649	19	the	the	DT
18637	3649	20	hands	hand	NNS
18637	3649	21	of	of	IN
18637	3649	22	the	the	DT
18637	3649	23	holders	holder	NNS
18637	3649	24	,	,	,
18637	3649	25	and	and	CC
18637	3649	26	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	3649	27	as	as	IN
18637	3649	28	forfeitable	forfeitable	JJ
18637	3649	29	only	only	RB
18637	3649	30	for	for	IN
18637	3649	31	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	3649	32	or	or	CC
18637	3649	33	in	in	IN
18637	3649	34	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	3649	35	with	with	IN
18637	3649	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3649	37	own	own	JJ
18637	3649	38	terms	term	NNS
18637	3649	39	.	.	.
18637	3650	1	This	this	DT
18637	3650	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	3650	3	the	the	DT
18637	3650	4	way	way	NN
18637	3650	5	in	in	IN
18637	3650	6	which	which	WDT
18637	3650	7	some	some	DT
18637	3650	8	of	of	IN
18637	3650	9	the	the	DT
18637	3650	10	early	early	JJ
18637	3650	11	State	State	NNP
18637	3650	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	3650	13	did	do	VBD
18637	3650	14	regard	regard	VB
18637	3650	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3650	16	at	at	IN
18637	3650	17	the	the	DT
18637	3650	18	outset	outset	NN
18637	3650	19	.	.	.
18637	3651	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3651	2	1617	1617	CD
18637	3651	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3651	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3651	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	3651	6	also	also	RB
18637	3651	7	the	the	DT
18637	3651	8	way	way	NN
18637	3651	9	in	in	IN
18637	3651	10	which	which	WDT
18637	3651	11	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
18637	3651	12	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	3651	13	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3651	14	in	in	IN
18637	3651	15	relation	relation	NN
18637	3651	16	to	to	IN
18637	3651	17	the	the	DT
18637	3651	18	royal	royal	NN
18637	3651	19	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	3651	20	,	,	,
18637	3651	21	although	although	IN
18637	3651	22	not	not	RB
18637	3651	23	in	in	IN
18637	3651	24	relation	relation	NN
18637	3651	25	to	to	IN
18637	3651	26	the	the	DT
18637	3651	27	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	3651	28	of	of	IN
18637	3651	29	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
18637	3651	30	;	;	:
18637	3651	31	and	and	CC
18637	3651	32	the	the	DT
18637	3651	33	same	same	JJ
18637	3651	34	point	point	NN
18637	3651	35	of	of	IN
18637	3651	36	view	view	NN
18637	3651	37	finds	find	VBZ
18637	3651	38	expression	expression	NN
18637	3651	39	in	in	IN
18637	3651	40	Story	Story	NNP
18637	3651	41	's	's	POS
18637	3651	42	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	3651	43	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3651	44	in	in	IN
18637	3651	45	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	3651	46	College	College	NNP
18637	3651	47	_	_	NNP
18637	3651	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	3651	49	_	_	NNP
18637	3651	50	Woodward	Woodward	NNP
18637	3651	51	,	,	,
18637	3651	52	as	as	IN
18637	3651	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3651	54	did	do	VBD
18637	3651	55	also	also	RB
18637	3651	56	in	in	IN
18637	3651	57	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	3651	58	's	's	POS
18637	3651	59	argument	argument	NN
18637	3651	60	in	in	IN
18637	3651	61	that	that	DT
18637	3651	62	case	case	NN
18637	3651	63	.	.	.
18637	3652	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3652	2	1618	1618	CD
18637	3652	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3652	4	The	the	DT
18637	3652	5	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	3652	6	College	College	NNP
18637	3652	7	Case	Case	NNP
18637	3652	8	The	the	DT
18637	3652	9	third	third	JJ
18637	3652	10	view	view	NN
18637	3652	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	3652	12	the	the	DT
18637	3652	13	one	one	CD
18637	3652	14	formulated	formulate	VBN
18637	3652	15	by	by	IN
18637	3652	16	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3652	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3652	18	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3652	19	in	in	IN
18637	3652	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3652	21	controlling	control	VBG
18637	3652	22	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3652	23	in	in	IN
18637	3652	24	Trustees	Trustees	NNP
18637	3652	25	of	of	IN
18637	3652	26	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	3652	27	College	College	NNP
18637	3652	28	_	_	NNP
18637	3652	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	3652	30	_	_	NNP
18637	3652	31	Woodward	Woodward	NNP
18637	3652	32	.	.	.
18637	3653	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3653	2	1619	1619	CD
18637	3653	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3653	4	This	this	DT
18637	3653	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	3653	6	that	that	IN
18637	3653	7	the	the	DT
18637	3653	8	charter	charter	NN
18637	3653	9	of	of	IN
18637	3653	10	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	3653	11	College	College	NNP
18637	3653	12	,	,	,
18637	3653	13	a	a	DT
18637	3653	14	purely	purely	RB
18637	3653	15	private	private	JJ
18637	3653	16	institution	institution	NN
18637	3653	17	,	,	,
18637	3653	18	was	be	VBD
18637	3653	19	the	the	DT
18637	3653	20	outcome	outcome	NN
18637	3653	21	and	and	CC
18637	3653	22	partial	partial	JJ
18637	3653	23	record	record	NN
18637	3653	24	of	of	IN
18637	3653	25	a	a	DT
18637	3653	26	contract	contract	NN
18637	3653	27	between	between	IN
18637	3653	28	the	the	DT
18637	3653	29	donors	donor	NNS
18637	3653	30	of	of	IN
18637	3653	31	the	the	DT
18637	3653	32	college	college	NN
18637	3653	33	,	,	,
18637	3653	34	on	on	IN
18637	3653	35	the	the	DT
18637	3653	36	one	one	CD
18637	3653	37	hand	hand	NN
18637	3653	38	,	,	,
18637	3653	39	and	and	CC
18637	3653	40	the	the	DT
18637	3653	41	British	British	NNP
18637	3653	42	Crown	Crown	NNP
18637	3653	43	,	,	,
18637	3653	44	on	on	IN
18637	3653	45	the	the	DT
18637	3653	46	other	other	JJ
18637	3653	47	,	,	,
18637	3653	48	which	which	WDT
18637	3653	49	contract	contract	NN
18637	3653	50	still	still	RB
18637	3653	51	continued	continue	VBD
18637	3653	52	in	in	IN
18637	3653	53	force	force	NN
18637	3653	54	between	between	IN
18637	3653	55	the	the	DT
18637	3653	56	State	State	NNP
18637	3653	57	of	of	IN
18637	3653	58	New	New	NNP
18637	3653	59	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	3653	60	,	,	,
18637	3653	61	as	as	IN
18637	3653	62	the	the	DT
18637	3653	63	successor	successor	NN
18637	3653	64	to	to	IN
18637	3653	65	the	the	DT
18637	3653	66	Crown	Crown	NNP
18637	3653	67	and	and	CC
18637	3653	68	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3653	69	of	of	IN
18637	3653	70	Great	Great	NNP
18637	3653	71	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	3653	72	,	,	,
18637	3653	73	and	and	CC
18637	3653	74	the	the	DT
18637	3653	75	trustees	trustee	NNS
18637	3653	76	,	,	,
18637	3653	77	as	as	IN
18637	3653	78	successors	successor	NNS
18637	3653	79	to	to	IN
18637	3653	80	the	the	DT
18637	3653	81	donors	donor	NNS
18637	3653	82	.	.	.
18637	3654	1	The	the	DT
18637	3654	2	charter	charter	NN
18637	3654	3	,	,	,
18637	3654	4	in	in	IN
18637	3654	5	other	other	JJ
18637	3654	6	words	word	NNS
18637	3654	7	,	,	,
18637	3654	8	was	be	VBD
18637	3654	9	not	not	RB
18637	3654	10	simply	simply	RB
18637	3654	11	a	a	DT
18637	3654	12	grant	grant	NN
18637	3654	13	--	--	:
18637	3654	14	rather	rather	RB
18637	3654	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3654	16	was	be	VBD
18637	3654	17	the	the	DT
18637	3654	18	documentary	documentary	JJ
18637	3654	19	record	record	NN
18637	3654	20	of	of	IN
18637	3654	21	a	a	DT
18637	3654	22	still	still	RB
18637	3654	23	existent	existent	NN
18637	3654	24	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3654	25	between	between	IN
18637	3654	26	still	still	RB
18637	3654	27	existent	existent	NN
18637	3654	28	parties	party	NNS
18637	3654	29	.	.	.
18637	3655	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3655	2	1620	1620	CD
18637	3655	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3655	4	Taking	take	VBG
18637	3655	5	this	this	DT
18637	3655	6	view	view	NN
18637	3655	7	,	,	,
18637	3655	8	which	which	WDT
18637	3655	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3655	10	developed	develop	VBD
18637	3655	11	with	with	IN
18637	3655	12	great	great	JJ
18637	3655	13	ingenuity	ingenuity	NN
18637	3655	14	and	and	CC
18637	3655	15	persuasiveness	persuasiveness	NN
18637	3655	16	,	,	,
18637	3655	17	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3655	18	was	be	VBD
18637	3655	19	able	able	JJ
18637	3655	20	to	to	TO
18637	3655	21	appeal	appeal	VB
18637	3655	22	to	to	IN
18637	3655	23	the	the	DT
18637	3655	24	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3655	25	of	of	IN
18637	3655	26	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3655	27	clause	clause	NN
18637	3655	28	directly	directly	RB
18637	3655	29	,	,	,
18637	3655	30	and	and	CC
18637	3655	31	without	without	IN
18637	3655	32	further	further	JJ
18637	3655	33	use	use	NN
18637	3655	34	of	of	IN
18637	3655	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3655	36	fiction	fiction	NN
18637	3655	37	in	in	IN
18637	3655	38	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	3655	39	_	_	NNP
18637	3655	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	3655	41	_	_	NNP
18637	3655	42	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	3655	43	of	of	IN
18637	3655	44	an	an	DT
18637	3655	45	executory	executory	JJ
18637	3655	46	contract	contract	NN
18637	3655	47	accompanying	accompany	VBG
18637	3655	48	the	the	DT
18637	3655	49	grant	grant	NN
18637	3655	50	.	.	.
18637	3656	1	A	a	DT
18637	3656	2	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	3656	3	still	still	RB
18637	3656	4	remained	remain	VBD
18637	3656	5	,	,	,
18637	3656	6	however	however	RB
18637	3656	7	,	,	,
18637	3656	8	in	in	IN
18637	3656	9	the	the	DT
18637	3656	10	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	3656	11	that	that	IN
18637	3656	12	a	a	DT
18637	3656	13	contract	contract	NN
18637	3656	14	must	must	MD
18637	3656	15	,	,	,
18637	3656	16	before	before	IN
18637	3656	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3656	18	can	can	MD
18637	3656	19	have	have	VB
18637	3656	20	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3656	21	,	,	,
18637	3656	22	import	import	NN
18637	3656	23	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	3656	24	,	,	,
18637	3656	25	that	that	DT
18637	3656	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	3656	27	to	to	TO
18637	3656	28	say	say	VB
18637	3656	29	,	,	,
18637	3656	30	must	must	MD
18637	3656	31	be	be	VB
18637	3656	32	shown	show	VBN
18637	3656	33	not	not	RB
18637	3656	34	to	to	TO
18637	3656	35	have	have	VB
18637	3656	36	been	be	VBN
18637	3656	37	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	3656	38	gratuitous	gratuitous	JJ
18637	3656	39	on	on	IN
18637	3656	40	either	either	DT
18637	3656	41	side	side	NN
18637	3656	42	.	.	.
18637	3657	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	3657	2	was	be	VBD
18637	3657	3	the	the	DT
18637	3657	4	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	3657	5	which	which	WDT
18637	3657	6	induced	induce	VBD
18637	3657	7	the	the	DT
18637	3657	8	Crown	Crown	NNP
18637	3657	9	to	to	TO
18637	3657	10	grant	grant	VB
18637	3657	11	a	a	DT
18637	3657	12	charter	charter	NN
18637	3657	13	to	to	IN
18637	3657	14	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	3657	15	College	College	NNP
18637	3657	16	a	a	DT
18637	3657	17	merely	merely	RB
18637	3657	18	speculative	speculative	JJ
18637	3657	19	one	one	CD
18637	3657	20	.	.	.
18637	3658	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3658	2	consisted	consist	VBD
18637	3658	3	of	of	IN
18637	3658	4	the	the	DT
18637	3658	5	donations	donation	NNS
18637	3658	6	of	of	IN
18637	3658	7	the	the	DT
18637	3658	8	donors	donor	NNS
18637	3658	9	to	to	IN
18637	3658	10	the	the	DT
18637	3658	11	important	important	JJ
18637	3658	12	public	public	JJ
18637	3658	13	interest	interest	NN
18637	3658	14	of	of	IN
18637	3658	15	education	education	NN
18637	3658	16	.	.	.
18637	3659	1	Fortunately	fortunately	RB
18637	3659	2	or	or	CC
18637	3659	3	unfortunately	unfortunately	RB
18637	3659	4	,	,	,
18637	3659	5	in	in	IN
18637	3659	6	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	3659	7	with	with	IN
18637	3659	8	this	this	DT
18637	3659	9	phase	phase	NN
18637	3659	10	of	of	IN
18637	3659	11	the	the	DT
18637	3659	12	case	case	NN
18637	3659	13	,	,	,
18637	3659	14	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3659	15	used	use	VBD
18637	3659	16	more	more	RBR
18637	3659	17	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	3659	18	terms	term	NNS
18637	3659	19	than	than	IN
18637	3659	20	were	be	VBD
18637	3659	21	needful	needful	JJ
18637	3659	22	.	.	.
18637	3660	1	"	"	``
18637	3660	2	The	the	DT
18637	3660	3	objects	object	NNS
18637	3660	4	for	for	IN
18637	3660	5	which	which	WDT
18637	3660	6	a	a	DT
18637	3660	7	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3660	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	3660	9	created	create	VBN
18637	3660	10	,	,	,
18637	3660	11	"	"	''
18637	3660	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3660	13	wrote	write	VBD
18637	3660	14	,	,	,
18637	3660	15	"	"	``
18637	3660	16	are	be	VBP
18637	3660	17	universally	universally	RB
18637	3660	18	such	such	JJ
18637	3660	19	as	as	IN
18637	3660	20	the	the	DT
18637	3660	21	government	government	NN
18637	3660	22	wishes	wish	VBZ
18637	3660	23	to	to	TO
18637	3660	24	promote	promote	VB
18637	3660	25	.	.	.
18637	3661	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3661	2	are	be	VBP
18637	3661	3	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	3661	4	beneficial	beneficial	JJ
18637	3661	5	to	to	IN
18637	3661	6	the	the	DT
18637	3661	7	country	country	NN
18637	3661	8	;	;	:
18637	3661	9	and	and	CC
18637	3661	10	this	this	DT
18637	3661	11	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	3661	12	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	3661	13	the	the	DT
18637	3661	14	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	3661	15	,	,	,
18637	3661	16	and	and	CC
18637	3661	17	in	in	IN
18637	3661	18	most	most	JJS
18637	3661	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	3661	20	,	,	,
18637	3661	21	the	the	DT
18637	3661	22	sole	sole	JJ
18637	3661	23	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	3661	24	of	of	IN
18637	3661	25	the	the	DT
18637	3661	26	grant	grant	NN
18637	3661	27	.	.	.
18637	3661	28	"	"	''
18637	3662	1	In	in	IN
18637	3662	2	other	other	JJ
18637	3662	3	words	word	NNS
18637	3662	4	,	,	,
18637	3662	5	the	the	DT
18637	3662	6	simple	simple	JJ
18637	3662	7	fact	fact	NN
18637	3662	8	of	of	IN
18637	3662	9	the	the	DT
18637	3662	10	charter	charter	NN
18637	3662	11	having	have	VBG
18637	3662	12	been	be	VBN
18637	3662	13	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3662	14	imports	import	NNS
18637	3662	15	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	3662	16	from	from	IN
18637	3662	17	the	the	DT
18637	3662	18	point	point	NN
18637	3662	19	of	of	IN
18637	3662	20	view	view	NN
18637	3662	21	of	of	IN
18637	3662	22	the	the	DT
18637	3662	23	State	State	NNP
18637	3662	24	.	.	.
18637	3663	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3663	2	1621	1621	CD
18637	3663	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3663	4	With	with	IN
18637	3663	5	this	this	DT
18637	3663	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3663	7	before	before	IN
18637	3663	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3663	9	,	,	,
18637	3663	10	the	the	DT
18637	3663	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3663	12	in	in	IN
18637	3663	13	Providence	Providence	NNP
18637	3663	14	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	3663	15	_	_	NNP
18637	3663	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	3663	17	_	_	NNP
18637	3663	18	Billings,[1622	Billings,[1622	NNP
18637	3663	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3663	20	and	and	CC
18637	3663	21	again	again	RB
18637	3663	22	in	in	IN
18637	3663	23	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	3663	24	River	River	NNP
18637	3663	25	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	3663	26	Company	Company	NNP
18637	3663	27	_	_	NNP
18637	3663	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	3663	29	_	_	NNP
18637	3663	30	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	3663	31	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	3663	32	Company,[1623	company,[1623	CD
18637	3663	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3663	34	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	3663	35	,	,	,
18637	3663	36	without	without	IN
18637	3663	37	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	3663	38	of	of	IN
18637	3663	39	the	the	DT
18637	3663	40	point	point	NN
18637	3663	41	,	,	,
18637	3663	42	the	the	DT
18637	3663	43	applicability	applicability	NN
18637	3663	44	of	of	IN
18637	3663	45	the	the	DT
18637	3663	46	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	3663	47	College	College	NNP
18637	3663	48	decision	decision	NN
18637	3663	49	to	to	TO
18637	3663	50	purely	purely	RB
18637	3663	51	business	business	VB
18637	3663	52	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	3663	53	.	.	.
18637	3664	1	Classes	class	NNS
18637	3664	2	of	of	IN
18637	3664	3	Cases	case	NNS
18637	3664	4	Under	under	IN
18637	3664	5	the	the	DT
18637	3664	6	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3664	7	The	the	DT
18637	3664	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	3664	9	just	just	RB
18637	3664	10	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	3664	11	produce	produce	NN
18637	3664	12	two	two	CD
18637	3664	13	principal	principal	JJ
18637	3664	14	lines	line	NNS
18637	3664	15	of	of	IN
18637	3664	16	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3664	17	stemming	stem	VBG
18637	3664	18	from	from	IN
18637	3664	19	the	the	DT
18637	3664	20	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3664	21	of	of	IN
18637	3664	22	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3664	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	3664	24	:	:	:
18637	3664	25	first	first	JJ
18637	3664	26	,	,	,
18637	3664	27	public	public	JJ
18637	3664	28	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3664	29	;	;	:
18637	3664	30	second	second	JJ
18637	3664	31	,	,	,
18637	3664	32	private	private	JJ
18637	3664	33	executory	executory	JJ
18637	3664	34	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3664	35	.	.	.
18637	3665	1	The	the	DT
18637	3665	2	chief	chief	JJ
18637	3665	3	category	category	NN
18637	3665	4	of	of	IN
18637	3665	5	the	the	DT
18637	3665	6	first	first	JJ
18637	3665	7	line	line	NN
18637	3665	8	of	of	IN
18637	3665	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	3665	10	consists	consist	VBZ
18637	3665	11	,	,	,
18637	3665	12	in	in	IN
18637	3665	13	turn	turn	NN
18637	3665	14	,	,	,
18637	3665	15	of	of	IN
18637	3665	16	those	those	DT
18637	3665	17	involving	involve	VBG
18637	3665	18	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	3665	19	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3665	20	,	,	,
18637	3665	21	both	both	CC
18637	3665	22	those	those	DT
18637	3665	23	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3665	24	directly	directly	RB
18637	3665	25	by	by	IN
18637	3665	26	the	the	DT
18637	3665	27	States	States	NNPS
18637	3665	28	and	and	CC
18637	3665	29	those	those	DT
18637	3665	30	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3665	31	by	by	IN
18637	3665	32	municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	3665	33	by	by	IN
18637	3665	34	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	3665	35	of	of	IN
18637	3665	36	authority	authority	NN
18637	3665	37	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	3665	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	3665	39	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3665	40	by	by	IN
18637	3665	41	the	the	DT
18637	3665	42	State;[1624	state;[1624	NN
18637	3665	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3665	44	while	while	IN
18637	3665	45	private	private	JJ
18637	3665	46	debts	debt	NNS
18637	3665	47	,	,	,
18637	3665	48	inclusive	inclusive	JJ
18637	3665	49	of	of	IN
18637	3665	50	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	3665	51	debts	debt	NNS
18637	3665	52	,	,	,
18637	3665	53	exhaust	exhaust	VBN
18637	3665	54	for	for	IN
18637	3665	55	the	the	DT
18637	3665	56	most	most	JJS
18637	3665	57	part	part	NN
18637	3665	58	the	the	DT
18637	3665	59	second	second	JJ
18637	3665	60	line	line	NN
18637	3665	61	.	.	.
18637	3666	1	Public	Public	NNP
18637	3666	2	Grants	Grants	NNPS
18637	3666	3	Municipal	Municipal	NNP
18637	3666	4	Corporations.--Not	corporations.--not	VB
18637	3666	5	all	all	DT
18637	3666	6	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3666	7	by	by	IN
18637	3666	8	a	a	DT
18637	3666	9	State	state	NN
18637	3666	10	constitute	constitute	NN
18637	3666	11	"	"	``
18637	3666	12	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3666	13	"	"	''
18637	3666	14	within	within	IN
18637	3666	15	the	the	DT
18637	3666	16	sense	sense	NN
18637	3666	17	of	of	IN
18637	3666	18	article	article	NN
18637	3666	19	I	i	NN
18637	3666	20	,	,	,
18637	3666	21	section	section	NN
18637	3666	22	10	10	CD
18637	3666	23	.	.	.
18637	3667	1	In	in	IN
18637	3667	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3667	3	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	3667	4	College	College	NNP
18637	3667	5	decision	decision	NN
18637	3667	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3667	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3667	8	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3667	9	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	3667	10	that	that	IN
18637	3667	11	"	"	``
18637	3667	12	if	if	IN
18637	3667	13	the	the	DT
18637	3667	14	act	act	NN
18637	3667	15	of	of	IN
18637	3667	16	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	3667	17	be	be	VB
18637	3667	18	a	a	DT
18637	3667	19	grant	grant	NN
18637	3667	20	of	of	IN
18637	3667	21	political	political	JJ
18637	3667	22	power	power	NN
18637	3667	23	,	,	,
18637	3667	24	if	if	IN
18637	3667	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3667	26	creates	create	VBZ
18637	3667	27	a	a	DT
18637	3667	28	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3667	29	institution	institution	NN
18637	3667	30	,	,	,
18637	3667	31	to	to	TO
18637	3667	32	be	be	VB
18637	3667	33	employed	employ	VBN
18637	3667	34	in	in	IN
18637	3667	35	the	the	DT
18637	3667	36	administration	administration	NN
18637	3667	37	of	of	IN
18637	3667	38	the	the	DT
18637	3667	39	government	government	NN
18637	3667	40	,	,	,
18637	3667	41	*	*	NFP
18637	3667	42	*	*	NFP
18637	3667	43	*	*	NFP
18637	3667	44	,	,	,
18637	3667	45	the	the	DT
18637	3667	46	subject	subject	NN
18637	3667	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	3667	48	one	one	CD
18637	3667	49	in	in	IN
18637	3667	50	which	which	WDT
18637	3667	51	the	the	DT
18637	3667	52	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3667	53	of	of	IN
18637	3667	54	the	the	DT
18637	3667	55	State	State	NNP
18637	3667	56	may	may	MD
18637	3667	57	act	act	VB
18637	3667	58	according	accord	VBG
18637	3667	59	to	to	IN
18637	3667	60	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3667	61	own	own	JJ
18637	3667	62	justment	justment	NN
18637	3667	63	,	,	,
18637	3667	64	"	"	''
18637	3667	65	unrestrained	unrestrained	JJ
18637	3667	66	by	by	IN
18637	3667	67	the	the	DT
18637	3667	68	Constitution[1625]--thereby	Constitution[1625]--thereby	NNP
18637	3667	69	drawing	draw	VBG
18637	3667	70	a	a	DT
18637	3667	71	line	line	NN
18637	3667	72	between	between	IN
18637	3667	73	"	"	``
18637	3667	74	public	public	JJ
18637	3667	75	"	"	''
18637	3667	76	and	and	CC
18637	3667	77	"	"	``
18637	3667	78	private	private	JJ
18637	3667	79	"	"	''
18637	3667	80	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	3667	81	which	which	WDT
18637	3667	82	remained	remain	VBD
18637	3667	83	undisturbed	undisturbed	JJ
18637	3667	84	for	for	IN
18637	3667	85	more	more	JJR
18637	3667	86	than	than	IN
18637	3667	87	half	half	PDT
18637	3667	88	a	a	DT
18637	3667	89	century	century	NN
18637	3667	90	.	.	.
18637	3668	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3668	2	1626	1626	CD
18637	3668	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3668	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3668	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	3668	6	been	be	VBN
18637	3668	7	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	3668	8	held	hold	VBN
18637	3668	9	many	many	JJ
18637	3668	10	times	time	NNS
18637	3668	11	that	that	IN
18637	3668	12	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	3668	13	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	3668	14	are	be	VBP
18637	3668	15	mere	mere	JJ
18637	3668	16	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	3668	17	of	of	IN
18637	3668	18	the	the	DT
18637	3668	19	State	State	NNP
18637	3668	20	for	for	IN
18637	3668	21	the	the	DT
18637	3668	22	more	more	RBR
18637	3668	23	convenient	convenient	JJ
18637	3668	24	administration	administration	NN
18637	3668	25	of	of	IN
18637	3668	26	local	local	JJ
18637	3668	27	governments	government	NNS
18637	3668	28	,	,	,
18637	3668	29	whose	whose	WP$
18637	3668	30	powers	power	NNS
18637	3668	31	may	may	MD
18637	3668	32	be	be	VB
18637	3668	33	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
18637	3668	34	,	,	,
18637	3668	35	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	3668	36	,	,	,
18637	3668	37	or	or	CC
18637	3668	38	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	3668	39	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	3668	40	at	at	IN
18637	3668	41	the	the	DT
18637	3668	42	pleasure	pleasure	NN
18637	3668	43	of	of	IN
18637	3668	44	the	the	DT
18637	3668	45	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3668	46	.	.	.
18637	3669	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3669	2	1627	1627	CD
18637	3669	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3669	4	The	the	DT
18637	3669	5	same	same	JJ
18637	3669	6	principle	principle	NN
18637	3669	7	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	3669	8	,	,	,
18637	3669	9	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	3669	10	,	,	,
18637	3669	11	to	to	IN
18637	3669	12	the	the	DT
18637	3669	13	property	property	NN
18637	3669	14	rights	right	NNS
18637	3669	15	which	which	WDT
18637	3669	16	the	the	DT
18637	3669	17	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	3669	18	derives	derive	VBZ
18637	3669	19	either	either	CC
18637	3669	20	directly	directly	RB
18637	3669	21	or	or	CC
18637	3669	22	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	3669	23	from	from	IN
18637	3669	24	the	the	DT
18637	3669	25	State	State	NNP
18637	3669	26	.	.	.
18637	3670	1	This	this	DT
18637	3670	2	was	be	VBD
18637	3670	3	first	first	RB
18637	3670	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	3670	5	as	as	IN
18637	3670	6	to	to	IN
18637	3670	7	the	the	DT
18637	3670	8	grant	grant	NN
18637	3670	9	of	of	IN
18637	3670	10	a	a	DT
18637	3670	11	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	3670	12	to	to	IN
18637	3670	13	a	a	DT
18637	3670	14	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	3670	15	to	to	TO
18637	3670	16	operate	operate	VB
18637	3670	17	a	a	DT
18637	3670	18	ferry	ferry	NN
18637	3670	19	,	,	,
18637	3670	20	and	and	CC
18637	3670	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	3670	22	since	since	IN
18637	3670	23	then	then	RB
18637	3670	24	been	be	VBN
18637	3670	25	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	3670	26	as	as	IN
18637	3670	27	the	the	DT
18637	3670	28	universal	universal	JJ
18637	3670	29	rule	rule	NN
18637	3670	30	.	.	.
18637	3671	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3671	2	1628	1628	CD
18637	3671	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3671	4	As	as	IN
18637	3671	5	was	be	VBD
18637	3671	6	stated	state	VBN
18637	3671	7	in	in	IN
18637	3671	8	a	a	DT
18637	3671	9	case	case	NN
18637	3671	10	decided	decide	VBN
18637	3671	11	in	in	IN
18637	3671	12	1923	1923	CD
18637	3671	13	:	:	:
18637	3671	14	"	"	``
18637	3671	15	The	the	DT
18637	3671	16	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	3671	17	between	between	IN
18637	3671	18	the	the	DT
18637	3671	19	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	3671	20	as	as	IN
18637	3671	21	an	an	DT
18637	3671	22	agent	agent	NN
18637	3671	23	of	of	IN
18637	3671	24	the	the	DT
18637	3671	25	State	State	NNP
18637	3671	26	for	for	IN
18637	3671	27	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	3671	28	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	3671	29	and	and	CC
18637	3671	30	as	as	IN
18637	3671	31	an	an	DT
18637	3671	32	organization	organization	NN
18637	3671	33	to	to	TO
18637	3671	34	care	care	VB
18637	3671	35	for	for	IN
18637	3671	36	local	local	JJ
18637	3671	37	needs	need	NNS
18637	3671	38	in	in	IN
18637	3671	39	a	a	DT
18637	3671	40	private	private	JJ
18637	3671	41	or	or	CC
18637	3671	42	proprietary	proprietary	JJ
18637	3671	43	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	3671	44	,	,	,
18637	3671	45	"	"	''
18637	3671	46	while	while	IN
18637	3671	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3671	48	limits	limit	VBZ
18637	3671	49	the	the	DT
18637	3671	50	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3671	51	liability	liability	NN
18637	3671	52	of	of	IN
18637	3671	53	municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	3671	54	for	for	IN
18637	3671	55	the	the	DT
18637	3671	56	negligent	negligent	JJ
18637	3671	57	acts	act	NNS
18637	3671	58	or	or	CC
18637	3671	59	omissions	omission	NNS
18637	3671	60	of	of	IN
18637	3671	61	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3671	62	officers	officer	NNS
18637	3671	63	or	or	CC
18637	3671	64	agents	agent	NNS
18637	3671	65	,	,	,
18637	3671	66	does	do	VBZ
18637	3671	67	not	not	RB
18637	3671	68	,	,	,
18637	3671	69	on	on	IN
18637	3671	70	the	the	DT
18637	3671	71	other	other	JJ
18637	3671	72	hand	hand	NN
18637	3671	73	,	,	,
18637	3671	74	furnish	furnish	JJ
18637	3671	75	ground	ground	NN
18637	3671	76	for	for	IN
18637	3671	77	the	the	DT
18637	3671	78	application	application	NN
18637	3671	79	of	of	IN
18637	3671	80	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3671	81	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	3671	82	against	against	IN
18637	3671	83	the	the	DT
18637	3671	84	State	State	NNP
18637	3671	85	in	in	IN
18637	3671	86	favor	favor	NN
18637	3671	87	of	of	IN
18637	3671	88	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3671	89	own	own	JJ
18637	3671	90	municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	3671	91	.	.	.
18637	3672	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3672	2	1629	1629	CD
18637	3672	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3672	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	3672	5	no	no	DT
18637	3672	6	contract	contract	NN
18637	3672	7	rights	right	NNS
18637	3672	8	are	be	VBP
18637	3672	9	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	3672	10	by	by	IN
18637	3672	11	a	a	DT
18637	3672	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	3672	13	removing	remove	VBG
18637	3672	14	a	a	DT
18637	3672	15	county	county	NN
18637	3672	16	seat	seat	NN
18637	3672	17	,	,	,
18637	3672	18	even	even	RB
18637	3672	19	though	though	IN
18637	3672	20	the	the	DT
18637	3672	21	former	former	JJ
18637	3672	22	location	location	NN
18637	3672	23	was	be	VBD
18637	3672	24	by	by	IN
18637	3672	25	law	law	NN
18637	3672	26	to	to	TO
18637	3672	27	be	be	VB
18637	3672	28	"	"	``
18637	3672	29	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	3672	30	"	"	''
18637	3672	31	when	when	WRB
18637	3672	32	the	the	DT
18637	3672	33	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	3672	34	of	of	IN
18637	3672	35	the	the	DT
18637	3672	36	community	community	NN
18637	3672	37	had	have	VBD
18637	3672	38	donated	donate	VBN
18637	3672	39	land	land	NN
18637	3672	40	and	and	CC
18637	3672	41	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	3672	42	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	3672	43	for	for	IN
18637	3672	44	the	the	DT
18637	3672	45	erection	erection	NN
18637	3672	46	of	of	IN
18637	3672	47	public	public	JJ
18637	3672	48	buildings	building	NNS
18637	3672	49	.	.	.
18637	3673	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3673	2	1630	1630	CD
18637	3673	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3673	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	3673	5	a	a	DT
18637	3673	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	3673	7	changing	change	VBG
18637	3673	8	the	the	DT
18637	3673	9	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	3673	10	of	of	IN
18637	3673	11	a	a	DT
18637	3673	12	school	school	NN
18637	3673	13	district	district	NN
18637	3673	14	,	,	,
18637	3673	15	giving	give	VBG
18637	3673	16	to	to	IN
18637	3673	17	the	the	DT
18637	3673	18	new	new	JJ
18637	3673	19	district	district	NN
18637	3673	20	the	the	DT
18637	3673	21	property	property	NN
18637	3673	22	within	within	IN
18637	3673	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3673	24	limits	limit	NNS
18637	3673	25	which	which	WDT
18637	3673	26	had	have	VBD
18637	3673	27	belonged	belong	VBN
18637	3673	28	to	to	IN
18637	3673	29	the	the	DT
18637	3673	30	former	former	JJ
18637	3673	31	district	district	NN
18637	3673	32	,	,	,
18637	3673	33	and	and	CC
18637	3673	34	requiring	require	VBG
18637	3673	35	the	the	DT
18637	3673	36	new	new	JJ
18637	3673	37	district	district	NN
18637	3673	38	to	to	TO
18637	3673	39	assume	assume	VB
18637	3673	40	the	the	DT
18637	3673	41	debts	debt	NNS
18637	3673	42	of	of	IN
18637	3673	43	the	the	DT
18637	3673	44	old	old	JJ
18637	3673	45	district	district	NN
18637	3673	46	,	,	,
18637	3673	47	does	do	VBZ
18637	3673	48	not	not	RB
18637	3673	49	impair	impair	VB
18637	3673	50	the	the	DT
18637	3673	51	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3673	52	of	of	IN
18637	3673	53	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3673	54	.	.	.
18637	3674	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3674	2	1631	1631	CD
18637	3674	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3674	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	3674	5	was	be	VBD
18637	3674	6	the	the	DT
18637	3674	7	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3674	8	clause	clause	NN
18637	3674	9	violated	violate	VBN
18637	3674	10	by	by	IN
18637	3674	11	State	State	NNP
18637	3674	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3674	13	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	3674	14	State	state	NN
18637	3674	15	control	control	NN
18637	3674	16	over	over	IN
18637	3674	17	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
18637	3674	18	communities	community	NNS
18637	3674	19	through	through	IN
18637	3674	20	a	a	DT
18637	3674	21	Municipal	Municipal	NNP
18637	3674	22	Finance	Finance	NNP
18637	3674	23	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	3674	24	.	.	.
18637	3675	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3675	2	1632	1632	CD
18637	3675	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3675	4	Public	public	JJ
18637	3675	5	Offices.--On	Offices.--On	NNS
18637	3675	6	the	the	DT
18637	3675	7	same	same	JJ
18637	3675	8	ground	ground	NN
18637	3675	9	of	of	IN
18637	3675	10	public	public	JJ
18637	3675	11	agency	agency	NN
18637	3675	12	,	,	,
18637	3675	13	neither	neither	CC
18637	3675	14	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	3675	15	nor	nor	CC
18637	3675	16	election	election	NN
18637	3675	17	to	to	IN
18637	3675	18	public	public	JJ
18637	3675	19	office	office	NN
18637	3675	20	creates	create	VBZ
18637	3675	21	a	a	DT
18637	3675	22	contract	contract	NN
18637	3675	23	in	in	IN
18637	3675	24	the	the	DT
18637	3675	25	sense	sense	NN
18637	3675	26	of	of	IN
18637	3675	27	article	article	NN
18637	3675	28	I	i	NN
18637	3675	29	,	,	,
18637	3675	30	section	section	NN
18637	3675	31	10	10	CD
18637	3675	32	,	,	,
18637	3675	33	whether	whether	IN
18637	3675	34	as	as	IN
18637	3675	35	to	to	IN
18637	3675	36	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	3675	37	,	,	,
18637	3675	38	or	or	CC
18637	3675	39	salary	salary	NN
18637	3675	40	,	,	,
18637	3675	41	or	or	CC
18637	3675	42	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3675	43	,	,	,
18637	3675	44	all	all	DT
18637	3675	45	of	of	IN
18637	3675	46	which	which	WDT
18637	3675	47	remain	remain	VBP
18637	3675	48	,	,	,
18637	3675	49	so	so	RB
18637	3675	50	far	far	RB
18637	3675	51	as	as	IN
18637	3675	52	the	the	DT
18637	3675	53	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3675	54	of	of	IN
18637	3675	55	the	the	DT
18637	3675	56	United	United	NNP
18637	3675	57	States	States	NNP
18637	3675	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	3675	59	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	3675	60	,	,	,
18637	3675	61	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3675	62	to	to	IN
18637	3675	63	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3675	64	modification	modification	NN
18637	3675	65	or	or	CC
18637	3675	66	outright	outright	JJ
18637	3675	67	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	3675	68	.	.	.
18637	3676	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3676	2	1633	1633	CD
18637	3676	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3676	4	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	3676	5	there	there	EX
18637	3676	6	can	can	MD
18637	3676	7	be	be	VB
18637	3676	8	no	no	DT
18637	3676	9	such	such	JJ
18637	3676	10	thing	thing	NN
18637	3676	11	in	in	IN
18637	3676	12	this	this	DT
18637	3676	13	country	country	NN
18637	3676	14	as	as	IN
18637	3676	15	property	property	NN
18637	3676	16	in	in	IN
18637	3676	17	office	office	NN
18637	3676	18	,	,	,
18637	3676	19	although	although	IN
18637	3676	20	the	the	DT
18637	3676	21	common	common	JJ
18637	3676	22	law	law	NN
18637	3676	23	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	3676	24	a	a	DT
18637	3676	25	different	different	JJ
18637	3676	26	view	view	NN
18637	3676	27	which	which	WDT
18637	3676	28	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	3676	29	found	find	VBD
18637	3676	30	reflection	reflection	NN
18637	3676	31	in	in	IN
18637	3676	32	early	early	JJ
18637	3676	33	cases	case	NNS
18637	3676	34	.	.	.
18637	3677	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3677	2	1634	1634	CD
18637	3677	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3677	4	When	when	WRB
18637	3677	5	,	,	,
18637	3677	6	however	however	RB
18637	3677	7	,	,	,
18637	3677	8	services	service	NNS
18637	3677	9	have	have	VBP
18637	3677	10	once	once	RB
18637	3677	11	been	be	VBN
18637	3677	12	rendered	render	VBN
18637	3677	13	,	,	,
18637	3677	14	there	there	EX
18637	3677	15	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	3677	16	an	an	DT
18637	3677	17	implied	imply	VBN
18637	3677	18	contract	contract	NN
18637	3677	19	that	that	IN
18637	3677	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3677	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	3677	22	be	be	VB
18637	3677	23	compensated	compensate	VBN
18637	3677	24	at	at	IN
18637	3677	25	the	the	DT
18637	3677	26	rate	rate	NN
18637	3677	27	which	which	WDT
18637	3677	28	was	be	VBD
18637	3677	29	in	in	IN
18637	3677	30	force	force	NN
18637	3677	31	at	at	IN
18637	3677	32	the	the	DT
18637	3677	33	time	time	NN
18637	3677	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3677	35	were	be	VBD
18637	3677	36	rendered	render	VBN
18637	3677	37	.	.	.
18637	3678	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3678	2	1635	1635	CD
18637	3678	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3678	4	Also	also	RB
18637	3678	5	,	,	,
18637	3678	6	an	an	DT
18637	3678	7	express	express	JJ
18637	3678	8	contract	contract	NN
18637	3678	9	between	between	IN
18637	3678	10	the	the	DT
18637	3678	11	State	State	NNP
18637	3678	12	and	and	CC
18637	3678	13	an	an	DT
18637	3678	14	individual	individual	NN
18637	3678	15	for	for	IN
18637	3678	16	the	the	DT
18637	3678	17	performance	performance	NN
18637	3678	18	of	of	IN
18637	3678	19	specific	specific	JJ
18637	3678	20	services	service	NNS
18637	3678	21	falls	fall	VBZ
18637	3678	22	within	within	IN
18637	3678	23	the	the	DT
18637	3678	24	protection	protection	NN
18637	3678	25	of	of	IN
18637	3678	26	the	the	DT
18637	3678	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3678	28	.	.	.
18637	3679	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	3679	2	a	a	DT
18637	3679	3	contract	contract	NN
18637	3679	4	made	make	VBN
18637	3679	5	by	by	IN
18637	3679	6	the	the	DT
18637	3679	7	governor	governor	NNP
18637	3679	8	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	3679	9	to	to	IN
18637	3679	10	a	a	DT
18637	3679	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	3679	12	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	3679	13	the	the	DT
18637	3679	14	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	3679	15	of	of	IN
18637	3679	16	a	a	DT
18637	3679	17	commissioner	commissioner	NN
18637	3679	18	to	to	TO
18637	3679	19	conduct	conduct	VB
18637	3679	20	,	,	,
18637	3679	21	over	over	IN
18637	3679	22	a	a	DT
18637	3679	23	period	period	NN
18637	3679	24	of	of	IN
18637	3679	25	years	year	NNS
18637	3679	26	,	,	,
18637	3679	27	a	a	DT
18637	3679	28	geological	geological	JJ
18637	3679	29	,	,	,
18637	3679	30	mineralogical	mineralogical	JJ
18637	3679	31	,	,	,
18637	3679	32	and	and	CC
18637	3679	33	agricultural	agricultural	JJ
18637	3679	34	survey	survey	NN
18637	3679	35	of	of	IN
18637	3679	36	the	the	DT
18637	3679	37	State	State	NNP
18637	3679	38	,	,	,
18637	3679	39	for	for	IN
18637	3679	40	which	which	WDT
18637	3679	41	a	a	DT
18637	3679	42	definite	definite	JJ
18637	3679	43	sum	sum	NN
18637	3679	44	had	have	VBD
18637	3679	45	been	be	VBN
18637	3679	46	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	3679	47	,	,	,
18637	3679	48	was	be	VBD
18637	3679	49	held	hold	VBN
18637	3679	50	to	to	TO
18637	3679	51	have	have	VB
18637	3679	52	been	be	VBN
18637	3679	53	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	3679	54	by	by	IN
18637	3679	55	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	3679	56	of	of	IN
18637	3679	57	the	the	DT
18637	3679	58	statute	statute	NN
18637	3679	59	.	.	.
18637	3680	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3680	2	1636	1636	CD
18637	3680	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3680	4	But	but	CC
18637	3680	5	a	a	DT
18637	3680	6	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	3680	7	of	of	IN
18637	3680	8	a	a	DT
18637	3680	9	New	New	NNP
18637	3680	10	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	3680	11	local	local	JJ
18637	3680	12	board	board	NN
18637	3680	13	of	of	IN
18637	3680	14	education	education	NN
18637	3680	15	reducing	reduce	VBG
18637	3680	16	teachers	teacher	NNS
18637	3680	17	'	'	POS
18637	3680	18	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	3680	19	for	for	IN
18637	3680	20	the	the	DT
18637	3680	21	school	school	NN
18637	3680	22	year	year	NN
18637	3680	23	1933	1933	CD
18637	3680	24	-	-	SYM
18637	3680	25	1934	1934	CD
18637	3680	26	,	,	,
18637	3680	27	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	3680	28	to	to	IN
18637	3680	29	an	an	DT
18637	3680	30	act	act	NN
18637	3680	31	of	of	IN
18637	3680	32	the	the	DT
18637	3680	33	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3680	34	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	3680	35	such	such	JJ
18637	3680	36	action	action	NN
18637	3680	37	,	,	,
18637	3680	38	was	be	VBD
18637	3680	39	held	hold	VBN
18637	3680	40	not	not	RB
18637	3680	41	to	to	TO
18637	3680	42	impair	impair	VB
18637	3680	43	the	the	DT
18637	3680	44	contract	contract	NN
18637	3680	45	of	of	IN
18637	3680	46	a	a	DT
18637	3680	47	teacher	teacher	NN
18637	3680	48	who	who	WP
18637	3680	49	,	,	,
18637	3680	50	having	have	VBG
18637	3680	51	served	serve	VBN
18637	3680	52	three	three	CD
18637	3680	53	years	year	NNS
18637	3680	54	,	,	,
18637	3680	55	was	be	VBD
18637	3680	56	by	by	IN
18637	3680	57	earlier	early	JJR
18637	3680	58	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3680	59	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	3680	60	from	from	IN
18637	3680	61	having	have	VBG
18637	3680	62	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3680	63	salary	salary	NN
18637	3680	64	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	3680	65	except	except	IN
18637	3680	66	for	for	IN
18637	3680	67	inefficiency	inefficiency	NN
18637	3680	68	or	or	CC
18637	3680	69	misconduct	misconduct	NN
18637	3680	70	.	.	.
18637	3681	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3681	2	1637	1637	CD
18637	3681	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3681	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	3681	5	,	,	,
18637	3681	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3681	7	was	be	VBD
18637	3681	8	held	hold	VBN
18637	3681	9	that	that	IN
18637	3681	10	an	an	DT
18637	3681	11	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	3681	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	3681	13	which	which	WDT
18637	3681	14	reduced	reduce	VBD
18637	3681	15	the	the	DT
18637	3681	16	annuity	annuity	NN
18637	3681	17	payable	payable	JJ
18637	3681	18	to	to	TO
18637	3681	19	retire	retire	VB
18637	3681	20	teachers	teacher	NNS
18637	3681	21	under	under	IN
18637	3681	22	an	an	DT
18637	3681	23	earlier	early	JJR
18637	3681	24	act	act	NN
18637	3681	25	did	do	VBD
18637	3681	26	not	not	RB
18637	3681	27	violate	violate	VB
18637	3681	28	the	the	DT
18637	3681	29	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3681	30	clause	clause	NN
18637	3681	31	,	,	,
18637	3681	32	since	since	IN
18637	3681	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3681	34	had	have	VBD
18637	3681	35	not	not	RB
18637	3681	36	been	be	VBN
18637	3681	37	the	the	DT
18637	3681	38	intention	intention	NN
18637	3681	39	of	of	IN
18637	3681	40	the	the	DT
18637	3681	41	earlier	early	JJR
18637	3681	42	act	act	NN
18637	3681	43	to	to	TO
18637	3681	44	propose	propose	VB
18637	3681	45	a	a	DT
18637	3681	46	contract	contract	NN
18637	3681	47	but	but	CC
18637	3681	48	only	only	RB
18637	3681	49	to	to	TO
18637	3681	50	put	put	VB
18637	3681	51	into	into	IN
18637	3681	52	effect	effect	NN
18637	3681	53	a	a	DT
18637	3681	54	general	general	JJ
18637	3681	55	policy	policy	NN
18637	3681	56	.	.	.
18637	3682	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3682	2	1638	1638	CD
18637	3682	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3682	4	On	on	IN
18637	3682	5	the	the	DT
18637	3682	6	other	other	JJ
18637	3682	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	3682	8	,	,	,
18637	3682	9	the	the	DT
18637	3682	10	right	right	NN
18637	3682	11	of	of	IN
18637	3682	12	one	one	CD
18637	3682	13	,	,	,
18637	3682	14	who	who	WP
18637	3682	15	had	have	VBD
18637	3682	16	become	become	VBN
18637	3682	17	a	a	DT
18637	3682	18	"	"	``
18637	3682	19	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	3682	20	teacher	teacher	NN
18637	3682	21	"	"	''
18637	3682	22	under	under	IN
18637	3682	23	the	the	DT
18637	3682	24	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	3682	25	Teachers	Teachers	NNPS
18637	3682	26	Tenure	Tenure	NNP
18637	3682	27	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3682	28	of	of	IN
18637	3682	29	1927	1927	CD
18637	3682	30	,	,	,
18637	3682	31	to	to	IN
18637	3682	32	continued	continue	VBN
18637	3682	33	employment	employment	NN
18637	3682	34	was	be	VBD
18637	3682	35	held	hold	VBN
18637	3682	36	to	to	TO
18637	3682	37	be	be	VB
18637	3682	38	contractual	contractual	JJ
18637	3682	39	and	and	CC
18637	3682	40	to	to	TO
18637	3682	41	have	have	VB
18637	3682	42	been	be	VBN
18637	3682	43	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	3682	44	by	by	IN
18637	3682	45	the	the	DT
18637	3682	46	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	3682	47	in	in	IN
18637	3682	48	1933	1933	CD
18637	3682	49	of	of	IN
18637	3682	50	the	the	DT
18637	3682	51	earlier	early	JJR
18637	3682	52	act	act	NN
18637	3682	53	.	.	.
18637	3683	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3683	2	1639	1639	CD
18637	3683	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3683	4	Revocable	revocable	JJ
18637	3683	5	Privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3683	6	Versus	versus	IN
18637	3683	7	"	"	``
18637	3683	8	Contracts	Contracts	NNP
18637	3683	9	"	"	''
18637	3683	10	:	:	:
18637	3683	11	Tax	tax	NN
18637	3683	12	Exemptions.--From	exemptions.--from	NN
18637	3683	13	a	a	DT
18637	3683	14	different	different	JJ
18637	3683	15	point	point	NN
18637	3683	16	of	of	IN
18637	3683	17	view	view	NN
18637	3683	18	,	,	,
18637	3683	19	the	the	DT
18637	3683	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3683	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	3683	22	sought	seek	VBN
18637	3683	23	to	to	TO
18637	3683	24	distinguish	distinguish	VB
18637	3683	25	between	between	IN
18637	3683	26	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3683	27	of	of	IN
18637	3683	28	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3683	29	,	,	,
18637	3683	30	whether	whether	IN
18637	3683	31	to	to	IN
18637	3683	32	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	3683	33	or	or	CC
18637	3683	34	to	to	IN
18637	3683	35	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	3683	36	,	,	,
18637	3683	37	which	which	WDT
18637	3683	38	are	be	VBP
18637	3683	39	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3683	40	and	and	CC
18637	3683	41	those	those	DT
18637	3683	42	which	which	WDT
18637	3683	43	are	be	VBP
18637	3683	44	mere	mere	JJ
18637	3683	45	revocable	revocable	JJ
18637	3683	46	licenses	license	NNS
18637	3683	47	,	,	,
18637	3683	48	although	although	IN
18637	3683	49	on	on	IN
18637	3683	50	account	account	NN
18637	3683	51	of	of	IN
18637	3683	52	the	the	DT
18637	3683	53	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3683	54	of	of	IN
18637	3683	55	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	3683	56	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	3683	57	mentioned	mention	VBD
18637	3683	58	earlier	early	RBR
18637	3683	59	,	,	,
18637	3683	60	this	this	DT
18637	3683	61	has	have	VBZ
18637	3683	62	not	not	RB
18637	3683	63	always	always	RB
18637	3683	64	been	be	VBN
18637	3683	65	easy	easy	JJ
18637	3683	66	to	to	TO
18637	3683	67	do	do	VB
18637	3683	68	.	.	.
18637	3684	1	In	in	IN
18637	3684	2	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	3684	3	of	of	IN
18637	3684	4	the	the	DT
18637	3684	5	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	3684	6	set	set	VBN
18637	3684	7	in	in	IN
18637	3684	8	New	New	NNP
18637	3684	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	3684	10	_	_	NNP
18637	3684	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	3684	12	_	_	NNP
18637	3684	13	Wilson,[1640	Wilson,[1640	NNP
18637	3684	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3684	15	the	the	DT
18637	3684	16	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3684	17	of	of	IN
18637	3684	18	a	a	DT
18637	3684	19	State	State	NNP
18637	3684	20	"	"	``
18637	3684	21	may	may	MD
18637	3684	22	exempt	exempt	VB
18637	3684	23	particular	particular	JJ
18637	3684	24	parcels	parcel	NNS
18637	3684	25	of	of	IN
18637	3684	26	property	property	NN
18637	3684	27	or	or	CC
18637	3684	28	the	the	DT
18637	3684	29	property	property	NN
18637	3684	30	of	of	IN
18637	3684	31	particular	particular	JJ
18637	3684	32	persons	person	NNS
18637	3684	33	or	or	CC
18637	3684	34	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	3684	35	from	from	IN
18637	3684	36	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3684	37	,	,	,
18637	3684	38	either	either	CC
18637	3684	39	for	for	IN
18637	3684	40	a	a	DT
18637	3684	41	specified	specified	JJ
18637	3684	42	period	period	NN
18637	3684	43	or	or	CC
18637	3684	44	perpetually	perpetually	RB
18637	3684	45	,	,	,
18637	3684	46	or	or	CC
18637	3684	47	may	may	MD
18637	3684	48	limit	limit	VB
18637	3684	49	the	the	DT
18637	3684	50	amount	amount	NN
18637	3684	51	or	or	CC
18637	3684	52	rate	rate	NN
18637	3684	53	of	of	IN
18637	3684	54	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3684	55	,	,	,
18637	3684	56	to	to	IN
18637	3684	57	which	which	WDT
18637	3684	58	such	such	JJ
18637	3684	59	property	property	NN
18637	3684	60	shall	shall	MD
18637	3684	61	be	be	VB
18637	3684	62	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	3684	63	,	,	,
18637	3684	64	"	"	''
18637	3684	65	and	and	CC
18637	3684	66	such	such	PDT
18637	3684	67	an	an	DT
18637	3684	68	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	3684	69	is	be	VBZ
18637	3684	70	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	3684	71	a	a	DT
18637	3684	72	contract	contract	NN
18637	3684	73	within	within	IN
18637	3684	74	the	the	DT
18637	3684	75	sense	sense	NN
18637	3684	76	of	of	IN
18637	3684	77	the	the	DT
18637	3684	78	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3684	79	.	.	.
18637	3685	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	3685	2	this	this	DT
18637	3685	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	3685	4	always	always	RB
18637	3685	5	so	so	RB
18637	3685	6	when	when	WRB
18637	3685	7	the	the	DT
18637	3685	8	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	3685	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	3685	10	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	3685	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	3685	12	a	a	DT
18637	3685	13	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3685	14	by	by	IN
18637	3685	15	the	the	DT
18637	3685	16	clear	clear	JJ
18637	3685	17	terms	term	NNS
18637	3685	18	of	of	IN
18637	3685	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3685	20	charter	charter	NN
18637	3685	21	.	.	.
18637	3686	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3686	2	1641	1641	CD
18637	3686	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3686	4	When	when	WRB
18637	3686	5	,	,	,
18637	3686	6	on	on	IN
18637	3686	7	the	the	DT
18637	3686	8	other	other	JJ
18637	3686	9	hand	hand	NN
18637	3686	10	,	,	,
18637	3686	11	an	an	DT
18637	3686	12	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	3686	13	of	of	IN
18637	3686	14	this	this	DT
18637	3686	15	sort	sort	JJ
18637	3686	16	springs	spring	NNS
18637	3686	17	from	from	IN
18637	3686	18	general	general	JJ
18637	3686	19	law	law	NN
18637	3686	20	,	,	,
18637	3686	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3686	22	precise	precise	JJ
18637	3686	23	nature	nature	NN
18637	3686	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	3686	25	more	more	RBR
18637	3686	26	open	open	JJ
18637	3686	27	to	to	IN
18637	3686	28	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	3686	29	,	,	,
18637	3686	30	as	as	IN
18637	3686	31	a	a	DT
18637	3686	32	comparison	comparison	NN
18637	3686	33	of	of	IN
18637	3686	34	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3686	35	will	will	MD
18637	3686	36	serve	serve	VB
18637	3686	37	to	to	TO
18637	3686	38	illustrate	illustrate	VB
18637	3686	39	.	.	.
18637	3687	1	In	in	IN
18637	3687	2	Piqua	Piqua	NNP
18637	3687	3	Branch	Branch	NNP
18637	3687	4	of	of	IN
18637	3687	5	the	the	DT
18637	3687	6	State	State	NNP
18637	3687	7	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	3687	8	_	_	NNP
18637	3687	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	3687	10	_	_	NNP
18637	3687	11	Knoop,[1642	Knoop,[1642	NNP
18637	3687	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3687	13	a	a	DT
18637	3687	14	closely	closely	RB
18637	3687	15	divided	divide	VBN
18637	3687	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3687	17	held	hold	VBD
18637	3687	18	that	that	IN
18637	3687	19	a	a	DT
18637	3687	20	general	general	JJ
18637	3687	21	banking	banking	NN
18637	3687	22	law	law	NN
18637	3687	23	of	of	IN
18637	3687	24	the	the	DT
18637	3687	25	State	State	NNP
18637	3687	26	of	of	IN
18637	3687	27	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	3687	28	which	which	WDT
18637	3687	29	provided	provide	VBD
18637	3687	30	that	that	IN
18637	3687	31	companies	company	NNS
18637	3687	32	complying	comply	VBG
18637	3687	33	therewith	therewith	NNP
18637	3687	34	and	and	CC
18637	3687	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3687	36	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	3687	37	should	should	MD
18637	3687	38	be	be	VB
18637	3687	39	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	3687	40	from	from	IN
18637	3687	41	all	all	DT
18637	3687	42	but	but	CC
18637	3687	43	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3687	44	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3687	45	,	,	,
18637	3687	46	was	be	VBD
18637	3687	47	,	,	,
18637	3687	48	as	as	IN
18637	3687	49	to	to	IN
18637	3687	50	a	a	DT
18637	3687	51	bank	bank	NN
18637	3687	52	organized	organize	VBN
18637	3687	53	under	under	IN
18637	3687	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3687	55	and	and	CC
18637	3687	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3687	57	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	3687	58	,	,	,
18637	3687	59	a	a	DT
18637	3687	60	contract	contract	NN
18637	3687	61	within	within	IN
18637	3687	62	the	the	DT
18637	3687	63	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	3687	64	of	of	IN
18637	3687	65	article	article	NN
18637	3687	66	I	i	NN
18637	3687	67	,	,	,
18637	3687	68	section	section	NN
18637	3687	69	10	10	CD
18637	3687	70	.	.	.
18637	3688	1	"	"	``
18637	3688	2	The	the	DT
18637	3688	3	provision	provision	NN
18637	3688	4	was	be	VBD
18637	3688	5	not	not	RB
18637	3688	6	,	,	,
18637	3688	7	"	"	''
18637	3688	8	the	the	DT
18637	3688	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3688	10	said	say	VBD
18637	3688	11	,	,	,
18637	3688	12	"	"	``
18637	3688	13	a	a	DT
18637	3688	14	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3688	15	command	command	NN
18637	3688	16	nor	nor	CC
18637	3688	17	a	a	DT
18637	3688	18	rule	rule	NN
18637	3688	19	of	of	IN
18637	3688	20	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3688	21	until	until	IN
18637	3688	22	changed	change	VBN
18637	3688	23	,	,	,
18637	3688	24	but	but	CC
18637	3688	25	a	a	DT
18637	3688	26	contract	contract	NN
18637	3688	27	stipulating	stipulating	NN
18637	3688	28	against	against	IN
18637	3688	29	any	any	DT
18637	3688	30	change	change	NN
18637	3688	31	,	,	,
18637	3688	32	from	from	IN
18637	3688	33	the	the	DT
18637	3688	34	nature	nature	NN
18637	3688	35	of	of	IN
18637	3688	36	the	the	DT
18637	3688	37	language	language	NN
18637	3688	38	used	use	VBN
18637	3688	39	and	and	CC
18637	3688	40	the	the	DT
18637	3688	41	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	3688	42	under	under	IN
18637	3688	43	which	which	WDT
18637	3688	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3688	45	was	be	VBD
18637	3688	46	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	3688	47	.	.	.
18637	3689	1	"	"	``
18637	3689	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3689	3	1643	1643	CD
18637	3689	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3689	5	When	when	WRB
18637	3689	6	,	,	,
18637	3689	7	however	however	RB
18637	3689	8	,	,	,
18637	3689	9	the	the	DT
18637	3689	10	State	State	NNP
18637	3689	11	of	of	IN
18637	3689	12	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	3689	13	pledged	pledge	VBD
18637	3689	14	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3689	15	,	,	,
18637	3689	16	by	by	IN
18637	3689	17	a	a	DT
18637	3689	18	general	general	JJ
18637	3689	19	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3689	20	act	act	NN
18637	3689	21	,	,	,
18637	3689	22	not	not	RB
18637	3689	23	to	to	TO
18637	3689	24	tax	tax	VB
18637	3689	25	any	any	DT
18637	3689	26	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3689	27	,	,	,
18637	3689	28	company	company	NN
18637	3689	29	,	,	,
18637	3689	30	or	or	CC
18637	3689	31	individual	individual	JJ
18637	3689	32	undertaking	undertaking	NN
18637	3689	33	to	to	TO
18637	3689	34	manufacture	manufacture	VB
18637	3689	35	salt	salt	NN
18637	3689	36	in	in	IN
18637	3689	37	the	the	DT
18637	3689	38	State	State	NNP
18637	3689	39	from	from	IN
18637	3689	40	water	water	NN
18637	3689	41	there	there	RB
18637	3689	42	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	3689	43	by	by	IN
18637	3689	44	boring	bore	VBG
18637	3689	45	on	on	IN
18637	3689	46	property	property	NN
18637	3689	47	used	use	VBN
18637	3689	48	for	for	IN
18637	3689	49	this	this	DT
18637	3689	50	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3689	51	and	and	CC
18637	3689	52	,	,	,
18637	3689	53	furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	3689	54	,	,	,
18637	3689	55	to	to	TO
18637	3689	56	pay	pay	VB
18637	3689	57	a	a	DT
18637	3689	58	bounty	bounty	NN
18637	3689	59	on	on	IN
18637	3689	60	the	the	DT
18637	3689	61	salt	salt	NN
18637	3689	62	so	so	RB
18637	3689	63	manufactured	manufactured	JJ
18637	3689	64	,	,	,
18637	3689	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3689	66	was	be	VBD
18637	3689	67	held	hold	VBN
18637	3689	68	not	not	RB
18637	3689	69	to	to	TO
18637	3689	70	have	have	VB
18637	3689	71	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	3689	72	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3689	73	within	within	IN
18637	3689	74	the	the	DT
18637	3689	75	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3689	76	sense	sense	NN
18637	3689	77	.	.	.
18637	3690	1	"	"	``
18637	3690	2	General	general	JJ
18637	3690	3	encouragements	encouragement	NNS
18637	3690	4	,	,	,
18637	3690	5	"	"	''
18637	3690	6	said	say	VBD
18637	3690	7	the	the	DT
18637	3690	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3690	9	,	,	,
18637	3690	10	"	"	''
18637	3690	11	held	hold	VBN
18637	3690	12	out	out	RP
18637	3690	13	to	to	IN
18637	3690	14	all	all	DT
18637	3690	15	persons	person	NNS
18637	3690	16	indiscriminately	indiscriminately	RB
18637	3690	17	,	,	,
18637	3690	18	to	to	TO
18637	3690	19	engage	engage	VB
18637	3690	20	in	in	IN
18637	3690	21	a	a	DT
18637	3690	22	particular	particular	JJ
18637	3690	23	trade	trade	NN
18637	3690	24	or	or	CC
18637	3690	25	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	3690	26	,	,	,
18637	3690	27	whether	whether	IN
18637	3690	28	such	such	JJ
18637	3690	29	encouragement	encouragement	NN
18637	3690	30	be	be	VBP
18637	3690	31	in	in	IN
18637	3690	32	the	the	DT
18637	3690	33	shape	shape	NN
18637	3690	34	of	of	IN
18637	3690	35	bounties	bounty	NNS
18637	3690	36	or	or	CC
18637	3690	37	drawbacks	drawback	NNS
18637	3690	38	,	,	,
18637	3690	39	or	or	CC
18637	3690	40	other	other	JJ
18637	3690	41	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	3690	42	,	,	,
18637	3690	43	are	be	VBP
18637	3690	44	always	always	RB
18637	3690	45	under	under	IN
18637	3690	46	the	the	DT
18637	3690	47	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3690	48	control	control	NN
18637	3690	49	,	,	,
18637	3690	50	and	and	CC
18637	3690	51	may	may	MD
18637	3690	52	be	be	VB
18637	3690	53	discontinued	discontinue	VBN
18637	3690	54	at	at	IN
18637	3690	55	any	any	DT
18637	3690	56	time	time	NN
18637	3690	57	.	.	.
18637	3691	1	"	"	``
18637	3691	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3691	3	1644	1644	CD
18637	3691	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3691	5	So	so	RB
18637	3691	6	far	far	RB
18637	3691	7	as	as	IN
18637	3691	8	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	3691	9	from	from	IN
18637	3691	10	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3691	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	3691	12	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	3691	13	the	the	DT
18637	3691	14	difference	difference	NN
18637	3691	15	between	between	IN
18637	3691	16	these	these	DT
18637	3691	17	two	two	CD
18637	3691	18	cases	case	NNS
18637	3691	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	3691	20	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	3691	21	slight	slight	JJ
18637	3691	22	;	;	:
18637	3691	23	but	but	CC
18637	3691	24	the	the	DT
18637	3691	25	later	later	JJ
18637	3691	26	one	one	NN
18637	3691	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	3691	28	unquestionable	unquestionable	JJ
18637	3691	29	authority	authority	NN
18637	3691	30	for	for	IN
18637	3691	31	the	the	DT
18637	3691	32	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	3691	33	that	that	IN
18637	3691	34	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3691	35	bounties	bounty	NNS
18637	3691	36	are	be	VBP
18637	3691	37	repealable	repealable	JJ
18637	3691	38	at	at	IN
18637	3691	39	will	will	NN
18637	3691	40	.	.	.
18637	3692	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	3692	2	,	,	,
18637	3692	3	exemptions	exemption	NNS
18637	3692	4	from	from	IN
18637	3692	5	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3692	6	have	have	VBP
18637	3692	7	in	in	IN
18637	3692	8	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3692	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	3692	10	been	be	VBN
18637	3692	11	treated	treat	VBN
18637	3692	12	as	as	IN
18637	3692	13	gratuities	gratuity	NNS
18637	3692	14	repealable	repealable	VBP
18637	3692	15	at	at	IN
18637	3692	16	will	will	NN
18637	3692	17	,	,	,
18637	3692	18	even	even	RB
18637	3692	19	when	when	WRB
18637	3692	20	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	3692	21	by	by	IN
18637	3692	22	specific	specific	JJ
18637	3692	23	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3692	24	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	3692	25	.	.	.
18637	3693	1	This	this	DT
18637	3693	2	would	would	MD
18637	3693	3	seem	seem	VB
18637	3693	4	always	always	RB
18637	3693	5	to	to	TO
18637	3693	6	be	be	VB
18637	3693	7	the	the	DT
18637	3693	8	case	case	NN
18637	3693	9	when	when	WRB
18637	3693	10	the	the	DT
18637	3693	11	beneficiaries	beneficiary	NNS
18637	3693	12	were	be	VBD
18637	3693	13	already	already	RB
18637	3693	14	in	in	IN
18637	3693	15	existence	existence	NN
18637	3693	16	when	when	WRB
18637	3693	17	the	the	DT
18637	3693	18	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	3693	19	was	be	VBD
18637	3693	20	created	create	VBN
18637	3693	21	and	and	CC
18637	3693	22	did	do	VBD
18637	3693	23	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	3693	24	of	of	IN
18637	3693	25	a	a	DT
18637	3693	26	more	more	RBR
18637	3693	27	positive	positive	JJ
18637	3693	28	nature	nature	NN
18637	3693	29	to	to	TO
18637	3693	30	qualify	qualify	VB
18637	3693	31	for	for	IN
18637	3693	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3693	33	than	than	IN
18637	3693	34	to	to	TO
18637	3693	35	continue	continue	VB
18637	3693	36	in	in	IN
18637	3693	37	existence	existence	NN
18637	3693	38	.	.	.
18637	3694	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3694	2	1645	1645	CD
18637	3694	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3694	4	Yet	yet	CC
18637	3694	5	the	the	DT
18637	3694	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	3694	7	are	be	VBP
18637	3694	8	not	not	RB
18637	3694	9	always	always	RB
18637	3694	10	easy	easy	JJ
18637	3694	11	to	to	TO
18637	3694	12	explain	explain	VB
18637	3694	13	in	in	IN
18637	3694	14	relation	relation	NN
18637	3694	15	to	to	IN
18637	3694	16	each	each	DT
18637	3694	17	other	other	JJ
18637	3694	18	,	,	,
18637	3694	19	except	except	IN
18637	3694	20	in	in	IN
18637	3694	21	light	light	NN
18637	3694	22	of	of	IN
18637	3694	23	the	the	DT
18637	3694	24	fact	fact	NN
18637	3694	25	that	that	IN
18637	3694	26	the	the	DT
18637	3694	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3694	28	's	's	POS
18637	3694	29	wider	wide	JJR
18637	3694	30	point	point	NN
18637	3694	31	of	of	IN
18637	3694	32	view	view	NN
18637	3694	33	has	have	VBZ
18637	3694	34	altered	alter	VBN
18637	3694	35	from	from	IN
18637	3694	36	time	time	NN
18637	3694	37	to	to	IN
18637	3694	38	time	time	NN
18637	3694	39	.	.	.
18637	3695	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3695	2	1646	1646	CD
18637	3695	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3695	4	Vested	vest	VBN
18637	3695	5	Rights.--Lastly	rights.--lastly	RB
18637	3695	6	,	,	,
18637	3695	7	the	the	DT
18637	3695	8	term	term	NN
18637	3695	9	"	"	``
18637	3695	10	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3695	11	"	"	''
18637	3695	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	3695	13	used	use	VBN
18637	3695	14	in	in	IN
18637	3695	15	the	the	DT
18637	3695	16	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3695	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	3695	18	in	in	IN
18637	3695	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3695	20	popular	popular	JJ
18637	3695	21	sense	sense	NN
18637	3695	22	of	of	IN
18637	3695	23	an	an	DT
18637	3695	24	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3695	25	of	of	IN
18637	3695	26	minds	mind	NNS
18637	3695	27	.	.	.
18637	3696	1	The	the	DT
18637	3696	2	clause	clause	NN
18637	3696	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	3696	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	3696	5	not	not	RB
18637	3696	6	protect	protect	VB
18637	3696	7	vested	vested	JJ
18637	3696	8	rights	right	NNS
18637	3696	9	that	that	WDT
18637	3696	10	are	be	VBP
18637	3696	11	not	not	RB
18637	3696	12	referable	referable	JJ
18637	3696	13	to	to	IN
18637	3696	14	such	such	PDT
18637	3696	15	an	an	DT
18637	3696	16	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3696	17	between	between	IN
18637	3696	18	the	the	DT
18637	3696	19	State	State	NNP
18637	3696	20	and	and	CC
18637	3696	21	an	an	DT
18637	3696	22	individual	individual	NN
18637	3696	23	,	,	,
18637	3696	24	such	such	JJ
18637	3696	25	as	as	IN
18637	3696	26	the	the	DT
18637	3696	27	right	right	NN
18637	3696	28	to	to	IN
18637	3696	29	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	3696	30	under	under	IN
18637	3696	31	a	a	DT
18637	3696	32	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	3696	33	.	.	.
18637	3697	1	The	the	DT
18637	3697	2	individual	individual	NN
18637	3697	3	in	in	IN
18637	3697	4	question	question	NN
18637	3697	5	may	may	MD
18637	3697	6	have	have	VB
18637	3697	7	a	a	DT
18637	3697	8	case	case	NN
18637	3697	9	under	under	IN
18637	3697	10	the	the	DT
18637	3697	11	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	3697	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3697	13	,	,	,
18637	3697	14	but	but	CC
18637	3697	15	not	not	RB
18637	3697	16	one	one	CD
18637	3697	17	under	under	IN
18637	3697	18	article	article	NN
18637	3697	19	I	i	NN
18637	3697	20	,	,	,
18637	3697	21	section	section	NN
18637	3697	22	10	10	CD
18637	3697	23	.	.	.
18637	3698	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3698	2	1647	1647	CD
18637	3698	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3698	4	Reservation	Reservation	NNP
18637	3698	5	of	of	IN
18637	3698	6	the	the	DT
18637	3698	7	Right	right	NN
18637	3698	8	to	to	IN
18637	3698	9	Alter	Alter	NNP
18637	3698	10	and	and	CC
18637	3698	11	Repeal	Repeal	NNP
18637	3698	12	So	so	RB
18637	3698	13	much	much	RB
18637	3698	14	for	for	IN
18637	3698	15	the	the	DT
18637	3698	16	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	3698	17	of	of	IN
18637	3698	18	the	the	DT
18637	3698	19	word	word	NN
18637	3698	20	"	"	``
18637	3698	21	contract	contract	NN
18637	3698	22	"	"	''
18637	3698	23	when	when	WRB
18637	3698	24	public	public	JJ
18637	3698	25	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3698	26	are	be	VBP
18637	3698	27	meant	mean	VBN
18637	3698	28	.	.	.
18637	3699	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3699	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	3699	3	next	next	JJ
18637	3699	4	in	in	IN
18637	3699	5	order	order	NN
18637	3699	6	to	to	TO
18637	3699	7	consider	consider	VB
18637	3699	8	four	four	CD
18637	3699	9	principles	principle	NNS
18637	3699	10	or	or	CC
18637	3699	11	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	3699	12	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	3699	13	the	the	DT
18637	3699	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3699	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	3699	16	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3699	17	broken	break	VBN
18637	3699	18	down	down	RP
18637	3699	19	the	the	DT
18637	3699	20	force	force	NN
18637	3699	21	of	of	IN
18637	3699	22	the	the	DT
18637	3699	23	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	3699	24	College	College	NNP
18637	3699	25	decision	decision	NN
18637	3699	26	in	in	IN
18637	3699	27	great	great	JJ
18637	3699	28	measure	measure	NN
18637	3699	29	in	in	IN
18637	3699	30	favor	favor	NN
18637	3699	31	of	of	IN
18637	3699	32	State	State	NNP
18637	3699	33	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3699	34	power	power	NN
18637	3699	35	.	.	.
18637	3700	1	By	by	IN
18637	3700	2	the	the	DT
18637	3700	3	logic	logic	NN
18637	3700	4	of	of	IN
18637	3700	5	the	the	DT
18637	3700	6	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	3700	7	College	College	NNP
18637	3700	8	decision	decision	NN
18637	3700	9	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3700	10	the	the	DT
18637	3700	11	State	state	NN
18637	3700	12	may	may	MD
18637	3700	13	reserve	reserve	VB
18637	3700	14	in	in	IN
18637	3700	15	a	a	DT
18637	3700	16	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	3700	17	charter	charter	NN
18637	3700	18	the	the	DT
18637	3700	19	right	right	NN
18637	3700	20	to	to	TO
18637	3700	21	"	"	``
18637	3700	22	amend	amend	VB
18637	3700	23	,	,	,
18637	3700	24	alter	alter	NN
18637	3700	25	,	,	,
18637	3700	26	and	and	CC
18637	3700	27	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	3700	28	"	"	''
18637	3700	29	the	the	DT
18637	3700	30	same	same	JJ
18637	3700	31	,	,	,
18637	3700	32	and	and	CC
18637	3700	33	such	such	JJ
18637	3700	34	reservation	reservation	NN
18637	3700	35	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	3700	36	a	a	DT
18637	3700	37	part	part	NN
18637	3700	38	of	of	IN
18637	3700	39	the	the	DT
18637	3700	40	contract	contract	NN
18637	3700	41	between	between	IN
18637	3700	42	the	the	DT
18637	3700	43	State	State	NNP
18637	3700	44	and	and	CC
18637	3700	45	the	the	DT
18637	3700	46	incorporators	incorporator	NNS
18637	3700	47	,	,	,
18637	3700	48	the	the	DT
18637	3700	49	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3700	50	of	of	IN
18637	3700	51	which	which	WDT
18637	3700	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	3700	53	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	3700	54	not	not	RB
18637	3700	55	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	3700	56	by	by	IN
18637	3700	57	the	the	DT
18637	3700	58	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3700	59	of	of	IN
18637	3700	60	the	the	DT
18637	3700	61	right	right	NN
18637	3700	62	.	.	.
18637	3701	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3701	2	1648	1648	CD
18637	3701	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3701	4	Later	late	JJR
18637	3701	5	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3701	6	recognize	recognize	VBP
18637	3701	7	that	that	IN
18637	3701	8	the	the	DT
18637	3701	9	State	State	NNP
18637	3701	10	may	may	MD
18637	3701	11	reserve	reserve	VB
18637	3701	12	the	the	DT
18637	3701	13	right	right	NN
18637	3701	14	to	to	TO
18637	3701	15	amend	amend	VB
18637	3701	16	,	,	,
18637	3701	17	alter	alter	VB
18637	3701	18	,	,	,
18637	3701	19	and	and	CC
18637	3701	20	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	3701	21	by	by	IN
18637	3701	22	general	general	JJ
18637	3701	23	law	law	NN
18637	3701	24	,	,	,
18637	3701	25	with	with	IN
18637	3701	26	the	the	DT
18637	3701	27	result	result	NN
18637	3701	28	of	of	IN
18637	3701	29	incorporating	incorporate	VBG
18637	3701	30	the	the	DT
18637	3701	31	reservation	reservation	NN
18637	3701	32	in	in	IN
18637	3701	33	all	all	DT
18637	3701	34	charters	charter	NNS
18637	3701	35	of	of	IN
18637	3701	36	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	3701	37	date	date	NN
18637	3701	38	.	.	.
18637	3702	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3702	2	1649	1649	CD
18637	3702	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3702	4	There	there	EX
18637	3702	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	3702	6	,	,	,
18637	3702	7	however	however	RB
18637	3702	8	,	,	,
18637	3702	9	a	a	DT
18637	3702	10	difference	difference	NN
18637	3702	11	between	between	IN
18637	3702	12	a	a	DT
18637	3702	13	reservation	reservation	NN
18637	3702	14	by	by	IN
18637	3702	15	a	a	DT
18637	3702	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	3702	17	and	and	CC
18637	3702	18	one	one	CD
18637	3702	19	by	by	IN
18637	3702	20	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3702	21	provision	provision	NN
18637	3702	22	.	.	.
18637	3703	1	While	while	IN
18637	3703	2	the	the	DT
18637	3703	3	former	former	JJ
18637	3703	4	may	may	MD
18637	3703	5	be	be	VB
18637	3703	6	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	3703	7	as	as	IN
18637	3703	8	to	to	IN
18637	3703	9	a	a	DT
18637	3703	10	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	3703	11	charter	charter	NN
18637	3703	12	by	by	IN
18637	3703	13	the	the	DT
18637	3703	14	specific	specific	JJ
18637	3703	15	terms	term	NNS
18637	3703	16	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	3703	17	,	,	,
18637	3703	18	the	the	DT
18637	3703	19	latter	latter	JJ
18637	3703	20	may	may	MD
18637	3703	21	not	not	RB
18637	3703	22	.	.	.
18637	3704	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3704	2	1650	1650	CD
18637	3704	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3704	4	The	the	DT
18637	3704	5	Right	Right	NNP
18637	3704	6	to	to	IN
18637	3704	7	Reserve	Reserve	NNP
18637	3704	8	:	:	:
18637	3704	9	When	when	WRB
18637	3704	10	Limited.--Is	Limited.--Is	NNP
18637	3704	11	the	the	DT
18637	3704	12	right	right	NN
18637	3704	13	which	which	WDT
18637	3704	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	3704	15	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	3704	16	by	by	IN
18637	3704	17	a	a	DT
18637	3704	18	State	state	NN
18637	3704	19	to	to	TO
18637	3704	20	"	"	``
18637	3704	21	amend	amend	VB
18637	3704	22	"	"	''
18637	3704	23	or	or	CC
18637	3704	24	"	"	``
18637	3704	25	alter	alter	VB
18637	3704	26	"	"	''
18637	3704	27	a	a	DT
18637	3704	28	charter	charter	NN
18637	3704	29	without	without	IN
18637	3704	30	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	3704	31	?	?	.
18637	3705	1	When	when	WRB
18637	3705	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3705	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	3705	4	accompanied	accompany	VBN
18637	3705	5	,	,	,
18637	3705	6	as	as	IN
18637	3705	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3705	8	generally	generally	RB
18637	3705	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	3705	10	,	,	,
18637	3705	11	by	by	IN
18637	3705	12	the	the	DT
18637	3705	13	right	right	NN
18637	3705	14	to	to	TO
18637	3705	15	"	"	``
18637	3705	16	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	3705	17	,	,	,
18637	3705	18	"	"	''
18637	3705	19	one	one	PRP
18637	3705	20	would	would	MD
18637	3705	21	suppose	suppose	VB
18637	3705	22	that	that	IN
18637	3705	23	the	the	DT
18637	3705	24	answer	answer	NN
18637	3705	25	to	to	IN
18637	3705	26	this	this	DT
18637	3705	27	question	question	NN
18637	3705	28	was	be	VBD
18637	3705	29	self	self	NN
18637	3705	30	-	-	HYPH
18637	3705	31	evident	evident	JJ
18637	3705	32	.	.	.
18637	3706	1	None	none	NN
18637	3706	2	the	the	DT
18637	3706	3	less	less	RBR
18637	3706	4	,	,	,
18637	3706	5	there	there	EX
18637	3706	6	are	be	VBP
18637	3706	7	a	a	DT
18637	3706	8	number	number	NN
18637	3706	9	of	of	IN
18637	3706	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3706	11	dicta	dicta	NN
18637	3706	12	to	to	IN
18637	3706	13	the	the	DT
18637	3706	14	effect	effect	NN
18637	3706	15	that	that	IN
18637	3706	16	this	this	DT
18637	3706	17	power	power	NN
18637	3706	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	3706	19	not	not	RB
18637	3706	20	without	without	IN
18637	3706	21	limit	limit	NN
18637	3706	22	,	,	,
18637	3706	23	that	that	IN
18637	3706	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3706	25	must	must	MD
18637	3706	26	be	be	VB
18637	3706	27	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	3706	28	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	3706	29	and	and	CC
18637	3706	30	in	in	IN
18637	3706	31	good	good	JJ
18637	3706	32	faith	faith	NN
18637	3706	33	,	,	,
18637	3706	34	and	and	CC
18637	3706	35	that	that	IN
18637	3706	36	the	the	DT
18637	3706	37	alterations	alteration	NNS
18637	3706	38	made	make	VBN
18637	3706	39	must	must	MD
18637	3706	40	be	be	VB
18637	3706	41	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	3706	42	with	with	IN
18637	3706	43	the	the	DT
18637	3706	44	scope	scope	NN
18637	3706	45	and	and	CC
18637	3706	46	object	object	NN
18637	3706	47	of	of	IN
18637	3706	48	the	the	DT
18637	3706	49	grant	grant	NN
18637	3706	50	,	,	,
18637	3706	51	etc	etc	FW
18637	3706	52	.	.	.
18637	3707	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3707	2	1651	1651	CD
18637	3707	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3707	4	Such	such	JJ
18637	3707	5	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	3707	6	amount	amount	NN
18637	3707	7	,	,	,
18637	3707	8	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	3707	9	,	,	,
18637	3707	10	to	to	IN
18637	3707	11	little	little	JJ
18637	3707	12	more	more	JJR
18637	3707	13	than	than	IN
18637	3707	14	an	an	DT
18637	3707	15	anchor	anchor	NN
18637	3707	16	to	to	TO
18637	3707	17	windward	windward	NN
18637	3707	18	,	,	,
18637	3707	19	for	for	IN
18637	3707	20	while	while	IN
18637	3707	21	some	some	DT
18637	3707	22	of	of	IN
18637	3707	23	the	the	DT
18637	3707	24	State	State	NNP
18637	3707	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	3707	26	have	have	VBP
18637	3707	27	applied	apply	VBN
18637	3707	28	tests	test	NNS
18637	3707	29	of	of	IN
18637	3707	30	this	this	DT
18637	3707	31	nature	nature	NN
18637	3707	32	to	to	IN
18637	3707	33	the	the	DT
18637	3707	34	disallowance	disallowance	NN
18637	3707	35	of	of	IN
18637	3707	36	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3707	37	,	,	,
18637	3707	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3707	39	does	do	VBZ
18637	3707	40	not	not	RB
18637	3707	41	appear	appear	VB
18637	3707	42	that	that	IN
18637	3707	43	the	the	DT
18637	3707	44	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3707	45	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3707	46	of	of	IN
18637	3707	47	the	the	DT
18637	3707	48	United	United	NNP
18637	3707	49	States	States	NNP
18637	3707	50	has	have	VBZ
18637	3707	51	ever	ever	RB
18637	3707	52	done	do	VBN
18637	3707	53	so	so	RB
18637	3707	54	.	.	.
18637	3708	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3708	2	1652	1652	CD
18637	3708	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3708	4	Quite	quite	RB
18637	3708	5	different	different	JJ
18637	3708	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	3708	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3708	8	with	with	IN
18637	3708	9	the	the	DT
18637	3708	10	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	3708	11	pointed	point	VBD
18637	3708	12	out	out	RP
18637	3708	13	in	in	IN
18637	3708	14	the	the	DT
18637	3708	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	3708	16	between	between	IN
18637	3708	17	the	the	DT
18637	3708	18	franchises	franchise	NNS
18637	3708	19	and	and	CC
18637	3708	20	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3708	21	which	which	WDT
18637	3708	22	a	a	DT
18637	3708	23	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3708	24	derives	derive	VBZ
18637	3708	25	from	from	IN
18637	3708	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3708	27	charter	charter	NN
18637	3708	28	and	and	CC
18637	3708	29	the	the	DT
18637	3708	30	rights	right	NNS
18637	3708	31	of	of	IN
18637	3708	32	property	property	NN
18637	3708	33	and	and	CC
18637	3708	34	contract	contract	NN
18637	3708	35	which	which	WDT
18637	3708	36	accrue	accrue	RB
18637	3708	37	to	to	IN
18637	3708	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3708	39	in	in	IN
18637	3708	40	the	the	DT
18637	3708	41	course	course	NN
18637	3708	42	of	of	IN
18637	3708	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3708	44	existence	existence	NN
18637	3708	45	.	.	.
18637	3709	1	Even	even	RB
18637	3709	2	the	the	DT
18637	3709	3	outright	outright	JJ
18637	3709	4	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	3709	5	of	of	IN
18637	3709	6	the	the	DT
18637	3709	7	former	former	JJ
18637	3709	8	does	do	VBZ
18637	3709	9	not	not	RB
18637	3709	10	wipe	wipe	VB
18637	3709	11	out	out	RP
18637	3709	12	the	the	DT
18637	3709	13	latter	latter	JJ
18637	3709	14	or	or	CC
18637	3709	15	cause	cause	VB
18637	3709	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3709	17	to	to	TO
18637	3709	18	escheat	escheat	VB
18637	3709	19	to	to	IN
18637	3709	20	the	the	DT
18637	3709	21	State	State	NNP
18637	3709	22	.	.	.
18637	3710	1	The	the	DT
18637	3710	2	primary	primary	JJ
18637	3710	3	heirs	heir	NNS
18637	3710	4	of	of	IN
18637	3710	5	the	the	DT
18637	3710	6	defunct	defunct	JJ
18637	3710	7	organization	organization	NN
18637	3710	8	are	be	VBP
18637	3710	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3710	10	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	3710	11	;	;	:
18637	3710	12	but	but	CC
18637	3710	13	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	3710	14	of	of	IN
18637	3710	15	value	value	NN
18637	3710	16	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	3710	17	after	after	IN
18637	3710	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3710	19	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3710	20	claims	claim	NNS
18637	3710	21	are	be	VBP
18637	3710	22	met	meet	VBN
18637	3710	23	goes	go	VBZ
18637	3710	24	to	to	IN
18637	3710	25	the	the	DT
18637	3710	26	former	former	JJ
18637	3710	27	shareholders	shareholder	NNS
18637	3710	28	.	.	.
18637	3711	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3711	2	1653	1653	CD
18637	3711	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3711	4	By	by	IN
18637	3711	5	the	the	DT
18637	3711	6	earlier	early	JJR
18637	3711	7	weight	weight	NN
18637	3711	8	of	of	IN
18637	3711	9	authority	authority	NN
18637	3711	10	,	,	,
18637	3711	11	on	on	IN
18637	3711	12	the	the	DT
18637	3711	13	other	other	JJ
18637	3711	14	hand	hand	NN
18637	3711	15	,	,	,
18637	3711	16	persons	person	NNS
18637	3711	17	who	who	WP
18637	3711	18	contract	contract	VBP
18637	3711	19	with	with	IN
18637	3711	20	companies	company	NNS
18637	3711	21	whose	whose	WP$
18637	3711	22	charters	charter	NNS
18637	3711	23	are	be	VBP
18637	3711	24	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3711	25	to	to	IN
18637	3711	26	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3711	27	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	3711	28	or	or	CC
18637	3711	29	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	3711	30	do	do	VBP
18637	3711	31	so	so	RB
18637	3711	32	at	at	IN
18637	3711	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3711	34	own	own	JJ
18637	3711	35	risk	risk	NN
18637	3711	36	:	:	:
18637	3711	37	any	any	DT
18637	3711	38	"	"	``
18637	3711	39	such	such	JJ
18637	3711	40	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3711	41	made	make	VBN
18637	3711	42	between	between	IN
18637	3711	43	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	3711	44	and	and	CC
18637	3711	45	the	the	DT
18637	3711	46	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3711	47	do	do	VBP
18637	3711	48	not	not	RB
18637	3711	49	vary	vary	VB
18637	3711	50	or	or	CC
18637	3711	51	in	in	IN
18637	3711	52	any	any	DT
18637	3711	53	manner	manner	NN
18637	3711	54	change	change	NN
18637	3711	55	or	or	CC
18637	3711	56	modify	modify	VB
18637	3711	57	the	the	DT
18637	3711	58	relation	relation	NN
18637	3711	59	between	between	IN
18637	3711	60	the	the	DT
18637	3711	61	State	State	NNP
18637	3711	62	and	and	CC
18637	3711	63	the	the	DT
18637	3711	64	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3711	65	in	in	IN
18637	3711	66	respect	respect	NN
18637	3711	67	to	to	IN
18637	3711	68	the	the	DT
18637	3711	69	right	right	NN
18637	3711	70	of	of	IN
18637	3711	71	the	the	DT
18637	3711	72	State	State	NNP
18637	3711	73	to	to	TO
18637	3711	74	alter	alter	VB
18637	3711	75	,	,	,
18637	3711	76	modify	modify	VB
18637	3711	77	,	,	,
18637	3711	78	or	or	CC
18637	3711	79	amend	amend	VB
18637	3711	80	such	such	PDT
18637	3711	81	a	a	DT
18637	3711	82	charter	charter	NN
18637	3711	83	,	,	,
18637	3711	84	*	*	NFP
18637	3711	85	*	*	NFP
18637	3711	86	*	*	NFP
18637	3711	87	"	"	''
18637	3711	88	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3711	89	1654	1654	CD
18637	3711	90	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3711	91	But	but	CC
18637	3711	92	later	later	JJ
18637	3711	93	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	3711	94	becloud	becloud	RB
18637	3711	95	this	this	DT
18637	3711	96	rule	rule	NN
18637	3711	97	.	.	.
18637	3712	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3712	2	1655	1655	CD
18637	3712	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3712	4	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	3712	5	As	as	IN
18637	3712	6	Persons	person	NNS
18637	3712	7	Subject	subject	JJ
18637	3712	8	To	to	IN
18637	3712	9	The	the	DT
18637	3712	10	Law.--But	Law.--But	NNP
18637	3712	11	suppose	suppose	VBP
18637	3712	12	the	the	DT
18637	3712	13	State	state	NN
18637	3712	14	neglects	neglect	VBZ
18637	3712	15	to	to	TO
18637	3712	16	reserve	reserve	VB
18637	3712	17	the	the	DT
18637	3712	18	right	right	NN
18637	3712	19	to	to	TO
18637	3712	20	amend	amend	VB
18637	3712	21	,	,	,
18637	3712	22	alter	alter	VB
18637	3712	23	,	,	,
18637	3712	24	or	or	CC
18637	3712	25	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	3712	26	--	--	:
18637	3712	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	3712	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3712	29	,	,	,
18637	3712	30	then	then	RB
18637	3712	31	,	,	,
18637	3712	32	without	without	IN
18637	3712	33	power	power	NN
18637	3712	34	to	to	TO
18637	3712	35	control	control	VB
18637	3712	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3712	37	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	3712	38	creatures	creature	NNS
18637	3712	39	?	?	.
18637	3713	1	By	by	IN
18637	3713	2	no	no	DT
18637	3713	3	means	means	NN
18637	3713	4	.	.	.
18637	3714	1	Private	private	JJ
18637	3714	2	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	3714	3	,	,	,
18637	3714	4	like	like	IN
18637	3714	5	other	other	JJ
18637	3714	6	private	private	JJ
18637	3714	7	persons	person	NNS
18637	3714	8	,	,	,
18637	3714	9	are	be	VBP
18637	3714	10	always	always	RB
18637	3714	11	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	3714	12	to	to	TO
18637	3714	13	be	be	VB
18637	3714	14	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3714	15	to	to	IN
18637	3714	16	the	the	DT
18637	3714	17	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3714	18	power	power	NN
18637	3714	19	of	of	IN
18637	3714	20	the	the	DT
18637	3714	21	State	State	NNP
18637	3714	22	;	;	:
18637	3714	23	from	from	IN
18637	3714	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3714	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3714	26	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	3714	27	that	that	IN
18637	3714	28	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	3714	29	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	3714	30	by	by	IN
18637	3714	31	charter	charter	NN
18637	3714	32	are	be	VBP
18637	3714	33	to	to	TO
18637	3714	34	be	be	VB
18637	3714	35	treated	treat	VBN
18637	3714	36	as	as	IN
18637	3714	37	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	3714	38	to	to	IN
18637	3714	39	an	an	DT
18637	3714	40	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	3714	41	controlling	controlling	JJ
18637	3714	42	rule	rule	NN
18637	3714	43	.	.	.
18637	3715	1	This	this	DT
18637	3715	2	principle	principle	NN
18637	3715	3	was	be	VBD
18637	3715	4	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	3715	5	by	by	IN
18637	3715	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3715	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3715	8	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3715	9	in	in	IN
18637	3715	10	the	the	DT
18637	3715	11	case	case	NN
18637	3715	12	of	of	IN
18637	3715	13	Providence	Providence	NNP
18637	3715	14	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	3715	15	_	_	NNP
18637	3715	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	3715	17	_	_	NNP
18637	3715	18	Billings,[1656	Billings,[1656	NNP
18637	3715	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3715	20	in	in	IN
18637	3715	21	which	which	WDT
18637	3715	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3715	23	held	hold	VBD
18637	3715	24	that	that	IN
18637	3715	25	in	in	IN
18637	3715	26	the	the	DT
18637	3715	27	absence	absence	NN
18637	3715	28	of	of	IN
18637	3715	29	express	express	JJ
18637	3715	30	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	3715	31	or	or	CC
18637	3715	32	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	3715	33	implication	implication	NN
18637	3715	34	to	to	IN
18637	3715	35	the	the	DT
18637	3715	36	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	3715	37	in	in	IN
18637	3715	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3715	39	charter	charter	NN
18637	3715	40	,	,	,
18637	3715	41	the	the	DT
18637	3715	42	bank	bank	NN
18637	3715	43	was	be	VBD
18637	3715	44	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3715	45	to	to	IN
18637	3715	46	the	the	DT
18637	3715	47	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	3715	48	power	power	NN
18637	3715	49	of	of	IN
18637	3715	50	the	the	DT
18637	3715	51	State	State	NNP
18637	3715	52	,	,	,
18637	3715	53	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	3715	54	that	that	IN
18637	3715	55	the	the	DT
18637	3715	56	power	power	NN
18637	3715	57	to	to	TO
18637	3715	58	tax	tax	NN
18637	3715	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	3715	60	the	the	DT
18637	3715	61	power	power	NN
18637	3715	62	to	to	TO
18637	3715	63	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	3715	64	.	.	.
18637	3716	1	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	3716	2	and	and	CC
18637	3716	3	the	the	DT
18637	3716	4	Police	Police	NNS
18637	3716	5	Power.--And	power.--and	RB
18637	3716	6	of	of	IN
18637	3716	7	course	course	NN
18637	3716	8	the	the	DT
18637	3716	9	same	same	JJ
18637	3716	10	principle	principle	NN
18637	3716	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	3716	12	equally	equally	RB
18637	3716	13	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	3716	14	to	to	IN
18637	3716	15	the	the	DT
18637	3716	16	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3716	17	by	by	IN
18637	3716	18	the	the	DT
18637	3716	19	State	State	NNP
18637	3716	20	of	of	IN
18637	3716	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3716	22	police	police	NN
18637	3716	23	powers	power	NNS
18637	3716	24	.	.	.
18637	3717	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	3717	2	,	,	,
18637	3717	3	in	in	IN
18637	3717	4	what	what	WP
18637	3717	5	was	be	VBD
18637	3717	6	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	3717	7	the	the	DT
18637	3717	8	leading	lead	VBG
18637	3717	9	case	case	NN
18637	3717	10	before	before	IN
18637	3717	11	the	the	DT
18637	3717	12	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3717	13	War	War	NNP
18637	3717	14	,	,	,
18637	3717	15	the	the	DT
18637	3717	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3717	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3717	18	of	of	IN
18637	3717	19	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	3717	20	held	hold	VBD
18637	3717	21	that	that	IN
18637	3717	22	the	the	DT
18637	3717	23	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3717	24	of	of	IN
18637	3717	25	that	that	DT
18637	3717	26	State	State	NNP
18637	3717	27	had	have	VBD
18637	3717	28	the	the	DT
18637	3717	29	right	right	NN
18637	3717	30	,	,	,
18637	3717	31	in	in	IN
18637	3717	32	furtherance	furtherance	NN
18637	3717	33	of	of	IN
18637	3717	34	the	the	DT
18637	3717	35	public	public	JJ
18637	3717	36	safety	safety	NN
18637	3717	37	,	,	,
18637	3717	38	to	to	TO
18637	3717	39	require	require	VB
18637	3717	40	chartered	chartered	JJ
18637	3717	41	companies	company	NNS
18637	3717	42	operating	operate	VBG
18637	3717	43	railways	railway	NNS
18637	3717	44	to	to	TO
18637	3717	45	fence	fence	VB
18637	3717	46	in	in	IN
18637	3717	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3717	48	tracks	track	NNS
18637	3717	49	and	and	CC
18637	3717	50	provide	provide	VB
18637	3717	51	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	3717	52	yards	yard	NNS
18637	3717	53	.	.	.
18637	3718	1	In	in	IN
18637	3718	2	a	a	DT
18637	3718	3	matter	matter	NN
18637	3718	4	of	of	IN
18637	3718	5	this	this	DT
18637	3718	6	nature	nature	NN
18637	3718	7	,	,	,
18637	3718	8	said	say	VBD
18637	3718	9	the	the	DT
18637	3718	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3718	11	,	,	,
18637	3718	12	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	3718	13	are	be	VBP
18637	3718	14	on	on	IN
18637	3718	15	a	a	DT
18637	3718	16	level	level	NN
18637	3718	17	with	with	IN
18637	3718	18	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	3718	19	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	3718	20	in	in	IN
18637	3718	21	the	the	DT
18637	3718	22	same	same	JJ
18637	3718	23	business	business	NN
18637	3718	24	,	,	,
18637	3718	25	unless	unless	IN
18637	3718	26	,	,	,
18637	3718	27	from	from	IN
18637	3718	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3718	29	charter	charter	NN
18637	3718	30	,	,	,
18637	3718	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3718	32	can	can	MD
18637	3718	33	prove	prove	VB
18637	3718	34	the	the	DT
18637	3718	35	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	3718	36	.	.	.
18637	3719	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3719	2	1657	1657	CD
18637	3719	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3719	4	Since	since	IN
18637	3719	5	then	then	RB
18637	3719	6	the	the	DT
18637	3719	7	rule	rule	NN
18637	3719	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	3719	9	been	be	VBN
18637	3719	10	applied	apply	VBN
18637	3719	11	many	many	JJ
18637	3719	12	times	time	NNS
18637	3719	13	in	in	IN
18637	3719	14	justification	justification	NN
18637	3719	15	of	of	IN
18637	3719	16	State	State	NNP
18637	3719	17	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	3719	18	of	of	IN
18637	3719	19	railroads,[1658	railroads,[1658	NNP
18637	3719	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3719	21	and	and	CC
18637	3719	22	even	even	RB
18637	3719	23	of	of	IN
18637	3719	24	the	the	DT
18637	3719	25	application	application	NN
18637	3719	26	of	of	IN
18637	3719	27	a	a	DT
18637	3719	28	State	State	NNP
18637	3719	29	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3719	30	law	law	NN
18637	3719	31	to	to	IN
18637	3719	32	a	a	DT
18637	3719	33	company	company	NN
18637	3719	34	which	which	WDT
18637	3719	35	had	have	VBD
18637	3719	36	been	be	VBN
18637	3719	37	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	3719	38	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	3719	39	to	to	TO
18637	3719	40	manufacture	manufacture	VB
18637	3719	41	beer	beer	NN
18637	3719	42	.	.	.
18637	3720	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3720	2	1659	1659	CD
18637	3720	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3720	4	The	the	DT
18637	3720	5	Strict	strict	JJ
18637	3720	6	Construction	Construction	NNP
18637	3720	7	of	of	IN
18637	3720	8	Public	Public	NNP
18637	3720	9	Grants	Grants	NNPS
18637	3720	10	Long	Long	NNP
18637	3720	11	,	,	,
18637	3720	12	however	however	RB
18637	3720	13	,	,	,
18637	3720	14	before	before	IN
18637	3720	15	the	the	DT
18637	3720	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	3720	17	last	last	JJ
18637	3720	18	cited	cite	VBN
18637	3720	19	were	be	VBD
18637	3720	20	decided	decide	VBN
18637	3720	21	,	,	,
18637	3720	22	the	the	DT
18637	3720	23	principle	principle	NN
18637	3720	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3720	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3720	26	illustrate	illustrate	VBP
18637	3720	27	had	have	VBD
18637	3720	28	come	come	VBN
18637	3720	29	to	to	TO
18637	3720	30	be	be	VB
18637	3720	31	powerfully	powerfully	RB
18637	3720	32	reinforced	reinforce	VBN
18637	3720	33	by	by	IN
18637	3720	34	two	two	CD
18637	3720	35	others	other	NNS
18637	3720	36	,	,	,
18637	3720	37	the	the	DT
18637	3720	38	first	first	JJ
18637	3720	39	of	of	IN
18637	3720	40	which	which	WDT
18637	3720	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	3720	42	that	that	IN
18637	3720	43	all	all	DT
18637	3720	44	charter	charter	NN
18637	3720	45	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3720	46	and	and	CC
18637	3720	47	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	3720	48	are	be	VBP
18637	3720	49	to	to	TO
18637	3720	50	be	be	VB
18637	3720	51	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	3720	52	construed	construe	VBN
18637	3720	53	as	as	IN
18637	3720	54	against	against	IN
18637	3720	55	the	the	DT
18637	3720	56	claims	claim	NNS
18637	3720	57	of	of	IN
18637	3720	58	the	the	DT
18637	3720	59	State	state	NN
18637	3720	60	;	;	:
18637	3720	61	or	or	CC
18637	3720	62	as	as	IN
18637	3720	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3720	64	is	be	VBZ
18637	3720	65	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	3720	66	often	often	RB
18637	3720	67	phrased	phrase	VBN
18637	3720	68	,	,	,
18637	3720	69	"	"	``
18637	3720	70	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	3720	71	passes	pass	VBZ
18637	3720	72	by	by	IN
18637	3720	73	implication	implication	NN
18637	3720	74	in	in	IN
18637	3720	75	a	a	DT
18637	3720	76	public	public	JJ
18637	3720	77	grant	grant	NN
18637	3720	78	.	.	.
18637	3720	79	"	"	''
18637	3721	1	The	the	DT
18637	3721	2	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	3721	3	River	River	NNP
18637	3721	4	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	3721	5	Case.--The	Case.--The	NNP
18637	3721	6	leading	leading	JJ
18637	3721	7	case	case	NN
18637	3721	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	3721	9	that	that	DT
18637	3721	10	of	of	IN
18637	3721	11	the	the	DT
18637	3721	12	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	3721	13	River	River	NNP
18637	3721	14	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	3721	15	Company	Company	NNP
18637	3721	16	_	_	NNP
18637	3721	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	3721	18	_	_	NNP
18637	3721	19	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	3721	20	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	3721	21	Company,[1660	company,[1660	NN
18637	3721	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3721	23	which	which	WDT
18637	3721	24	was	be	VBD
18637	3721	25	decided	decide	VBN
18637	3721	26	shortly	shortly	RB
18637	3721	27	after	after	IN
18637	3721	28	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3721	29	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3721	30	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3721	31	's	's	POS
18637	3721	32	death	death	NN
18637	3721	33	by	by	IN
18637	3721	34	a	a	DT
18637	3721	35	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	3721	36	new	new	JJ
18637	3721	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3721	38	.	.	.
18637	3722	1	The	the	DT
18637	3722	2	question	question	NN
18637	3722	3	at	at	IN
18637	3722	4	issue	issue	NN
18637	3722	5	was	be	VBD
18637	3722	6	whether	whether	IN
18637	3722	7	the	the	DT
18637	3722	8	charter	charter	NN
18637	3722	9	of	of	IN
18637	3722	10	the	the	DT
18637	3722	11	complaining	complain	VBG
18637	3722	12	company	company	NN
18637	3722	13	,	,	,
18637	3722	14	which	which	WDT
18637	3722	15	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	3722	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3722	17	to	to	TO
18637	3722	18	operate	operate	VB
18637	3722	19	a	a	DT
18637	3722	20	toll	toll	NN
18637	3722	21	bridge	bridge	NN
18637	3722	22	,	,	,
18637	3722	23	stood	stand	VBD
18637	3722	24	in	in	IN
18637	3722	25	the	the	DT
18637	3722	26	way	way	NN
18637	3722	27	of	of	IN
18637	3722	28	the	the	DT
18637	3722	29	State	State	NNP
18637	3722	30	's	's	POS
18637	3722	31	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	3722	32	another	another	DT
18637	3722	33	company	company	NN
18637	3722	34	of	of	IN
18637	3722	35	later	late	JJR
18637	3722	36	date	date	NN
18637	3722	37	to	to	TO
18637	3722	38	operate	operate	VB
18637	3722	39	a	a	DT
18637	3722	40	free	free	JJ
18637	3722	41	bridge	bridge	NN
18637	3722	42	in	in	IN
18637	3722	43	the	the	DT
18637	3722	44	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	3722	45	vicinity	vicinity	NN
18637	3722	46	.	.	.
18637	3723	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	3723	2	as	as	IN
18637	3723	3	the	the	DT
18637	3723	4	first	first	JJ
18637	3723	5	company	company	NN
18637	3723	6	could	could	MD
18637	3723	7	point	point	VB
18637	3723	8	to	to	IN
18637	3723	9	no	no	DT
18637	3723	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	3723	11	in	in	IN
18637	3723	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3723	13	charter	charter	NN
18637	3723	14	which	which	WDT
18637	3723	15	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	3723	16	vested	vest	VBD
18637	3723	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3723	18	with	with	IN
18637	3723	19	an	an	DT
18637	3723	20	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3723	21	right	right	NN
18637	3723	22	,	,	,
18637	3723	23	the	the	DT
18637	3723	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3723	25	held	hold	VBD
18637	3723	26	the	the	DT
18637	3723	27	charter	charter	NN
18637	3723	28	of	of	IN
18637	3723	29	the	the	DT
18637	3723	30	second	second	JJ
18637	3723	31	company	company	NN
18637	3723	32	to	to	TO
18637	3723	33	be	be	VB
18637	3723	34	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3723	35	on	on	IN
18637	3723	36	the	the	DT
18637	3723	37	principle	principle	NN
18637	3723	38	just	just	RB
18637	3723	39	stated	state	VBD
18637	3723	40	.	.	.
18637	3724	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3724	2	Story	Story	NNP
18637	3724	3	,	,	,
18637	3724	4	who	who	WP
18637	3724	5	remained	remain	VBD
18637	3724	6	from	from	IN
18637	3724	7	the	the	DT
18637	3724	8	old	old	JJ
18637	3724	9	Bench	Bench	NNP
18637	3724	10	,	,	,
18637	3724	11	presented	present	VBD
18637	3724	12	a	a	DT
18637	3724	13	vigorous	vigorous	JJ
18637	3724	14	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	3724	15	,	,	,
18637	3724	16	in	in	IN
18637	3724	17	which	which	WDT
18637	3724	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3724	19	argued	argue	VBD
18637	3724	20	cogently	cogently	RB
18637	3724	21	,	,	,
18637	3724	22	but	but	CC
18637	3724	23	unavailingly	unavailingly	RB
18637	3724	24	,	,	,
18637	3724	25	that	that	IN
18637	3724	26	the	the	DT
18637	3724	27	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	3724	28	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	3724	29	by	by	IN
18637	3724	30	the	the	DT
18637	3724	31	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	3724	32	River	River	NNP
18637	3724	33	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	3724	34	Company	Company	NNP
18637	3724	35	was	be	VBD
18637	3724	36	fully	fully	RB
18637	3724	37	as	as	RB
18637	3724	38	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	3724	39	an	an	DT
18637	3724	40	implication	implication	NN
18637	3724	41	from	from	IN
18637	3724	42	the	the	DT
18637	3724	43	terms	term	NNS
18637	3724	44	of	of	IN
18637	3724	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3724	46	charter	charter	NN
18637	3724	47	and	and	CC
18637	3724	48	the	the	DT
18637	3724	49	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	3724	50	surrounding	surround	VBG
18637	3724	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3724	52	concession	concession	NN
18637	3724	53	as	as	IN
18637	3724	54	perpetuity	perpetuity	NN
18637	3724	55	had	have	VBD
18637	3724	56	been	be	VBN
18637	3724	57	from	from	IN
18637	3724	58	the	the	DT
18637	3724	59	terms	term	NNS
18637	3724	60	of	of	IN
18637	3724	61	the	the	DT
18637	3724	62	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	3724	63	College	College	NNP
18637	3724	64	charter	charter	NN
18637	3724	65	and	and	CC
18637	3724	66	the	the	DT
18637	3724	67	environing	environing	NN
18637	3724	68	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	3724	69	.	.	.
18637	3725	1	The	the	DT
18637	3725	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3725	3	was	be	VBD
18637	3725	4	in	in	IN
18637	3725	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	3725	6	making	make	VBG
18637	3725	7	new	new	JJ
18637	3725	8	law	law	NN
18637	3725	9	,	,	,
18637	3725	10	because	because	IN
18637	3725	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3725	12	was	be	VBD
18637	3725	13	looking	look	VBG
18637	3725	14	at	at	IN
18637	3725	15	things	thing	NNS
18637	3725	16	from	from	IN
18637	3725	17	a	a	DT
18637	3725	18	new	new	JJ
18637	3725	19	point	point	NN
18637	3725	20	of	of	IN
18637	3725	21	view	view	NN
18637	3725	22	.	.	.
18637	3726	1	This	this	DT
18637	3726	2	was	be	VBD
18637	3726	3	the	the	DT
18637	3726	4	period	period	NN
18637	3726	5	when	when	WRB
18637	3726	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3726	7	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	3726	8	of	of	IN
18637	3726	9	the	the	DT
18637	3726	10	Police	Police	NNP
18637	3726	11	Power	Power	NNP
18637	3726	12	began	begin	VBD
18637	3726	13	to	to	TO
18637	3726	14	take	take	VB
18637	3726	15	on	on	RP
18637	3726	16	a	a	DT
18637	3726	17	doctrinal	doctrinal	JJ
18637	3726	18	character	character	NN
18637	3726	19	.	.	.
18637	3727	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3727	2	was	be	VBD
18637	3727	3	also	also	RB
18637	3727	4	the	the	DT
18637	3727	5	period	period	NN
18637	3727	6	when	when	WRB
18637	3727	7	the	the	DT
18637	3727	8	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	3727	9	business	business	NN
18637	3727	10	was	be	VBD
18637	3727	11	just	just	RB
18637	3727	12	beginning	begin	VBG
18637	3727	13	.	.	.
18637	3728	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3728	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3728	3	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	3728	4	's	's	POS
18637	3728	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3728	6	evinces	evince	VBZ
18637	3728	7	the	the	DT
18637	3728	8	influence	influence	NN
18637	3728	9	of	of	IN
18637	3728	10	both	both	PDT
18637	3728	11	these	these	DT
18637	3728	12	developments	development	NNS
18637	3728	13	.	.	.
18637	3729	1	The	the	DT
18637	3729	2	power	power	NN
18637	3729	3	of	of	IN
18637	3729	4	the	the	DT
18637	3729	5	State	State	NNP
18637	3729	6	to	to	TO
18637	3729	7	provide	provide	VB
18637	3729	8	for	for	IN
18637	3729	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3729	10	own	own	JJ
18637	3729	11	internal	internal	JJ
18637	3729	12	happiness	happiness	NN
18637	3729	13	and	and	CC
18637	3729	14	prosperity	prosperity	NN
18637	3729	15	was	be	VBD
18637	3729	16	not	not	RB
18637	3729	17	,	,	,
18637	3729	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3729	19	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	3729	20	,	,	,
18637	3729	21	to	to	TO
18637	3729	22	be	be	VB
18637	3729	23	pared	pare	VBN
18637	3729	24	away	away	RP
18637	3729	25	by	by	IN
18637	3729	26	mere	mere	JJ
18637	3729	27	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3729	28	intendments	intendment	NNS
18637	3729	29	;	;	:
18637	3729	30	nor	nor	CC
18637	3729	31	was	be	VBD
18637	3729	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3729	33	ability	ability	NN
18637	3729	34	to	to	TO
18637	3729	35	avail	avail	VB
18637	3729	36	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3729	37	of	of	IN
18637	3729	38	the	the	DT
18637	3729	39	lights	light	NNS
18637	3729	40	of	of	IN
18637	3729	41	modern	modern	JJ
18637	3729	42	science	science	NN
18637	3729	43	to	to	TO
18637	3729	44	be	be	VB
18637	3729	45	frustrated	frustrate	VBN
18637	3729	46	by	by	IN
18637	3729	47	obsolete	obsolete	JJ
18637	3729	48	interests	interest	NNS
18637	3729	49	such	such	JJ
18637	3729	50	as	as	IN
18637	3729	51	those	those	DT
18637	3729	52	of	of	IN
18637	3729	53	the	the	DT
18637	3729	54	old	old	JJ
18637	3729	55	turnpike	turnpike	JJ
18637	3729	56	companies	company	NNS
18637	3729	57	,	,	,
18637	3729	58	the	the	DT
18637	3729	59	charter	charter	NN
18637	3729	60	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3729	61	of	of	IN
18637	3729	62	which	which	WDT
18637	3729	63	,	,	,
18637	3729	64	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3729	65	apprehended	apprehend	VBD
18637	3729	66	,	,	,
18637	3729	67	might	may	MD
18637	3729	68	easily	easily	RB
18637	3729	69	become	become	VB
18637	3729	70	a	a	DT
18637	3729	71	bar	bar	NN
18637	3729	72	to	to	IN
18637	3729	73	the	the	DT
18637	3729	74	development	development	NN
18637	3729	75	of	of	IN
18637	3729	76	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	3729	77	along	along	IN
18637	3729	78	new	new	JJ
18637	3729	79	lines	line	NNS
18637	3729	80	.	.	.
18637	3730	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3730	2	1661	1661	CD
18637	3730	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3730	4	Applications	Applications	NNPS
18637	3730	5	of	of	IN
18637	3730	6	the	the	DT
18637	3730	7	Strict	Strict	NNP
18637	3730	8	Construction	Construction	NNP
18637	3730	9	Rule.--The	Rule.--The	NNP
18637	3730	10	rule	rule	NN
18637	3730	11	of	of	IN
18637	3730	12	strict	strict	JJ
18637	3730	13	construction	construction	NN
18637	3730	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	3730	15	been	be	VBN
18637	3730	16	reiterated	reiterate	VBN
18637	3730	17	by	by	IN
18637	3730	18	the	the	DT
18637	3730	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3730	20	many	many	JJ
18637	3730	21	times	time	NNS
18637	3730	22	.	.	.
18637	3731	1	A	a	DT
18637	3731	2	good	good	JJ
18637	3731	3	illustration	illustration	NN
18637	3731	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	3731	5	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	3731	6	by	by	IN
18637	3731	7	the	the	DT
18637	3731	8	following	follow	VBG
18637	3731	9	passage	passage	NN
18637	3731	10	from	from	IN
18637	3731	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3731	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3731	13	in	in	IN
18637	3731	14	Blair	Blair	NNP
18637	3731	15	_	_	NNP
18637	3731	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	3731	17	_	_	NNP
18637	3731	18	Chicago,[1662	Chicago,[1662	NNP
18637	3731	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3731	20	decided	decide	VBD
18637	3731	21	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	3731	22	seventy	seventy	CD
18637	3731	23	years	year	NNS
18637	3731	24	after	after	IN
18637	3731	25	the	the	DT
18637	3731	26	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	3731	27	River	River	NNP
18637	3731	28	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	3731	29	Case	case	NN
18637	3731	30	:	:	:
18637	3731	31	"	"	``
18637	3731	32	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3731	33	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3731	34	of	of	IN
18637	3731	35	this	this	DT
18637	3731	36	character	character	NN
18637	3731	37	should	should	MD
18637	3731	38	be	be	VB
18637	3731	39	in	in	IN
18637	3731	40	such	such	JJ
18637	3731	41	unequivocal	unequivocal	JJ
18637	3731	42	form	form	NN
18637	3731	43	of	of	IN
18637	3731	44	expression	expression	NN
18637	3731	45	that	that	IN
18637	3731	46	the	the	DT
18637	3731	47	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3731	48	mind	mind	NN
18637	3731	49	may	may	MD
18637	3731	50	be	be	VB
18637	3731	51	distinctly	distinctly	RB
18637	3731	52	impressed	impressed	JJ
18637	3731	53	with	with	IN
18637	3731	54	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3731	55	character	character	NN
18637	3731	56	and	and	CC
18637	3731	57	import	import	NN
18637	3731	58	,	,	,
18637	3731	59	in	in	IN
18637	3731	60	order	order	NN
18637	3731	61	that	that	IN
18637	3731	62	the	the	DT
18637	3731	63	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3731	64	may	may	MD
18637	3731	65	be	be	VB
18637	3731	66	intelligently	intelligently	RB
18637	3731	67	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3731	68	or	or	CC
18637	3731	69	purposely	purposely	RB
18637	3731	70	withheld	withhold	VBN
18637	3731	71	.	.	.
18637	3732	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3732	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	3732	3	a	a	DT
18637	3732	4	matter	matter	NN
18637	3732	5	of	of	IN
18637	3732	6	common	common	JJ
18637	3732	7	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	3732	8	that	that	IN
18637	3732	9	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3732	10	of	of	IN
18637	3732	11	this	this	DT
18637	3732	12	character	character	NN
18637	3732	13	are	be	VBP
18637	3732	14	usually	usually	RB
18637	3732	15	prepared	prepare	VBN
18637	3732	16	by	by	IN
18637	3732	17	those	those	DT
18637	3732	18	interested	interested	JJ
18637	3732	19	in	in	IN
18637	3732	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3732	21	,	,	,
18637	3732	22	and	and	CC
18637	3732	23	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	3732	24	to	to	IN
18637	3732	25	the	the	DT
18637	3732	26	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3732	27	with	with	IN
18637	3732	28	a	a	DT
18637	3732	29	view	view	NN
18637	3732	30	to	to	TO
18637	3732	31	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	3732	32	from	from	IN
18637	3732	33	such	such	JJ
18637	3732	34	bodies	body	NNS
18637	3732	35	the	the	DT
18637	3732	36	most	most	RBS
18637	3732	37	liberal	liberal	JJ
18637	3732	38	grant	grant	NN
18637	3732	39	of	of	IN
18637	3732	40	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3732	41	which	which	WDT
18637	3732	42	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3732	43	are	be	VBP
18637	3732	44	willing	willing	JJ
18637	3732	45	to	to	TO
18637	3732	46	give	give	VB
18637	3732	47	.	.	.
18637	3733	1	This	this	DT
18637	3733	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	3733	3	one	one	CD
18637	3733	4	among	among	IN
18637	3733	5	many	many	JJ
18637	3733	6	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	3733	7	why	why	WRB
18637	3733	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3733	9	are	be	VBP
18637	3733	10	to	to	TO
18637	3733	11	be	be	VB
18637	3733	12	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	3733	13	construed	construe	VBN
18637	3733	14	.	.	.
18637	3734	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3734	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3734	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3734	4	'	'	''
18637	3734	5	The	the	DT
18637	3734	6	principle	principle	NN
18637	3734	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	3734	8	this	this	DT
18637	3734	9	,	,	,
18637	3734	10	that	that	IN
18637	3734	11	all	all	DT
18637	3734	12	rights	right	NNS
18637	3734	13	which	which	WDT
18637	3734	14	are	be	VBP
18637	3734	15	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	3734	16	against	against	IN
18637	3734	17	the	the	DT
18637	3734	18	State	state	NN
18637	3734	19	must	must	MD
18637	3734	20	be	be	VB
18637	3734	21	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	3734	22	defined	define	VBN
18637	3734	23	,	,	,
18637	3734	24	and	and	CC
18637	3734	25	not	not	RB
18637	3734	26	raised	raise	VBN
18637	3734	27	by	by	IN
18637	3734	28	inference	inference	NN
18637	3734	29	or	or	CC
18637	3734	30	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	3734	31	;	;	:
18637	3734	32	and	and	CC
18637	3734	33	if	if	IN
18637	3734	34	the	the	DT
18637	3734	35	charter	charter	NN
18637	3734	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	3734	37	silent	silent	JJ
18637	3734	38	about	about	IN
18637	3734	39	a	a	DT
18637	3734	40	power	power	NN
18637	3734	41	,	,	,
18637	3734	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3734	43	does	do	VBZ
18637	3734	44	not	not	RB
18637	3734	45	exist	exist	VB
18637	3734	46	.	.	.
18637	3735	1	If	if	IN
18637	3735	2	,	,	,
18637	3735	3	on	on	IN
18637	3735	4	a	a	DT
18637	3735	5	fair	fair	JJ
18637	3735	6	reading	reading	NN
18637	3735	7	of	of	IN
18637	3735	8	the	the	DT
18637	3735	9	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	3735	10	,	,	,
18637	3735	11	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	3735	12	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	3735	13	arise	arise	VBP
18637	3735	14	as	as	IN
18637	3735	15	to	to	IN
18637	3735	16	the	the	DT
18637	3735	17	proper	proper	JJ
18637	3735	18	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	3735	19	to	to	TO
18637	3735	20	be	be	VB
18637	3735	21	given	give	VBN
18637	3735	22	to	to	IN
18637	3735	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3735	24	,	,	,
18637	3735	25	those	those	DT
18637	3735	26	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	3735	27	are	be	VBP
18637	3735	28	to	to	TO
18637	3735	29	be	be	VB
18637	3735	30	solved	solve	VBN
18637	3735	31	in	in	IN
18637	3735	32	favor	favor	NN
18637	3735	33	of	of	IN
18637	3735	34	the	the	DT
18637	3735	35	State	state	NN
18637	3735	36	;	;	:
18637	3735	37	and	and	CC
18637	3735	38	where	where	WRB
18637	3735	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3735	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	3735	41	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
18637	3735	42	of	of	IN
18637	3735	43	two	two	CD
18637	3735	44	meanings	meaning	NNS
18637	3735	45	,	,	,
18637	3735	46	the	the	DT
18637	3735	47	one	one	NN
18637	3735	48	restricting	restricting	NN
18637	3735	49	and	and	CC
18637	3735	50	the	the	DT
18637	3735	51	other	other	JJ
18637	3735	52	extending	extend	VBG
18637	3735	53	the	the	DT
18637	3735	54	powers	power	NNS
18637	3735	55	of	of	IN
18637	3735	56	the	the	DT
18637	3735	57	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3735	58	,	,	,
18637	3735	59	that	that	DT
18637	3735	60	construction	construction	NN
18637	3735	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	3735	62	to	to	TO
18637	3735	63	be	be	VB
18637	3735	64	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	3735	65	which	which	WDT
18637	3735	66	works	work	VBZ
18637	3735	67	the	the	DT
18637	3735	68	least	least	JJS
18637	3735	69	harm	harm	NN
18637	3735	70	to	to	IN
18637	3735	71	the	the	DT
18637	3735	72	State	State	NNP
18637	3735	73	.	.	.
18637	3736	1	'	'	``
18637	3736	2	"	"	``
18637	3736	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3736	4	1663	1663	CD
18637	3736	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3736	6	Strict	Strict	NNP
18637	3736	7	Construction	Construction	NNP
18637	3736	8	of	of	IN
18637	3736	9	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	3736	10	Exemptions.--An	Exemptions.--An	NNP
18637	3736	11	excellent	excellent	JJ
18637	3736	12	illustration	illustration	NN
18637	3736	13	of	of	IN
18637	3736	14	the	the	DT
18637	3736	15	operation	operation	NN
18637	3736	16	of	of	IN
18637	3736	17	the	the	DT
18637	3736	18	rule	rule	NN
18637	3736	19	in	in	IN
18637	3736	20	relation	relation	NN
18637	3736	21	to	to	IN
18637	3736	22	tax	tax	NN
18637	3736	23	exemptions	exemption	NNS
18637	3736	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	3736	25	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	3736	26	by	by	IN
18637	3736	27	the	the	DT
18637	3736	28	derivative	derivative	JJ
18637	3736	29	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3736	30	that	that	IN
18637	3736	31	an	an	DT
18637	3736	32	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	3736	33	of	of	IN
18637	3736	34	this	this	DT
18637	3736	35	character	character	NN
18637	3736	36	must	must	MD
18637	3736	37	be	be	VB
18637	3736	38	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	3736	39	as	as	IN
18637	3736	40	intended	intend	VBN
18637	3736	41	solely	solely	RB
18637	3736	42	for	for	IN
18637	3736	43	the	the	DT
18637	3736	44	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	3736	45	of	of	IN
18637	3736	46	the	the	DT
18637	3736	47	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3736	48	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	3736	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3736	50	and	and	CC
18637	3736	51	hence	hence	RB
18637	3736	52	may	may	MD
18637	3736	53	not	not	RB
18637	3736	54	,	,	,
18637	3736	55	in	in	IN
18637	3736	56	the	the	DT
18637	3736	57	absence	absence	NN
18637	3736	58	of	of	IN
18637	3736	59	express	express	JJ
18637	3736	60	permission	permission	NN
18637	3736	61	by	by	IN
18637	3736	62	the	the	DT
18637	3736	63	State	state	NN
18637	3736	64	,	,	,
18637	3736	65	be	be	VB
18637	3736	66	passed	pass	VBN
18637	3736	67	on	on	RP
18637	3736	68	to	to	IN
18637	3736	69	a	a	DT
18637	3736	70	successor	successor	NN
18637	3736	71	.	.	.
18637	3737	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3737	2	1664	1664	CD
18637	3737	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3737	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	3737	5	,	,	,
18637	3737	6	where	where	WRB
18637	3737	7	two	two	CD
18637	3737	8	companies	company	NNS
18637	3737	9	,	,	,
18637	3737	10	each	each	DT
18637	3737	11	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	3737	12	from	from	IN
18637	3737	13	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3737	14	,	,	,
18637	3737	15	were	be	VBD
18637	3737	16	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	3737	17	by	by	IN
18637	3737	18	the	the	DT
18637	3737	19	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3737	20	to	to	TO
18637	3737	21	consolidate	consolidate	VB
18637	3737	22	the	the	DT
18637	3737	23	new	new	JJ
18637	3737	24	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3737	25	was	be	VBD
18637	3737	26	held	hold	VBN
18637	3737	27	to	to	TO
18637	3737	28	be	be	VB
18637	3737	29	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3737	30	to	to	IN
18637	3737	31	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3737	32	.	.	.
18637	3738	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3738	2	1665	1665	CD
18637	3738	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3738	4	Again	again	RB
18637	3738	5	,	,	,
18637	3738	6	a	a	DT
18637	3738	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	3738	8	which	which	WDT
18637	3738	9	granted	grant	VBD
18637	3738	10	a	a	DT
18637	3738	11	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3738	12	all	all	DT
18637	3738	13	"	"	``
18637	3738	14	the	the	DT
18637	3738	15	rights	right	NNS
18637	3738	16	and	and	CC
18637	3738	17	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3738	18	"	"	''
18637	3738	19	of	of	IN
18637	3738	20	an	an	DT
18637	3738	21	earlier	early	JJR
18637	3738	22	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3738	23	was	be	VBD
18637	3738	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	3738	25	not	not	RB
18637	3738	26	to	to	TO
18637	3738	27	confer	confer	VB
18637	3738	28	the	the	DT
18637	3738	29	latter	latter	NN
18637	3738	30	's	's	POS
18637	3738	31	"	"	``
18637	3738	32	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	3738	33	"	"	''
18637	3738	34	from	from	IN
18637	3738	35	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3738	36	.	.	.
18637	3739	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3739	2	1666	1666	CD
18637	3739	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3739	4	Yet	yet	CC
18637	3739	5	again	again	RB
18637	3739	6	,	,	,
18637	3739	7	a	a	DT
18637	3739	8	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3739	9	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	3739	10	of	of	IN
18637	3739	11	the	the	DT
18637	3739	12	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	3739	13	by	by	IN
18637	3739	14	one	one	CD
18637	3739	15	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3739	16	to	to	IN
18637	3739	17	another	another	DT
18637	3739	18	of	of	IN
18637	3739	19	the	the	DT
18637	3739	20	former	former	JJ
18637	3739	21	's	's	POS
18637	3739	22	"	"	``
18637	3739	23	estate	estate	NN
18637	3739	24	,	,	,
18637	3739	25	property	property	NN
18637	3739	26	,	,	,
18637	3739	27	right	right	UH
18637	3739	28	,	,	,
18637	3739	29	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3739	30	,	,	,
18637	3739	31	and	and	CC
18637	3739	32	franchises	franchise	NNS
18637	3739	33	"	"	``
18637	3739	34	was	be	VBD
18637	3739	35	held	hold	VBN
18637	3739	36	not	not	RB
18637	3739	37	to	to	TO
18637	3739	38	clothe	clothe	VB
18637	3739	39	the	the	DT
18637	3739	40	later	later	JJ
18637	3739	41	company	company	NN
18637	3739	42	with	with	IN
18637	3739	43	the	the	DT
18637	3739	44	earlier	early	JJR
18637	3739	45	one	one	NN
18637	3739	46	's	's	POS
18637	3739	47	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	3739	48	from	from	IN
18637	3739	49	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3739	50	.	.	.
18637	3740	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3740	2	1667	1667	CD
18637	3740	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3740	4	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	3740	5	,	,	,
18637	3740	6	an	an	DT
18637	3740	7	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	3740	8	from	from	IN
18637	3740	9	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3740	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	3740	11	to	to	TO
18637	3740	12	be	be	VB
18637	3740	13	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	3740	14	construed	construe	VBN
18637	3740	15	even	even	RB
18637	3740	16	in	in	IN
18637	3740	17	the	the	DT
18637	3740	18	hands	hand	NNS
18637	3740	19	of	of	IN
18637	3740	20	one	one	CD
18637	3740	21	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	3740	22	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	3740	23	to	to	IN
18637	3740	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3740	25	.	.	.
18637	3741	1	So	so	RB
18637	3741	2	the	the	DT
18637	3741	3	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	3741	4	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	3741	5	by	by	IN
18637	3741	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3741	7	charter	charter	NN
18637	3741	8	on	on	IN
18637	3741	9	a	a	DT
18637	3741	10	railway	railway	NN
18637	3741	11	company	company	NN
18637	3741	12	was	be	VBD
18637	3741	13	held	hold	VBN
18637	3741	14	not	not	RB
18637	3741	15	to	to	TO
18637	3741	16	extend	extend	VB
18637	3741	17	to	to	IN
18637	3741	18	branch	branch	NN
18637	3741	19	roads	road	NNS
18637	3741	20	constructed	construct	VBN
18637	3741	21	by	by	IN
18637	3741	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3741	23	under	under	IN
18637	3741	24	a	a	DT
18637	3741	25	later	later	JJ
18637	3741	26	statute	statute	NN
18637	3741	27	.	.	.
18637	3742	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3742	2	1668	1668	CD
18637	3742	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3742	4	Also	also	RB
18637	3742	5	,	,	,
18637	3742	6	a	a	DT
18637	3742	7	general	general	JJ
18637	3742	8	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	3742	9	of	of	IN
18637	3742	10	the	the	DT
18637	3742	11	property	property	NN
18637	3742	12	of	of	IN
18637	3742	13	a	a	DT
18637	3742	14	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3742	15	from	from	IN
18637	3742	16	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3742	17	was	be	VBD
18637	3742	18	held	hold	VBN
18637	3742	19	to	to	TO
18637	3742	20	refer	refer	VB
18637	3742	21	only	only	RB
18637	3742	22	to	to	IN
18637	3742	23	the	the	DT
18637	3742	24	property	property	NN
18637	3742	25	actually	actually	RB
18637	3742	26	employed	employ	VBN
18637	3742	27	in	in	IN
18637	3742	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3742	29	business	business	NN
18637	3742	30	.	.	.
18637	3743	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3743	2	1669	1669	CD
18637	3743	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3743	4	Also	also	RB
18637	3743	5	,	,	,
18637	3743	6	the	the	DT
18637	3743	7	charter	charter	NN
18637	3743	8	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	3743	9	of	of	IN
18637	3743	10	the	the	DT
18637	3743	11	capital	capital	NN
18637	3743	12	stock	stock	NN
18637	3743	13	of	of	IN
18637	3743	14	a	a	DT
18637	3743	15	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	3743	16	from	from	IN
18637	3743	17	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3743	18	"	"	''
18637	3743	19	for	for	IN
18637	3743	20	ten	ten	CD
18637	3743	21	years	year	NNS
18637	3743	22	after	after	IN
18637	3743	23	completion	completion	NN
18637	3743	24	of	of	IN
18637	3743	25	the	the	DT
18637	3743	26	said	say	VBN
18637	3743	27	road	road	NN
18637	3743	28	"	"	''
18637	3743	29	was	be	VBD
18637	3743	30	held	hold	VBN
18637	3743	31	not	not	RB
18637	3743	32	to	to	TO
18637	3743	33	become	become	VB
18637	3743	34	operative	operative	JJ
18637	3743	35	until	until	IN
18637	3743	36	the	the	DT
18637	3743	37	completion	completion	NN
18637	3743	38	of	of	IN
18637	3743	39	the	the	DT
18637	3743	40	road	road	NN
18637	3743	41	.	.	.
18637	3744	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3744	2	1670	1670	CD
18637	3744	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3744	4	So	so	RB
18637	3744	5	also	also	RB
18637	3744	6	the	the	DT
18637	3744	7	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	3744	8	of	of	IN
18637	3744	9	the	the	DT
18637	3744	10	campus	campus	NN
18637	3744	11	and	and	CC
18637	3744	12	endowment	endowment	NN
18637	3744	13	fund	fund	NN
18637	3744	14	of	of	IN
18637	3744	15	a	a	DT
18637	3744	16	college	college	NN
18637	3744	17	was	be	VBD
18637	3744	18	held	hold	VBN
18637	3744	19	to	to	TO
18637	3744	20	leave	leave	VB
18637	3744	21	other	other	JJ
18637	3744	22	lands	land	NNS
18637	3744	23	of	of	IN
18637	3744	24	the	the	DT
18637	3744	25	college	college	NN
18637	3744	26	,	,	,
18637	3744	27	though	though	IN
18637	3744	28	a	a	DT
18637	3744	29	part	part	NN
18637	3744	30	of	of	IN
18637	3744	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3744	32	endowment	endowment	NN
18637	3744	33	,	,	,
18637	3744	34	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3744	35	to	to	IN
18637	3744	36	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3744	37	.	.	.
18637	3745	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3745	2	1671	1671	CD
18637	3745	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3745	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	3745	5	,	,	,
18637	3745	6	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	3745	7	in	in	IN
18637	3745	8	a	a	DT
18637	3745	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	3745	10	that	that	WDT
18637	3745	11	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	3745	12	of	of	IN
18637	3745	13	the	the	DT
18637	3745	14	State	State	NNP
18637	3745	15	and	and	CC
18637	3745	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3745	17	political	political	JJ
18637	3745	18	subdivisions	subdivision	NNS
18637	3745	19	are	be	VBP
18637	3745	20	not	not	RB
18637	3745	21	to	to	TO
18637	3745	22	be	be	VB
18637	3745	23	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	3745	24	and	and	CC
18637	3745	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	3745	26	not	not	RB
18637	3745	27	be	be	VB
18637	3745	28	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	3745	29	were	be	VBD
18637	3745	30	held	hold	VBN
18637	3745	31	not	not	RB
18637	3745	32	to	to	TO
18637	3745	33	exempt	exempt	VB
18637	3745	34	interest	interest	NN
18637	3745	35	on	on	IN
18637	3745	36	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3745	37	from	from	IN
18637	3745	38	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3745	39	as	as	IN
18637	3745	40	income	income	NN
18637	3745	41	of	of	IN
18637	3745	42	the	the	DT
18637	3745	43	owners	owner	NNS
18637	3745	44	.	.	.
18637	3746	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3746	2	1672	1672	CD
18637	3746	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3746	4	Strict	Strict	NNP
18637	3746	5	Construction	Construction	NNP
18637	3746	6	and	and	CC
18637	3746	7	the	the	DT
18637	3746	8	Police	Police	NNP
18637	3746	9	Power.--The	Power.--The	NNP
18637	3746	10	police	police	NN
18637	3746	11	power	power	NN
18637	3746	12	,	,	,
18637	3746	13	too	too	RB
18637	3746	14	,	,	,
18637	3746	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	3746	16	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	3746	17	benefited	benefit	VBN
18637	3746	18	from	from	IN
18637	3746	19	the	the	DT
18637	3746	20	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3746	21	of	of	IN
18637	3746	22	strict	strict	JJ
18637	3746	23	construction	construction	NN
18637	3746	24	,	,	,
18637	3746	25	although	although	IN
18637	3746	26	,	,	,
18637	3746	27	for	for	IN
18637	3746	28	a	a	DT
18637	3746	29	reason	reason	NN
18637	3746	30	pointed	point	VBD
18637	3746	31	out	out	RP
18637	3746	32	below	below	IN
18637	3746	33	,	,	,
18637	3746	34	this	this	DT
18637	3746	35	recourse	recourse	NN
18637	3746	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	3746	37	today	today	NN
18637	3746	38	seldom	seldom	RB
18637	3746	39	,	,	,
18637	3746	40	if	if	IN
18637	3746	41	ever	ever	RB
18637	3746	42	,	,	,
18637	3746	43	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3746	44	in	in	IN
18637	3746	45	this	this	DT
18637	3746	46	connection	connection	NN
18637	3746	47	.	.	.
18637	3747	1	Some	some	DT
18637	3747	2	of	of	IN
18637	3747	3	the	the	DT
18637	3747	4	more	more	RBR
18637	3747	5	striking	striking	JJ
18637	3747	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	3747	7	may	may	MD
18637	3747	8	be	be	VB
18637	3747	9	briefly	briefly	RB
18637	3747	10	summarized	summarize	VBN
18637	3747	11	.	.	.
18637	3748	1	The	the	DT
18637	3748	2	provision	provision	NN
18637	3748	3	in	in	IN
18637	3748	4	the	the	DT
18637	3748	5	charter	charter	NN
18637	3748	6	of	of	IN
18637	3748	7	a	a	DT
18637	3748	8	railway	railway	NN
18637	3748	9	company	company	NN
18637	3748	10	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	3748	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3748	12	to	to	TO
18637	3748	13	set	set	VB
18637	3748	14	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	3748	15	charges	charge	NNS
18637	3748	16	still	still	RB
18637	3748	17	left	leave	VBD
18637	3748	18	the	the	DT
18637	3748	19	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3748	20	free	free	JJ
18637	3748	21	to	to	TO
18637	3748	22	determine	determine	VB
18637	3748	23	what	what	WDT
18637	3748	24	charges	charge	NNS
18637	3748	25	were	be	VBD
18637	3748	26	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	3748	27	.	.	.
18637	3749	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3749	2	1673	1673	CD
18637	3749	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3749	4	On	on	IN
18637	3749	5	the	the	DT
18637	3749	6	other	other	JJ
18637	3749	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	3749	8	,	,	,
18637	3749	9	when	when	WRB
18637	3749	10	a	a	DT
18637	3749	11	railway	railway	NN
18637	3749	12	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	3749	13	to	to	TO
18637	3749	14	accept	accept	VB
18637	3749	15	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3749	16	rates	rate	NNS
18637	3749	17	for	for	IN
18637	3749	18	a	a	DT
18637	3749	19	specified	specified	JJ
18637	3749	20	period	period	NN
18637	3749	21	,	,	,
18637	3749	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3749	23	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	3749	24	foreclosed	foreclose	VBD
18637	3749	25	the	the	DT
18637	3749	26	question	question	NN
18637	3749	27	of	of	IN
18637	3749	28	the	the	DT
18637	3749	29	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	3749	30	of	of	IN
18637	3749	31	such	such	JJ
18637	3749	32	rates	rate	NNS
18637	3749	33	.	.	.
18637	3750	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3750	2	1674	1674	CD
18637	3750	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3750	4	The	the	DT
18637	3750	5	grant	grant	NN
18637	3750	6	to	to	IN
18637	3750	7	a	a	DT
18637	3750	8	company	company	NN
18637	3750	9	of	of	IN
18637	3750	10	the	the	DT
18637	3750	11	right	right	NN
18637	3750	12	to	to	TO
18637	3750	13	supply	supply	VB
18637	3750	14	a	a	DT
18637	3750	15	city	city	NN
18637	3750	16	with	with	IN
18637	3750	17	water	water	NN
18637	3750	18	for	for	IN
18637	3750	19	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	3750	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	3750	21	five	five	CD
18637	3750	22	years	year	NNS
18637	3750	23	was	be	VBD
18637	3750	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	3750	25	not	not	RB
18637	3750	26	to	to	TO
18637	3750	27	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	3750	28	a	a	DT
18637	3750	29	similar	similar	JJ
18637	3750	30	concession	concession	NN
18637	3750	31	to	to	IN
18637	3750	32	another	another	DT
18637	3750	33	company	company	NN
18637	3750	34	by	by	IN
18637	3750	35	the	the	DT
18637	3750	36	same	same	JJ
18637	3750	37	city	city	NN
18637	3750	38	.	.	.
18637	3751	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3751	2	1675	1675	CD
18637	3751	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3751	4	The	the	DT
18637	3751	5	promise	promise	NN
18637	3751	6	by	by	IN
18637	3751	7	a	a	DT
18637	3751	8	city	city	NN
18637	3751	9	in	in	IN
18637	3751	10	the	the	DT
18637	3751	11	charter	charter	NN
18637	3751	12	of	of	IN
18637	3751	13	a	a	DT
18637	3751	14	water	water	NN
18637	3751	15	company	company	NN
18637	3751	16	not	not	RB
18637	3751	17	to	to	TO
18637	3751	18	make	make	VB
18637	3751	19	a	a	DT
18637	3751	20	similar	similar	JJ
18637	3751	21	grant	grant	NN
18637	3751	22	to	to	IN
18637	3751	23	any	any	DT
18637	3751	24	other	other	JJ
18637	3751	25	person	person	NN
18637	3751	26	or	or	CC
18637	3751	27	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3751	28	was	be	VBD
18637	3751	29	held	hold	VBN
18637	3751	30	not	not	RB
18637	3751	31	to	to	TO
18637	3751	32	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	3751	33	the	the	DT
18637	3751	34	city	city	NN
18637	3751	35	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3751	36	from	from	IN
18637	3751	37	engaging	engage	VBG
18637	3751	38	in	in	IN
18637	3751	39	the	the	DT
18637	3751	40	business	business	NN
18637	3751	41	.	.	.
18637	3752	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3752	2	1676	1676	CD
18637	3752	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3752	4	A	a	DT
18637	3752	5	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	3752	6	concession	concession	NN
18637	3752	7	to	to	IN
18637	3752	8	a	a	DT
18637	3752	9	water	water	NN
18637	3752	10	company	company	NN
18637	3752	11	which	which	WDT
18637	3752	12	was	be	VBD
18637	3752	13	to	to	TO
18637	3752	14	run	run	VB
18637	3752	15	for	for	IN
18637	3752	16	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	3752	17	years	year	NNS
18637	3752	18	and	and	CC
18637	3752	19	which	which	WDT
18637	3752	20	was	be	VBD
18637	3752	21	accompanied	accompany	VBN
18637	3752	22	by	by	IN
18637	3752	23	the	the	DT
18637	3752	24	provision	provision	NN
18637	3752	25	that	that	IN
18637	3752	26	the	the	DT
18637	3752	27	"	"	``
18637	3752	28	said	say	VBD
18637	3752	29	company	company	NN
18637	3752	30	shall	shall	MD
18637	3752	31	charge	charge	VB
18637	3752	32	the	the	DT
18637	3752	33	following	follow	VBG
18637	3752	34	rates	rate	NNS
18637	3752	35	,	,	,
18637	3752	36	"	"	''
18637	3752	37	was	be	VBD
18637	3752	38	held	hold	VBN
18637	3752	39	not	not	RB
18637	3752	40	to	to	TO
18637	3752	41	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	3752	42	the	the	DT
18637	3752	43	city	city	NN
18637	3752	44	from	from	IN
18637	3752	45	reducing	reduce	VBG
18637	3752	46	such	such	JJ
18637	3752	47	rates	rate	NNS
18637	3752	48	.	.	.
18637	3753	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3753	2	1677	1677	CD
18637	3753	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3753	4	But	but	CC
18637	3753	5	more	more	RBR
18637	3753	6	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	3753	7	,	,	,
18637	3753	8	the	the	DT
18637	3753	9	grant	grant	NN
18637	3753	10	to	to	IN
18637	3753	11	a	a	DT
18637	3753	12	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	3753	13	of	of	IN
18637	3753	14	the	the	DT
18637	3753	15	power	power	NN
18637	3753	16	to	to	TO
18637	3753	17	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	3753	18	the	the	DT
18637	3753	19	charges	charge	NNS
18637	3753	20	of	of	IN
18637	3753	21	public	public	JJ
18637	3753	22	service	service	NN
18637	3753	23	companies	company	NNS
18637	3753	24	was	be	VBD
18637	3753	25	held	hold	VBN
18637	3753	26	not	not	RB
18637	3753	27	to	to	TO
18637	3753	28	bestow	bestow	VB
18637	3753	29	the	the	DT
18637	3753	30	right	right	NN
18637	3753	31	to	to	TO
18637	3753	32	contract	contract	VB
18637	3753	33	away	away	RP
18637	3753	34	this	this	DT
18637	3753	35	power	power	NN
18637	3753	36	.	.	.
18637	3754	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3754	2	1678	1678	CD
18637	3754	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3754	4	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	3754	5	,	,	,
18637	3754	6	any	any	DT
18637	3754	7	claim	claim	NN
18637	3754	8	by	by	IN
18637	3754	9	a	a	DT
18637	3754	10	private	private	JJ
18637	3754	11	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3754	12	that	that	IN
18637	3754	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3754	14	received	receive	VBD
18637	3754	15	the	the	DT
18637	3754	16	rate	rate	NN
18637	3754	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	3754	18	making	make	VBG
18637	3754	19	power	power	NN
18637	3754	20	from	from	IN
18637	3754	21	a	a	DT
18637	3754	22	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	3754	23	must	must	MD
18637	3754	24	survive	survive	VB
18637	3754	25	a	a	DT
18637	3754	26	two	two	CD
18637	3754	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	3754	28	fold	fold	JJ
18637	3754	29	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	3754	30	:	:	:
18637	3754	31	first	first	RB
18637	3754	32	,	,	,
18637	3754	33	as	as	IN
18637	3754	34	to	to	IN
18637	3754	35	the	the	DT
18637	3754	36	right	right	NN
18637	3754	37	of	of	IN
18637	3754	38	the	the	DT
18637	3754	39	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	3754	40	under	under	IN
18637	3754	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3754	42	charter	charter	NN
18637	3754	43	to	to	TO
18637	3754	44	make	make	VB
18637	3754	45	such	such	PDT
18637	3754	46	a	a	DT
18637	3754	47	grant	grant	NN
18637	3754	48	;	;	:
18637	3754	49	secondly	secondly	RB
18637	3754	50	,	,	,
18637	3754	51	as	as	IN
18637	3754	52	to	to	IN
18637	3754	53	whether	whether	IN
18637	3754	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3754	55	has	have	VBZ
18637	3754	56	actually	actually	RB
18637	3754	57	done	do	VBN
18637	3754	58	so	so	RB
18637	3754	59	;	;	:
18637	3754	60	and	and	CC
18637	3754	61	in	in	IN
18637	3754	62	both	both	DT
18637	3754	63	respects	respect	VBZ
18637	3754	64	an	an	DT
18637	3754	65	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	3754	66	answer	answer	NN
18637	3754	67	must	must	MD
18637	3754	68	be	be	VB
18637	3754	69	based	base	VBN
18637	3754	70	on	on	IN
18637	3754	71	express	express	JJ
18637	3754	72	words	word	NNS
18637	3754	73	and	and	CC
18637	3754	74	not	not	RB
18637	3754	75	on	on	IN
18637	3754	76	implication	implication	NN
18637	3754	77	.	.	.
18637	3755	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3755	2	1679	1679	CD
18637	3755	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3755	4	The	the	DT
18637	3755	5	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	3755	6	of	of	IN
18637	3755	7	Inalienable	Inalienable	NNP
18637	3755	8	State	State	NNP
18637	3755	9	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	3755	10	The	the	DT
18637	3755	11	second	second	JJ
18637	3755	12	of	of	IN
18637	3755	13	the	the	DT
18637	3755	14	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	3755	15	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	3755	16	above	above	RB
18637	3755	17	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	3755	18	the	the	DT
18637	3755	19	principle	principle	NN
18637	3755	20	of	of	IN
18637	3755	21	the	the	DT
18637	3755	22	subordination	subordination	NN
18637	3755	23	of	of	IN
18637	3755	24	all	all	DT
18637	3755	25	persons	person	NNS
18637	3755	26	,	,	,
18637	3755	27	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	3755	28	and	and	CC
18637	3755	29	individual	individual	JJ
18637	3755	30	alike	alike	RB
18637	3755	31	,	,	,
18637	3755	32	to	to	IN
18637	3755	33	the	the	DT
18637	3755	34	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3755	35	power	power	NN
18637	3755	36	of	of	IN
18637	3755	37	the	the	DT
18637	3755	38	State	State	NNP
18637	3755	39	has	have	VBZ
18637	3755	40	been	be	VBN
18637	3755	41	fortified	fortify	VBN
18637	3755	42	,	,	,
18637	3755	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	3755	44	the	the	DT
18637	3755	45	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3755	46	that	that	IN
18637	3755	47	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3755	48	of	of	IN
18637	3755	49	the	the	DT
18637	3755	50	State	State	NNP
18637	3755	51	's	's	POS
18637	3755	52	powers	power	NNS
18637	3755	53	are	be	VBP
18637	3755	54	inalienable	inalienable	JJ
18637	3755	55	,	,	,
18637	3755	56	and	and	CC
18637	3755	57	that	that	IN
18637	3755	58	any	any	DT
18637	3755	59	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	3755	60	by	by	IN
18637	3755	61	a	a	DT
18637	3755	62	State	State	NNP
18637	3755	63	to	to	TO
18637	3755	64	alienate	alienate	VB
18637	3755	65	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3755	66	,	,	,
18637	3755	67	upon	upon	IN
18637	3755	68	any	any	DT
18637	3755	69	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	3755	70	whatsoever	whatsoever	RB
18637	3755	71	,	,	,
18637	3755	72	is	be	VBZ
18637	3755	73	_	_	NNP
18637	3755	74	ipso	ipso	FW
18637	3755	75	facto	facto	FW
18637	3755	76	_	_	NNP
18637	3755	77	void	void	NN
18637	3755	78	,	,	,
18637	3755	79	and	and	CC
18637	3755	80	hence	hence	RB
18637	3755	81	incapable	incapable	JJ
18637	3755	82	of	of	IN
18637	3755	83	producing	produce	VBG
18637	3755	84	a	a	DT
18637	3755	85	"	"	``
18637	3755	86	contract	contract	NN
18637	3755	87	"	"	''
18637	3755	88	within	within	IN
18637	3755	89	the	the	DT
18637	3755	90	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	3755	91	of	of	IN
18637	3755	92	article	article	NN
18637	3755	93	I	i	NN
18637	3755	94	,	,	,
18637	3755	95	section	section	NN
18637	3755	96	10	10	CD
18637	3755	97	.	.	.
18637	3756	1	One	one	CD
18637	3756	2	of	of	IN
18637	3756	3	the	the	DT
18637	3756	4	earliest	early	JJS
18637	3756	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	3756	6	to	to	TO
18637	3756	7	assert	assert	VB
18637	3756	8	this	this	DT
18637	3756	9	principle	principle	NN
18637	3756	10	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	3756	11	in	in	IN
18637	3756	12	New	New	NNP
18637	3756	13	York	York	NNP
18637	3756	14	in	in	IN
18637	3756	15	1826	1826	CD
18637	3756	16	.	.	.
18637	3757	1	The	the	DT
18637	3757	2	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3757	3	of	of	IN
18637	3757	4	the	the	DT
18637	3757	5	City	City	NNP
18637	3757	6	of	of	IN
18637	3757	7	New	New	NNP
18637	3757	8	York	York	NNP
18637	3757	9	,	,	,
18637	3757	10	having	have	VBG
18637	3757	11	conveyed	convey	VBN
18637	3757	12	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3757	13	lands	land	NNS
18637	3757	14	for	for	IN
18637	3757	15	the	the	DT
18637	3757	16	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	3757	17	of	of	IN
18637	3757	18	a	a	DT
18637	3757	19	church	church	NN
18637	3757	20	and	and	CC
18637	3757	21	cemetery	cemetery	NN
18637	3757	22	together	together	RB
18637	3757	23	with	with	IN
18637	3757	24	a	a	DT
18637	3757	25	covenant	covenant	NN
18637	3757	26	for	for	IN
18637	3757	27	quiet	quiet	JJ
18637	3757	28	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	3757	29	,	,	,
18637	3757	30	later	later	RB
18637	3757	31	passed	pass	VBD
18637	3757	32	a	a	DT
18637	3757	33	by	by	IN
18637	3757	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	3757	35	law	law	NN
18637	3757	36	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	3757	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3757	38	use	use	NN
18637	3757	39	as	as	IN
18637	3757	40	a	a	DT
18637	3757	41	cemetery	cemetery	NN
18637	3757	42	.	.	.
18637	3758	1	In	in	IN
18637	3758	2	denying	deny	VBG
18637	3758	3	an	an	DT
18637	3758	4	action	action	NN
18637	3758	5	against	against	IN
18637	3758	6	the	the	DT
18637	3758	7	city	city	NN
18637	3758	8	for	for	IN
18637	3758	9	breach	breach	NN
18637	3758	10	of	of	IN
18637	3758	11	covenant	covenant	NN
18637	3758	12	,	,	,
18637	3758	13	the	the	DT
18637	3758	14	State	State	NNP
18637	3758	15	court	court	NN
18637	3758	16	said	say	VBD
18637	3758	17	the	the	DT
18637	3758	18	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	3758	19	"	"	``
18637	3758	20	had	have	VBD
18637	3758	21	no	no	DT
18637	3758	22	power	power	NN
18637	3758	23	as	as	IN
18637	3758	24	a	a	DT
18637	3758	25	party	party	NN
18637	3758	26	,	,	,
18637	3758	27	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3758	28	to	to	IN
18637	3758	29	the	the	DT
18637	3758	30	covenant	covenant	NN
18637	3758	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3758	32	to	to	TO
18637	3758	33	make	make	VB
18637	3758	34	a	a	DT
18637	3758	35	contract	contract	NN
18637	3758	36	which	which	WDT
18637	3758	37	should	should	MD
18637	3758	38	control	control	VB
18637	3758	39	or	or	CC
18637	3758	40	embarrass	embarrass	VB
18637	3758	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3758	42	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3758	43	powers	power	NNS
18637	3758	44	and	and	CC
18637	3758	45	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3758	46	.	.	.
18637	3759	1	"	"	``
18637	3759	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3759	3	1680	1680	CD
18637	3759	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3759	5	The	the	DT
18637	3759	6	Eminent	Eminent	NNP
18637	3759	7	Domain	Domain	NNP
18637	3759	8	Power	Power	NNP
18637	3759	9	Inalienable.--The	Inalienable.--The	NNP
18637	3759	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3759	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3759	12	first	first	RB
18637	3759	13	applied	apply	VBD
18637	3759	14	similar	similar	JJ
18637	3759	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3759	16	in	in	IN
18637	3759	17	1848	1848	CD
18637	3759	18	in	in	IN
18637	3759	19	a	a	DT
18637	3759	20	case	case	NN
18637	3759	21	involving	involve	VBG
18637	3759	22	a	a	DT
18637	3759	23	grant	grant	NN
18637	3759	24	of	of	IN
18637	3759	25	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3759	26	right	right	NN
18637	3759	27	to	to	TO
18637	3759	28	construct	construct	VB
18637	3759	29	a	a	DT
18637	3759	30	bridge	bridge	NN
18637	3759	31	at	at	IN
18637	3759	32	a	a	DT
18637	3759	33	specified	specify	VBN
18637	3759	34	locality	locality	NN
18637	3759	35	.	.	.
18637	3760	1	Sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	3760	2	the	the	DT
18637	3760	3	right	right	NN
18637	3760	4	of	of	IN
18637	3760	5	the	the	DT
18637	3760	6	State	State	NNP
18637	3760	7	of	of	IN
18637	3760	8	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	3760	9	to	to	TO
18637	3760	10	make	make	VB
18637	3760	11	a	a	DT
18637	3760	12	new	new	JJ
18637	3760	13	grant	grant	NN
18637	3760	14	to	to	IN
18637	3760	15	a	a	DT
18637	3760	16	competing	compete	VBG
18637	3760	17	company	company	NN
18637	3760	18	,	,	,
18637	3760	19	the	the	DT
18637	3760	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3760	21	held	hold	VBD
18637	3760	22	that	that	IN
18637	3760	23	the	the	DT
18637	3760	24	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3760	25	of	of	IN
18637	3760	26	the	the	DT
18637	3760	27	earlier	early	RBR
18637	3760	28	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3760	29	grant	grant	NN
18637	3760	30	was	be	VBD
18637	3760	31	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	3760	32	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	3760	33	in	in	IN
18637	3760	34	making	make	VBG
18637	3760	35	just	just	RB
18637	3760	36	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	3760	37	for	for	IN
18637	3760	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3760	39	;	;	:
18637	3760	40	and	and	CC
18637	3760	41	that	that	IN
18637	3760	42	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	3760	43	franchises	franchise	NNS
18637	3760	44	,	,	,
18637	3760	45	like	like	IN
18637	3760	46	all	all	DT
18637	3760	47	other	other	JJ
18637	3760	48	forms	form	NNS
18637	3760	49	of	of	IN
18637	3760	50	property	property	NN
18637	3760	51	,	,	,
18637	3760	52	are	be	VBP
18637	3760	53	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3760	54	to	to	IN
18637	3760	55	the	the	DT
18637	3760	56	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	3760	57	power	power	NN
18637	3760	58	of	of	IN
18637	3760	59	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	3760	60	domain	domain	NN
18637	3760	61	.	.	.
18637	3761	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3761	2	1681	1681	CD
18637	3761	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3761	4	This	this	DT
18637	3761	5	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	3761	6	was	be	VBD
18637	3761	7	reinforced	reinforce	VBN
18637	3761	8	by	by	IN
18637	3761	9	an	an	DT
18637	3761	10	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	3761	11	to	to	IN
18637	3761	12	the	the	DT
18637	3761	13	theory	theory	NN
18637	3761	14	of	of	IN
18637	3761	15	State	State	NNP
18637	3761	16	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	3761	17	,	,	,
18637	3761	18	which	which	WDT
18637	3761	19	was	be	VBD
18637	3761	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	3761	21	to	to	TO
18637	3761	22	involve	involve	VB
18637	3761	23	the	the	DT
18637	3761	24	corollary	corollary	NN
18637	3761	25	of	of	IN
18637	3761	26	the	the	DT
18637	3761	27	inalienability	inalienability	NN
18637	3761	28	of	of	IN
18637	3761	29	all	all	PDT
18637	3761	30	the	the	DT
18637	3761	31	principal	principal	JJ
18637	3761	32	powers	power	NNS
18637	3761	33	of	of	IN
18637	3761	34	a	a	DT
18637	3761	35	State	state	NN
18637	3761	36	.	.	.
18637	3762	1	The	the	DT
18637	3762	2	subordination	subordination	NN
18637	3762	3	of	of	IN
18637	3762	4	all	all	DT
18637	3762	5	charter	charter	NN
18637	3762	6	rights	right	NNS
18637	3762	7	and	and	CC
18637	3762	8	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3762	9	to	to	IN
18637	3762	10	the	the	DT
18637	3762	11	power	power	NN
18637	3762	12	of	of	IN
18637	3762	13	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	3762	14	domain	domain	NN
18637	3762	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	3762	16	been	be	VBN
18637	3762	17	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	3762	18	by	by	IN
18637	3762	19	the	the	DT
18637	3762	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3762	21	ever	ever	RB
18637	3762	22	since	since	RB
18637	3762	23	;	;	:
18637	3762	24	not	not	RB
18637	3762	25	even	even	RB
18637	3762	26	an	an	DT
18637	3762	27	explicit	explicit	JJ
18637	3762	28	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3762	29	by	by	IN
18637	3762	30	the	the	DT
18637	3762	31	State	State	NNP
18637	3762	32	to	to	TO
18637	3762	33	forego	forego	VB
18637	3762	34	the	the	DT
18637	3762	35	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3762	36	of	of	IN
18637	3762	37	the	the	DT
18637	3762	38	power	power	NN
18637	3762	39	will	will	MD
18637	3762	40	avail	avail	VB
18637	3762	41	against	against	IN
18637	3762	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3762	43	.	.	.
18637	3763	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3763	2	1682	1682	CD
18637	3763	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3763	4	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	3763	5	,	,	,
18637	3763	6	the	the	DT
18637	3763	7	State	state	NN
18637	3763	8	may	may	MD
18637	3763	9	revoke	revoke	VB
18637	3763	10	an	an	DT
18637	3763	11	improvident	improvident	JJ
18637	3763	12	grant	grant	NN
18637	3763	13	of	of	IN
18637	3763	14	the	the	DT
18637	3763	15	public	public	JJ
18637	3763	16	petitionary	petitionary	NN
18637	3763	17	without	without	IN
18637	3763	18	recourse	recourse	NN
18637	3763	19	to	to	IN
18637	3763	20	the	the	DT
18637	3763	21	power	power	NN
18637	3763	22	of	of	IN
18637	3763	23	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	3763	24	domain	domain	NN
18637	3763	25	,	,	,
18637	3763	26	such	such	PDT
18637	3763	27	a	a	DT
18637	3763	28	grant	grant	NN
18637	3763	29	being	be	VBG
18637	3763	30	inherently	inherently	RB
18637	3763	31	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	3763	32	the	the	DT
18637	3763	33	power	power	NN
18637	3763	34	of	of	IN
18637	3763	35	the	the	DT
18637	3763	36	State	State	NNP
18637	3763	37	to	to	TO
18637	3763	38	make	make	VB
18637	3763	39	.	.	.
18637	3764	1	So	so	RB
18637	3764	2	when	when	WRB
18637	3764	3	the	the	DT
18637	3764	4	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3764	5	of	of	IN
18637	3764	6	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	3764	7	in	in	IN
18637	3764	8	1869	1869	CD
18637	3764	9	devised	devise	VBD
18637	3764	10	to	to	IN
18637	3764	11	the	the	DT
18637	3764	12	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	3764	13	Central	Central	NNP
18637	3764	14	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	3764	15	Company	Company	NNP
18637	3764	16	,	,	,
18637	3764	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3764	18	successors	successor	NNS
18637	3764	19	and	and	CC
18637	3764	20	assigns	assign	NNS
18637	3764	21	,	,	,
18637	3764	22	the	the	DT
18637	3764	23	State	State	NNP
18637	3764	24	's	's	POS
18637	3764	25	right	right	NN
18637	3764	26	and	and	CC
18637	3764	27	title	title	NN
18637	3764	28	to	to	TO
18637	3764	29	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	3764	30	a	a	DT
18637	3764	31	thousand	thousand	CD
18637	3764	32	acres	acre	NNS
18637	3764	33	of	of	IN
18637	3764	34	submerged	submerge	VBN
18637	3764	35	land	land	NN
18637	3764	36	under	under	IN
18637	3764	37	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	3764	38	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	3764	39	along	along	IN
18637	3764	40	the	the	DT
18637	3764	41	harbor	harbor	NN
18637	3764	42	front	front	NN
18637	3764	43	of	of	IN
18637	3764	44	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	3764	45	,	,	,
18637	3764	46	and	and	CC
18637	3764	47	four	four	CD
18637	3764	48	years	year	NNS
18637	3764	49	later	later	RB
18637	3764	50	sought	seek	VBD
18637	3764	51	to	to	TO
18637	3764	52	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	3764	53	the	the	DT
18637	3764	54	grant	grant	NN
18637	3764	55	,	,	,
18637	3764	56	the	the	DT
18637	3764	57	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3764	58	,	,	,
18637	3764	59	in	in	IN
18637	3764	60	a	a	DT
18637	3764	61	four	four	CD
18637	3764	62	-	-	HYPH
18637	3764	63	to	to	IN
18637	3764	64	-	-	HYPH
18637	3764	65	three	three	CD
18637	3764	66	decision	decision	NN
18637	3764	67	,	,	,
18637	3764	68	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	3764	69	an	an	DT
18637	3764	70	action	action	NN
18637	3764	71	by	by	IN
18637	3764	72	the	the	DT
18637	3764	73	State	State	NNP
18637	3764	74	to	to	TO
18637	3764	75	recover	recover	VB
18637	3764	76	the	the	DT
18637	3764	77	lands	land	NNS
18637	3764	78	in	in	IN
18637	3764	79	question	question	NN
18637	3764	80	.	.	.
18637	3765	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	3765	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3765	3	Field	Field	NNP
18637	3765	4	,	,	,
18637	3765	5	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	3765	6	for	for	IN
18637	3765	7	the	the	DT
18637	3765	8	majority	majority	NN
18637	3765	9	:	:	:
18637	3765	10	"	"	``
18637	3765	11	Such	such	JJ
18637	3765	12	abdication	abdication	NN
18637	3765	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	3765	14	not	not	RB
18637	3765	15	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	3765	16	with	with	IN
18637	3765	17	the	the	DT
18637	3765	18	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3765	19	of	of	IN
18637	3765	20	that	that	DT
18637	3765	21	trust	trust	NN
18637	3765	22	which	which	WDT
18637	3765	23	requires	require	VBZ
18637	3765	24	the	the	DT
18637	3765	25	government	government	NN
18637	3765	26	of	of	IN
18637	3765	27	the	the	DT
18637	3765	28	State	State	NNP
18637	3765	29	to	to	TO
18637	3765	30	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	3765	31	such	such	JJ
18637	3765	32	waters	water	NNS
18637	3765	33	for	for	IN
18637	3765	34	the	the	DT
18637	3765	35	use	use	NN
18637	3765	36	of	of	IN
18637	3765	37	public	public	NN
18637	3765	38	.	.	.
18637	3766	1	The	the	DT
18637	3766	2	trust	trust	NN
18637	3766	3	devolving	devolve	VBG
18637	3766	4	upon	upon	IN
18637	3766	5	the	the	DT
18637	3766	6	State	State	NNP
18637	3766	7	for	for	IN
18637	3766	8	the	the	DT
18637	3766	9	public	public	NN
18637	3766	10	,	,	,
18637	3766	11	and	and	CC
18637	3766	12	which	which	WDT
18637	3766	13	can	can	MD
18637	3766	14	only	only	RB
18637	3766	15	be	be	VB
18637	3766	16	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	3766	17	by	by	IN
18637	3766	18	the	the	DT
18637	3766	19	management	management	NN
18637	3766	20	and	and	CC
18637	3766	21	control	control	NN
18637	3766	22	of	of	IN
18637	3766	23	property	property	NN
18637	3766	24	in	in	IN
18637	3766	25	which	which	WDT
18637	3766	26	the	the	DT
18637	3766	27	public	public	NN
18637	3766	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	3766	29	an	an	DT
18637	3766	30	interest	interest	NN
18637	3766	31	,	,	,
18637	3766	32	can	can	MD
18637	3766	33	not	not	RB
18637	3766	34	be	be	VB
18637	3766	35	relinquished	relinquish	VBN
18637	3766	36	by	by	IN
18637	3766	37	a	a	DT
18637	3766	38	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	3766	39	of	of	IN
18637	3766	40	the	the	DT
18637	3766	41	property	property	NN
18637	3766	42	.	.	.
18637	3767	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3767	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3767	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3767	4	Any	any	DT
18637	3767	5	grant	grant	NN
18637	3767	6	of	of	IN
18637	3767	7	the	the	DT
18637	3767	8	kind	kind	NN
18637	3767	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	3767	10	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	3767	11	revocable	revocable	JJ
18637	3767	12	,	,	,
18637	3767	13	and	and	CC
18637	3767	14	the	the	DT
18637	3767	15	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3767	16	of	of	IN
18637	3767	17	the	the	DT
18637	3767	18	trust	trust	NN
18637	3767	19	by	by	IN
18637	3767	20	which	which	WDT
18637	3767	21	the	the	DT
18637	3767	22	property	property	NN
18637	3767	23	was	be	VBD
18637	3767	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	3767	25	by	by	IN
18637	3767	26	the	the	DT
18637	3767	27	State	State	NNP
18637	3767	28	can	can	MD
18637	3767	29	be	be	VB
18637	3767	30	resumed	resume	VBN
18637	3767	31	at	at	IN
18637	3767	32	any	any	DT
18637	3767	33	time	time	NN
18637	3767	34	.	.	.
18637	3768	1	"	"	``
18637	3768	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3768	3	1683	1683	CD
18637	3768	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3768	5	The	the	DT
18637	3768	6	case	case	NN
18637	3768	7	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	3768	8	an	an	DT
18637	3768	9	interesting	interesting	JJ
18637	3768	10	commentary	commentary	NN
18637	3768	11	on	on	IN
18637	3768	12	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	3768	13	_	_	NNP
18637	3768	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	3768	15	_	_	NNP
18637	3768	16	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	3768	17	.	.	.
18637	3769	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3769	2	1684	1684	CD
18637	3769	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3769	4	The	the	DT
18637	3769	5	Taxing	Taxing	NNP
18637	3769	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	3769	7	Not	not	RB
18637	3769	8	Inalienable.--On	Inalienable.--On	VBZ
18637	3769	9	the	the	DT
18637	3769	10	other	other	JJ
18637	3769	11	hand	hand	NN
18637	3769	12	,	,	,
18637	3769	13	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	3769	14	endeavors	endeavor	NNS
18637	3769	15	to	to	TO
18637	3769	16	subject	subject	VB
18637	3769	17	tax	tax	NN
18637	3769	18	exemptions	exemption	NNS
18637	3769	19	to	to	IN
18637	3769	20	the	the	DT
18637	3769	21	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3769	22	of	of	IN
18637	3769	23	inalienability	inalienability	NN
18637	3769	24	though	though	IN
18637	3769	25	at	at	IN
18637	3769	26	times	time	NNS
18637	3769	27	supported	support	VBN
18637	3769	28	by	by	IN
18637	3769	29	powerful	powerful	JJ
18637	3769	30	minorities	minority	NNS
18637	3769	31	on	on	IN
18637	3769	32	the	the	DT
18637	3769	33	Bench	Bench	NNP
18637	3769	34	,	,	,
18637	3769	35	have	have	VBP
18637	3769	36	always	always	RB
18637	3769	37	failed	fail	VBN
18637	3769	38	.	.	.
18637	3770	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3770	2	1685	1685	CD
18637	3770	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3770	4	As	as	RB
18637	3770	5	recently	recently	RB
18637	3770	6	as	as	IN
18637	3770	7	January	January	NNP
18637	3770	8	,	,	,
18637	3770	9	1952	1952	CD
18637	3770	10	,	,	,
18637	3770	11	the	the	DT
18637	3770	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3770	13	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	3770	14	that	that	IN
18637	3770	15	the	the	DT
18637	3770	16	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	3770	17	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	3770	18	Company	Company	NNP
18637	3770	19	was	be	VBD
18637	3770	20	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	3770	21	to	to	TO
18637	3770	22	seek	seek	VB
18637	3770	23	an	an	DT
18637	3770	24	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	3770	25	in	in	IN
18637	3770	26	the	the	DT
18637	3770	27	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3770	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	3770	29	against	against	IN
18637	3770	30	an	an	DT
18637	3770	31	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	3770	32	by	by	IN
18637	3770	33	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	3770	34	's	's	POS
18637	3770	35	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	3770	36	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	3770	37	to	to	TO
18637	3770	38	compel	compel	VB
18637	3770	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3770	40	to	to	TO
18637	3770	41	pay	pay	VB
18637	3770	42	_	_	NNP
18637	3770	43	ad	ad	NN
18637	3770	44	valorem	valorem	NN
18637	3770	45	_	_	NNP
18637	3770	46	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3770	47	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	3770	48	to	to	IN
18637	3770	49	the	the	DT
18637	3770	50	terms	term	NNS
18637	3770	51	of	of	IN
18637	3770	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3770	53	special	special	JJ
18637	3770	54	charter	charter	NN
18637	3770	55	issued	issue	VBN
18637	3770	56	in	in	IN
18637	3770	57	1833	1833	CD
18637	3770	58	.	.	.
18637	3771	1	To	to	IN
18637	3771	2	the	the	DT
18637	3771	3	argument	argument	NN
18637	3771	4	that	that	IN
18637	3771	5	this	this	DT
18637	3771	6	was	be	VBD
18637	3771	7	a	a	DT
18637	3771	8	suit	suit	NN
18637	3771	9	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	3771	10	to	to	IN
18637	3771	11	the	the	DT
18637	3771	12	Eleventh	Eleventh	NNP
18637	3771	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3771	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3771	15	returned	return	VBD
18637	3771	16	the	the	DT
18637	3771	17	answer	answer	NN
18637	3771	18	that	that	IN
18637	3771	19	the	the	DT
18637	3771	20	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	3771	21	from	from	IN
18637	3771	22	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	3771	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3771	24	created	create	VBN
18637	3771	25	by	by	IN
18637	3771	26	the	the	DT
18637	3771	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3771	28	"	"	``
18637	3771	29	does	do	VBZ
18637	3771	30	not	not	RB
18637	3771	31	extend	extend	VB
18637	3771	32	to	to	IN
18637	3771	33	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	3771	34	who	who	WP
18637	3771	35	act	act	VBP
18637	3771	36	as	as	IN
18637	3771	37	officers	officer	NNS
18637	3771	38	without	without	IN
18637	3771	39	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3771	40	authority	authority	NN
18637	3771	41	.	.	.
18637	3772	1	"	"	``
18637	3772	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3772	3	1686	1686	CD
18637	3772	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3772	5	The	the	DT
18637	3772	6	Police	Police	NNP
18637	3772	7	Power	power	NN
18637	3772	8	;	;	:
18637	3772	9	When	when	WRB
18637	3772	10	Inalienable.--The	Inalienable.--The	NNP
18637	3772	11	leading	leading	JJ
18637	3772	12	case	case	NN
18637	3772	13	involving	involve	VBG
18637	3772	14	the	the	DT
18637	3772	15	police	police	NN
18637	3772	16	power	power	NN
18637	3772	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	3772	18	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	3772	19	_	_	NNP
18637	3772	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	3772	21	_	_	NNP
18637	3772	22	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	3772	23	,	,	,
18637	3772	24	101	101	CD
18637	3772	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	3772	26	814	814	CD
18637	3772	27	,	,	,
18637	3772	28	decided	decide	VBD
18637	3772	29	in	in	IN
18637	3772	30	1880	1880	CD
18637	3772	31	.	.	.
18637	3773	1	In	in	IN
18637	3773	2	1867	1867	CD
18637	3773	3	the	the	DT
18637	3773	4	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3773	5	of	of	IN
18637	3773	6	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	3773	7	chartered	charter	VBD
18637	3773	8	a	a	DT
18637	3773	9	company	company	NN
18637	3773	10	to	to	TO
18637	3773	11	which	which	WDT
18637	3773	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3773	13	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	3773	14	granted	grant	VBD
18637	3773	15	the	the	DT
18637	3773	16	power	power	NN
18637	3773	17	to	to	TO
18637	3773	18	conduct	conduct	VB
18637	3773	19	a	a	DT
18637	3773	20	lottery	lottery	NN
18637	3773	21	.	.	.
18637	3774	1	Two	two	CD
18637	3774	2	years	year	NNS
18637	3774	3	later	later	RB
18637	3774	4	the	the	DT
18637	3774	5	State	state	NN
18637	3774	6	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	3774	7	a	a	DT
18637	3774	8	new	new	JJ
18637	3774	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3774	10	which	which	WDT
18637	3774	11	contained	contain	VBD
18637	3774	12	a	a	DT
18637	3774	13	provision	provision	NN
18637	3774	14	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	3774	15	lotteries	lottery	NNS
18637	3774	16	;	;	:
18637	3774	17	and	and	CC
18637	3774	18	a	a	DT
18637	3774	19	year	year	NN
18637	3774	20	later	later	RB
18637	3774	21	the	the	DT
18637	3774	22	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3774	23	passed	pass	VBD
18637	3774	24	an	an	DT
18637	3774	25	act	act	NN
18637	3774	26	to	to	TO
18637	3774	27	put	put	VB
18637	3774	28	this	this	DT
18637	3774	29	provision	provision	NN
18637	3774	30	into	into	IN
18637	3774	31	effect	effect	NN
18637	3774	32	.	.	.
18637	3775	1	In	in	IN
18637	3775	2	upholding	uphold	VBG
18637	3775	3	this	this	DT
18637	3775	4	act	act	NN
18637	3775	5	and	and	CC
18637	3775	6	the	the	DT
18637	3775	7	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3775	8	provision	provision	NN
18637	3775	9	on	on	IN
18637	3775	10	which	which	WDT
18637	3775	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3775	12	was	be	VBD
18637	3775	13	based	base	VBN
18637	3775	14	,	,	,
18637	3775	15	the	the	DT
18637	3775	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3775	17	said	say	VBD
18637	3775	18	:	:	:
18637	3775	19	"	"	``
18637	3775	20	The	the	DT
18637	3775	21	power	power	NN
18637	3775	22	of	of	IN
18637	3775	23	governing	governing	NN
18637	3775	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	3775	25	a	a	DT
18637	3775	26	trust	trust	NN
18637	3775	27	committed	commit	VBN
18637	3775	28	by	by	IN
18637	3775	29	the	the	DT
18637	3775	30	people	people	NNS
18637	3775	31	to	to	IN
18637	3775	32	the	the	DT
18637	3775	33	government	government	NN
18637	3775	34	,	,	,
18637	3775	35	no	no	DT
18637	3775	36	part	part	NN
18637	3775	37	of	of	IN
18637	3775	38	which	which	WDT
18637	3775	39	can	can	MD
18637	3775	40	be	be	VB
18637	3775	41	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3775	42	away	away	RB
18637	3775	43	.	.	.
18637	3776	1	The	the	DT
18637	3776	2	people	people	NNS
18637	3776	3	,	,	,
18637	3776	4	in	in	IN
18637	3776	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3776	6	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	3776	7	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	3776	8	,	,	,
18637	3776	9	have	have	VBP
18637	3776	10	established	establish	VBN
18637	3776	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3776	12	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	3776	13	for	for	IN
18637	3776	14	the	the	DT
18637	3776	15	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	3776	16	of	of	IN
18637	3776	17	the	the	DT
18637	3776	18	public	public	JJ
18637	3776	19	health	health	NN
18637	3776	20	and	and	CC
18637	3776	21	the	the	DT
18637	3776	22	public	public	JJ
18637	3776	23	morals	moral	NNS
18637	3776	24	,	,	,
18637	3776	25	and	and	CC
18637	3776	26	the	the	DT
18637	3776	27	protection	protection	NN
18637	3776	28	of	of	IN
18637	3776	29	public	public	JJ
18637	3776	30	and	and	CC
18637	3776	31	private	private	JJ
18637	3776	32	rights	right	NNS
18637	3776	33	,	,	,
18637	3776	34	"	"	''
18637	3776	35	and	and	CC
18637	3776	36	these	these	DT
18637	3776	37	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	3776	38	can	can	MD
18637	3776	39	neither	neither	CC
18637	3776	40	give	give	VB
18637	3776	41	away	away	RP
18637	3776	42	nor	nor	CC
18637	3776	43	sell	sell	VB
18637	3776	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3776	45	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	3776	46	.	.	.
18637	3777	1	All	all	DT
18637	3777	2	that	that	DT
18637	3777	3	one	one	PRP
18637	3777	4	can	can	MD
18637	3777	5	get	get	VB
18637	3777	6	by	by	IN
18637	3777	7	a	a	DT
18637	3777	8	charter	charter	NN
18637	3777	9	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	3777	10	the	the	DT
18637	3777	11	business	business	NN
18637	3777	12	of	of	IN
18637	3777	13	conducting	conduct	VBG
18637	3777	14	a	a	DT
18637	3777	15	lottery	lottery	NN
18637	3777	16	"	"	``
18637	3777	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	3777	18	suspension	suspension	NN
18637	3777	19	of	of	IN
18637	3777	20	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3777	21	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	3777	22	rights	right	NNS
18637	3777	23	in	in	IN
18637	3777	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3777	25	favor	favor	NN
18637	3777	26	,	,	,
18637	3777	27	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3777	28	to	to	IN
18637	3777	29	withdrawal	withdrawal	NN
18637	3777	30	at	at	IN
18637	3777	31	will	will	NN
18637	3777	32	.	.	.
18637	3778	1	"	"	``
18637	3778	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3778	3	1687	1687	CD
18637	3778	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3778	5	The	the	DT
18637	3778	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3778	7	shortly	shortly	RB
18637	3778	8	afterward	afterward	RB
18637	3778	9	applied	apply	VBD
18637	3778	10	the	the	DT
18637	3778	11	same	same	JJ
18637	3778	12	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	3778	13	in	in	IN
18637	3778	14	a	a	DT
18637	3778	15	case	case	NN
18637	3778	16	in	in	IN
18637	3778	17	which	which	WDT
18637	3778	18	was	be	VBD
18637	3778	19	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	3778	20	the	the	DT
18637	3778	21	right	right	NN
18637	3778	22	of	of	IN
18637	3778	23	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	3778	24	to	to	TO
18637	3778	25	invade	invade	VB
18637	3778	26	the	the	DT
18637	3778	27	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3778	28	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	3778	29	of	of	IN
18637	3778	30	a	a	DT
18637	3778	31	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3778	32	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	3778	33	in	in	IN
18637	3778	34	the	the	DT
18637	3778	35	slaughter	slaughter	NN
18637	3778	36	of	of	IN
18637	3778	37	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	3778	38	in	in	IN
18637	3778	39	New	New	NNP
18637	3778	40	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	3778	41	by	by	IN
18637	3778	42	granting	grant	VBG
18637	3778	43	another	another	DT
18637	3778	44	company	company	NN
18637	3778	45	the	the	DT
18637	3778	46	right	right	NN
18637	3778	47	to	to	TO
18637	3778	48	engage	engage	VB
18637	3778	49	in	in	IN
18637	3778	50	the	the	DT
18637	3778	51	same	same	JJ
18637	3778	52	business	business	NN
18637	3778	53	.	.	.
18637	3779	1	Although	although	IN
18637	3779	2	the	the	DT
18637	3779	3	State	State	NNP
18637	3779	4	did	do	VBD
18637	3779	5	not	not	RB
18637	3779	6	offer	offer	VB
18637	3779	7	to	to	TO
18637	3779	8	compensate	compensate	VB
18637	3779	9	the	the	DT
18637	3779	10	older	old	JJR
18637	3779	11	company	company	NN
18637	3779	12	for	for	IN
18637	3779	13	the	the	DT
18637	3779	14	lost	lost	JJ
18637	3779	15	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	3779	16	,	,	,
18637	3779	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3779	18	action	action	NN
18637	3779	19	was	be	VBD
18637	3779	20	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	3779	21	on	on	IN
18637	3779	22	the	the	DT
18637	3779	23	ground	ground	NN
18637	3779	24	that	that	IN
18637	3779	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3779	26	had	have	VBD
18637	3779	27	been	be	VBN
18637	3779	28	taken	take	VBN
18637	3779	29	in	in	IN
18637	3779	30	the	the	DT
18637	3779	31	interest	interest	NN
18637	3779	32	of	of	IN
18637	3779	33	the	the	DT
18637	3779	34	public	public	JJ
18637	3779	35	health	health	NN
18637	3779	36	.	.	.
18637	3780	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3780	2	1688	1688	CD
18637	3780	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3780	4	When	when	WRB
18637	3780	5	,	,	,
18637	3780	6	however	however	RB
18637	3780	7	,	,	,
18637	3780	8	the	the	DT
18637	3780	9	City	City	NNP
18637	3780	10	of	of	IN
18637	3780	11	New	New	NNP
18637	3780	12	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	3780	13	,	,	,
18637	3780	14	in	in	IN
18637	3780	15	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	3780	16	on	on	IN
18637	3780	17	this	this	DT
18637	3780	18	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	3780	19	,	,	,
18637	3780	20	sought	seek	VBD
18637	3780	21	to	to	TO
18637	3780	22	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	3780	23	an	an	DT
18637	3780	24	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	3780	25	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	3780	26	which	which	WDT
18637	3780	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3780	28	had	have	VBD
18637	3780	29	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3780	30	a	a	DT
18637	3780	31	company	company	NN
18637	3780	32	for	for	IN
18637	3780	33	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	3780	34	years	year	NNS
18637	3780	35	to	to	TO
18637	3780	36	supply	supply	VB
18637	3780	37	gas	gas	NN
18637	3780	38	to	to	IN
18637	3780	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3780	40	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	3780	41	,	,	,
18637	3780	42	the	the	DT
18637	3780	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3780	44	interposed	interpose	VBD
18637	3780	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3780	46	veto	veto	NN
18637	3780	47	,	,	,
18637	3780	48	explaining	explain	VBG
18637	3780	49	that	that	IN
18637	3780	50	in	in	IN
18637	3780	51	this	this	DT
18637	3780	52	instance	instance	NN
18637	3780	53	neither	neither	CC
18637	3780	54	the	the	DT
18637	3780	55	public	public	JJ
18637	3780	56	health	health	NN
18637	3780	57	,	,	,
18637	3780	58	the	the	DT
18637	3780	59	public	public	JJ
18637	3780	60	morals	moral	NNS
18637	3780	61	,	,	,
18637	3780	62	nor	nor	CC
18637	3780	63	the	the	DT
18637	3780	64	public	public	JJ
18637	3780	65	safety	safety	NN
18637	3780	66	was	be	VBD
18637	3780	67	involved	involve	VBN
18637	3780	68	.	.	.
18637	3781	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3781	2	1689	1689	CD
18637	3781	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3781	4	Later	late	JJR
18637	3781	5	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3781	6	,	,	,
18637	3781	7	nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
18637	3781	8	,	,	,
18637	3781	9	apply	apply	VB
18637	3781	10	the	the	DT
18637	3781	11	principle	principle	NN
18637	3781	12	of	of	IN
18637	3781	13	inalienability	inalienability	NN
18637	3781	14	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	3781	15	.	.	.
18637	3782	1	To	to	TO
18637	3782	2	quote	quote	VB
18637	3782	3	from	from	IN
18637	3782	4	one	one	CD
18637	3782	5	:	:	:
18637	3782	6	"	"	``
18637	3782	7	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3782	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	3782	9	settled	settle	VBN
18637	3782	10	that	that	IN
18637	3782	11	neither	neither	CC
18637	3782	12	the	the	DT
18637	3782	13	'	'	``
18637	3782	14	contract	contract	NN
18637	3782	15	'	'	''
18637	3782	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	3782	17	nor	nor	CC
18637	3782	18	the	the	DT
18637	3782	19	'	'	``
18637	3782	20	due	due	JJ
18637	3782	21	process	process	NN
18637	3782	22	'	'	''
18637	3782	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	3782	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	3782	25	the	the	DT
18637	3782	26	effect	effect	NN
18637	3782	27	of	of	IN
18637	3782	28	overriding	override	VBG
18637	3782	29	the	the	DT
18637	3782	30	power	power	NN
18637	3782	31	to	to	IN
18637	3782	32	the	the	DT
18637	3782	33	State	State	NNP
18637	3782	34	to	to	TO
18637	3782	35	establish	establish	VB
18637	3782	36	all	all	DT
18637	3782	37	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	3782	38	that	that	WDT
18637	3782	39	are	be	VBP
18637	3782	40	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	3782	41	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3782	42	to	to	TO
18637	3782	43	secure	secure	VB
18637	3782	44	the	the	DT
18637	3782	45	health	health	NN
18637	3782	46	,	,	,
18637	3782	47	safety	safety	NN
18637	3782	48	,	,	,
18637	3782	49	good	good	JJ
18637	3782	50	order	order	NN
18637	3782	51	,	,	,
18637	3782	52	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	3782	53	,	,	,
18637	3782	54	or	or	CC
18637	3782	55	general	general	JJ
18637	3782	56	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	3782	57	of	of	IN
18637	3782	58	the	the	DT
18637	3782	59	community	community	NN
18637	3782	60	;	;	:
18637	3782	61	that	that	IN
18637	3782	62	this	this	DT
18637	3782	63	power	power	NN
18637	3782	64	can	can	MD
18637	3782	65	neither	neither	CC
18637	3782	66	be	be	VB
18637	3782	67	abdicated	abdicate	VBN
18637	3782	68	nor	nor	CC
18637	3782	69	bargained	bargain	VBN
18637	3782	70	away	away	RP
18637	3782	71	,	,	,
18637	3782	72	and	and	CC
18637	3782	73	is	be	VBZ
18637	3782	74	inalienable	inalienable	JJ
18637	3782	75	even	even	RB
18637	3782	76	by	by	IN
18637	3782	77	express	express	NNP
18637	3782	78	grant	grant	NN
18637	3782	79	;	;	:
18637	3782	80	and	and	CC
18637	3782	81	all	all	DT
18637	3782	82	contract	contract	NN
18637	3782	83	and	and	CC
18637	3782	84	property	property	NN
18637	3782	85	rights	right	NNS
18637	3782	86	are	be	VBP
18637	3782	87	held	hold	VBN
18637	3782	88	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3782	89	to	to	IN
18637	3782	90	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3782	91	fair	fair	JJ
18637	3782	92	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3782	93	.	.	.
18637	3783	1	"	"	``
18637	3783	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3783	3	1690	1690	CD
18637	3783	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3783	5	Today	today	NN
18637	3783	6	,	,	,
18637	3783	7	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	3783	8	,	,	,
18637	3783	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3783	10	scarcely	scarcely	RB
18637	3783	11	pays	pay	VBZ
18637	3783	12	a	a	DT
18637	3783	13	company	company	NN
18637	3783	14	to	to	TO
18637	3783	15	rely	rely	VB
18637	3783	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	3783	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3783	18	charter	charter	NN
18637	3783	19	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	3783	20	or	or	CC
18637	3783	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	3783	22	special	special	JJ
18637	3783	23	concessions	concession	NNS
18637	3783	24	from	from	IN
18637	3783	25	a	a	DT
18637	3783	26	State	state	NN
18637	3783	27	in	in	IN
18637	3783	28	resisting	resist	VBG
18637	3783	29	the	the	DT
18637	3783	30	application	application	NN
18637	3783	31	to	to	IN
18637	3783	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3783	33	of	of	IN
18637	3783	34	measures	measure	NNS
18637	3783	35	claiming	claim	VBG
18637	3783	36	to	to	TO
18637	3783	37	have	have	VB
18637	3783	38	been	be	VBN
18637	3783	39	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	3783	40	by	by	IN
18637	3783	41	the	the	DT
18637	3783	42	police	police	NN
18637	3783	43	power	power	NN
18637	3783	44	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	3783	45	.	.	.
18637	3784	1	For	for	IN
18637	3784	2	if	if	IN
18637	3784	3	this	this	DT
18637	3784	4	claim	claim	NN
18637	3784	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	3784	6	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	3784	7	by	by	IN
18637	3784	8	the	the	DT
18637	3784	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3784	10	,	,	,
18637	3784	11	the	the	DT
18637	3784	12	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3784	13	of	of	IN
18637	3784	14	the	the	DT
18637	3784	15	contract	contract	NN
18637	3784	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	3784	17	will	will	MD
18637	3784	18	not	not	RB
18637	3784	19	avail	avail	VB
18637	3784	20	;	;	:
18637	3784	21	while	while	IN
18637	3784	22	if	if	IN
18637	3784	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3784	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	3784	25	not	not	RB
18637	3784	26	,	,	,
18637	3784	27	the	the	DT
18637	3784	28	due	due	JJ
18637	3784	29	process	process	NN
18637	3784	30	of	of	IN
18637	3784	31	law	law	NN
18637	3784	32	clause	clause	NN
18637	3784	33	of	of	IN
18637	3784	34	the	the	DT
18637	3784	35	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	3784	36	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3784	37	will	will	MD
18637	3784	38	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	3784	39	a	a	DT
18637	3784	40	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	3784	41	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	3784	42	.	.	.
18637	3785	1	That	that	DT
18637	3785	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	3785	3	to	to	TO
18637	3785	4	say	say	VB
18637	3785	5	,	,	,
18637	3785	6	the	the	DT
18637	3785	7	discrepancy	discrepancy	NN
18637	3785	8	which	which	WDT
18637	3785	9	once	once	RB
18637	3785	10	existed	exist	VBD
18637	3785	11	between	between	IN
18637	3785	12	the	the	DT
18637	3785	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3785	14	's	's	POS
18637	3785	15	theory	theory	NN
18637	3785	16	of	of	IN
18637	3785	17	an	an	DT
18637	3785	18	overriding	override	VBG
18637	3785	19	police	police	NN
18637	3785	20	power	power	NN
18637	3785	21	in	in	IN
18637	3785	22	these	these	DT
18637	3785	23	two	two	CD
18637	3785	24	adjoining	adjoining	JJ
18637	3785	25	fields	field	NNS
18637	3785	26	of	of	IN
18637	3785	27	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3785	28	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3785	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	3785	30	today	today	NN
18637	3785	31	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	3785	32	at	at	IN
18637	3785	33	an	an	DT
18637	3785	34	end	end	NN
18637	3785	35	.	.	.
18637	3786	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	3786	2	,	,	,
18637	3786	3	there	there	EX
18637	3786	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	3786	5	usually	usually	RB
18637	3786	6	no	no	DT
18637	3786	7	sound	sound	JJ
18637	3786	8	reason	reason	NN
18637	3786	9	why	why	WRB
18637	3786	10	rights	right	NNS
18637	3786	11	based	base	VBN
18637	3786	12	on	on	IN
18637	3786	13	public	public	JJ
18637	3786	14	grant	grant	NN
18637	3786	15	should	should	MD
18637	3786	16	be	be	VB
18637	3786	17	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	3786	18	as	as	IN
18637	3786	19	more	more	RBR
18637	3786	20	sacrosanct	sacrosanct	JJ
18637	3786	21	than	than	IN
18637	3786	22	rights	right	NNS
18637	3786	23	which	which	WDT
18637	3786	24	involve	involve	VBP
18637	3786	25	the	the	DT
18637	3786	26	same	same	JJ
18637	3786	27	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3786	28	matter	matter	NN
18637	3786	29	but	but	CC
18637	3786	30	are	be	VBP
18637	3786	31	of	of	IN
18637	3786	32	different	different	JJ
18637	3786	33	provenience	provenience	NN
18637	3786	34	.	.	.
18637	3787	1	Private	private	JJ
18637	3787	2	Contracts	Contracts	NNPS
18637	3787	3	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	3787	4	of	of	IN
18637	3787	5	the	the	DT
18637	3787	6	Term.--The	Term.--The	NNP
18637	3787	7	term	term	NN
18637	3787	8	"	"	``
18637	3787	9	private	private	JJ
18637	3787	10	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3787	11	"	"	''
18637	3787	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	3787	13	,	,	,
18637	3787	14	naturally	naturally	RB
18637	3787	15	,	,	,
18637	3787	16	not	not	RB
18637	3787	17	all	all	RB
18637	3787	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	3787	19	inclusive	inclusive	JJ
18637	3787	20	.	.	.
18637	3788	1	A	a	DT
18637	3788	2	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	3788	3	,	,	,
18637	3788	4	though	though	IN
18637	3788	5	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3788	6	in	in	IN
18637	3788	7	favor	favor	NN
18637	3788	8	of	of	IN
18637	3788	9	a	a	DT
18637	3788	10	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	3788	11	,	,	,
18637	3788	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	3788	13	not	not	RB
18637	3788	14	a	a	DT
18637	3788	15	contract	contract	NN
18637	3788	16	in	in	IN
18637	3788	17	the	the	DT
18637	3788	18	sense	sense	NN
18637	3788	19	of	of	IN
18637	3788	20	the	the	DT
18637	3788	21	Constitution;[1691	Constitution;[1691	NNP
18637	3788	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3788	23	nor	nor	CC
18637	3788	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	3788	25	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	3788	26	.	.	.
18637	3789	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3789	2	1692	1692	CD
18637	3789	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3789	4	And	and	CC
18637	3789	5	whether	whether	IN
18637	3789	6	a	a	DT
18637	3789	7	particular	particular	JJ
18637	3789	8	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3789	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	3789	10	a	a	DT
18637	3789	11	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3789	12	contract	contract	NN
18637	3789	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	3789	14	a	a	DT
18637	3789	15	question	question	NN
18637	3789	16	for	for	IN
18637	3789	17	the	the	DT
18637	3789	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	3789	19	,	,	,
18637	3789	20	and	and	CC
18637	3789	21	finally	finally	RB
18637	3789	22	for	for	IN
18637	3789	23	the	the	DT
18637	3789	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3789	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3789	26	,	,	,
18637	3789	27	when	when	WRB
18637	3789	28	the	the	DT
18637	3789	29	protection	protection	NN
18637	3789	30	of	of	IN
18637	3789	31	the	the	DT
18637	3789	32	contract	contract	NN
18637	3789	33	clause	clause	NN
18637	3789	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	3789	35	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	3789	36	.	.	.
18637	3790	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3790	2	1693	1693	CD
18637	3790	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3790	4	Source	source	NN
18637	3790	5	of	of	IN
18637	3790	6	the	the	DT
18637	3790	7	Obligation.--The	obligation.--the	JJ
18637	3790	8	question	question	NN
18637	3790	9	of	of	IN
18637	3790	10	the	the	DT
18637	3790	11	nature	nature	NN
18637	3790	12	and	and	CC
18637	3790	13	source	source	NN
18637	3790	14	of	of	IN
18637	3790	15	the	the	DT
18637	3790	16	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3790	17	of	of	IN
18637	3790	18	a	a	DT
18637	3790	19	contract	contract	NN
18637	3790	20	,	,	,
18637	3790	21	which	which	WDT
18637	3790	22	went	go	VBD
18637	3790	23	by	by	IN
18637	3790	24	default	default	NN
18637	3790	25	in	in	IN
18637	3790	26	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	3790	27	_	_	NNP
18637	3790	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	3790	29	_	_	NNP
18637	3790	30	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	3790	31	and	and	CC
18637	3790	32	the	the	DT
18637	3790	33	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	3790	34	College	College	NNP
18637	3790	35	case	case	NN
18637	3790	36	,	,	,
18637	3790	37	with	with	IN
18637	3790	38	such	such	JJ
18637	3790	39	vastly	vastly	RB
18637	3790	40	important	important	JJ
18637	3790	41	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	3790	42	,	,	,
18637	3790	43	had	have	VBD
18637	3790	44	eventually	eventually	RB
18637	3790	45	to	to	TO
18637	3790	46	be	be	VB
18637	3790	47	met	meet	VBN
18637	3790	48	and	and	CC
18637	3790	49	answered	answer	VBN
18637	3790	50	by	by	IN
18637	3790	51	the	the	DT
18637	3790	52	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3790	53	in	in	IN
18637	3790	54	connection	connection	NN
18637	3790	55	with	with	IN
18637	3790	56	private	private	JJ
18637	3790	57	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3790	58	.	.	.
18637	3791	1	The	the	DT
18637	3791	2	first	first	JJ
18637	3791	3	case	case	NN
18637	3791	4	involving	involve	VBG
18637	3791	5	such	such	PDT
18637	3791	6	a	a	DT
18637	3791	7	contract	contract	NN
18637	3791	8	to	to	TO
18637	3791	9	reach	reach	VB
18637	3791	10	the	the	DT
18637	3791	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3791	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3791	13	was	be	VBD
18637	3791	14	Sturges	Sturges	NNP
18637	3791	15	_	_	NNP
18637	3791	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	3791	17	_	_	NNP
18637	3791	18	Crowninshield[1694	Crowninshield[1694	NNP
18637	3791	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3791	20	in	in	IN
18637	3791	21	which	which	WDT
18637	3791	22	a	a	DT
18637	3791	23	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	3791	24	sought	seek	VBD
18637	3791	25	escape	escape	NN
18637	3791	26	behind	behind	IN
18637	3791	27	a	a	DT
18637	3791	28	State	State	NNP
18637	3791	29	insolvency	insolvency	NN
18637	3791	30	act	act	NN
18637	3791	31	of	of	IN
18637	3791	32	later	later	JJ
18637	3791	33	date	date	NN
18637	3791	34	than	than	IN
18637	3791	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3791	36	note	note	NN
18637	3791	37	.	.	.
18637	3792	1	The	the	DT
18637	3792	2	act	act	NN
18637	3792	3	was	be	VBD
18637	3792	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	3792	5	inoperative	inoperative	JJ
18637	3792	6	;	;	:
18637	3792	7	but	but	CC
18637	3792	8	whether	whether	IN
18637	3792	9	this	this	DT
18637	3792	10	was	be	VBD
18637	3792	11	because	because	IN
18637	3792	12	of	of	IN
18637	3792	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3792	14	retroaction	retroaction	NN
18637	3792	15	in	in	IN
18637	3792	16	this	this	DT
18637	3792	17	particular	particular	JJ
18637	3792	18	case	case	NN
18637	3792	19	or	or	CC
18637	3792	20	for	for	IN
18637	3792	21	the	the	DT
18637	3792	22	broader	broad	JJR
18637	3792	23	reason	reason	NN
18637	3792	24	that	that	IN
18637	3792	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3792	26	assumed	assume	VBD
18637	3792	27	to	to	TO
18637	3792	28	excuse	excuse	VB
18637	3792	29	debtors	debtor	NNS
18637	3792	30	from	from	IN
18637	3792	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3792	32	promises	promise	NNS
18637	3792	33	,	,	,
18637	3792	34	was	be	VBD
18637	3792	35	not	not	RB
18637	3792	36	at	at	IN
18637	3792	37	the	the	DT
18637	3792	38	time	time	NN
18637	3792	39	made	make	VBN
18637	3792	40	clear	clear	JJ
18637	3792	41	.	.	.
18637	3793	1	As	as	IN
18637	3793	2	noted	note	VBN
18637	3793	3	earlier	early	RBR
18637	3793	4	,	,	,
18637	3793	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3793	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3793	7	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3793	8	's	's	POS
18637	3793	9	definition	definition	NN
18637	3793	10	on	on	IN
18637	3793	11	this	this	DT
18637	3793	12	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	3793	13	of	of	IN
18637	3793	14	the	the	DT
18637	3793	15	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3793	16	of	of	IN
18637	3793	17	a	a	DT
18637	3793	18	contract	contract	NN
18637	3793	19	as	as	IN
18637	3793	20	the	the	DT
18637	3793	21	law	law	NN
18637	3793	22	which	which	WDT
18637	3793	23	binds	bind	VBZ
18637	3793	24	the	the	DT
18637	3793	25	parties	party	NNS
18637	3793	26	to	to	TO
18637	3793	27	perform	perform	VB
18637	3793	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3793	29	undertakings	undertaking	NNS
18637	3793	30	was	be	VBD
18637	3793	31	not	not	RB
18637	3793	32	free	free	JJ
18637	3793	33	from	from	IN
18637	3793	34	ambiguity	ambiguity	NN
18637	3793	35	,	,	,
18637	3793	36	owing	owe	VBG
18637	3793	37	to	to	IN
18637	3793	38	the	the	DT
18637	3793	39	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
18637	3793	40	connotation	connotation	NN
18637	3793	41	of	of	IN
18637	3793	42	the	the	DT
18637	3793	43	term	term	NN
18637	3793	44	_	_	NNP
18637	3793	45	law	law	NN
18637	3793	46	_	_	NNP
18637	3793	47	.	.	.
18637	3794	1	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	3794	2	_	_	NNP
18637	3794	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	3794	4	_	_	NNP
18637	3794	5	Saunders.--These	Saunders.--These	NNP
18637	3794	6	obscurities	obscurity	NNS
18637	3794	7	were	be	VBD
18637	3794	8	finally	finally	RB
18637	3794	9	cleared	clear	VBN
18637	3794	10	up	up	RP
18637	3794	11	for	for	IN
18637	3794	12	most	most	JJS
18637	3794	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	3794	14	in	in	IN
18637	3794	15	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	3794	16	_	_	NNP
18637	3794	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	3794	18	_	_	NNP
18637	3794	19	Saunders,[1695	saunders,[1695	CD
18637	3794	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3794	21	in	in	IN
18637	3794	22	which	which	WDT
18637	3794	23	the	the	DT
18637	3794	24	temporal	temporal	JJ
18637	3794	25	relation	relation	NN
18637	3794	26	of	of	IN
18637	3794	27	the	the	DT
18637	3794	28	statute	statute	NN
18637	3794	29	and	and	CC
18637	3794	30	the	the	DT
18637	3794	31	contract	contract	NN
18637	3794	32	involved	involve	VBN
18637	3794	33	was	be	VBD
18637	3794	34	exactly	exactly	RB
18637	3794	35	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	3794	36	--	--	:
18637	3794	37	the	the	DT
18637	3794	38	former	former	JJ
18637	3794	39	antedating	antedate	VBG
18637	3794	40	the	the	DT
18637	3794	41	latter	latter	JJ
18637	3794	42	.	.	.
18637	3795	1	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3795	2	contended	contend	VBD
18637	3795	3	,	,	,
18637	3795	4	but	but	CC
18637	3795	5	unsuccessfully	unsuccessfully	RB
18637	3795	6	,	,	,
18637	3795	7	that	that	IN
18637	3795	8	the	the	DT
18637	3795	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	3795	10	was	be	VBD
18637	3795	11	void	void	JJ
18637	3795	12	,	,	,
18637	3795	13	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	3795	14	as	as	IN
18637	3795	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3795	16	purported	purport	VBD
18637	3795	17	to	to	TO
18637	3795	18	release	release	VB
18637	3795	19	the	the	DT
18637	3795	20	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	3795	21	from	from	IN
18637	3795	22	that	that	DT
18637	3795	23	original	original	JJ
18637	3795	24	,	,	,
18637	3795	25	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
18637	3795	26	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3795	27	which	which	WDT
18637	3795	28	always	always	RB
18637	3795	29	attaches	attach	VBZ
18637	3795	30	under	under	IN
18637	3795	31	natural	natural	JJ
18637	3795	32	law	law	NN
18637	3795	33	to	to	IN
18637	3795	34	the	the	DT
18637	3795	35	acts	act	NNS
18637	3795	36	of	of	IN
18637	3795	37	free	free	JJ
18637	3795	38	agents	agent	NNS
18637	3795	39	.	.	.
18637	3796	1	"	"	``
18637	3796	2	When	when	WRB
18637	3796	3	,	,	,
18637	3796	4	"	"	''
18637	3796	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3796	6	wrote	write	VBD
18637	3796	7	,	,	,
18637	3796	8	"	"	``
18637	3796	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3796	10	advert	advert	RB
18637	3796	11	to	to	IN
18637	3796	12	the	the	DT
18637	3796	13	course	course	NN
18637	3796	14	of	of	IN
18637	3796	15	reading	reading	NN
18637	3796	16	generally	generally	RB
18637	3796	17	pursued	pursue	VBN
18637	3796	18	by	by	IN
18637	3796	19	American	american	JJ
18637	3796	20	statesmen	statesman	NNS
18637	3796	21	in	in	IN
18637	3796	22	early	early	JJ
18637	3796	23	life	life	NN
18637	3796	24	,	,	,
18637	3796	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3796	26	must	must	MD
18637	3796	27	suppose	suppose	VB
18637	3796	28	that	that	IN
18637	3796	29	the	the	DT
18637	3796	30	framers	framer	NNS
18637	3796	31	of	of	IN
18637	3796	32	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3796	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3796	34	were	be	VBD
18637	3796	35	intimately	intimately	RB
18637	3796	36	acquainted	acquaint	VBN
18637	3796	37	with	with	IN
18637	3796	38	the	the	DT
18637	3796	39	writings	writing	NNS
18637	3796	40	of	of	IN
18637	3796	41	those	those	DT
18637	3796	42	wise	wise	JJ
18637	3796	43	and	and	CC
18637	3796	44	learned	learn	VBD
18637	3796	45	men	man	NNS
18637	3796	46	whose	whose	WP$
18637	3796	47	treatises	treatise	NNS
18637	3796	48	on	on	IN
18637	3796	49	the	the	DT
18637	3796	50	laws	law	NNS
18637	3796	51	of	of	IN
18637	3796	52	nature	nature	NN
18637	3796	53	and	and	CC
18637	3796	54	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3796	55	have	have	VBP
18637	3796	56	guided	guide	VBN
18637	3796	57	public	public	JJ
18637	3796	58	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3796	59	on	on	IN
18637	3796	60	the	the	DT
18637	3796	61	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	3796	62	of	of	IN
18637	3796	63	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3796	64	and	and	CC
18637	3796	65	contract	contract	NN
18637	3796	66	,	,	,
18637	3796	67	"	"	''
18637	3796	68	and	and	CC
18637	3796	69	that	that	IN
18637	3796	70	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3796	71	took	take	VBD
18637	3796	72	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3796	73	views	view	NNS
18637	3796	74	on	on	IN
18637	3796	75	these	these	DT
18637	3796	76	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	3796	77	from	from	IN
18637	3796	78	those	those	DT
18637	3796	79	sources	source	NNS
18637	3796	80	.	.	.
18637	3797	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3797	2	also	also	RB
18637	3797	3	posed	pose	VBD
18637	3797	4	the	the	DT
18637	3797	5	question	question	NN
18637	3797	6	of	of	IN
18637	3797	7	what	what	WP
18637	3797	8	would	would	MD
18637	3797	9	happen	happen	VB
18637	3797	10	to	to	IN
18637	3797	11	the	the	DT
18637	3797	12	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3797	13	of	of	IN
18637	3797	14	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3797	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	3797	16	if	if	IN
18637	3797	17	States	States	NNP
18637	3797	18	might	may	MD
18637	3797	19	pass	pass	VB
18637	3797	20	acts	act	NNS
18637	3797	21	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	3797	22	that	that	IN
18637	3797	23	all	all	DT
18637	3797	24	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3797	25	made	make	VBD
18637	3797	26	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	3797	27	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	3797	28	should	should	MD
18637	3797	29	be	be	VB
18637	3797	30	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3797	31	to	to	IN
18637	3797	32	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3797	33	control	control	NN
18637	3797	34	.	.	.
18637	3798	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3798	2	1696	1696	CD
18637	3798	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3798	4	For	for	IN
18637	3798	5	the	the	DT
18637	3798	6	first	first	JJ
18637	3798	7	and	and	CC
18637	3798	8	only	only	JJ
18637	3798	9	time	time	NN
18637	3798	10	majority	majority	NN
18637	3798	11	of	of	IN
18637	3798	12	the	the	DT
18637	3798	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3798	14	abandoned	abandon	VBD
18637	3798	15	the	the	DT
18637	3798	16	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3798	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3798	18	's	's	POS
18637	3798	19	leadership	leadership	NN
18637	3798	20	.	.	.
18637	3799	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	3799	2	by	by	IN
18637	3799	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3799	4	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	3799	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3799	6	held	hold	VBD
18637	3799	7	that	that	IN
18637	3799	8	the	the	DT
18637	3799	9	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3799	10	of	of	IN
18637	3799	11	private	private	JJ
18637	3799	12	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3799	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	3799	14	derived	derive	VBN
18637	3799	15	from	from	IN
18637	3799	16	the	the	DT
18637	3799	17	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	3799	18	law	law	NN
18637	3799	19	--	--	:
18637	3799	20	State	state	NN
18637	3799	21	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3799	22	and	and	CC
18637	3799	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3799	24	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3799	25	--	--	:
18637	3799	26	and	and	CC
18637	3799	27	that	that	IN
18637	3799	28	the	the	DT
18637	3799	29	inhibition	inhibition	NN
18637	3799	30	of	of	IN
18637	3799	31	article	article	NN
18637	3799	32	I	i	NN
18637	3799	33	,	,	,
18637	3799	34	section	section	NN
18637	3799	35	10	10	CD
18637	3799	36	,	,	,
18637	3799	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	3799	38	confined	confine	VBN
18637	3799	39	to	to	IN
18637	3799	40	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3799	41	acts	act	NNS
18637	3799	42	made	make	VBN
18637	3799	43	after	after	IN
18637	3799	44	the	the	DT
18637	3799	45	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3799	46	affected	affect	VBN
18637	3799	47	by	by	IN
18637	3799	48	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3799	49	,	,	,
18637	3799	50	with	with	IN
18637	3799	51	one	one	CD
18637	3799	52	exception	exception	NN
18637	3799	53	.	.	.
18637	3800	1	For	for	IN
18637	3800	2	by	by	IN
18637	3800	3	a	a	DT
18637	3800	4	curiously	curiously	RB
18637	3800	5	complicated	complicate	VBN
18637	3800	6	line	line	NN
18637	3800	7	of	of	IN
18637	3800	8	reasoning	reason	VBG
18637	3800	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3800	10	was	be	VBD
18637	3800	11	also	also	RB
18637	3800	12	held	hold	VBN
18637	3800	13	in	in	IN
18637	3800	14	this	this	DT
18637	3800	15	same	same	JJ
18637	3800	16	case	case	NN
18637	3800	17	that	that	IN
18637	3800	18	when	when	WRB
18637	3800	19	the	the	DT
18637	3800	20	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	3800	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	3800	22	a	a	DT
18637	3800	23	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	3800	24	,	,	,
18637	3800	25	then	then	RB
18637	3800	26	a	a	DT
18637	3800	27	State	state	NN
18637	3800	28	may	may	MD
18637	3800	29	not	not	RB
18637	3800	30	by	by	IN
18637	3800	31	an	an	DT
18637	3800	32	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
18637	3800	33	law	law	NN
18637	3800	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	3800	35	under	under	IN
18637	3800	36	a	a	DT
18637	3800	37	contract	contract	NN
18637	3800	38	,	,	,
18637	3800	39	albeit	albeit	IN
18637	3800	40	one	one	CD
18637	3800	41	of	of	IN
18637	3800	42	later	later	JJ
18637	3800	43	date	date	NN
18637	3800	44	.	.	.
18637	3801	1	With	with	IN
18637	3801	2	the	the	DT
18637	3801	3	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	3801	4	established	establish	VBN
18637	3801	5	that	that	IN
18637	3801	6	the	the	DT
18637	3801	7	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3801	8	of	of	IN
18637	3801	9	a	a	DT
18637	3801	10	private	private	JJ
18637	3801	11	contract	contract	NN
18637	3801	12	comes	come	VBZ
18637	3801	13	from	from	IN
18637	3801	14	the	the	DT
18637	3801	15	_	_	NNP
18637	3801	16	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	3801	17	_	_	NNP
18637	3801	18	law	law	NN
18637	3801	19	in	in	IN
18637	3801	20	existence	existence	NN
18637	3801	21	when	when	WRB
18637	3801	22	the	the	DT
18637	3801	23	contract	contract	NN
18637	3801	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	3801	25	made	make	VBN
18637	3801	26	,	,	,
18637	3801	27	a	a	DT
18637	3801	28	further	further	JJ
18637	3801	29	question	question	NN
18637	3801	30	presents	present	VBZ
18637	3801	31	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3801	32	,	,	,
18637	3801	33	namely	namely	RB
18637	3801	34	,	,	,
18637	3801	35	what	what	WDT
18637	3801	36	part	part	NN
18637	3801	37	of	of	IN
18637	3801	38	the	the	DT
18637	3801	39	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	3801	40	law	law	NN
18637	3801	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	3801	42	referred	refer	VBN
18637	3801	43	to	to	IN
18637	3801	44	?	?	.
18637	3802	1	No	no	RB
18637	3802	2	doubt	doubt	RB
18637	3802	3	,	,	,
18637	3802	4	the	the	DT
18637	3802	5	law	law	NN
18637	3802	6	which	which	WDT
18637	3802	7	determines	determine	VBZ
18637	3802	8	the	the	DT
18637	3802	9	validity	validity	NN
18637	3802	10	of	of	IN
18637	3802	11	the	the	DT
18637	3802	12	contract	contract	NN
18637	3802	13	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3802	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	3802	15	a	a	DT
18637	3802	16	part	part	NN
18637	3802	17	of	of	IN
18637	3802	18	such	such	JJ
18637	3802	19	law	law	NN
18637	3802	20	.	.	.
18637	3803	1	Also	also	RB
18637	3803	2	,	,	,
18637	3803	3	the	the	DT
18637	3803	4	law	law	NN
18637	3803	5	which	which	WDT
18637	3803	6	interprets	interpret	VBZ
18637	3803	7	the	the	DT
18637	3803	8	terms	term	NNS
18637	3803	9	used	use	VBN
18637	3803	10	in	in	IN
18637	3803	11	the	the	DT
18637	3803	12	contract	contract	NN
18637	3803	13	,	,	,
18637	3803	14	or	or	CC
18637	3803	15	which	which	WDT
18637	3803	16	supplies	supply	VBZ
18637	3803	17	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3803	18	terms	term	NNS
18637	3803	19	when	when	WRB
18637	3803	20	others	other	NNS
18637	3803	21	are	be	VBP
18637	3803	22	used	use	VBN
18637	3803	23	;	;	:
18637	3803	24	as	as	IN
18637	3803	25	for	for	IN
18637	3803	26	instance	instance	NN
18637	3803	27	,	,	,
18637	3803	28	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3803	29	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	3803	30	or	or	CC
18637	3803	31	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3803	32	which	which	WDT
18637	3803	33	determine	determine	VBP
18637	3803	34	what	what	WP
18637	3803	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	3803	36	"	"	``
18637	3803	37	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3803	38	tender	tender	NN
18637	3803	39	"	"	''
18637	3803	40	for	for	IN
18637	3803	41	the	the	DT
18637	3803	42	payment	payment	NN
18637	3803	43	of	of	IN
18637	3803	44	debts	debt	NNS
18637	3803	45	;	;	:
18637	3803	46	or	or	CC
18637	3803	47	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3803	48	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3803	49	which	which	WDT
18637	3803	50	construe	construe	VBP
18637	3803	51	the	the	DT
18637	3803	52	term	term	NN
18637	3803	53	"	"	``
18637	3803	54	for	for	IN
18637	3803	55	value	value	NN
18637	3803	56	received	receive	VBN
18637	3803	57	"	"	''
18637	3803	58	as	as	IN
18637	3803	59	used	use	VBN
18637	3803	60	in	in	IN
18637	3803	61	a	a	DT
18637	3803	62	promissory	promissory	JJ
18637	3803	63	note	note	NN
18637	3803	64	,	,	,
18637	3803	65	and	and	CC
18637	3803	66	so	so	RB
18637	3803	67	on	on	RB
18637	3803	68	.	.	.
18637	3804	1	In	in	IN
18637	3804	2	short	short	JJ
18637	3804	3	,	,	,
18637	3804	4	any	any	DT
18637	3804	5	law	law	NN
18637	3804	6	which	which	WDT
18637	3804	7	at	at	IN
18637	3804	8	the	the	DT
18637	3804	9	time	time	NN
18637	3804	10	of	of	IN
18637	3804	11	the	the	DT
18637	3804	12	making	making	NN
18637	3804	13	of	of	IN
18637	3804	14	a	a	DT
18637	3804	15	contract	contract	NN
18637	3804	16	goes	go	VBZ
18637	3804	17	to	to	TO
18637	3804	18	measure	measure	VB
18637	3804	19	the	the	DT
18637	3804	20	rights	right	NNS
18637	3804	21	and	and	CC
18637	3804	22	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3804	23	of	of	IN
18637	3804	24	the	the	DT
18637	3804	25	parties	party	NNS
18637	3804	26	to	to	IN
18637	3804	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3804	28	in	in	IN
18637	3804	29	relation	relation	NN
18637	3804	30	to	to	IN
18637	3804	31	each	each	DT
18637	3804	32	other	other	JJ
18637	3804	33	enters	enter	NNS
18637	3804	34	into	into	IN
18637	3804	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3804	36	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3804	37	.	.	.
18637	3805	1	Remedy	remedy	VB
18637	3805	2	a	a	DT
18637	3805	3	Part	part	NN
18637	3805	4	of	of	IN
18637	3805	5	the	the	DT
18637	3805	6	Obligation	Obligation	NNP
18637	3805	7	Suppose	Suppose	NNP
18637	3805	8	,	,	,
18637	3805	9	however	however	RB
18637	3805	10	,	,	,
18637	3805	11	that	that	IN
18637	3805	12	one	one	CD
18637	3805	13	of	of	IN
18637	3805	14	the	the	DT
18637	3805	15	parties	party	NNS
18637	3805	16	to	to	IN
18637	3805	17	a	a	DT
18637	3805	18	contract	contract	NN
18637	3805	19	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	3805	20	to	to	TO
18637	3805	21	live	live	VB
18637	3805	22	up	up	RP
18637	3805	23	to	to	IN
18637	3805	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3805	25	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3805	26	as	as	IN
18637	3805	27	thus	thus	RB
18637	3805	28	determined	determine	VBN
18637	3805	29	.	.	.
18637	3806	1	The	the	DT
18637	3806	2	contract	contract	NN
18637	3806	3	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3806	4	may	may	MD
18637	3806	5	now	now	RB
18637	3806	6	be	be	VB
18637	3806	7	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	3806	8	as	as	IN
18637	3806	9	at	at	IN
18637	3806	10	an	an	DT
18637	3806	11	end	end	NN
18637	3806	12	;	;	:
18637	3806	13	but	but	CC
18637	3806	14	the	the	DT
18637	3806	15	injured	injured	JJ
18637	3806	16	party	party	NN
18637	3806	17	,	,	,
18637	3806	18	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	3806	19	,	,	,
18637	3806	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	3806	21	a	a	DT
18637	3806	22	new	new	JJ
18637	3806	23	set	set	NN
18637	3806	24	of	of	IN
18637	3806	25	rights	right	NNS
18637	3806	26	in	in	IN
18637	3806	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3806	28	stead	stead	NN
18637	3806	29	,	,	,
18637	3806	30	those	those	DT
18637	3806	31	which	which	WDT
18637	3806	32	are	be	VBP
18637	3806	33	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	3806	34	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3806	35	by	by	IN
18637	3806	36	the	the	DT
18637	3806	37	remedial	remedial	JJ
18637	3806	38	law	law	NN
18637	3806	39	,	,	,
18637	3806	40	including	include	VBG
18637	3806	41	the	the	DT
18637	3806	42	law	law	NN
18637	3806	43	of	of	IN
18637	3806	44	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	3806	45	.	.	.
18637	3807	1	In	in	IN
18637	3807	2	the	the	DT
18637	3807	3	case	case	NN
18637	3807	4	of	of	IN
18637	3807	5	a	a	DT
18637	3807	6	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	3807	7	,	,	,
18637	3807	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3807	9	may	may	MD
18637	3807	10	foreclose	foreclose	VB
18637	3807	11	;	;	:
18637	3807	12	in	in	IN
18637	3807	13	the	the	DT
18637	3807	14	case	case	NN
18637	3807	15	of	of	IN
18637	3807	16	a	a	DT
18637	3807	17	promissory	promissory	JJ
18637	3807	18	note	note	NN
18637	3807	19	,	,	,
18637	3807	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3807	21	may	may	MD
18637	3807	22	sue	sue	VB
18637	3807	23	;	;	:
18637	3807	24	in	in	IN
18637	3807	25	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3807	26	cases	case	NNS
18637	3807	27	,	,	,
18637	3807	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3807	29	may	may	MD
18637	3807	30	demand	demand	VB
18637	3807	31	specific	specific	JJ
18637	3807	32	performance	performance	NN
18637	3807	33	.	.	.
18637	3808	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	3808	2	the	the	DT
18637	3808	3	further	further	JJ
18637	3808	4	question	question	NN
18637	3808	5	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	3808	6	,	,	,
18637	3808	7	whether	whether	IN
18637	3808	8	this	this	DT
18637	3808	9	remedial	remedial	JJ
18637	3808	10	law	law	NN
18637	3808	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	3808	12	to	to	TO
18637	3808	13	be	be	VB
18637	3808	14	considered	consider	VBN
18637	3808	15	a	a	DT
18637	3808	16	part	part	NN
18637	3808	17	of	of	IN
18637	3808	18	the	the	DT
18637	3808	19	law	law	NN
18637	3808	20	supplying	supply	VBG
18637	3808	21	the	the	DT
18637	3808	22	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3808	23	of	of	IN
18637	3808	24	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3808	25	.	.	.
18637	3809	1	Originally	originally	RB
18637	3809	2	,	,	,
18637	3809	3	the	the	DT
18637	3809	4	predominating	predominate	VBG
18637	3809	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3809	6	was	be	VBD
18637	3809	7	negative	negative	JJ
18637	3809	8	,	,	,
18637	3809	9	since	since	IN
18637	3809	10	as	as	IN
18637	3809	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3809	12	have	have	VBP
18637	3809	13	just	just	RB
18637	3809	14	seen	see	VBN
18637	3809	15	,	,	,
18637	3809	16	this	this	DT
18637	3809	17	law	law	NN
18637	3809	18	does	do	VBZ
18637	3809	19	not	not	RB
18637	3809	20	really	really	RB
18637	3809	21	come	come	VB
18637	3809	22	into	into	IN
18637	3809	23	operation	operation	NN
18637	3809	24	until	until	IN
18637	3809	25	the	the	DT
18637	3809	26	contract	contract	NN
18637	3809	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	3809	28	been	be	VBN
18637	3809	29	broken	break	VBN
18637	3809	30	.	.	.
18637	3810	1	Yet	yet	CC
18637	3810	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3810	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	3810	4	obvious	obvious	JJ
18637	3810	5	that	that	IN
18637	3810	6	the	the	DT
18637	3810	7	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	3810	8	which	which	WDT
18637	3810	9	this	this	DT
18637	3810	10	law	law	NN
18637	3810	11	lends	lend	VBZ
18637	3810	12	to	to	IN
18637	3810	13	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3810	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	3810	15	extremely	extremely	RB
18637	3810	16	important	important	JJ
18637	3810	17	--	--	:
18637	3810	18	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	3810	19	,	,	,
18637	3810	20	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
18637	3810	21	.	.	.
18637	3811	1	In	in	IN
18637	3811	2	due	due	JJ
18637	3811	3	course	course	NN
18637	3811	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3811	5	became	become	VBD
18637	3811	6	the	the	DT
18637	3811	7	accepted	accepted	JJ
18637	3811	8	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3811	9	that	that	IN
18637	3811	10	that	that	DT
18637	3811	11	part	part	NN
18637	3811	12	of	of	IN
18637	3811	13	the	the	DT
18637	3811	14	law	law	NN
18637	3811	15	which	which	WDT
18637	3811	16	supplies	supply	VBZ
18637	3811	17	one	one	CD
18637	3811	18	party	party	NN
18637	3811	19	to	to	IN
18637	3811	20	a	a	DT
18637	3811	21	contract	contract	NN
18637	3811	22	with	with	IN
18637	3811	23	a	a	DT
18637	3811	24	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	3811	25	if	if	IN
18637	3811	26	the	the	DT
18637	3811	27	other	other	JJ
18637	3811	28	party	party	NN
18637	3811	29	does	do	VBZ
18637	3811	30	not	not	RB
18637	3811	31	live	live	VB
18637	3811	32	up	up	RP
18637	3811	33	to	to	IN
18637	3811	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3811	35	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3811	36	,	,	,
18637	3811	37	as	as	IN
18637	3811	38	authoritatively	authoritatively	RB
18637	3811	39	interpreted	interpret	VBD
18637	3811	40	,	,	,
18637	3811	41	entered	enter	VBN
18637	3811	42	into	into	IN
18637	3811	43	the	the	DT
18637	3811	44	"	"	``
18637	3811	45	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3811	46	of	of	IN
18637	3811	47	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3811	48	"	"	''
18637	3811	49	in	in	IN
18637	3811	50	the	the	DT
18637	3811	51	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3811	52	sense	sense	NN
18637	3811	53	of	of	IN
18637	3811	54	this	this	DT
18637	3811	55	term	term	NN
18637	3811	56	,	,	,
18637	3811	57	and	and	CC
18637	3811	58	so	so	RB
18637	3811	59	might	may	MD
18637	3811	60	not	not	RB
18637	3811	61	be	be	VB
18637	3811	62	altered	alter	VBN
18637	3811	63	to	to	IN
18637	3811	64	the	the	DT
18637	3811	65	material	material	JJ
18637	3811	66	weakening	weakening	NN
18637	3811	67	of	of	IN
18637	3811	68	existing	exist	VBG
18637	3811	69	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3811	70	.	.	.
18637	3812	1	In	in	IN
18637	3812	2	the	the	DT
18637	3812	3	court	court	NN
18637	3812	4	's	's	POS
18637	3812	5	own	own	JJ
18637	3812	6	words	word	NNS
18637	3812	7	,	,	,
18637	3812	8	"	"	``
18637	3812	9	Nothing	nothing	NN
18637	3812	10	can	can	MD
18637	3812	11	be	be	VB
18637	3812	12	more	more	JJR
18637	3812	13	material	material	NN
18637	3812	14	to	to	IN
18637	3812	15	the	the	DT
18637	3812	16	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3812	17	than	than	IN
18637	3812	18	the	the	DT
18637	3812	19	means	mean	NNS
18637	3812	20	of	of	IN
18637	3812	21	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	3812	22	.	.	.
18637	3813	1	Without	without	IN
18637	3813	2	the	the	DT
18637	3813	3	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	3813	4	the	the	DT
18637	3813	5	contract	contract	NN
18637	3813	6	may	may	MD
18637	3813	7	,	,	,
18637	3813	8	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	3813	9	,	,	,
18637	3813	10	in	in	IN
18637	3813	11	the	the	DT
18637	3813	12	sense	sense	NN
18637	3813	13	of	of	IN
18637	3813	14	the	the	DT
18637	3813	15	law	law	NN
18637	3813	16	,	,	,
18637	3813	17	be	be	VB
18637	3813	18	said	say	VBN
18637	3813	19	not	not	RB
18637	3813	20	to	to	TO
18637	3813	21	exist	exist	VB
18637	3813	22	,	,	,
18637	3813	23	and	and	CC
18637	3813	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3813	25	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3813	26	to	to	TO
18637	3813	27	fall	fall	VB
18637	3813	28	within	within	IN
18637	3813	29	the	the	DT
18637	3813	30	class	class	NN
18637	3813	31	of	of	IN
18637	3813	32	those	those	DT
18637	3813	33	moral	moral	JJ
18637	3813	34	and	and	CC
18637	3813	35	social	social	JJ
18637	3813	36	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3813	37	which	which	WDT
18637	3813	38	depend	depend	VBP
18637	3813	39	for	for	IN
18637	3813	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3813	41	fulfillment	fulfillment	NN
18637	3813	42	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	3813	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	3813	44	the	the	DT
18637	3813	45	will	will	NN
18637	3813	46	of	of	IN
18637	3813	47	the	the	DT
18637	3813	48	individual	individual	NN
18637	3813	49	.	.	.
18637	3814	1	The	the	DT
18637	3814	2	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	3814	3	of	of	IN
18637	3814	4	validity	validity	NN
18637	3814	5	and	and	CC
18637	3814	6	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	3814	7	are	be	VBP
18637	3814	8	inseparable	inseparable	JJ
18637	3814	9	,	,	,
18637	3814	10	*	*	NFP
18637	3814	11	*	*	NFP
18637	3814	12	*	*	NFP
18637	3814	13	"	"	''
18637	3814	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3814	15	1697	1697	CD
18637	3814	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3814	17	Establishment	Establishment	NNP
18637	3814	18	Of	of	IN
18637	3814	19	The	the	DT
18637	3814	20	Rules.--This	rules.--thi	NNS
18637	3814	21	rule	rule	NN
18637	3814	22	was	be	VBD
18637	3814	23	first	first	RB
18637	3814	24	definitely	definitely	RB
18637	3814	25	announced	announce	VBN
18637	3814	26	in	in	IN
18637	3814	27	1843	1843	CD
18637	3814	28	in	in	IN
18637	3814	29	the	the	DT
18637	3814	30	case	case	NN
18637	3814	31	of	of	IN
18637	3814	32	Bronson	Bronson	NNP
18637	3814	33	_	_	NNP
18637	3814	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	3814	35	_	_	NNP
18637	3814	36	Kinzie	Kinzie	NNP
18637	3814	37	.	.	.
18637	3815	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3815	2	1698	1698	CD
18637	3815	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3815	4	Here	here	RB
18637	3815	5	an	an	DT
18637	3815	6	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	3815	7	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	3815	8	giving	give	VBG
18637	3815	9	the	the	DT
18637	3815	10	mortgagee	mortgagee	NN
18637	3815	11	an	an	DT
18637	3815	12	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
18637	3815	13	power	power	NN
18637	3815	14	of	of	IN
18637	3815	15	sale	sale	NN
18637	3815	16	in	in	IN
18637	3815	17	case	case	NN
18637	3815	18	of	of	IN
18637	3815	19	the	the	DT
18637	3815	20	mortgagor	mortgagor	NNP
18637	3815	21	's	's	POS
18637	3815	22	fault	fault	NN
18637	3815	23	was	be	VBD
18637	3815	24	involved	involve	VBN
18637	3815	25	,	,	,
18637	3815	26	along	along	IN
18637	3815	27	with	with	IN
18637	3815	28	a	a	DT
18637	3815	29	later	later	JJ
18637	3815	30	act	act	NN
18637	3815	31	of	of	IN
18637	3815	32	the	the	DT
18637	3815	33	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3815	34	which	which	WDT
18637	3815	35	required	require	VBD
18637	3815	36	mortgaged	mortgage	VBD
18637	3815	37	premises	premise	NNS
18637	3815	38	to	to	TO
18637	3815	39	be	be	VB
18637	3815	40	sold	sell	VBN
18637	3815	41	for	for	IN
18637	3815	42	not	not	RB
18637	3815	43	less	less	JJR
18637	3815	44	than	than	IN
18637	3815	45	two	two	CD
18637	3815	46	-	-	HYPH
18637	3815	47	thirds	third	NNS
18637	3815	48	of	of	IN
18637	3815	49	the	the	DT
18637	3815	50	appraised	appraise	VBN
18637	3815	51	value	value	NN
18637	3815	52	,	,	,
18637	3815	53	and	and	CC
18637	3815	54	allowed	allow	VBD
18637	3815	55	the	the	DT
18637	3815	56	mortgagor	mortgagor	NN
18637	3815	57	a	a	DT
18637	3815	58	year	year	NN
18637	3815	59	after	after	IN
18637	3815	60	the	the	DT
18637	3815	61	sale	sale	NN
18637	3815	62	to	to	TO
18637	3815	63	redeem	redeem	VB
18637	3815	64	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3815	65	.	.	.
18637	3816	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3816	2	was	be	VBD
18637	3816	3	held	hold	VBN
18637	3816	4	that	that	IN
18637	3816	5	the	the	DT
18637	3816	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	3816	7	,	,	,
18637	3816	8	in	in	IN
18637	3816	9	altering	alter	VBG
18637	3816	10	the	the	DT
18637	3816	11	preexisting	preexisting	NN
18637	3816	12	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	3816	13	to	to	IN
18637	3816	14	such	such	PDT
18637	3816	15	an	an	DT
18637	3816	16	extent	extent	NN
18637	3816	17	,	,	,
18637	3816	18	violated	violate	VBD
18637	3816	19	the	the	DT
18637	3816	20	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3816	21	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3816	22	,	,	,
18637	3816	23	and	and	CC
18637	3816	24	hence	hence	RB
18637	3816	25	was	be	VBD
18637	3816	26	void	void	JJ
18637	3816	27	.	.	.
18637	3817	1	The	the	DT
18637	3817	2	year	year	NN
18637	3817	3	following	follow	VBG
18637	3817	4	a	a	DT
18637	3817	5	like	like	JJ
18637	3817	6	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	3817	7	was	be	VBD
18637	3817	8	made	make	VBN
18637	3817	9	in	in	IN
18637	3817	10	the	the	DT
18637	3817	11	case	case	NN
18637	3817	12	of	of	IN
18637	3817	13	McCracken	McCracken	NNP
18637	3817	14	_	_	NNP
18637	3817	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	3817	16	_	_	NNP
18637	3817	17	Hayward[1699	Hayward[1699	NNP
18637	3817	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3817	19	as	as	IN
18637	3817	20	to	to	IN
18637	3817	21	a	a	DT
18637	3817	22	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	3817	23	provision	provision	NN
18637	3817	24	that	that	IN
18637	3817	25	personal	personal	JJ
18637	3817	26	property	property	NN
18637	3817	27	should	should	MD
18637	3817	28	not	not	RB
18637	3817	29	be	be	VB
18637	3817	30	sold	sell	VBN
18637	3817	31	under	under	IN
18637	3817	32	execution	execution	NN
18637	3817	33	for	for	IN
18637	3817	34	less	less	JJR
18637	3817	35	than	than	IN
18637	3817	36	two	two	CD
18637	3817	37	-	-	HYPH
18637	3817	38	thirds	third	NNS
18637	3817	39	of	of	IN
18637	3817	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3817	41	appraised	appraise	VBN
18637	3817	42	value	value	NN
18637	3817	43	.	.	.
18637	3818	1	Qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	3818	2	Of	of	IN
18637	3818	3	The	the	DT
18637	3818	4	Rule.--But	Rule.--But	NNP
18637	3818	5	the	the	DT
18637	3818	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	3818	7	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
18637	3818	8	by	by	IN
18637	3818	9	these	these	DT
18637	3818	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	3818	11	does	do	VBZ
18637	3818	12	not	not	RB
18637	3818	13	signify	signify	VB
18637	3818	14	that	that	IN
18637	3818	15	a	a	DT
18637	3818	16	State	state	NN
18637	3818	17	may	may	MD
18637	3818	18	make	make	VB
18637	3818	19	no	no	DT
18637	3818	20	changes	change	NNS
18637	3818	21	in	in	IN
18637	3818	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3818	23	remedial	remedial	JJ
18637	3818	24	or	or	CC
18637	3818	25	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	3818	26	law	law	NN
18637	3818	27	which	which	WDT
18637	3818	28	affect	affect	VBP
18637	3818	29	existing	existing	JJ
18637	3818	30	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3818	31	.	.	.
18637	3819	1	"	"	``
18637	3819	2	Provided	provide	VBN
18637	3819	3	,	,	,
18637	3819	4	"	"	''
18637	3819	5	the	the	DT
18637	3819	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3819	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	3819	8	said	say	VBN
18637	3819	9	,	,	,
18637	3819	10	"	"	``
18637	3819	11	a	a	DT
18637	3819	12	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	3819	13	or	or	CC
18637	3819	14	efficacious	efficacious	JJ
18637	3819	15	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	3819	16	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	3819	17	or	or	CC
18637	3819	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	3819	19	given	give	VBN
18637	3819	20	,	,	,
18637	3819	21	by	by	IN
18637	3819	22	means	mean	NNS
18637	3819	23	of	of	IN
18637	3819	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3819	25	a	a	DT
18637	3819	26	party	party	NN
18637	3819	27	can	can	MD
18637	3819	28	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	3819	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3819	30	rights	right	NNS
18637	3819	31	under	under	IN
18637	3819	32	the	the	DT
18637	3819	33	contract	contract	NN
18637	3819	34	,	,	,
18637	3819	35	the	the	DT
18637	3819	36	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	3819	37	may	may	MD
18637	3819	38	modify	modify	VB
18637	3819	39	or	or	CC
18637	3819	40	change	change	VB
18637	3819	41	existing	exist	VBG
18637	3819	42	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	3819	43	or	or	CC
18637	3819	44	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	3819	45	new	new	JJ
18637	3819	46	modes	mode	NNS
18637	3819	47	of	of	IN
18637	3819	48	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	3819	49	.	.	.
18637	3820	1	"	"	``
18637	3820	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3820	3	1700	1700	CD
18637	3820	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3820	5	Thus	thus	RB
18637	3820	6	States	States	NNP
18637	3820	7	are	be	VBP
18637	3820	8	constantly	constantly	RB
18637	3820	9	remodelling	remodelle	VBG
18637	3820	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3820	11	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3820	12	systems	system	NNS
18637	3820	13	and	and	CC
18637	3820	14	modes	mode	NNS
18637	3820	15	of	of	IN
18637	3820	16	practice	practice	NN
18637	3820	17	unembarrassed	unembarrasse	VBN
18637	3820	18	by	by	IN
18637	3820	19	the	the	DT
18637	3820	20	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3820	21	of	of	IN
18637	3820	22	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3820	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	3820	24	.	.	.
18637	3821	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3821	2	1701	1701	CD
18637	3821	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3821	4	The	the	DT
18637	3821	5	right	right	NN
18637	3821	6	of	of	IN
18637	3821	7	a	a	DT
18637	3821	8	State	State	NNP
18637	3821	9	to	to	TO
18637	3821	10	abolish	abolish	VB
18637	3821	11	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	3821	12	for	for	IN
18637	3821	13	debt	debt	NN
18637	3821	14	was	be	VBD
18637	3821	15	early	early	RB
18637	3821	16	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	3821	17	.	.	.
18637	3822	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3822	2	1702	1702	CD
18637	3822	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3822	4	Again	again	RB
18637	3822	5	the	the	DT
18637	3822	6	right	right	NN
18637	3822	7	of	of	IN
18637	3822	8	a	a	DT
18637	3822	9	State	State	NNP
18637	3822	10	to	to	TO
18637	3822	11	shorten	shorten	VB
18637	3822	12	the	the	DT
18637	3822	13	time	time	NN
18637	3822	14	for	for	IN
18637	3822	15	the	the	DT
18637	3822	16	bringing	bringing	NN
18637	3822	17	of	of	IN
18637	3822	18	actions	action	NNS
18637	3822	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	3822	20	been	be	VBN
18637	3822	21	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	3822	22	even	even	RB
18637	3822	23	as	as	IN
18637	3822	24	to	to	IN
18637	3822	25	existing	exist	VBG
18637	3822	26	causes	cause	NNS
18637	3822	27	of	of	IN
18637	3822	28	action	action	NN
18637	3822	29	,	,	,
18637	3822	30	but	but	CC
18637	3822	31	with	with	IN
18637	3822	32	the	the	DT
18637	3822	33	proviso	proviso	NN
18637	3822	34	added	add	VBD
18637	3822	35	that	that	IN
18637	3822	36	a	a	DT
18637	3822	37	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	3822	38	time	time	NN
18637	3822	39	must	must	MD
18637	3822	40	be	be	VB
18637	3822	41	left	leave	VBN
18637	3822	42	for	for	IN
18637	3822	43	the	the	DT
18637	3822	44	bringing	bringing	NN
18637	3822	45	of	of	IN
18637	3822	46	such	such	JJ
18637	3822	47	actions	action	NNS
18637	3822	48	.	.	.
18637	3823	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3823	2	1703	1703	CD
18637	3823	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3823	4	On	on	IN
18637	3823	5	the	the	DT
18637	3823	6	other	other	JJ
18637	3823	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	3823	8	,	,	,
18637	3823	9	a	a	DT
18637	3823	10	statute	statute	NN
18637	3823	11	which	which	WDT
18637	3823	12	withdrew	withdraw	VBD
18637	3823	13	the	the	DT
18637	3823	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3823	15	power	power	NN
18637	3823	16	to	to	TO
18637	3823	17	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	3823	18	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
18637	3823	19	of	of	IN
18637	3823	20	a	a	DT
18637	3823	21	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3823	22	class	class	NN
18637	3823	23	of	of	IN
18637	3823	24	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	3823	25	by	by	IN
18637	3823	26	mandamus	mandamus	NNP
18637	3823	27	was	be	VBD
18637	3823	28	held	hold	VBN
18637	3823	29	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	3823	30	.	.	.
18637	3824	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3824	2	1704	1704	CD
18637	3824	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3824	4	In	in	IN
18637	3824	5	the	the	DT
18637	3824	6	words	word	NNS
18637	3824	7	of	of	IN
18637	3824	8	the	the	DT
18637	3824	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3824	10	:	:	:
18637	3824	11	"	"	``
18637	3824	12	Every	every	DT
18637	3824	13	case	case	NN
18637	3824	14	must	must	MD
18637	3824	15	be	be	VB
18637	3824	16	determined	determine	VBN
18637	3824	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	3824	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3824	19	own	own	JJ
18637	3824	20	circumstances;"[1705	circumstances;"[1705	NNP
18637	3824	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3824	22	and	and	CC
18637	3824	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3824	24	later	later	RB
18637	3824	25	added	add	VBD
18637	3824	26	:	:	:
18637	3824	27	"	"	``
18637	3824	28	In	in	IN
18637	3824	29	all	all	DT
18637	3824	30	such	such	JJ
18637	3824	31	cases	case	NNS
18637	3824	32	the	the	DT
18637	3824	33	question	question	NN
18637	3824	34	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	3824	35	,	,	,
18637	3824	36	*	*	NFP
18637	3824	37	*	*	NFP
18637	3824	38	*	*	NFP
18637	3824	39	,	,	,
18637	3824	40	one	one	CD
18637	3824	41	of	of	IN
18637	3824	42	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	3824	43	,	,	,
18637	3824	44	and	and	CC
18637	3824	45	of	of	IN
18637	3824	46	that	that	DT
18637	3824	47	the	the	DT
18637	3824	48	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3824	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	3824	50	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	3824	51	the	the	DT
18637	3824	52	judge	judge	NN
18637	3824	53	.	.	.
18637	3825	1	"	"	``
18637	3825	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3825	3	1706	1706	CD
18637	3825	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3825	5	The	the	DT
18637	3825	6	Municipal	Municipal	NNP
18637	3825	7	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	3825	8	Cases.--There	Cases.--There	NNP
18637	3825	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	3825	10	one	one	CD
18637	3825	11	class	class	NN
18637	3825	12	of	of	IN
18637	3825	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	3825	14	resulting	result	VBG
18637	3825	15	from	from	IN
18637	3825	16	the	the	DT
18637	3825	17	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3825	18	that	that	IN
18637	3825	19	the	the	DT
18637	3825	20	law	law	NN
18637	3825	21	of	of	IN
18637	3825	22	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	3825	23	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	3825	24	a	a	DT
18637	3825	25	part	part	NN
18637	3825	26	of	of	IN
18637	3825	27	the	the	DT
18637	3825	28	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3825	29	of	of	IN
18637	3825	30	a	a	DT
18637	3825	31	contract	contract	NN
18637	3825	32	to	to	TO
18637	3825	33	which	which	WDT
18637	3825	34	a	a	DT
18637	3825	35	special	special	JJ
18637	3825	36	word	word	NN
18637	3825	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	3825	38	due	due	JJ
18637	3825	39	.	.	.
18637	3826	1	This	this	DT
18637	3826	2	comprises	comprise	VBZ
18637	3826	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	3826	4	in	in	IN
18637	3826	5	which	which	WDT
18637	3826	6	the	the	DT
18637	3826	7	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3826	8	involved	involve	VBN
18637	3826	9	were	be	VBD
18637	3826	10	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	3826	11	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	3826	12	.	.	.
18637	3827	1	While	while	IN
18637	3827	2	a	a	DT
18637	3827	3	city	city	NN
18637	3827	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	3827	5	from	from	IN
18637	3827	6	one	one	CD
18637	3827	7	point	point	NN
18637	3827	8	of	of	IN
18637	3827	9	view	view	NN
18637	3827	10	but	but	CC
18637	3827	11	an	an	DT
18637	3827	12	emanation	emanation	NN
18637	3827	13	from	from	IN
18637	3827	14	the	the	DT
18637	3827	15	government	government	NN
18637	3827	16	's	's	POS
18637	3827	17	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	3827	18	and	and	CC
18637	3827	19	an	an	DT
18637	3827	20	agent	agent	NN
18637	3827	21	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	3827	22	,	,	,
18637	3827	23	when	when	WRB
18637	3827	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3827	25	borrows	borrow	VBZ
18637	3827	26	money	money	NN
18637	3827	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3827	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	3827	29	held	hold	VBN
18637	3827	30	to	to	TO
18637	3827	31	be	be	VB
18637	3827	32	acting	act	VBG
18637	3827	33	in	in	IN
18637	3827	34	a	a	DT
18637	3827	35	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	3827	36	or	or	CC
18637	3827	37	private	private	JJ
18637	3827	38	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	3827	39	,	,	,
18637	3827	40	and	and	CC
18637	3827	41	so	so	RB
18637	3827	42	to	to	TO
18637	3827	43	be	be	VB
18637	3827	44	suable	suable	JJ
18637	3827	45	on	on	IN
18637	3827	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3827	47	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3827	48	.	.	.
18637	3828	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	3828	2	,	,	,
18637	3828	3	as	as	IN
18637	3828	4	was	be	VBD
18637	3828	5	held	hold	VBN
18637	3828	6	in	in	IN
18637	3828	7	the	the	DT
18637	3828	8	leading	leading	JJ
18637	3828	9	case	case	NN
18637	3828	10	of	of	IN
18637	3828	11	Von	Von	NNP
18637	3828	12	Hoffman	Hoffman	NNP
18637	3828	13	_	_	NNP
18637	3828	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	3828	15	_	_	NNP
18637	3828	16	Quincy,[1707	Quincy,[1707	NNP
18637	3828	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3828	18	"	"	``
18637	3828	19	where	where	WRB
18637	3828	20	a	a	DT
18637	3828	21	State	state	NN
18637	3828	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	3828	23	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	3828	24	a	a	DT
18637	3828	25	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	3828	26	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3828	27	to	to	TO
18637	3828	28	contract	contract	VB
18637	3828	29	and	and	CC
18637	3828	30	to	to	TO
18637	3828	31	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	3828	32	the	the	DT
18637	3828	33	power	power	NN
18637	3828	34	of	of	IN
18637	3828	35	local	local	JJ
18637	3828	36	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3828	37	to	to	IN
18637	3828	38	the	the	DT
18637	3828	39	extent	extent	NN
18637	3828	40	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3828	41	to	to	TO
18637	3828	42	meet	meet	VB
18637	3828	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3828	44	engagements	engagement	NNS
18637	3828	45	,	,	,
18637	3828	46	the	the	DT
18637	3828	47	power	power	NN
18637	3828	48	thus	thus	RB
18637	3828	49	given	give	VBN
18637	3828	50	can	can	MD
18637	3828	51	not	not	RB
18637	3828	52	be	be	VB
18637	3828	53	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	3828	54	until	until	IN
18637	3828	55	the	the	DT
18637	3828	56	contract	contract	NN
18637	3828	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	3828	58	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	3828	59	.	.	.
18637	3828	60	"	"	''
18637	3829	1	In	in	IN
18637	3829	2	this	this	DT
18637	3829	3	case	case	NN
18637	3829	4	the	the	DT
18637	3829	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3829	6	issued	issue	VBD
18637	3829	7	a	a	DT
18637	3829	8	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	3829	9	compelling	compel	VBG
18637	3829	10	the	the	DT
18637	3829	11	city	city	NN
18637	3829	12	officials	official	NNS
18637	3829	13	to	to	TO
18637	3829	14	levy	levy	VB
18637	3829	15	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3829	16	for	for	IN
18637	3829	17	the	the	DT
18637	3829	18	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
18637	3829	19	of	of	IN
18637	3829	20	a	a	DT
18637	3829	21	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	3829	22	on	on	IN
18637	3829	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3829	24	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	3829	25	in	in	IN
18637	3829	26	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	3829	27	with	with	IN
18637	3829	28	the	the	DT
18637	3829	29	law	law	NN
18637	3829	30	as	as	IN
18637	3829	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3829	32	stood	stand	VBD
18637	3829	33	when	when	WRB
18637	3829	34	the	the	DT
18637	3829	35	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	3829	36	were	be	VBD
18637	3829	37	issued	issue	VBN
18637	3829	38	.	.	.
18637	3830	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3830	2	1708	1708	CD
18637	3830	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3830	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	3830	5	may	may	MD
18637	3830	6	a	a	DT
18637	3830	7	State	state	NN
18637	3830	8	by	by	IN
18637	3830	9	dividing	divide	VBG
18637	3830	10	an	an	DT
18637	3830	11	indebted	indebted	JJ
18637	3830	12	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	3830	13	among	among	IN
18637	3830	14	others	other	NNS
18637	3830	15	enable	enable	VBP
18637	3830	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3830	17	to	to	TO
18637	3830	18	escape	escape	VB
18637	3830	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3830	20	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	3830	21	.	.	.
18637	3831	1	In	in	IN
18637	3831	2	such	such	PDT
18637	3831	3	a	a	DT
18637	3831	4	case	case	NN
18637	3831	5	the	the	DT
18637	3831	6	debt	debt	NN
18637	3831	7	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	3831	8	the	the	DT
18637	3831	9	territory	territory	NN
18637	3831	10	,	,	,
18637	3831	11	and	and	CC
18637	3831	12	the	the	DT
18637	3831	13	duty	duty	NN
18637	3831	14	of	of	IN
18637	3831	15	assessing	assess	VBG
18637	3831	16	and	and	CC
18637	3831	17	collecting	collect	VBG
18637	3831	18	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3831	19	to	to	TO
18637	3831	20	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	3831	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3831	22	devolves	devolve	VBZ
18637	3831	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	3831	24	the	the	DT
18637	3831	25	succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	3831	26	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	3831	27	and	and	CC
18637	3831	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3831	29	officers	officer	NNS
18637	3831	30	.	.	.
18637	3832	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3832	2	1709	1709	CD
18637	3832	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3832	4	But	but	CC
18637	3832	5	where	where	WRB
18637	3832	6	a	a	DT
18637	3832	7	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	3832	8	organization	organization	NN
18637	3832	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	3832	10	ceased	cease	VBN
18637	3832	11	practically	practically	RB
18637	3832	12	to	to	TO
18637	3832	13	exist	exist	VB
18637	3832	14	through	through	IN
18637	3832	15	the	the	DT
18637	3832	16	vacation	vacation	NN
18637	3832	17	of	of	IN
18637	3832	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3832	19	offices	office	NNS
18637	3832	20	,	,	,
18637	3832	21	and	and	CC
18637	3832	22	the	the	DT
18637	3832	23	government	government	NN
18637	3832	24	's	's	POS
18637	3832	25	function	function	NN
18637	3832	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	3832	27	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	3832	28	once	once	RB
18637	3832	29	more	more	JJR
18637	3832	30	by	by	IN
18637	3832	31	the	the	DT
18637	3832	32	State	State	NNP
18637	3832	33	directly	directly	RB
18637	3832	34	,	,	,
18637	3832	35	the	the	DT
18637	3832	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3832	37	has	have	VBZ
18637	3832	38	thus	thus	RB
18637	3832	39	far	far	RB
18637	3832	40	found	find	VBN
18637	3832	41	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3832	42	powerless	powerless	JJ
18637	3832	43	to	to	TO
18637	3832	44	frustrate	frustrate	VB
18637	3832	45	a	a	DT
18637	3832	46	program	program	NN
18637	3832	47	of	of	IN
18637	3832	48	repudiation	repudiation	NN
18637	3832	49	.	.	.
18637	3833	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3833	2	1710	1710	CD
18637	3833	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3833	4	However	however	RB
18637	3833	5	,	,	,
18637	3833	6	there	there	EX
18637	3833	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	3833	8	no	no	DT
18637	3833	9	reason	reason	NN
18637	3833	10	why	why	WRB
18637	3833	11	the	the	DT
18637	3833	12	State	state	NN
18637	3833	13	should	should	MD
18637	3833	14	enact	enact	VB
18637	3833	15	the	the	DT
18637	3833	16	role	role	NN
18637	3833	17	of	of	IN
18637	3833	18	_	_	NNP
18637	3833	19	particeps	particeps	NNP
18637	3833	20	criminis	criminis	NNP
18637	3833	21	_	_	NNP
18637	3833	22	in	in	IN
18637	3833	23	an	an	DT
18637	3833	24	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	3833	25	to	to	TO
18637	3833	26	relieve	relieve	VB
18637	3833	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3833	28	municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	3833	29	of	of	IN
18637	3833	30	the	the	DT
18637	3833	31	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3833	32	to	to	TO
18637	3833	33	meet	meet	VB
18637	3833	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3833	35	honest	honest	JJ
18637	3833	36	debts	debt	NNS
18637	3833	37	.	.	.
18637	3834	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	3834	2	in	in	IN
18637	3834	3	1931	1931	CD
18637	3834	4	,	,	,
18637	3834	5	during	during	IN
18637	3834	6	the	the	DT
18637	3834	7	Great	Great	NNP
18637	3834	8	Depression	Depression	NNP
18637	3834	9	,	,	,
18637	3834	10	New	New	NNP
18637	3834	11	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	3834	12	created	create	VBD
18637	3834	13	a	a	DT
18637	3834	14	Municipal	Municipal	NNP
18637	3834	15	Finance	Finance	NNP
18637	3834	16	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	3834	17	with	with	IN
18637	3834	18	power	power	NN
18637	3834	19	to	to	TO
18637	3834	20	assume	assume	VB
18637	3834	21	control	control	NN
18637	3834	22	over	over	IN
18637	3834	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3834	24	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
18637	3834	25	municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	3834	26	.	.	.
18637	3835	1	To	to	IN
18637	3835	2	the	the	DT
18637	3835	3	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	3835	4	of	of	IN
18637	3835	5	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3835	6	bondholders	bondholder	NNS
18637	3835	7	that	that	WDT
18637	3835	8	this	this	DT
18637	3835	9	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3835	10	impaired	impair	VBD
18637	3835	11	the	the	DT
18637	3835	12	contract	contract	NN
18637	3835	13	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	3835	14	of	of	IN
18637	3835	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3835	16	debtors	debtor	NNS
18637	3835	17	,	,	,
18637	3835	18	the	the	DT
18637	3835	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3835	20	,	,	,
18637	3835	21	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	3835	22	by	by	IN
18637	3835	23	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3835	24	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	3835	25	,	,	,
18637	3835	26	pointed	point	VBD
18637	3835	27	out	out	RP
18637	3835	28	that	that	IN
18637	3835	29	the	the	DT
18637	3835	30	practical	practical	JJ
18637	3835	31	value	value	NN
18637	3835	32	of	of	IN
18637	3835	33	an	an	DT
18637	3835	34	unsecured	unsecured	JJ
18637	3835	35	claim	claim	NN
18637	3835	36	against	against	IN
18637	3835	37	a	a	DT
18637	3835	38	city	city	NN
18637	3835	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	3835	40	"	"	``
18637	3835	41	the	the	DT
18637	3835	42	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
18637	3835	43	of	of	IN
18637	3835	44	the	the	DT
18637	3835	45	city	city	NN
18637	3835	46	's	's	POS
18637	3835	47	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	3835	48	power	power	NN
18637	3835	49	,	,	,
18637	3835	50	"	"	''
18637	3835	51	which	which	WDT
18637	3835	52	the	the	DT
18637	3835	53	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3835	54	under	under	IN
18637	3835	55	review	review	NN
18637	3835	56	was	be	VBD
18637	3835	57	designed	design	VBN
18637	3835	58	to	to	TO
18637	3835	59	conserve	conserve	VB
18637	3835	60	.	.	.
18637	3836	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3836	2	1711	1711	CD
18637	3836	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3836	4	Private	private	JJ
18637	3836	5	Contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3836	6	and	and	CC
18637	3836	7	the	the	DT
18637	3836	8	Police	Police	NNP
18637	3836	9	Power	Power	NNP
18637	3836	10	The	the	DT
18637	3836	11	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	3836	12	subjection	subjection	NN
18637	3836	13	of	of	IN
18637	3836	14	public	public	JJ
18637	3836	15	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3836	16	to	to	IN
18637	3836	17	the	the	DT
18637	3836	18	State	State	NNP
18637	3836	19	's	's	POS
18637	3836	20	police	police	NN
18637	3836	21	power	power	NN
18637	3836	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	3836	23	been	be	VBN
18637	3836	24	previously	previously	RB
18637	3836	25	pointed	point	VBN
18637	3836	26	out	out	RP
18637	3836	27	.	.	.
18637	3837	1	That	that	DT
18637	3837	2	purely	purely	RB
18637	3837	3	private	private	JJ
18637	3837	4	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3837	5	should	should	MD
18637	3837	6	be	be	VB
18637	3837	7	in	in	IN
18637	3837	8	any	any	DT
18637	3837	9	stronger	strong	JJR
18637	3837	10	situation	situation	NN
18637	3837	11	in	in	IN
18637	3837	12	this	this	DT
18637	3837	13	respect	respect	NN
18637	3837	14	would	would	MD
18637	3837	15	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	3837	16	be	be	VB
18637	3837	17	anomalous	anomalous	JJ
18637	3837	18	in	in	IN
18637	3837	19	the	the	DT
18637	3837	20	extreme	extreme	NN
18637	3837	21	.	.	.
18637	3838	1	In	in	IN
18637	3838	2	point	point	NN
18637	3838	3	of	of	IN
18637	3838	4	fact	fact	NN
18637	3838	5	,	,	,
18637	3838	6	the	the	DT
18637	3838	7	ability	ability	NN
18637	3838	8	of	of	IN
18637	3838	9	private	private	JJ
18637	3838	10	parties	party	NNS
18637	3838	11	to	to	TO
18637	3838	12	curtail	curtail	VB
18637	3838	13	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	3838	14	authority	authority	NN
18637	3838	15	by	by	IN
18637	3838	16	the	the	DT
18637	3838	17	easy	easy	JJ
18637	3838	18	devise	devise	NN
18637	3838	19	of	of	IN
18637	3838	20	contracting	contract	VBG
18637	3838	21	with	with	IN
18637	3838	22	one	one	NN
18637	3838	23	another	another	DT
18637	3838	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	3838	25	,	,	,
18637	3838	26	with	with	IN
18637	3838	27	an	an	DT
18637	3838	28	exception	exception	NN
18637	3838	29	to	to	TO
18637	3838	30	be	be	VB
18637	3838	31	noted	note	VBN
18637	3838	32	,	,	,
18637	3838	33	even	even	RB
18637	3838	34	less	less	JJR
18637	3838	35	than	than	IN
18637	3838	36	that	that	DT
18637	3838	37	of	of	IN
18637	3838	38	the	the	DT
18637	3838	39	State	State	NNP
18637	3838	40	to	to	TO
18637	3838	41	tie	tie	VB
18637	3838	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3838	43	own	own	JJ
18637	3838	44	hands	hand	NNS
18637	3838	45	by	by	IN
18637	3838	46	contracting	contract	VBG
18637	3838	47	away	away	RB
18637	3838	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3838	49	own	own	JJ
18637	3838	50	powers	power	NNS
18637	3838	51	.	.	.
18637	3839	1	So	so	CC
18637	3839	2	,	,	,
18637	3839	3	when	when	WRB
18637	3839	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3839	5	was	be	VBD
18637	3839	6	contended	contend	VBN
18637	3839	7	in	in	IN
18637	3839	8	an	an	DT
18637	3839	9	early	early	JJ
18637	3839	10	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	3839	11	case	case	NN
18637	3839	12	,	,	,
18637	3839	13	than	than	IN
18637	3839	14	an	an	DT
18637	3839	15	act	act	NN
18637	3839	16	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	3839	17	the	the	DT
18637	3839	18	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	3839	19	of	of	IN
18637	3839	20	notes	note	NNS
18637	3839	21	by	by	IN
18637	3839	22	unincorporated	unincorporated	JJ
18637	3839	23	banking	banking	NN
18637	3839	24	associations	association	NNS
18637	3839	25	was	be	VBD
18637	3839	26	violative	violative	JJ
18637	3839	27	of	of	IN
18637	3839	28	the	the	DT
18637	3839	29	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3839	30	of	of	IN
18637	3839	31	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3839	32	clause	clause	NN
18637	3839	33	because	because	IN
18637	3839	34	of	of	IN
18637	3839	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3839	36	effect	effect	NN
18637	3839	37	upon	upon	IN
18637	3839	38	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3839	39	existing	exist	VBG
18637	3839	40	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3839	41	of	of	IN
18637	3839	42	members	member	NNS
18637	3839	43	of	of	IN
18637	3839	44	such	such	JJ
18637	3839	45	associations	association	NNS
18637	3839	46	,	,	,
18637	3839	47	the	the	DT
18637	3839	48	State	State	NNP
18637	3839	49	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3839	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3839	51	answered	answer	VBD
18637	3839	52	:	:	:
18637	3839	53	"	"	``
18637	3839	54	But	but	CC
18637	3839	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3839	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	3839	57	said	say	VBN
18637	3839	58	,	,	,
18637	3839	59	that	that	IN
18637	3839	60	the	the	DT
18637	3839	61	members	member	NNS
18637	3839	62	had	have	VBD
18637	3839	63	formed	form	VBN
18637	3839	64	a	a	DT
18637	3839	65	contract	contract	NN
18637	3839	66	_	_	NNP
18637	3839	67	between	between	IN
18637	3839	68	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3839	69	_	_	NNP
18637	3839	70	,	,	,
18637	3839	71	which	which	WDT
18637	3839	72	would	would	MD
18637	3839	73	be	be	VB
18637	3839	74	dissolved	dissolve	VBN
18637	3839	75	by	by	IN
18637	3839	76	the	the	DT
18637	3839	77	stoppage	stoppage	NN
18637	3839	78	of	of	IN
18637	3839	79	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3839	80	business	business	NN
18637	3839	81	;	;	:
18637	3839	82	and	and	CC
18637	3839	83	what	what	WP
18637	3839	84	then	then	RB
18637	3839	85	?	?	.
18637	3840	1	Is	be	VBZ
18637	3840	2	that	that	DT
18637	3840	3	such	such	PDT
18637	3840	4	a	a	DT
18637	3840	5	violation	violation	NN
18637	3840	6	of	of	IN
18637	3840	7	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3840	8	as	as	IN
18637	3840	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	3840	10	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	3840	11	by	by	IN
18637	3840	12	the	the	DT
18637	3840	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3840	14	of	of	IN
18637	3840	15	the	the	DT
18637	3840	16	United	United	NNP
18637	3840	17	States	States	NNP
18637	3840	18	?	?	.
18637	3841	1	Consider	consider	VB
18637	3841	2	to	to	IN
18637	3841	3	what	what	WP
18637	3841	4	such	such	PDT
18637	3841	5	a	a	DT
18637	3841	6	construction	construction	NN
18637	3841	7	would	would	MD
18637	3841	8	lead	lead	VB
18637	3841	9	.	.	.
18637	3842	1	Let	let	VB
18637	3842	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3842	3	suppose	suppose	VB
18637	3842	4	,	,	,
18637	3842	5	that	that	IN
18637	3842	6	in	in	IN
18637	3842	7	one	one	CD
18637	3842	8	of	of	IN
18637	3842	9	the	the	DT
18637	3842	10	States	States	NNPS
18637	3842	11	there	there	EX
18637	3842	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	3842	13	no	no	DT
18637	3842	14	law	law	NN
18637	3842	15	against	against	IN
18637	3842	16	gaming	gaming	NN
18637	3842	17	,	,	,
18637	3842	18	cock	cock	NN
18637	3842	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	3842	20	fighting	fight	VBG
18637	3842	21	,	,	,
18637	3842	22	horse	horse	NN
18637	3842	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	3842	24	racing	racing	NN
18637	3842	25	or	or	CC
18637	3842	26	public	public	JJ
18637	3842	27	masquerades	masquerade	NNS
18637	3842	28	,	,	,
18637	3842	29	and	and	CC
18637	3842	30	that	that	IN
18637	3842	31	companies	company	NNS
18637	3842	32	should	should	MD
18637	3842	33	be	be	VB
18637	3842	34	formed	form	VBN
18637	3842	35	for	for	IN
18637	3842	36	the	the	DT
18637	3842	37	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3842	38	of	of	IN
18637	3842	39	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	3842	40	on	on	IN
18637	3842	41	these	these	DT
18637	3842	42	practices	practice	NNS
18637	3842	43	;	;	:
18637	3842	44	*	*	NFP
18637	3842	45	*	*	NFP
18637	3842	46	*	*	NFP
18637	3842	47	"	"	``
18637	3842	48	Would	Would	MD
18637	3842	49	the	the	DT
18637	3842	50	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3842	51	then	then	RB
18637	3842	52	be	be	VB
18637	3842	53	powerless	powerless	JJ
18637	3842	54	to	to	TO
18637	3842	55	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	3842	56	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3842	57	?	?	.
18637	3843	1	The	the	DT
18637	3843	2	answer	answer	NN
18637	3843	3	returned	return	VBD
18637	3843	4	,	,	,
18637	3843	5	of	of	IN
18637	3843	6	course	course	NN
18637	3843	7	,	,	,
18637	3843	8	was	be	VBD
18637	3843	9	no	no	UH
18637	3843	10	.	.	.
18637	3844	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3844	2	1712	1712	CD
18637	3844	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3844	4	The	the	DT
18637	3844	5	prevailing	prevail	VBG
18637	3844	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3844	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	3844	8	stated	state	VBN
18637	3844	9	by	by	IN
18637	3844	10	the	the	DT
18637	3844	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3844	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3844	13	of	of	IN
18637	3844	14	the	the	DT
18637	3844	15	United	United	NNP
18637	3844	16	States	States	NNP
18637	3844	17	in	in	IN
18637	3844	18	the	the	DT
18637	3844	19	following	follow	VBG
18637	3844	20	words	word	NNS
18637	3844	21	:	:	:
18637	3844	22	"	"	``
18637	3844	23	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3844	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	3844	25	the	the	DT
18637	3844	26	settled	settled	JJ
18637	3844	27	law	law	NN
18637	3844	28	of	of	IN
18637	3844	29	this	this	DT
18637	3844	30	court	court	NN
18637	3844	31	that	that	WDT
18637	3844	32	the	the	DT
18637	3844	33	interdiction	interdiction	NN
18637	3844	34	of	of	IN
18637	3844	35	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3844	36	impairing	impair	VBG
18637	3844	37	the	the	DT
18637	3844	38	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3844	39	of	of	IN
18637	3844	40	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3844	41	does	do	VBZ
18637	3844	42	not	not	RB
18637	3844	43	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	3844	44	the	the	DT
18637	3844	45	State	state	NN
18637	3844	46	from	from	IN
18637	3844	47	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	3844	48	such	such	JJ
18637	3844	49	powers	power	NNS
18637	3844	50	as	as	IN
18637	3844	51	are	be	VBP
18637	3844	52	vested	vest	VBN
18637	3844	53	in	in	IN
18637	3844	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3844	55	for	for	IN
18637	3844	56	the	the	DT
18637	3844	57	promotion	promotion	NN
18637	3844	58	of	of	IN
18637	3844	59	the	the	DT
18637	3844	60	common	common	JJ
18637	3844	61	weal	weal	NN
18637	3844	62	,	,	,
18637	3844	63	or	or	CC
18637	3844	64	are	be	VBP
18637	3844	65	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3844	66	for	for	IN
18637	3844	67	the	the	DT
18637	3844	68	general	general	JJ
18637	3844	69	good	good	NN
18637	3844	70	of	of	IN
18637	3844	71	the	the	DT
18637	3844	72	public	public	NN
18637	3844	73	,	,	,
18637	3844	74	though	though	IN
18637	3844	75	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3844	76	previously	previously	RB
18637	3844	77	entered	enter	VBD
18637	3844	78	into	into	IN
18637	3844	79	between	between	IN
18637	3844	80	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	3844	81	may	may	MD
18637	3844	82	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	3844	83	be	be	VB
18637	3844	84	affected	affect	VBN
18637	3844	85	.	.	.
18637	3845	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3845	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3845	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3845	4	In	in	IN
18637	3845	5	other	other	JJ
18637	3845	6	words	word	NNS
18637	3845	7	,	,	,
18637	3845	8	that	that	IN
18637	3845	9	parties	party	NNS
18637	3845	10	by	by	IN
18637	3845	11	entering	enter	VBG
18637	3845	12	into	into	IN
18637	3845	13	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3845	14	may	may	MD
18637	3845	15	not	not	RB
18637	3845	16	estop	estop	VB
18637	3845	17	the	the	DT
18637	3845	18	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3845	19	from	from	IN
18637	3845	20	enacting	enact	VBG
18637	3845	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	3845	22	intended	intend	VBN
18637	3845	23	for	for	IN
18637	3845	24	the	the	DT
18637	3845	25	public	public	JJ
18637	3845	26	good	good	NN
18637	3845	27	.	.	.
18637	3846	1	"	"	``
18637	3846	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3846	3	1713	1713	CD
18637	3846	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3846	5	So	so	CC
18637	3846	6	,	,	,
18637	3846	7	in	in	IN
18637	3846	8	an	an	DT
18637	3846	9	early	early	JJ
18637	3846	10	case	case	NN
18637	3846	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3846	12	find	find	VBP
18637	3846	13	a	a	DT
18637	3846	14	State	state	NN
18637	3846	15	recording	recording	NN
18637	3846	16	act	act	NN
18637	3846	17	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	3846	18	as	as	IN
18637	3846	19	applying	apply	VBG
18637	3846	20	to	to	IN
18637	3846	21	deeds	deed	NNS
18637	3846	22	dated	date	VBN
18637	3846	23	before	before	IN
18637	3846	24	the	the	DT
18637	3846	25	passage	passage	NN
18637	3846	26	of	of	IN
18637	3846	27	the	the	DT
18637	3846	28	act	act	NN
18637	3846	29	.	.	.
18637	3847	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3847	2	1714	1714	CD
18637	3847	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3847	4	Later	late	JJR
18637	3847	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	3847	6	have	have	VBP
18637	3847	7	brought	bring	VBN
18637	3847	8	the	the	DT
18637	3847	9	police	police	NN
18637	3847	10	power	power	NN
18637	3847	11	in	in	IN
18637	3847	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3847	13	more	more	JJR
18637	3847	14	customary	customary	JJ
18637	3847	15	phases	phase	NNS
18637	3847	16	into	into	IN
18637	3847	17	contact	contact	NN
18637	3847	18	with	with	IN
18637	3847	19	private	private	JJ
18637	3847	20	,	,	,
18637	3847	21	as	as	RB
18637	3847	22	well	well	RB
18637	3847	23	as	as	IN
18637	3847	24	with	with	IN
18637	3847	25	public	public	JJ
18637	3847	26	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3847	27	.	.	.
18637	3848	1	Lottery	lottery	NN
18637	3848	2	tickets	ticket	NNS
18637	3848	3	,	,	,
18637	3848	4	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3848	5	when	when	WRB
18637	3848	6	issued	issue	VBN
18637	3848	7	,	,	,
18637	3848	8	were	be	VBD
18637	3848	9	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	3848	10	invalidated	invalidate	VBN
18637	3848	11	by	by	IN
18637	3848	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3848	13	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	3848	14	the	the	DT
18637	3848	15	lottery	lottery	NN
18637	3848	16	business;[1715	business;[1715	NN
18637	3848	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3848	18	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3848	19	for	for	IN
18637	3848	20	the	the	DT
18637	3848	21	sale	sale	NN
18637	3848	22	of	of	IN
18637	3848	23	beer	beer	NN
18637	3848	24	,	,	,
18637	3848	25	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3848	26	when	when	WRB
18637	3848	27	entered	enter	VBN
18637	3848	28	into	into	IN
18637	3848	29	,	,	,
18637	3848	30	were	be	VBD
18637	3848	31	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	3848	32	nullified	nullify	VBN
18637	3848	33	by	by	IN
18637	3848	34	a	a	DT
18637	3848	35	State	State	NNP
18637	3848	36	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3848	37	law;[1716	law;[1716	VBN
18637	3848	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3848	39	and	and	CC
18637	3848	40	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3848	41	of	of	IN
18637	3848	42	employment	employment	NN
18637	3848	43	were	be	VBD
18637	3848	44	modified	modify	VBN
18637	3848	45	by	by	IN
18637	3848	46	later	later	JJ
18637	3848	47	laws	law	NNS
18637	3848	48	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	3848	49	the	the	DT
18637	3848	50	liability	liability	NN
18637	3848	51	of	of	IN
18637	3848	52	employers	employer	NNS
18637	3848	53	and	and	CC
18637	3848	54	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	3848	55	's	's	POS
18637	3848	56	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	3848	57	.	.	.
18637	3849	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3849	2	1717	1717	CD
18637	3849	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3849	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	3849	5	a	a	DT
18637	3849	6	contract	contract	NN
18637	3849	7	between	between	IN
18637	3849	8	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	3849	9	and	and	CC
18637	3849	10	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	3849	11	did	do	VBD
18637	3849	12	not	not	RB
18637	3849	13	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	3849	14	the	the	DT
18637	3849	15	State	state	NN
18637	3849	16	from	from	IN
18637	3849	17	making	make	VBG
18637	3849	18	the	the	DT
18637	3849	19	latter	latter	JJ
18637	3849	20	a	a	DT
18637	3849	21	concession	concession	NN
18637	3849	22	which	which	WDT
18637	3849	23	rendered	render	VBD
18637	3849	24	the	the	DT
18637	3849	25	contract	contract	NN
18637	3849	26	worthless;[1718	worthless;[1718	ADD
18637	3849	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3849	28	nor	nor	CC
18637	3849	29	did	do	VBD
18637	3849	30	a	a	DT
18637	3849	31	contract	contract	NN
18637	3849	32	as	as	IN
18637	3849	33	to	to	IN
18637	3849	34	rates	rate	NNS
18637	3849	35	between	between	IN
18637	3849	36	two	two	CD
18637	3849	37	railway	railway	NN
18637	3849	38	companies	company	NNS
18637	3849	39	prevent	prevent	VBP
18637	3849	40	the	the	DT
18637	3849	41	State	state	NN
18637	3849	42	from	from	IN
18637	3849	43	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	3849	44	different	different	JJ
18637	3849	45	rates;[1719	rates;[1719	.
18637	3849	46	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3849	47	nor	nor	CC
18637	3849	48	did	do	VBD
18637	3849	49	a	a	DT
18637	3849	50	contract	contract	NN
18637	3849	51	between	between	IN
18637	3849	52	a	a	DT
18637	3849	53	public	public	JJ
18637	3849	54	utility	utility	NN
18637	3849	55	company	company	NN
18637	3849	56	and	and	CC
18637	3849	57	a	a	DT
18637	3849	58	customer	customer	NN
18637	3849	59	protect	protect	NN
18637	3849	60	the	the	DT
18637	3849	61	rates	rate	NNS
18637	3849	62	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	3849	63	upon	upon	IN
18637	3849	64	from	from	IN
18637	3849	65	being	be	VBG
18637	3849	66	superseded	supersede	VBN
18637	3849	67	by	by	IN
18637	3849	68	those	those	DT
18637	3849	69	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	3849	70	by	by	IN
18637	3849	71	the	the	DT
18637	3849	72	State	State	NNP
18637	3849	73	.	.	.
18637	3850	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3850	2	1720	1720	CD
18637	3850	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3850	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	3850	5	,	,	,
18637	3850	6	a	a	DT
18637	3850	7	contract	contract	NN
18637	3850	8	for	for	IN
18637	3850	9	the	the	DT
18637	3850	10	conveyance	conveyance	NN
18637	3850	11	of	of	IN
18637	3850	12	water	water	NN
18637	3850	13	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	3850	14	the	the	DT
18637	3850	15	limits	limit	NNS
18637	3850	16	of	of	IN
18637	3850	17	a	a	DT
18637	3850	18	State	State	NNP
18637	3850	19	did	do	VBD
18637	3850	20	not	not	RB
18637	3850	21	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	3850	22	the	the	DT
18637	3850	23	State	state	NN
18637	3850	24	from	from	IN
18637	3850	25	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	3850	26	such	such	JJ
18637	3850	27	conveyance	conveyance	NN
18637	3850	28	.	.	.
18637	3851	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3851	2	1721	1721	CD
18637	3851	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3851	4	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	3851	5	Legislation.--But	Legislation.--But	NNP
18637	3851	6	the	the	DT
18637	3851	7	most	most	RBS
18637	3851	8	striking	striking	JJ
18637	3851	9	exertions	exertion	NNS
18637	3851	10	of	of	IN
18637	3851	11	the	the	DT
18637	3851	12	police	police	NN
18637	3851	13	power	power	NN
18637	3851	14	touching	touch	VBG
18637	3851	15	private	private	JJ
18637	3851	16	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3851	17	,	,	,
18637	3851	18	as	as	RB
18637	3851	19	well	well	RB
18637	3851	20	as	as	IN
18637	3851	21	other	other	JJ
18637	3851	22	private	private	JJ
18637	3851	23	interests	interest	NNS
18637	3851	24	,	,	,
18637	3851	25	within	within	IN
18637	3851	26	recent	recent	JJ
18637	3851	27	years	year	NNS
18637	3851	28	have	have	VBP
18637	3851	29	been	be	VBN
18637	3851	30	evoked	evoke	VBN
18637	3851	31	by	by	IN
18637	3851	32	war	war	NN
18637	3851	33	and	and	CC
18637	3851	34	economic	economic	JJ
18637	3851	35	depression	depression	NN
18637	3851	36	.	.	.
18637	3852	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	3852	2	in	in	IN
18637	3852	3	World	World	NNP
18637	3852	4	War	War	NNP
18637	3852	5	I	I	NNP
18637	3852	6	the	the	DT
18637	3852	7	State	State	NNP
18637	3852	8	of	of	IN
18637	3852	9	New	New	NNP
18637	3852	10	York	York	NNP
18637	3852	11	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	3852	12	a	a	DT
18637	3852	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	3852	14	which	which	WDT
18637	3852	15	,	,	,
18637	3852	16	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	3852	17	that	that	IN
18637	3852	18	a	a	DT
18637	3852	19	public	public	JJ
18637	3852	20	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	3852	21	existed	exist	VBD
18637	3852	22	,	,	,
18637	3852	23	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	3852	24	the	the	DT
18637	3852	25	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	3852	26	of	of	IN
18637	3852	27	covenants	covenant	NNS
18637	3852	28	for	for	IN
18637	3852	29	the	the	DT
18637	3852	30	surrender	surrender	NN
18637	3852	31	of	of	IN
18637	3852	32	the	the	DT
18637	3852	33	possession	possession	NN
18637	3852	34	of	of	IN
18637	3852	35	premises	premise	NNS
18637	3852	36	on	on	IN
18637	3852	37	the	the	DT
18637	3852	38	expiration	expiration	NN
18637	3852	39	of	of	IN
18637	3852	40	leases	lease	NNS
18637	3852	41	,	,	,
18637	3852	42	and	and	CC
18637	3852	43	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	3852	44	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	3852	45	for	for	IN
18637	3852	46	a	a	DT
18637	3852	47	period	period	NN
18637	3852	48	owners	owner	NNS
18637	3852	49	of	of	IN
18637	3852	50	dwellings	dwelling	NNS
18637	3852	51	,	,	,
18637	3852	52	including	include	VBG
18637	3852	53	apartment	apartment	NN
18637	3852	54	and	and	CC
18637	3852	55	tenement	tenement	NN
18637	3852	56	houses	house	NNS
18637	3852	57	,	,	,
18637	3852	58	within	within	IN
18637	3852	59	the	the	DT
18637	3852	60	City	City	NNP
18637	3852	61	of	of	IN
18637	3852	62	New	New	NNP
18637	3852	63	York	York	NNP
18637	3852	64	and	and	CC
18637	3852	65	contiguous	contiguous	JJ
18637	3852	66	counties	county	NNS
18637	3852	67	of	of	IN
18637	3852	68	possessory	possessory	JJ
18637	3852	69	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	3852	70	for	for	IN
18637	3852	71	the	the	DT
18637	3852	72	eviction	eviction	NN
18637	3852	73	from	from	IN
18637	3852	74	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3852	75	premises	premise	NNS
18637	3852	76	of	of	IN
18637	3852	77	tenants	tenant	NNS
18637	3852	78	in	in	IN
18637	3852	79	possession	possession	NN
18637	3852	80	when	when	WRB
18637	3852	81	the	the	DT
18637	3852	82	law	law	NN
18637	3852	83	took	take	VBD
18637	3852	84	effect	effect	NN
18637	3852	85	,	,	,
18637	3852	86	providing	provide	VBG
18637	3852	87	the	the	DT
18637	3852	88	latter	latter	JJ
18637	3852	89	were	be	VBD
18637	3852	90	able	able	JJ
18637	3852	91	and	and	CC
18637	3852	92	willing	willing	JJ
18637	3852	93	to	to	TO
18637	3852	94	pay	pay	VB
18637	3852	95	a	a	DT
18637	3852	96	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	3852	97	rent	rent	NN
18637	3852	98	.	.	.
18637	3853	1	In	in	IN
18637	3853	2	answer	answer	NN
18637	3853	3	to	to	IN
18637	3853	4	objections	objection	NNS
18637	3853	5	leveled	level	VBD
18637	3853	6	against	against	IN
18637	3853	7	this	this	DT
18637	3853	8	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3853	9	on	on	IN
18637	3853	10	the	the	DT
18637	3853	11	basis	basis	NN
18637	3853	12	of	of	IN
18637	3853	13	the	the	DT
18637	3853	14	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3853	15	of	of	IN
18637	3853	16	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3853	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	3853	18	,	,	,
18637	3853	19	the	the	DT
18637	3853	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3853	21	said	say	VBD
18637	3853	22	:	:	:
18637	3853	23	"	"	``
18637	3853	24	But	but	CC
18637	3853	25	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3853	26	are	be	VBP
18637	3853	27	made	make	VBN
18637	3853	28	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3853	29	to	to	IN
18637	3853	30	this	this	DT
18637	3853	31	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3853	32	of	of	IN
18637	3853	33	the	the	DT
18637	3853	34	power	power	NN
18637	3853	35	of	of	IN
18637	3853	36	the	the	DT
18637	3853	37	State	State	NNP
18637	3853	38	when	when	WRB
18637	3853	39	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	3853	40	justified	justify	VBN
18637	3853	41	,	,	,
18637	3853	42	as	as	IN
18637	3853	43	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3853	44	have	have	VBP
18637	3853	45	held	hold	VBN
18637	3853	46	this	this	DT
18637	3853	47	to	to	TO
18637	3853	48	be	be	VB
18637	3853	49	.	.	.
18637	3854	1	"	"	``
18637	3854	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3854	3	1722	1722	CD
18637	3854	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3854	5	In	in	IN
18637	3854	6	a	a	DT
18637	3854	7	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	3854	8	case	case	NN
18637	3854	9	,	,	,
18637	3854	10	however	however	RB
18637	3854	11	,	,	,
18637	3854	12	the	the	DT
18637	3854	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3854	14	added	add	VBD
18637	3854	15	that	that	IN
18637	3854	16	,	,	,
18637	3854	17	while	while	IN
18637	3854	18	the	the	DT
18637	3854	19	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	3854	20	by	by	IN
18637	3854	21	the	the	DT
18637	3854	22	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3854	23	of	of	IN
18637	3854	24	a	a	DT
18637	3854	25	justifying	justify	VBG
18637	3854	26	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	3854	27	was	be	VBD
18637	3854	28	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	3854	29	to	to	IN
18637	3854	30	great	great	JJ
18637	3854	31	respect	respect	NN
18637	3854	32	,	,	,
18637	3854	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3854	34	was	be	VBD
18637	3854	35	not	not	RB
18637	3854	36	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	3854	37	;	;	:
18637	3854	38	that	that	IN
18637	3854	39	a	a	DT
18637	3854	40	law	law	NN
18637	3854	41	"	"	''
18637	3854	42	depending	depend	VBG
18637	3854	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	3854	44	the	the	DT
18637	3854	45	existence	existence	NN
18637	3854	46	of	of	IN
18637	3854	47	an	an	DT
18637	3854	48	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	3854	49	or	or	CC
18637	3854	50	other	other	JJ
18637	3854	51	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3854	52	state	state	NN
18637	3854	53	of	of	IN
18637	3854	54	facts	fact	NNS
18637	3854	55	to	to	TO
18637	3854	56	uphold	uphold	VB
18637	3854	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3854	58	may	may	MD
18637	3854	59	cease	cease	VB
18637	3854	60	to	to	TO
18637	3854	61	operate	operate	VB
18637	3854	62	if	if	IN
18637	3854	63	the	the	DT
18637	3854	64	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	3854	65	ceases	cease	VBZ
18637	3854	66	or	or	CC
18637	3854	67	the	the	DT
18637	3854	68	facts	fact	NNS
18637	3854	69	change	change	VBP
18637	3854	70	,	,	,
18637	3854	71	"	"	''
18637	3854	72	and	and	CC
18637	3854	73	that	that	IN
18637	3854	74	whether	whether	IN
18637	3854	75	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3854	76	have	have	VBP
18637	3854	77	changed	change	VBN
18637	3854	78	was	be	VBD
18637	3854	79	always	always	RB
18637	3854	80	open	open	JJ
18637	3854	81	to	to	IN
18637	3854	82	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3854	83	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	3854	84	.	.	.
18637	3855	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3855	2	1723	1723	CD
18637	3855	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3855	4	Individual	Individual	NNP
18637	3855	5	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	3855	6	Versus	Versus	NNP
18637	3855	7	Public	Public	NNP
18637	3855	8	Welfare.--Summing	welfare.--summing	$
18637	3855	9	up	up	RP
18637	3855	10	the	the	DT
18637	3855	11	result	result	NN
18637	3855	12	of	of	IN
18637	3855	13	the	the	DT
18637	3855	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	3855	15	above	above	IN
18637	3855	16	referred	refer	VBD
18637	3855	17	to	to	IN
18637	3855	18	,	,	,
18637	3855	19	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3855	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3855	21	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	3855	22	,	,	,
18637	3855	23	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	3855	24	for	for	IN
18637	3855	25	the	the	DT
18637	3855	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3855	27	in	in	IN
18637	3855	28	Home	Home	NNP
18637	3855	29	Building	Building	NNP
18637	3855	30	and	and	CC
18637	3855	31	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	3855	32	Association	Association	NNP
18637	3855	33	_	_	NNP
18637	3855	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	3855	35	_	_	NNP
18637	3855	36	Blaisdell,[1724	Blaisdell,[1724	NNP
18637	3855	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3855	38	remarked	remark	VBN
18637	3855	39	in	in	IN
18637	3855	40	1934	1934	CD
18637	3855	41	:	:	:
18637	3855	42	"	"	``
18637	3855	43	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3855	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	3855	45	manifest	manif	JJS
18637	3855	46	from	from	IN
18637	3855	47	this	this	DT
18637	3855	48	review	review	NN
18637	3855	49	of	of	IN
18637	3855	50	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3855	51	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3855	52	that	that	WDT
18637	3855	53	there	there	EX
18637	3855	54	has	have	VBZ
18637	3855	55	been	be	VBN
18637	3855	56	a	a	DT
18637	3855	57	growing	grow	VBG
18637	3855	58	appreciation	appreciation	NN
18637	3855	59	of	of	IN
18637	3855	60	public	public	JJ
18637	3855	61	needs	need	NNS
18637	3855	62	and	and	CC
18637	3855	63	of	of	IN
18637	3855	64	the	the	DT
18637	3855	65	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	3855	66	of	of	IN
18637	3855	67	finding	find	VBG
18637	3855	68	ground	ground	NN
18637	3855	69	for	for	IN
18637	3855	70	a	a	DT
18637	3855	71	rational	rational	JJ
18637	3855	72	compromise	compromise	NN
18637	3855	73	between	between	IN
18637	3855	74	individual	individual	JJ
18637	3855	75	rights	right	NNS
18637	3855	76	and	and	CC
18637	3855	77	public	public	JJ
18637	3855	78	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	3855	79	.	.	.
18637	3856	1	The	the	DT
18637	3856	2	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	3856	3	and	and	CC
18637	3856	4	consequent	consequent	JJ
18637	3856	5	contraction	contraction	NN
18637	3856	6	of	of	IN
18637	3856	7	the	the	DT
18637	3856	8	public	public	JJ
18637	3856	9	domain	domain	NN
18637	3856	10	,	,	,
18637	3856	11	the	the	DT
18637	3856	12	pressure	pressure	NN
18637	3856	13	of	of	IN
18637	3856	14	a	a	DT
18637	3856	15	constantly	constantly	RB
18637	3856	16	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	3856	17	density	density	NN
18637	3856	18	of	of	IN
18637	3856	19	population	population	NN
18637	3856	20	,	,	,
18637	3856	21	the	the	DT
18637	3856	22	interrelation	interrelation	NN
18637	3856	23	of	of	IN
18637	3856	24	the	the	DT
18637	3856	25	activities	activity	NNS
18637	3856	26	of	of	IN
18637	3856	27	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3856	28	people	people	NNS
18637	3856	29	and	and	CC
18637	3856	30	the	the	DT
18637	3856	31	complexity	complexity	NN
18637	3856	32	of	of	IN
18637	3856	33	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3856	34	economic	economic	JJ
18637	3856	35	interests	interest	NNS
18637	3856	36	,	,	,
18637	3856	37	have	have	VBP
18637	3856	38	inevitably	inevitably	RB
18637	3856	39	led	lead	VBN
18637	3856	40	to	to	IN
18637	3856	41	an	an	DT
18637	3856	42	increased	increase	VBN
18637	3856	43	use	use	NN
18637	3856	44	of	of	IN
18637	3856	45	the	the	DT
18637	3856	46	organization	organization	NNP
18637	3856	47	of	of	IN
18637	3856	48	society	society	NN
18637	3856	49	in	in	IN
18637	3856	50	order	order	NN
18637	3856	51	to	to	TO
18637	3856	52	protect	protect	VB
18637	3856	53	the	the	DT
18637	3856	54	very	very	JJ
18637	3856	55	bases	basis	NNS
18637	3856	56	of	of	IN
18637	3856	57	individual	individual	JJ
18637	3856	58	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	3856	59	.	.	.
18637	3857	1	Where	where	WRB
18637	3857	2	,	,	,
18637	3857	3	in	in	IN
18637	3857	4	earlier	early	JJR
18637	3857	5	days	day	NNS
18637	3857	6	,	,	,
18637	3857	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3857	8	was	be	VBD
18637	3857	9	thought	think	VBN
18637	3857	10	that	that	IN
18637	3857	11	only	only	RB
18637	3857	12	the	the	DT
18637	3857	13	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	3857	14	of	of	IN
18637	3857	15	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	3857	16	or	or	CC
18637	3857	17	of	of	IN
18637	3857	18	classes	class	NNS
18637	3857	19	were	be	VBD
18637	3857	20	involved	involve	VBN
18637	3857	21	,	,	,
18637	3857	22	and	and	CC
18637	3857	23	that	that	IN
18637	3857	24	those	those	DT
18637	3857	25	of	of	IN
18637	3857	26	the	the	DT
18637	3857	27	State	State	NNP
18637	3857	28	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3857	29	were	be	VBD
18637	3857	30	touched	touch	VBN
18637	3857	31	only	only	RB
18637	3857	32	remotely	remotely	RB
18637	3857	33	,	,	,
18637	3857	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3857	35	has	have	VBZ
18637	3857	36	later	later	RB
18637	3857	37	been	be	VBN
18637	3857	38	found	find	VBN
18637	3857	39	that	that	IN
18637	3857	40	the	the	DT
18637	3857	41	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	3857	42	interests	interest	NNS
18637	3857	43	of	of	IN
18637	3857	44	the	the	DT
18637	3857	45	State	State	NNP
18637	3857	46	are	be	VBP
18637	3857	47	directly	directly	RB
18637	3857	48	affected	affect	VBN
18637	3857	49	;	;	:
18637	3857	50	and	and	CC
18637	3857	51	that	that	IN
18637	3857	52	the	the	DT
18637	3857	53	question	question	NN
18637	3857	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	3857	55	no	no	RB
18637	3857	56	longer	long	RBR
18637	3857	57	merely	merely	RB
18637	3857	58	that	that	DT
18637	3857	59	of	of	IN
18637	3857	60	one	one	CD
18637	3857	61	party	party	NN
18637	3857	62	to	to	IN
18637	3857	63	a	a	DT
18637	3857	64	contract	contract	NN
18637	3857	65	as	as	IN
18637	3857	66	against	against	IN
18637	3857	67	another	another	DT
18637	3857	68	,	,	,
18637	3857	69	but	but	CC
18637	3857	70	of	of	IN
18637	3857	71	the	the	DT
18637	3857	72	use	use	NN
18637	3857	73	of	of	IN
18637	3857	74	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	3857	75	means	mean	NNS
18637	3857	76	to	to	TO
18637	3857	77	safeguard	safeguard	VB
18637	3857	78	the	the	DT
18637	3857	79	economic	economic	JJ
18637	3857	80	structure	structure	NN
18637	3857	81	upon	upon	IN
18637	3857	82	which	which	WDT
18637	3857	83	the	the	DT
18637	3857	84	good	good	NN
18637	3857	85	of	of	IN
18637	3857	86	all	all	DT
18637	3857	87	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	3857	88	.	.	.
18637	3858	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3858	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3858	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3858	4	The	the	DT
18637	3858	5	principle	principle	NN
18637	3858	6	of	of	IN
18637	3858	7	this	this	DT
18637	3858	8	development	development	NN
18637	3858	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	3858	10	,	,	,
18637	3858	11	*	*	NFP
18637	3858	12	*	*	NFP
18637	3858	13	*	*	NFP
18637	3858	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3858	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3858	16	added	add	VBD
18637	3858	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3858	18	that	that	IN
18637	3858	19	the	the	DT
18637	3858	20	reservation	reservation	NN
18637	3858	21	of	of	IN
18637	3858	22	the	the	DT
18637	3858	23	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	3858	24	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3858	25	of	of	IN
18637	3858	26	the	the	DT
18637	3858	27	protective	protective	JJ
18637	3858	28	power	power	NN
18637	3858	29	of	of	IN
18637	3858	30	the	the	DT
18637	3858	31	States	States	NNP
18637	3858	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	3858	33	read	read	VBN
18637	3858	34	into	into	IN
18637	3858	35	all	all	DT
18637	3858	36	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3858	37	*	*	NFP
18637	3858	38	*	*	NFP
18637	3858	39	*	*	NFP
18637	3858	40	.	.	.
18637	3859	1	"	"	``
18637	3859	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3859	3	1725	1725	CD
18637	3859	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3859	5	Evaluation	evaluation	NN
18637	3859	6	of	of	IN
18637	3859	7	the	the	DT
18637	3859	8	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	3859	9	Today	Today	NNP
18637	3859	10	Yet	yet	CC
18637	3859	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3859	12	should	should	MD
18637	3859	13	not	not	RB
18637	3859	14	be	be	VB
18637	3859	15	inferred	infer	VBN
18637	3859	16	that	that	IN
18637	3859	17	the	the	DT
18637	3859	18	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3859	19	of	of	IN
18637	3859	20	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3859	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	3859	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	3859	23	today	today	NN
18637	3859	24	totally	totally	RB
18637	3859	25	moribund	moribund	JJ
18637	3859	26	even	even	RB
18637	3859	27	in	in	IN
18637	3859	28	times	time	NNS
18637	3859	29	of	of	IN
18637	3859	30	stress	stress	NN
18637	3859	31	.	.	.
18637	3860	1	As	as	IN
18637	3860	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3860	3	have	have	VBP
18637	3860	4	just	just	RB
18637	3860	5	seen	see	VBN
18637	3860	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3860	7	still	still	RB
18637	3860	8	furnishes	furnish	VBZ
18637	3860	9	the	the	DT
18637	3860	10	basis	basis	NN
18637	3860	11	for	for	IN
18637	3860	12	some	some	DT
18637	3860	13	degree	degree	NN
18637	3860	14	of	of	IN
18637	3860	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3860	16	review	review	NN
18637	3860	17	as	as	IN
18637	3860	18	to	to	IN
18637	3860	19	the	the	DT
18637	3860	20	substantiality	substantiality	NN
18637	3860	21	of	of	IN
18637	3860	22	the	the	DT
18637	3860	23	factual	factual	JJ
18637	3860	24	justification	justification	NN
18637	3860	25	of	of	IN
18637	3860	26	a	a	DT
18637	3860	27	professed	professed	JJ
18637	3860	28	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3860	29	by	by	IN
18637	3860	30	a	a	DT
18637	3860	31	State	State	NNP
18637	3860	32	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3860	33	of	of	IN
18637	3860	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3860	35	police	police	NN
18637	3860	36	power	power	NN
18637	3860	37	;	;	:
18637	3860	38	and	and	CC
18637	3860	39	in	in	IN
18637	3860	40	the	the	DT
18637	3860	41	case	case	NN
18637	3860	42	of	of	IN
18637	3860	43	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3860	44	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	3860	45	the	the	DT
18637	3860	46	remedial	remedial	JJ
18637	3860	47	rights	right	NNS
18637	3860	48	of	of	IN
18637	3860	49	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	3860	50	,	,	,
18637	3860	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3860	52	still	still	RB
18637	3860	53	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	3860	54	a	a	DT
18637	3860	55	solid	solid	JJ
18637	3860	56	and	and	CC
18637	3860	57	palpable	palpable	JJ
18637	3860	58	barrier	barrier	NN
18637	3860	59	against	against	IN
18637	3860	60	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	3860	61	erosion	erosion	NN
18637	3860	62	.	.	.
18637	3861	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	3861	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	3861	3	this	this	DT
18637	3861	4	surprising	surprising	JJ
18637	3861	5	in	in	IN
18637	3861	6	view	view	NN
18637	3861	7	of	of	IN
18637	3861	8	the	the	DT
18637	3861	9	fact	fact	NN
18637	3861	10	that	that	IN
18637	3861	11	,	,	,
18637	3861	12	as	as	IN
18637	3861	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3861	14	have	have	VBP
18637	3861	15	seen	see	VBN
18637	3861	16	,	,	,
18637	3861	17	such	such	JJ
18637	3861	18	rights	right	NNS
18637	3861	19	were	be	VBD
18637	3861	20	foremost	foremost	JJ
18637	3861	21	in	in	IN
18637	3861	22	the	the	DT
18637	3861	23	minds	mind	NNS
18637	3861	24	of	of	IN
18637	3861	25	the	the	DT
18637	3861	26	framers	framer	NNS
18637	3861	27	of	of	IN
18637	3861	28	the	the	DT
18637	3861	29	clause	clause	NN
18637	3861	30	.	.	.
18637	3862	1	The	the	DT
18637	3862	2	court	court	NN
18637	3862	3	's	's	POS
18637	3862	4	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	3862	5	toward	toward	IN
18637	3862	6	insolvency	insolvency	NN
18637	3862	7	laws	law	NNS
18637	3862	8	,	,	,
18637	3862	9	redemption	redemption	NN
18637	3862	10	laws	law	NNS
18637	3862	11	,	,	,
18637	3862	12	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	3862	13	laws	law	NNS
18637	3862	14	,	,	,
18637	3862	15	appraisement	appraisement	NN
18637	3862	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	3862	17	and	and	CC
18637	3862	18	the	the	DT
18637	3862	19	like	like	NN
18637	3862	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	3862	21	always	always	RB
18637	3862	22	been	be	VBN
18637	3862	23	that	that	IN
18637	3862	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3862	25	may	may	MD
18637	3862	26	not	not	RB
18637	3862	27	be	be	VB
18637	3862	28	given	give	VBN
18637	3862	29	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	3862	30	operation;[1726	operation;[1726	''
18637	3862	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3862	32	and	and	CC
18637	3862	33	the	the	DT
18637	3862	34	general	general	JJ
18637	3862	35	lesson	lesson	NN
18637	3862	36	of	of	IN
18637	3862	37	these	these	DT
18637	3862	38	earlier	early	JJR
18637	3862	39	cases	case	NNS
18637	3862	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	3862	41	confirmed	confirm	VBN
18637	3862	42	by	by	IN
18637	3862	43	the	the	DT
18637	3862	44	court	court	NN
18637	3862	45	's	's	POS
18637	3862	46	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	3862	47	between	between	IN
18637	3862	48	1934	1934	CD
18637	3862	49	and	and	CC
18637	3862	50	1945	1945	CD
18637	3862	51	in	in	IN
18637	3862	52	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3862	53	cases	case	NNS
18637	3862	54	involving	involve	VBG
18637	3862	55	State	state	NN
18637	3862	56	moratorium	moratorium	NN
18637	3862	57	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3862	58	.	.	.
18637	3863	1	In	in	IN
18637	3863	2	Home	Home	NNP
18637	3863	3	Building	Building	NNP
18637	3863	4	and	and	CC
18637	3863	5	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	3863	6	Association	Association	NNP
18637	3863	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3863	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	3863	9	_	_	NNP
18637	3863	10	Blaisdell,[1727	Blaisdell,[1727	NNP
18637	3863	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3863	12	the	the	DT
18637	3863	13	leading	leading	JJ
18637	3863	14	case	case	NN
18637	3863	15	,	,	,
18637	3863	16	a	a	DT
18637	3863	17	closely	closely	RB
18637	3863	18	divided	divide	VBN
18637	3863	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3863	20	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	3863	21	the	the	DT
18637	3863	22	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	3863	23	Moratorium	Moratorium	NNP
18637	3863	24	Act	Act	NNP
18637	3863	25	of	of	IN
18637	3863	26	April	April	NNP
18637	3863	27	18	18	CD
18637	3863	28	,	,	,
18637	3863	29	1933	1933	CD
18637	3863	30	,	,	,
18637	3863	31	which	which	WDT
18637	3863	32	,	,	,
18637	3863	33	reciting	recite	VBG
18637	3863	34	the	the	DT
18637	3863	35	existence	existence	NN
18637	3863	36	of	of	IN
18637	3863	37	a	a	DT
18637	3863	38	severe	severe	JJ
18637	3863	39	financial	financial	JJ
18637	3863	40	and	and	CC
18637	3863	41	economic	economic	JJ
18637	3863	42	depression	depression	NN
18637	3863	43	for	for	IN
18637	3863	44	several	several	JJ
18637	3863	45	years	year	NNS
18637	3863	46	and	and	CC
18637	3863	47	the	the	DT
18637	3863	48	frequent	frequent	JJ
18637	3863	49	occurrence	occurrence	NN
18637	3863	50	of	of	IN
18637	3863	51	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	3863	52	foreclosure	foreclosure	NN
18637	3863	53	sales	sale	NNS
18637	3863	54	for	for	IN
18637	3863	55	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
18637	3863	56	prices	price	NNS
18637	3863	57	,	,	,
18637	3863	58	and	and	CC
18637	3863	59	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	3863	60	that	that	IN
18637	3863	61	these	these	DT
18637	3863	62	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	3863	63	had	have	VBD
18637	3863	64	created	create	VBN
18637	3863	65	an	an	DT
18637	3863	66	economic	economic	JJ
18637	3863	67	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	3863	68	calling	call	VBG
18637	3863	69	for	for	IN
18637	3863	70	the	the	DT
18637	3863	71	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3863	72	of	of	IN
18637	3863	73	the	the	DT
18637	3863	74	State	State	NNP
18637	3863	75	's	's	POS
18637	3863	76	police	police	NN
18637	3863	77	power	power	NN
18637	3863	78	,	,	,
18637	3863	79	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	3863	80	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3863	81	courts	court	NNS
18637	3863	82	to	to	TO
18637	3863	83	extend	extend	VB
18637	3863	84	the	the	DT
18637	3863	85	period	period	NN
18637	3863	86	for	for	IN
18637	3863	87	redemption	redemption	NN
18637	3863	88	from	from	IN
18637	3863	89	foreclosure	foreclosure	NN
18637	3863	90	sales	sale	NNS
18637	3863	91	for	for	IN
18637	3863	92	such	such	JJ
18637	3863	93	additional	additional	JJ
18637	3863	94	time	time	NN
18637	3863	95	as	as	IN
18637	3863	96	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3863	97	might	may	MD
18637	3863	98	deem	deem	VB
18637	3863	99	just	just	RB
18637	3863	100	and	and	CC
18637	3863	101	equitable	equitable	VB
18637	3863	102	,	,	,
18637	3863	103	although	although	IN
18637	3863	104	in	in	IN
18637	3863	105	no	no	DT
18637	3863	106	event	event	NN
18637	3863	107	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	3863	108	May	May	NNP
18637	3863	109	1	1	CD
18637	3863	110	,	,	,
18637	3863	111	1935	1935	CD
18637	3863	112	.	.	.
18637	3864	1	The	the	DT
18637	3864	2	act	act	NN
18637	3864	3	also	also	RB
18637	3864	4	left	leave	VBD
18637	3864	5	the	the	DT
18637	3864	6	mortgagor	mortgagor	NN
18637	3864	7	in	in	IN
18637	3864	8	possession	possession	NN
18637	3864	9	during	during	IN
18637	3864	10	the	the	DT
18637	3864	11	period	period	NN
18637	3864	12	of	of	IN
18637	3864	13	extension	extension	NN
18637	3864	14	,	,	,
18637	3864	15	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3864	16	to	to	IN
18637	3864	17	the	the	DT
18637	3864	18	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	3864	19	that	that	IN
18637	3864	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3864	21	pay	pay	VB
18637	3864	22	a	a	DT
18637	3864	23	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	3864	24	rental	rental	NN
18637	3864	25	for	for	IN
18637	3864	26	the	the	DT
18637	3864	27	property	property	NN
18637	3864	28	as	as	IN
18637	3864	29	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	3864	30	by	by	IN
18637	3864	31	the	the	DT
18637	3864	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3864	33	,	,	,
18637	3864	34	at	at	IN
18637	3864	35	such	such	JJ
18637	3864	36	time	time	NN
18637	3864	37	and	and	CC
18637	3864	38	in	in	IN
18637	3864	39	such	such	JJ
18637	3864	40	manner	manner	NN
18637	3864	41	as	as	IN
18637	3864	42	should	should	MD
18637	3864	43	be	be	VB
18637	3864	44	determined	determine	VBN
18637	3864	45	by	by	IN
18637	3864	46	the	the	DT
18637	3864	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3864	48	.	.	.
18637	3865	1	Contemporaneously	contemporaneously	RB
18637	3865	2	,	,	,
18637	3865	3	however	however	RB
18637	3865	4	,	,	,
18637	3865	5	less	less	RBR
18637	3865	6	carefully	carefully	RB
18637	3865	7	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	3865	8	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3865	9	from	from	IN
18637	3865	10	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	3865	11	and	and	CC
18637	3865	12	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	3865	13	,	,	,
18637	3865	14	acts	act	NNS
18637	3865	15	which	which	WDT
18637	3865	16	were	be	VBD
18637	3865	17	less	less	RBR
18637	3865	18	considerate	considerate	JJ
18637	3865	19	of	of	IN
18637	3865	20	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	3865	21	's	's	POS
18637	3865	22	rights	right	NNS
18637	3865	23	,	,	,
18637	3865	24	were	be	VBD
18637	3865	25	set	set	VBN
18637	3865	26	aside	aside	RB
18637	3865	27	as	as	IN
18637	3865	28	violative	violative	NN
18637	3865	29	of	of	IN
18637	3865	30	the	the	DT
18637	3865	31	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3865	32	clause	clause	NN
18637	3865	33	.	.	.
18637	3866	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3866	2	1728	1728	CD
18637	3866	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3866	4	"	"	``
18637	3866	5	A	a	DT
18637	3866	6	State	state	NN
18637	3866	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	3866	8	free	free	JJ
18637	3866	9	to	to	TO
18637	3866	10	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	3866	11	the	the	DT
18637	3866	12	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	3866	13	in	in	IN
18637	3866	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3866	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	3866	16	even	even	RB
18637	3866	17	with	with	IN
18637	3866	18	reference	reference	NN
18637	3866	19	to	to	IN
18637	3866	20	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3866	21	already	already	RB
18637	3866	22	made	make	VBN
18637	3866	23	,	,	,
18637	3866	24	"	"	''
18637	3866	25	said	say	VBD
18637	3866	26	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3866	27	Cardozo	Cardozo	NNP
18637	3866	28	for	for	IN
18637	3866	29	the	the	DT
18637	3866	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3866	31	,	,	,
18637	3866	32	"	"	''
18637	3866	33	and	and	CC
18637	3866	34	moderate	moderate	JJ
18637	3866	35	extensions	extension	NNS
18637	3866	36	of	of	IN
18637	3866	37	the	the	DT
18637	3866	38	time	time	NN
18637	3866	39	for	for	IN
18637	3866	40	pleading	pleading	NN
18637	3866	41	or	or	CC
18637	3866	42	for	for	IN
18637	3866	43	trial	trial	NN
18637	3866	44	will	will	MD
18637	3866	45	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	3866	46	fall	fall	VB
18637	3866	47	within	within	IN
18637	3866	48	the	the	DT
18637	3866	49	power	power	NN
18637	3866	50	so	so	RB
18637	3866	51	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	3866	52	.	.	.
18637	3867	1	A	a	DT
18637	3867	2	different	different	JJ
18637	3867	3	situation	situation	NN
18637	3867	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	3867	5	presented	present	VBN
18637	3867	6	when	when	WRB
18637	3867	7	extensions	extension	NNS
18637	3867	8	are	be	VBP
18637	3867	9	so	so	RB
18637	3867	10	piled	pile	VBN
18637	3867	11	up	up	RP
18637	3867	12	as	as	IN
18637	3867	13	to	to	TO
18637	3867	14	make	make	VB
18637	3867	15	the	the	DT
18637	3867	16	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	3867	17	a	a	DT
18637	3867	18	shadow	shadow	NN
18637	3867	19	.	.	.
18637	3868	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3868	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3868	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3868	4	What	what	WP
18637	3868	5	controls	control	VBZ
18637	3868	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3868	7	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	3868	8	at	at	IN
18637	3868	9	such	such	JJ
18637	3868	10	times	time	NNS
18637	3868	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	3868	12	the	the	DT
18637	3868	13	underlying	underlying	JJ
18637	3868	14	reality	reality	NN
18637	3868	15	rather	rather	RB
18637	3868	16	than	than	IN
18637	3868	17	the	the	DT
18637	3868	18	form	form	NN
18637	3868	19	or	or	CC
18637	3868	20	label	label	NN
18637	3868	21	.	.	.
18637	3869	1	The	the	DT
18637	3869	2	changes	change	NNS
18637	3869	3	of	of	IN
18637	3869	4	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	3869	5	now	now	RB
18637	3869	6	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	3869	7	as	as	IN
18637	3869	8	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	3869	9	are	be	VBP
18637	3869	10	to	to	TO
18637	3869	11	be	be	VB
18637	3869	12	viewed	view	VBN
18637	3869	13	in	in	IN
18637	3869	14	combination	combination	NN
18637	3869	15	,	,	,
18637	3869	16	with	with	IN
18637	3869	17	the	the	DT
18637	3869	18	cumulative	cumulative	JJ
18637	3869	19	significance	significance	NN
18637	3869	20	that	that	IN
18637	3869	21	each	each	DT
18637	3869	22	imparts	impart	VBZ
18637	3869	23	to	to	IN
18637	3869	24	all	all	DT
18637	3869	25	.	.	.
18637	3870	1	So	so	RB
18637	3870	2	viewed	view	VBN
18637	3870	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3870	4	are	be	VBP
18637	3870	5	seen	see	VBN
18637	3870	6	to	to	TO
18637	3870	7	be	be	VB
18637	3870	8	an	an	DT
18637	3870	9	oppressive	oppressive	JJ
18637	3870	10	and	and	CC
18637	3870	11	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	3870	12	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	3870	13	of	of	IN
18637	3870	14	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	3870	15	all	all	PDT
18637	3870	16	the	the	DT
18637	3870	17	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	3870	18	that	that	WDT
18637	3870	19	give	give	VBP
18637	3870	20	attractiveness	attractiveness	NN
18637	3870	21	and	and	CC
18637	3870	22	value	value	NN
18637	3870	23	to	to	IN
18637	3870	24	collateral	collateral	JJ
18637	3870	25	security	security	NN
18637	3870	26	.	.	.
18637	3871	1	"	"	``
18637	3871	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3871	3	1729	1729	CD
18637	3871	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3871	5	On	on	IN
18637	3871	6	the	the	DT
18637	3871	7	other	other	JJ
18637	3871	8	hand	hand	NN
18637	3871	9	,	,	,
18637	3871	10	in	in	IN
18637	3871	11	the	the	DT
18637	3871	12	most	most	RBS
18637	3871	13	recent	recent	JJ
18637	3871	14	of	of	IN
18637	3871	15	this	this	DT
18637	3871	16	category	category	NN
18637	3871	17	of	of	IN
18637	3871	18	cases	case	NNS
18637	3871	19	,	,	,
18637	3871	20	the	the	DT
18637	3871	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3871	22	gave	give	VBD
18637	3871	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3871	24	approval	approval	NN
18637	3871	25	to	to	IN
18637	3871	26	an	an	DT
18637	3871	27	extension	extension	NN
18637	3871	28	by	by	IN
18637	3871	29	the	the	DT
18637	3871	30	State	State	NNP
18637	3871	31	of	of	IN
18637	3871	32	New	New	NNP
18637	3871	33	York	York	NNP
18637	3871	34	of	of	IN
18637	3871	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3871	36	moratorium	moratorium	NN
18637	3871	37	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3871	38	.	.	.
18637	3872	1	While	while	IN
18637	3872	2	recognizing	recognize	VBG
18637	3872	3	that	that	IN
18637	3872	4	business	business	NN
18637	3872	5	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	3872	6	had	have	VBD
18637	3872	7	improved	improve	VBN
18637	3872	8	,	,	,
18637	3872	9	the	the	DT
18637	3872	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3872	11	was	be	VBD
18637	3872	12	of	of	IN
18637	3872	13	the	the	DT
18637	3872	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3872	15	that	that	IN
18637	3872	16	there	there	EX
18637	3872	17	was	be	VBD
18637	3872	18	reason	reason	NN
18637	3872	19	to	to	TO
18637	3872	20	believe	believe	VB
18637	3872	21	that	that	IN
18637	3872	22	"	"	``
18637	3872	23	'	'	''
18637	3872	24	the	the	DT
18637	3872	25	sudden	sudden	JJ
18637	3872	26	termination	termination	NN
18637	3872	27	of	of	IN
18637	3872	28	the	the	DT
18637	3872	29	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3872	30	which	which	WDT
18637	3872	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	3872	32	damned	damn	VBN
18637	3872	33	up	up	RP
18637	3872	34	normal	normal	JJ
18637	3872	35	liquidation	liquidation	NN
18637	3872	36	of	of	IN
18637	3872	37	these	these	DT
18637	3872	38	mortgages	mortgage	NNS
18637	3872	39	for	for	IN
18637	3872	40	more	more	JJR
18637	3872	41	than	than	IN
18637	3872	42	eight	eight	CD
18637	3872	43	years	year	NNS
18637	3872	44	might	may	MD
18637	3872	45	well	well	RB
18637	3872	46	result	result	VB
18637	3872	47	in	in	IN
18637	3872	48	an	an	DT
18637	3872	49	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	3872	50	more	more	RBR
18637	3872	51	acute	acute	JJ
18637	3872	52	than	than	IN
18637	3872	53	that	that	DT
18637	3872	54	which	which	WDT
18637	3872	55	the	the	DT
18637	3872	56	original	original	JJ
18637	3872	57	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3872	58	was	be	VBD
18637	3872	59	intended	intend	VBN
18637	3872	60	to	to	TO
18637	3872	61	alleviate	alleviate	VB
18637	3872	62	.	.	.
18637	3873	1	'	'	``
18637	3873	2	"	"	''
18637	3873	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3873	4	1730	1730	CD
18637	3873	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3873	6	And	and	CC
18637	3873	7	meantime	meantime	RB
18637	3873	8	the	the	DT
18637	3873	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3873	10	had	have	VBD
18637	3873	11	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	3873	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3873	13	of	of	IN
18637	3873	14	the	the	DT
18637	3873	15	State	State	NNP
18637	3873	16	of	of	IN
18637	3873	17	New	New	NNP
18637	3873	18	York	York	NNP
18637	3873	19	under	under	IN
18637	3873	20	which	which	WDT
18637	3873	21	a	a	DT
18637	3873	22	mortgagee	mortgagee	NN
18637	3873	23	of	of	IN
18637	3873	24	real	real	JJ
18637	3873	25	property	property	NN
18637	3873	26	was	be	VBD
18637	3873	27	denied	deny	VBN
18637	3873	28	a	a	DT
18637	3873	29	deficiency	deficiency	NN
18637	3873	30	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	3873	31	in	in	IN
18637	3873	32	a	a	DT
18637	3873	33	foreclosure	foreclosure	NN
18637	3873	34	suit	suit	NN
18637	3873	35	where	where	WRB
18637	3873	36	the	the	DT
18637	3873	37	State	State	NNP
18637	3873	38	court	court	NN
18637	3873	39	found	find	VBD
18637	3873	40	that	that	IN
18637	3873	41	the	the	DT
18637	3873	42	value	value	NN
18637	3873	43	of	of	IN
18637	3873	44	the	the	DT
18637	3873	45	property	property	NN
18637	3873	46	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	3873	47	by	by	IN
18637	3873	48	the	the	DT
18637	3873	49	mortgagee	mortgagee	NN
18637	3873	50	at	at	IN
18637	3873	51	the	the	DT
18637	3873	52	foreclosure	foreclosure	NN
18637	3873	53	sale	sale	NN
18637	3873	54	was	be	VBD
18637	3873	55	equal	equal	JJ
18637	3873	56	to	to	IN
18637	3873	57	the	the	DT
18637	3873	58	debt	debt	NN
18637	3873	59	secured	secure	VBN
18637	3873	60	by	by	IN
18637	3873	61	the	the	DT
18637	3873	62	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	3873	63	.	.	.
18637	3874	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3874	2	1731	1731	CD
18637	3874	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3874	4	"	"	``
18637	3874	5	Mortgagees	Mortgagees	NNPS
18637	3874	6	,	,	,
18637	3874	7	"	"	''
18637	3874	8	the	the	DT
18637	3874	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3874	10	said	say	VBD
18637	3874	11	,	,	,
18637	3874	12	"	"	``
18637	3874	13	are	be	VBP
18637	3874	14	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	3874	15	entitled	entitled	JJ
18637	3874	16	to	to	IN
18637	3874	17	no	no	DT
18637	3874	18	more	more	JJR
18637	3874	19	than	than	IN
18637	3874	20	payment	payment	NN
18637	3874	21	in	in	IN
18637	3874	22	full	full	JJ
18637	3874	23	.	.	.
18637	3875	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3875	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3875	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3875	4	To	to	TO
18637	3875	5	hold	hold	VB
18637	3875	6	that	that	IN
18637	3875	7	mortgagees	mortgagee	NNS
18637	3875	8	are	be	VBP
18637	3875	9	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	3875	10	under	under	IN
18637	3875	11	the	the	DT
18637	3875	12	contract	contract	NN
18637	3875	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	3875	14	to	to	TO
18637	3875	15	retain	retain	VB
18637	3875	16	the	the	DT
18637	3875	17	advantages	advantage	NNS
18637	3875	18	of	of	IN
18637	3875	19	a	a	DT
18637	3875	20	forced	force	VBN
18637	3875	21	sale	sale	NN
18637	3875	22	would	would	MD
18637	3875	23	be	be	VB
18637	3875	24	to	to	TO
18637	3875	25	dignify	dignify	VB
18637	3875	26	into	into	IN
18637	3875	27	a	a	DT
18637	3875	28	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	3875	29	protected	protect	VBN
18637	3875	30	property	property	NN
18637	3875	31	right	right	IN
18637	3875	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3875	33	chance	chance	NN
18637	3875	34	to	to	TO
18637	3875	35	get	get	VB
18637	3875	36	more	more	JJR
18637	3875	37	than	than	IN
18637	3875	38	the	the	DT
18637	3875	39	amount	amount	NN
18637	3875	40	of	of	IN
18637	3875	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3875	42	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3875	43	.	.	.
18637	3876	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3876	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3876	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3876	4	The	the	DT
18637	3876	5	contract	contract	NN
18637	3876	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	3876	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	3876	8	not	not	RB
18637	3876	9	protect	protect	VB
18637	3876	10	such	such	PDT
18637	3876	11	a	a	DT
18637	3876	12	strategical	strategical	JJ
18637	3876	13	,	,	,
18637	3876	14	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	3876	15	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	3876	16	.	.	.
18637	3877	1	"	"	``
18637	3877	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3877	3	1732	1732	CD
18637	3877	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3877	5	Statistical	Statistical	NNP
18637	3877	6	Data	Data	NNP
18637	3877	7	Pertinent	Pertinent	NNP
18637	3877	8	to	to	IN
18637	3877	9	the	the	DT
18637	3877	10	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3877	11	The	the	DT
18637	3877	12	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3877	13	of	of	IN
18637	3877	14	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3877	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	3877	16	attained	attain	VBD
18637	3877	17	the	the	DT
18637	3877	18	high	high	JJ
18637	3877	19	point	point	NN
18637	3877	20	of	of	IN
18637	3877	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3877	22	importance	importance	NN
18637	3877	23	in	in	IN
18637	3877	24	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3877	25	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	3877	26	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3877	27	in	in	IN
18637	3877	28	the	the	DT
18637	3877	29	years	year	NNS
18637	3877	30	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	3877	31	following	follow	VBG
18637	3877	32	the	the	DT
18637	3877	33	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	3877	34	War	War	NNP
18637	3877	35	.	.	.
18637	3878	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3878	2	1733	1733	CD
18637	3878	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3878	4	Between	between	IN
18637	3878	5	1865	1865	CD
18637	3878	6	and	and	CC
18637	3878	7	1873	1873	CD
18637	3878	8	there	there	EX
18637	3878	9	were	be	VBD
18637	3878	10	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	3878	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	3878	12	in	in	IN
18637	3878	13	which	which	WDT
18637	3878	14	State	State	NNP
18637	3878	15	acts	act	NNS
18637	3878	16	were	be	VBD
18637	3878	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	3878	18	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	3878	19	under	under	IN
18637	3878	20	the	the	DT
18637	3878	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	3878	22	,	,	,
18637	3878	23	of	of	IN
18637	3878	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3878	25	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	3878	26	involved	involve	VBD
18637	3878	27	public	public	JJ
18637	3878	28	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3878	29	.	.	.
18637	3879	1	During	during	IN
18637	3879	2	the	the	DT
18637	3879	3	next	next	JJ
18637	3879	4	fifteen	fifteen	CD
18637	3879	5	years	year	NNS
18637	3879	6	,	,	,
18637	3879	7	which	which	WDT
18637	3879	8	was	be	VBD
18637	3879	9	the	the	DT
18637	3879	10	period	period	NN
18637	3879	11	of	of	IN
18637	3879	12	Waite	Waite	NNP
18637	3879	13	's	's	POS
18637	3879	14	chief	chief	JJ
18637	3879	15	justiceship	justiceship	NN
18637	3879	16	,	,	,
18637	3879	17	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	3879	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	3879	19	nine	nine	CD
18637	3879	20	cases	case	NNS
18637	3879	21	reached	reach	VBD
18637	3879	22	the	the	DT
18637	3879	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3879	24	in	in	IN
18637	3879	25	which	which	WDT
18637	3879	26	State	State	NNP
18637	3879	27	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3879	28	was	be	VBD
18637	3879	29	set	set	VBN
18637	3879	30	aside	aside	RB
18637	3879	31	under	under	IN
18637	3879	32	the	the	DT
18637	3879	33	clause	clause	NN
18637	3879	34	.	.	.
18637	3880	1	Twenty	twenty	CD
18637	3880	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	3880	3	four	four	CD
18637	3880	4	of	of	IN
18637	3880	5	these	these	DT
18637	3880	6	involved	involve	VBN
18637	3880	7	public	public	JJ
18637	3880	8	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3880	9	.	.	.
18637	3881	1	The	the	DT
18637	3881	2	decline	decline	NN
18637	3881	3	of	of	IN
18637	3881	4	the	the	DT
18637	3881	5	importance	importance	NN
18637	3881	6	of	of	IN
18637	3881	7	the	the	DT
18637	3881	8	clause	clause	NN
18637	3881	9	as	as	IN
18637	3881	10	a	a	DT
18637	3881	11	title	title	NN
18637	3881	12	in	in	IN
18637	3881	13	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	3881	14	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3881	15	began	begin	VBD
18637	3881	16	under	under	IN
18637	3881	17	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3881	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3881	19	Fuller	Fuller	NNP
18637	3881	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3881	21	1888	1888	CD
18637	3881	22	to	to	IN
18637	3881	23	1910	1910	CD
18637	3881	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3881	25	.	.	.
18637	3882	1	During	during	IN
18637	3882	2	this	this	DT
18637	3882	3	period	period	NN
18637	3882	4	less	less	JJR
18637	3882	5	than	than	IN
18637	3882	6	25	25	CD
18637	3882	7	%	%	NN
18637	3882	8	of	of	IN
18637	3882	9	the	the	DT
18637	3882	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	3882	11	involving	involve	VBG
18637	3882	12	the	the	DT
18637	3882	13	validity	validity	NN
18637	3882	14	of	of	IN
18637	3882	15	State	State	NNP
18637	3882	16	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3882	17	involved	involve	VBD
18637	3882	18	this	this	DT
18637	3882	19	rubric	rubric	NN
18637	3882	20	.	.	.
18637	3883	1	In	in	IN
18637	3883	2	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	3883	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	3883	4	eight	eight	CD
18637	3883	5	of	of	IN
18637	3883	6	these	these	DT
18637	3883	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	3883	8	,	,	,
18637	3883	9	of	of	IN
18637	3883	10	which	which	WDT
18637	3883	11	only	only	RB
18637	3883	12	two	two	CD
18637	3883	13	involved	involved	JJ
18637	3883	14	private	private	JJ
18637	3883	15	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3883	16	,	,	,
18637	3883	17	the	the	DT
18637	3883	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	3883	19	involved	involve	VBN
18637	3883	20	was	be	VBD
18637	3883	21	set	set	VBN
18637	3883	22	aside	aside	RB
18637	3883	23	.	.	.
18637	3884	1	During	during	IN
18637	3884	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3884	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3884	4	White	White	NNP
18637	3884	5	's	's	POS
18637	3884	6	term	term	NN
18637	3884	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3884	8	1910	1910	CD
18637	3884	9	to	to	IN
18637	3884	10	1921	1921	CD
18637	3884	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3884	12	the	the	DT
18637	3884	13	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	3884	14	of	of	IN
18637	3884	15	contract	contract	NN
18637	3884	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	3884	17	shrank	shrink	VBD
18637	3884	18	to	to	IN
18637	3884	19	15	15	CD
18637	3884	20	%	%	NN
18637	3884	21	,	,	,
18637	3884	22	and	and	CC
18637	3884	23	in	in	IN
18637	3884	24	that	that	DT
18637	3884	25	of	of	IN
18637	3884	26	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3884	27	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3884	28	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	3884	29	,	,	,
18637	3884	30	to	to	IN
18637	3884	31	9	9	CD
18637	3884	32	%	%	NN
18637	3884	33	.	.	.
18637	3885	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3885	2	1734	1734	CD
18637	3885	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3885	4	In	in	IN
18637	3885	5	recent	recent	JJ
18637	3885	6	years	year	NNS
18637	3885	7	the	the	DT
18637	3885	8	clause	clause	NN
18637	3885	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	3885	10	appeared	appear	VBN
18637	3885	11	to	to	TO
18637	3885	12	undergo	undergo	VB
18637	3885	13	something	something	NN
18637	3885	14	of	of	IN
18637	3885	15	a	a	DT
18637	3885	16	revival	revival	NN
18637	3885	17	,	,	,
18637	3885	18	not	not	RB
18637	3885	19	however	however	RB
18637	3885	20	as	as	IN
18637	3885	21	a	a	DT
18637	3885	22	protection	protection	NN
18637	3885	23	of	of	IN
18637	3885	24	public	public	JJ
18637	3885	25	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3885	26	,	,	,
18637	3885	27	but	but	CC
18637	3885	28	as	as	IN
18637	3885	29	a	a	DT
18637	3885	30	protection	protection	NN
18637	3885	31	of	of	IN
18637	3885	32	private	private	JJ
18637	3885	33	credits	credit	NNS
18637	3885	34	.	.	.
18637	3886	1	During	during	IN
18637	3886	2	the	the	DT
18637	3886	3	Depression	Depression	NNP
18637	3886	4	,	,	,
18637	3886	5	which	which	WDT
18637	3886	6	began	begin	VBD
18637	3886	7	in	in	IN
18637	3886	8	1929	1929	CD
18637	3886	9	and	and	CC
18637	3886	10	deepened	deepen	VBD
18637	3886	11	in	in	IN
18637	3886	12	1932	1932	CD
18637	3886	13	,	,	,
18637	3886	14	State	State	NNP
18637	3886	15	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	3886	16	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	3886	17	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	3886	18	moratorium	moratorium	NN
18637	3886	19	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	3886	20	,	,	,
18637	3886	21	and	and	CC
18637	3886	22	beginning	begin	VBG
18637	3886	23	with	with	IN
18637	3886	24	Home	Home	NNP
18637	3886	25	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	3886	26	Association	Association	NNP
18637	3886	27	_	_	NNP
18637	3886	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	3886	29	_	_	NNP
18637	3886	30	Blaisdell	Blaisdell	NNP
18637	3886	31	,	,	,
18637	3886	32	which	which	WDT
18637	3886	33	was	be	VBD
18637	3886	34	decided	decide	VBN
18637	3886	35	in	in	IN
18637	3886	36	1934	1934	CD
18637	3886	37	,	,	,
18637	3886	38	the	the	DT
18637	3886	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3886	40	was	be	VBD
18637	3886	41	required	require	VBN
18637	3886	42	to	to	TO
18637	3886	43	pass	pass	VB
18637	3886	44	upon	upon	IN
18637	3886	45	several	several	JJ
18637	3886	46	of	of	IN
18637	3886	47	these	these	DT
18637	3886	48	.	.	.
18637	3887	1	At	at	IN
18637	3887	2	the	the	DT
18637	3887	3	same	same	JJ
18637	3887	4	time	time	NN
18637	3887	5	the	the	DT
18637	3887	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	3887	7	was	be	VBD
18637	3887	8	,	,	,
18637	3887	9	in	in	IN
18637	3887	10	effect	effect	NN
18637	3887	11	,	,	,
18637	3887	12	treated	treat	VBN
18637	3887	13	by	by	IN
18637	3887	14	the	the	DT
18637	3887	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3887	16	in	in	IN
18637	3887	17	two	two	CD
18637	3887	18	important	important	JJ
18637	3887	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	3887	20	as	as	IN
18637	3887	21	interpretive	interpretive	JJ
18637	3887	22	of	of	IN
18637	3887	23	the	the	DT
18637	3887	24	due	due	JJ
18637	3887	25	process	process	NN
18637	3887	26	clause	clause	NN
18637	3887	27	,	,	,
18637	3887	28	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3887	29	V	V	NNP
18637	3887	30	,	,	,
18637	3887	31	and	and	CC
18637	3887	32	thus	thus	RB
18637	3887	33	applied	apply	VBD
18637	3887	34	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	3887	35	as	as	IN
18637	3887	36	a	a	DT
18637	3887	37	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	3887	38	on	on	IN
18637	3887	39	the	the	DT
18637	3887	40	power	power	NN
18637	3887	41	of	of	IN
18637	3887	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3887	43	.	.	.
18637	3888	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3888	2	1735	1735	CD
18637	3888	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3888	4	But	but	CC
18637	3888	5	this	this	DT
18637	3888	6	emergence	emergence	NN
18637	3888	7	of	of	IN
18637	3888	8	the	the	DT
18637	3888	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	3888	10	into	into	IN
18637	3888	11	prominence	prominence	NN
18637	3888	12	was	be	VBD
18637	3888	13	a	a	DT
18637	3888	14	flash	flash	NN
18637	3888	15	in	in	IN
18637	3888	16	the	the	DT
18637	3888	17	pan	pan	NN
18637	3888	18	.	.	.
18637	3889	1	During	during	IN
18637	3889	2	the	the	DT
18637	3889	3	last	last	JJ
18637	3889	4	decade	decade	NN
18637	3889	5	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	3889	6	a	a	DT
18637	3889	7	case	case	NN
18637	3889	8	a	a	DT
18637	3889	9	term	term	NN
18637	3889	10	involving	involve	VBG
18637	3889	11	the	the	DT
18637	3889	12	clause	clause	NN
18637	3889	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	3889	14	reached	reach	VBN
18637	3889	15	the	the	DT
18637	3889	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3889	17	,	,	,
18637	3889	18	counting	count	VBG
18637	3889	19	even	even	RB
18637	3889	20	those	those	DT
18637	3889	21	in	in	IN
18637	3889	22	which	which	WDT
18637	3889	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3889	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	3889	25	treated	treat	VBN
18637	3889	26	as	as	IN
18637	3889	27	a	a	DT
18637	3889	28	tail	tail	NN
18637	3889	29	to	to	IN
18637	3889	30	the	the	DT
18637	3889	31	due	due	JJ
18637	3889	32	process	process	NN
18637	3889	33	of	of	IN
18637	3889	34	law	law	NN
18637	3889	35	kite	kite	NN
18637	3889	36	.	.	.
18637	3890	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3890	2	1736	1736	CD
18637	3890	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3890	4	The	the	DT
18637	3890	5	reason	reason	NN
18637	3890	6	for	for	IN
18637	3890	7	this	this	DT
18637	3890	8	declension	declension	NN
18637	3890	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	3890	10	been	be	VBN
18637	3890	11	twofold	twofold	JJ
18637	3890	12	:	:	:
18637	3890	13	first	first	RB
18637	3890	14	,	,	,
18637	3890	15	the	the	DT
18637	3890	16	subordination	subordination	NN
18637	3890	17	of	of	IN
18637	3890	18	public	public	JJ
18637	3890	19	grants	grant	NNS
18637	3890	20	to	to	IN
18637	3890	21	the	the	DT
18637	3890	22	police	police	NN
18637	3890	23	power	power	NN
18637	3890	24	;	;	:
18637	3890	25	secondly	secondly	RB
18637	3890	26	,	,	,
18637	3890	27	the	the	DT
18637	3890	28	expansion	expansion	NN
18637	3890	29	of	of	IN
18637	3890	30	the	the	DT
18637	3890	31	due	due	JJ
18637	3890	32	process	process	NN
18637	3890	33	clause	clause	NN
18637	3890	34	,	,	,
18637	3890	35	which	which	WDT
18637	3890	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	3890	37	largely	largely	RB
18637	3890	38	rendered	render	VBN
18637	3890	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3890	40	a	a	DT
18637	3890	41	fifth	fifth	JJ
18637	3890	42	wheel	wheel	NN
18637	3890	43	to	to	IN
18637	3890	44	the	the	DT
18637	3890	45	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	3890	46	Law	Law	NNP
18637	3890	47	coach	coach	NN
18637	3890	48	.	.	.
18637	3891	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3891	2	2	2	CD
18637	3891	3	.	.	.
18637	3892	1	No	no	DT
18637	3892	2	State	state	NN
18637	3892	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	3892	4	,	,	,
18637	3892	5	without	without	IN
18637	3892	6	the	the	DT
18637	3892	7	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	3892	8	of	of	IN
18637	3892	9	the	the	DT
18637	3892	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3892	11	,	,	,
18637	3892	12	lay	lie	VBD
18637	3892	13	any	any	DT
18637	3892	14	Imposts	Imposts	NNPS
18637	3892	15	or	or	CC
18637	3892	16	Duties	duty	NNS
18637	3892	17	on	on	IN
18637	3892	18	Imports	Imports	NNPS
18637	3892	19	or	or	CC
18637	3892	20	Exports	Exports	NNPS
18637	3892	21	,	,	,
18637	3892	22	except	except	IN
18637	3892	23	what	what	WP
18637	3892	24	may	may	MD
18637	3892	25	be	be	VB
18637	3892	26	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	3892	27	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3892	28	for	for	IN
18637	3892	29	executing	execute	VBG
18637	3892	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3892	31	's	be	VBZ
18637	3892	32	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	3892	33	Laws	law	NNS
18637	3892	34	:	:	:
18637	3892	35	and	and	CC
18637	3892	36	the	the	DT
18637	3892	37	net	net	JJ
18637	3892	38	Produce	Produce	NNP
18637	3892	39	of	of	IN
18637	3892	40	all	all	DT
18637	3892	41	Duties	Duties	NNPS
18637	3892	42	and	and	CC
18637	3892	43	Imposts	Imposts	NNPS
18637	3892	44	,	,	,
18637	3892	45	laid	lay	VBN
18637	3892	46	by	by	IN
18637	3892	47	any	any	DT
18637	3892	48	State	State	NNP
18637	3892	49	on	on	IN
18637	3892	50	Imports	Imports	NNPS
18637	3892	51	or	or	CC
18637	3892	52	Exports	Exports	NNPS
18637	3892	53	,	,	,
18637	3892	54	shall	shall	MD
18637	3892	55	be	be	VB
18637	3892	56	for	for	IN
18637	3892	57	the	the	DT
18637	3892	58	Use	Use	NNP
18637	3892	59	of	of	IN
18637	3892	60	the	the	DT
18637	3892	61	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	3892	62	of	of	IN
18637	3892	63	the	the	DT
18637	3892	64	United	United	NNP
18637	3892	65	States	States	NNP
18637	3892	66	;	;	:
18637	3892	67	and	and	CC
18637	3892	68	all	all	DT
18637	3892	69	such	such	JJ
18637	3892	70	Laws	law	NNS
18637	3892	71	shall	shall	MD
18637	3892	72	be	be	VB
18637	3892	73	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3892	74	to	to	IN
18637	3892	75	the	the	DT
18637	3892	76	Revision	Revision	NNP
18637	3892	77	and	and	CC
18637	3892	78	Controul	Controul	NNP
18637	3892	79	of	of	IN
18637	3892	80	the	the	DT
18637	3892	81	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3892	82	.	.	.
18637	3893	1	DUTIES	duty	NNS
18637	3893	2	ON	on	IN
18637	3893	3	EXPORTS	EXPORTS	NNP
18637	3893	4	AND	and	CC
18637	3893	5	IMPORTS	IMPORTS	NNP
18637	3893	6	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	3893	7	Only	only	RB
18637	3893	8	articles	article	NNS
18637	3893	9	imported	import	VBN
18637	3893	10	from	from	IN
18637	3893	11	or	or	CC
18637	3893	12	exported	export	VBN
18637	3893	13	to	to	IN
18637	3893	14	a	a	DT
18637	3893	15	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3893	16	country	country	NN
18637	3893	17	,	,	,
18637	3893	18	or	or	CC
18637	3893	19	"	"	``
18637	3893	20	a	a	DT
18637	3893	21	place	place	NN
18637	3893	22	over	over	IN
18637	3893	23	which	which	WDT
18637	3893	24	the	the	DT
18637	3893	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3893	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	3893	27	not	not	RB
18637	3893	28	extended	extend	VBN
18637	3893	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3893	30	commands	command	NNS
18637	3893	31	with	with	IN
18637	3893	32	respect	respect	NN
18637	3893	33	to	to	IN
18637	3893	34	imports	import	NNS
18637	3893	35	and	and	CC
18637	3893	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3893	37	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3893	38	,	,	,
18637	3893	39	"	"	''
18637	3893	40	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	3893	41	,	,	,
18637	3893	42	the	the	DT
18637	3893	43	Philippine	Philippine	NNP
18637	3893	44	Islands	Islands	NNPS
18637	3893	45	,	,	,
18637	3893	46	are	be	VBP
18637	3893	47	comprehended	comprehend	VBN
18637	3893	48	by	by	IN
18637	3893	49	the	the	DT
18637	3893	50	terms	term	NNS
18637	3893	51	"	"	``
18637	3893	52	imports	import	NNS
18637	3893	53	"	"	''
18637	3893	54	and	and	CC
18637	3893	55	"	"	``
18637	3893	56	exports,"[1737	exports,"[1737	NNP
18637	3893	57	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3893	58	goods	good	NNS
18637	3893	59	brought	bring	VBN
18637	3893	60	from	from	IN
18637	3893	61	another	another	DT
18637	3893	62	State	state	NN
18637	3893	63	are	be	VBP
18637	3893	64	not	not	RB
18637	3893	65	affected	affect	VBN
18637	3893	66	by	by	IN
18637	3893	67	this	this	DT
18637	3893	68	section	section	NN
18637	3893	69	.	.	.
18637	3894	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3894	2	1738	1738	CD
18637	3894	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3894	4	To	to	TO
18637	3894	5	determine	determine	VB
18637	3894	6	how	how	WRB
18637	3894	7	long	long	RB
18637	3894	8	imported	import	VBN
18637	3894	9	wares	ware	NNS
18637	3894	10	remain	remain	VBP
18637	3894	11	under	under	IN
18637	3894	12	the	the	DT
18637	3894	13	protection	protection	NN
18637	3894	14	of	of	IN
18637	3894	15	this	this	DT
18637	3894	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	3894	17	,	,	,
18637	3894	18	the	the	DT
18637	3894	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3894	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3894	21	enunciated	enunciate	VBD
18637	3894	22	the	the	DT
18637	3894	23	original	original	JJ
18637	3894	24	package	package	NN
18637	3894	25	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3894	26	in	in	IN
18637	3894	27	the	the	DT
18637	3894	28	leading	leading	JJ
18637	3894	29	case	case	NN
18637	3894	30	of	of	IN
18637	3894	31	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	3894	32	_	_	NNP
18637	3894	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	3894	34	_	_	NNP
18637	3894	35	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	3894	36	.	.	.
18637	3895	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3895	2	1739	1739	CD
18637	3895	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3895	4	"	"	``
18637	3895	5	When	when	WRB
18637	3895	6	the	the	DT
18637	3895	7	importer	importer	NN
18637	3895	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	3895	9	so	so	RB
18637	3895	10	acted	act	VBN
18637	3895	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	3895	12	the	the	DT
18637	3895	13	thing	thing	NN
18637	3895	14	imported	import	VBN
18637	3895	15	,	,	,
18637	3895	16	"	"	''
18637	3895	17	wrote	write	VBD
18637	3895	18	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3895	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3895	20	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	3895	21	,	,	,
18637	3895	22	"	"	``
18637	3895	23	that	that	IN
18637	3895	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3895	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	3895	26	become	become	VBN
18637	3895	27	incorporated	incorporated	JJ
18637	3895	28	and	and	CC
18637	3895	29	mixed	mix	VBN
18637	3895	30	up	up	RP
18637	3895	31	with	with	IN
18637	3895	32	the	the	DT
18637	3895	33	mass	mass	NN
18637	3895	34	of	of	IN
18637	3895	35	property	property	NN
18637	3895	36	in	in	IN
18637	3895	37	the	the	DT
18637	3895	38	country	country	NN
18637	3895	39	,	,	,
18637	3895	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3895	41	has	have	VBZ
18637	3895	42	,	,	,
18637	3895	43	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	3895	44	,	,	,
18637	3895	45	lost	lose	VBD
18637	3895	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3895	47	distinctive	distinctive	JJ
18637	3895	48	character	character	NN
18637	3895	49	as	as	IN
18637	3895	50	an	an	DT
18637	3895	51	import	import	NN
18637	3895	52	,	,	,
18637	3895	53	and	and	CC
18637	3895	54	has	have	VBZ
18637	3895	55	become	become	VBN
18637	3895	56	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3895	57	to	to	IN
18637	3895	58	the	the	DT
18637	3895	59	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	3895	60	power	power	NN
18637	3895	61	of	of	IN
18637	3895	62	the	the	DT
18637	3895	63	State	State	NNP
18637	3895	64	;	;	:
18637	3895	65	but	but	CC
18637	3895	66	while	while	IN
18637	3895	67	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	3895	68	the	the	DT
18637	3895	69	property	property	NN
18637	3895	70	of	of	IN
18637	3895	71	the	the	DT
18637	3895	72	importer	importer	NN
18637	3895	73	,	,	,
18637	3895	74	in	in	IN
18637	3895	75	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3895	76	warehouse	warehouse	NN
18637	3895	77	,	,	,
18637	3895	78	in	in	IN
18637	3895	79	the	the	DT
18637	3895	80	original	original	JJ
18637	3895	81	form	form	NN
18637	3895	82	or	or	CC
18637	3895	83	package	package	NN
18637	3895	84	in	in	IN
18637	3895	85	which	which	WDT
18637	3895	86	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3895	87	was	be	VBD
18637	3895	88	imported	import	VBN
18637	3895	89	,	,	,
18637	3895	90	a	a	DT
18637	3895	91	tax	tax	NN
18637	3895	92	upon	upon	IN
18637	3895	93	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3895	94	is	be	VBZ
18637	3895	95	too	too	RB
18637	3895	96	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	3895	97	a	a	DT
18637	3895	98	duty	duty	NN
18637	3895	99	on	on	IN
18637	3895	100	imports	import	NNS
18637	3895	101	,	,	,
18637	3895	102	to	to	TO
18637	3895	103	escape	escape	VB
18637	3895	104	the	the	DT
18637	3895	105	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3895	106	in	in	IN
18637	3895	107	the	the	DT
18637	3895	108	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3895	109	.	.	.
18637	3896	1	"	"	``
18637	3896	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3896	3	1740	1740	CD
18637	3896	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3896	5	A	a	DT
18637	3896	6	box	box	NN
18637	3896	7	,	,	,
18637	3896	8	case	case	NN
18637	3896	9	or	or	CC
18637	3896	10	bale	bale	NN
18637	3896	11	in	in	IN
18637	3896	12	which	which	WDT
18637	3896	13	separate	separate	JJ
18637	3896	14	parcels	parcel	NNS
18637	3896	15	of	of	IN
18637	3896	16	goods	good	NNS
18637	3896	17	have	have	VBP
18637	3896	18	been	be	VBN
18637	3896	19	placed	place	VBN
18637	3896	20	by	by	IN
18637	3896	21	the	the	DT
18637	3896	22	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3896	23	seller	seller	NN
18637	3896	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	3896	25	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	3896	26	as	as	IN
18637	3896	27	the	the	DT
18637	3896	28	original	original	JJ
18637	3896	29	package	package	NN
18637	3896	30	,	,	,
18637	3896	31	and	and	CC
18637	3896	32	upon	upon	IN
18637	3896	33	the	the	DT
18637	3896	34	opening	opening	NN
18637	3896	35	of	of	IN
18637	3896	36	such	such	JJ
18637	3896	37	container	container	NN
18637	3896	38	for	for	IN
18637	3896	39	the	the	DT
18637	3896	40	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3896	41	of	of	IN
18637	3896	42	using	use	VBG
18637	3896	43	the	the	DT
18637	3896	44	separate	separate	JJ
18637	3896	45	parcels	parcel	NNS
18637	3896	46	,	,	,
18637	3896	47	or	or	CC
18637	3896	48	of	of	IN
18637	3896	49	exposing	expose	VBG
18637	3896	50	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3896	51	for	for	IN
18637	3896	52	sale	sale	NN
18637	3896	53	,	,	,
18637	3896	54	each	each	DT
18637	3896	55	parcel	parcel	NN
18637	3896	56	loses	lose	VBZ
18637	3896	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3896	58	character	character	NN
18637	3896	59	as	as	IN
18637	3896	60	an	an	DT
18637	3896	61	import	import	NN
18637	3896	62	and	and	CC
18637	3896	63	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	3896	64	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3896	65	to	to	IN
18637	3896	66	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3896	67	as	as	IN
18637	3896	68	a	a	DT
18637	3896	69	part	part	NN
18637	3896	70	of	of	IN
18637	3896	71	the	the	DT
18637	3896	72	general	general	JJ
18637	3896	73	mass	mass	NN
18637	3896	74	of	of	IN
18637	3896	75	property	property	NN
18637	3896	76	in	in	IN
18637	3896	77	the	the	DT
18637	3896	78	State	State	NNP
18637	3896	79	.	.	.
18637	3897	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3897	2	1741	1741	CD
18637	3897	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3897	4	Imports	import	NNS
18637	3897	5	for	for	IN
18637	3897	6	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	3897	7	cease	cease	NN
18637	3897	8	to	to	TO
18637	3897	9	be	be	VB
18637	3897	10	such	such	JJ
18637	3897	11	when	when	WRB
18637	3897	12	the	the	DT
18637	3897	13	intended	intend	VBN
18637	3897	14	processing	processing	NN
18637	3897	15	takes	take	VBZ
18637	3897	16	place,[1742	place,[1742	NNP
18637	3897	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3897	18	or	or	CC
18637	3897	19	when	when	WRB
18637	3897	20	the	the	DT
18637	3897	21	original	original	JJ
18637	3897	22	packages	package	NNS
18637	3897	23	are	be	VBP
18637	3897	24	broken	break	VBN
18637	3897	25	.	.	.
18637	3898	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3898	2	1743	1743	CD
18637	3898	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3898	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	3898	5	a	a	DT
18637	3898	6	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
18637	3898	7	imports	import	NNS
18637	3898	8	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	3898	9	and	and	CC
18637	3898	10	stores	store	VBZ
18637	3898	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3898	12	in	in	IN
18637	3898	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3898	14	warehouse	warehouse	NN
18637	3898	15	in	in	IN
18637	3898	16	the	the	DT
18637	3898	17	original	original	JJ
18637	3898	18	packages	package	NNS
18637	3898	19	,	,	,
18637	3898	20	that	that	DT
18637	3898	21	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	3898	22	does	do	VBZ
18637	3898	23	not	not	RB
18637	3898	24	lose	lose	VB
18637	3898	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3898	26	quality	quality	NN
18637	3898	27	as	as	IN
18637	3898	28	an	an	DT
18637	3898	29	import	import	NN
18637	3898	30	,	,	,
18637	3898	31	at	at	IN
18637	3898	32	least	least	JJS
18637	3898	33	so	so	RB
18637	3898	34	long	long	RB
18637	3898	35	as	as	IN
18637	3898	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3898	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	3898	38	not	not	RB
18637	3898	39	required	require	VBN
18637	3898	40	to	to	TO
18637	3898	41	meet	meet	VB
18637	3898	42	such	such	JJ
18637	3898	43	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	3898	44	needs	need	NNS
18637	3898	45	.	.	.
18637	3899	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3899	2	1744	1744	CD
18637	3899	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3899	4	The	the	DT
18637	3899	5	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	3899	6	of	of	IN
18637	3899	7	imported	import	VBN
18637	3899	8	goods	good	NNS
18637	3899	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	3899	10	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	3899	11	to	to	TO
18637	3899	12	be	be	VB
18637	3899	13	the	the	DT
18637	3899	14	importer	importer	NN
18637	3899	15	if	if	IN
18637	3899	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3899	17	was	be	VBD
18637	3899	18	the	the	DT
18637	3899	19	efficient	efficient	JJ
18637	3899	20	cause	cause	NN
18637	3899	21	of	of	IN
18637	3899	22	the	the	DT
18637	3899	23	importation	importation	NN
18637	3899	24	,	,	,
18637	3899	25	whether	whether	IN
18637	3899	26	the	the	DT
18637	3899	27	title	title	NN
18637	3899	28	to	to	IN
18637	3899	29	the	the	DT
18637	3899	30	goods	good	NNS
18637	3899	31	vested	vest	VBN
18637	3899	32	in	in	IN
18637	3899	33	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3899	34	at	at	IN
18637	3899	35	the	the	DT
18637	3899	36	time	time	NN
18637	3899	37	of	of	IN
18637	3899	38	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	3899	39	,	,	,
18637	3899	40	or	or	CC
18637	3899	41	after	after	IN
18637	3899	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3899	43	arrival	arrival	NN
18637	3899	44	in	in	IN
18637	3899	45	this	this	DT
18637	3899	46	country	country	NN
18637	3899	47	.	.	.
18637	3900	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3900	2	1745	1745	CD
18637	3900	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3900	4	A	a	DT
18637	3900	5	State	State	NNP
18637	3900	6	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	3900	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	3900	8	measured	measure	VBN
18637	3900	9	by	by	IN
18637	3900	10	properly	properly	RB
18637	3900	11	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	3900	12	gross	gross	JJ
18637	3900	13	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	3900	14	may	may	MD
18637	3900	15	be	be	VB
18637	3900	16	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	3900	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	3900	18	a	a	DT
18637	3900	19	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	3900	20	company	company	NN
18637	3900	21	in	in	IN
18637	3900	22	respect	respect	NN
18637	3900	23	of	of	IN
18637	3900	24	the	the	DT
18637	3900	25	company	company	NN
18637	3900	26	's	's	POS
18637	3900	27	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	3900	28	for	for	IN
18637	3900	29	services	service	NNS
18637	3900	30	in	in	IN
18637	3900	31	handling	handle	VBG
18637	3900	32	imports	import	NNS
18637	3900	33	and	and	CC
18637	3900	34	exports	export	NNS
18637	3900	35	at	at	IN
18637	3900	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3900	37	marine	marine	JJ
18637	3900	38	terminal	terminal	NN
18637	3900	39	.	.	.
18637	3901	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3901	2	1746	1746	CD
18637	3901	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3901	4	Privilege	Privilege	NNP
18637	3901	5	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3901	6	A	a	DT
18637	3901	7	State	State	NNP
18637	3901	8	law	law	NN
18637	3901	9	requiring	require	VBG
18637	3901	10	importers	importer	NNS
18637	3901	11	to	to	TO
18637	3901	12	take	take	VB
18637	3901	13	out	out	RP
18637	3901	14	a	a	DT
18637	3901	15	license	license	NN
18637	3901	16	to	to	TO
18637	3901	17	sell	sell	VB
18637	3901	18	imported	import	VBN
18637	3901	19	goods	good	NNS
18637	3901	20	amounts	amount	NNS
18637	3901	21	to	to	IN
18637	3901	22	an	an	DT
18637	3901	23	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	3901	24	tax	tax	NN
18637	3901	25	on	on	IN
18637	3901	26	imports	import	NNS
18637	3901	27	and	and	CC
18637	3901	28	hence	hence	RB
18637	3901	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	3901	30	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	3901	31	.	.	.
18637	3902	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3902	2	1747	1747	CD
18637	3902	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3902	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	3902	5	,	,	,
18637	3902	6	a	a	DT
18637	3902	7	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	3902	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	3902	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	3902	10	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3902	11	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	3902	12	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	3902	13	in	in	IN
18637	3902	14	importing	import	VBG
18637	3902	15	nitrate	nitrate	JJ
18637	3902	16	and	and	CC
18637	3902	17	selling	sell	VBG
18637	3902	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3902	19	in	in	IN
18637	3902	20	the	the	DT
18637	3902	21	original	original	JJ
18637	3902	22	packages,[1748	packages,[1748	NNP
18637	3902	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3902	24	a	a	DT
18637	3902	25	tax	tax	NN
18637	3902	26	on	on	IN
18637	3902	27	sales	sale	NNS
18637	3902	28	by	by	IN
18637	3902	29	brokers[1749	brokers[1749	NNP
18637	3902	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3902	31	and	and	CC
18637	3902	32	auctioneers[1750	auctioneers[1750	NNP
18637	3902	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3902	34	of	of	IN
18637	3902	35	imported	import	VBN
18637	3902	36	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	3902	37	in	in	IN
18637	3902	38	original	original	JJ
18637	3902	39	packages	package	NNS
18637	3902	40	,	,	,
18637	3902	41	and	and	CC
18637	3902	42	a	a	DT
18637	3902	43	tax	tax	NN
18637	3902	44	on	on	IN
18637	3902	45	the	the	DT
18637	3902	46	sale	sale	NN
18637	3902	47	of	of	IN
18637	3902	48	goods	good	NNS
18637	3902	49	in	in	IN
18637	3902	50	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3902	51	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	3902	52	consisting	consist	VBG
18637	3902	53	of	of	IN
18637	3902	54	an	an	DT
18637	3902	55	annual	annual	JJ
18637	3902	56	license	license	NN
18637	3902	57	fee	fee	NN
18637	3902	58	plus	plus	CC
18637	3902	59	a	a	DT
18637	3902	60	percentage	percentage	NN
18637	3902	61	of	of	IN
18637	3902	62	gross	gross	JJ
18637	3902	63	sales,[1751	sales,[1751	NNP
18637	3902	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3902	65	have	have	VBP
18637	3902	66	been	be	VBN
18637	3902	67	held	hold	VBN
18637	3902	68	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	3902	69	.	.	.
18637	3903	1	On	on	IN
18637	3903	2	the	the	DT
18637	3903	3	other	other	JJ
18637	3903	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	3903	5	,	,	,
18637	3903	6	pilotage	pilotage	JJ
18637	3903	7	fees,[1752	fees,[1752	NNP
18637	3903	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3903	9	a	a	DT
18637	3903	10	tax	tax	NN
18637	3903	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	3903	12	the	the	DT
18637	3903	13	gross	gross	JJ
18637	3903	14	sales	sale	NNS
18637	3903	15	of	of	IN
18637	3903	16	a	a	DT
18637	3903	17	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	3903	18	from	from	IN
18637	3903	19	the	the	DT
18637	3903	20	importer,[1753	importer,[1753	NNP
18637	3903	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3903	22	a	a	DT
18637	3903	23	license	license	NN
18637	3903	24	tax	tax	NN
18637	3903	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	3903	26	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	3903	27	in	in	IN
18637	3903	28	fish	fish	NN
18637	3903	29	which	which	WDT
18637	3903	30	,	,	,
18637	3903	31	through	through	IN
18637	3903	32	processing	processing	NN
18637	3903	33	,	,	,
18637	3903	34	handling	handling	NN
18637	3903	35	,	,	,
18637	3903	36	and	and	CC
18637	3903	37	sale	sale	NN
18637	3903	38	,	,	,
18637	3903	39	have	have	VBP
18637	3903	40	lost	lose	VBN
18637	3903	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3903	42	distinctive	distinctive	JJ
18637	3903	43	character	character	NN
18637	3903	44	as	as	IN
18637	3903	45	imports,[1754	imports,[1754	NNP
18637	3903	46	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3903	47	an	an	DT
18637	3903	48	annual	annual	JJ
18637	3903	49	license	license	NN
18637	3903	50	fee	fee	NN
18637	3903	51	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	3903	52	on	on	IN
18637	3903	53	persons	person	NNS
18637	3903	54	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	3903	55	in	in	IN
18637	3903	56	buying	buy	VBG
18637	3903	57	and	and	CC
18637	3903	58	selling	sell	VBG
18637	3903	59	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3903	60	bills	bill	NNS
18637	3903	61	of	of	IN
18637	3903	62	exchange,[1755	exchange,[1755	NNP
18637	3903	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3903	64	and	and	CC
18637	3903	65	a	a	DT
18637	3903	66	tax	tax	NN
18637	3903	67	upon	upon	IN
18637	3903	68	the	the	DT
18637	3903	69	right	right	NN
18637	3903	70	of	of	IN
18637	3903	71	an	an	DT
18637	3903	72	alien	alien	NN
18637	3903	73	to	to	TO
18637	3903	74	receive	receive	VB
18637	3903	75	property	property	NN
18637	3903	76	as	as	IN
18637	3903	77	heir	heir	NN
18637	3903	78	,	,	,
18637	3903	79	legatee	legatee	NNP
18637	3903	80	,	,	,
18637	3903	81	or	or	CC
18637	3903	82	donee	donee	NN
18637	3903	83	of	of	IN
18637	3903	84	a	a	DT
18637	3903	85	deceased	deceased	JJ
18637	3903	86	person[1756	person[1756	NNP
18637	3903	87	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3903	88	have	have	VBP
18637	3903	89	been	be	VBN
18637	3903	90	held	hold	VBN
18637	3903	91	not	not	RB
18637	3903	92	to	to	TO
18637	3903	93	be	be	VB
18637	3903	94	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3903	95	on	on	IN
18637	3903	96	imports	import	NNS
18637	3903	97	or	or	CC
18637	3903	98	exports	export	NNS
18637	3903	99	.	.	.
18637	3904	1	Property	Property	NNP
18637	3904	2	Taxes	Taxes	NNP
18637	3904	3	Property	Property	NNP
18637	3904	4	brought	bring	VBD
18637	3904	5	into	into	IN
18637	3904	6	the	the	DT
18637	3904	7	United	United	NNP
18637	3904	8	States	States	NNP
18637	3904	9	from	from	IN
18637	3904	10	without	without	IN
18637	3904	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	3904	12	immune	immune	JJ
18637	3904	13	from	from	IN
18637	3904	14	_	_	NNP
18637	3904	15	ad	ad	NN
18637	3904	16	valorem	valorem	NN
18637	3904	17	_	_	NNP
18637	3904	18	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	3904	19	so	so	RB
18637	3904	20	long	long	RB
18637	3904	21	as	as	IN
18637	3904	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3904	23	retains	retain	VBZ
18637	3904	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3904	25	character	character	NN
18637	3904	26	as	as	IN
18637	3904	27	an	an	DT
18637	3904	28	import,[1757	import,[1757	NNP
18637	3904	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3904	30	but	but	CC
18637	3904	31	the	the	DT
18637	3904	32	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	3904	33	of	of	IN
18637	3904	34	the	the	DT
18637	3904	35	sale	sale	NN
18637	3904	36	of	of	IN
18637	3904	37	imports	import	NNS
18637	3904	38	,	,	,
18637	3904	39	whether	whether	IN
18637	3904	40	in	in	IN
18637	3904	41	the	the	DT
18637	3904	42	form	form	NN
18637	3904	43	of	of	IN
18637	3904	44	money	money	NN
18637	3904	45	or	or	CC
18637	3904	46	notes	note	NNS
18637	3904	47	,	,	,
18637	3904	48	may	may	MD
18637	3904	49	be	be	VB
18637	3904	50	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	3904	51	by	by	IN
18637	3904	52	a	a	DT
18637	3904	53	State	state	NN
18637	3904	54	.	.	.
18637	3905	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3905	2	1758	1758	CD
18637	3905	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3905	4	A	a	DT
18637	3905	5	property	property	NN
18637	3905	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	3905	7	levied	levy	VBN
18637	3905	8	on	on	IN
18637	3905	9	warehouse	warehouse	NN
18637	3905	10	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	3905	11	for	for	IN
18637	3905	12	whiskey	whiskey	NN
18637	3905	13	exported	export	VBN
18637	3905	14	to	to	IN
18637	3905	15	Germany	Germany	NNP
18637	3905	16	was	be	VBD
18637	3905	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	3905	18	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	3905	19	as	as	IN
18637	3905	20	a	a	DT
18637	3905	21	tax	tax	NN
18637	3905	22	on	on	IN
18637	3905	23	exports	export	NNS
18637	3905	24	.	.	.
18637	3906	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3906	2	1759	1759	CD
18637	3906	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3906	4	Inspection	Inspection	NNP
18637	3906	5	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	3906	6	Inspection	Inspection	NNP
18637	3906	7	laws	law	NNS
18637	3906	8	"	"	''
18637	3906	9	are	be	VBP
18637	3906	10	confined	confine	VBN
18637	3906	11	to	to	IN
18637	3906	12	such	such	JJ
18637	3906	13	particulars	particular	NNS
18637	3906	14	as	as	IN
18637	3906	15	,	,	,
18637	3906	16	in	in	IN
18637	3906	17	the	the	DT
18637	3906	18	estimation	estimation	NN
18637	3906	19	of	of	IN
18637	3906	20	the	the	DT
18637	3906	21	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	3906	22	and	and	CC
18637	3906	23	according	accord	VBG
18637	3906	24	to	to	IN
18637	3906	25	the	the	DT
18637	3906	26	customs	custom	NNS
18637	3906	27	of	of	IN
18637	3906	28	trade	trade	NN
18637	3906	29	,	,	,
18637	3906	30	are	be	VBP
18637	3906	31	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	3906	32	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3906	33	to	to	TO
18637	3906	34	fit	fit	VB
18637	3906	35	the	the	DT
18637	3906	36	inspected	inspected	JJ
18637	3906	37	article	article	NN
18637	3906	38	for	for	IN
18637	3906	39	the	the	DT
18637	3906	40	market	market	NN
18637	3906	41	,	,	,
18637	3906	42	by	by	IN
18637	3906	43	giving	give	VBG
18637	3906	44	the	the	DT
18637	3906	45	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	3906	46	public	public	JJ
18637	3906	47	assurance	assurance	NN
18637	3906	48	that	that	IN
18637	3906	49	the	the	DT
18637	3906	50	article	article	NN
18637	3906	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	3906	52	in	in	IN
18637	3906	53	that	that	DT
18637	3906	54	condition	condition	NN
18637	3906	55	,	,	,
18637	3906	56	and	and	CC
18637	3906	57	of	of	IN
18637	3906	58	that	that	DT
18637	3906	59	quality	quality	NN
18637	3906	60	,	,	,
18637	3906	61	which	which	WDT
18637	3906	62	makes	make	VBZ
18637	3906	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3906	64	merchantable	merchantable	JJ
18637	3906	65	and	and	CC
18637	3906	66	fit	fit	JJ
18637	3906	67	for	for	IN
18637	3906	68	use	use	NN
18637	3906	69	or	or	CC
18637	3906	70	consumption	consumption	NN
18637	3906	71	.	.	.
18637	3907	1	"	"	``
18637	3907	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3907	3	1760	1760	CD
18637	3907	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3907	5	In	in	IN
18637	3907	6	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	3907	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3907	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	3907	9	_	_	NNP
18637	3907	10	Maryland[1761	Maryland[1761	NNP
18637	3907	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3907	12	the	the	DT
18637	3907	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3907	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3907	15	listed	list	VBD
18637	3907	16	as	as	IN
18637	3907	17	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	3907	18	elements	element	NNS
18637	3907	19	of	of	IN
18637	3907	20	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	3907	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	3907	22	,	,	,
18637	3907	23	the	the	DT
18637	3907	24	"	"	``
18637	3907	25	quality	quality	NN
18637	3907	26	of	of	IN
18637	3907	27	the	the	DT
18637	3907	28	article	article	NN
18637	3907	29	,	,	,
18637	3907	30	form	form	NN
18637	3907	31	,	,	,
18637	3907	32	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	3907	33	,	,	,
18637	3907	34	dimensions	dimension	NNS
18637	3907	35	,	,	,
18637	3907	36	and	and	CC
18637	3907	37	weight	weight	NN
18637	3907	38	of	of	IN
18637	3907	39	package	package	NN
18637	3907	40	,	,	,
18637	3907	41	mode	mode	NN
18637	3907	42	of	of	IN
18637	3907	43	putting	put	VBG
18637	3907	44	up	up	RP
18637	3907	45	,	,	,
18637	3907	46	and	and	CC
18637	3907	47	marking	mark	VBG
18637	3907	48	and	and	CC
18637	3907	49	branding	branding	NN
18637	3907	50	of	of	IN
18637	3907	51	various	various	JJ
18637	3907	52	kinds	kind	NNS
18637	3907	53	,	,	,
18637	3907	54	*	*	NFP
18637	3907	55	*	*	NFP
18637	3907	56	*	*	NFP
18637	3907	57	"	"	''
18637	3907	58	.	.	.
18637	3908	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3908	2	1762	1762	CD
18637	3908	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3908	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3908	5	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	3908	6	as	as	IN
18637	3908	7	an	an	DT
18637	3908	8	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	3908	9	law	law	NN
18637	3908	10	a	a	DT
18637	3908	11	charge	charge	NN
18637	3908	12	for	for	IN
18637	3908	13	storage	storage	NN
18637	3908	14	and	and	CC
18637	3908	15	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	3908	16	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	3908	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	3908	18	every	every	DT
18637	3908	19	hogshead	hogshead	NN
18637	3908	20	of	of	IN
18637	3908	21	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	3908	22	grown	grow	VBN
18637	3908	23	in	in	IN
18637	3908	24	the	the	DT
18637	3908	25	State	State	NNP
18637	3908	26	and	and	CC
18637	3908	27	intended	intend	VBN
18637	3908	28	for	for	IN
18637	3908	29	export	export	NN
18637	3908	30	,	,	,
18637	3908	31	which	which	WDT
18637	3908	32	the	the	DT
18637	3908	33	law	law	NN
18637	3908	34	required	require	VBD
18637	3908	35	to	to	TO
18637	3908	36	be	be	VB
18637	3908	37	brought	bring	VBN
18637	3908	38	to	to	IN
18637	3908	39	a	a	DT
18637	3908	40	State	state	NN
18637	3908	41	warehouse	warehouse	NN
18637	3908	42	to	to	TO
18637	3908	43	be	be	VB
18637	3908	44	inspected	inspect	VBN
18637	3908	45	and	and	CC
18637	3908	46	branded	brand	VBN
18637	3908	47	.	.	.
18637	3909	1	The	the	DT
18637	3909	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3909	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	3909	4	cited	cite	VBN
18637	3909	5	this	this	DT
18637	3909	6	section	section	NN
18637	3909	7	as	as	IN
18637	3909	8	a	a	DT
18637	3909	9	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	3909	10	of	of	IN
18637	3909	11	a	a	DT
18637	3909	12	general	general	JJ
18637	3909	13	right	right	NN
18637	3909	14	of	of	IN
18637	3909	15	the	the	DT
18637	3909	16	States	States	NNPS
18637	3909	17	to	to	TO
18637	3909	18	pass	pass	VB
18637	3909	19	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	3909	20	laws	law	NNS
18637	3909	21	,	,	,
18637	3909	22	and	and	CC
18637	3909	23	to	to	TO
18637	3909	24	bring	bring	VB
18637	3909	25	,	,	,
18637	3909	26	within	within	IN
18637	3909	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3909	28	reach	reach	NN
18637	3909	29	articles	article	NNS
18637	3909	30	of	of	IN
18637	3909	31	interstate	interstate	NN
18637	3909	32	,	,	,
18637	3909	33	as	as	RB
18637	3909	34	well	well	RB
18637	3909	35	as	as	IN
18637	3909	36	of	of	IN
18637	3909	37	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3909	38	,	,	,
18637	3909	39	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	3909	40	.	.	.
18637	3910	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3910	2	1763	1763	CD
18637	3910	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3910	4	But	but	CC
18637	3910	5	on	on	IN
18637	3910	6	the	the	DT
18637	3910	7	ground	ground	NN
18637	3910	8	that	that	IN
18637	3910	9	,	,	,
18637	3910	10	"	"	``
18637	3910	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3910	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	3910	13	never	never	RB
18637	3910	14	been	be	VBN
18637	3910	15	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	3910	16	as	as	IN
18637	3910	17	within	within	IN
18637	3910	18	the	the	DT
18637	3910	19	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	3910	20	scope	scope	NN
18637	3910	21	of	of	IN
18637	3910	22	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	3910	23	laws	law	NNS
18637	3910	24	to	to	TO
18637	3910	25	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	3910	26	trade	trade	NN
18637	3910	27	in	in	IN
18637	3910	28	respect	respect	NN
18637	3910	29	to	to	IN
18637	3910	30	any	any	DT
18637	3910	31	known	know	VBN
18637	3910	32	article	article	NN
18637	3910	33	of	of	IN
18637	3910	34	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	3910	35	,	,	,
18637	3910	36	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	3910	37	of	of	IN
18637	3910	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3910	39	condition	condition	NN
18637	3910	40	and	and	CC
18637	3910	41	quality	quality	NN
18637	3910	42	,	,	,
18637	3910	43	merely	merely	RB
18637	3910	44	on	on	IN
18637	3910	45	account	account	NN
18637	3910	46	of	of	IN
18637	3910	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3910	48	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
18637	3910	49	nature	nature	NN
18637	3910	50	and	and	CC
18637	3910	51	the	the	DT
18637	3910	52	injurious	injurious	JJ
18637	3910	53	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	3910	54	of	of	IN
18637	3910	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3910	56	use	use	NN
18637	3910	57	or	or	CC
18637	3910	58	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	3910	59	,	,	,
18637	3910	60	"	"	''
18637	3910	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3910	62	held	hold	VBD
18637	3910	63	that	that	IN
18637	3910	64	a	a	DT
18637	3910	65	State	State	NNP
18637	3910	66	law	law	NN
18637	3910	67	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	3910	68	the	the	DT
18637	3910	69	importation	importation	NN
18637	3910	70	of	of	IN
18637	3910	71	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	3910	72	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	3910	73	into	into	IN
18637	3910	74	the	the	DT
18637	3910	75	State	state	NN
18637	3910	76	could	could	MD
18637	3910	77	not	not	RB
18637	3910	78	be	be	VB
18637	3910	79	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	3910	80	as	as	IN
18637	3910	81	an	an	DT
18637	3910	82	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	3910	83	law	law	NN
18637	3910	84	.	.	.
18637	3911	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3911	2	1764	1764	CD
18637	3911	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3911	4	Since	since	IN
18637	3911	5	the	the	DT
18637	3911	6	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	3911	7	of	of	IN
18637	3911	8	the	the	DT
18637	3911	9	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	3911	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	3911	11	first	first	NNP
18637	3911	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3911	13	,	,	,
18637	3911	14	such	such	JJ
18637	3911	15	State	State	NNP
18637	3911	16	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3911	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	3911	18	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3911	19	whether	whether	IN
18637	3911	20	classified	classify	VBN
18637	3911	21	as	as	IN
18637	3911	22	an	an	DT
18637	3911	23	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	3911	24	law	law	NN
18637	3911	25	or	or	CC
18637	3911	26	not	not	RB
18637	3911	27	.	.	.
18637	3912	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	3912	2	3	3	CD
18637	3912	3	.	.	.
18637	3913	1	No	no	DT
18637	3913	2	State	state	NN
18637	3913	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	3913	4	,	,	,
18637	3913	5	without	without	IN
18637	3913	6	the	the	DT
18637	3913	7	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	3913	8	of	of	IN
18637	3913	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3913	10	,	,	,
18637	3913	11	lay	lie	VBD
18637	3913	12	any	any	DT
18637	3913	13	Duty	Duty	NNP
18637	3913	14	of	of	IN
18637	3913	15	Tonnage	Tonnage	NNP
18637	3913	16	,	,	,
18637	3913	17	keep	keep	VB
18637	3913	18	Troops	troop	NNS
18637	3913	19	,	,	,
18637	3913	20	or	or	CC
18637	3913	21	Ships	Ships	NNPS
18637	3913	22	of	of	IN
18637	3913	23	War	War	NNP
18637	3913	24	in	in	IN
18637	3913	25	time	time	NN
18637	3913	26	of	of	IN
18637	3913	27	Peace	Peace	NNP
18637	3913	28	,	,	,
18637	3913	29	enter	enter	VB
18637	3913	30	into	into	IN
18637	3913	31	any	any	DT
18637	3913	32	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	3913	33	or	or	CC
18637	3913	34	Compact	Compact	NNP
18637	3913	35	with	with	IN
18637	3913	36	another	another	DT
18637	3913	37	State	state	NN
18637	3913	38	,	,	,
18637	3913	39	or	or	CC
18637	3913	40	with	with	IN
18637	3913	41	a	a	DT
18637	3913	42	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3913	43	Power	power	NN
18637	3913	44	,	,	,
18637	3913	45	or	or	CC
18637	3913	46	engage	engage	VB
18637	3913	47	in	in	IN
18637	3913	48	War	War	NNP
18637	3913	49	,	,	,
18637	3913	50	unless	unless	IN
18637	3913	51	actually	actually	RB
18637	3913	52	invaded	invade	VBN
18637	3913	53	,	,	,
18637	3913	54	or	or	CC
18637	3913	55	in	in	IN
18637	3913	56	such	such	JJ
18637	3913	57	imminent	imminent	JJ
18637	3913	58	Danger	Danger	NNP
18637	3913	59	as	as	IN
18637	3913	60	will	will	MD
18637	3913	61	not	not	RB
18637	3913	62	admit	admit	VB
18637	3913	63	of	of	IN
18637	3913	64	delay	delay	NN
18637	3913	65	.	.	.
18637	3914	1	TONNAGE	tonnage	NN
18637	3914	2	DUTIES	dutie	VBZ
18637	3914	3	The	the	DT
18637	3914	4	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3914	5	against	against	IN
18637	3914	6	tonnage	tonnage	NN
18637	3914	7	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3914	8	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	3914	9	all	all	DT
18637	3914	10	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	3914	11	and	and	CC
18637	3914	12	duties	duty	NNS
18637	3914	13	,	,	,
18637	3914	14	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	3914	15	of	of	IN
18637	3914	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3914	17	name	name	NN
18637	3914	18	or	or	CC
18637	3914	19	form	form	NN
18637	3914	20	,	,	,
18637	3914	21	whether	whether	IN
18637	3914	22	measured	measure	VBN
18637	3914	23	by	by	IN
18637	3914	24	the	the	DT
18637	3914	25	tonnage	tonnage	NN
18637	3914	26	of	of	IN
18637	3914	27	the	the	DT
18637	3914	28	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	3914	29	or	or	CC
18637	3914	30	not	not	RB
18637	3914	31	,	,	,
18637	3914	32	which	which	WDT
18637	3914	33	are	be	VBP
18637	3914	34	in	in	IN
18637	3914	35	effect	effect	NN
18637	3914	36	charges	charge	NNS
18637	3914	37	for	for	IN
18637	3914	38	the	the	DT
18637	3914	39	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	3914	40	of	of	IN
18637	3914	41	entering	entering	NN
18637	3914	42	,	,	,
18637	3914	43	trading	trading	NN
18637	3914	44	in	in	RP
18637	3914	45	,	,	,
18637	3914	46	or	or	CC
18637	3914	47	lying	lie	VBG
18637	3914	48	in	in	IN
18637	3914	49	a	a	DT
18637	3914	50	port	port	NN
18637	3914	51	.	.	.
18637	3915	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3915	2	1765	1765	CD
18637	3915	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3915	4	But	but	CC
18637	3915	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3915	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	3915	7	not	not	RB
18637	3915	8	extend	extend	VB
18637	3915	9	to	to	IN
18637	3915	10	charges	charge	NNS
18637	3915	11	made	make	VBN
18637	3915	12	by	by	IN
18637	3915	13	State	State	NNP
18637	3915	14	authority	authority	NN
18637	3915	15	,	,	,
18637	3915	16	even	even	RB
18637	3915	17	if	if	IN
18637	3915	18	graduated	graduate	VBN
18637	3915	19	according	accord	VBG
18637	3915	20	to	to	IN
18637	3915	21	tonnage,[1766	tonnage,[1766	NNP
18637	3915	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3915	23	for	for	IN
18637	3915	24	services	service	NNS
18637	3915	25	rendered	render	VBN
18637	3915	26	to	to	IN
18637	3915	27	the	the	DT
18637	3915	28	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	3915	29	,	,	,
18637	3915	30	such	such	JJ
18637	3915	31	as	as	IN
18637	3915	32	pilotage	pilotage	NN
18637	3915	33	,	,	,
18637	3915	34	towage	towage	NN
18637	3915	35	,	,	,
18637	3915	36	charges	charge	NNS
18637	3915	37	for	for	IN
18637	3915	38	loading	loading	NN
18637	3915	39	and	and	CC
18637	3915	40	unloading	unloading	NN
18637	3915	41	cargoes	cargo	NNS
18637	3915	42	,	,	,
18637	3915	43	wharfage	wharfage	NN
18637	3915	44	,	,	,
18637	3915	45	or	or	CC
18637	3915	46	storage	storage	NN
18637	3915	47	.	.	.
18637	3916	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3916	2	1767	1767	CD
18637	3916	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3916	4	For	for	IN
18637	3916	5	the	the	DT
18637	3916	6	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	3916	7	of	of	IN
18637	3916	8	determining	determine	VBG
18637	3916	9	wharfage	wharfage	NN
18637	3916	10	charges	charge	NNS
18637	3916	11	,	,	,
18637	3916	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3916	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	3916	14	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
18637	3916	15	whether	whether	IN
18637	3916	16	the	the	DT
18637	3916	17	wharf	wharf	NN
18637	3916	18	was	be	VBD
18637	3916	19	built	build	VBN
18637	3916	20	by	by	IN
18637	3916	21	the	the	DT
18637	3916	22	State	State	NNP
18637	3916	23	,	,	,
18637	3916	24	a	a	DT
18637	3916	25	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	3916	26	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3916	27	or	or	CC
18637	3916	28	an	an	DT
18637	3916	29	individual	individual	NN
18637	3916	30	;	;	:
18637	3916	31	where	where	WRB
18637	3916	32	the	the	DT
18637	3916	33	wharf	wharf	NN
18637	3916	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	3916	35	owned	own	VBN
18637	3916	36	by	by	IN
18637	3916	37	a	a	DT
18637	3916	38	city	city	NN
18637	3916	39	,	,	,
18637	3916	40	the	the	DT
18637	3916	41	fact	fact	NN
18637	3916	42	that	that	IN
18637	3916	43	the	the	DT
18637	3916	44	city	city	NN
18637	3916	45	realized	realize	VBD
18637	3916	46	a	a	DT
18637	3916	47	profit	profit	NN
18637	3916	48	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	3916	49	the	the	DT
18637	3916	50	amount	amount	NN
18637	3916	51	expended	expend	VBN
18637	3916	52	does	do	VBZ
18637	3916	53	not	not	RB
18637	3916	54	render	render	VB
18637	3916	55	the	the	DT
18637	3916	56	toll	toll	NN
18637	3916	57	objectionable	objectionable	JJ
18637	3916	58	.	.	.
18637	3917	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3917	2	1768	1768	CD
18637	3917	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3917	4	The	the	DT
18637	3917	5	services	service	NNS
18637	3917	6	of	of	IN
18637	3917	7	harbor	harbor	NN
18637	3917	8	masters	master	NNS
18637	3917	9	for	for	IN
18637	3917	10	which	which	WDT
18637	3917	11	fees	fee	NNS
18637	3917	12	are	be	VBP
18637	3917	13	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	3917	14	must	must	MD
18637	3917	15	be	be	VB
18637	3917	16	actually	actually	RB
18637	3917	17	rendered	render	VBN
18637	3917	18	,	,	,
18637	3917	19	and	and	CC
18637	3917	20	a	a	DT
18637	3917	21	law	law	NN
18637	3917	22	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	3917	23	harbor	harbor	NN
18637	3917	24	masters	master	NNS
18637	3917	25	or	or	CC
18637	3917	26	port	port	NN
18637	3917	27	wardens	warden	NNS
18637	3917	28	to	to	TO
18637	3917	29	impose	impose	VB
18637	3917	30	a	a	DT
18637	3917	31	fee	fee	NN
18637	3917	32	in	in	IN
18637	3917	33	all	all	DT
18637	3917	34	cases	case	NNS
18637	3917	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	3917	36	void	void	JJ
18637	3917	37	.	.	.
18637	3918	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3918	2	1769	1769	CD
18637	3918	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3918	4	A	a	DT
18637	3918	5	State	state	NN
18637	3918	6	may	may	MD
18637	3918	7	not	not	RB
18637	3918	8	levy	levy	VB
18637	3918	9	a	a	DT
18637	3918	10	tonnage	tonnage	NN
18637	3918	11	duty	duty	NN
18637	3918	12	to	to	TO
18637	3918	13	defray	defray	VB
18637	3918	14	the	the	DT
18637	3918	15	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	3918	16	of	of	IN
18637	3918	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3918	18	quarantine	quarantine	NN
18637	3918	19	system,[1770	system,[1770	NNP
18637	3918	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3918	21	but	but	CC
18637	3918	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3918	23	may	may	MD
18637	3918	24	exact	exact	VB
18637	3918	25	a	a	DT
18637	3918	26	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	3918	27	fee	fee	NN
18637	3918	28	for	for	IN
18637	3918	29	examination	examination	NN
18637	3918	30	of	of	IN
18637	3918	31	all	all	DT
18637	3918	32	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	3918	33	passing	pass	VBG
18637	3918	34	quarantine	quarantine	NN
18637	3918	35	.	.	.
18637	3919	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3919	2	1771	1771	CD
18637	3919	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3919	4	A	a	DT
18637	3919	5	State	state	NN
18637	3919	6	license	license	NN
18637	3919	7	fee	fee	NN
18637	3919	8	for	for	IN
18637	3919	9	ferrying	ferry	VBG
18637	3919	10	on	on	IN
18637	3919	11	a	a	DT
18637	3919	12	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	3919	13	river	river	NN
18637	3919	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	3919	15	not	not	RB
18637	3919	16	a	a	DT
18637	3919	17	tonnage	tonnage	NN
18637	3919	18	tax	tax	NN
18637	3919	19	,	,	,
18637	3919	20	but	but	CC
18637	3919	21	rather	rather	RB
18637	3919	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	3919	23	a	a	DT
18637	3919	24	proper	proper	JJ
18637	3919	25	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	3919	26	of	of	IN
18637	3919	27	the	the	DT
18637	3919	28	police	police	NN
18637	3919	29	power	power	NN
18637	3919	30	,	,	,
18637	3919	31	and	and	CC
18637	3919	32	the	the	DT
18637	3919	33	fact	fact	NN
18637	3919	34	that	that	IN
18637	3919	35	a	a	DT
18637	3919	36	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	3919	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	3919	38	enrolled	enrol	VBN
18637	3919	39	under	under	IN
18637	3919	40	federal	federal	JJ
18637	3919	41	law	law	NN
18637	3919	42	does	do	VBZ
18637	3919	43	not	not	RB
18637	3919	44	exempt	exempt	VB
18637	3919	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3919	46	.	.	.
18637	3920	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3920	2	1772	1772	CD
18637	3920	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3920	4	In	in	IN
18637	3920	5	the	the	DT
18637	3920	6	State	State	NNP
18637	3920	7	Tonnage	Tonnage	NNP
18637	3920	8	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	3920	9	Cases,[1773	cases,[1773	CD
18637	3920	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3920	11	an	an	DT
18637	3920	12	annual	annual	JJ
18637	3920	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	3920	14	on	on	IN
18637	3920	15	steamboats	steamboat	NNS
18637	3920	16	measured	measure	VBN
18637	3920	17	by	by	IN
18637	3920	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3920	19	registered	register	VBN
18637	3920	20	tonnage	tonnage	NN
18637	3920	21	was	be	VBD
18637	3920	22	held	hold	VBN
18637	3920	23	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	3920	24	despite	despite	IN
18637	3920	25	the	the	DT
18637	3920	26	contention	contention	NN
18637	3920	27	that	that	IN
18637	3920	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3920	29	was	be	VBD
18637	3920	30	a	a	DT
18637	3920	31	valid	valid	JJ
18637	3920	32	tax	tax	NN
18637	3920	33	on	on	IN
18637	3920	34	the	the	DT
18637	3920	35	steamboat	steamboat	NN
18637	3920	36	as	as	IN
18637	3920	37	property	property	NN
18637	3920	38	.	.	.
18637	3921	1	KEEPING	keep	VBG
18637	3921	2	TROOPS	TROOPS	NNP
18637	3921	3	This	this	DT
18637	3921	4	provision	provision	NN
18637	3921	5	contemplates	contemplate	VBZ
18637	3921	6	the	the	DT
18637	3921	7	use	use	NN
18637	3921	8	of	of	IN
18637	3921	9	the	the	DT
18637	3921	10	State	State	NNP
18637	3921	11	's	's	POS
18637	3921	12	military	military	JJ
18637	3921	13	power	power	NN
18637	3921	14	to	to	TO
18637	3921	15	put	put	VB
18637	3921	16	down	down	RP
18637	3921	17	an	an	DT
18637	3921	18	armed	armed	JJ
18637	3921	19	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	3921	20	too	too	RB
18637	3921	21	strong	strong	JJ
18637	3921	22	to	to	TO
18637	3921	23	be	be	VB
18637	3921	24	controlled	control	VBN
18637	3921	25	by	by	IN
18637	3921	26	civil	civil	JJ
18637	3921	27	authority;[1774	authority;[1774	NNPS
18637	3921	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3921	29	and	and	CC
18637	3921	30	the	the	DT
18637	3921	31	organization	organization	NN
18637	3921	32	and	and	CC
18637	3921	33	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	3921	34	of	of	IN
18637	3921	35	an	an	DT
18637	3921	36	active	active	JJ
18637	3921	37	State	State	NNP
18637	3921	38	militia	militia	NN
18637	3921	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	3921	40	not	not	RB
18637	3921	41	a	a	DT
18637	3921	42	keeping	keeping	NN
18637	3921	43	of	of	IN
18637	3921	44	troops	troop	NNS
18637	3921	45	in	in	IN
18637	3921	46	time	time	NN
18637	3921	47	of	of	IN
18637	3921	48	peace	peace	NN
18637	3921	49	within	within	IN
18637	3921	50	the	the	DT
18637	3921	51	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3921	52	of	of	IN
18637	3921	53	this	this	DT
18637	3921	54	clause	clause	NN
18637	3921	55	.	.	.
18637	3922	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3922	2	1775	1775	CD
18637	3922	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3922	4	INTERSTATE	interstate	JJ
18637	3922	5	COMPACTS	COMPACTS	NNP
18637	3922	6	Background	background	NN
18637	3922	7	of	of	IN
18637	3922	8	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	3922	9	Except	except	IN
18637	3922	10	for	for	IN
18637	3922	11	the	the	DT
18637	3922	12	single	single	JJ
18637	3922	13	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	3922	14	that	that	IN
18637	3922	15	the	the	DT
18637	3922	16	consent	consent	NN
18637	3922	17	of	of	IN
18637	3922	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3922	19	must	must	MD
18637	3922	20	be	be	VB
18637	3922	21	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	3922	22	,	,	,
18637	3922	23	the	the	DT
18637	3922	24	original	original	JJ
18637	3922	25	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	3922	26	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	3922	27	rights	right	NNS
18637	3922	28	of	of	IN
18637	3922	29	the	the	DT
18637	3922	30	States	States	NNPS
18637	3922	31	to	to	TO
18637	3922	32	make	make	VB
18637	3922	33	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	3922	34	with	with	IN
18637	3922	35	each	each	DT
18637	3922	36	other	other	JJ
18637	3922	37	was	be	VBD
18637	3922	38	not	not	RB
18637	3922	39	surrendered	surrender	VBN
18637	3922	40	under	under	IN
18637	3922	41	the	the	DT
18637	3922	42	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3922	43	.	.	.
18637	3923	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3923	2	1776	1776	CD
18637	3923	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3923	4	"	"	``
18637	3923	5	The	the	DT
18637	3923	6	compact	compact	JJ
18637	3923	7	,	,	,
18637	3923	8	"	"	''
18637	3923	9	as	as	IN
18637	3923	10	the	the	DT
18637	3923	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3923	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3923	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	3923	14	put	put	VBN
18637	3923	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3923	16	,	,	,
18637	3923	17	"	"	''
18637	3923	18	adapts	adapt	VBZ
18637	3923	19	to	to	IN
18637	3923	20	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3923	21	Union	Union	NNP
18637	3923	22	of	of	IN
18637	3923	23	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	3923	24	States	state	NNS
18637	3923	25	the	the	DT
18637	3923	26	age	age	NN
18637	3923	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	3923	28	old	old	JJ
18637	3923	29	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	3923	30	-	-	HYPH
18637	3923	31	making	make	VBG
18637	3923	32	power	power	NN
18637	3923	33	of	of	IN
18637	3923	34	independent	independent	JJ
18637	3923	35	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	3923	36	nations	nation	NNS
18637	3923	37	.	.	.
18637	3924	1	"	"	``
18637	3924	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3924	3	1777	1777	CD
18637	3924	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3924	5	In	in	IN
18637	3924	6	American	american	JJ
18637	3924	7	history	history	NN
18637	3924	8	the	the	DT
18637	3924	9	compact	compact	JJ
18637	3924	10	technique	technique	NN
18637	3924	11	can	can	MD
18637	3924	12	be	be	VB
18637	3924	13	traced	trace	VBN
18637	3924	14	back	back	RB
18637	3924	15	to	to	IN
18637	3924	16	the	the	DT
18637	3924	17	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	3924	18	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	3924	19	which	which	WDT
18637	3924	20	arose	arise	VBD
18637	3924	21	over	over	IN
18637	3924	22	the	the	DT
18637	3924	23	ill	ill	RB
18637	3924	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	3924	25	defined	define	VBN
18637	3924	26	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	3924	27	of	of	IN
18637	3924	28	the	the	DT
18637	3924	29	original	original	JJ
18637	3924	30	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	3924	31	.	.	.
18637	3925	1	These	these	DT
18637	3925	2	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	3925	3	were	be	VBD
18637	3925	4	usually	usually	RB
18637	3925	5	resolved	resolve	VBN
18637	3925	6	by	by	IN
18637	3925	7	negotiation	negotiation	NN
18637	3925	8	,	,	,
18637	3925	9	with	with	IN
18637	3925	10	the	the	DT
18637	3925	11	resulting	result	VBG
18637	3925	12	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3925	13	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3925	14	to	to	IN
18637	3925	15	approval	approval	NN
18637	3925	16	by	by	IN
18637	3925	17	the	the	DT
18637	3925	18	Crown	Crown	NNP
18637	3925	19	.	.	.
18637	3926	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3926	2	1778	1778	CD
18637	3926	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3926	4	When	when	WRB
18637	3926	5	the	the	DT
18637	3926	6	political	political	JJ
18637	3926	7	ties	tie	NNS
18637	3926	8	with	with	IN
18637	3926	9	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	3926	10	were	be	VBD
18637	3926	11	broken	break	VBN
18637	3926	12	the	the	DT
18637	3926	13	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	3926	14	of	of	IN
18637	3926	15	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	3926	16	provided	provide	VBD
18637	3926	17	for	for	IN
18637	3926	18	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	3926	19	to	to	IN
18637	3926	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3926	21	in	in	IN
18637	3926	22	all	all	DT
18637	3926	23	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	3926	24	between	between	IN
18637	3926	25	two	two	CD
18637	3926	26	or	or	CC
18637	3926	27	more	more	JJR
18637	3926	28	States	state	NNS
18637	3926	29	over	over	IN
18637	3926	30	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	3926	31	or	or	CC
18637	3926	32	"	"	``
18637	3926	33	any	any	DT
18637	3926	34	cause	cause	NN
18637	3926	35	whatever"[1779	whatever"[1779	NNS
18637	3926	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3926	37	and	and	CC
18637	3926	38	required	require	VBD
18637	3926	39	the	the	DT
18637	3926	40	approval	approval	NN
18637	3926	41	of	of	IN
18637	3926	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3926	43	for	for	IN
18637	3926	44	any	any	DT
18637	3926	45	"	"	``
18637	3926	46	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	3926	47	confederation	confederation	NN
18637	3926	48	or	or	CC
18637	3926	49	alliance	alliance	NN
18637	3926	50	"	"	''
18637	3926	51	to	to	TO
18637	3926	52	which	which	WDT
18637	3926	53	a	a	DT
18637	3926	54	State	state	NN
18637	3926	55	should	should	MD
18637	3926	56	be	be	VB
18637	3926	57	a	a	DT
18637	3926	58	party	party	NN
18637	3926	59	.	.	.
18637	3927	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3927	2	1780	1780	CD
18637	3927	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3927	4	The	the	DT
18637	3927	5	framers	framer	NNS
18637	3927	6	of	of	IN
18637	3927	7	the	the	DT
18637	3927	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3927	9	went	go	VBD
18637	3927	10	further	far	RBR
18637	3927	11	.	.	.
18637	3928	1	By	by	IN
18637	3928	2	the	the	DT
18637	3928	3	first	first	JJ
18637	3928	4	clause	clause	NN
18637	3928	5	of	of	IN
18637	3928	6	this	this	DT
18637	3928	7	section	section	NN
18637	3928	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3928	9	laid	lay	VBD
18637	3928	10	down	down	RP
18637	3928	11	an	an	DT
18637	3928	12	unqualified	unqualified	JJ
18637	3928	13	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3928	14	against	against	IN
18637	3928	15	"	"	``
18637	3928	16	any	any	DT
18637	3928	17	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	3928	18	,	,	,
18637	3928	19	alliance	alliance	NN
18637	3928	20	or	or	CC
18637	3928	21	confederation	confederation	NN
18637	3928	22	"	"	''
18637	3928	23	;	;	,
18637	3928	24	and	and	CC
18637	3928	25	by	by	IN
18637	3928	26	the	the	DT
18637	3928	27	third	third	JJ
18637	3928	28	clause	clause	NN
18637	3928	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3928	30	required	require	VBD
18637	3928	31	the	the	DT
18637	3928	32	consent	consent	NN
18637	3928	33	of	of	IN
18637	3928	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3928	35	for	for	IN
18637	3928	36	"	"	``
18637	3928	37	any	any	DT
18637	3928	38	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3928	39	or	or	CC
18637	3928	40	compact	compact	JJ
18637	3928	41	.	.	.
18637	3928	42	"	"	''
18637	3929	1	The	the	DT
18637	3929	2	significance	significance	NN
18637	3929	3	of	of	IN
18637	3929	4	this	this	DT
18637	3929	5	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	3929	6	was	be	VBD
18637	3929	7	pointed	point	VBN
18637	3929	8	out	out	RP
18637	3929	9	by	by	IN
18637	3929	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3929	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3929	12	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	3929	13	in	in	IN
18637	3929	14	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	3929	15	_	_	NNP
18637	3929	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	3929	17	_	_	NNP
18637	3929	18	Jennison	Jennison	NNP
18637	3929	19	.	.	.
18637	3930	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3930	2	1781	1781	CD
18637	3930	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3930	4	"	"	``
18637	3930	5	As	as	IN
18637	3930	6	these	these	DT
18637	3930	7	words	word	NNS
18637	3930	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3930	9	'	'	``
18637	3930	10	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3930	11	or	or	CC
18637	3930	12	compact	compact	JJ
18637	3930	13	'	'	''
18637	3930	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3930	15	could	could	MD
18637	3930	16	not	not	RB
18637	3930	17	have	have	VB
18637	3930	18	been	be	VBN
18637	3930	19	idly	idly	RB
18637	3930	20	or	or	CC
18637	3930	21	superfluously	superfluously	RB
18637	3930	22	used	use	VBN
18637	3930	23	by	by	IN
18637	3930	24	the	the	DT
18637	3930	25	framers	framer	NNS
18637	3930	26	of	of	IN
18637	3930	27	the	the	DT
18637	3930	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3930	29	,	,	,
18637	3930	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3930	31	can	can	MD
18637	3930	32	not	not	RB
18637	3930	33	be	be	VB
18637	3930	34	construed	construe	VBN
18637	3930	35	to	to	TO
18637	3930	36	mean	mean	VB
18637	3930	37	the	the	DT
18637	3930	38	same	same	JJ
18637	3930	39	thing	thing	NN
18637	3930	40	with	with	IN
18637	3930	41	the	the	DT
18637	3930	42	word	word	NN
18637	3930	43	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	3930	44	.	.	.
18637	3931	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3931	2	evidently	evidently	RB
18637	3931	3	mean	mean	VBP
18637	3931	4	something	something	NN
18637	3931	5	more	more	JJR
18637	3931	6	,	,	,
18637	3931	7	and	and	CC
18637	3931	8	were	be	VBD
18637	3931	9	designed	design	VBN
18637	3931	10	to	to	TO
18637	3931	11	make	make	VB
18637	3931	12	the	the	DT
18637	3931	13	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3931	14	more	more	RBR
18637	3931	15	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	3931	16	.	.	.
18637	3932	1	*	*	NFP
18637	3932	2	*	*	NFP
18637	3932	3	*	*	NFP
18637	3932	4	The	the	DT
18637	3932	5	word	word	NN
18637	3932	6	'	'	''
18637	3932	7	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3932	8	,	,	,
18637	3932	9	'	'	''
18637	3932	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	3932	11	not	not	RB
18637	3932	12	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	3932	13	import	import	VB
18637	3932	14	and	and	CC
18637	3932	15	direct	direct	VB
18637	3932	16	any	any	DT
18637	3932	17	express	express	JJ
18637	3932	18	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	3932	19	;	;	:
18637	3932	20	nor	nor	CC
18637	3932	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	3932	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3932	23	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3932	24	that	that	IN
18637	3932	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3932	26	should	should	MD
18637	3932	27	be	be	VB
18637	3932	28	in	in	IN
18637	3932	29	writing	writing	NN
18637	3932	30	.	.	.
18637	3933	1	If	if	IN
18637	3933	2	there	there	EX
18637	3933	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	3933	4	a	a	DT
18637	3933	5	verbal	verbal	JJ
18637	3933	6	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	3933	7	,	,	,
18637	3933	8	to	to	TO
18637	3933	9	which	which	WDT
18637	3933	10	both	both	DT
18637	3933	11	parties	party	NNS
18637	3933	12	have	have	VBP
18637	3933	13	assented	assent	VBN
18637	3933	14	,	,	,
18637	3933	15	and	and	CC
18637	3933	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	3933	17	which	which	WDT
18637	3933	18	both	both	DT
18637	3933	19	are	be	VBP
18637	3933	20	acting	act	VBG
18637	3933	21	,	,	,
18637	3933	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3933	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	3933	24	an	an	DT
18637	3933	25	'	'	``
18637	3933	26	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3933	27	.	.	.
18637	3933	28	'	'	''
18637	3934	1	And	and	CC
18637	3934	2	the	the	DT
18637	3934	3	use	use	NN
18637	3934	4	of	of	IN
18637	3934	5	all	all	DT
18637	3934	6	of	of	IN
18637	3934	7	these	these	DT
18637	3934	8	terms	term	NNS
18637	3934	9	,	,	,
18637	3934	10	'	'	''
18637	3934	11	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	3934	12	,	,	,
18637	3934	13	'	'	''
18637	3934	14	'	'	''
18637	3934	15	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3934	16	,	,	,
18637	3934	17	'	'	''
18637	3934	18	'	'	``
18637	3934	19	compact	compact	JJ
18637	3934	20	,	,	,
18637	3934	21	'	'	''
18637	3934	22	show	show	VBP
18637	3934	23	that	that	IN
18637	3934	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3934	25	was	be	VBD
18637	3934	26	the	the	DT
18637	3934	27	intention	intention	NN
18637	3934	28	of	of	IN
18637	3934	29	the	the	DT
18637	3934	30	framers	framer	NNS
18637	3934	31	of	of	IN
18637	3934	32	the	the	DT
18637	3934	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3934	34	to	to	TO
18637	3934	35	use	use	VB
18637	3934	36	the	the	DT
18637	3934	37	broadest	broad	JJS
18637	3934	38	and	and	CC
18637	3934	39	most	most	RBS
18637	3934	40	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	3934	41	terms	term	NNS
18637	3934	42	;	;	:
18637	3934	43	and	and	CC
18637	3934	44	that	that	IN
18637	3934	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3934	46	anxiously	anxiously	RB
18637	3934	47	desired	desire	VBD
18637	3934	48	to	to	TO
18637	3934	49	cut	cut	VB
18637	3934	50	off	off	RP
18637	3934	51	all	all	DT
18637	3934	52	connection	connection	NN
18637	3934	53	or	or	CC
18637	3934	54	communication	communication	NN
18637	3934	55	between	between	IN
18637	3934	56	a	a	DT
18637	3934	57	State	state	NN
18637	3934	58	and	and	CC
18637	3934	59	a	a	DT
18637	3934	60	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3934	61	power	power	NN
18637	3934	62	;	;	:
18637	3934	63	and	and	CC
18637	3934	64	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3934	65	shall	shall	MD
18637	3934	66	fail	fail	VB
18637	3934	67	to	to	TO
18637	3934	68	execute	execute	VB
18637	3934	69	that	that	DT
18637	3934	70	evident	evident	JJ
18637	3934	71	intention	intention	NN
18637	3934	72	,	,	,
18637	3934	73	unless	unless	IN
18637	3934	74	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3934	75	give	give	VBP
18637	3934	76	to	to	IN
18637	3934	77	the	the	DT
18637	3934	78	word	word	NN
18637	3934	79	'	'	``
18637	3934	80	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3934	81	'	'	''
18637	3934	82	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3934	83	most	most	RBS
18637	3934	84	extended	extended	JJ
18637	3934	85	signification	signification	NN
18637	3934	86	;	;	:
18637	3934	87	and	and	CC
18637	3934	88	so	so	RB
18637	3934	89	apply	apply	VB
18637	3934	90	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3934	91	as	as	IN
18637	3934	92	to	to	TO
18637	3934	93	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	3934	94	every	every	DT
18637	3934	95	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3934	96	,	,	,
18637	3934	97	written	write	VBN
18637	3934	98	or	or	CC
18637	3934	99	verbal	verbal	JJ
18637	3934	100	,	,	,
18637	3934	101	formal	formal	JJ
18637	3934	102	or	or	CC
18637	3934	103	informal	informal	JJ
18637	3934	104	,	,	,
18637	3934	105	positive	positive	JJ
18637	3934	106	or	or	CC
18637	3934	107	implied	imply	VBN
18637	3934	108	,	,	,
18637	3934	109	by	by	IN
18637	3934	110	the	the	DT
18637	3934	111	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	3934	112	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	3934	113	of	of	IN
18637	3934	114	the	the	DT
18637	3934	115	parties	party	NNS
18637	3934	116	.	.	.
18637	3935	1	"	"	``
18637	3935	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3935	3	1782	1782	CD
18637	3935	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3935	5	But	but	CC
18637	3935	6	in	in	IN
18637	3935	7	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	3935	8	_	_	NNP
18637	3935	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	3935	10	_	_	NNP
18637	3935	11	Tennessee,[1783	Tennessee,[1783	NNP
18637	3935	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3935	13	decided	decide	VBD
18637	3935	14	more	more	JJR
18637	3935	15	than	than	IN
18637	3935	16	a	a	DT
18637	3935	17	half	half	JJ
18637	3935	18	century	century	NN
18637	3935	19	later	later	RB
18637	3935	20	,	,	,
18637	3935	21	the	the	DT
18637	3935	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3935	23	shifted	shift	VBD
18637	3935	24	position	position	NN
18637	3935	25	,	,	,
18637	3935	26	holding	hold	VBG
18637	3935	27	that	that	IN
18637	3935	28	the	the	DT
18637	3935	29	unqualified	unqualified	JJ
18637	3935	30	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3935	31	of	of	IN
18637	3935	32	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	3935	33	and	and	CC
18637	3935	34	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	3935	35	between	between	IN
18637	3935	36	States	state	NNS
18637	3935	37	without	without	IN
18637	3935	38	the	the	DT
18637	3935	39	consent	consent	NN
18637	3935	40	of	of	IN
18637	3935	41	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3935	42	did	do	VBD
18637	3935	43	not	not	RB
18637	3935	44	apply	apply	VB
18637	3935	45	to	to	IN
18637	3935	46	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	3935	47	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	3935	48	such	such	JJ
18637	3935	49	minor	minor	JJ
18637	3935	50	matters	matter	NNS
18637	3935	51	as	as	IN
18637	3935	52	adjustments	adjustment	NNS
18637	3935	53	of	of	IN
18637	3935	54	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	3935	55	,	,	,
18637	3935	56	which	which	WDT
18637	3935	57	have	have	VBP
18637	3935	58	no	no	DT
18637	3935	59	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	3935	60	to	to	TO
18637	3935	61	increase	increase	VB
18637	3935	62	the	the	DT
18637	3935	63	political	political	JJ
18637	3935	64	powers	power	NNS
18637	3935	65	of	of	IN
18637	3935	66	the	the	DT
18637	3935	67	contractant	contractant	JJ
18637	3935	68	States	state	NNS
18637	3935	69	or	or	CC
18637	3935	70	to	to	TO
18637	3935	71	encroach	encroach	VB
18637	3935	72	upon	upon	IN
18637	3935	73	the	the	DT
18637	3935	74	just	just	JJ
18637	3935	75	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	3935	76	of	of	IN
18637	3935	77	the	the	DT
18637	3935	78	United	United	NNP
18637	3935	79	States	States	NNP
18637	3935	80	.	.	.
18637	3936	1	This	this	DT
18637	3936	2	divergence	divergence	NN
18637	3936	3	of	of	IN
18637	3936	4	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	3936	5	may	may	MD
18637	3936	6	conceivably	conceivably	RB
18637	3936	7	have	have	VB
18637	3936	8	interesting	interesting	JJ
18637	3936	9	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	3936	10	.	.	.
18637	3937	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3937	2	1784	1784	CD
18637	3937	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3937	4	Subject	subject	JJ
18637	3937	5	Matter	Matter	NNP
18637	3937	6	of	of	IN
18637	3937	7	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	3937	8	Compacts	compact	NNS
18637	3937	9	For	for	IN
18637	3937	10	many	many	JJ
18637	3937	11	years	year	NNS
18637	3937	12	after	after	IN
18637	3937	13	the	the	DT
18637	3937	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3937	15	was	be	VBD
18637	3937	16	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	3937	17	,	,	,
18637	3937	18	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	3937	19	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	3937	20	continued	continue	VBD
18637	3937	21	to	to	TO
18637	3937	22	predominate	predominate	VB
18637	3937	23	as	as	IN
18637	3937	24	the	the	DT
18637	3937	25	subject	subject	JJ
18637	3937	26	matter	matter	NN
18637	3937	27	of	of	IN
18637	3937	28	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	3937	29	among	among	IN
18637	3937	30	the	the	DT
18637	3937	31	States	States	NNP
18637	3937	32	.	.	.
18637	3938	1	Since	since	IN
18637	3938	2	the	the	DT
18637	3938	3	turn	turn	NN
18637	3938	4	of	of	IN
18637	3938	5	the	the	DT
18637	3938	6	twentieth	twentieth	JJ
18637	3938	7	century	century	NN
18637	3938	8	,	,	,
18637	3938	9	however	however	RB
18637	3938	10	,	,	,
18637	3938	11	the	the	DT
18637	3938	12	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	3938	13	compact	compact	NN
18637	3938	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	3938	15	been	be	VBN
18637	3938	16	used	use	VBN
18637	3938	17	to	to	IN
18637	3938	18	an	an	DT
18637	3938	19	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	3938	20	extent	extent	NN
18637	3938	21	as	as	IN
18637	3938	22	an	an	DT
18637	3938	23	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	3938	24	for	for	IN
18637	3938	25	State	State	NNP
18637	3938	26	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	3938	27	in	in	IN
18637	3938	28	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	3938	29	out	out	RP
18637	3938	30	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	3938	31	programs	program	NNS
18637	3938	32	for	for	IN
18637	3938	33	solving	solve	VBG
18637	3938	34	common	common	JJ
18637	3938	35	problems	problem	NNS
18637	3938	36	.	.	.
18637	3939	1	The	the	DT
18637	3939	2	execution	execution	NN
18637	3939	3	of	of	IN
18637	3939	4	vast	vast	JJ
18637	3939	5	public	public	JJ
18637	3939	6	undertakings	undertaking	NNS
18637	3939	7	,	,	,
18637	3939	8	such	such	JJ
18637	3939	9	as	as	IN
18637	3939	10	the	the	DT
18637	3939	11	development	development	NN
18637	3939	12	of	of	IN
18637	3939	13	the	the	DT
18637	3939	14	Port	Port	NNP
18637	3939	15	of	of	IN
18637	3939	16	New	New	NNP
18637	3939	17	York	York	NNP
18637	3939	18	by	by	IN
18637	3939	19	the	the	DT
18637	3939	20	Port	Port	NNP
18637	3939	21	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	3939	22	created	create	VBN
18637	3939	23	by	by	IN
18637	3939	24	compact	compact	NN
18637	3939	25	between	between	IN
18637	3939	26	New	New	NNP
18637	3939	27	York	York	NNP
18637	3939	28	and	and	CC
18637	3939	29	New	New	NNP
18637	3939	30	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	3939	31	,	,	,
18637	3939	32	flood	flood	NN
18637	3939	33	control	control	NN
18637	3939	34	,	,	,
18637	3939	35	the	the	DT
18637	3939	36	prevention	prevention	NN
18637	3939	37	of	of	IN
18637	3939	38	pollution	pollution	NN
18637	3939	39	,	,	,
18637	3939	40	and	and	CC
18637	3939	41	the	the	DT
18637	3939	42	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	3939	43	and	and	CC
18637	3939	44	allocation	allocation	NN
18637	3939	45	of	of	IN
18637	3939	46	water	water	NN
18637	3939	47	supplied	supply	VBN
18637	3939	48	by	by	IN
18637	3939	49	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	3939	50	streams	stream	NNS
18637	3939	51	,	,	,
18637	3939	52	are	be	VBP
18637	3939	53	among	among	IN
18637	3939	54	the	the	DT
18637	3939	55	objectives	objective	NNS
18637	3939	56	accomplished	accomplish	VBN
18637	3939	57	by	by	IN
18637	3939	58	this	this	DT
18637	3939	59	means	mean	VBZ
18637	3939	60	.	.	.
18637	3940	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3940	2	1785	1785	CD
18637	3940	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3940	4	Another	another	DT
18637	3940	5	important	important	JJ
18637	3940	6	use	use	NN
18637	3940	7	of	of	IN
18637	3940	8	this	this	DT
18637	3940	9	device	device	NN
18637	3940	10	was	be	VBD
18637	3940	11	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	3940	12	by	by	IN
18637	3940	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3940	14	in	in	IN
18637	3940	15	the	the	DT
18637	3940	16	act	act	NN
18637	3940	17	of	of	IN
18637	3940	18	June	June	NNP
18637	3940	19	6	6	CD
18637	3940	20	,	,	,
18637	3940	21	1934,[1786	1934,[1786	CD
18637	3940	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3940	23	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	3940	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3940	25	consented	consent	VBD
18637	3940	26	in	in	IN
18637	3940	27	advance	advance	NN
18637	3940	28	to	to	IN
18637	3940	29	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	3940	30	for	for	IN
18637	3940	31	the	the	DT
18637	3940	32	control	control	NN
18637	3940	33	of	of	IN
18637	3940	34	crime	crime	NN
18637	3940	35	.	.	.
18637	3941	1	The	the	DT
18637	3941	2	first	first	JJ
18637	3941	3	response	response	NN
18637	3941	4	to	to	IN
18637	3941	5	this	this	DT
18637	3941	6	stimulus	stimulus	NN
18637	3941	7	was	be	VBD
18637	3941	8	the	the	DT
18637	3941	9	Crime	Crime	NNP
18637	3941	10	Compact	Compact	NNP
18637	3941	11	of	of	IN
18637	3941	12	1934	1934	CD
18637	3941	13	,	,	,
18637	3941	14	providing	provide	VBG
18637	3941	15	for	for	IN
18637	3941	16	the	the	DT
18637	3941	17	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	3941	18	of	of	IN
18637	3941	19	parolees	parolee	NNS
18637	3941	20	and	and	CC
18637	3941	21	probationers	probationer	NNS
18637	3941	22	,	,	,
18637	3941	23	to	to	IN
18637	3941	24	which	which	WDT
18637	3941	25	forty	forty	CD
18637	3941	26	-	-	HYPH
18637	3941	27	five	five	CD
18637	3941	28	States	state	NNS
18637	3941	29	had	have	VBD
18637	3941	30	given	give	VBN
18637	3941	31	adherence	adherence	NN
18637	3941	32	by	by	IN
18637	3941	33	1949	1949	CD
18637	3941	34	.	.	.
18637	3942	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3942	2	1787	1787	CD
18637	3942	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3942	4	Subsequently	Subsequently	NNP
18637	3942	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3942	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	3942	7	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	3942	8	,	,	,
18637	3942	9	on	on	IN
18637	3942	10	varying	vary	VBG
18637	3942	11	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	3942	12	,	,	,
18637	3942	13	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	3942	14	touching	touch	VBG
18637	3942	15	the	the	DT
18637	3942	16	production	production	NN
18637	3942	17	of	of	IN
18637	3942	18	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	3942	19	,	,	,
18637	3942	20	the	the	DT
18637	3942	21	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	3942	22	of	of	IN
18637	3942	23	natural	natural	JJ
18637	3942	24	gas	gas	NN
18637	3942	25	,	,	,
18637	3942	26	the	the	DT
18637	3942	27	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	3942	28	of	of	IN
18637	3942	29	fishing	fishing	NN
18637	3942	30	in	in	IN
18637	3942	31	inland	inland	JJ
18637	3942	32	waters	water	NNS
18637	3942	33	,	,	,
18637	3942	34	the	the	DT
18637	3942	35	furtherance	furtherance	NN
18637	3942	36	of	of	IN
18637	3942	37	flood	flood	NN
18637	3942	38	and	and	CC
18637	3942	39	pollution	pollution	NN
18637	3942	40	control	control	NN
18637	3942	41	,	,	,
18637	3942	42	and	and	CC
18637	3942	43	other	other	JJ
18637	3942	44	matters	matter	NNS
18637	3942	45	.	.	.
18637	3943	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	3943	2	,	,	,
18637	3943	3	since	since	IN
18637	3943	4	1935	1935	CD
18637	3943	5	at	at	IN
18637	3943	6	least	least	JJS
18637	3943	7	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	3943	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	3943	9	six	six	CD
18637	3943	10	States	state	NNS
18637	3943	11	,	,	,
18637	3943	12	beginning	begin	VBG
18637	3943	13	with	with	IN
18637	3943	14	New	New	NNP
18637	3943	15	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	3943	16	,	,	,
18637	3943	17	have	have	VBP
18637	3943	18	set	set	VBN
18637	3943	19	up	up	RP
18637	3943	20	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	3943	21	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	3943	22	for	for	IN
18637	3943	23	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	3943	24	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	3943	25	,	,	,
18637	3943	26	which	which	WDT
18637	3943	27	have	have	VBP
18637	3943	28	led	lead	VBN
18637	3943	29	to	to	IN
18637	3943	30	the	the	DT
18637	3943	31	formation	formation	NN
18637	3943	32	of	of	IN
18637	3943	33	a	a	DT
18637	3943	34	Council	Council	NNP
18637	3943	35	of	of	IN
18637	3943	36	State	State	NNP
18637	3943	37	Governments	Governments	NNPS
18637	3943	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3943	39	"	"	``
18637	3943	40	Cosgo	Cosgo	NNP
18637	3943	41	"	"	''
18637	3943	42	for	for	IN
18637	3943	43	short	short	JJ
18637	3943	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3943	45	,	,	,
18637	3943	46	the	the	DT
18637	3943	47	creation	creation	NN
18637	3943	48	of	of	IN
18637	3943	49	special	special	JJ
18637	3943	50	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	3943	51	for	for	IN
18637	3943	52	the	the	DT
18637	3943	53	study	study	NN
18637	3943	54	of	of	IN
18637	3943	55	the	the	DT
18637	3943	56	crime	crime	NN
18637	3943	57	problem	problem	NN
18637	3943	58	,	,	,
18637	3943	59	the	the	DT
18637	3943	60	problem	problem	NN
18637	3943	61	of	of	IN
18637	3943	62	highway	highway	NN
18637	3943	63	safety	safety	NN
18637	3943	64	,	,	,
18637	3943	65	the	the	DT
18637	3943	66	trailer	trailer	NN
18637	3943	67	problem	problem	NN
18637	3943	68	,	,	,
18637	3943	69	problems	problem	NNS
18637	3943	70	created	create	VBN
18637	3943	71	by	by	IN
18637	3943	72	social	social	JJ
18637	3943	73	security	security	NN
18637	3943	74	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3943	75	,	,	,
18637	3943	76	etc	etc	FW
18637	3943	77	.	.	FW
18637	3943	78	,	,	,
18637	3943	79	and	and	CC
18637	3943	80	the	the	DT
18637	3943	81	framing	framing	NN
18637	3943	82	of	of	IN
18637	3943	83	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	3943	84	State	State	NNP
18637	3943	85	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3943	86	for	for	IN
18637	3943	87	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	3943	88	with	with	IN
18637	3943	89	some	some	DT
18637	3943	90	of	of	IN
18637	3943	91	these	these	DT
18637	3943	92	.	.	.
18637	3944	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3944	2	1788	1788	CD
18637	3944	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3944	4	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	3944	5	of	of	IN
18637	3944	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3944	7	The	the	DT
18637	3944	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	3944	9	makes	make	VBZ
18637	3944	10	no	no	DT
18637	3944	11	provision	provision	NN
18637	3944	12	as	as	IN
18637	3944	13	to	to	IN
18637	3944	14	the	the	DT
18637	3944	15	time	time	NN
18637	3944	16	when	when	WRB
18637	3944	17	the	the	DT
18637	3944	18	consent	consent	NN
18637	3944	19	of	of	IN
18637	3944	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3944	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	3944	22	be	be	VB
18637	3944	23	given	give	VBN
18637	3944	24	or	or	CC
18637	3944	25	the	the	DT
18637	3944	26	mode	mode	NN
18637	3944	27	or	or	CC
18637	3944	28	form	form	NN
18637	3944	29	by	by	IN
18637	3944	30	which	which	WDT
18637	3944	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3944	32	shall	shall	MD
18637	3944	33	be	be	VB
18637	3944	34	signified	signify	VBN
18637	3944	35	.	.	.
18637	3945	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3945	2	1789	1789	CD
18637	3945	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3945	4	While	while	IN
18637	3945	5	the	the	DT
18637	3945	6	consent	consent	NN
18637	3945	7	will	will	MD
18637	3945	8	usually	usually	RB
18637	3945	9	precede	precede	VB
18637	3945	10	the	the	DT
18637	3945	11	compact	compact	JJ
18637	3945	12	or	or	CC
18637	3945	13	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3945	14	,	,	,
18637	3945	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3945	16	may	may	MD
18637	3945	17	be	be	VB
18637	3945	18	given	give	VBN
18637	3945	19	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	3945	20	where	where	WRB
18637	3945	21	the	the	DT
18637	3945	22	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3945	23	relates	relate	VBZ
18637	3945	24	to	to	IN
18637	3945	25	a	a	DT
18637	3945	26	matter	matter	NN
18637	3945	27	which	which	WDT
18637	3945	28	could	could	MD
18637	3945	29	not	not	RB
18637	3945	30	be	be	VB
18637	3945	31	well	well	RB
18637	3945	32	considered	consider	VBN
18637	3945	33	until	until	IN
18637	3945	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3945	35	nature	nature	NN
18637	3945	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	3945	37	fully	fully	RB
18637	3945	38	developed	develop	VBN
18637	3945	39	.	.	.
18637	3946	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3946	2	1790	1790	CD
18637	3946	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3946	4	The	the	DT
18637	3946	5	required	require	VBN
18637	3946	6	consent	consent	NN
18637	3946	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	3946	8	not	not	RB
18637	3946	9	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	3946	10	an	an	DT
18637	3946	11	expressed	express	VBN
18637	3946	12	consent	consent	NN
18637	3946	13	;	;	:
18637	3946	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3946	15	may	may	MD
18637	3946	16	be	be	VB
18637	3946	17	inferred	infer	VBN
18637	3946	18	from	from	IN
18637	3946	19	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	3946	20	.	.	.
18637	3947	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3947	2	1791	1791	CD
18637	3947	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3947	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3947	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	3947	6	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	3947	7	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	3947	8	,	,	,
18637	3947	9	when	when	WRB
18637	3947	10	not	not	RB
18637	3947	11	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	3947	12	to	to	TO
18637	3947	13	be	be	VB
18637	3947	14	made	make	VBN
18637	3947	15	in	in	IN
18637	3947	16	advance	advance	NN
18637	3947	17	,	,	,
18637	3947	18	by	by	IN
18637	3947	19	the	the	DT
18637	3947	20	approval	approval	NN
18637	3947	21	of	of	IN
18637	3947	22	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	3947	23	taken	take	VBN
18637	3947	24	under	under	IN
18637	3947	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3947	26	.	.	.
18637	3948	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3948	2	1792	1792	CD
18637	3948	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3948	4	The	the	DT
18637	3948	5	consent	consent	NN
18637	3948	6	of	of	IN
18637	3948	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3948	8	may	may	MD
18637	3948	9	be	be	VB
18637	3948	10	granted	grant	VBN
18637	3948	11	conditionally	conditionally	RB
18637	3948	12	"	"	''
18637	3948	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	3948	14	terms	term	NNS
18637	3948	15	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	3948	16	to	to	IN
18637	3948	17	the	the	DT
18637	3948	18	subject	subject	NN
18637	3948	19	and	and	CC
18637	3948	20	transgressing	transgress	VBG
18637	3948	21	no	no	DT
18637	3948	22	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3948	23	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	3948	24	.	.	.
18637	3949	1	"	"	``
18637	3949	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3949	3	1793	1793	CD
18637	3949	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3949	5	And	and	CC
18637	3949	6	in	in	IN
18637	3949	7	a	a	DT
18637	3949	8	recent	recent	JJ
18637	3949	9	instance	instance	NN
18637	3949	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3949	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	3949	12	not	not	RB
18637	3949	13	been	be	VBN
18637	3949	14	forthcoming	forthcoming	JJ
18637	3949	15	at	at	RB
18637	3949	16	all	all	RB
18637	3949	17	.	.	.
18637	3950	1	In	in	IN
18637	3950	2	Sipuel	Sipuel	NNP
18637	3950	3	_	_	NNP
18637	3950	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	3950	5	_	_	NNP
18637	3950	6	Board	Board	NNP
18637	3950	7	of	of	IN
18637	3950	8	Regents,[1794	Regents,[1794	NNP
18637	3950	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3950	10	decided	decide	VBD
18637	3950	11	in	in	IN
18637	3950	12	1948	1948	CD
18637	3950	13	,	,	,
18637	3950	14	the	the	DT
18637	3950	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3950	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3950	17	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	3950	18	that	that	IN
18637	3950	19	the	the	DT
18637	3950	20	equal	equal	JJ
18637	3950	21	protection	protection	NN
18637	3950	22	clause	clause	NN
18637	3950	23	of	of	IN
18637	3950	24	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	3950	25	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	3950	26	requires	require	VBZ
18637	3950	27	a	a	DT
18637	3950	28	State	state	NN
18637	3950	29	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	3950	30	a	a	DT
18637	3950	31	law	law	NN
18637	3950	32	school	school	NN
18637	3950	33	for	for	IN
18637	3950	34	white	white	JJ
18637	3950	35	students	student	NNS
18637	3950	36	to	to	TO
18637	3950	37	provide	provide	VB
18637	3950	38	legal	legal	JJ
18637	3950	39	education	education	NN
18637	3950	40	for	for	IN
18637	3950	41	a	a	DT
18637	3950	42	Negro	negro	JJ
18637	3950	43	applicant	applicant	NN
18637	3950	44	,	,	,
18637	3950	45	and	and	CC
18637	3950	46	to	to	TO
18637	3950	47	do	do	VB
18637	3950	48	so	so	RB
18637	3950	49	as	as	RB
18637	3950	50	soon	soon	RB
18637	3950	51	as	as	IN
18637	3950	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3950	53	does	do	VBZ
18637	3950	54	for	for	IN
18637	3950	55	applicants	applicant	NNS
18637	3950	56	of	of	IN
18637	3950	57	any	any	DT
18637	3950	58	other	other	JJ
18637	3950	59	group	group	NN
18637	3950	60	.	.	.
18637	3951	1	Shortly	shortly	RB
18637	3951	2	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	3951	3	the	the	DT
18637	3951	4	governors	governor	NNS
18637	3951	5	of	of	IN
18637	3951	6	12	12	CD
18637	3951	7	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	3951	8	States	States	NNPS
18637	3951	9	convened	convene	VBD
18637	3951	10	to	to	IN
18637	3951	11	canvass	canvass	NN
18637	3951	12	methods	method	NNS
18637	3951	13	for	for	IN
18637	3951	14	meeting	meet	VBG
18637	3951	15	the	the	DT
18637	3951	16	demands	demand	NNS
18637	3951	17	of	of	IN
18637	3951	18	the	the	DT
18637	3951	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3951	20	.	.	.
18637	3952	1	There	there	EX
18637	3952	2	resulted	result	VBD
18637	3952	3	a	a	DT
18637	3952	4	compact	compact	NN
18637	3952	5	to	to	TO
18637	3952	6	which	which	WDT
18637	3952	7	13	13	CD
18637	3952	8	State	state	NN
18637	3952	9	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	3952	10	have	have	VBP
18637	3952	11	consented	consent	VBN
18637	3952	12	and	and	CC
18637	3952	13	by	by	IN
18637	3952	14	which	which	WDT
18637	3952	15	a	a	DT
18637	3952	16	Board	Board	NNP
18637	3952	17	of	of	IN
18637	3952	18	Control	Control	NNP
18637	3952	19	for	for	IN
18637	3952	20	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	3952	21	Regional	Regional	NNP
18637	3952	22	Education	Education	NNP
18637	3952	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	3952	24	set	set	VBN
18637	3952	25	up	up	RP
18637	3952	26	.	.	.
18637	3953	1	Although	although	IN
18637	3953	2	some	some	DT
18637	3953	3	early	early	JJ
18637	3953	4	steps	step	NNS
18637	3953	5	were	be	VBD
18637	3953	6	taken	take	VBN
18637	3953	7	toward	toward	IN
18637	3953	8	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	3953	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3953	10	's	's	POS
18637	3953	11	consent	consent	NN
18637	3953	12	to	to	IN
18637	3953	13	the	the	DT
18637	3953	14	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3953	15	,	,	,
18637	3953	16	the	the	DT
18637	3953	17	effort	effort	NN
18637	3953	18	was	be	VBD
18637	3953	19	soon	soon	RB
18637	3953	20	abandoned	abandon	VBN
18637	3953	21	,	,	,
18637	3953	22	but	but	CC
18637	3953	23	without	without	IN
18637	3953	24	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	3953	25	the	the	DT
18637	3953	26	cooperative	cooperative	JJ
18637	3953	27	educational	educational	JJ
18637	3953	28	program	program	NN
18637	3953	29	,	,	,
18637	3953	30	which	which	WDT
18637	3953	31	to	to	IN
18637	3953	32	date	date	NN
18637	3953	33	has	have	VBZ
18637	3953	34	not	not	RB
18637	3953	35	been	be	VBN
18637	3953	36	extended	extend	VBN
18637	3953	37	to	to	IN
18637	3953	38	the	the	DT
18637	3953	39	question	question	NN
18637	3953	40	of	of	IN
18637	3953	41	racial	racial	JJ
18637	3953	42	segregation	segregation	NN
18637	3953	43	.	.	.
18637	3954	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3954	2	1795	1795	CD
18637	3954	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3954	4	Finally	finally	RB
18637	3954	5	,	,	,
18637	3954	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3954	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	3954	8	not	not	RB
18637	3954	9	,	,	,
18637	3954	10	by	by	IN
18637	3954	11	giving	give	VBG
18637	3954	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3954	13	consent	consent	NN
18637	3954	14	to	to	IN
18637	3954	15	a	a	DT
18637	3954	16	compact	compact	JJ
18637	3954	17	,	,	,
18637	3954	18	relinquish	relinquish	VB
18637	3954	19	or	or	CC
18637	3954	20	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	3954	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3954	22	own	own	JJ
18637	3954	23	powers	power	NNS
18637	3954	24	,	,	,
18637	3954	25	as	as	IN
18637	3954	26	for	for	IN
18637	3954	27	example	example	NN
18637	3954	28	,	,	,
18637	3954	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3954	30	power	power	NN
18637	3954	31	to	to	TO
18637	3954	32	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	3954	33	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	3954	34	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	3954	35	.	.	.
18637	3955	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3955	2	1796	1796	CD
18637	3955	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3955	4	Grants	Grants	NNPS
18637	3955	5	of	of	IN
18637	3955	6	Franchise	Franchise	NNP
18637	3955	7	to	to	IN
18637	3955	8	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	3955	9	by	by	IN
18637	3955	10	Two	two	CD
18637	3955	11	States	state	NNS
18637	3955	12	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3955	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	3955	14	competent	competent	JJ
18637	3955	15	for	for	IN
18637	3955	16	a	a	DT
18637	3955	17	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	3955	18	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	3955	19	organized	organize	VBN
18637	3955	20	under	under	IN
18637	3955	21	the	the	DT
18637	3955	22	laws	law	NNS
18637	3955	23	of	of	IN
18637	3955	24	one	one	CD
18637	3955	25	State	State	NNP
18637	3955	26	,	,	,
18637	3955	27	when	when	WRB
18637	3955	28	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	3955	29	so	so	RB
18637	3955	30	to	to	TO
18637	3955	31	do	do	VB
18637	3955	32	by	by	IN
18637	3955	33	the	the	DT
18637	3955	34	consent	consent	NN
18637	3955	35	of	of	IN
18637	3955	36	the	the	DT
18637	3955	37	State	State	NNP
18637	3955	38	which	which	WDT
18637	3955	39	created	create	VBD
18637	3955	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3955	41	,	,	,
18637	3955	42	to	to	TO
18637	3955	43	accept	accept	VB
18637	3955	44	authority	authority	NN
18637	3955	45	from	from	IN
18637	3955	46	another	another	DT
18637	3955	47	State	state	NN
18637	3955	48	to	to	TO
18637	3955	49	extend	extend	VB
18637	3955	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3955	51	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	3955	52	into	into	IN
18637	3955	53	such	such	JJ
18637	3955	54	State	State	NNP
18637	3955	55	and	and	CC
18637	3955	56	to	to	TO
18637	3955	57	receive	receive	VB
18637	3955	58	a	a	DT
18637	3955	59	grant	grant	NN
18637	3955	60	of	of	IN
18637	3955	61	powers	power	NNS
18637	3955	62	to	to	TO
18637	3955	63	own	own	VB
18637	3955	64	and	and	CC
18637	3955	65	control	control	VB
18637	3955	66	,	,	,
18637	3955	67	by	by	IN
18637	3955	68	lease	lease	NN
18637	3955	69	or	or	CC
18637	3955	70	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	3955	71	,	,	,
18637	3955	72	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	3955	73	therein	therein	RB
18637	3955	74	,	,	,
18637	3955	75	and	and	CC
18637	3955	76	to	to	TO
18637	3955	77	subject	subject	VB
18637	3955	78	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3955	79	to	to	IN
18637	3955	80	such	such	JJ
18637	3955	81	rules	rule	NNS
18637	3955	82	and	and	CC
18637	3955	83	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	3955	84	as	as	IN
18637	3955	85	may	may	MD
18637	3955	86	be	be	VB
18637	3955	87	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	3955	88	by	by	IN
18637	3955	89	the	the	DT
18637	3955	90	second	second	JJ
18637	3955	91	State	State	NNP
18637	3955	92	.	.	.
18637	3956	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	3956	2	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3956	3	on	on	IN
18637	3956	4	the	the	DT
18637	3956	5	part	part	NN
18637	3956	6	of	of	IN
18637	3956	7	two	two	CD
18637	3956	8	or	or	CC
18637	3956	9	more	more	JJR
18637	3956	10	States	States	NNPS
18637	3956	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	3956	12	not	not	RB
18637	3956	13	,	,	,
18637	3956	14	in	in	IN
18637	3956	15	the	the	DT
18637	3956	16	absence	absence	NN
18637	3956	17	of	of	IN
18637	3956	18	inhibitory	inhibitory	JJ
18637	3956	19	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	3956	20	by	by	IN
18637	3956	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3956	22	,	,	,
18637	3956	23	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	3956	24	as	as	IN
18637	3956	25	within	within	IN
18637	3956	26	the	the	DT
18637	3956	27	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	3956	28	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	3956	29	of	of	IN
18637	3956	30	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	3956	31	or	or	CC
18637	3956	32	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	3956	33	between	between	IN
18637	3956	34	States	States	NNP
18637	3956	35	.	.	.
18637	3957	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3957	2	1797	1797	CD
18637	3957	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3957	4	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	3957	5	Effect	Effect	NNP
18637	3957	6	of	of	IN
18637	3957	7	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	3957	8	Compacts	compact	NNS
18637	3957	9	Whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	3957	10	,	,	,
18637	3957	11	by	by	IN
18637	3957	12	the	the	DT
18637	3957	13	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3957	14	of	of	IN
18637	3957	15	the	the	DT
18637	3957	16	States	States	NNP
18637	3957	17	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	3957	18	and	and	CC
18637	3957	19	the	the	DT
18637	3957	20	consent	consent	NN
18637	3957	21	of	of	IN
18637	3957	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3957	23	,	,	,
18637	3957	24	an	an	DT
18637	3957	25	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	3957	26	compact	compact	NN
18637	3957	27	comes	come	VBZ
18637	3957	28	into	into	IN
18637	3957	29	operation	operation	NN
18637	3957	30	,	,	,
18637	3957	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3957	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	3957	33	the	the	DT
18637	3957	34	same	same	JJ
18637	3957	35	effect	effect	NN
18637	3957	36	as	as	IN
18637	3957	37	a	a	DT
18637	3957	38	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	3957	39	between	between	IN
18637	3957	40	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	3957	41	powers	power	NNS
18637	3957	42	.	.	.
18637	3958	1	Boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	3958	2	established	establish	VBN
18637	3958	3	by	by	IN
18637	3958	4	such	such	JJ
18637	3958	5	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	3958	6	become	become	VBN
18637	3958	7	binding	bind	VBG
18637	3958	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	3958	9	all	all	DT
18637	3958	10	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	3958	11	of	of	IN
18637	3958	12	the	the	DT
18637	3958	13	signatory	signatory	NN
18637	3958	14	States	States	NNPS
18637	3958	15	and	and	CC
18637	3958	16	are	be	VBP
18637	3958	17	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	3958	18	as	as	IN
18637	3958	19	to	to	IN
18637	3958	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	3958	21	rights	right	NNS
18637	3958	22	.	.	.
18637	3959	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3959	2	1798	1798	CD
18637	3959	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3959	4	Private	private	JJ
18637	3959	5	rights	right	NNS
18637	3959	6	may	may	MD
18637	3959	7	be	be	VB
18637	3959	8	affected	affect	VBN
18637	3959	9	by	by	IN
18637	3959	10	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	3959	11	for	for	IN
18637	3959	12	the	the	DT
18637	3959	13	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	3959	14	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	3959	15	of	of	IN
18637	3959	16	the	the	DT
18637	3959	17	water	water	NN
18637	3959	18	of	of	IN
18637	3959	19	an	an	DT
18637	3959	20	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	3959	21	stream	stream	NN
18637	3959	22	,	,	,
18637	3959	23	without	without	IN
18637	3959	24	a	a	DT
18637	3959	25	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	3959	26	determination	determination	NN
18637	3959	27	of	of	IN
18637	3959	28	existing	exist	VBG
18637	3959	29	rights	right	NNS
18637	3959	30	.	.	.
18637	3960	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3960	2	1799	1799	CD
18637	3960	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3960	4	Valid	Valid	NNP
18637	3960	5	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	3960	6	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	3960	7	are	be	VBP
18637	3960	8	within	within	IN
18637	3960	9	the	the	DT
18637	3960	10	protection	protection	NN
18637	3960	11	of	of	IN
18637	3960	12	the	the	DT
18637	3960	13	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	3960	14	of	of	IN
18637	3960	15	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	3960	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	3960	17	and	and	CC
18637	3960	18	specific	specific	JJ
18637	3960	19	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	3960	20	of	of	IN
18637	3960	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3960	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	3960	23	within	within	IN
18637	3960	24	the	the	DT
18637	3960	25	original	original	JJ
18637	3960	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	3960	27	of	of	IN
18637	3960	28	the	the	DT
18637	3960	29	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3960	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3960	31	.	.	.
18637	3961	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3961	2	1800	1800	CD
18637	3961	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3961	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3961	5	also	also	RB
18637	3961	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	3961	7	authority	authority	NN
18637	3961	8	to	to	TO
18637	3961	9	compel	compel	VB
18637	3961	10	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	3961	11	with	with	IN
18637	3961	12	such	such	PDT
18637	3961	13	a	a	DT
18637	3961	14	compact	compact	NN
18637	3961	15	.	.	.
18637	3962	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3962	2	1801	1801	CD
18637	3962	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3962	4	ADDENDUM	ADDENDUM	NNP
18637	3962	5	Nor	nor	CC
18637	3962	6	may	may	MD
18637	3962	7	a	a	DT
18637	3962	8	State	state	NN
18637	3962	9	read	read	VBD
18637	3962	10	herself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3962	11	out	out	IN
18637	3962	12	of	of	IN
18637	3962	13	a	a	DT
18637	3962	14	compact	compact	NN
18637	3962	15	which	which	WDT
18637	3962	16	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3962	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	3962	18	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	3962	19	and	and	CC
18637	3962	20	to	to	TO
18637	3962	21	which	which	WDT
18637	3962	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	3962	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	3962	24	consented	consent	VBN
18637	3962	25	by	by	IN
18637	3962	26	pleading	plead	VBG
18637	3962	27	that	that	IN
18637	3962	28	under	under	IN
18637	3962	29	the	the	DT
18637	3962	30	State	state	NN
18637	3962	31	's	's	POS
18637	3962	32	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	3962	33	as	as	IN
18637	3962	34	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	3962	35	by	by	IN
18637	3962	36	the	the	DT
18637	3962	37	highest	high	JJS
18637	3962	38	State	State	NNP
18637	3962	39	court	court	NN
18637	3962	40	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	3962	41	had	have	VBD
18637	3962	42	lacked	lack	VBN
18637	3962	43	power	power	NN
18637	3962	44	to	to	TO
18637	3962	45	enter	enter	VB
18637	3962	46	into	into	IN
18637	3962	47	such	such	PDT
18637	3962	48	an	an	DT
18637	3962	49	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	3962	50	and	and	CC
18637	3962	51	was	be	VBD
18637	3962	52	without	without	IN
18637	3962	53	power	power	NN
18637	3962	54	to	to	TO
18637	3962	55	meet	meet	VB
18637	3962	56	certain	certain	JJ
18637	3962	57	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	3962	58	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	3962	59	.	.	.
18637	3963	1	The	the	DT
18637	3963	2	final	final	JJ
18637	3963	3	construction	construction	NN
18637	3963	4	of	of	IN
18637	3963	5	the	the	DT
18637	3963	6	State	State	NNP
18637	3963	7	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	3963	8	in	in	IN
18637	3963	9	such	such	PDT
18637	3963	10	a	a	DT
18637	3963	11	case	case	NN
18637	3963	12	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	3963	13	with	with	IN
18637	3963	14	the	the	DT
18637	3963	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	3963	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	3963	17	.	.	.
18637	3964	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3964	2	1802	1802	CD
18637	3964	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3964	4	Notes	Notes	NNP
18637	3964	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3964	6	1	1	CD
18637	3964	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3964	8	4	4	CD
18637	3964	9	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	3964	10	.	.	.
18637	3965	1	316	316	CD
18637	3965	2	,	,	,
18637	3965	3	405	405	CD
18637	3965	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3965	5	1819	1819	CD
18637	3965	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3965	7	.	.	.
18637	3966	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3966	2	2	2	LS
18637	3966	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3966	4	_	_	NNP
18637	3966	5	See	See	NNP
18637	3966	6	_	_	NNP
18637	3966	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	3966	8	.	.	.
18637	3967	1	378	378	CD
18637	3967	2	-	-	SYM
18637	3967	3	379	379	CD
18637	3967	4	.	.	.
18637	3968	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3968	2	3	3	CD
18637	3968	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3968	4	206	206	CD
18637	3968	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	3968	6	46	46	CD
18637	3968	7	,	,	,
18637	3968	8	82	82	CD
18637	3968	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3968	10	1907	1907	CD
18637	3968	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3968	12	.	.	.
18637	3969	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3969	2	4	4	CD
18637	3969	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3969	4	4	4	CD
18637	3969	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	3969	6	.	.	.
18637	3970	1	at	at	IN
18637	3970	2	407	407	CD
18637	3970	3	.	.	.
18637	3971	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3971	2	5	5	CD
18637	3971	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3971	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	3971	5	.	.	.
18637	3972	1	411	411	CD
18637	3972	2	.	.	.
18637	3973	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3973	2	6	6	CD
18637	3973	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3973	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	3973	5	.	.	.
18637	3974	1	421	421	CD
18637	3974	2	.	.	.
18637	3975	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3975	2	7	7	CD
18637	3975	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3975	4	2	2	CD
18637	3975	5	Story	Story	NNP
18637	3975	6	,	,	,
18637	3975	7	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	3975	8	,	,	,
18637	3975	9	§	â§	NN
18637	3975	10	1256	1256	CD
18637	3975	11	.	.	.
18637	3976	1	_	_	NNP
18637	3976	2	See	See	NNP
18637	3976	3	also	also	RB
18637	3976	4	_	_	NNP
18637	3976	5	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	3976	6	.	.	.
18637	3977	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	3977	2	1286	1286	CD
18637	3977	3	and	and	CC
18637	3977	4	1330	1330	CD
18637	3977	5	.	.	.
18637	3978	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3978	2	8	8	CD
18637	3978	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3978	4	1	1	CD
18637	3978	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	3978	6	.	.	.
18637	3979	1	511	511	CD
18637	3979	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3979	3	1828	1828	CD
18637	3979	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3979	5	.	.	.
18637	3980	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3980	2	9	9	CD
18637	3980	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3980	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	3980	5	.	.	.
18637	3981	1	at	at	IN
18637	3981	2	542	542	CD
18637	3981	3	.	.	.
18637	3982	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3982	2	10	10	CD
18637	3982	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3982	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	3982	5	.	.	.
18637	3983	1	543	543	CD
18637	3983	2	.	.	.
18637	3984	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3984	2	11	11	CD
18637	3984	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3984	4	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
18637	3984	5	_	_	NNP
18637	3984	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	3984	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3984	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	3984	9	,	,	,
18637	3984	10	16	16	CD
18637	3984	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	3984	12	.	.	.
18637	3985	1	539	539	CD
18637	3985	2	,	,	,
18637	3985	3	616	616	CD
18637	3985	4	,	,	,
18637	3985	5	618	618	CD
18637	3985	6	-	-	SYM
18637	3985	7	619	619	CD
18637	3985	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3985	9	1842	1842	CD
18637	3985	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3985	11	.	.	.
18637	3986	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3986	2	12	12	CD
18637	3986	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3986	4	Juilliard	Juilliard	NNP
18637	3986	5	_	_	NNP
18637	3986	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	3986	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3986	8	Greenman	Greenman	NNP
18637	3986	9	,	,	,
18637	3986	10	110	110	CD
18637	3986	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	3986	12	421	421	CD
18637	3986	13	,	,	,
18637	3986	14	449	449	CD
18637	3986	15	-	-	SYM
18637	3986	16	450	450	CD
18637	3986	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3986	18	1884	1884	CD
18637	3986	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3986	20	.	.	.
18637	3987	1	_	_	NNP
18637	3987	2	See	See	NNP
18637	3987	3	also	also	RB
18637	3987	4	_	_	NNP
18637	3987	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3987	6	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	3987	7	's	's	POS
18637	3987	8	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	3987	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3987	10	in	in	IN
18637	3987	11	Knox	Knox	NNP
18637	3987	12	_	_	NNP
18637	3987	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	3987	14	_	_	NNP
18637	3987	15	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	3987	16	,	,	,
18637	3987	17	12	12	CD
18637	3987	18	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	3987	19	.	.	.
18637	3988	1	457	457	CD
18637	3988	2	,	,	,
18637	3988	3	565	565	CD
18637	3988	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3988	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	3988	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3988	7	.	.	.
18637	3989	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3989	2	13	13	CD
18637	3989	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3989	4	United	United	NNP
18637	3989	5	States	States	NNP
18637	3989	6	_	_	NNP
18637	3989	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	3989	8	_	_	NNP
18637	3989	9	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	3989	10	,	,	,
18637	3989	11	109	109	CD
18637	3989	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	3989	13	513	513	CD
18637	3989	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3989	15	1883	1883	CD
18637	3989	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3989	17	.	.	.
18637	3990	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3990	2	14	14	CD
18637	3990	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3990	4	United	United	NNP
18637	3990	5	States	States	NNP
18637	3990	6	_	_	NNP
18637	3990	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	3990	8	_	_	NNP
18637	3990	9	Kagama	Kagama	NNP
18637	3990	10	,	,	,
18637	3990	11	118	118	CD
18637	3990	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	3990	13	375	375	CD
18637	3990	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3990	15	1886	1886	CD
18637	3990	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3990	17	.	.	.
18637	3991	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3991	2	15	15	CD
18637	3991	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3991	4	Fong	Fong	NNP
18637	3991	5	Yue	Yue	NNP
18637	3991	6	Ting	Ting	NNP
18637	3991	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3991	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	3991	9	_	_	NNP
18637	3991	10	United	United	NNP
18637	3991	11	States	States	NNP
18637	3991	12	,	,	,
18637	3991	13	149	149	CD
18637	3991	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	3991	15	698	698	CD
18637	3991	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3991	17	1893	1893	CD
18637	3991	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3991	19	.	.	.
18637	3992	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3992	2	16	16	CD
18637	3992	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3992	4	Hines	Hines	NNP
18637	3992	5	_	_	NNP
18637	3992	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	3992	7	_	_	NNP
18637	3992	8	Davidowitz	Davidowitz	NNP
18637	3992	9	et	et	NNP
18637	3992	10	al	al	NNP
18637	3992	11	.	.	NNP
18637	3992	12	,	,	,
18637	3992	13	312	312	CD
18637	3992	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	3992	15	52	52	CD
18637	3992	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3992	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	3992	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3992	19	.	.	.
18637	3993	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3993	2	17	17	CD
18637	3993	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3993	4	299	299	CD
18637	3993	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	3993	6	304	304	CD
18637	3993	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3993	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	3993	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3993	10	.	.	.
18637	3994	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	3994	2	18	18	CD
18637	3994	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	3994	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	3994	5	.	.	.
18637	3995	1	315	315	CD
18637	3995	2	,	,	,
18637	3995	3	316	316	CD
18637	3995	4	-	-	SYM
18637	3995	5	317	317	CD
18637	3995	6	,	,	,
18637	3995	7	318	318	CD
18637	3995	8	_	_	NNP
18637	3995	9	passim	passim	NN
18637	3995	10	_	_	NNP
18637	3995	11	.	.	.
18637	3996	1	For	for	IN
18637	3996	2	anticipations	anticipation	NNS
18637	3996	3	of	of	IN
18637	3996	4	this	this	DT
18637	3996	5	conception	conception	NN
18637	3996	6	of	of	IN
18637	3996	7	the	the	DT
18637	3996	8	powers	power	NNS
18637	3996	9	of	of	IN
18637	3996	10	the	the	DT
18637	3996	11	National	National	NNP
18637	3996	12	Government	Government	NNP
18637	3996	13	in	in	IN
18637	3996	14	the	the	DT
18637	3996	15	field	field	NN
18637	3996	16	of	of	IN
18637	3996	17	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	3996	18	relations	relation	NNS
18637	3996	19	,	,	,
18637	3996	20	_	_	NNP
18637	3996	21	see	see	VBP
18637	3996	22	_	_	NNP
18637	3996	23	Penhallow	Penhallow	NNP
18637	3996	24	_	_	NNP
18637	3996	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	3996	26	_	_	NNP
18637	3996	27	Doane	Doane	NNP
18637	3996	28	,	,	,
18637	3996	29	3	3	CD
18637	3996	30	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	3996	31	.	.	.
18637	3997	1	54	54	CD
18637	3997	2	,	,	,
18637	3997	3	80	80	CD
18637	3997	4	,	,	,
18637	3997	5	81	81	CD
18637	3997	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3997	7	1795	1795	CD
18637	3997	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3997	9	;	;	:
18637	3997	10	_	_	NNP
18637	3997	11	also	also	RB
18637	3997	12	_	_	NNP
18637	3997	13	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	3997	14	.	.	.
18637	3998	1	74	74	CD
18637	3998	2	and	and	CC
18637	3998	3	76	76	CD
18637	3998	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3998	5	argument	argument	NN
18637	3998	6	of	of	IN
18637	3998	7	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	3998	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3998	9	;	;	:
18637	3998	10	_	_	NNP
18637	3998	11	also	also	RB
18637	3998	12	_	_	NNP
18637	3998	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	3998	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	3998	15	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	3998	16	's	's	POS
18637	3998	17	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	3998	18	in	in	IN
18637	3998	19	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	3998	20	_	_	NNP
18637	3998	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	3998	22	_	_	NNP
18637	3998	23	Jennison	Jennison	NNP
18637	3998	24	,	,	,
18637	3998	25	14	14	CD
18637	3998	26	Pet	pet	NN
18637	3998	27	.	.	.
18637	3999	1	540	540	CD
18637	3999	2	,	,	,
18637	3999	3	575	575	CD
18637	3999	4	-	-	SYM
18637	3999	5	576	576	CD
18637	3999	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	3999	7	1840	1840	CD
18637	3999	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	3999	9	.	.	.
18637	4000	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4000	2	19	19	CD
18637	4000	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4000	4	Locke	Locke	NNP
18637	4000	5	,	,	,
18637	4000	6	Second	Second	NNP
18637	4000	7	Treatise	Treatise	NNP
18637	4000	8	on	on	IN
18637	4000	9	Government	Government	NNP
18637	4000	10	,	,	,
18637	4000	11	Chapter	chapter	NN
18637	4000	12	XI	XI	NNP
18637	4000	13	§	§	NNP
18637	4000	14	141	141	CD
18637	4000	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4000	16	1691	1691	CD
18637	4000	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4000	18	.	.	.
18637	4001	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4001	2	20	20	CD
18637	4001	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4001	4	276	276	CD
18637	4001	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4001	6	394	394	CD
18637	4001	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4001	8	1928	1928	CD
18637	4001	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4001	10	.	.	.
18637	4002	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4002	2	21	21	CD
18637	4002	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4002	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4002	5	.	.	.
18637	4003	1	405	405	CD
18637	4003	2	,	,	,
18637	4003	3	406	406	CD
18637	4003	4	.	.	.
18637	4004	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4004	2	22	22	CD
18637	4004	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4004	4	Wayman	Wayman	NNP
18637	4004	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4004	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4004	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4004	8	Southard	Southard	NNP
18637	4004	9	,	,	,
18637	4004	10	10	10	CD
18637	4004	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4004	12	.	.	.
18637	4005	1	1	1	CD
18637	4005	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4005	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	4005	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4005	5	.	.	.
18637	4006	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4006	2	23	23	CD
18637	4006	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4006	4	The	the	DT
18637	4006	5	Brig	Brig	NNP
18637	4006	6	Aurora	Aurora	NNP
18637	4006	7	,	,	,
18637	4006	8	7	7	CD
18637	4006	9	Cr	cr	NN
18637	4006	10	.	.	.
18637	4007	1	382	382	CD
18637	4007	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4007	3	1813	1813	CD
18637	4007	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4007	5	.	.	.
18637	4008	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4008	2	24	24	CD
18637	4008	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4008	4	Wayman	Wayman	NNP
18637	4008	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4008	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4008	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4008	8	Southard	Southard	NNP
18637	4008	9	,	,	,
18637	4008	10	10	10	CD
18637	4008	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4008	12	.	.	.
18637	4009	1	1	1	CD
18637	4009	2	,	,	,
18637	4009	3	42	42	CD
18637	4009	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4009	5	1825	1825	CD
18637	4009	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4009	7	.	.	.
18637	4010	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4010	2	25	25	CD
18637	4010	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4010	4	Sunshine	Sunshine	NNP
18637	4010	5	Anthracite	Anthracite	NNP
18637	4010	6	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	4010	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4010	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4010	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4010	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4010	11	Adkins	Adkins	NNP
18637	4010	12	,	,	,
18637	4010	13	310	310	CD
18637	4010	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4010	15	381	381	CD
18637	4010	16	,	,	,
18637	4010	17	398	398	CD
18637	4010	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4010	19	1940	1940	CD
18637	4010	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4010	21	;	;	:
18637	4010	22	United	United	NNP
18637	4010	23	States	States	NNP
18637	4010	24	_	_	NNP
18637	4010	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	4010	26	_	_	NNP
18637	4010	27	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	4010	28	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	4010	29	Co	Co	NNP
18637	4010	30	-	-	NN
18637	4010	31	operative	operative	NNP
18637	4010	32	,	,	,
18637	4010	33	307	307	CD
18637	4010	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4010	35	533	533	CD
18637	4010	36	,	,	,
18637	4010	37	577	577	CD
18637	4010	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4010	39	1939	1939	CD
18637	4010	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4010	41	.	.	.
18637	4011	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4011	2	26	26	CD
18637	4011	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4011	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4011	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4011	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4011	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4011	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4011	9	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	4011	10	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	4011	11	Co	Co	NNP
18637	4011	12	-	-	NN
18637	4011	13	operative	operative	NNP
18637	4011	14	,	,	,
18637	4011	15	307	307	CD
18637	4011	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4011	17	533	533	CD
18637	4011	18	,	,	,
18637	4011	19	576	576	CD
18637	4011	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4011	21	1939	1939	CD
18637	4011	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4011	23	.	.	.
18637	4012	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4012	2	27	27	CD
18637	4012	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4012	4	Schechter	Schechter	NNP
18637	4012	5	Poultry	Poultry	NNP
18637	4012	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	4012	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4012	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4012	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4012	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4012	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4012	12	,	,	,
18637	4012	13	295	295	CD
18637	4012	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4012	15	495	495	CD
18637	4012	16	,	,	,
18637	4012	17	539	539	CD
18637	4012	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4012	19	1935	1935	CD
18637	4012	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4012	21	;	;	:
18637	4012	22	Opp	Opp	NNP
18637	4012	23	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	4012	24	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	4012	25	_	_	NNP
18637	4012	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	4012	27	_	_	NNP
18637	4012	28	Administrator	Administrator	NNP
18637	4012	29	,	,	,
18637	4012	30	312	312	CD
18637	4012	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4012	32	126	126	CD
18637	4012	33	,	,	,
18637	4012	34	144	144	CD
18637	4012	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4012	36	1941	1941	CD
18637	4012	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4012	38	;	;	:
18637	4012	39	American	American	NNP
18637	4012	40	Power	Power	NNP
18637	4012	41	&	&	CC
18637	4012	42	Light	Light	NNP
18637	4012	43	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4012	44	_	_	NNP
18637	4012	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	4012	46	_	_	NNP
18637	4012	47	Securities	Securities	NNP
18637	4012	48	&	&	CC
18637	4012	49	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	4012	50	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	4012	51	.	.	NNP
18637	4012	52	,	,	,
18637	4012	53	329	329	CD
18637	4012	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4012	55	90	90	CD
18637	4012	56	,	,	,
18637	4012	57	107	107	CD
18637	4012	58	,	,	,
18637	4012	59	108	108	CD
18637	4012	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4012	61	1946	1946	CD
18637	4012	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4012	63	.	.	.
18637	4013	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4013	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	4013	3	.	.	.
18637	4013	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4013	5	Wichita	Wichita	NNP
18637	4013	6	R.	R.	NNP
18637	4013	7	&	&	CC
18637	4013	8	L.	L.	NNP
18637	4013	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4013	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4013	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	4013	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4013	13	Public	Public	NNP
18637	4013	14	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	4013	15	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	4013	16	.	.	NNP
18637	4013	17	,	,	,
18637	4013	18	260	260	CD
18637	4013	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4013	20	48	48	CD
18637	4013	21	,	,	,
18637	4013	22	59	59	CD
18637	4013	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4013	24	1922	1922	CD
18637	4013	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4013	26	.	.	.
18637	4014	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4014	2	28	28	CD
18637	4014	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4014	4	New	New	NNP
18637	4014	5	York	York	NNP
18637	4014	6	Cent	Cent	NNP
18637	4014	7	.	.	.
18637	4015	1	Securities	Securities	NNP
18637	4015	2	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	4015	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4015	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	4015	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4015	6	United	United	NNP
18637	4015	7	States	States	NNP
18637	4015	8	,	,	,
18637	4015	9	287	287	CD
18637	4015	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4015	11	12	12	CD
18637	4015	12	,	,	,
18637	4015	13	24	24	CD
18637	4015	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4015	15	1932	1932	CD
18637	4015	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4015	17	.	.	.
18637	4016	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4016	2	29	29	CD
18637	4016	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4016	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4016	5	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	4016	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4016	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4016	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4016	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4016	10	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	4016	11	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	4017	1	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	4017	2	&	&	CC
18637	4017	3	Mortgage	Mortgage	NNP
18637	4017	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4017	5	,	,	,
18637	4017	6	289	289	CD
18637	4017	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4017	8	266	266	CD
18637	4017	9	,	,	,
18637	4017	10	285	285	CD
18637	4017	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4017	12	1933	1933	CD
18637	4017	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4017	14	;	;	:
18637	4017	15	National	National	NNP
18637	4017	16	Broadcasting	Broadcasting	NNP
18637	4017	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4017	18	_	_	NNP
18637	4017	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	4017	20	_	_	NNP
18637	4017	21	United	United	NNP
18637	4017	22	States	States	NNP
18637	4017	23	,	,	,
18637	4017	24	319	319	CD
18637	4017	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4017	26	190	190	CD
18637	4017	27	,	,	,
18637	4017	28	225	225	CD
18637	4017	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4017	30	1943	1943	CD
18637	4017	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4017	32	;	;	:
18637	4017	33	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4017	34	Communications	Communications	NNPS
18637	4017	35	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4017	36	_	_	NNP
18637	4017	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	4017	38	_	_	NNP
18637	4017	39	Pottsville	Pottsville	NNP
18637	4017	40	Broadcasting	Broadcasting	NNP
18637	4017	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4017	42	,	,	,
18637	4017	43	309	309	CD
18637	4017	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4017	45	134	134	CD
18637	4017	46	,	,	,
18637	4017	47	138	138	CD
18637	4017	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4017	49	1940	1940	CD
18637	4017	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4017	51	.	.	.
18637	4018	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4018	2	30	30	CD
18637	4018	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4018	4	Lichter	Lichter	NNP
18637	4018	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4018	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4018	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4018	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4018	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4018	10	,	,	,
18637	4018	11	334	334	CD
18637	4018	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4018	13	742	742	CD
18637	4018	14	,	,	,
18637	4018	15	783	783	CD
18637	4018	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4018	17	1948	1948	CD
18637	4018	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4018	19	.	.	.
18637	4019	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4019	2	31	31	CD
18637	4019	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4019	4	Panama	Panama	NNP
18637	4019	5	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	4019	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4019	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4019	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4019	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4019	10	Ryan	Ryan	NNP
18637	4019	11	,	,	,
18637	4019	12	293	293	CD
18637	4019	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4019	14	388	388	CD
18637	4019	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4019	16	1935	1935	CD
18637	4019	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4019	18	;	;	:
18637	4019	19	Schechter	Schechter	NNP
18637	4019	20	Poultry	Poultry	NNP
18637	4019	21	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	4019	22	_	_	NNP
18637	4019	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	4019	24	_	_	NNP
18637	4019	25	United	United	NNP
18637	4019	26	States	States	NNP
18637	4019	27	,	,	,
18637	4019	28	295	295	CD
18637	4019	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4019	30	495	495	CD
18637	4019	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4019	32	1985	1985	CD
18637	4019	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4019	34	.	.	.
18637	4020	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4020	2	32	32	CD
18637	4020	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4020	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4020	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4020	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4020	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4020	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4020	9	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	4020	10	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	4020	11	Co	Co	NNP
18637	4020	12	-	-	NN
18637	4020	13	operative	operative	NNP
18637	4020	14	,	,	,
18637	4020	15	307	307	CD
18637	4020	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4020	17	533	533	CD
18637	4020	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4020	19	1939	1939	CD
18637	4020	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4020	21	;	;	:
18637	4020	22	Sunshine	Sunshine	NNP
18637	4020	23	Anthracite	Anthracite	NNP
18637	4020	24	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	4020	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4020	26	_	_	NNP
18637	4020	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	4020	28	_	_	NNP
18637	4020	29	Adkins	Adkins	NNP
18637	4020	30	,	,	,
18637	4020	31	310	310	CD
18637	4020	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4020	33	381	381	CD
18637	4020	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4020	35	1940	1940	CD
18637	4020	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4020	37	;	;	:
18637	4020	38	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	4020	39	_	_	NNP
18637	4020	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	4020	41	_	_	NNP
18637	4020	42	Willingham	Willingham	NNP
18637	4020	43	,	,	,
18637	4020	44	321	321	CD
18637	4020	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4020	46	503	503	CD
18637	4020	47	,	,	,
18637	4020	48	514	514	CD
18637	4020	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4020	50	1944	1944	CD
18637	4020	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4020	52	;	;	:
18637	4020	53	Yakus	Yakus	NNP
18637	4020	54	_	_	NNP
18637	4020	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	4020	56	_	_	NNP
18637	4020	57	United	United	NNP
18637	4020	58	States	States	NNP
18637	4020	59	,	,	,
18637	4020	60	321	321	CD
18637	4020	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4020	62	414	414	CD
18637	4020	63	,	,	,
18637	4020	64	424	424	CD
18637	4020	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4020	66	1944	1944	CD
18637	4020	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4020	68	.	.	.
18637	4021	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4021	2	33	33	CD
18637	4021	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4021	4	Fahey	Fahey	NNP
18637	4021	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4021	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4021	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4021	8	Mallonee	Mallonee	NNP
18637	4021	9	,	,	,
18637	4021	10	332	332	CD
18637	4021	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4021	12	245	245	CD
18637	4021	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4021	14	1947	1947	CD
18637	4021	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4021	16	.	.	.
18637	4022	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4022	2	34	34	CD
18637	4022	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4022	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4022	5	.	.	.
18637	4023	1	250	250	CD
18637	4023	2	.	.	.
18637	4024	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4024	2	35	35	CD
18637	4024	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4024	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	4024	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	4024	6	Kollock	Kollock	NNP
18637	4024	7	,	,	,
18637	4024	8	165	165	CD
18637	4024	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4024	10	526	526	CD
18637	4024	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4024	12	1897	1897	CD
18637	4024	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4024	14	.	.	.
18637	4025	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4025	2	36	36	CD
18637	4025	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4025	4	Buttfield	Buttfield	NNP
18637	4025	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4025	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4025	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4025	8	Stranahan	Stranahan	NNP
18637	4025	9	,	,	,
18637	4025	10	192	192	CD
18637	4025	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4025	12	470	470	CD
18637	4025	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4025	14	1904	1904	CD
18637	4025	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4025	16	.	.	.
18637	4026	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4026	2	37	37	CD
18637	4026	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4026	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4026	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4026	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4026	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4026	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4026	9	Grimaud	Grimaud	NNP
18637	4026	10	,	,	,
18637	4026	11	220	220	CD
18637	4026	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4026	13	506	506	CD
18637	4026	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4026	15	1911	1911	CD
18637	4026	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4026	17	.	.	.
18637	4027	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4027	2	38	38	CD
18637	4027	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4027	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4027	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4027	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4027	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4027	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4027	9	Shreveport	Shreveport	NNP
18637	4027	10	Grain	Grain	NNP
18637	4027	11	&	&	CC
18637	4027	12	Elevator	Elevator	NNP
18637	4027	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4027	14	,	,	,
18637	4027	15	287	287	CD
18637	4027	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4027	17	77	77	CD
18637	4027	18	,	,	,
18637	4027	19	85	85	CD
18637	4027	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4027	21	1932	1932	CD
18637	4027	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4027	23	.	.	.
18637	4028	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4028	2	39	39	CD
18637	4028	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4028	4	Currin	Currin	NNP
18637	4028	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4028	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4028	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4028	8	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	4028	9	,	,	,
18637	4028	10	306	306	CD
18637	4028	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4028	12	1	1	CD
18637	4028	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4028	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	4028	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4028	16	.	.	.
18637	4029	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4029	2	40	40	CD
18637	4029	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4029	4	Avent	Avent	NNP
18637	4029	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4029	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4029	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4029	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4029	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4029	10	,	,	,
18637	4029	11	266	266	CD
18637	4029	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4029	13	127	127	CD
18637	4029	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4029	15	1924	1924	CD
18637	4029	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4029	17	.	.	.
18637	4030	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4030	2	41	41	CD
18637	4030	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4030	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4030	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4030	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4030	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4030	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4030	9	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	4030	10	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	4030	11	Co	Co	NNP
18637	4030	12	-	-	NN
18637	4030	13	operative	operative	NNP
18637	4030	14	,	,	,
18637	4030	15	307	307	CD
18637	4030	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4030	17	533	533	CD
18637	4030	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4030	19	1939	1939	CD
18637	4030	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4030	21	.	.	.
18637	4031	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4031	2	42	42	CD
18637	4031	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4031	4	Yakus	Yakus	NNP
18637	4031	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4031	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4031	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4031	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4031	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4031	10	,	,	,
18637	4031	11	321	321	CD
18637	4031	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4031	13	414	414	CD
18637	4031	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4031	15	1944	1944	CD
18637	4031	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4031	17	.	.	.
18637	4032	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4032	2	43	43	CD
18637	4032	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4032	4	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	4032	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4032	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4032	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4032	8	Willingham	Willingham	NNP
18637	4032	9	,	,	,
18637	4032	10	321	321	CD
18637	4032	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4032	12	503	503	CD
18637	4032	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4032	14	1944	1944	CD
18637	4032	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4032	16	.	.	.
18637	4033	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4033	2	44	44	CD
18637	4033	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4033	4	Sunshine	Sunshine	NNP
18637	4033	5	Anthracite	Anthracite	NNP
18637	4033	6	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	4033	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4033	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4033	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4033	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4033	11	Adkins	Adkins	NNP
18637	4033	12	,	,	,
18637	4033	13	310	310	CD
18637	4033	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4033	15	381	381	CD
18637	4033	16	,	,	,
18637	4033	17	397	397	CD
18637	4033	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4033	19	1940	1940	CD
18637	4033	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4033	21	.	.	.
18637	4034	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4034	2	45	45	CD
18637	4034	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4034	4	Hirabayashi	Hirabayashi	NNP
18637	4034	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4034	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4034	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4034	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4034	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4034	10	,	,	,
18637	4034	11	320	320	CD
18637	4034	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4034	13	81	81	CD
18637	4034	14	,	,	,
18637	4034	15	104	104	CD
18637	4034	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4034	17	1943	1943	CD
18637	4034	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4034	19	;	;	:
18637	4034	20	Korematsu	Korematsu	NNP
18637	4034	21	_	_	NNP
18637	4034	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	4034	23	_	_	NNP
18637	4034	24	United	United	NNP
18637	4034	25	States	States	NNP
18637	4034	26	,	,	,
18637	4034	27	323	323	CD
18637	4034	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4034	29	214	214	CD
18637	4034	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4034	31	1944	1944	CD
18637	4034	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4034	33	.	.	.
18637	4035	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4035	2	46	46	CD
18637	4035	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4035	4	Fahey	Fahey	NNP
18637	4035	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4035	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4035	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4035	8	Mallonee	Mallonee	NNP
18637	4035	9	,	,	,
18637	4035	10	332	332	CD
18637	4035	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4035	12	245	245	CD
18637	4035	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4035	14	1947	1947	CD
18637	4035	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4035	16	.	.	.
18637	4036	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4036	2	47	47	CD
18637	4036	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4036	4	Mulford	Mulford	NNP
18637	4036	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4036	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4036	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4036	8	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	4036	9	,	,	,
18637	4036	10	307	307	CD
18637	4036	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4036	12	38	38	CD
18637	4036	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4036	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	4036	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4036	16	.	.	.
18637	4037	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4037	2	48	48	CD
18637	4037	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4037	4	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	4037	5	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4037	6	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNS
18637	4037	7	.	.	.
18637	4038	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4038	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	4038	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4038	4	Goodrich	Goodrich	NNP
18637	4038	5	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	4038	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4038	7	,	,	,
18637	4038	8	224	224	CD
18637	4038	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4038	10	194	194	CD
18637	4038	11	,	,	,
18637	4038	12	214	214	CD
18637	4038	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4038	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	4038	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4038	16	.	.	.
18637	4039	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4039	2	49	49	CD
18637	4039	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4039	4	Although	although	IN
18637	4039	5	reversing	reverse	VBG
18637	4039	6	the	the	DT
18637	4039	7	decision	decision	NN
18637	4039	8	of	of	IN
18637	4039	9	the	the	DT
18637	4039	10	State	State	NNP
18637	4039	11	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	4039	12	court	court	NNP
18637	4039	13	that	that	WDT
18637	4039	14	rates	rate	NNS
18637	4039	15	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	4039	16	by	by	IN
18637	4039	17	the	the	DT
18637	4039	18	commission	commission	NN
18637	4039	19	were	be	VBD
18637	4039	20	not	not	RB
18637	4039	21	subject	subject	JJ
18637	4039	22	to	to	IN
18637	4039	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	4039	24	review	review	NN
18637	4039	25	,	,	,
18637	4039	26	the	the	DT
18637	4039	27	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	4039	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4039	29	implicitly	implicitly	RB
18637	4039	30	sanctioned	sanction	VBD
18637	4039	31	the	the	DT
18637	4039	32	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	4039	33	of	of	IN
18637	4039	34	rate	rate	NN
18637	4039	35	-	-	HYPH
18637	4039	36	making	make	VBG
18637	4039	37	power	power	NN
18637	4039	38	by	by	IN
18637	4039	39	such	such	JJ
18637	4039	40	bodies	body	NNS
18637	4039	41	.	.	.
18637	4040	1	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	4040	2	,	,	,
18637	4040	3	M.	M.	NNP
18637	4040	4	&	&	CC
18637	4040	5	St.	St.	NNP
18637	4040	6	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	4041	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4041	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4041	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4041	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4041	5	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	4041	6	,	,	,
18637	4041	7	134	134	CD
18637	4041	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4041	9	418	418	CD
18637	4041	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4041	11	1890	1890	CD
18637	4041	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4041	13	.	.	.
18637	4042	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4042	2	50	50	CD
18637	4042	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4042	4	Hampton	Hampton	NNP
18637	4042	5	&	&	CC
18637	4042	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4042	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4042	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4042	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4042	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4042	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4042	12	,	,	,
18637	4042	13	276	276	CD
18637	4042	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4042	15	394	394	CD
18637	4042	16	,	,	,
18637	4042	17	408	408	CD
18637	4042	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4042	19	1928	1928	CD
18637	4042	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4042	21	.	.	.
18637	4043	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4043	2	51	51	CD
18637	4043	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4043	4	State	State	NNP
18637	4043	5	of	of	IN
18637	4043	6	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	4043	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4043	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4043	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4043	10	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	4043	11	,	,	,
18637	4043	12	M.	M.	NNP
18637	4043	13	&	&	CC
18637	4043	14	St.	St.	NNP
18637	4043	15	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	4044	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4044	2	38	38	CD
18637	4044	3	Minn.	Minnesota	NNP
18637	4044	4	281	281	CD
18637	4044	5	,	,	,
18637	4044	6	301	301	CD
18637	4044	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4044	8	1888	1888	CD
18637	4044	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4044	10	.	.	.
18637	4045	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4045	2	52	52	CD
18637	4045	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4045	4	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	4045	5	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4045	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4045	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4045	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4045	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4045	10	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	4045	11	&	&	CC
18637	4045	12	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	4046	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4046	2	,	,	,
18637	4046	3	227	227	CD
18637	4046	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4046	5	88	88	CD
18637	4046	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4046	7	1913	1913	CD
18637	4046	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4046	9	;	;	:
18637	4046	10	New	New	NNP
18637	4046	11	York	York	NNP
18637	4046	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4046	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	4046	14	_	_	NNP
18637	4046	15	United	United	NNP
18637	4046	16	States	States	NNP
18637	4046	17	,	,	,
18637	4046	18	331	331	CD
18637	4046	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4046	20	284	284	CD
18637	4046	21	,	,	,
18637	4046	22	340	340	CD
18637	4046	23	-	-	SYM
18637	4046	24	350	350	CD
18637	4046	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4046	26	1947	1947	CD
18637	4046	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4046	28	and	and	CC
18637	4046	29	cases	case	NNS
18637	4046	30	cited	cite	VBD
18637	4046	31	therein	therein	RB
18637	4046	32	.	.	.
18637	4047	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4047	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4047	3	also	also	RB
18637	4047	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4047	5	New	New	NNP
18637	4047	6	York	York	NNP
18637	4047	7	et	et	NNP
18637	4047	8	al	al	NNP
18637	4047	9	.	.	.
18637	4048	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4048	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	4048	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4048	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4048	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4048	6	,	,	,
18637	4048	7	342	342	CD
18637	4048	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4048	9	882	882	CD
18637	4048	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4048	11	1951	1951	CD
18637	4048	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4048	13	.	.	.
18637	4049	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4049	2	53	53	CD
18637	4049	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4049	4	Union	Union	NNP
18637	4049	5	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	4049	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4049	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4049	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4049	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4049	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4049	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4049	12	,	,	,
18637	4049	13	204	204	CD
18637	4049	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4049	15	364	364	CD
18637	4049	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4049	17	1907	1907	CD
18637	4049	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4049	19	.	.	.
18637	4050	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4050	2	54	54	CD
18637	4050	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4050	4	First	First	NNP
18637	4050	5	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	4050	6	.	.	.
18637	4051	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	4051	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4051	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4051	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4051	5	Fellows	Fellows	NNP
18637	4051	6	,	,	,
18637	4051	7	ex	ex	FW
18637	4051	8	rel	rel	NN
18637	4051	9	.	.	.
18637	4052	1	Union	Union	NNP
18637	4052	2	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	4052	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4052	4	,	,	,
18637	4052	5	244	244	CD
18637	4052	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4052	7	416	416	CD
18637	4052	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4052	9	1917	1917	CD
18637	4052	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4052	11	.	.	.
18637	4053	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4053	2	55	55	CD
18637	4053	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4053	4	Mahler	Mahler	NNP
18637	4053	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4053	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4053	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4053	8	Eby	Eby	NNP
18637	4053	9	,	,	,
18637	4053	10	264	264	CD
18637	4053	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4053	12	32	32	CD
18637	4053	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4053	14	1924	1924	CD
18637	4053	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4053	16	;	;	:
18637	4053	17	United	United	NNP
18637	4053	18	States	States	NNP
18637	4053	19	ex	ex	NNP
18637	4053	20	rel	rel	NN
18637	4053	21	.	.	.
18637	4054	1	Tisi	Tisi	NNP
18637	4054	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4054	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4054	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4054	5	Tod	Tod	NNP
18637	4054	6	,	,	,
18637	4054	7	264	264	CD
18637	4054	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4054	9	131	131	CD
18637	4054	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4054	11	1924	1924	CD
18637	4054	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4054	13	.	.	.
18637	4055	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4055	2	56	56	CD
18637	4055	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4055	4	New	New	NNP
18637	4055	5	York	York	NNP
18637	4055	6	Central	Central	NNP
18637	4055	7	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	4055	8	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	4055	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4055	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	4055	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4055	12	United	United	NNP
18637	4055	13	States	States	NNP
18637	4055	14	,	,	,
18637	4055	15	287	287	CD
18637	4055	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4055	17	12	12	CD
18637	4055	18	,	,	,
18637	4055	19	25	25	CD
18637	4055	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4055	21	1932	1932	CD
18637	4055	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4055	23	.	.	.
18637	4056	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4056	2	57	57	CD
18637	4056	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4056	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4056	5	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	4056	6	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	4056	7	.	.	.
18637	4057	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4057	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	4057	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4057	4	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	4057	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	4058	1	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	4058	2	&	&	CC
18637	4058	3	Mortgage	Mortgage	NNP
18637	4058	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4058	5	,	,	,
18637	4058	6	289	289	CD
18637	4058	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4058	8	266	266	CD
18637	4058	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4058	10	1933	1933	CD
18637	4058	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4058	12	.	.	.
18637	4059	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4059	2	58	58	CD
18637	4059	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4059	4	National	National	NNP
18637	4059	5	Broadcasting	Broadcasting	NNP
18637	4059	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4059	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4059	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4059	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4059	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4059	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4059	12	,	,	,
18637	4059	13	319	319	CD
18637	4059	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4059	15	190	190	CD
18637	4059	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4059	17	1943	1943	CD
18637	4059	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4059	19	.	.	.
18637	4060	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4060	2	59	59	CD
18637	4060	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4060	4	50	50	CD
18637	4060	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4060	6	.	.	.
18637	4061	1	246	246	CD
18637	4061	2	,	,	,
18637	4061	3	as	as	IN
18637	4061	4	amended	amend	VBN
18637	4061	5	,	,	,
18637	4061	6	7	7	CD
18637	4061	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
18637	4062	1	§	§	NNP
18637	4062	2	601	601	CD
18637	4062	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4062	4	et	et	NNP
18637	4062	5	seq	seq	NN
18637	4062	6	.	.	.
18637	4062	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4062	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4062	9	60	60	CD
18637	4062	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4062	11	Brannan	Brannan	NNP
18637	4062	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4062	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	4062	14	_	_	NNP
18637	4062	15	Stark	Stark	NNP
18637	4062	16	,	,	,
18637	4062	17	342	342	CD
18637	4062	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4062	19	451	451	CD
18637	4062	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4062	21	1952	1952	CD
18637	4062	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4062	23	.	.	.
18637	4063	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4063	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	4063	3	,	,	,
18637	4063	4	with	with	IN
18637	4063	5	whom	whom	WP
18637	4063	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	4063	7	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	4063	8	and	and	CC
18637	4063	9	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	4063	10	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	4063	11	,	,	,
18637	4063	12	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	4063	13	,	,	,
18637	4063	14	saying	say	VBG
18637	4063	15	:	:	:
18637	4063	16	"	"	``
18637	4063	17	In	in	IN
18637	4063	18	striking	strike	VBG
18637	4063	19	down	down	RP
18637	4063	20	these	these	DT
18637	4063	21	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	4063	22	of	of	IN
18637	4063	23	the	the	DT
18637	4063	24	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	4063	25	's	's	POS
18637	4063	26	order	order	NN
18637	4063	27	,	,	,
18637	4063	28	the	the	DT
18637	4063	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4063	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	4063	31	departed	depart	VBN
18637	4063	32	from	from	IN
18637	4063	33	many	many	JJ
18637	4063	34	principles	principle	NNS
18637	4063	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4063	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	4063	37	previously	previously	RB
18637	4063	38	announced	announce	VBN
18637	4063	39	in	in	IN
18637	4063	40	connection	connection	NN
18637	4063	41	with	with	IN
18637	4063	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4063	43	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	4063	44	over	over	IN
18637	4063	45	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	4063	46	agents	agent	NNS
18637	4063	47	.	.	.
18637	4064	1	Under	under	IN
18637	4064	2	these	these	DT
18637	4064	3	principles	principle	NNS
18637	4064	4	,	,	,
18637	4064	5	the	the	DT
18637	4064	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4064	7	would	would	MD
18637	4064	8	refrain	refrain	VB
18637	4064	9	from	from	IN
18637	4064	10	setting	set	VBG
18637	4064	11	aside	aside	RB
18637	4064	12	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	4064	13	findings	finding	NNS
18637	4064	14	of	of	IN
18637	4064	15	fact	fact	NN
18637	4064	16	when	when	WRB
18637	4064	17	supported	support	VBN
18637	4064	18	by	by	IN
18637	4064	19	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	4064	20	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	4064	21	;	;	:
18637	4064	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4064	23	would	would	MD
18637	4064	24	give	give	VB
18637	4064	25	weight	weight	NN
18637	4064	26	to	to	IN
18637	4064	27	the	the	DT
18637	4064	28	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	4064	29	of	of	IN
18637	4064	30	a	a	DT
18637	4064	31	statute	statute	NN
18637	4064	32	by	by	IN
18637	4064	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4064	34	administrators	administrator	NNS
18637	4064	35	;	;	:
18637	4064	36	when	when	WRB
18637	4064	37	,	,	,
18637	4064	38	administrators	administrator	NNS
18637	4064	39	have	have	VBP
18637	4064	40	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	4064	41	broad	broad	JJ
18637	4064	42	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	4064	43	terms	term	NNS
18637	4064	44	,	,	,
18637	4064	45	such	such	JJ
18637	4064	46	,	,	,
18637	4064	47	as	as	RB
18637	4064	48	here	here	RB
18637	4064	49	involved	involve	VBN
18637	4064	50	,	,	,
18637	4064	51	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4064	52	would	would	MD
18637	4064	53	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	4064	54	that	that	IN
18637	4064	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4064	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	4064	57	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4064	58	duty	duty	NN
18637	4064	59	to	to	TO
18637	4064	60	accept	accept	VB
18637	4064	61	this	this	DT
18637	4064	62	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	4064	63	even	even	RB
18637	4064	64	though	though	IN
18637	4064	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4064	66	was	be	VBD
18637	4064	67	not	not	RB
18637	4064	68	'	'	``
18637	4064	69	the	the	DT
18637	4064	70	only	only	JJ
18637	4064	71	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	4064	72	one	one	CD
18637	4064	73	'	'	''
18637	4064	74	or	or	CC
18637	4064	75	the	the	DT
18637	4064	76	one	one	NN
18637	4064	77	'	'	''
18637	4064	78	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4064	79	would	would	MD
18637	4064	80	have	have	VB
18637	4064	81	reached	reach	VBN
18637	4064	82	had	have	VBD
18637	4064	83	the	the	DT
18637	4064	84	question	question	NN
18637	4064	85	arisen	arise	VBN
18637	4064	86	in	in	IN
18637	4064	87	the	the	DT
18637	4064	88	first	first	JJ
18637	4064	89	instance	instance	NN
18637	4064	90	in	in	IN
18637	4064	91	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	4064	92	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	4064	93	.	.	.
18637	4064	94	'	'	''
18637	4065	1	Unemployment	unemployment	NN
18637	4065	2	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	4065	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4065	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	4065	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4065	6	Aragon	Aragon	NNP
18637	4065	7	,	,	,
18637	4065	8	329	329	CD
18637	4065	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4065	10	143	143	CD
18637	4065	11	,	,	,
18637	4065	12	153	153	CD
18637	4065	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4065	14	1946	1946	CD
18637	4065	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4065	16	.	.	.
18637	4065	17	"	"	''
18637	4066	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	4066	2	.	.	.
18637	4067	1	484	484	CD
18637	4067	2	.	.	.
18637	4068	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4068	2	61	61	CD
18637	4068	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4068	4	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	4068	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4068	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4068	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4068	8	Roby	Roby	NNP
18637	4068	9	,	,	,
18637	4068	10	109	109	CD
18637	4068	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4068	12	440	440	CD
18637	4068	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4068	14	1883	1883	CD
18637	4068	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4068	16	;	;	:
18637	4068	17	Erhardt	Erhardt	NNP
18637	4068	18	_	_	NNP
18637	4068	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	4068	20	_	_	NNP
18637	4068	21	Boaro	Boaro	NNP
18637	4068	22	,	,	,
18637	4068	23	113	113	CD
18637	4068	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4068	25	527	527	CD
18637	4068	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4068	27	1885	1885	CD
18637	4068	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4068	29	;	;	:
18637	4068	30	Butte	Butte	NNP
18637	4068	31	City	City	NNP
18637	4068	32	Water	Water	NNP
18637	4068	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4068	34	_	_	NNP
18637	4068	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	4068	36	_	_	NNP
18637	4068	37	Baker	Baker	NNP
18637	4068	38	,	,	,
18637	4068	39	196	196	CD
18637	4068	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4068	41	119	119	CD
18637	4068	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4068	43	1905	1905	CD
18637	4068	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4068	45	.	.	.
18637	4069	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4069	2	62	62	CD
18637	4069	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4069	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	4069	5	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	4069	6	,	,	,
18637	4069	7	I.M.	I.M.	NNP
18637	4070	1	&	&	CC
18637	4070	2	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	4071	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4071	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4071	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4071	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4071	5	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	4071	6	,	,	,
18637	4071	7	210	210	CD
18637	4071	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4071	9	281	281	CD
18637	4071	10	,	,	,
18637	4071	11	286	286	CD
18637	4071	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4071	13	1908	1908	CD
18637	4071	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4071	15	.	.	.
18637	4072	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4072	2	63	63	CD
18637	4072	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4072	4	295	295	CD
18637	4072	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4072	6	495	495	CD
18637	4072	7	,	,	,
18637	4072	8	537	537	CD
18637	4072	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4072	10	1935	1935	CD
18637	4072	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4072	12	.	.	.
18637	4073	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4073	2	64	64	CD
18637	4073	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4073	4	298	298	CD
18637	4073	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4073	6	238	238	CD
18637	4073	7	,	,	,
18637	4073	8	311	311	CD
18637	4073	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4073	10	1936	1936	CD
18637	4073	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4073	12	.	.	.
18637	4074	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4074	2	65	65	CD
18637	4074	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4074	4	Currin	Currin	NNP
18637	4074	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4074	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4074	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4074	8	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	4074	9	,	,	,
18637	4074	10	306	306	CD
18637	4074	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4074	12	1	1	CD
18637	4074	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4074	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	4074	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4074	16	;	;	:
18637	4074	17	United	United	NNP
18637	4074	18	States	States	NNP
18637	4074	19	_	_	NNP
18637	4074	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	4074	21	_	_	NNP
18637	4074	22	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	4074	23	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	4074	24	Co	Co	NNP
18637	4074	25	-	-	NN
18637	4074	26	operative	operative	NNP
18637	4074	27	,	,	,
18637	4074	28	307	307	CD
18637	4074	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4074	30	533	533	CD
18637	4074	31	,	,	,
18637	4074	32	577	577	CD
18637	4074	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4074	34	1939	1939	CD
18637	4074	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4074	36	.	.	.
18637	4075	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4075	2	66	66	CD
18637	4075	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4075	4	Currin	Currin	NNP
18637	4075	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4075	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4075	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4075	8	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	4075	9	,	,	,
18637	4075	10	306	306	CD
18637	4075	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4075	12	1	1	CD
18637	4075	13	,	,	,
18637	4075	14	15	15	CD
18637	4075	15	,	,	,
18637	4075	16	16	16	CD
18637	4075	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4075	18	1939	1939	CD
18637	4075	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4075	20	.	.	.
18637	4076	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4076	2	67	67	CD
18637	4076	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4076	4	7	7	CD
18637	4076	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	4076	6	.	.	.
18637	4077	1	382	382	CD
18637	4077	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4077	3	1813	1813	CD
18637	4077	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4077	5	.	.	.
18637	4078	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4078	2	68	68	CD
18637	4078	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4078	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4078	5	.	.	.
18637	4079	1	388	388	CD
18637	4079	2	.	.	.
18637	4080	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4080	2	69	69	CD
18637	4080	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4080	4	143	143	CD
18637	4080	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4080	6	649	649	CD
18637	4080	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4080	8	1892	1892	CD
18637	4080	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4080	10	.	.	.
18637	4081	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4081	2	70	70	CD
18637	4081	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4081	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4081	5	.	.	.
18637	4082	1	691	691	CD
18637	4082	2	.	.	.
18637	4083	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4083	2	71	71	CD
18637	4083	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4083	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4083	5	.	.	.
18637	4084	1	692	692	CD
18637	4084	2	,	,	,
18637	4084	3	693	693	CD
18637	4084	4	.	.	.
18637	4085	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4085	2	72	72	CD
18637	4085	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4085	4	Hampton	Hampton	NNP
18637	4085	5	Jr.	Jr.	NNP
18637	4085	6	&	&	CC
18637	4085	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4085	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4085	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4085	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4085	11	United	United	NNP
18637	4085	12	States	States	NNP
18637	4085	13	,	,	,
18637	4085	14	276	276	CD
18637	4085	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4085	16	394	394	CD
18637	4085	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4085	18	1928	1928	CD
18637	4085	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4085	20	.	.	.
18637	4086	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4086	2	73	73	CD
18637	4086	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4086	4	299	299	CD
18637	4086	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4086	6	304	304	CD
18637	4086	7	,	,	,
18637	4086	8	312	312	CD
18637	4086	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4086	10	1936	1936	CD
18637	4086	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4086	12	.	.	.
18637	4087	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4087	2	74	74	CD
18637	4087	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4087	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4087	5	.	.	.
18637	4088	1	319	319	CD
18637	4088	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	4088	3	322.--United	322.--united	CD
18637	4088	4	States	States	NNPS
18637	4088	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4088	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4088	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4088	8	Chemical	Chemical	NNP
18637	4088	9	Foundation	Foundation	NNP
18637	4088	10	,	,	,
18637	4088	11	272	272	CD
18637	4088	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4088	13	1	1	CD
18637	4088	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4088	15	1926	1926	CD
18637	4088	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4088	17	presented	present	VBD
18637	4088	18	the	the	DT
18637	4088	19	anomalous	anomalous	JJ
18637	4088	20	situation	situation	NN
18637	4088	21	of	of	IN
18637	4088	22	the	the	DT
18637	4088	23	United	United	NNP
18637	4088	24	States	States	NNP
18637	4088	25	suing	sue	VBG
18637	4088	26	to	to	TO
18637	4088	27	set	set	VB
18637	4088	28	aside	aside	RB
18637	4088	29	a	a	DT
18637	4088	30	sale	sale	NN
18637	4088	31	of	of	IN
18637	4088	32	alien	alien	JJ
18637	4088	33	property	property	NN
18637	4088	34	sold	sell	VBN
18637	4088	35	by	by	IN
18637	4088	36	one	one	CD
18637	4088	37	of	of	IN
18637	4088	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4088	39	agents	agent	NNS
18637	4088	40	,	,	,
18637	4088	41	the	the	DT
18637	4088	42	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	4088	43	Property	Property	NNP
18637	4088	44	Custodian	Custodian	NNP
18637	4088	45	,	,	,
18637	4088	46	by	by	IN
18637	4088	47	authority	authority	NN
18637	4088	48	of	of	IN
18637	4088	49	the	the	DT
18637	4088	50	President	President	NNP
18637	4088	51	.	.	.
18637	4089	1	The	the	DT
18637	4089	2	government	government	NN
18637	4089	3	contended	contend	VBD
18637	4089	4	that	that	IN
18637	4089	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	4089	6	under	under	IN
18637	4089	7	which	which	WDT
18637	4089	8	the	the	DT
18637	4089	9	sale	sale	NN
18637	4089	10	was	be	VBD
18637	4089	11	made	make	VBN
18637	4089	12	was	be	VBD
18637	4089	13	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	4089	14	because	because	IN
18637	4089	15	,	,	,
18637	4089	16	in	in	IN
18637	4089	17	giving	give	VBG
18637	4089	18	the	the	DT
18637	4089	19	President	President	NNP
18637	4089	20	full	full	JJ
18637	4089	21	power	power	NN
18637	4089	22	of	of	IN
18637	4089	23	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	4089	24	of	of	IN
18637	4089	25	the	the	DT
18637	4089	26	property	property	NN
18637	4089	27	,	,	,
18637	4089	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4089	29	delegated	delegate	VBD
18637	4089	30	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	4089	31	power	power	NN
18637	4089	32	to	to	IN
18637	4089	33	the	the	DT
18637	4089	34	President	President	NNP
18637	4089	35	.	.	.
18637	4090	1	Declaring	declare	VBG
18637	4090	2	that	that	IN
18637	4090	3	"	"	``
18637	4090	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4090	5	was	be	VBD
18637	4090	6	peculiarly	peculiarly	JJ
18637	4090	7	within	within	IN
18637	4090	8	the	the	DT
18637	4090	9	province	province	NN
18637	4090	10	of	of	IN
18637	4090	11	the	the	DT
18637	4090	12	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	4090	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	4090	14	in	in	IN
18637	4090	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	4090	16	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	4090	17	to	to	TO
18637	4090	18	know	know	VB
18637	4090	19	the	the	DT
18637	4090	20	facts	fact	NNS
18637	4090	21	and	and	CC
18637	4090	22	to	to	TO
18637	4090	23	determine	determine	VB
18637	4090	24	what	what	WDT
18637	4090	25	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	4090	26	should	should	MD
18637	4090	27	be	be	VB
18637	4090	28	made	make	VBN
18637	4090	29	of	of	IN
18637	4090	30	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	4090	31	properties	property	NNS
18637	4090	32	in	in	IN
18637	4090	33	order	order	NN
18637	4090	34	effectively	effectively	RB
18637	4090	35	to	to	TO
18637	4090	36	carry	carry	VB
18637	4090	37	on	on	RP
18637	4090	38	the	the	DT
18637	4090	39	war	war	NN
18637	4090	40	,	,	,
18637	4090	41	"	"	''
18637	4090	42	the	the	DT
18637	4090	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4090	44	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	4090	45	a	a	DT
18637	4090	46	decree	decree	NN
18637	4090	47	dismissing	dismiss	VBG
18637	4090	48	the	the	DT
18637	4090	49	suit	suit	NN
18637	4090	50	.	.	.
18637	4091	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	4091	2	.	.	.
18637	4092	1	12	12	CD
18637	4092	2	.	.	.
18637	4093	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4093	2	75	75	CD
18637	4093	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4093	4	293	293	CD
18637	4093	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4093	6	388	388	CD
18637	4093	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4093	8	1935	1935	CD
18637	4093	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4093	10	.	.	.
18637	4094	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4094	2	76	76	CD
18637	4094	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4094	4	312	312	CD
18637	4094	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4094	6	126	126	CD
18637	4094	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4094	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	4094	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4094	10	.	.	.
18637	4095	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4095	2	77	77	CD
18637	4095	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4095	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4095	5	.	.	.
18637	4096	1	144	144	CD
18637	4096	2	,	,	,
18637	4096	3	145	145	CD
18637	4096	4	.	.	.
18637	4097	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4097	2	78	78	CD
18637	4097	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4097	4	White	White	NNP
18637	4097	5	House	House	NNP
18637	4097	6	Digest	Digest	NNP
18637	4097	7	of	of	IN
18637	4097	8	Provisions	Provisions	NNPS
18637	4097	9	of	of	IN
18637	4097	10	Law	Law	NNP
18637	4097	11	Which	which	WDT
18637	4097	12	Would	Would	MD
18637	4097	13	Become	become	VB
18637	4097	14	Operative	operative	JJ
18637	4097	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	4097	16	Proclamation	Proclamation	NNP
18637	4097	17	of	of	IN
18637	4097	18	a	a	DT
18637	4097	19	National	National	NNP
18637	4097	20	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	4097	21	by	by	IN
18637	4097	22	the	the	DT
18637	4097	23	President	President	NNP
18637	4097	24	.	.	.
18637	4098	1	The	the	DT
18637	4098	2	Digest	Digest	NNP
18637	4098	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	4098	4	dated	date	VBN
18637	4098	5	December	December	NNP
18637	4098	6	11	11	CD
18637	4098	7	,	,	,
18637	4098	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	4098	9	.	.	.
18637	4099	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4099	2	was	be	VBD
18637	4099	3	released	release	VBN
18637	4099	4	to	to	IN
18637	4099	5	the	the	DT
18637	4099	6	press	press	NN
18637	4099	7	on	on	IN
18637	4099	8	December	December	NNP
18637	4099	9	16th	16th	NN
18637	4099	10	.	.	.
18637	4100	1	15	15	CD
18637	4100	2	F.R.	F.R.	NNP
18637	4101	1	9029	9029	CD
18637	4101	2	.	.	.
18637	4102	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4102	2	79	79	CD
18637	4102	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4102	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4102	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4102	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4102	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4102	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4102	9	Grimaud	Grimaud	NNP
18637	4102	10	,	,	,
18637	4102	11	220	220	CD
18637	4102	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4102	13	506	506	CD
18637	4102	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4102	15	1911	1911	CD
18637	4102	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4102	17	.	.	.
18637	4103	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4103	2	80	80	CD
18637	4103	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4103	4	Steuart	Steuart	NNP
18637	4103	5	&	&	CC
18637	4103	6	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	4103	7	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	4103	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4103	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4103	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4103	11	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	4103	12	,	,	,
18637	4103	13	322	322	CD
18637	4103	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4103	15	398	398	CD
18637	4103	16	,	,	,
18637	4103	17	404	404	CD
18637	4103	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4103	19	1944	1944	CD
18637	4103	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4103	21	.	.	.
18637	4104	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4104	2	81	81	CD
18637	4104	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4104	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4104	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4104	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4104	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4104	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4104	9	Eaton	Eaton	NNP
18637	4104	10	,	,	,
18637	4104	11	144	144	CD
18637	4104	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4104	13	677	677	CD
18637	4104	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4104	15	1892	1892	CD
18637	4104	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4104	17	.	.	.
18637	4105	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4105	2	82	82	CD
18637	4105	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4105	4	Steuart	Steuart	NNP
18637	4105	5	&	&	CC
18637	4105	6	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	4105	7	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	4105	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4105	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4105	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4105	11	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	4105	12	,	,	,
18637	4105	13	322	322	CD
18637	4105	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4105	15	398	398	CD
18637	4105	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4105	17	1944	1944	CD
18637	4105	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4105	19	.	.	.
18637	4106	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4106	2	83	83	CD
18637	4106	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4106	4	Kraus	Kraus	NNP
18637	4106	5	&	&	CC
18637	4106	6	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	4106	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4106	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4106	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4106	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4106	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4106	12	,	,	,
18637	4106	13	327	327	CD
18637	4106	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4106	15	614	614	CD
18637	4106	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4106	17	1946	1946	CD
18637	4106	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4106	19	.	.	.
18637	4107	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4107	2	84	84	CD
18637	4107	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4107	4	Landis	Landis	NNP
18637	4107	5	,	,	,
18637	4107	6	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	4107	7	Limitations	Limitations	NNPS
18637	4107	8	on	on	IN
18637	4107	9	the	the	DT
18637	4107	10	Congressional	Congressional	NNP
18637	4107	11	Power	Power	NNP
18637	4107	12	of	of	IN
18637	4107	13	Investigation	Investigation	NNP
18637	4107	14	,	,	,
18637	4107	15	40	40	CD
18637	4107	16	Harvard	Harvard	NNP
18637	4107	17	Law	Law	NNP
18637	4107	18	Review	Review	NNP
18637	4107	19	,	,	,
18637	4107	20	153	153	CD
18637	4107	21	,	,	,
18637	4107	22	159	159	CD
18637	4107	23	-	-	SYM
18637	4107	24	166	166	CD
18637	4107	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4107	26	1926	1926	CD
18637	4107	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4107	28	.	.	.
18637	4108	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4108	2	85	85	CD
18637	4108	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4108	4	3	3	CD
18637	4108	5	Annals	Annals	NNPS
18637	4108	6	of	of	IN
18637	4108	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4108	8	,	,	,
18637	4108	9	493	493	CD
18637	4108	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4108	11	1792	1792	CD
18637	4108	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4108	13	.	.	.
18637	4109	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4109	2	86	86	CD
18637	4109	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4109	4	In	in	IN
18637	4109	5	1800	1800	CD
18637	4109	6	,	,	,
18637	4109	7	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	4109	8	of	of	IN
18637	4109	9	the	the	DT
18637	4109	10	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	4109	11	,	,	,
18637	4109	12	Oliver	Oliver	NNP
18637	4109	13	Wolcott	Wolcott	NNP
18637	4109	14	,	,	,
18637	4109	15	Jr.	Jr.	NNP
18637	4109	16	,	,	,
18637	4109	17	addressed	address	VBD
18637	4109	18	a	a	DT
18637	4109	19	letter	letter	NN
18637	4109	20	to	to	IN
18637	4109	21	the	the	DT
18637	4109	22	House	House	NNP
18637	4109	23	of	of	IN
18637	4109	24	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	4109	25	advising	advise	VBG
18637	4109	26	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4109	27	of	of	IN
18637	4109	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4109	29	resignation	resignation	NN
18637	4109	30	from	from	IN
18637	4109	31	office	office	NN
18637	4109	32	and	and	CC
18637	4109	33	inviting	invite	VBG
18637	4109	34	an	an	DT
18637	4109	35	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	4109	36	of	of	IN
18637	4109	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4109	38	office	office	NN
18637	4109	39	.	.	.
18637	4110	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	4110	2	an	an	DT
18637	4110	3	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	4110	4	was	be	VBD
18637	4110	5	made	make	VBN
18637	4110	6	.	.	.
18637	4111	1	10	10	CD
18637	4111	2	Annals	Annals	NNPS
18637	4111	3	of	of	IN
18637	4111	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4111	5	786	786	CD
18637	4111	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	4111	7	788	788	CD
18637	4111	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4111	9	1800	1800	CD
18637	4111	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4111	11	.	.	.
18637	4112	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4112	2	87	87	CD
18637	4112	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4112	4	8	8	CD
18637	4112	5	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	4112	6	.	.	.
18637	4113	1	Deb	Deb	NNP
18637	4113	2	.	.	.
18637	4114	1	2160	2160	CD
18637	4114	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4114	3	1832	1832	CD
18637	4114	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4114	5	.	.	.
18637	4115	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4115	2	88	88	CD
18637	4115	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4115	4	13	13	CD
18637	4115	5	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	4115	6	.	.	.
18637	4116	1	Deb	Deb	NNP
18637	4116	2	.	.	.
18637	4117	1	1057	1057	CD
18637	4117	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4117	3	1836	1836	CD
18637	4117	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4117	5	.	.	.
18637	4118	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4118	2	89	89	CD
18637	4118	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4118	4	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	4119	1	Rep.	Rep.	NNP
18637	4119	2	No	No	NNP
18637	4119	3	.	.	.
18637	4120	1	194	194	CD
18637	4120	2	,	,	,
18637	4120	3	24th	24th	NN
18637	4120	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	4120	5	.	.	NNP
18637	4120	6	,	,	,
18637	4120	7	2d	2d	CD
18637	4120	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	4120	9	.	.	.
18637	4120	10	,	,	,
18637	4120	11	Ser	Ser	NNP
18637	4120	12	.	.	.
18637	4121	1	No	no	UH
18637	4121	2	.	.	.
18637	4122	1	307	307	CD
18637	4122	2	,	,	,
18637	4122	3	1	1	CD
18637	4122	4	,	,	,
18637	4122	5	12	12	CD
18637	4122	6	,	,	,
18637	4122	7	31	31	CD
18637	4122	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4122	9	1837	1837	CD
18637	4122	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4122	11	.	.	.
18637	4123	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4123	2	90	90	CD
18637	4123	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4123	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	4123	5	.	.	.
18637	4124	1	Globe	Globe	NNP
18637	4124	2	,	,	,
18637	4124	3	36th	36th	NN
18637	4124	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	4124	5	.	.	.
18637	4125	1	1st	1st	JJ
18637	4125	2	sess	sess	NN
18637	4125	3	.	.	.
18637	4126	1	1100	1100	CD
18637	4126	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4126	3	1109	1109	CD
18637	4126	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4126	5	1860	1860	CD
18637	4126	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4126	7	.	.	.
18637	4127	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4127	2	91	91	CD
18637	4127	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4127	4	103	103	CD
18637	4127	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4127	6	168	168	CD
18637	4127	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4127	8	1881	1881	CD
18637	4127	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4127	10	.	.	.
18637	4128	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4128	2	92	92	CD
18637	4128	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4128	4	273	273	CD
18637	4128	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4128	6	135	135	CD
18637	4128	7	,	,	,
18637	4128	8	177	177	CD
18637	4128	9	,	,	,
18637	4128	10	178	178	CD
18637	4128	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4128	12	1927	1927	CD
18637	4128	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4128	14	.	.	.
18637	4129	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4129	2	93	93	CD
18637	4129	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4129	4	4	4	CD
18637	4129	5	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	4129	6	.	.	.
18637	4130	1	Deb	Deb	NNP
18637	4130	2	.	.	.
18637	4131	1	862	862	CD
18637	4131	2	,	,	,
18637	4131	3	868	868	CD
18637	4131	4	,	,	,
18637	4131	5	888	888	CD
18637	4131	6	,	,	,
18637	4131	7	889	889	CD
18637	4131	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4131	9	1827	1827	CD
18637	4131	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4131	11	.	.	.
18637	4132	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4132	2	94	94	CD
18637	4132	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4132	4	103	103	CD
18637	4132	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4132	6	168	168	CD
18637	4132	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4132	8	1881	1881	CD
18637	4132	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4132	10	.	.	.
18637	4133	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4133	2	95	95	CD
18637	4133	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4133	4	154	154	CD
18637	4133	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4133	6	447	447	CD
18637	4133	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4133	8	1894	1894	CD
18637	4133	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4133	10	.	.	.
18637	4134	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4134	2	96	96	CD
18637	4134	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4134	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4134	5	.	.	.
18637	4135	1	478	478	LS
18637	4135	2	.	.	.
18637	4136	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4136	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4136	3	also	also	RB
18637	4136	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4136	5	Harriman	Harriman	NNP
18637	4136	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4136	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4136	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4136	9	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	4136	10	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4136	11	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4136	12	,	,	,
18637	4136	13	211	211	CD
18637	4136	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4136	15	407	407	CD
18637	4136	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4136	17	1908	1908	CD
18637	4136	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4136	19	;	;	:
18637	4136	20	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	4136	21	_	_	NNP
18637	4136	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	4136	23	_	_	NNP
18637	4136	24	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	4136	25	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4136	26	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4136	27	,	,	,
18637	4136	28	245	245	CD
18637	4136	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4136	30	33	33	CD
18637	4136	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4136	32	1917	1917	CD
18637	4136	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4136	34	.	.	.
18637	4137	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4137	2	97	97	CD
18637	4137	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4137	4	273	273	CD
18637	4137	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4137	6	135	135	CD
18637	4137	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4137	8	1927	1927	CD
18637	4137	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4137	10	.	.	.
18637	4138	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4138	2	98	98	CD
18637	4138	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4138	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4138	5	.	.	.
18637	4139	1	154	154	CD
18637	4139	2	,	,	,
18637	4139	3	175	175	CD
18637	4139	4	.	.	.
18637	4140	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4140	2	99	99	CD
18637	4140	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4140	4	103	103	CD
18637	4140	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4140	6	168	168	CD
18637	4140	7	,	,	,
18637	4140	8	192	192	CD
18637	4140	9	-	-	SYM
18637	4140	10	196	196	CD
18637	4140	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4140	12	1881	1881	CD
18637	4140	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4140	14	.	.	.
18637	4141	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4141	2	100	100	CD
18637	4141	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4141	4	166	166	CD
18637	4141	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4141	6	661	661	CD
18637	4141	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4141	8	1897	1897	CD
18637	4141	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4141	10	.	.	.
18637	4142	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4142	2	101	101	CD
18637	4142	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4142	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4142	5	.	.	.
18637	4143	1	670	670	CD
18637	4143	2	.	.	.
18637	4144	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4144	2	102	102	CD
18637	4144	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4144	4	273	273	CD
18637	4144	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4144	6	135	135	CD
18637	4144	7	,	,	,
18637	4144	8	178	178	CD
18637	4144	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4144	10	1927	1927	CD
18637	4144	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4144	12	.	.	.
18637	4145	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4145	2	103	103	CD
18637	4145	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4145	4	279	279	CD
18637	4145	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4145	6	263	263	CD
18637	4145	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4145	8	1929	1929	CD
18637	4145	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4145	10	.	.	.
18637	4146	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4146	2	104	104	CD
18637	4146	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4146	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4146	5	.	.	.
18637	4147	1	295	295	CD
18637	4147	2	.	.	.
18637	4148	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4148	2	105	105	CD
18637	4148	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4148	4	In	in	IN
18637	4148	5	re	re	NN
18637	4148	6	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	4148	7	,	,	,
18637	4148	8	166	166	CD
18637	4148	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4148	10	661	661	CD
18637	4148	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4148	12	1897	1897	CD
18637	4148	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4148	14	.	.	.
18637	4149	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4149	2	106	106	CD
18637	4149	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4149	4	279	279	CD
18637	4149	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4149	6	597	597	CD
18637	4149	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4149	8	1929	1929	CD
18637	4149	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4149	10	.	.	.
18637	4150	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4150	2	107	107	CD
18637	4150	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4150	4	6	6	CD
18637	4150	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4150	6	.	.	.
18637	4151	1	204	204	CD
18637	4151	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4151	3	1821	1821	CD
18637	4151	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4151	5	.	.	.
18637	4152	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4152	2	108	108	CD
18637	4152	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4152	4	243	243	CD
18637	4152	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4152	6	521	521	CD
18637	4152	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4152	8	1917	1917	CD
18637	4152	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4152	10	.	.	.
18637	4153	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4153	2	109	109	CD
18637	4153	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4153	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4153	5	.	.	.
18637	4154	1	542	542	CD
18637	4154	2	.	.	.
18637	4155	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4155	2	110	110	CD
18637	4155	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4155	4	294	294	CD
18637	4155	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4155	6	125	125	CD
18637	4155	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4155	8	1935	1935	CD
18637	4155	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4155	10	.	.	.
18637	4156	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4156	2	111	111	CD
18637	4156	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4156	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4156	5	.	.	.
18637	4157	1	147	147	CD
18637	4157	2	,	,	,
18637	4157	3	150	150	CD
18637	4157	4	.	.	.
18637	4158	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4158	2	112	112	CD
18637	4158	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4158	4	6	6	CD
18637	4158	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4158	6	.	.	.
18637	4159	1	204	204	CD
18637	4159	2	,	,	,
18637	4159	3	231	231	CD
18637	4159	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4159	5	1821	1821	CD
18637	4159	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4159	7	.	.	.
18637	4160	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4160	2	113	113	CD
18637	4160	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4160	4	In	in	IN
18637	4160	5	re	re	IN
18637	4160	6	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	4160	7	,	,	,
18637	4160	8	166	166	CD
18637	4160	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4160	10	661	661	CD
18637	4160	11	,	,	,
18637	4160	12	671	671	CD
18637	4160	13	-	-	SYM
18637	4160	14	672	672	CD
18637	4160	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4160	16	1897	1897	CD
18637	4160	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4160	18	.	.	.
18637	4161	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4161	2	114	114	CD
18637	4161	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4161	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4161	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4161	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4161	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4161	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4161	9	Bryan	Bryan	NNP
18637	4161	10	,	,	,
18637	4161	11	339	339	CD
18637	4161	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4161	13	323	323	CD
18637	4161	14	,	,	,
18637	4161	15	330	330	CD
18637	4161	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4161	17	1950	1950	CD
18637	4161	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4161	19	;	;	:
18637	4161	20	United	United	NNP
18637	4161	21	States	States	NNP
18637	4161	22	_	_	NNP
18637	4161	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	4161	24	_	_	NNP
18637	4161	25	Fleischman	Fleischman	NNP
18637	4161	26	,	,	,
18637	4161	27	339	339	CD
18637	4161	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4161	29	349	349	CD
18637	4161	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4161	31	1950	1950	CD
18637	4161	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4161	33	.	.	.
18637	4162	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4162	2	115	115	CD
18637	4162	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4162	4	Christoffel	Christoffel	NNP
18637	4162	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4162	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4162	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4162	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4162	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4162	10	,	,	,
18637	4162	11	338	338	CD
18637	4162	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4162	13	84	84	CD
18637	4162	14	,	,	,
18637	4162	15	89	89	CD
18637	4162	16	,	,	,
18637	4162	17	90	90	CD
18637	4162	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4162	19	1949	1949	CD
18637	4162	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4162	21	.	.	.
18637	4163	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4163	2	116	116	CD
18637	4163	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4163	4	Minor	Minor	NNP
18637	4163	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4163	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4163	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4163	8	Happersett	Happersett	NNP
18637	4163	9	,	,	,
18637	4163	10	21	21	CD
18637	4163	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4163	12	.	.	.
18637	4164	1	162	162	CD
18637	4164	2	,	,	,
18637	4164	3	171	171	CD
18637	4164	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4164	5	1875	1875	CD
18637	4164	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4164	7	;	;	:
18637	4164	8	Breedlove	Breedlove	NNP
18637	4164	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4164	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	4164	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4164	12	Suttles	Suttles	NNP
18637	4164	13	,	,	,
18637	4164	14	302	302	CD
18637	4164	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4164	16	277	277	CD
18637	4164	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4164	18	1937	1937	CD
18637	4164	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4164	20	.	.	.
18637	4165	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4165	2	117	117	CD
18637	4165	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4165	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	4165	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	4165	6	Yarbrough	Yarbrough	NNP
18637	4165	7	,	,	,
18637	4165	8	110	110	CD
18637	4165	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4165	10	651	651	CD
18637	4165	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4165	12	1884	1884	CD
18637	4165	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4165	14	;	;	:
18637	4165	15	Wiley	Wiley	NNP
18637	4165	16	_	_	NNP
18637	4165	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	4165	18	_	_	NNP
18637	4165	19	Sinkler	Sinkler	NNP
18637	4165	20	,	,	,
18637	4165	21	179	179	CD
18637	4165	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4165	23	58	58	CD
18637	4165	24	,	,	,
18637	4165	25	62	62	CD
18637	4165	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4165	27	1900	1900	CD
18637	4165	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4165	29	;	;	:
18637	4165	30	Swafford	Swafford	NNP
18637	4165	31	_	_	NNP
18637	4165	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	4165	33	_	_	NNP
18637	4165	34	Templeton	Templeton	NNP
18637	4165	35	,	,	,
18637	4165	36	185	185	CD
18637	4165	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4165	38	487	487	CD
18637	4165	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4165	40	1902	1902	CD
18637	4165	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4165	42	;	;	:
18637	4165	43	United	United	NNP
18637	4165	44	States	States	NNP
18637	4165	45	_	_	NNP
18637	4165	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	4165	47	_	_	NNP
18637	4165	48	Classic	Classic	NNP
18637	4165	49	,	,	,
18637	4165	50	313	313	CD
18637	4165	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4165	52	299	299	CD
18637	4165	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4165	54	1941	1941	CD
18637	4165	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4165	56	.	.	.
18637	4166	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4166	2	118	118	CD
18637	4166	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4166	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4166	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4166	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4166	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4166	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4166	9	Classic	Classic	NNP
18637	4166	10	,	,	,
18637	4166	11	313	313	CD
18637	4166	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4166	13	299	299	CD
18637	4166	14	,	,	,
18637	4166	15	315	315	CD
18637	4166	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4166	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	4166	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4166	19	.	.	.
18637	4167	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4167	2	119	119	CD
18637	4167	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4167	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4167	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4167	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4167	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4167	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4167	9	Mosley	Mosley	NNP
18637	4167	10	,	,	,
18637	4167	11	238	238	CD
18637	4167	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4167	13	383	383	CD
18637	4167	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4167	15	1915	1915	CD
18637	4167	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4167	17	;	;	:
18637	4167	18	United	United	NNP
18637	4167	19	States	States	NNP
18637	4167	20	_	_	NNP
18637	4167	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	4167	22	_	_	NNP
18637	4167	23	Saylor	Saylor	NNP
18637	4167	24	,	,	,
18637	4167	25	322	322	CD
18637	4167	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4167	27	385	385	CD
18637	4167	28	,	,	,
18637	4167	29	387	387	CD
18637	4167	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4167	31	1944	1944	CD
18637	4167	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4167	33	.	.	.
18637	4168	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4168	2	120	120	CD
18637	4168	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4168	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4168	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4168	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4168	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4168	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4168	9	Classic	Classic	NNP
18637	4168	10	,	,	,
18637	4168	11	313	313	CD
18637	4168	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4168	13	299	299	CD
18637	4168	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4168	15	1941	1941	CD
18637	4168	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4168	17	.	.	.
18637	4169	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4169	2	121	121	CD
18637	4169	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4169	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4169	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4169	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4169	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4169	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4169	9	Mosley	Mosley	NNP
18637	4169	10	,	,	,
18637	4169	11	238	238	CD
18637	4169	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4169	13	383	383	CD
18637	4169	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4169	15	1915	1915	CD
18637	4169	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4169	17	.	.	.
18637	4170	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4170	2	122	122	CD
18637	4170	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4170	4	35	35	CD
18637	4170	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4170	6	.	.	.
18637	4171	1	1092	1092	CD
18637	4171	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4171	3	1909	1909	CD
18637	4171	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4171	5	;	;	:
18637	4171	6	18	18	CD
18637	4171	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	4172	1	§	§	NNP
18637	4172	2	51	51	CD
18637	4172	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4172	4	1946	1946	CD
18637	4172	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4172	6	,	,	,
18637	4172	7	superseded	supersede	VBN
18637	4172	8	by	by	IN
18637	4172	9	62	62	CD
18637	4172	10	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4172	11	.	.	.
18637	4173	1	696	696	CD
18637	4173	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4173	3	1948	1948	CD
18637	4173	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4173	5	;	;	:
18637	4173	6	18	18	CD
18637	4173	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	4174	1	§	§	NNP
18637	4174	2	241	241	CD
18637	4174	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4174	4	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	4174	5	.	.	.
18637	4175	1	II	II	NNP
18637	4175	2	,	,	,
18637	4175	3	1946	1946	CD
18637	4175	4	ed	ed	NNP
18637	4175	5	.	.	.
18637	4175	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4175	7	.	.	.
18637	4176	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4176	2	123	123	CD
18637	4176	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4176	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4176	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4176	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4176	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4176	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4176	9	Mosley	Mosley	NNP
18637	4176	10	,	,	,
18637	4176	11	238	238	CD
18637	4176	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4176	13	383	383	CD
18637	4176	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4176	15	1915	1915	CD
18637	4176	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4176	17	.	.	.
18637	4177	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4177	2	124	124	CD
18637	4177	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4177	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4177	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4177	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4177	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4177	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4177	9	Saylor	Saylor	NNP
18637	4177	10	,	,	,
18637	4177	11	322	322	CD
18637	4177	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4177	13	385	385	CD
18637	4177	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4177	15	1944	1944	CD
18637	4177	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4177	17	.	.	.
18637	4178	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4178	2	125	125	CD
18637	4178	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4178	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4178	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4178	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4178	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4178	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4178	9	Bathgate	Bathgate	NNP
18637	4178	10	,	,	,
18637	4178	11	246	246	CD
18637	4178	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4178	13	220	220	CD
18637	4178	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4178	15	1918	1918	CD
18637	4178	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4178	17	.	.	.
18637	4179	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4179	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4179	3	also	also	RB
18637	4179	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4179	5	United	United	NNP
18637	4179	6	States	States	NNP
18637	4179	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4179	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4179	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4179	10	Gradwell	Gradwell	NNP
18637	4179	11	,	,	,
18637	4179	12	243	243	CD
18637	4179	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4179	14	476	476	CD
18637	4179	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4179	16	1917	1917	CD
18637	4179	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4179	18	.	.	.
18637	4180	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4180	2	126	126	CD
18637	4180	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4180	4	Sen.	Sen.	NNP
18637	4180	5	Rep.	Rep.	NNP
18637	4180	6	904	904	CD
18637	4180	7	,	,	,
18637	4180	8	74th	74th	NN
18637	4180	9	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	4180	10	.	.	NNP
18637	4180	11	,	,	,
18637	4180	12	1st	1st	JJ
18637	4180	13	sess	sess	NN
18637	4180	14	.	.	.
18637	4181	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4181	2	1935	1935	CD
18637	4181	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4181	4	;	;	:
18637	4181	5	79	79	CD
18637	4181	6	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	4181	7	.	.	.
18637	4182	1	Rec	Rec	NNP
18637	4182	2	.	.	.
18637	4183	1	9651	9651	CD
18637	4183	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4183	3	9653	9653	CD
18637	4183	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4183	5	1935	1935	CD
18637	4183	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4183	7	.	.	.
18637	4184	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4184	2	127	127	CD
18637	4184	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4184	4	No	no	UH
18637	4184	5	.	.	.
18637	4185	1	LX	LX	NNP
18637	4185	2	.	.	.
18637	4186	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4186	2	128	128	CD
18637	4186	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4186	4	Hinds	Hinds	NNPS
18637	4186	5	'	'	POS
18637	4186	6	Precedents	Precedents	NNPS
18637	4186	7	of	of	IN
18637	4186	8	the	the	DT
18637	4186	9	House	House	NNP
18637	4186	10	of	of	IN
18637	4186	11	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	4186	12	,	,	,
18637	4186	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4186	14	:	:	:
18637	4186	15	§§	§§	NNP
18637	4186	16	443	443	CD
18637	4186	17	,	,	,
18637	4186	18	448	448	CD
18637	4186	19	-	-	SYM
18637	4186	20	458	458	CD
18637	4186	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4186	22	1907	1907	CD
18637	4186	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4186	24	.	.	.
18637	4187	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4187	2	129	129	CD
18637	4187	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4187	4	202	202	CD
18637	4187	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4187	6	344	344	CD
18637	4187	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4187	8	1906	1906	CD
18637	4187	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4187	10	.	.	.
18637	4188	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4188	2	130	130	CD
18637	4188	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4188	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4188	5	.	.	.
18637	4189	1	369	369	CD
18637	4189	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4189	3	370	370	CD
18637	4189	4	.	.	.
18637	4190	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4190	2	131	131	CD
18637	4190	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4190	4	Hinds	Hinds	NNPS
18637	4190	5	'	'	POS
18637	4190	6	Precedents	Precedents	NNPS
18637	4190	7	of	of	IN
18637	4190	8	the	the	DT
18637	4190	9	House	House	NNP
18637	4190	10	of	of	IN
18637	4190	11	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	4190	12	,	,	,
18637	4190	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4190	14	:	:	:
18637	4190	15	§§	â§â§	$
18637	4190	16	474	474	CD
18637	4190	17	-	-	SYM
18637	4190	18	477	477	CD
18637	4190	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4190	20	1907	1907	CD
18637	4190	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4190	22	.	.	.
18637	4191	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4191	2	132	132	CD
18637	4191	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4191	4	69	69	CD
18637	4191	5	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	4191	6	.	.	.
18637	4192	1	Rec	Rec	NNP
18637	4192	2	.	.	.
18637	4193	1	1718	1718	CD
18637	4193	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4193	3	1928	1928	CD
18637	4193	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4193	5	.	.	.
18637	4194	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4194	2	133	133	CD
18637	4194	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4194	4	Hinds	Hinds	NNP
18637	4194	5	'	'	POS
18637	4194	6	Precedents	Precedents	NNPS
18637	4194	7	of	of	IN
18637	4194	8	the	the	DT
18637	4194	9	House	House	NNP
18637	4194	10	of	of	IN
18637	4194	11	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	4194	12	,	,	,
18637	4194	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4194	14	:	:	:
18637	4194	15	§	§	NNP
18637	4194	16	414	414	CD
18637	4194	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4194	18	1907	1907	CD
18637	4194	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4194	20	.	.	.
18637	4195	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4195	2	134	134	CD
18637	4195	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4195	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4195	5	.	.	.
18637	4196	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	4196	2	415	415	CD
18637	4196	3	-	-	SYM
18637	4196	4	417	417	CD
18637	4196	5	.	.	.
18637	4197	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4197	2	135	135	CD
18637	4197	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4197	4	The	the	DT
18637	4197	5	part	part	NN
18637	4197	6	of	of	IN
18637	4197	7	this	this	DT
18637	4197	8	clause	clause	NN
18637	4197	9	relating	relate	VBG
18637	4197	10	to	to	IN
18637	4197	11	the	the	DT
18637	4197	12	mode	mode	NN
18637	4197	13	of	of	IN
18637	4197	14	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	4197	15	of	of	IN
18637	4197	16	Representative	Representative	NNP
18637	4197	17	among	among	IN
18637	4197	18	the	the	DT
18637	4197	19	several	several	JJ
18637	4197	20	States	States	NNP
18637	4197	21	,	,	,
18637	4197	22	was	be	VBD
18637	4197	23	changed	change	VBN
18637	4197	24	by	by	IN
18637	4197	25	the	the	DT
18637	4197	26	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	4197	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	4197	28	,	,	,
18637	4197	29	§	§	NNP
18637	4197	30	2	2	CD
18637	4197	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4197	32	p.	p.	NN
18637	4197	33	1170	1170	CD
18637	4197	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4197	35	and	and	CC
18637	4197	36	as	as	IN
18637	4197	37	to	to	IN
18637	4197	38	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	4197	39	on	on	IN
18637	4197	40	incomes	income	NNS
18637	4197	41	without	without	IN
18637	4197	42	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	4197	43	,	,	,
18637	4197	44	by	by	IN
18637	4197	45	the	the	DT
18637	4197	46	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	4197	47	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	4197	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4197	49	p.	p.	NN
18637	4197	50	1191	1191	CD
18637	4197	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4197	52	.	.	.
18637	4198	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4198	2	136	136	CD
18637	4198	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4198	4	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	4198	5	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	4198	6	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	4198	7	,	,	,
18637	4198	8	12	12	CD
18637	4198	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4198	10	.	.	.
18637	4199	1	457	457	CD
18637	4199	2	,	,	,
18637	4199	3	536	536	CD
18637	4199	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4199	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	4199	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4199	7	.	.	.
18637	4200	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4200	2	137	137	CD
18637	4200	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4200	4	46	46	CD
18637	4200	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4200	6	.	.	.
18637	4201	1	21	21	CD
18637	4201	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4201	3	1929	1929	CD
18637	4201	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4201	5	.	.	.
18637	4202	1	This	this	DT
18637	4202	2	same	same	JJ
18637	4202	3	act	act	NN
18637	4202	4	penalizes	penalize	VBZ
18637	4202	5	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	4202	6	to	to	TO
18637	4202	7	cooperate	cooperate	VB
18637	4202	8	properly	properly	RB
18637	4202	9	with	with	IN
18637	4202	10	the	the	DT
18637	4202	11	census	census	NN
18637	4202	12	taker	taker	NN
18637	4202	13	by	by	IN
18637	4202	14	answering	answer	VBG
18637	4202	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4202	16	questions	question	NNS
18637	4202	17	and	and	CC
18637	4202	18	in	in	IN
18637	4202	19	other	other	JJ
18637	4202	20	ways	way	NNS
18637	4202	21	.	.	.
18637	4203	1	13	13	CD
18637	4203	2	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
18637	4204	1	209	209	CD
18637	4204	2	.	.	.
18637	4205	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4205	2	138	138	CD
18637	4205	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4205	4	The	the	DT
18637	4205	5	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	4205	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	4205	7	a	a	DT
18637	4205	8	"	"	``
18637	4205	9	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	4205	10	body"--McGrain	body"--mcgrain	NN
18637	4205	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4205	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	4205	13	_	_	NNP
18637	4205	14	Daugherty	Daugherty	NNP
18637	4205	15	,	,	,
18637	4205	16	273	273	CD
18637	4205	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4205	18	135	135	CD
18637	4205	19	,	,	,
18637	4205	20	181	181	CD
18637	4205	21	-	-	SYM
18637	4205	22	182	182	CD
18637	4205	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4205	24	1927	1927	CD
18637	4205	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4205	26	.	.	.
18637	4206	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4206	2	139	139	CD
18637	4206	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4206	4	5	5	CD
18637	4206	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4206	6	.	.	.
18637	4207	1	491	491	CD
18637	4207	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4207	3	1842	1842	CD
18637	4207	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4207	5	.	.	.
18637	4208	1	This	this	DT
18637	4208	2	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	4208	3	was	be	VBD
18637	4208	4	dropped	drop	VBN
18637	4208	5	in	in	IN
18637	4208	6	1850	1850	CD
18637	4208	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4208	8	9	9	CD
18637	4208	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4208	10	.	.	.
18637	4209	1	428	428	CD
18637	4209	2	,	,	,
18637	4209	3	432	432	CD
18637	4209	4	-	-	SYM
18637	4209	5	433	433	CD
18637	4209	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4209	7	but	but	CC
18637	4209	8	was	be	VBD
18637	4209	9	renewed	renew	VBN
18637	4209	10	in	in	IN
18637	4209	11	1862	1862	CD
18637	4209	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4209	13	12	12	CD
18637	4209	14	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4209	15	.	.	.
18637	4210	1	572	572	CD
18637	4210	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4210	3	.	.	.
18637	4211	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4211	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4211	3	also	also	RB
18637	4211	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4211	5	Joel	Joel	NNP
18637	4211	6	Francis	Francis	NNP
18637	4211	7	Paschal	Paschal	NNP
18637	4211	8	,	,	,
18637	4211	9	The	the	DT
18637	4211	10	House	House	NNP
18637	4211	11	of	of	IN
18637	4211	12	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	4211	13	"	"	``
18637	4211	14	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	4211	15	Depository	Depository	NNP
18637	4211	16	of	of	IN
18637	4211	17	the	the	DT
18637	4211	18	Democratic	Democratic	NNP
18637	4211	19	Principle	Principle	NNP
18637	4211	20	"	"	''
18637	4211	21	,	,	,
18637	4211	22	Spring	spring	NN
18637	4211	23	1952	1952	CD
18637	4211	24	Issue	issue	NN
18637	4211	25	of	of	IN
18637	4211	26	Law	Law	NNP
18637	4211	27	and	and	CC
18637	4211	28	Contemporary	Contemporary	NNP
18637	4211	29	Problems	Problems	NNPS
18637	4211	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4211	31	Duke	Duke	NNP
18637	4211	32	University	University	NNP
18637	4211	33	School	School	NNP
18637	4211	34	of	of	IN
18637	4211	35	Law	Law	NNP
18637	4211	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4211	37	,	,	,
18637	4211	38	276	276	CD
18637	4211	39	-	-	SYM
18637	4211	40	289	289	CD
18637	4211	41	.	.	.
18637	4212	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4212	2	140	140	CD
18637	4212	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4212	4	14	14	CD
18637	4212	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4212	6	.	.	.
18637	4213	1	243	243	CD
18637	4213	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4213	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	4213	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4213	5	.	.	.
18637	4214	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4214	2	141	141	CD
18637	4214	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4214	4	16	16	CD
18637	4214	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4214	6	.	.	.
18637	4215	1	144	144	CD
18637	4215	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4215	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	4215	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4215	5	;	;	:
18637	4215	6	16	16	CD
18637	4215	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	4215	8	.	.	.
18637	4216	1	254	254	CD
18637	4216	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4216	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	4216	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4216	5	;	;	:
18637	4216	6	17	17	CD
18637	4216	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	4216	8	.	.	.
18637	4217	1	347	347	CD
18637	4217	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4217	3	349	349	CD
18637	4217	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4217	5	1872	1872	CD
18637	4217	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4217	7	.	.	.
18637	4218	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4218	2	142	142	CD
18637	4218	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4218	4	28	28	CD
18637	4218	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4218	6	.	.	.
18637	4219	1	36	36	CD
18637	4219	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4219	3	1894	1894	CD
18637	4219	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4219	5	.	.	.
18637	4220	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4220	2	143	143	CD
18637	4220	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4220	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4220	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4220	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4220	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4220	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4220	9	Reese	Reese	NNP
18637	4220	10	,	,	,
18637	4220	11	92	92	CD
18637	4220	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4220	13	214	214	CD
18637	4220	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4220	15	1876	1876	CD
18637	4220	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4220	17	.	.	.
18637	4221	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4221	2	144	144	CD
18637	4221	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4221	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	4221	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	4221	6	Siebold	Siebold	NNP
18637	4221	7	,	,	,
18637	4221	8	100	100	CD
18637	4221	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4221	10	371	371	CD
18637	4221	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4221	12	1880	1880	CD
18637	4221	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4221	14	;	;	:
18637	4221	15	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	4221	16	parte	parte	VBZ
18637	4221	17	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	4221	18	,	,	,
18637	4221	19	100	100	CD
18637	4221	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4221	21	399	399	CD
18637	4221	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4221	23	1880	1880	CD
18637	4221	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4221	25	;	;	:
18637	4221	26	United	United	NNP
18637	4221	27	States	States	NNP
18637	4221	28	_	_	NNP
18637	4221	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	4221	30	_	_	NNP
18637	4221	31	Gale	Gale	NNP
18637	4221	32	,	,	,
18637	4221	33	109	109	CD
18637	4221	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4221	35	65	65	CD
18637	4221	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4221	37	1883	1883	CD
18637	4221	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4221	39	.	.	.
18637	4222	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4222	2	145	145	CD
18637	4222	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4222	4	241	241	CD
18637	4222	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4222	6	565	565	CD
18637	4222	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4222	8	1916	1916	CD
18637	4222	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4222	10	.	.	.
18637	4223	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4223	2	146	146	CD
18637	4223	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4223	4	Smiley	Smiley	NNP
18637	4223	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4223	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4223	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4223	8	Holm	Holm	NNP
18637	4223	9	,	,	,
18637	4223	10	285	285	CD
18637	4223	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4223	12	355	355	CD
18637	4223	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4223	14	1932	1932	CD
18637	4223	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4223	16	;	;	:
18637	4223	17	Koenig	Koenig	NNP
18637	4223	18	_	_	NNP
18637	4223	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	4223	20	_	_	NNP
18637	4223	21	Flynn	Flynn	NNP
18637	4223	22	,	,	,
18637	4223	23	285	285	CD
18637	4223	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4223	25	375	375	CD
18637	4223	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4223	27	1932	1932	CD
18637	4223	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4223	29	;	;	:
18637	4223	30	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	4223	31	_	_	NNP
18637	4223	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	4223	33	_	_	NNP
18637	4223	34	Becker	Becker	NNP
18637	4223	35	,	,	,
18637	4223	36	285	285	CD
18637	4223	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4223	38	380	380	CD
18637	4223	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4223	40	1932	1932	CD
18637	4223	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4223	42	.	.	.
18637	4224	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4224	2	147	147	CD
18637	4224	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4224	4	46	46	CD
18637	4224	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4224	6	.	.	.
18637	4225	1	21	21	CD
18637	4225	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4225	3	1929	1929	CD
18637	4225	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4225	5	.	.	.
18637	4226	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4226	2	148	148	CD
18637	4226	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4226	4	37	37	CD
18637	4226	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4226	6	.	.	.
18637	4227	1	13	13	CD
18637	4227	2	,	,	,
18637	4227	3	14	14	CD
18637	4227	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4227	5	1911	1911	CD
18637	4227	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4227	7	.	.	.
18637	4228	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4228	2	149	149	CD
18637	4228	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4228	4	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	4228	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4228	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4228	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4228	8	Broom	Broom	NNP
18637	4228	9	,	,	,
18637	4228	10	287	287	CD
18637	4228	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4228	12	1	1	CD
18637	4228	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4228	14	1932	1932	CD
18637	4228	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4228	16	.	.	.
18637	4229	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4229	2	150	150	CD
18637	4229	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4229	4	328	328	CD
18637	4229	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4229	6	549	549	CD
18637	4229	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4229	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	4229	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4229	10	.	.	.
18637	4230	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4230	2	151	151	CD
18637	4230	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4230	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4230	5	.	.	.
18637	4231	1	556	556	CD
18637	4231	2	,	,	,
18637	4231	3	566	566	CD
18637	4231	4	.	.	.
18637	4232	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4232	2	152	152	CD
18637	4232	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4232	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4232	5	.	.	.
18637	4233	1	570	570	CD
18637	4233	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4233	3	571	571	CD
18637	4233	4	.	.	.
18637	4234	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4234	2	153	153	CD
18637	4234	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4234	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	4234	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	4234	6	Yarbrough	Yarbrough	NNP
18637	4234	7	,	,	,
18637	4234	8	110	110	CD
18637	4234	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4234	10	651	651	CD
18637	4234	11	,	,	,
18637	4234	12	661	661	CD
18637	4234	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4234	14	1884	1884	CD
18637	4234	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4234	16	;	;	:
18637	4234	17	United	United	NNP
18637	4234	18	States	States	NNP
18637	4234	19	_	_	NNP
18637	4234	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	4234	21	_	_	NNP
18637	4234	22	Mosley	Mosley	NNP
18637	4234	23	,	,	,
18637	4234	24	238	238	CD
18637	4234	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4234	26	383	383	CD
18637	4234	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4234	28	1915	1915	CD
18637	4234	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4234	30	;	;	:
18637	4234	31	United	United	NNP
18637	4234	32	States	States	NNP
18637	4234	33	_	_	NNP
18637	4234	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	4234	35	_	_	NNP
18637	4234	36	Saylor	Saylor	NNP
18637	4234	37	,	,	,
18637	4234	38	322	322	CD
18637	4234	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4234	40	385	385	CD
18637	4234	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4234	42	1944	1944	CD
18637	4234	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4234	44	.	.	.
18637	4235	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4235	2	154	154	CD
18637	4235	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4235	4	In	in	IN
18637	4235	5	re	re	FW
18637	4235	6	Coy	Coy	NNP
18637	4235	7	,	,	,
18637	4235	8	127	127	CD
18637	4235	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4235	10	731	731	CD
18637	4235	11	,	,	,
18637	4235	12	752	752	CD
18637	4235	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4235	14	1888	1888	CD
18637	4235	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4235	16	.	.	.
18637	4236	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4236	2	155	155	CD
18637	4236	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4236	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	4236	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	4236	6	Siebold	Siebold	NNP
18637	4236	7	,	,	,
18637	4236	8	100	100	CD
18637	4236	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4236	10	371	371	CD
18637	4236	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4236	12	1880	1880	CD
18637	4236	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4236	14	;	;	:
18637	4236	15	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	4236	16	parte	parte	VBZ
18637	4236	17	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	4236	18	,	,	,
18637	4236	19	100	100	CD
18637	4236	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4236	21	309	309	CD
18637	4236	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4236	23	1880	1880	CD
18637	4236	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4236	25	;	;	:
18637	4236	26	United	United	NNP
18637	4236	27	States	States	NNP
18637	4236	28	_	_	NNP
18637	4236	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	4236	30	_	_	NNP
18637	4236	31	Gale	Gale	NNP
18637	4236	32	,	,	,
18637	4236	33	109	109	CD
18637	4236	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4236	35	65	65	CD
18637	4236	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4236	37	1883	1883	CD
18637	4236	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4236	39	.	.	.
18637	4237	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4237	2	156	156	CD
18637	4237	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4237	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4237	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4237	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4237	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4237	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4237	9	Wurzbach	Wurzbach	NNP
18637	4237	10	,	,	,
18637	4237	11	280	280	CD
18637	4237	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4237	13	396	396	CD
18637	4237	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4237	15	1930	1930	CD
18637	4237	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4237	17	.	.	.
18637	4238	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4238	2	157	157	CD
18637	4238	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4238	4	Newberry	Newberry	NNP
18637	4238	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4238	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4238	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4238	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4238	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4238	10	,	,	,
18637	4238	11	256	256	CD
18637	4238	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4238	13	232	232	CD
18637	4238	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4238	15	1921	1921	CD
18637	4238	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4238	17	.	.	.
18637	4239	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4239	2	158	158	CD
18637	4239	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4239	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4239	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4239	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4239	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4239	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4239	9	Classic	Classic	NNP
18637	4239	10	,	,	,
18637	4239	11	313	313	CD
18637	4239	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4239	13	299	299	CD
18637	4239	14	,	,	,
18637	4239	15	318	318	CD
18637	4239	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4239	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	4239	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4239	19	.	.	.
18637	4240	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4240	2	159	159	CD
18637	4240	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4240	4	Barry	Barry	NNP
18637	4240	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4240	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4240	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4240	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4240	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4240	10	ex	ex	NNP
18637	4240	11	rel	rel	NN
18637	4240	12	.	.	.
18637	4241	1	Cunningham	Cunningham	NNP
18637	4241	2	,	,	,
18637	4241	3	279	279	CD
18637	4241	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4241	5	597	597	CD
18637	4241	6	,	,	,
18637	4241	7	616	616	CD
18637	4241	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4241	9	1929	1929	CD
18637	4241	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4241	11	.	.	.
18637	4242	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4242	2	160	160	CD
18637	4242	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4242	4	In	in	IN
18637	4242	5	re	re	NNP
18637	4242	6	Loney	Loney	NNP
18637	4242	7	,	,	,
18637	4242	8	134	134	CD
18637	4242	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4242	10	372	372	CD
18637	4242	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4242	12	1890	1890	CD
18637	4242	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4242	14	.	.	.
18637	4243	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4243	2	161	161	CD
18637	4243	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4243	4	Cannon	Cannon	NNP
18637	4243	5	's	's	POS
18637	4243	6	Precedents	Precedents	NNPS
18637	4243	7	of	of	IN
18637	4243	8	the	the	DT
18637	4243	9	House	House	NNP
18637	4243	10	of	of	IN
18637	4243	11	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	4243	12	,	,	,
18637	4243	13	VI	VI	NNP
18637	4243	14	:	:	:
18637	4243	15	§§	§§	NNP
18637	4243	16	72	72	CD
18637	4243	17	-	-	SYM
18637	4243	18	74	74	CD
18637	4243	19	,	,	,
18637	4243	20	180	180	CD
18637	4243	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4243	22	1936	1936	CD
18637	4243	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4243	24	.	.	.
18637	4244	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4244	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	4244	3	.	.	.
18637	4244	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4244	5	Newberry	Newberry	NNP
18637	4244	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4244	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4244	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4244	9	United	United	NNP
18637	4244	10	States	States	NNP
18637	4244	11	,	,	,
18637	4244	12	256	256	CD
18637	4244	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4244	14	232	232	CD
18637	4244	15	,	,	,
18637	4244	16	258	258	CD
18637	4244	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4244	18	1921	1921	CD
18637	4244	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4244	20	.	.	.
18637	4245	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4245	2	162	162	CD
18637	4245	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4245	4	Barry	Barry	NNP
18637	4245	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4245	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4245	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4245	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4245	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4245	10	ex	ex	NNP
18637	4245	11	rel	rel	NN
18637	4245	12	.	.	.
18637	4246	1	Cunningham	Cunningham	NNP
18637	4246	2	,	,	,
18637	4246	3	279	279	CD
18637	4246	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4246	5	597	597	CD
18637	4246	6	,	,	,
18637	4246	7	614	614	CD
18637	4246	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4246	9	1929	1929	CD
18637	4246	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4246	11	.	.	.
18637	4247	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4247	2	163	163	CD
18637	4247	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4247	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4247	5	.	.	.
18637	4248	1	615	615	CD
18637	4248	2	.	.	.
18637	4249	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4249	2	164	164	CD
18637	4249	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4249	4	Hinds	Hinds	NNP
18637	4249	5	'	'	POS
18637	4249	6	Precedents	Precedents	NNPS
18637	4249	7	of	of	IN
18637	4249	8	the	the	DT
18637	4249	9	House	House	NNP
18637	4249	10	of	of	IN
18637	4249	11	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	4249	12	,	,	,
18637	4249	13	IV	IV	NNP
18637	4249	14	:	:	:
18637	4249	15	§	§	NNP
18637	4249	16	2895	2895	CD
18637	4249	17	-	-	SYM
18637	4249	18	2905	2905	CD
18637	4249	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4249	20	1907	1907	CD
18637	4249	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4249	22	.	.	.
18637	4250	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4250	2	165	165	CD
18637	4250	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4250	4	144	144	CD
18637	4250	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4250	6	1	1	CD
18637	4250	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4250	8	1892	1892	CD
18637	4250	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4250	10	.	.	.
18637	4251	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4251	2	166	166	CD
18637	4251	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4251	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4251	5	.	.	.
18637	4252	1	5	5	CD
18637	4252	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4252	3	6	6	CD
18637	4252	4	.	.	.
18637	4253	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4253	2	167	167	CD
18637	4253	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4253	4	Rule	rule	NN
18637	4253	5	V.	v.	NN
18637	4253	6	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4253	7	168	168	CD
18637	4253	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4253	9	Hinds	Hinds	NNPS
18637	4253	10	'	'	POS
18637	4253	11	Precedents	Precedents	NNPS
18637	4253	12	of	of	IN
18637	4253	13	the	the	DT
18637	4253	14	House	House	NNP
18637	4253	15	of	of	IN
18637	4253	16	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	4253	17	,	,	,
18637	4253	18	IV	IV	NNP
18637	4253	19	:	:	:
18637	4253	20	§	§	NNP
18637	4253	21	2910	2910	CD
18637	4253	22	-	-	SYM
18637	4253	23	2915	2915	CD
18637	4253	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4253	25	1907	1907	CD
18637	4253	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4253	27	;	;	:
18637	4253	28	Cannon	Cannon	NNP
18637	4253	29	's	's	POS
18637	4253	30	Precedents	Precedents	NNPS
18637	4253	31	of	of	IN
18637	4253	32	the	the	DT
18637	4253	33	House	House	NNP
18637	4253	34	of	of	IN
18637	4253	35	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	4253	36	,	,	,
18637	4253	37	VI	VI	NNP
18637	4253	38	:	:	:
18637	4253	39	§§	§§	NNP
18637	4253	40	645	645	CD
18637	4253	41	,	,	,
18637	4253	42	646	646	CD
18637	4253	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4253	44	1936	1936	CD
18637	4253	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4253	46	.	.	.
18637	4254	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4254	2	169	169	CD
18637	4254	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4254	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4254	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4254	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4254	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4254	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4254	9	Ballin	Ballin	NNP
18637	4254	10	,	,	,
18637	4254	11	144	144	CD
18637	4254	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4254	13	1	1	CD
18637	4254	14	,	,	,
18637	4254	15	5	5	CD
18637	4254	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4254	17	1892	1892	CD
18637	4254	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4254	19	.	.	.
18637	4255	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4255	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	4255	3	,	,	,
18637	4255	4	of	of	IN
18637	4255	5	course	course	NN
18637	4255	6	,	,	,
18637	4255	7	by	by	IN
18637	4255	8	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	4255	9	of	of	IN
18637	4255	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4255	11	power	power	NN
18637	4255	12	to	to	TO
18637	4255	13	determine	determine	VB
18637	4255	14	"	"	``
18637	4255	15	rules	rule	NNS
18637	4255	16	of	of	IN
18637	4255	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4255	18	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	4255	19	"	"	''
18637	4255	20	that	that	WDT
18637	4255	21	the	the	DT
18637	4255	22	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	4255	23	enables	enable	VBZ
18637	4255	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4255	25	members	member	NNS
18637	4255	26	to	to	TO
18637	4255	27	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	4255	28	the	the	DT
18637	4255	29	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	4255	30	of	of	IN
18637	4255	31	business	business	NN
18637	4255	32	by	by	IN
18637	4255	33	what	what	WP
18637	4255	34	are	be	VBP
18637	4255	35	termed	term	VBN
18637	4255	36	"	"	``
18637	4255	37	filibusters	filibuster	NNS
18637	4255	38	"	"	''
18637	4255	39	.	.	.
18637	4256	1	The	the	DT
18637	4256	2	question	question	NN
18637	4256	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	4256	4	been	be	VBN
18637	4256	5	raised	raise	VBN
18637	4256	6	whether	whether	IN
18637	4256	7	the	the	DT
18637	4256	8	rules	rule	NNS
18637	4256	9	which	which	WDT
18637	4256	10	support	support	VBP
18637	4256	11	a	a	DT
18637	4256	12	filibuster	filibuster	NN
18637	4256	13	are	be	VBP
18637	4256	14	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	4256	15	compatible	compatible	JJ
18637	4256	16	with	with	IN
18637	4256	17	the	the	DT
18637	4256	18	clause	clause	NN
18637	4256	19	in	in	IN
18637	4256	20	the	the	DT
18637	4256	21	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	4256	22	section	section	NN
18637	4256	23	:	:	:
18637	4256	24	"	"	``
18637	4256	25	A	a	DT
18637	4256	26	majority	majority	NN
18637	4256	27	of	of	IN
18637	4256	28	each	each	DT
18637	4256	29	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4256	30	House	House	NNP
18637	4256	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4256	32	shall	shall	MD
18637	4256	33	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	4256	34	a	a	DT
18637	4256	35	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	4256	36	to	to	TO
18637	4256	37	do	do	VB
18637	4256	38	business	business	NN
18637	4256	39	"	"	''
18637	4256	40	.	.	.
18637	4257	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4257	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4257	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4257	4	Franklin	Franklin	NNP
18637	4257	5	Burdette	Burdette	NNP
18637	4257	6	,	,	,
18637	4257	7	Filibustering	filibuster	VBG
18637	4257	8	in	in	IN
18637	4257	9	the	the	DT
18637	4257	10	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	4257	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4257	12	Princeton	Princeton	NNP
18637	4257	13	University	University	NNP
18637	4257	14	Press	Press	NNP
18637	4257	15	,	,	,
18637	4257	16	1940	1940	CD
18637	4257	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4257	18	,	,	,
18637	4257	19	6	6	CD
18637	4257	20	,	,	,
18637	4257	21	61	61	CD
18637	4257	22	,	,	,
18637	4257	23	111	111	CD
18637	4257	24	-	-	SYM
18637	4257	25	112	112	CD
18637	4257	26	,	,	,
18637	4257	27	227	227	CD
18637	4257	28	-	-	SYM
18637	4257	29	229	229	CD
18637	4257	30	,	,	,
18637	4257	31	232	232	CD
18637	4257	32	-	-	SYM
18637	4257	33	233	233	CD
18637	4257	34	,	,	,
18637	4257	35	237	237	CD
18637	4257	36	-	-	SYM
18637	4257	37	238	238	CD
18637	4257	38	.	.	.
18637	4258	1	The	the	DT
18637	4258	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	4258	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	4258	4	"	"	``
18637	4258	5	a	a	DT
18637	4258	6	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	4258	7	body	body	NN
18637	4258	8	"	"	''
18637	4258	9	.	.	.
18637	4259	1	McGrain	McGrain	NNP
18637	4259	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4259	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4259	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4259	5	Daugherty	Daugherty	NNP
18637	4259	6	,	,	,
18637	4259	7	273	273	CD
18637	4259	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4259	9	139	139	CD
18637	4259	10	,	,	,
18637	4259	11	181	181	CD
18637	4259	12	-	-	SYM
18637	4259	13	182	182	CD
18637	4259	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4259	15	1927	1927	CD
18637	4259	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4259	17	.	.	.
18637	4260	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	4260	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4260	3	rules	rule	NNS
18637	4260	4	remain	remain	VBP
18637	4260	5	in	in	IN
18637	4260	6	force	force	NN
18637	4260	7	from	from	IN
18637	4260	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4260	9	to	to	IN
18637	4260	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4260	11	except	except	IN
18637	4260	12	as	as	IN
18637	4260	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4260	14	are	be	VBP
18637	4260	15	changed	change	VBN
18637	4260	16	from	from	IN
18637	4260	17	time	time	NN
18637	4260	18	to	to	IN
18637	4260	19	time	time	NN
18637	4260	20	,	,	,
18637	4260	21	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	4260	22	those	those	DT
18637	4260	23	of	of	IN
18637	4260	24	the	the	DT
18637	4260	25	House	House	NNP
18637	4260	26	are	be	VBP
18637	4260	27	readopted	readopte	VBN
18637	4260	28	at	at	IN
18637	4260	29	the	the	DT
18637	4260	30	outset	outset	NN
18637	4260	31	of	of	IN
18637	4260	32	each	each	DT
18637	4260	33	new	new	JJ
18637	4260	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4260	35	.	.	.
18637	4261	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4261	2	170	170	CD
18637	4261	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4261	4	286	286	CD
18637	4261	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4261	6	6	6	CD
18637	4261	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4261	8	1932	1932	CD
18637	4261	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4261	10	.	.	.
18637	4262	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4262	2	171	171	CD
18637	4262	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4262	4	338	338	CD
18637	4262	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4262	6	84	84	CD
18637	4262	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4262	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	4262	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4262	10	.	.	.
18637	4263	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4263	2	172	172	CD
18637	4263	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4263	4	Title	Title	NNP
18637	4263	5	22	22	CD
18637	4263	6	,	,	,
18637	4263	7	§	§	NNP
18637	4263	8	2501	2501	CD
18637	4263	9	.	.	.
18637	4264	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4264	2	173	173	CD
18637	4264	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4264	4	338	338	CD
18637	4264	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4264	6	at	at	IN
18637	4264	7	93	93	CD
18637	4264	8	-	-	SYM
18637	4264	9	95	95	CD
18637	4264	10	,	,	,
18637	4264	11	citing	cite	VBG
18637	4264	12	Field	Field	NNP
18637	4264	13	_	_	NNP
18637	4264	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	4264	15	_	_	NNP
18637	4264	16	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	4264	17	,	,	,
18637	4264	18	143	143	CD
18637	4264	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4264	20	649	649	CD
18637	4264	21	,	,	,
18637	4264	22	669	669	CD
18637	4264	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	4264	24	673	673	CD
18637	4264	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4264	26	1892	1892	CD
18637	4264	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4264	28	;	;	:
18637	4264	29	United	United	NNP
18637	4264	30	States	States	NNP
18637	4264	31	_	_	NNP
18637	4264	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	4264	33	_	_	NNP
18637	4264	34	Ballin	Ballin	NNP
18637	4264	35	,	,	,
18637	4264	36	144	144	CD
18637	4264	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4264	38	1	1	CD
18637	4264	39	,	,	,
18637	4264	40	5	5	CD
18637	4264	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4264	42	1892	1892	CD
18637	4264	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4264	44	;	;	:
18637	4264	45	and	and	CC
18637	4264	46	other	other	JJ
18637	4264	47	cases	case	NNS
18637	4264	48	.	.	.
18637	4265	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4265	2	174	174	CD
18637	4265	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4265	4	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	4265	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4265	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4265	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4265	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4265	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4265	10	,	,	,
18637	4265	11	202	202	CD
18637	4265	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4265	13	344	344	CD
18637	4265	14	,	,	,
18637	4265	15	356	356	CD
18637	4265	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4265	17	1906	1906	CD
18637	4265	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4265	19	.	.	.
18637	4266	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4266	2	175	175	CD
18637	4266	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4266	4	In	in	IN
18637	4266	5	re	re	IN
18637	4266	6	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	4266	7	,	,	,
18637	4266	8	166	166	CD
18637	4266	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4266	10	661	661	CD
18637	4266	11	,	,	,
18637	4266	12	669	669	CD
18637	4266	13	,	,	,
18637	4266	14	670	670	CD
18637	4266	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4266	16	1897	1897	CD
18637	4266	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4266	18	.	.	.
18637	4267	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4267	2	176	176	CD
18637	4267	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4267	4	I	I	NNP
18637	4267	5	Story	Story	NNP
18637	4267	6	,	,	,
18637	4267	7	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	4267	8	,	,	,
18637	4267	9	§	â§	NN
18637	4267	10	840	840	CD
18637	4267	11	,	,	,
18637	4267	12	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	4267	13	with	with	IN
18637	4267	14	approval	approval	NN
18637	4267	15	in	in	IN
18637	4267	16	Field	Field	NNP
18637	4267	17	_	_	NNP
18637	4267	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	4267	19	_	_	NNP
18637	4267	20	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	4267	21	,	,	,
18637	4267	22	143	143	CD
18637	4267	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4267	24	649	649	CD
18637	4267	25	,	,	,
18637	4267	26	670	670	CD
18637	4267	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4267	28	1892	1892	CD
18637	4267	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4267	30	.	.	.
18637	4268	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4268	2	177	177	CD
18637	4268	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4268	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4268	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4268	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4268	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4268	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4268	9	Ballin	Ballin	NNP
18637	4268	10	,	,	,
18637	4268	11	144	144	CD
18637	4268	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4268	13	1	1	CD
18637	4268	14	,	,	,
18637	4268	15	4	4	CD
18637	4268	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4268	17	1892	1892	CD
18637	4268	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4268	19	.	.	.
18637	4269	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4269	2	178	178	CD
18637	4269	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4269	4	Field	Field	NNP
18637	4269	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4269	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4269	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4269	8	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	4269	9	,	,	,
18637	4269	10	143	143	CD
18637	4269	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4269	12	649	649	CD
18637	4269	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4269	14	1892	1892	CD
18637	4269	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4269	16	;	;	:
18637	4269	17	Flint	Flint	NNP
18637	4269	18	_	_	NNP
18637	4269	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	4269	20	_	_	NNP
18637	4269	21	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	4269	22	Tracy	Tracy	NNP
18637	4269	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4269	24	,	,	,
18637	4269	25	220	220	CD
18637	4269	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4269	27	107	107	CD
18637	4269	28	,	,	,
18637	4269	29	143	143	CD
18637	4269	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4269	31	1911	1911	CD
18637	4269	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4269	33	.	.	.
18637	4270	1	A	a	DT
18637	4270	2	parallel	parallel	JJ
18637	4270	3	rule	rule	NN
18637	4270	4	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	4270	5	in	in	IN
18637	4270	6	the	the	DT
18637	4270	7	case	case	NN
18637	4270	8	of	of	IN
18637	4270	9	a	a	DT
18637	4270	10	duly	duly	RB
18637	4270	11	authenticated	authenticate	VBN
18637	4270	12	official	official	JJ
18637	4270	13	notice	notice	NN
18637	4270	14	to	to	IN
18637	4270	15	the	the	DT
18637	4270	16	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	4270	17	of	of	IN
18637	4270	18	State	State	NNP
18637	4270	19	that	that	WDT
18637	4270	20	a	a	DT
18637	4270	21	State	state	NN
18637	4270	22	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	4270	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	4270	24	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	4270	25	a	a	DT
18637	4270	26	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	4270	27	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	4270	28	to	to	IN
18637	4270	29	the	the	DT
18637	4270	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	4270	31	.	.	.
18637	4271	1	Leser	Leser	NNP
18637	4271	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4271	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4271	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4271	5	Garnett	Garnett	NNP
18637	4271	6	,	,	,
18637	4271	7	258	258	CD
18637	4271	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4271	9	130	130	CD
18637	4271	10	,	,	,
18637	4271	11	137	137	CD
18637	4271	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4271	13	1922	1922	CD
18637	4271	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4271	15	;	;	:
18637	4271	16	_	_	NNP
18637	4271	17	see	see	VB
18637	4271	18	also	also	RB
18637	4271	19	_	_	NNP
18637	4271	20	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	4271	21	_	_	NNP
18637	4271	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	4271	23	_	_	NNP
18637	4271	24	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	4271	25	,	,	,
18637	4271	26	307	307	CD
18637	4271	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4271	28	433	433	CD
18637	4271	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4271	30	1939	1939	CD
18637	4271	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4271	32	.	.	.
18637	4272	1	In	in	IN
18637	4272	2	Christoffel	Christoffel	NNP
18637	4272	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4272	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	4272	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4272	6	United	United	NNP
18637	4272	7	States	States	NNP
18637	4272	8	,	,	,
18637	4272	9	338	338	CD
18637	4272	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4272	11	84	84	CD
18637	4272	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4272	13	1949	1949	CD
18637	4272	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4272	15	,	,	,
18637	4272	16	a	a	DT
18637	4272	17	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	4272	18	divided	divide	VBN
18637	4272	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4272	20	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	4272	21	that	that	IN
18637	4272	22	,	,	,
18637	4272	23	in	in	IN
18637	4272	24	a	a	DT
18637	4272	25	case	case	NN
18637	4272	26	brought	bring	VBN
18637	4272	27	under	under	IN
18637	4272	28	the	the	DT
18637	4272	29	Perjury	Perjury	NNP
18637	4272	30	Statute	Statute	NNP
18637	4272	31	of	of	IN
18637	4272	32	the	the	DT
18637	4272	33	District	District	NNP
18637	4272	34	of	of	IN
18637	4272	35	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	4272	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4272	37	§	§	NNP
18637	4272	38	22	22	CD
18637	4272	39	-	-	SYM
18637	4272	40	2501	2501	CD
18637	4272	41	of	of	IN
18637	4272	42	the	the	DT
18637	4272	43	D.C.	D.C.	NNP
18637	4272	44	Code	Code	NNP
18637	4272	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4272	46	for	for	IN
18637	4272	47	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	4272	48	perjurious	perjurious	JJ
18637	4272	49	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	4272	50	before	before	IN
18637	4272	51	a	a	DT
18637	4272	52	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	4272	53	of	of	IN
18637	4272	54	the	the	DT
18637	4272	55	House	House	NNP
18637	4272	56	of	of	IN
18637	4272	57	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	4272	58	,	,	,
18637	4272	59	the	the	DT
18637	4272	60	trial	trial	NN
18637	4272	61	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4272	62	erred	err	VBD
18637	4272	63	in	in	IN
18637	4272	64	charging	charge	VBG
18637	4272	65	the	the	DT
18637	4272	66	jury	jury	NN
18637	4272	67	that	that	IN
18637	4272	68	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4272	69	was	be	VBD
18637	4272	70	free	free	JJ
18637	4272	71	to	to	TO
18637	4272	72	ignore	ignore	VB
18637	4272	73	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	4272	74	that	that	IN
18637	4272	75	less	less	JJR
18637	4272	76	than	than	IN
18637	4272	77	a	a	DT
18637	4272	78	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	4272	79	of	of	IN
18637	4272	80	the	the	DT
18637	4272	81	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	4272	82	was	be	VBD
18637	4272	83	in	in	IN
18637	4272	84	attendance	attendance	NN
18637	4272	85	when	when	WRB
18637	4272	86	the	the	DT
18637	4272	87	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	4272	88	perjury	perjury	NN
18637	4272	89	was	be	VBD
18637	4272	90	committed	commit	VBN
18637	4272	91	.	.	.
18637	4273	1	Four	four	CD
18637	4273	2	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	4273	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	4273	4	;	;	:
18637	4273	5	and	and	CC
18637	4273	6	curiously	curiously	RB
18637	4273	7	enough	enough	JJ
18637	4273	8	only	only	RB
18637	4273	9	four	four	CD
18637	4273	10	of	of	IN
18637	4273	11	the	the	DT
18637	4273	12	majority	majority	NN
18637	4273	13	were	be	VBD
18637	4273	14	present	present	JJ
18637	4273	15	when	when	WRB
18637	4273	16	the	the	DT
18637	4273	17	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	4273	18	was	be	VBD
18637	4273	19	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	4273	20	,	,	,
18637	4273	21	the	the	DT
18637	4273	22	fifth	fifth	JJ
18637	4273	23	being	be	VBG
18637	4273	24	indisposed	indispose	VBN
18637	4273	25	.	.	.
18637	4274	1	Remarks	Remarks	NNPS
18637	4274	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4274	3	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	4274	4	in	in	IN
18637	4274	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4274	6	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	4274	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	4274	8	in	in	IN
18637	4274	9	United	United	NNP
18637	4274	10	States	States	NNP
18637	4274	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4274	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	4274	13	_	_	NNP
18637	4274	14	Bryan	Bryan	NNP
18637	4274	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4274	16	339	339	CD
18637	4274	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4274	18	323	323	CD
18637	4274	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4274	20	1950	1950	CD
18637	4274	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4274	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4274	23	,	,	,
18637	4274	24	in	in	IN
18637	4274	25	which	which	WDT
18637	4274	26	the	the	DT
18637	4274	27	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	4274	28	in	in	IN
18637	4274	29	Christoffel	Christoffel	NNP
18637	4274	30	was	be	VBD
18637	4274	31	held	hold	VBN
18637	4274	32	to	to	TO
18637	4274	33	be	be	VB
18637	4274	34	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	4274	35	:	:	:
18637	4274	36	"	"	``
18637	4274	37	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4274	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	4274	39	ironic	ironic	JJ
18637	4274	40	that	that	IN
18637	4274	41	this	this	DT
18637	4274	42	interference	interference	NN
18637	4274	43	with	with	IN
18637	4274	44	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	4274	45	procedures	procedure	NNS
18637	4274	46	was	be	VBD
18637	4274	47	promulgated	promulgate	VBN
18637	4274	48	by	by	IN
18637	4274	49	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	4274	50	within	within	IN
18637	4274	51	the	the	DT
18637	4274	52	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4274	53	of	of	IN
18637	4274	54	the	the	DT
18637	4274	55	very	very	RB
18637	4274	56	right	right	NN
18637	4274	57	of	of	IN
18637	4274	58	absentee	absentee	NN
18637	4274	59	participation	participation	NN
18637	4274	60	denied	deny	VBN
18637	4274	61	to	to	IN
18637	4274	62	Congressmen	congressman	NNS
18637	4274	63	.	.	.
18637	4274	64	"	"	''
18637	4275	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	4275	2	.	.	.
18637	4276	1	344	344	CD
18637	4276	2	.	.	.
18637	4277	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4277	2	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	4277	3	unlikely	unlikely	JJ
18637	4277	4	that	that	IN
18637	4277	5	the	the	DT
18637	4277	6	Christoffel	Christoffel	NNP
18637	4277	7	decision	decision	NN
18637	4277	8	seriously	seriously	RB
18637	4277	9	undermines	undermine	VBZ
18637	4277	10	Field	Field	NNP
18637	4277	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4277	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	4277	13	_	_	NNP
18637	4277	14	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	4277	15	.	.	.
18637	4278	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4278	2	179	179	CD
18637	4278	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4278	4	Page	Page	NNP
18637	4278	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4278	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4278	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4278	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4278	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4278	10	,	,	,
18637	4278	11	127	127	CD
18637	4278	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4278	13	67	67	CD
18637	4278	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4278	15	1888	1888	CD
18637	4278	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4278	17	.	.	.
18637	4279	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4279	2	180	180	CD
18637	4279	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4279	4	Long	Long	NNP
18637	4279	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4279	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4279	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4279	8	Ansell	Ansell	NNP
18637	4279	9	,	,	,
18637	4279	10	293	293	CD
18637	4279	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4279	12	76	76	CD
18637	4279	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4279	14	1934	1934	CD
18637	4279	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4279	16	.	.	.
18637	4280	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4280	2	181	181	CD
18637	4280	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4280	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4280	5	.	.	.
18637	4281	1	83	83	CD
18637	4281	2	.	.	.
18637	4282	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4282	2	182	182	CD
18637	4282	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4282	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4282	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4282	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4282	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4282	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4282	9	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	4282	10	,	,	,
18637	4282	11	4	4	CD
18637	4282	12	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	4282	13	.	.	.
18637	4283	1	341	341	CD
18637	4283	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4283	3	1800	1800	CD
18637	4283	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4283	5	.	.	.
18637	4284	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4284	2	183	183	CD
18637	4284	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4284	4	Williamson	Williamson	NNP
18637	4284	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4284	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4284	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4284	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4284	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4284	10	,	,	,
18637	4284	11	207	207	CD
18637	4284	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4284	13	425	425	CD
18637	4284	14	,	,	,
18637	4284	15	446	446	CD
18637	4284	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4284	17	1908	1908	CD
18637	4284	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4284	19	.	.	.
18637	4285	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4285	2	184	184	CD
18637	4285	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4285	4	Kilbourn	Kilbourn	NNP
18637	4285	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4285	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4285	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4285	8	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	4285	9	,	,	,
18637	4285	10	103	103	CD
18637	4285	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4285	12	168	168	CD
18637	4285	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4285	14	1881	1881	CD
18637	4285	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4285	16	.	.	.
18637	4286	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4286	2	185	185	CD
18637	4286	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4286	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4286	5	.	.	.
18637	4287	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4287	2	186	186	CD
18637	4287	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4287	4	4	4	CD
18637	4287	5	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	4288	1	1	1	CD
18637	4288	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4288	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	4288	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4288	5	.	.	.
18637	4289	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4289	2	187	187	CD
18637	4289	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4289	4	Kilbourn	Kilbourn	NNP
18637	4289	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4289	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4289	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4289	8	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	4289	9	,	,	,
18637	4289	10	103	103	CD
18637	4289	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4289	12	168	168	CD
18637	4289	13	,	,	,
18637	4289	14	203	203	CD
18637	4289	15	,	,	,
18637	4289	16	204	204	CD
18637	4289	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4289	18	1881	1881	CD
18637	4289	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4289	20	.	.	.
18637	4290	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4290	2	188	188	CD
18637	4290	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4290	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4290	5	.	.	.
18637	4291	1	205	205	CD
18637	4291	2	.	.	.
18637	4292	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4292	2	189	189	CD
18637	4292	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4292	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4292	5	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	4292	6	for	for	IN
18637	4292	7	the	the	DT
18637	4292	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4292	9	in	in	IN
18637	4292	10	Tenney	Tenney	NNP
18637	4292	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4292	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	4292	13	_	_	NNP
18637	4292	14	Brandhove	Brandhove	NNP
18637	4292	15	,	,	,
18637	4292	16	341	341	CD
18637	4292	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4292	18	367	367	CD
18637	4292	19	,	,	,
18637	4292	20	377	377	CD
18637	4292	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4292	22	1951	1951	CD
18637	4292	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4292	24	.	.	.
18637	4293	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4293	2	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	4293	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	4293	4	:	:	:
18637	4293	5	"	"	``
18637	4293	6	*	*	NFP
18637	4293	7	*	*	NFP
18637	4293	8	*	*	NFP
18637	4293	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4293	10	do	do	VBP
18637	4293	11	not	not	RB
18637	4293	12	agree	agree	VB
18637	4293	13	that	that	IN
18637	4293	14	all	all	DT
18637	4293	15	abuses	abuse	NNS
18637	4293	16	of	of	IN
18637	4293	17	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	4293	18	committees	committee	NNS
18637	4293	19	are	be	VBP
18637	4293	20	solely	solely	RB
18637	4293	21	for	for	IN
18637	4293	22	the	the	DT
18637	4293	23	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	4293	24	body	body	NN
18637	4293	25	to	to	IN
18637	4293	26	police	police	NNS
18637	4293	27	.	.	.
18637	4294	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4294	2	are	be	VBP
18637	4294	3	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	4294	4	here	here	RB
18637	4294	5	with	with	IN
18637	4294	6	a	a	DT
18637	4294	7	right	right	NN
18637	4294	8	protected	protect	VBN
18637	4294	9	by	by	IN
18637	4294	10	the	the	DT
18637	4294	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	4294	12	--	--	:
18637	4294	13	the	the	DT
18637	4294	14	right	right	NN
18637	4294	15	of	of	IN
18637	4294	16	free	free	JJ
18637	4294	17	speech	speech	NN
18637	4294	18	.	.	.
18637	4295	1	The	the	DT
18637	4295	2	charge	charge	NN
18637	4295	3	*	*	NFP
18637	4295	4	*	*	NFP
18637	4295	5	*	*	NFP
18637	4295	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	4295	7	that	that	IN
18637	4295	8	a	a	DT
18637	4295	9	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	4295	10	committee	committee	NN
18637	4295	11	brought	bring	VBD
18637	4295	12	the	the	DT
18637	4295	13	weight	weight	NN
18637	4295	14	of	of	IN
18637	4295	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4295	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	4295	17	down	down	IN
18637	4295	18	on	on	IN
18637	4295	19	respondent	respondent	NN
18637	4295	20	for	for	IN
18637	4295	21	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	4295	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4295	23	right	right	NN
18637	4295	24	of	of	IN
18637	4295	25	free	free	JJ
18637	4295	26	speech	speech	NN
18637	4295	27	.	.	.
18637	4296	1	Reprisal	reprisal	NN
18637	4296	2	for	for	IN
18637	4296	3	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	4296	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	4296	5	as	as	RB
18637	4296	6	much	much	JJ
18637	4296	7	an	an	DT
18637	4296	8	abridgment	abridgment	NN
18637	4296	9	as	as	IN
18637	4296	10	a	a	DT
18637	4296	11	prior	prior	JJ
18637	4296	12	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	4296	13	.	.	.
18637	4297	1	If	if	IN
18637	4297	2	a	a	DT
18637	4297	3	committee	committee	NN
18637	4297	4	departs	depart	VBZ
18637	4297	5	so	so	RB
18637	4297	6	far	far	RB
18637	4297	7	from	from	IN
18637	4297	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4297	9	domain	domain	NN
18637	4297	10	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4297	11	as	as	IN
18637	4297	12	?	?	.
18637	4297	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4298	1	to	to	TO
18637	4298	2	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	4298	3	a	a	DT
18637	4298	4	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	4298	5	of	of	IN
18637	4298	6	a	a	DT
18637	4298	7	right	right	NN
18637	4298	8	protected	protect	VBN
18637	4298	9	by	by	IN
18637	4298	10	the	the	DT
18637	4298	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	4298	12	,	,	,
18637	4298	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4298	14	can	can	MD
18637	4298	15	think	think	VB
18637	4298	16	of	of	IN
18637	4298	17	no	no	DT
18637	4298	18	reason	reason	NN
18637	4298	19	why	why	WRB
18637	4298	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4298	21	should	should	MD
18637	4298	22	be	be	VB
18637	4298	23	immune	immune	JJ
18637	4298	24	"	"	''
18637	4298	25	.	.	.
18637	4299	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	4299	2	.	.	.
18637	4300	1	382	382	CD
18637	4300	2	.	.	.
18637	4301	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4301	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4301	3	also	also	RB
18637	4301	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4301	5	Barsky	Barsky	NNP
18637	4301	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4301	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4301	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4301	9	United	United	NNP
18637	4301	10	States	States	NNP
18637	4301	11	,	,	,
18637	4301	12	167	167	CD
18637	4301	13	F.	F.	NNP
18637	4301	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4301	15	2d	2d	NNP
18637	4301	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4301	17	241	241	CD
18637	4301	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4301	19	1948	1948	CD
18637	4301	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4301	21	;	;	:
18637	4301	22	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	4301	23	denied	denied	NNP
18637	4301	24	,	,	,
18637	4301	25	334	334	CD
18637	4301	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4301	27	843	843	CD
18637	4301	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4301	29	1948	1948	CD
18637	4301	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4301	31	.	.	.
18637	4302	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4302	2	190	190	CD
18637	4302	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4302	4	Hinds	Hinds	NNPS
18637	4302	5	'	'	POS
18637	4302	6	Precedents	Precedents	NNPS
18637	4302	7	of	of	IN
18637	4302	8	the	the	DT
18637	4302	9	House	House	NNP
18637	4302	10	of	of	IN
18637	4302	11	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	4302	12	,	,	,
18637	4302	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4302	14	:	:	:
18637	4302	15	§	§	NNP
18637	4302	16	493	493	CD
18637	4302	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4302	18	1907	1907	CD
18637	4302	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4302	20	;	;	:
18637	4302	21	Cannon	Cannon	NNP
18637	4302	22	's	's	POS
18637	4302	23	Precedents	Precedents	NNPS
18637	4302	24	of	of	IN
18637	4302	25	the	the	DT
18637	4302	26	House	House	NNP
18637	4302	27	of	of	IN
18637	4302	28	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	4302	29	,	,	,
18637	4302	30	VI	VI	NNP
18637	4302	31	:	:	:
18637	4302	32	§§	§§	NNP
18637	4302	33	63	63	CD
18637	4302	34	,	,	,
18637	4302	35	64	64	CD
18637	4302	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4302	37	1936	1936	CD
18637	4302	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4302	39	.	.	.
18637	4303	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4303	2	191	191	CD
18637	4303	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4303	4	Hinds	Hinds	NNP
18637	4303	5	'	'	POS
18637	4303	6	Precedents	Precedents	NNPS
18637	4303	7	of	of	IN
18637	4303	8	the	the	DT
18637	4303	9	House	House	NNP
18637	4303	10	of	of	IN
18637	4303	11	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	4303	12	,	,	,
18637	4303	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4303	14	:	:	:
18637	4303	15	§§	§§	NNP
18637	4303	16	496	496	CD
18637	4303	17	-	-	SYM
18637	4303	18	499	499	CD
18637	4303	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4303	20	1907	1907	CD
18637	4303	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4303	22	.	.	.
18637	4304	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4304	2	192	192	CD
18637	4304	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4304	4	34	34	CD
18637	4304	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4304	6	.	.	.
18637	4305	1	948	948	CD
18637	4305	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4305	3	1907	1907	CD
18637	4305	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4305	5	.	.	.
18637	4306	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4306	2	193	193	CD
18637	4306	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4306	4	35	35	CD
18637	4306	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4306	6	.	.	.
18637	4307	1	626	626	CD
18637	4307	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4307	3	1909	1909	CD
18637	4307	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4307	5	.	.	.
18637	4308	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4308	2	194	194	CD
18637	4308	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4308	4	The	the	DT
18637	4308	5	situation	situation	NN
18637	4308	6	gave	give	VBD
18637	4308	7	rise	rise	NN
18637	4308	8	to	to	IN
18637	4308	9	the	the	DT
18637	4308	10	case	case	NN
18637	4308	11	of	of	IN
18637	4308	12	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	4308	13	parte	parte	NN
18637	4308	14	Albert	Albert	NNP
18637	4308	15	Levitt	Levitt	NNP
18637	4308	16	,	,	,
18637	4308	17	Petitioner	Petitioner	NNP
18637	4308	18	,	,	,
18637	4308	19	302	302	CD
18637	4308	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4308	21	633	633	CD
18637	4308	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4308	23	1937	1937	CD
18637	4308	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4308	25	.	.	.
18637	4309	1	This	this	DT
18637	4309	2	was	be	VBD
18637	4309	3	the	the	DT
18637	4309	4	case	case	NN
18637	4309	5	in	in	IN
18637	4309	6	which	which	WDT
18637	4309	7	the	the	DT
18637	4309	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4309	9	declined	decline	VBD
18637	4309	10	to	to	TO
18637	4309	11	pass	pass	VB
18637	4309	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	4309	13	the	the	DT
18637	4309	14	validity	validity	NN
18637	4309	15	of	of	IN
18637	4309	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4309	17	Black	Black	NNP
18637	4309	18	's	's	POS
18637	4309	19	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	4309	20	.	.	.
18637	4310	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4310	2	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	4310	3	curious	curious	JJ
18637	4310	4	that	that	IN
18637	4310	5	the	the	DT
18637	4310	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4310	7	,	,	,
18637	4310	8	in	in	IN
18637	4310	9	rejecting	reject	VBG
18637	4310	10	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	4310	11	's	's	POS
18637	4310	12	application	application	NN
18637	4310	13	,	,	,
18637	4310	14	did	do	VBD
18637	4310	15	not	not	RB
18637	4310	16	point	point	VB
18637	4310	17	out	out	RP
18637	4310	18	that	that	IN
18637	4310	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4310	20	was	be	VBD
18637	4310	21	being	be	VBG
18637	4310	22	asked	ask	VBD
18637	4310	23	to	to	TO
18637	4310	24	assume	assume	VB
18637	4310	25	original	original	JJ
18637	4310	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	4310	27	contrary	contrary	RB
18637	4310	28	to	to	IN
18637	4310	29	the	the	DT
18637	4310	30	decision	decision	NN
18637	4310	31	in	in	IN
18637	4310	32	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	4310	33	_	_	NNP
18637	4310	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	4310	35	_	_	NNP
18637	4310	36	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	4310	37	,	,	,
18637	4310	38	1	1	CD
18637	4310	39	Cr	cr	NN
18637	4310	40	.	.	.
18637	4311	1	137	137	CD
18637	4311	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4311	3	1803	1803	CD
18637	4311	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4311	5	.	.	.
18637	4312	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4312	2	195	195	CD
18637	4312	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4312	4	I	I	NNP
18637	4312	5	Story	Story	NNP
18637	4312	6	,	,	,
18637	4312	7	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	4312	8	,	,	,
18637	4312	9	§	â§	NN
18637	4312	10	880	880	CD
18637	4312	11	.	.	.
18637	4313	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4313	2	196	196	CD
18637	4313	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4313	4	Twin	Twin	NNP
18637	4313	5	City	City	NNP
18637	4313	6	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	4313	7	.	.	.
18637	4314	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	4314	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4314	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4314	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4314	5	Nebeker	Nebeker	NNP
18637	4314	6	,	,	,
18637	4314	7	167	167	CD
18637	4314	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4314	9	196	196	CD
18637	4314	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4314	11	1897	1897	CD
18637	4314	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4314	13	.	.	.
18637	4315	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4315	2	197	197	CD
18637	4315	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4315	4	Millard	Millard	NNP
18637	4315	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4315	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4315	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4315	8	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	4315	9	,	,	,
18637	4315	10	202	202	CD
18637	4315	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4315	12	429	429	CD
18637	4315	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4315	14	1906	1906	CD
18637	4315	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4315	16	.	.	.
18637	4316	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4316	2	198	198	CD
18637	4316	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4316	4	Flint	Flint	NNP
18637	4316	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4316	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4316	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4316	8	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	4316	9	Tracy	Tracy	NNP
18637	4316	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4316	11	,	,	,
18637	4316	12	220	220	CD
18637	4316	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4316	14	107	107	CD
18637	4316	15	,	,	,
18637	4316	16	143	143	CD
18637	4316	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4316	18	1911	1911	CD
18637	4316	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4316	20	.	.	.
18637	4317	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4317	2	199	199	CD
18637	4317	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4317	4	Rainey	Rainey	NNP
18637	4317	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4317	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4317	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4317	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4317	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4317	10	,	,	,
18637	4317	11	232	232	CD
18637	4317	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4317	13	310	310	CD
18637	4317	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4317	15	1914	1914	CD
18637	4317	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4317	17	.	.	.
18637	4318	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4318	2	200	200	CD
18637	4318	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4318	4	La	La	NNP
18637	4318	5	Abra	Abra	NNP
18637	4318	6	Silver	Silver	NNP
18637	4318	7	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	4318	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4318	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4318	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	4318	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4318	12	United	United	NNP
18637	4318	13	States	States	NNP
18637	4318	14	,	,	,
18637	4318	15	175	175	CD
18637	4318	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4318	17	423	423	CD
18637	4318	18	,	,	,
18637	4318	19	453	453	CD
18637	4318	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4318	21	1899	1899	CD
18637	4318	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4318	23	.	.	.
18637	4319	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4319	2	201	201	CD
18637	4319	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4319	4	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	4319	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4319	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4319	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4319	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4319	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4319	10	,	,	,
18637	4319	11	286	286	CD
18637	4319	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4319	13	482	482	CD
18637	4319	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4319	15	1932	1932	CD
18637	4319	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4319	17	.	.	.
18637	4320	1	On	on	IN
18637	4320	2	one	one	CD
18637	4320	3	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	4320	4	in	in	IN
18637	4320	5	1936	1936	CD
18637	4320	6	,	,	,
18637	4320	7	delay	delay	NN
18637	4320	8	in	in	IN
18637	4320	9	presentation	presentation	NN
18637	4320	10	of	of	IN
18637	4320	11	a	a	DT
18637	4320	12	bill	bill	NN
18637	4320	13	enabled	enable	VBD
18637	4320	14	the	the	DT
18637	4320	15	President	President	NNP
18637	4320	16	to	to	TO
18637	4320	17	sign	sign	VB
18637	4320	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4320	19	23	23	CD
18637	4320	20	days	day	NNS
18637	4320	21	after	after	IN
18637	4320	22	the	the	DT
18637	4320	23	adjournment	adjournment	NN
18637	4320	24	of	of	IN
18637	4320	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4320	26	.	.	.
18637	4321	1	Schmeckebier	schmeckebier	RBR
18637	4321	2	,	,	,
18637	4321	3	Approval	approval	NN
18637	4321	4	of	of	IN
18637	4321	5	Bills	Bills	NNPS
18637	4321	6	After	after	IN
18637	4321	7	Adjournment	Adjournment	NNP
18637	4321	8	of	of	IN
18637	4321	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4321	10	,	,	,
18637	4321	11	33	33	CD
18637	4321	12	American	American	NNP
18637	4321	13	Political	Political	NNP
18637	4321	14	Science	Science	NNP
18637	4321	15	Review	Review	NNP
18637	4321	16	52	52	CD
18637	4321	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4321	18	1939	1939	CD
18637	4321	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4321	20	.	.	.
18637	4322	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4322	2	202	202	CD
18637	4322	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4322	4	Gardner	Gardner	NNP
18637	4322	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4322	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4322	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4322	8	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	4322	9	,	,	,
18637	4322	10	6	6	CD
18637	4322	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4322	12	.	.	.
18637	4323	1	499	499	CD
18637	4323	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4323	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	4323	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4323	5	.	.	.
18637	4324	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4324	2	203	203	CD
18637	4324	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4324	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4324	5	.	.	.
18637	4325	1	504	504	CD
18637	4325	2	.	.	.
18637	4326	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4326	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4326	3	also	also	RB
18637	4326	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4326	5	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
18637	4326	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4326	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4326	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4326	9	Salmon	Salmon	NNP
18637	4326	10	,	,	,
18637	4326	11	97	97	CD
18637	4326	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4326	13	381	381	CD
18637	4326	14	,	,	,
18637	4326	15	383	383	CD
18637	4326	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4326	17	1878	1878	CD
18637	4326	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4326	19	.	.	.
18637	4327	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4327	2	204	204	CD
18637	4327	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4327	4	Matthews	Matthews	NNP
18637	4327	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4327	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4327	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4327	8	Zane	Zane	NNP
18637	4327	9	,	,	,
18637	4327	10	7	7	CD
18637	4327	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4327	12	.	.	.
18637	4328	1	164	164	CD
18637	4328	2	,	,	,
18637	4328	3	211	211	CD
18637	4328	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4328	5	1822	1822	CD
18637	4328	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4328	7	.	.	.
18637	4329	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4329	2	205	205	CD
18637	4329	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4329	4	Lapeyre	Lapeyre	NNP
18637	4329	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4329	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4329	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4329	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4329	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4329	10	,	,	,
18637	4329	11	17	17	CD
18637	4329	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4329	13	.	.	.
18637	4330	1	191	191	CD
18637	4330	2	,	,	,
18637	4330	3	198	198	CD
18637	4330	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4330	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	4330	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4330	7	.	.	.
18637	4331	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4331	2	206	206	CD
18637	4331	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4331	4	Okanogan	Okanogan	NNP
18637	4331	5	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	4331	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4331	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4331	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4331	9	United	United	NNP
18637	4331	10	States	States	NNP
18637	4331	11	,	,	,
18637	4331	12	279	279	CD
18637	4331	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4331	14	655	655	CD
18637	4331	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4331	16	1929	1929	CD
18637	4331	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4331	18	.	.	.
18637	4332	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4332	2	207	207	CD
18637	4332	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4332	4	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	4332	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4332	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4332	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4332	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4332	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4332	10	,	,	,
18637	4332	11	302	302	CD
18637	4332	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4332	13	583	583	CD
18637	4332	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4332	15	1938	1938	CD
18637	4332	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4332	17	.	.	.
18637	4333	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4333	2	208	208	CD
18637	4333	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4333	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	4333	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	4334	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4334	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4334	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4334	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4334	5	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	4334	6	,	,	,
18637	4334	7	248	248	CD
18637	4334	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4334	9	276	276	CD
18637	4334	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4334	11	1919	1919	CD
18637	4334	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4334	13	.	.	.
18637	4335	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4335	2	209	209	CD
18637	4335	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4335	4	20	20	CD
18637	4335	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4335	6	.	.	.
18637	4336	1	92	92	CD
18637	4336	2	,	,	,
18637	4336	3	112	112	CD
18637	4336	4	,	,	,
18637	4336	5	113	113	CD
18637	4336	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4336	7	1874	1874	CD
18637	4336	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4336	9	.	.	.
18637	4337	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4337	2	210	210	CD
18637	4337	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4337	4	12	12	CD
18637	4337	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	4337	6	.	.	.
18637	4338	1	589	589	CD
18637	4338	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4338	3	1862	1862	CD
18637	4338	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4338	5	.	.	.
18637	4339	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4339	2	211	211	CD
18637	4339	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4339	4	54th	54th	JJ
18637	4339	5	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	4339	6	.	.	.
18637	4339	7	,	,	,
18637	4339	8	2d	2d	CD
18637	4339	9	sess	sess	NN
18637	4339	10	.	.	.
18637	4339	11	,	,	,
18637	4339	12	S.	S.	NNP
18637	4339	13	Doc	Doc	NNP
18637	4339	14	.	.	.
18637	4340	1	1335	1335	CD
18637	4340	2	;	;	:
18637	4340	3	Hinds	Hinds	NNP
18637	4340	4	'	'	POS
18637	4340	5	Precedents	Precedents	NNPS
18637	4340	6	of	of	IN
18637	4340	7	the	the	DT
18637	4340	8	House	House	NNP
18637	4340	9	of	of	IN
18637	4340	10	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	4340	11	,	,	,
18637	4340	12	IV	IV	NNP
18637	4340	13	:	:	:
18637	4340	14	§	§	NNP
18637	4340	15	3483	3483	CD
18637	4340	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4340	17	1907	1907	CD
18637	4340	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4340	19	.	.	.
18637	4341	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4341	2	212	212	CD
18637	4341	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4341	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4341	5	See	See	NNP
18637	4341	6	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	4341	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4341	8	,	,	,
18637	4341	9	Lend	lend	VB
18637	4341	10	Lease	Lease	NNP
18637	4341	11	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4341	12	of	of	IN
18637	4341	13	March	March	NNP
18637	4341	14	11	11	CD
18637	4341	15	,	,	,
18637	4341	16	1941	1941	CD
18637	4341	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4341	18	55	55	CD
18637	4341	19	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4341	20	.	.	.
18637	4342	1	31	31	CD
18637	4342	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4342	3	;	;	:
18637	4342	4	First	First	NNP
18637	4342	5	War	War	NNP
18637	4342	6	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	4342	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4342	8	of	of	IN
18637	4342	9	December	December	NNP
18637	4342	10	18	18	CD
18637	4342	11	,	,	,
18637	4342	12	1941	1941	CD
18637	4342	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4342	14	55	55	CD
18637	4342	15	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4342	16	.	.	.
18637	4343	1	838	838	CD
18637	4343	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4343	3	;	;	:
18637	4343	4	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	4343	5	Price	Price	NNP
18637	4343	6	Control	Control	NNP
18637	4343	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4343	8	of	of	IN
18637	4343	9	January	January	NNP
18637	4343	10	30	30	CD
18637	4343	11	,	,	,
18637	4343	12	1942	1942	CD
18637	4343	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4343	14	56	56	CD
18637	4343	15	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4343	16	.	.	.
18637	4344	1	23	23	CD
18637	4344	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4344	3	;	;	:
18637	4344	4	Stabilization	Stabilization	NNP
18637	4344	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4344	6	of	of	IN
18637	4344	7	October	October	NNP
18637	4344	8	2	2	CD
18637	4344	9	,	,	,
18637	4344	10	1942	1942	CD
18637	4344	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4344	12	56	56	CD
18637	4344	13	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4344	14	.	.	.
18637	4345	1	765	765	CD
18637	4345	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4345	3	;	;	:
18637	4345	4	War	War	NNP
18637	4345	5	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	4345	6	Disputes	Disputes	NNP
18637	4345	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4345	8	of	of	IN
18637	4345	9	June	June	NNP
18637	4345	10	25	25	CD
18637	4345	11	,	,	,
18637	4345	12	1943	1943	CD
18637	4345	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4345	14	57	57	CD
18637	4345	15	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4345	16	.	.	.
18637	4346	1	163	163	CD
18637	4346	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4346	3	.	.	.
18637	4347	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4347	2	213	213	CD
18637	4347	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4347	4	Reorganization	Reorganization	NNP
18637	4347	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4347	6	of	of	IN
18637	4347	7	June	June	NNP
18637	4347	8	20	20	CD
18637	4347	9	,	,	,
18637	4347	10	1949	1949	CD
18637	4347	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4347	12	63	63	CD
18637	4347	13	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4347	14	.	.	.
18637	4348	1	203	203	CD
18637	4348	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4348	3	.	.	.
18637	4349	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4349	2	214	214	CD
18637	4349	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4349	4	Reorganization	Reorganization	NNP
18637	4349	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4349	6	of	of	IN
18637	4349	7	April	April	NNP
18637	4349	8	3	3	CD
18637	4349	9	,	,	,
18637	4349	10	1939	1939	CD
18637	4349	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4349	12	53	53	CD
18637	4349	13	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4349	14	.	.	.
18637	4350	1	561	561	CD
18637	4350	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4350	3	.	.	.
18637	4351	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4351	2	215	215	CD
18637	4351	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4351	4	Hollingsworth	Hollingsworth	NNP
18637	4351	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4351	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4351	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4351	8	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	4351	9	,	,	,
18637	4351	10	3	3	CD
18637	4351	11	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	4351	12	.	.	.
18637	4352	1	378	378	CD
18637	4352	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4352	3	1798	1798	CD
18637	4352	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4352	5	.	.	.
18637	4353	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4353	2	216	216	CD
18637	4353	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4353	4	License	License	NNP
18637	4353	5	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	4353	6	Cases	case	NNS
18637	4353	7	,	,	,
18637	4353	8	5	5	CD
18637	4353	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4353	10	.	.	.
18637	4354	1	462	462	CD
18637	4354	2	,	,	,
18637	4354	3	471	471	CD
18637	4354	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4354	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	4354	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4354	7	.	.	.
18637	4355	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4355	2	217	217	CD
18637	4355	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4355	4	Brushaber	Brushaber	NNP
18637	4355	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4355	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4355	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4355	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	4355	9	Pac	Pac	NNP
18637	4355	10	.	.	.
18637	4356	1	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	4356	2	,	,	,
18637	4356	3	240	240	CD
18637	4356	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4356	5	1	1	CD
18637	4356	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4356	7	1916	1916	CD
18637	4356	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4356	9	.	.	.
18637	4357	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4357	2	218	218	CD
18637	4357	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4357	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4357	5	.	.	.
18637	4358	1	12	12	CD
18637	4358	2	.	.	.
18637	4359	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4359	2	219	219	CD
18637	4359	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4359	4	253	253	CD
18637	4359	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4359	6	245	245	CD
18637	4359	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4359	8	1920	1920	CD
18637	4359	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4359	10	.	.	.
18637	4360	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4360	2	220	220	CD
18637	4360	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4360	4	268	268	CD
18637	4360	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4360	6	501	501	CD
18637	4360	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4360	8	1925	1925	CD
18637	4360	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4360	10	.	.	.
18637	4361	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4361	2	221	221	CD
18637	4361	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4361	4	307	307	CD
18637	4361	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4361	6	277	277	CD
18637	4361	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4361	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	4361	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4361	10	.	.	.
18637	4362	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4362	2	222	222	CD
18637	4362	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4362	4	11	11	CD
18637	4362	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4362	6	.	.	.
18637	4363	1	113	113	CD
18637	4363	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4363	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	4363	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4363	5	.	.	.
18637	4364	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4364	2	223	223	CD
18637	4364	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4364	4	Graves	Graves	NNPS
18637	4364	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4364	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4364	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4364	8	O'Keefe	O'Keefe	NNP
18637	4364	9	,	,	,
18637	4364	10	306	306	CD
18637	4364	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4364	12	466	466	CD
18637	4364	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4364	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	4364	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4364	16	.	.	.
18637	4365	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4365	2	224	224	CD
18637	4365	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4365	4	304	304	CD
18637	4365	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4365	6	405	405	CD
18637	4365	7	,	,	,
18637	4365	8	414	414	CD
18637	4365	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4365	10	1938	1938	CD
18637	4365	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4365	12	.	.	.
18637	4366	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4366	2	225	225	CD
18637	4366	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4366	4	Veazie	Veazie	NNP
18637	4366	5	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	4366	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4366	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4366	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4366	9	Fenno	Fenno	NNP
18637	4366	10	,	,	,
18637	4366	11	8	8	CD
18637	4366	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4366	13	.	.	.
18637	4367	1	533	533	CD
18637	4367	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4367	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	4367	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4367	5	.	.	.
18637	4368	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4368	2	226	226	CD
18637	4368	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4368	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4368	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4368	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4368	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4368	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4368	9	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	4368	10	&	&	CC
18637	4368	11	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	4369	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4369	2	,	,	,
18637	4369	3	17	17	CD
18637	4369	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4369	5	.	.	.
18637	4370	1	322	322	CD
18637	4370	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4370	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	4370	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4370	5	.	.	.
18637	4371	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4371	2	227	227	CD
18637	4371	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4371	4	157	157	CD
18637	4371	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4371	6	429	429	CD
18637	4371	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4371	8	1895	1895	CD
18637	4371	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4371	10	.	.	.
18637	4372	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4372	2	228	228	CD
18637	4372	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4372	4	4	4	CD
18637	4372	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4372	6	.	.	.
18637	4373	1	316	316	CD
18637	4373	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4373	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	4373	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4373	5	.	.	.
18637	4374	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4374	2	229	229	CD
18637	4374	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4374	4	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	4374	5	Motorcycle	Motorcycle	NNP
18637	4374	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4374	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4374	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4374	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4374	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4374	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4374	12	,	,	,
18637	4374	13	283	283	CD
18637	4374	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4374	15	570	570	CD
18637	4374	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4374	17	1931	1931	CD
18637	4374	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4374	19	.	.	.
18637	4375	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4375	2	230	230	CD
18637	4375	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4375	4	12	12	CD
18637	4375	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4375	6	.	.	.
18637	4376	1	419	419	CD
18637	4376	2	,	,	,
18637	4376	3	444	444	CD
18637	4376	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4376	5	1827	1827	CD
18637	4376	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4376	7	.	.	.
18637	4377	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4377	2	231	231	CD
18637	4377	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4377	4	Snyder	Snyder	NNP
18637	4377	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4377	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4377	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4377	8	Bettman	Bettman	NNP
18637	4377	9	,	,	,
18637	4377	10	190	190	CD
18637	4377	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4377	12	249	249	CD
18637	4377	13	,	,	,
18637	4377	14	254	254	CD
18637	4377	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4377	16	1903	1903	CD
18637	4377	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4377	18	.	.	.
18637	4378	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4378	2	232	232	CD
18637	4378	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4378	4	South	South	NNP
18637	4378	5	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	4378	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4378	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4378	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4378	9	United	United	NNP
18637	4378	10	States	States	NNP
18637	4378	11	,	,	,
18637	4378	12	199	199	CD
18637	4378	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4378	14	437	437	CD
18637	4378	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4378	16	1905	1905	CD
18637	4378	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4378	18	.	.	.
18637	4379	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4379	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4379	3	also	also	RB
18637	4379	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4379	5	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	4379	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4379	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4379	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4379	9	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	4379	10	,	,	,
18637	4379	11	292	292	CD
18637	4379	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4379	13	360	360	CD
18637	4379	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4379	15	1934	1934	CD
18637	4379	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4379	17	.	.	.
18637	4380	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4380	2	233	233	CD
18637	4380	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4380	4	220	220	CD
18637	4380	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4380	6	107	107	CD
18637	4380	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4380	8	1911	1911	CD
18637	4380	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4380	10	.	.	.
18637	4381	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4381	2	234	234	CD
18637	4381	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4381	4	Greiner	Greiner	NNP
18637	4381	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4381	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4381	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4381	8	Lewellyn	Lewellyn	NNP
18637	4381	9	,	,	,
18637	4381	10	258	258	CD
18637	4381	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4381	12	384	384	CD
18637	4381	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4381	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	4381	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4381	16	.	.	.
18637	4382	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4382	2	235	235	CD
18637	4382	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4382	4	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	4382	5	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	4382	6	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	4382	7	&	&	CC
18637	4382	8	Supply	Supply	NNP
18637	4382	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4382	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4382	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	4382	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4382	13	United	United	NNP
18637	4382	14	States	States	NNP
18637	4382	15	,	,	,
18637	4382	16	281	281	CD
18637	4382	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4382	18	572	572	CD
18637	4382	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4382	20	1930	1930	CD
18637	4382	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4382	22	.	.	.
18637	4383	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4383	2	236	236	CD
18637	4383	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4383	4	University	University	NNP
18637	4383	5	of	of	IN
18637	4383	6	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	4383	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4383	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4383	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4383	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4383	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4383	12	,	,	,
18637	4383	13	289	289	CD
18637	4383	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4383	15	48	48	CD
18637	4383	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4383	17	1933	1933	CD
18637	4383	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4383	19	.	.	.
18637	4384	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4384	2	237	237	CD
18637	4384	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4384	4	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	4384	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4384	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4384	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4384	8	Regents	Regents	NNP
18637	4384	9	,	,	,
18637	4384	10	304	304	CD
18637	4384	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4384	12	439	439	CD
18637	4384	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4384	14	1938	1938	CD
18637	4384	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4384	16	.	.	.
18637	4385	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4385	2	238	238	CD
18637	4385	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4385	4	Wilmette	Wilmette	NNP
18637	4385	5	Park	Park	NNP
18637	4385	6	District	District	NNP
18637	4385	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4385	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4385	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4385	10	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
18637	4385	11	,	,	,
18637	4385	12	338	338	CD
18637	4385	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4385	14	411	411	CD
18637	4385	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4385	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	4385	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4385	18	.	.	.
18637	4386	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4386	2	239	239	CD
18637	4386	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4386	4	Metcalf	Metcalf	NNP
18637	4386	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4386	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4386	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4386	8	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	4386	9	,	,	,
18637	4386	10	269	269	CD
18637	4386	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4386	12	514	514	CD
18637	4386	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4386	14	1926	1926	CD
18637	4386	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4386	16	.	.	.
18637	4387	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4387	2	240	240	CD
18637	4387	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4387	4	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	4387	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4387	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4387	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4387	8	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	4387	9	,	,	,
18637	4387	10	293	293	CD
18637	4387	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4387	12	214	214	CD
18637	4387	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4387	14	1934	1934	CD
18637	4387	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4387	16	.	.	.
18637	4388	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4388	2	241	241	CD
18637	4388	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4388	4	Willcutts	Willcutts	NNP
18637	4388	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4388	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4388	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4388	8	Bunn	Bunn	NNP
18637	4388	9	,	,	,
18637	4388	10	282	282	CD
18637	4388	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4388	12	216	216	CD
18637	4388	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4388	14	1931	1931	CD
18637	4388	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4388	16	.	.	.
18637	4389	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4389	2	242	242	CD
18637	4389	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4389	4	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	4389	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4389	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4389	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4389	8	Mountain	Mountain	NNP
18637	4389	9	Producers	Producers	NNPS
18637	4389	10	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	4389	11	,	,	,
18637	4389	12	303	303	CD
18637	4389	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4389	14	376	376	CD
18637	4389	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4389	16	1938	1938	CD
18637	4389	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4389	18	,	,	,
18637	4389	19	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	4389	20	Burnet	Burnet	NNP
18637	4389	21	_	_	NNP
18637	4389	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	4389	23	_	_	NNP
18637	4389	24	Coronado	Coronado	NNP
18637	4389	25	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	4389	26	&	&	CC
18637	4389	27	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	4389	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4389	29	,	,	,
18637	4389	30	285	285	CD
18637	4389	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4389	32	393	393	CD
18637	4389	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4389	34	1932	1932	CD
18637	4389	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4389	36	.	.	.
18637	4390	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4390	2	243	243	CD
18637	4390	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4390	4	New	New	NNP
18637	4390	5	York	York	NNP
18637	4390	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4390	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4390	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4390	9	United	United	NNP
18637	4390	10	States	States	NNP
18637	4390	11	,	,	,
18637	4390	12	326	326	CD
18637	4390	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4390	14	572	572	CD
18637	4390	15	,	,	,
18637	4390	16	584	584	CD
18637	4390	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4390	18	1946	1946	CD
18637	4390	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4390	20	,	,	,
18637	4390	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4390	22	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	4390	23	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	4390	24	of	of	IN
18637	4390	25	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4390	26	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	4390	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4390	28	.	.	.
18637	4391	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4391	2	244	244	CD
18637	4391	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4391	4	304	304	CD
18637	4391	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4391	6	405	405	CD
18637	4391	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4391	8	1938	1938	CD
18637	4391	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4391	10	.	.	.
18637	4392	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4392	2	245	245	CD
18637	4392	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4392	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4392	5	.	.	.
18637	4393	1	419	419	CD
18637	4393	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4393	3	420	420	CD
18637	4393	4	.	.	.
18637	4394	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4394	2	246	246	CD
18637	4394	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4394	4	326	326	CD
18637	4394	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4394	6	572	572	CD
18637	4394	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4394	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	4394	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4394	10	.	.	.
18637	4395	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4395	2	247	247	CD
18637	4395	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4395	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4395	5	.	.	.
18637	4396	1	584	584	CD
18637	4396	2	.	.	.
18637	4397	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4397	2	248	248	CD
18637	4397	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4397	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4397	5	.	.	.
18637	4398	1	589	589	CD
18637	4398	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4398	3	590	590	CD
18637	4398	4	.	.	.
18637	4399	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4399	2	249	249	CD
18637	4399	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4399	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4399	5	.	.	.
18637	4400	1	596	596	CD
18637	4400	2	.	.	.
18637	4401	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4401	2	250	250	CD
18637	4401	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4401	4	Wilmette	Wilmette	NNP
18637	4401	5	Park	Park	NNP
18637	4401	6	District	District	NNP
18637	4401	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4401	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4401	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4401	10	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
18637	4401	11	,	,	,
18637	4401	12	338	338	CD
18637	4401	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4401	14	411	411	CD
18637	4401	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4401	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	4401	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4401	18	.	.	.
18637	4402	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4402	2	251	251	CD
18637	4402	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4402	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4402	5	See	See	NNP
18637	4402	6	also	also	RB
18637	4402	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4402	8	article	article	NN
18637	4402	9	I	i	NN
18637	4402	10	,	,	,
18637	4402	11	section	section	NN
18637	4402	12	9	9	CD
18637	4402	13	,	,	,
18637	4402	14	clause	clause	NN
18637	4402	15	4	4	CD
18637	4402	16	.	.	.
18637	4403	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4403	2	252	252	CD
18637	4403	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4403	4	LaBelle	LaBelle	NNP
18637	4403	5	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	4403	6	Works	Works	NNP
18637	4403	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4403	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4403	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4403	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4403	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4403	12	,	,	,
18637	4403	13	256	256	CD
18637	4403	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4403	15	377	377	CD
18637	4403	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4403	17	1921	1921	CD
18637	4403	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4403	19	;	;	:
18637	4403	20	Brushaber	Brushaber	NNP
18637	4403	21	_	_	NNP
18637	4403	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	4403	23	_	_	NNP
18637	4403	24	Union	Union	NNP
18637	4403	25	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	4404	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4404	2	,	,	,
18637	4404	3	240	240	CD
18637	4404	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4404	5	1	1	CD
18637	4404	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4404	7	1916	1916	CD
18637	4404	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4404	9	;	;	:
18637	4404	10	Head	Head	NNP
18637	4404	11	Money	Money	NNP
18637	4404	12	Cases	case	NNS
18637	4404	13	,	,	,
18637	4404	14	112	112	CD
18637	4404	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4404	16	580	580	CD
18637	4404	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4404	18	1884	1884	CD
18637	4404	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4404	20	.	.	.
18637	4405	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4405	2	253	253	CD
18637	4405	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4405	4	Knowlton	Knowlton	NNP
18637	4405	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4405	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4405	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4405	8	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	4405	9	,	,	,
18637	4405	10	178	178	CD
18637	4405	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4405	12	41	41	CD
18637	4405	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4405	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	4405	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4405	16	.	.	.
18637	4406	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4406	2	254	254	CD
18637	4406	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4406	4	Fernandez	Fernandez	NNP
18637	4406	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4406	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4406	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4406	8	Wiener	Wiener	NNP
18637	4406	9	,	,	,
18637	4406	10	326	326	CD
18637	4406	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4406	12	340	340	CD
18637	4406	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4406	14	1945	1945	CD
18637	4406	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4406	16	;	;	:
18637	4406	17	Riggs	Riggs	NNP
18637	4406	18	_	_	NNP
18637	4406	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	4406	20	_	_	NNP
18637	4406	21	Del	Del	NNP
18637	4406	22	Drago	Drago	NNP
18637	4406	23	,	,	,
18637	4406	24	317	317	CD
18637	4406	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4406	26	95	95	CD
18637	4406	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4406	28	1942	1942	CD
18637	4406	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4406	30	;	;	:
18637	4406	31	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	4406	32	_	_	NNP
18637	4406	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	4406	34	_	_	NNP
18637	4406	35	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	4406	36	of	of	IN
18637	4406	37	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	4406	38	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	4406	39	,	,	,
18637	4406	40	283	283	CD
18637	4406	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4406	42	589	589	CD
18637	4406	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4406	44	1931	1931	CD
18637	4406	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4406	46	;	;	:
18637	4406	47	Poe	Poe	NNP
18637	4406	48	_	_	NNP
18637	4406	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	4406	50	_	_	NNP
18637	4406	51	Seaborn	Seaborn	NNP
18637	4406	52	,	,	,
18637	4406	53	282	282	CD
18637	4406	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4406	55	101	101	CD
18637	4406	56	,	,	,
18637	4406	57	117	117	CD
18637	4406	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4406	59	1930	1930	CD
18637	4406	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4406	61	.	.	.
18637	4407	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4407	2	255	255	CD
18637	4407	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4407	4	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	4407	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4407	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4407	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4407	8	Mellon	Mellon	NNP
18637	4407	9	,	,	,
18637	4407	10	273	273	CD
18637	4407	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4407	12	12	12	CD
18637	4407	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4407	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	4407	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4407	16	.	.	.
18637	4408	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4408	2	256	256	CD
18637	4408	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4408	4	Downes	Downes	NNPS
18637	4408	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4408	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4408	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4408	8	Bidwell	Bidwell	NNP
18637	4408	9	,	,	,
18637	4408	10	182	182	CD
18637	4408	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4408	12	244	244	CD
18637	4408	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4408	14	1901	1901	CD
18637	4408	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4408	16	.	.	.
18637	4409	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4409	2	257	257	CD
18637	4409	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4409	4	194	194	CD
18637	4409	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4409	6	486	486	CD
18637	4409	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4409	8	1904	1904	CD
18637	4409	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4409	10	.	.	.
18637	4410	1	The	the	DT
18637	4410	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4410	3	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	4410	4	that	that	IN
18637	4410	5	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	4410	6	was	be	VBD
18637	4410	7	an	an	DT
18637	4410	8	incorporated	incorporated	JJ
18637	4410	9	territory	territory	NN
18637	4410	10	but	but	CC
18637	4410	11	took	take	VBD
18637	4410	12	the	the	DT
18637	4410	13	position	position	NN
18637	4410	14	that	that	IN
18637	4410	15	the	the	DT
18637	4410	16	situation	situation	NN
18637	4410	17	in	in	IN
18637	4410	18	substance	substance	NN
18637	4410	19	was	be	VBD
18637	4410	20	the	the	DT
18637	4410	21	same	same	JJ
18637	4410	22	as	as	IN
18637	4410	23	if	if	IN
18637	4410	24	the	the	DT
18637	4410	25	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	4410	26	had	have	VBD
18637	4410	27	been	be	VBN
18637	4410	28	directly	directly	RB
18637	4410	29	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	4410	30	by	by	IN
18637	4410	31	a	a	DT
18637	4410	32	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	4410	33	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	4410	34	for	for	IN
18637	4410	35	the	the	DT
18637	4410	36	support	support	NN
18637	4410	37	of	of	IN
18637	4410	38	the	the	DT
18637	4410	39	local	local	JJ
18637	4410	40	government	government	NN
18637	4410	41	.	.	.
18637	4411	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4411	2	258	258	CD
18637	4411	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4411	4	License	License	NNP
18637	4411	5	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	4411	6	Cases	case	NNS
18637	4411	7	,	,	,
18637	4411	8	5	5	CD
18637	4411	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4411	10	.	.	.
18637	4412	1	462	462	CD
18637	4412	2	,	,	,
18637	4412	3	471	471	CD
18637	4412	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4412	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	4412	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4412	7	.	.	.
18637	4413	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4413	2	259	259	CD
18637	4413	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4413	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4413	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4413	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4413	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4413	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4413	9	Yuginovich	Yuginovich	NNP
18637	4413	10	,	,	,
18637	4413	11	256	256	CD
18637	4413	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4413	13	450	450	CD
18637	4413	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4413	15	1921	1921	CD
18637	4413	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4413	17	.	.	.
18637	4414	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4414	2	260	260	CD
18637	4414	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4414	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4414	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4414	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4414	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4414	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4414	9	Constantine	Constantine	NNP
18637	4414	10	,	,	,
18637	4414	11	296	296	CD
18637	4414	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4414	13	287	287	CD
18637	4414	14	,	,	,
18637	4414	15	293	293	CD
18637	4414	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4414	17	1935	1935	CD
18637	4414	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4414	19	.	.	.
18637	4415	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4415	2	261	261	CD
18637	4415	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4415	4	License	License	NNP
18637	4415	5	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	4415	6	Cases	case	NNS
18637	4415	7	,	,	,
18637	4415	8	5	5	CD
18637	4415	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4415	10	.	.	.
18637	4416	1	462	462	CD
18637	4416	2	,	,	,
18637	4416	3	471	471	CD
18637	4416	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4416	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	4416	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4416	7	.	.	.
18637	4417	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4417	2	262	262	CD
18637	4417	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4417	4	Felsenheld	Felsenheld	NNP
18637	4417	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4417	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4417	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4417	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4417	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4417	10	,	,	,
18637	4417	11	186	186	CD
18637	4417	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4417	13	126	126	CD
18637	4417	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4417	15	1902	1902	CD
18637	4417	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4417	17	.	.	.
18637	4418	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4418	2	263	263	CD
18637	4418	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4418	4	In	in	IN
18637	4418	5	re	re	IN
18637	4418	6	Kollock	Kollock	NNP
18637	4418	7	,	,	,
18637	4418	8	105	105	CD
18637	4418	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4418	10	526	526	CD
18637	4418	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4418	12	1897	1897	CD
18637	4418	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4418	14	.	.	.
18637	4419	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4419	2	264	264	CD
18637	4419	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4419	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4419	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4419	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4419	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4419	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4419	9	Doremus	Doremus	NNP
18637	4419	10	,	,	,
18637	4419	11	249	249	CD
18637	4419	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4419	13	86	86	CD
18637	4419	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4419	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	4419	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4419	17	.	.	.
18637	4420	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4420	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	4420	3	.	.	.
18637	4420	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4420	5	Nigro	Nigro	NNP
18637	4420	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4420	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4420	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4420	9	United	United	NNP
18637	4420	10	States	States	NNP
18637	4420	11	,	,	,
18637	4420	12	276	276	CD
18637	4420	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4420	14	332	332	CD
18637	4420	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4420	16	1928	1928	CD
18637	4420	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4420	18	.	.	.
18637	4421	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4421	2	265	265	CD
18637	4421	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4421	4	Sonzinsky	Sonzinsky	NNP
18637	4421	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4421	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4421	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4421	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4421	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4421	10	,	,	,
18637	4421	11	300	300	CD
18637	4421	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4421	13	506	506	CD
18637	4421	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4421	15	1937	1937	CD
18637	4421	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4421	17	.	.	.
18637	4422	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4422	2	266	266	CD
18637	4422	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4422	4	McCray	McCray	NNP
18637	4422	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4422	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4422	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4422	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4422	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4422	10	,	,	,
18637	4422	11	195	195	CD
18637	4422	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4422	13	27	27	CD
18637	4422	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4422	15	1904	1904	CD
18637	4422	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4422	17	.	.	.
18637	4423	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4423	2	267	267	CD
18637	4423	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4423	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4423	5	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	4423	6	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	4423	7	for	for	IN
18637	4423	8	the	the	DT
18637	4423	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4423	10	in	in	IN
18637	4423	11	United	United	NNP
18637	4423	12	States	States	NNP
18637	4423	13	_	_	NNP
18637	4423	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	4423	15	_	_	NNP
18637	4423	16	Sanchez	Sanchez	NNP
18637	4423	17	,	,	,
18637	4423	18	340	340	CD
18637	4423	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4423	20	42	42	CD
18637	4423	21	,	,	,
18637	4423	22	44	44	CD
18637	4423	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4423	24	1950	1950	CD
18637	4423	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4423	26	.	.	.
18637	4424	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4424	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4424	3	also	also	RB
18637	4424	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4424	5	Sonzinsky	Sonzinsky	NNP
18637	4424	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4424	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4424	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4424	9	United	United	NNP
18637	4424	10	States	States	NNP
18637	4424	11	,	,	,
18637	4424	12	300	300	CD
18637	4424	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4424	14	506	506	CD
18637	4424	15	,	,	,
18637	4424	16	513	513	CD
18637	4424	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	4424	18	514	514	CD
18637	4424	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4424	20	1937	1937	CD
18637	4424	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4424	22	.	.	.
18637	4425	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4425	2	268	268	CD
18637	4425	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4425	4	Sunshine	Sunshine	NNP
18637	4425	5	Anthracite	Anthracite	NNP
18637	4425	6	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	4425	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4425	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4425	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4425	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4425	11	Adkins	Adkins	NNP
18637	4425	12	,	,	,
18637	4425	13	310	310	CD
18637	4425	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4425	15	381	381	CD
18637	4425	16	,	,	,
18637	4425	17	383	383	CD
18637	4425	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4425	19	1940	1940	CD
18637	4425	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4425	21	.	.	.
18637	4426	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4426	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4426	3	also	also	RB
18637	4426	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4426	5	Head	Head	NNP
18637	4426	6	Money	Money	NNP
18637	4426	7	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	4426	8	,	,	,
18637	4426	9	112	112	CD
18637	4426	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4426	11	580	580	CD
18637	4426	12	,	,	,
18637	4426	13	596	596	CD
18637	4426	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4426	15	1884	1884	CD
18637	4426	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4426	17	.	.	.
18637	4427	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4427	2	269	269	CD
18637	4427	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4427	4	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	4427	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4427	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4427	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4427	8	Drexel	Drexel	NNP
18637	4427	9	Furniture	Furniture	NNP
18637	4427	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4427	11	,	,	,
18637	4427	12	259	259	CD
18637	4427	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4427	14	20	20	CD
18637	4427	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4427	16	1922	1922	CD
18637	4427	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4427	18	;	;	:
18637	4427	19	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	4427	20	_	_	NNP
18637	4427	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	4427	22	_	_	NNP
18637	4427	23	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	4427	24	,	,	,
18637	4427	25	259	259	CD
18637	4427	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4427	27	44	44	CD
18637	4427	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4427	29	1922	1922	CD
18637	4427	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4427	31	;	;	:
18637	4427	32	Helwig	Helwig	NNP
18637	4427	33	_	_	NNP
18637	4427	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	4427	35	_	_	NNP
18637	4427	36	United	United	NNP
18637	4427	37	States	States	NNP
18637	4427	38	,	,	,
18637	4427	39	188	188	CD
18637	4427	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4427	41	605	605	CD
18637	4427	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4427	43	1903	1903	CD
18637	4427	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4427	45	.	.	.
18637	4428	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4428	2	270	270	CD
18637	4428	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4428	4	296	296	CD
18637	4428	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4428	6	287	287	CD
18637	4428	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4428	8	1935	1935	CD
18637	4428	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4428	10	.	.	.
18637	4429	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4429	2	271	271	CD
18637	4429	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4429	4	1	1	CD
18637	4429	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4429	6	.	.	.
18637	4430	1	24	24	CD
18637	4430	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4430	3	1789	1789	CD
18637	4430	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4430	5	.	.	.
18637	4431	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4431	2	272	272	CD
18637	4431	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4431	4	276	276	CD
18637	4431	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4431	6	394	394	CD
18637	4431	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4431	8	1928	1928	CD
18637	4431	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4431	10	.	.	.
18637	4432	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4432	2	273	273	CD
18637	4432	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4432	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4432	5	.	.	.
18637	4433	1	411	411	CD
18637	4433	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4433	3	412	412	CD
18637	4433	4	.	.	.
18637	4434	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4434	2	274	274	CD
18637	4434	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4434	4	III	iii	CD
18637	4434	5	Writings	Writings	NNPS
18637	4434	6	of	of	IN
18637	4434	7	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	4434	8	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	4434	9	,	,	,
18637	4434	10	147	147	CD
18637	4434	11	-	-	SYM
18637	4434	12	149	149	CD
18637	4434	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4434	14	Library	Library	NNP
18637	4434	15	Edition	Edition	NNP
18637	4434	16	,	,	,
18637	4434	17	1904	1904	CD
18637	4434	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4434	19	.	.	.
18637	4435	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4435	2	275	275	CD
18637	4435	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4435	4	James	James	NNP
18637	4435	5	Francis	Francis	NNP
18637	4435	6	Lawson	Lawson	NNP
18637	4435	7	,	,	,
18637	4435	8	The	the	DT
18637	4435	9	General	General	NNP
18637	4435	10	Welfare	Welfare	NNP
18637	4435	11	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	4435	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4435	13	1926	1926	CD
18637	4435	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4435	15	.	.	.
18637	4436	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4436	2	276	276	CD
18637	4436	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4436	4	The	the	DT
18637	4436	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	4436	6	Nos	Nos	NNP
18637	4436	7	.	.	.
18637	4437	1	30	30	CD
18637	4437	2	and	and	CC
18637	4437	3	34	34	CD
18637	4437	4	.	.	.
18637	4438	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4438	2	277	277	CD
18637	4438	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4438	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4438	5	.	.	.
18637	4439	1	No	no	UH
18637	4439	2	.	.	.
18637	4440	1	41	41	CD
18637	4440	2	.	.	.
18637	4441	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4441	2	278	278	CD
18637	4441	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4441	4	1	1	CD
18637	4441	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4441	6	.	.	.
18637	4442	1	229	229	CD
18637	4442	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4442	3	1792	1792	CD
18637	4442	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4442	5	.	.	.
18637	4443	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4443	2	279	279	CD
18637	4443	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4443	4	2	2	CD
18637	4443	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4443	6	.	.	.
18637	4444	1	357	357	CD
18637	4444	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4444	3	1806	1806	CD
18637	4444	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4444	5	.	.	.
18637	4445	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4445	2	280	280	CD
18637	4445	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4445	4	In	in	IN
18637	4445	5	an	an	DT
18637	4445	6	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	4445	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	4445	8	which	which	WDT
18637	4445	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4445	10	rendered	render	VBD
18637	4445	11	for	for	IN
18637	4445	12	President	President	NNP
18637	4445	13	Monroe	Monroe	NNP
18637	4445	14	at	at	IN
18637	4445	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4445	16	request	request	NN
18637	4445	17	on	on	IN
18637	4445	18	the	the	DT
18637	4445	19	power	power	NN
18637	4445	20	of	of	IN
18637	4445	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4445	22	to	to	TO
18637	4445	23	appropriate	appropriate	VB
18637	4445	24	funds	fund	NNS
18637	4445	25	for	for	IN
18637	4445	26	public	public	JJ
18637	4445	27	improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	4445	28	,	,	,
18637	4445	29	the	the	DT
18637	4445	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4445	31	answered	answer	VBD
18637	4445	32	that	that	IN
18637	4445	33	such	such	JJ
18637	4445	34	appropriations	appropriation	NNS
18637	4445	35	might	may	MD
18637	4445	36	be	be	VB
18637	4445	37	properly	properly	RB
18637	4445	38	made	make	VBN
18637	4445	39	under	under	IN
18637	4445	40	the	the	DT
18637	4445	41	war	war	NN
18637	4445	42	and	and	CC
18637	4445	43	postal	postal	JJ
18637	4445	44	powers	power	NNS
18637	4445	45	.	.	.
18637	4446	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4446	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4446	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4446	4	E.F.	E.F.	NNP
18637	4446	5	Albertsworth	Albertsworth	NNP
18637	4446	6	,	,	,
18637	4446	7	"	"	``
18637	4446	8	Advisory	Advisory	NNP
18637	4446	9	Functions	Functions	NNPS
18637	4446	10	in	in	IN
18637	4446	11	the	the	DT
18637	4446	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	4446	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4446	14	,	,	,
18637	4446	15	"	"	''
18637	4446	16	23	23	CD
18637	4446	17	Georgetown	Georgetown	NNP
18637	4446	18	L.J.	L.J.	NNP
18637	4447	1	643	643	CD
18637	4447	2	,	,	,
18637	4447	3	644	644	CD
18637	4447	4	-	-	SYM
18637	4447	5	647	647	CD
18637	4447	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4447	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	4447	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4447	9	.	.	.
18637	4448	1	Monroe	Monroe	NNP
18637	4448	2	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4448	3	ultimately	ultimately	RB
18637	4448	4	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	4448	5	the	the	DT
18637	4448	6	broadest	broad	JJS
18637	4448	7	view	view	NN
18637	4448	8	of	of	IN
18637	4448	9	the	the	DT
18637	4448	10	spending	spending	NN
18637	4448	11	power	power	NN
18637	4448	12	,	,	,
18637	4448	13	from	from	IN
18637	4448	14	which	which	WDT
18637	4448	15	,	,	,
18637	4448	16	however	however	RB
18637	4448	17	,	,	,
18637	4448	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4448	19	carefully	carefully	RB
18637	4448	20	excluded	exclude	VBD
18637	4448	21	any	any	DT
18637	4448	22	element	element	NN
18637	4448	23	of	of	IN
18637	4448	24	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	4448	25	or	or	CC
18637	4448	26	police	police	NN
18637	4448	27	power	power	NN
18637	4448	28	.	.	.
18637	4449	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4449	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4449	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4449	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4449	5	"	"	``
18637	4449	6	Views	view	NNS
18637	4449	7	of	of	IN
18637	4449	8	the	the	DT
18637	4449	9	President	President	NNP
18637	4449	10	of	of	IN
18637	4449	11	the	the	DT
18637	4449	12	United	United	NNP
18637	4449	13	States	States	NNP
18637	4449	14	on	on	IN
18637	4449	15	the	the	DT
18637	4449	16	Subject	subject	NN
18637	4449	17	of	of	IN
18637	4449	18	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	4449	19	Improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	4449	20	,	,	,
18637	4449	21	"	"	''
18637	4449	22	of	of	IN
18637	4449	23	May	May	NNP
18637	4449	24	4	4	CD
18637	4449	25	,	,	,
18637	4449	26	1822	1822	CD
18637	4449	27	,	,	,
18637	4449	28	2	2	CD
18637	4449	29	Richardson	Richardson	NNP
18637	4449	30	,	,	,
18637	4449	31	Messages	Messages	NNPS
18637	4449	32	and	and	CC
18637	4449	33	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	4449	34	of	of	IN
18637	4449	35	the	the	DT
18637	4449	36	Presidents	Presidents	NNPS
18637	4449	37	,	,	,
18637	4449	38	713	713	CD
18637	4449	39	-	-	SYM
18637	4449	40	752	752	CD
18637	4449	41	.	.	.
18637	4450	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4450	2	281	281	CD
18637	4450	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4450	4	The	the	DT
18637	4450	5	Council	Council	NNP
18637	4450	6	of	of	IN
18637	4450	7	State	State	NNP
18637	4450	8	Governments	Governments	NNPS
18637	4450	9	,	,	,
18637	4450	10	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4450	11	Grants	Grants	NNPS
18637	4450	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	4450	13	in	in	IN
18637	4450	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	4450	15	Aid	aid	NN
18637	4450	16	,	,	,
18637	4450	17	6	6	CD
18637	4450	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	4450	19	14	14	CD
18637	4450	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4450	21	1949	1949	CD
18637	4450	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4450	23	.	.	.
18637	4451	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4451	2	282	282	CD
18637	4451	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4451	4	127	127	CD
18637	4451	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4451	6	1	1	CD
18637	4451	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4451	8	1888	1888	CD
18637	4451	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4451	10	.	.	.
18637	4452	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4452	2	283	283	CD
18637	4452	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4452	4	255	255	CD
18637	4452	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4452	6	180	180	CD
18637	4452	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4452	8	1921	1921	CD
18637	4452	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4452	10	.	.	.
18637	4453	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4453	2	284	284	CD
18637	4453	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4453	4	262	262	CD
18637	4453	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4453	6	447	447	CD
18637	4453	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4453	8	1923	1923	CD
18637	4453	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4453	10	.	.	.
18637	4454	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4454	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4454	3	also	also	RB
18637	4454	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4454	5	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	4454	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	4454	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4454	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4454	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4454	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4454	11	Ickes	Ickes	NNP
18637	4454	12	,	,	,
18637	4454	13	302	302	CD
18637	4454	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4454	15	464	464	CD
18637	4454	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4454	17	1938	1938	CD
18637	4454	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4454	19	.	.	.
18637	4455	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4455	2	285	285	CD
18637	4455	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4455	4	160	160	CD
18637	4455	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4455	6	668	668	CD
18637	4455	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4455	8	1896	1896	CD
18637	4455	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4455	10	.	.	.
18637	4456	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4456	2	286	286	CD
18637	4456	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4456	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4456	5	.	.	.
18637	4457	1	681	681	CD
18637	4457	2	.	.	.
18637	4458	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4458	2	287	287	CD
18637	4458	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4458	4	297	297	CD
18637	4458	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4458	6	1	1	CD
18637	4458	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4458	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	4458	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4458	10	.	.	.
18637	4459	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4459	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4459	3	also	also	RB
18637	4459	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4459	5	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
18637	4459	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4459	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4459	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4459	9	United	United	NNP
18637	4459	10	States	States	NNP
18637	4459	11	,	,	,
18637	4459	12	323	323	CD
18637	4459	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4459	14	329	329	CD
18637	4459	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4459	16	1945	1945	CD
18637	4459	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4459	18	.	.	.
18637	4460	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4460	2	288	288	CD
18637	4460	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4460	4	297	297	CD
18637	4460	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4460	6	1	1	CD
18637	4460	7	,	,	,
18637	4460	8	65	65	CD
18637	4460	9	,	,	,
18637	4460	10	66	66	CD
18637	4460	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4460	12	1936	1936	CD
18637	4460	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4460	14	.	.	.
18637	4461	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4461	2	289	289	CD
18637	4461	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4461	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4461	5	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	4461	6	,	,	,
18637	4461	7	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	4461	8	for	for	IN
18637	4461	9	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4461	10	and	and	CC
18637	4461	11	two	two	CD
18637	4461	12	other	other	JJ
18637	4461	13	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	4461	14	,	,	,
18637	4461	15	dissented	dissent	VBN
18637	4461	16	on	on	IN
18637	4461	17	the	the	DT
18637	4461	18	ground	ground	NN
18637	4461	19	that	that	IN
18637	4461	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4461	21	was	be	VBD
18637	4461	22	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	4461	23	when	when	WRB
18637	4461	24	spending	spend	VBG
18637	4461	25	the	the	DT
18637	4461	26	national	national	JJ
18637	4461	27	revenues	revenue	NNS
18637	4461	28	for	for	IN
18637	4461	29	the	the	DT
18637	4461	30	"	"	``
18637	4461	31	general	general	JJ
18637	4461	32	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	4461	33	"	"	''
18637	4461	34	to	to	TO
18637	4461	35	see	see	VB
18637	4461	36	to	to	IN
18637	4461	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4461	38	that	that	IN
18637	4461	39	the	the	DT
18637	4461	40	country	country	NN
18637	4461	41	got	get	VBD
18637	4461	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4461	43	money	money	NN
18637	4461	44	's	's	POS
18637	4461	45	worth	worth	JJ
18637	4461	46	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	4461	47	,	,	,
18637	4461	48	and	and	CC
18637	4461	49	that	that	IN
18637	4461	50	the	the	DT
18637	4461	51	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	4461	52	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	4461	53	were	be	VBD
18637	4461	54	"	"	``
18637	4461	55	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	4461	56	and	and	CC
18637	4461	57	proper	proper	JJ
18637	4461	58	"	"	''
18637	4461	59	to	to	IN
18637	4461	60	that	that	DT
18637	4461	61	end	end	NN
18637	4461	62	.	.	.
18637	4462	1	United	United	NNP
18637	4462	2	States	States	NNP
18637	4462	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4462	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	4462	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4462	6	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	4462	7	,	,	,
18637	4462	8	297	297	CD
18637	4462	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4462	10	1	1	CD
18637	4462	11	,	,	,
18637	4462	12	84	84	CD
18637	4462	13	-	-	SYM
18637	4462	14	86	86	CD
18637	4462	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4462	16	1936	1936	CD
18637	4462	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4462	18	.	.	.
18637	4463	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4463	2	290	290	CD
18637	4463	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4463	4	301	301	CD
18637	4463	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4463	6	548	548	CD
18637	4463	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4463	8	1937	1937	CD
18637	4463	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4463	10	.	.	.
18637	4464	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4464	2	291	291	CD
18637	4464	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4464	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4464	5	.	.	.
18637	4465	1	591	591	CD
18637	4465	2	.	.	.
18637	4466	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4466	2	292	292	CD
18637	4466	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4466	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4466	5	.	.	.
18637	4467	1	590	590	CD
18637	4467	2	.	.	.
18637	4468	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4468	2	293	293	CD
18637	4468	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4468	4	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	4468	5	Soap	Soap	NNP
18637	4468	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4468	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4468	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4468	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4468	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4468	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4468	12	,	,	,
18637	4468	13	301	301	CD
18637	4468	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4468	15	308	308	CD
18637	4468	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4468	17	1937	1937	CD
18637	4468	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4468	19	.	.	.
18637	4469	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4469	2	294	294	CD
18637	4469	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4469	4	301	301	CD
18637	4469	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4469	6	619	619	CD
18637	4469	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4469	8	1937	1937	CD
18637	4469	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4469	10	.	.	.
18637	4470	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4470	2	295	295	CD
18637	4470	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4470	4	301	301	CD
18637	4470	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4470	6	548	548	CD
18637	4470	7	,	,	,
18637	4470	8	589	589	CD
18637	4470	9	,	,	,
18637	4470	10	590	590	CD
18637	4470	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4470	12	1937	1937	CD
18637	4470	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4470	14	.	.	.
18637	4471	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4471	2	296	296	CD
18637	4471	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4471	4	330	330	CD
18637	4471	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4471	6	127	127	CD
18637	4471	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4471	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	4471	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4471	10	.	.	.
18637	4472	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4472	2	297	297	CD
18637	4472	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4472	4	54	54	CD
18637	4472	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4472	6	.	.	.
18637	4473	1	767	767	CD
18637	4473	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4473	3	1940	1940	CD
18637	4473	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4473	5	.	.	.
18637	4474	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4474	2	298	298	CD
18637	4474	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4474	4	330	330	CD
18637	4474	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4474	6	127	127	CD
18637	4474	7	,	,	,
18637	4474	8	143	143	CD
18637	4474	9	.	.	.
18637	4475	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4475	2	299	299	CD
18637	4475	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4475	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4475	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4475	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4475	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4475	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4475	9	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	4475	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4475	11	,	,	,
18637	4475	12	163	163	CD
18637	4475	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4475	14	427	427	CD
18637	4475	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4475	16	1896	1896	CD
18637	4475	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4475	18	;	;	:
18637	4475	19	Pope	Pope	NNP
18637	4475	20	_	_	NNP
18637	4475	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	4475	22	_	_	NNP
18637	4475	23	United	United	NNP
18637	4475	24	States	States	NNP
18637	4475	25	,	,	,
18637	4475	26	323	323	CD
18637	4475	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4475	28	1	1	CD
18637	4475	29	,	,	,
18637	4475	30	9	9	CD
18637	4475	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4475	32	1944	1944	CD
18637	4475	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4475	34	.	.	.
18637	4476	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4476	2	300	300	CD
18637	4476	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4476	4	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	4476	5	Soap	Soap	NNP
18637	4476	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4476	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4476	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4476	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4476	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4476	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4476	12	,	,	,
18637	4476	13	301	301	CD
18637	4476	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4476	15	308	308	CD
18637	4476	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4476	17	1937	1937	CD
18637	4476	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4476	19	.	.	.
18637	4477	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4477	2	301	301	CD
18637	4477	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4477	4	Cr	cr	NN
18637	4477	5	.	.	.
18637	4478	1	358	358	CD
18637	4478	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4478	3	1805	1805	CD
18637	4478	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4478	5	.	.	.
18637	4479	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4479	2	302	302	CD
18637	4479	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4479	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4479	5	.	.	.
18637	4480	1	396	396	CD
18637	4480	2	.	.	.
18637	4481	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4481	2	303	303	CD
18637	4481	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4481	4	2	2	CD
18637	4481	5	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	4481	6	,	,	,
18637	4481	7	Notes	Notes	NNPS
18637	4481	8	on	on	IN
18637	4481	9	the	the	DT
18637	4481	10	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	4481	11	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	4481	12	,	,	,
18637	4481	13	81	81	CD
18637	4481	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4481	15	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
18637	4481	16	's	's	POS
18637	4481	17	ed	ed	NN
18637	4481	18	.	.	.
18637	4482	1	1908	1908	CD
18637	4482	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4482	3	.	.	.
18637	4483	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4483	2	304	304	CD
18637	4483	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4483	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4483	5	.	.	.
18637	4484	1	181	181	CD
18637	4484	2	.	.	.
18637	4485	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4485	2	305	305	CD
18637	4485	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4485	4	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	4485	5	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	4485	6	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	4485	7	,	,	,
18637	4485	8	12	12	CD
18637	4485	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4485	10	.	.	.
18637	4486	1	457	457	CD
18637	4486	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4486	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	4486	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4486	5	,	,	,
18637	4486	6	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	4486	7	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	4486	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4486	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4486	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4486	11	Griswold	Griswold	NNP
18637	4486	12	,	,	,
18637	4486	13	8	8	CD
18637	4486	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4486	15	.	.	.
18637	4487	1	603	603	CD
18637	4487	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4487	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	4487	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4487	5	.	.	.
18637	4488	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4488	2	306	306	CD
18637	4488	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4488	4	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	4488	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4488	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4488	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4488	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4488	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4488	10	,	,	,
18637	4488	11	294	294	CD
18637	4488	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4488	13	330	330	CD
18637	4488	14	,	,	,
18637	4488	15	351	351	CD
18637	4488	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4488	17	1935	1935	CD
18637	4488	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4488	19	.	.	.
18637	4489	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4489	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4489	3	also	also	RB
18637	4489	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4489	5	Lynch	Lynch	NNP
18637	4489	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4489	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4489	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4489	9	United	United	NNP
18637	4489	10	States	States	NNP
18637	4489	11	,	,	,
18637	4489	12	292	292	CD
18637	4489	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4489	14	571	571	CD
18637	4489	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4489	16	1934	1934	CD
18637	4489	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4489	18	.	.	.
18637	4490	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4490	2	307	307	CD
18637	4490	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4490	4	Prentice	Prentice	NNP
18637	4490	5	and	and	CC
18637	4490	6	Egan	Egan	NNP
18637	4490	7	,	,	,
18637	4490	8	The	the	DT
18637	4490	9	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4490	10	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	4490	11	of	of	IN
18637	4490	12	the	the	DT
18637	4490	13	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4490	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	4490	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4490	16	1898	1898	CD
18637	4490	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4490	18	14	14	CD
18637	4490	19	.	.	.
18637	4491	1	The	the	DT
18637	4491	2	balance	balance	NN
18637	4491	3	began	begin	VBD
18637	4491	4	inclining	incline	VBG
18637	4491	5	the	the	DT
18637	4491	6	other	other	JJ
18637	4491	7	way	way	NN
18637	4491	8	with	with	IN
18637	4491	9	the	the	DT
18637	4491	10	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	4491	11	of	of	IN
18637	4491	12	the	the	DT
18637	4491	13	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	4491	14	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4491	15	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4491	16	in	in	IN
18637	4491	17	1887	1887	CD
18637	4491	18	.	.	.
18637	4492	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4492	2	308	308	CD
18637	4492	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4492	4	9	9	CD
18637	4492	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4492	6	.	.	.
18637	4493	1	1	1	CD
18637	4493	2	,	,	,
18637	4493	3	189	189	CD
18637	4493	4	-	-	SYM
18637	4493	5	192	192	CD
18637	4493	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4493	7	1824	1824	CD
18637	4493	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4493	9	.	.	.
18637	4494	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4494	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	4494	3	.	.	.
18637	4494	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4494	5	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	4494	6	for	for	IN
18637	4494	7	the	the	DT
18637	4494	8	appellant	appellant	NN
18637	4494	9	:	:	:
18637	4494	10	"	"	``
18637	4494	11	Nothing	nothing	NN
18637	4494	12	was	be	VBD
18637	4494	13	more	more	RBR
18637	4494	14	complex	complex	JJ
18637	4494	15	than	than	IN
18637	4494	16	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4494	17	;	;	:
18637	4494	18	and	and	CC
18637	4494	19	in	in	IN
18637	4494	20	such	such	PDT
18637	4494	21	an	an	DT
18637	4494	22	age	age	NN
18637	4494	23	as	as	IN
18637	4494	24	this	this	DT
18637	4494	25	,	,	,
18637	4494	26	no	no	DT
18637	4494	27	words	word	NNS
18637	4494	28	embraced	embrace	VBD
18637	4494	29	a	a	DT
18637	4494	30	wider	wide	JJR
18637	4494	31	field	field	NN
18637	4494	32	than	than	IN
18637	4494	33	_	_	NNP
18637	4494	34	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	4494	35	_	_	NNP
18637	4494	36	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	4494	37	.	.	.
18637	4495	1	Almost	almost	RB
18637	4495	2	all	all	PDT
18637	4495	3	the	the	DT
18637	4495	4	business	business	NN
18637	4495	5	and	and	CC
18637	4495	6	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	4495	7	of	of	IN
18637	4495	8	life	life	NN
18637	4495	9	may	may	MD
18637	4495	10	be	be	VB
18637	4495	11	connected	connect	VBN
18637	4495	12	,	,	,
18637	4495	13	incidently	incidently	RB
18637	4495	14	,	,	,
18637	4495	15	more	more	RBR
18637	4495	16	or	or	CC
18637	4495	17	less	less	RBR
18637	4495	18	,	,	,
18637	4495	19	with	with	IN
18637	4495	20	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	4495	21	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	4495	22	.	.	.
18637	4495	23	"	"	''
18637	4496	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4496	2	ibid	ibid	NNP
18637	4496	3	.	.	.
18637	4497	1	9	9	CD
18637	4497	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4497	3	10	10	CD
18637	4497	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4497	5	;	;	:
18637	4497	6	also	also	RB
18637	4497	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4497	8	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	4497	9	,	,	,
18637	4497	10	in	in	IN
18637	4497	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4497	12	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	4497	13	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	4497	14	:	:	:
18637	4497	15	"	"	``
18637	4497	16	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4497	17	,	,	,
18637	4497	18	in	in	IN
18637	4497	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4497	20	simplest	simple	JJS
18637	4497	21	signification	signification	NN
18637	4497	22	,	,	,
18637	4497	23	means	mean	VBZ
18637	4497	24	an	an	DT
18637	4497	25	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	4497	26	of	of	IN
18637	4497	27	goods	good	NNS
18637	4497	28	;	;	:
18637	4497	29	but	but	CC
18637	4497	30	in	in	IN
18637	4497	31	the	the	DT
18637	4497	32	advancement	advancement	NN
18637	4497	33	of	of	IN
18637	4497	34	society	society	NN
18637	4497	35	,	,	,
18637	4497	36	labor	labor	NN
18637	4497	37	,	,	,
18637	4497	38	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	4497	39	,	,	,
18637	4497	40	intelligence	intelligence	NN
18637	4497	41	,	,	,
18637	4497	42	care	care	NN
18637	4497	43	,	,	,
18637	4497	44	and	and	CC
18637	4497	45	various	various	JJ
18637	4497	46	mediums	medium	NNS
18637	4497	47	of	of	IN
18637	4497	48	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	4497	49	,	,	,
18637	4497	50	become	become	VBP
18637	4497	51	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	4497	52	,	,	,
18637	4497	53	and	and	CC
18637	4497	54	enter	enter	VB
18637	4497	55	into	into	IN
18637	4497	56	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4497	57	;	;	:
18637	4497	58	the	the	DT
18637	4497	59	subject	subject	NN
18637	4497	60	,	,	,
18637	4497	61	the	the	DT
18637	4497	62	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	4497	63	,	,	,
18637	4497	64	the	the	DT
18637	4497	65	agent	agent	NN
18637	4497	66	,	,	,
18637	4497	67	and	and	CC
18637	4497	68	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4497	69	various	various	JJ
18637	4497	70	operations	operation	NNS
18637	4497	71	,	,	,
18637	4497	72	become	become	VB
18637	4497	73	the	the	DT
18637	4497	74	objects	object	NNS
18637	4497	75	of	of	IN
18637	4497	76	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	4497	77	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	4497	78	.	.	.
18637	4498	1	Shipbuilding	shipbuilding	NN
18637	4498	2	,	,	,
18637	4498	3	the	the	DT
18637	4498	4	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	4498	5	trade	trade	NN
18637	4498	6	,	,	,
18637	4498	7	and	and	CC
18637	4498	8	propagation	propagation	NN
18637	4498	9	of	of	IN
18637	4498	10	seamen	seaman	NNS
18637	4498	11	,	,	,
18637	4498	12	are	be	VBP
18637	4498	13	such	such	JJ
18637	4498	14	vital	vital	JJ
18637	4498	15	agents	agent	NNS
18637	4498	16	of	of	IN
18637	4498	17	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	4498	18	prosperity	prosperity	NN
18637	4498	19	,	,	,
18637	4498	20	that	that	IN
18637	4498	21	the	the	DT
18637	4498	22	nation	nation	NN
18637	4498	23	which	which	WDT
18637	4498	24	could	could	MD
18637	4498	25	not	not	RB
18637	4498	26	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	4498	27	over	over	IN
18637	4498	28	these	these	DT
18637	4498	29	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	4498	30	,	,	,
18637	4498	31	would	would	MD
18637	4498	32	not	not	RB
18637	4498	33	possess	possess	VB
18637	4498	34	power	power	NN
18637	4498	35	to	to	TO
18637	4498	36	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	4498	37	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4498	38	.	.	.
18637	4498	39	"	"	''
18637	4499	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4499	2	ibid	ibid	NNP
18637	4499	3	.	.	.
18637	4500	1	229	229	CD
18637	4500	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4500	3	230	230	CD
18637	4500	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4500	5	.	.	.
18637	4501	1	"	"	``
18637	4501	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4501	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	4501	4	all	all	DT
18637	4501	5	but	but	CC
18637	4501	6	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	4501	7	in	in	IN
18637	4501	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4501	9	own	own	JJ
18637	4501	10	age	age	NN
18637	4501	11	to	to	TO
18637	4501	12	sense	sense	VB
18637	4501	13	fully	fully	RB
18637	4501	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4501	15	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
18637	4501	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	4501	17	century	century	NN
18637	4501	18	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	4501	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4501	20	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	4501	21	,	,	,
18637	4501	22	the	the	DT
18637	4501	23	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	4501	24	of	of	IN
18637	4501	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4501	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4501	27	.	.	.
18637	4502	1	The	the	DT
18637	4502	2	Eighteenth	Eighteenth	NNP
18637	4502	3	Century	Century	NNP
18637	4502	4	did	do	VBD
18637	4502	5	not	not	RB
18637	4502	6	separate	separate	VB
18637	4502	7	by	by	IN
18637	4502	8	artificial	artificial	JJ
18637	4502	9	lines	line	NNS
18637	4502	10	aspects	aspect	NNS
18637	4502	11	of	of	IN
18637	4502	12	a	a	DT
18637	4502	13	culture	culture	NN
18637	4502	14	which	which	WDT
18637	4502	15	are	be	VBP
18637	4502	16	inseparable	inseparable	JJ
18637	4502	17	.	.	.
18637	4503	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4503	2	had	have	VBD
18637	4503	3	no	no	DT
18637	4503	4	lexicon	lexicon	NN
18637	4503	5	of	of	IN
18637	4503	6	legalisms	legalism	NNS
18637	4503	7	extracted	extract	VBN
18637	4503	8	from	from	IN
18637	4503	9	the	the	DT
18637	4503	10	law	law	NN
18637	4503	11	reports	report	VBZ
18637	4503	12	in	in	IN
18637	4503	13	which	which	WDT
18637	4503	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	4503	15	usage	usage	NN
18637	4503	16	lies	lie	VBZ
18637	4503	17	in	in	IN
18637	4503	18	a	a	DT
18637	4503	19	world	world	NN
18637	4503	20	apart	apart	RB
18637	4503	21	from	from	IN
18637	4503	22	the	the	DT
18637	4503	23	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	4503	24	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	4503	25	of	of	IN
18637	4503	26	life	life	NN
18637	4503	27	.	.	.
18637	4504	1	Commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4504	2	was	be	VBD
18637	4504	3	then	then	RB
18637	4504	4	more	more	JJR
18637	4504	5	than	than	IN
18637	4504	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4504	7	imply	imply	VBP
18637	4504	8	now	now	RB
18637	4504	9	by	by	IN
18637	4504	10	business	business	NN
18637	4504	11	or	or	CC
18637	4504	12	industry	industry	NN
18637	4504	13	.	.	.
18637	4505	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4505	2	was	be	VBD
18637	4505	3	a	a	DT
18637	4505	4	name	name	NN
18637	4505	5	for	for	IN
18637	4505	6	the	the	DT
18637	4505	7	economic	economic	JJ
18637	4505	8	order	order	NN
18637	4505	9	,	,	,
18637	4505	10	the	the	DT
18637	4505	11	domain	domain	NN
18637	4505	12	of	of	IN
18637	4505	13	political	political	JJ
18637	4505	14	economy	economy	NN
18637	4505	15	,	,	,
18637	4505	16	the	the	DT
18637	4505	17	realm	realm	NN
18637	4505	18	of	of	IN
18637	4505	19	a	a	DT
18637	4505	20	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	4505	21	public	public	JJ
18637	4505	22	policy	policy	NN
18637	4505	23	.	.	.
18637	4506	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4506	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	4506	3	a	a	DT
18637	4506	4	word	word	NN
18637	4506	5	which	which	WDT
18637	4506	6	makes	make	VBZ
18637	4506	7	trades	trade	NNS
18637	4506	8	,	,	,
18637	4506	9	activities	activity	NNS
18637	4506	10	and	and	CC
18637	4506	11	interests	interest	NNS
18637	4506	12	an	an	DT
18637	4506	13	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	4506	14	in	in	IN
18637	4506	15	the	the	DT
18637	4506	16	culture	culture	NN
18637	4506	17	of	of	IN
18637	4506	18	a	a	DT
18637	4506	19	people	people	NNS
18637	4506	20	.	.	.
18637	4507	1	If	if	IN
18637	4507	2	trust	trust	NN
18637	4507	3	was	be	VBD
18637	4507	4	to	to	TO
18637	4507	5	be	be	VB
18637	4507	6	reposed	repose	VBN
18637	4507	7	in	in	IN
18637	4507	8	parchment	parchment	NN
18637	4507	9	,	,	,
18637	4507	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4507	11	was	be	VBD
18637	4507	12	the	the	DT
18637	4507	13	only	only	JJ
18637	4507	14	word	word	NN
18637	4507	15	which	which	WDT
18637	4507	16	could	could	MD
18637	4507	17	catch	catch	VB
18637	4507	18	up	up	RP
18637	4507	19	into	into	IN
18637	4507	20	a	a	DT
18637	4507	21	single	single	JJ
18637	4507	22	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	4507	23	term	term	NN
18637	4507	24	all	all	DT
18637	4507	25	activities	activity	NNS
18637	4507	26	directly	directly	RB
18637	4507	27	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	4507	28	the	the	DT
18637	4507	29	wealth	wealth	NN
18637	4507	30	of	of	IN
18637	4507	31	the	the	DT
18637	4507	32	nation	nation	NN
18637	4507	33	,	,	,
18637	4507	34	"	"	''
18637	4507	35	Walton	Walton	NNP
18637	4507	36	H.	H.	NNP
18637	4507	37	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	4507	38	and	and	CC
18637	4507	39	Douglass	Douglass	NNP
18637	4507	40	Adair	Adair	NNP
18637	4507	41	,	,	,
18637	4507	42	The	the	DT
18637	4507	43	Power	power	NN
18637	4507	44	to	to	IN
18637	4507	45	Govern	Govern	NNP
18637	4507	46	,	,	,
18637	4507	47	62	62	CD
18637	4507	48	-	-	SYM
18637	4507	49	63	63	CD
18637	4507	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4507	51	New	New	NNP
18637	4507	52	York	York	NNP
18637	4507	53	:	:	:
18637	4507	54	1937	1937	CD
18637	4507	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4507	56	.	.	.
18637	4508	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4508	2	309	309	CD
18637	4508	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4508	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4508	5	.	.	.
18637	4509	1	191	191	CD
18637	4509	2	.	.	.
18637	4510	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4510	2	310	310	CD
18637	4510	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4510	4	9	9	CD
18637	4510	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4510	6	.	.	.
18637	4511	1	1	1	CD
18637	4511	2	,	,	,
18637	4511	3	193	193	CD
18637	4511	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4511	5	1824	1824	CD
18637	4511	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4511	7	.	.	.
18637	4512	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4512	2	311	311	CD
18637	4512	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4512	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4512	5	See	See	NNP
18637	4512	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4512	7	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	4512	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4512	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4512	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4512	11	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	4512	12	&	&	CC
18637	4512	13	Belmont	Belmont	NNP
18637	4512	14	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	4512	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4512	16	,	,	,
18637	4512	17	18	18	CD
18637	4512	18	How	how	WRB
18637	4512	19	.	.	.
18637	4513	1	421	421	CD
18637	4513	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4513	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	4513	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4513	5	;	;	:
18637	4513	6	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	4513	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4513	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4513	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4513	10	Kimball	Kimball	NNP
18637	4513	11	,	,	,
18637	4513	12	102	102	CD
18637	4513	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4513	14	691	691	CD
18637	4513	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4513	16	1881	1881	CD
18637	4513	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4513	18	;	;	:
18637	4513	19	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	4513	20	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	4513	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4513	22	_	_	NNP
18637	4513	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	4513	24	_	_	NNP
18637	4513	25	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	4513	26	,	,	,
18637	4513	27	154	154	CD
18637	4513	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4513	29	204	204	CD
18637	4513	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4513	31	1894	1894	CD
18637	4513	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4513	33	;	;	:
18637	4513	34	Kelley	Kelley	NNP
18637	4513	35	_	_	NNP
18637	4513	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	4513	37	_	_	NNP
18637	4513	38	Rhoads	Rhoads	NNP
18637	4513	39	,	,	,
18637	4513	40	188	188	CD
18637	4513	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4513	42	1	1	CD
18637	4513	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4513	44	1903	1903	CD
18637	4513	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4513	46	;	;	:
18637	4513	47	United	United	NNP
18637	4513	48	States	States	NNP
18637	4513	49	_	_	NNP
18637	4513	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	4513	51	_	_	NNP
18637	4513	52	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	4513	53	,	,	,
18637	4513	54	248	248	CD
18637	4513	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4513	56	420	420	CD
18637	4513	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4513	58	1919	1919	CD
18637	4513	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4513	60	;	;	:
18637	4513	61	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	4513	62	_	_	NNP
18637	4513	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	4513	64	_	_	NNP
18637	4513	65	California	California	NNP
18637	4513	66	,	,	,
18637	4513	67	314	314	CD
18637	4513	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4513	69	160	160	CD
18637	4513	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4513	71	1941	1941	CD
18637	4513	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4513	73	.	.	.
18637	4514	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4514	2	312	312	CD
18637	4514	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4514	4	Pensacola	Pensacola	NNP
18637	4514	5	Tel	Tel	NNP
18637	4514	6	.	.	.
18637	4515	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4515	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4515	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4515	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4515	5	Western	Western	NNP
18637	4515	6	Union	Union	NNP
18637	4515	7	Tel	Tel	NNP
18637	4515	8	.	.	.
18637	4516	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4516	2	,	,	,
18637	4516	3	96	96	CD
18637	4516	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4516	5	1	1	CD
18637	4516	6	,	,	,
18637	4516	7	9	9	CD
18637	4516	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4516	9	1878	1878	CD
18637	4516	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4516	11	;	;	:
18637	4516	12	International	International	NNP
18637	4516	13	Text	Text	NNP
18637	4516	14	Book	Book	NNP
18637	4516	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4516	16	_	_	NNP
18637	4516	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	4516	18	_	_	NNP
18637	4516	19	Pigg	Pigg	NNP
18637	4516	20	,	,	,
18637	4516	21	217	217	CD
18637	4516	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4516	23	91	91	CD
18637	4516	24	,	,	,
18637	4516	25	106	106	CD
18637	4516	26	-	-	SYM
18637	4516	27	107	107	CD
18637	4516	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4516	29	1910	1910	CD
18637	4516	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4516	31	;	;	:
18637	4516	32	Western	Western	NNP
18637	4516	33	Union	Union	NNP
18637	4516	34	Tel	Tel	NNP
18637	4516	35	.	.	.
18637	4517	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4517	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4517	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4517	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4517	5	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	4517	6	,	,	,
18637	4517	7	247	247	CD
18637	4517	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4517	9	105	105	CD
18637	4517	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4517	11	1918	1918	CD
18637	4517	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4517	13	;	;	:
18637	4517	14	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4517	15	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	4517	16	Com	Com	NNP
18637	4517	17	.	.	.
18637	4518	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4518	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	4518	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4518	4	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	4518	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	4518	6	,	,	,
18637	4518	7	289	289	CD
18637	4518	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4518	9	266	266	CD
18637	4518	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4518	11	1933	1933	CD
18637	4518	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4518	13	.	.	.
18637	4519	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4519	2	313	313	CD
18637	4519	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4519	4	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	4519	5	&	&	CC
18637	4519	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4519	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4519	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4519	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4519	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4519	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4519	12	,	,	,
18637	4519	13	196	196	CD
18637	4519	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4519	15	375	375	CD
18637	4519	16	,	,	,
18637	4519	17	398	398	CD
18637	4519	18	-	-	SYM
18637	4519	19	399	399	CD
18637	4519	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4519	21	1905	1905	CD
18637	4519	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4519	23	;	;	:
18637	4519	24	Dahnke	Dahnke	NNP
18637	4519	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	4519	26	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	4519	27	Milling	Milling	NNP
18637	4519	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4519	29	_	_	NNP
18637	4519	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	4519	31	_	_	NNP
18637	4519	32	Bondurant	Bondurant	NNP
18637	4519	33	,	,	,
18637	4519	34	257	257	CD
18637	4519	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4519	36	282	282	CD
18637	4519	37	,	,	,
18637	4519	38	290	290	CD
18637	4519	39	-	-	SYM
18637	4519	40	291	291	CD
18637	4519	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4519	42	1921	1921	CD
18637	4519	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4519	44	;	;	:
18637	4519	45	Stafford	Stafford	NNP
18637	4519	46	_	_	NNP
18637	4519	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	4519	48	_	_	NNP
18637	4519	49	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	4519	50	,	,	,
18637	4519	51	258	258	CD
18637	4519	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4519	53	495	495	CD
18637	4519	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4519	55	1922	1922	CD
18637	4519	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4519	57	;	;	:
18637	4519	58	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4519	59	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	4519	60	Com	Com	NNP
18637	4519	61	.	.	.
18637	4520	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4520	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	4520	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4520	4	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	4520	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4520	6	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	4520	7	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	4520	8	Assoc	Assoc	NNP
18637	4520	9	.	.	.
18637	4520	10	,	,	,
18637	4520	11	273	273	CD
18637	4520	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4520	13	52	52	CD
18637	4520	14	,	,	,
18637	4520	15	64	64	CD
18637	4520	16	-	-	SYM
18637	4520	17	65	65	CD
18637	4520	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4520	19	1927	1927	CD
18637	4520	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4520	21	.	.	.
18637	4521	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4521	2	314	314	CD
18637	4521	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4521	4	Kidd	Kidd	NNP
18637	4521	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4521	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4521	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4521	8	Pearson	Pearson	NNP
18637	4521	9	,	,	,
18637	4521	10	128	128	CD
18637	4521	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4521	12	1	1	CD
18637	4521	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4521	14	1888	1888	CD
18637	4521	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4521	16	;	;	:
18637	4521	17	Oliver	Oliver	NNP
18637	4521	18	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	4521	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4521	20	_	_	NNP
18637	4521	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	4521	22	_	_	NNP
18637	4521	23	Lord	Lord	NNP
18637	4521	24	,	,	,
18637	4521	25	262	262	CD
18637	4521	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4521	27	172	172	CD
18637	4521	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4521	29	1923	1923	CD
18637	4521	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4521	31	.	.	.
18637	4522	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4522	2	315	315	CD
18637	4522	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4522	4	Paul	Paul	NNP
18637	4522	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4522	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4522	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4522	8	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	4522	9	,	,	,
18637	4522	10	8	8	CD
18637	4522	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4522	12	.	.	.
18637	4523	1	168	168	CD
18637	4523	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4523	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	4523	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4523	5	.	.	.
18637	4524	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4524	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4524	3	also	also	RB
18637	4524	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4524	5	New	New	NNP
18637	4524	6	York	York	NNP
18637	4524	7	L.	L.	NNP
18637	4524	8	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	4524	9	.	.	.
18637	4525	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4525	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4525	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4525	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4525	5	Deer	Deer	NNP
18637	4525	6	Lodge	Lodge	NNP
18637	4525	7	County	County	NNP
18637	4525	8	,	,	,
18637	4525	9	231	231	CD
18637	4525	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4525	11	495	495	CD
18637	4525	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4525	13	1913	1913	CD
18637	4525	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4525	15	;	;	:
18637	4525	16	New	New	NNP
18637	4525	17	York	York	NNP
18637	4525	18	L.	L.	NNP
18637	4525	19	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	4525	20	.	.	.
18637	4526	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4526	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4526	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4526	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4526	5	Cravens	Cravens	NNP
18637	4526	6	,	,	,
18637	4526	7	178	178	CD
18637	4526	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4526	9	389	389	CD
18637	4526	10	,	,	,
18637	4526	11	401	401	CD
18637	4526	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4526	13	1900	1900	CD
18637	4526	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4526	15	;	;	:
18637	4526	16	Fire	Fire	NNP
18637	4526	17	Assoc	Assoc	NNP
18637	4526	18	.	.	.
18637	4527	1	of	of	IN
18637	4527	2	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	4527	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4527	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	4527	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4527	6	New	New	NNP
18637	4527	7	York	York	NNP
18637	4527	8	,	,	,
18637	4527	9	119	119	CD
18637	4527	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4527	11	110	110	CD
18637	4527	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4527	13	1886	1886	CD
18637	4527	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4527	15	;	;	:
18637	4527	16	Bothwell	Bothwell	NNP
18637	4527	17	_	_	NNP
18637	4527	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	4527	19	_	_	NNP
18637	4527	20	Buckbee	Buckbee	NNP
18637	4527	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	4527	22	Mears	Mears	NNP
18637	4527	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4527	24	,	,	,
18637	4527	25	275	275	CD
18637	4527	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4527	27	274	274	CD
18637	4527	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4527	29	1927	1927	CD
18637	4527	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4527	31	;	;	:
18637	4527	32	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
18637	4527	33	Casualty	Casualty	NNP
18637	4527	34	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	4527	35	.	.	.
18637	4528	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4528	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4528	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4528	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4528	5	Brownell	Brownell	NNP
18637	4528	6	,	,	,
18637	4528	7	294	294	CD
18637	4528	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4528	9	580	580	CD
18637	4528	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4528	11	1935	1935	CD
18637	4528	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4528	13	.	.	.
18637	4529	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4529	2	316	316	CD
18637	4529	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4529	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4529	5	Baseball	Baseball	NNP
18637	4529	6	Club	Club	NNP
18637	4529	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4529	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4529	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4529	10	National	National	NNP
18637	4529	11	League	League	NNP
18637	4529	12	,	,	,
18637	4529	13	259	259	CD
18637	4529	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4529	15	200	200	CD
18637	4529	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4529	17	1922	1922	CD
18637	4529	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4529	19	.	.	.
18637	4530	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4530	2	317	317	CD
18637	4530	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4530	4	Blumenstock	Blumenstock	NNP
18637	4530	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	4530	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4530	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4530	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4530	9	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	4530	10	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	4530	11	.	.	.
18637	4531	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4531	2	,	,	,
18637	4531	3	252	252	CD
18637	4531	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4531	5	436	436	CD
18637	4531	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4531	7	1920	1920	CD
18637	4531	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4531	9	.	.	.
18637	4532	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4532	2	318	318	CD
18637	4532	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4532	4	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	4532	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4532	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4532	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4532	8	Fears	Fears	NNP
18637	4532	9	,	,	,
18637	4532	10	179	179	CD
18637	4532	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4532	12	270	270	CD
18637	4532	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4532	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	4532	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4532	16	.	.	.
18637	4533	1	A	a	DT
18637	4533	2	contract	contract	NN
18637	4533	3	entered	enter	VBD
18637	4533	4	into	into	IN
18637	4533	5	for	for	IN
18637	4533	6	the	the	DT
18637	4533	7	erection	erection	NN
18637	4533	8	of	of	IN
18637	4533	9	a	a	DT
18637	4533	10	factory	factory	NN
18637	4533	11	which	which	WDT
18637	4533	12	was	be	VBD
18637	4533	13	to	to	TO
18637	4533	14	be	be	VB
18637	4533	15	supervised	supervise	VBN
18637	4533	16	and	and	CC
18637	4533	17	operated	operate	VBN
18637	4533	18	by	by	IN
18637	4533	19	the	the	DT
18637	4533	20	officers	officer	NNS
18637	4533	21	of	of	IN
18637	4533	22	a	a	DT
18637	4533	23	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	4533	24	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	4533	25	was	be	VBD
18637	4533	26	held	hold	VBN
18637	4533	27	not	not	RB
18637	4533	28	a	a	DT
18637	4533	29	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	4533	30	of	of	IN
18637	4533	31	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4533	32	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4533	33	in	in	IN
18637	4533	34	the	the	DT
18637	4533	35	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	4533	36	sense	sense	NN
18637	4533	37	merely	merely	RB
18637	4533	38	because	because	IN
18637	4533	39	of	of	IN
18637	4533	40	the	the	DT
18637	4533	41	fact	fact	NN
18637	4533	42	that	that	IN
18637	4533	43	the	the	DT
18637	4533	44	products	product	NNS
18637	4533	45	of	of	IN
18637	4533	46	the	the	DT
18637	4533	47	factory	factory	NN
18637	4533	48	are	be	VBP
18637	4533	49	largely	largely	RB
18637	4533	50	to	to	TO
18637	4533	51	be	be	VB
18637	4533	52	sold	sell	VBN
18637	4533	53	and	and	CC
18637	4533	54	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	4533	55	to	to	IN
18637	4533	56	other	other	JJ
18637	4533	57	factories	factory	NNS
18637	4533	58	.	.	.
18637	4534	1	Diamond	Diamond	NNP
18637	4534	2	Glue	Glue	NNP
18637	4534	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4534	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4534	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	4534	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4534	7	United	United	NNP
18637	4534	8	States	States	NNP
18637	4534	9	Glue	Glue	NNP
18637	4534	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4534	11	,	,	,
18637	4534	12	187	187	CD
18637	4534	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4534	14	611	611	CD
18637	4534	15	,	,	,
18637	4534	16	616	616	CD
18637	4534	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4534	18	1903	1903	CD
18637	4534	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4534	20	.	.	.
18637	4535	1	In	in	IN
18637	4535	2	Browning	Browning	NNP
18637	4535	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4535	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	4535	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4535	6	Waycross	Waycross	NNP
18637	4535	7	,	,	,
18637	4535	8	233	233	CD
18637	4535	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4535	10	16	16	CD
18637	4535	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4535	12	1914	1914	CD
18637	4535	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4535	14	,	,	,
18637	4535	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4535	16	was	be	VBD
18637	4535	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	4535	18	that	that	IN
18637	4535	19	the	the	DT
18637	4535	20	installation	installation	NN
18637	4535	21	of	of	IN
18637	4535	22	lightning	lightning	NN
18637	4535	23	rods	rod	NNS
18637	4535	24	sold	sell	VBN
18637	4535	25	by	by	IN
18637	4535	26	a	a	DT
18637	4535	27	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	4535	28	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	4535	29	was	be	VBD
18637	4535	30	not	not	RB
18637	4535	31	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4535	32	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4535	33	,	,	,
18637	4535	34	although	although	IN
18637	4535	35	provided	provide	VBN
18637	4535	36	for	for	IN
18637	4535	37	in	in	IN
18637	4535	38	the	the	DT
18637	4535	39	contract	contract	NN
18637	4535	40	of	of	IN
18637	4535	41	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	4535	42	.	.	.
18637	4536	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	4536	2	in	in	IN
18637	4536	3	General	General	NNP
18637	4536	4	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	4536	5	Signal	Signal	NNP
18637	4536	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4536	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4536	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4536	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4536	10	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	4536	11	,	,	,
18637	4536	12	246	246	CD
18637	4536	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4536	14	500	500	CD
18637	4536	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4536	16	1918	1918	CD
18637	4536	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4536	18	,	,	,
18637	4536	19	where	where	WRB
18637	4536	20	a	a	DT
18637	4536	21	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	4536	22	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	4536	23	installed	instal	VBD
18637	4536	24	signals	signal	NNS
18637	4536	25	in	in	IN
18637	4536	26	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	4536	27	,	,	,
18637	4536	28	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	4536	29	in	in	RP
18637	4536	30	materials	material	NNS
18637	4536	31	,	,	,
18637	4536	32	supplies	supply	NNS
18637	4536	33	,	,	,
18637	4536	34	and	and	CC
18637	4536	35	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	4536	36	from	from	IN
18637	4536	37	without	without	IN
18637	4536	38	the	the	DT
18637	4536	39	State	State	NNP
18637	4536	40	,	,	,
18637	4536	41	the	the	DT
18637	4536	42	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4536	43	held	hold	VBD
18637	4536	44	that	that	IN
18637	4536	45	local	local	JJ
18637	4536	46	business	business	NN
18637	4536	47	was	be	VBD
18637	4536	48	involved	involve	VBN
18637	4536	49	,	,	,
18637	4536	50	separate	separate	JJ
18637	4536	51	and	and	CC
18637	4536	52	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	4536	53	from	from	IN
18637	4536	54	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4536	55	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	4536	56	,	,	,
18637	4536	57	and	and	CC
18637	4536	58	subject	subject	JJ
18637	4536	59	to	to	IN
18637	4536	60	the	the	DT
18637	4536	61	licensing	licensing	NN
18637	4536	62	power	power	NN
18637	4536	63	of	of	IN
18637	4536	64	the	the	DT
18637	4536	65	State	State	NNP
18637	4536	66	.	.	.
18637	4537	1	However	however	RB
18637	4537	2	,	,	,
18637	4537	3	in	in	IN
18637	4537	4	an	an	DT
18637	4537	5	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4537	6	contract	contract	NN
18637	4537	7	for	for	IN
18637	4537	8	the	the	DT
18637	4537	9	sale	sale	NN
18637	4537	10	of	of	IN
18637	4537	11	a	a	DT
18637	4537	12	complicated	complicated	JJ
18637	4537	13	ice	ice	NN
18637	4537	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	4537	15	making	making	NN
18637	4537	16	plant	plant	NN
18637	4537	17	,	,	,
18637	4537	18	where	where	WRB
18637	4537	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4537	20	was	be	VBD
18637	4537	21	stipulated	stipulate	VBN
18637	4537	22	that	that	IN
18637	4537	23	the	the	DT
18637	4537	24	parts	part	NNS
18637	4537	25	should	should	MD
18637	4537	26	be	be	VB
18637	4537	27	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	4537	28	into	into	IN
18637	4537	29	the	the	DT
18637	4537	30	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	4537	31	's	's	POS
18637	4537	32	State	State	NNP
18637	4537	33	and	and	CC
18637	4537	34	the	the	DT
18637	4537	35	plant	plant	NN
18637	4537	36	there	there	RB
18637	4537	37	assembled	assemble	VBD
18637	4537	38	and	and	CC
18637	4537	39	tested	test	VBN
18637	4537	40	under	under	IN
18637	4537	41	the	the	DT
18637	4537	42	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	4537	43	of	of	IN
18637	4537	44	an	an	DT
18637	4537	45	expert	expert	NN
18637	4537	46	to	to	TO
18637	4537	47	be	be	VB
18637	4537	48	sent	send	VBN
18637	4537	49	by	by	IN
18637	4537	50	the	the	DT
18637	4537	51	seller	seller	NN
18637	4537	52	,	,	,
18637	4537	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4537	54	was	be	VBD
18637	4537	55	held	hold	VBN
18637	4537	56	that	that	IN
18637	4537	57	services	service	NNS
18637	4537	58	of	of	IN
18637	4537	59	the	the	DT
18637	4537	60	expert	expert	NN
18637	4537	61	did	do	VBD
18637	4537	62	not	not	RB
18637	4537	63	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	4537	64	the	the	DT
18637	4537	65	doing	doing	NN
18637	4537	66	of	of	IN
18637	4537	67	a	a	DT
18637	4537	68	local	local	JJ
18637	4537	69	business	business	NN
18637	4537	70	subjecting	subject	VBG
18637	4537	71	the	the	DT
18637	4537	72	seller	seller	NN
18637	4537	73	to	to	IN
18637	4537	74	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	4537	75	of	of	IN
18637	4537	76	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	4537	77	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	4537	78	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	4537	79	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	4537	80	.	.	.
18637	4538	1	York	York	NNP
18637	4538	2	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	4538	3	.	.	.
18637	4539	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4539	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4539	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4539	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4539	5	Colley	Colley	NNP
18637	4539	6	,	,	,
18637	4539	7	247	247	CD
18637	4539	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4539	9	21	21	CD
18637	4539	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4539	11	1918	1918	CD
18637	4539	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4539	13	.	.	.
18637	4540	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4540	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4540	3	also	also	RB
18637	4540	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4540	5	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	4540	6	City	City	NNP
18637	4540	7	Structural	Structural	NNP
18637	4540	8	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	4540	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4540	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4540	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	4540	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4540	13	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	4540	14	,	,	,
18637	4540	15	269	269	CD
18637	4540	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4540	17	148	148	CD
18637	4540	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4540	19	1925	1925	CD
18637	4540	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4540	21	.	.	.
18637	4541	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4541	2	319	319	CD
18637	4541	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4541	4	Associated	Associated	NNP
18637	4541	5	Press	Press	NNP
18637	4541	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4541	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4541	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4541	9	United	United	NNP
18637	4541	10	States	States	NNP
18637	4541	11	,	,	,
18637	4541	12	326	326	CD
18637	4541	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4541	14	1	1	CD
18637	4541	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4541	16	1945	1945	CD
18637	4541	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4541	18	.	.	.
18637	4542	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4542	2	320	320	CD
18637	4542	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4542	4	American	American	NNP
18637	4542	5	Medical	Medical	NNP
18637	4542	6	Association	Association	NNP
18637	4542	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4542	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4542	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4542	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4542	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4542	12	,	,	,
18637	4542	13	317	317	CD
18637	4542	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4542	15	519	519	CD
18637	4542	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4542	17	1943	1943	CD
18637	4542	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4542	19	.	.	.
18637	4543	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4543	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	4543	3	.	.	.
18637	4543	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4543	5	United	United	NNP
18637	4543	6	States	States	NNP
18637	4543	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4543	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4543	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4543	10	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	4543	11	State	State	NNP
18637	4543	12	Medical	Medical	NNP
18637	4543	13	Society	Society	NNP
18637	4543	14	,	,	,
18637	4543	15	343	343	CD
18637	4543	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4543	17	326	326	CD
18637	4543	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4543	19	1952	1952	CD
18637	4543	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4543	21	.	.	.
18637	4544	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4544	2	321	321	CD
18637	4544	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4544	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4544	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4544	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4544	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4544	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4544	9	South	South	NNP
18637	4544	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	4544	11	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	4544	12	Underwriters	Underwriters	NNPS
18637	4544	13	Assoc	Assoc	NNP
18637	4544	14	,	,	,
18637	4544	15	322	322	CD
18637	4544	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4544	17	533	533	CD
18637	4544	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4544	19	1944	1944	CD
18637	4544	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4544	21	.	.	.
18637	4545	1	The	the	DT
18637	4545	2	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4545	3	character	character	NN
18637	4545	4	of	of	IN
18637	4545	5	the	the	DT
18637	4545	6	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	4545	7	business	business	NN
18637	4545	8	as	as	IN
18637	4545	9	today	today	NN
18637	4545	10	organized	organize	VBD
18637	4545	11	and	and	CC
18637	4545	12	carried	carry	VBN
18637	4545	13	on	on	RP
18637	4545	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	4545	15	stressed	stress	VBN
18637	4545	16	,	,	,
18637	4545	17	although	although	IN
18637	4545	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4545	19	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	4545	20	elements	element	NNS
18637	4545	21	are	be	VBP
18637	4545	22	not	not	RB
18637	4545	23	overlooked	overlook	VBN
18637	4545	24	.	.	.
18637	4546	1	The	the	DT
18637	4546	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4546	3	's	's	POS
18637	4546	4	business	business	NN
18637	4546	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	4546	6	to	to	TO
18637	4546	7	determine	determine	VB
18637	4546	8	in	in	IN
18637	4546	9	each	each	DT
18637	4546	10	case	case	NN
18637	4546	11	whether	whether	IN
18637	4546	12	"	"	``
18637	4546	13	the	the	DT
18637	4546	14	competing	compete	VBG
18637	4546	15	*	*	NFP
18637	4546	16	*	*	NFP
18637	4546	17	*	*	NFP
18637	4546	18	State	state	NN
18637	4546	19	and	and	CC
18637	4546	20	national	national	JJ
18637	4546	21	interests	interest	NNS
18637	4546	22	*	*	NFP
18637	4546	23	*	*	NFP
18637	4546	24	*	*	NFP
18637	4546	25	can	can	MD
18637	4546	26	be	be	VB
18637	4546	27	accommodated	accommodate	VBN
18637	4546	28	.	.	.
18637	4546	29	"	"	''
18637	4547	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	4547	2	.	.	.
18637	4548	1	541	541	CD
18637	4548	2	and	and	CC
18637	4548	3	548	548	CD
18637	4548	4	.	.	.
18637	4549	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4549	2	322	322	CD
18637	4549	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4549	4	Article	article	NN
18637	4549	5	I	i	NN
18637	4549	6	,	,	,
18637	4549	7	§	§	NNP
18637	4549	8	8	8	CD
18637	4549	9	,	,	,
18637	4549	10	cl	cl	IN
18637	4549	11	.	.	.
18637	4550	1	18	18	CD
18637	4550	2	.	.	.
18637	4551	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4551	2	323	323	CD
18637	4551	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4551	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4551	5	See	See	NNP
18637	4551	6	infra	infra	NN
18637	4551	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4551	8	CONGRESSIONAL	congressional	JJ
18637	4551	9	REGULATIONS	regulation	NNS
18637	4551	10	OF	of	IN
18637	4551	11	PRODUCTION	production	NN
18637	4551	12	AND	and	CC
18637	4551	13	INDUSTRIAL	INDUSTRIAL	NNP
18637	4551	14	RELATIONS	RELATIONS	NNP
18637	4551	15	.	.	.
18637	4552	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4552	2	324	324	CD
18637	4552	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4552	4	6	6	CD
18637	4552	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4552	6	.	.	.
18637	4553	1	264	264	CD
18637	4553	2	,	,	,
18637	4553	3	413	413	CD
18637	4553	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4553	5	1821	1821	CD
18637	4553	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4553	7	.	.	.
18637	4554	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4554	2	325	325	CD
18637	4554	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4554	4	9	9	CD
18637	4554	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4554	6	.	.	.
18637	4555	1	1	1	CD
18637	4555	2	,	,	,
18637	4555	3	195	195	CD
18637	4555	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4555	5	1824	1824	CD
18637	4555	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4555	7	.	.	.
18637	4556	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4556	2	326	326	CD
18637	4556	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4556	4	New	New	NNP
18637	4556	5	York	York	NNP
18637	4556	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4556	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4556	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4556	9	Miln	Miln	NNP
18637	4556	10	,	,	,
18637	4556	11	11	11	CD
18637	4556	12	Pet	pet	NN
18637	4556	13	.	.	.
18637	4557	1	102	102	CD
18637	4557	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4557	3	1837	1837	CD
18637	4557	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4557	5	,	,	,
18637	4557	6	overturned	overturn	VBN
18637	4557	7	in	in	IN
18637	4557	8	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	4557	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4557	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	4557	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4557	12	New	New	NNP
18637	4557	13	York	York	NNP
18637	4557	14	,	,	,
18637	4557	15	92	92	CD
18637	4557	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4557	17	259	259	CD
18637	4557	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4557	19	1876	1876	CD
18637	4557	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4557	21	;	;	:
18637	4557	22	License	license	NN
18637	4557	23	Cases	case	NNS
18637	4557	24	,	,	,
18637	4557	25	5	5	CD
18637	4557	26	How	how	WRB
18637	4557	27	.	.	.
18637	4558	1	504	504	CD
18637	4558	2	,	,	,
18637	4558	3	573	573	CD
18637	4558	4	-	-	SYM
18637	4558	5	574	574	CD
18637	4558	6	,	,	,
18637	4558	7	588	588	CD
18637	4558	8	,	,	,
18637	4558	9	613	613	CD
18637	4558	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4558	11	1847	1847	CD
18637	4558	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4558	13	;	;	:
18637	4558	14	Passenger	Passenger	NNP
18637	4558	15	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	4558	16	,	,	,
18637	4558	17	7	7	CD
18637	4558	18	How	how	WRB
18637	4558	19	.	.	.
18637	4559	1	283	283	CD
18637	4559	2	,	,	,
18637	4559	3	399	399	CD
18637	4559	4	-	-	SYM
18637	4559	5	400	400	CD
18637	4559	6	,	,	,
18637	4559	7	465	465	CD
18637	4559	8	-	-	SYM
18637	4559	9	470	470	CD
18637	4559	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4559	11	1849	1849	CD
18637	4559	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4559	13	;	;	:
18637	4559	14	The	the	DT
18637	4559	15	Passaic	Passaic	NNP
18637	4559	16	Bridges	Bridges	NNPS
18637	4559	17	,	,	,
18637	4559	18	3	3	CD
18637	4559	19	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4559	20	.	.	.
18637	4560	1	782	782	CD
18637	4560	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4560	3	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
18637	4560	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4560	5	,	,	,
18637	4560	6	793	793	CD
18637	4560	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4560	8	1866	1866	CD
18637	4560	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4560	10	;	;	:
18637	4560	11	United	United	NNP
18637	4560	12	States	States	NNP
18637	4560	13	_	_	NNP
18637	4560	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	4560	15	_	_	NNP
18637	4560	16	Dewitt	Dewitt	NNP
18637	4560	17	,	,	,
18637	4560	18	9	9	CD
18637	4560	19	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4560	20	.	.	.
18637	4561	1	41	41	CD
18637	4561	2	,	,	,
18637	4561	3	44	44	CD
18637	4561	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4561	5	1870	1870	CD
18637	4561	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4561	7	;	;	:
18637	4561	8	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	4561	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4561	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	4561	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4561	12	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	4561	13	,	,	,
18637	4561	14	97	97	CD
18637	4561	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4561	16	501	501	CD
18637	4561	17	,	,	,
18637	4561	18	503	503	CD
18637	4561	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4561	20	1879	1879	CD
18637	4561	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4561	22	;	;	:
18637	4561	23	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	4561	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	4561	25	Mark	Mark	NNP
18637	4561	26	Cases	case	NNS
18637	4561	27	,	,	,
18637	4561	28	100	100	CD
18637	4561	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4561	30	82	82	CD
18637	4561	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4561	32	1879	1879	CD
18637	4561	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4561	34	;	;	:
18637	4561	35	Kidd	Kidd	NNP
18637	4561	36	_	_	NNP
18637	4561	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	4561	38	_	_	NNP
18637	4561	39	Pearson	Pearson	NNP
18637	4561	40	,	,	,
18637	4561	41	128	128	CD
18637	4561	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4561	43	1	1	CD
18637	4561	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4561	45	1888	1888	CD
18637	4561	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4561	47	;	;	:
18637	4561	48	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	4561	49	Central	Central	NNP
18637	4561	50	R.	R.	NNP
18637	4561	51	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4561	52	_	_	NNP
18637	4561	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	4561	54	_	_	NNP
18637	4561	55	McKendree	McKendree	NNP
18637	4561	56	,	,	,
18637	4561	57	203	203	CD
18637	4561	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4561	59	514	514	CD
18637	4561	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4561	61	1906	1906	CD
18637	4561	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4561	63	;	;	:
18637	4561	64	Keller	Keller	NNP
18637	4561	65	_	_	NNP
18637	4561	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	4561	67	_	_	NNP
18637	4561	68	United	United	NNP
18637	4561	69	States	States	NNP
18637	4561	70	,	,	,
18637	4561	71	213	213	CD
18637	4561	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4561	73	138	138	CD
18637	4561	74	,	,	,
18637	4561	75	144	144	CD
18637	4561	76	-	-	SYM
18637	4561	77	149	149	CD
18637	4561	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4561	79	1909	1909	CD
18637	4561	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4561	81	;	;	:
18637	4561	82	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	4561	83	_	_	NNP
18637	4561	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	4561	85	_	_	NNP
18637	4561	86	Dagenhart	Dagenhart	NNP
18637	4561	87	,	,	,
18637	4561	88	247	247	CD
18637	4561	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4561	90	251	251	CD
18637	4561	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4561	92	1918	1918	CD
18637	4561	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4561	94	.	.	.
18637	4562	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4562	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4562	3	also	also	RB
18637	4562	4	infra	infra	VB
18637	4562	5	.	.	.
18637	4562	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4562	7	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4562	8	327	327	CD
18637	4562	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4562	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4562	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4562	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4562	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	4562	14	_	_	NNP
18637	4562	15	Wrightwood	Wrightwood	NNP
18637	4562	16	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
18637	4562	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4562	18	,	,	,
18637	4562	19	315	315	CD
18637	4562	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4562	21	110	110	CD
18637	4562	22	,	,	,
18637	4562	23	119	119	CD
18637	4562	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4562	25	1942	1942	CD
18637	4562	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4562	27	.	.	.
18637	4563	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4563	2	328	328	CD
18637	4563	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4563	4	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	4563	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4563	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4563	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4563	8	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	4563	9	,	,	,
18637	4563	10	9	9	CD
18637	4563	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4563	12	.	.	.
18637	4564	1	1	1	CD
18637	4564	2	,	,	,
18637	4564	3	196	196	CD
18637	4564	4	.	.	.
18637	4565	1	Commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4565	2	"	"	``
18637	4565	3	among	among	IN
18637	4565	4	the	the	DT
18637	4565	5	several	several	JJ
18637	4565	6	States	States	NNPS
18637	4565	7	"	"	``
18637	4565	8	does	do	VBZ
18637	4565	9	not	not	RB
18637	4565	10	comprise	comprise	VB
18637	4565	11	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4565	12	of	of	IN
18637	4565	13	the	the	DT
18637	4565	14	District	District	NNP
18637	4565	15	of	of	IN
18637	4565	16	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	4565	17	nor	nor	CC
18637	4565	18	the	the	DT
18637	4565	19	territories	territory	NNS
18637	4565	20	of	of	IN
18637	4565	21	the	the	DT
18637	4565	22	United	United	NNP
18637	4565	23	States	States	NNP
18637	4565	24	.	.	.
18637	4566	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4566	2	's	's	POS
18637	4566	3	power	power	NN
18637	4566	4	over	over	IN
18637	4566	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4566	6	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4566	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	4566	8	an	an	DT
18637	4566	9	incident	incident	NN
18637	4566	10	of	of	IN
18637	4566	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4566	12	general	general	JJ
18637	4566	13	power	power	NN
18637	4566	14	over	over	IN
18637	4566	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4566	16	.	.	.
18637	4567	1	Stoutenburgh	Stoutenburgh	NNP
18637	4567	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4567	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4567	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4567	5	Hennick	Hennick	NNP
18637	4567	6	,	,	,
18637	4567	7	129	129	CD
18637	4567	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4567	9	141	141	CD
18637	4567	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4567	11	1889	1889	CD
18637	4567	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4567	13	;	;	:
18637	4567	14	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	4567	15	Cleaners	Cleaners	NNPS
18637	4567	16	and	and	CC
18637	4567	17	Dyers	Dyers	NNPS
18637	4567	18	,	,	,
18637	4567	19	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	4567	20	_	_	NNP
18637	4567	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	4567	22	_	_	NNP
18637	4567	23	United	United	NNP
18637	4567	24	States	States	NNP
18637	4567	25	,	,	,
18637	4567	26	286	286	CD
18637	4567	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4567	28	427	427	CD
18637	4567	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4567	30	1932	1932	CD
18637	4567	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4567	32	;	;	:
18637	4567	33	In	in	IN
18637	4567	34	re	re	NNP
18637	4567	35	Bryant	Bryant	NNP
18637	4567	36	,	,	,
18637	4567	37	4	4	CD
18637	4567	38	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	4567	39	.	.	.
18637	4568	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	4568	2	.	.	.
18637	4569	1	No	no	UH
18637	4569	2	.	.	.
18637	4570	1	2067	2067	CD
18637	4570	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4570	3	1865	1865	CD
18637	4570	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4570	5	.	.	.
18637	4571	1	Transportation	transportation	NN
18637	4571	2	between	between	IN
18637	4571	3	two	two	CD
18637	4571	4	points	point	NNS
18637	4571	5	in	in	IN
18637	4571	6	the	the	DT
18637	4571	7	same	same	JJ
18637	4571	8	State	State	NNP
18637	4571	9	,	,	,
18637	4571	10	when	when	WRB
18637	4571	11	a	a	DT
18637	4571	12	large	large	JJ
18637	4571	13	part	part	NN
18637	4571	14	of	of	IN
18637	4571	15	the	the	DT
18637	4571	16	route	route	NN
18637	4571	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	4571	18	a	a	DT
18637	4571	19	loop	loop	NN
18637	4571	20	outside	outside	IN
18637	4571	21	the	the	DT
18637	4571	22	State	State	NNP
18637	4571	23	,	,	,
18637	4571	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	4571	25	"	"	``
18637	4571	26	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4571	27	among	among	IN
18637	4571	28	the	the	DT
18637	4571	29	several	several	JJ
18637	4571	30	States	state	NNS
18637	4571	31	.	.	.
18637	4571	32	"	"	''
18637	4572	1	Hanley	Hanley	NNP
18637	4572	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4572	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4572	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4572	5	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	4572	6	City	City	NNP
18637	4572	7	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	4572	8	R.	R.	NNP
18637	4572	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4572	10	,	,	,
18637	4572	11	187	187	CD
18637	4572	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4572	13	617	617	CD
18637	4572	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4572	15	1903	1903	CD
18637	4572	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4572	17	;	;	:
18637	4572	18	followed	follow	VBN
18637	4572	19	in	in	IN
18637	4572	20	Western	Western	NNP
18637	4572	21	Union	Union	NNP
18637	4572	22	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	4572	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4572	24	_	_	NNP
18637	4572	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	4572	26	_	_	NNP
18637	4572	27	Speight	Speight	NNP
18637	4572	28	,	,	,
18637	4572	29	254	254	CD
18637	4572	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4572	31	17	17	CD
18637	4572	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4572	33	1920	1920	CD
18637	4572	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4572	35	,	,	,
18637	4572	36	as	as	IN
18637	4572	37	to	to	IN
18637	4572	38	a	a	DT
18637	4572	39	message	message	NN
18637	4572	40	sent	send	VBN
18637	4572	41	from	from	IN
18637	4572	42	one	one	CD
18637	4572	43	point	point	NN
18637	4572	44	to	to	IN
18637	4572	45	another	another	DT
18637	4572	46	in	in	IN
18637	4572	47	North	North	NNP
18637	4572	48	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	4572	49	via	via	IN
18637	4572	50	a	a	DT
18637	4572	51	point	point	NN
18637	4572	52	in	in	IN
18637	4572	53	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	4572	54	.	.	.
18637	4573	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4573	2	329	329	CD
18637	4573	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4573	4	9	9	CD
18637	4573	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4573	6	.	.	.
18637	4574	1	1	1	CD
18637	4574	2	,	,	,
18637	4574	3	196	196	CD
18637	4574	4	-	-	SYM
18637	4574	5	197	197	CD
18637	4574	6	.	.	.
18637	4575	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4575	2	330	330	CD
18637	4575	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4575	4	Champion	Champion	NNP
18637	4575	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4575	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4575	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4575	8	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	4575	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4575	10	Lottery	Lottery	NNP
18637	4575	11	Case	Case	NNP
18637	4575	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4575	13	,	,	,
18637	4575	14	188	188	CD
18637	4575	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4575	16	321	321	CD
18637	4575	17	,	,	,
18637	4575	18	373	373	CD
18637	4575	19	-	-	SYM
18637	4575	20	374	374	CD
18637	4575	21	.	.	.
18637	4576	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4576	2	331	331	CD
18637	4576	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4576	4	Brolan	Brolan	NNP
18637	4576	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4576	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4576	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4576	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4576	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4576	10	,	,	,
18637	4576	11	236	236	CD
18637	4576	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4576	13	216	216	CD
18637	4576	14	,	,	,
18637	4576	15	222	222	CD
18637	4576	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4576	17	1915	1915	CD
18637	4576	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4576	19	.	.	.
18637	4577	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4577	2	332	332	CD
18637	4577	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4577	4	Thurlow	Thurlow	NNP
18637	4577	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4577	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4577	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4577	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	4577	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4577	10	License	License	NNP
18637	4577	11	Cases	Cases	NNP
18637	4577	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4577	13	,	,	,
18637	4577	14	5	5	CD
18637	4577	15	How	how	WRB
18637	4577	16	.	.	.
18637	4578	1	504	504	CD
18637	4578	2	,	,	,
18637	4578	3	578	578	CD
18637	4578	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4578	5	1847	1847	CD
18637	4578	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4578	7	.	.	.
18637	4579	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4579	2	333	333	CD
18637	4579	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4579	4	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	4579	5	&	&	CC
18637	4579	6	S.	S.	NNP
18637	4579	7	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	4579	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4579	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4579	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	4579	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4579	12	Bates	Bates	NNP
18637	4579	13	,	,	,
18637	4579	14	156	156	CD
18637	4579	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4579	16	577	577	CD
18637	4579	17	,	,	,
18637	4579	18	587	587	CD
18637	4579	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4579	20	1895	1895	CD
18637	4579	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4579	22	.	.	.
18637	4580	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4580	2	334	334	CD
18637	4580	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4580	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4580	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4580	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4580	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4580	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4580	9	Carolene	Carolene	NNP
18637	4580	10	Products	Products	NNP
18637	4580	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4580	12	,	,	,
18637	4580	13	304	304	CD
18637	4580	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4580	15	144	144	CD
18637	4580	16	,	,	,
18637	4580	17	147	147	CD
18637	4580	18	-	-	SYM
18637	4580	19	148	148	CD
18637	4580	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4580	21	1938	1938	CD
18637	4580	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4580	23	.	.	.
18637	4581	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4581	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4581	3	also	also	RB
18637	4581	4	infra	infra	VB
18637	4581	5	.	.	.
18637	4581	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4581	7	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4581	8	335	335	CD
18637	4581	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4581	10	The	the	DT
18637	4581	11	"	"	``
18637	4581	12	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	4581	13	Ball	Ball	NNP
18637	4581	14	,	,	,
18637	4581	15	"	"	''
18637	4581	16	10	10	CD
18637	4581	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4581	18	.	.	.
18637	4582	1	557	557	CD
18637	4582	2	,	,	,
18637	4582	3	564	564	CD
18637	4582	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4582	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	4582	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4582	7	.	.	.
18637	4583	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4583	2	336	336	CD
18637	4583	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4583	4	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	4583	5	County	County	NNP
18637	4583	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4583	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4583	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4583	9	Kimball	Kimball	NNP
18637	4583	10	,	,	,
18637	4583	11	102	102	CD
18637	4583	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4583	13	691	691	CD
18637	4583	14	,	,	,
18637	4583	15	696	696	CD
18637	4583	16	,	,	,
18637	4583	17	697	697	CD
18637	4583	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4583	19	1881	1881	CD
18637	4583	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4583	21	.	.	.
18637	4584	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4584	2	337	337	CD
18637	4584	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4584	4	Second	Second	NNP
18637	4584	5	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	4584	6	'	'	POS
18637	4584	7	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	4584	8	Cases	case	NNS
18637	4584	9	,	,	,
18637	4584	10	223	223	CD
18637	4584	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4584	12	1	1	CD
18637	4584	13	,	,	,
18637	4584	14	47	47	CD
18637	4584	15	,	,	,
18637	4584	16	53	53	CD
18637	4584	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	4584	18	54	54	CD
18637	4584	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4584	20	1912	1912	CD
18637	4584	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4584	22	.	.	.
18637	4585	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4585	2	338	338	CD
18637	4585	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4585	4	The	the	DT
18637	4585	5	above	above	JJ
18637	4585	6	case	case	NN
18637	4585	7	.	.	.
18637	4586	1	And	and	CC
18637	4586	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4586	3	see	see	UH
18637	4586	4	infra	infra	NNP
18637	4586	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4586	6	.	.	.
18637	4587	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4587	2	339	339	CD
18637	4587	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4587	4	9	9	CD
18637	4587	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4587	6	.	.	.
18637	4588	1	1	1	CD
18637	4588	2	,	,	,
18637	4588	3	217	217	CD
18637	4588	4	,	,	,
18637	4588	5	221	221	CD
18637	4588	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4588	7	1824	1824	CD
18637	4588	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4588	9	.	.	.
18637	4589	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4589	2	340	340	CD
18637	4589	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4589	4	Pensacola	Pensacola	NNP
18637	4589	5	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	4589	6	.	.	.
18637	4590	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4590	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4590	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4590	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4590	5	Western	Western	NNP
18637	4590	6	Union	Union	NNP
18637	4590	7	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	4590	8	.	.	.
18637	4591	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4591	2	,	,	,
18637	4591	3	96	96	CD
18637	4591	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4591	5	1	1	CD
18637	4591	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4591	7	1878	1878	CD
18637	4591	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4591	9	.	.	.
18637	4592	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4592	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4592	3	also	also	RB
18637	4592	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4592	5	Western	Western	NNP
18637	4592	6	Union	Union	NNP
18637	4592	7	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	4592	8	.	.	.
18637	4593	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4593	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4593	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4593	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4593	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	4593	6	,	,	,
18637	4593	7	105	105	CD
18637	4593	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4593	9	460	460	CD
18637	4593	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4593	11	1882	1882	CD
18637	4593	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4593	13	.	.	.
18637	4594	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4594	2	341	341	CD
18637	4594	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4594	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4594	5	.	.	.
18637	4595	1	9	9	CD
18637	4595	2	.	.	.
18637	4596	1	"	"	``
18637	4596	2	Commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4596	3	embraces	embrace	NNS
18637	4596	4	appliances	appliance	VBZ
18637	4596	5	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	4596	6	employed	employ	VBN
18637	4596	7	in	in	IN
18637	4596	8	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	4596	9	on	on	IN
18637	4596	10	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	4596	11	by	by	IN
18637	4596	12	land	land	NN
18637	4596	13	and	and	CC
18637	4596	14	water	water	NN
18637	4596	15	.	.	.
18637	4596	16	"	"	''
18637	4597	1	--Chicago	--Chicago	NFP
18637	4597	2	&	&	CC
18637	4597	3	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	4598	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4598	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4598	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4598	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4598	5	Fuller	Fuller	NNP
18637	4598	6	,	,	,
18637	4598	7	17	17	CD
18637	4598	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4598	9	.	.	.
18637	4599	1	560	560	CD
18637	4599	2	,	,	,
18637	4599	3	568	568	CD
18637	4599	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4599	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	4599	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4599	7	.	.	.
18637	4600	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4600	2	342	342	CD
18637	4600	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4600	4	"	"	``
18637	4600	5	No	no	DT
18637	4600	6	question	question	NN
18637	4600	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	4600	8	presented	present	VBN
18637	4600	9	as	as	IN
18637	4600	10	to	to	IN
18637	4600	11	the	the	DT
18637	4600	12	power	power	NN
18637	4600	13	of	of	IN
18637	4600	14	the	the	DT
18637	4600	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4600	16	,	,	,
18637	4600	17	in	in	IN
18637	4600	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4600	19	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	4600	20	of	of	IN
18637	4600	21	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4600	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4600	23	,	,	,
18637	4600	24	to	to	TO
18637	4600	25	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	4600	26	radio	radio	NN
18637	4600	27	communications	communication	NNS
18637	4600	28	.	.	.
18637	4600	29	"	"	''
18637	4601	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	4601	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4601	3	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	4601	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	4601	5	for	for	IN
18637	4601	6	the	the	DT
18637	4601	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4601	8	in	in	IN
18637	4601	9	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4601	10	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	4601	11	Com	Com	NNP
18637	4601	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4601	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	4601	14	_	_	NNP
18637	4601	15	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	4601	16	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	4601	17	B.	B.	NNP
18637	4602	1	&	&	CC
18637	4602	2	M.	M.	NNP
18637	4602	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4602	4	,	,	,
18637	4602	5	289	289	CD
18637	4602	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4602	7	266	266	CD
18637	4602	8	,	,	,
18637	4602	9	279	279	CD
18637	4602	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4602	11	1933	1933	CD
18637	4602	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4602	13	.	.	.
18637	4603	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4603	2	Said	Said	NNP
18637	4603	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4603	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4603	5	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	4603	6	,	,	,
18637	4603	7	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	4603	8	for	for	IN
18637	4603	9	the	the	DT
18637	4603	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4603	11	in	in	IN
18637	4603	12	1936	1936	CD
18637	4603	13	:	:	:
18637	4603	14	"	"	``
18637	4603	15	Appellant	appellant	NN
18637	4603	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	4603	17	thus	thus	RB
18637	4603	18	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4603	19	in	in	IN
18637	4603	20	the	the	DT
18637	4603	21	business	business	NN
18637	4603	22	of	of	IN
18637	4603	23	transmitting	transmit	VBG
18637	4603	24	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	4603	25	programs	program	NNS
18637	4603	26	from	from	IN
18637	4603	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4603	28	stations	station	NNS
18637	4603	29	in	in	IN
18637	4603	30	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	4603	31	to	to	IN
18637	4603	32	those	those	DT
18637	4603	33	persons	person	NNS
18637	4603	34	in	in	IN
18637	4603	35	other	other	JJ
18637	4603	36	States	state	NNS
18637	4603	37	who	who	WP
18637	4603	38	'	'	''
18637	4603	39	listen	listen	VB
18637	4603	40	in	in	RP
18637	4603	41	'	'	''
18637	4603	42	through	through	IN
18637	4603	43	the	the	DT
18637	4603	44	use	use	NN
18637	4603	45	of	of	IN
18637	4603	46	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	4603	47	sets	set	NNS
18637	4603	48	.	.	.
18637	4604	1	In	in	IN
18637	4604	2	all	all	DT
18637	4604	3	essentials	essential	NNS
18637	4604	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4604	5	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	4604	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	4604	7	not	not	RB
18637	4604	8	differ	differ	VB
18637	4604	9	from	from	IN
18637	4604	10	that	that	DT
18637	4604	11	employed	employ	VBN
18637	4604	12	in	in	IN
18637	4604	13	sending	send	VBG
18637	4604	14	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	4604	15	or	or	CC
18637	4604	16	telephone	telephone	NN
18637	4604	17	messages	message	NNS
18637	4604	18	across	across	IN
18637	4604	19	State	state	NN
18637	4604	20	lines	line	NNS
18637	4604	21	,	,	,
18637	4604	22	which	which	WDT
18637	4604	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	4604	24	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4604	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4604	26	.	.	.
18637	4605	1	Western	Western	NNP
18637	4605	2	Union	Union	NNP
18637	4605	3	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	4605	4	.	.	.
18637	4606	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4606	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4606	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4606	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4606	5	Speight	Speight	NNP
18637	4606	6	,	,	,
18637	4606	7	254	254	CD
18637	4606	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4606	9	17	17	CD
18637	4606	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4606	11	1920	1920	CD
18637	4606	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4606	13	;	;	:
18637	4606	14	New	New	NNP
18637	4606	15	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	4606	16	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	4606	17	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	4606	18	.	.	.
18637	4607	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4607	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4607	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4607	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4607	5	State	State	NNP
18637	4607	6	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	4607	7	.	.	.
18637	4608	1	of	of	IN
18637	4608	2	Taxes	Taxes	NNP
18637	4608	3	&	&	CC
18637	4608	4	Assessments	Assessments	NNPS
18637	4608	5	,	,	,
18637	4608	6	280	280	CD
18637	4608	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4608	8	338	338	CD
18637	4608	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4608	10	1930	1930	CD
18637	4608	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4608	12	;	;	:
18637	4608	13	Cooney	Cooney	NNP
18637	4608	14	_	_	NNP
18637	4608	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	4608	16	_	_	NNP
18637	4608	17	Mountain	Mountain	NNP
18637	4608	18	States	States	NNP
18637	4608	19	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	4608	20	.	.	.
18637	4609	1	&	&	CC
18637	4609	2	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	4609	3	.	.	.
18637	4610	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4610	2	,	,	,
18637	4610	3	294	294	CD
18637	4610	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4610	5	384	384	CD
18637	4610	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4610	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	4610	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4610	9	;	;	:
18637	4610	10	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	4610	11	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	4610	12	.	.	.
18637	4611	1	&	&	CC
18637	4611	2	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	4611	3	.	.	.
18637	4612	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4612	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4612	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4612	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4612	5	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	4612	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4612	7	,	,	,
18637	4612	8	297	297	CD
18637	4612	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4612	10	403	403	CD
18637	4612	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4612	12	1936	1936	CD
18637	4612	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4612	14	.	.	.
18637	4613	1	In	in	IN
18637	4613	2	each	each	DT
18637	4613	3	,	,	,
18637	4613	4	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	4613	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	4613	6	effected	effect	VBN
18637	4613	7	by	by	IN
18637	4613	8	means	mean	NNS
18637	4613	9	of	of	IN
18637	4613	10	energy	energy	NN
18637	4613	11	manifestations	manifestation	NNS
18637	4613	12	produced	produce	VBN
18637	4613	13	at	at	IN
18637	4613	14	the	the	DT
18637	4613	15	point	point	NN
18637	4613	16	of	of	IN
18637	4613	17	reception	reception	NN
18637	4613	18	in	in	IN
18637	4613	19	one	one	CD
18637	4613	20	State	state	NN
18637	4613	21	which	which	WDT
18637	4613	22	are	be	VBP
18637	4613	23	generated	generate	VBN
18637	4613	24	and	and	CC
18637	4613	25	controlled	control	VBN
18637	4613	26	at	at	IN
18637	4613	27	the	the	DT
18637	4613	28	sending	sending	NN
18637	4613	29	point	point	NN
18637	4613	30	in	in	IN
18637	4613	31	another	another	DT
18637	4613	32	.	.	.
18637	4614	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	4614	2	the	the	DT
18637	4614	3	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	4614	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	4614	5	effected	effect	VBN
18637	4614	6	by	by	IN
18637	4614	7	the	the	DT
18637	4614	8	aid	aid	NN
18637	4614	9	of	of	IN
18637	4614	10	wires	wire	NNS
18637	4614	11	,	,	,
18637	4614	12	or	or	CC
18637	4614	13	through	through	IN
18637	4614	14	a	a	DT
18637	4614	15	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	4614	16	less	less	RBR
18637	4614	17	well	well	RB
18637	4614	18	understood	understand	VBN
18637	4614	19	medium	medium	NN
18637	4614	20	,	,	,
18637	4614	21	'	'	''
18637	4614	22	the	the	DT
18637	4614	23	ether	ether	NN
18637	4614	24	,	,	,
18637	4614	25	'	'	''
18637	4614	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	4614	27	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
18637	4614	28	,	,	,
18637	4614	29	in	in	IN
18637	4614	30	the	the	DT
18637	4614	31	light	light	NN
18637	4614	32	of	of	IN
18637	4614	33	those	those	DT
18637	4614	34	practical	practical	JJ
18637	4614	35	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	4614	36	which	which	WDT
18637	4614	37	have	have	VBP
18637	4614	38	dictated	dictate	VBN
18637	4614	39	the	the	DT
18637	4614	40	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	4614	41	that	that	IN
18637	4614	42	the	the	DT
18637	4614	43	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	4614	44	of	of	IN
18637	4614	45	information	information	NN
18637	4614	46	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4614	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	4614	48	a	a	DT
18637	4614	49	form	form	NN
18637	4614	50	of	of	IN
18637	4614	51	'	'	``
18637	4614	52	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	4614	53	,	,	,
18637	4614	54	'	'	''
18637	4614	55	which	which	WDT
18637	4614	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	4614	57	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4614	58	.	.	.
18637	4615	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4615	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4615	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4615	4	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	4615	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4615	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4615	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4615	8	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	4615	9	,	,	,
18637	4615	10	9	9	CD
18637	4615	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4615	12	.	.	.
18637	4616	1	1	1	CD
18637	4616	2	,	,	,
18637	4616	3	189	189	CD
18637	4616	4	.	.	.
18637	4616	5	"	"	''
18637	4617	1	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	4617	2	's	's	POS
18637	4617	3	Blend	Blend	NNP
18637	4617	4	Station	Station	NNP
18637	4617	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4617	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4617	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4617	8	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	4617	9	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4617	10	,	,	,
18637	4617	11	297	297	CD
18637	4617	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4617	13	650	650	CD
18637	4617	14	,	,	,
18637	4617	15	654	654	CD
18637	4617	16	-	-	SYM
18637	4617	17	655	655	CD
18637	4617	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4617	19	1936	1936	CD
18637	4617	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4617	21	.	.	.
18637	4618	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4618	2	343	343	CD
18637	4618	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4618	4	13	13	CD
18637	4618	5	How	how	WRB
18637	4618	6	.	.	.
18637	4619	1	518	518	CD
18637	4619	2	.	.	.
18637	4620	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4620	2	344	344	CD
18637	4620	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4620	4	10	10	CD
18637	4620	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4620	6	.	.	.
18637	4621	1	112	112	CD
18637	4621	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4621	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	4621	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4621	5	.	.	.
18637	4622	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4622	2	345	345	CD
18637	4622	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4622	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	4622	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4622	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4622	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4622	8	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	4622	9	&	&	CC
18637	4622	10	Belmont	Belmont	NNP
18637	4622	11	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	4622	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4622	13	,	,	,
18637	4622	14	18	18	CD
18637	4622	15	How	how	WRB
18637	4622	16	.	.	.
18637	4623	1	421	421	CD
18637	4623	2	,	,	,
18637	4623	3	430	430	CD
18637	4623	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4623	5	1856	1856	CD
18637	4623	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4623	7	.	.	.
18637	4624	1	"	"	``
18637	4624	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4624	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	4624	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4624	5	,	,	,
18637	4624	6	and	and	CC
18637	4624	7	not	not	RB
18637	4624	8	the	the	DT
18637	4624	9	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	4624	10	Department	Department	NNP
18637	4624	11	,	,	,
18637	4624	12	to	to	TO
18637	4624	13	which	which	WDT
18637	4624	14	the	the	DT
18637	4624	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	4624	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	4624	17	given	give	VBN
18637	4624	18	the	the	DT
18637	4624	19	power	power	NN
18637	4624	20	to	to	TO
18637	4624	21	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	4624	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4624	23	with	with	IN
18637	4624	24	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	4624	25	nations	nation	NNS
18637	4624	26	and	and	CC
18637	4624	27	among	among	IN
18637	4624	28	the	the	DT
18637	4624	29	several	several	JJ
18637	4624	30	States	state	NNS
18637	4624	31	.	.	.
18637	4625	1	The	the	DT
18637	4625	2	courts	court	NNS
18637	4625	3	can	can	MD
18637	4625	4	never	never	RB
18637	4625	5	take	take	VB
18637	4625	6	the	the	DT
18637	4625	7	initiative	initiative	NN
18637	4625	8	on	on	IN
18637	4625	9	this	this	DT
18637	4625	10	subject	subject	NN
18637	4625	11	.	.	.
18637	4625	12	"	"	''
18637	4626	1	Parkersburg	Parkersburg	NNP
18637	4626	2	&	&	CC
18637	4626	3	O.	O.	NNP
18637	4626	4	River	River	NNP
18637	4626	5	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	4626	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4626	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4626	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4626	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4626	10	Parkersburg	Parkersburg	NNP
18637	4626	11	,	,	,
18637	4626	12	107	107	CD
18637	4626	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4626	14	691	691	CD
18637	4626	15	,	,	,
18637	4626	16	701	701	CD
18637	4626	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4626	18	1883	1883	CD
18637	4626	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4626	20	.	.	.
18637	4627	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4627	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4627	3	also	also	RB
18637	4627	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4627	5	Prudential	Prudential	NNP
18637	4627	6	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	4627	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4627	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4627	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4627	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4627	11	Benjamin	Benjamin	NNP
18637	4627	12	,	,	,
18637	4627	13	328	328	CD
18637	4627	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4627	15	408	408	CD
18637	4627	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4627	17	1946	1946	CD
18637	4627	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4627	19	;	;	:
18637	4627	20	and	and	CC
18637	4627	21	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	4627	22	_	_	NNP
18637	4627	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	4627	24	_	_	NNP
18637	4627	25	California	California	NNP
18637	4627	26	,	,	,
18637	4627	27	328	328	CD
18637	4627	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4627	29	440	440	CD
18637	4627	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4627	31	1946	1946	CD
18637	4627	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4627	33	.	.	.
18637	4628	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4628	2	346	346	CD
18637	4628	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4628	4	3	3	CD
18637	4628	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4628	6	.	.	.
18637	4629	1	713	713	CD
18637	4629	2	.	.	.
18637	4630	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4630	2	347	347	CD
18637	4630	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4630	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4630	5	.	.	.
18637	4631	1	724	724	CD
18637	4631	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4631	3	725	725	CD
18637	4631	4	.	.	.
18637	4632	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4632	2	348	348	CD
18637	4632	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4632	4	Union	Union	NNP
18637	4632	5	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	4632	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4632	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4632	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4632	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4632	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4632	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4632	12	,	,	,
18637	4632	13	204	204	CD
18637	4632	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4632	15	364	364	CD
18637	4632	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4632	17	1907	1907	CD
18637	4632	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4632	19	.	.	.
18637	4633	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4633	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4633	3	also	also	RB
18637	4633	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4633	5	Monongahela	Monongahela	NNP
18637	4633	6	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	4633	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4633	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4633	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4633	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4633	11	United	United	NNP
18637	4633	12	States	States	NNP
18637	4633	13	,	,	,
18637	4633	14	216	216	CD
18637	4633	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4633	16	177	177	CD
18637	4633	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4633	18	1910	1910	CD
18637	4633	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4633	20	;	;	:
18637	4633	21	and	and	CC
18637	4633	22	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	4633	23	_	_	NNP
18637	4633	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	4633	25	_	_	NNP
18637	4633	26	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	4633	27	,	,	,
18637	4633	28	278	278	CD
18637	4633	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4633	30	367	367	CD
18637	4633	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4633	32	1929	1929	CD
18637	4633	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4633	34	.	.	.
18637	4634	1	Of	of	IN
18637	4634	2	collateral	collateral	JJ
18637	4634	3	interest	interest	NN
18637	4634	4	are	be	VBP
18637	4634	5	the	the	DT
18637	4634	6	following	follow	VBG
18637	4634	7	:	:	:
18637	4634	8	South	South	NNP
18637	4634	9	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	4634	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4634	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	4634	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4634	13	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	4634	14	,	,	,
18637	4634	15	93	93	CD
18637	4634	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4634	17	4	4	CD
18637	4634	18	,	,	,
18637	4634	19	13	13	CD
18637	4634	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4634	21	1876	1876	CD
18637	4634	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4634	23	;	;	:
18637	4634	24	Bedford	Bedford	NNP
18637	4634	25	_	_	NNP
18637	4634	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	4634	27	_	_	NNP
18637	4634	28	United	United	NNP
18637	4634	29	States	States	NNP
18637	4634	30	,	,	,
18637	4634	31	192	192	CD
18637	4634	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4634	33	217	217	CD
18637	4634	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4634	35	1904	1904	CD
18637	4634	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4634	37	;	;	:
18637	4634	38	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	4634	39	_	_	NNP
18637	4634	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	4634	41	_	_	NNP
18637	4634	42	United	United	NNP
18637	4634	43	States	States	NNP
18637	4634	44	,	,	,
18637	4634	45	230	230	CD
18637	4634	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4634	47	1	1	CD
18637	4634	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4634	49	1913	1913	CD
18637	4634	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4634	51	;	;	:
18637	4634	52	United	United	NNP
18637	4634	53	States	States	NNP
18637	4634	54	_	_	NNP
18637	4634	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	4634	56	_	_	NNP
18637	4634	57	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	4634	58	,	,	,
18637	4634	59	295	295	CD
18637	4634	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4634	61	174	174	CD
18637	4634	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4634	63	1935	1935	CD
18637	4634	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4634	65	.	.	.
18637	4635	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4635	2	349	349	CD
18637	4635	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4635	4	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	4635	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4635	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4635	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4635	8	United	United	NNP
18637	4635	9	States	States	NNP
18637	4635	10	,	,	,
18637	4635	11	166	166	CD
18637	4635	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4635	13	269	269	CD
18637	4635	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4635	15	1897	1897	CD
18637	4635	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4635	17	.	.	.
18637	4636	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4636	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4636	3	also	also	RB
18637	4636	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4636	5	Newport	Newport	NNP
18637	4636	6	&	&	CC
18637	4636	7	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	4636	8	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	4636	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4636	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4636	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	4636	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4636	13	United	United	NNP
18637	4636	14	States	States	NNP
18637	4636	15	,	,	,
18637	4636	16	105	105	CD
18637	4636	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4636	18	470	470	CD
18637	4636	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4636	20	1882	1882	CD
18637	4636	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4636	22	;	;	:
18637	4636	23	United	United	NNP
18637	4636	24	States	States	NNP
18637	4636	25	_	_	NNP
18637	4636	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	4636	27	_	_	NNP
18637	4636	28	Rio	Rio	NNP
18637	4636	29	Grande	Grande	NNP
18637	4636	30	Dam	Dam	NNP
18637	4636	31	&	&	CC
18637	4636	32	Irrig	Irrig	NNP
18637	4636	33	.	.	.
18637	4637	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4637	2	,	,	,
18637	4637	3	174	174	CD
18637	4637	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4637	5	690	690	CD
18637	4637	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4637	7	1899	1899	CD
18637	4637	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4637	9	;	;	:
18637	4637	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4637	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4637	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4637	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	4637	14	_	_	NNP
18637	4637	15	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	4637	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	4637	17	Dunbar	Dunbar	NNP
18637	4637	18	Water	Water	NNP
18637	4637	19	Power	Power	NNP
18637	4637	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4637	21	,	,	,
18637	4637	22	229	229	CD
18637	4637	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4637	24	53	53	CD
18637	4637	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4637	26	1913	1913	CD
18637	4637	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4637	28	;	;	:
18637	4637	29	Seattle	Seattle	NNP
18637	4637	30	_	_	NNP
18637	4637	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	4637	32	_	_	NNP
18637	4637	33	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	4637	34	&	&	CC
18637	4637	35	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	4637	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4637	37	,	,	,
18637	4637	38	255	255	CD
18637	4637	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4637	40	56	56	CD
18637	4637	41	,	,	,
18637	4637	42	63	63	CD
18637	4637	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4637	44	1921	1921	CD
18637	4637	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4637	46	;	;	:
18637	4637	47	Economy	Economy	NNP
18637	4637	48	Light	Light	NNP
18637	4637	49	&	&	CC
18637	4637	50	Power	Power	NNP
18637	4637	51	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4637	52	_	_	NNP
18637	4637	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	4637	54	_	_	NNP
18637	4637	55	United	United	NNP
18637	4637	56	States	States	NNP
18637	4637	57	,	,	,
18637	4637	58	256	256	CD
18637	4637	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4637	60	113	113	CD
18637	4637	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4637	62	1921	1921	CD
18637	4637	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4637	64	;	;	:
18637	4637	65	United	United	NNP
18637	4637	66	States	States	NNP
18637	4637	67	_	_	NNP
18637	4637	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	4637	69	_	_	NNP
18637	4637	70	River	River	NNP
18637	4637	71	Rouge	Rouge	NNP
18637	4637	72	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	4637	73	.	.	.
18637	4638	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4638	2	,	,	,
18637	4638	3	269	269	CD
18637	4638	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4638	5	411	411	CD
18637	4638	6	,	,	,
18637	4638	7	419	419	CD
18637	4638	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4638	9	1926	1926	CD
18637	4638	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4638	11	;	;	:
18637	4638	12	Henry	Henry	NNP
18637	4638	13	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	4638	14	&	&	CC
18637	4638	15	Son	Son	NNP
18637	4638	16	_	_	NNP
18637	4638	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	4638	18	_	_	NNP
18637	4638	19	Little	Little	NNP
18637	4638	20	Falls	Falls	NNP
18637	4638	21	Fibre	Fibre	NNP
18637	4638	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4638	23	,	,	,
18637	4638	24	280	280	CD
18637	4638	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4638	26	369	369	CD
18637	4638	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4638	28	1930	1930	CD
18637	4638	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4638	30	;	;	:
18637	4638	31	United	United	NNP
18637	4638	32	States	States	NNP
18637	4638	33	_	_	NNP
18637	4638	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	4638	35	_	_	NNP
18637	4638	36	Commodore	Commodore	NNP
18637	4638	37	Park	Park	NNP
18637	4638	38	,	,	,
18637	4638	39	324	324	CD
18637	4638	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4638	41	386	386	CD
18637	4638	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4638	43	1945	1945	CD
18637	4638	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4638	45	.	.	.
18637	4639	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4639	2	350	350	CD
18637	4639	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4639	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4639	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4639	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4639	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4639	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4639	9	Cress	Cress	NNP
18637	4639	10	,	,	,
18637	4639	11	243	243	CD
18637	4639	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4639	13	316	316	CD
18637	4639	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4639	15	1917	1917	CD
18637	4639	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4639	17	.	.	.
18637	4640	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4640	2	351	351	CD
18637	4640	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4640	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4640	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4640	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4640	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4640	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4640	9	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	4640	10	,	,	,
18637	4640	11	M.	M.	NNP
18637	4640	12	,	,	,
18637	4640	13	St.	St.	NNP
18637	4640	14	P.	P.	NNP
18637	4640	15	&	&	CC
18637	4640	16	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	4641	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4641	2	,	,	,
18637	4641	3	312	312	CD
18637	4641	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4641	5	592	592	CD
18637	4641	6	,	,	,
18637	4641	7	597	597	CD
18637	4641	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4641	9	1941	1941	CD
18637	4641	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4641	11	;	;	:
18637	4641	12	United	United	NNP
18637	4641	13	States	States	NNP
18637	4641	14	_	_	NNP
18637	4641	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	4641	16	_	_	NNP
18637	4641	17	Willow	Willow	NNP
18637	4641	18	River	River	NNP
18637	4641	19	Power	Power	NNP
18637	4641	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4641	21	,	,	,
18637	4641	22	324	324	CD
18637	4641	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4641	24	499	499	CD
18637	4641	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4641	26	1945	1945	CD
18637	4641	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4641	28	.	.	.
18637	4642	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4642	2	352	352	CD
18637	4642	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4642	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4642	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4642	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4642	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4642	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4642	9	Rio	Rio	NNP
18637	4642	10	Grande	Grande	NNP
18637	4642	11	Dam	Dam	NNP
18637	4642	12	&	&	CC
18637	4642	13	Irrig	Irrig	NNP
18637	4642	14	.	.	.
18637	4643	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4643	2	,	,	,
18637	4643	3	174	174	CD
18637	4643	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4643	5	690	690	CD
18637	4643	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4643	7	1899	1899	CD
18637	4643	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4643	9	;	;	:
18637	4643	10	and	and	CC
18637	4643	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4643	12	cf	cf	NNP
18637	4643	13	.	.	.
18637	4643	14	_	_	IN
18637	4643	15	below	below	IN
18637	4643	16	the	the	DT
18637	4643	17	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	4643	18	of	of	IN
18637	4643	19	United	United	NNP
18637	4643	20	States	States	NNP
18637	4643	21	_	_	NNP
18637	4643	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	4643	23	_	_	NNP
18637	4643	24	Appalachian	Appalachian	NNP
18637	4643	25	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	4643	26	P.	P.	NNP
18637	4643	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4643	28	,	,	,
18637	4643	29	311	311	CD
18637	4643	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4643	31	377	377	CD
18637	4643	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4643	33	1940	1940	CD
18637	4643	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4643	35	.	.	.
18637	4644	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4644	2	353	353	CD
18637	4644	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4644	4	The	the	DT
18637	4644	5	"	"	``
18637	4644	6	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	4644	7	Ball	Ball	NNP
18637	4644	8	"	"	''
18637	4644	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4644	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	4644	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4644	12	United	United	NNP
18637	4644	13	States	States	NNP
18637	4644	14	,	,	,
18637	4644	15	10	10	CD
18637	4644	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4644	17	.	.	.
18637	4645	1	557	557	CD
18637	4645	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4645	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	4645	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4645	5	.	.	.
18637	4646	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4646	2	354	354	CD
18637	4646	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4646	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4646	5	.	.	.
18637	4647	1	560	560	CD
18637	4647	2	.	.	.
18637	4648	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4648	2	355	355	LS
18637	4648	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4648	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4648	5	.	.	.
18637	4649	1	565	565	CD
18637	4649	2	.	.	.
18637	4650	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4650	2	356	356	CD
18637	4650	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4650	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4650	5	.	.	.
18637	4651	1	566	566	CD
18637	4651	2	.	.	.
18637	4652	1	"	"	``
18637	4652	2	The	the	DT
18637	4652	3	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	4652	4	of	of	IN
18637	4652	5	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4652	6	implies	imply	VBZ
18637	4652	7	as	as	IN
18637	4652	8	much	much	JJ
18637	4652	9	control	control	NN
18637	4652	10	,	,	,
18637	4652	11	as	as	IN
18637	4652	12	far	far	RB
18637	4652	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	4652	14	reaching	reach	VBG
18637	4652	15	power	power	NN
18637	4652	16	,	,	,
18637	4652	17	over	over	IN
18637	4652	18	an	an	DT
18637	4652	19	artificial	artificial	NN
18637	4652	20	as	as	IN
18637	4652	21	over	over	IN
18637	4652	22	a	a	DT
18637	4652	23	natural	natural	JJ
18637	4652	24	highway	highway	NN
18637	4652	25	.	.	.
18637	4652	26	"	"	''
18637	4653	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4653	2	Brewer	Brewer	NNP
18637	4653	3	for	for	IN
18637	4653	4	the	the	DT
18637	4653	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4653	6	in	in	IN
18637	4653	7	Monongahela	Monongahela	NNP
18637	4653	8	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	4653	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4653	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4653	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	4653	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4653	13	United	United	NNP
18637	4653	14	States	States	NNP
18637	4653	15	,	,	,
18637	4653	16	148	148	CD
18637	4653	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4653	18	312	312	CD
18637	4653	19	,	,	,
18637	4653	20	342	342	CD
18637	4653	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4653	22	1893	1893	CD
18637	4653	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4653	24	.	.	.
18637	4654	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4654	2	357	357	CD
18637	4654	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4654	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4654	5	had	have	VBD
18637	4654	6	the	the	DT
18637	4654	7	right	right	NN
18637	4654	8	to	to	TO
18637	4654	9	confer	confer	VB
18637	4654	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	4654	11	the	the	DT
18637	4654	12	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	4654	13	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4654	14	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4654	15	the	the	DT
18637	4654	16	power	power	NN
18637	4654	17	to	to	TO
18637	4654	18	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	4654	19	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4654	20	ferry	ferry	NN
18637	4654	21	rates	rate	NNS
18637	4654	22	.	.	.
18637	4655	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4655	2	New	New	NNP
18637	4655	3	York	York	NNP
18637	4655	4	C.	C.	NNP
18637	4655	5	&	&	CC
18637	4655	6	H.R.R.	H.R.R.	NNP
18637	4656	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4656	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4656	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4656	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4656	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	4656	6	of	of	IN
18637	4656	7	Chosen	Chosen	NNP
18637	4656	8	Freeholders	Freeholders	NNP
18637	4656	9	,	,	,
18637	4656	10	227	227	CD
18637	4656	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4656	12	248	248	CD
18637	4656	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4656	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	4656	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4656	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4656	17	;	;	:
18637	4656	18	and	and	CC
18637	4656	19	to	to	TO
18637	4656	20	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	4656	21	the	the	DT
18637	4656	22	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4656	23	to	to	TO
18637	4656	24	govern	govern	VB
18637	4656	25	the	the	DT
18637	4656	26	towing	towing	NN
18637	4656	27	of	of	IN
18637	4656	28	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	4656	29	between	between	IN
18637	4656	30	points	point	NNS
18637	4656	31	in	in	IN
18637	4656	32	the	the	DT
18637	4656	33	same	same	JJ
18637	4656	34	State	state	NN
18637	4656	35	but	but	CC
18637	4656	36	partly	partly	RB
18637	4656	37	through	through	IN
18637	4656	38	waters	water	NNS
18637	4656	39	of	of	IN
18637	4656	40	an	an	DT
18637	4656	41	adjoining	adjoining	JJ
18637	4656	42	State	State	NNP
18637	4656	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4656	44	Cornell	Cornell	NNP
18637	4656	45	Steamboat	Steamboat	NNP
18637	4656	46	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4656	47	_	_	NNP
18637	4656	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	4656	49	_	_	NNP
18637	4656	50	United	United	NNP
18637	4656	51	States	States	NNP
18637	4656	52	,	,	,
18637	4656	53	321	321	CD
18637	4656	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4656	55	634	634	CD
18637	4656	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4656	57	1944	1944	CD
18637	4656	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4656	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4656	60	.	.	.
18637	4657	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4657	2	Also	also	RB
18637	4657	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4657	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4657	5	's	's	POS
18637	4657	6	power	power	NN
18637	4657	7	over	over	IN
18637	4657	8	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	4657	9	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	4657	10	to	to	IN
18637	4657	11	persons	person	NNS
18637	4657	12	furnishing	furnish	VBG
18637	4657	13	wharfage	wharfage	NN
18637	4657	14	,	,	,
18637	4657	15	dock	dock	NN
18637	4657	16	,	,	,
18637	4657	17	warehouse	warehouse	NN
18637	4657	18	,	,	,
18637	4657	19	and	and	CC
18637	4657	20	other	other	JJ
18637	4657	21	terminal	terminal	JJ
18637	4657	22	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	4657	23	to	to	IN
18637	4657	24	a	a	DT
18637	4657	25	common	common	JJ
18637	4657	26	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	4657	27	by	by	IN
18637	4657	28	water	water	NN
18637	4657	29	.	.	.
18637	4658	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	4658	2	an	an	DT
18637	4658	3	order	order	NN
18637	4658	4	of	of	IN
18637	4658	5	the	the	DT
18637	4658	6	United	United	NNP
18637	4658	7	States	States	NNP
18637	4658	8	Maritime	Maritime	NNP
18637	4658	9	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4658	10	banning	ban	VBG
18637	4658	11	certain	certain	JJ
18637	4658	12	allegedly	allegedly	RB
18637	4658	13	"	"	``
18637	4658	14	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	4658	15	practices	practice	NNS
18637	4658	16	"	"	''
18637	4658	17	by	by	IN
18637	4658	18	terminals	terminal	NNS
18637	4658	19	in	in	IN
18637	4658	20	the	the	DT
18637	4658	21	Port	Port	NNP
18637	4658	22	of	of	IN
18637	4658	23	San	San	NNP
18637	4658	24	Francisco	Francisco	NNP
18637	4658	25	,	,	,
18637	4658	26	and	and	CC
18637	4658	27	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	4658	28	schedules	schedule	NNS
18637	4658	29	of	of	IN
18637	4658	30	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	4658	31	free	free	JJ
18637	4658	32	time	time	NN
18637	4658	33	periods	period	NNS
18637	4658	34	and	and	CC
18637	4658	35	of	of	IN
18637	4658	36	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	4658	37	charges	charge	NNS
18637	4658	38	was	be	VBD
18637	4658	39	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	4658	40	.	.	.
18637	4659	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4659	2	California	California	NNP
18637	4659	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4659	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	4659	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4659	6	United	United	NNP
18637	4659	7	States	States	NNP
18637	4659	8	,	,	,
18637	4659	9	320	320	CD
18637	4659	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4659	11	577	577	CD
18637	4659	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4659	13	1944	1944	CD
18637	4659	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4659	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4659	16	.	.	.
18637	4660	1	The	the	DT
18637	4660	2	same	same	JJ
18637	4660	3	power	power	NN
18637	4660	4	also	also	RB
18637	4660	5	comprises	comprise	VBZ
18637	4660	6	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	4660	7	of	of	IN
18637	4660	8	the	the	DT
18637	4660	9	registry	registry	NN
18637	4660	10	,	,	,
18637	4660	11	enrollment	enrollment	NN
18637	4660	12	,	,	,
18637	4660	13	license	license	NN
18637	4660	14	,	,	,
18637	4660	15	and	and	CC
18637	4660	16	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	4660	17	of	of	IN
18637	4660	18	ships	ship	NNS
18637	4660	19	and	and	CC
18637	4660	20	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	4660	21	;	;	:
18637	4660	22	the	the	DT
18637	4660	23	method	method	NN
18637	4660	24	of	of	IN
18637	4660	25	recording	record	VBG
18637	4660	26	bills	bill	NNS
18637	4660	27	of	of	IN
18637	4660	28	sale	sale	NN
18637	4660	29	and	and	CC
18637	4660	30	mortgages	mortgage	NNS
18637	4660	31	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	4660	32	;	;	:
18637	4660	33	the	the	DT
18637	4660	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	4660	35	and	and	CC
18637	4660	36	duties	duty	NNS
18637	4660	37	of	of	IN
18637	4660	38	seamen	seaman	NNS
18637	4660	39	;	;	:
18637	4660	40	the	the	DT
18637	4660	41	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	4660	42	of	of	IN
18637	4660	43	the	the	DT
18637	4660	44	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	4660	45	of	of	IN
18637	4660	46	shipowners	shipowner	NNS
18637	4660	47	for	for	IN
18637	4660	48	the	the	DT
18637	4660	49	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	4660	50	and	and	CC
18637	4660	51	misconduct	misconduct	NN
18637	4660	52	of	of	IN
18637	4660	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4660	54	captains	captain	NNS
18637	4660	55	and	and	CC
18637	4660	56	crews	crew	NNS
18637	4660	57	;	;	:
18637	4660	58	and	and	CC
18637	4660	59	many	many	JJ
18637	4660	60	other	other	JJ
18637	4660	61	things	thing	NNS
18637	4660	62	of	of	IN
18637	4660	63	a	a	DT
18637	4660	64	character	character	NN
18637	4660	65	truly	truly	RB
18637	4660	66	maritime	maritime	RB
18637	4660	67	.	.	.
18637	4661	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4661	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4661	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4661	4	Rodd	Rodd	NNP
18637	4661	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4661	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4661	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4661	8	Heartt	Heartt	NNP
18637	4661	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4661	10	The	the	DT
18637	4661	11	"	"	``
18637	4661	12	Lottawanna	Lottawanna	NNP
18637	4661	13	"	"	''
18637	4661	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4661	15	,	,	,
18637	4661	16	21	21	CD
18637	4661	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4661	18	.	.	.
18637	4662	1	558	558	CD
18637	4662	2	,	,	,
18637	4662	3	577	577	CD
18637	4662	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4662	5	1875	1875	CD
18637	4662	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4662	7	;	;	:
18637	4662	8	Providence	Providence	NNP
18637	4662	9	&	&	CC
18637	4662	10	N.Y.S.S.	N.Y.S.S.	NNP
18637	4663	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4663	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4663	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4663	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4663	5	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	4663	6	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	4663	7	.	.	.
18637	4664	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4664	2	,	,	,
18637	4664	3	109	109	CD
18637	4664	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4664	5	578	578	CD
18637	4664	6	,	,	,
18637	4664	7	589	589	CD
18637	4664	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4664	9	1883	1883	CD
18637	4664	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4664	11	;	;	:
18637	4664	12	Old	Old	NNP
18637	4664	13	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	4664	14	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	4664	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4664	16	_	_	NNP
18637	4664	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	4664	18	_	_	NNP
18637	4664	19	Gilmore	Gilmore	NNP
18637	4664	20	,	,	,
18637	4664	21	207	207	CD
18637	4664	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4664	23	398	398	CD
18637	4664	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4664	25	1907	1907	CD
18637	4664	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4664	27	;	;	:
18637	4664	28	O'Donnell	O'Donnell	NNP
18637	4664	29	_	_	NNP
18637	4664	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	4664	31	_	_	NNP
18637	4664	32	Great	Great	NNP
18637	4664	33	Lakes	Lakes	NNP
18637	4664	34	Dredge	Dredge	NNP
18637	4664	35	&	&	CC
18637	4664	36	Dock	Dock	NNP
18637	4664	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4664	38	,	,	,
18637	4664	39	318	318	CD
18637	4664	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4664	41	36	36	CD
18637	4664	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4664	43	1943	1943	CD
18637	4664	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4664	45	.	.	.
18637	4665	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4665	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4665	3	also	also	RB
18637	4665	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4665	5	below	below	IN
18637	4665	6	article	article	NN
18637	4665	7	III	iii	CD
18637	4665	8	,	,	,
18637	4665	9	§	â§	NN
18637	4665	10	2	2	CD
18637	4665	11	,	,	,
18637	4665	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4665	13	Admiralty	Admiralty	NNP
18637	4665	14	and	and	CC
18637	4665	15	Maritime	Maritime	NNP
18637	4665	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	4665	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4665	18	.	.	.
18637	4666	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4666	2	358	358	CD
18637	4666	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4666	4	Pollard	Pollard	NNP
18637	4666	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4666	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4666	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4666	8	Hagan	Hagan	NNP
18637	4666	9	,	,	,
18637	4666	10	3	3	CD
18637	4666	11	How	how	WRB
18637	4666	12	.	.	.
18637	4667	1	212	212	CD
18637	4667	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4667	3	1845	1845	CD
18637	4667	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4667	5	;	;	:
18637	4667	6	Shively	shively	RB
18637	4667	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4667	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4667	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4667	10	Bowlby	Bowlby	NNP
18637	4667	11	,	,	,
18637	4667	12	152	152	CD
18637	4667	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4667	14	1	1	CD
18637	4667	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4667	16	1894	1894	CD
18637	4667	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4667	18	.	.	.
18637	4668	1	"	"	``
18637	4668	2	The	the	DT
18637	4668	3	shores	shore	NNS
18637	4668	4	of	of	IN
18637	4668	5	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	4668	6	waters	water	NNS
18637	4668	7	,	,	,
18637	4668	8	and	and	CC
18637	4668	9	the	the	DT
18637	4668	10	soils	soil	NNS
18637	4668	11	under	under	IN
18637	4668	12	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4668	13	,	,	,
18637	4668	14	were	be	VBD
18637	4668	15	not	not	RB
18637	4668	16	granted	grant	VBN
18637	4668	17	by	by	IN
18637	4668	18	the	the	DT
18637	4668	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	4668	20	to	to	IN
18637	4668	21	the	the	DT
18637	4668	22	United	United	NNP
18637	4668	23	States	States	NNP
18637	4668	24	,	,	,
18637	4668	25	but	but	CC
18637	4668	26	were	be	VBD
18637	4668	27	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	4668	28	to	to	IN
18637	4668	29	the	the	DT
18637	4668	30	States	States	NNP
18637	4668	31	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	4668	32	;	;	:
18637	4668	33	and	and	CC
18637	4668	34	the	the	DT
18637	4668	35	new	new	JJ
18637	4668	36	States	States	NNPS
18637	4668	37	have	have	VBP
18637	4668	38	the	the	DT
18637	4668	39	same	same	JJ
18637	4668	40	rights	right	NNS
18637	4668	41	,	,	,
18637	4668	42	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	4668	43	,	,	,
18637	4668	44	and	and	CC
18637	4668	45	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	4668	46	over	over	IN
18637	4668	47	this	this	DT
18637	4668	48	subject	subject	NN
18637	4668	49	as	as	IN
18637	4668	50	the	the	DT
18637	4668	51	original	original	JJ
18637	4668	52	States	state	NNS
18637	4668	53	.	.	.
18637	4668	54	"	"	''
18637	4669	1	3	3	LS
18637	4669	2	How	how	WRB
18637	4669	3	.	.	.
18637	4670	1	212	212	CD
18637	4670	2	,	,	,
18637	4670	3	headnote	headnote	VBP
18637	4670	4	3	3	CD
18637	4670	5	.	.	.
18637	4671	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4671	2	359	359	CD
18637	4671	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4671	4	Green	Green	NNP
18637	4671	5	Bay	Bay	NNP
18637	4671	6	&	&	CC
18637	4671	7	M.	M.	NNP
18637	4671	8	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	4671	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4671	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4671	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	4671	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4671	13	Patten	Patten	NNP
18637	4671	14	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	4671	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4671	16	,	,	,
18637	4671	17	172	172	CD
18637	4671	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4671	19	58	58	CD
18637	4671	20	,	,	,
18637	4671	21	80	80	CD
18637	4671	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4671	23	1898	1898	CD
18637	4671	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4671	25	.	.	.
18637	4672	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4672	2	360	360	CD
18637	4672	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4672	4	229	229	CD
18637	4672	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4672	6	53	53	CD
18637	4672	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4672	8	1913	1913	CD
18637	4672	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4672	10	.	.	.
18637	4673	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4673	2	361	361	CD
18637	4673	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4673	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4673	5	.	.	.
18637	4674	1	72	72	CD
18637	4674	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4674	3	73	73	CD
18637	4674	4	,	,	,
18637	4674	5	citing	cite	VBG
18637	4674	6	Kaukauna	Kaukauna	NNP
18637	4674	7	Water	Water	NNP
18637	4674	8	Power	Power	NNP
18637	4674	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4674	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4674	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	4674	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4674	13	Green	Green	NNP
18637	4674	14	Bay	Bay	NNP
18637	4674	15	&	&	CC
18637	4674	16	M.	M.	NNP
18637	4674	17	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	4674	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4674	19	,	,	,
18637	4674	20	142	142	CD
18637	4674	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4674	22	254	254	CD
18637	4674	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4674	24	1891	1891	CD
18637	4674	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4674	26	.	.	.
18637	4675	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4675	2	362	362	CD
18637	4675	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4675	4	283	283	CD
18637	4675	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4675	6	423	423	CD
18637	4675	7	.	.	.
18637	4676	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4676	2	363	363	CD
18637	4676	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4676	4	311	311	CD
18637	4676	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4676	6	377	377	CD
18637	4676	7	.	.	.
18637	4677	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4677	2	364	364	CD
18637	4677	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4677	4	283	283	CD
18637	4677	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4677	6	at	at	IN
18637	4677	7	455	455	CD
18637	4677	8	,	,	,
18637	4677	9	456	456	CD
18637	4677	10	.	.	.
18637	4678	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4678	2	365	365	CD
18637	4678	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4678	4	311	311	CD
18637	4678	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4678	6	at	at	IN
18637	4678	7	407	407	CD
18637	4678	8	,	,	,
18637	4678	9	409	409	CD
18637	4678	10	-	-	SYM
18637	4678	11	410	410	CD
18637	4678	12	.	.	.
18637	4679	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4679	2	366	366	CD
18637	4679	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4679	4	311	311	CD
18637	4679	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4679	6	at	at	IN
18637	4679	7	426	426	CD
18637	4679	8	.	.	.
18637	4680	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4680	2	367	367	CD
18637	4680	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4680	4	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	4680	5	ex	ex	NN
18637	4680	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	4680	7	.	.	.
18637	4681	1	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	4681	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4681	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4681	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4681	5	Atkinson	Atkinson	NNP
18637	4681	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4681	7	,	,	,
18637	4681	8	313	313	CD
18637	4681	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4681	10	508	508	CD
18637	4681	11	,	,	,
18637	4681	12	523	523	CD
18637	4681	13	-	-	SYM
18637	4681	14	534	534	CD
18637	4681	15	_	_	NNP
18637	4681	16	passim	passim	NN
18637	4681	17	_	_	NNP
18637	4681	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4681	19	1941	1941	CD
18637	4681	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4681	21	.	.	.
18637	4682	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4682	2	368	368	CD
18637	4682	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4682	4	Ashwander	Ashwander	NNP
18637	4682	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4682	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4682	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4682	8	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	4682	9	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	4682	10	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	4682	11	,	,	,
18637	4682	12	297	297	CD
18637	4682	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4682	14	288	288	CD
18637	4682	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4682	16	1936	1936	CD
18637	4682	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4682	18	.	.	.
18637	4683	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4683	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4683	3	infra	infra	NN
18637	4683	4	.	.	.
18637	4683	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4683	6	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4683	7	369	369	CD
18637	4683	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4683	9	12	12	CD
18637	4683	10	Stat	stat	NN
18637	4683	11	.	.	.
18637	4684	1	489	489	CD
18637	4684	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4684	3	1862	1862	CD
18637	4684	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4684	5	.	.	.
18637	4685	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4685	2	370	370	CD
18637	4685	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4685	4	Thomson	Thomson	NNP
18637	4685	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4685	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4685	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4685	8	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	4685	9	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	4685	10	,	,	,
18637	4685	11	9	9	CD
18637	4685	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4685	13	.	.	.
18637	4686	1	579	579	CD
18637	4686	2	,	,	,
18637	4686	3	589	589	CD
18637	4686	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4686	5	1870	1870	CD
18637	4686	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4686	7	;	;	:
18637	4686	8	California	California	NNP
18637	4686	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4686	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	4686	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4686	12	Central	Central	NNP
18637	4686	13	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	4686	14	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	4686	15	,	,	,
18637	4686	16	127	127	CD
18637	4686	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4686	18	1	1	CD
18637	4686	19	,	,	,
18637	4686	20	39	39	CD
18637	4686	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4686	22	1888	1888	CD
18637	4686	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4686	24	;	;	:
18637	4686	25	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	4686	26	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	4686	27	_	_	NNP
18637	4686	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	4686	29	_	_	NNP
18637	4686	30	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	4686	31	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	4686	32	R.	R.	NNP
18637	4686	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4686	34	,	,	,
18637	4686	35	135	135	CD
18637	4686	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4686	37	641	641	CD
18637	4686	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4686	39	1890	1890	CD
18637	4686	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4686	41	;	;	:
18637	4686	42	Luxton	Luxton	NNP
18637	4686	43	_	_	NNP
18637	4686	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	4686	45	_	_	NNP
18637	4686	46	North	North	NNP
18637	4686	47	River	River	NNP
18637	4686	48	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	4686	49	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4686	50	,	,	,
18637	4686	51	153	153	CD
18637	4686	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4686	53	525	525	CD
18637	4686	54	,	,	,
18637	4686	55	530	530	CD
18637	4686	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4686	57	1894	1894	CD
18637	4686	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4686	59	.	.	.
18637	4687	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4687	2	371	371	CD
18637	4687	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4687	4	14	14	CD
18637	4687	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	4687	6	.	.	.
18637	4688	1	66	66	CD
18637	4688	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4688	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	4688	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4688	5	.	.	.
18637	4689	1	In	in	IN
18637	4689	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4689	3	first	first	JJ
18637	4689	4	annual	annual	JJ
18637	4689	5	message	message	NN
18637	4689	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4689	7	December	December	NNP
18637	4689	8	4	4	CD
18637	4689	9	,	,	,
18637	4689	10	1865	1865	CD
18637	4689	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4689	12	,	,	,
18637	4689	13	President	President	NNP
18637	4689	14	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	4689	15	had	have	VBD
18637	4689	16	asked	ask	VBN
18637	4689	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4689	18	"	"	''
18637	4689	19	to	to	TO
18637	4689	20	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	4689	21	any	any	DT
18637	4689	22	selfish	selfish	JJ
18637	4689	23	impediment	impediment	NN
18637	4689	24	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4689	25	by	by	IN
18637	4689	26	the	the	DT
18637	4689	27	States	States	NNPS
18637	4689	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4689	29	to	to	IN
18637	4689	30	the	the	DT
18637	4689	31	free	free	JJ
18637	4689	32	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	4689	33	of	of	IN
18637	4689	34	men	man	NNS
18637	4689	35	and	and	CC
18637	4689	36	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	4689	37	.	.	.
18637	4689	38	"	"	''
18637	4690	1	6	6	CD
18637	4690	2	Richardson	Richardson	NNP
18637	4690	3	,	,	,
18637	4690	4	Messages	Messages	NNPS
18637	4690	5	and	and	CC
18637	4690	6	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	4690	7	of	of	IN
18637	4690	8	the	the	DT
18637	4690	9	Presidents	Presidents	NNPS
18637	4690	10	,	,	,
18637	4690	11	362	362	CD
18637	4690	12	.	.	.
18637	4691	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4691	2	372	372	CD
18637	4691	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4691	4	14	14	CD
18637	4691	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4691	6	.	.	.
18637	4692	1	221	221	CD
18637	4692	2	;	;	:
18637	4692	3	Pensacola	Pensacola	NNP
18637	4692	4	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	4692	5	.	.	.
18637	4693	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4693	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4693	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4693	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4693	5	Western	Western	NNP
18637	4693	6	Union	Union	NNP
18637	4693	7	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	4693	8	.	.	.
18637	4694	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4694	2	,	,	,
18637	4694	3	96	96	CD
18637	4694	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4694	5	1	1	CD
18637	4694	6	,	,	,
18637	4694	7	3	3	CD
18637	4694	8	-	-	SYM
18637	4694	9	4	4	CD
18637	4694	10	,	,	,
18637	4694	11	11	11	CD
18637	4694	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4694	13	1878	1878	CD
18637	4694	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4694	15	.	.	.
18637	4695	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4695	2	373	373	CD
18637	4695	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4695	4	R.S.	R.S.	NNP
18637	4696	1	Secs	secs	JJ
18637	4696	2	.	.	.
18637	4697	1	4386	4386	CD
18637	4697	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4697	3	4390	4390	CD
18637	4697	4	;	;	:
18637	4697	5	replaced	replace	VBN
18637	4697	6	today	today	NN
18637	4697	7	by	by	IN
18637	4697	8	the	the	DT
18637	4697	9	Live	Live	NNP
18637	4697	10	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	4697	11	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	4697	12	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4697	13	of	of	IN
18637	4697	14	1906	1906	CD
18637	4697	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4697	16	34	34	CD
18637	4697	17	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4697	18	.	.	.
18637	4698	1	607	607	CD
18637	4698	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4698	3	.	.	.
18637	4699	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4699	2	374	374	CD
18637	4699	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4699	4	94	94	CD
18637	4699	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4699	6	113	113	CD
18637	4699	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4699	8	1877	1877	CD
18637	4699	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4699	10	.	.	.
18637	4700	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4700	2	375	375	CD
18637	4700	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4700	4	118	118	CD
18637	4700	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4700	6	557	557	CD
18637	4700	7	.	.	.
18637	4701	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4701	2	376	376	CD
18637	4701	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4701	4	24	24	CD
18637	4701	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4701	6	.	.	.
18637	4702	1	379	379	CD
18637	4702	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4702	3	1887	1887	CD
18637	4702	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4702	5	.	.	.
18637	4703	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4703	2	377	377	CD
18637	4703	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4703	4	154	154	CD
18637	4703	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4703	6	447	447	CD
18637	4703	7	.	.	.
18637	4704	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4704	2	378	378	CD
18637	4704	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4704	4	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	4704	5	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4704	6	Com	Com	NNP
18637	4704	7	.	.	.
18637	4705	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4705	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	4705	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4705	4	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	4705	5	Midland	Midland	NNP
18637	4705	6	R.	R.	NNP
18637	4705	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4705	8	,	,	,
18637	4705	9	168	168	CD
18637	4705	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4705	11	144	144	CD
18637	4705	12	,	,	,
18637	4705	13	176	176	CD
18637	4705	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4705	15	1897	1897	CD
18637	4705	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4705	17	.	.	.
18637	4706	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4706	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4706	3	also	also	RB
18637	4706	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4706	5	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	4706	6	,	,	,
18637	4706	7	N.O.	N.O.	NNP
18637	4707	1	&	&	CC
18637	4707	2	T.P.R.	T.P.R.	NNP
18637	4708	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4708	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4708	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4708	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4708	5	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	4708	6	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4708	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4708	8	,	,	,
18637	4708	9	162	162	CD
18637	4708	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4708	11	184	184	CD
18637	4708	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4708	13	1896	1896	CD
18637	4708	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4708	15	.	.	.
18637	4709	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4709	2	379	379	CD
18637	4709	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4709	4	34	34	CD
18637	4709	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4709	6	.	.	.
18637	4710	1	584	584	CD
18637	4710	2	.	.	.
18637	4711	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4711	2	380	380	CD
18637	4711	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4711	4	36	36	CD
18637	4711	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4711	6	.	.	.
18637	4712	1	539	539	CD
18637	4712	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4712	3	1910	1910	CD
18637	4712	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4712	5	.	.	.
18637	4713	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4713	2	381	381	CD
18637	4713	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4713	4	By	by	IN
18637	4713	5	the	the	DT
18637	4713	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4713	7	Communications	Communications	NNPS
18637	4713	8	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4713	9	of	of	IN
18637	4713	10	1934	1934	CD
18637	4713	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4713	12	48	48	CD
18637	4713	13	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4713	14	.	.	.
18637	4714	1	1081	1081	CD
18637	4714	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4714	3	,	,	,
18637	4714	4	this	this	DT
18637	4714	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	4714	6	was	be	VBD
18637	4714	7	handed	hand	VBN
18637	4714	8	over	over	RP
18637	4714	9	to	to	IN
18637	4714	10	the	the	DT
18637	4714	11	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4714	12	Communications	Communications	NNPS
18637	4714	13	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4714	14	,	,	,
18637	4714	15	created	create	VBN
18637	4714	16	by	by	IN
18637	4714	17	the	the	DT
18637	4714	18	act	act	NN
18637	4714	19	.	.	.
18637	4715	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4715	2	382	382	CD
18637	4715	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4715	4	41	41	CD
18637	4715	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	4715	6	.	.	.
18637	4716	1	474	474	CD
18637	4716	2	§	§	NNP
18637	4716	3	400	400	CD
18637	4716	4	;	;	:
18637	4716	5	488	488	CD
18637	4716	6	§	§	NNP
18637	4716	7	422	422	CD
18637	4716	8	.	.	.
18637	4717	1	The	the	DT
18637	4717	2	act	act	NN
18637	4717	3	must	must	MD
18637	4717	4	today	today	NN
18637	4717	5	be	be	VB
18637	4717	6	read	read	VBN
18637	4717	7	in	in	IN
18637	4717	8	conjunction	conjunction	NN
18637	4717	9	with	with	IN
18637	4717	10	the	the	DT
18637	4717	11	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	4717	12	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4717	13	of	of	IN
18637	4717	14	1940	1940	CD
18637	4717	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4717	16	54	54	CD
18637	4717	17	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4717	18	.	.	.
18637	4718	1	898	898	CD
18637	4718	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4718	3	,	,	,
18637	4718	4	which	which	WDT
18637	4718	5	"	"	``
18637	4718	6	was	be	VBD
18637	4718	7	intended	intend	VBN
18637	4718	8	,	,	,
18637	4718	9	together	together	RB
18637	4718	10	with	with	IN
18637	4718	11	the	the	DT
18637	4718	12	old	old	JJ
18637	4718	13	law	law	NN
18637	4718	14	,	,	,
18637	4718	15	to	to	TO
18637	4718	16	provide	provide	VB
18637	4718	17	a	a	DT
18637	4718	18	completely	completely	RB
18637	4718	19	integrated	integrate	VBN
18637	4718	20	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4718	21	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	4718	22	system	system	NN
18637	4718	23	over	over	IN
18637	4718	24	motor	motor	NN
18637	4718	25	,	,	,
18637	4718	26	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	4718	27	,	,	,
18637	4718	28	and	and	CC
18637	4718	29	water	water	NN
18637	4718	30	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	4718	31	.	.	.
18637	4718	32	"	"	''
18637	4719	1	United	United	NNP
18637	4719	2	States	States	NNP
18637	4719	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4719	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	4719	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4719	6	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	4719	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	4719	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4719	9	,	,	,
18637	4719	10	323	323	CD
18637	4719	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4719	12	612	612	CD
18637	4719	13	,	,	,
18637	4719	14	618	618	CD
18637	4719	15	-	-	SYM
18637	4719	16	619	619	CD
18637	4719	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4719	18	1945	1945	CD
18637	4719	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4719	20	.	.	.
18637	4720	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4720	2	383	383	CD
18637	4720	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4720	4	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	4720	5	E.	E.	NNP
18637	4720	6	&	&	CC
18637	4720	7	W.T.R.	W.T.R.	NNP
18637	4721	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4721	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4721	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4721	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4721	5	United	United	NNP
18637	4721	6	States	States	NNP
18637	4721	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4721	8	Shreveport	Shreveport	NNP
18637	4721	9	Case	Case	NNP
18637	4721	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4721	11	,	,	,
18637	4721	12	234	234	CD
18637	4721	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4721	14	342	342	CD
18637	4721	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4721	16	1914	1914	CD
18637	4721	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4721	18	.	.	.
18637	4722	1	Forty	Forty	NNP
18637	4722	2	States	States	NNP
18637	4722	3	,	,	,
18637	4722	4	through	through	IN
18637	4722	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4722	6	Attorneys	Attorneys	NNP
18637	4722	7	General	General	NNP
18637	4722	8	,	,	,
18637	4722	9	intervened	intervene	VBD
18637	4722	10	in	in	IN
18637	4722	11	the	the	DT
18637	4722	12	case	case	NN
18637	4722	13	against	against	IN
18637	4722	14	the	the	DT
18637	4722	15	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4722	16	's	's	POS
18637	4722	17	order	order	NN
18637	4722	18	.	.	.
18637	4723	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4723	2	384	384	CD
18637	4723	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4723	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4723	5	.	.	.
18637	4724	1	351	351	CD
18637	4724	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4724	3	352	352	CD
18637	4724	4	.	.	.
18637	4725	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4725	2	385	385	CD
18637	4725	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4725	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4725	5	.	.	.
18637	4726	1	353	353	CD
18637	4726	2	.	.	.
18637	4727	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4727	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4727	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4727	4	to	to	IN
18637	4727	5	the	the	DT
18637	4727	6	same	same	JJ
18637	4727	7	effect	effect	NN
18637	4727	8	American	American	NNP
18637	4727	9	Express	Express	NNP
18637	4727	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4727	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4727	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	4727	13	_	_	NNP
18637	4727	14	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	4727	15	,	,	,
18637	4727	16	244	244	CD
18637	4727	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4727	18	617	617	CD
18637	4727	19	,	,	,
18637	4727	20	627	627	CD
18637	4727	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4727	22	1917	1917	CD
18637	4727	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4727	24	;	;	:
18637	4727	25	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	4727	26	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	4727	27	.	.	.
18637	4728	1	&	&	CC
18637	4728	2	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	4728	3	.	.	.
18637	4729	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4729	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4729	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4729	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4729	5	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	4729	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4729	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4729	8	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	4729	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4729	10	,	,	,
18637	4729	11	297	297	CD
18637	4729	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4729	13	403	403	CD
18637	4729	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4729	15	1936	1936	CD
18637	4729	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4729	17	;	;	:
18637	4729	18	Weiss	Weiss	NNP
18637	4729	19	_	_	NNP
18637	4729	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	4729	21	_	_	NNP
18637	4729	22	United	United	NNP
18637	4729	23	States	States	NNP
18637	4729	24	,	,	,
18637	4729	25	308	308	CD
18637	4729	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4729	27	321	321	CD
18637	4729	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4729	29	1939	1939	CD
18637	4729	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4729	31	;	;	:
18637	4729	32	Bethlehem	Bethlehem	NNP
18637	4729	33	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	4729	34	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4729	35	_	_	NNP
18637	4729	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	4729	37	_	_	NNP
18637	4729	38	New	New	NNP
18637	4729	39	York	York	NNP
18637	4729	40	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	4729	41	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	4729	42	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	4729	43	.	.	NNP
18637	4729	44	,	,	,
18637	4729	45	330	330	CD
18637	4729	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4729	47	767	767	CD
18637	4729	48	,	,	,
18637	4729	49	772	772	CD
18637	4729	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4729	51	1947	1947	CD
18637	4729	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4729	53	;	;	:
18637	4729	54	and	and	CC
18637	4729	55	United	United	NNP
18637	4729	56	States	States	NNP
18637	4729	57	_	_	NNP
18637	4729	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	4729	59	_	_	NNP
18637	4729	60	Walsh	Walsh	NNP
18637	4729	61	,	,	,
18637	4729	62	331	331	CD
18637	4729	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4729	64	432	432	CD
18637	4729	65	,	,	,
18637	4729	66	438	438	CD
18637	4729	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4729	68	1947	1947	CD
18637	4729	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4729	70	.	.	.
18637	4730	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4730	2	386	386	CD
18637	4730	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4730	4	257	257	CD
18637	4730	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4730	6	563	563	CD
18637	4730	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4730	8	1922	1922	CD
18637	4730	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4730	10	.	.	.
18637	4731	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4731	2	387	387	CD
18637	4731	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4731	4	In	in	IN
18637	4731	5	North	North	NNP
18637	4731	6	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	4731	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4731	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4731	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4731	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4731	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4731	12	,	,	,
18637	4731	13	325	325	CD
18637	4731	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4731	15	507	507	CD
18637	4731	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4731	17	1945	1945	CD
18637	4731	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4731	19	,	,	,
18637	4731	20	the	the	DT
18637	4731	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4731	22	disallowed	disallow	VBD
18637	4731	23	as	as	IN
18637	4731	24	_	_	NNP
18637	4731	25	ultra	ultra	JJ
18637	4731	26	vires	vis	NNS
18637	4731	27	_	_	VBP
18637	4731	28	an	an	DT
18637	4731	29	order	order	NN
18637	4731	30	of	of	IN
18637	4731	31	the	the	DT
18637	4731	32	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	4731	33	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4731	34	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4731	35	,	,	,
18637	4731	36	setting	set	VBG
18637	4731	37	aside	aside	RP
18637	4731	38	State	state	NN
18637	4731	39	-	-	HYPH
18637	4731	40	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	4731	41	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	4731	42	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	4731	43	rates	rate	NNS
18637	4731	44	,	,	,
18637	4731	45	on	on	IN
18637	4731	46	the	the	DT
18637	4731	47	ground	ground	NN
18637	4731	48	that	that	IN
18637	4731	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4731	50	was	be	VBD
18637	4731	51	unsupported	unsupported	JJ
18637	4731	52	by	by	IN
18637	4731	53	clear	clear	JJ
18637	4731	54	findings	finding	NNS
18637	4731	55	and	and	CC
18637	4731	56	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	4731	57	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	4731	58	to	to	TO
18637	4731	59	show	show	VB
18637	4731	60	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4731	61	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	4731	62	.	.	.
18637	4732	1	Among	among	IN
18637	4732	2	the	the	DT
18637	4732	3	various	various	JJ
18637	4732	4	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	4732	5	of	of	IN
18637	4732	6	the	the	DT
18637	4732	7	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	4732	8	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4732	9	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4732	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4732	11	that	that	WDT
18637	4732	12	have	have	VBP
18637	4732	13	been	be	VBN
18637	4732	14	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	4732	15	in	in	IN
18637	4732	16	specific	specific	JJ
18637	4732	17	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	4732	18	are	be	VBP
18637	4732	19	the	the	DT
18637	4732	20	following	follow	VBG
18637	4732	21	:	:	:
18637	4732	22	a	a	DT
18637	4732	23	provision	provision	NN
18637	4732	24	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	4732	25	shippers	shipper	NNS
18637	4732	26	for	for	IN
18637	4732	27	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	4732	28	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	4732	29	at	at	IN
18637	4732	30	less	less	JJR
18637	4732	31	than	than	IN
18637	4732	32	published	publish	VBN
18637	4732	33	rates	rate	NNS
18637	4732	34	,	,	,
18637	4732	35	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	4732	36	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	4732	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4732	38	_	_	NNP
18637	4732	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	4732	40	_	_	NNP
18637	4732	41	United	United	NNP
18637	4732	42	States	States	NNP
18637	4732	43	,	,	,
18637	4732	44	209	209	CD
18637	4732	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4732	46	56	56	CD
18637	4732	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4732	48	1908	1908	CD
18637	4732	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4732	50	;	;	:
18637	4732	51	the	the	DT
18637	4732	52	so	so	RB
18637	4732	53	-	-	HYPH
18637	4732	54	called	call	VBN
18637	4732	55	"	"	``
18637	4732	56	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	4732	57	clause	clause	NN
18637	4732	58	"	"	''
18637	4732	59	of	of	IN
18637	4732	60	the	the	DT
18637	4732	61	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	4732	62	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4732	63	of	of	IN
18637	4732	64	June	June	NNP
18637	4732	65	29	29	CD
18637	4732	66	,	,	,
18637	4732	67	1906	1906	CD
18637	4732	68	,	,	,
18637	4732	69	construed	construe	VBD
18637	4732	70	as	as	IN
18637	4732	71	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	4732	72	the	the	DT
18637	4732	73	hauling	hauling	NN
18637	4732	74	of	of	IN
18637	4732	75	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	4732	76	in	in	IN
18637	4732	77	which	which	WDT
18637	4732	78	the	the	DT
18637	4732	79	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	4732	80	had	have	VBD
18637	4732	81	at	at	IN
18637	4732	82	the	the	DT
18637	4732	83	_	_	NNP
18637	4732	84	time	time	NN
18637	4732	85	of	of	IN
18637	4732	86	haul	haul	NNP
18637	4732	87	_	_	NNP
18637	4732	88	a	a	DT
18637	4732	89	proprietary	proprietary	JJ
18637	4732	90	interest	interest	NN
18637	4732	91	,	,	,
18637	4732	92	United	United	NNP
18637	4732	93	States	States	NNP
18637	4732	94	_	_	NNP
18637	4732	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	4732	96	_	_	NNP
18637	4732	97	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	4732	98	&	&	CC
18637	4732	99	H.	H.	NNP
18637	4732	100	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4732	101	,	,	,
18637	4732	102	213	213	CD
18637	4732	103	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4732	104	366	366	CD
18637	4732	105	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4732	106	1909	1909	CD
18637	4732	107	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4732	108	;	;	:
18637	4732	109	a	a	DT
18637	4732	110	provision	provision	NN
18637	4732	111	of	of	IN
18637	4732	112	the	the	DT
18637	4732	113	same	same	JJ
18637	4732	114	act	act	NN
18637	4732	115	abrogating	abrogate	VBG
18637	4732	116	life	life	NN
18637	4732	117	passes	pass	VBZ
18637	4732	118	,	,	,
18637	4732	119	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	4732	120	&	&	CC
18637	4732	121	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	4733	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4733	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4733	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4733	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4733	5	Mottley	Mottley	NNP
18637	4733	6	,	,	,
18637	4733	7	219	219	CD
18637	4733	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4733	9	467	467	CD
18637	4733	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4733	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	4733	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4733	13	;	;	:
18637	4733	14	a	a	DT
18637	4733	15	provision	provision	NN
18637	4733	16	of	of	IN
18637	4733	17	the	the	DT
18637	4733	18	same	same	JJ
18637	4733	19	act	act	NN
18637	4733	20	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	4733	21	the	the	DT
18637	4733	22	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4733	23	to	to	TO
18637	4733	24	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	4733	25	the	the	DT
18637	4733	26	entire	entire	JJ
18637	4733	27	system	system	NN
18637	4733	28	of	of	IN
18637	4733	29	bookkeeping	bookkeeping	NN
18637	4733	30	of	of	IN
18637	4733	31	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4733	32	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	4733	33	,	,	,
18637	4733	34	including	include	VBG
18637	4733	35	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	4733	36	accounts	account	NNS
18637	4733	37	,	,	,
18637	4733	38	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	4733	39	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4733	40	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4733	41	_	_	NNP
18637	4733	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	4733	43	_	_	NNP
18637	4733	44	Goodrich	Goodrich	NNP
18637	4733	45	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	4733	46	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4733	47	,	,	,
18637	4733	48	224	224	CD
18637	4733	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4733	50	194	194	CD
18637	4733	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4733	52	1912	1912	CD
18637	4733	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4733	54	;	;	:
18637	4733	55	the	the	DT
18637	4733	56	"	"	``
18637	4733	57	long	long	JJ
18637	4733	58	and	and	CC
18637	4733	59	short	short	JJ
18637	4733	60	haul	haul	NN
18637	4733	61	"	"	''
18637	4733	62	clause	clause	NN
18637	4733	63	of	of	IN
18637	4733	64	the	the	DT
18637	4733	65	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	4733	66	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4733	67	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4733	68	,	,	,
18637	4733	69	United	United	NNP
18637	4733	70	States	States	NNP
18637	4733	71	_	_	NNP
18637	4733	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	4733	73	_	_	NNP
18637	4733	74	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	4733	75	,	,	,
18637	4733	76	T.	T.	NNP
18637	4733	77	&	&	CC
18637	4733	78	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	4734	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4734	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4734	3	Intermountain	Intermountain	NNP
18637	4734	4	Rate	Rate	NNP
18637	4734	5	Cases	Cases	NNP
18637	4734	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4734	7	,	,	,
18637	4734	8	234	234	CD
18637	4734	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4734	10	476	476	CD
18637	4734	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4734	12	1914	1914	CD
18637	4734	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4734	14	;	;	:
18637	4734	15	an	an	DT
18637	4734	16	order	order	NN
18637	4734	17	of	of	IN
18637	4734	18	the	the	DT
18637	4734	19	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4734	20	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	4734	21	the	the	DT
18637	4734	22	so	so	RB
18637	4734	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	4734	24	called	call	VBN
18637	4734	25	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	4734	26	zone	zone	NN
18637	4734	27	or	or	CC
18637	4734	28	block	block	NN
18637	4734	29	system	system	NN
18637	4734	30	of	of	IN
18637	4734	31	express	express	JJ
18637	4734	32	rates	rate	NNS
18637	4734	33	,	,	,
18637	4734	34	American	American	NNP
18637	4734	35	Express	Express	NNP
18637	4734	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4734	37	_	_	NNP
18637	4734	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	4734	39	_	_	NNP
18637	4734	40	South	South	NNP
18637	4734	41	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	4734	42	ex	ex	NNP
18637	4734	43	rel	rel	NN
18637	4734	44	.	.	.
18637	4735	1	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	4735	2	,	,	,
18637	4735	3	244	244	CD
18637	4735	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4735	5	617	617	CD
18637	4735	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4735	7	1917	1917	CD
18637	4735	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4735	9	;	;	:
18637	4735	10	an	an	DT
18637	4735	11	order	order	NN
18637	4735	12	of	of	IN
18637	4735	13	the	the	DT
18637	4735	14	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4735	15	directing	direct	VBG
18637	4735	16	the	the	DT
18637	4735	17	abandonment	abandonment	NN
18637	4735	18	of	of	IN
18637	4735	19	an	an	DT
18637	4735	20	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	4735	21	branch	branch	NN
18637	4735	22	of	of	IN
18637	4735	23	an	an	DT
18637	4735	24	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4735	25	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	4735	26	,	,	,
18637	4735	27	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	4735	28	_	_	NNP
18637	4735	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	4735	30	_	_	NNP
18637	4735	31	United	United	NNP
18637	4735	32	States	States	NNP
18637	4735	33	,	,	,
18637	4735	34	271	271	CD
18637	4735	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4735	36	153	153	CD
18637	4735	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4735	38	1926	1926	CD
18637	4735	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4735	40	;	;	:
18637	4735	41	an	an	DT
18637	4735	42	order	order	NN
18637	4735	43	of	of	IN
18637	4735	44	the	the	DT
18637	4735	45	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4735	46	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	4735	47	rates	rate	NNS
18637	4735	48	of	of	IN
18637	4735	49	a	a	DT
18637	4735	50	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	4735	51	company	company	NN
18637	4735	52	operating	operate	VBG
18637	4735	53	solely	solely	RB
18637	4735	54	in	in	IN
18637	4735	55	the	the	DT
18637	4735	56	District	District	NNP
18637	4735	57	of	of	IN
18637	4735	58	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	4735	59	,	,	,
18637	4735	60	on	on	IN
18637	4735	61	the	the	DT
18637	4735	62	ground	ground	NN
18637	4735	63	that	that	IN
18637	4735	64	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4735	65	carriage	carriage	NN
18637	4735	66	of	of	IN
18637	4735	67	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	4735	68	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	4735	69	part	part	NN
18637	4735	70	of	of	IN
18637	4735	71	an	an	DT
18637	4735	72	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4735	73	movement	movement	NN
18637	4735	74	,	,	,
18637	4735	75	United	United	NNP
18637	4735	76	States	States	NNP
18637	4735	77	_	_	NNP
18637	4735	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	4735	79	_	_	NNP
18637	4735	80	Capital	Capital	NNP
18637	4735	81	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	4735	82	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4735	83	,	,	,
18637	4735	84	338	338	CD
18637	4735	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4735	86	286	286	CD
18637	4735	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4735	88	1949	1949	CD
18637	4735	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4735	90	.	.	.
18637	4736	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4736	2	388	388	CD
18637	4736	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4736	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4736	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4736	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4736	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4736	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4736	9	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	4736	10	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	4736	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4736	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4736	13	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	4736	14	Line	Line	NNP
18637	4736	15	Cases	Cases	NNP
18637	4736	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4736	17	,	,	,
18637	4736	18	234	234	CD
18637	4736	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4736	20	548	548	CD
18637	4736	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4736	22	1914	1914	CD
18637	4736	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4736	24	.	.	.
18637	4737	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4737	2	389	389	CD
18637	4737	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4737	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4737	5	See	See	NNP
18637	4737	6	also	also	RB
18637	4737	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4737	8	State	State	NNP
18637	4737	9	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	4737	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4737	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4737	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	4737	13	_	_	NNP
18637	4737	14	Wichita	Wichita	NNP
18637	4737	15	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	4737	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4737	17	,	,	,
18637	4737	18	290	290	CD
18637	4737	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4737	20	561	561	CD
18637	4737	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4737	22	1934	1934	CD
18637	4737	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4737	24	;	;	:
18637	4737	25	Eureka	Eureka	NNP
18637	4737	26	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	4737	27	Line	Line	NNP
18637	4737	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4737	29	_	_	NNP
18637	4737	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	4737	31	_	_	NNP
18637	4737	32	Hallanan	Hallanan	NNP
18637	4737	33	,	,	,
18637	4737	34	257	257	CD
18637	4737	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4737	36	265	265	CD
18637	4737	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4737	38	1921	1921	CD
18637	4737	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4737	40	;	;	:
18637	4737	41	United	United	NNP
18637	4737	42	Fuel	Fuel	NNP
18637	4737	43	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	4737	44	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4737	45	_	_	NNP
18637	4737	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	4737	47	_	_	NNP
18637	4737	48	Hallanan	Hallanan	NNP
18637	4737	49	,	,	,
18637	4737	50	257	257	CD
18637	4737	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4737	52	277	277	CD
18637	4737	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4737	54	1921	1921	CD
18637	4737	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4737	56	;	;	:
18637	4737	57	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	4737	58	_	_	NNP
18637	4737	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	4737	60	_	_	NNP
18637	4737	61	West	West	NNP
18637	4737	62	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	4737	63	,	,	,
18637	4737	64	262	262	CD
18637	4737	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4737	66	553	553	CD
18637	4737	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4737	68	1923	1923	CD
18637	4737	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4737	70	;	;	:
18637	4737	71	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	4737	72	ex	ex	NNP
18637	4737	73	rel	rel	NN
18637	4737	74	.	.	.
18637	4738	1	Barrett	Barrett	NNP
18637	4738	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4738	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4738	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4738	5	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	4738	6	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	4738	7	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	4738	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4738	9	,	,	,
18637	4738	10	265	265	CD
18637	4738	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4738	12	298	298	CD
18637	4738	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4738	14	1924	1924	CD
18637	4738	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4738	16	.	.	.
18637	4739	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4739	2	390	390	CD
18637	4739	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4739	4	Public	Public	NNP
18637	4739	5	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	4739	6	Com	Com	NNP
18637	4739	7	.	.	.
18637	4740	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4740	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	4740	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4740	4	Attleboro	Attleboro	NNP
18637	4740	5	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	4740	6	and	and	CC
18637	4740	7	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	4740	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4740	9	,	,	,
18637	4740	10	273	273	CD
18637	4740	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4740	12	83	83	CD
18637	4740	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4740	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	4740	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4740	16	.	.	.
18637	4741	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4741	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4741	3	also	also	RB
18637	4741	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4741	5	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	4741	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	4741	7	&	&	CC
18637	4741	8	Light	Light	NNP
18637	4741	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4741	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4741	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	4741	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4741	13	Pfost	Pfost	NNP
18637	4741	14	,	,	,
18637	4741	15	286	286	CD
18637	4741	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4741	17	165	165	CD
18637	4741	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4741	19	1932	1932	CD
18637	4741	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4741	21	.	.	.
18637	4742	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4742	2	391	391	CD
18637	4742	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4742	4	49	49	CD
18637	4742	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	4742	6	.	.	.
18637	4743	1	838	838	CD
18637	4743	2	.	.	.
18637	4744	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4744	2	392	392	CD
18637	4744	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4744	4	The	the	DT
18637	4744	5	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	4744	6	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	4744	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4744	8	of	of	IN
18637	4744	9	1938	1938	CD
18637	4744	10	,	,	,
18637	4744	11	52	52	CD
18637	4744	12	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	4744	13	.	.	.
18637	4745	1	821	821	CD
18637	4745	2	.	.	.
18637	4746	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4746	2	393	393	CD
18637	4746	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4746	4	315	315	CD
18637	4746	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4746	6	575	575	CD
18637	4746	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4746	8	1942	1942	CD
18637	4746	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4746	10	.	.	.
18637	4747	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4747	2	394	394	CD
18637	4747	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4747	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4747	5	.	.	.
18637	4748	1	582	582	CD
18637	4748	2	.	.	.
18637	4749	1	Sales	sale	NNS
18637	4749	2	to	to	IN
18637	4749	3	distributors	distributor	NNS
18637	4749	4	by	by	IN
18637	4749	5	a	a	DT
18637	4749	6	wholesaler	wholesaler	NN
18637	4749	7	of	of	IN
18637	4749	8	natural	natural	JJ
18637	4749	9	gas	gas	NN
18637	4749	10	which	which	WDT
18637	4749	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	4749	12	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	4749	13	to	to	IN
18637	4749	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4749	15	from	from	IN
18637	4749	16	an	an	DT
18637	4749	17	out	out	JJ
18637	4749	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	4749	19	of	of	IN
18637	4749	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	4749	21	State	state	NN
18637	4749	22	source	source	NN
18637	4749	23	are	be	VBP
18637	4749	24	subject	subject	JJ
18637	4749	25	to	to	IN
18637	4749	26	the	the	DT
18637	4749	27	rate	rate	NN
18637	4749	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	4749	29	making	make	VBG
18637	4749	30	powers	power	NNS
18637	4749	31	of	of	IN
18637	4749	32	the	the	DT
18637	4749	33	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4749	34	Power	Power	NNP
18637	4749	35	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4749	36	.	.	.
18637	4750	1	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	4750	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	4750	3	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	4750	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4750	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4750	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4750	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4750	8	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	4750	9	.	.	NNP
18637	4750	10	,	,	,
18637	4750	11	324	324	CD
18637	4750	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4750	13	626	626	CD
18637	4750	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4750	15	1945	1945	CD
18637	4750	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4750	17	.	.	.
18637	4751	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4751	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4751	3	also	also	RB
18637	4751	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4751	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	4751	6	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	4751	7	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	4751	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4751	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4751	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	4751	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4751	12	Central	Central	NNP
18637	4751	13	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	4751	14	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	4751	15	.	.	.
18637	4752	1	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	4752	2	.	.	.
18637	4753	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4753	2	,	,	,
18637	4753	3	314	314	CD
18637	4753	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4753	5	498	498	CD
18637	4753	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4753	7	1942	1942	CD
18637	4753	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4753	9	;	;	:
18637	4753	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4753	11	also	also	RB
18637	4753	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4753	13	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4753	14	Power	Power	NNP
18637	4753	15	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4753	16	_	_	NNP
18637	4753	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	4753	18	_	_	NNP
18637	4753	19	East	East	NNP
18637	4753	20	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	4753	21	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	4753	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4753	23	,	,	,
18637	4753	24	338	338	CD
18637	4753	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4753	26	464	464	CD
18637	4753	27	,	,	,
18637	4753	28	decided	decide	VBD
18637	4753	29	January	January	NNP
18637	4753	30	9	9	CD
18637	4753	31	,	,	,
18637	4753	32	1950	1950	CD
18637	4753	33	,	,	,
18637	4753	34	where	where	WRB
18637	4753	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4753	36	was	be	VBD
18637	4753	37	held	hold	VBN
18637	4753	38	that	that	IN
18637	4753	39	a	a	DT
18637	4753	40	natural	natural	JJ
18637	4753	41	gas	gas	NN
18637	4753	42	company	company	NN
18637	4753	43	which	which	WDT
18637	4753	44	,	,	,
18637	4753	45	while	while	IN
18637	4753	46	operating	operate	VBG
18637	4753	47	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	4753	48	in	in	IN
18637	4753	49	one	one	CD
18637	4753	50	State	state	NN
18637	4753	51	,	,	,
18637	4753	52	sold	sell	VBN
18637	4753	53	there	there	RB
18637	4753	54	directly	directly	RB
18637	4753	55	to	to	IN
18637	4753	56	consumers	consumer	NNS
18637	4753	57	gas	gas	NN
18637	4753	58	transported	transport	VBN
18637	4753	59	into	into	IN
18637	4753	60	the	the	DT
18637	4753	61	State	State	NNP
18637	4753	62	through	through	IN
18637	4753	63	the	the	DT
18637	4753	64	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4753	65	lines	line	NNS
18637	4753	66	of	of	IN
18637	4753	67	other	other	JJ
18637	4753	68	companies	company	NNS
18637	4753	69	,	,	,
18637	4753	70	"	"	''
18637	4753	71	a	a	DT
18637	4753	72	natural	natural	JJ
18637	4753	73	gas	gas	NN
18637	4753	74	company	company	NN
18637	4753	75	"	"	''
18637	4753	76	within	within	IN
18637	4753	77	the	the	DT
18637	4753	78	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	4753	79	of	of	IN
18637	4753	80	the	the	DT
18637	4753	81	act	act	NN
18637	4753	82	of	of	IN
18637	4753	83	1938	1938	CD
18637	4753	84	,	,	,
18637	4753	85	and	and	CC
18637	4753	86	so	so	RB
18637	4753	87	could	could	MD
18637	4753	88	be	be	VB
18637	4753	89	required	require	VBN
18637	4753	90	by	by	IN
18637	4753	91	the	the	DT
18637	4753	92	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4753	93	to	to	TO
18637	4753	94	keep	keep	VB
18637	4753	95	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	4753	96	accounts	account	NNS
18637	4753	97	and	and	CC
18637	4753	98	submit	submit	VB
18637	4753	99	reports	report	NNS
18637	4753	100	.	.	.
18637	4754	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4754	2	395	395	CD
18637	4754	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4754	4	48	48	CD
18637	4754	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4754	6	.	.	.
18637	4755	1	1064	1064	CD
18637	4755	2	.	.	.
18637	4756	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4756	2	396	396	CD
18637	4756	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4756	4	49	49	CD
18637	4756	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	4756	6	.	.	.
18637	4757	1	543	543	CD
18637	4757	2	;	;	:
18637	4757	3	since	since	IN
18637	4757	4	amended	amend	VBN
18637	4757	5	in	in	IN
18637	4757	6	some	some	DT
18637	4757	7	respects	respect	NNS
18637	4757	8	in	in	IN
18637	4757	9	1938	1938	CD
18637	4757	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4757	11	52	52	CD
18637	4757	12	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4757	13	.	.	.
18637	4758	1	973	973	CD
18637	4758	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4758	3	and	and	CC
18637	4758	4	1940	1940	CD
18637	4758	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4758	6	54	54	CD
18637	4758	7	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4758	8	.	.	.
18637	4759	1	735	735	CD
18637	4759	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4759	3	.	.	.
18637	4760	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4760	2	397	397	CD
18637	4760	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4760	4	52	52	CD
18637	4760	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4760	6	.	.	.
18637	4761	1	973	973	CD
18637	4761	2	.	.	.
18637	4762	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4762	2	398	398	CD
18637	4762	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4762	4	27	27	CD
18637	4762	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	4762	6	.	.	.
18637	4763	1	531	531	CD
18637	4763	2	.	.	.
18637	4764	1	As	as	RB
18637	4764	2	early	early	RB
18637	4764	3	as	as	IN
18637	4764	4	1838	1838	CD
18637	4764	5	laws	law	NNS
18637	4764	6	were	be	VBD
18637	4764	7	passed	pass	VBN
18637	4764	8	requiring	require	VBG
18637	4764	9	the	the	DT
18637	4764	10	installation	installation	NN
18637	4764	11	of	of	IN
18637	4764	12	safety	safety	NN
18637	4764	13	devices	device	NNS
18637	4764	14	on	on	IN
18637	4764	15	steam	steam	NN
18637	4764	16	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	4764	17	.	.	.
18637	4765	1	5	5	CD
18637	4765	2	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	4765	3	.	.	.
18637	4766	1	304	304	CD
18637	4766	2	and	and	CC
18637	4766	3	626	626	CD
18637	4766	4	.	.	.
18637	4767	1	Along	along	IN
18637	4767	2	with	with	IN
18637	4767	3	the	the	DT
18637	4767	4	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	4767	5	Appliance	Appliance	NNP
18637	4767	6	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	4767	7	mention	mention	VBP
18637	4767	8	should	should	MD
18637	4767	9	also	also	RB
18637	4767	10	be	be	VB
18637	4767	11	made	make	VBN
18637	4767	12	of	of	IN
18637	4767	13	acts	act	NNS
18637	4767	14	requiring	require	VBG
18637	4767	15	the	the	DT
18637	4767	16	use	use	NN
18637	4767	17	of	of	IN
18637	4767	18	ashpans	ashpan	NNS
18637	4767	19	on	on	IN
18637	4767	20	locomotives	locomotive	NNS
18637	4767	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4767	22	35	35	CD
18637	4767	23	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4767	24	.	.	.
18637	4768	1	476	476	CD
18637	4768	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4768	3	1908	1908	CD
18637	4768	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4768	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4768	6	;	;	:
18637	4768	7	the	the	DT
18637	4768	8	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	4768	9	of	of	IN
18637	4768	10	boilers	boiler	NNS
18637	4768	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4768	12	36	36	CD
18637	4768	13	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4768	14	.	.	.
18637	4769	1	913	913	CD
18637	4769	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4769	3	1911	1911	CD
18637	4769	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4769	5	and	and	CC
18637	4769	6	38	38	CD
18637	4769	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	4769	8	.	.	.
18637	4770	1	1192	1192	CD
18637	4770	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4770	3	1915	1915	CD
18637	4770	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4770	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4770	6	;	;	:
18637	4770	7	the	the	DT
18637	4770	8	use	use	NN
18637	4770	9	of	of	IN
18637	4770	10	ladders	ladder	NNS
18637	4770	11	,	,	,
18637	4770	12	drawbars	drawbar	NNS
18637	4770	13	,	,	,
18637	4770	14	etc	etc	FW
18637	4770	15	.	.	FW
18637	4770	16	,	,	,
18637	4770	17	on	on	IN
18637	4770	18	cars	car	NNS
18637	4770	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4770	20	36	36	CD
18637	4770	21	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4770	22	.	.	.
18637	4771	1	298	298	CD
18637	4771	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4771	3	1910	1910	CD
18637	4771	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4771	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4771	6	;	;	,
18637	4771	7	etc	etc	FW
18637	4771	8	.	.	.
18637	4772	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4772	2	399	399	CD
18637	4772	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4772	4	32	32	CD
18637	4772	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4772	6	.	.	.
18637	4773	1	943	943	CD
18637	4773	2	.	.	.
18637	4774	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4774	2	400	400	CD
18637	4774	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4774	4	222	222	CD
18637	4774	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4774	6	20	20	CD
18637	4774	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4774	8	1911	1911	CD
18637	4774	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4774	10	.	.	.
18637	4775	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4775	2	401	401	CD
18637	4775	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4775	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4775	5	.	.	.
18637	4776	1	26	26	CD
18637	4776	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4776	3	27	27	CD
18637	4776	4	.	.	.
18637	4777	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4777	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4777	3	also	also	RB
18637	4777	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4777	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	4777	6	&	&	CC
18637	4777	7	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	4778	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4778	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4778	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4778	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4778	5	Rigsby	Rigsby	NNP
18637	4778	6	,	,	,
18637	4778	7	241	241	CD
18637	4778	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4778	9	33	33	CD
18637	4778	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4778	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	4778	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4778	13	;	;	:
18637	4778	14	and	and	CC
18637	4778	15	United	United	NNP
18637	4778	16	States	States	NNP
18637	4778	17	_	_	NNP
18637	4778	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	4778	19	_	_	NNP
18637	4778	20	California	California	NNP
18637	4778	21	,	,	,
18637	4778	22	297	297	CD
18637	4778	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4778	24	175	175	CD
18637	4778	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4778	26	1936	1936	CD
18637	4778	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4778	28	.	.	.
18637	4779	1	In	in	IN
18637	4779	2	the	the	DT
18637	4779	3	latter	latter	JJ
18637	4779	4	case	case	NN
18637	4779	5	the	the	DT
18637	4779	6	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	4779	7	railway	railway	NN
18637	4779	8	involved	involve	VBN
18637	4779	9	was	be	VBD
18637	4779	10	property	property	NN
18637	4779	11	of	of	IN
18637	4779	12	the	the	DT
18637	4779	13	State	State	NNP
18637	4779	14	.	.	.
18637	4780	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4780	2	402	402	CD
18637	4780	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4780	4	34	34	CD
18637	4780	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4780	6	.	.	.
18637	4781	1	1415	1415	CD
18637	4781	2	.	.	.
18637	4782	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4782	2	403	403	CD
18637	4782	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4782	4	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	4782	5	&	&	CC
18637	4782	6	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	4783	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4783	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4783	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4783	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4783	5	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	4783	6	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4783	7	Com	Com	NNP
18637	4783	8	.	.	NNP
18637	4783	9	,	,	,
18637	4783	10	221	221	CD
18637	4783	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4783	12	612	612	CD
18637	4783	13	,	,	,
18637	4783	14	618	618	CD
18637	4783	15	-	-	SYM
18637	4783	16	619	619	CD
18637	4783	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4783	18	1911	1911	CD
18637	4783	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4783	20	.	.	.
18637	4784	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4784	2	404	404	CD
18637	4784	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4784	4	34	34	CD
18637	4784	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4784	6	.	.	.
18637	4785	1	232	232	CD
18637	4785	2	,	,	,
18637	4785	3	disallowed	disallow	VBN
18637	4785	4	in	in	IN
18637	4785	5	part	part	NN
18637	4785	6	in	in	IN
18637	4785	7	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	4785	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4785	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4785	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4785	11	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	4785	12	Central	Central	NNP
18637	4785	13	R.	R.	NNP
18637	4785	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4785	15	,	,	,
18637	4785	16	207	207	CD
18637	4785	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4785	18	463	463	CD
18637	4785	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4785	20	1908	1908	CD
18637	4785	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4785	22	;	;	:
18637	4785	23	35	35	CD
18637	4785	24	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	4785	25	.	.	.
18637	4786	1	65	65	CD
18637	4786	2	,	,	,
18637	4786	3	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	4786	4	in	in	IN
18637	4786	5	the	the	DT
18637	4786	6	Second	Second	NNP
18637	4786	7	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	4786	8	'	'	POS
18637	4786	9	Liability	liability	NN
18637	4786	10	Cases	case	NNS
18637	4786	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4786	12	Mondou	Mondou	NNP
18637	4786	13	_	_	NNP
18637	4786	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	4786	15	_	_	NNP
18637	4786	16	New	New	NNP
18637	4786	17	York	York	NNP
18637	4786	18	,	,	,
18637	4786	19	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	4786	20	&	&	CC
18637	4786	21	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	4787	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4787	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4787	3	,	,	,
18637	4787	4	223	223	CD
18637	4787	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4787	6	1	1	CD
18637	4787	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4787	8	1912	1912	CD
18637	4787	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4787	10	.	.	.
18637	4788	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4788	2	405	405	CD
18637	4788	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4788	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4788	5	See	See	NNP
18637	4788	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4788	7	223	223	CD
18637	4788	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4788	9	at	at	IN
18637	4788	10	19	19	CD
18637	4788	11	-	-	SYM
18637	4788	12	22	22	CD
18637	4788	13	.	.	.
18637	4789	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4789	2	406	406	CD
18637	4789	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4789	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4789	5	.	.	.
18637	4790	1	48	48	CD
18637	4790	2	.	.	.
18637	4791	1	Because	because	IN
18637	4791	2	the	the	DT
18637	4791	3	injured	injure	VBN
18637	4791	4	employee	employee	NN
18637	4791	5	must	must	MD
18637	4791	6	,	,	,
18637	4791	7	in	in	IN
18637	4791	8	order	order	NN
18637	4791	9	to	to	TO
18637	4791	10	benefit	benefit	VB
18637	4791	11	from	from	IN
18637	4791	12	the	the	DT
18637	4791	13	act	act	NN
18637	4791	14	,	,	,
18637	4791	15	be	be	VB
18637	4791	16	employed	employ	VBN
18637	4791	17	at	at	IN
18637	4791	18	the	the	DT
18637	4791	19	time	time	NN
18637	4791	20	of	of	IN
18637	4791	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4791	22	injury	injury	NN
18637	4791	23	"	"	''
18637	4791	24	in	in	IN
18637	4791	25	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4791	26	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4791	27	,	,	,
18637	4791	28	"	"	''
18637	4791	29	the	the	DT
18637	4791	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4791	31	's	's	POS
18637	4791	32	application	application	NN
18637	4791	33	of	of	IN
18637	4791	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4791	35	has	have	VBZ
18637	4791	36	given	give	VBN
18637	4791	37	rise	rise	NN
18637	4791	38	to	to	IN
18637	4791	39	some	some	DT
18637	4791	40	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	4791	41	distinctions	distinction	NNS
18637	4791	42	.	.	.
18637	4792	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4792	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4792	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4792	4	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	4792	5	Central	Central	NNP
18637	4792	6	R.	R.	NNP
18637	4792	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4792	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4792	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4792	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4792	11	Peery	Peery	NNP
18637	4792	12	,	,	,
18637	4792	13	242	242	CD
18637	4792	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4792	15	292	292	CD
18637	4792	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4792	17	1916	1916	CD
18637	4792	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4792	19	;	;	:
18637	4792	20	New	New	NNP
18637	4792	21	York	York	NNP
18637	4792	22	Central	Central	NNP
18637	4792	23	R.	R.	NNP
18637	4792	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4792	25	_	_	NNP
18637	4792	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	4792	27	_	_	NNP
18637	4792	28	White	White	NNP
18637	4792	29	,	,	,
18637	4792	30	243	243	CD
18637	4792	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4792	32	188	188	CD
18637	4792	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4792	34	1917	1917	CD
18637	4792	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4792	36	;	;	:
18637	4792	37	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	4792	38	,	,	,
18637	4792	39	B.	B.	NNP
18637	4793	1	&	&	CC
18637	4793	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	4794	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4794	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4794	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4794	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4794	5	Harrington	Harrington	NNP
18637	4794	6	,	,	,
18637	4794	7	241	241	CD
18637	4794	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4794	9	177	177	CD
18637	4794	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4794	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	4794	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4794	13	;	;	:
18637	4794	14	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	4794	15	&	&	CC
18637	4794	16	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	4795	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4795	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4795	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4795	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4795	5	Parker	Parker	NNP
18637	4795	6	,	,	,
18637	4795	7	242	242	CD
18637	4795	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4795	9	13	13	CD
18637	4795	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4795	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	4795	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4795	13	;	;	:
18637	4795	14	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	4795	15	Central	Central	NNP
18637	4795	16	R.	R.	NNP
18637	4795	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4795	18	_	_	NNP
18637	4795	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	4795	20	_	_	NNP
18637	4795	21	Behrens	Behrens	NNP
18637	4795	22	,	,	,
18637	4795	23	233	233	CD
18637	4795	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4795	25	473	473	CD
18637	4795	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4795	27	1914	1914	CD
18637	4795	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4795	29	;	;	:
18637	4795	30	St.	St.	NNP
18637	4795	31	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	4795	32	,	,	,
18637	4795	33	S.F.	S.F.	NNP
18637	4796	1	&	&	CC
18637	4796	2	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	4797	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4797	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4797	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4797	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4797	5	Seale	Seale	NNP
18637	4797	6	,	,	,
18637	4797	7	229	229	CD
18637	4797	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4797	9	156	156	CD
18637	4797	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4797	11	1913	1913	CD
18637	4797	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4797	13	;	;	:
18637	4797	14	Pedersen	Pedersen	NNP
18637	4797	15	_	_	NNP
18637	4797	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	4797	17	_	_	NNP
18637	4797	18	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	4797	19	,	,	,
18637	4797	20	L.	L.	NNP
18637	4797	21	&	&	CC
18637	4797	22	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	4797	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4797	24	,	,	,
18637	4797	25	229	229	CD
18637	4797	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4797	27	146	146	CD
18637	4797	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4797	29	1913	1913	CD
18637	4797	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4797	31	;	;	:
18637	4797	32	Shanks	Shanks	NNP
18637	4797	33	_	_	NNP
18637	4797	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	4797	35	_	_	NNP
18637	4797	36	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	4797	37	,	,	,
18637	4797	38	L.	L.	NNP
18637	4797	39	&	&	CC
18637	4797	40	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	4797	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4797	42	,	,	,
18637	4797	43	239	239	CD
18637	4797	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4797	45	556	556	CD
18637	4797	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4797	47	1916	1916	CD
18637	4797	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4797	49	;	;	:
18637	4797	50	Lehigh	Lehigh	NNP
18637	4797	51	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	4797	52	R.	R.	NNP
18637	4797	53	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4797	54	_	_	NNP
18637	4797	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	4797	56	_	_	NNP
18637	4797	57	Barlow	Barlow	NNP
18637	4797	58	,	,	,
18637	4797	59	244	244	CD
18637	4797	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4797	61	183	183	CD
18637	4797	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4797	63	1917	1917	CD
18637	4797	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4797	65	;	;	:
18637	4797	66	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	4797	67	R.	R.	NNP
18637	4797	68	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4797	69	_	_	NNP
18637	4797	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	4797	71	_	_	NNP
18637	4797	72	Puckett	Puckett	NNP
18637	4797	73	,	,	,
18637	4797	74	244	244	CD
18637	4797	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4797	76	571	571	CD
18637	4797	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4797	78	1917	1917	CD
18637	4797	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4797	80	;	;	:
18637	4797	81	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	4797	82	_	_	NNP
18637	4797	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	4797	84	_	_	NNP
18637	4797	85	Director	Director	NNP
18637	4797	86	General	General	NNP
18637	4797	87	of	of	IN
18637	4797	88	Railroads	Railroads	NNP
18637	4797	89	,	,	,
18637	4797	90	258	258	CD
18637	4797	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4797	92	92	92	CD
18637	4797	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4797	94	1922	1922	CD
18637	4797	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4797	96	.	.	.
18637	4798	1	That	that	IN
18637	4798	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4798	3	might	may	MD
18637	4798	4	"	"	``
18637	4798	5	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	4798	6	as	as	IN
18637	4798	7	to	to	IN
18637	4798	8	the	the	DT
18637	4798	9	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	4798	10	,	,	,
18637	4798	11	duties	duty	NNS
18637	4798	12	,	,	,
18637	4798	13	and	and	CC
18637	4798	14	liabilities	liability	NNS
18637	4798	15	of	of	IN
18637	4798	16	employes	employe	NNS
18637	4798	17	and	and	CC
18637	4798	18	others	other	NNS
18637	4798	19	on	on	IN
18637	4798	20	railway	railway	NN
18637	4798	21	trains	train	NNS
18637	4798	22	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	4798	23	in	in	IN
18637	4798	24	that	that	DT
18637	4798	25	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4798	26	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4798	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4798	28	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4798	29	,	,	,
18637	4798	30	"	"	''
18637	4798	31	was	be	VBD
18637	4798	32	stated	state	VBN
18637	4798	33	by	by	IN
18637	4798	34	the	the	DT
18637	4798	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4798	36	in	in	IN
18637	4798	37	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	4798	38	,	,	,
18637	4798	39	C.	C.	NNP
18637	4798	40	&	&	CC
18637	4798	41	St.	St.	NNP
18637	4798	42	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	4799	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4799	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4799	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4799	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4799	5	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	4799	6	,	,	,
18637	4799	7	128	128	CD
18637	4799	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4799	9	96	96	CD
18637	4799	10	,	,	,
18637	4799	11	99	99	CD
18637	4799	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4799	13	1888	1888	CD
18637	4799	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4799	15	.	.	.
18637	4800	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4800	2	407	407	CD
18637	4800	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4800	4	208	208	CD
18637	4800	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4800	6	161	161	CD
18637	4800	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4800	8	1908	1908	CD
18637	4800	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4800	10	.	.	.
18637	4801	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4801	2	408	408	CD
18637	4801	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4801	4	30	30	CD
18637	4801	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4801	6	.	.	.
18637	4802	1	424	424	CD
18637	4802	2	.	.	.
18637	4803	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4803	2	409	409	CD
18637	4803	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4803	4	44	44	CD
18637	4803	5	.	.	.
18637	4804	1	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	4804	2	.	.	.
18637	4805	1	577	577	CD
18637	4805	2	.	.	.
18637	4806	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4806	2	410	410	CD
18637	4806	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4806	4	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	4806	5	&	&	CC
18637	4806	6	N.O.R.	N.O.R.	NNP
18637	4807	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4807	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4807	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4807	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4807	5	Brotherhood	Brotherhood	NNP
18637	4807	6	of	of	IN
18637	4807	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	4807	8	&	&	CC
18637	4807	9	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	4807	10	Clerks	Clerks	NNP
18637	4807	11	,	,	,
18637	4807	12	281	281	CD
18637	4807	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4807	14	548	548	CD
18637	4807	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4807	16	1930	1930	CD
18637	4807	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4807	18	.	.	.
18637	4808	1	The	the	DT
18637	4808	2	provision	provision	NN
18637	4808	3	of	of	IN
18637	4808	4	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	4808	5	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	4808	6	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4808	7	of	of	IN
18637	4808	8	1926	1926	CD
18637	4808	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4808	10	44	44	CD
18637	4808	11	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4808	12	.	.	.
18637	4809	1	577	577	CD
18637	4809	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4809	3	,	,	,
18637	4809	4	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	4809	5	interference	interference	NN
18637	4809	6	by	by	IN
18637	4809	7	either	either	DT
18637	4809	8	party	party	NN
18637	4809	9	with	with	IN
18637	4809	10	organization	organization	NN
18637	4809	11	or	or	CC
18637	4809	12	designation	designation	NN
18637	4809	13	of	of	IN
18637	4809	14	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	4809	15	by	by	IN
18637	4809	16	the	the	DT
18637	4809	17	other	other	JJ
18637	4809	18	,	,	,
18637	4809	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	4809	20	within	within	IN
18637	4809	21	the	the	DT
18637	4809	22	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	4809	23	authority	authority	NN
18637	4809	24	of	of	IN
18637	4809	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4809	26	.	.	.
18637	4810	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	4810	2	,	,	,
18637	4810	3	"	"	``
18637	4810	4	back	back	JJ
18637	4810	5	shop	shop	NN
18637	4810	6	"	"	''
18637	4810	7	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4810	8	of	of	IN
18637	4810	9	an	an	DT
18637	4810	10	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4810	11	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	4810	12	,	,	,
18637	4810	13	who	who	WP
18637	4810	14	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	4810	15	in	in	IN
18637	4810	16	making	make	VBG
18637	4810	17	heavy	heavy	JJ
18637	4810	18	repairs	repair	NNS
18637	4810	19	on	on	IN
18637	4810	20	locomotives	locomotive	NNS
18637	4810	21	and	and	CC
18637	4810	22	cars	car	NNS
18637	4810	23	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	4810	24	from	from	IN
18637	4810	25	service	service	NN
18637	4810	26	for	for	IN
18637	4810	27	that	that	DT
18637	4810	28	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	4810	29	for	for	IN
18637	4810	30	long	long	JJ
18637	4810	31	periods	period	NNS
18637	4810	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4810	33	an	an	DT
18637	4810	34	average	average	NN
18637	4810	35	of	of	IN
18637	4810	36	105	105	CD
18637	4810	37	days	day	NNS
18637	4810	38	for	for	IN
18637	4810	39	locomotives	locomotive	NNS
18637	4810	40	and	and	CC
18637	4810	41	109	109	CD
18637	4810	42	days	day	NNS
18637	4810	43	for	for	IN
18637	4810	44	cars	car	NNS
18637	4810	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4810	46	,	,	,
18637	4810	47	were	be	VBD
18637	4810	48	held	hold	VBN
18637	4810	49	to	to	TO
18637	4810	50	be	be	VB
18637	4810	51	within	within	IN
18637	4810	52	the	the	DT
18637	4810	53	terms	term	NNS
18637	4810	54	of	of	IN
18637	4810	55	the	the	DT
18637	4810	56	act	act	NN
18637	4810	57	as	as	IN
18637	4810	58	amended	amend	VBN
18637	4810	59	in	in	IN
18637	4810	60	1934	1934	CD
18637	4810	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4810	62	48	48	CD
18637	4810	63	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4810	64	.	.	.
18637	4811	1	1185	1185	CD
18637	4811	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4811	3	.	.	.
18637	4812	1	"	"	``
18637	4812	2	The	the	DT
18637	4812	3	activities	activity	NNS
18637	4812	4	in	in	IN
18637	4812	5	which	which	WDT
18637	4812	6	these	these	DT
18637	4812	7	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4812	8	are	be	VBP
18637	4812	9	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4812	10	have	have	VBP
18637	4812	11	such	such	PDT
18637	4812	12	a	a	DT
18637	4812	13	relation	relation	NN
18637	4812	14	to	to	IN
18637	4812	15	the	the	DT
18637	4812	16	other	other	JJ
18637	4812	17	confessedly	confessedly	RB
18637	4812	18	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4812	19	activities	activity	NNS
18637	4812	20	of	of	IN
18637	4812	21	the	the	DT
18637	4812	22	*	*	NFP
18637	4812	23	*	*	NFP
18637	4812	24	*	*	NFP
18637	4812	25	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4812	26	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	4812	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4812	28	that	that	IN
18637	4812	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4812	30	are	be	VBP
18637	4812	31	to	to	TO
18637	4812	32	be	be	VB
18637	4812	33	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	4812	34	as	as	IN
18637	4812	35	a	a	DT
18637	4812	36	part	part	NN
18637	4812	37	of	of	IN
18637	4812	38	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4812	39	.	.	.
18637	4813	1	All	all	DT
18637	4813	2	taken	take	VBN
18637	4813	3	together	together	RB
18637	4813	4	fall	fall	VBP
18637	4813	5	within	within	IN
18637	4813	6	the	the	DT
18637	4813	7	power	power	NN
18637	4813	8	of	of	IN
18637	4813	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4813	10	over	over	IN
18637	4813	11	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4813	12	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4813	13	.	.	.
18637	4813	14	"	"	''
18637	4814	1	Virginian	Virginian	NNP
18637	4814	2	R.	R.	NNP
18637	4814	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4814	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4814	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	4814	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4814	7	System	System	NNP
18637	4814	8	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	4814	9	No	No	NNP
18637	4814	10	.	.	.
18637	4815	1	40	40	CD
18637	4815	2	,	,	,
18637	4815	3	300	300	CD
18637	4815	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4815	5	515	515	CD
18637	4815	6	,	,	,
18637	4815	7	556	556	CD
18637	4815	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4815	9	1937	1937	CD
18637	4815	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4815	11	.	.	.
18637	4816	1	By	by	IN
18637	4816	2	the	the	DT
18637	4816	3	Adamson	Adamson	NNP
18637	4816	4	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4816	5	of	of	IN
18637	4816	6	1916	1916	CD
18637	4816	7	a	a	DT
18637	4816	8	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	4816	9	increase	increase	NN
18637	4816	10	in	in	IN
18637	4816	11	wages	wage	NNS
18637	4816	12	was	be	VBD
18637	4816	13	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	4816	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	4816	15	the	the	DT
18637	4816	16	railways	railway	NNS
18637	4816	17	of	of	IN
18637	4816	18	the	the	DT
18637	4816	19	country	country	NN
18637	4816	20	in	in	IN
18637	4816	21	order	order	NN
18637	4816	22	to	to	TO
18637	4816	23	meet	meet	VB
18637	4816	24	a	a	DT
18637	4816	25	sudden	sudden	JJ
18637	4816	26	threat	threat	NN
18637	4816	27	to	to	TO
18637	4816	28	strike	strike	VB
18637	4816	29	by	by	IN
18637	4816	30	important	important	JJ
18637	4816	31	groups	group	NNS
18637	4816	32	of	of	IN
18637	4816	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4816	34	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4816	35	.	.	.
18637	4817	1	The	the	DT
18637	4817	2	act	act	NN
18637	4817	3	was	be	VBD
18637	4817	4	assailed	assail	VBN
18637	4817	5	on	on	IN
18637	4817	6	the	the	DT
18637	4817	7	dual	dual	JJ
18637	4817	8	ground	ground	NN
18637	4817	9	that	that	IN
18637	4817	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4817	11	was	be	VBD
18637	4817	12	not	not	RB
18637	4817	13	a	a	DT
18637	4817	14	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	4817	15	of	of	IN
18637	4817	16	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4817	17	among	among	IN
18637	4817	18	the	the	DT
18637	4817	19	States	States	NNP
18637	4817	20	and	and	CC
18637	4817	21	that	that	IN
18637	4817	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4817	23	was	be	VBD
18637	4817	24	violative	violative	JJ
18637	4817	25	of	of	IN
18637	4817	26	the	the	DT
18637	4817	27	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	4817	28	'	'	POS
18637	4817	29	rights	right	NNS
18637	4817	30	under	under	IN
18637	4817	31	the	the	DT
18637	4817	32	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	4817	33	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	4817	34	.	.	.
18637	4818	1	A	a	DT
18637	4818	2	closely	closely	RB
18637	4818	3	divided	divide	VBN
18637	4818	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4818	5	,	,	,
18637	4818	6	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	4818	7	through	through	IN
18637	4818	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	4818	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4818	10	White	White	NNP
18637	4818	11	,	,	,
18637	4818	12	answered	answer	VBD
18637	4818	13	both	both	DT
18637	4818	14	objections	objection	NNS
18637	4818	15	by	by	IN
18637	4818	16	pointing	point	VBG
18637	4818	17	to	to	IN
18637	4818	18	the	the	DT
18637	4818	19	magnitude	magnitude	NN
18637	4818	20	of	of	IN
18637	4818	21	the	the	DT
18637	4818	22	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	4818	23	which	which	WDT
18637	4818	24	had	have	VBD
18637	4818	25	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	4818	26	the	the	DT
18637	4818	27	country	country	NN
18637	4818	28	with	with	IN
18637	4818	29	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	4818	30	paralysis	paralysis	NN
18637	4818	31	and	and	CC
18637	4818	32	grave	grave	JJ
18637	4818	33	loss	loss	NN
18637	4818	34	and	and	CC
18637	4818	35	suffering	suffering	NN
18637	4818	36	.	.	.
18637	4819	1	To	to	IN
18637	4819	2	the	the	DT
18637	4819	3	familiar	familiar	JJ
18637	4819	4	argument	argument	NN
18637	4819	5	that	that	IN
18637	4819	6	"	"	``
18637	4819	7	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	4819	8	may	may	MD
18637	4819	9	not	not	RB
18637	4819	10	create	create	VB
18637	4819	11	power	power	NN
18637	4819	12	"	"	''
18637	4819	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4819	14	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	4819	15	parte	parte	NN
18637	4819	16	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
18637	4819	17	,	,	,
18637	4819	18	4	4	CD
18637	4819	19	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	4819	20	.	.	.
18637	4820	1	2	2	CD
18637	4820	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4820	3	1806	1806	CD
18637	4820	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4820	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4820	6	,	,	,
18637	4820	7	the	the	DT
18637	4820	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	4820	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4820	10	answered	answer	VBD
18637	4820	11	that	that	IN
18637	4820	12	"	"	``
18637	4820	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4820	14	may	may	MD
18637	4820	15	afford	afford	VB
18637	4820	16	a	a	DT
18637	4820	17	reason	reason	NN
18637	4820	18	for	for	IN
18637	4820	19	exerting	exert	VBG
18637	4820	20	a	a	DT
18637	4820	21	power	power	NN
18637	4820	22	already	already	RB
18637	4820	23	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
18637	4820	24	.	.	.
18637	4820	25	"	"	''
18637	4821	1	A	a	DT
18637	4821	2	further	further	JJ
18637	4821	3	answer	answer	NN
18637	4821	4	to	to	IN
18637	4821	5	objections	objection	NNS
18637	4821	6	based	base	VBN
18637	4821	7	on	on	IN
18637	4821	8	the	the	DT
18637	4821	9	rights	right	NNS
18637	4821	10	of	of	IN
18637	4821	11	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	4821	12	under	under	IN
18637	4821	13	the	the	DT
18637	4821	14	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	4821	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	4821	16	,	,	,
18637	4821	17	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	4821	18	the	the	DT
18637	4821	19	right	right	NN
18637	4821	20	of	of	IN
18637	4821	21	"	"	``
18637	4821	22	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	4821	23	of	of	IN
18637	4821	24	contract	contract	NN
18637	4821	25	,	,	,
18637	4821	26	"	"	''
18637	4821	27	was	be	VBD
18637	4821	28	that	that	IN
18637	4821	29	the	the	DT
18637	4821	30	situation	situation	NN
18637	4821	31	met	meet	VBN
18637	4821	32	by	by	IN
18637	4821	33	the	the	DT
18637	4821	34	statute	statute	NN
18637	4821	35	had	have	VBD
18637	4821	36	arisen	arise	VBN
18637	4821	37	in	in	IN
18637	4821	38	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	4821	39	of	of	IN
18637	4821	40	a	a	DT
18637	4821	41	failure	failure	NN
18637	4821	42	to	to	TO
18637	4821	43	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	4821	44	these	these	DT
18637	4821	45	rights	right	NNS
18637	4821	46	--	--	:
18637	4821	47	a	a	DT
18637	4821	48	far	far	RB
18637	4821	49	from	from	IN
18637	4821	50	satisfactory	satisfactory	JJ
18637	4821	51	answer	answer	NN
18637	4821	52	,	,	,
18637	4821	53	as	as	IN
18637	4821	54	the	the	DT
18637	4821	55	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	4821	56	pointed	point	VBD
18637	4821	57	out	out	RP
18637	4821	58	,	,	,
18637	4821	59	since	since	IN
18637	4821	60	one	one	CD
18637	4821	61	element	element	NN
18637	4821	62	of	of	IN
18637	4821	63	a	a	DT
18637	4821	64	right	right	NN
18637	4821	65	is	be	VBZ
18637	4821	66	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	4821	67	of	of	IN
18637	4821	68	choice	choice	NN
18637	4821	69	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	4821	70	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4821	71	use	use	NN
18637	4821	72	or	or	CC
18637	4821	73	nonuse	nonuse	NN
18637	4821	74	.	.	.
18637	4822	1	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	4822	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4822	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4822	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4822	5	New	New	NNP
18637	4822	6	,	,	,
18637	4822	7	243	243	CD
18637	4822	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4822	9	332	332	CD
18637	4822	10	,	,	,
18637	4822	11	387	387	CD
18637	4822	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4822	13	1917	1917	CD
18637	4822	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4822	15	.	.	.
18637	4823	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4823	2	411	411	CD
18637	4823	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4823	4	48	48	CD
18637	4823	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4823	6	.	.	.
18637	4824	1	1283	1283	CD
18637	4824	2	.	.	.
18637	4825	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4825	2	412	412	CD
18637	4825	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4825	4	295	295	CD
18637	4825	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4825	6	330	330	CD
18637	4825	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4825	8	1935	1935	CD
18637	4825	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4825	10	.	.	.
18637	4826	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4826	2	413	413	CD
18637	4826	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4826	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4826	5	.	.	.
18637	4827	1	374	374	CD
18637	4827	2	.	.	.
18637	4828	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4828	2	414	414	CD
18637	4828	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4828	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4828	5	.	.	.
18637	4829	1	384	384	CD
18637	4829	2	.	.	.
18637	4830	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4830	2	415	415	CD
18637	4830	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4830	4	326	326	CD
18637	4830	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4830	6	446	446	CD
18637	4830	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4830	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	4830	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4830	10	.	.	.
18637	4831	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	4831	2	,	,	,
18637	4831	3	in	in	IN
18637	4831	4	a	a	DT
18637	4831	5	case	case	NN
18637	4831	6	decided	decide	VBN
18637	4831	7	in	in	IN
18637	4831	8	June	June	NNP
18637	4831	9	,	,	,
18637	4831	10	1948	1948	CD
18637	4831	11	,	,	,
18637	4831	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4831	13	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	4831	14	,	,	,
18637	4831	15	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	4831	16	for	for	IN
18637	4831	17	a	a	DT
18637	4831	18	majority	majority	NN
18637	4831	19	of	of	IN
18637	4831	20	the	the	DT
18637	4831	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4831	22	,	,	,
18637	4831	23	listed	list	VBD
18637	4831	24	the	the	DT
18637	4831	25	Alton	Alton	NNP
18637	4831	26	case	case	NN
18637	4831	27	as	as	IN
18637	4831	28	one	one	CD
18637	4831	29	"	"	``
18637	4831	30	foredoomed	foredoom	VBN
18637	4831	31	to	to	TO
18637	4831	32	reversal	reversal	VB
18637	4831	33	,	,	,
18637	4831	34	"	"	''
18637	4831	35	though	though	IN
18637	4831	36	the	the	DT
18637	4831	37	formal	formal	JJ
18637	4831	38	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	4831	39	has	have	VBZ
18637	4831	40	never	never	RB
18637	4831	41	taken	take	VBN
18637	4831	42	place	place	NN
18637	4831	43	.	.	.
18637	4832	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4832	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4832	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4832	4	Mandeville	Mandeville	NNP
18637	4832	5	Is	be	VBZ
18637	4832	6	.	.	.
18637	4833	1	Farms	Farms	NNP
18637	4833	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4833	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4833	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4833	5	American	American	NNP
18637	4833	6	C.S.	C.S.	NNP
18637	4834	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4834	2	,	,	,
18637	4834	3	334	334	CD
18637	4834	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4834	5	219	219	CD
18637	4834	6	,	,	,
18637	4834	7	230	230	CD
18637	4834	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4834	9	1948	1948	CD
18637	4834	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4834	11	.	.	.
18637	4835	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4835	2	416	416	CD
18637	4835	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4835	4	250	250	CD
18637	4835	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4835	6	199	199	CD
18637	4835	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4835	8	1919	1919	CD
18637	4835	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4835	10	.	.	.
18637	4836	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4836	2	417	417	CD
18637	4836	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4836	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4836	5	.	.	.
18637	4837	1	203	203	CD
18637	4837	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4837	3	204	204	CD
18637	4837	4	.	.	.
18637	4838	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4838	2	418	418	CD
18637	4838	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4838	4	26	26	CD
18637	4838	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4838	6	.	.	.
18637	4839	1	209	209	CD
18637	4839	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4839	3	1890	1890	CD
18637	4839	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4839	5	.	.	.
18637	4840	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4840	2	419	419	CD
18637	4840	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4840	4	156	156	CD
18637	4840	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4840	6	1	1	CD
18637	4840	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4840	8	1895	1895	CD
18637	4840	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4840	10	.	.	.
18637	4841	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4841	2	420	420	CD
18637	4841	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4841	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4841	5	.	.	.
18637	4842	1	13	13	CD
18637	4842	2	.	.	.
18637	4843	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4843	2	421	421	CD
18637	4843	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4843	4	156	156	CD
18637	4843	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4843	6	1	1	CD
18637	4843	7	,	,	,
18637	4843	8	13	13	CD
18637	4843	9	-	-	SYM
18637	4843	10	16	16	CD
18637	4843	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4843	12	1895	1895	CD
18637	4843	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4843	14	.	.	.
18637	4844	1	"	"	``
18637	4844	2	Slight	slight	JJ
18637	4844	3	reflection	reflection	NN
18637	4844	4	will	will	MD
18637	4844	5	show	show	VB
18637	4844	6	that	that	IN
18637	4844	7	if	if	IN
18637	4844	8	the	the	DT
18637	4844	9	national	national	JJ
18637	4844	10	power	power	NN
18637	4844	11	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	4844	12	to	to	IN
18637	4844	13	all	all	DT
18637	4844	14	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	4844	15	and	and	CC
18637	4844	16	combinations	combination	NNS
18637	4844	17	in	in	IN
18637	4844	18	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	4844	19	,	,	,
18637	4844	20	agriculture	agriculture	NN
18637	4844	21	,	,	,
18637	4844	22	mining	mining	NN
18637	4844	23	,	,	,
18637	4844	24	and	and	CC
18637	4844	25	other	other	JJ
18637	4844	26	productive	productive	JJ
18637	4844	27	industries	industry	NNS
18637	4844	28	,	,	,
18637	4844	29	whose	whose	WP$
18637	4844	30	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	4844	31	result	result	NN
18637	4844	32	may	may	MD
18637	4844	33	effect	effect	VB
18637	4844	34	external	external	JJ
18637	4844	35	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	4844	36	,	,	,
18637	4844	37	comparatively	comparatively	RB
18637	4844	38	little	little	JJ
18637	4844	39	of	of	IN
18637	4844	40	business	business	NN
18637	4844	41	operations	operation	NNS
18637	4844	42	and	and	CC
18637	4844	43	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	4844	44	would	would	MD
18637	4844	45	be	be	VB
18637	4844	46	left	leave	VBN
18637	4844	47	for	for	IN
18637	4844	48	State	State	NNP
18637	4844	49	control	control	NN
18637	4844	50	.	.	.
18637	4844	51	"	"	''
18637	4845	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4845	2	422	422	CD
18637	4845	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4845	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4845	5	.	.	.
18637	4846	1	17	17	CD
18637	4846	2	.	.	.
18637	4847	1	The	the	DT
18637	4847	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	4847	3	of	of	IN
18637	4847	4	the	the	DT
18637	4847	5	case	case	NN
18637	4847	6	simmered	simmer	VBD
18637	4847	7	down	down	RP
18637	4847	8	to	to	IN
18637	4847	9	the	the	DT
18637	4847	10	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	4847	11	that	that	IN
18637	4847	12	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4847	13	was	be	VBD
18637	4847	14	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	4847	15	only	only	RB
18637	4847	16	;	;	:
18637	4847	17	a	a	DT
18637	4847	18	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	4847	19	which	which	WDT
18637	4847	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4847	21	Harlan	Harlan	NNP
18637	4847	22	undertook	undertake	VBD
18637	4847	23	to	to	TO
18637	4847	24	refute	refute	VB
18637	4847	25	in	in	IN
18637	4847	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4847	27	notable	notable	JJ
18637	4847	28	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	4847	29	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	4847	30	:	:	:
18637	4847	31	"	"	``
18637	4847	32	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	4847	33	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4847	34	does	do	VBZ
18637	4847	35	not	not	RB
18637	4847	36	,	,	,
18637	4847	37	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	4847	38	,	,	,
18637	4847	39	consist	consist	VBP
18637	4847	40	in	in	IN
18637	4847	41	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	4847	42	simply	simply	RB
18637	4847	43	.	.	.
18637	4848	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4848	2	includes	include	VBZ
18637	4848	3	the	the	DT
18637	4848	4	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	4848	5	and	and	CC
18637	4848	6	sale	sale	NN
18637	4848	7	of	of	IN
18637	4848	8	articles	article	NNS
18637	4848	9	that	that	WDT
18637	4848	10	are	be	VBP
18637	4848	11	intended	intend	VBN
18637	4848	12	to	to	TO
18637	4848	13	be	be	VB
18637	4848	14	transported	transport	VBN
18637	4848	15	from	from	IN
18637	4848	16	one	one	CD
18637	4848	17	State	state	NN
18637	4848	18	to	to	IN
18637	4848	19	another	another	DT
18637	4848	20	--	--	:
18637	4848	21	every	every	DT
18637	4848	22	species	species	NN
18637	4848	23	of	of	IN
18637	4848	24	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	4848	25	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	4848	26	among	among	IN
18637	4848	27	the	the	DT
18637	4848	28	States	States	NNP
18637	4848	29	and	and	CC
18637	4848	30	with	with	IN
18637	4848	31	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	4848	32	nations	nation	NNS
18637	4848	33	.	.	.
18637	4848	34	"	"	''
18637	4849	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4849	2	p.	p.	NN
18637	4849	3	22	22	CD
18637	4849	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4849	5	.	.	.
18637	4850	1	"	"	``
18637	4850	2	Any	any	DT
18637	4850	3	combination	combination	NN
18637	4850	4	,	,	,
18637	4850	5	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	4850	6	,	,	,
18637	4850	7	that	that	IN
18637	4850	8	disturbs	disturb	NNS
18637	4850	9	or	or	CC
18637	4850	10	unreasonably	unreasonably	RB
18637	4850	11	obstructs	obstruct	VBZ
18637	4850	12	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	4850	13	in	in	IN
18637	4850	14	buying	buy	VBG
18637	4850	15	and	and	CC
18637	4850	16	selling	sell	VBG
18637	4850	17	articles	article	NNS
18637	4850	18	manufactured	manufacture	VBN
18637	4850	19	to	to	TO
18637	4850	20	be	be	VB
18637	4850	21	sold	sell	VBN
18637	4850	22	to	to	IN
18637	4850	23	persons	person	NNS
18637	4850	24	in	in	IN
18637	4850	25	other	other	JJ
18637	4850	26	States	States	NNPS
18637	4850	27	or	or	CC
18637	4850	28	to	to	TO
18637	4850	29	be	be	VB
18637	4850	30	carried	carry	VBN
18637	4850	31	to	to	IN
18637	4850	32	other	other	JJ
18637	4850	33	States	States	NNPS
18637	4850	34	--	--	:
18637	4850	35	a	a	DT
18637	4850	36	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	4850	37	that	that	WDT
18637	4850	38	can	can	MD
18637	4850	39	not	not	RB
18637	4850	40	exist	exist	VB
18637	4850	41	if	if	IN
18637	4850	42	the	the	DT
18637	4850	43	right	right	NN
18637	4850	44	to	to	TO
18637	4850	45	buy	buy	VB
18637	4850	46	and	and	CC
18637	4850	47	sell	sell	VB
18637	4850	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	4850	49	fettered	fetter	VBN
18637	4850	50	by	by	IN
18637	4850	51	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	4850	52	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	4850	53	that	that	WDT
18637	4850	54	crush	crush	VBP
18637	4850	55	out	out	RP
18637	4850	56	competition	competition	NN
18637	4850	57	--	--	:
18637	4850	58	affects	affect	NNS
18637	4850	59	,	,	,
18637	4850	60	not	not	RB
18637	4850	61	incidentally	incidentally	RB
18637	4850	62	,	,	,
18637	4850	63	but	but	CC
18637	4850	64	directly	directly	RB
18637	4850	65	,	,	,
18637	4850	66	the	the	DT
18637	4850	67	people	people	NNS
18637	4850	68	of	of	IN
18637	4850	69	all	all	PDT
18637	4850	70	the	the	DT
18637	4850	71	States	States	NNPS
18637	4850	72	;	;	:
18637	4850	73	and	and	CC
18637	4850	74	the	the	DT
18637	4850	75	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	4850	76	for	for	IN
18637	4850	77	such	such	PDT
18637	4850	78	an	an	DT
18637	4850	79	evil	evil	NN
18637	4850	80	is	be	VBZ
18637	4850	81	found	find	VBN
18637	4850	82	only	only	RB
18637	4850	83	in	in	IN
18637	4850	84	the	the	DT
18637	4850	85	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	4850	86	of	of	IN
18637	4850	87	powers	power	NNS
18637	4850	88	confided	confide	VBD
18637	4850	89	to	to	IN
18637	4850	90	a	a	DT
18637	4850	91	government	government	NN
18637	4850	92	which	which	WDT
18637	4850	93	,	,	,
18637	4850	94	this	this	DT
18637	4850	95	court	court	NN
18637	4850	96	has	have	VBZ
18637	4850	97	said	say	VBN
18637	4850	98	,	,	,
18637	4850	99	was	be	VBD
18637	4850	100	the	the	DT
18637	4850	101	government	government	NN
18637	4850	102	of	of	IN
18637	4850	103	all	all	DT
18637	4850	104	,	,	,
18637	4850	105	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	4850	106	powers	power	NNS
18637	4850	107	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	4850	108	by	by	IN
18637	4850	109	all	all	DT
18637	4850	110	,	,	,
18637	4850	111	representing	represent	VBG
18637	4850	112	all	all	DT
18637	4850	113	,	,	,
18637	4850	114	acting	act	VBG
18637	4850	115	for	for	IN
18637	4850	116	all	all	DT
18637	4850	117	.	.	.
18637	4851	1	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	4851	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4851	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4851	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4851	5	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	4851	6	,	,	,
18637	4851	7	4	4	CD
18637	4851	8	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4851	9	.	.	.
18637	4852	1	316	316	CD
18637	4852	2	,	,	,
18637	4852	3	405	405	CD
18637	4852	4	.	.	.
18637	4852	5	"	"	''
18637	4853	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4853	2	p.	p.	NN
18637	4853	3	33	33	CD
18637	4853	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4853	5	.	.	.
18637	4854	1	"	"	``
18637	4854	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4854	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	4854	4	said	say	VBN
18637	4854	5	that	that	IN
18637	4854	6	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	4854	7	precedes	precede	NNS
18637	4854	8	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4854	9	and	and	CC
18637	4854	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	4854	11	not	not	RB
18637	4854	12	a	a	DT
18637	4854	13	part	part	NN
18637	4854	14	of	of	IN
18637	4854	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4854	16	.	.	.
18637	4855	1	But	but	CC
18637	4855	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4855	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	4855	4	equally	equally	RB
18637	4855	5	true	true	JJ
18637	4855	6	that	that	IN
18637	4855	7	when	when	WRB
18637	4855	8	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	4855	9	ends	end	VBZ
18637	4855	10	,	,	,
18637	4855	11	that	that	IN
18637	4855	12	which	which	WDT
18637	4855	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	4855	14	been	be	VBN
18637	4855	15	manufactured	manufacture	VBN
18637	4855	16	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	4855	17	a	a	DT
18637	4855	18	subject	subject	NN
18637	4855	19	of	of	IN
18637	4855	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4855	21	;	;	:
18637	4855	22	that	that	IN
18637	4855	23	buying	buy	VBG
18637	4855	24	and	and	CC
18637	4855	25	selling	selling	NN
18637	4855	26	succeed	succeed	NN
18637	4855	27	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	4855	28	,	,	,
18637	4855	29	come	come	VB
18637	4855	30	into	into	IN
18637	4855	31	existence	existence	NN
18637	4855	32	after	after	IN
18637	4855	33	the	the	DT
18637	4855	34	process	process	NN
18637	4855	35	of	of	IN
18637	4855	36	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	4855	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	4855	38	completed	complete	VBN
18637	4855	39	,	,	,
18637	4855	40	precede	precede	NN
18637	4855	41	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	4855	42	,	,	,
18637	4855	43	and	and	CC
18637	4855	44	are	be	VBP
18637	4855	45	as	as	RB
18637	4855	46	much	much	JJ
18637	4855	47	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	4855	48	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	4855	49	,	,	,
18637	4855	50	where	where	WRB
18637	4855	51	articles	article	NNS
18637	4855	52	are	be	VBP
18637	4855	53	bought	buy	VBN
18637	4855	54	_	_	NNP
18637	4855	55	to	to	TO
18637	4855	56	be	be	VB
18637	4855	57	_	_	NNP
18637	4855	58	carried	carry	VBN
18637	4855	59	from	from	IN
18637	4855	60	one	one	CD
18637	4855	61	State	state	NN
18637	4855	62	to	to	IN
18637	4855	63	another	another	DT
18637	4855	64	,	,	,
18637	4855	65	as	as	IN
18637	4855	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	4855	67	the	the	DT
18637	4855	68	manual	manual	JJ
18637	4855	69	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	4855	70	of	of	IN
18637	4855	71	such	such	JJ
18637	4855	72	articles	article	NNS
18637	4855	73	after	after	IN
18637	4855	74	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4855	75	have	have	VBP
18637	4855	76	been	be	VBN
18637	4855	77	so	so	RB
18637	4855	78	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	4855	79	.	.	.
18637	4856	1	The	the	DT
18637	4856	2	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	4856	3	was	be	VBD
18637	4856	4	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	4856	5	by	by	IN
18637	4856	6	this	this	DT
18637	4856	7	court	court	NN
18637	4856	8	in	in	IN
18637	4856	9	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	4856	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4856	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	4856	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4856	13	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	4856	14	,	,	,
18637	4856	15	where	where	WRB
18637	4856	16	the	the	DT
18637	4856	17	principal	principal	JJ
18637	4856	18	question	question	NN
18637	4856	19	was	be	VBD
18637	4856	20	whether	whether	IN
18637	4856	21	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4856	22	included	include	VBD
18637	4856	23	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	4856	24	.	.	.
18637	4857	1	Both	both	DT
18637	4857	2	the	the	DT
18637	4857	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4857	4	and	and	CC
18637	4857	5	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	4857	6	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	4857	7	buying	buying	NN
18637	4857	8	and	and	CC
18637	4857	9	selling	selling	NN
18637	4857	10	or	or	CC
18637	4857	11	barter	barter	NN
18637	4857	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4857	13	as	as	IN
18637	4857	14	included	include	VBN
18637	4857	15	in	in	IN
18637	4857	16	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	4857	17	_	_	NNP
18637	4857	18	.	.	.
18637	4858	1	*	*	NFP
18637	4858	2	*	*	NFP
18637	4858	3	*	*	NFP
18637	4858	4	The	the	DT
18637	4858	5	power	power	NN
18637	4858	6	of	of	IN
18637	4858	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4858	8	covers	cover	VBZ
18637	4858	9	and	and	CC
18637	4858	10	protects	protect	VBZ
18637	4858	11	the	the	DT
18637	4858	12	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	4858	13	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	4858	14	of	of	IN
18637	4858	15	such	such	JJ
18637	4858	16	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	4858	17	and	and	CC
18637	4858	18	trade	trade	NN
18637	4858	19	among	among	IN
18637	4858	20	the	the	DT
18637	4858	21	States	States	NNPS
18637	4858	22	as	as	IN
18637	4858	23	may	may	MD
18637	4858	24	or	or	CC
18637	4858	25	must	must	MD
18637	4858	26	succeed	succeed	VB
18637	4858	27	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	4858	28	and	and	CC
18637	4858	29	precede	precede	VB
18637	4858	30	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	4858	31	from	from	IN
18637	4858	32	the	the	DT
18637	4858	33	place	place	NN
18637	4858	34	of	of	IN
18637	4858	35	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	4858	36	.	.	.
18637	4858	37	"	"	''
18637	4859	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4859	2	p.	p.	NN
18637	4859	3	35	35	CD
18637	4859	4	-	-	SYM
18637	4859	5	36	36	CD
18637	4859	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4859	7	.	.	.
18637	4860	1	"	"	``
18637	4860	2	When	when	WRB
18637	4860	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4860	4	speak	speak	VBP
18637	4860	5	of	of	IN
18637	4860	6	trade	trade	NN
18637	4860	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4860	8	mean	mean	VBP
18637	4860	9	the	the	DT
18637	4860	10	buying	buying	NN
18637	4860	11	and	and	CC
18637	4860	12	selling	selling	NN
18637	4860	13	of	of	IN
18637	4860	14	articles	article	NNS
18637	4860	15	of	of	IN
18637	4860	16	every	every	DT
18637	4860	17	kind	kind	NN
18637	4860	18	that	that	WDT
18637	4860	19	are	be	VBP
18637	4860	20	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	4860	21	articles	article	NNS
18637	4860	22	of	of	IN
18637	4860	23	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4860	24	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4860	25	.	.	.
18637	4861	1	Whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	4861	2	improperly	improperly	RB
18637	4861	3	obstructs	obstruct	VBZ
18637	4861	4	the	the	DT
18637	4861	5	free	free	JJ
18637	4861	6	course	course	NN
18637	4861	7	of	of	IN
18637	4861	8	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4861	9	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	4861	10	and	and	CC
18637	4861	11	trade	trade	NN
18637	4861	12	,	,	,
18637	4861	13	as	as	IN
18637	4861	14	involved	involve	VBN
18637	4861	15	in	in	IN
18637	4861	16	the	the	DT
18637	4861	17	buying	buying	NN
18637	4861	18	and	and	CC
18637	4861	19	selling	selling	NN
18637	4861	20	of	of	IN
18637	4861	21	articles	article	NNS
18637	4861	22	to	to	TO
18637	4861	23	be	be	VB
18637	4861	24	carried	carry	VBN
18637	4861	25	from	from	IN
18637	4861	26	one	one	CD
18637	4861	27	State	state	NN
18637	4861	28	to	to	IN
18637	4861	29	another	another	DT
18637	4861	30	,	,	,
18637	4861	31	may	may	MD
18637	4861	32	be	be	VB
18637	4861	33	reached	reach	VBN
18637	4861	34	by	by	IN
18637	4861	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4861	36	,	,	,
18637	4861	37	under	under	IN
18637	4861	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4861	39	authority	authority	NN
18637	4861	40	to	to	TO
18637	4861	41	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	4861	42	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4861	43	among	among	IN
18637	4861	44	the	the	DT
18637	4861	45	States	States	NNP
18637	4861	46	.	.	.
18637	4861	47	"	"	''
18637	4862	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4862	2	p.	p.	NN
18637	4862	3	37	37	CD
18637	4862	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4862	5	.	.	.
18637	4863	1	"	"	``
18637	4863	2	If	if	IN
18637	4863	3	the	the	DT
18637	4863	4	national	national	JJ
18637	4863	5	power	power	NN
18637	4863	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	4863	7	competent	competent	JJ
18637	4863	8	to	to	IN
18637	4863	9	repress	repress	NN
18637	4863	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4863	11	State	State	NNP
18637	4863	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4863	13	action	action	NN
18637	4863	14	in	in	IN
18637	4863	15	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	4863	16	of	of	IN
18637	4863	17	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4863	18	trade	trade	NN
18637	4863	19	as	as	IN
18637	4863	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4863	21	may	may	MD
18637	4863	22	be	be	VB
18637	4863	23	involved	involve	VBN
18637	4863	24	in	in	IN
18637	4863	25	purchases	purchase	NNS
18637	4863	26	of	of	IN
18637	4863	27	refined	refined	JJ
18637	4863	28	sugar	sugar	NN
18637	4863	29	to	to	TO
18637	4863	30	be	be	VB
18637	4863	31	transported	transport	VBN
18637	4863	32	from	from	IN
18637	4863	33	one	one	CD
18637	4863	34	State	state	NN
18637	4863	35	to	to	IN
18637	4863	36	another	another	DT
18637	4863	37	State	state	NN
18637	4863	38	,	,	,
18637	4863	39	surely	surely	RB
18637	4863	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4863	41	ought	ought	MD
18637	4863	42	to	to	TO
18637	4863	43	be	be	VB
18637	4863	44	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	4863	45	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	4863	46	to	to	TO
18637	4863	47	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	4863	48	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	4863	49	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	4863	50	attempted	attempt	VBD
18637	4863	51	to	to	TO
18637	4863	52	be	be	VB
18637	4863	53	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	4863	54	by	by	IN
18637	4863	55	combinations	combination	NNS
18637	4863	56	of	of	IN
18637	4863	57	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	4863	58	or	or	CC
18637	4863	59	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	4863	60	upon	upon	IN
18637	4863	61	those	those	DT
18637	4863	62	identical	identical	JJ
18637	4863	63	purchases	purchase	NNS
18637	4863	64	;	;	,
18637	4863	65	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	4863	66	,	,	,
18637	4863	67	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	4863	68	combinations	combination	NNS
18637	4863	69	of	of	IN
18637	4863	70	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	4863	71	or	or	CC
18637	4863	72	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	4863	73	may	may	MD
18637	4863	74	--	--	:
18637	4863	75	so	so	RB
18637	4863	76	far	far	RB
18637	4863	77	as	as	IN
18637	4863	78	national	national	JJ
18637	4863	79	power	power	NN
18637	4863	80	and	and	CC
18637	4863	81	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4863	82	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4863	83	are	be	VBP
18637	4863	84	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	4863	85	--	--	:
18637	4863	86	do	do	VB
18637	4863	87	,	,	,
18637	4863	88	with	with	IN
18637	4863	89	impunity	impunity	NN
18637	4863	90	,	,	,
18637	4863	91	what	what	WP
18637	4863	92	no	no	DT
18637	4863	93	State	state	NN
18637	4863	94	can	can	MD
18637	4863	95	do	do	VB
18637	4863	96	.	.	.
18637	4863	97	"	"	''
18637	4864	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4864	2	p.	p.	NN
18637	4864	3	38	38	CD
18637	4864	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4864	5	.	.	.
18637	4865	1	"	"	``
18637	4865	2	Whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	4865	3	a	a	DT
18637	4865	4	State	state	NN
18637	4865	5	may	may	MD
18637	4865	6	do	do	VB
18637	4865	7	to	to	TO
18637	4865	8	protect	protect	VB
18637	4865	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4865	10	completely	completely	RB
18637	4865	11	interior	interior	JJ
18637	4865	12	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	4865	13	or	or	CC
18637	4865	14	trade	trade	NN
18637	4865	15	against	against	IN
18637	4865	16	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	4865	17	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	4865	18	,	,	,
18637	4865	19	the	the	DT
18637	4865	20	general	general	JJ
18637	4865	21	government	government	NN
18637	4865	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	4865	23	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	4865	24	to	to	TO
18637	4865	25	do	do	VB
18637	4865	26	for	for	IN
18637	4865	27	the	the	DT
18637	4865	28	protection	protection	NN
18637	4865	29	of	of	IN
18637	4865	30	the	the	DT
18637	4865	31	people	people	NNS
18637	4865	32	of	of	IN
18637	4865	33	all	all	PDT
18637	4865	34	the	the	DT
18637	4865	35	States	States	NNPS
18637	4865	36	--	--	:
18637	4865	37	for	for	IN
18637	4865	38	this	this	DT
18637	4865	39	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	4865	40	one	one	CD
18637	4865	41	people	people	NNS
18637	4865	42	--	--	:
18637	4865	43	against	against	IN
18637	4865	44	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	4865	45	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	4865	46	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	4865	47	upon	upon	IN
18637	4865	48	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4865	49	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	4865	50	or	or	CC
18637	4865	51	trade	trade	NN
18637	4865	52	in	in	IN
18637	4865	53	articles	article	NNS
18637	4865	54	that	that	WDT
18637	4865	55	are	be	VBP
18637	4865	56	to	to	TO
18637	4865	57	enter	enter	VB
18637	4865	58	into	into	IN
18637	4865	59	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4865	60	among	among	IN
18637	4865	61	the	the	DT
18637	4865	62	several	several	JJ
18637	4865	63	States	state	NNS
18637	4865	64	.	.	.
18637	4865	65	"	"	''
18637	4866	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4866	2	p.	p.	NN
18637	4866	3	42	42	CD
18637	4866	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4866	5	.	.	.
18637	4867	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4867	2	423	423	CD
18637	4867	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4867	4	175	175	CD
18637	4867	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4867	6	211	211	CD
18637	4867	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4867	8	1899	1899	CD
18637	4867	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4867	10	.	.	.
18637	4868	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4868	2	424	424	CD
18637	4868	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4868	4	196	196	CD
18637	4868	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4869	1	375.--The	375.--the	CD
18637	4869	2	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	4869	3	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4869	4	was	be	VBD
18637	4869	5	applied	apply	VBN
18637	4869	6	to	to	TO
18637	4869	7	break	break	VB
18637	4869	8	up	up	RP
18637	4869	9	combinations	combination	NNS
18637	4869	10	of	of	IN
18637	4869	11	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4869	12	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	4869	13	in	in	IN
18637	4869	14	United	United	NNP
18637	4869	15	States	States	NNP
18637	4869	16	_	_	NNP
18637	4869	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	4869	18	_	_	NNP
18637	4869	19	Trans	Trans	NNP
18637	4869	20	-	-	NNP
18637	4869	21	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	4869	22	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	4869	23	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	4869	24	.	.	.
18637	4869	25	,	,	,
18637	4869	26	166	166	CD
18637	4869	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4869	28	290	290	CD
18637	4869	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4869	30	1897	1897	CD
18637	4869	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4869	32	;	;	:
18637	4869	33	United	United	NNP
18637	4869	34	States	States	NNP
18637	4869	35	_	_	NNP
18637	4869	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	4869	37	_	_	NNP
18637	4869	38	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	4869	39	-	-	HYPH
18637	4869	40	Traffic	Traffic	NNP
18637	4869	41	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	4869	42	.	.	.
18637	4869	43	,	,	,
18637	4869	44	171	171	CD
18637	4869	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4869	46	505	505	CD
18637	4869	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4869	48	1898	1898	CD
18637	4869	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4869	50	;	;	:
18637	4869	51	and	and	CC
18637	4869	52	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	4869	53	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	4869	54	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4869	55	_	_	NNP
18637	4869	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	4869	57	_	_	NNP
18637	4869	58	United	United	NNP
18637	4869	59	States	States	NNP
18637	4869	60	,	,	,
18637	4869	61	193	193	CD
18637	4869	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4869	63	197	197	CD
18637	4869	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4869	65	1904	1904	CD
18637	4869	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4869	67	.	.	.
18637	4870	1	In	in	IN
18637	4870	2	the	the	DT
18637	4870	3	first	first	JJ
18637	4870	4	of	of	IN
18637	4870	5	these	these	DT
18637	4870	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	4870	7	the	the	DT
18637	4870	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4870	9	was	be	VBD
18637	4870	10	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	4870	11	with	with	IN
18637	4870	12	the	the	DT
18637	4870	13	contention	contention	NN
18637	4870	14	that	that	IN
18637	4870	15	the	the	DT
18637	4870	16	act	act	NN
18637	4870	17	had	have	VBD
18637	4870	18	been	be	VBN
18637	4870	19	intended	intend	VBN
18637	4870	20	only	only	RB
18637	4870	21	for	for	IN
18637	4870	22	the	the	DT
18637	4870	23	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	4870	24	combinations	combination	NNS
18637	4870	25	,	,	,
18637	4870	26	and	and	CC
18637	4870	27	hence	hence	RB
18637	4870	28	was	be	VBD
18637	4870	29	not	not	RB
18637	4870	30	designed	design	VBN
18637	4870	31	to	to	TO
18637	4870	32	apply	apply	VB
18637	4870	33	to	to	IN
18637	4870	34	the	the	DT
18637	4870	35	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	4870	36	,	,	,
18637	4870	37	for	for	IN
18637	4870	38	whose	whose	WP$
18637	4870	39	governance	governance	NN
18637	4870	40	the	the	DT
18637	4870	41	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	4870	42	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	4870	43	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4870	44	had	have	VBD
18637	4870	45	been	be	VBN
18637	4870	46	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	4870	47	three	three	CD
18637	4870	48	years	year	NNS
18637	4870	49	prior	prior	RB
18637	4870	50	.	.	.
18637	4871	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4871	2	Peckham	Peckham	NNP
18637	4871	3	answered	answer	VBD
18637	4871	4	the	the	DT
18637	4871	5	argument	argument	NN
18637	4871	6	by	by	IN
18637	4871	7	saying	say	VBG
18637	4871	8	that	that	IN
18637	4871	9	"	"	``
18637	4871	10	to	to	TO
18637	4871	11	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	4871	12	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	4871	13	as	as	IN
18637	4871	14	to	to	IN
18637	4871	15	rates	rate	NNS
18637	4871	16	by	by	IN
18637	4871	17	competing	compete	VBG
18637	4871	18	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	4871	19	*	*	NFP
18637	4871	20	*	*	NFP
18637	4871	21	*	*	NFP
18637	4871	22	would	would	MD
18637	4871	23	leave	leave	VB
18637	4871	24	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4871	25	very	very	RB
18637	4871	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4871	27	little	little	JJ
18637	4871	28	for	for	IN
18637	4871	29	the	the	DT
18637	4871	30	act	act	NN
18637	4871	31	to	to	TO
18637	4871	32	take	take	VB
18637	4871	33	effect	effect	NN
18637	4871	34	upon	upon	IN
18637	4871	35	,	,	,
18637	4871	36	"	"	''
18637	4871	37	referring	refer	VBG
18637	4871	38	in	in	IN
18637	4871	39	this	this	DT
18637	4871	40	connection	connection	NN
18637	4871	41	to	to	IN
18637	4871	42	the	the	DT
18637	4871	43	decision	decision	NN
18637	4871	44	in	in	IN
18637	4871	45	the	the	DT
18637	4871	46	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	4871	47	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	4871	48	Case	Case	NNP
18637	4871	49	,	,	,
18637	4871	50	166	166	CD
18637	4871	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4871	52	at	at	IN
18637	4871	53	313	313	CD
18637	4871	54	.	.	.
18637	4872	1	Alluding	allude	VBG
18637	4872	2	in	in	IN
18637	4872	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4872	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	4872	5	for	for	IN
18637	4872	6	the	the	DT
18637	4872	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4872	8	in	in	IN
18637	4872	9	Mandeville	Mandeville	NNP
18637	4872	10	Island	Island	NNP
18637	4872	11	Farms	Farms	NNP
18637	4872	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4872	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	4872	14	_	_	NNP
18637	4872	15	American	American	NNP
18637	4872	16	C.S.	C.S.	NNP
18637	4873	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4873	2	,	,	,
18637	4873	3	334	334	CD
18637	4873	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4873	5	219	219	CD
18637	4873	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4873	7	1948	1948	CD
18637	4873	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4873	9	to	to	IN
18637	4873	10	the	the	DT
18637	4873	11	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	4873	12	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	4873	13	Case	Case	NNP
18637	4873	14	,	,	,
18637	4873	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4873	16	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	4873	17	said	say	VBD
18637	4873	18	:	:	:
18637	4873	19	"	"	``
18637	4873	20	Like	like	IN
18637	4873	21	this	this	DT
18637	4873	22	one	one	NN
18637	4873	23	,	,	,
18637	4873	24	that	that	DT
18637	4873	25	case	case	NN
18637	4873	26	involved	involve	VBD
18637	4873	27	the	the	DT
18637	4873	28	refining	refining	NN
18637	4873	29	and	and	CC
18637	4873	30	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4873	31	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	4873	32	of	of	IN
18637	4873	33	sugar	sugar	NN
18637	4873	34	.	.	.
18637	4874	1	But	but	CC
18637	4874	2	because	because	IN
18637	4874	3	the	the	DT
18637	4874	4	refining	refining	NN
18637	4874	5	was	be	VBD
18637	4874	6	done	do	VBN
18637	4874	7	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	4874	8	within	within	IN
18637	4874	9	a	a	DT
18637	4874	10	single	single	JJ
18637	4874	11	state	state	NN
18637	4874	12	,	,	,
18637	4874	13	the	the	DT
18637	4874	14	case	case	NN
18637	4874	15	was	be	VBD
18637	4874	16	held	hold	VBN
18637	4874	17	to	to	TO
18637	4874	18	be	be	VB
18637	4874	19	one	one	CD
18637	4874	20	involving	involve	VBG
18637	4874	21	'	'	``
18637	4874	22	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	4874	23	'	'	``
18637	4874	24	only	only	RB
18637	4874	25	'	'	''
18637	4874	26	production	production	NN
18637	4874	27	'	'	''
18637	4874	28	or	or	CC
18637	4874	29	'	'	''
18637	4874	30	manufacturing	manufacturing	NN
18637	4874	31	,	,	,
18637	4874	32	'	'	''
18637	4874	33	although	although	IN
18637	4874	34	the	the	DT
18637	4874	35	vast	vast	JJ
18637	4874	36	part	part	NN
18637	4874	37	of	of	IN
18637	4874	38	the	the	DT
18637	4874	39	sugar	sugar	NN
18637	4874	40	produced	produce	VBN
18637	4874	41	was	be	VBD
18637	4874	42	sold	sell	VBN
18637	4874	43	and	and	CC
18637	4874	44	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	4874	45	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4874	46	,	,	,
18637	4874	47	and	and	CC
18637	4874	48	this	this	DT
18637	4874	49	was	be	VBD
18637	4874	50	the	the	DT
18637	4874	51	main	main	JJ
18637	4874	52	end	end	NN
18637	4874	53	of	of	IN
18637	4874	54	the	the	DT
18637	4874	55	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	4874	56	.	.	.
18637	4875	1	The	the	DT
18637	4875	2	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4875	3	distributing	distributing	JJ
18637	4875	4	phase	phase	NN
18637	4875	5	,	,	,
18637	4875	6	however	however	RB
18637	4875	7	,	,	,
18637	4875	8	was	be	VBD
18637	4875	9	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	4875	10	as	as	IN
18637	4875	11	being	be	VBG
18637	4875	12	only	only	RB
18637	4875	13	'	'	''
18637	4875	14	incidentally	incidentally	RB
18637	4875	15	,	,	,
18637	4875	16	'	'	''
18637	4875	17	'	'	''
18637	4875	18	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	4875	19	,	,	,
18637	4875	20	'	'	''
18637	4875	21	or	or	CC
18637	4875	22	'	'	``
18637	4875	23	remotely	remotely	RB
18637	4875	24	'	'	''
18637	4875	25	involved	involve	VBN
18637	4875	26	;	;	:
18637	4875	27	and	and	CC
18637	4875	28	to	to	TO
18637	4875	29	be	be	VB
18637	4875	30	'	'	``
18637	4875	31	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	4875	32	,	,	,
18637	4875	33	'	'	''
18637	4875	34	'	'	''
18637	4875	35	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	4875	36	,	,	,
18637	4875	37	'	'	''
18637	4875	38	or	or	CC
18637	4875	39	'	'	``
18637	4875	40	remote	remote	JJ
18637	4875	41	'	'	''
18637	4875	42	was	be	VBD
18637	4875	43	to	to	TO
18637	4875	44	be	be	VB
18637	4875	45	,	,	,
18637	4875	46	under	under	IN
18637	4875	47	the	the	DT
18637	4875	48	prevailing	prevail	VBG
18637	4875	49	climate	climate	NN
18637	4875	50	,	,	,
18637	4875	51	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	4875	52	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4875	53	'	'	POS
18637	4875	54	power	power	NN
18637	4875	55	to	to	TO
18637	4875	56	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	4875	57	,	,	,
18637	4875	58	and	and	CC
18637	4875	59	hence	hence	RB
18637	4875	60	outside	outside	IN
18637	4875	61	the	the	DT
18637	4875	62	scope	scope	NN
18637	4875	63	of	of	IN
18637	4875	64	the	the	DT
18637	4875	65	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	4875	66	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4875	67	.	.	.
18637	4876	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4876	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4876	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4876	4	Wickard	Wickard	NNP
18637	4876	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4876	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4876	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4876	8	Filburn	Filburn	NNP
18637	4876	9	,	,	,
18637	4876	10	317	317	CD
18637	4876	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4876	12	at	at	IN
18637	4876	13	119	119	CD
18637	4876	14	et	et	NN
18637	4876	15	seq	seq	NN
18637	4876	16	.	.	.
18637	4877	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4877	2	1942	1942	CD
18637	4877	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4877	4	.	.	.
18637	4878	1	"	"	``
18637	4878	2	The	the	DT
18637	4878	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4878	4	Knight	Knight	NNP
18637	4878	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4878	6	decision	decision	NN
18637	4878	7	made	make	VBD
18637	4878	8	the	the	DT
18637	4878	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	4878	10	a	a	DT
18637	4878	11	dead	dead	JJ
18637	4878	12	letter	letter	NN
18637	4878	13	for	for	IN
18637	4878	14	more	more	JJR
18637	4878	15	than	than	IN
18637	4878	16	a	a	DT
18637	4878	17	decade	decade	NN
18637	4878	18	and	and	CC
18637	4878	19	,	,	,
18637	4878	20	had	have	VBD
18637	4878	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4878	22	full	full	JJ
18637	4878	23	force	force	NN
18637	4878	24	remained	remain	VBD
18637	4878	25	unmodified	unmodified	JJ
18637	4878	26	,	,	,
18637	4878	27	the	the	DT
18637	4878	28	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4878	29	today	today	NN
18637	4878	30	would	would	MD
18637	4878	31	be	be	VB
18637	4878	32	a	a	DT
18637	4878	33	weak	weak	JJ
18637	4878	34	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	4878	35	,	,	,
18637	4878	36	as	as	IN
18637	4878	37	would	would	MD
18637	4878	38	also	also	RB
18637	4878	39	the	the	DT
18637	4878	40	power	power	NN
18637	4878	41	of	of	IN
18637	4878	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4878	43	,	,	,
18637	4878	44	to	to	TO
18637	4878	45	reach	reach	VB
18637	4878	46	evils	evil	NNS
18637	4878	47	in	in	IN
18637	4878	48	all	all	PDT
18637	4878	49	the	the	DT
18637	4878	50	vast	vast	JJ
18637	4878	51	operations	operation	NNS
18637	4878	52	of	of	IN
18637	4878	53	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4878	54	gigantic	gigantic	JJ
18637	4878	55	national	national	JJ
18637	4878	56	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	4878	57	system	system	NN
18637	4878	58	antecedent	antecedent	NN
18637	4878	59	to	to	TO
18637	4878	60	interstate	interstate	VB
18637	4878	61	sale	sale	NN
18637	4878	62	and	and	CC
18637	4878	63	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	4878	64	of	of	IN
18637	4878	65	manufactured	manufacture	VBN
18637	4878	66	products	product	NNS
18637	4878	67	.	.	.
18637	4879	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	4879	2	,	,	,
18637	4879	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4879	4	and	and	CC
18637	4879	5	succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	4879	6	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	4879	7	,	,	,
18637	4879	8	embracing	embrace	VBG
18637	4879	9	the	the	DT
18637	4879	10	same	same	JJ
18637	4879	11	artificially	artificially	RB
18637	4879	12	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	4879	13	lines	line	NNS
18637	4879	14	,	,	,
18637	4879	15	produced	produce	VBD
18637	4879	16	a	a	DT
18637	4879	17	series	series	NN
18637	4879	18	of	of	IN
18637	4879	19	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	4879	20	for	for	IN
18637	4879	21	the	the	DT
18637	4879	22	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	4879	23	of	of	IN
18637	4879	24	national	national	JJ
18637	4879	25	power	power	NN
18637	4879	26	over	over	IN
18637	4879	27	industry	industry	NN
18637	4879	28	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	4879	29	on	on	IN
18637	4879	30	a	a	DT
18637	4879	31	national	national	JJ
18637	4879	32	scale	scale	NN
18637	4879	33	which	which	WDT
18637	4879	34	the	the	DT
18637	4879	35	evolving	evolve	VBG
18637	4879	36	nature	nature	NN
18637	4879	37	of	of	IN
18637	4879	38	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4879	39	industrialism	industrialism	NN
18637	4879	40	foredoomed	foredoom	VBN
18637	4879	41	to	to	TO
18637	4879	42	reversal	reversal	VB
18637	4879	43	.	.	.
18637	4879	44	"	"	''
18637	4880	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	4880	2	.	.	.
18637	4881	1	229	229	CD
18637	4881	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4881	3	230	230	CD
18637	4881	4	.	.	.
18637	4882	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4882	2	425	425	CD
18637	4882	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4882	4	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	4882	5	&	&	CC
18637	4882	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4882	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4882	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4882	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4882	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4882	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4882	12	,	,	,
18637	4882	13	196	196	CD
18637	4882	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4882	15	375	375	CD
18637	4882	16	,	,	,
18637	4882	17	396	396	CD
18637	4882	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4882	19	1905	1905	CD
18637	4882	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4882	21	.	.	.
18637	4883	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4883	2	426	426	CD
18637	4883	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4883	4	196	196	CD
18637	4883	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4883	6	at	at	IN
18637	4883	7	398	398	CD
18637	4883	8	-	-	SYM
18637	4883	9	399	399	CD
18637	4883	10	.	.	.
18637	4884	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4884	2	427	427	CD
18637	4884	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4884	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4884	5	.	.	.
18637	4885	1	399	399	CD
18637	4885	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4885	3	401	401	CD
18637	4885	4	.	.	.
18637	4886	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4886	2	428	428	CD
18637	4886	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4886	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4886	5	.	.	.
18637	4887	1	400	400	CD
18637	4887	2	.	.	.
18637	4888	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4888	2	429	429	CD
18637	4888	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4888	4	Loewe	Loewe	NNP
18637	4888	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4888	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4888	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4888	8	Lawlor	Lawlor	NNP
18637	4888	9	,	,	,
18637	4888	10	208	208	CD
18637	4888	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4888	12	274	274	CD
18637	4888	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4888	14	1908	1908	CD
18637	4888	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4888	16	;	;	:
18637	4888	17	Duplex	Duplex	NNP
18637	4888	18	Printing	Printing	NNP
18637	4888	19	Press	Press	NNP
18637	4888	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4888	21	_	_	NNP
18637	4888	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	4888	23	_	_	NNP
18637	4888	24	Deering	Deering	NNP
18637	4888	25	,	,	,
18637	4888	26	254	254	CD
18637	4888	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4888	28	443	443	CD
18637	4888	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4888	30	1921	1921	CD
18637	4888	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4888	32	;	;	:
18637	4888	33	Coronado	Coronado	NNP
18637	4888	34	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	4888	35	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4888	36	_	_	NNP
18637	4888	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	4888	38	_	_	NNP
18637	4888	39	United	United	NNP
18637	4888	40	Mine	Mine	NNP
18637	4888	41	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	4888	42	of	of	IN
18637	4888	43	America	America	NNP
18637	4888	44	,	,	,
18637	4888	45	268	268	CD
18637	4888	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4888	47	295	295	CD
18637	4888	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4888	49	1925	1925	CD
18637	4888	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4888	51	;	;	:
18637	4888	52	United	United	NNP
18637	4888	53	States	States	NNP
18637	4888	54	_	_	NNP
18637	4888	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	4888	56	_	_	NNP
18637	4888	57	Brime	Brime	NNP
18637	4888	58	,	,	,
18637	4888	59	272	272	CD
18637	4888	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4888	61	549	549	CD
18637	4888	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4888	63	1926	1926	CD
18637	4888	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4888	65	;	;	:
18637	4888	66	Bedford	Bedford	NNP
18637	4888	67	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4888	68	_	_	NNP
18637	4888	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	4888	70	_	_	NNP
18637	4888	71	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	4888	72	Cutters	Cutters	NNPS
18637	4888	73	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	4888	74	.	.	.
18637	4888	75	,	,	,
18637	4888	76	274	274	CD
18637	4888	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4888	78	37	37	CD
18637	4888	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4888	80	1927	1927	CD
18637	4888	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4888	82	;	;	:
18637	4888	83	Local	local	JJ
18637	4888	84	167	167	CD
18637	4888	85	_	_	NNP
18637	4888	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	4888	87	_	_	NNP
18637	4888	88	United	United	NNP
18637	4888	89	States	States	NNP
18637	4888	90	,	,	,
18637	4888	91	291	291	CD
18637	4888	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4888	93	293	293	CD
18637	4888	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4888	95	1934	1934	CD
18637	4888	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4888	97	;	;	:
18637	4888	98	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	4888	99	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	4888	100	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4888	101	_	_	NNP
18637	4888	102	v.	v.	IN
18637	4888	103	_	_	NNP
18637	4888	104	Union	Union	NNP
18637	4888	105	,	,	,
18637	4888	106	325	325	CD
18637	4888	107	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4888	108	797	797	CD
18637	4888	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4888	110	1945	1945	CD
18637	4888	111	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4888	112	.	.	.
18637	4889	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4889	2	430	430	CD
18637	4889	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4889	4	42	42	CD
18637	4889	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4889	6	.	.	.
18637	4890	1	159	159	CD
18637	4890	2	.	.	.
18637	4891	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4891	2	431	431	CD
18637	4891	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4891	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4891	5	.	.	.
18637	4892	1	998	998	CD
18637	4892	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4892	3	1922	1922	CD
18637	4892	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4892	5	.	.	.
18637	4893	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4893	2	432	432	CD
18637	4893	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4893	4	258	258	CD
18637	4893	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4893	6	495	495	CD
18637	4893	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4893	8	1922	1922	CD
18637	4893	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4893	10	.	.	.
18637	4894	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4894	2	433	433	CD
18637	4894	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4894	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4894	5	.	.	.
18637	4895	1	514	514	CD
18637	4895	2	.	.	.
18637	4896	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4896	2	434	434	CD
18637	4896	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4896	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4896	5	.	.	.
18637	4897	1	515	515	CD
18637	4897	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4897	3	516	516	CD
18637	4897	4	.	.	.
18637	4898	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4898	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4898	3	also	also	RB
18637	4898	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4898	5	Lemke	Lemke	NNP
18637	4898	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4898	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4898	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4898	9	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	4898	10	'	'	POS
18637	4898	11	Grain	Grain	NNP
18637	4898	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4898	13	,	,	,
18637	4898	14	258	258	CD
18637	4898	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4898	16	50	50	CD
18637	4898	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4898	18	1922	1922	CD
18637	4898	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4898	20	;	;	:
18637	4898	21	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	4898	22	_	_	NNP
18637	4898	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	4898	24	_	_	NNP
18637	4898	25	Blasius	Blasius	NNP
18637	4898	26	,	,	,
18637	4898	27	290	290	CD
18637	4898	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4898	29	1	1	CD
18637	4898	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4898	31	1933	1933	CD
18637	4898	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4898	33	.	.	.
18637	4899	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4899	2	435	435	CD
18637	4899	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4899	4	262	262	CD
18637	4899	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4899	6	1	1	CD
18637	4899	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4899	8	1923	1923	CD
18637	4899	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4899	10	.	.	.
18637	4900	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4900	2	436	436	CD
18637	4900	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4900	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4900	5	.	.	.
18637	4901	1	35	35	CD
18637	4901	2	.	.	.
18637	4902	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4902	2	437	437	CD
18637	4902	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4902	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4902	5	.	.	.
18637	4903	1	40	40	CD
18637	4903	2	.	.	.
18637	4904	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4904	2	438	438	CD
18637	4904	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4904	4	258	258	CD
18637	4904	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4904	6	at	at	IN
18637	4904	7	521	521	CD
18637	4904	8	;	;	:
18637	4904	9	262	262	CD
18637	4904	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4904	11	at	at	IN
18637	4904	12	37	37	CD
18637	4904	13	.	.	.
18637	4905	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4905	2	439	439	CD
18637	4905	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4905	4	48	48	CD
18637	4905	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4905	6	.	.	.
18637	4906	1	881	881	CD
18637	4906	2	.	.	.
18637	4907	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4907	2	440	440	CD
18637	4907	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4907	4	49	49	CD
18637	4907	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	4907	6	.	.	.
18637	4908	1	803	803	CD
18637	4908	2	.	.	.
18637	4909	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4909	2	441	441	CD
18637	4909	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4909	4	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	4909	5	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	4909	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4909	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4909	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4909	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4909	10	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	4909	11	.	.	NNP
18637	4909	12	,	,	,
18637	4909	13	303	303	CD
18637	4909	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4909	15	419	419	CD
18637	4909	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4909	17	1938	1938	CD
18637	4909	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4909	19	;	;	:
18637	4909	20	North	North	NNP
18637	4909	21	American	American	NNP
18637	4909	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4909	23	_	_	NNP
18637	4909	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	4909	25	_	_	NNP
18637	4909	26	S.E.C.	S.E.C.	NNP
18637	4909	27	,	,	,
18637	4909	28	327	327	CD
18637	4909	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4909	30	686	686	CD
18637	4909	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4909	32	1946	1946	CD
18637	4909	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4909	34	;	;	:
18637	4909	35	American	American	NNP
18637	4909	36	Power	Power	NNP
18637	4909	37	&	&	CC
18637	4909	38	Light	Light	NNP
18637	4909	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4909	40	_	_	NNP
18637	4909	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	4909	42	_	_	NNP
18637	4909	43	S.E.C.	S.E.C.	NNP
18637	4909	44	,	,	,
18637	4909	45	329	329	CD
18637	4909	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4909	47	90	90	CD
18637	4909	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4909	49	1946	1946	CD
18637	4909	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4909	51	.	.	.
18637	4910	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4910	2	442	442	CD
18637	4910	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4910	4	"	"	``
18637	4910	5	The	the	DT
18637	4910	6	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	4910	7	and	and	CC
18637	4910	8	Share	Share	NNP
18637	4910	9	system	system	NN
18637	4910	10	,	,	,
18637	4910	11	including	include	VBG
18637	4910	12	American	American	NNP
18637	4910	13	and	and	CC
18637	4910	14	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	4910	15	,	,	,
18637	4910	16	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	4910	17	an	an	DT
18637	4910	18	undeniable	undeniable	JJ
18637	4910	19	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4910	20	character	character	NN
18637	4910	21	which	which	WDT
18637	4910	22	makes	make	VBZ
18637	4910	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4910	24	properly	properly	RB
18637	4910	25	subject	subject	JJ
18637	4910	26	,	,	,
18637	4910	27	from	from	IN
18637	4910	28	the	the	DT
18637	4910	29	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	4910	30	standpoint	standpoint	NN
18637	4910	31	,	,	,
18637	4910	32	to	to	IN
18637	4910	33	the	the	DT
18637	4910	34	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	4910	35	of	of	IN
18637	4910	36	§	§	NNP
18637	4910	37	11	11	CD
18637	4910	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4910	39	b	b	NN
18637	4910	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4910	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4910	42	2	2	CD
18637	4910	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4910	44	.	.	.
18637	4911	1	This	this	DT
18637	4911	2	vast	vast	JJ
18637	4911	3	system	system	NN
18637	4911	4	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	4911	5	utility	utility	NN
18637	4911	6	properties	property	NNS
18637	4911	7	in	in	IN
18637	4911	8	no	no	DT
18637	4911	9	fewer	few	JJR
18637	4911	10	than	than	IN
18637	4911	11	32	32	CD
18637	4911	12	States	States	NNPS
18637	4911	13	,	,	,
18637	4911	14	from	from	IN
18637	4911	15	New	New	NNP
18637	4911	16	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	4911	17	to	to	IN
18637	4911	18	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	4911	19	and	and	CC
18637	4911	20	from	from	IN
18637	4911	21	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	4911	22	to	to	IN
18637	4911	23	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	4911	24	,	,	,
18637	4911	25	as	as	RB
18637	4911	26	well	well	RB
18637	4911	27	as	as	IN
18637	4911	28	in	in	IN
18637	4911	29	12	12	CD
18637	4911	30	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	4911	31	countries	country	NNS
18637	4911	32	.	.	.
18637	4912	1	Bond	bond	NN
18637	4912	2	and	and	CC
18637	4912	3	Share	Share	NNP
18637	4912	4	dominates	dominate	NNS
18637	4912	5	and	and	CC
18637	4912	6	controls	control	VBZ
18637	4912	7	this	this	DT
18637	4912	8	system	system	NN
18637	4912	9	from	from	IN
18637	4912	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4912	11	headquarters	headquarters	NN
18637	4912	12	in	in	IN
18637	4912	13	New	New	NNP
18637	4912	14	York	York	NNP
18637	4912	15	City	City	NNP
18637	4912	16	.	.	.
18637	4913	1	*	*	NFP
18637	4913	2	*	*	NFP
18637	4913	3	*	*	NFP
18637	4913	4	the	the	DT
18637	4913	5	proper	proper	JJ
18637	4913	6	control	control	NN
18637	4913	7	and	and	CC
18637	4913	8	functioning	functioning	NN
18637	4913	9	of	of	IN
18637	4913	10	such	such	PDT
18637	4913	11	an	an	DT
18637	4913	12	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	4913	13	multi	multi	JJ
18637	4913	14	-	-	JJ
18637	4913	15	state	state	JJ
18637	4913	16	network	network	NN
18637	4913	17	of	of	IN
18637	4913	18	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	4913	19	necessitates	necessitates	VBP
18637	4913	20	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	4913	21	and	and	CC
18637	4913	22	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	4913	23	use	use	NN
18637	4913	24	of	of	IN
18637	4913	25	the	the	DT
18637	4913	26	mails	mail	NNS
18637	4913	27	and	and	CC
18637	4913	28	the	the	DT
18637	4913	29	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	4913	30	of	of	IN
18637	4913	31	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4913	32	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4913	33	.	.	.
18637	4914	1	Only	only	RB
18637	4914	2	in	in	IN
18637	4914	3	that	that	DT
18637	4914	4	way	way	NN
18637	4914	5	can	can	MD
18637	4914	6	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	4914	7	and	and	CC
18637	4914	8	Share	share	VB
18637	4914	9	,	,	,
18637	4914	10	or	or	CC
18637	4914	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4914	12	subholding	subholde	VBG
18637	4914	13	companies	company	NNS
18637	4914	14	or	or	CC
18637	4914	15	service	service	NN
18637	4914	16	subsidiary	subsidiary	NN
18637	4914	17	,	,	,
18637	4914	18	market	market	NN
18637	4914	19	and	and	CC
18637	4914	20	distribute	distribute	VB
18637	4914	21	securities	security	NNS
18637	4914	22	,	,	,
18637	4914	23	control	control	NN
18637	4914	24	and	and	CC
18637	4914	25	influence	influence	VB
18637	4914	26	the	the	DT
18637	4914	27	various	various	JJ
18637	4914	28	operating	operating	NN
18637	4914	29	companies	company	NNS
18637	4914	30	,	,	,
18637	4914	31	negotiate	negotiate	VB
18637	4914	32	inter	inter	JJ
18637	4914	33	-	-	JJ
18637	4914	34	system	system	JJ
18637	4914	35	loans	loan	NNS
18637	4914	36	,	,	,
18637	4914	37	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	4914	38	or	or	CC
18637	4914	39	exchange	exchange	VB
18637	4914	40	property	property	NN
18637	4914	41	,	,	,
18637	4914	42	perform	perform	VB
18637	4914	43	service	service	NN
18637	4914	44	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	4914	45	,	,	,
18637	4914	46	or	or	CC
18637	4914	47	reap	reap	VB
18637	4914	48	the	the	DT
18637	4914	49	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	4914	50	of	of	IN
18637	4914	51	stock	stock	NN
18637	4914	52	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	4914	53	.	.	.
18637	4915	1	*	*	NFP
18637	4915	2	*	*	NFP
18637	4915	3	*	*	NFP
18637	4915	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	4915	5	,	,	,
18637	4915	6	many	many	JJ
18637	4915	7	of	of	IN
18637	4915	8	the	the	DT
18637	4915	9	operating	operate	VBG
18637	4915	10	companies	company	NNS
18637	4915	11	on	on	IN
18637	4915	12	the	the	DT
18637	4915	13	lower	low	JJR
18637	4915	14	echelon	echelon	JJ
18637	4915	15	sell	sell	NN
18637	4915	16	and	and	CC
18637	4915	17	transmit	transmit	VB
18637	4915	18	electric	electric	JJ
18637	4915	19	energy	energy	NN
18637	4915	20	or	or	CC
18637	4915	21	gas	gas	NN
18637	4915	22	in	in	IN
18637	4915	23	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4915	24	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4915	25	to	to	IN
18637	4915	26	an	an	DT
18637	4915	27	extent	extent	NN
18637	4915	28	that	that	WDT
18637	4915	29	can	can	MD
18637	4915	30	not	not	RB
18637	4915	31	be	be	VB
18637	4915	32	described	describe	VBN
18637	4915	33	as	as	IN
18637	4915	34	spasmodic	spasmodic	JJ
18637	4915	35	or	or	CC
18637	4915	36	insignificant	insignificant	JJ
18637	4915	37	.	.	.
18637	4916	1	*	*	NFP
18637	4916	2	*	*	NFP
18637	4916	3	*	*	NFP
18637	4916	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4916	5	,	,	,
18637	4916	6	of	of	IN
18637	4916	7	course	course	NN
18637	4916	8	,	,	,
18637	4916	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	4916	10	undoubted	undoubted	JJ
18637	4916	11	power	power	NN
18637	4916	12	under	under	IN
18637	4916	13	the	the	DT
18637	4916	14	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	4916	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	4916	16	to	to	TO
18637	4916	17	impose	impose	VB
18637	4916	18	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	4916	19	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	4916	20	and	and	CC
18637	4916	21	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	4916	22	on	on	IN
18637	4916	23	those	those	DT
18637	4916	24	who	who	WP
18637	4916	25	use	use	VBP
18637	4916	26	the	the	DT
18637	4916	27	channels	channel	NNS
18637	4916	28	of	of	IN
18637	4916	29	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4916	30	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4916	31	so	so	IN
18637	4916	32	that	that	IN
18637	4916	33	those	those	DT
18637	4916	34	channels	channel	NNS
18637	4916	35	will	will	MD
18637	4916	36	not	not	RB
18637	4916	37	be	be	VB
18637	4916	38	conduits	conduit	NNS
18637	4916	39	for	for	IN
18637	4916	40	promoting	promote	VBG
18637	4916	41	or	or	CC
18637	4916	42	perpetuating	perpetuate	VBG
18637	4916	43	economic	economic	JJ
18637	4916	44	evils	evil	NNS
18637	4916	45	.	.	.
18637	4917	1	*	*	NFP
18637	4917	2	*	*	NFP
18637	4917	3	*	*	NFP
18637	4917	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	4917	5	to	to	IN
18637	4917	6	the	the	DT
18637	4917	7	extent	extent	NN
18637	4917	8	that	that	IN
18637	4917	9	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	4917	10	business	business	NN
18637	4917	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	4917	12	transacted	transact	VBN
18637	4917	13	through	through	IN
18637	4917	14	such	such	JJ
18637	4917	15	channels	channel	NNS
18637	4917	16	,	,	,
18637	4917	17	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	4917	18	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4917	19	in	in	IN
18637	4917	20	more	more	JJR
18637	4917	21	States	States	NNP
18637	4917	22	than	than	IN
18637	4917	23	one	one	CD
18637	4917	24	,	,	,
18637	4917	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4917	26	may	may	MD
18637	4917	27	act	act	VB
18637	4917	28	directly	directly	RB
18637	4917	29	with	with	IN
18637	4917	30	respect	respect	NN
18637	4917	31	to	to	IN
18637	4917	32	that	that	DT
18637	4917	33	business	business	NN
18637	4917	34	to	to	TO
18637	4917	35	protect	protect	VB
18637	4917	36	what	what	WP
18637	4917	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4917	38	conceives	conceive	VBZ
18637	4917	39	to	to	TO
18637	4917	40	be	be	VB
18637	4917	41	the	the	DT
18637	4917	42	national	national	JJ
18637	4917	43	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	4917	44	.	.	.
18637	4918	1	*	*	NFP
18637	4918	2	*	*	NFP
18637	4918	3	*	*	NFP
18637	4918	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4918	5	may	may	MD
18637	4918	6	compel	compel	VB
18637	4918	7	changes	change	NNS
18637	4918	8	in	in	IN
18637	4918	9	the	the	DT
18637	4918	10	voting	voting	NN
18637	4918	11	rights	right	NNS
18637	4918	12	and	and	CC
18637	4918	13	other	other	JJ
18637	4918	14	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	4918	15	of	of	IN
18637	4918	16	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	4918	17	.	.	.
18637	4919	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4919	2	may	may	MD
18637	4919	3	order	order	VB
18637	4919	4	the	the	DT
18637	4919	5	divestment	divestment	NN
18637	4919	6	or	or	CC
18637	4919	7	rearrangement	rearrangement	NN
18637	4919	8	of	of	IN
18637	4919	9	properties	property	NNS
18637	4919	10	.	.	.
18637	4920	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4920	2	may	may	MD
18637	4920	3	order	order	VB
18637	4920	4	the	the	DT
18637	4920	5	reorganization	reorganization	NN
18637	4920	6	or	or	CC
18637	4920	7	dissolution	dissolution	NN
18637	4920	8	of	of	IN
18637	4920	9	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	4920	10	.	.	.
18637	4921	1	In	in	IN
18637	4921	2	short	short	JJ
18637	4921	3	,	,	,
18637	4921	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4921	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	4921	6	completely	completely	RB
18637	4921	7	uninhibited	uninhibited	JJ
18637	4921	8	by	by	IN
18637	4921	9	the	the	DT
18637	4921	10	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	4921	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	4921	12	in	in	IN
18637	4921	13	selecting	select	VBG
18637	4921	14	the	the	DT
18637	4921	15	means	mean	NNS
18637	4921	16	considered	consider	VBN
18637	4921	17	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	4921	18	for	for	IN
18637	4921	19	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	4921	20	about	about	RP
18637	4921	21	the	the	DT
18637	4921	22	desired	desire	VBN
18637	4921	23	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	4921	24	in	in	IN
18637	4921	25	the	the	DT
18637	4921	26	channels	channel	NNS
18637	4921	27	of	of	IN
18637	4921	28	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4921	29	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4921	30	.	.	.
18637	4922	1	Any	any	DT
18637	4922	2	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	4922	3	are	be	VBP
18637	4922	4	to	to	TO
18637	4922	5	be	be	VB
18637	4922	6	found	find	VBN
18637	4922	7	in	in	IN
18637	4922	8	other	other	JJ
18637	4922	9	sections	section	NNS
18637	4922	10	of	of	IN
18637	4922	11	the	the	DT
18637	4922	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	4922	13	.	.	.
18637	4923	1	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	4923	2	_	_	NNP
18637	4923	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	4923	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4923	5	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	4923	6	,	,	,
18637	4923	7	9	9	CD
18637	4923	8	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	4923	9	.	.	.
18637	4924	1	1	1	CD
18637	4924	2	,	,	,
18637	4924	3	196	196	CD
18637	4924	4	.	.	.
18637	4924	5	"	"	''
18637	4925	1	American	American	NNP
18637	4925	2	Power	Power	NNP
18637	4925	3	&	&	CC
18637	4925	4	Light	Light	NNP
18637	4925	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4925	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4925	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4925	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4925	9	S.E.C.	S.E.C.	NNP
18637	4925	10	,	,	,
18637	4925	11	329	329	CD
18637	4925	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4925	13	90	90	CD
18637	4925	14	,	,	,
18637	4925	15	98	98	CD
18637	4925	16	-	-	SYM
18637	4925	17	100	100	CD
18637	4925	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4925	19	1946	1946	CD
18637	4925	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4925	21	.	.	.
18637	4926	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4926	2	443	443	CD
18637	4926	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4926	4	Appalachian	Appalachian	NNP
18637	4926	5	Coals	Coals	NNP
18637	4926	6	,	,	,
18637	4926	7	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	4926	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4926	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4926	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4926	11	United	United	NNP
18637	4926	12	States	States	NNP
18637	4926	13	,	,	,
18637	4926	14	288	288	CD
18637	4926	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4926	16	344	344	CD
18637	4926	17	,	,	,
18637	4926	18	372	372	CD
18637	4926	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4926	20	1933	1933	CD
18637	4926	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4926	22	.	.	.
18637	4927	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4927	2	444	444	CD
18637	4927	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4927	4	48	48	CD
18637	4927	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4927	6	.	.	.
18637	4928	1	195	195	CD
18637	4928	2	.	.	.
18637	4929	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4929	2	445	445	CD
18637	4929	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4929	4	295	295	CD
18637	4929	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4929	6	495	495	CD
18637	4929	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4929	8	1935	1935	CD
18637	4929	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4929	10	.	.	.
18637	4930	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4930	2	446	446	CD
18637	4930	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4930	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4930	5	.	.	.
18637	4931	1	548	548	CD
18637	4931	2	.	.	.
18637	4932	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4932	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4932	3	also	also	RB
18637	4932	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4932	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4932	6	.	.	.
18637	4933	1	546	546	CD
18637	4933	2	.	.	.
18637	4934	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4934	2	447	447	CD
18637	4934	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4934	4	In	in	IN
18637	4934	5	United	United	NNP
18637	4934	6	States	States	NNP
18637	4934	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4934	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4934	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4934	10	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
18637	4934	11	,	,	,
18637	4934	12	332	332	CD
18637	4934	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4934	14	689	689	CD
18637	4934	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4934	16	1948	1948	CD
18637	4934	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4934	18	,	,	,
18637	4934	19	the	the	DT
18637	4934	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4934	21	interpreted	interpret	VBD
18637	4934	22	the	the	DT
18637	4934	23	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4934	24	Food	Food	NNP
18637	4934	25	,	,	,
18637	4934	26	Drug	Drug	NNP
18637	4934	27	,	,	,
18637	4934	28	and	and	CC
18637	4934	29	Cosmetics	Cosmetics	NNPS
18637	4934	30	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4934	31	of	of	IN
18637	4934	32	1938	1938	CD
18637	4934	33	as	as	IN
18637	4934	34	applying	apply	VBG
18637	4934	35	to	to	IN
18637	4934	36	the	the	DT
18637	4934	37	sale	sale	NN
18637	4934	38	by	by	IN
18637	4934	39	a	a	DT
18637	4934	40	retailer	retailer	NN
18637	4934	41	of	of	IN
18637	4934	42	drugs	drug	NNS
18637	4934	43	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	4934	44	from	from	IN
18637	4934	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4934	46	wholesaler	wholesaler	NN
18637	4934	47	within	within	IN
18637	4934	48	the	the	DT
18637	4934	49	State	State	NNP
18637	4934	50	nine	nine	CD
18637	4934	51	months	month	NNS
18637	4934	52	after	after	IN
18637	4934	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4934	54	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4934	55	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	4934	56	had	have	VBD
18637	4934	57	been	be	VBN
18637	4934	58	completed	complete	VBN
18637	4934	59	.	.	.
18637	4935	1	The	the	DT
18637	4935	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4935	3	,	,	,
18637	4935	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	4935	5	by	by	IN
18637	4935	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4935	7	Black	Black	NNP
18637	4935	8	,	,	,
18637	4935	9	cited	cite	VBD
18637	4935	10	United	United	NNP
18637	4935	11	States	States	NNP
18637	4935	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4935	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	4935	14	_	_	NNP
18637	4935	15	Walsh	Walsh	NNP
18637	4935	16	,	,	,
18637	4935	17	331	331	CD
18637	4935	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4935	19	432	432	CD
18637	4935	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4935	21	1947	1947	CD
18637	4935	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4935	23	;	;	:
18637	4935	24	Wickard	Wickard	NNP
18637	4935	25	_	_	NNP
18637	4935	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	4935	27	_	_	NNP
18637	4935	28	Filburn	Filburn	NNP
18637	4935	29	,	,	,
18637	4935	30	317	317	CD
18637	4935	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4935	32	111	111	CD
18637	4935	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4935	34	1942	1942	CD
18637	4935	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4935	36	;	;	:
18637	4935	37	United	United	NNP
18637	4935	38	States	States	NNP
18637	4935	39	_	_	NNP
18637	4935	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	4935	41	_	_	NNP
18637	4935	42	Wrightwood	Wrightwood	NNP
18637	4935	43	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
18637	4935	44	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4935	45	,	,	,
18637	4935	46	315	315	CD
18637	4935	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4935	48	110	110	CD
18637	4935	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4935	50	1942	1942	CD
18637	4935	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4935	52	;	;	:
18637	4935	53	United	United	NNP
18637	4935	54	States	States	NNP
18637	4935	55	_	_	NNP
18637	4935	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	4935	57	_	_	NNP
18637	4935	58	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	4935	59	,	,	,
18637	4935	60	312	312	CD
18637	4935	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4935	62	100	100	CD
18637	4935	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4935	64	1941	1941	CD
18637	4935	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4935	66	.	.	.
18637	4936	1	The	the	DT
18637	4936	2	last	last	JJ
18637	4936	3	three	three	CD
18637	4936	4	of	of	IN
18637	4936	5	these	these	DT
18637	4936	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	4936	7	are	be	VBP
18637	4936	8	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	4936	9	below	below	RB
18637	4936	10	.	.	.
18637	4937	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4937	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4937	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4937	4	pp	pp	NNP
18637	4937	5	.	.	.
18637	4938	1	155	155	CD
18637	4938	2	,	,	,
18637	4938	3	159	159	CD
18637	4938	4	.	.	.
18637	4939	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4939	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	4939	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	4939	4	on	on	IN
18637	4939	5	the	the	DT
18637	4939	6	basis	basis	NN
18637	4939	7	of	of	IN
18637	4939	8	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4939	9	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	4939	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	4939	11	_	_	NNP
18637	4939	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	4939	13	_	_	NNP
18637	4939	14	Bunte	Bunte	NNP
18637	4939	15	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	4939	16	,	,	,
18637	4939	17	312	312	CD
18637	4939	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4939	19	349	349	CD
18637	4939	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4939	21	1941	1941	CD
18637	4939	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4939	23	.	.	.
18637	4940	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4940	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	4940	3	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	4940	4	that	that	IN
18637	4940	5	the	the	DT
18637	4940	6	Schechter	Schechter	NNP
18637	4940	7	case	case	NN
18637	4940	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	4940	9	been	be	VBN
18637	4940	10	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
18637	4940	11	repudiated	repudiate	VBN
18637	4940	12	so	so	RB
18637	4940	13	far	far	RB
18637	4940	14	as	as	IN
18637	4940	15	the	the	DT
18637	4940	16	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	4940	17	"	"	``
18637	4940	18	direct	direct	JJ
18637	4940	19	"	"	''
18637	4940	20	and	and	CC
18637	4940	21	"	"	``
18637	4940	22	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	4940	23	"	"	''
18637	4940	24	effects	effect	NNS
18637	4940	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	4940	26	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	4940	27	.	.	.
18637	4941	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4941	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4941	3	also	also	RB
18637	4941	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4941	5	McDermott	McDermott	NNP
18637	4941	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4941	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4941	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4941	9	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	4941	10	,	,	,
18637	4941	11	228	228	CD
18637	4941	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4941	13	115	115	CD
18637	4941	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4941	15	1913	1913	CD
18637	4941	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4941	17	,	,	,
18637	4941	18	which	which	WDT
18637	4941	19	preceded	precede	VBD
18637	4941	20	the	the	DT
18637	4941	21	Schechter	Schechter	NNP
18637	4941	22	decision	decision	NN
18637	4941	23	by	by	IN
18637	4941	24	more	more	JJR
18637	4941	25	than	than	IN
18637	4941	26	two	two	CD
18637	4941	27	decades	decade	NNS
18637	4941	28	.	.	.
18637	4942	1	The	the	DT
18637	4942	2	N.I.R.A.	N.I.R.A.	NNP
18637	4942	3	,	,	,
18637	4942	4	however	however	RB
18637	4942	5	,	,	,
18637	4942	6	was	be	VBD
18637	4942	7	found	find	VBN
18637	4942	8	to	to	TO
18637	4942	9	have	have	VB
18637	4942	10	several	several	JJ
18637	4942	11	other	other	JJ
18637	4942	12	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	4942	13	infirmities	infirmity	NNS
18637	4942	14	besides	besides	IN
18637	4942	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4942	16	disregard	disregard	NN
18637	4942	17	,	,	,
18637	4942	18	as	as	IN
18637	4942	19	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
18637	4942	20	by	by	IN
18637	4942	21	the	the	DT
18637	4942	22	Live	Live	NNP
18637	4942	23	Poultry	Poultry	NNP
18637	4942	24	Code	Code	NNP
18637	4942	25	,	,	,
18637	4942	26	of	of	IN
18637	4942	27	the	the	DT
18637	4942	28	"	"	``
18637	4942	29	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	4942	30	"	"	''
18637	4942	31	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	4942	32	between	between	IN
18637	4942	33	"	"	``
18637	4942	34	direct	direct	JJ
18637	4942	35	"	"	''
18637	4942	36	and	and	CC
18637	4942	37	"	"	``
18637	4942	38	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	4942	39	"	"	''
18637	4942	40	effects	effect	NNS
18637	4942	41	,	,	,
18637	4942	42	namely	namely	RB
18637	4942	43	,	,	,
18637	4942	44	the	the	DT
18637	4942	45	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	4942	46	of	of	IN
18637	4942	47	uncanalized	uncanalized	JJ
18637	4942	48	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	4942	49	power	power	NN
18637	4942	50	;	;	:
18637	4942	51	the	the	DT
18637	4942	52	absence	absence	NN
18637	4942	53	of	of	IN
18637	4942	54	any	any	DT
18637	4942	55	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	4942	56	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	4942	57	safeguards	safeguard	NNS
18637	4942	58	;	;	:
18637	4942	59	the	the	DT
18637	4942	60	absence	absence	NN
18637	4942	61	of	of	IN
18637	4942	62	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	4942	63	review	review	NN
18637	4942	64	;	;	:
18637	4942	65	and	and	CC
18637	4942	66	the	the	DT
18637	4942	67	dominant	dominant	JJ
18637	4942	68	role	role	NN
18637	4942	69	played	play	VBN
18637	4942	70	by	by	IN
18637	4942	71	private	private	JJ
18637	4942	72	groups	group	NNS
18637	4942	73	in	in	IN
18637	4942	74	the	the	DT
18637	4942	75	general	general	JJ
18637	4942	76	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	4942	77	of	of	IN
18637	4942	78	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	4942	79	.	.	.
18637	4943	1	These	these	DT
18637	4943	2	objections	objection	NNS
18637	4943	3	are	be	VBP
18637	4943	4	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	4943	5	with	with	IN
18637	4943	6	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	4943	7	in	in	IN
18637	4943	8	this	this	DT
18637	4943	9	volume	volume	NN
18637	4943	10	.	.	.
18637	4944	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4944	2	Supra	Supra	NNP
18637	4944	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4944	4	,	,	,
18637	4944	5	pp	pp	NNP
18637	4944	6	.	.	.
18637	4945	1	75	75	CD
18637	4945	2	,	,	,
18637	4945	3	78	78	CD
18637	4945	4	,	,	,
18637	4945	5	80	80	CD
18637	4945	6	.	.	.
18637	4946	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4946	2	448	448	CD
18637	4946	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4946	4	48	48	CD
18637	4946	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	4946	6	31	31	CD
18637	4946	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4946	8	1933	1933	CD
18637	4946	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4946	10	.	.	.
18637	4947	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4947	2	449	449	CD
18637	4947	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4947	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4947	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4947	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4947	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4947	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4947	9	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	4947	10	,	,	,
18637	4947	11	297	297	CD
18637	4947	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4947	13	1	1	CD
18637	4947	14	,	,	,
18637	4947	15	63	63	CD
18637	4947	16	-	-	SYM
18637	4947	17	64	64	CD
18637	4947	18	,	,	,
18637	4947	19	68	68	CD
18637	4947	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4947	21	1936	1936	CD
18637	4947	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4947	23	.	.	.
18637	4948	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4948	2	450	450	CD
18637	4948	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4948	4	49	49	CD
18637	4948	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	4948	6	.	.	.
18637	4949	1	991	991	CD
18637	4949	2	.	.	.
18637	4950	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4950	2	451	451	CD
18637	4950	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4950	4	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	4950	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4950	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	4950	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4950	8	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	4950	9	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	4950	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4950	11	,	,	,
18637	4950	12	298	298	CD
18637	4950	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4950	14	238	238	CD
18637	4950	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4950	16	1936	1936	CD
18637	4950	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4950	18	.	.	.
18637	4951	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4951	2	452	452	CD
18637	4951	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4951	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4951	5	.	.	.
18637	4952	1	308	308	CD
18637	4952	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4952	3	309	309	CD
18637	4952	4	.	.	.
18637	4953	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4953	2	453	453	CD
18637	4953	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4953	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4953	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4953	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4953	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4953	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4953	9	E.C.	E.C.	NNP
18637	4954	1	Knight	Knight	NNP
18637	4954	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4954	3	,	,	,
18637	4954	4	156	156	CD
18637	4954	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4954	6	1	1	CD
18637	4954	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4954	8	1895	1895	CD
18637	4954	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4954	10	.	.	.
18637	4955	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4955	2	454	454	CD
18637	4955	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4955	4	301	301	CD
18637	4955	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4955	6	1	1	CD
18637	4955	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4955	8	1937	1937	CD
18637	4955	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4955	10	.	.	.
18637	4956	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4956	2	455	455	CD
18637	4956	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4956	4	49	49	CD
18637	4956	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	4956	6	.	.	.
18637	4957	1	449	449	CD
18637	4957	2	.	.	.
18637	4958	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4958	2	456	456	CD
18637	4958	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4958	4	301	301	CD
18637	4958	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4958	6	at	at	IN
18637	4958	7	38	38	CD
18637	4958	8	,	,	,
18637	4958	9	41	41	CD
18637	4958	10	-	-	SYM
18637	4958	11	42	42	CD
18637	4958	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4958	13	1937	1937	CD
18637	4958	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4958	15	.	.	.
18637	4959	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4959	2	457	457	CD
18637	4959	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4959	4	National	National	NNP
18637	4959	5	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	4959	6	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	4959	7	Board	Board	NNP
18637	4959	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4959	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4959	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4959	11	Fruehauf	Fruehauf	NNP
18637	4959	12	Trailer	Trailer	NNP
18637	4959	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4959	14	,	,	,
18637	4959	15	301	301	CD
18637	4959	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4959	17	49	49	CD
18637	4959	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4959	19	1937	1937	CD
18637	4959	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4959	21	;	;	:
18637	4959	22	National	National	NNP
18637	4959	23	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	4959	24	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	4959	25	Board	Board	NNP
18637	4959	26	_	_	NNP
18637	4959	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	4959	28	_	_	NNP
18637	4959	29	Friedman	Friedman	NNP
18637	4959	30	-	-	HYPH
18637	4959	31	Harry	Harry	NNP
18637	4959	32	Marks	Marks	NNP
18637	4959	33	Clothing	Clothing	NNP
18637	4959	34	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4959	35	,	,	,
18637	4959	36	301	301	CD
18637	4959	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4959	38	58	58	CD
18637	4959	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4959	40	1937	1937	CD
18637	4959	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4959	42	.	.	.
18637	4960	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4960	2	458	458	CD
18637	4960	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4960	4	National	National	NNP
18637	4960	5	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	4960	6	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	4960	7	Board	Board	NNP
18637	4960	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4960	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	4960	10	_	_	NNP
18637	4960	11	Fainblatt	Fainblatt	NNP
18637	4960	12	,	,	,
18637	4960	13	306	306	CD
18637	4960	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4960	15	601	601	CD
18637	4960	16	,	,	,
18637	4960	17	606	606	CD
18637	4960	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4960	19	1939	1939	CD
18637	4960	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4960	21	.	.	.
18637	4961	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4961	2	459	459	CD
18637	4961	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4961	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4961	5	See	See	NNP
18637	4961	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4961	7	Santa	Santa	NNP
18637	4961	8	Cruz	Cruz	NNP
18637	4961	9	Fruit	Fruit	NNP
18637	4961	10	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	4961	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4961	12	_	_	NNP
18637	4961	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	4961	14	_	_	NNP
18637	4961	15	National	National	NNP
18637	4961	16	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	4961	17	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	4961	18	Board	Board	NNP
18637	4961	19	,	,	,
18637	4961	20	303	303	CD
18637	4961	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4961	22	453	453	CD
18637	4961	23	,	,	,
18637	4961	24	465	465	CD
18637	4961	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4961	26	1938	1938	CD
18637	4961	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4961	28	.	.	.
18637	4962	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4962	2	460	460	CD
18637	4962	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4962	4	52	52	CD
18637	4962	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4962	6	.	.	.
18637	4963	1	1060	1060	CD
18637	4963	2	.	.	.
18637	4964	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4964	2	461	461	CD
18637	4964	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4964	4	United	United	NNP
18637	4964	5	States	States	NNP
18637	4964	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4964	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	4964	8	_	_	NNP
18637	4964	9	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	4964	10	,	,	,
18637	4964	11	312	312	CD
18637	4964	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4964	13	100	100	CD
18637	4964	14	,	,	,
18637	4964	15	115	115	CD
18637	4964	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4964	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	4964	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4964	19	.	.	.
18637	4965	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4965	2	462	462	CD
18637	4965	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4965	4	_	_	NNP
18637	4965	5	See	See	NNP
18637	4965	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4965	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	4965	8	.	.	.
18637	4966	1	113	113	CD
18637	4966	2	,	,	,
18637	4966	3	114	114	CD
18637	4966	4	,	,	,
18637	4966	5	118	118	CD
18637	4966	6	.	.	.
18637	4967	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4967	2	463	463	CD
18637	4967	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4967	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4967	5	.	.	.
18637	4968	1	123	123	CD
18637	4968	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4968	3	124	124	CD
18637	4968	4	.	.	.
18637	4969	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4969	2	464	464	CD
18637	4969	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4969	4	Owen	Owen	NNP
18637	4969	5	J.	J.	NNP
18637	4969	6	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	4969	7	,	,	,
18637	4969	8	The	the	DT
18637	4969	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4969	10	and	and	CC
18637	4969	11	the	the	DT
18637	4969	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	4969	13	,	,	,
18637	4969	14	The	the	DT
18637	4969	15	Oliver	Oliver	NNP
18637	4969	16	Wendell	Wendell	NNP
18637	4969	17	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	4969	18	Lectures	Lectures	NNP
18637	4969	19	1951	1951	CD
18637	4969	20	,	,	,
18637	4969	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4969	22	Harvard	Harvard	NNP
18637	4969	23	University	University	NNP
18637	4969	24	Press	Press	NNP
18637	4969	25	1951	1951	CD
18637	4969	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4969	27	,	,	,
18637	4969	28	56	56	CD
18637	4969	29	.	.	.
18637	4970	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4970	2	465	465	CD
18637	4970	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4970	4	The	the	DT
18637	4970	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4970	6	provided	provide	VBN
18637	4970	7	originally	originally	RB
18637	4970	8	that	that	IN
18637	4970	9	"	"	``
18637	4970	10	for	for	IN
18637	4970	11	the	the	DT
18637	4970	12	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	4970	13	of	of	IN
18637	4970	14	this	this	DT
18637	4970	15	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4970	16	an	an	DT
18637	4970	17	employee	employee	NN
18637	4970	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	4970	19	be	be	VB
18637	4970	20	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	4970	21	to	to	TO
18637	4970	22	have	have	VB
18637	4970	23	been	be	VBN
18637	4970	24	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4970	25	in	in	IN
18637	4970	26	the	the	DT
18637	4970	27	production	production	NN
18637	4970	28	of	of	IN
18637	4970	29	goods	good	NNS
18637	4970	30	if	if	IN
18637	4970	31	such	such	JJ
18637	4970	32	employee	employee	NN
18637	4970	33	was	be	VBD
18637	4970	34	employed	employ	VBN
18637	4970	35	*	*	NFP
18637	4970	36	*	*	NFP
18637	4970	37	*	*	NFP
18637	4970	38	in	in	IN
18637	4970	39	any	any	DT
18637	4970	40	process	process	NN
18637	4970	41	or	or	CC
18637	4970	42	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	4970	43	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	4970	44	to	to	IN
18637	4970	45	the	the	DT
18637	4970	46	production	production	NN
18637	4970	47	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	4970	48	,	,	,
18637	4970	49	in	in	IN
18637	4970	50	any	any	DT
18637	4970	51	State	State	NNP
18637	4970	52	.	.	.
18637	4970	53	"	"	''
18637	4971	1	By	by	IN
18637	4971	2	63	63	CD
18637	4971	3	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4971	4	.	.	.
18637	4972	1	910	910	CD
18637	4972	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4972	3	1949	1949	CD
18637	4972	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4972	5	,	,	,
18637	4972	6	"	"	``
18637	4972	7	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	4972	8	to	to	IN
18637	4972	9	the	the	DT
18637	4972	10	production	production	NN
18637	4972	11	thereof	thereof	IN
18637	4972	12	"	"	``
18637	4972	13	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	4972	14	"	"	``
18637	4972	15	directly	directly	RB
18637	4972	16	essential	essential	JJ
18637	4972	17	to	to	IN
18637	4972	18	the	the	DT
18637	4972	19	production	production	NN
18637	4972	20	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	4972	21	.	.	.
18637	4972	22	"	"	''
18637	4973	1	The	the	DT
18637	4973	2	effect	effect	NN
18637	4973	3	of	of	IN
18637	4973	4	this	this	DT
18637	4973	5	change	change	NN
18637	4973	6	,	,	,
18637	4973	7	which	which	WDT
18637	4973	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	4973	9	not	not	RB
18637	4973	10	yet	yet	RB
18637	4973	11	registered	register	VBN
18637	4973	12	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4973	13	in	in	IN
18637	4973	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	4973	15	decision	decision	NN
18637	4973	16	,	,	,
18637	4973	17	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	4973	18	likely	likely	JJ
18637	4973	19	to	to	TO
18637	4973	20	be	be	VB
18637	4973	21	slight	slight	JJ
18637	4973	22	,	,	,
18637	4973	23	in	in	IN
18637	4973	24	view	view	NN
18637	4973	25	of	of	IN
18637	4973	26	the	the	DT
18637	4973	27	power	power	NN
18637	4973	28	,	,	,
18637	4973	29	which	which	WDT
18637	4973	30	the	the	DT
18637	4973	31	act	act	NN
18637	4973	32	gives	give	VBZ
18637	4973	33	the	the	DT
18637	4973	34	Administrator	administrator	NN
18637	4973	35	to	to	TO
18637	4973	36	lay	lay	VB
18637	4973	37	down	down	RP
18637	4973	38	"	"	``
18637	4973	39	such	such	JJ
18637	4973	40	terms	term	NNS
18637	4973	41	and	and	CC
18637	4973	42	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	4973	43	"	"	''
18637	4973	44	as	as	IN
18637	4973	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4973	46	"	"	``
18637	4973	47	finds	find	VBZ
18637	4973	48	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	4973	49	to	to	TO
18637	4973	50	carry	carry	VB
18637	4973	51	out	out	RP
18637	4973	52	the	the	DT
18637	4973	53	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	4973	54	of	of	IN
18637	4973	55	"	"	``
18637	4973	56	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4973	57	orders	order	NNS
18637	4973	58	to	to	TO
18637	4973	59	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	4973	60	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4973	61	evasion	evasion	NN
18637	4973	62	or	or	CC
18637	4973	63	circumvention	circumvention	NN
18637	4973	64	.	.	.
18637	4974	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4974	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4974	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4974	4	Gemsco	Gemsco	NNP
18637	4974	5	,	,	,
18637	4974	6	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	4974	7	_	_	NNP
18637	4974	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	4974	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4974	10	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	4974	11	,	,	,
18637	4974	12	324	324	CD
18637	4974	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4974	14	244	244	CD
18637	4974	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4974	16	1945	1945	CD
18637	4974	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4974	18	.	.	.
18637	4975	1	The	the	DT
18637	4975	2	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4975	3	involved	involve	VBN
18637	4975	4	in	in	IN
18637	4975	5	the	the	DT
18637	4975	6	following	follow	VBG
18637	4975	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	4975	8	have	have	VBP
18637	4975	9	been	be	VBN
18637	4975	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	4975	11	to	to	TO
18637	4975	12	be	be	VB
18637	4975	13	covered	cover	VBN
18637	4975	14	by	by	IN
18637	4975	15	the	the	DT
18637	4975	16	act	act	NN
18637	4975	17	:	:	:
18637	4975	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	19	1	1	LS
18637	4975	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	21	Operating	operating	NN
18637	4975	22	and	and	CC
18637	4975	23	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	4975	24	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4975	25	of	of	IN
18637	4975	26	the	the	DT
18637	4975	27	owner	owner	NN
18637	4975	28	of	of	IN
18637	4975	29	a	a	DT
18637	4975	30	loft	loft	NN
18637	4975	31	building	building	NN
18637	4975	32	,	,	,
18637	4975	33	space	space	NN
18637	4975	34	in	in	IN
18637	4975	35	which	which	WDT
18637	4975	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	4975	37	rented	rent	VBN
18637	4975	38	to	to	IN
18637	4975	39	persons	person	NNS
18637	4975	40	producing	produce	VBG
18637	4975	41	goods	good	NNS
18637	4975	42	principally	principally	RB
18637	4975	43	for	for	IN
18637	4975	44	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4975	45	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4975	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	47	Kirschbaum	Kirschbaum	NNP
18637	4975	48	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	4975	50	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	51	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	4975	52	,	,	,
18637	4975	53	316	316	CD
18637	4975	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4975	55	517	517	CD
18637	4975	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	57	1942	1942	CD
18637	4975	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	60	;	;	,
18637	4975	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	62	2	2	LS
18637	4975	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	64	an	an	DT
18637	4975	65	employee	employee	NN
18637	4975	66	of	of	IN
18637	4975	67	an	an	DT
18637	4975	68	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4975	69	motor	motor	NN
18637	4975	70	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	4975	71	company	company	NN
18637	4975	72	,	,	,
18637	4975	73	who	who	WP
18637	4975	74	acted	act	VBD
18637	4975	75	as	as	IN
18637	4975	76	rate	rate	NN
18637	4975	77	clerk	clerk	NN
18637	4975	78	and	and	CC
18637	4975	79	performed	perform	VBD
18637	4975	80	other	other	JJ
18637	4975	81	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	4975	82	duties	duty	NNS
18637	4975	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	84	Overnight	Overnight	NNP
18637	4975	85	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	4975	86	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4975	87	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	4975	89	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	90	Missel	Missel	NNP
18637	4975	91	,	,	,
18637	4975	92	316	316	CD
18637	4975	93	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4975	94	572	572	CD
18637	4975	95	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	96	1942	1942	CD
18637	4975	97	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	99	;	;	:
18637	4975	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	101	3	3	LS
18637	4975	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	103	members	member	NNS
18637	4975	104	of	of	IN
18637	4975	105	a	a	DT
18637	4975	106	rotary	rotary	JJ
18637	4975	107	drilling	drilling	NN
18637	4975	108	crew	crew	NN
18637	4975	109	,	,	,
18637	4975	110	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	4975	111	within	within	IN
18637	4975	112	a	a	DT
18637	4975	113	State	State	NNP
18637	4975	114	,	,	,
18637	4975	115	as	as	IN
18637	4975	116	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4975	117	of	of	IN
18637	4975	118	an	an	DT
18637	4975	119	independent	independent	JJ
18637	4975	120	contractor	contractor	NN
18637	4975	121	,	,	,
18637	4975	122	in	in	IN
18637	4975	123	partially	partially	RB
18637	4975	124	drilling	drill	VBG
18637	4975	125	oil	oil	NN
18637	4975	126	wells	well	NNS
18637	4975	127	,	,	,
18637	4975	128	a	a	DT
18637	4975	129	portion	portion	NN
18637	4975	130	of	of	IN
18637	4975	131	the	the	DT
18637	4975	132	products	product	NNS
18637	4975	133	from	from	IN
18637	4975	134	which	which	WDT
18637	4975	135	later	later	RB
18637	4975	136	moved	move	VBD
18637	4975	137	in	in	IN
18637	4975	138	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4975	139	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4975	140	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	141	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	4975	142	-	-	HYPH
18637	4975	143	Bradshaw	Bradshaw	NNP
18637	4975	144	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4975	145	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	146	v.	v.	IN
18637	4975	147	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	148	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	4975	149	,	,	,
18637	4975	150	317	317	CD
18637	4975	151	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4975	152	88	88	CD
18637	4975	153	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	154	1942	1942	CD
18637	4975	155	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	156	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	157	;	;	:
18637	4975	158	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	159	4	4	LS
18637	4975	160	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	161	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4975	162	of	of	IN
18637	4975	163	a	a	DT
18637	4975	164	wholesale	wholesale	JJ
18637	4975	165	paper	paper	NN
18637	4975	166	company	company	NN
18637	4975	167	who	who	WP
18637	4975	168	are	be	VBP
18637	4975	169	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4975	170	in	in	IN
18637	4975	171	the	the	DT
18637	4975	172	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	4975	173	,	,	,
18637	4975	174	from	from	IN
18637	4975	175	company	company	NN
18637	4975	176	warehouse	warehouse	NN
18637	4975	177	within	within	IN
18637	4975	178	a	a	DT
18637	4975	179	State	state	NN
18637	4975	180	to	to	IN
18637	4975	181	customers	customer	NNS
18637	4975	182	within	within	IN
18637	4975	183	that	that	DT
18637	4975	184	State	State	NNP
18637	4975	185	,	,	,
18637	4975	186	after	after	IN
18637	4975	187	a	a	DT
18637	4975	188	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	4975	189	pause	pause	NN
18637	4975	190	at	at	IN
18637	4975	191	such	such	JJ
18637	4975	192	warehouses	warehouse	NNS
18637	4975	193	,	,	,
18637	4975	194	of	of	IN
18637	4975	195	goods	good	NNS
18637	4975	196	procured	procure	VBN
18637	4975	197	outside	outside	RB
18637	4975	198	of	of	IN
18637	4975	199	the	the	DT
18637	4975	200	State	State	NNP
18637	4975	201	upon	upon	IN
18637	4975	202	prior	prior	JJ
18637	4975	203	orders	order	NNS
18637	4975	204	from	from	IN
18637	4975	205	,	,	,
18637	4975	206	or	or	CC
18637	4975	207	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	4975	208	to	to	IN
18637	4975	209	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	4975	210	with	with	IN
18637	4975	211	,	,	,
18637	4975	212	such	such	JJ
18637	4975	213	customers	customer	NNS
18637	4975	214	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	215	Walling	wall	VBG
18637	4975	216	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	217	v.	v.	IN
18637	4975	218	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	219	Jacksonville	Jacksonville	NNP
18637	4975	220	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	4975	221	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4975	222	,	,	,
18637	4975	223	317	317	CD
18637	4975	224	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4975	225	564	564	CD
18637	4975	226	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	227	1943	1943	CD
18637	4975	228	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	229	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	230	;	;	:
18637	4975	231	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	232	5	5	LS
18637	4975	233	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	234	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4975	235	of	of	IN
18637	4975	236	a	a	DT
18637	4975	237	private	private	JJ
18637	4975	238	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	4975	239	who	who	WP
18637	4975	240	are	be	VBP
18637	4975	241	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4975	242	in	in	IN
18637	4975	243	the	the	DT
18637	4975	244	operation	operation	NN
18637	4975	245	and	and	CC
18637	4975	246	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	4975	247	of	of	IN
18637	4975	248	a	a	DT
18637	4975	249	drawbridge	drawbridge	NN
18637	4975	250	which	which	WDT
18637	4975	251	is	be	VBZ
18637	4975	252	part	part	NN
18637	4975	253	of	of	IN
18637	4975	254	a	a	DT
18637	4975	255	toll	toll	NN
18637	4975	256	road	road	NN
18637	4975	257	used	use	VBN
18637	4975	258	extensively	extensively	RB
18637	4975	259	by	by	IN
18637	4975	260	persons	person	NNS
18637	4975	261	and	and	CC
18637	4975	262	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	4975	263	traveling	travel	VBG
18637	4975	264	in	in	IN
18637	4975	265	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4975	266	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4975	267	,	,	,
18637	4975	268	and	and	CC
18637	4975	269	which	which	WDT
18637	4975	270	spans	span	VBZ
18637	4975	271	an	an	DT
18637	4975	272	intercoastal	intercoastal	JJ
18637	4975	273	waterway	waterway	NN
18637	4975	274	used	use	VBN
18637	4975	275	in	in	IN
18637	4975	276	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4975	277	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4975	278	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	279	Overstreet	Overstreet	NNP
18637	4975	280	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	281	v.	v.	IN
18637	4975	282	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	283	North	North	NNP
18637	4975	284	Shore	Shore	NNP
18637	4975	285	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	4975	286	,	,	,
18637	4975	287	318	318	CD
18637	4975	288	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4975	289	125	125	CD
18637	4975	290	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	291	1943	1943	CD
18637	4975	292	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	293	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	294	;	;	:
18637	4975	295	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	296	6	6	LS
18637	4975	297	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	298	a	a	DT
18637	4975	299	night	night	NN
18637	4975	300	watchman	watchman	NN
18637	4975	301	employed	employ	VBN
18637	4975	302	in	in	IN
18637	4975	303	a	a	DT
18637	4975	304	plant	plant	NN
18637	4975	305	in	in	IN
18637	4975	306	which	which	WDT
18637	4975	307	veneer	veneer	NN
18637	4975	308	was	be	VBD
18637	4975	309	manufactured	manufacture	VBN
18637	4975	310	from	from	IN
18637	4975	311	logs	logs	NNP
18637	4975	312	and	and	CC
18637	4975	313	from	from	IN
18637	4975	314	which	which	WDT
18637	4975	315	a	a	DT
18637	4975	316	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	4975	317	portion	portion	NN
18637	4975	318	of	of	IN
18637	4975	319	the	the	DT
18637	4975	320	manufactured	manufacture	VBN
18637	4975	321	product	product	NN
18637	4975	322	was	be	VBD
18637	4975	323	shipped	ship	VBN
18637	4975	324	in	in	IN
18637	4975	325	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4975	326	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4975	327	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	328	Walton	Walton	NNP
18637	4975	329	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	330	v.	v.	IN
18637	4975	331	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	332	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	4975	333	Package	Package	NNP
18637	4975	334	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	4975	335	,	,	,
18637	4975	336	320	320	CD
18637	4975	337	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4975	338	540	540	CD
18637	4975	339	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	340	1944	1944	CD
18637	4975	341	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	342	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	343	;	;	:
18637	4975	344	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	345	7	7	LS
18637	4975	346	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	347	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4975	348	putting	put	VBG
18637	4975	349	in	in	RP
18637	4975	350	stand	stand	VB
18637	4975	351	-	-	HYPH
18637	4975	352	by	by	RP
18637	4975	353	time	time	NN
18637	4975	354	in	in	IN
18637	4975	355	the	the	DT
18637	4975	356	auxiliary	auxiliary	JJ
18637	4975	357	fire	fire	NN
18637	4975	358	-	-	HYPH
18637	4975	359	fighting	fight	VBG
18637	4975	360	service	service	NN
18637	4975	361	of	of	IN
18637	4975	362	an	an	DT
18637	4975	363	employer	employer	NN
18637	4975	364	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4975	365	in	in	IN
18637	4975	366	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4975	367	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4975	368	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	369	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	4975	370	&	&	CC
18637	4975	371	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4975	372	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	373	v.	v.	IN
18637	4975	374	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	375	Wantock	Wantock	NNP
18637	4975	376	,	,	,
18637	4975	377	323	323	CD
18637	4975	378	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4975	379	126	126	CD
18637	4975	380	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	381	1944	1944	CD
18637	4975	382	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	383	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	384	;	;	:
18637	4975	385	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	386	8)	8)	CD
18637	4975	387	warehouse	warehouse	NN
18637	4975	388	and	and	CC
18637	4975	389	central	central	JJ
18637	4975	390	office	office	NN
18637	4975	391	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4975	392	of	of	IN
18637	4975	393	an	an	DT
18637	4975	394	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4975	395	retail	retail	JJ
18637	4975	396	chain	chain	NN
18637	4975	397	store	store	NN
18637	4975	398	system	system	NN
18637	4975	399	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	400	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	4975	401	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4975	402	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	403	v.	v.	IN
18637	4975	404	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	405	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	4975	406	,	,	,
18637	4975	407	324	324	CD
18637	4975	408	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4975	409	490	490	CD
18637	4975	410	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	411	1945	1945	CD
18637	4975	412	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	413	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	414	;	;	:
18637	4975	415	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	416	9	9	LS
18637	4975	417	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	418	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4975	419	of	of	IN
18637	4975	420	an	an	DT
18637	4975	421	independent	independent	JJ
18637	4975	422	contractor	contractor	NN
18637	4975	423	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4975	424	in	in	IN
18637	4975	425	repairing	repair	VBG
18637	4975	426	abutments	abutment	NNS
18637	4975	427	and	and	CC
18637	4975	428	substructures	substructure	NNS
18637	4975	429	of	of	IN
18637	4975	430	bridges	bridge	NNS
18637	4975	431	which	which	WDT
18637	4975	432	were	be	VBD
18637	4975	433	part	part	NN
18637	4975	434	of	of	IN
18637	4975	435	the	the	DT
18637	4975	436	line	line	NN
18637	4975	437	of	of	IN
18637	4975	438	an	an	DT
18637	4975	439	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4975	440	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	4975	441	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	442	Fitzgerald	Fitzgerald	NNP
18637	4975	443	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4975	444	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	445	v.	v.	IN
18637	4975	446	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	447	Pedersen	Pedersen	NNP
18637	4975	448	,	,	,
18637	4975	449	324	324	CD
18637	4975	450	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4975	451	720	720	CD
18637	4975	452	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	453	1945	1945	CD
18637	4975	454	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	455	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	456	;	;	:
18637	4975	457	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	458	10	10	LS
18637	4975	459	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	460	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	4975	461	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4975	462	of	of	IN
18637	4975	463	an	an	DT
18637	4975	464	office	office	NN
18637	4975	465	building	building	NN
18637	4975	466	which	which	WDT
18637	4975	467	was	be	VBD
18637	4975	468	owned	own	VBN
18637	4975	469	and	and	CC
18637	4975	470	operated	operate	VBN
18637	4975	471	by	by	IN
18637	4975	472	a	a	DT
18637	4975	473	manufacturing	manufacture	VBG
18637	4975	474	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	4975	475	and	and	CC
18637	4975	476	in	in	IN
18637	4975	477	which	which	WDT
18637	4975	478	58	58	CD
18637	4975	479	per	per	IN
18637	4975	480	cent	cent	NN
18637	4975	481	of	of	IN
18637	4975	482	the	the	DT
18637	4975	483	rental	rental	JJ
18637	4975	484	space	space	NN
18637	4975	485	was	be	VBD
18637	4975	486	used	use	VBN
18637	4975	487	for	for	IN
18637	4975	488	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4975	489	central	central	JJ
18637	4975	490	offices	office	NNS
18637	4975	491	,	,	,
18637	4975	492	where	where	WRB
18637	4975	493	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4975	494	production	production	NN
18637	4975	495	of	of	IN
18637	4975	496	goods	good	NNS
18637	4975	497	for	for	IN
18637	4975	498	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4975	499	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	4975	500	was	be	VBD
18637	4975	501	administered	administer	VBN
18637	4975	502	,	,	,
18637	4975	503	managed	manage	VBN
18637	4975	504	and	and	CC
18637	4975	505	controlled	control	VBN
18637	4975	506	,	,	,
18637	4975	507	although	although	IN
18637	4975	508	the	the	DT
18637	4975	509	goods	good	NNS
18637	4975	510	were	be	VBD
18637	4975	511	actually	actually	RB
18637	4975	512	produced	produce	VBN
18637	4975	513	at	at	IN
18637	4975	514	plants	plant	NNS
18637	4975	515	located	locate	VBN
18637	4975	516	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	4975	517	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	518	Borden	Borden	NNP
18637	4975	519	Company	Company	NNP
18637	4975	520	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	521	v.	v.	IN
18637	4975	522	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	523	Borella	Borella	NNP
18637	4975	524	,	,	,
18637	4975	525	325	325	CD
18637	4975	526	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4975	527	679	679	CD
18637	4975	528	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	529	1945	1945	CD
18637	4975	530	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	531	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	532	;	;	:
18637	4975	533	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	534	11	11	LS
18637	4975	535	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	536	the	the	DT
18637	4975	537	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4975	538	of	of	IN
18637	4975	539	an	an	DT
18637	4975	540	electrical	electrical	JJ
18637	4975	541	contractor	contractor	NN
18637	4975	542	,	,	,
18637	4975	543	locally	locally	RB
18637	4975	544	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4975	545	in	in	IN
18637	4975	546	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	4975	547	and	and	CC
18637	4975	548	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	4975	549	wiring	wiring	NN
18637	4975	550	and	and	CC
18637	4975	551	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	4975	552	in	in	IN
18637	4975	553	electrical	electrical	JJ
18637	4975	554	motors	motor	NNS
18637	4975	555	and	and	CC
18637	4975	556	generators	generator	NNS
18637	4975	557	for	for	IN
18637	4975	558	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	4975	559	and	and	CC
18637	4975	560	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	4975	561	uses	use	NNS
18637	4975	562	,	,	,
18637	4975	563	whose	whose	WP$
18637	4975	564	customers	customer	NNS
18637	4975	565	are	be	VBP
18637	4975	566	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4975	567	in	in	IN
18637	4975	568	the	the	DT
18637	4975	569	production	production	NN
18637	4975	570	of	of	IN
18637	4975	571	goods	good	NNS
18637	4975	572	for	for	IN
18637	4975	573	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4975	574	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4975	575	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	576	Roland	Roland	NNP
18637	4975	577	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4975	578	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	579	v.	v.	IN
18637	4975	580	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	581	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	4975	582	,	,	,
18637	4975	583	326	326	CD
18637	4975	584	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4975	585	657	657	CD
18637	4975	586	-	-	SYM
18637	4975	587	678	678	CD
18637	4975	588	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	589	1946	1946	CD
18637	4975	590	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	591	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	592	;	;	:
18637	4975	593	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	594	12	12	CD
18637	4975	595	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	596	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4975	597	of	of	IN
18637	4975	598	a	a	DT
18637	4975	599	window	window	NN
18637	4975	600	-	-	HYPH
18637	4975	601	cleaning	clean	VBG
18637	4975	602	company	company	NN
18637	4975	603	,	,	,
18637	4975	604	the	the	DT
18637	4975	605	greater	great	JJR
18637	4975	606	part	part	NN
18637	4975	607	of	of	IN
18637	4975	608	whose	whose	WP$
18637	4975	609	work	work	NN
18637	4975	610	is	be	VBZ
18637	4975	611	done	do	VBN
18637	4975	612	on	on	IN
18637	4975	613	the	the	DT
18637	4975	614	windows	window	NNS
18637	4975	615	of	of	IN
18637	4975	616	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	4975	617	plants	plant	NNS
18637	4975	618	of	of	IN
18637	4975	619	producers	producer	NNS
18637	4975	620	of	of	IN
18637	4975	621	goods	good	NNS
18637	4975	622	for	for	IN
18637	4975	623	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4975	624	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4975	625	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	626	Martino	Martino	NNP
18637	4975	627	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	628	v.	v.	IN
18637	4975	629	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	630	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	4975	631	Window	Window	NNP
18637	4975	632	Cleaning	Cleaning	NNP
18637	4975	633	Company	Company	NNP
18637	4975	634	,	,	,
18637	4975	635	327	327	CD
18637	4975	636	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4975	637	173	173	CD
18637	4975	638	-	-	SYM
18637	4975	639	178	178	CD
18637	4975	640	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	641	1946	1946	CD
18637	4975	642	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	643	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	644	;	;	:
18637	4975	645	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	646	13	13	CD
18637	4975	647	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	648	mechanics	mechanic	NNS
18637	4975	649	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4975	650	in	in	IN
18637	4975	651	servicing	servicing	NN
18637	4975	652	and	and	CC
18637	4975	653	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	4975	654	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	4975	655	of	of	IN
18637	4975	656	a	a	DT
18637	4975	657	motor	motor	NN
18637	4975	658	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	4975	659	company	company	NN
18637	4975	660	which	which	WDT
18637	4975	661	is	be	VBZ
18637	4975	662	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4975	663	in	in	IN
18637	4975	664	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4975	665	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4975	666	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	667	Boutell	Boutell	NNP
18637	4975	668	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	669	v.	v.	IN
18637	4975	670	_	_	NNP
18637	4975	671	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	4975	672	,	,	,
18637	4975	673	327	327	CD
18637	4975	674	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4975	675	463	463	CD
18637	4975	676	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4975	677	1946	1946	CD
18637	4975	678	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	679	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4975	680	.	.	.
18637	4976	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	4976	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	4976	3	the	the	DT
18637	4976	4	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	4976	5	"	"	``
18637	4976	6	_	_	NNP
18637	4976	7	de	de	NNP
18637	4976	8	minimis	minimis	NNP
18637	4976	9	_	_	NNP
18637	4976	10	"	"	``
18637	4976	11	apply	apply	VB
18637	4976	12	to	to	IN
18637	4976	13	the	the	DT
18637	4976	14	act	act	NN
18637	4976	15	.	.	.
18637	4977	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	4977	2	the	the	DT
18637	4977	3	publishers	publisher	NNS
18637	4977	4	of	of	IN
18637	4977	5	a	a	DT
18637	4977	6	daily	daily	JJ
18637	4977	7	newspaper	newspaper	NN
18637	4977	8	only	only	RB
18637	4977	9	about	about	RB
18637	4977	10	one	one	CD
18637	4977	11	half	half	NN
18637	4977	12	of	of	IN
18637	4977	13	one	one	CD
18637	4977	14	per	per	IN
18637	4977	15	cent	cent	NN
18637	4977	16	of	of	IN
18637	4977	17	whose	whose	WP$
18637	4977	18	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	4977	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	4977	20	outside	outside	IN
18637	4977	21	the	the	DT
18637	4977	22	State	State	NNP
18637	4977	23	of	of	IN
18637	4977	24	publication	publication	NN
18637	4977	25	are	be	VBP
18637	4977	26	not	not	RB
18637	4977	27	by	by	IN
18637	4977	28	that	that	DT
18637	4977	29	fact	fact	NN
18637	4977	30	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	4977	31	from	from	IN
18637	4977	32	the	the	DT
18637	4977	33	operation	operation	NN
18637	4977	34	of	of	IN
18637	4977	35	the	the	DT
18637	4977	36	act	act	NN
18637	4977	37	.	.	.
18637	4978	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4978	2	Mabee	Mabee	NNP
18637	4978	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4978	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	4978	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4978	6	White	White	NNP
18637	4978	7	Plains	Plains	NNPS
18637	4978	8	Publishing	Publishing	NNP
18637	4978	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	4978	10	,	,	,
18637	4978	11	327	327	CD
18637	4978	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4978	13	178	178	CD
18637	4978	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4978	15	1946	1946	CD
18637	4978	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4978	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4978	18	.	.	.
18637	4979	1	On	on	IN
18637	4979	2	the	the	DT
18637	4979	3	other	other	JJ
18637	4979	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	4979	5	,	,	,
18637	4979	6	an	an	DT
18637	4979	7	employee	employee	NN
18637	4979	8	whose	whose	WP$
18637	4979	9	work	work	NN
18637	4979	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4979	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	4979	12	to	to	TO
18637	4979	13	prepare	prepare	VB
18637	4979	14	meals	meal	NNS
18637	4979	15	and	and	CC
18637	4979	16	serve	serve	VB
18637	4979	17	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4979	18	to	to	IN
18637	4979	19	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	4979	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	4979	21	of	of	IN
18637	4979	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	4979	23	way	way	NN
18637	4979	24	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4979	25	of	of	IN
18637	4979	26	an	an	DT
18637	4979	27	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	4979	28	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	4979	29	in	in	IN
18637	4979	30	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	4979	31	of	of	IN
18637	4979	32	a	a	DT
18637	4979	33	contract	contract	NN
18637	4979	34	between	between	IN
18637	4979	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4979	36	employer	employer	NN
18637	4979	37	and	and	CC
18637	4979	38	the	the	DT
18637	4979	39	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	4979	40	company	company	NN
18637	4979	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	4979	42	not	not	RB
18637	4979	43	"	"	``
18637	4979	44	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4979	45	in	in	IN
18637	4979	46	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4979	47	"	"	''
18637	4979	48	within	within	IN
18637	4979	49	the	the	DT
18637	4979	50	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	4979	51	of	of	IN
18637	4979	52	§§	§§	NNP
18637	4979	53	6	6	CD
18637	4979	54	and	and	CC
18637	4979	55	7	7	CD
18637	4979	56	of	of	IN
18637	4979	57	the	the	DT
18637	4979	58	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	4979	59	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	4979	60	Standards	Standards	NNP
18637	4979	61	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4979	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4979	63	McLeod	McLeod	NNP
18637	4979	64	_	_	NNP
18637	4979	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	4979	66	_	_	NNP
18637	4979	67	Threlkeld	Threlkeld	NNP
18637	4979	68	,	,	,
18637	4979	69	319	319	CD
18637	4979	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4979	71	491	491	CD
18637	4979	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4979	73	1943	1943	CD
18637	4979	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4979	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4979	76	;	;	:
18637	4979	77	nor	nor	CC
18637	4979	78	are	be	VBP
18637	4979	79	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	4979	80	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4979	81	of	of	IN
18637	4979	82	a	a	DT
18637	4979	83	typical	typical	JJ
18637	4979	84	metropolitan	metropolitan	JJ
18637	4979	85	office	office	NN
18637	4979	86	building	building	NN
18637	4979	87	operated	operate	VBD
18637	4979	88	as	as	IN
18637	4979	89	an	an	DT
18637	4979	90	independent	independent	JJ
18637	4979	91	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	4979	92	,	,	,
18637	4979	93	which	which	WDT
18637	4979	94	is	be	VBZ
18637	4979	95	used	use	VBN
18637	4979	96	and	and	CC
18637	4979	97	is	be	VBZ
18637	4979	98	to	to	TO
18637	4979	99	be	be	VB
18637	4979	100	used	use	VBN
18637	4979	101	for	for	IN
18637	4979	102	offices	office	NNS
18637	4979	103	by	by	IN
18637	4979	104	every	every	DT
18637	4979	105	variety	variety	NN
18637	4979	106	of	of	IN
18637	4979	107	tenants	tenant	NNS
18637	4979	108	,	,	,
18637	4979	109	including	include	VBG
18637	4979	110	some	some	DT
18637	4979	111	producers	producer	NNS
18637	4979	112	of	of	IN
18637	4979	113	goods	good	NNS
18637	4979	114	for	for	IN
18637	4979	115	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4979	116	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4979	117	10	10	CD
18637	4979	118	East	East	NNP
18637	4979	119	40th	40th	NNP
18637	4979	120	St.	St.	NNP
18637	4979	121	_	_	NNP
18637	4979	122	v.	v.	IN
18637	4979	123	_	_	NNP
18637	4979	124	Callus	Callus	NNP
18637	4979	125	,	,	,
18637	4979	126	325	325	CD
18637	4979	127	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4979	128	578	578	CD
18637	4979	129	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4979	130	1945	1945	CD
18637	4979	131	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4979	132	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4979	133	;	;	:
18637	4979	134	nor	nor	CC
18637	4979	135	are	be	VBP
18637	4979	136	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	4979	137	employees	employee	NNS
18637	4979	138	of	of	IN
18637	4979	139	a	a	DT
18637	4979	140	building	building	NN
18637	4979	141	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	4979	142	which	which	WDT
18637	4979	143	furnishes	furnish	VBZ
18637	4979	144	loft	loft	NNP
18637	4979	145	space	space	NN
18637	4979	146	to	to	IN
18637	4979	147	tenants	tenant	NNS
18637	4979	148	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4979	149	in	in	IN
18637	4979	150	production	production	NN
18637	4979	151	for	for	IN
18637	4979	152	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4979	153	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4979	154	"	"	''
18637	4979	155	unless	unless	IN
18637	4979	156	an	an	DT
18637	4979	157	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	4979	158	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	4979	159	of	of	IN
18637	4979	160	such	such	JJ
18637	4979	161	tenants	tenant	NNS
18637	4979	162	are	be	VBP
18637	4979	163	so	so	RB
18637	4979	164	engaged	engaged	JJ
18637	4979	165	.	.	.
18637	4979	166	"	"	''
18637	4980	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4980	2	Schulte	Schulte	NNP
18637	4980	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4980	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	4980	5	_	_	NNP
18637	4980	6	Gangi	Gangi	NNP
18637	4980	7	,	,	,
18637	4980	8	328	328	CD
18637	4980	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4980	10	108	108	CD
18637	4980	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4980	12	1946	1946	CD
18637	4980	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4980	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4980	15	.	.	.
18637	4981	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4981	2	Also	also	RB
18637	4981	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4981	4	Section	Section	NNP
18637	4981	5	12	12	CD
18637	4981	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4981	7	a	a	DT
18637	4981	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4981	9	of	of	IN
18637	4981	10	the	the	DT
18637	4981	11	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	4981	12	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	4981	13	Standards	Standards	NNP
18637	4981	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4981	15	,	,	,
18637	4981	16	which	which	WDT
18637	4981	17	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	4981	18	that	that	IN
18637	4981	19	"	"	``
18637	4981	20	no	no	DT
18637	4981	21	producer	producer	NN
18637	4981	22	,	,	,
18637	4981	23	*	*	NFP
18637	4981	24	*	*	NFP
18637	4981	25	*	*	NFP
18637	4981	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	4981	27	ship	ship	NN
18637	4981	28	or	or	CC
18637	4981	29	deliver	deliver	VB
18637	4981	30	for	for	IN
18637	4981	31	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	4981	32	in	in	IN
18637	4981	33	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4981	34	any	any	DT
18637	4981	35	goods	good	NNS
18637	4981	36	produced	produce	VBN
18637	4981	37	in	in	IN
18637	4981	38	an	an	DT
18637	4981	39	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	4981	40	*	*	NFP
18637	4981	41	*	*	NFP
18637	4981	42	*	*	NFP
18637	4981	43	in	in	IN
18637	4981	44	or	or	CC
18637	4981	45	about	about	IN
18637	4981	46	which	which	WDT
18637	4981	47	*	*	NFP
18637	4981	48	*	*	NFP
18637	4981	49	*	*	NFP
18637	4981	50	any	any	DT
18637	4981	51	oppressive	oppressive	JJ
18637	4981	52	child	child	NN
18637	4981	53	labor	labor	NN
18637	4981	54	has	have	VBZ
18637	4981	55	been	be	VBN
18637	4981	56	employed	employ	VBN
18637	4981	57	*	*	NFP
18637	4981	58	*	*	NFP
18637	4981	59	*	*	NFP
18637	4981	60	"	"	''
18637	4981	61	was	be	VBD
18637	4981	62	held	hold	VBN
18637	4981	63	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	4981	64	to	to	IN
18637	4981	65	a	a	DT
18637	4981	66	company	company	NN
18637	4981	67	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4981	68	in	in	IN
18637	4981	69	the	the	DT
18637	4981	70	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	4981	71	in	in	IN
18637	4981	72	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	4981	73	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4981	74	of	of	IN
18637	4981	75	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	4981	76	messages	message	NNS
18637	4981	77	,	,	,
18637	4981	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4981	79	Western	Western	NNP
18637	4981	80	Union	Union	NNP
18637	4981	81	_	_	NNP
18637	4981	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	4981	83	_	_	NNP
18637	4981	84	Lenroot	Lenroot	NNP
18637	4981	85	,	,	,
18637	4981	86	323	323	CD
18637	4981	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4981	88	490	490	CD
18637	4981	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4981	90	1945	1945	CD
18637	4981	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4981	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4981	93	.	.	.
18637	4982	1	The	the	DT
18637	4982	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	4982	3	was	be	VBD
18637	4982	4	a	a	DT
18637	4982	5	five	five	CD
18637	4982	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	4982	7	to	to	IN
18637	4982	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	4982	9	four	four	CD
18637	4982	10	one	one	CD
18637	4982	11	.	.	.
18637	4983	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4983	2	should	should	MD
18637	4983	3	be	be	VB
18637	4983	4	added	add	VBN
18637	4983	5	that	that	IN
18637	4983	6	the	the	DT
18637	4983	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4983	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	4983	9	not	not	RB
18637	4983	10	always	always	RB
18637	4983	11	been	be	VBN
18637	4983	12	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	4983	13	in	in	IN
18637	4983	14	favoring	favor	VBG
18637	4983	15	coverage	coverage	NN
18637	4983	16	by	by	IN
18637	4983	17	the	the	DT
18637	4983	18	act	act	NN
18637	4983	19	.	.	.
18637	4984	1	In	in	IN
18637	4984	2	the	the	DT
18637	4984	3	Borden	Borden	NNP
18637	4984	4	case	case	NN
18637	4984	5	above	above	IN
18637	4984	6	,	,	,
18637	4984	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	4984	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4984	9	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	4984	10	,	,	,
18637	4984	11	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	4984	12	for	for	IN
18637	4984	13	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4984	14	and	and	CC
18637	4984	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4984	16	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	4984	17	,	,	,
18637	4984	18	protested	protest	VBD
18637	4984	19	,	,	,
18637	4984	20	as	as	IN
18637	4984	21	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	4984	22	:	:	:
18637	4984	23	"	"	``
18637	4984	24	No	no	DT
18637	4984	25	doubt	doubt	RB
18637	4984	26	there	there	EX
18637	4984	27	are	be	VBP
18637	4984	28	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
18637	4984	29	who	who	WP
18637	4984	30	would	would	MD
18637	4984	31	argue	argue	VB
18637	4984	32	,	,	,
18637	4984	33	what	what	WP
18637	4984	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	4984	35	implicit	implicit	JJ
18637	4984	36	in	in	IN
18637	4984	37	the	the	DT
18637	4984	38	decision	decision	NN
18637	4984	39	now	now	RB
18637	4984	40	rendered	render	VBN
18637	4984	41	,	,	,
18637	4984	42	that	that	IN
18637	4984	43	in	in	IN
18637	4984	44	a	a	DT
18637	4984	45	complex	complex	JJ
18637	4984	46	modern	modern	JJ
18637	4984	47	society	society	NN
18637	4984	48	there	there	EX
18637	4984	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	4984	50	such	such	JJ
18637	4984	51	interdependence	interdependence	NN
18637	4984	52	of	of	IN
18637	4984	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4984	54	members	member	NNS
18637	4984	55	that	that	IN
18637	4984	56	the	the	DT
18637	4984	57	activities	activity	NNS
18637	4984	58	of	of	IN
18637	4984	59	most	most	JJS
18637	4984	60	of	of	IN
18637	4984	61	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4984	62	are	be	VBP
18637	4984	63	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	4984	64	to	to	IN
18637	4984	65	the	the	DT
18637	4984	66	activities	activity	NNS
18637	4984	67	of	of	IN
18637	4984	68	most	most	JJS
18637	4984	69	others	other	NNS
18637	4984	70	.	.	.
18637	4985	1	But	but	CC
18637	4985	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4985	3	think	think	VBP
18637	4985	4	that	that	IN
18637	4985	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4985	6	did	do	VBD
18637	4985	7	not	not	RB
18637	4985	8	make	make	VB
18637	4985	9	that	that	DT
18637	4985	10	philosophy	philosophy	NN
18637	4985	11	the	the	DT
18637	4985	12	basis	basis	NN
18637	4985	13	of	of	IN
18637	4985	14	the	the	DT
18637	4985	15	coverage	coverage	NN
18637	4985	16	of	of	IN
18637	4985	17	the	the	DT
18637	4985	18	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	4985	19	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	4985	20	Standards	Standards	NNP
18637	4985	21	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4985	22	.	.	.
18637	4986	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4986	2	did	do	VBD
18637	4986	3	not	not	RB
18637	4986	4	,	,	,
18637	4986	5	by	by	IN
18637	4986	6	a	a	DT
18637	4986	7	'	'	``
18637	4986	8	house	house	NN
18637	4986	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	4986	10	that	that	DT
18637	4986	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	4986	12	Jack	Jack	NNP
18637	4986	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	4986	14	built	build	VBN
18637	4986	15	'	'	''
18637	4986	16	chain	chain	NN
18637	4986	17	of	of	IN
18637	4986	18	causation	causation	NN
18637	4986	19	,	,	,
18637	4986	20	bring	bring	VB
18637	4986	21	within	within	IN
18637	4986	22	the	the	DT
18637	4986	23	sweep	sweep	NN
18637	4986	24	of	of	IN
18637	4986	25	the	the	DT
18637	4986	26	statute	statute	NN
18637	4986	27	the	the	DT
18637	4986	28	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	4986	29	_	_	NNP
18637	4986	30	causa	causa	VBD
18637	4986	31	causarum	causarum	NNP
18637	4986	32	_	_	NNP
18637	4986	33	which	which	WDT
18637	4986	34	result	result	VBP
18637	4986	35	in	in	IN
18637	4986	36	the	the	DT
18637	4986	37	production	production	NN
18637	4986	38	of	of	IN
18637	4986	39	goods	good	NNS
18637	4986	40	for	for	IN
18637	4986	41	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4986	42	.	.	.
18637	4987	1	Instead	instead	RB
18637	4987	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4987	3	defined	define	VBD
18637	4987	4	production	production	NN
18637	4987	5	as	as	IN
18637	4987	6	a	a	DT
18637	4987	7	physical	physical	JJ
18637	4987	8	process	process	NN
18637	4987	9	.	.	.
18637	4988	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4988	2	said	say	VBD
18637	4988	3	in	in	IN
18637	4988	4	§	§	NNP
18637	4988	5	3	3	CD
18637	4988	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4988	7	j	j	NNP
18637	4988	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4988	9	'	'	''
18637	4988	10	Produced	produce	VBN
18637	4988	11	means	mean	NNS
18637	4988	12	produced	produce	VBN
18637	4988	13	,	,	,
18637	4988	14	manufactured	manufacture	VBN
18637	4988	15	,	,	,
18637	4988	16	mined	mine	VBN
18637	4988	17	,	,	,
18637	4988	18	handled	handle	VBD
18637	4988	19	,	,	,
18637	4988	20	or	or	CC
18637	4988	21	in	in	IN
18637	4988	22	any	any	DT
18637	4988	23	other	other	JJ
18637	4988	24	manner	manner	NN
18637	4988	25	worked	work	VBD
18637	4988	26	on	on	IN
18637	4988	27	'	'	''
18637	4988	28	and	and	CC
18637	4988	29	declared	declare	VBD
18637	4988	30	that	that	IN
18637	4988	31	those	those	DT
18637	4988	32	who	who	WP
18637	4988	33	participate	participate	VBP
18637	4988	34	in	in	IN
18637	4988	35	any	any	DT
18637	4988	36	of	of	IN
18637	4988	37	these	these	DT
18637	4988	38	processes	process	NNS
18637	4988	39	'	'	POS
18637	4988	40	or	or	CC
18637	4988	41	in	in	IN
18637	4988	42	any	any	DT
18637	4988	43	process	process	NN
18637	4988	44	or	or	CC
18637	4988	45	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	4988	46	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	4988	47	to	to	IN
18637	4988	48	'	'	''
18637	4988	49	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	4988	50	are	be	VBP
18637	4988	51	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4988	52	in	in	IN
18637	4988	53	production	production	NN
18637	4988	54	and	and	CC
18637	4988	55	subject	subject	NN
18637	4988	56	to	to	IN
18637	4988	57	the	the	DT
18637	4988	58	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4988	59	.	.	.
18637	4988	60	"	"	''
18637	4989	1	325	325	CD
18637	4989	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4989	3	679	679	CD
18637	4989	4	,	,	,
18637	4989	5	685	685	CD
18637	4989	6	.	.	.
18637	4990	1	On	on	IN
18637	4990	2	the	the	DT
18637	4990	3	other	other	JJ
18637	4990	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	4990	5	,	,	,
18637	4990	6	the	the	DT
18637	4990	7	holding	holding	NN
18637	4990	8	in	in	IN
18637	4990	9	10	10	CD
18637	4990	10	East	East	NNP
18637	4990	11	40th	40th	NNP
18637	4990	12	St.	St.	NNP
18637	4990	13	,	,	,
18637	4990	14	above	above	RB
18637	4990	15	,	,	,
18637	4990	16	was	be	VBD
18637	4990	17	a	a	DT
18637	4990	18	five	five	CD
18637	4990	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	4990	20	to	to	IN
18637	4990	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	4990	22	four	four	CD
18637	4990	23	decision	decision	NN
18637	4990	24	,	,	,
18637	4990	25	and	and	CC
18637	4990	26	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	4990	27	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	4990	28	,	,	,
18637	4990	29	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	4990	30	for	for	IN
18637	4990	31	the	the	DT
18637	4990	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4990	33	took	take	VBD
18637	4990	34	pains	pain	NNS
18637	4990	35	to	to	TO
18637	4990	36	explain	explain	VB
18637	4990	37	that	that	IN
18637	4990	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	4990	39	in	in	IN
18637	4990	40	enacting	enact	VBG
18637	4990	41	the	the	DT
18637	4990	42	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	4990	43	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	4990	44	Standards	Standards	NNP
18637	4990	45	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4990	46	,	,	,
18637	4990	47	"	"	``
18637	4990	48	did	do	VBD
18637	4990	49	not	not	RB
18637	4990	50	see	see	VB
18637	4990	51	fit	fit	NNP
18637	4990	52	,	,	,
18637	4990	53	*	*	NFP
18637	4990	54	*	*	NFP
18637	4990	55	*	*	NFP
18637	4990	56	,	,	,
18637	4990	57	to	to	TO
18637	4990	58	exhaust	exhaust	VB
18637	4990	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	4990	60	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	4990	61	power	power	NN
18637	4990	62	over	over	IN
18637	4990	63	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4990	64	.	.	.
18637	4990	65	"	"	''
18637	4991	1	325	325	CD
18637	4991	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4991	3	578	578	CD
18637	4991	4	-	-	SYM
18637	4991	5	579	579	CD
18637	4991	6	.	.	.
18637	4992	1	_	_	NNP
18637	4992	2	See	See	NNP
18637	4992	3	_	_	NNP
18637	4992	4	87	87	CD
18637	4992	5	Law	Law	NNP
18637	4992	6	Ed	Ed	NNP
18637	4992	7	.	.	.
18637	4993	1	pp	pp	NNP
18637	4993	2	.	.	.
18637	4994	1	87	87	CD
18637	4994	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4994	3	105	105	CD
18637	4994	4	for	for	IN
18637	4994	5	a	a	DT
18637	4994	6	note	note	NN
18637	4994	7	reviewing	review	VBG
18637	4994	8	both	both	CC
18637	4994	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	4994	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4994	11	,	,	,
18637	4994	12	lower	low	JJR
18637	4994	13	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	4994	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	4994	15	,	,	,
18637	4994	16	and	and	CC
18637	4994	17	State	state	NN
18637	4994	18	court	court	NN
18637	4994	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	4994	20	defining	define	VBG
18637	4994	21	"	"	``
18637	4994	22	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	4994	23	in	in	IN
18637	4994	24	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	4994	25	"	"	''
18637	4994	26	as	as	IN
18637	4994	27	that	that	DT
18637	4994	28	term	term	NN
18637	4994	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	4994	30	used	use	VBN
18637	4994	31	in	in	IN
18637	4994	32	the	the	DT
18637	4994	33	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	4994	34	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	4994	35	Standards	Standards	NNP
18637	4994	36	Act	Act	NNP
18637	4994	37	.	.	.
18637	4995	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4995	2	466	466	CD
18637	4995	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4995	4	50	50	CD
18637	4995	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	4995	6	.	.	.
18637	4996	1	246	246	CD
18637	4996	2	.	.	.
18637	4997	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4997	2	467	467	CD
18637	4997	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4997	4	315	315	CD
18637	4997	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	4997	6	110	110	CD
18637	4997	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	4997	8	1942	1942	CD
18637	4997	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	4997	10	.	.	.
18637	4998	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	4998	2	468	468	CD
18637	4998	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	4998	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	4998	5	.	.	.
18637	4999	1	118	118	CD
18637	4999	2	-	-	SYM
18637	4999	3	119	119	CD
18637	4999	4	.	.	.
18637	5000	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5000	2	469	469	CD
18637	5000	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5000	4	317	317	CD
18637	5000	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5000	6	111	111	CD
18637	5000	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5000	8	1942	1942	CD
18637	5000	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5000	10	.	.	.
18637	5001	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5001	2	470	470	CD
18637	5001	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5001	4	52	52	CD
18637	5001	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5001	6	.	.	.
18637	5002	1	31	31	CD
18637	5002	2	.	.	.
18637	5003	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5003	2	471	471	CD
18637	5003	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5003	4	317	317	CD
18637	5003	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5003	6	at	at	IN
18637	5003	7	128	128	CD
18637	5003	8	-	-	SYM
18637	5003	9	129	129	CD
18637	5003	10	.	.	.
18637	5004	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5004	2	472	472	CD
18637	5004	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5004	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5004	5	.	.	.
18637	5005	1	120	120	CD
18637	5005	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5005	3	124	124	CD
18637	5005	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5005	5	passim	passim	NN
18637	5005	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5005	7	.	.	.
18637	5006	1	In	in	IN
18637	5006	2	United	United	NNP
18637	5006	3	States	States	NNP
18637	5006	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5006	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	5006	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5006	7	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	5006	8	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	5006	9	Co	Co	NNP
18637	5006	10	-	-	NN
18637	5006	11	operative	operative	NNP
18637	5006	12	,	,	,
18637	5006	13	307	307	CD
18637	5006	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5006	15	533	533	CD
18637	5006	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5006	17	1939	1939	CD
18637	5006	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5006	19	,	,	,
18637	5006	20	the	the	DT
18637	5006	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5006	22	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	5006	23	an	an	DT
18637	5006	24	order	order	NN
18637	5006	25	under	under	IN
18637	5006	26	the	the	DT
18637	5006	27	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	5006	28	Marketing	Marketing	NNP
18637	5006	29	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	5006	30	Act	Act	NNP
18637	5006	31	of	of	IN
18637	5006	32	1937	1937	CD
18637	5006	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5006	34	50	50	CD
18637	5006	35	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5006	36	.	.	.
18637	5007	1	752	752	CD
18637	5007	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5007	3	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	5007	4	the	the	DT
18637	5007	5	price	price	NN
18637	5007	6	of	of	IN
18637	5007	7	milk	milk	NN
18637	5007	8	in	in	IN
18637	5007	9	certain	certain	JJ
18637	5007	10	instances	instance	NNS
18637	5007	11	.	.	.
18637	5008	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	5008	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5008	3	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	5008	4	for	for	IN
18637	5008	5	the	the	DT
18637	5008	6	majority	majority	NN
18637	5008	7	of	of	IN
18637	5008	8	the	the	DT
18637	5008	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5008	10	:	:	:
18637	5008	11	"	"	``
18637	5008	12	The	the	DT
18637	5008	13	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	5008	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	5008	15	to	to	IN
18637	5008	16	the	the	DT
18637	5008	17	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	5008	18	'	'	''
18637	5008	19	of	of	IN
18637	5008	20	the	the	DT
18637	5008	21	price	price	NN
18637	5008	22	to	to	TO
18637	5008	23	be	be	VB
18637	5008	24	paid	pay	VBN
18637	5008	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	5008	26	the	the	DT
18637	5008	27	sale	sale	NN
18637	5008	28	by	by	IN
18637	5008	29	a	a	DT
18637	5008	30	dairy	dairy	NN
18637	5008	31	farmer	farmer	NN
18637	5008	32	who	who	WP
18637	5008	33	delivers	deliver	VBZ
18637	5008	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5008	35	milk	milk	NN
18637	5008	36	to	to	IN
18637	5008	37	some	some	DT
18637	5008	38	country	country	NN
18637	5008	39	plant	plant	NN
18637	5008	40	.	.	.
18637	5008	41	'	'	''
18637	5009	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5009	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	5009	3	urged	urge	VBN
18637	5009	4	that	that	IN
18637	5009	5	the	the	DT
18637	5009	6	sale	sale	NN
18637	5009	7	,	,	,
18637	5009	8	a	a	DT
18637	5009	9	local	local	JJ
18637	5009	10	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	5009	11	,	,	,
18637	5009	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	5009	13	fully	fully	RB
18637	5009	14	completed	complete	VBN
18637	5009	15	before	before	IN
18637	5009	16	any	any	DT
18637	5009	17	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5009	18	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5009	19	begins	begin	VBZ
18637	5009	20	and	and	CC
18637	5009	21	that	that	IN
18637	5009	22	the	the	DT
18637	5009	23	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	5009	24	to	to	TO
18637	5009	25	fix	fix	VB
18637	5009	26	the	the	DT
18637	5009	27	price	price	NN
18637	5009	28	or	or	CC
18637	5009	29	other	other	JJ
18637	5009	30	elements	element	NNS
18637	5009	31	of	of	IN
18637	5009	32	that	that	DT
18637	5009	33	incident	incident	NN
18637	5009	34	violates	violate	VBZ
18637	5009	35	the	the	DT
18637	5009	36	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	5009	37	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	5009	38	.	.	.
18637	5010	1	But	but	CC
18637	5010	2	where	where	WRB
18637	5010	3	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	5010	4	are	be	VBP
18637	5010	5	bought	buy	VBN
18637	5010	6	for	for	IN
18637	5010	7	use	use	NN
18637	5010	8	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	5010	9	State	State	NNP
18637	5010	10	lines	line	NNS
18637	5010	11	,	,	,
18637	5010	12	the	the	DT
18637	5010	13	sale	sale	NN
18637	5010	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	5010	15	a	a	DT
18637	5010	16	part	part	NN
18637	5010	17	of	of	IN
18637	5010	18	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5010	19	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5010	20	.	.	.
18637	5011	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5011	2	have	have	VBP
18637	5011	3	likewise	likewise	RB
18637	5011	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	5011	5	that	that	IN
18637	5011	6	where	where	WRB
18637	5011	7	sales	sale	NNS
18637	5011	8	for	for	IN
18637	5011	9	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5011	10	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	5011	11	were	be	VBD
18637	5011	12	commingled	commingle	VBN
18637	5011	13	with	with	IN
18637	5011	14	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	5011	15	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	5011	16	,	,	,
18637	5011	17	the	the	DT
18637	5011	18	existence	existence	NN
18637	5011	19	of	of	IN
18637	5011	20	the	the	DT
18637	5011	21	local	local	JJ
18637	5011	22	activity	activity	NN
18637	5011	23	did	do	VBD
18637	5011	24	not	not	RB
18637	5011	25	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	5011	26	with	with	IN
18637	5011	27	the	the	DT
18637	5011	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	5011	29	power	power	NN
18637	5011	30	to	to	TO
18637	5011	31	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5011	32	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	5011	33	of	of	IN
18637	5011	34	the	the	DT
18637	5011	35	whole	whole	NN
18637	5011	36	.	.	.
18637	5012	1	Activities	activity	NNS
18637	5012	2	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	5012	3	within	within	IN
18637	5012	4	the	the	DT
18637	5012	5	State	State	NNP
18637	5012	6	lines	line	NNS
18637	5012	7	do	do	VBP
18637	5012	8	not	not	RB
18637	5012	9	by	by	IN
18637	5012	10	this	this	DT
18637	5012	11	fact	fact	NN
18637	5012	12	alone	alone	RB
18637	5012	13	escape	escape	VB
18637	5012	14	the	the	DT
18637	5012	15	sweep	sweep	NN
18637	5012	16	of	of	IN
18637	5012	17	the	the	DT
18637	5012	18	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	5012	19	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	5012	20	.	.	.
18637	5013	1	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	5013	2	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5013	3	may	may	MD
18637	5013	4	be	be	VB
18637	5013	5	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	5013	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	5013	7	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5013	8	.	.	.
18637	5014	1	Power	power	NN
18637	5014	2	to	to	TO
18637	5014	3	establish	establish	VB
18637	5014	4	quotas	quota	NNS
18637	5014	5	for	for	IN
18637	5014	6	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5014	7	marketing	marketing	NN
18637	5014	8	gives	give	VBZ
18637	5014	9	power	power	NN
18637	5014	10	to	to	TO
18637	5014	11	name	name	VB
18637	5014	12	quotas	quota	NNS
18637	5014	13	for	for	IN
18637	5014	14	that	that	DT
18637	5014	15	which	which	WDT
18637	5014	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	5014	17	to	to	TO
18637	5014	18	be	be	VB
18637	5014	19	left	leave	VBN
18637	5014	20	within	within	IN
18637	5014	21	the	the	DT
18637	5014	22	State	State	NNP
18637	5014	23	of	of	IN
18637	5014	24	production	production	NN
18637	5014	25	.	.	.
18637	5015	1	Where	where	WRB
18637	5015	2	local	local	JJ
18637	5015	3	and	and	CC
18637	5015	4	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	5015	5	milk	milk	NN
18637	5015	6	alike	alike	RB
18637	5015	7	are	be	VBP
18637	5015	8	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	5015	9	into	into	IN
18637	5015	10	a	a	DT
18637	5015	11	general	general	JJ
18637	5015	12	plan	plan	NN
18637	5015	13	for	for	IN
18637	5015	14	protecting	protect	VBG
18637	5015	15	the	the	DT
18637	5015	16	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5015	17	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5015	18	in	in	IN
18637	5015	19	the	the	DT
18637	5015	20	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	5015	21	from	from	IN
18637	5015	22	the	the	DT
18637	5015	23	interferences	interference	NNS
18637	5015	24	,	,	,
18637	5015	25	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	5015	26	and	and	CC
18637	5015	27	obstructions	obstruction	NNS
18637	5015	28	,	,	,
18637	5015	29	arising	arise	VBG
18637	5015	30	from	from	IN
18637	5015	31	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	5015	32	surplus	surplus	NN
18637	5015	33	and	and	CC
18637	5015	34	the	the	DT
18637	5015	35	social	social	JJ
18637	5015	36	and	and	CC
18637	5015	37	sanitary	sanitary	JJ
18637	5015	38	evils	evil	NNS
18637	5015	39	of	of	IN
18637	5015	40	low	low	JJ
18637	5015	41	values	value	NNS
18637	5015	42	,	,	,
18637	5015	43	the	the	DT
18637	5015	44	power	power	NN
18637	5015	45	of	of	IN
18637	5015	46	the	the	DT
18637	5015	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5015	48	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	5015	49	also	also	RB
18637	5015	50	to	to	IN
18637	5015	51	the	the	DT
18637	5015	52	local	local	JJ
18637	5015	53	sales	sale	NNS
18637	5015	54	.	.	.
18637	5015	55	"	"	''
18637	5015	56	'	'	''
18637	5016	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	5016	2	.	.	.
18637	5017	1	568	568	CD
18637	5017	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5017	3	569	569	CD
18637	5017	4	.	.	.
18637	5018	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5018	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5018	3	also	also	RB
18637	5018	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5018	5	H.P.	H.P.	NNP
18637	5019	1	Hood	Hood	NNP
18637	5019	2	&	&	CC
18637	5019	3	Sons	Sons	NNPS
18637	5019	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5019	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	5019	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5019	7	United	United	NNP
18637	5019	8	States	States	NNP
18637	5019	9	,	,	,
18637	5019	10	307	307	CD
18637	5019	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5019	12	588	588	CD
18637	5019	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5019	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	5019	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5019	16	,	,	,
18637	5019	17	another	another	DT
18637	5019	18	milk	milk	NN
18637	5019	19	case	case	NN
18637	5019	20	;	;	,
18637	5019	21	and	and	CC
18637	5019	22	Mulford	Mulford	NNP
18637	5019	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5019	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	5019	25	_	_	NNP
18637	5019	26	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	5019	27	,	,	,
18637	5019	28	307	307	CD
18637	5019	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5019	30	38	38	CD
18637	5019	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5019	32	1939	1939	CD
18637	5019	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5019	34	,	,	,
18637	5019	35	in	in	IN
18637	5019	36	which	which	WDT
18637	5019	37	certain	certain	JJ
18637	5019	38	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	5019	39	on	on	IN
18637	5019	40	the	the	DT
18637	5019	41	sale	sale	NN
18637	5019	42	of	of	IN
18637	5019	43	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	5019	44	,	,	,
18637	5019	45	under	under	IN
18637	5019	46	the	the	DT
18637	5019	47	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	5019	48	Adjustment	Adjustment	NNP
18637	5019	49	Act	Act	NNP
18637	5019	50	of	of	IN
18637	5019	51	1938	1938	CD
18637	5019	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5019	53	52	52	CD
18637	5019	54	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5019	55	.	.	.
18637	5020	1	31	31	CD
18637	5020	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5020	3	,	,	,
18637	5020	4	were	be	VBD
18637	5020	5	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	5020	6	in	in	IN
18637	5020	7	an	an	DT
18637	5020	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	5020	9	by	by	IN
18637	5020	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5020	11	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	5020	12	,	,	,
18637	5020	13	who	who	WP
18637	5020	14	spoke	speak	VBD
18637	5020	15	for	for	IN
18637	5020	16	the	the	DT
18637	5020	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5020	18	in	in	IN
18637	5020	19	the	the	DT
18637	5020	20	latter	latter	JJ
18637	5020	21	case	case	NN
18637	5020	22	.	.	.
18637	5021	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5021	2	473	473	CD
18637	5021	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5021	4	United	United	NNP
18637	5021	5	States	States	NNP
18637	5021	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5021	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5021	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5021	9	The	the	DT
18637	5021	10	William	William	NNP
18637	5021	11	,	,	,
18637	5021	12	28	28	CD
18637	5021	13	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	5021	14	.	.	.
18637	5022	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	5022	2	.	.	.
18637	5023	1	No	no	UH
18637	5023	2	.	.	.
18637	5024	1	16,700	16,700	CD
18637	5024	2	,	,	,
18637	5024	3	614	614	CD
18637	5024	4	,	,	,
18637	5024	5	620	620	CD
18637	5024	6	-	-	SYM
18637	5024	7	623	623	CD
18637	5024	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5024	9	passim	passim	NN
18637	5024	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5024	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5024	12	1808	1808	CD
18637	5024	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5024	14	.	.	.
18637	5025	1	Other	other	JJ
18637	5025	2	parts	part	NNS
18637	5025	3	of	of	IN
18637	5025	4	this	this	DT
18637	5025	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	5025	6	are	be	VBP
18637	5025	7	considered	consider	VBN
18637	5025	8	below	below	RB
18637	5025	9	in	in	IN
18637	5025	10	connection	connection	NN
18637	5025	11	with	with	IN
18637	5025	12	the	the	DT
18637	5025	13	prohibiting	prohibiting	NN
18637	5025	14	of	of	IN
18637	5025	15	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5025	16	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	5025	17	.	.	.
18637	5026	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5026	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5026	3	also	also	RB
18637	5026	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5026	5	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	5026	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5026	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5026	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5026	9	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	5026	10	,	,	,
18637	5026	11	9	9	CD
18637	5026	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5026	13	.	.	.
18637	5027	1	1	1	CD
18637	5027	2	,	,	,
18637	5027	3	191	191	CD
18637	5027	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5027	5	1824	1824	CD
18637	5027	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5027	7	;	;	:
18637	5027	8	United	United	NNP
18637	5027	9	States	States	NNP
18637	5027	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5027	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	5027	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5027	13	Marigold	Marigold	NNP
18637	5027	14	,	,	,
18637	5027	15	9	9	CD
18637	5027	16	How	how	WRB
18637	5027	17	.	.	.
18637	5028	1	560	560	CD
18637	5028	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5028	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	5028	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5028	5	.	.	.
18637	5029	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5029	2	474	474	CD
18637	5029	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5029	4	289	289	CD
18637	5029	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5029	6	48	48	CD
18637	5029	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5029	8	1933	1933	CD
18637	5029	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5029	10	.	.	.
18637	5030	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5030	2	475	475	CD
18637	5030	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5030	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5030	5	.	.	.
18637	5031	1	57	57	CD
18637	5031	2	,	,	,
18637	5031	3	58	58	CD
18637	5031	4	.	.	.
18637	5032	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5032	2	476	476	CD
18637	5032	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5032	4	5	5	CD
18637	5032	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5032	6	.	.	.
18637	5033	1	566	566	CD
18637	5033	2	§	â§	SYM
18637	5033	3	28	28	CD
18637	5033	4	.	.	.
18637	5034	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5034	2	477	477	CD
18637	5034	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5034	4	9	9	CD
18637	5034	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5034	6	.	.	.
18637	5035	1	237	237	CD
18637	5035	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5035	3	1848	1848	CD
18637	5035	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5035	5	.	.	.
18637	5036	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5036	2	478	478	CD
18637	5036	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5036	4	24	24	CD
18637	5036	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5036	6	.	.	.
18637	5037	1	409	409	CD
18637	5037	2	.	.	.
18637	5038	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5038	2	479	479	CD
18637	5038	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5038	4	35	35	CD
18637	5038	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5038	6	.	.	.
18637	5039	1	614	614	CD
18637	5039	2	;	;	:
18637	5039	3	38	38	CD
18637	5039	4	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	5039	5	.	.	.
18637	5040	1	275	275	CD
18637	5040	2	.	.	.
18637	5041	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5041	2	480	480	CD
18637	5041	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5041	4	29	29	CD
18637	5041	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	5041	6	.	.	.
18637	5042	1	605	605	CD
18637	5042	2	.	.	.
18637	5043	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5043	2	481	481	CD
18637	5043	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5043	4	192	192	CD
18637	5043	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5043	6	470	470	CD
18637	5043	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5043	8	1904	1904	CD
18637	5043	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5043	10	.	.	.
18637	5044	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5044	2	482	482	CD
18637	5044	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5044	4	223	223	CD
18637	5044	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5044	6	166	166	CD
18637	5044	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5044	8	1912	1912	CD
18637	5044	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5044	10	;	;	:
18637	5044	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5044	12	cf	cf	NNP
18637	5044	13	.	.	.
18637	5044	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5044	15	United	United	NNP
18637	5044	16	States	States	NNP
18637	5044	17	_	_	NNP
18637	5044	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	5044	19	_	_	NNP
18637	5044	20	California	California	NNP
18637	5044	21	,	,	,
18637	5044	22	332	332	CD
18637	5044	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5044	24	19	19	CD
18637	5044	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5044	26	1947	1947	CD
18637	5044	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5044	28	.	.	.
18637	5045	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5045	2	483	483	CD
18637	5045	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5045	4	239	239	CD
18637	5045	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5045	6	325	325	CD
18637	5045	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5045	8	1915	1915	CD
18637	5045	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5045	10	.	.	.
18637	5046	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5046	2	484	484	CD
18637	5046	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5046	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5046	5	.	.	.
18637	5047	1	329	329	CD
18637	5047	2	.	.	.
18637	5048	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5048	2	485	485	CD
18637	5048	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5048	4	236	236	CD
18637	5048	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5048	6	216	216	CD
18637	5048	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5048	8	1915	1915	CD
18637	5048	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5048	10	.	.	.
18637	5049	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5049	2	486	486	CD
18637	5049	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5049	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5049	5	.	.	.
18637	5050	1	222	222	CD
18637	5050	2	.	.	.
18637	5051	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5051	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5051	3	also	also	RB
18637	5051	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5051	5	Robert	Robert	NNP
18637	5051	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	5051	7	Cushman	Cushman	NNP
18637	5051	8	,	,	,
18637	5051	9	National	National	NNP
18637	5051	10	Police	Police	NNP
18637	5051	11	Power	Power	NNP
18637	5051	12	Under	under	IN
18637	5051	13	the	the	DT
18637	5051	14	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	5051	15	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	5051	16	,	,	,
18637	5051	17	3	3	CD
18637	5051	18	Selected	select	VBN
18637	5051	19	Essays	essay	NNS
18637	5051	20	on	on	IN
18637	5051	21	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	5051	22	Law	Law	NNP
18637	5051	23	,	,	,
18637	5051	24	62	62	CD
18637	5051	25	-	-	SYM
18637	5051	26	79	79	CD
18637	5051	27	.	.	.
18637	5052	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5052	2	487	487	CD
18637	5052	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5052	4	Groves	Groves	NNP
18637	5052	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5052	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5052	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5052	8	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	5052	9	,	,	,
18637	5052	10	15	15	CD
18637	5052	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	5052	12	.	.	.
18637	5053	1	449	449	CD
18637	5053	2	,	,	,
18637	5053	3	488	488	CD
18637	5053	4	-	-	SYM
18637	5053	5	489	489	CD
18637	5053	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5053	7	1841	1841	CD
18637	5053	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5053	9	.	.	.
18637	5054	1	The	the	DT
18637	5054	2	Issue	issue	NN
18637	5054	3	A	a	DT
18637	5054	4	little	little	JJ
18637	5054	5	reflection	reflection	NN
18637	5054	6	will	will	MD
18637	5054	7	suffice	suffice	VB
18637	5054	8	to	to	TO
18637	5054	9	show	show	VB
18637	5054	10	that	that	IN
18637	5054	11	,	,	,
18637	5054	12	as	as	IN
18637	5054	13	a	a	DT
18637	5054	14	matter	matter	NN
18637	5054	15	of	of	IN
18637	5054	16	fact	fact	NN
18637	5054	17	,	,	,
18637	5054	18	any	any	DT
18637	5054	19	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	5054	20	at	at	RB
18637	5054	21	all	all	DT
18637	5054	22	of	of	IN
18637	5054	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5054	24	implies	imply	VBZ
18637	5054	25	some	some	DT
18637	5054	26	measure	measure	NN
18637	5054	27	of	of	IN
18637	5054	28	power	power	NN
18637	5054	29	to	to	TO
18637	5054	30	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	5054	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5054	32	,	,	,
18637	5054	33	since	since	IN
18637	5054	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5054	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	5054	36	the	the	DT
18637	5054	37	very	very	JJ
18637	5054	38	nature	nature	NN
18637	5054	39	of	of	IN
18637	5054	40	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	5054	41	to	to	TO
18637	5054	42	lay	lay	VB
18637	5054	43	down	down	RP
18637	5054	44	terms	term	NNS
18637	5054	45	on	on	IN
18637	5054	46	which	which	WDT
18637	5054	47	the	the	DT
18637	5054	48	activity	activity	NN
18637	5054	49	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	5054	50	will	will	MD
18637	5054	51	be	be	VB
18637	5054	52	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	5054	53	and	and	CC
18637	5054	54	for	for	IN
18637	5054	55	noncompliance	noncompliance	NN
18637	5054	56	with	with	IN
18637	5054	57	which	which	WDT
18637	5054	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5054	59	will	will	MD
18637	5054	60	not	not	RB
18637	5054	61	be	be	VB
18637	5054	62	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	5054	63	.	.	.
18637	5055	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5055	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	5055	3	also	also	RB
18637	5055	4	evident	evident	JJ
18637	5055	5	that	that	IN
18637	5055	6	when	when	WRB
18637	5055	7	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	5055	8	does	do	VBZ
18637	5055	9	arise	arise	VB
18637	5055	10	for	for	IN
18637	5055	11	an	an	DT
18637	5055	12	outright	outright	JJ
18637	5055	13	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	5055	14	of	of	IN
18637	5055	15	an	an	DT
18637	5055	16	activity	activity	NN
18637	5055	17	,	,	,
18637	5055	18	the	the	DT
18637	5055	19	power	power	NN
18637	5055	20	to	to	TO
18637	5055	21	enact	enact	VB
18637	5055	22	the	the	DT
18637	5055	23	required	require	VBN
18637	5055	24	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	5055	25	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	5055	26	must	must	MD
18637	5055	27	belong	belong	VB
18637	5055	28	to	to	IN
18637	5055	29	the	the	DT
18637	5055	30	body	body	NN
18637	5055	31	which	which	WDT
18637	5055	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	5055	33	vested	vest	VBN
18637	5055	34	with	with	IN
18637	5055	35	authority	authority	NN
18637	5055	36	to	to	TO
18637	5055	37	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5055	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5055	39	,	,	,
18637	5055	40	which	which	WDT
18637	5055	41	in	in	IN
18637	5055	42	this	this	DT
18637	5055	43	instance	instance	NN
18637	5055	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	5055	45	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5055	46	.	.	.
18637	5056	1	What	what	WP
18637	5056	2	,	,	,
18637	5056	3	then	then	RB
18637	5056	4	,	,	,
18637	5056	5	are	be	VBP
18637	5056	6	the	the	DT
18637	5056	7	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	5056	8	differences	difference	NNS
18637	5056	9	between	between	IN
18637	5056	10	such	such	JJ
18637	5056	11	conditional	conditional	JJ
18637	5056	12	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
18637	5056	13	of	of	IN
18637	5056	14	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5056	15	and	and	CC
18637	5056	16	that	that	IN
18637	5056	17	with	with	IN
18637	5056	18	which	which	WDT
18637	5056	19	this	this	DT
18637	5056	20	rÃ	rÃ	NNP
18637	5056	21	©	©	NN
18637	5056	22	sumÃ	sumã	CD
18637	5056	23	©	©	NN
18637	5056	24	deals	deal	NNS
18637	5056	25	?	?	.
18637	5057	1	There	there	EX
18637	5057	2	seem	seem	VBP
18637	5057	3	to	to	TO
18637	5057	4	be	be	VB
18637	5057	5	three	three	CD
18637	5057	6	such	such	JJ
18637	5057	7	differences	difference	NNS
18637	5057	8	.	.	.
18637	5058	1	First	first	RB
18637	5058	2	,	,	,
18637	5058	3	there	there	EX
18637	5058	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	5058	5	often	often	RB
18637	5058	6	a	a	DT
18637	5058	7	difference	difference	NN
18637	5058	8	of	of	IN
18637	5058	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5058	10	modus	modus	NN
18637	5058	11	operandi	operandi	NNP
18637	5058	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5058	13	between	between	IN
18637	5058	14	the	the	DT
18637	5058	15	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	5058	16	already	already	RB
18637	5058	17	considered	consider	VBN
18637	5058	18	and	and	CC
18637	5058	19	those	those	DT
18637	5058	20	about	about	IN
18637	5058	21	to	to	TO
18637	5058	22	be	be	VB
18637	5058	23	considered	consider	VBN
18637	5058	24	.	.	.
18637	5059	1	The	the	DT
18637	5059	2	former	former	JJ
18637	5059	3	impinge	impinge	NN
18637	5059	4	upon	upon	IN
18637	5059	5	persons	person	NNS
18637	5059	6	or	or	CC
18637	5059	7	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	5059	8	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	5059	9	in	in	IN
18637	5059	10	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5059	11	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5059	12	and	and	CC
18637	5059	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5059	14	activities	activity	NNS
18637	5059	15	in	in	IN
18637	5059	16	connection	connection	NN
18637	5059	17	therewith	therewith	NN
18637	5059	18	,	,	,
18637	5059	19	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	5059	20	the	the	DT
18637	5059	21	latter	latter	JJ
18637	5059	22	look	look	NN
18637	5059	23	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	5059	24	to	to	IN
18637	5059	25	things	thing	NNS
18637	5059	26	,	,	,
18637	5059	27	or	or	CC
18637	5059	28	the	the	DT
18637	5059	29	subject	subject	JJ
18637	5059	30	matter	matter	NN
18637	5059	31	,	,	,
18637	5059	32	of	of	IN
18637	5059	33	the	the	DT
18637	5059	34	trade	trade	NN
18637	5059	35	or	or	CC
18637	5059	36	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5059	37	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	5059	38	.	.	.
18637	5060	1	Secondly	secondly	RB
18637	5060	2	,	,	,
18637	5060	3	there	there	EX
18637	5060	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	5060	5	a	a	DT
18637	5060	6	difference	difference	NN
18637	5060	7	in	in	IN
18637	5060	8	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	5060	9	between	between	IN
18637	5060	10	the	the	DT
18637	5060	11	two	two	CD
18637	5060	12	categories	category	NNS
18637	5060	13	of	of	IN
18637	5060	14	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	5060	15	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	5060	16	.	.	.
18637	5061	1	The	the	DT
18637	5061	2	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	5061	3	of	of	IN
18637	5061	4	the	the	DT
18637	5061	5	acts	act	NNS
18637	5061	6	already	already	RB
18637	5061	7	treated	treat	VBN
18637	5061	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	5061	9	to	to	TO
18637	5061	10	lay	lay	VB
18637	5061	11	down	down	RP
18637	5061	12	the	the	DT
18637	5061	13	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	5061	14	on	on	IN
18637	5061	15	which	which	WDT
18637	5061	16	a	a	DT
18637	5061	17	designated	designate	VBN
18637	5061	18	branch	branch	NN
18637	5061	19	of	of	IN
18637	5061	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5061	21	among	among	IN
18637	5061	22	the	the	DT
18637	5061	23	States	States	NNPS
18637	5061	24	may	may	MD
18637	5061	25	be	be	VB
18637	5061	26	carried	carry	VBN
18637	5061	27	on	on	IN
18637	5061	28	;	;	:
18637	5061	29	that	that	DT
18637	5061	30	of	of	IN
18637	5061	31	the	the	DT
18637	5061	32	acts	act	NNS
18637	5061	33	now	now	RB
18637	5061	34	to	to	TO
18637	5061	35	be	be	VB
18637	5061	36	treated	treat	VBN
18637	5061	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	5061	38	to	to	TO
18637	5061	39	eliminate	eliminate	VB
18637	5061	40	outright	outright	RB
18637	5061	41	a	a	DT
18637	5061	42	designated	designate	VBN
18637	5061	43	branch	branch	NN
18637	5061	44	of	of	IN
18637	5061	45	trade	trade	NN
18637	5061	46	among	among	IN
18637	5061	47	the	the	DT
18637	5061	48	States	States	NNP
18637	5061	49	.	.	.
18637	5062	1	In	in	IN
18637	5062	2	other	other	JJ
18637	5062	3	words	word	NNS
18637	5062	4	,	,	,
18637	5062	5	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	5062	6	the	the	DT
18637	5062	7	former	former	JJ
18637	5062	8	acts	act	NNS
18637	5062	9	were	be	VBD
18637	5062	10	,	,	,
18637	5062	11	in	in	IN
18637	5062	12	general	general	JJ
18637	5062	13	,	,	,
18637	5062	14	preservative	preservative	JJ
18637	5062	15	of	of	IN
18637	5062	16	the	the	DT
18637	5062	17	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5062	18	which	which	WDT
18637	5062	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5062	20	regulated	regulate	VBD
18637	5062	21	because	because	IN
18637	5062	22	of	of	IN
18637	5062	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5062	24	value	value	NN
18637	5062	25	to	to	IN
18637	5062	26	society	society	NN
18637	5062	27	,	,	,
18637	5062	28	the	the	DT
18637	5062	29	latter	latter	JJ
18637	5062	30	regard	regard	NN
18637	5062	31	the	the	DT
18637	5062	32	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5062	33	which	which	WDT
18637	5062	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5062	35	reach	reach	VBP
18637	5062	36	as	as	IN
18637	5062	37	detrimental	detrimental	JJ
18637	5062	38	to	to	IN
18637	5062	39	society	society	NN
18637	5062	40	.	.	.
18637	5063	1	The	the	DT
18637	5063	2	third	third	JJ
18637	5063	3	,	,	,
18637	5063	4	and	and	CC
18637	5063	5	most	most	RBS
18637	5063	6	important	important	JJ
18637	5063	7	difference	difference	NN
18637	5063	8	from	from	IN
18637	5063	9	the	the	DT
18637	5063	10	point	point	NN
18637	5063	11	of	of	IN
18637	5063	12	view	view	NN
18637	5063	13	of	of	IN
18637	5063	14	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	5063	15	Law	Law	NNP
18637	5063	16	,	,	,
18637	5063	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	5063	18	the	the	DT
18637	5063	19	difference	difference	NN
18637	5063	20	in	in	IN
18637	5063	21	relation	relation	NN
18637	5063	22	of	of	IN
18637	5063	23	the	the	DT
18637	5063	24	two	two	CD
18637	5063	25	categories	category	NNS
18637	5063	26	of	of	IN
18637	5063	27	acts	act	NNS
18637	5063	28	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	5063	29	to	to	IN
18637	5063	30	the	the	DT
18637	5063	31	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	5063	32	powers	power	NNS
18637	5063	33	of	of	IN
18637	5063	34	the	the	DT
18637	5063	35	States	States	NNP
18637	5063	36	.	.	.
18637	5064	1	The	the	DT
18637	5064	2	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	5064	3	of	of	IN
18637	5064	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5064	5	already	already	RB
18637	5064	6	dealt	deal	VBD
18637	5064	7	with	with	IN
18637	5064	8	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	5064	9	intrude	intrude	VB
18637	5064	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	5064	11	the	the	DT
18637	5064	12	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	5064	13	field	field	NN
18637	5064	14	of	of	IN
18637	5064	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	5064	16	of	of	IN
18637	5064	17	the	the	DT
18637	5064	18	States	States	NNPS
18637	5064	19	;	;	:
18637	5064	20	but	but	CC
18637	5064	21	when	when	WRB
18637	5064	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5064	23	do	do	VBP
18637	5064	24	so	so	RB
18637	5064	25	,	,	,
18637	5064	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5064	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	5064	28	because	because	IN
18637	5064	29	the	the	DT
18637	5064	30	acts	act	NNS
18637	5064	31	or	or	CC
18637	5064	32	things	thing	NNS
18637	5064	33	which	which	WDT
18637	5064	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5064	35	thus	thus	RB
18637	5064	36	bring	bring	VBP
18637	5064	37	under	under	IN
18637	5064	38	national	national	JJ
18637	5064	39	control	control	NN
18637	5064	40	are	be	VBP
18637	5064	41	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	5064	42	as	as	IN
18637	5064	43	"	"	``
18637	5064	44	local	local	JJ
18637	5064	45	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	5064	46	"	"	''
18637	5064	47	of	of	IN
18637	5064	48	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5064	49	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	5064	50	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5064	51	.	.	.
18637	5065	1	The	the	DT
18637	5065	2	relation	relation	NN
18637	5065	3	of	of	IN
18637	5065	4	the	the	DT
18637	5065	5	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	5065	6	about	about	JJ
18637	5065	7	to	to	TO
18637	5065	8	be	be	VB
18637	5065	9	considered	consider	VBN
18637	5065	10	to	to	IN
18637	5065	11	the	the	DT
18637	5065	12	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	5065	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	5065	14	of	of	IN
18637	5065	15	the	the	DT
18637	5065	16	States	States	NNP
18637	5065	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	5065	18	precisely	precisely	RB
18637	5065	19	the	the	DT
18637	5065	20	inverse	inverse	NN
18637	5065	21	of	of	IN
18637	5065	22	this	this	DT
18637	5065	23	.	.	.
18637	5066	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5066	2	very	very	JJ
18637	5066	3	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	5066	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	5066	5	to	to	TO
18637	5066	6	reach	reach	VB
18637	5066	7	and	and	CC
18637	5066	8	control	control	NN
18637	5066	9	matters	matter	NNS
18637	5066	10	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	5066	11	governed	govern	VBN
18637	5066	12	by	by	IN
18637	5066	13	the	the	DT
18637	5066	14	State	State	NNP
18637	5066	15	's	's	POS
18637	5066	16	police	police	NN
18637	5066	17	power	power	NN
18637	5066	18	,	,	,
18637	5066	19	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	5066	20	in	in	IN
18637	5066	21	order	order	NN
18637	5066	22	to	to	TO
18637	5066	23	make	make	VB
18637	5066	24	State	state	NN
18637	5066	25	policy	policy	NN
18637	5066	26	more	more	RBR
18637	5066	27	effective	effective	JJ
18637	5066	28	,	,	,
18637	5066	29	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	5066	30	in	in	IN
18637	5066	31	order	order	NN
18637	5066	32	to	to	TO
18637	5066	33	supply	supply	VB
18637	5066	34	a	a	DT
18637	5066	35	corrective	corrective	NN
18637	5066	36	to	to	IN
18637	5066	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5066	38	.	.	.
18637	5067	1	The	the	DT
18637	5067	2	Argument	argument	NN
18637	5067	3	Denying	deny	VBG
18637	5067	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5067	5	'	'	POS
18637	5067	6	Power	power	NN
18637	5067	7	To	to	IN
18637	5067	8	Prohibit	Prohibit	NNP
18637	5067	9	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	5067	10	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	5067	11	The	the	DT
18637	5067	12	principal	principal	JJ
18637	5067	13	argument	argument	NN
18637	5067	14	against	against	IN
18637	5067	15	the	the	DT
18637	5067	16	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	5067	17	of	of	IN
18637	5067	18	prohibitory	prohibitory	JJ
18637	5067	19	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	5067	20	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	5067	21	pivoted	pivot	VBN
18637	5067	22	on	on	IN
18637	5067	23	the	the	DT
18637	5067	24	dual	dual	JJ
18637	5067	25	conception	conception	NN
18637	5067	26	of	of	IN
18637	5067	27	the	the	DT
18637	5067	28	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	5067	29	System	System	NNP
18637	5067	30	"	"	''
18637	5067	31	The	the	DT
18637	5067	32	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	5067	33	Equilibrium	Equilibrium	NNP
18637	5067	34	"	"	''
18637	5067	35	.	.	.
18637	5068	1	The	the	DT
18637	5068	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5068	3	,	,	,
18637	5068	4	the	the	DT
18637	5068	5	argument	argument	NN
18637	5068	6	ran	run	VBD
18637	5068	7	,	,	,
18637	5068	8	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	5068	9	contemplates	contemplate	VBZ
18637	5068	10	two	two	CD
18637	5068	11	spheres	sphere	NNS
18637	5068	12	of	of	IN
18637	5068	13	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	5068	14	activity	activity	NN
18637	5068	15	,	,	,
18637	5068	16	that	that	DT
18637	5068	17	of	of	IN
18637	5068	18	the	the	DT
18637	5068	19	States	States	NNPS
18637	5068	20	,	,	,
18637	5068	21	that	that	DT
18637	5068	22	of	of	IN
18637	5068	23	the	the	DT
18637	5068	24	United	United	NNP
18637	5068	25	States	States	NNP
18637	5068	26	;	;	:
18637	5068	27	and	and	CC
18637	5068	28	while	while	IN
18637	5068	29	the	the	DT
18637	5068	30	latter	latter	JJ
18637	5068	31	government	government	NN
18637	5068	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	5068	33	generally	generally	RB
18637	5068	34	supreme	supreme	JJ
18637	5068	35	when	when	WRB
18637	5068	36	the	the	DT
18637	5068	37	two	two	CD
18637	5068	38	collide	collide	NN
18637	5068	39	with	with	IN
18637	5068	40	one	one	NN
18637	5068	41	another	another	DT
18637	5068	42	in	in	IN
18637	5068	43	the	the	DT
18637	5068	44	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	5068	45	of	of	IN
18637	5068	46	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5068	47	respective	respective	JJ
18637	5068	48	powers	power	NNS
18637	5068	49	,	,	,
18637	5068	50	yet	yet	CC
18637	5068	51	collision	collision	NN
18637	5068	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	5068	53	not	not	RB
18637	5068	54	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
18637	5068	55	as	as	IN
18637	5068	56	the	the	DT
18637	5068	57	rule	rule	NN
18637	5068	58	of	of	IN
18637	5068	59	life	life	NN
18637	5068	60	of	of	IN
18637	5068	61	the	the	DT
18637	5068	62	system	system	NN
18637	5068	63	,	,	,
18637	5068	64	but	but	CC
18637	5068	65	the	the	DT
18637	5068	66	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	5068	67	.	.	.
18637	5069	1	And	and	CC
18637	5069	2	since	since	IN
18637	5069	3	there	there	EX
18637	5069	4	are	be	VBP
18637	5069	5	these	these	DT
18637	5069	6	two	two	CD
18637	5069	7	spheres	sphere	NNS
18637	5069	8	,	,	,
18637	5069	9	the	the	DT
18637	5069	10	line	line	NN
18637	5069	11	to	to	TO
18637	5069	12	be	be	VB
18637	5069	13	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	5069	14	between	between	IN
18637	5069	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5069	16	,	,	,
18637	5069	17	in	in	IN
18637	5069	18	order	order	NN
18637	5069	19	to	to	TO
18637	5069	20	secure	secure	VB
18637	5069	21	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	5069	22	instead	instead	RB
18637	5069	23	of	of	IN
18637	5069	24	collision	collision	NN
18637	5069	25	,	,	,
18637	5069	26	should	should	MD
18637	5069	27	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	5069	28	that	that	IN
18637	5069	29	the	the	DT
18637	5069	30	objects	object	NNS
18637	5069	31	which	which	WDT
18637	5069	32	the	the	DT
18637	5069	33	National	National	NNP
18637	5069	34	Government	Government	NNP
18637	5069	35	was	be	VBD
18637	5069	36	established	establish	VBN
18637	5069	37	to	to	TO
18637	5069	38	promote	promote	VB
18637	5069	39	are	be	VBP
18637	5069	40	relatively	relatively	RB
18637	5069	41	few	few	JJ
18637	5069	42	,	,	,
18637	5069	43	while	while	IN
18637	5069	44	those	those	DT
18637	5069	45	which	which	WDT
18637	5069	46	the	the	DT
18637	5069	47	States	States	NNPS
18637	5069	48	were	be	VBD
18637	5069	49	retained	retain	VBN
18637	5069	50	to	to	IN
18637	5069	51	advance	advance	NN
18637	5069	52	comprise	comprise	VB
18637	5069	53	the	the	DT
18637	5069	54	principal	principal	JJ
18637	5069	55	objectives	objective	NNS
18637	5069	56	of	of	IN
18637	5069	57	government	government	NN
18637	5069	58	,	,	,
18637	5069	59	the	the	DT
18637	5069	60	protection	protection	NN
18637	5069	61	of	of	IN
18637	5069	62	the	the	DT
18637	5069	63	public	public	JJ
18637	5069	64	health	health	NN
18637	5069	65	,	,	,
18637	5069	66	safety	safety	NN
18637	5069	67	,	,	,
18637	5069	68	morals	moral	NNS
18637	5069	69	,	,	,
18637	5069	70	and	and	CC
18637	5069	71	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	5069	72	.	.	.
18637	5070	1	The	the	DT
18637	5070	2	power	power	NN
18637	5070	3	to	to	TO
18637	5070	4	promote	promote	VB
18637	5070	5	these	these	DT
18637	5070	6	ends	end	NNS
18637	5070	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	5070	8	,	,	,
18637	5070	9	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	5070	10	,	,	,
18637	5070	11	the	the	DT
18637	5070	12	very	very	JJ
18637	5070	13	definition	definition	NN
18637	5070	14	of	of	IN
18637	5070	15	the	the	DT
18637	5070	16	police	police	NN
18637	5070	17	power	power	NN
18637	5070	18	of	of	IN
18637	5070	19	the	the	DT
18637	5070	20	States	States	NNPS
18637	5070	21	--	--	:
18637	5070	22	that	that	DT
18637	5070	23	power	power	NN
18637	5070	24	for	for	IN
18637	5070	25	which	which	WDT
18637	5070	26	all	all	DT
18637	5070	27	other	other	JJ
18637	5070	28	powers	power	NNS
18637	5070	29	of	of	IN
18637	5070	30	the	the	DT
18637	5070	31	States	state	NNS
18637	5070	32	exist	exist	VBP
18637	5070	33	.	.	.
18637	5071	1	Seriously	seriously	RB
18637	5071	2	to	to	TO
18637	5071	3	impair	impair	VB
18637	5071	4	the	the	DT
18637	5071	5	police	police	NN
18637	5071	6	power	power	NN
18637	5071	7	of	of	IN
18637	5071	8	the	the	DT
18637	5071	9	States	States	NNPS
18637	5071	10	,	,	,
18637	5071	11	or	or	CC
18637	5071	12	to	to	TO
18637	5071	13	diminish	diminish	VB
18637	5071	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5071	15	autonomy	autonomy	NN
18637	5071	16	in	in	IN
18637	5071	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5071	18	employment	employment	NN
18637	5071	19	,	,	,
18637	5071	20	would	would	MD
18637	5071	21	be	be	VB
18637	5071	22	,	,	,
18637	5071	23	in	in	IN
18637	5071	24	fact	fact	NN
18637	5071	25	to	to	TO
18637	5071	26	remove	remove	VB
18637	5071	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5071	28	reason	reason	NN
18637	5071	29	for	for	IN
18637	5071	30	being	being	NN
18637	5071	31	,	,	,
18637	5071	32	and	and	CC
18637	5071	33	so	so	RB
18637	5071	34	the	the	DT
18637	5071	35	reason	reason	NN
18637	5071	36	for	for	IN
18637	5071	37	the	the	DT
18637	5071	38	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	5071	39	System	System	NNP
18637	5071	40	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5071	41	.	.	.
18637	5072	1	So	so	CC
18637	5072	2	while	while	IN
18637	5072	3	the	the	DT
18637	5072	4	power	power	NN
18637	5072	5	of	of	IN
18637	5072	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5072	7	to	to	TO
18637	5072	8	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5072	9	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5072	10	among	among	IN
18637	5072	11	the	the	DT
18637	5072	12	States	States	NNP
18637	5072	13	and	and	CC
18637	5072	14	with	with	IN
18637	5072	15	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	5072	16	nations	nation	NNS
18637	5072	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	5072	18	in	in	IN
18637	5072	19	terms	term	NNS
18637	5072	20	a	a	DT
18637	5072	21	single	single	JJ
18637	5072	22	power	power	NN
18637	5072	23	,	,	,
18637	5072	24	in	in	IN
18637	5072	25	the	the	DT
18637	5072	26	intention	intention	NN
18637	5072	27	of	of	IN
18637	5072	28	the	the	DT
18637	5072	29	framers	framer	NNS
18637	5072	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5072	31	comprised	comprise	VBD
18637	5072	32	two	two	CD
18637	5072	33	very	very	RB
18637	5072	34	different	different	JJ
18637	5072	35	powers	power	NNS
18637	5072	36	.	.	.
18637	5073	1	In	in	IN
18637	5073	2	the	the	DT
18637	5073	3	field	field	NN
18637	5073	4	of	of	IN
18637	5073	5	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	5073	6	relations	relation	NNS
18637	5073	7	,	,	,
18637	5073	8	the	the	DT
18637	5073	9	National	National	NNP
18637	5073	10	Government	Government	NNP
18637	5073	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	5073	12	completely	completely	RB
18637	5073	13	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	5073	14	,	,	,
18637	5073	15	and	and	CC
18637	5073	16	the	the	DT
18637	5073	17	power	power	NN
18637	5073	18	to	to	TO
18637	5073	19	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5073	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5073	21	with	with	IN
18637	5073	22	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	5073	23	nations	nation	NNS
18637	5073	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	5073	25	but	but	CC
18637	5073	26	a	a	DT
18637	5073	27	branch	branch	NN
18637	5073	28	of	of	IN
18637	5073	29	this	this	DT
18637	5073	30	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	5073	31	power	power	NN
18637	5073	32	.	.	.
18637	5074	1	The	the	DT
18637	5074	2	power	power	NN
18637	5074	3	to	to	TO
18637	5074	4	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5074	5	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5074	6	among	among	IN
18637	5074	7	the	the	DT
18637	5074	8	States	States	NNP
18637	5074	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	5074	10	,	,	,
18637	5074	11	on	on	IN
18637	5074	12	the	the	DT
18637	5074	13	other	other	JJ
18637	5074	14	hand	hand	NN
18637	5074	15	,	,	,
18637	5074	16	not	not	RB
18637	5074	17	a	a	DT
18637	5074	18	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	5074	19	power	power	NN
18637	5074	20	except	except	IN
18637	5074	21	for	for	IN
18637	5074	22	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	5074	23	of	of	IN
18637	5074	24	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	5074	25	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	5074	26	;	;	:
18637	5074	27	in	in	IN
18637	5074	28	other	other	JJ
18637	5074	29	respects	respect	NNS
18637	5074	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5074	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	5074	32	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	5074	33	at	at	IN
18637	5074	34	every	every	DT
18637	5074	35	turn	turn	NN
18637	5074	36	by	by	IN
18637	5074	37	the	the	DT
18637	5074	38	police	police	NN
18637	5074	39	power	power	NN
18637	5074	40	of	of	IN
18637	5074	41	the	the	DT
18637	5074	42	States	States	NNPS
18637	5074	43	,	,	,
18637	5074	44	and	and	CC
18637	5074	45	hence	hence	RB
18637	5074	46	requires	require	VBZ
18637	5074	47	to	to	TO
18637	5074	48	be	be	VB
18637	5074	49	defined	define	VBN
18637	5074	50	in	in	IN
18637	5074	51	relation	relation	NN
18637	5074	52	to	to	IN
18637	5074	53	the	the	DT
18637	5074	54	known	know	VBN
18637	5074	55	and	and	CC
18637	5074	56	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	5074	57	reiterated	reiterate	VBD
18637	5074	58	objectives	objective	NNS
18637	5074	59	of	of	IN
18637	5074	60	that	that	DT
18637	5074	61	power	power	NN
18637	5074	62	.	.	.
18637	5075	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	5075	2	,	,	,
18637	5075	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5075	4	was	be	VBD
18637	5075	5	urged	urge	VBN
18637	5075	6	on	on	IN
18637	5075	7	the	the	DT
18637	5075	8	authority	authority	NN
18637	5075	9	of	of	IN
18637	5075	10	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	5075	11	that	that	IN
18637	5075	12	the	the	DT
18637	5075	13	power	power	NN
18637	5075	14	to	to	TO
18637	5075	15	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5075	16	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5075	17	among	among	IN
18637	5075	18	the	the	DT
18637	5075	19	States	States	NNP
18637	5075	20	was	be	VBD
18637	5075	21	not	not	RB
18637	5075	22	bestowed	bestow	VBN
18637	5075	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	5075	24	the	the	DT
18637	5075	25	National	National	NNP
18637	5075	26	Government	Government	NNP
18637	5075	27	"	"	''
18637	5075	28	to	to	TO
18637	5075	29	be	be	VB
18637	5075	30	used	use	VBN
18637	5075	31	for	for	IN
18637	5075	32	*	*	NFP
18637	5075	33	*	*	NFP
18637	5075	34	*	*	NFP
18637	5075	35	positive	positive	JJ
18637	5075	36	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	5075	37	,	,	,
18637	5075	38	"	"	''
18637	5075	39	but	but	CC
18637	5075	40	merely	merely	RB
18637	5075	41	as	as	IN
18637	5075	42	"	"	``
18637	5075	43	a	a	DT
18637	5075	44	negative	negative	JJ
18637	5075	45	and	and	CC
18637	5075	46	preventive	preventive	JJ
18637	5075	47	provision	provision	NN
18637	5075	48	against	against	IN
18637	5075	49	injustice	injustice	NN
18637	5075	50	among	among	IN
18637	5075	51	the	the	DT
18637	5075	52	States	States	NNP
18637	5075	53	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5075	54	.	.	.
18637	5075	55	"	"	''
18637	5076	1	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	5076	2	IV	IV	NNP
18637	5076	3	,	,	,
18637	5076	4	Letters	Letters	NNPS
18637	5076	5	and	and	CC
18637	5076	6	Other	Other	NNP
18637	5076	7	Writings	Writings	NNPS
18637	5076	8	,	,	,
18637	5076	9	15	15	CD
18637	5076	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5076	11	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	5076	12	,	,	,
18637	5076	13	1865	1865	CD
18637	5076	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5076	15	.	.	.
18637	5077	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	5077	2	,	,	,
18637	5077	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5077	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	5077	5	a	a	DT
18637	5077	6	power	power	NN
18637	5077	7	which	which	WDT
18637	5077	8	was	be	VBD
18637	5077	9	designed	design	VBN
18637	5077	10	for	for	IN
18637	5077	11	the	the	DT
18637	5077	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5077	13	promotion	promotion	NN
18637	5077	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5077	15	and	and	CC
18637	5077	16	_	_	NNP
18637	5077	17	advancement	advancement	NN
18637	5077	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5077	19	of	of	IN
18637	5077	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5077	21	,	,	,
18637	5077	22	not	not	RB
18637	5077	23	a	a	DT
18637	5077	24	power	power	NN
18637	5077	25	to	to	TO
18637	5077	26	strike	strike	VB
18637	5077	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5077	28	down	down	RP
18637	5077	29	in	in	IN
18637	5077	30	order	order	NN
18637	5077	31	to	to	TO
18637	5077	32	advance	advance	VB
18637	5077	33	other	other	JJ
18637	5077	34	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	5077	35	and	and	CC
18637	5077	36	programs	program	NNS
18637	5077	37	.	.	.
18637	5078	1	Grant	grant	VB
18637	5078	2	that	that	IN
18637	5078	3	the	the	DT
18637	5078	4	power	power	NN
18637	5078	5	to	to	TO
18637	5078	6	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5078	7	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5078	8	among	among	IN
18637	5078	9	the	the	DT
18637	5078	10	States	States	NNP
18637	5078	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	5078	12	the	the	DT
18637	5078	13	power	power	NN
18637	5078	14	to	to	TO
18637	5078	15	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	5078	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5078	17	at	at	IN
18637	5078	18	the	the	DT
18637	5078	19	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	5078	20	of	of	IN
18637	5078	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5078	22	,	,	,
18637	5078	23	and	and	CC
18637	5078	24	you	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5078	25	at	at	IN
18637	5078	26	once	once	RB
18637	5078	27	endow	endow	NN
18637	5078	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5078	29	with	with	IN
18637	5078	30	power	power	NN
18637	5078	31	which	which	WDT
18637	5078	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5078	33	may	may	MD
18637	5078	34	use	use	VB
18637	5078	35	as	as	IN
18637	5078	36	a	a	DT
18637	5078	37	weapon	weapon	NN
18637	5078	38	to	to	TO
18637	5078	39	consolidate	consolidate	VB
18637	5078	40	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	5078	41	all	all	DT
18637	5078	42	power	power	NN
18637	5078	43	in	in	IN
18637	5078	44	the	the	DT
18637	5078	45	hands	hand	NNS
18637	5078	46	of	of	IN
18637	5078	47	the	the	DT
18637	5078	48	National	National	NNP
18637	5078	49	Government	Government	NNP
18637	5078	50	.	.	.
18637	5079	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	5079	2	,	,	,
18637	5079	3	if	if	IN
18637	5079	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5079	5	may	may	MD
18637	5079	6	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	5079	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5079	8	ad	ad	NN
18637	5079	9	libitum	libitum	NN
18637	5079	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5079	11	the	the	DT
18637	5079	12	carrying	carrying	NN
18637	5079	13	on	on	RP
18637	5079	14	of	of	IN
18637	5079	15	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5079	16	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5079	17	,	,	,
18637	5079	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5079	19	may	may	MD
18637	5079	20	make	make	VB
18637	5079	21	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	5079	22	of	of	IN
18637	5079	23	the	the	DT
18637	5079	24	right	right	NN
18637	5079	25	to	to	TO
18637	5079	26	engage	engage	VB
18637	5079	27	in	in	IN
18637	5079	28	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5079	29	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5079	30	in	in	IN
18637	5079	31	any	any	DT
18637	5079	32	of	of	IN
18637	5079	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5079	34	phases	phase	NNS
18637	5079	35	,	,	,
18637	5079	36	even	even	RB
18637	5079	37	the	the	DT
18637	5079	38	right	right	NN
18637	5079	39	to	to	TO
18637	5079	40	move	move	VB
18637	5079	41	from	from	IN
18637	5079	42	one	one	CD
18637	5079	43	State	state	NN
18637	5079	44	to	to	IN
18637	5079	45	another	another	DT
18637	5079	46	,	,	,
18637	5079	47	a	a	DT
18637	5079	48	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	5079	49	of	of	IN
18637	5079	50	ever	ever	RB
18637	5079	51	-	-	HYPH
18637	5079	52	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	5079	53	efficacy	efficacy	NN
18637	5079	54	for	for	IN
18637	5079	55	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	5079	56	standards	standard	NNS
18637	5079	57	of	of	IN
18637	5079	58	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	5079	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5079	60	may	may	MD
18637	5079	61	choose	choose	VB
18637	5079	62	to	to	TO
18637	5079	63	lay	lay	VB
18637	5079	64	down	down	RP
18637	5079	65	in	in	IN
18637	5079	66	any	any	DT
18637	5079	67	field	field	NN
18637	5079	68	of	of	IN
18637	5079	69	human	human	JJ
18637	5079	70	action	action	NN
18637	5079	71	;	;	:
18637	5079	72	and	and	CC
18637	5079	73	since	since	IN
18637	5079	74	laws	law	NNS
18637	5079	75	passed	pass	VBN
18637	5079	76	by	by	IN
18637	5079	77	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5079	78	in	in	IN
18637	5079	79	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	5079	80	of	of	IN
18637	5079	81	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5079	82	powers	power	NNS
18637	5079	83	are	be	VBP
18637	5079	84	generally	generally	RB
18637	5079	85	supreme	supreme	RB
18637	5079	86	over	over	IN
18637	5079	87	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	5079	88	State	state	NN
18637	5079	89	laws	law	NNS
18637	5079	90	,	,	,
18637	5079	91	these	these	DT
18637	5079	92	standards	standard	NNS
18637	5079	93	would	would	MD
18637	5079	94	supersede	supersede	VB
18637	5079	95	the	the	DT
18637	5079	96	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	5079	97	standards	standard	NNS
18637	5079	98	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	5079	99	under	under	IN
18637	5079	100	the	the	DT
18637	5079	101	police	police	NN
18637	5079	102	powers	power	NNS
18637	5079	103	of	of	IN
18637	5079	104	the	the	DT
18637	5079	105	States	States	NNP
18637	5079	106	.	.	.
18637	5080	1	Henceforth	henceforth	RB
18637	5080	2	,	,	,
18637	5080	3	in	in	IN
18637	5080	4	effect	effect	NN
18637	5080	5	,	,	,
18637	5080	6	the	the	DT
18637	5080	7	police	police	NN
18637	5080	8	power	power	NN
18637	5080	9	would	would	MD
18637	5080	10	exist	exist	VB
18637	5080	11	solely	solely	RB
18637	5080	12	by	by	IN
18637	5080	13	"	"	``
18637	5080	14	leave	leave	NN
18637	5080	15	and	and	CC
18637	5080	16	license	license	VBP
18637	5080	17	"	"	''
18637	5080	18	of	of	IN
18637	5080	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5080	20	--	--	:
18637	5080	21	as	as	IN
18637	5080	22	"	"	``
18637	5080	23	the	the	DT
18637	5080	24	power	power	NN
18637	5080	25	to	to	TO
18637	5080	26	govern	govern	VB
18637	5080	27	men	man	NNS
18637	5080	28	and	and	CC
18637	5080	29	things	thing	NNS
18637	5080	30	"	"	''
18637	5080	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5080	32	would	would	MD
18637	5080	33	be	be	VB
18637	5080	34	at	at	IN
18637	5080	35	an	an	DT
18637	5080	36	end	end	NN
18637	5080	37	;	;	:
18637	5080	38	and	and	CC
18637	5080	39	by	by	IN
18637	5080	40	the	the	DT
18637	5080	41	same	same	JJ
18637	5080	42	token	token	NN
18637	5080	43	the	the	DT
18637	5080	44	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	5080	45	System	System	NNP
18637	5080	46	,	,	,
18637	5080	47	which	which	WDT
18637	5080	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	5080	49	the	the	DT
18637	5080	50	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	5080	51	feature	feature	NN
18637	5080	52	of	of	IN
18637	5080	53	government	government	NN
18637	5080	54	under	under	IN
18637	5080	55	the	the	DT
18637	5080	56	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5080	57	,	,	,
18637	5080	58	would	would	MD
18637	5080	59	be	be	VB
18637	5080	60	at	at	IN
18637	5080	61	an	an	DT
18637	5080	62	end	end	NN
18637	5080	63	.	.	.
18637	5081	1	In	in	IN
18637	5081	2	the	the	DT
18637	5081	3	First	First	NNP
18637	5081	4	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	5081	5	'	'	POS
18637	5081	6	Liability	liability	NN
18637	5081	7	Cases	case	NNS
18637	5081	8	,	,	,
18637	5081	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5081	10	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	5081	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5081	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	5081	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5081	14	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5081	15	Central	Central	NNP
18637	5081	16	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5081	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5081	18	,	,	,
18637	5081	19	207	207	CD
18637	5081	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5081	21	463	463	CD
18637	5081	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5081	23	1908	1908	CD
18637	5081	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5081	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5081	26	,	,	,
18637	5081	27	the	the	DT
18637	5081	28	majority	majority	NN
18637	5081	29	of	of	IN
18637	5081	30	the	the	DT
18637	5081	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5081	32	,	,	,
18637	5081	33	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	5081	34	through	through	IN
18637	5081	35	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5081	36	White	White	NNP
18637	5081	37	,	,	,
18637	5081	38	gave	give	VBD
18637	5081	39	special	special	JJ
18637	5081	40	attention	attention	NN
18637	5081	41	to	to	IN
18637	5081	42	the	the	DT
18637	5081	43	Government	Government	NNP
18637	5081	44	's	's	POS
18637	5081	45	argument	argument	NN
18637	5081	46	that	that	IN
18637	5081	47	though	though	IN
18637	5081	48	the	the	DT
18637	5081	49	act	act	NN
18637	5081	50	,	,	,
18637	5081	51	in	in	IN
18637	5081	52	terms	term	NNS
18637	5081	53	,	,	,
18637	5081	54	governed	govern	VBD
18637	5081	55	the	the	DT
18637	5081	56	liability	liability	NN
18637	5081	57	of	of	IN
18637	5081	58	"	"	``
18637	5081	59	every	every	DT
18637	5081	60	"	"	``
18637	5081	61	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5081	62	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	5081	63	to	to	IN
18637	5081	64	"	"	``
18637	5081	65	any	any	DT
18637	5081	66	"	"	''
18637	5081	67	of	of	IN
18637	5081	68	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5081	69	employees	employee	NNS
18637	5081	70	,	,	,
18637	5081	71	whether	whether	IN
18637	5081	72	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	5081	73	in	in	IN
18637	5081	74	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5081	75	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5081	76	or	or	CC
18637	5081	77	not	not	RB
18637	5081	78	when	when	WRB
18637	5081	79	the	the	DT
18637	5081	80	liability	liability	NN
18637	5081	81	fell	fall	VBD
18637	5081	82	,	,	,
18637	5081	83	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5081	84	was	be	VBD
18637	5081	85	none	none	NN
18637	5081	86	the	the	DT
18637	5081	87	less	less	RBR
18637	5081	88	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	5081	89	"	"	''
18637	5081	90	because	because	IN
18637	5081	91	one	one	NN
18637	5081	92	who	who	WP
18637	5081	93	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	5081	94	in	in	IN
18637	5081	95	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5081	96	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	5081	97	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	5081	98	submits	submit	VBZ
18637	5081	99	all	all	PDT
18637	5081	100	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5081	101	business	business	NN
18637	5081	102	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	5081	103	to	to	IN
18637	5081	104	the	the	DT
18637	5081	105	regulating	regulating	NN
18637	5081	106	power	power	NN
18637	5081	107	of	of	IN
18637	5081	108	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5081	109	.	.	.
18637	5081	110	"	"	''
18637	5082	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5082	2	White	White	NNP
18637	5082	3	answered	answer	VBD
18637	5082	4	:	:	:
18637	5082	5	"	"	``
18637	5082	6	To	to	TO
18637	5082	7	state	state	VB
18637	5082	8	the	the	DT
18637	5082	9	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	5082	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	5082	11	to	to	TO
18637	5082	12	refute	refute	VB
18637	5082	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5082	14	.	.	.
18637	5083	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5083	2	assumes	assume	VBZ
18637	5083	3	that	that	IN
18637	5083	4	because	because	IN
18637	5083	5	one	one	CD
18637	5083	6	engages	engage	NNS
18637	5083	7	in	in	IN
18637	5083	8	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5083	9	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5083	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5083	11	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	5083	12	endows	endow	VBZ
18637	5083	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5083	14	with	with	IN
18637	5083	15	power	power	NN
18637	5083	16	not	not	RB
18637	5083	17	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	5083	18	to	to	IN
18637	5083	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5083	20	by	by	IN
18637	5083	21	the	the	DT
18637	5083	22	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5083	23	;	;	:
18637	5083	24	in	in	IN
18637	5083	25	other	other	JJ
18637	5083	26	words	word	NNS
18637	5083	27	,	,	,
18637	5083	28	with	with	IN
18637	5083	29	the	the	DT
18637	5083	30	right	right	NN
18637	5083	31	to	to	TO
18637	5083	32	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	5083	33	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	5083	34	matters	matter	NNS
18637	5083	35	of	of	IN
18637	5083	36	purely	purely	RB
18637	5083	37	State	state	NN
18637	5083	38	concern	concern	NN
18637	5083	39	.	.	.
18637	5084	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5084	2	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	5084	3	upon	upon	IN
18637	5084	4	the	the	DT
18637	5084	5	conception	conception	NN
18637	5084	6	that	that	WDT
18637	5084	7	the	the	DT
18637	5084	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5084	9	destroyed	destroy	VBD
18637	5084	10	that	that	IN
18637	5084	11	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	5084	12	of	of	IN
18637	5084	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5084	14	which	which	WDT
18637	5084	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5084	16	was	be	VBD
18637	5084	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5084	18	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	5084	19	to	to	TO
18637	5084	20	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	5084	21	,	,	,
18637	5084	22	since	since	IN
18637	5084	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5084	24	treats	treat	VBZ
18637	5084	25	the	the	DT
18637	5084	26	right	right	NN
18637	5084	27	to	to	TO
18637	5084	28	engage	engage	VB
18637	5084	29	in	in	IN
18637	5084	30	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5084	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5084	32	as	as	IN
18637	5084	33	a	a	DT
18637	5084	34	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	5084	35	which	which	WDT
18637	5084	36	can	can	MD
18637	5084	37	not	not	RB
18637	5084	38	be	be	VB
18637	5084	39	availed	avail	VBN
18637	5084	40	of	of	IN
18637	5084	41	except	except	IN
18637	5084	42	upon	upon	IN
18637	5084	43	such	such	JJ
18637	5084	44	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	5084	45	as	as	IN
18637	5084	46	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5084	47	may	may	MD
18637	5084	48	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	5084	49	,	,	,
18637	5084	50	even	even	RB
18637	5084	51	although	although	IN
18637	5084	52	the	the	DT
18637	5084	53	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	5084	54	would	would	MD
18637	5084	55	be	be	VB
18637	5084	56	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	5084	57	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	5084	58	the	the	DT
18637	5084	59	power	power	NN
18637	5084	60	of	of	IN
18637	5084	61	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5084	62	.	.	.
18637	5085	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5085	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	5085	3	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	5085	4	that	that	IN
18637	5085	5	if	if	IN
18637	5085	6	the	the	DT
18637	5085	7	contention	contention	NN
18637	5085	8	were	be	VBD
18637	5085	9	well	well	RB
18637	5085	10	founded	found	VBN
18637	5085	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5085	12	would	would	MD
18637	5085	13	extend	extend	VB
18637	5085	14	the	the	DT
18637	5085	15	power	power	NN
18637	5085	16	of	of	IN
18637	5085	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5085	18	to	to	IN
18637	5085	19	every	every	DT
18637	5085	20	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
18637	5085	21	subject	subject	NN
18637	5085	22	,	,	,
18637	5085	23	however	however	RB
18637	5085	24	inherently	inherently	RB
18637	5085	25	local	local	JJ
18637	5085	26	,	,	,
18637	5085	27	would	would	MD
18637	5085	28	obliterate	obliterate	VB
18637	5085	29	all	all	PDT
18637	5085	30	the	the	DT
18637	5085	31	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	5085	32	of	of	IN
18637	5085	33	power	power	NN
18637	5085	34	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	5085	35	by	by	IN
18637	5085	36	the	the	DT
18637	5085	37	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5085	38	,	,	,
18637	5085	39	and	and	CC
18637	5085	40	would	would	MD
18637	5085	41	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	5085	42	the	the	DT
18637	5085	43	authority	authority	NN
18637	5085	44	of	of	IN
18637	5085	45	the	the	DT
18637	5085	46	States	States	NNPS
18637	5085	47	as	as	IN
18637	5085	48	to	to	IN
18637	5085	49	all	all	DT
18637	5085	50	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
18637	5085	51	matters	matter	NNS
18637	5085	52	which	which	WDT
18637	5085	53	from	from	IN
18637	5085	54	the	the	DT
18637	5085	55	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	5085	56	have	have	VBP
18637	5085	57	been	be	VBN
18637	5085	58	,	,	,
18637	5085	59	and	and	CC
18637	5085	60	must	must	MD
18637	5085	61	continue	continue	VB
18637	5085	62	to	to	TO
18637	5085	63	be	be	VB
18637	5085	64	,	,	,
18637	5085	65	under	under	IN
18637	5085	66	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5085	67	control	control	NN
18637	5085	68	so	so	RB
18637	5085	69	long	long	RB
18637	5085	70	as	as	IN
18637	5085	71	the	the	DT
18637	5085	72	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5085	73	endures	endure	VBZ
18637	5085	74	.	.	.
18637	5085	75	"	"	''
18637	5086	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	5086	2	.	.	.
18637	5087	1	502	502	CD
18637	5087	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5087	3	503	503	CD
18637	5087	4	.	.	.
18637	5088	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5088	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5088	3	also	also	RB
18637	5088	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5088	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5088	6	White	White	NNP
18637	5088	7	's	's	POS
18637	5088	8	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	5088	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	5088	10	,	,	,
18637	5088	11	for	for	IN
18637	5088	12	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5088	13	,	,	,
18637	5088	14	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	5088	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5088	16	Fuller	Fuller	NNP
18637	5088	17	,	,	,
18637	5088	18	and	and	CC
18637	5088	19	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	5088	20	Peckham	Peckham	NNP
18637	5088	21	and	and	CC
18637	5088	22	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	5088	23	,	,	,
18637	5088	24	in	in	IN
18637	5088	25	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	5088	26	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	5088	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5088	28	_	_	NNP
18637	5088	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	5088	30	_	_	NNP
18637	5088	31	United	United	NNP
18637	5088	32	States	States	NNP
18637	5088	33	,	,	,
18637	5088	34	193	193	CD
18637	5088	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5088	36	197	197	CD
18637	5088	37	,	,	,
18637	5088	38	396	396	CD
18637	5088	39	-	-	SYM
18637	5088	40	397	397	CD
18637	5088	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5088	42	1904	1904	CD
18637	5088	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5088	44	.	.	.
18637	5089	1	The	the	DT
18637	5089	2	Argument	argument	NN
18637	5089	3	Asserting	assert	VBG
18637	5089	4	the	the	DT
18637	5089	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	5089	6	The	the	DT
18637	5089	7	thesis	thesis	NN
18637	5089	8	that	that	IN
18637	5089	9	the	the	DT
18637	5089	10	power	power	NN
18637	5089	11	to	to	TO
18637	5089	12	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5089	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5089	14	among	among	IN
18637	5089	15	the	the	DT
18637	5089	16	States	States	NNP
18637	5089	17	comprises	comprise	VBZ
18637	5089	18	in	in	IN
18637	5089	19	general	general	JJ
18637	5089	20	the	the	DT
18637	5089	21	power	power	NN
18637	5089	22	to	to	TO
18637	5089	23	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	5089	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5089	25	turns	turn	VBZ
18637	5089	26	on	on	IN
18637	5089	27	the	the	DT
18637	5089	28	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	5089	29	stated	state	VBN
18637	5089	30	by	by	IN
18637	5089	31	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	5089	32	in	in	IN
18637	5089	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5089	34	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	5089	35	in	in	IN
18637	5089	36	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	5089	37	_	_	NNP
18637	5089	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	5089	39	_	_	NNP
18637	5089	40	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	5089	41	,	,	,
18637	5089	42	that	that	IN
18637	5089	43	this	this	DT
18637	5089	44	power	power	NN
18637	5089	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	5089	46	vested	vest	VBN
18637	5089	47	"	"	''
18637	5089	48	in	in	IN
18637	5089	49	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5089	50	as	as	RB
18637	5089	51	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	5089	52	as	as	IN
18637	5089	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5089	54	would	would	MD
18637	5089	55	be	be	VB
18637	5089	56	in	in	IN
18637	5089	57	a	a	DT
18637	5089	58	single	single	JJ
18637	5089	59	government	government	NN
18637	5089	60	,	,	,
18637	5089	61	having	have	VBG
18637	5089	62	in	in	IN
18637	5089	63	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5089	64	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5089	65	the	the	DT
18637	5089	66	same	same	JJ
18637	5089	67	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	5089	68	on	on	IN
18637	5089	69	the	the	DT
18637	5089	70	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	5089	71	of	of	IN
18637	5089	72	the	the	DT
18637	5089	73	power	power	NN
18637	5089	74	as	as	IN
18637	5089	75	are	be	VBP
18637	5089	76	found	find	VBN
18637	5089	77	in	in	IN
18637	5089	78	the	the	DT
18637	5089	79	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5089	80	of	of	IN
18637	5089	81	the	the	DT
18637	5089	82	United	United	NNP
18637	5089	83	States	States	NNP
18637	5089	84	.	.	.
18637	5090	1	The	the	DT
18637	5090	2	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	5090	3	and	and	CC
18637	5090	4	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	5090	5	of	of	IN
18637	5090	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5090	7	,	,	,
18637	5090	8	"	"	''
18637	5090	9	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	5090	10	continued	continue	VBD
18637	5090	11	,	,	,
18637	5090	12	"	"	``
18637	5090	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5090	14	identity	identity	NN
18637	5090	15	with	with	IN
18637	5090	16	the	the	DT
18637	5090	17	people	people	NNS
18637	5090	18	,	,	,
18637	5090	19	and	and	CC
18637	5090	20	the	the	DT
18637	5090	21	influence	influence	NN
18637	5090	22	which	which	WDT
18637	5090	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5090	24	constituents	constituent	NNS
18637	5090	25	possess	possess	VBP
18637	5090	26	at	at	IN
18637	5090	27	elections	election	NNS
18637	5090	28	,	,	,
18637	5090	29	are	be	VBP
18637	5090	30	,	,	,
18637	5090	31	in	in	IN
18637	5090	32	this	this	DT
18637	5090	33	,	,	,
18637	5090	34	as	as	IN
18637	5090	35	in	in	IN
18637	5090	36	many	many	JJ
18637	5090	37	other	other	JJ
18637	5090	38	instances	instance	NNS
18637	5090	39	,	,	,
18637	5090	40	as	as	IN
18637	5090	41	that	that	DT
18637	5090	42	,	,	,
18637	5090	43	for	for	IN
18637	5090	44	example	example	NN
18637	5090	45	,	,	,
18637	5090	46	of	of	IN
18637	5090	47	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	5090	48	war	war	NN
18637	5090	49	,	,	,
18637	5090	50	the	the	DT
18637	5090	51	sole	sole	JJ
18637	5090	52	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	5090	53	on	on	IN
18637	5090	54	which	which	WDT
18637	5090	55	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5090	56	have	have	VBP
18637	5090	57	relied	rely	VBN
18637	5090	58	,	,	,
18637	5090	59	to	to	TO
18637	5090	60	secure	secure	VB
18637	5090	61	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5090	62	from	from	IN
18637	5090	63	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5090	64	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	5090	65	.	.	.
18637	5090	66	"	"	''
18637	5091	1	9	9	CD
18637	5091	2	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5091	3	.	.	.
18637	5092	1	1	1	CD
18637	5092	2	,	,	,
18637	5092	3	196	196	CD
18637	5092	4	-	-	SYM
18637	5092	5	197	197	CD
18637	5092	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5092	7	1824	1824	CD
18637	5092	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5092	9	.	.	.
18637	5093	1	That	that	IN
18637	5093	2	the	the	DT
18637	5093	3	National	National	NNP
18637	5093	4	Government	Government	NNP
18637	5093	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	5093	6	a	a	DT
18637	5093	7	government	government	NN
18637	5093	8	of	of	IN
18637	5093	9	limited	limited	JJ
18637	5093	10	powers	power	NNS
18637	5093	11	,	,	,
18637	5093	12	the	the	DT
18637	5093	13	advocates	advocate	NNS
18637	5093	14	of	of	IN
18637	5093	15	this	this	DT
18637	5093	16	view	view	NN
18637	5093	17	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	5093	18	;	;	:
18637	5093	19	but	but	CC
18637	5093	20	the	the	DT
18637	5093	21	powers	power	NNS
18637	5093	22	which	which	WDT
18637	5093	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5093	24	uncontrovertibly	uncontrovertibly	RB
18637	5093	25	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	5093	26	,	,	,
18637	5093	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5093	28	urged	urge	VBD
18637	5093	29	,	,	,
18637	5093	30	may	may	MD
18637	5093	31	be	be	VB
18637	5093	32	utilized	utilize	VBN
18637	5093	33	to	to	TO
18637	5093	34	promote	promote	VB
18637	5093	35	all	all	DT
18637	5093	36	good	good	JJ
18637	5093	37	causes	cause	NNS
18637	5093	38	,	,	,
18637	5093	39	of	of	IN
18637	5093	40	which	which	WDT
18637	5093	41	fact	fact	NN
18637	5093	42	,	,	,
18637	5093	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5093	44	was	be	VBD
18637	5093	45	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	5093	46	,	,	,
18637	5093	47	the	the	DT
18637	5093	48	Preamble	Preamble	NNP
18637	5093	49	of	of	IN
18637	5093	50	the	the	DT
18637	5093	51	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5093	52	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5093	53	was	be	VBD
18637	5093	54	proof	proof	NN
18637	5093	55	.	.	.
18637	5094	1	There	there	RB
18637	5094	2	the	the	DT
18637	5094	3	objectives	objective	NNS
18637	5094	4	of	of	IN
18637	5094	5	the	the	DT
18637	5094	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5094	7	and	and	CC
18637	5094	8	so	so	RB
18637	5094	9	,	,	,
18637	5094	10	presumably	presumably	RB
18637	5094	11	,	,	,
18637	5094	12	of	of	IN
18637	5094	13	the	the	DT
18637	5094	14	Government	Government	NNP
18637	5094	15	created	create	VBN
18637	5094	16	by	by	IN
18637	5094	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5094	18	,	,	,
18637	5094	19	are	be	VBP
18637	5094	20	stated	state	VBN
18637	5094	21	to	to	TO
18637	5094	22	be	be	VB
18637	5094	23	"	"	``
18637	5094	24	more	more	RBR
18637	5094	25	perfect	perfect	JJ
18637	5094	26	union	union	NN
18637	5094	27	,	,	,
18637	5094	28	"	"	''
18637	5094	29	"	"	``
18637	5094	30	justice	justice	NN
18637	5094	31	,	,	,
18637	5094	32	"	"	''
18637	5094	33	"	"	``
18637	5094	34	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	5094	35	tranquillity	tranquillity	NN
18637	5094	36	,	,	,
18637	5094	37	"	"	''
18637	5094	38	"	"	``
18637	5094	39	the	the	DT
18637	5094	40	common	common	JJ
18637	5094	41	defense	defense	NN
18637	5094	42	,	,	,
18637	5094	43	"	"	''
18637	5094	44	"	"	``
18637	5094	45	the	the	DT
18637	5094	46	general	general	JJ
18637	5094	47	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	5094	48	,	,	,
18637	5094	49	"	"	''
18637	5094	50	and	and	CC
18637	5094	51	"	"	``
18637	5094	52	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	5094	53	.	.	.
18637	5094	54	"	"	''
18637	5095	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5095	2	was	be	VBD
18637	5095	3	to	to	TO
18637	5095	4	forward	forward	VB
18637	5095	5	these	these	DT
18637	5095	6	broad	broad	JJ
18637	5095	7	general	general	JJ
18637	5095	8	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	5095	9	,	,	,
18637	5095	10	then	then	RB
18637	5095	11	,	,	,
18637	5095	12	that	that	IN
18637	5095	13	the	the	DT
18637	5095	14	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	5095	15	power	power	NN
18637	5095	16	,	,	,
18637	5095	17	like	like	IN
18637	5095	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5095	19	other	other	JJ
18637	5095	20	powers	power	NNS
18637	5095	21	,	,	,
18637	5095	22	was	be	VBD
18637	5095	23	bestowed	bestow	VBN
18637	5095	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	5095	25	the	the	DT
18637	5095	26	National	National	NNP
18637	5095	27	Government	Government	NNP
18637	5095	28	.	.	.
18637	5096	1	No	no	RB
18637	5096	2	doubt	doubt	RB
18637	5096	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5096	4	was	be	VBD
18637	5096	5	expected	expect	VBN
18637	5096	6	that	that	IN
18637	5096	7	the	the	DT
18637	5096	8	States	States	NNPS
18637	5096	9	,	,	,
18637	5096	10	too	too	RB
18637	5096	11	,	,	,
18637	5096	12	would	would	MD
18637	5096	13	use	use	VB
18637	5096	14	the	the	DT
18637	5096	15	powers	power	NNS
18637	5096	16	still	still	RB
18637	5096	17	left	leave	VBD
18637	5096	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5096	19	to	to	TO
18637	5096	20	assist	assist	VB
18637	5096	21	the	the	DT
18637	5096	22	same	same	JJ
18637	5096	23	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	5096	24	,	,	,
18637	5096	25	which	which	WDT
18637	5096	26	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	5096	27	are	be	VBP
18637	5096	28	those	those	DT
18637	5096	29	of	of	IN
18637	5096	30	good	good	JJ
18637	5096	31	government	government	NN
18637	5096	32	always	always	RB
18637	5096	33	.	.	.
18637	5097	1	Yet	yet	RB
18637	5097	2	that	that	DT
18637	5097	3	circumstance	circumstance	NN
18637	5097	4	should	should	MD
18637	5097	5	not	not	RB
18637	5097	6	operate	operate	VB
18637	5097	7	to	to	TO
18637	5097	8	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	5097	9	the	the	DT
18637	5097	10	powers	power	NNS
18637	5097	11	delegated	delegate	VBD
18637	5097	12	to	to	IN
18637	5097	13	the	the	DT
18637	5097	14	National	National	NNP
18637	5097	15	Government	Government	NNP
18637	5097	16	from	from	IN
18637	5097	17	the	the	DT
18637	5097	18	service	service	NN
18637	5097	19	of	of	IN
18637	5097	20	these	these	DT
18637	5097	21	same	same	JJ
18637	5097	22	ends	end	NNS
18637	5097	23	.	.	.
18637	5098	1	The	the	DT
18637	5098	2	fact	fact	NN
18637	5098	3	,	,	,
18637	5098	4	in	in	IN
18637	5098	5	other	other	JJ
18637	5098	6	words	word	NNS
18637	5098	7	,	,	,
18637	5098	8	that	that	IN
18637	5098	9	the	the	DT
18637	5098	10	power	power	NN
18637	5098	11	to	to	TO
18637	5098	12	govern	govern	VB
18637	5098	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5098	14	among	among	IN
18637	5098	15	the	the	DT
18637	5098	16	States	States	NNP
18637	5098	17	was	be	VBD
18637	5098	18	bestowed	bestow	VBN
18637	5098	19	by	by	IN
18637	5098	20	the	the	DT
18637	5098	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5098	22	on	on	IN
18637	5098	23	the	the	DT
18637	5098	24	National	National	NNP
18637	5098	25	Government	Government	NNP
18637	5098	26	should	should	MD
18637	5098	27	not	not	RB
18637	5098	28	imply	imply	VB
18637	5098	29	that	that	IN
18637	5098	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5098	31	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	5098	32	became	become	VBD
18637	5098	33	available	available	JJ
18637	5098	34	merely	merely	RB
18637	5098	35	for	for	IN
18637	5098	36	the	the	DT
18637	5098	37	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	5098	38	of	of	IN
18637	5098	39	fostering	foster	VBG
18637	5098	40	such	such	JJ
18637	5098	41	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5098	42	.	.	.
18637	5099	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5099	2	ought	ought	MD
18637	5099	3	,	,	,
18637	5099	4	on	on	IN
18637	5099	5	the	the	DT
18637	5099	6	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	5099	7	,	,	,
18637	5099	8	to	to	TO
18637	5099	9	be	be	VB
18637	5099	10	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	5099	11	,	,	,
18637	5099	12	as	as	IN
18637	5099	13	would	would	MD
18637	5099	14	be	be	VB
18637	5099	15	the	the	DT
18637	5099	16	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
18637	5099	17	power	power	NN
18637	5099	18	in	in	IN
18637	5099	19	England	England	NNP
18637	5099	20	or	or	CC
18637	5099	21	France	France	NNP
18637	5099	22	for	for	IN
18637	5099	23	instance	instance	NN
18637	5099	24	,	,	,
18637	5099	25	to	to	TO
18637	5099	26	aid	aid	VB
18637	5099	27	and	and	CC
18637	5099	28	support	support	VB
18637	5099	29	all	all	DT
18637	5099	30	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	5099	31	objectives	objective	NNS
18637	5099	32	of	of	IN
18637	5099	33	government	government	NN
18637	5099	34	.	.	.
18637	5100	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5100	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5100	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5100	4	Juilliard	Juilliard	NNP
18637	5100	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5100	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5100	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5100	8	Greenman	Greenman	NNP
18637	5100	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5100	10	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	5100	11	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	5100	12	Case	Case	NNP
18637	5100	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5100	14	,	,	,
18637	5100	15	110	110	CD
18637	5100	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5100	17	421	421	CD
18637	5100	18	,	,	,
18637	5100	19	447	447	CD
18637	5100	20	-	-	SYM
18637	5100	21	448	448	CD
18637	5100	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5100	23	1884	1884	CD
18637	5100	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5100	25	.	.	.
18637	5101	1	As	as	IN
18637	5101	2	originally	originally	RB
18637	5101	3	possessed	possess	VBN
18637	5101	4	by	by	IN
18637	5101	5	the	the	DT
18637	5101	6	several	several	JJ
18637	5101	7	States	States	NNPS
18637	5101	8	,	,	,
18637	5101	9	the	the	DT
18637	5101	10	power	power	NN
18637	5101	11	to	to	TO
18637	5101	12	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5101	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5101	14	with	with	IN
18637	5101	15	one	one	CD
18637	5101	16	another	another	DT
18637	5101	17	included	include	VBD
18637	5101	18	the	the	DT
18637	5101	19	power	power	NN
18637	5101	20	to	to	TO
18637	5101	21	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	5101	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5101	23	at	at	IN
18637	5101	24	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	5101	25	;	;	:
18637	5101	26	on	on	IN
18637	5101	27	what	what	WDT
18637	5101	28	principle	principle	NN
18637	5101	29	,	,	,
18637	5101	30	then	then	RB
18637	5101	31	,	,	,
18637	5101	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5101	33	was	be	VBD
18637	5101	34	asked	ask	VBN
18637	5101	35	,	,	,
18637	5101	36	can	can	MD
18637	5101	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5101	38	be	be	VB
18637	5101	39	contended	contend	VBN
18637	5101	40	that	that	IN
18637	5101	41	the	the	DT
18637	5101	42	power	power	NN
18637	5101	43	delegated	delegate	VBD
18637	5101	44	to	to	IN
18637	5101	45	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5101	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	5101	47	not	not	RB
18637	5101	48	as	as	RB
18637	5101	49	exhaustive	exhaustive	JJ
18637	5101	50	and	and	CC
18637	5101	51	complete	complete	JJ
18637	5101	52	as	as	IN
18637	5101	53	the	the	DT
18637	5101	54	power	power	NN
18637	5101	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5101	56	was	be	VBD
18637	5101	57	designed	design	VBN
18637	5101	58	to	to	TO
18637	5101	59	supersede	supersede	VB
18637	5101	60	?	?	.
18637	5102	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5102	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5102	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5102	4	especially	especially	RB
18637	5102	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5102	6	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	5102	7	'	'	POS
18637	5102	8	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	5102	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	5102	10	in	in	IN
18637	5102	11	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	5102	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5102	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	5102	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5102	15	Dagenhart	Dagenhart	NNP
18637	5102	16	,	,	,
18637	5102	17	247	247	CD
18637	5102	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5102	19	251	251	CD
18637	5102	20	,	,	,
18637	5102	21	277	277	CD
18637	5102	22	-	-	SYM
18637	5102	23	281	281	CD
18637	5102	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5102	25	1918	1918	CD
18637	5102	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5102	27	.	.	.
18637	5103	1	And	and	CC
18637	5103	2	,	,	,
18637	5103	3	the	the	DT
18637	5103	4	protagonists	protagonist	NNS
18637	5103	5	of	of	IN
18637	5103	6	this	this	DT
18637	5103	7	view	view	NN
18637	5103	8	continued	continue	VBD
18637	5103	9	,	,	,
18637	5103	10	if	if	IN
18637	5103	11	the	the	DT
18637	5103	12	public	public	JJ
18637	5103	13	health	health	NN
18637	5103	14	,	,	,
18637	5103	15	safety	safety	NN
18637	5103	16	,	,	,
18637	5103	17	morals	moral	NNS
18637	5103	18	,	,	,
18637	5103	19	and	and	CC
18637	5103	20	general	general	JJ
18637	5103	21	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	5103	22	must	must	MD
18637	5103	23	depend	depend	VB
18637	5103	24	solely	solely	RB
18637	5103	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	5103	26	the	the	DT
18637	5103	27	police	police	NN
18637	5103	28	powers	power	NNS
18637	5103	29	of	of	IN
18637	5103	30	the	the	DT
18637	5103	31	States	States	NNPS
18637	5103	32	,	,	,
18637	5103	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5103	34	must	must	MD
18637	5103	35	in	in	IN
18637	5103	36	modern	modern	JJ
18637	5103	37	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	5103	38	,	,	,
18637	5103	39	often	often	RB
18637	5103	40	fail	fail	VBP
18637	5103	41	of	of	IN
18637	5103	42	realization	realization	NN
18637	5103	43	in	in	IN
18637	5103	44	this	this	DT
18637	5103	45	country	country	NN
18637	5103	46	.	.	.
18637	5104	1	With	with	IN
18637	5104	2	goods	good	NNS
18637	5104	3	flowing	flow	VBG
18637	5104	4	over	over	IN
18637	5104	5	State	state	NN
18637	5104	6	lines	line	NNS
18637	5104	7	in	in	IN
18637	5104	8	ever	ever	RB
18637	5104	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	5104	10	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	5104	11	quantities	quantity	NNS
18637	5104	12	,	,	,
18637	5104	13	and	and	CC
18637	5104	14	people	people	NNS
18637	5104	15	in	in	IN
18637	5104	16	ever	ever	RB
18637	5104	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	5104	18	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	5104	19	numbers	number	NNS
18637	5104	20	,	,	,
18637	5104	21	how	how	WRB
18637	5104	22	was	be	VBD
18637	5104	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5104	24	possible	possible	JJ
18637	5104	25	to	to	TO
18637	5104	26	regard	regard	VB
18637	5104	27	the	the	DT
18637	5104	28	States	States	NNP
18637	5104	29	as	as	IN
18637	5104	30	watertight	watertight	JJ
18637	5104	31	compartments	compartment	NNS
18637	5104	32	?	?	.
18637	5105	1	At	at	RB
18637	5105	2	least	least	RBS
18637	5105	3	,	,	,
18637	5105	4	then	then	RB
18637	5105	5	,	,	,
18637	5105	6	when	when	WRB
18637	5105	7	local	local	JJ
18637	5105	8	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	5105	9	programs	program	NNS
18637	5105	10	break	break	VBP
18637	5105	11	down	down	RP
18637	5105	12	on	on	IN
18637	5105	13	account	account	NN
18637	5105	14	of	of	IN
18637	5105	15	the	the	DT
18637	5105	16	division	division	NN
18637	5105	17	of	of	IN
18637	5105	18	the	the	DT
18637	5105	19	country	country	NN
18637	5105	20	into	into	IN
18637	5105	21	States	States	NNP
18637	5105	22	,	,	,
18637	5105	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5105	24	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	5105	25	the	the	DT
18637	5105	26	clear	clear	JJ
18637	5105	27	duty	duty	NN
18637	5105	28	of	of	IN
18637	5105	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5105	30	to	to	TO
18637	5105	31	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	5105	32	supplementary	supplementary	JJ
18637	5105	33	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	5105	34	to	to	TO
18637	5105	35	remedy	remedy	VB
18637	5105	36	the	the	DT
18637	5105	37	situation	situation	NN
18637	5105	38	.	.	.
18637	5106	1	In	in	IN
18637	5106	2	doing	do	VBG
18637	5106	3	so	so	RB
18637	5106	4	,	,	,
18637	5106	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5106	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	5106	7	not	not	RB
18637	5106	8	undermining	undermine	VBG
18637	5106	9	the	the	DT
18637	5106	10	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	5106	11	System	System	NNP
18637	5106	12	;	;	:
18637	5106	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5106	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	5106	15	supporting	support	VBG
18637	5106	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5106	17	,	,	,
18637	5106	18	by	by	IN
18637	5106	19	making	make	VBG
18637	5106	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5106	21	viable	viable	JJ
18637	5106	22	in	in	IN
18637	5106	23	modern	modern	JJ
18637	5106	24	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	5106	25	.	.	.
18637	5107	1	The	the	DT
18637	5107	2	assemblage	assemblage	NN
18637	5107	3	of	of	IN
18637	5107	4	the	the	DT
18637	5107	5	States	States	NNPS
18637	5107	6	in	in	IN
18637	5107	7	one	one	CD
18637	5107	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	5107	9	was	be	VBD
18637	5107	10	never	never	RB
18637	5107	11	intended	intend	VBN
18637	5107	12	to	to	TO
18637	5107	13	put	put	VB
18637	5107	14	one	one	CD
18637	5107	15	State	state	NN
18637	5107	16	at	at	IN
18637	5107	17	the	the	DT
18637	5107	18	mercy	mercy	NN
18637	5107	19	of	of	IN
18637	5107	20	another	another	DT
18637	5107	21	.	.	.
18637	5108	1	If	if	IN
18637	5108	2	,	,	,
18637	5108	3	however	however	RB
18637	5108	4	,	,	,
18637	5108	5	well	well	RB
18637	5108	6	considered	consider	VBN
18637	5108	7	programs	program	NNS
18637	5108	8	of	of	IN
18637	5108	9	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	5108	10	are	be	VBP
18637	5108	11	rendered	render	VBN
18637	5108	12	abortive	abortive	JJ
18637	5108	13	in	in	IN
18637	5108	14	a	a	DT
18637	5108	15	State	State	NNP
18637	5108	16	in	in	IN
18637	5108	17	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	5108	18	of	of	IN
18637	5108	19	the	the	DT
18637	5108	20	flow	flow	NN
18637	5108	21	of	of	IN
18637	5108	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5108	23	into	into	IN
18637	5108	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5108	25	from	from	IN
18637	5108	26	other	other	JJ
18637	5108	27	States	States	NNPS
18637	5108	28	,	,	,
18637	5108	29	then	then	RB
18637	5108	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5108	31	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	5108	32	the	the	DT
18637	5108	33	duty	duty	NN
18637	5108	34	--	--	:
18637	5108	35	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	5108	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5108	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	5108	38	within	within	IN
18637	5108	39	the	the	DT
18637	5108	40	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	5108	41	of	of	IN
18637	5108	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5108	43	--	--	:
18637	5108	44	which	which	WDT
18637	5108	45	alone	alone	RB
18637	5108	46	can	can	MD
18637	5108	47	govern	govern	VB
18637	5108	48	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5108	49	among	among	IN
18637	5108	50	the	the	DT
18637	5108	51	States	States	NNP
18637	5108	52	,	,	,
18637	5108	53	to	to	TO
18637	5108	54	supply	supply	VB
18637	5108	55	the	the	DT
18637	5108	56	required	require	VBN
18637	5108	57	relief	relief	NN
18637	5108	58	.	.	.
18637	5109	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5109	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5109	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5109	4	especially	especially	RB
18637	5109	5	Assistant	Assistant	NNP
18637	5109	6	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	5109	7	General	General	NNP
18637	5109	8	Maury	Maury	NNP
18637	5109	9	's	's	POS
18637	5109	10	argument	argument	NN
18637	5109	11	.	.	.
18637	5110	1	In	in	IN
18637	5110	2	re	re	NN
18637	5110	3	Rapier	Rapier	NNP
18637	5110	4	,	,	,
18637	5110	5	143	143	CD
18637	5110	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5110	7	110	110	CD
18637	5110	8	,	,	,
18637	5110	9	127	127	CD
18637	5110	10	-	-	SYM
18637	5110	11	129	129	CD
18637	5110	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5110	13	1892	1892	CD
18637	5110	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5110	15	.	.	.
18637	5111	1	In	in	IN
18637	5111	2	this	this	DT
18637	5111	3	connection	connection	NN
18637	5111	4	the	the	DT
18637	5111	5	advocates	advocate	NNS
18637	5111	6	of	of	IN
18637	5111	7	this	this	DT
18637	5111	8	view	view	NN
18637	5111	9	cited	cite	VBD
18637	5111	10	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	5111	11	contemporaneous	contemporaneous	JJ
18637	5111	12	with	with	IN
18637	5111	13	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	5111	14	's	's	POS
18637	5111	15	Embargo	Embargo	NNP
18637	5111	16	,	,	,
18637	5111	17	and	and	CC
18637	5111	18	under	under	IN
18637	5111	19	the	the	DT
18637	5111	20	embargo	embargo	NN
18637	5111	21	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5111	22	,	,	,
18637	5111	23	as	as	IN
18637	5111	24	supporting	support	VBG
18637	5111	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5111	26	position	position	NN
18637	5111	27	.	.	.
18637	5112	1	In	in	IN
18637	5112	2	the	the	DT
18637	5112	3	case	case	NN
18637	5112	4	of	of	IN
18637	5112	5	the	the	DT
18637	5112	6	Brigantine	Brigantine	NNP
18637	5112	7	William	William	NNP
18637	5112	8	the	the	DT
18637	5112	9	validity	validity	NN
18637	5112	10	of	of	IN
18637	5112	11	the	the	DT
18637	5112	12	embargo	embargo	NN
18637	5112	13	was	be	VBD
18637	5112	14	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	5112	15	before	before	IN
18637	5112	16	the	the	DT
18637	5112	17	United	United	NNP
18637	5112	18	States	States	NNP
18637	5112	19	District	District	NNP
18637	5112	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5112	21	of	of	IN
18637	5112	22	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	5112	23	on	on	IN
18637	5112	24	the	the	DT
18637	5112	25	ground	ground	NN
18637	5112	26	that	that	IN
18637	5112	27	the	the	DT
18637	5112	28	power	power	NN
18637	5112	29	to	to	TO
18637	5112	30	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5112	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5112	32	did	do	VBD
18637	5112	33	not	not	RB
18637	5112	34	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	5112	35	the	the	DT
18637	5112	36	power	power	NN
18637	5112	37	to	to	TO
18637	5112	38	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	5112	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5112	40	.	.	.
18637	5113	1	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	5113	2	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	5113	3	answered	answer	VBD
18637	5113	4	:	:	:
18637	5113	5	"	"	``
18637	5113	6	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5113	7	will	will	MD
18637	5113	8	be	be	VB
18637	5113	9	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	5113	10	that	that	IN
18637	5113	11	partial	partial	JJ
18637	5113	12	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
18637	5113	13	are	be	VBP
18637	5113	14	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	5113	15	by	by	IN
18637	5113	16	this	this	DT
18637	5113	17	expression	expression	NN
18637	5113	18	;	;	:
18637	5113	19	and	and	CC
18637	5113	20	how	how	WRB
18637	5113	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	5113	22	the	the	DT
18637	5113	23	degree	degree	NN
18637	5113	24	,	,	,
18637	5113	25	or	or	CC
18637	5113	26	extent	extent	NN
18637	5113	27	,	,	,
18637	5113	28	of	of	IN
18637	5113	29	the	the	DT
18637	5113	30	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	5113	31	be	be	VB
18637	5113	32	adjusted	adjust	VBN
18637	5113	33	,	,	,
18637	5113	34	but	but	CC
18637	5113	35	by	by	IN
18637	5113	36	the	the	DT
18637	5113	37	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	5113	38	of	of	IN
18637	5113	39	the	the	DT
18637	5113	40	National	National	NNP
18637	5113	41	Government	Government	NNP
18637	5113	42	,	,	,
18637	5113	43	to	to	TO
18637	5113	44	whom	whom	WP
18637	5113	45	the	the	DT
18637	5113	46	subject	subject	NN
18637	5113	47	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	5113	48	to	to	TO
18637	5113	49	have	have	VB
18637	5113	50	been	be	VBN
18637	5113	51	committed	commit	VBN
18637	5113	52	?	?	.
18637	5114	1	*	*	NFP
18637	5114	2	*	*	NFP
18637	5114	3	*	*	NFP
18637	5114	4	The	the	DT
18637	5114	5	power	power	NN
18637	5114	6	to	to	TO
18637	5114	7	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5114	8	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5114	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	5114	10	not	not	RB
18637	5114	11	to	to	TO
18637	5114	12	be	be	VB
18637	5114	13	confined	confine	VBN
18637	5114	14	to	to	IN
18637	5114	15	the	the	DT
18637	5114	16	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	5114	17	of	of	IN
18637	5114	18	measures	measure	NNS
18637	5114	19	,	,	,
18637	5114	20	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	5114	21	beneficial	beneficial	JJ
18637	5114	22	to	to	IN
18637	5114	23	commerce	commerce	VB
18637	5114	24	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5114	25	,	,	,
18637	5114	26	or	or	CC
18637	5114	27	tending	tend	VBG
18637	5114	28	to	to	IN
18637	5114	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5114	30	advancement	advancement	NN
18637	5114	31	;	;	:
18637	5114	32	but	but	CC
18637	5114	33	,	,	,
18637	5114	34	in	in	IN
18637	5114	35	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5114	36	national	national	JJ
18637	5114	37	system	system	NN
18637	5114	38	,	,	,
18637	5114	39	as	as	IN
18637	5114	40	in	in	IN
18637	5114	41	all	all	DT
18637	5114	42	modern	modern	JJ
18637	5114	43	sovereignties	sovereignty	NNS
18637	5114	44	,	,	,
18637	5114	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5114	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	5114	47	also	also	RB
18637	5114	48	to	to	TO
18637	5114	49	be	be	VB
18637	5114	50	considered	consider	VBN
18637	5114	51	as	as	IN
18637	5114	52	an	an	DT
18637	5114	53	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	5114	54	for	for	IN
18637	5114	55	other	other	JJ
18637	5114	56	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	5114	57	of	of	IN
18637	5114	58	general	general	JJ
18637	5114	59	policy	policy	NN
18637	5114	60	and	and	CC
18637	5114	61	interest	interest	NN
18637	5114	62	.	.	.
18637	5115	1	*	*	NFP
18637	5115	2	*	*	NFP
18637	5115	3	*	*	NFP
18637	5115	4	the	the	DT
18637	5115	5	national	national	JJ
18637	5115	6	right	right	NN
18637	5115	7	,	,	,
18637	5115	8	or	or	CC
18637	5115	9	power	power	NN
18637	5115	10	,	,	,
18637	5115	11	under	under	IN
18637	5115	12	the	the	DT
18637	5115	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5115	14	,	,	,
18637	5115	15	to	to	TO
18637	5115	16	adapt	adapt	VB
18637	5115	17	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	5115	18	of	of	IN
18637	5115	19	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5115	20	to	to	IN
18637	5115	21	other	other	JJ
18637	5115	22	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	5115	23	,	,	,
18637	5115	24	than	than	IN
18637	5115	25	the	the	DT
18637	5115	26	mere	mere	JJ
18637	5115	27	advancement	advancement	NN
18637	5115	28	of	of	IN
18637	5115	29	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	5115	30	,	,	,
18637	5115	31	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	5115	32	to	to	TO
18637	5115	33	be	be	VB
18637	5115	34	unquestionable	unquestionable	JJ
18637	5115	35	.	.	.
18637	5116	1	*	*	NFP
18637	5116	2	*	*	NFP
18637	5116	3	*	*	NFP
18637	5116	4	The	the	DT
18637	5116	5	situation	situation	NN
18637	5116	6	of	of	IN
18637	5116	7	the	the	DT
18637	5116	8	United	United	NNP
18637	5116	9	States	States	NNP
18637	5116	10	,	,	,
18637	5116	11	in	in	IN
18637	5116	12	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	5116	13	times	time	NNS
18637	5116	14	,	,	,
18637	5116	15	might	may	MD
18637	5116	16	render	render	VB
18637	5116	17	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	5116	18	interferences	interference	NNS
18637	5116	19	,	,	,
18637	5116	20	relative	relative	JJ
18637	5116	21	to	to	IN
18637	5116	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5116	23	,	,	,
18637	5116	24	less	less	RBR
18637	5116	25	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	5116	26	;	;	:
18637	5116	27	but	but	CC
18637	5116	28	the	the	DT
18637	5116	29	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	5116	30	and	and	CC
18637	5116	31	power	power	NN
18637	5116	32	of	of	IN
18637	5116	33	managing	manage	VBG
18637	5116	34	and	and	CC
18637	5116	35	directing	direct	VBG
18637	5116	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5116	37	,	,	,
18637	5116	38	for	for	IN
18637	5116	39	the	the	DT
18637	5116	40	advancement	advancement	NN
18637	5116	41	of	of	IN
18637	5116	42	great	great	JJ
18637	5116	43	national	national	JJ
18637	5116	44	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	5116	45	,	,	,
18637	5116	46	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	5116	47	an	an	DT
18637	5116	48	important	important	JJ
18637	5116	49	ingredient	ingredient	NN
18637	5116	50	of	of	IN
18637	5116	51	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	5116	52	.	.	.
18637	5116	53	"	"	''
18637	5117	1	And	and	CC
18637	5117	2	in	in	IN
18637	5117	3	confirmation	confirmation	NN
18637	5117	4	of	of	IN
18637	5117	5	this	this	DT
18637	5117	6	argument	argument	NN
18637	5117	7	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	5117	8	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	5117	9	cited	cite	VBD
18637	5117	10	the	the	DT
18637	5117	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	5117	12	of	of	IN
18637	5117	13	§	§	NNP
18637	5117	14	9	9	CD
18637	5117	15	of	of	IN
18637	5117	16	article	article	NN
18637	5117	17	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5117	18	of	of	IN
18637	5117	19	the	the	DT
18637	5117	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5117	21	interdicting	interdict	VBG
18637	5117	22	a	a	DT
18637	5117	23	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	5117	24	of	of	IN
18637	5117	25	the	the	DT
18637	5117	26	slave	slave	NN
18637	5117	27	trade	trade	NN
18637	5117	28	till	till	IN
18637	5117	29	1808	1808	CD
18637	5117	30	.	.	.
18637	5118	1	This	this	DT
18637	5118	2	clause	clause	NN
18637	5118	3	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	5118	4	proves	prove	VBZ
18637	5118	5	that	that	IN
18637	5118	6	those	those	DT
18637	5118	7	who	who	WP
18637	5118	8	framed	frame	VBD
18637	5118	9	the	the	DT
18637	5118	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5118	11	perceived	perceive	VBD
18637	5118	12	that	that	IN
18637	5118	13	"	"	``
18637	5118	14	under	under	IN
18637	5118	15	the	the	DT
18637	5118	16	power	power	NN
18637	5118	17	of	of	IN
18637	5118	18	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	5118	19	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5118	20	,	,	,
18637	5118	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5118	22	would	would	MD
18637	5118	23	be	be	VB
18637	5118	24	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	5118	25	to	to	TO
18637	5118	26	abridge	abridge	VB
18637	5118	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5118	28	,	,	,
18637	5118	29	in	in	IN
18637	5118	30	favour	favour	NN
18637	5118	31	of	of	IN
18637	5118	32	the	the	DT
18637	5118	33	great	great	JJ
18637	5118	34	principles	principle	NNS
18637	5118	35	of	of	IN
18637	5118	36	humanity	humanity	NN
18637	5118	37	and	and	CC
18637	5118	38	justice	justice	NN
18637	5118	39	.	.	.
18637	5118	40	"	"	''
18637	5119	1	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	5119	2	.	.	.
18637	5120	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	5120	2	.	.	.
18637	5121	1	No	no	UH
18637	5121	2	.	.	.
18637	5122	1	16,700	16,700	CD
18637	5122	2	,	,	,
18637	5122	3	614	614	CD
18637	5122	4	,	,	,
18637	5122	5	621	621	CD
18637	5122	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5122	7	1808	1808	CD
18637	5122	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5122	9	.	.	.
18637	5123	1	The	the	DT
18637	5123	2	embargo	embargo	NN
18637	5123	3	,	,	,
18637	5123	4	to	to	TO
18637	5123	5	be	be	VB
18637	5123	6	sure	sure	JJ
18637	5123	7	,	,	,
18637	5123	8	operated	operate	VBN
18637	5123	9	on	on	IN
18637	5123	10	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	5123	11	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5123	12	;	;	:
18637	5123	13	but	but	CC
18637	5123	14	that	that	IN
18637	5123	15	there	there	EX
18637	5123	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	5123	17	any	any	DT
18637	5123	18	difference	difference	NN
18637	5123	19	between	between	IN
18637	5123	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5123	21	's	's	POS
18637	5123	22	power	power	NN
18637	5123	23	in	in	IN
18637	5123	24	relation	relation	NN
18637	5123	25	to	to	IN
18637	5123	26	foreign	foreign	NN
18637	5123	27	and	and	CC
18637	5123	28	to	to	TO
18637	5123	29	interstate	interstate	VB
18637	5123	30	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	5123	31	the	the	DT
18637	5123	32	advocates	advocate	NNS
18637	5123	33	of	of	IN
18637	5123	34	the	the	DT
18637	5123	35	view	view	NN
18637	5123	36	under	under	IN
18637	5123	37	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	5123	38	denied	deny	VBN
18637	5123	39	.	.	.
18637	5124	1	The	the	DT
18637	5124	2	power	power	NN
18637	5124	3	to	to	TO
18637	5124	4	"	"	``
18637	5124	5	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5124	6	"	"	''
18637	5124	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	5124	8	the	the	DT
18637	5124	9	power	power	NN
18637	5124	10	which	which	WDT
18637	5124	11	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	5124	12	to	to	IN
18637	5124	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5124	14	as	as	IN
18637	5124	15	to	to	IN
18637	5124	16	the	the	DT
18637	5124	17	one	one	NN
18637	5124	18	as	as	RB
18637	5124	19	well	well	RB
18637	5124	20	as	as	IN
18637	5124	21	to	to	IN
18637	5124	22	the	the	DT
18637	5124	23	other	other	JJ
18637	5124	24	;	;	:
18637	5124	25	and	and	CC
18637	5124	26	if	if	IN
18637	5124	27	this	this	DT
18637	5124	28	comprehends	comprehend	VBZ
18637	5124	29	the	the	DT
18637	5124	30	power	power	NN
18637	5124	31	to	to	TO
18637	5124	32	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	5124	33	in	in	IN
18637	5124	34	the	the	DT
18637	5124	35	one	one	CD
18637	5124	36	case	case	NN
18637	5124	37	,	,	,
18637	5124	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5124	39	must	must	MD
18637	5124	40	equally	equally	RB
18637	5124	41	,	,	,
18637	5124	42	by	by	IN
18637	5124	43	acknowledged	acknowledged	JJ
18637	5124	44	principles	principle	NNS
18637	5124	45	of	of	IN
18637	5124	46	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	5124	47	construction	construction	NN
18637	5124	48	,	,	,
18637	5124	49	comprehend	comprehend	VB
18637	5124	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5124	51	in	in	IN
18637	5124	52	the	the	DT
18637	5124	53	other	other	JJ
18637	5124	54	case	case	NN
18637	5124	55	as	as	RB
18637	5124	56	well	well	RB
18637	5124	57	.	.	.
18637	5125	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	5125	2	in	in	IN
18637	5125	3	fact	fact	NN
18637	5125	4	,	,	,
18637	5125	5	the	the	DT
18637	5125	6	argument	argument	NN
18637	5125	7	continued	continue	VBD
18637	5125	8	,	,	,
18637	5125	9	does	do	VBZ
18637	5125	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5125	11	make	make	VB
18637	5125	12	any	any	DT
18637	5125	13	difference	difference	NN
18637	5125	14	,	,	,
18637	5125	15	by	by	IN
18637	5125	16	approved	approve	VBN
18637	5125	17	principles	principle	NNS
18637	5125	18	of	of	IN
18637	5125	19	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	5125	20	construction	construction	NN
18637	5125	21	,	,	,
18637	5125	22	what	what	WP
18637	5125	23	purposes	purpose	VBZ
18637	5125	24	the	the	DT
18637	5125	25	framers	framer	NNS
18637	5125	26	of	of	IN
18637	5125	27	the	the	DT
18637	5125	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5125	29	may	may	MD
18637	5125	30	have	have	VB
18637	5125	31	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	5125	32	in	in	IN
18637	5125	33	mind	mind	NN
18637	5125	34	when	when	WRB
18637	5125	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5125	36	gave	give	VBD
18637	5125	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5125	38	power	power	NN
18637	5125	39	to	to	TO
18637	5125	40	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5125	41	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5125	42	among	among	IN
18637	5125	43	the	the	DT
18637	5125	44	States	States	NNP
18637	5125	45	;	;	:
18637	5125	46	the	the	DT
18637	5125	47	governing	govern	VBG
18637	5125	48	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	5125	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	5125	50	that	that	IN
18637	5125	51	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5125	52	gave	give	VBD
18637	5125	53	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5125	54	the	the	DT
18637	5125	55	power	power	NN
18637	5125	56	,	,	,
18637	5125	57	to	to	TO
18637	5125	58	be	be	VB
18637	5125	59	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	5125	60	in	in	IN
18637	5125	61	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	5125	62	with	with	IN
18637	5125	63	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5125	64	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	5125	65	of	of	IN
18637	5125	66	what	what	WP
18637	5125	67	are	be	VBP
18637	5125	68	proper	proper	JJ
18637	5125	69	occasions	occasion	NNS
18637	5125	70	for	for	IN
18637	5125	71	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5125	72	use	use	NN
18637	5125	73	.	.	.
18637	5126	1	"	"	``
18637	5126	2	The	the	DT
18637	5126	3	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	5126	4	which	which	WDT
18637	5126	5	may	may	MD
18637	5126	6	have	have	VB
18637	5126	7	caused	cause	VBN
18637	5126	8	the	the	DT
18637	5126	9	framers	framer	NNS
18637	5126	10	of	of	IN
18637	5126	11	the	the	DT
18637	5126	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5126	13	to	to	TO
18637	5126	14	repose	repose	VB
18637	5126	15	the	the	DT
18637	5126	16	power	power	NN
18637	5126	17	to	to	TO
18637	5126	18	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5126	19	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5126	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5126	21	in	in	IN
18637	5126	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5126	23	do	do	VBP
18637	5126	24	not	not	RB
18637	5126	25	,	,	,
18637	5126	26	however	however	RB
18637	5126	27	,	,	,
18637	5126	28	affect	affect	VB
18637	5126	29	or	or	CC
18637	5126	30	limit	limit	VB
18637	5126	31	the	the	DT
18637	5126	32	extent	extent	NN
18637	5126	33	of	of	IN
18637	5126	34	the	the	DT
18637	5126	35	power	power	NN
18637	5126	36	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5126	37	.	.	.
18637	5126	38	"	"	''
18637	5127	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5127	2	Peckham	Peckham	NNP
18637	5127	3	for	for	IN
18637	5127	4	the	the	DT
18637	5127	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5127	6	in	in	IN
18637	5127	7	Addyston	Addyston	NNP
18637	5127	8	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	5127	9	&	&	CC
18637	5127	10	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	5127	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5127	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5127	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	5127	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5127	15	United	United	NNP
18637	5127	16	States	States	NNP
18637	5127	17	,	,	,
18637	5127	18	175	175	CD
18637	5127	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5127	20	211	211	CD
18637	5127	21	,	,	,
18637	5127	22	228	228	CD
18637	5127	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5127	24	1899	1899	CD
18637	5127	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5127	26	.	.	.
18637	5128	1	References	reference	NNS
18637	5128	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5128	3	See	See	NNP
18637	5128	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5128	5	especially	especially	RB
18637	5128	6	the	the	DT
18637	5128	7	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	5128	8	of	of	IN
18637	5128	9	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	5128	10	In	in	IN
18637	5128	11	re	re	NN
18637	5128	12	Rapier	Rapier	NNP
18637	5128	13	,	,	,
18637	5128	14	143	143	CD
18637	5128	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5128	16	110	110	CD
18637	5128	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5128	18	1892	1892	CD
18637	5128	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5128	20	;	;	:
18637	5128	21	Champion	Champion	NNP
18637	5128	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5128	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	5128	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5128	25	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	5128	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5128	27	Lottery	Lottery	NNP
18637	5128	28	Case	Case	NNP
18637	5128	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5128	30	,	,	,
18637	5128	31	188	188	CD
18637	5128	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5128	33	321	321	CD
18637	5128	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5128	35	1903	1903	CD
18637	5128	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5128	37	;	;	:
18637	5128	38	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	5128	39	_	_	NNP
18637	5128	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	5128	41	_	_	NNP
18637	5128	42	Dagenhart	Dagenhart	NNP
18637	5128	43	,	,	,
18637	5128	44	247	247	CD
18637	5128	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5128	46	251	251	CD
18637	5128	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5128	48	1918	1918	CD
18637	5128	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5128	50	;	;	:
18637	5128	51	3	3	CD
18637	5128	52	Selected	select	VBN
18637	5128	53	Essays	essay	NNS
18637	5128	54	on	on	IN
18637	5128	55	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	5128	56	Law	Law	NNP
18637	5128	57	,	,	,
18637	5128	58	103	103	CD
18637	5128	59	,	,	,
18637	5128	60	138	138	CD
18637	5128	61	,	,	,
18637	5128	62	165	165	CD
18637	5128	63	,	,	,
18637	5128	64	295	295	CD
18637	5128	65	,	,	,
18637	5128	66	314	314	CD
18637	5128	67	,	,	,
18637	5128	68	336	336	CD
18637	5128	69	.	.	.
18637	5129	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	5129	2	,	,	,
18637	5129	3	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	5129	4	of	of	IN
18637	5129	5	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5129	6	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5129	7	by	by	IN
18637	5129	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5129	9	may	may	MD
18637	5129	10	take	take	VB
18637	5129	11	the	the	DT
18637	5129	12	form	form	NN
18637	5129	13	of	of	IN
18637	5129	14	a	a	DT
18637	5129	15	positive	positive	JJ
18637	5129	16	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	5129	17	by	by	IN
18637	5129	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5129	19	of	of	IN
18637	5129	20	a	a	DT
18637	5129	21	regime	regime	NN
18637	5129	22	of	of	IN
18637	5129	23	State	State	NNP
18637	5129	24	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	5129	25	in	in	IN
18637	5129	26	the	the	DT
18637	5129	27	form	form	NN
18637	5129	28	of	of	IN
18637	5129	29	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	5129	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5129	31	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	5129	32	,	,	,
18637	5129	33	pilotage	pilotage	NN
18637	5129	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5129	35	or	or	CC
18637	5129	36	of	of	IN
18637	5129	37	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	5129	38	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	5129	39	in	in	IN
18637	5129	40	some	some	DT
18637	5129	41	degree	degree	NN
18637	5129	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5129	43	as	as	IN
18637	5129	44	in	in	IN
18637	5129	45	the	the	DT
18637	5129	46	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	5129	47	Carrier	Carrier	NNP
18637	5129	48	Act	Act	NNP
18637	5129	49	of	of	IN
18637	5129	50	1935	1935	CD
18637	5129	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5129	52	;	;	:
18637	5129	53	or	or	CC
18637	5129	54	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5129	55	may	may	MD
18637	5129	56	"	"	``
18637	5129	57	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5129	58	"	"	''
18637	5129	59	through	through	IN
18637	5129	60	the	the	DT
18637	5129	61	device	device	NN
18637	5129	62	of	of	IN
18637	5129	63	divestment	divestment	NN
18637	5129	64	of	of	IN
18637	5129	65	a	a	DT
18637	5129	66	subject	subject	JJ
18637	5129	67	matter	matter	NN
18637	5129	68	of	of	IN
18637	5129	69	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5129	70	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5129	71	character	character	NN
18637	5129	72	,	,	,
18637	5129	73	thus	thus	RB
18637	5129	74	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	5129	75	causing	cause	VBG
18637	5129	76	State	state	NN
18637	5129	77	laws	law	NNS
18637	5129	78	to	to	TO
18637	5129	79	apply	apply	VB
18637	5129	80	,	,	,
18637	5129	81	as	as	IN
18637	5129	82	was	be	VBD
18637	5129	83	done	do	VBN
18637	5129	84	by	by	IN
18637	5129	85	the	the	DT
18637	5129	86	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	5129	87	Act	Act	NNP
18637	5129	88	of	of	IN
18637	5129	89	1890	1890	CD
18637	5129	90	in	in	IN
18637	5129	91	respect	respect	NN
18637	5129	92	to	to	IN
18637	5129	93	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	5129	94	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	5129	95	,	,	,
18637	5129	96	or	or	CC
18637	5129	97	by	by	IN
18637	5129	98	the	the	DT
18637	5129	99	McCarran	McCarran	NNP
18637	5129	100	Act	Act	NNP
18637	5129	101	of	of	IN
18637	5129	102	1945	1945	CD
18637	5129	103	following	follow	VBG
18637	5129	104	the	the	DT
18637	5129	105	United	United	NNP
18637	5129	106	States	States	NNP
18637	5129	107	_	_	NNP
18637	5129	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	5129	109	_	_	NNP
18637	5129	110	South	South	NNP
18637	5129	111	-	-	HYPH
18637	5129	112	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	5129	113	Underwriters	Underwriters	NNPS
18637	5129	114	Association	Association	NNP
18637	5129	115	,	,	,
18637	5129	116	322	322	CD
18637	5129	117	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5129	118	533	533	CD
18637	5129	119	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5129	120	1944	1944	CD
18637	5129	121	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5129	122	,	,	,
18637	5129	123	in	in	IN
18637	5129	124	respect	respect	NN
18637	5129	125	to	to	IN
18637	5129	126	the	the	DT
18637	5129	127	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	5129	128	business	business	NN
18637	5129	129	.	.	.
18637	5130	1	In	in	IN
18637	5130	2	a	a	DT
18637	5130	3	sense	sense	NN
18637	5130	4	,	,	,
18637	5130	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5130	6	may	may	MD
18637	5130	7	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	5130	8	to	to	IN
18637	5130	9	the	the	DT
18637	5130	10	States	States	NNP
18637	5130	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5130	12	power	power	NN
18637	5130	13	to	to	TO
18637	5130	14	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5130	15	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5130	16	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5130	17	.	.	.
18637	5131	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5131	2	488	488	CD
18637	5131	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5131	4	23	23	CD
18637	5131	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5131	6	.	.	.
18637	5132	1	31	31	CD
18637	5132	2	.	.	.
18637	5133	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5133	2	489	489	CD
18637	5133	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5133	4	32	32	CD
18637	5133	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5133	6	.	.	.
18637	5134	1	791	791	CD
18637	5134	2	.	.	.
18637	5135	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5135	2	490	490	CD
18637	5135	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5135	4	33	33	CD
18637	5135	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5135	6	.	.	.
18637	5136	1	1264	1264	CD
18637	5136	2	.	.	.
18637	5137	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5137	2	491	491	CD
18637	5137	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5137	4	33	33	CD
18637	5137	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5137	6	.	.	.
18637	5138	1	1269	1269	CD
18637	5138	2	.	.	.
18637	5139	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5139	2	492	492	CD
18637	5139	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5139	4	37	37	CD
18637	5139	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5139	6	.	.	.
18637	5140	1	315	315	CD
18637	5140	2	.	.	.
18637	5141	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5141	2	493	493	CD
18637	5141	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5141	4	39	39	CD
18637	5141	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5141	6	.	.	.
18637	5142	1	1165	1165	CD
18637	5142	2	.	.	.
18637	5143	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5143	2	494	494	CD
18637	5143	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5143	4	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5143	5	Central	Central	NNP
18637	5143	6	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5143	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5143	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5143	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5143	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5143	11	McKendree	McKendree	NNP
18637	5143	12	,	,	,
18637	5143	13	203	203	CD
18637	5143	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5143	15	514	514	CD
18637	5143	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5143	17	1906	1906	CD
18637	5143	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5143	19	.	.	.
18637	5144	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5144	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5144	3	also	also	RB
18637	5144	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5144	5	United	United	NNP
18637	5144	6	States	States	NNP
18637	5144	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5144	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5144	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5144	10	DeWitt	DeWitt	NNP
18637	5144	11	,	,	,
18637	5144	12	9	9	CD
18637	5144	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5144	14	.	.	.
18637	5145	1	41	41	CD
18637	5145	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5145	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	5145	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5145	5	.	.	.
18637	5146	1	Of	of	IN
18637	5146	2	the	the	DT
18637	5146	3	nature	nature	NN
18637	5146	4	of	of	IN
18637	5146	5	a	a	DT
18637	5146	6	quarantine	quarantine	JJ
18637	5146	7	act	act	NN
18637	5146	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	5146	9	the	the	DT
18637	5146	10	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	5146	11	Firearms	Firearms	NNPS
18637	5146	12	Act	Act	NNP
18637	5146	13	of	of	IN
18637	5146	14	1938	1938	CD
18637	5146	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5146	16	52	52	CD
18637	5146	17	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5146	18	1250	1250	CD
18637	5146	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5146	20	.	.	.
18637	5147	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5147	2	495	495	CD
18637	5147	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5147	4	Champion	Champion	NNP
18637	5147	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5147	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5147	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5147	8	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	5147	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5147	10	The	the	DT
18637	5147	11	Lottery	Lottery	NNP
18637	5147	12	Case	Case	NNP
18637	5147	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5147	14	,	,	,
18637	5147	15	188	188	CD
18637	5147	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5147	17	321	321	CD
18637	5147	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5147	19	1903	1903	CD
18637	5147	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5147	21	.	.	.
18637	5148	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5148	2	496	496	CD
18637	5148	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5148	4	28	28	CD
18637	5148	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5148	6	963	963	CD
18637	5148	7	.	.	.
18637	5149	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5149	2	497	497	CD
18637	5149	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5149	4	143	143	CD
18637	5149	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5149	6	110	110	CD
18637	5149	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5149	8	1892	1892	CD
18637	5149	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5149	10	.	.	.
18637	5150	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5150	2	498	498	CD
18637	5150	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5150	4	Champion	Champion	NNP
18637	5150	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5150	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5150	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5150	8	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	5150	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5150	10	The	the	DT
18637	5150	11	Lottery	Lottery	NNP
18637	5150	12	Case	Case	NNP
18637	5150	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5150	14	,	,	,
18637	5150	15	188	188	CD
18637	5150	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5150	17	321	321	CD
18637	5150	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5150	19	1903	1903	CD
18637	5150	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5150	21	.	.	.
18637	5151	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5151	2	499	499	CD
18637	5151	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5151	4	9	9	CD
18637	5151	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5151	6	.	.	.
18637	5152	1	1	1	CD
18637	5152	2	,	,	,
18637	5152	3	227	227	CD
18637	5152	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5152	5	1824	1824	CD
18637	5152	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5152	7	.	.	.
18637	5153	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5153	2	500	500	CD
18637	5153	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5153	4	114	114	CD
18637	5153	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5153	6	622	622	CD
18637	5153	7	,	,	,
18637	5153	8	630	630	CD
18637	5153	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5153	10	1885	1885	CD
18637	5153	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5153	12	.	.	.
18637	5154	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5154	2	501	501	CD
18637	5154	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5154	4	26	26	CD
18637	5154	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5154	6	.	.	.
18637	5155	1	313	313	CD
18637	5155	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5155	3	1890	1890	CD
18637	5155	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5155	5	;	;	:
18637	5155	6	37	37	CD
18637	5155	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	5155	8	.	.	.
18637	5156	1	699	699	CD
18637	5156	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5156	3	1913	1913	CD
18637	5156	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5156	5	,	,	,
18637	5156	6	"	"	``
18637	5156	7	The	the	DT
18637	5156	8	Webb	Webb	NNP
18637	5156	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	5156	10	Kenyon	Kenyon	NNP
18637	5156	11	Act	Act	NNP
18637	5156	12	.	.	.
18637	5156	13	"	"	''
18637	5157	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5157	2	502	502	CD
18637	5157	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5157	4	31	31	CD
18637	5157	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5157	6	.	.	.
18637	5158	1	188	188	CD
18637	5158	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5158	3	1900	1900	CD
18637	5158	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5158	5	.	.	.
18637	5159	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5159	2	503	503	CD
18637	5159	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5159	4	45	45	CD
18637	5159	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5159	6	.	.	.
18637	5160	1	1084	1084	CD
18637	5160	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5160	3	1929	1929	CD
18637	5160	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5160	5	,	,	,
18637	5160	6	"	"	``
18637	5160	7	The	the	DT
18637	5160	8	Hawes	Hawes	NNP
18637	5160	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	5160	10	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	5160	11	Act	Act	NNP
18637	5160	12	.	.	.
18637	5160	13	"	"	''
18637	5161	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5161	2	504	504	CD
18637	5161	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5161	4	36	36	CD
18637	5161	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5161	6	.	.	.
18637	5162	1	825	825	CD
18637	5162	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5162	3	1910	1910	CD
18637	5162	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5162	5	,	,	,
18637	5162	6	"	"	``
18637	5162	7	The	the	DT
18637	5162	8	Mann	Mann	NNP
18637	5162	9	Act	Act	NNP
18637	5162	10	.	.	.
18637	5162	11	"	"	''
18637	5163	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5163	2	505	505	CD
18637	5163	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5163	4	41	41	CD
18637	5163	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	5163	6	.	.	.
18637	5164	1	324	324	CD
18637	5164	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5164	3	1919	1919	CD
18637	5164	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5164	5	.	.	.
18637	5165	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5165	2	506	506	CD
18637	5165	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5165	4	47	47	CD
18637	5165	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5165	6	.	.	.
18637	5166	1	326	326	CD
18637	5166	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5166	3	1932	1932	CD
18637	5166	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5166	5	.	.	.
18637	5167	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5167	2	507	507	CD
18637	5167	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5167	4	48	48	CD
18637	5167	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5167	6	.	.	.
18637	5168	1	794	794	CD
18637	5168	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5168	3	1934	1934	CD
18637	5168	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5168	5	.	.	.
18637	5169	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5169	2	508	508	CD
18637	5169	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5169	4	48	48	CD
18637	5169	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5169	6	.	.	.
18637	5170	1	979	979	CD
18637	5170	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5170	3	1934	1934	CD
18637	5170	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5170	5	.	.	.
18637	5171	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5171	2	509	509	CD
18637	5171	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5171	4	54	54	CD
18637	5171	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5171	6	.	.	.
18637	5172	1	686	686	CD
18637	5172	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5172	3	1940	1940	CD
18637	5172	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5172	5	.	.	.
18637	5173	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5173	2	510	510	CD
18637	5173	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5173	4	Hoke	Hoke	NNP
18637	5173	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5173	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5173	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5173	8	United	United	NNP
18637	5173	9	States	States	NNP
18637	5173	10	,	,	,
18637	5173	11	227	227	CD
18637	5173	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5173	13	308	308	CD
18637	5173	14	,	,	,
18637	5173	15	322	322	CD
18637	5173	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5173	17	1913	1913	CD
18637	5173	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5173	19	.	.	.
18637	5174	1	In	in	IN
18637	5174	2	Caminetti	Caminetti	NNP
18637	5174	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5174	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	5174	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5174	6	United	United	NNP
18637	5174	7	States	States	NNP
18637	5174	8	,	,	,
18637	5174	9	242	242	CD
18637	5174	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5174	11	470	470	CD
18637	5174	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5174	13	1917	1917	CD
18637	5174	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5174	15	the	the	DT
18637	5174	16	act	act	NN
18637	5174	17	was	be	VBD
18637	5174	18	held	hold	VBN
18637	5174	19	to	to	TO
18637	5174	20	apply	apply	VB
18637	5174	21	to	to	IN
18637	5174	22	the	the	DT
18637	5174	23	case	case	NN
18637	5174	24	of	of	IN
18637	5174	25	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	5174	26	of	of	IN
18637	5174	27	a	a	DT
18637	5174	28	woman	woman	NN
18637	5174	29	for	for	IN
18637	5174	30	immoral	immoral	JJ
18637	5174	31	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	5174	32	,	,	,
18637	5174	33	although	although	IN
18637	5174	34	no	no	DT
18637	5174	35	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	5174	36	motive	motive	NN
18637	5174	37	was	be	VBD
18637	5174	38	present	present	JJ
18637	5174	39	;	;	:
18637	5174	40	and	and	CC
18637	5174	41	in	in	IN
18637	5174	42	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
18637	5174	43	_	_	NNP
18637	5174	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	5174	45	_	_	NNP
18637	5174	46	United	United	NNP
18637	5174	47	States	States	NNP
18637	5174	48	,	,	,
18637	5174	49	329	329	CD
18637	5174	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5174	51	14	14	CD
18637	5174	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5174	53	1946	1946	CD
18637	5174	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5174	55	,	,	,
18637	5174	56	to	to	IN
18637	5174	57	the	the	DT
18637	5174	58	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	5174	59	of	of	IN
18637	5174	60	a	a	DT
18637	5174	61	plural	plural	JJ
18637	5174	62	wife	wife	NN
18637	5174	63	by	by	IN
18637	5174	64	the	the	DT
18637	5174	65	member	member	NN
18637	5174	66	of	of	IN
18637	5174	67	a	a	DT
18637	5174	68	religious	religious	JJ
18637	5174	69	sect	sect	NN
18637	5174	70	a	a	DT
18637	5174	71	tenet	tenet	NN
18637	5174	72	of	of	IN
18637	5174	73	which	which	WDT
18637	5174	74	is	be	VBZ
18637	5174	75	polygamy	polygamy	JJ
18637	5174	76	.	.	.
18637	5175	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5175	2	511	511	CD
18637	5175	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5175	4	United	United	NNP
18637	5175	5	States	States	NNP
18637	5175	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5175	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5175	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5175	9	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	5175	10	,	,	,
18637	5175	11	248	248	CD
18637	5175	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5175	13	420	420	CD
18637	5175	14	,	,	,
18637	5175	15	425	425	CD
18637	5175	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5175	17	1919	1919	CD
18637	5175	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5175	19	.	.	.
18637	5176	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5176	2	512	512	CD
18637	5176	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5176	4	247	247	CD
18637	5176	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5176	6	251	251	CD
18637	5176	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5176	8	1918	1918	CD
18637	5176	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5176	10	.	.	.
18637	5177	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5177	2	513	513	CD
18637	5177	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5177	4	39	39	CD
18637	5177	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5177	6	.	.	.
18637	5178	1	675	675	CD
18637	5178	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5178	3	1916	1916	CD
18637	5178	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5178	5	.	.	.
18637	5179	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5179	2	514	514	CD
18637	5179	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5179	4	247	247	CD
18637	5179	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5179	6	at	at	IN
18637	5179	7	275	275	CD
18637	5179	8	.	.	.
18637	5180	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5180	2	515	515	CD
18637	5180	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5180	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5180	5	.	.	.
18637	5181	1	271	271	CD
18637	5181	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5181	3	272	272	CD
18637	5181	4	.	.	.
18637	5182	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5182	2	516	516	CD
18637	5182	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5182	4	267	267	CD
18637	5182	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5182	6	432	432	CD
18637	5182	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5182	8	1925	1925	CD
18637	5182	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5182	10	.	.	.
18637	5183	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5183	2	517	517	CD
18637	5183	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5183	4	41	41	CD
18637	5183	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	5183	6	.	.	.
18637	5184	1	324	324	CD
18637	5184	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5184	3	1919	1919	CD
18637	5184	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5184	5	.	.	.
18637	5185	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5185	2	518	518	CD
18637	5185	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5185	4	267	267	CD
18637	5185	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5185	6	at	at	IN
18637	5185	7	436	436	CD
18637	5185	8	-	-	SYM
18637	5185	9	439	439	CD
18637	5185	10	.	.	.
18637	5186	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5186	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5186	3	also	also	RB
18637	5186	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5186	5	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5186	6	Whip	Whip	NNP
18637	5186	7	&	&	CC
18637	5186	8	Collar	Collar	NNP
18637	5186	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5186	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5186	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	5186	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5186	13	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5186	14	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	5187	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5187	2	,	,	,
18637	5187	3	299	299	CD
18637	5187	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5187	5	334	334	CD
18637	5187	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5187	7	1937	1937	CD
18637	5187	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5187	9	.	.	.
18637	5188	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5188	2	519	519	CD
18637	5188	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5188	4	United	United	NNP
18637	5188	5	States	States	NNP
18637	5188	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5188	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5188	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5188	9	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	5188	10	,	,	,
18637	5188	11	312	312	CD
18637	5188	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5188	13	100	100	CD
18637	5188	14	,	,	,
18637	5188	15	116	116	CD
18637	5188	16	-	-	SYM
18637	5188	17	117	117	CD
18637	5188	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5188	19	1941	1941	CD
18637	5188	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5188	21	.	.	.
18637	5189	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5189	2	520	520	CD
18637	5189	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5189	4	Roland	Roland	NNP
18637	5189	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5189	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5189	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5189	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5189	9	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	5189	10	,	,	,
18637	5189	11	326	326	CD
18637	5189	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5189	13	657	657	CD
18637	5189	14	,	,	,
18637	5189	15	669	669	CD
18637	5189	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5189	17	1946	1946	CD
18637	5189	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5189	19	.	.	.
18637	5190	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5190	2	521	521	CD
18637	5190	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5190	4	Polish	Polish	NNP
18637	5190	5	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	5190	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5190	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5190	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5190	9	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	5190	10	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5190	11	,	,	,
18637	5190	12	322	322	CD
18637	5190	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5190	14	643	643	CD
18637	5190	15	,	,	,
18637	5190	16	650	650	CD
18637	5190	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5190	18	1944	1944	CD
18637	5190	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5190	20	.	.	.
18637	5191	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5191	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	5191	3	.	.	.
18637	5191	4	_	_	IN
18637	5191	5	the	the	DT
18637	5191	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	5191	7	of	of	IN
18637	5191	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	5191	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5191	10	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	5191	11	for	for	IN
18637	5191	12	the	the	DT
18637	5191	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5191	14	in	in	IN
18637	5191	15	Bus	Bus	NNP
18637	5191	16	Employees	Employees	NNP
18637	5191	17	_	_	NNP
18637	5191	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	5191	19	_	_	NNP
18637	5191	20	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	5191	21	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5191	22	,	,	,
18637	5191	23	340	340	CD
18637	5191	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5191	25	383	383	CD
18637	5191	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5191	27	1951	1951	CD
18637	5191	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5191	29	.	.	.
18637	5192	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5192	2	522	522	CD
18637	5192	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5192	4	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	5192	5	No	no	NN
18637	5192	6	.	.	.
18637	5193	1	32	32	CD
18637	5193	2	.	.	.
18637	5194	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5194	2	523	523	CD
18637	5194	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5194	4	9	9	CD
18637	5194	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5194	6	.	.	.
18637	5195	1	1	1	CD
18637	5195	2	,	,	,
18637	5195	3	11	11	CD
18637	5195	4	,	,	,
18637	5195	5	226	226	CD
18637	5195	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5195	7	1824	1824	CD
18637	5195	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5195	9	.	.	.
18637	5196	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5196	2	524	524	CD
18637	5196	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5196	4	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	5196	5	,	,	,
18637	5196	6	IV	IV	NNP
18637	5196	7	,	,	,
18637	5196	8	Letters	Letters	NNPS
18637	5196	9	and	and	CC
18637	5196	10	Other	Other	NNP
18637	5196	11	Writings	Writings	NNPS
18637	5196	12	,	,	,
18637	5196	13	14	14	CD
18637	5196	14	-	-	SYM
18637	5196	15	15	15	CD
18637	5196	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5196	17	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	5196	18	,	,	,
18637	5196	19	1865	1865	CD
18637	5196	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5196	21	.	.	.
18637	5197	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5197	2	525	525	CD
18637	5197	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5197	4	9	9	CD
18637	5197	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5197	6	.	.	.
18637	5198	1	1	1	CD
18637	5198	2	,	,	,
18637	5198	3	203	203	CD
18637	5198	4	.	.	.
18637	5199	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5199	2	526	526	CD
18637	5199	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5199	4	9	9	CD
18637	5199	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5199	6	.	.	.
18637	5200	1	at	at	IN
18637	5200	2	210	210	CD
18637	5200	3	-	-	SYM
18637	5200	4	211	211	CD
18637	5200	5	.	.	.
18637	5201	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5201	2	527	527	CD
18637	5201	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5201	4	9	9	CD
18637	5201	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5201	6	.	.	.
18637	5202	1	at	at	IN
18637	5202	2	13	13	CD
18637	5202	3	-	-	SYM
18637	5202	4	14	14	CD
18637	5202	5	;	;	:
18637	5202	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5202	7	also	also	RB
18637	5202	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5202	9	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	5202	10	.	.	.
18637	5203	1	16	16	CD
18637	5203	2	.	.	.
18637	5204	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5204	2	528	528	CD
18637	5204	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5204	4	9	9	CD
18637	5204	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5204	6	.	.	.
18637	5205	1	17	17	CD
18637	5205	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5205	3	18	18	CD
18637	5205	4	,	,	,
18637	5205	5	209	209	CD
18637	5205	6	.	.	.
18637	5206	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5206	2	529	529	CD
18637	5206	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5206	4	12	12	CD
18637	5206	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5206	6	.	.	.
18637	5207	1	419	419	CD
18637	5207	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5207	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	5207	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5207	5	.	.	.
18637	5208	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5208	2	530	530	CD
18637	5208	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5208	4	12	12	CD
18637	5208	5	How	how	WRB
18637	5208	6	.	.	.
18637	5209	1	299	299	CD
18637	5209	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5209	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	5209	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5209	5	.	.	.
18637	5210	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5210	2	531	531	CD
18637	5210	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5210	4	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	5210	5	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	5210	6	of	of	IN
18637	5210	7	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5210	8	,	,	,
18637	5210	9	however	however	RB
18637	5210	10	,	,	,
18637	5210	11	does	do	VBZ
18637	5210	12	not	not	RB
18637	5210	13	have	have	VB
18637	5210	14	to	to	TO
18637	5210	15	be	be	VB
18637	5210	16	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	5210	17	.	.	.
18637	5211	1	The	the	DT
18637	5211	2	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	5211	3	rule	rule	NN
18637	5211	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	5211	5	a	a	DT
18637	5211	6	test	test	NN
18637	5211	7	of	of	IN
18637	5211	8	the	the	DT
18637	5211	9	invalidity	invalidity	NN
18637	5211	10	of	of	IN
18637	5211	11	State	State	NNP
18637	5211	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	5211	13	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	5211	14	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5211	15	,	,	,
18637	5211	16	not	not	RB
18637	5211	17	the	the	DT
18637	5211	18	validity	validity	NN
18637	5211	19	of	of	IN
18637	5211	20	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	5211	21	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	5211	22	regulating	regulating	NN
18637	5211	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5211	24	.	.	.
18637	5212	1	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	5212	2	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	5212	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5212	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5212	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	5212	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5212	7	W.M.R.	W.M.R.	NNP
18637	5213	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5213	2	,	,	,
18637	5213	3	242	242	CD
18637	5213	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5213	5	311	311	CD
18637	5213	6	,	,	,
18637	5213	7	327	327	CD
18637	5213	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5213	9	1917	1917	CD
18637	5213	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5213	11	;	;	:
18637	5213	12	Currin	Currin	NNP
18637	5213	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5213	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	5213	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5213	16	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	5213	17	,	,	,
18637	5213	18	306	306	CD
18637	5213	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5213	20	1	1	CD
18637	5213	21	,	,	,
18637	5213	22	14	14	CD
18637	5213	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5213	24	1939	1939	CD
18637	5213	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5213	26	;	;	:
18637	5213	27	Prudential	Prudential	NNP
18637	5213	28	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	5213	29	.	.	.
18637	5214	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5214	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5214	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5214	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5214	5	Benjamin	Benjamin	NNP
18637	5214	6	,	,	,
18637	5214	7	328	328	CD
18637	5214	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5214	9	408	408	CD
18637	5214	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5214	11	1946	1946	CD
18637	5214	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5214	13	.	.	.
18637	5215	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5215	2	532	532	CD
18637	5215	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5215	4	Simpson	Simpson	NNP
18637	5215	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5215	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5215	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5215	8	Shepard	Shepard	NNP
18637	5215	9	,	,	,
18637	5215	10	230	230	CD
18637	5215	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5215	12	352	352	CD
18637	5215	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5215	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	5215	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5215	16	.	.	.
18637	5216	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5216	2	533	533	CD
18637	5216	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5216	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5216	5	.	.	.
18637	5217	1	400	400	CD
18637	5217	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5217	3	402	402	CD
18637	5217	4	.	.	.
18637	5218	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5218	2	534	534	CD
18637	5218	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5218	4	McCarroll	McCarroll	NNP
18637	5218	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5218	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5218	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5218	8	Dixie	Dixie	NNP
18637	5218	9	Greyhound	Greyhound	NNP
18637	5218	10	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	5218	11	,	,	,
18637	5218	12	309	309	CD
18637	5218	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5218	14	176	176	CD
18637	5218	15	,	,	,
18637	5218	16	188	188	CD
18637	5218	17	-	-	SYM
18637	5218	18	189	189	CD
18637	5218	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5218	20	1940	1940	CD
18637	5218	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5218	22	.	.	.
18637	5219	1	F.D.G.	F.D.G.	NNP
18637	5220	1	Ribble	ribble	JJ
18637	5220	2	's	's	POS
18637	5220	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5220	4	State	State	NNP
18637	5220	5	and	and	CC
18637	5220	6	National	National	NNP
18637	5220	7	Power	Power	NNP
18637	5220	8	Over	Over	NNP
18637	5220	9	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	5220	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5220	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5220	12	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	5220	13	University	University	NNP
18637	5220	14	Press	Press	NNP
18637	5220	15	,	,	,
18637	5220	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	5220	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5220	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	5220	19	an	an	DT
18637	5220	20	excellent	excellent	JJ
18637	5220	21	study	study	NN
18637	5220	22	both	both	DT
18637	5220	23	of	of	IN
18637	5220	24	the	the	DT
18637	5220	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5220	26	's	's	POS
18637	5220	27	formulas	formula	NNS
18637	5220	28	and	and	CC
18637	5220	29	of	of	IN
18637	5220	30	the	the	DT
18637	5220	31	arbitral	arbitral	JJ
18637	5220	32	character	character	NN
18637	5220	33	of	of	IN
18637	5220	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5220	35	task	task	NN
18637	5220	36	in	in	IN
18637	5220	37	this	this	DT
18637	5220	38	field	field	NN
18637	5220	39	of	of	IN
18637	5220	40	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	5220	41	Law	Law	NNP
18637	5220	42	.	.	.
18637	5221	1	On	on	IN
18637	5221	2	the	the	DT
18637	5221	3	latter	latter	JJ
18637	5221	4	point	point	NN
18637	5221	5	,	,	,
18637	5221	6	see	see	VBP
18637	5221	7	especially	especially	RB
18637	5221	8	Chapters	chapter	NNS
18637	5221	9	X	X	NNP
18637	5221	10	and	and	CC
18637	5221	11	XII	XII	NNP
18637	5221	12	.	.	.
18637	5222	1	The	the	DT
18637	5222	2	late	late	JJ
18637	5222	3	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	5222	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5222	5	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	5222	6	took	take	VBD
18637	5222	7	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	5222	8	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	5222	9	to	to	TO
18637	5222	10	stress	stress	VB
18637	5222	11	the	the	DT
18637	5222	12	"	"	``
18637	5222	13	balancing	balancing	NN
18637	5222	14	"	"	''
18637	5222	15	and	and	CC
18637	5222	16	"	"	``
18637	5222	17	adjusting	adjust	VBG
18637	5222	18	"	"	''
18637	5222	19	role	role	NN
18637	5222	20	of	of	IN
18637	5222	21	the	the	DT
18637	5222	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5222	23	when	when	WRB
18637	5222	24	applying	apply	VBG
18637	5222	25	the	the	DT
18637	5222	26	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	5222	27	clause	clause	NN
18637	5222	28	in	in	IN
18637	5222	29	relation	relation	NN
18637	5222	30	to	to	IN
18637	5222	31	State	state	NN
18637	5222	32	power	power	NN
18637	5222	33	.	.	.
18637	5223	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5223	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5223	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5223	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5223	5	words	word	NNS
18637	5223	6	in	in	IN
18637	5223	7	South	South	NNP
18637	5223	8	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	5223	9	State	State	NNP
18637	5223	10	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	5223	11	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	5223	12	.	.	.
18637	5224	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5224	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5224	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5224	4	Barnwell	Barnwell	NNP
18637	5224	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	5224	6	,	,	,
18637	5224	7	303	303	CD
18637	5224	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5224	9	177	177	CD
18637	5224	10	,	,	,
18637	5224	11	184	184	CD
18637	5224	12	-	-	SYM
18637	5224	13	192	192	CD
18637	5224	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5224	15	1938	1938	CD
18637	5224	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5224	17	;	;	:
18637	5224	18	California	California	NNP
18637	5224	19	_	_	NNP
18637	5224	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	5224	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5224	22	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	5224	23	,	,	,
18637	5224	24	313	313	CD
18637	5224	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5224	26	109	109	CD
18637	5224	27	,	,	,
18637	5224	28	113	113	CD
18637	5224	29	-	-	SYM
18637	5224	30	116	116	CD
18637	5224	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5224	32	1941	1941	CD
18637	5224	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5224	34	;	;	:
18637	5224	35	Parker	Parker	NNP
18637	5224	36	_	_	NNP
18637	5224	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	5224	38	_	_	NNP
18637	5224	39	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	5224	40	,	,	,
18637	5224	41	317	317	CD
18637	5224	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5224	43	341	341	CD
18637	5224	44	,	,	,
18637	5224	45	362	362	CD
18637	5224	46	-	-	HYPH
18637	5224	47	363	363	CD
18637	5224	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5224	49	1943	1943	CD
18637	5224	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5224	51	;	;	:
18637	5224	52	and	and	CC
18637	5224	53	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	5224	54	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	5224	55	_	_	NNP
18637	5224	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	5224	57	_	_	NNP
18637	5224	58	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	5224	59	,	,	,
18637	5224	60	325	325	CD
18637	5224	61	.	.	.
18637	5225	1	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5225	2	761	761	CD
18637	5225	3	,	,	,
18637	5225	4	766	766	CD
18637	5225	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	5225	6	770	770	CD
18637	5225	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5225	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	5225	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5225	10	.	.	.
18637	5226	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5226	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5226	3	also	also	RB
18637	5226	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5226	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5226	6	Black	Black	NNP
18637	5226	7	for	for	IN
18637	5226	8	the	the	DT
18637	5226	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5226	10	in	in	IN
18637	5226	11	United	United	NNP
18637	5226	12	States	States	NNP
18637	5226	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5226	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	5226	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5226	16	South	South	NNP
18637	5226	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	5226	18	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	5226	19	Underwriters	Underwriters	NNPS
18637	5226	20	Assoc	Assoc	NNP
18637	5226	21	.	.	.
18637	5226	22	,	,	,
18637	5226	23	322	322	CD
18637	5226	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5226	25	533	533	CD
18637	5226	26	,	,	,
18637	5226	27	548	548	CD
18637	5226	28	-	-	SYM
18637	5226	29	549	549	CD
18637	5226	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5226	31	1944	1944	CD
18637	5226	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5226	33	.	.	.
18637	5227	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5227	2	535	535	CD
18637	5227	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5227	4	12	12	CD
18637	5227	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5227	6	.	.	.
18637	5228	1	419	419	CD
18637	5228	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5228	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	5228	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5228	5	.	.	.
18637	5229	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5229	2	536	536	CD
18637	5229	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5229	4	Compare	compare	VB
18637	5229	5	,	,	,
18637	5229	6	for	for	IN
18637	5229	7	example	example	NN
18637	5229	8	,	,	,
18637	5229	9	May	May	NNP
18637	5229	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5229	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	5229	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5229	13	New	New	NNP
18637	5229	14	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	5229	15	,	,	,
18637	5229	16	178	178	CD
18637	5229	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5229	18	496	496	CD
18637	5229	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5229	20	1900	1900	CD
18637	5229	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5229	22	;	;	:
18637	5229	23	and	and	CC
18637	5229	24	the	the	DT
18637	5229	25	recent	recent	JJ
18637	5229	26	case	case	NN
18637	5229	27	of	of	IN
18637	5229	28	Hooven	Hooven	NNP
18637	5229	29	&	&	CC
18637	5229	30	Allison	Allison	NNP
18637	5229	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5229	32	_	_	NNP
18637	5229	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	5229	34	_	_	NNP
18637	5229	35	Evatt	Evatt	NNP
18637	5229	36	,	,	,
18637	5229	37	324	324	CD
18637	5229	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5229	39	652	652	CD
18637	5229	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5229	41	1945	1945	CD
18637	5229	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5229	43	.	.	.
18637	5230	1	In	in	IN
18637	5230	2	the	the	DT
18637	5230	3	latter	latter	JJ
18637	5230	4	case	case	NN
18637	5230	5	the	the	DT
18637	5230	6	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	5230	7	of	of	IN
18637	5230	8	the	the	DT
18637	5230	9	original	original	JJ
18637	5230	10	package	package	NN
18637	5230	11	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	5230	12	were	be	VBD
18637	5230	13	extended	extend	VBN
18637	5230	14	to	to	IN
18637	5230	15	imports	import	NNS
18637	5230	16	from	from	IN
18637	5230	17	the	the	DT
18637	5230	18	Philippine	Philippine	NNP
18637	5230	19	Islands	Islands	NNPS
18637	5230	20	title	title	NN
18637	5230	21	to	to	TO
18637	5230	22	which	which	WDT
18637	5230	23	did	do	VBD
18637	5230	24	not	not	RB
18637	5230	25	vest	vest	VB
18637	5230	26	in	in	IN
18637	5230	27	the	the	DT
18637	5230	28	importer	importer	NN
18637	5230	29	until	until	IN
18637	5230	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5230	31	arrival	arrival	NN
18637	5230	32	in	in	IN
18637	5230	33	the	the	DT
18637	5230	34	United	United	NNP
18637	5230	35	States	States	NNP
18637	5230	36	.	.	.
18637	5231	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5231	2	537	537	CD
18637	5231	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5231	4	Freeman	Freeman	NNP
18637	5231	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5231	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5231	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5231	8	Hewit	Hewit	NNP
18637	5231	9	,	,	,
18637	5231	10	329	329	CD
18637	5231	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5231	12	249	249	CD
18637	5231	13	,	,	,
18637	5231	14	251	251	CD
18637	5231	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5231	16	1946	1946	CD
18637	5231	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5231	18	.	.	.
18637	5232	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5232	2	538	538	CD
18637	5232	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5232	4	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	5232	5	&	&	CC
18637	5232	6	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	5233	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5233	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5233	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5233	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5233	5	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5233	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5233	7	State	State	NNP
18637	5233	8	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	5233	9	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5233	10	Case	Case	NNP
18637	5233	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5233	12	,	,	,
18637	5233	13	15	15	CD
18637	5233	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5233	15	.	.	.
18637	5234	1	232	232	CD
18637	5234	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5234	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	5234	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5234	5	.	.	.
18637	5235	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5235	2	539	539	CD
18637	5235	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5235	4	Headnotes	Headnotes	NNP
18637	5235	5	.	.	.
18637	5236	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	5236	2	the	the	DT
18637	5236	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5236	4	:	:	:
18637	5236	5	"	"	``
18637	5236	6	The	the	DT
18637	5236	7	rule	rule	NN
18637	5236	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	5236	9	been	be	VBN
18637	5236	10	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	5236	11	with	with	IN
18637	5236	12	great	great	JJ
18637	5236	13	clearness	clearness	NN
18637	5236	14	,	,	,
18637	5236	15	that	that	IN
18637	5236	16	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	5236	17	the	the	DT
18637	5236	18	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	5236	19	over	over	IN
18637	5236	20	which	which	WDT
18637	5236	21	a	a	DT
18637	5236	22	power	power	NN
18637	5236	23	to	to	TO
18637	5236	24	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	5236	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5236	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	5236	27	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	5236	28	are	be	VBP
18637	5236	29	in	in	IN
18637	5236	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5236	31	nature	nature	NN
18637	5236	32	national	national	JJ
18637	5236	33	,	,	,
18637	5236	34	or	or	CC
18637	5236	35	admit	admit	NN
18637	5236	36	of	of	IN
18637	5236	37	one	one	CD
18637	5236	38	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	5236	39	system	system	NN
18637	5236	40	or	or	CC
18637	5236	41	plan	plan	NN
18637	5236	42	of	of	IN
18637	5236	43	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	5236	44	,	,	,
18637	5236	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5236	46	may	may	MD
18637	5236	47	justly	justly	RB
18637	5236	48	be	be	VB
18637	5236	49	said	say	VBN
18637	5236	50	to	to	TO
18637	5236	51	be	be	VB
18637	5236	52	of	of	IN
18637	5236	53	such	such	PDT
18637	5236	54	a	a	DT
18637	5236	55	nature	nature	NN
18637	5236	56	as	as	IN
18637	5236	57	to	to	TO
18637	5236	58	require	require	VB
18637	5236	59	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	5236	60	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	5236	61	by	by	IN
18637	5236	62	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	5236	63	.	.	.
18637	5237	1	Surely	surely	RB
18637	5237	2	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	5237	3	of	of	IN
18637	5237	4	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	5237	5	or	or	CC
18637	5237	6	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	5237	7	through	through	IN
18637	5237	8	a	a	DT
18637	5237	9	State	state	NN
18637	5237	10	,	,	,
18637	5237	11	or	or	CC
18637	5237	12	from	from	IN
18637	5237	13	one	one	CD
18637	5237	14	State	state	NN
18637	5237	15	to	to	IN
18637	5237	16	another	another	DT
18637	5237	17	,	,	,
18637	5237	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	5237	19	of	of	IN
18637	5237	20	this	this	DT
18637	5237	21	nature	nature	NN
18637	5237	22	.	.	.
18637	5238	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5238	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	5238	3	of	of	IN
18637	5238	4	national	national	JJ
18637	5238	5	importance	importance	NN
18637	5238	6	that	that	IN
18637	5238	7	over	over	IN
18637	5238	8	that	that	DT
18637	5238	9	subject	subject	NN
18637	5238	10	there	there	EX
18637	5238	11	should	should	MD
18637	5238	12	be	be	VB
18637	5238	13	but	but	CC
18637	5238	14	one	one	CD
18637	5238	15	regulating	regulating	NN
18637	5238	16	power	power	NN
18637	5238	17	,	,	,
18637	5238	18	for	for	IN
18637	5238	19	if	if	IN
18637	5238	20	one	one	CD
18637	5238	21	State	State	NNP
18637	5238	22	can	can	MD
18637	5238	23	directly	directly	RB
18637	5238	24	tax	tax	VB
18637	5238	25	persons	person	NNS
18637	5238	26	or	or	CC
18637	5238	27	property	property	NN
18637	5238	28	passing	pass	VBG
18637	5238	29	through	through	IN
18637	5238	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5238	31	,	,	,
18637	5238	32	or	or	CC
18637	5238	33	tax	tax	VB
18637	5238	34	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5238	35	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	5238	36	by	by	IN
18637	5238	37	levying	levy	VBG
18637	5238	38	a	a	DT
18637	5238	39	tax	tax	NN
18637	5238	40	upon	upon	IN
18637	5238	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5238	42	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	5238	43	,	,	,
18637	5238	44	every	every	DT
18637	5238	45	other	other	JJ
18637	5238	46	may	may	NN
18637	5238	47	,	,	,
18637	5238	48	and	and	CC
18637	5238	49	thus	thus	RB
18637	5238	50	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	5238	51	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	5238	52	between	between	IN
18637	5238	53	States	States	NNP
18637	5238	54	remote	remote	VBP
18637	5238	55	from	from	IN
18637	5238	56	each	each	DT
18637	5238	57	other	other	JJ
18637	5238	58	may	may	MD
18637	5238	59	be	be	VB
18637	5238	60	destroyed	destroy	VBN
18637	5238	61	.	.	.
18637	5238	62	"	"	''
18637	5239	1	15	15	CD
18637	5239	2	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5239	3	.	.	.
18637	5240	1	at	at	IN
18637	5240	2	279	279	CD
18637	5240	3	-	-	SYM
18637	5240	4	280	280	CD
18637	5240	5	,	,	,
18637	5240	6	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5240	7	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	5240	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5240	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5240	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5240	11	Port	Port	NNP
18637	5240	12	Wardens	Wardens	NNP
18637	5240	13	,	,	,
18637	5240	14	12	12	CD
18637	5240	15	How	how	WRB
18637	5240	16	.	.	.
18637	5241	1	299	299	CD
18637	5241	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5241	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	5241	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5241	5	;	;	:
18637	5241	6	Gilman	Gilman	NNP
18637	5241	7	.	.	.
18637	5242	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5242	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5242	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5242	4	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	5242	5	,	,	,
18637	5242	6	3	3	CD
18637	5242	7	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5242	8	.	.	.
18637	5243	1	713	713	CD
18637	5243	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5243	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	5243	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5243	5	;	;	:
18637	5243	6	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	5243	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5243	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5243	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5243	10	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	5243	11	,	,	,
18637	5243	12	6	6	CD
18637	5243	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5243	14	.	.	.
18637	5244	1	35	35	CD
18637	5244	2	,	,	,
18637	5244	3	42	42	CD
18637	5244	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5244	5	1868	1868	CD
18637	5244	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5244	7	.	.	.
18637	5245	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5245	2	540	540	CD
18637	5245	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5245	4	116	116	CD
18637	5245	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5245	6	517	517	CD
18637	5245	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5245	8	1886	1886	CD
18637	5245	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5245	10	.	.	.
18637	5246	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5246	2	541	541	CD
18637	5246	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5246	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5246	5	.	.	.
18637	5247	1	527	527	CD
18637	5247	2	.	.	.
18637	5248	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5248	2	542	542	CD
18637	5248	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5248	4	Heisler	Heisler	NNP
18637	5248	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5248	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5248	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5248	8	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	5248	9	Colliery	Colliery	NNP
18637	5248	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5248	11	,	,	,
18637	5248	12	260	260	CD
18637	5248	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5248	14	245	245	CD
18637	5248	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5248	16	1922	1922	CD
18637	5248	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5248	18	.	.	.
18637	5249	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5249	2	543	543	CD
18637	5249	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5249	4	262	262	CD
18637	5249	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5249	6	172	172	CD
18637	5249	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5249	8	1923	1923	CD
18637	5249	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5249	10	.	.	.
18637	5250	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5250	2	544	544	CD
18637	5250	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5250	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5250	5	.	.	.
18637	5251	1	178	178	CD
18637	5251	2	.	.	.
18637	5252	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5252	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5252	3	also	also	RB
18637	5252	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5252	5	Diamond	Diamond	NNP
18637	5252	6	Match	Match	NNP
18637	5252	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5252	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5252	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5252	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5252	11	Ontonagon	Ontonagon	NNP
18637	5252	12	188	188	CD
18637	5252	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5252	14	82	82	CD
18637	5252	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5252	16	1903	1903	CD
18637	5252	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5252	18	.	.	.
18637	5253	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5253	2	545	545	CD
18637	5253	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5253	4	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	5253	5	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	5253	6	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5253	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5253	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5253	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5253	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5253	11	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	5253	12	,	,	,
18637	5253	13	274	274	CD
18637	5253	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5253	15	284	284	CD
18637	5253	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5253	17	1927	1927	CD
18637	5253	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5253	19	.	.	.
18637	5254	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5254	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5254	3	also	also	RB
18637	5254	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5254	5	American	American	NNP
18637	5254	6	Manufacturing	Manufacturing	NNP
18637	5254	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5254	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5254	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5254	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5254	11	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5254	12	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	5254	13	,	,	,
18637	5254	14	250	250	CD
18637	5254	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5254	16	459	459	CD
18637	5254	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5254	18	1919	1919	CD
18637	5254	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5254	20	in	in	IN
18637	5254	21	which	which	WDT
18637	5254	22	there	there	EX
18637	5254	23	was	be	VBD
18637	5254	24	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	5254	25	a	a	DT
18637	5254	26	license	license	NN
18637	5254	27	tax	tax	NN
18637	5254	28	on	on	IN
18637	5254	29	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	5254	30	of	of	IN
18637	5254	31	goods	good	NNS
18637	5254	32	computed	compute	VBN
18637	5254	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	5254	34	the	the	DT
18637	5254	35	amount	amount	NN
18637	5254	36	of	of	IN
18637	5254	37	sales	sale	NNS
18637	5254	38	of	of	IN
18637	5254	39	the	the	DT
18637	5254	40	goods	good	NNS
18637	5254	41	.	.	.
18637	5255	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5255	2	546	546	CD
18637	5255	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5255	4	286	286	CD
18637	5255	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5255	6	165	165	CD
18637	5255	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5255	8	1932	1932	CD
18637	5255	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5255	10	.	.	.
18637	5256	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5256	2	547	547	CD
18637	5256	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5256	4	Coverdale	Coverdale	NNP
18637	5256	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5256	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5256	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5256	8	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	5256	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	5256	10	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	5256	11	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	5256	12	Line	Line	NNP
18637	5256	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5256	14	,	,	,
18637	5256	15	303	303	CD
18637	5256	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5256	17	604	604	CD
18637	5256	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5256	19	1938	1938	CD
18637	5256	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5256	21	.	.	.
18637	5257	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5257	2	548	548	CD
18637	5257	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5257	4	Toomer	Toomer	NNP
18637	5257	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5257	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5257	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5257	8	Witsell	Witsell	NNP
18637	5257	9	,	,	,
18637	5257	10	334	334	CD
18637	5257	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5257	12	385	385	CD
18637	5257	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5257	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	5257	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5257	16	.	.	.
18637	5258	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5258	2	549	549	CD
18637	5258	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5258	4	Dahnke	Dahnke	NNP
18637	5258	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	5258	6	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	5258	7	Milling	Milling	NNP
18637	5258	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5258	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5258	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5258	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5258	12	Bondurant	Bondurant	NNP
18637	5258	13	,	,	,
18637	5258	14	257	257	CD
18637	5258	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5258	16	282	282	CD
18637	5258	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5258	18	1921	1921	CD
18637	5258	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5258	20	.	.	.
18637	5259	1	Here	here	RB
18637	5259	2	a	a	DT
18637	5259	3	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	5259	4	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	5259	5	,	,	,
18637	5259	6	in	in	IN
18637	5259	7	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	5259	8	of	of	IN
18637	5259	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5259	10	practice	practice	NN
18637	5259	11	of	of	IN
18637	5259	12	purchasing	purchase	VBG
18637	5259	13	grain	grain	NN
18637	5259	14	in	in	IN
18637	5259	15	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5259	16	to	to	TO
18637	5259	17	be	be	VB
18637	5259	18	transported	transport	VBN
18637	5259	19	to	to	IN
18637	5259	20	and	and	CC
18637	5259	21	used	use	VBN
18637	5259	22	in	in	IN
18637	5259	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5259	24	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	5259	25	mill	mill	NN
18637	5259	26	,	,	,
18637	5259	27	made	make	VBD
18637	5259	28	a	a	DT
18637	5259	29	contract	contract	NN
18637	5259	30	for	for	IN
18637	5259	31	the	the	DT
18637	5259	32	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	5259	33	of	of	IN
18637	5259	34	wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5259	35	,	,	,
18637	5259	36	to	to	TO
18637	5259	37	be	be	VB
18637	5259	38	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	5259	39	in	in	IN
18637	5259	40	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5259	41	on	on	IN
18637	5259	42	the	the	DT
18637	5259	43	cars	car	NNS
18637	5259	44	of	of	IN
18637	5259	45	a	a	DT
18637	5259	46	public	public	JJ
18637	5259	47	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	5259	48	,	,	,
18637	5259	49	intending	intend	VBG
18637	5259	50	to	to	IN
18637	5259	51	forward	forward	VB
18637	5259	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5259	53	as	as	RB
18637	5259	54	soon	soon	RB
18637	5259	55	as	as	IN
18637	5259	56	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	5259	57	was	be	VBD
18637	5259	58	made	make	VBN
18637	5259	59	.	.	.
18637	5260	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5260	2	was	be	VBD
18637	5260	3	held	hold	VBN
18637	5260	4	that	that	IN
18637	5260	5	the	the	DT
18637	5260	6	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	5260	7	was	be	VBD
18637	5260	8	in	in	IN
18637	5260	9	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5260	10	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5260	11	,	,	,
18637	5260	12	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	5260	13	the	the	DT
18637	5260	14	contract	contract	NN
18637	5260	15	was	be	VBD
18637	5260	16	made	make	VBN
18637	5260	17	and	and	CC
18637	5260	18	to	to	TO
18637	5260	19	be	be	VB
18637	5260	20	performed	perform	VBN
18637	5260	21	in	in	IN
18637	5260	22	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5260	23	;	;	:
18637	5260	24	and	and	CC
18637	5260	25	that	that	IN
18637	5260	26	the	the	DT
18637	5260	27	possibility	possibility	NN
18637	5260	28	that	that	IN
18637	5260	29	the	the	DT
18637	5260	30	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	5260	31	might	may	MD
18637	5260	32	change	change	VB
18637	5260	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5260	34	mind	mind	NN
18637	5260	35	after	after	IN
18637	5260	36	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	5260	37	and	and	CC
18637	5260	38	sell	sell	VB
18637	5260	39	the	the	DT
18637	5260	40	grains	grain	NNS
18637	5260	41	in	in	IN
18637	5260	42	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5260	43	or	or	CC
18637	5260	44	consign	consign	VB
18637	5260	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5260	46	to	to	IN
18637	5260	47	some	some	DT
18637	5260	48	other	other	JJ
18637	5260	49	place	place	NN
18637	5260	50	in	in	IN
18637	5260	51	that	that	DT
18637	5260	52	State	state	NN
18637	5260	53	did	do	VBD
18637	5260	54	not	not	RB
18637	5260	55	affect	affect	VB
18637	5260	56	the	the	DT
18637	5260	57	essential	essential	JJ
18637	5260	58	character	character	NN
18637	5260	59	of	of	IN
18637	5260	60	the	the	DT
18637	5260	61	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	5260	62	.	.	.
18637	5261	1	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	5261	2	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5261	3	,	,	,
18637	5261	4	said	say	VBD
18637	5261	5	the	the	DT
18637	5261	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5261	7	,	,	,
18637	5261	8	"	"	''
18637	5261	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	5261	10	not	not	RB
18637	5261	11	confined	confine	VBN
18637	5261	12	to	to	IN
18637	5261	13	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	5261	14	from	from	IN
18637	5261	15	one	one	CD
18637	5261	16	State	state	NN
18637	5261	17	to	to	IN
18637	5261	18	another	another	DT
18637	5261	19	,	,	,
18637	5261	20	but	but	CC
18637	5261	21	comprehends	comprehend	VBZ
18637	5261	22	all	all	DT
18637	5261	23	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	5261	24	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	5261	25	between	between	IN
18637	5261	26	different	different	JJ
18637	5261	27	States	States	NNPS
18637	5261	28	and	and	CC
18637	5261	29	all	all	PDT
18637	5261	30	the	the	DT
18637	5261	31	component	component	NN
18637	5261	32	parts	part	NNS
18637	5261	33	of	of	IN
18637	5261	34	that	that	DT
18637	5261	35	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	5261	36	.	.	.
18637	5261	37	"	"	''
18637	5262	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	5262	2	.	.	.
18637	5263	1	290	290	CD
18637	5263	2	.	.	.
18637	5264	1	Followed	follow	VBN
18637	5264	2	in	in	IN
18637	5264	3	Lemke	Lemke	NNP
18637	5264	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5264	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	5264	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5264	7	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	5264	8	Grain	Grain	NNP
18637	5264	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5264	10	,	,	,
18637	5264	11	258	258	CD
18637	5264	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5264	13	50	50	CD
18637	5264	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5264	15	1922	1922	CD
18637	5264	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5264	17	;	;	:
18637	5264	18	and	and	CC
18637	5264	19	Flanagan	Flanagan	NNP
18637	5264	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5264	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	5264	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5264	23	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	5264	24	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	5264	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5264	26	,	,	,
18637	5264	27	267	267	CD
18637	5264	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5264	29	222	222	CD
18637	5264	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5264	31	1925	1925	CD
18637	5264	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5264	33	.	.	.
18637	5265	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5265	2	550	550	CD
18637	5265	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5265	4	Eureka	Eureka	NNP
18637	5265	5	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	5265	6	Line	Line	NNP
18637	5265	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5265	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5265	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5265	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5265	11	Hallanan	Hallanan	NNP
18637	5265	12	,	,	,
18637	5265	13	257	257	CD
18637	5265	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5265	15	265	265	CD
18637	5265	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5265	17	1921	1921	CD
18637	5265	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5265	19	.	.	.
18637	5266	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5266	2	551	551	CD
18637	5266	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5266	4	United	United	NNP
18637	5266	5	Fuel	Fuel	NNP
18637	5266	6	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5266	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5266	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5266	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5266	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5266	11	Hallanan	Hallanan	NNP
18637	5266	12	,	,	,
18637	5266	13	257	257	CD
18637	5266	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5266	15	277	277	CD
18637	5266	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5266	17	1921	1921	CD
18637	5266	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5266	19	.	.	.
18637	5267	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5267	2	552	552	CD
18637	5267	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5267	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5267	5	.	.	.
18637	5268	1	281	281	CD
18637	5268	2	.	.	.
18637	5269	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5269	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5269	3	also	also	RB
18637	5269	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5269	5	State	State	NNP
18637	5269	6	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5269	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	5269	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5269	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5269	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5269	11	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	5269	12	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	5269	13	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5269	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5269	15	,	,	,
18637	5269	16	284	284	CD
18637	5269	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5269	18	41	41	CD
18637	5269	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5269	20	1931	1931	CD
18637	5269	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5269	22	holding	hold	VBG
18637	5269	23	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	5269	24	a	a	DT
18637	5269	25	State	State	NNP
18637	5269	26	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	5269	27	tax	tax	NN
18637	5269	28	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	5269	29	on	on	IN
18637	5269	30	a	a	DT
18637	5269	31	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	5269	32	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	5269	33	selling	sell	VBG
18637	5269	34	to	to	IN
18637	5269	35	distributors	distributor	NNS
18637	5269	36	in	in	IN
18637	5269	37	the	the	DT
18637	5269	38	State	State	NNP
18637	5269	39	natural	natural	JJ
18637	5269	40	gas	gas	NN
18637	5269	41	piped	pipe	VBN
18637	5269	42	in	in	RP
18637	5269	43	from	from	IN
18637	5269	44	another	another	DT
18637	5269	45	State	State	NNP
18637	5269	46	,	,	,
18637	5269	47	whose	whose	WP$
18637	5269	48	only	only	JJ
18637	5269	49	activity	activity	NN
18637	5269	50	was	be	VBD
18637	5269	51	the	the	DT
18637	5269	52	use	use	NN
18637	5269	53	of	of	IN
18637	5269	54	a	a	DT
18637	5269	55	thermometer	thermometer	NN
18637	5269	56	and	and	CC
18637	5269	57	meter	meter	NN
18637	5269	58	and	and	CC
18637	5269	59	reduction	reduction	NN
18637	5269	60	of	of	IN
18637	5269	61	pressure	pressure	NN
18637	5269	62	to	to	TO
18637	5269	63	permit	permit	VB
18637	5269	64	vendee	vendee	NN
18637	5269	65	to	to	TO
18637	5269	66	draw	draw	VB
18637	5269	67	off	off	RP
18637	5269	68	the	the	DT
18637	5269	69	gas	gas	NN
18637	5269	70	.	.	.
18637	5270	1	"	"	``
18637	5270	2	The	the	DT
18637	5270	3	work	work	NN
18637	5270	4	done	do	VBN
18637	5270	5	by	by	IN
18637	5270	6	the	the	DT
18637	5270	7	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	5270	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	5270	9	done	do	VBN
18637	5270	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	5270	11	the	the	DT
18637	5270	12	flowing	flow	VBG
18637	5270	13	gas	gas	NN
18637	5270	14	to	to	TO
18637	5270	15	help	help	VB
18637	5270	16	the	the	DT
18637	5270	17	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	5270	18	and	and	CC
18637	5270	19	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	5270	20	to	to	IN
18637	5270	21	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5270	22	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	5270	23	to	to	TO
18637	5270	24	be	be	VB
18637	5270	25	an	an	DT
18637	5270	26	incident	incident	NN
18637	5270	27	to	to	IN
18637	5270	28	the	the	DT
18637	5270	29	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5270	30	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5270	31	between	between	IN
18637	5270	32	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	5270	33	and	and	CC
18637	5270	34	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	5270	35	.	.	.
18637	5270	36	"	"	''
18637	5271	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	5271	2	.	.	.
18637	5272	1	44	44	CD
18637	5272	2	.	.	.
18637	5273	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5273	2	553	553	CD
18637	5273	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5273	4	12	12	CD
18637	5273	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5273	6	.	.	.
18637	5274	1	419	419	CD
18637	5274	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5274	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	5274	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5274	5	.	.	.
18637	5275	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5275	2	554	554	CD
18637	5275	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5275	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5275	5	.	.	.
18637	5276	1	449	449	CD
18637	5276	2	.	.	.
18637	5277	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5277	2	555	555	CD
18637	5277	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5277	4	8	8	CD
18637	5277	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5277	6	.	.	.
18637	5278	1	123	123	CD
18637	5278	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5278	3	1860	1860	CD
18637	5278	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5278	5	.	.	.
18637	5279	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5279	2	556	556	CD
18637	5279	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5279	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5279	5	.	.	.
18637	5280	1	140	140	CD
18637	5280	2	.	.	.
18637	5281	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5281	2	557	557	CD
18637	5281	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5281	4	114	114	CD
18637	5281	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5281	6	622	622	CD
18637	5281	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5281	8	1885	1885	CD
18637	5281	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5281	10	.	.	.
18637	5282	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5282	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5282	3	also	also	RB
18637	5282	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5282	5	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	5282	6	&	&	CC
18637	5282	7	S.	S.	NNP
18637	5282	8	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	5282	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5282	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5282	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	5282	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5282	13	Bates	Bates	NNP
18637	5282	14	,	,	,
18637	5282	15	156	156	CD
18637	5282	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5282	17	577	577	CD
18637	5282	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5282	19	1895	1895	CD
18637	5282	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5282	21	.	.	.
18637	5283	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5283	2	558	558	CD
18637	5283	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5283	4	114	114	CD
18637	5283	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5283	6	at	at	IN
18637	5283	7	632	632	CD
18637	5283	8	-	-	SYM
18637	5283	9	633	633	CD
18637	5283	10	.	.	.
18637	5284	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5284	2	559	559	CD
18637	5284	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5284	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5284	5	.	.	.
18637	5285	1	634	634	CD
18637	5285	2	.	.	.
18637	5286	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5286	2	560	560	CD
18637	5286	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5286	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5286	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5286	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5286	7	Wagner	Wagner	NNP
18637	5286	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5286	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5286	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5286	11	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	5286	12	,	,	,
18637	5286	13	251	251	CD
18637	5286	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5286	15	95	95	CD
18637	5286	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5286	17	1919	1919	CD
18637	5286	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5286	19	.	.	.
18637	5287	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5287	2	561	561	CD
18637	5287	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5287	4	Brimmer	Brimmer	NNP
18637	5287	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5287	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5287	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5287	8	Rebman	Rebman	NNP
18637	5287	9	,	,	,
18637	5287	10	138	138	CD
18637	5287	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5287	12	78	78	CD
18637	5287	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5287	14	1891	1891	CD
18637	5287	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5287	16	;	;	:
18637	5287	17	Patapsco	Patapsco	NNP
18637	5287	18	Guano	Guano	NNP
18637	5287	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5287	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5287	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	5287	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5287	23	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5287	24	of	of	IN
18637	5287	25	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	5287	26	,	,	,
18637	5287	27	171	171	CD
18637	5287	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5287	29	345	345	CD
18637	5287	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5287	31	1898	1898	CD
18637	5287	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5287	33	;	;	:
18637	5287	34	Red	Red	NNP
18637	5287	35	"	"	``
18637	5287	36	C	C	NNP
18637	5287	37	"	"	''
18637	5287	38	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	5287	39	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	5287	40	.	.	.
18637	5288	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5288	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5288	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5288	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5288	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5288	6	of	of	IN
18637	5288	7	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	5288	8	,	,	,
18637	5288	9	222	222	CD
18637	5288	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5288	11	380	380	CD
18637	5288	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5288	13	1912	1912	CD
18637	5288	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5288	15	;	;	:
18637	5288	16	Savage	Savage	NNP
18637	5288	17	_	_	NNP
18637	5288	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	5288	19	_	_	NNP
18637	5288	20	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	5288	21	,	,	,
18637	5288	22	225	225	CD
18637	5288	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5288	24	501	501	CD
18637	5288	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5288	26	1912	1912	CD
18637	5288	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5288	28	;	;	:
18637	5288	29	Foote	Foote	NNP
18637	5288	30	&	&	CC
18637	5288	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5288	32	_	_	NNP
18637	5288	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	5288	34	_	_	NNP
18637	5288	35	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
18637	5288	36	,	,	,
18637	5288	37	232	232	CD
18637	5288	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5288	39	494	494	CD
18637	5288	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5288	41	1914	1914	CD
18637	5288	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5288	43	.	.	.
18637	5289	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5289	2	562	562	CD
18637	5289	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5289	4	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	5289	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	5289	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5289	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5289	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5289	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5289	10	Graves	Graves	NNP
18637	5289	11	,	,	,
18637	5289	12	249	249	CD
18637	5289	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5289	14	389	389	CD
18637	5289	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5289	16	1919	1919	CD
18637	5289	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5289	18	;	;	:
18637	5289	19	Askren	Askren	NNP
18637	5289	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5289	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	5289	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5289	23	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	5289	24	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	5289	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5289	26	,	,	,
18637	5289	27	252	252	CD
18637	5289	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5289	29	444	444	CD
18637	5289	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5289	31	1920	1920	CD
18637	5289	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5289	33	;	;	:
18637	5289	34	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	5289	35	_	_	NNP
18637	5289	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	5289	37	_	_	NNP
18637	5289	38	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	5289	39	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	5289	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5289	41	,	,	,
18637	5289	42	256	256	CD
18637	5289	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5289	44	642	642	CD
18637	5289	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5289	46	1921	1921	CD
18637	5289	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5289	48	;	;	:
18637	5289	49	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	5289	50	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5289	51	_	_	NNP
18637	5289	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	5289	53	_	_	NNP
18637	5289	54	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	5289	55	,	,	,
18637	5289	56	258	258	CD
18637	5289	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5289	58	466	466	CD
18637	5289	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5289	60	1922	1922	CD
18637	5289	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5289	62	.	.	.
18637	5290	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5290	2	563	563	CD
18637	5290	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5290	4	Sonneborn	Sonneborn	NNP
18637	5290	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	5290	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5290	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5290	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5290	9	Cureton	Cureton	NNP
18637	5290	10	,	,	,
18637	5290	11	262	262	CD
18637	5290	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5290	13	506	506	CD
18637	5290	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5290	15	1923	1923	CD
18637	5290	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5290	17	.	.	.
18637	5291	1	Reviewing	review	VBG
18637	5291	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	5291	3	.	.	.
18637	5292	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5292	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	5292	3	.	.	.
18637	5292	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5292	5	Phipps	Phipps	NNP
18637	5292	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5292	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5292	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5292	9	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
18637	5292	10	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	5292	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5292	12	,	,	,
18637	5292	13	261	261	CD
18637	5292	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5292	15	449	449	CD
18637	5292	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5292	17	1923	1923	CD
18637	5292	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5292	19	.	.	.
18637	5293	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5293	2	564	564	CD
18637	5293	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5293	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5293	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5293	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5293	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	5293	8	.	.	.
18637	5294	1	178	178	CD
18637	5294	2	,	,	,
18637	5294	3	238	238	CD
18637	5294	4	-	-	SYM
18637	5294	5	239	239	CD
18637	5294	6	.	.	.
18637	5295	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5295	2	565	565	CD
18637	5295	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5295	4	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	5295	5	Air	Air	NNP
18637	5295	6	Transport	Transport	NNP
18637	5295	7	,	,	,
18637	5295	8	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	5295	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5295	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5295	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5295	12	South	South	NNP
18637	5295	13	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	5295	14	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5295	15	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	5295	16	.	.	.
18637	5295	17	,	,	,
18637	5295	18	285	285	CD
18637	5295	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5295	20	147	147	CD
18637	5295	21	,	,	,
18637	5295	22	153	153	CD
18637	5295	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5295	24	1932	1932	CD
18637	5295	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5295	26	.	.	.
18637	5296	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5296	2	566	566	CD
18637	5296	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5296	4	Rast	Rast	NNP
18637	5296	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5296	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5296	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5296	8	Van	Van	NNP
18637	5296	9	Deman	Deman	NNP
18637	5296	10	and	and	CC
18637	5296	11	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	5296	12	,	,	,
18637	5296	13	240	240	CD
18637	5296	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5296	15	342	342	CD
18637	5296	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5296	17	1916	1916	CD
18637	5296	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5296	19	.	.	.
18637	5297	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5297	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5297	3	also	also	RB
18637	5297	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5297	5	Tanner	Tanner	NNP
18637	5297	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5297	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5297	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5297	9	Little	Little	NNP
18637	5297	10	,	,	,
18637	5297	11	240	240	CD
18637	5297	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5297	13	369	369	CD
18637	5297	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5297	15	1916	1916	CD
18637	5297	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5297	17	,	,	,
18637	5297	18	and	and	CC
18637	5297	19	Pitney	Pitney	NNP
18637	5297	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5297	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	5297	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5297	23	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	5297	24	,	,	,
18637	5297	25	240	240	CD
18637	5297	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5297	27	387	387	CD
18637	5297	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5297	29	1916	1916	CD
18637	5297	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5297	31	upholding	uphold	VBG
18637	5297	32	a	a	DT
18637	5297	33	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	5297	34	statute	statute	NN
18637	5297	35	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	5297	36	a	a	DT
18637	5297	37	prohibitive	prohibitive	JJ
18637	5297	38	license	license	NN
18637	5297	39	tax	tax	NN
18637	5297	40	upon	upon	IN
18637	5297	41	merchants	merchant	NNS
18637	5297	42	using	use	VBG
18637	5297	43	trading	trading	NN
18637	5297	44	stamps	stamp	NNS
18637	5297	45	or	or	CC
18637	5297	46	coupons	coupon	NNS
18637	5297	47	redeemable	redeemable	JJ
18637	5297	48	in	in	IN
18637	5297	49	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	5297	50	.	.	.
18637	5298	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5298	2	567	567	CD
18637	5298	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5298	4	Howe	Howe	NNP
18637	5298	5	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	5298	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5298	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5298	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5298	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5298	10	Gage	Gage	NNP
18637	5298	11	,	,	,
18637	5298	12	100	100	CD
18637	5298	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5298	14	676	676	CD
18637	5298	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5298	16	1880	1880	CD
18637	5298	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5298	18	;	;	:
18637	5298	19	Emert	Emert	NNP
18637	5298	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5298	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	5298	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5298	23	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	5298	24	,	,	,
18637	5298	25	156	156	CD
18637	5298	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5298	27	296	296	CD
18637	5298	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5298	29	1895	1895	CD
18637	5298	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5298	31	;	;	:
18637	5298	32	Singer	Singer	NNP
18637	5298	33	Sewing	Sewing	NNP
18637	5298	34	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	5298	35	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5298	36	_	_	NNP
18637	5298	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	5298	38	_	_	NNP
18637	5298	39	Brickell	Brickell	NNP
18637	5298	40	,	,	,
18637	5298	41	233	233	CD
18637	5298	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5298	43	304	304	CD
18637	5298	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5298	45	1914	1914	CD
18637	5298	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5298	47	;	;	:
18637	5298	48	Wagner	Wagner	NNP
18637	5298	49	_	_	NNP
18637	5298	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	5298	51	_	_	NNP
18637	5298	52	City	City	NNP
18637	5298	53	of	of	IN
18637	5298	54	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	5298	55	,	,	,
18637	5298	56	251	251	CD
18637	5298	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5298	58	95	95	CD
18637	5298	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5298	60	1919	1919	CD
18637	5298	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5298	62	;	;	:
18637	5298	63	Caskey	Caskey	NNP
18637	5298	64	Baking	Baking	NNP
18637	5298	65	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5298	66	_	_	NNP
18637	5298	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	5298	68	_	_	NNP
18637	5298	69	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	5298	70	,	,	,
18637	5298	71	313	313	CD
18637	5298	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5298	73	117	117	CD
18637	5298	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5298	75	1941	1941	CD
18637	5298	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5298	77	.	.	.
18637	5299	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5299	2	568	568	CD
18637	5299	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5299	4	197	197	CD
18637	5299	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5299	6	60	60	CD
18637	5299	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5299	8	1905	1905	CD
18637	5299	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5299	10	.	.	.
18637	5300	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5300	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5300	3	also	also	RB
18637	5300	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5300	5	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	5300	6	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	5300	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5300	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5300	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5300	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5300	11	Lacy	Lacy	NNP
18637	5300	12	,	,	,
18637	5300	13	200	200	CD
18637	5300	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5300	15	226	226	CD
18637	5300	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5300	17	1906	1906	CD
18637	5300	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5300	19	.	.	.
18637	5301	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5301	2	569	569	CD
18637	5301	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5301	4	91	91	CD
18637	5301	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5301	6	275	275	CD
18637	5301	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5301	8	1876	1876	CD
18637	5301	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5301	10	;	;	:
18637	5301	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5301	12	see	see	VB
18637	5301	13	also	also	RB
18637	5301	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5301	15	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	5301	16	_	_	NNP
18637	5301	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	5301	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5301	19	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	5301	20	,	,	,
18637	5301	21	12	12	CD
18637	5301	22	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5301	23	.	.	.
18637	5302	1	418	418	CD
18637	5302	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5302	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	5302	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5302	5	.	.	.
18637	5303	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5303	2	570	570	CD
18637	5303	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5303	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5303	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	7	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	5303	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5303	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	11	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5303	12	,	,	,
18637	5303	13	97	97	CD
18637	5303	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5303	15	566	566	CD
18637	5303	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5303	17	1878	1878	CD
18637	5303	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5303	19	;	;	:
18637	5303	20	Guy	Guy	NNP
18637	5303	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	5303	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	24	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	5303	25	,	,	,
18637	5303	26	100	100	CD
18637	5303	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5303	28	434	434	CD
18637	5303	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5303	30	1880	1880	CD
18637	5303	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5303	32	;	;	:
18637	5303	33	Tiernan	Tiernan	NNP
18637	5303	34	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	5303	36	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	37	Rinker	Rinker	NNP
18637	5303	38	,	,	,
18637	5303	39	102	102	CD
18637	5303	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5303	41	123	123	CD
18637	5303	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5303	43	1880	1880	CD
18637	5303	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5303	45	;	;	:
18637	5303	46	Howe	Howe	NNP
18637	5303	47	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	5303	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5303	49	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	5303	51	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	52	Gage	Gage	NNP
18637	5303	53	,	,	,
18637	5303	54	100	100	CD
18637	5303	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5303	56	676	676	CD
18637	5303	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5303	58	1880	1880	CD
18637	5303	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5303	60	;	;	:
18637	5303	61	Webber	Webber	NNP
18637	5303	62	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	5303	64	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	65	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	5303	66	,	,	,
18637	5303	67	103	103	CD
18637	5303	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5303	69	344	344	CD
18637	5303	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5303	71	1881	1881	CD
18637	5303	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5303	73	;	;	:
18637	5303	74	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	5303	75	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	5303	77	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	78	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	5303	79	,	,	,
18637	5303	80	116	116	CD
18637	5303	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5303	82	446	446	CD
18637	5303	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5303	84	1886	1886	CD
18637	5303	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5303	86	;	;	:
18637	5303	87	Darnell	Darnell	NNP
18637	5303	88	&	&	CC
18637	5303	89	Son	Son	NNP
18637	5303	90	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5303	91	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	5303	93	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	94	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	5303	95	,	,	,
18637	5303	96	208	208	CD
18637	5303	97	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5303	98	113	113	CD
18637	5303	99	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5303	100	1908	1908	CD
18637	5303	101	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5303	102	,	,	,
18637	5303	103	where	where	WRB
18637	5303	104	was	be	VBD
18637	5303	105	held	hold	VBN
18637	5303	106	void	void	RB
18637	5303	107	a	a	DT
18637	5303	108	property	property	NN
18637	5303	109	tax	tax	NN
18637	5303	110	on	on	IN
18637	5303	111	lumber	lumber	NN
18637	5303	112	which	which	WDT
18637	5303	113	discriminated	discriminate	VBN
18637	5303	114	in	in	IN
18637	5303	115	favor	favor	NN
18637	5303	116	of	of	IN
18637	5303	117	the	the	DT
18637	5303	118	local	local	JJ
18637	5303	119	product	product	NN
18637	5303	120	:	:	:
18637	5303	121	Bethlehem	Bethlehem	NNP
18637	5303	122	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	5303	123	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	5303	124	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	125	v.	v.	IN
18637	5303	126	_	_	NNP
18637	5303	127	Flynt	Flynt	NNP
18637	5303	128	,	,	,
18637	5303	129	256	256	CD
18637	5303	130	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5303	131	421	421	CD
18637	5303	132	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5303	133	1921	1921	CD
18637	5303	134	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5303	135	,	,	,
18637	5303	136	where	where	WRB
18637	5303	137	a	a	DT
18637	5303	138	license	license	NN
18637	5303	139	tax	tax	NN
18637	5303	140	on	on	IN
18637	5303	141	distributors	distributor	NNS
18637	5303	142	was	be	VBD
18637	5303	143	held	hold	VBN
18637	5303	144	to	to	TO
18637	5303	145	be	be	VB
18637	5303	146	invalidated	invalidate	VBN
18637	5303	147	by	by	IN
18637	5303	148	the	the	DT
18637	5303	149	provision	provision	NN
18637	5303	150	made	make	VBN
18637	5303	151	for	for	IN
18637	5303	152	a	a	DT
18637	5303	153	rebate	rebate	NN
18637	5303	154	under	under	IN
18637	5303	155	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	5303	156	that	that	WDT
18637	5303	157	could	could	MD
18637	5303	158	be	be	VB
18637	5303	159	met	meet	VBN
18637	5303	160	only	only	RB
18637	5303	161	by	by	IN
18637	5303	162	manufacturers	manufacturer	NNS
18637	5303	163	within	within	IN
18637	5303	164	the	the	DT
18637	5303	165	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	5303	166	State	state	NN
18637	5303	167	.	.	.
18637	5304	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5304	2	571	571	CD
18637	5304	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5304	4	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	5304	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5304	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5304	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5304	8	Errol	Errol	NNP
18637	5304	9	,	,	,
18637	5304	10	116	116	CD
18637	5304	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5304	12	517	517	CD
18637	5304	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5304	14	1886	1886	CD
18637	5304	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5304	16	.	.	.
18637	5305	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5305	2	572	572	CD
18637	5305	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5305	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5305	5	.	.	.
18637	5306	1	525	525	CD
18637	5306	2	.	.	.
18637	5307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5307	2	573	573	CD
18637	5307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5307	4	General	General	NNP
18637	5307	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	5307	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5307	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5307	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5307	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5307	10	Crain	Crain	NNP
18637	5307	11	,	,	,
18637	5307	12	209	209	CD
18637	5307	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5307	14	211	211	CD
18637	5307	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5307	16	1908	1908	CD
18637	5307	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5307	18	.	.	.
18637	5308	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5308	2	574	574	CD
18637	5308	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5308	4	American	American	NNP
18637	5308	5	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	5308	6	&	&	CC
18637	5308	7	Wire	Wire	NNP
18637	5308	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5308	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5308	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5308	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5308	12	Speed	Speed	NNP
18637	5308	13	,	,	,
18637	5308	14	192	192	CD
18637	5308	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5308	16	500	500	CD
18637	5308	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5308	18	1904	1904	CD
18637	5308	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5308	20	;	;	:
18637	5308	21	Bacon	Bacon	NNP
18637	5308	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5308	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	5308	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5308	25	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5308	26	,	,	,
18637	5308	27	227	227	CD
18637	5308	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5308	29	504	504	CD
18637	5308	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5308	31	1913	1913	CD
18637	5308	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5308	33	;	;	:
18637	5308	34	Susquehanna	Susquehanna	NNP
18637	5308	35	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	5308	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5308	37	_	_	NNP
18637	5308	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	5308	39	_	_	NNP
18637	5308	40	South	South	NNP
18637	5308	41	Amboy	Amboy	NNP
18637	5308	42	,	,	,
18637	5308	43	228	228	CD
18637	5308	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5308	45	665	665	CD
18637	5308	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5308	47	1913	1913	CD
18637	5308	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5308	49	;	;	:
18637	5308	50	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5308	51	_	_	NNP
18637	5308	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	5308	53	_	_	NNP
18637	5308	54	Blasius	Blasius	NNP
18637	5308	55	,	,	,
18637	5308	56	290	290	CD
18637	5308	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5308	58	1	1	CD
18637	5308	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5308	60	1933	1933	CD
18637	5308	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5308	62	;	;	:
18637	5308	63	Independent	Independent	NNP
18637	5308	64	Warehouses	Warehouses	NNPS
18637	5308	65	_	_	NNP
18637	5308	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	5308	67	_	_	NNP
18637	5308	68	Scheele	Scheele	NNP
18637	5308	69	,	,	,
18637	5308	70	331	331	CD
18637	5308	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5308	72	70	70	CD
18637	5308	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5308	74	1947	1947	CD
18637	5308	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5308	76	.	.	.
18637	5309	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5309	2	575	575	CD
18637	5309	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5309	4	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	5309	5	,	,	,
18637	5309	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	5309	7	&	&	CC
18637	5309	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5309	9	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	5310	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5310	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5310	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5310	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5310	5	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	5310	6	,	,	,
18637	5310	7	288	288	CD
18637	5310	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5310	9	249	249	CD
18637	5310	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5310	11	1933	1933	CD
18637	5310	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5310	13	.	.	.
18637	5311	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5311	2	576	576	CD
18637	5311	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5311	4	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
18637	5311	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5311	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5311	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5311	8	Boeing	Boeing	NNP
18637	5311	9	Air	Air	NNP
18637	5311	10	Transport	Transport	NNP
18637	5311	11	,	,	,
18637	5311	12	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	5311	13	,	,	,
18637	5311	14	289	289	CD
18637	5311	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5311	16	249	249	CD
18637	5311	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5311	18	1933	1933	CD
18637	5311	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5311	20	.	.	.
18637	5312	1	The	the	DT
18637	5312	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5312	3	also	also	RB
18637	5312	4	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	5312	5	a	a	DT
18637	5312	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	5312	7	on	on	IN
18637	5312	8	the	the	DT
18637	5312	9	sale	sale	NN
18637	5312	10	of	of	IN
18637	5312	11	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	5312	12	for	for	IN
18637	5312	13	use	use	NN
18637	5312	14	by	by	IN
18637	5312	15	an	an	DT
18637	5312	16	air	air	NN
18637	5312	17	transport	transport	NN
18637	5312	18	line	line	NN
18637	5312	19	in	in	IN
18637	5312	20	conducting	conduct	VBG
18637	5312	21	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5312	22	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	5312	23	across	across	IN
18637	5312	24	the	the	DT
18637	5312	25	State	State	NNP
18637	5312	26	in	in	IN
18637	5312	27	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	5312	28	Air	Air	NNP
18637	5312	29	Transport	Transport	NNP
18637	5312	30	,	,	,
18637	5312	31	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	5312	32	_	_	NNP
18637	5312	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	5312	34	_	_	NNP
18637	5312	35	South	South	NNP
18637	5312	36	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	5312	37	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5312	38	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	5312	39	.	.	NNP
18637	5312	40	,	,	,
18637	5312	41	285	285	CD
18637	5312	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5312	43	147	147	CD
18637	5312	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5312	45	1932	1932	CD
18637	5312	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5312	47	.	.	.
18637	5313	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5313	2	577	577	CD
18637	5313	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5313	4	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	5313	5	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	5313	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5313	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5313	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5313	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5313	10	Gallagher	Gallagher	NNP
18637	5313	11	,	,	,
18637	5313	12	306	306	CD
18637	5313	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5313	14	167	167	CD
18637	5313	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5313	16	1939	1939	CD
18637	5313	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5313	18	.	.	.
18637	5314	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5314	2	578	578	CD
18637	5314	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5314	4	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	5314	5	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	5314	6	&	&	CC
18637	5314	7	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	5314	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5314	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5314	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5314	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5314	12	Gallagher	Gallagher	NNP
18637	5314	13	,	,	,
18637	5314	14	306	306	CD
18637	5314	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5314	16	182	182	CD
18637	5314	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5314	18	1939	1939	CD
18637	5314	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5314	20	.	.	.
18637	5315	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5315	2	579	579	CD
18637	5315	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5315	4	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	5315	5	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	5315	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5315	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5315	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5315	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5315	10	Gallagher	Gallagher	NNP
18637	5315	11	,	,	,
18637	5315	12	306	306	CD
18637	5315	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5315	14	167	167	CD
18637	5315	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5315	16	1939	1939	CD
18637	5315	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5315	18	,	,	,
18637	5315	19	as	as	IN
18637	5315	20	formulated	formulate	VBN
18637	5315	21	in	in	IN
18637	5315	22	the	the	DT
18637	5315	23	headnotes	headnote	NNS
18637	5315	24	;	;	:
18637	5315	25	_	_	NNP
18637	5315	26	see	see	VB
18637	5315	27	also	also	RB
18637	5315	28	_	_	NNP
18637	5315	29	Monamotor	Monamotor	NNP
18637	5315	30	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	5315	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5315	32	_	_	NNP
18637	5315	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	5315	34	_	_	NNP
18637	5315	35	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	5315	36	,	,	,
18637	5315	37	292	292	CD
18637	5315	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5315	39	86	86	CD
18637	5315	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5315	41	1934	1934	CD
18637	5315	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5315	43	.	.	.
18637	5316	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5316	2	580	580	CD
18637	5316	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5316	4	Bingaman	Bingaman	NNP
18637	5316	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5316	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5316	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5316	8	Golden	Golden	NNP
18637	5316	9	Eagle	Eagle	NNP
18637	5316	10	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5316	11	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	5316	12	,	,	,
18637	5316	13	297	297	CD
18637	5316	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5316	15	626	626	CD
18637	5316	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5316	17	1936	1936	CD
18637	5316	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5316	19	;	;	:
18637	5316	20	McCarroll	McCarroll	NNP
18637	5316	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5316	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	5316	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5316	24	Dixie	Dixie	NNP
18637	5316	25	Greyhound	Greyhound	NNP
18637	5316	26	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	5316	27	,	,	,
18637	5316	28	309	309	CD
18637	5316	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5316	30	176	176	CD
18637	5316	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5316	32	1940	1940	CD
18637	5316	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5316	34	.	.	.
18637	5317	1	In	in	IN
18637	5317	2	Helson	Helson	NNP
18637	5317	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5317	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	5317	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5317	6	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5317	7	,	,	,
18637	5317	8	279	279	CD
18637	5317	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5317	10	245	245	CD
18637	5317	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5317	12	1929	1929	CD
18637	5317	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5317	14	,	,	,
18637	5317	15	the	the	DT
18637	5317	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5317	17	held	hold	VBD
18637	5317	18	that	that	IN
18637	5317	19	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	5317	20	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	5317	21	in	in	IN
18637	5317	22	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5317	23	and	and	CC
18637	5317	24	used	use	VBN
18637	5317	25	in	in	IN
18637	5317	26	an	an	DT
18637	5317	27	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5317	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	5317	29	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5317	30	ferry	ferry	NN
18637	5317	31	could	could	MD
18637	5317	32	not	not	RB
18637	5317	33	be	be	VB
18637	5317	34	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	5317	35	by	by	IN
18637	5317	36	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5317	37	,	,	,
18637	5317	38	being	be	VBG
18637	5317	39	,	,	,
18637	5317	40	as	as	IN
18637	5317	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5317	42	were	be	VBD
18637	5317	43	,	,	,
18637	5317	44	a	a	DT
18637	5317	45	part	part	NN
18637	5317	46	of	of	IN
18637	5317	47	the	the	DT
18637	5317	48	ferry	ferry	NN
18637	5317	49	,	,	,
18637	5317	50	an	an	DT
18637	5317	51	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	5317	52	of	of	IN
18637	5317	53	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5317	54	between	between	IN
18637	5317	55	the	the	DT
18637	5317	56	two	two	CD
18637	5317	57	States	States	NNPS
18637	5317	58	.	.	.
18637	5318	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5318	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5318	3	also	also	RB
18637	5318	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5318	5	Kelley	Kelley	NNP
18637	5318	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5318	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5318	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5318	9	Rhoads	Rhoads	NNP
18637	5318	10	,	,	,
18637	5318	11	188	188	CD
18637	5318	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5318	13	1	1	CD
18637	5318	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5318	15	1903	1903	CD
18637	5318	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5318	17	;	;	:
18637	5318	18	Champlain	Champlain	NNP
18637	5318	19	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	5318	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5318	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5318	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	5318	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5318	24	Brattleboro	Brattleboro	NNP
18637	5318	25	,	,	,
18637	5318	26	260	260	CD
18637	5318	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5318	28	366	366	CD
18637	5318	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5318	30	1922	1922	CD
18637	5318	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5318	32	;	;	:
18637	5318	33	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	5318	34	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	5319	1	Timber	Timber	NNP
18637	5319	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5319	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5319	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	5319	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5319	6	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5319	7	,	,	,
18637	5319	8	272	272	CD
18637	5319	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5319	10	469	469	CD
18637	5319	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5319	12	1926	1926	CD
18637	5319	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5319	14	;	;	:
18637	5319	15	Carson	Carson	NNP
18637	5319	16	Petroleum	Petroleum	NNP
18637	5319	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5319	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5319	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	5319	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5319	21	Vial	Vial	NNP
18637	5319	22	,	,	,
18637	5319	23	279	279	CD
18637	5319	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5319	25	95	95	CD
18637	5319	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5319	27	1929	1929	CD
18637	5319	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5319	29	.	.	.
18637	5320	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5320	2	581	581	CD
18637	5320	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5320	4	120	120	CD
18637	5320	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5320	6	489	489	CD
18637	5320	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5320	8	1887	1887	CD
18637	5320	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5320	10	.	.	.
18637	5321	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5321	2	582	582	CD
18637	5321	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5321	4	Corson	Corson	NNP
18637	5321	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5321	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	5321	9	,	,	,
18637	5321	10	120	120	CD
18637	5321	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5321	12	502	502	CD
18637	5321	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5321	14	1887	1887	CD
18637	5321	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5321	16	;	;	:
18637	5321	17	Asher	Asher	NNP
18637	5321	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	5321	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	21	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	5321	22	,	,	,
18637	5321	23	128	128	CD
18637	5321	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5321	25	129	129	CD
18637	5321	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5321	27	1888	1888	CD
18637	5321	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5321	29	;	;	:
18637	5321	30	Stoutenburgh	Stoutenburgh	NNP
18637	5321	31	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	5321	33	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	34	Hennick	Hennick	NNP
18637	5321	35	,	,	,
18637	5321	36	129	129	CD
18637	5321	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5321	38	141	141	CD
18637	5321	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5321	40	1889	1889	CD
18637	5321	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5321	42	;	;	:
18637	5321	43	Brennan	Brennan	NNP
18637	5321	44	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	5321	46	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	47	Titusville	Titusville	NNP
18637	5321	48	,	,	,
18637	5321	49	153	153	CD
18637	5321	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5321	51	289	289	CD
18637	5321	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5321	53	1894	1894	CD
18637	5321	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5321	55	;	;	:
18637	5321	56	Stockard	Stockard	NNP
18637	5321	57	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	5321	59	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	60	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	5321	61	,	,	,
18637	5321	62	185	185	CD
18637	5321	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5321	64	27	27	CD
18637	5321	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5321	66	1902	1902	CD
18637	5321	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5321	68	;	;	:
18637	5321	69	Crenshaw	Crenshaw	NNP
18637	5321	70	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	5321	72	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	73	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	5321	74	,	,	,
18637	5321	75	227	227	CD
18637	5321	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5321	77	389	389	CD
18637	5321	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5321	79	1913	1913	CD
18637	5321	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5321	81	;	;	:
18637	5321	82	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	5321	83	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	5321	85	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	86	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	5321	87	,	,	,
18637	5321	88	227	227	CD
18637	5321	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5321	90	401	401	CD
18637	5321	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5321	92	1913	1913	CD
18637	5321	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5321	94	;	;	:
18637	5321	95	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	5321	96	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	5321	98	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	99	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	5321	100	,	,	,
18637	5321	101	232	232	CD
18637	5321	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5321	103	665	665	CD
18637	5321	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5321	105	1914	1914	CD
18637	5321	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5321	107	;	;	:
18637	5321	108	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5321	109	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	5321	110	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	5321	111	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5321	112	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	5321	114	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	115	Lipscomb	Lipscomb	NNP
18637	5321	116	,	,	,
18637	5321	117	244	244	CD
18637	5321	118	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5321	119	346	346	CD
18637	5321	120	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5321	121	1917	1917	CD
18637	5321	122	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5321	123	;	;	:
18637	5321	124	Cheney	Cheney	NNP
18637	5321	125	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	5321	126	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	127	v.	v.	IN
18637	5321	128	_	_	NNP
18637	5321	129	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	5321	130	,	,	,
18637	5321	131	246	246	CD
18637	5321	132	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5321	133	147	147	CD
18637	5321	134	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5321	135	1918	1918	CD
18637	5321	136	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5321	137	.	.	.
18637	5322	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5322	2	583	583	CD
18637	5322	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5322	4	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	5322	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5322	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5322	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5322	8	North	North	NNP
18637	5322	9	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	5322	10	,	,	,
18637	5322	11	187	187	CD
18637	5322	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5322	13	622	622	CD
18637	5322	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5322	15	1903	1903	CD
18637	5322	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5322	17	.	.	.
18637	5323	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5323	2	584	584	CD
18637	5323	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5323	4	Norfolk	Norfolk	NNP
18637	5323	5	&	&	CC
18637	5323	6	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	5323	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5323	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5323	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5323	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5323	11	Sims	Sims	NNP
18637	5323	12	,	,	,
18637	5323	13	191	191	CD
18637	5323	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5323	15	441	441	CD
18637	5323	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5323	17	1903	1903	CD
18637	5323	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5323	19	.	.	.
18637	5324	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5324	2	585	585	CD
18637	5324	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5324	4	Rearick	Rearick	NNP
18637	5324	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5324	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5324	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5324	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5324	9	,	,	,
18637	5324	10	203	203	CD
18637	5324	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5324	12	507	507	CD
18637	5324	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5324	14	1906	1906	CD
18637	5324	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5324	16	;	;	:
18637	5324	17	Dozier	Dozier	NNP
18637	5324	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5324	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	5324	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5324	21	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	5324	22	,	,	,
18637	5324	23	218	218	CD
18637	5324	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5324	25	124	124	CD
18637	5324	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5324	27	1910	1910	CD
18637	5324	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5324	29	;	;	:
18637	5324	30	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	5324	31	_	_	NNP
18637	5324	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	5324	33	_	_	NNP
18637	5324	34	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	5324	35	,	,	,
18637	5324	36	236	236	CD
18637	5324	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5324	38	697	697	CD
18637	5324	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5324	40	1915	1915	CD
18637	5324	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5324	42	.	.	.
18637	5325	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5325	2	586	586	CD
18637	5325	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5325	4	203	203	CD
18637	5325	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5325	6	at	at	IN
18637	5325	7	512	512	CD
18637	5325	8	.	.	.
18637	5326	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5326	2	587	587	CD
18637	5326	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5326	4	Real	real	JJ
18637	5326	5	Silk	Silk	NNP
18637	5326	6	Hosiery	Hosiery	NNP
18637	5326	7	Mills	Mills	NNPS
18637	5326	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5326	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5326	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5326	11	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	5326	12	,	,	,
18637	5326	13	268	268	CD
18637	5326	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5326	15	325	325	CD
18637	5326	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5326	17	1925	1925	CD
18637	5326	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5326	19	.	.	.
18637	5327	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5327	2	588	588	CD
18637	5327	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5327	4	Heyman	Heyman	NNP
18637	5327	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5327	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5327	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5327	8	Hays	Hays	NNP
18637	5327	9	,	,	,
18637	5327	10	236	236	CD
18637	5327	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5327	12	178	178	CD
18637	5327	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5327	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	5327	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5327	16	.	.	.
18637	5328	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5328	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5328	3	also	also	RB
18637	5328	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5328	5	Hump	Hump	NNP
18637	5328	6	Hairpin	Hairpin	NNP
18637	5328	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5328	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5328	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5328	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5328	11	Emmerson	Emmerson	NNP
18637	5328	12	,	,	,
18637	5328	13	258	258	CD
18637	5328	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5328	15	290	290	CD
18637	5328	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5328	17	1922	1922	CD
18637	5328	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5328	19	,	,	,
18637	5328	20	holding	hold	VBG
18637	5328	21	that	that	DT
18637	5328	22	business	business	NN
18637	5328	23	done	do	VBN
18637	5328	24	by	by	IN
18637	5328	25	a	a	DT
18637	5328	26	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	5328	27	through	through	IN
18637	5328	28	orders	order	NNS
18637	5328	29	which	which	WDT
18637	5328	30	were	be	VBD
18637	5328	31	approved	approve	VBN
18637	5328	32	in	in	IN
18637	5328	33	a	a	DT
18637	5328	34	State	state	NN
18637	5328	35	where	where	WRB
18637	5328	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5328	37	tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	5328	38	property	property	NN
18637	5328	39	and	and	CC
18637	5328	40	offices	office	NNS
18637	5328	41	were	be	VBD
18637	5328	42	located	locate	VBN
18637	5328	43	,	,	,
18637	5328	44	but	but	CC
18637	5328	45	which	which	WDT
18637	5328	46	were	be	VBD
18637	5328	47	first	first	RB
18637	5328	48	taken	take	VBN
18637	5328	49	by	by	IN
18637	5328	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5328	51	salesmen	salesman	NNS
18637	5328	52	in	in	IN
18637	5328	53	other	other	JJ
18637	5328	54	States	States	NNP
18637	5328	55	,	,	,
18637	5328	56	was	be	VBD
18637	5328	57	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5328	58	,	,	,
18637	5328	59	although	although	IN
18637	5328	60	the	the	DT
18637	5328	61	tax	tax	NN
18637	5328	62	involved	involve	VBN
18637	5328	63	was	be	VBD
18637	5328	64	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	5328	65	.	.	.
18637	5329	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5329	2	589	589	CD
18637	5329	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5329	4	Ficklen	Ficklen	NNP
18637	5329	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5329	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5329	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5329	8	Shelby	Shelby	NNP
18637	5329	9	County	County	NNP
18637	5329	10	Taxing	Taxing	NNP
18637	5329	11	District	District	NNP
18637	5329	12	,	,	,
18637	5329	13	145	145	CD
18637	5329	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5329	15	1	1	CD
18637	5329	16	,	,	,
18637	5329	17	21	21	CD
18637	5329	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5329	19	1892	1892	CD
18637	5329	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5329	21	.	.	.
18637	5330	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5330	2	590	590	CD
18637	5330	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5330	4	New	New	NNP
18637	5330	5	York	York	NNP
18637	5330	6	ex	ex	NN
18637	5330	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	5330	8	.	.	.
18637	5331	1	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	5331	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5331	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5331	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5331	5	Reardon	Reardon	NNP
18637	5331	6	,	,	,
18637	5331	7	204	204	CD
18637	5331	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5331	9	152	152	CD
18637	5331	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5331	11	1907	1907	CD
18637	5331	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5331	13	;	;	:
18637	5331	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5331	15	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	5331	16	.	.	.
18637	5331	17	_	_	NNP
18637	5331	18	Nathan	Nathan	NNP
18637	5331	19	_	_	NNP
18637	5331	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	5331	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5331	22	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	5331	23	,	,	,
18637	5331	24	8	8	CD
18637	5331	25	How	how	WRB
18637	5331	26	.	.	.
18637	5332	1	73	73	CD
18637	5332	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5332	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	5332	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5332	5	.	.	.
18637	5333	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5333	2	591	591	CD
18637	5333	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5333	4	Ware	Ware	NNP
18637	5333	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5333	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5333	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5333	8	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	5333	9	County	County	NNP
18637	5333	10	,	,	,
18637	5333	11	209	209	CD
18637	5333	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5333	13	405	405	CD
18637	5333	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5333	15	1908	1908	CD
18637	5333	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5333	17	.	.	.
18637	5334	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5334	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5334	3	also	also	RB
18637	5334	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5334	5	Brodnax	Brodnax	NNP
18637	5334	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5334	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5334	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5334	9	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	5334	10	,	,	,
18637	5334	11	219	219	CD
18637	5334	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5334	13	285	285	CD
18637	5334	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5334	15	1911	1911	CD
18637	5334	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5334	17	.	.	.
18637	5335	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5335	2	592	592	CD
18637	5335	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5335	4	222	222	CD
18637	5335	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5335	6	210	210	CD
18637	5335	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5335	8	1911	1911	CD
18637	5335	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5335	10	.	.	.
18637	5336	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5336	2	593	593	CD
18637	5336	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5336	4	233	233	CD
18637	5336	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5336	6	16	16	CD
18637	5336	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5336	8	1914	1914	CD
18637	5336	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5336	10	.	.	.
18637	5337	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5337	2	594	594	CD
18637	5337	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5337	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5337	5	.	.	.
18637	5338	1	23	23	CD
18637	5338	2	.	.	.
18637	5339	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5339	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5339	3	also	also	RB
18637	5339	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5339	5	Superior	Superior	NNP
18637	5339	6	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	5339	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5339	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5339	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5339	10	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	5339	11	ex	ex	NNP
18637	5339	12	rel	rel	NN
18637	5339	13	.	.	.
18637	5340	1	Knox	Knox	NNP
18637	5340	2	,	,	,
18637	5340	3	280	280	CD
18637	5340	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5340	5	390	390	CD
18637	5340	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5340	7	1930	1930	CD
18637	5340	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5340	9	.	.	.
18637	5341	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5341	2	595	595	CD
18637	5341	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5341	4	Chassaniol	Chassaniol	NNP
18637	5341	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5341	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5341	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5341	8	Greenwood	Greenwood	NNP
18637	5341	9	,	,	,
18637	5341	10	291	291	CD
18637	5341	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5341	12	584	584	CD
18637	5341	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5341	14	1934	1934	CD
18637	5341	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5341	16	.	.	.
18637	5342	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5342	2	596	596	CD
18637	5342	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5342	4	Wiloil	Wiloil	NNP
18637	5342	5	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	5342	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5342	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5342	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5342	9	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5342	10	,	,	,
18637	5342	11	294	294	CD
18637	5342	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5342	13	169	169	CD
18637	5342	14	,	,	,
18637	5342	15	173	173	CD
18637	5342	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5342	17	1935	1935	CD
18637	5342	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5342	19	;	;	:
18637	5342	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5342	21	see	see	VB
18637	5342	22	also	also	RB
18637	5342	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5342	24	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5342	25	_	_	NNP
18637	5342	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	5342	27	_	_	NNP
18637	5342	28	Blasius	Blasius	NNP
18637	5342	29	,	,	,
18637	5342	30	290	290	CD
18637	5342	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5342	32	1	1	CD
18637	5342	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5342	34	1933	1933	CD
18637	5342	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5342	36	.	.	.
18637	5343	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5343	2	597	597	CD
18637	5343	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5343	4	309	309	CD
18637	5343	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5343	6	33	33	CD
18637	5343	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5343	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	5343	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5343	10	.	.	.
18637	5344	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5344	2	598	598	CD
18637	5344	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5344	4	Best	Best	NNP
18637	5344	5	&	&	CC
18637	5344	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5344	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5344	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5344	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5344	10	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	5344	11	.	.	.
18637	5345	1	311	311	CD
18637	5345	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5345	3	454	454	CD
18637	5345	4	,	,	,
18637	5345	5	455	455	CD
18637	5345	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5345	7	1940	1940	CD
18637	5345	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5345	9	.	.	.
18637	5346	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5346	2	599	599	CD
18637	5346	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5346	4	300	300	CD
18637	5346	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5346	6	577	577	CD
18637	5346	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5346	8	1937	1937	CD
18637	5346	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5346	10	.	.	.
18637	5347	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5347	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	5347	3	.	.	.
18637	5347	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5347	5	Hinson	Hinson	NNP
18637	5347	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5347	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5347	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5347	9	Lott	Lott	NNP
18637	5347	10	,	,	,
18637	5347	11	8	8	CD
18637	5347	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5347	13	.	.	.
18637	5348	1	148	148	CD
18637	5348	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5348	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	5348	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5348	5	.	.	.
18637	5349	1	Here	here	RB
18637	5349	2	was	be	VBD
18637	5349	3	involved	involve	VBN
18637	5349	4	a	a	DT
18637	5349	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	5349	6	of	of	IN
18637	5349	7	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	5349	8	cents	cent	NNS
18637	5349	9	per	per	IN
18637	5349	10	gallon	gallon	NN
18637	5349	11	on	on	IN
18637	5349	12	all	all	DT
18637	5349	13	spiritous	spiritous	JJ
18637	5349	14	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	5349	15	brought	bring	VBN
18637	5349	16	into	into	IN
18637	5349	17	the	the	DT
18637	5349	18	State	State	NNP
18637	5349	19	.	.	.
18637	5350	1	Comparing	compare	VBG
18637	5350	2	the	the	DT
18637	5350	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	5350	4	with	with	IN
18637	5350	5	a	a	DT
18637	5350	6	similar	similar	JJ
18637	5350	7	one	one	NN
18637	5350	8	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	5350	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	5350	10	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	5350	11	manufactured	manufacture	VBN
18637	5350	12	in	in	IN
18637	5350	13	the	the	DT
18637	5350	14	State	State	NNP
18637	5350	15	,	,	,
18637	5350	16	the	the	DT
18637	5350	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5350	18	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	5350	19	the	the	DT
18637	5350	20	statute	statute	NN
18637	5350	21	.	.	.
18637	5351	1	"	"	``
18637	5351	2	The	the	DT
18637	5351	3	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	5351	4	were	be	VBD
18637	5351	5	complementary	complementary	JJ
18637	5351	6	and	and	CC
18637	5351	7	were	be	VBD
18637	5351	8	intended	intend	VBN
18637	5351	9	to	to	TO
18637	5351	10	effect	effect	VB
18637	5351	11	equality	equality	NN
18637	5351	12	.	.	.
18637	5351	13	"	"	''
18637	5352	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5352	2	600	600	CD
18637	5352	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5352	4	300	300	CD
18637	5352	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5352	6	at	at	IN
18637	5352	7	583	583	CD
18637	5352	8	-	-	SYM
18637	5352	9	584	584	CD
18637	5352	10	.	.	.
18637	5353	1	Some	some	DT
18637	5353	2	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	5353	3	use	use	VBP
18637	5353	4	tax	tax	NN
18637	5353	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	5353	6	in	in	IN
18637	5353	7	the	the	DT
18637	5353	8	Henneford	Henneford	NNP
18637	5353	9	pattern	pattern	NN
18637	5353	10	are	be	VBP
18637	5353	11	the	the	DT
18637	5353	12	following	follow	VBG
18637	5353	13	:	:	:
18637	5353	14	Bacon	Bacon	NNP
18637	5353	15	&	&	CC
18637	5353	16	Sons	Sons	NNPS
18637	5353	17	_	_	NNP
18637	5353	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	5353	19	_	_	NNP
18637	5353	20	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	5353	21	was	be	VBD
18637	5353	22	decided	decide	VBN
18637	5353	23	in	in	IN
18637	5353	24	a	a	DT
18637	5353	25	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	5353	26	_	_	NNP
18637	5353	27	per	per	IN
18637	5353	28	curiam	curiam	NNP
18637	5353	29	_	_	NNP
18637	5353	30	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	5353	31	.	.	.
18637	5354	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5354	2	involved	involve	VBD
18637	5354	3	a	a	DT
18637	5354	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5354	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	5354	6	which	which	WDT
18637	5354	7	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	5354	8	a	a	DT
18637	5354	9	tax	tax	NN
18637	5354	10	"	"	''
18637	5354	11	on	on	IN
18637	5354	12	the	the	DT
18637	5354	13	'	'	``
18637	5354	14	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	5354	15	'	'	''
18637	5354	16	of	of	IN
18637	5354	17	cosmetics	cosmetic	NNS
18637	5354	18	in	in	IN
18637	5354	19	the	the	DT
18637	5354	20	State	State	NNP
18637	5354	21	by	by	IN
18637	5354	22	any	any	DT
18637	5354	23	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5354	24	retailer	retailer	NN
18637	5354	25	"	"	''
18637	5354	26	equal	equal	JJ
18637	5354	27	to	to	IN
18637	5354	28	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	5354	29	per	per	IN
18637	5354	30	cent	cent	NN
18637	5354	31	of	of	IN
18637	5354	32	the	the	DT
18637	5354	33	invoice	invoice	NN
18637	5354	34	price	price	NN
18637	5354	35	plus	plus	CC
18637	5354	36	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	5354	37	cost	cost	NN
18637	5354	38	,	,	,
18637	5354	39	if	if	IN
18637	5354	40	any	any	DT
18637	5354	41	to	to	IN
18637	5354	42	the	the	DT
18637	5354	43	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5354	44	dealer	dealer	NN
18637	5354	45	.	.	.
18637	5355	1	The	the	DT
18637	5355	2	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5355	3	court	court	NN
18637	5355	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	5355	5	that	that	IN
18637	5355	6	"	"	``
18637	5355	7	the	the	DT
18637	5355	8	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	5355	9	of	of	IN
18637	5355	10	the	the	DT
18637	5355	11	tax	tax	NN
18637	5355	12	against	against	IN
18637	5355	13	the	the	DT
18637	5355	14	retailer	retailer	NN
18637	5355	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	5355	16	not	not	RB
18637	5355	17	on	on	IN
18637	5355	18	the	the	DT
18637	5355	19	act	act	NN
18637	5355	20	of	of	IN
18637	5355	21	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	5355	22	the	the	DT
18637	5355	23	cosmetics	cosmetic	NNS
18637	5355	24	,	,	,
18637	5355	25	but	but	CC
18637	5355	26	on	on	IN
18637	5355	27	the	the	DT
18637	5355	28	sale	sale	NN
18637	5355	29	and	and	CC
18637	5355	30	use	use	VB
18637	5355	31	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	5355	32	,	,	,
18637	5355	33	after	after	IN
18637	5355	34	the	the	DT
18637	5355	35	retailer	retailer	NN
18637	5355	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	5355	37	received	receive	VBN
18637	5355	38	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5355	39	.	.	.
18637	5355	40	"	"	''
18637	5356	1	On	on	IN
18637	5356	2	this	this	DT
18637	5356	3	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	5356	4	the	the	DT
18637	5356	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	5356	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5356	7	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	5356	8	the	the	DT
18637	5356	9	tax	tax	NN
18637	5356	10	.	.	.
18637	5357	1	Obviously	obviously	RB
18637	5357	2	,	,	,
18637	5357	3	other	other	JJ
18637	5357	4	things	thing	NNS
18637	5357	5	being	be	VBG
18637	5357	6	equal	equal	JJ
18637	5357	7	,	,	,
18637	5357	8	there	there	EX
18637	5357	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	5357	10	little	little	JJ
18637	5357	11	difference	difference	NN
18637	5357	12	between	between	IN
18637	5357	13	a	a	DT
18637	5357	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	5357	15	on	on	IN
18637	5357	16	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	5357	17	and	and	CC
18637	5357	18	a	a	DT
18637	5357	19	tax	tax	NN
18637	5357	20	on	on	IN
18637	5357	21	possession	possession	NN
18637	5357	22	a	a	DT
18637	5357	23	moment	moment	NN
18637	5357	24	later	later	RB
18637	5357	25	.	.	.
18637	5358	1	305	305	CD
18637	5358	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5358	3	380	380	CD
18637	5358	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5358	5	1939	1939	CD
18637	5358	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5358	7	.	.	.
18637	5359	1	In	in	IN
18637	5359	2	Felt	Felt	NNP
18637	5359	3	&	&	CC
18637	5359	4	Tarrant	Tarrant	NNP
18637	5359	5	Manufacturing	Manufacturing	NNP
18637	5359	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5359	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5359	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5359	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5359	10	Gallagher	Gallagher	NNP
18637	5359	11	,	,	,
18637	5359	12	306	306	CD
18637	5359	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5359	14	62	62	CD
18637	5359	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5359	16	1939	1939	CD
18637	5359	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5359	18	,	,	,
18637	5359	19	a	a	DT
18637	5359	20	California	California	NNP
18637	5359	21	use	use	NN
18637	5359	22	tax	tax	NN
18637	5359	23	was	be	VBD
18637	5359	24	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	5359	25	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	5359	26	to	to	IN
18637	5359	27	a	a	DT
18637	5359	28	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	5359	29	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	5359	30	which	which	WDT
18637	5359	31	solicited	solicit	VBD
18637	5359	32	orders	order	NNS
18637	5359	33	from	from	IN
18637	5359	34	California	California	NNP
18637	5359	35	purchasers	purchaser	NNS
18637	5359	36	through	through	IN
18637	5359	37	agents	agent	NNS
18637	5359	38	for	for	IN
18637	5359	39	whom	whom	WP
18637	5359	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5359	41	hired	hire	VBD
18637	5359	42	offices	office	NNS
18637	5359	43	in	in	IN
18637	5359	44	the	the	DT
18637	5359	45	State	State	NNP
18637	5359	46	and	and	CC
18637	5359	47	took	take	VBD
18637	5359	48	orders	order	NNS
18637	5359	49	subject	subject	JJ
18637	5359	50	to	to	IN
18637	5359	51	the	the	DT
18637	5359	52	vendor	vendor	NN
18637	5359	53	's	's	POS
18637	5359	54	approval	approval	NN
18637	5359	55	.	.	.
18637	5360	1	In	in	IN
18637	5360	2	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	5360	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5360	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	5360	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5360	6	Sears	Sears	NNP
18637	5360	7	,	,	,
18637	5360	8	Roebuck	Roebuck	NNP
18637	5360	9	&	&	CC
18637	5360	10	Company	Company	NNP
18637	5360	11	and	and	CC
18637	5360	12	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	5360	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5360	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	5360	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5360	16	Montgomery	Montgomery	NNP
18637	5360	17	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	5360	18	&	&	CC
18637	5360	19	Company	Company	NNP
18637	5360	20	,	,	,
18637	5360	21	312	312	CD
18637	5360	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5360	23	359	359	CD
18637	5360	24	and	and	CC
18637	5360	25	373	373	CD
18637	5360	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5360	27	1941	1941	CD
18637	5360	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5360	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5360	30	was	be	VBD
18637	5360	31	held	hold	VBN
18637	5360	32	that	that	IN
18637	5360	33	a	a	DT
18637	5360	34	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	5360	35	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	5360	36	which	which	WDT
18637	5360	37	maintained	maintain	VBD
18637	5360	38	retail	retail	JJ
18637	5360	39	stores	store	NNS
18637	5360	40	in	in	IN
18637	5360	41	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	5360	42	could	could	MD
18637	5360	43	be	be	VB
18637	5360	44	validly	validly	RB
18637	5360	45	required	require	VBN
18637	5360	46	to	to	TO
18637	5360	47	collect	collect	VB
18637	5360	48	an	an	DT
18637	5360	49	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	5360	50	use	use	NN
18637	5360	51	tax	tax	NN
18637	5360	52	in	in	IN
18637	5360	53	respect	respect	NN
18637	5360	54	of	of	IN
18637	5360	55	mail	mail	NN
18637	5360	56	orders	order	NNS
18637	5360	57	sent	send	VBN
18637	5360	58	by	by	IN
18637	5360	59	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	5360	60	purchasers	purchaser	NNS
18637	5360	61	to	to	IN
18637	5360	62	out	out	RB
18637	5360	63	-	-	HYPH
18637	5360	64	of	of	IN
18637	5360	65	-	-	HYPH
18637	5360	66	state	state	NN
18637	5360	67	branches	branch	NNS
18637	5360	68	of	of	IN
18637	5360	69	the	the	DT
18637	5360	70	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	5360	71	and	and	CC
18637	5360	72	filled	fill	VBN
18637	5360	73	by	by	IN
18637	5360	74	direct	direct	JJ
18637	5360	75	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	5360	76	by	by	IN
18637	5360	77	mail	mail	NN
18637	5360	78	or	or	CC
18637	5360	79	common	common	JJ
18637	5360	80	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	5360	81	from	from	IN
18637	5360	82	those	those	DT
18637	5360	83	branches	branch	NNS
18637	5360	84	to	to	IN
18637	5360	85	the	the	DT
18637	5360	86	purchasers	purchaser	NNS
18637	5360	87	.	.	.
18637	5361	1	In	in	IN
18637	5361	2	General	General	NNP
18637	5361	3	Trading	Trading	NNP
18637	5361	4	Company	Company	NNP
18637	5361	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5361	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5361	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5361	8	State	State	NNP
18637	5361	9	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5361	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	5361	11	,	,	,
18637	5361	12	322	322	CD
18637	5361	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5361	14	335	335	CD
18637	5361	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5361	16	1944	1944	CD
18637	5361	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5361	18	,	,	,
18637	5361	19	also	also	RB
18637	5361	20	involving	involve	VBG
18637	5361	21	the	the	DT
18637	5361	22	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	5361	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	5361	24	,	,	,
18637	5361	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5361	26	was	be	VBD
18637	5361	27	held	hold	VBN
18637	5361	28	that	that	IN
18637	5361	29	a	a	DT
18637	5361	30	company	company	NN
18637	5361	31	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	5361	32	on	on	IN
18637	5361	33	no	no	DT
18637	5361	34	operations	operation	NNS
18637	5361	35	in	in	IN
18637	5361	36	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	5361	37	other	other	JJ
18637	5361	38	than	than	IN
18637	5361	39	the	the	DT
18637	5361	40	solicitation	solicitation	NN
18637	5361	41	of	of	IN
18637	5361	42	orders	order	NNS
18637	5361	43	by	by	IN
18637	5361	44	traveling	travel	VBG
18637	5361	45	salesmen	salesman	NNS
18637	5361	46	was	be	VBD
18637	5361	47	liable	liable	JJ
18637	5361	48	for	for	IN
18637	5361	49	collection	collection	NN
18637	5361	50	of	of	IN
18637	5361	51	the	the	DT
18637	5361	52	tax	tax	NN
18637	5361	53	on	on	IN
18637	5361	54	goods	good	NNS
18637	5361	55	sold	sell	VBN
18637	5361	56	to	to	IN
18637	5361	57	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	5361	58	residents	resident	NNS
18637	5361	59	,	,	,
18637	5361	60	even	even	RB
18637	5361	61	though	though	IN
18637	5361	62	the	the	DT
18637	5361	63	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	5361	64	was	be	VBD
18637	5361	65	not	not	RB
18637	5361	66	licensed	license	VBN
18637	5361	67	to	to	TO
18637	5361	68	do	do	VB
18637	5361	69	business	business	NN
18637	5361	70	in	in	IN
18637	5361	71	the	the	DT
18637	5361	72	State	State	NNP
18637	5361	73	and	and	CC
18637	5361	74	the	the	DT
18637	5361	75	orders	order	NNS
18637	5361	76	were	be	VBD
18637	5361	77	forwarded	forward	VBN
18637	5361	78	for	for	IN
18637	5361	79	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	5361	80	to	to	IN
18637	5361	81	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5361	82	where	where	WRB
18637	5361	83	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5361	84	were	be	VBD
18637	5361	85	filled	fill	VBN
18637	5361	86	by	by	IN
18637	5361	87	direct	direct	JJ
18637	5361	88	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	5361	89	to	to	IN
18637	5361	90	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	5361	91	customers	customer	NNS
18637	5361	92	.	.	.
18637	5362	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5362	2	601	601	CD
18637	5362	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5362	4	309	309	CD
18637	5362	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5362	6	33	33	CD
18637	5362	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5362	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	5362	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5362	10	.	.	.
18637	5363	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5363	2	602	602	CD
18637	5363	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5363	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5363	5	.	.	.
18637	5364	1	53	53	CD
18637	5364	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5364	3	54	54	CD
18637	5364	4	.	.	.
18637	5365	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5365	2	603	603	CD
18637	5365	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5365	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5365	5	.	.	.
18637	5366	1	57	57	CD
18637	5366	2	,	,	,
18637	5366	3	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5366	4	Ficklen	Ficklen	NNP
18637	5366	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5366	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5366	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5366	8	Shelby	Shelby	NNP
18637	5366	9	County	County	NNP
18637	5366	10	Taxing	Taxing	NNP
18637	5366	11	District	District	NNP
18637	5366	12	,	,	,
18637	5366	13	145	145	CD
18637	5366	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5366	15	1	1	CD
18637	5366	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5366	17	1892	1892	CD
18637	5366	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5366	19	;	;	:
18637	5366	20	Howe	Howe	NNP
18637	5366	21	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	5366	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5366	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5366	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	5366	25	_	_	NNP
18637	5366	26	Gage	Gage	NNP
18637	5366	27	,	,	,
18637	5366	28	100	100	CD
18637	5366	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5366	30	676	676	CD
18637	5366	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5366	32	1880	1880	CD
18637	5366	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5366	34	;	;	:
18637	5366	35	and	and	CC
18637	5366	36	Wagner	Wagner	NNP
18637	5366	37	_	_	NNP
18637	5366	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	5366	39	_	_	NNP
18637	5366	40	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	5366	41	,	,	,
18637	5366	42	251	251	CD
18637	5366	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5366	44	95	95	CD
18637	5366	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5366	46	1919	1919	CD
18637	5366	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5366	48	.	.	.
18637	5367	1	In	in	IN
18637	5367	2	the	the	DT
18637	5367	3	first	first	JJ
18637	5367	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5367	5	was	be	VBD
18637	5367	6	held	hold	VBN
18637	5367	7	that	that	IN
18637	5367	8	the	the	DT
18637	5367	9	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	5367	10	case	case	NN
18637	5367	11	did	do	VBD
18637	5367	12	not	not	RB
18637	5367	13	apply	apply	VB
18637	5367	14	to	to	IN
18637	5367	15	a	a	DT
18637	5367	16	firm	firm	NN
18637	5367	17	of	of	IN
18637	5367	18	agents	agent	NNS
18637	5367	19	and	and	CC
18637	5367	20	brokers	broker	NNS
18637	5367	21	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	5367	22	an	an	DT
18637	5367	23	office	office	NN
18637	5367	24	and	and	CC
18637	5367	25	samples	sample	NNS
18637	5367	26	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	5367	27	the	the	DT
18637	5367	28	year	year	NN
18637	5367	29	in	in	IN
18637	5367	30	the	the	DT
18637	5367	31	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	5367	32	district	district	NN
18637	5367	33	.	.	.
18637	5368	1	The	the	DT
18637	5368	2	other	other	JJ
18637	5368	3	two	two	CD
18637	5368	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	5368	5	were	be	VBD
18637	5368	6	totally	totally	RB
18637	5368	7	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
18637	5368	8	.	.	.
18637	5369	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5369	2	604	604	CD
18637	5369	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5369	4	309	309	CD
18637	5369	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5369	6	70	70	CD
18637	5369	7	and	and	CC
18637	5369	8	430	430	CD
18637	5369	9	.	.	.
18637	5370	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5370	2	605	605	CD
18637	5370	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5370	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5370	5	.	.	.
18637	5371	1	414	414	CD
18637	5371	2	.	.	.
18637	5372	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5372	2	606	606	CD
18637	5372	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5372	4	322	322	CD
18637	5372	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5372	6	327	327	CD
18637	5372	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5372	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	5372	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5372	10	.	.	.
18637	5373	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5373	2	607	607	CD
18637	5373	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5373	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5373	5	.	.	.
18637	5374	1	330	330	CD
18637	5374	2	.	.	.
18637	5375	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5375	2	608	608	CD
18637	5375	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5375	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5375	5	.	.	.
18637	5376	1	332	332	CD
18637	5376	2	.	.	.
18637	5377	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5377	2	609	609	CD
18637	5377	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5377	4	327	327	CD
18637	5377	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5377	6	416	416	CD
18637	5377	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5377	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	5377	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5377	10	.	.	.
18637	5378	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5378	2	610	610	CD
18637	5378	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5378	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5378	5	.	.	.
18637	5379	1	417	417	CD
18637	5379	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5379	3	418	418	CD
18637	5379	4	.	.	.
18637	5380	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5380	2	611	611	CD
18637	5380	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5380	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5380	5	.	.	.
18637	5381	1	435	435	CD
18637	5381	2	.	.	.
18637	5382	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5382	2	612	612	CD
18637	5382	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5382	4	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	5382	5	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	5382	6	Laundry	Laundry	NNP
18637	5382	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5382	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5382	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5382	10	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	5382	11	,	,	,
18637	5382	12	342	342	CD
18637	5382	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5382	14	389	389	CD
18637	5382	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5382	16	1952	1952	CD
18637	5382	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5382	18	.	.	.
18637	5383	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5383	2	613	613	CD
18637	5383	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5383	4	Norton	Norton	NNP
18637	5383	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5383	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5383	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5383	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5383	9	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	5383	10	.	.	.
18637	5384	1	of	of	IN
18637	5384	2	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	5384	3	,	,	,
18637	5384	4	340	340	CD
18637	5384	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5384	6	534	534	CD
18637	5384	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5384	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	5384	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5384	10	,	,	,
18637	5384	11	although	although	IN
18637	5384	12	decided	decide	VBN
18637	5384	13	by	by	IN
18637	5384	14	a	a	DT
18637	5384	15	closely	closely	RB
18637	5384	16	divided	divide	VBN
18637	5384	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5384	18	,	,	,
18637	5384	19	further	further	RB
18637	5384	20	confirms	confirm	VBZ
18637	5384	21	this	this	DT
18637	5384	22	impression	impression	NN
18637	5384	23	.	.	.
18637	5385	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5385	2	614	614	CD
18637	5385	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5385	4	9	9	CD
18637	5385	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5385	6	.	.	.
18637	5386	1	1	1	CD
18637	5386	2	,	,	,
18637	5386	3	217	217	CD
18637	5386	4	-	-	SYM
18637	5386	5	219	219	CD
18637	5386	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5386	7	1824	1824	CD
18637	5386	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5386	9	.	.	.
18637	5387	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5387	2	615	615	CD
18637	5387	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5387	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	5387	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5387	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5387	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5387	8	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	5387	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5387	10	Passenger	Passenger	NNP
18637	5387	11	Cases	Cases	NNP
18637	5387	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5387	13	,	,	,
18637	5387	14	7	7	CD
18637	5387	15	How	how	WRB
18637	5387	16	.	.	.
18637	5388	1	283	283	CD
18637	5388	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5388	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	5388	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5388	5	.	.	.
18637	5389	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5389	2	616	616	CD
18637	5389	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5389	4	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	5389	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5389	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5389	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5389	8	Mayor	Mayor	NNP
18637	5389	9	of	of	IN
18637	5389	10	New	New	NNP
18637	5389	11	York	York	NNP
18637	5389	12	,	,	,
18637	5389	13	92	92	CD
18637	5389	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5389	15	259	259	CD
18637	5389	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5389	17	1876	1876	CD
18637	5389	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5389	19	;	;	:
18637	5389	20	New	New	NNP
18637	5389	21	York	York	NNP
18637	5389	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5389	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	5389	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5389	25	Compagnie	Compagnie	NNP
18637	5389	26	GÃ	GÃ	NNP
18637	5389	27	©	©	NNP
18637	5389	28	nÃ	nÃ	NNP
18637	5389	29	©	©	NNP
18637	5389	30	rale	rale	NN
18637	5389	31	Transatlantique	Transatlantique	NNP
18637	5389	32	,	,	,
18637	5389	33	107	107	CD
18637	5389	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5389	35	59	59	CD
18637	5389	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5389	37	1883	1883	CD
18637	5389	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5389	39	.	.	.
18637	5390	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5390	2	617	617	CD
18637	5390	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5390	4	6	6	CD
18637	5390	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5390	6	.	.	.
18637	5391	1	35	35	CD
18637	5391	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5391	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	5391	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5391	5	.	.	.
18637	5392	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5392	2	618	618	LS
18637	5392	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5392	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5392	5	.	.	.
18637	5393	1	49	49	CD
18637	5393	2	.	.	.
18637	5394	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5394	2	619	619	CD
18637	5394	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5394	4	114	114	CD
18637	5394	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5394	6	196	196	CD
18637	5394	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5394	8	1885	1885	CD
18637	5394	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5394	10	.	.	.
18637	5395	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5395	2	620	620	CD
18637	5395	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5395	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5395	5	.	.	.
18637	5396	1	203	203	CD
18637	5396	2	.	.	.
18637	5397	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5397	2	621	621	CD
18637	5397	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5397	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5397	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5397	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5397	7	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	5397	8	&	&	CC
18637	5397	9	C.	C.	NNP
18637	5397	10	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	5397	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5397	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5397	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	5397	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5397	15	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5397	16	,	,	,
18637	5397	17	154	154	CD
18637	5397	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5397	19	204	204	CD
18637	5397	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5397	21	1894	1894	CD
18637	5397	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5397	23	;	;	:
18637	5397	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5397	25	also	also	RB
18637	5397	26	_	_	NNP
18637	5397	27	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	5397	28	_	_	NNP
18637	5397	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	5397	30	_	_	NNP
18637	5397	31	California	California	NNP
18637	5397	32	,	,	,
18637	5397	33	314	314	CD
18637	5397	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5397	35	160	160	CD
18637	5397	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5397	37	1941	1941	CD
18637	5397	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5397	39	,	,	,
18637	5397	40	the	the	DT
18637	5397	41	decision	decision	NN
18637	5397	42	in	in	IN
18637	5397	43	which	which	WDT
18637	5397	44	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	5397	45	the	the	DT
18637	5397	46	exact	exact	JJ
18637	5397	47	inverse	inverse	NN
18637	5397	48	of	of	IN
18637	5397	49	that	that	DT
18637	5397	50	in	in	IN
18637	5397	51	the	the	DT
18637	5397	52	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	5397	53	Case	Case	NNP
18637	5397	54	,	,	,
18637	5397	55	being	be	VBG
18637	5397	56	based	base	VBN
18637	5397	57	by	by	IN
18637	5397	58	the	the	DT
18637	5397	59	majority	majority	NN
18637	5397	60	on	on	IN
18637	5397	61	the	the	DT
18637	5397	62	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	5397	63	clause	clause	NN
18637	5397	64	,	,	,
18637	5397	65	while	while	IN
18637	5397	66	several	several	JJ
18637	5397	67	of	of	IN
18637	5397	68	the	the	DT
18637	5397	69	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	5397	70	preferred	prefer	VBD
18637	5397	71	to	to	TO
18637	5397	72	put	put	VB
18637	5397	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5397	74	on	on	IN
18637	5397	75	the	the	DT
18637	5397	76	broader	broad	JJR
18637	5397	77	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	5397	78	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	5397	79	by	by	IN
18637	5397	80	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5397	81	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	5397	82	in	in	IN
18637	5397	83	the	the	DT
18637	5397	84	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	5397	85	Case	Case	NNP
18637	5397	86	.	.	.
18637	5398	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5398	2	622	622	CD
18637	5398	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5398	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5398	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	5398	6	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	5398	7	Company	Company	NNP
18637	5398	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5398	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5398	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5398	11	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	5398	12	,	,	,
18637	5398	13	105	105	CD
18637	5398	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5398	15	460	460	CD
18637	5398	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5398	17	1882	1882	CD
18637	5398	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5398	19	State	State	NNP
18637	5398	20	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	5398	21	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5398	22	Case	Case	NNP
18637	5398	23	,	,	,
18637	5398	24	15	15	CD
18637	5398	25	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5398	26	.	.	.
18637	5399	1	232	232	CD
18637	5399	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5399	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	5399	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5399	5	and	and	CC
18637	5399	6	Pensacola	Pensacola	NNP
18637	5399	7	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	5399	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5399	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5399	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5399	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5399	12	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5399	13	Union	Union	NNP
18637	5399	14	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	5399	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5399	16	,	,	,
18637	5399	17	96	96	CD
18637	5399	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5399	19	1	1	CD
18637	5399	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5399	21	1878	1878	CD
18637	5399	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5399	23	were	be	VBD
18637	5399	24	the	the	DT
18637	5399	25	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	5399	26	principally	principally	RB
18637	5399	27	relied	rely	VBD
18637	5399	28	on	on	RP
18637	5399	29	.	.	.
18637	5400	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5400	2	623	623	CD
18637	5400	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5400	4	8	8	CD
18637	5400	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5400	6	.	.	.
18637	5401	1	168	168	CD
18637	5401	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5401	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	5401	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5401	5	.	.	.
18637	5402	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5402	2	624	624	CD
18637	5402	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5402	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5402	5	.	.	.
18637	5403	1	181	181	CD
18637	5403	2	.	.	.
18637	5404	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5404	2	625	625	CD
18637	5404	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5404	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5404	5	.	.	.
18637	5405	1	182	182	CD
18637	5405	2	.	.	.
18637	5406	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5406	2	626	626	CD
18637	5406	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5406	4	15	15	CD
18637	5406	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5406	6	.	.	.
18637	5407	1	232	232	CD
18637	5407	2	,	,	,
18637	5407	3	233	233	CD
18637	5407	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	5407	5	234	234	CD
18637	5407	6	,	,	,
18637	5407	7	278	278	CD
18637	5407	8	-	-	SYM
18637	5407	9	279	279	CD
18637	5407	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5407	11	1873	1873	CD
18637	5407	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5407	13	.	.	.
18637	5408	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5408	2	627	627	CD
18637	5408	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5408	4	127	127	CD
18637	5408	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5408	6	640	640	CD
18637	5408	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5408	8	1888	1888	CD
18637	5408	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5408	10	.	.	.
18637	5409	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5409	2	628	628	CD
18637	5409	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5409	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5409	5	.	.	.
18637	5410	1	645	645	CD
18637	5410	2	.	.	.
18637	5411	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5411	2	629	629	CD
18637	5411	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5411	4	Crutcher	Crutcher	NNP
18637	5411	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5411	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5411	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5411	8	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5411	9	,	,	,
18637	5411	10	141	141	CD
18637	5411	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5411	12	47	47	CD
18637	5411	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5411	14	1891	1891	CD
18637	5411	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5411	16	.	.	.
18637	5412	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5412	2	630	630	CD
18637	5412	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5412	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5412	5	.	.	.
18637	5413	1	57	57	CD
18637	5413	2	.	.	.
18637	5414	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5414	2	631	631	CD
18637	5414	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5414	4	266	266	CD
18637	5414	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5414	6	555	555	CD
18637	5414	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5414	8	1925	1925	CD
18637	5414	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5414	10	.	.	.
18637	5415	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5415	2	632	632	CD
18637	5415	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5415	4	268	268	CD
18637	5415	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5415	6	203	203	CD
18637	5415	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5415	8	1925	1925	CD
18637	5415	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5415	10	;	;	:
18637	5415	11	followed	follow	VBN
18637	5415	12	in	in	IN
18637	5415	13	Cudahy	Cudahy	NNP
18637	5415	14	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	5415	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5415	16	_	_	NNP
18637	5415	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	5415	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5415	19	Hinkle	Hinkle	NNP
18637	5415	20	,	,	,
18637	5415	21	278	278	CD
18637	5415	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5415	23	460	460	CD
18637	5415	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5415	25	1929	1929	CD
18637	5415	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5415	27	.	.	.
18637	5416	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5416	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	5416	3	.	.	.
18637	5416	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5416	5	,	,	,
18637	5416	6	however	however	RB
18637	5416	7	,	,	,
18637	5416	8	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5416	9	Live	Live	NNP
18637	5416	10	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	5416	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5416	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	5416	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5416	14	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
18637	5416	15	of	of	IN
18637	5416	16	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	5416	17	,	,	,
18637	5416	18	303	303	CD
18637	5416	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5416	20	250	250	CD
18637	5416	21	,	,	,
18637	5416	22	255	255	CD
18637	5416	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5416	24	1938	1938	CD
18637	5416	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5416	26	.	.	.
18637	5417	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5417	2	633	633	CD
18637	5417	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5417	4	Anglo	anglo	JJ
18637	5417	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	5417	6	Chilean	Chilean	NNP
18637	5417	7	Nitrate	Nitrate	NNP
18637	5417	8	Sales	Sales	NNPS
18637	5417	9	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	5417	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5417	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	5417	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5417	13	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	5417	14	,	,	,
18637	5417	15	288	288	CD
18637	5417	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5417	17	218	218	CD
18637	5417	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5417	19	1933	1933	CD
18637	5417	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5417	21	.	.	.
18637	5418	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5418	2	634	634	CD
18637	5418	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5418	4	Cooney	Cooney	NNP
18637	5418	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5418	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5418	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5418	8	Mountain	Mountain	NNP
18637	5418	9	States	States	NNP
18637	5418	10	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	5418	11	&	&	CC
18637	5418	12	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	5418	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5418	14	,	,	,
18637	5418	15	294	294	CD
18637	5418	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5418	17	384	384	CD
18637	5418	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5418	19	1935	1935	CD
18637	5418	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5418	21	.	.	.
18637	5419	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5419	2	635	635	CD
18637	5419	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5419	4	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	5419	5	's	's	POS
18637	5419	6	Blend	Blend	NNP
18637	5419	7	Station	Station	NNP
18637	5419	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5419	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5419	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5419	11	State	State	NNP
18637	5419	12	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5419	13	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	5419	14	,	,	,
18637	5419	15	297	297	CD
18637	5419	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5419	17	650	650	CD
18637	5419	18	,	,	,
18637	5419	19	656	656	CD
18637	5419	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5419	21	1936	1936	CD
18637	5419	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5419	23	.	.	.
18637	5420	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5420	2	636	636	CD
18637	5420	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5420	4	Puget	Puget	NNP
18637	5420	5	Sound	sound	NN
18637	5420	6	Stevedoring	Stevedoring	NNP
18637	5420	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5420	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5420	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5420	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5420	11	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5420	12	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	5420	13	of	of	IN
18637	5420	14	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	5420	15	,	,	,
18637	5420	16	302	302	CD
18637	5420	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5420	18	90	90	CD
18637	5420	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5420	20	1937	1937	CD
18637	5420	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5420	22	.	.	.
18637	5421	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5421	2	637	637	CD
18637	5421	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5421	4	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	5421	5	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	5421	6	.	.	.
18637	5422	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5422	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5422	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5422	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5422	5	Storen	Storen	NNP
18637	5422	6	,	,	,
18637	5422	7	304	304	CD
18637	5422	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5422	9	307	307	CD
18637	5422	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5422	11	1938	1938	CD
18637	5422	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5422	13	.	.	.
18637	5423	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5423	2	638	638	CD
18637	5423	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5423	4	McCarroll	McCarroll	NNP
18637	5423	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5423	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5423	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5423	8	Dixie	Dixie	NNP
18637	5423	9	Greyhound	Greyhound	NNP
18637	5423	10	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	5423	11	,	,	,
18637	5423	12	309	309	CD
18637	5423	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5423	14	176	176	CD
18637	5423	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5423	16	1940	1940	CD
18637	5423	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5423	18	.	.	.
18637	5424	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5424	3	also	also	RB
18637	5424	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	5	the	the	DT
18637	5424	6	following	follow	VBG
18637	5424	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	5424	8	in	in	IN
18637	5424	9	which	which	WDT
18637	5424	10	the	the	DT
18637	5424	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5424	12	found	find	VBD
18637	5424	13	a	a	DT
18637	5424	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	5424	15	to	to	TO
18637	5424	16	be	be	VB
18637	5424	17	an	an	DT
18637	5424	18	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	5424	19	interference	interference	NN
18637	5424	20	with	with	IN
18637	5424	21	the	the	DT
18637	5424	22	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5424	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5424	24	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	5424	25	:	:	:
18637	5424	26	Tax	tax	NN
18637	5424	27	on	on	IN
18637	5424	28	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	5424	29	of	of	IN
18637	5424	30	office	office	NN
18637	5424	31	in	in	IN
18637	5424	32	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5424	33	for	for	IN
18637	5424	34	use	use	NN
18637	5424	35	of	of	IN
18637	5424	36	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	5424	37	,	,	,
18637	5424	38	officers	officer	NNS
18637	5424	39	,	,	,
18637	5424	40	employees	employee	NNS
18637	5424	41	,	,	,
18637	5424	42	and	and	CC
18637	5424	43	agents	agent	NNS
18637	5424	44	of	of	IN
18637	5424	45	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	5424	46	not	not	RB
18637	5424	47	operating	operate	VBG
18637	5424	48	in	in	IN
18637	5424	49	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5424	50	but	but	CC
18637	5424	51	a	a	DT
18637	5424	52	link	link	NN
18637	5424	53	in	in	IN
18637	5424	54	a	a	DT
18637	5424	55	line	line	NN
18637	5424	56	operating	operate	VBG
18637	5424	57	therein	therein	RB
18637	5424	58	,	,	,
18637	5424	59	Norfolk	Norfolk	NNP
18637	5424	60	&	&	CC
18637	5424	61	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	5424	62	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5424	63	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	5424	65	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	66	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5424	67	,	,	,
18637	5424	68	136	136	CD
18637	5424	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5424	70	114	114	CD
18637	5424	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5424	72	1890	1890	CD
18637	5424	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5424	74	;	;	:
18637	5424	75	license	license	NN
18637	5424	76	tax	tax	NN
18637	5424	77	on	on	IN
18637	5424	78	sale	sale	NN
18637	5424	79	of	of	IN
18637	5424	80	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	5424	81	as	as	IN
18637	5424	82	applied	apply	VBN
18637	5424	83	to	to	IN
18637	5424	84	a	a	DT
18637	5424	85	sale	sale	NN
18637	5424	86	out	out	IN
18637	5424	87	of	of	IN
18637	5424	88	State	state	NN
18637	5424	89	by	by	IN
18637	5424	90	mail	mail	NN
18637	5424	91	,	,	,
18637	5424	92	Heyman	Heyman	NNP
18637	5424	93	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	94	v.	v.	IN
18637	5424	95	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	96	Hays	Hays	NNP
18637	5424	97	,	,	,
18637	5424	98	236	236	CD
18637	5424	99	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5424	100	178	178	CD
18637	5424	101	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5424	102	1915	1915	CD
18637	5424	103	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5424	104	;	;	:
18637	5424	105	tax	tax	NN
18637	5424	106	on	on	IN
18637	5424	107	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	5424	108	lines	line	NNS
18637	5424	109	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	5424	110	oil	oil	NN
18637	5424	111	or	or	CC
18637	5424	112	gas	gas	NN
18637	5424	113	produced	produce	VBN
18637	5424	114	in	in	IN
18637	5424	115	State	State	NNP
18637	5424	116	but	but	CC
18637	5424	117	which	which	WDT
18637	5424	118	might	may	MD
18637	5424	119	pass	pass	VB
18637	5424	120	out	out	IN
18637	5424	121	of	of	IN
18637	5424	122	State	State	NNP
18637	5424	123	,	,	,
18637	5424	124	Eureka	Eureka	NNP
18637	5424	125	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	5424	126	Line	Line	NNP
18637	5424	127	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5424	128	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	129	v.	v.	IN
18637	5424	130	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	131	Hallanan	Hallanan	NNP
18637	5424	132	,	,	,
18637	5424	133	257	257	CD
18637	5424	134	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5424	135	265	265	CD
18637	5424	136	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5424	137	1921	1921	CD
18637	5424	138	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5424	139	;	;	:
18637	5424	140	United	United	NNP
18637	5424	141	Fuel	Fuel	NNP
18637	5424	142	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5424	143	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5424	144	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	145	v.	v.	IN
18637	5424	146	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	147	Hallanan	Hallanan	NNP
18637	5424	148	,	,	,
18637	5424	149	257	257	CD
18637	5424	150	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5424	151	277	277	CD
18637	5424	152	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5424	153	1921	1921	CD
18637	5424	154	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5424	155	;	;	:
18637	5424	156	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5424	157	tax	tax	NN
18637	5424	158	on	on	IN
18637	5424	159	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	5424	160	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	5424	161	in	in	IN
18637	5424	162	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5424	163	and	and	CC
18637	5424	164	used	use	VBN
18637	5424	165	in	in	IN
18637	5424	166	an	an	DT
18637	5424	167	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5424	168	-	-	HYPH
18637	5424	169	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5424	170	ferry	ferry	NN
18637	5424	171	,	,	,
18637	5424	172	Helson	Helson	NNP
18637	5424	173	&	&	CC
18637	5424	174	Randolph	Randolph	NNP
18637	5424	175	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	176	v.	v.	IN
18637	5424	177	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	178	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5424	179	,	,	,
18637	5424	180	279	279	CD
18637	5424	181	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5424	182	245	245	CD
18637	5424	183	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5424	184	1929	1929	CD
18637	5424	185	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5424	186	;	;	:
18637	5424	187	tax	tax	NN
18637	5424	188	laid	lay	VBN
18637	5424	189	on	on	IN
18637	5424	190	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	5424	191	of	of	IN
18637	5424	192	operating	operate	VBG
18637	5424	193	a	a	DT
18637	5424	194	bus	bus	NN
18637	5424	195	in	in	IN
18637	5424	196	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5424	197	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5424	198	because	because	IN
18637	5424	199	not	not	RB
18637	5424	200	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	5424	201	solely	solely	RB
18637	5424	202	as	as	IN
18637	5424	203	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	5424	204	for	for	IN
18637	5424	205	use	use	NN
18637	5424	206	of	of	IN
18637	5424	207	highways	highway	NNS
18637	5424	208	or	or	CC
18637	5424	209	to	to	TO
18637	5424	210	defray	defray	VB
18637	5424	211	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	5424	212	of	of	IN
18637	5424	213	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	5424	214	motor	motor	NN
18637	5424	215	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	5424	216	,	,	,
18637	5424	217	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	5424	218	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	5424	219	,	,	,
18637	5424	220	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	5424	221	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	222	v.	v.	IN
18637	5424	223	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	224	Lindsey	Lindsey	NNP
18637	5424	225	,	,	,
18637	5424	226	283	283	CD
18637	5424	227	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5424	228	183	183	CD
18637	5424	229	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5424	230	1931	1931	CD
18637	5424	231	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5424	232	;	;	:
18637	5424	233	tax	tax	NN
18637	5424	234	on	on	IN
18637	5424	235	gas	gas	NN
18637	5424	236	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	5424	237	line	line	NN
18637	5424	238	whose	whose	WP$
18637	5424	239	only	only	JJ
18637	5424	240	activity	activity	NN
18637	5424	241	in	in	IN
18637	5424	242	State	state	NN
18637	5424	243	was	be	VBD
18637	5424	244	the	the	DT
18637	5424	245	use	use	NN
18637	5424	246	of	of	IN
18637	5424	247	a	a	DT
18637	5424	248	thermometer	thermometer	NN
18637	5424	249	and	and	CC
18637	5424	250	reduction	reduction	NN
18637	5424	251	of	of	IN
18637	5424	252	pressure	pressure	NN
18637	5424	253	to	to	TO
18637	5424	254	permit	permit	VB
18637	5424	255	a	a	DT
18637	5424	256	vendee	vendee	NN
18637	5424	257	to	to	TO
18637	5424	258	draw	draw	VB
18637	5424	259	off	off	RP
18637	5424	260	gas	gas	NN
18637	5424	261	,	,	,
18637	5424	262	State	State	NNP
18637	5424	263	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5424	264	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	5424	265	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	266	v.	v.	IN
18637	5424	267	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	268	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	5424	269	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	5424	270	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5424	271	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5424	272	,	,	,
18637	5424	273	284	284	CD
18637	5424	274	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5424	275	41	41	CD
18637	5424	276	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5424	277	1931)--but	1931)--but	CD
18637	5424	278	see	see	NN
18637	5424	279	East	East	NNP
18637	5424	280	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	5424	281	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5424	282	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5424	283	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	284	v.	v.	IN
18637	5424	285	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	286	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5424	287	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	5424	288	,	,	,
18637	5424	289	283	283	CD
18637	5424	290	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5424	291	465	465	CD
18637	5424	292	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5424	293	1931	1931	CD
18637	5424	294	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5424	295	;	;	:
18637	5424	296	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	5424	297	tax	tax	NN
18637	5424	298	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	5424	299	per	per	IN
18637	5424	300	gallon	gallon	NN
18637	5424	301	of	of	IN
18637	5424	302	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	5424	303	imported	import	VBN
18637	5424	304	by	by	IN
18637	5424	305	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5424	306	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	5424	307	as	as	IN
18637	5424	308	fuel	fuel	NN
18637	5424	309	for	for	IN
18637	5424	310	use	use	NN
18637	5424	311	in	in	IN
18637	5424	312	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5424	313	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	5424	314	within	within	IN
18637	5424	315	the	the	DT
18637	5424	316	State	State	NNP
18637	5424	317	as	as	RB
18637	5424	318	well	well	RB
18637	5424	319	as	as	IN
18637	5424	320	in	in	IN
18637	5424	321	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5424	322	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5424	323	travel	travel	NN
18637	5424	324	,	,	,
18637	5424	325	Bingaman	Bingaman	NNP
18637	5424	326	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	327	v.	v.	IN
18637	5424	328	_	_	NNP
18637	5424	329	Golden	Golden	NNP
18637	5424	330	Eagle	Eagle	NNP
18637	5424	331	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5424	332	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	5424	333	,	,	,
18637	5424	334	297	297	CD
18637	5424	335	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5424	336	626	626	CD
18637	5424	337	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5424	338	1936	1936	CD
18637	5424	339	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5424	340	.	.	.
18637	5425	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5425	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5425	3	also	also	RB
18637	5425	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5425	5	,	,	,
18637	5425	6	for	for	IN
18637	5425	7	reiteration	reiteration	NN
18637	5425	8	of	of	IN
18637	5425	9	the	the	DT
18637	5425	10	basic	basic	JJ
18637	5425	11	rule	rule	NN
18637	5425	12	that	that	IN
18637	5425	13	the	the	DT
18637	5425	14	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	5425	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	5425	16	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	5425	17	States	States	NNP
18637	5425	18	to	to	TO
18637	5425	19	tax	tax	VB
18637	5425	20	the	the	DT
18637	5425	21	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	5425	22	of	of	IN
18637	5425	23	engaging	engage	VBG
18637	5425	24	in	in	IN
18637	5425	25	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5425	26	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5425	27	,	,	,
18637	5425	28	Gwin	Gwin	NNP
18637	5425	29	,	,	,
18637	5425	30	White	White	NNP
18637	5425	31	&	&	CC
18637	5425	32	Prince	Prince	NNP
18637	5425	33	_	_	NNP
18637	5425	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	5425	35	_	_	NNP
18637	5425	36	Henneford	Henneford	NNP
18637	5425	37	,	,	,
18637	5425	38	305	305	CD
18637	5425	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5425	40	434	434	CD
18637	5425	41	,	,	,
18637	5425	42	438	438	CD
18637	5425	43	-	-	SYM
18637	5425	44	439	439	CD
18637	5425	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5425	46	1939	1939	CD
18637	5425	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5425	48	.	.	.
18637	5426	1	In	in	IN
18637	5426	2	California	California	NNP
18637	5426	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5426	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	5426	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5426	6	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	5426	7	,	,	,
18637	5426	8	313	313	CD
18637	5426	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5426	10	109	109	CD
18637	5426	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5426	12	1941	1941	CD
18637	5426	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5426	14	,	,	,
18637	5426	15	the	the	DT
18637	5426	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5426	17	,	,	,
18637	5426	18	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	5426	19	Di	Di	NNP
18637	5426	20	Santo	Santo	NNP
18637	5426	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5426	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	5426	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5426	24	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5426	25	,	,	,
18637	5426	26	273	273	CD
18637	5426	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5426	28	34	34	CD
18637	5426	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5426	30	1927	1927	CD
18637	5426	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5426	32	,	,	,
18637	5426	33	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	5426	34	,	,	,
18637	5426	35	as	as	IN
18637	5426	36	not	not	RB
18637	5426	37	a	a	DT
18637	5426	38	"	"	``
18637	5426	39	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	5426	40	measure	measure	NN
18637	5426	41	,	,	,
18637	5426	42	"	"	''
18637	5426	43	but	but	CC
18637	5426	44	"	"	``
18637	5426	45	a	a	DT
18637	5426	46	measure	measure	NN
18637	5426	47	to	to	TO
18637	5426	48	safeguard	safeguard	VB
18637	5426	49	the	the	DT
18637	5426	50	traveling	travel	VBG
18637	5426	51	public	public	NN
18637	5426	52	by	by	IN
18637	5426	53	motor	motor	NN
18637	5426	54	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	5426	55	,	,	,
18637	5426	56	"	"	``
18637	5426	57	who	who	WP
18637	5426	58	are	be	VBP
18637	5426	59	"	"	``
18637	5426	60	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	5426	61	unable	unable	JJ
18637	5426	62	"	"	''
18637	5426	63	to	to	TO
18637	5426	64	protect	protect	VB
18637	5426	65	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5426	66	against	against	IN
18637	5426	67	overreaching	overreach	VBG
18637	5426	68	by	by	IN
18637	5426	69	those	those	DT
18637	5426	70	"	"	``
18637	5426	71	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	5426	72	in	in	IN
18637	5426	73	a	a	DT
18637	5426	74	business	business	NN
18637	5426	75	notoriously	notoriously	RB
18637	5426	76	subject	subject	JJ
18637	5426	77	to	to	IN
18637	5426	78	abuses	abuse	NNS
18637	5426	79	,	,	,
18637	5426	80	"	"	''
18637	5426	81	a	a	DT
18637	5426	82	California	California	NNP
18637	5426	83	statute	statute	NN
18637	5426	84	requiring	require	VBG
18637	5426	85	that	that	IN
18637	5426	86	agents	agent	NNS
18637	5426	87	for	for	IN
18637	5426	88	this	this	DT
18637	5426	89	type	type	NN
18637	5426	90	of	of	IN
18637	5426	91	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	5426	92	take	take	VB
18637	5426	93	out	out	RP
18637	5426	94	a	a	DT
18637	5426	95	license	license	NN
18637	5426	96	for	for	IN
18637	5426	97	both	both	CC
18637	5426	98	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5426	99	interstate	interstate	NN
18637	5426	100	and	and	CC
18637	5426	101	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5426	102	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	5426	103	business	business	NN
18637	5426	104	.	.	.
18637	5427	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5427	2	639	639	CD
18637	5427	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5427	4	216	216	CD
18637	5427	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5427	6	1	1	CD
18637	5427	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5427	8	1910	1910	CD
18637	5427	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5427	10	.	.	.
18637	5428	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5428	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	5428	3	.	.	.
18637	5428	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5428	5	Osborne	Osborne	NNP
18637	5428	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5428	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5428	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5428	9	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	5428	10	,	,	,
18637	5428	11	164	164	CD
18637	5428	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5428	13	650	650	CD
18637	5428	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5428	15	1897	1897	CD
18637	5428	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5428	17	,	,	,
18637	5428	18	involving	involve	VBG
18637	5428	19	an	an	DT
18637	5428	20	express	express	JJ
18637	5428	21	business	business	NN
18637	5428	22	;	;	:
18637	5428	23	in	in	IN
18637	5428	24	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	5428	25	Company	Company	NNP
18637	5428	26	_	_	NNP
18637	5428	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	5428	28	_	_	NNP
18637	5428	29	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	5428	30	,	,	,
18637	5428	31	189	189	CD
18637	5428	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5428	33	420	420	CD
18637	5428	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5428	35	1903	1903	CD
18637	5428	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5428	37	;	;	:
18637	5428	38	and	and	CC
18637	5428	39	in	in	IN
18637	5428	40	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	5428	41	_	_	NNP
18637	5428	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	5428	43	_	_	NNP
18637	5428	44	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	5428	45	's	's	POS
18637	5428	46	Palace	Palace	NNP
18637	5428	47	Car	Car	NNP
18637	5428	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5428	49	,	,	,
18637	5428	50	191	191	CD
18637	5428	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5428	52	171	171	CD
18637	5428	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5428	54	1903	1903	CD
18637	5428	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5428	56	.	.	.
18637	5429	1	Here	here	RB
18637	5429	2	State	state	NN
18637	5429	3	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	5429	4	levied	levy	VBN
18637	5429	5	on	on	IN
18637	5429	6	the	the	DT
18637	5429	7	local	local	JJ
18637	5429	8	business	business	NN
18637	5429	9	of	of	IN
18637	5429	10	companies	company	NNS
18637	5429	11	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	5429	12	also	also	RB
18637	5429	13	in	in	IN
18637	5429	14	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5429	15	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	5429	16	were	be	VBD
18637	5429	17	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	5429	18	"	"	''
18637	5429	19	on	on	IN
18637	5429	20	the	the	DT
18637	5429	21	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	5429	22	"	"	''
18637	5429	23	that	that	IN
18637	5429	24	the	the	DT
18637	5429	25	companies	company	NNS
18637	5429	26	in	in	IN
18637	5429	27	question	question	NN
18637	5429	28	were	be	VBD
18637	5429	29	free	free	JJ
18637	5429	30	to	to	TO
18637	5429	31	abandon	abandon	VB
18637	5429	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5429	33	local	local	JJ
18637	5429	34	business	business	NN
18637	5429	35	.	.	.
18637	5430	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5430	2	640	640	CD
18637	5430	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5430	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5430	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5430	6	also	also	RB
18637	5430	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5430	8	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	5430	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5430	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5430	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	5430	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5430	13	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	5430	14	ex	ex	NNP
18637	5430	15	rel	rel	NNP
18637	5430	16	.	.	.
18637	5431	1	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	5431	2	,	,	,
18637	5431	3	216	216	CD
18637	5431	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5431	5	56	56	CD
18637	5431	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5431	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	5431	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5431	9	;	;	:
18637	5431	10	Ludwig	Ludwig	NNP
18637	5431	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5431	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	5431	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5431	14	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5431	15	Union	Union	NNP
18637	5431	16	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5431	17	.	.	.
18637	5432	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5432	2	,	,	,
18637	5432	3	216	216	CD
18637	5432	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5432	5	146	146	CD
18637	5432	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5432	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	5432	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5432	9	;	;	:
18637	5432	10	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	5432	11	,	,	,
18637	5432	12	T.	T.	NNP
18637	5432	13	&	&	CC
18637	5432	14	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	5433	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5433	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5433	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5433	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5433	5	O'Connor	O'Connor	NNP
18637	5433	6	,	,	,
18637	5433	7	223	223	CD
18637	5433	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5433	9	280	280	CD
18637	5433	10	,	,	,
18637	5433	11	285	285	CD
18637	5433	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5433	13	1912	1912	CD
18637	5433	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5433	15	.	.	.
18637	5434	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5434	2	641	641	CD
18637	5434	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5434	4	245	245	CD
18637	5434	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5434	6	178	178	CD
18637	5434	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5434	8	1917	1917	CD
18637	5434	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5434	10	.	.	.
18637	5435	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5435	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	5435	3	.	.	.
18637	5435	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5435	5	Baltic	Baltic	NNP
18637	5435	6	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	5435	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5435	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5435	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5435	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5435	11	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	5435	12	,	,	,
18637	5435	13	231	231	CD
18637	5435	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5435	15	68	68	CD
18637	5435	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5435	17	1914	1914	CD
18637	5435	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5435	19	;	;	:
18637	5435	20	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	5435	21	City	City	NNP
18637	5435	22	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	5435	23	.	.	.
18637	5436	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5436	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5436	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5436	4	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	5436	5	,	,	,
18637	5436	6	240	240	CD
18637	5436	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5436	8	227	227	CD
18637	5436	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5436	10	1916	1916	CD
18637	5436	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5436	12	;	;	:
18637	5436	13	and	and	CC
18637	5436	14	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	5436	15	City	City	NNP
18637	5436	16	,	,	,
18637	5436	17	M.	M.	NNP
18637	5436	18	&	&	CC
18637	5436	19	B.R.	B.R.	NNP
18637	5437	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5437	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5437	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5437	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5437	5	Stiles	Stiles	NNP
18637	5437	6	,	,	,
18637	5437	7	242	242	CD
18637	5437	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5437	9	111	111	CD
18637	5437	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5437	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	5437	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5437	13	.	.	.
18637	5438	1	In	in	IN
18637	5438	2	each	each	DT
18637	5438	3	of	of	IN
18637	5438	4	these	these	DT
18637	5438	5	a	a	DT
18637	5438	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	5438	7	like	like	IN
18637	5438	8	that	that	DT
18637	5438	9	involved	involve	VBN
18637	5438	10	in	in	IN
18637	5438	11	Looney	Looney	NNP
18637	5438	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5438	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	5438	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5438	15	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	5438	16	was	be	VBD
18637	5438	17	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	5438	18	,	,	,
18637	5438	19	in	in	IN
18637	5438	20	the	the	DT
18637	5438	21	first	first	JJ
18637	5438	22	two	two	CD
18637	5438	23	because	because	IN
18637	5438	24	the	the	DT
18637	5438	25	statute	statute	NN
18637	5438	26	set	set	VBD
18637	5438	27	a	a	DT
18637	5438	28	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	5438	29	limit	limit	NN
18637	5438	30	to	to	IN
18637	5438	31	the	the	DT
18637	5438	32	tax	tax	NN
18637	5438	33	;	;	:
18637	5438	34	in	in	IN
18637	5438	35	the	the	DT
18637	5438	36	third	third	JJ
18637	5438	37	because	because	IN
18637	5438	38	the	the	DT
18637	5438	39	amount	amount	NN
18637	5438	40	collected	collect	VBN
18637	5438	41	under	under	IN
18637	5438	42	the	the	DT
18637	5438	43	act	act	NN
18637	5438	44	was	be	VBD
18637	5438	45	held	hold	VBN
18637	5438	46	to	to	TO
18637	5438	47	be	be	VB
18637	5438	48	"	"	``
18637	5438	49	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	5438	50	.	.	.
18637	5438	51	"	"	''
18637	5439	1	The	the	DT
18637	5439	2	ideology	ideology	NN
18637	5439	3	of	of	IN
18637	5439	4	these	these	DT
18637	5439	5	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	5439	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	5439	7	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	5439	8	opposed	opposed	JJ
18637	5439	9	to	to	IN
18637	5439	10	that	that	DT
18637	5439	11	of	of	IN
18637	5439	12	the	the	DT
18637	5439	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	5439	14	treated	treat	VBN
18637	5439	15	in	in	IN
18637	5439	16	the	the	DT
18637	5439	17	text	text	NN
18637	5439	18	.	.	.
18637	5440	1	The	the	DT
18637	5440	2	rule	rule	NN
18637	5440	3	in	in	IN
18637	5440	4	Looney	Looney	NNP
18637	5440	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5440	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5440	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5440	8	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	5440	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5440	10	was	be	VBD
18637	5440	11	held	hold	VBN
18637	5440	12	not	not	RB
18637	5440	13	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	5440	14	in	in	IN
18637	5440	15	the	the	DT
18637	5440	16	case	case	NN
18637	5440	17	of	of	IN
18637	5440	18	a	a	DT
18637	5440	19	West	West	NNP
18637	5440	20	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	5440	21	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	5440	22	doing	do	VBG
18637	5440	23	business	business	NN
18637	5440	24	in	in	IN
18637	5440	25	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5440	26	and	and	CC
18637	5440	27	owning	own	VBG
18637	5440	28	practically	practically	RB
18637	5440	29	all	all	DT
18637	5440	30	of	of	IN
18637	5440	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5440	32	property	property	NN
18637	5440	33	there	there	RB
18637	5440	34	.	.	.
18637	5441	1	An	an	DT
18637	5441	2	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5441	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	5441	4	on	on	IN
18637	5441	5	the	the	DT
18637	5441	6	local	local	JJ
18637	5441	7	business	business	NN
18637	5441	8	,	,	,
18637	5441	9	which	which	WDT
18637	5441	10	was	be	VBD
18637	5441	11	measured	measure	VBN
18637	5441	12	by	by	IN
18637	5441	13	the	the	DT
18637	5441	14	total	total	JJ
18637	5441	15	capitalization	capitalization	NN
18637	5441	16	of	of	IN
18637	5441	17	the	the	DT
18637	5441	18	company	company	NN
18637	5441	19	was	be	VBD
18637	5441	20	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	5441	21	,	,	,
18637	5441	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5441	23	being	be	VBG
18637	5441	24	shown	show	VBN
18637	5441	25	further	further	RB
18637	5441	26	that	that	IN
18637	5441	27	the	the	DT
18637	5441	28	tax	tax	NN
18637	5441	29	was	be	VBD
18637	5441	30	little	little	RB
18637	5441	31	more	more	JJR
18637	5441	32	than	than	IN
18637	5441	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5441	34	would	would	MD
18637	5441	35	have	have	VB
18637	5441	36	been	be	VBN
18637	5441	37	if	if	IN
18637	5441	38	levied	levy	VBN
18637	5441	39	at	at	IN
18637	5441	40	the	the	DT
18637	5441	41	same	same	JJ
18637	5441	42	rate	rate	NN
18637	5441	43	directly	directly	RB
18637	5441	44	on	on	IN
18637	5441	45	the	the	DT
18637	5441	46	property	property	NN
18637	5441	47	of	of	IN
18637	5441	48	the	the	DT
18637	5441	49	company	company	NN
18637	5441	50	that	that	WDT
18637	5441	51	was	be	VBD
18637	5441	52	in	in	IN
18637	5441	53	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5441	54	.	.	.
18637	5442	1	Hump	Hump	NNP
18637	5442	2	Hairpin	Hairpin	NNP
18637	5442	3	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	5442	4	.	.	.
18637	5443	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5443	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5443	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5443	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5443	5	Emmerson	Emmerson	NNP
18637	5443	6	,	,	,
18637	5443	7	258	258	CD
18637	5443	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5443	9	290	290	CD
18637	5443	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5443	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	5443	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5443	13	.	.	.
18637	5444	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5444	2	642	642	CD
18637	5444	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5444	4	246	246	CD
18637	5444	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5444	6	135	135	CD
18637	5444	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5444	8	1918	1918	CD
18637	5444	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5444	10	.	.	.
18637	5445	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5445	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5445	3	also	also	RB
18637	5445	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5445	5	Locomobile	Locomobile	NNP
18637	5445	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5445	7	of	of	IN
18637	5445	8	America	America	NNP
18637	5445	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5445	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5445	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5445	12	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	5445	13	,	,	,
18637	5445	14	246	246	CD
18637	5445	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5445	16	146	146	CD
18637	5445	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5445	18	1918	1918	CD
18637	5445	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5445	20	;	;	:
18637	5445	21	Cheney	Cheney	NNP
18637	5445	22	Brothers	Brothers	NNPS
18637	5445	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5445	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5445	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	5445	26	_	_	NNP
18637	5445	27	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	5445	28	,	,	,
18637	5445	29	246	246	CD
18637	5445	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5445	31	147	147	CD
18637	5445	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5445	33	1918	1918	CD
18637	5445	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5445	35	;	;	:
18637	5445	36	Union	Union	NNP
18637	5445	37	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	5445	38	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	5446	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5446	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5446	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5446	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5446	5	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	5446	6	.	.	.
18637	5447	1	Service	Service	NNP
18637	5447	2	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	5447	3	.	.	NNP
18637	5447	4	,	,	,
18637	5447	5	248	248	CD
18637	5447	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5447	7	67	67	CD
18637	5447	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5447	9	1918	1918	CD
18637	5447	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5447	11	.	.	.
18637	5448	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5448	2	643	643	CD
18637	5448	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5448	4	246	246	CD
18637	5448	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5448	6	at	at	IN
18637	5448	7	141	141	CD
18637	5448	8	.	.	.
18637	5449	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5449	2	644	644	CD
18637	5449	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5449	4	277	277	CD
18637	5449	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5449	6	163	163	CD
18637	5449	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5449	8	1928	1928	CD
18637	5449	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5449	10	.	.	.
18637	5450	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5450	2	645	645	CD
18637	5450	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5450	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5450	5	.	.	.
18637	5451	1	171	171	CD
18637	5451	2	.	.	.
18637	5452	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5452	2	646	646	CD
18637	5452	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5452	4	294	294	CD
18637	5452	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5452	6	384	384	CD
18637	5452	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5452	8	1935	1935	CD
18637	5452	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5452	10	.	.	.
18637	5453	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5453	2	647	647	CD
18637	5453	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5453	4	297	297	CD
18637	5453	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5453	6	403	403	CD
18637	5453	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5453	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	5453	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5453	10	.	.	.
18637	5454	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5454	2	648	648	CD
18637	5454	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5454	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5454	5	.	.	.
18637	5455	1	415	415	CD
18637	5455	2	.	.	.
18637	5456	1	Headnote	Headnote	NNP
18637	5456	2	6	6	CD
18637	5456	3	.	.	.
18637	5457	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5457	2	649	649	CD
18637	5457	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5457	4	8	8	CD
18637	5457	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5457	6	.	.	.
18637	5458	1	168	168	CD
18637	5458	2	,	,	,
18637	5458	3	181	181	CD
18637	5458	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5458	5	1869	1869	CD
18637	5458	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5458	7	.	.	.
18637	5459	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5459	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5459	3	also	also	RB
18637	5459	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5459	5	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	5459	6	of	of	IN
18637	5459	7	Augusta	Augusta	NNP
18637	5459	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5459	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5459	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5459	11	Earle	Earle	NNP
18637	5459	12	,	,	,
18637	5459	13	13	13	CD
18637	5459	14	Pet	pet	NN
18637	5459	15	.	.	.
18637	5460	1	519	519	CD
18637	5460	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5460	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	5460	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5460	5	;	;	:
18637	5460	6	and	and	CC
18637	5460	7	Security	Security	NNP
18637	5460	8	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	5460	9	.	.	.
18637	5461	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	5461	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	5461	3	.	.	.
18637	5462	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5462	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5462	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5462	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5462	5	Prewitt	Prewitt	NNP
18637	5462	6	,	,	,
18637	5462	7	202	202	CD
18637	5462	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5462	9	246	246	CD
18637	5462	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5462	11	1906	1906	CD
18637	5462	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5462	13	.	.	.
18637	5463	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5463	2	650	650	CD
18637	5463	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5463	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5463	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	7	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	5463	8	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	5463	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5463	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	5463	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	13	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	5463	14	,	,	,
18637	5463	15	298	298	CD
18637	5463	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5463	17	553	553	CD
18637	5463	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5463	19	1936	1936	CD
18637	5463	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5463	21	;	;	:
18637	5463	22	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	5463	23	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	5463	24	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5463	25	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	5463	26	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	5463	28	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	29	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	5463	30	,	,	,
18637	5463	31	301	301	CD
18637	5463	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5463	33	148	148	CD
18637	5463	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5463	35	1937	1937	CD
18637	5463	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5463	37	;	;	:
18637	5463	38	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	5463	39	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	5463	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5463	41	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	5463	43	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	44	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	5463	45	,	,	,
18637	5463	46	302	302	CD
18637	5463	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5463	48	22	22	CD
18637	5463	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5463	50	1937	1937	CD
18637	5463	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5463	52	;	;	:
18637	5463	53	Coverdale	Coverdale	NNP
18637	5463	54	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	5463	56	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	57	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	5463	58	-	-	HYPH
18637	5463	59	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	5463	60	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	5463	61	Line	Line	NNP
18637	5463	62	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5463	63	,	,	,
18637	5463	64	303	303	CD
18637	5463	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5463	66	604	604	CD
18637	5463	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5463	68	1938	1938	CD
18637	5463	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5463	70	;	;	:
18637	5463	71	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	5463	72	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	5463	73	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5463	74	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	5463	76	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	77	Beauchamp	Beauchamp	NNP
18637	5463	78	,	,	,
18637	5463	79	308	308	CD
18637	5463	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5463	81	331	331	CD
18637	5463	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5463	83	1939	1939	CD
18637	5463	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5463	85	;	;	:
18637	5463	86	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	5463	87	of	of	IN
18637	5463	88	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	5463	89	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	5463	91	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	92	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	5463	93	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	5463	94	,	,	,
18637	5463	95	313	313	CD
18637	5463	96	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5463	97	62	62	CD
18637	5463	98	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5463	99	1941	1941	CD
18637	5463	100	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5463	101	;	;	:
18637	5463	102	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	5463	103	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	5463	104	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	5463	105	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	106	v.	v.	IN
18637	5463	107	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	108	Glander	Glander	NNP
18637	5463	109	,	,	,
18637	5463	110	337	337	CD
18637	5463	111	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5463	112	562	562	CD
18637	5463	113	,	,	,
18637	5463	114	571	571	CD
18637	5463	115	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5463	116	1949	1949	CD
18637	5463	117	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5463	118	;	;	:
18637	5463	119	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	120	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	5463	121	.	.	.
18637	5463	122	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	123	however	however	RB
18637	5463	124	,	,	,
18637	5463	125	James	James	NNP
18637	5463	126	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	127	v.	v.	IN
18637	5463	128	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	129	Dravo	Dravo	NNP
18637	5463	130	Contracting	Contracting	NNP
18637	5463	131	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5463	132	,	,	,
18637	5463	133	302	302	CD
18637	5463	134	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5463	135	134	134	CD
18637	5463	136	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5463	137	1937	1937	CD
18637	5463	138	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5463	139	;	;	:
18637	5463	140	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	5463	141	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	5463	142	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5463	143	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5463	144	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	145	v.	v.	IN
18637	5463	146	_	_	NNP
18637	5463	147	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	5463	148	,	,	,
18637	5463	149	335	335	CD
18637	5463	150	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5463	151	80	80	CD
18637	5463	152	,	,	,
18637	5463	153	85	85	CD
18637	5463	154	-	-	SYM
18637	5463	155	86	86	CD
18637	5463	156	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5463	157	1948	1948	CD
18637	5463	158	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5463	159	.	.	.
18637	5464	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5464	2	651	651	CD
18637	5464	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5464	4	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	5464	5	&	&	CC
18637	5464	6	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	5465	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5465	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5465	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5465	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5465	5	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5465	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5465	7	State	State	NNP
18637	5465	8	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	5465	9	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5465	10	Case	Case	NNP
18637	5465	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5465	12	,	,	,
18637	5465	13	15	15	CD
18637	5465	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5465	15	.	.	.
18637	5466	1	232	232	CD
18637	5466	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5466	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	5466	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5466	5	.	.	.
18637	5467	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5467	2	652	652	CD
18637	5467	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5467	4	Prudential	Prudential	NNP
18637	5467	5	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	5467	6	.	.	.
18637	5468	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5468	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5468	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5468	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5468	5	Benjamin	Benjamin	NNP
18637	5468	6	,	,	,
18637	5468	7	328	328	CD
18637	5468	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5468	9	408	408	CD
18637	5468	10	,	,	,
18637	5468	11	418	418	CD
18637	5468	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5468	13	1946	1946	CD
18637	5468	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5468	15	.	.	.
18637	5469	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5469	2	653	653	CD
18637	5469	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5469	4	12	12	CD
18637	5469	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5469	6	.	.	.
18637	5470	1	419	419	CD
18637	5470	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5470	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	5470	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5470	5	.	.	.
18637	5471	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5471	2	654	654	CD
18637	5471	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5471	4	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	5471	5	&	&	CC
18637	5471	6	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	5472	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5472	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5472	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5472	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5472	5	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5472	6	,	,	,
18637	5472	7	15	15	CD
18637	5472	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5472	9	.	.	.
18637	5473	1	284	284	CD
18637	5473	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5473	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	5473	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5473	5	.	.	.
18637	5474	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5474	2	655	655	CD
18637	5474	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5474	4	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	5474	5	&	&	CC
18637	5474	6	S.	S.	NNP
18637	5474	7	Mail	Mail	NNP
18637	5474	8	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	5474	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5474	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5474	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	5474	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5474	13	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5474	14	,	,	,
18637	5474	15	122	122	CD
18637	5474	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5474	17	326	326	CD
18637	5474	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5474	19	1887	1887	CD
18637	5474	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5474	21	.	.	.
18637	5475	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5475	2	656	656	CD
18637	5475	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5475	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5475	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	5475	6	Tel	Tel	NNP
18637	5475	7	.	.	.
18637	5476	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5476	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5476	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5476	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5476	5	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	5476	6	,	,	,
18637	5476	7	125	125	CD
18637	5476	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5476	9	530	530	CD
18637	5476	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5476	11	1888	1888	CD
18637	5476	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5476	13	.	.	.
18637	5477	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5477	2	657	657	CD
18637	5477	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5477	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5477	5	.	.	.
18637	5478	1	547	547	CD
18637	5478	2	.	.	.
18637	5479	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5479	2	658	658	CD
18637	5479	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5479	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5479	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5479	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5479	7	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	5479	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5479	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5479	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5479	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5479	12	Peniston	Peniston	NNP
18637	5479	13	,	,	,
18637	5479	14	18	18	CD
18637	5479	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5479	16	.	.	.
18637	5480	1	5	5	CD
18637	5480	2	,	,	,
18637	5480	3	30	30	CD
18637	5480	4	-	-	SYM
18637	5480	5	31	31	CD
18637	5480	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5480	7	1873	1873	CD
18637	5480	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5480	9	.	.	.
18637	5481	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5481	2	659	659	CD
18637	5481	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5481	4	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	5481	5	's	's	POS
18637	5481	6	Palace	Palace	NNP
18637	5481	7	Car	Car	NNP
18637	5481	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5481	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5481	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5481	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5481	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5481	13	,	,	,
18637	5481	14	141	141	CD
18637	5481	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5481	16	18	18	CD
18637	5481	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5481	18	1891	1891	CD
18637	5481	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5481	20	.	.	.
18637	5482	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5482	2	660	660	CD
18637	5482	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5482	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5482	5	.	.	.
18637	5483	1	26	26	CD
18637	5483	2	.	.	.
18637	5484	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5484	2	661	661	CD
18637	5484	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5484	4	165	165	CD
18637	5484	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5484	6	194	194	CD
18637	5484	7	;	;	:
18637	5484	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	5484	9	rehearing	rehear	VBG
18637	5484	10	166	166	CD
18637	5484	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5484	12	185	185	CD
18637	5484	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5484	14	1897	1897	CD
18637	5484	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5484	16	.	.	.
18637	5485	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5485	2	662	662	CD
18637	5485	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5485	4	166	166	CD
18637	5485	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5485	6	at	at	IN
18637	5485	7	220	220	CD
18637	5485	8	.	.	.
18637	5486	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5486	2	663	663	CD
18637	5486	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5486	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5486	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5486	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5486	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5486	8	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	5486	9	'	'	POS
18637	5486	10	language	language	NN
18637	5486	11	in	in	IN
18637	5486	12	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	5486	13	,	,	,
18637	5486	14	Harrisburg	Harrisburg	NNP
18637	5486	15	,	,	,
18637	5486	16	&	&	CC
18637	5486	17	S.A.	S.A.	NNP
18637	5486	18	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	5486	19	.	.	.
18637	5487	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5487	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5487	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5487	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5487	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	5487	6	,	,	,
18637	5487	7	210	210	CD
18637	5487	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5487	9	217	217	CD
18637	5487	10	,	,	,
18637	5487	11	225	225	CD
18637	5487	12	,	,	,
18637	5487	13	227	227	CD
18637	5487	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5487	15	1908	1908	CD
18637	5487	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5487	17	.	.	.
18637	5488	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5488	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5488	3	also	also	RB
18637	5488	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5488	5	Cudahy	Cudahy	NNP
18637	5488	6	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	5488	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5488	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5488	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5488	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5488	11	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5488	12	246	246	CD
18637	5488	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5488	14	450	450	CD
18637	5488	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5488	16	1918	1918	CD
18637	5488	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5488	18	;	;	:
18637	5488	19	and	and	CC
18637	5488	20	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	5488	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5488	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5488	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	5488	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5488	25	Richardson	Richardson	NNP
18637	5488	26	,	,	,
18637	5488	27	261	261	CD
18637	5488	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5488	29	330	330	CD
18637	5488	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5488	31	1923	1923	CD
18637	5488	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5488	33	;	;	:
18637	5488	34	and	and	CC
18637	5488	35	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	5488	36	_	_	NNP
18637	5488	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	5488	38	_	_	NNP
18637	5488	39	Imperial	Imperial	NNP
18637	5488	40	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	5488	41	Sales	Sales	NNP
18637	5488	42	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5488	43	,	,	,
18637	5488	44	293	293	CD
18637	5488	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5488	46	15	15	CD
18637	5488	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5488	48	1934	1934	CD
18637	5488	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5488	50	.	.	.
18637	5489	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5489	2	664	664	CD
18637	5489	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5489	4	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	5489	5	's	's	POS
18637	5489	6	Palace	Palace	NNP
18637	5489	7	Car	Car	NNP
18637	5489	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5489	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5489	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5489	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5489	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5489	13	,	,	,
18637	5489	14	141	141	CD
18637	5489	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5489	16	18	18	CD
18637	5489	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5489	18	1891	1891	CD
18637	5489	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5489	20	.	.	.
18637	5490	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5490	2	665	665	CD
18637	5490	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5490	4	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	5490	5	,	,	,
18637	5490	6	C.C.	C.C.	NNP
18637	5491	1	&	&	CC
18637	5491	2	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5491	3	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	5492	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5492	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5492	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5492	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5492	5	Backus	Backus	NNP
18637	5492	6	,	,	,
18637	5492	7	154	154	CD
18637	5492	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5492	9	421	421	CD
18637	5492	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5492	11	1894	1894	CD
18637	5492	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5492	13	;	;	:
18637	5492	14	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
18637	5492	15	,	,	,
18637	5492	16	C.C.	C.C.	NNP
18637	5493	1	&	&	CC
18637	5493	2	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5493	3	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	5494	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5494	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5494	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5494	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5494	5	Backus	Backus	NNP
18637	5494	6	,	,	,
18637	5494	7	154	154	CD
18637	5494	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5494	9	439	439	CD
18637	5494	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5494	11	1894	1894	CD
18637	5494	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5494	13	.	.	.
18637	5495	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5495	2	666	666	CD
18637	5495	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5495	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5495	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	5495	6	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5495	7	.	.	.
18637	5496	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5496	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5496	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5496	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5496	5	Taggart	Taggart	NNP
18637	5496	6	,	,	,
18637	5496	7	163	163	CD
18637	5496	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5496	9	1	1	CD
18637	5496	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5496	11	1896	1896	CD
18637	5496	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5496	13	.	.	.
18637	5497	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5497	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5497	3	also	also	RB
18637	5497	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5497	5	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5497	6	Union	Union	NNP
18637	5497	7	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5497	8	.	.	.
18637	5498	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5498	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5498	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5498	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5498	5	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	5498	6	,	,	,
18637	5498	7	125	125	CD
18637	5498	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5498	9	530	530	CD
18637	5498	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5498	11	1888	1888	CD
18637	5498	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5498	13	.	.	.
18637	5499	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5499	2	667	667	CD
18637	5499	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5499	4	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	5499	5	Express	Express	NNP
18637	5499	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5499	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5499	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5499	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5499	10	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	5499	11	,	,	,
18637	5499	12	165	165	CD
18637	5499	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5499	14	194	194	CD
18637	5499	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5499	16	1897	1897	CD
18637	5499	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5499	18	,	,	,
18637	5499	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	5499	20	rehearing	rehear	VBG
18637	5499	21	166	166	CD
18637	5499	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5499	23	185	185	CD
18637	5499	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5499	25	1897	1897	CD
18637	5499	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5499	27	.	.	.
18637	5500	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5500	2	668	668	CD
18637	5500	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5500	4	Great	Great	NNP
18637	5500	5	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	5500	6	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	5500	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5500	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5500	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5500	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5500	11	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5500	12	,	,	,
18637	5500	13	278	278	CD
18637	5500	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5500	15	503	503	CD
18637	5500	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5500	17	1929	1929	CD
18637	5500	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5500	19	.	.	.
18637	5501	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5501	2	669	669	CD
18637	5501	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5501	4	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	5501	5	,	,	,
18637	5501	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	5501	7	&	&	CC
18637	5501	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5501	9	L.	L.	NNP
18637	5501	10	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	5501	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5501	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	5501	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5501	14	Browning	Browning	NNP
18637	5501	15	,	,	,
18637	5501	16	310	310	CD
18637	5501	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5501	18	362	362	CD
18637	5501	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5501	20	1910	1910	CD
18637	5501	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5501	22	.	.	.
18637	5502	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5502	2	670	670	CD
18637	5502	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5502	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5502	5	.	.	.
18637	5503	1	366	366	CD
18637	5503	2	,	,	,
18637	5503	3	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5503	4	Union	Union	NNP
18637	5503	5	Tank	Tank	NNP
18637	5503	6	Line	Line	NNP
18637	5503	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5503	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5503	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5503	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5503	11	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	5503	12	,	,	,
18637	5503	13	249	249	CD
18637	5503	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5503	15	275	275	CD
18637	5503	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5503	17	1919	1919	CD
18637	5503	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5503	19	;	;	:
18637	5503	20	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	5503	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5503	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	5503	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5503	24	Hines	Hines	NNP
18637	5503	25	,	,	,
18637	5503	26	253	253	CD
18637	5503	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5503	28	66	66	CD
18637	5503	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5503	30	1920	1920	CD
18637	5503	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5503	32	;	;	:
18637	5503	33	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	5503	34	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5503	35	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5503	36	_	_	NNP
18637	5503	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	5503	38	_	_	NNP
18637	5503	39	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5503	40	,	,	,
18637	5503	41	274	274	CD
18637	5503	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5503	43	76	76	CD
18637	5503	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5503	45	1927	1927	CD
18637	5503	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5503	47	.	.	.
18637	5504	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5504	2	671	671	CD
18637	5504	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5504	4	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	5504	5	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	5504	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5504	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5504	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5504	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5504	10	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	5504	11	,	,	,
18637	5504	12	298	298	CD
18637	5504	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5504	14	553	553	CD
18637	5504	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5504	16	1936	1936	CD
18637	5504	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5504	18	.	.	.
18637	5505	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5505	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	5505	3	.	.	.
18637	5505	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5505	5	Alpha	Alpha	NNP
18637	5505	6	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	5505	7	Cement	Cement	NNP
18637	5505	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5505	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5505	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5505	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5505	12	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	5505	13	,	,	,
18637	5505	14	268	268	CD
18637	5505	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5505	16	203	203	CD
18637	5505	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5505	18	1925	1925	CD
18637	5505	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5505	20	.	.	.
18637	5506	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5506	2	672	672	CD
18637	5506	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5506	4	142	142	CD
18637	5506	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5506	6	217	217	CD
18637	5506	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5506	8	1891	1891	CD
18637	5506	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5506	10	.	.	.
18637	5507	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5507	2	673	673	CD
18637	5507	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5507	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5507	5	.	.	.
18637	5508	1	227	227	CD
18637	5508	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5508	3	228	228	CD
18637	5508	4	.	.	.
18637	5509	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5509	2	674	674	CD
18637	5509	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5509	4	Citing	cite	VBG
18637	5509	5	Pickard	Pickard	NNP
18637	5509	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5509	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5509	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5509	9	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	5509	10	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	5509	11	Car	Car	NNP
18637	5509	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5509	13	,	,	,
18637	5509	14	117	117	CD
18637	5509	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5509	16	34	34	CD
18637	5509	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5509	18	1886	1886	CD
18637	5509	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5509	20	;	;	:
18637	5509	21	Leloup	Leloup	NNP
18637	5509	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5509	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	5509	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5509	25	Port	Port	NNP
18637	5509	26	of	of	IN
18637	5509	27	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	5509	28	,	,	,
18637	5509	29	127	127	CD
18637	5509	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5509	31	640	640	CD
18637	5509	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5509	33	1888	1888	CD
18637	5509	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5509	35	;	;	:
18637	5509	36	Crutcher	Crutcher	NNP
18637	5509	37	_	_	NNP
18637	5509	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	5509	39	_	_	NNP
18637	5509	40	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5509	41	,	,	,
18637	5509	42	141	141	CD
18637	5509	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5509	44	47	47	CD
18637	5509	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5509	46	1891	1891	CD
18637	5509	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5509	48	;	;	:
18637	5509	49	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	5509	50	&	&	CC
18637	5509	51	S.	S.	NNP
18637	5509	52	Mail	Mail	NNP
18637	5509	53	Steamship	Steamship	NNP
18637	5509	54	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5509	55	_	_	NNP
18637	5509	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	5509	57	_	_	NNP
18637	5509	58	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5509	59	,	,	,
18637	5509	60	122	122	CD
18637	5509	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5509	62	326	326	CD
18637	5509	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5509	64	1887	1887	CD
18637	5509	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5509	66	.	.	.
18637	5510	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5510	2	675	675	CD
18637	5510	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5510	4	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	5510	5	,	,	,
18637	5510	6	Harrisburg	Harrisburg	NNP
18637	5510	7	&	&	CC
18637	5510	8	S.A.R.	S.A.R.	NNP
18637	5511	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5511	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5511	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5511	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5511	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	5511	6	,	,	,
18637	5511	7	210	210	CD
18637	5511	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5511	9	217	217	CD
18637	5511	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5511	11	1908	1908	CD
18637	5511	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5511	13	.	.	.
18637	5512	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5512	2	676	676	CD
18637	5512	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5512	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5512	5	.	.	.
18637	5513	1	226	226	CD
18637	5513	2	.	.	.
18637	5514	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5514	2	677	677	CD
18637	5514	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5514	4	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	5514	5	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	5514	6	Cable	Cable	NNP
18637	5514	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5514	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5514	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5514	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5514	11	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	5514	12	,	,	,
18637	5514	13	155	155	CD
18637	5514	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5514	15	688	688	CD
18637	5514	16	,	,	,
18637	5514	17	697	697	CD
18637	5514	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5514	19	1895	1895	CD
18637	5514	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5514	21	.	.	.
18637	5515	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5515	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5515	3	also	also	RB
18637	5515	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5515	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5515	6	Central	Central	NNP
18637	5515	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5515	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5515	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5515	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5515	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5515	12	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5515	13	,	,	,
18637	5515	14	309	309	CD
18637	5515	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5515	16	157	157	CD
18637	5515	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5515	18	1940	1940	CD
18637	5515	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5515	20	,	,	,
18637	5515	21	in	in	IN
18637	5515	22	which	which	WDT
18637	5515	23	was	be	VBD
18637	5515	24	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	5515	25	a	a	DT
18637	5515	26	five	five	CD
18637	5515	27	percent	percent	NN
18637	5515	28	gross	gross	JJ
18637	5515	29	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	5515	30	tax	tax	NN
18637	5515	31	on	on	IN
18637	5515	32	all	all	DT
18637	5515	33	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	5515	34	operating	operate	VBG
18637	5515	35	in	in	IN
18637	5515	36	the	the	DT
18637	5515	37	State	State	NNP
18637	5515	38	,	,	,
18637	5515	39	payable	payable	JJ
18637	5515	40	in	in	IN
18637	5515	41	lieu	lieu	NN
18637	5515	42	of	of	IN
18637	5515	43	all	all	DT
18637	5515	44	other	other	JJ
18637	5515	45	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	5515	46	and	and	CC
18637	5515	47	found	find	VBD
18637	5515	48	to	to	TO
18637	5515	49	have	have	VB
18637	5515	50	"	"	``
18637	5515	51	a	a	DT
18637	5515	52	fair	fair	JJ
18637	5515	53	relation	relation	NN
18637	5515	54	to	to	IN
18637	5515	55	the	the	DT
18637	5515	56	property	property	NN
18637	5515	57	employed	employ	VBN
18637	5515	58	in	in	IN
18637	5515	59	the	the	DT
18637	5515	60	State	State	NNP
18637	5515	61	.	.	.
18637	5515	62	"	"	''
18637	5516	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5516	2	678	678	CD
18637	5516	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5516	4	New	New	NNP
18637	5516	5	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	5516	6	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	5516	7	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	5516	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5516	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5516	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5516	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5516	12	State	State	NNP
18637	5516	13	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	5516	14	.	.	.
18637	5517	1	of	of	IN
18637	5517	2	Taxes	Taxes	NNP
18637	5517	3	&	&	CC
18637	5517	4	Assessments	Assessments	NNPS
18637	5517	5	,	,	,
18637	5517	6	280	280	CD
18637	5517	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5517	8	338	338	CD
18637	5517	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5517	10	1930	1930	CD
18637	5517	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5517	12	.	.	.
18637	5518	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5518	2	679	679	CD
18637	5518	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5518	4	Bass	Bass	NNP
18637	5518	5	,	,	,
18637	5518	6	Ratcliff	Ratcliff	NNP
18637	5518	7	&	&	CC
18637	5518	8	Gretton	Gretton	NNP
18637	5518	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5518	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5518	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5518	12	State	State	NNP
18637	5518	13	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5518	14	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5518	15	.	.	NNP
18637	5518	16	,	,	,
18637	5518	17	266	266	CD
18637	5518	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5518	19	271	271	CD
18637	5518	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5518	21	1924	1924	CD
18637	5518	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5518	23	.	.	.
18637	5519	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5519	2	680	680	CD
18637	5519	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5519	4	Matson	Matson	NNP
18637	5519	5	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	5519	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5519	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5519	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5519	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5519	10	State	State	NNP
18637	5519	11	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5519	12	,	,	,
18637	5519	13	297	297	CD
18637	5519	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5519	15	441	441	CD
18637	5519	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5519	17	1936	1936	CD
18637	5519	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5519	19	.	.	.
18637	5520	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5520	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5520	3	also	also	RB
18637	5520	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5520	5	International	International	NNP
18637	5520	6	Shoe	Shoe	NNP
18637	5520	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5520	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5520	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5520	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5520	11	Shartel	Shartel	NNP
18637	5520	12	,	,	,
18637	5520	13	279	279	CD
18637	5520	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5520	15	429	429	CD
18637	5520	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5520	17	1929	1929	CD
18637	5520	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5520	19	.	.	.
18637	5521	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5521	2	681	681	CD
18637	5521	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5521	4	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	5521	5	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	5521	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5521	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5521	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5521	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5521	10	Beauchamp	Beauchamp	NNP
18637	5521	11	,	,	,
18637	5521	12	308	308	CD
18637	5521	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5521	14	331	331	CD
18637	5521	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5521	16	1939	1939	CD
18637	5521	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5521	18	.	.	.
18637	5522	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5522	2	682	682	CD
18637	5522	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5522	4	International	International	NNP
18637	5522	5	Harvester	Harvester	NNP
18637	5522	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5522	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5522	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5522	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5522	10	Evatt	Evatt	NNP
18637	5522	11	,	,	,
18637	5522	12	329	329	CD
18637	5522	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5522	14	416	416	CD
18637	5522	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5522	16	1947	1947	CD
18637	5522	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5522	18	.	.	.
18637	5523	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5523	2	683	683	CD
18637	5523	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5523	4	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	5523	5	,	,	,
18637	5523	6	Harrisburg	Harrisburg	NNP
18637	5523	7	&	&	CC
18637	5523	8	San	San	NNP
18637	5523	9	Antonio	Antonio	NNP
18637	5523	10	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5523	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5523	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5523	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	5523	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5523	15	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	5523	16	,	,	,
18637	5523	17	210	210	CD
18637	5523	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5523	19	217	217	CD
18637	5523	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5523	21	1908	1908	CD
18637	5523	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5523	23	.	.	.
18637	5524	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5524	2	684	684	CD
18637	5524	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5524	4	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	5524	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5524	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5524	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5524	8	Hines	Hines	NNP
18637	5524	9	,	,	,
18637	5524	10	253	253	CD
18637	5524	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5524	12	66	66	CD
18637	5524	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5524	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	5524	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5524	16	.	.	.
18637	5525	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5525	2	685	685	CD
18637	5525	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5525	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5525	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5525	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5525	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	5525	8	.	.	.
18637	5526	1	194	194	CD
18637	5526	2	,	,	,
18637	5526	3	202	202	CD
18637	5526	4	.	.	.
18637	5527	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5527	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5527	3	also	also	RB
18637	5527	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5527	5	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	5527	6	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	5527	7	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	5527	8	Line	Line	NNP
18637	5527	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5527	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5527	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	5527	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5527	13	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	5527	14	,	,	,
18637	5527	15	337	337	CD
18637	5527	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5527	17	662	662	CD
18637	5527	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5527	19	1949	1949	CD
18637	5527	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5527	21	for	for	IN
18637	5527	22	an	an	DT
18637	5527	23	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	5527	24	review	review	NN
18637	5527	25	and	and	CC
18637	5527	26	evaluation	evaluation	NN
18637	5527	27	of	of	IN
18637	5527	28	cases	case	NNS
18637	5527	29	.	.	.
18637	5528	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5528	2	686	686	CD
18637	5528	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5528	4	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5528	5	Central	Central	NNP
18637	5528	6	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5528	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5528	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5528	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5528	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5528	11	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5528	12	,	,	,
18637	5528	13	309	309	CD
18637	5528	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5528	15	157	157	CD
18637	5528	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5528	17	1940	1940	CD
18637	5528	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5528	19	.	.	.
18637	5529	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5529	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5529	3	also	also	RB
18637	5529	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5529	5	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	5529	6	and	and	CC
18637	5529	7	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	5529	8	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	5529	9	.	.	.
18637	5530	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5530	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5530	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5530	4	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	5530	5	,	,	,
18637	5530	6	191	191	CD
18637	5530	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5530	8	379	379	CD
18637	5530	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5530	10	1903	1903	CD
18637	5530	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5530	12	;	;	:
18637	5530	13	United	United	NNP
18637	5530	14	States	States	NNP
18637	5530	15	Express	Express	NNP
18637	5530	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5530	17	_	_	NNP
18637	5530	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	5530	19	_	_	NNP
18637	5530	20	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5530	21	,	,	,
18637	5530	22	223	223	CD
18637	5530	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5530	24	335	335	CD
18637	5530	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5530	26	1912	1912	CD
18637	5530	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5530	28	.	.	.
18637	5531	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5531	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5531	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5531	4	note	note	NN
18637	5531	5	13	13	CD
18637	5531	6	to	to	IN
18637	5531	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5531	8	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	5531	9	's	's	POS
18637	5531	10	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	5531	11	in	in	IN
18637	5531	12	Freeman	Freeman	NNP
18637	5531	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5531	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	5531	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5531	16	Hewit	Hewit	NNP
18637	5531	17	,	,	,
18637	5531	18	329	329	CD
18637	5531	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5531	20	at	at	IN
18637	5531	21	pp	pp	NNP
18637	5531	22	.	.	.
18637	5532	1	265	265	CD
18637	5532	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5532	3	266	266	CD
18637	5532	4	.	.	.
18637	5533	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5533	2	687	687	CD
18637	5533	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5533	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5533	5	Live	Live	NNP
18637	5533	6	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	5533	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5533	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5533	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5533	10	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
18637	5533	11	of	of	IN
18637	5533	12	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	5533	13	,	,	,
18637	5533	14	303	303	CD
18637	5533	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5533	16	250	250	CD
18637	5533	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5533	18	1938	1938	CD
18637	5533	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5533	20	.	.	.
18637	5534	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5534	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5534	3	also	also	RB
18637	5534	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5534	5	United	United	NNP
18637	5534	6	States	States	NNP
18637	5534	7	Express	Express	NNP
18637	5534	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5534	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5534	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5534	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5534	12	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5534	13	,	,	,
18637	5534	14	223	223	CD
18637	5534	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5534	16	335	335	CD
18637	5534	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5534	18	1912	1912	CD
18637	5534	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5534	20	;	;	:
18637	5534	21	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	5534	22	.	.	.
18637	5535	1	of	of	IN
18637	5535	2	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	5535	3	of	of	IN
18637	5535	4	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	5535	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5535	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5535	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5535	8	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	5535	9	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	5535	10	,	,	,
18637	5535	11	313	313	CD
18637	5535	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5535	13	62	62	CD
18637	5535	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5535	15	1941	1941	CD
18637	5535	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5535	17	;	;	:
18637	5535	18	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	5535	19	.	.	.
18637	5536	1	of	of	IN
18637	5536	2	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	5536	3	of	of	IN
18637	5536	4	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	5536	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5536	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5536	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5536	8	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	5536	9	.	.	.
18637	5537	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5537	2	,	,	,
18637	5537	3	313	313	CD
18637	5537	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5537	5	252	252	CD
18637	5537	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5537	7	1941	1941	CD
18637	5537	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5537	9	;	;	:
18637	5537	10	Harvester	Harvester	NNP
18637	5537	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5537	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5537	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	5537	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5537	15	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	5537	16	.	.	.
18637	5538	1	of	of	IN
18637	5538	2	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	5538	3	,	,	,
18637	5538	4	322	322	CD
18637	5538	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5538	6	340	340	CD
18637	5538	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5538	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	5538	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5538	10	.	.	.
18637	5539	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5539	2	688	688	CD
18637	5539	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5539	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5539	5	Live	Live	NNP
18637	5539	6	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	5539	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5539	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5539	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5539	10	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
18637	5539	11	of	of	IN
18637	5539	12	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	5539	13	,	,	,
18637	5539	14	303	303	CD
18637	5539	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5539	16	250	250	CD
18637	5539	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5539	18	1938	1938	CD
18637	5539	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5539	20	.	.	.
18637	5540	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5540	2	689	689	CD
18637	5540	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5540	4	Meyer	Meyer	NNP
18637	5540	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5540	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5540	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5540	8	Wells	Wells	NNP
18637	5540	9	,	,	,
18637	5540	10	Fargo	Fargo	NNP
18637	5540	11	&	&	CC
18637	5540	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5540	13	,	,	,
18637	5540	14	223	223	CD
18637	5540	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5540	16	298	298	CD
18637	5540	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5540	18	1912	1912	CD
18637	5540	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5540	20	;	;	:
18637	5540	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5540	22	also	also	RB
18637	5540	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5540	24	the	the	DT
18637	5540	25	following	follow	VBG
18637	5540	26	note	note	NN
18637	5540	27	.	.	.
18637	5541	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5541	2	690	690	CD
18637	5541	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5541	4	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	5541	5	&	&	CC
18637	5541	6	S.	S.	NNP
18637	5541	7	Mail	Mail	NNP
18637	5541	8	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	5541	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5541	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5541	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	5541	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5541	13	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5541	14	,	,	,
18637	5541	15	122	122	CD
18637	5541	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5541	17	326	326	CD
18637	5541	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5541	19	1887	1887	CD
18637	5541	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5541	21	;	;	:
18637	5541	22	Ratterman	Ratterman	NNP
18637	5541	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5541	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	5541	25	_	_	NNP
18637	5541	26	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5541	27	Union	Union	NNP
18637	5541	28	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5541	29	.	.	.
18637	5542	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5542	2	,	,	,
18637	5542	3	127	127	CD
18637	5542	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5542	5	411	411	CD
18637	5542	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5542	7	1888	1888	CD
18637	5542	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5542	9	;	;	:
18637	5542	10	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5542	11	Union	Union	NNP
18637	5542	12	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5542	13	.	.	.
18637	5543	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5543	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5543	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5543	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5543	5	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	5543	6	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5543	7	of	of	IN
18637	5543	8	Assessment	Assessment	NNP
18637	5543	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5543	10	Seay	Seay	NNP
18637	5543	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5543	12	,	,	,
18637	5543	13	132	132	CD
18637	5543	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5543	15	472	472	CD
18637	5543	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5543	17	1889	1889	CD
18637	5543	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5543	19	;	;	:
18637	5543	20	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	5543	21	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	5543	22	.	.	.
18637	5544	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5544	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5544	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5544	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5544	5	Storen	Storen	NNP
18637	5544	6	,	,	,
18637	5544	7	304	304	CD
18637	5544	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5544	9	307	307	CD
18637	5544	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5544	11	1938	1938	CD
18637	5544	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5544	13	;	;	:
18637	5544	14	Gwin	Gwin	NNP
18637	5544	15	,	,	,
18637	5544	16	White	White	NNP
18637	5544	17	&	&	CC
18637	5544	18	Prince	Prince	NNP
18637	5544	19	_	_	NNP
18637	5544	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	5544	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5544	22	Henneford	Henneford	NNP
18637	5544	23	,	,	,
18637	5544	24	305	305	CD
18637	5544	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5544	26	434	434	CD
18637	5544	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5544	28	1939	1939	CD
18637	5544	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5544	30	.	.	.
18637	5545	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5545	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	5545	3	.	.	.
18637	5545	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5545	5	Fargo	Fargo	NNP
18637	5545	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5545	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5545	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5545	9	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	5545	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5545	11	Fargo	Fargo	NNP
18637	5545	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5545	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	5545	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5545	15	Stevens	Stevens	NNP
18637	5545	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5545	17	,	,	,
18637	5545	18	121	121	CD
18637	5545	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5545	20	230	230	CD
18637	5545	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5545	22	1887	1887	CD
18637	5545	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5545	24	,	,	,
18637	5545	25	as	as	IN
18637	5545	26	explained	explain	VBN
18637	5545	27	in	in	IN
18637	5545	28	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5545	29	Live	Live	NNP
18637	5545	30	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	5545	31	_	_	NNP
18637	5545	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	5545	33	_	_	NNP
18637	5545	34	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
18637	5545	35	of	of	IN
18637	5545	36	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	5545	37	,	,	,
18637	5545	38	303	303	CD
18637	5545	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5545	40	250	250	CD
18637	5545	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5545	42	1938	1938	CD
18637	5545	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5545	44	.	.	.
18637	5546	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5546	2	691	691	CD
18637	5546	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5546	4	Lockhart	Lockhart	NNP
18637	5546	5	,	,	,
18637	5546	6	Gross	Gross	NNP
18637	5546	7	Receipts	Receipts	NNPS
18637	5546	8	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	5546	9	on	on	IN
18637	5546	10	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	5546	11	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	5546	12	and	and	CC
18637	5546	13	Communication	Communication	NNP
18637	5546	14	,	,	,
18637	5546	15	57	57	CD
18637	5546	16	Harvard	Harvard	NNP
18637	5546	17	L.	L.	NNP
18637	5546	18	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	5547	1	40	40	CD
18637	5547	2	,	,	,
18637	5547	3	65	65	CD
18637	5547	4	,	,	,
18637	5547	5	66	66	CD
18637	5547	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5547	7	1943	1943	CD
18637	5547	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5547	9	;	;	:
18637	5547	10	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	5547	11	,	,	,
18637	5547	12	H.	H.	NNP
18637	5547	13	&	&	CC
18637	5547	14	S.A.R.	S.A.R.	NNP
18637	5548	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5548	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5548	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5548	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5548	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	5548	6	,	,	,
18637	5548	7	210	210	CD
18637	5548	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5548	9	217	217	CD
18637	5548	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5548	11	1908	1908	CD
18637	5548	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5548	13	;	;	:
18637	5548	14	New	New	NNP
18637	5548	15	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	5548	16	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	5548	17	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	5548	18	.	.	.
18637	5549	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5549	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5549	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5549	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5549	5	State	State	NNP
18637	5549	6	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	5549	7	.	.	.
18637	5550	1	of	of	IN
18637	5550	2	Taxes	Taxes	NNPS
18637	5550	3	and	and	CC
18637	5550	4	Assessments	Assessments	NNPS
18637	5550	5	,	,	,
18637	5550	6	280	280	CD
18637	5550	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5550	8	338	338	CD
18637	5550	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5550	10	1930	1930	CD
18637	5550	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5550	12	.	.	.
18637	5551	1	But	but	CC
18637	5551	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5551	3	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	5551	4	.	.	.
18637	5551	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5551	6	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	5551	7	,	,	,
18637	5551	8	C.	C.	NNP
18637	5551	9	and	and	CC
18637	5551	10	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5551	11	L.	L.	NNP
18637	5551	12	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	5551	13	.	.	.
18637	5552	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5552	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5552	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5552	4	Browning	Browning	NNP
18637	5552	5	,	,	,
18637	5552	6	310	310	CD
18637	5552	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5552	8	362	362	CD
18637	5552	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5552	10	1940	1940	CD
18637	5552	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5552	12	.	.	.
18637	5553	1	In	in	IN
18637	5553	2	both	both	CC
18637	5553	3	the	the	DT
18637	5553	4	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	5553	5	and	and	CC
18637	5553	6	New	New	NNP
18637	5553	7	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	5553	8	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	5553	9	Company	Company	NNP
18637	5553	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	5553	11	,	,	,
18637	5553	12	although	although	IN
18637	5553	13	the	the	DT
18637	5553	14	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	5553	15	events	event	NNS
18637	5553	16	all	all	DT
18637	5553	17	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	5553	18	within	within	IN
18637	5553	19	the	the	DT
18637	5553	20	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	5553	21	State	State	NNP
18637	5553	22	,	,	,
18637	5553	23	the	the	DT
18637	5553	24	possibility	possibility	NN
18637	5553	25	of	of	IN
18637	5553	26	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	5553	27	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	5553	28	was	be	VBD
18637	5553	29	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	5553	30	present	present	JJ
18637	5553	31	.	.	.
18637	5554	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5554	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5554	3	also	also	RB
18637	5554	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5554	5	Puget	Puget	NNP
18637	5554	6	Sound	Sound	NNP
18637	5554	7	Stevedoring	Stevedoring	NNP
18637	5554	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5554	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5554	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5554	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5554	12	State	State	NNP
18637	5554	13	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5554	14	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	5554	15	,	,	,
18637	5554	16	302	302	CD
18637	5554	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5554	18	90	90	CD
18637	5554	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5554	20	1937	1937	CD
18637	5554	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5554	22	,	,	,
18637	5554	23	the	the	DT
18637	5554	24	decision	decision	NN
18637	5554	25	in	in	IN
18637	5554	26	which	which	WDT
18637	5554	27	might	may	MD
18637	5554	28	have	have	VB
18637	5554	29	been	be	VBN
18637	5554	30	rested	rest	VBN
18637	5554	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	5554	32	the	the	DT
18637	5554	33	clause	clause	NN
18637	5554	34	of	of	IN
18637	5554	35	the	the	DT
18637	5554	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	5554	37	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	5554	38	the	the	DT
18637	5554	39	States	state	NNS
18637	5554	40	to	to	TO
18637	5554	41	tax	tax	NN
18637	5554	42	exports	export	NNS
18637	5554	43	.	.	.
18637	5555	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5555	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5555	3	also	also	RB
18637	5555	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5555	5	Richfield	Richfield	NNP
18637	5555	6	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	5555	7	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	5555	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5555	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5555	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5555	11	State	State	NNP
18637	5555	12	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5555	13	of	of	IN
18637	5555	14	Equalization	Equalization	NNP
18637	5555	15	,	,	,
18637	5555	16	329	329	CD
18637	5555	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5555	18	69	69	CD
18637	5555	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5555	20	1946	1946	CD
18637	5555	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5555	22	.	.	.
18637	5556	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5556	2	692	692	CD
18637	5556	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5556	4	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	5556	5	's	's	POS
18637	5556	6	Blend	Blend	NNP
18637	5556	7	Station	Station	NNP
18637	5556	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5556	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5556	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5556	11	State	State	NNP
18637	5556	12	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5556	13	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	5556	14	.	.	NNP
18637	5556	15	,	,	,
18637	5556	16	297	297	CD
18637	5556	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5556	18	650	650	CD
18637	5556	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5556	20	1936	1936	CD
18637	5556	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5556	22	;	;	:
18637	5556	23	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5556	24	Live	live	JJ
18637	5556	25	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	5556	26	_	_	NNP
18637	5556	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	5556	28	_	_	NNP
18637	5556	29	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
18637	5556	30	of	of	IN
18637	5556	31	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	5556	32	,	,	,
18637	5556	33	303	303	CD
18637	5556	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5556	35	250	250	CD
18637	5556	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5556	37	1938	1938	CD
18637	5556	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5556	39	.	.	.
18637	5557	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5557	2	693	693	CD
18637	5557	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5557	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5557	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5557	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5557	7	p.	p.	NN
18637	5557	8	193	193	CD
18637	5557	9	.	.	.
18637	5558	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5558	2	694	694	CD
18637	5558	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5558	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5558	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5558	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5558	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	5558	8	.	.	.
18637	5559	1	150	150	CD
18637	5559	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5559	3	160	160	CD
18637	5559	4	.	.	.
18637	5560	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5560	2	695	695	CD
18637	5560	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5560	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5560	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5560	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5560	7	p.	p.	NN
18637	5560	8	189	189	CD
18637	5560	9	.	.	.
18637	5561	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5561	2	696	696	CD
18637	5561	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5561	4	303	303	CD
18637	5561	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5561	6	250	250	CD
18637	5561	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5561	8	1938	1938	CD
18637	5561	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5561	10	.	.	.
18637	5562	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5562	2	697	697	CD
18637	5562	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5562	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5562	5	.	.	.
18637	5563	1	254	254	CD
18637	5563	2	.	.	.
18637	5564	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5564	2	698	698	CD
18637	5564	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5564	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5564	5	.	.	.
18637	5565	1	255	255	CD
18637	5565	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5565	3	256	256	CD
18637	5565	4	.	.	.
18637	5566	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5566	2	699	699	CD
18637	5566	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5566	4	305	305	CD
18637	5566	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5566	6	434	434	CD
18637	5566	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5566	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	5566	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5566	10	.	.	.
18637	5567	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5567	2	700	700	CD
18637	5567	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5567	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5567	5	.	.	.
18637	5568	1	439	439	CD
18637	5568	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5568	3	440	440	CD
18637	5568	4	.	.	.
18637	5569	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5569	2	701	701	CD
18637	5569	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5569	4	305	305	CD
18637	5569	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5569	6	at	at	IN
18637	5569	7	455	455	CD
18637	5569	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5569	9	1939	1939	CD
18637	5569	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5569	11	.	.	.
18637	5570	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5570	2	702	702	CD
18637	5570	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5570	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5570	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5570	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5570	7	McCarroll	McCarroll	NNP
18637	5570	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5570	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5570	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5570	11	Dixie	Dixie	NNP
18637	5570	12	Greyhound	Greyhound	NNP
18637	5570	13	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	5570	14	,	,	,
18637	5570	15	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	5570	16	,	,	,
18637	5570	17	309	309	CD
18637	5570	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5570	19	176	176	CD
18637	5570	20	,	,	,
18637	5570	21	188	188	CD
18637	5570	22	-	-	SYM
18637	5570	23	189	189	CD
18637	5570	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5570	25	1940	1940	CD
18637	5570	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5570	27	.	.	.
18637	5571	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5571	2	703	703	CD
18637	5571	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5571	4	Freeman	Freeman	NNP
18637	5571	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5571	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5571	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5571	8	Hewit	Hewit	NNP
18637	5571	9	,	,	,
18637	5571	10	329	329	CD
18637	5571	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5571	12	249	249	CD
18637	5571	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5571	14	1946	1946	CD
18637	5571	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5571	16	.	.	.
18637	5572	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5572	2	704	704	CD
18637	5572	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5572	4	329	329	CD
18637	5572	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5572	6	249	249	CD
18637	5572	7	.	.	.
18637	5573	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5573	2	705	705	CD
18637	5573	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5573	4	The	the	DT
18637	5573	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5573	6	relied	rely	VBD
18637	5573	7	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	5573	8	on	on	IN
18637	5573	9	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	5573	10	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	5573	11	.	.	.
18637	5574	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5574	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5574	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5574	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5574	5	Storen	Storen	NNP
18637	5574	6	,	,	,
18637	5574	7	304	304	CD
18637	5574	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5574	9	307	307	CD
18637	5574	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5574	11	1938	1938	CD
18637	5574	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5574	13	in	in	IN
18637	5574	14	which	which	WDT
18637	5574	15	the	the	DT
18637	5574	16	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	5574	17	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	5574	18	test	test	NN
18637	5574	19	had	have	VBD
18637	5574	20	been	be	VBN
18637	5574	21	used	use	VBN
18637	5574	22	.	.	.
18637	5575	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5575	2	706	706	CD
18637	5575	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5575	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5575	5	Black	Black	NNP
18637	5575	6	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	5575	7	without	without	IN
18637	5575	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	5575	9	.	.	.
18637	5576	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5576	2	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	5576	3	,	,	,
18637	5576	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	5576	5	also	also	RB
18637	5576	6	for	for	IN
18637	5576	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5576	8	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	5576	9	,	,	,
18637	5576	10	contended	contend	VBD
18637	5576	11	that	that	IN
18637	5576	12	the	the	DT
18637	5576	13	sale	sale	NN
18637	5576	14	had	have	VBD
18637	5576	15	been	be	VBN
18637	5576	16	local	local	JJ
18637	5576	17	,	,	,
18637	5576	18	and	and	CC
18637	5576	19	that	that	IN
18637	5576	20	the	the	DT
18637	5576	21	only	only	JJ
18637	5576	22	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5576	23	agency	agency	NN
18637	5576	24	employed	employ	VBN
18637	5576	25	had	have	VBD
18637	5576	26	been	be	VBN
18637	5576	27	the	the	DT
18637	5576	28	mails	mail	NNS
18637	5576	29	,	,	,
18637	5576	30	an	an	DT
18637	5576	31	argument	argument	NN
18637	5576	32	which	which	WDT
18637	5576	33	squares	square	VBZ
18637	5576	34	badly	badly	RB
18637	5576	35	with	with	IN
18637	5576	36	the	the	DT
18637	5576	37	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	5576	38	of	of	IN
18637	5576	39	the	the	DT
18637	5576	40	same	same	JJ
18637	5576	41	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	5576	42	in	in	IN
18637	5576	43	United	United	NNP
18637	5576	44	States	States	NNP
18637	5576	45	_	_	NNP
18637	5576	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	5576	47	_	_	NNP
18637	5576	48	South	South	NNP
18637	5576	49	-	-	HYPH
18637	5576	50	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	5576	51	Underwriters	Underwriters	NNPS
18637	5576	52	Assoc	Assoc	NNP
18637	5576	53	.	.	.
18637	5576	54	,	,	,
18637	5576	55	322	322	CD
18637	5576	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5576	57	533	533	CD
18637	5576	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5576	59	1944	1944	CD
18637	5576	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5576	61	.	.	.
18637	5577	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5577	2	707	707	CD
18637	5577	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5577	4	330	330	CD
18637	5577	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5577	6	422	422	CD
18637	5577	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5577	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	5577	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5577	10	,	,	,
18637	5577	11	reaffirming	reaffirm	VBG
18637	5577	12	Puget	Puget	NNP
18637	5577	13	Sound	Sound	NNP
18637	5577	14	Stevedoring	Stevedoring	NNP
18637	5577	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5577	16	_	_	NNP
18637	5577	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	5577	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5577	19	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5577	20	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	5577	21	.	.	NNP
18637	5577	22	,	,	,
18637	5577	23	302	302	CD
18637	5577	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5577	25	90	90	CD
18637	5577	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5577	27	1937	1937	CD
18637	5577	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5577	29	.	.	.
18637	5578	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5578	2	708	708	CD
18637	5578	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5578	4	330	330	CD
18637	5578	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5578	6	at	at	IN
18637	5578	7	433	433	CD
18637	5578	8	.	.	.
18637	5579	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5579	2	709	709	CD
18637	5579	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5579	4	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	5579	5	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	5579	6	,	,	,
18637	5579	7	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	5579	8	,	,	,
18637	5579	9	and	and	CC
18637	5579	10	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	5579	11	thought	think	VBD
18637	5579	12	the	the	DT
18637	5579	13	decision	decision	NN
18637	5579	14	correct	correct	JJ
18637	5579	15	as	as	IN
18637	5579	16	to	to	IN
18637	5579	17	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	5579	18	from	from	IN
18637	5579	19	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	5579	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5579	21	.	.	.
18637	5580	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	5580	2	for	for	IN
18637	5580	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5580	4	,	,	,
18637	5580	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5580	6	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	5580	7	made	make	VBD
18637	5580	8	an	an	DT
18637	5580	9	effort	effort	NN
18637	5580	10	to	to	TO
18637	5580	11	resurrect	resurrect	VB
18637	5580	12	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	5580	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5580	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	5580	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5580	16	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	5580	17	Trunk	Trunk	NNP
18637	5580	18	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5580	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5580	20	,	,	,
18637	5580	21	142	142	CD
18637	5580	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5580	23	217	217	CD
18637	5580	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5580	25	1891	1891	CD
18637	5580	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5580	27	.	.	.
18637	5581	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5581	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	5581	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	5581	4	without	without	IN
18637	5581	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	5581	6	.	.	.
18637	5582	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5582	2	710	710	CD
18637	5582	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5582	4	334	334	CD
18637	5582	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5582	6	653	653	CD
18637	5582	7	.	.	.
18637	5583	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5583	2	711	711	CD
18637	5583	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5583	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5583	5	.	.	.
18637	5584	1	663	663	CD
18637	5584	2	,	,	,
18637	5584	3	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5584	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5584	5	Live	Live	NNP
18637	5584	6	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	5584	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5584	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5584	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5584	10	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
18637	5584	11	of	of	IN
18637	5584	12	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	5584	13	,	,	,
18637	5584	14	303	303	CD
18637	5584	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5584	16	250	250	CD
18637	5584	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5584	18	1938	1938	CD
18637	5584	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5584	20	;	;	:
18637	5584	21	and	and	CC
18637	5584	22	Ratterman	Ratterman	NNP
18637	5584	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5584	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	5584	25	_	_	NNP
18637	5584	26	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5584	27	Union	Union	NNP
18637	5584	28	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5584	29	.	.	.
18637	5585	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5585	2	,	,	,
18637	5585	3	127	127	CD
18637	5585	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5585	5	411	411	CD
18637	5585	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5585	7	1888	1888	CD
18637	5585	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5585	9	.	.	.
18637	5586	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5586	2	712	712	CD
18637	5586	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5586	4	335	335	CD
18637	5586	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5586	6	80	80	CD
18637	5586	7	.	.	.
18637	5587	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5587	2	713	713	CD
18637	5587	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5587	4	337	337	CD
18637	5587	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5587	6	662	662	CD
18637	5587	7	,	,	,
18637	5587	8	666	666	CD
18637	5587	9	,	,	,
18637	5587	10	677	677	CD
18637	5587	11	-	-	SYM
18637	5587	12	678	678	CD
18637	5587	13	,	,	,
18637	5587	14	680	680	CD
18637	5587	15	.	.	.
18637	5588	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5588	2	714	714	CD
18637	5588	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5588	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5588	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5588	6	supra	supra	IN
18637	5588	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5588	8	,	,	,
18637	5588	9	pp	pp	NNP
18637	5588	10	.	.	.
18637	5589	1	196	196	CD
18637	5589	2	,	,	,
18637	5589	3	204	204	CD
18637	5589	4	-	-	SYM
18637	5589	5	207	207	CD
18637	5589	6	.	.	.
18637	5590	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5590	2	715	715	CD
18637	5590	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5590	4	247	247	CD
18637	5590	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5590	6	321	321	CD
18637	5590	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5590	8	1918	1918	CD
18637	5590	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5590	10	.	.	.
18637	5591	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5591	2	716	716	CD
18637	5591	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5591	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5591	5	.	.	.
18637	5592	1	328	328	CD
18637	5592	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5592	3	329	329	CD
18637	5592	4	.	.	.
18637	5593	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5593	2	717	717	CD
18637	5593	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5593	4	Shaffer	Shaffer	NNP
18637	5593	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5593	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5593	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5593	8	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	5593	9	,	,	,
18637	5593	10	252	252	CD
18637	5593	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5593	12	37	37	CD
18637	5593	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5593	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	5593	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5593	16	.	.	.
18637	5594	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5594	2	718	718	CD
18637	5594	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5594	4	Underwood	Underwood	NNP
18637	5594	5	Typewriter	Typewriter	NNP
18637	5594	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5594	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5594	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5594	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5594	10	Chamberlain	Chamberlain	NNP
18637	5594	11	,	,	,
18637	5594	12	254	254	CD
18637	5594	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5594	14	113	113	CD
18637	5594	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5594	16	1920	1920	CD
18637	5594	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5594	18	;	;	:
18637	5594	19	Bass	Bass	NNP
18637	5594	20	,	,	,
18637	5594	21	Ratcliff	Ratcliff	NNP
18637	5594	22	&	&	CC
18637	5594	23	Gretton	Gretton	NNP
18637	5594	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5594	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	5594	26	_	_	NNP
18637	5594	27	State	State	NNP
18637	5594	28	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5594	29	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	5594	30	,	,	,
18637	5594	31	266	266	CD
18637	5594	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5594	33	271	271	CD
18637	5594	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5594	35	1924	1924	CD
18637	5594	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5594	37	.	.	.
18637	5595	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5595	2	719	719	CD
18637	5595	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5595	4	Hans	Hans	NNP
18637	5595	5	Rees	Rees	NNPS
18637	5595	6	'	'	POS
18637	5595	7	Sons	Sons	NNPS
18637	5595	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5595	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5595	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5595	11	North	North	NNP
18637	5595	12	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	5595	13	,	,	,
18637	5595	14	283	283	CD
18637	5595	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5595	16	123	123	CD
18637	5595	17	,	,	,
18637	5595	18	132	132	CD
18637	5595	19	,	,	,
18637	5595	20	133	133	CD
18637	5595	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5595	22	1931	1931	CD
18637	5595	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5595	24	.	.	.
18637	5596	1	In	in	IN
18637	5596	2	this	this	DT
18637	5596	3	case	case	NN
18637	5596	4	a	a	DT
18637	5596	5	North	North	NNP
18637	5596	6	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	5596	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	5596	8	was	be	VBD
18637	5596	9	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	5596	10	on	on	IN
18637	5596	11	the	the	DT
18637	5596	12	income	income	NN
18637	5596	13	of	of	IN
18637	5596	14	a	a	DT
18637	5596	15	New	New	NNP
18637	5596	16	York	York	NNP
18637	5596	17	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	5596	18	,	,	,
18637	5596	19	which	which	WDT
18637	5596	20	bought	buy	VBD
18637	5596	21	leather	leather	NN
18637	5596	22	,	,	,
18637	5596	23	manufactured	manufacture	VBD
18637	5596	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5596	25	in	in	IN
18637	5596	26	North	North	NNP
18637	5596	27	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	5596	28	,	,	,
18637	5596	29	and	and	CC
18637	5596	30	sold	sell	VBD
18637	5596	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5596	32	products	product	NNS
18637	5596	33	at	at	IN
18637	5596	34	wholesale	wholesale	JJ
18637	5596	35	and	and	CC
18637	5596	36	retail	retail	NN
18637	5596	37	in	in	IN
18637	5596	38	New	New	NNP
18637	5596	39	York	York	NNP
18637	5596	40	.	.	.
18637	5597	1	The	the	DT
18637	5597	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5597	3	observed	observe	VBD
18637	5597	4	:	:	:
18637	5597	5	"	"	``
18637	5597	6	The	the	DT
18637	5597	7	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	5597	8	of	of	IN
18637	5597	9	making	make	VBG
18637	5597	10	an	an	DT
18637	5597	11	exact	exact	JJ
18637	5597	12	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	5597	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	5597	14	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	5597	15	and	and	CC
18637	5597	16	hence	hence	RB
18637	5597	17	,	,	,
18637	5597	18	when	when	WRB
18637	5597	19	the	the	DT
18637	5597	20	State	State	NNP
18637	5597	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	5597	22	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	5597	23	a	a	DT
18637	5597	24	method	method	NN
18637	5597	25	not	not	RB
18637	5597	26	intrinsically	intrinsically	RB
18637	5597	27	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	5597	28	,	,	,
18637	5597	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5597	30	will	will	MD
18637	5597	31	be	be	VB
18637	5597	32	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	5597	33	until	until	IN
18637	5597	34	proof	proof	NN
18637	5597	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	5597	36	offered	offer	VBN
18637	5597	37	of	of	IN
18637	5597	38	an	an	DT
18637	5597	39	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	5597	40	and	and	CC
18637	5597	41	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	5597	42	application	application	NN
18637	5597	43	in	in	IN
18637	5597	44	particular	particular	JJ
18637	5597	45	cases	case	NNS
18637	5597	46	.	.	.
18637	5597	47	"	"	''
18637	5598	1	The	the	DT
18637	5598	2	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	5598	3	in	in	IN
18637	5598	4	the	the	DT
18637	5598	5	Underwood	Underwood	NNP
18637	5598	6	and	and	CC
18637	5598	7	Bass	Bass	NNP
18637	5598	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	5598	9	,	,	,
18637	5598	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5598	11	supra	supra	NNP
18637	5598	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5598	13	,	,	,
18637	5598	14	"	"	``
18637	5598	15	are	be	VBP
18637	5598	16	not	not	RB
18637	5598	17	authority	authority	NN
18637	5598	18	for	for	IN
18637	5598	19	the	the	DT
18637	5598	20	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	5598	21	that	that	IN
18637	5598	22	where	where	WRB
18637	5598	23	a	a	DT
18637	5598	24	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	5598	25	manufactures	manufacture	VBZ
18637	5598	26	in	in	IN
18637	5598	27	one	one	CD
18637	5598	28	State	State	NNP
18637	5598	29	and	and	CC
18637	5598	30	sells	sell	VBZ
18637	5598	31	in	in	IN
18637	5598	32	another	another	DT
18637	5598	33	,	,	,
18637	5598	34	the	the	DT
18637	5598	35	net	net	JJ
18637	5598	36	profits	profit	NNS
18637	5598	37	of	of	IN
18637	5598	38	the	the	DT
18637	5598	39	entire	entire	JJ
18637	5598	40	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	5598	41	,	,	,
18637	5598	42	as	as	IN
18637	5598	43	a	a	DT
18637	5598	44	unitary	unitary	JJ
18637	5598	45	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	5598	46	,	,	,
18637	5598	47	may	may	MD
18637	5598	48	be	be	VB
18637	5598	49	attributed	attribute	VBN
18637	5598	50	,	,	,
18637	5598	51	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	5598	52	of	of	IN
18637	5598	53	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	5598	54	,	,	,
18637	5598	55	to	to	IN
18637	5598	56	either	either	DT
18637	5598	57	State	State	NNP
18637	5598	58	.	.	.
18637	5598	59	"	"	''
18637	5599	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5599	2	720	720	CD
18637	5599	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5599	4	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	5599	5	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	5599	6	Line	Line	NNP
18637	5599	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5599	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5599	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5599	10	Daughton	Daughton	NNP
18637	5599	11	,	,	,
18637	5599	12	262	262	CD
18637	5599	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5599	14	413	413	CD
18637	5599	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5599	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	5599	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5599	18	.	.	.
18637	5600	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5600	2	721	721	CD
18637	5600	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5600	4	Matson	Matson	NNP
18637	5600	5	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	5600	6	.	.	.
18637	5601	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5601	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5601	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5601	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5601	5	State	State	NNP
18637	5601	6	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5601	7	,	,	,
18637	5601	8	297	297	CD
18637	5601	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5601	10	441	441	CD
18637	5601	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5601	12	1936	1936	CD
18637	5601	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5601	14	.	.	.
18637	5602	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5602	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5602	3	also	also	RB
18637	5602	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5602	5	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	5602	6	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	5602	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5602	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5602	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5602	10	McColgan	McColgan	NNP
18637	5602	11	,	,	,
18637	5602	12	315	315	CD
18637	5602	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5602	14	501	501	CD
18637	5602	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5602	16	1942	1942	CD
18637	5602	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5602	18	,	,	,
18637	5602	19	where	where	WRB
18637	5602	20	the	the	DT
18637	5602	21	tax	tax	NN
18637	5602	22	was	be	VBD
18637	5602	23	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	5602	24	under	under	IN
18637	5602	25	the	the	DT
18637	5602	26	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	5602	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	5602	28	.	.	.
18637	5603	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5603	2	722	722	CD
18637	5603	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5603	4	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	5603	5	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5603	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5603	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5603	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5603	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5603	10	Beeler	Beeler	NNP
18637	5603	11	,	,	,
18637	5603	12	315	315	CD
18637	5603	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5603	14	649	649	CD
18637	5603	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5603	16	1942	1942	CD
18637	5603	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5603	18	.	.	.
18637	5604	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5604	2	723	723	CD
18637	5604	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5604	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5604	5	.	.	.
18637	5605	1	656	656	CD
18637	5605	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	5605	3	657	657	CD
18637	5605	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5605	5	724	724	CD
18637	5605	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5605	7	Spector	Spector	NNP
18637	5605	8	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	5605	9	Service	Service	NNP
18637	5605	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5605	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	5605	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5605	13	O'Connor	O'Connor	NNP
18637	5605	14	,	,	,
18637	5605	15	340	340	CD
18637	5605	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5605	17	602	602	CD
18637	5605	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5605	19	1951	1951	CD
18637	5605	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5605	21	.	.	.
18637	5606	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5606	2	725	725	CD
18637	5606	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5606	4	114	114	CD
18637	5606	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5606	6	196	196	CD
18637	5606	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5606	8	1885	1885	CD
18637	5606	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5606	10	.	.	.
18637	5607	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5607	2	726	726	CD
18637	5607	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5607	4	Hays	Hays	NNP
18637	5607	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5607	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5607	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5607	8	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	5607	9	Mail	Mail	NNP
18637	5607	10	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	5607	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5607	12	,	,	,
18637	5607	13	17	17	CD
18637	5607	14	How	how	WRB
18637	5607	15	.	.	.
18637	5608	1	596	596	CD
18637	5608	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5608	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	5608	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5608	5	.	.	.
18637	5609	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5609	2	727	727	CD
18637	5609	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5609	4	Packet	Packet	NNP
18637	5609	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5609	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5609	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5609	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5609	9	Keokuk	Keokuk	NNP
18637	5609	10	,	,	,
18637	5609	11	95	95	CD
18637	5609	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5609	13	80	80	CD
18637	5609	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5609	15	1877	1877	CD
18637	5609	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5609	17	;	;	:
18637	5609	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5609	19	see	see	VB
18637	5609	20	also	also	RB
18637	5609	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5609	22	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	5609	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5609	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5609	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	5609	26	_	_	NNP
18637	5609	27	Parkersburg	Parkersburg	NNP
18637	5609	28	,	,	,
18637	5609	29	107	107	CD
18637	5609	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5609	31	691	691	CD
18637	5609	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5609	33	1883	1883	CD
18637	5609	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5609	35	.	.	.
18637	5610	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5610	2	728	728	CD
18637	5610	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5610	4	Ayer	Ayer	NNP
18637	5610	5	&	&	CC
18637	5610	6	L.	L.	NNP
18637	5610	7	Tie	Tie	NNP
18637	5610	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5610	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5610	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5610	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5610	12	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5610	13	,	,	,
18637	5610	14	202	202	CD
18637	5610	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5610	16	409	409	CD
18637	5610	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5610	18	1906	1906	CD
18637	5610	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5610	20	.	.	.
18637	5611	1	For	for	IN
18637	5611	2	a	a	DT
18637	5611	3	rÃ	rÃ	NNP
18637	5611	4	©	©	NN
18637	5611	5	sumÃ	sumã	CD
18637	5611	6	©	©	NNP
18637	5611	7	of	of	IN
18637	5611	8	the	the	DT
18637	5611	9	rules	rule	NNS
18637	5611	10	for	for	IN
18637	5611	11	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	5611	12	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	5611	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5611	14	see	see	VBP
18637	5611	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5611	16	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	5611	17	Airlines	Airlines	NNPS
18637	5611	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5611	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	5611	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5611	21	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5611	22	,	,	,
18637	5611	23	322	322	CD
18637	5611	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5611	25	292	292	CD
18637	5611	26	,	,	,
18637	5611	27	314	314	CD
18637	5611	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	5611	29	315	315	CD
18637	5611	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5611	31	1944	1944	CD
18637	5611	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5611	33	,	,	,
18637	5611	34	note	note	VB
18637	5611	35	2	2	CD
18637	5611	36	.	.	.
18637	5612	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5612	2	729	729	CD
18637	5612	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5612	4	Old	Old	NNP
18637	5612	5	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	5612	6	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	5612	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5612	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5612	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5612	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5612	11	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	5612	12	,	,	,
18637	5612	13	198	198	CD
18637	5612	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5612	15	299	299	CD
18637	5612	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5612	17	1905	1905	CD
18637	5612	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5612	19	:	:	:
18637	5612	20	a	a	DT
18637	5612	21	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	5612	22	enrolled	enrol	VBN
18637	5612	23	in	in	IN
18637	5612	24	New	New	NNP
18637	5612	25	York	York	NNP
18637	5612	26	at	at	IN
18637	5612	27	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	5612	28	of	of	IN
18637	5612	29	owner	owner	NN
18637	5612	30	,	,	,
18637	5612	31	but	but	CC
18637	5612	32	operating	operate	VBG
18637	5612	33	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	5612	34	in	in	IN
18637	5612	35	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	5612	36	,	,	,
18637	5612	37	was	be	VBD
18637	5612	38	held	hold	VBN
18637	5612	39	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	5612	40	in	in	IN
18637	5612	41	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	5612	42	.	.	.
18637	5613	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5613	2	730	730	CD
18637	5613	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5613	4	336	336	CD
18637	5613	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5613	6	169	169	CD
18637	5613	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5613	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	5613	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5613	10	.	.	.
18637	5614	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5614	2	731	731	CD
18637	5614	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5614	4	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	5614	5	Airlines	Airlines	NNPS
18637	5614	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5614	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5614	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5614	9	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5614	10	,	,	,
18637	5614	11	322	322	CD
18637	5614	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5614	13	292	292	CD
18637	5614	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5614	15	1944	1944	CD
18637	5614	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5614	17	.	.	.
18637	5615	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5615	2	732	732	CD
18637	5615	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5615	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5615	5	also	also	RB
18637	5615	6	invoked	invoke	VBD
18637	5615	7	New	New	NNP
18637	5615	8	York	York	NNP
18637	5615	9	Central	Central	NNP
18637	5615	10	and	and	CC
18637	5615	11	H.R.R.	H.R.R.	NNP
18637	5616	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5616	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5616	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5616	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5616	5	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	5616	6	,	,	,
18637	5616	7	202	202	CD
18637	5616	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5616	9	584	584	CD
18637	5616	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5616	11	1906	1906	CD
18637	5616	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5616	13	,	,	,
18637	5616	14	where	where	WRB
18637	5616	15	although	although	IN
18637	5616	16	12	12	CD
18637	5616	17	to	to	TO
18637	5616	18	64	64	CD
18637	5616	19	per	per	NN
18637	5616	20	cent	cent	NN
18637	5616	21	of	of	IN
18637	5616	22	the	the	DT
18637	5616	23	rolling	roll	VBG
18637	5616	24	stock	stock	NN
18637	5616	25	of	of	IN
18637	5616	26	the	the	DT
18637	5616	27	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	5616	28	was	be	VBD
18637	5616	29	outside	outside	RB
18637	5616	30	of	of	IN
18637	5616	31	New	New	NNP
18637	5616	32	York	York	NNP
18637	5616	33	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	5616	34	the	the	DT
18637	5616	35	tax	tax	NN
18637	5616	36	year	year	NN
18637	5616	37	,	,	,
18637	5616	38	New	New	NNP
18637	5616	39	York	York	NNP
18637	5616	40	was	be	VBD
18637	5616	41	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	5616	42	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	5616	43	to	to	TO
18637	5616	44	tax	tax	VB
18637	5616	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5616	46	all	all	DT
18637	5616	47	because	because	IN
18637	5616	48	no	no	DT
18637	5616	49	part	part	NN
18637	5616	50	was	be	VBD
18637	5616	51	in	in	IN
18637	5616	52	any	any	DT
18637	5616	53	other	other	JJ
18637	5616	54	State	State	NNP
18637	5616	55	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	5616	56	the	the	DT
18637	5616	57	year	year	NN
18637	5616	58	.	.	.
18637	5617	1	The	the	DT
18637	5617	2	case	case	NN
18637	5617	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	5617	4	atypical	atypical	JJ
18637	5617	5	,	,	,
18637	5617	6	a	a	DT
18637	5617	7	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	5617	8	sport	sport	NN
18637	5617	9	;	;	:
18637	5617	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5617	11	cf	cf	NNP
18637	5617	12	.	.	.
18637	5617	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5617	14	Union	Union	NNP
18637	5617	15	Refrigerator	Refrigerator	NNP
18637	5617	16	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	5617	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5617	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5617	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	5617	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5617	21	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5617	22	,	,	,
18637	5617	23	199	199	CD
18637	5617	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5617	25	194	194	CD
18637	5617	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5617	27	1905	1905	CD
18637	5617	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5617	29	.	.	.
18637	5618	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5618	2	733	733	CD
18637	5618	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5618	4	322	322	CD
18637	5618	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5618	6	at	at	IN
18637	5618	7	301	301	CD
18637	5618	8	-	-	SYM
18637	5618	9	302	302	CD
18637	5618	10	.	.	.
18637	5619	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5619	2	734	734	CD
18637	5619	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5619	4	"	"	``
18637	5619	5	The	the	DT
18637	5619	6	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	5619	7	theory	theory	NN
18637	5619	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	5619	9	a	a	DT
18637	5619	10	mongrel	mongrel	NN
18637	5619	11	one	one	CD
18637	5619	12	,	,	,
18637	5619	13	a	a	DT
18637	5619	14	cross	cross	NN
18637	5619	15	between	between	IN
18637	5619	16	desire	desire	NN
18637	5619	17	not	not	RB
18637	5619	18	to	to	TO
18637	5619	19	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	5619	20	with	with	IN
18637	5619	21	State	state	NN
18637	5619	22	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	5619	23	and	and	CC
18637	5619	24	desire	desire	NN
18637	5619	25	at	at	IN
18637	5619	26	the	the	DT
18637	5619	27	same	same	JJ
18637	5619	28	time	time	NN
18637	5619	29	not	not	RB
18637	5619	30	utterly	utterly	RB
18637	5619	31	to	to	TO
18637	5619	32	crush	crush	VB
18637	5619	33	out	out	RP
18637	5619	34	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5619	35	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5619	36	.	.	.
18637	5620	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5620	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	5620	3	a	a	DT
18637	5620	4	practical	practical	JJ
18637	5620	5	,	,	,
18637	5620	6	but	but	CC
18637	5620	7	rather	rather	RB
18637	5620	8	illogical	illogical	JJ
18637	5620	9	,	,	,
18637	5620	10	device	device	NN
18637	5620	11	to	to	TO
18637	5620	12	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	5620	13	duplication	duplication	NN
18637	5620	14	of	of	IN
18637	5620	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	5620	16	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	5620	17	on	on	IN
18637	5620	18	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	5620	19	in	in	IN
18637	5620	20	transit	transit	NN
18637	5620	21	.	.	.
18637	5621	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5621	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	5621	3	established	establish	VBN
18637	5621	4	in	in	IN
18637	5621	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5621	6	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	5621	7	and	and	CC
18637	5621	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	5621	9	been	be	VBN
18637	5621	10	found	find	VBN
18637	5621	11	more	more	RBR
18637	5621	12	or	or	CC
18637	5621	13	less	less	RBR
18637	5621	14	workable	workable	JJ
18637	5621	15	with	with	IN
18637	5621	16	more	more	JJR
18637	5621	17	or	or	CC
18637	5621	18	less	less	RBR
18637	5621	19	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	5621	20	formulae	formula	NNS
18637	5621	21	of	of	IN
18637	5621	22	apportionment	apportionment	NNP
18637	5621	23	.	.	.
18637	5622	1	Nothing	nothing	NN
18637	5622	2	either	either	CC
18637	5622	3	in	in	IN
18637	5622	4	theory	theory	NN
18637	5622	5	or	or	CC
18637	5622	6	in	in	IN
18637	5622	7	practice	practice	NN
18637	5622	8	commends	commend	VBZ
18637	5622	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5622	10	for	for	IN
18637	5622	11	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	5622	12	to	to	IN
18637	5622	13	air	air	NN
18637	5622	14	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	5622	15	.	.	.
18637	5622	16	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	5622	17	.	.	.
18637	5623	1	306	306	CD
18637	5623	2	.	.	.
18637	5624	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5624	2	735	735	CD
18637	5624	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5624	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5624	5	.	.	.
18637	5625	1	308	308	CD
18637	5625	2	.	.	.
18637	5626	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5626	2	736	736	CD
18637	5626	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5626	4	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	5626	5	's	's	POS
18637	5626	6	Palace	Palace	NNP
18637	5626	7	Car	Car	NNP
18637	5626	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5626	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5626	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5626	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5626	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5626	13	,	,	,
18637	5626	14	141	141	CD
18637	5626	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5626	16	18	18	CD
18637	5626	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5626	18	1891	1891	CD
18637	5626	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5626	20	.	.	.
18637	5627	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5627	2	737	737	CD
18637	5627	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5627	4	322	322	CD
18637	5627	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5627	6	309	309	CD
18637	5627	7	.	.	.
18637	5628	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5628	2	738	738	CD
18637	5628	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5628	4	235	235	CD
18637	5628	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5628	6	610	610	CD
18637	5628	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5628	8	1915	1915	CD
18637	5628	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5628	10	.	.	.
18637	5629	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5629	2	739	739	CD
18637	5629	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5629	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5629	5	.	.	.
18637	5630	1	622	622	CD
18637	5630	2	.	.	.
18637	5631	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5631	2	740	740	CD
18637	5631	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5631	4	Hendrick	Hendrick	NNP
18637	5631	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5631	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5631	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5631	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	5631	9	,	,	,
18637	5631	10	235	235	CD
18637	5631	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5631	12	610	610	CD
18637	5631	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5631	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	5631	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5631	16	.	.	.
18637	5632	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5632	2	741	741	CD
18637	5632	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5632	4	Kane	Kane	NNP
18637	5632	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5632	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5632	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5632	8	New	New	NNP
18637	5632	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	5632	10	,	,	,
18637	5632	11	242	242	CD
18637	5632	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5632	13	160	160	CD
18637	5632	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5632	15	1916	1916	CD
18637	5632	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5632	17	.	.	.
18637	5633	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5633	2	742	742	CD
18637	5633	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5633	4	Morf	Morf	NNP
18637	5633	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5633	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5633	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5633	8	Bingaman	Bingaman	NNP
18637	5633	9	,	,	,
18637	5633	10	298	298	CD
18637	5633	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5633	12	407	407	CD
18637	5633	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5633	14	1936	1936	CD
18637	5633	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5633	16	.	.	.
18637	5634	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5634	2	743	743	CD
18637	5634	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5634	4	Ingels	Ingels	NNPS
18637	5634	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5634	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5634	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5634	8	Morf	Morf	NNP
18637	5634	9	,	,	,
18637	5634	10	300	300	CD
18637	5634	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5634	12	290	290	CD
18637	5634	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5634	14	1937	1937	CD
18637	5634	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5634	16	.	.	.
18637	5635	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5635	2	744	744	CD
18637	5635	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5635	4	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	5635	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5635	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5635	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5635	8	Poor	Poor	NNP
18637	5635	9	,	,	,
18637	5635	10	274	274	CD
18637	5635	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5635	12	554	554	CD
18637	5635	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5635	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	5635	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5635	16	;	;	:
18637	5635	17	Hicklin	Hicklin	NNP
18637	5635	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5635	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	5635	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5635	21	Coney	Coney	NNP
18637	5635	22	,	,	,
18637	5635	23	290	290	CD
18637	5635	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5635	25	109	109	CD
18637	5635	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5635	27	1933	1933	CD
18637	5635	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5635	29	.	.	.
18637	5636	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5636	2	745	745	CD
18637	5636	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5636	4	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	5636	5	Busses	Busses	NNPS
18637	5636	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	5636	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5636	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5636	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5636	10	Blodgett	Blodgett	NNP
18637	5636	11	,	,	,
18637	5636	12	276	276	CD
18637	5636	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5636	14	245	245	CD
18637	5636	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5636	16	1928	1928	CD
18637	5636	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5636	18	;	;	:
18637	5636	19	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	5636	20	Baking	Baking	NNP
18637	5636	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5636	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5636	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	5636	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5636	25	Woodring	Woodring	NNP
18637	5636	26	,	,	,
18637	5636	27	286	286	CD
18637	5636	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5636	29	352	352	CD
18637	5636	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5636	31	1932	1932	CD
18637	5636	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5636	33	.	.	.
18637	5637	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5637	2	746	746	CD
18637	5637	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5637	4	Aero	Aero	NNP
18637	5637	5	Mayflower	Mayflower	NNP
18637	5637	6	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	5637	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5637	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5637	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5637	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5637	11	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	5637	12	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	5637	13	.	.	.
18637	5638	1	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	5638	2	.	.	.
18637	5639	1	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	5639	2	,	,	,
18637	5639	3	295	295	CD
18637	5639	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5639	5	285	285	CD
18637	5639	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5639	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	5639	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5639	9	.	.	.
18637	5640	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5640	2	747	747	CD
18637	5640	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5640	4	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	5640	5	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	5640	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5640	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5640	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5640	9	Lindsey	Lindsey	NNP
18637	5640	10	,	,	,
18637	5640	11	283	283	CD
18637	5640	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5640	13	183	183	CD
18637	5640	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5640	15	1931	1931	CD
18637	5640	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5640	17	.	.	.
18637	5641	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5641	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	5641	3	.	.	.
18637	5641	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5641	5	Sprout	Sprout	NNP
18637	5641	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5641	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5641	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5641	9	South	South	NNP
18637	5641	10	Bend	Bend	NNP
18637	5641	11	,	,	,
18637	5641	12	277	277	CD
18637	5641	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5641	14	163	163	CD
18637	5641	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5641	16	1928	1928	CD
18637	5641	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5641	18	.	.	.
18637	5642	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5642	2	748	748	CD
18637	5642	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5642	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5642	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5642	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5642	7	Dixie	Dixie	NNP
18637	5642	8	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	5642	9	Express	Express	NNP
18637	5642	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5642	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5642	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	5642	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5642	14	State	State	NNP
18637	5642	15	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	5643	1	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	5643	2	.	.	NNP
18637	5643	3	,	,	,
18637	5643	4	306	306	CD
18637	5643	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5643	6	72	72	CD
18637	5643	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5643	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	5643	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5643	10	;	;	:
18637	5643	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5643	12	also	also	RB
18637	5643	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5643	14	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	5643	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5643	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	5643	17	_	_	NNP
18637	5643	18	Paul	Paul	NNP
18637	5643	19	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	5643	20	,	,	,
18637	5643	21	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	5643	22	,	,	,
18637	5643	23	306	306	CD
18637	5643	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5643	25	583	583	CD
18637	5643	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5643	27	1939	1939	CD
18637	5643	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5643	29	;	;	:
18637	5643	30	Aero	Aero	NNP
18637	5643	31	Mayflower	Mayflower	NNP
18637	5643	32	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	5643	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5643	34	_	_	NNP
18637	5643	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	5643	36	_	_	NNP
18637	5643	37	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5643	38	of	of	IN
18637	5643	39	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	5644	1	Commrs	Commrs	NNP
18637	5644	2	.	.	NNP
18637	5644	3	,	,	,
18637	5644	4	332	332	CD
18637	5644	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5644	6	495	495	CD
18637	5644	7	,	,	,
18637	5644	8	503	503	CD
18637	5644	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	5644	10	504	504	CD
18637	5644	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5644	12	1947	1947	CD
18637	5644	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5644	14	.	.	.
18637	5645	1	Here	here	RB
18637	5645	2	was	be	VBD
18637	5645	3	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	5645	4	a	a	DT
18637	5645	5	State	State	NNP
18637	5645	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	5645	7	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	5645	8	a	a	DT
18637	5645	9	flat	flat	JJ
18637	5645	10	tax	tax	NN
18637	5645	11	of	of	IN
18637	5645	12	$	$	$
18637	5645	13	10	10	CD
18637	5645	14	annually	annually	RB
18637	5645	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	5645	16	each	each	DT
18637	5645	17	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	5645	18	operated	operate	VBN
18637	5645	19	by	by	IN
18637	5645	20	a	a	DT
18637	5645	21	motor	motor	NN
18637	5645	22	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	5645	23	over	over	IN
18637	5645	24	the	the	DT
18637	5645	25	State	State	NNP
18637	5645	26	's	's	POS
18637	5645	27	highways	highway	NNS
18637	5645	28	,	,	,
18637	5645	29	and	and	CC
18637	5645	30	a	a	DT
18637	5645	31	fee	fee	NN
18637	5645	32	of	of	IN
18637	5645	33	one	one	CD
18637	5645	34	half	half	NN
18637	5645	35	of	of	IN
18637	5645	36	one	one	CD
18637	5645	37	per	per	IN
18637	5645	38	cent	cent	NN
18637	5645	39	of	of	IN
18637	5645	40	the	the	DT
18637	5645	41	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	5645	42	's	's	POS
18637	5645	43	gross	gross	JJ
18637	5645	44	operating	operating	NN
18637	5645	45	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	5645	46	from	from	IN
18637	5645	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5645	48	operations	operation	NNS
18637	5645	49	within	within	IN
18637	5645	50	the	the	DT
18637	5645	51	State	State	NNP
18637	5645	52	,	,	,
18637	5645	53	with	with	IN
18637	5645	54	an	an	DT
18637	5645	55	annual	annual	JJ
18637	5645	56	minimum	minimum	NN
18637	5645	57	of	of	IN
18637	5645	58	$	$	$
18637	5645	59	15	15	CD
18637	5645	60	per	per	IN
18637	5645	61	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	5645	62	,	,	,
18637	5645	63	in	in	IN
18637	5645	64	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	5645	65	of	of	IN
18637	5645	66	the	the	DT
18637	5645	67	use	use	NN
18637	5645	68	of	of	IN
18637	5645	69	the	the	DT
18637	5645	70	highways	highway	NNS
18637	5645	71	and	and	CC
18637	5645	72	in	in	IN
18637	5645	73	addition	addition	NN
18637	5645	74	to	to	IN
18637	5645	75	all	all	DT
18637	5645	76	other	other	JJ
18637	5645	77	motor	motor	NN
18637	5645	78	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	5645	79	license	license	NN
18637	5645	80	fees	fee	NNS
18637	5645	81	and	and	CC
18637	5645	82	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	5645	83	.	.	.
18637	5646	1	This	this	DT
18637	5646	2	was	be	VBD
18637	5646	3	held	hold	VBN
18637	5646	4	,	,	,
18637	5646	5	as	as	IN
18637	5646	6	applied	apply	VBN
18637	5646	7	to	to	IN
18637	5646	8	a	a	DT
18637	5646	9	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	5646	10	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	5646	11	solely	solely	RB
18637	5646	12	in	in	IN
18637	5646	13	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5646	14	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5646	15	,	,	,
18637	5646	16	not	not	RB
18637	5646	17	to	to	TO
18637	5646	18	burden	burden	VB
18637	5646	19	such	such	JJ
18637	5646	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5646	21	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	RB
18637	5646	22	,	,	,
18637	5646	23	although	although	IN
18637	5646	24	the	the	DT
18637	5646	25	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	5646	26	went	go	VBD
18637	5646	27	into	into	IN
18637	5646	28	the	the	DT
18637	5646	29	State	State	NNP
18637	5646	30	's	's	POS
18637	5646	31	general	general	JJ
18637	5646	32	fund	fund	NN
18637	5646	33	subject	subject	NN
18637	5646	34	to	to	IN
18637	5646	35	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	5646	36	for	for	IN
18637	5646	37	other	other	JJ
18637	5646	38	than	than	IN
18637	5646	39	highway	highway	NN
18637	5646	40	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	5646	41	.	.	.
18637	5647	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5647	2	Opinion	opinion	NN
18637	5647	3	by	by	IN
18637	5647	4	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	5647	5	,	,	,
18637	5647	6	J.	J.	NNP
18637	5647	7	,	,	,
18637	5647	8	all	all	DT
18637	5647	9	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	5647	10	.	.	.
18637	5647	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5648	1	While	while	IN
18637	5648	2	a	a	DT
18637	5648	3	"	"	``
18637	5648	4	State	state	NN
18637	5648	5	may	may	MD
18637	5648	6	not	not	RB
18637	5648	7	discriminate	discriminate	VB
18637	5648	8	against	against	IN
18637	5648	9	or	or	CC
18637	5648	10	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	5648	11	such	such	JJ
18637	5648	12	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5648	13	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	5648	14	generally	generally	RB
18637	5648	15	in	in	IN
18637	5648	16	the	the	DT
18637	5648	17	use	use	NN
18637	5648	18	of	of	IN
18637	5648	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5648	20	highways	highway	NNS
18637	5648	21	,	,	,
18637	5648	22	*	*	NFP
18637	5648	23	*	*	NFP
18637	5648	24	*	*	NFP
18637	5648	25	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5648	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5648	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	5648	28	not	not	RB
18637	5648	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5648	30	required	require	VBN
18637	5648	31	to	to	TO
18637	5648	32	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	5648	33	those	those	DT
18637	5648	34	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	5648	35	to	to	IN
18637	5648	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	5648	37	free	free	JJ
18637	5648	38	of	of	IN
18637	5648	39	charge	charge	NN
18637	5648	40	or	or	CC
18637	5648	41	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	5648	42	on	on	IN
18637	5648	43	equal	equal	JJ
18637	5648	44	terms	term	NNS
18637	5648	45	with	with	IN
18637	5648	46	other	other	JJ
18637	5648	47	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	5648	48	not	not	RB
18637	5648	49	inflicting	inflict	VBG
18637	5648	50	similar	similar	JJ
18637	5648	51	destructive	destructive	JJ
18637	5648	52	effects	effect	NNS
18637	5648	53	.	.	.
18637	5649	1	*	*	NFP
18637	5649	2	*	*	NFP
18637	5649	3	*	*	NFP
18637	5649	4	Interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	5649	5	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	5649	6	equally	equally	RB
18637	5649	7	with	with	IN
18637	5649	8	intrastate	intrastate	NN
18637	5649	9	may	may	MD
18637	5649	10	be	be	VB
18637	5649	11	required	require	VBN
18637	5649	12	to	to	TO
18637	5649	13	pay	pay	VB
18637	5649	14	a	a	DT
18637	5649	15	fair	fair	JJ
18637	5649	16	share	share	NN
18637	5649	17	of	of	IN
18637	5649	18	the	the	DT
18637	5649	19	cost	cost	NN
18637	5649	20	and	and	CC
18637	5649	21	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	5649	22	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	5649	23	related	relate	VBN
18637	5649	24	to	to	IN
18637	5649	25	the	the	DT
18637	5649	26	use	use	NN
18637	5649	27	made	make	VBN
18637	5649	28	of	of	IN
18637	5649	29	the	the	DT
18637	5649	30	highways	highway	NNS
18637	5649	31	.	.	.
18637	5649	32	"	"	''
18637	5650	1	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5650	2	.	.	.
18637	5650	3	,	,	,
18637	5650	4	headnote	headnote	NNP
18637	5650	5	6	6	CD
18637	5650	6	.	.	.
18637	5651	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5651	2	749	749	CD
18637	5651	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5651	4	339	339	CD
18637	5651	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5651	6	542	542	CD
18637	5651	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5651	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	5651	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5651	10	.	.	.
18637	5652	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5652	2	750	750	CD
18637	5652	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5652	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5652	5	.	.	.
18637	5653	1	561	561	CD
18637	5653	2	.	.	.
18637	5654	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5654	2	751	751	CD
18637	5654	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5654	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5654	5	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	5654	6	for	for	IN
18637	5654	7	the	the	DT
18637	5654	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5654	9	in	in	IN
18637	5654	10	Great	Great	NNP
18637	5654	11	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	5654	12	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5654	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5654	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5654	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	5654	16	_	_	NNP
18637	5654	17	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	5654	18	,	,	,
18637	5654	19	300	300	CD
18637	5654	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5654	21	154	154	CD
18637	5654	22	,	,	,
18637	5654	23	159	159	CD
18637	5654	24	-	-	SYM
18637	5654	25	161	161	CD
18637	5654	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5654	27	1937	1937	CD
18637	5654	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5654	29	.	.	.
18637	5655	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5655	2	752	752	CD
18637	5655	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5655	4	Charlotte	Charlotte	NNP
18637	5655	5	,	,	,
18637	5655	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	5655	7	&	&	CC
18637	5655	8	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	5656	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5656	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5656	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5656	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5656	5	Gibbes	Gibbes	NNP
18637	5656	6	,	,	,
18637	5656	7	142	142	CD
18637	5656	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5656	9	386	386	CD
18637	5656	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5656	11	1892	1892	CD
18637	5656	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5656	13	;	;	:
18637	5656	14	New	New	NNP
18637	5656	15	York	York	NNP
18637	5656	16	ex	ex	NN
18637	5656	17	rel	rel	NN
18637	5656	18	.	.	.
18637	5657	1	New	New	NNP
18637	5657	2	York	York	NNP
18637	5657	3	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	5657	4	Lines	Lines	NNPS
18637	5657	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5657	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5657	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5657	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5657	9	Squire	Squire	NNP
18637	5657	10	,	,	,
18637	5657	11	145	145	CD
18637	5657	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5657	13	175	175	CD
18637	5657	14	,	,	,
18637	5657	15	191	191	CD
18637	5657	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5657	17	1892	1892	CD
18637	5657	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5657	19	.	.	.
18637	5658	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5658	2	753	753	CD
18637	5658	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5658	4	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	5658	5	&	&	CC
18637	5658	6	P.	P.	NNP
18637	5658	7	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5658	8	.	.	.
18637	5659	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5659	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5659	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5659	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5659	5	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	5659	6	,	,	,
18637	5659	7	190	190	CD
18637	5659	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5659	9	160	160	CD
18637	5659	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5659	11	1903	1903	CD
18637	5659	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5659	13	;	;	:
18637	5659	14	Mackay	Mackay	NNP
18637	5659	15	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5659	16	.	.	.
18637	5660	1	&	&	CC
18637	5660	2	Cable	Cable	NNP
18637	5660	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5660	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5660	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	5660	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5660	7	Little	Little	NNP
18637	5660	8	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	5660	9	,	,	,
18637	5660	10	250	250	CD
18637	5660	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5660	12	94	94	CD
18637	5660	13	,	,	,
18637	5660	14	99	99	CD
18637	5660	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5660	16	1919	1919	CD
18637	5660	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5660	18	.	.	.
18637	5661	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5661	2	754	754	CD
18637	5661	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5661	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5661	5	U.	U.	NNP
18637	5661	6	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5661	7	.	.	.
18637	5662	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5662	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5662	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5662	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5662	5	New	New	NNP
18637	5662	6	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	5662	7	,	,	,
18637	5662	8	187	187	CD
18637	5662	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5662	10	419	419	CD
18637	5662	11	,	,	,
18637	5662	12	425	425	CD
18637	5662	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5662	14	1903	1903	CD
18637	5662	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5662	16	;	;	:
18637	5662	17	Pure	Pure	NNP
18637	5662	18	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	5662	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5662	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5662	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	5662	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5662	23	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5662	24	,	,	,
18637	5662	25	248	248	CD
18637	5662	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5662	27	158	158	CD
18637	5662	28	,	,	,
18637	5662	29	162	162	CD
18637	5662	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5662	31	1918	1918	CD
18637	5662	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5662	33	.	.	.
18637	5663	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5663	2	755	755	CD
18637	5663	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5663	4	New	New	NNP
18637	5663	5	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	5663	6	ex	ex	NN
18637	5663	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	5663	8	.	.	.
18637	5664	1	McLean	McLean	NNP
18637	5664	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5664	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5664	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5664	5	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	5664	6	&	&	CC
18637	5664	7	R.G.R.	R.G.R.	NNP
18637	5665	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5665	2	,	,	,
18637	5665	3	203	203	CD
18637	5665	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5665	5	38	38	CD
18637	5665	6	,	,	,
18637	5665	7	55	55	CD
18637	5665	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5665	9	1906	1906	CD
18637	5665	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5665	11	.	.	.
18637	5666	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5666	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	5666	3	.	.	.
18637	5666	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5666	5	Red	Red	NNP
18637	5666	6	"	"	``
18637	5666	7	C	C	NNP
18637	5666	8	"	"	''
18637	5666	9	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	5666	10	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	5666	11	.	.	.
18637	5667	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5667	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5667	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5667	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5667	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5667	6	of	of	IN
18637	5667	7	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	5667	8	,	,	,
18637	5667	9	222	222	CD
18637	5667	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5667	11	380	380	CD
18637	5667	12	,	,	,
18637	5667	13	393	393	CD
18637	5667	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5667	15	1912	1912	CD
18637	5667	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5667	17	;	;	:
18637	5667	18	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5667	19	U.	U.	NNP
18637	5667	20	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5667	21	.	.	.
18637	5668	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5668	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5668	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5668	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5668	5	New	New	NNP
18637	5668	6	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	5668	7	,	,	,
18637	5668	8	187	187	CD
18637	5668	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5668	10	419	419	CD
18637	5668	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5668	12	1903	1903	CD
18637	5668	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5668	14	.	.	.
18637	5669	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5669	2	756	756	CD
18637	5669	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5669	4	Brimmer	Brimmer	NNP
18637	5669	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5669	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5669	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5669	8	Rebman	Rebman	NNP
18637	5669	9	,	,	,
18637	5669	10	138	138	CD
18637	5669	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5669	12	78	78	CD
18637	5669	13	,	,	,
18637	5669	14	83	83	CD
18637	5669	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5669	16	1891	1891	CD
18637	5669	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5669	18	;	;	:
18637	5669	19	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	5669	20	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5669	21	.	.	.
18637	5670	1	&	&	CC
18637	5670	2	Cable	Cable	NNP
18637	5670	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5670	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5670	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	5670	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5670	7	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	5670	8	,	,	,
18637	5670	9	192	192	CD
18637	5670	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5670	11	64	64	CD
18637	5670	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5670	13	1904	1904	CD
18637	5670	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5670	15	;	;	:
18637	5670	16	Pure	Pure	NNP
18637	5670	17	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	5670	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5670	19	_	_	NNP
18637	5670	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	5670	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5670	22	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5670	23	,	,	,
18637	5670	24	248	248	CD
18637	5670	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5670	26	158	158	CD
18637	5670	27	,	,	,
18637	5670	28	162	162	CD
18637	5670	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5670	30	1918	1918	CD
18637	5670	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5670	32	.	.	.
18637	5671	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5671	2	757	757	CD
18637	5671	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5671	4	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	5671	5	&	&	CC
18637	5671	6	P.	P.	NNP
18637	5671	7	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5671	8	.	.	.
18637	5672	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5672	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5672	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5672	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5672	5	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	5672	6	,	,	,
18637	5672	7	190	190	CD
18637	5672	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5672	9	160	160	CD
18637	5672	10	,	,	,
18637	5672	11	164	164	CD
18637	5672	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5672	13	1903	1903	CD
18637	5672	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5672	15	;	;	:
18637	5672	16	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	5672	17	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5672	18	.	.	.
18637	5673	1	Cable	Cable	NNP
18637	5673	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5673	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5673	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	5673	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5673	6	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	5673	7	,	,	,
18637	5673	8	192	192	CD
18637	5673	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5673	10	64	64	CD
18637	5673	11	,	,	,
18637	5673	12	69	69	CD
18637	5673	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5673	14	1904	1904	CD
18637	5673	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5673	16	;	;	:
18637	5673	17	Foote	Foote	NNP
18637	5673	18	&	&	CC
18637	5673	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5673	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5673	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	5673	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5673	23	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
18637	5673	24	,	,	,
18637	5673	25	232	232	CD
18637	5673	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5673	27	494	494	CD
18637	5673	28	,	,	,
18637	5673	29	503	503	CD
18637	5673	30	,	,	,
18637	5673	31	504	504	CD
18637	5673	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5673	33	1914	1914	CD
18637	5673	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5673	35	.	.	.
18637	5674	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5674	2	758	758	CD
18637	5674	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5674	4	Foote	Foote	NNP
18637	5674	5	&	&	CC
18637	5674	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5674	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5674	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5674	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5674	10	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
18637	5674	11	,	,	,
18637	5674	12	232	232	CD
18637	5674	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5674	14	494	494	CD
18637	5674	15	,	,	,
18637	5674	16	505	505	CD
18637	5674	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5674	18	1914	1914	CD
18637	5674	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5674	20	;	;	:
18637	5674	21	Lugo	Lugo	NNP
18637	5674	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5674	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	5674	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5674	25	Suazo	Suazo	NNP
18637	5674	26	,	,	,
18637	5674	27	59	59	CD
18637	5674	28	F.	F.	NNP
18637	5674	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5674	30	2d	2d	CD
18637	5674	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5674	32	386	386	CD
18637	5674	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5674	34	1932	1932	CD
18637	5674	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5674	36	.	.	.
18637	5675	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5675	2	759	759	CD
18637	5675	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5675	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5675	5	U.	U.	NNP
18637	5675	6	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5675	7	.	.	.
18637	5676	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5676	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5676	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5676	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5676	5	New	New	NNP
18637	5676	6	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	5676	7	,	,	,
18637	5676	8	187	187	CD
18637	5676	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5676	10	419	419	CD
18637	5676	11	,	,	,
18637	5676	12	425	425	CD
18637	5676	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5676	14	1903	1903	CD
18637	5676	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5676	16	;	;	:
18637	5676	17	Foote	Foote	NNP
18637	5676	18	&	&	CC
18637	5676	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5676	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5676	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	5676	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5676	23	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
18637	5676	24	,	,	,
18637	5676	25	232	232	CD
18637	5676	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5676	27	494	494	CD
18637	5676	28	,	,	,
18637	5676	29	507	507	CD
18637	5676	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5676	31	1914	1914	CD
18637	5676	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5676	33	.	.	.
18637	5677	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5677	2	760	760	CD
18637	5677	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5677	4	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	5677	5	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5677	6	.	.	.
18637	5678	1	Cable	Cable	NNP
18637	5678	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5678	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5678	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	5678	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5678	6	New	New	NNP
18637	5678	7	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	5678	8	,	,	,
18637	5678	9	192	192	CD
18637	5678	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5678	11	55	55	CD
18637	5678	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5678	13	1904	1904	CD
18637	5678	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5678	15	;	;	:
18637	5678	16	Foote	Foote	NNP
18637	5678	17	&	&	CC
18637	5678	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5678	19	_	_	NNP
18637	5678	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	5678	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5678	22	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
18637	5678	23	,	,	,
18637	5678	24	232	232	CD
18637	5678	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5678	26	494	494	CD
18637	5678	27	,	,	,
18637	5678	28	508	508	CD
18637	5678	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5678	30	1914	1914	CD
18637	5678	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5678	32	.	.	.
18637	5679	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5679	2	761	761	CD
18637	5679	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5679	4	10	10	CD
18637	5679	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5679	6	.	.	.
18637	5680	1	112	112	CD
18637	5680	2	.	.	.
18637	5681	1	Sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	5681	2	in	in	IN
18637	5681	3	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5681	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5681	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	5681	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5681	7	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	5681	8	&	&	CC
18637	5681	9	Belmont	Belmont	NNP
18637	5681	10	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	5681	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5681	12	,	,	,
18637	5681	13	18	18	CD
18637	5681	14	How	how	WRB
18637	5681	15	.	.	.
18637	5682	1	421	421	CD
18637	5682	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5682	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	5682	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5682	5	.	.	.
18637	5683	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5683	2	762	762	CD
18637	5683	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5683	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5683	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5683	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5683	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5683	8	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	5683	9	&	&	CC
18637	5683	10	Belmont	Belmont	NNP
18637	5683	11	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	5683	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5683	13	,	,	,
18637	5683	14	13	13	CD
18637	5683	15	How	how	WRB
18637	5683	16	.	.	.
18637	5684	1	518	518	CD
18637	5684	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5684	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	5684	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5684	5	.	.	.
18637	5685	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5685	2	763	763	CD
18637	5685	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5685	4	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	5685	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5685	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5685	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5685	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5685	9	Parkersburg	Parkersburg	NNP
18637	5685	10	,	,	,
18637	5685	11	107	107	CD
18637	5685	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5685	13	691	691	CD
18637	5685	14	,	,	,
18637	5685	15	701	701	CD
18637	5685	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5685	17	1883	1883	CD
18637	5685	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5685	19	.	.	.
18637	5686	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5686	2	764	764	CD
18637	5686	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5686	4	322	322	CD
18637	5686	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5686	6	533	533	CD
18637	5686	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5686	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	5686	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5686	10	.	.	.
18637	5687	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5687	2	765	765	CD
18637	5687	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5687	4	59	59	CD
18637	5687	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	5687	6	.	.	.
18637	5688	1	33	33	CD
18637	5688	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5688	3	1945	1945	CD
18637	5688	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5688	5	.	.	.
18637	5689	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5689	2	766	766	CD
18637	5689	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5689	4	328	328	CD
18637	5689	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5689	6	408	408	CD
18637	5689	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5689	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	5689	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5689	10	.	.	.
18637	5690	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5690	2	767	767	CD
18637	5690	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5690	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5690	5	.	.	.
18637	5691	1	429	429	CD
18637	5691	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5691	3	430	430	CD
18637	5691	4	,	,	,
18637	5691	5	434	434	CD
18637	5691	6	-	-	SYM
18637	5691	7	435	435	CD
18637	5691	8	.	.	.
18637	5692	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5692	2	768	768	CD
18637	5692	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5692	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5692	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5692	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5692	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	5692	8	.	.	.
18637	5693	1	163	163	CD
18637	5693	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5693	3	172	172	CD
18637	5693	4	.	.	.
18637	5694	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5694	2	769	769	CD
18637	5694	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5694	4	9	9	CD
18637	5694	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5694	6	.	.	.
18637	5695	1	1	1	CD
18637	5695	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5695	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	5695	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5695	5	.	.	.
18637	5696	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5696	2	770	770	CD
18637	5696	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5696	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5696	5	.	.	.
18637	5697	1	203	203	CD
18637	5697	2	.	.	.
18637	5698	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5698	2	771	771	CD
18637	5698	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5698	4	12	12	CD
18637	5698	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5698	6	.	.	.
18637	5699	1	419	419	CD
18637	5699	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5699	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	5699	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5699	5	.	.	.
18637	5700	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5700	2	772	772	CD
18637	5700	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5700	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5700	5	.	.	.
18637	5701	1	443	443	CD
18637	5701	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5701	3	444	444	CD
18637	5701	4	.	.	.
18637	5702	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5702	2	773	773	CD
18637	5702	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5702	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5702	5	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	5702	6	.	.	.
18637	5702	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5702	8	12	12	CD
18637	5702	9	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5702	10	.	.	.
18637	5703	1	at	at	IN
18637	5703	2	439	439	CD
18637	5703	3	-	-	SYM
18637	5703	4	440	440	CD
18637	5703	5	.	.	.
18637	5704	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5704	2	774	774	CD
18637	5704	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5704	4	11	11	CD
18637	5704	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	5704	6	.	.	.
18637	5705	1	102	102	CD
18637	5705	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5705	3	1837	1837	CD
18637	5705	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5705	5	.	.	.
18637	5706	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5706	2	775	775	CD
18637	5706	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5706	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	5706	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5706	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5706	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5706	8	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	5706	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5706	10	Passenger	Passenger	NNP
18637	5706	11	Cases	Cases	NNP
18637	5706	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5706	13	,	,	,
18637	5706	14	7	7	CD
18637	5706	15	How	how	WRB
18637	5706	16	.	.	.
18637	5707	1	283	283	CD
18637	5707	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5707	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	5707	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5707	5	.	.	.
18637	5708	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5708	2	776	776	CD
18637	5708	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5708	4	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	5708	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5708	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5708	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5708	8	New	New	NNP
18637	5708	9	York	York	NNP
18637	5708	10	,	,	,
18637	5708	11	92	92	CD
18637	5708	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5708	13	259	259	CD
18637	5708	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5708	15	1876	1876	CD
18637	5708	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5708	17	.	.	.
18637	5709	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5709	2	777	777	CD
18637	5709	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5709	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5709	5	.	.	.
18637	5710	1	272	272	CD
18637	5710	2	.	.	.
18637	5711	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5711	2	778	778	CD
18637	5711	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5711	4	Chy	Chy	NNP
18637	5711	5	Lung	Lung	NNP
18637	5711	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5711	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5711	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5711	9	Freeman	Freeman	NNP
18637	5711	10	,	,	,
18637	5711	11	92	92	CD
18637	5711	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5711	13	275	275	CD
18637	5711	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5711	15	1876	1876	CD
18637	5711	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5711	17	.	.	.
18637	5712	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5712	2	779	779	CD
18637	5712	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5712	4	Compagnie	Compagnie	NNP
18637	5712	5	Francaise	Francaise	NNP
18637	5712	6	de	de	NNP
18637	5712	7	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	5712	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5712	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5712	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5712	11	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	5712	12	.	.	.
18637	5713	1	of	of	IN
18637	5713	2	Health	Health	NNP
18637	5713	3	,	,	,
18637	5713	4	186	186	CD
18637	5713	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5713	6	380	380	CD
18637	5713	7	,	,	,
18637	5713	8	398	398	CD
18637	5713	9	,	,	,
18637	5713	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5713	11	1902	1902	CD
18637	5713	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5713	13	.	.	.
18637	5714	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5714	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5714	3	also	also	RB
18637	5714	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5714	5	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	5714	6	's	's	POS
18637	5714	7	L.	L.	NNP
18637	5714	8	&	&	CC
18637	5714	9	T.R.S.S.	T.R.S.S.	NNP
18637	5715	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5715	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5715	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5715	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5715	5	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	5715	6	.	.	.
18637	5716	1	of	of	IN
18637	5716	2	Health	Health	NNP
18637	5716	3	,	,	,
18637	5716	4	118	118	CD
18637	5716	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5716	6	455	455	CD
18637	5716	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5716	8	1886	1886	CD
18637	5716	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5716	10	;	;	:
18637	5716	11	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	5716	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5716	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	5716	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5716	15	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	5716	16	,	,	,
18637	5716	17	176	176	CD
18637	5716	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5716	19	1	1	CD
18637	5716	20	,	,	,
18637	5716	21	21	21	CD
18637	5716	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5716	23	1900	1900	CD
18637	5716	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5716	25	.	.	.
18637	5717	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5717	2	780	780	CD
18637	5717	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5717	4	211	211	CD
18637	5717	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5717	6	31	31	CD
18637	5717	7	,	,	,
18637	5717	8	36	36	CD
18637	5717	9	-	-	SYM
18637	5717	10	37	37	CD
18637	5717	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5717	12	1908	1908	CD
18637	5717	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5717	14	.	.	.
18637	5718	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5718	2	781	781	CD
18637	5718	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5718	4	As	as	IN
18637	5718	5	to	to	IN
18637	5718	6	concessions	concession	NNS
18637	5718	7	by	by	IN
18637	5718	8	the	the	DT
18637	5718	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5718	10	to	to	IN
18637	5718	11	the	the	DT
18637	5718	12	practical	practical	JJ
18637	5718	13	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	5718	14	of	of	IN
18637	5718	15	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	5718	16	,	,	,
18637	5718	17	_	_	NNP
18637	5718	18	see	see	VBP
18637	5718	19	also	also	RB
18637	5718	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5718	21	Bayside	Bayside	NNP
18637	5718	22	Fish	Fish	NNP
18637	5718	23	Flour	Flour	NNP
18637	5718	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5718	25	_	_	NNP
18637	5718	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	5718	27	_	_	NNP
18637	5718	28	Gentry	Gentry	NNP
18637	5718	29	,	,	,
18637	5718	30	297	297	CD
18637	5718	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5718	32	422	422	CD
18637	5718	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5718	34	1936	1936	CD
18637	5718	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5718	36	;	;	:
18637	5718	37	and	and	CC
18637	5718	38	Whitfield	Whitfield	NNP
18637	5718	39	_	_	NNP
18637	5718	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	5718	41	_	_	NNP
18637	5718	42	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	5718	43	,	,	,
18637	5718	44	297	297	CD
18637	5718	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5718	46	431	431	CD
18637	5718	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5718	48	1936	1936	CD
18637	5718	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5718	50	.	.	.
18637	5719	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5719	2	782	782	CD
18637	5719	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5719	4	325	325	CD
18637	5719	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5719	6	761	761	CD
18637	5719	7	,	,	,
18637	5719	8	766	766	CD
18637	5719	9	-	-	SYM
18637	5719	10	767	767	CD
18637	5719	11	.	.	.
18637	5720	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5720	2	783	783	CD
18637	5720	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5720	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5720	5	.	.	.
18637	5721	1	767	767	CD
18637	5721	2	;	;	:
18637	5721	3	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5721	4	:	:	:
18637	5721	5	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5721	6	Rate	Rate	NNP
18637	5721	7	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	5721	8	,	,	,
18637	5721	9	230	230	CD
18637	5721	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5721	11	352	352	CD
18637	5721	12	,	,	,
18637	5721	13	399	399	CD
18637	5721	14	,	,	,
18637	5721	15	400	400	CD
18637	5721	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5721	17	1913	1913	CD
18637	5721	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5721	19	;	;	:
18637	5721	20	South	South	NNP
18637	5721	21	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	5721	22	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	5721	23	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	5721	24	.	.	.
18637	5722	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5722	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5722	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5722	4	Barnwell	Barnwell	NNP
18637	5722	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	5722	6	,	,	,
18637	5722	7	303	303	CD
18637	5722	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5722	9	177	177	CD
18637	5722	10	,	,	,
18637	5722	11	187	187	CD
18637	5722	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5722	13	1938	1938	CD
18637	5722	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5722	15	,	,	,
18637	5722	16	et	et	NN
18637	5722	17	seq	seq	NN
18637	5722	18	.	.	.
18637	5723	1	;	;	:
18637	5723	2	California	California	NNP
18637	5723	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5723	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	5723	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5723	6	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	5723	7	,	,	,
18637	5723	8	313	313	CD
18637	5723	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5723	10	109	109	CD
18637	5723	11	,	,	,
18637	5723	12	113	113	CD
18637	5723	13	,	,	,
18637	5723	14	114	114	CD
18637	5723	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5723	16	1941	1941	CD
18637	5723	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5723	18	and	and	CC
18637	5723	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	5723	20	cited	cite	VBD
18637	5723	21	;	;	:
18637	5723	22	Parker	Parker	NNP
18637	5723	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5723	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	5723	25	_	_	NNP
18637	5723	26	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	5723	27	,	,	,
18637	5723	28	317	317	CD
18637	5723	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5723	30	341	341	CD
18637	5723	31	,	,	,
18637	5723	32	359	359	CD
18637	5723	33	,	,	,
18637	5723	34	360	360	CD
18637	5723	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5723	36	1943	1943	CD
18637	5723	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5723	38	.	.	.
18637	5724	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5724	2	784	784	CD
18637	5724	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5724	4	325	325	CD
18637	5724	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5724	6	at	at	IN
18637	5724	7	767	767	CD
18637	5724	8	;	;	:
18637	5724	9	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5724	10	:	:	:
18637	5724	11	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	5724	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5724	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	5724	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5724	15	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5724	16	of	of	IN
18637	5724	17	Wardens	Wardens	NNP
18637	5724	18	,	,	,
18637	5724	19	12	12	CD
18637	5724	20	How	how	WRB
18637	5724	21	.	.	.
18637	5725	1	at	at	IN
18637	5725	2	319	319	CD
18637	5725	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5725	4	1851	1851	CD
18637	5725	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5725	6	;	;	:
18637	5725	7	South	South	NNP
18637	5725	8	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	5725	9	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	5725	10	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	5725	11	.	.	.
18637	5726	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5726	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5726	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5726	4	Barnwell	Barnwell	NNP
18637	5726	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	5726	6	,	,	,
18637	5726	7	303	303	CD
18637	5726	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5726	9	at	at	IN
18637	5726	10	185	185	CD
18637	5726	11	;	;	:
18637	5726	12	California	California	NNP
18637	5726	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5726	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	5726	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5726	16	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	5726	17	,	,	,
18637	5726	18	313	313	CD
18637	5726	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5726	20	at	at	IN
18637	5726	21	113	113	CD
18637	5726	22	;	;	:
18637	5726	23	Duckworth	Duckworth	NNP
18637	5726	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5726	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	5726	26	_	_	NNP
18637	5726	27	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	5726	28	,	,	,
18637	5726	29	314	314	CD
18637	5726	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5726	31	390	390	CD
18637	5726	32	,	,	,
18637	5726	33	394	394	CD
18637	5726	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5726	35	1941	1941	CD
18637	5726	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5726	37	;	;	:
18637	5726	38	Parker	Parker	NNP
18637	5726	39	_	_	NNP
18637	5726	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	5726	41	_	_	NNP
18637	5726	42	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	5726	43	,	,	,
18637	5726	44	317	317	CD
18637	5726	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5726	46	at	at	IN
18637	5726	47	362	362	CD
18637	5726	48	,	,	,
18637	5726	49	363	363	CD
18637	5726	50	.	.	.
18637	5727	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5727	2	785	785	CD
18637	5727	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5727	4	325	325	CD
18637	5727	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5727	6	at	at	IN
18637	5727	7	767	767	CD
18637	5727	8	;	;	:
18637	5727	9	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5727	10	:	:	:
18637	5727	11	South	South	NNP
18637	5727	12	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	5727	13	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	5727	14	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	5727	15	.	.	.
18637	5728	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5728	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5728	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5728	4	Barnwell	Barnwell	NNP
18637	5728	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	5728	6	,	,	,
18637	5728	7	303	303	CD
18637	5728	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5728	9	at	at	IN
18637	5728	10	188	188	CD
18637	5728	11	and	and	CC
18637	5728	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	5728	13	cited	cite	VBN
18637	5728	14	;	;	:
18637	5728	15	Lone	Lone	NNP
18637	5728	16	Star	Star	NNP
18637	5728	17	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5728	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5728	19	_	_	NNP
18637	5728	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	5728	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5728	22	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	5728	23	,	,	,
18637	5728	24	304	304	CD
18637	5728	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5728	26	224	224	CD
18637	5728	27	,	,	,
18637	5728	28	238	238	CD
18637	5728	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5728	30	1938	1938	CD
18637	5728	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5728	32	;	;	:
18637	5728	33	Milk	Milk	NNP
18637	5728	34	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5728	35	_	_	NNP
18637	5728	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	5728	37	_	_	NNP
18637	5728	38	Eisenberg	Eisenberg	NNP
18637	5728	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5728	40	,	,	,
18637	5728	41	306	306	CD
18637	5728	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5728	43	346	346	CD
18637	5728	44	,	,	,
18637	5728	45	351	351	CD
18637	5728	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5728	47	1939	1939	CD
18637	5728	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5728	49	;	;	:
18637	5728	50	Maurer	Maurer	NNP
18637	5728	51	_	_	NNP
18637	5728	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	5728	53	_	_	NNP
18637	5728	54	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	5728	55	,	,	,
18637	5728	56	309	309	CD
18637	5728	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5728	58	598	598	CD
18637	5728	59	,	,	,
18637	5728	60	603	603	CD
18637	5728	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5728	62	1940	1940	CD
18637	5728	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5728	64	;	;	:
18637	5728	65	California	California	NNP
18637	5728	66	_	_	NNP
18637	5728	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	5728	68	_	_	NNP
18637	5728	69	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	5728	70	,	,	,
18637	5728	71	313	313	CD
18637	5728	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5728	73	113	113	CD
18637	5728	74	,	,	,
18637	5728	75	114	114	CD
18637	5728	76	and	and	CC
18637	5728	77	cases	case	NNS
18637	5728	78	cited	cite	VBD
18637	5728	79	.	.	.
18637	5729	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5729	2	786	786	CD
18637	5729	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5729	4	325	325	CD
18637	5729	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5729	6	at	at	IN
18637	5729	7	767	767	CD
18637	5729	8	,	,	,
18637	5729	9	768	768	CD
18637	5729	10	;	;	:
18637	5729	11	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5729	12	:	:	:
18637	5729	13	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	5729	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5729	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	5729	16	_	_	NNP
18637	5729	17	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5729	18	of	of	IN
18637	5729	19	Wardens	Wardens	NNP
18637	5729	20	,	,	,
18637	5729	21	12	12	CD
18637	5729	22	How	how	WRB
18637	5729	23	.	.	.
18637	5730	1	at	at	IN
18637	5730	2	319	319	CD
18637	5730	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5730	4	1851	1851	CD
18637	5730	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5730	6	;	;	:
18637	5730	7	Leisy	Leisy	NNP
18637	5730	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5730	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5730	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5730	11	Hardin	Hardin	NNP
18637	5730	12	,	,	,
18637	5730	13	135	135	CD
18637	5730	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5730	15	100	100	CD
18637	5730	16	,	,	,
18637	5730	17	108	108	CD
18637	5730	18	,	,	,
18637	5730	19	109	109	CD
18637	5730	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5730	21	1890	1890	CD
18637	5730	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5730	23	;	;	:
18637	5730	24	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5730	25	Rate	Rate	NNP
18637	5730	26	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	5730	27	,	,	,
18637	5730	28	230	230	CD
18637	5730	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5730	30	at	at	IN
18637	5730	31	399	399	CD
18637	5730	32	,	,	,
18637	5730	33	400	400	CD
18637	5730	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5730	35	1913	1913	CD
18637	5730	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5730	37	;	;	:
18637	5730	38	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	5730	39	_	_	NNP
18637	5730	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	5730	41	_	_	NNP
18637	5730	42	California	California	NNP
18637	5730	43	,	,	,
18637	5730	44	314	314	CD
18637	5730	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5730	46	160	160	CD
18637	5730	47	,	,	,
18637	5730	48	176	176	CD
18637	5730	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5730	50	1941	1941	CD
18637	5730	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5730	52	.	.	.
18637	5731	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5731	2	787	787	CD
18637	5731	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5731	4	325	325	CD
18637	5731	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5731	6	at	at	IN
18637	5731	7	768	768	CD
18637	5731	8	;	;	:
18637	5731	9	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5731	10	:	:	:
18637	5731	11	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	5731	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5731	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	5731	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5731	15	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	5731	16	,	,	,
18637	5731	17	12	12	CD
18637	5731	18	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5731	19	.	.	.
18637	5732	1	419	419	CD
18637	5732	2	,	,	,
18637	5732	3	447	447	CD
18637	5732	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5732	5	1827	1827	CD
18637	5732	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5732	7	;	;	:
18637	5732	8	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5732	9	Rate	Rate	NNP
18637	5732	10	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	5732	11	,	,	,
18637	5732	12	230	230	CD
18637	5732	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5732	14	at	at	IN
18637	5732	15	399	399	CD
18637	5732	16	,	,	,
18637	5732	17	400	400	CD
18637	5732	18	;	;	:
18637	5732	19	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5732	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5732	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	5732	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5732	23	West	West	NNP
18637	5732	24	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	5732	25	,	,	,
18637	5732	26	262	262	CD
18637	5732	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5732	28	553	553	CD
18637	5732	29	,	,	,
18637	5732	30	596	596	CD
18637	5732	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5732	32	1923	1923	CD
18637	5732	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5732	34	;	;	:
18637	5732	35	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	5732	36	_	_	NNP
18637	5732	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	5732	38	_	_	NNP
18637	5732	39	Seelig	Seelig	NNP
18637	5732	40	,	,	,
18637	5732	41	294	294	CD
18637	5732	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5732	43	511	511	CD
18637	5732	44	,	,	,
18637	5732	45	522	522	CD
18637	5732	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5732	47	1935	1935	CD
18637	5732	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5732	49	;	;	:
18637	5732	50	South	South	NNP
18637	5732	51	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	5732	52	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	5732	53	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	5732	54	.	.	.
18637	5733	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5733	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5733	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5733	4	Barnwell	Barnwell	NNP
18637	5733	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	5733	6	,	,	,
18637	5733	7	303	303	CD
18637	5733	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5733	9	at	at	IN
18637	5733	10	185	185	CD
18637	5733	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5733	12	1938	1938	CD
18637	5733	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5733	14	.	.	.
18637	5734	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5734	2	788	788	CD
18637	5734	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5734	4	325	325	CD
18637	5734	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5734	6	at	at	IN
18637	5734	7	768	768	CD
18637	5734	8	;	;	:
18637	5734	9	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5734	10	:	:	:
18637	5734	11	Welton	Welton	NNP
18637	5734	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5734	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	5734	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5734	15	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	5734	16	,	,	,
18637	5734	17	91	91	CD
18637	5734	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5734	19	275	275	CD
18637	5734	20	,	,	,
18637	5734	21	282	282	CD
18637	5734	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5734	23	1876	1876	CD
18637	5734	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5734	25	;	;	:
18637	5734	26	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	5734	27	_	_	NNP
18637	5734	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	5734	29	_	_	NNP
18637	5734	30	DeCuir	DeCuir	NNP
18637	5734	31	,	,	,
18637	5734	32	95	95	CD
18637	5734	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5734	34	485	485	CD
18637	5734	35	,	,	,
18637	5734	36	490	490	CD
18637	5734	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5734	38	1878	1878	CD
18637	5734	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5734	40	;	;	:
18637	5734	41	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	5734	42	_	_	NNP
18637	5734	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	5734	44	_	_	NNP
18637	5734	45	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	5734	46	,	,	,
18637	5734	47	114	114	CD
18637	5734	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5734	49	622	622	CD
18637	5734	50	,	,	,
18637	5734	51	631	631	CD
18637	5734	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5734	53	1885	1885	CD
18637	5734	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5734	55	;	;	:
18637	5734	56	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	5734	57	_	_	NNP
18637	5734	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	5734	59	_	_	NNP
18637	5734	60	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	5734	61	&	&	CC
18637	5734	62	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	5735	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5735	2	,	,	,
18637	5735	3	125	125	CD
18637	5735	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5735	5	465	465	CD
18637	5735	6	,	,	,
18637	5735	7	481	481	CD
18637	5735	8	,	,	,
18637	5735	9	482	482	CD
18637	5735	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5735	11	1888	1888	CD
18637	5735	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5735	13	;	;	:
18637	5735	14	Leisy	Leisy	NNP
18637	5735	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5735	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	5735	17	_	_	NNP
18637	5735	18	Hardin	Hardin	NNP
18637	5735	19	,	,	,
18637	5735	20	135	135	CD
18637	5735	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5735	22	at	at	IN
18637	5735	23	109	109	CD
18637	5735	24	;	;	:
18637	5735	25	In	in	IN
18637	5735	26	re	re	NN
18637	5735	27	Rahrer	Rahrer	NNP
18637	5735	28	,	,	,
18637	5735	29	140	140	CD
18637	5735	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5735	31	545	545	CD
18637	5735	32	,	,	,
18637	5735	33	559	559	CD
18637	5735	34	,	,	,
18637	5735	35	560	560	CD
18637	5735	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5735	37	1891	1891	CD
18637	5735	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5735	39	;	;	:
18637	5735	40	Brennan	Brennan	NNP
18637	5735	41	_	_	NNP
18637	5735	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	5735	43	_	_	NNP
18637	5735	44	Titusville	Titusville	NNP
18637	5735	45	,	,	,
18637	5735	46	153	153	CD
18637	5735	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5735	48	289	289	CD
18637	5735	49	,	,	,
18637	5735	50	302	302	CD
18637	5735	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5735	52	1894	1894	CD
18637	5735	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5735	54	;	;	:
18637	5735	55	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	5735	56	&	&	CC
18637	5735	57	C.	C.	NNP
18637	5735	58	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	5735	59	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5735	60	_	_	NNP
18637	5735	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	5735	62	_	_	NNP
18637	5735	63	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5735	64	,	,	,
18637	5735	65	154	154	CD
18637	5735	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5735	67	204	204	CD
18637	5735	68	,	,	,
18637	5735	69	212	212	CD
18637	5735	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5735	71	1894	1894	CD
18637	5735	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5735	73	;	;	:
18637	5735	74	Graves	Graves	NNPS
18637	5735	75	_	_	NNP
18637	5735	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	5735	77	_	_	NNP
18637	5735	78	New	New	NNP
18637	5735	79	York	York	NNP
18637	5735	80	ex	ex	NNP
18637	5735	81	rel	rel	NN
18637	5735	82	.	.	.
18637	5736	1	O'Keefe	O'Keefe	NNP
18637	5736	2	,	,	,
18637	5736	3	306	306	CD
18637	5736	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5736	5	466	466	CD
18637	5736	6	,	,	,
18637	5736	7	479	479	CD
18637	5736	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5736	9	1939	1939	CD
18637	5736	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5736	11	;	;	:
18637	5736	12	Dowling	Dowling	NNP
18637	5736	13	,	,	,
18637	5736	14	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	5736	15	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	5736	16	and	and	CC
18637	5736	17	State	State	NNP
18637	5736	18	Power	Power	NNP
18637	5736	19	,	,	,
18637	5736	20	27	27	CD
18637	5736	21	Va.	Virginia	NNP
18637	5736	22	Law	Law	NNP
18637	5736	23	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	5737	1	1	1	CD
18637	5737	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5737	3	1940	1940	CD
18637	5737	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5737	5	.	.	.
18637	5738	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5738	2	789	789	CD
18637	5738	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5738	4	325	325	CD
18637	5738	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5738	6	at	at	IN
18637	5738	7	769	769	CD
18637	5738	8	;	;	:
18637	5738	9	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5738	10	:	:	:
18637	5738	11	Parker	Parker	NNP
18637	5738	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5738	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	5738	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5738	15	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	5738	16	.	.	.
18637	5739	1	317	317	CD
18637	5739	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5739	3	at	at	IN
18637	5739	4	362	362	CD
18637	5739	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5739	6	1943	1943	CD
18637	5739	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5739	8	;	;	:
18637	5739	9	Terminal	Terminal	NNP
18637	5739	10	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	5739	11	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	5739	12	.	.	.
18637	5740	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5740	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5740	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5740	4	Brotherhood	Brotherhood	NNP
18637	5740	5	,	,	,
18637	5740	6	318	318	CD
18637	5740	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5740	8	1	1	CD
18637	5740	9	,	,	,
18637	5740	10	8	8	CD
18637	5740	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5740	12	1943	1943	CD
18637	5740	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5740	14	;	;	:
18637	5740	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5740	16	see	see	VB
18637	5740	17	_	_	NNP
18637	5740	18	Di	Di	NNP
18637	5740	19	Santo	Santo	NNP
18637	5740	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5740	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	5740	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5740	23	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5740	24	,	,	,
18637	5740	25	273	273	CD
18637	5740	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5740	27	34	34	CD
18637	5740	28	,	,	,
18637	5740	29	44	44	CD
18637	5740	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5740	31	1927	1927	CD
18637	5740	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5740	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5740	34	and	and	CC
18637	5740	35	compare	compare	VB
18637	5740	36	California	California	NNP
18637	5740	37	_	_	NNP
18637	5740	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	5740	39	_	_	NNP
18637	5740	40	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	5740	41	,	,	,
18637	5740	42	313	313	CD
18637	5740	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5740	44	109	109	CD
18637	5740	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5740	46	1941	1941	CD
18637	5740	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5740	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5740	49	;	;	:
18637	5740	50	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5740	51	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5740	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5740	53	_	_	NNP
18637	5740	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	5740	55	_	_	NNP
18637	5740	56	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5740	57	Service	Service	NNP
18637	5740	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5740	59	,	,	,
18637	5740	60	314	314	CD
18637	5740	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5740	62	498	498	CD
18637	5740	63	,	,	,
18637	5740	64	504	504	CD
18637	5740	65	,	,	,
18637	5740	66	505	505	CD
18637	5740	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5740	68	1942	1942	CD
18637	5740	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5740	70	.	.	.
18637	5741	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5741	2	790	790	CD
18637	5741	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5741	4	325	325	CD
18637	5741	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5741	6	at	at	IN
18637	5741	7	769	769	CD
18637	5741	8	;	;	:
18637	5741	9	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5741	10	:	:	:
18637	5741	11	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	5741	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5741	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	5741	14	_	_	NNP
18637	5741	15	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5741	16	of	of	IN
18637	5741	17	Wardens	Wardens	NNP
18637	5741	18	,	,	,
18637	5741	19	12	12	CD
18637	5741	20	How	how	WRB
18637	5741	21	.	.	.
18637	5742	1	299	299	CD
18637	5742	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5742	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	5742	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5742	5	;	;	:
18637	5742	6	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	5742	7	City	City	NNP
18637	5742	8	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	5742	9	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5742	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5742	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5742	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	5742	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5742	14	Kaw	Kaw	NNP
18637	5742	15	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	5742	16	District	District	NNP
18637	5742	17	,	,	,
18637	5742	18	233	233	CD
18637	5742	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5742	20	75	75	CD
18637	5742	21	,	,	,
18637	5742	22	79	79	CD
18637	5742	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5742	24	1914	1914	CD
18637	5742	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5742	26	;	;	:
18637	5742	27	South	South	NNP
18637	5742	28	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	5742	29	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5742	30	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5742	31	_	_	NNP
18637	5742	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	5742	33	_	_	NNP
18637	5742	34	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	5742	35	,	,	,
18637	5742	36	235	235	CD
18637	5742	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5742	38	537	537	CD
18637	5742	39	,	,	,
18637	5742	40	546	546	CD
18637	5742	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5742	42	1915	1915	CD
18637	5742	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5742	44	;	;	:
18637	5742	45	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	5742	46	,	,	,
18637	5742	47	K.	K.	NNP
18637	5742	48	&	&	CC
18637	5742	49	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	5743	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5743	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5743	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5743	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5743	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	5743	6	,	,	,
18637	5743	7	245	245	CD
18637	5743	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5743	9	484	484	CD
18637	5743	10	,	,	,
18637	5743	11	488	488	CD
18637	5743	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5743	13	1918	1918	CD
18637	5743	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5743	15	;	;	:
18637	5743	16	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5743	17	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	5743	18	&	&	CC
18637	5743	19	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	5744	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5744	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5744	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5744	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5744	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5744	6	Service	Service	NNP
18637	5744	7	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	5744	8	.	.	.
18637	5744	9	,	,	,
18637	5744	10	254	254	CD
18637	5744	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5744	12	535	535	CD
18637	5744	13	,	,	,
18637	5744	14	537	537	CD
18637	5744	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5744	16	1921	1921	CD
18637	5744	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5744	18	:	:	:
18637	5744	19	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	5744	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	5744	21	Fountain	Fountain	NNP
18637	5744	22	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	5744	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5744	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5744	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	5744	26	_	_	NNP
18637	5744	27	Haydel	Haydel	NNP
18637	5744	28	,	,	,
18637	5744	29	278	278	CD
18637	5744	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5744	31	1	1	CD
18637	5744	32	,	,	,
18637	5744	33	10	10	CD
18637	5744	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5744	35	1928	1928	CD
18637	5744	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5744	37	;	;	:
18637	5744	38	Gwin	Gwin	NNP
18637	5744	39	,	,	,
18637	5744	40	White	White	NNP
18637	5744	41	&	&	CC
18637	5744	42	Prince	Prince	NNP
18637	5744	43	_	_	NNP
18637	5744	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	5744	45	_	_	NNP
18637	5744	46	Henneford	Henneford	NNP
18637	5744	47	,	,	,
18637	5744	48	305	305	CD
18637	5744	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5744	50	434	434	CD
18637	5744	51	,	,	,
18637	5744	52	441	441	CD
18637	5744	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5744	54	1939	1939	CD
18637	5744	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5744	56	;	;	:
18637	5744	57	McCarroll	McCarroll	NNP
18637	5744	58	_	_	NNP
18637	5744	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	5744	60	_	_	NNP
18637	5744	61	Dixie	Dixie	NNP
18637	5744	62	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	5744	63	,	,	,
18637	5744	64	309	309	CD
18637	5744	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5744	66	176	176	CD
18637	5744	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5744	68	1940	1940	CD
18637	5744	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5744	70	.	.	.
18637	5745	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5745	2	791	791	CD
18637	5745	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5745	4	325	325	CD
18637	5745	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5745	6	at	at	IN
18637	5745	7	769	769	CD
18637	5745	8	;	;	:
18637	5745	9	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5745	10	:	:	:
18637	5745	11	In	in	IN
18637	5745	12	re	re	NNP
18637	5745	13	Rahrer	Rahrer	NNP
18637	5745	14	,	,	,
18637	5745	15	140	140	CD
18637	5745	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5745	17	at	at	IN
18637	5745	18	561	561	CD
18637	5745	19	,	,	,
18637	5745	20	562	562	CD
18637	5745	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5745	22	1891	1891	CD
18637	5745	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5745	24	;	;	:
18637	5745	25	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	5745	26	Express	Express	NNP
18637	5745	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5745	28	_	_	NNP
18637	5745	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	5745	30	_	_	NNP
18637	5745	31	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5745	32	,	,	,
18637	5745	33	238	238	CD
18637	5745	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5745	35	190	190	CD
18637	5745	36	,	,	,
18637	5745	37	198	198	CD
18637	5745	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5745	39	1915	1915	CD
18637	5745	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5745	41	;	;	:
18637	5745	42	Rosenberger	Rosenberger	NNP
18637	5745	43	_	_	NNP
18637	5745	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	5745	45	_	_	NNP
18637	5745	46	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	5745	47	Express	Express	NNP
18637	5745	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5745	49	,	,	,
18637	5745	50	241	241	CD
18637	5745	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5745	52	48	48	CD
18637	5745	53	,	,	,
18637	5745	54	50	50	CD
18637	5745	55	,	,	,
18637	5745	56	51	51	CD
18637	5745	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5745	58	1916	1916	CD
18637	5745	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5745	60	;	;	:
18637	5745	61	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	5745	62	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	5745	63	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5745	64	_	_	NNP
18637	5745	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	5745	66	_	_	NNP
18637	5745	67	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5745	68	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	5745	69	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5745	70	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5745	71	,	,	,
18637	5745	72	242	242	CD
18637	5745	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5745	74	311	311	CD
18637	5745	75	,	,	,
18637	5745	76	325	325	CD
18637	5745	77	,	,	,
18637	5745	78	326	326	CD
18637	5745	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5745	80	1917	1917	CD
18637	5745	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5745	82	;	;	:
18637	5745	83	Whitfield	Whitfield	NNP
18637	5745	84	_	_	NNP
18637	5745	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	5745	86	_	_	NNP
18637	5745	87	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	5745	88	,	,	,
18637	5745	89	297	297	CD
18637	5745	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5745	91	431	431	CD
18637	5745	92	,	,	,
18637	5745	93	438	438	CD
18637	5745	94	-	-	SYM
18637	5745	95	440	440	CD
18637	5745	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5745	97	1936	1936	CD
18637	5745	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5745	99	;	;	:
18637	5745	100	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5745	101	Whip	Whip	NNP
18637	5745	102	&	&	CC
18637	5745	103	Collar	Collar	NNP
18637	5745	104	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5745	105	_	_	NNP
18637	5745	106	v.	v.	IN
18637	5745	107	_	_	NNP
18637	5745	108	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5745	109	Central	Central	NNP
18637	5745	110	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5745	111	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5745	112	,	,	,
18637	5745	113	299	299	CD
18637	5745	114	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5745	115	334	334	CD
18637	5745	116	,	,	,
18637	5745	117	350	350	CD
18637	5745	118	,	,	,
18637	5745	119	351	351	CD
18637	5745	120	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5745	121	1937	1937	CD
18637	5745	122	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5745	123	;	;	:
18637	5745	124	Hooven	Hooven	NNP
18637	5745	125	&	&	CC
18637	5745	126	Allison	Allison	NNP
18637	5745	127	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5745	128	_	_	NNP
18637	5745	129	v.	v.	IN
18637	5745	130	_	_	NNP
18637	5745	131	Evatt	Evatt	NNP
18637	5745	132	,	,	,
18637	5745	133	324	324	CD
18637	5745	134	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5745	135	652	652	CD
18637	5745	136	,	,	,
18637	5745	137	679	679	CD
18637	5745	138	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5745	139	1945	1945	CD
18637	5745	140	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5745	141	.	.	.
18637	5746	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5746	2	792	792	CD
18637	5746	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5746	4	325	325	CD
18637	5746	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5746	6	at	at	IN
18637	5746	7	769	769	CD
18637	5746	8	,	,	,
18637	5746	9	770	770	CD
18637	5746	10	;	;	:
18637	5746	11	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5746	12	:	:	:
18637	5746	13	Addyston	Addyston	NNP
18637	5746	14	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	5746	15	&	&	CC
18637	5746	16	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	5746	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5746	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5746	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	5746	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5746	21	United	United	NNP
18637	5746	22	States	States	NNP
18637	5746	23	,	,	,
18637	5746	24	175	175	CD
18637	5746	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5746	26	211	211	CD
18637	5746	27	,	,	,
18637	5746	28	230	230	CD
18637	5746	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5746	30	1899	1899	CD
18637	5746	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5746	32	;	;	:
18637	5746	33	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	5746	34	&	&	CC
18637	5746	35	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	5746	36	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5746	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5746	38	_	_	NNP
18637	5746	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	5746	40	_	_	NNP
18637	5746	41	Mottley	Mottley	NNP
18637	5746	42	,	,	,
18637	5746	43	219	219	CD
18637	5746	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5746	45	467	467	CD
18637	5746	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5746	47	1911	1911	CD
18637	5746	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5746	49	;	;	:
18637	5746	50	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	5746	51	,	,	,
18637	5746	52	E.	E.	NNP
18637	5746	53	&	&	CC
18637	5746	54	W.T.R.	W.T.R.	NNP
18637	5747	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5747	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5747	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5747	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5747	5	United	United	NNP
18637	5747	6	States	States	NNP
18637	5747	7	,	,	,
18637	5747	8	234	234	CD
18637	5747	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5747	10	342	342	CD
18637	5747	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5747	12	1914	1914	CD
18637	5747	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5747	14	;	;	:
18637	5747	15	American	American	NNP
18637	5747	16	Express	Express	NNP
18637	5747	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5747	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5747	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	5747	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5747	21	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	5747	22	,	,	,
18637	5747	23	244	244	CD
18637	5747	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5747	25	617	617	CD
18637	5747	26	,	,	,
18637	5747	27	626	626	CD
18637	5747	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5747	29	1917	1917	CD
18637	5747	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5747	31	;	;	:
18637	5747	32	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5747	33	Central	Central	NNP
18637	5747	34	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5747	35	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5747	36	_	_	NNP
18637	5747	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	5747	38	_	_	NNP
18637	5747	39	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5747	40	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	5747	41	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	5747	42	.	.	.
18637	5747	43	,	,	,
18637	5747	44	245	245	CD
18637	5747	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5747	46	493	493	CD
18637	5747	47	,	,	,
18637	5747	48	506	506	CD
18637	5747	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5747	50	1918	1918	CD
18637	5747	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5747	52	;	;	:
18637	5747	53	New	New	NNP
18637	5747	54	York	York	NNP
18637	5747	55	_	_	NNP
18637	5747	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	5747	57	_	_	NNP
18637	5747	58	United	United	NNP
18637	5747	59	States	States	NNP
18637	5747	60	,	,	,
18637	5747	61	257	257	CD
18637	5747	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5747	63	591	591	CD
18637	5747	64	,	,	,
18637	5747	65	601	601	CD
18637	5747	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5747	67	1922	1922	CD
18637	5747	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5747	69	;	;	:
18637	5747	70	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	5747	71	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5747	72	Service	Service	NNP
18637	5747	73	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	5747	74	.	.	.
18637	5748	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5748	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5748	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5748	4	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	5748	5	&	&	CC
18637	5748	6	N.O.R.	N.O.R.	NNP
18637	5749	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5749	2	,	,	,
18637	5749	3	284	284	CD
18637	5749	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5749	5	125	125	CD
18637	5749	6	,	,	,
18637	5749	7	130	130	CD
18637	5749	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5749	9	1931	1931	CD
18637	5749	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5749	11	;	;	:
18637	5749	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5749	13	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5749	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5749	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5749	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	5749	17	_	_	NNP
18637	5749	18	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5749	19	Brick	Brick	NNP
18637	5749	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5749	21	,	,	,
18637	5749	22	297	297	CD
18637	5749	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5749	24	447	447	CD
18637	5749	25	,	,	,
18637	5749	26	459	459	CD
18637	5749	27	,	,	,
18637	5749	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5749	29	1936	1936	CD
18637	5749	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5749	31	.	.	.
18637	5750	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5750	2	793	793	CD
18637	5750	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5750	4	325	325	CD
18637	5750	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5750	6	at	at	IN
18637	5750	7	770	770	CD
18637	5750	8	;	;	:
18637	5750	9	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5750	10	:	:	:
18637	5750	11	Gwin	Gwin	NNP
18637	5750	12	,	,	,
18637	5750	13	White	White	NNP
18637	5750	14	&	&	CC
18637	5750	15	Prince	Prince	NNP
18637	5750	16	_	_	NNP
18637	5750	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	5750	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5750	19	Henneford	Henneford	NNP
18637	5750	20	,	,	,
18637	5750	21	305	305	CD
18637	5750	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5750	23	434	434	CD
18637	5750	24	,	,	,
18637	5750	25	441	441	CD
18637	5750	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5750	27	1939	1939	CD
18637	5750	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5750	29	.	.	.
18637	5751	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5751	2	794	794	CD
18637	5751	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5751	4	325	325	CD
18637	5751	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5751	6	at	at	IN
18637	5751	7	770	770	CD
18637	5751	8	;	;	:
18637	5751	9	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5751	10	:	:	:
18637	5751	11	Terminal	Terminal	NNP
18637	5751	12	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	5751	13	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	5751	14	.	.	.
18637	5752	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5752	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5752	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5752	4	Brotherhood	Brotherhood	NNP
18637	5752	5	,	,	,
18637	5752	6	318	318	CD
18637	5752	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5752	8	1	1	CD
18637	5752	9	,	,	,
18637	5752	10	8	8	CD
18637	5752	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5752	12	1943	1943	CD
18637	5752	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5752	14	;	;	:
18637	5752	15	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	5752	16	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5752	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5752	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5752	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	5752	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5752	21	King	King	NNP
18637	5752	22	,	,	,
18637	5752	23	217	217	CD
18637	5752	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5752	25	524	524	CD
18637	5752	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5752	27	1910	1910	CD
18637	5752	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5752	29	.	.	.
18637	5753	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5753	2	795	795	CD
18637	5753	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5753	4	Peik	Peik	NNP
18637	5753	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5753	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5753	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5753	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	5753	9	&	&	CC
18637	5753	10	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	5754	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5754	2	,	,	,
18637	5754	3	94	94	CD
18637	5754	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5754	5	164	164	CD
18637	5754	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5754	7	1877	1877	CD
18637	5754	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5754	9	.	.	.
18637	5755	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5755	2	796	796	CD
18637	5755	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5755	4	Wabash	Wabash	NNP
18637	5755	5	,	,	,
18637	5755	6	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5755	7	L.	L.	NNP
18637	5755	8	&	&	CC
18637	5755	9	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	5756	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5756	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5756	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5756	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5756	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5756	6	,	,	,
18637	5756	7	118	118	CD
18637	5756	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5756	9	557	557	CD
18637	5756	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5756	11	1886	1886	CD
18637	5756	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5756	13	.	.	.
18637	5757	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5757	2	797	797	CD
18637	5757	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5757	4	24	24	CD
18637	5757	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	5757	6	.	.	.
18637	5758	1	379	379	CD
18637	5758	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5758	3	1887	1887	CD
18637	5758	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5758	5	.	.	.
18637	5759	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5759	2	798	798	CD
18637	5759	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5759	4	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	5759	5	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	5759	6	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5759	7	.	.	.
18637	5760	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5760	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5760	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5760	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	5760	5	,	,	,
18637	5760	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	5761	1	&	&	CC
18637	5761	2	Q.R.R.	Q.R.R.	NNP
18637	5762	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5762	2	,	,	,
18637	5762	3	257	257	CD
18637	5762	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5762	5	563	563	CD
18637	5762	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5762	7	1922	1922	CD
18637	5762	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5762	9	.	.	.
18637	5763	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5763	2	799	799	CD
18637	5763	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5763	4	Gladson	Gladson	NNP
18637	5763	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5763	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5763	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5763	8	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5763	9	,	,	,
18637	5763	10	166	166	CD
18637	5763	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5763	12	427	427	CD
18637	5763	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5763	14	1897	1897	CD
18637	5763	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5763	16	;	;	:
18637	5763	17	followed	follow	VBN
18637	5763	18	in	in	IN
18637	5763	19	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	5763	20	Shore	Shore	NNP
18637	5763	21	&	&	CC
18637	5763	22	M.S.R.	M.S.R.	NNP
18637	5764	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5764	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5764	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5764	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5764	5	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	5764	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	5764	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	5764	8	.	.	.
18637	5765	1	Lawrence	Lawrence	NNP
18637	5765	2	,	,	,
18637	5765	3	173	173	CD
18637	5765	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5765	5	285	285	CD
18637	5765	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5765	7	1899	1899	CD
18637	5765	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5765	9	,	,	,
18637	5765	10	in	in	IN
18637	5765	11	which	which	WDT
18637	5765	12	an	an	DT
18637	5765	13	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	5765	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	5765	15	requiring	require	VBG
18637	5765	16	that	that	IN
18637	5765	17	"	"	``
18637	5765	18	each	each	DT
18637	5765	19	company	company	NN
18637	5765	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	5765	21	cause	cause	VB
18637	5765	22	three	three	CD
18637	5765	23	,	,	,
18637	5765	24	each	each	DT
18637	5765	25	way	way	NN
18637	5765	26	,	,	,
18637	5765	27	of	of	IN
18637	5765	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5765	29	regular	regular	JJ
18637	5765	30	trains	train	NNS
18637	5765	31	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	5765	32	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	5765	33	,	,	,
18637	5765	34	*	*	NFP
18637	5765	35	*	*	NFP
18637	5765	36	*	*	NFP
18637	5765	37	Sundays	sunday	NNS
18637	5765	38	excepted	except	VBN
18637	5765	39	,	,	,
18637	5765	40	to	to	TO
18637	5765	41	stop	stop	VB
18637	5765	42	at	at	IN
18637	5765	43	a	a	DT
18637	5765	44	station	station	NN
18637	5765	45	,	,	,
18637	5765	46	city	city	NN
18637	5765	47	or	or	CC
18637	5765	48	village	village	NN
18637	5765	49	,	,	,
18637	5765	50	containing	contain	VBG
18637	5765	51	three	three	CD
18637	5765	52	thousand	thousand	CD
18637	5765	53	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	5765	54	,	,	,
18637	5765	55	for	for	IN
18637	5765	56	a	a	DT
18637	5765	57	time	time	NN
18637	5765	58	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	5765	59	to	to	TO
18637	5765	60	receive	receive	VB
18637	5765	61	and	and	CC
18637	5765	62	let	let	VB
18637	5765	63	off	off	RP
18637	5765	64	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	5765	65	;	;	:
18637	5765	66	*	*	NFP
18637	5765	67	*	*	NFP
18637	5765	68	*	*	NFP
18637	5765	69	"	"	''
18637	5765	70	was	be	VBD
18637	5765	71	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	5765	72	.	.	.
18637	5766	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5766	2	800	800	CD
18637	5766	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5766	4	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5766	5	Central	Central	NNP
18637	5766	6	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	5767	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5767	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5767	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5767	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5767	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5767	6	,	,	,
18637	5767	7	163	163	CD
18637	5767	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5767	9	142	142	CD
18637	5767	10	,	,	,
18637	5767	11	153	153	CD
18637	5767	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5767	13	1896	1896	CD
18637	5767	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5767	15	.	.	.
18637	5768	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5768	2	801	801	CD
18637	5768	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5768	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	5768	5	,	,	,
18637	5768	6	Burlington	Burlington	NNP
18637	5768	7	&	&	CC
18637	5768	8	Quincy	Quincy	NNP
18637	5768	9	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	5769	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5769	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5769	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5769	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5769	5	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	5769	6	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	5770	1	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5770	2	.	.	NNP
18637	5770	3	,	,	,
18637	5770	4	237	237	CD
18637	5770	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5770	6	220	220	CD
18637	5770	7	,	,	,
18637	5770	8	226	226	CD
18637	5770	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5770	10	1915	1915	CD
18637	5770	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5770	12	;	;	:
18637	5770	13	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5770	14	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	5770	15	&	&	CC
18637	5770	16	San	San	NNP
18637	5770	17	Francisco	Francisco	NNP
18637	5770	18	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5770	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5770	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5770	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	5770	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5770	23	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5770	24	Service	Service	NNP
18637	5770	25	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5770	26	.	.	NNP
18637	5770	27	,	,	,
18637	5770	28	254	254	CD
18637	5770	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5770	30	535	535	CD
18637	5770	31	,	,	,
18637	5770	32	536	536	CD
18637	5770	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	5770	34	537	537	CD
18637	5770	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5770	36	1921	1921	CD
18637	5770	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5770	38	.	.	.
18637	5771	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5771	2	802	802	CD
18637	5771	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5771	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5771	5	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	5771	6	&	&	CC
18637	5771	7	San	San	NNP
18637	5771	8	Francisco	Francisco	NNP
18637	5771	9	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5771	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5771	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5771	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	5771	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5771	14	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5771	15	Service	Service	NNP
18637	5771	16	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5771	17	.	.	NNP
18637	5771	18	,	,	,
18637	5771	19	261	261	CD
18637	5771	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5771	21	369	369	CD
18637	5771	22	,	,	,
18637	5771	23	371	371	CD
18637	5771	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5771	25	1923	1923	CD
18637	5771	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5771	27	.	.	.
18637	5772	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5772	2	803	803	CD
18637	5772	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5772	4	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	5772	5	,	,	,
18637	5772	6	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5772	7	&	&	CC
18637	5772	8	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	5772	9	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	5773	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5773	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5773	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5773	4	Jacobson	Jacobson	NNP
18637	5773	5	,	,	,
18637	5773	6	179	179	CD
18637	5773	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5773	8	287	287	CD
18637	5773	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5773	10	1900	1900	CD
18637	5773	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5773	12	.	.	.
18637	5774	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5774	2	804	804	CD
18637	5774	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5774	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	5774	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	5775	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5775	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5775	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5775	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5775	5	Larabee	Larabee	NNP
18637	5775	6	Flour	Flour	NNP
18637	5775	7	Mills	Mills	NNPS
18637	5775	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5775	9	,	,	,
18637	5775	10	211	211	CD
18637	5775	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5775	12	612	612	CD
18637	5775	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5775	14	1909	1909	CD
18637	5775	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5775	16	.	.	.
18637	5776	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5776	2	805	805	CD
18637	5776	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5776	4	McNeill	McNeill	NNP
18637	5776	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5776	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5776	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5776	8	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	5776	9	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5776	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5776	11	,	,	,
18637	5776	12	202	202	CD
18637	5776	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5776	14	543	543	CD
18637	5776	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5776	16	1906	1906	CD
18637	5776	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5776	18	.	.	.
18637	5777	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5777	2	806	806	CD
18637	5777	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5777	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5777	5	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	5777	6	S.W.R.	S.W.R.	NNP
18637	5778	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5778	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5778	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5778	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5778	5	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	5778	6	,	,	,
18637	5778	7	217	217	CD
18637	5778	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5778	9	136	136	CD
18637	5778	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5778	11	1910	1910	CD
18637	5778	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5778	13	.	.	.
18637	5779	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5779	2	807	807	CD
18637	5779	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5779	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5779	5	See	See	NNP
18637	5779	6	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	5779	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5779	8	The	the	DT
18637	5779	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5779	10	's	's	POS
18637	5779	11	language	language	NN
18637	5779	12	in	in	IN
18637	5779	13	Hannibal	Hannibal	NNP
18637	5779	14	&	&	CC
18637	5779	15	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5779	16	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	5780	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5780	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5780	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5780	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5780	5	Husen	Husen	NNP
18637	5780	6	,	,	,
18637	5780	7	95	95	CD
18637	5780	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5780	9	465	465	CD
18637	5780	10	,	,	,
18637	5780	11	470	470	CD
18637	5780	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5780	13	1878	1878	CD
18637	5780	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5780	15	;	;	:
18637	5780	16	New	New	NNP
18637	5780	17	York	York	NNP
18637	5780	18	,	,	,
18637	5780	19	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	5780	20	&	&	CC
18637	5780	21	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	5781	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5781	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5781	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5781	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5781	5	New	New	NNP
18637	5781	6	York	York	NNP
18637	5781	7	,	,	,
18637	5781	8	165	165	CD
18637	5781	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5781	10	628	628	CD
18637	5781	11	,	,	,
18637	5781	12	631	631	CD
18637	5781	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5781	14	1897	1897	CD
18637	5781	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5781	16	;	;	:
18637	5781	17	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	5781	18	Shore	Shore	NNP
18637	5781	19	&	&	CC
18637	5781	20	M.S.R.	M.S.R.	NNP
18637	5782	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5782	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5782	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5782	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5782	5	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	5782	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	5782	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	5782	8	.	.	.
18637	5783	1	Lawrence	Lawrence	NNP
18637	5783	2	,	,	,
18637	5783	3	173	173	CD
18637	5783	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5783	5	285	285	CD
18637	5783	6	,	,	,
18637	5783	7	292	292	CD
18637	5783	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5783	9	1899	1899	CD
18637	5783	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5783	11	;	;	:
18637	5783	12	Hennington	Hennington	NNP
18637	5783	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5783	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	5783	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5783	16	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	5783	17	,	,	,
18637	5783	18	163	163	CD
18637	5783	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5783	20	299	299	CD
18637	5783	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5783	22	1896	1896	CD
18637	5783	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5783	24	;	;	:
18637	5783	25	Simpson	Simpson	NNP
18637	5783	26	_	_	NNP
18637	5783	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	5783	28	_	_	NNP
18637	5783	29	Shepard	Shepard	NNP
18637	5783	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5783	31	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5783	32	Rate	Rate	NNP
18637	5783	33	Cases	Cases	NNP
18637	5783	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5783	35	,	,	,
18637	5783	36	230	230	CD
18637	5783	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5783	38	352	352	CD
18637	5783	39	,	,	,
18637	5783	40	402	402	CD
18637	5783	41	-	-	SYM
18637	5783	42	410	410	CD
18637	5783	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5783	44	1913	1913	CD
18637	5783	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5783	46	.	.	.
18637	5784	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5784	2	808	808	CD
18637	5784	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5784	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	5784	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5784	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5784	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5784	8	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	5784	9	,	,	,
18637	5784	10	124	124	CD
18637	5784	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5784	12	465	465	CD
18637	5784	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5784	14	1888	1888	CD
18637	5784	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5784	16	;	;	:
18637	5784	17	_	_	NNP
18637	5784	18	see	see	VB
18637	5784	19	also	also	RB
18637	5784	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5784	21	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	5784	22	,	,	,
18637	5784	23	C.	C.	NNP
18637	5784	24	&	&	CC
18637	5784	25	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5784	26	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	5785	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5785	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5785	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5785	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5785	5	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	5785	6	,	,	,
18637	5785	7	128	128	CD
18637	5785	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5785	9	96	96	CD
18637	5785	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5785	11	1888	1888	CD
18637	5785	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5785	13	;	;	:
18637	5785	14	McCall	McCall	NNP
18637	5785	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5785	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	5785	17	_	_	NNP
18637	5785	18	California	California	NNP
18637	5785	19	,	,	,
18637	5785	20	136	136	CD
18637	5785	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5785	22	104	104	CD
18637	5785	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5785	24	1890	1890	CD
18637	5785	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5785	26	;	;	:
18637	5785	27	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	5785	28	,	,	,
18637	5785	29	K.	K.	NNP
18637	5785	30	&	&	CC
18637	5785	31	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	5786	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5786	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5786	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5786	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5786	5	Haber	Haber	NNP
18637	5786	6	,	,	,
18637	5786	7	109	109	CD
18637	5786	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5786	9	613	613	CD
18637	5786	10	,	,	,
18637	5786	11	633	633	CD
18637	5786	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5786	13	1898	1898	CD
18637	5786	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5786	15	.	.	.
18637	5787	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5787	2	809	809	CD
18637	5787	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5787	4	New	New	NNP
18637	5787	5	York	York	NNP
18637	5787	6	,	,	,
18637	5787	7	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	5787	8	&	&	CC
18637	5787	9	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	5788	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5788	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5788	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5788	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5788	5	New	New	NNP
18637	5788	6	York	York	NNP
18637	5788	7	,	,	,
18637	5788	8	165	165	CD
18637	5788	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5788	10	628	628	CD
18637	5788	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5788	12	1807	1807	CD
18637	5788	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5788	14	.	.	.
18637	5789	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5789	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5789	3	also	also	RB
18637	5789	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5789	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	5789	6	,	,	,
18637	5789	7	M.	M.	NNP
18637	5789	8	&	&	CC
18637	5789	9	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5789	10	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	5790	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5790	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5790	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5790	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5790	5	Solan	Solan	NNP
18637	5790	6	,	,	,
18637	5790	7	169	169	CD
18637	5790	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5790	9	133	133	CD
18637	5790	10	,	,	,
18637	5790	11	137	137	CD
18637	5790	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5790	13	1898	1898	CD
18637	5790	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5790	15	.	.	.
18637	5791	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5791	2	810	810	CD
18637	5791	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5791	4	Erb	Erb	NNP
18637	5791	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5791	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5791	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5791	8	Morasch	Morasch	NNP
18637	5791	9	,	,	,
18637	5791	10	177	177	CD
18637	5791	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5791	12	584	584	CD
18637	5791	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5791	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	5791	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5791	16	.	.	.
18637	5792	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5792	2	811	811	CD
18637	5792	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5792	4	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	5792	5	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	5793	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5793	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5793	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5793	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5793	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5793	6	Utility	Utility	NNP
18637	5793	7	Commrs	Commrs	NNP
18637	5793	8	.	.	NNP
18637	5793	9	,	,	,
18637	5793	10	254	254	CD
18637	5793	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5793	12	394	394	CD
18637	5793	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5793	14	1921	1921	CD
18637	5793	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5793	16	.	.	.
18637	5794	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5794	2	812	812	CD
18637	5794	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5794	4	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	5794	5	,	,	,
18637	5794	6	T.	T.	NNP
18637	5794	7	&	&	CC
18637	5794	8	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	5795	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5795	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5795	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5795	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5795	5	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	5796	1	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	5796	2	.	.	NNP
18637	5796	3	,	,	,
18637	5796	4	283	283	CD
18637	5796	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5796	6	380	380	CD
18637	5796	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5796	8	1931	1931	CD
18637	5796	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5796	10	.	.	.
18637	5797	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5797	2	813	813	CD
18637	5797	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5797	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	5797	5	,	,	,
18637	5797	6	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	5797	7	&	&	CC
18637	5797	8	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	5798	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5798	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5798	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5798	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5798	5	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	5798	6	,	,	,
18637	5798	7	219	219	CD
18637	5798	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5798	9	453	453	CD
18637	5798	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5798	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	5798	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5798	13	.	.	.
18637	5799	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5799	2	814	814	CD
18637	5799	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5799	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5799	5	,	,	,
18637	5799	6	453	453	CD
18637	5799	7	,	,	,
18637	5799	8	466	466	CD
18637	5799	9	.	.	.
18637	5800	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5800	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5800	3	also	also	RB
18637	5800	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5800	5	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5800	6	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	5800	7	,	,	,
18637	5800	8	I.M.	I.M.	NNP
18637	5801	1	&	&	CC
18637	5801	2	S.	S.	NNP
18637	5801	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5801	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5801	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	5801	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5801	7	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	5801	8	,	,	,
18637	5801	9	240	240	CD
18637	5801	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5801	11	518	518	CD
18637	5801	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5801	13	1916	1916	CD
18637	5801	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5801	15	;	;	:
18637	5801	16	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	5801	17	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	5802	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5802	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5802	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5802	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5802	5	Norwood	Norwood	NNP
18637	5802	6	,	,	,
18637	5802	7	283	283	CD
18637	5802	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5802	9	249	249	CD
18637	5802	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5802	11	1931	1931	CD
18637	5802	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5802	13	.	.	.
18637	5803	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5803	2	815	815	CD
18637	5803	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5803	4	Terminal	Terminal	NNP
18637	5803	5	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	5803	6	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	5803	7	.	.	.
18637	5804	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5804	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5804	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5804	4	Brotherhood	Brotherhood	NNP
18637	5804	5	,	,	,
18637	5804	6	318	318	CD
18637	5804	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5804	8	1	1	CD
18637	5804	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5804	10	1943	1943	CD
18637	5804	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5804	12	.	.	.
18637	5805	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5805	2	816	816	CD
18637	5805	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5805	4	163	163	CD
18637	5805	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5805	6	299	299	CD
18637	5805	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5805	8	1896	1896	CD
18637	5805	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5805	10	.	.	.
18637	5806	1	In	in	IN
18637	5806	2	South	South	NNP
18637	5806	3	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	5806	4	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5806	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5806	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5806	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5806	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5806	9	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	5806	10	,	,	,
18637	5806	11	235	235	CD
18637	5806	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5806	13	537	537	CD
18637	5806	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5806	15	1915	1915	CD
18637	5806	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5806	17	,	,	,
18637	5806	18	the	the	DT
18637	5806	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5806	20	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	5806	21	a	a	DT
18637	5806	22	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	5806	23	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	5806	24	which	which	WDT
18637	5806	25	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	5806	26	the	the	DT
18637	5806	27	company	company	NN
18637	5806	28	from	from	IN
18637	5806	29	allowing	allow	VBG
18637	5806	30	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	5806	31	to	to	TO
18637	5806	32	ride	ride	VB
18637	5806	33	on	on	IN
18637	5806	34	the	the	DT
18637	5806	35	rear	rear	JJ
18637	5806	36	or	or	CC
18637	5806	37	front	front	JJ
18637	5806	38	platforms	platform	NNS
18637	5806	39	without	without	IN
18637	5806	40	suitable	suitable	JJ
18637	5806	41	barriers	barrier	NNS
18637	5806	42	,	,	,
18637	5806	43	and	and	CC
18637	5806	44	requires	require	VBZ
18637	5806	45	that	that	IN
18637	5806	46	the	the	DT
18637	5806	47	cars	car	NNS
18637	5806	48	be	be	VB
18637	5806	49	kept	keep	VBN
18637	5806	50	clean	clean	JJ
18637	5806	51	and	and	CC
18637	5806	52	ventilated	ventilate	VBD
18637	5806	53	and	and	CC
18637	5806	54	fumigated	fumigate	VBD
18637	5806	55	.	.	.
18637	5807	1	However	however	RB
18637	5807	2	,	,	,
18637	5807	3	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	5807	4	of	of	IN
18637	5807	5	the	the	DT
18637	5807	6	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	5807	7	that	that	IN
18637	5807	8	cars	car	NNS
18637	5807	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	5807	10	never	never	RB
18637	5807	11	be	be	VB
18637	5807	12	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	5807	13	to	to	TO
18637	5807	14	fall	fall	VB
18637	5807	15	below	below	IN
18637	5807	16	a	a	DT
18637	5807	17	certain	certain	JJ
18637	5807	18	temperature	temperature	NN
18637	5807	19	and	and	CC
18637	5807	20	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	5807	21	the	the	DT
18637	5807	22	number	number	NN
18637	5807	23	of	of	IN
18637	5807	24	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	5807	25	to	to	TO
18637	5807	26	be	be	VB
18637	5807	27	carried	carry	VBN
18637	5807	28	in	in	IN
18637	5807	29	the	the	DT
18637	5807	30	cars	car	NNS
18637	5807	31	were	be	VBD
18637	5807	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	5807	33	to	to	TO
18637	5807	34	be	be	VB
18637	5807	35	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	5807	36	and	and	CC
18637	5807	37	violative	violative	JJ
18637	5807	38	of	of	IN
18637	5807	39	the	the	DT
18637	5807	40	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	5807	41	clause	clause	NN
18637	5807	42	.	.	.
18637	5808	1	There	there	EX
18637	5808	2	was	be	VBD
18637	5808	3	no	no	DT
18637	5808	4	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	5808	5	interference	interference	NN
18637	5808	6	with	with	IN
18637	5808	7	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5808	8	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	5808	9	by	by	IN
18637	5808	10	a	a	DT
18637	5808	11	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	5808	12	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	5808	13	which	which	WDT
18637	5808	14	directed	direct	VBD
18637	5808	15	a	a	DT
18637	5808	16	railway	railway	NN
18637	5808	17	company	company	NN
18637	5808	18	to	to	TO
18637	5808	19	remove	remove	VB
18637	5808	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	5808	21	tracks	track	NNS
18637	5808	22	from	from	IN
18637	5808	23	a	a	DT
18637	5808	24	busy	busy	JJ
18637	5808	25	street	street	NN
18637	5808	26	intersection	intersection	NN
18637	5808	27	.	.	.
18637	5809	1	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	5809	2	&	&	CC
18637	5809	3	R.G.R.	R.G.R.	NNP
18637	5810	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5810	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5810	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5810	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5810	5	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	5810	6	,	,	,
18637	5810	7	250	250	CD
18637	5810	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5810	9	241	241	CD
18637	5810	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5810	11	1919	1919	CD
18637	5810	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5810	13	.	.	.
18637	5811	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5811	2	817	817	CD
18637	5811	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5811	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	5811	5	,	,	,
18637	5811	6	M.	M.	NNP
18637	5811	7	&	&	CC
18637	5811	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5811	9	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	5812	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5812	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5812	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5812	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5812	5	Solan	Solan	NNP
18637	5812	6	,	,	,
18637	5812	7	169	169	CD
18637	5812	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5812	9	133	133	CD
18637	5812	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5812	11	1898	1898	CD
18637	5812	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5812	13	;	;	:
18637	5812	14	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	5812	15	&	&	CC
18637	5812	16	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	5813	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5813	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5813	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5813	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5813	5	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	5813	6	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	5813	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5813	8	,	,	,
18637	5813	9	169	169	CD
18637	5813	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5813	11	311	311	CD
18637	5813	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5813	13	1898	1898	CD
18637	5813	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5813	15	.	.	.
18637	5814	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5814	2	818	818	CD
18637	5814	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5814	4	325	325	CD
18637	5814	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5814	6	761	761	CD
18637	5814	7	,	,	,
18637	5814	8	779	779	CD
18637	5814	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	5814	10	780	780	CD
18637	5814	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5814	12	1945	1945	CD
18637	5814	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5814	14	.	.	.
18637	5815	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5815	2	819	819	CD
18637	5815	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5815	4	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	5815	5	City	City	NNP
18637	5815	6	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	5815	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5815	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5815	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5815	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5815	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5815	12	Kaw	Kaw	NNP
18637	5815	13	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	5815	14	Drainage	Drainage	NNP
18637	5815	15	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	5815	16	.	.	.
18637	5815	17	,	,	,
18637	5815	18	233	233	CD
18637	5815	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5815	20	75	75	CD
18637	5815	21	,	,	,
18637	5815	22	79	79	CD
18637	5815	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5815	24	1914	1914	CD
18637	5815	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5815	26	.	.	.
18637	5816	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5816	2	820	820	CD
18637	5816	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5816	4	244	244	CD
18637	5816	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5816	6	310	310	CD
18637	5816	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5816	8	1917	1917	CD
18637	5816	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5816	10	.	.	.
18637	5817	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5817	2	821	821	CD
18637	5817	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5817	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5817	5	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	5817	6	.	.	.
18637	5817	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5817	8	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	5817	9	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5817	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5817	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5817	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	5817	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5817	14	King	King	NNP
18637	5817	15	,	,	,
18637	5817	16	217	217	CD
18637	5817	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5817	18	524	524	CD
18637	5817	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5817	20	1910	1910	CD
18637	5817	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5817	22	,	,	,
18637	5817	23	where	where	WRB
18637	5817	24	the	the	DT
18637	5817	25	crossings	crossing	NNS
18637	5817	26	were	be	VBD
18637	5817	27	fewer	few	JJR
18637	5817	28	and	and	CC
18637	5817	29	the	the	DT
18637	5817	30	burden	burden	NN
18637	5817	31	to	to	TO
18637	5817	32	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	5817	33	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	5817	34	was	be	VBD
18637	5817	35	shown	show	VBN
18637	5817	36	not	not	RB
18637	5817	37	to	to	TO
18637	5817	38	be	be	VB
18637	5817	39	unduly	unduly	RB
18637	5817	40	heavy	heavy	JJ
18637	5817	41	.	.	.
18637	5818	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5818	2	822	822	CD
18637	5818	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5818	4	302	302	CD
18637	5818	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5818	6	1	1	CD
18637	5818	7	,	,	,
18637	5818	8	15	15	CD
18637	5818	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5818	10	1937	1937	CD
18637	5818	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5818	12	.	.	.
18637	5819	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5819	2	823	823	CD
18637	5819	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5819	4	325	325	CD
18637	5819	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5819	6	761	761	CD
18637	5819	7	,	,	,
18637	5819	8	771	771	CD
18637	5819	9	-	-	SYM
18637	5819	10	776	776	CD
18637	5819	11	.	.	.
18637	5820	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5820	2	824	824	CD
18637	5820	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5820	4	328	328	CD
18637	5820	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5820	6	373	373	CD
18637	5820	7	,	,	,
18637	5820	8	380	380	CD
18637	5820	9	,	,	,
18637	5820	10	386	386	CD
18637	5820	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5820	12	1946	1946	CD
18637	5820	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5820	14	.	.	.
18637	5821	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5821	2	825	825	CD
18637	5821	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5821	4	Hendrick	Hendrick	NNP
18637	5821	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5821	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5821	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5821	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	5821	9	,	,	,
18637	5821	10	235	235	CD
18637	5821	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5821	12	610	610	CD
18637	5821	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5821	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	5821	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5821	16	;	;	:
18637	5821	17	Kane	Kane	NNP
18637	5821	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5821	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	5821	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5821	21	New	New	NNP
18637	5821	22	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	5821	23	,	,	,
18637	5821	24	242	242	CD
18637	5821	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5821	26	160	160	CD
18637	5821	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5821	28	1916	1916	CD
18637	5821	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5821	30	.	.	.
18637	5822	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5822	2	826	826	CD
18637	5822	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5822	4	Sproles	Sproles	NNP
18637	5822	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5822	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5822	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5822	8	Binford	Binford	NNP
18637	5822	9	,	,	,
18637	5822	10	286	286	CD
18637	5822	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5822	12	374	374	CD
18637	5822	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5822	14	1932	1932	CD
18637	5822	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5822	16	.	.	.
18637	5823	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5823	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5823	3	also	also	RB
18637	5823	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5823	5	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	5823	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5823	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5823	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5823	9	Duby	Duby	NNP
18637	5823	10	,	,	,
18637	5823	11	274	274	CD
18637	5823	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5823	13	135	135	CD
18637	5823	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5823	15	1927	1927	CD
18637	5823	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5823	17	.	.	.
18637	5824	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5824	2	827	827	CD
18637	5824	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5824	4	South	South	NNP
18637	5824	5	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	5824	6	State	State	NNP
18637	5824	7	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	5824	8	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	5824	9	.	.	.
18637	5825	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5825	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5825	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5825	4	Barnwell	Barnwell	NNP
18637	5825	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	5825	6	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	5825	7	,	,	,
18637	5825	8	303	303	CD
18637	5825	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5825	10	177	177	CD
18637	5825	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5825	12	1938	1938	CD
18637	5825	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5825	14	.	.	.
18637	5826	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5826	2	828	828	CD
18637	5826	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5826	4	289	289	CD
18637	5826	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5826	6	92	92	CD
18637	5826	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5826	8	1933	1933	CD
18637	5826	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5826	10	.	.	.
18637	5827	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5827	2	829	829	CD
18637	5827	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5827	4	309	309	CD
18637	5827	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5827	6	598	598	CD
18637	5827	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5827	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	5827	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5827	10	.	.	.
18637	5828	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5828	2	830	830	CD
18637	5828	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5828	4	306	306	CD
18637	5828	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5828	6	79	79	CD
18637	5828	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5828	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	5828	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5828	10	.	.	.
18637	5829	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5829	2	831	831	CD
18637	5829	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5829	4	Eichholz	Eichholz	NNP
18637	5829	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5829	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5829	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5829	8	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5829	9	Service	Service	NNP
18637	5829	10	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5829	11	.	.	.
18637	5830	1	of	of	IN
18637	5830	2	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	5830	3	,	,	,
18637	5830	4	306	306	CD
18637	5830	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5830	6	268	268	CD
18637	5830	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5830	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	5830	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5830	10	,	,	,
18637	5830	11	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5830	12	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	5830	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5830	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	5830	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5830	16	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5830	17	of	of	IN
18637	5830	18	Wardens	Wardens	NNP
18637	5830	19	,	,	,
18637	5830	20	12	12	CD
18637	5830	21	How	how	WRB
18637	5830	22	.	.	.
18637	5831	1	299	299	CD
18637	5831	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5831	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	5831	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5831	5	.	.	.
18637	5832	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5832	2	832	832	CD
18637	5832	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5832	4	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	5832	5	Express	Express	NNP
18637	5832	6	Agency	Agency	NNP
18637	5832	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5832	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5832	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5832	10	New	New	NNP
18637	5832	11	York	York	NNP
18637	5832	12	,	,	,
18637	5832	13	336	336	CD
18637	5832	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5832	15	106	106	CD
18637	5832	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5832	17	1949	1949	CD
18637	5832	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5832	19	.	.	.
18637	5833	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5833	2	833	833	CD
18637	5833	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5833	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5833	5	.	.	.
18637	5834	1	111	111	CD
18637	5834	2	.	.	.
18637	5835	1	For	for	IN
18637	5835	2	a	a	DT
18637	5835	3	more	more	RBR
18637	5835	4	extreme	extreme	JJ
18637	5835	5	application	application	NN
18637	5835	6	of	of	IN
18637	5835	7	this	this	DT
18637	5835	8	idea	idea	NN
18637	5835	9	by	by	IN
18637	5835	10	a	a	DT
18637	5835	11	narrowly	narrowly	RB
18637	5835	12	divided	divide	VBN
18637	5835	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5835	14	,	,	,
18637	5835	15	in	in	IN
18637	5835	16	a	a	DT
18637	5835	17	quite	quite	RB
18637	5835	18	special	special	JJ
18637	5835	19	situation	situation	NN
18637	5835	20	,	,	,
18637	5835	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5835	22	see	see	VBP
18637	5835	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5835	24	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	5835	25	et	et	NNP
18637	5835	26	al	al	NNP
18637	5835	27	.	.	.
18637	5836	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5836	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5836	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5836	4	California	California	NNP
18637	5836	5	,	,	,
18637	5836	6	342	342	CD
18637	5836	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5836	8	99	99	CD
18637	5836	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5836	10	1952	1952	CD
18637	5836	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5836	12	.	.	.
18637	5837	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5837	2	834	834	CD
18637	5837	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5837	4	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	5837	5	Baking	Baking	NNP
18637	5837	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5837	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5837	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5837	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5837	10	Woodring	Woodring	NNP
18637	5837	11	,	,	,
18637	5837	12	286	286	CD
18637	5837	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5837	14	352	352	CD
18637	5837	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5837	16	1932	1932	CD
18637	5837	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5837	18	;	;	:
18637	5837	19	Stephenson	Stephenson	NNP
18637	5837	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5837	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	5837	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5837	23	Binford	Binford	NNP
18637	5837	24	,	,	,
18637	5837	25	287	287	CD
18637	5837	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5837	27	251	251	CD
18637	5837	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5837	29	1932	1932	CD
18637	5837	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5837	31	;	;	:
18637	5837	32	Hicklin	Hicklin	NNP
18637	5837	33	_	_	NNP
18637	5837	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	5837	35	_	_	NNP
18637	5837	36	Coney	Coney	NNP
18637	5837	37	,	,	,
18637	5837	38	290	290	CD
18637	5837	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5837	40	169	169	CD
18637	5837	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5837	42	1933	1933	CD
18637	5837	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5837	44	.	.	.
18637	5838	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5838	2	835	835	CD
18637	5838	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5838	4	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	5838	5	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	5838	6	.	.	.
18637	5839	1	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	5839	2	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5839	3	.	.	.
18637	5840	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5840	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5840	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5840	4	Duke	Duke	NNP
18637	5840	5	,	,	,
18637	5840	6	266	266	CD
18637	5840	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5840	8	570	570	CD
18637	5840	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5840	10	1925	1925	CD
18637	5840	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5840	12	.	.	.
18637	5841	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5841	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5841	3	also	also	RB
18637	5841	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5841	5	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	5841	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5841	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5841	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5841	9	Cahoon	Cahoon	NNP
18637	5841	10	,	,	,
18637	5841	11	283	283	CD
18637	5841	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5841	13	553	553	CD
18637	5841	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5841	15	1931	1931	CD
18637	5841	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5841	17	;	;	:
18637	5841	18	and	and	CC
18637	5841	19	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	5841	20	Baking	Baking	NNP
18637	5841	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5841	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5841	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	5841	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5841	25	Woodring	Woodring	NNP
18637	5841	26	,	,	,
18637	5841	27	286	286	CD
18637	5841	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5841	29	352	352	CD
18637	5841	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5841	31	1932	1932	CD
18637	5841	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5841	33	.	.	.
18637	5842	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5842	2	836	836	CD
18637	5842	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5842	4	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	5842	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5842	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5842	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5842	8	Kuykendall	Kuykendall	NNP
18637	5842	9	,	,	,
18637	5842	10	267	267	CD
18637	5842	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5842	12	307	307	CD
18637	5842	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5842	14	1925	1925	CD
18637	5842	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5842	16	.	.	.
18637	5843	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5843	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5843	3	also	also	RB
18637	5843	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5843	5	,	,	,
18637	5843	6	Bush	Bush	NNP
18637	5843	7	&	&	CC
18637	5843	8	Sons	Sons	NNP
18637	5843	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5843	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5843	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	5843	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5843	13	Maloy	Maloy	NNP
18637	5843	14	,	,	,
18637	5843	15	267	267	CD
18637	5843	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5843	17	317	317	CD
18637	5843	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5843	19	1925	1925	CD
18637	5843	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5843	21	;	;	:
18637	5843	22	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	5843	23	Busses	Busses	NNPS
18637	5843	24	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	5843	25	_	_	NNP
18637	5843	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	5843	27	_	_	NNP
18637	5843	28	Holyoke	Holyoke	NNP
18637	5843	29	Street	Street	NNP
18637	5843	30	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5843	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5843	32	,	,	,
18637	5843	33	273	273	CD
18637	5843	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5843	35	45	45	CD
18637	5843	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5843	37	1927	1927	CD
18637	5843	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5843	39	.	.	.
18637	5844	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5844	2	837	837	CD
18637	5844	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5844	4	273	273	CD
18637	5844	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5844	6	34	34	CD
18637	5844	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5844	8	1927	1927	CD
18637	5844	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5844	10	.	.	.
18637	5845	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5845	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5845	3	also	also	RB
18637	5845	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5845	5	McCall	McCall	NNP
18637	5845	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5845	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5845	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5845	9	California	California	NNP
18637	5845	10	,	,	,
18637	5845	11	136	136	CD
18637	5845	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5845	13	104	104	CD
18637	5845	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5845	15	1890	1890	CD
18637	5845	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5845	17	.	.	.
18637	5846	1	In	in	IN
18637	5846	2	the	the	DT
18637	5846	3	former	former	JJ
18637	5846	4	case	case	NN
18637	5846	5	,	,	,
18637	5846	6	agents	agent	NNS
18637	5846	7	soliciting	solicit	VBG
18637	5846	8	patronage	patronage	NN
18637	5846	9	for	for	IN
18637	5846	10	steamship	steamship	NN
18637	5846	11	lines	line	NNS
18637	5846	12	were	be	VBD
18637	5846	13	involved	involve	VBN
18637	5846	14	;	;	:
18637	5846	15	in	in	IN
18637	5846	16	the	the	DT
18637	5846	17	latter	latter	JJ
18637	5846	18	,	,	,
18637	5846	19	an	an	DT
18637	5846	20	agent	agent	NN
18637	5846	21	soliciting	solicit	VBG
18637	5846	22	patronage	patronage	NN
18637	5846	23	for	for	IN
18637	5846	24	a	a	DT
18637	5846	25	particular	particular	JJ
18637	5846	26	railway	railway	NN
18637	5846	27	line	line	NN
18637	5846	28	.	.	.
18637	5847	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5847	2	838	838	CD
18637	5847	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5847	4	California	California	NNP
18637	5847	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5847	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5847	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5847	8	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	5847	9	,	,	,
18637	5847	10	313	313	CD
18637	5847	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5847	12	109	109	CD
18637	5847	13	,	,	,
18637	5847	14	115	115	CD
18637	5847	15	-	-	SYM
18637	5847	16	116	116	CD
18637	5847	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5847	18	1941	1941	CD
18637	5847	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5847	20	.	.	.
18637	5848	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5848	2	839	839	CD
18637	5848	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5848	4	9	9	CD
18637	5848	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5848	6	.	.	.
18637	5849	1	1	1	CD
18637	5849	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5849	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	5849	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5849	5	.	.	.
18637	5850	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5850	2	840	840	CD
18637	5850	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5850	4	2	2	CD
18637	5850	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	5850	6	.	.	.
18637	5851	1	245	245	CD
18637	5851	2	,	,	,
18637	5851	3	252	252	CD
18637	5851	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5851	5	1829	1829	CD
18637	5851	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5851	7	.	.	.
18637	5852	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5852	2	841	841	CD
18637	5852	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5852	4	12	12	CD
18637	5852	5	How	how	WRB
18637	5852	6	.	.	.
18637	5853	1	299	299	CD
18637	5853	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5853	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	5853	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5853	5	.	.	.
18637	5854	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5854	2	842	842	CD
18637	5854	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5854	4	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	5854	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5854	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5854	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5854	8	Davenport	Davenport	NNP
18637	5854	9	,	,	,
18637	5854	10	22	22	CD
18637	5854	11	How	how	WRB
18637	5854	12	.	.	.
18637	5855	1	244	244	CD
18637	5855	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5855	3	1859	1859	CD
18637	5855	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5855	5	;	;	:
18637	5855	6	Sinnot	Sinnot	NNP
18637	5855	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5855	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5855	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5855	10	Davenport	Davenport	NNP
18637	5855	11	,	,	,
18637	5855	12	22	22	CD
18637	5855	13	How	how	WRB
18637	5855	14	.	.	.
18637	5856	1	227	227	CD
18637	5856	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5856	3	1859	1859	CD
18637	5856	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5856	5	.	.	.
18637	5857	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5857	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5857	3	also	also	RB
18637	5857	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5857	5	Lord	Lord	NNP
18637	5857	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5857	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5857	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5857	9	Steamship	Steamship	NNP
18637	5857	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5857	11	,	,	,
18637	5857	12	102	102	CD
18637	5857	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5857	14	541	541	CD
18637	5857	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5857	16	1881	1881	CD
18637	5857	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5857	18	.	.	.
18637	5858	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5858	2	843	843	CD
18637	5858	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5858	4	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	5858	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5858	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5858	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5858	8	Master	Master	NNP
18637	5858	9	&	&	CC
18637	5858	10	Wardens	Wardens	NNP
18637	5858	11	of	of	IN
18637	5858	12	Port	Port	NNP
18637	5858	13	of	of	IN
18637	5858	14	New	New	NNP
18637	5858	15	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	5858	16	,	,	,
18637	5858	17	94	94	CD
18637	5858	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5858	19	246	246	CD
18637	5858	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5858	21	1877	1877	CD
18637	5858	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5858	23	.	.	.
18637	5859	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5859	2	844	844	CD
18637	5859	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5859	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5859	5	.	.	.
18637	5860	1	247	247	CD
18637	5860	2	.	.	.
18637	5861	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5861	2	845	845	CD
18637	5861	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5861	4	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	5861	5	Transp	Transp	NNP
18637	5861	6	.	.	.
18637	5862	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5862	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5862	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5862	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5862	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	5862	6	,	,	,
18637	5862	7	99	99	CD
18637	5862	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5862	9	635	635	CD
18637	5862	10	,	,	,
18637	5862	11	643	643	CD
18637	5862	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5862	13	1879	1879	CD
18637	5862	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5862	15	;	;	:
18637	5862	16	Willamette	Willamette	NNP
18637	5862	17	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	5862	18	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	5862	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5862	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5862	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	5862	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5862	23	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	5862	24	,	,	,
18637	5862	25	125	125	CD
18637	5862	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5862	27	1	1	CD
18637	5862	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5862	29	1888	1888	CD
18637	5862	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5862	31	;	;	:
18637	5862	32	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5862	33	_	_	NNP
18637	5862	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	5862	35	_	_	NNP
18637	5862	36	Economy	Economy	NNP
18637	5862	37	Power	Power	NNP
18637	5862	38	Light	Light	NNP
18637	5862	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5862	40	,	,	,
18637	5862	41	234	234	CD
18637	5862	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5862	43	497	497	CD
18637	5862	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5862	45	1914	1914	CD
18637	5862	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5862	47	.	.	.
18637	5863	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5863	2	846	846	CD
18637	5863	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5863	4	Economy	Economy	NNP
18637	5863	5	Light	Light	NNP
18637	5863	6	and	and	CC
18637	5863	7	Power	Power	NNP
18637	5863	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5863	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5863	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5863	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5863	12	United	United	NNP
18637	5863	13	States	States	NNP
18637	5863	14	,	,	,
18637	5863	15	256	256	CD
18637	5863	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5863	17	113	113	CD
18637	5863	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5863	19	1921	1921	CD
18637	5863	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5863	21	.	.	.
18637	5864	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5864	2	847	847	CD
18637	5864	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5864	4	Harman	Harman	NNP
18637	5864	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5864	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5864	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5864	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	5864	9	,	,	,
18637	5864	10	147	147	CD
18637	5864	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5864	12	396	396	CD
18637	5864	13	,	,	,
18637	5864	14	412	412	CD
18637	5864	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5864	16	1893	1893	CD
18637	5864	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5864	18	.	.	.
18637	5865	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5865	2	848	848	CD
18637	5865	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5865	4	302	302	CD
18637	5865	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5865	6	1	1	CD
18637	5865	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5865	8	1937	1937	CD
18637	5865	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5865	10	.	.	.
18637	5866	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5866	2	849	849	CD
18637	5866	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5866	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5866	5	.	.	.
18637	5867	1	10	10	CD
18637	5867	2	.	.	.
18637	5868	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5868	2	850	850	CD
18637	5868	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5868	4	333	333	CD
18637	5868	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5868	6	28	28	CD
18637	5868	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5868	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	5868	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5868	10	.	.	.
18637	5869	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5869	2	851	851	CD
18637	5869	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5869	4	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	5869	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5869	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5869	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5869	8	De	De	NNP
18637	5869	9	Cuir	Cuir	NNP
18637	5869	10	,	,	,
18637	5869	11	95	95	CD
18637	5869	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5869	13	485	485	CD
18637	5869	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5869	15	1878	1878	CD
18637	5869	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5869	17	.	.	.
18637	5870	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5870	2	852	852	CD
18637	5870	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5870	4	2	2	CD
18637	5870	5	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	5870	6	.	.	.
18637	5871	1	245	245	CD
18637	5871	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5871	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	5871	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5871	5	.	.	.
18637	5872	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5872	2	853	853	CD
18637	5872	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5872	4	Pound	Pound	NNP
18637	5872	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5872	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5872	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5872	8	Turck	Turck	NNP
18637	5872	9	,	,	,
18637	5872	10	95	95	CD
18637	5872	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5872	12	459	459	CD
18637	5872	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5872	14	1878	1878	CD
18637	5872	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5872	16	;	;	:
18637	5872	17	Lindsay	Lindsay	NNP
18637	5872	18	&	&	CC
18637	5872	19	Phelps	Phelps	NNP
18637	5872	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5872	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5872	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	5872	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5872	24	Mullen	Mullen	NNP
18637	5872	25	,	,	,
18637	5872	26	176	176	CD
18637	5872	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5872	28	126	126	CD
18637	5872	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5872	30	1900	1900	CD
18637	5872	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5872	32	.	.	.
18637	5873	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5873	2	854	854	CD
18637	5873	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5873	4	3	3	CD
18637	5873	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	5873	6	.	.	.
18637	5874	1	713	713	CD
18637	5874	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5874	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	5874	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5874	5	.	.	.
18637	5875	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5875	2	855	855	CD
18637	5875	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5875	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5875	5	.	.	.
18637	5876	1	729	729	CD
18637	5876	2	.	.	.
18637	5877	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5877	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5877	3	also	also	RB
18637	5877	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5877	5	,	,	,
18637	5877	6	Escanaba	Escanaba	NNP
18637	5877	7	&	&	CC
18637	5877	8	L.M.	L.M.	NNP
18637	5878	1	Transp	Transp	NNP
18637	5878	2	.	.	.
18637	5879	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5879	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5879	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5879	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5879	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	5879	6	,	,	,
18637	5879	7	107	107	CD
18637	5879	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5879	9	678	678	CD
18637	5879	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5879	11	1883	1883	CD
18637	5879	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5879	13	;	;	:
18637	5879	14	and	and	CC
18637	5879	15	Cardwell	Cardwell	NNP
18637	5879	16	_	_	NNP
18637	5879	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	5879	18	_	_	NNP
18637	5879	19	American	American	NNP
18637	5879	20	River	River	NNP
18637	5879	21	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	5879	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5879	23	,	,	,
18637	5879	24	113	113	CD
18637	5879	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5879	26	205	205	CD
18637	5879	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5879	28	1885	1885	CD
18637	5879	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5879	30	.	.	.
18637	5880	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5880	2	856	856	CD
18637	5880	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5880	4	119	119	CD
18637	5880	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5880	6	543	543	CD
18637	5880	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5880	8	1886	1886	CD
18637	5880	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5880	10	.	.	.
18637	5881	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5881	2	857	857	CD
18637	5881	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5881	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5881	5	.	.	.
18637	5882	1	548	548	CD
18637	5882	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5882	3	549	549	CD
18637	5882	4	.	.	.
18637	5883	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5883	2	858	858	CD
18637	5883	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5883	4	Packet	Packet	NNP
18637	5883	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5883	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5883	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5883	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5883	9	Keokuk	Keokuk	NNP
18637	5883	10	,	,	,
18637	5883	11	95	95	CD
18637	5883	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5883	13	80	80	CD
18637	5883	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5883	15	1877	1877	CD
18637	5883	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5883	17	;	;	:
18637	5883	18	Ouachita	Ouachita	NNP
18637	5883	19	Packet	Packet	NNP
18637	5883	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5883	21	_	_	NNP
18637	5883	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	5883	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5883	24	Aiken	Aiken	NNP
18637	5883	25	,	,	,
18637	5883	26	121	121	CD
18637	5883	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5883	28	444	444	CD
18637	5883	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5883	30	1887	1887	CD
18637	5883	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5883	32	.	.	.
18637	5884	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5884	2	859	859	CD
18637	5884	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5884	4	Prosser	Prosser	NNP
18637	5884	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5884	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5884	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5884	8	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	5884	9	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	5885	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5885	2	,	,	,
18637	5885	3	152	152	CD
18637	5885	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5885	5	59	59	CD
18637	5885	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5885	7	1894	1894	CD
18637	5885	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5885	9	.	.	.
18637	5886	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5886	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5886	3	also	also	RB
18637	5886	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5886	5	Sands	Sands	NNPS
18637	5886	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5886	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5886	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5886	9	Manistee	Manistee	NNP
18637	5886	10	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5886	11	Imp	Imp	NNP
18637	5886	12	.	.	.
18637	5887	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5887	2	,	,	,
18637	5887	3	123	123	CD
18637	5887	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5887	5	288	288	CD
18637	5887	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5887	7	1887	1887	CD
18637	5887	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5887	9	;	;	:
18637	5887	10	Gring	Gring	NNP
18637	5887	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5887	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	5887	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5887	14	Ives	Ives	NNP
18637	5887	15	,	,	,
18637	5887	16	222	222	CD
18637	5887	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5887	18	365	365	CD
18637	5887	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5887	20	1912	1912	CD
18637	5887	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5887	22	.	.	.
18637	5888	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5888	2	860	860	CD
18637	5888	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5888	4	Cases	case	NNS
18637	5888	5	cited	cite	VBD
18637	5888	6	in	in	IN
18637	5888	7	note	note	NN
18637	5888	8	7	7	CD
18637	5888	9	above;[Transcriber	above;[transcriber	XX
18637	5888	10	's	's	POS
18637	5888	11	Note	note	NN
18637	5888	12	:	:	:
18637	5888	13	Reference	reference	NN
18637	5888	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	5888	15	to	to	IN
18637	5888	16	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	5888	17	858	858	CD
18637	5888	18	,	,	,
18637	5888	19	above	above	RB
18637	5888	20	.	.	.
18637	5888	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5889	1	Parkersburg	Parkersburg	NNP
18637	5889	2	&	&	CC
18637	5889	3	O.	O.	NNP
18637	5889	4	Transp	Transp	NNP
18637	5889	5	.	.	.
18637	5890	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5890	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5890	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5890	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5890	5	Parkersburg	Parkersburg	NNP
18637	5890	6	,	,	,
18637	5890	7	107	107	CD
18637	5890	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5890	9	691	691	CD
18637	5890	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5890	11	1883	1883	CD
18637	5890	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5890	13	.	.	.
18637	5891	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5891	2	861	861	CD
18637	5891	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5891	4	Gloucester	Gloucester	NNP
18637	5891	5	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	5891	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5891	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5891	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5891	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5891	10	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5891	11	,	,	,
18637	5891	12	114	114	CD
18637	5891	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5891	14	196	196	CD
18637	5891	15	,	,	,
18637	5891	16	215	215	CD
18637	5891	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5891	18	1885	1885	CD
18637	5891	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5891	20	;	;	:
18637	5891	21	Conway	Conway	NNP
18637	5891	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5891	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	5891	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5891	25	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	5891	26	,	,	,
18637	5891	27	1	1	CD
18637	5891	28	Black	black	JJ
18637	5891	29	603	603	CD
18637	5891	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5891	31	1862	1862	CD
18637	5891	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5891	33	;	;	:
18637	5891	34	Wiggins	Wiggins	NNP
18637	5891	35	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	5891	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5891	37	_	_	NNP
18637	5891	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	5891	39	_	_	NNP
18637	5891	40	East	East	NNP
18637	5891	41	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5891	42	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	5891	43	,	,	,
18637	5891	44	107	107	CD
18637	5891	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5891	46	365	365	CD
18637	5891	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5891	48	1883	1883	CD
18637	5891	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5891	50	.	.	.
18637	5892	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5892	2	862	862	CD
18637	5892	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5892	4	Mayor	Mayor	NNP
18637	5892	5	and	and	CC
18637	5892	6	Board	Board	NNP
18637	5892	7	of	of	IN
18637	5892	8	Aldermen	Aldermen	NNP
18637	5892	9	of	of	IN
18637	5892	10	Vidalia	Vidalia	NNP
18637	5892	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5892	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	5892	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5892	14	McNeely	McNeely	NNP
18637	5892	15	,	,	,
18637	5892	16	274	274	CD
18637	5892	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5892	18	676	676	CD
18637	5892	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5892	20	1927	1927	CD
18637	5892	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5892	22	.	.	.
18637	5893	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5893	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5893	3	also	also	RB
18637	5893	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5893	5	Helson	Helson	NNP
18637	5893	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5893	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5893	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5893	9	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5893	10	,	,	,
18637	5893	11	279	279	CD
18637	5893	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5893	13	245	245	CD
18637	5893	14	,	,	,
18637	5893	15	249	249	CD
18637	5893	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5893	17	1929	1929	CD
18637	5893	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5893	19	.	.	.
18637	5894	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5894	2	863	863	CD
18637	5894	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5894	4	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	5894	5	&	&	CC
18637	5894	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	5894	7	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	5894	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5894	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5894	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5894	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5894	12	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5894	13	,	,	,
18637	5894	14	154	154	CD
18637	5894	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5894	16	204	204	CD
18637	5894	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5894	18	1894	1894	CD
18637	5894	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5894	20	.	.	.
18637	5895	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5895	2	864	864	CD
18637	5895	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5895	4	Port	Port	NNP
18637	5895	5	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	5895	6	and	and	CC
18637	5895	7	Bergen	Bergen	NNP
18637	5895	8	Point	Point	NNP
18637	5895	9	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	5895	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5895	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5895	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	5895	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5895	14	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	5895	15	.	.	.
18637	5896	1	of	of	IN
18637	5896	2	Chosen	Chosen	NNP
18637	5896	3	Freeholders	Freeholders	NNP
18637	5896	4	,	,	,
18637	5896	5	234	234	CD
18637	5896	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5896	7	317	317	CD
18637	5896	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5896	9	1914	1914	CD
18637	5896	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5896	11	.	.	.
18637	5897	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5897	2	865	865	CD
18637	5897	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5897	4	New	New	NNP
18637	5897	5	York	York	NNP
18637	5897	6	Central	Central	NNP
18637	5897	7	&	&	CC
18637	5897	8	H.R.R.	H.R.R.	NNP
18637	5898	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5898	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5898	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5898	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5898	5	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	5898	6	.	.	.
18637	5899	1	of	of	IN
18637	5899	2	Chosen	Chosen	NNP
18637	5899	3	Freeholders	Freeholders	NNP
18637	5899	4	,	,	,
18637	5899	5	227	227	CD
18637	5899	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5899	7	248	248	CD
18637	5899	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5899	9	1913	1913	CD
18637	5899	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5899	11	.	.	.
18637	5900	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5900	2	866	866	CD
18637	5900	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5900	4	Wilmington	Wilmington	NNP
18637	5900	5	Transp	Transp	NNP
18637	5900	6	.	.	.
18637	5901	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5901	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5901	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5901	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5901	5	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	5902	1	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5902	2	.	.	NNP
18637	5902	3	,	,	,
18637	5902	4	236	236	CD
18637	5902	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5902	6	151	151	CD
18637	5902	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5902	8	1915	1915	CD
18637	5902	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5902	10	.	.	.
18637	5903	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5903	2	867	867	CD
18637	5903	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5903	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5903	5	U.	U.	NNP
18637	5903	6	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5903	7	.	.	.
18637	5904	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5904	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5904	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5904	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5904	5	Pendleton	Pendleton	NNP
18637	5904	6	,	,	,
18637	5904	7	122	122	CD
18637	5904	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5904	9	347	347	CD
18637	5904	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5904	11	1887	1887	CD
18637	5904	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5904	13	.	.	.
18637	5905	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5905	2	868	868	CD
18637	5905	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5905	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5905	5	U.	U.	NNP
18637	5905	6	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5905	7	.	.	.
18637	5906	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5906	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5906	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5906	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5906	5	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	5906	6	,	,	,
18637	5906	7	247	247	CD
18637	5906	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5906	9	105	105	CD
18637	5906	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5906	11	1918	1918	CD
18637	5906	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5906	13	.	.	.
18637	5907	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5907	2	869	869	CD
18637	5907	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5907	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5907	5	U.	U.	NNP
18637	5907	6	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5907	7	.	.	.
18637	5908	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5908	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5908	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5908	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5908	5	Crovo	Crovo	NNP
18637	5908	6	,	,	,
18637	5908	7	220	220	CD
18637	5908	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5908	9	364	364	CD
18637	5908	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5908	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	5908	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5908	13	.	.	.
18637	5909	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5909	2	870	870	CD
18637	5909	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5909	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5909	5	U.	U.	NNP
18637	5909	6	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5909	7	.	.	.
18637	5910	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5910	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5910	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5910	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5910	5	Commercial	Commercial	NNP
18637	5910	6	Milling	Milling	NNP
18637	5910	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5910	8	,	,	,
18637	5910	9	218	218	CD
18637	5910	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5910	11	406	406	CD
18637	5910	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5910	13	1910	1910	CD
18637	5910	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5910	15	.	.	.
18637	5911	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5911	2	871	871	CD
18637	5911	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5911	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5911	5	U.	U.	NNP
18637	5911	6	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5911	7	.	.	.
18637	5912	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5912	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5912	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5912	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5912	5	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	5912	6	,	,	,
18637	5912	7	234	234	CD
18637	5912	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5912	9	542	542	CD
18637	5912	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5912	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	5912	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5912	13	.	.	.
18637	5913	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5913	2	872	872	CD
18637	5913	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5913	4	Essex	Essex	NNP
18637	5913	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5913	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5913	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5913	8	New	New	NNP
18637	5913	9	England	England	NNP
18637	5913	10	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5913	11	.	.	.
18637	5914	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5914	2	,	,	,
18637	5914	3	239	239	CD
18637	5914	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5914	5	313	313	CD
18637	5914	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5914	7	1915	1915	CD
18637	5914	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5914	9	.	.	.
18637	5915	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5915	2	873	873	CD
18637	5915	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5915	4	Pensacola	Pensacola	NNP
18637	5915	5	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5915	6	.	.	.
18637	5916	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5916	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5916	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5916	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5916	5	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5916	6	U.	U.	NNP
18637	5916	7	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5916	8	.	.	.
18637	5917	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5917	2	,	,	,
18637	5917	3	96	96	CD
18637	5917	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5917	5	1	1	CD
18637	5917	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5917	7	1878	1878	CD
18637	5917	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5917	9	.	.	.
18637	5918	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5918	2	874	874	CD
18637	5918	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5918	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5918	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	5918	6	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5918	7	.	.	.
18637	5919	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5919	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5919	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5919	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5919	5	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	5919	6	,	,	,
18637	5919	7	224	224	CD
18637	5919	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5919	9	160	160	CD
18637	5919	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5919	11	1912	1912	CD
18637	5919	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5919	13	.	.	.
18637	5920	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5920	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5920	3	also	also	RB
18637	5920	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5920	5	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	5920	6	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	5920	7	.	.	.
18637	5921	1	Cable	Cable	NNP
18637	5921	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5921	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5921	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	5921	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5921	6	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	5921	7	,	,	,
18637	5921	8	249	249	CD
18637	5921	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5921	10	252	252	CD
18637	5921	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5921	12	1919	1919	CD
18637	5921	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5921	14	.	.	.
18637	5922	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5922	2	875	875	CD
18637	5922	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5922	4	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	5922	5	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	5922	6	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	5922	7	.	.	.
18637	5923	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5923	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5923	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5923	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5923	5	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	5923	6	State	State	NNP
18637	5923	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	5924	1	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5924	2	.	.	NNP
18637	5924	3	,	,	,
18637	5924	4	297	297	CD
18637	5924	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5924	6	471	471	CD
18637	5924	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5924	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	5924	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5924	10	.	.	.
18637	5925	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5925	2	876	876	CD
18637	5925	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5925	4	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	5925	5	Tel	Tel	NNP
18637	5925	6	.	.	.
18637	5926	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5926	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5926	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5926	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5926	5	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5926	6	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5926	7	Util	Util	NNP
18637	5926	8	.	.	.
18637	5927	1	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5927	2	.	.	NNP
18637	5927	3	,	,	,
18637	5927	4	309	309	CD
18637	5927	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5927	6	30	30	CD
18637	5927	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5927	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	5927	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5927	10	.	.	.
18637	5928	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5928	2	877	877	CD
18637	5928	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5928	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	5928	5	ex	ex	NNP
18637	5928	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	5928	7	.	.	.
18637	5929	1	Barrett	Barrett	NNP
18637	5929	2	_	_	NNP
18637	5929	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	5929	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5929	5	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	5929	6	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	5929	7	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5929	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5929	9	,	,	,
18637	5929	10	265	265	CD
18637	5929	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5929	12	298	298	CD
18637	5929	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5929	14	1924	1924	CD
18637	5929	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5929	16	.	.	.
18637	5930	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5930	2	878	878	CD
18637	5930	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5930	4	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5930	5	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	5930	6	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5930	7	.	.	.
18637	5931	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5931	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5931	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5931	4	Attleboro	Attleboro	NNP
18637	5931	5	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	5931	6	&	&	CC
18637	5931	7	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	5931	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5931	9	,	,	,
18637	5931	10	273	273	CD
18637	5931	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5931	12	83	83	CD
18637	5931	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5931	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	5931	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5931	16	.	.	.
18637	5932	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5932	2	879	879	CD
18637	5932	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5932	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	5932	5	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	5932	6	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5932	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5932	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5932	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5932	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5932	11	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5932	12	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	5932	13	.	.	.
18637	5933	1	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5933	2	.	.	NNP
18637	5933	3	,	,	,
18637	5933	4	252	252	CD
18637	5933	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5933	6	23	23	CD
18637	5933	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5933	8	1920	1920	CD
18637	5933	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5933	10	;	;	:
18637	5933	11	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5933	12	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	5933	13	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5933	14	.	.	.
18637	5934	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5934	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5934	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5934	4	Landon	Landon	NNP
18637	5934	5	,	,	,
18637	5934	6	249	249	CD
18637	5934	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5934	8	236	236	CD
18637	5934	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5934	10	1919	1919	CD
18637	5934	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5934	12	.	.	.
18637	5935	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5935	2	880	880	CD
18637	5935	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5935	4	Panhandle	Panhandle	NNP
18637	5935	5	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	5935	6	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	5935	7	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	5935	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5935	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5935	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5935	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5935	12	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5935	13	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	5935	14	.	.	.
18637	5936	1	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5936	2	.	.	NNP
18637	5936	3	,	,	,
18637	5936	4	332	332	CD
18637	5936	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5936	6	507	507	CD
18637	5936	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5936	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	5936	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5936	10	.	.	.
18637	5937	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5937	2	881	881	CD
18637	5937	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5937	4	Panhandle	Panhandle	NNP
18637	5937	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5937	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5937	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5937	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5937	9	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	5937	10	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	5937	11	.	.	.
18637	5937	12	,	,	,
18637	5937	13	341	341	CD
18637	5937	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5937	15	329	329	CD
18637	5937	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5937	17	1951	1951	CD
18637	5937	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5937	19	.	.	.
18637	5938	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5938	2	882	882	CD
18637	5938	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5938	4	Peoples	Peoples	NNP
18637	5938	5	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	5938	6	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5938	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5938	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5938	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5938	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5938	11	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5938	12	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	5938	13	.	.	.
18637	5939	1	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5939	2	.	.	NNP
18637	5939	3	,	,	,
18637	5939	4	270	270	CD
18637	5939	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5939	6	550	550	CD
18637	5939	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5939	8	1926	1926	CD
18637	5939	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5939	10	.	.	.
18637	5940	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5940	2	883	883	CD
18637	5940	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5940	4	East	East	NNP
18637	5940	5	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	5940	6	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5940	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5940	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5940	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5940	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5940	11	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	5940	12	Com	Com	NNP
18637	5940	13	.	.	.
18637	5941	1	of	of	IN
18637	5941	2	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	5941	3	,	,	,
18637	5941	4	283	283	CD
18637	5941	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5941	6	465	465	CD
18637	5941	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5941	8	1931	1931	CD
18637	5941	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5941	10	.	.	.
18637	5942	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5942	2	884	884	CD
18637	5942	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5942	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	5942	5	Distributing	Distributing	NNP
18637	5942	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5942	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5942	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5942	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5942	10	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5942	11	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	5942	12	.	.	.
18637	5943	1	Com	com	NN
18637	5943	2	.	.	.
18637	5944	1	of	of	IN
18637	5944	2	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	5944	3	,	,	,
18637	5944	4	285	285	CD
18637	5944	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5944	6	119	119	CD
18637	5944	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5944	8	1932	1932	CD
18637	5944	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5944	10	.	.	.
18637	5945	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5945	2	885	885	CD
18637	5945	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5945	4	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	5945	5	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	5945	6	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5945	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5945	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5945	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5945	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5945	11	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	5945	12	.	.	.
18637	5946	1	of	of	IN
18637	5946	2	Public	Public	NNP
18637	5946	3	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	5946	4	,	,	,
18637	5946	5	304	304	CD
18637	5946	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5946	7	61	61	CD
18637	5946	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5946	9	1938	1938	CD
18637	5946	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5946	11	.	.	.
18637	5947	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5947	2	886	886	CD
18637	5947	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5947	4	Lone	Lone	NNP
18637	5947	5	Star	Star	NNP
18637	5947	6	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5947	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5947	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5947	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5947	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5947	11	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	5947	12	,	,	,
18637	5947	13	304	304	CD
18637	5947	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5947	15	224	224	CD
18637	5947	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5947	17	1938	1938	CD
18637	5947	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5947	19	.	.	.
18637	5948	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5948	2	887	887	CD
18637	5948	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5948	4	Cities	Cities	NNP
18637	5948	5	Service	Service	NNP
18637	5948	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5948	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5948	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5948	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5948	10	Peerless	Peerless	NNP
18637	5948	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5948	12	,	,	,
18637	5948	13	340	340	CD
18637	5948	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5948	15	179	179	CD
18637	5948	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5948	17	1950	1950	CD
18637	5948	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5948	19	.	.	.
18637	5949	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5949	2	888	888	CD
18637	5949	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5949	4	Union	Union	NNP
18637	5949	5	Brokerage	Brokerage	NNP
18637	5949	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5949	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5949	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5949	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5949	10	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	5949	11	,	,	,
18637	5949	12	322	322	CD
18637	5949	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5949	14	202	202	CD
18637	5949	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5949	16	1944	1944	CD
18637	5949	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5949	18	.	.	.
18637	5950	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5950	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5950	3	also	also	RB
18637	5950	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5950	5	International	International	NNP
18637	5950	6	Harvester	Harvester	NNP
18637	5950	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5950	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5950	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5950	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5950	11	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	5950	12	,	,	,
18637	5950	13	234	234	CD
18637	5950	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5950	15	579	579	CD
18637	5950	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5950	17	1914	1914	CD
18637	5950	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5950	19	;	;	:
18637	5950	20	Sioux	Sioux	NNP
18637	5950	21	Remedy	Remedy	NNP
18637	5950	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5950	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5950	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	5950	25	_	_	NNP
18637	5950	26	Cope	Cope	NNP
18637	5950	27	,	,	,
18637	5950	28	235	235	CD
18637	5950	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5950	30	197	197	CD
18637	5950	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5950	32	1914	1914	CD
18637	5950	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5950	34	;	;	:
18637	5950	35	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	5950	36	Amusement	Amusement	NNP
18637	5950	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5950	38	_	_	NNP
18637	5950	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	5950	40	_	_	NNP
18637	5950	41	Albert	Albert	NNP
18637	5950	42	,	,	,
18637	5950	43	239	239	CD
18637	5950	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5950	45	560	560	CD
18637	5950	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5950	47	1916	1916	CD
18637	5950	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5950	49	.	.	.
18637	5951	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5951	2	889	889	CD
18637	5951	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5951	4	322	322	CD
18637	5951	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5951	6	at	at	IN
18637	5951	7	207	207	CD
18637	5951	8	-	-	SYM
18637	5951	9	209	209	CD
18637	5951	10	.	.	.
18637	5952	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5952	2	890	890	CD
18637	5952	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5952	4	Sioux	Sioux	NNP
18637	5952	5	Remedy	Remedy	NNP
18637	5952	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5952	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5952	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5952	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5952	10	Cope	Cope	NNP
18637	5952	11	,	,	,
18637	5952	12	235	235	CD
18637	5952	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5952	14	197	197	CD
18637	5952	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5952	16	1914	1914	CD
18637	5952	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5952	18	.	.	.
18637	5953	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5953	2	891	891	CD
18637	5953	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5953	4	International	International	NNP
18637	5953	5	Milling	Milling	NNP
18637	5953	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5953	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5953	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5953	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5953	10	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	5953	11	T.	T.	NNP
18637	5953	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5953	13	,	,	,
18637	5953	14	292	292	CD
18637	5953	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5953	16	511	511	CD
18637	5953	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5953	18	1934	1934	CD
18637	5953	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5953	20	.	.	.
18637	5954	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5954	2	892	892	CD
18637	5954	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5954	4	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	5954	5	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	5954	6	Pipeline	Pipeline	NNP
18637	5954	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5954	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5954	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5954	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5954	11	Slattery	Slattery	NNP
18637	5954	12	,	,	,
18637	5954	13	302	302	CD
18637	5954	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5954	15	300	300	CD
18637	5954	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5954	17	1937	1937	CD
18637	5954	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5954	19	.	.	.
18637	5955	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5955	2	893	893	CD
18637	5955	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5955	4	Engel	Engel	NNP
18637	5955	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5955	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5955	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5955	8	O'Malley	O'Malley	NNP
18637	5955	9	,	,	,
18637	5955	10	219	219	CD
18637	5955	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5955	12	128	128	CD
18637	5955	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5955	14	1911	1911	CD
18637	5955	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5955	16	.	.	.
18637	5956	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5956	2	894	894	CD
18637	5956	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5956	4	Merrick	Merrick	NNP
18637	5956	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5956	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5956	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5956	8	Halsey	Halsey	NNP
18637	5956	9	&	&	CC
18637	5956	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5956	11	,	,	,
18637	5956	12	242	242	CD
18637	5956	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5956	14	568	568	CD
18637	5956	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5956	16	1917	1917	CD
18637	5956	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5956	18	.	.	.
18637	5957	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5957	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5957	3	also	also	RB
18637	5957	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5957	5	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	5957	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5957	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5957	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5957	9	Geiger	Geiger	NNP
18637	5957	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	5957	11	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	5957	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5957	13	,	,	,
18637	5957	14	242	242	CD
18637	5957	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5957	16	539	539	CD
18637	5957	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5957	18	1917	1917	CD
18637	5957	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5957	20	;	;	:
18637	5957	21	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	5957	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5957	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	5957	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5957	25	Sioux	Sioux	NNP
18637	5957	26	Falls	Falls	NNP
18637	5957	27	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	5957	28	Yards	Yards	NNP
18637	5957	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5957	30	,	,	,
18637	5957	31	242	242	CD
18637	5957	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5957	33	559	559	CD
18637	5957	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5957	35	1917	1917	CD
18637	5957	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5957	37	.	.	.
18637	5958	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5958	2	895	895	CD
18637	5958	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5958	4	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	5958	5	Accident	Accident	NNP
18637	5958	6	&	&	CC
18637	5958	7	Indemnity	Indemnity	NNP
18637	5958	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5958	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5958	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5958	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5958	12	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	5958	13	ex	ex	NNP
18637	5958	14	rel	rel	NN
18637	5958	15	.	.	.
18637	5959	1	McLaughlin	McLaughlin	NNP
18637	5959	2	,	,	,
18637	5959	3	298	298	CD
18637	5959	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5959	5	155	155	CD
18637	5959	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5959	7	1936	1936	CD
18637	5959	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5959	9	,	,	,
18637	5959	10	citing	cite	VBG
18637	5959	11	Cargill	Cargill	NNP
18637	5959	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5959	13	_	_	NNP
18637	5959	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	5959	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5959	16	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5959	17	,	,	,
18637	5959	18	180	180	CD
18637	5959	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5959	20	452	452	CD
18637	5959	21	,	,	,
18637	5959	22	470	470	CD
18637	5959	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5959	24	1901	1901	CD
18637	5959	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5959	26	;	;	:
18637	5959	27	Simpson	Simpson	NNP
18637	5959	28	_	_	NNP
18637	5959	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	5959	30	_	_	NNP
18637	5959	31	Shepard	Shepard	NNP
18637	5959	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5959	33	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5959	34	Rate	Rate	NNP
18637	5959	35	Case	Case	NNP
18637	5959	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5959	37	,	,	,
18637	5959	38	230	230	CD
18637	5959	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5959	40	352	352	CD
18637	5959	41	,	,	,
18637	5959	42	410	410	CD
18637	5959	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5959	44	1913	1913	CD
18637	5959	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5959	46	;	;	:
18637	5959	47	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	5959	48	_	_	NNP
18637	5959	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	5959	50	_	_	NNP
18637	5959	51	Geiger	Geiger	NNP
18637	5959	52	-	-	HYPH
18637	5959	53	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	5959	54	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5959	55	,	,	,
18637	5959	56	242	242	CD
18637	5959	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5959	58	539	539	CD
18637	5959	59	,	,	,
18637	5959	60	557	557	CD
18637	5959	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5959	62	1917	1917	CD
18637	5959	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5959	64	;	;	:
18637	5959	65	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	5959	66	Compress	Compress	NNP
18637	5959	67	&	&	CC
18637	5959	68	Warehouse	Warehouse	NNP
18637	5959	69	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5959	70	_	_	NNP
18637	5959	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	5959	72	_	_	NNP
18637	5959	73	McLean	McLean	NNP
18637	5959	74	,	,	,
18637	5959	75	291	291	CD
18637	5959	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5959	77	17	17	CD
18637	5959	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5959	79	1934	1934	CD
18637	5959	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5959	81	.	.	.
18637	5960	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5960	2	896	896	CD
18637	5960	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5960	4	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	5960	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5960	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5960	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5960	8	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
18637	5960	9	,	,	,
18637	5960	10	C.C.	C.C.	NNP
18637	5961	1	&	&	CC
18637	5961	2	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5961	3	L.	L.	NNP
18637	5961	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5961	5	,	,	,
18637	5961	6	217	217	CD
18637	5961	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5961	8	157	157	CD
18637	5961	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5961	10	1910	1910	CD
18637	5961	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5961	12	.	.	.
18637	5962	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5962	2	897	897	CD
18637	5962	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5962	4	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	5962	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5962	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5962	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5962	8	West	West	NNP
18637	5962	9	,	,	,
18637	5962	10	222	222	CD
18637	5962	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5962	12	191	191	CD
18637	5962	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5962	14	1911	1911	CD
18637	5962	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5962	16	.	.	.
18637	5963	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5963	2	898	898	CD
18637	5963	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5963	4	The	the	DT
18637	5963	5	"	"	``
18637	5963	6	Winnebago	Winnebago	NNP
18637	5963	7	,	,	,
18637	5963	8	"	"	''
18637	5963	9	205	205	CD
18637	5963	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5963	11	354	354	CD
18637	5963	12	,	,	,
18637	5963	13	362	362	CD
18637	5963	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5963	15	1907	1907	CD
18637	5963	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5963	17	.	.	.
18637	5964	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5964	2	899	899	CD
18637	5964	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5964	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	5964	5	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	5964	6	for	for	IN
18637	5964	7	the	the	DT
18637	5964	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	5964	9	in	in	IN
18637	5964	10	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5964	11	Rate	Rate	NNP
18637	5964	12	Cases	Cases	NNP
18637	5964	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5964	14	Simpson	Simpson	NNP
18637	5964	15	_	_	NNP
18637	5964	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	5964	17	_	_	NNP
18637	5964	18	Shepard	shepard	RB
18637	5964	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5964	20	,	,	,
18637	5964	21	230	230	CD
18637	5964	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5964	23	352	352	CD
18637	5964	24	,	,	,
18637	5964	25	406	406	CD
18637	5964	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5964	27	1913	1913	CD
18637	5964	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5964	29	.	.	.
18637	5965	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5965	2	900	900	CD
18637	5965	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5965	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5965	5	.	.	.
18637	5966	1	408	408	CD
18637	5966	2	.	.	.
18637	5967	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5967	2	901	901	CD
18637	5967	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5967	4	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	5967	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5967	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5967	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5967	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5967	9	Husen	Husen	NNP
18637	5967	10	,	,	,
18637	5967	11	95	95	CD
18637	5967	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5967	13	465	465	CD
18637	5967	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5967	15	1878	1878	CD
18637	5967	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5967	17	.	.	.
18637	5968	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5968	2	902	902	CD
18637	5968	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5968	4	Kimmish	Kimmish	NNP
18637	5968	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5968	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5968	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5968	8	Ball	Ball	NNP
18637	5968	9	,	,	,
18637	5968	10	129	129	CD
18637	5968	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5968	12	217	217	CD
18637	5968	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5968	14	1889	1889	CD
18637	5968	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5968	16	.	.	.
18637	5969	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5969	2	903	903	CD
18637	5969	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5969	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	5969	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5969	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5969	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5969	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	5969	9	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	5969	10	&	&	CC
18637	5969	11	S.W.R.	S.W.R.	NNP
18637	5970	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5970	2	,	,	,
18637	5970	3	181	181	CD
18637	5970	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5970	5	248	248	CD
18637	5970	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5970	7	1901	1901	CD
18637	5970	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5970	9	.	.	.
18637	5971	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5971	2	904	904	CD
18637	5971	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5971	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5971	5	.	.	.
18637	5972	1	255	255	CD
18637	5972	2	.	.	.
18637	5973	1	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	5973	2	's	's	POS
18637	5973	3	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	5973	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5973	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5973	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5973	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5973	8	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	5973	9	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	5973	10	.	.	.
18637	5974	1	of	of	IN
18637	5974	2	Health	Health	NNP
18637	5974	3	,	,	,
18637	5974	4	118	118	CD
18637	5974	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5974	6	455	455	CD
18637	5974	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5974	8	1886	1886	CD
18637	5974	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5974	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	5974	11	cited	cite	VBN
18637	5974	12	.	.	.
18637	5975	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5975	2	905	905	CD
18637	5975	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5975	4	Hebe	Hebe	NNP
18637	5975	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5975	6	_	_	NNP
18637	5975	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	5975	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5975	9	Shaw	Shaw	NNP
18637	5975	10	,	,	,
18637	5975	11	248	248	CD
18637	5975	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5975	13	297	297	CD
18637	5975	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5975	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	5975	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5975	17	.	.	.
18637	5976	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5976	2	906	906	CD
18637	5976	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5976	4	Hygrade	Hygrade	NNP
18637	5976	5	Provision	Provision	NNP
18637	5976	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5976	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5976	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5976	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5976	10	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	5976	11	,	,	,
18637	5976	12	266	266	CD
18637	5976	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5976	14	497	497	CD
18637	5976	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5976	16	1925	1925	CD
18637	5976	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5976	18	.	.	.
18637	5977	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5977	2	907	907	CD
18637	5977	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5977	4	Mintz	Mintz	NNP
18637	5977	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5977	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5977	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5977	8	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	5977	9	,	,	,
18637	5977	10	289	289	CD
18637	5977	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5977	12	346	346	CD
18637	5977	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5977	14	1933	1933	CD
18637	5977	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5977	16	.	.	.
18637	5978	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5978	2	908	908	CD
18637	5978	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5978	4	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	5978	5	States	States	NNPS
18637	5978	6	Box	Box	NNP
18637	5978	7	&	&	CC
18637	5978	8	Basket	Basket	NNP
18637	5978	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5978	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5978	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	5978	12	_	_	NNP
18637	5978	13	White	White	NNP
18637	5978	14	,	,	,
18637	5978	15	296	296	CD
18637	5978	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5978	17	176	176	CD
18637	5978	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5978	19	1935	1935	CD
18637	5978	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5978	21	.	.	.
18637	5979	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5979	2	909	909	CD
18637	5979	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5979	4	Bayside	Bayside	NNP
18637	5979	5	Fish	Fish	NNP
18637	5979	6	Flour	Flour	NNP
18637	5979	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5979	8	_	_	NNP
18637	5979	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	5979	10	_	_	NNP
18637	5979	11	Gentry	Gentry	NNP
18637	5979	12	,	,	,
18637	5979	13	297	297	CD
18637	5979	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5979	15	422	422	CD
18637	5979	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5979	17	1936	1936	CD
18637	5979	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5979	19	.	.	.
18637	5980	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5980	2	910	910	CD
18637	5980	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5980	4	Highland	Highland	NNP
18637	5980	5	Farms	Farms	NNP
18637	5980	6	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
18637	5980	7	,	,	,
18637	5980	8	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	5980	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5980	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	5980	11	_	_	NNP
18637	5980	12	Agnew	Agnew	NNP
18637	5980	13	,	,	,
18637	5980	14	300	300	CD
18637	5980	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5980	16	608	608	CD
18637	5980	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5980	18	1937	1937	CD
18637	5980	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5980	20	.	.	.
18637	5981	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5981	2	911	911	CD
18637	5981	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5981	4	Bourjois	Bourjois	NNP
18637	5981	5	,	,	,
18637	5981	6	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	5981	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5981	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5981	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5981	10	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	5981	11	,	,	,
18637	5981	12	301	301	CD
18637	5981	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5981	14	183	183	CD
18637	5981	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5981	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	5981	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5981	18	.	.	.
18637	5982	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5982	2	912	912	CD
18637	5982	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5982	4	Clason	Clason	NNP
18637	5982	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5982	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5982	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5982	8	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	5982	9	,	,	,
18637	5982	10	306	306	CD
18637	5982	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5982	12	439	439	CD
18637	5982	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5982	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	5982	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5982	16	.	.	.
18637	5983	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5983	2	913	913	CD
18637	5983	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5983	4	Milk	milk	NN
18637	5983	5	Control	Control	NNP
18637	5983	6	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	5983	7	.	.	.
18637	5984	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5984	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	5984	3	_	_	NNP
18637	5984	4	Eisenberg	Eisenberg	NNP
18637	5984	5	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	5984	6	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	5984	7	,	,	,
18637	5984	8	306	306	CD
18637	5984	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5984	10	346	346	CD
18637	5984	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5984	12	1939	1939	CD
18637	5984	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5984	14	.	.	.
18637	5985	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5985	2	914	914	CD
18637	5985	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5985	4	Patapsco	Patapsco	NNP
18637	5985	5	Guano	Guano	NNP
18637	5985	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5985	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5985	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5985	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5985	10	North	North	NNP
18637	5985	11	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	5985	12	,	,	,
18637	5985	13	171	171	CD
18637	5985	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5985	15	345	345	CD
18637	5985	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5985	17	1898	1898	CD
18637	5985	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5985	19	.	.	.
18637	5986	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5986	2	915	915	CD
18637	5986	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5986	4	Savage	Savage	NNP
18637	5986	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5986	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5986	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5986	8	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	5986	9	,	,	,
18637	5986	10	225	225	CD
18637	5986	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5986	12	501	501	CD
18637	5986	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5986	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	5986	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5986	16	;	;	,
18637	5986	17	followed	follow	VBN
18637	5986	18	in	in	IN
18637	5986	19	Corn	Corn	NNP
18637	5986	20	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	5986	21	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	5986	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5986	23	_	_	NNP
18637	5986	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	5986	25	_	_	NNP
18637	5986	26	Eddy	Eddy	NNP
18637	5986	27	,	,	,
18637	5986	28	249	249	CD
18637	5986	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5986	30	427	427	CD
18637	5986	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5986	32	1919	1919	CD
18637	5986	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5986	34	.	.	.
18637	5987	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5987	2	916	916	CD
18637	5987	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5987	4	Pure	Pure	NNP
18637	5987	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	5987	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5987	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5987	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5987	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5987	10	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5987	11	,	,	,
18637	5987	12	248	248	CD
18637	5987	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5987	14	158	158	CD
18637	5987	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5987	16	1918	1918	CD
18637	5987	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5987	18	.	.	.
18637	5988	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5988	2	917	917	CD
18637	5988	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5988	4	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	5988	5	Film	Film	NNP
18637	5988	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	5988	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5988	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5988	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5988	10	Hodges	Hodges	NNPS
18637	5988	11	,	,	,
18637	5988	12	236	236	CD
18637	5988	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5988	14	248	248	CD
18637	5988	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5988	16	1915	1915	CD
18637	5988	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5988	18	.	.	.
18637	5989	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5989	2	918	918	CD
18637	5989	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5989	4	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	5989	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5989	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5989	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5989	8	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	5989	9	,	,	,
18637	5989	10	136	136	CD
18637	5989	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5989	12	313	313	CD
18637	5989	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5989	14	1890	1890	CD
18637	5989	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5989	16	;	;	:
18637	5989	17	_	_	NNP
18637	5989	18	see	see	VB
18637	5989	19	also	also	RB
18637	5989	20	_	_	NNP
18637	5989	21	Brimmer	Brimmer	NNP
18637	5989	22	_	_	NNP
18637	5989	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	5989	24	_	_	NNP
18637	5989	25	Rebman	Rebman	NNP
18637	5989	26	,	,	,
18637	5989	27	138	138	CD
18637	5989	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5989	29	78	78	CD
18637	5989	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5989	31	1891	1891	CD
18637	5989	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5989	33	.	.	.
18637	5990	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5990	2	919	919	CD
18637	5990	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5990	4	136	136	CD
18637	5990	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5990	6	at	at	IN
18637	5990	7	322	322	CD
18637	5990	8	.	.	.
18637	5991	1	_	_	NNP
18637	5991	2	See	See	NNP
18637	5991	3	also	also	RB
18637	5991	4	_	_	NNP
18637	5991	5	pp	pp	NNP
18637	5991	6	.	.	.
18637	5992	1	328	328	CD
18637	5992	2	-	-	SYM
18637	5992	3	329	329	CD
18637	5992	4	.	.	.
18637	5993	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5993	2	920	920	CD
18637	5993	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5993	4	Voight	Voight	NNP
18637	5993	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5993	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5993	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5993	8	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	5993	9	,	,	,
18637	5993	10	141	141	CD
18637	5993	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5993	12	62	62	CD
18637	5993	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5993	14	1891	1891	CD
18637	5993	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5993	16	.	.	.
18637	5994	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5994	2	921	921	CD
18637	5994	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5994	4	Hale	Hale	NNP
18637	5994	5	_	_	NNP
18637	5994	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	5994	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5994	8	Bimco	Bimco	NNP
18637	5994	9	Trading	Trading	NNP
18637	5994	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5994	11	,	,	,
18637	5994	12	306	306	CD
18637	5994	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5994	14	375	375	CD
18637	5994	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5994	16	1939	1939	CD
18637	5994	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5994	18	.	.	.
18637	5995	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5995	2	922	922	CD
18637	5995	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5995	4	Dean	Dean	NNP
18637	5995	5	Milk	Milk	NNP
18637	5995	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	5995	7	_	_	NNP
18637	5995	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	5995	9	_	_	NNP
18637	5995	10	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	5995	11	,	,	,
18637	5995	12	340	340	CD
18637	5995	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	5995	14	349	349	CD
18637	5995	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5995	16	1951	1951	CD
18637	5995	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5995	18	.	.	.
18637	5996	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5996	2	923	923	CD
18637	5996	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5996	4	12	12	CD
18637	5996	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	5996	6	.	.	.
18637	5997	1	419	419	CD
18637	5997	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	5997	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	5997	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	5997	5	.	.	.
18637	5998	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	5998	2	924	924	CD
18637	5998	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	5998	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	5998	5	.	.	.
18637	5999	1	449	449	CD
18637	5999	2	.	.	.
18637	6000	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6000	2	925	925	CD
18637	6000	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6000	4	Woodruff	Woodruff	NNP
18637	6000	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6000	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6000	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6000	8	Parham	Parham	NNP
18637	6000	9	,	,	,
18637	6000	10	8	8	CD
18637	6000	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6000	12	.	.	.
18637	6001	1	123	123	CD
18637	6001	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6001	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	6001	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6001	5	.	.	.
18637	6002	1	There	there	EX
18637	6002	2	were	be	VBD
18637	6002	3	later	later	RB
18637	6002	4	some	some	DT
18637	6002	5	departures	departure	NNS
18637	6002	6	from	from	IN
18637	6002	7	the	the	DT
18637	6002	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	6002	9	,	,	,
18637	6002	10	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	6002	11	due	due	JJ
18637	6002	12	to	to	IN
18637	6002	13	inattention	inattention	NN
18637	6002	14	,	,	,
18637	6002	15	in	in	IN
18637	6002	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	6002	17	involving	involve	VBG
18637	6002	18	oil	oil	NN
18637	6002	19	.	.	.
18637	6003	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6003	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6003	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6003	4	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	6003	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	6003	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6003	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6003	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6003	9	Graves	Graves	NNP
18637	6003	10	,	,	,
18637	6003	11	249	249	CD
18637	6003	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6003	13	389	389	CD
18637	6003	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6003	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	6003	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6003	17	;	;	:
18637	6003	18	Askren	Askren	NNP
18637	6003	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6003	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	6003	21	_	_	NNP
18637	6003	22	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	6003	23	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	6003	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6003	25	,	,	,
18637	6003	26	252	252	CD
18637	6003	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6003	28	444	444	CD
18637	6003	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6003	30	1920	1920	CD
18637	6003	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6003	32	;	;	:
18637	6003	33	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	6003	34	_	_	NNP
18637	6003	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	6003	36	_	_	NNP
18637	6003	37	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	6003	38	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	6003	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6003	40	,	,	,
18637	6003	41	256	256	CD
18637	6003	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6003	43	642	642	CD
18637	6003	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6003	45	1921	1921	CD
18637	6003	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6003	47	and	and	CC
18637	6003	48	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	6003	49	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6003	50	_	_	NNP
18637	6003	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	6003	52	_	_	NNP
18637	6003	53	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	6003	54	,	,	,
18637	6003	55	258	258	CD
18637	6003	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6003	57	466	466	CD
18637	6003	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6003	59	1922	1922	CD
18637	6003	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6003	61	.	.	.
18637	6004	1	These	these	DT
18637	6004	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	6004	3	were	be	VBD
18637	6004	4	"	"	``
18637	6004	5	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	6004	6	,	,	,
18637	6004	7	"	"	''
18637	6004	8	and	and	CC
18637	6004	9	in	in	IN
18637	6004	10	fact	fact	NN
18637	6004	11	disavowed	disavow	VBN
18637	6004	12	in	in	IN
18637	6004	13	Sonneborn	Sonneborn	NNP
18637	6004	14	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	6004	15	_	_	NNP
18637	6004	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	6004	17	_	_	NNP
18637	6004	18	Cureton	Cureton	NNP
18637	6004	19	,	,	,
18637	6004	20	262	262	CD
18637	6004	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6004	22	506	506	CD
18637	6004	23	,	,	,
18637	6004	24	520	520	CD
18637	6004	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6004	26	1923	1923	CD
18637	6004	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6004	28	.	.	.
18637	6005	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6005	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	6005	3	.	.	.
18637	6005	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6005	5	the	the	DT
18637	6005	6	contemporary	contemporary	JJ
18637	6005	7	case	case	NN
18637	6005	8	of	of	IN
18637	6005	9	Wagner	Wagner	NNP
18637	6005	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6005	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	6005	12	_	_	NNP
18637	6005	13	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	6005	14	,	,	,
18637	6005	15	251	251	CD
18637	6005	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6005	17	95	95	CD
18637	6005	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6005	19	1912	1912	CD
18637	6005	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6005	21	where	where	WRB
18637	6005	22	the	the	DT
18637	6005	23	true	true	JJ
18637	6005	24	rule	rule	NN
18637	6005	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	6005	26	followed	follow	VBN
18637	6005	27	.	.	.
18637	6006	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6006	2	926	926	CD
18637	6006	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6006	4	Mugler	Mugler	NNP
18637	6006	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6006	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6006	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6006	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	6006	9	,	,	,
18637	6006	10	123	123	CD
18637	6006	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6006	12	623	623	CD
18637	6006	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6006	14	1887	1887	CD
18637	6006	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6006	16	.	.	.
18637	6007	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6007	2	927	927	CD
18637	6007	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6007	4	Kidd	Kidd	NNP
18637	6007	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6007	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6007	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6007	8	Pearson	Pearson	NNP
18637	6007	9	,	,	,
18637	6007	10	128	128	CD
18637	6007	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6007	12	1	1	CD
18637	6007	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6007	14	1888	1888	CD
18637	6007	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6007	16	.	.	.
18637	6008	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6008	2	928	928	CD
18637	6008	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6008	4	125	125	CD
18637	6008	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6008	6	465	465	CD
18637	6008	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6008	8	1888	1888	CD
18637	6008	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6008	10	.	.	.
18637	6009	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6009	2	929	929	CD
18637	6009	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6009	4	Leisy	Leisy	NNP
18637	6009	5	&	&	CC
18637	6009	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6009	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6009	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6009	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6009	10	Hardin	Hardin	NNP
18637	6009	11	,	,	,
18637	6009	12	135	135	CD
18637	6009	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6009	14	100	100	CD
18637	6009	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6009	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	6009	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6009	18	.	.	.
18637	6010	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6010	2	930	930	CD
18637	6010	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6010	4	26	26	CD
18637	6010	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6010	6	.	.	.
18637	6011	1	313	313	CD
18637	6011	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6011	3	1890	1890	CD
18637	6011	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6011	5	;	;	,
18637	6011	6	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	6011	7	in	in	IN
18637	6011	8	In	in	IN
18637	6011	9	re	re	NN
18637	6011	10	Rahrer	Rahrer	NNP
18637	6011	11	,	,	,
18637	6011	12	140	140	CD
18637	6011	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6011	14	545	545	CD
18637	6011	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6011	16	1891	1891	CD
18637	6011	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6011	18	.	.	.
18637	6012	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6012	2	931	931	CD
18637	6012	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6012	4	Rhodes	Rhodes	NNP
18637	6012	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6012	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6012	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6012	8	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	6012	9	,	,	,
18637	6012	10	170	170	CD
18637	6012	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6012	12	412	412	CD
18637	6012	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6012	14	1898	1898	CD
18637	6012	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6012	16	.	.	.
18637	6013	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6013	2	932	932	CD
18637	6013	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6013	4	37	37	CD
18637	6013	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6013	6	.	.	.
18637	6014	1	699	699	CD
18637	6014	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6014	3	1913	1913	CD
18637	6014	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6014	5	;	;	:
18637	6014	6	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	6014	7	in	in	IN
18637	6014	8	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	6014	9	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	6014	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6014	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6014	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	6014	13	_	_	NNP
18637	6014	14	Western	Western	NNP
18637	6014	15	Md.	Md.	NNP
18637	6015	1	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	6015	2	.	.	.
18637	6016	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6016	2	,	,	,
18637	6016	3	242	242	CD
18637	6016	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6016	5	311	311	CD
18637	6016	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6016	7	1917	1917	CD
18637	6016	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6016	9	.	.	.
18637	6017	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6017	2	933	933	CD
18637	6017	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6017	4	Austin	Austin	NNP
18637	6017	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6017	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6017	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6017	8	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	6017	9	,	,	,
18637	6017	10	179	179	CD
18637	6017	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6017	12	343	343	CD
18637	6017	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6017	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	6017	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6017	16	.	.	.
18637	6018	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6018	2	934	934	CD
18637	6018	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6018	4	155	155	CD
18637	6018	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6018	6	461	461	CD
18637	6018	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6018	8	1894	1894	CD
18637	6018	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6018	10	.	.	.
18637	6019	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6019	2	935	935	CD
18637	6019	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6019	4	135	135	CD
18637	6019	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6019	6	100	100	CD
18637	6019	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6019	8	1890	1890	CD
18637	6019	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6019	10	.	.	.
18637	6020	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6020	2	936	936	CD
18637	6020	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6020	4	155	155	CD
18637	6020	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6020	6	at	at	IN
18637	6020	7	474	474	CD
18637	6020	8	.	.	.
18637	6021	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6021	2	937	937	CD
18637	6021	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6021	4	Schollenberger	Schollenberger	NNP
18637	6021	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6021	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6021	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6021	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	6021	9	,	,	,
18637	6021	10	171	171	CD
18637	6021	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6021	12	1	1	CD
18637	6021	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6021	14	1898	1898	CD
18637	6021	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6021	16	.	.	.
18637	6022	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6022	2	938	938	CD
18637	6022	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6022	4	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	6022	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6022	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6022	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6022	8	New	New	NNP
18637	6022	9	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	6022	10	,	,	,
18637	6022	11	171	171	CD
18637	6022	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6022	13	30	30	CD
18637	6022	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6022	15	1898	1898	CD
18637	6022	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6022	17	.	.	.
18637	6023	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6023	2	939	939	CD
18637	6023	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6023	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6023	5	See	See	NNP
18637	6023	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6023	7	note	note	NN
18637	6023	8	1	1	CD
18637	6023	9	above	above	RB
18637	6023	10	.	.	.
18637	6024	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6024	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	6024	3	's	's	POS
18637	6024	4	Note	note	NN
18637	6024	5	:	:	:
18637	6024	6	Reference	reference	NN
18637	6024	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	6024	8	to	to	IN
18637	6024	9	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	6024	10	933	933	CD
18637	6024	11	,	,	,
18637	6024	12	above	above	RB
18637	6024	13	.	.	.
18637	6024	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6025	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6025	2	940	940	CD
18637	6025	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6025	4	State	State	NNP
18637	6025	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	6025	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6025	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6025	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6025	9	Young	Young	NNP
18637	6025	10	's	's	POS
18637	6025	11	Market	Market	NNP
18637	6025	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6025	13	,	,	,
18637	6025	14	299	299	CD
18637	6025	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6025	16	59	59	CD
18637	6025	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6025	18	1936	1936	CD
18637	6025	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6025	20	;	;	:
18637	6025	21	Finch	Finch	NNP
18637	6025	22	&	&	CC
18637	6025	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6025	24	_	_	NNP
18637	6025	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	6025	26	_	_	NNP
18637	6025	27	McKittrick	McKittrick	NNP
18637	6025	28	,	,	,
18637	6025	29	305	305	CD
18637	6025	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6025	31	395	395	CD
18637	6025	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6025	33	1939	1939	CD
18637	6025	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6025	35	;	;	:
18637	6025	36	Brewing	Brewing	NNP
18637	6025	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6025	38	_	_	NNP
18637	6025	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	6025	40	_	_	NNP
18637	6025	41	Liquor	Liquor	NNP
18637	6025	42	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	6025	43	.	.	NNP
18637	6025	44	,	,	,
18637	6025	45	305	305	CD
18637	6025	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6025	47	391	391	CD
18637	6025	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6025	49	1939	1939	CD
18637	6025	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6025	51	;	;	:
18637	6025	52	Ziffrin	Ziffrin	NNP
18637	6025	53	,	,	,
18637	6025	54	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	6025	55	_	_	NNP
18637	6025	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	6025	57	_	_	NNP
18637	6025	58	Reeves	Reeves	NNP
18637	6025	59	,	,	,
18637	6025	60	308	308	CD
18637	6025	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6025	62	132	132	CD
18637	6025	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6025	64	1939	1939	CD
18637	6025	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6025	66	.	.	.
18637	6026	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6026	2	941	941	CD
18637	6026	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6026	4	Duckworth	Duckworth	NNP
18637	6026	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6026	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6026	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6026	8	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	6026	9	,	,	,
18637	6026	10	314	314	CD
18637	6026	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6026	12	390	390	CD
18637	6026	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6026	14	1941	1941	CD
18637	6026	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6026	16	;	;	:
18637	6026	17	followed	follow	VBN
18637	6026	18	in	in	IN
18637	6026	19	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	6026	20	_	_	NNP
18637	6026	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	6026	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6026	23	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	6026	24	,	,	,
18637	6026	25	321	321	CD
18637	6026	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6026	27	131	131	CD
18637	6026	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6026	29	1944	1944	CD
18637	6026	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6026	31	.	.	.
18637	6027	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6027	2	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	6027	3	would	would	MD
18637	6027	4	have	have	VB
18637	6027	5	preferred	prefer	VBN
18637	6027	6	to	to	TO
18637	6027	7	rest	rest	VB
18637	6027	8	the	the	DT
18637	6027	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	6027	10	on	on	IN
18637	6027	11	the	the	DT
18637	6027	12	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	6027	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	6027	14	first	first	NNP
18637	6027	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	6027	16	instead	instead	RB
18637	6027	17	of	of	IN
18637	6027	18	"	"	``
18637	6027	19	what	what	WP
18637	6027	20	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6027	21	regard	regard	VBP
18637	6027	22	as	as	IN
18637	6027	23	an	an	DT
18637	6027	24	unwise	unwise	JJ
18637	6027	25	extension	extension	NN
18637	6027	26	of	of	IN
18637	6027	27	State	State	NNP
18637	6027	28	power	power	NN
18637	6027	29	over	over	IN
18637	6027	30	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	6027	31	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	6027	32	,	,	,
18637	6027	33	"	"	''
18637	6027	34	314	314	CD
18637	6027	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6027	36	at	at	IN
18637	6027	37	397	397	CD
18637	6027	38	;	;	:
18637	6027	39	and	and	CC
18637	6027	40	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	6027	41	to	to	TO
18637	6027	42	have	have	VB
18637	6027	43	converted	convert	VBN
18637	6027	44	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6027	45	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	6027	46	.	.	.
18637	6028	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6028	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6028	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6028	4	latter	latter	NN
18637	6028	5	's	's	POS
18637	6028	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	6028	7	in	in	IN
18637	6028	8	321	321	CD
18637	6028	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6028	10	at	at	IN
18637	6028	11	139	139	CD
18637	6028	12	-	-	SYM
18637	6028	13	143	143	CD
18637	6028	14	.	.	.
18637	6029	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6029	2	942	942	CD
18637	6029	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6029	4	297	297	CD
18637	6029	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6029	6	431	431	CD
18637	6029	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6029	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	6029	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6029	10	.	.	.
18637	6030	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6030	2	943	943	CD
18637	6030	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6030	4	45	45	CD
18637	6030	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	6030	6	1084	1084	CD
18637	6030	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6030	8	1929	1929	CD
18637	6030	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6030	10	.	.	.
18637	6031	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6031	2	944	944	CD
18637	6031	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6031	4	297	297	CD
18637	6031	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6031	6	at	at	IN
18637	6031	7	440	440	CD
18637	6031	8	.	.	.
18637	6032	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6032	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6032	3	also	also	RB
18637	6032	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6032	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6032	6	Cardozo	Cardozo	NNP
18637	6032	7	's	's	POS
18637	6032	8	remarks	remark	NNS
18637	6032	9	in	in	IN
18637	6032	10	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	6032	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6032	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	6032	13	_	_	NNP
18637	6032	14	Seelig	Seelig	NNP
18637	6032	15	,	,	,
18637	6032	16	294	294	CD
18637	6032	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6032	18	511	511	CD
18637	6032	19	,	,	,
18637	6032	20	526	526	CD
18637	6032	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	6032	22	527	527	CD
18637	6032	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6032	24	1935	1935	CD
18637	6032	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6032	26	.	.	.
18637	6033	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6033	2	945	945	CD
18637	6033	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6033	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6033	5	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	6033	6	.	.	.
18637	6033	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6033	8	Plumley	Plumley	NNP
18637	6033	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6033	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6033	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6033	12	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	6033	13	,	,	,
18637	6033	14	155	155	CD
18637	6033	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6033	16	461	461	CD
18637	6033	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6033	18	1894	1894	CD
18637	6033	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6033	20	;	;	:
18637	6033	21	Savage	Savage	NNP
18637	6033	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6033	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	6033	24	_	_	NNP
18637	6033	25	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	6033	26	,	,	,
18637	6033	27	225	225	CD
18637	6033	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6033	29	501	501	CD
18637	6033	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6033	31	1912	1912	CD
18637	6033	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6033	33	;	;	:
18637	6033	34	Corn	Corn	NNP
18637	6033	35	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	6033	36	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	6033	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6033	38	_	_	NNP
18637	6033	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	6033	40	_	_	NNP
18637	6033	41	Eddy	Eddy	NNP
18637	6033	42	,	,	,
18637	6033	43	249	249	CD
18637	6033	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6033	45	427	427	CD
18637	6033	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6033	47	1919	1919	CD
18637	6033	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6033	49	.	.	.
18637	6034	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6034	2	946	946	CD
18637	6034	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6034	4	Elkison	Elkison	NNP
18637	6034	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6034	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6034	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6034	8	Deliesseline	Deliesseline	NNP
18637	6034	9	,	,	,
18637	6034	10	8	8	CD
18637	6034	11	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	6034	12	.	.	.
18637	6035	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	6035	2	.	.	.
18637	6036	1	No	no	UH
18637	6036	2	.	.	.
18637	6037	1	4366	4366	CD
18637	6037	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6037	3	1823	1823	CD
18637	6037	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6037	5	.	.	.
18637	6038	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6038	2	947	947	CD
18637	6038	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6038	4	For	for	IN
18637	6038	5	interesting	interesting	JJ
18637	6038	6	particulars	particular	NNS
18637	6038	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6038	8	see	see	VBP
18637	6038	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6038	10	2	2	CD
18637	6038	11	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	6038	12	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	6038	13	,	,	,
18637	6038	14	The	the	DT
18637	6038	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	6038	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	6038	17	in	in	IN
18637	6038	18	United	United	NNP
18637	6038	19	States	States	NNP
18637	6038	20	History	History	NNP
18637	6038	21	,	,	,
18637	6038	22	84	84	CD
18637	6038	23	-	-	SYM
18637	6038	24	87	87	CD
18637	6038	25	.	.	.
18637	6039	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6039	2	948	948	CD
18637	6039	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6039	4	1	1	CD
18637	6039	5	Op	op	NN
18637	6039	6	.	.	.
18637	6040	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	6040	2	.	.	.
18637	6041	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	6041	2	659	659	CD
18637	6041	3	.	.	.
18637	6042	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6042	2	949	949	CD
18637	6042	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6042	4	2	2	CD
18637	6042	5	Op	op	NN
18637	6042	6	.	.	.
18637	6043	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	6043	2	.	.	.
18637	6044	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	6044	2	426	426	CD
18637	6044	3	.	.	.
18637	6045	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6045	2	950	950	CD
18637	6045	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6045	4	11	11	CD
18637	6045	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	6045	6	.	.	.
18637	6046	1	102	102	CD
18637	6046	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6046	3	1837	1837	CD
18637	6046	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6046	5	.	.	.
18637	6047	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6047	2	951	951	CD
18637	6047	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6047	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	6047	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6047	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6047	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6047	8	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	6047	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6047	10	Passenger	Passenger	NNP
18637	6047	11	Cases	Cases	NNP
18637	6047	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6047	13	,	,	,
18637	6047	14	7	7	CD
18637	6047	15	How	how	WRB
18637	6047	16	.	.	.
18637	6048	1	283	283	CD
18637	6048	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6048	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	6048	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6048	5	.	.	.
18637	6049	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6049	2	952	952	CD
18637	6049	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6049	4	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	6049	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6049	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6049	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6049	8	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	6049	9	,	,	,
18637	6049	10	6	6	CD
18637	6049	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6049	12	.	.	.
18637	6050	1	35	35	CD
18637	6050	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6050	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	6050	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6050	5	.	.	.
18637	6051	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6051	2	953	953	CD
18637	6051	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6051	4	314	314	CD
18637	6051	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6051	6	160	160	CD
18637	6051	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6051	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	6051	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6051	10	.	.	.
18637	6052	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6052	2	954	954	CD
18637	6052	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6052	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6052	5	.	.	.
18637	6053	1	172	172	CD
18637	6053	2	.	.	.
18637	6054	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6054	2	955	955	CD
18637	6054	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6054	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6054	5	.	.	.
18637	6055	1	173	173	CD
18637	6055	2	.	.	.
18637	6056	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6056	2	Cardozo	Cardozo	NNP
18637	6056	3	's	's	POS
18637	6056	4	words	word	NNS
18637	6056	5	,	,	,
18637	6056	6	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	6056	7	by	by	IN
18637	6056	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6056	9	Byrnes	Byrnes	NNP
18637	6056	10	,	,	,
18637	6056	11	occur	occur	VBP
18637	6056	12	in	in	IN
18637	6056	13	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	6056	14	_	_	NNP
18637	6056	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	6056	16	_	_	NNP
18637	6056	17	Seelig	Seelig	NNP
18637	6056	18	,	,	,
18637	6056	19	294	294	CD
18637	6056	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6056	21	511	511	CD
18637	6056	22	,	,	,
18637	6056	23	523	523	CD
18637	6056	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6056	25	1935	1935	CD
18637	6056	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6056	27	.	.	.
18637	6057	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6057	2	Byrnes	Byrnes	NNP
18637	6057	3	'	'	POS
18637	6057	4	answer	answer	NN
18637	6057	5	to	to	IN
18637	6057	6	another	another	DT
18637	6057	7	argument	argument	NN
18637	6057	8	of	of	IN
18637	6057	9	the	the	DT
18637	6057	10	State	State	NNP
18637	6057	11	,	,	,
18637	6057	12	based	base	VBN
18637	6057	13	on	on	IN
18637	6057	14	historical	historical	JJ
18637	6057	15	conceptions	conception	NNS
18637	6057	16	of	of	IN
18637	6057	17	the	the	DT
18637	6057	18	word	word	NN
18637	6057	19	"	"	``
18637	6057	20	indigent	indigent	JJ
18637	6057	21	,	,	,
18637	6057	22	"	"	''
18637	6057	23	was	be	VBD
18637	6057	24	,	,	,
18637	6057	25	"	"	``
18637	6057	26	poverty	poverty	NN
18637	6057	27	and	and	CC
18637	6057	28	immorality	immorality	NN
18637	6057	29	are	be	VBP
18637	6057	30	not	not	RB
18637	6057	31	synonymous	synonymous	JJ
18637	6057	32	.	.	.
18637	6057	33	"	"	''
18637	6058	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6058	2	956	956	CD
18637	6058	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6058	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6058	5	See	See	NNP
18637	6058	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6058	7	especially	especially	RB
18637	6058	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6058	9	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	6058	10	'	'	POS
18637	6058	11	forceful	forceful	JJ
18637	6058	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	6058	13	.	.	.
18637	6059	1	314	314	CD
18637	6059	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6059	3	177	177	CD
18637	6059	4	-	-	SYM
18637	6059	5	181	181	CD
18637	6059	6	.	.	.
18637	6060	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6060	2	957	957	CD
18637	6060	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6060	4	161	161	CD
18637	6060	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6060	6	519	519	CD
18637	6060	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6060	8	1896	1896	CD
18637	6060	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6060	10	.	.	.
18637	6061	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6061	2	958	958	CD
18637	6061	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6061	4	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	6061	5	County	County	NNP
18637	6061	6	Water	Water	NNP
18637	6061	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6061	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6061	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	6061	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6061	11	McCarter	McCarter	NNP
18637	6061	12	,	,	,
18637	6061	13	209	209	CD
18637	6061	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6061	15	349	349	CD
18637	6061	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6061	17	1908	1908	CD
18637	6061	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6061	19	.	.	.
18637	6062	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6062	2	959	959	CD
18637	6062	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6062	4	221	221	CD
18637	6062	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6062	6	229	229	CD
18637	6062	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6062	8	1911	1911	CD
18637	6062	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6062	10	.	.	.
18637	6063	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6063	2	960	960	CD
18637	6063	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6063	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6063	5	.	.	.
18637	6064	1	255	255	CD
18637	6064	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6064	3	256	256	CD
18637	6064	4	.	.	.
18637	6065	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6065	2	961	961	CD
18637	6065	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6065	4	262	262	CD
18637	6065	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6065	6	553	553	CD
18637	6065	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6065	8	1923	1923	CD
18637	6065	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6065	10	.	.	.
18637	6066	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6066	2	962	962	CD
18637	6066	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6066	4	237	237	CD
18637	6066	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6066	6	52	52	CD
18637	6066	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6066	8	1915	1915	CD
18637	6066	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6066	10	.	.	.
18637	6067	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6067	2	963	963	CD
18637	6067	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6067	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6067	5	.	.	.
18637	6068	1	61	61	CD
18637	6068	2	.	.	.
18637	6069	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6069	2	964	964	CD
18637	6069	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6069	4	258	258	CD
18637	6069	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6069	6	50	50	CD
18637	6069	7	,	,	,
18637	6069	8	61	61	CD
18637	6069	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6069	10	1922	1922	CD
18637	6069	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6069	12	.	.	.
18637	6070	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6070	2	965	965	CD
18637	6070	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6070	4	258	258	CD
18637	6070	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6070	6	50	50	CD
18637	6070	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6070	8	1922	1922	CD
18637	6070	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6070	10	;	;	:
18637	6070	11	66	66	CD
18637	6070	12	L.	L.	NNP
18637	6070	13	Ed	Ed	NNP
18637	6070	14	.	.	.
18637	6071	1	458	458	CD
18637	6071	2	,	,	,
18637	6071	3	Hd	hd	UH
18637	6071	4	.	.	.
18637	6072	1	2	2	LS
18637	6072	2	.	.	.
18637	6073	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6073	2	966	966	CD
18637	6073	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6073	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6073	5	See	See	NNP
18637	6073	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6073	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	6073	8	.	.	.
18637	6074	1	193	193	CD
18637	6074	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6074	3	195	195	CD
18637	6074	4	.	.	.
18637	6075	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6075	2	967	967	CD
18637	6075	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6075	4	291	291	CD
18637	6075	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6075	6	502	502	CD
18637	6075	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6075	8	1934	1934	CD
18637	6075	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6075	10	;	;	:
18637	6075	11	followed	follow	VBN
18637	6075	12	in	in	IN
18637	6075	13	Hegeman	Hegeman	NNP
18637	6075	14	Farms	Farms	NNP
18637	6075	15	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6075	16	_	_	NNP
18637	6075	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	6075	18	_	_	NNP
18637	6075	19	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	6075	20	,	,	,
18637	6075	21	293	293	CD
18637	6075	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6075	23	163	163	CD
18637	6075	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6075	25	1934	1934	CD
18637	6075	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6075	27	.	.	.
18637	6076	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6076	2	968	968	CD
18637	6076	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6076	4	294	294	CD
18637	6076	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6076	6	511	511	CD
18637	6076	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6076	8	1935	1935	CD
18637	6076	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6076	10	.	.	.
18637	6077	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6077	2	969	969	CD
18637	6077	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6077	4	Milk	milk	NN
18637	6077	5	Control	Control	NNP
18637	6077	6	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	6077	7	.	.	.
18637	6078	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6078	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	6078	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6078	4	Eisenberg	Eisenberg	NNP
18637	6078	5	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	6078	6	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	6078	7	,	,	,
18637	6078	8	306	306	CD
18637	6078	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6078	10	346	346	CD
18637	6078	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6078	12	1939	1939	CD
18637	6078	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6078	14	.	.	.
18637	6079	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6079	2	970	970	CD
18637	6079	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6079	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6079	5	.	.	.
18637	6080	1	352	352	CD
18637	6080	2	.	.	.
18637	6081	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6081	2	971	971	CD
18637	6081	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6081	4	Hood	Hood	NNP
18637	6081	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6081	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6081	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6081	8	Du	Du	NNP
18637	6081	9	Mond	Mond	NNP
18637	6081	10	,	,	,
18637	6081	11	336	336	CD
18637	6081	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6081	13	525	525	CD
18637	6081	14	,	,	,
18637	6081	15	535	535	CD
18637	6081	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6081	17	1949	1949	CD
18637	6081	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6081	19	.	.	.
18637	6082	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6082	2	972	972	CD
18637	6082	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6082	4	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	6082	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	6082	6	Fountain	Fountain	NNP
18637	6082	7	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	6082	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6082	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6082	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6082	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6082	12	Haydel	Haydel	NNP
18637	6082	13	,	,	,
18637	6082	14	278	278	CD
18637	6082	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6082	16	1	1	CD
18637	6082	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6082	18	1928	1928	CD
18637	6082	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6082	20	.	.	.
18637	6083	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6083	2	973	973	CD
18637	6083	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6083	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6083	5	.	.	.
18637	6084	1	13	13	CD
18637	6084	2	.	.	.
18637	6085	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6085	2	974	974	CD
18637	6085	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6085	4	Toomer	Toomer	NNP
18637	6085	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6085	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6085	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6085	8	Witsell	Witsell	NNP
18637	6085	9	,	,	,
18637	6085	10	334	334	CD
18637	6085	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6085	12	385	385	CD
18637	6085	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6085	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	6085	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6085	16	.	.	.
18637	6086	1	Other	other	JJ
18637	6086	2	features	feature	NNS
18637	6086	3	of	of	IN
18637	6086	4	the	the	DT
18637	6086	5	South	South	NNP
18637	6086	6	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	6086	7	act	act	NN
18637	6086	8	were	be	VBD
18637	6086	9	found	find	VBN
18637	6086	10	to	to	TO
18637	6086	11	violate	violate	VB
18637	6086	12	article	article	NN
18637	6086	13	IV	IV	NNP
18637	6086	14	,	,	,
18637	6086	15	section	section	NN
18637	6086	16	2	2	CD
18637	6086	17	.	.	.
18637	6087	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6087	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6087	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6087	4	p.	p.	NN
18637	6087	5	690	690	CD
18637	6087	6	.	.	.
18637	6088	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6088	2	975	975	CD
18637	6088	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6088	4	Bayside	Bayside	NNP
18637	6088	5	Fish	Fish	NNP
18637	6088	6	Flour	Flour	NNP
18637	6088	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6088	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6088	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	6088	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6088	11	Gentry	Gentry	NNP
18637	6088	12	,	,	,
18637	6088	13	297	297	CD
18637	6088	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6088	15	422	422	CD
18637	6088	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6088	17	1936	1936	CD
18637	6088	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6088	19	.	.	.
18637	6089	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6089	2	976	976	CD
18637	6089	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6089	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6089	5	.	.	.
18637	6090	1	426	426	CD
18637	6090	2	,	,	,
18637	6090	3	citing	cite	VBG
18637	6090	4	Silz	Silz	NNP
18637	6090	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6090	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6090	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6090	8	Hesterberg	Hesterberg	NNP
18637	6090	9	,	,	,
18637	6090	10	211	211	CD
18637	6090	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6090	12	31	31	CD
18637	6090	13	,	,	,
18637	6090	14	39	39	CD
18637	6090	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6090	16	1908	1908	CD
18637	6090	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6090	18	.	.	.
18637	6091	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6091	2	977	977	CD
18637	6091	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6091	4	34	34	CD
18637	6091	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6091	6	.	.	.
18637	6092	1	584	584	CD
18637	6092	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6092	3	1906	1906	CD
18637	6092	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6092	5	.	.	.
18637	6093	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6093	2	978	978	CD
18637	6093	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6093	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	6093	5	,	,	,
18637	6093	6	I.	I.	NNP
18637	6094	1	&	&	CC
18637	6094	2	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	6095	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6095	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6095	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6095	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6095	5	United	United	NNP
18637	6095	6	States	States	NNP
18637	6095	7	,	,	,
18637	6095	8	219	219	CD
18637	6095	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6095	10	486	486	CD
18637	6095	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6095	12	1911	1911	CD
18637	6095	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6095	14	.	.	.
18637	6096	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6096	2	979	979	CD
18637	6096	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6096	4	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	6096	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	6096	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6096	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6096	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6096	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6096	10	Reid	Reid	NNP
18637	6096	11	,	,	,
18637	6096	12	222	222	CD
18637	6096	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6096	14	424	424	CD
18637	6096	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6096	16	1912	1912	CD
18637	6096	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6096	18	;	;	:
18637	6096	19	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	6096	20	R.	R.	NNP
18637	6096	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6096	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6096	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	6096	24	_	_	NNP
18637	6096	25	Burlington	Burlington	NNP
18637	6096	26	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	6096	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6096	28	,	,	,
18637	6096	29	225	225	CD
18637	6096	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6096	31	99	99	CD
18637	6096	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6096	33	1912	1912	CD
18637	6096	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6096	35	.	.	.
18637	6097	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6097	2	980	980	CD
18637	6097	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6097	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	6097	5	,	,	,
18637	6097	6	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	6097	7	&	&	CC
18637	6097	8	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	6098	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6098	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6098	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6098	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6098	5	Hardwick	Hardwick	NNP
18637	6098	6	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	6098	7	Elevator	Elevator	NNP
18637	6098	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6098	9	,	,	,
18637	6098	10	226	226	CD
18637	6098	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6098	12	426	426	CD
18637	6098	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6098	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	6098	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6098	16	.	.	.
18637	6099	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6099	2	981	981	CD
18637	6099	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6099	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	6099	5	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	6099	6	,	,	,
18637	6099	7	I.M.	I.M.	NNP
18637	6100	1	&	&	CC
18637	6100	2	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	6101	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6101	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6101	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6101	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6101	5	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	6101	6	,	,	,
18637	6101	7	227	227	CD
18637	6101	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6101	9	265	265	CD
18637	6101	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6101	11	1913	1913	CD
18637	6101	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6101	13	.	.	.
18637	6102	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6102	2	982	982	CD
18637	6102	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6102	4	Yazoo	Yazoo	NNP
18637	6102	5	&	&	CC
18637	6102	6	M.V.R.	M.V.R.	NNP
18637	6103	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6103	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6103	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6103	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6103	5	Greenwood	Greenwood	NNP
18637	6103	6	Grocery	Grocery	NNP
18637	6103	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6103	8	,	,	,
18637	6103	9	227	227	CD
18637	6103	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6103	11	1	1	CD
18637	6103	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6103	13	1913	1913	CD
18637	6103	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6103	15	.	.	.
18637	6104	1	In	in	IN
18637	6104	2	this	this	DT
18637	6104	3	case	case	NN
18637	6104	4	the	the	DT
18637	6104	5	severity	severity	NN
18637	6104	6	of	of	IN
18637	6104	7	the	the	DT
18637	6104	8	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	6104	9	furnished	furnish	VBD
18637	6104	10	additional	additional	JJ
18637	6104	11	reason	reason	NN
18637	6104	12	for	for	IN
18637	6104	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	6104	14	disallowance	disallowance	NN
18637	6104	15	.	.	.
18637	6105	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6105	2	983	983	CD
18637	6105	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6105	4	226	226	CD
18637	6105	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6105	6	491	491	CD
18637	6105	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6105	8	1913	1913	CD
18637	6105	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6105	10	.	.	.
18637	6106	1	For	for	IN
18637	6106	2	the	the	DT
18637	6106	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	6106	4	's	's	POS
18637	6106	5	reiteration	reiteration	NN
18637	6106	6	of	of	IN
18637	6106	7	the	the	DT
18637	6106	8	formula	formula	NN
18637	6106	9	governing	govern	VBG
18637	6106	10	such	such	JJ
18637	6106	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	6106	12	,	,	,
18637	6106	13	_	_	NNP
18637	6106	14	see	see	VBP
18637	6106	15	_	_	NNP
18637	6106	16	ibid	ibid	NNP
18637	6106	17	.	.	.
18637	6107	1	505	505	CD
18637	6107	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6107	3	506	506	CD
18637	6107	4	.	.	.
18637	6108	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6108	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6108	3	also	also	RB
18637	6108	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6108	5	Barrett	Barrett	NNP
18637	6108	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6108	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6108	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6108	9	New	New	NNP
18637	6108	10	York	York	NNP
18637	6108	11	,	,	,
18637	6108	12	232	232	CD
18637	6108	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6108	14	14	14	CD
18637	6108	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6108	16	1914	1914	CD
18637	6108	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6108	18	;	;	:
18637	6108	19	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	6108	20	,	,	,
18637	6108	21	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	6108	22	&	&	CC
18637	6108	23	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	6109	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6109	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6109	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6109	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6109	5	Cramer	Cramer	NNP
18637	6109	6	,	,	,
18637	6109	7	232	232	CD
18637	6109	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6109	9	490	490	CD
18637	6109	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6109	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	6109	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6109	13	;	;	:
18637	6109	14	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	6109	15	,	,	,
18637	6109	16	T.	T.	NNP
18637	6109	17	&	&	CC
18637	6109	18	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	6110	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6110	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6110	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6110	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6110	5	Harold	Harold	NNP
18637	6110	6	,	,	,
18637	6110	7	241	241	CD
18637	6110	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6110	9	371	371	CD
18637	6110	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6110	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	6110	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6110	13	;	;	:
18637	6110	14	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	6110	15	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	6111	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6111	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6111	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6111	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6111	5	Porter	Porter	NNP
18637	6111	6	,	,	,
18637	6111	7	273	273	CD
18637	6111	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6111	9	341	341	CD
18637	6111	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6111	11	1927	1927	CD
18637	6111	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6111	13	.	.	.
18637	6112	1	A	a	DT
18637	6112	2	year	year	NN
18637	6112	3	before	before	IN
18637	6112	4	the	the	DT
18637	6112	5	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	6112	6	of	of	IN
18637	6112	7	the	the	DT
18637	6112	8	Carmack	Carmack	NNP
18637	6112	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	6112	10	the	the	DT
18637	6112	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	6112	12	had	have	VBD
18637	6112	13	held	hold	VBN
18637	6112	14	that	that	IN
18637	6112	15	the	the	DT
18637	6112	16	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	6112	17	by	by	IN
18637	6112	18	a	a	DT
18637	6112	19	State	state	NN
18637	6112	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	6112	21	the	the	DT
18637	6112	22	initial	initial	JJ
18637	6112	23	or	or	CC
18637	6112	24	any	any	DT
18637	6112	25	connecting	connect	VBG
18637	6112	26	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	6112	27	of	of	IN
18637	6112	28	the	the	DT
18637	6112	29	duty	duty	NN
18637	6112	30	of	of	IN
18637	6112	31	tracing	trace	VBG
18637	6112	32	the	the	DT
18637	6112	33	freight	freight	NN
18637	6112	34	and	and	CC
18637	6112	35	informing	inform	VBG
18637	6112	36	the	the	DT
18637	6112	37	shipper	shipper	NN
18637	6112	38	in	in	IN
18637	6112	39	writing	writing	NN
18637	6112	40	when	when	WRB
18637	6112	41	,	,	,
18637	6112	42	where	where	WRB
18637	6112	43	,	,	,
18637	6112	44	how	how	WRB
18637	6112	45	,	,	,
18637	6112	46	and	and	CC
18637	6112	47	by	by	IN
18637	6112	48	which	which	WDT
18637	6112	49	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	6112	50	the	the	DT
18637	6112	51	freight	freight	NN
18637	6112	52	was	be	VBD
18637	6112	53	lost	lose	VBN
18637	6112	54	,	,	,
18637	6112	55	damaged	damage	VBN
18637	6112	56	,	,	,
18637	6112	57	or	or	CC
18637	6112	58	destroyed	destroy	VBN
18637	6112	59	,	,	,
18637	6112	60	and	and	CC
18637	6112	61	of	of	IN
18637	6112	62	giving	give	VBG
18637	6112	63	the	the	DT
18637	6112	64	names	name	NNS
18637	6112	65	of	of	IN
18637	6112	66	the	the	DT
18637	6112	67	parties	party	NNS
18637	6112	68	and	and	CC
18637	6112	69	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	6112	70	official	official	JJ
18637	6112	71	position	position	NN
18637	6112	72	,	,	,
18637	6112	73	by	by	IN
18637	6112	74	whom	whom	WP
18637	6112	75	the	the	DT
18637	6112	76	truth	truth	NN
18637	6112	77	of	of	IN
18637	6112	78	the	the	DT
18637	6112	79	facts	fact	NNS
18637	6112	80	set	set	VBN
18637	6112	81	out	out	RP
18637	6112	82	in	in	IN
18637	6112	83	the	the	DT
18637	6112	84	information	information	NN
18637	6112	85	could	could	MD
18637	6112	86	be	be	VB
18637	6112	87	established	establish	VBN
18637	6112	88	,	,	,
18637	6112	89	was	be	VBD
18637	6112	90	,	,	,
18637	6112	91	when	when	WRB
18637	6112	92	applied	apply	VBN
18637	6112	93	to	to	IN
18637	6112	94	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	6112	95	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	6112	96	,	,	,
18637	6112	97	a	a	DT
18637	6112	98	violation	violation	NN
18637	6112	99	of	of	IN
18637	6112	100	the	the	DT
18637	6112	101	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	6112	102	clause	clause	NN
18637	6112	103	.	.	.
18637	6113	1	Central	Central	NNP
18637	6113	2	of	of	IN
18637	6113	3	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	6113	4	R.	R.	NNP
18637	6113	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6113	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6113	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6113	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6113	9	Murphey	Murphey	NNP
18637	6113	10	,	,	,
18637	6113	11	196	196	CD
18637	6113	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6113	13	194	194	CD
18637	6113	14	,	,	,
18637	6113	15	202	202	CD
18637	6113	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6113	17	1905	1905	CD
18637	6113	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6113	19	.	.	.
18637	6114	1	The	the	DT
18637	6114	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	6114	3	's	's	POS
18637	6114	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	6114	5	definitely	definitely	RB
18637	6114	6	invited	invite	VBD
18637	6114	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	6114	8	to	to	TO
18637	6114	9	deal	deal	VB
18637	6114	10	with	with	IN
18637	6114	11	the	the	DT
18637	6114	12	subject	subject	NN
18637	6114	13	,	,	,
18637	6114	14	as	as	IN
18637	6114	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6114	16	does	do	VBZ
18637	6114	17	in	in	IN
18637	6114	18	the	the	DT
18637	6114	19	Carmack	Carmack	NNP
18637	6114	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	6114	21	.	.	.
18637	6115	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6115	2	984	984	CD
18637	6115	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6115	4	35	35	CD
18637	6115	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6115	6	.	.	.
18637	6116	1	65	65	CD
18637	6116	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6116	3	1908	1908	CD
18637	6116	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6116	5	;	;	:
18637	6116	6	36	36	CD
18637	6116	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	6116	8	.	.	.
18637	6117	1	291	291	CD
18637	6117	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6117	3	1910	1910	CD
18637	6117	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6117	5	.	.	.
18637	6118	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6118	2	985	985	CD
18637	6118	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6118	4	34	34	CD
18637	6118	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6118	6	.	.	.
18637	6119	1	1415	1415	CD
18637	6119	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6119	3	1907	1907	CD
18637	6119	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6119	5	.	.	.
18637	6120	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6120	2	986	986	CD
18637	6120	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6120	4	27	27	CD
18637	6120	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	6120	6	.	.	.
18637	6121	1	531	531	CD
18637	6121	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6121	3	1893	1893	CD
18637	6121	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6121	5	;	;	:
18637	6121	6	32	32	CD
18637	6121	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	6121	8	.	.	.
18637	6122	1	943	943	CD
18637	6122	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6122	3	1903	1903	CD
18637	6122	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6122	5	.	.	.
18637	6123	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6123	2	987	987	CD
18637	6123	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6123	4	Mondou	Mondou	NNP
18637	6123	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6123	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6123	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6123	8	New	New	NNP
18637	6123	9	York	York	NNP
18637	6123	10	,	,	,
18637	6123	11	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	6123	12	&	&	CC
18637	6123	13	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	6124	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6124	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6124	3	Second	Second	NNP
18637	6124	4	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	6124	5	'	'	POS
18637	6124	6	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	6124	7	Cases	case	NNS
18637	6124	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6124	9	,	,	,
18637	6124	10	223	223	CD
18637	6124	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6124	12	1	1	CD
18637	6124	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6124	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	6124	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6124	16	;	;	:
18637	6124	17	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	6124	18	R.	R.	NNP
18637	6124	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6124	20	_	_	NNP
18637	6124	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	6124	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6124	23	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	6124	24	Com	Com	NNP
18637	6124	25	.	.	NNP
18637	6124	26	,	,	,
18637	6124	27	236	236	CD
18637	6124	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6124	29	439	439	CD
18637	6124	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6124	31	1915	1915	CD
18637	6124	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6124	33	.	.	.
18637	6125	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6125	2	988	988	CD
18637	6125	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6125	4	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	6125	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	6125	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6125	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6125	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6125	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6125	10	New	New	NNP
18637	6125	11	York	York	NNP
18637	6125	12	,	,	,
18637	6125	13	233	233	CD
18637	6125	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6125	15	671	671	CD
18637	6125	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6125	17	1914	1914	CD
18637	6125	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6125	19	.	.	.
18637	6126	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6126	2	989	989	CD
18637	6126	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6126	4	26	26	CD
18637	6126	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6126	6	.	.	.
18637	6127	1	414	414	CD
18637	6127	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6127	3	1890	1890	CD
18637	6127	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6127	5	.	.	.
18637	6128	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6128	2	990	990	CD
18637	6128	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6128	4	Crossman	Crossman	NNP
18637	6128	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6128	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6128	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6128	8	Lurman	Lurman	NNP
18637	6128	9	,	,	,
18637	6128	10	192	192	CD
18637	6128	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6128	12	189	189	CD
18637	6128	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6128	14	1904	1904	CD
18637	6128	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6128	16	.	.	.
18637	6129	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6129	2	991	991	CD
18637	6129	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6129	4	34	34	CD
18637	6129	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6129	6	.	.	.
18637	6130	1	768	768	CD
18637	6130	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6130	3	1906	1906	CD
18637	6130	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6130	5	;	;	:
18637	6130	6	Savage	Savage	NNP
18637	6130	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6130	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6130	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6130	10	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	6130	11	,	,	,
18637	6130	12	225	225	CD
18637	6130	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6130	14	501	501	CD
18637	6130	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6130	16	1912	1912	CD
18637	6130	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6130	18	,	,	,
18637	6130	19	citing	cite	VBG
18637	6130	20	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	6130	21	,	,	,
18637	6130	22	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	6130	23	&	&	CC
18637	6130	24	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	6130	25	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	6130	26	.	.	.
18637	6131	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6131	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6131	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6131	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6131	5	Haber	Haber	NNP
18637	6131	6	,	,	,
18637	6131	7	169	169	CD
18637	6131	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6131	9	613	613	CD
18637	6131	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6131	11	1898	1898	CD
18637	6131	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6131	13	;	;	:
18637	6131	14	Reid	Reid	NNP
18637	6131	15	_	_	NNP
18637	6131	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	6131	17	_	_	NNP
18637	6131	18	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	6131	19	,	,	,
18637	6131	20	187	187	CD
18637	6131	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6131	22	137	137	CD
18637	6131	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6131	24	1902	1902	CD
18637	6131	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6131	26	;	;	:
18637	6131	27	Asbell	Asbell	NNP
18637	6131	28	_	_	NNP
18637	6131	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	6131	30	_	_	NNP
18637	6131	31	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	6131	32	,	,	,
18637	6131	33	209	209	CD
18637	6131	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6131	35	251	251	CD
18637	6131	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6131	37	1908	1908	CD
18637	6131	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6131	39	;	;	:
18637	6131	40	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	6131	41	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	6131	42	.	.	.
18637	6132	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6132	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6132	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6132	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6132	5	Reid	Reid	NNP
18637	6132	6	,	,	,
18637	6132	7	222	222	CD
18637	6132	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6132	9	424	424	CD
18637	6132	10	,	,	,
18637	6132	11	442	442	CD
18637	6132	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6132	13	1912	1912	CD
18637	6132	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6132	15	.	.	.
18637	6133	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6133	2	992	992	CD
18637	6133	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6133	4	McDermott	McDermott	NNP
18637	6133	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6133	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6133	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6133	8	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	6133	9	,	,	,
18637	6133	10	228	228	CD
18637	6133	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6133	12	115	115	CD
18637	6133	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6133	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	6133	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6133	16	.	.	.
18637	6134	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6134	2	993	993	CD
18637	6134	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6134	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6134	5	.	.	.
18637	6135	1	137	137	CD
18637	6135	2	.	.	.
18637	6136	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6136	2	994	994	CD
18637	6136	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6136	4	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	6136	5	&	&	CC
18637	6136	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6136	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6136	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6136	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6136	10	North	North	NNP
18637	6136	11	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	6136	12	,	,	,
18637	6136	13	240	240	CD
18637	6136	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6136	15	510	510	CD
18637	6136	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6136	17	1916	1916	CD
18637	6136	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6136	19	.	.	.
18637	6137	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6137	2	995	995	CD
18637	6137	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6137	4	37	37	CD
18637	6137	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6137	6	.	.	.
18637	6138	1	315	315	CD
18637	6138	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6138	3	1912	1912	CD
18637	6138	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6138	5	;	;	:
18637	6138	6	39	39	CD
18637	6138	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	6138	8	.	.	.
18637	6139	1	1165	1165	CD
18637	6139	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6139	3	1917	1917	CD
18637	6139	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6139	5	.	.	.
18637	6140	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6140	2	996	996	CD
18637	6140	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6140	4	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	6140	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	6140	6	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	6140	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	6140	8	&	&	CC
18637	6140	9	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	6140	10	.	.	.
18637	6141	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6141	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6141	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6141	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6141	5	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	6141	6	,	,	,
18637	6141	7	270	270	CD
18637	6141	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6141	9	87	87	CD
18637	6141	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6141	11	1926	1926	CD
18637	6141	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6141	13	.	.	.
18637	6142	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6142	2	997	997	CD
18637	6142	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6142	4	44	44	CD
18637	6142	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	6142	6	.	.	.
18637	6143	1	250	250	CD
18637	6143	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6143	3	1926	1926	CD
18637	6143	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6143	5	.	.	.
18637	6144	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6144	2	998	998	CD
18637	6144	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6144	4	Mintz	Mintz	NNP
18637	6144	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6144	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6144	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6144	8	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	6144	9	,	,	,
18637	6144	10	289	289	CD
18637	6144	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6144	12	346	346	CD
18637	6144	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6144	14	1933	1933	CD
18637	6144	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6144	16	.	.	.
18637	6145	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6145	2	999	999	CD
18637	6145	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6145	4	32	32	CD
18637	6145	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6145	6	.	.	.
18637	6146	1	791	791	CD
18637	6146	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6146	3	1903	1903	CD
18637	6146	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6146	5	;	;	:
18637	6146	6	33	33	CD
18637	6146	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	6146	8	.	.	.
18637	6147	1	1264	1264	CD
18637	6147	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6147	3	1905	1905	CD
18637	6147	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6147	5	.	.	.
18637	6148	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6148	2	1000	1000	CD
18637	6148	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6148	4	Townsend	Townsend	NNP
18637	6148	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6148	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6148	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6148	8	Yeomans	Yeomans	NNPS
18637	6148	9	,	,	,
18637	6148	10	301	301	CD
18637	6148	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6148	12	441	441	CD
18637	6148	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6148	14	1937	1937	CD
18637	6148	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6148	16	.	.	.
18637	6149	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6149	2	1001	1001	CD
18637	6149	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6149	4	49	49	CD
18637	6149	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6149	6	.	.	.
18637	6150	1	731	731	CD
18637	6150	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6150	3	1935	1935	CD
18637	6150	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6150	5	.	.	.
18637	6151	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6151	2	1002	1002	CD
18637	6151	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6151	4	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	6151	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	6151	6	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	6151	7	Local	Local	NNP
18637	6151	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6151	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	6151	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6151	11	Employment	Employment	NNP
18637	6151	12	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	6151	13	Board	Board	NNP
18637	6151	14	,	,	,
18637	6151	15	315	315	CD
18637	6151	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6151	17	740	740	CD
18637	6151	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6151	19	1942	1942	CD
18637	6151	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6151	21	.	.	.
18637	6152	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6152	2	1003	1003	CD
18637	6152	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6152	4	49	49	CD
18637	6152	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	6152	6	.	.	.
18637	6153	1	449	449	CD
18637	6153	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6153	3	1935	1935	CD
18637	6153	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6153	5	.	.	.
18637	6154	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6154	2	1004	1004	CD
18637	6154	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6154	4	Quoting	Quoting	NNP
18637	6154	5	Napier	Napier	NNP
18637	6154	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6154	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6154	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6154	9	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	6154	10	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	6154	11	Line	Line	NNP
18637	6154	12	R.	R.	NNP
18637	6154	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6154	14	,	,	,
18637	6154	15	272	272	CD
18637	6154	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6154	17	605	605	CD
18637	6154	18	,	,	,
18637	6154	19	611	611	CD
18637	6154	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6154	21	1926	1926	CD
18637	6154	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6154	23	.	.	.
18637	6155	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6155	2	1005	1005	CD
18637	6155	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6155	4	Parker	Parker	NNP
18637	6155	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6155	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6155	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6155	8	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	6155	9	,	,	,
18637	6155	10	317	317	CD
18637	6155	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6155	12	341	341	CD
18637	6155	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6155	14	1943	1943	CD
18637	6155	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6155	16	.	.	.
18637	6156	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6156	2	1006	1006	CD
18637	6156	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6156	4	50	50	CD
18637	6156	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6156	6	.	.	.
18637	6157	1	246	246	CD
18637	6157	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6157	3	1937	1937	CD
18637	6157	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6157	5	.	.	.
18637	6158	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6158	2	1007	1007	CD
18637	6158	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6158	4	317	317	CD
18637	6158	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6158	6	at	at	IN
18637	6158	7	368	368	CD
18637	6158	8	.	.	.
18637	6159	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6159	2	1008	1008	CD
18637	6159	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6159	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6159	5	.	.	.
18637	6160	1	362	362	CD
18637	6160	2	.	.	.
18637	6161	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6161	2	1009	1009	CD
18637	6161	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6161	4	Union	Union	NNP
18637	6161	5	Brokerage	Brokerage	NNP
18637	6161	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6161	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6161	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6161	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6161	10	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	6161	11	,	,	,
18637	6161	12	322	322	CD
18637	6161	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6161	14	202	202	CD
18637	6161	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6161	16	1944	1944	CD
18637	6161	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6161	18	.	.	.
18637	6162	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6162	2	1010	1010	CD
18637	6162	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6162	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6162	5	.	.	.
18637	6163	1	211	211	CD
18637	6163	2	.	.	.
18637	6164	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6164	2	1011	1011	CD
18637	6164	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6164	4	Panhandle	Panhandle	NNP
18637	6164	5	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	6164	6	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	6164	7	Line	Line	NNP
18637	6164	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6164	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6164	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6164	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6164	12	Public	Public	NNP
18637	6164	13	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	6164	14	.	.	.
18637	6165	1	Com	com	NN
18637	6165	2	.	.	.
18637	6166	1	of	of	IN
18637	6166	2	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	6166	3	,	,	,
18637	6166	4	332	332	CD
18637	6166	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6166	6	507	507	CD
18637	6166	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6166	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	6166	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6166	10	;	;	:
18637	6166	11	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	6166	12	_	_	NNP
18637	6166	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	6166	14	_	_	NNP
18637	6166	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	6166	16	Board	Board	NNP
18637	6166	17	of	of	IN
18637	6166	18	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	6166	19	,	,	,
18637	6166	20	331	331	CD
18637	6166	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6166	22	247	247	CD
18637	6166	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6166	24	1947	1947	CD
18637	6166	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6166	26	.	.	.
18637	6167	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6167	2	1012	1012	CD
18637	6167	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6167	4	52	52	CD
18637	6167	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6167	6	.	.	.
18637	6168	1	821	821	CD
18637	6168	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6168	3	1938	1938	CD
18637	6168	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6168	5	.	.	.
18637	6169	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6169	2	1013	1013	CD
18637	6169	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6169	4	49	49	CD
18637	6169	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6169	6	.	.	.
18637	6170	1	1491	1491	CD
18637	6170	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6170	3	1936	1936	CD
18637	6170	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6170	5	.	.	.
18637	6171	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6171	2	1014	1014	CD
18637	6171	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6171	4	49	49	CD
18637	6171	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6171	6	.	.	.
18637	6172	1	543	543	CD
18637	6172	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6172	3	1935	1935	CD
18637	6172	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6172	5	;	;	:
18637	6172	6	54	54	CD
18637	6172	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	6172	8	.	.	.
18637	6173	1	919	919	CD
18637	6173	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	6173	3	920	920	CD
18637	6173	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6173	5	1940	1940	CD
18637	6173	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6173	7	.	.	.
18637	6174	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6174	2	1015	1015	CD
18637	6174	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6174	4	California	California	NNP
18637	6174	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6174	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6174	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6174	8	Zook	Zook	NNP
18637	6174	9	,	,	,
18637	6174	10	336	336	CD
18637	6174	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6174	12	725	725	CD
18637	6174	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6174	14	1949	1949	CD
18637	6174	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6174	16	.	.	.
18637	6175	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6175	2	1016	1016	CD
18637	6175	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6175	4	52	52	CD
18637	6175	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6175	6	.	.	.
18637	6176	1	821	821	CD
18637	6176	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6176	3	1938	1938	CD
18637	6176	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6176	5	.	.	.
18637	6177	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6177	2	1017	1017	CD
18637	6177	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6177	4	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	6177	5	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	6177	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6177	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6177	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6177	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6177	10	Public	Public	NNP
18637	6177	11	Service	Service	NNP
18637	6177	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6177	13	,	,	,
18637	6177	14	314	314	CD
18637	6177	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6177	16	498	498	CD
18637	6177	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6177	18	1942	1942	CD
18637	6177	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6177	20	.	.	.
18637	6178	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6178	2	1018	1018	CD
18637	6178	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6178	4	26	26	CD
18637	6178	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	6179	1	§	§	NNP
18637	6179	2	2320	2320	CD
18637	6179	3	-	-	SYM
18637	6179	4	2327	2327	CD
18637	6179	5	.	.	.
18637	6180	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6180	2	1019	1019	CD
18637	6180	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6180	4	Cloverleaf	Cloverleaf	NNP
18637	6180	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6180	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6180	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6180	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6180	9	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	6180	10	,	,	,
18637	6180	11	315	315	CD
18637	6180	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6180	13	148	148	CD
18637	6180	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6180	15	1942	1942	CD
18637	6180	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6180	17	.	.	.
18637	6181	1	Four	four	CD
18637	6181	2	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	6181	3	,	,	,
18637	6181	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	6181	5	by	by	IN
18637	6181	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	6181	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6181	8	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	6181	9	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	6181	10	,	,	,
18637	6181	11	on	on	IN
18637	6181	12	the	the	DT
18637	6181	13	basis	basis	NN
18637	6181	14	of	of	IN
18637	6181	15	Mintz	Mintz	NNP
18637	6181	16	_	_	NNP
18637	6181	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	6181	18	_	_	NNP
18637	6181	19	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	6181	20	,	,	,
18637	6181	21	289	289	CD
18637	6181	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6181	23	346	346	CD
18637	6181	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6181	25	1933	1933	CD
18637	6181	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6181	27	;	;	:
18637	6181	28	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
18637	6181	29	_	_	NNP
18637	6181	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	6181	31	_	_	NNP
18637	6181	32	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	6181	33	ex	ex	NNP
18637	6181	34	rel	rel	NN
18637	6181	35	.	.	.
18637	6182	1	Foss	Foss	NNP
18637	6182	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6182	3	,	,	,
18637	6182	4	302	302	CD
18637	6182	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6182	6	1	1	CD
18637	6182	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6182	8	1937	1937	CD
18637	6182	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6182	10	;	;	:
18637	6182	11	and	and	CC
18637	6182	12	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	6182	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6182	14	_	_	NNP
18637	6182	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	6182	16	_	_	NNP
18637	6182	17	New	New	NNP
18637	6182	18	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	6182	19	,	,	,
18637	6182	20	306	306	CD
18637	6182	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6182	22	79	79	CD
18637	6182	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6182	24	1939	1939	CD
18637	6182	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6182	26	.	.	.
18637	6183	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6183	2	1020	1020	CD
18637	6183	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6183	4	39	39	CD
18637	6183	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6183	6	.	.	.
18637	6184	1	486	486	CD
18637	6184	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6184	3	1916	1916	CD
18637	6184	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6184	5	;	;	,
18637	6184	6	amended	amend	VBN
18637	6184	7	by	by	IN
18637	6184	8	46	46	CD
18637	6184	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6184	10	.	.	.
18637	6185	1	1463	1463	CD
18637	6185	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6185	3	1931	1931	CD
18637	6185	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6185	5	.	.	.
18637	6186	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6186	2	1021	1021	CD
18637	6186	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6186	4	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	6186	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6186	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6186	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6186	8	Santa	Santa	NNP
18637	6186	9	Fe	Fe	NNP
18637	6186	10	Elevator	Elevator	NNP
18637	6186	11	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6186	12	,	,	,
18637	6186	13	331	331	CD
18637	6186	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6186	15	218	218	CD
18637	6186	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6186	17	1947	1947	CD
18637	6186	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6186	19	.	.	.
18637	6187	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6187	2	1022	1022	CD
18637	6187	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6187	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6187	5	See	See	NNP
18637	6187	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6187	7	note	note	NN
18637	6187	8	1	1	CD
18637	6187	9	above	above	RB
18637	6187	10	.	.	.
18637	6188	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6188	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	6188	3	's	's	POS
18637	6188	4	Note	note	NN
18637	6188	5	:	:	:
18637	6188	6	Reference	reference	NN
18637	6188	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	6188	8	to	to	IN
18637	6188	9	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	6188	10	1016	1016	CD
18637	6188	11	,	,	,
18637	6188	12	above	above	RB
18637	6188	13	.	.	.
18637	6188	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6189	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6189	2	1023	1023	CD
18637	6189	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6189	4	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	6189	5	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	6189	6	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	6189	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6189	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6189	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	6189	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6189	11	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	6189	12	Power	Power	NNP
18637	6189	13	Com	Com	NNP
18637	6189	14	.	.	NNP
18637	6189	15	,	,	,
18637	6189	16	331	331	CD
18637	6189	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6189	18	682	682	CD
18637	6189	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6189	20	1947	1947	CD
18637	6189	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6189	22	.	.	.
18637	6190	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6190	2	1024	1024	CD
18637	6190	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6190	4	49	49	CD
18637	6190	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	6191	1	5	5	CD
18637	6191	2	.	.	.
18637	6192	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6192	2	1025	1025	CD
18637	6192	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6192	4	Schwabacher	Schwabacher	NNP
18637	6192	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6192	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6192	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6192	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6192	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6192	10	,	,	,
18637	6192	11	334	334	CD
18637	6192	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6192	13	182	182	CD
18637	6192	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6192	15	1948	1948	CD
18637	6192	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6192	17	.	.	.
18637	6193	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6193	2	1026	1026	CD
18637	6193	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6193	4	Seaboard	Seaboard	NNP
18637	6193	5	Air	Air	NNP
18637	6193	6	Line	Line	NNP
18637	6193	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	6193	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6193	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6193	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6193	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6193	12	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	6193	13	,	,	,
18637	6193	14	333	333	CD
18637	6193	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6193	16	118	118	CD
18637	6193	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6193	18	1948	1948	CD
18637	6193	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6193	20	.	.	.
18637	6194	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6194	2	1027	1027	CD
18637	6194	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6194	4	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	6194	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6194	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6194	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6194	8	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	6194	9	,	,	,
18637	6194	10	325	325	CD
18637	6194	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6194	12	538	538	CD
18637	6194	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6194	14	1945	1945	CD
18637	6194	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6194	16	.	.	.
18637	6195	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6195	2	1028	1028	CD
18637	6195	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6195	4	49	49	CD
18637	6195	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	6195	6	.	.	.
18637	6196	1	449	449	CD
18637	6196	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6196	3	1935	1935	CD
18637	6196	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6196	5	.	.	.
18637	6197	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6197	2	1029	1029	CD
18637	6197	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6197	4	325	325	CD
18637	6197	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6197	6	at	at	IN
18637	6197	7	542	542	CD
18637	6197	8	.	.	.
18637	6198	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6198	2	1030	1030	CD
18637	6198	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6198	4	Auto	Auto	NNP
18637	6198	5	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	6198	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6198	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6198	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6198	9	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	6198	10	Board	Board	NNP
18637	6198	11	,	,	,
18637	6198	12	336	336	CD
18637	6198	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6198	14	245	245	CD
18637	6198	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6198	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	6198	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6198	18	.	.	.
18637	6199	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6199	2	1031	1031	CD
18637	6199	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6199	4	49	49	CD
18637	6199	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6199	6	.	.	.
18637	6200	1	449	449	CD
18637	6200	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6200	3	1935	1935	CD
18637	6200	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6200	5	;	;	:
18637	6200	6	61	61	CD
18637	6200	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	6200	8	.	.	.
18637	6201	1	136	136	CD
18637	6201	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6201	3	1947	1947	CD
18637	6201	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6201	5	.	.	.
18637	6202	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6202	2	1032	1032	CD
18637	6202	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6202	4	Algoma	Algoma	NNP
18637	6202	5	Plywood	Plywood	NNP
18637	6202	6	&	&	CC
18637	6202	7	Veneer	Veneer	NNP
18637	6202	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6202	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6202	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6202	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6202	12	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	6202	13	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	6202	14	.	.	NNP
18637	6202	15	,	,	,
18637	6202	16	336	336	CD
18637	6202	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6202	18	301	301	CD
18637	6202	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6202	20	1949	1949	CD
18637	6202	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6202	22	.	.	.
18637	6203	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6203	2	1033	1033	CD
18637	6203	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6203	4	Automobile	Automobile	NNP
18637	6203	5	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	6203	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6203	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6203	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6203	9	O'Brien	O'Brien	NNP
18637	6203	10	,	,	,
18637	6203	11	339	339	CD
18637	6203	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6203	13	454	454	CD
18637	6203	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6203	15	1950	1950	CD
18637	6203	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6203	17	;	;	:
18637	6203	18	Bus	Bus	NNP
18637	6203	19	Employees	Employees	NNP
18637	6203	20	_	_	NNP
18637	6203	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	6203	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6203	23	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	6203	24	Board	Board	NNP
18637	6203	25	,	,	,
18637	6203	26	340	340	CD
18637	6203	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6203	28	383	383	CD
18637	6203	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6203	30	1951	1951	CD
18637	6203	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6203	32	.	.	.
18637	6204	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6204	2	1034	1034	CD
18637	6204	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6204	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6204	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6204	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6204	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6204	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6204	9	Kagama	Kagama	NNP
18637	6204	10	,	,	,
18637	6204	11	118	118	CD
18637	6204	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6204	13	375	375	CD
18637	6204	14	,	,	,
18637	6204	15	384	384	CD
18637	6204	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6204	17	1886	1886	CD
18637	6204	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6204	19	;	;	:
18637	6204	20	_	_	NNP
18637	6204	21	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	6204	22	.	.	.
18637	6204	23	_	_	NNP
18637	6204	24	United	United	NNP
18637	6204	25	States	States	NNP
18637	6204	26	_	_	NNP
18637	6204	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	6204	28	_	_	NNP
18637	6204	29	Holliday	Holliday	NNP
18637	6204	30	,	,	,
18637	6204	31	3	3	CD
18637	6204	32	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6204	33	.	.	.
18637	6205	1	407	407	CD
18637	6205	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6205	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	6205	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6205	5	.	.	.
18637	6206	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6206	2	1035	1035	CD
18637	6206	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6206	4	16	16	CD
18637	6206	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6206	6	.	.	.
18637	6207	1	544	544	CD
18637	6207	2	,	,	,
18637	6207	3	566	566	CD
18637	6207	4	;	;	:
18637	6207	5	R.S.	R.S.	NNP
18637	6208	1	2079	2079	CD
18637	6208	2	.	.	.
18637	6209	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6209	2	1036	1036	CD
18637	6209	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6209	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6209	5	See	See	NNP
18637	6209	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6209	7	United	United	NNP
18637	6209	8	States	States	NNP
18637	6209	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6209	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6209	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6209	12	Sandoval	Sandoval	NNP
18637	6209	13	,	,	,
18637	6209	14	231	231	CD
18637	6209	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6209	16	28	28	CD
18637	6209	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6209	18	1914	1914	CD
18637	6209	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6209	20	.	.	.
18637	6210	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6210	2	1037	1037	CD
18637	6210	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6210	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6210	5	See	See	NNP
18637	6210	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6210	7	Perrin	Perrin	NNP
18637	6210	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6210	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	6210	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6210	11	United	United	NNP
18637	6210	12	States	States	NNP
18637	6210	13	,	,	,
18637	6210	14	232	232	CD
18637	6210	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6210	16	478	478	CD
18637	6210	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6210	18	1914	1914	CD
18637	6210	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6210	20	;	;	:
18637	6210	21	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	6210	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6210	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	6210	24	_	_	NNP
18637	6210	25	Gearlds	Gearlds	NNP
18637	6210	26	,	,	,
18637	6210	27	234	234	CD
18637	6210	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6210	29	422	422	CD
18637	6210	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6210	31	1914	1914	CD
18637	6210	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6210	33	;	;	:
18637	6210	34	Dick	Dick	NNP
18637	6210	35	_	_	NNP
18637	6210	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	6210	37	_	_	NNP
18637	6210	38	United	United	NNP
18637	6210	39	States	States	NNP
18637	6210	40	,	,	,
18637	6210	41	208	208	CD
18637	6210	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6210	43	340	340	CD
18637	6210	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6210	45	1908	1908	CD
18637	6210	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6210	47	.	.	.
18637	6211	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6211	2	1038	1038	CD
18637	6211	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6211	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6211	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6211	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6211	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6211	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6211	9	Nice	Nice	NNP
18637	6211	10	,	,	,
18637	6211	11	241	241	CD
18637	6211	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6211	13	591	591	CD
18637	6211	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6211	15	1916	1916	CD
18637	6211	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6211	17	,	,	,
18637	6211	18	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	6211	19	Re	Re	NNP
18637	6211	20	Heff	Heff	NNP
18637	6211	21	,	,	,
18637	6211	22	197	197	CD
18637	6211	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6211	24	488	488	CD
18637	6211	25	,	,	,
18637	6211	26	509	509	CD
18637	6211	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6211	28	1905	1905	CD
18637	6211	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6211	30	.	.	.
18637	6212	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6212	2	1039	1039	CD
18637	6212	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6212	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6212	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6212	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6212	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6212	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6212	9	Sandoval	Sandoval	NNP
18637	6212	10	,	,	,
18637	6212	11	231	231	CD
18637	6212	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6212	13	28	28	CD
18637	6212	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6212	15	1914	1914	CD
18637	6212	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6212	17	.	.	.
18637	6213	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6213	2	1040	1040	CD
18637	6213	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6213	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6213	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6213	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6213	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6213	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6213	9	Holliday	Holliday	NNP
18637	6213	10	,	,	,
18637	6213	11	3	3	CD
18637	6213	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6213	13	.	.	.
18637	6214	1	407	407	CD
18637	6214	2	,	,	,
18637	6214	3	419	419	CD
18637	6214	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6214	5	1866	1866	CD
18637	6214	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6214	7	.	.	.
18637	6215	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6215	2	1041	1041	CD
18637	6215	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6215	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	6215	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	6215	6	Webb	Webb	NNP
18637	6215	7	,	,	,
18637	6215	8	225	225	CD
18637	6215	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6215	10	663	663	CD
18637	6215	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6215	12	1912	1912	CD
18637	6215	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6215	14	.	.	.
18637	6216	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6216	2	1042	1042	CD
18637	6216	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6216	4	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
18637	6216	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6216	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6216	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6216	8	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	6216	9	,	,	,
18637	6216	10	143	143	CD
18637	6216	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6216	12	135	135	CD
18637	6216	13	,	,	,
18637	6216	14	162	162	CD
18637	6216	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6216	16	1892	1892	CD
18637	6216	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6216	18	.	.	.
18637	6217	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6217	2	1043	1043	CD
18637	6217	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6217	4	10	10	CD
18637	6217	5	How	how	WRB
18637	6217	6	.	.	.
18637	6218	1	393	393	CD
18637	6218	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6218	3	1857	1857	CD
18637	6218	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6218	5	.	.	.
18637	6219	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6219	2	1044	1044	CD
18637	6219	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6219	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6219	5	.	.	.
18637	6220	1	417	417	CD
18637	6220	2	,	,	,
18637	6220	3	419	419	CD
18637	6220	4	.	.	.
18637	6221	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6221	2	1045	1045	CD
18637	6221	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6221	4	Mackenzie	Mackenzie	NNP
18637	6221	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6221	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6221	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6221	8	Hare	Hare	NNP
18637	6221	9	,	,	,
18637	6221	10	239	239	CD
18637	6221	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6221	12	299	299	CD
18637	6221	13	,	,	,
18637	6221	14	311	311	CD
18637	6221	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6221	16	1915	1915	CD
18637	6221	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6221	18	.	.	.
18637	6222	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6222	2	1046	1046	CD
18637	6222	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6222	4	66	66	CD
18637	6222	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6222	6	.	.	.
18637	6223	1	163	163	CD
18637	6223	2	;	;	:
18637	6223	3	Public	Public	NNP
18637	6223	4	Law	Law	NNP
18637	6223	5	414	414	CD
18637	6223	6	,	,	,
18637	6223	7	82d	82d	NNPS
18637	6223	8	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	6223	9	.	.	NNP
18637	6223	10	,	,	,
18637	6223	11	2d	2d	NNP
18637	6223	12	Sess	Sess	NNP
18637	6223	13	.	.	.
18637	6224	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6224	2	1952	1952	CD
18637	6224	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6224	4	.	.	.
18637	6225	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6225	2	1047	1047	CD
18637	6225	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6225	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6225	5	.	.	.
18637	6226	1	tit	tit	NN
18637	6226	2	.	.	.
18637	6227	1	III	III	NNP
18637	6227	2	,	,	,
18637	6227	3	§	§	NNP
18637	6227	4	301	301	CD
18637	6227	5	.	.	.
18637	6228	1	The	the	DT
18637	6228	2	first	first	JJ
18637	6228	3	category	category	NN
18637	6228	4	comprises	comprise	NNS
18637	6228	5	,	,	,
18637	6228	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6228	7	should	should	MD
18637	6228	8	be	be	VB
18637	6228	9	noted	note	VBN
18637	6228	10	,	,	,
18637	6228	11	those	those	DT
18637	6228	12	who	who	WP
18637	6228	13	are	be	VBP
18637	6228	14	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	6228	15	by	by	IN
18637	6228	16	the	the	DT
18637	6228	17	opening	opening	NN
18637	6228	18	clause	clause	NN
18637	6228	19	of	of	IN
18637	6228	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	6228	21	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	6228	22	,	,	,
18637	6228	23	which	which	WDT
18637	6228	24	embodies	embody	VBZ
18637	6228	25	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	6228	26	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6228	27	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	6228	28	's	's	POS
18637	6228	29	holding	holding	NN
18637	6228	30	in	in	IN
18637	6228	31	Gassies	Gassies	NNPS
18637	6228	32	_	_	NNP
18637	6228	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	6228	34	_	_	NNP
18637	6228	35	Ballon	Ballon	NNP
18637	6228	36	,	,	,
18637	6228	37	that	that	IN
18637	6228	38	a	a	DT
18637	6228	39	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	6228	40	of	of	IN
18637	6228	41	the	the	DT
18637	6228	42	United	United	NNP
18637	6228	43	States	States	NNP
18637	6228	44	,	,	,
18637	6228	45	residing	reside	VBG
18637	6228	46	in	in	IN
18637	6228	47	any	any	DT
18637	6228	48	State	State	NNP
18637	6228	49	of	of	IN
18637	6228	50	the	the	DT
18637	6228	51	Union	Union	NNP
18637	6228	52	,	,	,
18637	6228	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	6228	54	a	a	DT
18637	6228	55	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	6228	56	of	of	IN
18637	6228	57	that	that	DT
18637	6228	58	State	State	NNP
18637	6228	59	.	.	.
18637	6229	1	6	6	CD
18637	6229	2	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	6229	3	.	.	.
18637	6230	1	761	761	CD
18637	6230	2	,	,	,
18637	6230	3	762	762	CD
18637	6230	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6230	5	1832	1832	CD
18637	6230	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6230	7	.	.	.
18637	6231	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6231	2	1048	1048	CD
18637	6231	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6231	4	66	66	CD
18637	6231	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6231	6	.	.	.
18637	6232	1	163	163	CD
18637	6232	2	;	;	:
18637	6232	3	tit	tit	NN
18637	6232	4	.	.	.
18637	6233	1	III	III	NNP
18637	6233	2	,	,	,
18637	6233	3	§§	§§	NNP
18637	6233	4	302	302	CD
18637	6233	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	6233	6	307	307	CD
18637	6233	7	.	.	.
18637	6234	1	These	these	DT
18637	6234	2	categories	category	NNS
18637	6234	3	illustrate	illustrate	VBP
18637	6234	4	collective	collective	JJ
18637	6234	5	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	6234	6	.	.	.
18637	6235	1	"	"	``
18637	6235	2	Instances	instance	NNS
18637	6235	3	of	of	IN
18637	6235	4	collective	collective	JJ
18637	6235	5	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	6235	6	by	by	IN
18637	6235	7	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	6235	8	or	or	CC
18637	6235	9	by	by	IN
18637	6235	10	statute	statute	NN
18637	6235	11	are	be	VBP
18637	6235	12	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	6235	13	.	.	.
18637	6235	14	"	"	''
18637	6236	1	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
18637	6236	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6236	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6236	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6236	5	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	6236	6	,	,	,
18637	6236	7	143	143	CD
18637	6236	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6236	9	135	135	CD
18637	6236	10	,	,	,
18637	6236	11	162	162	CD
18637	6236	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6236	13	1892	1892	CD
18637	6236	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6236	15	.	.	.
18637	6237	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6237	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6237	3	also	also	RB
18637	6237	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6237	5	Elk	Elk	NNP
18637	6237	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6237	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6237	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6237	9	Wilkins	Wilkins	NNP
18637	6237	10	,	,	,
18637	6237	11	112	112	CD
18637	6237	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6237	13	94	94	CD
18637	6237	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6237	15	1884	1884	CD
18637	6237	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6237	17	.	.	.
18637	6238	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6238	2	1049	1049	CD
18637	6238	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6238	4	57	57	CD
18637	6238	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6238	6	.	.	.
18637	6239	1	600	600	CD
18637	6239	2	.	.	.
18637	6240	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6240	2	1050	1050	CD
18637	6240	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6240	4	66	66	CD
18637	6240	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6240	6	.	.	.
18637	6241	1	163	163	CD
18637	6241	2	,	,	,
18637	6241	3	tit	tit	NN
18637	6241	4	.	.	.
18637	6242	1	III	III	NNP
18637	6242	2	,	,	,
18637	6242	3	§	§	NNP
18637	6242	4	311	311	CD
18637	6242	5	.	.	.
18637	6243	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6243	2	1051	1051	CD
18637	6243	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6243	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6243	5	.	.	.
18637	6244	1	§	§	NNP
18637	6244	2	313	313	CD
18637	6244	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6244	4	a	a	NN
18637	6244	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6244	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6244	7	4	4	CD
18637	6244	8	-	-	SYM
18637	6244	9	6	6	CD
18637	6244	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6244	11	.	.	.
18637	6245	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6245	2	1052	1052	CD
18637	6245	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6245	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6245	5	.	.	.
18637	6246	1	§	§	NNP
18637	6246	2	313	313	NNP
18637	6246	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6246	4	c	c	NNP
18637	6246	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6246	6	.	.	.
18637	6247	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6247	2	1053	1053	CD
18637	6247	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6247	4	66	66	CD
18637	6247	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6247	6	.	.	.
18637	6248	1	163	163	CD
18637	6248	2	,	,	,
18637	6248	3	§	§	NNP
18637	6248	4	337	337	CD
18637	6248	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6248	6	a	a	NN
18637	6248	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6248	8	.	.	.
18637	6249	1	In	in	IN
18637	6249	2	United	United	NNP
18637	6249	3	States	States	NNP
18637	6249	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6249	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	6249	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6249	7	Schwimmer	Schwimmer	NNP
18637	6249	8	,	,	,
18637	6249	9	279	279	CD
18637	6249	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6249	11	644	644	CD
18637	6249	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6249	13	1929	1929	CD
18637	6249	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6249	15	;	;	:
18637	6249	16	and	and	CC
18637	6249	17	United	United	NNP
18637	6249	18	States	States	NNP
18637	6249	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6249	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	6249	21	_	_	NNP
18637	6249	22	Macintosh	Macintosh	NNP
18637	6249	23	,	,	,
18637	6249	24	283	283	CD
18637	6249	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6249	26	605	605	CD
18637	6249	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6249	28	1931	1931	CD
18637	6249	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6249	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6249	31	was	be	VBD
18637	6249	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	6249	33	,	,	,
18637	6249	34	by	by	IN
18637	6249	35	a	a	DT
18637	6249	36	divided	divide	VBN
18637	6249	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	6249	38	,	,	,
18637	6249	39	that	that	WDT
18637	6249	40	clauses	clause	VBZ
18637	6249	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6249	42	3	3	CD
18637	6249	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6249	44	and	and	CC
18637	6249	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6249	46	4	4	CD
18637	6249	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6249	48	of	of	IN
18637	6249	49	the	the	DT
18637	6249	50	oath	oath	NN
18637	6249	51	,	,	,
18637	6249	52	as	as	RB
18637	6249	53	previously	previously	RB
18637	6249	54	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	6249	55	,	,	,
18637	6249	56	required	require	VBD
18637	6249	57	the	the	DT
18637	6249	58	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	6249	59	for	for	IN
18637	6249	60	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	6249	61	to	to	TO
18637	6249	62	be	be	VB
18637	6249	63	ready	ready	JJ
18637	6249	64	and	and	CC
18637	6249	65	willing	willing	JJ
18637	6249	66	to	to	TO
18637	6249	67	bear	bear	VB
18637	6249	68	arms	arm	NNS
18637	6249	69	for	for	IN
18637	6249	70	the	the	DT
18637	6249	71	United	United	NNP
18637	6249	72	States	States	NNP
18637	6249	73	,	,	,
18637	6249	74	but	but	CC
18637	6249	75	these	these	DT
18637	6249	76	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	6249	77	were	be	VBD
18637	6249	78	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	6249	79	in	in	IN
18637	6249	80	Girouard	Girouard	NNP
18637	6249	81	_	_	NNP
18637	6249	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	6249	83	_	_	NNP
18637	6249	84	United	United	NNP
18637	6249	85	States	States	NNP
18637	6249	86	,	,	,
18637	6249	87	328	328	CD
18637	6249	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6249	89	61	61	CD
18637	6249	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6249	91	1946	1946	CD
18637	6249	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6249	93	.	.	.
18637	6250	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6250	2	1054	1054	CD
18637	6250	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6250	4	66	66	CD
18637	6250	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6250	6	.	.	.
18637	6251	1	163	163	CD
18637	6251	2	,	,	,
18637	6251	3	§	§	NNP
18637	6251	4	340	340	CD
18637	6251	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6251	6	a	a	NN
18637	6251	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6251	8	;	;	:
18637	6251	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6251	10	see	see	VB
18637	6251	11	also	also	RB
18637	6251	12	_	_	NNP
18637	6251	13	Johannessen	Johannessen	NNP
18637	6251	14	_	_	NNP
18637	6251	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	6251	16	_	_	NNP
18637	6251	17	United	United	NNP
18637	6251	18	States	States	NNP
18637	6251	19	,	,	,
18637	6251	20	225	225	CD
18637	6251	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6251	22	227	227	CD
18637	6251	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6251	24	1912	1912	CD
18637	6251	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6251	26	.	.	.
18637	6252	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6252	2	1055	1055	CD
18637	6252	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6252	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6252	5	.	.	.
18637	6253	1	§	§	NNP
18637	6253	2	340	340	CD
18637	6253	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6253	4	c	c	NN
18637	6253	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6253	6	.	.	.
18637	6254	1	For	for	IN
18637	6254	2	cancellation	cancellation	NN
18637	6254	3	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	6254	4	under	under	IN
18637	6254	5	the	the	DT
18637	6254	6	Nationality	Nationality	NNP
18637	6254	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	6254	8	of	of	IN
18637	6254	9	1910	1910	CD
18637	6254	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6254	11	54	54	CD
18637	6254	12	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6254	13	.	.	.
18637	6255	1	1158	1158	CD
18637	6255	2	,	,	,
18637	6255	3	§	§	NNP
18637	6255	4	338	338	CD
18637	6255	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6255	6	;	;	:
18637	6255	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6255	8	see	see	VBP
18637	6255	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6255	10	Schneiderman	Schneiderman	NNP
18637	6255	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6255	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	6255	13	_	_	NNP
18637	6255	14	United	United	NNP
18637	6255	15	States	States	NNP
18637	6255	16	,	,	,
18637	6255	17	320	320	CD
18637	6255	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6255	19	118	118	CD
18637	6255	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6255	21	1943	1943	CD
18637	6255	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6255	23	;	;	:
18637	6255	24	Baumgartner	Baumgartner	NNP
18637	6255	25	_	_	NNP
18637	6255	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	6255	27	_	_	NNP
18637	6255	28	United	United	NNP
18637	6255	29	States	States	NNP
18637	6255	30	322	322	CD
18637	6255	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6255	32	665	665	CD
18637	6255	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6255	34	1944	1944	CD
18637	6255	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6255	36	,	,	,
18637	6255	37	where	where	WRB
18637	6255	38	district	district	NN
18637	6255	39	court	court	NN
18637	6255	40	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	6255	41	ordering	order	VBG
18637	6255	42	cancellation	cancellation	NN
18637	6255	43	were	be	VBD
18637	6255	44	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	6255	45	on	on	IN
18637	6255	46	the	the	DT
18637	6255	47	ground	ground	NN
18637	6255	48	that	that	IN
18637	6255	49	the	the	DT
18637	6255	50	Government	Government	NNP
18637	6255	51	had	have	VBD
18637	6255	52	not	not	RB
18637	6255	53	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	6255	54	the	the	DT
18637	6255	55	burden	burden	NN
18637	6255	56	of	of	IN
18637	6255	57	proof	proof	NN
18637	6255	58	resting	rest	VBG
18637	6255	59	upon	upon	IN
18637	6255	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6255	61	.	.	.
18637	6256	1	Knauer	Knauer	NNP
18637	6256	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6256	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6256	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6256	5	United	United	NNP
18637	6256	6	States	States	NNP
18637	6256	7	,	,	,
18637	6256	8	328	328	CD
18637	6256	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6256	10	654	654	CD
18637	6256	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6256	12	1946	1946	CD
18637	6256	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6256	14	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	6256	15	a	a	DT
18637	6256	16	less	less	RBR
18637	6256	17	rigid	rigid	JJ
18637	6256	18	view	view	NN
18637	6256	19	.	.	.
18637	6257	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6257	2	1056	1056	CD
18637	6257	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6257	4	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	6257	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6257	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6257	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6257	8	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6257	9	of	of	IN
18637	6257	10	the	the	DT
18637	6257	11	United	United	NNP
18637	6257	12	States	States	NNP
18637	6257	13	,	,	,
18637	6257	14	9	9	CD
18637	6257	15	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6257	16	.	.	.
18637	6258	1	738	738	CD
18637	6258	2	,	,	,
18637	6258	3	827	827	CD
18637	6258	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6258	5	1824	1824	CD
18637	6258	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6258	7	.	.	.
18637	6259	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6259	2	1057	1057	CD
18637	6259	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6259	4	328	328	CD
18637	6259	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6259	6	654	654	CD
18637	6259	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6259	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	6259	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6259	10	.	.	.
18637	6260	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6260	2	1058	1058	CD
18637	6260	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6260	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6260	5	.	.	.
18637	6261	1	658	658	CD
18637	6261	2	.	.	.
18637	6262	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6262	2	1059	1059	CD
18637	6262	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6262	4	Johannessen	Johannessen	NNP
18637	6262	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6262	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6262	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6262	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6262	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6262	10	,	,	,
18637	6262	11	225	225	CD
18637	6262	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6262	13	227	227	CD
18637	6262	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6262	15	1912	1912	CD
18637	6262	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6262	17	and	and	CC
18637	6262	18	Knauer	Knauer	NNP
18637	6262	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6262	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	6262	21	_	_	NNP
18637	6262	22	United	United	NNP
18637	6262	23	States	States	NNP
18637	6262	24	,	,	,
18637	6262	25	328	328	CD
18637	6262	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6262	27	654	654	CD
18637	6262	28	,	,	,
18637	6262	29	673	673	CD
18637	6262	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6262	31	1946	1946	CD
18637	6262	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6262	33	.	.	.
18637	6263	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6263	2	1060	1060	CD
18637	6263	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6263	4	66	66	CD
18637	6263	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6263	6	.	.	.
18637	6264	1	163	163	CD
18637	6264	2	,	,	,
18637	6264	3	tit	tit	NN
18637	6264	4	.	.	.
18637	6265	1	III	III	NNP
18637	6265	2	,	,	,
18637	6265	3	§	§	NNP
18637	6265	4	352	352	CD
18637	6265	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6265	6	a	a	NN
18637	6265	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6265	8	.	.	.
18637	6266	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6266	2	1061	1061	CD
18637	6266	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6266	4	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
18637	6266	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6266	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6266	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6266	8	Elg	Elg	NNP
18637	6266	9	,	,	,
18637	6266	10	307	307	CD
18637	6266	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6266	12	325	325	CD
18637	6266	13	,	,	,
18637	6266	14	329	329	CD
18637	6266	15	,	,	,
18637	6266	16	334	334	CD
18637	6266	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6266	18	1939	1939	CD
18637	6266	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6266	20	.	.	.
18637	6267	1	Naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	6267	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	6267	3	a	a	DT
18637	6267	4	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	6267	5	effect	effect	NN
18637	6267	6	and	and	CC
18637	6267	7	removes	remove	VBZ
18637	6267	8	all	all	DT
18637	6267	9	liability	liability	NN
18637	6267	10	to	to	IN
18637	6267	11	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	6267	12	of	of	IN
18637	6267	13	land	land	NN
18637	6267	14	held	hold	VBN
18637	6267	15	while	while	IN
18637	6267	16	an	an	DT
18637	6267	17	alien	alien	NN
18637	6267	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6267	19	Osterman	Osterman	NNP
18637	6267	20	_	_	NNP
18637	6267	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	6267	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6267	23	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	6267	24	,	,	,
18637	6267	25	6	6	CD
18637	6267	26	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6267	27	.	.	.
18637	6268	1	116	116	CD
18637	6268	2	,	,	,
18637	6268	3	122	122	CD
18637	6268	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6268	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	6268	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6268	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6268	8	;	;	:
18637	6268	9	the	the	DT
18637	6268	10	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	6268	11	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	6268	12	of	of	IN
18637	6268	13	an	an	DT
18637	6268	14	alien	alien	NN
18637	6268	15	who	who	WP
18637	6268	16	takes	take	VBZ
18637	6268	17	land	land	NN
18637	6268	18	by	by	IN
18637	6268	19	grant	grant	NN
18637	6268	20	or	or	CC
18637	6268	21	by	by	IN
18637	6268	22	location	location	NN
18637	6268	23	on	on	IN
18637	6268	24	public	public	JJ
18637	6268	25	land	land	NN
18637	6268	26	relates	relate	VBZ
18637	6268	27	back	back	RB
18637	6268	28	and	and	CC
18637	6268	29	obviates	obviate	VBZ
18637	6268	30	every	every	DT
18637	6268	31	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	6268	32	of	of	IN
18637	6268	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	6268	34	alien	alien	JJ
18637	6268	35	disability	disability	NN
18637	6268	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6268	37	Manuel	Manuel	NNP
18637	6268	38	_	_	NNP
18637	6268	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	6268	40	_	_	NNP
18637	6268	41	Wulff	Wulff	NNP
18637	6268	42	,	,	,
18637	6268	43	152	152	CD
18637	6268	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6268	45	505	505	CD
18637	6268	46	,	,	,
18637	6268	47	511	511	CD
18637	6268	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6268	49	1894	1894	CD
18637	6268	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6268	51	;	;	:
18637	6268	52	Doe	Doe	NNP
18637	6268	53	ex	ex	NNP
18637	6268	54	dem	dem	NNP
18637	6268	55	.	.	.
18637	6269	1	Governeur	Governeur	NNP
18637	6269	2	's	's	POS
18637	6269	3	Heirs	Heirs	NNPS
18637	6269	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6269	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	6269	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6269	7	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	6269	8	,	,	,
18637	6269	9	11	11	CD
18637	6269	10	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6269	11	.	.	.
18637	6270	1	332	332	CD
18637	6270	2	,	,	,
18637	6270	3	350	350	CD
18637	6270	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6270	5	1826	1826	CD
18637	6270	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6270	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6270	8	.	.	.
18637	6271	1	A	a	DT
18637	6271	2	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	6271	3	of	of	IN
18637	6271	4	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	6271	5	,	,	,
18637	6271	6	while	while	IN
18637	6271	7	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	6271	8	as	as	IN
18637	6271	9	a	a	DT
18637	6271	10	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	6271	11	of	of	IN
18637	6271	12	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	6271	13	,	,	,
18637	6271	14	can	can	MD
18637	6271	15	not	not	RB
18637	6271	16	be	be	VB
18637	6271	17	introduced	introduce	VBN
18637	6271	18	in	in	IN
18637	6271	19	a	a	DT
18637	6271	20	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	6271	21	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	6271	22	as	as	IN
18637	6271	23	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	6271	24	of	of	IN
18637	6271	25	residence	residence	NN
18637	6271	26	,	,	,
18637	6271	27	age	age	NN
18637	6271	28	or	or	CC
18637	6271	29	good	good	JJ
18637	6271	30	character	character	NN
18637	6271	31	of	of	IN
18637	6271	32	the	the	DT
18637	6271	33	person	person	NN
18637	6271	34	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	6271	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6271	36	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	6271	37	Ben	Ben	NNP
18637	6271	38	.	.	.
18637	6272	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	6272	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	6272	3	.	.	.
18637	6273	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6273	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6273	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6273	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6273	5	Tisdale	Tisdale	NNP
18637	6273	6	,	,	,
18637	6273	7	91	91	CD
18637	6273	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6273	9	238	238	CD
18637	6273	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6273	11	1876	1876	CD
18637	6273	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6273	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6273	14	.	.	.
18637	6274	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6274	2	1062	1062	CD
18637	6274	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6274	4	Chirac	Chirac	NNP
18637	6274	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6274	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6274	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6274	8	Chirac	Chirac	NNP
18637	6274	9	,	,	,
18637	6274	10	2	2	CD
18637	6274	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6274	12	.	.	.
18637	6275	1	259	259	CD
18637	6275	2	,	,	,
18637	6275	3	269	269	CD
18637	6275	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6275	5	1817	1817	CD
18637	6275	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6275	7	.	.	.
18637	6276	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6276	2	1063	1063	CD
18637	6276	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6276	4	Holmgren	Holmgren	NNP
18637	6276	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6276	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6276	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6276	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6276	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6276	10	,	,	,
18637	6276	11	217	217	CD
18637	6276	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6276	13	509	509	CD
18637	6276	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6276	15	1910	1910	CD
18637	6276	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6276	17	,	,	,
18637	6276	18	where	where	WRB
18637	6276	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6276	20	was	be	VBD
18637	6276	21	also	also	RB
18637	6276	22	held	hold	VBN
18637	6276	23	that	that	IN
18637	6276	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	6276	25	may	may	MD
18637	6276	26	provide	provide	VB
18637	6276	27	for	for	IN
18637	6276	28	the	the	DT
18637	6276	29	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	6276	30	of	of	IN
18637	6276	31	false	false	JJ
18637	6276	32	swearing	swearing	NN
18637	6276	33	in	in	IN
18637	6276	34	such	such	JJ
18637	6276	35	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	6276	36	in	in	IN
18637	6276	37	State	State	NNP
18637	6276	38	court	court	NN
18637	6276	39	.	.	.
18637	6277	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	6277	2	.	.	.
18637	6278	1	520	520	CD
18637	6278	2	.	.	.
18637	6279	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6279	2	1064	1064	CD
18637	6279	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6279	4	Spragins	Spragins	NNP
18637	6279	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6279	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6279	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6279	8	Houghton	Houghton	NNP
18637	6279	9	,	,	,
18637	6279	10	3	3	CD
18637	6279	11	Ill.	Illinois	NNP
18637	6279	12	377	377	CD
18637	6279	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6279	14	1840	1840	CD
18637	6279	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6279	16	;	;	:
18637	6279	17	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	6279	18	_	_	NNP
18637	6279	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	6279	20	_	_	NNP
18637	6279	21	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	6279	22	,	,	,
18637	6279	23	2	2	CD
18637	6279	24	Binney	Binney	NNP
18637	6279	25	's	's	POS
18637	6279	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6279	27	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	6279	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6279	29	110	110	CD
18637	6279	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6279	31	1809	1809	CD
18637	6279	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6279	33	.	.	.
18637	6280	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6280	2	1065	1065	CD
18637	6280	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6280	4	Shanks	Shanks	NNP
18637	6280	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6280	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6280	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6280	8	Dupont	Dupont	NNP
18637	6280	9	,	,	,
18637	6280	10	3	3	CD
18637	6280	11	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	6280	12	.	.	.
18637	6281	1	242	242	CD
18637	6281	2	,	,	,
18637	6281	3	240	240	CD
18637	6281	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6281	5	1830	1830	CD
18637	6281	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6281	7	.	.	.
18637	6282	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6282	2	1066	1066	CD
18637	6282	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6282	4	15	15	CD
18637	6282	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6282	6	.	.	.
18637	6283	1	223	223	CD
18637	6283	2	;	;	:
18637	6283	3	8	8	CD
18637	6283	4	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	6284	1	§	§	NNP
18637	6284	2	800	800	CD
18637	6284	3	.	.	.
18637	6285	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6285	2	1067	1067	CD
18637	6285	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6285	4	MacKenzie	MacKenzie	NNP
18637	6285	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6285	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6285	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6285	8	Hare	Hare	NNP
18637	6285	9	,	,	,
18637	6285	10	239	239	CD
18637	6285	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6285	12	299	299	CD
18637	6285	13	,	,	,
18637	6285	14	309	309	CD
18637	6285	15	,	,	,
18637	6285	16	311	311	CD
18637	6285	17	-	-	SYM
18637	6285	18	312	312	CD
18637	6285	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6285	20	1915	1915	CD
18637	6285	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6285	22	.	.	.
18637	6286	1	In	in	IN
18637	6286	2	this	this	DT
18637	6286	3	case	case	NN
18637	6286	4	,	,	,
18637	6286	5	a	a	DT
18637	6286	6	now	now	RB
18637	6286	7	obsolete	obsolete	JJ
18637	6286	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	6286	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6286	10	34	34	CD
18637	6286	11	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6286	12	.	.	.
18637	6287	1	1228	1228	CD
18637	6287	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6287	3	,	,	,
18637	6287	4	known	know	VBN
18637	6287	5	as	as	IN
18637	6287	6	the	the	DT
18637	6287	7	Citizenship	Citizenship	NNP
18637	6287	8	Act	Act	NNP
18637	6287	9	of	of	IN
18637	6287	10	1907	1907	CD
18637	6287	11	,	,	,
18637	6287	12	which	which	WDT
18637	6287	13	divested	divest	VBD
18637	6287	14	the	the	DT
18637	6287	15	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	6287	16	of	of	IN
18637	6287	17	a	a	DT
18637	6287	18	woman	woman	NN
18637	6287	19	marrying	marry	VBG
18637	6287	20	an	an	DT
18637	6287	21	alien	alien	NN
18637	6287	22	,	,	,
18637	6287	23	was	be	VBD
18637	6287	24	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	6287	25	as	as	IN
18637	6287	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	6287	27	.	.	.
18637	6288	1	Under	under	IN
18637	6288	2	the	the	DT
18637	6288	3	Act	Act	NNP
18637	6288	4	of	of	IN
18637	6288	5	June	June	NNP
18637	6288	6	27	27	CD
18637	6288	7	,	,	,
18637	6288	8	1952	1952	CD
18637	6288	9	,	,	,
18637	6288	10	these	these	DT
18637	6288	11	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	6288	12	comprise	comprise	VBP
18637	6288	13	the	the	DT
18637	6288	14	following	following	NN
18637	6288	15	:	:	:
18637	6288	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6288	17	1	1	LS
18637	6288	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6288	19	Obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	6288	20	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	6288	21	in	in	IN
18637	6288	22	a	a	DT
18637	6288	23	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	6288	24	State	state	NN
18637	6288	25	;	;	:
18637	6288	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6288	27	2	2	LS
18637	6288	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6288	29	Taking	take	VBG
18637	6288	30	an	an	DT
18637	6288	31	oath	oath	NN
18637	6288	32	of	of	IN
18637	6288	33	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	6288	34	to	to	IN
18637	6288	35	a	a	DT
18637	6288	36	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	6288	37	State	state	NN
18637	6288	38	;	;	:
18637	6288	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6288	40	3	3	LS
18637	6288	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6288	42	Serving	serve	VBG
18637	6288	43	in	in	IN
18637	6288	44	the	the	DT
18637	6288	45	armed	armed	JJ
18637	6288	46	forces	force	NNS
18637	6288	47	of	of	IN
18637	6288	48	a	a	DT
18637	6288	49	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	6288	50	State	State	NNP
18637	6288	51	without	without	IN
18637	6288	52	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	6288	53	and	and	CC
18637	6288	54	with	with	IN
18637	6288	55	consequent	consequent	JJ
18637	6288	56	acquisition	acquisition	NN
18637	6288	57	of	of	IN
18637	6288	58	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	6288	59	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	6288	60	;	;	,
18637	6288	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6288	62	4	4	LS
18637	6288	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6288	64	Assuming	assume	VBG
18637	6288	65	public	public	JJ
18637	6288	66	office	office	NN
18637	6288	67	under	under	IN
18637	6288	68	the	the	DT
18637	6288	69	government	government	NN
18637	6288	70	of	of	IN
18637	6288	71	a	a	DT
18637	6288	72	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	6288	73	State	State	NNP
18637	6288	74	,	,	,
18637	6288	75	for	for	IN
18637	6288	76	which	which	WDT
18637	6288	77	only	only	RB
18637	6288	78	nationals	national	NNS
18637	6288	79	of	of	IN
18637	6288	80	that	that	DT
18637	6288	81	State	state	NN
18637	6288	82	are	be	VBP
18637	6288	83	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	6288	84	;	;	:
18637	6288	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6288	86	5	5	LS
18637	6288	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6288	88	Voting	vote	VBG
18637	6288	89	in	in	IN
18637	6288	90	an	an	DT
18637	6288	91	election	election	NN
18637	6288	92	or	or	CC
18637	6288	93	participating	participate	VBG
18637	6288	94	in	in	IN
18637	6288	95	a	a	DT
18637	6288	96	plebiscite	plebiscite	NN
18637	6288	97	in	in	IN
18637	6288	98	a	a	DT
18637	6288	99	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	6288	100	State	state	NN
18637	6288	101	;	;	:
18637	6288	102	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6288	103	6	6	LS
18637	6288	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6288	105	Formal	formal	JJ
18637	6288	106	renunciation	renunciation	NN
18637	6288	107	of	of	IN
18637	6288	108	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	6288	109	before	before	IN
18637	6288	110	an	an	DT
18637	6288	111	American	american	JJ
18637	6288	112	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	6288	113	service	service	NN
18637	6288	114	officer	officer	NN
18637	6288	115	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	6288	116	;	;	,
18637	6288	117	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6288	118	7	7	LS
18637	6288	119	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6288	120	Conviction	conviction	NN
18637	6288	121	and	and	CC
18637	6288	122	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	6288	123	from	from	IN
18637	6288	124	the	the	DT
18637	6288	125	armed	armed	JJ
18637	6288	126	services	service	NNS
18637	6288	127	for	for	IN
18637	6288	128	desertion	desertion	NN
18637	6288	129	in	in	IN
18637	6288	130	time	time	NN
18637	6288	131	of	of	IN
18637	6288	132	war	war	NN
18637	6288	133	;	;	,
18637	6288	134	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6288	135	8)	8)	CD
18637	6288	136	Conviction	Conviction	NNP
18637	6288	137	of	of	IN
18637	6288	138	treason	treason	NN
18637	6288	139	or	or	CC
18637	6288	140	an	an	DT
18637	6288	141	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	6288	142	at	at	IN
18637	6288	143	forceful	forceful	JJ
18637	6288	144	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	6288	145	of	of	IN
18637	6288	146	the	the	DT
18637	6288	147	United	United	NNP
18637	6288	148	States	States	NNP
18637	6288	149	;	;	:
18637	6288	150	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6288	151	9	9	LS
18637	6288	152	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6288	153	Formal	formal	JJ
18637	6288	154	renunciation	renunciation	NN
18637	6288	155	of	of	IN
18637	6288	156	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	6288	157	within	within	IN
18637	6288	158	the	the	DT
18637	6288	159	United	United	NNP
18637	6288	160	States	States	NNP
18637	6288	161	in	in	IN
18637	6288	162	time	time	NN
18637	6288	163	of	of	IN
18637	6288	164	war	war	NN
18637	6288	165	,	,	,
18637	6288	166	subject	subject	JJ
18637	6288	167	to	to	IN
18637	6288	168	approval	approval	NN
18637	6288	169	by	by	IN
18637	6288	170	the	the	DT
18637	6288	171	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	6288	172	General	General	NNP
18637	6288	173	;	;	:
18637	6288	174	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6288	175	10	10	LS
18637	6288	176	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6288	177	Fleeing	flee	VBG
18637	6288	178	or	or	CC
18637	6288	179	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	6288	180	outside	outside	IN
18637	6288	181	the	the	DT
18637	6288	182	United	United	NNP
18637	6288	183	States	States	NNP
18637	6288	184	in	in	IN
18637	6288	185	time	time	NN
18637	6288	186	of	of	IN
18637	6288	187	war	war	NN
18637	6288	188	or	or	CC
18637	6288	189	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
18637	6288	190	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	6288	191	in	in	IN
18637	6288	192	order	order	NN
18637	6288	193	to	to	TO
18637	6288	194	evade	evade	VB
18637	6288	195	military	military	JJ
18637	6288	196	training	training	NN
18637	6288	197	;	;	:
18637	6288	198	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6288	199	11	11	LS
18637	6288	200	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6288	201	Residence	residence	NN
18637	6288	202	by	by	IN
18637	6288	203	a	a	DT
18637	6288	204	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	6288	205	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	6288	206	,	,	,
18637	6288	207	subject	subject	JJ
18637	6288	208	to	to	IN
18637	6288	209	certain	certain	JJ
18637	6288	210	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	6288	211	,	,	,
18637	6288	212	for	for	IN
18637	6288	213	two	two	CD
18637	6288	214	to	to	TO
18637	6288	215	three	three	CD
18637	6288	216	years	year	NNS
18637	6288	217	in	in	IN
18637	6288	218	the	the	DT
18637	6288	219	country	country	NN
18637	6288	220	of	of	IN
18637	6288	221	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	6288	222	birth	birth	NN
18637	6288	223	or	or	CC
18637	6288	224	in	in	IN
18637	6288	225	which	which	WDT
18637	6288	226	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6288	227	formerly	formerly	RB
18637	6288	228	was	be	VBD
18637	6288	229	a	a	DT
18637	6288	230	national	national	JJ
18637	6288	231	or	or	CC
18637	6288	232	for	for	IN
18637	6288	233	five	five	CD
18637	6288	234	years	year	NNS
18637	6288	235	in	in	IN
18637	6288	236	any	any	DT
18637	6288	237	other	other	JJ
18637	6288	238	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	6288	239	State	State	NNP
18637	6288	240	,	,	,
18637	6288	241	and	and	CC
18637	6288	242	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6288	243	12	12	CD
18637	6288	244	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6288	245	Minor	minor	JJ
18637	6288	246	children	child	NNS
18637	6288	247	,	,	,
18637	6288	248	of	of	IN
18637	6288	249	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	6288	250	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	6288	251	losing	lose	VBG
18637	6288	252	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	6288	253	by	by	IN
18637	6288	254	such	such	JJ
18637	6288	255	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	6288	256	residence	residence	NN
18637	6288	257	,	,	,
18637	6288	258	also	also	RB
18637	6288	259	lose	lose	VB
18637	6288	260	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	6288	261	United	United	NNP
18637	6288	262	States	States	NNP
18637	6288	263	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	6288	264	if	if	IN
18637	6288	265	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6288	266	acquire	acquire	VBP
18637	6288	267	the	the	DT
18637	6288	268	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	6288	269	of	of	IN
18637	6288	270	a	a	DT
18637	6288	271	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	6288	272	State	state	NN
18637	6288	273	;	;	:
18637	6288	274	but	but	CC
18637	6288	275	not	not	RB
18637	6288	276	until	until	IN
18637	6288	277	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6288	278	attain	attain	VBP
18637	6288	279	the	the	DT
18637	6288	280	age	age	NN
18637	6288	281	of	of	IN
18637	6288	282	25	25	CD
18637	6288	283	without	without	IN
18637	6288	284	having	have	VBG
18637	6288	285	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	6288	286	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	6288	287	residence	residence	NN
18637	6288	288	in	in	IN
18637	6288	289	the	the	DT
18637	6288	290	United	United	NNP
18637	6288	291	States	States	NNP
18637	6288	292	.	.	.
18637	6289	1	66	66	CD
18637	6289	2	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	6289	3	.	.	.
18637	6290	1	163	163	CD
18637	6290	2	;	;	:
18637	6290	3	Tit	Tit	NNS
18637	6290	4	.	.	.
18637	6291	1	III	iii	CD
18637	6291	2	§§	§§	NNP
18637	6291	3	349	349	CD
18637	6291	4	-	-	SYM
18637	6291	5	357	357	CD
18637	6291	6	.	.	.
18637	6292	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6292	2	1068	1068	CD
18637	6292	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6292	4	Chinese	Chinese	NNP
18637	6292	5	Exclusion	Exclusion	NNP
18637	6292	6	Case	Case	NNP
18637	6292	7	,	,	,
18637	6292	8	130	130	CD
18637	6292	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6292	10	581	581	CD
18637	6292	11	,	,	,
18637	6292	12	603	603	CD
18637	6292	13	,	,	,
18637	6292	14	604	604	CD
18637	6292	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6292	16	1889	1889	CD
18637	6292	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6292	18	;	;	:
18637	6292	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6292	20	See	See	NNP
18637	6292	21	also	also	RB
18637	6292	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6292	23	Fong	Fong	NNP
18637	6292	24	Yue	Yue	NNP
18637	6292	25	Ting	Ting	NNP
18637	6292	26	_	_	NNP
18637	6292	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	6292	28	_	_	NNP
18637	6292	29	United	United	NNP
18637	6292	30	States	States	NNP
18637	6292	31	,	,	,
18637	6292	32	149	149	CD
18637	6292	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6292	34	698	698	CD
18637	6292	35	,	,	,
18637	6292	36	705	705	CD
18637	6292	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6292	38	1893	1893	CD
18637	6292	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6292	40	;	;	:
18637	6292	41	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	6292	42	Immigrant	Immigrant	NNP
18637	6292	43	Case	Case	NNP
18637	6292	44	,	,	,
18637	6292	45	189	189	CD
18637	6292	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6292	47	86	86	CD
18637	6292	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6292	49	1903	1903	CD
18637	6292	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6292	51	;	;	:
18637	6292	52	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	6292	53	_	_	NNP
18637	6292	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	6292	55	_	_	NNP
18637	6292	56	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	6292	57	,	,	,
18637	6292	58	194	194	CD
18637	6292	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6292	60	279	279	CD
18637	6292	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6292	62	1904	1904	CD
18637	6292	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6292	64	;	;	:
18637	6292	65	Bugajewitz	Bugajewitz	NNP
18637	6292	66	_	_	NNP
18637	6292	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	6292	68	_	_	NNP
18637	6292	69	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	6292	70	,	,	,
18637	6292	71	228	228	CD
18637	6292	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6292	73	585	585	CD
18637	6292	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6292	75	1913	1913	CD
18637	6292	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6292	77	;	;	:
18637	6292	78	Hines	Hines	NNP
18637	6292	79	_	_	NNP
18637	6292	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	6292	81	_	_	NNP
18637	6292	82	Davidowitz	Davidowitz	NNP
18637	6292	83	,	,	,
18637	6292	84	312	312	CD
18637	6292	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6292	86	52	52	CD
18637	6292	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6292	88	1941	1941	CD
18637	6292	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6292	90	.	.	.
18637	6293	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6293	2	1069	1069	CD
18637	6293	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6293	4	66	66	CD
18637	6293	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6293	6	.	.	.
18637	6294	1	163	163	CD
18637	6294	2	;	;	:
18637	6294	3	Tit	Tit	NNS
18637	6294	4	.	.	.
18637	6295	1	II	II	NNP
18637	6295	2	,	,	,
18637	6295	3	§	§	NNP
18637	6295	4	212	212	CD
18637	6295	5	.	.	.
18637	6296	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6296	2	1070	1070	CD
18637	6296	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6296	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6296	5	.	.	.
18637	6297	1	§	§	NNP
18637	6297	2	212	212	CD
18637	6297	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6297	4	a	a	NN
18637	6297	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6297	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6297	7	28	28	CD
18637	6297	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6297	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6297	10	F	f	NN
18637	6297	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6297	12	.	.	.
18637	6298	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6298	2	1071	1071	CD
18637	6298	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6298	4	54	54	CD
18637	6298	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6298	6	.	.	.
18637	6299	1	670	670	CD
18637	6299	2	.	.	.
18637	6300	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6300	2	1072	1072	CD
18637	6300	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6300	4	Hines	Hines	NNP
18637	6300	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6300	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6300	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6300	8	Davidowitz	Davidowitz	NNP
18637	6300	9	,	,	,
18637	6300	10	312	312	CD
18637	6300	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6300	12	52	52	CD
18637	6300	13	,	,	,
18637	6300	14	69	69	CD
18637	6300	15	-	-	SYM
18637	6300	16	70	70	CD
18637	6300	17	.	.	.
18637	6301	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6301	2	1073	1073	CD
18637	6301	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6301	4	66	66	CD
18637	6301	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6301	6	.	.	.
18637	6302	1	163	163	CD
18637	6302	2	;	;	:
18637	6302	3	Tit	Tit	NNS
18637	6302	4	.	.	.
18637	6303	1	II	II	NNP
18637	6303	2	,	,	,
18637	6303	3	§§	§§	NNP
18637	6303	4	261	261	CD
18637	6303	5	-	-	SYM
18637	6303	6	266	266	CD
18637	6303	7	.	.	.
18637	6304	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6304	2	1074	1074	CD
18637	6304	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6304	4	338	338	CD
18637	6304	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6304	6	537	537	CD
18637	6304	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6304	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	6304	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6304	10	.	.	.
18637	6305	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6305	2	1075	1075	CD
18637	6305	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6305	4	59	59	CD
18637	6305	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6305	6	.	.	.
18637	6306	1	659	659	CD
18637	6306	2	.	.	.
18637	6307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6307	2	1076	1076	CD
18637	6307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6307	4	338	338	CD
18637	6307	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6307	6	at	at	IN
18637	6307	7	543	543	CD
18637	6307	8	.	.	.
18637	6308	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6308	2	1077	1077	CD
18637	6308	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6308	4	Carlson	Carlson	NNP
18637	6308	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6308	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6308	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6308	8	Landon	Landon	NNP
18637	6308	9	,	,	,
18637	6308	10	342	342	CD
18637	6308	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6308	12	524	524	CD
18637	6308	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6308	14	1952	1952	CD
18637	6308	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6308	16	.	.	.
18637	6309	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6309	2	1078	1078	CD
18637	6309	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6309	4	54	54	CD
18637	6309	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6309	6	.	.	.
18637	6310	1	670	670	CD
18637	6310	2	.	.	.
18637	6311	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6311	2	1079	1079	CD
18637	6311	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6311	4	Harisiades	Harisiades	NNP
18637	6311	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6311	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6311	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6311	8	Shaughnessy	Shaughnessy	NNP
18637	6311	9	,	,	,
18637	6311	10	342	342	CD
18637	6311	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6311	12	580	580	CD
18637	6311	13	,	,	,
18637	6311	14	587	587	CD
18637	6311	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6311	16	1952	1952	CD
18637	6311	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6311	18	.	.	.
18637	6312	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6312	2	1080	1080	CD
18637	6312	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6312	4	8	8	CD
18637	6312	5	U.S.C	U.S.C	NNP
18637	6312	6	,	,	,
18637	6312	7	§	§	NNP
18637	6312	8	156	156	CD
18637	6312	9	C	C	NNP
18637	6312	10	was	be	VBD
18637	6312	11	the	the	DT
18637	6312	12	provision	provision	NN
18637	6312	13	in	in	IN
18637	6312	14	question	question	NN
18637	6312	15	.	.	.
18637	6313	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6313	2	1081	1081	CD
18637	6313	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6313	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6313	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6313	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6313	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6313	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6313	9	Spector	Spector	NNP
18637	6313	10	,	,	,
18637	6313	11	343	343	CD
18637	6313	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6313	13	169	169	CD
18637	6313	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6313	15	1952	1952	CD
18637	6313	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6313	17	.	.	.
18637	6314	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6314	2	1082	1082	CD
18637	6314	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6314	4	Keller	Keller	NNP
18637	6314	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6314	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6314	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6314	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6314	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6314	10	,	,	,
18637	6314	11	213	213	CD
18637	6314	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6314	13	138	138	CD
18637	6314	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6314	15	1909	1909	CD
18637	6314	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6314	17	.	.	.
18637	6315	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6315	2	1083	1083	CD
18637	6315	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6315	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6315	5	.	.	.
18637	6316	1	149	149	CD
18637	6316	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6316	3	150	150	CD
18637	6316	4	.	.	.
18637	6317	1	For	for	IN
18637	6317	2	the	the	DT
18637	6317	3	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	6317	4	of	of	IN
18637	6317	5	due	due	JJ
18637	6317	6	process	process	NN
18637	6317	7	of	of	IN
18637	6317	8	law	law	NN
18637	6317	9	in	in	IN
18637	6317	10	the	the	DT
18637	6317	11	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	6317	12	of	of	IN
18637	6317	13	alien	alien	NNP
18637	6317	14	,	,	,
18637	6317	15	_	_	NNP
18637	6317	16	see	see	VBP
18637	6317	17	_	_	NNP
18637	6317	18	p.	p.	NN
18637	6317	19	852	852	CD
18637	6317	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6317	21	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	6317	22	V	V	NNP
18637	6317	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6317	24	.	.	.
18637	6318	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6318	2	1084	1084	CD
18637	6318	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6318	4	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	6318	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6318	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6318	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6318	8	Storey	Storey	NNP
18637	6318	9	,	,	,
18637	6318	10	1	1	CD
18637	6318	11	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	6318	12	.	.	.
18637	6319	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	6319	2	.	.	.
18637	6320	1	No	no	UH
18637	6320	2	.	.	.
18637	6321	1	66	66	CD
18637	6321	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6321	3	1817	1817	CD
18637	6321	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6321	5	.	.	.
18637	6322	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6322	2	1085	1085	CD
18637	6322	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6322	4	2	2	CD
18637	6322	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6322	6	.	.	.
18637	6323	1	19	19	CD
18637	6323	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6323	3	1800	1800	CD
18637	6323	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6323	5	.	.	.
18637	6324	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6324	2	1086	1086	CD
18637	6324	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6324	4	Story	story	NN
18637	6324	5	's	's	POS
18637	6324	6	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	6324	7	,	,	,
18637	6324	8	II	II	NNP
18637	6324	9	,	,	,
18637	6324	10	1113	1113	CD
18637	6324	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6324	12	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	6324	13	's	's	POS
18637	6324	14	ed	ed	NN
18637	6324	15	.	.	.
18637	6325	1	1873	1873	CD
18637	6325	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6325	3	.	.	.
18637	6326	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6326	2	1087	1087	CD
18637	6326	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6326	4	186	186	CD
18637	6326	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6326	6	181	181	CD
18637	6326	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6326	8	1902	1902	CD
18637	6326	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6326	10	.	.	.
18637	6327	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6327	2	1088	1088	CD
18637	6327	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6327	4	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	6327	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	6327	6	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	6327	7	.	.	.
18637	6328	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6328	2	&	&	CC
18637	6328	3	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	6328	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6328	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6328	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6328	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6328	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	6328	9	,	,	,
18637	6328	10	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	6328	11	&	&	CC
18637	6328	12	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	6329	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6329	2	,	,	,
18637	6329	3	294	294	CD
18637	6329	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6329	5	648	648	CD
18637	6329	6	,	,	,
18637	6329	7	670	670	CD
18637	6329	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6329	9	1935	1935	CD
18637	6329	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6329	11	.	.	.
18637	6330	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6330	2	1089	1089	CD
18637	6330	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6330	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6330	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6330	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6330	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6330	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6330	9	Bekins	Bekins	NNPS
18637	6330	10	,	,	,
18637	6330	11	304	304	CD
18637	6330	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6330	13	27	27	CD
18637	6330	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6330	15	1938	1938	CD
18637	6330	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6330	17	,	,	,
18637	6330	18	distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
18637	6330	19	Ashton	Ashton	NNP
18637	6330	20	_	_	NNP
18637	6330	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	6330	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6330	23	Cameron	Cameron	NNP
18637	6330	24	County	County	NNP
18637	6330	25	Water	Water	NNP
18637	6330	26	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	6330	27	.	.	.
18637	6331	1	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	6331	2	.	.	.
18637	6331	3	,	,	,
18637	6331	4	298	298	CD
18637	6331	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6331	6	513	513	CD
18637	6331	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6331	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	6331	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6331	10	.	.	.
18637	6332	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6332	2	1090	1090	CD
18637	6332	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6332	4	In	in	IN
18637	6332	5	re	re	FW
18637	6332	6	Reiman	Reiman	NNP
18637	6332	7	,	,	,
18637	6332	8	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	6332	9	.	.	.
18637	6333	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	6333	2	.	.	.
18637	6334	1	No	no	UH
18637	6334	2	.	.	.
18637	6335	1	11,673	11,673	CD
18637	6335	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6335	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	6335	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6335	5	,	,	,
18637	6335	6	cited	cite	VBD
18637	6335	7	with	with	IN
18637	6335	8	approval	approval	NN
18637	6335	9	in	in	IN
18637	6335	10	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	6335	11	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	6335	12	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	6335	13	.	.	.
18637	6336	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6336	2	&	&	CC
18637	6336	3	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	6336	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6336	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6336	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6336	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6336	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	6336	9	,	,	,
18637	6336	10	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	6336	11	&	&	CC
18637	6336	12	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	6337	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6337	2	,	,	,
18637	6337	3	294	294	CD
18637	6337	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6337	5	648	648	CD
18637	6337	6	,	,	,
18637	6337	7	672	672	CD
18637	6337	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6337	9	1935	1935	CD
18637	6337	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6337	11	.	.	.
18637	6338	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6338	2	1091	1091	CD
18637	6338	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6338	4	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	6338	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	6338	6	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	6338	7	.	.	.
18637	6339	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6339	2	&	&	CC
18637	6339	3	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	6339	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6339	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6339	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6339	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6339	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	6339	9	,	,	,
18637	6339	10	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	6339	11	&	&	CC
18637	6339	12	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	6340	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6340	2	,	,	,
18637	6340	3	294	294	CD
18637	6340	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6340	5	648	648	CD
18637	6340	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6340	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	6340	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6340	9	.	.	.
18637	6341	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6341	2	1092	1092	CD
18637	6341	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6341	4	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	6341	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6341	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6341	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6341	8	Mountain	Mountain	NNP
18637	6341	9	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	6341	10	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6341	11	,	,	,
18637	6341	12	300	300	CD
18637	6341	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6341	14	440	440	CD
18637	6341	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6341	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	6341	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6341	18	;	;	:
18637	6341	19	Adair	Adair	NNP
18637	6341	20	_	_	NNP
18637	6341	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	6341	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6341	23	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6341	24	of	of	IN
18637	6341	25	America	America	NNP
18637	6341	26	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	6341	27	.	.	.
18637	6341	28	,	,	,
18637	6341	29	303	303	CD
18637	6341	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6341	31	350	350	CD
18637	6341	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6341	33	1938	1938	CD
18637	6341	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6341	35	.	.	.
18637	6342	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6342	2	1093	1093	CD
18637	6342	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6342	4	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	6342	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6342	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6342	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6342	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	6342	9	Central	Central	NNP
18637	6342	10	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	6342	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6342	12	,	,	,
18637	6342	13	304	304	CD
18637	6342	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6342	15	502	502	CD
18637	6342	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6342	17	1938	1938	CD
18637	6342	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6342	19	.	.	.
18637	6343	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6343	2	1094	1094	CD
18637	6343	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6343	4	294	294	CD
18637	6343	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6343	6	648	648	CD
18637	6343	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6343	8	1935	1935	CD
18637	6343	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6343	10	.	.	.
18637	6344	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6344	2	1095	1095	CD
18637	6344	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6344	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6344	5	.	.	.
18637	6345	1	671	671	CD
18637	6345	2	.	.	.
18637	6346	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6346	2	1096	1096	CD
18637	6346	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6346	4	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	6346	5	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	6346	6	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	6346	7	Land	Land	NNP
18637	6346	8	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6346	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6346	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6346	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6346	12	Radford	Radford	NNP
18637	6346	13	,	,	,
18637	6346	14	295	295	CD
18637	6346	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6346	16	555	555	CD
18637	6346	17	,	,	,
18637	6346	18	589	589	CD
18637	6346	19	,	,	,
18637	6346	20	602	602	CD
18637	6346	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6346	22	1935	1935	CD
18637	6346	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6346	24	.	.	.
18637	6347	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6347	2	1097	1097	CD
18637	6347	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6347	4	Ashton	Ashton	NNP
18637	6347	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6347	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6347	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6347	8	Cameron	Cameron	NNP
18637	6347	9	County	County	NNP
18637	6347	10	Water	Water	NNP
18637	6347	11	Improvement	Improvement	NNP
18637	6347	12	District	District	NNP
18637	6347	13	,	,	,
18637	6347	14	298	298	CD
18637	6347	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6347	16	513	513	CD
18637	6347	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6347	18	1936	1936	CD
18637	6347	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6347	20	.	.	.
18637	6348	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6348	2	But	but	CC
18637	6348	3	see	see	VB
18637	6348	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6348	5	United	United	NNP
18637	6348	6	States	States	NNP
18637	6348	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6348	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6348	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6348	10	Bekins	Bekins	NNPS
18637	6348	11	,	,	,
18637	6348	12	304	304	CD
18637	6348	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6348	14	27	27	CD
18637	6348	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6348	16	1938	1938	CD
18637	6348	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6348	18	.	.	.
18637	6349	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6349	2	1098	1098	CD
18637	6349	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6349	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	6349	5	Title	Title	NNP
18637	6349	6	&	&	CC
18637	6349	7	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	6349	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6349	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6349	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6349	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6349	12	4136	4136	CD
18637	6349	13	Wilcox	Wilcox	NNP
18637	6349	14	Bldg	Bldg	NNP
18637	6349	15	.	.	.
18637	6350	1	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6350	2	,	,	,
18637	6350	3	302	302	CD
18637	6350	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6350	5	120	120	CD
18637	6350	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6350	7	1937	1937	CD
18637	6350	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6350	9	.	.	.
18637	6351	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6351	2	1099	1099	CD
18637	6351	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6351	4	Re	Re	NNP
18637	6351	5	Klein	Klein	NNP
18637	6351	6	,	,	,
18637	6351	7	1	1	CD
18637	6351	8	How	how	WRB
18637	6351	9	.	.	.
18637	6352	1	277	277	CD
18637	6352	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6352	3	1843	1843	CD
18637	6352	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6352	5	;	;	:
18637	6352	6	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
18637	6352	7	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	6352	8	.	.	.
18637	6353	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6353	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6353	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6353	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6353	5	Moyses	Moyses	NNP
18637	6353	6	,	,	,
18637	6353	7	186	186	CD
18637	6353	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6353	9	181	181	CD
18637	6353	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6353	11	1902	1902	CD
18637	6353	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6353	13	.	.	.
18637	6354	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6354	2	1100	1100	CD
18637	6354	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6354	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6354	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6354	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6354	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6354	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6354	9	Bekins	Bekins	NNPS
18637	6354	10	,	,	,
18637	6354	11	304	304	CD
18637	6354	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6354	13	27	27	CD
18637	6354	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6354	15	1938	1938	CD
18637	6354	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6354	17	.	.	.
18637	6355	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6355	2	1101	1101	CD
18637	6355	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6355	4	Stellwagen	Stellwagen	NNP
18637	6355	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6355	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6355	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6355	8	Clum	Clum	NNP
18637	6355	9	,	,	,
18637	6355	10	245	245	CD
18637	6355	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6355	12	605	605	CD
18637	6355	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6355	14	1918	1918	CD
18637	6355	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6355	16	;	;	:
18637	6355	17	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
18637	6355	18	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	6355	19	.	.	.
18637	6356	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6356	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6356	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6356	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6356	5	Moyses	Moyses	NNP
18637	6356	6	,	,	,
18637	6356	7	186	186	CD
18637	6356	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6356	9	181	181	CD
18637	6356	10	,	,	,
18637	6356	11	190	190	CD
18637	6356	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6356	13	1902	1902	CD
18637	6356	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6356	15	.	.	.
18637	6357	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6357	2	1102	1102	CD
18637	6357	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6357	4	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
18637	6357	5	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	6357	6	.	.	.
18637	6358	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6358	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6358	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6358	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6358	5	Moyses	Moyses	NNP
18637	6358	6	,	,	,
18637	6358	7	186	186	CD
18637	6358	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6358	9	181	181	CD
18637	6358	10	,	,	,
18637	6358	11	184	184	CD
18637	6358	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6358	13	1902	1902	CD
18637	6358	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6358	15	.	.	.
18637	6359	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6359	2	1103	1103	CD
18637	6359	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6359	4	Sturges	Sturges	NNP
18637	6359	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6359	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6359	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6359	8	Crowninshield	Crowninshield	NNP
18637	6359	9	,	,	,
18637	6359	10	4	4	CD
18637	6359	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6359	12	.	.	.
18637	6360	1	122	122	CD
18637	6360	2	,	,	,
18637	6360	3	199	199	CD
18637	6360	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6360	5	1819	1819	CD
18637	6360	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6360	7	;	;	:
18637	6360	8	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	6360	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6360	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6360	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6360	12	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
18637	6360	13	,	,	,
18637	6360	14	12	12	CD
18637	6360	15	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6360	16	.	.	.
18637	6361	1	212	212	CD
18637	6361	2	,	,	,
18637	6361	3	368	368	CD
18637	6361	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6361	5	1827	1827	CD
18637	6361	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6361	7	.	.	.
18637	6362	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6362	2	1104	1104	CD
18637	6362	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6362	4	Tua	Tua	NNP
18637	6362	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6362	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6362	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6362	8	Carriere	Carriere	NNP
18637	6362	9	,	,	,
18637	6362	10	117	117	CD
18637	6362	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6362	12	201	201	CD
18637	6362	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6362	14	1886	1886	CD
18637	6362	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6362	16	;	;	:
18637	6362	17	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	6362	18	_	_	NNP
18637	6362	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	6362	20	_	_	NNP
18637	6362	21	Goreley	Goreley	NNP
18637	6362	22	,	,	,
18637	6362	23	146	146	CD
18637	6362	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6362	25	303	303	CD
18637	6362	26	,	,	,
18637	6362	27	314	314	CD
18637	6362	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6362	29	1892	1892	CD
18637	6362	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6362	31	.	.	.
18637	6363	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6363	2	1105	1105	CD
18637	6363	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6363	4	Sturges	Sturges	NNP
18637	6363	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6363	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6363	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6363	8	Crowninshield	Crowninshield	NNP
18637	6363	9	,	,	,
18637	6363	10	4	4	CD
18637	6363	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6363	12	.	.	.
18637	6364	1	122	122	CD
18637	6364	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6364	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	6364	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6364	5	.	.	.
18637	6365	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6365	2	1106	1106	CD
18637	6365	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6365	4	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	6365	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6365	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6365	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6365	8	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
18637	6365	9	,	,	,
18637	6365	10	12	12	CD
18637	6365	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6365	12	.	.	.
18637	6366	1	212	212	CD
18637	6366	2	,	,	,
18637	6366	3	358	358	CD
18637	6366	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6366	5	1827	1827	CD
18637	6366	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6366	7	;	;	:
18637	6366	8	Denny	Denny	NNP
18637	6366	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6366	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6366	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6366	12	Bennett	Bennett	NNP
18637	6366	13	,	,	,
18637	6366	14	128	128	CD
18637	6366	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6366	16	489	489	CD
18637	6366	17	,	,	,
18637	6366	18	498	498	CD
18637	6366	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6366	20	1888	1888	CD
18637	6366	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6366	22	;	;	:
18637	6366	23	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	6366	24	_	_	NNP
18637	6366	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	6366	26	_	_	NNP
18637	6366	27	Smart	Smart	NNP
18637	6366	28	,	,	,
18637	6366	29	145	145	CD
18637	6366	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6366	31	454	454	CD
18637	6366	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6366	33	1892	1892	CD
18637	6366	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6366	35	.	.	.
18637	6367	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6367	2	1107	1107	CD
18637	6367	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6367	4	Re	Re	NNP
18637	6367	5	Watts	Watts	NNP
18637	6367	6	,	,	,
18637	6367	7	190	190	CD
18637	6367	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6367	9	1	1	CD
18637	6367	10	,	,	,
18637	6367	11	27	27	CD
18637	6367	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6367	13	1903	1903	CD
18637	6367	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6367	15	;	;	:
18637	6367	16	International	International	NNP
18637	6367	17	Shoe	Shoe	NNP
18637	6367	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6367	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6367	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	6367	21	_	_	NNP
18637	6367	22	Pinkus	Pinkus	NNP
18637	6367	23	,	,	,
18637	6367	24	278	278	CD
18637	6367	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6367	26	261	261	CD
18637	6367	27	,	,	,
18637	6367	28	264	264	CD
18637	6367	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6367	30	1929	1929	CD
18637	6367	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6367	32	.	.	.
18637	6368	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6368	2	1108	1108	CD
18637	6368	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6368	4	International	International	NNP
18637	6368	5	Shoe	Shoe	NNP
18637	6368	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6368	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6368	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6368	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6368	10	Pinkus	Pinkus	NNP
18637	6368	11	,	,	,
18637	6368	12	278	278	CD
18637	6368	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6368	14	261	261	CD
18637	6368	15	,	,	,
18637	6368	16	265	265	CD
18637	6368	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6368	18	1929	1929	CD
18637	6368	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6368	20	.	.	.
18637	6369	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6369	2	1109	1109	CD
18637	6369	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6369	4	Kalb	Kalb	NNP
18637	6369	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6369	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6369	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6369	8	Feuerstein	Feuerstein	NNP
18637	6369	9	,	,	,
18637	6369	10	308	308	CD
18637	6369	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6369	12	433	433	CD
18637	6369	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6369	14	1940	1940	CD
18637	6369	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6369	16	.	.	.
18637	6370	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6370	2	1110	1110	CD
18637	6370	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6370	4	Stellwagen	Stellwagen	NNP
18637	6370	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6370	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6370	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6370	8	Clum	Clum	NNP
18637	6370	9	,	,	,
18637	6370	10	245	245	CD
18637	6370	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6370	12	605	605	CD
18637	6370	13	,	,	,
18637	6370	14	615	615	CD
18637	6370	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6370	16	1918	1918	CD
18637	6370	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6370	18	.	.	.
18637	6371	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6371	2	1111	1111	CD
18637	6371	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6371	4	Reitz	Reitz	NNP
18637	6371	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6371	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6371	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6371	8	Mealey	Mealey	NNP
18637	6371	9	,	,	,
18637	6371	10	314	314	CD
18637	6371	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6371	12	33	33	CD
18637	6371	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6371	14	1941	1941	CD
18637	6371	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6371	16	.	.	.
18637	6372	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6372	2	1112	1112	CD
18637	6372	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6372	4	New	New	NNP
18637	6372	5	York	York	NNP
18637	6372	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6372	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6372	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6372	9	Irving	Irving	NNP
18637	6372	10	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	6372	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6372	12	,	,	,
18637	6372	13	288	288	CD
18637	6372	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6372	15	329	329	CD
18637	6372	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6372	17	1933	1933	CD
18637	6372	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6372	19	.	.	.
18637	6373	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6373	2	1113	1113	CD
18637	6373	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6373	4	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	6373	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6373	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6373	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6373	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	6373	9	,	,	,
18637	6373	10	4	4	CD
18637	6373	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6373	12	.	.	.
18637	6374	1	316	316	CD
18637	6374	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6374	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	6374	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6374	5	.	.	.
18637	6375	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6375	2	1114	1114	CD
18637	6375	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6375	4	Veazie	Veazie	NNP
18637	6375	5	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6375	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6375	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6375	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6375	9	Fenno	Fenno	NNP
18637	6375	10	,	,	,
18637	6375	11	8	8	CD
18637	6375	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6375	13	.	.	.
18637	6376	1	533	533	CD
18637	6376	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6376	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	6376	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6376	5	.	.	.
18637	6377	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6377	2	1115	1115	CD
18637	6377	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6377	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6377	5	.	.	.
18637	6378	1	548	548	CD
18637	6378	2	.	.	.
18637	6379	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6379	2	1116	1116	CD
18637	6379	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6379	4	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	6379	5	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	6379	6	.	.	.
18637	6380	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6380	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6380	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6380	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6380	5	United	United	NNP
18637	6380	6	States	States	NNP
18637	6380	7	,	,	,
18637	6380	8	101	101	CD
18637	6380	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6380	10	1	1	CD
18637	6380	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6380	12	1880	1880	CD
18637	6380	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6380	14	.	.	.
18637	6381	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6381	2	1117	1117	CD
18637	6381	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6381	4	Nortz	Nortz	NNP
18637	6381	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6381	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6381	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6381	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6381	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6381	10	,	,	,
18637	6381	11	294	294	CD
18637	6381	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6381	13	317	317	CD
18637	6381	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6381	15	1935	1935	CD
18637	6381	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6381	17	.	.	.
18637	6382	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6382	2	1118	1118	CD
18637	6382	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6382	4	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	6382	5	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	6382	6	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	6382	7	,	,	,
18637	6382	8	12	12	CD
18637	6382	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6382	10	.	.	.
18637	6383	1	457	457	CD
18637	6383	2	,	,	,
18637	6383	3	549	549	CD
18637	6383	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6383	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	6383	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6383	7	;	;	:
18637	6383	8	Juilliard	Juilliard	NNP
18637	6383	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6383	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6383	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6383	12	Greenman	Greenman	NNP
18637	6383	13	,	,	,
18637	6383	14	110	110	CD
18637	6383	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6383	16	421	421	CD
18637	6383	17	,	,	,
18637	6383	18	449	449	CD
18637	6383	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6383	20	1884	1884	CD
18637	6383	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6383	22	.	.	.
18637	6384	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6384	2	1119	1119	CD
18637	6384	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6384	4	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	6384	5	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	6384	6	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	6384	7	,	,	,
18637	6384	8	12	12	CD
18637	6384	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6384	10	.	.	.
18637	6385	1	457	457	CD
18637	6385	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6385	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	6385	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6385	5	.	.	.
18637	6386	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6386	2	1120	1120	CD
18637	6386	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6386	4	Norman	Norman	NNP
18637	6386	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6386	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6386	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6386	8	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	6386	9	&	&	CC
18637	6386	10	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	6387	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6387	2	,	,	,
18637	6387	3	294	294	CD
18637	6387	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6387	5	240	240	CD
18637	6387	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6387	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	6387	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6387	9	.	.	.
18637	6388	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6388	2	1121	1121	CD
18637	6388	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6388	4	Ling	Ling	NNP
18637	6388	5	Su	Su	NNP
18637	6388	6	Fan	Fan	NNP
18637	6388	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6388	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6388	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6388	10	United	United	NNP
18637	6388	11	States	States	NNP
18637	6388	12	,	,	,
18637	6388	13	218	218	CD
18637	6388	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6388	15	302	302	CD
18637	6388	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6388	17	1910	1910	CD
18637	6388	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6388	19	.	.	.
18637	6389	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6389	2	1122	1122	CD
18637	6389	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6389	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6389	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6389	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6389	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6389	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6389	9	Marigold	Marigold	NNP
18637	6389	10	,	,	,
18637	6389	11	9	9	CD
18637	6389	12	How	how	WRB
18637	6389	13	.	.	.
18637	6390	1	560	560	CD
18637	6390	2	,	,	,
18637	6390	3	568	568	CD
18637	6390	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6390	5	1850	1850	CD
18637	6390	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6390	7	.	.	.
18637	6391	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6391	2	1123	1123	CD
18637	6391	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6391	4	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	6391	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6391	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6391	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6391	8	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	6391	9	,	,	,
18637	6391	10	5	5	CD
18637	6391	11	How	how	WRB
18637	6391	12	.	.	.
18637	6392	1	410	410	CD
18637	6392	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6392	3	1847	1847	CD
18637	6392	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6392	5	.	.	.
18637	6393	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6393	2	1124	1124	CD
18637	6393	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6393	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6393	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6393	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6393	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6393	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6393	9	Marigold	Marigold	NNP
18637	6393	10	,	,	,
18637	6393	11	9	9	CD
18637	6393	12	How	how	WRB
18637	6393	13	.	.	.
18637	6394	1	560	560	CD
18637	6394	2	,	,	,
18637	6394	3	568	568	CD
18637	6394	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6394	5	1850	1850	CD
18637	6394	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6394	7	.	.	.
18637	6395	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6395	2	1125	1125	CD
18637	6395	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6395	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6395	5	.	.	.
18637	6396	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6396	2	1126	1126	CD
18637	6396	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6396	4	Baender	Baender	NNP
18637	6396	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6396	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6396	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6396	8	Barnett	Barnett	NNP
18637	6396	9	,	,	,
18637	6396	10	255	255	CD
18637	6396	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6396	12	224	224	CD
18637	6396	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6396	14	1921	1921	CD
18637	6396	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6396	16	.	.	.
18637	6397	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6397	2	1127	1127	CD
18637	6397	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6397	4	Knox	Knox	NNP
18637	6397	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6397	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6397	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6397	8	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	6397	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6397	10	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	6397	11	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	6397	12	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	6397	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6397	14	,	,	,
18637	6397	15	12	12	CD
18637	6397	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6397	17	.	.	.
18637	6398	1	457	457	CD
18637	6398	2	,	,	,
18637	6398	3	536	536	CD
18637	6398	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6398	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	6398	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6398	7	.	.	.
18637	6399	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6399	2	1128	1128	CD
18637	6399	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6399	4	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	6399	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6399	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6399	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6399	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	6399	9	,	,	,
18637	6399	10	4	4	CD
18637	6399	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6399	12	.	.	.
18637	6400	1	316	316	CD
18637	6400	2	,	,	,
18637	6400	3	407	407	CD
18637	6400	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6400	5	1819	1819	CD
18637	6400	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6400	7	;	;	:
18637	6400	8	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	6400	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6400	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6400	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6400	12	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6400	13	of	of	IN
18637	6400	14	United	United	NNP
18637	6400	15	States	States	NNP
18637	6400	16	,	,	,
18637	6400	17	9	9	CD
18637	6400	18	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6400	19	.	.	.
18637	6401	1	738	738	CD
18637	6401	2	,	,	,
18637	6401	3	861	861	CD
18637	6401	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6401	5	1824	1824	CD
18637	6401	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6401	7	;	;	:
18637	6401	8	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	6401	9	'	'	POS
18637	6401	10	&	&	CC
18637	6401	11	Mechanics	Mechanics	NNPS
18637	6401	12	'	'	POS
18637	6401	13	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	6401	14	.	.	.
18637	6402	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6402	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6402	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6402	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6402	5	Dearing	Dearing	NNP
18637	6402	6	,	,	,
18637	6402	7	91	91	CD
18637	6402	8	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	6403	1	29	29	CD
18637	6403	2	,	,	,
18637	6403	3	33	33	CD
18637	6403	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6403	5	1875	1875	CD
18637	6403	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6403	7	;	;	:
18637	6403	8	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	6403	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6403	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6403	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6403	12	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	6403	13	City	City	NNP
18637	6403	14	Title	Title	NNP
18637	6403	15	&	&	CC
18637	6403	16	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	6403	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6403	18	,	,	,
18637	6403	19	255	255	CD
18637	6403	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6403	21	180	180	CD
18637	6403	22	,	,	,
18637	6403	23	208	208	CD
18637	6403	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6403	25	1921	1921	CD
18637	6403	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6403	27	.	.	.
18637	6404	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6404	2	1129	1129	CD
18637	6404	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6404	4	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	6404	5	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	6404	6	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	6404	7	,	,	,
18637	6404	8	12	12	CD
18637	6404	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6404	10	.	.	.
18637	6405	1	457	457	CD
18637	6405	2	,	,	,
18637	6405	3	540	540	CD
18637	6405	4	-	-	SYM
18637	6405	5	547	547	CD
18637	6405	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6405	7	1871	1871	CD
18637	6405	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6405	9	.	.	.
18637	6406	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6406	2	1130	1130	CD
18637	6406	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6406	4	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	6406	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6406	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6406	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6406	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6406	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6406	10	,	,	,
18637	6406	11	294	294	CD
18637	6406	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6406	13	330	330	CD
18637	6406	14	,	,	,
18637	6406	15	353	353	CD
18637	6406	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6406	17	1935	1935	CD
18637	6406	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6406	19	.	.	.
18637	6407	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6407	2	1131	1131	CD
18637	6407	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6407	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6407	5	.	.	.
18637	6408	1	361	361	CD
18637	6408	2	.	.	.
18637	6409	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6409	2	1132	1132	CD
18637	6409	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6409	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6409	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6409	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6409	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6409	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6409	9	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	6409	10	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	6409	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6409	12	,	,	,
18637	6409	13	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	6409	14	.	.	.
18637	6410	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	6410	2	.	.	.
18637	6411	1	No	no	UH
18637	6411	2	.	.	.
18637	6412	1	16,114	16,114	CD
18637	6412	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6412	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	6412	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6412	5	.	.	.
18637	6413	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6413	2	1133	1133	CD
18637	6413	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6413	4	Searight	Searight	NNP
18637	6413	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6413	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6413	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6413	8	Stokes	Stokes	NNP
18637	6413	9	,	,	,
18637	6413	10	3	3	CD
18637	6413	11	How	how	WRB
18637	6413	12	.	.	.
18637	6414	1	151	151	CD
18637	6414	2	,	,	,
18637	6414	3	166	166	CD
18637	6414	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6414	5	1845	1845	CD
18637	6414	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6414	7	.	.	.
18637	6415	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6415	2	1134	1134	CD
18637	6415	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6415	4	91	91	CD
18637	6415	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6415	6	367	367	CD
18637	6415	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6415	8	1876	1876	CD
18637	6415	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6415	10	.	.	.
18637	6416	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6416	2	1135	1135	CD
18637	6416	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6416	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	6416	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	6416	6	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	6416	7	,	,	,
18637	6416	8	96	96	CD
18637	6416	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6416	10	727	727	CD
18637	6416	11	,	,	,
18637	6416	12	732	732	CD
18637	6416	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6416	14	1878	1878	CD
18637	6416	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6416	16	.	.	.
18637	6417	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6417	2	1136	1136	CD
18637	6417	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6417	4	Searight	Searight	NNP
18637	6417	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6417	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6417	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6417	8	Stokes	Stokes	NNP
18637	6417	9	,	,	,
18637	6417	10	3	3	CD
18637	6417	11	How	how	WRB
18637	6417	12	.	.	.
18637	6418	1	151	151	CD
18637	6418	2	,	,	,
18637	6418	3	169	169	CD
18637	6418	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6418	5	1845	1845	CD
18637	6418	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6418	7	.	.	.
18637	6419	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6419	2	1137	1137	CD
18637	6419	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6419	4	Re	Re	NNP
18637	6419	5	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	6419	6	,	,	,
18637	6419	7	158	158	CD
18637	6419	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6419	9	564	564	CD
18637	6419	10	,	,	,
18637	6419	11	599	599	CD
18637	6419	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6419	13	1895	1895	CD
18637	6419	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6419	15	.	.	.
18637	6420	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6420	2	1138	1138	CD
18637	6420	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6420	4	2	2	CD
18637	6420	5	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	6420	6	.	.	.
18637	6421	1	Globe	Globe	NNP
18637	6421	2	4	4	CD
18637	6421	3	,	,	,
18637	6421	4	10	10	CD
18637	6421	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6421	6	1835	1835	CD
18637	6421	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6421	8	.	.	.
18637	6422	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6422	2	1139	1139	CD
18637	6422	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6422	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6422	5	.	.	.
18637	6423	1	298	298	CD
18637	6423	2	.	.	.
18637	6424	1	On	on	IN
18637	6424	2	this	this	DT
18637	6424	3	point	point	NN
18637	6424	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	6424	5	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	6424	6	would	would	MD
18637	6424	7	appear	appear	VB
18637	6424	8	to	to	TO
18637	6424	9	be	be	VB
18637	6424	10	vindicated	vindicate	VBN
18637	6424	11	by	by	IN
18637	6424	12	such	such	JJ
18637	6424	13	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	6424	14	,	,	,
18637	6424	15	as	as	IN
18637	6424	16	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	6424	17	_	_	NNP
18637	6424	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	6424	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6424	20	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	6424	21	&	&	CC
18637	6424	22	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	6425	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6425	2	,	,	,
18637	6425	3	125	125	CD
18637	6425	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6425	5	465	465	CD
18637	6425	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6425	7	1888	1888	CD
18637	6425	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6425	9	and	and	CC
18637	6425	10	Leisy	Leisy	NNP
18637	6425	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6425	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	6425	13	_	_	NNP
18637	6425	14	Hardin	Hardin	NNP
18637	6425	15	,	,	,
18637	6425	16	135	135	CD
18637	6425	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6425	18	100	100	CD
18637	6425	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6425	20	1890	1890	CD
18637	6425	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6425	22	denying	deny	VBG
18637	6425	23	the	the	DT
18637	6425	24	right	right	NN
18637	6425	25	of	of	IN
18637	6425	26	the	the	DT
18637	6425	27	States	States	NNPS
18637	6425	28	to	to	TO
18637	6425	29	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	6425	30	the	the	DT
18637	6425	31	importation	importation	NN
18637	6425	32	of	of	IN
18637	6425	33	alcoholic	alcoholic	JJ
18637	6425	34	beverages	beverage	NNS
18637	6425	35	from	from	IN
18637	6425	36	other	other	JJ
18637	6425	37	States	state	NNS
18637	6425	38	.	.	.
18637	6426	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6426	2	1140	1140	CD
18637	6426	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6426	4	96	96	CD
18637	6426	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6426	6	727	727	CD
18637	6426	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6426	8	1878	1878	CD
18637	6426	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6426	10	.	.	.
18637	6427	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6427	2	1141	1141	CD
18637	6427	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6427	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6427	5	.	.	.
18637	6428	1	732	732	CD
18637	6428	2	.	.	.
18637	6429	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6429	2	1142	1142	CD
18637	6429	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6429	4	Public	Public	NNP
18637	6429	5	Clearing	Clearing	NNP
18637	6429	6	House	House	NNP
18637	6429	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6429	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6429	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6429	10	Coyne	Coyne	NNP
18637	6429	11	,	,	,
18637	6429	12	194	194	CD
18637	6429	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6429	14	497	497	CD
18637	6429	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6429	16	1904	1904	CD
18637	6429	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6429	18	,	,	,
18637	6429	19	followed	follow	VBN
18637	6429	20	in	in	IN
18637	6429	21	Donaldson	Donaldson	NNP
18637	6429	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6429	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	6429	24	_	_	NNP
18637	6429	25	Read	Read	NNP
18637	6429	26	Magazine	Magazine	NNP
18637	6429	27	,	,	,
18637	6429	28	333	333	CD
18637	6429	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6429	30	178	178	CD
18637	6429	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6429	32	1948	1948	CD
18637	6429	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6429	34	.	.	.
18637	6430	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6430	2	1143	1143	CD
18637	6430	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6430	4	194	194	CD
18637	6430	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6430	6	at	at	IN
18637	6430	7	506	506	CD
18637	6430	8	.	.	.
18637	6431	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6431	2	1144	1144	CD
18637	6431	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6431	4	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	6431	5	Publishing	Publishing	NNP
18637	6431	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6431	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6431	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6431	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6431	10	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	6431	11	,	,	,
18637	6431	12	229	229	CD
18637	6431	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6431	14	288	288	CD
18637	6431	15	,	,	,
18637	6431	16	316	316	CD
18637	6431	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6431	18	1913	1913	CD
18637	6431	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6431	20	.	.	.
18637	6432	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6432	2	1145	1145	CD
18637	6432	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6432	4	255	255	CD
18637	6432	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6432	6	407	407	CD
18637	6432	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6432	8	1921	1921	CD
18637	6432	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6432	10	.	.	.
18637	6433	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6433	2	1146	1146	CD
18637	6433	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6433	4	Hannegan	Hannegan	NNP
18637	6433	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6433	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6433	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6433	8	Esquire	Esquire	NNP
18637	6433	9	,	,	,
18637	6433	10	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	6433	11	,	,	,
18637	6433	12	327	327	CD
18637	6433	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6433	14	146	146	CD
18637	6433	15	,	,	,
18637	6433	16	155	155	CD
18637	6433	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6433	18	1946	1946	CD
18637	6433	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6433	20	.	.	.
18637	6434	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6434	2	1147	1147	CD
18637	6434	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6434	4	49	49	CD
18637	6434	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	6434	6	.	.	.
18637	6435	1	803	803	CD
18637	6435	2	,	,	,
18637	6435	3	812	812	CD
18637	6435	4	,	,	,
18637	6435	5	813	813	CD
18637	6435	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6435	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	6435	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6435	9	,	,	,
18637	6435	10	15	15	CD
18637	6435	11	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
18637	6436	1	79d	79d	NNS
18637	6436	2	,	,	,
18637	6436	3	79e	79e	NNS
18637	6436	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6436	5	1946	1946	CD
18637	6436	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6436	7	.	.	.
18637	6437	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6437	2	1148	1148	CD
18637	6437	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6437	4	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	6437	5	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	6437	6	&	&	CC
18637	6437	7	Share	Share	NNP
18637	6437	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6437	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6437	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6437	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6437	12	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	6437	13	and	and	CC
18637	6437	14	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	6437	15	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	6437	16	.	.	.
18637	6437	17	,	,	,
18637	6437	18	303	303	CD
18637	6437	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6437	20	419	419	CD
18637	6437	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6437	22	1938	1938	CD
18637	6437	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6437	24	.	.	.
18637	6438	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6438	2	1149	1149	CD
18637	6438	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6438	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6438	5	.	.	.
18637	6439	1	442	442	CD
18637	6439	2	.	.	.
18637	6440	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6440	2	1150	1150	CD
18637	6440	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6440	4	Pensacola	Pensacola	NNP
18637	6440	5	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	6440	6	.	.	.
18637	6441	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6441	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6441	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6441	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6441	5	Western	Western	NNP
18637	6441	6	U.	U.	NNP
18637	6441	7	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	6441	8	.	.	.
18637	6442	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6442	2	,	,	,
18637	6442	3	90	90	CD
18637	6442	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6442	5	1	1	CD
18637	6442	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6442	7	1878	1878	CD
18637	6442	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6442	9	.	.	.
18637	6443	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6443	2	1151	1151	CD
18637	6443	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6443	4	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	6443	5	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	6444	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6444	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6444	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6444	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6444	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	6444	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	6444	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	6444	8	.	.	.
18637	6445	1	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	6445	2	,	,	,
18637	6445	3	163	163	CD
18637	6445	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6445	5	142	142	CD
18637	6445	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6445	7	1896	1896	CD
18637	6445	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6445	9	.	.	.
18637	6446	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6446	2	1152	1152	CD
18637	6446	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6446	4	Gladson	Gladson	NNP
18637	6446	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6446	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6446	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6446	8	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	6446	9	,	,	,
18637	6446	10	166	166	CD
18637	6446	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6446	12	427	427	CD
18637	6446	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6446	14	1897	1897	CD
18637	6446	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6446	16	.	.	.
18637	6447	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6447	2	1153	1153	CD
18637	6447	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6447	4	Price	Price	NNP
18637	6447	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6447	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6447	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6447	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	6447	9	R.	R.	NNP
18637	6447	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6447	11	,	,	,
18637	6447	12	113	113	CD
18637	6447	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6447	14	218	218	CD
18637	6447	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6447	16	1885	1885	CD
18637	6447	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6447	18	;	;	:
18637	6447	19	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	6447	20	_	_	NNP
18637	6447	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	6447	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6447	23	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	6447	24	&	&	CC
18637	6447	25	L.E.R.	L.E.R.	NNP
18637	6448	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6448	2	,	,	,
18637	6448	3	203	203	CD
18637	6448	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6448	5	284	284	CD
18637	6448	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6448	7	1906	1906	CD
18637	6448	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6448	9	.	.	.
18637	6449	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6449	2	1154	1154	CD
18637	6449	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6449	4	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	6449	5	Mail	Mail	NNP
18637	6449	6	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	6449	7	.	.	.
18637	6450	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6450	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	6450	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6450	4	Corsi	Corsi	NNP
18637	6450	5	,	,	,
18637	6450	6	326	326	CD
18637	6450	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6450	8	88	88	CD
18637	6450	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6450	10	1945	1945	CD
18637	6450	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6450	12	.	.	.
18637	6451	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6451	2	1155	1155	CD
18637	6451	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6451	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6451	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6451	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6451	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6451	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6451	9	Kirby	Kirby	NNP
18637	6451	10	,	,	,
18637	6451	11	7	7	CD
18637	6451	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6451	13	.	.	.
18637	6452	1	482	482	CD
18637	6452	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6452	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	6452	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6452	5	.	.	.
18637	6453	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6453	2	1156	1156	CD
18637	6453	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6453	4	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	6453	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6453	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6453	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6453	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	6453	9	,	,	,
18637	6453	10	254	254	CD
18637	6453	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6453	12	51	51	CD
18637	6453	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6453	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	6453	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6453	16	.	.	.
18637	6454	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6454	2	1157	1157	CD
18637	6454	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6454	4	Pennock	Pennock	NNP
18637	6454	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6454	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6454	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6454	8	Dialogue	Dialogue	NNP
18637	6454	9	,	,	,
18637	6454	10	2	2	CD
18637	6454	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	6454	12	.	.	.
18637	6455	1	1	1	CD
18637	6455	2	,	,	,
18637	6455	3	17	17	CD
18637	6455	4	,	,	,
18637	6455	5	18	18	CD
18637	6455	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6455	7	1829	1829	CD
18637	6455	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6455	9	.	.	.
18637	6456	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6456	2	1158	1158	CD
18637	6456	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6456	4	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
18637	6456	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6456	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6456	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6456	8	Peters	Peters	NNP
18637	6456	9	,	,	,
18637	6456	10	8	8	CD
18637	6456	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	6456	12	.	.	.
18637	6457	1	591	591	CD
18637	6457	2	,	,	,
18637	6457	3	656	656	CD
18637	6457	4	,	,	,
18637	6457	5	658	658	CD
18637	6457	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6457	7	1834	1834	CD
18637	6457	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6457	9	.	.	.
18637	6458	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6458	2	1159	1159	CD
18637	6458	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6458	4	Kendall	Kendall	NNP
18637	6458	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6458	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6458	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6458	8	Winsor	Winsor	NNP
18637	6458	9	,	,	,
18637	6458	10	21	21	CD
18637	6458	11	How	how	WRB
18637	6458	12	.	.	.
18637	6459	1	322	322	CD
18637	6459	2	,	,	,
18637	6459	3	328	328	CD
18637	6459	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6459	5	1859	1859	CD
18637	6459	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6459	7	;	;	:
18637	6459	8	Great	Great	NNP
18637	6459	9	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	6459	10	&	&	CC
18637	6459	11	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	6459	12	Tea	Tea	NNP
18637	6459	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6459	14	_	_	NNP
18637	6459	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	6459	16	_	_	NNP
18637	6459	17	Supermarket	Supermarket	NNP
18637	6459	18	Equipment	Equipment	NNP
18637	6459	19	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6459	20	,	,	,
18637	6459	21	340	340	CD
18637	6459	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6459	23	147	147	CD
18637	6459	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6459	25	1950	1950	CD
18637	6459	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6459	27	.	.	.
18637	6460	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6460	2	1160	1160	CD
18637	6460	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6460	4	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	6460	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6460	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6460	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6460	8	Jordan	Jordan	NNP
18637	6460	9	,	,	,
18637	6460	10	9	9	CD
18637	6460	11	Cr	cr	NN
18637	6460	12	.	.	.
18637	6461	1	199	199	CD
18637	6461	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6461	3	1815	1815	CD
18637	6461	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6461	5	;	;	:
18637	6461	6	Bloomer	Bloomer	NNP
18637	6461	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6461	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6461	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6461	10	McQuewan	McQuewan	NNP
18637	6461	11	,	,	,
18637	6461	12	14	14	CD
18637	6461	13	How	how	WRB
18637	6461	14	.	.	.
18637	6462	1	539	539	CD
18637	6462	2	,	,	,
18637	6462	3	548	548	CD
18637	6462	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6462	5	1852	1852	CD
18637	6462	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6462	7	;	;	:
18637	6462	8	Bloomer	Bloomer	NNP
18637	6462	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6462	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6462	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6462	12	Millinger	Millinger	NNP
18637	6462	13	,	,	,
18637	6462	14	1	1	CD
18637	6462	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6462	16	.	.	.
18637	6463	1	340	340	CD
18637	6463	2	,	,	,
18637	6463	3	350	350	CD
18637	6463	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6463	5	1864	1864	CD
18637	6463	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6463	7	;	;	:
18637	6463	8	Eunson	Eunson	NNP
18637	6463	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6463	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6463	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6463	12	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	6463	13	,	,	,
18637	6463	14	18	18	CD
18637	6463	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6463	16	.	.	.
18637	6464	1	414	414	CD
18637	6464	2	,	,	,
18637	6464	3	416	416	CD
18637	6464	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6464	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	6464	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6464	7	.	.	.
18637	6465	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6465	2	1161	1161	CD
18637	6465	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6465	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	6465	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6465	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6465	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6465	8	Duchesne	Duchesne	NNP
18637	6465	9	,	,	,
18637	6465	10	19	19	CD
18637	6465	11	How	how	WRB
18637	6465	12	.	.	.
18637	6466	1	183	183	CD
18637	6466	2	,	,	,
18637	6466	3	195	195	CD
18637	6466	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6466	5	1857	1857	CD
18637	6466	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6466	7	.	.	.
18637	6467	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6467	2	1162	1162	CD
18637	6467	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6467	4	Seymour	Seymour	NNP
18637	6467	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6467	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6467	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6467	8	Osborne	Osborne	NNP
18637	6467	9	,	,	,
18637	6467	10	11	11	CD
18637	6467	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6467	12	.	.	.
18637	6468	1	516	516	CD
18637	6468	2	,	,	,
18637	6468	3	549	549	CD
18637	6468	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6468	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	6468	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6468	7	.	.	.
18637	6469	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6469	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	6469	3	.	.	.
18637	6469	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6469	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	6469	6	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	6469	7	Collar	Collar	NNP
18637	6469	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6469	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6469	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6469	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6469	12	Van	Van	NNP
18637	6469	13	Dusen	Dusen	NNP
18637	6469	14	,	,	,
18637	6469	15	23	23	CD
18637	6469	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6469	17	.	.	.
18637	6470	1	530	530	CD
18637	6470	2	,	,	,
18637	6470	3	563	563	CD
18637	6470	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6470	5	1875	1875	CD
18637	6470	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6470	7	;	;	:
18637	6470	8	Reckendorfer	Reckendorfer	NNP
18637	6470	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6470	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6470	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6470	12	Faber	Faber	NNP
18637	6470	13	,	,	,
18637	6470	14	92	92	CD
18637	6470	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6470	16	347	347	CD
18637	6470	17	,	,	,
18637	6470	18	356	356	CD
18637	6470	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6470	20	1876	1876	CD
18637	6470	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6470	22	.	.	.
18637	6471	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6471	2	1163	1163	CD
18637	6471	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6471	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	6471	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6471	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6471	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6471	8	Nichols	Nichols	NNP
18637	6471	9	,	,	,
18637	6471	10	21	21	CD
18637	6471	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6471	12	.	.	.
18637	6472	1	112	112	CD
18637	6472	2	,	,	,
18637	6472	3	118	118	CD
18637	6472	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6472	5	1875	1875	CD
18637	6472	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6472	7	.	.	.
18637	6473	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6473	2	1164	1164	CD
18637	6473	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6473	4	Rubber	Rubber	NNP
18637	6473	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	6473	6	Tip	Tip	NNP
18637	6473	7	Pencil	Pencil	NNP
18637	6473	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6473	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6473	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6473	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6473	12	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	6473	13	,	,	,
18637	6473	14	20	20	CD
18637	6473	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6473	16	.	.	.
18637	6474	1	498	498	CD
18637	6474	2	,	,	,
18637	6474	3	507	507	CD
18637	6474	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6474	5	1874	1874	CD
18637	6474	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6474	7	;	;	:
18637	6474	8	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	6474	9	Thread	Thread	NNP
18637	6474	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6474	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6474	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	6474	13	_	_	NNP
18637	6474	14	Willimantic	Willimantic	NNP
18637	6474	15	Linen	Linen	NNP
18637	6474	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6474	17	,	,	,
18637	6474	18	140	140	CD
18637	6474	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6474	20	481	481	CD
18637	6474	21	,	,	,
18637	6474	22	489	489	CD
18637	6474	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6474	24	1891	1891	CD
18637	6474	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6474	26	.	.	.
18637	6475	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6475	2	1165	1165	CD
18637	6475	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6475	4	Funk	Funk	NNP
18637	6475	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	6476	1	Seed	Seed	NNP
18637	6476	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6476	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6476	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	6476	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6476	6	Kalo	Kalo	NNP
18637	6476	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6476	8	,	,	,
18637	6476	9	333	333	CD
18637	6476	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6476	11	127	127	CD
18637	6476	12	,	,	,
18637	6476	13	130	130	CD
18637	6476	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6476	15	1948	1948	CD
18637	6476	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6476	17	.	.	.
18637	6477	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6477	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	6477	3	.	.	.
18637	6477	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6477	5	Dow	Dow	NNP
18637	6477	6	Chemical	Chemical	NNP
18637	6477	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6477	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6477	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	6477	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6477	11	Halliburton	Halliburton	NNP
18637	6477	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6477	13	,	,	,
18637	6477	14	324	324	CD
18637	6477	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6477	16	320	320	CD
18637	6477	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6477	18	1945	1945	CD
18637	6477	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6477	20	;	;	:
18637	6477	21	Cuno	Cuno	NNP
18637	6477	22	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6477	23	_	_	NNP
18637	6477	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	6477	25	_	_	NNP
18637	6477	26	Automatic	Automatic	NNP
18637	6477	27	Devices	Devices	NNPS
18637	6477	28	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6477	29	,	,	,
18637	6477	30	314	314	CD
18637	6477	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6477	32	84	84	CD
18637	6477	33	,	,	,
18637	6477	34	89	89	CD
18637	6477	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6477	36	1941	1941	CD
18637	6477	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6477	38	.	.	.
18637	6478	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6478	2	1166	1166	CD
18637	6478	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6478	4	Sinclair	Sinclair	NNP
18637	6478	5	&	&	CC
18637	6478	6	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	6478	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6478	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6478	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	6478	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6478	11	Interchemical	Interchemical	NNP
18637	6478	12	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6478	13	,	,	,
18637	6478	14	325	325	CD
18637	6478	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6478	16	327	327	CD
18637	6478	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6478	18	1945	1945	CD
18637	6478	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6478	20	;	;	:
18637	6478	21	Marconi	Marconi	NNP
18637	6478	22	Wireless	Wireless	NNP
18637	6478	23	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	6478	24	.	.	.
18637	6479	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6479	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6479	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6479	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6479	5	United	United	NNP
18637	6479	6	States	States	NNP
18637	6479	7	,	,	,
18637	6479	8	320	320	CD
18637	6479	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6479	10	1	1	CD
18637	6479	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6479	12	1943	1943	CD
18637	6479	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6479	14	.	.	.
18637	6480	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6480	2	1167	1167	CD
18637	6480	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6480	4	Keystone	Keystone	NNP
18637	6480	5	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	6480	6	.	.	.
18637	6481	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6481	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6481	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6481	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6481	5	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	6481	6	,	,	,
18637	6481	7	151	151	CD
18637	6481	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6481	9	139	139	CD
18637	6481	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6481	11	1894	1894	CD
18637	6481	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6481	13	;	;	:
18637	6481	14	Diamond	Diamond	NNP
18637	6481	15	Rubber	Rubber	NNP
18637	6481	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6481	17	_	_	NNP
18637	6481	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	6481	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6481	20	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	6481	21	Tire	Tire	NNP
18637	6481	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6481	23	,	,	,
18637	6481	24	220	220	CD
18637	6481	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6481	26	428	428	CD
18637	6481	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6481	28	1911	1911	CD
18637	6481	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6481	30	.	.	.
18637	6482	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6482	2	1168	1168	CD
18637	6482	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6482	4	Great	Great	NNP
18637	6482	5	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	6482	6	&	&	CC
18637	6482	7	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	6482	8	Tea	Tea	NNP
18637	6482	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6482	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6482	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	6482	12	_	_	NNP
18637	6482	13	Supermarket	Supermarket	NNP
18637	6482	14	Equipment	Equipment	NNP
18637	6482	15	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6482	16	,	,	,
18637	6482	17	340	340	CD
18637	6482	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6482	19	147	147	CD
18637	6482	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6482	21	1950	1950	CD
18637	6482	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6482	23	.	.	.
18637	6483	1	An	an	DT
18637	6483	2	interesting	interesting	JJ
18637	6483	3	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	6483	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	6483	5	was	be	VBD
18637	6483	6	filed	file	VBN
18637	6483	7	by	by	IN
18637	6483	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6483	9	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	6483	10	for	for	IN
18637	6483	11	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6483	12	and	and	CC
18637	6483	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6483	14	Black	Black	NNP
18637	6483	15	:	:	:
18637	6483	16	"	"	``
18637	6483	17	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6483	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	6483	19	not	not	RB
18637	6483	20	enough	enough	JJ
18637	6483	21	,	,	,
18637	6483	22	"	"	''
18637	6483	23	says	say	VBZ
18637	6483	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6483	25	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	6483	26	,	,	,
18637	6483	27	"	"	''
18637	6483	28	that	that	IN
18637	6483	29	an	an	DT
18637	6483	30	article	article	NN
18637	6483	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	6483	32	new	new	JJ
18637	6483	33	and	and	CC
18637	6483	34	useful	useful	JJ
18637	6483	35	.	.	.
18637	6484	1	The	the	DT
18637	6484	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	6484	3	never	never	RB
18637	6484	4	sanctioned	sanction	VBD
18637	6484	5	the	the	DT
18637	6484	6	patenting	patenting	NN
18637	6484	7	of	of	IN
18637	6484	8	gadgets	gadget	NNS
18637	6484	9	.	.	.
18637	6485	1	Patents	patent	NNS
18637	6485	2	serve	serve	VBP
18637	6485	3	a	a	DT
18637	6485	4	higher	high	JJR
18637	6485	5	end	end	NN
18637	6485	6	--	--	:
18637	6485	7	the	the	DT
18637	6485	8	advancement	advancement	NN
18637	6485	9	of	of	IN
18637	6485	10	science	science	NN
18637	6485	11	.	.	.
18637	6486	1	An	an	DT
18637	6486	2	invention	invention	NN
18637	6486	3	need	nee	MD
18637	6486	4	not	not	RB
18637	6486	5	be	be	VB
18637	6486	6	as	as	RB
18637	6486	7	startling	startling	JJ
18637	6486	8	as	as	IN
18637	6486	9	an	an	DT
18637	6486	10	atomic	atomic	JJ
18637	6486	11	bomb	bomb	NN
18637	6486	12	to	to	TO
18637	6486	13	be	be	VB
18637	6486	14	patentable	patentable	JJ
18637	6486	15	.	.	.
18637	6487	1	But	but	CC
18637	6487	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6487	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	6487	4	to	to	TO
18637	6487	5	be	be	VB
18637	6487	6	of	of	IN
18637	6487	7	such	such	JJ
18637	6487	8	quality	quality	NN
18637	6487	9	and	and	CC
18637	6487	10	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	6487	11	that	that	IN
18637	6487	12	masters	master	NNS
18637	6487	13	of	of	IN
18637	6487	14	the	the	DT
18637	6487	15	scientific	scientific	JJ
18637	6487	16	field	field	NN
18637	6487	17	in	in	IN
18637	6487	18	which	which	WDT
18637	6487	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6487	20	falls	fall	VBZ
18637	6487	21	will	will	MD
18637	6487	22	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	6487	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6487	24	as	as	IN
18637	6487	25	an	an	DT
18637	6487	26	advance	advance	NN
18637	6487	27	.	.	.
18637	6487	28	"	"	''
18637	6488	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	6488	2	.	.	.
18637	6489	1	154	154	CD
18637	6489	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6489	3	155	155	CD
18637	6489	4	.	.	.
18637	6490	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6490	2	then	then	RB
18637	6490	3	quotes	quote	VBZ
18637	6490	4	the	the	DT
18637	6490	5	following	following	NN
18637	6490	6	from	from	IN
18637	6490	7	an	an	DT
18637	6490	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	6490	9	of	of	IN
18637	6490	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6490	11	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	6490	12	's	's	POS
18637	6490	13	given	give	VBN
18637	6490	14	70	70	CD
18637	6490	15	years	year	NNS
18637	6490	16	ago	ago	RB
18637	6490	17	:	:	:
18637	6490	18	"	"	``
18637	6490	19	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6490	20	was	be	VBD
18637	6490	21	never	never	RB
18637	6490	22	the	the	DT
18637	6490	23	object	object	NN
18637	6490	24	of	of	IN
18637	6490	25	those	those	DT
18637	6490	26	laws	law	NNS
18637	6490	27	to	to	TO
18637	6490	28	grant	grant	VB
18637	6490	29	a	a	DT
18637	6490	30	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	6490	31	for	for	IN
18637	6490	32	every	every	DT
18637	6490	33	trifling	trifle	VBG
18637	6490	34	device	device	NN
18637	6490	35	,	,	,
18637	6490	36	every	every	DT
18637	6490	37	shadow	shadow	NN
18637	6490	38	of	of	IN
18637	6490	39	a	a	DT
18637	6490	40	shade	shade	NN
18637	6490	41	of	of	IN
18637	6490	42	an	an	DT
18637	6490	43	idea	idea	NN
18637	6490	44	,	,	,
18637	6490	45	which	which	WDT
18637	6490	46	would	would	MD
18637	6490	47	naturally	naturally	RB
18637	6490	48	and	and	CC
18637	6490	49	spontaneously	spontaneously	RB
18637	6490	50	occur	occur	VB
18637	6490	51	to	to	IN
18637	6490	52	any	any	DT
18637	6490	53	skilled	skilled	JJ
18637	6490	54	mechanic	mechanic	NN
18637	6490	55	or	or	CC
18637	6490	56	operator	operator	NN
18637	6490	57	in	in	IN
18637	6490	58	the	the	DT
18637	6490	59	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	6490	60	progress	progress	NN
18637	6490	61	of	of	IN
18637	6490	62	manufactures	manufacture	NNS
18637	6490	63	.	.	.
18637	6491	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	6491	2	an	an	DT
18637	6491	3	indiscriminate	indiscriminate	JJ
18637	6491	4	creation	creation	NN
18637	6491	5	of	of	IN
18637	6491	6	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	6491	7	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	6491	8	tends	tend	VBZ
18637	6491	9	rather	rather	RB
18637	6491	10	to	to	TO
18637	6491	11	obstruct	obstruct	VB
18637	6491	12	than	than	IN
18637	6491	13	to	to	TO
18637	6491	14	stimulate	stimulate	VB
18637	6491	15	invention	invention	NN
18637	6491	16	.	.	.
18637	6492	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6492	2	creates	create	VBZ
18637	6492	3	a	a	DT
18637	6492	4	class	class	NN
18637	6492	5	of	of	IN
18637	6492	6	speculative	speculative	JJ
18637	6492	7	schemers	schemer	NNS
18637	6492	8	who	who	WP
18637	6492	9	make	make	VBP
18637	6492	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6492	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	6492	12	business	business	NN
18637	6492	13	to	to	TO
18637	6492	14	watch	watch	VB
18637	6492	15	the	the	DT
18637	6492	16	advancing	advance	VBG
18637	6492	17	wave	wave	NN
18637	6492	18	of	of	IN
18637	6492	19	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	6492	20	,	,	,
18637	6492	21	and	and	CC
18637	6492	22	gather	gather	VB
18637	6492	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	6492	24	foam	foam	NN
18637	6492	25	in	in	IN
18637	6492	26	the	the	DT
18637	6492	27	form	form	NN
18637	6492	28	of	of	IN
18637	6492	29	patented	patent	VBN
18637	6492	30	monopolies	monopoly	NNS
18637	6492	31	,	,	,
18637	6492	32	which	which	WDT
18637	6492	33	enable	enable	VBP
18637	6492	34	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6492	35	to	to	TO
18637	6492	36	lay	lay	VB
18637	6492	37	a	a	DT
18637	6492	38	heavy	heavy	JJ
18637	6492	39	tax	tax	NN
18637	6492	40	upon	upon	IN
18637	6492	41	the	the	DT
18637	6492	42	industry	industry	NN
18637	6492	43	of	of	IN
18637	6492	44	the	the	DT
18637	6492	45	country	country	NN
18637	6492	46	,	,	,
18637	6492	47	without	without	IN
18637	6492	48	contributing	contribute	VBG
18637	6492	49	anything	anything	NN
18637	6492	50	to	to	IN
18637	6492	51	the	the	DT
18637	6492	52	real	real	JJ
18637	6492	53	advancement	advancement	NN
18637	6492	54	of	of	IN
18637	6492	55	the	the	DT
18637	6492	56	arts	art	NNS
18637	6492	57	.	.	.
18637	6493	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6493	2	embarrasses	embarrass	VBZ
18637	6493	3	the	the	DT
18637	6493	4	honest	honest	JJ
18637	6493	5	pursuit	pursuit	NN
18637	6493	6	of	of	IN
18637	6493	7	business	business	NN
18637	6493	8	with	with	IN
18637	6493	9	fears	fear	NNS
18637	6493	10	and	and	CC
18637	6493	11	apprehensions	apprehension	NNS
18637	6493	12	of	of	IN
18637	6493	13	concealed	conceal	VBN
18637	6493	14	liens	lien	NNS
18637	6493	15	and	and	CC
18637	6493	16	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	6493	17	liabilities	liability	NNS
18637	6493	18	to	to	IN
18637	6493	19	lawsuits	lawsuit	NNS
18637	6493	20	and	and	CC
18637	6493	21	vexatious	vexatious	JJ
18637	6493	22	accountings	accounting	NNS
18637	6493	23	for	for	IN
18637	6493	24	profits	profit	NNS
18637	6493	25	made	make	VBN
18637	6493	26	in	in	IN
18637	6493	27	good	good	JJ
18637	6493	28	faith	faith	NN
18637	6493	29	.	.	.
18637	6494	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6494	2	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	6494	3	Works	Works	NNP
18637	6494	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6494	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	6494	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6494	7	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	6494	8	,	,	,
18637	6494	9	107	107	CD
18637	6494	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6494	11	192	192	CD
18637	6494	12	,	,	,
18637	6494	13	200	200	CD
18637	6494	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6494	15	1882	1882	CD
18637	6494	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6494	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6494	18	.	.	.
18637	6494	19	"	"	''
18637	6495	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	6495	2	.	.	.
18637	6496	1	155	155	CD
18637	6496	2	.	.	.
18637	6497	1	The	the	DT
18637	6497	2	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	6497	3	concludes	conclude	VBZ
18637	6497	4	:	:	:
18637	6497	5	"	"	``
18637	6497	6	The	the	DT
18637	6497	7	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	6497	8	through	through	IN
18637	6497	9	the	the	DT
18637	6497	10	years	year	NNS
18637	6497	11	to	to	TO
18637	6497	12	get	get	VB
18637	6497	13	a	a	DT
18637	6497	14	broader	broad	JJR
18637	6497	15	,	,	,
18637	6497	16	looser	loose	JJR
18637	6497	17	conception	conception	NN
18637	6497	18	of	of	IN
18637	6497	19	patents	patent	NNS
18637	6497	20	than	than	IN
18637	6497	21	the	the	DT
18637	6497	22	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	6497	23	contemplates	contemplate	NNS
18637	6497	24	have	have	VBP
18637	6497	25	been	be	VBN
18637	6497	26	persistent	persistent	JJ
18637	6497	27	.	.	.
18637	6498	1	The	the	DT
18637	6498	2	Patent	Patent	NNP
18637	6498	3	Office	Office	NNP
18637	6498	4	,	,	,
18637	6498	5	like	like	IN
18637	6498	6	most	most	JJS
18637	6498	7	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	6498	8	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	6498	9	,	,	,
18637	6498	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	6498	11	looked	look	VBN
18637	6498	12	with	with	IN
18637	6498	13	favor	favor	NN
18637	6498	14	on	on	IN
18637	6498	15	the	the	DT
18637	6498	16	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	6498	17	which	which	WDT
18637	6498	18	the	the	DT
18637	6498	19	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	6498	20	of	of	IN
18637	6498	21	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	6498	22	affords	afford	NNS
18637	6498	23	to	to	TO
18637	6498	24	expand	expand	VB
18637	6498	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	6498	26	own	own	JJ
18637	6498	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	6498	28	.	.	.
18637	6499	1	And	and	CC
18637	6499	2	so	so	RB
18637	6499	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6499	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	6499	5	placed	place	VBN
18637	6499	6	a	a	DT
18637	6499	7	host	host	NN
18637	6499	8	of	of	IN
18637	6499	9	gadgets	gadget	NNS
18637	6499	10	under	under	IN
18637	6499	11	the	the	DT
18637	6499	12	armour	armour	NN
18637	6499	13	of	of	IN
18637	6499	14	patents	patent	NNS
18637	6499	15	--	--	:
18637	6499	16	gadgets	gadget	NNS
18637	6499	17	that	that	WDT
18637	6499	18	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	6499	19	have	have	VBP
18637	6499	20	had	have	VBN
18637	6499	21	no	no	DT
18637	6499	22	place	place	NN
18637	6499	23	in	in	IN
18637	6499	24	the	the	DT
18637	6499	25	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	6499	26	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	6499	27	of	of	IN
18637	6499	28	advancing	advance	VBG
18637	6499	29	scientific	scientific	JJ
18637	6499	30	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	6499	31	.	.	.
18637	6500	1	A	a	DT
18637	6500	2	few	few	JJ
18637	6500	3	that	that	WDT
18637	6500	4	have	have	VBP
18637	6500	5	reached	reach	VBN
18637	6500	6	this	this	DT
18637	6500	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	6500	8	show	show	VB
18637	6500	9	the	the	DT
18637	6500	10	pressure	pressure	NN
18637	6500	11	to	to	TO
18637	6500	12	extend	extend	VB
18637	6500	13	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	6500	14	to	to	IN
18637	6500	15	the	the	DT
18637	6500	16	simplest	simple	JJS
18637	6500	17	of	of	IN
18637	6500	18	devices	device	NNS
18637	6500	19	:	:	:
18637	6500	20	"	"	``
18637	6500	21	Hotchkiss	Hotchkiss	NNP
18637	6500	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6500	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	6500	24	_	_	NNP
18637	6500	25	Greenwood	Greenwood	NNP
18637	6500	26	,	,	,
18637	6500	27	11	11	CD
18637	6500	28	How	how	WRB
18637	6500	29	.	.	.
18637	6501	1	248	248	CD
18637	6501	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6501	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	6501	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6501	5	:	:	:
18637	6501	6	Doorknob	Doorknob	NNP
18637	6501	7	made	make	VBN
18637	6501	8	of	of	IN
18637	6501	9	clay	clay	NN
18637	6501	10	rather	rather	RB
18637	6501	11	than	than	IN
18637	6501	12	metal	metal	NN
18637	6501	13	or	or	CC
18637	6501	14	wood	wood	NN
18637	6501	15	,	,	,
18637	6501	16	where	where	WRB
18637	6501	17	different	different	JJ
18637	6501	18	shaped	shaped	JJ
18637	6501	19	doorknobs	doorknob	NNS
18637	6501	20	had	have	VBD
18637	6501	21	previously	previously	RB
18637	6501	22	been	be	VBN
18637	6501	23	made	make	VBN
18637	6501	24	of	of	IN
18637	6501	25	clay	clay	NN
18637	6501	26	.	.	.
18637	6502	1	"	"	``
18637	6502	2	Rubber	Rubber	NNP
18637	6502	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	6502	4	Tip	Tip	NNP
18637	6502	5	Pencil	Pencil	NNP
18637	6502	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6502	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6502	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6502	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6502	10	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	6502	11	,	,	,
18637	6502	12	20	20	CD
18637	6502	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6502	14	.	.	.
18637	6503	1	498	498	CD
18637	6503	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6503	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	6503	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6503	5	:	:	:
18637	6503	6	Rubber	rubber	NN
18637	6503	7	caps	cap	NNS
18637	6503	8	put	put	VBP
18637	6503	9	on	on	IN
18637	6503	10	wood	wood	NN
18637	6503	11	pencils	pencil	NNS
18637	6503	12	to	to	TO
18637	6503	13	serve	serve	VB
18637	6503	14	as	as	IN
18637	6503	15	erasers	eraser	NNS
18637	6503	16	.	.	.
18637	6504	1	"	"	``
18637	6504	2	Union	Union	NNP
18637	6504	3	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	6504	4	Collar	Collar	NNP
18637	6504	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6504	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6504	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6504	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6504	9	Van	Van	NNP
18637	6504	10	Dusen	Dusen	NNP
18637	6504	11	,	,	,
18637	6504	12	23	23	CD
18637	6504	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6504	14	.	.	.
18637	6505	1	530	530	CD
18637	6505	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6505	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	6505	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6505	5	:	:	:
18637	6505	6	Making	make	VBG
18637	6505	7	collars	collar	NNS
18637	6505	8	of	of	IN
18637	6505	9	parchment	parchment	NN
18637	6505	10	paper	paper	NN
18637	6505	11	where	where	WRB
18637	6505	12	linen	linen	NN
18637	6505	13	paper	paper	NN
18637	6505	14	and	and	CC
18637	6505	15	linen	linen	NN
18637	6505	16	had	have	VBD
18637	6505	17	previously	previously	RB
18637	6505	18	been	be	VBN
18637	6505	19	used	use	VBN
18637	6505	20	.	.	.
18637	6506	1	"	"	``
18637	6506	2	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	6506	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6506	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	6506	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6506	6	Piper	Piper	NNP
18637	6506	7	,	,	,
18637	6506	8	91	91	CD
18637	6506	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6506	10	37	37	CD
18637	6506	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6506	12	1875	1875	CD
18637	6506	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6506	14	:	:	:
18637	6506	15	A	a	DT
18637	6506	16	method	method	NN
18637	6506	17	for	for	IN
18637	6506	18	preserving	preserve	VBG
18637	6506	19	fish	fish	NN
18637	6506	20	by	by	IN
18637	6506	21	freezing	freeze	VBG
18637	6506	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6506	23	in	in	IN
18637	6506	24	a	a	DT
18637	6506	25	container	container	NN
18637	6506	26	operating	operate	VBG
18637	6506	27	in	in	IN
18637	6506	28	the	the	DT
18637	6506	29	same	same	JJ
18637	6506	30	manner	manner	NN
18637	6506	31	as	as	IN
18637	6506	32	an	an	DT
18637	6506	33	ice	ice	NN
18637	6506	34	cream	cream	NN
18637	6506	35	freezer	freezer	NN
18637	6506	36	.	.	.
18637	6507	1	"	"	``
18637	6507	2	Reckendorfer	Reckendorfer	NNP
18637	6507	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6507	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	6507	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6507	6	Faber	Faber	NNP
18637	6507	7	,	,	,
18637	6507	8	92	92	CD
18637	6507	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6507	10	347	347	CD
18637	6507	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6507	12	1876	1876	CD
18637	6507	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6507	14	:	:	:
18637	6507	15	Inserting	insert	VBG
18637	6507	16	a	a	DT
18637	6507	17	piece	piece	NN
18637	6507	18	of	of	IN
18637	6507	19	rubber	rubber	NN
18637	6507	20	in	in	IN
18637	6507	21	a	a	DT
18637	6507	22	slot	slot	NN
18637	6507	23	in	in	IN
18637	6507	24	the	the	DT
18637	6507	25	end	end	NN
18637	6507	26	of	of	IN
18637	6507	27	a	a	DT
18637	6507	28	wood	wood	NN
18637	6507	29	pencil	pencil	NN
18637	6507	30	to	to	TO
18637	6507	31	serve	serve	VB
18637	6507	32	as	as	IN
18637	6507	33	an	an	DT
18637	6507	34	eraser	eraser	NN
18637	6507	35	.	.	.
18637	6508	1	"	"	``
18637	6508	2	Dalton	Dalton	NNP
18637	6508	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6508	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	6508	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6508	6	Jennings	Jennings	NNP
18637	6508	7	,	,	,
18637	6508	8	93	93	CD
18637	6508	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6508	10	271	271	CD
18637	6508	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6508	12	1876	1876	CD
18637	6508	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6508	14	:	:	:
18637	6508	15	Fine	fine	JJ
18637	6508	16	thread	thread	NN
18637	6508	17	placed	place	VBN
18637	6508	18	across	across	IN
18637	6508	19	open	open	JJ
18637	6508	20	squares	square	NNS
18637	6508	21	in	in	IN
18637	6508	22	a	a	DT
18637	6508	23	regular	regular	JJ
18637	6508	24	hairnet	hairnet	NN
18637	6508	25	to	to	TO
18637	6508	26	keep	keep	VB
18637	6508	27	hair	hair	NN
18637	6508	28	in	in	IN
18637	6508	29	place	place	NN
18637	6508	30	more	more	RBR
18637	6508	31	effectively	effectively	RB
18637	6508	32	.	.	.
18637	6509	1	"	"	``
18637	6509	2	Double	double	JJ
18637	6509	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	6509	4	Pointed	pointed	JJ
18637	6509	5	Tack	Tack	NNP
18637	6509	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6509	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6509	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6509	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6509	10	Two	Two	NNP
18637	6509	11	Rivers	Rivers	NNPS
18637	6509	12	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	6509	13	.	.	.
18637	6510	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6510	2	,	,	,
18637	6510	3	109	109	CD
18637	6510	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6510	5	117	117	CD
18637	6510	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6510	7	1883	1883	CD
18637	6510	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6510	9	:	:	:
18637	6510	10	Putting	put	VBG
18637	6510	11	a	a	DT
18637	6510	12	metal	metal	NN
18637	6510	13	washer	washer	NN
18637	6510	14	on	on	IN
18637	6510	15	a	a	DT
18637	6510	16	wire	wire	NN
18637	6510	17	staple	staple	NN
18637	6510	18	.	.	.
18637	6511	1	"	"	``
18637	6511	2	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	6511	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6511	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	6511	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6511	6	Foree	Foree	NNP
18637	6511	7	,	,	,
18637	6511	8	116	116	CD
18637	6511	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6511	10	22	22	CD
18637	6511	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6511	12	1885	1885	CD
18637	6511	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6511	14	:	:	:
18637	6511	15	A	a	DT
18637	6511	16	stamp	stamp	NN
18637	6511	17	for	for	IN
18637	6511	18	impressing	impress	VBG
18637	6511	19	initials	initial	NNS
18637	6511	20	in	in	IN
18637	6511	21	the	the	DT
18637	6511	22	side	side	NN
18637	6511	23	of	of	IN
18637	6511	24	a	a	DT
18637	6511	25	plug	plug	NN
18637	6511	26	of	of	IN
18637	6511	27	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	6511	28	.	.	.
18637	6512	1	"	"	``
18637	6512	2	Preston	Preston	NNP
18637	6512	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6512	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	6512	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6512	6	Manard	Manard	NNP
18637	6512	7	,	,	,
18637	6512	8	116	116	CD
18637	6512	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6512	10	661	661	CD
18637	6512	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6512	12	1886	1886	CD
18637	6512	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6512	14	:	:	:
18637	6512	15	A	a	DT
18637	6512	16	hose	hose	NN
18637	6512	17	reel	reel	NN
18637	6512	18	of	of	IN
18637	6512	19	large	large	JJ
18637	6512	20	diameter	diameter	NN
18637	6512	21	so	so	IN
18637	6512	22	that	that	DT
18637	6512	23	water	water	NN
18637	6512	24	may	may	MD
18637	6512	25	flow	flow	VB
18637	6512	26	through	through	IN
18637	6512	27	hose	hose	NN
18637	6512	28	while	while	IN
18637	6512	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6512	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	6512	31	wound	wind	VBN
18637	6512	32	on	on	IN
18637	6512	33	the	the	DT
18637	6512	34	reel	reel	NN
18637	6512	35	.	.	.
18637	6513	1	"	"	``
18637	6513	2	Hendy	Hendy	NNP
18637	6513	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6513	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	6513	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6513	6	Miners	Miners	NNPS
18637	6513	7	'	'	POS
18637	6513	8	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	6513	9	Works	Works	NNP
18637	6513	10	,	,	,
18637	6513	11	127	127	CD
18637	6513	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6513	13	370	370	CD
18637	6513	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6513	15	1888	1888	CD
18637	6513	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6513	17	:	:	:
18637	6513	18	Putting	put	VBG
18637	6513	19	rollers	roller	NNS
18637	6513	20	on	on	IN
18637	6513	21	a	a	DT
18637	6513	22	machine	machine	NN
18637	6513	23	to	to	TO
18637	6513	24	make	make	VB
18637	6513	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6513	26	moveable	moveable	JJ
18637	6513	27	.	.	.
18637	6514	1	"	"	``
18637	6514	2	St.	St.	NNP
18637	6514	3	Germain	Germain	NNP
18637	6514	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6514	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	6514	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6514	7	Brunswick	Brunswick	NNP
18637	6514	8	,	,	,
18637	6514	9	135	135	CD
18637	6514	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6514	11	227	227	CD
18637	6514	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6514	13	1890	1890	CD
18637	6514	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6514	15	:	:	:
18637	6514	16	Revolving	revolve	VBG
18637	6514	17	cue	cue	NN
18637	6514	18	rack	rack	NN
18637	6514	19	.	.	.
18637	6515	1	"	"	``
18637	6515	2	Shenfield	Shenfield	NNP
18637	6515	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6515	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	6515	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6515	6	Nashawannuck	Nashawannuck	NNP
18637	6515	7	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	6515	8	.	.	.
18637	6516	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6516	2	,	,	,
18637	6516	3	137	137	CD
18637	6516	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6516	5	56	56	CD
18637	6516	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6516	7	1890	1890	CD
18637	6516	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6516	9	:	:	:
18637	6516	10	Using	use	VBG
18637	6516	11	flat	flat	JJ
18637	6516	12	cord	cord	NN
18637	6516	13	instead	instead	RB
18637	6516	14	of	of	IN
18637	6516	15	round	round	JJ
18637	6516	16	cord	cord	NN
18637	6516	17	for	for	IN
18637	6516	18	the	the	DT
18637	6516	19	loop	loop	NN
18637	6516	20	at	at	IN
18637	6516	21	the	the	DT
18637	6516	22	end	end	NN
18637	6516	23	of	of	IN
18637	6516	24	suspenders	suspender	NNS
18637	6516	25	.	.	.
18637	6517	1	"	"	``
18637	6517	2	Florsheim	Florsheim	NNP
18637	6517	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6517	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	6517	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6517	6	Schilling	Schilling	NNP
18637	6517	7	,	,	,
18637	6517	8	137	137	CD
18637	6517	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6517	10	64	64	CD
18637	6517	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6517	12	1890	1890	CD
18637	6517	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6517	14	:	:	:
18637	6517	15	Putting	put	VBG
18637	6517	16	elastic	elastic	JJ
18637	6517	17	gussets	gusset	NNS
18637	6517	18	in	in	IN
18637	6517	19	corsets	corset	NNS
18637	6517	20	.	.	.
18637	6518	1	"	"	``
18637	6518	2	Cluett	Cluett	NNP
18637	6518	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6518	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	6518	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6518	6	Claflin	Claflin	NNP
18637	6518	7	,	,	,
18637	6518	8	140	140	CD
18637	6518	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6518	10	180	180	CD
18637	6518	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6518	12	1891	1891	CD
18637	6518	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6518	14	:	:	:
18637	6518	15	A	a	DT
18637	6518	16	shirt	shirt	NN
18637	6518	17	bosom	bosom	NN
18637	6518	18	or	or	CC
18637	6518	19	dickie	dickie	NN
18637	6518	20	sewn	sew	VBD
18637	6518	21	onto	onto	IN
18637	6518	22	the	the	DT
18637	6518	23	front	front	NN
18637	6518	24	of	of	IN
18637	6518	25	a	a	DT
18637	6518	26	shirt	shirt	NN
18637	6518	27	.	.	.
18637	6519	1	"	"	``
18637	6519	2	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	6519	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6519	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	6519	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6519	6	Bellaire	Bellaire	NNP
18637	6519	7	Stamping	Stamping	NNP
18637	6519	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6519	9	,	,	,
18637	6519	10	141	141	CD
18637	6519	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6519	12	539	539	CD
18637	6519	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6519	14	1891	1891	CD
18637	6519	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6519	16	:	:	:
18637	6519	17	A	a	DT
18637	6519	18	lantern	lantern	JJ
18637	6519	19	lid	lid	NN
18637	6519	20	fastened	fasten	VBN
18637	6519	21	to	to	IN
18637	6519	22	the	the	DT
18637	6519	23	lantern	lantern	NN
18637	6519	24	by	by	IN
18637	6519	25	a	a	DT
18637	6519	26	hinge	hinge	NN
18637	6519	27	on	on	IN
18637	6519	28	one	one	CD
18637	6519	29	side	side	NN
18637	6519	30	and	and	CC
18637	6519	31	a	a	DT
18637	6519	32	catch	catch	NN
18637	6519	33	on	on	IN
18637	6519	34	the	the	DT
18637	6519	35	other	other	JJ
18637	6519	36	.	.	.
18637	6520	1	"	"	``
18637	6520	2	Patent	Patent	NNP
18637	6520	3	Clothing	Clothing	NNP
18637	6520	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6520	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6520	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6520	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6520	8	Glover	Glover	NNP
18637	6520	9	,	,	,
18637	6520	10	141	141	CD
18637	6520	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6520	12	560	560	CD
18637	6520	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6520	14	1891	1891	CD
18637	6520	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6520	16	:	:	:
18637	6520	17	Bridging	bridge	VBG
18637	6520	18	a	a	DT
18637	6520	19	strip	strip	NN
18637	6520	20	of	of	IN
18637	6520	21	cloth	cloth	NN
18637	6520	22	across	across	IN
18637	6520	23	the	the	DT
18637	6520	24	fly	fly	NN
18637	6520	25	of	of	IN
18637	6520	26	pantaloons	pantaloon	NNS
18637	6520	27	to	to	TO
18637	6520	28	reinforce	reinforce	VB
18637	6520	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6520	30	against	against	IN
18637	6520	31	tearing	tear	VBG
18637	6520	32	.	.	.
18637	6521	1	"	"	``
18637	6521	2	Pope	Pope	NNP
18637	6521	3	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	6521	4	.	.	.
18637	6522	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6522	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6522	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6522	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6522	5	Gormully	Gormully	NNP
18637	6522	6	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	6522	7	.	.	.
18637	6523	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6523	2	,	,	,
18637	6523	3	144	144	CD
18637	6523	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6523	5	238	238	CD
18637	6523	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6523	7	1892	1892	CD
18637	6523	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6523	9	:	:	:
18637	6523	10	Placing	place	VBG
18637	6523	11	rubber	rubber	NN
18637	6523	12	hand	hand	NN
18637	6523	13	grips	grip	NNS
18637	6523	14	on	on	IN
18637	6523	15	bicycle	bicycle	NN
18637	6523	16	handlebars	handlebar	NNS
18637	6523	17	.	.	.
18637	6524	1	"	"	``
18637	6524	2	Knapp	Knapp	NNP
18637	6524	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6524	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	6524	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6524	6	Morss	Morss	NNP
18637	6524	7	,	,	,
18637	6524	8	150	150	CD
18637	6524	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6524	10	221	221	CD
18637	6524	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6524	12	1893	1893	CD
18637	6524	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6524	14	:	:	:
18637	6524	15	Applying	apply	VBG
18637	6524	16	the	the	DT
18637	6524	17	principle	principle	NN
18637	6524	18	of	of	IN
18637	6524	19	the	the	DT
18637	6524	20	umbrella	umbrella	NN
18637	6524	21	to	to	IN
18637	6524	22	a	a	DT
18637	6524	23	skirt	skirt	NN
18637	6524	24	form	form	NN
18637	6524	25	.	.	.
18637	6525	1	"	"	``
18637	6525	2	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	6525	3	Envelope	Envelope	NNP
18637	6525	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6525	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6525	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6525	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6525	8	Albany	Albany	NNP
18637	6525	9	Perforated	Perforated	NNP
18637	6525	10	Wrapping	Wrapping	NNP
18637	6525	11	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	6525	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6525	13	,	,	,
18637	6525	14	152	152	CD
18637	6525	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6525	16	425	425	CD
18637	6525	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6525	18	1894	1894	CD
18637	6525	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6525	20	:	:	:
18637	6525	21	An	an	DT
18637	6525	22	oval	oval	NN
18637	6525	23	rather	rather	RB
18637	6525	24	than	than	IN
18637	6525	25	cylindrical	cylindrical	JJ
18637	6525	26	toilet	toilet	NN
18637	6525	27	paper	paper	NN
18637	6525	28	roll	roll	NN
18637	6525	29	,	,	,
18637	6525	30	to	to	TO
18637	6525	31	facilitate	facilitate	VB
18637	6525	32	tearing	tear	VBG
18637	6525	33	off	off	RP
18637	6525	34	strips	strip	NNS
18637	6525	35	.	.	.
18637	6526	1	"	"	``
18637	6526	2	Dunham	Dunham	NNP
18637	6526	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6526	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	6526	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6526	6	Dennison	Dennison	NNP
18637	6526	7	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	6526	8	.	.	.
18637	6527	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6527	2	,	,	,
18637	6527	3	154	154	CD
18637	6527	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6527	5	103	103	CD
18637	6527	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6527	7	1894	1894	CD
18637	6527	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6527	9	:	:	:
18637	6527	10	An	an	DT
18637	6527	11	envelope	envelope	NN
18637	6527	12	flap	flap	NN
18637	6527	13	which	which	WDT
18637	6527	14	could	could	MD
18637	6527	15	be	be	VB
18637	6527	16	fastened	fasten	VBN
18637	6527	17	to	to	IN
18637	6527	18	the	the	DT
18637	6527	19	envelope	envelope	NN
18637	6527	20	in	in	IN
18637	6527	21	such	such	PDT
18637	6527	22	a	a	DT
18637	6527	23	fashion	fashion	NN
18637	6527	24	that	that	WDT
18637	6527	25	the	the	DT
18637	6527	26	envelope	envelope	NN
18637	6527	27	could	could	MD
18637	6527	28	be	be	VB
18637	6527	29	opened	open	VBN
18637	6527	30	without	without	IN
18637	6527	31	tearing	tear	VBG
18637	6527	32	.	.	.
18637	6528	1	"	"	``
18637	6528	2	The	the	DT
18637	6528	3	patent	patent	NN
18637	6528	4	involved	involve	VBN
18637	6528	5	in	in	IN
18637	6528	6	the	the	DT
18637	6528	7	present	present	JJ
18637	6528	8	case	case	NN
18637	6528	9	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	6528	10	to	to	IN
18637	6528	11	this	this	DT
18637	6528	12	list	list	NN
18637	6528	13	of	of	IN
18637	6528	14	incredible	incredible	JJ
18637	6528	15	patents	patent	NNS
18637	6528	16	which	which	WDT
18637	6528	17	the	the	DT
18637	6528	18	Patent	Patent	NNP
18637	6528	19	Office	Office	NNP
18637	6528	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	6528	21	spawned	spawn	VBN
18637	6528	22	.	.	.
18637	6529	1	The	the	DT
18637	6529	2	fact	fact	NN
18637	6529	3	that	that	IN
18637	6529	4	a	a	DT
18637	6529	5	patent	patent	NN
18637	6529	6	as	as	IN
18637	6529	7	flimsy	flimsy	JJ
18637	6529	8	and	and	CC
18637	6529	9	as	as	RB
18637	6529	10	spurious	spurious	JJ
18637	6529	11	as	as	IN
18637	6529	12	this	this	DT
18637	6529	13	one	one	NN
18637	6529	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	6529	15	to	to	TO
18637	6529	16	be	be	VB
18637	6529	17	brought	bring	VBN
18637	6529	18	all	all	PDT
18637	6529	19	the	the	DT
18637	6529	20	way	way	NN
18637	6529	21	to	to	IN
18637	6529	22	this	this	DT
18637	6529	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	6529	24	to	to	TO
18637	6529	25	be	be	VB
18637	6529	26	declared	declare	VBN
18637	6529	27	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	6529	28	dramatically	dramatically	RB
18637	6529	29	illustrates	illustrate	VBZ
18637	6529	30	how	how	WRB
18637	6529	31	far	far	RB
18637	6529	32	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	6529	33	patent	patent	NN
18637	6529	34	system	system	NN
18637	6529	35	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	6529	36	departs	depart	VBZ
18637	6529	37	from	from	IN
18637	6529	38	the	the	DT
18637	6529	39	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	6529	40	standards	standard	NNS
18637	6529	41	which	which	WDT
18637	6529	42	are	be	VBP
18637	6529	43	supposed	suppose	VBN
18637	6529	44	to	to	TO
18637	6529	45	govern	govern	VB
18637	6529	46	.	.	.
18637	6529	47	"	"	''
18637	6530	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	6530	2	.	.	.
18637	6531	1	156	156	CD
18637	6531	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6531	3	158	158	CD
18637	6531	4	.	.	.
18637	6532	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6532	2	1169	1169	CD
18637	6532	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6532	4	"	"	``
18637	6532	5	Inventive	inventive	JJ
18637	6532	6	genius"--Justice	genius"--Justice	NNP
18637	6532	7	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
18637	6532	8	in	in	IN
18637	6532	9	Reckendorfer	Reckendorfer	NNP
18637	6532	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6532	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	6532	12	_	_	NNP
18637	6532	13	Faber	Faber	NNP
18637	6532	14	,	,	,
18637	6532	15	92	92	CD
18637	6532	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6532	17	347	347	CD
18637	6532	18	,	,	,
18637	6532	19	357	357	CD
18637	6532	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6532	21	1875	1875	CD
18637	6532	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6532	23	;	;	:
18637	6532	24	"	"	``
18637	6532	25	Genius	genius	NN
18637	6532	26	or	or	CC
18637	6532	27	invention"--Chief	invention"--Chief	NNP
18637	6532	28	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6532	29	Fuller	Fuller	NNP
18637	6532	30	in	in	IN
18637	6532	31	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	6532	32	_	_	NNP
18637	6532	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	6532	34	_	_	NNP
18637	6532	35	Whitman	Whitman	NNP
18637	6532	36	Saddle	Saddle	NNP
18637	6532	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6532	38	,	,	,
18637	6532	39	148	148	CD
18637	6532	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6532	41	674	674	CD
18637	6532	42	,	,	,
18637	6532	43	681	681	CD
18637	6532	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6532	45	1893	1893	CD
18637	6532	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6532	47	;	;	:
18637	6532	48	"	"	``
18637	6532	49	Intuitive	intuitive	JJ
18637	6532	50	genius"--Justice	genius"--Justice	NNP
18637	6532	51	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	6532	52	in	in	IN
18637	6532	53	Potts	Potts	NNP
18637	6532	54	_	_	NNP
18637	6532	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	6532	56	_	_	NNP
18637	6532	57	Creager	Creager	NNP
18637	6532	58	,	,	,
18637	6532	59	155	155	CD
18637	6532	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6532	61	597	597	CD
18637	6532	62	,	,	,
18637	6532	63	607	607	CD
18637	6532	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6532	65	1895	1895	CD
18637	6532	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6532	67	;	;	:
18637	6532	68	"	"	``
18637	6532	69	Inventive	inventive	JJ
18637	6532	70	genius"--Justice	genius"--Justice	NNP
18637	6532	71	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	6532	72	in	in	IN
18637	6532	73	Concrete	Concrete	NNP
18637	6532	74	Appliances	Appliances	NNP
18637	6532	75	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6532	76	_	_	NNP
18637	6532	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	6532	78	_	_	NNP
18637	6532	79	Gomery	Gomery	NNP
18637	6532	80	,	,	,
18637	6532	81	269	269	CD
18637	6532	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6532	83	177	177	CD
18637	6532	84	,	,	,
18637	6532	85	185	185	CD
18637	6532	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6532	87	1925	1925	CD
18637	6532	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6532	89	;	;	:
18637	6532	90	"	"	``
18637	6532	91	Inventive	inventive	JJ
18637	6532	92	genius"--Justice	genius"--Justice	NNP
18637	6532	93	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	6532	94	in	in	IN
18637	6532	95	Mantle	Mantle	NNP
18637	6532	96	Lamp	Lamp	NNP
18637	6532	97	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6532	98	_	_	NNP
18637	6532	99	v.	v.	IN
18637	6532	100	_	_	NNP
18637	6532	101	Aluminum	Aluminum	NNP
18637	6532	102	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6532	103	,	,	,
18637	6532	104	301	301	CD
18637	6532	105	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6532	106	544	544	CD
18637	6532	107	,	,	,
18637	6532	108	546	546	CD
18637	6532	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6532	110	1937	1937	CD
18637	6532	111	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6532	112	;	;	:
18637	6532	113	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6532	114	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	6532	115	in	in	IN
18637	6532	116	Cuno	Cuno	NNP
18637	6532	117	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6532	118	_	_	NNP
18637	6532	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	6532	120	_	_	NNP
18637	6532	121	Automatic	Automatic	NNP
18637	6532	122	Devices	Devices	NNPS
18637	6532	123	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6532	124	,	,	,
18637	6532	125	314	314	CD
18637	6532	126	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6532	127	84	84	CD
18637	6532	128	,	,	,
18637	6532	129	91	91	CD
18637	6532	130	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6532	131	1941	1941	CD
18637	6532	132	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6532	133	;	;	:
18637	6532	134	"	"	``
18637	6532	135	the	the	DT
18637	6532	136	flash	flash	NN
18637	6532	137	of	of	IN
18637	6532	138	creative	creative	JJ
18637	6532	139	genius	genius	NN
18637	6532	140	,	,	,
18637	6532	141	not	not	RB
18637	6532	142	merely	merely	RB
18637	6532	143	the	the	DT
18637	6532	144	skill	skill	NN
18637	6532	145	of	of	IN
18637	6532	146	the	the	DT
18637	6532	147	calling	calling	NN
18637	6532	148	.	.	.
18637	6532	149	"	"	''
18637	6533	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6533	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6533	3	also	also	RB
18637	6533	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6533	5	Note	Note	NNP
18637	6533	6	2	2	CD
18637	6533	7	above	above	RB
18637	6533	8	.	.	.
18637	6534	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6534	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	6534	3	's	's	POS
18637	6534	4	Note	note	NN
18637	6534	5	:	:	:
18637	6534	6	Reference	reference	NN
18637	6534	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	6534	8	to	to	IN
18637	6534	9	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	6534	10	1163	1163	CD
18637	6534	11	,	,	,
18637	6534	12	above	above	RB
18637	6534	13	.	.	.
18637	6534	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6535	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6535	2	1170	1170	CD
18637	6535	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6535	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6535	5	See	See	NNP
18637	6535	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6535	7	Note	Note	NNP
18637	6535	8	7	7	CD
18637	6535	9	above	above	RB
18637	6535	10	.	.	.
18637	6536	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6536	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	6536	3	's	's	POS
18637	6536	4	Note	note	NN
18637	6536	5	:	:	:
18637	6536	6	Reference	reference	NN
18637	6536	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	6536	8	to	to	IN
18637	6536	9	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	6536	10	1168	1168	CD
18637	6536	11	,	,	,
18637	6536	12	above	above	RB
18637	6536	13	.	.	.
18637	6536	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6537	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6537	2	1171	1171	CD
18637	6537	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6537	4	Great	Great	NNP
18637	6537	5	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	6537	6	&	&	CC
18637	6537	7	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	6537	8	Tea	Tea	NNP
18637	6537	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6537	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6537	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	6537	12	_	_	NNP
18637	6537	13	Supermarket	Supermarket	NNP
18637	6537	14	Equipment	Equipment	NNP
18637	6537	15	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6537	16	,	,	,
18637	6537	17	340	340	CD
18637	6537	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6537	19	147	147	CD
18637	6537	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6537	21	1950	1950	CD
18637	6537	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6537	23	;	;	:
18637	6537	24	Mahn	Mahn	NNP
18637	6537	25	_	_	NNP
18637	6537	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	6537	27	_	_	NNP
18637	6537	28	Harwood	Harwood	NNP
18637	6537	29	,	,	,
18637	6537	30	112	112	CD
18637	6537	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6537	32	354	354	CD
18637	6537	33	,	,	,
18637	6537	34	358	358	CD
18637	6537	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6537	36	1884	1884	CD
18637	6537	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6537	38	.	.	.
18637	6538	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6538	2	1172	1172	CD
18637	6538	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6538	4	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	6538	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6538	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6538	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6538	8	Eaton	Eaton	NNP
18637	6538	9	,	,	,
18637	6538	10	3	3	CD
18637	6538	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6538	12	.	.	.
18637	6539	1	454	454	CD
18637	6539	2	,	,	,
18637	6539	3	512	512	CD
18637	6539	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6539	5	1818	1818	CD
18637	6539	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6539	7	.	.	.
18637	6540	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6540	2	1173	1173	CD
18637	6540	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6540	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6540	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6540	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6540	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6540	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6540	9	Duell	Duell	NNP
18637	6540	10	,	,	,
18637	6540	11	172	172	CD
18637	6540	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6540	13	576	576	CD
18637	6540	14	,	,	,
18637	6540	15	586	586	CD
18637	6540	16	-	-	SYM
18637	6540	17	589	589	CD
18637	6540	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6540	19	1899	1899	CD
18637	6540	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6540	21	.	.	.
18637	6541	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6541	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6541	3	also	also	RB
18637	6541	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6541	5	Butterworth	Butterworth	NNP
18637	6541	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6541	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6541	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6541	9	Hoe	Hoe	NNP
18637	6541	10	,	,	,
18637	6541	11	112	112	CD
18637	6541	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6541	13	50	50	CD
18637	6541	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6541	15	1884	1884	CD
18637	6541	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6541	17	.	.	.
18637	6542	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6542	2	1174	1174	CD
18637	6542	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6542	4	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
18637	6542	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6542	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6542	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6542	8	Peters	Peters	NNP
18637	6542	9	,	,	,
18637	6542	10	8	8	CD
18637	6542	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	6542	12	.	.	.
18637	6543	1	591	591	CD
18637	6543	2	,	,	,
18637	6543	3	660	660	CD
18637	6543	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6543	5	1834	1834	CD
18637	6543	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6543	7	;	;	:
18637	6543	8	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	6543	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6543	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6543	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6543	12	Hurst	Hurst	NNP
18637	6543	13	,	,	,
18637	6543	14	174	174	CD
18637	6543	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6543	16	82	82	CD
18637	6543	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6543	18	1899	1899	CD
18637	6543	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6543	20	.	.	.
18637	6544	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6544	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	6544	3	.	.	.
18637	6544	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6544	5	E.	E.	NNP
18637	6544	6	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	6544	7	Inlow	Inlow	NNP
18637	6544	8	,	,	,
18637	6544	9	The	the	DT
18637	6544	10	Patent	Patent	NNP
18637	6544	11	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	6544	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6544	13	1950	1950	CD
18637	6544	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6544	15	Chaps	Chaps	NNP
18637	6544	16	.	.	.
18637	6545	1	III	III	NNP
18637	6545	2	and	and	CC
18637	6545	3	IV	IV	NNP
18637	6545	4	,	,	,
18637	6545	5	for	for	IN
18637	6545	6	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	6545	7	of	of	IN
18637	6545	8	a	a	DT
18637	6545	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	6545	10	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	6545	11	of	of	IN
18637	6545	12	an	an	DT
18637	6545	13	inventor	inventor	NN
18637	6545	14	's	's	POS
18637	6545	15	inchoate	inchoate	JJ
18637	6545	16	right	right	NN
18637	6545	17	to	to	TO
18637	6545	18	have	have	VB
18637	6545	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	6545	20	invention	invention	NN
18637	6545	21	patented	patent	VBN
18637	6545	22	.	.	.
18637	6546	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6546	2	1175	1175	CD
18637	6546	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6546	4	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
18637	6546	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6546	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6546	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6546	8	Peters	Peters	NNP
18637	6546	9	,	,	,
18637	6546	10	8	8	CD
18637	6546	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	6546	12	.	.	.
18637	6547	1	591	591	CD
18637	6547	2	,	,	,
18637	6547	3	662	662	CD
18637	6547	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6547	5	1834	1834	CD
18637	6547	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6547	7	;	;	:
18637	6547	8	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	6547	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6547	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6547	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6547	12	Jordan	Jordan	NNP
18637	6547	13	,	,	,
18637	6547	14	9	9	CD
18637	6547	15	Cr	cr	NN
18637	6547	16	.	.	.
18637	6548	1	199	199	CD
18637	6548	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6548	3	1815	1815	CD
18637	6548	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6548	5	.	.	.
18637	6549	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6549	2	1176	1176	CD
18637	6549	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6549	4	Kalem	Kalem	NNP
18637	6549	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6549	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6549	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6549	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6549	9	Harper	Harper	NNP
18637	6549	10	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	6549	11	222	222	CD
18637	6549	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6549	13	55	55	CD
18637	6549	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6549	15	1911	1911	CD
18637	6549	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6549	17	.	.	.
18637	6550	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6550	2	1177	1177	CD
18637	6550	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6550	4	Baker	Baker	NNP
18637	6550	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6550	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6550	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6550	8	Selden	Selden	NNP
18637	6550	9	,	,	,
18637	6550	10	101	101	CD
18637	6550	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6550	12	99	99	CD
18637	6550	13	,	,	,
18637	6550	14	105	105	CD
18637	6550	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6550	16	1880	1880	CD
18637	6550	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6550	18	.	.	.
18637	6551	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6551	2	1178	1178	CD
18637	6551	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6551	4	Stevens	Stevens	NNP
18637	6551	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6551	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6551	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6551	8	Gladding	Gladding	NNP
18637	6551	9	,	,	,
18637	6551	10	17	17	CD
18637	6551	11	How	how	WRB
18637	6551	12	.	.	.
18637	6552	1	447	447	CD
18637	6552	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6552	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	6552	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6552	5	.	.	.
18637	6553	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6553	2	1179	1179	CD
18637	6553	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6553	4	Ager	Ager	NNP
18637	6553	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6553	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6553	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6553	8	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	6553	9	,	,	,
18637	6553	10	105	105	CD
18637	6553	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6553	12	126	126	CD
18637	6553	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6553	14	1882	1882	CD
18637	6553	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6553	16	.	.	.
18637	6554	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6554	2	1180	1180	CD
18637	6554	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6554	4	James	James	NNP
18637	6554	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6554	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6554	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6554	8	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
18637	6554	9	,	,	,
18637	6554	10	104	104	CD
18637	6554	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6554	12	356	356	CD
18637	6554	13	,	,	,
18637	6554	14	358	358	CD
18637	6554	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6554	16	1882	1882	CD
18637	6554	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6554	18	.	.	.
18637	6555	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6555	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6555	3	also	also	RB
18637	6555	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6555	5	United	United	NNP
18637	6555	6	States	States	NNP
18637	6555	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6555	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6555	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6555	10	Burns	Burns	NNP
18637	6555	11	,	,	,
18637	6555	12	12	12	CD
18637	6555	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6555	14	.	.	.
18637	6556	1	246	246	CD
18637	6556	2	,	,	,
18637	6556	3	252	252	CD
18637	6556	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6556	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	6556	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6556	7	;	;	:
18637	6556	8	Cammeyer	Cammeyer	NNP
18637	6556	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6556	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6556	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6556	12	Newton	Newton	NNP
18637	6556	13	,	,	,
18637	6556	14	94	94	CD
18637	6556	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6556	16	225	225	CD
18637	6556	17	,	,	,
18637	6556	18	234	234	CD
18637	6556	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6556	20	1877	1877	CD
18637	6556	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6556	22	;	;	:
18637	6556	23	Hollister	Hollister	NNP
18637	6556	24	_	_	NNP
18637	6556	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	6556	26	_	_	NNP
18637	6556	27	Benedict	Benedict	NNP
18637	6556	28	Manufacturing	Manufacturing	NNP
18637	6556	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6556	30	,	,	,
18637	6556	31	113	113	CD
18637	6556	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6556	33	59	59	CD
18637	6556	34	,	,	,
18637	6556	35	67	67	CD
18637	6556	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6556	37	1885	1885	CD
18637	6556	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6556	39	;	;	:
18637	6556	40	United	United	NNP
18637	6556	41	States	States	NNP
18637	6556	42	_	_	NNP
18637	6556	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	6556	44	_	_	NNP
18637	6556	45	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	6556	46	,	,	,
18637	6556	47	128	128	CD
18637	6556	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6556	49	262	262	CD
18637	6556	50	,	,	,
18637	6556	51	271	271	CD
18637	6556	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6556	53	1888	1888	CD
18637	6556	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6556	55	;	;	:
18637	6556	56	Belknap	Belknap	NNP
18637	6556	57	_	_	NNP
18637	6556	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	6556	59	_	_	NNP
18637	6556	60	Schild	Schild	NNP
18637	6556	61	,	,	,
18637	6556	62	161	161	CD
18637	6556	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6556	64	10	10	CD
18637	6556	65	,	,	,
18637	6556	66	16	16	CD
18637	6556	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6556	68	1896	1896	CD
18637	6556	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6556	70	.	.	.
18637	6557	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6557	2	1181	1181	CD
18637	6557	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6557	4	McClurg	McClurg	NNP
18637	6557	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6557	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6557	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6557	8	Kingsland	Kingsland	NNP
18637	6557	9	,	,	,
18637	6557	10	1	1	CD
18637	6557	11	How	how	WRB
18637	6557	12	.	.	.
18637	6558	1	202	202	CD
18637	6558	2	,	,	,
18637	6558	3	206	206	CD
18637	6558	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6558	5	1843	1843	CD
18637	6558	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6558	7	.	.	.
18637	6559	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6559	2	1182	1182	CD
18637	6559	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6559	4	Bloomer	Bloomer	NNP
18637	6559	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6559	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6559	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6559	8	McQuewan	McQuewan	NNP
18637	6559	9	,	,	,
18637	6559	10	14	14	CD
18637	6559	11	How	how	WRB
18637	6559	12	.	.	.
18637	6560	1	539	539	CD
18637	6560	2	,	,	,
18637	6560	3	553	553	CD
18637	6560	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6560	5	1852	1852	CD
18637	6560	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6560	7	.	.	.
18637	6561	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6561	2	1183	1183	CD
18637	6561	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6561	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6561	5	See	See	NNP
18637	6561	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6561	7	Motion	Motion	NNP
18637	6561	8	Picture	Picture	NNP
18637	6561	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6561	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6561	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	6561	12	_	_	NNP
18637	6561	13	Universal	Universal	NNP
18637	6561	14	Film	Film	NNP
18637	6561	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6561	16	,	,	,
18637	6561	17	243	243	CD
18637	6561	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6561	19	502	502	CD
18637	6561	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6561	21	1917	1917	CD
18637	6561	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6561	23	;	;	:
18637	6561	24	Morton	Morton	NNP
18637	6561	25	Salt	Salt	NNP
18637	6561	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6561	27	_	_	NNP
18637	6561	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	6561	29	_	_	NNP
18637	6561	30	Suppiger	Suppiger	NNP
18637	6561	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6561	32	,	,	,
18637	6561	33	314	314	CD
18637	6561	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6561	35	488	488	CD
18637	6561	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6561	37	1942	1942	CD
18637	6561	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6561	39	;	;	:
18637	6561	40	United	United	NNP
18637	6561	41	States	States	NNP
18637	6561	42	_	_	NNP
18637	6561	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	6561	44	_	_	NNP
18637	6561	45	Masonite	Masonite	NNP
18637	6561	46	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6561	47	,	,	,
18637	6561	48	316	316	CD
18637	6561	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6561	50	265	265	CD
18637	6561	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6561	52	1942	1942	CD
18637	6561	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6561	54	;	;	:
18637	6561	55	and	and	CC
18637	6561	56	United	United	NNP
18637	6561	57	States	States	NNP
18637	6561	58	_	_	NNP
18637	6561	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	6561	60	_	_	NNP
18637	6561	61	New	New	NNP
18637	6561	62	Wrinkle	Wrinkle	NNP
18637	6561	63	,	,	,
18637	6561	64	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	6561	65	,	,	,
18637	6561	66	342	342	CD
18637	6561	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6561	68	371	371	CD
18637	6561	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6561	70	1952	1952	CD
18637	6561	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6561	72	,	,	,
18637	6561	73	where	where	WRB
18637	6561	74	the	the	DT
18637	6561	75	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	6561	76	divide	divide	VBP
18637	6561	77	6	6	CD
18637	6561	78	to	to	IN
18637	6561	79	3	3	CD
18637	6561	80	as	as	IN
18637	6561	81	to	to	IN
18637	6561	82	the	the	DT
18637	6561	83	significance	significance	NN
18637	6561	84	for	for	IN
18637	6561	85	the	the	DT
18637	6561	86	case	case	NN
18637	6561	87	of	of	IN
18637	6561	88	certain	certain	JJ
18637	6561	89	leading	leading	JJ
18637	6561	90	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	6561	91	.	.	.
18637	6562	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6562	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6562	3	also	also	RB
18637	6562	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6562	5	Inlow	Inlow	NNP
18637	6562	6	,	,	,
18637	6562	7	The	the	DT
18637	6562	8	Patent	Patent	NNP
18637	6562	9	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	6562	10	,	,	,
18637	6562	11	Chap	Chap	NNP
18637	6562	12	.	.	.
18637	6563	1	V.	V.	NNP
18637	6563	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6563	3	1184	1184	CD
18637	6563	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6563	5	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	6563	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6563	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6563	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6563	9	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	6563	10	,	,	,
18637	6563	11	97	97	CD
18637	6563	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6563	13	501	501	CD
18637	6563	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6563	15	1879	1879	CD
18637	6563	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6563	17	.	.	.
18637	6564	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6564	2	1185	1185	CD
18637	6564	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6564	4	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	6564	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6564	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6564	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6564	8	Riley	Riley	NNP
18637	6564	9	,	,	,
18637	6564	10	203	203	CD
18637	6564	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6564	12	347	347	CD
18637	6564	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6564	14	1906	1906	CD
18637	6564	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6564	16	:	:	:
18637	6564	17	Woods	Woods	NNP
18637	6564	18	&	&	CC
18637	6564	19	Sons	Sons	NNPS
18637	6564	20	_	_	NNP
18637	6564	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	6564	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6564	23	Carl	Carl	NNP
18637	6564	24	,	,	,
18637	6564	25	203	203	CD
18637	6564	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6564	27	358	358	CD
18637	6564	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6564	29	1906	1906	CD
18637	6564	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6564	31	;	;	:
18637	6564	32	Ozan	Ozan	NNP
18637	6564	33	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	6564	34	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6564	35	_	_	NNP
18637	6564	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	6564	37	_	_	NNP
18637	6564	38	Union	Union	NNP
18637	6564	39	County	County	NNP
18637	6564	40	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6564	41	,	,	,
18637	6564	42	207	207	CD
18637	6564	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6564	44	251	251	CD
18637	6564	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6564	46	1907	1907	CD
18637	6564	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6564	48	.	.	.
18637	6565	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6565	2	1186	1186	CD
18637	6565	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6565	4	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	6565	5	Film	Film	NNP
18637	6565	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6565	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6565	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6565	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6565	10	Doyal	Doyal	NNP
18637	6565	11	,	,	,
18637	6565	12	280	280	CD
18637	6565	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6565	14	123	123	CD
18637	6565	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6565	16	1932)--overruling	1932)--overruling	CD
18637	6565	17	Long	Long	NNP
18637	6565	18	_	_	NNP
18637	6565	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	6565	20	_	_	NNP
18637	6565	21	Rockwood	Rockwood	NNP
18637	6565	22	,	,	,
18637	6565	23	277	277	CD
18637	6565	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6565	25	142	142	CD
18637	6565	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6565	27	1928	1928	CD
18637	6565	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6565	29	.	.	.
18637	6566	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6566	2	1187	1187	CD
18637	6566	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6566	4	100	100	CD
18637	6566	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6566	6	82	82	CD
18637	6566	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6566	8	1879	1879	CD
18637	6566	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6566	10	.	.	.
18637	6567	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6567	2	1188	1188	CD
18637	6567	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6567	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6567	5	.	.	.
18637	6568	1	94	94	CD
18637	6568	2	.	.	.
18637	6569	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6569	2	1189	1189	CD
18637	6569	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6569	4	Burrow	Burrow	NNP
18637	6569	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	6569	6	Giles	Giles	NNP
18637	6569	7	Lithographic	Lithographic	NNP
18637	6569	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6569	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6569	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6569	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6569	12	Sarony	Sarony	NNP
18637	6569	13	,	,	,
18637	6569	14	111	111	CD
18637	6569	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6569	16	53	53	CD
18637	6569	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6569	18	1884	1884	CD
18637	6569	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6569	20	.	.	.
18637	6570	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6570	2	1190	1190	CD
18637	6570	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6570	4	Bleistein	Bleistein	NNP
18637	6570	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6570	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6570	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6570	8	Donaldson	Donaldson	NNP
18637	6570	9	Lithographing	Lithographing	NNP
18637	6570	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6570	11	,	,	,
18637	6570	12	188	188	CD
18637	6570	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6570	14	239	239	CD
18637	6570	15	,	,	,
18637	6570	16	252	252	CD
18637	6570	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6570	18	1903	1903	CD
18637	6570	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6570	20	.	.	.
18637	6571	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6571	2	1191	1191	CD
18637	6571	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6571	4	Kent	Kent	NNP
18637	6571	5	,	,	,
18637	6571	6	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	6571	7	,	,	,
18637	6571	8	1	1	CD
18637	6571	9	-	-	SYM
18637	6571	10	2	2	CD
18637	6571	11	,	,	,
18637	6571	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6571	13	12th	12th	NNP
18637	6571	14	ed	ed	NN
18637	6571	15	.	.	.
18637	6572	1	1873	1873	CD
18637	6572	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6572	3	.	.	.
18637	6573	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6573	2	1192	1192	CD
18637	6573	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6573	4	XIX	XIX	NNP
18637	6573	5	Journals	Journals	NNPS
18637	6573	6	of	of	IN
18637	6573	7	the	the	DT
18637	6573	8	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	6573	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	6573	10	315	315	CD
18637	6573	11	,	,	,
18637	6573	12	361	361	CD
18637	6573	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6573	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	6573	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6573	16	.	.	.
18637	6574	1	XX	XX	NNP
18637	6574	2	Id.	Idaho	NNP
18637	6575	1	762	762	CD
18637	6575	2	,	,	,
18637	6575	3	XXI	XXI	NNP
18637	6575	4	i	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6575	5	d	d	NN
18637	6575	6	.	.	.
18637	6576	1	1136	1136	CD
18637	6576	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6576	3	1137	1137	CD
18637	6576	4	,	,	,
18637	6576	5	1158	1158	CD
18637	6576	6	.	.	.
18637	6577	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6577	2	1193	1193	CD
18637	6577	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6577	4	Article	Article	NNP
18637	6577	5	IX	IX	NNP
18637	6577	6	.	.	.
18637	6578	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6578	2	1194	1194	CD
18637	6578	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6578	4	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	6578	5	,	,	,
18637	6578	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	6578	7	of	of	IN
18637	6578	8	the	the	DT
18637	6578	9	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	6578	10	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	6578	11	,	,	,
18637	6578	12	II	II	NNP
18637	6578	13	,	,	,
18637	6578	14	82	82	CD
18637	6578	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6578	16	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
18637	6578	17	's	's	POS
18637	6578	18	ed	ed	NN
18637	6578	19	.	.	.
18637	6579	1	1908	1908	CD
18637	6579	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6579	3	.	.	.
18637	6580	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6580	2	1195	1195	CD
18637	6580	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6580	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6580	5	.	.	.
18637	6581	1	185	185	CD
18637	6581	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6581	3	186	186	CD
18637	6581	4	,	,	,
18637	6581	5	372	372	CD
18637	6581	6	.	.	.
18637	6582	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6582	2	1196	1196	CD
18637	6582	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6582	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6582	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6582	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6582	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6582	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6582	9	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	6582	10	,	,	,
18637	6582	11	5	5	CD
18637	6582	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6582	13	.	.	.
18637	6583	1	153	153	CD
18637	6583	2	,	,	,
18637	6583	3	160	160	CD
18637	6583	4	,	,	,
18637	6583	5	162	162	CD
18637	6583	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6583	7	1820	1820	CD
18637	6583	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6583	9	.	.	.
18637	6584	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6584	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6584	3	also	also	RB
18637	6584	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6584	5	The	the	DT
18637	6584	6	Marianna	Marianna	NNP
18637	6584	7	Flora	Flora	NNP
18637	6584	8	,	,	,
18637	6584	9	11	11	CD
18637	6584	10	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6584	11	.	.	.
18637	6585	1	1	1	CD
18637	6585	2	,	,	,
18637	6585	3	40	40	CD
18637	6585	4	-	-	SYM
18637	6585	5	41	41	CD
18637	6585	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6585	7	1826	1826	CD
18637	6585	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6585	9	;	;	:
18637	6585	10	United	United	NNP
18637	6585	11	States	States	NNP
18637	6585	12	_	_	NNP
18637	6585	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	6585	14	_	_	NNP
18637	6585	15	Brig	Brig	NNP
18637	6585	16	Malek	Malek	NNP
18637	6585	17	Abhel	Abhel	NNP
18637	6585	18	,	,	,
18637	6585	19	2	2	CD
18637	6585	20	How	how	WRB
18637	6585	21	.	.	.
18637	6586	1	210	210	CD
18637	6586	2	,	,	,
18637	6586	3	232	232	CD
18637	6586	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6586	5	1844	1844	CD
18637	6586	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6586	7	.	.	.
18637	6587	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6587	2	1197	1197	CD
18637	6587	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6587	4	317	317	CD
18637	6587	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6587	6	1	1	CD
18637	6587	7	,	,	,
18637	6587	8	27	27	CD
18637	6587	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6587	10	1942	1942	CD
18637	6587	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6587	12	.	.	.
18637	6588	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6588	2	1198	1198	CD
18637	6588	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6588	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6588	5	.	.	.
18637	6589	1	28	28	CD
18637	6589	2	.	.	.
18637	6590	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6590	2	1199	1199	CD
18637	6590	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6590	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6590	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6590	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6590	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6590	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6590	9	Arjona	Arjona	NNP
18637	6590	10	,	,	,
18637	6590	11	120	120	CD
18637	6590	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6590	13	479	479	CD
18637	6590	14	,	,	,
18637	6590	15	487	487	CD
18637	6590	16	,	,	,
18637	6590	17	488	488	CD
18637	6590	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6590	19	1887	1887	CD
18637	6590	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6590	21	.	.	.
18637	6591	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6591	2	1200	1200	CD
18637	6591	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6591	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6591	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6591	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6591	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6591	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6591	9	Flores	Flores	NNP
18637	6591	10	,	,	,
18637	6591	11	3	3	CD
18637	6591	12	F.	F.	NNP
18637	6591	13	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	6591	14	.	.	.
18637	6592	1	134	134	CD
18637	6592	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6592	3	1932	1932	CD
18637	6592	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6592	5	.	.	.
18637	6593	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6593	2	1201	1201	CD
18637	6593	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6593	4	289	289	CD
18637	6593	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6593	6	137	137	CD
18637	6593	7	,	,	,
18637	6593	8	149	149	CD
18637	6593	9	-	-	SYM
18637	6593	10	150	150	CD
18637	6593	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6593	12	1933	1933	CD
18637	6593	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6593	14	.	.	.
18637	6594	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6594	2	1202	1202	CD
18637	6594	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6594	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6594	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6594	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6594	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6594	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6594	9	Furlong	Furlong	NNP
18637	6594	10	,	,	,
18637	6594	11	5	5	CD
18637	6594	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6594	13	.	.	.
18637	6595	1	184	184	CD
18637	6595	2	,	,	,
18637	6595	3	200	200	CD
18637	6595	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6595	5	1920	1920	CD
18637	6595	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6595	7	.	.	.
18637	6596	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6596	2	1203	1203	CD
18637	6596	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6596	4	The	the	DT
18637	6596	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	6596	6	No	no	NN
18637	6596	7	.	.	.
18637	6597	1	23	23	CD
18637	6597	2	.	.	.
18637	6598	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6598	2	1204	1204	CD
18637	6598	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6598	4	Penhallow	Penhallow	NNP
18637	6598	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6598	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6598	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6598	8	Doane	Doane	NNP
18637	6598	9	,	,	,
18637	6598	10	3	3	CD
18637	6598	11	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	6598	12	.	.	.
18637	6599	1	54	54	CD
18637	6599	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6599	3	1795	1795	CD
18637	6599	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6599	5	.	.	.
18637	6600	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6600	2	1205	1205	CD
18637	6600	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6600	4	4	4	CD
18637	6600	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6600	6	.	.	.
18637	6601	1	316	316	CD
18637	6601	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6601	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	6601	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6601	5	.	.	.
18637	6602	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6602	2	1206	1206	CD
18637	6602	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6602	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6602	5	.	.	.
18637	6603	1	407	407	CD
18637	6603	2	.	.	.
18637	6604	1	Emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	6604	2	supplied	supply	VBD
18637	6604	3	.	.	.
18637	6605	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6605	2	1207	1207	CD
18637	6605	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6605	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	6605	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	6605	6	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
18637	6605	7	,	,	,
18637	6605	8	4	4	CD
18637	6605	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6605	10	.	.	.
18637	6606	1	2	2	CD
18637	6606	2	,	,	,
18637	6606	3	139	139	CD
18637	6606	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6606	5	1866	1866	CD
18637	6606	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6606	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6606	8	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	6606	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	6606	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6606	11	;	;	:
18637	6606	12	_	_	NNP
18637	6606	13	see	see	VB
18637	6606	14	also	also	RB
18637	6606	15	_	_	NNP
18637	6606	16	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	6606	17	_	_	NNP
18637	6606	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	6606	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6606	20	United	United	NNP
18637	6606	21	States	States	NNP
18637	6606	22	,	,	,
18637	6606	23	11	11	CD
18637	6606	24	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6606	25	.	.	.
18637	6607	1	268	268	CD
18637	6607	2	,	,	,
18637	6607	3	305	305	CD
18637	6607	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6607	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	6607	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6607	7	;	;	:
18637	6607	8	and	and	CC
18637	6607	9	United	United	NNP
18637	6607	10	States	States	NNP
18637	6607	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6607	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	6607	13	_	_	NNP
18637	6607	14	Macintosh	Macintosh	NNP
18637	6607	15	,	,	,
18637	6607	16	283	283	CD
18637	6607	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6607	18	605	605	CD
18637	6607	19	,	,	,
18637	6607	20	622	622	CD
18637	6607	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6607	22	1931	1931	CD
18637	6607	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6607	24	.	.	.
18637	6608	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6608	2	1208	1208	CD
18637	6608	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6608	4	58	58	CD
18637	6608	5	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	6608	6	.	.	.
18637	6609	1	Globe	Globe	NNP
18637	6609	2	,	,	,
18637	6609	3	37th	37th	NN
18637	6609	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	6609	5	.	.	NNP
18637	6609	6	,	,	,
18637	6609	7	1st	1st	JJ
18637	6609	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	6609	9	.	.	.
18637	6609	10	,	,	,
18637	6609	11	App	App	NNP
18637	6609	12	.	.	.
18637	6610	1	1	1	CD
18637	6610	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6610	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	6610	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6610	5	.	.	.
18637	6611	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6611	2	1209	1209	CD
18637	6611	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6611	4	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	6611	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6611	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6611	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6611	8	Dillin	Dillin	NNP
18637	6611	9	,	,	,
18637	6611	10	21	21	CD
18637	6611	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6611	12	.	.	.
18637	6612	1	73	73	CD
18637	6612	2	,	,	,
18637	6612	3	86	86	CD
18637	6612	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6612	5	1875	1875	CD
18637	6612	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6612	7	.	.	.
18637	6613	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6613	2	1210	1210	CD
18637	6613	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6613	4	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	6613	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	6614	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6614	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6614	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6614	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6614	5	North	North	NNP
18637	6614	6	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	6614	7	,	,	,
18637	6614	8	250	250	CD
18637	6614	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6614	10	135	135	CD
18637	6614	11	,	,	,
18637	6614	12	149	149	CD
18637	6614	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6614	14	1919	1919	CD
18637	6614	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6614	16	.	.	.
18637	6615	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6615	2	1211	1211	CD
18637	6615	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6615	4	Home	Home	NNP
18637	6615	5	Bldg	Bldg	NNP
18637	6615	6	.	.	.
18637	6616	1	&	&	CC
18637	6616	2	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	6616	3	Assoc	Assoc	NNP
18637	6616	4	.	.	.
18637	6617	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6617	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	6617	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6617	4	Blaisdell	Blaisdell	NNP
18637	6617	5	,	,	,
18637	6617	6	290	290	CD
18637	6617	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6617	8	398	398	CD
18637	6617	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6617	10	1934	1934	CD
18637	6617	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6617	12	.	.	.
18637	6618	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6618	2	1212	1212	CD
18637	6618	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6618	4	Northern	northern	JJ
18637	6618	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	6619	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6619	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6619	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6619	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6619	5	North	North	NNP
18637	6619	6	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	6619	7	,	,	,
18637	6619	8	250	250	CD
18637	6619	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6619	10	135	135	CD
18637	6619	11	,	,	,
18637	6619	12	149	149	CD
18637	6619	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6619	14	1919	1919	CD
18637	6619	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6619	16	.	.	.
18637	6620	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6620	2	1213	1213	CD
18637	6620	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6620	4	299	299	CD
18637	6620	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6620	6	304	304	CD
18637	6620	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6620	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	6620	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6620	10	.	.	.
18637	6621	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6621	2	1214	1214	CD
18637	6621	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6621	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6621	5	.	.	.
18637	6622	1	316	316	CD
18637	6622	2	,	,	,
18637	6622	3	318	318	CD
18637	6622	4	.	.	.
18637	6623	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6623	2	1215	1215	CD
18637	6623	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6623	4	334	334	CD
18637	6623	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6623	6	742	742	CD
18637	6623	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6623	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	6623	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6623	10	.	.	.
18637	6624	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6624	2	1216	1216	CD
18637	6624	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6624	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6624	5	.	.	.
18637	6625	1	757	757	CD
18637	6625	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6625	3	758	758	CD
18637	6625	4	.	.	.
18637	6626	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6626	2	1217	1217	CD
18637	6626	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6626	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6626	5	.	.	.
18637	6627	1	755	755	CD
18637	6627	2	.	.	.
18637	6628	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6628	2	1218	1218	CD
18637	6628	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6628	4	II	II	NNP
18637	6628	5	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	6628	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	6628	7	of	of	IN
18637	6628	8	the	the	DT
18637	6628	9	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	6628	10	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	6628	11	82	82	CD
18637	6628	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6628	13	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
18637	6628	14	's	's	POS
18637	6628	15	ed	ed	NN
18637	6628	16	.	.	.
18637	6629	1	1908	1908	CD
18637	6629	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6629	3	.	.	.
18637	6630	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6630	2	1219	1219	CD
18637	6630	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6630	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6630	5	.	.	.
18637	6631	1	188	188	CD
18637	6631	2	.	.	.
18637	6632	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6632	2	1220	1220	CD
18637	6632	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6632	4	11	11	CD
18637	6632	5	Annals	Annals	NNPS
18637	6632	6	of	of	IN
18637	6632	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	6632	8	11	11	CD
18637	6632	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6632	10	1801	1801	CD
18637	6632	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6632	12	.	.	.
18637	6633	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6633	2	1221	1221	CD
18637	6633	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6633	4	Works	Works	NNP
18637	6633	5	of	of	IN
18637	6633	6	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	6633	7	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	6633	8	,	,	,
18637	6633	9	VII	VII	NNP
18637	6633	10	,	,	,
18637	6633	11	746	746	CD
18637	6633	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6633	13	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	6633	14	's	's	POS
18637	6633	15	ed	ed	NN
18637	6633	16	.	.	.
18637	6634	1	1851	1851	CD
18637	6634	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6634	3	.	.	.
18637	6635	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6635	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	6635	3	.	.	.
18637	6635	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6635	5	Bas	Bas	NNP
18637	6635	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6635	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6635	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6635	9	Tingy	Tingy	NNP
18637	6635	10	,	,	,
18637	6635	11	4	4	CD
18637	6635	12	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	6635	13	.	.	.
18637	6636	1	37	37	CD
18637	6636	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6636	3	1800	1800	CD
18637	6636	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6636	5	.	.	.
18637	6637	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6637	2	1222	1222	CD
18637	6637	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6637	4	2	2	CD
18637	6637	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6637	6	.	.	.
18637	6638	1	129	129	CD
18637	6638	2	,	,	,
18637	6638	3	130	130	CD
18637	6638	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6638	5	1802	1802	CD
18637	6638	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6638	7	.	.	.
18637	6639	1	Emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	6639	2	supplied	supply	VBD
18637	6639	3	.	.	.
18637	6640	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6640	2	1223	1223	CD
18637	6640	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6640	4	The	the	DT
18637	6640	5	Prize	Prize	NNP
18637	6640	6	Cases	case	NNS
18637	6640	7	,	,	,
18637	6640	8	2	2	CD
18637	6640	9	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	6640	10	.	.	.
18637	6641	1	635	635	CD
18637	6641	2	,	,	,
18637	6641	3	668	668	CD
18637	6641	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6641	5	1863	1863	CD
18637	6641	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6641	7	.	.	.
18637	6642	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6642	2	1224	1224	CD
18637	6642	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6642	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6642	5	.	.	.
18637	6643	1	683	683	CD
18637	6643	2	,	,	,
18637	6643	3	688	688	CD
18637	6643	4	.	.	.
18637	6644	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6644	2	1225	1225	CD
18637	6644	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6644	4	12	12	CD
18637	6644	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6644	6	.	.	.
18637	6645	1	700	700	CD
18637	6645	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6645	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	6645	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6645	5	.	.	.
18637	6646	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6646	2	1226	1226	CD
18637	6646	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6646	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6646	5	.	.	.
18637	6647	1	702	702	CD
18637	6647	2	.	.	.
18637	6648	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6648	2	1227	1227	CD
18637	6648	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6648	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6648	5	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
18637	6648	6	,	,	,
18637	6648	7	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNP
18637	6648	8	263	263	CD
18637	6648	9	,	,	,
18637	6648	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6648	11	Wendell	Wendell	NNP
18637	6648	12	's	's	POS
18637	6648	13	ed	ed	NN
18637	6648	14	.	.	.
18637	6649	1	1857	1857	CD
18637	6649	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6649	3	.	.	.
18637	6650	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6650	2	1228	1228	CD
18637	6650	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6650	4	II	II	NNP
18637	6650	5	Story	Story	NNP
18637	6650	6	,	,	,
18637	6650	7	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	6650	8	,	,	,
18637	6650	9	§	â§	NN
18637	6650	10	1187	1187	CD
18637	6650	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6650	12	4th	4th	JJ
18637	6650	13	ed	ed	NNP
18637	6650	14	.	.	.
18637	6651	1	1873	1873	CD
18637	6651	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6651	3	.	.	.
18637	6652	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6652	2	1229	1229	CD
18637	6652	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6652	4	25	25	CD
18637	6652	5	Op	op	NN
18637	6652	6	.	.	.
18637	6653	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	6653	2	.	.	.
18637	6654	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	6654	2	105	105	CD
18637	6654	3	,	,	,
18637	6654	4	108	108	CD
18637	6654	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6654	6	1904	1904	CD
18637	6654	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6654	8	.	.	.
18637	6655	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6655	2	1230	1230	CD
18637	6655	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6655	4	40	40	CD
18637	6655	5	Op	Op	NNP
18637	6655	6	.	.	.
18637	6656	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	6656	2	.	.	.
18637	6657	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	6657	2	555	555	CD
18637	6657	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6657	4	1948	1948	CD
18637	6657	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6657	6	.	.	.
18637	6658	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6658	2	1231	1231	CD
18637	6658	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6658	4	61	61	CD
18637	6658	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6658	6	.	.	.
18637	6659	1	405	405	CD
18637	6659	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6659	3	1947	1947	CD
18637	6659	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6659	5	.	.	.
18637	6660	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6660	2	1232	1232	CD
18637	6660	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6660	4	H.J.	H.J.	NNP
18637	6661	1	Res	Res	NNP
18637	6661	2	.	.	.
18637	6662	1	298	298	CD
18637	6662	2	,	,	,
18637	6662	3	80th	80th	NNP
18637	6662	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	6662	5	.	.	NNP
18637	6662	6	,	,	,
18637	6662	7	2d	2d	CD
18637	6662	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	6662	9	.	.	.
18637	6663	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6663	2	1948	1948	CD
18637	6663	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6663	4	.	.	.
18637	6664	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6664	2	1233	1233	CD
18637	6664	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6664	4	Selective	Selective	NNP
18637	6664	5	Draft	Draft	NNP
18637	6664	6	Law	Law	NNP
18637	6664	7	Cases	case	NNS
18637	6664	8	,	,	,
18637	6664	9	245	245	CD
18637	6664	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6664	11	366	366	CD
18637	6664	12	,	,	,
18637	6664	13	380	380	CD
18637	6664	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6664	15	1918	1918	CD
18637	6664	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6664	17	;	;	:
18637	6664	18	Cox	Cox	NNP
18637	6664	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6664	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	6664	21	_	_	NNP
18637	6664	22	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	6664	23	,	,	,
18637	6664	24	247	247	CD
18637	6664	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6664	26	3	3	CD
18637	6664	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6664	28	1918	1918	CD
18637	6664	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6664	30	.	.	.
18637	6665	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6665	2	1234	1234	CD
18637	6665	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6665	4	245	245	CD
18637	6665	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6665	6	at	at	IN
18637	6665	7	385	385	CD
18637	6665	8	.	.	.
18637	6666	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6666	2	1235	1235	CD
18637	6666	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6666	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6666	5	.	.	.
18637	6667	1	386	386	CD
18637	6667	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6667	3	388	388	CD
18637	6667	4	.	.	.
18637	6668	1	The	the	DT
18637	6668	2	measure	measure	NN
18637	6668	3	was	be	VBD
18637	6668	4	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	6668	5	by	by	IN
18637	6668	6	a	a	DT
18637	6668	7	State	State	NNP
18637	6668	8	court	court	NN
18637	6668	9	,	,	,
18637	6668	10	Kneedler	Kneedler	NNP
18637	6668	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6668	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	6668	13	_	_	NNP
18637	6668	14	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	6668	15	,	,	,
18637	6668	16	45	45	CD
18637	6668	17	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	6668	18	238	238	CD
18637	6668	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6668	20	1863	1863	CD
18637	6668	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6668	22	.	.	.
18637	6669	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6669	2	1236	1236	CD
18637	6669	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6669	4	Selective	Selective	NNP
18637	6669	5	Draft	Draft	NNP
18637	6669	6	Law	Law	NNP
18637	6669	7	Cases	case	NNS
18637	6669	8	,	,	,
18637	6669	9	245	245	CD
18637	6669	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6669	11	366	366	CD
18637	6669	12	,	,	,
18637	6669	13	381	381	CD
18637	6669	14	,	,	,
18637	6669	15	382	382	CD
18637	6669	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6669	17	1918	1918	CD
18637	6669	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6669	19	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6669	20	1237	1237	CD
18637	6669	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6669	22	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	6669	23	_	_	NNP
18637	6669	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	6669	25	_	_	NNP
18637	6669	26	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	6669	27	,	,	,
18637	6669	28	240	240	CD
18637	6669	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6669	30	328	328	CD
18637	6669	31	,	,	,
18637	6669	32	333	333	CD
18637	6669	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6669	34	1916	1916	CD
18637	6669	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6669	36	.	.	.
18637	6670	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6670	2	1238	1238	CD
18637	6670	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6670	4	245	245	CD
18637	6670	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6670	6	366	366	CD
18637	6670	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6670	8	1918	1918	CD
18637	6670	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6670	10	.	.	.
18637	6671	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6671	2	1239	1239	CD
18637	6671	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6671	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6671	5	.	.	.
18637	6672	1	390	390	CD
18637	6672	2	.	.	.
18637	6673	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6673	2	1240	1240	CD
18637	6673	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6673	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6673	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6673	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6673	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6673	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6673	9	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	6673	10	,	,	,
18637	6673	11	302	302	CD
18637	6673	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6673	13	46	46	CD
18637	6673	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6673	15	1937	1937	CD
18637	6673	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6673	17	.	.	.
18637	6674	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6674	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6674	3	also	also	RB
18637	6674	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6674	5	In	in	IN
18637	6674	6	re	re	IN
18637	6674	7	Grimley	Grimley	NNP
18637	6674	8	,	,	,
18637	6674	9	137	137	CD
18637	6674	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6674	11	147	147	CD
18637	6674	12	,	,	,
18637	6674	13	153	153	CD
18637	6674	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6674	15	1890	1890	CD
18637	6674	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6674	17	;	;	:
18637	6674	18	In	in	IN
18637	6674	19	re	re	NN
18637	6674	20	Morrissey	Morrissey	NNP
18637	6674	21	,	,	,
18637	6674	22	137	137	CD
18637	6674	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6674	24	157	157	CD
18637	6674	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6674	26	1890	1890	CD
18637	6674	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6674	28	.	.	.
18637	6675	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6675	2	1241	1241	CD
18637	6675	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6675	4	Wissner	Wissner	NNP
18637	6675	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6675	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6675	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6675	8	Wissner	Wissner	NNP
18637	6675	9	,	,	,
18637	6675	10	338	338	CD
18637	6675	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6675	12	655	655	CD
18637	6675	13	,	,	,
18637	6675	14	660	660	CD
18637	6675	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6675	16	1950	1950	CD
18637	6675	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6675	18	.	.	.
18637	6676	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6676	2	1242	1242	CD
18637	6676	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6676	4	McKinley	McKinley	NNP
18637	6676	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6676	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6676	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6676	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6676	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6676	10	,	,	,
18637	6676	11	249	249	CD
18637	6676	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6676	13	397	397	CD
18637	6676	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6676	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	6676	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6676	17	.	.	.
18637	6677	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6677	2	1243	1243	CD
18637	6677	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6677	4	Dynes	Dynes	NNP
18637	6677	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6677	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6677	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6677	8	Hoover	Hoover	NNP
18637	6677	9	,	,	,
18637	6677	10	20	20	CD
18637	6677	11	How	how	WRB
18637	6677	12	.	.	.
18637	6678	1	65	65	CD
18637	6678	2	,	,	,
18637	6678	3	79	79	CD
18637	6678	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6678	5	1858	1858	CD
18637	6678	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6678	7	.	.	.
18637	6679	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6679	2	1244	1244	CD
18637	6679	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6679	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	6679	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	6679	6	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
18637	6679	7	,	,	,
18637	6679	8	4	4	CD
18637	6679	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6679	10	.	.	.
18637	6680	1	2	2	CD
18637	6680	2	,	,	,
18637	6680	3	123	123	CD
18637	6680	4	,	,	,
18637	6680	5	138	138	CD
18637	6680	6	-	-	SYM
18637	6680	7	139	139	CD
18637	6680	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6680	9	1866	1866	CD
18637	6680	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6680	11	.	.	.
18637	6681	1	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	6681	2	parte	parte	NNP
18637	6681	3	Quirin	Quirin	NNP
18637	6681	4	,	,	,
18637	6681	5	317	317	CD
18637	6681	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6681	7	1	1	CD
18637	6681	8	,	,	,
18637	6681	9	40	40	CD
18637	6681	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6681	11	1942	1942	CD
18637	6681	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6681	13	.	.	.
18637	6682	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6682	2	1245	1245	CD
18637	6682	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6682	4	Wade	Wade	NNP
18637	6682	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6682	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6682	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6682	8	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	6682	9	,	,	,
18637	6682	10	336	336	CD
18637	6682	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6682	12	684	684	CD
18637	6682	13	,	,	,
18637	6682	14	687	687	CD
18637	6682	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6682	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	6682	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6682	18	.	.	.
18637	6683	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6683	2	1246	1246	CD
18637	6683	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6683	4	Dynes	Dynes	NNP
18637	6683	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6683	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6683	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6683	8	Hoover	Hoover	NNP
18637	6683	9	,	,	,
18637	6683	10	20	20	CD
18637	6683	11	How	how	WRB
18637	6683	12	.	.	.
18637	6684	1	65	65	CD
18637	6684	2	,	,	,
18637	6684	3	82	82	CD
18637	6684	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6684	5	1858	1858	CD
18637	6684	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6684	7	.	.	.
18637	6685	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6685	2	1247	1247	CD
18637	6685	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6685	4	Swaim	Swaim	NNP
18637	6685	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6685	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6685	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6685	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6685	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6685	10	,	,	,
18637	6685	11	165	165	CD
18637	6685	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6685	13	553	553	CD
18637	6685	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6685	15	1897	1897	CD
18637	6685	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6685	17	;	;	:
18637	6685	18	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	6685	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6685	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	6685	21	_	_	NNP
18637	6685	22	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	6685	23	,	,	,
18637	6685	24	177	177	CD
18637	6685	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6685	26	496	496	CD
18637	6685	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6685	28	1900	1900	CD
18637	6685	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6685	30	;	;	:
18637	6685	31	Hiatt	Hiatt	NNP
18637	6685	32	_	_	NNP
18637	6685	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	6685	34	_	_	NNP
18637	6685	35	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	6685	36	,	,	,
18637	6685	37	339	339	CD
18637	6685	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6685	39	103	103	CD
18637	6685	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6685	41	1950	1950	CD
18637	6685	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6685	43	.	.	.
18637	6686	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6686	2	1248	1248	CD
18637	6686	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6686	4	Mullan	Mullan	NNP
18637	6686	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6686	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6686	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6686	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6686	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6686	10	,	,	,
18637	6686	11	212	212	CD
18637	6686	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6686	13	516	516	CD
18637	6686	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6686	15	1909	1909	CD
18637	6686	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6686	17	;	;	:
18637	6686	18	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	6686	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6686	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	6686	21	_	_	NNP
18637	6686	22	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	6686	23	,	,	,
18637	6686	24	116	116	CD
18637	6686	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6686	26	167	167	CD
18637	6686	27	,	,	,
18637	6686	28	177	177	CD
18637	6686	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6686	30	1886	1886	CD
18637	6686	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6686	32	;	;	:
18637	6686	33	Hiatt	Hiatt	NNP
18637	6686	34	_	_	NNP
18637	6686	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	6686	36	_	_	NNP
18637	6686	37	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	6686	38	,	,	,
18637	6686	39	339	339	CD
18637	6686	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6686	41	103	103	CD
18637	6686	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6686	43	1950	1950	CD
18637	6686	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6686	45	.	.	.
18637	6687	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6687	2	1249	1249	CD
18637	6687	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6687	4	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	6687	5	,	,	,
18637	6687	6	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	6687	7	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
18637	6687	8	Passed	pass	VBD
18637	6687	9	Prior	prior	RB
18637	6687	10	to	to	IN
18637	6687	11	December	December	NNP
18637	6687	12	1917	1917	CD
18637	6687	13	,	,	,
18637	6687	14	211	211	CD
18637	6687	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6687	16	1918	1918	CD
18637	6687	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6687	18	.	.	.
18637	6688	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6688	2	1250	1250	CD
18637	6688	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6688	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6688	5	.	.	.
18637	6689	1	214	214	CD
18637	6689	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6689	3	1251	1251	CD
18637	6689	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6689	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6689	6	.	.	.
18637	6690	1	250	250	CD
18637	6690	2	,	,	,
18637	6690	3	332	332	CD
18637	6690	4	,	,	,
18637	6690	5	380	380	CD
18637	6690	6	,	,	,
18637	6690	7	438	438	CD
18637	6690	8	,	,	,
18637	6690	9	497	497	CD
18637	6690	10	.	.	.
18637	6691	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6691	2	1252	1252	CD
18637	6691	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6691	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6691	5	.	.	.
18637	6692	1	420	420	CD
18637	6692	2	,	,	,
18637	6692	3	466	466	CD
18637	6692	4	,	,	,
18637	6692	5	535	535	CD
18637	6692	6	,	,	,
18637	6692	7	595	595	CD
18637	6692	8	,	,	,
18637	6692	9	636	636	CD
18637	6692	10	,	,	,
18637	6692	11	823	823	CD
18637	6692	12	.	.	.
18637	6693	1	Many	many	JJ
18637	6693	2	of	of	IN
18637	6693	3	these	these	DT
18637	6693	4	were	be	VBD
18637	6693	5	soon	soon	RB
18637	6693	6	suspended	suspend	VBN
18637	6693	7	or	or	CC
18637	6693	8	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	6693	9	.	.	.
18637	6694	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	6694	2	.	.	.
18637	6695	1	458	458	CD
18637	6695	2	,	,	,
18637	6695	3	553	553	CD
18637	6695	4	,	,	,
18637	6695	5	601	601	CD
18637	6695	6	,	,	,
18637	6695	7	733	733	CD
18637	6695	8	.	.	.
18637	6696	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6696	2	1253	1253	CD
18637	6696	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6696	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6696	5	.	.	.
18637	6697	1	482	482	CD
18637	6697	2	,	,	,
18637	6697	3	543	543	CD
18637	6697	4	,	,	,
18637	6697	5	963	963	CD
18637	6697	6	,	,	,
18637	6697	7	969	969	CD
18637	6697	8	.	.	.
18637	6698	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6698	2	1254	1254	CD
18637	6698	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6698	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6698	5	.	.	.
18637	6699	1	916	916	CD
18637	6699	2	.	.	.
18637	6700	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6700	2	1255	1255	CD
18637	6700	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6700	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6700	5	.	.	.
18637	6701	1	280	280	CD
18637	6701	2	.	.	.
18637	6702	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6702	2	1256	1256	CD
18637	6702	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6702	4	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	6702	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6702	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6702	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6702	8	Griswold	Griswold	NNP
18637	6702	9	,	,	,
18637	6702	10	8	8	CD
18637	6702	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6702	12	.	.	.
18637	6703	1	603	603	CD
18637	6703	2	,	,	,
18637	6703	3	617	617	CD
18637	6703	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6703	5	1870	1870	CD
18637	6703	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6703	7	.	.	.
18637	6704	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6704	2	1257	1257	CD
18637	6704	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6704	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6704	5	.	.	.
18637	6705	1	626	626	CD
18637	6705	2	.	.	.
18637	6706	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6706	2	1258	1258	CD
18637	6706	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6706	4	Knox	Knox	NNP
18637	6706	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6706	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6706	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6706	8	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	6706	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6706	10	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	6706	11	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	6706	12	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	6706	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6706	14	,	,	,
18637	6706	15	12	12	CD
18637	6706	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6706	17	.	.	.
18637	6707	1	457	457	CD
18637	6707	2	,	,	,
18637	6707	3	540	540	CD
18637	6707	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6707	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	6707	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6707	7	.	.	.
18637	6708	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6708	2	1259	1259	CD
18637	6708	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6708	4	40	40	CD
18637	6708	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6708	6	.	.	.
18637	6709	1	276	276	CD
18637	6709	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6709	3	1917	1917	CD
18637	6709	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6709	5	.	.	.
18637	6710	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6710	2	1260	1260	CD
18637	6710	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6710	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6710	5	.	.	.
18637	6711	1	272	272	CD
18637	6711	2	.	.	.
18637	6712	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6712	2	1261	1261	CD
18637	6712	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6712	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6712	5	.	.	.
18637	6713	1	411	411	CD
18637	6713	2	.	.	.
18637	6714	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6714	2	1262	1262	CD
18637	6714	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6714	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6714	5	.	.	.
18637	6715	1	451	451	CD
18637	6715	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6715	3	1918	1918	CD
18637	6715	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6715	5	.	.	.
18637	6716	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6716	2	1263	1263	CD
18637	6716	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6716	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6716	5	.	.	.
18637	6717	1	904	904	CD
18637	6717	2	.	.	.
18637	6718	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6718	2	1264	1264	CD
18637	6718	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6718	4	55	55	CD
18637	6718	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6718	6	.	.	.
18637	6719	1	236	236	CD
18637	6719	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6719	3	1941	1941	CD
18637	6719	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6719	5	.	.	.
18637	6720	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6720	2	1265	1265	CD
18637	6720	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6720	4	56	56	CD
18637	6720	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6720	6	.	.	.
18637	6721	1	176	176	CD
18637	6721	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6721	3	1942	1942	CD
18637	6721	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6721	5	.	.	.
18637	6722	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6722	2	1266	1266	CD
18637	6722	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6722	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6722	5	.	.	.
18637	6723	1	23	23	CD
18637	6723	2	.	.	.
18637	6724	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6724	2	1267	1267	CD
18637	6724	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6724	4	57	57	CD
18637	6724	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6724	6	.	.	.
18637	6725	1	163	163	CD
18637	6725	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6725	3	1943	1943	CD
18637	6725	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6725	5	.	.	.
18637	6726	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6726	2	1268	1268	CD
18637	6726	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6726	4	Lichter	Lichter	NNP
18637	6726	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6726	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6726	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6726	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6726	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6726	10	,	,	,
18637	6726	11	334	334	CD
18637	6726	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6726	13	742	742	CD
18637	6726	14	,	,	,
18637	6726	15	754	754	CD
18637	6726	16	-	-	SYM
18637	6726	17	756	756	CD
18637	6726	18	,	,	,
18637	6726	19	765	765	CD
18637	6726	20	,	,	,
18637	6726	21	766	766	CD
18637	6726	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6726	23	1948	1948	CD
18637	6726	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6726	25	.	.	.
18637	6727	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6727	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6727	3	also	also	RB
18637	6727	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6727	5	United	United	NNP
18637	6727	6	States	States	NNP
18637	6727	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6727	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6727	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6727	10	Bethlehem	Bethlehem	NNP
18637	6727	11	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	6727	12	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6727	13	,	,	,
18637	6727	14	315	315	CD
18637	6727	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6727	16	289	289	CD
18637	6727	17	,	,	,
18637	6727	18	305	305	CD
18637	6727	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6727	20	1942	1942	CD
18637	6727	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6727	22	;	;	:
18637	6727	23	Clallam	Clallam	NNP
18637	6727	24	County	County	NNP
18637	6727	25	_	_	NNP
18637	6727	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	6727	27	_	_	NNP
18637	6727	28	United	United	NNP
18637	6727	29	States	States	NNP
18637	6727	30	,	,	,
18637	6727	31	263	263	CD
18637	6727	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6727	33	341	341	CD
18637	6727	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6727	35	1923	1923	CD
18637	6727	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6727	37	;	;	:
18637	6727	38	Sloan	Sloan	NNP
18637	6727	39	Shipyards	Shipyards	NNP
18637	6727	40	_	_	NNP
18637	6727	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	6727	42	_	_	NNP
18637	6727	43	United	United	NNP
18637	6727	44	States	States	NNP
18637	6727	45	Fleet	Fleet	NNP
18637	6727	46	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6727	47	,	,	,
18637	6727	48	258	258	CD
18637	6727	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6727	50	549	549	CD
18637	6727	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6727	52	1922	1922	CD
18637	6727	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6727	54	.	.	.
18637	6728	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6728	2	1269	1269	CD
18637	6728	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6728	4	Lichter	Lichter	NNP
18637	6728	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6728	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6728	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6728	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6728	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6728	10	,	,	,
18637	6728	11	334	334	CD
18637	6728	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6728	13	742	742	CD
18637	6728	14	,	,	,
18637	6728	15	779	779	CD
18637	6728	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6728	17	1948	1948	CD
18637	6728	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6728	19	.	.	.
18637	6729	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6729	2	1270	1270	CD
18637	6729	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6729	4	245	245	CD
18637	6729	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6729	6	366	366	CD
18637	6729	7	,	,	,
18637	6729	8	389	389	CD
18637	6729	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6729	10	1918	1918	CD
18637	6729	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6729	12	.	.	.
18637	6730	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6730	2	1271	1271	CD
18637	6730	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6730	4	Yakus	Yakus	NNP
18637	6730	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6730	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6730	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6730	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6730	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6730	10	,	,	,
18637	6730	11	321	321	CD
18637	6730	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6730	13	414	414	CD
18637	6730	14	,	,	,
18637	6730	15	424	424	CD
18637	6730	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6730	17	1944	1944	CD
18637	6730	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6730	19	.	.	.
18637	6731	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6731	2	1272	1272	CD
18637	6731	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6731	4	21	21	CD
18637	6731	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6731	6	.	.	.
18637	6732	1	73	73	CD
18637	6732	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6732	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	6732	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6732	5	.	.	.
18637	6733	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6733	2	1273	1273	CD
18637	6733	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6733	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6733	5	.	.	.
18637	6734	1	96	96	CD
18637	6734	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6734	3	97	97	CD
18637	6734	4	.	.	.
18637	6735	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6735	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	6735	3	.	.	.
18637	6735	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6735	5	United	United	NNP
18637	6735	6	States	States	NNP
18637	6735	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6735	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6735	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6735	10	Chemical	Chemical	NNP
18637	6735	11	Foundation	Foundation	NNP
18637	6735	12	,	,	,
18637	6735	13	272	272	CD
18637	6735	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6735	15	1	1	CD
18637	6735	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6735	17	1926	1926	CD
18637	6735	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6735	19	.	.	.
18637	6736	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6736	2	1274	1274	CD
18637	6736	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6736	4	320	320	CD
18637	6736	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6736	6	81	81	CD
18637	6736	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6736	8	1943	1943	CD
18637	6736	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6736	10	.	.	.
18637	6737	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6737	2	1275	1275	CD
18637	6737	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6737	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6737	5	.	.	.
18637	6738	1	91	91	CD
18637	6738	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6738	3	92	92	CD
18637	6738	4	,	,	,
18637	6738	5	104	104	CD
18637	6738	6	.	.	.
18637	6739	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6739	2	1276	1276	CD
18637	6739	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6739	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6739	5	.	.	.
18637	6740	1	104	104	CD
18637	6740	2	.	.	.
18637	6741	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6741	2	1277	1277	CD
18637	6741	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6741	4	334	334	CD
18637	6741	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6741	6	742	742	CD
18637	6741	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6741	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	6741	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6741	10	.	.	.
18637	6742	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6742	2	1278	1278	CD
18637	6742	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6742	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6742	5	.	.	.
18637	6743	1	778	778	CD
18637	6743	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6743	3	779	779	CD
18637	6743	4	.	.	.
18637	6744	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6744	2	1279	1279	CD
18637	6744	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6744	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6744	5	.	.	.
18637	6745	1	782	782	CD
18637	6745	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6745	3	783	783	CD
18637	6745	4	.	.	.
18637	6746	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6746	2	1280	1280	CD
18637	6746	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6746	4	Story	Story	NNP
18637	6746	5	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	6746	6	on	on	IN
18637	6746	7	the	the	DT
18637	6746	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	6746	9	,	,	,
18637	6746	10	II	II	NNP
18637	6746	11	,	,	,
18637	6746	12	§	§	NNP
18637	6746	13	1185	1185	CD
18637	6746	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6746	15	4th	4th	NNP
18637	6746	16	ed	ed	NNP
18637	6746	17	.	.	NNP
18637	6746	18	,	,	,
18637	6746	19	1873	1873	CD
18637	6746	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6746	21	.	.	.
18637	6747	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6747	2	1281	1281	CD
18637	6747	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6747	4	297	297	CD
18637	6747	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6747	6	288	288	CD
18637	6747	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6747	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	6747	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6747	10	.	.	.
18637	6748	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6748	2	1282	1282	CD
18637	6748	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6748	4	39	39	CD
18637	6748	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6748	6	.	.	.
18637	6749	1	166	166	CD
18637	6749	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6749	3	1916	1916	CD
18637	6749	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6749	5	.	.	.
18637	6750	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6750	2	1283	1283	CD
18637	6750	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6750	4	297	297	CD
18637	6750	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6750	6	288	288	CD
18637	6750	7	,	,	,
18637	6750	8	327	327	CD
18637	6750	9	-	-	SYM
18637	6750	10	328	328	CD
18637	6750	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6750	12	1936	1936	CD
18637	6750	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6750	14	.	.	.
18637	6751	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6751	2	1284	1284	CD
18637	6751	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6751	4	60	60	CD
18637	6751	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6751	6	.	.	.
18637	6752	1	755	755	CD
18637	6752	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6752	3	1946	1946	CD
18637	6752	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6752	5	.	.	.
18637	6753	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6753	2	1285	1285	CD
18637	6753	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6753	4	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	6753	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6753	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6753	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6753	8	Kahn	Kahn	NNP
18637	6753	9	,	,	,
18637	6753	10	11	11	CD
18637	6753	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6753	12	.	.	.
18637	6754	1	493	493	CD
18637	6754	2	,	,	,
18637	6754	3	507	507	CD
18637	6754	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6754	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	6754	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6754	7	.	.	.
18637	6755	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6755	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6755	3	also	also	RB
18637	6755	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6755	5	Mayfield	Mayfield	NNP
18637	6755	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6755	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6755	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6755	9	Richards	Richards	NNP
18637	6755	10	,	,	,
18637	6755	11	115	115	CD
18637	6755	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6755	13	137	137	CD
18637	6755	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6755	15	1885	1885	CD
18637	6755	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6755	17	.	.	.
18637	6756	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6756	2	1286	1286	CD
18637	6756	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6756	4	251	251	CD
18637	6756	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6756	6	146	146	CD
18637	6756	7	,	,	,
18637	6756	8	163	163	CD
18637	6756	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6756	10	1919	1919	CD
18637	6756	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6756	12	.	.	.
18637	6757	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6757	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6757	3	also	also	RB
18637	6757	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6757	5	Ruppert	Ruppert	NNP
18637	6757	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6757	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6757	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6757	9	Caffey	Caffey	NNP
18637	6757	10	,	,	,
18637	6757	11	251	251	CD
18637	6757	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6757	13	264	264	CD
18637	6757	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6757	15	1920	1920	CD
18637	6757	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6757	17	.	.	.
18637	6758	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6758	2	1287	1287	CD
18637	6758	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6758	4	Block	Block	NNP
18637	6758	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6758	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6758	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6758	8	Hirsh	Hirsh	NNP
18637	6758	9	,	,	,
18637	6758	10	256	256	CD
18637	6758	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6758	12	135	135	CD
18637	6758	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6758	14	1921	1921	CD
18637	6758	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6758	16	.	.	.
18637	6759	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6759	2	1288	1288	CD
18637	6759	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6759	4	Chastleton	Chastleton	NNP
18637	6759	5	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6759	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6759	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6759	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6759	9	Sinclair	Sinclair	NNP
18637	6759	10	,	,	,
18637	6759	11	264	264	CD
18637	6759	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6759	13	543	543	CD
18637	6759	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6759	15	1924	1924	CD
18637	6759	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6759	17	.	.	.
18637	6760	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6760	2	1289	1289	CD
18637	6760	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6760	4	333	333	CD
18637	6760	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6760	6	138	138	CD
18637	6760	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6760	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	6760	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6760	10	.	.	.
18637	6761	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6761	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6761	3	also	also	RB
18637	6761	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6761	5	Fleming	Fleming	NNP
18637	6761	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6761	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6761	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6761	9	Mohawk	Mohawk	NNP
18637	6761	10	Wrecking	Wrecking	NNP
18637	6761	11	&	&	CC
18637	6761	12	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	6761	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6761	14	,	,	,
18637	6761	15	331	331	CD
18637	6761	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6761	17	111	111	CD
18637	6761	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6761	19	1947	1947	CD
18637	6761	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6761	21	.	.	.
18637	6762	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6762	2	1290	1290	CD
18637	6762	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6762	4	333	333	CD
18637	6762	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6762	6	138	138	CD
18637	6762	7	,	,	,
18637	6762	8	143	143	CD
18637	6762	9	-	-	SYM
18637	6762	10	144	144	CD
18637	6762	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6762	12	1948	1948	CD
18637	6762	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6762	14	.	.	.
18637	6763	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6763	2	1291	1291	CD
18637	6763	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6763	4	Ludecke	Ludecke	NNP
18637	6763	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6763	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6763	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6763	8	Watkins	Watkins	NNP
18637	6763	9	,	,	,
18637	6763	10	335	335	CD
18637	6763	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6763	12	160	160	CD
18637	6763	13	,	,	,
18637	6763	14	170	170	CD
18637	6763	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6763	16	1948	1948	CD
18637	6763	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6763	18	.	.	.
18637	6764	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6764	2	1292	1292	CD
18637	6764	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6764	4	100	100	CD
18637	6764	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6764	6	158	158	CD
18637	6764	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6764	8	1880	1880	CD
18637	6764	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6764	10	.	.	.
18637	6765	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6765	2	1293	1293	CD
18637	6765	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6765	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6765	5	.	.	.
18637	6766	1	170	170	CD
18637	6766	2	.	.	.
18637	6767	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6767	2	1294	1294	CD
18637	6767	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6767	4	4	4	CD
18637	6767	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6767	6	.	.	.
18637	6768	1	2	2	CD
18637	6768	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6768	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	6768	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6768	5	.	.	.
18637	6769	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6769	2	1295	1295	CD
18637	6769	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6769	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6769	5	.	.	.
18637	6770	1	127	127	CD
18637	6770	2	.	.	.
18637	6771	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6771	2	1296	1296	CD
18637	6771	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6771	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6771	5	.	.	.
18637	6772	1	132	132	CD
18637	6772	2	,	,	,
18637	6772	3	138	138	CD
18637	6772	4	.	.	.
18637	6773	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6773	2	1297	1297	CD
18637	6773	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6773	4	327	327	CD
18637	6773	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6773	6	304	304	CD
18637	6773	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6773	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	6773	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6773	10	.	.	.
18637	6774	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6774	2	1298	1298	CD
18637	6774	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6774	4	8	8	CD
18637	6774	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	6774	6	.	.	.
18637	6775	1	110	110	CD
18637	6775	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6775	3	1814	1814	CD
18637	6775	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6775	5	.	.	.
18637	6776	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6776	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6776	3	also	also	RB
18637	6776	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6776	5	Conrad	Conrad	NNP
18637	6776	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6776	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6776	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6776	9	Waples	Waples	NNP
18637	6776	10	,	,	,
18637	6776	11	96	96	CD
18637	6776	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6776	13	279	279	CD
18637	6776	14	,	,	,
18637	6776	15	284	284	CD
18637	6776	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6776	17	1878	1878	CD
18637	6776	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6776	19	.	.	.
18637	6777	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6777	2	1299	1299	CD
18637	6777	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6777	4	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	6777	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6777	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6777	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6777	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6777	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6777	10	,	,	,
18637	6777	11	11	11	CD
18637	6777	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6777	13	.	.	.
18637	6778	1	268	268	CD
18637	6778	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6778	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	6778	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6778	5	.	.	.
18637	6779	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6779	2	1300	1300	CD
18637	6779	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6779	4	Stoehr	Stoehr	NNP
18637	6779	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6779	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6779	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6779	8	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	6779	9	,	,	,
18637	6779	10	255	255	CD
18637	6779	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6779	12	239	239	CD
18637	6779	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6779	14	1921	1921	CD
18637	6779	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6779	16	;	;	:
18637	6779	17	Central	Central	NNP
18637	6779	18	Union	Union	NNP
18637	6779	19	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	6779	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6779	21	_	_	NNP
18637	6779	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	6779	23	_	_	NNP
18637	6779	24	Garvan	Garvan	NNP
18637	6779	25	,	,	,
18637	6779	26	254	254	CD
18637	6779	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6779	28	554	554	CD
18637	6779	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6779	30	1921	1921	CD
18637	6779	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6779	32	;	;	:
18637	6779	33	United	United	NNP
18637	6779	34	States	States	NNP
18637	6779	35	_	_	NNP
18637	6779	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	6779	37	_	_	NNP
18637	6779	38	Chemical	Chemical	NNP
18637	6779	39	Foundation	Foundation	NNP
18637	6779	40	,	,	,
18637	6779	41	272	272	CD
18637	6779	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6779	43	1	1	CD
18637	6779	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6779	45	1926	1926	CD
18637	6779	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6779	47	;	;	:
18637	6779	48	Silesian	Silesian	NNP
18637	6779	49	-	-	HYPH
18637	6779	50	American	American	NNP
18637	6779	51	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6779	52	_	_	NNP
18637	6779	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	6779	54	_	_	NNP
18637	6779	55	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	6779	56	,	,	,
18637	6779	57	332	332	CD
18637	6779	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6779	59	469	469	CD
18637	6779	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6779	61	1947	1947	CD
18637	6779	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6779	63	;	;	:
18637	6779	64	Cities	Cities	NNP
18637	6779	65	Service	Service	NNP
18637	6779	66	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6779	67	_	_	NNP
18637	6779	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	6779	69	_	_	NNP
18637	6779	70	McGrath	McGrath	NNP
18637	6779	71	,	,	,
18637	6779	72	342	342	CD
18637	6779	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6779	74	330	330	CD
18637	6779	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6779	76	1952	1952	CD
18637	6779	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6779	78	.	.	.
18637	6780	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6780	2	1301	1301	CD
18637	6780	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6780	4	The	the	DT
18637	6780	5	"	"	``
18637	6780	6	Siren	Siren	NNP
18637	6780	7	,	,	,
18637	6780	8	"	"	''
18637	6780	9	13	13	CD
18637	6780	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6780	11	.	.	.
18637	6781	1	389	389	CD
18637	6781	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6781	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	6781	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6781	5	.	.	.
18637	6782	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6782	2	1302	1302	CD
18637	6782	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6782	4	The	the	DT
18637	6782	5	"	"	``
18637	6782	6	Hampton	Hampton	NNP
18637	6782	7	,	,	,
18637	6782	8	"	"	''
18637	6782	9	5	5	CD
18637	6782	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6782	11	.	.	.
18637	6783	1	372	372	CD
18637	6783	2	,	,	,
18637	6783	3	376	376	CD
18637	6783	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6783	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	6783	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6783	7	.	.	.
18637	6784	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6784	2	1303	1303	CD
18637	6784	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6784	4	The	the	DT
18637	6784	5	"	"	``
18637	6784	6	Paquete	Paquete	NNP
18637	6784	7	Habana	Habana	NNP
18637	6784	8	,	,	,
18637	6784	9	"	"	''
18637	6784	10	175	175	CD
18637	6784	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6784	12	677	677	CD
18637	6784	13	,	,	,
18637	6784	14	700	700	CD
18637	6784	15	,	,	,
18637	6784	16	711	711	CD
18637	6784	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6784	18	1900	1900	CD
18637	6784	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6784	20	.	.	.
18637	6785	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6785	2	1304	1304	CD
18637	6785	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6785	4	Block	Block	NNP
18637	6785	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6785	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6785	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6785	8	Hirsh	Hirsh	NNP
18637	6785	9	,	,	,
18637	6785	10	256	256	CD
18637	6785	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6785	12	135	135	CD
18637	6785	13	,	,	,
18637	6785	14	156	156	CD
18637	6785	15	,	,	,
18637	6785	16	157	157	CD
18637	6785	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6785	18	1921	1921	CD
18637	6785	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6785	20	.	.	.
18637	6786	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6786	2	1305	1305	CD
18637	6786	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6786	4	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	6786	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6786	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6786	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6786	8	Willingham	Willingham	NNP
18637	6786	9	,	,	,
18637	6786	10	321	321	CD
18637	6786	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6786	12	503	503	CD
18637	6786	13	,	,	,
18637	6786	14	519	519	CD
18637	6786	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6786	16	1944	1944	CD
18637	6786	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6786	18	.	.	.
18637	6787	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6787	2	1306	1306	CD
18637	6787	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6787	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6787	5	.	.	.
18637	6788	1	521	521	CD
18637	6788	2	.	.	.
18637	6789	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6789	2	1307	1307	CD
18637	6789	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6789	4	255	255	CD
18637	6789	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6789	6	81	81	CD
18637	6789	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6789	8	1921	1921	CD
18637	6789	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6789	10	.	.	.
18637	6790	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6790	2	1308	1308	CD
18637	6790	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6790	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6790	5	.	.	.
18637	6791	1	89	89	CD
18637	6791	2	.	.	.
18637	6792	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6792	2	1309	1309	CD
18637	6792	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6792	4	Schenck	Schenck	NNP
18637	6792	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6792	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6792	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6792	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6792	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6792	10	,	,	,
18637	6792	11	249	249	CD
18637	6792	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6792	13	47	47	CD
18637	6792	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6792	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	6792	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6792	17	;	;	:
18637	6792	18	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	6792	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6792	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	6792	21	_	_	NNP
18637	6792	22	United	United	NNP
18637	6792	23	States	States	NNP
18637	6792	24	,	,	,
18637	6792	25	249	249	CD
18637	6792	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6792	27	211	211	CD
18637	6792	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6792	29	1919	1919	CD
18637	6792	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6792	31	;	;	:
18637	6792	32	Sugarman	Sugarman	NNP
18637	6792	33	_	_	NNP
18637	6792	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	6792	35	_	_	NNP
18637	6792	36	United	United	NNP
18637	6792	37	States	States	NNP
18637	6792	38	,	,	,
18637	6792	39	249	249	CD
18637	6792	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6792	41	182	182	CD
18637	6792	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6792	43	1919	1919	CD
18637	6792	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6792	45	;	;	:
18637	6792	46	Frohwerk	Frohwerk	NNP
18637	6792	47	_	_	NNP
18637	6792	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	6792	49	_	_	NNP
18637	6792	50	United	United	NNP
18637	6792	51	States	States	NNP
18637	6792	52	,	,	,
18637	6792	53	249	249	CD
18637	6792	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6792	55	204	204	CD
18637	6792	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6792	57	1919	1919	CD
18637	6792	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6792	59	;	;	:
18637	6792	60	Abrams	Abrams	NNP
18637	6792	61	_	_	NNP
18637	6792	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	6792	63	_	_	NNP
18637	6792	64	United	United	NNP
18637	6792	65	States	States	NNP
18637	6792	66	,	,	,
18637	6792	67	250	250	CD
18637	6792	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6792	69	616	616	CD
18637	6792	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6792	71	1919	1919	CD
18637	6792	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6792	73	.	.	.
18637	6793	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6793	2	1310	1310	CD
18637	6793	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6793	4	40	40	CD
18637	6793	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6793	6	.	.	.
18637	6794	1	217	217	CD
18637	6794	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6794	3	1917	1917	CD
18637	6794	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6794	5	;	;	,
18637	6794	6	amended	amend	VBN
18637	6794	7	by	by	IN
18637	6794	8	40	40	CD
18637	6794	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6794	10	.	.	.
18637	6795	1	553	553	CD
18637	6795	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6795	3	1918	1918	CD
18637	6795	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6795	5	.	.	.
18637	6796	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6796	2	1311	1311	CD
18637	6796	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6796	4	249	249	CD
18637	6796	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6796	6	47	47	CD
18637	6796	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6796	8	1919	1919	CD
18637	6796	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6796	10	.	.	.
18637	6797	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6797	2	1312	1312	CD
18637	6797	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6797	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6797	5	.	.	.
18637	6798	1	52	52	CD
18637	6798	2	.	.	.
18637	6799	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6799	2	1313	1313	CD
18637	6799	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6799	4	Gilbert	Gilbert	NNP
18637	6799	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6799	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6799	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6799	8	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	6799	9	,	,	,
18637	6799	10	254	254	CD
18637	6799	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6799	12	325	325	CD
18637	6799	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6799	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	6799	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6799	16	.	.	.
18637	6800	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6800	2	1314	1314	CD
18637	6800	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6800	4	Hirabayashi	Hirabayashi	NNP
18637	6800	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6800	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6800	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6800	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6800	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6800	10	,	,	,
18637	6800	11	320	320	CD
18637	6800	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6800	13	81	81	CD
18637	6800	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6800	15	1943	1943	CD
18637	6800	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6800	17	.	.	.
18637	6801	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6801	2	1315	1315	CD
18637	6801	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6801	4	Korematsu	Korematsu	NNP
18637	6801	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6801	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6801	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6801	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6801	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6801	10	,	,	,
18637	6801	11	323	323	CD
18637	6801	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6801	13	214	214	CD
18637	6801	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6801	15	1944	1944	CD
18637	6801	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6801	17	.	.	.
18637	6802	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6802	2	1316	1316	CD
18637	6802	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6802	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	6802	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	6802	6	Endo	Endo	NNP
18637	6802	7	,	,	,
18637	6802	8	323	323	CD
18637	6802	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6802	10	283	283	CD
18637	6802	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6802	12	1944	1944	CD
18637	6802	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6802	14	.	.	.
18637	6803	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6803	2	1317	1317	CD
18637	6803	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6803	4	1	1	CD
18637	6803	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6803	6	.	.	.
18637	6804	1	577	577	CD
18637	6804	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6804	3	1798	1798	CD
18637	6804	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6804	5	.	.	.
18637	6805	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6805	2	1318	1318	CD
18637	6805	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6805	4	Writings	Writings	NNP
18637	6805	5	of	of	IN
18637	6805	6	James	James	NNP
18637	6805	7	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	6805	8	,	,	,
18637	6805	9	VI	VI	NNP
18637	6805	10	,	,	,
18637	6805	11	360	360	CD
18637	6805	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	6805	13	361	361	CD
18637	6805	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6805	15	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
18637	6805	16	's	's	POS
18637	6805	17	ed	ed	NNP
18637	6805	18	.	.	NNP
18637	6805	19	,	,	,
18637	6805	20	1906	1906	CD
18637	6805	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6805	22	.	.	.
18637	6806	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6806	2	1319	1319	CD
18637	6806	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6806	4	40	40	CD
18637	6806	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6806	6	.	.	.
18637	6807	1	531	531	CD
18637	6807	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6807	3	1918	1918	CD
18637	6807	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6807	5	.	.	.
18637	6808	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6808	2	1320	1320	CD
18637	6808	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6808	4	335	335	CD
18637	6808	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6808	6	160	160	CD
18637	6808	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6808	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	6808	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6808	10	.	.	.
18637	6809	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6809	2	1321	1321	CD
18637	6809	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6809	4	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	6809	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6809	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6809	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6809	8	Harmony	Harmony	NNP
18637	6809	9	,	,	,
18637	6809	10	13	13	CD
18637	6809	11	How	how	WRB
18637	6809	12	.	.	.
18637	6810	1	115	115	CD
18637	6810	2	,	,	,
18637	6810	3	134	134	CD
18637	6810	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6810	5	1852	1852	CD
18637	6810	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6810	7	.	.	.
18637	6811	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6811	2	1322	1322	CD
18637	6811	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6811	4	13	13	CD
18637	6811	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6811	6	.	.	.
18637	6812	1	623	623	CD
18637	6812	2	,	,	,
18637	6812	3	627	627	CD
18637	6812	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6812	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	6812	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6812	7	.	.	.
18637	6813	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6813	2	1323	1323	CD
18637	6813	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6813	4	120	120	CD
18637	6813	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6813	6	227	227	CD
18637	6813	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6813	8	1887	1887	CD
18637	6813	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6813	10	.	.	.
18637	6814	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6814	2	1324	1324	CD
18637	6814	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6814	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6814	5	.	.	.
18637	6815	1	239	239	CD
18637	6815	2	.	.	.
18637	6816	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6816	2	1325	1325	CD
18637	6816	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6816	4	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	6817	1	Rep.	Rep.	NNP
18637	6817	2	No	No	NNP
18637	6817	3	.	.	.
18637	6818	1	262	262	CD
18637	6818	2	,	,	,
18637	6818	3	43d	43d	NNPS
18637	6818	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	6818	5	.	.	NNP
18637	6818	6	,	,	,
18637	6818	7	1st	1st	JJ
18637	6818	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	6818	9	.	.	.
18637	6818	10	,	,	,
18637	6818	11	39	39	CD
18637	6818	12	-	-	SYM
18637	6818	13	40	40	CD
18637	6818	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6818	15	1874	1874	CD
18637	6818	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6818	17	.	.	.
18637	6819	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6819	2	1326	1326	CD
18637	6819	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6819	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6819	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6819	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6819	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6819	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6819	9	Commodities	Commodities	NNPS
18637	6819	10	Trading	Trading	NNP
18637	6819	11	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6819	12	,	,	,
18637	6819	13	339	339	CD
18637	6819	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6819	15	121	121	CD
18637	6819	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6819	17	1950	1950	CD
18637	6819	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6819	19	;	;	:
18637	6819	20	United	United	NNP
18637	6819	21	States	States	NNP
18637	6819	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6819	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	6819	24	_	_	NNP
18637	6819	25	Toronto	Toronto	NNP
18637	6819	26	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	6819	27	.	.	.
18637	6820	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6820	2	,	,	,
18637	6820	3	338	338	CD
18637	6820	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6820	5	396	396	CD
18637	6820	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6820	7	1949	1949	CD
18637	6820	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6820	9	;	;	:
18637	6820	10	Kimball	Kimball	NNP
18637	6820	11	Laundry	Laundry	NNP
18637	6820	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6820	13	_	_	NNP
18637	6820	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	6820	15	_	_	NNP
18637	6820	16	United	United	NNP
18637	6820	17	States	States	NNP
18637	6820	18	,	,	,
18637	6820	19	338	338	CD
18637	6820	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6820	21	1	1	CD
18637	6820	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6820	23	1949	1949	CD
18637	6820	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6820	25	;	;	:
18637	6820	26	United	United	NNP
18637	6820	27	States	States	NNP
18637	6820	28	_	_	NNP
18637	6820	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	6820	30	_	_	NNP
18637	6820	31	Cors	Cors	NNP
18637	6820	32	,	,	,
18637	6820	33	337	337	CD
18637	6820	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6820	35	325	325	CD
18637	6820	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6820	37	1949	1949	CD
18637	6820	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6820	39	;	;	:
18637	6820	40	United	United	NNP
18637	6820	41	States	States	NNP
18637	6820	42	_	_	NNP
18637	6820	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	6820	44	_	_	NNP
18637	6820	45	John	John	NNP
18637	6820	46	J.	J.	NNP
18637	6820	47	Felin	Felin	NNP
18637	6820	48	&	&	CC
18637	6820	49	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6820	50	,	,	,
18637	6820	51	334	334	CD
18637	6820	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6820	53	624	624	CD
18637	6820	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6820	55	1948	1948	CD
18637	6820	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6820	57	;	;	:
18637	6820	58	United	United	NNP
18637	6820	59	States	States	NNP
18637	6820	60	_	_	NNP
18637	6820	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	6820	62	_	_	NNP
18637	6820	63	Petty	Petty	NNP
18637	6820	64	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	6820	65	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6820	66	,	,	,
18637	6820	67	327	327	CD
18637	6820	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6820	69	372	372	CD
18637	6820	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6820	71	1946	1946	CD
18637	6820	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6820	73	;	;	:
18637	6820	74	United	United	NNP
18637	6820	75	States	States	NNP
18637	6820	76	_	_	NNP
18637	6820	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	6820	78	_	_	NNP
18637	6820	79	General	General	NNP
18637	6820	80	Motors	Motors	NNPS
18637	6820	81	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6820	82	,	,	,
18637	6820	83	323	323	CD
18637	6820	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6820	85	373	373	CD
18637	6820	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6820	87	1945	1945	CD
18637	6820	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6820	89	.	.	.
18637	6821	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6821	2	1327	1327	CD
18637	6821	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6821	4	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	6821	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6821	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6821	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6821	8	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	6821	9	,	,	,
18637	6821	10	3	3	NNP
18637	6821	11	S.	S.	NNP
18637	6821	12	&	&	CC
18637	6821	13	R.	R.	NNP
18637	6821	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6821	15	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	6821	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6821	17	169	169	CD
18637	6821	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6821	19	1817	1817	CD
18637	6821	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6821	21	,	,	,
18637	6821	22	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	6821	23	in	in	IN
18637	6821	24	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	6821	25	_	_	NNP
18637	6821	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	6821	27	_	_	NNP
18637	6821	28	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	6821	29	,	,	,
18637	6821	30	5	5	CD
18637	6821	31	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6821	32	.	.	.
18637	6822	1	1	1	CD
18637	6822	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6822	3	1820	1820	CD
18637	6822	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6822	5	.	.	.
18637	6823	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6823	2	1328	1328	CD
18637	6823	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6823	4	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	6823	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6823	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6823	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6823	8	White	White	NNP
18637	6823	9	,	,	,
18637	6823	10	7	7	CD
18637	6823	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6823	12	.	.	.
18637	6824	1	700	700	CD
18637	6824	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6824	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	6824	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6824	5	;	;	:
18637	6824	6	Tyler	Tyler	NNP
18637	6824	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6824	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6824	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6824	10	Defrees	Defrees	NNP
18637	6824	11	,	,	,
18637	6824	12	11	11	CD
18637	6824	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6824	14	.	.	.
18637	6825	1	331	331	CD
18637	6825	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6825	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	6825	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6825	5	.	.	.
18637	6826	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6826	2	1329	1329	CD
18637	6826	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6826	4	1	1	CD
18637	6826	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6826	6	.	.	.
18637	6827	1	424	424	CD
18637	6827	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6827	3	1795	1795	CD
18637	6827	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6827	5	.	.	.
18637	6828	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6828	2	1330	1330	CD
18637	6828	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6828	4	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	6828	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6828	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6828	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6828	8	Mott	Mott	NNP
18637	6828	9	,	,	,
18637	6828	10	12	12	CD
18637	6828	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6828	12	.	.	.
18637	6829	1	19	19	CD
18637	6829	2	,	,	,
18637	6829	3	32	32	CD
18637	6829	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6829	5	1827	1827	CD
18637	6829	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6829	7	.	.	.
18637	6830	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6830	2	1331	1331	CD
18637	6830	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6830	4	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	6830	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6830	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6830	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6830	8	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	6830	9	,	,	,
18637	6830	10	5	5	CD
18637	6830	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6830	12	.	.	.
18637	6831	1	1	1	CD
18637	6831	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6831	3	1820	1820	CD
18637	6831	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6831	5	;	;	:
18637	6831	6	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	6831	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6831	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6831	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6831	10	Mott	Mott	NNP
18637	6831	11	,	,	,
18637	6831	12	12	12	CD
18637	6831	13	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6831	14	.	.	.
18637	6832	1	19	19	CD
18637	6832	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6832	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	6832	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6832	5	.	.	.
18637	6833	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6833	2	1332	1332	CD
18637	6833	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6833	4	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	6833	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6833	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6833	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6833	8	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	6833	9	,	,	,
18637	6833	10	5	5	CD
18637	6833	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6833	12	.	.	.
18637	6834	1	1	1	CD
18637	6834	2	,	,	,
18637	6834	3	16	16	CD
18637	6834	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6834	5	1820	1820	CD
18637	6834	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6834	7	.	.	.
18637	6835	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6835	2	1333	1333	CD
18637	6835	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6835	4	39	39	CD
18637	6835	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6835	6	.	.	.
18637	6836	1	166	166	CD
18637	6836	2	,	,	,
18637	6836	3	197	197	CD
18637	6836	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6836	5	1916).--By	1916).--by	CD
18637	6836	6	the	the	DT
18637	6836	7	act	act	NN
18637	6836	8	of	of	IN
18637	6836	9	June	June	NNP
18637	6836	10	28	28	CD
18637	6836	11	,	,	,
18637	6836	12	1947	1947	CD
18637	6836	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6836	14	61	61	CD
18637	6836	15	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6836	16	.	.	.
18637	6837	1	191	191	CD
18637	6837	2	,	,	,
18637	6837	3	192	192	CD
18637	6837	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6837	5	the	the	DT
18637	6837	6	age	age	NN
18637	6837	7	of	of	IN
18637	6837	8	enlistment	enlistment	NN
18637	6837	9	in	in	IN
18637	6837	10	the	the	DT
18637	6837	11	National	National	NNP
18637	6837	12	Guard	Guard	NNP
18637	6837	13	was	be	VBD
18637	6837	14	lowered	lower	VBN
18637	6837	15	to	to	IN
18637	6837	16	17	17	CD
18637	6837	17	years	year	NNS
18637	6837	18	.	.	.
18637	6838	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6838	2	1334	1334	CD
18637	6838	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6838	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6838	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6838	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6838	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6838	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6838	9	Hammond	Hammond	NNP
18637	6838	10	,	,	,
18637	6838	11	1	1	CD
18637	6838	12	Cr	cr	NN
18637	6838	13	.	.	.
18637	6839	1	C.C.	C.C.	NNP
18637	6840	1	15	15	CD
18637	6840	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6840	3	1801	1801	CD
18637	6840	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6840	5	.	.	.
18637	6841	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6841	2	1335	1335	CD
18637	6841	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6841	4	2	2	CD
18637	6841	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6841	6	.	.	.
18637	6842	1	103	103	CD
18637	6842	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6842	3	1801	1801	CD
18637	6842	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6842	5	.	.	.
18637	6843	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6843	2	1336	1336	CD
18637	6843	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6843	4	2	2	CD
18637	6843	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6843	6	.	.	.
18637	6844	1	195	195	CD
18637	6844	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6844	3	1802	1802	CD
18637	6844	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6844	5	.	.	.
18637	6845	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6845	2	1337	1337	CD
18637	6845	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6845	4	20	20	CD
18637	6845	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6845	6	.	.	.
18637	6846	1	102	102	CD
18637	6846	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6846	3	1878	1878	CD
18637	6846	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6846	5	.	.	.
18637	6847	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6847	2	1338	1338	CD
18637	6847	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6847	4	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
18637	6847	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	6847	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6847	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6847	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6847	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6847	10	District	District	NNP
18637	6847	11	of	of	IN
18637	6847	12	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	6847	13	,	,	,
18637	6847	14	132	132	CD
18637	6847	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6847	16	1	1	CD
18637	6847	17	,	,	,
18637	6847	18	9	9	CD
18637	6847	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6847	20	1889	1889	CD
18637	6847	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6847	22	.	.	.
18637	6848	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6848	2	1339	1339	CD
18637	6848	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6848	4	District	District	NNP
18637	6848	5	of	of	IN
18637	6848	6	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	6848	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6848	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6848	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6848	10	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	6848	11	,	,	,
18637	6848	12	171	171	CD
18637	6848	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6848	14	161	161	CD
18637	6848	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6848	16	1898	1898	CD
18637	6848	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6848	18	.	.	.
18637	6849	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6849	2	1340	1340	CD
18637	6849	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6849	4	Shoemaker	Shoemaker	NNP
18637	6849	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6849	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6849	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6849	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6849	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6849	10	,	,	,
18637	6849	11	147	147	CD
18637	6849	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6849	13	282	282	CD
18637	6849	14	,	,	,
18637	6849	15	299	299	CD
18637	6849	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6849	17	1893	1893	CD
18637	6849	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6849	19	.	.	.
18637	6850	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6850	2	1341	1341	CD
18637	6850	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6850	4	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	6850	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6850	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6850	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6850	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6850	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6850	10	,	,	,
18637	6850	11	174	174	CD
18637	6850	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6850	13	196	196	CD
18637	6850	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6850	15	1899	1899	CD
18637	6850	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6850	17	.	.	.
18637	6851	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6851	2	1342	1342	CD
18637	6851	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6851	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6851	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6851	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	6851	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	6851	8	.	.	.
18637	6852	1	Greathouse	Greathouse	NNP
18637	6852	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6852	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6852	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6852	5	Dern	Dern	NNP
18637	6852	6	,	,	,
18637	6852	7	289	289	CD
18637	6852	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6852	9	352	352	CD
18637	6852	10	,	,	,
18637	6852	11	354	354	CD
18637	6852	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6852	13	1933	1933	CD
18637	6852	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6852	15	;	;	:
18637	6852	16	Smoot	Smoot	NNP
18637	6852	17	Sand	Sand	NNP
18637	6852	18	&	&	CC
18637	6852	19	Gravel	Gravel	NNP
18637	6852	20	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6852	21	_	_	NNP
18637	6852	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	6852	23	_	_	NNP
18637	6852	24	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	6852	25	Airport	Airport	NNP
18637	6852	26	,	,	,
18637	6852	27	283	283	CD
18637	6852	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6852	29	348	348	CD
18637	6852	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6852	31	1931	1931	CD
18637	6852	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6852	33	;	;	:
18637	6852	34	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	6852	35	_	_	NNP
18637	6852	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	6852	37	_	_	NNP
18637	6852	38	West	West	NNP
18637	6852	39	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	6852	40	,	,	,
18637	6852	41	217	217	CD
18637	6852	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6852	43	577	577	CD
18637	6852	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6852	45	1910	1910	CD
18637	6852	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6852	47	;	;	:
18637	6852	48	Marine	Marine	NNP
18637	6852	49	R.	R.	NNP
18637	6852	50	&	&	CC
18637	6852	51	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	6852	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6852	53	_	_	NNP
18637	6852	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	6852	55	_	_	NNP
18637	6852	56	United	United	NNP
18637	6852	57	States	States	NNP
18637	6852	58	,	,	,
18637	6852	59	257	257	CD
18637	6852	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6852	61	47	47	CD
18637	6852	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6852	63	1921	1921	CD
18637	6852	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6852	65	;	;	:
18637	6852	66	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	6852	67	_	_	NNP
18637	6852	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	6852	69	_	_	NNP
18637	6852	70	United	United	NNP
18637	6852	71	States	States	NNP
18637	6852	72	,	,	,
18637	6852	73	174	174	CD
18637	6852	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6852	75	196	196	CD
18637	6852	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6852	77	1899	1899	CD
18637	6852	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6852	79	.	.	.
18637	6853	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6853	2	1343	1343	CD
18637	6853	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6853	4	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	6853	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6853	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6853	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6853	8	Payne	Payne	NNP
18637	6853	9	,	,	,
18637	6853	10	92	92	CD
18637	6853	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6853	12	130	130	CD
18637	6853	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6853	14	1876	1876	CD
18637	6853	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6853	16	.	.	.
18637	6854	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6854	2	1344	1344	CD
18637	6854	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6854	4	1	1	CD
18637	6854	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6854	6	.	.	.
18637	6855	1	139	139	CD
18637	6855	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6855	3	1790	1790	CD
18637	6855	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6855	5	.	.	.
18637	6856	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6856	2	1345	1345	CD
18637	6856	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6856	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6856	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6856	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6856	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6856	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6856	9	Simms	Simms	NNP
18637	6856	10	,	,	,
18637	6856	11	1	1	CD
18637	6856	12	Cr	cr	NN
18637	6856	13	.	.	.
18637	6857	1	252	252	CD
18637	6857	2	,	,	,
18637	6857	3	256	256	CD
18637	6857	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6857	5	1803	1803	CD
18637	6857	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6857	7	.	.	.
18637	6858	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6858	2	1346	1346	CD
18637	6858	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6858	4	2	2	CD
18637	6858	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	6858	6	.	.	.
18637	6859	1	103	103	CD
18637	6859	2	,	,	,
18637	6859	3	104	104	CD
18637	6859	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6859	5	1801	1801	CD
18637	6859	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6859	7	.	.	.
18637	6860	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6860	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6860	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6860	4	Tayloe	Tayloe	NNP
18637	6860	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6860	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6860	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6860	8	Thomson	Thomson	NNP
18637	6860	9	,	,	,
18637	6860	10	5	5	CD
18637	6860	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	6860	12	.	.	.
18637	6861	1	358	358	CD
18637	6861	2	,	,	,
18637	6861	3	368	368	CD
18637	6861	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6861	5	1831	1831	CD
18637	6861	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6861	7	;	;	:
18637	6861	8	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	6861	9	parte	parte	NN
18637	6861	10	Watkins	Watkins	NNP
18637	6861	11	,	,	,
18637	6861	12	7	7	CD
18637	6861	13	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	6861	14	.	.	.
18637	6862	1	568	568	CD
18637	6862	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6862	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	6862	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6862	5	;	;	:
18637	6862	6	Stelle	Stelle	NNP
18637	6862	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6862	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6862	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6862	10	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	6862	11	,	,	,
18637	6862	12	12	12	CD
18637	6862	13	Pet	pet	NN
18637	6862	14	.	.	.
18637	6863	1	201	201	CD
18637	6863	2	,	,	,
18637	6863	3	205	205	CD
18637	6863	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6863	5	1838	1838	CD
18637	6863	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6863	7	;	;	:
18637	6863	8	Van	Van	NNP
18637	6863	9	Ness	Ness	NNP
18637	6863	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6863	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	6863	12	_	_	NNP
18637	6863	13	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6863	14	of	of	IN
18637	6863	15	United	United	NNP
18637	6863	16	States	States	NNP
18637	6863	17	,	,	,
18637	6863	18	13	13	CD
18637	6863	19	Pet	pet	NN
18637	6863	20	.	.	.
18637	6864	1	17	17	CD
18637	6864	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6864	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	6864	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6864	5	;	;	:
18637	6864	6	United	United	NNP
18637	6864	7	States	States	NNP
18637	6864	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6864	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	6864	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6864	11	Eliason	Eliason	NNP
18637	6864	12	,	,	,
18637	6864	13	16	16	CD
18637	6864	14	Pet	pet	NN
18637	6864	15	.	.	.
18637	6865	1	291	291	CD
18637	6865	2	,	,	,
18637	6865	3	301	301	CD
18637	6865	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6865	5	1842	1842	CD
18637	6865	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6865	7	.	.	.
18637	6866	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6866	2	1347	1347	CD
18637	6866	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6866	4	Reily	Reily	NNP
18637	6866	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6866	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6866	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6866	8	Lamar	Lamar	NNP
18637	6866	9	,	,	,
18637	6866	10	2	2	CD
18637	6866	11	Cr	cr	NN
18637	6866	12	.	.	.
18637	6867	1	344	344	CD
18637	6867	2	,	,	,
18637	6867	3	356	356	CD
18637	6867	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6867	5	1805	1805	CD
18637	6867	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6867	7	.	.	.
18637	6868	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6868	2	1348	1348	CD
18637	6868	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6868	4	Korn	Korn	NNP
18637	6868	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6868	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6868	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6868	8	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	6868	9	Assur	Assur	NNP
18637	6868	10	.	.	.
18637	6869	1	Soc	Soc	NNP
18637	6869	2	.	.	NNP
18637	6869	3	,	,	,
18637	6869	4	6	6	CD
18637	6869	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	6869	6	.	.	.
18637	6870	1	192	192	CD
18637	6870	2	,	,	,
18637	6870	3	199	199	CD
18637	6870	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6870	5	1810	1810	CD
18637	6870	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6870	7	.	.	.
18637	6871	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6871	2	1349	1349	CD
18637	6871	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6871	4	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	6871	5	Assur	Assur	NNP
18637	6871	6	.	.	.
18637	6872	1	Soc	Soc	NNP
18637	6872	2	.	.	.
18637	6873	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6873	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	6873	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6873	4	Watts	Watts	NNP
18637	6873	5	,	,	,
18637	6873	6	1	1	CD
18637	6873	7	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6873	8	.	.	.
18637	6874	1	279	279	CD
18637	6874	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6874	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	6874	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6874	5	.	.	.
18637	6875	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6875	2	1350	1350	CD
18637	6875	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6875	4	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	6875	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6875	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6875	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6875	8	Ellzey	Ellzey	NNP
18637	6875	9	,	,	,
18637	6875	10	2	2	CD
18637	6875	11	Cr	cr	NN
18637	6875	12	.	.	.
18637	6876	1	445	445	CD
18637	6876	2	,	,	,
18637	6876	3	452	452	CD
18637	6876	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6876	5	1805	1805	CD
18637	6876	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6876	7	;	;	:
18637	6876	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6876	9	see	see	VB
18637	6876	10	also	also	RB
18637	6876	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6876	12	Serè	Serè	NNP
18637	6876	13	_	_	NNP
18637	6876	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	6876	15	_	_	NNP
18637	6876	16	Pitot	Pitot	NNP
18637	6876	17	,	,	,
18637	6876	18	6	6	CD
18637	6876	19	Cr	cr	NN
18637	6876	20	.	.	.
18637	6877	1	332	332	CD
18637	6877	2	,	,	,
18637	6877	3	336	336	CD
18637	6877	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6877	5	1810	1810	CD
18637	6877	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6877	7	;	;	:
18637	6877	8	New	New	NNP
18637	6877	9	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	6877	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6877	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	6877	12	_	_	NNP
18637	6877	13	Winter	Winter	NNP
18637	6877	14	,	,	,
18637	6877	15	1	1	CD
18637	6877	16	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6877	17	.	.	.
18637	6878	1	91	91	CD
18637	6878	2	,	,	,
18637	6878	3	94	94	CD
18637	6878	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6878	5	1816	1816	CD
18637	6878	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6878	7	.	.	.
18637	6879	1	The	the	DT
18637	6879	2	District	District	NNP
18637	6879	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	6879	4	been	be	VBN
18637	6879	5	held	hold	VBN
18637	6879	6	to	to	TO
18637	6879	7	be	be	VB
18637	6879	8	a	a	DT
18637	6879	9	"	"	``
18637	6879	10	State	state	NN
18637	6879	11	"	"	''
18637	6879	12	within	within	IN
18637	6879	13	the	the	DT
18637	6879	14	terms	term	NNS
18637	6879	15	of	of	IN
18637	6879	16	a	a	DT
18637	6879	17	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	6879	18	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	6879	19	the	the	DT
18637	6879	20	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	6879	21	of	of	IN
18637	6879	22	property	property	NN
18637	6879	23	within	within	IN
18637	6879	24	the	the	DT
18637	6879	25	"	"	``
18637	6879	26	States	States	NNP
18637	6879	27	of	of	IN
18637	6879	28	the	the	DT
18637	6879	29	Union	Union	NNP
18637	6879	30	.	.	.
18637	6879	31	"	"	''
18637	6880	1	De	De	NNP
18637	6880	2	Geofroy	Geofroy	NNP
18637	6880	3	_	_	NNP
18637	6880	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	6880	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6880	6	Riggs	Riggs	NNP
18637	6880	7	,	,	,
18637	6880	8	133	133	CD
18637	6880	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6880	10	258	258	CD
18637	6880	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6880	12	1890	1890	CD
18637	6880	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6880	14	.	.	.
18637	6881	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6881	2	1351	1351	CD
18637	6881	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6881	4	Barney	Barney	NNP
18637	6881	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6881	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6881	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6881	8	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	6881	9	,	,	,
18637	6881	10	6	6	CD
18637	6881	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6881	12	.	.	.
18637	6882	1	280	280	CD
18637	6882	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6882	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	6882	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6882	5	;	;	:
18637	6882	6	Hooe	Hooe	NNP
18637	6882	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6882	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6882	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6882	10	Jamieson	Jamieson	NNP
18637	6882	11	,	,	,
18637	6882	12	166	166	CD
18637	6882	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6882	14	395	395	CD
18637	6882	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6882	16	1897	1897	CD
18637	6882	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6882	18	;	;	:
18637	6882	19	Hooe	Hooe	NNP
18637	6882	20	_	_	NNP
18637	6882	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	6882	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6882	23	Werner	Werner	NNP
18637	6882	24	,	,	,
18637	6882	25	166	166	CD
18637	6882	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6882	27	399	399	CD
18637	6882	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6882	29	1897	1897	CD
18637	6882	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6882	31	.	.	.
18637	6883	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6883	2	1352	1352	CD
18637	6883	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6883	4	National	National	NNP
18637	6883	5	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	6883	6	.	.	.
18637	6884	1	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	6884	2	.	.	.
18637	6885	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6885	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6885	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6885	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6885	5	Tidewater	Tidewater	NNP
18637	6885	6	Transfer	Transfer	NNP
18637	6885	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6885	8	,	,	,
18637	6885	9	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	6885	10	,	,	,
18637	6885	11	337	337	CD
18637	6885	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6885	13	582	582	CD
18637	6885	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6885	15	1949	1949	CD
18637	6885	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6885	17	.	.	.
18637	6886	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6886	2	1353	1353	CD
18637	6886	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6886	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6886	5	.	.	.
18637	6887	1	588	588	CD
18637	6887	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6887	3	600	600	CD
18637	6887	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6887	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	6887	6	of	of	IN
18637	6887	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6887	8	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	6887	9	,	,	,
18637	6887	10	with	with	IN
18637	6887	11	whom	whom	WP
18637	6887	12	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	6887	13	Black	Black	NNP
18637	6887	14	and	and	CC
18637	6887	15	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	6887	16	concurred	concur	VBN
18637	6887	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6887	18	.	.	.
18637	6888	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6888	2	1354	1354	CD
18637	6888	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6888	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6888	5	.	.	.
18637	6889	1	604	604	CD
18637	6889	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6889	3	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	6889	4	of	of	IN
18637	6889	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6889	6	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	6889	7	,	,	,
18637	6889	8	with	with	IN
18637	6889	9	whom	whom	WP
18637	6889	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	6889	11	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	6889	12	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	6889	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6889	14	.	.	.
18637	6890	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6890	2	1355	1355	CD
18637	6890	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6890	4	Callan	Callan	NNP
18637	6890	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6890	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6890	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6890	8	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	6890	9	,	,	,
18637	6890	10	127	127	CD
18637	6890	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6890	12	540	540	CD
18637	6890	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6890	14	1888	1888	CD
18637	6890	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6890	16	;	;	:
18637	6890	17	Capital	Capital	NNP
18637	6890	18	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	6890	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6890	20	_	_	NNP
18637	6890	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	6890	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6890	23	Hof	Hof	NNP
18637	6890	24	,	,	,
18637	6890	25	174	174	CD
18637	6890	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6890	27	1	1	CD
18637	6890	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6890	29	1899	1899	CD
18637	6890	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6890	31	.	.	.
18637	6891	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6891	2	1356	1356	CD
18637	6891	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6891	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6891	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6891	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6891	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6891	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6891	9	Moreland	Moreland	NNP
18637	6891	10	,	,	,
18637	6891	11	258	258	CD
18637	6891	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6891	13	433	433	CD
18637	6891	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6891	15	1922	1922	CD
18637	6891	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6891	17	.	.	.
18637	6892	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6892	2	1357	1357	CD
18637	6892	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6892	4	Wight	Wight	NNP
18637	6892	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6892	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6892	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6892	8	Davidson	Davidson	NNP
18637	6892	9	,	,	,
18637	6892	10	181	181	CD
18637	6892	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6892	12	371	371	CD
18637	6892	13	,	,	,
18637	6892	14	384	384	CD
18637	6892	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6892	16	1901	1901	CD
18637	6892	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6892	18	;	;	:
18637	6892	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6892	20	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	6892	21	.	.	.
18637	6892	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6892	23	Adkins	Adkins	NNP
18637	6892	24	_	_	NNP
18637	6892	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	6892	26	_	_	NNP
18637	6892	27	Children	Children	NNP
18637	6892	28	's	's	POS
18637	6892	29	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	6892	30	,	,	,
18637	6892	31	261	261	CD
18637	6892	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6892	33	525	525	CD
18637	6892	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6892	35	1923	1923	CD
18637	6892	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6892	37	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	6892	38	by	by	IN
18637	6892	39	West	West	NNP
18637	6892	40	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	6892	41	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	6892	42	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6892	43	_	_	NNP
18637	6892	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	6892	45	_	_	NNP
18637	6892	46	Parrish	Parrish	NNP
18637	6892	47	,	,	,
18637	6892	48	300	300	CD
18637	6892	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6892	50	379	379	CD
18637	6892	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6892	52	1937	1937	CD
18637	6892	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6892	54	.	.	.
18637	6893	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6893	2	1358	1358	CD
18637	6893	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6893	4	Kendall	Kendall	NNP
18637	6893	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6893	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6893	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6893	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6893	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6893	10	ex	ex	NNP
18637	6893	11	rel	rel	NN
18637	6893	12	.	.	.
18637	6894	1	Stokes	stoke	NNS
18637	6894	2	,	,	,
18637	6894	3	12	12	CD
18637	6894	4	Pet	pet	NN
18637	6894	5	.	.	.
18637	6895	1	524	524	CD
18637	6895	2	,	,	,
18637	6895	3	619	619	CD
18637	6895	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6895	5	1838	1838	CD
18637	6895	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6895	7	;	;	:
18637	6895	8	Shoemaker	Shoemaker	NNP
18637	6895	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6895	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6895	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6895	12	United	United	NNP
18637	6895	13	States	States	NNP
18637	6895	14	,	,	,
18637	6895	15	147	147	CD
18637	6895	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6895	17	282	282	CD
18637	6895	18	,	,	,
18637	6895	19	300	300	CD
18637	6895	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6895	21	1893	1893	CD
18637	6895	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6895	23	;	;	:
18637	6895	24	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	6895	25	Cleaners	Cleaners	NNP
18637	6895	26	&	&	CC
18637	6895	27	Dyers	Dyers	NNPS
18637	6895	28	_	_	NNP
18637	6895	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	6895	30	_	_	NNP
18637	6895	31	United	United	NNP
18637	6895	32	States	States	NNP
18637	6895	33	,	,	,
18637	6895	34	286	286	CD
18637	6895	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6895	36	427	427	CD
18637	6895	37	,	,	,
18637	6895	38	435	435	CD
18637	6895	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6895	40	1932	1932	CD
18637	6895	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6895	42	;	;	:
18637	6895	43	O'Donoghue	O'Donoghue	NNP
18637	6895	44	_	_	NNP
18637	6895	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	6895	46	_	_	NNP
18637	6895	47	United	United	NNP
18637	6895	48	States	States	NNP
18637	6895	49	289	289	CD
18637	6895	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6895	51	516	516	CD
18637	6895	52	,	,	,
18637	6895	53	518	518	CD
18637	6895	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6895	55	1933	1933	CD
18637	6895	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6895	57	.	.	.
18637	6896	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6896	2	1359	1359	CD
18637	6896	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6896	4	6	6	CD
18637	6896	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6896	6	.	.	.
18637	6897	1	264	264	CD
18637	6897	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6897	3	1821	1821	CD
18637	6897	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6897	5	.	.	.
18637	6898	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6898	2	1360	1360	CD
18637	6898	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6898	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6898	5	.	.	.
18637	6899	1	428	428	CD
18637	6899	2	.	.	.
18637	6900	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6900	2	1361	1361	CD
18637	6900	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6900	4	Loughborough	Loughborough	NNP
18637	6900	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6900	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6900	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6900	8	Blake	Blake	NNP
18637	6900	9	,	,	,
18637	6900	10	5	5	CD
18637	6900	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6900	12	.	.	.
18637	6901	1	317	317	CD
18637	6901	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6901	3	1820	1820	CD
18637	6901	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6901	5	.	.	.
18637	6902	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6902	2	1362	1362	CD
18637	6902	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6902	4	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	6902	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6902	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6902	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6902	8	District	District	NNP
18637	6902	9	of	of	IN
18637	6902	10	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	6902	11	,	,	,
18637	6902	12	116	116	CD
18637	6902	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6902	14	404	404	CD
18637	6902	15	,	,	,
18637	6902	16	408	408	CD
18637	6902	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6902	18	1886	1886	CD
18637	6902	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6902	20	;	;	:
18637	6902	21	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	6902	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6902	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	6902	24	_	_	NNP
18637	6902	25	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	6902	26	,	,	,
18637	6902	27	97	97	CD
18637	6902	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6902	29	541	541	CD
18637	6902	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6902	31	1879	1879	CD
18637	6902	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6902	33	.	.	.
18637	6903	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6903	2	1363	1363	CD
18637	6903	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6903	4	Loughborough	Loughborough	NNP
18637	6903	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6903	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6903	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6903	8	Blake	Blake	NNP
18637	6903	9	,	,	,
18637	6903	10	5	5	CD
18637	6903	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6903	12	.	.	.
18637	6904	1	317	317	CD
18637	6904	2	,	,	,
18637	6904	3	320	320	CD
18637	6904	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6904	5	1820	1820	CD
18637	6904	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6904	7	;	;	:
18637	6904	8	Heald	Heald	NNP
18637	6904	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6904	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6904	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6904	12	District	District	NNP
18637	6904	13	of	of	IN
18637	6904	14	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	6904	15	,	,	,
18637	6904	16	259	259	CD
18637	6904	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6904	18	114	114	CD
18637	6904	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6904	20	1922	1922	CD
18637	6904	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6904	22	.	.	.
18637	6905	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6905	2	1364	1364	CD
18637	6905	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6905	4	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	6905	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6905	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6905	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6905	8	Roe	Roe	NNP
18637	6905	9	ex	ex	NNP
18637	6905	10	dem	dem	NNP
18637	6905	11	.	.	.
18637	6906	1	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	6906	2	,	,	,
18637	6906	3	22	22	CD
18637	6906	4	How	how	WRB
18637	6906	5	.	.	.
18637	6907	1	422	422	CD
18637	6907	2	,	,	,
18637	6907	3	435	435	CD
18637	6907	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6907	5	1860	1860	CD
18637	6907	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6907	7	;	;	:
18637	6907	8	Stoutenburgh	Stoutenburgh	NNP
18637	6907	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6907	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6907	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6907	12	Hennick	Hennick	NNP
18637	6907	13	,	,	,
18637	6907	14	129	129	CD
18637	6907	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6907	16	141	141	CD
18637	6907	17	,	,	,
18637	6907	18	147	147	CD
18637	6907	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6907	20	1889	1889	CD
18637	6907	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6907	22	.	.	.
18637	6908	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6908	2	1365	1365	CD
18637	6908	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6908	4	Willard	Willard	NNP
18637	6908	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6908	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6908	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6908	8	Presbury	Presbury	NNP
18637	6908	9	,	,	,
18637	6908	10	14	14	CD
18637	6908	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6908	12	.	.	.
18637	6909	1	676	676	CD
18637	6909	2	,	,	,
18637	6909	3	680	680	CD
18637	6909	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6909	5	1870	1870	CD
18637	6909	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6909	7	;	;	:
18637	6909	8	Briscoe	Briscoe	NNP
18637	6909	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6909	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6909	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6909	12	Rudolph	Rudolph	NNP
18637	6909	13	,	,	,
18637	6909	14	221	221	CD
18637	6909	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6909	16	547	547	CD
18637	6909	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6909	18	1911	1911	CD
18637	6909	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6909	20	.	.	.
18637	6910	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6910	2	1366	1366	CD
18637	6910	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6910	4	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	6910	5	Market	Market	NNP
18637	6910	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6910	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6910	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6910	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6910	10	District	District	NNP
18637	6910	11	of	of	IN
18637	6910	12	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	6910	13	,	,	,
18637	6910	14	172	172	CD
18637	6910	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6910	16	361	361	CD
18637	6910	17	,	,	,
18637	6910	18	367	367	CD
18637	6910	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6910	20	1899	1899	CD
18637	6910	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6910	22	.	.	.
18637	6911	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6911	2	1367	1367	CD
18637	6911	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6911	4	Mattingly	Mattingly	NNP
18637	6911	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6911	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6911	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6911	8	District	District	NNP
18637	6911	9	of	of	IN
18637	6911	10	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	6911	11	,	,	,
18637	6911	12	97	97	CD
18637	6911	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6911	14	687	687	CD
18637	6911	15	,	,	,
18637	6911	16	690	690	CD
18637	6911	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6911	18	1878	1878	CD
18637	6911	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6911	20	.	.	.
18637	6912	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6912	2	1368	1368	CD
18637	6912	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6912	4	129	129	CD
18637	6912	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6912	6	141	141	CD
18637	6912	7	,	,	,
18637	6912	8	148	148	CD
18637	6912	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6912	10	1889	1889	CD
18637	6912	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6912	12	.	.	.
18637	6913	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6913	2	1369	1369	CD
18637	6913	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6913	4	Keller	Keller	NNP
18637	6913	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6913	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6913	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6913	8	Potomac	Potomac	NNP
18637	6913	9	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	6913	10	Power	Power	NNP
18637	6913	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6913	12	,	,	,
18637	6913	13	261	261	CD
18637	6913	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6913	15	428	428	CD
18637	6913	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6913	17	1923	1923	CD
18637	6913	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6913	19	.	.	.
18637	6914	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6914	2	1370	1370	CD
18637	6914	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6914	4	O'Donoghue	O'Donoghue	NNP
18637	6914	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6914	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6914	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6914	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6914	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6914	10	,	,	,
18637	6914	11	289	289	CD
18637	6914	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6914	13	516	516	CD
18637	6914	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6914	15	1933	1933	CD
18637	6914	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6914	17	.	.	.
18637	6915	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6915	2	1371	1371	CD
18637	6915	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6915	4	Embry	Embry	NNP
18637	6915	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6915	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6915	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6915	8	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	6915	9	,	,	,
18637	6915	10	107	107	CD
18637	6915	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6915	12	3	3	CD
18637	6915	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6915	14	1883	1883	CD
18637	6915	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6915	16	.	.	.
18637	6916	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6916	2	1372	1372	CD
18637	6916	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6916	4	James	James	NNP
18637	6916	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6916	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6916	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6916	8	Dravo	Dravo	NNP
18637	6916	9	Contracting	Contracting	NNP
18637	6916	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6916	11	,	,	,
18637	6916	12	302	302	CD
18637	6916	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6916	14	134	134	CD
18637	6916	15	,	,	,
18637	6916	16	143	143	CD
18637	6916	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6916	18	1937	1937	CD
18637	6916	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6916	20	.	.	.
18637	6917	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6917	2	1373	1373	CD
18637	6917	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6917	4	Battle	Battle	NNP
18637	6917	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6917	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6917	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6917	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6917	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6917	10	,	,	,
18637	6917	11	209	209	CD
18637	6917	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6917	13	36	36	CD
18637	6917	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6917	15	1908	1908	CD
18637	6917	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6917	17	.	.	.
18637	6918	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6918	2	1374	1374	CD
18637	6918	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6918	4	Arlington	Arlington	NNP
18637	6918	5	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	6918	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6918	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6918	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6918	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6918	10	Fant	Fant	NNP
18637	6918	11	,	,	,
18637	6918	12	278	278	CD
18637	6918	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6918	14	439	439	CD
18637	6918	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6918	16	1929	1929	CD
18637	6918	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6918	18	.	.	.
18637	6919	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6919	2	1375	1375	CD
18637	6919	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6919	4	James	James	NNP
18637	6919	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6919	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6919	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6919	8	Dravo	Dravo	NNP
18637	6919	9	Contracting	Contracting	NNP
18637	6919	10	Co	Co	NNP
18637	6919	11	,	,	,
18637	6919	12	302	302	CD
18637	6919	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6919	14	134	134	CD
18637	6919	15	,	,	,
18637	6919	16	143	143	CD
18637	6919	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6919	18	1937	1937	CD
18637	6919	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6919	20	.	.	.
18637	6920	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6920	2	1376	1376	CD
18637	6920	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6920	4	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	6920	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6920	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6920	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6920	8	Yosemite	Yosemite	NNP
18637	6920	9	Park	Park	NNP
18637	6920	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6920	11	,	,	,
18637	6920	12	304	304	CD
18637	6920	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6920	14	518	518	CD
18637	6920	15	,	,	,
18637	6920	16	530	530	CD
18637	6920	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6920	18	1938	1938	CD
18637	6920	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6920	20	.	.	.
18637	6921	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6921	2	1377	1377	CD
18637	6921	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6921	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6921	5	.	.	.
18637	6922	1	528	528	CD
18637	6922	2	.	.	.
18637	6923	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6923	2	1378	1378	CD
18637	6923	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6923	4	Battle	Battle	NNP
18637	6923	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6923	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6923	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6923	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6923	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6923	10	,	,	,
18637	6923	11	209	209	CD
18637	6923	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6923	13	36	36	CD
18637	6923	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6923	15	1908	1908	CD
18637	6923	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6923	17	;	;	:
18637	6923	18	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	6923	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6923	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	6923	21	_	_	NNP
18637	6923	22	Yellow	Yellow	NNP
18637	6923	23	Cab	Cab	NNP
18637	6923	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6923	25	,	,	,
18637	6923	26	321	321	CD
18637	6923	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6923	28	383	383	CD
18637	6923	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6923	30	1944	1944	CD
18637	6923	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6923	32	;	;	:
18637	6923	33	Bowen	Bowen	NNP
18637	6923	34	_	_	NNP
18637	6923	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	6923	36	_	_	NNP
18637	6923	37	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	6923	38	,	,	,
18637	6923	39	306	306	CD
18637	6923	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6923	41	19	19	CD
18637	6923	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6923	43	1939	1939	CD
18637	6923	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6923	45	.	.	.
18637	6924	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6924	2	1379	1379	CD
18637	6924	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6924	4	Surplus	Surplus	NNP
18637	6924	5	Trading	Trading	NNP
18637	6924	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6924	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6924	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6924	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6924	10	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	6924	11	,	,	,
18637	6924	12	281	281	CD
18637	6924	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6924	14	647	647	CD
18637	6924	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6924	16	1930	1930	CD
18637	6924	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6924	18	.	.	.
18637	6925	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6925	2	1380	1380	CD
18637	6925	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6925	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	6925	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	6925	6	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	6925	7	.	.	.
18637	6926	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6926	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6926	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6926	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6926	5	Chiles	Chiles	NNP
18637	6926	6	,	,	,
18637	6926	7	214	214	CD
18637	6926	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6926	9	274	274	CD
18637	6926	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6926	11	1909	1909	CD
18637	6926	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6926	13	;	;	:
18637	6926	14	Arlington	Arlington	NNP
18637	6926	15	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	6926	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6926	17	_	_	NNP
18637	6926	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	6926	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6926	20	Fant	Fant	NNP
18637	6926	21	,	,	,
18637	6926	22	278	278	CD
18637	6926	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6926	24	439	439	CD
18637	6926	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6926	26	1929	1929	CD
18637	6926	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6926	28	;	;	:
18637	6926	29	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	6926	30	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	6926	31	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
18637	6926	32	_	_	NNP
18637	6926	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	6926	34	_	_	NNP
18637	6926	35	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	6926	36	.	.	.
18637	6927	1	of	of	IN
18637	6927	2	Agri	Agri	NNP
18637	6927	3	.	.	NNP
18637	6927	4	,	,	,
18637	6927	5	318	318	CD
18637	6927	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6927	7	285	285	CD
18637	6927	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6927	9	1943	1943	CD
18637	6927	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6927	11	.	.	.
18637	6928	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6928	2	1381	1381	CD
18637	6928	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6928	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	6928	5	,	,	,
18637	6928	6	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	6928	7	&	&	CC
18637	6928	8	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	6929	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6929	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6929	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6929	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6929	5	McGlinn	McGlinn	NNP
18637	6929	6	,	,	,
18637	6929	7	114	114	CD
18637	6929	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6929	9	542	542	CD
18637	6929	10	,	,	,
18637	6929	11	545	545	CD
18637	6929	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6929	13	1885	1885	CD
18637	6929	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6929	15	;	;	:
18637	6929	16	James	James	NNP
18637	6929	17	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	6929	18	&	&	CC
18637	6929	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6929	20	_	_	NNP
18637	6929	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	6929	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6929	23	Sadrakula	Sadrakula	NNP
18637	6929	24	,	,	,
18637	6929	25	309	309	CD
18637	6929	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6929	27	94	94	CD
18637	6929	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6929	29	1940	1940	CD
18637	6929	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6929	31	.	.	.
18637	6930	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6930	2	1382	1382	CD
18637	6930	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6930	4	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	6930	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6930	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6930	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6930	8	Barrett	Barrett	NNP
18637	6930	9	,	,	,
18637	6930	10	162	162	CD
18637	6930	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6930	12	399	399	CD
18637	6930	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6930	14	1896	1896	CD
18637	6930	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6930	16	.	.	.
18637	6931	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6931	2	1383	1383	CD
18637	6931	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6931	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6931	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6931	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6931	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6931	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6931	9	Unzeuta	Unzeuta	NNP
18637	6931	10	,	,	,
18637	6931	11	281	281	CD
18637	6931	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6931	13	138	138	CD
18637	6931	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6931	15	1930	1930	CD
18637	6931	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6931	17	.	.	.
18637	6932	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6932	2	1384	1384	CD
18637	6932	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6932	4	Benson	Benson	NNP
18637	6932	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6932	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6932	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6932	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6932	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6932	10	,	,	,
18637	6932	11	146	146	CD
18637	6932	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6932	13	325	325	CD
18637	6932	14	,	,	,
18637	6932	15	331	331	CD
18637	6932	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6932	17	1892	1892	CD
18637	6932	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6932	19	.	.	.
18637	6933	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6933	2	1385	1385	CD
18637	6933	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6933	4	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	6933	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6933	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6933	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6933	8	Barrett	Barrett	NNP
18637	6933	9	,	,	,
18637	6933	10	162	162	CD
18637	6933	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6933	12	399	399	CD
18637	6933	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6933	14	1896	1896	CD
18637	6933	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6933	16	.	.	.
18637	6934	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6934	2	1386	1386	CD
18637	6934	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6934	4	S.R.A.	S.R.A.	NNP
18637	6934	5	,	,	,
18637	6934	6	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	6934	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6934	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6934	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6934	10	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	6934	11	,	,	,
18637	6934	12	327	327	CD
18637	6934	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6934	14	558	558	CD
18637	6934	15	,	,	,
18637	6934	16	564	564	CD
18637	6934	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6934	18	1946	1946	CD
18637	6934	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6934	20	.	.	.
18637	6935	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6935	2	1387	1387	CD
18637	6935	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6935	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6935	5	.	.	.
18637	6936	1	570	570	CD
18637	6936	2	,	,	,
18637	6936	3	571	571	CD
18637	6936	4	.	.	.
18637	6937	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6937	2	1388	1388	CD
18637	6937	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6937	4	Fort	Fort	NNP
18637	6937	5	Leavenworth	Leavenworth	NNP
18637	6937	6	R.	R.	NNP
18637	6937	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6937	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6937	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	6937	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6937	11	Lowe	Lowe	NNP
18637	6937	12	,	,	,
18637	6937	13	114	114	CD
18637	6937	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6937	15	525	525	CD
18637	6937	16	,	,	,
18637	6937	17	532	532	CD
18637	6937	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6937	19	1885	1885	CD
18637	6937	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6937	21	;	;	:
18637	6937	22	United	United	NNP
18637	6937	23	States	States	NNP
18637	6937	24	_	_	NNP
18637	6937	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	6937	26	_	_	NNP
18637	6937	27	Unzeuta	Unzeuta	NNP
18637	6937	28	,	,	,
18637	6937	29	281	281	CD
18637	6937	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6937	31	138	138	CD
18637	6937	32	,	,	,
18637	6937	33	142	142	CD
18637	6937	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6937	35	1930	1930	CD
18637	6937	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6937	37	;	;	:
18637	6937	38	Surplus	Surplus	NNP
18637	6937	39	Trading	Trading	NNP
18637	6937	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6937	41	_	_	NNP
18637	6937	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	6937	43	_	_	NNP
18637	6937	44	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	6937	45	,	,	,
18637	6937	46	281	281	CD
18637	6937	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6937	48	647	647	CD
18637	6937	49	,	,	,
18637	6937	50	652	652	CD
18637	6937	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6937	52	1930	1930	CD
18637	6937	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6937	54	.	.	.
18637	6938	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6938	2	1389	1389	CD
18637	6938	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6938	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6938	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6938	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6938	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6938	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6938	9	Cornell	Cornell	NNP
18637	6938	10	,	,	,
18637	6938	11	25	25	CD
18637	6938	12	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	6938	13	.	.	.
18637	6939	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	6939	2	.	.	.
18637	6940	1	No	no	UH
18637	6940	2	.	.	.
18637	6941	1	14,867	14,867	CD
18637	6941	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6941	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	6941	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6941	5	.	.	.
18637	6942	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6942	2	1390	1390	CD
18637	6942	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6942	4	James	James	NNP
18637	6942	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6942	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6942	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6942	8	Dravo	Dravo	NNP
18637	6942	9	Contracting	Contracting	NNP
18637	6942	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6942	11	,	,	,
18637	6942	12	302	302	CD
18637	6942	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6942	14	134	134	CD
18637	6942	15	,	,	,
18637	6942	16	145	145	CD
18637	6942	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6942	18	1937	1937	CD
18637	6942	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6942	20	.	.	.
18637	6943	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6943	2	1391	1391	CD
18637	6943	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6943	4	Silas	Silas	NNP
18637	6943	5	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	6943	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6943	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6943	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	6943	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6943	10	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	6943	11	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	6943	12	of	of	IN
18637	6943	13	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	6943	14	,	,	,
18637	6943	15	302	302	CD
18637	6943	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6943	17	186	186	CD
18637	6943	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6943	19	1937	1937	CD
18637	6943	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6943	21	.	.	.
18637	6944	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6944	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6944	3	also	also	RB
18637	6944	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6944	5	Atkinson	Atkinson	NNP
18637	6944	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6944	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6944	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6944	9	State	State	NNP
18637	6944	10	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	6944	11	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	6944	12	,	,	,
18637	6944	13	303	303	CD
18637	6944	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6944	15	20	20	CD
18637	6944	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6944	17	1938	1938	CD
18637	6944	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6944	19	.	.	.
18637	6945	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6945	2	1392	1392	CD
18637	6945	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6945	4	4	4	CD
18637	6945	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6945	6	.	.	.
18637	6946	1	316	316	CD
18637	6946	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6946	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	6946	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6946	5	.	.	.
18637	6947	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6947	2	1393	1393	CD
18637	6947	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6947	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	6947	5	.	.	.
18637	6948	1	420	420	CD
18637	6948	2	.	.	.
18637	6949	1	This	this	DT
18637	6949	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	6949	3	had	have	VBD
18637	6949	4	been	be	VBN
18637	6949	5	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	6949	6	foreshadowed	foreshadow	VBN
18637	6949	7	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	6949	8	years	year	NNS
18637	6949	9	earlier	early	RBR
18637	6949	10	by	by	IN
18637	6949	11	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	6949	12	's	's	POS
18637	6949	13	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	6949	14	in	in	IN
18637	6949	15	United	United	NNP
18637	6949	16	States	States	NNP
18637	6949	17	_	_	NNP
18637	6949	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	6949	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6949	20	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	6949	21	,	,	,
18637	6949	22	2	2	CD
18637	6949	23	Cr	cr	NN
18637	6949	24	.	.	.
18637	6950	1	358	358	CD
18637	6950	2	,	,	,
18637	6950	3	396	396	CD
18637	6950	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6950	5	1805	1805	CD
18637	6950	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6950	7	.	.	.
18637	6951	1	Upholding	uphold	VBG
18637	6951	2	an	an	DT
18637	6951	3	act	act	NN
18637	6951	4	which	which	WDT
18637	6951	5	gave	give	VBD
18637	6951	6	priority	priority	NN
18637	6951	7	to	to	IN
18637	6951	8	claims	claim	NNS
18637	6951	9	of	of	IN
18637	6951	10	the	the	DT
18637	6951	11	United	United	NNP
18637	6951	12	States	States	NNP
18637	6951	13	against	against	IN
18637	6951	14	the	the	DT
18637	6951	15	estate	estate	NN
18637	6951	16	of	of	IN
18637	6951	17	a	a	DT
18637	6951	18	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
18637	6951	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6951	20	wrote	write	VBD
18637	6951	21	:	:	:
18637	6951	22	"	"	``
18637	6951	23	The	the	DT
18637	6951	24	government	government	NN
18637	6951	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	6951	26	to	to	TO
18637	6951	27	pay	pay	VB
18637	6951	28	the	the	DT
18637	6951	29	debt	debt	NN
18637	6951	30	of	of	IN
18637	6951	31	the	the	DT
18637	6951	32	Union	Union	NNP
18637	6951	33	,	,	,
18637	6951	34	and	and	CC
18637	6951	35	must	must	MD
18637	6951	36	be	be	VB
18637	6951	37	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	6951	38	to	to	TO
18637	6951	39	use	use	VB
18637	6951	40	the	the	DT
18637	6951	41	means	mean	NNS
18637	6951	42	which	which	WDT
18637	6951	43	appear	appear	VBP
18637	6951	44	to	to	IN
18637	6951	45	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6951	46	most	most	RBS
18637	6951	47	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	6951	48	to	to	TO
18637	6951	49	effect	effect	VB
18637	6951	50	that	that	DT
18637	6951	51	object	object	NN
18637	6951	52	.	.	.
18637	6952	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	6952	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	6952	3	,	,	,
18637	6952	4	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	6952	5	,	,	,
18637	6952	6	a	a	DT
18637	6952	7	right	right	NN
18637	6952	8	to	to	TO
18637	6952	9	make	make	VB
18637	6952	10	remittances	remittance	NNS
18637	6952	11	,	,	,
18637	6952	12	by	by	IN
18637	6952	13	bills	bill	NNS
18637	6952	14	or	or	CC
18637	6952	15	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	6952	16	,	,	,
18637	6952	17	and	and	CC
18637	6952	18	to	to	TO
18637	6952	19	take	take	VB
18637	6952	20	those	those	DT
18637	6952	21	precautions	precaution	NNS
18637	6952	22	which	which	WDT
18637	6952	23	will	will	MD
18637	6952	24	render	render	VB
18637	6952	25	the	the	DT
18637	6952	26	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	6952	27	safe	safe	JJ
18637	6952	28	.	.	.
18637	6952	29	"	"	''
18637	6953	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6953	2	1394	1394	CD
18637	6953	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6953	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6953	5	See	See	NNP
18637	6953	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6953	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	6953	8	.	.	.
18637	6954	1	74	74	CD
18637	6954	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6954	3	82	82	CD
18637	6954	4	,	,	,
18637	6954	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6954	6	supra	supra	NNP
18637	6954	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6954	8	.	.	.
18637	6955	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6955	2	1395	1395	CD
18637	6955	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6955	4	Neely	neely	RB
18637	6955	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6955	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6955	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6955	8	Henkel	Henkel	NNP
18637	6955	9	,	,	,
18637	6955	10	180	180	CD
18637	6955	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6955	12	109	109	CD
18637	6955	13	,	,	,
18637	6955	14	121	121	CD
18637	6955	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6955	16	1901	1901	CD
18637	6955	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6955	18	.	.	.
18637	6956	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6956	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6956	3	also	also	RB
18637	6956	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6956	5	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	6956	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6956	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6956	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6956	9	Holland	Holland	NNP
18637	6956	10	,	,	,
18637	6956	11	252	252	CD
18637	6956	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6956	13	416	416	CD
18637	6956	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6956	15	1920	1920	CD
18637	6956	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6956	17	.	.	.
18637	6957	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6957	2	1396	1396	CD
18637	6957	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6957	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6957	5	See	See	NNP
18637	6957	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6957	7	p.	p.	NN
18637	6957	8	426	426	CD
18637	6957	9	,	,	,
18637	6957	10	_	_	NNP
18637	6957	11	supra	supra	NNP
18637	6957	12	_	_	NNP
18637	6957	13	.	.	.
18637	6958	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6958	2	1397	1397	CD
18637	6958	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6958	4	Den	Den	NNP
18637	6958	5	ex	ex	NNP
18637	6958	6	dem	dem	NNP
18637	6958	7	.	.	.
18637	6959	1	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	6959	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6959	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6959	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6959	5	Hoboken	Hoboken	NNP
18637	6959	6	Land	Land	NNP
18637	6959	7	&	&	CC
18637	6959	8	Improvement	Improvement	NNP
18637	6959	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6959	10	,	,	,
18637	6959	11	18	18	CD
18637	6959	12	How	how	WRB
18637	6959	13	.	.	.
18637	6960	1	272	272	CD
18637	6960	2	,	,	,
18637	6960	3	281	281	CD
18637	6960	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6960	5	1856	1856	CD
18637	6960	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6960	7	.	.	.
18637	6961	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6961	2	1398	1398	CD
18637	6961	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6961	4	Kohl	Kohl	NNP
18637	6961	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6961	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6961	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6961	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6961	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6961	10	,	,	,
18637	6961	11	91	91	CD
18637	6961	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6961	13	367	367	CD
18637	6961	14	,	,	,
18637	6961	15	373	373	CD
18637	6961	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6961	17	1876	1876	CD
18637	6961	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6961	19	;	;	:
18637	6961	20	United	United	NNP
18637	6961	21	Slates	Slates	NNP
18637	6961	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6961	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	6961	24	_	_	NNP
18637	6961	25	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	6961	26	,	,	,
18637	6961	27	94	94	CD
18637	6961	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6961	29	315	315	CD
18637	6961	30	,	,	,
18637	6961	31	320	320	CD
18637	6961	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6961	33	1877	1877	CD
18637	6961	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6961	35	.	.	.
18637	6962	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6962	2	1399	1399	CD
18637	6962	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6962	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6962	5	See	See	NNP
18637	6962	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6962	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	6962	8	.	.	.
18637	6963	1	110	110	CD
18637	6963	2	-	-	SYM
18637	6963	3	117	117	CD
18637	6963	4	,	,	,
18637	6963	5	266	266	CD
18637	6963	6	-	-	SYM
18637	6963	7	267	267	CD
18637	6963	8	.	.	.
18637	6964	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6964	2	1400	1400	CD
18637	6964	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6964	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6964	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6964	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6964	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6964	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6964	9	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	6964	10	,	,	,
18637	6964	11	95	95	CD
18637	6964	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6964	13	670	670	CD
18637	6964	14	,	,	,
18637	6964	15	672	672	CD
18637	6964	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6964	17	1878	1878	CD
18637	6964	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6964	19	;	;	:
18637	6964	20	United	United	NNP
18637	6964	21	States	States	NNP
18637	6964	22	_	_	NNP
18637	6964	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	6964	24	_	_	NNP
18637	6964	25	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	6964	26	,	,	,
18637	6964	27	98	98	CD
18637	6964	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6964	29	343	343	CD
18637	6964	30	,	,	,
18637	6964	31	357	357	CD
18637	6964	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6964	33	1879	1879	CD
18637	6964	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6964	35	;	;	:
18637	6964	36	United	United	NNP
18637	6964	37	States	States	NNP
18637	6964	38	_	_	NNP
18637	6964	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	6964	40	_	_	NNP
18637	6964	41	Worrall	Worrall	NNP
18637	6964	42	,	,	,
18637	6964	43	2	2	CD
18637	6964	44	Dall	dall	NN
18637	6964	45	.	.	.
18637	6965	1	384	384	CD
18637	6965	2	,	,	,
18637	6965	3	394	394	CD
18637	6965	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6965	5	1790	1790	CD
18637	6965	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6965	7	;	;	:
18637	6965	8	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	6965	9	_	_	NNP
18637	6965	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	6965	11	_	_	NNP
18637	6965	12	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	6965	13	,	,	,
18637	6965	14	4	4	CD
18637	6965	15	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6965	16	.	.	.
18637	6966	1	316	316	CD
18637	6966	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6966	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	6966	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6966	5	.	.	.
18637	6967	1	That	that	IN
18637	6967	2	this	this	DT
18637	6967	3	power	power	NN
18637	6967	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	6967	5	been	be	VBN
18637	6967	6	freely	freely	RB
18637	6967	7	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	6967	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	6967	9	attested	attest	VBN
18637	6967	10	by	by	IN
18637	6967	11	the	the	DT
18637	6967	12	180	180	CD
18637	6967	13	pages	page	NNS
18637	6967	14	of	of	IN
18637	6967	15	the	the	DT
18637	6967	16	United	United	NNP
18637	6967	17	States	States	NNP
18637	6967	18	Code	Code	NNP
18637	6967	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6967	20	1950	1950	CD
18637	6967	21	ed	ed	NNP
18637	6967	22	.	.	.
18637	6967	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6968	1	devoted	devoted	JJ
18637	6968	2	to	to	IN
18637	6968	3	Title	Title	NNP
18637	6968	4	18	18	CD
18637	6968	5	,	,	,
18637	6968	6	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	6968	7	"	"	``
18637	6968	8	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
18637	6968	9	Code	Code	NNP
18637	6968	10	and	and	CC
18637	6968	11	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
18637	6968	12	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	6968	13	.	.	.
18637	6968	14	"	"	''
18637	6969	1	In	in	IN
18637	6969	2	addition	addition	NN
18637	6969	3	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	6969	4	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	6969	5	measures	measure	NNS
18637	6969	6	prescribe	prescribe	VBP
18637	6969	7	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	6969	8	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	6969	9	for	for	IN
18637	6969	10	infractions	infraction	NNS
18637	6969	11	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	6969	12	.	.	.
18637	6970	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6970	2	1401	1401	CD
18637	6970	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6970	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	6970	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	6970	6	Carll	Carll	NNP
18637	6970	7	,	,	,
18637	6970	8	106	106	CD
18637	6970	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6970	10	521	521	CD
18637	6970	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6970	12	1883	1883	CD
18637	6970	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6970	14	.	.	.
18637	6971	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6971	2	1402	1402	CD
18637	6971	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6971	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6971	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6971	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6971	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6971	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6971	9	Marigold	Marigold	NNP
18637	6971	10	,	,	,
18637	6971	11	9	9	CD
18637	6971	12	How	how	WRB
18637	6971	13	.	.	.
18637	6972	1	560	560	CD
18637	6972	2	,	,	,
18637	6972	3	567	567	CD
18637	6972	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6972	5	1850	1850	CD
18637	6972	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6972	7	.	.	.
18637	6973	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6973	2	1403	1403	CD
18637	6973	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6973	4	Logan	Logan	NNP
18637	6973	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6973	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6973	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6973	8	United	United	NNP
18637	6973	9	States	States	NNP
18637	6973	10	,	,	,
18637	6973	11	144	144	CD
18637	6973	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6973	13	263	263	CD
18637	6973	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6973	15	1892	1892	CD
18637	6973	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6973	17	.	.	.
18637	6974	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6974	2	1404	1404	CD
18637	6974	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6974	4	United	United	NNP
18637	6974	5	States	States	NNP
18637	6974	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6974	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6974	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6974	9	Barnow	Barnow	NNP
18637	6974	10	,	,	,
18637	6974	11	239	239	CD
18637	6974	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6974	13	74	74	CD
18637	6974	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6974	15	1915	1915	CD
18637	6974	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6974	17	.	.	.
18637	6975	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6975	2	1405	1405	CD
18637	6975	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6975	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	6975	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	6975	6	Yarbrough	Yarbrough	NNP
18637	6975	7	,	,	,
18637	6975	8	110	110	CD
18637	6975	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6975	10	651	651	CD
18637	6975	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6975	12	1884	1884	CD
18637	6975	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6975	14	;	;	:
18637	6975	15	United	United	NNP
18637	6975	16	States	States	NNP
18637	6975	17	_	_	NNP
18637	6975	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	6975	19	_	_	NNP
18637	6975	20	Waddell	Waddell	NNP
18637	6975	21	,	,	,
18637	6975	22	112	112	CD
18637	6975	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6975	24	76	76	CD
18637	6975	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6975	26	1884	1884	CD
18637	6975	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6975	28	;	;	:
18637	6975	29	In	in	IN
18637	6975	30	re	re	JJ
18637	6975	31	Quarles	Quarles	NNP
18637	6975	32	,	,	,
18637	6975	33	158	158	CD
18637	6975	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6975	35	532	532	CD
18637	6975	36	,	,	,
18637	6975	37	537	537	CD
18637	6975	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6975	39	1895	1895	CD
18637	6975	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6975	41	;	;	:
18637	6975	42	Motes	Motes	NNP
18637	6975	43	_	_	NNP
18637	6975	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	6975	45	_	_	NNP
18637	6975	46	United	United	NNP
18637	6975	47	States	States	NNP
18637	6975	48	,	,	,
18637	6975	49	178	178	CD
18637	6975	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6975	51	458	458	CD
18637	6975	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6975	53	1900	1900	CD
18637	6975	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6975	55	;	;	:
18637	6975	56	United	United	NNP
18637	6975	57	States	States	NNP
18637	6975	58	_	_	NNP
18637	6975	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	6975	60	_	_	NNP
18637	6975	61	Mosley	Mosley	NNP
18637	6975	62	,	,	,
18637	6975	63	238	238	CD
18637	6975	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6975	65	383	383	CD
18637	6975	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6975	67	1915	1915	CD
18637	6975	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6975	69	.	.	.
18637	6976	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6976	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6976	3	also	also	RB
18637	6976	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6976	5	Rakes	Rakes	NNP
18637	6976	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6976	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6976	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6976	9	United	United	NNP
18637	6976	10	States	States	NNP
18637	6976	11	,	,	,
18637	6976	12	212	212	CD
18637	6976	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6976	14	55	55	CD
18637	6976	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6976	16	1909	1909	CD
18637	6976	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6976	18	.	.	.
18637	6977	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6977	2	1406	1406	CD
18637	6977	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6977	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	6977	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	6977	6	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	6977	7	,	,	,
18637	6977	8	106	106	CD
18637	6977	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6977	10	371	371	CD
18637	6977	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6977	12	1882	1882	CD
18637	6977	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6977	14	.	.	.
18637	6978	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6978	2	1407	1407	CD
18637	6978	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6978	4	The	the	DT
18637	6978	5	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	6978	6	Registration	Registration	NNP
18637	6978	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	6978	8	of	of	IN
18637	6978	9	1940	1940	CD
18637	6978	10	,	,	,
18637	6978	11	54	54	CD
18637	6978	12	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	6978	13	.	.	.
18637	6979	1	670	670	CD
18637	6979	2	,	,	,
18637	6979	3	18	18	CD
18637	6979	4	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	6980	1	§	§	NNP
18637	6980	2	2385	2385	CD
18637	6980	3	.	.	.
18637	6981	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6981	2	1408	1408	CD
18637	6981	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6981	4	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	6981	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6981	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6981	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6981	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	6981	9	,	,	,
18637	6981	10	4	4	CD
18637	6981	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6981	12	.	.	.
18637	6982	1	316	316	CD
18637	6982	2	,	,	,
18637	6982	3	407	407	CD
18637	6982	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6982	5	1819	1819	CD
18637	6982	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6982	7	.	.	.
18637	6983	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6983	2	1409	1409	CD
18637	6983	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6983	4	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	6983	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6983	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6983	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6983	8	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6983	9	of	of	IN
18637	6983	10	the	the	DT
18637	6983	11	United	United	NNP
18637	6983	12	States	States	NNP
18637	6983	13	,	,	,
18637	6983	14	9	9	CD
18637	6983	15	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	6983	16	.	.	.
18637	6984	1	738	738	CD
18637	6984	2	,	,	,
18637	6984	3	862	862	CD
18637	6984	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6984	5	1824	1824	CD
18637	6984	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6984	7	.	.	.
18637	6985	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6985	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6985	3	also	also	RB
18637	6985	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6985	5	Pittman	Pittman	NNP
18637	6985	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6985	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6985	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6985	9	Home	Home	NNP
18637	6985	10	Owners	Owners	NNP
18637	6985	11	'	'	POS
18637	6985	12	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	6985	13	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	6985	14	,	,	,
18637	6985	15	308	308	CD
18637	6985	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6985	17	21	21	CD
18637	6985	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6985	19	1939	1939	CD
18637	6985	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6985	21	.	.	.
18637	6986	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6986	2	1410	1410	CD
18637	6986	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6986	4	First	First	NNP
18637	6986	5	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	6986	6	.	.	.
18637	6987	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6987	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6987	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6987	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6987	5	Fellows	Fellows	NNP
18637	6987	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	6987	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	6987	8	.	.	.
18637	6988	1	Union	Union	NNP
18637	6988	2	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	6988	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6988	4	,	,	,
18637	6988	5	244	244	CD
18637	6988	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6988	7	416	416	CD
18637	6988	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6988	9	1917	1917	CD
18637	6988	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6988	11	;	;	:
18637	6988	12	Burnes	Burnes	NNPS
18637	6988	13	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	6988	14	.	.	.
18637	6989	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6989	2	_	_	NNP
18637	6989	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	6989	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6989	5	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	6989	6	,	,	,
18637	6989	7	265	265	CD
18637	6989	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6989	9	17	17	CD
18637	6989	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6989	11	1924	1924	CD
18637	6989	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6989	13	.	.	.
18637	6990	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6990	2	1411	1411	CD
18637	6990	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6990	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	6990	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6990	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6990	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6990	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	6990	9	City	City	NNP
18637	6990	10	Title	Title	NNP
18637	6990	11	and	and	CC
18637	6990	12	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	6990	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6990	14	,	,	,
18637	6990	15	255	255	CD
18637	6990	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6990	17	180	180	CD
18637	6990	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6990	19	1921	1921	CD
18637	6990	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6990	21	.	.	.
18637	6991	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6991	2	1412	1412	CD
18637	6991	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6991	4	Juilliard	Juilliard	NNP
18637	6991	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6991	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6991	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6991	8	Greenman	Greenman	NNP
18637	6991	9	,	,	,
18637	6991	10	110	110	CD
18637	6991	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6991	12	421	421	CD
18637	6991	13	,	,	,
18637	6991	14	449	449	CD
18637	6991	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6991	16	1884	1884	CD
18637	6991	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6991	18	.	.	.
18637	6992	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6992	2	1413	1413	CD
18637	6992	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6992	4	Veazie	Veazie	NNP
18637	6992	5	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	6992	6	_	_	NNP
18637	6992	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	6992	8	_	_	NNP
18637	6992	9	Fenno	Fenno	NNP
18637	6992	10	,	,	,
18637	6992	11	8	8	CD
18637	6992	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6992	13	.	.	.
18637	6993	1	533	533	CD
18637	6993	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6993	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	6993	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6993	5	.	.	.
18637	6994	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6994	2	1414	1414	CD
18637	6994	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6994	4	Juilliard	Juilliard	NNP
18637	6994	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6994	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6994	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6994	8	Greenman	Greenman	NNP
18637	6994	9	,	,	,
18637	6994	10	110	110	CD
18637	6994	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6994	12	421	421	CD
18637	6994	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6994	14	1884	1884	CD
18637	6994	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6994	16	.	.	.
18637	6995	1	_	_	NNP
18637	6995	2	See	See	NNP
18637	6995	3	also	also	RB
18637	6995	4	_	_	NNP
18637	6995	5	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	6995	6	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	6995	7	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	6995	8	,	,	,
18637	6995	9	12	12	CD
18637	6995	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	6995	11	.	.	.
18637	6996	1	457	457	CD
18637	6996	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6996	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	6996	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6996	5	.	.	.
18637	6997	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6997	2	1415	1415	CD
18637	6997	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6997	4	Norman	Norman	NNP
18637	6997	5	_	_	NNP
18637	6997	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	6997	7	_	_	NNP
18637	6997	8	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	6997	9	&	&	CC
18637	6997	10	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	6998	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	6998	2	,	,	,
18637	6998	3	294	294	CD
18637	6998	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	6998	5	240	240	CD
18637	6998	6	,	,	,
18637	6998	7	303	303	CD
18637	6998	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6998	9	1935	1935	CD
18637	6998	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	6998	11	.	.	.
18637	6999	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	6999	2	1416	1416	CD
18637	6999	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	6999	4	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	6999	5	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	6999	6	Removal	Removal	NNP
18637	6999	7	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	6999	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	6999	9	Union	Union	NNP
18637	6999	10	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	7000	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7000	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7000	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7000	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7000	5	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	7000	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7000	7	,	,	,
18637	7000	8	115	115	CD
18637	7000	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7000	10	1	1	CD
18637	7000	11	,	,	,
18637	7000	12	18	18	CD
18637	7000	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7000	14	1885	1885	CD
18637	7000	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7000	16	;	;	:
18637	7000	17	California	California	NNP
18637	7000	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7000	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	7000	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7000	21	Central	Central	NNP
18637	7000	22	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	7001	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7001	2	,	,	,
18637	7001	3	127	127	CD
18637	7001	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7001	5	1	1	CD
18637	7001	6	,	,	,
18637	7001	7	39	39	CD
18637	7001	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7001	9	1888	1888	CD
18637	7001	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7001	11	.	.	.
18637	7002	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7002	2	1417	1417	CD
18637	7002	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7002	4	Luxton	Luxton	NNP
18637	7002	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7002	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7002	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7002	8	North	North	NNP
18637	7002	9	River	River	NNP
18637	7002	10	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	7002	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7002	12	,	,	,
18637	7002	13	153	153	CD
18637	7002	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7002	15	525	525	CD
18637	7002	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7002	17	1894	1894	CD
18637	7002	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7002	19	.	.	.
18637	7003	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7003	2	1418	1418	CD
18637	7003	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7003	4	Clallam	Clallam	NNP
18637	7003	5	County	County	NNP
18637	7003	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7003	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7003	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7003	9	United	United	NNP
18637	7003	10	States	States	NNP
18637	7003	11	,	,	,
18637	7003	12	263	263	CD
18637	7003	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7003	14	341	341	CD
18637	7003	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7003	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	7003	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7003	18	.	.	.
18637	7004	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7004	2	1419	1419	CD
18637	7004	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7004	4	Sloan	Sloan	NNP
18637	7004	5	Shipyards	Shipyards	NNP
18637	7004	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7004	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7004	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7004	9	United	United	NNP
18637	7004	10	States	States	NNP
18637	7004	11	Fleet	Fleet	NNP
18637	7004	12	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	7004	13	,	,	,
18637	7004	14	258	258	CD
18637	7004	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7004	16	549	549	CD
18637	7004	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7004	18	1922	1922	CD
18637	7004	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7004	20	.	.	.
18637	7005	1	In	in	IN
18637	7005	2	1944	1944	CD
18637	7005	3	,	,	,
18637	7005	4	the	the	DT
18637	7005	5	Congressional	Congressional	NNP
18637	7005	6	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	7005	7	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	7005	8	on	on	IN
18637	7005	9	Nonessential	Nonessential	NNP
18637	7005	10	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	7005	11	Expenditures	Expenditures	NNPS
18637	7005	12	reported	report	VBD
18637	7005	13	that	that	IN
18637	7005	14	there	there	EX
18637	7005	15	were	be	VBD
18637	7005	16	then	then	RB
18637	7005	17	in	in	IN
18637	7005	18	existence	existence	NN
18637	7005	19	one	one	CD
18637	7005	20	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	7005	21	government	government	NN
18637	7005	22	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	7005	23	,	,	,
18637	7005	24	including	include	VBG
18637	7005	25	subsidiaries	subsidiary	NNS
18637	7005	26	and	and	CC
18637	7005	27	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	7005	28	-	-	JJ
18637	7005	29	private	private	JJ
18637	7005	30	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	7005	31	in	in	IN
18637	7005	32	which	which	WDT
18637	7005	33	the	the	DT
18637	7005	34	Government	Government	NNP
18637	7005	35	had	have	VBD
18637	7005	36	some	some	DT
18637	7005	37	special	special	JJ
18637	7005	38	contractual	contractual	JJ
18637	7005	39	or	or	CC
18637	7005	40	proprietary	proprietary	JJ
18637	7005	41	interest	interest	NN
18637	7005	42	.	.	.
18637	7006	1	S.	S.	NNP
18637	7006	2	Doc	Doc	NNP
18637	7006	3	.	.	.
18637	7007	1	No	no	UH
18637	7007	2	.	.	.
18637	7008	1	227	227	CD
18637	7008	2	,	,	,
18637	7008	3	78th	78th	NNP
18637	7008	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	7008	5	.	.	NNP
18637	7008	6	,	,	,
18637	7008	7	2d	2d	CD
18637	7008	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	7008	9	.	.	.
18637	7009	1	2	2	CD
18637	7009	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7009	3	1944	1944	CD
18637	7009	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7009	5	.	.	.
18637	7010	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7010	2	1420	1420	CD
18637	7010	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7010	4	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	7010	5	Island	Island	NNP
18637	7010	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7010	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7010	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7010	9	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	7010	10	,	,	,
18637	7010	11	12	12	CD
18637	7010	12	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7010	13	.	.	.
18637	7011	1	657	657	CD
18637	7011	2	,	,	,
18637	7011	3	721	721	CD
18637	7011	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7011	5	1838	1838	CD
18637	7011	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7011	7	.	.	.
18637	7012	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7012	2	1421	1421	CD
18637	7012	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7012	4	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	7012	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7012	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7012	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7012	8	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	7012	9	,	,	,
18637	7012	10	100	100	CD
18637	7012	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7012	12	257	257	CD
18637	7012	13	,	,	,
18637	7012	14	263	263	CD
18637	7012	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7012	16	1880	1880	CD
18637	7012	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7012	18	.	.	.
18637	7013	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7013	2	1422	1422	CD
18637	7013	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7013	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	7013	5	&	&	CC
18637	7013	6	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	7013	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7013	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7013	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7013	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7013	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7013	12	Whitton	Whitton	NNP
18637	7013	13	,	,	,
18637	7013	14	13	13	CD
18637	7013	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7013	16	.	.	.
18637	7014	1	270	270	CD
18637	7014	2	,	,	,
18637	7014	3	287	287	CD
18637	7014	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7014	5	1872	1872	CD
18637	7014	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7014	7	.	.	.
18637	7015	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7015	2	1423	1423	CD
18637	7015	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7015	4	Embry	Embry	NNP
18637	7015	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7015	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7015	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7015	8	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	7015	9	,	,	,
18637	7015	10	107	107	CD
18637	7015	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7015	12	3	3	CD
18637	7015	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7015	14	1883	1883	CD
18637	7015	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7015	16	.	.	.
18637	7016	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7016	2	1424	1424	CD
18637	7016	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7016	4	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7016	5	of	of	IN
18637	7016	6	United	United	NNP
18637	7016	7	States	States	NNP
18637	7016	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7016	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7016	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7016	11	Halstead	Halstead	NNP
18637	7016	12	,	,	,
18637	7016	13	10	10	CD
18637	7016	14	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7016	15	.	.	.
18637	7017	1	51	51	CD
18637	7017	2	,	,	,
18637	7017	3	53	53	CD
18637	7017	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7017	5	1825	1825	CD
18637	7017	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7017	7	.	.	.
18637	7018	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7018	2	1425	1425	CD
18637	7018	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7018	4	United	United	NNP
18637	7018	5	States	States	NNP
18637	7018	6	Exp	Exp	NNP
18637	7018	7	.	.	.
18637	7019	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7019	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7019	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7019	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7019	5	Kountze	Kountze	NNP
18637	7019	6	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	7019	7	,	,	,
18637	7019	8	8	8	CD
18637	7019	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7019	10	.	.	.
18637	7020	1	342	342	CD
18637	7020	2	,	,	,
18637	7020	3	350	350	CD
18637	7020	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7020	5	1860	1860	CD
18637	7020	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7020	7	.	.	.
18637	7021	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7021	2	1426	1426	CD
18637	7021	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7021	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	7021	5	parte	parte	VBZ
18637	7021	6	Bakelite	Bakelite	NNP
18637	7021	7	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	7021	8	,	,	,
18637	7021	9	279	279	CD
18637	7021	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7021	11	438	438	CD
18637	7021	12	,	,	,
18637	7021	13	449	449	CD
18637	7021	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7021	15	1929	1929	CD
18637	7021	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7021	17	.	.	.
18637	7022	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7022	2	1427	1427	CD
18637	7022	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7022	4	43	43	CD
18637	7022	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	7022	6	.	.	.
18637	7023	1	5	5	CD
18637	7023	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7023	3	1924	1924	CD
18637	7023	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7023	5	.	.	.
18637	7024	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7024	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7024	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7024	4	Sinclair	Sinclair	NNP
18637	7024	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7024	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7024	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7024	8	United	United	NNP
18637	7024	9	States	States	NNP
18637	7024	10	,	,	,
18637	7024	11	279	279	CD
18637	7024	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7024	13	263	263	CD
18637	7024	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7024	15	1929	1929	CD
18637	7024	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7024	17	.	.	.
18637	7025	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7025	2	1428	1428	CD
18637	7025	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7025	4	Paramino	Paramino	NNP
18637	7025	5	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	7025	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7025	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7025	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7025	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7025	10	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	7025	11	,	,	,
18637	7025	12	309	309	CD
18637	7025	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7025	14	370	370	CD
18637	7025	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7025	16	1940	1940	CD
18637	7025	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7025	18	.	.	.
18637	7026	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7026	2	1429	1429	CD
18637	7026	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7026	4	Pope	Pope	NNP
18637	7026	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7026	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7026	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7026	8	United	United	NNP
18637	7026	9	States	States	NNP
18637	7026	10	,	,	,
18637	7026	11	323	323	CD
18637	7026	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7026	13	1	1	CD
18637	7026	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7026	15	1944	1944	CD
18637	7026	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7026	17	.	.	.
18637	7027	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7027	2	1430	1430	CD
18637	7027	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7027	4	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	7027	5	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	7027	6	Company	Company	NNP
18637	7027	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7027	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7027	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7027	10	The	the	DT
18637	7027	11	"	"	``
18637	7027	12	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	7027	13	Barium	Barium	NNP
18637	7027	14	,	,	,
18637	7027	15	"	"	''
18637	7027	16	293	293	CD
18637	7027	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7027	18	21	21	CD
18637	7027	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7027	20	1934	1934	CD
18637	7027	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7027	22	.	.	.
18637	7028	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7028	2	1431	1431	CD
18637	7028	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7028	4	Knickerbocker	Knickerbocker	NNP
18637	7028	5	Ice	Ice	NNP
18637	7028	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7028	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7028	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7028	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7028	10	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	7028	11	,	,	,
18637	7028	12	253	253	CD
18637	7028	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7028	14	149	149	CD
18637	7028	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7028	16	1920	1920	CD
18637	7028	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7028	18	;	;	:
18637	7028	19	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	7028	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7028	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	7028	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7028	23	Dawson	Dawson	NNP
18637	7028	24	&	&	CC
18637	7028	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7028	26	,	,	,
18637	7028	27	264	264	CD
18637	7028	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7028	29	219	219	CD
18637	7028	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7028	31	1924	1924	CD
18637	7028	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7028	33	.	.	.
18637	7029	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7029	2	1432	1432	CD
18637	7029	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7029	4	Barron	Barron	NNP
18637	7029	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7029	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7029	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7029	8	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	7029	9	,	,	,
18637	7029	10	7	7	CD
18637	7029	11	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	7029	12	.	.	.
18637	7030	1	243	243	CD
18637	7030	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7030	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	7030	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7030	5	;	;	:
18637	7030	6	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	7030	7	's	's	POS
18637	7030	8	L.	L.	NNP
18637	7030	9	&	&	CC
18637	7030	10	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	7031	1	&	&	CC
18637	7031	2	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	7031	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7031	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7031	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	7031	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7031	7	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7031	8	Board	Board	NNP
18637	7031	9	of	of	IN
18637	7031	10	Health	Health	NNP
18637	7031	11	,	,	,
18637	7031	12	118	118	CD
18637	7031	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7031	14	455	455	CD
18637	7031	15	,	,	,
18637	7031	16	467	467	CD
18637	7031	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7031	18	1886	1886	CD
18637	7031	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7031	20	.	.	.
18637	7032	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7032	2	1433	1433	CD
18637	7032	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7032	4	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	7032	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7032	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7032	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7032	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	7032	9	,	,	,
18637	7032	10	94	94	CD
18637	7032	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7032	12	113	113	CD
18637	7032	13	,	,	,
18637	7032	14	135	135	CD
18637	7032	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7032	16	1877	1877	CD
18637	7032	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7032	18	;	;	:
18637	7032	19	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	7032	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7032	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	7032	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7032	23	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	7032	24	&	&	CC
18637	7032	25	P.	P.	NNP
18637	7032	26	Elevator	Elevator	NNP
18637	7032	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7032	28	,	,	,
18637	7032	29	119	119	CD
18637	7032	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7032	31	388	388	CD
18637	7032	32	,	,	,
18637	7032	33	400	400	CD
18637	7032	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7032	35	1886	1886	CD
18637	7032	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7032	37	.	.	.
18637	7033	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7033	2	1434	1434	CD
18637	7033	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7033	4	19	19	CD
18637	7033	5	How	how	WRB
18637	7033	6	.	.	.
18637	7034	1	393	393	CD
18637	7034	2	,	,	,
18637	7034	3	411	411	CD
18637	7034	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7034	5	1857	1857	CD
18637	7034	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7034	7	.	.	.
18637	7035	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7035	2	1435	1435	CD
18637	7035	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7035	4	Gasquet	Gasquet	NNP
18637	7035	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7035	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7035	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7035	8	Lapeyre	Lapeyre	NNP
18637	7035	9	,	,	,
18637	7035	10	242	242	CD
18637	7035	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7035	12	367	367	CD
18637	7035	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7035	14	1917	1917	CD
18637	7035	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7035	16	.	.	.
18637	7036	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7036	2	1436	1436	CD
18637	7036	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7036	4	1	1	CD
18637	7036	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	7036	6	.	.	.
18637	7037	1	73	73	CD
18637	7037	2	,	,	,
18637	7037	3	81	81	CD
18637	7037	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7037	5	1789	1789	CD
18637	7037	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7037	7	.	.	.
18637	7038	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7038	2	1437	1437	CD
18637	7038	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7038	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	7038	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	7038	6	Watkins	Watkins	NNP
18637	7038	7	,	,	,
18637	7038	8	3	3	CD
18637	7038	9	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	7038	10	.	.	.
18637	7039	1	193	193	CD
18637	7039	2	,	,	,
18637	7039	3	202	202	CD
18637	7039	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7039	5	1830	1830	CD
18637	7039	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7039	7	.	.	.
18637	7040	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7040	2	1438	1438	CD
18637	7040	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7040	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	7040	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	7040	6	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	7040	7	,	,	,
18637	7040	8	4	4	CD
18637	7040	9	Cr	cr	NN
18637	7040	10	.	.	.
18637	7041	1	75	75	CD
18637	7041	2	,	,	,
18637	7041	3	101	101	CD
18637	7041	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7041	5	1807	1807	CD
18637	7041	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7041	7	.	.	.
18637	7042	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7042	2	1439	1439	CD
18637	7042	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7042	4	Price	Price	NNP
18637	7042	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7042	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7042	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7042	8	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	7042	9	,	,	,
18637	7042	10	334	334	CD
18637	7042	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7042	12	266	266	CD
18637	7042	13	,	,	,
18637	7042	14	282	282	CD
18637	7042	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7042	16	1948	1948	CD
18637	7042	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7042	18	.	.	.
18637	7043	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7043	2	1440	1440	CD
18637	7043	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7043	4	United	United	NNP
18637	7043	5	States	States	NNP
18637	7043	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7043	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7043	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7043	9	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	7043	10	,	,	,
18637	7043	11	331	331	CD
18637	7043	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7043	13	469	469	CD
18637	7043	14	,	,	,
18637	7043	15	475	475	CD
18637	7043	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7043	17	1947	1947	CD
18637	7043	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7043	19	.	.	.
18637	7044	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7044	2	1441	1441	CD
18637	7044	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7044	4	Gusik	Gusik	NNP
18637	7044	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7044	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7044	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7044	8	Schilder	Schilder	NNP
18637	7044	9	,	,	,
18637	7044	10	339	339	CD
18637	7044	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7044	12	977	977	CD
18637	7044	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7044	14	1950	1950	CD
18637	7044	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7044	16	.	.	.
18637	7045	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7045	2	1442	1442	CD
18637	7045	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7045	4	Frank	Frank	NNP
18637	7045	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7045	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7045	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7045	8	Mangum	Mangum	NNP
18637	7045	9	,	,	,
18637	7045	10	237	237	CD
18637	7045	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7045	12	309	309	CD
18637	7045	13	,	,	,
18637	7045	14	330	330	CD
18637	7045	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7045	16	1915	1915	CD
18637	7045	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7045	18	.	.	.
18637	7046	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7046	2	1443	1443	CD
18637	7046	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7046	4	1	1	CD
18637	7046	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	7046	6	.	.	.
18637	7047	1	73	73	CD
18637	7047	2	,	,	,
18637	7047	3	81	81	CD
18637	7047	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7047	5	1789	1789	CD
18637	7047	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7047	7	.	.	.
18637	7048	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7048	2	1444	1444	CD
18637	7048	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7048	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	7048	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	7048	6	Watkins	Watkins	NNP
18637	7048	7	,	,	,
18637	7048	8	3	3	CD
18637	7048	9	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	7048	10	.	.	.
18637	7049	1	193	193	CD
18637	7049	2	,	,	,
18637	7049	3	202	202	CD
18637	7049	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7049	5	1830	1830	CD
18637	7049	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7049	7	;	;	:
18637	7049	8	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	7049	9	parte	parte	NN
18637	7049	10	Kearney	Kearney	NNP
18637	7049	11	,	,	,
18637	7049	12	7	7	CD
18637	7049	13	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7049	14	.	.	.
18637	7050	1	38	38	CD
18637	7050	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7050	3	1822	1822	CD
18637	7050	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7050	5	.	.	.
18637	7051	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7051	2	1445	1445	CD
18637	7051	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7051	4	14	14	CD
18637	7051	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	7051	6	.	.	.
18637	7052	1	385	385	CD
18637	7052	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7052	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	7052	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7052	5	.	.	.
18637	7053	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7053	2	1446	1446	CD
18637	7053	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7053	4	Frank	Frank	NNP
18637	7053	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7053	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7053	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7053	8	Mangum	Mangum	NNP
18637	7053	9	,	,	,
18637	7053	10	237	237	CD
18637	7053	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7053	12	309	309	CD
18637	7053	13	,	,	,
18637	7053	14	331	331	CD
18637	7053	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7053	16	1915	1915	CD
18637	7053	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7053	18	.	.	.
18637	7054	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7054	2	1447	1447	CD
18637	7054	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7054	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	7054	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	7054	6	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	7054	7	,	,	,
18637	7054	8	4	4	CD
18637	7054	9	Cr	cr	NN
18637	7054	10	.	.	.
18637	7055	1	75	75	CD
18637	7055	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7055	3	1807	1807	CD
18637	7055	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7055	5	.	.	.
18637	7056	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7056	2	1448	1448	CD
18637	7056	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7056	4	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	7056	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7056	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7056	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7056	8	United	United	NNP
18637	7056	9	States	States	NNP
18637	7056	10	ex	ex	NNP
18637	7056	11	rel	rel	NN
18637	7056	12	.	.	.
18637	7057	1	McCann	McCann	NNP
18637	7057	2	,	,	,
18637	7057	3	317	317	CD
18637	7057	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7057	5	269	269	CD
18637	7057	6	,	,	,
18637	7057	7	274	274	CD
18637	7057	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7057	9	1942	1942	CD
18637	7057	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7057	11	;	;	:
18637	7057	12	Glasgow	Glasgow	NNP
18637	7057	13	_	_	NNP
18637	7057	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	7057	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7057	16	Moyer	Moyer	NNP
18637	7057	17	,	,	,
18637	7057	18	225	225	CD
18637	7057	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7057	20	420	420	CD
18637	7057	21	,	,	,
18637	7057	22	428	428	CD
18637	7057	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7057	24	1912	1912	CD
18637	7057	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7057	26	;	;	:
18637	7057	27	Matter	Matter	NNP
18637	7057	28	of	of	IN
18637	7057	29	Gregory	Gregory	NNP
18637	7057	30	,	,	,
18637	7057	31	219	219	CD
18637	7057	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7057	33	210	210	CD
18637	7057	34	,	,	,
18637	7057	35	213	213	CD
18637	7057	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7057	37	1911	1911	CD
18637	7057	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7057	39	.	.	.
18637	7058	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7058	2	1449	1449	CD
18637	7058	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7058	4	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	7058	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7058	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7058	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7058	8	United	United	NNP
18637	7058	9	States	States	NNP
18637	7058	10	ex	ex	NNP
18637	7058	11	rel	rel	NN
18637	7058	12	.	.	.
18637	7059	1	McCann	McCann	NNP
18637	7059	2	,	,	,
18637	7059	3	317	317	CD
18637	7059	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7059	5	269	269	CD
18637	7059	6	,	,	,
18637	7059	7	274	274	CD
18637	7059	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7059	9	1942	1942	CD
18637	7059	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7059	11	.	.	.
18637	7060	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7060	2	1450	1450	CD
18637	7060	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7060	4	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	7060	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7060	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7060	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7060	8	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	7060	9	,	,	,
18637	7060	10	312	312	CD
18637	7060	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7060	12	275	275	CD
18637	7060	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7060	14	1941	1941	CD
18637	7060	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7060	16	;	;	:
18637	7060	17	Waley	Waley	NNP
18637	7060	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7060	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	7060	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7060	21	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	7060	22	,	,	,
18637	7060	23	316	316	CD
18637	7060	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7060	25	101	101	CD
18637	7060	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7060	27	1942	1942	CD
18637	7060	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7060	29	.	.	.
18637	7061	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7061	2	1451	1451	CD
18637	7061	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7061	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	7061	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	7061	6	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
18637	7061	7	,	,	,
18637	7061	8	4	4	CD
18637	7061	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7061	10	.	.	.
18637	7062	1	2	2	CD
18637	7062	2	,	,	,
18637	7062	3	110	110	CD
18637	7062	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7062	5	1866	1866	CD
18637	7062	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7062	7	.	.	.
18637	7063	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7063	2	1452	1452	CD
18637	7063	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7063	4	McNally	McNally	NNP
18637	7063	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7063	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7063	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7063	8	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	7063	9	,	,	,
18637	7063	10	293	293	CD
18637	7063	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7063	12	131	131	CD
18637	7063	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7063	14	1934	1934	CD
18637	7063	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7063	16	.	.	.
18637	7064	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7064	2	1453	1453	CD
18637	7064	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7064	4	Goto	Goto	NNP
18637	7064	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7064	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7064	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7064	8	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	7064	9	,	,	,
18637	7064	10	265	265	CD
18637	7064	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7064	12	393	393	CD
18637	7064	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7064	14	1924	1924	CD
18637	7064	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7064	16	.	.	.
18637	7065	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7065	2	1454	1454	CD
18637	7065	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7065	4	Salinger	Salinger	NNP
18637	7065	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7065	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7065	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7065	8	Loisel	Loisel	NNP
18637	7065	9	,	,	,
18637	7065	10	265	265	CD
18637	7065	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7065	12	224	224	CD
18637	7065	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7065	14	1924	1924	CD
18637	7065	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7065	16	.	.	.
18637	7066	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7066	2	1455	1455	CD
18637	7066	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7066	4	Wong	Wong	NNP
18637	7066	5	Doo	Doo	NNP
18637	7066	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7066	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7066	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7066	9	United	United	NNP
18637	7066	10	States	States	NNP
18637	7066	11	,	,	,
18637	7066	12	265	265	CD
18637	7066	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7066	14	239	239	CD
18637	7066	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7066	16	1924	1924	CD
18637	7066	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7066	18	.	.	.
18637	7067	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7067	2	1456	1456	CD
18637	7067	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7067	4	Price	Price	NNP
18637	7067	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7067	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7067	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7067	8	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	7067	9	,	,	,
18637	7067	10	334	334	CD
18637	7067	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7067	12	266	266	CD
18637	7067	13	,	,	,
18637	7067	14	294	294	CD
18637	7067	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7067	16	1948	1948	CD
18637	7067	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7067	18	.	.	.
18637	7068	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7068	2	1457	1457	CD
18637	7068	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7068	4	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	7068	5	,	,	,
18637	7068	6	The	the	DT
18637	7068	7	President	President	NNP
18637	7068	8	,	,	,
18637	7068	9	Office	Office	NNP
18637	7068	10	and	and	CC
18637	7068	11	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	7068	12	,	,	,
18637	7068	13	178	178	CD
18637	7068	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7068	15	3d	3d	NNP
18637	7068	16	ed	ed	NNP
18637	7068	17	.	.	NNP
18637	7068	18	,	,	,
18637	7068	19	1948	1948	CD
18637	7068	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7068	21	.	.	.
18637	7069	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7069	2	1458	1458	CD
18637	7069	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7069	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	7069	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	7069	6	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	7069	7	,	,	,
18637	7069	8	4	4	CD
18637	7069	9	Cr	cr	NN
18637	7069	10	.	.	.
18637	7070	1	75	75	CD
18637	7070	2	,	,	,
18637	7070	3	101	101	CD
18637	7070	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7070	5	1807	1807	CD
18637	7070	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7070	7	.	.	.
18637	7071	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7071	2	1459	1459	CD
18637	7071	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7071	4	Messages	Messages	NNPS
18637	7071	5	and	and	CC
18637	7071	6	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	7071	7	of	of	IN
18637	7071	8	the	the	DT
18637	7071	9	Presidents	Presidents	NNPS
18637	7071	10	,	,	,
18637	7071	11	VII	VII	NNP
18637	7071	12	,	,	,
18637	7071	13	3219	3219	CD
18637	7071	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7071	15	1897	1897	CD
18637	7071	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7071	17	.	.	.
18637	7072	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7072	2	1460	1460	CD
18637	7072	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7072	4	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	7072	5	.	.	.
18637	7073	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	7073	2	.	.	.
18637	7074	1	No	no	UH
18637	7074	2	.	.	.
18637	7075	1	9	9	CD
18637	7075	2	,	,	,
18637	7075	3	487	487	CD
18637	7075	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7075	5	1861	1861	CD
18637	7075	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7075	7	.	.	.
18637	7076	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7076	2	1461	1461	CD
18637	7076	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7076	4	10	10	CD
18637	7076	5	Op	Op	NNP
18637	7076	6	.	.	.
18637	7077	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	7077	2	.	.	.
18637	7078	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	7078	2	74	74	CD
18637	7078	3	,	,	,
18637	7078	4	89	89	CD
18637	7078	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7078	6	1861	1861	CD
18637	7078	7	-	-	SYM
18637	7078	8	1863	1863	CD
18637	7078	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7078	10	.	.	.
18637	7079	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7079	2	1462	1462	CD
18637	7079	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7079	4	12	12	CD
18637	7079	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	7079	6	.	.	.
18637	7080	1	755	755	CD
18637	7080	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7080	3	1863	1863	CD
18637	7080	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7080	5	.	.	.
18637	7081	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7081	2	1463	1463	CD
18637	7081	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7081	4	4	4	CD
18637	7081	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7081	6	.	.	.
18637	7082	1	2	2	CD
18637	7082	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7082	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	7082	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7082	5	.	.	.
18637	7083	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7083	2	1464	1464	CD
18637	7083	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7083	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7083	5	.	.	.
18637	7084	1	114	114	CD
18637	7084	2	.	.	.
18637	7085	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7085	2	1465	1465	CD
18637	7085	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7085	4	Story	story	NN
18637	7085	5	,	,	,
18637	7085	6	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	7085	7	on	on	IN
18637	7085	8	the	the	DT
18637	7085	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7085	10	,	,	,
18637	7085	11	II	II	NNP
18637	7085	12	,	,	,
18637	7085	13	§	§	NNP
18637	7085	14	1344	1344	CD
18637	7085	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7085	16	4th	4th	NNP
18637	7085	17	ed	ed	NNP
18637	7085	18	.	.	NNP
18637	7085	19	,	,	,
18637	7085	20	1873	1873	CD
18637	7085	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7085	22	.	.	.
18637	7086	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7086	2	1466	1466	CD
18637	7086	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7086	4	Cummings	Cummings	NNP
18637	7086	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7086	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7086	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7086	8	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	7086	9	,	,	,
18637	7086	10	4	4	CD
18637	7086	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7086	12	.	.	.
18637	7087	1	277	277	CD
18637	7087	2	,	,	,
18637	7087	3	323	323	CD
18637	7087	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7087	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	7087	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7087	7	.	.	.
18637	7088	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7088	2	1467	1467	CD
18637	7088	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7088	4	United	United	NNP
18637	7088	5	States	States	NNP
18637	7088	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7088	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7088	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7088	9	Lovett	Lovett	NNP
18637	7088	10	,	,	,
18637	7088	11	328	328	CD
18637	7088	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7088	13	303	303	CD
18637	7088	14	,	,	,
18637	7088	15	315	315	CD
18637	7088	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7088	17	1946	1946	CD
18637	7088	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7088	19	.	.	.
18637	7089	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7089	2	1468	1468	CD
18637	7089	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7089	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	7089	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	7089	6	Garland	Garland	NNP
18637	7089	7	,	,	,
18637	7089	8	4	4	CD
18637	7089	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7089	10	.	.	.
18637	7090	1	333	333	CD
18637	7090	2	,	,	,
18637	7090	3	377	377	CD
18637	7090	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7090	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	7090	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7090	7	.	.	.
18637	7091	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7091	2	1469	1469	CD
18637	7091	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7091	4	United	United	NNP
18637	7091	5	States	States	NNP
18637	7091	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7091	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7091	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7091	9	Lovett	Lovett	NNP
18637	7091	10	,	,	,
18637	7091	11	328	328	CD
18637	7091	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7091	13	303	303	CD
18637	7091	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7091	15	1946	1946	CD
18637	7091	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7091	17	.	.	.
18637	7092	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7092	2	1470	1470	CD
18637	7092	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7092	4	Story	story	NN
18637	7092	5	,	,	,
18637	7092	6	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	7092	7	on	on	IN
18637	7092	8	the	the	DT
18637	7092	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7092	10	,	,	,
18637	7092	11	II	II	NNP
18637	7092	12	,	,	,
18637	7092	13	§	â§	NN
18637	7092	14	1345	1345	CD
18637	7092	15	.	.	.
18637	7093	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7093	2	1471	1471	CD
18637	7093	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7093	4	3	3	CD
18637	7093	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	7093	6	.	.	.
18637	7094	1	386	386	CD
18637	7094	2	,	,	,
18637	7094	3	393	393	CD
18637	7094	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7094	5	1798	1798	CD
18637	7094	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7094	7	.	.	.
18637	7095	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7095	2	1472	1472	CD
18637	7095	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7095	4	Bankers	Bankers	NNPS
18637	7095	5	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	7095	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7095	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7095	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7095	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7095	10	Blodgett	Blodgett	NNP
18637	7095	11	,	,	,
18637	7095	12	260	260	CD
18637	7095	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7095	14	647	647	CD
18637	7095	15	,	,	,
18637	7095	16	652	652	CD
18637	7095	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7095	18	1923	1923	CD
18637	7095	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7095	20	.	.	.
18637	7096	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7096	2	1473	1473	CD
18637	7096	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7096	4	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
18637	7096	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7096	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7096	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7096	8	Salmon	Salmon	NNP
18637	7096	9	,	,	,
18637	7096	10	97	97	CD
18637	7096	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7096	12	381	381	CD
18637	7096	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7096	14	1878	1878	CD
18637	7096	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7096	16	.	.	.
18637	7097	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7097	2	1474	1474	CD
18637	7097	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7097	4	Calder	Calder	NNP
18637	7097	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7097	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7097	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7097	8	Bull	Bull	NNP
18637	7097	9	,	,	,
18637	7097	10	3	3	CD
18637	7097	11	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	7097	12	.	.	.
18637	7098	1	386	386	CD
18637	7098	2	,	,	,
18637	7098	3	390	390	CD
18637	7098	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7098	5	1798	1798	CD
18637	7098	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7098	7	;	;	:
18637	7098	8	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	7098	9	parte	parte	NN
18637	7098	10	Garland	Garland	NNP
18637	7098	11	,	,	,
18637	7098	12	4	4	CD
18637	7098	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7098	14	.	.	.
18637	7099	1	333	333	CD
18637	7099	2	,	,	,
18637	7099	3	377	377	CD
18637	7099	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7099	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	7099	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7099	7	;	;	:
18637	7099	8	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
18637	7099	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7099	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7099	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7099	12	Salmon	Salmon	NNP
18637	7099	13	,	,	,
18637	7099	14	97	97	CD
18637	7099	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7099	16	381	381	CD
18637	7099	17	,	,	,
18637	7099	18	384	384	CD
18637	7099	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7099	20	1878	1878	CD
18637	7099	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7099	22	.	.	.
18637	7100	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7100	2	1475	1475	CD
18637	7100	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7100	4	United	United	NNP
18637	7100	5	States	States	NNP
18637	7100	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7100	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7100	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7100	9	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	7100	10	,	,	,
18637	7100	11	307	307	CD
18637	7100	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7100	13	214	214	CD
18637	7100	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7100	15	1939	1939	CD
18637	7100	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7100	17	.	.	.
18637	7101	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7101	2	1476	1476	CD
18637	7101	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7101	4	Neely	neely	RB
18637	7101	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7101	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7101	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7101	8	Henkel	Henkel	NNP
18637	7101	9	,	,	,
18637	7101	10	180	180	CD
18637	7101	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7101	12	109	109	CD
18637	7101	13	,	,	,
18637	7101	14	123	123	CD
18637	7101	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7101	16	1901	1901	CD
18637	7101	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7101	18	.	.	.
18637	7102	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7102	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	7102	3	.	.	.
18637	7102	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7102	5	In	in	IN
18637	7102	6	re	re	IN
18637	7102	7	Yamashita	Yamashita	NNP
18637	7102	8	,	,	,
18637	7102	9	327	327	CD
18637	7102	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7102	11	1	1	CD
18637	7102	12	,	,	,
18637	7102	13	26	26	CD
18637	7102	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7102	15	1946	1946	CD
18637	7102	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7102	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7102	18	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	7102	19	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	7102	20	of	of	IN
18637	7102	21	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7102	22	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	7102	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7102	24	;	;	:
18637	7102	25	Hirota	Hirota	NNP
18637	7102	26	_	_	NNP
18637	7102	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	7102	28	_	_	NNP
18637	7102	29	MacArthur	MacArthur	NNP
18637	7102	30	,	,	,
18637	7102	31	338	338	CD
18637	7102	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7102	33	197	197	CD
18637	7102	34	,	,	,
18637	7102	35	199	199	CD
18637	7102	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7102	37	1948	1948	CD
18637	7102	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7102	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7102	40	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	7102	41	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	7102	42	of	of	IN
18637	7102	43	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7102	44	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	7102	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7102	46	.	.	.
18637	7103	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7103	2	1477	1477	CD
18637	7103	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7103	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	7103	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	7103	6	Garland	Garland	NNP
18637	7103	7	,	,	,
18637	7103	8	4	4	CD
18637	7103	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7103	10	.	.	.
18637	7104	1	333	333	CD
18637	7104	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7104	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	7104	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7104	5	.	.	.
18637	7105	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7105	2	1478	1478	CD
18637	7105	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7105	4	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	7105	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7105	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7105	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7105	8	Ramsey	Ramsey	NNP
18637	7105	9	,	,	,
18637	7105	10	114	114	CD
18637	7105	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7105	12	15	15	CD
18637	7105	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7105	14	1885	1885	CD
18637	7105	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7105	16	.	.	.
18637	7106	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7106	2	1479	1479	CD
18637	7106	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7106	4	Mahler	Mahler	NNP
18637	7106	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7106	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7106	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7106	8	Eby	Eby	NNP
18637	7106	9	,	,	,
18637	7106	10	264	264	CD
18637	7106	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7106	12	32	32	CD
18637	7106	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7106	14	1924	1924	CD
18637	7106	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7106	16	;	;	:
18637	7106	17	Bugajewitz	Bugajewitz	NNP
18637	7106	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7106	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	7106	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7106	21	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	7106	22	,	,	,
18637	7106	23	228	228	CD
18637	7106	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7106	25	585	585	CD
18637	7106	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7106	27	1913	1913	CD
18637	7106	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7106	29	.	.	.
18637	7107	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7107	2	1480	1480	CD
18637	7107	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7107	4	Johannessen	Johannessen	NNP
18637	7107	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7107	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7107	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7107	8	United	United	NNP
18637	7107	9	States	States	NNP
18637	7107	10	,	,	,
18637	7107	11	225	225	CD
18637	7107	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7107	13	227	227	CD
18637	7107	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7107	15	1912	1912	CD
18637	7107	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7107	17	.	.	.
18637	7108	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7108	2	1481	1481	CD
18637	7108	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7108	4	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	7108	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7108	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7108	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7108	8	United	United	NNP
18637	7108	9	States	States	NNP
18637	7108	10	,	,	,
18637	7108	11	138	138	CD
18637	7108	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7108	13	157	157	CD
18637	7108	14	,	,	,
18637	7108	15	183	183	CD
18637	7108	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7108	17	1891	1891	CD
18637	7108	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7108	19	.	.	.
18637	7109	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7109	2	1482	1482	CD
18637	7109	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7109	4	Calder	Calder	NNP
18637	7109	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7109	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7109	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7109	8	Bull	Bull	NNP
18637	7109	9	,	,	,
18637	7109	10	3	3	CD
18637	7109	11	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	7109	12	.	.	.
18637	7110	1	386	386	CD
18637	7110	2	,	,	,
18637	7110	3	390	390	CD
18637	7110	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7110	5	1798	1798	CD
18637	7110	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7110	7	.	.	.
18637	7111	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7111	2	1483	1483	CD
18637	7111	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7111	4	Hopt	Hopt	NNP
18637	7111	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7111	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7111	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7111	8	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	7111	9	,	,	,
18637	7111	10	110	110	CD
18637	7111	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7111	12	574	574	CD
18637	7111	13	,	,	,
18637	7111	14	589	589	CD
18637	7111	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7111	16	1884	1884	CD
18637	7111	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7111	18	.	.	.
18637	7112	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7112	2	1484	1484	CD
18637	7112	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7112	4	157	157	CD
18637	7112	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7112	6	429	429	CD
18637	7112	7	,	,	,
18637	7112	8	573	573	CD
18637	7112	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7112	10	1895	1895	CD
18637	7112	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7112	12	.	.	.
18637	7113	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7113	2	1485	1485	CD
18637	7113	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7113	4	2	2	CD
18637	7113	5	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	7113	6	,	,	,
18637	7113	7	The	the	DT
18637	7113	8	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	7113	9	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	7113	10	,	,	,
18637	7113	11	208	208	CD
18637	7113	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7113	13	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
18637	7113	14	's	's	POS
18637	7113	15	ed	ed	NNP
18637	7113	16	.	.	NNP
18637	7113	17	,	,	,
18637	7113	18	1908	1908	CD
18637	7113	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7113	20	.	.	.
18637	7114	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7114	2	1486	1486	CD
18637	7114	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7114	4	3	3	CD
18637	7114	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	7114	6	.	.	.
18637	7115	1	171	171	CD
18637	7115	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7115	3	1796	1796	CD
18637	7115	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7115	5	.	.	.
18637	7116	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7116	2	1487	1487	CD
18637	7116	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7116	4	7	7	CD
18637	7116	5	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	7116	6	's	's	POS
18637	7116	7	Works	work	NNS
18637	7116	8	,	,	,
18637	7116	9	845	845	CD
18637	7116	10	,	,	,
18637	7116	11	848	848	CD
18637	7116	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7116	13	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	7116	14	's	's	POS
18637	7116	15	ed	ed	NNP
18637	7116	16	.	.	NNP
18637	7116	17	,	,	,
18637	7116	18	1851	1851	CD
18637	7116	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7116	20	.	.	.
18637	7117	1	"	"	``
18637	7117	2	If	if	IN
18637	7117	3	the	the	DT
18637	7117	4	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	7117	5	of	of	IN
18637	7117	6	the	the	DT
18637	7117	7	word	word	NN
18637	7117	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7117	9	excise	excise	NN
18637	7117	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7117	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	7117	12	to	to	TO
18637	7117	13	be	be	VB
18637	7117	14	sought	seek	VBN
18637	7117	15	in	in	IN
18637	7117	16	the	the	DT
18637	7117	17	British	british	JJ
18637	7117	18	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	7117	19	,	,	,
18637	7117	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7117	21	will	will	MD
18637	7117	22	be	be	VB
18637	7117	23	found	find	VBN
18637	7117	24	to	to	TO
18637	7117	25	include	include	VB
18637	7117	26	the	the	DT
18637	7117	27	duty	duty	NN
18637	7117	28	on	on	IN
18637	7117	29	carriages	carriage	NNS
18637	7117	30	,	,	,
18637	7117	31	which	which	WDT
18637	7117	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	7117	33	there	there	RB
18637	7117	34	considered	consider	VBN
18637	7117	35	as	as	IN
18637	7117	36	an	an	DT
18637	7117	37	_	_	NNP
18637	7117	38	excise	excise	NN
18637	7117	39	_	_	NNP
18637	7117	40	,	,	,
18637	7117	41	and	and	CC
18637	7117	42	then	then	RB
18637	7117	43	must	must	MD
18637	7117	44	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	7117	45	be	be	VB
18637	7117	46	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	7117	47	and	and	CC
18637	7117	48	liable	liable	JJ
18637	7117	49	to	to	IN
18637	7117	50	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	7117	51	;	;	:
18637	7117	52	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	7117	53	,	,	,
18637	7117	54	not	not	RB
18637	7117	55	a	a	DT
18637	7117	56	direct	direct	JJ
18637	7117	57	tax	tax	NN
18637	7117	58	.	.	.
18637	7117	59	"	"	''
18637	7118	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	7118	2	.	.	.
18637	7119	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7119	2	1488	1488	CD
18637	7119	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7119	4	4	4	CD
18637	7119	5	Annals	Annals	NNPS
18637	7119	6	of	of	IN
18637	7119	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7119	8	,	,	,
18637	7119	9	730	730	CD
18637	7119	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7119	11	1794	1794	CD
18637	7119	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7119	13	;	;	:
18637	7119	14	2	2	CD
18637	7119	15	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	7119	16	's	's	POS
18637	7119	17	Writings	Writings	NNP
18637	7119	18	,	,	,
18637	7119	19	14	14	CD
18637	7119	20	,	,	,
18637	7119	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7119	22	Library	Library	NNP
18637	7119	23	of	of	IN
18637	7119	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7119	25	ed	ed	NNP
18637	7119	26	.	.	NNP
18637	7119	27	,	,	,
18637	7119	28	1865	1865	CD
18637	7119	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7119	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7119	31	Letter	letter	NN
18637	7119	32	to	to	IN
18637	7119	33	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	7119	34	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	7119	35	,	,	,
18637	7119	36	May	May	NNP
18637	7119	37	11	11	CD
18637	7119	38	,	,	,
18637	7119	39	1794	1794	CD
18637	7119	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7119	41	.	.	.
18637	7120	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7120	2	1489	1489	CD
18637	7120	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7120	4	3	3	CD
18637	7120	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	7120	6	.	.	.
18637	7121	1	171	171	CD
18637	7121	2	,	,	,
18637	7121	3	177	177	CD
18637	7121	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7121	5	1796	1796	CD
18637	7121	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7121	7	.	.	.
18637	7122	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7122	2	1490	1490	CD
18637	7122	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7122	4	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	7122	5	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	7122	6	.	.	.
18637	7123	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7123	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7123	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7123	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7123	5	Soule	Soule	NNP
18637	7123	6	,	,	,
18637	7123	7	7	7	CD
18637	7123	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7123	9	.	.	.
18637	7124	1	433	433	CD
18637	7124	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7124	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	7124	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7124	5	.	.	.
18637	7125	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7125	2	1491	1491	CD
18637	7125	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7125	4	Veazie	Veazie	NNP
18637	7125	5	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7125	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7125	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7125	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7125	9	Fenno	Fenno	NNP
18637	7125	10	,	,	,
18637	7125	11	8	8	CD
18637	7125	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7125	13	.	.	.
18637	7126	1	533	533	CD
18637	7126	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7126	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	7126	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7126	5	.	.	.
18637	7127	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7127	2	1492	1492	CD
18637	7127	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7127	4	Scholey	Scholey	NNP
18637	7127	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7127	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7127	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7127	8	Rew	Rew	NNP
18637	7127	9	,	,	,
18637	7127	10	23	23	CD
18637	7127	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7127	12	.	.	.
18637	7128	1	331	331	CD
18637	7128	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7128	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	7128	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7128	5	.	.	.
18637	7129	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7129	2	1493	1493	CD
18637	7129	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7129	4	Springer	Springer	NNP
18637	7129	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7129	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7129	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7129	8	United	United	NNP
18637	7129	9	States	States	NNP
18637	7129	10	,	,	,
18637	7129	11	102	102	CD
18637	7129	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7129	13	586	586	CD
18637	7129	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7129	15	1881	1881	CD
18637	7129	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7129	17	.	.	.
18637	7130	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7130	2	1494	1494	CD
18637	7130	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7130	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7130	5	.	.	.
18637	7131	1	602	602	CD
18637	7131	2	.	.	.
18637	7132	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7132	2	1495	1495	CD
18637	7132	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7132	4	157	157	CD
18637	7132	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7132	6	429	429	CD
18637	7132	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7132	8	1895	1895	CD
18637	7132	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7132	10	;	;	:
18637	7132	11	158	158	CD
18637	7132	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7132	13	601	601	CD
18637	7132	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7132	15	1895	1895	CD
18637	7132	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7132	17	.	.	.
18637	7133	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7133	2	1496	1496	CD
18637	7133	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7133	4	28	28	CD
18637	7133	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	7133	6	.	.	.
18637	7134	1	509	509	CD
18637	7134	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7134	3	1894	1894	CD
18637	7134	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7134	5	.	.	.
18637	7135	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7135	2	1497	1497	CD
18637	7135	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7135	4	Stanton	Stanton	NNP
18637	7135	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7135	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7135	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7135	8	Baltic	Baltic	NNP
18637	7135	9	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	7135	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7135	11	,	,	,
18637	7135	12	240	240	CD
18637	7135	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7135	14	103	103	CD
18637	7135	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7135	16	1916	1916	CD
18637	7135	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7135	18	;	;	:
18637	7135	19	Knowlton	Knowlton	NNP
18637	7135	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7135	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	7135	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7135	23	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	7135	24	,	,	,
18637	7135	25	178	178	CD
18637	7135	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7135	27	41	41	CD
18637	7135	28	,	,	,
18637	7135	29	80	80	CD
18637	7135	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7135	31	1900	1900	CD
18637	7135	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7135	33	.	.	.
18637	7136	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7136	2	1498	1498	CD
18637	7136	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7136	4	Nicol	Nicol	NNP
18637	7136	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7136	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7136	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7136	8	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	7136	9	,	,	,
18637	7136	10	173	173	CD
18637	7136	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7136	12	509	509	CD
18637	7136	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7136	14	1899	1899	CD
18637	7136	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7136	16	.	.	.
18637	7137	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7137	2	1499	1499	CD
18637	7137	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7137	4	Knowlton	Knowlton	NNP
18637	7137	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7137	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7137	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7137	8	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	7137	9	,	,	,
18637	7137	10	178	178	CD
18637	7137	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7137	12	41	41	CD
18637	7137	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7137	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	7137	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7137	16	.	.	.
18637	7138	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7138	2	1500	1500	CD
18637	7138	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7138	4	Patton	Patton	NNP
18637	7138	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7138	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7138	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7138	8	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	7138	9	,	,	,
18637	7138	10	184	184	CD
18637	7138	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7138	12	608	608	CD
18637	7138	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7138	14	1902	1902	CD
18637	7138	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7138	16	.	.	.
18637	7139	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7139	2	1501	1501	CD
18637	7139	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7139	4	192	192	CD
18637	7139	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7139	6	363	363	CD
18637	7139	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7139	8	1904	1904	CD
18637	7139	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7139	10	.	.	.
18637	7140	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7140	2	1502	1502	CD
18637	7140	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7140	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7140	5	.	.	.
18637	7141	1	370	370	CD
18637	7141	2	.	.	.
18637	7142	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7142	2	1503	1503	CD
18637	7142	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7142	4	192	192	CD
18637	7142	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7142	6	397	397	CD
18637	7142	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7142	8	1904	1904	CD
18637	7142	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7142	10	.	.	.
18637	7143	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7143	2	1504	1504	CD
18637	7143	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7143	4	220	220	CD
18637	7143	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7143	6	107	107	CD
18637	7143	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7143	8	1911	1911	CD
18637	7143	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7143	10	.	.	.
18637	7144	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7144	2	1505	1505	CD
18637	7144	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7144	4	240	240	CD
18637	7144	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7144	6	103	103	CD
18637	7144	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7144	8	1916	1916	CD
18637	7144	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7144	10	.	.	.
18637	7145	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7145	2	1506	1506	CD
18637	7145	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7145	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7145	5	.	.	.
18637	7146	1	114	114	CD
18637	7146	2	.	.	.
18637	7147	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7147	2	1507	1507	CD
18637	7147	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7147	4	232	232	CD
18637	7147	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7147	6	261	261	CD
18637	7147	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7147	8	1914	1914	CD
18637	7147	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7147	10	.	.	.
18637	7148	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7148	2	1508	1508	CD
18637	7148	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7148	4	New	New	NNP
18637	7148	5	York	York	NNP
18637	7148	6	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	7148	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7148	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7148	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7148	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7148	11	Eisner	Eisner	NNP
18637	7148	12	,	,	,
18637	7148	13	256	256	CD
18637	7148	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7148	15	345	345	CD
18637	7148	16	,	,	,
18637	7148	17	349	349	CD
18637	7148	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7148	19	1921	1921	CD
18637	7148	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7148	21	.	.	.
18637	7149	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7149	2	1509	1509	CD
18637	7149	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7149	4	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	7149	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7149	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7149	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7149	8	Dime	Dime	NNP
18637	7149	9	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	7149	10	&	&	CC
18637	7149	11	Safe	Safe	NNP
18637	7149	12	Deposit	Deposit	NNP
18637	7149	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7149	14	,	,	,
18637	7149	15	284	284	CD
18637	7149	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7149	17	160	160	CD
18637	7149	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7149	19	1931	1931	CD
18637	7149	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7149	21	.	.	.
18637	7150	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7150	2	1510	1510	CD
18637	7150	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7150	4	Tyler	Tyler	NNP
18637	7150	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7150	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7150	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7150	8	United	United	NNP
18637	7150	9	States	States	NNP
18637	7150	10	,	,	,
18637	7150	11	281	281	CD
18637	7150	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7150	13	497	497	CD
18637	7150	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7150	15	1930	1930	CD
18637	7150	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7150	17	.	.	.
18637	7151	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7151	2	1511	1511	CD
18637	7151	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7151	4	Fernandez	Fernandez	NNP
18637	7151	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7151	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7151	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7151	8	Wiener	Wiener	NNP
18637	7151	9	,	,	,
18637	7151	10	326	326	CD
18637	7151	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7151	12	340	340	CD
18637	7151	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7151	14	1945	1945	CD
18637	7151	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7151	16	.	.	.
18637	7152	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7152	2	1512	1512	CD
18637	7152	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7152	4	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	7152	5	National	National	NNP
18637	7152	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7152	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7152	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7152	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7152	10	United	United	NNP
18637	7152	11	States	States	NNP
18637	7152	12	,	,	,
18637	7152	13	278	278	CD
18637	7152	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7152	15	327	327	CD
18637	7152	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7152	17	1929	1929	CD
18637	7152	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7152	19	.	.	.
18637	7153	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7153	2	1513	1513	CD
18637	7153	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7153	4	Bromley	Bromley	NNP
18637	7153	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7153	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7153	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7153	8	McCaughn	McCaughn	NNP
18637	7153	9	,	,	,
18637	7153	10	280	280	CD
18637	7153	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7153	12	124	124	CD
18637	7153	13	,	,	,
18637	7153	14	136	136	CD
18637	7153	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7153	16	1929	1929	CD
18637	7153	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7153	18	.	.	.
18637	7154	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7154	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7154	3	also	also	RB
18637	7154	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7154	5	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	7154	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7154	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7154	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7154	9	Bullard	Bullard	NNP
18637	7154	10	,	,	,
18637	7154	11	303	303	CD
18637	7154	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7154	13	297	297	CD
18637	7154	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7154	15	1938	1938	CD
18637	7154	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7154	17	.	.	.
18637	7155	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7155	2	1514	1514	CD
18637	7155	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7155	4	Bromley	Bromley	NNP
18637	7155	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7155	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7155	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7155	8	McCaughn	McCaughn	NNP
18637	7155	9	,	,	,
18637	7155	10	280	280	CD
18637	7155	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7155	12	124	124	CD
18637	7155	13	,	,	,
18637	7155	14	140	140	CD
18637	7155	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7155	16	1929	1929	CD
18637	7155	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7155	18	.	.	.
18637	7156	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7156	2	1515	1515	CD
18637	7156	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7156	4	Loughborough	Loughborough	NNP
18637	7156	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7156	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7156	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7156	8	Blake	Blake	NNP
18637	7156	9	,	,	,
18637	7156	10	5	5	CD
18637	7156	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7156	12	.	.	.
18637	7157	1	317	317	CD
18637	7157	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7157	3	1820	1820	CD
18637	7157	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7157	5	.	.	.
18637	7158	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7158	2	1516	1516	CD
18637	7158	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7158	4	De	De	NNP
18637	7158	5	Treville	Treville	NNP
18637	7158	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7158	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7158	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7158	9	Smalls	Smalls	NNP
18637	7158	10	,	,	,
18637	7158	11	98	98	CD
18637	7158	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7158	13	517	517	CD
18637	7158	14	,	,	,
18637	7158	15	527	527	CD
18637	7158	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7158	17	1879	1879	CD
18637	7158	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7158	19	.	.	.
18637	7159	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7159	2	1517	1517	CD
18637	7159	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7159	4	Turpin	Turpin	NNP
18637	7159	5	&	&	CC
18637	7159	6	Bro	Bro	NNP
18637	7159	7	.	.	.
18637	7160	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7160	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	7160	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7160	4	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
18637	7160	5	,	,	,
18637	7160	6	117	117	CD
18637	7160	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7160	8	504	504	CD
18637	7160	9	,	,	,
18637	7160	10	507	507	CD
18637	7160	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7160	12	1886	1886	CD
18637	7160	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7160	14	.	.	.
18637	7161	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7161	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	7161	3	.	.	.
18637	7161	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7161	5	Almy	Almy	NNP
18637	7161	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7161	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7161	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7161	9	California	California	NNP
18637	7161	10	,	,	,
18637	7161	11	24	24	CD
18637	7161	12	How	how	WRB
18637	7161	13	.	.	.
18637	7162	1	169	169	CD
18637	7162	2	,	,	,
18637	7162	3	174	174	CD
18637	7162	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7162	5	1861	1861	CD
18637	7162	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7162	7	.	.	.
18637	7163	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7163	2	1518	1518	CD
18637	7163	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7163	4	Dooley	Dooley	NNP
18637	7163	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7163	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7163	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7163	8	United	United	NNP
18637	7163	9	States	States	NNP
18637	7163	10	,	,	,
18637	7163	11	183	183	CD
18637	7163	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7163	13	151	151	CD
18637	7163	14	,	,	,
18637	7163	15	154	154	CD
18637	7163	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7163	17	1901	1901	CD
18637	7163	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7163	19	.	.	.
18637	7164	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7164	2	1519	1519	CD
18637	7164	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7164	4	Cornell	Cornell	NNP
18637	7164	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7164	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7164	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7164	8	Coyne	Coyne	NNP
18637	7164	9	,	,	,
18637	7164	10	192	192	CD
18637	7164	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7164	12	418	418	CD
18637	7164	13	,	,	,
18637	7164	14	428	428	CD
18637	7164	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7164	16	1904	1904	CD
18637	7164	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7164	18	;	;	:
18637	7164	19	Turpin	Turpin	NNP
18637	7164	20	&	&	CC
18637	7164	21	Bro	Bro	NNP
18637	7164	22	.	.	.
18637	7165	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7165	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	7165	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7165	4	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
18637	7165	5	,	,	,
18637	7165	6	117	117	CD
18637	7165	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7165	8	504	504	CD
18637	7165	9	,	,	,
18637	7165	10	507	507	CD
18637	7165	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7165	12	1886	1886	CD
18637	7165	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7165	14	.	.	.
18637	7166	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7166	2	1520	1520	CD
18637	7166	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7166	4	Spalding	Spalding	NNP
18637	7166	5	&	&	CC
18637	7166	6	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	7166	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7166	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7166	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7166	10	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	7166	11	,	,	,
18637	7166	12	262	262	CD
18637	7166	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7166	14	66	66	CD
18637	7166	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7166	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	7166	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7166	18	.	.	.
18637	7167	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7167	2	1521	1521	CD
18637	7167	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7167	4	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	7167	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7167	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7167	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7167	8	United	United	NNP
18637	7167	9	States	States	NNP
18637	7167	10	,	,	,
18637	7167	11	142	142	CD
18637	7167	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7167	13	471	471	CD
18637	7167	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7167	15	1892	1892	CD
18637	7167	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7167	17	.	.	.
18637	7168	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7168	2	1522	1522	CD
18637	7168	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7168	4	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	7168	5	&	&	CC
18637	7168	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7168	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7168	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7168	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7168	10	Lowe	Lowe	NNP
18637	7168	11	,	,	,
18637	7168	12	247	247	CD
18637	7168	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7168	14	165	165	CD
18637	7168	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7168	16	1918	1918	CD
18637	7168	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7168	18	;	;	:
18637	7168	19	National	National	NNP
18637	7168	20	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	7168	21	&	&	CC
18637	7168	22	Type	Type	NNP
18637	7168	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7168	24	_	_	NNP
18637	7168	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	7168	26	_	_	NNP
18637	7168	27	Bowers	Bowers	NNP
18637	7168	28	,	,	,
18637	7168	29	266	266	CD
18637	7168	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7168	31	373	373	CD
18637	7168	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7168	33	1924	1924	CD
18637	7168	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7168	35	.	.	.
18637	7169	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7169	2	1523	1523	CD
18637	7169	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7169	4	Fairbank	Fairbank	NNP
18637	7169	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7169	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7169	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7169	8	United	United	NNP
18637	7169	9	States	States	NNP
18637	7169	10	,	,	,
18637	7169	11	181	181	CD
18637	7169	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7169	13	283	283	CD
18637	7169	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7169	15	1901	1901	CD
18637	7169	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7169	17	.	.	.
18637	7170	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7170	2	1524	1524	CD
18637	7170	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7170	4	United	United	NNP
18637	7170	5	States	States	NNP
18637	7170	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7170	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7170	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7170	9	Hvoslef	Hvoslef	NNP
18637	7170	10	,	,	,
18637	7170	11	237	237	CD
18637	7170	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7170	13	1	1	CD
18637	7170	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7170	15	1915	1915	CD
18637	7170	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7170	17	.	.	.
18637	7171	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7171	2	1525	1525	CD
18637	7171	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7171	4	Thames	Thames	NNP
18637	7171	5	&	&	CC
18637	7171	6	Mersey	Mersey	NNP
18637	7171	7	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	7171	8	.	.	.
18637	7172	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7172	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7172	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7172	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7172	5	United	United	NNP
18637	7172	6	States	States	NNP
18637	7172	7	,	,	,
18637	7172	8	237	237	CD
18637	7172	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7172	10	19	19	CD
18637	7172	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7172	12	1915	1915	CD
18637	7172	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7172	14	.	.	.
18637	7173	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7173	2	1526	1526	CD
18637	7173	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7173	4	Pace	Pace	NNP
18637	7173	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7173	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7173	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7173	8	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
18637	7173	9	,	,	,
18637	7173	10	92	92	CD
18637	7173	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7173	12	372	372	CD
18637	7173	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7173	14	1876	1876	CD
18637	7173	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7173	16	;	;	:
18637	7173	17	Turpin	Turpin	NNP
18637	7173	18	&	&	CC
18637	7173	19	Bro	Bro	NNP
18637	7173	20	.	.	.
18637	7174	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7174	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	7174	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7174	4	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
18637	7174	5	,	,	,
18637	7174	6	117	117	CD
18637	7174	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7174	8	504	504	CD
18637	7174	9	,	,	,
18637	7174	10	505	505	CD
18637	7174	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7174	12	1886	1886	CD
18637	7174	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7174	14	.	.	.
18637	7175	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7175	2	1527	1527	CD
18637	7175	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7175	4	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7175	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	7175	6	Service	Service	NNP
18637	7175	7	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	7175	8	.	.	.
18637	7176	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7176	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	7176	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7176	4	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	7176	5	&	&	CC
18637	7176	6	N.O.R.	N.O.R.	NNP
18637	7177	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7177	2	,	,	,
18637	7177	3	284	284	CD
18637	7177	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7177	5	125	125	CD
18637	7177	6	,	,	,
18637	7177	7	131	131	CD
18637	7177	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7177	9	1931	1931	CD
18637	7177	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7177	11	;	;	:
18637	7177	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7177	13	_	_	NNP
18637	7177	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	7177	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7177	16	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	7177	17	&	&	CC
18637	7177	18	Belmont	Belmont	NNP
18637	7177	19	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	7177	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7177	21	,	,	,
18637	7177	22	18	18	CD
18637	7177	23	How	how	WRB
18637	7177	24	.	.	.
18637	7178	1	421	421	CD
18637	7178	2	,	,	,
18637	7178	3	433	433	CD
18637	7178	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7178	5	1856	1856	CD
18637	7178	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7178	7	;	;	:
18637	7178	8	South	South	NNP
18637	7178	9	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	7178	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7178	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	7178	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7178	13	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	7178	14	,	,	,
18637	7178	15	93	93	CD
18637	7178	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7178	17	4	4	CD
18637	7178	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7178	19	1876	1876	CD
18637	7178	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7178	21	.	.	.
18637	7179	1	In	in	IN
18637	7179	2	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	7179	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7179	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	7179	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7179	6	United	United	NNP
18637	7179	7	States	States	NNP
18637	7179	8	,	,	,
18637	7179	9	255	255	CD
18637	7179	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7179	11	336	336	CD
18637	7179	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7179	13	1921	1921	CD
18637	7179	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7179	15	the	the	DT
18637	7179	16	argument	argument	NN
18637	7179	17	that	that	IN
18637	7179	18	an	an	DT
18637	7179	19	act	act	NN
18637	7179	20	of	of	IN
18637	7179	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7179	22	which	which	WDT
18637	7179	23	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	7179	24	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	7179	25	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	7179	26	of	of	IN
18637	7179	27	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	7179	28	into	into	IN
18637	7179	29	States	States	NNPS
18637	7179	30	whose	whose	WP$
18637	7179	31	laws	law	NNS
18637	7179	32	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	7179	33	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	7179	34	or	or	CC
18637	7179	35	sale	sale	NN
18637	7179	36	of	of	IN
18637	7179	37	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	7179	38	for	for	IN
18637	7179	39	beverage	beverage	NN
18637	7179	40	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	7179	41	was	be	VBD
18637	7179	42	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	7179	43	to	to	IN
18637	7179	44	this	this	DT
18637	7179	45	clause	clause	NN
18637	7179	46	was	be	VBD
18637	7179	47	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	7179	48	as	as	RB
18637	7179	49	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	7179	50	wanting	want	VBG
18637	7179	51	in	in	IN
18637	7179	52	merit	merit	NN
18637	7179	53	.	.	.
18637	7180	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7180	2	1528	1528	CD
18637	7180	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7180	4	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7180	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	7180	6	Service	Service	NNP
18637	7180	7	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	7180	8	.	.	.
18637	7181	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7181	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	7181	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7181	4	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	7181	5	&	&	CC
18637	7181	6	N.O.R.	N.O.R.	NNP
18637	7182	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7182	2	,	,	,
18637	7182	3	284	284	CD
18637	7182	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7182	5	125	125	CD
18637	7182	6	,	,	,
18637	7182	7	132	132	CD
18637	7182	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7182	9	1931	1931	CD
18637	7182	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7182	11	.	.	.
18637	7183	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7183	2	1529	1529	CD
18637	7183	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7183	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	7183	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7183	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7183	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7183	8	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	7183	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7183	10	Passenger	Passenger	NNP
18637	7183	11	Cases	Cases	NNP
18637	7183	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7183	13	,	,	,
18637	7183	14	7	7	CD
18637	7183	15	How	how	WRB
18637	7183	16	.	.	.
18637	7184	1	283	283	CD
18637	7184	2	,	,	,
18637	7184	3	414	414	CD
18637	7184	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7184	5	1849	1849	CD
18637	7184	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7184	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7184	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	7184	9	of	of	IN
18637	7184	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7184	11	Wayne	Wayne	NNP
18637	7184	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7184	13	;	;	:
18637	7184	14	_	_	NNP
18637	7184	15	cf	cf	NNP
18637	7184	16	.	.	.
18637	7184	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7184	18	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	7184	19	_	_	NNP
18637	7184	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	7184	21	_	_	NNP
18637	7184	22	Board	Board	NNP
18637	7184	23	of	of	IN
18637	7184	24	Port	Port	NNP
18637	7184	25	Wardens	Wardens	NNP
18637	7184	26	,	,	,
18637	7184	27	12	12	CD
18637	7184	28	How	how	WRB
18637	7184	29	.	.	.
18637	7185	1	299	299	CD
18637	7185	2	,	,	,
18637	7185	3	314	314	CD
18637	7185	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7185	5	1851	1851	CD
18637	7185	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7185	7	.	.	.
18637	7186	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7186	2	1530	1530	CD
18637	7186	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7186	4	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	7186	5	's	's	POS
18637	7186	6	L.	L.	NNP
18637	7186	7	&	&	CC
18637	7186	8	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	7187	1	&	&	CC
18637	7187	2	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	7187	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7187	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7187	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	7187	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7187	7	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7187	8	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	7187	9	.	.	.
18637	7188	1	of	of	IN
18637	7188	2	Health	Health	NNP
18637	7188	3	,	,	,
18637	7188	4	118	118	CD
18637	7188	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7188	6	455	455	CD
18637	7188	7	,	,	,
18637	7188	8	467	467	CD
18637	7188	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7188	10	1886	1886	CD
18637	7188	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7188	12	.	.	.
18637	7189	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7189	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7189	3	also	also	RB
18637	7189	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7189	5	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	7189	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7189	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7189	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7189	9	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	7189	10	,	,	,
18637	7189	11	94	94	CD
18637	7189	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7189	13	113	113	CD
18637	7189	14	,	,	,
18637	7189	15	135	135	CD
18637	7189	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7189	17	1877	1877	CD
18637	7189	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7189	19	;	;	:
18637	7189	20	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	7189	21	_	_	NNP
18637	7189	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	7189	23	_	_	NNP
18637	7189	24	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	7189	25	&	&	CC
18637	7189	26	P.	P.	NNP
18637	7189	27	Elevator	Elevator	NNP
18637	7189	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7189	29	,	,	,
18637	7189	30	119	119	CD
18637	7189	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7189	32	388	388	CD
18637	7189	33	,	,	,
18637	7189	34	400	400	CD
18637	7189	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7189	36	1886	1886	CD
18637	7189	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7189	38	.	.	.
18637	7190	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7190	2	1531	1531	CD
18637	7190	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7190	4	1	1	CD
18637	7190	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	7190	6	.	.	.
18637	7191	1	53	53	CD
18637	7191	2	,	,	,
18637	7191	3	54	54	CD
18637	7191	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7191	5	1789	1789	CD
18637	7191	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7191	7	.	.	.
18637	7192	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7192	2	1532	1532	CD
18637	7192	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7192	4	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	7192	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7192	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7192	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7192	8	Darden	Darden	NNP
18637	7192	9	,	,	,
18637	7192	10	198	198	CD
18637	7192	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7192	12	310	310	CD
18637	7192	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7192	14	1905	1905	CD
18637	7192	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7192	16	.	.	.
18637	7193	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7193	2	1533	1533	CD
18637	7193	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7193	4	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	7193	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7193	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7193	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7193	8	Troy	Troy	NNP
18637	7193	9	,	,	,
18637	7193	10	258	258	CD
18637	7193	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7193	12	101	101	CD
18637	7193	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7193	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	7193	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7193	16	.	.	.
18637	7194	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7194	2	1534	1534	CD
18637	7194	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7194	4	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	7194	5	Soap	Soap	NNP
18637	7194	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7194	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7194	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7194	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7194	10	United	United	NNP
18637	7194	11	States	States	NNP
18637	7194	12	,	,	,
18637	7194	13	301	301	CD
18637	7194	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7194	15	308	308	CD
18637	7194	16	,	,	,
18637	7194	17	321	321	CD
18637	7194	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7194	19	1937	1937	CD
18637	7194	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7194	21	;	;	:
18637	7194	22	Knote	Knote	NNP
18637	7194	23	_	_	NNP
18637	7194	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	7194	25	_	_	NNP
18637	7194	26	United	United	NNP
18637	7194	27	States	States	NNP
18637	7194	28	,	,	,
18637	7194	29	95	95	CD
18637	7194	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7194	31	149	149	CD
18637	7194	32	,	,	,
18637	7194	33	154	154	CD
18637	7194	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7194	35	1877	1877	CD
18637	7194	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7194	37	.	.	.
18637	7195	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7195	2	1535	1535	CD
18637	7195	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7195	4	United	United	NNP
18637	7195	5	States	States	NNP
18637	7195	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7195	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7195	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7195	9	Price	Price	NNP
18637	7195	10	,	,	,
18637	7195	11	116	116	CD
18637	7195	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7195	13	43	43	CD
18637	7195	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7195	15	1885	1885	CD
18637	7195	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7195	17	;	;	:
18637	7195	18	United	United	NNP
18637	7195	19	States	States	NNP
18637	7195	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7195	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	7195	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7195	23	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	7195	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7195	25	,	,	,
18637	7195	26	163	163	CD
18637	7195	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7195	28	427	427	CD
18637	7195	29	,	,	,
18637	7195	30	439	439	CD
18637	7195	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7195	32	1896	1896	CD
18637	7195	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7195	34	;	;	:
18637	7195	35	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	7195	36	_	_	NNP
18637	7195	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	7195	38	_	_	NNP
18637	7195	39	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	7195	40	,	,	,
18637	7195	41	173	173	CD
18637	7195	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7195	43	389	389	CD
18637	7195	44	,	,	,
18637	7195	45	393	393	CD
18637	7195	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7195	47	1899	1899	CD
18637	7195	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7195	49	.	.	.
18637	7196	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7196	2	1536	1536	CD
18637	7196	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7196	4	Hart	Hart	NNP
18637	7196	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7196	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7196	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7196	8	United	United	NNP
18637	7196	9	States	States	NNP
18637	7196	10	,	,	,
18637	7196	11	118	118	CD
18637	7196	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7196	13	62	62	CD
18637	7196	14	,	,	,
18637	7196	15	67	67	CD
18637	7196	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7196	17	1886	1886	CD
18637	7196	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7196	19	.	.	.
18637	7197	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7197	2	1537	1537	CD
18637	7197	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7197	4	32	32	CD
18637	7197	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	7197	6	.	.	.
18637	7198	1	388	388	CD
18637	7198	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7198	3	1902	1902	CD
18637	7198	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7198	5	.	.	.
18637	7199	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7199	2	1538	1538	CD
18637	7199	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7199	4	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	7199	5	Soap	Soap	NNP
18637	7199	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7199	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7199	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7199	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7199	10	United	United	NNP
18637	7199	11	States	States	NNP
18637	7199	12	,	,	,
18637	7199	13	301	301	CD
18637	7199	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7199	15	308	308	CD
18637	7199	16	,	,	,
18637	7199	17	322	322	CD
18637	7199	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7199	19	1937	1937	CD
18637	7199	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7199	21	.	.	.
18637	7200	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7200	2	1539	1539	CD
18637	7200	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7200	4	Reeside	Reeside	NNP
18637	7200	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7200	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7200	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7200	8	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	7200	9	,	,	,
18637	7200	10	11	11	CD
18637	7200	11	How	how	WRB
18637	7200	12	.	.	.
18637	7201	1	272	272	CD
18637	7201	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7201	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	7201	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7201	5	.	.	.
18637	7202	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7202	2	1540	1540	CD
18637	7202	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7202	4	United	United	NNP
18637	7202	5	States	States	NNP
18637	7202	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7202	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7202	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7202	9	Klein	Klein	NNP
18637	7202	10	,	,	,
18637	7202	11	13	13	CD
18637	7202	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7202	13	.	.	.
18637	7203	1	128	128	CD
18637	7203	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7203	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	7203	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7203	5	.	.	.
18637	7204	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7204	2	1541	1541	CD
18637	7204	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7204	4	Knote	Knote	NNP
18637	7204	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7204	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7204	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7204	8	United	United	NNP
18637	7204	9	States	States	NNP
18637	7204	10	,	,	,
18637	7204	11	95	95	CD
18637	7204	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7204	13	149	149	CD
18637	7204	14	,	,	,
18637	7204	15	154	154	CD
18637	7204	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7204	17	1877	1877	CD
18637	7204	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7204	19	;	;	:
18637	7204	20	Austin	Austin	NNP
18637	7204	21	_	_	NNP
18637	7204	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	7204	23	_	_	NNP
18637	7204	24	United	United	NNP
18637	7204	25	States	States	NNP
18637	7204	26	,	,	,
18637	7204	27	155	155	CD
18637	7204	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7204	29	417	417	CD
18637	7204	30	,	,	,
18637	7204	31	427	427	CD
18637	7204	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7204	33	1894	1894	CD
18637	7204	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7204	35	.	.	.
18637	7205	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7205	2	1542	1542	CD
18637	7205	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7205	4	Hart	Hart	NNP
18637	7205	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7205	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7205	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7205	8	United	United	NNP
18637	7205	9	States	States	NNP
18637	7205	10	,	,	,
18637	7205	11	118	118	CD
18637	7205	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7205	13	62	62	CD
18637	7205	14	,	,	,
18637	7205	15	67	67	CD
18637	7205	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7205	17	1886	1886	CD
18637	7205	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7205	19	.	.	.
18637	7206	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7206	2	1543	1543	CD
18637	7206	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7206	4	13	13	CD
18637	7206	5	Op	Op	NNP
18637	7206	6	.	.	.
18637	7207	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	7207	2	.	.	.
18637	7208	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	7208	2	538	538	CD
18637	7208	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7208	4	1871	1871	CD
18637	7208	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7208	6	.	.	.
18637	7209	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7209	2	1544	1544	CD
18637	7209	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7209	4	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	7209	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7209	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7209	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7209	8	Bruffy	Bruffy	NNP
18637	7209	9	,	,	,
18637	7209	10	96	96	CD
18637	7209	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7209	12	176	176	CD
18637	7209	13	,	,	,
18637	7209	14	183	183	CD
18637	7209	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7209	16	1878	1878	CD
18637	7209	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7209	18	.	.	.
18637	7210	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7210	2	1545	1545	CD
18637	7210	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7210	4	14	14	CD
18637	7210	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7210	6	.	.	.
18637	7211	1	540	540	CD
18637	7211	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7211	3	1840	1840	CD
18637	7211	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7211	5	.	.	.
18637	7212	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7212	2	1546	1546	CD
18637	7212	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7212	4	United	United	NNP
18637	7212	5	States	States	NNP
18637	7212	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7212	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7212	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7212	9	California	California	NNP
18637	7212	10	,	,	,
18637	7212	11	332	332	CD
18637	7212	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7212	13	19	19	CD
18637	7212	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7212	15	1947	1947	CD
18637	7212	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7212	17	.	.	.
18637	7213	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7213	2	1547	1547	CD
18637	7213	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7213	4	313	313	CD
18637	7213	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7213	6	69	69	CD
18637	7213	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7213	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	7213	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7213	10	.	.	.
18637	7214	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7214	2	1548	1548	CD
18637	7214	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7214	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7214	5	.	.	.
18637	7215	1	78	78	CD
18637	7215	2	-	-	SYM
18637	7215	3	79	79	CD
18637	7215	4	.	.	.
18637	7216	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7216	2	1549	1549	CD
18637	7216	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7216	4	Craig	Craig	NNP
18637	7216	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7216	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7216	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7216	8	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	7216	9	,	,	,
18637	7216	10	4	4	CD
18637	7216	11	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	7216	12	.	.	.
18637	7217	1	410	410	CD
18637	7217	2	,	,	,
18637	7217	3	425	425	CD
18637	7217	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7217	5	1830	1830	CD
18637	7217	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7217	7	;	;	:
18637	7217	8	Byrne	Byrne	NNP
18637	7217	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7217	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7217	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7217	12	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	7217	13	,	,	,
18637	7217	14	8	8	CD
18637	7217	15	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7217	16	.	.	.
18637	7218	1	40	40	CD
18637	7218	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7218	3	1834	1834	CD
18637	7218	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7218	5	.	.	.
18637	7219	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7219	2	1550	1550	CD
18637	7219	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7219	4	Poindexter	Poindexter	NNP
18637	7219	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7219	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7219	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7219	8	Greenhow	Greenhow	NNP
18637	7219	9	,	,	,
18637	7219	10	114	114	CD
18637	7219	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7219	12	270	270	CD
18637	7219	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7219	14	1885	1885	CD
18637	7219	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7219	16	;	;	:
18637	7219	17	Chaffin	Chaffin	NNP
18637	7219	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7219	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	7219	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7219	21	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	7219	22	,	,	,
18637	7219	23	116	116	CD
18637	7219	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7219	25	567	567	CD
18637	7219	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7219	27	1886	1886	CD
18637	7219	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7219	29	.	.	.
18637	7220	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7220	2	1551	1551	CD
18637	7220	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7220	4	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	7220	5	&	&	CC
18637	7220	6	T.C.R.	T.C.R.	NNP
18637	7221	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7221	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7221	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7221	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7221	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	7221	6	,	,	,
18637	7221	7	177	177	CD
18637	7221	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7221	9	66	66	CD
18637	7221	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7221	11	1900	1900	CD
18637	7221	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7221	13	.	.	.
18637	7222	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7222	2	1552	1552	CD
18637	7222	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7222	4	Briscoe	Briscoe	NNP
18637	7222	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7222	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7222	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7222	8	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7222	9	of	of	IN
18637	7222	10	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	7222	11	,	,	,
18637	7222	12	11	11	CD
18637	7222	13	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7222	14	.	.	.
18637	7223	1	257	257	CD
18637	7223	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7223	3	1837	1837	CD
18637	7223	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7223	5	.	.	.
18637	7224	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7224	2	1553	1553	CD
18637	7224	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7224	4	Darrington	Darrington	NNP
18637	7224	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7224	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7224	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7224	8	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7224	9	of	of	IN
18637	7224	10	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	7224	11	,	,	,
18637	7224	12	13	13	CD
18637	7224	13	How	how	WRB
18637	7224	14	.	.	.
18637	7225	1	12	12	CD
18637	7225	2	,	,	,
18637	7225	3	15	15	CD
18637	7225	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7225	5	1851	1851	CD
18637	7225	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7225	7	;	;	:
18637	7225	8	Curran	Curran	NNP
18637	7225	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7225	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7225	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7225	12	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	7225	13	,	,	,
18637	7225	14	15	15	CD
18637	7225	15	How	how	WRB
18637	7225	16	.	.	.
18637	7226	1	304	304	CD
18637	7226	2	,	,	,
18637	7226	3	317	317	CD
18637	7226	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7226	5	1853	1853	CD
18637	7226	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7226	7	.	.	.
18637	7227	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7227	2	1554	1554	CD
18637	7227	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7227	4	Briscoe	Briscoe	NNP
18637	7227	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7227	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7227	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7227	8	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7227	9	of	of	IN
18637	7227	10	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	7227	11	,	,	,
18637	7227	12	11	11	CD
18637	7227	13	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7227	14	.	.	.
18637	7228	1	257	257	CD
18637	7228	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7228	3	1837	1837	CD
18637	7228	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7228	5	.	.	.
18637	7229	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7229	2	1555	1555	CD
18637	7229	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7229	4	Woodruff	Woodruff	NNP
18637	7229	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7229	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7229	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7229	8	Trapnall	Trapnall	NNP
18637	7229	9	,	,	,
18637	7229	10	10	10	CD
18637	7229	11	How	how	WRB
18637	7229	12	.	.	.
18637	7230	1	190	190	CD
18637	7230	2	,	,	,
18637	7230	3	205	205	CD
18637	7230	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7230	5	1851	1851	CD
18637	7230	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7230	7	.	.	.
18637	7231	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7231	2	1556	1556	CD
18637	7231	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7231	4	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	7231	5	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	7231	6	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	7231	7	,	,	,
18637	7231	8	110	110	CD
18637	7231	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7231	10	421	421	CD
18637	7231	11	,	,	,
18637	7231	12	446	446	CD
18637	7231	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7231	14	1884	1884	CD
18637	7231	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7231	16	.	.	.
18637	7232	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7232	2	1557	1557	CD
18637	7232	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7232	4	Gwin	Gwin	NNP
18637	7232	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7232	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7232	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7232	8	Breedlove	Breedlove	NNP
18637	7232	9	,	,	,
18637	7232	10	2	2	CD
18637	7232	11	How	how	WRB
18637	7232	12	.	.	.
18637	7233	1	29	29	CD
18637	7233	2	,	,	,
18637	7233	3	38	38	CD
18637	7233	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7233	5	1844	1844	CD
18637	7233	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7233	7	.	.	.
18637	7234	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7234	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7234	3	also	also	RB
18637	7234	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7234	5	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	7234	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7234	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7234	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7234	9	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	7234	10	,	,	,
18637	7234	11	2	2	CD
18637	7234	12	How	how	WRB
18637	7234	13	.	.	.
18637	7235	1	244	244	CD
18637	7235	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7235	3	1844	1844	CD
18637	7235	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7235	5	.	.	.
18637	7236	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7236	2	1558	1558	CD
18637	7236	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7236	4	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	7236	5	&	&	CC
18637	7236	6	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	7236	7	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7236	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7236	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7236	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7236	11	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	7236	12	Reserve	Reserve	NNP
18637	7236	13	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7236	14	,	,	,
18637	7236	15	262	262	CD
18637	7236	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7236	17	649	649	CD
18637	7236	18	,	,	,
18637	7236	19	659	659	CD
18637	7236	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7236	21	1923	1923	CD
18637	7236	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7236	23	.	.	.
18637	7237	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7237	2	1559	1559	CD
18637	7237	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7237	4	Cummings	Cummings	NNP
18637	7237	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7237	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7237	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7237	8	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	7237	9	,	,	,
18637	7237	10	4	4	CD
18637	7237	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7237	12	.	.	.
18637	7238	1	277	277	CD
18637	7238	2	,	,	,
18637	7238	3	323	323	CD
18637	7238	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7238	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	7238	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7238	7	;	;	:
18637	7238	8	Klinger	Klinger	NNP
18637	7238	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7238	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7238	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7238	12	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	7238	13	,	,	,
18637	7238	14	13	13	CD
18637	7238	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7238	16	.	.	.
18637	7239	1	257	257	CD
18637	7239	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7239	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	7239	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7239	5	;	;	:
18637	7239	6	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	7239	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7239	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7239	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7239	10	Carskadon	Carskadon	NNP
18637	7239	11	,	,	,
18637	7239	12	16	16	CD
18637	7239	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7239	14	.	.	.
18637	7240	1	234	234	CD
18637	7240	2	,	,	,
18637	7240	3	239	239	CD
18637	7240	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7240	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	7240	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7240	7	.	.	.
18637	7241	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7241	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7241	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7241	4	p.	p.	NN
18637	7241	5	317	317	CD
18637	7241	6	,	,	,
18637	7241	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7241	8	supra	supra	NNP
18637	7241	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7241	10	,	,	,
18637	7241	11	and	and	CC
18637	7241	12	p.	p.	NN
18637	7241	13	327	327	CD
18637	7241	14	,	,	,
18637	7241	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7241	16	post	post	NN
18637	7241	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7241	18	.	.	.
18637	7242	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7242	2	1560	1560	CD
18637	7242	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7242	4	Calder	Calder	NNP
18637	7242	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7242	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7242	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7242	8	Bull	Bull	NNP
18637	7242	9	,	,	,
18637	7242	10	3	3	CD
18637	7242	11	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	7242	12	.	.	.
18637	7243	1	386	386	CD
18637	7243	2	,	,	,
18637	7243	3	390	390	CD
18637	7243	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7243	5	1798	1798	CD
18637	7243	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7243	7	;	;	:
18637	7243	8	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	7243	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7243	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7243	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7243	12	Mercer	Mercer	NNP
18637	7243	13	,	,	,
18637	7243	14	8	8	CD
18637	7243	15	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7243	16	.	.	.
18637	7244	1	88	88	CD
18637	7244	2	,	,	,
18637	7244	3	110	110	CD
18637	7244	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7244	5	1834	1834	CD
18637	7244	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7244	7	;	;	:
18637	7244	8	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	7244	9	&	&	CC
18637	7244	10	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	7245	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7245	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7245	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7245	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7245	5	Nesbit	Nesbit	NNP
18637	7245	6	,	,	,
18637	7245	7	10	10	CD
18637	7245	8	How	how	WRB
18637	7245	9	.	.	.
18637	7246	1	395	395	CD
18637	7246	2	,	,	,
18637	7246	3	401	401	CD
18637	7246	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7246	5	1850	1850	CD
18637	7246	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7246	7	;	;	:
18637	7246	8	Carpenter	Carpenter	NNP
18637	7246	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7246	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7246	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7246	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7246	13	,	,	,
18637	7246	14	17	17	CD
18637	7246	15	How	how	WRB
18637	7246	16	.	.	.
18637	7247	1	456	456	CD
18637	7247	2	,	,	,
18637	7247	3	463	463	CD
18637	7247	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7247	5	1855	1855	CD
18637	7247	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7247	7	;	;	:
18637	7247	8	Loche	Loche	NNP
18637	7247	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7247	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7247	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7247	12	New	New	NNP
18637	7247	13	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7247	14	,	,	,
18637	7247	15	4	4	CD
18637	7247	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7247	17	.	.	.
18637	7248	1	172	172	CD
18637	7248	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7248	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	7248	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7248	5	;	;	:
18637	7248	6	Orr	Orr	NNP
18637	7248	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7248	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7248	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7248	10	Gilman	Gilman	NNP
18637	7248	11	,	,	,
18637	7248	12	183	183	CD
18637	7248	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7248	14	278	278	CD
18637	7248	15	,	,	,
18637	7248	16	285	285	CD
18637	7248	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7248	18	1902	1902	CD
18637	7248	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7248	20	;	;	:
18637	7248	21	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	7248	22	Union	Union	NNP
18637	7248	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7248	24	_	_	NNP
18637	7248	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	7248	26	_	_	NNP
18637	7248	27	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	7248	28	,	,	,
18637	7248	29	219	219	CD
18637	7248	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7248	31	140	140	CD
18637	7248	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7248	33	1911	1911	CD
18637	7248	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7248	35	.	.	.
18637	7249	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7249	2	1561	1561	CD
18637	7249	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7249	4	Frank	Frank	NNP
18637	7249	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7249	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7249	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7249	8	Mangum	Mangum	NNP
18637	7249	9	,	,	,
18637	7249	10	237	237	CD
18637	7249	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7249	12	300	300	CD
18637	7249	13	,	,	,
18637	7249	14	344	344	CD
18637	7249	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7249	16	1915	1915	CD
18637	7249	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7249	18	;	;	:
18637	7249	19	Ross	Ross	NNP
18637	7249	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7249	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	7249	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7249	23	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	7249	24	,	,	,
18637	7249	25	227	227	CD
18637	7249	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7249	27	150	150	CD
18637	7249	28	,	,	,
18637	7249	29	161	161	CD
18637	7249	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7249	31	1913	1913	CD
18637	7249	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7249	33	.	.	.
18637	7250	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7250	2	1562	1562	CD
18637	7250	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7250	4	Jaehne	Jaehne	NNP
18637	7250	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7250	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7250	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7250	8	New	New	NNP
18637	7250	9	York	York	NNP
18637	7250	10	,	,	,
18637	7250	11	128	128	CD
18637	7250	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7250	13	189	189	CD
18637	7250	14	,	,	,
18637	7250	15	190	190	CD
18637	7250	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7250	17	1888	1888	CD
18637	7250	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7250	19	.	.	.
18637	7251	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7251	2	1563	1563	CD
18637	7251	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7251	4	Rooney	Rooney	NNP
18637	7251	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7251	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7251	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7251	8	North	North	NNP
18637	7251	9	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	7251	10	,	,	,
18637	7251	11	196	196	CD
18637	7251	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7251	13	319	319	CD
18637	7251	14	,	,	,
18637	7251	15	325	325	CD
18637	7251	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7251	17	1905	1905	CD
18637	7251	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7251	19	.	.	.
18637	7252	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7252	2	1564	1564	CD
18637	7252	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7252	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	7252	5	&	&	CC
18637	7252	6	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	7253	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7253	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7253	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7253	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7253	5	Tranbarger	Tranbarger	NNP
18637	7253	6	,	,	,
18637	7253	7	238	238	CD
18637	7253	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7253	9	67	67	CD
18637	7253	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7253	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	7253	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7253	13	.	.	.
18637	7254	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7254	2	1565	1565	CD
18637	7254	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7254	4	Samuels	Samuels	NNPS
18637	7254	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7254	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7254	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7254	8	McCurdy	McCurdy	NNP
18637	7254	9	,	,	,
18637	7254	10	267	267	CD
18637	7254	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7254	12	188	188	CD
18637	7254	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7254	14	1925	1925	CD
18637	7254	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7254	16	.	.	.
18637	7255	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7255	2	1566	1566	CD
18637	7255	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7255	4	Hawker	Hawker	NNP
18637	7255	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7255	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7255	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7255	8	New	New	NNP
18637	7255	9	York	York	NNP
18637	7255	10	,	,	,
18637	7255	11	170	170	CD
18637	7255	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7255	13	189	189	CD
18637	7255	14	,	,	,
18637	7255	15	190	190	CD
18637	7255	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7255	17	1898	1898	CD
18637	7255	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7255	19	.	.	.
18637	7256	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7256	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7256	3	also	also	RB
18637	7256	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7256	5	Reetz	Reetz	NNP
18637	7256	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7256	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7256	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7256	9	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	7256	10	,	,	,
18637	7256	11	188	188	CD
18637	7256	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7256	13	505	505	CD
18637	7256	14	,	,	,
18637	7256	15	509	509	CD
18637	7256	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7256	17	1903	1903	CD
18637	7256	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7256	19	;	;	:
18637	7256	20	Lehmann	Lehmann	NNP
18637	7256	21	_	_	NNP
18637	7256	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	7256	23	_	_	NNP
18637	7256	24	State	State	NNP
18637	7256	25	Board	Board	NNP
18637	7256	26	of	of	IN
18637	7256	27	Public	Public	NNP
18637	7256	28	Accountancy	Accountancy	NNP
18637	7256	29	,	,	,
18637	7256	30	263	263	CD
18637	7256	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7256	32	394	394	CD
18637	7256	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7256	34	1923	1923	CD
18637	7256	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7256	36	.	.	.
18637	7257	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7257	2	1567	1567	CD
18637	7257	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7257	4	Cummings	Cummings	NNP
18637	7257	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7257	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7257	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7257	8	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	7257	9	,	,	,
18637	7257	10	4	4	CD
18637	7257	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7257	12	.	.	.
18637	7258	1	277	277	CD
18637	7258	2	,	,	,
18637	7258	3	316	316	CD
18637	7258	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7258	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	7258	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7258	7	.	.	.
18637	7259	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7259	2	1568	1568	CD
18637	7259	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7259	4	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	7259	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7259	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7259	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7259	8	Carskadon	Carskadon	NNP
18637	7259	9	,	,	,
18637	7259	10	16	16	CD
18637	7259	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7259	12	.	.	.
18637	7260	1	234	234	CD
18637	7260	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7260	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	7260	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7260	5	.	.	.
18637	7261	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7261	2	1569	1569	CD
18637	7261	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7261	4	Lindsey	Lindsey	NNP
18637	7261	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7261	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7261	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7261	8	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	7261	9	,	,	,
18637	7261	10	301	301	CD
18637	7261	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7261	12	397	397	CD
18637	7261	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7261	14	1937	1937	CD
18637	7261	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7261	16	.	.	.
18637	7262	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7262	2	1570	1570	CD
18637	7262	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7262	4	Kring	Kring	NNP
18637	7262	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7262	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7262	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7262	8	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	7262	9	,	,	,
18637	7262	10	107	107	CD
18637	7262	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7262	12	221	221	CD
18637	7262	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7262	14	1883	1883	CD
18637	7262	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7262	16	.	.	.
18637	7263	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7263	2	1571	1571	CD
18637	7263	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7263	4	Holden	Holden	NNP
18637	7263	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7263	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7263	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7263	8	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	7263	9	,	,	,
18637	7263	10	137	137	CD
18637	7263	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7263	12	483	483	CD
18637	7263	13	,	,	,
18637	7263	14	491	491	CD
18637	7263	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7263	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	7263	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7263	18	.	.	.
18637	7264	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7264	2	1572	1572	CD
18637	7264	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7264	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	7264	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	7264	6	Medley	Medley	NNP
18637	7264	7	,	,	,
18637	7264	8	134	134	CD
18637	7264	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7264	10	160	160	CD
18637	7264	11	,	,	,
18637	7264	12	171	171	CD
18637	7264	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7264	14	1890	1890	CD
18637	7264	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7264	16	.	.	.
18637	7265	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7265	2	1573	1573	CD
18637	7265	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7265	4	Gryger	Gryger	NNP
18637	7265	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7265	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7265	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7265	8	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	7265	9	,	,	,
18637	7265	10	334	334	CD
18637	7265	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7265	12	728	728	CD
18637	7265	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7265	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	7265	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7265	16	;	;	:
18637	7265	17	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	7265	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7265	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	7265	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7265	21	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	7265	22	,	,	,
18637	7265	23	180	180	CD
18637	7265	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7265	25	311	311	CD
18637	7265	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7265	27	1901	1901	CD
18637	7265	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7265	29	;	;	:
18637	7265	30	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	7265	31	_	_	NNP
18637	7265	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	7265	33	_	_	NNP
18637	7265	34	West	West	NNP
18637	7265	35	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7265	36	,	,	,
18637	7265	37	224	224	CD
18637	7265	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7265	39	616	616	CD
18637	7265	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7265	41	1912	1912	CD
18637	7265	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7265	43	.	.	.
18637	7266	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7266	2	1574	1574	CD
18637	7266	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7266	4	Malloy	Malloy	NNP
18637	7266	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7266	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7266	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7266	8	South	South	NNP
18637	7266	9	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	7266	10	,	,	,
18637	7266	11	237	237	CD
18637	7266	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7266	13	180	180	CD
18637	7266	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7266	15	1915	1915	CD
18637	7266	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7266	17	.	.	.
18637	7267	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7267	2	1575	1575	CD
18637	7267	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7267	4	Rooney	Rooney	NNP
18637	7267	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7267	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7267	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7267	8	North	North	NNP
18637	7267	9	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	7267	10	,	,	,
18637	7267	11	196	196	CD
18637	7267	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7267	13	319	319	CD
18637	7267	14	,	,	,
18637	7267	15	324	324	CD
18637	7267	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7267	17	1905	1905	CD
18637	7267	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7267	19	.	.	.
18637	7268	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7268	2	1576	1576	CD
18637	7268	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7268	4	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	7268	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7268	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7268	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7268	8	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	7268	9	,	,	,
18637	7268	10	162	162	CD
18637	7268	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7268	12	565	565	CD
18637	7268	13	,	,	,
18637	7268	14	590	590	CD
18637	7268	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7268	16	1896	1896	CD
18637	7268	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7268	18	.	.	.
18637	7269	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7269	2	1577	1577	CD
18637	7269	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7269	4	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	7269	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7269	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7269	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7269	8	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	7269	9	,	,	,
18637	7269	10	152	152	CD
18637	7269	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7269	12	377	377	CD
18637	7269	13	,	,	,
18637	7269	14	382	382	CD
18637	7269	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7269	16	1894	1894	CD
18637	7269	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7269	18	.	.	.
18637	7270	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7270	2	1578	1578	CD
18637	7270	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7270	4	Gut	Gut	NNP
18637	7270	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7270	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7270	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7270	8	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	7270	9	,	,	,
18637	7270	10	9	9	CD
18637	7270	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7270	12	.	.	.
18637	7271	1	35	35	CD
18637	7271	2	,	,	,
18637	7271	3	37	37	CD
18637	7271	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7271	5	1870	1870	CD
18637	7271	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7271	7	.	.	.
18637	7272	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7272	2	1579	1579	CD
18637	7272	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7272	4	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	7272	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7272	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7272	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7272	8	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	7272	9	,	,	,
18637	7272	10	152	152	CD
18637	7272	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7272	12	377	377	CD
18637	7272	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7272	14	1894	1894	CD
18637	7272	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7272	16	.	.	.
18637	7273	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7273	2	1580	1580	CD
18637	7273	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7273	4	Mallett	Mallett	NNP
18637	7273	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7273	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7273	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7273	8	North	North	NNP
18637	7273	9	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	7273	10	,	,	,
18637	7273	11	181	181	CD
18637	7273	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7273	13	589	589	CD
18637	7273	14	,	,	,
18637	7273	15	593	593	CD
18637	7273	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7273	17	1901	1901	CD
18637	7273	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7273	19	.	.	.
18637	7274	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7274	2	1581	1581	CD
18637	7274	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7274	4	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	7274	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7274	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7274	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7274	8	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	7274	9	,	,	,
18637	7274	10	162	162	CD
18637	7274	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7274	12	565	565	CD
18637	7274	13	,	,	,
18637	7274	14	588	588	CD
18637	7274	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7274	16	1896	1896	CD
18637	7274	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7274	18	.	.	.
18637	7275	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7275	2	1582	1582	CD
18637	7275	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7275	4	Beazell	Beazell	NNP
18637	7275	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7275	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7275	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7275	8	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	7275	9	,	,	,
18637	7275	10	269	269	CD
18637	7275	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7275	12	167	167	CD
18637	7275	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7275	14	1925	1925	CD
18637	7275	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7275	16	.	.	.
18637	7276	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7276	2	1583	1583	CD
18637	7276	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7276	4	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	7276	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7276	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7276	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7276	8	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	7276	9	,	,	,
18637	7276	10	171	171	CD
18637	7276	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7276	12	380	380	CD
18637	7276	13	,	,	,
18637	7276	14	381	381	CD
18637	7276	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7276	16	1898	1898	CD
18637	7276	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7276	18	.	.	.
18637	7277	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7277	2	1584	1584	CD
18637	7277	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7277	4	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	7277	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7277	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7277	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7277	8	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	7277	9	,	,	,
18637	7277	10	170	170	CD
18637	7277	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7277	12	343	343	CD
18637	7277	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7277	14	1898	1898	CD
18637	7277	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7277	16	.	.	.
18637	7278	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7278	2	1585	1585	CD
18637	7278	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7278	4	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	7278	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7278	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7278	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7278	8	Woolsey	Woolsey	NNP
18637	7278	9	,	,	,
18637	7278	10	18	18	CD
18637	7278	11	How	how	WRB
18637	7278	12	.	.	.
18637	7279	1	331	331	CD
18637	7279	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7279	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	7279	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7279	5	;	;	:
18637	7279	6	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	7279	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7279	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7279	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7279	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7279	11	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	7279	12	,	,	,
18637	7279	13	10	10	CD
18637	7279	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7279	15	.	.	.
18637	7280	1	511	511	CD
18637	7280	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7280	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	7280	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7280	5	;	;	:
18637	7280	6	New	New	NNP
18637	7280	7	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7280	8	Gaslight	Gaslight	NNP
18637	7280	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7280	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7280	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	7280	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7280	13	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7280	14	Light	Light	NNP
18637	7280	15	&	&	CC
18637	7280	16	Heat	Heat	NNP
18637	7280	17	Producing	Producing	NNP
18637	7280	18	&	&	CC
18637	7280	19	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	7280	20	.	.	.
18637	7281	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7281	2	,	,	,
18637	7281	3	115	115	CD
18637	7281	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7281	5	650	650	CD
18637	7281	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7281	7	1885	1885	CD
18637	7281	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7281	9	;	;	:
18637	7281	10	Bier	Bier	NNP
18637	7281	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7281	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	7281	13	_	_	NNP
18637	7281	14	McGehee	McGehee	NNP
18637	7281	15	,	,	,
18637	7281	16	148	148	CD
18637	7281	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7281	18	137	137	CD
18637	7281	19	,	,	,
18637	7281	20	140	140	CD
18637	7281	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7281	22	1893	1893	CD
18637	7281	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7281	24	.	.	.
18637	7282	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7282	2	1586	1586	CD
18637	7282	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7282	4	New	New	NNP
18637	7282	5	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7282	6	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	7282	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7282	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7282	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7282	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7282	11	Rivers	Rivers	NNP
18637	7282	12	,	,	,
18637	7282	13	115	115	CD
18637	7282	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7282	15	674	674	CD
18637	7282	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7282	17	1885	1885	CD
18637	7282	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7282	19	;	;	:
18637	7282	20	Walla	Walla	NNP
18637	7282	21	Walla	Walla	NNP
18637	7282	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7282	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	7282	24	_	_	NNP
18637	7282	25	Walla	Walla	NNP
18637	7282	26	Walla	Walla	NNP
18637	7282	27	Water	Water	NNP
18637	7282	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7282	29	,	,	,
18637	7282	30	172	172	CD
18637	7282	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7282	32	1	1	CD
18637	7282	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7282	34	1898	1898	CD
18637	7282	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7282	36	;	;	:
18637	7282	37	Vicksburg	Vicksburg	NNP
18637	7282	38	_	_	NNP
18637	7282	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	7282	40	_	_	NNP
18637	7282	41	Vicksburg	Vicksburg	NNP
18637	7282	42	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	7282	43	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7282	44	,	,	,
18637	7282	45	202	202	CD
18637	7282	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7282	47	453	453	CD
18637	7282	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7282	49	1906	1906	CD
18637	7282	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7282	51	;	;	:
18637	7282	52	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	7282	53	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	7282	54	Line	Line	NNP
18637	7282	55	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7282	56	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7282	57	_	_	NNP
18637	7282	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	7282	59	_	_	NNP
18637	7282	60	Goldsboro	Goldsboro	NNP
18637	7282	61	,	,	,
18637	7282	62	232	232	CD
18637	7282	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7282	64	548	548	CD
18637	7282	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7282	66	1914	1914	CD
18637	7282	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7282	68	;	;	:
18637	7282	69	Cuyahoga	Cuyahoga	NNP
18637	7282	70	River	River	NNP
18637	7282	71	Power	Power	NNP
18637	7282	72	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7282	73	_	_	NNP
18637	7282	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	7282	75	_	_	NNP
18637	7282	76	Akron	Akron	NNP
18637	7282	77	,	,	,
18637	7282	78	240	240	CD
18637	7282	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7282	80	462	462	CD
18637	7282	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7282	82	1916	1916	CD
18637	7282	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7282	84	.	.	.
18637	7283	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7283	2	1587	1587	CD
18637	7283	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7283	4	The	the	DT
18637	7283	5	above	above	RB
18637	7283	6	;	;	:
18637	7283	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7283	8	also	also	RB
18637	7283	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7283	10	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	7283	11	Trunk	Trunk	NNP
18637	7283	12	Western	Western	NNP
18637	7283	13	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7283	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7283	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7283	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	7283	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7283	18	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	7283	19	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	7283	20	,	,	,
18637	7283	21	221	221	CD
18637	7283	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7283	23	400	400	CD
18637	7283	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7283	25	1911	1911	CD
18637	7283	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7283	27	;	;	:
18637	7283	28	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	7283	29	&	&	CC
18637	7283	30	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	7284	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7284	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7284	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7284	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7284	5	Garrett	Garrett	NNP
18637	7284	6	,	,	,
18637	7284	7	231	231	CD
18637	7284	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7284	9	298	298	CD
18637	7284	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7284	11	1913	1913	CD
18637	7284	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7284	13	;	;	:
18637	7284	14	Appleby	Appleby	NNP
18637	7284	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7284	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	7284	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7284	18	Delaney	Delaney	NNP
18637	7284	19	,	,	,
18637	7284	20	271	271	CD
18637	7284	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7284	22	403	403	CD
18637	7284	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7284	24	1926	1926	CD
18637	7284	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7284	26	.	.	.
18637	7285	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7285	2	1588	1588	CD
18637	7285	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7285	4	Central	Central	NNP
18637	7285	5	Land	Land	NNP
18637	7285	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7285	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7285	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7285	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7285	10	Laidley	Laidley	NNP
18637	7285	11	,	,	,
18637	7285	12	159	159	CD
18637	7285	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7285	14	103	103	CD
18637	7285	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7285	16	1895	1895	CD
18637	7285	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7285	18	.	.	.
18637	7286	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7286	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7286	3	also	also	RB
18637	7286	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7286	5	New	New	NNP
18637	7286	6	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7286	7	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	7286	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7286	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7286	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7286	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7286	12	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7286	13	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	7286	14	Ref	Ref	NNP
18637	7286	15	.	.	.
18637	7287	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7287	2	,	,	,
18637	7287	3	125	125	CD
18637	7287	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7287	5	18	18	CD
18637	7287	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7287	7	1888	1888	CD
18637	7287	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7287	9	;	;	:
18637	7287	10	Hanford	Hanford	NNP
18637	7287	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7287	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	7287	13	_	_	NNP
18637	7287	14	Davies	Davies	NNP
18637	7287	15	,	,	,
18637	7287	16	163	163	CD
18637	7287	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7287	18	273	273	CD
18637	7287	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7287	20	1896	1896	CD
18637	7287	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7287	22	;	;	:
18637	7287	23	Ross	Ross	NNP
18637	7287	24	_	_	NNP
18637	7287	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	7287	26	_	_	NNP
18637	7287	27	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	7287	28	,	,	,
18637	7287	29	227	227	CD
18637	7287	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7287	31	150	150	CD
18637	7287	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7287	33	1913	1913	CD
18637	7287	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7287	35	;	;	:
18637	7287	36	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	7287	37	United	United	NNP
18637	7287	38	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7287	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7287	40	_	_	NNP
18637	7287	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	7287	42	_	_	NNP
18637	7287	43	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	7287	44	,	,	,
18637	7287	45	242	242	CD
18637	7287	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7287	47	238	238	CD
18637	7287	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7287	49	1916	1916	CD
18637	7287	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7287	51	;	;	:
18637	7287	52	Long	Long	NNP
18637	7287	53	Sault	Sault	NNP
18637	7287	54	Development	Development	NNP
18637	7287	55	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7287	56	_	_	NNP
18637	7287	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	7287	58	_	_	NNP
18637	7287	59	Call	Call	NNP
18637	7287	60	,	,	,
18637	7287	61	242	242	CD
18637	7287	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7287	63	272	272	CD
18637	7287	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7287	65	1916	1916	CD
18637	7287	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7287	67	;	;	:
18637	7287	68	McCoy	McCoy	NNP
18637	7287	69	_	_	NNP
18637	7287	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	7287	71	_	_	NNP
18637	7287	72	Union	Union	NNP
18637	7287	73	Elev	Elev	NNP
18637	7287	74	.	.	.
18637	7288	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7288	2	,	,	,
18637	7288	3	247	247	CD
18637	7288	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7288	5	354	354	CD
18637	7288	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7288	7	1918	1918	CD
18637	7288	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7288	9	;	;	:
18637	7288	10	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	7288	11	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7288	12	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	7288	13	&	&	CC
18637	7288	14	E.	E.	NNP
18637	7288	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7288	16	_	_	NNP
18637	7288	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	7288	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7288	19	South	South	NNP
18637	7288	20	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	7288	21	,	,	,
18637	7288	22	261	261	CD
18637	7288	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7288	24	236	236	CD
18637	7288	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7288	26	1923	1923	CD
18637	7288	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7288	28	;	;	:
18637	7288	29	Tidal	Tidal	NNP
18637	7288	30	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	7288	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7288	32	_	_	NNP
18637	7288	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	7288	34	_	_	NNP
18637	7288	35	Flanagan	Flanagan	NNP
18637	7288	36	,	,	,
18637	7288	37	263	263	CD
18637	7288	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7288	39	444	444	CD
18637	7288	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7288	41	1924	1924	CD
18637	7288	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7288	43	.	.	.
18637	7289	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7289	2	1589	1589	CD
18637	7289	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7289	4	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	7289	5	Branch	Branch	NNP
18637	7289	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7289	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7289	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7289	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7289	10	Skelly	Skelly	NNP
18637	7289	11	,	,	,
18637	7289	12	1	1	CD
18637	7289	13	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	7289	14	.	.	.
18637	7290	1	436	436	CD
18637	7290	2	,	,	,
18637	7290	3	443	443	CD
18637	7290	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7290	5	1862	1862	CD
18637	7290	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7290	7	;	;	:
18637	7290	8	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	7290	9	Proprietors	Proprietors	NNP
18637	7290	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7290	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	7290	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7290	13	Hoboken	Hoboken	NNP
18637	7290	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7290	15	,	,	,
18637	7290	16	1	1	CD
18637	7290	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7290	18	.	.	.
18637	7291	1	116	116	CD
18637	7291	2	,	,	,
18637	7291	3	145	145	CD
18637	7291	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7291	5	1863	1863	CD
18637	7291	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7291	7	;	;	:
18637	7291	8	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	7291	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7291	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7291	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7291	12	Nagle	Nagle	NNP
18637	7291	13	,	,	,
18637	7291	14	101	101	CD
18637	7291	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7291	16	791	791	CD
18637	7291	17	,	,	,
18637	7291	18	793	793	CD
18637	7291	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7291	20	1880	1880	CD
18637	7291	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7291	22	;	;	:
18637	7291	23	and	and	CC
18637	7291	24	McGahey	McGahey	NNP
18637	7291	25	_	_	NNP
18637	7291	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	7291	27	_	_	NNP
18637	7291	28	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7291	29	,	,	,
18637	7291	30	135	135	CD
18637	7291	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7291	32	662	662	CD
18637	7291	33	,	,	,
18637	7291	34	667	667	CD
18637	7291	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7291	36	1890	1890	CD
18637	7291	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7291	38	;	;	:
18637	7291	39	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	7291	40	_	_	NNP
18637	7291	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	7291	42	_	_	NNP
18637	7291	43	McNeal	McNeal	NNP
18637	7291	44	,	,	,
18637	7291	45	154	154	CD
18637	7291	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7291	47	34	34	CD
18637	7291	48	,	,	,
18637	7291	49	45	45	CD
18637	7291	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7291	51	1894	1894	CD
18637	7291	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7291	53	;	;	:
18637	7291	54	Stearns	Stearns	NNP
18637	7291	55	_	_	NNP
18637	7291	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	7291	57	_	_	NNP
18637	7291	58	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	7291	59	,	,	,
18637	7291	60	179	179	CD
18637	7291	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7291	62	223	223	CD
18637	7291	63	,	,	,
18637	7291	64	232	232	CD
18637	7291	65	-	-	SYM
18637	7291	66	233	233	CD
18637	7291	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7291	68	1900	1900	CD
18637	7291	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7291	70	;	;	:
18637	7291	71	Coombes	Coombes	NNP
18637	7291	72	_	_	NNP
18637	7291	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	7291	74	_	_	NNP
18637	7291	75	Getz	Getz	NNP
18637	7291	76	,	,	,
18637	7291	77	285	285	CD
18637	7291	78	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7291	79	434	434	CD
18637	7291	80	,	,	,
18637	7291	81	441	441	CD
18637	7291	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7291	83	1932	1932	CD
18637	7291	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7291	85	;	;	:
18637	7291	86	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	7291	87	C.L.R.	C.L.R.	NNP
18637	7292	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7292	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7292	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7292	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7292	5	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	7292	6	,	,	,
18637	7292	7	332	332	CD
18637	7292	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7292	9	168	168	CD
18637	7292	10	,	,	,
18637	7292	11	170	170	CD
18637	7292	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7292	13	1947	1947	CD
18637	7292	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7292	15	.	.	.
18637	7293	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7293	2	1590	1590	CD
18637	7293	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7293	4	McCullough	McCullough	NNP
18637	7293	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7293	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7293	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7293	8	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7293	9	,	,	,
18637	7293	10	172	172	CD
18637	7293	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7293	12	102	102	CD
18637	7293	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7293	14	1898	1898	CD
18637	7293	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7293	16	;	;	:
18637	7293	17	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	7293	18	&	&	CC
18637	7293	19	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	7293	20	Central	Central	NNP
18637	7293	21	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	7294	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7294	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7294	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7294	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7294	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	7294	6	,	,	,
18637	7294	7	177	177	CD
18637	7294	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7294	9	66	66	CD
18637	7294	10	,	,	,
18637	7294	11	76	76	CD
18637	7294	12	,	,	,
18637	7294	13	77	77	CD
18637	7294	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7294	15	1900	1900	CD
18637	7294	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7294	17	;	;	:
18637	7294	18	Hubert	Hubert	NNP
18637	7294	19	_	_	NNP
18637	7294	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	7294	21	_	_	NNP
18637	7294	22	New	New	NNP
18637	7294	23	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7294	24	,	,	,
18637	7294	25	215	215	CD
18637	7294	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7294	27	170	170	CD
18637	7294	28	,	,	,
18637	7294	29	175	175	CD
18637	7294	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7294	31	1909	1909	CD
18637	7294	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7294	33	;	;	:
18637	7294	34	Carondelet	Carondelet	NNP
18637	7294	35	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	7294	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7294	37	_	_	NNP
18637	7294	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	7294	39	_	_	NNP
18637	7294	40	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7294	41	,	,	,
18637	7294	42	233	233	CD
18637	7294	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7294	44	362	362	CD
18637	7294	45	,	,	,
18637	7294	46	376	376	CD
18637	7294	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7294	48	1914	1914	CD
18637	7294	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7294	50	;	;	:
18637	7294	51	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7294	52	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	7294	53	.	.	.
18637	7295	1	&	&	CC
18637	7295	2	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	7295	3	.	.	.
18637	7296	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7296	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7296	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7296	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7296	5	New	New	NNP
18637	7296	6	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7296	7	,	,	,
18637	7296	8	235	235	CD
18637	7296	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7296	10	164	164	CD
18637	7296	11	,	,	,
18637	7296	12	171	171	CD
18637	7296	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7296	14	1914	1914	CD
18637	7296	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7296	16	.	.	.
18637	7297	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7297	2	1591	1591	CD
18637	7297	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7297	4	State	State	NNP
18637	7297	5	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7297	6	of	of	IN
18637	7297	7	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	7297	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7297	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7297	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7297	11	Knoop	Knoop	NNP
18637	7297	12	,	,	,
18637	7297	13	16	16	CD
18637	7297	14	How	how	WRB
18637	7297	15	.	.	.
18637	7298	1	369	369	CD
18637	7298	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7298	3	1854	1854	CD
18637	7298	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7298	5	,	,	,
18637	7298	6	and	and	CC
18637	7298	7	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	7298	8	Life	Life	NNP
18637	7298	9	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	7298	10	&	&	CC
18637	7298	11	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	7298	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7298	13	_	_	NNP
18637	7298	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	7298	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7298	16	Debolt	Debolt	NNP
18637	7298	17	,	,	,
18637	7298	18	16	16	CD
18637	7298	19	How	how	WRB
18637	7298	20	.	.	.
18637	7299	1	416	416	CD
18637	7299	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7299	3	1854	1854	CD
18637	7299	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7299	5	are	be	VBP
18637	7299	6	the	the	DT
18637	7299	7	leading	lead	VBG
18637	7299	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	7299	9	.	.	.
18637	7300	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7300	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7300	3	also	also	RB
18637	7300	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7300	5	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	7300	6	Branch	Branch	NNP
18637	7300	7	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7300	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7300	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7300	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7300	11	Skelly	Skelly	NNP
18637	7300	12	,	,	,
18637	7300	13	1	1	CD
18637	7300	14	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	7300	15	.	.	.
18637	7301	1	436	436	CD
18637	7301	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7301	3	1862	1862	CD
18637	7301	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7301	5	;	;	:
18637	7301	6	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7301	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7301	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7301	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7301	10	Pilsbury	Pilsbury	NNP
18637	7301	11	,	,	,
18637	7301	12	105	105	CD
18637	7301	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7301	14	278	278	CD
18637	7301	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7301	16	1882	1882	CD
18637	7301	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7301	18	;	;	:
18637	7301	19	McGahey	McGahey	NNP
18637	7301	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7301	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	7301	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7301	23	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7301	24	,	,	,
18637	7301	25	135	135	CD
18637	7301	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7301	27	662	662	CD
18637	7301	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7301	29	1890	1890	CD
18637	7301	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7301	31	;	;	:
18637	7301	32	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	7301	33	&	&	CC
18637	7301	34	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	7301	35	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	7302	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7302	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7302	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7302	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7302	5	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	7302	6	,	,	,
18637	7302	7	153	153	CD
18637	7302	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7302	9	486	486	CD
18637	7302	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7302	11	1894	1894	CD
18637	7302	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7302	13	;	;	:
18637	7302	14	Bacon	Bacon	NNP
18637	7302	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7302	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	7302	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7302	18	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	7302	19	,	,	,
18637	7302	20	163	163	CD
18637	7302	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7302	22	207	207	CD
18637	7302	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7302	24	1896	1896	CD
18637	7302	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7302	26	;	;	:
18637	7302	27	McCullough	McCullough	NNP
18637	7302	28	_	_	NNP
18637	7302	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	7302	30	_	_	NNP
18637	7302	31	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7302	32	,	,	,
18637	7302	33	172	172	CD
18637	7302	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7302	35	102	102	CD
18637	7302	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7302	37	1898	1898	CD
18637	7302	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7302	39	.	.	.
18637	7303	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7303	2	1592	1592	CD
18637	7303	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7303	4	Gelpcke	Gelpcke	NNP
18637	7303	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7303	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7303	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7303	8	Dubuque	Dubuque	NNP
18637	7303	9	,	,	,
18637	7303	10	1	1	CD
18637	7303	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7303	12	.	.	.
18637	7304	1	175	175	CD
18637	7304	2	,	,	,
18637	7304	3	206	206	CD
18637	7304	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7304	5	1864	1864	CD
18637	7304	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7304	7	;	;	:
18637	7304	8	Havemeyer	Havemeyer	NNP
18637	7304	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7304	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7304	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7304	12	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	7304	13	County	County	NNP
18637	7304	14	,	,	,
18637	7304	15	3	3	CD
18637	7304	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7304	17	.	.	.
18637	7305	1	294	294	CD
18637	7305	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7305	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	7305	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7305	5	;	;	:
18637	7305	6	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	7305	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7305	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7305	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7305	10	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	7305	11	County	County	NNP
18637	7305	12	,	,	,
18637	7305	13	3	3	CD
18637	7305	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7305	15	.	.	.
18637	7306	1	327	327	CD
18637	7306	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7306	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	7306	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7306	5	;	;	:
18637	7306	6	Kenosha	Kenosha	NNP
18637	7306	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7306	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7306	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7306	10	Lamson	Lamson	NNP
18637	7306	11	,	,	,
18637	7306	12	9	9	CD
18637	7306	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7306	14	.	.	.
18637	7307	1	477	477	CD
18637	7307	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7307	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	7307	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7307	5	;	;	:
18637	7307	6	Olcott	Olcott	NNP
18637	7307	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7307	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7307	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7307	10	Fond	Fond	NNP
18637	7307	11	du	du	NNP
18637	7307	12	Lac	Lac	NNP
18637	7307	13	County	County	NNP
18637	7307	14	,	,	,
18637	7307	15	16	16	CD
18637	7307	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7307	17	.	.	.
18637	7308	1	678	678	CD
18637	7308	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7308	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	7308	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7308	5	;	;	:
18637	7308	6	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	7308	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7308	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7308	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7308	10	Ypsilanti	Ypsilanti	NNP
18637	7308	11	,	,	,
18637	7308	12	105	105	CD
18637	7308	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7308	14	60	60	CD
18637	7308	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7308	16	1882	1882	CD
18637	7308	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7308	18	;	;	:
18637	7308	19	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	7308	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7308	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	7308	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7308	23	Santa	Santa	NNP
18637	7308	24	Anna	Anna	NNP
18637	7308	25	,	,	,
18637	7308	26	116	116	CD
18637	7308	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7308	28	356	356	CD
18637	7308	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7308	30	1886	1886	CD
18637	7308	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7308	32	;	;	:
18637	7308	33	Wilkes	Wilkes	NNP
18637	7308	34	County	County	NNP
18637	7308	35	_	_	NNP
18637	7308	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	7308	37	_	_	NNP
18637	7308	38	Coler	Coler	NNP
18637	7308	39	,	,	,
18637	7308	40	180	180	CD
18637	7308	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7308	42	506	506	CD
18637	7308	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7308	44	1901	1901	CD
18637	7308	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7308	46	.	.	.
18637	7309	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7309	2	1593	1593	CD
18637	7309	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7309	4	Great	Great	NNP
18637	7309	5	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	7309	6	Fire	Fire	NNP
18637	7309	7	Proof	Proof	NNP
18637	7309	8	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	7309	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7309	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7309	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	7309	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7309	13	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	7309	14	,	,	,
18637	7309	15	193	193	CD
18637	7309	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7309	17	532	532	CD
18637	7309	18	,	,	,
18637	7309	19	548	548	CD
18637	7309	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7309	21	1904	1904	CD
18637	7309	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7309	23	.	.	.
18637	7310	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7310	2	1594	1594	CD
18637	7310	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7310	4	Sauer	Sauer	NNP
18637	7310	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7310	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7310	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7310	8	New	New	NNP
18637	7310	9	York	York	NNP
18637	7310	10	,	,	,
18637	7310	11	206	206	CD
18637	7310	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7310	13	536	536	CD
18637	7310	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7310	15	1907	1907	CD
18637	7310	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7310	17	;	;	:
18637	7310	18	Muhlker	Muhlker	NNP
18637	7310	19	_	_	NNP
18637	7310	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	7310	21	_	_	NNP
18637	7310	22	New	New	NNP
18637	7310	23	York	York	NNP
18637	7310	24	&	&	CC
18637	7310	25	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	7311	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7311	2	,	,	,
18637	7311	3	197	197	CD
18637	7311	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7311	5	544	544	CD
18637	7311	6	,	,	,
18637	7311	7	570	570	CD
18637	7311	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7311	9	1905	1905	CD
18637	7311	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7311	11	.	.	.
18637	7312	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7312	2	1595	1595	CD
18637	7312	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7312	4	Tidal	Tidal	NNP
18637	7312	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	7312	6	Company	Company	NNP
18637	7312	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7312	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7312	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7312	10	Flanagan	Flanagan	NNP
18637	7312	11	,	,	,
18637	7312	12	263	263	CD
18637	7312	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7312	14	444	444	CD
18637	7312	15	,	,	,
18637	7312	16	450	450	CD
18637	7312	17	,	,	,
18637	7312	18	451	451	CD
18637	7312	19	-	-	SYM
18637	7312	20	452	452	CD
18637	7312	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7312	22	1924	1924	CD
18637	7312	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7312	24	.	.	.
18637	7313	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7313	2	1596	1596	CD
18637	7313	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7313	4	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	7313	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7313	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7313	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7313	8	Whitehead	Whitehead	NNP
18637	7313	9	,	,	,
18637	7313	10	16	16	CD
18637	7313	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7313	12	.	.	.
18637	7314	1	314	314	CD
18637	7314	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7314	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	7314	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7314	5	;	;	:
18637	7314	6	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	7314	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7314	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7314	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7314	10	Lovett	Lovett	NNP
18637	7314	11	,	,	,
18637	7314	12	313	313	CD
18637	7314	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7314	14	362	362	CD
18637	7314	15	,	,	,
18637	7314	16	370	370	CD
18637	7314	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7314	18	1941	1941	CD
18637	7314	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7314	20	.	.	.
18637	7315	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7315	2	1597	1597	CD
18637	7315	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7315	4	4	4	CD
18637	7315	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7315	6	.	.	.
18637	7316	1	122	122	CD
18637	7316	2	,	,	,
18637	7316	3	197	197	CD
18637	7316	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7316	5	1819	1819	CD
18637	7316	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7316	7	;	;	:
18637	7316	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7316	9	see	see	VB
18637	7316	10	also	also	RB
18637	7316	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7316	12	Curran	Curran	NNP
18637	7316	13	_	_	NNP
18637	7316	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	7316	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7316	16	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	7316	17	,	,	,
18637	7316	18	15	15	CD
18637	7316	19	How	how	WRB
18637	7316	20	.	.	.
18637	7317	1	304	304	CD
18637	7317	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7317	3	1853	1853	CD
18637	7317	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7317	5	.	.	.
18637	7318	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7318	2	1598	1598	CD
18637	7318	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7318	4	4	4	CD
18637	7318	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7318	6	.	.	.
18637	7319	1	518	518	CD
18637	7319	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7319	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	7319	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7319	5	.	.	.
18637	7320	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7320	2	1599	1599	CD
18637	7320	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7320	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7320	5	.	.	.
18637	7321	1	627	627	CD
18637	7321	2	.	.	.
18637	7322	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7322	2	1600	1600	CD
18637	7322	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7322	4	290	290	CD
18637	7322	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7322	6	398	398	CD
18637	7322	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7322	8	1934	1934	CD
18637	7322	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7322	10	.	.	.
18637	7323	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7323	2	1601	1601	CD
18637	7323	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7323	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7323	5	.	.	.
18637	7324	1	431	431	CD
18637	7324	2	.	.	.
18637	7325	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7325	2	1602	1602	CD
18637	7325	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7325	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7325	5	.	.	.
18637	7326	1	435	435	CD
18637	7326	2	.	.	.
18637	7327	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7327	2	1603	1603	CD
18637	7327	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7327	4	"	"	``
18637	7327	5	The	the	DT
18637	7327	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7327	7	Blaisdell	Blaisdell	NNP
18637	7327	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7327	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	7327	10	represented	represent	VBD
18637	7327	11	a	a	DT
18637	7327	12	realistic	realistic	JJ
18637	7327	13	appreciation	appreciation	NN
18637	7327	14	of	of	IN
18637	7327	15	the	the	DT
18637	7327	16	fact	fact	NN
18637	7327	17	that	that	IN
18637	7327	18	ours	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7327	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	7327	20	an	an	DT
18637	7327	21	evolving	evolve	VBG
18637	7327	22	society	society	NN
18637	7327	23	and	and	CC
18637	7327	24	that	that	IN
18637	7327	25	the	the	DT
18637	7327	26	general	general	JJ
18637	7327	27	words	word	NNS
18637	7327	28	of	of	IN
18637	7327	29	the	the	DT
18637	7327	30	contract	contract	NN
18637	7327	31	clause	clause	NN
18637	7327	32	were	be	VBD
18637	7327	33	not	not	RB
18637	7327	34	intended	intend	VBN
18637	7327	35	to	to	TO
18637	7327	36	reduce	reduce	VB
18637	7327	37	the	the	DT
18637	7327	38	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	7327	39	branch	branch	NN
18637	7327	40	of	of	IN
18637	7327	41	government	government	NN
18637	7327	42	to	to	IN
18637	7327	43	helpless	helpless	JJ
18637	7327	44	impotency	impotency	NN
18637	7327	45	.	.	.
18637	7327	46	"	"	''
18637	7328	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7328	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	7328	3	,	,	,
18637	7328	4	in	in	IN
18637	7328	5	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	7328	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7328	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7328	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7328	9	Lovett	Lovett	NNP
18637	7328	10	,	,	,
18637	7328	11	313	313	CD
18637	7328	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7328	13	362	362	CD
18637	7328	14	,	,	,
18637	7328	15	383	383	CD
18637	7328	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7328	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	7328	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7328	19	.	.	.
18637	7329	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7329	2	1604	1604	CD
18637	7329	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7329	4	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	7329	5	,	,	,
18637	7329	6	The	the	DT
18637	7329	7	Contract	Contract	NNP
18637	7329	8	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	7329	9	of	of	IN
18637	7329	10	the	the	DT
18637	7329	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7329	12	,	,	,
18637	7329	13	95	95	CD
18637	7329	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7329	15	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
18637	7329	16	,	,	,
18637	7329	17	1938	1938	CD
18637	7329	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7329	19	.	.	.
18637	7330	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7330	2	1605	1605	CD
18637	7330	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7330	4	Farrand	Farrand	NNP
18637	7330	5	,	,	,
18637	7330	6	Records	Records	NNP
18637	7330	7	,	,	,
18637	7330	8	III	III	NNP
18637	7330	9	,	,	,
18637	7330	10	548	548	CD
18637	7330	11	.	.	.
18637	7331	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7331	2	1606	1606	CD
18637	7331	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7331	4	The	the	DT
18637	7331	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	7331	6	,	,	,
18637	7331	7	No	no	UH
18637	7331	8	.	.	.
18637	7332	1	44	44	CD
18637	7332	2	.	.	.
18637	7333	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7333	2	1607	1607	CD
18637	7333	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7333	4	Works	Works	NNP
18637	7333	5	of	of	IN
18637	7333	6	James	James	NNP
18637	7333	7	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	7333	8	,	,	,
18637	7333	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7333	10	,	,	,
18637	7333	11	567	567	CD
18637	7333	12	,	,	,
18637	7333	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7333	14	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
18637	7333	15	,	,	,
18637	7333	16	ed	ed	NNP
18637	7333	17	.	.	NNP
18637	7333	18	,	,	,
18637	7333	19	1896	1896	CD
18637	7333	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7333	21	.	.	.
18637	7334	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7334	2	1608	1608	CD
18637	7334	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7334	4	2	2	CD
18637	7334	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	7334	6	.	.	.
18637	7335	1	410	410	CD
18637	7335	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7335	3	1793	1793	CD
18637	7335	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7335	5	.	.	.
18637	7336	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7336	2	1609	1609	CD
18637	7336	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7336	4	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	7336	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7336	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7336	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7336	8	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
18637	7336	9	,	,	,
18637	7336	10	12	12	CD
18637	7336	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7336	12	.	.	.
18637	7337	1	213	213	CD
18637	7337	2	,	,	,
18637	7337	3	338	338	CD
18637	7337	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7337	5	1827	1827	CD
18637	7337	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7337	7	.	.	.
18637	7338	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7338	2	1610	1610	CD
18637	7338	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7338	4	6	6	CD
18637	7338	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	7338	6	.	.	.
18637	7339	1	87	87	CD
18637	7339	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7339	3	1810	1810	CD
18637	7339	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7339	5	.	.	.
18637	7340	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7340	2	1611	1611	CD
18637	7340	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7340	4	In	in	IN
18637	7340	5	Ware	Ware	NNP
18637	7340	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7340	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7340	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7340	9	Hylton	Hylton	NNP
18637	7340	10	,	,	,
18637	7340	11	3	3	CD
18637	7340	12	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	7340	13	.	.	.
18637	7341	1	199	199	CD
18637	7341	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7341	3	1797	1797	CD
18637	7341	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7341	5	the	the	DT
18637	7341	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7341	7	had	have	VBD
18637	7341	8	earlier	early	RBR
18637	7341	9	set	set	VBN
18637	7341	10	aside	aside	RB
18637	7341	11	an	an	DT
18637	7341	12	act	act	NN
18637	7341	13	of	of	IN
18637	7341	14	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7341	15	as	as	IN
18637	7341	16	being	be	VBG
18637	7341	17	in	in	IN
18637	7341	18	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	7341	19	with	with	IN
18637	7341	20	the	the	DT
18637	7341	21	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	7341	22	of	of	IN
18637	7341	23	Peace	Peace	NNP
18637	7341	24	,	,	,
18637	7341	25	of	of	IN
18637	7341	26	1783	1783	CD
18637	7341	27	,	,	,
18637	7341	28	with	with	IN
18637	7341	29	Great	Great	NNP
18637	7341	30	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	7341	31	.	.	.
18637	7342	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7342	2	1612	1612	CD
18637	7342	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7342	4	As	as	IN
18637	7342	5	given	give	VBN
18637	7342	6	by	by	IN
18637	7342	7	Professor	Professor	NNP
18637	7342	8	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	7342	9	in	in	IN
18637	7342	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7342	11	treatise	treatise	NN
18637	7342	12	,	,	,
18637	7342	13	The	the	DT
18637	7342	14	Contract	Contract	NNP
18637	7342	15	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	7342	16	of	of	IN
18637	7342	17	the	the	DT
18637	7342	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7342	19	,	,	,
18637	7342	20	22	22	CD
18637	7342	21	.	.	.
18637	7343	1	Professor	Professor	NNP
18637	7343	2	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	7343	3	dates	date	VBZ
18637	7343	4	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	7343	5	's	's	POS
18637	7343	6	pamphlet	pamphlet	NN
18637	7343	7	,	,	,
18637	7343	8	1796	1796	CD
18637	7343	9	.	.	.
18637	7344	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7344	2	1613	1613	CD
18637	7344	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7344	4	6	6	CD
18637	7344	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	7344	6	.	.	.
18637	7345	1	87	87	CD
18637	7345	2	,	,	,
18637	7345	3	139	139	CD
18637	7345	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7345	5	1810	1810	CD
18637	7345	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7345	7	.	.	.
18637	7346	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7346	2	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	7346	3	,	,	,
18637	7346	4	in	in	IN
18637	7346	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7346	6	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	7346	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	7346	8	,	,	,
18637	7346	9	relied	rely	VBD
18637	7346	10	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	7346	11	on	on	IN
18637	7346	12	general	general	JJ
18637	7346	13	principles	principle	NNS
18637	7346	14	.	.	.
18637	7347	1	"	"	``
18637	7347	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7347	3	do	do	VBP
18637	7347	4	not	not	RB
18637	7347	5	hesitate	hesitate	VB
18637	7347	6	to	to	TO
18637	7347	7	declare	declare	VB
18637	7347	8	,	,	,
18637	7347	9	that	that	IN
18637	7347	10	a	a	DT
18637	7347	11	State	state	NN
18637	7347	12	does	do	VBZ
18637	7347	13	not	not	RB
18637	7347	14	possess	possess	VB
18637	7347	15	the	the	DT
18637	7347	16	power	power	NN
18637	7347	17	of	of	IN
18637	7347	18	revoking	revoke	VBG
18637	7347	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7347	20	own	own	JJ
18637	7347	21	grants	grant	NNS
18637	7347	22	.	.	.
18637	7348	1	But	but	CC
18637	7348	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7348	3	do	do	VBP
18637	7348	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7348	5	,	,	,
18637	7348	6	on	on	IN
18637	7348	7	a	a	DT
18637	7348	8	general	general	JJ
18637	7348	9	principle	principle	NN
18637	7348	10	,	,	,
18637	7348	11	on	on	IN
18637	7348	12	the	the	DT
18637	7348	13	reason	reason	NN
18637	7348	14	and	and	CC
18637	7348	15	nature	nature	NN
18637	7348	16	of	of	IN
18637	7348	17	things	thing	NNS
18637	7348	18	;	;	:
18637	7348	19	a	a	DT
18637	7348	20	principle	principle	NN
18637	7348	21	which	which	WDT
18637	7348	22	will	will	MD
18637	7348	23	impose	impose	VB
18637	7348	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	7348	25	even	even	RB
18637	7348	26	on	on	IN
18637	7348	27	the	the	DT
18637	7348	28	Deity	deity	NN
18637	7348	29	.	.	.
18637	7348	30	"	"	''
18637	7349	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	7349	2	.	.	.
18637	7350	1	143	143	CD
18637	7350	2	.	.	.
18637	7351	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7351	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7351	3	also	also	RB
18637	7351	4	_	_	IN
18637	7351	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7351	6	words	word	NNS
18637	7351	7	in	in	IN
18637	7351	8	Satterlee	Satterlee	NNP
18637	7351	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7351	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7351	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7351	12	Matthewson	Matthewson	NNP
18637	7351	13	,	,	,
18637	7351	14	2	2	CD
18637	7351	15	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7351	16	.	.	.
18637	7352	1	380	380	CD
18637	7352	2	,	,	,
18637	7352	3	686	686	CD
18637	7352	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7352	5	1829	1829	CD
18637	7352	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7352	7	;	;	:
18637	7352	8	and	and	CC
18637	7352	9	those	those	DT
18637	7352	10	of	of	IN
18637	7352	11	the	the	DT
18637	7352	12	North	North	NNP
18637	7352	13	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	7352	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	7352	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7352	16	in	in	IN
18637	7352	17	Barnes	Barnes	NNPS
18637	7352	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7352	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	7352	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7352	21	Barnes	Barnes	NNPS
18637	7352	22	,	,	,
18637	7352	23	8	8	CD
18637	7352	24	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	7352	25	L.	L.	NNP
18637	7352	26	53	53	CD
18637	7352	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7352	28	N.C.	North Carolina	NNP
18637	7352	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7352	30	366	366	CD
18637	7352	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7352	32	1861	1861	CD
18637	7352	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7352	34	,	,	,
18637	7352	35	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	7352	36	in	in	IN
18637	7352	37	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	7352	38	Henry	Henry	NNP
18637	7352	39	Calvert	Calvert	NNP
18637	7352	40	.	.	.
18637	7353	1	The	the	DT
18637	7353	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7353	3	and	and	CC
18637	7353	4	the	the	DT
18637	7353	5	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	7353	6	,	,	,
18637	7353	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7353	8	,	,	,
18637	7353	9	948	948	CD
18637	7353	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7353	11	Northport	Northport	NNP
18637	7353	12	,	,	,
18637	7353	13	L.I.	L.I.	NNP
18637	7353	14	,	,	,
18637	7353	15	1924	1924	CD
18637	7353	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7353	17	.	.	.
18637	7354	1	In	in	IN
18637	7354	2	both	both	PDT
18637	7354	3	these	these	DT
18637	7354	4	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	7354	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7354	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	7354	7	asseverated	asseverate	VBN
18637	7354	8	that	that	IN
18637	7354	9	the	the	DT
18637	7354	10	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	7354	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	7354	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	7354	13	been	be	VBN
18637	7354	14	made	make	VBN
18637	7354	15	to	to	TO
18637	7354	16	do	do	VB
18637	7354	17	the	the	DT
18637	7354	18	work	work	NN
18637	7354	19	of	of	IN
18637	7354	20	"	"	``
18637	7354	21	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	7354	22	principles	principle	NNS
18637	7354	23	.	.	.
18637	7354	24	"	"	''
18637	7355	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7355	2	1614	1614	CD
18637	7355	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7355	4	7	7	CD
18637	7355	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	7355	6	.	.	.
18637	7356	1	164	164	NNP
18637	7356	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7356	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	7356	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7356	5	.	.	.
18637	7357	1	The	the	DT
18637	7357	2	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	7357	3	from	from	IN
18637	7357	4	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	7357	5	which	which	WDT
18637	7357	6	was	be	VBD
18637	7357	7	involved	involve	VBN
18637	7357	8	in	in	IN
18637	7357	9	this	this	DT
18637	7357	10	case	case	NN
18637	7357	11	was	be	VBD
18637	7357	12	held	hold	VBN
18637	7357	13	in	in	IN
18637	7357	14	1886	1886	CD
18637	7357	15	to	to	TO
18637	7357	16	have	have	VB
18637	7357	17	lapsed	lapse	VBN
18637	7357	18	through	through	IN
18637	7357	19	the	the	DT
18637	7357	20	acquiescence	acquiescence	NN
18637	7357	21	for	for	IN
18637	7357	22	sixty	sixty	CD
18637	7357	23	years	year	NNS
18637	7357	24	of	of	IN
18637	7357	25	the	the	DT
18637	7357	26	owners	owner	NNS
18637	7357	27	of	of	IN
18637	7357	28	the	the	DT
18637	7357	29	lands	land	NNS
18637	7357	30	in	in	IN
18637	7357	31	the	the	DT
18637	7357	32	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	7357	33	of	of	IN
18637	7357	34	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	7357	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	7357	36	these	these	DT
18637	7357	37	.	.	.
18637	7358	1	Given	give	VBN
18637	7358	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7358	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7358	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7358	5	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	7358	6	,	,	,
18637	7358	7	117	117	CD
18637	7358	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7358	9	648	648	CD
18637	7358	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7358	11	1886	1886	CD
18637	7358	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7358	13	.	.	.
18637	7359	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7359	2	1615	1615	CD
18637	7359	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7359	4	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	7359	5	College	College	NNP
18637	7359	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7359	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7359	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7359	9	Woodward	Woodward	NNP
18637	7359	10	,	,	,
18637	7359	11	4	4	CD
18637	7359	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7359	13	.	.	.
18637	7360	1	518	518	CD
18637	7360	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7360	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	7360	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7360	5	.	.	.
18637	7361	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7361	2	1616	1616	CD
18637	7361	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7361	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7361	5	was	be	VBD
18637	7361	6	not	not	RB
18637	7361	7	until	until	IN
18637	7361	8	well	well	RB
18637	7361	9	along	along	RB
18637	7361	10	in	in	IN
18637	7361	11	the	the	DT
18637	7361	12	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
18637	7361	13	century	century	NN
18637	7361	14	that	that	WDT
18637	7361	15	the	the	DT
18637	7361	16	first	first	JJ
18637	7361	17	American	american	JJ
18637	7361	18	business	business	NN
18637	7361	19	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	7361	20	was	be	VBD
18637	7361	21	created	create	VBN
18637	7361	22	:	:	:
18637	7361	23	"	"	``
18637	7361	24	This	this	DT
18637	7361	25	was	be	VBD
18637	7361	26	the	the	DT
18637	7361	27	New	New	NNP
18637	7361	28	London	London	NNP
18637	7361	29	Society	Society	NNP
18637	7361	30	United	United	NNP
18637	7361	31	for	for	IN
18637	7361	32	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	7361	33	and	and	CC
18637	7361	34	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	7361	35	,	,	,
18637	7361	36	which	which	WDT
18637	7361	37	was	be	VBD
18637	7361	38	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	7361	39	in	in	IN
18637	7361	40	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	7361	41	in	in	IN
18637	7361	42	1732	1732	CD
18637	7361	43	.	.	.
18637	7362	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7362	2	had	have	VBD
18637	7362	3	,	,	,
18637	7362	4	however	however	RB
18637	7362	5	,	,	,
18637	7362	6	an	an	DT
18637	7362	7	early	early	JJ
18637	7362	8	demise	demise	NN
18637	7362	9	.	.	.
18637	7363	1	Following	follow	VBG
18637	7363	2	this	this	DT
18637	7363	3	was	be	VBD
18637	7363	4	a	a	DT
18637	7363	5	second	second	JJ
18637	7363	6	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	7363	7	charter	charter	NN
18637	7363	8	,	,	,
18637	7363	9	namely	namely	RB
18637	7363	10	,	,	,
18637	7363	11	for	for	IN
18637	7363	12	building	build	VBG
18637	7363	13	'	'	''
18637	7363	14	Union	Union	NNP
18637	7363	15	Wharf	Wharf	NNP
18637	7363	16	,	,	,
18637	7363	17	'	'	''
18637	7363	18	on	on	IN
18637	7363	19	'	'	''
18637	7363	20	Long	Long	NNP
18637	7363	21	Wharf	Wharf	NNP
18637	7363	22	,	,	,
18637	7363	23	'	'	''
18637	7363	24	at	at	IN
18637	7363	25	New	New	NNP
18637	7363	26	Haven	Haven	NNP
18637	7363	27	.	.	.
18637	7364	1	A	a	DT
18637	7364	2	similar	similar	JJ
18637	7364	3	company	company	NN
18637	7364	4	,	,	,
18637	7364	5	'	'	''
18637	7364	6	The	the	DT
18637	7364	7	Proprietors	Proprietors	NNPS
18637	7364	8	of	of	IN
18637	7364	9	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	7364	10	Pier	Pier	NNP
18637	7364	11	,	,	,
18637	7364	12	'	'	''
18637	7364	13	or	or	CC
18637	7364	14	'	'	''
18637	7364	15	The	the	DT
18637	7364	16	Long	Long	NNP
18637	7364	17	Wharf	Wharf	NNP
18637	7364	18	in	in	IN
18637	7364	19	the	the	DT
18637	7364	20	Town	Town	NNP
18637	7364	21	of	of	IN
18637	7364	22	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	7364	23	in	in	IN
18637	7364	24	New	New	NNP
18637	7364	25	England	England	NNP
18637	7364	26	,	,	,
18637	7364	27	'	'	''
18637	7364	28	was	be	VBD
18637	7364	29	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	7364	30	by	by	IN
18637	7364	31	the	the	DT
18637	7364	32	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	7364	33	General	General	NNP
18637	7364	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7364	35	in	in	IN
18637	7364	36	1772	1772	CD
18637	7364	37	.	.	.
18637	7365	1	In	in	IN
18637	7365	2	1768	1768	CD
18637	7365	3	the	the	DT
18637	7365	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7365	5	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
18637	7365	6	incorporated	incorporate	VBD
18637	7365	7	'	'	''
18637	7365	8	The	the	DT
18637	7365	9	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	7365	10	Contributionship	Contributionship	NNP
18637	7365	11	for	for	IN
18637	7365	12	the	the	DT
18637	7365	13	Insuring	insuring	NN
18637	7365	14	of	of	IN
18637	7365	15	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	7365	16	from	from	IN
18637	7365	17	Loss	Loss	NNP
18637	7365	18	by	by	IN
18637	7365	19	Fire	Fire	NNP
18637	7365	20	.	.	.
18637	7365	21	'	'	''
18637	7366	1	Alone	alone	JJ
18637	7366	2	of	of	IN
18637	7366	3	the	the	DT
18637	7366	4	colonial	colonial	JJ
18637	7366	5	business	business	NN
18637	7366	6	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	7366	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7366	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	7366	9	had	have	VBN
18637	7366	10	a	a	DT
18637	7366	11	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	7366	12	existence	existence	NN
18637	7366	13	to	to	IN
18637	7366	14	the	the	DT
18637	7366	15	present	present	JJ
18637	7366	16	day	day	NN
18637	7366	17	.	.	.
18637	7367	1	"	"	``
18637	7367	2	Apparently	apparently	RB
18637	7367	3	the	the	DT
18637	7367	4	only	only	JJ
18637	7367	5	other	other	JJ
18637	7367	6	business	business	NN
18637	7367	7	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	7367	8	of	of	IN
18637	7367	9	the	the	DT
18637	7367	10	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	7367	11	were	be	VBD
18637	7367	12	companies	company	NNS
18637	7367	13	for	for	IN
18637	7367	14	supplying	supply	VBG
18637	7367	15	water	water	NN
18637	7367	16	.	.	.
18637	7368	1	One	one	CD
18637	7368	2	was	be	VBD
18637	7368	3	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	7368	4	in	in	IN
18637	7368	5	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	7368	6	in	in	IN
18637	7368	7	1652	1652	CD
18637	7368	8	,	,	,
18637	7368	9	and	and	CC
18637	7368	10	three	three	CD
18637	7368	11	in	in	IN
18637	7368	12	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	7368	13	Island	Island	NNP
18637	7368	14	in	in	IN
18637	7368	15	1772	1772	CD
18637	7368	16	and	and	CC
18637	7368	17	1773	1773	CD
18637	7368	18	.	.	.
18637	7369	1	Alongside	alongside	IN
18637	7369	2	of	of	IN
18637	7369	3	these	these	DT
18637	7369	4	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	7369	5	,	,	,
18637	7369	6	and	and	CC
18637	7369	7	,	,	,
18637	7369	8	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	7369	9	,	,	,
18637	7369	10	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	7369	11	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7369	12	,	,	,
18637	7369	13	were	be	VBD
18637	7369	14	a	a	DT
18637	7369	15	large	large	JJ
18637	7369	16	number	number	NN
18637	7369	17	of	of	IN
18637	7369	18	unincorporated	unincorporated	JJ
18637	7369	19	associations	association	NNS
18637	7369	20	,	,	,
18637	7369	21	partnerships	partnership	NNS
18637	7369	22	,	,	,
18637	7369	23	societies	society	NNS
18637	7369	24	,	,	,
18637	7369	25	groups	group	NNS
18637	7369	26	of	of	IN
18637	7369	27	'	'	``
18637	7369	28	undertakers	undertaker	NNS
18637	7369	29	,	,	,
18637	7369	30	'	'	''
18637	7369	31	'	'	''
18637	7369	32	companies	company	NNS
18637	7369	33	,	,	,
18637	7369	34	'	'	''
18637	7369	35	formed	form	VBN
18637	7369	36	for	for	IN
18637	7369	37	a	a	DT
18637	7369	38	great	great	JJ
18637	7369	39	variety	variety	NN
18637	7369	40	of	of	IN
18637	7369	41	business	business	NN
18637	7369	42	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	7369	43	.	.	.
18637	7370	1	In	in	IN
18637	7370	2	the	the	DT
18637	7370	3	eye	eye	NN
18637	7370	4	of	of	IN
18637	7370	5	the	the	DT
18637	7370	6	law	law	NN
18637	7370	7	all	all	DT
18637	7370	8	of	of	IN
18637	7370	9	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7370	10	were	be	VBD
18637	7370	11	probably	probably	RB
18637	7370	12	mere	mere	JJ
18637	7370	13	partnerships	partnership	NNS
18637	7370	14	or	or	CC
18637	7370	15	tenancies	tenancy	NNS
18637	7370	16	in	in	IN
18637	7370	17	common	common	JJ
18637	7370	18	.	.	.
18637	7371	1	Whaling	whaling	NN
18637	7371	2	and	and	CC
18637	7371	3	fishing	fishing	NN
18637	7371	4	companies	company	NNS
18637	7371	5	,	,	,
18637	7371	6	so	so	RB
18637	7371	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	7371	8	called	call	VBN
18637	7371	9	,	,	,
18637	7371	10	were	be	VBD
18637	7371	11	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	7371	12	.	.	.
18637	7372	1	There	there	EX
18637	7372	2	were	be	VBD
18637	7372	3	a	a	DT
18637	7372	4	number	number	NN
18637	7372	5	of	of	IN
18637	7372	6	mining	mining	NN
18637	7372	7	companies	company	NNS
18637	7372	8	,	,	,
18637	7372	9	chiefly	chiefly	RB
18637	7372	10	for	for	IN
18637	7372	11	producing	produce	VBG
18637	7372	12	iron	iron	NN
18637	7372	13	or	or	CC
18637	7372	14	copper	copper	NN
18637	7372	15	.	.	.
18637	7373	1	There	there	EX
18637	7373	2	were	be	VBD
18637	7373	3	some	some	DT
18637	7373	4	manufacturing	manufacturing	NN
18637	7373	5	companies	company	NNS
18637	7373	6	,	,	,
18637	7373	7	but	but	CC
18637	7373	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7373	9	were	be	VBD
18637	7373	10	not	not	RB
18637	7373	11	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	7373	12	.	.	.
18637	7374	1	Banking	banking	NN
18637	7374	2	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	7374	3	were	be	VBD
18637	7374	4	represented	represent	VBN
18637	7374	5	notably	notably	RB
18637	7374	6	by	by	IN
18637	7374	7	the	the	DT
18637	7374	8	'	'	``
18637	7374	9	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7374	10	of	of	IN
18637	7374	11	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	7374	12	Lumbard	Lumbard	NNP
18637	7374	13	,	,	,
18637	7374	14	'	'	''
18637	7374	15	promoted	promote	VBN
18637	7374	16	in	in	IN
18637	7374	17	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	7374	18	by	by	IN
18637	7374	19	John	John	NNP
18637	7374	20	Blackwell	Blackwell	NNP
18637	7374	21	and	and	CC
18637	7374	22	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	7374	23	by	by	IN
18637	7374	24	the	the	DT
18637	7374	25	General	General	NNP
18637	7374	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7374	27	in	in	IN
18637	7374	28	1686	1686	CD
18637	7374	29	,	,	,
18637	7374	30	and	and	CC
18637	7374	31	by	by	IN
18637	7374	32	the	the	DT
18637	7374	33	'	'	``
18637	7374	34	Land	Land	NNP
18637	7374	35	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7374	36	or	or	CC
18637	7374	37	Manufacturing	Manufacturing	NNP
18637	7374	38	Scheme	Scheme	NNP
18637	7374	39	'	'	''
18637	7374	40	in	in	IN
18637	7374	41	the	the	DT
18637	7374	42	same	same	JJ
18637	7374	43	colony	colony	NN
18637	7374	44	in	in	IN
18637	7374	45	1739	1739	CD
18637	7374	46	-	-	SYM
18637	7374	47	41	41	CD
18637	7374	48	.	.	.
18637	7375	1	"	"	``
18637	7375	2	In	in	IN
18637	7375	3	addition	addition	NN
18637	7375	4	to	to	IN
18637	7375	5	these	these	DT
18637	7375	6	there	there	EX
18637	7375	7	were	be	VBD
18637	7375	8	a	a	DT
18637	7375	9	few	few	JJ
18637	7375	10	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	7375	11	companies	company	NNS
18637	7375	12	,	,	,
18637	7375	13	a	a	DT
18637	7375	14	number	number	NN
18637	7375	15	of	of	IN
18637	7375	16	companies	company	NNS
18637	7375	17	formed	form	VBN
18637	7375	18	for	for	IN
18637	7375	19	the	the	DT
18637	7375	20	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	7375	21	trade	trade	NN
18637	7375	22	,	,	,
18637	7375	23	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	7375	24	land	land	NN
18637	7375	25	companies	company	NNS
18637	7375	26	,	,	,
18637	7375	27	large	large	JJ
18637	7375	28	and	and	CC
18637	7375	29	small	small	JJ
18637	7375	30	,	,	,
18637	7375	31	a	a	DT
18637	7375	32	number	number	NN
18637	7375	33	of	of	IN
18637	7375	34	associations	association	NNS
18637	7375	35	for	for	IN
18637	7375	36	erecting	erect	VBG
18637	7375	37	bridges	bridge	NNS
18637	7375	38	,	,	,
18637	7375	39	building	build	VBG
18637	7375	40	or	or	CC
18637	7375	41	repairing	repair	VBG
18637	7375	42	roads	road	NNS
18637	7375	43	,	,	,
18637	7375	44	and	and	CC
18637	7375	45	improving	improve	VBG
18637	7375	46	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	7375	47	of	of	IN
18637	7375	48	small	small	JJ
18637	7375	49	streams	stream	NNS
18637	7375	50	or	or	CC
18637	7375	51	rivers	river	NNS
18637	7375	52	.	.	.
18637	7376	1	Besides	besides	IN
18637	7376	2	these	these	DT
18637	7376	3	there	there	EX
18637	7376	4	were	be	VBD
18637	7376	5	a	a	DT
18637	7376	6	few	few	JJ
18637	7376	7	colonial	colonial	JJ
18637	7376	8	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	7376	9	not	not	RB
18637	7376	10	easily	easily	RB
18637	7376	11	classed	class	VBN
18637	7376	12	,	,	,
18637	7376	13	such	such	JJ
18637	7376	14	as	as	IN
18637	7376	15	libraries	library	NNS
18637	7376	16	,	,	,
18637	7376	17	chambers	chamber	NNS
18637	7376	18	of	of	IN
18637	7376	19	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	7376	20	,	,	,
18637	7376	21	etc	etc	FW
18637	7376	22	.	.	.
18637	7377	1	"	"	``
18637	7377	2	During	during	IN
18637	7377	3	the	the	DT
18637	7377	4	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
18637	7377	5	few	few	JJ
18637	7377	6	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	7377	7	of	of	IN
18637	7377	8	any	any	DT
18637	7377	9	sort	sort	NN
18637	7377	10	were	be	VBD
18637	7377	11	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	7377	12	.	.	.
18637	7378	1	After	after	IN
18637	7378	2	the	the	DT
18637	7378	3	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	7378	4	of	of	IN
18637	7378	5	peace	peace	NN
18637	7378	6	the	the	DT
18637	7378	7	situation	situation	NN
18637	7378	8	was	be	VBD
18637	7378	9	materially	materially	RB
18637	7378	10	altered	alter	VBN
18637	7378	11	.	.	.
18637	7379	1	Capital	capital	NN
18637	7379	2	had	have	VBD
18637	7379	3	accumulated	accumulate	VBN
18637	7379	4	during	during	IN
18637	7379	5	the	the	DT
18637	7379	6	war	war	NN
18637	7379	7	.	.	.
18637	7380	1	The	the	DT
18637	7380	2	disbanding	disbanding	NN
18637	7380	3	of	of	IN
18637	7380	4	the	the	DT
18637	7380	5	army	army	NN
18637	7380	6	set	set	VBD
18637	7380	7	free	free	JJ
18637	7380	8	a	a	DT
18637	7380	9	labor	labor	NN
18637	7380	10	supply	supply	NN
18637	7380	11	,	,	,
18637	7380	12	which	which	WDT
18637	7380	13	was	be	VBD
18637	7380	14	rapidly	rapidly	RB
18637	7380	15	increased	increase	VBN
18637	7380	16	by	by	IN
18637	7380	17	throngs	throng	NNS
18637	7380	18	of	of	IN
18637	7380	19	immigrants	immigrant	NNS
18637	7380	20	.	.	.
18637	7381	1	The	the	DT
18637	7381	2	day	day	NN
18637	7381	3	was	be	VBD
18637	7381	4	one	one	CD
18637	7381	5	of	of	IN
18637	7381	6	bold	bold	JJ
18637	7381	7	experimentation	experimentation	NN
18637	7381	8	,	,	,
18637	7381	9	enthusiastic	enthusiastic	JJ
18637	7381	10	exploitation	exploitation	NN
18637	7381	11	of	of	IN
18637	7381	12	new	new	JJ
18637	7381	13	methods	method	NNS
18637	7381	14	,	,	,
18637	7381	15	eager	eager	JJ
18637	7381	16	exploration	exploration	NN
18637	7381	17	of	of	IN
18637	7381	18	new	new	JJ
18637	7381	19	paths	path	NNS
18637	7381	20	,	,	,
18637	7381	21	confident	confident	JJ
18637	7381	22	undertaking	undertaking	NN
18637	7381	23	of	of	IN
18637	7381	24	new	new	JJ
18637	7381	25	enterprises	enterprise	NNS
18637	7381	26	.	.	.
18637	7382	1	Everything	everything	NN
18637	7382	2	conspired	conspire	VBD
18637	7382	3	to	to	TO
18637	7382	4	bring	bring	VB
18637	7382	5	about	about	RP
18637	7382	6	a	a	DT
18637	7382	7	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	7382	8	extension	extension	NN
18637	7382	9	of	of	IN
18637	7382	10	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	7382	11	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	7382	12	in	in	IN
18637	7382	13	the	the	DT
18637	7382	14	field	field	NN
18637	7382	15	of	of	IN
18637	7382	16	business	business	NN
18637	7382	17	before	before	IN
18637	7382	18	the	the	DT
18637	7382	19	end	end	NN
18637	7382	20	of	of	IN
18637	7382	21	the	the	DT
18637	7382	22	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
18637	7382	23	century	century	NN
18637	7382	24	,	,	,
18637	7382	25	notably	notably	RB
18637	7382	26	after	after	IN
18637	7382	27	the	the	DT
18637	7382	28	critical	critical	JJ
18637	7382	29	period	period	NN
18637	7382	30	of	of	IN
18637	7382	31	disunion	disunion	NN
18637	7382	32	and	and	CC
18637	7382	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7382	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	7382	35	making	making	NN
18637	7382	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	7382	37	passed	pass	VBN
18637	7382	38	.	.	.
18637	7383	1	Prior	prior	RB
18637	7383	2	to	to	IN
18637	7383	3	1801	1801	CD
18637	7383	4	over	over	IN
18637	7383	5	three	three	CD
18637	7383	6	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	7383	7	charters	charter	NNS
18637	7383	8	were	be	VBD
18637	7383	9	granted	grant	VBN
18637	7383	10	for	for	IN
18637	7383	11	business	business	NN
18637	7383	12	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	7383	13	;	;	:
18637	7383	14	90	90	CD
18637	7383	15	per	per	NN
18637	7383	16	cent	cent	NN
18637	7383	17	.	.	.
18637	7384	1	of	of	IN
18637	7384	2	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7384	3	after	after	IN
18637	7384	4	1789	1789	CD
18637	7384	5	.	.	.
18637	7385	1	Judged	judge	VBN
18637	7385	2	by	by	IN
18637	7385	3	twentieth	twentieth	JJ
18637	7385	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	7385	5	century	century	NN
18637	7385	6	standards	standard	NNS
18637	7385	7	these	these	DT
18637	7385	8	seem	seem	VBP
18637	7385	9	few	few	JJ
18637	7385	10	,	,	,
18637	7385	11	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	7385	12	,	,	,
18637	7385	13	but	but	CC
18637	7385	14	neither	neither	DT
18637	7385	15	in	in	IN
18637	7385	16	the	the	DT
18637	7385	17	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	7385	18	nor	nor	CC
18637	7385	19	in	in	IN
18637	7385	20	the	the	DT
18637	7385	21	mother	mother	NN
18637	7385	22	country	country	NN
18637	7385	23	was	be	VBD
18637	7385	24	there	there	RB
18637	7385	25	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	7385	26	for	for	IN
18637	7385	27	such	such	PDT
18637	7385	28	a	a	DT
18637	7385	29	development	development	NN
18637	7385	30	.	.	.
18637	7385	31	"	"	''
18637	7386	1	105	105	CD
18637	7386	2	The	the	DT
18637	7386	3	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	7386	4	512	512	CD
18637	7386	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7386	6	New	New	NNP
18637	7386	7	York	York	NNP
18637	7386	8	,	,	,
18637	7386	9	Nov.	November	NNP
18637	7386	10	8	8	CD
18637	7386	11	,	,	,
18637	7386	12	1917	1917	CD
18637	7386	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7386	14	,	,	,
18637	7386	15	reviewing	review	VBG
18637	7386	16	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
18637	7386	17	Stancliffe	Stancliffe	NNP
18637	7386	18	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	7386	19	,	,	,
18637	7386	20	Essays	Essays	NNPS
18637	7386	21	in	in	IN
18637	7386	22	the	the	DT
18637	7386	23	Earlier	early	JJR
18637	7386	24	History	history	NN
18637	7386	25	of	of	IN
18637	7386	26	American	American	NNP
18637	7386	27	Corporations	Corporations	NNPS
18637	7386	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7386	29	2	2	CD
18637	7386	30	vols	vol	NNS
18637	7386	31	.	.	.
18637	7386	32	,	,	,
18637	7386	33	Harvard	Harvard	NNP
18637	7386	34	University	University	NNP
18637	7386	35	Press	Press	NNP
18637	7386	36	,	,	,
18637	7386	37	1917	1917	CD
18637	7386	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7386	39	.	.	.
18637	7387	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7387	2	1617	1617	CD
18637	7387	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7387	4	In	in	IN
18637	7387	5	1806	1806	CD
18637	7387	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	7387	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7387	8	Parsons	Parsons	NNP
18637	7387	9	of	of	IN
18637	7387	10	the	the	DT
18637	7387	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	7387	12	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	7387	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7387	14	of	of	IN
18637	7387	15	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	7387	16	,	,	,
18637	7387	17	without	without	IN
18637	7387	18	mentioning	mention	VBG
18637	7387	19	the	the	DT
18637	7387	20	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	7387	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	7387	22	,	,	,
18637	7387	23	declared	declare	VBD
18637	7387	24	that	that	IN
18637	7387	25	rights	right	NNS
18637	7387	26	legally	legally	RB
18637	7387	27	vested	vest	VBN
18637	7387	28	in	in	IN
18637	7387	29	a	a	DT
18637	7387	30	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	7387	31	can	can	MD
18637	7387	32	not	not	RB
18637	7387	33	be	be	VB
18637	7387	34	"	"	``
18637	7387	35	controuled	controule	VBN
18637	7387	36	or	or	CC
18637	7387	37	destroyed	destroy	VBN
18637	7387	38	by	by	IN
18637	7387	39	a	a	DT
18637	7387	40	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	7387	41	statute	statute	NN
18637	7387	42	,	,	,
18637	7387	43	unless	unless	IN
18637	7387	44	a	a	DT
18637	7387	45	power	power	NN
18637	7387	46	be	be	VB
18637	7387	47	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	7387	48	to	to	IN
18637	7387	49	the	the	DT
18637	7387	50	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	7387	51	in	in	IN
18637	7387	52	the	the	DT
18637	7387	53	act	act	NN
18637	7387	54	of	of	IN
18637	7387	55	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	7387	56	,	,	,
18637	7387	57	"	"	''
18637	7387	58	Wales	Wales	NNP
18637	7387	59	_	_	NNP
18637	7387	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	7387	61	_	_	NNP
18637	7387	62	Stetson	Stetson	NNP
18637	7387	63	,	,	,
18637	7387	64	2	2	CD
18637	7387	65	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	7388	1	143	143	CD
18637	7388	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7388	3	1806	1806	CD
18637	7388	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7388	5	.	.	.
18637	7389	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7389	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7389	3	also	also	RB
18637	7389	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7389	5	Stoughton	Stoughton	NNP
18637	7389	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7389	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7389	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7389	9	Baker	Baker	NNP
18637	7389	10	et	et	NNP
18637	7389	11	al	al	NNP
18637	7389	12	.	.	NNP
18637	7389	13	,	,	,
18637	7389	14	4	4	CD
18637	7389	15	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	7390	1	522	522	CD
18637	7390	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7390	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	7390	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7390	5	to	to	TO
18637	7390	6	like	like	IN
18637	7390	7	effect	effect	NN
18637	7390	8	;	;	:
18637	7390	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7390	10	cf	cf	NNP
18637	7390	11	.	.	.
18637	7390	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7390	13	Locke	Locke	NNP
18637	7390	14	_	_	NNP
18637	7390	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	7390	16	_	_	NNP
18637	7390	17	Dane	Dane	NNP
18637	7390	18	,	,	,
18637	7390	19	9	9	CD
18637	7390	20	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	7391	1	360	360	CD
18637	7391	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7391	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	7391	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7391	5	in	in	IN
18637	7391	6	which	which	WDT
18637	7391	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7391	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	7391	9	said	say	VBN
18637	7391	10	that	that	IN
18637	7391	11	the	the	DT
18637	7391	12	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	7391	13	of	of	IN
18637	7391	14	the	the	DT
18637	7391	15	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	7391	16	clause	clause	NNP
18637	7391	17	was	be	VBD
18637	7391	18	to	to	TO
18637	7391	19	"	"	``
18637	7391	20	provide	provide	VB
18637	7391	21	against	against	IN
18637	7391	22	paper	paper	NN
18637	7391	23	money	money	NN
18637	7391	24	and	and	CC
18637	7391	25	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
18637	7391	26	laws	law	NNS
18637	7391	27	.	.	.
18637	7391	28	"	"	''
18637	7392	1	Together	together	RB
18637	7392	2	these	these	DT
18637	7392	3	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	7392	4	add	add	VBP
18637	7392	5	up	up	RP
18637	7392	6	to	to	IN
18637	7392	7	the	the	DT
18637	7392	8	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	7392	9	that	that	IN
18637	7392	10	the	the	DT
18637	7392	11	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	7392	12	of	of	IN
18637	7392	13	the	the	DT
18637	7392	14	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	7392	15	court	court	NN
18637	7392	16	was	be	VBD
18637	7392	17	on	on	IN
18637	7392	18	"	"	``
18637	7392	19	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	7392	20	principles	principle	NNS
18637	7392	21	,	,	,
18637	7392	22	"	"	''
18637	7392	23	rather	rather	RB
18637	7392	24	than	than	IN
18637	7392	25	the	the	DT
18637	7392	26	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	7392	27	clause	clause	NN
18637	7392	28	.	.	.
18637	7393	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7393	2	1618	1618	CD
18637	7393	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7393	4	4	4	CD
18637	7393	5	Wheat	Wheat	NNP
18637	7393	6	.	.	.
18637	7393	7	,	,	,
18637	7393	8	especially	especially	RB
18637	7393	9	at	at	IN
18637	7393	10	577	577	CD
18637	7393	11	-	-	SYM
18637	7393	12	595	595	CD
18637	7393	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7393	14	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	7393	15	's	's	POS
18637	7393	16	argument	argument	NN
18637	7393	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7393	18	;	;	,
18637	7393	19	ibid	ibid	NNP
18637	7393	20	.	.	.
18637	7394	1	666	666	CD
18637	7394	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7394	3	Story	story	NN
18637	7394	4	's	's	POS
18637	7394	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	7394	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7394	7	.	.	.
18637	7395	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7395	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7395	3	also	also	RB
18637	7395	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7395	5	Story	Story	NNP
18637	7395	6	's	's	POS
18637	7395	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	7395	8	for	for	IN
18637	7395	9	the	the	DT
18637	7395	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7395	11	in	in	IN
18637	7395	12	Terrett	Terrett	NNP
18637	7395	13	_	_	NNP
18637	7395	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	7395	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7395	16	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	7395	17	,	,	,
18637	7395	18	9	9	CD
18637	7395	19	Cr	cr	NN
18637	7395	20	.	.	.
18637	7396	1	43	43	CD
18637	7396	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7396	3	1815	1815	CD
18637	7396	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7396	5	.	.	.
18637	7397	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7397	2	1619	1619	CD
18637	7397	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7397	4	4	4	CD
18637	7397	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7397	6	.	.	.
18637	7398	1	518	518	CD
18637	7398	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7398	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	7398	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7398	5	.	.	.
18637	7399	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7399	2	1620	1620	CD
18637	7399	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7399	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7399	5	.	.	.
18637	7400	1	627	627	CD
18637	7400	2	.	.	.
18637	7401	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7401	2	1621	1621	CD
18637	7401	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7401	4	4	4	CD
18637	7401	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7401	6	.	.	.
18637	7402	1	at	at	IN
18637	7402	2	637	637	CD
18637	7402	3	;	;	:
18637	7402	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7402	5	see	see	VB
18637	7402	6	also	also	RB
18637	7402	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7402	8	Home	Home	NNP
18637	7402	9	of	of	IN
18637	7402	10	the	the	DT
18637	7402	11	Friendless	Friendless	NNP
18637	7402	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7402	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	7402	14	_	_	NNP
18637	7402	15	Rouse	Rouse	NNP
18637	7402	16	,	,	,
18637	7402	17	8	8	CD
18637	7402	18	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7402	19	.	.	.
18637	7403	1	430	430	CD
18637	7403	2	,	,	,
18637	7403	3	437	437	CD
18637	7403	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7403	5	1869	1869	CD
18637	7403	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7403	7	.	.	.
18637	7404	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7404	2	1622	1622	CD
18637	7404	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7404	4	4	4	CD
18637	7404	5	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	7404	6	.	.	.
18637	7405	1	514	514	CD
18637	7405	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7405	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	7405	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7405	5	.	.	.
18637	7406	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7406	2	1623	1623	CD
18637	7406	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7406	4	11	11	CD
18637	7406	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7406	6	.	.	.
18637	7407	1	420	420	CD
18637	7407	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7407	3	1837	1837	CD
18637	7407	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7407	5	.	.	.
18637	7408	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7408	2	1624	1624	CD
18637	7408	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7408	4	Note	note	VB
18637	7408	5	the	the	DT
18637	7408	6	various	various	JJ
18637	7408	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	7408	8	to	to	TO
18637	7408	9	which	which	WDT
18637	7408	10	municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	7408	11	are	be	VBP
18637	7408	12	parties	party	NNS
18637	7408	13	.	.	.
18637	7409	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7409	2	1625	1625	CD
18637	7409	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7409	4	4	4	CD
18637	7409	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7409	6	.	.	.
18637	7410	1	at	at	IN
18637	7410	2	629	629	CD
18637	7410	3	.	.	.
18637	7411	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7411	2	1626	1626	CD
18637	7411	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7411	4	In	in	IN
18637	7411	5	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	7411	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7411	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7411	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7411	9	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	7411	10	,	,	,
18637	7411	11	94	94	CD
18637	7411	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7411	13	113	113	CD
18637	7411	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7411	15	1877	1877	CD
18637	7411	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7411	17	a	a	DT
18637	7411	18	category	category	NN
18637	7411	19	of	of	IN
18637	7411	20	"	"	``
18637	7411	21	business	business	NN
18637	7411	22	affected	affect	VBN
18637	7411	23	with	with	IN
18637	7411	24	a	a	DT
18637	7411	25	public	public	JJ
18637	7411	26	interest	interest	NN
18637	7411	27	"	"	''
18637	7411	28	and	and	CC
18637	7411	29	whose	whose	WP$
18637	7411	30	property	property	NN
18637	7411	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	7411	32	"	"	``
18637	7411	33	impressed	impressed	JJ
18637	7411	34	with	with	IN
18637	7411	35	a	a	DT
18637	7411	36	public	public	JJ
18637	7411	37	use	use	NN
18637	7411	38	"	"	''
18637	7411	39	was	be	VBD
18637	7411	40	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	7411	41	.	.	.
18637	7412	1	A	a	DT
18637	7412	2	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	7412	3	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	7412	4	in	in	IN
18637	7412	5	such	such	PDT
18637	7412	6	a	a	DT
18637	7412	7	business	business	NN
18637	7412	8	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	7412	9	a	a	DT
18637	7412	10	"	"	``
18637	7412	11	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	7412	12	-	-	JJ
18637	7412	13	public	public	JJ
18637	7412	14	"	"	''
18637	7412	15	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	7412	16	,	,	,
18637	7412	17	the	the	DT
18637	7412	18	power	power	NN
18637	7412	19	of	of	IN
18637	7412	20	the	the	DT
18637	7412	21	State	State	NNP
18637	7412	22	to	to	TO
18637	7412	23	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	7412	24	which	which	WDT
18637	7412	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	7412	26	larger	large	JJR
18637	7412	27	than	than	IN
18637	7412	28	in	in	IN
18637	7412	29	the	the	DT
18637	7412	30	case	case	NN
18637	7412	31	of	of	IN
18637	7412	32	a	a	DT
18637	7412	33	purely	purely	RB
18637	7412	34	private	private	JJ
18637	7412	35	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	7412	36	.	.	.
18637	7413	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	7413	2	as	as	IN
18637	7413	3	most	most	JJS
18637	7413	4	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	7413	5	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	7413	6	public	public	JJ
18637	7413	7	franchises	franchise	NNS
18637	7413	8	are	be	VBP
18637	7413	9	of	of	IN
18637	7413	10	this	this	DT
18637	7413	11	character	character	NN
18637	7413	12	,	,	,
18637	7413	13	the	the	DT
18637	7413	14	final	final	JJ
18637	7413	15	result	result	NN
18637	7413	16	of	of	IN
18637	7413	17	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	7413	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7413	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	7413	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7413	21	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	7413	22	was	be	VBD
18637	7413	23	to	to	TO
18637	7413	24	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	7413	25	the	the	DT
18637	7413	26	police	police	NN
18637	7413	27	power	power	NN
18637	7413	28	of	of	IN
18637	7413	29	the	the	DT
18637	7413	30	State	State	NNP
18637	7413	31	in	in	IN
18637	7413	32	the	the	DT
18637	7413	33	case	case	NN
18637	7413	34	of	of	IN
18637	7413	35	the	the	DT
18637	7413	36	most	most	RBS
18637	7413	37	important	important	JJ
18637	7413	38	beneficiaries	beneficiary	NNS
18637	7413	39	of	of	IN
18637	7413	40	the	the	DT
18637	7413	41	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	7413	42	College	College	NNP
18637	7413	43	decision	decision	NN
18637	7413	44	.	.	.
18637	7414	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7414	2	1627	1627	CD
18637	7414	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7414	4	Meriwether	Meriwether	NNP
18637	7414	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7414	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7414	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7414	8	Garrett	Garrett	NNP
18637	7414	9	,	,	,
18637	7414	10	102	102	CD
18637	7414	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7414	12	472	472	CD
18637	7414	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7414	14	1880	1880	CD
18637	7414	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7414	16	;	;	:
18637	7414	17	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	7414	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7414	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	7414	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7414	21	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	7414	22	,	,	,
18637	7414	23	173	173	CD
18637	7414	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7414	25	231	231	CD
18637	7414	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7414	27	1899	1899	CD
18637	7414	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7414	29	;	;	:
18637	7414	30	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	7414	31	_	_	NNP
18637	7414	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	7414	33	_	_	NNP
18637	7414	34	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	7414	35	,	,	,
18637	7414	36	207	207	CD
18637	7414	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7414	38	161	161	CD
18637	7414	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7414	40	1907	1907	CD
18637	7414	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7414	42	.	.	.
18637	7415	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7415	2	1628	1628	CD
18637	7415	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7415	4	East	East	NNP
18637	7415	5	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	7415	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7415	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7415	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7415	9	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	7415	10	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	7415	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7415	12	,	,	,
18637	7415	13	10	10	CD
18637	7415	14	How	how	WRB
18637	7415	15	.	.	.
18637	7416	1	511	511	CD
18637	7416	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7416	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	7416	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7416	5	;	;	:
18637	7416	6	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	7416	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7416	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7416	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7416	10	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	7416	11	,	,	,
18637	7416	12	207	207	CD
18637	7416	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7416	14	161	161	CD
18637	7416	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7416	16	1907	1907	CD
18637	7416	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7416	18	.	.	.
18637	7417	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7417	2	1629	1629	CD
18637	7417	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7417	4	Trenton	Trenton	NNP
18637	7417	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7417	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7417	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7417	8	New	New	NNP
18637	7417	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	7417	10	,	,	,
18637	7417	11	262	262	CD
18637	7417	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7417	13	182	182	CD
18637	7417	14	,	,	,
18637	7417	15	191	191	CD
18637	7417	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7417	17	1923	1923	CD
18637	7417	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7417	19	.	.	.
18637	7418	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7418	2	1630	1630	CD
18637	7418	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7418	4	Newton	Newton	NNP
18637	7418	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7418	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7418	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7418	8	Mahoning	Mahoning	NNP
18637	7418	9	County	County	NNP
18637	7418	10	,	,	,
18637	7418	11	100	100	CD
18637	7418	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7418	13	548	548	CD
18637	7418	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7418	15	1880	1880	CD
18637	7418	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7418	17	.	.	.
18637	7419	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7419	2	1631	1631	CD
18637	7419	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7419	4	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	7419	5	General	General	NNP
18637	7419	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	7419	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	7419	8	.	.	.
18637	7420	1	Kies	Kies	NNPS
18637	7420	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7420	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7420	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7420	5	Lowrey	Lowrey	NNP
18637	7420	6	,	,	,
18637	7420	7	199	199	CD
18637	7420	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7420	9	233	233	CD
18637	7420	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7420	11	1905	1905	CD
18637	7420	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7420	13	.	.	.
18637	7421	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7421	2	1632	1632	CD
18637	7421	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7421	4	Faitoute	Faitoute	NNP
18637	7421	5	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	7421	6	&	&	CC
18637	7421	7	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	7421	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7421	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7421	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7421	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7421	12	Asbury	Asbury	NNP
18637	7421	13	Park	Park	NNP
18637	7421	14	,	,	,
18637	7421	15	316	316	CD
18637	7421	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7421	17	502	502	CD
18637	7421	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7421	19	1942	1942	CD
18637	7421	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7421	21	.	.	.
18637	7422	1	In	in	IN
18637	7422	2	this	this	DT
18637	7422	3	case	case	NN
18637	7422	4	the	the	DT
18637	7422	5	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	7422	6	involved	involve	VBN
18637	7422	7	were	be	VBD
18637	7422	8	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	7422	9	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	7422	10	,	,	,
18637	7422	11	and	and	CC
18637	7422	12	hence	hence	RB
18637	7422	13	"	"	``
18637	7422	14	private	private	JJ
18637	7422	15	"	"	''
18637	7422	16	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	7422	17	;	;	:
18637	7422	18	but	but	CC
18637	7422	19	the	the	DT
18637	7422	20	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	7422	21	power	power	NN
18637	7422	22	of	of	IN
18637	7422	23	the	the	DT
18637	7422	24	State	State	NNP
18637	7422	25	in	in	IN
18637	7422	26	relation	relation	NN
18637	7422	27	to	to	IN
18637	7422	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7422	29	municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	7422	30	was	be	VBD
18637	7422	31	one	one	CD
18637	7422	32	of	of	IN
18637	7422	33	the	the	DT
18637	7422	34	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	7422	35	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	7422	36	by	by	IN
18637	7422	37	the	the	DT
18637	7422	38	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7422	39	in	in	IN
18637	7422	40	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	7422	41	the	the	DT
18637	7422	42	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	7422	43	.	.	.
18637	7423	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7423	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7423	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7423	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7423	5	.	.	.
18637	7424	1	509	509	CD
18637	7424	2	.	.	.
18637	7425	1	"	"	``
18637	7425	2	'	'	``
18637	7425	3	A	a	DT
18637	7425	4	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	7425	5	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	7425	6	*	*	NFP
18637	7425	7	*	*	NFP
18637	7425	8	*	*	NFP
18637	7425	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	7425	10	a	a	DT
18637	7425	11	representative	representative	NN
18637	7425	12	not	not	RB
18637	7425	13	only	only	RB
18637	7425	14	of	of	IN
18637	7425	15	the	the	DT
18637	7425	16	State	State	NNP
18637	7425	17	,	,	,
18637	7425	18	but	but	CC
18637	7425	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	7425	20	a	a	DT
18637	7425	21	portion	portion	NN
18637	7425	22	of	of	IN
18637	7425	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7425	24	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	7425	25	power	power	NN
18637	7425	26	.	.	.
18637	7426	1	*	*	NFP
18637	7426	2	*	*	NFP
18637	7426	3	*	*	NFP
18637	7426	4	The	the	DT
18637	7426	5	State	State	NNP
18637	7426	6	may	may	MD
18637	7426	7	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	7426	8	these	these	DT
18637	7426	9	local	local	JJ
18637	7426	10	powers	power	NNS
18637	7426	11	of	of	IN
18637	7426	12	government	government	NN
18637	7426	13	at	at	IN
18637	7426	14	pleasure	pleasure	NN
18637	7426	15	,	,	,
18637	7426	16	and	and	CC
18637	7426	17	may	may	MD
18637	7426	18	,	,	,
18637	7426	19	through	through	IN
18637	7426	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7426	21	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	7426	22	or	or	CC
18637	7426	23	other	other	JJ
18637	7426	24	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	7426	25	channels	channel	NNS
18637	7426	26	,	,	,
18637	7426	27	govern	govern	VB
18637	7426	28	the	the	DT
18637	7426	29	local	local	JJ
18637	7426	30	territory	territory	NN
18637	7426	31	as	as	IN
18637	7426	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7426	33	governs	govern	VBZ
18637	7426	34	the	the	DT
18637	7426	35	State	State	NNP
18637	7426	36	at	at	IN
18637	7426	37	large	large	JJ
18637	7426	38	.	.	.
18637	7427	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7427	2	may	may	MD
18637	7427	3	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	7427	4	or	or	CC
18637	7427	5	contract	contract	VB
18637	7427	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7427	7	powers	power	NNS
18637	7427	8	or	or	CC
18637	7427	9	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	7427	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7427	11	existence	existence	NN
18637	7427	12	.	.	.
18637	7427	13	'	'	''
18637	7427	14	"	"	''
18637	7428	1	United	United	NNP
18637	7428	2	States	States	NNP
18637	7428	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7428	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	7428	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7428	6	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	7428	7	&	&	CC
18637	7428	8	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	7429	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7429	2	,	,	,
18637	7429	3	17	17	CD
18637	7429	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7429	5	.	.	.
18637	7430	1	322	322	CD
18637	7430	2	,	,	,
18637	7430	3	329	329	CD
18637	7430	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7430	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	7430	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7430	7	;	;	:
18637	7430	8	and	and	CC
18637	7430	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7430	10	see	see	VBP
18637	7430	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7430	12	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	7430	13	_	_	NNP
18637	7430	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	7430	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7430	16	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	7430	17	,	,	,
18637	7430	18	207	207	CD
18637	7430	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7430	20	161	161	CD
18637	7430	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7430	22	1907	1907	CD
18637	7430	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7430	24	.	.	.
18637	7431	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7431	2	1633	1633	CD
18637	7431	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7431	4	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	7431	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7431	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7431	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7431	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7431	9	,	,	,
18637	7431	10	10	10	CD
18637	7431	11	How	how	WRB
18637	7431	12	.	.	.
18637	7432	1	402	402	CD
18637	7432	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7432	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	7432	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7432	5	;	;	:
18637	7432	6	Fisk	Fisk	NNP
18637	7432	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7432	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7432	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7432	10	Police	Police	NNP
18637	7432	11	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	7432	12	,	,	,
18637	7432	13	116	116	CD
18637	7432	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7432	15	131	131	CD
18637	7432	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7432	17	1885	1885	CD
18637	7432	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7432	19	;	;	:
18637	7432	20	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	7432	21	_	_	NNP
18637	7432	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	7432	23	_	_	NNP
18637	7432	24	Board	Board	NNP
18637	7432	25	of	of	IN
18637	7432	26	Education	Education	NNP
18637	7432	27	,	,	,
18637	7432	28	302	302	CD
18637	7432	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7432	30	74	74	CD
18637	7432	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7432	32	1937	1937	CD
18637	7432	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7432	34	;	;	:
18637	7432	35	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	7432	36	Use	Use	NNP
18637	7432	37	of	of	IN
18637	7432	38	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	7432	39	_	_	NNP
18637	7432	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	7432	41	_	_	NNP
18637	7432	42	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	7432	43	,	,	,
18637	7432	44	276	276	CD
18637	7432	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7432	46	174	174	CD
18637	7432	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7432	48	1928	1928	CD
18637	7432	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7432	50	.	.	.
18637	7433	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7433	2	1634	1634	CD
18637	7433	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7433	4	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	7433	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7433	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7433	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7433	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7433	9	,	,	,
18637	7433	10	10	10	CD
18637	7433	11	How	how	WRB
18637	7433	12	.	.	.
18637	7434	1	420	420	CD
18637	7434	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7434	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	7434	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7434	5	.	.	.
18637	7435	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7435	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	7435	3	.	.	.
18637	7435	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7435	5	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	7435	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7435	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7435	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7435	9	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	7435	10	,	,	,
18637	7435	11	1	1	CD
18637	7435	12	Cr	cr	NN
18637	7435	13	.	.	.
18637	7436	1	137	137	CD
18637	7436	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7436	3	1803	1803	CD
18637	7436	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7436	5	;	;	:
18637	7436	6	Hoke	Hoke	NNP
18637	7436	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7436	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7436	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7436	10	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	7436	11	,	,	,
18637	7436	12	15	15	CD
18637	7436	13	N.C.	North Carolina	NNP
18637	7436	14	,	,	,
18637	7436	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7436	16	4	4	CD
18637	7436	17	Dev	Dev	NNP
18637	7436	18	.	.	.
18637	7436	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7437	1	1	1	CD
18637	7437	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7437	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	7437	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7437	5	.	.	.
18637	7438	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7438	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7438	3	also	also	RB
18637	7438	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7438	5	United	United	NNP
18637	7438	6	States	States	NNP
18637	7438	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7438	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7438	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7438	10	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	7438	11	,	,	,
18637	7438	12	109	109	CD
18637	7438	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7438	14	143	143	CD
18637	7438	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7438	16	1883	1883	CD
18637	7438	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7438	18	;	;	:
18637	7438	19	United	United	NNP
18637	7438	20	States	States	NNP
18637	7438	21	_	_	NNP
18637	7438	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	7438	23	_	_	NNP
18637	7438	24	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	7438	25	,	,	,
18637	7438	26	109	109	CD
18637	7438	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7438	28	146	146	CD
18637	7438	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7438	30	1883	1883	CD
18637	7438	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7438	32	;	;	:
18637	7438	33	Crenshaw	Crenshaw	NNP
18637	7438	34	_	_	NNP
18637	7438	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	7438	36	_	_	NNP
18637	7438	37	United	United	NNP
18637	7438	38	States	States	NNP
18637	7438	39	,	,	,
18637	7438	40	134	134	CD
18637	7438	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7438	42	99	99	CD
18637	7438	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7438	44	1890	1890	CD
18637	7438	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7438	46	.	.	.
18637	7439	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7439	2	1635	1635	CD
18637	7439	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7439	4	Fisk	Fisk	NNP
18637	7439	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7439	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7439	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7439	8	Police	Police	NNP
18637	7439	9	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	7439	10	,	,	,
18637	7439	11	116	116	CD
18637	7439	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7439	13	131	131	CD
18637	7439	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7439	15	1885	1885	CD
18637	7439	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7439	17	;	;	:
18637	7439	18	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	7439	19	Use	Use	NNP
18637	7439	20	of	of	IN
18637	7439	21	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	7439	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7439	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	7439	24	_	_	NNP
18637	7439	25	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	7439	26	,	,	,
18637	7439	27	276	276	CD
18637	7439	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7439	29	174	174	CD
18637	7439	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7439	31	1928	1928	CD
18637	7439	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7439	33	.	.	.
18637	7440	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7440	2	1636	1636	CD
18637	7440	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7440	4	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	7440	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7440	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7440	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7440	8	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	7440	9	,	,	,
18637	7440	10	103	103	CD
18637	7440	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7440	12	5	5	CD
18637	7440	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7440	14	1880	1880	CD
18637	7440	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7440	16	.	.	.
18637	7441	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7441	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	7441	3	.	.	.
18637	7441	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7441	5	Higginbotham	Higginbotham	NNP
18637	7441	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7441	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7441	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7441	9	Baton	Baton	NNP
18637	7441	10	Rouge	Rouge	NNP
18637	7441	11	,	,	,
18637	7441	12	306	306	CD
18637	7441	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7441	14	535	535	CD
18637	7441	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7441	16	1939	1939	CD
18637	7441	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7441	18	.	.	.
18637	7442	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7442	2	1637	1637	CD
18637	7442	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7442	4	Phelps	Phelps	NNP
18637	7442	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7442	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7442	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7442	8	Board	Board	NNP
18637	7442	9	of	of	IN
18637	7442	10	Education	Education	NNP
18637	7442	11	,	,	,
18637	7442	12	300	300	CD
18637	7442	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7442	14	319	319	CD
18637	7442	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7442	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	7442	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7442	18	.	.	.
18637	7443	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7443	2	1638	1638	CD
18637	7443	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7443	4	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	7443	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7443	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7443	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7443	8	Board	Board	NNP
18637	7443	9	of	of	IN
18637	7443	10	Education	Education	NNP
18637	7443	11	,	,	,
18637	7443	12	302	302	CD
18637	7443	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7443	14	74	74	CD
18637	7443	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7443	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	7443	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7443	18	.	.	.
18637	7444	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7444	2	1639	1639	CD
18637	7444	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7444	4	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	7444	5	ex	ex	FW
18637	7444	6	rel	rel	NNP
18637	7444	7	.	.	.
18637	7445	1	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	7445	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7445	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7445	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7445	5	Brand	Brand	NNP
18637	7445	6	303	303	CD
18637	7445	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7445	8	95	95	CD
18637	7445	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7445	10	1938	1938	CD
18637	7445	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7445	12	.	.	.
18637	7446	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7446	2	1640	1640	CD
18637	7446	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7446	4	7	7	CD
18637	7446	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	7446	6	.	.	.
18637	7447	1	164	164	NNP
18637	7447	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7447	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	7447	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7447	5	.	.	.
18637	7448	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7448	2	1641	1641	CD
18637	7448	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7448	4	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	7448	5	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	7448	6	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	7448	7	,	,	,
18637	7448	8	18	18	CD
18637	7448	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7448	10	.	.	.
18637	7449	1	206	206	CD
18637	7449	2	,	,	,
18637	7449	3	225	225	CD
18637	7449	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7449	5	1874	1874	CD
18637	7449	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7449	7	;	;	:
18637	7449	8	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	7449	9	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7449	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7449	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7449	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	7449	13	_	_	NNP
18637	7449	14	Maguire	Maguire	NNP
18637	7449	15	,	,	,
18637	7449	16	20	20	CD
18637	7449	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7449	18	.	.	.
18637	7450	1	36	36	CD
18637	7450	2	,	,	,
18637	7450	3	43	43	CD
18637	7450	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7450	5	1874	1874	CD
18637	7450	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7450	7	;	;	:
18637	7450	8	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	7450	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7450	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7450	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7450	12	Pegues	Pegues	NNP
18637	7450	13	,	,	,
18637	7450	14	16	16	CD
18637	7450	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7450	16	.	.	.
18637	7451	1	244	244	CD
18637	7451	2	,	,	,
18637	7451	3	249	249	CD
18637	7451	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7451	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	7451	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7451	7	;	;	:
18637	7451	8	Home	Home	NNP
18637	7451	9	of	of	IN
18637	7451	10	Friendless	Friendless	NNP
18637	7451	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7451	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	7451	13	_	_	NNP
18637	7451	14	Rouse	Rouse	NNP
18637	7451	15	,	,	,
18637	7451	16	8	8	CD
18637	7451	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7451	18	.	.	.
18637	7452	1	430	430	CD
18637	7452	2	,	,	,
18637	7452	3	438	438	CD
18637	7452	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7452	5	1869	1869	CD
18637	7452	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7452	7	.	.	.
18637	7453	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7453	2	1642	1642	CD
18637	7453	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7453	4	16	16	CD
18637	7453	5	How	how	WRB
18637	7453	6	.	.	.
18637	7454	1	369	369	CD
18637	7454	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7454	3	1854	1854	CD
18637	7454	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7454	5	.	.	.
18637	7455	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7455	2	1643	1643	CD
18637	7455	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7455	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7455	5	.	.	.
18637	7456	1	382	382	CD
18637	7456	2	-	-	SYM
18637	7456	3	383	383	CD
18637	7456	4	.	.	.
18637	7457	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7457	2	1644	1644	CD
18637	7457	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7457	4	Salt	Salt	NNP
18637	7457	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7457	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7457	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7457	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7457	9	East	East	NNP
18637	7457	10	Saginaw	Saginaw	NNP
18637	7457	11	,	,	,
18637	7457	12	13	13	CD
18637	7457	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7457	14	.	.	.
18637	7458	1	373	373	CD
18637	7458	2	,	,	,
18637	7458	3	379	379	CD
18637	7458	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7458	5	1872	1872	CD
18637	7458	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7458	7	.	.	.
18637	7459	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7459	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7459	3	also	also	RB
18637	7459	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7459	5	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	7459	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7459	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7459	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7459	9	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	7459	10	,	,	,
18637	7459	11	97	97	CD
18637	7459	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7459	13	541	541	CD
18637	7459	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7459	15	1879	1879	CD
18637	7459	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7459	17	;	;	:
18637	7459	18	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	7459	19	Lodge	Lodge	NNP
18637	7459	20	,	,	,
18637	7459	21	F.	F.	NNP
18637	7459	22	&	&	CC
18637	7459	23	A.M.	A.M.	NNP
18637	7459	24	_	_	NNP
18637	7459	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	7459	26	_	_	NNP
18637	7459	27	New	New	NNP
18637	7459	28	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7459	29	,	,	,
18637	7459	30	166	166	CD
18637	7459	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7459	32	143	143	CD
18637	7459	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7459	34	1897	1897	CD
18637	7459	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7459	36	;	;	:
18637	7459	37	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	7459	38	&	&	CC
18637	7459	39	M.R.	M.R.	NNP
18637	7460	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7460	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7460	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7460	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7460	5	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	7460	6	,	,	,
18637	7460	7	191	191	CD
18637	7460	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7460	9	379	379	CD
18637	7460	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7460	11	1903	1903	CD
18637	7460	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7460	13	.	.	.
18637	7461	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7461	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	7461	3	.	.	.
18637	7461	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7461	5	Ettor	Ettor	NNP
18637	7461	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7461	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7461	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7461	9	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
18637	7461	10	,	,	,
18637	7461	11	228	228	CD
18637	7461	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7461	13	148	148	CD
18637	7461	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7461	15	1913	1913	CD
18637	7461	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7461	17	,	,	,
18637	7461	18	in	in	IN
18637	7461	19	which	which	WDT
18637	7461	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7461	21	was	be	VBD
18637	7461	22	held	hold	VBN
18637	7461	23	that	that	IN
18637	7461	24	the	the	DT
18637	7461	25	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	7461	26	of	of	IN
18637	7461	27	a	a	DT
18637	7461	28	statute	statute	NN
18637	7461	29	providing	provide	VBG
18637	7461	30	for	for	IN
18637	7461	31	consequential	consequential	JJ
18637	7461	32	damages	damage	NNS
18637	7461	33	caused	cause	VBN
18637	7461	34	by	by	IN
18637	7461	35	changes	change	NNS
18637	7461	36	of	of	IN
18637	7461	37	grades	grade	NNS
18637	7461	38	of	of	IN
18637	7461	39	streets	street	NNS
18637	7461	40	could	could	MD
18637	7461	41	not	not	RB
18637	7461	42	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	7461	43	affect	affect	VB
18637	7461	44	an	an	DT
18637	7461	45	already	already	RB
18637	7461	46	accrued	accrue	VBN
18637	7461	47	right	right	NN
18637	7461	48	to	to	IN
18637	7461	49	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	7461	50	.	.	.
18637	7462	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7462	2	1645	1645	CD
18637	7462	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7462	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7462	5	See	See	NNP
18637	7462	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7462	7	Christ	Christ	NNP
18637	7462	8	Church	Church	NNP
18637	7462	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7462	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7462	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7462	12	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	7462	13	County	County	NNP
18637	7462	14	,	,	,
18637	7462	15	24	24	CD
18637	7462	16	How	how	WRB
18637	7462	17	.	.	.
18637	7463	1	300	300	CD
18637	7463	2	,	,	,
18637	7463	3	302	302	CD
18637	7463	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7463	5	1861	1861	CD
18637	7463	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7463	7	;	;	:
18637	7463	8	Seton	Seton	NNP
18637	7463	9	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	7463	10	College	College	NNP
18637	7463	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7463	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	7463	13	_	_	NNP
18637	7463	14	South	South	NNP
18637	7463	15	Orange	Orange	NNP
18637	7463	16	,	,	,
18637	7463	17	242	242	CD
18637	7463	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7463	19	100	100	CD
18637	7463	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7463	21	1916	1916	CD
18637	7463	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7463	23	.	.	.
18637	7464	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7464	2	1646	1646	CD
18637	7464	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7464	4	Compare	compare	VB
18637	7464	5	the	the	DT
18637	7464	6	above	above	JJ
18637	7464	7	case	case	NN
18637	7464	8	with	with	IN
18637	7464	9	Home	Home	NNP
18637	7464	10	of	of	IN
18637	7464	11	Friendless	Friendless	NNP
18637	7464	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7464	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	7464	14	_	_	NNP
18637	7464	15	Rouse	Rouse	NNP
18637	7464	16	,	,	,
18637	7464	17	8	8	CD
18637	7464	18	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7464	19	.	.	.
18637	7465	1	430	430	CD
18637	7465	2	,	,	,
18637	7465	3	437	437	CD
18637	7465	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7465	5	1869	1869	CD
18637	7465	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7465	7	;	;	:
18637	7465	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7465	9	also	also	RB
18637	7465	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7465	11	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	7465	12	Central	Central	NNP
18637	7465	13	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7465	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7465	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7465	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	7465	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7465	18	Decatur	Decatur	NNP
18637	7465	19	,	,	,
18637	7465	20	147	147	CD
18637	7465	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7465	22	190	190	CD
18637	7465	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7465	24	1893	1893	CD
18637	7465	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7465	26	with	with	IN
18637	7465	27	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	7465	28	&	&	CC
18637	7465	29	M.R.	M.R.	NNP
18637	7466	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7466	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7466	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7466	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7466	5	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	7466	6	,	,	,
18637	7466	7	191	191	CD
18637	7466	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7466	9	379	379	CD
18637	7466	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7466	11	1903	1903	CD
18637	7466	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7466	13	.	.	.
18637	7467	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7467	2	1647	1647	CD
18637	7467	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7467	4	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	7467	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7467	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7467	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7467	8	Hahlo	Hahlo	NNP
18637	7467	9	,	,	,
18637	7467	10	258	258	CD
18637	7467	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7467	12	142	142	CD
18637	7467	13	,	,	,
18637	7467	14	145	145	CD
18637	7467	15	-	-	SYM
18637	7467	16	146	146	CD
18637	7467	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7467	18	1922	1922	CD
18637	7467	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7467	20	;	;	:
18637	7467	21	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7467	22	ex	ex	NNP
18637	7467	23	rel	rel	NN
18637	7467	24	.	.	.
18637	7468	1	Folsom	Folsom	NNP
18637	7468	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7468	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7468	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7468	5	New	New	NNP
18637	7468	6	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7468	7	,	,	,
18637	7468	8	109	109	CD
18637	7468	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7468	10	285	285	CD
18637	7468	11	,	,	,
18637	7468	12	288	288	CD
18637	7468	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7468	14	1883	1883	CD
18637	7468	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7468	16	;	;	:
18637	7468	17	Morley	Morley	NNP
18637	7468	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7468	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	7468	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7468	21	Lakeshore	Lakeshore	NNP
18637	7468	22	&	&	CC
18637	7468	23	M.S.R.	M.S.R.	NNP
18637	7469	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7469	2	,	,	,
18637	7469	3	146	146	CD
18637	7469	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7469	5	162	162	CD
18637	7469	6	,	,	,
18637	7469	7	169	169	CD
18637	7469	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7469	9	1892	1892	CD
18637	7469	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7469	11	.	.	.
18637	7470	1	That	that	IN
18637	7470	2	the	the	DT
18637	7470	3	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	7470	4	of	of	IN
18637	7470	5	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	7470	6	clause	clause	NNP
18637	7470	7	did	do	VBD
18637	7470	8	not	not	RB
18637	7470	9	protect	protect	VB
18637	7470	10	vested	vested	JJ
18637	7470	11	rights	right	NNS
18637	7470	12	merely	merely	RB
18637	7470	13	as	as	IN
18637	7470	14	such	such	JJ
18637	7470	15	was	be	VBD
18637	7470	16	stated	state	VBN
18637	7470	17	by	by	IN
18637	7470	18	the	the	DT
18637	7470	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7470	20	as	as	RB
18637	7470	21	early	early	RB
18637	7470	22	as	as	IN
18637	7470	23	Satterlee	Satterlee	NNP
18637	7470	24	_	_	NNP
18637	7470	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	7470	26	_	_	NNP
18637	7470	27	Matthewson	Matthewson	NNP
18637	7470	28	,	,	,
18637	7470	29	2	2	CD
18637	7470	30	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7470	31	.	.	.
18637	7471	1	380	380	CD
18637	7471	2	,	,	,
18637	7471	3	413	413	CD
18637	7471	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7471	5	1829	1829	CD
18637	7471	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7471	7	;	;	:
18637	7471	8	and	and	CC
18637	7471	9	again	again	RB
18637	7471	10	in	in	IN
18637	7471	11	the	the	DT
18637	7471	12	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	7471	13	River	River	NNP
18637	7471	14	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	7471	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7471	16	_	_	NNP
18637	7471	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	7471	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7471	19	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	7471	20	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	7471	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7471	22	,	,	,
18637	7471	23	11	11	CD
18637	7471	24	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7471	25	.	.	.
18637	7472	1	420	420	CD
18637	7472	2	,	,	,
18637	7472	3	539	539	CD
18637	7472	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	7472	5	540	540	CD
18637	7472	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7472	7	1837	1837	CD
18637	7472	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7472	9	.	.	.
18637	7473	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7473	2	1648	1648	CD
18637	7473	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7473	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7473	5	See	See	NNP
18637	7473	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7473	7	Story	Story	NNP
18637	7473	8	's	's	POS
18637	7473	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	7473	10	.	.	.
18637	7474	1	4	4	CD
18637	7474	2	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7474	3	.	.	.
18637	7475	1	at	at	IN
18637	7475	2	712	712	CD
18637	7475	3	.	.	.
18637	7476	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7476	2	1649	1649	CD
18637	7476	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7476	4	Home	Home	NNP
18637	7476	5	of	of	IN
18637	7476	6	Friendless	Friendless	NNP
18637	7476	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7476	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7476	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7476	10	Rouse	Rouse	NNP
18637	7476	11	,	,	,
18637	7476	12	8	8	CD
18637	7476	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7476	14	.	.	.
18637	7477	1	430	430	CD
18637	7477	2	,	,	,
18637	7477	3	438	438	CD
18637	7477	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7477	5	1869	1869	CD
18637	7477	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7477	7	;	;	:
18637	7477	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7477	9	College	College	NNP
18637	7477	10	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	7477	11	,	,	,
18637	7477	12	13	13	CD
18637	7477	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7477	14	.	.	.
18637	7478	1	190	190	CD
18637	7478	2	,	,	,
18637	7478	3	213	213	CD
18637	7478	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7478	5	1872	1872	CD
18637	7478	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7478	7	;	;	:
18637	7478	8	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	7478	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7478	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7478	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7478	12	New	New	NNP
18637	7478	13	York	York	NNP
18637	7478	14	,	,	,
18637	7478	15	15	15	CD
18637	7478	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7478	17	.	.	.
18637	7479	1	478	478	CD
18637	7479	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7479	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	7479	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7479	5	;	;	:
18637	7479	6	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	7479	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7479	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7479	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7479	10	Charleston	Charleston	NNP
18637	7479	11	,	,	,
18637	7479	12	96	96	CD
18637	7479	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7479	14	432	432	CD
18637	7479	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7479	16	1878	1878	CD
18637	7479	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7479	18	;	;	:
18637	7479	19	Greenwood	Greenwood	NNP
18637	7479	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7479	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	7479	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7479	23	Union	Union	NNP
18637	7479	24	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	7479	25	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7479	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7479	27	,	,	,
18637	7479	28	105	105	CD
18637	7479	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7479	30	13	13	CD
18637	7479	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7479	32	1882	1882	CD
18637	7479	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7479	34	;	;	:
18637	7479	35	Chesapeake	Chesapeake	NNP
18637	7479	36	&	&	CC
18637	7479	37	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	7480	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7480	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7480	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7480	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7480	5	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	7480	6	,	,	,
18637	7480	7	114	114	CD
18637	7480	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7480	9	176	176	CD
18637	7480	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7480	11	1885	1885	CD
18637	7480	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7480	13	;	;	:
18637	7480	14	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	7480	15	Water	Water	NNP
18637	7480	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7480	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7480	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	7480	19	_	_	NNP
18637	7480	20	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	7480	21	,	,	,
18637	7480	22	143	143	CD
18637	7480	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7480	24	1	1	CD
18637	7480	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7480	26	1892	1892	CD
18637	7480	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7480	28	.	.	.
18637	7481	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7481	2	1650	1650	CD
18637	7481	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7481	4	New	New	NNP
18637	7481	5	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	7481	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7481	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7481	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7481	9	Yard	Yard	NNP
18637	7481	10	,	,	,
18637	7481	11	95	95	CD
18637	7481	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7481	13	104	104	CD
18637	7481	14	,	,	,
18637	7481	15	111	111	CD
18637	7481	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7481	17	1877	1877	CD
18637	7481	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7481	19	.	.	.
18637	7482	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7482	2	1651	1651	CD
18637	7482	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7482	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7482	5	See	See	NNP
18637	7482	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7482	7	Holyoke	Holyoke	NNP
18637	7482	8	Water	Water	NNP
18637	7482	9	Power	Power	NNP
18637	7482	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7482	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7482	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	7482	13	_	_	NNP
18637	7482	14	Lyman	Lyman	NNP
18637	7482	15	,	,	,
18637	7482	16	15	15	CD
18637	7482	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7482	18	.	.	.
18637	7483	1	500	500	CD
18637	7483	2	,	,	,
18637	7483	3	520	520	CD
18637	7483	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7483	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	7483	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7483	7	,	,	,
18637	7483	8	following	follow	VBG
18637	7483	9	Fisheries	Fisheries	NNPS
18637	7483	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7483	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	7483	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7483	13	Holyoke	Holyoke	NNP
18637	7483	14	Water	Water	NNP
18637	7483	15	Power	Power	NNP
18637	7483	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7483	17	,	,	,
18637	7483	18	104	104	CD
18637	7483	19	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	7484	1	446	446	CD
18637	7484	2	,	,	,
18637	7484	3	451	451	CD
18637	7484	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7484	5	1870	1870	CD
18637	7484	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7484	7	;	;	:
18637	7484	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7484	9	also	also	RB
18637	7484	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7484	11	Shields	Shields	NNP
18637	7484	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7484	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	7484	14	_	_	NNP
18637	7484	15	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	7484	16	,	,	,
18637	7484	17	95	95	CD
18637	7484	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7484	19	319	319	CD
18637	7484	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7484	21	1877	1877	CD
18637	7484	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7484	23	;	;	:
18637	7484	24	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	7484	25	Haven	Haven	NNP
18637	7484	26	&	&	CC
18637	7484	27	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	7484	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7484	29	_	_	NNP
18637	7484	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	7484	31	_	_	NNP
18637	7484	32	New	New	NNP
18637	7484	33	Haven	Haven	NNP
18637	7484	34	,	,	,
18637	7484	35	203	203	CD
18637	7484	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7484	37	379	379	CD
18637	7484	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7484	39	1906	1906	CD
18637	7484	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7484	41	;	;	:
18637	7484	42	Berea	Berea	NNP
18637	7484	43	College	College	NNP
18637	7484	44	_	_	NNP
18637	7484	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	7484	46	_	_	NNP
18637	7484	47	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	7484	48	,	,	,
18637	7484	49	211	211	CD
18637	7484	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7484	51	45	45	CD
18637	7484	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7484	53	1908	1908	CD
18637	7484	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7484	55	.	.	.
18637	7485	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7485	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7485	3	also	also	RB
18637	7485	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7485	5	Lothrop	Lothrop	NNP
18637	7485	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7485	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7485	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7485	9	Stedman	Stedman	NNP
18637	7485	10	,	,	,
18637	7485	11	15	15	CD
18637	7485	12	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	7485	13	.	.	.
18637	7486	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	7486	2	.	.	.
18637	7487	1	No	no	UH
18637	7487	2	.	.	.
18637	7488	1	8,519	8,519	CD
18637	7488	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7488	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	7488	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7488	5	,	,	,
18637	7488	6	where	where	WRB
18637	7488	7	the	the	DT
18637	7488	8	principles	principle	NNS
18637	7488	9	of	of	IN
18637	7488	10	natural	natural	JJ
18637	7488	11	justice	justice	NN
18637	7488	12	are	be	VBP
18637	7488	13	thought	think	VBN
18637	7488	14	to	to	TO
18637	7488	15	set	set	VB
18637	7488	16	a	a	DT
18637	7488	17	limit	limit	NN
18637	7488	18	to	to	IN
18637	7488	19	the	the	DT
18637	7488	20	power	power	NN
18637	7488	21	.	.	.
18637	7489	1	Earlier	early	RBR
18637	7489	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	7489	3	Zabriskie	Zabriskie	NNP
18637	7489	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7489	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	7489	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7489	7	Hackensack	Hackensack	NNP
18637	7489	8	&	&	CC
18637	7489	9	N.Y.R.	N.Y.R.	NNP
18637	7490	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7490	2	,	,	,
18637	7490	3	18	18	CD
18637	7490	4	N.J.	New Jersey	NNP
18637	7490	5	Eq	Eq	NNS
18637	7490	6	.	.	.
18637	7491	1	178	178	CD
18637	7491	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7491	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	7491	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7491	5	where	where	WRB
18637	7491	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7491	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	7491	8	said	say	VBN
18637	7491	9	that	that	IN
18637	7491	10	a	a	DT
18637	7491	11	new	new	JJ
18637	7491	12	charter	charter	NN
18637	7491	13	may	may	MD
18637	7491	14	not	not	RB
18637	7491	15	be	be	VB
18637	7491	16	substituted	substitute	VBN
18637	7491	17	;	;	:
18637	7491	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7491	19	also	also	RB
18637	7491	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7491	21	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	7491	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7491	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	7491	24	_	_	NNP
18637	7491	25	McKean	McKean	NNP
18637	7491	26	,	,	,
18637	7491	27	1	1	CD
18637	7491	28	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	7491	29	.	.	.
18637	7492	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	7492	2	.	.	.
18637	7493	1	No	no	UH
18637	7493	2	.	.	.
18637	7494	1	229	229	CD
18637	7494	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7494	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	7494	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7494	5	in	in	IN
18637	7494	6	which	which	WDT
18637	7494	7	a	a	DT
18637	7494	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	7494	9	court	court	NN
18637	7494	10	set	set	VBD
18637	7494	11	aside	aside	RP
18637	7494	12	a	a	DT
18637	7494	13	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	7494	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	7494	15	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	7494	16	like	like	IN
18637	7494	17	the	the	DT
18637	7494	18	one	one	NN
18637	7494	19	involved	involve	VBN
18637	7494	20	in	in	IN
18637	7494	21	the	the	DT
18637	7494	22	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	7494	23	College	College	NNP
18637	7494	24	case	case	NN
18637	7494	25	,	,	,
18637	7494	26	on	on	IN
18637	7494	27	the	the	DT
18637	7494	28	ground	ground	NN
18637	7494	29	that	that	IN
18637	7494	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7494	31	went	go	VBD
18637	7494	32	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	7494	33	the	the	DT
18637	7494	34	power	power	NN
18637	7494	35	of	of	IN
18637	7494	36	mere	mere	JJ
18637	7494	37	alteration	alteration	NN
18637	7494	38	.	.	.
18637	7495	1	In	in	IN
18637	7495	2	this	this	DT
18637	7495	3	case	case	NN
18637	7495	4	,	,	,
18637	7495	5	however	however	RB
18637	7495	6	,	,	,
18637	7495	7	only	only	RB
18637	7495	8	the	the	DT
18637	7495	9	right	right	NN
18637	7495	10	to	to	TO
18637	7495	11	alter	alter	VB
18637	7495	12	had	have	VBD
18637	7495	13	been	be	VBN
18637	7495	14	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	7495	15	,	,	,
18637	7495	16	in	in	IN
18637	7495	17	the	the	DT
18637	7495	18	charter	charter	NN
18637	7495	19	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7495	20	,	,	,
18637	7495	21	and	and	CC
18637	7495	22	not	not	RB
18637	7495	23	the	the	DT
18637	7495	24	right	right	NN
18637	7495	25	to	to	TO
18637	7495	26	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	7495	27	.	.	.
18637	7496	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7496	2	1652	1652	CD
18637	7496	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7496	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7496	5	See	See	NNP
18637	7496	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7496	7	in	in	IN
18637	7496	8	this	this	DT
18637	7496	9	connection	connection	NN
18637	7496	10	the	the	DT
18637	7496	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	7496	12	cited	cite	VBN
18637	7496	13	by	by	IN
18637	7496	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7496	15	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	7496	16	in	in	IN
18637	7496	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7496	18	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	7496	19	for	for	IN
18637	7496	20	the	the	DT
18637	7496	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7496	22	in	in	IN
18637	7496	23	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	7496	24	Petroleum	Petroleum	NNP
18637	7496	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7496	26	_	_	NNP
18637	7496	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	7496	28	_	_	NNP
18637	7496	29	Jenkins	Jenkins	NNP
18637	7496	30	,	,	,
18637	7496	31	297	297	CD
18637	7496	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7496	33	629	629	CD
18637	7496	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7496	35	1936	1936	CD
18637	7496	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7496	37	.	.	.
18637	7497	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7497	2	1653	1653	CD
18637	7497	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7497	4	Curran	Curran	NNP
18637	7497	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7497	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7497	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7497	8	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	7497	9	,	,	,
18637	7497	10	15	15	CD
18637	7497	11	How	how	WRB
18637	7497	12	.	.	.
18637	7498	1	304	304	CD
18637	7498	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7498	3	1853	1853	CD
18637	7498	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7498	5	;	;	:
18637	7498	6	Shields	Shields	NNP
18637	7498	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7498	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7498	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7498	10	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	7498	11	,	,	,
18637	7498	12	95	95	CD
18637	7498	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7498	14	319	319	CD
18637	7498	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7498	16	1877	1877	CD
18637	7498	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7498	18	;	;	:
18637	7498	19	Greenwood	Greenwood	NNP
18637	7498	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7498	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	7498	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7498	23	Union	Union	NNP
18637	7498	24	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	7498	25	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7498	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7498	27	,	,	,
18637	7498	28	105	105	CD
18637	7498	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7498	30	13	13	CD
18637	7498	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7498	32	1882	1882	CD
18637	7498	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7498	34	;	;	:
18637	7498	35	Adirondack	Adirondack	NNP
18637	7498	36	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7498	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7498	38	_	_	NNP
18637	7498	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	7498	40	_	_	NNP
18637	7498	41	New	New	NNP
18637	7498	42	York	York	NNP
18637	7498	43	,	,	,
18637	7498	44	176	176	CD
18637	7498	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7498	46	335	335	CD
18637	7498	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7498	48	1900	1900	CD
18637	7498	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7498	50	;	;	:
18637	7498	51	Stearns	Stearns	NNP
18637	7498	52	_	_	NNP
18637	7498	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	7498	54	_	_	NNP
18637	7498	55	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	7498	56	,	,	,
18637	7498	57	179	179	CD
18637	7498	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7498	59	223	223	CD
18637	7498	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7498	61	1900	1900	CD
18637	7498	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7498	63	;	;	:
18637	7498	64	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	7498	65	,	,	,
18637	7498	66	M.	M.	NNP
18637	7498	67	&	&	CC
18637	7498	68	St.	St.	NNP
18637	7498	69	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	7499	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7499	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7499	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7499	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7499	5	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	7499	6	,	,	,
18637	7499	7	238	238	CD
18637	7499	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7499	9	491	491	CD
18637	7499	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7499	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	7499	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7499	13	;	;	:
18637	7499	14	Coombes	Coombes	NNP
18637	7499	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7499	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	7499	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7499	18	Getz	Getz	NNP
18637	7499	19	,	,	,
18637	7499	20	285	285	CD
18637	7499	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7499	22	434	434	CD
18637	7499	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7499	24	1932	1932	CD
18637	7499	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7499	26	.	.	.
18637	7500	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7500	2	1654	1654	CD
18637	7500	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7500	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7500	5	College	College	NNP
18637	7500	6	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	7500	7	,	,	,
18637	7500	8	13	13	CD
18637	7500	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7500	10	.	.	.
18637	7501	1	190	190	CD
18637	7501	2	,	,	,
18637	7501	3	218	218	CD
18637	7501	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7501	5	1872	1872	CD
18637	7501	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7501	7	.	.	.
18637	7502	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7502	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7502	3	also	also	RB
18637	7502	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7502	5	Calder	Calder	NNP
18637	7502	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7502	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7502	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7502	9	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	7502	10	,	,	,
18637	7502	11	218	218	CD
18637	7502	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7502	13	591	591	CD
18637	7502	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7502	15	1910	1910	CD
18637	7502	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7502	17	.	.	.
18637	7503	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7503	2	1655	1655	CD
18637	7503	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7503	4	Lakeshore	Lakeshore	NNP
18637	7503	5	&	&	CC
18637	7503	6	M.S.R.	M.S.R.	NNP
18637	7504	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7504	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7504	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7504	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7504	5	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	7504	6	,	,	,
18637	7504	7	173	173	CD
18637	7504	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7504	9	684	684	CD
18637	7504	10	,	,	,
18637	7504	11	690	690	CD
18637	7504	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7504	13	1899	1899	CD
18637	7504	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7504	15	;	;	:
18637	7504	16	Coombes	Coombes	NNP
18637	7504	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7504	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	7504	19	_	_	NNP
18637	7504	20	Getz	Getz	NNP
18637	7504	21	,	,	,
18637	7504	22	285	285	CD
18637	7504	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7504	24	434	434	CD
18637	7504	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7504	26	1932	1932	CD
18637	7504	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7504	28	.	.	.
18637	7505	1	Both	both	DT
18637	7505	2	these	these	DT
18637	7505	3	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	7505	4	cite	cite	VBP
18637	7505	5	Greenwood	Greenwood	NNP
18637	7505	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7505	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7505	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7505	9	Union	Union	NNP
18637	7505	10	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	7505	11	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7505	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7505	13	,	,	,
18637	7505	14	105	105	CD
18637	7505	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7505	16	13	13	CD
18637	7505	17	,	,	,
18637	7505	18	17	17	CD
18637	7505	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7505	20	1882	1882	CD
18637	7505	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7505	22	,	,	,
18637	7505	23	but	but	CC
18637	7505	24	without	without	IN
18637	7505	25	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	7505	26	justification	justification	NN
18637	7505	27	.	.	.
18637	7506	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7506	2	1656	1656	CD
18637	7506	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7506	4	4	4	CD
18637	7506	5	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	7506	6	.	.	.
18637	7507	1	514	514	CD
18637	7507	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7507	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	7507	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7507	5	.	.	.
18637	7508	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7508	2	1657	1657	CD
18637	7508	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7508	4	Thorpe	Thorpe	NNP
18637	7508	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7508	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7508	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7508	8	Rutland	Rutland	NNP
18637	7508	9	&	&	CC
18637	7508	10	Burlington	Burlington	NNP
18637	7508	11	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	7508	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7508	13	,	,	,
18637	7508	14	27	27	CD
18637	7508	15	Vt	Vt	NNP
18637	7508	16	.	.	NNP
18637	7508	17	140	140	CD
18637	7508	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7508	19	1854	1854	CD
18637	7508	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7508	21	.	.	.
18637	7509	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7509	2	1658	1658	CD
18637	7509	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7509	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	7509	5	a	a	DT
18637	7509	6	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	7509	7	may	may	MD
18637	7509	8	be	be	VB
18637	7509	9	required	require	VBN
18637	7509	10	,	,	,
18637	7509	11	at	at	IN
18637	7509	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7509	13	own	own	JJ
18637	7509	14	expense	expense	NN
18637	7509	15	and	and	CC
18637	7509	16	irrespective	irrespective	JJ
18637	7509	17	of	of	IN
18637	7509	18	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	7509	19	to	to	IN
18637	7509	20	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7509	21	,	,	,
18637	7509	22	to	to	TO
18637	7509	23	eliminate	eliminate	VB
18637	7509	24	grade	grade	NN
18637	7509	25	crossings	crossing	NNS
18637	7509	26	in	in	IN
18637	7509	27	the	the	DT
18637	7509	28	interest	interest	NN
18637	7509	29	of	of	IN
18637	7509	30	public	public	JJ
18637	7509	31	safety	safety	NN
18637	7509	32	,	,	,
18637	7509	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7509	34	New	New	NNP
18637	7509	35	York	York	NNP
18637	7509	36	&	&	CC
18637	7509	37	N.E.R.	N.E.R.	NNP
18637	7510	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7510	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7510	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7510	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7510	5	Bristol	Bristol	NNP
18637	7510	6	,	,	,
18637	7510	7	151	151	CD
18637	7510	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7510	9	556	556	CD
18637	7510	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7510	11	1894	1894	CD
18637	7510	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7510	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7510	14	;	;	:
18637	7510	15	to	to	TO
18637	7510	16	make	make	VB
18637	7510	17	highway	highway	NN
18637	7510	18	crossings	crossing	NNS
18637	7510	19	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	7510	20	safe	safe	JJ
18637	7510	21	and	and	CC
18637	7510	22	convenient	convenient	JJ
18637	7510	23	for	for	IN
18637	7510	24	public	public	JJ
18637	7510	25	use	use	NN
18637	7510	26	,	,	,
18637	7510	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7510	28	Great	Great	NNP
18637	7510	29	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	7510	30	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7510	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7510	32	_	_	NNP
18637	7510	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	7510	34	_	_	NNP
18637	7510	35	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	7510	36	,	,	,
18637	7510	37	246	246	CD
18637	7510	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7510	39	434	434	CD
18637	7510	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7510	41	1918	1918	CD
18637	7510	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7510	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7510	44	;	;	:
18637	7510	45	to	to	TO
18637	7510	46	repair	repair	VB
18637	7510	47	viaducts	viaduct	NNS
18637	7510	48	,	,	,
18637	7510	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7510	50	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	7510	51	Pac	Pac	NNP
18637	7510	52	.	.	.
18637	7511	1	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7511	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7511	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7511	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	7511	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7511	6	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	7511	7	,	,	,
18637	7511	8	208	208	CD
18637	7511	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7511	10	583	583	CD
18637	7511	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7511	12	1908	1908	CD
18637	7511	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7511	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7511	15	;	;	:
18637	7511	16	and	and	CC
18637	7511	17	to	to	TO
18637	7511	18	fence	fence	VB
18637	7511	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7511	20	right	right	NN
18637	7511	21	of	of	IN
18637	7511	22	way	way	NN
18637	7511	23	,	,	,
18637	7511	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7511	25	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
18637	7511	26	&	&	CC
18637	7511	27	St.	St.	NNP
18637	7511	28	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	7512	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7512	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7512	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7512	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7512	5	Emmons	Emmons	NNP
18637	7512	6	,	,	,
18637	7512	7	149	149	CD
18637	7512	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7512	9	364	364	CD
18637	7512	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7512	11	1893	1893	CD
18637	7512	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7512	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7512	14	.	.	.
18637	7513	1	Though	though	IN
18637	7513	2	a	a	DT
18637	7513	3	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	7513	4	company	company	NN
18637	7513	5	owns	own	VBZ
18637	7513	6	the	the	DT
18637	7513	7	right	right	NN
18637	7513	8	of	of	IN
18637	7513	9	way	way	NN
18637	7513	10	along	along	IN
18637	7513	11	a	a	DT
18637	7513	12	street	street	NN
18637	7513	13	,	,	,
18637	7513	14	the	the	DT
18637	7513	15	city	city	NN
18637	7513	16	may	may	MD
18637	7513	17	require	require	VB
18637	7513	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7513	19	to	to	TO
18637	7513	20	lay	lay	VB
18637	7513	21	tracks	track	NNS
18637	7513	22	to	to	TO
18637	7513	23	conform	conform	VB
18637	7513	24	to	to	IN
18637	7513	25	the	the	DT
18637	7513	26	established	established	JJ
18637	7513	27	grade	grade	NN
18637	7513	28	;	;	:
18637	7513	29	to	to	TO
18637	7513	30	fill	fill	VB
18637	7513	31	in	in	RP
18637	7513	32	tracks	track	NNS
18637	7513	33	at	at	IN
18637	7513	34	street	street	NN
18637	7513	35	intersections	intersection	NNS
18637	7513	36	;	;	:
18637	7513	37	and	and	CC
18637	7513	38	to	to	TO
18637	7513	39	remove	remove	VB
18637	7513	40	tracks	track	NNS
18637	7513	41	from	from	IN
18637	7513	42	a	a	DT
18637	7513	43	busy	busy	JJ
18637	7513	44	street	street	NN
18637	7513	45	intersection	intersection	NN
18637	7513	46	,	,	,
18637	7513	47	when	when	WRB
18637	7513	48	the	the	DT
18637	7513	49	attendant	attendant	JJ
18637	7513	50	disadvantages	disadvantage	NNS
18637	7513	51	and	and	CC
18637	7513	52	expense	expense	NN
18637	7513	53	are	be	VBP
18637	7513	54	small	small	JJ
18637	7513	55	and	and	CC
18637	7513	56	the	the	DT
18637	7513	57	safety	safety	NN
18637	7513	58	of	of	IN
18637	7513	59	the	the	DT
18637	7513	60	public	public	NN
18637	7513	61	appreciably	appreciably	RB
18637	7513	62	enhanced	enhance	VBN
18637	7513	63	,	,	,
18637	7513	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7513	65	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	7513	66	&	&	CC
18637	7513	67	R.G.R.	R.G.R.	NNP
18637	7514	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7514	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7514	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7514	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7514	5	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	7514	6	,	,	,
18637	7514	7	250	250	CD
18637	7514	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7514	9	241	241	CD
18637	7514	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7514	11	1919	1919	CD
18637	7514	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7514	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7514	14	.	.	.
18637	7515	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	7515	2	the	the	DT
18637	7515	3	State	State	NNP
18637	7515	4	,	,	,
18637	7515	5	in	in	IN
18637	7515	6	the	the	DT
18637	7515	7	public	public	JJ
18637	7515	8	interest	interest	NN
18637	7515	9	,	,	,
18637	7515	10	may	may	MD
18637	7515	11	require	require	VB
18637	7515	12	a	a	DT
18637	7515	13	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	7515	14	to	to	TO
18637	7515	15	reestablish	reestablish	VB
18637	7515	16	an	an	DT
18637	7515	17	abandoned	abandon	VBN
18637	7515	18	station	station	NN
18637	7515	19	,	,	,
18637	7515	20	even	even	RB
18637	7515	21	though	though	IN
18637	7515	22	the	the	DT
18637	7515	23	railroad	railroad	NNP
18637	7515	24	commission	commission	NNP
18637	7515	25	had	have	VBD
18637	7515	26	previously	previously	RB
18637	7515	27	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	7515	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7515	29	abandonment	abandonment	NN
18637	7515	30	on	on	IN
18637	7515	31	condition	condition	NN
18637	7515	32	that	that	IN
18637	7515	33	another	another	DT
18637	7515	34	station	station	NN
18637	7515	35	be	be	VB
18637	7515	36	established	establish	VBN
18637	7515	37	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	7515	38	,	,	,
18637	7515	39	a	a	DT
18637	7515	40	condition	condition	NN
18637	7515	41	which	which	WDT
18637	7515	42	had	have	VBD
18637	7515	43	been	be	VBN
18637	7515	44	complied	comply	VBN
18637	7515	45	with	with	IN
18637	7515	46	,	,	,
18637	7515	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7515	48	New	New	NNP
18637	7515	49	Haven	Haven	NNP
18637	7515	50	&	&	CC
18637	7515	51	N.	N.	NNP
18637	7515	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7515	53	_	_	NNP
18637	7515	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	7515	55	_	_	NNP
18637	7515	56	Hamersley	Hamersley	NNP
18637	7515	57	,	,	,
18637	7515	58	104	104	CD
18637	7515	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7515	60	1	1	CD
18637	7515	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7515	62	1881	1881	CD
18637	7515	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7515	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7515	65	.	.	.
18637	7516	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7516	2	may	may	MD
18637	7516	3	impose	impose	VB
18637	7516	4	upon	upon	IN
18637	7516	5	a	a	DT
18637	7516	6	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	7516	7	liability	liability	NN
18637	7516	8	for	for	IN
18637	7516	9	fire	fire	NN
18637	7516	10	communicated	communicate	VBN
18637	7516	11	by	by	IN
18637	7516	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7516	13	locomotives	locomotive	NNS
18637	7516	14	,	,	,
18637	7516	15	even	even	RB
18637	7516	16	though	though	IN
18637	7516	17	the	the	DT
18637	7516	18	State	State	NNP
18637	7516	19	had	have	VBD
18637	7516	20	previously	previously	RB
18637	7516	21	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	7516	22	the	the	DT
18637	7516	23	company	company	NN
18637	7516	24	to	to	TO
18637	7516	25	use	use	VB
18637	7516	26	said	say	VBN
18637	7516	27	type	type	NN
18637	7516	28	of	of	IN
18637	7516	29	locomotive	locomotive	JJ
18637	7516	30	power	power	NN
18637	7516	31	,	,	,
18637	7516	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7516	33	St.	St.	NNP
18637	7516	34	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	7516	35	&	&	CC
18637	7516	36	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	7517	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7517	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7517	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7517	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7517	5	Mathews	Mathews	NNP
18637	7517	6	,	,	,
18637	7517	7	165	165	CD
18637	7517	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7517	9	1	1	CD
18637	7517	10	,	,	,
18637	7517	11	5	5	CD
18637	7517	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7517	13	1897	1897	CD
18637	7517	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7517	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7517	16	;	;	:
18637	7517	17	and	and	CC
18637	7517	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7517	19	may	may	MD
18637	7517	20	penalize	penalize	VB
18637	7517	21	the	the	DT
18637	7517	22	failure	failure	NN
18637	7517	23	to	to	TO
18637	7517	24	cut	cut	VB
18637	7517	25	drains	drain	NNS
18637	7517	26	through	through	IN
18637	7517	27	embankments	embankment	NNS
18637	7517	28	so	so	IN
18637	7517	29	as	as	IN
18637	7517	30	to	to	TO
18637	7517	31	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	7517	32	flooding	flooding	NN
18637	7517	33	of	of	IN
18637	7517	34	adjacent	adjacent	JJ
18637	7517	35	lands	land	NNS
18637	7517	36	,	,	,
18637	7517	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7517	38	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	7517	39	&	&	CC
18637	7517	40	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	7518	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7518	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7518	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7518	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7518	5	Tranbarger	Tranbarger	NNP
18637	7518	6	,	,	,
18637	7518	7	238	238	CD
18637	7518	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7518	9	67	67	CD
18637	7518	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7518	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	7518	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7518	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7518	14	.	.	.
18637	7519	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7519	2	1659	1659	CD
18637	7519	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7519	4	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	7519	5	Beer	Beer	NNP
18637	7519	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7519	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7519	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7519	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7519	10	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	7519	11	,	,	,
18637	7519	12	97	97	CD
18637	7519	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7519	14	25	25	CD
18637	7519	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7519	16	1878	1878	CD
18637	7519	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7519	18	.	.	.
18637	7520	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7520	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7520	3	also	also	RB
18637	7520	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7520	5	Fertilizing	Fertilizing	NNP
18637	7520	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7520	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7520	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7520	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7520	10	Hyde	Hyde	NNP
18637	7520	11	Park	Park	NNP
18637	7520	12	,	,	,
18637	7520	13	97	97	CD
18637	7520	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7520	15	659	659	CD
18637	7520	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7520	17	1878	1878	CD
18637	7520	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7520	19	;	;	:
18637	7520	20	and	and	CC
18637	7520	21	Hammond	Hammond	NNP
18637	7520	22	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	7520	23	_	_	NNP
18637	7520	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	7520	25	_	_	NNP
18637	7520	26	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	7520	27	,	,	,
18637	7520	28	212	212	CD
18637	7520	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7520	30	322	322	CD
18637	7520	31	,	,	,
18637	7520	32	345	345	CD
18637	7520	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7520	34	1909	1909	CD
18637	7520	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7520	36	.	.	.
18637	7521	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7521	2	1660	1660	CD
18637	7521	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7521	4	11	11	CD
18637	7521	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7521	6	.	.	.
18637	7522	1	420	420	CD
18637	7522	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7522	3	1837	1837	CD
18637	7522	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7522	5	.	.	.
18637	7523	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7523	2	1661	1661	CD
18637	7523	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7523	4	11	11	CD
18637	7523	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7523	6	.	.	.
18637	7524	1	at	at	IN
18637	7524	2	548	548	CD
18637	7524	3	-	-	SYM
18637	7524	4	553	553	CD
18637	7524	5	.	.	.
18637	7525	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7525	2	1662	1662	CD
18637	7525	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7525	4	201	201	CD
18637	7525	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7525	6	400	400	CD
18637	7525	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7525	8	1906	1906	CD
18637	7525	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7525	10	.	.	.
18637	7526	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7526	2	1663	1663	CD
18637	7526	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7526	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7526	5	.	.	.
18637	7527	1	471	471	CD
18637	7527	2	-	-	SYM
18637	7527	3	472	472	CD
18637	7527	4	,	,	,
18637	7527	5	citing	cite	VBG
18637	7527	6	The	the	DT
18637	7527	7	Binghamton	Binghamton	NNP
18637	7527	8	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	7527	9	,	,	,
18637	7527	10	3	3	CD
18637	7527	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7527	12	.	.	.
18637	7528	1	51	51	CD
18637	7528	2	,	,	,
18637	7528	3	75	75	CD
18637	7528	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7528	5	1865	1865	CD
18637	7528	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7528	7	.	.	.
18637	7529	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7529	2	1664	1664	CD
18637	7529	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7529	4	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	7529	5	&	&	CC
18637	7529	6	L.R.R.	L.R.R.	NNP
18637	7530	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7530	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7530	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7530	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7530	5	Berry	Berry	NNP
18637	7530	6	,	,	,
18637	7530	7	112	112	CD
18637	7530	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7530	9	609	609	CD
18637	7530	10	,	,	,
18637	7530	11	617	617	CD
18637	7530	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7530	13	1884	1884	CD
18637	7530	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7530	15	.	.	.
18637	7531	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7531	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7531	3	also	also	RB
18637	7531	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7531	5	Picard	Picard	NNP
18637	7531	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7531	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7531	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7531	9	East	East	NNP
18637	7531	10	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	7531	11	,	,	,
18637	7531	12	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7531	13	&	&	CC
18637	7531	14	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	7531	15	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7531	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7531	17	,	,	,
18637	7531	18	130	130	CD
18637	7531	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7531	20	637	637	CD
18637	7531	21	,	,	,
18637	7531	22	641	641	CD
18637	7531	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7531	24	1889	1889	CD
18637	7531	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7531	26	;	;	:
18637	7531	27	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	7531	28	&	&	CC
18637	7531	29	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	7532	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7532	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7532	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7532	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7532	5	Palmes	Palmes	NNP
18637	7532	6	,	,	,
18637	7532	7	109	109	CD
18637	7532	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7532	9	244	244	CD
18637	7532	10	,	,	,
18637	7532	11	251	251	CD
18637	7532	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7532	13	1883	1883	CD
18637	7532	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7532	15	;	;	:
18637	7532	16	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	7532	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7532	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	7532	19	_	_	NNP
18637	7532	20	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7532	21	,	,	,
18637	7532	22	93	93	CD
18637	7532	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7532	24	217	217	CD
18637	7532	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7532	26	1876	1876	CD
18637	7532	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7532	28	;	;	:
18637	7532	29	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	7532	30	_	_	NNP
18637	7532	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	7532	32	_	_	NNP
18637	7532	33	Gaines	Gaines	NNP
18637	7532	34	,	,	,
18637	7532	35	103	103	CD
18637	7532	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7532	37	417	417	CD
18637	7532	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7532	39	1881	1881	CD
18637	7532	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7532	41	;	;	:
18637	7532	42	Norfolk	Norfolk	NNP
18637	7532	43	&	&	CC
18637	7532	44	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	7532	45	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7532	46	_	_	NNP
18637	7532	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	7532	48	_	_	NNP
18637	7532	49	Pendleton	Pendleton	NNP
18637	7532	50	,	,	,
18637	7532	51	156	156	CD
18637	7532	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7532	53	667	667	CD
18637	7532	54	,	,	,
18637	7532	55	673	673	CD
18637	7532	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7532	57	1895	1895	CD
18637	7532	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7532	59	.	.	.
18637	7533	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7533	2	1665	1665	CD
18637	7533	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7533	4	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	7533	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7533	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7533	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7533	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7533	9	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	7533	10	,	,	,
18637	7533	11	98	98	CD
18637	7533	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7533	13	359	359	CD
18637	7533	14	,	,	,
18637	7533	15	365	365	CD
18637	7533	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7533	17	1879	1879	CD
18637	7533	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7533	19	.	.	.
18637	7534	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7534	2	1666	1666	CD
18637	7534	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7534	4	Phoenix	Phoenix	NNP
18637	7534	5	F.	F.	NNP
18637	7534	6	&	&	CC
18637	7534	7	M.	M.	NNP
18637	7534	8	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	7534	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7534	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7534	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	7534	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7534	13	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	7534	14	,	,	,
18637	7534	15	161	161	CD
18637	7534	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7534	17	174	174	CD
18637	7534	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7534	19	1896	1896	CD
18637	7534	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7534	21	.	.	.
18637	7535	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7535	2	1667	1667	CD
18637	7535	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7535	4	Rochester	Rochester	NNP
18637	7535	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7535	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7535	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7535	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7535	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7535	10	Rochester	Rochester	NNP
18637	7535	11	,	,	,
18637	7535	12	205	205	CD
18637	7535	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7535	14	236	236	CD
18637	7535	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7535	16	1907	1907	CD
18637	7535	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7535	18	;	;	:
18637	7535	19	followed	follow	VBN
18637	7535	20	in	in	IN
18637	7535	21	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	7535	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7535	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	7535	24	_	_	NNP
18637	7535	25	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	7535	26	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7535	27	&	&	CC
18637	7535	28	Bkg	Bkg	NNP
18637	7535	29	.	.	.
18637	7536	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7536	2	,	,	,
18637	7536	3	216	216	CD
18637	7536	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7536	5	420	420	CD
18637	7536	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7536	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	7536	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7536	9	;	;	:
18637	7536	10	and	and	CC
18637	7536	11	New	New	NNP
18637	7536	12	York	York	NNP
18637	7536	13	Rapid	Rapid	NNP
18637	7536	14	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	7536	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7536	16	_	_	NNP
18637	7536	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	7536	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7536	19	City	City	NNP
18637	7536	20	of	of	IN
18637	7536	21	New	New	NNP
18637	7536	22	York	York	NNP
18637	7536	23	,	,	,
18637	7536	24	303	303	CD
18637	7536	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7536	26	573	573	CD
18637	7536	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7536	28	1938	1938	CD
18637	7536	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7536	30	.	.	.
18637	7537	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7537	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	7537	3	.	.	.
18637	7537	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7537	5	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	7537	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7537	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7537	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7537	9	Whitworth	Whitworth	NNP
18637	7537	10	,	,	,
18637	7537	11	117	117	CD
18637	7537	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7537	13	139	139	CD
18637	7537	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7537	15	1886	1886	CD
18637	7537	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7537	17	the	the	DT
18637	7537	18	authority	authority	NN
18637	7537	19	of	of	IN
18637	7537	20	which	which	WDT
18637	7537	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	7537	22	respected	respect	VBN
18637	7537	23	in	in	IN
18637	7537	24	the	the	DT
18637	7537	25	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	7537	26	case	case	NN
18637	7537	27	.	.	.
18637	7538	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7538	2	1668	1668	CD
18637	7538	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7538	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	7538	5	,	,	,
18637	7538	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	7539	1	&	&	CC
18637	7539	2	K.C.R.	K.C.R.	NNP
18637	7540	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7540	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7540	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7540	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7540	5	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	7540	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	7540	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	7540	8	.	.	.
18637	7541	1	Guffey	Guffey	NNP
18637	7541	2	,	,	,
18637	7541	3	120	120	CD
18637	7541	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7541	5	569	569	CD
18637	7541	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7541	7	1887	1887	CD
18637	7541	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7541	9	.	.	.
18637	7542	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7542	2	1669	1669	CD
18637	7542	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7542	4	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	7542	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7542	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7542	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7542	8	Delta	Delta	NNP
18637	7542	9	&	&	CC
18637	7542	10	Pine	Pine	NNP
18637	7542	11	Land	Land	NNP
18637	7542	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7542	13	,	,	,
18637	7542	14	164	164	CD
18637	7542	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7542	16	662	662	CD
18637	7542	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7542	18	1897	1897	CD
18637	7542	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7542	20	.	.	.
18637	7543	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7543	2	1670	1670	CD
18637	7543	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7543	4	Vicksburg	Vicksburg	NNP
18637	7543	5	,	,	,
18637	7543	6	S.	S.	NNP
18637	7543	7	&	&	CC
18637	7543	8	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	7544	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7544	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7544	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7544	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7544	5	Dennis	Dennis	NNP
18637	7544	6	,	,	,
18637	7544	7	116	116	CD
18637	7544	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7544	9	665	665	CD
18637	7544	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7544	11	1886	1886	CD
18637	7544	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7544	13	.	.	.
18637	7545	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7545	2	1671	1671	CD
18637	7545	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7545	4	Millsaps	Millsaps	NNP
18637	7545	5	College	College	NNP
18637	7545	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7545	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7545	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7545	9	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	7545	10	,	,	,
18637	7545	11	275	275	CD
18637	7545	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7545	13	129	129	CD
18637	7545	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7545	15	1927	1927	CD
18637	7545	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7545	17	.	.	.
18637	7546	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7546	2	1672	1672	CD
18637	7546	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7546	4	Hale	Hale	NNP
18637	7546	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7546	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7546	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7546	8	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	7546	9	State	State	NNP
18637	7546	10	Board	Board	NNP
18637	7546	11	of	of	IN
18637	7546	12	Assessment	Assessment	NNP
18637	7546	13	,	,	,
18637	7546	14	302	302	CD
18637	7546	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7546	16	95	95	CD
18637	7546	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7546	18	1937	1937	CD
18637	7546	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7546	20	.	.	.
18637	7547	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7547	2	1673	1673	CD
18637	7547	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7547	4	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	7547	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7547	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7547	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7547	8	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	7547	9	'	'	POS
18637	7547	10	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	7547	11	&	&	CC
18637	7547	12	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	7547	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7547	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7547	15	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	7547	16	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	7547	17	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	7547	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7547	19	,	,	,
18637	7547	20	116	116	CD
18637	7547	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7547	22	307	307	CD
18637	7547	23	,	,	,
18637	7547	24	330	330	CD
18637	7547	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7547	26	1886	1886	CD
18637	7547	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7547	28	extended	extend	VBN
18637	7547	29	in	in	IN
18637	7547	30	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	7547	31	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	7547	32	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7547	33	_	_	NNP
18637	7547	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	7547	35	_	_	NNP
18637	7547	36	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
18637	7547	37	,	,	,
18637	7547	38	230	230	CD
18637	7547	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7547	40	537	537	CD
18637	7547	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7547	42	1913	1913	CD
18637	7547	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7547	44	to	to	IN
18637	7547	45	cases	case	NNS
18637	7547	46	in	in	IN
18637	7547	47	which	which	WDT
18637	7547	48	the	the	DT
18637	7547	49	word	word	NN
18637	7547	50	"	"	``
18637	7547	51	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	7547	52	"	"	''
18637	7547	53	does	do	VBZ
18637	7547	54	not	not	RB
18637	7547	55	appear	appear	VB
18637	7547	56	to	to	TO
18637	7547	57	qualify	qualify	VB
18637	7547	58	the	the	DT
18637	7547	59	company	company	NN
18637	7547	60	's	's	POS
18637	7547	61	right	right	NN
18637	7547	62	to	to	TO
18637	7547	63	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	7547	64	tolls	toll	NNS
18637	7547	65	.	.	.
18637	7548	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7548	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7548	3	also	also	RB
18637	7548	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7548	5	American	American	NNP
18637	7548	6	Toll	Toll	NNP
18637	7548	7	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	7548	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7548	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7548	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7548	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7548	12	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	7548	13	Com	Com	NNP
18637	7548	14	.	.	.
18637	7549	1	of	of	IN
18637	7549	2	California	California	NNP
18637	7549	3	et	et	NNP
18637	7549	4	al	al	NNP
18637	7549	5	.	.	NNP
18637	7549	6	,	,	,
18637	7549	7	307	307	CD
18637	7549	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7549	9	486	486	CD
18637	7549	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7549	11	1939	1939	CD
18637	7549	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7549	13	.	.	.
18637	7550	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7550	2	1674	1674	CD
18637	7550	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7550	4	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	7550	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7550	6	&	&	CC
18637	7550	7	Power	Power	NNP
18637	7550	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7550	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7550	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7550	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7550	12	Decatur	Decatur	NNP
18637	7550	13	,	,	,
18637	7550	14	262	262	CD
18637	7550	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7550	16	432	432	CD
18637	7550	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7550	18	1923	1923	CD
18637	7550	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7550	20	.	.	.
18637	7551	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7551	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7551	3	also	also	RB
18637	7551	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7551	5	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	7551	6	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	7551	7	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	7551	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7551	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7551	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7551	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7551	12	Chariton	Chariton	NNP
18637	7551	13	,	,	,
18637	7551	14	255	255	CD
18637	7551	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7551	16	539	539	CD
18637	7551	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7551	18	1921	1921	CD
18637	7551	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7551	20	.	.	.
18637	7552	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7552	2	1675	1675	CD
18637	7552	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7552	4	Walla	Walla	NNP
18637	7552	5	Walla	Walla	NNP
18637	7552	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7552	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7552	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7552	9	Walla	Walla	NNP
18637	7552	10	Walla	Walla	NNP
18637	7552	11	Water	Water	NNP
18637	7552	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7552	13	,	,	,
18637	7552	14	172	172	CD
18637	7552	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7552	16	1	1	CD
18637	7552	17	,	,	,
18637	7552	18	15	15	CD
18637	7552	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7552	20	1898	1898	CD
18637	7552	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7552	22	.	.	.
18637	7553	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7553	2	1676	1676	CD
18637	7553	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7553	4	Skaneateles	Skaneateles	NNP
18637	7553	5	Water	Water	NNP
18637	7553	6	Works	Works	NNP
18637	7553	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7553	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7553	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7553	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7553	11	Skaneateles	Skaneateles	NNP
18637	7553	12	,	,	,
18637	7553	13	184	184	CD
18637	7553	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7553	15	354	354	CD
18637	7553	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7553	17	1902	1902	CD
18637	7553	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7553	19	;	;	:
18637	7553	20	Knoxville	Knoxville	NNP
18637	7553	21	Water	Water	NNP
18637	7553	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7553	23	_	_	NNP
18637	7553	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	7553	25	_	_	NNP
18637	7553	26	Knoxville	Knoxville	NNP
18637	7553	27	,	,	,
18637	7553	28	200	200	CD
18637	7553	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7553	30	22	22	CD
18637	7553	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7553	32	1906	1906	CD
18637	7553	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7553	34	;	;	:
18637	7553	35	Madera	Madera	NNP
18637	7553	36	Water	Water	NNP
18637	7553	37	Works	Works	NNP
18637	7553	38	_	_	NNP
18637	7553	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	7553	40	_	_	NNP
18637	7553	41	Madera	Madera	NNP
18637	7553	42	,	,	,
18637	7553	43	228	228	CD
18637	7553	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7553	45	454	454	CD
18637	7553	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7553	47	1913	1913	CD
18637	7553	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7553	49	.	.	.
18637	7554	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7554	2	1677	1677	CD
18637	7554	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7554	4	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	7554	5	Park	Park	NNP
18637	7554	6	Water	Water	NNP
18637	7554	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7554	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7554	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7554	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7554	11	Fergus	Fergus	NNP
18637	7554	12	,	,	,
18637	7554	13	180	180	CD
18637	7554	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7554	15	624	624	CD
18637	7554	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7554	17	1901	1901	CD
18637	7554	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7554	19	.	.	.
18637	7555	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7555	2	1678	1678	CD
18637	7555	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7555	4	Home	Home	NNP
18637	7555	5	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	7555	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7555	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7555	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7555	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7555	10	Los	Los	NNP
18637	7555	11	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	7555	12	,	,	,
18637	7555	13	211	211	CD
18637	7555	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7555	15	265	265	CD
18637	7555	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7555	17	1908	1908	CD
18637	7555	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7555	19	;	;	:
18637	7555	20	Wyandotte	Wyandotte	NNP
18637	7555	21	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	7555	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7555	23	_	_	NNP
18637	7555	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	7555	25	_	_	NNP
18637	7555	26	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	7555	27	,	,	,
18637	7555	28	231	231	CD
18637	7555	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7555	30	622	622	CD
18637	7555	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7555	32	1914	1914	CD
18637	7555	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7555	34	.	.	.
18637	7556	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7556	2	1679	1679	CD
18637	7556	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7556	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7556	5	See	See	NNP
18637	7556	6	also	also	RB
18637	7556	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7556	8	Puget	Puget	NNP
18637	7556	9	Sound	Sound	NNP
18637	7556	10	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	7556	11	,	,	,
18637	7556	12	Light	Light	NNP
18637	7556	13	&	&	CC
18637	7556	14	P.	P.	NNP
18637	7556	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7556	16	_	_	NNP
18637	7556	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	7556	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7556	19	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	7556	20	,	,	,
18637	7556	21	244	244	CD
18637	7556	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7556	23	574	574	CD
18637	7556	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7556	25	1917	1917	CD
18637	7556	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7556	27	.	.	.
18637	7557	1	"	"	``
18637	7557	2	Before	before	IN
18637	7557	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7557	4	can	can	MD
18637	7557	5	find	find	VB
18637	7557	6	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	7557	7	of	of	IN
18637	7557	8	a	a	DT
18637	7557	9	contract	contract	NN
18637	7557	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7557	11	must	must	MD
18637	7557	12	find	find	VB
18637	7557	13	an	an	DT
18637	7557	14	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	7557	15	of	of	IN
18637	7557	16	the	the	DT
18637	7557	17	contract	contract	NN
18637	7557	18	which	which	WDT
18637	7557	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	7557	20	been	be	VBN
18637	7557	21	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	7557	22	.	.	.
18637	7558	1	Since	since	IN
18637	7558	2	the	the	DT
18637	7558	3	contract	contract	NN
18637	7558	4	here	here	RB
18637	7558	5	relied	rely	VBD
18637	7558	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	7558	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	7558	8	one	one	CD
18637	7558	9	between	between	IN
18637	7558	10	a	a	DT
18637	7558	11	political	political	JJ
18637	7558	12	subdivision	subdivision	NN
18637	7558	13	of	of	IN
18637	7558	14	a	a	DT
18637	7558	15	state	state	NN
18637	7558	16	and	and	CC
18637	7558	17	private	private	JJ
18637	7558	18	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	7558	19	,	,	,
18637	7558	20	settled	settle	VBD
18637	7558	21	principles	principle	NNS
18637	7558	22	of	of	IN
18637	7558	23	construction	construction	NN
18637	7558	24	require	require	VBP
18637	7558	25	that	that	IN
18637	7558	26	the	the	DT
18637	7558	27	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	7558	28	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	7558	29	to	to	TO
18637	7558	30	have	have	VB
18637	7558	31	been	be	VBN
18637	7558	32	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	7558	33	be	be	VB
18637	7558	34	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	7558	35	and	and	CC
18637	7558	36	unequivocally	unequivocally	RB
18637	7558	37	expressed	express	VBN
18637	7558	38	.	.	.
18637	7558	39	"	"	''
18637	7559	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7559	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	7559	3	for	for	IN
18637	7559	4	the	the	DT
18637	7559	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7559	6	in	in	IN
18637	7559	7	Keefe	Keefe	NNP
18637	7559	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7559	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7559	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7559	11	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	7559	12	,	,	,
18637	7559	13	322	322	CD
18637	7559	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7559	15	393	393	CD
18637	7559	16	,	,	,
18637	7559	17	396	396	CD
18637	7559	18	-	-	SYM
18637	7559	19	397	397	CD
18637	7559	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7559	21	1944	1944	CD
18637	7559	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7559	23	.	.	.
18637	7560	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7560	2	1680	1680	CD
18637	7560	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7560	4	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	7560	5	of	of	IN
18637	7560	6	Brick	Brick	NNP
18637	7560	7	Church	Church	NNP
18637	7560	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7560	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7560	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7560	11	Mayor	Mayor	NNP
18637	7560	12	et	et	NNP
18637	7560	13	al	al	NNP
18637	7560	14	.	.	NNP
18637	7560	15	,	,	,
18637	7560	16	5	5	CD
18637	7560	17	Cowen	Cowen	NNP
18637	7560	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7560	19	N.Y.	New York	NNP
18637	7560	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7560	21	538	538	CD
18637	7560	22	,	,	,
18637	7560	23	540	540	CD
18637	7560	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7560	25	1826	1826	CD
18637	7560	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7560	27	.	.	.
18637	7561	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7561	2	1681	1681	CD
18637	7561	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7561	4	West	West	NNP
18637	7561	5	River	River	NNP
18637	7561	6	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	7561	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7561	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7561	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7561	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7561	11	Dix	Dix	NNP
18637	7561	12	,	,	,
18637	7561	13	6	6	CD
18637	7561	14	How	how	WRB
18637	7561	15	.	.	.
18637	7562	1	507	507	CD
18637	7562	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7562	3	1848	1848	CD
18637	7562	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7562	5	.	.	.
18637	7563	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7563	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7563	3	also	also	RB
18637	7563	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7563	5	Backus	Backus	NNP
18637	7563	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7563	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7563	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7563	9	Lebanon	Lebanon	NNP
18637	7563	10	,	,	,
18637	7563	11	11	11	CD
18637	7563	12	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	7563	13	19	19	CD
18637	7563	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7563	15	1840	1840	CD
18637	7563	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7563	17	;	;	:
18637	7563	18	White	White	NNP
18637	7563	19	River	River	NNP
18637	7563	20	Turnpike	Turnpike	NNP
18637	7563	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7563	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7563	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	7563	24	_	_	NNP
18637	7563	25	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	7563	26	Cent	Cent	NNP
18637	7563	27	.	.	.
18637	7564	1	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7564	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7564	3	,	,	,
18637	7564	4	21	21	CD
18637	7564	5	Vt	Vt	NNP
18637	7564	6	.	.	NNP
18637	7564	7	590	590	CD
18637	7564	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7564	9	1849	1849	CD
18637	7564	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7564	11	;	;	:
18637	7564	12	and	and	CC
18637	7564	13	Bonaparte	Bonaparte	NNP
18637	7564	14	_	_	NNP
18637	7564	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	7564	16	_	_	NNP
18637	7564	17	Camden	Camden	NNP
18637	7564	18	&	&	CC
18637	7564	19	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	7565	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7565	2	,	,	,
18637	7565	3	3	3	CD
18637	7565	4	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	7565	5	.	.	.
18637	7566	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	7566	2	.	.	.
18637	7567	1	No	no	UH
18637	7567	2	.	.	.
18637	7568	1	1,617	1,617	CD
18637	7568	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7568	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	7568	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7568	5	;	;	,
18637	7568	6	cited	cite	VBN
18637	7568	7	in	in	IN
18637	7568	8	Calvert	Calvert	NNP
18637	7568	9	I	I	NNP
18637	7568	10	,	,	,
18637	7568	11	960	960	CD
18637	7568	12	-	-	SYM
18637	7568	13	961	961	CD
18637	7568	14	.	.	.
18637	7569	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7569	2	1682	1682	CD
18637	7569	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7569	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7569	5	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	7569	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7569	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7569	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7569	9	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	7569	10	,	,	,
18637	7569	11	245	245	CD
18637	7569	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7569	13	20	20	CD
18637	7569	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7569	15	1917	1917	CD
18637	7569	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7569	17	.	.	.
18637	7570	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7570	2	1683	1683	CD
18637	7570	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7570	4	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	7570	5	Central	Central	NNP
18637	7570	6	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	7570	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7570	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7570	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7570	10	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	7570	11	,	,	,
18637	7570	12	146	146	CD
18637	7570	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7570	14	387	387	CD
18637	7570	15	,	,	,
18637	7570	16	453	453	CD
18637	7570	17	,	,	,
18637	7570	18	455	455	CD
18637	7570	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7570	20	1892	1892	CD
18637	7570	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7570	22	.	.	.
18637	7571	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7571	2	1684	1684	CD
18637	7571	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7571	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7571	5	See	See	NNP
18637	7571	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7571	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	7571	8	.	.	.
18637	7572	1	335	335	CD
18637	7572	2	-	-	SYM
18637	7572	3	336	336	CD
18637	7572	4	.	.	.
18637	7573	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7573	2	1685	1685	CD
18637	7573	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7573	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7573	5	See	See	NNP
18637	7573	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7573	7	especially	especially	RB
18637	7573	8	Home	home	NN
18637	7573	9	of	of	IN
18637	7573	10	the	the	DT
18637	7573	11	Friendless	Friendless	NNP
18637	7573	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7573	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	7573	14	_	_	NNP
18637	7573	15	Rouse	Rouse	NNP
18637	7573	16	,	,	,
18637	7573	17	8	8	CD
18637	7573	18	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7573	19	.	.	.
18637	7574	1	430	430	CD
18637	7574	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7574	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	7574	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7574	5	,	,	,
18637	7574	6	and	and	CC
18637	7574	7	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	7574	8	University	University	NNP
18637	7574	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7574	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7574	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7574	12	Rouse	Rouse	NNP
18637	7574	13	,	,	,
18637	7574	14	8	8	CD
18637	7574	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7574	16	.	.	.
18637	7575	1	439	439	CD
18637	7575	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7575	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	7575	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7575	5	.	.	.
18637	7576	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7576	2	1686	1686	CD
18637	7576	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7576	4	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	7576	5	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	7576	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7576	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7576	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7576	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7576	10	Redwine	Redwine	NNP
18637	7576	11	,	,	,
18637	7576	12	342	342	CD
18637	7576	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7576	14	299	299	CD
18637	7576	15	,	,	,
18637	7576	16	305	305	CD
18637	7576	17	-	-	SYM
18637	7576	18	06	06	CD
18637	7576	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7576	20	1952	1952	CD
18637	7576	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7576	22	.	.	.
18637	7577	1	The	the	DT
18637	7577	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7577	3	distinguishes	distinguish	VBZ
18637	7577	4	In	in	IN
18637	7577	5	re	re	NN
18637	7577	6	Ayers	Ayers	NNP
18637	7577	7	,	,	,
18637	7577	8	123	123	CD
18637	7577	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7577	10	443	443	CD
18637	7577	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7577	12	1887	1887	CD
18637	7577	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7577	14	on	on	IN
18637	7577	15	the	the	DT
18637	7577	16	ground	ground	NN
18637	7577	17	that	that	IN
18637	7577	18	the	the	DT
18637	7577	19	action	action	NN
18637	7577	20	there	there	EX
18637	7577	21	was	be	VBD
18637	7577	22	barred	bar	VBN
18637	7577	23	"	"	''
18637	7577	24	as	as	IN
18637	7577	25	one	one	CD
18637	7577	26	in	in	IN
18637	7577	27	substance	substance	NN
18637	7577	28	directed	direct	VBN
18637	7577	29	against	against	IN
18637	7577	30	the	the	DT
18637	7577	31	State	State	NNP
18637	7577	32	to	to	TO
18637	7577	33	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	7577	34	specific	specific	JJ
18637	7577	35	performance	performance	NN
18637	7577	36	of	of	IN
18637	7577	37	a	a	DT
18637	7577	38	contract	contract	NN
18637	7577	39	with	with	IN
18637	7577	40	the	the	DT
18637	7577	41	State	State	NNP
18637	7577	42	"	"	''
18637	7577	43	.	.	.
18637	7578	1	342	342	CD
18637	7578	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7578	3	305	305	CD
18637	7578	4	.	.	.
18637	7579	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7579	2	1687	1687	CD
18637	7579	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7579	4	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	7579	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7579	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7579	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7579	8	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	7579	9	,	,	,
18637	7579	10	101	101	CD
18637	7579	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7579	12	814	814	CD
18637	7579	13	,	,	,
18637	7579	14	820	820	CD
18637	7579	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7579	16	1880	1880	CD
18637	7579	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7579	18	.	.	.
18637	7580	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7580	2	1688	1688	CD
18637	7580	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7580	4	Butcher	Butcher	NNP
18637	7580	5	's	's	POS
18637	7580	6	Union	Union	NNP
18637	7580	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7580	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7580	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7580	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7580	11	Crescent	Crescent	NNP
18637	7580	12	City	City	NNP
18637	7580	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7580	14	,	,	,
18637	7580	15	111	111	CD
18637	7580	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7580	17	746	746	CD
18637	7580	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7580	19	1884	1884	CD
18637	7580	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7580	21	.	.	.
18637	7581	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7581	2	1689	1689	CD
18637	7581	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7581	4	New	New	NNP
18637	7581	5	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7581	6	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	7581	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7581	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7581	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7581	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7581	11	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7581	12	Light	Light	NNP
18637	7581	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7581	14	,	,	,
18637	7581	15	115	115	CD
18637	7581	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7581	17	630	630	CD
18637	7581	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7581	19	1885	1885	CD
18637	7581	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7581	21	.	.	.
18637	7582	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7582	2	1690	1690	CD
18637	7582	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7582	4	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	7582	5	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	7582	6	Line	Line	NNP
18637	7582	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7582	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7582	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7582	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7582	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7582	12	Goldsboro	Goldsboro	NNP
18637	7582	13	,	,	,
18637	7582	14	232	232	CD
18637	7582	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7582	16	548	548	CD
18637	7582	17	,	,	,
18637	7582	18	558	558	CD
18637	7582	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7582	20	1914	1914	CD
18637	7582	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7582	22	.	.	.
18637	7583	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7583	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7583	3	also	also	RB
18637	7583	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7583	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	7583	6	&	&	CC
18637	7583	7	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	7584	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7584	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7584	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7584	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7584	5	Tranbarger	Tranbarger	NNP
18637	7584	6	,	,	,
18637	7584	7	238	238	CD
18637	7584	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7584	9	67	67	CD
18637	7584	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7584	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	7584	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7584	13	;	;	:
18637	7584	14	_	_	NNP
18637	7584	15	also	also	RB
18637	7584	16	_	_	NNP
18637	7584	17	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7584	18	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	7584	19	_	_	NNP
18637	7584	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	7584	21	_	_	NNP
18637	7584	22	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	7584	23	,	,	,
18637	7584	24	245	245	CD
18637	7584	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7584	26	20	20	CD
18637	7584	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7584	28	1917	1917	CD
18637	7584	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7584	30	,	,	,
18637	7584	31	where	where	WRB
18637	7584	32	the	the	DT
18637	7584	33	police	police	NN
18637	7584	34	power	power	NN
18637	7584	35	and	and	CC
18637	7584	36	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	7584	37	domain	domain	NN
18637	7584	38	are	be	VBP
18637	7584	39	treated	treat	VBN
18637	7584	40	on	on	IN
18637	7584	41	the	the	DT
18637	7584	42	same	same	JJ
18637	7584	43	basis	basis	NN
18637	7584	44	in	in	IN
18637	7584	45	respect	respect	NN
18637	7584	46	of	of	IN
18637	7584	47	inalienability	inalienability	NN
18637	7584	48	;	;	:
18637	7584	49	also	also	RB
18637	7584	50	Wabash	Wabash	NNP
18637	7584	51	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7584	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7584	53	_	_	NNP
18637	7584	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	7584	55	_	_	NNP
18637	7584	56	Defiance	Defiance	NNP
18637	7584	57	,	,	,
18637	7584	58	167	167	CD
18637	7584	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7584	60	88	88	CD
18637	7584	61	,	,	,
18637	7584	62	97	97	CD
18637	7584	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7584	64	1897	1897	CD
18637	7584	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7584	66	;	;	:
18637	7584	67	Home	Home	NNP
18637	7584	68	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	7584	69	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7584	70	_	_	NNP
18637	7584	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	7584	72	_	_	NNP
18637	7584	73	Los	Los	NNP
18637	7584	74	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	7584	75	,	,	,
18637	7584	76	211	211	CD
18637	7584	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7584	78	265	265	CD
18637	7584	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7584	80	1908	1908	CD
18637	7584	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7584	82	;	;	:
18637	7584	83	and	and	CC
18637	7584	84	Calvert	Calvert	NNP
18637	7584	85	I	I	NNP
18637	7584	86	,	,	,
18637	7584	87	962	962	CD
18637	7584	88	.	.	.
18637	7585	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7585	2	1691	1691	CD
18637	7585	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7585	4	Morley	Morley	NNP
18637	7585	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7585	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7585	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7585	8	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	7585	9	Shore	Shore	NNP
18637	7585	10	&	&	CC
18637	7585	11	M.S.R.	M.S.R.	NNP
18637	7586	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7586	2	,	,	,
18637	7586	3	146	146	CD
18637	7586	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7586	5	162	162	CD
18637	7586	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7586	7	1892	1892	CD
18637	7586	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7586	9	;	;	:
18637	7586	10	New	New	NNP
18637	7586	11	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7586	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7586	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	7586	14	_	_	NNP
18637	7586	15	New	New	NNP
18637	7586	16	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7586	17	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	7586	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7586	19	,	,	,
18637	7586	20	142	142	CD
18637	7586	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7586	22	79	79	CD
18637	7586	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7586	24	1891	1891	CD
18637	7586	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7586	26	;	;	:
18637	7586	27	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	7586	28	&	&	CC
18637	7586	29	A.	A.	NNP
18637	7587	1	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	7587	2	&	&	CC
18637	7587	3	Min	Min	NNP
18637	7587	4	.	.	.
18637	7588	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7588	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7588	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7588	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7588	5	Greenwood	Greenwood	NNP
18637	7588	6	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	7588	7	,	,	,
18637	7588	8	249	249	CD
18637	7588	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7588	10	170	170	CD
18637	7588	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7588	12	1919	1919	CD
18637	7588	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7588	14	.	.	.
18637	7589	1	But	but	CC
18637	7589	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7589	3	cf	cf	NNP
18637	7589	4	.	.	.
18637	7589	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7589	6	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
18637	7589	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7589	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7589	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7589	10	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	7589	11	,	,	,
18637	7589	12	7	7	CD
18637	7589	13	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	7589	14	.	.	.
18637	7590	1	469	469	CD
18637	7590	2	,	,	,
18637	7590	3	549	549	CD
18637	7590	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7590	5	1833	1833	CD
18637	7590	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7590	7	;	;	:
18637	7590	8	and	and	CC
18637	7590	9	Garrison	Garrison	NNP
18637	7590	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7590	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	7590	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7590	13	New	New	NNP
18637	7590	14	York	York	NNP
18637	7590	15	,	,	,
18637	7590	16	21	21	CD
18637	7590	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7590	18	.	.	.
18637	7591	1	196	196	CD
18637	7591	2	,	,	,
18637	7591	3	203	203	CD
18637	7591	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7591	5	1875	1875	CD
18637	7591	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7591	7	,	,	,
18637	7591	8	suggesting	suggest	VBG
18637	7591	9	that	that	IN
18637	7591	10	a	a	DT
18637	7591	11	different	different	JJ
18637	7591	12	view	view	NN
18637	7591	13	was	be	VBD
18637	7591	14	earlier	early	RBR
18637	7591	15	entertained	entertain	VBN
18637	7591	16	in	in	IN
18637	7591	17	the	the	DT
18637	7591	18	case	case	NN
18637	7591	19	of	of	IN
18637	7591	20	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	7591	21	in	in	IN
18637	7591	22	actions	action	NNS
18637	7591	23	of	of	IN
18637	7591	24	debt	debt	NN
18637	7591	25	.	.	.
18637	7592	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7592	2	1692	1692	CD
18637	7592	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7592	4	Maynard	Maynard	NNP
18637	7592	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7592	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7592	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7592	8	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	7592	9	,	,	,
18637	7592	10	125	125	CD
18637	7592	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7592	12	190	190	CD
18637	7592	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7592	14	1888	1888	CD
18637	7592	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7592	16	;	;	:
18637	7592	17	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	7592	18	College	College	NNP
18637	7592	19	_	_	NNP
18637	7592	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	7592	21	_	_	NNP
18637	7592	22	Woodward	Woodward	NNP
18637	7592	23	,	,	,
18637	7592	24	4	4	CD
18637	7592	25	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7592	26	.	.	.
18637	7593	1	518	518	CD
18637	7593	2	,	,	,
18637	7593	3	629	629	CD
18637	7593	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7593	5	1819	1819	CD
18637	7593	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7593	7	.	.	.
18637	7594	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7594	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	7594	3	.	.	.
18637	7594	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7594	5	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
18637	7594	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7594	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7594	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7594	9	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
18637	7594	10	,	,	,
18637	7594	11	188	188	CD
18637	7594	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7594	13	14	14	CD
18637	7594	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7594	15	1903	1903	CD
18637	7594	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7594	17	.	.	.
18637	7595	1	The	the	DT
18637	7595	2	question	question	NN
18637	7595	3	whether	whether	IN
18637	7595	4	a	a	DT
18637	7595	5	wife	wife	NN
18637	7595	6	's	's	POS
18637	7595	7	rights	right	NNS
18637	7595	8	in	in	IN
18637	7595	9	the	the	DT
18637	7595	10	community	community	NN
18637	7595	11	property	property	NN
18637	7595	12	under	under	IN
18637	7595	13	the	the	DT
18637	7595	14	laws	law	NNS
18637	7595	15	of	of	IN
18637	7595	16	California	California	NNP
18637	7595	17	were	be	VBD
18637	7595	18	of	of	IN
18637	7595	19	a	a	DT
18637	7595	20	contractual	contractual	JJ
18637	7595	21	nature	nature	NN
18637	7595	22	was	be	VBD
18637	7595	23	raised	raise	VBN
18637	7595	24	but	but	CC
18637	7595	25	not	not	RB
18637	7595	26	determined	determine	VBN
18637	7595	27	in	in	IN
18637	7595	28	Moffitt	Moffitt	NNP
18637	7595	29	_	_	NNP
18637	7595	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	7595	31	_	_	NNP
18637	7595	32	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
18637	7595	33	,	,	,
18637	7595	34	218	218	CD
18637	7595	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7595	36	400	400	CD
18637	7595	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7595	38	1910	1910	CD
18637	7595	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7595	40	.	.	.
18637	7596	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7596	2	1693	1693	CD
18637	7596	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7596	4	New	New	NNP
18637	7596	5	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7596	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7596	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7596	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7596	9	New	New	NNP
18637	7596	10	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7596	11	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	7596	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7596	13	,	,	,
18637	7596	14	142	142	CD
18637	7596	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7596	16	79	79	CD
18637	7596	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7596	18	1891	1891	CD
18637	7596	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7596	20	;	;	:
18637	7596	21	Zane	Zane	NNP
18637	7596	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7596	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	7596	24	_	_	NNP
18637	7596	25	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	7596	26	County	County	NNP
18637	7596	27	,	,	,
18637	7596	28	189	189	CD
18637	7596	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7596	30	370	370	CD
18637	7596	31	,	,	,
18637	7596	32	381	381	CD
18637	7596	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7596	34	1903	1903	CD
18637	7596	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7596	36	.	.	.
18637	7597	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7597	2	1694	1694	CD
18637	7597	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7597	4	4	4	CD
18637	7597	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7597	6	.	.	.
18637	7598	1	122	122	CD
18637	7598	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7598	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	7598	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7598	5	.	.	.
18637	7599	1	For	for	IN
18637	7599	2	the	the	DT
18637	7599	3	first	first	JJ
18637	7599	4	such	such	JJ
18637	7599	5	case	case	NN
18637	7599	6	in	in	IN
18637	7599	7	a	a	DT
18637	7599	8	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	7599	9	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
18637	7599	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7599	11	,	,	,
18637	7599	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7599	13	see	see	VBP
18637	7599	14	_	_	NNP
18637	7599	15	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	7599	16	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	7599	17	,	,	,
18637	7599	18	The	the	DT
18637	7599	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	7599	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7599	21	in	in	IN
18637	7599	22	United	United	NNP
18637	7599	23	States	States	NNP
18637	7599	24	History	History	NNP
18637	7599	25	,	,	,
18637	7599	26	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7599	27	,	,	,
18637	7599	28	67	67	CD
18637	7599	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7599	30	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	7599	31	,	,	,
18637	7599	32	1922	1922	CD
18637	7599	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7599	34	.	.	.
18637	7600	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7600	2	1695	1695	CD
18637	7600	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7600	4	12	12	CD
18637	7600	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7600	6	.	.	.
18637	7601	1	213	213	CD
18637	7601	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7601	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	7601	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7601	5	.	.	.
18637	7602	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7602	2	1696	1696	CD
18637	7602	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7602	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7602	5	.	.	.
18637	7603	1	353	353	CD
18637	7603	2	-	-	SYM
18637	7603	3	354	354	CD
18637	7603	4	.	.	.
18637	7604	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7604	2	1697	1697	CD
18637	7604	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7604	4	Von	Von	NNP
18637	7604	5	Hoffman	Hoffman	NNP
18637	7604	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7604	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7604	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7604	9	Quincy	Quincy	NNP
18637	7604	10	,	,	,
18637	7604	11	4	4	CD
18637	7604	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7604	13	.	.	.
18637	7605	1	535	535	CD
18637	7605	2	,	,	,
18637	7605	3	552	552	CD
18637	7605	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7605	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	7605	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7605	7	.	.	.
18637	7606	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7606	2	1698	1698	CD
18637	7606	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7606	4	1	1	CD
18637	7606	5	How	how	WRB
18637	7606	6	.	.	.
18637	7607	1	311	311	CD
18637	7607	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7607	3	1843	1843	CD
18637	7607	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7607	5	.	.	.
18637	7608	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7608	2	1699	1699	CD
18637	7608	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7608	4	2	2	CD
18637	7608	5	How	how	WRB
18637	7608	6	.	.	.
18637	7609	1	608	608	CD
18637	7609	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7609	3	1844	1844	CD
18637	7609	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7609	5	.	.	.
18637	7610	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7610	2	1700	1700	CD
18637	7610	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7610	4	Oshkosh	Oshkosh	NNP
18637	7610	5	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	7610	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7610	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7610	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7610	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7610	10	Oshkosh	Oshkosh	NNP
18637	7610	11	,	,	,
18637	7610	12	187	187	CD
18637	7610	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7610	14	437	437	CD
18637	7610	15	,	,	,
18637	7610	16	439	439	CD
18637	7610	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7610	18	1903	1903	CD
18637	7610	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7610	20	;	;	:
18637	7610	21	New	New	NNP
18637	7610	22	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7610	23	&	&	CC
18637	7610	24	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	7611	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7611	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7611	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7611	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7611	5	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7611	6	,	,	,
18637	7611	7	157	157	CD
18637	7611	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7611	9	219	219	CD
18637	7611	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7611	11	1895	1895	CD
18637	7611	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7611	13	.	.	.
18637	7612	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7612	2	1701	1701	CD
18637	7612	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7612	4	Antoni	Antoni	NNP
18637	7612	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7612	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7612	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7612	8	Greenhow	Greenhow	NNP
18637	7612	9	,	,	,
18637	7612	10	107	107	CD
18637	7612	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7612	12	769	769	CD
18637	7612	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7612	14	1883	1883	CD
18637	7612	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7612	16	.	.	.
18637	7613	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7613	2	1702	1702	CD
18637	7613	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7613	4	The	the	DT
18637	7613	5	right	right	NN
18637	7613	6	was	be	VBD
18637	7613	7	unheld	unheld	JJ
18637	7613	8	in	in	IN
18637	7613	9	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	7613	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7613	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	7613	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7613	13	Haile	Haile	NNP
18637	7613	14	,	,	,
18637	7613	15	12	12	CD
18637	7613	16	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7613	17	.	.	.
18637	7614	1	370	370	CD
18637	7614	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7614	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	7614	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7614	5	;	;	:
18637	7614	6	and	and	CC
18637	7614	7	again	again	RB
18637	7614	8	in	in	IN
18637	7614	9	Vial	Vial	NNP
18637	7614	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7614	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	7614	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7614	13	Penniman	Penniman	NNP
18637	7614	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7614	15	Penniman	Penniman	NNP
18637	7614	16	's	's	POS
18637	7614	17	Case	Case	NNP
18637	7614	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7614	19	,	,	,
18637	7614	20	103	103	CD
18637	7614	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7614	22	714	714	CD
18637	7614	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7614	24	1881	1881	CD
18637	7614	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7614	26	.	.	.
18637	7615	1	On	on	IN
18637	7615	2	early	early	JJ
18637	7615	3	English	English	NNP
18637	7615	4	and	and	CC
18637	7615	5	Colonial	colonial	JJ
18637	7615	6	law	law	NN
18637	7615	7	touching	touch	VBG
18637	7615	8	the	the	DT
18637	7615	9	subject	subject	NN
18637	7615	10	,	,	,
18637	7615	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7615	12	see	see	VBP
18637	7615	13	_	_	NNP
18637	7615	14	argument	argument	NN
18637	7615	15	of	of	IN
18637	7615	16	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	7615	17	in	in	IN
18637	7615	18	Sturges	Sturges	NNP
18637	7615	19	_	_	NNP
18637	7615	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	7615	21	_	_	NNP
18637	7615	22	Crowninshield	Crowninshield	NNP
18637	7615	23	,	,	,
18637	7615	24	4	4	CD
18637	7615	25	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7615	26	.	.	.
18637	7616	1	122	122	CD
18637	7616	2	,	,	,
18637	7616	3	140	140	CD
18637	7616	4	-	-	SYM
18637	7616	5	145	145	CD
18637	7616	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7616	7	1819	1819	CD
18637	7616	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7616	9	.	.	.
18637	7617	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7617	2	1703	1703	CD
18637	7617	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7617	4	McGahey	McGahey	NNP
18637	7617	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7617	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7617	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7617	8	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7617	9	,	,	,
18637	7617	10	135	135	CD
18637	7617	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7617	12	662	662	CD
18637	7617	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7617	14	1890	1890	CD
18637	7617	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7617	16	.	.	.
18637	7618	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7618	2	1704	1704	CD
18637	7618	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7618	4	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7618	5	ex	ex	NNP
18637	7618	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	7618	7	.	.	.
18637	7619	1	Ranger	Ranger	NNP
18637	7619	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7619	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7619	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7619	5	New	New	NNP
18637	7619	6	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7619	7	,	,	,
18637	7619	8	102	102	CD
18637	7619	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7619	10	203	203	CD
18637	7619	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7619	12	1880	1880	CD
18637	7619	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7619	14	.	.	.
18637	7620	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7620	2	1705	1705	CD
18637	7620	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7620	4	Von	Von	NNP
18637	7620	5	Hoffman	Hoffman	NNP
18637	7620	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7620	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7620	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7620	9	Quincy	Quincy	NNP
18637	7620	10	,	,	,
18637	7620	11	4	4	CD
18637	7620	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7620	13	.	.	.
18637	7621	1	535	535	CD
18637	7621	2	,	,	,
18637	7621	3	554	554	CD
18637	7621	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7621	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	7621	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7621	7	.	.	.
18637	7622	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7622	2	1706	1706	CD
18637	7622	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7622	4	Antoni	Antoni	NNP
18637	7622	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7622	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7622	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7622	8	Greenhow	Greenhow	NNP
18637	7622	9	,	,	,
18637	7622	10	107	107	CD
18637	7622	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7622	12	769	769	CD
18637	7622	13	,	,	,
18637	7622	14	775.--Illustrations	775.--illustrations	CD
18637	7622	15	of	of	IN
18637	7622	16	changes	change	NNS
18637	7622	17	in	in	IN
18637	7622	18	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	7622	19	,	,	,
18637	7622	20	which	which	WDT
18637	7622	21	have	have	VBP
18637	7622	22	been	be	VBN
18637	7622	23	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	7622	24	,	,	,
18637	7622	25	may	may	MD
18637	7622	26	be	be	VB
18637	7622	27	seen	see	VBN
18637	7622	28	in	in	IN
18637	7622	29	the	the	DT
18637	7622	30	following	follow	VBG
18637	7622	31	cases	case	NNS
18637	7622	32	:	:	:
18637	7622	33	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	7622	34	ex	ex	NNP
18637	7622	35	dem	dem	NNP
18637	7622	36	.	.	.
18637	7623	1	Hart	Hart	NNP
18637	7623	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7623	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7623	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7623	5	Lamphire	Lamphire	NNP
18637	7623	6	,	,	,
18637	7623	7	3	3	CD
18637	7623	8	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	7623	9	.	.	.
18637	7624	1	280	280	CD
18637	7624	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7624	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	7624	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7624	5	;	;	:
18637	7624	6	Hawkins	Hawkins	NNP
18637	7624	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7624	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7624	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7624	10	Barney	Barney	NNP
18637	7624	11	,	,	,
18637	7624	12	5	5	CD
18637	7624	13	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7624	14	.	.	.
18637	7625	1	457	457	CD
18637	7625	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7625	3	1831	1831	CD
18637	7625	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7625	5	;	;	:
18637	7625	6	Crawford	Crawford	NNP
18637	7625	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7625	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7625	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7625	10	Branch	Branch	NNP
18637	7625	11	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7625	12	of	of	IN
18637	7625	13	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	7625	14	,	,	,
18637	7625	15	7	7	CD
18637	7625	16	How	how	WRB
18637	7625	17	.	.	.
18637	7626	1	279	279	CD
18637	7626	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7626	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	7626	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7626	5	;	;	:
18637	7626	6	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	7626	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7626	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7626	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7626	10	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	7626	11	,	,	,
18637	7626	12	13	13	CD
18637	7626	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7626	14	.	.	.
18637	7627	1	68	68	CD
18637	7627	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7627	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	7627	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7627	5	;	;	:
18637	7627	6	Cairo	Cairo	NNP
18637	7627	7	&	&	CC
18637	7627	8	F.R.	F.R.	NNP
18637	7628	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7628	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7628	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7628	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7628	5	Hecht	Hecht	NNP
18637	7628	6	,	,	,
18637	7628	7	95	95	CD
18637	7628	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7628	9	168	168	CD
18637	7628	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7628	11	1877	1877	CD
18637	7628	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7628	13	;	;	:
18637	7628	14	Terry	Terry	NNP
18637	7628	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7628	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	7628	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7628	18	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	7628	19	,	,	,
18637	7628	20	95	95	CD
18637	7628	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7628	22	628	628	CD
18637	7628	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7628	24	1877	1877	CD
18637	7628	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7628	26	;	;	:
18637	7628	27	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	7628	28	_	_	NNP
18637	7628	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	7628	30	_	_	NNP
18637	7628	31	Sneed	Sneed	NNP
18637	7628	32	,	,	,
18637	7628	33	96	96	CD
18637	7628	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7628	35	69	69	CD
18637	7628	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7628	37	1877	1877	CD
18637	7628	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7628	39	;	;	:
18637	7628	40	South	South	NNP
18637	7628	41	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	7628	42	_	_	NNP
18637	7628	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	7628	44	_	_	NNP
18637	7628	45	Gaillard	Gaillard	NNP
18637	7628	46	,	,	,
18637	7628	47	101	101	CD
18637	7628	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7628	49	433	433	CD
18637	7628	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7628	51	1880	1880	CD
18637	7628	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7628	53	;	;	:
18637	7628	54	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7628	55	_	_	NNP
18637	7628	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	7628	57	_	_	NNP
18637	7628	58	New	New	NNP
18637	7628	59	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7628	60	,	,	,
18637	7628	61	102	102	CD
18637	7628	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7628	63	203	203	CD
18637	7628	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7628	65	1880	1880	CD
18637	7628	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7628	67	;	;	:
18637	7628	68	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	7628	69	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	7628	70	.	.	.
18637	7629	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	7629	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	7629	3	.	.	.
18637	7630	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7630	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7630	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7630	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7630	5	Cushman	Cushman	NNP
18637	7630	6	,	,	,
18637	7630	7	108	108	CD
18637	7630	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7630	9	51	51	CD
18637	7630	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7630	11	1883	1883	CD
18637	7630	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7630	13	;	;	:
18637	7630	14	Vance	Vance	NNP
18637	7630	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7630	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	7630	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7630	18	Vance	Vance	NNP
18637	7630	19	,	,	,
18637	7630	20	108	108	CD
18637	7630	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7630	22	514	514	CD
18637	7630	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7630	24	1883	1883	CD
18637	7630	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7630	26	;	;	:
18637	7630	27	Gilfillan	Gilfillan	NNP
18637	7630	28	_	_	NNP
18637	7630	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	7630	30	_	_	NNP
18637	7630	31	Union	Union	NNP
18637	7630	32	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	7630	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7630	34	,	,	,
18637	7630	35	109	109	CD
18637	7630	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7630	37	401	401	CD
18637	7630	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7630	39	1883	1883	CD
18637	7630	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7630	41	;	;	:
18637	7630	42	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	7630	43	_	_	NNP
18637	7630	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	7630	45	_	_	NNP
18637	7630	46	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	7630	47	'	'	POS
18637	7630	48	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	7630	49	.	.	.
18637	7631	1	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	7631	2	.	.	.
18637	7632	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7632	2	,	,	,
18637	7632	3	134	134	CD
18637	7632	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7632	5	515	515	CD
18637	7632	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7632	7	1890	1890	CD
18637	7632	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7632	9	;	;	:
18637	7632	10	New	New	NNP
18637	7632	11	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7632	12	City	City	NNP
18637	7632	13	&	&	CC
18637	7632	14	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	7632	15	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7632	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7632	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7632	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	7632	19	_	_	NNP
18637	7632	20	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7632	21	,	,	,
18637	7632	22	157	157	CD
18637	7632	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7632	24	219	219	CD
18637	7632	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7632	26	1895	1895	CD
18637	7632	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7632	28	;	;	:
18637	7632	29	Red	Red	NNP
18637	7632	30	River	River	NNP
18637	7632	31	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	7632	32	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	7632	33	.	.	.
18637	7633	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7633	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7633	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7633	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7633	5	Craig	Craig	NNP
18637	7633	6	,	,	,
18637	7633	7	181	181	CD
18637	7633	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7633	9	548	548	CD
18637	7633	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7633	11	1901	1901	CD
18637	7633	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7633	13	;	;	:
18637	7633	14	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	7633	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7633	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	7633	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7633	18	Standefer	Standefer	NNP
18637	7633	19	,	,	,
18637	7633	20	184	184	CD
18637	7633	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7633	22	399	399	CD
18637	7633	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7633	24	1902	1902	CD
18637	7633	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7633	26	;	;	:
18637	7633	27	Oshkosh	Oshkosh	NNP
18637	7633	28	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	7633	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7633	30	_	_	NNP
18637	7633	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	7633	32	_	_	NNP
18637	7633	33	Oshkosh	Oshkosh	NNP
18637	7633	34	,	,	,
18637	7633	35	187	187	CD
18637	7633	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7633	37	437	437	CD
18637	7633	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7633	39	1903	1903	CD
18637	7633	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7633	41	;	;	:
18637	7633	42	Waggoner	Waggoner	NNP
18637	7633	43	_	_	NNP
18637	7633	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	7633	45	_	_	NNP
18637	7633	46	Flack	Flack	NNP
18637	7633	47	,	,	,
18637	7633	48	188	188	CD
18637	7633	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7633	50	595	595	CD
18637	7633	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7633	52	1903	1903	CD
18637	7633	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7633	54	;	;	:
18637	7633	55	Bernheimer	Bernheimer	NNP
18637	7633	56	_	_	NNP
18637	7633	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	7633	58	_	_	NNP
18637	7633	59	Converse	Converse	NNP
18637	7633	60	,	,	,
18637	7633	61	206	206	CD
18637	7633	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7633	63	516	516	CD
18637	7633	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7633	65	1907	1907	CD
18637	7633	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7633	67	;	;	:
18637	7633	68	Henley	Henley	NNP
18637	7633	69	_	_	NNP
18637	7633	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	7633	71	_	_	NNP
18637	7633	72	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	7633	73	,	,	,
18637	7633	74	215	215	CD
18637	7633	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7633	76	373	373	CD
18637	7633	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7633	78	1910	1910	CD
18637	7633	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7633	80	;	;	:
18637	7633	81	Selig	Selig	NNP
18637	7633	82	_	_	NNP
18637	7633	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	7633	84	_	_	NNP
18637	7633	85	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	7633	86	,	,	,
18637	7633	87	234	234	CD
18637	7633	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7633	89	652	652	CD
18637	7633	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7633	91	1914	1914	CD
18637	7633	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7633	93	;	;	:
18637	7633	94	Security	Security	NNP
18637	7633	95	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	7633	96	.	.	.
18637	7634	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7634	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7634	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7634	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7634	5	California	California	NNP
18637	7634	6	,	,	,
18637	7634	7	263	263	CD
18637	7634	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7634	9	282	282	CD
18637	7634	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7634	11	1923	1923	CD
18637	7634	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7634	13	;	;	:
18637	7634	14	United	United	NNP
18637	7634	15	States	States	NNP
18637	7634	16	Mortgage	Mortgage	NNP
18637	7634	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7634	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7634	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	7634	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7634	21	Matthews	Matthews	NNP
18637	7634	22	,	,	,
18637	7634	23	293	293	CD
18637	7634	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7634	25	232	232	CD
18637	7634	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7634	27	1934	1934	CD
18637	7634	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7634	29	.	.	.
18637	7635	1	Compare	compare	VB
18637	7635	2	the	the	DT
18637	7635	3	following	follow	VBG
18637	7635	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	7635	5	,	,	,
18637	7635	6	where	where	WRB
18637	7635	7	changes	change	NNS
18637	7635	8	in	in	IN
18637	7635	9	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	7635	10	were	be	VBD
18637	7635	11	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	7635	12	to	to	TO
18637	7635	13	be	be	VB
18637	7635	14	of	of	IN
18637	7635	15	such	such	PDT
18637	7635	16	a	a	DT
18637	7635	17	character	character	NN
18637	7635	18	as	as	IN
18637	7635	19	to	to	TO
18637	7635	20	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	7635	21	with	with	IN
18637	7635	22	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	7635	23	rights	right	NNS
18637	7635	24	:	:	:
18637	7635	25	Wilmington	Wilmington	NNP
18637	7635	26	&	&	CC
18637	7635	27	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	7635	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7635	29	_	_	NNP
18637	7635	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	7635	31	_	_	NNP
18637	7635	32	King	King	NNP
18637	7635	33	,	,	,
18637	7635	34	91	91	CD
18637	7635	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7635	36	3	3	CD
18637	7635	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7635	38	1875	1875	CD
18637	7635	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7635	40	;	;	:
18637	7635	41	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	7635	42	_	_	NNP
18637	7635	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	7635	44	_	_	NNP
18637	7635	45	United	United	NNP
18637	7635	46	States	States	NNP
18637	7635	47	,	,	,
18637	7635	48	97	97	CD
18637	7635	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7635	50	293	293	CD
18637	7635	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7635	52	1878	1878	CD
18637	7635	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7635	54	;	;	:
18637	7635	55	Poindexter	Poindexter	NNP
18637	7635	56	_	_	NNP
18637	7635	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	7635	58	_	_	NNP
18637	7635	59	Greenhow	Greenhow	NNP
18637	7635	60	,	,	,
18637	7635	61	114	114	CD
18637	7635	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7635	63	269	269	CD
18637	7635	64	,	,	,
18637	7635	65	270	270	CD
18637	7635	66	,	,	,
18637	7635	67	298	298	CD
18637	7635	68	,	,	,
18637	7635	69	299	299	CD
18637	7635	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7635	71	1885	1885	CD
18637	7635	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7635	73	;	;	:
18637	7635	74	Effinger	Effinger	NNP
18637	7635	75	_	_	NNP
18637	7635	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	7635	77	_	_	NNP
18637	7635	78	Kenney	Kenney	NNP
18637	7635	79	,	,	,
18637	7635	80	115	115	CD
18637	7635	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7635	82	566	566	CD
18637	7635	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7635	84	1885	1885	CD
18637	7635	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7635	86	;	;	:
18637	7635	87	Fisk	Fisk	NNP
18637	7635	88	_	_	NNP
18637	7635	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	7635	90	_	_	NNP
18637	7635	91	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	7635	92	Police	Police	NNP
18637	7635	93	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	7635	94	,	,	,
18637	7635	95	116	116	CD
18637	7635	96	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7635	97	131	131	CD
18637	7635	98	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7635	99	1885	1885	CD
18637	7635	100	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7635	101	;	;	:
18637	7635	102	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	7635	103	_	_	NNP
18637	7635	104	v.	v.	IN
18637	7635	105	_	_	NNP
18637	7635	106	Lightcap	Lightcap	NNP
18637	7635	107	,	,	,
18637	7635	108	195	195	CD
18637	7635	109	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7635	110	1	1	CD
18637	7635	111	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7635	112	1904	1904	CD
18637	7635	113	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7635	114	;	;	:
18637	7635	115	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7635	116	of	of	IN
18637	7635	117	Minden	Minden	NNP
18637	7635	118	_	_	NNP
18637	7635	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	7635	120	_	_	NNP
18637	7635	121	Clement	Clement	NNP
18637	7635	122	,	,	,
18637	7635	123	256	256	CD
18637	7635	124	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7635	125	126	126	CD
18637	7635	126	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7635	127	1921	1921	CD
18637	7635	128	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7635	129	.	.	.
18637	7636	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7636	2	1707	1707	CD
18637	7636	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7636	4	Von	Von	NNP
18637	7636	5	Hoffman	Hoffman	NNP
18637	7636	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7636	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7636	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7636	9	Quincy	Quincy	NNP
18637	7636	10	,	,	,
18637	7636	11	4	4	CD
18637	7636	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7636	13	.	.	.
18637	7637	1	535	535	CD
18637	7637	2	,	,	,
18637	7637	3	554	554	CD
18637	7637	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	7637	5	555	555	CD
18637	7637	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7637	7	1867	1867	CD
18637	7637	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7637	9	.	.	.
18637	7638	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7638	2	1708	1708	CD
18637	7638	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7638	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7638	5	See	See	NNP
18637	7638	6	also	also	RB
18637	7638	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7638	8	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7638	9	ex	ex	NNP
18637	7638	10	rel	rel	NN
18637	7638	11	.	.	.
18637	7639	1	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	7639	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7639	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7639	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7639	5	St.	St.	NNP
18637	7639	6	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	7639	7	's	's	POS
18637	7639	8	Parish	Parish	NNP
18637	7639	9	,	,	,
18637	7639	10	111	111	CD
18637	7639	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7639	12	716	716	CD
18637	7639	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7639	14	1884	1884	CD
18637	7639	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7639	16	.	.	.
18637	7640	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7640	2	1709	1709	CD
18637	7640	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7640	4	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	7640	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7640	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7640	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7640	8	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	7640	9	,	,	,
18637	7640	10	116	116	CD
18637	7640	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7640	12	289	289	CD
18637	7640	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7640	14	1886	1886	CD
18637	7640	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7640	16	;	;	:
18637	7640	17	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	7640	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7640	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	7640	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7640	21	Folsom	Folsom	NNP
18637	7640	22	,	,	,
18637	7640	23	200	200	CD
18637	7640	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7640	25	248	248	CD
18637	7640	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7640	27	1906	1906	CD
18637	7640	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7640	29	.	.	.
18637	7641	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7641	2	1710	1710	CD
18637	7641	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7641	4	Heine	Heine	NNP
18637	7641	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7641	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7641	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7641	8	Levee	Levee	NNP
18637	7641	9	Commissioners	Commissioners	NNP
18637	7641	10	,	,	,
18637	7641	11	19	19	CD
18637	7641	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7641	13	.	.	.
18637	7642	1	655	655	CD
18637	7642	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7642	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	7642	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7642	5	.	.	.
18637	7643	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7643	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	7643	3	.	.	.
18637	7643	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7643	5	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7643	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7643	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7643	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7643	9	West	West	NNP
18637	7643	10	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7643	11	,	,	,
18637	7643	12	246	246	CD
18637	7643	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7643	14	565	565	CD
18637	7643	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7643	16	1918	1918	CD
18637	7643	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7643	18	.	.	.
18637	7644	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7644	2	1711	1711	CD
18637	7644	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7644	4	Faitoute	Faitoute	NNP
18637	7644	5	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	7644	6	&	&	CC
18637	7644	7	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	7644	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7644	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7644	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7644	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7644	12	Asbury	Asbury	NNP
18637	7644	13	Park	Park	NNP
18637	7644	14	,	,	,
18637	7644	15	316	316	CD
18637	7644	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7644	17	502	502	CD
18637	7644	18	,	,	,
18637	7644	19	510	510	CD
18637	7644	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7644	21	1942	1942	CD
18637	7644	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7644	23	.	.	.
18637	7645	1	Alluding	allude	VBG
18637	7645	2	to	to	IN
18637	7645	3	the	the	DT
18637	7645	4	ineffectiveness	ineffectiveness	NN
18637	7645	5	of	of	IN
18637	7645	6	purely	purely	RB
18637	7645	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	7645	8	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	7645	9	against	against	IN
18637	7645	10	defaulting	default	VBG
18637	7645	11	municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	7645	12	,	,	,
18637	7645	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7645	14	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	7645	15	says	say	VBZ
18637	7645	16	:	:	:
18637	7645	17	"	"	``
18637	7645	18	For	for	IN
18637	7645	19	there	there	EX
18637	7645	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	7645	21	no	no	DT
18637	7645	22	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	7645	23	when	when	WRB
18637	7645	24	resort	resort	NN
18637	7645	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	7645	26	had	have	VBN
18637	7645	27	to	to	TO
18637	7645	28	'	'	``
18637	7645	29	devices	device	NNS
18637	7645	30	and	and	CC
18637	7645	31	contrivances	contrivance	NNS
18637	7645	32	'	'	''
18637	7645	33	to	to	TO
18637	7645	34	nullify	nullify	VB
18637	7645	35	the	the	DT
18637	7645	36	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	7645	37	power	power	NN
18637	7645	38	which	which	WDT
18637	7645	39	can	can	MD
18637	7645	40	be	be	VB
18637	7645	41	carried	carry	VBN
18637	7645	42	out	out	RP
18637	7645	43	only	only	RB
18637	7645	44	through	through	IN
18637	7645	45	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	7645	46	officials	official	NNS
18637	7645	47	.	.	.
18637	7646	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7646	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7646	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7646	4	Rees	Rees	NNPS
18637	7646	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7646	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7646	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7646	8	City	City	NNP
18637	7646	9	of	of	IN
18637	7646	10	Watertown	Watertown	NNP
18637	7646	11	,	,	,
18637	7646	12	19	19	CD
18637	7646	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7646	14	.	.	.
18637	7647	1	107	107	CD
18637	7647	2	,	,	,
18637	7647	3	124	124	CD
18637	7647	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7647	5	1874	1874	CD
18637	7647	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7647	7	.	.	.
18637	7648	1	And	and	CC
18637	7648	2	so	so	RB
18637	7648	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7648	4	have	have	VBP
18637	7648	5	had	have	VBN
18637	7648	6	the	the	DT
18637	7648	7	spectacle	spectacle	NN
18637	7648	8	of	of	IN
18637	7648	9	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	7648	10	officials	official	NNS
18637	7648	11	resigning	resign	VBG
18637	7648	12	from	from	IN
18637	7648	13	office	office	NN
18637	7648	14	in	in	IN
18637	7648	15	order	order	NN
18637	7648	16	to	to	TO
18637	7648	17	frustrate	frustrate	VB
18637	7648	18	tax	tax	NN
18637	7648	19	levies	levy	NNS
18637	7648	20	through	through	IN
18637	7648	21	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	7648	22	,	,	,
18637	7648	23	and	and	CC
18637	7648	24	officials	official	NNS
18637	7648	25	running	run	VBG
18637	7648	26	on	on	IN
18637	7648	27	a	a	DT
18637	7648	28	platform	platform	NN
18637	7648	29	of	of	IN
18637	7648	30	willingness	willingness	NN
18637	7648	31	to	to	TO
18637	7648	32	go	go	VB
18637	7648	33	to	to	IN
18637	7648	34	jail	jail	NN
18637	7648	35	rather	rather	RB
18637	7648	36	than	than	IN
18637	7648	37	to	to	TO
18637	7648	38	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	7648	39	a	a	DT
18637	7648	40	tax	tax	NN
18637	7648	41	levy	levy	NN
18637	7648	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7648	43	_	_	NNP
18637	7648	44	see	see	UH
18637	7648	45	_	_	NNP
18637	7648	46	Raymond	Raymond	NNP
18637	7648	47	,	,	,
18637	7648	48	State	State	NNP
18637	7648	49	and	and	CC
18637	7648	50	Municipal	Municipal	NNP
18637	7648	51	Bonds	Bonds	NNPS
18637	7648	52	,	,	,
18637	7648	53	342	342	CD
18637	7648	54	-	-	SYM
18637	7648	55	343	343	CD
18637	7648	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7648	57	,	,	,
18637	7648	58	and	and	CC
18637	7648	59	evasion	evasion	NN
18637	7648	60	of	of	IN
18637	7648	61	service	service	NN
18637	7648	62	by	by	IN
18637	7648	63	tax	tax	NN
18637	7648	64	collectors	collector	NNS
18637	7648	65	,	,	,
18637	7648	66	thus	thus	RB
18637	7648	67	making	make	VBG
18637	7648	68	impotent	impotent	NN
18637	7648	69	a	a	DT
18637	7648	70	court	court	NN
18637	7648	71	's	's	POS
18637	7648	72	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	7648	73	.	.	.
18637	7649	1	Yost	Yost	NNP
18637	7649	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7649	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7649	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7649	5	Dallas	Dallas	NNP
18637	7649	6	County	County	NNP
18637	7649	7	,	,	,
18637	7649	8	236	236	CD
18637	7649	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7649	10	50	50	CD
18637	7649	11	,	,	,
18637	7649	12	57	57	CD
18637	7649	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7649	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	7649	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7649	16	.	.	.
18637	7649	17	"	"	''
18637	7650	1	316	316	CD
18637	7650	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7650	3	at	at	IN
18637	7650	4	511	511	CD
18637	7650	5	.	.	.
18637	7651	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7651	2	1712	1712	CD
18637	7651	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7651	4	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	7651	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7651	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7651	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7651	8	Irwin	Irwin	NNP
18637	7651	9	,	,	,
18637	7651	10	2	2	CD
18637	7651	11	Sergeant	Sergeant	NNP
18637	7651	12	and	and	CC
18637	7651	13	Rawle	Rawle	NNP
18637	7651	14	's	's	POS
18637	7651	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7651	16	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7651	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7651	18	,	,	,
18637	7651	19	367	367	CD
18637	7651	20	,	,	,
18637	7651	21	371	371	CD
18637	7651	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7651	23	1816	1816	CD
18637	7651	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7651	25	;	;	:
18637	7651	26	_	_	NNP
18637	7651	27	also	also	RB
18637	7651	28	_	_	NNP
18637	7651	29	,	,	,
18637	7651	30	to	to	IN
18637	7651	31	same	same	JJ
18637	7651	32	effect	effect	NN
18637	7651	33	,	,	,
18637	7651	34	Lindenmuller	Lindenmuller	NNP
18637	7651	35	_	_	NNP
18637	7651	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	7651	37	_	_	NNP
18637	7651	38	The	the	DT
18637	7651	39	People	People	NNPS
18637	7651	40	,	,	,
18637	7651	41	33	33	CD
18637	7651	42	Barbour	Barbour	NNP
18637	7651	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7651	44	N.Y.	New York	NNP
18637	7651	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7651	46	,	,	,
18637	7651	47	548	548	CD
18637	7651	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7651	49	1861	1861	CD
18637	7651	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7651	51	.	.	.
18637	7652	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7652	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7652	3	also	also	RB
18637	7652	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7652	5	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	7652	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7652	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7652	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7652	9	Penobscot	Penobscot	NNP
18637	7652	10	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7652	11	,	,	,
18637	7652	12	8	8	CD
18637	7652	13	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	7653	1	445	445	CD
18637	7653	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7653	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	7653	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7653	5	.	.	.
18637	7654	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7654	2	1713	1713	CD
18637	7654	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7654	4	Manigault	Manigault	NNP
18637	7654	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7654	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7654	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7654	8	Springs	Springs	NNP
18637	7654	9	,	,	,
18637	7654	10	199	199	CD
18637	7654	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7654	12	473	473	CD
18637	7654	13	,	,	,
18637	7654	14	480	480	CD
18637	7654	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7654	16	1905	1905	CD
18637	7654	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7654	18	.	.	.
18637	7655	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7655	2	1714	1714	CD
18637	7655	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7655	4	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	7655	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7655	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7655	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7655	8	Lamphire	Lamphire	NNP
18637	7655	9	,	,	,
18637	7655	10	3	3	CD
18637	7655	11	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	7655	12	.	.	.
18637	7656	1	280	280	CD
18637	7656	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7656	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	7656	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7656	5	.	.	.
18637	7657	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7657	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7657	3	also	also	RB
18637	7657	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7657	5	Phalen	Phalen	NNP
18637	7657	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7657	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7657	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7657	9	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7657	10	,	,	,
18637	7657	11	8	8	CD
18637	7657	12	How	how	WRB
18637	7657	13	.	.	.
18637	7658	1	163	163	CD
18637	7658	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7658	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	7658	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7658	5	.	.	.
18637	7659	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7659	2	1715	1715	CD
18637	7659	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7659	4	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	7659	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7659	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7659	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7659	8	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	7659	9	,	,	,
18637	7659	10	101	101	CD
18637	7659	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7659	12	814	814	CD
18637	7659	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7659	14	1880	1880	CD
18637	7659	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7659	16	.	.	.
18637	7660	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7660	2	1716	1716	CD
18637	7660	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7660	4	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	7660	5	Beer	Beer	NNP
18637	7660	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7660	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7660	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7660	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7660	10	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	7660	11	,	,	,
18637	7660	12	97	97	CD
18637	7660	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7660	14	25	25	CD
18637	7660	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7660	16	1878	1878	CD
18637	7660	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7660	18	.	.	.
18637	7661	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7661	2	1717	1717	CD
18637	7661	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7661	4	New	New	NNP
18637	7661	5	York	York	NNP
18637	7661	6	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	7662	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7662	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7662	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7662	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7662	5	White	White	NNP
18637	7662	6	,	,	,
18637	7662	7	243	243	CD
18637	7662	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7662	9	188	188	CD
18637	7662	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7662	11	1917	1917	CD
18637	7662	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7662	13	.	.	.
18637	7663	1	In	in	IN
18637	7663	2	this	this	DT
18637	7663	3	and	and	CC
18637	7663	4	the	the	DT
18637	7663	5	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	7663	6	two	two	CD
18637	7663	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	7663	8	the	the	DT
18637	7663	9	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	7663	10	act	act	NN
18637	7663	11	involved	involve	VBN
18637	7663	12	did	do	VBD
18637	7663	13	not	not	RB
18637	7663	14	except	except	IN
18637	7663	15	from	from	IN
18637	7663	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7663	17	operation	operation	NN
18637	7663	18	existing	exist	VBG
18637	7663	19	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	7663	20	.	.	.
18637	7664	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7664	2	1718	1718	CD
18637	7664	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7664	4	Manigault	Manigault	NNP
18637	7664	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7664	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7664	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7664	8	Springs	Springs	NNP
18637	7664	9	,	,	,
18637	7664	10	199	199	CD
18637	7664	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7664	12	473	473	CD
18637	7664	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7664	14	1905	1905	CD
18637	7664	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7664	16	.	.	.
18637	7665	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7665	2	1719	1719	CD
18637	7665	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7665	4	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	7665	5	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	7665	6	,	,	,
18637	7665	7	Light	Light	NNP
18637	7665	8	&	&	CC
18637	7665	9	Power	Power	NNP
18637	7665	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7665	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7665	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	7665	13	_	_	NNP
18637	7665	14	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	7665	15	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	7665	16	.	.	.
18637	7666	1	of	of	IN
18637	7666	2	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	7666	3	,	,	,
18637	7666	4	229	229	CD
18637	7666	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7666	6	397	397	CD
18637	7666	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7666	8	1913	1913	CD
18637	7666	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7666	10	.	.	.
18637	7667	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7667	2	1720	1720	CD
18637	7667	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7667	4	Midland	Midland	NNP
18637	7667	5	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	7667	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7667	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7667	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7667	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7667	10	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	7667	11	City	City	NNP
18637	7667	12	Power	Power	NNP
18637	7667	13	&	&	CC
18637	7667	14	Light	Light	NNP
18637	7667	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7667	16	,	,	,
18637	7667	17	300	300	CD
18637	7667	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7667	19	109	109	CD
18637	7667	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7667	21	1937	1937	CD
18637	7667	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7667	23	.	.	.
18637	7668	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7668	2	1721	1721	CD
18637	7668	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7668	4	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	7668	5	County	County	NNP
18637	7668	6	Water	Water	NNP
18637	7668	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7668	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7668	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7668	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7668	11	McCarter	McCarter	NNP
18637	7668	12	,	,	,
18637	7668	13	209	209	CD
18637	7668	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7668	15	349	349	CD
18637	7668	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7668	17	1908	1908	CD
18637	7668	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7668	19	.	.	.
18637	7669	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7669	2	1722	1722	CD
18637	7669	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7669	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	7669	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7669	6	Marcus	Marcus	NNP
18637	7669	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7669	8	Holding	Holding	NNP
18637	7669	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7669	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7669	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	7669	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7669	13	Feldman	Feldman	NNP
18637	7669	14	,	,	,
18637	7669	15	256	256	CD
18637	7669	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7669	17	170	170	CD
18637	7669	18	,	,	,
18637	7669	19	198	198	CD
18637	7669	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7669	21	1921	1921	CD
18637	7669	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7669	23	;	;	:
18637	7669	24	followed	follow	VBN
18637	7669	25	in	in	IN
18637	7669	26	Levy	Levy	NNP
18637	7669	27	Leasing	Leasing	NNP
18637	7669	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7669	29	_	_	NNP
18637	7669	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	7669	31	_	_	NNP
18637	7669	32	Siegel	Siegel	NNP
18637	7669	33	,	,	,
18637	7669	34	258	258	CD
18637	7669	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7669	36	242	242	CD
18637	7669	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7669	38	1922	1922	CD
18637	7669	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7669	40	.	.	.
18637	7670	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7670	2	1723	1723	CD
18637	7670	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7670	4	Chastleton	Chastleton	NNP
18637	7670	5	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	7670	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7670	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7670	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7670	9	Sinclair	Sinclair	NNP
18637	7670	10	,	,	,
18637	7670	11	264	264	CD
18637	7670	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7670	13	543	543	CD
18637	7670	14	,	,	,
18637	7670	15	547	547	CD
18637	7670	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	7670	17	548	548	CD
18637	7670	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7670	19	1924	1924	CD
18637	7670	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7670	21	.	.	.
18637	7671	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7671	2	1724	1724	CD
18637	7671	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7671	4	290	290	CD
18637	7671	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7671	6	398	398	CD
18637	7671	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7671	8	1934	1934	CD
18637	7671	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7671	10	.	.	.
18637	7672	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7672	2	1725	1725	CD
18637	7672	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7672	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7672	5	.	.	.
18637	7673	1	442	442	CD
18637	7673	2	,	,	,
18637	7673	3	444	444	CD
18637	7673	4	.	.	.
18637	7674	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7674	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7674	3	also	also	RB
18637	7674	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7674	5	Veix	Veix	NNP
18637	7674	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7674	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7674	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7674	9	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	7674	10	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	7674	11	Building	Building	NNP
18637	7674	12	and	and	CC
18637	7674	13	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	7674	14	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	7674	15	.	.	.
18637	7675	1	of	of	IN
18637	7675	2	Newark	Newark	NNP
18637	7675	3	,	,	,
18637	7675	4	310	310	CD
18637	7675	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7675	6	32	32	CD
18637	7675	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7675	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	7675	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7675	10	in	in	IN
18637	7675	11	which	which	WDT
18637	7675	12	was	be	VBD
18637	7675	13	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	7675	14	a	a	DT
18637	7675	15	New	New	NNP
18637	7675	16	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	7675	17	statute	statute	NN
18637	7675	18	,	,	,
18637	7675	19	amending	amend	VBG
18637	7675	20	,	,	,
18637	7675	21	in	in	IN
18637	7675	22	view	view	NN
18637	7675	23	of	of	IN
18637	7675	24	the	the	DT
18637	7675	25	Depression	Depression	NNP
18637	7675	26	,	,	,
18637	7675	27	the	the	DT
18637	7675	28	law	law	NN
18637	7675	29	governing	govern	VBG
18637	7675	30	building	building	NN
18637	7675	31	and	and	CC
18637	7675	32	loan	loan	NN
18637	7675	33	associations	association	NNS
18637	7675	34	.	.	.
18637	7676	1	The	the	DT
18637	7676	2	authority	authority	NN
18637	7676	3	of	of	IN
18637	7676	4	the	the	DT
18637	7676	5	State	State	NNP
18637	7676	6	to	to	TO
18637	7676	7	safeguard	safeguard	VB
18637	7676	8	the	the	DT
18637	7676	9	vital	vital	JJ
18637	7676	10	interests	interest	NNS
18637	7676	11	of	of	IN
18637	7676	12	the	the	DT
18637	7676	13	people	people	NNS
18637	7676	14	,	,	,
18637	7676	15	said	say	VBD
18637	7676	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7676	17	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	7676	18	,	,	,
18637	7676	19	"	"	``
18637	7676	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	7676	21	not	not	RB
18637	7676	22	limited	limit	VBN
18637	7676	23	to	to	IN
18637	7676	24	health	health	NN
18637	7676	25	,	,	,
18637	7676	26	morals	moral	NNS
18637	7676	27	and	and	CC
18637	7676	28	safety	safety	NN
18637	7676	29	.	.	.
18637	7677	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7677	2	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	7677	3	to	to	IN
18637	7677	4	economic	economic	JJ
18637	7677	5	needs	need	NNS
18637	7677	6	as	as	RB
18637	7677	7	well	well	RB
18637	7677	8	.	.	.
18637	7677	9	"	"	''
18637	7678	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	7678	2	.	.	.
18637	7679	1	38	38	CD
18637	7679	2	-	-	SYM
18637	7679	3	39	39	CD
18637	7679	4	.	.	.
18637	7680	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7680	2	1726	1726	CD
18637	7680	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7680	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7680	5	See	See	NNP
18637	7680	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7680	7	especially	especially	RB
18637	7680	8	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	7680	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7680	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7680	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7680	12	Kearzey	Kearzey	NNP
18637	7680	13	,	,	,
18637	7680	14	96	96	CD
18637	7680	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7680	16	595	595	CD
18637	7680	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7680	18	1878	1878	CD
18637	7680	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7680	20	;	;	:
18637	7680	21	and	and	CC
18637	7680	22	Barnitz	Barnitz	NNP
18637	7680	23	_	_	NNP
18637	7680	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	7680	25	_	_	NNP
18637	7680	26	Beverly	Beverly	NNP
18637	7680	27	,	,	,
18637	7680	28	163	163	CD
18637	7680	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7680	30	118	118	CD
18637	7680	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7680	32	1896	1896	CD
18637	7680	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7680	34	.	.	.
18637	7681	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7681	2	1727	1727	CD
18637	7681	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7681	4	290	290	CD
18637	7681	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7681	6	398	398	CD
18637	7681	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7681	8	1934	1934	CD
18637	7681	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7681	10	.	.	.
18637	7682	1	As	as	IN
18637	7682	2	to	to	IN
18637	7682	3	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	7682	4	surrounding	surround	VBG
18637	7682	5	the	the	DT
18637	7682	6	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	7682	7	of	of	IN
18637	7682	8	moratorium	moratorium	NN
18637	7682	9	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	7682	10	in	in	IN
18637	7682	11	1933	1933	CD
18637	7682	12	,	,	,
18637	7682	13	_	_	NNP
18637	7682	14	see	see	VBP
18637	7682	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7682	16	New	New	NNP
18637	7682	17	York	York	NNP
18637	7682	18	Times	Times	NNP
18637	7682	19	of	of	IN
18637	7682	20	January	January	NNP
18637	7682	21	22	22	CD
18637	7682	22	,	,	,
18637	7682	23	1933	1933	CD
18637	7682	24	,	,	,
18637	7682	25	sec	sec	NNP
18637	7682	26	.	.	.
18637	7683	1	II	II	NNP
18637	7683	2	,	,	,
18637	7683	3	pp	pp	NNP
18637	7683	4	.	.	.
18637	7684	1	1	1	CD
18637	7684	2	-	-	SYM
18637	7684	3	2	2	CD
18637	7684	4	.	.	.
18637	7685	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7685	2	1728	1728	CD
18637	7685	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7685	4	Worthen	Worthen	NNP
18637	7685	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7685	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7685	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7685	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7685	9	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	7685	10	,	,	,
18637	7685	11	292	292	CD
18637	7685	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7685	13	426	426	CD
18637	7685	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7685	15	1934	1934	CD
18637	7685	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7685	17	;	;	:
18637	7685	18	Worthen	Worthen	NNP
18637	7685	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7685	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7685	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	7685	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7685	23	Kavanaugh	Kavanaugh	NNP
18637	7685	24	,	,	,
18637	7685	25	295	295	CD
18637	7685	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7685	27	56	56	CD
18637	7685	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7685	29	1935	1935	CD
18637	7685	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7685	31	.	.	.
18637	7686	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7686	2	1729	1729	CD
18637	7686	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7686	4	295	295	CD
18637	7686	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7686	6	at	at	IN
18637	7686	7	62	62	CD
18637	7686	8	.	.	.
18637	7687	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7687	2	1730	1730	CD
18637	7687	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7687	4	East	East	NNP
18637	7687	5	New	New	NNP
18637	7687	6	York	York	NNP
18637	7687	7	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	7687	8	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7687	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7687	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7687	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7687	12	Hahn	Hahn	NNP
18637	7687	13	,	,	,
18637	7687	14	326	326	CD
18637	7687	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7687	16	230	230	CD
18637	7687	17	,	,	,
18637	7687	18	235	235	CD
18637	7687	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7687	20	1945	1945	CD
18637	7687	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7687	22	.	.	.
18637	7688	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7688	2	1731	1731	CD
18637	7688	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7688	4	Honeyman	Honeyman	NNP
18637	7688	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7688	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7688	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7688	8	Jacobs	Jacobs	NNP
18637	7688	9	,	,	,
18637	7688	10	306	306	CD
18637	7688	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7688	12	539	539	CD
18637	7688	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7688	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	7688	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7688	16	.	.	.
18637	7689	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7689	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7689	3	also	also	RB
18637	7689	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7689	5	Gelfert	Gelfert	NNP
18637	7689	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7689	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7689	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7689	9	National	National	NNP
18637	7689	10	City	City	NNP
18637	7689	11	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7689	12	,	,	,
18637	7689	13	313	313	CD
18637	7689	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7689	15	221	221	CD
18637	7689	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7689	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	7689	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7689	19	.	.	.
18637	7690	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7690	2	1732	1732	CD
18637	7690	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7690	4	313	313	CD
18637	7690	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7690	6	at	at	IN
18637	7690	7	233	233	CD
18637	7690	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	7690	9	234	234	CD
18637	7690	10	.	.	.
18637	7691	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7691	2	1733	1733	CD
18637	7691	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7691	4	One	one	CD
18637	7691	5	reason	reason	NN
18637	7691	6	for	for	IN
18637	7691	7	this	this	DT
18637	7691	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	7691	9	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	7691	10	in	in	IN
18637	7691	11	the	the	DT
18637	7691	12	following	follow	VBG
18637	7691	13	passage	passage	NN
18637	7691	14	from	from	IN
18637	7691	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7691	16	Field	Field	NNP
18637	7691	17	's	's	POS
18637	7691	18	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	7691	19	for	for	IN
18637	7691	20	the	the	DT
18637	7691	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7691	22	in	in	IN
18637	7691	23	Paul	Paul	NNP
18637	7691	24	_	_	NNP
18637	7691	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	7691	26	_	_	NNP
18637	7691	27	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7691	28	,	,	,
18637	7691	29	decided	decide	VBD
18637	7691	30	in	in	IN
18637	7691	31	1869	1869	CD
18637	7691	32	:	:	:
18637	7691	33	"	"	``
18637	7691	34	At	at	IN
18637	7691	35	the	the	DT
18637	7691	36	present	present	JJ
18637	7691	37	day	day	NN
18637	7691	38	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	7691	39	are	be	VBP
18637	7691	40	multiplied	multiply	VBN
18637	7691	41	to	to	IN
18637	7691	42	an	an	DT
18637	7691	43	almost	almost	RB
18637	7691	44	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	7691	45	extent	extent	NN
18637	7691	46	.	.	.
18637	7692	1	There	there	EX
18637	7692	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	7692	3	scarcely	scarcely	RB
18637	7692	4	a	a	DT
18637	7692	5	business	business	NN
18637	7692	6	pursued	pursue	VBD
18637	7692	7	requiring	require	VBG
18637	7692	8	the	the	DT
18637	7692	9	expenditure	expenditure	NN
18637	7692	10	of	of	IN
18637	7692	11	large	large	JJ
18637	7692	12	capital	capital	NN
18637	7692	13	,	,	,
18637	7692	14	or	or	CC
18637	7692	15	the	the	DT
18637	7692	16	union	union	NN
18637	7692	17	of	of	IN
18637	7692	18	large	large	JJ
18637	7692	19	numbers	number	NNS
18637	7692	20	,	,	,
18637	7692	21	that	that	WDT
18637	7692	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	7692	23	not	not	RB
18637	7692	24	carried	carry	VBN
18637	7692	25	on	on	RP
18637	7692	26	by	by	IN
18637	7692	27	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	7692	28	.	.	.
18637	7693	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7693	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	7693	3	not	not	RB
18637	7693	4	too	too	RB
18637	7693	5	much	much	JJ
18637	7693	6	to	to	TO
18637	7693	7	say	say	VB
18637	7693	8	that	that	IN
18637	7693	9	the	the	DT
18637	7693	10	wealth	wealth	NN
18637	7693	11	and	and	CC
18637	7693	12	business	business	NN
18637	7693	13	of	of	IN
18637	7693	14	the	the	DT
18637	7693	15	country	country	NN
18637	7693	16	are	be	VBP
18637	7693	17	to	to	IN
18637	7693	18	a	a	DT
18637	7693	19	great	great	JJ
18637	7693	20	extent	extent	NN
18637	7693	21	controlled	control	VBN
18637	7693	22	by	by	IN
18637	7693	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7693	24	.	.	.
18637	7693	25	"	"	''
18637	7694	1	8	8	CD
18637	7694	2	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7694	3	.	.	.
18637	7695	1	168	168	CD
18637	7695	2	,	,	,
18637	7695	3	181	181	CD
18637	7695	4	-	-	SYM
18637	7695	5	182	182	CD
18637	7695	6	.	.	.
18637	7696	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7696	2	1734	1734	CD
18637	7696	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7696	4	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	7696	5	,	,	,
18637	7696	6	The	the	DT
18637	7696	7	Contract	Contract	NNP
18637	7696	8	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	7696	9	,	,	,
18637	7696	10	91	91	CD
18637	7696	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	7696	12	100	100	CD
18637	7696	13	.	.	.
18637	7697	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7697	2	1735	1735	CD
18637	7697	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7697	4	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	7697	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7697	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7697	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7697	8	United	United	NNP
18637	7697	9	States	States	NNP
18637	7697	10	,	,	,
18637	7697	11	294	294	CD
18637	7697	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7697	13	330	330	CD
18637	7697	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7697	15	1935	1935	CD
18637	7697	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7697	17	;	;	:
18637	7697	18	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	7697	19	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	7697	20	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	7697	21	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7697	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7697	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	7697	24	_	_	NNP
18637	7697	25	Radford	Radford	NNP
18637	7697	26	,	,	,
18637	7697	27	295	295	CD
18637	7697	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7697	29	555	555	CD
18637	7697	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7697	31	1935	1935	CD
18637	7697	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7697	33	.	.	.
18637	7698	1	The	the	DT
18637	7698	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7698	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	7698	4	pointed	point	VBN
18637	7698	5	out	out	RP
18637	7698	6	,	,	,
18637	7698	7	what	what	WP
18637	7698	8	of	of	IN
18637	7698	9	course	course	NN
18637	7698	10	,	,	,
18637	7698	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	7698	12	evident	evident	JJ
18637	7698	13	on	on	IN
18637	7698	14	a	a	DT
18637	7698	15	reading	reading	NN
18637	7698	16	of	of	IN
18637	7698	17	the	the	DT
18637	7698	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7698	19	,	,	,
18637	7698	20	that	that	IN
18637	7698	21	the	the	DT
18637	7698	22	contract	contract	NN
18637	7698	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	7698	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	7698	25	a	a	DT
18637	7698	26	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	7698	27	on	on	IN
18637	7698	28	the	the	DT
18637	7698	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	7698	30	of	of	IN
18637	7698	31	the	the	DT
18637	7698	32	States	States	NNPS
18637	7698	33	and	and	CC
18637	7698	34	not	not	RB
18637	7698	35	of	of	IN
18637	7698	36	the	the	DT
18637	7698	37	United	United	NNP
18637	7698	38	States	States	NNP
18637	7698	39	.	.	.
18637	7699	1	Central	central	JJ
18637	7699	2	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	7700	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7700	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7700	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7700	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7700	5	Gallatin	Gallatin	NNP
18637	7700	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7700	7	Sinking	Sinking	NNP
18637	7700	8	Fund	Fund	NNP
18637	7700	9	Cases	case	NNS
18637	7700	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7700	11	,	,	,
18637	7700	12	99	99	CD
18637	7700	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7700	14	700	700	CD
18637	7700	15	,	,	,
18637	7700	16	718	718	CD
18637	7700	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7700	18	1879	1879	CD
18637	7700	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7700	20	.	.	.
18637	7701	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7701	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7701	3	also	also	RB
18637	7701	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7701	5	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	7701	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7701	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7701	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7701	9	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	7701	10	,	,	,
18637	7701	11	110	110	CD
18637	7701	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7701	13	633	633	CD
18637	7701	14	,	,	,
18637	7701	15	643	643	CD
18637	7701	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7701	17	1884	1884	CD
18637	7701	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7701	19	;	;	:
18637	7701	20	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	7701	21	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	7701	22	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	7701	23	,	,	,
18637	7701	24	12	12	CD
18637	7701	25	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7701	26	.	.	.
18637	7702	1	457	457	CD
18637	7702	2	,	,	,
18637	7702	3	529	529	CD
18637	7702	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7702	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	7702	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7702	7	;	;	:
18637	7702	8	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	7702	9	Ill.	Illinois	NNP
18637	7702	10	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	7702	11	.	.	.
18637	7703	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7703	2	&	&	CC
18637	7703	3	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	7703	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7703	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7703	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7703	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7703	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	7703	9	,	,	,
18637	7703	10	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	7703	11	&	&	CC
18637	7703	12	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	7704	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7704	2	,	,	,
18637	7704	3	294	294	CD
18637	7704	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7704	5	648	648	CD
18637	7704	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7704	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	7704	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7704	9	;	;	:
18637	7704	10	St.	St.	NNP
18637	7704	11	Anthony	Anthony	NNP
18637	7704	12	Falls	Falls	NNP
18637	7704	13	Water	Water	NNP
18637	7704	14	Power	Power	NNP
18637	7704	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7704	16	_	_	NNP
18637	7704	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	7704	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7704	19	Board	Board	NNP
18637	7704	20	of	of	IN
18637	7704	21	Water	Water	NNP
18637	7704	22	Commissioners	Commissioners	NNPS
18637	7704	23	,	,	,
18637	7704	24	168	168	CD
18637	7704	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7704	26	349	349	CD
18637	7704	27	,	,	,
18637	7704	28	372	372	CD
18637	7704	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7704	30	1897	1897	CD
18637	7704	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7704	32	;	;	:
18637	7704	33	Dubuque	dubuque	NN
18637	7704	34	,	,	,
18637	7704	35	S.C.R.	S.C.R.	NNS
18637	7705	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7705	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7705	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7705	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7705	5	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	7705	6	,	,	,
18637	7705	7	19	19	CD
18637	7705	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7705	9	.	.	.
18637	7706	1	584	584	CD
18637	7706	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7706	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	7706	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7706	5	;	;	:
18637	7706	6	New	New	NNP
18637	7706	7	York	York	NNP
18637	7706	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7706	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7706	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7706	11	United	United	NNP
18637	7706	12	States	States	NNP
18637	7706	13	,	,	,
18637	7706	14	257	257	CD
18637	7706	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7706	16	591	591	CD
18637	7706	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7706	18	1922	1922	CD
18637	7706	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7706	20	.	.	.
18637	7707	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7707	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	7707	3	.	.	.
18637	7707	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7707	5	however	however	RB
18637	7707	6	,	,	,
18637	7707	7	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	7707	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7707	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7707	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7707	11	Griswold	Griswold	NNP
18637	7707	12	,	,	,
18637	7707	13	8	8	CD
18637	7707	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7707	15	.	.	.
18637	7708	1	603	603	CD
18637	7708	2	,	,	,
18637	7708	3	623	623	CD
18637	7708	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7708	5	1870	1870	CD
18637	7708	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7708	7	;	;	:
18637	7708	8	and	and	CC
18637	7708	9	Central	Central	NNP
18637	7708	10	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	7708	11	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	7709	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7709	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7709	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7709	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7709	5	Gallatin	Gallatin	NNP
18637	7709	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7709	7	Sinking	Sinking	NNP
18637	7709	8	Fund	Fund	NNP
18637	7709	9	Cases	case	NNS
18637	7709	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7709	11	,	,	,
18637	7709	12	99	99	CD
18637	7709	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7709	14	700	700	CD
18637	7709	15	,	,	,
18637	7709	16	737	737	CD
18637	7709	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7709	18	1879	1879	CD
18637	7709	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7709	20	.	.	.
18637	7710	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7710	2	1736	1736	CD
18637	7710	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7710	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7710	5	See	See	NNP
18637	7710	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7710	7	,	,	,
18637	7710	8	e.g.	e.g.	NNP
18637	7710	9	,	,	,
18637	7710	10	Neblett	Neblett	NNP
18637	7710	11	et	et	FW
18637	7710	12	al	al	NNP
18637	7710	13	.	.	.
18637	7711	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7711	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	7711	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7711	4	Carpenter	Carpenter	NNP
18637	7711	5	,	,	,
18637	7711	6	et	et	NNP
18637	7711	7	al	al	NNP
18637	7711	8	.	.	NNP
18637	7711	9	,	,	,
18637	7711	10	305	305	CD
18637	7711	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7711	12	297	297	CD
18637	7711	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7711	14	1938	1938	CD
18637	7711	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7711	16	;	;	:
18637	7711	17	Asbury	Asbury	NNP
18637	7711	18	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	7711	19	_	_	NNP
18637	7711	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	7711	21	_	_	NNP
18637	7711	22	Cass	Cass	NNP
18637	7711	23	County	County	NNP
18637	7711	24	,	,	,
18637	7711	25	326	326	CD
18637	7711	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7711	27	207	207	CD
18637	7711	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7711	29	1945	1945	CD
18637	7711	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7711	31	;	;	:
18637	7711	32	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	7711	33	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	7711	34	L.	L.	NNP
18637	7711	35	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	7711	36	.	.	.
18637	7712	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7712	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7712	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7712	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7712	5	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	7712	6	,	,	,
18637	7712	7	333	333	CD
18637	7712	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7712	9	541	541	CD
18637	7712	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7712	11	1948	1948	CD
18637	7712	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7712	13	.	.	.
18637	7713	1	For	for	IN
18637	7713	2	a	a	DT
18637	7713	3	notable	notable	JJ
18637	7713	4	case	case	NN
18637	7713	5	in	in	IN
18637	7713	6	which	which	WDT
18637	7713	7	the	the	DT
18637	7713	8	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	7713	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	7713	10	was	be	VBD
18637	7713	11	mustered	muster	VBN
18637	7713	12	into	into	IN
18637	7713	13	service	service	NN
18637	7713	14	,	,	,
18637	7713	15	by	by	IN
18637	7713	16	rather	rather	RB
18637	7713	17	heroic	heroic	JJ
18637	7713	18	logic	logic	NN
18637	7713	19	,	,	,
18637	7713	20	to	to	TO
18637	7713	21	do	do	VB
18637	7713	22	work	work	NN
18637	7713	23	that	that	WDT
18637	7713	24	was	be	VBD
18637	7713	25	afterwards	afterwards	RB
18637	7713	26	put	put	VBN
18637	7713	27	upon	upon	IN
18637	7713	28	the	the	DT
18637	7713	29	due	due	JJ
18637	7713	30	process	process	NN
18637	7713	31	clause	clause	NN
18637	7713	32	,	,	,
18637	7713	33	_	_	NNP
18637	7713	34	see	see	VBP
18637	7713	35	_	_	NNP
18637	7713	36	State	State	NNP
18637	7713	37	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	7713	38	On	on	IN
18637	7713	39	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	7713	40	-	-	HYPH
18637	7713	41	Held	hold	VBN
18637	7713	42	Bonds	Bonds	NNPS
18637	7713	43	,	,	,
18637	7713	44	15	15	CD
18637	7713	45	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7713	46	.	.	.
18637	7714	1	300	300	CD
18637	7714	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7714	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	7714	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7714	5	.	.	.
18637	7715	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7715	2	1737	1737	CD
18637	7715	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7715	4	Hooven	Hooven	NNP
18637	7715	5	&	&	CC
18637	7715	6	Allison	Allison	NNP
18637	7715	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7715	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7715	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7715	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7715	11	Evatt	Evatt	NNP
18637	7715	12	,	,	,
18637	7715	13	324	324	CD
18637	7715	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7715	15	652	652	CD
18637	7715	16	,	,	,
18637	7715	17	673	673	CD
18637	7715	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7715	19	1945	1945	CD
18637	7715	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7715	21	.	.	.
18637	7716	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7716	2	1738	1738	CD
18637	7716	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7716	4	Woodruff	Woodruff	NNP
18637	7716	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7716	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7716	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7716	8	Parham	Parham	NNP
18637	7716	9	,	,	,
18637	7716	10	8	8	CD
18637	7716	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7716	12	.	.	.
18637	7717	1	123	123	CD
18637	7717	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7717	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	7717	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7717	5	.	.	.
18637	7718	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7718	2	1739	1739	CD
18637	7718	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7718	4	12	12	CD
18637	7718	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7718	6	.	.	.
18637	7719	1	419	419	CD
18637	7719	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7719	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	7719	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7719	5	.	.	.
18637	7720	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7720	2	1740	1740	CD
18637	7720	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7720	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7720	5	.	.	.
18637	7721	1	441	441	CD
18637	7721	2	.	.	.
18637	7722	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7722	2	1741	1741	CD
18637	7722	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7722	4	May	May	NNP
18637	7722	5	&	&	CC
18637	7722	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7722	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7722	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7722	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7722	10	New	New	NNP
18637	7722	11	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7722	12	,	,	,
18637	7722	13	178	178	CD
18637	7722	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7722	15	496	496	CD
18637	7722	16	,	,	,
18637	7722	17	502	502	CD
18637	7722	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7722	19	1900	1900	CD
18637	7722	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7722	21	.	.	.
18637	7723	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7723	2	1742	1742	CD
18637	7723	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7723	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7723	5	.	.	.
18637	7724	1	501	501	CD
18637	7724	2	;	;	:
18637	7724	3	Gulf	Gulf	NNP
18637	7724	4	Fisheries	Fisheries	NNPS
18637	7724	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7724	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7724	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7724	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7724	9	MacInerney	MacInerney	NNP
18637	7724	10	,	,	,
18637	7724	11	276	276	CD
18637	7724	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7724	13	124	124	CD
18637	7724	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7724	15	1928	1928	CD
18637	7724	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7724	17	;	;	:
18637	7724	18	McGoldrick	McGoldrick	NNP
18637	7724	19	_	_	NNP
18637	7724	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	7724	21	_	_	NNP
18637	7724	22	Gulf	Gulf	NNP
18637	7724	23	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	7724	24	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	7724	25	,	,	,
18637	7724	26	309	309	CD
18637	7724	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7724	28	414	414	CD
18637	7724	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7724	30	1940	1940	CD
18637	7724	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7724	32	.	.	.
18637	7725	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7725	2	1743	1743	CD
18637	7725	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7725	4	Low	Low	NNP
18637	7725	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7725	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7725	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7725	8	Austin	Austin	NNP
18637	7725	9	,	,	,
18637	7725	10	13	13	CD
18637	7725	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7725	12	.	.	.
18637	7726	1	29	29	CD
18637	7726	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7726	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	7726	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7726	5	;	;	:
18637	7726	6	May	May	NNP
18637	7726	7	&	&	CC
18637	7726	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7726	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7726	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7726	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7726	12	New	New	NNP
18637	7726	13	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7726	14	,	,	,
18637	7726	15	178	178	CD
18637	7726	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7726	17	496	496	CD
18637	7726	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7726	19	1900	1900	CD
18637	7726	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7726	21	.	.	.
18637	7727	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7727	2	1744	1744	CD
18637	7727	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7727	4	Hooven	Hooven	NNP
18637	7727	5	&	&	CC
18637	7727	6	Allison	Allison	NNP
18637	7727	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7727	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7727	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7727	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7727	11	Evatt	Evatt	NNP
18637	7727	12	,	,	,
18637	7727	13	324	324	CD
18637	7727	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7727	15	652	652	CD
18637	7727	16	,	,	,
18637	7727	17	667	667	CD
18637	7727	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7727	19	1945	1945	CD
18637	7727	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7727	21	.	.	.
18637	7728	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7728	2	1745	1745	CD
18637	7728	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7728	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7728	5	.	.	.
18637	7729	1	664	664	CD
18637	7729	2	.	.	.
18637	7730	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7730	2	1746	1746	CD
18637	7730	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7730	4	Canton	Canton	NNP
18637	7730	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	7730	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7730	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7730	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7730	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7730	10	Rogan	Rogan	NNP
18637	7730	11	,	,	,
18637	7730	12	340	340	CD
18637	7730	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7730	14	511	511	CD
18637	7730	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7730	16	1951	1951	CD
18637	7730	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7730	18	.	.	.
18637	7731	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7731	2	1747	1747	CD
18637	7731	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7731	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	7731	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7731	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7731	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7731	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	7731	9	,	,	,
18637	7731	10	12	12	CD
18637	7731	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7731	12	.	.	.
18637	7732	1	419	419	CD
18637	7732	2	,	,	,
18637	7732	3	447	447	CD
18637	7732	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7732	5	1827	1827	CD
18637	7732	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7732	7	.	.	.
18637	7733	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7733	2	1748	1748	CD
18637	7733	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7733	4	Anglo	anglo	JJ
18637	7733	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	7733	6	Chilean	Chilean	NNP
18637	7733	7	Nitrate	Nitrate	NNP
18637	7733	8	Sales	Sales	NNPS
18637	7733	9	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	7733	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7733	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	7733	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7733	13	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	7733	14	,	,	,
18637	7733	15	288	288	CD
18637	7733	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7733	17	218	218	CD
18637	7733	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7733	19	1933	1933	CD
18637	7733	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7733	21	.	.	.
18637	7734	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7734	2	1749	1749	CD
18637	7734	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7734	4	Low	Low	NNP
18637	7734	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7734	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7734	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7734	8	Austin	Austin	NNP
18637	7734	9	,	,	,
18637	7734	10	13	13	CD
18637	7734	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7734	12	.	.	.
18637	7735	1	29	29	CD
18637	7735	2	,	,	,
18637	7735	3	33	33	CD
18637	7735	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7735	5	1872	1872	CD
18637	7735	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7735	7	.	.	.
18637	7736	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7736	2	1750	1750	CD
18637	7736	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7736	4	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	7736	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7736	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7736	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7736	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7736	9	,	,	,
18637	7736	10	97	97	CD
18637	7736	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7736	12	566	566	CD
18637	7736	13	,	,	,
18637	7736	14	573	573	CD
18637	7736	15	,	,	,
18637	7736	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7736	17	1878	1878	CD
18637	7736	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7736	19	.	.	.
18637	7737	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7737	2	1751	1751	CD
18637	7737	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7737	4	Crew	Crew	NNP
18637	7737	5	Levick	Levick	NNP
18637	7737	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7737	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7737	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7737	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7737	10	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7737	11	,	,	,
18637	7737	12	245	245	CD
18637	7737	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7737	14	292	292	CD
18637	7737	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7737	16	1917	1917	CD
18637	7737	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7737	18	.	.	.
18637	7738	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7738	2	1752	1752	CD
18637	7738	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7738	4	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	7738	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7738	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7738	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7738	8	Board	Board	NNP
18637	7738	9	of	of	IN
18637	7738	10	Port	Port	NNP
18637	7738	11	Wardens	Wardens	NNP
18637	7738	12	,	,	,
18637	7738	13	12	12	CD
18637	7738	14	How	how	WRB
18637	7738	15	.	.	.
18637	7739	1	299	299	CD
18637	7739	2	,	,	,
18637	7739	3	313	313	CD
18637	7739	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7739	5	1851	1851	CD
18637	7739	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7739	7	.	.	.
18637	7740	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7740	2	1753	1753	CD
18637	7740	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7740	4	Waring	Waring	NNP
18637	7740	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7740	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7740	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7740	8	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	7740	9	,	,	,
18637	7740	10	8	8	CD
18637	7740	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7740	12	.	.	.
18637	7741	1	110	110	CD
18637	7741	2	,	,	,
18637	7741	3	122	122	CD
18637	7741	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7741	5	1869	1869	CD
18637	7741	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7741	7	.	.	.
18637	7742	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7742	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7742	3	also	also	RB
18637	7742	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7742	5	Pervear	Pervear	NNP
18637	7742	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7742	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7742	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7742	9	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	7742	10	,	,	,
18637	7742	11	5	5	CD
18637	7742	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7742	13	.	.	.
18637	7743	1	475	475	CD
18637	7743	2	,	,	,
18637	7743	3	478	478	CD
18637	7743	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7743	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	7743	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7743	7	;	;	:
18637	7743	8	Schollenberger	Schollenberger	NNP
18637	7743	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7743	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7743	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7743	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7743	13	,	,	,
18637	7743	14	171	171	CD
18637	7743	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7743	16	1	1	CD
18637	7743	17	,	,	,
18637	7743	18	24	24	CD
18637	7743	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7743	20	1898	1898	CD
18637	7743	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7743	22	.	.	.
18637	7744	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7744	2	1754	1754	CD
18637	7744	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7744	4	Gulf	Gulf	NNP
18637	7744	5	Fisheries	Fisheries	NNPS
18637	7744	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7744	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7744	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7744	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7744	10	MacInerney	MacInerney	NNP
18637	7744	11	,	,	,
18637	7744	12	276	276	CD
18637	7744	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7744	14	124	124	CD
18637	7744	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7744	16	1928	1928	CD
18637	7744	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7744	18	.	.	.
18637	7745	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7745	2	1755	1755	CD
18637	7745	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7745	4	Nathan	Nathan	NNP
18637	7745	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7745	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7745	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7745	8	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	7745	9	,	,	,
18637	7745	10	8	8	CD
18637	7745	11	How	how	WRB
18637	7745	12	.	.	.
18637	7746	1	73	73	CD
18637	7746	2	,	,	,
18637	7746	3	81	81	CD
18637	7746	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7746	5	1850	1850	CD
18637	7746	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7746	7	.	.	.
18637	7747	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7747	2	1756	1756	CD
18637	7747	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7747	4	Mager	Mager	NNP
18637	7747	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7747	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7747	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7747	8	Grima	Grima	NNP
18637	7747	9	,	,	,
18637	7747	10	8	8	CD
18637	7747	11	How	how	WRB
18637	7747	12	.	.	.
18637	7748	1	490	490	CD
18637	7748	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7748	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	7748	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7748	5	.	.	.
18637	7749	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7749	2	1757	1757	CD
18637	7749	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7749	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	7749	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7749	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7749	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7749	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	7749	9	,	,	,
18637	7749	10	12	12	CD
18637	7749	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7749	12	.	.	.
18637	7750	1	419	419	CD
18637	7750	2	,	,	,
18637	7750	3	441	441	CD
18637	7750	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7750	5	1827	1827	CD
18637	7750	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7750	7	;	;	:
18637	7750	8	Hooven	Hooven	NNP
18637	7750	9	&	&	CC
18637	7750	10	Allison	Allison	NNP
18637	7750	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7750	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7750	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	7750	14	_	_	NNP
18637	7750	15	Evatt	Evatt	NNP
18637	7750	16	,	,	,
18637	7750	17	324	324	CD
18637	7750	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7750	19	652	652	CD
18637	7750	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7750	21	1945	1945	CD
18637	7750	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7750	23	.	.	.
18637	7751	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7751	2	1758	1758	CD
18637	7751	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7751	4	New	New	NNP
18637	7751	5	York	York	NNP
18637	7751	6	ex	ex	NN
18637	7751	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	7751	8	.	.	.
18637	7752	1	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	7752	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7752	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7752	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7752	5	Wells	Wells	NNP
18637	7752	6	,	,	,
18637	7752	7	208	208	CD
18637	7752	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7752	9	14	14	CD
18637	7752	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7752	11	1908	1908	CD
18637	7752	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7752	13	.	.	.
18637	7753	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7753	2	1759	1759	CD
18637	7753	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7753	4	Selliger	Selliger	NNP
18637	7753	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7753	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7753	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7753	8	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	7753	9	,	,	,
18637	7753	10	213	213	CD
18637	7753	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7753	12	200	200	CD
18637	7753	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7753	14	1909	1909	CD
18637	7753	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7753	16	;	;	:
18637	7753	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7753	18	cf	cf	NNP
18637	7753	19	.	.	.
18637	7753	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7753	21	Almy	Almy	NNP
18637	7753	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7753	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	7753	24	_	_	NNP
18637	7753	25	California	California	NNP
18637	7753	26	,	,	,
18637	7753	27	24	24	CD
18637	7753	28	How	how	WRB
18637	7753	29	.	.	.
18637	7754	1	169	169	CD
18637	7754	2	,	,	,
18637	7754	3	174	174	CD
18637	7754	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7754	5	1861	1861	CD
18637	7754	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7754	7	.	.	.
18637	7755	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7755	2	1760	1760	CD
18637	7755	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7755	4	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	7755	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7755	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7755	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7755	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	7755	9	&	&	CC
18637	7755	10	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	7756	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7756	2	,	,	,
18637	7756	3	125	125	CD
18637	7756	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7756	5	465	465	CD
18637	7756	6	,	,	,
18637	7756	7	488	488	CD
18637	7756	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7756	9	1888	1888	CD
18637	7756	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7756	11	.	.	.
18637	7757	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7757	2	1761	1761	CD
18637	7757	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7757	4	107	107	CD
18637	7757	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7757	6	38	38	CD
18637	7757	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7757	8	1883	1883	CD
18637	7757	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7757	10	.	.	.
18637	7758	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7758	2	1762	1762	CD
18637	7758	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7758	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7758	5	.	.	.
18637	7759	1	55	55	CD
18637	7759	2	.	.	.
18637	7760	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7760	2	1763	1763	CD
18637	7760	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7760	4	Patapsco	Patapsco	NNP
18637	7760	5	Guano	Guano	NNP
18637	7760	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7760	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7760	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7760	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7760	10	North	North	NNP
18637	7760	11	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	7760	12	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	7760	13	.	.	.
18637	7761	1	of	of	IN
18637	7761	2	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	7761	3	,	,	,
18637	7761	4	171	171	CD
18637	7761	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7761	6	345	345	CD
18637	7761	7	,	,	,
18637	7761	8	301	301	CD
18637	7761	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7761	10	1898	1898	CD
18637	7761	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7761	12	.	.	.
18637	7762	1	For	for	IN
18637	7762	2	a	a	DT
18637	7762	3	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	7762	4	of	of	IN
18637	7762	5	the	the	DT
18637	7762	6	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	7762	7	on	on	IN
18637	7762	8	State	State	NNP
18637	7762	9	power	power	NN
18637	7762	10	to	to	TO
18637	7762	11	pass	pass	VB
18637	7762	12	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	7762	13	laws	law	NNS
18637	7762	14	resulting	result	VBG
18637	7762	15	from	from	IN
18637	7762	16	the	the	DT
18637	7762	17	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	7762	18	clause	clause	NNP
18637	7762	19	,	,	,
18637	7762	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7762	21	see	see	VBP
18637	7762	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7762	23	pp	pp	NNP
18637	7762	24	.	.	.
18637	7763	1	183	183	CD
18637	7763	2	,	,	,
18637	7763	3	237	237	CD
18637	7763	4	.	.	.
18637	7764	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7764	2	1764	1764	CD
18637	7764	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7764	4	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	7764	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7764	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7764	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7764	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	7764	9	&	&	CC
18637	7764	10	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	7765	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7765	2	,	,	,
18637	7765	3	125	125	CD
18637	7765	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7765	5	465	465	CD
18637	7765	6	,	,	,
18637	7765	7	488	488	CD
18637	7765	8	-	-	SYM
18637	7765	9	489	489	CD
18637	7765	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7765	11	1888	1888	CD
18637	7765	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7765	13	.	.	.
18637	7766	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7766	2	1765	1765	CD
18637	7766	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7766	4	Clyde	Clyde	NNP
18637	7766	5	Mallory	Mallory	NNP
18637	7766	6	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	7766	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7766	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7766	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7766	10	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	7766	11	ex	ex	NNP
18637	7766	12	rel	rel	NN
18637	7766	13	.	.	.
18637	7767	1	State	State	NNP
18637	7767	2	Docks	Docks	NNPS
18637	7767	3	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	7767	4	,	,	,
18637	7767	5	296	296	CD
18637	7767	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7767	7	261	261	CD
18637	7767	8	,	,	,
18637	7767	9	265	265	CD
18637	7767	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7767	11	1935	1935	CD
18637	7767	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7767	13	;	;	:
18637	7767	14	Cannon	Cannon	NNP
18637	7767	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7767	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	7767	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7767	18	New	New	NNP
18637	7767	19	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	7767	20	,	,	,
18637	7767	21	20	20	CD
18637	7767	22	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7767	23	.	.	.
18637	7768	1	577	577	CD
18637	7768	2	,	,	,
18637	7768	3	581	581	CD
18637	7768	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7768	5	1874	1874	CD
18637	7768	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7768	7	;	;	:
18637	7768	8	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	7768	9	,	,	,
18637	7768	10	P.	P.	NNP
18637	7768	11	&	&	CC
18637	7768	12	C.	C.	NNP
18637	7768	13	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	7768	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7768	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7768	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	7768	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7768	18	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	7768	19	,	,	,
18637	7768	20	99	99	CD
18637	7768	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7768	22	273	273	CD
18637	7768	23	,	,	,
18637	7768	24	283	283	CD
18637	7768	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7768	26	1879	1879	CD
18637	7768	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7768	28	.	.	.
18637	7769	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7769	2	1766	1766	CD
18637	7769	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7769	4	Keokuk	Keokuk	NNP
18637	7769	5	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	7769	6	Line	Line	NNP
18637	7769	7	Packet	Packet	NNP
18637	7769	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7769	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7769	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7769	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7769	12	Keokuk	Keokuk	NNP
18637	7769	13	,	,	,
18637	7769	14	95	95	CD
18637	7769	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7769	16	80	80	CD
18637	7769	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7769	18	1877	1877	CD
18637	7769	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7769	20	;	;	:
18637	7769	21	Parkersburg	Parkersburg	NNP
18637	7769	22	&	&	CC
18637	7769	23	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	7769	24	River	River	NNP
18637	7769	25	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	7769	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7769	27	_	_	NNP
18637	7769	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	7769	29	_	_	NNP
18637	7769	30	Parkersburg	Parkersburg	NNP
18637	7769	31	,	,	,
18637	7769	32	107	107	CD
18637	7769	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7769	34	691	691	CD
18637	7769	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7769	36	1883	1883	CD
18637	7769	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7769	38	;	;	:
18637	7769	39	Ouachita	Ouachita	NNP
18637	7769	40	Packet	Packet	NNP
18637	7769	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7769	42	_	_	NNP
18637	7769	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	7769	44	_	_	NNP
18637	7769	45	Aiken	Aiken	NNP
18637	7769	46	,	,	,
18637	7769	47	121	121	CD
18637	7769	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7769	49	444	444	CD
18637	7769	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7769	51	1887	1887	CD
18637	7769	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7769	53	.	.	.
18637	7770	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7770	2	1767	1767	CD
18637	7770	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7770	4	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	7770	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7770	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7770	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7770	8	Board	Board	NNP
18637	7770	9	of	of	IN
18637	7770	10	Port	Port	NNP
18637	7770	11	Wardens	Wardens	NNP
18637	7770	12	,	,	,
18637	7770	13	12	12	CD
18637	7770	14	How	how	WRB
18637	7770	15	.	.	.
18637	7771	1	299	299	CD
18637	7771	2	,	,	,
18637	7771	3	314	314	CD
18637	7771	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7771	5	1851	1851	CD
18637	7771	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7771	7	;	;	:
18637	7771	8	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	7771	9	parte	parte	NNP
18637	7771	10	McNiel	McNiel	NNP
18637	7771	11	,	,	,
18637	7771	12	13	13	CD
18637	7771	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7771	14	.	.	.
18637	7772	1	236	236	CD
18637	7772	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7772	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	7772	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7772	5	;	;	:
18637	7772	6	Inman	Inman	NNP
18637	7772	7	Steamship	Steamship	NNP
18637	7772	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7772	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7772	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7772	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7772	12	Tinker	Tinker	NNP
18637	7772	13	,	,	,
18637	7772	14	94	94	CD
18637	7772	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7772	16	238	238	CD
18637	7772	17	,	,	,
18637	7772	18	243	243	CD
18637	7772	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7772	20	1877	1877	CD
18637	7772	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7772	22	;	;	:
18637	7772	23	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	7772	24	Union	Union	NNP
18637	7772	25	Packet	Packet	NNP
18637	7772	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7772	27	_	_	NNP
18637	7772	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	7772	29	_	_	NNP
18637	7772	30	St.	St.	NNP
18637	7772	31	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	7772	32	,	,	,
18637	7772	33	100	100	CD
18637	7772	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7772	35	423	423	CD
18637	7772	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7772	37	1880	1880	CD
18637	7772	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7772	39	;	;	:
18637	7772	40	Vicksburg	Vicksburg	NNP
18637	7772	41	_	_	NNP
18637	7772	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	7772	43	_	_	NNP
18637	7772	44	Tobin	Tobin	NNP
18637	7772	45	,	,	,
18637	7772	46	100	100	CD
18637	7772	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7772	48	430	430	CD
18637	7772	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7772	50	1880	1880	CD
18637	7772	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7772	52	;	;	:
18637	7772	53	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	7772	54	,	,	,
18637	7772	55	P.B.S.	P.B.S.	NNP
18637	7773	1	&	&	CC
18637	7773	2	P.	P.	NNP
18637	7773	3	Packet	Packet	NNP
18637	7773	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7773	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7773	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7773	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7773	8	Catlettsburg	Catlettsburg	NNP
18637	7773	9	,	,	,
18637	7773	10	105	105	CD
18637	7773	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7773	12	559	559	CD
18637	7773	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7773	14	1882	1882	CD
18637	7773	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7773	16	.	.	.
18637	7774	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7774	2	1768	1768	CD
18637	7774	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7774	4	Huse	Huse	NNP
18637	7774	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7774	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7774	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7774	8	Glover	Glover	NNP
18637	7774	9	,	,	,
18637	7774	10	119	119	CD
18637	7774	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7774	12	543	543	CD
18637	7774	13	,	,	,
18637	7774	14	549	549	CD
18637	7774	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7774	16	1886	1886	CD
18637	7774	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7774	18	.	.	.
18637	7775	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7775	2	1769	1769	CD
18637	7775	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7775	4	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	7775	5	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	7775	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7775	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7775	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7775	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7775	10	Portwardens	Portwardens	NNP
18637	7775	11	,	,	,
18637	7775	12	6	6	CD
18637	7775	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7775	14	.	.	.
18637	7776	1	31	31	CD
18637	7776	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7776	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	7776	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7776	5	.	.	.
18637	7777	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7777	2	1770	1770	CD
18637	7777	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7777	4	Peete	Peete	NNP
18637	7777	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7777	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7777	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7777	8	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	7777	9	,	,	,
18637	7777	10	19	19	CD
18637	7777	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7777	12	.	.	.
18637	7778	1	581	581	CD
18637	7778	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7778	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	7778	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7778	5	.	.	.
18637	7779	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7779	2	1771	1771	CD
18637	7779	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7779	4	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	7779	5	's	's	POS
18637	7779	6	L.	L.	NNP
18637	7779	7	&	&	CC
18637	7779	8	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	7780	1	&	&	CC
18637	7780	2	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	7780	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7780	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7780	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	7780	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7780	7	Board	Board	NNP
18637	7780	8	of	of	IN
18637	7780	9	Health	Health	NNP
18637	7780	10	,	,	,
18637	7780	11	118	118	CD
18637	7780	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7780	13	455	455	CD
18637	7780	14	,	,	,
18637	7780	15	462	462	CD
18637	7780	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7780	17	1886	1886	CD
18637	7780	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7780	19	.	.	.
18637	7781	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7781	2	1772	1772	CD
18637	7781	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7781	4	Wiggins	Wiggins	NNP
18637	7781	5	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	7781	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7781	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7781	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	7781	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7781	10	East	East	NNP
18637	7781	11	St.	St.	NNP
18637	7781	12	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	7781	13	,	,	,
18637	7781	14	107	107	CD
18637	7781	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7781	16	365	365	CD
18637	7781	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7781	18	1883	1883	CD
18637	7781	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7781	20	.	.	.
18637	7782	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7782	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7782	3	also	also	RB
18637	7782	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7782	5	Gloucester	Gloucester	NNP
18637	7782	6	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	7782	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7782	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7782	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	7782	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7782	11	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7782	12	,	,	,
18637	7782	13	114	114	CD
18637	7782	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7782	15	196	196	CD
18637	7782	16	,	,	,
18637	7782	17	212	212	CD
18637	7782	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7782	19	1885	1885	CD
18637	7782	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7782	21	;	;	:
18637	7782	22	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	7782	23	&	&	CC
18637	7782	24	S.	S.	NNP
18637	7782	25	Mail	Mail	NNP
18637	7782	26	Steamship	Steamship	NNP
18637	7782	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7782	28	_	_	NNP
18637	7782	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	7782	30	_	_	NNP
18637	7782	31	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7782	32	,	,	,
18637	7782	33	122	122	CD
18637	7782	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7782	35	326	326	CD
18637	7782	36	,	,	,
18637	7782	37	338	338	CD
18637	7782	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7782	39	1887	1887	CD
18637	7782	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7782	41	;	;	:
18637	7782	42	Osborne	Osborne	NNP
18637	7782	43	_	_	NNP
18637	7782	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	7782	45	_	_	NNP
18637	7782	46	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	7782	47	,	,	,
18637	7782	48	16	16	CD
18637	7782	49	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7782	50	.	.	.
18637	7783	1	479	479	CD
18637	7783	2	,	,	,
18637	7783	3	481	481	CD
18637	7783	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7783	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	7783	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7783	7	.	.	.
18637	7784	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7784	2	1773	1773	CD
18637	7784	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7784	4	Cox	Cox	NNP
18637	7784	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7784	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7784	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7784	8	Lott	Lott	NNP
18637	7784	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7784	10	State	State	NNP
18637	7784	11	Tonnage	Tonnage	NNP
18637	7784	12	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	7784	13	Cases	case	NNS
18637	7784	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7784	15	,	,	,
18637	7784	16	12	12	CD
18637	7784	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7784	18	.	.	.
18637	7785	1	204	204	CD
18637	7785	2	,	,	,
18637	7785	3	217	217	CD
18637	7785	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7785	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	7785	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7785	7	.	.	.
18637	7786	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7786	2	1774	1774	CD
18637	7786	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7786	4	Luther	Luther	NNP
18637	7786	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7786	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7786	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7786	8	Borden	Borden	NNP
18637	7786	9	,	,	,
18637	7786	10	7	7	CD
18637	7786	11	How	how	WRB
18637	7786	12	.	.	.
18637	7787	1	1	1	CD
18637	7787	2	,	,	,
18637	7787	3	45	45	CD
18637	7787	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7787	5	1849	1849	CD
18637	7787	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7787	7	.	.	.
18637	7788	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7788	2	1775	1775	CD
18637	7788	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7788	4	Presser	Presser	NNP
18637	7788	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7788	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7788	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7788	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	7788	9	,	,	,
18637	7788	10	116	116	CD
18637	7788	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7788	12	252	252	CD
18637	7788	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7788	14	1886	1886	CD
18637	7788	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7788	16	.	.	.
18637	7789	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7789	2	1776	1776	CD
18637	7789	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7789	4	Poole	Poole	NNP
18637	7789	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7789	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7789	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7789	8	Fleeger	Fleeger	NNP
18637	7789	9	,	,	,
18637	7789	10	11	11	CD
18637	7789	11	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	7789	12	185	185	CD
18637	7789	13	,	,	,
18637	7789	14	209	209	CD
18637	7789	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7789	16	1837	1837	CD
18637	7789	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7789	18	.	.	.
18637	7790	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7790	2	1777	1777	CD
18637	7790	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7790	4	Hinderlider	Hinderlider	NNP
18637	7790	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7790	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7790	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7790	8	La	La	NNP
18637	7790	9	Plata	Plata	NNP
18637	7790	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7790	11	,	,	,
18637	7790	12	304	304	CD
18637	7790	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7790	14	92	92	CD
18637	7790	15	,	,	,
18637	7790	16	104	104	CD
18637	7790	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7790	18	1938	1938	CD
18637	7790	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7790	20	.	.	.
18637	7791	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7791	2	1778	1778	CD
18637	7791	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7791	4	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	7791	5	and	and	CC
18637	7791	6	Landis	Landis	NNP
18637	7791	7	,	,	,
18637	7791	8	The	the	DT
18637	7791	9	Compact	Compact	NNP
18637	7791	10	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	7791	11	of	of	IN
18637	7791	12	the	the	DT
18637	7791	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7791	14	--	--	:
18637	7791	15	A	a	DT
18637	7791	16	Study	Study	NNP
18637	7791	17	in	in	IN
18637	7791	18	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	7791	19	Adjustments	Adjustments	NNPS
18637	7791	20	,	,	,
18637	7791	21	34	34	CD
18637	7791	22	Yale	Yale	NNP
18637	7791	23	Law	Law	NNP
18637	7791	24	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	7791	25	,	,	,
18637	7791	26	685	685	CD
18637	7791	27	,	,	,
18637	7791	28	691	691	CD
18637	7791	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7791	30	1925	1925	CD
18637	7791	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7791	32	.	.	.
18637	7792	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7792	2	1779	1779	CD
18637	7792	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7792	4	Article	Article	NNP
18637	7792	5	IX	IX	NNP
18637	7792	6	.	.	.
18637	7793	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7793	2	1780	1780	CD
18637	7793	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7793	4	Article	Article	NNP
18637	7793	5	VI	VI	NNP
18637	7793	6	.	.	.
18637	7794	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7794	2	1781	1781	CD
18637	7794	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7794	4	14	14	CD
18637	7794	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7794	6	.	.	.
18637	7795	1	540	540	CD
18637	7795	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7795	3	1840	1840	CD
18637	7795	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7795	5	.	.	.
18637	7796	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7796	2	1782	1782	CD
18637	7796	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7796	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	7796	5	.	.	.
18637	7797	1	570	570	CD
18637	7797	2	,	,	,
18637	7797	3	571	571	CD
18637	7797	4	,	,	,
18637	7797	5	572	572	CD
18637	7797	6	.	.	.
18637	7798	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7798	2	1783	1783	CD
18637	7798	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7798	4	148	148	CD
18637	7798	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7798	6	503	503	CD
18637	7798	7	,	,	,
18637	7798	8	518	518	CD
18637	7798	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7798	10	1893	1893	CD
18637	7798	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7798	12	.	.	.
18637	7799	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7799	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7799	3	also	also	RB
18637	7799	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7799	5	Stearns	Stearns	NNP
18637	7799	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7799	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7799	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7799	9	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	7799	10	,	,	,
18637	7799	11	179	179	CD
18637	7799	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7799	13	223	223	CD
18637	7799	14	,	,	,
18637	7799	15	244	244	CD
18637	7799	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7799	17	1900	1900	CD
18637	7799	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7799	19	;	;	:
18637	7799	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7799	21	also	also	RB
18637	7799	22	_	_	NNP
18637	7799	23	reference	reference	NN
18637	7799	24	in	in	IN
18637	7799	25	next	next	JJ
18637	7799	26	note	note	NN
18637	7799	27	,	,	,
18637	7799	28	at	at	IN
18637	7799	29	pp	pp	NNP
18637	7799	30	.	.	.
18637	7800	1	761	761	CD
18637	7800	2	-	-	SYM
18637	7800	3	762	762	CD
18637	7800	4	.	.	.
18637	7801	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7801	2	1784	1784	CD
18637	7801	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7801	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7801	5	See	See	NNP
18637	7801	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7801	7	Leslie	Leslie	NNP
18637	7801	8	W.	W.	NNP
18637	7801	9	Dunbar	Dunbar	NNP
18637	7801	10	,	,	,
18637	7801	11	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	7801	12	Compacts	Compacts	NNPS
18637	7801	13	and	and	CC
18637	7801	14	Congressional	Congressional	NNP
18637	7801	15	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	7801	16	,	,	,
18637	7801	17	36	36	CD
18637	7801	18	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7801	19	Law	Law	NNP
18637	7801	20	Review	Review	NNP
18637	7801	21	,	,	,
18637	7801	22	753	753	CD
18637	7801	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7801	24	October	October	NNP
18637	7801	25	,	,	,
18637	7801	26	1950	1950	CD
18637	7801	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7801	28	.	.	.
18637	7802	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7802	2	1785	1785	CD
18637	7802	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7802	4	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	7802	5	and	and	CC
18637	7802	6	Landis	Landis	NNP
18637	7802	7	,	,	,
18637	7802	8	The	the	DT
18637	7802	9	Compact	Compact	NNP
18637	7802	10	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	7802	11	of	of	IN
18637	7802	12	the	the	DT
18637	7802	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7802	14	--	--	:
18637	7802	15	A	a	DT
18637	7802	16	Study	Study	NNP
18637	7802	17	in	in	IN
18637	7802	18	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	7802	19	Adjustments	Adjustments	NNPS
18637	7802	20	,	,	,
18637	7802	21	34	34	CD
18637	7802	22	Yale	Yale	NNP
18637	7802	23	Law	Law	NNP
18637	7802	24	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	7802	25	,	,	,
18637	7802	26	685	685	CD
18637	7802	27	,	,	,
18637	7802	28	735	735	CD
18637	7802	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7802	30	1925	1925	CD
18637	7802	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7802	32	;	;	:
18637	7802	33	Frederick	Frederick	NNP
18637	7802	34	L.	L.	NNP
18637	7802	35	Zimmerman	Zimmerman	NNP
18637	7802	36	and	and	CC
18637	7802	37	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	7802	38	Wendell	Wendell	NNP
18637	7802	39	,	,	,
18637	7802	40	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	7802	41	Compacts	compact	NNS
18637	7802	42	Since	since	IN
18637	7802	43	1925	1925	CD
18637	7802	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7802	45	1951	1951	CD
18637	7802	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7802	47	,	,	,
18637	7802	48	8	8	CD
18637	7802	49	Book	Book	NNP
18637	7802	50	of	of	IN
18637	7802	51	States	States	NNP
18637	7802	52	,	,	,
18637	7802	53	26	26	CD
18637	7802	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7802	55	1950	1950	CD
18637	7802	56	-	-	SYM
18637	7802	57	1951	1951	CD
18637	7802	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7802	59	.	.	.
18637	7803	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7803	2	1786	1786	CD
18637	7803	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7803	4	48	48	CD
18637	7803	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	7803	6	.	.	.
18637	7804	1	909	909	CD
18637	7804	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7804	3	1934	1934	CD
18637	7804	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7804	5	.	.	.
18637	7805	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7805	2	1787	1787	CD
18637	7805	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7805	4	8	8	CD
18637	7805	5	Book	Book	NNP
18637	7805	6	of	of	IN
18637	7805	7	the	the	DT
18637	7805	8	States	States	NNPS
18637	7805	9	,	,	,
18637	7805	10	45	45	CD
18637	7805	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7805	12	1950	1950	CD
18637	7805	13	-	-	SYM
18637	7805	14	1951	1951	CD
18637	7805	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7805	16	.	.	.
18637	7806	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7806	2	1788	1788	CD
18637	7806	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7806	4	7	7	CD
18637	7806	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	7807	1	§	§	NNP
18637	7807	2	515	515	CD
18637	7807	3	;	;	:
18637	7807	4	15	15	CD
18637	7807	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	7808	1	§	§	NNP
18637	7808	2	717j	717j	NNPS
18637	7808	3	;	;	:
18637	7808	4	16	16	CD
18637	7808	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	7809	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	7809	2	552	552	CD
18637	7809	3	,	,	,
18637	7809	4	667a	667a	NNPS
18637	7809	5	;	;	:
18637	7809	6	33	33	CD
18637	7809	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	7810	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	7810	2	11	11	CD
18637	7810	3	,	,	,
18637	7810	4	567	567	CD
18637	7810	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	7810	6	567b	567b	CD
18637	7810	7	.	.	.
18637	7811	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7811	2	1789	1789	CD
18637	7811	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7811	4	Green	Green	NNP
18637	7811	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7811	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7811	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7811	8	Biddle	Biddle	NNP
18637	7811	9	,	,	,
18637	7811	10	8	8	CD
18637	7811	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7811	12	.	.	.
18637	7812	1	1	1	CD
18637	7812	2	,	,	,
18637	7812	3	85	85	CD
18637	7812	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7812	5	1823	1823	CD
18637	7812	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7812	7	.	.	.
18637	7813	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7813	2	1790	1790	CD
18637	7813	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7813	4	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7813	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7813	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7813	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7813	8	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	7813	9	,	,	,
18637	7813	10	148	148	CD
18637	7813	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7813	12	503	503	CD
18637	7813	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7813	14	1893	1893	CD
18637	7813	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7813	16	.	.	.
18637	7814	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7814	2	1791	1791	CD
18637	7814	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7814	4	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7814	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7814	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7814	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7814	8	West	West	NNP
18637	7814	9	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7814	10	,	,	,
18637	7814	11	11	11	CD
18637	7814	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	7814	13	.	.	.
18637	7815	1	39	39	CD
18637	7815	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7815	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	7815	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7815	5	.	.	.
18637	7816	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7816	2	1792	1792	CD
18637	7816	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7816	4	Wharton	Wharton	NNP
18637	7816	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7816	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7816	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7816	8	Wise	Wise	NNP
18637	7816	9	,	,	,
18637	7816	10	153	153	CD
18637	7816	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7816	12	155	155	CD
18637	7816	13	,	,	,
18637	7816	14	173	173	CD
18637	7816	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7816	16	1894	1894	CD
18637	7816	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7816	18	.	.	.
18637	7817	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7817	2	1793	1793	CD
18637	7817	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7817	4	James	James	NNP
18637	7817	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7817	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7817	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7817	8	Dravo	Dravo	NNP
18637	7817	9	Contracting	Contracting	NNP
18637	7817	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7817	11	,	,	,
18637	7817	12	302	302	CD
18637	7817	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7817	14	134	134	CD
18637	7817	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7817	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	7817	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7817	18	.	.	.
18637	7818	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7818	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7818	3	also	also	RB
18637	7818	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7818	5	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	7818	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7818	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7818	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7818	9	California	California	NNP
18637	7818	10	,	,	,
18637	7818	11	292	292	CD
18637	7818	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7818	13	341	341	CD
18637	7818	14	,	,	,
18637	7818	15	315	315	CD
18637	7818	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7818	17	1934	1934	CD
18637	7818	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7818	19	.	.	.
18637	7819	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7819	2	1794	1794	CD
18637	7819	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7819	4	332	332	CD
18637	7819	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7819	6	631	631	CD
18637	7819	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7819	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	7819	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7819	10	.	.	.
18637	7820	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7820	2	1795	1795	CD
18637	7820	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7820	4	On	on	IN
18637	7820	5	the	the	DT
18637	7820	6	activities	activity	NNS
18637	7820	7	of	of	IN
18637	7820	8	the	the	DT
18637	7820	9	Board	Board	NNP
18637	7820	10	,	,	,
18637	7820	11	in	in	IN
18637	7820	12	which	which	WDT
18637	7820	13	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	7820	14	of	of	IN
18637	7820	15	both	both	DT
18637	7820	16	races	race	NNS
18637	7820	17	participate	participate	VBP
18637	7820	18	and	and	CC
18637	7820	19	from	from	IN
18637	7820	20	which	which	WDT
18637	7820	21	both	both	DT
18637	7820	22	races	race	NNS
18637	7820	23	have	have	VBP
18637	7820	24	benefited	benefit	VBN
18637	7820	25	,	,	,
18637	7820	26	_	_	NNP
18637	7820	27	see	see	VBP
18637	7820	28	_	_	NNP
18637	7820	29	Remarks	Remarks	NNPS
18637	7820	30	of	of	IN
18637	7820	31	Hon	Hon	NNP
18637	7820	32	.	.	.
18637	7821	1	Spessard	Spessard	NNP
18637	7821	2	L.	L.	NNP
18637	7821	3	Holland	Holland	NNP
18637	7821	4	of	of	IN
18637	7821	5	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	7821	6	.	.	.
18637	7822	1	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	7822	2	.	.	.
18637	7823	1	Rec	Rec	NNP
18637	7823	2	.	.	NNP
18637	7823	3	,	,	,
18637	7823	4	81st	81st	NNP
18637	7823	5	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	7823	6	.	.	NNP
18637	7823	7	,	,	,
18637	7823	8	2d	2d	NNP
18637	7823	9	sess	sess	NN
18637	7823	10	.	.	.
18637	7823	11	,	,	,
18637	7823	12	v.	v.	CC
18637	7823	13	96	96	CD
18637	7823	14	,	,	,
18637	7823	15	p.	p.	NN
18637	7823	16	465	465	CD
18637	7823	17	-	-	SYM
18637	7823	18	470	470	CD
18637	7823	19	.	.	.
18637	7824	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7824	2	1796	1796	CD
18637	7824	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7824	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7824	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7824	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7824	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7824	8	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	7824	9	&	&	CC
18637	7824	10	Belmont	Belmont	NNP
18637	7824	11	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	7824	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7824	13	,	,	,
18637	7824	14	18	18	CD
18637	7824	15	How	how	WRB
18637	7824	16	.	.	.
18637	7825	1	421	421	CD
18637	7825	2	,	,	,
18637	7825	3	433	433	CD
18637	7825	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7825	5	1856	1856	CD
18637	7825	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7825	7	.	.	.
18637	7826	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7826	2	1797	1797	CD
18637	7826	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7826	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	7826	5	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	7826	6	&	&	CC
18637	7826	7	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	7827	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7827	2	_	_	NNP
18637	7827	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	7827	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7827	5	James	James	NNP
18637	7827	6	,	,	,
18637	7827	7	161	161	CD
18637	7827	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7827	9	545	545	CD
18637	7827	10	,	,	,
18637	7827	11	562	562	CD
18637	7827	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7827	13	1896	1896	CD
18637	7827	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7827	15	.	.	.
18637	7828	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7828	2	1798	1798	CD
18637	7828	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7828	4	Poole	Poole	NNP
18637	7828	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7828	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7828	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7828	8	Fleeger	Fleeger	NNP
18637	7828	9	,	,	,
18637	7828	10	11	11	CD
18637	7828	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7828	12	.	.	.
18637	7829	1	185	185	CD
18637	7829	2	,	,	,
18637	7829	3	209	209	CD
18637	7829	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7829	5	1837	1837	CD
18637	7829	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7829	7	;	;	:
18637	7829	8	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	7829	9	Island	Island	NNP
18637	7829	10	_	_	NNP
18637	7829	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	7829	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7829	13	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	7829	14	,	,	,
18637	7829	15	12	12	CD
18637	7829	16	Pet	pet	NN
18637	7829	17	.	.	.
18637	7830	1	657	657	CD
18637	7830	2	,	,	,
18637	7830	3	725	725	CD
18637	7830	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7830	5	1838	1838	CD
18637	7830	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7830	7	.	.	.
18637	7831	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7831	2	1799	1799	CD
18637	7831	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7831	4	Hinderlider	Hinderlider	NNP
18637	7831	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7831	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7831	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7831	8	La	La	NNP
18637	7831	9	Plata	Plata	NNP
18637	7831	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7831	11	,	,	,
18637	7831	12	304	304	CD
18637	7831	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7831	14	92	92	CD
18637	7831	15	,	,	,
18637	7831	16	104	104	CD
18637	7831	17	,	,	,
18637	7831	18	106	106	CD
18637	7831	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7831	20	1938	1938	CD
18637	7831	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7831	22	.	.	.
18637	7832	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7832	2	1800	1800	CD
18637	7832	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7832	4	Green	Green	NNP
18637	7832	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7832	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7832	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7832	8	Biddle	Biddle	NNP
18637	7832	9	,	,	,
18637	7832	10	8	8	CD
18637	7832	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	7832	12	.	.	.
18637	7833	1	1	1	CD
18637	7833	2	,	,	,
18637	7833	3	13	13	CD
18637	7833	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7833	5	1823	1823	CD
18637	7833	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7833	7	;	;	:
18637	7833	8	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7833	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7833	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7833	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7833	12	West	West	NNP
18637	7833	13	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7833	14	,	,	,
18637	7833	15	246	246	CD
18637	7833	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7833	17	565	565	CD
18637	7833	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7833	19	1918	1918	CD
18637	7833	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7833	21	.	.	.
18637	7834	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7834	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7834	3	also	also	RB
18637	7834	4	_	_	NNP
18637	7834	5	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	7834	6	_	_	NNP
18637	7834	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	7834	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7834	9	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	7834	10	&	&	CC
18637	7834	11	Belmont	Belmont	NNP
18637	7834	12	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	7834	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	7834	14	,	,	,
18637	7834	15	13	13	CD
18637	7834	16	How	how	WRB
18637	7834	17	.	.	.
18637	7835	1	518	518	CD
18637	7835	2	,	,	,
18637	7835	3	566	566	CD
18637	7835	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7835	5	1852	1852	CD
18637	7835	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7835	7	;	;	:
18637	7835	8	Olin	Olin	NNP
18637	7835	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7835	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	7835	11	_	_	NNP
18637	7835	12	Kitzmiller	Kitzmiller	NNP
18637	7835	13	,	,	,
18637	7835	14	259	259	CD
18637	7835	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7835	16	260	260	CD
18637	7835	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7835	18	1922	1922	CD
18637	7835	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7835	20	.	.	.
18637	7836	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7836	2	1801	1801	CD
18637	7836	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7836	4	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7836	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7836	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7836	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7836	8	West	West	NNP
18637	7836	9	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7836	10	,	,	,
18637	7836	11	246	246	CD
18637	7836	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7836	13	565	565	CD
18637	7836	14	,	,	,
18637	7836	15	601	601	CD
18637	7836	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7836	17	1918	1918	CD
18637	7836	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7836	19	.	.	.
18637	7837	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7837	2	1802	1802	CD
18637	7837	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7837	4	Dyer	Dyer	NNP
18637	7837	5	_	_	NNP
18637	7837	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	7837	7	_	_	NNP
18637	7837	8	Sims	Sims	NNP
18637	7837	9	,	,	,
18637	7837	10	341	341	CD
18637	7837	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	7837	12	22	22	CD
18637	7837	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7837	14	1951	1951	CD
18637	7837	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7837	16	.	.	.
18637	7838	1	The	the	DT
18637	7838	2	case	case	NN
18637	7838	3	stemmed	stem	VBD
18637	7838	4	from	from	IN
18637	7838	5	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	7838	6	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	7838	7	brought	bring	VBN
18637	7838	8	to	to	TO
18637	7838	9	compel	compel	VB
18637	7838	10	the	the	DT
18637	7838	11	auditor	auditor	NN
18637	7838	12	of	of	IN
18637	7838	13	West	West	NNP
18637	7838	14	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7838	15	to	to	TO
18637	7838	16	pay	pay	VB
18637	7838	17	out	out	RP
18637	7838	18	money	money	NN
18637	7838	19	to	to	IN
18637	7838	20	a	a	DT
18637	7838	21	commission	commission	NN
18637	7838	22	which	which	WDT
18637	7838	23	had	have	VBD
18637	7838	24	been	be	VBN
18637	7838	25	created	create	VBN
18637	7838	26	by	by	IN
18637	7838	27	a	a	DT
18637	7838	28	compact	compact	NN
18637	7838	29	between	between	IN
18637	7838	30	West	West	NNP
18637	7838	31	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7838	32	and	and	CC
18637	7838	33	other	other	JJ
18637	7838	34	States	States	NNPS
18637	7838	35	to	to	TO
18637	7838	36	control	control	VB
18637	7838	37	pollution	pollution	NN
18637	7838	38	of	of	IN
18637	7838	39	the	the	DT
18637	7838	40	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	7838	41	River	River	NNP
18637	7838	42	.	.	.
18637	7839	1	The	the	DT
18637	7839	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	7839	3	of	of	IN
18637	7839	4	the	the	DT
18637	7839	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	7839	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7839	7	of	of	IN
18637	7839	8	Appeals	Appeals	NNP
18637	7839	9	of	of	IN
18637	7839	10	West	West	NNP
18637	7839	11	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7839	12	denying	deny	VBG
18637	7839	13	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	7839	14	was	be	VBD
18637	7839	15	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	7839	16	by	by	IN
18637	7839	17	the	the	DT
18637	7839	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	7839	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7839	20	,	,	,
18637	7839	21	and	and	CC
18637	7839	22	the	the	DT
18637	7839	23	case	case	NN
18637	7839	24	remanded	remand	VBD
18637	7839	25	.	.	.
18637	7840	1	The	the	DT
18637	7840	2	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	7840	3	of	of	IN
18637	7840	4	the	the	DT
18637	7840	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7840	6	,	,	,
18637	7840	7	by	by	IN
18637	7840	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7840	9	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	7840	10	,	,	,
18637	7840	11	reviews	review	NNS
18637	7840	12	and	and	CC
18637	7840	13	revises	revise	VBZ
18637	7840	14	the	the	DT
18637	7840	15	West	West	NNP
18637	7840	16	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	7840	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7840	18	's	's	POS
18637	7840	19	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	7840	20	of	of	IN
18637	7840	21	the	the	DT
18637	7840	22	State	State	NNP
18637	7840	23	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	7840	24	,	,	,
18637	7840	25	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	7840	26	opening	open	VBG
18637	7840	27	up	up	RP
18637	7840	28	,	,	,
18637	7840	29	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	7840	30	at	at	IN
18637	7840	31	least	least	JJS
18637	7840	32	,	,	,
18637	7840	33	a	a	DT
18637	7840	34	new	new	JJ
18637	7840	35	field	field	NN
18637	7840	36	of	of	IN
18637	7840	37	power	power	NN
18637	7840	38	for	for	IN
18637	7840	39	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	7840	40	review	review	NN
18637	7840	41	.	.	.
18637	7841	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7841	2	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	7841	3	,	,	,
18637	7841	4	challenging	challenge	VBG
18637	7841	5	this	this	DT
18637	7841	6	extension	extension	NN
18637	7841	7	of	of	IN
18637	7841	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	7841	9	review	review	NN
18637	7841	10	,	,	,
18637	7841	11	thought	think	VBD
18637	7841	12	the	the	DT
18637	7841	13	issue	issue	NN
18637	7841	14	determined	determine	VBN
18637	7841	15	by	by	IN
18637	7841	16	the	the	DT
18637	7841	17	Supremacy	Supremacy	NNP
18637	7841	18	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	7841	19	.	.	.
18637	7842	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7842	2	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	7842	3	urged	urge	VBD
18637	7842	4	that	that	IN
18637	7842	5	the	the	DT
18637	7842	6	compact	compact	JJ
18637	7842	7	power	power	NN
18637	7842	8	was	be	VBD
18637	7842	9	"	"	``
18637	7842	10	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	7842	11	in	in	IN
18637	7842	12	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	7842	13	"	"	''
18637	7842	14	and	and	CC
18637	7842	15	hence	hence	RB
18637	7842	16	was	be	VBD
18637	7842	17	limited	limit	VBN
18637	7842	18	only	only	RB
18637	7842	19	by	by	IN
18637	7842	20	the	the	DT
18637	7842	21	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	7842	22	of	of	IN
18637	7842	23	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	7842	24	consent	consent	NN
18637	7842	25	.	.	.
18637	7843	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7843	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	7843	3	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	7843	4	in	in	IN
18637	7843	5	the	the	DT
18637	7843	6	result	result	NN
18637	7843	7	without	without	IN
18637	7843	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	7843	9	.	.	.
18637	7844	1	ARTICLE	ARTICLE	NNP
18637	7844	2	II	II	NNP
18637	7844	3	EXECUTIVE	executive	NN
18637	7844	4	DEPARTMENT	DEPARTMENT	NNP
18637	7844	5	Section	Section	NNP
18637	7844	6	1	1	CD
18637	7844	7	.	.	.
18637	7845	1	The	the	DT
18637	7845	2	President	President	NNP
18637	7845	3	:	:	:
18637	7845	4	Page	Page	NNP
18637	7845	5	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	7845	6	1	1	CD
18637	7845	7	.	.	.
18637	7846	1	Powers	power	NNS
18637	7846	2	and	and	CC
18637	7846	3	term	term	NN
18637	7846	4	of	of	IN
18637	7846	5	the	the	DT
18637	7846	6	President	President	NNP
18637	7846	7	377	377	CD
18637	7846	8	Nature	Nature	NNP
18637	7846	9	and	and	CC
18637	7846	10	scope	scope	NN
18637	7846	11	of	of	IN
18637	7846	12	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7846	13	power	power	NN
18637	7846	14	377	377	CD
18637	7846	15	Contemporary	Contemporary	NNP
18637	7846	16	source	source	NN
18637	7846	17	of	of	IN
18637	7846	18	the	the	DT
18637	7846	19	Presidency	Presidency	NNP
18637	7846	20	377	377	CD
18637	7846	21	Presidency	Presidency	NNP
18637	7846	22	in	in	IN
18637	7846	23	the	the	DT
18637	7846	24	federal	federal	JJ
18637	7846	25	convention	convention	NN
18637	7846	26	378	378	CD
18637	7846	27	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	7846	28	power	power	NN
18637	7846	29	;	;	:
18637	7846	30	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	7846	31	's	's	POS
18637	7846	32	contribution	contribution	NN
18637	7846	33	378	378	CD
18637	7846	34	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	7846	35	case	case	NN
18637	7846	36	379	379	CD
18637	7846	37	Curtiss	Curtiss	NNP
18637	7846	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	7846	39	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	7846	40	case	case	NN
18637	7846	41	380	380	CD
18637	7846	42	Theory	theory	NN
18637	7846	43	of	of	IN
18637	7846	44	the	the	DT
18637	7846	45	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7846	46	office	office	NN
18637	7846	47	380	380	CD
18637	7846	48	Term	term	NN
18637	7846	49	of	of	IN
18637	7846	50	four	four	CD
18637	7846	51	years	year	NNS
18637	7846	52	382	382	CD
18637	7846	53	Anti	anti	JJ
18637	7846	54	-	-	JJ
18637	7846	55	third	third	JJ
18637	7846	56	term	term	NN
18637	7846	57	tradition	tradition	NN
18637	7846	58	382	382	CD
18637	7846	59	Clauses	clause	NNS
18637	7846	60	2	2	CD
18637	7846	61	,	,	,
18637	7846	62	3	3	CD
18637	7846	63	,	,	,
18637	7846	64	4	4	CD
18637	7846	65	,	,	,
18637	7846	66	5	5	CD
18637	7846	67	,	,	,
18637	7846	68	6	6	CD
18637	7846	69	,	,	,
18637	7846	70	7	7	CD
18637	7846	71	,	,	,
18637	7846	72	and	and	CC
18637	7846	73	8	8	CD
18637	7846	74	.	.	.
18637	7847	1	Election	election	NN
18637	7847	2	,	,	,
18637	7847	3	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	7847	4	,	,	,
18637	7847	5	succession	succession	NN
18637	7847	6	,	,	,
18637	7847	7	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	7847	8	,	,	,
18637	7847	9	and	and	CC
18637	7847	10	oath	oath	NN
18637	7847	11	of	of	IN
18637	7847	12	the	the	DT
18637	7847	13	President	President	NNP
18637	7847	14	383	383	CD
18637	7847	15	Maintenance	Maintenance	NNP
18637	7847	16	of	of	IN
18637	7847	17	the	the	DT
18637	7847	18	office	office	NN
18637	7847	19	of	of	IN
18637	7847	20	President	President	NNP
18637	7847	21	384	384	CD
18637	7847	22	"	"	``
18637	7847	23	Electoral	Electoral	NNP
18637	7847	24	college	college	NN
18637	7847	25	"	"	''
18637	7847	26	384	384	CD
18637	7847	27	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	7847	28	status	status	NN
18637	7847	29	of	of	IN
18637	7847	30	electors	elector	NNS
18637	7847	31	385	385	CD
18637	7847	32	"	"	``
18637	7847	33	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	7847	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	7847	35	born	bear	VBN
18637	7847	36	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	7847	37	"	"	``
18637	7847	38	386	386	CD
18637	7847	39	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7847	40	succession	succession	NN
18637	7847	41	387	387	CD
18637	7847	42	Act	Act	NNP
18637	7847	43	of	of	IN
18637	7847	44	1792	1792	CD
18637	7847	45	387	387	CD
18637	7847	46	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	7847	47	of	of	IN
18637	7847	48	1886	1886	CD
18637	7847	49	and	and	CC
18637	7847	50	1947	1947	CD
18637	7847	51	388	388	CD
18637	7847	52	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	7847	53	and	and	CC
18637	7847	54	emoluments	emolument	VBZ
18637	7847	55	388	388	CD
18637	7847	56	Oath	Oath	NNP
18637	7847	57	of	of	IN
18637	7847	58	office	office	NN
18637	7847	59	388	388	CD
18637	7847	60	Effect	Effect	NNP
18637	7847	61	of	of	IN
18637	7847	62	the	the	DT
18637	7847	63	oath	oath	NN
18637	7847	64	389	389	CD
18637	7847	65	Section	section	NN
18637	7847	66	2	2	CD
18637	7847	67	.	.	.
18637	7848	1	Powers	power	NNS
18637	7848	2	and	and	CC
18637	7848	3	duties	duty	NNS
18637	7848	4	of	of	IN
18637	7848	5	the	the	DT
18637	7848	6	President	President	NNP
18637	7848	7	389	389	CD
18637	7848	8	Clause	clause	NN
18637	7848	9	1	1	CD
18637	7848	10	.	.	.
18637	7849	1	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	7849	2	in	in	IN
18637	7849	3	chiefship	chiefship	NN
18637	7849	4	;	;	,
18637	7849	5	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	7849	6	from	from	IN
18637	7849	7	heads	head	NNS
18637	7849	8	of	of	IN
18637	7849	9	departments	department	NNS
18637	7849	10	;	;	:
18637	7849	11	pardons	pardon	NNS
18637	7849	12	389	389	CD
18637	7849	13	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	7849	14	in	in	IN
18637	7849	15	chiefship	chiefship	NN
18637	7849	16	389	389	CD
18637	7849	17	Historical	historical	JJ
18637	7849	18	389	389	CD
18637	7849	19	Prize	Prize	NNP
18637	7849	20	cases	case	NNS
18637	7849	21	390	390	CD
18637	7849	22	Impact	impact	NN
18637	7849	23	of	of	IN
18637	7849	24	the	the	DT
18637	7849	25	Prize	Prize	NNP
18637	7849	26	cases	case	NNS
18637	7849	27	on	on	IN
18637	7849	28	World	World	NNP
18637	7849	29	Wars	Wars	NNPS
18637	7849	30	I	I	NNP
18637	7849	31	and	and	CC
18637	7849	32	II	II	NNP
18637	7849	33	391	391	CD
18637	7849	34	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7849	35	theory	theory	NN
18637	7849	36	of	of	IN
18637	7849	37	the	the	DT
18637	7849	38	commander	commander	NN
18637	7849	39	in	in	IN
18637	7849	40	chiefship	chiefship	NN
18637	7849	41	in	in	IN
18637	7849	42	World	World	NNP
18637	7849	43	War	War	NNP
18637	7849	44	II	II	NNP
18637	7849	45	392	392	CD
18637	7849	46	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7849	47	war	war	NN
18637	7849	48	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	7849	49	393	393	CD
18637	7849	50	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	7849	51	status	status	NN
18637	7849	52	of	of	IN
18637	7849	53	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7849	54	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	7849	55	394	394	CD
18637	7849	56	West	West	NNP
18637	7849	57	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	7849	58	Japanese	Japanese	NNP
18637	7849	59	394	394	CD
18637	7849	60	Act	Act	NNP
18637	7849	61	of	of	IN
18637	7849	62	March	March	NNP
18637	7849	63	21	21	CD
18637	7849	64	,	,	,
18637	7849	65	1942	1942	CD
18637	7849	66	395	395	CD
18637	7849	67	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7849	68	government	government	NN
18637	7849	69	of	of	IN
18637	7849	70	labor	labor	NN
18637	7849	71	relations	relation	NNS
18637	7849	72	395	395	CD
18637	7849	73	"	"	``
18637	7849	74	Sanctions	Sanctions	NNPS
18637	7849	75	"	"	''
18637	7849	76	397	397	CD
18637	7849	77	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	7849	78	basis	basis	NN
18637	7849	79	of	of	IN
18637	7849	80	sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	7849	81	397	397	CD
18637	7849	82	Martial	martial	JJ
18637	7849	83	law	law	NN
18637	7849	84	and	and	CC
18637	7849	85	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	7849	86	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	7849	87	398	398	CD
18637	7849	88	Martial	martial	JJ
18637	7849	89	law	law	NN
18637	7849	90	in	in	IN
18637	7849	91	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	7849	92	400	400	CD
18637	7849	93	Case	Case	NNP
18637	7849	94	of	of	IN
18637	7849	95	the	the	DT
18637	7849	96	Nazi	Nazi	NNP
18637	7849	97	saboteurs	saboteurs	NNP
18637	7849	98	401	401	CD
18637	7849	99	War	war	NN
18637	7849	100	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	7849	101	cases	case	NNS
18637	7849	102	402	402	CD
18637	7849	103	President	President	NNP
18637	7849	104	as	as	IN
18637	7849	105	commander	commander	NN
18637	7849	106	of	of	IN
18637	7849	107	the	the	DT
18637	7849	108	forces	force	NNS
18637	7849	109	403	403	CD
18637	7849	110	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	7849	111	in	in	IN
18637	7849	112	chief	chief	NN
18637	7849	113	a	a	DT
18637	7849	114	civilian	civilian	JJ
18637	7849	115	officer	officer	NN
18637	7849	116	404	404	CD
18637	7849	117	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7849	118	advisers	adviser	NNS
18637	7849	119	405	405	CD
18637	7849	120	The	the	DT
18637	7849	121	Cabinet	Cabinet	NNP
18637	7849	122	405	405	CD
18637	7849	123	Pardons	Pardons	NNPS
18637	7849	124	and	and	CC
18637	7849	125	reprieves	reprieve	VBZ
18637	7849	126	406	406	CD
18637	7849	127	Legal	legal	JJ
18637	7849	128	nature	nature	NN
18637	7849	129	of	of	IN
18637	7849	130	a	a	DT
18637	7849	131	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	7849	132	406	406	CD
18637	7849	133	Qualification	qualification	NN
18637	7849	134	of	of	IN
18637	7849	135	above	above	RB
18637	7849	136	theory	theory	NN
18637	7849	137	407	407	CD
18637	7849	138	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	7849	139	of	of	IN
18637	7849	140	the	the	DT
18637	7849	141	power	power	NN
18637	7849	142	408	408	CD
18637	7849	143	"	"	``
18637	7849	144	Offenses	offense	NNS
18637	7849	145	against	against	IN
18637	7849	146	the	the	DT
18637	7849	147	United	United	NNP
18637	7849	148	States	States	NNP
18637	7849	149	"	"	''
18637	7849	150	;	;	:
18637	7849	151	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	7849	152	of	of	IN
18637	7849	153	court	court	NN
18637	7849	154	408	408	CD
18637	7849	155	Effects	Effects	NNPS
18637	7849	156	of	of	IN
18637	7849	157	a	a	DT
18637	7849	158	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	7849	159	:	:	:
18637	7849	160	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	7849	161	parte	parte	NN
18637	7849	162	Garland	Garland	NNP
18637	7849	163	409	409	CD
18637	7849	164	Limits	Limits	NNPS
18637	7849	165	to	to	IN
18637	7849	166	the	the	DT
18637	7849	167	efficacy	efficacy	NN
18637	7849	168	of	of	IN
18637	7849	169	a	a	DT
18637	7849	170	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	7849	171	410	410	CD
18637	7849	172	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7849	173	and	and	CC
18637	7849	174	Amnesty	Amnesty	NNP
18637	7849	175	411	411	CD
18637	7849	176	Clauses	clause	NNS
18637	7849	177	2	2	CD
18637	7849	178	and	and	CC
18637	7849	179	3	3	CD
18637	7849	180	.	.	.
18637	7850	1	Treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	7850	2	and	and	CC
18637	7850	3	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	7850	4	of	of	IN
18637	7850	5	officers	officer	NNS
18637	7850	6	412	412	CD
18637	7850	7	Treaty	treaty	NN
18637	7850	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	7850	9	making	make	VBG
18637	7850	10	power	power	NN
18637	7850	11	412	412	CD
18637	7850	12	President	President	NNP
18637	7850	13	and	and	CC
18637	7850	14	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	7850	15	412	412	CD
18637	7850	16	Negotiation	negotiation	NN
18637	7850	17	a	a	DT
18637	7850	18	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7850	19	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	7850	20	412	412	CD
18637	7850	21	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	7850	22	as	as	IN
18637	7850	23	law	law	NN
18637	7850	24	of	of	IN
18637	7850	25	the	the	DT
18637	7850	26	land	land	NN
18637	7850	27	413	413	CD
18637	7850	28	Origin	origin	NN
18637	7850	29	of	of	IN
18637	7850	30	the	the	DT
18637	7850	31	conception	conception	NN
18637	7850	32	414	414	CD
18637	7850	33	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	7850	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	7850	35	versus	versus	IN
18637	7850	36	State	state	NN
18637	7850	37	power	power	NN
18637	7850	38	415	415	CD
18637	7850	39	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	7850	40	cases	case	NNS
18637	7850	41	417	417	CD
18637	7850	42	When	when	WRB
18637	7850	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	7850	44	a	a	DT
18637	7850	45	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	7850	46	self	self	NN
18637	7850	47	-	-	HYPH
18637	7850	48	executing	execute	VBG
18637	7850	49	;	;	:
18637	7850	50	when	when	WRB
18637	7850	51	not	not	RB
18637	7850	52	417	417	CD
18637	7850	53	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	7850	54	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	7850	55	of	of	IN
18637	7850	56	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7850	57	with	with	IN
18637	7850	58	respect	respect	NN
18637	7850	59	to	to	IN
18637	7850	60	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	7850	61	418	418	CD
18637	7850	62	Treaty	treaty	NN
18637	7850	63	-	-	HYPH
18637	7850	64	making	make	VBG
18637	7850	65	power	power	NN
18637	7850	66	and	and	CC
18637	7850	67	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	7850	68	laws	law	NNS
18637	7850	69	419	419	CD
18637	7850	70	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	7850	71	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	7850	72	of	of	IN
18637	7850	73	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	7850	74	420	420	CD
18637	7850	75	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	7850	76	versus	versus	IN
18637	7850	77	prior	prior	JJ
18637	7850	78	acts	act	NNS
18637	7850	79	of	of	IN
18637	7850	80	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7850	81	421	421	CD
18637	7850	82	Interpretation	Interpretation	NNP
18637	7850	83	and	and	CC
18637	7850	84	termination	termination	NN
18637	7850	85	of	of	IN
18637	7850	86	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	7850	87	as	as	IN
18637	7850	88	international	international	JJ
18637	7850	89	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	7850	90	423	423	CD
18637	7850	91	Termination	Termination	NNP
18637	7850	92	of	of	IN
18637	7850	93	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	7850	94	by	by	IN
18637	7850	95	notice	notice	NN
18637	7850	96	423	423	CD
18637	7850	97	Determination	Determination	NNP
18637	7850	98	whether	whether	IN
18637	7850	99	a	a	DT
18637	7850	100	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	7850	101	has	have	VBZ
18637	7850	102	lapsed	lapse	VBN
18637	7850	103	425	425	CD
18637	7850	104	Status	Status	NNP
18637	7850	105	of	of	IN
18637	7850	106	a	a	DT
18637	7850	107	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	7850	108	a	a	DT
18637	7850	109	political	political	JJ
18637	7850	110	question	question	NN
18637	7850	111	426	426	CD
18637	7850	112	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	7850	113	and	and	CC
18637	7850	114	the	the	DT
18637	7850	115	"	"	``
18637	7850	116	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	7850	117	and	and	CC
18637	7850	118	proper	proper	JJ
18637	7850	119	"	"	''
18637	7850	120	clause	clause	NN
18637	7850	121	426	426	CD
18637	7850	122	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	7850	123	limits	limit	NNS
18637	7850	124	of	of	IN
18637	7850	125	the	the	DT
18637	7850	126	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	7850	127	-	-	HYPH
18637	7850	128	making	make	VBG
18637	7850	129	power	power	NN
18637	7850	130	:	:	:
18637	7850	131	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	7850	132	_	_	NNP
18637	7850	133	v.	v.	IN
18637	7850	134	_	_	NNP
18637	7850	135	Holland	Holland	NNP
18637	7850	136	428	428	CD
18637	7850	137	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	7850	138	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	7850	139	431	431	CD
18637	7850	140	Present	present	JJ
18637	7850	141	status	status	NN
18637	7850	142	of	of	IN
18637	7850	143	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	7850	144	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	7850	145	432	432	CD
18637	7850	146	International	International	NNP
18637	7850	147	Agreements	Agreements	NNPS
18637	7850	148	without	without	IN
18637	7850	149	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	7850	150	approval	approval	NN
18637	7850	151	433	433	CD
18637	7850	152	Routine	Routine	NNP
18637	7850	153	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7850	154	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	7850	155	433	433	CD
18637	7850	156	Law	Law	NNP
18637	7850	157	-	-	HYPH
18637	7850	158	making	make	VBG
18637	7850	159	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7850	160	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	7850	161	434	434	CD
18637	7850	162	President	President	NNP
18637	7850	163	McKinley	McKinley	NNP
18637	7850	164	's	's	POS
18637	7850	165	contribution	contribution	NN
18637	7850	166	435	435	CD
18637	7850	167	Executive	executive	JJ
18637	7850	168	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	7850	169	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	7850	170	Far	Far	NNP
18637	7850	171	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	7850	172	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	7850	173	436	436	CD
18637	7850	174	International	international	JJ
18637	7850	175	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	7850	176	of	of	IN
18637	7850	177	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7850	178	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	7850	179	436	436	CD
18637	7850	180	Litvinov	Litvinov	NNP
18637	7850	181	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	7850	182	of	of	IN
18637	7850	183	1933	1933	CD
18637	7850	184	437	437	CD
18637	7850	185	United	United	NNP
18637	7850	186	States	States	NNP
18637	7850	187	_	_	NNP
18637	7850	188	v.	v.	IN
18637	7850	189	_	_	NNP
18637	7850	190	Belmont	Belmont	NNP
18637	7850	191	437	437	CD
18637	7850	192	United	United	NNP
18637	7850	193	States	States	NNP
18637	7850	194	_	_	NNP
18637	7850	195	v.	v.	IN
18637	7850	196	_	_	NNP
18637	7850	197	Pink	Pink	NNP
18637	7850	198	;	;	:
18637	7850	199	National	national	JJ
18637	7850	200	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	7850	201	438	438	CD
18637	7850	202	Hull	Hull	NNP
18637	7850	203	-	-	HYPH
18637	7850	204	Lothian	lothian	JJ
18637	7850	205	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	7850	206	,	,	,
18637	7850	207	1940	1940	CD
18637	7850	208	439	439	CD
18637	7850	209	War	war	JJ
18637	7850	210	-	-	HYPH
18637	7850	211	time	time	NN
18637	7850	212	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	7850	213	440	440	CD
18637	7850	214	Executive	executive	JJ
18637	7850	215	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	7850	216	by	by	IN
18637	7850	217	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	7850	218	of	of	IN
18637	7850	219	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7850	220	441	441	CD
18637	7850	221	Reciprocal	reciprocal	JJ
18637	7850	222	trade	trade	NN
18637	7850	223	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	7850	224	441	441	CD
18637	7850	225	Constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	7850	226	of	of	IN
18637	7850	227	trade	trade	NN
18637	7850	228	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	7850	229	442	442	CD
18637	7850	230	Lend	Lend	NNP
18637	7850	231	-	-	HYPH
18637	7850	232	Lease	Lease	NNP
18637	7850	233	Act	Act	NNP
18637	7850	234	443	443	CD
18637	7850	235	President	President	NNP
18637	7850	236	plus	plus	CC
18637	7850	237	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7850	238	versus	versus	IN
18637	7850	239	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	7850	240	443	443	CD
18637	7850	241	Arbitration	Arbitration	NNP
18637	7850	242	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	7850	243	444	444	CD
18637	7850	244	Agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	7850	245	under	under	IN
18637	7850	246	the	the	DT
18637	7850	247	United	United	NNP
18637	7850	248	Nations	Nations	NNPS
18637	7850	249	Charter	Charter	NNP
18637	7850	250	444	444	CD
18637	7850	251	United	United	NNP
18637	7850	252	Nations	Nations	NNP
18637	7850	253	Participation	Participation	NNP
18637	7850	254	Act	Act	NNP
18637	7850	255	445	445	CD
18637	7850	256	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	7850	257	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	7850	258	445	445	CD
18637	7850	259	"	"	``
18637	7850	260	Office	Office	NNP
18637	7850	261	"	"	''
18637	7850	262	445	445	CD
18637	7850	263	"	"	''
18637	7850	264	Ambassadors	Ambassadors	NNPS
18637	7850	265	and	and	CC
18637	7850	266	other	other	JJ
18637	7850	267	public	public	JJ
18637	7850	268	ministers	minister	NNS
18637	7850	269	"	"	``
18637	7850	270	445	445	CD
18637	7850	271	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7850	272	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	7850	273	agents	agent	NNS
18637	7850	274	447	447	CD
18637	7850	275	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	7850	276	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	7850	277	of	of	IN
18637	7850	278	offices	office	NNS
18637	7850	279	449	449	CD
18637	7850	280	Conduct	conduct	NN
18637	7850	281	in	in	IN
18637	7850	282	office	office	NN
18637	7850	283	450	450	CD
18637	7850	284	The	the	DT
18637	7850	285	loyalty	loyalty	NN
18637	7850	286	issue	issue	NN
18637	7850	287	451	451	CD
18637	7850	288	Legislation	legislation	NN
18637	7850	289	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	7850	290	duties	duty	NNS
18637	7850	291	of	of	IN
18637	7850	292	an	an	DT
18637	7850	293	officer	officer	NN
18637	7850	294	452	452	CD
18637	7850	295	"	"	``
18637	7850	296	Inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	7850	297	officers	officer	NNS
18637	7850	298	"	"	''
18637	7850	299	;	;	:
18637	7850	300	"	"	``
18637	7850	301	employees	employee	NNS
18637	7850	302	"	"	``
18637	7850	303	452	452	CD
18637	7850	304	Stages	stage	NNS
18637	7850	305	of	of	IN
18637	7850	306	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	7850	307	process	process	NN
18637	7850	308	453	453	CD
18637	7850	309	Nomination	nomination	NN
18637	7850	310	453	453	CD
18637	7850	311	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	7850	312	approval	approval	NN
18637	7850	313	453	453	CD
18637	7850	314	When	when	WRB
18637	7850	315	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	7850	316	consent	consent	NN
18637	7850	317	is	be	VBZ
18637	7850	318	complete	complete	JJ
18637	7850	319	453	453	CD
18637	7850	320	Commissioning	commission	VBG
18637	7850	321	the	the	DT
18637	7850	322	officer	officer	NN
18637	7850	323	454	454	CD
18637	7850	324	Recess	Recess	NNP
18637	7850	325	appointments	appointment	VBZ
18637	7850	326	455	455	CD
18637	7850	327	Ad	ad	NN
18637	7850	328	interim	interim	JJ
18637	7850	329	designations	designation	NNS
18637	7850	330	455	455	CD
18637	7850	331	Removal	removal	NN
18637	7850	332	power	power	NN
18637	7850	333	;	;	:
18637	7850	334	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	7850	335	case	case	NN
18637	7850	336	455	455	CD
18637	7850	337	"	"	``
18637	7850	338	Nature	Nature	NNP
18637	7850	339	of	of	IN
18637	7850	340	the	the	DT
18637	7850	341	office	office	NN
18637	7850	342	"	"	''
18637	7850	343	concept	concept	NN
18637	7850	344	458	458	CD
18637	7850	345	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	7850	346	case	case	NN
18637	7850	347	458	458	CD
18637	7850	348	Other	other	JJ
18637	7850	349	phases	phase	NNS
18637	7850	350	of	of	IN
18637	7850	351	the	the	DT
18637	7850	352	removal	removal	NN
18637	7850	353	power	power	NN
18637	7850	354	459	459	CD
18637	7850	355	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7850	356	aegis	aegis	NN
18637	7850	357	460	460	CD
18637	7850	358	Section	section	NN
18637	7850	359	3	3	CD
18637	7850	360	.	.	.
18637	7851	1	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	7851	2	,	,	,
18637	7851	3	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	7851	4	,	,	,
18637	7851	5	and	and	CC
18637	7851	6	law	law	NN
18637	7851	7	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	7851	8	duties	duty	NNS
18637	7851	9	of	of	IN
18637	7851	10	the	the	DT
18637	7851	11	President	President	NNP
18637	7851	12	462	462	CD
18637	7851	13	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	7851	14	role	role	NN
18637	7851	15	of	of	IN
18637	7851	16	the	the	DT
18637	7851	17	President	President	NNP
18637	7851	18	462	462	CD
18637	7851	19	Right	Right	NNP
18637	7851	20	of	of	IN
18637	7851	21	Reception	Reception	NNP
18637	7851	22	463	463	CD
18637	7851	23	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	7851	24	of	of	IN
18637	7851	25	the	the	DT
18637	7851	26	power	power	NN
18637	7851	27	463	463	CD
18637	7851	28	A	a	DT
18637	7851	29	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7851	30	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	7851	31	464	464	CD
18637	7851	32	"	"	``
18637	7851	33	The	the	DT
18637	7851	34	Logan	Logan	NNP
18637	7851	35	Act	Act	NNP
18637	7851	36	"	"	``
18637	7851	37	464	464	CD
18637	7851	38	A	a	DT
18637	7851	39	formal	formal	JJ
18637	7851	40	or	or	CC
18637	7851	41	a	a	DT
18637	7851	42	formative	formative	JJ
18637	7851	43	power	power	NN
18637	7851	44	465	465	CD
18637	7851	45	President	President	NNP
18637	7851	46	's	's	POS
18637	7851	47	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	7851	48	role	role	NN
18637	7851	49	465	465	CD
18637	7851	50	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	7851	51	's	's	POS
18637	7851	52	real	real	JJ
18637	7851	53	position	position	NN
18637	7851	54	466	466	CD
18637	7851	55	Power	Power	NNP
18637	7851	56	of	of	IN
18637	7851	57	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	7851	58	467	467	CD
18637	7851	59	The	the	DT
18637	7851	60	case	case	NN
18637	7851	61	of	of	IN
18637	7851	62	Cuba	Cuba	NNP
18637	7851	63	468	468	CD
18637	7851	64	Power	Power	NNP
18637	7851	65	of	of	IN
18637	7851	66	nonrecognition	nonrecognition	NN
18637	7851	67	469	469	CD
18637	7851	68	President	President	NNP
18637	7851	69	and	and	CC
18637	7851	70	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7851	71	470	470	CD
18637	7851	72	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	7851	73	implementation	implementation	NN
18637	7851	74	of	of	IN
18637	7851	75	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7851	76	policies	policy	NNS
18637	7851	77	471	471	CD
18637	7851	78	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	7851	79	of	of	IN
18637	7851	80	political	political	JJ
18637	7851	81	questions	question	NNS
18637	7851	82	471	471	CD
18637	7851	83	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	7851	84	statements	statement	NNS
18637	7851	85	of	of	IN
18637	7851	86	the	the	DT
18637	7851	87	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	7851	88	473	473	CD
18637	7851	89	The	the	DT
18637	7851	90	President	President	NNP
18637	7851	91	as	as	IN
18637	7851	92	law	law	NN
18637	7851	93	enforcer	enforcer	NN
18637	7851	94	475	475	CD
18637	7851	95	Types	type	NNS
18637	7851	96	of	of	IN
18637	7851	97	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7851	98	power	power	NN
18637	7851	99	475	475	CD
18637	7851	100	How	how	WRB
18637	7851	101	the	the	DT
18637	7851	102	President	President	NNP
18637	7851	103	's	's	POS
18637	7851	104	own	own	JJ
18637	7851	105	powers	power	NNS
18637	7851	106	are	be	VBP
18637	7851	107	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	7851	108	476	476	CD
18637	7851	109	Power	power	NN
18637	7851	110	and	and	CC
18637	7851	111	duty	duty	NN
18637	7851	112	of	of	IN
18637	7851	113	the	the	DT
18637	7851	114	President	President	NNP
18637	7851	115	in	in	IN
18637	7851	116	relation	relation	NN
18637	7851	117	to	to	IN
18637	7851	118	subordinate	subordinate	JJ
18637	7851	119	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7851	120	officers	officer	NNS
18637	7851	121	478	478	CD
18637	7851	122	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	7851	123	Decentralization	Decentralization	NNP
18637	7851	124	_	_	NNP
18637	7851	125	v.	v.	IN
18637	7851	126	_	_	NNP
18637	7851	127	Jacksonian	Jacksonian	NNP
18637	7851	128	Centralism	Centralism	NNP
18637	7851	129	478	478	CD
18637	7851	130	Congressional	Congressional	NNP
18637	7851	131	Power	Power	NNP
18637	7851	132	_	_	NNP
18637	7851	133	v.	v.	IN
18637	7851	134	_	_	NNP
18637	7851	135	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	7851	136	Duty	Duty	NNP
18637	7851	137	to	to	IN
18637	7851	138	the	the	DT
18637	7851	139	Law	Law	NNP
18637	7851	140	479	479	CD
18637	7851	141	Myers	Myers	NNPS
18637	7851	142	Case	Case	NNP
18637	7851	143	_	_	NNP
18637	7851	144	v.	v.	IN
18637	7851	145	_	_	NNP
18637	7851	146	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	7851	147	Case	Case	NNP
18637	7851	148	480	480	CD
18637	7851	149	Power	Power	NNP
18637	7851	150	of	of	IN
18637	7851	151	the	the	DT
18637	7851	152	President	President	NNP
18637	7851	153	to	to	TO
18637	7851	154	guide	guide	VB
18637	7851	155	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	7851	156	of	of	IN
18637	7851	157	the	the	DT
18637	7851	158	penal	penal	JJ
18637	7851	159	law	law	NN
18637	7851	160	481	481	CD
18637	7851	161	President	President	NNP
18637	7851	162	as	as	IN
18637	7851	163	law	law	NN
18637	7851	164	interpreter	interpreter	NN
18637	7851	165	481	481	CD
18637	7851	166	Military	military	JJ
18637	7851	167	power	power	NN
18637	7851	168	in	in	IN
18637	7851	169	law	law	NN
18637	7851	170	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	7851	171	:	:	:
18637	7851	172	the	the	DT
18637	7851	173	posse	posse	NN
18637	7851	174	comitatus	comitatus	NN
18637	7851	175	482	482	CD
18637	7851	176	Suspension	Suspension	NNP
18637	7851	177	of	of	IN
18637	7851	178	Habeas	Habeas	NNP
18637	7851	179	Corpus	Corpus	NNP
18637	7851	180	by	by	IN
18637	7851	181	President	President	NNP
18637	7851	182	484	484	CD
18637	7851	183	Preventive	Preventive	NNP
18637	7851	184	martial	martial	JJ
18637	7851	185	law	law	NN
18637	7851	186	484	484	CD
18637	7851	187	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	7851	188	case	case	NN
18637	7851	189	484	484	CD
18637	7851	190	Status	Status	NNP
18637	7851	191	of	of	IN
18637	7851	192	the	the	DT
18637	7851	193	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	7851	194	case	case	NN
18637	7851	195	,	,	,
18637	7851	196	today	today	NN
18637	7851	197	485	485	CD
18637	7851	198	President	President	NNP
18637	7851	199	's	's	POS
18637	7851	200	duty	duty	NN
18637	7851	201	in	in	IN
18637	7851	202	cases	case	NNS
18637	7851	203	of	of	IN
18637	7851	204	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	7851	205	violence	violence	NN
18637	7851	206	486	486	CD
18637	7851	207	President	President	NNP
18637	7851	208	as	as	IN
18637	7851	209	executive	executive	NN
18637	7851	210	of	of	IN
18637	7851	211	the	the	DT
18637	7851	212	law	law	NN
18637	7851	213	of	of	IN
18637	7851	214	nations	nation	NNS
18637	7851	215	486	486	CD
18637	7851	216	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	7851	217	of	of	IN
18637	7851	218	American	american	JJ
18637	7851	219	rights	right	NNS
18637	7851	220	of	of	IN
18637	7851	221	person	person	NN
18637	7851	222	and	and	CC
18637	7851	223	property	property	NN
18637	7851	224	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	7851	225	487	487	CD
18637	7851	226	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7851	227	world	world	NN
18637	7851	228	policing	police	VBG
18637	7851	229	488	488	CD
18637	7851	230	The	the	DT
18637	7851	231	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	7851	232	Pact	Pact	NNP
18637	7851	233	488	488	CD
18637	7851	234	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7851	235	action	action	NN
18637	7851	236	in	in	IN
18637	7851	237	the	the	DT
18637	7851	238	domain	domain	NN
18637	7851	239	of	of	IN
18637	7851	240	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7851	241	:	:	:
18637	7851	242	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	7851	243	Seizure	Seizure	NNP
18637	7851	244	Case	case	NN
18637	7851	245	489	489	CD
18637	7851	246	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7851	247	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	7851	248	from	from	IN
18637	7851	249	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	7851	250	direction	direction	NN
18637	7851	251	499	499	CD
18637	7851	252	President	President	NNP
18637	7851	253	's	's	POS
18637	7851	254	subordinates	subordinate	NNS
18637	7851	255	and	and	CC
18637	7851	256	the	the	DT
18637	7851	257	courts	court	NNS
18637	7851	258	500	500	CD
18637	7851	259	Section	Section	NNP
18637	7851	260	4	4	CD
18637	7851	261	.	.	.
18637	7852	1	Impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	7852	2	501	501	CD
18637	7852	3	Impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	7852	4	501	501	CD
18637	7852	5	"	"	``
18637	7852	6	Civil	civil	JJ
18637	7852	7	"	"	''
18637	7852	8	officer	officer	NN
18637	7852	9	501	501	CD
18637	7852	10	"	"	``
18637	7852	11	High	high	JJ
18637	7852	12	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	7852	13	and	and	CC
18637	7852	14	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
18637	7852	15	"	"	``
18637	7852	16	502	502	CD
18637	7852	17	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	7852	18	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	7852	19	502	502	CD
18637	7852	20	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	7852	21	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	7852	22	503	503	CD
18637	7852	23	Later	late	JJR
18637	7852	24	impeachments	impeachment	VBZ
18637	7852	25	503	503	CD
18637	7852	26	EXECUTIVE	executive	NN
18637	7852	27	DEPARTMENT	DEPARTMENT	NNP
18637	7852	28	Article	Article	NNP
18637	7852	29	II	II	NNP
18637	7852	30	Section	Section	NNP
18637	7852	31	1	1	CD
18637	7852	32	:	:	:
18637	7852	33	The	the	DT
18637	7852	34	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7852	35	Power	power	NN
18637	7852	36	shall	shall	MD
18637	7852	37	be	be	VB
18637	7852	38	vested	vest	VBN
18637	7852	39	in	in	IN
18637	7852	40	a	a	DT
18637	7852	41	President	President	NNP
18637	7852	42	of	of	IN
18637	7852	43	the	the	DT
18637	7852	44	United	United	NNP
18637	7852	45	States	States	NNP
18637	7852	46	of	of	IN
18637	7852	47	America	America	NNP
18637	7852	48	.	.	.
18637	7853	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7853	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	7853	3	hold	hold	VB
18637	7853	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7853	5	Office	Office	NNP
18637	7853	6	during	during	IN
18637	7853	7	the	the	DT
18637	7853	8	Term	Term	NNP
18637	7853	9	of	of	IN
18637	7853	10	four	four	CD
18637	7853	11	Years	Years	NNPS
18637	7853	12	,	,	,
18637	7853	13	and	and	CC
18637	7853	14	,	,	,
18637	7853	15	together	together	RB
18637	7853	16	with	with	IN
18637	7853	17	the	the	DT
18637	7853	18	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7853	19	President	President	NNP
18637	7853	20	,	,	,
18637	7853	21	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	7853	22	for	for	IN
18637	7853	23	the	the	DT
18637	7853	24	same	same	JJ
18637	7853	25	Term	Term	NNP
18637	7853	26	,	,	,
18637	7853	27	be	be	VB
18637	7853	28	elected	elect	VBN
18637	7853	29	,	,	,
18637	7853	30	as	as	IN
18637	7853	31	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	7853	32	:	:	:
18637	7853	33	The	the	DT
18637	7853	34	Nature	Nature	NNP
18637	7853	35	and	and	CC
18637	7853	36	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	7853	37	of	of	IN
18637	7853	38	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	7853	39	Power	Power	NNP
18637	7853	40	CONTEMPORARY	CONTEMPORARY	NNP
18637	7853	41	SOURCE	SOURCE	NNP
18637	7853	42	OF	of	IN
18637	7853	43	THE	the	DT
18637	7853	44	PRESIDENCY	PRESIDENCY	VBN
18637	7853	45	The	the	DT
18637	7853	46	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	7853	47	source	source	NN
18637	7853	48	of	of	IN
18637	7853	49	article	article	NN
18637	7853	50	II	ii	CD
18637	7853	51	was	be	VBD
18637	7853	52	the	the	DT
18637	7853	53	New	New	NNP
18637	7853	54	York	York	NNP
18637	7853	55	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	7853	56	of	of	IN
18637	7853	57	1777,[1	1777,[1	CD
18637	7853	58	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7853	59	of	of	IN
18637	7853	60	which	which	WDT
18637	7853	61	the	the	DT
18637	7853	62	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	7853	63	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	7853	64	are	be	VBP
18637	7853	65	the	the	DT
18637	7853	66	following	follow	VBG
18637	7853	67	:	:	:
18637	7853	68	"	"	``
18637	7853	69	Art	art	NN
18637	7853	70	.	.	.
18637	7854	1	XVIII	xviii	NN
18637	7854	2	.	.	.
18637	7855	1	*	*	NFP
18637	7855	2	*	*	NFP
18637	7855	3	*	*	NFP
18637	7855	4	The	the	DT
18637	7855	5	governor	governor	NN
18637	7855	6	*	*	NFP
18637	7855	7	*	*	NFP
18637	7855	8	*	*	NFP
18637	7855	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	7855	10	by	by	IN
18637	7855	11	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	7855	12	of	of	IN
18637	7855	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7855	14	office	office	NN
18637	7855	15	,	,	,
18637	7855	16	be	be	VB
18637	7855	17	general	general	JJ
18637	7855	18	and	and	CC
18637	7855	19	commander	commander	NN
18637	7855	20	in	in	IN
18637	7855	21	chief	chief	NN
18637	7855	22	of	of	IN
18637	7855	23	all	all	PDT
18637	7855	24	the	the	DT
18637	7855	25	militia	militia	NN
18637	7855	26	,	,	,
18637	7855	27	and	and	CC
18637	7855	28	admiral	admiral	NN
18637	7855	29	of	of	IN
18637	7855	30	the	the	DT
18637	7855	31	navy	navy	NNP
18637	7855	32	of	of	IN
18637	7855	33	this	this	DT
18637	7855	34	state	state	NN
18637	7855	35	;	;	:
18637	7855	36	*	*	NFP
18637	7855	37	*	*	NFP
18637	7855	38	*	*	NFP
18637	7855	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7855	40	shall	shall	MD
18637	7855	41	have	have	VB
18637	7855	42	power	power	NN
18637	7855	43	to	to	TO
18637	7855	44	convene	convene	VB
18637	7855	45	the	the	DT
18637	7855	46	assembly	assembly	NNP
18637	7855	47	and	and	CC
18637	7855	48	senate	senate	NNP
18637	7855	49	on	on	IN
18637	7855	50	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	7855	51	occasions	occasion	NNS
18637	7855	52	;	;	,
18637	7855	53	to	to	TO
18637	7855	54	prorogue	prorogue	VB
18637	7855	55	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7855	56	from	from	IN
18637	7855	57	time	time	NN
18637	7855	58	to	to	IN
18637	7855	59	time	time	NN
18637	7855	60	,	,	,
18637	7855	61	provided	provide	VBD
18637	7855	62	such	such	JJ
18637	7855	63	prorogations	prorogation	NNS
18637	7855	64	shall	shall	MD
18637	7855	65	not	not	RB
18637	7855	66	exceed	exceed	VB
18637	7855	67	sixty	sixty	JJ
18637	7855	68	days	day	NNS
18637	7855	69	in	in	IN
18637	7855	70	the	the	DT
18637	7855	71	space	space	NN
18637	7855	72	of	of	IN
18637	7855	73	any	any	DT
18637	7855	74	one	one	CD
18637	7855	75	year	year	NN
18637	7855	76	;	;	:
18637	7855	77	and	and	CC
18637	7855	78	,	,	,
18637	7855	79	at	at	IN
18637	7855	80	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7855	81	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	7855	82	,	,	,
18637	7855	83	to	to	TO
18637	7855	84	grant	grant	VB
18637	7855	85	reprieves	reprieve	NNS
18637	7855	86	and	and	CC
18637	7855	87	pardons	pardon	NNS
18637	7855	88	to	to	IN
18637	7855	89	persons	person	NNS
18637	7855	90	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	7855	91	of	of	IN
18637	7855	92	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	7855	93	,	,	,
18637	7855	94	other	other	JJ
18637	7855	95	than	than	IN
18637	7855	96	treason	treason	NN
18637	7855	97	and	and	CC
18637	7855	98	murder	murder	NN
18637	7855	99	,	,	,
18637	7855	100	in	in	IN
18637	7855	101	which	which	WDT
18637	7855	102	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7855	103	may	may	MD
18637	7855	104	suspend	suspend	VB
18637	7855	105	the	the	DT
18637	7855	106	execution	execution	NN
18637	7855	107	of	of	IN
18637	7855	108	the	the	DT
18637	7855	109	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	7855	110	,	,	,
18637	7855	111	until	until	IN
18637	7855	112	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7855	113	shall	shall	MD
18637	7855	114	be	be	VB
18637	7855	115	reported	report	VBN
18637	7855	116	to	to	IN
18637	7855	117	the	the	DT
18637	7855	118	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	7855	119	at	at	IN
18637	7855	120	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7855	121	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	7855	122	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	7855	123	;	;	:
18637	7855	124	and	and	CC
18637	7855	125	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7855	126	shall	shall	MD
18637	7855	127	either	either	CC
18637	7855	128	pardon	pardon	VB
18637	7855	129	or	or	CC
18637	7855	130	direct	direct	VB
18637	7855	131	the	the	DT
18637	7855	132	execution	execution	NN
18637	7855	133	of	of	IN
18637	7855	134	the	the	DT
18637	7855	135	criminal	criminal	NN
18637	7855	136	,	,	,
18637	7855	137	or	or	CC
18637	7855	138	grant	grant	VB
18637	7855	139	a	a	DT
18637	7855	140	further	further	JJ
18637	7855	141	reprieve	reprieve	NN
18637	7855	142	.	.	.
18637	7856	1	"	"	``
18637	7856	2	Art	art	NN
18637	7856	3	.	.	.
18637	7857	1	XIX	XIX	NNP
18637	7857	2	.	.	.
18637	7858	1	*	*	NFP
18637	7858	2	*	*	NFP
18637	7858	3	*	*	NFP
18637	7858	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7858	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	7858	6	be	be	VB
18637	7858	7	the	the	DT
18637	7858	8	duty	duty	NN
18637	7858	9	of	of	IN
18637	7858	10	the	the	DT
18637	7858	11	governor	governor	NN
18637	7858	12	to	to	TO
18637	7858	13	inform	inform	VB
18637	7858	14	the	the	DT
18637	7858	15	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	7858	16	at	at	IN
18637	7858	17	every	every	DT
18637	7858	18	session	session	NN
18637	7858	19	of	of	IN
18637	7858	20	the	the	DT
18637	7858	21	condition	condition	NN
18637	7858	22	of	of	IN
18637	7858	23	the	the	DT
18637	7858	24	State	State	NNP
18637	7858	25	so	so	RB
18637	7858	26	far	far	RB
18637	7858	27	as	as	IN
18637	7858	28	may	may	MD
18637	7858	29	concern	concern	VB
18637	7858	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7858	31	department	department	NN
18637	7858	32	;	;	:
18637	7858	33	to	to	TO
18637	7858	34	recommend	recommend	VB
18637	7858	35	such	such	JJ
18637	7858	36	matters	matter	NNS
18637	7858	37	to	to	IN
18637	7858	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7858	39	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	7858	40	as	as	IN
18637	7858	41	shall	shall	MD
18637	7858	42	appear	appear	VB
18637	7858	43	to	to	IN
18637	7858	44	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7858	45	to	to	TO
18637	7858	46	concern	concern	VB
18637	7858	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7858	48	good	good	JJ
18637	7858	49	government	government	NN
18637	7858	50	,	,	,
18637	7858	51	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	7858	52	,	,	,
18637	7858	53	and	and	CC
18637	7858	54	prosperity	prosperity	NN
18637	7858	55	;	;	:
18637	7858	56	to	to	TO
18637	7858	57	correspond	correspond	VB
18637	7858	58	with	with	IN
18637	7858	59	the	the	DT
18637	7858	60	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	7858	61	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7858	62	and	and	CC
18637	7858	63	other	other	JJ
18637	7858	64	States	States	NNPS
18637	7858	65	;	;	:
18637	7858	66	to	to	TO
18637	7858	67	transact	transact	VB
18637	7858	68	all	all	DT
18637	7858	69	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	7858	70	business	business	NN
18637	7858	71	with	with	IN
18637	7858	72	the	the	DT
18637	7858	73	officers	officer	NNS
18637	7858	74	of	of	IN
18637	7858	75	government	government	NN
18637	7858	76	,	,	,
18637	7858	77	civil	civil	JJ
18637	7858	78	and	and	CC
18637	7858	79	military	military	NN
18637	7858	80	;	;	:
18637	7858	81	to	to	TO
18637	7858	82	take	take	VB
18637	7858	83	care	care	NN
18637	7858	84	that	that	IN
18637	7858	85	the	the	DT
18637	7858	86	laws	law	NNS
18637	7858	87	are	be	VBP
18637	7858	88	executed	execute	VBN
18637	7858	89	to	to	IN
18637	7858	90	the	the	DT
18637	7858	91	best	good	JJS
18637	7858	92	of	of	IN
18637	7858	93	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7858	94	ability	ability	NN
18637	7858	95	;	;	:
18637	7858	96	and	and	CC
18637	7858	97	to	to	TO
18637	7858	98	expedite	expedite	VB
18637	7858	99	all	all	DT
18637	7858	100	such	such	JJ
18637	7858	101	measures	measure	NNS
18637	7858	102	as	as	IN
18637	7858	103	may	may	MD
18637	7858	104	be	be	VB
18637	7858	105	resolved	resolve	VBN
18637	7858	106	upon	upon	IN
18637	7858	107	by	by	IN
18637	7858	108	the	the	DT
18637	7858	109	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	7858	110	.	.	.
18637	7859	1	"	"	``
18637	7859	2	To	to	IN
18637	7859	3	these	these	DT
18637	7859	4	,	,	,
18637	7859	5	of	of	IN
18637	7859	6	course	course	NN
18637	7859	7	,	,	,
18637	7859	8	are	be	VBP
18637	7859	9	to	to	TO
18637	7859	10	be	be	VB
18637	7859	11	added	add	VBN
18637	7859	12	the	the	DT
18637	7859	13	important	important	JJ
18637	7859	14	powers	power	NNS
18637	7859	15	of	of	IN
18637	7859	16	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	7859	17	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	7859	18	and	and	CC
18637	7859	19	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	7859	20	veto	veto	NN
18637	7859	21	.	.	.
18637	7860	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7860	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	7860	3	to	to	TO
18637	7860	4	be	be	VB
18637	7860	5	observed	observe	VBN
18637	7860	6	also	also	RB
18637	7860	7	that	that	IN
18637	7860	8	there	there	EX
18637	7860	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	7860	10	no	no	DT
18637	7860	11	question	question	NN
18637	7860	12	of	of	IN
18637	7860	13	the	the	DT
18637	7860	14	interposition	interposition	NN
18637	7860	15	of	of	IN
18637	7860	16	the	the	DT
18637	7860	17	law	law	NN
18637	7860	18	of	of	IN
18637	7860	19	the	the	DT
18637	7860	20	land	land	NN
18637	7860	21	to	to	TO
18637	7860	22	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	7860	23	these	these	DT
18637	7860	24	powers	power	NNS
18637	7860	25	.	.	.
18637	7861	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7861	2	are	be	VBP
18637	7861	3	the	the	DT
18637	7861	4	governor	governor	NN
18637	7861	5	's	's	POS
18637	7861	6	,	,	,
18637	7861	7	by	by	IN
18637	7861	8	direct	direct	JJ
18637	7861	9	grant	grant	NN
18637	7861	10	of	of	IN
18637	7861	11	the	the	DT
18637	7861	12	people	people	NNS
18637	7861	13	,	,	,
18637	7861	14	and	and	CC
18637	7861	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7861	16	alone	alone	JJ
18637	7861	17	.	.	.
18637	7862	1	Another	another	DT
18637	7862	2	distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
18637	7862	3	characteristic	characteristic	NN
18637	7862	4	,	,	,
18637	7862	5	equally	equally	RB
18637	7862	6	important	important	JJ
18637	7862	7	,	,	,
18637	7862	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	7862	9	the	the	DT
18637	7862	10	fact	fact	NN
18637	7862	11	that	that	IN
18637	7862	12	the	the	DT
18637	7862	13	governor	governor	NN
18637	7862	14	was	be	VBD
18637	7862	15	to	to	TO
18637	7862	16	be	be	VB
18637	7862	17	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	7862	18	by	by	IN
18637	7862	19	a	a	DT
18637	7862	20	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	7862	21	defined	define	VBN
18637	7862	22	electorate	electorate	NN
18637	7862	23	,	,	,
18637	7862	24	not	not	RB
18637	7862	25	by	by	IN
18637	7862	26	the	the	DT
18637	7862	27	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	7862	28	.	.	.
18637	7863	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7863	2	was	be	VBD
18637	7863	3	also	also	RB
18637	7863	4	to	to	TO
18637	7863	5	have	have	VB
18637	7863	6	a	a	DT
18637	7863	7	three	three	CD
18637	7863	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	7863	9	year	year	NN
18637	7863	10	term	term	NN
18637	7863	11	,	,	,
18637	7863	12	and	and	CC
18637	7863	13	there	there	EX
18637	7863	14	were	be	VBD
18637	7863	15	to	to	TO
18637	7863	16	be	be	VB
18637	7863	17	no	no	DT
18637	7863	18	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	7863	19	on	on	IN
18637	7863	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7863	21	re	re	NN
18637	7863	22	-	-	NN
18637	7863	23	eligibility	eligibility	NN
18637	7863	24	to	to	IN
18637	7863	25	office	office	NN
18637	7863	26	.	.	.
18637	7864	1	In	in	IN
18637	7864	2	short	short	JJ
18637	7864	3	,	,	,
18637	7864	4	all	all	PDT
18637	7864	5	the	the	DT
18637	7864	6	isolated	isolated	JJ
18637	7864	7	principles	principle	NNS
18637	7864	8	of	of	IN
18637	7864	9	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7864	10	strength	strength	NN
18637	7864	11	in	in	IN
18637	7864	12	other	other	JJ
18637	7864	13	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	7864	14	were	be	VBD
18637	7864	15	here	here	RB
18637	7864	16	brought	bring	VBN
18637	7864	17	into	into	IN
18637	7864	18	a	a	DT
18637	7864	19	new	new	JJ
18637	7864	20	whole	whole	NN
18637	7864	21	.	.	.
18637	7865	1	Alone	alone	RB
18637	7865	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7865	3	were	be	VBD
18637	7865	4	of	of	IN
18637	7865	5	slight	slight	JJ
18637	7865	6	importance	importance	NN
18637	7865	7	;	;	,
18637	7865	8	gathered	gather	VBD
18637	7865	9	together	together	RB
18637	7865	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7865	11	gain	gain	VBP
18637	7865	12	new	new	JJ
18637	7865	13	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	7865	14	.	.	.
18637	7866	1	And	and	CC
18637	7866	2	,	,	,
18637	7866	3	in	in	IN
18637	7866	4	addition	addition	NN
18637	7866	5	,	,	,
18637	7866	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7866	7	have	have	VBP
18637	7866	8	new	new	JJ
18637	7866	9	elements	element	NNS
18637	7866	10	of	of	IN
18637	7866	11	strength	strength	NN
18637	7866	12	utilized	utilize	VBN
18637	7866	13	for	for	IN
18637	7866	14	the	the	DT
18637	7866	15	first	first	JJ
18637	7866	16	time	time	NN
18637	7866	17	on	on	IN
18637	7866	18	the	the	DT
18637	7866	19	American	american	JJ
18637	7866	20	continent	continent	NN
18637	7866	21	.	.	.
18637	7867	1	"	"	``
18637	7867	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7867	3	2	2	LS
18637	7867	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7867	5	The	the	DT
18637	7867	6	appellation	appellation	NN
18637	7867	7	"	"	``
18637	7867	8	President	President	NNP
18637	7867	9	"	"	''
18637	7867	10	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	7867	11	to	to	TO
18637	7867	12	have	have	VB
18637	7867	13	been	be	VBN
18637	7867	14	suggested	suggest	VBN
18637	7867	15	to	to	IN
18637	7867	16	the	the	DT
18637	7867	17	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	7867	18	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	7867	19	by	by	IN
18637	7867	20	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	7867	21	Pinckney,[3	Pinckney,[3	NNP
18637	7867	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7867	23	to	to	TO
18637	7867	24	whom	whom	WP
18637	7867	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7867	26	may	may	MD
18637	7867	27	have	have	VB
18637	7867	28	been	be	VBN
18637	7867	29	suggested	suggest	VBN
18637	7867	30	by	by	IN
18637	7867	31	the	the	DT
18637	7867	32	title	title	NN
18637	7867	33	at	at	IN
18637	7867	34	that	that	DT
18637	7867	35	date	date	NN
18637	7867	36	of	of	IN
18637	7867	37	the	the	DT
18637	7867	38	chief	chief	JJ
18637	7867	39	magistrate	magistrate	NN
18637	7867	40	of	of	IN
18637	7867	41	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	7867	42	.	.	.
18637	7868	1	THE	the	DT
18637	7868	2	PRESIDENCY	PRESIDENCY	NNP
18637	7868	3	IN	in	IN
18637	7868	4	THE	the	DT
18637	7868	5	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	7868	6	CONVENTION	convention	NN
18637	7868	7	The	the	DT
18637	7868	8	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	7868	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	7868	10	in	in	IN
18637	7868	11	the	the	DT
18637	7868	12	Report	Report	NNP
18637	7868	13	from	from	IN
18637	7868	14	the	the	DT
18637	7868	15	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	7868	16	of	of	IN
18637	7868	17	Detail	Detail	NNP
18637	7868	18	of	of	IN
18637	7868	19	August	August	NNP
18637	7868	20	6	6	CD
18637	7868	21	,	,	,
18637	7868	22	1787	1787	CD
18637	7868	23	to	to	IN
18637	7868	24	the	the	DT
18637	7868	25	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	7868	26	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	7868	27	read	read	VBD
18637	7868	28	as	as	IN
18637	7868	29	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	7868	30	:	:	:
18637	7868	31	"	"	``
18637	7868	32	The	the	DT
18637	7868	33	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	7868	34	Power	Power	NNP
18637	7868	35	of	of	IN
18637	7868	36	the	the	DT
18637	7868	37	United	United	NNP
18637	7868	38	States	States	NNP
18637	7868	39	shall	shall	MD
18637	7868	40	be	be	VB
18637	7868	41	vested	vest	VBN
18637	7868	42	in	in	IN
18637	7868	43	a	a	DT
18637	7868	44	single	single	JJ
18637	7868	45	person	person	NN
18637	7868	46	.	.	.
18637	7869	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7869	2	stile	stile	NN
18637	7869	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	7869	4	be	be	VB
18637	7869	5	'	'	''
18637	7869	6	The	the	DT
18637	7869	7	President	President	NNP
18637	7869	8	of	of	IN
18637	7869	9	the	the	DT
18637	7869	10	United	United	NNP
18637	7869	11	States	States	NNP
18637	7869	12	of	of	IN
18637	7869	13	America	America	NNP
18637	7869	14	'	'	''
18637	7869	15	;	;	:
18637	7869	16	and	and	CC
18637	7869	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7869	18	title	title	NN
18637	7869	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	7869	20	be	be	VB
18637	7869	21	'	'	''
18637	7869	22	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7869	23	Excellency	Excellency	NNP
18637	7869	24	.	.	.
18637	7870	1	'	'	``
18637	7870	2	"	"	``
18637	7870	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7870	4	4	4	LS
18637	7870	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7870	6	This	this	DT
18637	7870	7	language	language	NN
18637	7870	8	recorded	record	VBD
18637	7870	9	the	the	DT
18637	7870	10	decision	decision	NN
18637	7870	11	of	of	IN
18637	7870	12	the	the	DT
18637	7870	13	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	7870	14	,	,	,
18637	7870	15	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	7870	16	in	in	IN
18637	7870	17	committee	committee	NN
18637	7870	18	of	of	IN
18637	7870	19	the	the	DT
18637	7870	20	whole	whole	NN
18637	7870	21	,	,	,
18637	7870	22	that	that	IN
18637	7870	23	the	the	DT
18637	7870	24	national	national	JJ
18637	7870	25	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7870	26	power	power	NN
18637	7870	27	should	should	MD
18637	7870	28	be	be	VB
18637	7870	29	vested	vest	VBN
18637	7870	30	in	in	IN
18637	7870	31	a	a	DT
18637	7870	32	single	single	JJ
18637	7870	33	person	person	NN
18637	7870	34	,	,	,
18637	7870	35	not	not	RB
18637	7870	36	a	a	DT
18637	7870	37	body	body	NN
18637	7870	38	.	.	.
18637	7871	1	For	for	IN
18637	7871	2	the	the	DT
18637	7871	3	rest	rest	NN
18637	7871	4	,	,	,
18637	7871	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7871	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	7871	7	a	a	DT
18637	7871	8	simple	simple	JJ
18637	7871	9	designation	designation	NN
18637	7871	10	of	of	IN
18637	7871	11	office	office	NN
18637	7871	12	.	.	.
18637	7872	1	The	the	DT
18637	7872	2	final	final	JJ
18637	7872	3	form	form	NN
18637	7872	4	of	of	IN
18637	7872	5	the	the	DT
18637	7872	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	7872	7	came	come	VBD
18637	7872	8	from	from	IN
18637	7872	9	the	the	DT
18637	7872	10	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	7872	11	of	of	IN
18637	7872	12	Style,[5	Style,[5	NNP
18637	7872	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7872	14	and	and	CC
18637	7872	15	was	be	VBD
18637	7872	16	never	never	RB
18637	7872	17	separately	separately	RB
18637	7872	18	acted	act	VBN
18637	7872	19	on	on	IN
18637	7872	20	by	by	IN
18637	7872	21	the	the	DT
18637	7872	22	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	7872	23	.	.	.
18637	7873	1	"	"	``
18637	7873	2	EXECUTIVE	executive	NN
18637	7873	3	POWER	power	NN
18637	7873	4	"	"	''
18637	7873	5	;	;	:
18637	7873	6	HAMILTON	HAMILTON	NNP
18637	7873	7	'S	's	POS
18637	7873	8	CONTRIBUTION	contribution	NN
18637	7873	9	Is	be	VBZ
18637	7873	10	this	this	DT
18637	7873	11	term	term	NN
18637	7873	12	a	a	DT
18637	7873	13	summary	summary	NN
18637	7873	14	description	description	NN
18637	7873	15	merely	merely	RB
18637	7873	16	of	of	IN
18637	7873	17	the	the	DT
18637	7873	18	powers	power	NNS
18637	7873	19	which	which	WDT
18637	7873	20	are	be	VBP
18637	7873	21	granted	grant	VBN
18637	7873	22	in	in	IN
18637	7873	23	more	more	RBR
18637	7873	24	specific	specific	JJ
18637	7873	25	terms	term	NNS
18637	7873	26	in	in	IN
18637	7873	27	succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	7873	28	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	7873	29	of	of	IN
18637	7873	30	article	article	NN
18637	7873	31	II	ii	CD
18637	7873	32	,	,	,
18637	7873	33	or	or	CC
18637	7873	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	7873	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7873	36	also	also	RB
18637	7873	37	a	a	DT
18637	7873	38	grant	grant	NN
18637	7873	39	of	of	IN
18637	7873	40	powers	power	NNS
18637	7873	41	;	;	:
18637	7873	42	and	and	CC
18637	7873	43	if	if	IN
18637	7873	44	the	the	DT
18637	7873	45	latter	latter	JJ
18637	7873	46	,	,	,
18637	7873	47	what	what	WDT
18637	7873	48	powers	power	NNS
18637	7873	49	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	7873	50	does	do	VBZ
18637	7873	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7873	52	comprise	comprise	VB
18637	7873	53	?	?	.
18637	7874	1	In	in	IN
18637	7874	2	the	the	DT
18637	7874	3	debate	debate	NN
18637	7874	4	on	on	IN
18637	7874	5	the	the	DT
18637	7874	6	location	location	NN
18637	7874	7	of	of	IN
18637	7874	8	the	the	DT
18637	7874	9	removal	removal	NN
18637	7874	10	power	power	NN
18637	7874	11	in	in	IN
18637	7874	12	the	the	DT
18637	7874	13	House	House	NNP
18637	7874	14	of	of	IN
18637	7874	15	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	7874	16	in	in	IN
18637	7874	17	1789[6	1789[6	NNP
18637	7874	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7874	19	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	7874	20	and	and	CC
18637	7874	21	others	other	NNS
18637	7874	22	urged	urge	VBD
18637	7874	23	that	that	IN
18637	7874	24	this	this	DT
18637	7874	25	was	be	VBD
18637	7874	26	"	"	``
18637	7874	27	in	in	IN
18637	7874	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7874	29	nature	nature	NN
18637	7874	30	"	"	``
18637	7874	31	an	an	DT
18637	7874	32	"	"	``
18637	7874	33	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7874	34	power";[7	power";[7	NN
18637	7874	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7874	36	and	and	CC
18637	7874	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7874	38	view	view	NN
18637	7874	39	prevailed	prevail	VBD
18637	7874	40	so	so	RB
18637	7874	41	far	far	RB
18637	7874	42	as	as	IN
18637	7874	43	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7874	44	officers	officer	NNS
18637	7874	45	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	7874	46	without	without	IN
18637	7874	47	stated	state	VBN
18637	7874	48	term	term	NN
18637	7874	49	by	by	IN
18637	7874	50	the	the	DT
18637	7874	51	President	President	NNP
18637	7874	52	,	,	,
18637	7874	53	with	with	IN
18637	7874	54	the	the	DT
18637	7874	55	advice	advice	NN
18637	7874	56	and	and	CC
18637	7874	57	consent	consent	NN
18637	7874	58	of	of	IN
18637	7874	59	the	the	DT
18637	7874	60	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	7874	61	,	,	,
18637	7874	62	were	be	VBD
18637	7874	63	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	7874	64	.	.	.
18637	7875	1	Four	four	CD
18637	7875	2	years	year	NNS
18637	7875	3	later	later	RBR
18637	7875	4	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	7875	5	,	,	,
18637	7875	6	in	in	IN
18637	7875	7	defending	defend	VBG
18637	7875	8	President	President	NNP
18637	7875	9	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	7875	10	's	's	POS
18637	7875	11	course	course	NN
18637	7875	12	in	in	IN
18637	7875	13	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	7875	14	a	a	DT
18637	7875	15	Proclamation	Proclamation	NNP
18637	7875	16	of	of	IN
18637	7875	17	Impartiality	Impartiality	NNP
18637	7875	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	7875	19	the	the	DT
18637	7875	20	outbreak	outbreak	NN
18637	7875	21	of	of	IN
18637	7875	22	war	war	NN
18637	7875	23	between	between	IN
18637	7875	24	France	France	NNP
18637	7875	25	and	and	CC
18637	7875	26	Great	Great	NNP
18637	7875	27	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	7875	28	,	,	,
18637	7875	29	developed	develop	VBD
18637	7875	30	the	the	DT
18637	7875	31	following	follow	VBG
18637	7875	32	argument	argument	NN
18637	7875	33	:	:	:
18637	7875	34	"	"	``
18637	7875	35	The	the	DT
18637	7875	36	second	second	JJ
18637	7875	37	article	article	NN
18637	7875	38	of	of	IN
18637	7875	39	the	the	DT
18637	7875	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7875	41	of	of	IN
18637	7875	42	the	the	DT
18637	7875	43	United	United	NNP
18637	7875	44	States	States	NNP
18637	7875	45	,	,	,
18637	7875	46	section	section	NN
18637	7875	47	first	first	RB
18637	7875	48	,	,	,
18637	7875	49	establishes	establish	VBZ
18637	7875	50	this	this	DT
18637	7875	51	general	general	JJ
18637	7875	52	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	7875	53	,	,	,
18637	7875	54	that	that	IN
18637	7875	55	'	'	``
18637	7875	56	the	the	DT
18637	7875	57	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	7875	58	Power	Power	NNP
18637	7875	59	shall	shall	MD
18637	7875	60	be	be	VB
18637	7875	61	vested	vest	VBN
18637	7875	62	in	in	IN
18637	7875	63	a	a	DT
18637	7875	64	President	President	NNP
18637	7875	65	of	of	IN
18637	7875	66	the	the	DT
18637	7875	67	United	United	NNP
18637	7875	68	States	States	NNP
18637	7875	69	of	of	IN
18637	7875	70	America	America	NNP
18637	7875	71	.	.	.
18637	7875	72	'	'	''
18637	7876	1	The	the	DT
18637	7876	2	same	same	JJ
18637	7876	3	article	article	NN
18637	7876	4	,	,	,
18637	7876	5	in	in	IN
18637	7876	6	a	a	DT
18637	7876	7	succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	7876	8	section	section	NN
18637	7876	9	,	,	,
18637	7876	10	proceeds	proceed	VBZ
18637	7876	11	to	to	TO
18637	7876	12	delineate	delineate	VB
18637	7876	13	particular	particular	JJ
18637	7876	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	7876	15	of	of	IN
18637	7876	16	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7876	17	power	power	NN
18637	7876	18	.	.	.
18637	7877	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7877	2	declares	declare	VBZ
18637	7877	3	,	,	,
18637	7877	4	among	among	IN
18637	7877	5	other	other	JJ
18637	7877	6	things	thing	NNS
18637	7877	7	,	,	,
18637	7877	8	that	that	IN
18637	7877	9	the	the	DT
18637	7877	10	president	president	NN
18637	7877	11	shall	shall	MD
18637	7877	12	be	be	VB
18637	7877	13	commander	commander	NN
18637	7877	14	in	in	IN
18637	7877	15	chief	chief	NN
18637	7877	16	of	of	IN
18637	7877	17	the	the	DT
18637	7877	18	army	army	NNP
18637	7877	19	and	and	CC
18637	7877	20	navy	navy	NNP
18637	7877	21	of	of	IN
18637	7877	22	the	the	DT
18637	7877	23	United	United	NNP
18637	7877	24	States	States	NNP
18637	7877	25	,	,	,
18637	7877	26	and	and	CC
18637	7877	27	of	of	IN
18637	7877	28	the	the	DT
18637	7877	29	militia	militia	NN
18637	7877	30	of	of	IN
18637	7877	31	the	the	DT
18637	7877	32	several	several	JJ
18637	7877	33	states	state	NNS
18637	7877	34	,	,	,
18637	7877	35	when	when	WRB
18637	7877	36	called	call	VBN
18637	7877	37	into	into	IN
18637	7877	38	the	the	DT
18637	7877	39	actual	actual	JJ
18637	7877	40	service	service	NN
18637	7877	41	of	of	IN
18637	7877	42	the	the	DT
18637	7877	43	United	United	NNP
18637	7877	44	States	States	NNP
18637	7877	45	;	;	:
18637	7877	46	that	that	IN
18637	7877	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7877	48	shall	shall	MD
18637	7877	49	have	have	VB
18637	7877	50	power	power	NN
18637	7877	51	,	,	,
18637	7877	52	by	by	RB
18637	7877	53	and	and	CC
18637	7877	54	with	with	IN
18637	7877	55	the	the	DT
18637	7877	56	advice	advice	NN
18637	7877	57	and	and	CC
18637	7877	58	consent	consent	NN
18637	7877	59	of	of	IN
18637	7877	60	the	the	DT
18637	7877	61	senate	senate	NNP
18637	7877	62	,	,	,
18637	7877	63	to	to	TO
18637	7877	64	make	make	VB
18637	7877	65	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	7877	66	;	;	:
18637	7877	67	that	that	IN
18637	7877	68	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7877	69	shall	shall	MD
18637	7877	70	be	be	VB
18637	7877	71	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7877	72	duty	duty	NN
18637	7877	73	to	to	TO
18637	7877	74	receive	receive	VB
18637	7877	75	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	7877	76	and	and	CC
18637	7877	77	other	other	JJ
18637	7877	78	public	public	JJ
18637	7877	79	ministers	minister	NNS
18637	7877	80	,	,	,
18637	7877	81	_	_	NNP
18637	7877	82	and	and	CC
18637	7877	83	to	to	TO
18637	7877	84	take	take	VB
18637	7877	85	care	care	NN
18637	7877	86	that	that	IN
18637	7877	87	the	the	DT
18637	7877	88	laws	law	NNS
18637	7877	89	be	be	VB
18637	7877	90	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	7877	91	executed	execute	VBN
18637	7877	92	.	.	.
18637	7877	93	_	_	NNP
18637	7877	94	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7877	95	would	would	MD
18637	7877	96	not	not	RB
18637	7877	97	consist	consist	VB
18637	7877	98	with	with	IN
18637	7877	99	the	the	DT
18637	7877	100	rules	rule	NNS
18637	7877	101	of	of	IN
18637	7877	102	sound	sound	JJ
18637	7877	103	construction	construction	NN
18637	7877	104	,	,	,
18637	7877	105	to	to	TO
18637	7877	106	consider	consider	VB
18637	7877	107	this	this	DT
18637	7877	108	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	7877	109	of	of	IN
18637	7877	110	particular	particular	JJ
18637	7877	111	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	7877	112	as	as	IN
18637	7877	113	derogating	derogate	VBG
18637	7877	114	from	from	IN
18637	7877	115	the	the	DT
18637	7877	116	more	more	RBR
18637	7877	117	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	7877	118	grant	grant	NN
18637	7877	119	in	in	IN
18637	7877	120	the	the	DT
18637	7877	121	general	general	JJ
18637	7877	122	clause	clause	NN
18637	7877	123	,	,	,
18637	7877	124	further	further	RB
18637	7877	125	than	than	IN
18637	7877	126	as	as	IN
18637	7877	127	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7877	128	may	may	MD
18637	7877	129	be	be	VB
18637	7877	130	coupled	couple	VBN
18637	7877	131	with	with	IN
18637	7877	132	express	express	JJ
18637	7877	133	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	7877	134	or	or	CC
18637	7877	135	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	7877	136	;	;	,
18637	7877	137	as	as	IN
18637	7877	138	in	in	IN
18637	7877	139	regard	regard	NN
18637	7877	140	to	to	IN
18637	7877	141	the	the	DT
18637	7877	142	co	co	NN
18637	7877	143	-	-	NN
18637	7877	144	operation	operation	NN
18637	7877	145	of	of	IN
18637	7877	146	the	the	DT
18637	7877	147	senate	senate	NNP
18637	7877	148	in	in	IN
18637	7877	149	the	the	DT
18637	7877	150	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	7877	151	of	of	IN
18637	7877	152	officers	officer	NNS
18637	7877	153	,	,	,
18637	7877	154	and	and	CC
18637	7877	155	the	the	DT
18637	7877	156	making	making	NN
18637	7877	157	of	of	IN
18637	7877	158	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	7877	159	;	;	:
18637	7877	160	which	which	WDT
18637	7877	161	are	be	VBP
18637	7877	162	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	7877	163	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	7877	164	of	of	IN
18637	7877	165	the	the	DT
18637	7877	166	general	general	JJ
18637	7877	167	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7877	168	powers	power	NNS
18637	7877	169	of	of	IN
18637	7877	170	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	7877	171	officers	officer	NNS
18637	7877	172	and	and	CC
18637	7877	173	making	make	VBG
18637	7877	174	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	7877	175	.	.	.
18637	7878	1	The	the	DT
18637	7878	2	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	7878	3	of	of	IN
18637	7878	4	a	a	DT
18637	7878	5	complete	complete	JJ
18637	7878	6	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	7878	7	of	of	IN
18637	7878	8	all	all	PDT
18637	7878	9	the	the	DT
18637	7878	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	7878	11	of	of	IN
18637	7878	12	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7878	13	authority	authority	NN
18637	7878	14	,	,	,
18637	7878	15	would	would	MD
18637	7878	16	naturally	naturally	RB
18637	7878	17	dictate	dictate	VB
18637	7878	18	the	the	DT
18637	7878	19	use	use	NN
18637	7878	20	of	of	IN
18637	7878	21	general	general	JJ
18637	7878	22	terms	term	NNS
18637	7878	23	,	,	,
18637	7878	24	and	and	CC
18637	7878	25	would	would	MD
18637	7878	26	render	render	VB
18637	7878	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7878	28	improbable	improbable	JJ
18637	7878	29	that	that	IN
18637	7878	30	a	a	DT
18637	7878	31	specification	specification	NN
18637	7878	32	of	of	IN
18637	7878	33	certain	certain	JJ
18637	7878	34	particulars	particular	NNS
18637	7878	35	was	be	VBD
18637	7878	36	designed	design	VBN
18637	7878	37	as	as	IN
18637	7878	38	a	a	DT
18637	7878	39	substitute	substitute	NN
18637	7878	40	for	for	IN
18637	7878	41	those	those	DT
18637	7878	42	terms	term	NNS
18637	7878	43	,	,	,
18637	7878	44	when	when	WRB
18637	7878	45	antecedently	antecedently	RB
18637	7878	46	used	use	VBD
18637	7878	47	.	.	.
18637	7879	1	The	the	DT
18637	7879	2	different	different	JJ
18637	7879	3	mode	mode	NN
18637	7879	4	of	of	IN
18637	7879	5	expression	expression	NN
18637	7879	6	employed	employ	VBN
18637	7879	7	in	in	IN
18637	7879	8	the	the	DT
18637	7879	9	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	7879	10	,	,	,
18637	7879	11	in	in	IN
18637	7879	12	regard	regard	NN
18637	7879	13	to	to	IN
18637	7879	14	the	the	DT
18637	7879	15	two	two	CD
18637	7879	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	7879	17	,	,	,
18637	7879	18	the	the	DT
18637	7879	19	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	7879	20	and	and	CC
18637	7879	21	the	the	DT
18637	7879	22	executive	executive	NN
18637	7879	23	,	,	,
18637	7879	24	serves	serve	VBZ
18637	7879	25	to	to	TO
18637	7879	26	confirm	confirm	VB
18637	7879	27	this	this	DT
18637	7879	28	inference	inference	NN
18637	7879	29	.	.	.
18637	7880	1	In	in	IN
18637	7880	2	the	the	DT
18637	7880	3	article	article	NN
18637	7880	4	which	which	WDT
18637	7880	5	gives	give	VBZ
18637	7880	6	the	the	DT
18637	7880	7	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	7880	8	powers	power	NNS
18637	7880	9	of	of	IN
18637	7880	10	the	the	DT
18637	7880	11	government	government	NN
18637	7880	12	,	,	,
18637	7880	13	the	the	DT
18637	7880	14	expressions	expression	NNS
18637	7880	15	are	be	VBP
18637	7880	16	,	,	,
18637	7880	17	'	'	''
18637	7880	18	All	all	DT
18637	7880	19	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	7880	20	powers	power	NNS
18637	7880	21	herein	herein	NNP
18637	7880	22	granted	grant	VBN
18637	7880	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	7880	24	be	be	VB
18637	7880	25	vested	vest	VBN
18637	7880	26	in	in	IN
18637	7880	27	a	a	DT
18637	7880	28	congress	congress	NN
18637	7880	29	of	of	IN
18637	7880	30	the	the	DT
18637	7880	31	United	United	NNP
18637	7880	32	States	States	NNP
18637	7880	33	.	.	.
18637	7880	34	'	'	''
18637	7881	1	In	in	IN
18637	7881	2	that	that	DT
18637	7881	3	which	which	WDT
18637	7881	4	grants	grant	VBZ
18637	7881	5	the	the	DT
18637	7881	6	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7881	7	power	power	NN
18637	7881	8	,	,	,
18637	7881	9	the	the	DT
18637	7881	10	expressions	expression	NNS
18637	7881	11	are	be	VBP
18637	7881	12	,	,	,
18637	7881	13	'	'	''
18637	7881	14	The	the	DT
18637	7881	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7881	16	executive	executive	NN
18637	7881	17	power	power	NN
18637	7881	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7881	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	7881	20	be	be	VB
18637	7881	21	vested	vest	VBN
18637	7881	22	in	in	IN
18637	7881	23	a	a	DT
18637	7881	24	President	President	NNP
18637	7881	25	of	of	IN
18637	7881	26	the	the	DT
18637	7881	27	United	United	NNP
18637	7881	28	States	States	NNP
18637	7881	29	.	.	.
18637	7881	30	'	'	''
18637	7882	1	The	the	DT
18637	7882	2	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	7882	3	ought	ought	MD
18637	7882	4	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	7882	5	to	to	TO
18637	7882	6	be	be	VB
18637	7882	7	considered	consider	VBN
18637	7882	8	,	,	,
18637	7882	9	as	as	IN
18637	7882	10	intended	intend	VBN
18637	7882	11	merely	merely	RB
18637	7882	12	to	to	TO
18637	7882	13	specify	specify	VB
18637	7882	14	the	the	DT
18637	7882	15	principal	principal	JJ
18637	7882	16	articles	article	NNS
18637	7882	17	implied	imply	VBN
18637	7882	18	in	in	IN
18637	7882	19	the	the	DT
18637	7882	20	definition	definition	NN
18637	7882	21	of	of	IN
18637	7882	22	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7882	23	power	power	NN
18637	7882	24	;	;	,
18637	7882	25	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	7882	26	the	the	DT
18637	7882	27	rest	rest	NN
18637	7882	28	to	to	TO
18637	7882	29	flow	flow	VB
18637	7882	30	from	from	IN
18637	7882	31	the	the	DT
18637	7882	32	general	general	JJ
18637	7882	33	grant	grant	NN
18637	7882	34	of	of	IN
18637	7882	35	that	that	DT
18637	7882	36	power	power	NN
18637	7882	37	,	,	,
18637	7882	38	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	7882	39	in	in	IN
18637	7882	40	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	7882	41	with	with	IN
18637	7882	42	other	other	JJ
18637	7882	43	parts	part	NNS
18637	7882	44	of	of	IN
18637	7882	45	the	the	DT
18637	7882	46	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7882	47	,	,	,
18637	7882	48	and	and	CC
18637	7882	49	with	with	IN
18637	7882	50	the	the	DT
18637	7882	51	principles	principle	NNS
18637	7882	52	of	of	IN
18637	7882	53	free	free	JJ
18637	7882	54	government	government	NN
18637	7882	55	.	.	.
18637	7883	1	The	the	DT
18637	7883	2	general	general	JJ
18637	7883	3	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	7883	4	of	of	IN
18637	7883	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7883	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7883	7	then	then	RB
18637	7883	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	7883	9	,	,	,
18637	7883	10	that	that	IN
18637	7883	11	the	the	DT
18637	7883	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7883	13	executive	executive	NN
18637	7883	14	power	power	NN
18637	7883	15	_	_	NNP
18637	7883	16	of	of	IN
18637	7883	17	the	the	DT
18637	7883	18	nation	nation	NN
18637	7883	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	7883	20	vested	vest	VBN
18637	7883	21	in	in	IN
18637	7883	22	the	the	DT
18637	7883	23	President	President	NNP
18637	7883	24	;	;	:
18637	7883	25	subject	subject	JJ
18637	7883	26	only	only	RB
18637	7883	27	to	to	IN
18637	7883	28	the	the	DT
18637	7883	29	_	_	NNP
18637	7883	30	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	7883	31	_	_	NNP
18637	7883	32	and	and	CC
18637	7883	33	_	_	NNP
18637	7883	34	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	7883	35	_	_	NNP
18637	7883	36	,	,	,
18637	7883	37	which	which	WDT
18637	7883	38	are	be	VBP
18637	7883	39	expressed	express	VBN
18637	7883	40	in	in	IN
18637	7883	41	the	the	DT
18637	7883	42	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	7883	43	.	.	.
18637	7884	1	"	"	``
18637	7884	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7884	3	8	8	CD
18637	7884	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7884	5	THE	the	DT
18637	7884	6	MYERS	MYERS	NNP
18637	7884	7	CASE	case	NN
18637	7884	8	These	these	DT
18637	7884	9	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
18637	7884	10	conceptions	conception	NNS
18637	7884	11	of	of	IN
18637	7884	12	the	the	DT
18637	7884	13	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7884	14	power	power	NN
18637	7884	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	7884	16	have	have	VBP
18637	7884	17	been	be	VBN
18637	7884	18	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	7884	19	by	by	IN
18637	7884	20	the	the	DT
18637	7884	21	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	7884	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7884	23	within	within	IN
18637	7884	24	recent	recent	JJ
18637	7884	25	times	time	NNS
18637	7884	26	.	.	.
18637	7885	1	In	in	IN
18637	7885	2	the	the	DT
18637	7885	3	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	7885	4	case,[9	case,[9	NN
18637	7885	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7885	6	decided	decide	VBN
18637	7885	7	in	in	IN
18637	7885	8	1926	1926	CD
18637	7885	9	,	,	,
18637	7885	10	not	not	RB
18637	7885	11	only	only	RB
18637	7885	12	was	be	VBD
18637	7885	13	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	7885	14	's	's	POS
18637	7885	15	contention	contention	NN
18637	7885	16	as	as	IN
18637	7885	17	to	to	IN
18637	7885	18	the	the	DT
18637	7885	19	location	location	NN
18637	7885	20	of	of	IN
18637	7885	21	the	the	DT
18637	7885	22	removal	removal	NN
18637	7885	23	power	power	NN
18637	7885	24	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	7885	25	,	,	,
18637	7885	26	and	and	CC
18637	7885	27	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	7885	28	extended	extend	VBN
18637	7885	29	,	,	,
18637	7885	30	but	but	CC
18637	7885	31	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	7885	32	's	's	POS
18637	7885	33	general	general	JJ
18637	7885	34	theory	theory	NN
18637	7885	35	as	as	IN
18637	7885	36	to	to	IN
18637	7885	37	the	the	DT
18637	7885	38	proper	proper	JJ
18637	7885	39	mode	mode	NN
18637	7885	40	of	of	IN
18637	7885	41	construing	construe	VBG
18637	7885	42	the	the	DT
18637	7885	43	clause	clause	NN
18637	7885	44	was	be	VBD
18637	7885	45	unqualifiedly	unqualifiedly	RB
18637	7885	46	endorsed	endorse	VBN
18637	7885	47	.	.	.
18637	7886	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	7886	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	7886	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7886	4	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	7886	5	,	,	,
18637	7886	6	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	7886	7	for	for	IN
18637	7886	8	the	the	DT
18637	7886	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7886	10	:	:	:
18637	7886	11	"	"	``
18637	7886	12	The	the	DT
18637	7886	13	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7886	14	power	power	NN
18637	7886	15	was	be	VBD
18637	7886	16	given	give	VBN
18637	7886	17	in	in	IN
18637	7886	18	general	general	JJ
18637	7886	19	terms	term	NNS
18637	7886	20	,	,	,
18637	7886	21	strengthened	strengthen	VBN
18637	7886	22	by	by	IN
18637	7886	23	specific	specific	JJ
18637	7886	24	terms	term	NNS
18637	7886	25	where	where	WRB
18637	7886	26	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	7886	27	was	be	VBD
18637	7886	28	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	7886	29	as	as	IN
18637	7886	30	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	7886	31	,	,	,
18637	7886	32	and	and	CC
18637	7886	33	was	be	VBD
18637	7886	34	limited	limit	VBN
18637	7886	35	by	by	IN
18637	7886	36	direct	direct	JJ
18637	7886	37	expressions	expression	NNS
18637	7886	38	where	where	WRB
18637	7886	39	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	7886	40	was	be	VBD
18637	7886	41	needed	need	VBN
18637	7886	42	,	,	,
18637	7886	43	*	*	NFP
18637	7886	44	*	*	NFP
18637	7886	45	*	*	NFP
18637	7886	46	"	"	''
18637	7886	47	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7886	48	10	10	CD
18637	7886	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7886	50	THE	the	DT
18637	7886	51	CURTISS	CURTISS	NNP
18637	7886	52	-	-	HYPH
18637	7886	53	WRIGHT	WRIGHT	NNP
18637	7886	54	CASE	case	NN
18637	7886	55	Ten	ten	CD
18637	7886	56	years	year	NNS
18637	7886	57	later	later	RBR
18637	7886	58	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7886	59	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	7886	60	,	,	,
18637	7886	61	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	7886	62	for	for	IN
18637	7886	63	the	the	DT
18637	7886	64	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7886	65	in	in	IN
18637	7886	66	United	United	NNP
18637	7886	67	States	States	NNP
18637	7886	68	_	_	NNP
18637	7886	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	7886	70	_	_	NNP
18637	7886	71	Curtiss	Curtiss	NNP
18637	7886	72	-	-	HYPH
18637	7886	73	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	7886	74	Corporation,[11	corporation,[11	NN
18637	7886	75	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7886	76	joined	join	VBD
18637	7886	77	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	7886	78	's	's	POS
18637	7886	79	conception	conception	NN
18637	7886	80	of	of	IN
18637	7886	81	the	the	DT
18637	7886	82	President	President	NNP
18637	7886	83	's	's	POS
18637	7886	84	role	role	NN
18637	7886	85	in	in	IN
18637	7886	86	the	the	DT
18637	7886	87	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	7886	88	relations	relation	NNS
18637	7886	89	field	field	NN
18637	7886	90	to	to	IN
18637	7886	91	the	the	DT
18637	7886	92	conception	conception	NN
18637	7886	93	that	that	IN
18637	7886	94	in	in	IN
18637	7886	95	this	this	DT
18637	7886	96	field	field	NN
18637	7886	97	the	the	DT
18637	7886	98	National	National	NNP
18637	7886	99	Government	Government	NNP
18637	7886	100	is	be	VBZ
18637	7886	101	not	not	RB
18637	7886	102	one	one	CD
18637	7886	103	of	of	IN
18637	7886	104	enumerated	enumerated	JJ
18637	7886	105	but	but	CC
18637	7886	106	of	of	IN
18637	7886	107	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	7886	108	powers;[12	powers;[12	NNPS
18637	7886	109	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7886	110	and	and	CC
18637	7886	111	the	the	DT
18637	7886	112	practical	practical	JJ
18637	7886	113	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	7886	114	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7886	115	drew	draw	VBD
18637	7886	116	was	be	VBD
18637	7886	117	that	that	IN
18637	7886	118	the	the	DT
18637	7886	119	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	7886	120	objection	objection	NN
18637	7886	121	to	to	IN
18637	7886	122	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	7886	123	of	of	IN
18637	7886	124	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	7886	125	power	power	NN
18637	7886	126	does	do	VBZ
18637	7886	127	not	not	RB
18637	7886	128	apply	apply	VB
18637	7886	129	to	to	IN
18637	7886	130	a	a	DT
18637	7886	131	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	7886	132	by	by	IN
18637	7886	133	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7886	134	to	to	IN
18637	7886	135	the	the	DT
18637	7886	136	President	President	NNP
18637	7886	137	of	of	IN
18637	7886	138	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7886	139	"	"	``
18637	7886	140	cognate	cognate	NN
18637	7886	141	"	"	''
18637	7886	142	powers	power	NNS
18637	7886	143	in	in	IN
18637	7886	144	this	this	DT
18637	7886	145	field	field	NN
18637	7886	146	;	;	:
18637	7886	147	that	that	IN
18637	7886	148	,	,	,
18637	7886	149	in	in	IN
18637	7886	150	short	short	JJ
18637	7886	151	,	,	,
18637	7886	152	the	the	DT
18637	7886	153	merged	merged	JJ
18637	7886	154	powers	power	NNS
18637	7886	155	of	of	IN
18637	7886	156	the	the	DT
18637	7886	157	two	two	CD
18637	7886	158	departments	department	NNS
18637	7886	159	may	may	MD
18637	7886	160	be	be	VB
18637	7886	161	put	put	VBN
18637	7886	162	at	at	IN
18637	7886	163	the	the	DT
18637	7886	164	President	President	NNP
18637	7886	165	's	's	POS
18637	7886	166	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	7886	167	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	7886	168	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7886	169	so	so	RB
18637	7886	170	desires	desire	VBZ
18637	7886	171	.	.	.
18637	7887	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7887	2	13	13	CD
18637	7887	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7887	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	7887	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	7887	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7887	7	alone	alone	JJ
18637	7887	8	in	in	IN
18637	7887	9	the	the	DT
18637	7887	10	field	field	NN
18637	7887	11	of	of	IN
18637	7887	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	7887	13	relations	relation	NNS
18637	7887	14	that	that	WDT
18637	7887	15	the	the	DT
18637	7887	16	opening	opening	NN
18637	7887	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	7887	18	of	of	IN
18637	7887	19	article	article	NN
18637	7887	20	II	II	NNP
18637	7887	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	7887	22	promoted	promote	VBN
18637	7887	23	latitudinarian	latitudinarian	JJ
18637	7887	24	conceptions	conception	NNS
18637	7887	25	of	of	IN
18637	7887	26	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7887	27	power	power	NN
18637	7887	28	.	.	.
18637	7888	1	Especially	especially	RB
18637	7888	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	7888	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7888	4	role	role	NN
18637	7888	5	as	as	IN
18637	7888	6	"	"	``
18637	7888	7	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	7888	8	in	in	IN
18637	7888	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	7888	10	in	in	IN
18637	7888	11	wartime	wartime	NN
18637	7888	12	"	"	``
18637	7888	13	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	7888	14	nourishment	nourishment	NN
18637	7888	15	from	from	IN
18637	7888	16	the	the	DT
18637	7888	17	same	same	JJ
18637	7888	18	source	source	NN
18637	7888	19	,	,	,
18637	7888	20	in	in	IN
18637	7888	21	recent	recent	JJ
18637	7888	22	years	year	NNS
18637	7888	23	.	.	.
18637	7889	1	The	the	DT
18637	7889	2	matter	matter	NN
18637	7889	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	7889	4	treated	treat	VBN
18637	7889	5	in	in	IN
18637	7889	6	later	later	JJ
18637	7889	7	pages	page	NNS
18637	7889	8	.	.	.
18637	7890	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7890	2	14	14	CD
18637	7890	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7890	4	THEORY	THEORY	NNP
18637	7890	5	OF	of	IN
18637	7890	6	THE	the	DT
18637	7890	7	PRESIDENTIAL	PRESIDENTIAL	NNP
18637	7890	8	OFFICE	OFFICE	VBD
18637	7890	9	The	the	DT
18637	7890	10	looseness	looseness	NN
18637	7890	11	of	of	IN
18637	7890	12	the	the	DT
18637	7890	13	grants	grant	NNS
18637	7890	14	of	of	IN
18637	7890	15	power	power	NN
18637	7890	16	to	to	IN
18637	7890	17	the	the	DT
18637	7890	18	President	President	NNP
18637	7890	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	7890	20	been	be	VBN
18637	7890	21	more	more	JJR
18637	7890	22	than	than	IN
18637	7890	23	once	once	IN
18637	7890	24	the	the	DT
18637	7890	25	subject	subject	NN
18637	7890	26	of	of	IN
18637	7890	27	animadversion	animadversion	NN
18637	7890	28	.	.	.
18637	7891	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7891	2	15	15	CD
18637	7891	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7891	4	This	this	DT
18637	7891	5	and	and	CC
18637	7891	6	the	the	DT
18637	7891	7	unity	unity	NN
18637	7891	8	of	of	IN
18637	7891	9	the	the	DT
18637	7891	10	office	office	NN
18637	7891	11	furnished	furnish	VBD
18637	7891	12	a	a	DT
18637	7891	13	text	text	NN
18637	7891	14	for	for	IN
18637	7891	15	opponents	opponent	NNS
18637	7891	16	of	of	IN
18637	7891	17	the	the	DT
18637	7891	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7891	19	while	while	IN
18637	7891	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7891	21	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	7891	22	was	be	VBD
18637	7891	23	pending	pende	VBG
18637	7891	24	.	.	.
18637	7892	1	"	"	``
18637	7892	2	Here	here	RB
18637	7892	3	,	,	,
18637	7892	4	"	"	''
18637	7892	5	according	accord	VBG
18637	7892	6	to	to	IN
18637	7892	7	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	7892	8	,	,	,
18637	7892	9	writing	write	VBG
18637	7892	10	in	in	IN
18637	7892	11	The	the	DT
18637	7892	12	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	7892	13	,	,	,
18637	7892	14	"	"	''
18637	7892	15	the	the	DT
18637	7892	16	writers	writer	NNS
18637	7892	17	against	against	IN
18637	7892	18	the	the	DT
18637	7892	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7892	20	,	,	,
18637	7892	21	seem	seem	VBP
18637	7892	22	to	to	TO
18637	7892	23	have	have	VB
18637	7892	24	taken	take	VBN
18637	7892	25	pains	pain	NNS
18637	7892	26	to	to	TO
18637	7892	27	signalize	signalize	VB
18637	7892	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7892	29	talent	talent	NN
18637	7892	30	of	of	IN
18637	7892	31	misrepresentation	misrepresentation	NN
18637	7892	32	.	.	.
18637	7893	1	"	"	``
18637	7893	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7893	3	16	16	CD
18637	7893	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7893	5	Once	once	IN
18637	7893	6	the	the	DT
18637	7893	7	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7893	8	was	be	VBD
18637	7893	9	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	7893	10	,	,	,
18637	7893	11	however	however	RB
18637	7893	12	,	,	,
18637	7893	13	the	the	DT
18637	7893	14	tables	table	NNS
18637	7893	15	were	be	VBD
18637	7893	16	turned	turn	VBN
18637	7893	17	,	,	,
18637	7893	18	and	and	CC
18637	7893	19	some	some	DT
18637	7893	20	members	member	NNS
18637	7893	21	of	of	IN
18637	7893	22	the	the	DT
18637	7893	23	first	first	JJ
18637	7893	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7893	25	,	,	,
18637	7893	26	including	include	VBG
18637	7893	27	certain	certain	JJ
18637	7893	28	former	former	JJ
18637	7893	29	members	member	NNS
18637	7893	30	of	of	IN
18637	7893	31	the	the	DT
18637	7893	32	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	7893	33	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	7893	34	,	,	,
18637	7893	35	sought	seek	VBD
18637	7893	36	to	to	TO
18637	7893	37	elaborate	elaborate	VB
18637	7893	38	the	the	DT
18637	7893	39	monarchical	monarchical	JJ
18637	7893	40	aspects	aspect	NNS
18637	7893	41	of	of	IN
18637	7893	42	the	the	DT
18637	7893	43	office	office	NN
18637	7893	44	.	.	.
18637	7894	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7894	2	would	would	MD
18637	7894	3	fain	fain	VB
18637	7894	4	give	give	VB
18637	7894	5	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7894	6	a	a	DT
18637	7894	7	title	title	NN
18637	7894	8	,	,	,
18637	7894	9	_	_	NNP
18637	7894	10	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7894	11	Excellency	Excellency	NNP
18637	7894	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7894	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7894	14	already	already	RB
18637	7894	15	applied	apply	VBN
18637	7894	16	in	in	IN
18637	7894	17	several	several	JJ
18637	7894	18	States	state	NNS
18637	7894	19	to	to	IN
18637	7894	20	the	the	DT
18637	7894	21	governors	governor	NNS
18637	7894	22	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	7894	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7894	24	,	,	,
18637	7894	25	_	_	NNP
18637	7894	26	Highness	Highness	NNP
18637	7894	27	_	_	NNP
18637	7894	28	,	,	,
18637	7894	29	_	_	NNP
18637	7894	30	Elective	Elective	NNP
18637	7894	31	Majesty	Majesty	NNP
18637	7894	32	_	_	NNP
18637	7894	33	,	,	,
18637	7894	34	being	be	VBG
18637	7894	35	suggestions	suggestion	NNS
18637	7894	36	.	.	.
18637	7895	1	Ellsworth	Ellsworth	NNP
18637	7895	2	of	of	IN
18637	7895	3	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	7895	4	wished	wish	VBD
18637	7895	5	to	to	TO
18637	7895	6	see	see	VB
18637	7895	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7895	8	_	_	NNP
18637	7895	9	name	name	NN
18637	7895	10	or	or	CC
18637	7895	11	place	place	NN
18637	7895	12	_	_	NNP
18637	7895	13	inserted	insert	VBN
18637	7895	14	in	in	IN
18637	7895	15	the	the	DT
18637	7895	16	enacting	enact	VBG
18637	7895	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	7895	18	of	of	IN
18637	7895	19	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	7895	20	.	.	.
18637	7896	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7896	2	contrived	contrive	VBD
18637	7896	3	to	to	TO
18637	7896	4	make	make	VB
18637	7896	5	a	a	DT
18637	7896	6	ceremony	ceremony	NN
18637	7896	7	of	of	IN
18637	7896	8	the	the	DT
18637	7896	9	President	President	NNP
18637	7896	10	's	's	POS
18637	7896	11	appearances	appearance	NNS
18637	7896	12	before	before	IN
18637	7896	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7896	14	,	,	,
18637	7896	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7896	16	annual	annual	JJ
18637	7896	17	address	address	NN
18637	7896	18	to	to	IN
18637	7896	19	which	which	WDT
18637	7896	20	,	,	,
18637	7896	21	given	give	VBN
18637	7896	22	in	in	IN
18637	7896	23	person	person	NN
18637	7896	24	,	,	,
18637	7896	25	was	be	VBD
18637	7896	26	answered	answer	VBN
18637	7896	27	by	by	IN
18637	7896	28	a	a	DT
18637	7896	29	reply	reply	NN
18637	7896	30	equally	equally	RB
18637	7896	31	formal	formal	JJ
18637	7896	32	.	.	.
18637	7897	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7897	2	17	17	CD
18637	7897	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7897	4	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7897	5	sought	seek	VBD
18637	7897	6	to	to	TO
18637	7897	7	enact	enact	VB
18637	7897	8	that	that	IN
18637	7897	9	"	"	``
18637	7897	10	all	all	DT
18637	7897	11	writs	writ	NNS
18637	7897	12	and	and	CC
18637	7897	13	processes	process	NNS
18637	7897	14	,	,	,
18637	7897	15	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	7897	16	out	out	IN
18637	7897	17	of	of	IN
18637	7897	18	the	the	DT
18637	7897	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	7897	20	or	or	CC
18637	7897	21	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	7897	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	7897	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	7897	24	be	be	VB
18637	7897	25	in	in	IN
18637	7897	26	the	the	DT
18637	7897	27	name	name	NN
18637	7897	28	of	of	IN
18637	7897	29	the	the	DT
18637	7897	30	President	President	NNP
18637	7897	31	of	of	IN
18637	7897	32	the	the	DT
18637	7897	33	United	United	NNP
18637	7897	34	States	States	NNP
18637	7897	35	.	.	.
18637	7897	36	"	"	''
18637	7898	1	Although	although	IN
18637	7898	2	the	the	DT
18637	7898	3	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	7898	4	failed	fail	VBD
18637	7898	5	,	,	,
18637	7898	6	owing	owe	VBG
18637	7898	7	to	to	IN
18637	7898	8	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	7898	9	in	in	IN
18637	7898	10	the	the	DT
18637	7898	11	House	House	NNP
18637	7898	12	,	,	,
18637	7898	13	the	the	DT
18637	7898	14	idea	idea	NN
18637	7898	15	was	be	VBD
18637	7898	16	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	7898	17	by	by	IN
18637	7898	18	the	the	DT
18637	7898	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	7898	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7898	21	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7898	22	in	in	IN
18637	7898	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7898	24	first	first	JJ
18637	7898	25	term	term	NN
18637	7898	26	,	,	,
18637	7898	27	that	that	DT
18637	7898	28	of	of	IN
18637	7898	29	February	February	NNP
18637	7898	30	1790	1790	CD
18637	7898	31	,	,	,
18637	7898	32	when	when	WRB
18637	7898	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7898	34	"	"	``
18637	7898	35	_	_	NNP
18637	7898	36	ordered	order	VBD
18637	7898	37	_	_	NNP
18637	7898	38	,	,	,
18637	7898	39	That	that	DT
18637	7898	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7898	41	unless	unless	IN
18637	7898	42	,	,	,
18637	7898	43	and	and	CC
18637	7898	44	until	until	IN
18637	7898	45	,	,	,
18637	7898	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7898	47	shall	shall	MD
18637	7898	48	be	be	VB
18637	7898	49	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	7898	50	provided	provide	VBN
18637	7898	51	by	by	IN
18637	7898	52	law	law	NN
18637	7898	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7898	54	all	all	DT
18637	7898	55	process	process	NN
18637	7898	56	of	of	IN
18637	7898	57	this	this	DT
18637	7898	58	court	court	NN
18637	7898	59	shall	shall	MD
18637	7898	60	be	be	VB
18637	7898	61	in	in	IN
18637	7898	62	the	the	DT
18637	7898	63	name	name	NN
18637	7898	64	of	of	IN
18637	7898	65	'	'	''
18637	7898	66	the	the	DT
18637	7898	67	President	President	NNP
18637	7898	68	of	of	IN
18637	7898	69	the	the	DT
18637	7898	70	United	United	NNP
18637	7898	71	States,'"[18	States,'"[18	''
18637	7898	72	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7898	73	and	and	CC
18637	7898	74	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7898	75	has	have	VBZ
18637	7898	76	never	never	RB
18637	7898	77	been	be	VBN
18637	7898	78	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	7898	79	provided	provide	VBN
18637	7898	80	by	by	IN
18637	7898	81	law	law	NN
18637	7898	82	.	.	.
18637	7899	1	Meantime	meantime	RB
18637	7899	2	,	,	,
18637	7899	3	on	on	IN
18637	7899	4	October	October	NNP
18637	7899	5	3	3	CD
18637	7899	6	,	,	,
18637	7899	7	1789	1789	CD
18637	7899	8	,	,	,
18637	7899	9	President	President	NNP
18637	7899	10	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	7899	11	had	have	VBD
18637	7899	12	,	,	,
18637	7899	13	at	at	IN
18637	7899	14	the	the	DT
18637	7899	15	request	request	NN
18637	7899	16	of	of	IN
18637	7899	17	a	a	DT
18637	7899	18	joint	joint	JJ
18637	7899	19	committee	committee	NN
18637	7899	20	of	of	IN
18637	7899	21	"	"	``
18637	7899	22	both	both	DT
18637	7899	23	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	7899	24	of	of	IN
18637	7899	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7899	26	,	,	,
18637	7899	27	"	"	''
18637	7899	28	issued	issue	VBD
18637	7899	29	the	the	DT
18637	7899	30	first	first	JJ
18637	7899	31	Thanksgiving	Thanksgiving	NNP
18637	7899	32	Proclamation	Proclamation	NNP
18637	7899	33	.	.	.
18637	7900	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7900	2	19	19	CD
18637	7900	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7900	4	The	the	DT
18637	7900	5	"	"	``
18637	7900	6	revolution	revolution	NN
18637	7900	7	of	of	IN
18637	7900	8	1800	1800	CD
18637	7900	9	"	"	''
18637	7900	10	was	be	VBD
18637	7900	11	,	,	,
18637	7900	12	in	in	IN
18637	7900	13	the	the	DT
18637	7900	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	7900	15	of	of	IN
18637	7900	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7900	17	principal	principal	JJ
18637	7900	18	author	author	NN
18637	7900	19	,	,	,
18637	7900	20	a	a	DT
18637	7900	21	revolution	revolution	NN
18637	7900	22	against	against	IN
18637	7900	23	monarchical	monarchical	JJ
18637	7900	24	tendencies	tendency	NNS
18637	7900	25	,	,	,
18637	7900	26	and	and	CC
18637	7900	27	making	make	VBG
18637	7900	28	a	a	DT
18637	7900	29	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	7900	30	of	of	IN
18637	7900	31	the	the	DT
18637	7900	32	fact	fact	NN
18637	7900	33	that	that	IN
18637	7900	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7900	35	was	be	VBD
18637	7900	36	a	a	DT
18637	7900	37	bad	bad	JJ
18637	7900	38	public	public	JJ
18637	7900	39	speaker	speaker	NN
18637	7900	40	,	,	,
18637	7900	41	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	7900	42	,	,	,
18637	7900	43	in	in	IN
18637	7900	44	a	a	DT
18637	7900	45	symbolic	symbolic	JJ
18637	7900	46	gesture	gesture	NN
18637	7900	47	,	,	,
18637	7900	48	substituted	substitute	VBD
18637	7900	49	the	the	DT
18637	7900	50	written	write	VBN
18637	7900	51	message	message	NN
18637	7900	52	for	for	IN
18637	7900	53	the	the	DT
18637	7900	54	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7900	55	address	address	NN
18637	7900	56	.	.	.
18637	7901	1	But	but	CC
18637	7901	2	the	the	DT
18637	7901	3	claims	claim	NNS
18637	7901	4	of	of	IN
18637	7901	5	the	the	DT
18637	7901	6	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7901	7	office	office	NN
18637	7901	8	to	to	TO
18637	7901	9	power	power	VB
18637	7901	10	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	7901	11	in	in	IN
18637	7901	12	no	no	DT
18637	7901	13	wise	wise	JJ
18637	7901	14	abated,[20	abated,[20	CD
18637	7901	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7901	16	although	although	IN
18637	7901	17	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	7901	18	had	have	VBD
18637	7901	19	predicted	predict	VBN
18637	7901	20	that	that	IN
18637	7901	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7901	22	would;[21	would;[21	NNP
18637	7901	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7901	24	to	to	IN
18637	7901	25	the	the	DT
18637	7901	26	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	7901	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7901	28	in	in	IN
18637	7901	29	some	some	DT
18637	7901	30	respects	respect	NNS
18637	7901	31	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
18637	7901	32	upon	upon	IN
18637	7901	33	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7901	34	.	.	.
18637	7902	1	After	after	IN
18637	7902	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7902	3	day	day	NN
18637	7902	4	,	,	,
18637	7902	5	however	however	RB
18637	7902	6	,	,	,
18637	7902	7	the	the	DT
18637	7902	8	office	office	NN
18637	7902	9	passed	pass	VBD
18637	7902	10	into	into	IN
18637	7902	11	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	7902	12	eclipse	eclipse	NN
18637	7902	13	behind	behind	IN
18637	7902	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7902	15	own	own	JJ
18637	7902	16	creature	creature	NN
18637	7902	17	,	,	,
18637	7902	18	the	the	DT
18637	7902	19	Cabinet,[22	Cabinet,[22	NNP
18637	7902	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7902	21	an	an	DT
18637	7902	22	ignominy	ignominy	NN
18637	7902	23	from	from	IN
18637	7902	24	which	which	WDT
18637	7902	25	Andrew	Andrew	NNP
18637	7902	26	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	7902	27	rescued	rescue	VBD
18637	7902	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7902	29	.	.	.
18637	7903	1	As	as	IN
18637	7903	2	"	"	``
18637	7903	3	the	the	DT
18637	7903	4	People	People	NNPS
18637	7903	5	's	's	POS
18637	7903	6	Choice	Choice	NNP
18637	7903	7	,	,	,
18637	7903	8	"	"	''
18637	7903	9	as	as	IN
18637	7903	10	all	all	RB
18637	7903	11	by	by	IN
18637	7903	12	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7903	13	"	"	``
18637	7903	14	one	one	CD
18637	7903	15	of	of	IN
18637	7903	16	the	the	DT
18637	7903	17	three	three	CD
18637	7903	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7903	19	equal	equal	JJ
18637	7903	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7903	21	departments	department	NNS
18637	7903	22	of	of	IN
18637	7903	23	government,"[23	government,"[23	NNP
18637	7903	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7903	25	as	as	IN
18637	7903	26	the	the	DT
18637	7903	27	leader	leader	NN
18637	7903	28	of	of	IN
18637	7903	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7903	30	party	party	NN
18637	7903	31	,	,	,
18637	7903	32	as	as	IN
18637	7903	33	the	the	DT
18637	7903	34	embodiment	embodiment	NN
18637	7903	35	of	of	IN
18637	7903	36	the	the	DT
18637	7903	37	unity	unity	NN
18637	7903	38	of	of	IN
18637	7903	39	the	the	DT
18637	7903	40	country,[24	country,[24	CD
18637	7903	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7903	42	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	7903	43	stamped	stamp	VBD
18637	7903	44	upon	upon	IN
18637	7903	45	the	the	DT
18637	7903	46	Presidency	Presidency	NNP
18637	7903	47	the	the	DT
18637	7903	48	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	7903	49	features	feature	NNS
18637	7903	50	of	of	IN
18637	7903	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7903	52	final	final	JJ
18637	7903	53	character	character	NN
18637	7903	54	,	,	,
18637	7903	55	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	7903	56	reviving	revive	VBG
18637	7903	57	,	,	,
18637	7903	58	in	in	IN
18637	7903	59	the	the	DT
18637	7903	60	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	7903	61	of	of	IN
18637	7903	62	Henry	Henry	NNP
18637	7903	63	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	7903	64	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	7903	65	,	,	,
18637	7903	66	"	"	''
18637	7903	67	the	the	DT
18637	7903	68	oldest	old	JJS
18637	7903	69	political	political	JJ
18637	7903	70	institution	institution	NN
18637	7903	71	of	of	IN
18637	7903	72	the	the	DT
18637	7903	73	race	race	NN
18637	7903	74	,	,	,
18637	7903	75	the	the	DT
18637	7903	76	elective	elective	JJ
18637	7903	77	Kingship	Kingship	NNP
18637	7903	78	.	.	.
18637	7904	1	"	"	``
18637	7904	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7904	3	25	25	CD
18637	7904	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7904	5	The	the	DT
18637	7904	6	modern	modern	JJ
18637	7904	7	theory	theory	NN
18637	7904	8	of	of	IN
18637	7904	9	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7904	10	power	power	NN
18637	7904	11	was	be	VBD
18637	7904	12	the	the	DT
18637	7904	13	contribution	contribution	NN
18637	7904	14	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	7904	15	of	of	IN
18637	7904	16	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	7904	17	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	7904	18	;	;	:
18637	7904	19	the	the	DT
18637	7904	20	modern	modern	JJ
18637	7904	21	conception	conception	NN
18637	7904	22	of	of	IN
18637	7904	23	the	the	DT
18637	7904	24	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7904	25	office	office	NN
18637	7904	26	was	be	VBD
18637	7904	27	the	the	DT
18637	7904	28	contribution	contribution	NN
18637	7904	29	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	7904	30	of	of	IN
18637	7904	31	Andrew	Andrew	NNP
18637	7904	32	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	7904	33	and	and	CC
18637	7904	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7904	35	times	time	NNS
18637	7904	36	.	.	.
18637	7905	1	"	"	``
18637	7905	2	THE	the	DT
18637	7905	3	TERM	term	NN
18637	7905	4	OF	of	IN
18637	7905	5	FOUR	four	CD
18637	7905	6	YEARS	year	NNS
18637	7905	7	"	"	``
18637	7905	8	Formerly	formerly	RB
18637	7905	9	the	the	DT
18637	7905	10	term	term	NN
18637	7905	11	of	of	IN
18637	7905	12	four	four	CD
18637	7905	13	years	year	NNS
18637	7905	14	during	during	IN
18637	7905	15	which	which	WDT
18637	7905	16	the	the	DT
18637	7905	17	President	President	NNP
18637	7905	18	"	"	``
18637	7905	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	7905	20	hold	hold	VB
18637	7905	21	office	office	NN
18637	7905	22	"	"	''
18637	7905	23	was	be	VBD
18637	7905	24	reckoned	reckon	VBN
18637	7905	25	from	from	IN
18637	7905	26	March	March	NNP
18637	7905	27	4	4	CD
18637	7905	28	of	of	IN
18637	7905	29	the	the	DT
18637	7905	30	alternate	alternate	JJ
18637	7905	31	odd	odd	JJ
18637	7905	32	years	year	NNS
18637	7905	33	beginning	begin	VBG
18637	7905	34	with	with	IN
18637	7905	35	1789	1789	CD
18637	7905	36	.	.	.
18637	7906	1	This	this	DT
18637	7906	2	came	come	VBD
18637	7906	3	about	about	RP
18637	7906	4	from	from	IN
18637	7906	5	the	the	DT
18637	7906	6	circumstance	circumstance	NN
18637	7906	7	that	that	WDT
18637	7906	8	under	under	IN
18637	7906	9	the	the	DT
18637	7906	10	act	act	NN
18637	7906	11	of	of	IN
18637	7906	12	September	September	NNP
18637	7906	13	13	13	CD
18637	7906	14	,	,	,
18637	7906	15	1788	1788	CD
18637	7906	16	,	,	,
18637	7906	17	of	of	IN
18637	7906	18	"	"	``
18637	7906	19	the	the	DT
18637	7906	20	Old	Old	NNP
18637	7906	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7906	22	,	,	,
18637	7906	23	"	"	''
18637	7906	24	the	the	DT
18637	7906	25	first	first	JJ
18637	7906	26	Wednesday	Wednesday	NNP
18637	7906	27	in	in	IN
18637	7906	28	March	March	NNP
18637	7906	29	,	,	,
18637	7906	30	which	which	WDT
18637	7906	31	was	be	VBD
18637	7906	32	March	March	NNP
18637	7906	33	4	4	CD
18637	7906	34	,	,	,
18637	7906	35	1789	1789	CD
18637	7906	36	,	,	,
18637	7906	37	was	be	VBD
18637	7906	38	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	7906	39	as	as	IN
18637	7906	40	the	the	DT
18637	7906	41	time	time	NN
18637	7906	42	for	for	IN
18637	7906	43	commencing	commence	VBG
18637	7906	44	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	7906	45	under	under	IN
18637	7906	46	the	the	DT
18637	7906	47	said	say	VBN
18637	7906	48	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7906	49	.	.	.
18637	7907	1	Although	although	IN
18637	7907	2	as	as	IN
18637	7907	3	a	a	DT
18637	7907	4	matter	matter	NN
18637	7907	5	of	of	IN
18637	7907	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	7907	7	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	7907	8	was	be	VBD
18637	7907	9	not	not	RB
18637	7907	10	inaugurated	inaugurate	VBN
18637	7907	11	until	until	IN
18637	7907	12	April	April	NNP
18637	7907	13	30	30	CD
18637	7907	14	of	of	IN
18637	7907	15	that	that	DT
18637	7907	16	year	year	NN
18637	7907	17	,	,	,
18637	7907	18	by	by	IN
18637	7907	19	an	an	DT
18637	7907	20	act	act	NN
18637	7907	21	approved	approve	VBN
18637	7907	22	March	March	NNP
18637	7907	23	1	1	CD
18637	7907	24	,	,	,
18637	7907	25	1792	1792	CD
18637	7907	26	,	,	,
18637	7907	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7907	28	was	be	VBD
18637	7907	29	provided	provide	VBN
18637	7907	30	that	that	IN
18637	7907	31	the	the	DT
18637	7907	32	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7907	33	term	term	NN
18637	7907	34	should	should	MD
18637	7907	35	be	be	VB
18637	7907	36	reckoned	reckon	VBN
18637	7907	37	from	from	IN
18637	7907	38	the	the	DT
18637	7907	39	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	7907	40	day	day	NN
18637	7907	41	of	of	IN
18637	7907	42	March	March	NNP
18637	7907	43	next	next	IN
18637	7907	44	succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	7907	45	the	the	DT
18637	7907	46	date	date	NN
18637	7907	47	of	of	IN
18637	7907	48	election	election	NN
18637	7907	49	.	.	.
18637	7908	1	And	and	CC
18637	7908	2	so	so	RB
18637	7908	3	things	thing	NNS
18637	7908	4	stood	stand	VBD
18637	7908	5	until	until	IN
18637	7908	6	the	the	DT
18637	7908	7	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	7908	8	of	of	IN
18637	7908	9	the	the	DT
18637	7908	10	Twentieth	Twentieth	NNP
18637	7908	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	7908	12	by	by	IN
18637	7908	13	which	which	WDT
18637	7908	14	the	the	DT
18637	7908	15	terms	term	NNS
18637	7908	16	of	of	IN
18637	7908	17	the	the	DT
18637	7908	18	President	President	NNP
18637	7908	19	and	and	CC
18637	7908	20	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7908	21	President	President	NNP
18637	7908	22	end	end	VBP
18637	7908	23	at	at	IN
18637	7908	24	noon	noon	NN
18637	7908	25	on	on	IN
18637	7908	26	the	the	DT
18637	7908	27	20th	20th	NN
18637	7908	28	of	of	IN
18637	7908	29	January	January	NNP
18637	7908	30	.	.	.
18637	7909	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7909	2	26	26	CD
18637	7909	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7909	4	THE	the	DT
18637	7909	5	ANTI	anti	JJ
18637	7909	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	7909	7	THIRD	third	JJ
18637	7909	8	TERM	term	NN
18637	7909	9	TRADITION	tradition	NN
18637	7909	10	The	the	DT
18637	7909	11	prevailing	prevail	VBG
18637	7909	12	sentiment	sentiment	NN
18637	7909	13	of	of	IN
18637	7909	14	the	the	DT
18637	7909	15	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	7909	16	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	7909	17	favored	favor	VBD
18637	7909	18	the	the	DT
18637	7909	19	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	7909	20	eligibility	eligibility	NN
18637	7909	21	of	of	IN
18637	7909	22	the	the	DT
18637	7909	23	President	President	NNP
18637	7909	24	.	.	.
18637	7910	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7910	2	was	be	VBD
18637	7910	3	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	7910	4	who	who	WP
18637	7910	5	raised	raise	VBD
18637	7910	6	the	the	DT
18637	7910	7	objection	objection	NN
18637	7910	8	that	that	WDT
18637	7910	9	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	7910	10	eligibility	eligibility	NN
18637	7910	11	would	would	MD
18637	7910	12	in	in	IN
18637	7910	13	fact	fact	NN
18637	7910	14	be	be	VB
18637	7910	15	for	for	IN
18637	7910	16	life	life	NN
18637	7910	17	and	and	CC
18637	7910	18	degenerate	degenerate	VB
18637	7910	19	into	into	IN
18637	7910	20	an	an	DT
18637	7910	21	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	7910	22	.	.	.
18637	7911	1	Prior	prior	RB
18637	7911	2	to	to	IN
18637	7911	3	1940	1940	CD
18637	7911	4	the	the	DT
18637	7911	5	idea	idea	NN
18637	7911	6	that	that	IN
18637	7911	7	no	no	DT
18637	7911	8	President	President	NNP
18637	7911	9	should	should	MD
18637	7911	10	hold	hold	VB
18637	7911	11	for	for	IN
18637	7911	12	more	more	JJR
18637	7911	13	than	than	IN
18637	7911	14	two	two	CD
18637	7911	15	terms	term	NNS
18637	7911	16	was	be	VBD
18637	7911	17	generally	generally	RB
18637	7911	18	thought	think	VBN
18637	7911	19	to	to	TO
18637	7911	20	be	be	VB
18637	7911	21	a	a	DT
18637	7911	22	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	7911	23	tradition	tradition	NN
18637	7911	24	,	,	,
18637	7911	25	although	although	IN
18637	7911	26	some	some	DT
18637	7911	27	quibbles	quibble	NNS
18637	7911	28	had	have	VBD
18637	7911	29	been	be	VBN
18637	7911	30	raised	raise	VBN
18637	7911	31	as	as	IN
18637	7911	32	to	to	IN
18637	7911	33	the	the	DT
18637	7911	34	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	7911	35	of	of	IN
18637	7911	36	the	the	DT
18637	7911	37	word	word	NN
18637	7911	38	"	"	``
18637	7911	39	term	term	NN
18637	7911	40	"	"	''
18637	7911	41	.	.	.
18637	7912	1	President	President	NNP
18637	7912	2	Franklin	Franklin	NNP
18637	7912	3	D.	D.	NNP
18637	7912	4	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	7912	5	's	's	POS
18637	7912	6	violation	violation	NN
18637	7912	7	of	of	IN
18637	7912	8	the	the	DT
18637	7912	9	tradition	tradition	NN
18637	7912	10	led	lead	VBD
18637	7912	11	to	to	IN
18637	7912	12	the	the	DT
18637	7912	13	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	7912	14	by	by	IN
18637	7912	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7912	16	on	on	IN
18637	7912	17	March	March	NNP
18637	7912	18	24	24	CD
18637	7912	19	,	,	,
18637	7912	20	1947	1947	CD
18637	7912	21	,	,	,
18637	7912	22	of	of	IN
18637	7912	23	an	an	DT
18637	7912	24	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	7912	25	to	to	IN
18637	7912	26	the	the	DT
18637	7912	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7912	28	to	to	TO
18637	7912	29	rescue	rescue	VB
18637	7912	30	the	the	DT
18637	7912	31	tradition	tradition	NN
18637	7912	32	by	by	IN
18637	7912	33	embodying	embody	VBG
18637	7912	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7912	35	in	in	IN
18637	7912	36	the	the	DT
18637	7912	37	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	7912	38	Document	Document	NNP
18637	7912	39	.	.	.
18637	7913	1	The	the	DT
18637	7913	2	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	7913	3	became	become	VBD
18637	7913	4	a	a	DT
18637	7913	5	part	part	NN
18637	7913	6	of	of	IN
18637	7913	7	the	the	DT
18637	7913	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7913	9	on	on	IN
18637	7913	10	February	February	NNP
18637	7913	11	27	27	CD
18637	7913	12	,	,	,
18637	7913	13	1951	1951	CD
18637	7913	14	,	,	,
18637	7913	15	in	in	IN
18637	7913	16	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	7913	17	of	of	IN
18637	7913	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7913	19	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	7913	20	by	by	IN
18637	7913	21	the	the	DT
18637	7913	22	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	7913	23	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	7913	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	7913	25	sixth	sixth	JJ
18637	7913	26	State	State	NNP
18637	7913	27	,	,	,
18637	7913	28	which	which	WDT
18637	7913	29	was	be	VBD
18637	7913	30	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	7913	31	.	.	.
18637	7914	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7914	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7914	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7914	4	pp	pp	NNP
18637	7914	5	.	.	.
18637	7915	1	54	54	CD
18637	7915	2	,	,	,
18637	7915	3	1236	1236	CD
18637	7915	4	.	.	.
18637	7916	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7916	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	7916	3	's	's	POS
18637	7916	4	Note	note	NN
18637	7916	5	:	:	:
18637	7916	6	Page	page	NN
18637	7916	7	1236	1236	CD
18637	7916	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	7916	9	blank	blank	JJ
18637	7916	10	.	.	.
18637	7917	1	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7917	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7917	3	27	27	CD
18637	7917	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7917	5	Clause	clause	NN
18637	7917	6	2	2	CD
18637	7917	7	.	.	.
18637	7918	1	Each	each	DT
18637	7918	2	State	state	NN
18637	7918	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	7918	4	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	7918	5	,	,	,
18637	7918	6	in	in	IN
18637	7918	7	such	such	JJ
18637	7918	8	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	7918	9	as	as	IN
18637	7918	10	the	the	DT
18637	7918	11	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	7918	12	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	7918	13	may	may	MD
18637	7918	14	direct	direct	VB
18637	7918	15	,	,	,
18637	7918	16	a	a	DT
18637	7918	17	Number	Number	NNP
18637	7918	18	of	of	IN
18637	7918	19	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	7918	20	,	,	,
18637	7918	21	equal	equal	JJ
18637	7918	22	to	to	IN
18637	7918	23	the	the	DT
18637	7918	24	whole	whole	JJ
18637	7918	25	Number	Number	NNP
18637	7918	26	of	of	IN
18637	7918	27	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	7918	28	and	and	CC
18637	7918	29	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	7918	30	to	to	TO
18637	7918	31	which	which	WDT
18637	7918	32	the	the	DT
18637	7918	33	State	state	NN
18637	7918	34	may	may	MD
18637	7918	35	be	be	VB
18637	7918	36	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	7918	37	in	in	IN
18637	7918	38	the	the	DT
18637	7918	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7918	40	;	;	:
18637	7918	41	but	but	CC
18637	7918	42	no	no	DT
18637	7918	43	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	7918	44	or	or	CC
18637	7918	45	Representative	Representative	NNP
18637	7918	46	,	,	,
18637	7918	47	or	or	CC
18637	7918	48	Person	person	NN
18637	7918	49	holding	hold	VBG
18637	7918	50	an	an	DT
18637	7918	51	Office	Office	NNP
18637	7918	52	of	of	IN
18637	7918	53	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	7918	54	or	or	CC
18637	7918	55	Profit	Profit	NNP
18637	7918	56	under	under	IN
18637	7918	57	the	the	DT
18637	7918	58	United	United	NNP
18637	7918	59	States	States	NNP
18637	7918	60	,	,	,
18637	7918	61	shall	shall	MD
18637	7918	62	be	be	VB
18637	7918	63	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	7918	64	an	an	DT
18637	7918	65	Elector	Elector	NNP
18637	7918	66	.	.	.
18637	7919	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	7919	2	3	3	CD
18637	7919	3	.	.	.
18637	7920	1	The	the	DT
18637	7920	2	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	7920	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	7920	4	meet	meet	VB
18637	7920	5	in	in	IN
18637	7920	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7920	7	respective	respective	JJ
18637	7920	8	States	state	NNS
18637	7920	9	,	,	,
18637	7920	10	and	and	CC
18637	7920	11	vote	vote	NN
18637	7920	12	by	by	IN
18637	7920	13	Ballot	Ballot	NNP
18637	7920	14	for	for	IN
18637	7920	15	two	two	CD
18637	7920	16	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	7920	17	,	,	,
18637	7920	18	of	of	IN
18637	7920	19	whom	whom	WP
18637	7920	20	one	one	CD
18637	7920	21	at	at	RB
18637	7920	22	least	least	JJS
18637	7920	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	7920	24	not	not	RB
18637	7920	25	be	be	VB
18637	7920	26	an	an	DT
18637	7920	27	Inhabitant	Inhabitant	NNP
18637	7920	28	of	of	IN
18637	7920	29	the	the	DT
18637	7920	30	same	same	JJ
18637	7920	31	State	state	NN
18637	7920	32	with	with	IN
18637	7920	33	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7920	34	.	.	.
18637	7921	1	And	and	CC
18637	7921	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7921	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	7921	4	make	make	VB
18637	7921	5	a	a	DT
18637	7921	6	List	list	NN
18637	7921	7	of	of	IN
18637	7921	8	all	all	PDT
18637	7921	9	the	the	DT
18637	7921	10	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	7921	11	voted	vote	VBD
18637	7921	12	for	for	IN
18637	7921	13	,	,	,
18637	7921	14	and	and	CC
18637	7921	15	of	of	IN
18637	7921	16	the	the	DT
18637	7921	17	Number	Number	NNP
18637	7921	18	of	of	IN
18637	7921	19	Votes	vote	NNS
18637	7921	20	for	for	IN
18637	7921	21	each	each	DT
18637	7921	22	;	;	:
18637	7921	23	which	which	WDT
18637	7921	24	List	list	VBP
18637	7921	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7921	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	7921	27	sign	sign	VB
18637	7921	28	and	and	CC
18637	7921	29	certify	certify	VB
18637	7921	30	,	,	,
18637	7921	31	and	and	CC
18637	7921	32	transmit	transmit	VB
18637	7921	33	sealed	seal	VBN
18637	7921	34	to	to	IN
18637	7921	35	the	the	DT
18637	7921	36	Seat	Seat	NNP
18637	7921	37	of	of	IN
18637	7921	38	Government	Government	NNP
18637	7921	39	of	of	IN
18637	7921	40	the	the	DT
18637	7921	41	United	United	NNP
18637	7921	42	States	States	NNP
18637	7921	43	,	,	,
18637	7921	44	directed	direct	VBN
18637	7921	45	to	to	IN
18637	7921	46	the	the	DT
18637	7921	47	President	President	NNP
18637	7921	48	of	of	IN
18637	7921	49	the	the	DT
18637	7921	50	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	7921	51	.	.	.
18637	7922	1	The	the	DT
18637	7922	2	President	President	NNP
18637	7922	3	of	of	IN
18637	7922	4	the	the	DT
18637	7922	5	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	7922	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	7922	7	,	,	,
18637	7922	8	in	in	IN
18637	7922	9	the	the	DT
18637	7922	10	Presence	Presence	NNP
18637	7922	11	of	of	IN
18637	7922	12	the	the	DT
18637	7922	13	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	7922	14	and	and	CC
18637	7922	15	House	House	NNP
18637	7922	16	of	of	IN
18637	7922	17	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	7922	18	,	,	,
18637	7922	19	open	open	VB
18637	7922	20	all	all	PDT
18637	7922	21	the	the	DT
18637	7922	22	Certificates	Certificates	NNPS
18637	7922	23	,	,	,
18637	7922	24	and	and	CC
18637	7922	25	the	the	DT
18637	7922	26	Votes	Votes	NNPS
18637	7922	27	shall	shall	MD
18637	7922	28	then	then	RB
18637	7922	29	be	be	VB
18637	7922	30	counted	count	VBN
18637	7922	31	.	.	.
18637	7923	1	The	the	DT
18637	7923	2	Person	person	NN
18637	7923	3	having	have	VBG
18637	7923	4	the	the	DT
18637	7923	5	greatest	great	JJS
18637	7923	6	Number	Number	NNP
18637	7923	7	of	of	IN
18637	7923	8	Votes	vote	NNS
18637	7923	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	7923	10	be	be	VB
18637	7923	11	the	the	DT
18637	7923	12	President	President	NNP
18637	7923	13	,	,	,
18637	7923	14	if	if	IN
18637	7923	15	such	such	JJ
18637	7923	16	Number	Number	NNP
18637	7923	17	be	be	VBP
18637	7923	18	a	a	DT
18637	7923	19	Majority	majority	NN
18637	7923	20	of	of	IN
18637	7923	21	the	the	DT
18637	7923	22	whole	whole	JJ
18637	7923	23	Number	Number	NNP
18637	7923	24	of	of	IN
18637	7923	25	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	7923	26	appointed	appoint	VBD
18637	7923	27	;	;	:
18637	7923	28	and	and	CC
18637	7923	29	if	if	IN
18637	7923	30	there	there	EX
18637	7923	31	be	be	VB
18637	7923	32	more	more	JJR
18637	7923	33	than	than	IN
18637	7923	34	one	one	CD
18637	7923	35	who	who	WP
18637	7923	36	have	have	VBP
18637	7923	37	such	such	JJ
18637	7923	38	Majority	Majority	NNP
18637	7923	39	,	,	,
18637	7923	40	and	and	CC
18637	7923	41	have	have	VBP
18637	7923	42	an	an	DT
18637	7923	43	equal	equal	JJ
18637	7923	44	Number	number	NN
18637	7923	45	of	of	IN
18637	7923	46	Votes	vote	NNS
18637	7923	47	,	,	,
18637	7923	48	then	then	RB
18637	7923	49	the	the	DT
18637	7923	50	House	House	NNP
18637	7923	51	of	of	IN
18637	7923	52	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	7923	53	shall	shall	MD
18637	7923	54	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	7923	55	chuse	chuse	VB
18637	7923	56	by	by	IN
18637	7923	57	Ballot	Ballot	NNP
18637	7923	58	one	one	CD
18637	7923	59	of	of	IN
18637	7923	60	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7923	61	for	for	IN
18637	7923	62	President	President	NNP
18637	7923	63	;	;	:
18637	7923	64	and	and	CC
18637	7923	65	if	if	IN
18637	7923	66	no	no	DT
18637	7923	67	Person	person	NN
18637	7923	68	have	have	VBP
18637	7923	69	a	a	DT
18637	7923	70	Majority	majority	NN
18637	7923	71	,	,	,
18637	7923	72	then	then	RB
18637	7923	73	from	from	IN
18637	7923	74	the	the	DT
18637	7923	75	five	five	CD
18637	7923	76	highest	high	JJS
18637	7923	77	on	on	IN
18637	7923	78	the	the	DT
18637	7923	79	List	list	NN
18637	7923	80	the	the	DT
18637	7923	81	said	say	VBD
18637	7923	82	House	House	NNP
18637	7923	83	shall	shall	MD
18637	7923	84	in	in	IN
18637	7923	85	like	like	IN
18637	7923	86	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	7923	87	chuse	chuse	NN
18637	7923	88	the	the	DT
18637	7923	89	President	President	NNP
18637	7923	90	.	.	.
18637	7924	1	But	but	CC
18637	7924	2	in	in	IN
18637	7924	3	chusing	chuse	VBG
18637	7924	4	the	the	DT
18637	7924	5	President	President	NNP
18637	7924	6	,	,	,
18637	7924	7	the	the	DT
18637	7924	8	Votes	Votes	NNPS
18637	7924	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	7924	10	be	be	VB
18637	7924	11	taken	take	VBN
18637	7924	12	by	by	IN
18637	7924	13	States	States	NNP
18637	7924	14	,	,	,
18637	7924	15	the	the	DT
18637	7924	16	Representation	representation	NN
18637	7924	17	from	from	IN
18637	7924	18	each	each	DT
18637	7924	19	State	state	NN
18637	7924	20	having	have	VBG
18637	7924	21	one	one	CD
18637	7924	22	Vote	vote	NN
18637	7924	23	;	;	:
18637	7924	24	A	a	DT
18637	7924	25	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	7924	26	for	for	IN
18637	7924	27	this	this	DT
18637	7924	28	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	7924	29	shall	shall	MD
18637	7924	30	consist	consist	VB
18637	7924	31	of	of	IN
18637	7924	32	a	a	DT
18637	7924	33	Member	Member	NNP
18637	7924	34	or	or	CC
18637	7924	35	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	7924	36	from	from	IN
18637	7924	37	two	two	CD
18637	7924	38	thirds	third	NNS
18637	7924	39	of	of	IN
18637	7924	40	the	the	DT
18637	7924	41	States	States	NNPS
18637	7924	42	,	,	,
18637	7924	43	and	and	CC
18637	7924	44	a	a	DT
18637	7924	45	Majority	majority	NN
18637	7924	46	of	of	IN
18637	7924	47	all	all	PDT
18637	7924	48	the	the	DT
18637	7924	49	States	state	NNS
18637	7924	50	shall	shall	MD
18637	7924	51	be	be	VB
18637	7924	52	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	7924	53	to	to	IN
18637	7924	54	a	a	DT
18637	7924	55	Choice	Choice	NNP
18637	7924	56	.	.	.
18637	7925	1	In	in	IN
18637	7925	2	every	every	DT
18637	7925	3	Case	Case	NNP
18637	7925	4	,	,	,
18637	7925	5	after	after	IN
18637	7925	6	the	the	DT
18637	7925	7	Choice	Choice	NNP
18637	7925	8	of	of	IN
18637	7925	9	the	the	DT
18637	7925	10	President	President	NNP
18637	7925	11	,	,	,
18637	7925	12	the	the	DT
18637	7925	13	Person	person	NN
18637	7925	14	having	have	VBG
18637	7925	15	the	the	DT
18637	7925	16	greatest	great	JJS
18637	7925	17	Number	Number	NNP
18637	7925	18	of	of	IN
18637	7925	19	Votes	vote	NNS
18637	7925	20	of	of	IN
18637	7925	21	the	the	DT
18637	7925	22	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	7925	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	7925	24	be	be	VB
18637	7925	25	the	the	DT
18637	7925	26	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7925	27	President	President	NNP
18637	7925	28	.	.	.
18637	7926	1	But	but	CC
18637	7926	2	if	if	IN
18637	7926	3	there	there	EX
18637	7926	4	should	should	MD
18637	7926	5	remain	remain	VB
18637	7926	6	two	two	CD
18637	7926	7	or	or	CC
18637	7926	8	more	more	JJR
18637	7926	9	who	who	WP
18637	7926	10	have	have	VBP
18637	7926	11	equal	equal	JJ
18637	7926	12	Votes	vote	NNS
18637	7926	13	,	,	,
18637	7926	14	the	the	DT
18637	7926	15	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	7926	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	7926	17	chuse	chuse	VB
18637	7926	18	from	from	IN
18637	7926	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7926	20	by	by	IN
18637	7926	21	Ballot	Ballot	NNP
18637	7926	22	the	the	DT
18637	7926	23	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7926	24	President	President	NNP
18637	7926	25	.	.	.
18637	7927	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	7927	2	4	4	CD
18637	7927	3	.	.	.
18637	7928	1	The	the	DT
18637	7928	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7928	3	may	may	MD
18637	7928	4	determine	determine	VB
18637	7928	5	the	the	DT
18637	7928	6	Time	time	NN
18637	7928	7	of	of	IN
18637	7928	8	chusing	chuse	VBG
18637	7928	9	the	the	DT
18637	7928	10	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	7928	11	,	,	,
18637	7928	12	and	and	CC
18637	7928	13	the	the	DT
18637	7928	14	Day	day	NN
18637	7928	15	on	on	IN
18637	7928	16	which	which	WDT
18637	7928	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7928	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	7928	19	give	give	VB
18637	7928	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7928	21	Votes	vote	NNS
18637	7928	22	;	;	:
18637	7928	23	which	which	WDT
18637	7928	24	Day	day	NN
18637	7928	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	7928	26	be	be	VB
18637	7928	27	the	the	DT
18637	7928	28	same	same	JJ
18637	7928	29	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	7928	30	the	the	DT
18637	7928	31	United	United	NNP
18637	7928	32	States	States	NNP
18637	7928	33	.	.	.
18637	7929	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	7929	2	5	5	CD
18637	7929	3	.	.	.
18637	7930	1	No	no	DT
18637	7930	2	Person	person	NN
18637	7930	3	except	except	IN
18637	7930	4	a	a	DT
18637	7930	5	natural	natural	JJ
18637	7930	6	born	bear	VBN
18637	7930	7	Citizen	Citizen	NNP
18637	7930	8	,	,	,
18637	7930	9	or	or	CC
18637	7930	10	a	a	DT
18637	7930	11	Citizen	Citizen	NNP
18637	7930	12	of	of	IN
18637	7930	13	the	the	DT
18637	7930	14	United	United	NNP
18637	7930	15	States	States	NNP
18637	7930	16	,	,	,
18637	7930	17	at	at	IN
18637	7930	18	the	the	DT
18637	7930	19	time	time	NN
18637	7930	20	of	of	IN
18637	7930	21	the	the	DT
18637	7930	22	Adoption	Adoption	NNP
18637	7930	23	of	of	IN
18637	7930	24	this	this	DT
18637	7930	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7930	26	,	,	,
18637	7930	27	shall	shall	MD
18637	7930	28	be	be	VB
18637	7930	29	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	7930	30	to	to	IN
18637	7930	31	the	the	DT
18637	7930	32	Office	Office	NNP
18637	7930	33	of	of	IN
18637	7930	34	President	President	NNP
18637	7930	35	;	;	:
18637	7930	36	neither	neither	DT
18637	7930	37	shall	shall	MD
18637	7930	38	any	any	DT
18637	7930	39	Person	person	NN
18637	7930	40	be	be	VB
18637	7930	41	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	7930	42	to	to	IN
18637	7930	43	that	that	DT
18637	7930	44	Office	office	NN
18637	7930	45	who	who	WP
18637	7930	46	shall	shall	MD
18637	7930	47	not	not	RB
18637	7930	48	have	have	VB
18637	7930	49	attained	attain	VBN
18637	7930	50	to	to	IN
18637	7930	51	the	the	DT
18637	7930	52	Age	Age	NNP
18637	7930	53	of	of	IN
18637	7930	54	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	7930	55	five	five	CD
18637	7930	56	Years	year	NNS
18637	7930	57	,	,	,
18637	7930	58	and	and	CC
18637	7930	59	been	be	VBN
18637	7930	60	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	7930	61	Years	year	NNS
18637	7930	62	a	a	DT
18637	7930	63	Resident	resident	NN
18637	7930	64	within	within	IN
18637	7930	65	the	the	DT
18637	7930	66	United	United	NNP
18637	7930	67	States	States	NNP
18637	7930	68	.	.	.
18637	7931	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	7931	2	6	6	CD
18637	7931	3	.	.	.
18637	7932	1	In	in	IN
18637	7932	2	Case	case	NN
18637	7932	3	of	of	IN
18637	7932	4	the	the	DT
18637	7932	5	Removal	Removal	NNP
18637	7932	6	of	of	IN
18637	7932	7	the	the	DT
18637	7932	8	President	President	NNP
18637	7932	9	from	from	IN
18637	7932	10	Office	Office	NNP
18637	7932	11	,	,	,
18637	7932	12	or	or	CC
18637	7932	13	of	of	IN
18637	7932	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7932	15	Death	Death	NNP
18637	7932	16	,	,	,
18637	7932	17	Resignation	resignation	NN
18637	7932	18	,	,	,
18637	7932	19	or	or	CC
18637	7932	20	Inability	inability	NN
18637	7932	21	to	to	TO
18637	7932	22	discharge	discharge	VB
18637	7932	23	the	the	DT
18637	7932	24	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	7932	25	and	and	CC
18637	7932	26	Duties	Duties	NNPS
18637	7932	27	of	of	IN
18637	7932	28	the	the	DT
18637	7932	29	said	say	VBD
18637	7932	30	Office	Office	NNP
18637	7932	31	,	,	,
18637	7932	32	the	the	DT
18637	7932	33	Same	same	JJ
18637	7932	34	shall	shall	MD
18637	7932	35	devolve	devolve	VB
18637	7932	36	on	on	IN
18637	7932	37	the	the	DT
18637	7932	38	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7932	39	President	President	NNP
18637	7932	40	,	,	,
18637	7932	41	and	and	CC
18637	7932	42	the	the	DT
18637	7932	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7932	44	may	may	MD
18637	7932	45	by	by	IN
18637	7932	46	law	law	NN
18637	7932	47	provide	provide	VB
18637	7932	48	for	for	IN
18637	7932	49	the	the	DT
18637	7932	50	Case	Case	NNP
18637	7932	51	of	of	IN
18637	7932	52	Removal	Removal	NNP
18637	7932	53	,	,	,
18637	7932	54	Death	Death	NNP
18637	7932	55	,	,	,
18637	7932	56	Resignation	Resignation	NNP
18637	7932	57	or	or	CC
18637	7932	58	Inability	Inability	NNP
18637	7932	59	,	,	,
18637	7932	60	both	both	DT
18637	7932	61	of	of	IN
18637	7932	62	the	the	DT
18637	7932	63	President	President	NNP
18637	7932	64	and	and	CC
18637	7932	65	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7932	66	President	President	NNP
18637	7932	67	,	,	,
18637	7932	68	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	7932	69	what	what	WP
18637	7932	70	Officer	Officer	NNP
18637	7932	71	shall	shall	MD
18637	7932	72	then	then	RB
18637	7932	73	act	act	VB
18637	7932	74	as	as	IN
18637	7932	75	President	President	NNP
18637	7932	76	,	,	,
18637	7932	77	and	and	CC
18637	7932	78	such	such	JJ
18637	7932	79	Officer	Officer	NNP
18637	7932	80	shall	shall	MD
18637	7932	81	act	act	VB
18637	7932	82	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	7932	83	,	,	,
18637	7932	84	until	until	IN
18637	7932	85	the	the	DT
18637	7932	86	Disability	Disability	NNP
18637	7932	87	be	be	VB
18637	7932	88	removed	remove	VBN
18637	7932	89	,	,	,
18637	7932	90	or	or	CC
18637	7932	91	a	a	DT
18637	7932	92	President	President	NNP
18637	7932	93	shall	shall	MD
18637	7932	94	be	be	VB
18637	7932	95	elected	elect	VBN
18637	7932	96	.	.	.
18637	7933	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	7933	2	7	7	CD
18637	7933	3	.	.	.
18637	7934	1	The	the	DT
18637	7934	2	President	President	NNP
18637	7934	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	7934	4	,	,	,
18637	7934	5	at	at	IN
18637	7934	6	stated	state	VBN
18637	7934	7	Times	Times	NNP
18637	7934	8	,	,	,
18637	7934	9	receive	receive	VB
18637	7934	10	for	for	IN
18637	7934	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7934	12	Services	Services	NNPS
18637	7934	13	,	,	,
18637	7934	14	a	a	DT
18637	7934	15	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	7934	16	,	,	,
18637	7934	17	which	which	WDT
18637	7934	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	7934	19	neither	neither	CC
18637	7934	20	be	be	VB
18637	7934	21	encreased	encrease	VBN
18637	7934	22	nor	nor	CC
18637	7934	23	diminished	diminish	VBN
18637	7934	24	during	during	IN
18637	7934	25	the	the	DT
18637	7934	26	Period	Period	NNP
18637	7934	27	for	for	IN
18637	7934	28	which	which	WDT
18637	7934	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7934	30	shall	shall	MD
18637	7934	31	have	have	VB
18637	7934	32	been	be	VBN
18637	7934	33	elected	elect	VBN
18637	7934	34	,	,	,
18637	7934	35	and	and	CC
18637	7934	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7934	37	shall	shall	MD
18637	7934	38	not	not	RB
18637	7934	39	receive	receive	VB
18637	7934	40	within	within	IN
18637	7934	41	that	that	DT
18637	7934	42	Period	period	NN
18637	7934	43	any	any	DT
18637	7934	44	other	other	JJ
18637	7934	45	Emolument	Emolument	NNP
18637	7934	46	from	from	IN
18637	7934	47	the	the	DT
18637	7934	48	United	United	NNP
18637	7934	49	States	States	NNP
18637	7934	50	,	,	,
18637	7934	51	or	or	CC
18637	7934	52	any	any	DT
18637	7934	53	of	of	IN
18637	7934	54	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7934	55	.	.	.
18637	7935	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	7935	2	8	8	CD
18637	7935	3	.	.	.
18637	7936	1	Before	before	IN
18637	7936	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7936	3	enter	enter	VBP
18637	7936	4	on	on	IN
18637	7936	5	the	the	DT
18637	7936	6	Execution	Execution	NNP
18637	7936	7	of	of	IN
18637	7936	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7936	9	Office	Office	NNP
18637	7936	10	,	,	,
18637	7936	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7936	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	7936	13	take	take	VB
18637	7936	14	the	the	DT
18637	7936	15	following	follow	VBG
18637	7936	16	Oath	Oath	NNP
18637	7936	17	or	or	CC
18637	7936	18	Affirmation:--"I	affirmation:--"i	CD
18637	7936	19	do	do	VBP
18637	7936	20	solemnly	solemnly	RB
18637	7936	21	swear	swear	VB
18637	7936	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	7936	23	or	or	CC
18637	7936	24	affirm	affirm	NN
18637	7936	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	7936	26	that	that	IN
18637	7936	27	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7936	28	will	will	MD
18637	7936	29	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	7936	30	execute	execute	VB
18637	7936	31	the	the	DT
18637	7936	32	Office	Office	NNP
18637	7936	33	of	of	IN
18637	7936	34	President	President	NNP
18637	7936	35	of	of	IN
18637	7936	36	the	the	DT
18637	7936	37	United	United	NNP
18637	7936	38	States	States	NNP
18637	7936	39	,	,	,
18637	7936	40	and	and	CC
18637	7936	41	will	will	MD
18637	7936	42	to	to	IN
18637	7936	43	the	the	DT
18637	7936	44	best	good	JJS
18637	7936	45	of	of	IN
18637	7936	46	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7936	47	Ability	ability	NN
18637	7936	48	,	,	,
18637	7936	49	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	7936	50	,	,	,
18637	7936	51	protect	protect	VB
18637	7936	52	and	and	CC
18637	7936	53	defend	defend	VB
18637	7936	54	the	the	DT
18637	7936	55	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7936	56	of	of	IN
18637	7936	57	the	the	DT
18637	7936	58	United	United	NNP
18637	7936	59	States	States	NNP
18637	7936	60	.	.	.
18637	7936	61	"	"	''
18637	7937	1	Maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	7937	2	of	of	IN
18637	7937	3	the	the	DT
18637	7937	4	Office	Office	NNP
18637	7937	5	of	of	IN
18637	7937	6	President	President	NNP
18637	7937	7	"	"	``
18637	7937	8	THE	the	DT
18637	7937	9	ELECTORAL	electoral	JJ
18637	7937	10	COLLEGE	college	NN
18637	7937	11	"	"	``
18637	7937	12	The	the	DT
18637	7937	13	word	word	NN
18637	7937	14	"	"	``
18637	7937	15	appoint	appoint	NN
18637	7937	16	"	"	''
18637	7937	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	7937	18	used	use	VBN
18637	7937	19	in	in	IN
18637	7937	20	clause	clause	NN
18637	7937	21	2	2	CD
18637	7937	22	"	"	''
18637	7937	23	as	as	IN
18637	7937	24	conveying	convey	VBG
18637	7937	25	the	the	DT
18637	7937	26	broadest	broad	JJS
18637	7937	27	power	power	NN
18637	7937	28	of	of	IN
18637	7937	29	determination	determination	NN
18637	7937	30	.	.	.
18637	7938	1	"	"	``
18637	7938	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7938	3	28	28	CD
18637	7938	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7938	5	This	this	DT
18637	7938	6	power	power	NN
18637	7938	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	7938	8	been	be	VBN
18637	7938	9	used	use	VBN
18637	7938	10	.	.	.
18637	7939	1	"	"	``
18637	7939	2	Therefore	therefore	RB
18637	7939	3	,	,	,
18637	7939	4	on	on	IN
18637	7939	5	reference	reference	NN
18637	7939	6	to	to	IN
18637	7939	7	contemporaneous	contemporaneous	JJ
18637	7939	8	and	and	CC
18637	7939	9	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	7939	10	action	action	NN
18637	7939	11	under	under	IN
18637	7939	12	the	the	DT
18637	7939	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	7939	14	,	,	,
18637	7939	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7939	16	should	should	MD
18637	7939	17	expect	expect	VB
18637	7939	18	to	to	TO
18637	7939	19	find	find	VB
18637	7939	20	,	,	,
18637	7939	21	as	as	IN
18637	7939	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7939	23	do	do	VBP
18637	7939	24	,	,	,
18637	7939	25	that	that	IN
18637	7939	26	various	various	JJ
18637	7939	27	modes	mode	NNS
18637	7939	28	of	of	IN
18637	7939	29	choosing	choose	VBG
18637	7939	30	the	the	DT
18637	7939	31	electors	elector	NNS
18637	7939	32	were	be	VBD
18637	7939	33	pursued	pursue	VBN
18637	7939	34	,	,	,
18637	7939	35	as	as	IN
18637	7939	36	,	,	,
18637	7939	37	by	by	IN
18637	7939	38	the	the	DT
18637	7939	39	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	7939	40	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7939	41	on	on	IN
18637	7939	42	joint	joint	JJ
18637	7939	43	ballot	ballot	NN
18637	7939	44	;	;	:
18637	7939	45	by	by	IN
18637	7939	46	the	the	DT
18637	7939	47	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	7939	48	through	through	IN
18637	7939	49	a	a	DT
18637	7939	50	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	7939	51	vote	vote	NN
18637	7939	52	of	of	IN
18637	7939	53	the	the	DT
18637	7939	54	two	two	CD
18637	7939	55	houses	house	NNS
18637	7939	56	;	;	:
18637	7939	57	by	by	IN
18637	7939	58	vote	vote	NN
18637	7939	59	of	of	IN
18637	7939	60	the	the	DT
18637	7939	61	people	people	NNS
18637	7939	62	for	for	IN
18637	7939	63	a	a	DT
18637	7939	64	general	general	JJ
18637	7939	65	ticket	ticket	NN
18637	7939	66	;	;	:
18637	7939	67	by	by	IN
18637	7939	68	vote	vote	NN
18637	7939	69	of	of	IN
18637	7939	70	the	the	DT
18637	7939	71	people	people	NNS
18637	7939	72	in	in	IN
18637	7939	73	districts	district	NNS
18637	7939	74	;	;	,
18637	7939	75	by	by	IN
18637	7939	76	choice	choice	NN
18637	7939	77	partly	partly	RB
18637	7939	78	by	by	IN
18637	7939	79	the	the	DT
18637	7939	80	people	people	NNS
18637	7939	81	voting	vote	VBG
18637	7939	82	in	in	IN
18637	7939	83	districts	district	NNS
18637	7939	84	and	and	CC
18637	7939	85	partly	partly	RB
18637	7939	86	by	by	IN
18637	7939	87	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	7939	88	;	;	:
18637	7939	89	by	by	IN
18637	7939	90	choice	choice	NN
18637	7939	91	by	by	IN
18637	7939	92	the	the	DT
18637	7939	93	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	7939	94	from	from	IN
18637	7939	95	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	7939	96	voted	vote	VBD
18637	7939	97	for	for	IN
18637	7939	98	by	by	IN
18637	7939	99	the	the	DT
18637	7939	100	people	people	NNS
18637	7939	101	in	in	IN
18637	7939	102	districts	district	NNS
18637	7939	103	;	;	,
18637	7939	104	and	and	CC
18637	7939	105	in	in	IN
18637	7939	106	other	other	JJ
18637	7939	107	ways	way	NNS
18637	7939	108	,	,	,
18637	7939	109	as	as	IN
18637	7939	110	,	,	,
18637	7939	111	notably	notably	RB
18637	7939	112	,	,	,
18637	7939	113	by	by	IN
18637	7939	114	North	North	NNP
18637	7939	115	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	7939	116	in	in	IN
18637	7939	117	1792	1792	CD
18637	7939	118	,	,	,
18637	7939	119	and	and	CC
18637	7939	120	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	7939	121	in	in	IN
18637	7939	122	1796	1796	CD
18637	7939	123	and	and	CC
18637	7939	124	1800	1800	CD
18637	7939	125	.	.	.
18637	7940	1	No	no	DT
18637	7940	2	question	question	NN
18637	7940	3	was	be	VBD
18637	7940	4	raised	raise	VBN
18637	7940	5	as	as	IN
18637	7940	6	to	to	IN
18637	7940	7	the	the	DT
18637	7940	8	power	power	NN
18637	7940	9	of	of	IN
18637	7940	10	the	the	DT
18637	7940	11	State	State	NNP
18637	7940	12	to	to	TO
18637	7940	13	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	7940	14	,	,	,
18637	7940	15	in	in	IN
18637	7940	16	any	any	DT
18637	7940	17	mode	mode	NN
18637	7940	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7940	19	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	7940	20	saw	see	VBD
18637	7940	21	fit	fit	JJ
18637	7940	22	to	to	TO
18637	7940	23	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	7940	24	,	,	,
18637	7940	25	and	and	CC
18637	7940	26	none	none	NN
18637	7940	27	that	that	IN
18637	7940	28	a	a	DT
18637	7940	29	single	single	JJ
18637	7940	30	method	method	NN
18637	7940	31	,	,	,
18637	7940	32	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	7940	33	without	without	IN
18637	7940	34	exception	exception	NN
18637	7940	35	,	,	,
18637	7940	36	must	must	MD
18637	7940	37	be	be	VB
18637	7940	38	pursued	pursue	VBN
18637	7940	39	in	in	IN
18637	7940	40	the	the	DT
18637	7940	41	absence	absence	NN
18637	7940	42	of	of	IN
18637	7940	43	an	an	DT
18637	7940	44	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	7940	45	to	to	IN
18637	7940	46	the	the	DT
18637	7940	47	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7940	48	.	.	.
18637	7941	1	The	the	DT
18637	7941	2	district	district	NN
18637	7941	3	system	system	NN
18637	7941	4	was	be	VBD
18637	7941	5	largely	largely	RB
18637	7941	6	considered	consider	VBN
18637	7941	7	the	the	DT
18637	7941	8	most	most	RBS
18637	7941	9	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	7941	10	,	,	,
18637	7941	11	and	and	CC
18637	7941	12	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	7941	13	wrote	write	VBD
18637	7941	14	that	that	IN
18637	7941	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7941	16	was	be	VBD
18637	7941	17	that	that	DT
18637	7941	18	system	system	NN
18637	7941	19	which	which	WDT
18637	7941	20	was	be	VBD
18637	7941	21	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
18637	7941	22	by	by	IN
18637	7941	23	the	the	DT
18637	7941	24	framers	framer	NNS
18637	7941	25	of	of	IN
18637	7941	26	the	the	DT
18637	7941	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7941	28	,	,	,
18637	7941	29	although	although	IN
18637	7941	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7941	31	was	be	VBD
18637	7941	32	soon	soon	RB
18637	7941	33	seen	see	VBN
18637	7941	34	that	that	IN
18637	7941	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7941	36	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	7941	37	by	by	IN
18637	7941	38	some	some	DT
18637	7941	39	States	state	NNS
18637	7941	40	might	may	MD
18637	7941	41	place	place	VB
18637	7941	42	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7941	43	at	at	IN
18637	7941	44	a	a	DT
18637	7941	45	disadvantage	disadvantage	NN
18637	7941	46	by	by	IN
18637	7941	47	a	a	DT
18637	7941	48	division	division	NN
18637	7941	49	of	of	IN
18637	7941	50	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7941	51	strength	strength	NN
18637	7941	52	,	,	,
18637	7941	53	and	and	CC
18637	7941	54	that	that	IN
18637	7941	55	a	a	DT
18637	7941	56	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	7941	57	rule	rule	NN
18637	7941	58	was	be	VBD
18637	7941	59	preferable	preferable	JJ
18637	7941	60	.	.	.
18637	7942	1	"	"	``
18637	7942	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7942	3	29	29	CD
18637	7942	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7942	5	In	in	IN
18637	7942	6	the	the	DT
18637	7942	7	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	7942	8	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	7942	9	James	James	NNP
18637	7942	10	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	7942	11	had	have	VBD
18637	7942	12	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	7942	13	that	that	IN
18637	7942	14	the	the	DT
18637	7942	15	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	7942	16	be	be	VB
18637	7942	17	"	"	``
18637	7942	18	taken	take	VBN
18637	7942	19	by	by	IN
18637	7942	20	lot	lot	NN
18637	7942	21	from	from	IN
18637	7942	22	the	the	DT
18637	7942	23	national	national	JJ
18637	7942	24	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	7942	25	,	,	,
18637	7942	26	"	"	''
18637	7942	27	but	but	CC
18637	7942	28	the	the	DT
18637	7942	29	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	7942	30	failed	fail	VBD
18637	7942	31	to	to	TO
18637	7942	32	come	come	VB
18637	7942	33	to	to	IN
18637	7942	34	a	a	DT
18637	7942	35	vote	vote	NN
18637	7942	36	.	.	.
18637	7943	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7943	2	30	30	CD
18637	7943	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7943	4	CONSTITUTIONAL	constitutional	JJ
18637	7943	5	STATUS	status	NN
18637	7943	6	OF	of	IN
18637	7943	7	ELECTORS	elector	NNS
18637	7943	8	Dealing	deal	VBG
18637	7943	9	with	with	IN
18637	7943	10	the	the	DT
18637	7943	11	question	question	NN
18637	7943	12	of	of	IN
18637	7943	13	the	the	DT
18637	7943	14	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	7943	15	status	status	NN
18637	7943	16	of	of	IN
18637	7943	17	the	the	DT
18637	7943	18	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	7943	19	,	,	,
18637	7943	20	the	the	DT
18637	7943	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7943	22	said	say	VBD
18637	7943	23	in	in	IN
18637	7943	24	1890	1890	CD
18637	7943	25	:	:	:
18637	7943	26	"	"	``
18637	7943	27	The	the	DT
18637	7943	28	sole	sole	JJ
18637	7943	29	function	function	NN
18637	7943	30	of	of	IN
18637	7943	31	the	the	DT
18637	7943	32	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7943	33	electors	elector	NNS
18637	7943	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	7943	35	to	to	TO
18637	7943	36	cast	cast	VB
18637	7943	37	,	,	,
18637	7943	38	certify	certify	VB
18637	7943	39	and	and	CC
18637	7943	40	transmit	transmit	VB
18637	7943	41	the	the	DT
18637	7943	42	vote	vote	NN
18637	7943	43	of	of	IN
18637	7943	44	the	the	DT
18637	7943	45	State	State	NNP
18637	7943	46	for	for	IN
18637	7943	47	President	President	NNP
18637	7943	48	and	and	CC
18637	7943	49	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7943	50	President	President	NNP
18637	7943	51	of	of	IN
18637	7943	52	the	the	DT
18637	7943	53	nation	nation	NN
18637	7943	54	.	.	.
18637	7944	1	Although	although	IN
18637	7944	2	the	the	DT
18637	7944	3	electors	elector	NNS
18637	7944	4	are	be	VBP
18637	7944	5	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	7944	6	and	and	CC
18637	7944	7	act	act	VB
18637	7944	8	under	under	IN
18637	7944	9	and	and	CC
18637	7944	10	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	7944	11	to	to	IN
18637	7944	12	the	the	DT
18637	7944	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7944	14	of	of	IN
18637	7944	15	the	the	DT
18637	7944	16	United	United	NNP
18637	7944	17	States	States	NNP
18637	7944	18	,	,	,
18637	7944	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7944	20	are	be	VBP
18637	7944	21	no	no	RB
18637	7944	22	more	more	JJR
18637	7944	23	officers	officer	NNS
18637	7944	24	or	or	CC
18637	7944	25	agents	agent	NNS
18637	7944	26	of	of	IN
18637	7944	27	the	the	DT
18637	7944	28	United	United	NNP
18637	7944	29	States	States	NNP
18637	7944	30	than	than	IN
18637	7944	31	are	be	VBP
18637	7944	32	the	the	DT
18637	7944	33	members	member	NNS
18637	7944	34	of	of	IN
18637	7944	35	the	the	DT
18637	7944	36	State	State	NNP
18637	7944	37	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	7944	38	when	when	WRB
18637	7944	39	acting	act	VBG
18637	7944	40	as	as	IN
18637	7944	41	electors	elector	NNS
18637	7944	42	of	of	IN
18637	7944	43	federal	federal	JJ
18637	7944	44	senators	senator	NNS
18637	7944	45	,	,	,
18637	7944	46	or	or	CC
18637	7944	47	the	the	DT
18637	7944	48	people	people	NNS
18637	7944	49	of	of	IN
18637	7944	50	the	the	DT
18637	7944	51	States	States	NNP
18637	7944	52	when	when	WRB
18637	7944	53	acting	act	VBG
18637	7944	54	as	as	IN
18637	7944	55	electors	elector	NNS
18637	7944	56	of	of	IN
18637	7944	57	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	7944	58	in	in	IN
18637	7944	59	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7944	60	.	.	.
18637	7945	1	*	*	NFP
18637	7945	2	*	*	NFP
18637	7945	3	*	*	NFP
18637	7945	4	In	in	IN
18637	7945	5	accord	accord	NN
18637	7945	6	with	with	IN
18637	7945	7	the	the	DT
18637	7945	8	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	7945	9	of	of	IN
18637	7945	10	the	the	DT
18637	7945	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7945	12	,	,	,
18637	7945	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7945	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	7945	15	determined	determine	VBN
18637	7945	16	the	the	DT
18637	7945	17	time	time	NN
18637	7945	18	as	as	IN
18637	7945	19	of	of	IN
18637	7945	20	which	which	WDT
18637	7945	21	the	the	DT
18637	7945	22	number	number	NN
18637	7945	23	of	of	IN
18637	7945	24	electors	elector	NNS
18637	7945	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	7945	26	be	be	VB
18637	7945	27	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	7945	28	,	,	,
18637	7945	29	and	and	CC
18637	7945	30	the	the	DT
18637	7945	31	days	day	NNS
18637	7945	32	on	on	IN
18637	7945	33	which	which	WDT
18637	7945	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7945	35	shall	shall	MD
18637	7945	36	be	be	VB
18637	7945	37	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	7945	38	and	and	CC
18637	7945	39	shall	shall	MD
18637	7945	40	meet	meet	VB
18637	7945	41	and	and	CC
18637	7945	42	vote	vote	VB
18637	7945	43	in	in	IN
18637	7945	44	the	the	DT
18637	7945	45	States	States	NNP
18637	7945	46	,	,	,
18637	7945	47	and	and	CC
18637	7945	48	on	on	IN
18637	7945	49	which	which	WDT
18637	7945	50	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7945	51	votes	vote	NNS
18637	7945	52	shall	shall	MD
18637	7945	53	be	be	VB
18637	7945	54	counted	count	VBN
18637	7945	55	in	in	IN
18637	7945	56	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7945	57	;	;	:
18637	7945	58	has	have	VBZ
18637	7945	59	provided	provide	VBN
18637	7945	60	for	for	IN
18637	7945	61	the	the	DT
18637	7945	62	filling	filling	NN
18637	7945	63	by	by	IN
18637	7945	64	each	each	DT
18637	7945	65	State	State	NNP
18637	7945	66	,	,	,
18637	7945	67	in	in	IN
18637	7945	68	such	such	JJ
18637	7945	69	manner	manner	NN
18637	7945	70	as	as	IN
18637	7945	71	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7945	72	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	7945	73	may	may	MD
18637	7945	74	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	7945	75	,	,	,
18637	7945	76	of	of	IN
18637	7945	77	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	7945	78	in	in	IN
18637	7945	79	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7945	80	college	college	NN
18637	7945	81	of	of	IN
18637	7945	82	electors	elector	NNS
18637	7945	83	;	;	:
18637	7945	84	and	and	CC
18637	7945	85	has	have	VBZ
18637	7945	86	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	7945	87	the	the	DT
18637	7945	88	manner	manner	NN
18637	7945	89	of	of	IN
18637	7945	90	certifying	certify	VBG
18637	7945	91	and	and	CC
18637	7945	92	transmitting	transmit	VBG
18637	7945	93	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7945	94	votes	vote	NNS
18637	7945	95	to	to	IN
18637	7945	96	the	the	DT
18637	7945	97	seat	seat	NN
18637	7945	98	of	of	IN
18637	7945	99	the	the	DT
18637	7945	100	national	national	JJ
18637	7945	101	government	government	NN
18637	7945	102	,	,	,
18637	7945	103	and	and	CC
18637	7945	104	the	the	DT
18637	7945	105	course	course	NN
18637	7945	106	of	of	IN
18637	7945	107	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	7945	108	in	in	IN
18637	7945	109	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7945	110	opening	opening	NN
18637	7945	111	and	and	CC
18637	7945	112	counting	count	VBG
18637	7945	113	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7945	114	.	.	.
18637	7946	1	"	"	``
18637	7946	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7946	3	31	31	CD
18637	7946	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7946	5	The	the	DT
18637	7946	6	truth	truth	NN
18637	7946	7	of	of	IN
18637	7946	8	the	the	DT
18637	7946	9	matter	matter	NN
18637	7946	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	7946	11	that	that	IN
18637	7946	12	the	the	DT
18637	7946	13	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	7946	14	are	be	VBP
18637	7946	15	not	not	RB
18637	7946	16	"	"	``
18637	7946	17	officers	officer	NNS
18637	7946	18	"	"	''
18637	7946	19	at	at	RB
18637	7946	20	all	all	RB
18637	7946	21	,	,	,
18637	7946	22	by	by	IN
18637	7946	23	the	the	DT
18637	7946	24	usual	usual	JJ
18637	7946	25	tests	test	NNS
18637	7946	26	of	of	IN
18637	7946	27	office	office	NN
18637	7946	28	.	.	.
18637	7947	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7947	2	32	32	CD
18637	7947	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7947	4	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7947	5	have	have	VBP
18637	7947	6	neither	neither	DT
18637	7947	7	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	7947	8	nor	nor	CC
18637	7947	9	salary	salary	NN
18637	7947	10	,	,	,
18637	7947	11	and	and	CC
18637	7947	12	having	have	VBG
18637	7947	13	performed	perform	VBN
18637	7947	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7947	15	single	single	JJ
18637	7947	16	function	function	NN
18637	7947	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7947	18	cease	cease	VBP
18637	7947	19	to	to	TO
18637	7947	20	exist	exist	VB
18637	7947	21	as	as	IN
18637	7947	22	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	7947	23	.	.	.
18637	7948	1	This	this	DT
18637	7948	2	function	function	NN
18637	7948	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	7948	4	,	,	,
18637	7948	5	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	7948	6	,	,	,
18637	7948	7	"	"	''
18637	7948	8	a	a	DT
18637	7948	9	federal	federal	JJ
18637	7948	10	function,"[33	function,"[33	NNP
18637	7948	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7948	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7948	13	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	7948	14	to	to	TO
18637	7948	15	perform	perform	VB
18637	7948	16	which	which	WDT
18637	7948	17	results	result	VBZ
18637	7948	18	from	from	IN
18637	7948	19	no	no	DT
18637	7948	20	power	power	NN
18637	7948	21	which	which	WDT
18637	7948	22	was	be	VBD
18637	7948	23	originally	originally	RB
18637	7948	24	resident	resident	JJ
18637	7948	25	in	in	IN
18637	7948	26	the	the	DT
18637	7948	27	States	States	NNP
18637	7948	28	,	,	,
18637	7948	29	but	but	CC
18637	7948	30	springs	spring	NNS
18637	7948	31	directly	directly	RB
18637	7948	32	from	from	IN
18637	7948	33	the	the	DT
18637	7948	34	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7948	35	of	of	IN
18637	7948	36	the	the	DT
18637	7948	37	United	United	NNP
18637	7948	38	States	States	NNP
18637	7948	39	.	.	.
18637	7949	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7949	2	34	34	CD
18637	7949	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7949	4	In	in	IN
18637	7949	5	the	the	DT
18637	7949	6	face	face	NN
18637	7949	7	,	,	,
18637	7949	8	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	7949	9	,	,	,
18637	7949	10	of	of	IN
18637	7949	11	the	the	DT
18637	7949	12	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	7949	13	that	that	WDT
18637	7949	14	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	7949	15	are	be	VBP
18637	7949	16	State	state	NN
18637	7949	17	officers	officer	NNS
18637	7949	18	,	,	,
18637	7949	19	the	the	DT
18637	7949	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7949	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	7949	22	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	7949	23	the	the	DT
18637	7949	24	power	power	NN
18637	7949	25	of	of	IN
18637	7949	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7949	27	to	to	TO
18637	7949	28	protect	protect	VB
18637	7949	29	the	the	DT
18637	7949	30	right	right	NN
18637	7949	31	of	of	IN
18637	7949	32	all	all	DT
18637	7949	33	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	7949	34	who	who	WP
18637	7949	35	are	be	VBP
18637	7949	36	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	7949	37	to	to	TO
18637	7949	38	vote	vote	VB
18637	7949	39	to	to	TO
18637	7949	40	lend	lend	VB
18637	7949	41	aid	aid	NN
18637	7949	42	and	and	CC
18637	7949	43	support	support	NN
18637	7949	44	in	in	IN
18637	7949	45	any	any	DT
18637	7949	46	legal	legal	JJ
18637	7949	47	manner	manner	NN
18637	7949	48	to	to	IN
18637	7949	49	the	the	DT
18637	7949	50	election	election	NN
18637	7949	51	of	of	IN
18637	7949	52	any	any	DT
18637	7949	53	legally	legally	RB
18637	7949	54	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	7949	55	person	person	NN
18637	7949	56	as	as	IN
18637	7949	57	a	a	DT
18637	7949	58	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	7949	59	Elector;[35	Elector;[35	NNP
18637	7949	60	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7949	61	and	and	CC
18637	7949	62	more	more	RBR
18637	7949	63	recently	recently	RB
18637	7949	64	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7949	65	power	power	NN
18637	7949	66	to	to	TO
18637	7949	67	protect	protect	VB
18637	7949	68	the	the	DT
18637	7949	69	choice	choice	NN
18637	7949	70	of	of	IN
18637	7949	71	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	7949	72	from	from	IN
18637	7949	73	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	7949	74	or	or	CC
18637	7949	75	corruption	corruption	NN
18637	7949	76	.	.	.
18637	7950	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7950	2	36	36	CD
18637	7950	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7950	4	"	"	``
18637	7950	5	'	'	``
18637	7950	6	If	if	IN
18637	7950	7	this	this	DT
18637	7950	8	government	government	NN
18637	7950	9	,	,	,
18637	7950	10	'	'	''
18637	7950	11	said	say	VBD
18637	7950	12	the	the	DT
18637	7950	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7950	14	,	,	,
18637	7950	15	'	'	''
18637	7950	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	7950	17	anything	anything	NN
18637	7950	18	more	more	JJR
18637	7950	19	than	than	IN
18637	7950	20	a	a	DT
18637	7950	21	mere	mere	JJ
18637	7950	22	aggregation	aggregation	NN
18637	7950	23	of	of	IN
18637	7950	24	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	7950	25	agents	agent	NNS
18637	7950	26	of	of	IN
18637	7950	27	other	other	JJ
18637	7950	28	States	state	NNS
18637	7950	29	and	and	CC
18637	7950	30	governments	government	NNS
18637	7950	31	,	,	,
18637	7950	32	each	each	DT
18637	7950	33	of	of	IN
18637	7950	34	which	which	WDT
18637	7950	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	7950	36	superior	superior	JJ
18637	7950	37	to	to	IN
18637	7950	38	the	the	DT
18637	7950	39	general	general	JJ
18637	7950	40	government	government	NN
18637	7950	41	,	,	,
18637	7950	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7950	43	must	must	MD
18637	7950	44	have	have	VB
18637	7950	45	the	the	DT
18637	7950	46	power	power	NN
18637	7950	47	to	to	TO
18637	7950	48	protect	protect	VB
18637	7950	49	the	the	DT
18637	7950	50	elections	election	NNS
18637	7950	51	on	on	IN
18637	7950	52	which	which	WDT
18637	7950	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7950	54	existence	existence	NN
18637	7950	55	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	7950	56	from	from	IN
18637	7950	57	violence	violence	NN
18637	7950	58	and	and	CC
18637	7950	59	corruption	corruption	NN
18637	7950	60	.	.	.
18637	7951	1	If	if	IN
18637	7951	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7951	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	7951	4	not	not	RB
18637	7951	5	this	this	DT
18637	7951	6	power	power	NN
18637	7951	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7951	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	7951	9	left	leave	VBN
18637	7951	10	helpless	helpless	JJ
18637	7951	11	before	before	IN
18637	7951	12	the	the	DT
18637	7951	13	two	two	CD
18637	7951	14	great	great	JJ
18637	7951	15	natural	natural	JJ
18637	7951	16	and	and	CC
18637	7951	17	historical	historical	JJ
18637	7951	18	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	7951	19	of	of	IN
18637	7951	20	all	all	DT
18637	7951	21	republics	republic	NNS
18637	7951	22	,	,	,
18637	7951	23	open	open	JJ
18637	7951	24	violence	violence	NN
18637	7951	25	and	and	CC
18637	7951	26	insidious	insidious	JJ
18637	7951	27	corruption	corruption	NN
18637	7951	28	.	.	.
18637	7952	1	'	'	``
18637	7952	2	"	"	``
18637	7952	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7952	4	37	37	CD
18637	7952	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7952	6	The	the	DT
18637	7952	7	conception	conception	NN
18637	7952	8	of	of	IN
18637	7952	9	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	7952	10	as	as	IN
18637	7952	11	State	State	NNP
18637	7952	12	officers	officer	NNS
18637	7952	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	7952	14	still	still	RB
18637	7952	15	,	,	,
18637	7952	16	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	7952	17	,	,	,
18637	7952	18	of	of	IN
18637	7952	19	some	some	DT
18637	7952	20	importance	importance	NN
18637	7952	21	,	,	,
18637	7952	22	as	as	IN
18637	7952	23	was	be	VBD
18637	7952	24	shown	show	VBN
18637	7952	25	in	in	IN
18637	7952	26	the	the	DT
18637	7952	27	recent	recent	JJ
18637	7952	28	case	case	NN
18637	7952	29	of	of	IN
18637	7952	30	Ray	Ray	NNP
18637	7952	31	_	_	NNP
18637	7952	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	7952	33	_	_	NNP
18637	7952	34	Blair,[38	Blair,[38	NNP
18637	7952	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7952	36	which	which	WDT
18637	7952	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	7952	38	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	7952	39	with	with	IN
18637	7952	40	in	in	IN
18637	7952	41	connection	connection	NN
18637	7952	42	with	with	IN
18637	7952	43	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	7952	44	XII	XII	NNP
18637	7952	45	.	.	.
18637	7953	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7953	2	39	39	CD
18637	7953	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7953	4	"	"	``
18637	7953	5	NATURAL	NATURAL	NNP
18637	7953	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	7953	7	BORN	born	NN
18637	7953	8	"	"	''
18637	7953	9	CITIZEN	CITIZEN	NNP
18637	7953	10	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	7953	11	3	3	CD
18637	7953	12	of	of	IN
18637	7953	13	this	this	DT
18637	7953	14	section	section	NN
18637	7953	15	,	,	,
18637	7953	16	while	while	IN
18637	7953	17	requiring	require	VBG
18637	7953	18	that	that	IN
18637	7953	19	the	the	DT
18637	7953	20	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	7953	21	each	each	DT
18637	7953	22	vote	vote	NN
18637	7953	23	for	for	IN
18637	7953	24	two	two	CD
18637	7953	25	persons	person	NNS
18637	7953	26	,	,	,
18637	7953	27	did	do	VBD
18637	7953	28	not	not	RB
18637	7953	29	require	require	VB
18637	7953	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7953	31	to	to	TO
18637	7953	32	distinguish	distinguish	VB
18637	7953	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7953	34	choices	choice	NNS
18637	7953	35	for	for	IN
18637	7953	36	President	President	NNP
18637	7953	37	and	and	CC
18637	7953	38	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7953	39	President	President	NNP
18637	7953	40	,	,	,
18637	7953	41	the	the	DT
18637	7953	42	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	7953	43	being	be	VBG
18637	7953	44	that	that	IN
18637	7953	45	the	the	DT
18637	7953	46	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7953	47	President	President	NNP
18637	7953	48	would	would	MD
18637	7953	49	be	be	VB
18637	7953	50	the	the	DT
18637	7953	51	runner	runner	NN
18637	7953	52	-	-	HYPH
18637	7953	53	up	up	NN
18637	7953	54	of	of	IN
18637	7953	55	the	the	DT
18637	7953	56	successful	successful	JJ
18637	7953	57	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	7953	58	for	for	IN
18637	7953	59	President	President	NNP
18637	7953	60	.	.	.
18637	7954	1	As	as	IN
18637	7954	2	a	a	DT
18637	7954	3	result	result	NN
18637	7954	4	of	of	IN
18637	7954	5	this	this	DT
18637	7954	6	arrangement	arrangement	NN
18637	7954	7	the	the	DT
18637	7954	8	election	election	NN
18637	7954	9	of	of	IN
18637	7954	10	1800	1800	CD
18637	7954	11	produced	produce	VBD
18637	7954	12	a	a	DT
18637	7954	13	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	7954	14	tie	tie	NN
18637	7954	15	between	between	IN
18637	7954	16	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	7954	17	and	and	CC
18637	7954	18	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	7954	19	,	,	,
18637	7954	20	the	the	DT
18637	7954	21	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	7954	22	of	of	IN
18637	7954	23	the	the	DT
18637	7954	24	Republican	Republican	NNP
18637	7954	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	7954	26	Democrat	Democrat	NNP
18637	7954	27	Party	Party	NNP
18637	7954	28	for	for	IN
18637	7954	29	President	President	NNP
18637	7954	30	and	and	CC
18637	7954	31	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7954	32	President	President	NNP
18637	7954	33	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	7954	34	.	.	.
18637	7955	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	7955	2	XII	XII	NNP
18637	7955	3	,	,	,
18637	7955	4	which	which	WDT
18637	7955	5	was	be	VBD
18637	7955	6	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	7955	7	in	in	IN
18637	7955	8	1803	1803	CD
18637	7955	9	and	and	CC
18637	7955	10	replaces	replace	VBZ
18637	7955	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	7955	12	3	3	CD
18637	7955	13	,	,	,
18637	7955	14	makes	make	VBZ
18637	7955	15	a	a	DT
18637	7955	16	recurrence	recurrence	NN
18637	7955	17	of	of	IN
18637	7955	18	the	the	DT
18637	7955	19	1800	1800	CD
18637	7955	20	contretemps	contretemp	NNS
18637	7955	21	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	7955	22	.	.	.
18637	7956	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7956	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7956	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7956	4	pp	pp	NNP
18637	7956	5	.	.	.
18637	7957	1	941	941	CD
18637	7957	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	7957	3	942	942	CD
18637	7957	4	.	.	.
18637	7958	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	7958	2	4	4	CD
18637	7958	3	testifies	testifie	NNS
18637	7958	4	still	still	RB
18637	7958	5	further	further	RB
18637	7958	6	to	to	IN
18637	7958	7	the	the	DT
18637	7958	8	national	national	JJ
18637	7958	9	character	character	NN
18637	7958	10	of	of	IN
18637	7958	11	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	7958	12	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	7958	13	.	.	.
18637	7959	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	7959	2	5	5	CD
18637	7959	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	7959	4	today	today	NN
18637	7959	5	chiefly	chiefly	RB
18637	7959	6	of	of	IN
18637	7959	7	historical	historical	JJ
18637	7959	8	interest	interest	NN
18637	7959	9	,	,	,
18637	7959	10	all	all	DT
18637	7959	11	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	7959	12	since	since	IN
18637	7959	13	,	,	,
18637	7959	14	and	and	CC
18637	7959	15	including	include	VBG
18637	7959	16	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	7959	17	Van	Van	NNP
18637	7959	18	Buren	Buren	NNP
18637	7959	19	,	,	,
18637	7959	20	except	except	IN
18637	7959	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7959	22	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	7959	23	successor	successor	NN
18637	7959	24	,	,	,
18637	7959	25	William	William	NNP
18637	7959	26	Henry	Henry	NNP
18637	7959	27	Harrison	Harrison	NNP
18637	7959	28	,	,	,
18637	7959	29	having	have	VBG
18637	7959	30	been	be	VBN
18637	7959	31	born	bear	VBN
18637	7959	32	in	in	IN
18637	7959	33	the	the	DT
18637	7959	34	United	United	NNP
18637	7959	35	States	States	NNP
18637	7959	36	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	7959	37	to	to	IN
18637	7959	38	the	the	DT
18637	7959	39	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
18637	7959	40	of	of	IN
18637	7959	41	Independence	Independence	NNP
18637	7959	42	.	.	.
18637	7960	1	The	the	DT
18637	7960	2	question	question	NN
18637	7960	3	,	,	,
18637	7960	4	however	however	RB
18637	7960	5	,	,	,
18637	7960	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	7960	7	been	be	VBN
18637	7960	8	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	7960	9	mooted	moot	VBN
18637	7960	10	,	,	,
18637	7960	11	whether	whether	IN
18637	7960	12	a	a	DT
18637	7960	13	child	child	NN
18637	7960	14	born	bear	VBN
18637	7960	15	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	7960	16	of	of	IN
18637	7960	17	American	american	JJ
18637	7960	18	parents	parent	NNS
18637	7960	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	7960	20	"	"	``
18637	7960	21	a	a	DT
18637	7960	22	natural	natural	RB
18637	7960	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	7960	24	born	bear	VBN
18637	7960	25	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	7960	26	"	"	''
18637	7960	27	in	in	IN
18637	7960	28	the	the	DT
18637	7960	29	sense	sense	NN
18637	7960	30	of	of	IN
18637	7960	31	this	this	DT
18637	7960	32	clause	clause	NN
18637	7960	33	.	.	.
18637	7961	1	The	the	DT
18637	7961	2	answer	answer	NN
18637	7961	3	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	7961	4	upon	upon	IN
18637	7961	5	whether	whether	IN
18637	7961	6	the	the	DT
18637	7961	7	definition	definition	NN
18637	7961	8	of	of	IN
18637	7961	9	"	"	``
18637	7961	10	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	7961	11	of	of	IN
18637	7961	12	the	the	DT
18637	7961	13	United	United	NNP
18637	7961	14	States	States	NNP
18637	7961	15	"	"	''
18637	7961	16	in	in	IN
18637	7961	17	section	section	NN
18637	7961	18	I	I	NNP
18637	7961	19	of	of	IN
18637	7961	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	7961	21	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	7961	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	7961	23	to	to	TO
18637	7961	24	be	be	VB
18637	7961	25	given	give	VBN
18637	7961	26	an	an	DT
18637	7961	27	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	7961	28	or	or	CC
18637	7961	29	inclusive	inclusive	JJ
18637	7961	30	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	7961	31	.	.	.
18637	7962	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7962	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7962	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7962	4	pp	pp	NNP
18637	7962	5	.	.	.
18637	7963	1	963	963	CD
18637	7963	2	-	-	SYM
18637	7963	3	964	964	CD
18637	7963	4	.	.	.
18637	7964	1	PRESIDENTIAL	PRESIDENTIAL	NNP
18637	7964	2	SUCCESSION	SUCCESSION	NNP
18637	7964	3	Was	be	VBD
18637	7964	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7964	5	the	the	DT
18637	7964	6	thought	thought	NN
18637	7964	7	of	of	IN
18637	7964	8	the	the	DT
18637	7964	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7964	10	that	that	WDT
18637	7964	11	a	a	DT
18637	7964	12	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7964	13	President	President	NNP
18637	7964	14	,	,	,
18637	7964	15	in	in	IN
18637	7964	16	succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	7964	17	to	to	IN
18637	7964	18	"	"	``
18637	7964	19	the	the	DT
18637	7964	20	powers	power	NNS
18637	7964	21	and	and	CC
18637	7964	22	duties	duty	NNS
18637	7964	23	"	"	''
18637	7964	24	of	of	IN
18637	7964	25	the	the	DT
18637	7964	26	office	office	NN
18637	7964	27	of	of	IN
18637	7964	28	President	President	NNP
18637	7964	29	,	,	,
18637	7964	30	should	should	MD
18637	7964	31	succeed	succeed	VB
18637	7964	32	also	also	RB
18637	7964	33	to	to	IN
18637	7964	34	the	the	DT
18637	7964	35	title	title	NN
18637	7964	36	?	?	.
18637	7965	1	In	in	IN
18637	7965	2	answering	answer	VBG
18637	7965	3	this	this	DT
18637	7965	4	question	question	NN
18637	7965	5	in	in	IN
18637	7965	6	the	the	DT
18637	7965	7	affirmative	affirmative	NN
18637	7965	8	in	in	IN
18637	7965	9	1841	1841	CD
18637	7965	10	,	,	,
18637	7965	11	John	John	NNP
18637	7965	12	Tyler	Tyler	NNP
18637	7965	13	established	establish	VBD
18637	7965	14	a	a	DT
18637	7965	15	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	7965	16	which	which	WDT
18637	7965	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	7965	18	been	be	VBN
18637	7965	19	followed	follow	VBN
18637	7965	20	ever	ever	RB
18637	7965	21	since	since	RB
18637	7965	22	;	;	:
18637	7965	23	but	but	CC
18637	7965	24	inasmuch	inasmuch	VB
18637	7965	25	as	as	IN
18637	7965	26	all	all	DT
18637	7965	27	successions	succession	NNS
18637	7965	28	have	have	VBP
18637	7965	29	taken	take	VBN
18637	7965	30	place	place	NN
18637	7965	31	in	in	IN
18637	7965	32	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	7965	33	of	of	IN
18637	7965	34	the	the	DT
18637	7965	35	death	death	NN
18637	7965	36	in	in	IN
18637	7965	37	office	office	NN
18637	7965	38	of	of	IN
18637	7965	39	a	a	DT
18637	7965	40	President	President	NNP
18637	7965	41	,	,	,
18637	7965	42	the	the	DT
18637	7965	43	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	7965	44	would	would	MD
18637	7965	45	not	not	RB
18637	7965	46	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	7965	47	hold	hold	VB
18637	7965	48	in	in	RP
18637	7965	49	the	the	DT
18637	7965	50	case	case	NN
18637	7965	51	of	of	IN
18637	7965	52	a	a	DT
18637	7965	53	succession	succession	NN
18637	7965	54	on	on	IN
18637	7965	55	account	account	NN
18637	7965	56	of	of	IN
18637	7965	57	the	the	DT
18637	7965	58	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	7965	59	inability	inability	NN
18637	7965	60	of	of	IN
18637	7965	61	the	the	DT
18637	7965	62	incumbent	incumbent	JJ
18637	7965	63	President	President	NNP
18637	7965	64	.	.	.
18637	7966	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	7966	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	7966	3	any	any	DT
18637	7966	4	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	7966	5	been	be	VBN
18637	7966	6	established	establish	VBN
18637	7966	7	for	for	IN
18637	7966	8	determining	determine	VBG
18637	7966	9	the	the	DT
18637	7966	10	question	question	NN
18637	7966	11	of	of	IN
18637	7966	12	inability	inability	NN
18637	7966	13	,	,	,
18637	7966	14	with	with	IN
18637	7966	15	the	the	DT
18637	7966	16	result	result	NN
18637	7966	17	that	that	IN
18637	7966	18	in	in	IN
18637	7966	19	the	the	DT
18637	7966	20	two	two	CD
18637	7966	21	instances	instance	NNS
18637	7966	22	of	of	IN
18637	7966	23	disability	disability	NN
18637	7966	24	which	which	WDT
18637	7966	25	have	have	VBP
18637	7966	26	occurred	occur	VBN
18637	7966	27	,	,	,
18637	7966	28	those	those	DT
18637	7966	29	of	of	IN
18637	7966	30	Presidents	Presidents	NNPS
18637	7966	31	Garfield	Garfield	NNP
18637	7966	32	and	and	CC
18637	7966	33	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	7966	34	,	,	,
18637	7966	35	the	the	DT
18637	7966	36	former	former	JJ
18637	7966	37	continued	continue	VBN
18637	7966	38	in	in	IN
18637	7966	39	office	office	NN
18637	7966	40	until	until	IN
18637	7966	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7966	42	death	death	NN
18637	7966	43	and	and	CC
18637	7966	44	the	the	DT
18637	7966	45	other	other	JJ
18637	7966	46	,	,	,
18637	7966	47	after	after	IN
18637	7966	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7966	49	partial	partial	JJ
18637	7966	50	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	7966	51	,	,	,
18637	7966	52	till	till	IN
18637	7966	53	the	the	DT
18637	7966	54	end	end	NN
18637	7966	55	of	of	IN
18637	7966	56	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7966	57	term	term	NN
18637	7966	58	.	.	.
18637	7967	1	The	the	DT
18637	7967	2	Act	Act	NNP
18637	7967	3	of	of	IN
18637	7967	4	1792	1792	CD
18637	7967	5	In	in	IN
18637	7967	6	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	7967	7	of	of	IN
18637	7967	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7967	9	power	power	NN
18637	7967	10	to	to	TO
18637	7967	11	provide	provide	VB
18637	7967	12	for	for	IN
18637	7967	13	the	the	DT
18637	7967	14	disappearance	disappearance	NN
18637	7967	15	,	,	,
18637	7967	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	7967	17	permanently	permanently	RB
18637	7967	18	or	or	CC
18637	7967	19	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	7967	20	,	,	,
18637	7967	21	from	from	IN
18637	7967	22	the	the	DT
18637	7967	23	scene	scene	NN
18637	7967	24	of	of	IN
18637	7967	25	both	both	DT
18637	7967	26	President	President	NNP
18637	7967	27	and	and	CC
18637	7967	28	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7967	29	President	President	NNP
18637	7967	30	,	,	,
18637	7967	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7967	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	7967	33	passed	pass	VBN
18637	7967	34	three	three	CD
18637	7967	35	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	7967	36	Succession	Succession	NNP
18637	7967	37	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	7967	38	.	.	.
18637	7968	1	A	a	DT
18637	7968	2	law	law	NN
18637	7968	3	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	7968	4	March	March	NNP
18637	7968	5	1	1	CD
18637	7968	6	,	,	,
18637	7968	7	1792[40	1792[40	LS
18637	7968	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7968	9	provided	provide	VBN
18637	7968	10	for	for	IN
18637	7968	11	the	the	DT
18637	7968	12	succession	succession	NN
18637	7968	13	first	first	RB
18637	7968	14	of	of	IN
18637	7968	15	the	the	DT
18637	7968	16	President	President	NNP
18637	7968	17	_	_	NNP
18637	7968	18	pro	pro	NN
18637	7968	19	tempore	tempore	JJ
18637	7968	20	_	_	NNP
18637	7968	21	of	of	IN
18637	7968	22	the	the	DT
18637	7968	23	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	7968	24	and	and	CC
18637	7968	25	then	then	RB
18637	7968	26	of	of	IN
18637	7968	27	the	the	DT
18637	7968	28	Speaker	Speaker	NNP
18637	7968	29	;	;	:
18637	7968	30	but	but	CC
18637	7968	31	in	in	IN
18637	7968	32	the	the	DT
18637	7968	33	event	event	NN
18637	7968	34	that	that	IN
18637	7968	35	both	both	DT
18637	7968	36	of	of	IN
18637	7968	37	these	these	DT
18637	7968	38	offices	office	NNS
18637	7968	39	were	be	VBD
18637	7968	40	vacant	vacant	JJ
18637	7968	41	,	,	,
18637	7968	42	then	then	RB
18637	7968	43	the	the	DT
18637	7968	44	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	7968	45	of	of	IN
18637	7968	46	State	State	NNP
18637	7968	47	was	be	VBD
18637	7968	48	to	to	TO
18637	7968	49	inform	inform	VB
18637	7968	50	the	the	DT
18637	7968	51	executive	executive	NN
18637	7968	52	of	of	IN
18637	7968	53	each	each	DT
18637	7968	54	State	State	NNP
18637	7968	55	of	of	IN
18637	7968	56	the	the	DT
18637	7968	57	fact	fact	NN
18637	7968	58	and	and	CC
18637	7968	59	at	at	IN
18637	7968	60	the	the	DT
18637	7968	61	same	same	JJ
18637	7968	62	time	time	NN
18637	7968	63	give	give	VB
18637	7968	64	public	public	JJ
18637	7968	65	notice	notice	NN
18637	7968	66	that	that	IN
18637	7968	67	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	7968	68	will	will	MD
18637	7968	69	be	be	VB
18637	7968	70	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	7968	71	in	in	IN
18637	7968	72	each	each	DT
18637	7968	73	State	state	NN
18637	7968	74	to	to	TO
18637	7968	75	elect	elect	VB
18637	7968	76	a	a	DT
18637	7968	77	President	President	NNP
18637	7968	78	and	and	CC
18637	7968	79	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7968	80	President	President	NNP
18637	7968	81	,	,	,
18637	7968	82	unless	unless	IN
18637	7968	83	the	the	DT
18637	7968	84	regular	regular	JJ
18637	7968	85	time	time	NN
18637	7968	86	of	of	IN
18637	7968	87	such	such	JJ
18637	7968	88	election	election	NN
18637	7968	89	was	be	VBD
18637	7968	90	so	so	RB
18637	7968	91	near	near	JJ
18637	7968	92	at	at	IN
18637	7968	93	hand	hand	NN
18637	7968	94	as	as	IN
18637	7968	95	to	to	TO
18637	7968	96	render	render	VB
18637	7968	97	the	the	DT
18637	7968	98	step	step	NN
18637	7968	99	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	7968	100	.	.	.
18637	7969	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7969	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	7969	3	unlikely	unlikely	JJ
18637	7969	4	that	that	IN
18637	7969	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7969	6	ever	ever	RB
18637	7969	7	passed	pass	VBD
18637	7969	8	a	a	DT
18637	7969	9	more	more	RBR
18637	7969	10	ill	ill	RB
18637	7969	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	7969	12	considered	consider	VBN
18637	7969	13	law	law	NN
18637	7969	14	.	.	.
18637	7970	1	As	as	IN
18637	7970	2	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	7970	3	pointed	point	VBD
18637	7970	4	out	out	RP
18637	7970	5	at	at	IN
18637	7970	6	the	the	DT
18637	7970	7	time	time	NN
18637	7970	8	,	,	,
18637	7970	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7970	10	violated	violate	VBD
18637	7970	11	the	the	DT
18637	7970	12	principle	principle	NN
18637	7970	13	of	of	IN
18637	7970	14	the	the	DT
18637	7970	15	Separation	Separation	NNP
18637	7970	16	of	of	IN
18637	7970	17	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	7970	18	and	and	CC
18637	7970	19	flouted	flout	VBD
18637	7970	20	the	the	DT
18637	7970	21	probability	probability	NN
18637	7970	22	that	that	IN
18637	7970	23	neither	neither	CC
18637	7970	24	the	the	DT
18637	7970	25	President	President	NNP
18637	7970	26	_	_	NNP
18637	7970	27	pro	pro	NN
18637	7970	28	tempore	tempore	NN
18637	7970	29	_	_	NNP
18637	7970	30	nor	nor	CC
18637	7970	31	the	the	DT
18637	7970	32	Speaker	Speaker	NNP
18637	7970	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	7970	34	an	an	DT
18637	7970	35	"	"	``
18637	7970	36	officer	officer	NN
18637	7970	37	"	"	''
18637	7970	38	in	in	IN
18637	7970	39	the	the	DT
18637	7970	40	sense	sense	NN
18637	7970	41	of	of	IN
18637	7970	42	this	this	DT
18637	7970	43	paragraph	paragraph	NN
18637	7970	44	of	of	IN
18637	7970	45	the	the	DT
18637	7970	46	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7970	47	.	.	.
18637	7971	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7971	2	thus	thus	RB
18637	7971	3	contemplated	contemplate	VBD
18637	7971	4	the	the	DT
18637	7971	5	possibility	possibility	NN
18637	7971	6	of	of	IN
18637	7971	7	there	there	RB
18637	7971	8	being	be	VBG
18637	7971	9	nobody	nobody	NN
18637	7971	10	to	to	TO
18637	7971	11	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	7971	12	the	the	DT
18637	7971	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	7971	14	of	of	IN
18637	7971	15	the	the	DT
18637	7971	16	President	President	NNP
18637	7971	17	for	for	IN
18637	7971	18	an	an	DT
18637	7971	19	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	7971	20	period	period	NN
18637	7971	21	,	,	,
18637	7971	22	and	and	CC
18637	7971	23	at	at	IN
18637	7971	24	the	the	DT
18637	7971	25	same	same	JJ
18637	7971	26	time	time	NN
18637	7971	27	set	set	VBN
18637	7971	28	at	at	IN
18637	7971	29	naught	naught	NN
18637	7971	30	,	,	,
18637	7971	31	by	by	IN
18637	7971	32	the	the	DT
18637	7971	33	provision	provision	NN
18637	7971	34	made	make	VBN
18637	7971	35	for	for	IN
18637	7971	36	an	an	DT
18637	7971	37	interim	interim	JJ
18637	7971	38	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7971	39	election	election	NN
18637	7971	40	,	,	,
18637	7971	41	the	the	DT
18637	7971	42	synchrony	synchrony	NN
18637	7971	43	evidently	evidently	RB
18637	7971	44	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
18637	7971	45	by	by	IN
18637	7971	46	the	the	DT
18637	7971	47	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	7971	48	in	in	IN
18637	7971	49	the	the	DT
18637	7971	50	choice	choice	NN
18637	7971	51	of	of	IN
18637	7971	52	a	a	DT
18637	7971	53	President	President	NNP
18637	7971	54	with	with	IN
18637	7971	55	a	a	DT
18637	7971	56	new	new	JJ
18637	7971	57	House	House	NNP
18637	7971	58	of	of	IN
18637	7971	59	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	7971	60	and	and	CC
18637	7971	61	a	a	DT
18637	7971	62	new	new	JJ
18637	7971	63	one	one	CD
18637	7971	64	-	-	HYPH
18637	7971	65	third	third	NN
18637	7971	66	of	of	IN
18637	7971	67	the	the	DT
18637	7971	68	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	7971	69	.	.	.
18637	7972	1	Yet	yet	CC
18637	7972	2	this	this	DT
18637	7972	3	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
18637	7972	4	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	7972	5	remained	remain	VBD
18637	7972	6	on	on	IN
18637	7972	7	the	the	DT
18637	7972	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	7972	9	book	book	NN
18637	7972	10	for	for	IN
18637	7972	11	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	7972	12	one	one	CD
18637	7972	13	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	7972	14	years	year	NNS
18637	7972	15	,	,	,
18637	7972	16	becoming	become	VBG
18637	7972	17	all	all	PDT
18637	7972	18	the	the	DT
18637	7972	19	time	time	NN
18637	7972	20	more	more	RBR
18637	7972	21	and	and	CC
18637	7972	22	more	more	RBR
18637	7972	23	unworkable	unworkable	JJ
18637	7972	24	from	from	IN
18637	7972	25	obsolescence	obsolescence	NN
18637	7972	26	.	.	.
18637	7973	1	One	one	CD
18637	7973	2	provision	provision	NN
18637	7973	3	of	of	IN
18637	7973	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7973	5	,	,	,
18637	7973	6	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	7973	7	,	,	,
18637	7973	8	still	still	RB
18637	7973	9	survives	survive	VBZ
18637	7973	10	,	,	,
18637	7973	11	that	that	IN
18637	7973	12	which	which	WDT
18637	7973	13	ordains	ordain	VBZ
18637	7973	14	that	that	IN
18637	7973	15	the	the	DT
18637	7973	16	only	only	JJ
18637	7973	17	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	7973	18	of	of	IN
18637	7973	19	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	7973	20	to	to	TO
18637	7973	21	accept	accept	VB
18637	7973	22	,	,	,
18637	7973	23	or	or	CC
18637	7973	24	of	of	IN
18637	7973	25	resignation	resignation	NN
18637	7973	26	from	from	IN
18637	7973	27	the	the	DT
18637	7973	28	office	office	NN
18637	7973	29	of	of	IN
18637	7973	30	President	President	NNP
18637	7973	31	or	or	CC
18637	7973	32	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7973	33	President	President	NNP
18637	7973	34	,	,	,
18637	7973	35	shall	shall	MD
18637	7973	36	be	be	VB
18637	7973	37	an	an	DT
18637	7973	38	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	7973	39	in	in	IN
18637	7973	40	writing	write	VBG
18637	7973	41	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	7973	42	the	the	DT
18637	7973	43	same	same	JJ
18637	7973	44	and	and	CC
18637	7973	45	subscribed	subscribe	VBN
18637	7973	46	by	by	IN
18637	7973	47	the	the	DT
18637	7973	48	person	person	NN
18637	7973	49	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	7973	50	to	to	TO
18637	7973	51	accept	accept	VB
18637	7973	52	,	,	,
18637	7973	53	or	or	CC
18637	7973	54	resigning	resign	VBG
18637	7973	55	,	,	,
18637	7973	56	as	as	IN
18637	7973	57	the	the	DT
18637	7973	58	case	case	NN
18637	7973	59	may	may	MD
18637	7973	60	be	be	VB
18637	7973	61	,	,	,
18637	7973	62	and	and	CC
18637	7973	63	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	7973	64	into	into	IN
18637	7973	65	the	the	DT
18637	7973	66	office	office	NN
18637	7973	67	of	of	IN
18637	7973	68	the	the	DT
18637	7973	69	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	7973	70	of	of	IN
18637	7973	71	State	State	NNP
18637	7973	72	.	.	.
18637	7974	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7974	2	41	41	CD
18637	7974	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7974	4	The	the	DT
18637	7974	5	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	7974	6	of	of	IN
18637	7974	7	1886	1886	CD
18637	7974	8	and	and	CC
18637	7974	9	1947	1947	CD
18637	7974	10	By	by	IN
18637	7974	11	the	the	DT
18637	7974	12	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	7974	13	Succession	Succession	NNP
18637	7974	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	7974	15	of	of	IN
18637	7974	16	January	January	NNP
18637	7974	17	19	19	CD
18637	7974	18	,	,	,
18637	7974	19	1886,[42	1886,[42	CD
18637	7974	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7974	21	recently	recently	RB
18637	7974	22	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	7974	23	,	,	,
18637	7974	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7974	25	provided	provide	VBD
18637	7974	26	that	that	IN
18637	7974	27	,	,	,
18637	7974	28	in	in	IN
18637	7974	29	case	case	NN
18637	7974	30	of	of	IN
18637	7974	31	the	the	DT
18637	7974	32	disqualification	disqualification	NN
18637	7974	33	of	of	IN
18637	7974	34	both	both	DT
18637	7974	35	President	President	NNP
18637	7974	36	and	and	CC
18637	7974	37	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7974	38	President	President	NNP
18637	7974	39	,	,	,
18637	7974	40	the	the	DT
18637	7974	41	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	7974	42	of	of	IN
18637	7974	43	State	State	NNP
18637	7974	44	should	should	MD
18637	7974	45	act	act	VB
18637	7974	46	as	as	IN
18637	7974	47	President	President	NNP
18637	7974	48	provided	provide	VBD
18637	7974	49	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7974	50	possessed	possess	VBD
18637	7974	51	the	the	DT
18637	7974	52	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	7974	53	laid	lay	VBN
18637	7974	54	down	down	RP
18637	7974	55	in	in	IN
18637	7974	56	clause	clause	NN
18637	7974	57	5	5	CD
18637	7974	58	,	,	,
18637	7974	59	above	above	RB
18637	7974	60	;	;	:
18637	7974	61	if	if	IN
18637	7974	62	not	not	RB
18637	7974	63	,	,	,
18637	7974	64	then	then	RB
18637	7974	65	the	the	DT
18637	7974	66	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	7974	67	of	of	IN
18637	7974	68	the	the	DT
18637	7974	69	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	7974	70	,	,	,
18637	7974	71	etc	etc	FW
18637	7974	72	.	.	.
18637	7975	1	The	the	DT
18637	7975	2	act	act	NN
18637	7975	3	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	7975	4	assumed	assume	VBD
18637	7975	5	that	that	IN
18637	7975	6	while	while	IN
18637	7975	7	a	a	DT
18637	7975	8	member	member	NN
18637	7975	9	of	of	IN
18637	7975	10	the	the	DT
18637	7975	11	Cabinet	Cabinet	NNP
18637	7975	12	acted	act	VBD
18637	7975	13	as	as	IN
18637	7975	14	President	President	NNP
18637	7975	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7975	16	would	would	MD
18637	7975	17	retain	retain	VB
18637	7975	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7975	19	Cabinet	Cabinet	NNP
18637	7975	20	post	post	NN
18637	7975	21	.	.	.
18637	7976	1	The	the	DT
18637	7976	2	Succession	Succession	NNP
18637	7976	3	Act	Act	NNP
18637	7976	4	now	now	RB
18637	7976	5	in	in	IN
18637	7976	6	force	force	NN
18637	7976	7	was	be	VBD
18637	7976	8	urged	urge	VBN
18637	7976	9	by	by	IN
18637	7976	10	President	President	NNP
18637	7976	11	Truman	Truman	NNP
18637	7976	12	,	,	,
18637	7976	13	who	who	WP
18637	7976	14	argued	argue	VBD
18637	7976	15	that	that	IN
18637	7976	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7976	17	was	be	VBD
18637	7976	18	"	"	``
18637	7976	19	undemocratic	undemocratic	JJ
18637	7976	20	"	"	''
18637	7976	21	for	for	IN
18637	7976	22	a	a	DT
18637	7976	23	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7976	24	President	President	NNP
18637	7976	25	who	who	WP
18637	7976	26	had	have	VBD
18637	7976	27	succeeded	succeed	VBN
18637	7976	28	to	to	IN
18637	7976	29	the	the	DT
18637	7976	30	Presidency	Presidency	NNP
18637	7976	31	to	to	TO
18637	7976	32	be	be	VB
18637	7976	33	able	able	JJ
18637	7976	34	to	to	TO
18637	7976	35	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	7976	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7976	37	own	own	JJ
18637	7976	38	successor	successor	NN
18637	7976	39	.	.	.
18637	7977	1	By	by	IN
18637	7977	2	the	the	DT
18637	7977	3	act	act	NN
18637	7977	4	of	of	IN
18637	7977	5	July	July	NNP
18637	7977	6	18	18	CD
18637	7977	7	,	,	,
18637	7977	8	1947[43	1947[43	LS
18637	7977	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7977	10	the	the	DT
18637	7977	11	Speaker	Speaker	NNP
18637	7977	12	of	of	IN
18637	7977	13	the	the	DT
18637	7977	14	House	House	NNP
18637	7977	15	and	and	CC
18637	7977	16	the	the	DT
18637	7977	17	President	President	NNP
18637	7977	18	_	_	NNP
18637	7977	19	pro	pro	NN
18637	7977	20	tempore	tempore	JJ
18637	7977	21	_	_	NNP
18637	7977	22	of	of	IN
18637	7977	23	the	the	DT
18637	7977	24	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	7977	25	are	be	VBP
18637	7977	26	put	put	VBN
18637	7977	27	ahead	ahead	RB
18637	7977	28	of	of	IN
18637	7977	29	the	the	DT
18637	7977	30	members	member	NNS
18637	7977	31	of	of	IN
18637	7977	32	the	the	DT
18637	7977	33	Cabinet	Cabinet	NNP
18637	7977	34	in	in	IN
18637	7977	35	the	the	DT
18637	7977	36	order	order	NN
18637	7977	37	of	of	IN
18637	7977	38	succession	succession	NN
18637	7977	39	,	,	,
18637	7977	40	but	but	CC
18637	7977	41	when	when	WRB
18637	7977	42	either	either	CC
18637	7977	43	succeeds	succeed	VBZ
18637	7977	44	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7977	45	must	must	MD
18637	7977	46	resign	resign	VB
18637	7977	47	both	both	CC
18637	7977	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7977	49	post	post	NN
18637	7977	50	and	and	CC
18637	7977	51	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7977	52	seat	seat	NN
18637	7977	53	in	in	IN
18637	7977	54	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7977	55	;	;	:
18637	7977	56	and	and	CC
18637	7977	57	a	a	DT
18637	7977	58	member	member	NN
18637	7977	59	of	of	IN
18637	7977	60	the	the	DT
18637	7977	61	Cabinet	Cabinet	NNP
18637	7977	62	must	must	MD
18637	7977	63	in	in	IN
18637	7977	64	the	the	DT
18637	7977	65	like	like	JJ
18637	7977	66	situation	situation	NN
18637	7977	67	resign	resign	VB
18637	7977	68	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7977	69	Cabinet	Cabinet	NNP
18637	7977	70	post	post	NN
18637	7977	71	.	.	.
18637	7978	1	The	the	DT
18637	7978	2	new	new	JJ
18637	7978	3	act	act	NN
18637	7978	4	also	also	RB
18637	7978	5	implements	implement	VBZ
18637	7978	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	7978	7	XX	XX	NNP
18637	7978	8	by	by	IN
18637	7978	9	providing	provide	VBG
18637	7978	10	for	for	IN
18637	7978	11	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	7978	12	due	due	JJ
18637	7978	13	to	to	IN
18637	7978	14	failure	failure	NN
18637	7978	15	to	to	TO
18637	7978	16	qualify	qualify	VB
18637	7978	17	of	of	IN
18637	7978	18	both	both	CC
18637	7978	19	a	a	DT
18637	7978	20	newly	newly	RB
18637	7978	21	elected	elect	VBN
18637	7978	22	President	President	NNP
18637	7978	23	and	and	CC
18637	7978	24	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	7978	25	President	President	NNP
18637	7978	26	.	.	.
18637	7979	1	COMPENSATION	COMPENSATION	NNP
18637	7979	2	AND	and	CC
18637	7979	3	EMOLUMENTS	EMOLUMENTS	NNP
18637	7979	4	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	7979	5	7	7	CD
18637	7979	6	may	may	MD
18637	7979	7	be	be	VB
18637	7979	8	advantageously	advantageously	RB
18637	7979	9	considered	consider	VBN
18637	7979	10	in	in	IN
18637	7979	11	the	the	DT
18637	7979	12	light	light	NN
18637	7979	13	of	of	IN
18637	7979	14	what	what	WP
18637	7979	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	7979	16	been	be	VBN
18637	7979	17	determined	determine	VBN
18637	7979	18	as	as	IN
18637	7979	19	to	to	IN
18637	7979	20	the	the	DT
18637	7979	21	application	application	NN
18637	7979	22	of	of	IN
18637	7979	23	the	the	DT
18637	7979	24	parallel	parallel	JJ
18637	7979	25	provision	provision	NN
18637	7979	26	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	7979	27	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	7979	28	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	7979	29	.	.	.
18637	7980	1	_	_	NNP
18637	7980	2	See	See	NNP
18637	7980	3	_	_	NNP
18637	7980	4	pp	pp	NNP
18637	7980	5	.	.	.
18637	7981	1	530	530	CD
18637	7981	2	-	-	SYM
18637	7981	3	531	531	CD
18637	7981	4	.	.	.
18637	7982	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7982	2	44	44	CD
18637	7982	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7982	4	OATH	OATH	NNP
18637	7982	5	OF	of	IN
18637	7982	6	OFFICE	OFFICE	NNP
18637	7982	7	What	what	WP
18637	7982	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	7982	9	the	the	DT
18637	7982	10	time	time	NN
18637	7982	11	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	7982	12	between	between	IN
18637	7982	13	a	a	DT
18637	7982	14	President	President	NNP
18637	7982	15	's	's	POS
18637	7982	16	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	7982	17	of	of	IN
18637	7982	18	office	office	NN
18637	7982	19	and	and	CC
18637	7982	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7982	21	taking	take	VBG
18637	7982	22	the	the	DT
18637	7982	23	oath	oath	NN
18637	7982	24	?	?	.
18637	7983	1	Apparently	apparently	RB
18637	7983	2	the	the	DT
18637	7983	3	former	former	NN
18637	7983	4	comes	come	VBZ
18637	7983	5	first	first	RB
18637	7983	6	.	.	.
18637	7984	1	This	this	DT
18637	7984	2	answer	answer	NN
18637	7984	3	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	7984	4	to	to	TO
18637	7984	5	be	be	VB
18637	7984	6	required	require	VBN
18637	7984	7	by	by	IN
18637	7984	8	the	the	DT
18637	7984	9	language	language	NN
18637	7984	10	of	of	IN
18637	7984	11	the	the	DT
18637	7984	12	clause	clause	NN
18637	7984	13	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7984	14	,	,	,
18637	7984	15	and	and	CC
18637	7984	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	7984	17	further	further	RB
18637	7984	18	supported	support	VBN
18637	7984	19	by	by	IN
18637	7984	20	the	the	DT
18637	7984	21	fact	fact	NN
18637	7984	22	that	that	IN
18637	7984	23	,	,	,
18637	7984	24	while	while	IN
18637	7984	25	the	the	DT
18637	7984	26	act	act	NN
18637	7984	27	of	of	IN
18637	7984	28	March	March	NNP
18637	7984	29	1	1	CD
18637	7984	30	,	,	,
18637	7984	31	1792	1792	CD
18637	7984	32	assumes	assume	VBZ
18637	7984	33	that	that	IN
18637	7984	34	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	7984	35	became	become	VBD
18637	7984	36	President	President	NNP
18637	7984	37	March	March	NNP
18637	7984	38	4	4	CD
18637	7984	39	,	,	,
18637	7984	40	1789	1789	CD
18637	7984	41	,	,	,
18637	7984	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7984	43	did	do	VBD
18637	7984	44	not	not	RB
18637	7984	45	take	take	VB
18637	7984	46	the	the	DT
18637	7984	47	oath	oath	NN
18637	7984	48	till	till	IN
18637	7984	49	April	April	NNP
18637	7984	50	30th	30th	NN
18637	7984	51	.	.	.
18637	7985	1	Also	also	RB
18637	7985	2	,	,	,
18637	7985	3	in	in	IN
18637	7985	4	the	the	DT
18637	7985	5	parallel	parallel	JJ
18637	7985	6	case	case	NN
18637	7985	7	of	of	IN
18637	7985	8	the	the	DT
18637	7985	9	coronation	coronation	NN
18637	7985	10	oath	oath	NN
18637	7985	11	of	of	IN
18637	7985	12	the	the	DT
18637	7985	13	British	British	NNP
18637	7985	14	Monarch	Monarch	NNP
18637	7985	15	,	,	,
18637	7985	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7985	17	taking	taking	NN
18637	7985	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	7985	19	been	be	VBN
18637	7985	20	at	at	IN
18637	7985	21	times	time	NNS
18637	7985	22	postponed	postpone	VBN
18637	7985	23	for	for	IN
18637	7985	24	years	year	NNS
18637	7985	25	after	after	IN
18637	7985	26	the	the	DT
18637	7985	27	heir	heir	NN
18637	7985	28	's	's	POS
18637	7985	29	succession	succession	NN
18637	7985	30	.	.	.
18637	7986	1	Effect	effect	NN
18637	7986	2	of	of	IN
18637	7986	3	the	the	DT
18637	7986	4	Oath	Oath	NNP
18637	7986	5	Does	do	VBZ
18637	7986	6	the	the	DT
18637	7986	7	oath	oath	NN
18637	7986	8	add	add	VB
18637	7986	9	anything	anything	NN
18637	7986	10	to	to	IN
18637	7986	11	the	the	DT
18637	7986	12	President	President	NNP
18637	7986	13	's	's	POS
18637	7986	14	powers	power	NNS
18637	7986	15	?	?	.
18637	7987	1	Again	again	RB
18637	7987	2	to	to	TO
18637	7987	3	judge	judge	VB
18637	7987	4	from	from	IN
18637	7987	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7987	6	English	english	JJ
18637	7987	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	7987	8	British	british	JJ
18637	7987	9	antecedent	antecedent	NN
18637	7987	10	,	,	,
18637	7987	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7987	12	informing	inform	VBG
18637	7987	13	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	7987	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	7987	15	to	to	TO
18637	7987	16	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	7987	17	rather	rather	RB
18637	7987	18	than	than	IN
18637	7987	19	to	to	TO
18637	7987	20	aggrandize	aggrandize	VB
18637	7987	21	power	power	NN
18637	7987	22	.	.	.
18637	7988	1	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	7988	2	,	,	,
18637	7988	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7988	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	7988	5	true	true	JJ
18637	7988	6	,	,	,
18637	7988	7	appealed	appeal	VBD
18637	7988	8	to	to	IN
18637	7988	9	the	the	DT
18637	7988	10	oath	oath	NN
18637	7988	11	in	in	IN
18637	7988	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7988	13	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	7988	14	Veto	Veto	NNP
18637	7988	15	Message	Message	NNP
18637	7988	16	of	of	IN
18637	7988	17	July	July	NNP
18637	7988	18	10	10	CD
18637	7988	19	,	,	,
18637	7988	20	1832	1832	CD
18637	7988	21	;	;	:
18637	7988	22	and	and	CC
18637	7988	23	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	7988	24	did	do	VBD
18637	7988	25	so	so	RB
18637	7988	26	in	in	IN
18637	7988	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7988	28	Message	message	NN
18637	7988	29	of	of	IN
18637	7988	30	July	July	NNP
18637	7988	31	4	4	CD
18637	7988	32	,	,	,
18637	7988	33	1861	1861	CD
18637	7988	34	;	;	:
18637	7988	35	as	as	IN
18637	7988	36	did	do	VBD
18637	7988	37	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	7988	38	's	's	POS
18637	7988	39	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	7988	40	in	in	IN
18637	7988	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7988	42	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	7988	43	trial	trial	NN
18637	7988	44	;	;	:
18637	7988	45	but	but	CC
18637	7988	46	in	in	IN
18637	7988	47	each	each	DT
18637	7988	48	of	of	IN
18637	7988	49	these	these	DT
18637	7988	50	instances	instance	NNS
18637	7988	51	the	the	DT
18637	7988	52	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	7988	53	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	7988	54	of	of	IN
18637	7988	55	power	power	NN
18637	7988	56	involved	involve	VBN
18637	7988	57	rested	rest	VBN
18637	7988	58	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	7988	59	on	on	IN
18637	7988	60	other	other	JJ
18637	7988	61	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	7988	62	.	.	.
18637	7989	1	Section	section	NN
18637	7989	2	2	2	CD
18637	7989	3	.	.	.
18637	7990	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	7990	2	1	1	CD
18637	7990	3	.	.	.
18637	7991	1	The	the	DT
18637	7991	2	President	President	NNP
18637	7991	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	7991	4	be	be	VB
18637	7991	5	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	7991	6	in	in	IN
18637	7991	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	7991	8	of	of	IN
18637	7991	9	the	the	DT
18637	7991	10	Army	Army	NNP
18637	7991	11	and	and	CC
18637	7991	12	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	7991	13	of	of	IN
18637	7991	14	the	the	DT
18637	7991	15	United	United	NNP
18637	7991	16	States	States	NNP
18637	7991	17	,	,	,
18637	7991	18	and	and	CC
18637	7991	19	of	of	IN
18637	7991	20	the	the	DT
18637	7991	21	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	7991	22	of	of	IN
18637	7991	23	the	the	DT
18637	7991	24	several	several	JJ
18637	7991	25	States	States	NNPS
18637	7991	26	,	,	,
18637	7991	27	when	when	WRB
18637	7991	28	called	call	VBN
18637	7991	29	into	into	IN
18637	7991	30	the	the	DT
18637	7991	31	actual	actual	JJ
18637	7991	32	Service	Service	NNP
18637	7991	33	of	of	IN
18637	7991	34	the	the	DT
18637	7991	35	United	United	NNP
18637	7991	36	States	States	NNP
18637	7991	37	;	;	:
18637	7991	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7991	39	may	may	MD
18637	7991	40	require	require	VB
18637	7991	41	the	the	DT
18637	7991	42	Opinion	Opinion	NNP
18637	7991	43	,	,	,
18637	7991	44	in	in	IN
18637	7991	45	writing	writing	NN
18637	7991	46	,	,	,
18637	7991	47	of	of	IN
18637	7991	48	the	the	DT
18637	7991	49	principal	principal	JJ
18637	7991	50	Officer	Officer	NNP
18637	7991	51	in	in	IN
18637	7991	52	each	each	DT
18637	7991	53	of	of	IN
18637	7991	54	the	the	DT
18637	7991	55	executive	executive	JJ
18637	7991	56	Departments	department	NNS
18637	7991	57	,	,	,
18637	7991	58	upon	upon	IN
18637	7991	59	any	any	DT
18637	7991	60	Subject	Subject	NNP
18637	7991	61	relating	relate	VBG
18637	7991	62	to	to	IN
18637	7991	63	the	the	DT
18637	7991	64	Duties	Duties	NNPS
18637	7991	65	of	of	IN
18637	7991	66	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7991	67	respective	respective	JJ
18637	7991	68	Offices	office	NNS
18637	7991	69	,	,	,
18637	7991	70	and	and	CC
18637	7991	71	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7991	72	shall	shall	MD
18637	7991	73	have	have	VB
18637	7991	74	Power	Power	NNP
18637	7991	75	to	to	TO
18637	7991	76	grant	grant	VB
18637	7991	77	Reprieves	Reprieves	NNP
18637	7991	78	and	and	CC
18637	7991	79	Pardons	Pardons	NNPS
18637	7991	80	for	for	IN
18637	7991	81	Offences	offence	NNS
18637	7991	82	against	against	IN
18637	7991	83	the	the	DT
18637	7991	84	United	United	NNP
18637	7991	85	States	States	NNP
18637	7991	86	,	,	,
18637	7991	87	except	except	IN
18637	7991	88	in	in	IN
18637	7991	89	Cases	case	NNS
18637	7991	90	of	of	IN
18637	7991	91	Impeachment	Impeachment	NNP
18637	7991	92	.	.	.
18637	7992	1	The	the	DT
18637	7992	2	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	7992	3	in	in	IN
18637	7992	4	Chiefship	Chiefship	NNP
18637	7992	5	HISTORICAL	HISTORICAL	NNP
18637	7992	6	The	the	DT
18637	7992	7	purely	purely	RB
18637	7992	8	military	military	JJ
18637	7992	9	aspects	aspect	NNS
18637	7992	10	of	of	IN
18637	7992	11	the	the	DT
18637	7992	12	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	7992	13	in	in	IN
18637	7992	14	Chiefship	Chiefship	NNP
18637	7992	15	were	be	VBD
18637	7992	16	those	those	DT
18637	7992	17	which	which	WDT
18637	7992	18	were	be	VBD
18637	7992	19	originally	originally	RB
18637	7992	20	stressed	stress	VBN
18637	7992	21	.	.	.
18637	7993	1	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	7993	2	said	say	VBD
18637	7993	3	the	the	DT
18637	7993	4	office	office	NN
18637	7993	5	"	"	``
18637	7993	6	would	would	MD
18637	7993	7	amount	amount	VB
18637	7993	8	to	to	IN
18637	7993	9	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	7993	10	more	more	JJR
18637	7993	11	than	than	IN
18637	7993	12	the	the	DT
18637	7993	13	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	7993	14	command	command	NNP
18637	7993	15	and	and	CC
18637	7993	16	direction	direction	NN
18637	7993	17	of	of	IN
18637	7993	18	the	the	DT
18637	7993	19	Military	military	JJ
18637	7993	20	and	and	CC
18637	7993	21	naval	naval	JJ
18637	7993	22	forces	force	NNS
18637	7993	23	,	,	,
18637	7993	24	as	as	IN
18637	7993	25	first	first	JJ
18637	7993	26	general	general	JJ
18637	7993	27	and	and	CC
18637	7993	28	admiral	admiral	NN
18637	7993	29	of	of	IN
18637	7993	30	the	the	DT
18637	7993	31	confederacy	confederacy	NN
18637	7993	32	.	.	.
18637	7994	1	"	"	``
18637	7994	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7994	3	45	45	CD
18637	7994	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7994	5	Story	story	NN
18637	7994	6	wrote	write	VBD
18637	7994	7	in	in	IN
18637	7994	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7994	9	Commentaries	commentary	NNS
18637	7994	10	:	:	:
18637	7994	11	"	"	``
18637	7994	12	The	the	DT
18637	7994	13	propriety	propriety	NN
18637	7994	14	of	of	IN
18637	7994	15	admitting	admit	VBG
18637	7994	16	the	the	DT
18637	7994	17	president	president	NN
18637	7994	18	to	to	TO
18637	7994	19	be	be	VB
18637	7994	20	commander	commander	NN
18637	7994	21	in	in	IN
18637	7994	22	chief	chief	NN
18637	7994	23	,	,	,
18637	7994	24	so	so	RB
18637	7994	25	far	far	RB
18637	7994	26	as	as	IN
18637	7994	27	to	to	TO
18637	7994	28	give	give	VB
18637	7994	29	orders	order	NNS
18637	7994	30	,	,	,
18637	7994	31	and	and	CC
18637	7994	32	have	have	VB
18637	7994	33	a	a	DT
18637	7994	34	general	general	JJ
18637	7994	35	superintendency	superintendency	NN
18637	7994	36	,	,	,
18637	7994	37	was	be	VBD
18637	7994	38	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	7994	39	.	.	.
18637	7995	1	But	but	CC
18637	7995	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7995	3	was	be	VBD
18637	7995	4	urged	urge	VBN
18637	7995	5	,	,	,
18637	7995	6	that	that	IN
18637	7995	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7995	8	would	would	MD
18637	7995	9	be	be	VB
18637	7995	10	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	7995	11	to	to	TO
18637	7995	12	let	let	VB
18637	7995	13	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7995	14	command	command	VB
18637	7995	15	in	in	IN
18637	7995	16	person	person	NN
18637	7995	17	,	,	,
18637	7995	18	without	without	IN
18637	7995	19	any	any	DT
18637	7995	20	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	7995	21	,	,	,
18637	7995	22	as	as	IN
18637	7995	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7995	24	might	may	MD
18637	7995	25	make	make	VB
18637	7995	26	a	a	DT
18637	7995	27	bad	bad	JJ
18637	7995	28	use	use	NN
18637	7995	29	of	of	IN
18637	7995	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7995	31	.	.	.
18637	7996	1	The	the	DT
18637	7996	2	consent	consent	NN
18637	7996	3	of	of	IN
18637	7996	4	both	both	DT
18637	7996	5	houses	house	NNS
18637	7996	6	of	of	IN
18637	7996	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	7996	8	ought	ought	MD
18637	7996	9	,	,	,
18637	7996	10	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	7996	11	,	,	,
18637	7996	12	to	to	TO
18637	7996	13	be	be	VB
18637	7996	14	required	require	VBN
18637	7996	15	,	,	,
18637	7996	16	before	before	IN
18637	7996	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7996	18	should	should	MD
18637	7996	19	take	take	VB
18637	7996	20	the	the	DT
18637	7996	21	actual	actual	JJ
18637	7996	22	command	command	NN
18637	7996	23	.	.	.
18637	7997	1	The	the	DT
18637	7997	2	answer	answer	NN
18637	7997	3	then	then	RB
18637	7997	4	given	give	VBN
18637	7997	5	was	be	VBD
18637	7997	6	,	,	,
18637	7997	7	that	that	IN
18637	7997	8	though	though	IN
18637	7997	9	the	the	DT
18637	7997	10	president	president	NN
18637	7997	11	might	may	MD
18637	7997	12	,	,	,
18637	7997	13	there	there	EX
18637	7997	14	was	be	VBD
18637	7997	15	no	no	DT
18637	7997	16	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	7997	17	that	that	IN
18637	7997	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7997	19	should	should	MD
18637	7997	20	,	,	,
18637	7997	21	take	take	VB
18637	7997	22	the	the	DT
18637	7997	23	command	command	NN
18637	7997	24	in	in	IN
18637	7997	25	person	person	NN
18637	7997	26	;	;	:
18637	7997	27	and	and	CC
18637	7997	28	there	there	EX
18637	7997	29	was	be	VBD
18637	7997	30	no	no	DT
18637	7997	31	probability	probability	NN
18637	7997	32	that	that	IN
18637	7997	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7997	34	would	would	MD
18637	7997	35	do	do	VB
18637	7997	36	so	so	RB
18637	7997	37	,	,	,
18637	7997	38	except	except	IN
18637	7997	39	in	in	IN
18637	7997	40	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	7997	41	emergencies	emergency	NNS
18637	7997	42	,	,	,
18637	7997	43	and	and	CC
18637	7997	44	when	when	WRB
18637	7997	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7997	46	was	be	VBD
18637	7997	47	possessed	possess	VBN
18637	7997	48	of	of	IN
18637	7997	49	superior	superior	JJ
18637	7997	50	military	military	JJ
18637	7997	51	talents	talent	NNS
18637	7997	52	.	.	.
18637	7998	1	"	"	``
18637	7998	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7998	3	46	46	CD
18637	7998	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7998	5	In	in	IN
18637	7998	6	1850	1850	CD
18637	7998	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	7998	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	7998	9	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	7998	10	,	,	,
18637	7998	11	for	for	IN
18637	7998	12	the	the	DT
18637	7998	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	7998	14	,	,	,
18637	7998	15	said	say	VBD
18637	7998	16	:	:	:
18637	7998	17	"	"	``
18637	7998	18	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7998	19	[	[	-LRB-
18637	7998	20	the	the	DT
18637	7998	21	President	President	NNP
18637	7998	22	's	's	POS
18637	7998	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	7998	24	duty	duty	NN
18637	7998	25	and	and	CC
18637	7998	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7998	27	power	power	NN
18637	7998	28	are	be	VBP
18637	7998	29	purely	purely	RB
18637	7998	30	military	military	JJ
18637	7998	31	.	.	.
18637	7999	1	As	as	IN
18637	7999	2	commander	commander	NN
18637	7999	3	in	in	IN
18637	7999	4	chief	chief	NN
18637	7999	5	,	,	,
18637	7999	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7999	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	7999	8	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	7999	9	to	to	TO
18637	7999	10	direct	direct	VB
18637	7999	11	the	the	DT
18637	7999	12	movements	movement	NNS
18637	7999	13	of	of	IN
18637	7999	14	the	the	DT
18637	7999	15	naval	naval	JJ
18637	7999	16	and	and	CC
18637	7999	17	military	military	JJ
18637	7999	18	forces	force	NNS
18637	7999	19	placed	place	VBN
18637	7999	20	by	by	IN
18637	7999	21	law	law	NN
18637	7999	22	at	at	IN
18637	7999	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	7999	24	command	command	NN
18637	7999	25	,	,	,
18637	7999	26	and	and	CC
18637	7999	27	to	to	TO
18637	7999	28	employ	employ	VB
18637	7999	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7999	30	in	in	IN
18637	7999	31	the	the	DT
18637	7999	32	manner	manner	NN
18637	7999	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	7999	34	may	may	MD
18637	7999	35	deem	deem	VB
18637	7999	36	most	most	JJS
18637	7999	37	effectual	effectual	JJ
18637	7999	38	to	to	TO
18637	7999	39	harass	harass	VB
18637	7999	40	and	and	CC
18637	7999	41	conquer	conquer	VB
18637	7999	42	and	and	CC
18637	7999	43	subdue	subdue	VB
18637	7999	44	the	the	DT
18637	7999	45	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	7999	46	.	.	.
18637	8000	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8000	2	may	may	MD
18637	8000	3	invade	invade	VB
18637	8000	4	the	the	DT
18637	8000	5	hostile	hostile	JJ
18637	8000	6	country	country	NN
18637	8000	7	,	,	,
18637	8000	8	and	and	CC
18637	8000	9	subject	subject	VB
18637	8000	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8000	11	to	to	IN
18637	8000	12	the	the	DT
18637	8000	13	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	8000	14	and	and	CC
18637	8000	15	authority	authority	NN
18637	8000	16	of	of	IN
18637	8000	17	the	the	DT
18637	8000	18	United	United	NNP
18637	8000	19	States	States	NNP
18637	8000	20	.	.	.
18637	8001	1	But	but	CC
18637	8001	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8001	3	conquests	conquest	NNS
18637	8001	4	do	do	VBP
18637	8001	5	not	not	RB
18637	8001	6	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	8001	7	the	the	DT
18637	8001	8	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	8001	9	of	of	IN
18637	8001	10	this	this	DT
18637	8001	11	Union	Union	NNP
18637	8001	12	,	,	,
18637	8001	13	nor	nor	CC
18637	8001	14	extend	extend	VB
18637	8001	15	the	the	DT
18637	8001	16	operation	operation	NN
18637	8001	17	of	of	IN
18637	8001	18	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8001	19	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	8001	20	and	and	CC
18637	8001	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	8001	22	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	8001	23	the	the	DT
18637	8001	24	limits	limit	NNS
18637	8001	25	before	before	IN
18637	8001	26	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	8001	27	to	to	IN
18637	8001	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8001	29	by	by	IN
18637	8001	30	the	the	DT
18637	8001	31	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8001	32	power	power	NN
18637	8001	33	.	.	.
18637	8002	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8002	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8002	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8002	4	But	but	CC
18637	8002	5	in	in	IN
18637	8002	6	the	the	DT
18637	8002	7	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	8002	8	of	of	IN
18637	8002	9	political	political	JJ
18637	8002	10	power	power	NN
18637	8002	11	between	between	IN
18637	8002	12	the	the	DT
18637	8002	13	great	great	JJ
18637	8002	14	departments	department	NNS
18637	8002	15	of	of	IN
18637	8002	16	government	government	NN
18637	8002	17	,	,	,
18637	8002	18	there	there	EX
18637	8002	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	8002	20	such	such	PDT
18637	8002	21	a	a	DT
18637	8002	22	wide	wide	JJ
18637	8002	23	difference	difference	NN
18637	8002	24	between	between	IN
18637	8002	25	the	the	DT
18637	8002	26	power	power	NN
18637	8002	27	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	8002	28	on	on	IN
18637	8002	29	the	the	DT
18637	8002	30	President	President	NNP
18637	8002	31	of	of	IN
18637	8002	32	the	the	DT
18637	8002	33	United	United	NNP
18637	8002	34	States	States	NNP
18637	8002	35	,	,	,
18637	8002	36	and	and	CC
18637	8002	37	the	the	DT
18637	8002	38	authority	authority	NN
18637	8002	39	and	and	CC
18637	8002	40	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	8002	41	which	which	WDT
18637	8002	42	belong	belong	VBP
18637	8002	43	to	to	IN
18637	8002	44	the	the	DT
18637	8002	45	English	english	JJ
18637	8002	46	crown	crown	NN
18637	8002	47	,	,	,
18637	8002	48	that	that	IN
18637	8002	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8002	50	would	would	MD
18637	8002	51	be	be	VB
18637	8002	52	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	8002	53	unsafe	unsafe	JJ
18637	8002	54	to	to	TO
18637	8002	55	reason	reason	VB
18637	8002	56	from	from	IN
18637	8002	57	any	any	DT
18637	8002	58	supposed	suppose	VBN
18637	8002	59	resemblance	resemblance	NN
18637	8002	60	between	between	IN
18637	8002	61	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8002	62	,	,	,
18637	8002	63	either	either	CC
18637	8002	64	as	as	IN
18637	8002	65	regards	regard	NNS
18637	8002	66	conquest	conquest	NN
18637	8002	67	in	in	IN
18637	8002	68	war	war	NN
18637	8002	69	,	,	,
18637	8002	70	or	or	CC
18637	8002	71	any	any	DT
18637	8002	72	other	other	JJ
18637	8002	73	subject	subject	NN
18637	8002	74	where	where	WRB
18637	8002	75	the	the	DT
18637	8002	76	rights	right	NNS
18637	8002	77	and	and	CC
18637	8002	78	powers	power	NNS
18637	8002	79	of	of	IN
18637	8002	80	the	the	DT
18637	8002	81	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8002	82	arm	arm	NN
18637	8002	83	of	of	IN
18637	8002	84	the	the	DT
18637	8002	85	government	government	NN
18637	8002	86	are	be	VBP
18637	8002	87	brought	bring	VBN
18637	8002	88	into	into	IN
18637	8002	89	question	question	NN
18637	8002	90	.	.	.
18637	8003	1	"	"	``
18637	8003	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8003	3	47	47	CD
18637	8003	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8003	5	Even	even	RB
18637	8003	6	after	after	IN
18637	8003	7	the	the	DT
18637	8003	8	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	8003	9	War	War	NNP
18637	8003	10	a	a	DT
18637	8003	11	powerful	powerful	JJ
18637	8003	12	minority	minority	NN
18637	8003	13	of	of	IN
18637	8003	14	the	the	DT
18637	8003	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8003	16	described	describe	VBD
18637	8003	17	the	the	DT
18637	8003	18	role	role	NN
18637	8003	19	of	of	IN
18637	8003	20	President	President	NNP
18637	8003	21	as	as	IN
18637	8003	22	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8003	23	in	in	IN
18637	8003	24	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8003	25	simply	simply	RB
18637	8003	26	as	as	IN
18637	8003	27	"	"	``
18637	8003	28	the	the	DT
18637	8003	29	command	command	NN
18637	8003	30	of	of	IN
18637	8003	31	the	the	DT
18637	8003	32	forces	force	NNS
18637	8003	33	and	and	CC
18637	8003	34	the	the	DT
18637	8003	35	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	8003	36	of	of	IN
18637	8003	37	campaigns	campaign	NNS
18637	8003	38	.	.	.
18637	8004	1	"	"	``
18637	8004	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8004	3	48	48	CD
18637	8004	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8004	5	THE	the	DT
18637	8004	6	PRIZE	prize	NN
18637	8004	7	CASES	cases	VBP
18637	8004	8	The	the	DT
18637	8004	9	basis	basis	NN
18637	8004	10	for	for	IN
18637	8004	11	a	a	DT
18637	8004	12	broader	broad	JJR
18637	8004	13	conception	conception	NN
18637	8004	14	was	be	VBD
18637	8004	15	laid	lay	VBN
18637	8004	16	in	in	IN
18637	8004	17	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8004	18	early	early	JJ
18637	8004	19	acts	act	NNS
18637	8004	20	of	of	IN
18637	8004	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8004	22	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	8004	23	the	the	DT
18637	8004	24	President	President	NNP
18637	8004	25	to	to	TO
18637	8004	26	employ	employ	VB
18637	8004	27	military	military	JJ
18637	8004	28	force	force	NN
18637	8004	29	in	in	IN
18637	8004	30	the	the	DT
18637	8004	31	execution	execution	NN
18637	8004	32	of	of	IN
18637	8004	33	the	the	DT
18637	8004	34	laws	law	NNS
18637	8004	35	.	.	.
18637	8005	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8005	2	49	49	CD
18637	8005	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8005	4	In	in	IN
18637	8005	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8005	6	famous	famous	JJ
18637	8005	7	message	message	NN
18637	8005	8	to	to	IN
18637	8005	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8005	10	of	of	IN
18637	8005	11	July	July	NNP
18637	8005	12	4	4	CD
18637	8005	13	,	,	,
18637	8005	14	1861,[50	1861,[50	CD
18637	8005	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8005	16	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	8005	17	advanced	advance	VBD
18637	8005	18	the	the	DT
18637	8005	19	claim	claim	NN
18637	8005	20	that	that	IN
18637	8005	21	the	the	DT
18637	8005	22	"	"	``
18637	8005	23	war	war	NN
18637	8005	24	power	power	NN
18637	8005	25	"	"	''
18637	8005	26	was	be	VBD
18637	8005	27	his	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8005	28	for	for	IN
18637	8005	29	the	the	DT
18637	8005	30	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8005	31	of	of	IN
18637	8005	32	suppressing	suppress	VBG
18637	8005	33	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	8005	34	;	;	:
18637	8005	35	and	and	CC
18637	8005	36	in	in	IN
18637	8005	37	the	the	DT
18637	8005	38	Prize	Prize	NNP
18637	8005	39	Cases[51	Cases[51	NNP
18637	8005	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8005	41	of	of	IN
18637	8005	42	1863	1863	CD
18637	8005	43	,	,	,
18637	8005	44	a	a	DT
18637	8005	45	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	8005	46	divided	divide	VBN
18637	8005	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8005	48	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	8005	49	this	this	DT
18637	8005	50	theory	theory	NN
18637	8005	51	.	.	.
18637	8006	1	The	the	DT
18637	8006	2	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	8006	3	issue	issue	NN
18637	8006	4	of	of	IN
18637	8006	5	the	the	DT
18637	8006	6	case	case	NN
18637	8006	7	was	be	VBD
18637	8006	8	the	the	DT
18637	8006	9	validity	validity	NN
18637	8006	10	of	of	IN
18637	8006	11	the	the	DT
18637	8006	12	blockade	blockade	NN
18637	8006	13	which	which	WDT
18637	8006	14	the	the	DT
18637	8006	15	President	President	NNP
18637	8006	16	,	,	,
18637	8006	17	following	follow	VBG
18637	8006	18	the	the	DT
18637	8006	19	attack	attack	NN
18637	8006	20	on	on	IN
18637	8006	21	Fort	Fort	NNP
18637	8006	22	Sumter	Sumter	NNP
18637	8006	23	,	,	,
18637	8006	24	had	have	VBD
18637	8006	25	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
18637	8006	26	of	of	IN
18637	8006	27	the	the	DT
18637	8006	28	Southern	southern	JJ
18637	8006	29	ports	port	NNS
18637	8006	30	.	.	.
18637	8007	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8007	2	52	52	CD
18637	8007	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8007	4	The	the	DT
18637	8007	5	argument	argument	NN
18637	8007	6	was	be	VBD
18637	8007	7	advanced	advanced	JJ
18637	8007	8	that	that	IN
18637	8007	9	a	a	DT
18637	8007	10	blockade	blockade	NN
18637	8007	11	to	to	TO
18637	8007	12	be	be	VB
18637	8007	13	valid	valid	JJ
18637	8007	14	must	must	MD
18637	8007	15	be	be	VB
18637	8007	16	an	an	DT
18637	8007	17	incident	incident	NN
18637	8007	18	of	of	IN
18637	8007	19	a	a	DT
18637	8007	20	"	"	``
18637	8007	21	public	public	JJ
18637	8007	22	war	war	NN
18637	8007	23	"	"	''
18637	8007	24	validly	validly	RB
18637	8007	25	declared	declare	VBD
18637	8007	26	,	,	,
18637	8007	27	and	and	CC
18637	8007	28	that	that	IN
18637	8007	29	only	only	RB
18637	8007	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8007	31	could	could	MD
18637	8007	32	,	,	,
18637	8007	33	by	by	IN
18637	8007	34	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	8007	35	of	of	IN
18637	8007	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8007	37	power	power	NN
18637	8007	38	"	"	''
18637	8007	39	to	to	TO
18637	8007	40	declare	declare	VB
18637	8007	41	war	war	NN
18637	8007	42	,	,	,
18637	8007	43	"	"	''
18637	8007	44	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	8007	45	impart	impart	NN
18637	8007	46	to	to	IN
18637	8007	47	a	a	DT
18637	8007	48	military	military	JJ
18637	8007	49	situation	situation	NN
18637	8007	50	this	this	DT
18637	8007	51	character	character	NN
18637	8007	52	and	and	CC
18637	8007	53	scope	scope	NN
18637	8007	54	.	.	.
18637	8008	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8008	2	for	for	IN
18637	8008	3	the	the	DT
18637	8008	4	majority	majority	NN
18637	8008	5	of	of	IN
18637	8008	6	the	the	DT
18637	8008	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8008	8	,	,	,
18637	8008	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8008	10	Grier	Grier	NNP
18637	8008	11	answered	answer	VBD
18637	8008	12	:	:	:
18637	8008	13	"	"	``
18637	8008	14	If	if	IN
18637	8008	15	a	a	DT
18637	8008	16	war	war	NN
18637	8008	17	be	be	VB
18637	8008	18	made	make	VBN
18637	8008	19	by	by	IN
18637	8008	20	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	8008	21	of	of	IN
18637	8008	22	a	a	DT
18637	8008	23	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8008	24	nation	nation	NN
18637	8008	25	,	,	,
18637	8008	26	the	the	DT
18637	8008	27	President	President	NNP
18637	8008	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	8008	29	not	not	RB
18637	8008	30	only	only	RB
18637	8008	31	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8008	32	but	but	CC
18637	8008	33	bound	bind	VBN
18637	8008	34	to	to	TO
18637	8008	35	resist	resist	VB
18637	8008	36	force	force	NN
18637	8008	37	by	by	IN
18637	8008	38	force	force	NN
18637	8008	39	.	.	.
18637	8009	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8009	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	8009	3	not	not	RB
18637	8009	4	initiate	initiate	VB
18637	8009	5	the	the	DT
18637	8009	6	war	war	NN
18637	8009	7	,	,	,
18637	8009	8	but	but	CC
18637	8009	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	8009	10	bound	bind	VBN
18637	8009	11	to	to	TO
18637	8009	12	accept	accept	VB
18637	8009	13	the	the	DT
18637	8009	14	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	8009	15	without	without	IN
18637	8009	16	waiting	wait	VBG
18637	8009	17	for	for	IN
18637	8009	18	any	any	DT
18637	8009	19	special	special	JJ
18637	8009	20	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8009	21	authority	authority	NN
18637	8009	22	.	.	.
18637	8010	1	And	and	CC
18637	8010	2	whether	whether	IN
18637	8010	3	the	the	DT
18637	8010	4	hostile	hostile	JJ
18637	8010	5	party	party	NN
18637	8010	6	be	be	VB
18637	8010	7	a	a	DT
18637	8010	8	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8010	9	invader	invader	NN
18637	8010	10	,	,	,
18637	8010	11	or	or	CC
18637	8010	12	States	States	NNP
18637	8010	13	organized	organize	VBD
18637	8010	14	in	in	IN
18637	8010	15	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	8010	16	,	,	,
18637	8010	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8010	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	8010	19	none	none	NN
18637	8010	20	the	the	DT
18637	8010	21	less	less	RBR
18637	8010	22	a	a	DT
18637	8010	23	war	war	NN
18637	8010	24	,	,	,
18637	8010	25	although	although	IN
18637	8010	26	the	the	DT
18637	8010	27	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	8010	28	of	of	IN
18637	8010	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8010	30	be	be	VB
18637	8010	31	'	'	''
18637	8010	32	_	_	NNP
18637	8010	33	unilateral	unilateral	JJ
18637	8010	34	_	_	NNP
18637	8010	35	.	.	.
18637	8010	36	'	'	''
18637	8011	1	Lord	Lord	NNP
18637	8011	2	Stowell	Stowell	NNP
18637	8011	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8011	4	1	1	CD
18637	8011	5	Dodson	Dodson	NNP
18637	8011	6	,	,	,
18637	8011	7	247	247	CD
18637	8011	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8011	9	observes	observe	VBZ
18637	8011	10	,	,	,
18637	8011	11	'	'	''
18637	8011	12	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8011	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	8011	14	not	not	RB
18637	8011	15	the	the	DT
18637	8011	16	less	less	RBR
18637	8011	17	a	a	DT
18637	8011	18	war	war	NN
18637	8011	19	on	on	IN
18637	8011	20	_	_	NNP
18637	8011	21	that	that	DT
18637	8011	22	account	account	NN
18637	8011	23	_	_	NNP
18637	8011	24	,	,	,
18637	8011	25	for	for	IN
18637	8011	26	war	war	NN
18637	8011	27	may	may	MD
18637	8011	28	exist	exist	VB
18637	8011	29	without	without	IN
18637	8011	30	a	a	DT
18637	8011	31	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	8011	32	on	on	IN
18637	8011	33	either	either	DT
18637	8011	34	side	side	NN
18637	8011	35	.	.	.
18637	8012	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8012	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8012	3	so	so	RB
18637	8012	4	laid	lay	VBN
18637	8012	5	down	down	RP
18637	8012	6	by	by	IN
18637	8012	7	the	the	DT
18637	8012	8	best	good	JJS
18637	8012	9	writers	writer	NNS
18637	8012	10	on	on	IN
18637	8012	11	the	the	DT
18637	8012	12	law	law	NN
18637	8012	13	of	of	IN
18637	8012	14	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8012	15	.	.	.
18637	8013	1	A	a	DT
18637	8013	2	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	8013	3	of	of	IN
18637	8013	4	war	war	NN
18637	8013	5	by	by	IN
18637	8013	6	one	one	CD
18637	8013	7	country	country	NN
18637	8013	8	only	only	RB
18637	8013	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	8013	10	not	not	RB
18637	8013	11	a	a	DT
18637	8013	12	mere	mere	JJ
18637	8013	13	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	8013	14	to	to	TO
18637	8013	15	be	be	VB
18637	8013	16	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	8013	17	or	or	CC
18637	8013	18	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	8013	19	at	at	IN
18637	8013	20	pleasure	pleasure	NN
18637	8013	21	by	by	IN
18637	8013	22	the	the	DT
18637	8013	23	other	other	JJ
18637	8013	24	.	.	.
18637	8013	25	'	'	''
18637	8014	1	The	the	DT
18637	8014	2	battles	battle	NNS
18637	8014	3	of	of	IN
18637	8014	4	Palo	Palo	NNP
18637	8014	5	Alto	Alto	NNP
18637	8014	6	and	and	CC
18637	8014	7	Resaca	Resaca	NNP
18637	8014	8	de	de	NNP
18637	8014	9	la	la	NNP
18637	8014	10	Palma	Palma	NNP
18637	8014	11	had	have	VBD
18637	8014	12	been	be	VBN
18637	8014	13	fought	fight	VBN
18637	8014	14	before	before	IN
18637	8014	15	the	the	DT
18637	8014	16	passage	passage	NN
18637	8014	17	of	of	IN
18637	8014	18	the	the	DT
18637	8014	19	act	act	NN
18637	8014	20	of	of	IN
18637	8014	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8014	22	of	of	IN
18637	8014	23	May	May	NNP
18637	8014	24	13	13	CD
18637	8014	25	,	,	,
18637	8014	26	1846	1846	CD
18637	8014	27	,	,	,
18637	8014	28	which	which	WDT
18637	8014	29	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	8014	30	'	'	''
18637	8014	31	_	_	NNP
18637	8014	32	a	a	DT
18637	8014	33	state	state	NN
18637	8014	34	of	of	IN
18637	8014	35	war	war	NN
18637	8014	36	as	as	IN
18637	8014	37	existing	exist	VBG
18637	8014	38	by	by	IN
18637	8014	39	the	the	DT
18637	8014	40	act	act	NN
18637	8014	41	of	of	IN
18637	8014	42	the	the	DT
18637	8014	43	Republic	Republic	NNP
18637	8014	44	of	of	IN
18637	8014	45	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	8014	46	_	_	NNP
18637	8014	47	.	.	.
18637	8014	48	'	'	''
18637	8015	1	This	this	DT
18637	8015	2	act	act	NN
18637	8015	3	not	not	RB
18637	8015	4	only	only	RB
18637	8015	5	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8015	6	for	for	IN
18637	8015	7	the	the	DT
18637	8015	8	future	future	JJ
18637	8015	9	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	8015	10	of	of	IN
18637	8015	11	the	the	DT
18637	8015	12	war	war	NN
18637	8015	13	,	,	,
18637	8015	14	but	but	CC
18637	8015	15	was	be	VBD
18637	8015	16	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8015	17	a	a	DT
18637	8015	18	vindication	vindication	NN
18637	8015	19	and	and	CC
18637	8015	20	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	8015	21	of	of	IN
18637	8015	22	the	the	DT
18637	8015	23	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8015	24	of	of	IN
18637	8015	25	the	the	DT
18637	8015	26	President	President	NNP
18637	8015	27	in	in	IN
18637	8015	28	accepting	accept	VBG
18637	8015	29	the	the	DT
18637	8015	30	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	8015	31	without	without	IN
18637	8015	32	a	a	DT
18637	8015	33	previous	previous	JJ
18637	8015	34	formal	formal	JJ
18637	8015	35	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	8015	36	of	of	IN
18637	8015	37	war	war	NN
18637	8015	38	by	by	IN
18637	8015	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8015	40	.	.	.
18637	8016	1	This	this	DT
18637	8016	2	greatest	great	JJS
18637	8016	3	of	of	IN
18637	8016	4	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8016	5	wars	war	NNS
18637	8016	6	was	be	VBD
18637	8016	7	not	not	RB
18637	8016	8	gradually	gradually	RB
18637	8016	9	developed	develop	VBN
18637	8016	10	by	by	IN
18637	8016	11	popular	popular	JJ
18637	8016	12	commotion	commotion	NN
18637	8016	13	,	,	,
18637	8016	14	tumultuous	tumultuous	JJ
18637	8016	15	assemblies	assembly	NNS
18637	8016	16	,	,	,
18637	8016	17	or	or	CC
18637	8016	18	local	local	JJ
18637	8016	19	unorganized	unorganized	JJ
18637	8016	20	insurrections	insurrection	NNS
18637	8016	21	.	.	.
18637	8017	1	However	however	WRB
18637	8017	2	long	long	RB
18637	8017	3	may	may	MD
18637	8017	4	have	have	VB
18637	8017	5	been	be	VBN
18637	8017	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8017	7	previous	previous	JJ
18637	8017	8	conception	conception	NN
18637	8017	9	,	,	,
18637	8017	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8017	11	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	8017	12	sprung	spring	VBD
18637	8017	13	forth	forth	RB
18637	8017	14	suddenly	suddenly	RB
18637	8017	15	from	from	IN
18637	8017	16	the	the	DT
18637	8017	17	parent	parent	NN
18637	8017	18	brain	brain	NN
18637	8017	19	,	,	,
18637	8017	20	a	a	DT
18637	8017	21	Minerva	Minerva	NNP
18637	8017	22	in	in	IN
18637	8017	23	the	the	DT
18637	8017	24	full	full	JJ
18637	8017	25	panoply	panoply	NN
18637	8017	26	of	of	IN
18637	8017	27	_	_	NNP
18637	8017	28	war	war	NN
18637	8017	29	_	_	NNP
18637	8017	30	.	.	.
18637	8018	1	The	the	DT
18637	8018	2	President	President	NNP
18637	8018	3	was	be	VBD
18637	8018	4	bound	bind	VBN
18637	8018	5	to	to	TO
18637	8018	6	meet	meet	VB
18637	8018	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8018	8	in	in	IN
18637	8018	9	the	the	DT
18637	8018	10	shape	shape	NN
18637	8018	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8018	12	presented	present	VBD
18637	8018	13	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8018	14	,	,	,
18637	8018	15	without	without	IN
18637	8018	16	waiting	wait	VBG
18637	8018	17	for	for	IN
18637	8018	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8018	19	to	to	TO
18637	8018	20	baptize	baptize	VB
18637	8018	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8018	22	with	with	IN
18637	8018	23	a	a	DT
18637	8018	24	name	name	NN
18637	8018	25	;	;	:
18637	8018	26	and	and	CC
18637	8018	27	no	no	DT
18637	8018	28	name	name	NN
18637	8018	29	given	give	VBN
18637	8018	30	to	to	IN
18637	8018	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8018	32	by	by	IN
18637	8018	33	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8018	34	or	or	CC
18637	8018	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8018	36	could	could	MD
18637	8018	37	change	change	VB
18637	8018	38	the	the	DT
18637	8018	39	fact	fact	NN
18637	8018	40	.	.	.
18637	8019	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8019	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8019	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8019	4	Whether	whether	IN
18637	8019	5	the	the	DT
18637	8019	6	President	President	NNP
18637	8019	7	in	in	IN
18637	8019	8	fulfilling	fulfil	VBG
18637	8019	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8019	10	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8019	11	,	,	,
18637	8019	12	as	as	IN
18637	8019	13	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8019	14	in	in	IN
18637	8019	15	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8019	16	,	,	,
18637	8019	17	in	in	IN
18637	8019	18	suppressing	suppress	VBG
18637	8019	19	an	an	DT
18637	8019	20	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	8019	21	,	,	,
18637	8019	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	8019	23	met	meet	VBN
18637	8019	24	with	with	IN
18637	8019	25	such	such	JJ
18637	8019	26	armed	armed	JJ
18637	8019	27	hostile	hostile	JJ
18637	8019	28	resistance	resistance	NN
18637	8019	29	,	,	,
18637	8019	30	and	and	CC
18637	8019	31	a	a	DT
18637	8019	32	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8019	33	war	war	NN
18637	8019	34	of	of	IN
18637	8019	35	such	such	JJ
18637	8019	36	alarming	alarm	VBG
18637	8019	37	proportions	proportion	NNS
18637	8019	38	as	as	IN
18637	8019	39	will	will	MD
18637	8019	40	compel	compel	VB
18637	8019	41	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8019	42	to	to	TO
18637	8019	43	accord	accord	VB
18637	8019	44	to	to	IN
18637	8019	45	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8019	46	the	the	DT
18637	8019	47	character	character	NN
18637	8019	48	of	of	IN
18637	8019	49	belligerents	belligerent	NNS
18637	8019	50	,	,	,
18637	8019	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	8019	52	a	a	DT
18637	8019	53	question	question	NN
18637	8019	54	to	to	TO
18637	8019	55	be	be	VB
18637	8019	56	decided	decide	VBN
18637	8019	57	_	_	NNP
18637	8019	58	by	by	IN
18637	8019	59	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8019	60	_	_	NNP
18637	8019	61	,	,	,
18637	8019	62	and	and	CC
18637	8019	63	this	this	DT
18637	8019	64	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8019	65	must	must	MD
18637	8019	66	be	be	VB
18637	8019	67	governed	govern	VBN
18637	8019	68	by	by	IN
18637	8019	69	the	the	DT
18637	8019	70	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	8019	71	and	and	CC
18637	8019	72	acts	act	NNS
18637	8019	73	of	of	IN
18637	8019	74	the	the	DT
18637	8019	75	political	political	JJ
18637	8019	76	department	department	NN
18637	8019	77	of	of	IN
18637	8019	78	the	the	DT
18637	8019	79	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8019	80	to	to	TO
18637	8019	81	which	which	WDT
18637	8019	82	this	this	DT
18637	8019	83	power	power	NN
18637	8019	84	was	be	VBD
18637	8019	85	entrusted	entrust	VBN
18637	8019	86	.	.	.
18637	8020	1	'	'	``
18637	8020	2	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8020	3	must	must	MD
18637	8020	4	determine	determine	VB
18637	8020	5	what	what	WDT
18637	8020	6	degree	degree	NN
18637	8020	7	of	of	IN
18637	8020	8	force	force	NN
18637	8020	9	the	the	DT
18637	8020	10	crisis	crisis	NN
18637	8020	11	demands	demand	NNS
18637	8020	12	.	.	.
18637	8020	13	'	'	''
18637	8021	1	The	the	DT
18637	8021	2	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	8021	3	of	of	IN
18637	8021	4	blockade	blockade	NNP
18637	8021	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	8021	6	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8021	7	official	official	JJ
18637	8021	8	and	and	CC
18637	8021	9	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	8021	10	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	8021	11	to	to	IN
18637	8021	12	the	the	DT
18637	8021	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8021	14	that	that	IN
18637	8021	15	a	a	DT
18637	8021	16	state	state	NN
18637	8021	17	of	of	IN
18637	8021	18	war	war	NN
18637	8021	19	existed	exist	VBD
18637	8021	20	which	which	WDT
18637	8021	21	demanded	demand	VBD
18637	8021	22	and	and	CC
18637	8021	23	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	8021	24	a	a	DT
18637	8021	25	recourse	recourse	NN
18637	8021	26	to	to	IN
18637	8021	27	such	such	PDT
18637	8021	28	a	a	DT
18637	8021	29	measure	measure	NN
18637	8021	30	,	,	,
18637	8021	31	under	under	IN
18637	8021	32	the	the	DT
18637	8021	33	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	8021	34	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	8021	35	to	to	IN
18637	8021	36	the	the	DT
18637	8021	37	case	case	NN
18637	8021	38	.	.	.
18637	8022	1	"	"	``
18637	8022	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8022	3	53	53	CD
18637	8022	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8022	5	IMPACT	impact	NN
18637	8022	6	OF	of	IN
18637	8022	7	THE	the	DT
18637	8022	8	PRIZE	prize	NN
18637	8022	9	CASES	case	NNS
18637	8022	10	ON	on	IN
18637	8022	11	WORLD	world	NN
18637	8022	12	WARS	WARS	NNP
18637	8022	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8022	14	AND	and	CC
18637	8022	15	II	II	NNP
18637	8022	16	In	in	IN
18637	8022	17	brief	brief	NN
18637	8022	18	,	,	,
18637	8022	19	the	the	DT
18637	8022	20	powers	power	NNS
18637	8022	21	claimable	claimable	JJ
18637	8022	22	for	for	IN
18637	8022	23	the	the	DT
18637	8022	24	President	President	NNP
18637	8022	25	under	under	IN
18637	8022	26	the	the	DT
18637	8022	27	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8022	28	in	in	IN
18637	8022	29	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8022	30	clause	clause	NN
18637	8022	31	at	at	IN
18637	8022	32	a	a	DT
18637	8022	33	time	time	NN
18637	8022	34	of	of	IN
18637	8022	35	wide	wide	JJ
18637	8022	36	-	-	HYPH
18637	8022	37	spread	spread	NN
18637	8022	38	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	8022	39	were	be	VBD
18637	8022	40	equated	equate	VBN
18637	8022	41	with	with	IN
18637	8022	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8022	43	powers	power	NNS
18637	8022	44	under	under	IN
18637	8022	45	the	the	DT
18637	8022	46	clause	clause	NN
18637	8022	47	at	at	IN
18637	8022	48	a	a	DT
18637	8022	49	time	time	NN
18637	8022	50	when	when	WRB
18637	8022	51	the	the	DT
18637	8022	52	United	United	NNP
18637	8022	53	States	States	NNP
18637	8022	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	8022	55	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	8022	56	in	in	IN
18637	8022	57	a	a	DT
18637	8022	58	formally	formally	RB
18637	8022	59	declared	declare	VBN
18637	8022	60	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8022	61	war	war	NN
18637	8022	62	;	;	,
18637	8022	63	and	and	CC
18637	8022	64	--	--	:
18637	8022	65	impliedly	impliedly	RB
18637	8022	66	--	--	:
18637	8022	67	vice	vice	RB
18637	8022	68	versa	versa	RB
18637	8022	69	.	.	.
18637	8023	1	And	and	CC
18637	8023	2	since	since	IN
18637	8023	3	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	8023	4	performed	perform	VBD
18637	8023	5	various	various	JJ
18637	8023	6	acts	act	NNS
18637	8023	7	especially	especially	RB
18637	8023	8	in	in	IN
18637	8023	9	the	the	DT
18637	8023	10	early	early	JJ
18637	8023	11	months	month	NNS
18637	8023	12	of	of	IN
18637	8023	13	the	the	DT
18637	8023	14	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	8023	15	War	War	NNP
18637	8023	16	which	which	WDT
18637	8023	17	,	,	,
18637	8023	18	like	like	IN
18637	8023	19	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	8023	20	the	the	DT
18637	8023	21	Army	Army	NNP
18637	8023	22	and	and	CC
18637	8023	23	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	8023	24	,	,	,
18637	8023	25	admittedly	admittedly	RB
18637	8023	26	fell	fall	VBD
18637	8023	27	within	within	IN
18637	8023	28	the	the	DT
18637	8023	29	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8023	30	province	province	NN
18637	8023	31	of	of	IN
18637	8023	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8023	33	,	,	,
18637	8023	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8023	35	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	8023	36	to	to	TO
18637	8023	37	have	have	VB
18637	8023	38	been	be	VBN
18637	8023	39	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	8023	40	during	during	IN
18637	8023	41	World	World	NNP
18637	8023	42	War	War	NNP
18637	8023	43	I	I	NNP
18637	8023	44	and	and	CC
18637	8023	45	World	World	NNP
18637	8023	46	War	War	NNP
18637	8023	47	II	II	NNP
18637	8023	48	that	that	IN
18637	8023	49	the	the	DT
18637	8023	50	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8023	51	in	in	IN
18637	8023	52	Chiefship	Chiefship	NNP
18637	8023	53	carries	carry	VBZ
18637	8023	54	with	with	IN
18637	8023	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8023	56	the	the	DT
18637	8023	57	power	power	NN
18637	8023	58	to	to	TO
18637	8023	59	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	8023	60	like	like	IN
18637	8023	61	powers	power	NNS
18637	8023	62	practically	practically	RB
18637	8023	63	at	at	IN
18637	8023	64	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	8023	65	;	;	:
18637	8023	66	and	and	CC
18637	8023	67	not	not	RB
18637	8023	68	merely	merely	RB
18637	8023	69	in	in	IN
18637	8023	70	wartime	wartime	NN
18637	8023	71	but	but	CC
18637	8023	72	even	even	RB
18637	8023	73	at	at	IN
18637	8023	74	a	a	DT
18637	8023	75	time	time	NN
18637	8023	76	when	when	WRB
18637	8023	77	war	war	NN
18637	8023	78	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	8023	79	a	a	DT
18637	8023	80	strong	strong	JJ
18637	8023	81	possibility	possibility	NN
18637	8023	82	.	.	.
18637	8024	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	8024	2	was	be	VBD
18637	8024	3	any	any	DT
18637	8024	4	attention	attention	NN
18637	8024	5	given	give	VBN
18637	8024	6	the	the	DT
18637	8024	7	fact	fact	NN
18637	8024	8	that	that	IN
18637	8024	9	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	8024	10	had	have	VBD
18637	8024	11	asked	ask	VBN
18637	8024	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8024	13	to	to	TO
18637	8024	14	ratify	ratify	VB
18637	8024	15	and	and	CC
18637	8024	16	confirm	confirm	VB
18637	8024	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8024	18	acts	act	NNS
18637	8024	19	,	,	,
18637	8024	20	which	which	WDT
18637	8024	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8024	22	promptly	promptly	RB
18637	8024	23	did,[54	did,[54	NN
18637	8024	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8024	25	with	with	IN
18637	8024	26	the	the	DT
18637	8024	27	exception	exception	NN
18637	8024	28	of	of	IN
18637	8024	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8024	30	suspension	suspension	NN
18637	8024	31	of	of	IN
18637	8024	32	the	the	DT
18637	8024	33	_	_	NNP
18637	8024	34	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	8024	35	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	8024	36	_	_	NNP
18637	8024	37	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	8024	38	which	which	WDT
18637	8024	39	was	be	VBD
18637	8024	40	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	8024	41	by	by	IN
18637	8024	42	many	many	JJ
18637	8024	43	as	as	IN
18637	8024	44	attributable	attributable	JJ
18637	8024	45	to	to	IN
18637	8024	46	the	the	DT
18637	8024	47	President	President	NNP
18637	8024	48	in	in	IN
18637	8024	49	the	the	DT
18637	8024	50	situation	situation	NN
18637	8024	51	then	then	RB
18637	8024	52	existing	exist	VBG
18637	8024	53	,	,	,
18637	8024	54	by	by	IN
18637	8024	55	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	8024	56	of	of	IN
18637	8024	57	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8024	58	duty	duty	NN
18637	8024	59	to	to	TO
18637	8024	60	take	take	VB
18637	8024	61	care	care	NN
18637	8024	62	that	that	IN
18637	8024	63	the	the	DT
18637	8024	64	laws	law	NNS
18637	8024	65	be	be	VB
18637	8024	66	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8024	67	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8024	68	.	.	.
18637	8025	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8025	2	55	55	CD
18637	8025	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8025	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	8025	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	8025	6	this	this	DT
18637	8025	7	the	the	DT
18637	8025	8	only	only	JJ
18637	8025	9	respect	respect	NN
18637	8025	10	in	in	IN
18637	8025	11	which	which	WDT
18637	8025	12	war	war	NN
18637	8025	13	or	or	CC
18637	8025	14	the	the	DT
18637	8025	15	approach	approach	NN
18637	8025	16	of	of	IN
18637	8025	17	war	war	NN
18637	8025	18	operates	operate	VBZ
18637	8025	19	to	to	TO
18637	8025	20	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	8025	21	the	the	DT
18637	8025	22	scope	scope	NN
18637	8025	23	of	of	IN
18637	8025	24	power	power	NN
18637	8025	25	which	which	WDT
18637	8025	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	8025	27	claimable	claimable	JJ
18637	8025	28	by	by	IN
18637	8025	29	the	the	DT
18637	8025	30	President	President	NNP
18637	8025	31	as	as	IN
18637	8025	32	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8025	33	in	in	IN
18637	8025	34	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8025	35	in	in	IN
18637	8025	36	wartime	wartime	NN
18637	8025	37	.	.	.
18637	8026	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8026	2	56	56	CD
18637	8026	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8026	4	For	for	IN
18637	8026	5	at	at	IN
18637	8026	6	such	such	JJ
18637	8026	7	time	time	NN
18637	8026	8	the	the	DT
18637	8026	9	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	8026	10	that	that	IN
18637	8026	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8026	12	may	may	MD
18637	8026	13	not	not	RB
18637	8026	14	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	8026	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8026	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	8026	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	8026	18	,	,	,
18637	8026	19	by	by	IN
18637	8026	20	the	the	DT
18637	8026	21	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	8026	22	of	of	IN
18637	8026	23	the	the	DT
18637	8026	24	Curtiss	Curtiss	NNP
18637	8026	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	8026	26	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	8026	27	case,[57	case,[57	CD
18637	8026	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8026	29	in	in	IN
18637	8026	30	a	a	DT
18637	8026	31	state	state	NN
18637	8026	32	of	of	IN
18637	8026	33	suspended	suspend	VBN
18637	8026	34	animation	animation	NN
18637	8026	35	.	.	.
18637	8027	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8027	2	58	58	CD
18637	8027	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8027	4	PRESIDENTIAL	presidential	JJ
18637	8027	5	THEORY	THEORY	NNS
18637	8027	6	OF	of	IN
18637	8027	7	THE	the	DT
18637	8027	8	COMMANDER	COMMANDER	NNP
18637	8027	9	IN	in	IN
18637	8027	10	CHIEFSHIP	CHIEFSHIP	NNP
18637	8027	11	IN	in	IN
18637	8027	12	WORLD	WORLD	NNP
18637	8027	13	WAR	WAR	NNP
18637	8027	14	II	II	NNP
18637	8027	15	In	in	IN
18637	8027	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8027	17	message	message	NN
18637	8027	18	of	of	IN
18637	8027	19	September	September	NNP
18637	8027	20	7	7	CD
18637	8027	21	,	,	,
18637	8027	22	1942	1942	CD
18637	8027	23	to	to	IN
18637	8027	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8027	25	,	,	,
18637	8027	26	in	in	IN
18637	8027	27	which	which	WDT
18637	8027	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8027	29	demanded	demand	VBD
18637	8027	30	that	that	IN
18637	8027	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8027	32	forthwith	forthwith	VBP
18637	8027	33	repeal	repeal	JJ
18637	8027	34	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8027	35	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8027	36	of	of	IN
18637	8027	37	the	the	DT
18637	8027	38	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	8027	39	Price	Price	NNP
18637	8027	40	Control	Control	NNP
18637	8027	41	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8027	42	of	of	IN
18637	8027	43	the	the	DT
18637	8027	44	previous	previous	JJ
18637	8027	45	January	January	NNP
18637	8027	46	30th,[59	30th,[59	NNP
18637	8027	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8027	48	the	the	DT
18637	8027	49	late	late	JJ
18637	8027	50	President	President	NNP
18637	8027	51	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8027	52	formulated	formulate	VBD
18637	8027	53	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8027	54	conception	conception	NN
18637	8027	55	of	of	IN
18637	8027	56	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8027	57	powers	power	NNS
18637	8027	58	as	as	IN
18637	8027	59	"	"	``
18637	8027	60	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8027	61	in	in	IN
18637	8027	62	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8027	63	in	in	IN
18637	8027	64	wartime	wartime	NN
18637	8027	65	"	"	``
18637	8027	66	as	as	IN
18637	8027	67	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	8027	68	:	:	:
18637	8027	69	"	"	``
18637	8027	70	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8027	71	ask	ask	VBP
18637	8027	72	the	the	DT
18637	8027	73	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8027	74	to	to	TO
18637	8027	75	take	take	VB
18637	8027	76	this	this	DT
18637	8027	77	action	action	NN
18637	8027	78	by	by	IN
18637	8027	79	the	the	DT
18637	8027	80	first	first	JJ
18637	8027	81	of	of	IN
18637	8027	82	October	October	NNP
18637	8027	83	.	.	.
18637	8028	1	Inaction	inaction	NN
18637	8028	2	on	on	IN
18637	8028	3	your	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8028	4	part	part	NN
18637	8028	5	by	by	IN
18637	8028	6	that	that	DT
18637	8028	7	date	date	NN
18637	8028	8	will	will	MD
18637	8028	9	leave	leave	VB
18637	8028	10	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8028	11	with	with	IN
18637	8028	12	an	an	DT
18637	8028	13	inescapable	inescapable	JJ
18637	8028	14	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	8028	15	to	to	IN
18637	8028	16	the	the	DT
18637	8028	17	people	people	NNS
18637	8028	18	of	of	IN
18637	8028	19	this	this	DT
18637	8028	20	country	country	NN
18637	8028	21	to	to	TO
18637	8028	22	see	see	VB
18637	8028	23	to	to	IN
18637	8028	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8028	25	that	that	IN
18637	8028	26	the	the	DT
18637	8028	27	war	war	NN
18637	8028	28	effort	effort	NN
18637	8028	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	8028	30	no	no	RB
18637	8028	31	longer	long	RBR
18637	8028	32	imperiled	imperil	VBN
18637	8028	33	by	by	IN
18637	8028	34	threat	threat	NN
18637	8028	35	of	of	IN
18637	8028	36	economic	economic	JJ
18637	8028	37	chaos	chaos	NN
18637	8028	38	.	.	.
18637	8029	1	"	"	``
18637	8029	2	In	in	IN
18637	8029	3	the	the	DT
18637	8029	4	event	event	NN
18637	8029	5	that	that	WDT
18637	8029	6	the	the	DT
18637	8029	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8029	8	should	should	MD
18637	8029	9	fail	fail	VB
18637	8029	10	to	to	TO
18637	8029	11	act	act	VB
18637	8029	12	,	,	,
18637	8029	13	and	and	CC
18637	8029	14	act	act	VB
18637	8029	15	adequately	adequately	RB
18637	8029	16	,	,	,
18637	8029	17	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8029	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	8029	19	accept	accept	VB
18637	8029	20	the	the	DT
18637	8029	21	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	8029	22	,	,	,
18637	8029	23	and	and	CC
18637	8029	24	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8029	25	will	will	MD
18637	8029	26	act	act	VB
18637	8029	27	.	.	.
18637	8030	1	"	"	``
18637	8030	2	At	at	IN
18637	8030	3	the	the	DT
18637	8030	4	same	same	JJ
18637	8030	5	time	time	NN
18637	8030	6	that	that	IN
18637	8030	7	farm	farm	NN
18637	8030	8	prices	price	NNS
18637	8030	9	are	be	VBP
18637	8030	10	stabilized	stabilize	VBN
18637	8030	11	,	,	,
18637	8030	12	wages	wage	NNS
18637	8030	13	can	can	MD
18637	8030	14	and	and	CC
18637	8030	15	will	will	MD
18637	8030	16	be	be	VB
18637	8030	17	stabilized	stabilize	VBN
18637	8030	18	also	also	RB
18637	8030	19	.	.	.
18637	8031	1	This	this	DT
18637	8031	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8031	3	will	will	MD
18637	8031	4	do	do	VB
18637	8031	5	.	.	.
18637	8032	1	"	"	``
18637	8032	2	The	the	DT
18637	8032	3	President	President	NNP
18637	8032	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	8032	5	the	the	DT
18637	8032	6	powers	power	NNS
18637	8032	7	,	,	,
18637	8032	8	under	under	IN
18637	8032	9	the	the	DT
18637	8032	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8032	11	and	and	CC
18637	8032	12	under	under	IN
18637	8032	13	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	8032	14	acts	act	NNS
18637	8032	15	,	,	,
18637	8032	16	to	to	TO
18637	8032	17	take	take	VB
18637	8032	18	measures	measure	NNS
18637	8032	19	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8032	20	to	to	TO
18637	8032	21	avert	avert	VB
18637	8032	22	a	a	DT
18637	8032	23	disaster	disaster	NN
18637	8032	24	which	which	WDT
18637	8032	25	would	would	MD
18637	8032	26	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	8032	27	with	with	IN
18637	8032	28	the	the	DT
18637	8032	29	winning	winning	NN
18637	8032	30	of	of	IN
18637	8032	31	the	the	DT
18637	8032	32	war	war	NN
18637	8032	33	.	.	.
18637	8033	1	"	"	``
18637	8033	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8033	3	have	have	VBP
18637	8033	4	given	give	VBN
18637	8033	5	the	the	DT
18637	8033	6	most	most	RBS
18637	8033	7	thoughtful	thoughtful	JJ
18637	8033	8	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	8033	9	to	to	IN
18637	8033	10	meeting	meet	VBG
18637	8033	11	this	this	DT
18637	8033	12	issue	issue	NN
18637	8033	13	without	without	IN
18637	8033	14	further	further	JJ
18637	8033	15	reference	reference	NN
18637	8033	16	to	to	IN
18637	8033	17	the	the	DT
18637	8033	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8033	19	.	.	.
18637	8034	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8034	2	have	have	VBP
18637	8034	3	determined	determine	VBN
18637	8034	4	,	,	,
18637	8034	5	however	however	RB
18637	8034	6	,	,	,
18637	8034	7	on	on	IN
18637	8034	8	this	this	DT
18637	8034	9	vital	vital	JJ
18637	8034	10	matter	matter	NN
18637	8034	11	to	to	TO
18637	8034	12	consult	consult	VB
18637	8034	13	with	with	IN
18637	8034	14	the	the	DT
18637	8034	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8034	16	.	.	.
18637	8035	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8035	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8035	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8035	4	"	"	``
18637	8035	5	The	the	DT
18637	8035	6	American	american	JJ
18637	8035	7	people	people	NNS
18637	8035	8	can	can	MD
18637	8035	9	be	be	VB
18637	8035	10	sure	sure	JJ
18637	8035	11	that	that	IN
18637	8035	12	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8035	13	will	will	MD
18637	8035	14	use	use	VB
18637	8035	15	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8035	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	8035	17	with	with	IN
18637	8035	18	a	a	DT
18637	8035	19	full	full	JJ
18637	8035	20	sense	sense	NN
18637	8035	21	of	of	IN
18637	8035	22	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8035	23	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	8035	24	to	to	IN
18637	8035	25	the	the	DT
18637	8035	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8035	27	and	and	CC
18637	8035	28	to	to	IN
18637	8035	29	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8035	30	country	country	NN
18637	8035	31	.	.	.
18637	8036	1	The	the	DT
18637	8036	2	American	american	JJ
18637	8036	3	people	people	NNS
18637	8036	4	can	can	MD
18637	8036	5	also	also	RB
18637	8036	6	be	be	VB
18637	8036	7	sure	sure	JJ
18637	8036	8	that	that	IN
18637	8036	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8036	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	8036	11	not	not	RB
18637	8036	12	hesitate	hesitate	VB
18637	8036	13	to	to	TO
18637	8036	14	use	use	VB
18637	8036	15	every	every	DT
18637	8036	16	power	power	NN
18637	8036	17	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8036	18	in	in	IN
18637	8036	19	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8036	20	to	to	TO
18637	8036	21	accomplish	accomplish	VB
18637	8036	22	the	the	DT
18637	8036	23	defeat	defeat	NN
18637	8036	24	of	of	IN
18637	8036	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8036	26	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	8036	27	in	in	IN
18637	8036	28	any	any	DT
18637	8036	29	part	part	NN
18637	8036	30	of	of	IN
18637	8036	31	the	the	DT
18637	8036	32	world	world	NN
18637	8036	33	where	where	WRB
18637	8036	34	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8036	35	own	own	JJ
18637	8036	36	safety	safety	NN
18637	8036	37	demands	demand	VBZ
18637	8036	38	such	such	JJ
18637	8036	39	defeat	defeat	NN
18637	8036	40	.	.	.
18637	8037	1	"	"	``
18637	8037	2	When	when	WRB
18637	8037	3	the	the	DT
18637	8037	4	war	war	NN
18637	8037	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	8037	6	won	win	VBN
18637	8037	7	,	,	,
18637	8037	8	the	the	DT
18637	8037	9	powers	power	NNS
18637	8037	10	under	under	IN
18637	8037	11	which	which	WDT
18637	8037	12	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8037	13	act	act	VBP
18637	8037	14	automatically	automatically	RB
18637	8037	15	revert	revert	VBP
18637	8037	16	to	to	IN
18637	8037	17	the	the	DT
18637	8037	18	people	people	NNS
18637	8037	19	--	--	:
18637	8037	20	to	to	TO
18637	8037	21	whom	whom	WP
18637	8037	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8037	23	belong	belong	VBP
18637	8037	24	.	.	.
18637	8038	1	"	"	``
18637	8038	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8038	3	60	60	CD
18637	8038	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8038	5	PRESIDENTIAL	PRESIDENTIAL	NNP
18637	8038	6	WAR	WAR	NNP
18637	8038	7	AGENCIES	agency	NNS
18637	8038	8	While	while	IN
18637	8038	9	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	8038	10	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	8038	11	with	with	IN
18637	8038	12	the	the	DT
18637	8038	13	President	President	NNP
18637	8038	14	's	's	POS
18637	8038	15	demand	demand	NN
18637	8038	16	rendered	render	VBD
18637	8038	17	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	8038	18	an	an	DT
18637	8038	19	effort	effort	NN
18637	8038	20	on	on	IN
18637	8038	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8038	22	part	part	NN
18637	8038	23	to	to	TO
18637	8038	24	amend	amend	VB
18637	8038	25	the	the	DT
18637	8038	26	Price	Price	NNP
18637	8038	27	Control	Control	NNP
18637	8038	28	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8038	29	,	,	,
18637	8038	30	there	there	EX
18637	8038	31	were	be	VBD
18637	8038	32	other	other	JJ
18637	8038	33	matters	matter	NNS
18637	8038	34	as	as	IN
18637	8038	35	to	to	TO
18637	8038	36	which	which	WDT
18637	8038	37	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8038	38	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	8038	39	took	take	VBD
18637	8038	40	action	action	NN
18637	8038	41	within	within	IN
18637	8038	42	the	the	DT
18637	8038	43	normal	normal	JJ
18637	8038	44	field	field	NN
18637	8038	45	of	of	IN
18637	8038	46	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	8038	47	powers	power	NNS
18637	8038	48	,	,	,
18637	8038	49	not	not	RB
18637	8038	50	only	only	RB
18637	8038	51	during	during	IN
18637	8038	52	the	the	DT
18637	8038	53	war	war	NN
18637	8038	54	,	,	,
18637	8038	55	but	but	CC
18637	8038	56	in	in	IN
18637	8038	57	some	some	DT
18637	8038	58	instances	instance	NNS
18637	8038	59	prior	prior	RB
18637	8038	60	to	to	IN
18637	8038	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8038	62	.	.	.
18637	8039	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	8039	2	in	in	IN
18637	8039	3	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	8039	4	both	both	CC
18637	8039	5	the	the	DT
18637	8039	6	powers	power	NNS
18637	8039	7	which	which	WDT
18637	8039	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8039	9	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	8039	10	as	as	IN
18637	8039	11	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8039	12	in	in	IN
18637	8039	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8039	14	and	and	CC
18637	8039	15	those	those	DT
18637	8039	16	which	which	WDT
18637	8039	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8039	18	conferred	confer	VBD
18637	8039	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	8039	20	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8039	21	to	to	TO
18637	8039	22	meet	meet	VB
18637	8039	23	the	the	DT
18637	8039	24	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	8039	25	,	,	,
18637	8039	26	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	8039	27	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8039	28	employed	employ	VBD
18637	8039	29	new	new	JJ
18637	8039	30	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	8039	31	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	8039	32	,	,	,
18637	8039	33	created	create	VBN
18637	8039	34	by	by	IN
18637	8039	35	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8039	36	and	and	CC
18637	8039	37	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	8039	38	directly	directly	RB
18637	8039	39	to	to	IN
18637	8039	40	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8039	41	,	,	,
18637	8039	42	rather	rather	RB
18637	8039	43	than	than	IN
18637	8039	44	the	the	DT
18637	8039	45	established	establish	VBN
18637	8039	46	departments	department	NNS
18637	8039	47	or	or	CC
18637	8039	48	existing	exist	VBG
18637	8039	49	independent	independent	JJ
18637	8039	50	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	8039	51	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	8039	52	.	.	.
18637	8040	1	Oldest	old	JJS
18637	8040	2	of	of	IN
18637	8040	3	all	all	PDT
18637	8040	4	these	these	DT
18637	8040	5	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8040	6	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	8040	7	was	be	VBD
18637	8040	8	the	the	DT
18637	8040	9	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8040	10	for	for	IN
18637	8040	11	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	8040	12	Management	Management	NNP
18637	8040	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8040	14	OEM	OEM	NNP
18637	8040	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8040	16	,	,	,
18637	8040	17	which	which	WDT
18637	8040	18	was	be	VBD
18637	8040	19	created	create	VBN
18637	8040	20	by	by	IN
18637	8040	21	an	an	DT
18637	8040	22	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8040	23	order	order	NN
18637	8040	24	dated	date	VBN
18637	8040	25	May	May	NNP
18637	8040	26	25	25	CD
18637	8040	27	,	,	,
18637	8040	28	1940	1940	CD
18637	8040	29	.	.	.
18637	8041	1	Others	other	NNS
18637	8041	2	were	be	VBD
18637	8041	3	the	the	DT
18637	8041	4	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8041	5	of	of	IN
18637	8041	6	Economic	Economic	NNP
18637	8041	7	Warfare	Warfare	NNP
18637	8041	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8041	9	BEW	BEW	NNP
18637	8041	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8041	11	,	,	,
18637	8041	12	the	the	DT
18637	8041	13	National	National	NNP
18637	8041	14	Housing	Housing	NNP
18637	8041	15	Agency	Agency	NNP
18637	8041	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8041	17	NHA	NHA	NNP
18637	8041	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8041	19	,	,	,
18637	8041	20	the	the	DT
18637	8041	21	National	National	NNP
18637	8041	22	War	War	NNP
18637	8041	23	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8041	24	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8041	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8041	26	NWLB	NWLB	NNP
18637	8041	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8041	28	,	,	,
18637	8041	29	or	or	CC
18637	8041	30	more	more	RBR
18637	8041	31	shortly	shortly	RB
18637	8041	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8041	33	WLB	WLB	NNP
18637	8041	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8041	35	,	,	,
18637	8041	36	the	the	DT
18637	8041	37	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8041	38	of	of	IN
18637	8041	39	Censorship	Censorship	NNP
18637	8041	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8041	41	OC	OC	NNP
18637	8041	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8041	43	,	,	,
18637	8041	44	the	the	DT
18637	8041	45	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8041	46	of	of	IN
18637	8041	47	Civilian	Civilian	NNP
18637	8041	48	Defense	Defense	NNP
18637	8041	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8041	50	OCD	OCD	NNP
18637	8041	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8041	52	,	,	,
18637	8041	53	the	the	DT
18637	8041	54	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8041	55	of	of	IN
18637	8041	56	Defense	Defense	NNP
18637	8041	57	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	8041	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8041	59	ODT	ODT	NNP
18637	8041	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8041	61	,	,	,
18637	8041	62	the	the	DT
18637	8041	63	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8041	64	of	of	IN
18637	8041	65	Facts	Facts	NNPS
18637	8041	66	and	and	CC
18637	8041	67	Figures	Figures	NNPS
18637	8041	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8041	69	OFF	OFF	NNP
18637	8041	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8041	71	,	,	,
18637	8041	72	presently	presently	RB
18637	8041	73	absorbed	absorb	VBN
18637	8041	74	into	into	IN
18637	8041	75	the	the	DT
18637	8041	76	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8041	77	of	of	IN
18637	8041	78	War	War	NNP
18637	8041	79	Information	Information	NNP
18637	8041	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8041	81	OWI	OWI	NNP
18637	8041	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8041	83	,	,	,
18637	8041	84	the	the	DT
18637	8041	85	War	War	NNP
18637	8041	86	Production	Production	NNP
18637	8041	87	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8041	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8041	89	WPB	WPB	NNP
18637	8041	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8041	91	,	,	,
18637	8041	92	which	which	WDT
18637	8041	93	superseded	supersede	VBD
18637	8041	94	the	the	DT
18637	8041	95	earlier	early	JJR
18637	8041	96	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8041	97	of	of	IN
18637	8041	98	Production	Production	NNP
18637	8041	99	Management	Management	NNP
18637	8041	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8041	101	OPM	OPM	NNP
18637	8041	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8041	103	,	,	,
18637	8041	104	the	the	DT
18637	8041	105	War	War	NNP
18637	8041	106	Manpower	Manpower	NNP
18637	8041	107	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	8041	108	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8041	109	WMC	WMC	NNP
18637	8041	110	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8041	111	,	,	,
18637	8041	112	etc	etc	FW
18637	8041	113	.	.	.
18637	8042	1	Earlier	early	RBR
18637	8042	2	there	there	EX
18637	8042	3	had	have	VBD
18637	8042	4	been	be	VBN
18637	8042	5	the	the	DT
18637	8042	6	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8042	7	of	of	IN
18637	8042	8	Price	Price	NNP
18637	8042	9	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	8042	10	and	and	CC
18637	8042	11	Civilian	Civilian	NNP
18637	8042	12	Supply	Supply	NNP
18637	8042	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8042	14	OPACS	OPACS	NNP
18637	8042	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8042	16	,	,	,
18637	8042	17	but	but	CC
18637	8042	18	was	be	VBD
18637	8042	19	replaced	replace	VBN
18637	8042	20	under	under	IN
18637	8042	21	the	the	DT
18637	8042	22	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	8042	23	Price	Price	NNP
18637	8042	24	Control	Control	NNP
18637	8042	25	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8042	26	of	of	IN
18637	8042	27	January	January	NNP
18637	8042	28	30	30	CD
18637	8042	29	,	,	,
18637	8042	30	1942	1942	CD
18637	8042	31	,	,	,
18637	8042	32	by	by	IN
18637	8042	33	OPA	OPA	NNP
18637	8042	34	.	.	.
18637	8043	1	Later	later	JJ
18637	8043	2	OWI	OWI	NNP
18637	8043	3	was	be	VBD
18637	8043	4	created	create	VBN
18637	8043	5	by	by	IN
18637	8043	6	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8043	7	order	order	NN
18637	8043	8	,	,	,
18637	8043	9	as	as	IN
18637	8043	10	was	be	VBD
18637	8043	11	also	also	RB
18637	8043	12	the	the	DT
18637	8043	13	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8043	14	of	of	IN
18637	8043	15	Economic	Economic	NNP
18637	8043	16	Stabilization	Stabilization	NNP
18637	8043	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8043	18	OES	OES	NNP
18637	8043	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8043	20	.	.	.
18637	8044	1	The	the	DT
18637	8044	2	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8044	3	of	of	IN
18637	8044	4	War	War	NNP
18637	8044	5	Mobilization	Mobilization	NNP
18637	8044	6	and	and	CC
18637	8044	7	Reconversion	Reconversion	NNP
18637	8044	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8044	9	OWMR	OWMR	NNP
18637	8044	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8044	11	,	,	,
18637	8044	12	one	one	CD
18637	8044	13	of	of	IN
18637	8044	14	the	the	DT
18637	8044	15	last	last	JJ
18637	8044	16	of	of	IN
18637	8044	17	the	the	DT
18637	8044	18	war	war	NN
18637	8044	19	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	8044	20	to	to	TO
18637	8044	21	appear	appear	VB
18637	8044	22	,	,	,
18637	8044	23	was	be	VBD
18637	8044	24	established	establish	VBN
18637	8044	25	by	by	IN
18637	8044	26	the	the	DT
18637	8044	27	War	War	NNP
18637	8044	28	Mobilization	Mobilization	NNP
18637	8044	29	and	and	CC
18637	8044	30	Reconversion	Reconversion	NNP
18637	8044	31	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8044	32	of	of	IN
18637	8044	33	October	October	NNP
18637	8044	34	3	3	CD
18637	8044	35	,	,	,
18637	8044	36	1944	1944	CD
18637	8044	37	.	.	.
18637	8045	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8045	2	61	61	CD
18637	8045	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8045	4	CONSTITUTIONAL	constitutional	JJ
18637	8045	5	STATUS	status	NN
18637	8045	6	OF	of	IN
18637	8045	7	PRESIDENTIAL	PRESIDENTIAL	NNP
18637	8045	8	AGENCIES	agency	NNS
18637	8045	9	The	the	DT
18637	8045	10	question	question	NN
18637	8045	11	of	of	IN
18637	8045	12	the	the	DT
18637	8045	13	legal	legal	JJ
18637	8045	14	status	status	NN
18637	8045	15	of	of	IN
18637	8045	16	the	the	DT
18637	8045	17	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8045	18	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	8045	19	was	be	VBD
18637	8045	20	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	8045	21	with	with	IN
18637	8045	22	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	8045	23	but	but	CC
18637	8045	24	once	once	RB
18637	8045	25	.	.	.
18637	8046	1	This	this	DT
18637	8046	2	was	be	VBD
18637	8046	3	in	in	IN
18637	8046	4	the	the	DT
18637	8046	5	decision	decision	NN
18637	8046	6	,	,	,
18637	8046	7	in	in	IN
18637	8046	8	June	June	NNP
18637	8046	9	1944	1944	CD
18637	8046	10	,	,	,
18637	8046	11	of	of	IN
18637	8046	12	the	the	DT
18637	8046	13	United	United	NNP
18637	8046	14	States	States	NNP
18637	8046	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8046	16	of	of	IN
18637	8046	17	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	8046	18	of	of	IN
18637	8046	19	the	the	DT
18637	8046	20	District	District	NNP
18637	8046	21	of	of	IN
18637	8046	22	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	8046	23	in	in	IN
18637	8046	24	a	a	DT
18637	8046	25	case	case	NN
18637	8046	26	styled	style	VBN
18637	8046	27	Employers	Employers	NNP
18637	8046	28	Group	Group	NNP
18637	8046	29	of	of	IN
18637	8046	30	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	8046	31	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	8046	32	Carriers	Carriers	NNPS
18637	8046	33	_	_	NNP
18637	8046	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	8046	35	_	_	NNP
18637	8046	36	National	National	NNP
18637	8046	37	War	War	NNP
18637	8046	38	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8046	39	Board,[62	Board,[62	NNP
18637	8046	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8046	41	which	which	WDT
18637	8046	42	was	be	VBD
18637	8046	43	a	a	DT
18637	8046	44	suit	suit	NN
18637	8046	45	to	to	IN
18637	8046	46	annul	annul	VB
18637	8046	47	and	and	CC
18637	8046	48	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	8046	49	a	a	DT
18637	8046	50	"	"	``
18637	8046	51	directive	directive	JJ
18637	8046	52	order	order	NN
18637	8046	53	"	"	''
18637	8046	54	of	of	IN
18637	8046	55	the	the	DT
18637	8046	56	War	War	NNP
18637	8046	57	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8046	58	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8046	59	.	.	.
18637	8047	1	The	the	DT
18637	8047	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8047	3	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	8047	4	the	the	DT
18637	8047	5	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	8047	6	on	on	IN
18637	8047	7	the	the	DT
18637	8047	8	ground	ground	NN
18637	8047	9	that	that	IN
18637	8047	10	at	at	IN
18637	8047	11	the	the	DT
18637	8047	12	time	time	NN
18637	8047	13	when	when	WRB
18637	8047	14	the	the	DT
18637	8047	15	directive	directive	NN
18637	8047	16	was	be	VBD
18637	8047	17	issued	issue	VBN
18637	8047	18	any	any	DT
18637	8047	19	action	action	NN
18637	8047	20	of	of	IN
18637	8047	21	the	the	DT
18637	8047	22	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8047	23	was	be	VBD
18637	8047	24	"	"	``
18637	8047	25	informatory	informatory	JJ
18637	8047	26	,	,	,
18637	8047	27	"	"	''
18637	8047	28	"	"	``
18637	8047	29	at	at	IN
18637	8047	30	most	most	JJS
18637	8047	31	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	8047	32	.	.	.
18637	8047	33	"	"	''
18637	8048	1	In	in	IN
18637	8048	2	support	support	NN
18637	8048	3	of	of	IN
18637	8048	4	this	this	DT
18637	8048	5	view	view	NN
18637	8048	6	the	the	DT
18637	8048	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8048	8	quoted	quote	VBD
18637	8048	9	approvingly	approvingly	RB
18637	8048	10	a	a	DT
18637	8048	11	statement	statement	NN
18637	8048	12	by	by	IN
18637	8048	13	the	the	DT
18637	8048	14	chairman	chairman	NN
18637	8048	15	of	of	IN
18637	8048	16	the	the	DT
18637	8048	17	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8048	18	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8048	19	:	:	:
18637	8048	20	"	"	``
18637	8048	21	These	these	DT
18637	8048	22	orders	order	NNS
18637	8048	23	are	be	VBP
18637	8048	24	in	in	IN
18637	8048	25	reality	reality	NN
18637	8048	26	mere	mere	JJ
18637	8048	27	declarations	declaration	NNS
18637	8048	28	of	of	IN
18637	8048	29	the	the	DT
18637	8048	30	equities	equity	NNS
18637	8048	31	of	of	IN
18637	8048	32	each	each	DT
18637	8048	33	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	8048	34	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	8048	35	,	,	,
18637	8048	36	as	as	IN
18637	8048	37	determined	determine	VBN
18637	8048	38	by	by	IN
18637	8048	39	a	a	DT
18637	8048	40	tripartite	tripartite	JJ
18637	8048	41	body	body	NN
18637	8048	42	in	in	IN
18637	8048	43	which	which	WDT
18637	8048	44	industry	industry	NN
18637	8048	45	,	,	,
18637	8048	46	labor	labor	NN
18637	8048	47	,	,	,
18637	8048	48	and	and	CC
18637	8048	49	the	the	DT
18637	8048	50	public	public	JJ
18637	8048	51	share	share	NN
18637	8048	52	equal	equal	JJ
18637	8048	53	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	8048	54	;	;	:
18637	8048	55	and	and	CC
18637	8048	56	the	the	DT
18637	8048	57	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	8048	58	of	of	IN
18637	8048	59	the	the	DT
18637	8048	60	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8048	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	8048	62	to	to	IN
18637	8048	63	the	the	DT
18637	8048	64	moral	moral	JJ
18637	8048	65	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8048	66	of	of	IN
18637	8048	67	employers	employer	NNS
18637	8048	68	and	and	CC
18637	8048	69	workers	worker	NNS
18637	8048	70	to	to	TO
18637	8048	71	abide	abide	VB
18637	8048	72	by	by	IN
18637	8048	73	the	the	DT
18637	8048	74	nonstrike	nonstrike	JJ
18637	8048	75	,	,	,
18637	8048	76	no	no	DT
18637	8048	77	-	-	HYPH
18637	8048	78	lock	lock	NN
18637	8048	79	-	-	HYPH
18637	8048	80	out	out	NN
18637	8048	81	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8048	82	and	and	CC
18637	8048	83	*	*	NFP
18637	8048	84	*	*	NFP
18637	8048	85	*	*	NFP
18637	8048	86	to	to	TO
18637	8048	87	carry	carry	VB
18637	8048	88	out	out	RP
18637	8048	89	the	the	DT
18637	8048	90	directives	directive	NNS
18637	8048	91	of	of	IN
18637	8048	92	the	the	DT
18637	8048	93	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	8048	94	created	create	VBN
18637	8048	95	under	under	IN
18637	8048	96	that	that	DT
18637	8048	97	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8048	98	by	by	IN
18637	8048	99	the	the	DT
18637	8048	100	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8048	101	in	in	IN
18637	8048	102	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8048	103	.	.	.
18637	8048	104	"	"	''
18637	8049	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	8049	2	,	,	,
18637	8049	3	the	the	DT
18637	8049	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8049	5	continued	continue	VBD
18637	8049	6	,	,	,
18637	8049	7	had	have	VBD
18637	8049	8	the	the	DT
18637	8049	9	later	later	JJ
18637	8049	10	War	War	NNP
18637	8049	11	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8049	12	Disputes	Disputes	NNPS
18637	8049	13	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8049	14	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8049	15	War	War	NNP
18637	8049	16	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8049	17	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8049	18	's	's	POS
18637	8049	19	orders	order	NNS
18637	8049	20	with	with	IN
18637	8049	21	any	any	DT
18637	8049	22	greater	great	JJR
18637	8049	23	authority	authority	NN
18637	8049	24	,	,	,
18637	8049	25	with	with	IN
18637	8049	26	the	the	DT
18637	8049	27	result	result	NN
18637	8049	28	that	that	IN
18637	8049	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8049	30	were	be	VBD
18637	8049	31	still	still	RB
18637	8049	32	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	8049	33	unenforceable	unenforceable	JJ
18637	8049	34	and	and	CC
18637	8049	35	unreviewable	unreviewable	JJ
18637	8049	36	.	.	.
18637	8050	1	Following	follow	VBG
18637	8050	2	this	this	DT
18637	8050	3	theory	theory	NN
18637	8050	4	,	,	,
18637	8050	5	War	War	NNP
18637	8050	6	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8050	7	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8050	8	was	be	VBD
18637	8050	9	not	not	RB
18637	8050	10	an	an	DT
18637	8050	11	office	office	NN
18637	8050	12	wielding	wield	VBG
18637	8050	13	power	power	NN
18637	8050	14	,	,	,
18637	8050	15	but	but	CC
18637	8050	16	a	a	DT
18637	8050	17	purely	purely	RB
18637	8050	18	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	8050	19	body	body	NN
18637	8050	20	,	,	,
18637	8050	21	such	such	JJ
18637	8050	22	as	as	IN
18637	8050	23	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	8050	24	have	have	VBP
18637	8050	25	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	8050	26	created	create	VBN
18637	8050	27	in	in	IN
18637	8050	28	the	the	DT
18637	8050	29	past	past	NN
18637	8050	30	without	without	IN
18637	8050	31	the	the	DT
18637	8050	32	aid	aid	NN
18637	8050	33	or	or	CC
18637	8050	34	consent	consent	NN
18637	8050	35	of	of	IN
18637	8050	36	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8050	37	.	.	.
18637	8051	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8051	2	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8051	3	,	,	,
18637	8051	4	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	8051	5	,	,	,
18637	8051	6	both	both	DT
18637	8051	7	in	in	IN
18637	8051	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8051	9	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	8051	10	acts	act	NNS
18637	8051	11	and	and	CC
18637	8051	12	in	in	IN
18637	8051	13	other	other	JJ
18637	8051	14	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8051	15	,	,	,
18637	8051	16	treated	treat	VBD
18637	8051	17	the	the	DT
18637	8051	18	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8051	19	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	8051	20	as	as	IN
18637	8051	21	in	in	IN
18637	8051	22	all	all	DT
18637	8051	23	respects	respect	NNS
18637	8051	24	offices	office	NNS
18637	8051	25	.	.	.
18637	8052	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8052	2	63	63	CD
18637	8052	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8052	4	THE	the	DT
18637	8052	5	WEST	west	NN
18637	8052	6	COAST	coast	NN
18637	8052	7	JAPANESE	JAPANESE	NNPS
18637	8052	8	On	on	IN
18637	8052	9	February	February	NNP
18637	8052	10	19	19	CD
18637	8052	11	,	,	,
18637	8052	12	1942	1942	CD
18637	8052	13	the	the	DT
18637	8052	14	President	President	NNP
18637	8052	15	issued	issue	VBD
18637	8052	16	an	an	DT
18637	8052	17	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8052	18	order	order	NN
18637	8052	19	the	the	DT
18637	8052	20	essential	essential	JJ
18637	8052	21	paragraphs	paragraph	NNS
18637	8052	22	of	of	IN
18637	8052	23	which	which	WDT
18637	8052	24	read	read	VBP
18637	8052	25	as	as	IN
18637	8052	26	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	8052	27	:	:	:
18637	8052	28	"	"	``
18637	8052	29	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	8052	30	the	the	DT
18637	8052	31	successful	successful	JJ
18637	8052	32	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	8052	33	of	of	IN
18637	8052	34	the	the	DT
18637	8052	35	war	war	NN
18637	8052	36	requires	require	VBZ
18637	8052	37	every	every	DT
18637	8052	38	possible	possible	JJ
18637	8052	39	protection	protection	NN
18637	8052	40	against	against	IN
18637	8052	41	espionage	espionage	NN
18637	8052	42	and	and	CC
18637	8052	43	against	against	IN
18637	8052	44	sabotage	sabotage	NN
18637	8052	45	to	to	IN
18637	8052	46	national	national	JJ
18637	8052	47	-	-	HYPH
18637	8052	48	defense	defense	NN
18637	8052	49	material	material	NN
18637	8052	50	,	,	,
18637	8052	51	national	national	JJ
18637	8052	52	-	-	HYPH
18637	8052	53	defense	defense	NN
18637	8052	54	premises	premise	NNS
18637	8052	55	,	,	,
18637	8052	56	and	and	CC
18637	8052	57	national	national	JJ
18637	8052	58	-	-	HYPH
18637	8052	59	defense	defense	NN
18637	8052	60	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	8052	61	*	*	NFP
18637	8052	62	*	*	NFP
18637	8052	63	*	*	NFP
18637	8052	64	"	"	''
18637	8052	65	Now	now	RB
18637	8052	66	,	,	,
18637	8052	67	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8052	68	,	,	,
18637	8052	69	by	by	IN
18637	8052	70	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	8052	71	of	of	IN
18637	8052	72	the	the	DT
18637	8052	73	authority	authority	NN
18637	8052	74	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8052	75	in	in	IN
18637	8052	76	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8052	77	as	as	IN
18637	8052	78	President	President	NNP
18637	8052	79	of	of	IN
18637	8052	80	the	the	DT
18637	8052	81	United	United	NNP
18637	8052	82	States	States	NNP
18637	8052	83	,	,	,
18637	8052	84	and	and	CC
18637	8052	85	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8052	86	in	in	IN
18637	8052	87	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8052	88	of	of	IN
18637	8052	89	the	the	DT
18637	8052	90	Army	Army	NNP
18637	8052	91	and	and	CC
18637	8052	92	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	8052	93	,	,	,
18637	8052	94	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8052	95	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	8052	96	authorize	authorize	VBP
18637	8052	97	and	and	CC
18637	8052	98	direct	direct	VB
18637	8052	99	the	the	DT
18637	8052	100	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8052	101	of	of	IN
18637	8052	102	War	War	NNP
18637	8052	103	,	,	,
18637	8052	104	and	and	CC
18637	8052	105	the	the	DT
18637	8052	106	Military	Military	NNP
18637	8052	107	Commanders	Commanders	NNPS
18637	8052	108	whom	whom	WP
18637	8052	109	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8052	110	may	may	MD
18637	8052	111	from	from	IN
18637	8052	112	time	time	NN
18637	8052	113	to	to	IN
18637	8052	114	time	time	NN
18637	8052	115	designate	designate	VB
18637	8052	116	,	,	,
18637	8052	117	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	8052	118	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8052	119	or	or	CC
18637	8052	120	any	any	DT
18637	8052	121	designated	designate	VBN
18637	8052	122	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8052	123	deems	deem	NNS
18637	8052	124	such	such	JJ
18637	8052	125	action	action	NN
18637	8052	126	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8052	127	or	or	CC
18637	8052	128	desirable	desirable	JJ
18637	8052	129	,	,	,
18637	8052	130	to	to	TO
18637	8052	131	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	8052	132	military	military	JJ
18637	8052	133	areas	area	NNS
18637	8052	134	in	in	IN
18637	8052	135	such	such	JJ
18637	8052	136	places	place	NNS
18637	8052	137	and	and	CC
18637	8052	138	of	of	IN
18637	8052	139	such	such	JJ
18637	8052	140	extent	extent	NN
18637	8052	141	as	as	IN
18637	8052	142	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8052	143	or	or	CC
18637	8052	144	the	the	DT
18637	8052	145	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	8052	146	Military	Military	NNP
18637	8052	147	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8052	148	may	may	MD
18637	8052	149	determine	determine	VB
18637	8052	150	,	,	,
18637	8052	151	from	from	IN
18637	8052	152	which	which	WDT
18637	8052	153	any	any	DT
18637	8052	154	or	or	CC
18637	8052	155	all	all	DT
18637	8052	156	persons	person	NNS
18637	8052	157	may	may	MD
18637	8052	158	be	be	VB
18637	8052	159	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	8052	160	,	,	,
18637	8052	161	and	and	CC
18637	8052	162	with	with	IN
18637	8052	163	respect	respect	NN
18637	8052	164	to	to	IN
18637	8052	165	which	which	WDT
18637	8052	166	,	,	,
18637	8052	167	the	the	DT
18637	8052	168	right	right	NN
18637	8052	169	of	of	IN
18637	8052	170	any	any	DT
18637	8052	171	person	person	NN
18637	8052	172	to	to	TO
18637	8052	173	enter	enter	VB
18637	8052	174	,	,	,
18637	8052	175	remain	remain	VBP
18637	8052	176	in	in	IN
18637	8052	177	,	,	,
18637	8052	178	or	or	CC
18637	8052	179	leave	leave	VB
18637	8052	180	shall	shall	MD
18637	8052	181	be	be	VB
18637	8052	182	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8052	183	to	to	IN
18637	8052	184	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	8052	185	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	8052	186	the	the	DT
18637	8052	187	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8052	188	of	of	IN
18637	8052	189	War	War	NNP
18637	8052	190	or	or	CC
18637	8052	191	the	the	DT
18637	8052	192	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	8052	193	Military	Military	NNP
18637	8052	194	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8052	195	may	may	MD
18637	8052	196	impose	impose	VB
18637	8052	197	in	in	IN
18637	8052	198	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8052	199	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	8052	200	.	.	.
18637	8053	1	The	the	DT
18637	8053	2	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8053	3	of	of	IN
18637	8053	4	War	War	NNP
18637	8053	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	8053	6	hereby	hereby	NNP
18637	8053	7	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8053	8	to	to	TO
18637	8053	9	provide	provide	VB
18637	8053	10	for	for	IN
18637	8053	11	residents	resident	NNS
18637	8053	12	of	of	IN
18637	8053	13	any	any	DT
18637	8053	14	such	such	JJ
18637	8053	15	area	area	NN
18637	8053	16	who	who	WP
18637	8053	17	are	be	VBP
18637	8053	18	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	8053	19	therefrom	therefrom	JJ
18637	8053	20	,	,	,
18637	8053	21	such	such	JJ
18637	8053	22	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	8053	23	,	,	,
18637	8053	24	food	food	NN
18637	8053	25	,	,	,
18637	8053	26	shelter	shelter	NN
18637	8053	27	,	,	,
18637	8053	28	and	and	CC
18637	8053	29	other	other	JJ
18637	8053	30	accommodations	accommodation	NNS
18637	8053	31	as	as	IN
18637	8053	32	may	may	MD
18637	8053	33	be	be	VB
18637	8053	34	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8053	35	,	,	,
18637	8053	36	in	in	IN
18637	8053	37	the	the	DT
18637	8053	38	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8053	39	of	of	IN
18637	8053	40	the	the	DT
18637	8053	41	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8053	42	of	of	IN
18637	8053	43	War	War	NNP
18637	8053	44	or	or	CC
18637	8053	45	the	the	DT
18637	8053	46	said	say	VBN
18637	8053	47	Military	Military	NNP
18637	8053	48	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8053	49	,	,	,
18637	8053	50	and	and	CC
18637	8053	51	until	until	IN
18637	8053	52	other	other	JJ
18637	8053	53	arrangements	arrangement	NNS
18637	8053	54	are	be	VBP
18637	8053	55	made	make	VBN
18637	8053	56	,	,	,
18637	8053	57	to	to	TO
18637	8053	58	accomplish	accomplish	VB
18637	8053	59	the	the	DT
18637	8053	60	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8053	61	of	of	IN
18637	8053	62	this	this	DT
18637	8053	63	order	order	NN
18637	8053	64	.	.	.
18637	8054	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8054	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8054	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8054	4	"	"	``
18637	8054	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8054	6	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	8054	7	further	further	RB
18637	8054	8	authorize	authorize	VBP
18637	8054	9	and	and	CC
18637	8054	10	direct	direct	VB
18637	8054	11	all	all	DT
18637	8054	12	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8054	13	Departments	Departments	NNPS
18637	8054	14	,	,	,
18637	8054	15	independent	independent	JJ
18637	8054	16	establishments	establishment	NNS
18637	8054	17	and	and	CC
18637	8054	18	other	other	JJ
18637	8054	19	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8054	20	Agencies	Agencies	NNPS
18637	8054	21	,	,	,
18637	8054	22	to	to	TO
18637	8054	23	assist	assist	VB
18637	8054	24	the	the	DT
18637	8054	25	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8054	26	of	of	IN
18637	8054	27	War	War	NNP
18637	8054	28	or	or	CC
18637	8054	29	the	the	DT
18637	8054	30	said	say	VBN
18637	8054	31	Military	Military	NNP
18637	8054	32	Commanders	Commanders	NNPS
18637	8054	33	in	in	IN
18637	8054	34	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	8054	35	out	out	RP
18637	8054	36	this	this	DT
18637	8054	37	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8054	38	Order	order	NN
18637	8054	39	,	,	,
18637	8054	40	including	include	VBG
18637	8054	41	the	the	DT
18637	8054	42	furnishing	furnishing	NN
18637	8054	43	of	of	IN
18637	8054	44	medical	medical	JJ
18637	8054	45	aid	aid	NN
18637	8054	46	,	,	,
18637	8054	47	hospitalization	hospitalization	NN
18637	8054	48	,	,	,
18637	8054	49	food	food	NN
18637	8054	50	,	,	,
18637	8054	51	clothing	clothing	NN
18637	8054	52	,	,	,
18637	8054	53	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	8054	54	,	,	,
18637	8054	55	use	use	NN
18637	8054	56	of	of	IN
18637	8054	57	land	land	NN
18637	8054	58	,	,	,
18637	8054	59	shelter	shelter	NN
18637	8054	60	,	,	,
18637	8054	61	and	and	CC
18637	8054	62	other	other	JJ
18637	8054	63	supplies	supply	NNS
18637	8054	64	,	,	,
18637	8054	65	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	8054	66	,	,	,
18637	8054	67	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	8054	68	,	,	,
18637	8054	69	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	8054	70	and	and	CC
18637	8054	71	services	service	NNS
18637	8054	72	.	.	.
18637	8055	1	"	"	``
18637	8055	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8055	3	64	64	CD
18637	8055	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8055	5	In	in	IN
18637	8055	6	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	8055	7	of	of	IN
18637	8055	8	this	this	DT
18637	8055	9	order	order	NN
18637	8055	10	more	more	JJR
18637	8055	11	than	than	IN
18637	8055	12	112,000	112,000	CD
18637	8055	13	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	8055	14	residents	resident	NNS
18637	8055	15	of	of	IN
18637	8055	16	Western	Western	NNP
18637	8055	17	States	States	NNP
18637	8055	18	,	,	,
18637	8055	19	of	of	IN
18637	8055	20	whom	whom	WP
18637	8055	21	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	8055	22	two	two	CD
18637	8055	23	out	out	IN
18637	8055	24	of	of	IN
18637	8055	25	every	every	DT
18637	8055	26	three	three	CD
18637	8055	27	were	be	VBD
18637	8055	28	natural	natural	RB
18637	8055	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	8055	30	born	bear	VBN
18637	8055	31	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8055	32	of	of	IN
18637	8055	33	the	the	DT
18637	8055	34	United	United	NNP
18637	8055	35	States	States	NNP
18637	8055	36	,	,	,
18637	8055	37	were	be	VBD
18637	8055	38	eventually	eventually	RB
18637	8055	39	removed	remove	VBN
18637	8055	40	from	from	IN
18637	8055	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8055	42	farms	farm	NNS
18637	8055	43	and	and	CC
18637	8055	44	homes	home	NNS
18637	8055	45	and	and	CC
18637	8055	46	herded	herd	VBD
18637	8055	47	,	,	,
18637	8055	48	first	first	RB
18637	8055	49	in	in	IN
18637	8055	50	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	8055	51	camps	camp	NNS
18637	8055	52	,	,	,
18637	8055	53	later	later	RB
18637	8055	54	in	in	IN
18637	8055	55	ten	ten	CD
18637	8055	56	so	so	RB
18637	8055	57	-	-	HYPH
18637	8055	58	called	call	VBN
18637	8055	59	"	"	``
18637	8055	60	relocation	relocation	NN
18637	8055	61	centers	center	NNS
18637	8055	62	,	,	,
18637	8055	63	"	"	''
18637	8055	64	situated	situate	VBN
18637	8055	65	in	in	IN
18637	8055	66	the	the	DT
18637	8055	67	desert	desert	NN
18637	8055	68	country	country	NN
18637	8055	69	of	of	IN
18637	8055	70	California	California	NNP
18637	8055	71	,	,	,
18637	8055	72	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	8055	73	,	,	,
18637	8055	74	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
18637	8055	75	,	,	,
18637	8055	76	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	8055	77	,	,	,
18637	8055	78	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	8055	79	,	,	,
18637	8055	80	and	and	CC
18637	8055	81	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	8055	82	and	and	CC
18637	8055	83	in	in	IN
18637	8055	84	the	the	DT
18637	8055	85	delta	delta	NN
18637	8055	86	areas	area	NNS
18637	8055	87	of	of	IN
18637	8055	88	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	8055	89	.	.	.
18637	8056	1	The	the	DT
18637	8056	2	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8056	3	of	of	IN
18637	8056	4	March	March	NNP
18637	8056	5	21	21	CD
18637	8056	6	,	,	,
18637	8056	7	1942	1942	CD
18637	8056	8	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8056	9	was	be	VBD
18637	8056	10	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	8056	11	the	the	DT
18637	8056	12	original	original	JJ
18637	8056	13	intention	intention	NN
18637	8056	14	of	of	IN
18637	8056	15	the	the	DT
18637	8056	16	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	8056	17	to	to	TO
18637	8056	18	rest	rest	VB
18637	8056	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8056	20	measures	measure	NNS
18637	8056	21	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	8056	22	this	this	DT
18637	8056	23	matter	matter	NN
18637	8056	24	on	on	IN
18637	8056	25	the	the	DT
18637	8056	26	general	general	JJ
18637	8056	27	principle	principle	NN
18637	8056	28	of	of	IN
18637	8056	29	military	military	JJ
18637	8056	30	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	8056	31	and	and	CC
18637	8056	32	the	the	DT
18637	8056	33	power	power	NN
18637	8056	34	of	of	IN
18637	8056	35	the	the	DT
18637	8056	36	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8056	37	in	in	IN
18637	8056	38	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8056	39	in	in	IN
18637	8056	40	wartime	wartime	NN
18637	8056	41	.	.	.
18637	8057	1	But	but	CC
18637	8057	2	before	before	IN
18637	8057	3	any	any	DT
18637	8057	4	action	action	NN
18637	8057	5	of	of	IN
18637	8057	6	importance	importance	NN
18637	8057	7	was	be	VBD
18637	8057	8	taken	take	VBN
18637	8057	9	under	under	IN
18637	8057	10	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8057	11	Order	Order	NNP
18637	8057	12	9066	9066	CD
18637	8057	13	,	,	,
18637	8057	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8057	15	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	8057	16	and	and	CC
18637	8057	17	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	8057	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8057	19	by	by	IN
18637	8057	20	the	the	DT
18637	8057	21	act	act	NN
18637	8057	22	of	of	IN
18637	8057	23	March	March	NNP
18637	8057	24	21	21	CD
18637	8057	25	,	,	,
18637	8057	26	1942,[65	1942,[65	CD
18637	8057	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8057	28	by	by	IN
18637	8057	29	which	which	WDT
18637	8057	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8057	31	was	be	VBD
18637	8057	32	made	make	VBN
18637	8057	33	a	a	DT
18637	8057	34	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
18637	8057	35	to	to	TO
18637	8057	36	knowingly	knowingly	RB
18637	8057	37	enter	enter	VB
18637	8057	38	,	,	,
18637	8057	39	remain	remain	VBP
18637	8057	40	in	in	IN
18637	8057	41	,	,	,
18637	8057	42	or	or	CC
18637	8057	43	leave	leave	VB
18637	8057	44	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	8057	45	military	military	JJ
18637	8057	46	areas	area	NNS
18637	8057	47	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	8057	48	to	to	IN
18637	8057	49	the	the	DT
18637	8057	50	orders	order	NNS
18637	8057	51	of	of	IN
18637	8057	52	the	the	DT
18637	8057	53	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8057	54	of	of	IN
18637	8057	55	War	War	NNP
18637	8057	56	or	or	CC
18637	8057	57	of	of	IN
18637	8057	58	the	the	DT
18637	8057	59	commanding	command	VBG
18637	8057	60	officer	officer	NN
18637	8057	61	of	of	IN
18637	8057	62	the	the	DT
18637	8057	63	area	area	NN
18637	8057	64	.	.	.
18637	8058	1	The	the	DT
18637	8058	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	8058	3	which	which	WDT
18637	8058	4	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	8058	5	arose	arise	VBD
18637	8058	6	in	in	IN
18637	8058	7	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	8058	8	of	of	IN
18637	8058	9	the	the	DT
18637	8058	10	order	order	NN
18637	8058	11	were	be	VBD
18637	8058	12	decided	decide	VBN
18637	8058	13	under	under	IN
18637	8058	14	the	the	DT
18637	8058	15	order	order	NN
18637	8058	16	plus	plus	CC
18637	8058	17	the	the	DT
18637	8058	18	act	act	NN
18637	8058	19	.	.	.
18637	8059	1	The	the	DT
18637	8059	2	question	question	NN
18637	8059	3	at	at	IN
18637	8059	4	issue	issue	NN
18637	8059	5	,	,	,
18637	8059	6	said	say	VBD
18637	8059	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8059	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8059	9	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	8059	10	for	for	IN
18637	8059	11	the	the	DT
18637	8059	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8059	13	,	,	,
18637	8059	14	"	"	''
18637	8059	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	8059	16	not	not	RB
18637	8059	17	one	one	CD
18637	8059	18	of	of	IN
18637	8059	19	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	8059	20	power	power	NN
18637	8059	21	to	to	TO
18637	8059	22	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	8059	23	to	to	IN
18637	8059	24	the	the	DT
18637	8059	25	President	President	NNP
18637	8059	26	the	the	DT
18637	8059	27	promulgation	promulgation	NN
18637	8059	28	of	of	IN
18637	8059	29	the	the	DT
18637	8059	30	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8059	31	Order	Order	NNP
18637	8059	32	,	,	,
18637	8059	33	but	but	CC
18637	8059	34	whether	whether	IN
18637	8059	35	,	,	,
18637	8059	36	acting	act	VBG
18637	8059	37	in	in	IN
18637	8059	38	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	8059	39	,	,	,
18637	8059	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8059	41	and	and	CC
18637	8059	42	the	the	DT
18637	8059	43	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8059	44	have	have	VBP
18637	8059	45	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8059	46	*	*	NFP
18637	8059	47	*	*	NFP
18637	8059	48	*	*	NFP
18637	8059	49	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8059	50	power	power	NN
18637	8059	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8059	52	to	to	TO
18637	8059	53	impose	impose	VB
18637	8059	54	the	the	DT
18637	8059	55	curfew	curfew	NN
18637	8059	56	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	8059	57	here	here	RB
18637	8059	58	complained	complain	VBD
18637	8059	59	of	of	IN
18637	8059	60	.	.	.
18637	8060	1	"	"	``
18637	8060	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8060	3	66	66	CD
18637	8060	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8060	5	This	this	DT
18637	8060	6	question	question	NN
18637	8060	7	was	be	VBD
18637	8060	8	answered	answer	VBN
18637	8060	9	in	in	IN
18637	8060	10	the	the	DT
18637	8060	11	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	8060	12	,	,	,
18637	8060	13	as	as	IN
18637	8060	14	was	be	VBD
18637	8060	15	the	the	DT
18637	8060	16	similar	similar	JJ
18637	8060	17	question	question	NN
18637	8060	18	later	later	RB
18637	8060	19	raised	raise	VBN
18637	8060	20	by	by	IN
18637	8060	21	an	an	DT
18637	8060	22	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	8060	23	order	order	NN
18637	8060	24	.	.	.
18637	8061	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8061	2	67	67	CD
18637	8061	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8061	4	PRESIDENTIAL	presidential	JJ
18637	8061	5	GOVERNMENT	government	NN
18637	8061	6	OF	of	IN
18637	8061	7	LABOR	labor	NN
18637	8061	8	RELATIONS	RELATIONS	NNP
18637	8061	9	The	the	DT
18637	8061	10	most	most	RBS
18637	8061	11	important	important	JJ
18637	8061	12	segment	segment	NN
18637	8061	13	of	of	IN
18637	8061	14	the	the	DT
18637	8061	15	home	home	NN
18637	8061	16	front	front	NN
18637	8061	17	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	8061	18	by	by	IN
18637	8061	19	what	what	WP
18637	8061	20	were	be	VBD
18637	8061	21	in	in	IN
18637	8061	22	effect	effect	JJ
18637	8061	23	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8061	24	edicts	edict	NNS
18637	8061	25	was	be	VBD
18637	8061	26	the	the	DT
18637	8061	27	field	field	NN
18637	8061	28	of	of	IN
18637	8061	29	labor	labor	NN
18637	8061	30	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8061	31	.	.	.
18637	8062	1	Exactly	exactly	RB
18637	8062	2	six	six	CD
18637	8062	3	months	month	NNS
18637	8062	4	before	before	IN
18637	8062	5	Pearl	Pearl	NNP
18637	8062	6	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	8062	7	,	,	,
18637	8062	8	on	on	IN
18637	8062	9	June	June	NNP
18637	8062	10	7	7	CD
18637	8062	11	,	,	,
18637	8062	12	1941	1941	CD
18637	8062	13	,	,	,
18637	8062	14	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	8062	15	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8062	16	,	,	,
18637	8062	17	citing	cite	VBG
18637	8062	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8062	19	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	8062	20	thirteen	thirteen	CD
18637	8062	21	days	day	NNS
18637	8062	22	earlier	early	RBR
18637	8062	23	of	of	IN
18637	8062	24	an	an	DT
18637	8062	25	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	8062	26	national	national	JJ
18637	8062	27	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	8062	28	,	,	,
18637	8062	29	issued	issue	VBD
18637	8062	30	an	an	DT
18637	8062	31	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8062	32	Order	order	NN
18637	8062	33	seizing	seize	VBG
18637	8062	34	the	the	DT
18637	8062	35	North	North	NNP
18637	8062	36	American	American	NNP
18637	8062	37	Aviation	Aviation	NNP
18637	8062	38	Plant	Plant	NNP
18637	8062	39	at	at	IN
18637	8062	40	Inglewood	Inglewood	NNP
18637	8062	41	,	,	,
18637	8062	42	California	California	NNP
18637	8062	43	,	,	,
18637	8062	44	where	where	WRB
18637	8062	45	,	,	,
18637	8062	46	on	on	IN
18637	8062	47	account	account	NN
18637	8062	48	of	of	IN
18637	8062	49	a	a	DT
18637	8062	50	strike	strike	NN
18637	8062	51	,	,	,
18637	8062	52	production	production	NN
18637	8062	53	was	be	VBD
18637	8062	54	at	at	IN
18637	8062	55	a	a	DT
18637	8062	56	standstill	standstill	NN
18637	8062	57	.	.	.
18637	8063	1	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8063	2	General	General	NNP
18637	8063	3	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	8063	4	justified	justify	VBD
18637	8063	5	the	the	DT
18637	8063	6	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	8063	7	as	as	IN
18637	8063	8	growing	grow	VBG
18637	8063	9	out	out	IN
18637	8063	10	of	of	IN
18637	8063	11	the	the	DT
18637	8063	12	"	"	``
18637	8063	13	'	'	``
18637	8063	14	duty	duty	NN
18637	8063	15	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	8063	16	and	and	CC
18637	8063	17	inherently	inherently	RB
18637	8063	18	rested	rest	VBD
18637	8063	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	8063	20	the	the	DT
18637	8063	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8063	22	to	to	TO
18637	8063	23	exert	exert	VB
18637	8063	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8063	25	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8063	26	and	and	CC
18637	8063	27	military	military	NN
18637	8063	28	as	as	RB
18637	8063	29	well	well	RB
18637	8063	30	as	as	IN
18637	8063	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8063	32	moral	moral	JJ
18637	8063	33	authority	authority	NN
18637	8063	34	to	to	TO
18637	8063	35	keep	keep	VB
18637	8063	36	the	the	DT
18637	8063	37	defense	defense	NN
18637	8063	38	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	8063	39	of	of	IN
18637	8063	40	the	the	DT
18637	8063	41	United	United	NNP
18637	8063	42	States	States	NNP
18637	8063	43	a	a	DT
18637	8063	44	going	go	VBG
18637	8063	45	concern	concern	NN
18637	8063	46	,	,	,
18637	8063	47	'	'	''
18637	8063	48	"	"	``
18637	8063	49	as	as	RB
18637	8063	50	well	well	RB
18637	8063	51	as	as	IN
18637	8063	52	"	"	``
18637	8063	53	to	to	TO
18637	8063	54	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	8063	55	supplies	supply	NNS
18637	8063	56	for	for	IN
18637	8063	57	which	which	WDT
18637	8063	58	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8063	59	has	have	VBZ
18637	8063	60	appropriated	appropriate	VBN
18637	8063	61	the	the	DT
18637	8063	62	money	money	NN
18637	8063	63	,	,	,
18637	8063	64	and	and	CC
18637	8063	65	which	which	WDT
18637	8063	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8063	67	has	have	VBZ
18637	8063	68	directed	direct	VBN
18637	8063	69	the	the	DT
18637	8063	70	President	President	NNP
18637	8063	71	to	to	TO
18637	8063	72	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	8063	73	.	.	.
18637	8064	1	"	"	``
18637	8064	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8064	3	68	68	CD
18637	8064	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8064	5	Other	other	JJ
18637	8064	6	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	8064	7	followed	follow	VBD
18637	8064	8	,	,	,
18637	8064	9	and	and	CC
18637	8064	10	on	on	IN
18637	8064	11	January	January	NNP
18637	8064	12	12	12	CD
18637	8064	13	,	,	,
18637	8064	14	1942	1942	CD
18637	8064	15	,	,	,
18637	8064	16	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	8064	17	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8064	18	,	,	,
18637	8064	19	by	by	IN
18637	8064	20	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8064	21	Order	Order	NNP
18637	8064	22	9017	9017	CD
18637	8064	23	,	,	,
18637	8064	24	created	create	VBD
18637	8064	25	the	the	DT
18637	8064	26	National	National	NNP
18637	8064	27	War	War	NNP
18637	8064	28	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8064	29	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8064	30	.	.	.
18637	8065	1	"	"	``
18637	8065	2	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	8065	3	,	,	,
18637	8065	4	"	"	''
18637	8065	5	the	the	DT
18637	8065	6	order	order	NN
18637	8065	7	read	read	VBD
18637	8065	8	in	in	IN
18637	8065	9	part	part	NN
18637	8065	10	,	,	,
18637	8065	11	"	"	''
18637	8065	12	by	by	IN
18637	8065	13	reason	reason	NN
18637	8065	14	of	of	IN
18637	8065	15	the	the	DT
18637	8065	16	state	state	NN
18637	8065	17	of	of	IN
18637	8065	18	war	war	NN
18637	8065	19	declared	declare	VBN
18637	8065	20	to	to	TO
18637	8065	21	exist	exist	VB
18637	8065	22	by	by	IN
18637	8065	23	joint	joint	JJ
18637	8065	24	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	8065	25	of	of	IN
18637	8065	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8065	27	,	,	,
18637	8065	28	*	*	NFP
18637	8065	29	*	*	NFP
18637	8065	30	*	*	NFP
18637	8065	31	,	,	,
18637	8065	32	the	the	DT
18637	8065	33	national	national	JJ
18637	8065	34	interest	interest	NN
18637	8065	35	demands	demand	VBZ
18637	8065	36	that	that	IN
18637	8065	37	there	there	EX
18637	8065	38	shall	shall	MD
18637	8065	39	be	be	VB
18637	8065	40	no	no	DT
18637	8065	41	interruption	interruption	NN
18637	8065	42	of	of	IN
18637	8065	43	any	any	DT
18637	8065	44	work	work	NN
18637	8065	45	which	which	WDT
18637	8065	46	contributes	contribute	VBZ
18637	8065	47	to	to	IN
18637	8065	48	the	the	DT
18637	8065	49	effective	effective	JJ
18637	8065	50	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	8065	51	of	of	IN
18637	8065	52	the	the	DT
18637	8065	53	war	war	NN
18637	8065	54	;	;	:
18637	8065	55	and	and	CC
18637	8065	56	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	8065	57	as	as	IN
18637	8065	58	a	a	DT
18637	8065	59	result	result	NN
18637	8065	60	of	of	IN
18637	8065	61	a	a	DT
18637	8065	62	conference	conference	NN
18637	8065	63	of	of	IN
18637	8065	64	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	8065	65	of	of	IN
18637	8065	66	labor	labor	NN
18637	8065	67	and	and	CC
18637	8065	68	industry	industry	NN
18637	8065	69	which	which	WDT
18637	8065	70	met	meet	VBD
18637	8065	71	at	at	IN
18637	8065	72	the	the	DT
18637	8065	73	call	call	NN
18637	8065	74	of	of	IN
18637	8065	75	the	the	DT
18637	8065	76	President	President	NNP
18637	8065	77	on	on	IN
18637	8065	78	December	December	NNP
18637	8065	79	17	17	CD
18637	8065	80	,	,	,
18637	8065	81	1941	1941	CD
18637	8065	82	,	,	,
18637	8065	83	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8065	84	has	have	VBZ
18637	8065	85	been	be	VBN
18637	8065	86	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	8065	87	that	that	IN
18637	8065	88	for	for	IN
18637	8065	89	the	the	DT
18637	8065	90	duration	duration	NN
18637	8065	91	of	of	IN
18637	8065	92	the	the	DT
18637	8065	93	war	war	NN
18637	8065	94	there	there	RB
18637	8065	95	shall	shall	MD
18637	8065	96	be	be	VB
18637	8065	97	no	no	DT
18637	8065	98	strikes	strike	NNS
18637	8065	99	or	or	CC
18637	8065	100	lockouts	lockout	NNS
18637	8065	101	,	,	,
18637	8065	102	and	and	CC
18637	8065	103	that	that	IN
18637	8065	104	all	all	DT
18637	8065	105	labor	labor	NN
18637	8065	106	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	8065	107	shall	shall	MD
18637	8065	108	be	be	VB
18637	8065	109	settled	settle	VBN
18637	8065	110	by	by	IN
18637	8065	111	peaceful	peaceful	JJ
18637	8065	112	means	mean	NNS
18637	8065	113	,	,	,
18637	8065	114	and	and	CC
18637	8065	115	that	that	IN
18637	8065	116	a	a	DT
18637	8065	117	National	National	NNP
18637	8065	118	War	War	NNP
18637	8065	119	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8065	120	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8065	121	be	be	VB
18637	8065	122	established	establish	VBN
18637	8065	123	for	for	IN
18637	8065	124	a	a	DT
18637	8065	125	peaceful	peaceful	JJ
18637	8065	126	adjustment	adjustment	NN
18637	8065	127	of	of	IN
18637	8065	128	such	such	JJ
18637	8065	129	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	8065	130	.	.	.
18637	8066	1	Now	now	RB
18637	8066	2	,	,	,
18637	8066	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8066	4	,	,	,
18637	8066	5	by	by	IN
18637	8066	6	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	8066	7	of	of	IN
18637	8066	8	the	the	DT
18637	8066	9	authority	authority	NN
18637	8066	10	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8066	11	in	in	IN
18637	8066	12	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8066	13	by	by	IN
18637	8066	14	the	the	DT
18637	8066	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8066	16	and	and	CC
18637	8066	17	the	the	DT
18637	8066	18	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	8066	19	of	of	IN
18637	8066	20	the	the	DT
18637	8066	21	United	United	NNP
18637	8066	22	States	States	NNP
18637	8066	23	,	,	,
18637	8066	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8066	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	8066	26	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	8066	27	ordered	order	VBN
18637	8066	28	:	:	:
18637	8066	29	1	1	CD
18637	8066	30	.	.	.
18637	8067	1	There	there	EX
18637	8067	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8067	3	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	8067	4	created	create	VBN
18637	8067	5	in	in	IN
18637	8067	6	the	the	DT
18637	8067	7	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8067	8	for	for	IN
18637	8067	9	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	8067	10	Management	Management	NNP
18637	8067	11	a	a	DT
18637	8067	12	National	National	NNP
18637	8067	13	War	War	NNP
18637	8067	14	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8067	15	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8067	16	,	,	,
18637	8067	17	*	*	NFP
18637	8067	18	*	*	NFP
18637	8067	19	*	*	NFP
18637	8067	20	"	"	''
18637	8067	21	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8067	22	69	69	CD
18637	8067	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8067	24	In	in	IN
18637	8067	25	this	this	DT
18637	8067	26	field	field	NN
18637	8067	27	,	,	,
18637	8067	28	too	too	RB
18637	8067	29	,	,	,
18637	8067	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8067	31	intervened	intervene	VBD
18637	8067	32	by	by	IN
18637	8067	33	means	mean	NNS
18637	8067	34	of	of	IN
18637	8067	35	the	the	DT
18637	8067	36	War	War	NNP
18637	8067	37	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8067	38	Disputes	Disputes	NNP
18637	8067	39	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8067	40	of	of	IN
18637	8067	41	June	June	NNP
18637	8067	42	25	25	CD
18637	8067	43	,	,	,
18637	8067	44	1943,[70	1943,[70	CD
18637	8067	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8067	46	which	which	WDT
18637	8067	47	however	however	RB
18637	8067	48	still	still	RB
18637	8067	49	left	leave	VBD
18637	8067	50	ample	ample	JJ
18637	8067	51	basis	basis	NN
18637	8067	52	for	for	IN
18637	8067	53	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8067	54	activity	activity	NN
18637	8067	55	of	of	IN
18637	8067	56	a	a	DT
18637	8067	57	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8067	58	character	character	NN
18637	8067	59	.	.	.
18637	8068	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8068	2	71	71	CD
18637	8068	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8068	4	"	"	``
18637	8068	5	SANCTIONS	SANCTIONS	NNP
18637	8068	6	"	"	''
18637	8068	7	To	to	TO
18637	8068	8	implement	implement	VB
18637	8068	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8068	10	directives	directive	NNS
18637	8068	11	as	as	IN
18637	8068	12	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8068	13	in	in	IN
18637	8068	14	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8068	15	in	in	IN
18637	8068	16	wartime	wartime	NN
18637	8068	17	,	,	,
18637	8068	18	and	and	CC
18637	8068	19	especially	especially	RB
18637	8068	20	those	those	DT
18637	8068	21	which	which	WDT
18637	8068	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8068	23	issued	issue	VBD
18637	8068	24	in	in	IN
18637	8068	25	governing	govern	VBG
18637	8068	26	labor	labor	NN
18637	8068	27	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8068	28	,	,	,
18637	8068	29	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	8068	30	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8068	31	often	often	RB
18637	8068	32	resorted	resort	VBD
18637	8068	33	to	to	IN
18637	8068	34	"	"	``
18637	8068	35	sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	8068	36	,	,	,
18637	8068	37	"	"	''
18637	8068	38	which	which	WDT
18637	8068	39	may	may	MD
18637	8068	40	be	be	VB
18637	8068	41	described	describe	VBN
18637	8068	42	as	as	IN
18637	8068	43	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	8068	44	lacking	lack	VBG
18637	8068	45	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	8068	46	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	8068	47	.	.	.
18637	8069	1	Ultimately	ultimately	RB
18637	8069	2	,	,	,
18637	8069	3	the	the	DT
18637	8069	4	President	President	NNP
18637	8069	5	sought	seek	VBD
18637	8069	6	,	,	,
18637	8069	7	by	by	IN
18637	8069	8	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8069	9	Order	order	NN
18637	8069	10	9370	9370	CD
18637	8069	11	of	of	IN
18637	8069	12	August	August	NNP
18637	8069	13	16	16	CD
18637	8069	14	,	,	,
18637	8069	15	1943	1943	CD
18637	8069	16	,	,	,
18637	8069	17	to	to	TO
18637	8069	18	put	put	VB
18637	8069	19	sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	8069	20	in	in	IN
18637	8069	21	this	this	DT
18637	8069	22	field	field	NN
18637	8069	23	on	on	IN
18637	8069	24	a	a	DT
18637	8069	25	systematic	systematic	JJ
18637	8069	26	basis	basis	NN
18637	8069	27	.	.	.
18637	8070	1	This	this	DT
18637	8070	2	order	order	NN
18637	8070	3	read	read	VBD
18637	8070	4	:	:	:
18637	8070	5	"	"	``
18637	8070	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8070	7	a	a	LS
18637	8070	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8070	9	To	to	IN
18637	8070	10	other	other	JJ
18637	8070	11	departments	department	NNS
18637	8070	12	or	or	CC
18637	8070	13	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	8070	14	of	of	IN
18637	8070	15	the	the	DT
18637	8070	16	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8070	17	directing	direct	VBG
18637	8070	18	the	the	DT
18637	8070	19	taking	taking	NN
18637	8070	20	of	of	IN
18637	8070	21	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	8070	22	action	action	NN
18637	8070	23	relating	relate	VBG
18637	8070	24	to	to	IN
18637	8070	25	withholding	withhold	VBG
18637	8070	26	or	or	CC
18637	8070	27	withdrawing	withdraw	VBG
18637	8070	28	from	from	IN
18637	8070	29	a	a	DT
18637	8070	30	noncomplying	noncomplying	NN
18637	8070	31	employer	employer	NN
18637	8070	32	any	any	DT
18637	8070	33	priorities	priority	NNS
18637	8070	34	,	,	,
18637	8070	35	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	8070	36	or	or	CC
18637	8070	37	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	8070	38	extended	extend	VBN
18637	8070	39	,	,	,
18637	8070	40	or	or	CC
18637	8070	41	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	8070	42	entered	enter	VBD
18637	8070	43	into	into	IN
18637	8070	44	,	,	,
18637	8070	45	by	by	IN
18637	8070	46	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8070	47	action	action	NN
18637	8070	48	of	of	IN
18637	8070	49	the	the	DT
18637	8070	50	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8070	51	,	,	,
18637	8070	52	until	until	IN
18637	8070	53	the	the	DT
18637	8070	54	National	National	NNP
18637	8070	55	War	War	NNP
18637	8070	56	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8070	57	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8070	58	has	have	VBZ
18637	8070	59	reported	report	VBN
18637	8070	60	that	that	IN
18637	8070	61	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	8070	62	has	have	VBZ
18637	8070	63	been	be	VBN
18637	8070	64	effectuated	effectuate	VBN
18637	8070	65	;	;	:
18637	8070	66	"	"	''
18637	8070	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8070	68	b	b	NN
18637	8070	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8070	70	To	to	IN
18637	8070	71	any	any	DT
18637	8070	72	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8070	73	agency	agency	NN
18637	8070	74	operating	operate	VBG
18637	8070	75	a	a	DT
18637	8070	76	plant	plant	NN
18637	8070	77	,	,	,
18637	8070	78	mine	mine	NN
18637	8070	79	or	or	CC
18637	8070	80	facility	facility	NN
18637	8070	81	,	,	,
18637	8070	82	possession	possession	NN
18637	8070	83	of	of	IN
18637	8070	84	which	which	WDT
18637	8070	85	has	have	VBZ
18637	8070	86	been	be	VBN
18637	8070	87	taken	take	VBN
18637	8070	88	by	by	IN
18637	8070	89	the	the	DT
18637	8070	90	President	President	NNP
18637	8070	91	under	under	IN
18637	8070	92	section	section	NN
18637	8070	93	3	3	CD
18637	8070	94	of	of	IN
18637	8070	95	the	the	DT
18637	8070	96	War	War	NNP
18637	8070	97	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8070	98	Disputes	Disputes	NNP
18637	8070	99	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8070	100	,	,	,
18637	8070	101	directing	direct	VBG
18637	8070	102	such	such	JJ
18637	8070	103	agency	agency	NN
18637	8070	104	to	to	TO
18637	8070	105	apply	apply	VB
18637	8070	106	to	to	IN
18637	8070	107	the	the	DT
18637	8070	108	National	National	NNP
18637	8070	109	War	War	NNP
18637	8070	110	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8070	111	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8070	112	,	,	,
18637	8070	113	under	under	IN
18637	8070	114	section	section	NN
18637	8070	115	5	5	CD
18637	8070	116	of	of	IN
18637	8070	117	said	said	NNP
18637	8070	118	act	act	NNP
18637	8070	119	,	,	,
18637	8070	120	for	for	IN
18637	8070	121	an	an	DT
18637	8070	122	order	order	NN
18637	8070	123	withholding	withholding	NN
18637	8070	124	or	or	CC
18637	8070	125	withdrawing	withdraw	VBG
18637	8070	126	from	from	IN
18637	8070	127	a	a	DT
18637	8070	128	noncomplying	noncomplying	NN
18637	8070	129	labor	labor	NN
18637	8070	130	union	union	NN
18637	8070	131	any	any	DT
18637	8070	132	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	8070	133	,	,	,
18637	8070	134	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	8070	135	or	or	CC
18637	8070	136	rights	right	NNS
18637	8070	137	accruing	accrue	VBG
18637	8070	138	to	to	IN
18637	8070	139	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8070	140	under	under	IN
18637	8070	141	the	the	DT
18637	8070	142	terms	term	NNS
18637	8070	143	of	of	IN
18637	8070	144	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	8070	145	of	of	IN
18637	8070	146	employment	employment	NN
18637	8070	147	in	in	IN
18637	8070	148	effect	effect	NN
18637	8070	149	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8070	150	whether	whether	IN
18637	8070	151	by	by	IN
18637	8070	152	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8070	153	between	between	IN
18637	8070	154	the	the	DT
18637	8070	155	parties	party	NNS
18637	8070	156	or	or	CC
18637	8070	157	by	by	IN
18637	8070	158	order	order	NN
18637	8070	159	of	of	IN
18637	8070	160	the	the	DT
18637	8070	161	National	National	NNP
18637	8070	162	War	War	NNP
18637	8070	163	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8070	164	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8070	165	,	,	,
18637	8070	166	or	or	CC
18637	8070	167	both	both	DT
18637	8070	168	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8070	169	when	when	WRB
18637	8070	170	possession	possession	NN
18637	8070	171	was	be	VBD
18637	8070	172	taken	take	VBN
18637	8070	173	,	,	,
18637	8070	174	until	until	IN
18637	8070	175	such	such	JJ
18637	8070	176	time	time	NN
18637	8070	177	as	as	IN
18637	8070	178	the	the	DT
18637	8070	179	noncomplying	noncomplying	NNP
18637	8070	180	labor	labor	NNP
18637	8070	181	union	union	NNP
18637	8070	182	has	have	VBZ
18637	8070	183	demonstrated	demonstrate	VBN
18637	8070	184	to	to	IN
18637	8070	185	the	the	DT
18637	8070	186	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
18637	8070	187	of	of	IN
18637	8070	188	the	the	DT
18637	8070	189	National	National	NNP
18637	8070	190	War	War	NNP
18637	8070	191	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8070	192	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8070	193	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8070	194	willingness	willingness	NN
18637	8070	195	and	and	CC
18637	8070	196	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	8070	197	to	to	TO
18637	8070	198	comply	comply	VB
18637	8070	199	;	;	:
18637	8070	200	but	but	CC
18637	8070	201	,	,	,
18637	8070	202	when	when	WRB
18637	8070	203	the	the	DT
18637	8070	204	check	check	NN
18637	8070	205	-	-	HYPH
18637	8070	206	off	off	NN
18637	8070	207	is	be	VBZ
18637	8070	208	denied	deny	VBN
18637	8070	209	,	,	,
18637	8070	210	dues	due	NNS
18637	8070	211	received	receive	VBN
18637	8070	212	from	from	IN
18637	8070	213	the	the	DT
18637	8070	214	check	check	NN
18637	8070	215	-	-	HYPH
18637	8070	216	off	off	NN
18637	8070	217	shall	shall	MD
18637	8070	218	be	be	VB
18637	8070	219	held	hold	VBN
18637	8070	220	in	in	IN
18637	8070	221	escrow	escrow	NN
18637	8070	222	for	for	IN
18637	8070	223	the	the	DT
18637	8070	224	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	8070	225	of	of	IN
18637	8070	226	the	the	DT
18637	8070	227	union	union	NN
18637	8070	228	to	to	TO
18637	8070	229	be	be	VB
18637	8070	230	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	8070	231	to	to	IN
18637	8070	232	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8070	233	upon	upon	IN
18637	8070	234	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	8070	235	by	by	IN
18637	8070	236	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8070	237	.	.	.
18637	8071	1	"	"	``
18637	8071	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8071	3	c	c	NN
18637	8071	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8071	5	To	to	IN
18637	8071	6	the	the	DT
18637	8071	7	War	War	NNP
18637	8071	8	Manpower	Manpower	NNP
18637	8071	9	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	8071	10	,	,	,
18637	8071	11	in	in	IN
18637	8071	12	the	the	DT
18637	8071	13	case	case	NN
18637	8071	14	of	of	IN
18637	8071	15	noncomplying	noncomplye	VBG
18637	8071	16	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	8071	17	,	,	,
18637	8071	18	directing	direct	VBG
18637	8071	19	the	the	DT
18637	8071	20	entry	entry	NN
18637	8071	21	of	of	IN
18637	8071	22	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	8071	23	orders	order	NNS
18637	8071	24	relating	relate	VBG
18637	8071	25	to	to	IN
18637	8071	26	the	the	DT
18637	8071	27	modification	modification	NN
18637	8071	28	or	or	CC
18637	8071	29	cancellation	cancellation	NN
18637	8071	30	of	of	IN
18637	8071	31	draft	draft	NN
18637	8071	32	deferments	deferment	NNS
18637	8071	33	or	or	CC
18637	8071	34	employment	employment	NN
18637	8071	35	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	8071	36	,	,	,
18637	8071	37	or	or	CC
18637	8071	38	both	both	DT
18637	8071	39	.	.	.
18637	8072	1	"	"	``
18637	8072	2	Franklin	Franklin	NNP
18637	8072	3	D.	D.	NNP
18637	8072	4	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8072	5	.	.	.
18637	8073	1	"	"	``
18637	8073	2	The	the	DT
18637	8073	3	White	White	NNP
18637	8073	4	House	House	NNP
18637	8073	5	,	,	,
18637	8073	6	_	_	NNP
18637	8073	7	Aug.	August	NNP
18637	8074	1	16	16	CD
18637	8074	2	,	,	,
18637	8074	3	1943._"[72	1943._"[72	CD
18637	8074	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8074	5	CONSTITUTIONAL	constitutional	JJ
18637	8074	6	BASIS	basi	NNS
18637	8074	7	OF	of	IN
18637	8074	8	SANCTIONS	SANCTIONS	NNP
18637	8074	9	Sanctions	Sanctions	NNPS
18637	8074	10	were	be	VBD
18637	8074	11	also	also	RB
18637	8074	12	occasionally	occasionally	RB
18637	8074	13	employed	employ	VBN
18637	8074	14	by	by	IN
18637	8074	15	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	8074	16	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	8074	17	,	,	,
18637	8074	18	as	as	IN
18637	8074	19	by	by	IN
18637	8074	20	OPA	OPA	NNP
18637	8074	21	,	,	,
18637	8074	22	to	to	TO
18637	8074	23	supplement	supplement	VB
18637	8074	24	the	the	DT
18637	8074	25	penal	penal	JJ
18637	8074	26	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8074	27	of	of	IN
18637	8074	28	the	the	DT
18637	8074	29	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	8074	30	Price	Price	NNP
18637	8074	31	Control	Control	NNP
18637	8074	32	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8074	33	of	of	IN
18637	8074	34	January	January	NNP
18637	8074	35	30	30	CD
18637	8074	36	,	,	,
18637	8074	37	1942;[73	1942;[73	CD
18637	8074	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8074	39	and	and	CC
18637	8074	40	in	in	IN
18637	8074	41	the	the	DT
18637	8074	42	case	case	NN
18637	8074	43	of	of	IN
18637	8074	44	Steuart	Steuart	NNP
18637	8074	45	and	and	CC
18637	8074	46	Bro	Bro	NNP
18637	8074	47	.	.	NNP
18637	8074	48	,	,	,
18637	8074	49	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	8074	50	_	_	NNP
18637	8074	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	8074	52	_	_	NNP
18637	8074	53	Bowles,[74	Bowles,[74	NNP
18637	8074	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8074	55	the	the	DT
18637	8074	56	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8074	57	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8074	58	had	have	VBD
18637	8074	59	the	the	DT
18637	8074	60	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	8074	61	to	to	TO
18637	8074	62	attempt	attempt	VB
18637	8074	63	to	to	TO
18637	8074	64	regularize	regularize	VB
18637	8074	65	this	this	DT
18637	8074	66	type	type	NN
18637	8074	67	of	of	IN
18637	8074	68	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8074	69	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	8074	70	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8074	71	.	.	.
18637	8075	1	Here	here	RB
18637	8075	2	a	a	DT
18637	8075	3	retail	retail	JJ
18637	8075	4	dealer	dealer	NN
18637	8075	5	in	in	IN
18637	8075	6	fuel	fuel	NN
18637	8075	7	oil	oil	NN
18637	8075	8	in	in	IN
18637	8075	9	the	the	DT
18637	8075	10	District	District	NNP
18637	8075	11	of	of	IN
18637	8075	12	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	8075	13	was	be	VBD
18637	8075	14	charged	charge	VBN
18637	8075	15	with	with	IN
18637	8075	16	having	have	VBG
18637	8075	17	violated	violate	VBN
18637	8075	18	a	a	DT
18637	8075	19	rationing	ration	VBG
18637	8075	20	order	order	NN
18637	8075	21	of	of	IN
18637	8075	22	OPA	opa	NN
18637	8075	23	by	by	IN
18637	8075	24	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	8075	25	large	large	JJ
18637	8075	26	quantities	quantity	NNS
18637	8075	27	of	of	IN
18637	8075	28	oil	oil	NN
18637	8075	29	from	from	IN
18637	8075	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8075	31	supplier	supplier	NN
18637	8075	32	without	without	IN
18637	8075	33	surrendering	surrender	VBG
18637	8075	34	ration	ration	NN
18637	8075	35	coupons	coupon	NNS
18637	8075	36	,	,	,
18637	8075	37	by	by	IN
18637	8075	38	delivering	deliver	VBG
18637	8075	39	many	many	JJ
18637	8075	40	thousands	thousand	NNS
18637	8075	41	of	of	IN
18637	8075	42	gallons	gallon	NNS
18637	8075	43	of	of	IN
18637	8075	44	fuel	fuel	NN
18637	8075	45	oil	oil	NN
18637	8075	46	without	without	IN
18637	8075	47	requiring	require	VBG
18637	8075	48	ration	ration	NN
18637	8075	49	coupons	coupon	NNS
18637	8075	50	,	,	,
18637	8075	51	and	and	CC
18637	8075	52	so	so	RB
18637	8075	53	on	on	RB
18637	8075	54	,	,	,
18637	8075	55	and	and	CC
18637	8075	56	was	be	VBD
18637	8075	57	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	8075	58	by	by	IN
18637	8075	59	the	the	DT
18637	8075	60	agency	agency	NN
18637	8075	61	from	from	IN
18637	8075	62	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	8075	63	oil	oil	NN
18637	8075	64	for	for	IN
18637	8075	65	resale	resale	NN
18637	8075	66	or	or	CC
18637	8075	67	transfer	transfer	VB
18637	8075	68	for	for	IN
18637	8075	69	the	the	DT
18637	8075	70	ensuing	ensue	VBG
18637	8075	71	year	year	NN
18637	8075	72	.	.	.
18637	8076	1	The	the	DT
18637	8076	2	offender	offender	NN
18637	8076	3	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	8076	4	the	the	DT
18637	8076	5	validity	validity	NN
18637	8076	6	of	of	IN
18637	8076	7	the	the	DT
18637	8076	8	rationing	ration	VBG
18637	8076	9	order	order	NN
18637	8076	10	in	in	IN
18637	8076	11	support	support	NN
18637	8076	12	of	of	IN
18637	8076	13	which	which	WDT
18637	8076	14	the	the	DT
18637	8076	15	suspension	suspension	NN
18637	8076	16	order	order	NN
18637	8076	17	was	be	VBD
18637	8076	18	issued	issue	VBN
18637	8076	19	,	,	,
18637	8076	20	but	but	CC
18637	8076	21	challenged	challenge	VBD
18637	8076	22	the	the	DT
18637	8076	23	validity	validity	NN
18637	8076	24	of	of	IN
18637	8076	25	the	the	DT
18637	8076	26	latter	latter	JJ
18637	8076	27	as	as	IN
18637	8076	28	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	8076	29	a	a	DT
18637	8076	30	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	8076	31	that	that	WDT
18637	8076	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8076	33	has	have	VBZ
18637	8076	34	not	not	RB
18637	8076	35	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	8076	36	,	,	,
18637	8076	37	and	and	CC
18637	8076	38	asked	ask	VBD
18637	8076	39	the	the	DT
18637	8076	40	district	district	NN
18637	8076	41	court	court	NN
18637	8076	42	to	to	TO
18637	8076	43	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	8076	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8076	45	.	.	.
18637	8077	1	The	the	DT
18637	8077	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8077	3	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	8077	4	to	to	TO
18637	8077	5	do	do	VB
18637	8077	6	so	so	RB
18637	8077	7	and	and	CC
18637	8077	8	was	be	VBD
18637	8077	9	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	8077	10	by	by	IN
18637	8077	11	the	the	DT
18637	8077	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8077	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8077	14	in	in	IN
18637	8077	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8077	16	position	position	NN
18637	8077	17	.	.	.
18637	8078	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	8078	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8078	3	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	8078	4	,	,	,
18637	8078	5	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8078	6	for	for	IN
18637	8078	7	the	the	DT
18637	8078	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8078	9	:	:	:
18637	8078	10	"	"	``
18637	8078	11	Without	without	IN
18637	8078	12	rationing	ration	VBG
18637	8078	13	,	,	,
18637	8078	14	the	the	DT
18637	8078	15	fuel	fuel	NN
18637	8078	16	tanks	tank	NNS
18637	8078	17	of	of	IN
18637	8078	18	a	a	DT
18637	8078	19	few	few	JJ
18637	8078	20	would	would	MD
18637	8078	21	be	be	VB
18637	8078	22	full	full	JJ
18637	8078	23	;	;	:
18637	8078	24	the	the	DT
18637	8078	25	fuel	fuel	NN
18637	8078	26	tanks	tank	NNS
18637	8078	27	of	of	IN
18637	8078	28	many	many	JJ
18637	8078	29	would	would	MD
18637	8078	30	be	be	VB
18637	8078	31	empty	empty	JJ
18637	8078	32	.	.	.
18637	8079	1	Some	some	DT
18637	8079	2	localities	locality	NNS
18637	8079	3	would	would	MD
18637	8079	4	have	have	VB
18637	8079	5	plenty	plenty	NN
18637	8079	6	;	;	:
18637	8079	7	communities	community	NNS
18637	8079	8	less	less	RBR
18637	8079	9	favorably	favorably	RB
18637	8079	10	situated	situate	VBN
18637	8079	11	would	would	MD
18637	8079	12	suffer	suffer	VB
18637	8079	13	.	.	.
18637	8080	1	Allocation	allocation	NN
18637	8080	2	or	or	CC
18637	8080	3	rationing	rationing	NN
18637	8080	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	8080	5	designed	design	VBN
18637	8080	6	to	to	TO
18637	8080	7	eliminate	eliminate	VB
18637	8080	8	such	such	JJ
18637	8080	9	inequalities	inequality	NNS
18637	8080	10	and	and	CC
18637	8080	11	to	to	TO
18637	8080	12	treat	treat	VB
18637	8080	13	all	all	DT
18637	8080	14	alike	alike	RB
18637	8080	15	who	who	WP
18637	8080	16	are	be	VBP
18637	8080	17	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	8080	18	situated	situate	VBN
18637	8080	19	.	.	.
18637	8081	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8081	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8081	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8081	4	But	but	CC
18637	8081	5	middlemen	middleman	NNS
18637	8081	6	--	--	:
18637	8081	7	wholesalers	wholesaler	NNS
18637	8081	8	and	and	CC
18637	8081	9	retailers	retailer	NNS
18637	8081	10	--	--	:
18637	8081	11	bent	bent	JJ
18637	8081	12	on	on	IN
18637	8081	13	defying	defy	VBG
18637	8081	14	the	the	DT
18637	8081	15	rationing	ration	VBG
18637	8081	16	system	system	NN
18637	8081	17	could	could	MD
18637	8081	18	raise	raise	VB
18637	8081	19	havoc	havoc	NN
18637	8081	20	with	with	IN
18637	8081	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8081	22	.	.	.
18637	8082	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8082	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8082	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8082	4	These	these	DT
18637	8082	5	middlemen	middleman	NNS
18637	8082	6	are	be	VBP
18637	8082	7	the	the	DT
18637	8082	8	chief	chief	NN
18637	8082	9	if	if	IN
18637	8082	10	not	not	RB
18637	8082	11	the	the	DT
18637	8082	12	only	only	JJ
18637	8082	13	conduits	conduit	NNS
18637	8082	14	between	between	IN
18637	8082	15	the	the	DT
18637	8082	16	source	source	NN
18637	8082	17	of	of	IN
18637	8082	18	limited	limited	JJ
18637	8082	19	supplies	supply	NNS
18637	8082	20	and	and	CC
18637	8082	21	the	the	DT
18637	8082	22	consumers	consumer	NNS
18637	8082	23	.	.	.
18637	8083	1	From	from	IN
18637	8083	2	the	the	DT
18637	8083	3	viewpoint	viewpoint	NN
18637	8083	4	of	of	IN
18637	8083	5	a	a	DT
18637	8083	6	rationing	ration	VBG
18637	8083	7	system	system	NN
18637	8083	8	a	a	DT
18637	8083	9	middleman	middleman	NN
18637	8083	10	who	who	WP
18637	8083	11	distributes	distribute	VBZ
18637	8083	12	the	the	DT
18637	8083	13	product	product	NN
18637	8083	14	in	in	IN
18637	8083	15	violation	violation	NN
18637	8083	16	and	and	CC
18637	8083	17	disregard	disregard	NN
18637	8083	18	of	of	IN
18637	8083	19	the	the	DT
18637	8083	20	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	8083	21	quotas	quota	NNS
18637	8083	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	8083	23	an	an	DT
18637	8083	24	inefficient	inefficient	JJ
18637	8083	25	and	and	CC
18637	8083	26	wasteful	wasteful	JJ
18637	8083	27	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	8083	28	.	.	.
18637	8084	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8084	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8084	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8084	4	Certainly	certainly	RB
18637	8084	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8084	6	could	could	MD
18637	8084	7	not	not	RB
18637	8084	8	say	say	VB
18637	8084	9	that	that	IN
18637	8084	10	the	the	DT
18637	8084	11	President	President	NNP
18637	8084	12	would	would	MD
18637	8084	13	lack	lack	VB
18637	8084	14	the	the	DT
18637	8084	15	power	power	NN
18637	8084	16	under	under	IN
18637	8084	17	this	this	DT
18637	8084	18	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8084	19	to	to	TO
18637	8084	20	take	take	VB
18637	8084	21	away	away	RB
18637	8084	22	from	from	IN
18637	8084	23	a	a	DT
18637	8084	24	wasteful	wasteful	JJ
18637	8084	25	factory	factory	NN
18637	8084	26	and	and	CC
18637	8084	27	route	route	NN
18637	8084	28	to	to	IN
18637	8084	29	an	an	DT
18637	8084	30	efficient	efficient	JJ
18637	8084	31	one	one	CD
18637	8084	32	a	a	DT
18637	8084	33	previous	previous	JJ
18637	8084	34	supply	supply	NN
18637	8084	35	of	of	IN
18637	8084	36	material	material	NN
18637	8084	37	needed	need	VBN
18637	8084	38	for	for	IN
18637	8084	39	the	the	DT
18637	8084	40	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	8084	41	of	of	IN
18637	8084	42	articles	article	NNS
18637	8084	43	of	of	IN
18637	8084	44	war	war	NN
18637	8084	45	.	.	.
18637	8085	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8085	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8085	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8085	4	From	from	IN
18637	8085	5	the	the	DT
18637	8085	6	point	point	NN
18637	8085	7	of	of	IN
18637	8085	8	view	view	NN
18637	8085	9	of	of	IN
18637	8085	10	the	the	DT
18637	8085	11	factory	factory	NN
18637	8085	12	owner	owner	NN
18637	8085	13	from	from	IN
18637	8085	14	whom	whom	WP
18637	8085	15	the	the	DT
18637	8085	16	materials	material	NNS
18637	8085	17	were	be	VBD
18637	8085	18	diverted	divert	VBN
18637	8085	19	the	the	DT
18637	8085	20	action	action	NN
18637	8085	21	would	would	MD
18637	8085	22	be	be	VB
18637	8085	23	harsh	harsh	JJ
18637	8085	24	.	.	.
18637	8086	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8086	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8086	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8086	4	But	but	CC
18637	8086	5	in	in	IN
18637	8086	6	times	time	NNS
18637	8086	7	of	of	IN
18637	8086	8	war	war	NN
18637	8086	9	the	the	DT
18637	8086	10	national	national	JJ
18637	8086	11	interest	interest	NN
18637	8086	12	can	can	MD
18637	8086	13	not	not	RB
18637	8086	14	wait	wait	VB
18637	8086	15	on	on	IN
18637	8086	16	individual	individual	JJ
18637	8086	17	claims	claim	NNS
18637	8086	18	to	to	TO
18637	8086	19	preference	preference	VB
18637	8086	20	.	.	.
18637	8087	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8087	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8087	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8087	4	Yet	yet	CC
18637	8087	5	if	if	IN
18637	8087	6	the	the	DT
18637	8087	7	President	President	NNP
18637	8087	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	8087	9	the	the	DT
18637	8087	10	power	power	NN
18637	8087	11	to	to	TO
18637	8087	12	channel	channel	VB
18637	8087	13	raw	raw	JJ
18637	8087	14	materials	material	NNS
18637	8087	15	into	into	IN
18637	8087	16	the	the	DT
18637	8087	17	most	most	RBS
18637	8087	18	efficient	efficient	JJ
18637	8087	19	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	8087	20	units	unit	NNS
18637	8087	21	and	and	CC
18637	8087	22	thus	thus	RB
18637	8087	23	save	save	VB
18637	8087	24	scarce	scarce	JJ
18637	8087	25	materials	material	NNS
18637	8087	26	from	from	IN
18637	8087	27	wastage	wastage	NN
18637	8087	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8087	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	8087	30	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	8087	31	to	to	TO
18637	8087	32	see	see	VB
18637	8087	33	why	why	WRB
18637	8087	34	the	the	DT
18637	8087	35	same	same	JJ
18637	8087	36	principle	principle	NN
18637	8087	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	8087	38	not	not	RB
18637	8087	39	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	8087	40	to	to	IN
18637	8087	41	the	the	DT
18637	8087	42	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	8087	43	of	of	IN
18637	8087	44	fuel	fuel	NN
18637	8087	45	oil	oil	NN
18637	8087	46	.	.	.
18637	8088	1	"	"	``
18637	8088	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8088	3	75	75	CD
18637	8088	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8088	5	Sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	8088	6	were	be	VBD
18637	8088	7	,	,	,
18637	8088	8	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8088	9	,	,	,
18637	8088	10	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8088	11	when	when	WRB
18637	8088	12	the	the	DT
18637	8088	13	deprivations	deprivation	NNS
18637	8088	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8088	15	wrought	work	VBD
18637	8088	16	were	be	VBD
18637	8088	17	a	a	DT
18637	8088	18	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	8088	19	implied	imply	VBN
18637	8088	20	amplification	amplification	NN
18637	8088	21	of	of	IN
18637	8088	22	the	the	DT
18637	8088	23	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	8088	24	power	power	NN
18637	8088	25	which	which	WDT
18637	8088	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8088	27	supported	support	VBD
18637	8088	28	and	and	CC
18637	8088	29	were	be	VBD
18637	8088	30	directly	directly	RB
18637	8088	31	conservative	conservative	JJ
18637	8088	32	of	of	IN
18637	8088	33	the	the	DT
18637	8088	34	interests	interest	NNS
18637	8088	35	which	which	WDT
18637	8088	36	this	this	DT
18637	8088	37	power	power	NN
18637	8088	38	was	be	VBD
18637	8088	39	created	create	VBN
18637	8088	40	to	to	TO
18637	8088	41	protect	protect	VB
18637	8088	42	and	and	CC
18637	8088	43	advance	advance	VB
18637	8088	44	.	.	.
18637	8089	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8089	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8089	3	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8089	4	,	,	,
18637	8089	5	however	however	RB
18637	8089	6	,	,	,
18637	8089	7	that	that	IN
18637	8089	8	sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	8089	9	not	not	RB
18637	8089	10	uncommonly	uncommonly	RB
18637	8089	11	exceeded	exceed	VBD
18637	8089	12	this	this	DT
18637	8089	13	pattern	pattern	NN
18637	8089	14	.	.	.
18637	8090	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8090	2	76	76	CD
18637	8090	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8090	4	MARTIAL	martial	NN
18637	8090	5	LAW	law	NN
18637	8090	6	AND	and	CC
18637	8090	7	CONSTITUTIONAL	constitutional	JJ
18637	8090	8	LIMITATIONS	limitation	NNS
18637	8090	9	Two	two	CD
18637	8090	10	theories	theory	NNS
18637	8090	11	of	of	IN
18637	8090	12	martial	martial	JJ
18637	8090	13	law	law	NN
18637	8090	14	are	be	VBP
18637	8090	15	reflected	reflect	VBN
18637	8090	16	in	in	IN
18637	8090	17	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	8090	18	of	of	IN
18637	8090	19	the	the	DT
18637	8090	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8090	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8090	22	.	.	.
18637	8091	1	By	by	IN
18637	8091	2	one	one	CD
18637	8091	3	,	,	,
18637	8091	4	which	which	WDT
18637	8091	5	stems	stem	VBZ
18637	8091	6	from	from	IN
18637	8091	7	the	the	DT
18637	8091	8	Petition	Petition	NNP
18637	8091	9	of	of	IN
18637	8091	10	Right	Right	NNP
18637	8091	11	,	,	,
18637	8091	12	1628	1628	CD
18637	8091	13	,	,	,
18637	8091	14	the	the	DT
18637	8091	15	common	common	JJ
18637	8091	16	law	law	NN
18637	8091	17	knows	know	VBZ
18637	8091	18	no	no	DT
18637	8091	19	such	such	JJ
18637	8091	20	thing	thing	NN
18637	8091	21	as	as	IN
18637	8091	22	martial	martial	JJ
18637	8091	23	law;[77	law;[77	NNP
18637	8091	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8091	25	at	at	IN
18637	8091	26	any	any	DT
18637	8091	27	rate	rate	NN
18637	8091	28	martial	martial	JJ
18637	8091	29	law	law	NN
18637	8091	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	8091	31	not	not	RB
18637	8091	32	established	establish	VBN
18637	8091	33	by	by	IN
18637	8091	34	official	official	JJ
18637	8091	35	authority	authority	NN
18637	8091	36	of	of	IN
18637	8091	37	any	any	DT
18637	8091	38	sort	sort	NN
18637	8091	39	,	,	,
18637	8091	40	but	but	CC
18637	8091	41	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	8091	42	from	from	IN
18637	8091	43	the	the	DT
18637	8091	44	nature	nature	NN
18637	8091	45	of	of	IN
18637	8091	46	things	thing	NNS
18637	8091	47	,	,	,
18637	8091	48	being	be	VBG
18637	8091	49	the	the	DT
18637	8091	50	law	law	NN
18637	8091	51	of	of	IN
18637	8091	52	paramount	paramount	JJ
18637	8091	53	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	8091	54	,	,	,
18637	8091	55	of	of	IN
18637	8091	56	which	which	WDT
18637	8091	57	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	8091	58	the	the	DT
18637	8091	59	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8091	60	courts	court	NNS
18637	8091	61	are	be	VBP
18637	8091	62	the	the	DT
18637	8091	63	final	final	JJ
18637	8091	64	judges	judge	NNS
18637	8091	65	.	.	.
18637	8092	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8092	2	78	78	CD
18637	8092	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8092	4	By	by	IN
18637	8092	5	the	the	DT
18637	8092	6	other	other	JJ
18637	8092	7	theory	theory	NN
18637	8092	8	,	,	,
18637	8092	9	martial	martial	JJ
18637	8092	10	law	law	NN
18637	8092	11	can	can	MD
18637	8092	12	be	be	VB
18637	8092	13	validly	validly	RB
18637	8092	14	and	and	CC
18637	8092	15	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	8092	16	established	establish	VBN
18637	8092	17	by	by	IN
18637	8092	18	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	8092	19	political	political	NNP
18637	8092	20	authority	authority	NN
18637	8092	21	in	in	IN
18637	8092	22	wartime	wartime	NN
18637	8092	23	.	.	.
18637	8093	1	The	the	DT
18637	8093	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	8093	3	theory	theory	NN
18637	8093	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	8093	5	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	8093	6	by	by	IN
18637	8093	7	the	the	DT
18637	8093	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8093	9	in	in	IN
18637	8093	10	Luther	Luther	NNP
18637	8093	11	_	_	NNP
18637	8093	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	8093	13	_	_	NNP
18637	8093	14	Borden,[79	Borden,[79	NNP
18637	8093	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8093	16	where	where	WRB
18637	8093	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8093	18	was	be	VBD
18637	8093	19	held	hold	VBN
18637	8093	20	that	that	IN
18637	8093	21	the	the	DT
18637	8093	22	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	8093	23	Island	Island	NNP
18637	8093	24	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	8093	25	had	have	VBD
18637	8093	26	been	be	VBN
18637	8093	27	within	within	IN
18637	8093	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8093	29	rights	right	NNS
18637	8093	30	in	in	IN
18637	8093	31	1842	1842	CD
18637	8093	32	in	in	IN
18637	8093	33	resorting	resort	VBG
18637	8093	34	to	to	IN
18637	8093	35	the	the	DT
18637	8093	36	rights	right	NNS
18637	8093	37	and	and	CC
18637	8093	38	usages	usage	NNS
18637	8093	39	of	of	IN
18637	8093	40	war	war	NN
18637	8093	41	in	in	IN
18637	8093	42	combating	combat	VBG
18637	8093	43	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	8093	44	in	in	IN
18637	8093	45	that	that	DT
18637	8093	46	State	State	NNP
18637	8093	47	.	.	.
18637	8094	1	The	the	DT
18637	8094	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	8094	3	in	in	IN
18637	8094	4	the	the	DT
18637	8094	5	Prize	Prize	NNP
18637	8094	6	Cases,[80	Cases,[80	NNP
18637	8094	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8094	8	while	while	IN
18637	8094	9	not	not	RB
18637	8094	10	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	8094	11	directly	directly	RB
18637	8094	12	with	with	IN
18637	8094	13	the	the	DT
18637	8094	14	subject	subject	NN
18637	8094	15	of	of	IN
18637	8094	16	martial	martial	JJ
18637	8094	17	law	law	NN
18637	8094	18	,	,	,
18637	8094	19	gave	give	VBD
18637	8094	20	national	national	JJ
18637	8094	21	scope	scope	NN
18637	8094	22	to	to	IN
18637	8094	23	the	the	DT
18637	8094	24	same	same	JJ
18637	8094	25	general	general	JJ
18637	8094	26	principle	principle	NN
18637	8094	27	in	in	IN
18637	8094	28	1863	1863	CD
18637	8094	29	.	.	.
18637	8095	1	The	the	DT
18637	8095	2	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	8095	3	War	War	NNP
18637	8095	4	being	be	VBG
18637	8095	5	safely	safely	RB
18637	8095	6	over	over	RB
18637	8095	7	,	,	,
18637	8095	8	however	however	RB
18637	8095	9	,	,	,
18637	8095	10	a	a	DT
18637	8095	11	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	8095	12	divided	divide	VBN
18637	8095	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8095	14	,	,	,
18637	8095	15	in	in	IN
18637	8095	16	the	the	DT
18637	8095	17	elaborately	elaborately	RB
18637	8095	18	argued	argue	VBN
18637	8095	19	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
18637	8095	20	case,[81	case,[81	CD
18637	8095	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8095	22	reverting	revert	VBG
18637	8095	23	to	to	IN
18637	8095	24	the	the	DT
18637	8095	25	older	old	JJR
18637	8095	26	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	8095	27	,	,	,
18637	8095	28	pronounced	pronounce	VBD
18637	8095	29	void	void	JJ
18637	8095	30	President	President	NNP
18637	8095	31	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	8095	32	's	's	POS
18637	8095	33	action	action	NN
18637	8095	34	,	,	,
18637	8095	35	following	follow	VBG
18637	8095	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8095	37	suspension	suspension	NN
18637	8095	38	of	of	IN
18637	8095	39	the	the	DT
18637	8095	40	writ	writ	NNP
18637	8095	41	of	of	IN
18637	8095	42	_	_	NNP
18637	8095	43	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	8095	44	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	8095	45	_	_	NNP
18637	8095	46	in	in	IN
18637	8095	47	September	September	NNP
18637	8095	48	,	,	,
18637	8095	49	1863	1863	CD
18637	8095	50	,	,	,
18637	8095	51	in	in	IN
18637	8095	52	ordering	order	VBG
18637	8095	53	the	the	DT
18637	8095	54	trial	trial	NN
18637	8095	55	by	by	IN
18637	8095	56	military	military	NNP
18637	8095	57	commission	commission	NNP
18637	8095	58	of	of	IN
18637	8095	59	persons	person	NNS
18637	8095	60	held	hold	VBN
18637	8095	61	in	in	IN
18637	8095	62	custody	custody	NN
18637	8095	63	as	as	IN
18637	8095	64	"	"	``
18637	8095	65	spies	spy	NNS
18637	8095	66	"	"	''
18637	8095	67	and	and	CC
18637	8095	68	"	"	``
18637	8095	69	abettors	abettor	NNS
18637	8095	70	of	of	IN
18637	8095	71	the	the	DT
18637	8095	72	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	8095	73	.	.	.
18637	8095	74	"	"	''
18637	8096	1	The	the	DT
18637	8096	2	salient	salient	NN
18637	8096	3	passage	passage	NN
18637	8096	4	of	of	IN
18637	8096	5	the	the	DT
18637	8096	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8096	7	's	's	POS
18637	8096	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8096	9	bearing	bear	VBG
18637	8096	10	on	on	IN
18637	8096	11	this	this	DT
18637	8096	12	point	point	NN
18637	8096	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	8096	14	the	the	DT
18637	8096	15	following	follow	VBG
18637	8096	16	:	:	:
18637	8096	17	"	"	``
18637	8096	18	If	if	IN
18637	8096	19	,	,	,
18637	8096	20	in	in	IN
18637	8096	21	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8096	22	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	8096	23	or	or	CC
18637	8096	24	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8096	25	war	war	NN
18637	8096	26	,	,	,
18637	8096	27	the	the	DT
18637	8096	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	8096	29	are	be	VBP
18637	8096	30	actually	actually	RB
18637	8096	31	closed	closed	JJ
18637	8096	32	,	,	,
18637	8096	33	and	and	CC
18637	8096	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8096	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	8096	36	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	8096	37	to	to	TO
18637	8096	38	administer	administer	VB
18637	8096	39	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	8096	40	justice	justice	NN
18637	8096	41	according	accord	VBG
18637	8096	42	to	to	IN
18637	8096	43	law	law	NN
18637	8096	44	,	,	,
18637	8096	45	_	_	NNP
18637	8096	46	then	then	RB
18637	8096	47	_	_	NNP
18637	8096	48	,	,	,
18637	8096	49	on	on	IN
18637	8096	50	the	the	DT
18637	8096	51	theatre	theatre	NN
18637	8096	52	of	of	IN
18637	8096	53	active	active	JJ
18637	8096	54	military	military	JJ
18637	8096	55	operations	operation	NNS
18637	8096	56	,	,	,
18637	8096	57	where	where	WRB
18637	8096	58	war	war	NN
18637	8096	59	really	really	RB
18637	8096	60	prevails	prevail	VBZ
18637	8096	61	,	,	,
18637	8096	62	there	there	EX
18637	8096	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	8096	64	a	a	DT
18637	8096	65	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	8096	66	to	to	TO
18637	8096	67	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	8096	68	a	a	DT
18637	8096	69	substitute	substitute	NN
18637	8096	70	for	for	IN
18637	8096	71	the	the	DT
18637	8096	72	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8096	73	authority	authority	NN
18637	8096	74	,	,	,
18637	8096	75	thus	thus	RB
18637	8096	76	overthrown	overthrow	VBN
18637	8096	77	,	,	,
18637	8096	78	to	to	TO
18637	8096	79	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	8096	80	the	the	DT
18637	8096	81	safety	safety	NN
18637	8096	82	of	of	IN
18637	8096	83	the	the	DT
18637	8096	84	army	army	NN
18637	8096	85	and	and	CC
18637	8096	86	society	society	NN
18637	8096	87	;	;	:
18637	8096	88	and	and	CC
18637	8096	89	as	as	IN
18637	8096	90	no	no	DT
18637	8096	91	power	power	NN
18637	8096	92	is	be	VBZ
18637	8096	93	left	leave	VBN
18637	8096	94	but	but	CC
18637	8096	95	the	the	DT
18637	8096	96	military	military	NN
18637	8096	97	,	,	,
18637	8096	98	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8096	99	is	be	VBZ
18637	8096	100	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	8096	101	to	to	TO
18637	8096	102	govern	govern	VB
18637	8096	103	by	by	IN
18637	8096	104	martial	martial	JJ
18637	8096	105	rule	rule	NN
18637	8096	106	until	until	IN
18637	8096	107	the	the	DT
18637	8096	108	laws	law	NNS
18637	8096	109	can	can	MD
18637	8096	110	have	have	VB
18637	8096	111	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8096	112	free	free	JJ
18637	8096	113	course	course	NN
18637	8096	114	.	.	.
18637	8097	1	As	as	IN
18637	8097	2	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	8097	3	creates	create	VBZ
18637	8097	4	the	the	DT
18637	8097	5	rule	rule	NN
18637	8097	6	,	,	,
18637	8097	7	so	so	IN
18637	8097	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8097	9	limits	limit	VBZ
18637	8097	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8097	11	duration	duration	NN
18637	8097	12	;	;	,
18637	8097	13	for	for	IN
18637	8097	14	,	,	,
18637	8097	15	if	if	IN
18637	8097	16	this	this	DT
18637	8097	17	government	government	NN
18637	8097	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	8097	19	continued	continue	VBN
18637	8097	20	_	_	NNP
18637	8097	21	after	after	IN
18637	8097	22	_	_	NNP
18637	8097	23	the	the	DT
18637	8097	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	8097	25	are	be	VBP
18637	8097	26	reinstated	reinstate	VBN
18637	8097	27	,	,	,
18637	8097	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8097	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	8097	30	a	a	DT
18637	8097	31	gross	gross	JJ
18637	8097	32	usurpation	usurpation	NN
18637	8097	33	of	of	IN
18637	8097	34	power	power	NN
18637	8097	35	.	.	.
18637	8098	1	Martial	martial	JJ
18637	8098	2	rule	rule	NN
18637	8098	3	can	can	MD
18637	8098	4	never	never	RB
18637	8098	5	exist	exist	VB
18637	8098	6	where	where	WRB
18637	8098	7	the	the	DT
18637	8098	8	courts	court	NNS
18637	8098	9	are	be	VBP
18637	8098	10	open	open	JJ
18637	8098	11	,	,	,
18637	8098	12	and	and	CC
18637	8098	13	in	in	IN
18637	8098	14	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8098	15	and	and	CC
18637	8098	16	unobstructed	unobstructed	JJ
18637	8098	17	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	8098	18	of	of	IN
18637	8098	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8098	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	8098	21	.	.	.
18637	8099	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8099	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8099	3	also	also	RB
18637	8099	4	confined	confine	VBN
18637	8099	5	to	to	IN
18637	8099	6	the	the	DT
18637	8099	7	locality	locality	NN
18637	8099	8	of	of	IN
18637	8099	9	actual	actual	JJ
18637	8099	10	war	war	NN
18637	8099	11	.	.	.
18637	8100	1	"	"	``
18637	8100	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8100	3	82	82	CD
18637	8100	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8100	5	Four	four	CD
18637	8100	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	8100	7	,	,	,
18637	8100	8	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8100	9	by	by	IN
18637	8100	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8100	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8100	12	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	8100	13	,	,	,
18637	8100	14	while	while	IN
18637	8100	15	holding	hold	VBG
18637	8100	16	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
18637	8100	17	's	's	POS
18637	8100	18	trial	trial	NN
18637	8100	19	to	to	TO
18637	8100	20	have	have	VB
18637	8100	21	been	be	VBN
18637	8100	22	void	void	JJ
18637	8100	23	because	because	IN
18637	8100	24	violative	violative	JJ
18637	8100	25	of	of	IN
18637	8100	26	the	the	DT
18637	8100	27	act	act	NN
18637	8100	28	of	of	IN
18637	8100	29	March	March	NNP
18637	8100	30	3	3	CD
18637	8100	31	,	,	,
18637	8100	32	1863	1863	CD
18637	8100	33	governing	govern	VBG
18637	8100	34	the	the	DT
18637	8100	35	custody	custody	NN
18637	8100	36	and	and	CC
18637	8100	37	trial	trial	NN
18637	8100	38	of	of	IN
18637	8100	39	persons	person	NNS
18637	8100	40	who	who	WP
18637	8100	41	had	have	VBD
18637	8100	42	been	be	VBN
18637	8100	43	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	8100	44	of	of	IN
18637	8100	45	the	the	DT
18637	8100	46	_	_	NNP
18637	8100	47	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	8100	48	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	8100	49	_	_	NNP
18637	8100	50	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	8100	51	,	,	,
18637	8100	52	declared	declare	VBD
18637	8100	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8100	54	belief	belief	NN
18637	8100	55	that	that	IN
18637	8100	56	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8100	57	could	could	MD
18637	8100	58	have	have	VB
18637	8100	59	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8100	60	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
18637	8100	61	's	's	POS
18637	8100	62	trial	trial	NN
18637	8100	63	.	.	.
18637	8101	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	8101	2	the	the	DT
18637	8101	3	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8101	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8101	5	:	:	:
18637	8101	6	"	"	``
18637	8101	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8101	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	8101	9	the	the	DT
18637	8101	10	power	power	NN
18637	8101	11	not	not	RB
18637	8101	12	only	only	RB
18637	8101	13	to	to	TO
18637	8101	14	raise	raise	VB
18637	8101	15	and	and	CC
18637	8101	16	support	support	VB
18637	8101	17	and	and	CC
18637	8101	18	govern	govern	VBP
18637	8101	19	armies	army	NNS
18637	8101	20	but	but	CC
18637	8101	21	to	to	TO
18637	8101	22	declare	declare	VB
18637	8101	23	war	war	NN
18637	8101	24	.	.	.
18637	8102	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8102	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	8102	3	,	,	,
18637	8102	4	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8102	5	,	,	,
18637	8102	6	the	the	DT
18637	8102	7	power	power	NN
18637	8102	8	to	to	TO
18637	8102	9	provide	provide	VB
18637	8102	10	by	by	IN
18637	8102	11	law	law	NN
18637	8102	12	for	for	IN
18637	8102	13	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	8102	14	on	on	IN
18637	8102	15	war	war	NN
18637	8102	16	.	.	.
18637	8103	1	This	this	DT
18637	8103	2	power	power	NN
18637	8103	3	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	8103	4	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	8103	5	to	to	IN
18637	8103	6	all	all	DT
18637	8103	7	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8103	8	essential	essential	JJ
18637	8103	9	to	to	IN
18637	8103	10	the	the	DT
18637	8103	11	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	8103	12	of	of	IN
18637	8103	13	war	war	NN
18637	8103	14	with	with	IN
18637	8103	15	vigor	vigor	NN
18637	8103	16	and	and	CC
18637	8103	17	success	success	NN
18637	8103	18	,	,	,
18637	8103	19	except	except	IN
18637	8103	20	such	such	JJ
18637	8103	21	as	as	IN
18637	8103	22	interferes	interfere	NNS
18637	8103	23	with	with	IN
18637	8103	24	the	the	DT
18637	8103	25	command	command	NN
18637	8103	26	of	of	IN
18637	8103	27	the	the	DT
18637	8103	28	forces	force	NNS
18637	8103	29	and	and	CC
18637	8103	30	the	the	DT
18637	8103	31	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	8103	32	of	of	IN
18637	8103	33	campaigns	campaign	NNS
18637	8103	34	.	.	.
18637	8104	1	That	that	DT
18637	8104	2	power	power	NN
18637	8104	3	and	and	CC
18637	8104	4	duty	duty	NN
18637	8104	5	belong	belong	VBP
18637	8104	6	to	to	IN
18637	8104	7	the	the	DT
18637	8104	8	President	President	NNP
18637	8104	9	as	as	IN
18637	8104	10	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8104	11	in	in	IN
18637	8104	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8104	13	.	.	.
18637	8105	1	Both	both	DT
18637	8105	2	these	these	DT
18637	8105	3	powers	power	NNS
18637	8105	4	are	be	VBP
18637	8105	5	derived	derive	VBN
18637	8105	6	from	from	IN
18637	8105	7	the	the	DT
18637	8105	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8105	9	,	,	,
18637	8105	10	but	but	CC
18637	8105	11	neither	neither	DT
18637	8105	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	8105	13	defined	define	VBN
18637	8105	14	by	by	IN
18637	8105	15	that	that	DT
18637	8105	16	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	8105	17	.	.	.
18637	8106	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8106	2	extent	extent	NN
18637	8106	3	must	must	MD
18637	8106	4	be	be	VB
18637	8106	5	determined	determine	VBN
18637	8106	6	by	by	IN
18637	8106	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8106	8	nature	nature	NN
18637	8106	9	,	,	,
18637	8106	10	and	and	CC
18637	8106	11	by	by	IN
18637	8106	12	the	the	DT
18637	8106	13	principles	principle	NNS
18637	8106	14	of	of	IN
18637	8106	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8106	16	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	8106	17	.	.	.
18637	8107	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8107	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8107	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8107	4	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8107	5	by	by	IN
18637	8107	6	no	no	DT
18637	8107	7	means	means	NN
18637	8107	8	assert	assert	NN
18637	8107	9	that	that	IN
18637	8107	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8107	11	can	can	MD
18637	8107	12	establish	establish	VB
18637	8107	13	and	and	CC
18637	8107	14	apply	apply	VB
18637	8107	15	the	the	DT
18637	8107	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	8107	17	of	of	IN
18637	8107	18	war	war	NN
18637	8107	19	where	where	WRB
18637	8107	20	no	no	DT
18637	8107	21	war	war	NN
18637	8107	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	8107	23	been	be	VBN
18637	8107	24	declared	declare	VBN
18637	8107	25	or	or	CC
18637	8107	26	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	8107	27	.	.	.
18637	8108	1	Where	where	WRB
18637	8108	2	peace	peace	NN
18637	8108	3	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	8108	4	the	the	DT
18637	8108	5	laws	law	NNS
18637	8108	6	of	of	IN
18637	8108	7	peace	peace	NN
18637	8108	8	must	must	MD
18637	8108	9	prevail	prevail	VB
18637	8108	10	.	.	.
18637	8109	1	What	what	WP
18637	8109	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8109	3	do	do	VBP
18637	8109	4	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	8109	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	8109	6	,	,	,
18637	8109	7	that	that	IN
18637	8109	8	when	when	WRB
18637	8109	9	the	the	DT
18637	8109	10	nation	nation	NN
18637	8109	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	8109	12	involved	involve	VBN
18637	8109	13	in	in	IN
18637	8109	14	war	war	NN
18637	8109	15	,	,	,
18637	8109	16	and	and	CC
18637	8109	17	some	some	DT
18637	8109	18	portions	portion	NNS
18637	8109	19	of	of	IN
18637	8109	20	the	the	DT
18637	8109	21	country	country	NN
18637	8109	22	are	be	VBP
18637	8109	23	invaded	invade	VBN
18637	8109	24	,	,	,
18637	8109	25	and	and	CC
18637	8109	26	all	all	DT
18637	8109	27	are	be	VBP
18637	8109	28	exposed	expose	VBN
18637	8109	29	to	to	IN
18637	8109	30	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	8109	31	,	,	,
18637	8109	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8109	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	8109	34	within	within	IN
18637	8109	35	the	the	DT
18637	8109	36	power	power	NN
18637	8109	37	of	of	IN
18637	8109	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8109	39	to	to	TO
18637	8109	40	determine	determine	VB
18637	8109	41	in	in	IN
18637	8109	42	what	what	WP
18637	8109	43	States	States	NNPS
18637	8109	44	or	or	CC
18637	8109	45	districts	district	NNS
18637	8109	46	such	such	JJ
18637	8109	47	great	great	JJ
18637	8109	48	and	and	CC
18637	8109	49	imminent	imminent	JJ
18637	8109	50	public	public	JJ
18637	8109	51	danger	danger	NN
18637	8109	52	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	8109	53	as	as	IN
18637	8109	54	justifies	justifie	NNS
18637	8109	55	the	the	DT
18637	8109	56	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	8109	57	of	of	IN
18637	8109	58	military	military	JJ
18637	8109	59	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	8109	60	for	for	IN
18637	8109	61	the	the	DT
18637	8109	62	trial	trial	NN
18637	8109	63	of	of	IN
18637	8109	64	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	8109	65	and	and	CC
18637	8109	66	offences	offence	NNS
18637	8109	67	against	against	IN
18637	8109	68	the	the	DT
18637	8109	69	discipline	discipline	NN
18637	8109	70	or	or	CC
18637	8109	71	security	security	NN
18637	8109	72	of	of	IN
18637	8109	73	the	the	DT
18637	8109	74	army	army	NN
18637	8109	75	or	or	CC
18637	8109	76	against	against	IN
18637	8109	77	the	the	DT
18637	8109	78	public	public	JJ
18637	8109	79	safety	safety	NN
18637	8109	80	.	.	.
18637	8110	1	"	"	``
18637	8110	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8110	3	83	83	CD
18637	8110	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8110	5	In	in	IN
18637	8110	6	short	short	JJ
18637	8110	7	,	,	,
18637	8110	8	only	only	RB
18637	8110	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8110	10	can	can	MD
18637	8110	11	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	8110	12	the	the	DT
18637	8110	13	substitution	substitution	NN
18637	8110	14	of	of	IN
18637	8110	15	military	military	JJ
18637	8110	16	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	8110	17	for	for	IN
18637	8110	18	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8110	19	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	8110	20	for	for	IN
18637	8110	21	the	the	DT
18637	8110	22	trial	trial	NN
18637	8110	23	of	of	IN
18637	8110	24	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	8110	25	;	;	,
18637	8110	26	and	and	CC
18637	8110	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8110	28	can	can	MD
18637	8110	29	do	do	VB
18637	8110	30	so	so	RB
18637	8110	31	only	only	RB
18637	8110	32	in	in	IN
18637	8110	33	wartime	wartime	NN
18637	8110	34	.	.	.
18637	8111	1	MARTIAL	MARTIAL	NNP
18637	8111	2	LAW	law	NN
18637	8111	3	IN	in	IN
18637	8111	4	HAWAII	HAWAII	NNP
18637	8111	5	The	the	DT
18637	8111	6	question	question	NN
18637	8111	7	of	of	IN
18637	8111	8	the	the	DT
18637	8111	9	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8111	10	status	status	NN
18637	8111	11	of	of	IN
18637	8111	12	martial	martial	JJ
18637	8111	13	law	law	NN
18637	8111	14	was	be	VBD
18637	8111	15	raised	raise	VBN
18637	8111	16	in	in	IN
18637	8111	17	World	World	NNP
18637	8111	18	War	War	NNP
18637	8111	19	II	II	NNP
18637	8111	20	by	by	IN
18637	8111	21	the	the	DT
18637	8111	22	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	8111	23	of	of	IN
18637	8111	24	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	8111	25	Poindexter	Poindexter	NNP
18637	8111	26	of	of	IN
18637	8111	27	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	8111	28	,	,	,
18637	8111	29	on	on	IN
18637	8111	30	December	December	NNP
18637	8111	31	7	7	CD
18637	8111	32	,	,	,
18637	8111	33	1941	1941	CD
18637	8111	34	,	,	,
18637	8111	35	suspending	suspend	VBG
18637	8111	36	the	the	DT
18637	8111	37	writ	writ	NNP
18637	8111	38	of	of	IN
18637	8111	39	_	_	NNP
18637	8111	40	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	8111	41	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	8111	42	_	_	NNP
18637	8111	43	and	and	CC
18637	8111	44	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	8111	45	on	on	IN
18637	8111	46	the	the	DT
18637	8111	47	local	local	JJ
18637	8111	48	commanding	command	VBG
18637	8111	49	General	General	NNP
18637	8111	50	of	of	IN
18637	8111	51	the	the	DT
18637	8111	52	Army	Army	NNP
18637	8111	53	all	all	PDT
18637	8111	54	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8111	55	own	own	JJ
18637	8111	56	powers	power	NNS
18637	8111	57	as	as	IN
18637	8111	58	governor	governor	NN
18637	8111	59	and	and	CC
18637	8111	60	also	also	RB
18637	8111	61	"	"	``
18637	8111	62	all	all	DT
18637	8111	63	of	of	IN
18637	8111	64	the	the	DT
18637	8111	65	powers	power	NNS
18637	8111	66	normally	normally	RB
18637	8111	67	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	8111	68	by	by	IN
18637	8111	69	the	the	DT
18637	8111	70	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8111	71	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8111	72	*	*	NFP
18637	8111	73	*	*	NFP
18637	8111	74	*	*	NFP
18637	8111	75	of	of	IN
18637	8111	76	this	this	DT
18637	8111	77	territory	territory	NN
18637	8111	78	*	*	NFP
18637	8111	79	*	*	NFP
18637	8111	80	*	*	NFP
18637	8111	81	during	during	IN
18637	8111	82	the	the	DT
18637	8111	83	present	present	JJ
18637	8111	84	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	8111	85	and	and	CC
18637	8111	86	until	until	IN
18637	8111	87	the	the	DT
18637	8111	88	danger	danger	NN
18637	8111	89	of	of	IN
18637	8111	90	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	8111	91	is	be	VBZ
18637	8111	92	removed	remove	VBN
18637	8111	93	.	.	.
18637	8111	94	"	"	''
18637	8112	1	Two	two	CD
18637	8112	2	days	day	NNS
18637	8112	3	later	later	RBR
18637	8112	4	the	the	DT
18637	8112	5	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	8112	6	's	's	POS
18637	8112	7	action	action	NN
18637	8112	8	was	be	VBD
18637	8112	9	approved	approve	VBN
18637	8112	10	by	by	IN
18637	8112	11	President	President	NNP
18637	8112	12	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8112	13	.	.	.
18637	8113	1	The	the	DT
18637	8113	2	regime	regime	NN
18637	8113	3	which	which	WDT
18637	8113	4	the	the	DT
18637	8113	5	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	8113	6	set	set	VBD
18637	8113	7	up	up	RP
18637	8113	8	continued	continued	JJ
18637	8113	9	with	with	IN
18637	8113	10	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8113	11	abatements	abatement	NNS
18637	8113	12	until	until	IN
18637	8113	13	October	October	NNP
18637	8113	14	24	24	CD
18637	8113	15	,	,	,
18637	8113	16	1944	1944	CD
18637	8113	17	.	.	.
18637	8114	1	By	by	IN
18637	8114	2	section	section	NN
18637	8114	3	67	67	CD
18637	8114	4	of	of	IN
18637	8114	5	the	the	DT
18637	8114	6	Organic	Organic	NNP
18637	8114	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8114	8	of	of	IN
18637	8114	9	April	April	NNP
18637	8114	10	30	30	CD
18637	8114	11	,	,	,
18637	8114	12	1900,[84	1900,[84	CD
18637	8114	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8114	14	the	the	DT
18637	8114	15	Territorial	Territorial	NNP
18637	8114	16	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	8114	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	8114	18	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8114	19	"	"	''
18637	8114	20	in	in	IN
18637	8114	21	case	case	NN
18637	8114	22	of	of	IN
18637	8114	23	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	8114	24	or	or	CC
18637	8114	25	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	8114	26	,	,	,
18637	8114	27	or	or	CC
18637	8114	28	imminent	imminent	JJ
18637	8114	29	danger	danger	NN
18637	8114	30	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8114	31	,	,	,
18637	8114	32	when	when	WRB
18637	8114	33	the	the	DT
18637	8114	34	public	public	JJ
18637	8114	35	safety	safety	NN
18637	8114	36	requires	require	VBZ
18637	8114	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8114	38	,	,	,
18637	8114	39	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8114	40	to	to	TO
18637	8114	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8114	42	suspend	suspend	VB
18637	8114	43	the	the	DT
18637	8114	44	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	8114	45	of	of	IN
18637	8114	46	the	the	DT
18637	8114	47	writ	writ	NNP
18637	8114	48	of	of	IN
18637	8114	49	_	_	NNP
18637	8114	50	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	8114	51	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	8114	52	_	_	NNP
18637	8114	53	,	,	,
18637	8114	54	or	or	CC
18637	8114	55	place	place	VB
18637	8114	56	the	the	DT
18637	8114	57	Territory	territory	NN
18637	8114	58	,	,	,
18637	8114	59	or	or	CC
18637	8114	60	any	any	DT
18637	8114	61	part	part	NN
18637	8114	62	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8114	63	,	,	,
18637	8114	64	under	under	IN
18637	8114	65	martial	martial	JJ
18637	8114	66	law	law	NN
18637	8114	67	until	until	IN
18637	8114	68	communication	communication	NN
18637	8114	69	can	can	MD
18637	8114	70	be	be	VB
18637	8114	71	had	have	VBN
18637	8114	72	with	with	IN
18637	8114	73	the	the	DT
18637	8114	74	President	President	NNP
18637	8114	75	and	and	CC
18637	8114	76	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8114	77	decision	decision	NN
18637	8114	78	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	8114	79	made	make	VBN
18637	8114	80	known	known	JJ
18637	8114	81	.	.	.
18637	8114	82	"	"	''
18637	8115	1	By	by	IN
18637	8115	2	section	section	NN
18637	8115	3	5	5	CD
18637	8115	4	of	of	IN
18637	8115	5	the	the	DT
18637	8115	6	Organic	Organic	NNP
18637	8115	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8115	8	,	,	,
18637	8115	9	"	"	''
18637	8115	10	the	the	DT
18637	8115	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8115	12	,	,	,
18637	8115	13	*	*	NFP
18637	8115	14	*	*	NFP
18637	8115	15	*	*	NFP
18637	8115	16	,	,	,
18637	8115	17	shall	shall	MD
18637	8115	18	have	have	VB
18637	8115	19	the	the	DT
18637	8115	20	same	same	JJ
18637	8115	21	force	force	NN
18637	8115	22	and	and	CC
18637	8115	23	effect	effect	NN
18637	8115	24	within	within	IN
18637	8115	25	the	the	DT
18637	8115	26	said	say	VBN
18637	8115	27	Territory	territory	NN
18637	8115	28	as	as	RB
18637	8115	29	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	8115	30	in	in	IN
18637	8115	31	the	the	DT
18637	8115	32	United	United	NNP
18637	8115	33	States	States	NNP
18637	8115	34	.	.	.
18637	8115	35	"	"	''
18637	8116	1	In	in	IN
18637	8116	2	a	a	DT
18637	8116	3	brace	brace	NN
18637	8116	4	of	of	IN
18637	8116	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	8116	6	which	which	WDT
18637	8116	7	reached	reach	VBD
18637	8116	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8116	9	in	in	IN
18637	8116	10	February	February	NNP
18637	8116	11	1945	1945	CD
18637	8116	12	but	but	CC
18637	8116	13	which	which	WDT
18637	8116	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8116	15	contrived	contrive	VBD
18637	8116	16	to	to	TO
18637	8116	17	postpone	postpone	VB
18637	8116	18	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	8116	19	till	till	IN
18637	8116	20	February	February	NNP
18637	8116	21	1946,[85	1946,[85	CD
18637	8116	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8116	23	the	the	DT
18637	8116	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8116	25	,	,	,
18637	8116	26	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8116	27	by	by	IN
18637	8116	28	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8116	29	Black	Black	NNP
18637	8116	30	,	,	,
18637	8116	31	held	hold	VBD
18637	8116	32	that	that	IN
18637	8116	33	the	the	DT
18637	8116	34	term	term	NN
18637	8116	35	"	"	``
18637	8116	36	martial	martial	JJ
18637	8116	37	law	law	NN
18637	8116	38	"	"	''
18637	8116	39	as	as	IN
18637	8116	40	employed	employ	VBN
18637	8116	41	in	in	IN
18637	8116	42	the	the	DT
18637	8116	43	Organic	Organic	NNP
18637	8116	44	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8116	45	,	,	,
18637	8116	46	"	"	''
18637	8116	47	while	while	IN
18637	8116	48	intended	intend	VBN
18637	8116	49	to	to	TO
18637	8116	50	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	8116	51	the	the	DT
18637	8116	52	military	military	NN
18637	8116	53	to	to	TO
18637	8116	54	act	act	VB
18637	8116	55	vigorously	vigorously	RB
18637	8116	56	for	for	IN
18637	8116	57	the	the	DT
18637	8116	58	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	8116	59	of	of	IN
18637	8116	60	an	an	DT
18637	8116	61	orderly	orderly	JJ
18637	8116	62	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8116	63	government	government	NN
18637	8116	64	and	and	CC
18637	8116	65	for	for	IN
18637	8116	66	the	the	DT
18637	8116	67	defense	defense	NN
18637	8116	68	of	of	IN
18637	8116	69	the	the	DT
18637	8116	70	Islands	Islands	NNPS
18637	8116	71	against	against	IN
18637	8116	72	actual	actual	JJ
18637	8116	73	or	or	CC
18637	8116	74	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	8116	75	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	8116	76	or	or	CC
18637	8116	77	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	8116	78	,	,	,
18637	8116	79	was	be	VBD
18637	8116	80	not	not	RB
18637	8116	81	intended	intend	VBN
18637	8116	82	to	to	TO
18637	8116	83	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	8116	84	the	the	DT
18637	8116	85	supplanting	supplanting	NN
18637	8116	86	of	of	IN
18637	8116	87	courts	court	NNS
18637	8116	88	by	by	IN
18637	8116	89	military	military	JJ
18637	8116	90	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	8116	91	.	.	.
18637	8117	1	"	"	``
18637	8117	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8117	3	86	86	CD
18637	8117	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8117	5	The	the	DT
18637	8117	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8117	7	relied	rely	VBD
18637	8117	8	on	on	IN
18637	8117	9	the	the	DT
18637	8117	10	majority	majority	NN
18637	8117	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8117	12	in	in	IN
18637	8117	13	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	8117	14	parte	parte	NN
18637	8117	15	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
18637	8117	16	.	.	.
18637	8118	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8118	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8118	3	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	8118	4	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	8118	5	in	in	IN
18637	8118	6	the	the	DT
18637	8118	7	result	result	NN
18637	8118	8	.	.	.
18637	8119	1	"	"	``
18637	8119	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8119	3	assume	assume	VBP
18637	8119	4	also	also	RB
18637	8119	5	,	,	,
18637	8119	6	"	"	''
18637	8119	7	said	say	VBD
18637	8119	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8119	9	,	,	,
18637	8119	10	"	"	``
18637	8119	11	that	that	IN
18637	8119	12	there	there	EX
18637	8119	13	could	could	MD
18637	8119	14	be	be	VB
18637	8119	15	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	8119	16	in	in	IN
18637	8119	17	which	which	WDT
18637	8119	18	the	the	DT
18637	8119	19	public	public	JJ
18637	8119	20	safety	safety	NN
18637	8119	21	requires	require	VBZ
18637	8119	22	,	,	,
18637	8119	23	and	and	CC
18637	8119	24	the	the	DT
18637	8119	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8119	26	permits	permit	VBZ
18637	8119	27	,	,	,
18637	8119	28	substitution	substitution	NN
18637	8119	29	of	of	IN
18637	8119	30	trials	trial	NNS
18637	8119	31	by	by	IN
18637	8119	32	military	military	JJ
18637	8119	33	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	8119	34	for	for	IN
18637	8119	35	trials	trial	NNS
18637	8119	36	in	in	IN
18637	8119	37	the	the	DT
18637	8119	38	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8119	39	courts";[87	courts";[87	NN
18637	8119	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8119	41	but	but	CC
18637	8119	42	added	add	VBD
18637	8119	43	that	that	IN
18637	8119	44	the	the	DT
18637	8119	45	military	military	JJ
18637	8119	46	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	8119	47	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8119	48	had	have	VBD
18637	8119	49	failed	fail	VBN
18637	8119	50	to	to	TO
18637	8119	51	show	show	VB
18637	8119	52	justifying	justifying	NN
18637	8119	53	facts	fact	NNS
18637	8119	54	in	in	IN
18637	8119	55	this	this	DT
18637	8119	56	instance	instance	NN
18637	8119	57	.	.	.
18637	8120	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8120	2	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	8120	3	,	,	,
18637	8120	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8120	5	for	for	IN
18637	8120	6	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8120	7	and	and	CC
18637	8120	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8120	9	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	8120	10	,	,	,
18637	8120	11	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	8120	12	.	.	.
18637	8121	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8121	2	stressed	stress	VBD
18637	8121	3	the	the	DT
18637	8121	4	importance	importance	NN
18637	8121	5	of	of	IN
18637	8121	6	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	8121	7	as	as	IN
18637	8121	8	a	a	DT
18637	8121	9	military	military	JJ
18637	8121	10	outpost	outpost	NN
18637	8121	11	and	and	CC
18637	8121	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8121	13	constant	constant	JJ
18637	8121	14	exposure	exposure	NN
18637	8121	15	to	to	IN
18637	8121	16	the	the	DT
18637	8121	17	danger	danger	NN
18637	8121	18	of	of	IN
18637	8121	19	fresh	fresh	JJ
18637	8121	20	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	8121	21	.	.	.
18637	8122	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8122	2	warned	warn	VBD
18637	8122	3	that	that	IN
18637	8122	4	"	"	``
18637	8122	5	courts	court	NNS
18637	8122	6	must	must	MD
18637	8122	7	guard	guard	VB
18637	8122	8	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8122	9	with	with	IN
18637	8122	10	special	special	JJ
18637	8122	11	care	care	NN
18637	8122	12	against	against	IN
18637	8122	13	judging	judge	VBG
18637	8122	14	past	past	JJ
18637	8122	15	military	military	JJ
18637	8122	16	action	action	NN
18637	8122	17	too	too	RB
18637	8122	18	closely	closely	RB
18637	8122	19	by	by	IN
18637	8122	20	the	the	DT
18637	8122	21	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	8122	22	standards	standard	NNS
18637	8122	23	of	of	IN
18637	8122	24	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8122	25	,	,	,
18637	8122	26	or	or	CC
18637	8122	27	even	even	RB
18637	8122	28	military	military	JJ
18637	8122	29	,	,	,
18637	8122	30	hindsight	hindsight	JJ
18637	8122	31	.	.	.
18637	8123	1	"	"	``
18637	8123	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8123	3	88	88	CD
18637	8123	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8123	5	THE	the	DT
18637	8123	6	CASE	case	NN
18637	8123	7	OF	of	IN
18637	8123	8	THE	the	DT
18637	8123	9	NAZI	NAZI	NNP
18637	8123	10	SABOTEURS[89	SABOTEURS[89	''
18637	8123	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8123	12	The	the	DT
18637	8123	13	saboteurs	saboteur	NNS
18637	8123	14	were	be	VBD
18637	8123	15	eight	eight	CD
18637	8123	16	youths	youth	NNS
18637	8123	17	,	,	,
18637	8123	18	seven	seven	CD
18637	8123	19	Germans	Germans	NNPS
18637	8123	20	and	and	CC
18637	8123	21	one	one	CD
18637	8123	22	an	an	DT
18637	8123	23	American	American	NNP
18637	8123	24	,	,	,
18637	8123	25	who	who	WP
18637	8123	26	,	,	,
18637	8123	27	following	follow	VBG
18637	8123	28	a	a	DT
18637	8123	29	course	course	NN
18637	8123	30	of	of	IN
18637	8123	31	training	training	NN
18637	8123	32	in	in	IN
18637	8123	33	sabotage	sabotage	NN
18637	8123	34	in	in	IN
18637	8123	35	Berlin	Berlin	NNP
18637	8123	36	,	,	,
18637	8123	37	were	be	VBD
18637	8123	38	brought	bring	VBN
18637	8123	39	to	to	IN
18637	8123	40	this	this	DT
18637	8123	41	country	country	NN
18637	8123	42	in	in	IN
18637	8123	43	June	June	NNP
18637	8123	44	1942	1942	CD
18637	8123	45	aboard	aboard	IN
18637	8123	46	two	two	CD
18637	8123	47	German	german	JJ
18637	8123	48	submarines	submarine	NNS
18637	8123	49	and	and	CC
18637	8123	50	put	put	VBD
18637	8123	51	ashore	ashore	RB
18637	8123	52	,	,	,
18637	8123	53	one	one	CD
18637	8123	54	group	group	NN
18637	8123	55	on	on	IN
18637	8123	56	the	the	DT
18637	8123	57	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	8123	58	coast	coast	NN
18637	8123	59	,	,	,
18637	8123	60	the	the	DT
18637	8123	61	other	other	JJ
18637	8123	62	on	on	IN
18637	8123	63	Long	Long	NNP
18637	8123	64	Island	Island	NNP
18637	8123	65	,	,	,
18637	8123	66	with	with	IN
18637	8123	67	the	the	DT
18637	8123	68	idea	idea	NN
18637	8123	69	that	that	IN
18637	8123	70	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8123	71	would	would	MD
18637	8123	72	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	8123	73	forthwith	forthwith	NN
18637	8123	74	to	to	TO
18637	8123	75	practice	practice	VB
18637	8123	76	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8123	77	art	art	NN
18637	8123	78	on	on	IN
18637	8123	79	American	american	JJ
18637	8123	80	factories	factory	NNS
18637	8123	81	,	,	,
18637	8123	82	military	military	JJ
18637	8123	83	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	8123	84	,	,	,
18637	8123	85	and	and	CC
18637	8123	86	installations	installation	NNS
18637	8123	87	.	.	.
18637	8124	1	Making	make	VBG
18637	8124	2	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8124	3	way	way	NN
18637	8124	4	inland	inland	RB
18637	8124	5	,	,	,
18637	8124	6	the	the	DT
18637	8124	7	saboteurs	saboteurs	NNPS
18637	8124	8	were	be	VBD
18637	8124	9	soon	soon	RB
18637	8124	10	picked	pick	VBN
18637	8124	11	up	up	RP
18637	8124	12	by	by	IN
18637	8124	13	the	the	DT
18637	8124	14	FBI	FBI	NNP
18637	8124	15	,	,	,
18637	8124	16	some	some	DT
18637	8124	17	in	in	IN
18637	8124	18	New	New	NNP
18637	8124	19	York	York	NNP
18637	8124	20	,	,	,
18637	8124	21	others	other	NNS
18637	8124	22	in	in	IN
18637	8124	23	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	8124	24	,	,	,
18637	8124	25	and	and	CC
18637	8124	26	turned	turn	VBD
18637	8124	27	over	over	RP
18637	8124	28	to	to	IN
18637	8124	29	the	the	DT
18637	8124	30	Provost	Provost	NNP
18637	8124	31	Marshal	Marshal	NNP
18637	8124	32	of	of	IN
18637	8124	33	the	the	DT
18637	8124	34	District	District	NNP
18637	8124	35	of	of	IN
18637	8124	36	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	8124	37	.	.	.
18637	8125	1	On	on	IN
18637	8125	2	July	July	NNP
18637	8125	3	2	2	CD
18637	8125	4	,	,	,
18637	8125	5	the	the	DT
18637	8125	6	President	President	NNP
18637	8125	7	appointed	appoint	VBD
18637	8125	8	a	a	DT
18637	8125	9	military	military	JJ
18637	8125	10	commission	commission	NN
18637	8125	11	to	to	TO
18637	8125	12	try	try	VB
18637	8125	13	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8125	14	for	for	IN
18637	8125	15	violation	violation	NN
18637	8125	16	of	of	IN
18637	8125	17	the	the	DT
18637	8125	18	laws	law	NNS
18637	8125	19	of	of	IN
18637	8125	20	war	war	NN
18637	8125	21	,	,	,
18637	8125	22	to	to	IN
18637	8125	23	wit	wit	NN
18637	8125	24	:	:	:
18637	8125	25	for	for	IN
18637	8125	26	not	not	RB
18637	8125	27	wearing	wear	VBG
18637	8125	28	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	8125	29	emblems	emblem	NNS
18637	8125	30	to	to	TO
18637	8125	31	indicate	indicate	VB
18637	8125	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8125	33	combatant	combatant	JJ
18637	8125	34	status	status	NN
18637	8125	35	.	.	.
18637	8126	1	In	in	IN
18637	8126	2	the	the	DT
18637	8126	3	midst	midst	NN
18637	8126	4	of	of	IN
18637	8126	5	the	the	DT
18637	8126	6	trial	trial	NN
18637	8126	7	,	,	,
18637	8126	8	the	the	DT
18637	8126	9	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	8126	10	petitioned	petition	VBD
18637	8126	11	the	the	DT
18637	8126	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8126	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8126	14	and	and	CC
18637	8126	15	the	the	DT
18637	8126	16	United	United	NNP
18637	8126	17	States	States	NNP
18637	8126	18	District	District	NNP
18637	8126	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8126	20	for	for	IN
18637	8126	21	the	the	DT
18637	8126	22	District	District	NNP
18637	8126	23	of	of	IN
18637	8126	24	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	8126	25	for	for	IN
18637	8126	26	leave	leave	NN
18637	8126	27	to	to	TO
18637	8126	28	bring	bring	VB
18637	8126	29	_	_	NNP
18637	8126	30	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	8126	31	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	8126	32	_	_	NNP
18637	8126	33	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	8126	34	.	.	.
18637	8127	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8127	2	argument	argument	NN
18637	8127	3	embraced	embrace	VBD
18637	8127	4	the	the	DT
18637	8127	5	contentions	contention	NNS
18637	8127	6	:	:	:
18637	8127	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8127	8	1	1	LS
18637	8127	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8127	10	that	that	IN
18637	8127	11	the	the	DT
18637	8127	12	offense	offense	NN
18637	8127	13	charged	charge	VBD
18637	8127	14	against	against	IN
18637	8127	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8127	16	was	be	VBD
18637	8127	17	not	not	RB
18637	8127	18	known	know	VBN
18637	8127	19	to	to	IN
18637	8127	20	the	the	DT
18637	8127	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	8127	22	of	of	IN
18637	8127	23	the	the	DT
18637	8127	24	United	United	NNP
18637	8127	25	States	States	NNP
18637	8127	26	;	;	:
18637	8127	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8127	28	2	2	LS
18637	8127	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8127	30	that	that	IN
18637	8127	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8127	32	was	be	VBD
18637	8127	33	not	not	RB
18637	8127	34	one	one	CD
18637	8127	35	arising	arise	VBG
18637	8127	36	in	in	IN
18637	8127	37	the	the	DT
18637	8127	38	land	land	NN
18637	8127	39	and	and	CC
18637	8127	40	naval	naval	JJ
18637	8127	41	forces	force	NNS
18637	8127	42	;	;	:
18637	8127	43	and	and	CC
18637	8127	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8127	45	3	3	LS
18637	8127	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8127	47	that	that	IN
18637	8127	48	the	the	DT
18637	8127	49	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	8127	50	trying	try	VBG
18637	8127	51	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8127	52	had	have	VBD
18637	8127	53	not	not	RB
18637	8127	54	been	be	VBN
18637	8127	55	constituted	constitute	VBN
18637	8127	56	in	in	IN
18637	8127	57	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	8127	58	with	with	IN
18637	8127	59	the	the	DT
18637	8127	60	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	8127	61	of	of	IN
18637	8127	62	the	the	DT
18637	8127	63	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	8127	64	of	of	IN
18637	8127	65	War	War	NNP
18637	8127	66	.	.	.
18637	8128	1	The	the	DT
18637	8128	2	first	first	JJ
18637	8128	3	argument	argument	NN
18637	8128	4	the	the	DT
18637	8128	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8128	6	met	meet	VBD
18637	8128	7	as	as	IN
18637	8128	8	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	8128	9	:	:	:
18637	8128	10	The	the	DT
18637	8128	11	act	act	NN
18637	8128	12	of	of	IN
18637	8128	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8128	14	in	in	IN
18637	8128	15	providing	provide	VBG
18637	8128	16	for	for	IN
18637	8128	17	the	the	DT
18637	8128	18	trial	trial	NN
18637	8128	19	before	before	IN
18637	8128	20	military	military	JJ
18637	8128	21	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	8128	22	of	of	IN
18637	8128	23	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	8128	24	against	against	IN
18637	8128	25	the	the	DT
18637	8128	26	law	law	NN
18637	8128	27	of	of	IN
18637	8128	28	war	war	NN
18637	8128	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	8128	30	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	8128	31	definite	definite	JJ
18637	8128	32	,	,	,
18637	8128	33	although	although	IN
18637	8128	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8128	35	has	have	VBZ
18637	8128	36	not	not	RB
18637	8128	37	undertaken	undertake	VBN
18637	8128	38	to	to	TO
18637	8128	39	codify	codify	VB
18637	8128	40	or	or	CC
18637	8128	41	mark	mark	VB
18637	8128	42	the	the	DT
18637	8128	43	precise	precise	JJ
18637	8128	44	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	8128	45	of	of	IN
18637	8128	46	the	the	DT
18637	8128	47	law	law	NN
18637	8128	48	of	of	IN
18637	8128	49	war	war	NN
18637	8128	50	,	,	,
18637	8128	51	or	or	CC
18637	8128	52	to	to	TO
18637	8128	53	enumerate	enumerate	VB
18637	8128	54	or	or	CC
18637	8128	55	define	define	VB
18637	8128	56	by	by	IN
18637	8128	57	statute	statute	NN
18637	8128	58	all	all	PDT
18637	8128	59	the	the	DT
18637	8128	60	acts	act	NNS
18637	8128	61	which	which	WDT
18637	8128	62	that	that	DT
18637	8128	63	law	law	NN
18637	8128	64	condemns	condemn	VBZ
18637	8128	65	.	.	.
18637	8129	1	"	"	``
18637	8129	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8129	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8129	4	*	*	NFP
18637	8129	5	those	those	DT
18637	8129	6	who	who	WP
18637	8129	7	during	during	IN
18637	8129	8	time	time	NN
18637	8129	9	of	of	IN
18637	8129	10	war	war	NN
18637	8129	11	pass	pass	VB
18637	8129	12	surreptitiously	surreptitiously	RB
18637	8129	13	from	from	IN
18637	8129	14	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	8129	15	territory	territory	NN
18637	8129	16	into	into	IN
18637	8129	17	*	*	NFP
18637	8129	18	*	*	NFP
18637	8129	19	*	*	NFP
18637	8129	20	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8129	21	that	that	DT
18637	8129	22	of	of	IN
18637	8129	23	the	the	DT
18637	8129	24	United	United	NNP
18637	8129	25	States	States	NNP
18637	8129	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8129	27	,	,	,
18637	8129	28	discarding	discard	VBG
18637	8129	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8129	30	uniforms	uniform	NNS
18637	8129	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	8129	32	entry	entry	NN
18637	8129	33	,	,	,
18637	8129	34	for	for	IN
18637	8129	35	the	the	DT
18637	8129	36	commission	commission	NN
18637	8129	37	of	of	IN
18637	8129	38	hostile	hostile	JJ
18637	8129	39	acts	act	NNS
18637	8129	40	involving	involve	VBG
18637	8129	41	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	8129	42	of	of	IN
18637	8129	43	life	life	NN
18637	8129	44	or	or	CC
18637	8129	45	property	property	NN
18637	8129	46	,	,	,
18637	8129	47	have	have	VBP
18637	8129	48	the	the	DT
18637	8129	49	status	status	NN
18637	8129	50	of	of	IN
18637	8129	51	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	8129	52	combatants	combatant	NNS
18637	8129	53	punishable	punishable	JJ
18637	8129	54	as	as	IN
18637	8129	55	such	such	JJ
18637	8129	56	by	by	IN
18637	8129	57	military	military	NNP
18637	8129	58	commission	commission	NN
18637	8129	59	.	.	.
18637	8130	1	"	"	``
18637	8130	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8130	3	90	90	CD
18637	8130	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8130	5	The	the	DT
18637	8130	6	second	second	JJ
18637	8130	7	argument	argument	NN
18637	8130	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8130	9	disposed	dispose	VBD
18637	8130	10	of	of	IN
18637	8130	11	by	by	IN
18637	8130	12	showing	show	VBG
18637	8130	13	that	that	IN
18637	8130	14	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	8130	15	'	'	POS
18637	8130	16	case	case	NN
18637	8130	17	was	be	VBD
18637	8130	18	of	of	IN
18637	8130	19	a	a	DT
18637	8130	20	kind	kind	NN
18637	8130	21	that	that	WDT
18637	8130	22	was	be	VBD
18637	8130	23	never	never	RB
18637	8130	24	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	8130	25	to	to	TO
18637	8130	26	be	be	VB
18637	8130	27	within	within	IN
18637	8130	28	the	the	DT
18637	8130	29	terms	term	NNS
18637	8130	30	of	of	IN
18637	8130	31	Amendments	Amendments	NNP
18637	8130	32	V	V	NNP
18637	8130	33	and	and	CC
18637	8130	34	VI	VI	NNP
18637	8130	35	,	,	,
18637	8130	36	citing	cite	VBG
18637	8130	37	in	in	IN
18637	8130	38	confirmation	confirmation	NN
18637	8130	39	of	of	IN
18637	8130	40	this	this	DT
18637	8130	41	position	position	NN
18637	8130	42	the	the	DT
18637	8130	43	trial	trial	NN
18637	8130	44	of	of	IN
18637	8130	45	Major	Major	NNP
18637	8130	46	Andre	Andre	NNP
18637	8130	47	.	.	.
18637	8131	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8131	2	91	91	CD
18637	8131	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8131	4	The	the	DT
18637	8131	5	third	third	JJ
18637	8131	6	contention	contention	NN
18637	8131	7	the	the	DT
18637	8131	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8131	9	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	8131	10	by	by	IN
18637	8131	11	declining	decline	VBG
18637	8131	12	to	to	TO
18637	8131	13	draw	draw	VB
18637	8131	14	the	the	DT
18637	8131	15	line	line	NN
18637	8131	16	between	between	IN
18637	8131	17	the	the	DT
18637	8131	18	powers	power	NNS
18637	8131	19	of	of	IN
18637	8131	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8131	21	and	and	CC
18637	8131	22	the	the	DT
18637	8131	23	President	President	NNP
18637	8131	24	in	in	IN
18637	8131	25	the	the	DT
18637	8131	26	premises,[92	premises,[92	CD
18637	8131	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8131	28	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	8131	29	,	,	,
18637	8131	30	in	in	IN
18637	8131	31	effect	effect	NN
18637	8131	32	,	,	,
18637	8131	33	attributing	attribute	VBG
18637	8131	34	to	to	IN
18637	8131	35	the	the	DT
18637	8131	36	latter	latter	JJ
18637	8131	37	the	the	DT
18637	8131	38	right	right	NN
18637	8131	39	to	to	TO
18637	8131	40	amend	amend	VB
18637	8131	41	the	the	DT
18637	8131	42	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	8131	43	of	of	IN
18637	8131	44	War	War	NNP
18637	8131	45	in	in	IN
18637	8131	46	a	a	DT
18637	8131	47	case	case	NN
18637	8131	48	of	of	IN
18637	8131	49	the	the	DT
18637	8131	50	kind	kind	NN
18637	8131	51	before	before	IN
18637	8131	52	the	the	DT
18637	8131	53	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8131	54	_	_	NNP
18637	8131	55	ad	ad	NN
18637	8131	56	libitum	libitum	NN
18637	8131	57	_	_	NNP
18637	8131	58	.	.	.
18637	8132	1	The	the	DT
18637	8132	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	8132	3	might	may	MD
18637	8132	4	well	well	RB
18637	8132	5	have	have	VB
18637	8132	6	rested	rest	VBN
18637	8132	7	on	on	IN
18637	8132	8	the	the	DT
18637	8132	9	ground	ground	NN
18637	8132	10	that	that	IN
18637	8132	11	the	the	DT
18637	8132	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8132	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	8132	14	without	without	IN
18637	8132	15	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	8132	16	force	force	NN
18637	8132	17	in	in	IN
18637	8132	18	wartime	wartime	NN
18637	8132	19	in	in	IN
18637	8132	20	a	a	DT
18637	8132	21	situation	situation	NN
18637	8132	22	of	of	IN
18637	8132	23	this	this	DT
18637	8132	24	sort	sort	NN
18637	8132	25	.	.	.
18637	8133	1	The	the	DT
18637	8133	2	saboteurs	saboteur	NNS
18637	8133	3	were	be	VBD
18637	8133	4	invaders	invader	NNS
18637	8133	5	;	;	:
18637	8133	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8133	7	penetration	penetration	NN
18637	8133	8	of	of	IN
18637	8133	9	the	the	DT
18637	8133	10	boundary	boundary	NN
18637	8133	11	of	of	IN
18637	8133	12	the	the	DT
18637	8133	13	country	country	NN
18637	8133	14	,	,	,
18637	8133	15	projected	project	VBN
18637	8133	16	from	from	IN
18637	8133	17	units	unit	NNS
18637	8133	18	of	of	IN
18637	8133	19	a	a	DT
18637	8133	20	hostile	hostile	JJ
18637	8133	21	fleet	fleet	NN
18637	8133	22	,	,	,
18637	8133	23	was	be	VBD
18637	8133	24	essentially	essentially	RB
18637	8133	25	a	a	DT
18637	8133	26	military	military	JJ
18637	8133	27	operation	operation	NN
18637	8133	28	,	,	,
18637	8133	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8133	30	capture	capture	NN
18637	8133	31	was	be	VBD
18637	8133	32	a	a	DT
18637	8133	33	continuation	continuation	NN
18637	8133	34	of	of	IN
18637	8133	35	that	that	DT
18637	8133	36	operation	operation	NN
18637	8133	37	.	.	.
18637	8134	1	Punishment	punishment	NN
18637	8134	2	of	of	IN
18637	8134	3	the	the	DT
18637	8134	4	saboteurs	saboteur	NNS
18637	8134	5	was	be	VBD
18637	8134	6	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8134	7	within	within	IN
18637	8134	8	the	the	DT
18637	8134	9	President	President	NNP
18637	8134	10	's	's	POS
18637	8134	11	purely	purely	RB
18637	8134	12	martial	martial	JJ
18637	8134	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	8134	14	as	as	IN
18637	8134	15	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8134	16	in	in	IN
18637	8134	17	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8134	18	.	.	.
18637	8135	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	8135	2	,	,	,
18637	8135	3	seven	seven	CD
18637	8135	4	of	of	IN
18637	8135	5	the	the	DT
18637	8135	6	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	8135	7	were	be	VBD
18637	8135	8	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	8135	9	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	8135	10	,	,	,
18637	8135	11	and	and	CC
18637	8135	12	so	so	RB
18637	8135	13	,	,	,
18637	8135	14	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	8135	15	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8135	16	,	,	,
18637	8135	17	without	without	IN
18637	8135	18	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8135	19	status	status	NN
18637	8135	20	.	.	.
18637	8136	1	Even	even	RB
18637	8136	2	had	have	VBD
18637	8136	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8136	4	been	be	VBN
18637	8136	5	civilians	civilian	NNS
18637	8136	6	properly	properly	RB
18637	8136	7	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	8136	8	in	in	IN
18637	8136	9	the	the	DT
18637	8136	10	United	United	NNP
18637	8136	11	States	States	NNP
18637	8136	12	at	at	IN
18637	8136	13	the	the	DT
18637	8136	14	outbreak	outbreak	NN
18637	8136	15	of	of	IN
18637	8136	16	the	the	DT
18637	8136	17	war	war	NN
18637	8136	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8136	19	would	would	MD
18637	8136	20	have	have	VB
18637	8136	21	been	be	VBN
18637	8136	22	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8136	23	under	under	IN
18637	8136	24	the	the	DT
18637	8136	25	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	8136	26	to	to	TO
18637	8136	27	restraint	restraint	VB
18637	8136	28	and	and	CC
18637	8136	29	other	other	JJ
18637	8136	30	disciplinary	disciplinary	JJ
18637	8136	31	action	action	NN
18637	8136	32	by	by	IN
18637	8136	33	the	the	DT
18637	8136	34	President	President	NNP
18637	8136	35	without	without	IN
18637	8136	36	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	8136	37	to	to	IN
18637	8136	38	the	the	DT
18637	8136	39	courts	court	NNS
18637	8136	40	.	.	.
18637	8137	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8137	2	93	93	CD
18637	8137	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8137	4	THE	the	DT
18637	8137	5	WAR	war	NN
18637	8137	6	CRIMES	CRIMES	NNP
18637	8137	7	CASES	cases	NN
18637	8137	8	As	as	IN
18637	8137	9	a	a	DT
18637	8137	10	matter	matter	NN
18637	8137	11	of	of	IN
18637	8137	12	fact	fact	NN
18637	8137	13	,	,	,
18637	8137	14	in	in	IN
18637	8137	15	General	General	NNP
18637	8137	16	Yamashita	Yamashita	NNP
18637	8137	17	's	's	POS
18637	8137	18	case,[94	case,[94	CD
18637	8137	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8137	20	which	which	WDT
18637	8137	21	was	be	VBD
18637	8137	22	brought	bring	VBN
18637	8137	23	after	after	IN
18637	8137	24	the	the	DT
18637	8137	25	termination	termination	NN
18637	8137	26	of	of	IN
18637	8137	27	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	8137	28	for	for	IN
18637	8137	29	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	8137	30	"	"	``
18637	8137	31	war	war	NN
18637	8137	32	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	8137	33	,	,	,
18637	8137	34	"	"	''
18637	8137	35	the	the	DT
18637	8137	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8137	37	abandoned	abandon	VBD
18637	8137	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8137	39	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	8137	40	conception	conception	NN
18637	8137	41	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	8137	42	.	.	.
18637	8138	1	In	in	IN
18637	8138	2	the	the	DT
18637	8138	3	words	word	NNS
18637	8138	4	of	of	IN
18637	8138	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8138	6	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	8138	7	's	's	POS
18637	8138	8	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	8138	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8138	10	in	in	IN
18637	8138	11	this	this	DT
18637	8138	12	case	case	NN
18637	8138	13	:	:	:
18637	8138	14	"	"	``
18637	8138	15	The	the	DT
18637	8138	16	difference	difference	NN
18637	8138	17	between	between	IN
18637	8138	18	the	the	DT
18637	8138	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8138	20	's	's	POS
18637	8138	21	view	view	NN
18637	8138	22	of	of	IN
18637	8138	23	this	this	DT
18637	8138	24	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	8138	25	and	and	CC
18637	8138	26	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8138	27	own	own	JJ
18637	8138	28	comes	come	VBZ
18637	8138	29	down	down	RP
18637	8138	30	in	in	IN
18637	8138	31	the	the	DT
18637	8138	32	end	end	NN
18637	8138	33	to	to	IN
18637	8138	34	the	the	DT
18637	8138	35	view	view	NN
18637	8138	36	,	,	,
18637	8138	37	on	on	IN
18637	8138	38	the	the	DT
18637	8138	39	one	one	CD
18637	8138	40	hand	hand	NN
18637	8138	41	,	,	,
18637	8138	42	that	that	IN
18637	8138	43	there	there	EX
18637	8138	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	8138	45	no	no	DT
18637	8138	46	law	law	NN
18637	8138	47	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	8138	48	upon	upon	IN
18637	8138	49	these	these	DT
18637	8138	50	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	8138	51	other	other	JJ
18637	8138	52	than	than	IN
18637	8138	53	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	8138	54	rules	rule	NNS
18637	8138	55	and	and	CC
18637	8138	56	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	8138	57	may	may	MD
18637	8138	58	be	be	VB
18637	8138	59	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	8138	60	for	for	IN
18637	8138	61	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8138	62	government	government	NN
18637	8138	63	by	by	IN
18637	8138	64	the	the	DT
18637	8138	65	executive	executive	NNP
18637	8138	66	authority	authority	NNP
18637	8138	67	or	or	CC
18637	8138	68	the	the	DT
18637	8138	69	military	military	NN
18637	8138	70	and	and	CC
18637	8138	71	,	,	,
18637	8138	72	on	on	IN
18637	8138	73	the	the	DT
18637	8138	74	other	other	JJ
18637	8138	75	hand	hand	NN
18637	8138	76	,	,	,
18637	8138	77	that	that	IN
18637	8138	78	the	the	DT
18637	8138	79	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8138	80	of	of	IN
18637	8138	81	the	the	DT
18637	8138	82	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	8138	83	of	of	IN
18637	8138	84	War	War	NNP
18637	8138	85	,	,	,
18637	8138	86	of	of	IN
18637	8138	87	the	the	DT
18637	8138	88	Geneva	Geneva	NNP
18637	8138	89	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	8138	90	and	and	CC
18637	8138	91	the	the	DT
18637	8138	92	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	8138	93	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	8138	94	apply	apply	VBP
18637	8138	95	.	.	.
18637	8139	1	"	"	``
18637	8139	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8139	3	95	95	CD
18637	8139	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8139	5	And	and	CC
18637	8139	6	the	the	DT
18637	8139	7	adherence	adherence	NN
18637	8139	8	of	of	IN
18637	8139	9	the	the	DT
18637	8139	10	United	United	NNP
18637	8139	11	States	States	NNP
18637	8139	12	to	to	IN
18637	8139	13	the	the	DT
18637	8139	14	Charter	Charter	NNP
18637	8139	15	of	of	IN
18637	8139	16	London	London	NNP
18637	8139	17	in	in	IN
18637	8139	18	August	August	NNP
18637	8139	19	1945	1945	CD
18637	8139	20	,	,	,
18637	8139	21	under	under	IN
18637	8139	22	which	which	WDT
18637	8139	23	the	the	DT
18637	8139	24	Nazi	Nazi	NNP
18637	8139	25	leaders	leader	NNS
18637	8139	26	were	be	VBD
18637	8139	27	brought	bring	VBN
18637	8139	28	to	to	IN
18637	8139	29	trial	trial	NN
18637	8139	30	,	,	,
18637	8139	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	8139	32	explicable	explicable	JJ
18637	8139	33	by	by	IN
18637	8139	34	the	the	DT
18637	8139	35	same	same	JJ
18637	8139	36	theory	theory	NN
18637	8139	37	.	.	.
18637	8140	1	These	these	DT
18637	8140	2	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	8140	3	were	be	VBD
18637	8140	4	charged	charge	VBN
18637	8140	5	with	with	IN
18637	8140	6	the	the	DT
18637	8140	7	crime	crime	NN
18637	8140	8	of	of	IN
18637	8140	9	instigating	instigate	VBG
18637	8140	10	aggressive	aggressive	JJ
18637	8140	11	war	war	NN
18637	8140	12	,	,	,
18637	8140	13	which	which	WDT
18637	8140	14	at	at	IN
18637	8140	15	the	the	DT
18637	8140	16	time	time	NN
18637	8140	17	of	of	IN
18637	8140	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8140	19	commission	commission	NN
18637	8140	20	was	be	VBD
18637	8140	21	not	not	RB
18637	8140	22	a	a	DT
18637	8140	23	crime	crime	NN
18637	8140	24	either	either	CC
18637	8140	25	under	under	IN
18637	8140	26	International	International	NNP
18637	8140	27	Law	Law	NNP
18637	8140	28	or	or	CC
18637	8140	29	under	under	IN
18637	8140	30	the	the	DT
18637	8140	31	laws	law	NNS
18637	8140	32	of	of	IN
18637	8140	33	the	the	DT
18637	8140	34	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
18637	8140	35	governments	government	NNS
18637	8140	36	.	.	.
18637	8141	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8141	2	must	must	MD
18637	8141	3	be	be	VB
18637	8141	4	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	8141	5	that	that	IN
18637	8141	6	the	the	DT
18637	8141	7	President	President	NNP
18637	8141	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	8141	9	not	not	RB
18637	8141	10	in	in	IN
18637	8141	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8141	12	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	8141	13	as	as	IN
18637	8141	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8141	15	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8141	16	bound	bind	VBN
18637	8141	17	by	by	IN
18637	8141	18	the	the	DT
18637	8141	19	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	8141	20	in	in	IN
18637	8141	21	the	the	DT
18637	8141	22	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8141	23	of	of	IN
18637	8141	24	_	_	NNP
18637	8141	25	ex	ex	FW
18637	8141	26	post	post	FW
18637	8141	27	facto	facto	FW
18637	8141	28	_	_	NNP
18637	8141	29	laws	law	NNS
18637	8141	30	;	;	,
18637	8141	31	nor	nor	CC
18637	8141	32	does	do	VBZ
18637	8141	33	International	International	NNP
18637	8141	34	Law	Law	NNP
18637	8141	35	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	8141	36	_	_	NNP
18637	8141	37	ex	ex	FW
18637	8141	38	post	post	FW
18637	8141	39	facto	facto	FW
18637	8141	40	_	_	NNP
18637	8141	41	laws	law	NNS
18637	8141	42	.	.	.
18637	8142	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8142	2	96	96	CD
18637	8142	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8142	4	THE	the	DT
18637	8142	5	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	8142	6	AS	as	IN
18637	8142	7	COMMANDER	COMMANDER	NNP
18637	8142	8	OF	of	IN
18637	8142	9	THE	the	DT
18637	8142	10	FORCES	force	NNS
18637	8142	11	While	while	IN
18637	8142	12	the	the	DT
18637	8142	13	President	President	NNP
18637	8142	14	customarily	customarily	RB
18637	8142	15	delegates	delegate	VBZ
18637	8142	16	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	8142	17	command	command	NNP
18637	8142	18	of	of	IN
18637	8142	19	the	the	DT
18637	8142	20	forces	force	NNS
18637	8142	21	in	in	IN
18637	8142	22	active	active	JJ
18637	8142	23	service	service	NN
18637	8142	24	,	,	,
18637	8142	25	there	there	EX
18637	8142	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	8142	27	no	no	DT
18637	8142	28	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8142	29	reason	reason	NN
18637	8142	30	why	why	WRB
18637	8142	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8142	32	should	should	MD
18637	8142	33	do	do	VB
18637	8142	34	so	so	RB
18637	8142	35	;	;	:
18637	8142	36	and	and	CC
18637	8142	37	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8142	38	has	have	VBZ
18637	8142	39	been	be	VBN
18637	8142	40	known	know	VBN
18637	8142	41	to	to	TO
18637	8142	42	resolve	resolve	VB
18637	8142	43	personally	personally	RB
18637	8142	44	important	important	JJ
18637	8142	45	questions	question	NNS
18637	8142	46	of	of	IN
18637	8142	47	military	military	JJ
18637	8142	48	policy	policy	NN
18637	8142	49	.	.	.
18637	8143	1	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	8143	2	early	early	RB
18637	8143	3	in	in	IN
18637	8143	4	1862	1862	CD
18637	8143	5	issued	issue	VBN
18637	8143	6	orders	order	NNS
18637	8143	7	for	for	IN
18637	8143	8	a	a	DT
18637	8143	9	general	general	JJ
18637	8143	10	advance	advance	NN
18637	8143	11	in	in	IN
18637	8143	12	the	the	DT
18637	8143	13	hope	hope	NN
18637	8143	14	of	of	IN
18637	8143	15	stimulating	stimulate	VBG
18637	8143	16	McClellan	McClellan	NNP
18637	8143	17	to	to	IN
18637	8143	18	action	action	NN
18637	8143	19	;	;	:
18637	8143	20	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	8143	21	in	in	IN
18637	8143	22	1918	1918	CD
18637	8143	23	settled	settle	VBD
18637	8143	24	the	the	DT
18637	8143	25	question	question	NN
18637	8143	26	of	of	IN
18637	8143	27	an	an	DT
18637	8143	28	independent	independent	JJ
18637	8143	29	American	american	JJ
18637	8143	30	command	command	NN
18637	8143	31	on	on	IN
18637	8143	32	the	the	DT
18637	8143	33	Western	western	JJ
18637	8143	34	Front	front	NN
18637	8143	35	;	;	:
18637	8143	36	Truman	Truman	NNP
18637	8143	37	in	in	IN
18637	8143	38	1945	1945	CD
18637	8143	39	ordered	order	VBD
18637	8143	40	that	that	IN
18637	8143	41	the	the	DT
18637	8143	42	bomb	bomb	NN
18637	8143	43	be	be	VB
18637	8143	44	dropped	drop	VBN
18637	8143	45	on	on	IN
18637	8143	46	Hiroshima	Hiroshima	NNP
18637	8143	47	and	and	CC
18637	8143	48	Nagasaki	Nagasaki	NNP
18637	8143	49	.	.	.
18637	8144	1	As	as	IN
18637	8144	2	against	against	IN
18637	8144	3	an	an	DT
18637	8144	4	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	8144	5	in	in	IN
18637	8144	6	the	the	DT
18637	8144	7	field	field	NN
18637	8144	8	the	the	DT
18637	8144	9	President	President	NNP
18637	8144	10	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	8144	11	all	all	PDT
18637	8144	12	the	the	DT
18637	8144	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	8144	14	which	which	WDT
18637	8144	15	are	be	VBP
18637	8144	16	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	8144	17	by	by	IN
18637	8144	18	International	International	NNP
18637	8144	19	Law	Law	NNP
18637	8144	20	to	to	IN
18637	8144	21	any	any	DT
18637	8144	22	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	8144	23	commander	commander	NNP
18637	8144	24	.	.	.
18637	8145	1	"	"	``
18637	8145	2	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8145	3	may	may	MD
18637	8145	4	invade	invade	VB
18637	8145	5	the	the	DT
18637	8145	6	hostile	hostile	JJ
18637	8145	7	country	country	NN
18637	8145	8	,	,	,
18637	8145	9	and	and	CC
18637	8145	10	subject	subject	VB
18637	8145	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8145	12	to	to	IN
18637	8145	13	the	the	DT
18637	8145	14	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	8145	15	and	and	CC
18637	8145	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	8145	17	of	of	IN
18637	8145	18	the	the	DT
18637	8145	19	United	United	NNP
18637	8145	20	States	States	NNP
18637	8145	21	.	.	.
18637	8146	1	"	"	``
18637	8146	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8146	3	97	97	CD
18637	8146	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8146	5	In	in	IN
18637	8146	6	the	the	DT
18637	8146	7	absence	absence	NN
18637	8146	8	of	of	IN
18637	8146	9	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	8146	10	by	by	IN
18637	8146	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8146	12	to	to	TO
18637	8146	13	limit	limit	VB
18637	8146	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8146	15	power	power	NN
18637	8146	16	,	,	,
18637	8146	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8146	18	may	may	MD
18637	8146	19	establish	establish	VB
18637	8146	20	and	and	CC
18637	8146	21	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	8146	22	the	the	DT
18637	8146	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	8146	24	and	and	CC
18637	8146	25	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	8146	26	of	of	IN
18637	8146	27	military	military	JJ
18637	8146	28	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	8146	29	,	,	,
18637	8146	30	and	and	CC
18637	8146	31	of	of	IN
18637	8146	32	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	8146	33	in	in	IN
18637	8146	34	the	the	DT
18637	8146	35	nature	nature	NN
18637	8146	36	of	of	IN
18637	8146	37	such	such	JJ
18637	8146	38	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	8146	39	,	,	,
18637	8146	40	in	in	IN
18637	8146	41	territory	territory	NN
18637	8146	42	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	8146	43	by	by	IN
18637	8146	44	Armed	Armed	NNP
18637	8146	45	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	8146	46	of	of	IN
18637	8146	47	the	the	DT
18637	8146	48	United	United	NNP
18637	8146	49	States	States	NNP
18637	8146	50	,	,	,
18637	8146	51	and	and	CC
18637	8146	52	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8146	53	authority	authority	NN
18637	8146	54	to	to	TO
18637	8146	55	do	do	VB
18637	8146	56	this	this	DT
18637	8146	57	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	8146	58	survives	survive	VBZ
18637	8146	59	cessation	cessation	NN
18637	8146	60	of	of	IN
18637	8146	61	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	8146	62	.	.	.
18637	8147	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8147	2	98	98	CD
18637	8147	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8147	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8147	5	may	may	MD
18637	8147	6	employ	employ	VB
18637	8147	7	secret	secret	JJ
18637	8147	8	agents	agent	NNS
18637	8147	9	to	to	TO
18637	8147	10	enter	enter	VB
18637	8147	11	the	the	DT
18637	8147	12	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	8147	13	's	's	POS
18637	8147	14	lines	line	NNS
18637	8147	15	and	and	CC
18637	8147	16	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	8147	17	information	information	NN
18637	8147	18	as	as	IN
18637	8147	19	to	to	IN
18637	8147	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8147	21	strength	strength	NN
18637	8147	22	,	,	,
18637	8147	23	resources	resource	NNS
18637	8147	24	,	,	,
18637	8147	25	and	and	CC
18637	8147	26	movements	movement	NNS
18637	8147	27	.	.	.
18637	8148	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8148	2	99	99	CD
18637	8148	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8148	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8148	5	may	may	MD
18637	8148	6	,	,	,
18637	8148	7	at	at	IN
18637	8148	8	least	least	JJS
18637	8148	9	with	with	IN
18637	8148	10	the	the	DT
18637	8148	11	assent	assent	NN
18637	8148	12	of	of	IN
18637	8148	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8148	14	,	,	,
18637	8148	15	authorize	authorize	VBP
18637	8148	16	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	8148	17	with	with	IN
18637	8148	18	the	the	DT
18637	8148	19	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	8148	20	.	.	.
18637	8149	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8149	2	100	100	CD
18637	8149	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8149	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8149	5	may	may	MD
18637	8149	6	also	also	RB
18637	8149	7	requisition	requisition	VB
18637	8149	8	property	property	NN
18637	8149	9	and	and	CC
18637	8149	10	compel	compel	NN
18637	8149	11	services	service	NNS
18637	8149	12	from	from	IN
18637	8149	13	American	american	JJ
18637	8149	14	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8149	15	and	and	CC
18637	8149	16	friendly	friendly	JJ
18637	8149	17	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	8149	18	who	who	WP
18637	8149	19	are	be	VBP
18637	8149	20	situated	situate	VBN
18637	8149	21	within	within	IN
18637	8149	22	the	the	DT
18637	8149	23	theatre	theatre	NNP
18637	8149	24	of	of	IN
18637	8149	25	military	military	JJ
18637	8149	26	operations	operation	NNS
18637	8149	27	when	when	WRB
18637	8149	28	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	8149	29	requires	require	VBZ
18637	8149	30	,	,	,
18637	8149	31	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	8149	32	incurring	incur	VBG
18637	8149	33	for	for	IN
18637	8149	34	the	the	DT
18637	8149	35	United	United	NNP
18637	8149	36	States	States	NNP
18637	8149	37	the	the	DT
18637	8149	38	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8149	39	to	to	TO
18637	8149	40	render	render	VB
18637	8149	41	"	"	``
18637	8149	42	just	just	RB
18637	8149	43	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	8149	44	.	.	.
18637	8150	1	"	"	``
18637	8150	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8150	3	101	101	CD
18637	8150	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8150	5	By	by	IN
18637	8150	6	the	the	DT
18637	8150	7	same	same	JJ
18637	8150	8	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	8150	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8150	10	may	may	MD
18637	8150	11	bring	bring	VB
18637	8150	12	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	8150	13	to	to	IN
18637	8150	14	a	a	DT
18637	8150	15	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	8150	16	by	by	IN
18637	8150	17	arranging	arrange	VBG
18637	8150	18	an	an	DT
18637	8150	19	armistice	armistice	NN
18637	8150	20	,	,	,
18637	8150	21	stipulating	stipulate	VBG
18637	8150	22	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	8150	23	which	which	WDT
18637	8150	24	may	may	MD
18637	8150	25	determine	determine	VB
18637	8150	26	to	to	IN
18637	8150	27	a	a	DT
18637	8150	28	great	great	JJ
18637	8150	29	extent	extent	NN
18637	8150	30	the	the	DT
18637	8150	31	ensuing	ensue	VBG
18637	8150	32	peace	peace	NN
18637	8150	33	.	.	.
18637	8151	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8151	2	102	102	CD
18637	8151	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8151	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8151	5	may	may	MD
18637	8151	6	not	not	RB
18637	8151	7	,	,	,
18637	8151	8	however	however	RB
18637	8151	9	,	,	,
18637	8151	10	effect	effect	VB
18637	8151	11	a	a	DT
18637	8151	12	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	8151	13	acquisition	acquisition	NN
18637	8151	14	of	of	IN
18637	8151	15	territory;[103	territory;[103	NNP
18637	8151	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8151	17	though	though	IN
18637	8151	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8151	19	may	may	MD
18637	8151	20	govern	govern	VB
18637	8151	21	recently	recently	RB
18637	8151	22	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	8151	23	territory	territory	NN
18637	8151	24	until	until	IN
18637	8151	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8151	26	sets	set	VBZ
18637	8151	27	up	up	RP
18637	8151	28	a	a	DT
18637	8151	29	more	more	RBR
18637	8151	30	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	8151	31	regime	regime	NN
18637	8151	32	.	.	.
18637	8152	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8152	2	104	104	CD
18637	8152	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8152	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8152	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	8152	6	the	the	DT
18637	8152	7	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	8152	8	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	8152	9	for	for	IN
18637	8152	10	the	the	DT
18637	8152	11	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	8152	12	of	of	IN
18637	8152	13	the	the	DT
18637	8152	14	rules	rule	NNS
18637	8152	15	and	and	CC
18637	8152	16	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	8152	17	which	which	WDT
18637	8152	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8152	19	adopts	adopt	VBZ
18637	8152	20	for	for	IN
18637	8152	21	the	the	DT
18637	8152	22	government	government	NN
18637	8152	23	of	of	IN
18637	8152	24	the	the	DT
18637	8152	25	forces	force	NNS
18637	8152	26	,	,	,
18637	8152	27	and	and	CC
18637	8152	28	which	which	WDT
18637	8152	29	are	be	VBP
18637	8152	30	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	8152	31	through	through	IN
18637	8152	32	courts	court	NNS
18637	8152	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	8152	34	martial	martial	JJ
18637	8152	35	.	.	.
18637	8153	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8153	2	105	105	CD
18637	8153	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8153	4	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	8153	5	,	,	,
18637	8153	6	until	until	IN
18637	8153	7	1830	1830	CD
18637	8153	8	,	,	,
18637	8153	9	courts	court	NNS
18637	8153	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	8153	11	martial	martial	NNP
18637	8153	12	were	be	VBD
18637	8153	13	convened	convene	VBN
18637	8153	14	solely	solely	RB
18637	8153	15	on	on	IN
18637	8153	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8153	17	authority	authority	NN
18637	8153	18	as	as	IN
18637	8153	19	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8153	20	in	in	IN
18637	8153	21	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8153	22	.	.	.
18637	8154	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8154	2	106	106	CD
18637	8154	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8154	4	Such	such	JJ
18637	8154	5	rules	rule	NNS
18637	8154	6	and	and	CC
18637	8154	7	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	8154	8	are	be	VBP
18637	8154	9	,	,	,
18637	8154	10	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	8154	11	,	,	,
18637	8154	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8154	13	would	would	MD
18637	8154	14	seem	seem	VB
18637	8154	15	,	,	,
18637	8154	16	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8154	17	in	in	IN
18637	8154	18	wartime	wartime	NN
18637	8154	19	to	to	IN
18637	8154	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8154	21	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	8154	22	at	at	IN
18637	8154	23	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	8154	24	.	.	.
18637	8155	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8155	2	107	107	CD
18637	8155	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8155	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	8155	5	,	,	,
18637	8155	6	the	the	DT
18637	8155	7	power	power	NN
18637	8155	8	of	of	IN
18637	8155	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8155	10	to	to	TO
18637	8155	11	"	"	``
18637	8155	12	make	make	VB
18637	8155	13	rules	rule	NNS
18637	8155	14	for	for	IN
18637	8155	15	the	the	DT
18637	8155	16	government	government	NN
18637	8155	17	and	and	CC
18637	8155	18	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	8155	19	of	of	IN
18637	8155	20	the	the	DT
18637	8155	21	law	law	NN
18637	8155	22	and	and	CC
18637	8155	23	naval	naval	JJ
18637	8155	24	forces	force	NNS
18637	8155	25	"	"	''
18637	8155	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8155	27	Art	art	NN
18637	8155	28	.	.	.
18637	8156	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8156	2	,	,	,
18637	8156	3	§	§	NNP
18637	8156	4	8	8	CD
18637	8156	5	,	,	,
18637	8156	6	cl	cl	IN
18637	8156	7	.	.	.
18637	8157	1	14	14	CD
18637	8157	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8157	3	did	do	VBD
18637	8157	4	not	not	RB
18637	8157	5	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	8157	6	President	President	NNP
18637	8157	7	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	8157	8	from	from	IN
18637	8157	9	promulgating	promulgate	VBG
18637	8157	10	in	in	IN
18637	8157	11	April	April	NNP
18637	8157	12	,	,	,
18637	8157	13	1863	1863	CD
18637	8157	14	a	a	DT
18637	8157	15	code	code	NN
18637	8157	16	of	of	IN
18637	8157	17	rules	rule	NNS
18637	8157	18	to	to	TO
18637	8157	19	govern	govern	VB
18637	8157	20	the	the	DT
18637	8157	21	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	8157	22	in	in	IN
18637	8157	23	the	the	DT
18637	8157	24	field	field	NN
18637	8157	25	of	of	IN
18637	8157	26	the	the	DT
18637	8157	27	armies	army	NNS
18637	8157	28	of	of	IN
18637	8157	29	the	the	DT
18637	8157	30	United	United	NNP
18637	8157	31	States	States	NNP
18637	8157	32	which	which	WDT
18637	8157	33	was	be	VBD
18637	8157	34	prepared	prepare	VBN
18637	8157	35	at	at	IN
18637	8157	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8157	37	instance	instance	NN
18637	8157	38	by	by	IN
18637	8157	39	a	a	DT
18637	8157	40	commission	commission	NN
18637	8157	41	headed	head	VBN
18637	8157	42	by	by	IN
18637	8157	43	Francis	Francis	NNP
18637	8157	44	Lieber	Lieber	NNP
18637	8157	45	and	and	CC
18637	8157	46	which	which	WDT
18637	8157	47	later	later	RB
18637	8157	48	became	become	VBD
18637	8157	49	the	the	DT
18637	8157	50	basis	basis	NN
18637	8157	51	of	of	IN
18637	8157	52	all	all	DT
18637	8157	53	similar	similar	JJ
18637	8157	54	codifications	codification	NNS
18637	8157	55	both	both	CC
18637	8157	56	here	here	RB
18637	8157	57	and	and	CC
18637	8157	58	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	8157	59	.	.	.
18637	8158	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8158	2	108	108	CD
18637	8158	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8158	4	One	one	CD
18637	8158	5	important	important	JJ
18637	8158	6	power	power	NN
18637	8158	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8158	8	lacks	lack	VBZ
18637	8158	9	,	,	,
18637	8158	10	that	that	DT
18637	8158	11	of	of	IN
18637	8158	12	choosing	choose	VBG
18637	8158	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8158	14	subordinates	subordinate	NNS
18637	8158	15	,	,	,
18637	8158	16	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8158	17	grades	grade	NNS
18637	8158	18	and	and	CC
18637	8158	19	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	8158	20	are	be	VBP
18637	8158	21	determined	determine	VBN
18637	8158	22	by	by	IN
18637	8158	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8158	24	and	and	CC
18637	8158	25	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8158	26	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8158	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	8158	28	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	8158	29	made	make	VBN
18637	8158	30	by	by	IN
18637	8158	31	and	and	CC
18637	8158	32	with	with	IN
18637	8158	33	the	the	DT
18637	8158	34	advice	advice	NN
18637	8158	35	and	and	CC
18637	8158	36	consent	consent	NN
18637	8158	37	of	of	IN
18637	8158	38	the	the	DT
18637	8158	39	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8158	40	,	,	,
18637	8158	41	though	though	IN
18637	8158	42	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	8158	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8158	44	could	could	MD
18637	8158	45	if	if	IN
18637	8158	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8158	47	wished	wish	VBD
18637	8158	48	vest	vest	VBN
18637	8158	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8158	50	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8158	51	in	in	IN
18637	8158	52	"	"	``
18637	8158	53	the	the	DT
18637	8158	54	President	President	NNP
18637	8158	55	alone	alone	RB
18637	8158	56	.	.	.
18637	8159	1	"	"	``
18637	8159	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8159	3	109	109	CD
18637	8159	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8159	5	Also	also	RB
18637	8159	6	,	,	,
18637	8159	7	the	the	DT
18637	8159	8	President	President	NNP
18637	8159	9	's	's	POS
18637	8159	10	power	power	NN
18637	8159	11	to	to	TO
18637	8159	12	dismiss	dismiss	VB
18637	8159	13	an	an	DT
18637	8159	14	officer	officer	NN
18637	8159	15	from	from	IN
18637	8159	16	the	the	DT
18637	8159	17	service	service	NN
18637	8159	18	,	,	,
18637	8159	19	once	once	RB
18637	8159	20	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	8159	21	,	,	,
18637	8159	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	8159	23	today	today	NN
18637	8159	24	confined	confine	VBN
18637	8159	25	by	by	IN
18637	8159	26	statute	statute	NN
18637	8159	27	in	in	IN
18637	8159	28	time	time	NN
18637	8159	29	of	of	IN
18637	8159	30	peace	peace	NN
18637	8159	31	to	to	TO
18637	8159	32	dismissal	dismissal	VB
18637	8159	33	"	"	''
18637	8159	34	in	in	IN
18637	8159	35	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	8159	36	of	of	IN
18637	8159	37	the	the	DT
18637	8159	38	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	8159	39	of	of	IN
18637	8159	40	a	a	DT
18637	8159	41	general	general	JJ
18637	8159	42	court	court	NN
18637	8159	43	-	-	HYPH
18637	8159	44	martial	martial	JJ
18637	8159	45	or	or	CC
18637	8159	46	in	in	IN
18637	8159	47	mitigation	mitigation	NN
18637	8159	48	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8159	49	.	.	.
18637	8160	1	"	"	``
18637	8160	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8160	3	110	110	CD
18637	8160	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8160	5	But	but	CC
18637	8160	6	the	the	DT
18637	8160	7	provision	provision	NN
18637	8160	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	8160	9	not	not	RB
18637	8160	10	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	8160	11	by	by	IN
18637	8160	12	the	the	DT
18637	8160	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8160	14	as	as	IN
18637	8160	15	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	8160	16	the	the	DT
18637	8160	17	President	President	NNP
18637	8160	18	from	from	IN
18637	8160	19	displacing	displace	VBG
18637	8160	20	an	an	DT
18637	8160	21	officer	officer	NN
18637	8160	22	of	of	IN
18637	8160	23	the	the	DT
18637	8160	24	Army	Army	NNP
18637	8160	25	or	or	CC
18637	8160	26	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	8160	27	by	by	IN
18637	8160	28	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	8160	29	with	with	IN
18637	8160	30	the	the	DT
18637	8160	31	advice	advice	NN
18637	8160	32	and	and	CC
18637	8160	33	consent	consent	NN
18637	8160	34	of	of	IN
18637	8160	35	the	the	DT
18637	8160	36	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8160	37	another	another	DT
18637	8160	38	person	person	NN
18637	8160	39	in	in	IN
18637	8160	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8160	41	place	place	NN
18637	8160	42	.	.	.
18637	8161	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8161	2	111	111	CD
18637	8161	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8161	4	The	the	DT
18637	8161	5	President	President	NNP
18637	8161	6	's	's	POS
18637	8161	7	power	power	NN
18637	8161	8	of	of	IN
18637	8161	9	dismissal	dismissal	NN
18637	8161	10	in	in	IN
18637	8161	11	time	time	NN
18637	8161	12	of	of	IN
18637	8161	13	war	war	NN
18637	8161	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8161	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	8161	16	never	never	RB
18637	8161	17	attempted	attempt	VBN
18637	8161	18	to	to	TO
18637	8161	19	limit	limit	VB
18637	8161	20	.	.	.
18637	8162	1	THE	the	DT
18637	8162	2	COMMANDER	COMMANDER	NNP
18637	8162	3	IN	in	IN
18637	8162	4	CHIEF	chief	NN
18637	8162	5	A	a	DT
18637	8162	6	CIVILIAN	civilian	JJ
18637	8162	7	OFFICER	officer	NN
18637	8162	8	Is	be	VBZ
18637	8162	9	the	the	DT
18637	8162	10	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8162	11	in	in	IN
18637	8162	12	Chiefship	Chiefship	NNP
18637	8162	13	a	a	DT
18637	8162	14	military	military	JJ
18637	8162	15	or	or	CC
18637	8162	16	civilian	civilian	JJ
18637	8162	17	office	office	NN
18637	8162	18	in	in	IN
18637	8162	19	the	the	DT
18637	8162	20	contemplation	contemplation	NN
18637	8162	21	of	of	IN
18637	8162	22	the	the	DT
18637	8162	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8162	24	?	?	.
18637	8163	1	Unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
18637	8163	2	the	the	DT
18637	8163	3	latter	latter	NN
18637	8163	4	.	.	.
18637	8164	1	A	a	DT
18637	8164	2	recent	recent	JJ
18637	8164	3	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8164	4	by	by	IN
18637	8164	5	a	a	DT
18637	8164	6	New	New	NNP
18637	8164	7	York	York	NNP
18637	8164	8	surrogate	surrogate	JJ
18637	8164	9	deals	deal	NNS
18637	8164	10	adequately	adequately	RB
18637	8164	11	,	,	,
18637	8164	12	though	though	IN
18637	8164	13	not	not	RB
18637	8164	14	authoritatively	authoritatively	JJ
18637	8164	15	,	,	,
18637	8164	16	with	with	IN
18637	8164	17	the	the	DT
18637	8164	18	subject	subject	NN
18637	8164	19	:	:	:
18637	8164	20	"	"	``
18637	8164	21	The	the	DT
18637	8164	22	President	President	NNP
18637	8164	23	receives	receive	VBZ
18637	8164	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8164	25	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	8164	26	for	for	IN
18637	8164	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8164	28	services	service	NNS
18637	8164	29	,	,	,
18637	8164	30	rendered	render	VBN
18637	8164	31	as	as	IN
18637	8164	32	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8164	33	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8164	34	of	of	IN
18637	8164	35	the	the	DT
18637	8164	36	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	8164	37	,	,	,
18637	8164	38	not	not	RB
18637	8164	39	for	for	IN
18637	8164	40	the	the	DT
18637	8164	41	individual	individual	JJ
18637	8164	42	parts	part	NNS
18637	8164	43	of	of	IN
18637	8164	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8164	45	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8164	46	.	.	.
18637	8165	1	No	no	DT
18637	8165	2	part	part	NN
18637	8165	3	of	of	IN
18637	8165	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8165	5	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	8165	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	8165	7	paid	pay	VBN
18637	8165	8	from	from	IN
18637	8165	9	sums	sum	NNS
18637	8165	10	appropriated	appropriate	VBN
18637	8165	11	for	for	IN
18637	8165	12	the	the	DT
18637	8165	13	military	military	JJ
18637	8165	14	or	or	CC
18637	8165	15	naval	naval	JJ
18637	8165	16	forces	force	NNS
18637	8165	17	;	;	:
18637	8165	18	and	and	CC
18637	8165	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8165	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	8165	21	equally	equally	RB
18637	8165	22	clear	clear	JJ
18637	8165	23	under	under	IN
18637	8165	24	the	the	DT
18637	8165	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8165	26	that	that	WDT
18637	8165	27	the	the	DT
18637	8165	28	President	President	NNP
18637	8165	29	's	's	POS
18637	8165	30	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8165	31	as	as	IN
18637	8165	32	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8165	33	in	in	IN
18637	8165	34	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8165	35	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	8165	36	only	only	RB
18637	8165	37	a	a	DT
18637	8165	38	part	part	NN
18637	8165	39	of	of	IN
18637	8165	40	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8165	41	_	_	NNP
18637	8165	42	ex	ex	NNP
18637	8165	43	officio	officio	NNP
18637	8165	44	_	_	NNP
18637	8165	45	as	as	IN
18637	8165	46	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8165	47	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8165	48	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8165	49	Article	Article	NNP
18637	8165	50	II	II	NNP
18637	8165	51	,	,	,
18637	8165	52	sections	section	NNS
18637	8165	53	2	2	CD
18637	8165	54	and	and	CC
18637	8165	55	3	3	CD
18637	8165	56	of	of	IN
18637	8165	57	the	the	DT
18637	8165	58	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8165	59	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8165	60	and	and	CC
18637	8165	61	that	that	IN
18637	8165	62	the	the	DT
18637	8165	63	latter	latter	NN
18637	8165	64	's	's	POS
18637	8165	65	office	office	NN
18637	8165	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	8165	67	a	a	DT
18637	8165	68	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8165	69	office	office	NN
18637	8165	70	.	.	.
18637	8166	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8166	2	Article	Article	NNP
18637	8166	3	II	II	NNP
18637	8166	4	,	,	,
18637	8166	5	section	section	NN
18637	8166	6	1	1	CD
18637	8166	7	of	of	IN
18637	8166	8	the	the	DT
18637	8166	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8166	10	;	;	:
18637	8166	11	vol	vol	NNP
18637	8166	12	.	.	.
18637	8167	1	91	91	CD
18637	8167	2	,	,	,
18637	8167	3	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	8167	4	.	.	.
18637	8168	1	Rec	Rec	NNP
18637	8168	2	.	.	.
18637	8169	1	4910	4910	CD
18637	8169	2	-	-	SYM
18637	8169	3	4916	4916	CD
18637	8169	4	;	;	:
18637	8169	5	Beard	Beard	NNP
18637	8169	6	,	,	,
18637	8169	7	The	the	DT
18637	8169	8	Republic	Republic	NNP
18637	8169	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8169	10	1943	1943	CD
18637	8169	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8169	12	pp	pp	NNP
18637	8169	13	.	.	.
18637	8170	1	100	100	CD
18637	8170	2	-	-	SYM
18637	8170	3	103	103	CD
18637	8170	4	.	.	.
18637	8170	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8171	1	The	the	DT
18637	8171	2	President	President	NNP
18637	8171	3	does	do	VBZ
18637	8171	4	not	not	RB
18637	8171	5	enlist	enlist	VB
18637	8171	6	in	in	RB
18637	8171	7	,	,	,
18637	8171	8	and	and	CC
18637	8171	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8171	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	8171	11	not	not	RB
18637	8171	12	inducted	induct	VBN
18637	8171	13	or	or	CC
18637	8171	14	drafted	draft	VBN
18637	8171	15	into	into	IN
18637	8171	16	the	the	DT
18637	8171	17	armed	armed	JJ
18637	8171	18	forces	force	NNS
18637	8171	19	.	.	.
18637	8172	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	8172	2	,	,	,
18637	8172	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8172	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8172	5	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8172	6	to	to	IN
18637	8172	7	court	court	NN
18637	8172	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	8172	9	martial	martial	JJ
18637	8172	10	or	or	CC
18637	8172	11	other	other	JJ
18637	8172	12	military	military	JJ
18637	8172	13	discipline	discipline	NN
18637	8172	14	.	.	.
18637	8173	1	On	on	IN
18637	8173	2	the	the	DT
18637	8173	3	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	8173	4	,	,	,
18637	8173	5	article	article	NN
18637	8173	6	II	II	NNP
18637	8173	7	,	,	,
18637	8173	8	section	section	NN
18637	8173	9	4	4	CD
18637	8173	10	of	of	IN
18637	8173	11	the	the	DT
18637	8173	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8173	13	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	8173	14	that	that	IN
18637	8173	15	'	'	``
18637	8173	16	The	the	DT
18637	8173	17	President	President	NNP
18637	8173	18	,	,	,
18637	8173	19	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8173	20	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	8173	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8173	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8173	23	and	and	CC
18637	8173	24	All	all	DT
18637	8173	25	Civil	civil	JJ
18637	8173	26	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	8173	27	of	of	IN
18637	8173	28	the	the	DT
18637	8173	29	United	United	NNP
18637	8173	30	States	States	NNP
18637	8173	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	8173	32	be	be	VB
18637	8173	33	removed	remove	VBN
18637	8173	34	from	from	IN
18637	8173	35	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8173	36	on	on	IN
18637	8173	37	Impeachment	Impeachment	NNP
18637	8173	38	for	for	IN
18637	8173	39	,	,	,
18637	8173	40	and	and	CC
18637	8173	41	Conviction	Conviction	NNP
18637	8173	42	of	of	IN
18637	8173	43	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	8173	44	,	,	,
18637	8173	45	Bribery	Bribery	NNP
18637	8173	46	or	or	CC
18637	8173	47	other	other	JJ
18637	8173	48	high	high	JJ
18637	8173	49	Crimes	Crimes	NNPS
18637	8173	50	and	and	CC
18637	8173	51	Misdemeanors	Misdemeanors	NNPS
18637	8173	52	.	.	.
18637	8173	53	'	'	''
18637	8174	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8174	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8174	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8174	4	The	the	DT
18637	8174	5	last	last	JJ
18637	8174	6	two	two	CD
18637	8174	7	War	War	NNP
18637	8174	8	Presidents	Presidents	NNPS
18637	8174	9	,	,	,
18637	8174	10	President	President	NNP
18637	8174	11	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	8174	12	and	and	CC
18637	8174	13	President	President	NNP
18637	8174	14	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8174	15	,	,	,
18637	8174	16	both	both	DT
18637	8174	17	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	8174	18	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	8174	19	the	the	DT
18637	8174	20	civilian	civilian	JJ
18637	8174	21	nature	nature	NN
18637	8174	22	of	of	IN
18637	8174	23	the	the	DT
18637	8174	24	President	President	NNP
18637	8174	25	's	's	POS
18637	8174	26	position	position	NN
18637	8174	27	as	as	IN
18637	8174	28	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8174	29	in	in	IN
18637	8174	30	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8174	31	.	.	.
18637	8175	1	President	President	NNP
18637	8175	2	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8175	3	,	,	,
18637	8175	4	in	in	IN
18637	8175	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8175	6	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	8175	7	Day	Day	NNP
18637	8175	8	Campaign	Campaign	NNP
18637	8175	9	speech	speech	NN
18637	8175	10	at	at	IN
18637	8175	11	Shibe	Shibe	NNP
18637	8175	12	Park	Park	NNP
18637	8175	13	,	,	,
18637	8175	14	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	8175	15	,	,	,
18637	8175	16	on	on	IN
18637	8175	17	October	October	NNP
18637	8175	18	27	27	CD
18637	8175	19	,	,	,
18637	8175	20	1944	1944	CD
18637	8175	21	,	,	,
18637	8175	22	pronounced	pronounce	VBD
18637	8175	23	this	this	DT
18637	8175	24	principle	principle	NN
18637	8175	25	as	as	IN
18637	8175	26	follows:--'It	follows:--'it	CD
18637	8175	27	was	be	VBD
18637	8175	28	due	due	JJ
18637	8175	29	to	to	IN
18637	8175	30	no	no	DT
18637	8175	31	accident	accident	NN
18637	8175	32	and	and	CC
18637	8175	33	no	no	DT
18637	8175	34	oversight	oversight	NN
18637	8175	35	that	that	WDT
18637	8175	36	the	the	DT
18637	8175	37	framers	framer	NNS
18637	8175	38	of	of	IN
18637	8175	39	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8175	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8175	41	put	put	VBD
18637	8175	42	the	the	DT
18637	8175	43	command	command	NN
18637	8175	44	of	of	IN
18637	8175	45	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8175	46	armed	armed	JJ
18637	8175	47	forces	force	NNS
18637	8175	48	under	under	IN
18637	8175	49	civilian	civilian	JJ
18637	8175	50	authority	authority	NN
18637	8175	51	.	.	.
18637	8176	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8176	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8176	3	the	the	DT
18637	8176	4	duty	duty	NN
18637	8176	5	of	of	IN
18637	8176	6	the	the	DT
18637	8176	7	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8176	8	in	in	IN
18637	8176	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8176	10	to	to	TO
18637	8176	11	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	8176	12	the	the	DT
18637	8176	13	Secretaries	Secretaries	NNPS
18637	8176	14	of	of	IN
18637	8176	15	War	War	NNP
18637	8176	16	and	and	CC
18637	8176	17	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	8176	18	and	and	CC
18637	8176	19	the	the	DT
18637	8176	20	Chiefs	Chiefs	NNPS
18637	8176	21	of	of	IN
18637	8176	22	Staff	Staff	NNP
18637	8176	23	.	.	.
18637	8176	24	'	'	''
18637	8177	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8177	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8177	3	also	also	RB
18637	8177	4	to	to	TO
18637	8177	5	be	be	VB
18637	8177	6	noted	note	VBN
18637	8177	7	that	that	IN
18637	8177	8	the	the	DT
18637	8177	9	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8177	10	of	of	IN
18637	8177	11	War	War	NNP
18637	8177	12	,	,	,
18637	8177	13	who	who	WP
18637	8177	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8177	15	the	the	DT
18637	8177	16	regularly	regularly	RB
18637	8177	17	constituted	constituted	JJ
18637	8177	18	organ	organ	NN
18637	8177	19	of	of	IN
18637	8177	20	the	the	DT
18637	8177	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8177	22	for	for	IN
18637	8177	23	the	the	DT
18637	8177	24	administration	administration	NN
18637	8177	25	of	of	IN
18637	8177	26	the	the	DT
18637	8177	27	military	military	JJ
18637	8177	28	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	8177	29	of	of	IN
18637	8177	30	the	the	DT
18637	8177	31	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	8177	32	,	,	,
18637	8177	33	has	have	VBZ
18637	8177	34	been	be	VBN
18637	8177	35	held	hold	VBN
18637	8177	36	by	by	IN
18637	8177	37	the	the	DT
18637	8177	38	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8177	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8177	40	of	of	IN
18637	8177	41	the	the	DT
18637	8177	42	United	United	NNP
18637	8177	43	States	States	NNP
18637	8177	44	to	to	TO
18637	8177	45	be	be	VB
18637	8177	46	merely	merely	RB
18637	8177	47	a	a	DT
18637	8177	48	civilian	civilian	JJ
18637	8177	49	officer	officer	NN
18637	8177	50	,	,	,
18637	8177	51	not	not	RB
18637	8177	52	in	in	IN
18637	8177	53	military	military	JJ
18637	8177	54	service	service	NN
18637	8177	55	.	.	.
18637	8178	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8178	2	United	United	NNP
18637	8178	3	States	States	NNP
18637	8178	4	_	_	NNP
18637	8178	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	8178	6	_	_	NNP
18637	8178	7	Burns	Burns	NNP
18637	8178	8	,	,	,
18637	8178	9	79	79	CD
18637	8178	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	8178	11	246	246	CD
18637	8178	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8178	13	1871	1871	CD
18637	8178	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8178	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8178	16	.	.	.
18637	8179	1	On	on	IN
18637	8179	2	the	the	DT
18637	8179	3	general	general	JJ
18637	8179	4	principle	principle	NN
18637	8179	5	of	of	IN
18637	8179	6	civilian	civilian	JJ
18637	8179	7	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	8179	8	over	over	IN
18637	8179	9	the	the	DT
18637	8179	10	military	military	NN
18637	8179	11	,	,	,
18637	8179	12	by	by	IN
18637	8179	13	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	8179	14	of	of	IN
18637	8179	15	the	the	DT
18637	8179	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8179	17	,	,	,
18637	8179	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8179	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	8179	20	recently	recently	RB
18637	8179	21	been	be	VBN
18637	8179	22	said	say	VBN
18637	8179	23	:	:	:
18637	8179	24	'	'	''
18637	8179	25	The	the	DT
18637	8179	26	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	8179	27	of	of	IN
18637	8179	28	the	the	DT
18637	8179	29	civil	civil	NN
18637	8179	30	over	over	IN
18637	8179	31	the	the	DT
18637	8179	32	military	military	NN
18637	8179	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	8179	34	one	one	CD
18637	8179	35	of	of	IN
18637	8179	36	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8179	37	great	great	JJ
18637	8179	38	heritages	heritage	NNS
18637	8179	39	.	.	.
18637	8179	40	'	'	''
18637	8180	1	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	8180	2	_	_	NNP
18637	8180	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	8180	4	_	_	NNP
18637	8180	5	Kahanamoku	Kahanamoku	NNP
18637	8180	6	,	,	,
18637	8180	7	324	324	CD
18637	8180	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	8180	9	833	833	CD
18637	8180	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8180	11	1945	1945	CD
18637	8180	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8180	13	,	,	,
18637	8180	14	14	14	CD
18637	8180	15	L.W.	L.W.	NNP
18637	8181	1	4205	4205	CD
18637	8181	2	at	at	IN
18637	8181	3	page	page	NN
18637	8181	4	4210	4210	CD
18637	8181	5	.	.	.
18637	8182	1	"	"	``
18637	8182	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8182	3	112	112	CD
18637	8182	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8182	5	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	8182	6	Advisers	Advisers	NNPS
18637	8182	7	THE	the	DT
18637	8182	8	CABINET	CABINET	NNS
18637	8182	9	The	the	DT
18637	8182	10	above	above	JJ
18637	8182	11	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8182	12	are	be	VBP
18637	8182	13	the	the	DT
18637	8182	14	meager	meager	JJ
18637	8182	15	residue	residue	NN
18637	8182	16	from	from	IN
18637	8182	17	a	a	DT
18637	8182	18	persistent	persistent	JJ
18637	8182	19	effort	effort	NN
18637	8182	20	in	in	IN
18637	8182	21	the	the	DT
18637	8182	22	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8182	23	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	8182	24	to	to	TO
18637	8182	25	impose	impose	VB
18637	8182	26	a	a	DT
18637	8182	27	council	council	NN
18637	8182	28	on	on	IN
18637	8182	29	the	the	DT
18637	8182	30	President	President	NNP
18637	8182	31	.	.	.
18637	8183	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8183	2	113	113	CD
18637	8183	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8183	4	The	the	DT
18637	8183	5	idea	idea	NN
18637	8183	6	ultimately	ultimately	RB
18637	8183	7	failed	fail	VBD
18637	8183	8	,	,	,
18637	8183	9	partly	partly	RB
18637	8183	10	because	because	IN
18637	8183	11	of	of	IN
18637	8183	12	the	the	DT
18637	8183	13	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	8183	14	of	of	IN
18637	8183	15	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	8183	16	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	8183	17	the	the	DT
18637	8183	18	Council	Council	NNP
18637	8183	19	's	's	POS
18637	8183	20	make	make	NN
18637	8183	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	8183	22	up	up	NN
18637	8183	23	.	.	.
18637	8184	1	One	one	CD
18637	8184	2	member	member	NN
18637	8184	3	wished	wish	VBD
18637	8184	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8184	5	to	to	TO
18637	8184	6	consist	consist	VB
18637	8184	7	of	of	IN
18637	8184	8	"	"	``
18637	8184	9	members	member	NNS
18637	8184	10	of	of	IN
18637	8184	11	the	the	DT
18637	8184	12	two	two	CD
18637	8184	13	houses	house	NNS
18637	8184	14	,	,	,
18637	8184	15	"	"	''
18637	8184	16	another	another	DT
18637	8184	17	wished	wish	VBD
18637	8184	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8184	19	to	to	TO
18637	8184	20	comprise	comprise	VB
18637	8184	21	two	two	CD
18637	8184	22	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	8184	23	from	from	IN
18637	8184	24	each	each	DT
18637	8184	25	of	of	IN
18637	8184	26	three	three	CD
18637	8184	27	sections	section	NNS
18637	8184	28	,	,	,
18637	8184	29	"	"	''
18637	8184	30	with	with	IN
18637	8184	31	a	a	DT
18637	8184	32	rotation	rotation	NN
18637	8184	33	and	and	CC
18637	8184	34	duration	duration	NN
18637	8184	35	of	of	IN
18637	8184	36	office	office	NN
18637	8184	37	similar	similar	JJ
18637	8184	38	to	to	IN
18637	8184	39	those	those	DT
18637	8184	40	of	of	IN
18637	8184	41	the	the	DT
18637	8184	42	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8184	43	.	.	.
18637	8184	44	"	"	''
18637	8185	1	The	the	DT
18637	8185	2	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	8185	3	which	which	WDT
18637	8185	4	had	have	VBD
18637	8185	5	the	the	DT
18637	8185	6	strongest	strong	JJS
18637	8185	7	backing	backing	NN
18637	8185	8	was	be	VBD
18637	8185	9	that	that	IN
18637	8185	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8185	11	should	should	MD
18637	8185	12	consist	consist	VB
18637	8185	13	of	of	IN
18637	8185	14	the	the	DT
18637	8185	15	heads	head	NNS
18637	8185	16	of	of	IN
18637	8185	17	departments	department	NNS
18637	8185	18	and	and	CC
18637	8185	19	the	the	DT
18637	8185	20	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8185	21	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8185	22	of	of	IN
18637	8185	23	the	the	DT
18637	8185	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8185	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8185	26	,	,	,
18637	8185	27	who	who	WP
18637	8185	28	should	should	MD
18637	8185	29	preside	preside	VB
18637	8185	30	when	when	WRB
18637	8185	31	the	the	DT
18637	8185	32	President	President	NNP
18637	8185	33	was	be	VBD
18637	8185	34	absent	absent	JJ
18637	8185	35	.	.	.
18637	8186	1	Of	of	IN
18637	8186	2	this	this	DT
18637	8186	3	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	8186	4	the	the	DT
18637	8186	5	only	only	JJ
18637	8186	6	part	part	NN
18637	8186	7	to	to	TO
18637	8186	8	survive	survive	VB
18637	8186	9	was	be	VBD
18637	8186	10	the	the	DT
18637	8186	11	above	above	RB
18637	8186	12	cited	cite	VBN
18637	8186	13	provision	provision	NN
18637	8186	14	.	.	.
18637	8187	1	The	the	DT
18637	8187	2	consultative	consultative	JJ
18637	8187	3	relation	relation	NN
18637	8187	4	here	here	RB
18637	8187	5	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
18637	8187	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	8187	7	an	an	DT
18637	8187	8	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	8187	9	one	one	CD
18637	8187	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	8187	11	sided	sided	JJ
18637	8187	12	affair	affair	NN
18637	8187	13	,	,	,
18637	8187	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8187	15	to	to	TO
18637	8187	16	be	be	VB
18637	8187	17	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	8187	18	with	with	IN
18637	8187	19	each	each	DT
18637	8187	20	principal	principal	JJ
18637	8187	21	officer	officer	NN
18637	8187	22	separately	separately	RB
18637	8187	23	and	and	CC
18637	8187	24	in	in	IN
18637	8187	25	writing	writing	NN
18637	8187	26	,	,	,
18637	8187	27	and	and	CC
18637	8187	28	to	to	TO
18637	8187	29	relate	relate	VB
18637	8187	30	only	only	RB
18637	8187	31	to	to	IN
18637	8187	32	the	the	DT
18637	8187	33	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8187	34	of	of	IN
18637	8187	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8187	36	respective	respective	JJ
18637	8187	37	offices	office	NNS
18637	8187	38	.	.	.
18637	8188	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8188	2	114	114	CD
18637	8188	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8188	4	The	the	DT
18637	8188	5	_	_	NNP
18637	8188	6	Cabinet	Cabinet	NNP
18637	8188	7	_	_	NNP
18637	8188	8	,	,	,
18637	8188	9	as	as	IN
18637	8188	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8188	11	know	know	VBP
18637	8188	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8188	13	today	today	NN
18637	8188	14	,	,	,
18637	8188	15	that	that	DT
18637	8188	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	8188	17	to	to	TO
18637	8188	18	say	say	VB
18637	8188	19	,	,	,
18637	8188	20	the	the	DT
18637	8188	21	Cabinet	Cabinet	NNP
18637	8188	22	_	_	NNP
18637	8188	23	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	8188	24	_	_	NNP
18637	8188	25	,	,	,
18637	8188	26	was	be	VBD
18637	8188	27	brought	bring	VBN
18637	8188	28	about	about	RP
18637	8188	29	solely	solely	RB
18637	8188	30	on	on	IN
18637	8188	31	the	the	DT
18637	8188	32	initiative	initiative	NN
18637	8188	33	of	of	IN
18637	8188	34	the	the	DT
18637	8188	35	first	first	JJ
18637	8188	36	President	President	NNP
18637	8188	37	,	,	,
18637	8188	38	and	and	CC
18637	8188	39	may	may	MD
18637	8188	40	be	be	VB
18637	8188	41	dispensed	dispense	VBN
18637	8188	42	with	with	IN
18637	8188	43	on	on	IN
18637	8188	44	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8188	45	initiative	initiative	NN
18637	8188	46	at	at	IN
18637	8188	47	any	any	DT
18637	8188	48	time	time	NN
18637	8188	49	,	,	,
18637	8188	50	being	be	VBG
18637	8188	51	totally	totally	RB
18637	8188	52	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	8188	53	to	to	IN
18637	8188	54	the	the	DT
18637	8188	55	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8188	56	.	.	.
18637	8189	1	Several	several	JJ
18637	8189	2	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	8189	3	have	have	VBP
18637	8189	4	in	in	IN
18637	8189	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	8189	6	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	8189	7	the	the	DT
18637	8189	8	Cabinet	Cabinet	NNP
18637	8189	9	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	8189	10	to	to	IN
18637	8189	11	little	little	JJ
18637	8189	12	more	more	JJR
18637	8189	13	than	than	IN
18637	8189	14	a	a	DT
18637	8189	15	ceremony	ceremony	NN
18637	8189	16	with	with	IN
18637	8189	17	social	social	JJ
18637	8189	18	trimmings	trimming	NNS
18637	8189	19	.	.	.
18637	8190	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8190	2	115	115	CD
18637	8190	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8190	4	Pardons	Pardons	NNPS
18637	8190	5	and	and	CC
18637	8190	6	Reprieves	Reprieves	NNPS
18637	8190	7	THE	the	DT
18637	8190	8	LEGAL	legal	NN
18637	8190	9	NATURE	nature	NN
18637	8190	10	OF	of	IN
18637	8190	11	A	a	DT
18637	8190	12	PARDON	PARDON	NNP
18637	8190	13	In	in	IN
18637	8190	14	the	the	DT
18637	8190	15	first	first	JJ
18637	8190	16	case	case	NN
18637	8190	17	to	to	TO
18637	8190	18	be	be	VB
18637	8190	19	decided	decide	VBN
18637	8190	20	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	8190	21	the	the	DT
18637	8190	22	pardoning	pardon	VBG
18637	8190	23	power	power	NN
18637	8190	24	,	,	,
18637	8190	25	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8190	26	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8190	27	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	8190	28	,	,	,
18637	8190	29	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8190	30	for	for	IN
18637	8190	31	the	the	DT
18637	8190	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8190	33	,	,	,
18637	8190	34	said	say	VBD
18637	8190	35	:	:	:
18637	8190	36	"	"	``
18637	8190	37	As	as	IN
18637	8190	38	this	this	DT
18637	8190	39	power	power	NN
18637	8190	40	had	have	VBD
18637	8190	41	been	be	VBN
18637	8190	42	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	8190	43	from	from	IN
18637	8190	44	time	time	NN
18637	8190	45	immemorial	immemorial	JJ
18637	8190	46	by	by	IN
18637	8190	47	the	the	DT
18637	8190	48	executive	executive	NN
18637	8190	49	of	of	IN
18637	8190	50	that	that	DT
18637	8190	51	nation	nation	NN
18637	8190	52	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8190	53	language	language	NN
18637	8190	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	8190	55	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8190	56	language	language	NN
18637	8190	57	,	,	,
18637	8190	58	and	and	CC
18637	8190	59	to	to	IN
18637	8190	60	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8190	61	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8190	62	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	8190	63	ours	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8190	64	bear	bear	VBP
18637	8190	65	a	a	DT
18637	8190	66	close	close	JJ
18637	8190	67	resemblance	resemblance	NN
18637	8190	68	;	;	:
18637	8190	69	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8190	70	adopt	adopt	VBP
18637	8190	71	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8190	72	principles	principle	NNS
18637	8190	73	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	8190	74	the	the	DT
18637	8190	75	operation	operation	NN
18637	8190	76	and	and	CC
18637	8190	77	effect	effect	NN
18637	8190	78	of	of	IN
18637	8190	79	a	a	DT
18637	8190	80	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8190	81	,	,	,
18637	8190	82	and	and	CC
18637	8190	83	look	look	VB
18637	8190	84	into	into	IN
18637	8190	85	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8190	86	books	book	NNS
18637	8190	87	for	for	IN
18637	8190	88	the	the	DT
18637	8190	89	rules	rule	NNS
18637	8190	90	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	8190	91	the	the	DT
18637	8190	92	manner	manner	NN
18637	8190	93	in	in	IN
18637	8190	94	which	which	WDT
18637	8190	95	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8190	96	is	be	VBZ
18637	8190	97	to	to	TO
18637	8190	98	be	be	VB
18637	8190	99	used	use	VBN
18637	8190	100	by	by	IN
18637	8190	101	the	the	DT
18637	8190	102	person	person	NN
18637	8190	103	who	who	WP
18637	8190	104	would	would	MD
18637	8190	105	avail	avail	VB
18637	8190	106	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8190	107	of	of	IN
18637	8190	108	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8190	109	.	.	.
18637	8191	1	A	a	DT
18637	8191	2	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8191	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8191	4	an	an	DT
18637	8191	5	act	act	NN
18637	8191	6	of	of	IN
18637	8191	7	grace	grace	NN
18637	8191	8	,	,	,
18637	8191	9	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	8191	10	from	from	IN
18637	8191	11	the	the	DT
18637	8191	12	power	power	NN
18637	8191	13	entrusted	entrust	VBN
18637	8191	14	with	with	IN
18637	8191	15	the	the	DT
18637	8191	16	execution	execution	NN
18637	8191	17	of	of	IN
18637	8191	18	the	the	DT
18637	8191	19	laws	law	NNS
18637	8191	20	,	,	,
18637	8191	21	which	which	WDT
18637	8191	22	exempts	exempt	VBZ
18637	8191	23	the	the	DT
18637	8191	24	individual	individual	NN
18637	8191	25	,	,	,
18637	8191	26	on	on	IN
18637	8191	27	whom	whom	WP
18637	8191	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8191	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	8191	30	bestowed	bestow	VBN
18637	8191	31	,	,	,
18637	8191	32	from	from	IN
18637	8191	33	the	the	DT
18637	8191	34	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	8191	35	the	the	DT
18637	8191	36	law	law	NN
18637	8191	37	inflicts	inflict	VBZ
18637	8191	38	for	for	IN
18637	8191	39	a	a	DT
18637	8191	40	crime	crime	NN
18637	8191	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8191	42	has	have	VBZ
18637	8191	43	committed	commit	VBN
18637	8191	44	.	.	.
18637	8192	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8192	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8192	3	the	the	DT
18637	8192	4	private	private	JJ
18637	8192	5	,	,	,
18637	8192	6	though	though	IN
18637	8192	7	official	official	JJ
18637	8192	8	act	act	NN
18637	8192	9	of	of	IN
18637	8192	10	the	the	DT
18637	8192	11	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8192	12	magistrate	magistrate	NN
18637	8192	13	,	,	,
18637	8192	14	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	8192	15	to	to	IN
18637	8192	16	the	the	DT
18637	8192	17	individual	individual	NN
18637	8192	18	for	for	IN
18637	8192	19	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8192	20	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	8192	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8192	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	8192	23	intended	intend	VBN
18637	8192	24	,	,	,
18637	8192	25	and	and	CC
18637	8192	26	not	not	RB
18637	8192	27	communicated	communicate	VBN
18637	8192	28	officially	officially	RB
18637	8192	29	to	to	IN
18637	8192	30	the	the	DT
18637	8192	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8192	32	.	.	.
18637	8193	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8193	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8193	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8193	4	A	a	DT
18637	8193	5	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8193	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	8193	7	a	a	DT
18637	8193	8	deed	deed	NN
18637	8193	9	,	,	,
18637	8193	10	to	to	IN
18637	8193	11	the	the	DT
18637	8193	12	validity	validity	NN
18637	8193	13	of	of	IN
18637	8193	14	which	which	WDT
18637	8193	15	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	8193	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	8193	17	essential	essential	JJ
18637	8193	18	,	,	,
18637	8193	19	and	and	CC
18637	8193	20	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	8193	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	8193	22	not	not	RB
18637	8193	23	complete	complete	JJ
18637	8193	24	without	without	IN
18637	8193	25	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	8193	26	.	.	.
18637	8194	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8194	2	may	may	MD
18637	8194	3	then	then	RB
18637	8194	4	be	be	VB
18637	8194	5	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	8194	6	by	by	IN
18637	8194	7	the	the	DT
18637	8194	8	person	person	NN
18637	8194	9	to	to	IN
18637	8194	10	whom	whom	WP
18637	8194	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8194	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	8194	13	tendered	tender	VBN
18637	8194	14	;	;	:
18637	8194	15	and	and	CC
18637	8194	16	if	if	IN
18637	8194	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8194	18	be	be	VB
18637	8194	19	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	8194	20	,	,	,
18637	8194	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8194	22	have	have	VBP
18637	8194	23	discovered	discover	VBN
18637	8194	24	no	no	DT
18637	8194	25	power	power	NN
18637	8194	26	in	in	IN
18637	8194	27	a	a	DT
18637	8194	28	court	court	NN
18637	8194	29	to	to	TO
18637	8194	30	force	force	VB
18637	8194	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8194	32	on	on	IN
18637	8194	33	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8194	34	.	.	.
18637	8194	35	"	"	''
18637	8195	1	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	8195	2	thereupon	thereupon	RB
18637	8195	3	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	8195	4	to	to	TO
18637	8195	5	lay	lay	VB
18637	8195	6	down	down	RP
18637	8195	7	the	the	DT
18637	8195	8	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	8195	9	,	,	,
18637	8195	10	that	that	IN
18637	8195	11	"	"	``
18637	8195	12	a	a	DT
18637	8195	13	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8195	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8195	15	a	a	DT
18637	8195	16	deed	deed	NN
18637	8195	17	to	to	IN
18637	8195	18	the	the	DT
18637	8195	19	validity	validity	NN
18637	8195	20	of	of	IN
18637	8195	21	which	which	WDT
18637	8195	22	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	8195	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	8195	24	essential	essential	JJ
18637	8195	25	,	,	,
18637	8195	26	and	and	CC
18637	8195	27	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	8195	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	8195	29	not	not	RB
18637	8195	30	complete	complete	JJ
18637	8195	31	without	without	IN
18637	8195	32	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	8195	33	"	"	''
18637	8195	34	;	;	:
18637	8195	35	and	and	CC
18637	8195	36	that	that	DT
18637	8195	37	to	to	TO
18637	8195	38	be	be	VB
18637	8195	39	noticed	notice	VBN
18637	8195	40	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	8195	41	this	this	DT
18637	8195	42	deed	deed	NN
18637	8195	43	must	must	MD
18637	8195	44	be	be	VB
18637	8195	45	pleaded	plead	VBN
18637	8195	46	,	,	,
18637	8195	47	like	like	IN
18637	8195	48	any	any	DT
18637	8195	49	private	private	JJ
18637	8195	50	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	8195	51	.	.	.
18637	8196	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8196	2	116	116	CD
18637	8196	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8196	4	Qualification	qualification	NN
18637	8196	5	of	of	IN
18637	8196	6	the	the	DT
18637	8196	7	Above	Above	NNP
18637	8196	8	Theory	Theory	NNP
18637	8196	9	In	in	IN
18637	8196	10	the	the	DT
18637	8196	11	case	case	NN
18637	8196	12	of	of	IN
18637	8196	13	Burdick	Burdick	NNP
18637	8196	14	_	_	NNP
18637	8196	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	8196	16	_	_	NNP
18637	8196	17	United	United	NNP
18637	8196	18	States,[117	States,[117	NNP
18637	8196	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8196	20	decided	decide	VBN
18637	8196	21	in	in	IN
18637	8196	22	1915	1915	CD
18637	8196	23	,	,	,
18637	8196	24	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	8196	25	's	's	POS
18637	8196	26	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	8196	27	was	be	VBD
18637	8196	28	put	put	VBN
18637	8196	29	to	to	IN
18637	8196	30	a	a	DT
18637	8196	31	test	test	NN
18637	8196	32	that	that	WDT
18637	8196	33	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	8196	34	to	to	TO
18637	8196	35	have	have	VB
18637	8196	36	overtaxed	overtax	VBN
18637	8196	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8196	38	,	,	,
18637	8196	39	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	8196	40	fatally	fatally	RB
18637	8196	41	.	.	.
18637	8197	1	Burdick	Burdick	NNP
18637	8197	2	,	,	,
18637	8197	3	having	have	VBG
18637	8197	4	declined	decline	VBN
18637	8197	5	to	to	TO
18637	8197	6	testify	testify	VB
18637	8197	7	before	before	IN
18637	8197	8	a	a	DT
18637	8197	9	federal	federal	JJ
18637	8197	10	grand	grand	JJ
18637	8197	11	jury	jury	NN
18637	8197	12	on	on	IN
18637	8197	13	the	the	DT
18637	8197	14	ground	ground	NN
18637	8197	15	that	that	IN
18637	8197	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8197	17	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	8197	18	would	would	MD
18637	8197	19	tend	tend	VB
18637	8197	20	to	to	TO
18637	8197	21	incriminate	incriminate	VB
18637	8197	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8197	23	,	,	,
18637	8197	24	was	be	VBD
18637	8197	25	proffered	proffer	VBN
18637	8197	26	by	by	IN
18637	8197	27	President	President	NNP
18637	8197	28	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	8197	29	"	"	``
18637	8197	30	a	a	DT
18637	8197	31	full	full	JJ
18637	8197	32	and	and	CC
18637	8197	33	unconditional	unconditional	JJ
18637	8197	34	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8197	35	for	for	IN
18637	8197	36	all	all	DT
18637	8197	37	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	8197	38	against	against	IN
18637	8197	39	the	the	DT
18637	8197	40	United	United	NNP
18637	8197	41	States	States	NNP
18637	8197	42	"	"	''
18637	8197	43	which	which	WDT
18637	8197	44	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8197	45	might	may	MD
18637	8197	46	have	have	VB
18637	8197	47	committed	commit	VBN
18637	8197	48	or	or	CC
18637	8197	49	participated	participate	VBN
18637	8197	50	in	in	IN
18637	8197	51	in	in	IN
18637	8197	52	connection	connection	NN
18637	8197	53	with	with	IN
18637	8197	54	the	the	DT
18637	8197	55	matter	matter	NN
18637	8197	56	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8197	57	had	have	VBD
18637	8197	58	been	be	VBN
18637	8197	59	questioned	question	VBN
18637	8197	60	about	about	IN
18637	8197	61	.	.	.
18637	8198	1	Burdick	Burdick	NNP
18637	8198	2	,	,	,
18637	8198	3	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	8198	4	,	,	,
18637	8198	5	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	8198	6	to	to	TO
18637	8198	7	accept	accept	VB
18637	8198	8	the	the	DT
18637	8198	9	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8198	10	and	and	CC
18637	8198	11	persisted	persist	VBD
18637	8198	12	in	in	IN
18637	8198	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8198	14	contumacy	contumacy	NN
18637	8198	15	with	with	IN
18637	8198	16	the	the	DT
18637	8198	17	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	8198	18	support	support	NN
18637	8198	19	of	of	IN
18637	8198	20	the	the	DT
18637	8198	21	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8198	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8198	23	.	.	.
18637	8199	1	"	"	``
18637	8199	2	The	the	DT
18637	8199	3	grace	grace	NN
18637	8199	4	of	of	IN
18637	8199	5	a	a	DT
18637	8199	6	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8199	7	,	,	,
18637	8199	8	"	"	''
18637	8199	9	remarked	remark	VBD
18637	8199	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8199	11	McKenna	McKenna	NNP
18637	8199	12	sententiously	sententiously	RB
18637	8199	13	,	,	,
18637	8199	14	"	"	``
18637	8199	15	may	may	MD
18637	8199	16	be	be	VB
18637	8199	17	only	only	RB
18637	8199	18	a	a	DT
18637	8199	19	pretense	pretense	NN
18637	8199	20	*	*	NFP
18637	8199	21	*	*	NFP
18637	8199	22	*	*	NFP
18637	8199	23	involving	involve	VBG
18637	8199	24	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	8199	25	of	of	IN
18637	8199	26	even	even	RB
18637	8199	27	greater	great	JJR
18637	8199	28	disgrace	disgrace	NN
18637	8199	29	than	than	IN
18637	8199	30	those	those	DT
18637	8199	31	from	from	IN
18637	8199	32	which	which	WDT
18637	8199	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8199	34	purports	purport	VBZ
18637	8199	35	to	to	TO
18637	8199	36	relieve	relieve	VB
18637	8199	37	.	.	.
18637	8200	1	Circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	8200	2	may	may	MD
18637	8200	3	be	be	VB
18637	8200	4	made	make	VBN
18637	8200	5	to	to	TO
18637	8200	6	bring	bring	VB
18637	8200	7	innocence	innocence	NN
18637	8200	8	under	under	IN
18637	8200	9	the	the	DT
18637	8200	10	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	8200	11	of	of	IN
18637	8200	12	the	the	DT
18637	8200	13	law	law	NN
18637	8200	14	.	.	.
18637	8201	1	If	if	IN
18637	8201	2	so	so	RB
18637	8201	3	brought	bring	VBN
18637	8201	4	,	,	,
18637	8201	5	escape	escape	VB
18637	8201	6	by	by	IN
18637	8201	7	confession	confession	NN
18637	8201	8	of	of	IN
18637	8201	9	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	8201	10	implied	imply	VBN
18637	8201	11	in	in	IN
18637	8201	12	the	the	DT
18637	8201	13	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	8201	14	of	of	IN
18637	8201	15	a	a	DT
18637	8201	16	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8201	17	may	may	MD
18637	8201	18	be	be	VB
18637	8201	19	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	8201	20	,	,	,
18637	8201	21	*	*	NFP
18637	8201	22	*	*	NFP
18637	8201	23	*	*	NFP
18637	8201	24	"	"	''
18637	8201	25	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8201	26	118	118	CD
18637	8201	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8201	28	Nor	nor	CC
18637	8201	29	did	do	VBD
18637	8201	30	the	the	DT
18637	8201	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8201	32	give	give	VB
18637	8201	33	any	any	DT
18637	8201	34	attention	attention	NN
18637	8201	35	to	to	IN
18637	8201	36	the	the	DT
18637	8201	37	fact	fact	NN
18637	8201	38	that	that	IN
18637	8201	39	the	the	DT
18637	8201	40	President	President	NNP
18637	8201	41	had	have	VBD
18637	8201	42	accompanied	accompany	VBN
18637	8201	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8201	44	proffer	proffer	NN
18637	8201	45	to	to	IN
18637	8201	46	Burdick	Burdick	NNP
18637	8201	47	with	with	IN
18637	8201	48	a	a	DT
18637	8201	49	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	8201	50	,	,	,
18637	8201	51	although	although	IN
18637	8201	52	a	a	DT
18637	8201	53	similar	similar	JJ
18637	8201	54	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	8201	55	had	have	VBD
18637	8201	56	been	be	VBN
18637	8201	57	held	hold	VBN
18637	8201	58	to	to	TO
18637	8201	59	bring	bring	VB
18637	8201	60	President	President	NNP
18637	8201	61	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	8201	62	's	's	POS
18637	8201	63	amnesties	amnesty	NNS
18637	8201	64	to	to	IN
18637	8201	65	the	the	DT
18637	8201	66	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8201	67	's	's	POS
18637	8201	68	notice	notice	NN
18637	8201	69	.	.	.
18637	8202	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8202	2	119	119	CD
18637	8202	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8202	4	In	in	IN
18637	8202	5	1927	1927	CD
18637	8202	6	,	,	,
18637	8202	7	however	however	RB
18637	8202	8	,	,	,
18637	8202	9	in	in	IN
18637	8202	10	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	8202	11	the	the	DT
18637	8202	12	right	right	NN
18637	8202	13	of	of	IN
18637	8202	14	the	the	DT
18637	8202	15	President	President	NNP
18637	8202	16	to	to	TO
18637	8202	17	commute	commute	VB
18637	8202	18	a	a	DT
18637	8202	19	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	8202	20	of	of	IN
18637	8202	21	death	death	NN
18637	8202	22	to	to	IN
18637	8202	23	one	one	CD
18637	8202	24	of	of	IN
18637	8202	25	life	life	NN
18637	8202	26	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	8202	27	,	,	,
18637	8202	28	against	against	IN
18637	8202	29	the	the	DT
18637	8202	30	will	will	NN
18637	8202	31	of	of	IN
18637	8202	32	the	the	DT
18637	8202	33	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	8202	34	,	,	,
18637	8202	35	the	the	DT
18637	8202	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8202	37	abandoned	abandon	VBD
18637	8202	38	this	this	DT
18637	8202	39	view	view	NN
18637	8202	40	.	.	.
18637	8203	1	"	"	``
18637	8203	2	A	a	DT
18637	8203	3	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8203	4	in	in	IN
18637	8203	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8203	6	days	day	NNS
18637	8203	7	,	,	,
18637	8203	8	"	"	''
18637	8203	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8203	10	said	say	VBD
18637	8203	11	,	,	,
18637	8203	12	"	"	``
18637	8203	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	8203	14	not	not	RB
18637	8203	15	a	a	DT
18637	8203	16	private	private	JJ
18637	8203	17	act	act	NN
18637	8203	18	of	of	IN
18637	8203	19	grace	grace	NN
18637	8203	20	from	from	IN
18637	8203	21	an	an	DT
18637	8203	22	individual	individual	JJ
18637	8203	23	happening	happen	VBG
18637	8203	24	to	to	TO
18637	8203	25	possess	possess	VB
18637	8203	26	power	power	NN
18637	8203	27	.	.	.
18637	8204	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8204	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8204	3	a	a	DT
18637	8204	4	part	part	NN
18637	8204	5	of	of	IN
18637	8204	6	the	the	DT
18637	8204	7	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8204	8	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	8204	9	.	.	.
18637	8205	1	When	when	WRB
18637	8205	2	granted	grant	VBN
18637	8205	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8205	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	8205	5	the	the	DT
18637	8205	6	determination	determination	NN
18637	8205	7	of	of	IN
18637	8205	8	the	the	DT
18637	8205	9	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	8205	10	authority	authority	NN
18637	8205	11	that	that	IN
18637	8205	12	the	the	DT
18637	8205	13	public	public	JJ
18637	8205	14	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	8205	15	will	will	MD
18637	8205	16	be	be	VB
18637	8205	17	better	well	RBR
18637	8205	18	served	serve	VBN
18637	8205	19	by	by	IN
18637	8205	20	inflicting	inflict	VBG
18637	8205	21	less	less	JJR
18637	8205	22	than	than	IN
18637	8205	23	what	what	WP
18637	8205	24	the	the	DT
18637	8205	25	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8205	26	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	8205	27	.	.	.
18637	8206	1	"	"	``
18637	8206	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8206	3	120	120	CD
18637	8206	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8206	5	Whether	whether	IN
18637	8206	6	these	these	DT
18637	8206	7	words	word	NNS
18637	8206	8	sound	sound	VBP
18637	8206	9	the	the	DT
18637	8206	10	death	death	NN
18637	8206	11	knell	knell	NN
18637	8206	12	of	of	IN
18637	8206	13	the	the	DT
18637	8206	14	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	8206	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	8206	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	8206	17	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	8206	18	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
18637	8206	19	.	.	.
18637	8207	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8207	2	121	121	CD
18637	8207	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8207	4	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8207	5	seem	seem	VBP
18637	8207	6	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	8207	7	to	to	TO
18637	8207	8	indicate	indicate	VB
18637	8207	9	that	that	IN
18637	8207	10	by	by	IN
18637	8207	11	substantiating	substantiate	VBG
18637	8207	12	a	a	DT
18637	8207	13	commutation	commutation	NN
18637	8207	14	order	order	NN
18637	8207	15	for	for	IN
18637	8207	16	a	a	DT
18637	8207	17	deed	deed	NN
18637	8207	18	of	of	IN
18637	8207	19	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8207	20	,	,	,
18637	8207	21	a	a	DT
18637	8207	22	President	President	NNP
18637	8207	23	can	can	MD
18637	8207	24	always	always	RB
18637	8207	25	have	have	VB
18637	8207	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8207	27	way	way	NN
18637	8207	28	in	in	IN
18637	8207	29	such	such	JJ
18637	8207	30	matters	matter	NNS
18637	8207	31	,	,	,
18637	8207	32	provided	provide	VBD
18637	8207	33	the	the	DT
18637	8207	34	substituted	substituted	JJ
18637	8207	35	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	8207	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	8207	37	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8207	38	by	by	IN
18637	8207	39	law	law	NN
18637	8207	40	and	and	CC
18637	8207	41	does	do	VBZ
18637	8207	42	not	not	RB
18637	8207	43	in	in	IN
18637	8207	44	common	common	JJ
18637	8207	45	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	8207	46	exceed	exceed	VB
18637	8207	47	the	the	DT
18637	8207	48	original	original	JJ
18637	8207	49	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	8207	50	.	.	.
18637	8208	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8208	2	122	122	CD
18637	8208	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8208	4	SCOPE	scope	NN
18637	8208	5	OF	of	IN
18637	8208	6	THE	the	DT
18637	8208	7	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	8208	8	The	the	DT
18637	8208	9	power	power	NN
18637	8208	10	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	8208	11	all	all	DT
18637	8208	12	"	"	``
18637	8208	13	offences	offence	NNS
18637	8208	14	against	against	IN
18637	8208	15	the	the	DT
18637	8208	16	United	United	NNP
18637	8208	17	States	States	NNP
18637	8208	18	,	,	,
18637	8208	19	"	"	''
18637	8208	20	except	except	IN
18637	8208	21	cases	case	NNS
18637	8208	22	of	of	IN
18637	8208	23	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	8208	24	,	,	,
18637	8208	25	and	and	CC
18637	8208	26	includes	include	VBZ
18637	8208	27	the	the	DT
18637	8208	28	power	power	NN
18637	8208	29	to	to	TO
18637	8208	30	remit	remit	VB
18637	8208	31	fines	fine	NNS
18637	8208	32	,	,	,
18637	8208	33	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	8208	34	,	,	,
18637	8208	35	and	and	CC
18637	8208	36	forfeitures	forfeiture	NNS
18637	8208	37	,	,	,
18637	8208	38	except	except	IN
18637	8208	39	as	as	IN
18637	8208	40	to	to	IN
18637	8208	41	money	money	NN
18637	8208	42	covered	cover	VBN
18637	8208	43	into	into	IN
18637	8208	44	the	the	DT
18637	8208	45	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	8208	46	or	or	CC
18637	8208	47	paid	pay	VBD
18637	8208	48	an	an	DT
18637	8208	49	informer;[123	informer;[123	XX
18637	8208	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8208	51	also	also	RB
18637	8208	52	the	the	DT
18637	8208	53	power	power	NN
18637	8208	54	to	to	TO
18637	8208	55	pardon	pardon	VB
18637	8208	56	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	8208	57	or	or	CC
18637	8208	58	conditionally	conditionally	RB
18637	8208	59	;	;	:
18637	8208	60	and	and	CC
18637	8208	61	includes	include	VBZ
18637	8208	62	the	the	DT
18637	8208	63	power	power	NN
18637	8208	64	to	to	TO
18637	8208	65	commute	commute	VB
18637	8208	66	sentences	sentence	NNS
18637	8208	67	,	,	,
18637	8208	68	which	which	WDT
18637	8208	69	,	,	,
18637	8208	70	as	as	IN
18637	8208	71	seen	see	VBN
18637	8208	72	above	above	RB
18637	8208	73	,	,	,
18637	8208	74	is	be	VBZ
18637	8208	75	effective	effective	JJ
18637	8208	76	without	without	IN
18637	8208	77	the	the	DT
18637	8208	78	convict	convict	NN
18637	8208	79	's	's	POS
18637	8208	80	consent	consent	NN
18637	8208	81	.	.	.
18637	8209	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8209	2	124	124	CD
18637	8209	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8209	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8209	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	8209	6	been	be	VBN
18637	8209	7	held	hold	VBN
18637	8209	8	,	,	,
18637	8209	9	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	8209	10	,	,	,
18637	8209	11	in	in	IN
18637	8209	12	face	face	NN
18637	8209	13	of	of	IN
18637	8209	14	earlier	early	JJR
18637	8209	15	English	english	JJ
18637	8209	16	practice	practice	NN
18637	8209	17	,	,	,
18637	8209	18	that	that	DT
18637	8209	19	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	8209	20	suspension	suspension	NN
18637	8209	21	of	of	IN
18637	8209	22	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	8209	23	by	by	IN
18637	8209	24	a	a	DT
18637	8209	25	court	court	NN
18637	8209	26	of	of	IN
18637	8209	27	the	the	DT
18637	8209	28	United	United	NNP
18637	8209	29	States	States	NNP
18637	8209	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	8209	31	an	an	DT
18637	8209	32	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	8209	33	of	of	IN
18637	8209	34	the	the	DT
18637	8209	35	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8209	36	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	8209	37	,	,	,
18637	8209	38	amounting	amount	VBG
18637	8209	39	as	as	IN
18637	8209	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8209	41	does	do	VBZ
18637	8209	42	to	to	IN
18637	8209	43	a	a	DT
18637	8209	44	condonation	condonation	NN
18637	8209	45	of	of	IN
18637	8209	46	the	the	DT
18637	8209	47	offense	offense	NN
18637	8209	48	.	.	.
18637	8210	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8210	2	125	125	CD
18637	8210	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8210	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8210	5	was	be	VBD
18637	8210	6	early	early	RB
18637	8210	7	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	8210	8	that	that	IN
18637	8210	9	the	the	DT
18637	8210	10	power	power	NN
18637	8210	11	included	include	VBD
18637	8210	12	the	the	DT
18637	8210	13	power	power	NN
18637	8210	14	to	to	TO
18637	8210	15	pardon	pardon	VB
18637	8210	16	specified	specify	VBN
18637	8210	17	classes	class	NNS
18637	8210	18	or	or	CC
18637	8210	19	communities	community	NNS
18637	8210	20	wholesale	wholesale	JJ
18637	8210	21	,	,	,
18637	8210	22	in	in	IN
18637	8210	23	short	short	JJ
18637	8210	24	,	,	,
18637	8210	25	the	the	DT
18637	8210	26	power	power	NN
18637	8210	27	to	to	IN
18637	8210	28	amnesty	amnesty	NNP
18637	8210	29	,	,	,
18637	8210	30	which	which	WDT
18637	8210	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	8210	32	usually	usually	RB
18637	8210	33	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	8210	34	by	by	IN
18637	8210	35	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	8210	36	.	.	.
18637	8211	1	General	general	JJ
18637	8211	2	amnesties	amnesty	NNS
18637	8211	3	were	be	VBD
18637	8211	4	issued	issue	VBN
18637	8211	5	by	by	IN
18637	8211	6	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	8211	7	in	in	IN
18637	8211	8	1795	1795	CD
18637	8211	9	,	,	,
18637	8211	10	by	by	IN
18637	8211	11	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	8211	12	in	in	IN
18637	8211	13	1800	1800	CD
18637	8211	14	,	,	,
18637	8211	15	by	by	IN
18637	8211	16	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8211	17	in	in	IN
18637	8211	18	1815	1815	CD
18637	8211	19	,	,	,
18637	8211	20	by	by	IN
18637	8211	21	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	8211	22	in	in	IN
18637	8211	23	1863	1863	CD
18637	8211	24	,	,	,
18637	8211	25	by	by	IN
18637	8211	26	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	8211	27	in	in	IN
18637	8211	28	1865	1865	CD
18637	8211	29	,	,	,
18637	8211	30	1867	1867	CD
18637	8211	31	,	,	,
18637	8211	32	and	and	CC
18637	8211	33	1868	1868	CD
18637	8211	34	,	,	,
18637	8211	35	and	and	CC
18637	8211	36	by	by	IN
18637	8211	37	the	the	DT
18637	8211	38	first	first	JJ
18637	8211	39	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8211	40	--	--	:
18637	8211	41	to	to	IN
18637	8211	42	Aguinaldo	Aguinaldo	NNP
18637	8211	43	's	's	POS
18637	8211	44	followers	follower	NNS
18637	8211	45	--	--	:
18637	8211	46	in	in	IN
18637	8211	47	1902	1902	CD
18637	8211	48	.	.	.
18637	8212	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8212	2	126	126	CD
18637	8212	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8212	4	Not	not	RB
18637	8212	5	,	,	,
18637	8212	6	however	however	RB
18637	8212	7	,	,	,
18637	8212	8	till	till	IN
18637	8212	9	after	after	IN
18637	8212	10	the	the	DT
18637	8212	11	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	8212	12	War	War	NNP
18637	8212	13	was	be	VBD
18637	8212	14	the	the	DT
18637	8212	15	point	point	NN
18637	8212	16	adjudicated	adjudicate	VBN
18637	8212	17	,	,	,
18637	8212	18	when	when	WRB
18637	8212	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8212	20	was	be	VBD
18637	8212	21	decided	decide	VBN
18637	8212	22	in	in	IN
18637	8212	23	favor	favor	NN
18637	8212	24	of	of	IN
18637	8212	25	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8212	26	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	8212	27	.	.	.
18637	8213	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8213	2	127	127	CD
18637	8213	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8213	4	"	"	``
18637	8213	5	OFFENSES	OFFENSES	NNP
18637	8213	6	AGAINST	against	IN
18637	8213	7	THE	the	DT
18637	8213	8	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	8213	9	STATES	STATES	NNP
18637	8213	10	"	"	''
18637	8213	11	;	;	:
18637	8213	12	CONTEMPT	CONTEMPT	NNP
18637	8213	13	OF	of	IN
18637	8213	14	COURT	COURT	NNP
18637	8213	15	In	in	IN
18637	8213	16	the	the	DT
18637	8213	17	first	first	JJ
18637	8213	18	place	place	NN
18637	8213	19	,	,	,
18637	8213	20	such	such	JJ
18637	8213	21	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	8213	22	are	be	VBP
18637	8213	23	not	not	RB
18637	8213	24	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	8213	25	against	against	IN
18637	8213	26	the	the	DT
18637	8213	27	States	States	NNP
18637	8213	28	.	.	.
18637	8214	1	In	in	IN
18637	8214	2	the	the	DT
18637	8214	3	second	second	JJ
18637	8214	4	place	place	NN
18637	8214	5	,	,	,
18637	8214	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8214	7	are	be	VBP
18637	8214	8	completed	complete	VBN
18637	8214	9	offenses;[128	offenses;[128	ADD
18637	8214	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8214	11	the	the	DT
18637	8214	12	President	President	NNP
18637	8214	13	can	can	MD
18637	8214	14	not	not	RB
18637	8214	15	pardon	pardon	VB
18637	8214	16	by	by	IN
18637	8214	17	anticipation	anticipation	NN
18637	8214	18	,	,	,
18637	8214	19	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	8214	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8214	21	would	would	MD
18637	8214	22	be	be	VB
18637	8214	23	invested	invest	VBN
18637	8214	24	with	with	IN
18637	8214	25	the	the	DT
18637	8214	26	power	power	NN
18637	8214	27	to	to	TO
18637	8214	28	dispense	dispense	VB
18637	8214	29	with	with	IN
18637	8214	30	the	the	DT
18637	8214	31	laws	law	NNS
18637	8214	32	,	,	,
18637	8214	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8214	34	claim	claim	NN
18637	8214	35	to	to	TO
18637	8214	36	which	which	WDT
18637	8214	37	was	be	VBD
18637	8214	38	the	the	DT
18637	8214	39	principal	principal	JJ
18637	8214	40	cause	cause	NN
18637	8214	41	of	of	IN
18637	8214	42	James	James	NNP
18637	8214	43	II	II	NNP
18637	8214	44	's	's	POS
18637	8214	45	forced	force	VBN
18637	8214	46	abdication	abdication	NN
18637	8214	47	.	.	.
18637	8215	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8215	2	129	129	CD
18637	8215	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8215	4	Lastly	Lastly	NNP
18637	8215	5	,	,	,
18637	8215	6	the	the	DT
18637	8215	7	term	term	NN
18637	8215	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	8215	9	been	be	VBN
18637	8215	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	8215	11	to	to	TO
18637	8215	12	include	include	VB
18637	8215	13	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	8215	14	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	8215	15	of	of	IN
18637	8215	16	court	court	NN
18637	8215	17	.	.	.
18637	8216	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	8216	2	was	be	VBD
18637	8216	3	the	the	DT
18637	8216	4	holding	holding	NN
18637	8216	5	in	in	IN
18637	8216	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	8216	7	parte	parte	NN
18637	8216	8	Grossman,[130	Grossman,[130	NNP
18637	8216	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8216	10	where	where	WRB
18637	8216	11	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8216	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8216	13	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	8216	14	,	,	,
18637	8216	15	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8216	16	for	for	IN
18637	8216	17	the	the	DT
18637	8216	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8216	19	,	,	,
18637	8216	20	resorted	resort	VBD
18637	8216	21	once	once	RB
18637	8216	22	more	more	JJR
18637	8216	23	to	to	IN
18637	8216	24	English	english	JJ
18637	8216	25	conceptions	conception	NNS
18637	8216	26	as	as	IN
18637	8216	27	being	be	VBG
18637	8216	28	authoritative	authoritative	JJ
18637	8216	29	in	in	IN
18637	8216	30	construing	construe	VBG
18637	8216	31	this	this	DT
18637	8216	32	clause	clause	NN
18637	8216	33	of	of	IN
18637	8216	34	the	the	DT
18637	8216	35	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8216	36	.	.	.
18637	8217	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	8217	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8217	3	:	:	:
18637	8217	4	"	"	``
18637	8217	5	The	the	DT
18637	8217	6	King	King	NNP
18637	8217	7	of	of	IN
18637	8217	8	England	England	NNP
18637	8217	9	before	before	IN
18637	8217	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8217	11	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
18637	8217	12	,	,	,
18637	8217	13	in	in	IN
18637	8217	14	the	the	DT
18637	8217	15	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	8217	16	of	of	IN
18637	8217	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8217	18	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	8217	19	,	,	,
18637	8217	20	had	have	VBD
18637	8217	21	always	always	RB
18637	8217	22	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	8217	23	the	the	DT
18637	8217	24	power	power	NN
18637	8217	25	to	to	TO
18637	8217	26	pardon	pardon	VB
18637	8217	27	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	8217	28	of	of	IN
18637	8217	29	court	court	NN
18637	8217	30	,	,	,
18637	8217	31	just	just	RB
18637	8217	32	as	as	IN
18637	8217	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8217	34	did	do	VBD
18637	8217	35	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	8217	36	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	8217	37	and	and	CC
18637	8217	38	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
18637	8217	39	and	and	CC
18637	8217	40	as	as	IN
18637	8217	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8217	42	has	have	VBZ
18637	8217	43	done	do	VBN
18637	8217	44	to	to	IN
18637	8217	45	the	the	DT
18637	8217	46	present	present	JJ
18637	8217	47	day	day	NN
18637	8217	48	.	.	.
18637	8218	1	In	in	IN
18637	8218	2	the	the	DT
18637	8218	3	mind	mind	NN
18637	8218	4	of	of	IN
18637	8218	5	a	a	DT
18637	8218	6	common	common	JJ
18637	8218	7	law	law	NN
18637	8218	8	lawyer	lawyer	NN
18637	8218	9	of	of	IN
18637	8218	10	the	the	DT
18637	8218	11	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
18637	8218	12	century	century	NN
18637	8218	13	the	the	DT
18637	8218	14	word	word	NN
18637	8218	15	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8218	16	included	include	VBD
18637	8218	17	within	within	IN
18637	8218	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8218	19	scope	scope	NN
18637	8218	20	the	the	DT
18637	8218	21	ending	ending	NN
18637	8218	22	by	by	IN
18637	8218	23	the	the	DT
18637	8218	24	King	King	NNP
18637	8218	25	's	's	POS
18637	8218	26	grace	grace	NN
18637	8218	27	of	of	IN
18637	8218	28	the	the	DT
18637	8218	29	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	8218	30	of	of	IN
18637	8218	31	such	such	JJ
18637	8218	32	derelictions	dereliction	NNS
18637	8218	33	,	,	,
18637	8218	34	whether	whether	IN
18637	8218	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8218	36	was	be	VBD
18637	8218	37	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	8218	38	by	by	IN
18637	8218	39	the	the	DT
18637	8218	40	court	court	NN
18637	8218	41	without	without	IN
18637	8218	42	a	a	DT
18637	8218	43	jury	jury	NN
18637	8218	44	or	or	CC
18637	8218	45	upon	upon	IN
18637	8218	46	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	8218	47	,	,	,
18637	8218	48	for	for	IN
18637	8218	49	both	both	DT
18637	8218	50	forms	form	NNS
18637	8218	51	of	of	IN
18637	8218	52	trial	trial	NN
18637	8218	53	for	for	IN
18637	8218	54	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	8218	55	were	be	VBD
18637	8218	56	had	have	VBN
18637	8218	57	.	.	.
18637	8219	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8219	2	Citing	cite	VBG
18637	8219	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	8219	4	.	.	.
18637	8219	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8220	1	These	these	DT
18637	8220	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	8220	3	also	also	RB
18637	8220	4	show	show	VBP
18637	8220	5	that	that	IN
18637	8220	6	,	,	,
18637	8220	7	long	long	RB
18637	8220	8	before	before	IN
18637	8220	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8220	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8220	11	,	,	,
18637	8220	12	a	a	DT
18637	8220	13	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	8220	14	had	have	VBD
18637	8220	15	been	be	VBN
18637	8220	16	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	8220	17	at	at	IN
18637	8220	18	common	common	JJ
18637	8220	19	law	law	NN
18637	8220	20	between	between	IN
18637	8220	21	the	the	DT
18637	8220	22	effect	effect	NN
18637	8220	23	of	of	IN
18637	8220	24	the	the	DT
18637	8220	25	King	King	NNP
18637	8220	26	's	's	POS
18637	8220	27	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8220	28	to	to	TO
18637	8220	29	wipe	wipe	VB
18637	8220	30	out	out	RP
18637	8220	31	the	the	DT
18637	8220	32	effect	effect	NN
18637	8220	33	of	of	IN
18637	8220	34	a	a	DT
18637	8220	35	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	8220	36	for	for	IN
18637	8220	37	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	8220	38	in	in	RP
18637	8220	39	so	so	RB
18637	8220	40	far	far	RB
18637	8220	41	as	as	IN
18637	8220	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8220	43	had	have	VBD
18637	8220	44	been	be	VBN
18637	8220	45	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	8220	46	to	to	TO
18637	8220	47	punish	punish	VB
18637	8220	48	the	the	DT
18637	8220	49	contemnor	contemnor	NN
18637	8220	50	for	for	IN
18637	8220	51	violating	violate	VBG
18637	8220	52	the	the	DT
18637	8220	53	dignity	dignity	NN
18637	8220	54	of	of	IN
18637	8220	55	the	the	DT
18637	8220	56	court	court	NN
18637	8220	57	and	and	CC
18637	8220	58	the	the	DT
18637	8220	59	King	King	NNP
18637	8220	60	,	,	,
18637	8220	61	in	in	IN
18637	8220	62	the	the	DT
18637	8220	63	public	public	JJ
18637	8220	64	interest	interest	NN
18637	8220	65	,	,	,
18637	8220	66	and	and	CC
18637	8220	67	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8220	68	inefficacy	inefficacy	NN
18637	8220	69	to	to	TO
18637	8220	70	halt	halt	VB
18637	8220	71	or	or	CC
18637	8220	72	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	8220	73	with	with	IN
18637	8220	74	the	the	DT
18637	8220	75	remedial	remedial	JJ
18637	8220	76	part	part	NN
18637	8220	77	of	of	IN
18637	8220	78	the	the	DT
18637	8220	79	court	court	NN
18637	8220	80	's	's	POS
18637	8220	81	order	order	NN
18637	8220	82	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8220	83	to	to	TO
18637	8220	84	secure	secure	VB
18637	8220	85	the	the	DT
18637	8220	86	rights	right	NNS
18637	8220	87	of	of	IN
18637	8220	88	the	the	DT
18637	8220	89	injured	injure	VBN
18637	8220	90	suitor	suitor	NN
18637	8220	91	.	.	.
18637	8221	1	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
18637	8221	2	IV	IV	NNP
18637	8221	3	,	,	,
18637	8221	4	285	285	CD
18637	8221	5	,	,	,
18637	8221	6	397	397	CD
18637	8221	7	,	,	,
18637	8221	8	398	398	CD
18637	8221	9	;	;	:
18637	8221	10	Hawkins	Hawkins	NNP
18637	8221	11	Pleas	Pleas	NNPS
18637	8221	12	of	of	IN
18637	8221	13	the	the	DT
18637	8221	14	Crown	Crown	NNP
18637	8221	15	,	,	,
18637	8221	16	6th	6th	NN
18637	8221	17	Ed	Ed	NNP
18637	8221	18	.	.	.
18637	8222	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8222	2	1787	1787	CD
18637	8222	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8222	4	,	,	,
18637	8222	5	Vol	Vol	NNP
18637	8222	6	.	.	.
18637	8223	1	2	2	CD
18637	8223	2	,	,	,
18637	8223	3	553	553	CD
18637	8223	4	.	.	.
18637	8224	1	The	the	DT
18637	8224	2	same	same	JJ
18637	8224	3	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	8224	4	,	,	,
18637	8224	5	nowadays	nowadays	RB
18637	8224	6	referred	refer	VBD
18637	8224	7	to	to	IN
18637	8224	8	as	as	IN
18637	8224	9	the	the	DT
18637	8224	10	difference	difference	NN
18637	8224	11	between	between	IN
18637	8224	12	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8224	13	and	and	CC
18637	8224	14	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	8224	15	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	8224	16	,	,	,
18637	8224	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	8224	18	still	still	RB
18637	8224	19	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	8224	20	in	in	IN
18637	8224	21	English	English	NNP
18637	8224	22	law[131	law[131	NNP
18637	8224	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8224	24	.	.	.
18637	8224	25	"	"	''
18637	8225	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	8225	2	was	be	VBD
18637	8225	3	any	any	DT
18637	8225	4	new	new	JJ
18637	8225	5	or	or	CC
18637	8225	6	special	special	JJ
18637	8225	7	danger	danger	NN
18637	8225	8	to	to	TO
18637	8225	9	be	be	VB
18637	8225	10	apprehended	apprehend	VBN
18637	8225	11	from	from	IN
18637	8225	12	this	this	DT
18637	8225	13	view	view	NN
18637	8225	14	of	of	IN
18637	8225	15	the	the	DT
18637	8225	16	pardoning	pardon	VBG
18637	8225	17	power	power	NN
18637	8225	18	.	.	.
18637	8226	1	"	"	``
18637	8226	2	If	if	IN
18637	8226	3	,	,	,
18637	8226	4	"	"	''
18637	8226	5	says	say	VBZ
18637	8226	6	the	the	DT
18637	8226	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8226	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8226	9	,	,	,
18637	8226	10	"	"	``
18637	8226	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8226	12	could	could	MD
18637	8226	13	conjure	conjure	VB
18637	8226	14	up	up	RP
18637	8226	15	in	in	IN
18637	8226	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8226	17	minds	mind	NNS
18637	8226	18	a	a	DT
18637	8226	19	President	President	NNP
18637	8226	20	willing	willing	JJ
18637	8226	21	to	to	TO
18637	8226	22	paralyze	paralyze	VB
18637	8226	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	8226	24	by	by	IN
18637	8226	25	pardoning	pardon	VBG
18637	8226	26	all	all	DT
18637	8226	27	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	8226	28	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	8226	29	,	,	,
18637	8226	30	why	why	WRB
18637	8226	31	not	not	RB
18637	8226	32	a	a	DT
18637	8226	33	President	President	NNP
18637	8226	34	ordering	order	VBG
18637	8226	35	a	a	DT
18637	8226	36	general	general	JJ
18637	8226	37	jail	jail	NN
18637	8226	38	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	8226	39	?	?	.
18637	8226	40	"	"	''
18637	8227	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	8227	2	,	,	,
18637	8227	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8227	4	queries	query	VBZ
18637	8227	5	further	far	RBR
18637	8227	6	,	,	,
18637	8227	7	in	in	IN
18637	8227	8	view	view	NN
18637	8227	9	of	of	IN
18637	8227	10	the	the	DT
18637	8227	11	peculiarities	peculiarity	NNS
18637	8227	12	of	of	IN
18637	8227	13	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	8227	14	in	in	IN
18637	8227	15	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	8227	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	8227	17	,	,	,
18637	8227	18	"	"	``
18637	8227	19	may	may	MD
18637	8227	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8227	21	not	not	RB
18637	8227	22	be	be	VB
18637	8227	23	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	8227	24	said	say	VBN
18637	8227	25	that	that	IN
18637	8227	26	in	in	IN
18637	8227	27	order	order	NN
18637	8227	28	to	to	TO
18637	8227	29	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	8227	30	possible	possible	JJ
18637	8227	31	mistake	mistake	NN
18637	8227	32	,	,	,
18637	8227	33	undue	undue	JJ
18637	8227	34	prejudice	prejudice	NN
18637	8227	35	or	or	CC
18637	8227	36	needless	needless	JJ
18637	8227	37	severity	severity	NN
18637	8227	38	,	,	,
18637	8227	39	the	the	DT
18637	8227	40	chance	chance	NN
18637	8227	41	of	of	IN
18637	8227	42	pardon	pardon	NNP
18637	8227	43	should	should	MD
18637	8227	44	exist	exist	VB
18637	8227	45	at	at	IN
18637	8227	46	least	least	JJS
18637	8227	47	as	as	RB
18637	8227	48	much	much	RB
18637	8227	49	in	in	IN
18637	8227	50	favor	favor	NN
18637	8227	51	of	of	IN
18637	8227	52	a	a	DT
18637	8227	53	person	person	NN
18637	8227	54	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	8227	55	by	by	IN
18637	8227	56	a	a	DT
18637	8227	57	judge	judge	NN
18637	8227	58	without	without	IN
18637	8227	59	a	a	DT
18637	8227	60	jury	jury	NN
18637	8227	61	as	as	IN
18637	8227	62	in	in	IN
18637	8227	63	favor	favor	NN
18637	8227	64	of	of	IN
18637	8227	65	one	one	CD
18637	8227	66	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	8227	67	in	in	IN
18637	8227	68	a	a	DT
18637	8227	69	jury	jury	NN
18637	8227	70	trial[132	trial[132	NN
18637	8227	71	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8227	72	?	?	.
18637	8227	73	"	"	''
18637	8228	1	EFFECTS	effect	NNS
18637	8228	2	OF	of	IN
18637	8228	3	A	a	DT
18637	8228	4	PARDON	PARDON	NNP
18637	8228	5	;	;	:
18637	8228	6	EX	EX	NNP
18637	8228	7	PARTE	PARTE	NNP
18637	8228	8	GARLAND	GARLAND	VBD
18637	8228	9	The	the	DT
18637	8228	10	great	great	JJ
18637	8228	11	leading	leading	JJ
18637	8228	12	case	case	NN
18637	8228	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	8228	14	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	8228	15	parte	parte	NNP
18637	8228	16	Garland[133	Garland[133	NNP
18637	8228	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8228	18	which	which	WDT
18637	8228	19	was	be	VBD
18637	8228	20	decided	decide	VBN
18637	8228	21	shortly	shortly	RB
18637	8228	22	after	after	IN
18637	8228	23	the	the	DT
18637	8228	24	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	8228	25	War	War	NNP
18637	8228	26	.	.	.
18637	8229	1	By	by	IN
18637	8229	2	an	an	DT
18637	8229	3	act	act	NN
18637	8229	4	passed	pass	VBN
18637	8229	5	in	in	IN
18637	8229	6	1865	1865	CD
18637	8229	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8229	8	had	have	VBD
18637	8229	9	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	8229	10	that	that	IN
18637	8229	11	before	before	IN
18637	8229	12	any	any	DT
18637	8229	13	person	person	NN
18637	8229	14	should	should	MD
18637	8229	15	be	be	VB
18637	8229	16	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	8229	17	to	to	TO
18637	8229	18	practice	practice	VB
18637	8229	19	in	in	IN
18637	8229	20	a	a	DT
18637	8229	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	8229	22	court	court	NN
18637	8229	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8229	24	must	must	MD
18637	8229	25	take	take	VB
18637	8229	26	oath	oath	NN
18637	8229	27	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	8229	28	that	that	IN
18637	8229	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8229	30	had	have	VBD
18637	8229	31	never	never	RB
18637	8229	32	voluntarily	voluntarily	RB
18637	8229	33	borne	bear	VBN
18637	8229	34	arms	arm	NNS
18637	8229	35	against	against	IN
18637	8229	36	the	the	DT
18637	8229	37	United	United	NNP
18637	8229	38	States	States	NNP
18637	8229	39	,	,	,
18637	8229	40	had	have	VBD
18637	8229	41	never	never	RB
18637	8229	42	given	give	VBN
18637	8229	43	aid	aid	NN
18637	8229	44	or	or	CC
18637	8229	45	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	8229	46	to	to	IN
18637	8229	47	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	8229	48	of	of	IN
18637	8229	49	the	the	DT
18637	8229	50	United	United	NNP
18637	8229	51	States	States	NNP
18637	8229	52	,	,	,
18637	8229	53	and	and	CC
18637	8229	54	so	so	RB
18637	8229	55	on	on	RB
18637	8229	56	.	.	.
18637	8230	1	Garland	Garland	NNP
18637	8230	2	,	,	,
18637	8230	3	who	who	WP
18637	8230	4	had	have	VBD
18637	8230	5	been	be	VBN
18637	8230	6	a	a	DT
18637	8230	7	Confederate	Confederate	NNP
18637	8230	8	sympathizer	sympathizer	NN
18637	8230	9	and	and	CC
18637	8230	10	so	so	RB
18637	8230	11	was	be	VBD
18637	8230	12	unable	unable	JJ
18637	8230	13	to	to	TO
18637	8230	14	take	take	VB
18637	8230	15	the	the	DT
18637	8230	16	oath	oath	NN
18637	8230	17	,	,	,
18637	8230	18	had	have	VBD
18637	8230	19	however	however	RB
18637	8230	20	received	receive	VBN
18637	8230	21	from	from	IN
18637	8230	22	President	President	NNP
18637	8230	23	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	8230	24	the	the	DT
18637	8230	25	same	same	JJ
18637	8230	26	year	year	NN
18637	8230	27	"	"	``
18637	8230	28	a	a	DT
18637	8230	29	full	full	JJ
18637	8230	30	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8230	31	'	'	''
18637	8230	32	for	for	IN
18637	8230	33	all	all	DT
18637	8230	34	offences	offence	NNS
18637	8230	35	by	by	IN
18637	8230	36	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8230	37	committed	commit	VBD
18637	8230	38	,	,	,
18637	8230	39	arising	arise	VBG
18637	8230	40	from	from	IN
18637	8230	41	participation	participation	NN
18637	8230	42	,	,	,
18637	8230	43	direct	direct	JJ
18637	8230	44	or	or	CC
18637	8230	45	implied	imply	VBN
18637	8230	46	,	,	,
18637	8230	47	in	in	IN
18637	8230	48	the	the	DT
18637	8230	49	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
18637	8230	50	,	,	,
18637	8230	51	'	'	''
18637	8230	52	*	*	NFP
18637	8230	53	*	*	NFP
18637	8230	54	*	*	NFP
18637	8230	55	"	"	``
18637	8230	56	The	the	DT
18637	8230	57	question	question	NN
18637	8230	58	before	before	IN
18637	8230	59	the	the	DT
18637	8230	60	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8230	61	was	be	VBD
18637	8230	62	whether	whether	IN
18637	8230	63	,	,	,
18637	8230	64	armed	arm	VBN
18637	8230	65	with	with	IN
18637	8230	66	this	this	DT
18637	8230	67	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8230	68	,	,	,
18637	8230	69	Garland	Garland	NNP
18637	8230	70	was	be	VBD
18637	8230	71	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	8230	72	to	to	TO
18637	8230	73	practice	practice	VB
18637	8230	74	in	in	IN
18637	8230	75	the	the	DT
18637	8230	76	federal	federal	JJ
18637	8230	77	courts	court	NNS
18637	8230	78	despite	despite	IN
18637	8230	79	the	the	DT
18637	8230	80	act	act	NN
18637	8230	81	of	of	IN
18637	8230	82	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8230	83	just	just	RB
18637	8230	84	mentioned	mention	VBD
18637	8230	85	.	.	.
18637	8231	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	8231	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8231	3	Field	Field	NNP
18637	8231	4	for	for	IN
18637	8231	5	a	a	DT
18637	8231	6	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	8231	7	divided	divide	VBN
18637	8231	8	Court	court	NN
18637	8231	9	:	:	:
18637	8231	10	"	"	``
18637	8231	11	The	the	DT
18637	8231	12	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	8231	13	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	8231	14	as	as	IN
18637	8231	15	to	to	IN
18637	8231	16	the	the	DT
18637	8231	17	effect	effect	NN
18637	8231	18	and	and	CC
18637	8231	19	operation	operation	NN
18637	8231	20	of	of	IN
18637	8231	21	a	a	DT
18637	8231	22	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8231	23	,	,	,
18637	8231	24	and	and	CC
18637	8231	25	on	on	IN
18637	8231	26	this	this	DT
18637	8231	27	point	point	NN
18637	8231	28	all	all	PDT
18637	8231	29	the	the	DT
18637	8231	30	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	8231	31	concur	concur	VBP
18637	8231	32	.	.	.
18637	8232	1	A	a	DT
18637	8232	2	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8232	3	reaches	reach	VBZ
18637	8232	4	both	both	CC
18637	8232	5	the	the	DT
18637	8232	6	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	8232	7	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	8232	8	for	for	IN
18637	8232	9	the	the	DT
18637	8232	10	offence	offence	NN
18637	8232	11	and	and	CC
18637	8232	12	the	the	DT
18637	8232	13	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	8232	14	of	of	IN
18637	8232	15	the	the	DT
18637	8232	16	offender	offender	NN
18637	8232	17	;	;	,
18637	8232	18	and	and	CC
18637	8232	19	when	when	WRB
18637	8232	20	the	the	DT
18637	8232	21	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8232	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	8232	23	full	full	JJ
18637	8232	24	,	,	,
18637	8232	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8232	26	releases	release	VBZ
18637	8232	27	the	the	DT
18637	8232	28	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	8232	29	and	and	CC
18637	8232	30	blots	blot	NNS
18637	8232	31	out	out	IN
18637	8232	32	of	of	IN
18637	8232	33	existence	existence	NN
18637	8232	34	the	the	DT
18637	8232	35	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	8232	36	,	,	,
18637	8232	37	so	so	IN
18637	8232	38	that	that	IN
18637	8232	39	in	in	IN
18637	8232	40	the	the	DT
18637	8232	41	eye	eye	NN
18637	8232	42	of	of	IN
18637	8232	43	the	the	DT
18637	8232	44	law	law	NN
18637	8232	45	the	the	DT
18637	8232	46	offender	offender	NN
18637	8232	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	8232	48	as	as	RB
18637	8232	49	innocent	innocent	JJ
18637	8232	50	as	as	IN
18637	8232	51	if	if	IN
18637	8232	52	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8232	53	had	have	VBD
18637	8232	54	never	never	RB
18637	8232	55	committed	commit	VBN
18637	8232	56	the	the	DT
18637	8232	57	offense	offense	NN
18637	8232	58	.	.	.
18637	8233	1	If	if	IN
18637	8233	2	granted	grant	VBN
18637	8233	3	before	before	IN
18637	8233	4	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	8233	5	,	,	,
18637	8233	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8233	7	prevents	prevent	VBZ
18637	8233	8	any	any	DT
18637	8233	9	of	of	IN
18637	8233	10	the	the	DT
18637	8233	11	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	8233	12	and	and	CC
18637	8233	13	disabilities	disability	NNS
18637	8233	14	consequent	consequent	NN
18637	8233	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	8233	16	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	8233	17	from	from	IN
18637	8233	18	attaching	attach	VBG
18637	8233	19	;	;	:
18637	8233	20	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8233	21	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	8233	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8233	23	,	,	,
18637	8233	24	if	if	IN
18637	8233	25	granted	grant	VBN
18637	8233	26	after	after	IN
18637	8233	27	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	8233	28	,	,	,
18637	8233	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8233	30	removes	remove	VBZ
18637	8233	31	the	the	DT
18637	8233	32	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	8233	33	and	and	CC
18637	8233	34	disabilities	disability	NNS
18637	8233	35	,	,	,
18637	8233	36	and	and	CC
18637	8233	37	restores	restore	VBZ
18637	8233	38	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8233	39	to	to	IN
18637	8233	40	all	all	DT
18637	8233	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8233	42	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8233	43	rights	right	NNS
18637	8233	44	;	;	:
18637	8233	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8233	46	makes	make	VBZ
18637	8233	47	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8233	48	,	,	,
18637	8233	49	as	as	IN
18637	8233	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8233	51	were	be	VBD
18637	8233	52	,	,	,
18637	8233	53	a	a	DT
18637	8233	54	new	new	JJ
18637	8233	55	man	man	NN
18637	8233	56	,	,	,
18637	8233	57	and	and	CC
18637	8233	58	gives	give	VBZ
18637	8233	59	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8233	60	a	a	DT
18637	8233	61	new	new	JJ
18637	8233	62	credit	credit	NN
18637	8233	63	and	and	CC
18637	8233	64	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	8233	65	.	.	.
18637	8234	1	"	"	``
18637	8234	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8234	3	134	134	CD
18637	8234	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8234	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8234	6	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	8234	7	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8234	8	for	for	IN
18637	8234	9	the	the	DT
18637	8234	10	minority	minority	NN
18637	8234	11	protested	protest	VBD
18637	8234	12	that	that	IN
18637	8234	13	the	the	DT
18637	8234	14	act	act	NN
18637	8234	15	of	of	IN
18637	8234	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8234	17	involved	involve	VBN
18637	8234	18	was	be	VBD
18637	8234	19	not	not	RB
18637	8234	20	penal	penal	JJ
18637	8234	21	in	in	IN
18637	8234	22	character	character	NN
18637	8234	23	,	,	,
18637	8234	24	but	but	CC
18637	8234	25	merely	merely	RB
18637	8234	26	laid	lay	VBD
18637	8234	27	down	down	RP
18637	8234	28	an	an	DT
18637	8234	29	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	8234	30	test	test	NN
18637	8234	31	of	of	IN
18637	8234	32	fitness	fitness	NN
18637	8234	33	to	to	TO
18637	8234	34	practice	practice	VB
18637	8234	35	the	the	DT
18637	8234	36	law	law	NN
18637	8234	37	.	.	.
18637	8235	1	"	"	``
18637	8235	2	The	the	DT
18637	8235	3	man	man	NN
18637	8235	4	who	who	WP
18637	8235	5	,	,	,
18637	8235	6	by	by	IN
18637	8235	7	counterfeiting	counterfeit	VBG
18637	8235	8	,	,	,
18637	8235	9	by	by	IN
18637	8235	10	theft	theft	NN
18637	8235	11	,	,	,
18637	8235	12	by	by	IN
18637	8235	13	murder	murder	NN
18637	8235	14	,	,	,
18637	8235	15	or	or	CC
18637	8235	16	by	by	IN
18637	8235	17	treason	treason	NN
18637	8235	18	,	,	,
18637	8235	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	8235	20	rendered	render	VBN
18637	8235	21	unfit	unfit	JJ
18637	8235	22	to	to	TO
18637	8235	23	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	8235	24	the	the	DT
18637	8235	25	functions	function	NNS
18637	8235	26	of	of	IN
18637	8235	27	an	an	DT
18637	8235	28	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	8235	29	or	or	CC
18637	8235	30	counsellor	counsellor	NN
18637	8235	31	at	at	IN
18637	8235	32	law	law	NN
18637	8235	33	,	,	,
18637	8235	34	may	may	MD
18637	8235	35	be	be	VB
18637	8235	36	saved	save	VBN
18637	8235	37	by	by	IN
18637	8235	38	the	the	DT
18637	8235	39	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8235	40	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8235	41	from	from	IN
18637	8235	42	the	the	DT
18637	8235	43	penitentiary	penitentiary	NN
18637	8235	44	or	or	CC
18637	8235	45	the	the	DT
18637	8235	46	gallows	gallow	NNS
18637	8235	47	,	,	,
18637	8235	48	but	but	CC
18637	8235	49	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8235	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	8235	51	not	not	RB
18637	8235	52	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	8235	53	restored	restore	VBN
18637	8235	54	to	to	IN
18637	8235	55	the	the	DT
18637	8235	56	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	8235	57	which	which	WDT
18637	8235	58	are	be	VBP
18637	8235	59	essential	essential	JJ
18637	8235	60	to	to	TO
18637	8235	61	admission	admission	VB
18637	8235	62	to	to	IN
18637	8235	63	the	the	DT
18637	8235	64	bar	bar	NN
18637	8235	65	.	.	.
18637	8236	1	"	"	``
18637	8236	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8236	3	135	135	CD
18637	8236	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8236	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8236	6	Field	Field	NNP
18637	8236	7	's	's	POS
18637	8236	8	language	language	NN
18637	8236	9	must	must	MD
18637	8236	10	today	today	NN
18637	8236	11	be	be	VB
18637	8236	12	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	8236	13	as	as	RB
18637	8236	14	much	much	RB
18637	8236	15	too	too	RB
18637	8236	16	sweeping	sweep	VBG
18637	8236	17	in	in	IN
18637	8236	18	light	light	NN
18637	8236	19	of	of	IN
18637	8236	20	a	a	DT
18637	8236	21	decision	decision	NN
18637	8236	22	rendered	render	VBN
18637	8236	23	in	in	IN
18637	8236	24	1914	1914	CD
18637	8236	25	in	in	IN
18637	8236	26	the	the	DT
18637	8236	27	case	case	NN
18637	8236	28	of	of	IN
18637	8236	29	Carlesi	Carlesi	NNP
18637	8236	30	_	_	NNP
18637	8236	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	8236	32	_	_	NNP
18637	8236	33	New	New	NNP
18637	8236	34	York	York	NNP
18637	8236	35	.	.	.
18637	8237	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8237	2	136	136	CD
18637	8237	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8237	4	Carlesi	Carlesi	NNP
18637	8237	5	had	have	VBD
18637	8237	6	some	some	DT
18637	8237	7	years	year	NNS
18637	8237	8	before	before	IN
18637	8237	9	been	be	VBN
18637	8237	10	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	8237	11	of	of	IN
18637	8237	12	committing	commit	VBG
18637	8237	13	a	a	DT
18637	8237	14	federal	federal	JJ
18637	8237	15	offense	offense	NN
18637	8237	16	.	.	.
18637	8238	1	In	in	IN
18637	8238	2	the	the	DT
18637	8238	3	instant	instant	NN
18637	8238	4	case	case	NN
18637	8238	5	the	the	DT
18637	8238	6	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	8238	7	was	be	VBD
18637	8238	8	being	be	VBG
18637	8238	9	tried	try	VBN
18637	8238	10	for	for	IN
18637	8238	11	a	a	DT
18637	8238	12	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	8238	13	offense	offense	NN
18637	8238	14	committed	commit	VBN
18637	8238	15	in	in	IN
18637	8238	16	New	New	NNP
18637	8238	17	York	York	NNP
18637	8238	18	.	.	.
18637	8239	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8239	2	was	be	VBD
18637	8239	3	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	8239	4	as	as	IN
18637	8239	5	a	a	DT
18637	8239	6	second	second	JJ
18637	8239	7	offender	offender	NN
18637	8239	8	,	,	,
18637	8239	9	although	although	IN
18637	8239	10	the	the	DT
18637	8239	11	President	President	NNP
18637	8239	12	had	have	VBD
18637	8239	13	pardoned	pardon	VBN
18637	8239	14	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8239	15	for	for	IN
18637	8239	16	the	the	DT
18637	8239	17	earlier	early	JJR
18637	8239	18	federal	federal	JJ
18637	8239	19	offense	offense	NN
18637	8239	20	.	.	.
18637	8240	1	In	in	IN
18637	8240	2	other	other	JJ
18637	8240	3	words	word	NNS
18637	8240	4	,	,	,
18637	8240	5	the	the	DT
18637	8240	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	8240	7	of	of	IN
18637	8240	8	prior	prior	JJ
18637	8240	9	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	8240	10	by	by	IN
18637	8240	11	a	a	DT
18637	8240	12	federal	federal	JJ
18637	8240	13	court	court	NN
18637	8240	14	was	be	VBD
18637	8240	15	considered	consider	VBN
18637	8240	16	in	in	IN
18637	8240	17	determining	determine	VBG
18637	8240	18	the	the	DT
18637	8240	19	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	8240	20	for	for	IN
18637	8240	21	a	a	DT
18637	8240	22	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	8240	23	State	State	NNP
18637	8240	24	offense	offense	NN
18637	8240	25	.	.	.
18637	8241	1	This	this	DT
18637	8241	2	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	8241	3	and	and	CC
18637	8241	4	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	8241	5	were	be	VBD
18637	8241	6	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	8241	7	by	by	IN
18637	8241	8	the	the	DT
18637	8241	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8241	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8241	11	.	.	.
18637	8242	1	While	while	IN
18637	8242	2	this	this	DT
18637	8242	3	case	case	NN
18637	8242	4	involved	involve	VBD
18637	8242	5	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	8242	6	against	against	IN
18637	8242	7	different	different	JJ
18637	8242	8	sovereignties	sovereignty	NNS
18637	8242	9	,	,	,
18637	8242	10	the	the	DT
18637	8242	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8242	12	declared	declare	VBD
18637	8242	13	by	by	IN
18637	8242	14	way	way	NN
18637	8242	15	of	of	IN
18637	8242	16	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	8242	17	that	that	IN
18637	8242	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8242	19	decision	decision	NN
18637	8242	20	"	"	``
18637	8242	21	must	must	MD
18637	8242	22	not	not	RB
18637	8242	23	be	be	VB
18637	8242	24	understood	understand	VBN
18637	8242	25	as	as	IN
18637	8242	26	in	in	IN
18637	8242	27	the	the	DT
18637	8242	28	slightest	slight	JJS
18637	8242	29	degree	degree	NN
18637	8242	30	intimating	intimate	VBG
18637	8242	31	that	that	IN
18637	8242	32	a	a	DT
18637	8242	33	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8242	34	would	would	MD
18637	8242	35	operate	operate	VB
18637	8242	36	to	to	TO
18637	8242	37	limit	limit	VB
18637	8242	38	the	the	DT
18637	8242	39	power	power	NN
18637	8242	40	of	of	IN
18637	8242	41	the	the	DT
18637	8242	42	United	United	NNP
18637	8242	43	States	States	NNP
18637	8242	44	in	in	IN
18637	8242	45	punishing	punish	VBG
18637	8242	46	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	8242	47	against	against	IN
18637	8242	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8242	49	authority	authority	NN
18637	8242	50	to	to	TO
18637	8242	51	provide	provide	VB
18637	8242	52	for	for	IN
18637	8242	53	taking	take	VBG
18637	8242	54	into	into	IN
18637	8242	55	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	8242	56	past	past	NN
18637	8242	57	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	8242	58	committed	commit	VBN
18637	8242	59	by	by	IN
18637	8242	60	the	the	DT
18637	8242	61	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	8242	62	as	as	IN
18637	8242	63	a	a	DT
18637	8242	64	circumstance	circumstance	NN
18637	8242	65	of	of	IN
18637	8242	66	aggravation	aggravation	NN
18637	8242	67	even	even	RB
18637	8242	68	although	although	IN
18637	8242	69	for	for	IN
18637	8242	70	such	such	JJ
18637	8242	71	past	past	JJ
18637	8242	72	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	8242	73	there	there	RB
18637	8242	74	had	have	VBD
18637	8242	75	been	be	VBN
18637	8242	76	a	a	DT
18637	8242	77	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8242	78	granted	grant	VBN
18637	8242	79	.	.	.
18637	8243	1	"	"	``
18637	8243	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8243	3	137	137	CD
18637	8243	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8243	5	LIMITS	LIMITS	NNP
18637	8243	6	TO	to	IN
18637	8243	7	THE	the	DT
18637	8243	8	EFFICACY	efficacy	NN
18637	8243	9	OF	of	IN
18637	8243	10	A	a	DT
18637	8243	11	PARDON	PARDON	NNP
18637	8243	12	But	but	CC
18637	8243	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8243	14	Field	Field	NNP
18637	8243	15	's	's	POS
18637	8243	16	latitudinarian	latitudinarian	JJ
18637	8243	17	view	view	NN
18637	8243	18	of	of	IN
18637	8243	19	the	the	DT
18637	8243	20	effect	effect	NN
18637	8243	21	of	of	IN
18637	8243	22	a	a	DT
18637	8243	23	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8243	24	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	8243	25	still	still	RB
18637	8243	26	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	8243	27	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	8243	28	where	where	WRB
18637	8243	29	the	the	DT
18637	8243	30	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8243	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	8243	32	issued	issue	VBN
18637	8243	33	_	_	NNP
18637	8243	34	before	before	IN
18637	8243	35	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	8243	36	_	_	NNP
18637	8243	37	.	.	.
18637	8244	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8244	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8244	3	also	also	RB
18637	8244	4	correct	correct	JJ
18637	8244	5	in	in	IN
18637	8244	6	saying	say	VBG
18637	8244	7	that	that	IN
18637	8244	8	a	a	DT
18637	8244	9	full	full	JJ
18637	8244	10	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8244	11	restores	restore	VBZ
18637	8244	12	a	a	DT
18637	8244	13	_	_	NNP
18637	8244	14	convict	convict	NN
18637	8244	15	_	_	NNP
18637	8244	16	to	to	IN
18637	8244	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8244	18	"	"	``
18637	8244	19	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8244	20	rights	right	NNS
18637	8244	21	,	,	,
18637	8244	22	"	"	''
18637	8244	23	and	and	CC
18637	8244	24	this	this	DT
18637	8244	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	8244	26	so	so	RB
18637	8244	27	even	even	RB
18637	8244	28	though	though	IN
18637	8244	29	simple	simple	JJ
18637	8244	30	completion	completion	NN
18637	8244	31	of	of	IN
18637	8244	32	the	the	DT
18637	8244	33	convict	convict	NN
18637	8244	34	's	's	POS
18637	8244	35	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	8244	36	would	would	MD
18637	8244	37	not	not	RB
18637	8244	38	have	have	VB
18637	8244	39	had	have	VBN
18637	8244	40	that	that	DT
18637	8244	41	effect	effect	NN
18637	8244	42	.	.	.
18637	8245	1	One	one	CD
18637	8245	2	such	such	JJ
18637	8245	3	right	right	NN
18637	8245	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	8245	5	the	the	DT
18637	8245	6	right	right	NN
18637	8245	7	to	to	TO
18637	8245	8	testify	testify	VB
18637	8245	9	in	in	IN
18637	8245	10	court	court	NN
18637	8245	11	,	,	,
18637	8245	12	and	and	CC
18637	8245	13	in	in	IN
18637	8245	14	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
18637	8245	15	_	_	NNP
18637	8245	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	8245	17	_	_	NNP
18637	8245	18	United	United	NNP
18637	8245	19	States	States	NNP
18637	8245	20	the	the	DT
18637	8245	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8245	22	held	hold	VBD
18637	8245	23	that	that	IN
18637	8245	24	the	the	DT
18637	8245	25	disability	disability	NN
18637	8245	26	to	to	TO
18637	8245	27	testify	testify	VB
18637	8245	28	being	be	VBG
18637	8245	29	a	a	DT
18637	8245	30	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	8245	31	,	,	,
18637	8245	32	according	accord	VBG
18637	8245	33	to	to	IN
18637	8245	34	principles	principle	NNS
18637	8245	35	of	of	IN
18637	8245	36	the	the	DT
18637	8245	37	common	common	JJ
18637	8245	38	law	law	NN
18637	8245	39	,	,	,
18637	8245	40	of	of	IN
18637	8245	41	the	the	DT
18637	8245	42	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8245	43	of	of	IN
18637	8245	44	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	8245	45	,	,	,
18637	8245	46	the	the	DT
18637	8245	47	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8245	48	obliterated	obliterate	VBD
18637	8245	49	that	that	DT
18637	8245	50	effect	effect	NN
18637	8245	51	.	.	.
18637	8246	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8246	2	138	138	CD
18637	8246	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8246	4	But	but	CC
18637	8246	5	a	a	DT
18637	8246	6	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8246	7	can	can	MD
18637	8246	8	not	not	RB
18637	8246	9	"	"	``
18637	8246	10	make	make	VB
18637	8246	11	amends	amend	NNS
18637	8246	12	for	for	IN
18637	8246	13	the	the	DT
18637	8246	14	past	past	NN
18637	8246	15	.	.	.
18637	8247	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8247	2	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	8247	3	no	no	DT
18637	8247	4	relief	relief	NN
18637	8247	5	for	for	IN
18637	8247	6	what	what	WP
18637	8247	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	8247	8	been	be	VBN
18637	8247	9	suffered	suffer	VBN
18637	8247	10	by	by	IN
18637	8247	11	the	the	DT
18637	8247	12	offender	offender	NN
18637	8247	13	in	in	IN
18637	8247	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8247	15	person	person	NN
18637	8247	16	by	by	IN
18637	8247	17	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	8247	18	,	,	,
18637	8247	19	forced	force	VBN
18637	8247	20	labor	labor	NN
18637	8247	21	,	,	,
18637	8247	22	or	or	CC
18637	8247	23	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	8247	24	;	;	:
18637	8247	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8247	26	does	do	VBZ
18637	8247	27	not	not	RB
18637	8247	28	give	give	VB
18637	8247	29	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	8247	30	for	for	IN
18637	8247	31	what	what	WP
18637	8247	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	8247	33	been	be	VBN
18637	8247	34	done	do	VBN
18637	8247	35	or	or	CC
18637	8247	36	suffered	suffer	VBN
18637	8247	37	,	,	,
18637	8247	38	nor	nor	CC
18637	8247	39	does	do	VBZ
18637	8247	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8247	41	impose	impose	VB
18637	8247	42	upon	upon	IN
18637	8247	43	the	the	DT
18637	8247	44	government	government	NN
18637	8247	45	any	any	DT
18637	8247	46	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8247	47	to	to	TO
18637	8247	48	give	give	VB
18637	8247	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8247	50	.	.	.
18637	8248	1	The	the	DT
18637	8248	2	offence	offence	NN
18637	8248	3	being	be	VBG
18637	8248	4	established	establish	VBN
18637	8248	5	by	by	IN
18637	8248	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8248	7	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	8248	8	,	,	,
18637	8248	9	that	that	WDT
18637	8248	10	which	which	WDT
18637	8248	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	8248	12	been	be	VBN
18637	8248	13	done	do	VBN
18637	8248	14	or	or	CC
18637	8248	15	suffered	suffer	VBN
18637	8248	16	while	while	IN
18637	8248	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8248	18	were	be	VBD
18637	8248	19	in	in	IN
18637	8248	20	force	force	NN
18637	8248	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	8248	22	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	8248	23	to	to	TO
18637	8248	24	have	have	VB
18637	8248	25	been	be	VBN
18637	8248	26	rightfully	rightfully	RB
18637	8248	27	done	do	VBN
18637	8248	28	and	and	CC
18637	8248	29	justly	justly	RB
18637	8248	30	suffered	suffer	VBN
18637	8248	31	,	,	,
18637	8248	32	and	and	CC
18637	8248	33	no	no	DT
18637	8248	34	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
18637	8248	35	for	for	IN
18637	8248	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8248	37	can	can	MD
18637	8248	38	be	be	VB
18637	8248	39	required	require	VBN
18637	8248	40	.	.	.
18637	8249	1	Neither	neither	CC
18637	8249	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	8249	3	the	the	DT
18637	8249	4	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8249	5	affect	affect	VB
18637	8249	6	any	any	DT
18637	8249	7	rights	right	NNS
18637	8249	8	which	which	WDT
18637	8249	9	have	have	VBP
18637	8249	10	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8249	11	in	in	IN
18637	8249	12	others	other	NNS
18637	8249	13	directly	directly	RB
18637	8249	14	by	by	IN
18637	8249	15	the	the	DT
18637	8249	16	execution	execution	NN
18637	8249	17	of	of	IN
18637	8249	18	the	the	DT
18637	8249	19	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8249	20	for	for	IN
18637	8249	21	the	the	DT
18637	8249	22	offence	offence	NN
18637	8249	23	,	,	,
18637	8249	24	or	or	CC
18637	8249	25	which	which	WDT
18637	8249	26	have	have	VBP
18637	8249	27	been	be	VBN
18637	8249	28	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	8249	29	by	by	IN
18637	8249	30	others	other	NNS
18637	8249	31	whilst	whilst	IN
18637	8249	32	that	that	DT
18637	8249	33	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8249	34	was	be	VBD
18637	8249	35	in	in	IN
18637	8249	36	force	force	NN
18637	8249	37	.	.	.
18637	8250	1	If	if	IN
18637	8250	2	,	,	,
18637	8250	3	for	for	IN
18637	8250	4	example	example	NN
18637	8250	5	,	,	,
18637	8250	6	by	by	IN
18637	8250	7	the	the	DT
18637	8250	8	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8250	9	a	a	DT
18637	8250	10	sale	sale	NN
18637	8250	11	of	of	IN
18637	8250	12	the	the	DT
18637	8250	13	offender	offender	NN
18637	8250	14	's	's	POS
18637	8250	15	property	property	NN
18637	8250	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	8250	17	been	be	VBN
18637	8250	18	had	have	VBN
18637	8250	19	,	,	,
18637	8250	20	the	the	DT
18637	8250	21	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	8250	22	will	will	MD
18637	8250	23	hold	hold	VB
18637	8250	24	the	the	DT
18637	8250	25	property	property	NN
18637	8250	26	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	8250	27	the	the	DT
18637	8250	28	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	8250	29	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8250	30	.	.	.
18637	8251	1	And	and	CC
18637	8251	2	if	if	IN
18637	8251	3	the	the	DT
18637	8251	4	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	8251	5	of	of	IN
18637	8251	6	the	the	DT
18637	8251	7	sale	sale	NN
18637	8251	8	have	have	VBP
18637	8251	9	been	be	VBN
18637	8251	10	paid	pay	VBN
18637	8251	11	to	to	IN
18637	8251	12	a	a	DT
18637	8251	13	party	party	NN
18637	8251	14	to	to	TO
18637	8251	15	whom	whom	WP
18637	8251	16	the	the	DT
18637	8251	17	law	law	NN
18637	8251	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	8251	19	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	8251	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8251	21	,	,	,
18637	8251	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8251	23	can	can	MD
18637	8251	24	not	not	RB
18637	8251	25	be	be	VB
18637	8251	26	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	8251	27	reached	reach	VBN
18637	8251	28	and	and	CC
18637	8251	29	recovered	recover	VBN
18637	8251	30	by	by	IN
18637	8251	31	the	the	DT
18637	8251	32	offender	offender	NN
18637	8251	33	.	.	.
18637	8252	1	The	the	DT
18637	8252	2	rights	right	NNS
18637	8252	3	of	of	IN
18637	8252	4	the	the	DT
18637	8252	5	parties	party	NNS
18637	8252	6	have	have	VBP
18637	8252	7	become	become	VBN
18637	8252	8	vested	vested	JJ
18637	8252	9	,	,	,
18637	8252	10	and	and	CC
18637	8252	11	are	be	VBP
18637	8252	12	as	as	RB
18637	8252	13	complete	complete	JJ
18637	8252	14	as	as	IN
18637	8252	15	if	if	IN
18637	8252	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8252	17	were	be	VBD
18637	8252	18	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	8252	19	in	in	IN
18637	8252	20	any	any	DT
18637	8252	21	other	other	JJ
18637	8252	22	legal	legal	JJ
18637	8252	23	way	way	NN
18637	8252	24	.	.	.
18637	8253	1	So	so	RB
18637	8253	2	,	,	,
18637	8253	3	also	also	RB
18637	8253	4	,	,	,
18637	8253	5	if	if	IN
18637	8253	6	the	the	DT
18637	8253	7	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	8253	8	have	have	VBP
18637	8253	9	been	be	VBN
18637	8253	10	paid	pay	VBN
18637	8253	11	into	into	IN
18637	8253	12	the	the	DT
18637	8253	13	treasury	treasury	NNP
18637	8253	14	,	,	,
18637	8253	15	the	the	DT
18637	8253	16	right	right	NN
18637	8253	17	to	to	IN
18637	8253	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8253	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	8253	20	so	so	RB
18637	8253	21	far	far	RB
18637	8253	22	become	become	VBN
18637	8253	23	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8253	24	in	in	IN
18637	8253	25	the	the	DT
18637	8253	26	United	United	NNP
18637	8253	27	States	States	NNP
18637	8253	28	that	that	IN
18637	8253	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8253	30	can	can	MD
18637	8253	31	only	only	RB
18637	8253	32	be	be	VB
18637	8253	33	secured	secure	VBN
18637	8253	34	to	to	IN
18637	8253	35	the	the	DT
18637	8253	36	former	former	JJ
18637	8253	37	owner	owner	NN
18637	8253	38	of	of	IN
18637	8253	39	the	the	DT
18637	8253	40	property	property	NN
18637	8253	41	through	through	IN
18637	8253	42	an	an	DT
18637	8253	43	act	act	NN
18637	8253	44	of	of	IN
18637	8253	45	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8253	46	.	.	.
18637	8254	1	Moneys	money	NNS
18637	8254	2	once	once	RB
18637	8254	3	in	in	IN
18637	8254	4	the	the	DT
18637	8254	5	treasury	treasury	NN
18637	8254	6	can	can	MD
18637	8254	7	only	only	RB
18637	8254	8	be	be	VB
18637	8254	9	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	8254	10	by	by	IN
18637	8254	11	an	an	DT
18637	8254	12	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	8254	13	by	by	IN
18637	8254	14	law	law	NN
18637	8254	15	.	.	.
18637	8255	1	"	"	``
18637	8255	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8255	3	139	139	CD
18637	8255	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8255	5	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	8255	6	AND	and	CC
18637	8255	7	AMNESTY	AMNESTY	NNP
18637	8255	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8255	9	can	can	MD
18637	8255	10	not	not	RB
18637	8255	11	limit	limit	VB
18637	8255	12	the	the	DT
18637	8255	13	effects	effect	NNS
18637	8255	14	of	of	IN
18637	8255	15	a	a	DT
18637	8255	16	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8255	17	amnesty	amnesty	NN
18637	8255	18	.	.	.
18637	8256	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	8256	2	the	the	DT
18637	8256	3	act	act	NN
18637	8256	4	of	of	IN
18637	8256	5	July	July	NNP
18637	8256	6	12	12	CD
18637	8256	7	,	,	,
18637	8256	8	1870	1870	CD
18637	8256	9	,	,	,
18637	8256	10	making	make	VBG
18637	8256	11	proof	proof	NN
18637	8256	12	of	of	IN
18637	8256	13	loyalty	loyalty	NN
18637	8256	14	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8256	15	to	to	TO
18637	8256	16	recover	recover	VB
18637	8256	17	property	property	NN
18637	8256	18	abandoned	abandon	VBN
18637	8256	19	and	and	CC
18637	8256	20	sold	sell	VBN
18637	8256	21	by	by	IN
18637	8256	22	the	the	DT
18637	8256	23	government	government	NN
18637	8256	24	during	during	IN
18637	8256	25	the	the	DT
18637	8256	26	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	8256	27	War	War	NNP
18637	8256	28	,	,	,
18637	8256	29	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	8256	30	any	any	DT
18637	8256	31	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8256	32	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	8256	33	,	,	,
18637	8256	34	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8256	35	,	,	,
18637	8256	36	amnesty	amnesty	NNP
18637	8256	37	,	,	,
18637	8256	38	or	or	CC
18637	8256	39	other	other	JJ
18637	8256	40	act	act	NN
18637	8256	41	of	of	IN
18637	8256	42	condonation	condonation	NN
18637	8256	43	or	or	CC
18637	8256	44	oblivion	oblivion	NN
18637	8256	45	,	,	,
18637	8256	46	was	be	VBD
18637	8256	47	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
18637	8256	48	void	void	JJ
18637	8256	49	.	.	.
18637	8257	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	8257	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8257	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8257	4	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	8257	5	for	for	IN
18637	8257	6	the	the	DT
18637	8257	7	majority	majority	NN
18637	8257	8	:	:	:
18637	8257	9	"	"	``
18637	8257	10	*	*	NFP
18637	8257	11	*	*	NFP
18637	8257	12	*	*	NFP
18637	8257	13	the	the	DT
18637	8257	14	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	8257	15	can	can	MD
18637	8257	16	not	not	RB
18637	8257	17	change	change	VB
18637	8257	18	the	the	DT
18637	8257	19	effect	effect	NN
18637	8257	20	of	of	IN
18637	8257	21	such	such	PDT
18637	8257	22	a	a	DT
18637	8257	23	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	8257	24	any	any	DT
18637	8257	25	more	more	RBR
18637	8257	26	than	than	IN
18637	8257	27	the	the	DT
18637	8257	28	executive	executive	NN
18637	8257	29	can	can	MD
18637	8257	30	change	change	VB
18637	8257	31	a	a	DT
18637	8257	32	law	law	NN
18637	8257	33	.	.	.
18637	8258	1	Yet	yet	CC
18637	8258	2	this	this	DT
18637	8258	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8258	4	attempted	attempt	VBN
18637	8258	5	by	by	IN
18637	8258	6	the	the	DT
18637	8258	7	provision	provision	NN
18637	8258	8	under	under	IN
18637	8258	9	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	8258	10	.	.	.
18637	8259	1	The	the	DT
18637	8259	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8259	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8259	4	required	require	VBN
18637	8259	5	to	to	TO
18637	8259	6	receive	receive	VB
18637	8259	7	special	special	JJ
18637	8259	8	pardons	pardon	NNS
18637	8259	9	as	as	IN
18637	8259	10	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	8259	11	of	of	IN
18637	8259	12	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	8259	13	and	and	CC
18637	8259	14	to	to	TO
18637	8259	15	treat	treat	VB
18637	8259	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8259	17	as	as	IN
18637	8259	18	null	null	JJ
18637	8259	19	and	and	CC
18637	8259	20	void	void	JJ
18637	8259	21	.	.	.
18637	8260	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8260	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8260	3	required	require	VBN
18637	8260	4	to	to	TO
18637	8260	5	disregard	disregard	VB
18637	8260	6	pardons	pardon	NNS
18637	8260	7	granted	grant	VBN
18637	8260	8	by	by	IN
18637	8260	9	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	8260	10	on	on	IN
18637	8260	11	condition	condition	NN
18637	8260	12	,	,	,
18637	8260	13	though	though	IN
18637	8260	14	the	the	DT
18637	8260	15	condition	condition	NN
18637	8260	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	8260	17	been	be	VBN
18637	8260	18	fulfilled	fulfil	VBN
18637	8260	19	,	,	,
18637	8260	20	and	and	CC
18637	8260	21	to	to	TO
18637	8260	22	deny	deny	VB
18637	8260	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8260	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8260	25	legal	legal	JJ
18637	8260	26	effect	effect	NN
18637	8260	27	.	.	.
18637	8261	1	This	this	DT
18637	8261	2	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	8261	3	impairs	impairs	VBP
18637	8261	4	the	the	DT
18637	8261	5	executive	executive	NNP
18637	8261	6	authority	authority	NN
18637	8261	7	and	and	CC
18637	8261	8	directs	direct	VBZ
18637	8261	9	the	the	DT
18637	8261	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8261	11	to	to	TO
18637	8261	12	be	be	VB
18637	8261	13	instrumental	instrumental	JJ
18637	8261	14	to	to	IN
18637	8261	15	that	that	DT
18637	8261	16	end	end	NN
18637	8261	17	.	.	.
18637	8262	1	"	"	``
18637	8262	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8262	3	140	140	CD
18637	8262	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8262	5	On	on	IN
18637	8262	6	the	the	DT
18637	8262	7	other	other	JJ
18637	8262	8	hand	hand	NN
18637	8262	9	,	,	,
18637	8262	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8262	11	may	may	MD
18637	8262	12	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8262	13	,	,	,
18637	8262	14	under	under	IN
18637	8262	15	the	the	DT
18637	8262	16	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8262	17	and	and	CC
18637	8262	18	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8262	19	clause	clause	NN
18637	8262	20	,	,	,
18637	8262	21	enact	enact	VB
18637	8262	22	amnesty	amnesty	NN
18637	8262	23	laws	law	NNS
18637	8262	24	remitting	remit	VBG
18637	8262	25	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	8262	26	incurred	incur	VBN
18637	8262	27	under	under	IN
18637	8262	28	the	the	DT
18637	8262	29	national	national	JJ
18637	8262	30	statutes,[141	statutes,[141	NN
18637	8262	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8262	32	and	and	CC
18637	8262	33	may	may	MD
18637	8262	34	stipulate	stipulate	VB
18637	8262	35	that	that	IN
18637	8262	36	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	8262	37	before	before	IN
18637	8262	38	courts	court	NNS
18637	8262	39	or	or	CC
18637	8262	40	other	other	JJ
18637	8262	41	bodies	body	NNS
18637	8262	42	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	8262	43	to	to	TO
18637	8262	44	take	take	VB
18637	8262	45	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	8262	46	shall	shall	MD
18637	8262	47	not	not	RB
18637	8262	48	be	be	VB
18637	8262	49	prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
18637	8262	50	by	by	IN
18637	8262	51	the	the	DT
18637	8262	52	National	National	NNP
18637	8262	53	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8262	54	for	for	IN
18637	8262	55	any	any	DT
18637	8262	56	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	8262	57	disclosed	disclose	VBN
18637	8262	58	by	by	IN
18637	8262	59	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8262	60	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	8262	61	.	.	.
18637	8263	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8263	2	142	142	CD
18637	8263	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8263	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	8263	5	2	2	CD
18637	8263	6	.	.	.
18637	8264	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8264	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	8264	3	have	have	VB
18637	8264	4	Power	power	NN
18637	8264	5	,	,	,
18637	8264	6	by	by	RB
18637	8264	7	and	and	CC
18637	8264	8	with	with	IN
18637	8264	9	the	the	DT
18637	8264	10	Advice	Advice	NNP
18637	8264	11	and	and	CC
18637	8264	12	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	8264	13	of	of	IN
18637	8264	14	the	the	DT
18637	8264	15	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8264	16	,	,	,
18637	8264	17	to	to	TO
18637	8264	18	make	make	VB
18637	8264	19	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	8264	20	,	,	,
18637	8264	21	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8264	22	two	two	CD
18637	8264	23	thirds	third	NNS
18637	8264	24	of	of	IN
18637	8264	25	the	the	DT
18637	8264	26	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	8264	27	present	present	JJ
18637	8264	28	concur	concur	NN
18637	8264	29	;	;	:
18637	8264	30	and	and	CC
18637	8264	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8264	32	shall	shall	MD
18637	8264	33	nominate	nominate	VB
18637	8264	34	,	,	,
18637	8264	35	and	and	CC
18637	8264	36	by	by	RB
18637	8264	37	and	and	CC
18637	8264	38	with	with	IN
18637	8264	39	the	the	DT
18637	8264	40	Advice	Advice	NNP
18637	8264	41	and	and	CC
18637	8264	42	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	8264	43	of	of	IN
18637	8264	44	the	the	DT
18637	8264	45	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8264	46	,	,	,
18637	8264	47	shall	shall	MD
18637	8264	48	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	8264	49	Ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	8264	50	,	,	,
18637	8264	51	other	other	JJ
18637	8264	52	public	public	JJ
18637	8264	53	Ministers	Ministers	NNPS
18637	8264	54	and	and	CC
18637	8264	55	Consuls	Consuls	NNPS
18637	8264	56	,	,	,
18637	8264	57	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	8264	58	of	of	IN
18637	8264	59	the	the	DT
18637	8264	60	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	8264	61	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8264	62	,	,	,
18637	8264	63	and	and	CC
18637	8264	64	all	all	DT
18637	8264	65	other	other	JJ
18637	8264	66	Officers	officer	NNS
18637	8264	67	of	of	IN
18637	8264	68	the	the	DT
18637	8264	69	United	United	NNP
18637	8264	70	States	States	NNP
18637	8264	71	,	,	,
18637	8264	72	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8264	73	Appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	8264	74	are	be	VBP
18637	8264	75	not	not	RB
18637	8264	76	herein	herein	RB
18637	8264	77	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	8264	78	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8264	79	for	for	IN
18637	8264	80	,	,	,
18637	8264	81	and	and	CC
18637	8264	82	which	which	WDT
18637	8264	83	shall	shall	MD
18637	8264	84	be	be	VB
18637	8264	85	established	establish	VBN
18637	8264	86	by	by	IN
18637	8264	87	Law	Law	NNP
18637	8264	88	:	:	:
18637	8264	89	but	but	CC
18637	8264	90	the	the	DT
18637	8264	91	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8264	92	may	may	MD
18637	8264	93	by	by	IN
18637	8264	94	Law	Law	NNP
18637	8264	95	vest	vest	VBD
18637	8264	96	the	the	DT
18637	8264	97	Appointment	Appointment	NNP
18637	8264	98	of	of	IN
18637	8264	99	such	such	JJ
18637	8264	100	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	8264	101	Officers	officer	NNS
18637	8264	102	,	,	,
18637	8264	103	as	as	IN
18637	8264	104	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8264	105	think	think	VBP
18637	8264	106	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8264	107	,	,	,
18637	8264	108	in	in	IN
18637	8264	109	the	the	DT
18637	8264	110	President	President	NNP
18637	8264	111	alone	alone	RB
18637	8264	112	,	,	,
18637	8264	113	in	in	IN
18637	8264	114	the	the	DT
18637	8264	115	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	8264	116	of	of	IN
18637	8264	117	Law	Law	NNP
18637	8264	118	,	,	,
18637	8264	119	or	or	CC
18637	8264	120	in	in	IN
18637	8264	121	the	the	DT
18637	8264	122	Heads	head	NNS
18637	8264	123	of	of	IN
18637	8264	124	Departments	Departments	NNP
18637	8264	125	.	.	.
18637	8265	1	The	the	DT
18637	8265	2	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	8265	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	8265	4	Making	Making	NNP
18637	8265	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	8265	6	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	8265	7	AND	and	CC
18637	8265	8	SENATE	SENATE	NNP
18637	8265	9	The	the	DT
18637	8265	10	plan	plan	NN
18637	8265	11	which	which	WDT
18637	8265	12	the	the	DT
18637	8265	13	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	8265	14	of	of	IN
18637	8265	15	Detail	Detail	NNP
18637	8265	16	reported	report	VBD
18637	8265	17	to	to	IN
18637	8265	18	the	the	DT
18637	8265	19	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8265	20	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	8265	21	on	on	IN
18637	8265	22	August	August	NNP
18637	8265	23	6	6	CD
18637	8265	24	,	,	,
18637	8265	25	1787	1787	CD
18637	8265	26	provided	provide	VBD
18637	8265	27	that	that	IN
18637	8265	28	"	"	``
18637	8265	29	the	the	DT
18637	8265	30	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8265	31	of	of	IN
18637	8265	32	the	the	DT
18637	8265	33	United	United	NNP
18637	8265	34	States	States	NNP
18637	8265	35	shall	shall	MD
18637	8265	36	have	have	VB
18637	8265	37	power	power	NN
18637	8265	38	to	to	TO
18637	8265	39	make	make	VB
18637	8265	40	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8265	41	,	,	,
18637	8265	42	and	and	CC
18637	8265	43	to	to	TO
18637	8265	44	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	8265	45	Ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	8265	46	,	,	,
18637	8265	47	and	and	CC
18637	8265	48	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	8265	49	of	of	IN
18637	8265	50	the	the	DT
18637	8265	51	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8265	52	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8265	53	.	.	.
18637	8266	1	"	"	``
18637	8266	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8266	3	143	143	CD
18637	8266	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8266	5	Not	not	RB
18637	8266	6	until	until	IN
18637	8266	7	September	September	NNP
18637	8266	8	7	7	CD
18637	8266	9	,	,	,
18637	8266	10	ten	ten	CD
18637	8266	11	days	day	NNS
18637	8266	12	before	before	IN
18637	8266	13	the	the	DT
18637	8266	14	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	8266	15	's	's	POS
18637	8266	16	final	final	JJ
18637	8266	17	adjournment	adjournment	NN
18637	8266	18	,	,	,
18637	8266	19	was	be	VBD
18637	8266	20	the	the	DT
18637	8266	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8266	22	made	make	VBD
18637	8266	23	a	a	DT
18637	8266	24	participant	participant	NN
18637	8266	25	in	in	IN
18637	8266	26	these	these	DT
18637	8266	27	powers	power	NNS
18637	8266	28	.	.	.
18637	8267	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8267	2	144	144	LS
18637	8267	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8267	4	The	the	DT
18637	8267	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8267	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	8267	7	evidently	evidently	RB
18637	8267	8	assumes	assume	VBZ
18637	8267	9	that	that	IN
18637	8267	10	the	the	DT
18637	8267	11	President	President	NNP
18637	8267	12	and	and	CC
18637	8267	13	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8267	14	will	will	MD
18637	8267	15	be	be	VB
18637	8267	16	associated	associate	VBN
18637	8267	17	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	8267	18	the	the	DT
18637	8267	19	entire	entire	JJ
18637	8267	20	process	process	NN
18637	8267	21	of	of	IN
18637	8267	22	making	make	VBG
18637	8267	23	a	a	DT
18637	8267	24	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8267	25	,	,	,
18637	8267	26	although	although	IN
18637	8267	27	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	8267	28	,	,	,
18637	8267	29	writing	write	VBG
18637	8267	30	in	in	IN
18637	8267	31	The	the	DT
18637	8267	32	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	8267	33	,	,	,
18637	8267	34	foresaw	foresaw	VB
18637	8267	35	that	that	IN
18637	8267	36	the	the	DT
18637	8267	37	initiative	initiative	NN
18637	8267	38	must	must	MD
18637	8267	39	often	often	RB
18637	8267	40	be	be	VB
18637	8267	41	seized	seize	VBN
18637	8267	42	by	by	IN
18637	8267	43	the	the	DT
18637	8267	44	President	President	NNP
18637	8267	45	without	without	IN
18637	8267	46	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	8267	47	of	of	IN
18637	8267	48	Senatorial	senatorial	JJ
18637	8267	49	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	8267	50	.	.	.
18637	8268	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8268	2	145	145	CD
18637	8268	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8268	4	Yet	yet	CC
18637	8268	5	so	so	RB
18637	8268	6	late	late	JJ
18637	8268	7	as	as	IN
18637	8268	8	1818	1818	CD
18637	8268	9	Rufus	Rufus	NNP
18637	8268	10	King	King	NNP
18637	8268	11	,	,	,
18637	8268	12	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	8268	13	from	from	IN
18637	8268	14	New	New	NNP
18637	8268	15	York	York	NNP
18637	8268	16	,	,	,
18637	8268	17	who	who	WP
18637	8268	18	had	have	VBD
18637	8268	19	been	be	VBN
18637	8268	20	a	a	DT
18637	8268	21	member	member	NN
18637	8268	22	of	of	IN
18637	8268	23	the	the	DT
18637	8268	24	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	8268	25	,	,	,
18637	8268	26	declared	declare	VBD
18637	8268	27	on	on	IN
18637	8268	28	the	the	DT
18637	8268	29	floor	floor	NN
18637	8268	30	of	of	IN
18637	8268	31	the	the	DT
18637	8268	32	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8268	33	:	:	:
18637	8268	34	"	"	``
18637	8268	35	In	in	IN
18637	8268	36	these	these	DT
18637	8268	37	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	8268	38	the	the	DT
18637	8268	39	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8268	40	are	be	VBP
18637	8268	41	the	the	DT
18637	8268	42	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8268	43	and	and	CC
18637	8268	44	the	the	DT
18637	8268	45	only	only	JJ
18637	8268	46	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	8268	47	counsellors	counsellor	NNS
18637	8268	48	of	of	IN
18637	8268	49	the	the	DT
18637	8268	50	President	President	NNP
18637	8268	51	.	.	.
18637	8269	1	And	and	CC
18637	8269	2	in	in	IN
18637	8269	3	this	this	DT
18637	8269	4	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	8269	5	the	the	DT
18637	8269	6	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8269	7	may	may	MD
18637	8269	8	,	,	,
18637	8269	9	and	and	CC
18637	8269	10	ought	ought	MD
18637	8269	11	to	to	TO
18637	8269	12	,	,	,
18637	8269	13	look	look	VB
18637	8269	14	into	into	IN
18637	8269	15	and	and	CC
18637	8269	16	watch	watch	VB
18637	8269	17	over	over	IN
18637	8269	18	every	every	DT
18637	8269	19	branch	branch	NN
18637	8269	20	of	of	IN
18637	8269	21	the	the	DT
18637	8269	22	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8269	23	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	8269	24	of	of	IN
18637	8269	25	the	the	DT
18637	8269	26	nation	nation	NN
18637	8269	27	;	;	:
18637	8269	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8269	29	may	may	MD
18637	8269	30	,	,	,
18637	8269	31	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8269	32	,	,	,
18637	8269	33	at	at	IN
18637	8269	34	any	any	DT
18637	8269	35	time	time	NN
18637	8269	36	call	call	NN
18637	8269	37	for	for	IN
18637	8269	38	full	full	JJ
18637	8269	39	and	and	CC
18637	8269	40	exact	exact	JJ
18637	8269	41	information	information	NN
18637	8269	42	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	8269	43	the	the	DT
18637	8269	44	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8269	45	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	8269	46	,	,	,
18637	8269	47	and	and	CC
18637	8269	48	express	express	VB
18637	8269	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8269	50	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8269	51	and	and	CC
18637	8269	52	advice	advice	NN
18637	8269	53	to	to	IN
18637	8269	54	the	the	DT
18637	8269	55	President	President	NNP
18637	8269	56	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	8269	57	the	the	DT
18637	8269	58	same	same	JJ
18637	8269	59	,	,	,
18637	8269	60	when	when	WRB
18637	8269	61	,	,	,
18637	8269	62	and	and	CC
18637	8269	63	under	under	IN
18637	8269	64	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	8269	65	other	other	JJ
18637	8269	66	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	8269	67	,	,	,
18637	8269	68	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8269	69	may	may	MD
18637	8269	70	think	think	VB
18637	8269	71	such	such	JJ
18637	8269	72	advice	advice	NN
18637	8269	73	expedient	expedient	NN
18637	8269	74	.	.	.
18637	8270	1	"	"	``
18637	8270	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8270	3	146	146	CD
18637	8270	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8270	5	NEGOTIATION	negotiation	VB
18637	8270	6	A	a	DT
18637	8270	7	PRESIDENTIAL	presidential	JJ
18637	8270	8	MONOPOLY	MONOPOLY	NNS
18637	8270	9	Actually	actually	RB
18637	8270	10	,	,	,
18637	8270	11	the	the	DT
18637	8270	12	negotiation	negotiation	NN
18637	8270	13	of	of	IN
18637	8270	14	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8270	15	had	have	VBD
18637	8270	16	long	long	RB
18637	8270	17	since	since	IN
18637	8270	18	been	be	VBN
18637	8270	19	taken	take	VBN
18637	8270	20	over	over	RP
18637	8270	21	by	by	IN
18637	8270	22	the	the	DT
18637	8270	23	President	President	NNP
18637	8270	24	;	;	:
18637	8270	25	the	the	DT
18637	8270	26	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8270	27	's	's	POS
18637	8270	28	role	role	NN
18637	8270	29	in	in	IN
18637	8270	30	relation	relation	NN
18637	8270	31	to	to	IN
18637	8270	32	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8270	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	8270	34	today	today	NN
18637	8270	35	essentially	essentially	RB
18637	8270	36	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8270	37	in	in	IN
18637	8270	38	character	character	NN
18637	8270	39	.	.	.
18637	8271	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8271	2	147	147	CD
18637	8271	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8271	4	"	"	``
18637	8271	5	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8271	6	alone	alone	RB
18637	8271	7	negotiates	negotiate	VBZ
18637	8271	8	.	.	.
18637	8272	1	Into	into	IN
18637	8272	2	the	the	DT
18637	8272	3	field	field	NN
18637	8272	4	of	of	IN
18637	8272	5	negotiation	negotiation	NN
18637	8272	6	,	,	,
18637	8272	7	the	the	DT
18637	8272	8	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8272	9	can	can	MD
18637	8272	10	not	not	RB
18637	8272	11	intrude	intrude	VB
18637	8272	12	;	;	:
18637	8272	13	and	and	CC
18637	8272	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8272	15	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8272	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	8272	17	powerless	powerless	JJ
18637	8272	18	to	to	TO
18637	8272	19	invade	invade	VB
18637	8272	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8272	21	,	,	,
18637	8272	22	"	"	''
18637	8272	23	declared	declare	VBD
18637	8272	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8272	25	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	8272	26	for	for	IN
18637	8272	27	the	the	DT
18637	8272	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8272	29	in	in	IN
18637	8272	30	1936	1936	CD
18637	8272	31	.	.	.
18637	8273	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8273	2	148	148	CD
18637	8273	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8273	4	The	the	DT
18637	8273	5	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8273	6	must	must	MD
18637	8273	7	,	,	,
18637	8273	8	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	8273	9	,	,	,
18637	8273	10	content	content	VB
18637	8273	11	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8273	12	with	with	IN
18637	8273	13	such	such	JJ
18637	8273	14	information	information	NN
18637	8273	15	as	as	IN
18637	8273	16	the	the	DT
18637	8273	17	President	President	NNP
18637	8273	18	chooses	choose	VBZ
18637	8273	19	to	to	TO
18637	8273	20	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	8273	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8273	22	.	.	.
18637	8274	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8274	2	149	149	CD
18637	8274	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8274	4	In	in	IN
18637	8274	5	performing	perform	VBG
18637	8274	6	the	the	DT
18637	8274	7	function	function	NN
18637	8274	8	that	that	WDT
18637	8274	9	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	8274	10	to	to	IN
18637	8274	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8274	12	,	,	,
18637	8274	13	however	however	RB
18637	8274	14	,	,	,
18637	8274	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8274	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	8274	17	several	several	JJ
18637	8274	18	options	option	NNS
18637	8274	19	.	.	.
18637	8275	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8275	2	may	may	MD
18637	8275	3	consent	consent	VB
18637	8275	4	unconditionally	unconditionally	RB
18637	8275	5	to	to	IN
18637	8275	6	a	a	DT
18637	8275	7	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	8275	8	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8275	9	,	,	,
18637	8275	10	or	or	CC
18637	8275	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8275	12	may	may	MD
18637	8275	13	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	8275	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8275	15	consent	consent	NN
18637	8275	16	,	,	,
18637	8275	17	or	or	CC
18637	8275	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8275	19	may	may	MD
18637	8275	20	stipulate	stipulate	VB
18637	8275	21	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	8275	22	in	in	IN
18637	8275	23	the	the	DT
18637	8275	24	form	form	NN
18637	8275	25	of	of	IN
18637	8275	26	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	8275	27	to	to	IN
18637	8275	28	the	the	DT
18637	8275	29	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8275	30	or	or	CC
18637	8275	31	of	of	IN
18637	8275	32	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	8275	33	to	to	IN
18637	8275	34	the	the	DT
18637	8275	35	act	act	NN
18637	8275	36	of	of	IN
18637	8275	37	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	8275	38	,	,	,
18637	8275	39	the	the	DT
18637	8275	40	difference	difference	NN
18637	8275	41	between	between	IN
18637	8275	42	the	the	DT
18637	8275	43	two	two	CD
18637	8275	44	being	be	VBG
18637	8275	45	that	that	WDT
18637	8275	46	,	,	,
18637	8275	47	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	8275	48	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	8275	49	,	,	,
18637	8275	50	if	if	IN
18637	8275	51	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	8275	52	by	by	IN
18637	8275	53	the	the	DT
18637	8275	54	President	President	NNP
18637	8275	55	and	and	CC
18637	8275	56	the	the	DT
18637	8275	57	other	other	JJ
18637	8275	58	party	party	NN
18637	8275	59	or	or	CC
18637	8275	60	parties	party	NNS
18637	8275	61	to	to	IN
18637	8275	62	the	the	DT
18637	8275	63	Treaty,[150	treaty,[150	NN
18637	8275	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8275	65	change	change	VB
18637	8275	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8275	67	for	for	IN
18637	8275	68	all	all	DT
18637	8275	69	parties	party	NNS
18637	8275	70	,	,	,
18637	8275	71	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	8275	72	limit	limit	VBP
18637	8275	73	only	only	RB
18637	8275	74	the	the	DT
18637	8275	75	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	8275	76	of	of	IN
18637	8275	77	the	the	DT
18637	8275	78	United	United	NNP
18637	8275	79	States	States	NNP
18637	8275	80	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	8275	81	.	.	.
18637	8276	1	The	the	DT
18637	8276	2	act	act	NN
18637	8276	3	of	of	IN
18637	8276	4	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	8276	5	for	for	IN
18637	8276	6	the	the	DT
18637	8276	7	United	United	NNP
18637	8276	8	States	States	NNP
18637	8276	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	8276	10	the	the	DT
18637	8276	11	President	President	NNP
18637	8276	12	's	's	POS
18637	8276	13	act	act	NN
18637	8276	14	,	,	,
18637	8276	15	but	but	CC
18637	8276	16	may	may	MD
18637	8276	17	not	not	RB
18637	8276	18	be	be	VB
18637	8276	19	forthcoming	forthcoming	JJ
18637	8276	20	unless	unless	IN
18637	8276	21	the	the	DT
18637	8276	22	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8276	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	8276	24	consented	consent	VBN
18637	8276	25	to	to	IN
18637	8276	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8276	27	by	by	IN
18637	8276	28	the	the	DT
18637	8276	29	required	require	VBN
18637	8276	30	two	two	CD
18637	8276	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	8276	32	thirds	third	NNS
18637	8276	33	of	of	IN
18637	8276	34	the	the	DT
18637	8276	35	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	8276	36	present	present	NN
18637	8276	37	,	,	,
18637	8276	38	which	which	WDT
18637	8276	39	signifies	signify	VBZ
18637	8276	40	two	two	CD
18637	8276	41	-	-	HYPH
18637	8276	42	thirds	third	NNS
18637	8276	43	of	of	IN
18637	8276	44	a	a	DT
18637	8276	45	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	8276	46	,	,	,
18637	8276	47	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	8276	48	the	the	DT
18637	8276	49	consent	consent	NN
18637	8276	50	rendered	render	VBN
18637	8276	51	would	would	MD
18637	8276	52	not	not	RB
18637	8276	53	be	be	VB
18637	8276	54	that	that	DT
18637	8276	55	of	of	IN
18637	8276	56	the	the	DT
18637	8276	57	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8276	58	as	as	IN
18637	8276	59	organized	organize	VBN
18637	8276	60	under	under	IN
18637	8276	61	the	the	DT
18637	8276	62	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8276	63	to	to	TO
18637	8276	64	do	do	VB
18637	8276	65	business	business	NN
18637	8276	66	.	.	.
18637	8277	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8277	2	151	151	CD
18637	8277	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8277	4	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	8277	5	,	,	,
18637	8277	6	the	the	DT
18637	8277	7	President	President	NNP
18637	8277	8	may	may	MD
18637	8277	9	,	,	,
18637	8277	10	if	if	IN
18637	8277	11	dissatisfied	dissatisfy	VBN
18637	8277	12	with	with	IN
18637	8277	13	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	8277	14	which	which	WDT
18637	8277	15	have	have	VBP
18637	8277	16	been	be	VBN
18637	8277	17	affixed	affix	VBN
18637	8277	18	by	by	IN
18637	8277	19	the	the	DT
18637	8277	20	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8277	21	to	to	IN
18637	8277	22	a	a	DT
18637	8277	23	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	8277	24	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8277	25	or	or	CC
18637	8277	26	with	with	IN
18637	8277	27	the	the	DT
18637	8277	28	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	8277	29	stipulated	stipulate	VBN
18637	8277	30	by	by	IN
18637	8277	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8277	32	to	to	IN
18637	8277	33	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	8277	34	,	,	,
18637	8277	35	decide	decide	VB
18637	8277	36	to	to	TO
18637	8277	37	abandon	abandon	VB
18637	8277	38	the	the	DT
18637	8277	39	negotiation	negotiation	NN
18637	8277	40	,	,	,
18637	8277	41	which	which	WDT
18637	8277	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8277	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	8277	44	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	8277	45	free	free	JJ
18637	8277	46	to	to	TO
18637	8277	47	do	do	VB
18637	8277	48	.	.	.
18637	8278	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8278	2	152	152	CD
18637	8278	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8278	4	TREATIES	TREATIES	NNP
18637	8278	5	AS	as	IN
18637	8278	6	LAW	law	NN
18637	8278	7	OF	of	IN
18637	8278	8	THE	the	DT
18637	8278	9	LAND	LAND	NNP
18637	8278	10	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	8278	11	commitments	commitment	NNS
18637	8278	12	of	of	IN
18637	8278	13	the	the	DT
18637	8278	14	United	United	NNP
18637	8278	15	States	States	NNP
18637	8278	16	are	be	VBP
18637	8278	17	of	of	IN
18637	8278	18	two	two	CD
18637	8278	19	kinds	kind	NNS
18637	8278	20	.	.	.
18637	8279	1	In	in	IN
18637	8279	2	the	the	DT
18637	8279	3	language	language	NN
18637	8279	4	of	of	IN
18637	8279	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8279	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8279	7	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	8279	8	in	in	IN
18637	8279	9	1829	1829	CD
18637	8279	10	;	;	:
18637	8279	11	"	"	``
18637	8279	12	A	a	DT
18637	8279	13	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8279	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8279	15	,	,	,
18637	8279	16	in	in	IN
18637	8279	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8279	18	nature	nature	NN
18637	8279	19	,	,	,
18637	8279	20	a	a	DT
18637	8279	21	contract	contract	NN
18637	8279	22	between	between	IN
18637	8279	23	two	two	CD
18637	8279	24	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8279	25	,	,	,
18637	8279	26	not	not	RB
18637	8279	27	a	a	DT
18637	8279	28	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8279	29	act	act	NN
18637	8279	30	.	.	.
18637	8280	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8280	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	8280	3	not	not	RB
18637	8280	4	generally	generally	RB
18637	8280	5	effect	effect	VB
18637	8280	6	,	,	,
18637	8280	7	of	of	IN
18637	8280	8	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8280	9	,	,	,
18637	8280	10	the	the	DT
18637	8280	11	object	object	NN
18637	8280	12	to	to	TO
18637	8280	13	be	be	VB
18637	8280	14	accomplished	accomplish	VBN
18637	8280	15	;	;	:
18637	8280	16	especially	especially	RB
18637	8280	17	,	,	,
18637	8280	18	so	so	RB
18637	8280	19	far	far	RB
18637	8280	20	as	as	IN
18637	8280	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8280	22	operation	operation	NN
18637	8280	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	8280	24	infraterritorial	infraterritorial	JJ
18637	8280	25	;	;	:
18637	8280	26	but	but	CC
18637	8280	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	8280	28	carried	carry	VBN
18637	8280	29	into	into	IN
18637	8280	30	execution	execution	NN
18637	8280	31	by	by	IN
18637	8280	32	the	the	DT
18637	8280	33	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	8280	34	power	power	NN
18637	8280	35	of	of	IN
18637	8280	36	the	the	DT
18637	8280	37	respective	respective	JJ
18637	8280	38	parties	party	NNS
18637	8280	39	to	to	IN
18637	8280	40	the	the	DT
18637	8280	41	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	8280	42	.	.	.
18637	8281	1	In	in	IN
18637	8281	2	the	the	DT
18637	8281	3	United	United	NNP
18637	8281	4	States	States	NNP
18637	8281	5	,	,	,
18637	8281	6	a	a	DT
18637	8281	7	different	different	JJ
18637	8281	8	principle	principle	NN
18637	8281	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	8281	10	established	establish	VBN
18637	8281	11	.	.	.
18637	8282	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8282	2	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	8282	3	declares	declare	VBZ
18637	8282	4	a	a	DT
18637	8282	5	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8282	6	to	to	TO
18637	8282	7	be	be	VB
18637	8282	8	the	the	DT
18637	8282	9	law	law	NN
18637	8282	10	of	of	IN
18637	8282	11	the	the	DT
18637	8282	12	land	land	NN
18637	8282	13	.	.	.
18637	8283	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8283	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8283	3	,	,	,
18637	8283	4	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	8283	5	,	,	,
18637	8283	6	to	to	TO
18637	8283	7	be	be	VB
18637	8283	8	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	8283	9	in	in	IN
18637	8283	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	8283	11	of	of	IN
18637	8283	12	justice	justice	NN
18637	8283	13	as	as	IN
18637	8283	14	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
18637	8283	15	to	to	IN
18637	8283	16	an	an	DT
18637	8283	17	act	act	NN
18637	8283	18	of	of	IN
18637	8283	19	the	the	DT
18637	8283	20	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	8283	21	,	,	,
18637	8283	22	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	8283	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8283	24	operates	operate	VBZ
18637	8283	25	of	of	IN
18637	8283	26	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8283	27	,	,	,
18637	8283	28	without	without	IN
18637	8283	29	the	the	DT
18637	8283	30	aid	aid	NN
18637	8283	31	of	of	IN
18637	8283	32	any	any	DT
18637	8283	33	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8283	34	provision	provision	NN
18637	8283	35	.	.	.
18637	8284	1	But	but	CC
18637	8284	2	when	when	WRB
18637	8284	3	the	the	DT
18637	8284	4	terms	term	NNS
18637	8284	5	of	of	IN
18637	8284	6	the	the	DT
18637	8284	7	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	8284	8	import	import	NN
18637	8284	9	a	a	DT
18637	8284	10	contract	contract	NN
18637	8284	11	--	--	:
18637	8284	12	when	when	WRB
18637	8284	13	either	either	DT
18637	8284	14	of	of	IN
18637	8284	15	the	the	DT
18637	8284	16	parties	party	NNS
18637	8284	17	engages	engage	VBZ
18637	8284	18	to	to	TO
18637	8284	19	perform	perform	VB
18637	8284	20	a	a	DT
18637	8284	21	particular	particular	JJ
18637	8284	22	act	act	NN
18637	8284	23	,	,	,
18637	8284	24	the	the	DT
18637	8284	25	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8284	26	addresses	address	VBZ
18637	8284	27	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8284	28	to	to	IN
18637	8284	29	the	the	DT
18637	8284	30	political	political	JJ
18637	8284	31	,	,	,
18637	8284	32	not	not	RB
18637	8284	33	the	the	DT
18637	8284	34	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8284	35	department	department	NN
18637	8284	36	;	;	:
18637	8284	37	and	and	CC
18637	8284	38	the	the	DT
18637	8284	39	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	8284	40	must	must	MD
18637	8284	41	execute	execute	VB
18637	8284	42	the	the	DT
18637	8284	43	contract	contract	NN
18637	8284	44	,	,	,
18637	8284	45	before	before	IN
18637	8284	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8284	47	can	can	MD
18637	8284	48	become	become	VB
18637	8284	49	a	a	DT
18637	8284	50	rule	rule	NN
18637	8284	51	for	for	IN
18637	8284	52	the	the	DT
18637	8284	53	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8284	54	.	.	.
18637	8285	1	"	"	``
18637	8285	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8285	3	153	153	CD
18637	8285	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8285	5	To	to	IN
18637	8285	6	the	the	DT
18637	8285	7	same	same	JJ
18637	8285	8	effect	effect	NN
18637	8285	9	,	,	,
18637	8285	10	but	but	CC
18637	8285	11	more	more	RBR
18637	8285	12	accurate	accurate	JJ
18637	8285	13	,	,	,
18637	8285	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8285	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8285	16	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	8285	17	's	's	POS
18637	8285	18	language	language	NN
18637	8285	19	for	for	IN
18637	8285	20	the	the	DT
18637	8285	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8285	22	a	a	DT
18637	8285	23	half	half	JJ
18637	8285	24	century	century	NN
18637	8285	25	later	later	RB
18637	8285	26	,	,	,
18637	8285	27	in	in	IN
18637	8285	28	Head	Head	NNP
18637	8285	29	Money	Money	NNP
18637	8285	30	Cases	case	NNS
18637	8285	31	:	:	:
18637	8285	32	"	"	``
18637	8285	33	A	a	DT
18637	8285	34	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8285	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	8285	36	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	8285	37	a	a	DT
18637	8285	38	compact	compact	NN
18637	8285	39	between	between	IN
18637	8285	40	independent	independent	JJ
18637	8285	41	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8285	42	.	.	.
18637	8286	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8286	2	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	8286	3	for	for	IN
18637	8286	4	the	the	DT
18637	8286	5	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	8286	6	of	of	IN
18637	8286	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8286	8	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8286	9	on	on	IN
18637	8286	10	the	the	DT
18637	8286	11	interest	interest	NN
18637	8286	12	and	and	CC
18637	8286	13	the	the	DT
18637	8286	14	honor	honor	NN
18637	8286	15	of	of	IN
18637	8286	16	the	the	DT
18637	8286	17	governments	government	NNS
18637	8286	18	which	which	WDT
18637	8286	19	are	be	VBP
18637	8286	20	parties	party	NNS
18637	8286	21	to	to	IN
18637	8286	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8286	23	.	.	.
18637	8287	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8287	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8287	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8287	4	But	but	CC
18637	8287	5	a	a	DT
18637	8287	6	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8287	7	may	may	MD
18637	8287	8	also	also	RB
18637	8287	9	contain	contain	VB
18637	8287	10	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8287	11	which	which	WDT
18637	8287	12	confer	confer	VBP
18637	8287	13	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8287	14	rights	right	NNS
18637	8287	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	8287	16	the	the	DT
18637	8287	17	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8287	18	or	or	CC
18637	8287	19	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	8287	20	of	of	IN
18637	8287	21	one	one	CD
18637	8287	22	of	of	IN
18637	8287	23	the	the	DT
18637	8287	24	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8287	25	residing	reside	VBG
18637	8287	26	in	in	IN
18637	8287	27	the	the	DT
18637	8287	28	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	8287	29	limits	limit	NNS
18637	8287	30	of	of	IN
18637	8287	31	the	the	DT
18637	8287	32	other	other	JJ
18637	8287	33	,	,	,
18637	8287	34	which	which	WDT
18637	8287	35	partake	partake	NN
18637	8287	36	of	of	IN
18637	8287	37	the	the	DT
18637	8287	38	nature	nature	NN
18637	8287	39	of	of	IN
18637	8287	40	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	8287	41	law	law	NN
18637	8287	42	,	,	,
18637	8287	43	and	and	CC
18637	8287	44	which	which	WDT
18637	8287	45	are	be	VBP
18637	8287	46	capable	capable	JJ
18637	8287	47	of	of	IN
18637	8287	48	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	8287	49	as	as	IN
18637	8287	50	between	between	IN
18637	8287	51	private	private	JJ
18637	8287	52	parties	party	NNS
18637	8287	53	in	in	IN
18637	8287	54	the	the	DT
18637	8287	55	courts	court	NNS
18637	8287	56	of	of	IN
18637	8287	57	the	the	DT
18637	8287	58	country	country	NN
18637	8287	59	.	.	.
18637	8288	1	"	"	``
18637	8288	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8288	3	154	154	CD
18637	8288	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8288	5	Origin	Origin	NNP
18637	8288	6	of	of	IN
18637	8288	7	the	the	DT
18637	8288	8	Conception	Conception	NNP
18637	8288	9	How	how	WRB
18637	8288	10	did	do	VBD
18637	8288	11	this	this	DT
18637	8288	12	distinctive	distinctive	JJ
18637	8288	13	feature	feature	NN
18637	8288	14	of	of	IN
18637	8288	15	the	the	DT
18637	8288	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8288	17	come	come	VB
18637	8288	18	about	about	RP
18637	8288	19	,	,	,
18637	8288	20	by	by	IN
18637	8288	21	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	8288	22	of	of	IN
18637	8288	23	which	which	WDT
18637	8288	24	the	the	DT
18637	8288	25	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8288	26	-	-	HYPH
18637	8288	27	making	make	VBG
18637	8288	28	authority	authority	NN
18637	8288	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	8288	30	enabled	enable	VBN
18637	8288	31	to	to	TO
18637	8288	32	stamp	stamp	VB
18637	8288	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	8288	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8288	35	promises	promise	NNS
18637	8288	36	the	the	DT
18637	8288	37	quality	quality	NN
18637	8288	38	of	of	IN
18637	8288	39	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	8288	40	law	law	NN
18637	8288	41	,	,	,
18637	8288	42	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	8288	43	rendering	render	VBG
18637	8288	44	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8288	45	"	"	``
18637	8288	46	self	self	NN
18637	8288	47	-	-	HYPH
18637	8288	48	executory	executory	NN
18637	8288	49	,	,	,
18637	8288	50	"	"	''
18637	8288	51	as	as	IN
18637	8288	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8288	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	8288	54	said	say	VBN
18637	8288	55	;	;	:
18637	8288	56	in	in	IN
18637	8288	57	other	other	JJ
18637	8288	58	words	word	NNS
18637	8288	59	,	,	,
18637	8288	60	enforceable	enforceable	JJ
18637	8288	61	by	by	IN
18637	8288	62	the	the	DT
18637	8288	63	courts	court	NNS
18637	8288	64	?	?	.
18637	8289	1	The	the	DT
18637	8289	2	answer	answer	NN
18637	8289	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8289	4	that	that	IN
18637	8289	5	article	article	NN
18637	8289	6	VI	VI	NNP
18637	8289	7	,	,	,
18637	8289	8	paragraph	paragraph	NN
18637	8289	9	2	2	CD
18637	8289	10	was	be	VBD
18637	8289	11	,	,	,
18637	8289	12	at	at	IN
18637	8289	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8289	14	inception	inception	NN
18637	8289	15	,	,	,
18637	8289	16	an	an	DT
18637	8289	17	outgrowth	outgrowth	NN
18637	8289	18	of	of	IN
18637	8289	19	a	a	DT
18637	8289	20	major	major	JJ
18637	8289	21	weakness	weakness	NN
18637	8289	22	of	of	IN
18637	8289	23	the	the	DT
18637	8289	24	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	8289	25	of	of	IN
18637	8289	26	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	8289	27	.	.	.
18637	8290	1	Although	although	IN
18637	8290	2	the	the	DT
18637	8290	3	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	8290	4	entrusted	entrust	VBD
18637	8290	5	the	the	DT
18637	8290	6	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8290	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	8290	8	making	make	VBG
18637	8290	9	power	power	NN
18637	8290	10	to	to	IN
18637	8290	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8290	12	,	,	,
18637	8290	13	fulfillment	fulfillment	NN
18637	8290	14	of	of	IN
18637	8290	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8290	16	'	'	POS
18637	8290	17	promises	promise	NNS
18637	8290	18	was	be	VBD
18637	8290	19	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	8290	20	on	on	IN
18637	8290	21	the	the	DT
18637	8290	22	State	State	NNP
18637	8290	23	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	8290	24	.	.	.
18637	8291	1	The	the	DT
18637	8291	2	result	result	NN
18637	8291	3	was	be	VBD
18637	8291	4	that	that	IN
18637	8291	5	two	two	CD
18637	8291	6	highly	highly	RB
18637	8291	7	important	important	JJ
18637	8291	8	Articles	article	NNS
18637	8291	9	of	of	IN
18637	8291	10	the	the	DT
18637	8291	11	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	8291	12	of	of	IN
18637	8291	13	Peace	Peace	NNP
18637	8291	14	of	of	IN
18637	8291	15	1783	1783	CD
18637	8291	16	not	not	RB
18637	8291	17	only	only	RB
18637	8291	18	went	go	VBD
18637	8291	19	unenforced	unenforced	JJ
18637	8291	20	,	,	,
18637	8291	21	but	but	CC
18637	8291	22	were	be	VBD
18637	8291	23	in	in	IN
18637	8291	24	some	some	DT
18637	8291	25	instances	instance	NNS
18637	8291	26	directly	directly	RB
18637	8291	27	flouted	flout	VBN
18637	8291	28	by	by	IN
18637	8291	29	the	the	DT
18637	8291	30	local	local	JJ
18637	8291	31	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	8291	32	.	.	.
18637	8292	1	These	these	DT
18637	8292	2	were	be	VBD
18637	8292	3	articles	article	NNS
18637	8292	4	IV	IV	NNP
18637	8292	5	and	and	CC
18637	8292	6	VI	VI	NNP
18637	8292	7	,	,	,
18637	8292	8	which	which	WDT
18637	8292	9	contained	contain	VBD
18637	8292	10	stipulations	stipulation	NNS
18637	8292	11	in	in	IN
18637	8292	12	favor	favor	NN
18637	8292	13	,	,	,
18637	8292	14	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	8292	15	,	,	,
18637	8292	16	of	of	IN
18637	8292	17	British	british	JJ
18637	8292	18	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	8292	19	of	of	IN
18637	8292	20	American	american	JJ
18637	8292	21	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8292	22	and	and	CC
18637	8292	23	of	of	IN
18637	8292	24	the	the	DT
18637	8292	25	former	former	JJ
18637	8292	26	Loyalists	Loyalists	NNPS
18637	8292	27	;	;	:
18637	8292	28	in	in	IN
18637	8292	29	short	short	NN
18637	8292	30	of	of	IN
18637	8292	31	_	_	NNP
18637	8292	32	private	private	JJ
18637	8292	33	persons	person	NNS
18637	8292	34	_	_	NNP
18637	8292	35	.	.	.
18637	8293	1	Confronted	confront	VBN
18637	8293	2	with	with	IN
18637	8293	3	the	the	DT
18637	8293	4	reiterated	reiterate	VBN
18637	8293	5	protests	protest	NNS
18637	8293	6	of	of	IN
18637	8293	7	the	the	DT
18637	8293	8	British	british	JJ
18637	8293	9	government	government	NN
18637	8293	10	,	,	,
18637	8293	11	John	John	NNP
18637	8293	12	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	8293	13	,	,	,
18637	8293	14	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8293	15	of	of	IN
18637	8293	16	the	the	DT
18637	8293	17	United	United	NNP
18637	8293	18	States	States	NNP
18637	8293	19	for	for	IN
18637	8293	20	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	8293	21	Affairs	Affairs	NNPS
18637	8293	22	,	,	,
18637	8293	23	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	8293	24	to	to	IN
18637	8293	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8293	26	late	late	RB
18637	8293	27	in	in	IN
18637	8293	28	1786	1786	CD
18637	8293	29	that	that	IN
18637	8293	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8293	31	request	request	VBD
18637	8293	32	the	the	DT
18637	8293	33	State	state	NN
18637	8293	34	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	8293	35	to	to	TO
18637	8293	36	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	8293	37	all	all	DT
18637	8293	38	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8293	39	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	8293	40	to	to	IN
18637	8293	41	the	the	DT
18637	8293	42	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	8293	43	of	of	IN
18637	8293	44	Peace	Peace	NNP
18637	8293	45	,	,	,
18637	8293	46	and	and	CC
18637	8293	47	at	at	IN
18637	8293	48	the	the	DT
18637	8293	49	same	same	JJ
18637	8293	50	time	time	NN
18637	8293	51	authorize	authorize	VBP
18637	8293	52	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8293	53	courts	court	NNS
18637	8293	54	in	in	IN
18637	8293	55	all	all	DT
18637	8293	56	cases	case	NNS
18637	8293	57	arising	arise	VBG
18637	8293	58	from	from	IN
18637	8293	59	the	the	DT
18637	8293	60	said	say	VBN
18637	8293	61	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8293	62	to	to	TO
18637	8293	63	decide	decide	VB
18637	8293	64	and	and	CC
18637	8293	65	adjudge	adjudge	VB
18637	8293	66	according	accord	VBG
18637	8293	67	to	to	IN
18637	8293	68	the	the	DT
18637	8293	69	true	true	JJ
18637	8293	70	intent	intent	NN
18637	8293	71	and	and	CC
18637	8293	72	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	8293	73	of	of	IN
18637	8293	74	the	the	DT
18637	8293	75	same	same	JJ
18637	8293	76	,	,	,
18637	8293	77	"	"	``
18637	8293	78	anything	anything	NN
18637	8293	79	in	in	IN
18637	8293	80	the	the	DT
18637	8293	81	said	say	VBN
18637	8293	82	acts	act	NNS
18637	8293	83	*	*	NFP
18637	8293	84	*	*	NFP
18637	8293	85	*	*	NFP
18637	8293	86	to	to	IN
18637	8293	87	the	the	DT
18637	8293	88	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	8293	89	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	8293	90	.	.	.
18637	8293	91	"	"	''
18637	8294	1	On	on	IN
18637	8294	2	April	April	NNP
18637	8294	3	13	13	CD
18637	8294	4	,	,	,
18637	8294	5	1787	1787	CD
18637	8294	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8294	7	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	8294	8	voted	vote	VBD
18637	8294	9	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	8294	10	's	's	POS
18637	8294	11	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	8294	12	,	,	,
18637	8294	13	which	which	WDT
18637	8294	14	on	on	IN
18637	8294	15	the	the	DT
18637	8294	16	eve	eve	NN
18637	8294	17	of	of	IN
18637	8294	18	the	the	DT
18637	8294	19	assembling	assembling	NN
18637	8294	20	of	of	IN
18637	8294	21	the	the	DT
18637	8294	22	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8294	23	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	8294	24	was	be	VBD
18637	8294	25	transmitted	transmit	VBN
18637	8294	26	to	to	IN
18637	8294	27	the	the	DT
18637	8294	28	State	State	NNP
18637	8294	29	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	8294	30	,	,	,
18637	8294	31	by	by	IN
18637	8294	32	seven	seven	CD
18637	8294	33	of	of	IN
18637	8294	34	which	which	WDT
18637	8294	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8294	36	was	be	VBD
18637	8294	37	promptly	promptly	RB
18637	8294	38	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	8294	39	.	.	.
18637	8295	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8295	2	155	155	CD
18637	8295	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8295	4	TREATY	TREATY	NNP
18637	8295	5	RIGHTS	right	NNS
18637	8295	6	VERSUS	versu	NNS
18637	8295	7	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	8295	8	POWER	power	NN
18637	8295	9	The	the	DT
18637	8295	10	first	first	JJ
18637	8295	11	case	case	NN
18637	8295	12	to	to	TO
18637	8295	13	arise	arise	VB
18637	8295	14	under	under	IN
18637	8295	15	article	article	NN
18637	8295	16	VI	VI	NNP
18637	8295	17	,	,	,
18637	8295	18	clause	clause	NN
18637	8295	19	2	2	CD
18637	8295	20	,	,	,
18637	8295	21	was	be	VBD
18637	8295	22	Ware	Ware	NNP
18637	8295	23	_	_	NNP
18637	8295	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	8295	25	_	_	NNP
18637	8295	26	Hylton	Hylton	NNP
18637	8295	27	.	.	.
18637	8296	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8296	2	156	156	CD
18637	8296	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8296	4	The	the	DT
18637	8296	5	facts	fact	NNS
18637	8296	6	and	and	CC
18637	8296	7	bearing	bearing	NN
18637	8296	8	of	of	IN
18637	8296	9	the	the	DT
18637	8296	10	decision	decision	NN
18637	8296	11	are	be	VBP
18637	8296	12	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	8296	13	in	in	IN
18637	8296	14	the	the	DT
18637	8296	15	syllabus	syllabus	NN
18637	8296	16	:	:	:
18637	8296	17	"	"	``
18637	8296	18	A	a	DT
18637	8296	19	debt	debt	NN
18637	8296	20	,	,	,
18637	8296	21	due	due	JJ
18637	8296	22	before	before	IN
18637	8296	23	the	the	DT
18637	8296	24	war	war	NN
18637	8296	25	from	from	IN
18637	8296	26	an	an	DT
18637	8296	27	American	American	NNP
18637	8296	28	to	to	IN
18637	8296	29	a	a	DT
18637	8296	30	British	british	JJ
18637	8296	31	subject	subject	NN
18637	8296	32	,	,	,
18637	8296	33	was	be	VBD
18637	8296	34	during	during	IN
18637	8296	35	the	the	DT
18637	8296	36	war	war	NN
18637	8296	37	,	,	,
18637	8296	38	paid	pay	VBN
18637	8296	39	into	into	IN
18637	8296	40	the	the	DT
18637	8296	41	loan	loan	NN
18637	8296	42	office	office	NN
18637	8296	43	of	of	IN
18637	8296	44	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	8296	45	,	,	,
18637	8296	46	in	in	IN
18637	8296	47	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	8296	48	of	of	IN
18637	8296	49	a	a	DT
18637	8296	50	law	law	NN
18637	8296	51	of	of	IN
18637	8296	52	that	that	DT
18637	8296	53	State	State	NNP
18637	8296	54	of	of	IN
18637	8296	55	the	the	DT
18637	8296	56	20th	20th	NN
18637	8296	57	of	of	IN
18637	8296	58	December	December	NNP
18637	8296	59	,	,	,
18637	8296	60	1777	1777	CD
18637	8296	61	,	,	,
18637	8296	62	sequestering	sequester	VBG
18637	8296	63	British	british	JJ
18637	8296	64	property	property	NN
18637	8296	65	and	and	CC
18637	8296	66	providing	provide	VBG
18637	8296	67	that	that	DT
18637	8296	68	such	such	JJ
18637	8296	69	payment	payment	NN
18637	8296	70	,	,	,
18637	8296	71	and	and	CC
18637	8296	72	a	a	DT
18637	8296	73	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	8296	74	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	8296	75	,	,	,
18637	8296	76	should	should	MD
18637	8296	77	discharge	discharge	VB
18637	8296	78	the	the	DT
18637	8296	79	debt	debt	NN
18637	8296	80	.	.	.
18637	8297	1	Held	hold	VBN
18637	8297	2	:	:	:
18637	8297	3	That	that	IN
18637	8297	4	the	the	DT
18637	8297	5	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	8297	6	of	of	IN
18637	8297	7	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	8297	8	which	which	WDT
18637	8297	9	from	from	IN
18637	8297	10	the	the	DT
18637	8297	11	4th	4th	NN
18637	8297	12	of	of	IN
18637	8297	13	July	July	NNP
18637	8297	14	,	,	,
18637	8297	15	1776	1776	CD
18637	8297	16	,	,	,
18637	8297	17	and	and	CC
18637	8297	18	before	before	IN
18637	8297	19	the	the	DT
18637	8297	20	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	8297	21	of	of	IN
18637	8297	22	the	the	DT
18637	8297	23	United	United	NNP
18637	8297	24	States	States	NNP
18637	8297	25	,	,	,
18637	8297	26	*	*	NFP
18637	8297	27	*	*	NFP
18637	8297	28	*	*	NFP
18637	8297	29	possessed	possess	VBD
18637	8297	30	and	and	CC
18637	8297	31	exercised	exercise	VBD
18637	8297	32	all	all	PDT
18637	8297	33	the	the	DT
18637	8297	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	8297	35	of	of	IN
18637	8297	36	independent	independent	JJ
18637	8297	37	governments	government	NNS
18637	8297	38	,	,	,
18637	8297	39	had	have	VBD
18637	8297	40	authority	authority	NN
18637	8297	41	to	to	TO
18637	8297	42	make	make	VB
18637	8297	43	such	such	JJ
18637	8297	44	law	law	NN
18637	8297	45	and	and	CC
18637	8297	46	that	that	IN
18637	8297	47	the	the	DT
18637	8297	48	same	same	JJ
18637	8297	49	was	be	VBD
18637	8297	50	obligatory	obligatory	JJ
18637	8297	51	,	,	,
18637	8297	52	since	since	IN
18637	8297	53	every	every	DT
18637	8297	54	nation	nation	NN
18637	8297	55	at	at	IN
18637	8297	56	war	war	NN
18637	8297	57	with	with	IN
18637	8297	58	another	another	DT
18637	8297	59	may	may	MD
18637	8297	60	confiscate	confiscate	VB
18637	8297	61	all	all	DT
18637	8297	62	property	property	NN
18637	8297	63	of	of	IN
18637	8297	64	,	,	,
18637	8297	65	including	include	VBG
18637	8297	66	private	private	JJ
18637	8297	67	debts	debt	NNS
18637	8297	68	due	due	JJ
18637	8297	69	,	,	,
18637	8297	70	the	the	DT
18637	8297	71	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	8297	72	.	.	.
18637	8298	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	8298	2	payment	payment	NN
18637	8298	3	and	and	CC
18637	8298	4	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8298	5	would	would	MD
18637	8298	6	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8298	7	be	be	VB
18637	8298	8	a	a	DT
18637	8298	9	bar	bar	NN
18637	8298	10	to	to	IN
18637	8298	11	a	a	DT
18637	8298	12	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	8298	13	action	action	NN
18637	8298	14	,	,	,
18637	8298	15	unless	unless	IN
18637	8298	16	the	the	DT
18637	8298	17	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	8298	18	's	's	POS
18637	8298	19	right	right	NN
18637	8298	20	was	be	VBD
18637	8298	21	revived	revive	VBN
18637	8298	22	by	by	IN
18637	8298	23	the	the	DT
18637	8298	24	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8298	25	of	of	IN
18637	8298	26	peace	peace	NN
18637	8298	27	,	,	,
18637	8298	28	by	by	IN
18637	8298	29	which	which	WDT
18637	8298	30	alone	alone	RB
18637	8298	31	the	the	DT
18637	8298	32	restitution	restitution	NN
18637	8298	33	of	of	IN
18637	8298	34	,	,	,
18637	8298	35	or	or	CC
18637	8298	36	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	8298	37	for	for	IN
18637	8298	38	,	,	,
18637	8298	39	British	british	JJ
18637	8298	40	property	property	NN
18637	8298	41	confiscated	confiscate	VBN
18637	8298	42	during	during	IN
18637	8298	43	the	the	DT
18637	8298	44	war	war	NN
18637	8298	45	by	by	IN
18637	8298	46	any	any	DT
18637	8298	47	of	of	IN
18637	8298	48	the	the	DT
18637	8298	49	United	United	NNP
18637	8298	50	States	States	NNP
18637	8298	51	could	could	MD
18637	8298	52	only	only	RB
18637	8298	53	be	be	VB
18637	8298	54	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8298	55	for	for	IN
18637	8298	56	.	.	.
18637	8299	1	Held	hold	VBN
18637	8299	2	,	,	,
18637	8299	3	that	that	IN
18637	8299	4	the	the	DT
18637	8299	5	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	8299	6	article	article	NN
18637	8299	7	of	of	IN
18637	8299	8	the	the	DT
18637	8299	9	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8299	10	of	of	IN
18637	8299	11	peace	peace	NN
18637	8299	12	between	between	IN
18637	8299	13	Great	Great	NNP
18637	8299	14	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	8299	15	and	and	CC
18637	8299	16	the	the	DT
18637	8299	17	United	United	NNP
18637	8299	18	States	States	NNP
18637	8299	19	,	,	,
18637	8299	20	of	of	IN
18637	8299	21	September	September	NNP
18637	8299	22	3	3	CD
18637	8299	23	,	,	,
18637	8299	24	1783	1783	CD
18637	8299	25	,	,	,
18637	8299	26	nullifies	nullifie	NNS
18637	8299	27	said	say	VBD
18637	8299	28	law	law	NN
18637	8299	29	of	of	IN
18637	8299	30	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	8299	31	,	,	,
18637	8299	32	destroys	destroy	VBZ
18637	8299	33	the	the	DT
18637	8299	34	payment	payment	NN
18637	8299	35	made	make	VBN
18637	8299	36	under	under	IN
18637	8299	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8299	38	,	,	,
18637	8299	39	and	and	CC
18637	8299	40	revives	revive	VBZ
18637	8299	41	the	the	DT
18637	8299	42	debt	debt	NN
18637	8299	43	,	,	,
18637	8299	44	and	and	CC
18637	8299	45	gives	give	VBZ
18637	8299	46	a	a	DT
18637	8299	47	right	right	NN
18637	8299	48	of	of	IN
18637	8299	49	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	8299	50	against	against	IN
18637	8299	51	the	the	DT
18637	8299	52	principal	principal	JJ
18637	8299	53	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	8299	54	,	,	,
18637	8299	55	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	8299	56	such	such	JJ
18637	8299	57	payment	payment	NN
18637	8299	58	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8299	59	,	,	,
18637	8299	60	under	under	IN
18637	8299	61	the	the	DT
18637	8299	62	authority	authority	NN
18637	8299	63	of	of	IN
18637	8299	64	State	State	NNP
18637	8299	65	law	law	NN
18637	8299	66	.	.	.
18637	8299	67	"	"	''
18637	8300	1	In	in	IN
18637	8300	2	Hopkirk	Hopkirk	NNP
18637	8300	3	_	_	NNP
18637	8300	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	8300	5	_	_	NNP
18637	8300	6	Bell[157	bell[157	CD
18637	8300	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8300	8	the	the	DT
18637	8300	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8300	10	further	further	RB
18637	8300	11	held	hold	VBD
18637	8300	12	that	that	IN
18637	8300	13	this	this	DT
18637	8300	14	same	same	JJ
18637	8300	15	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8300	16	provision	provision	NN
18637	8300	17	prevented	prevent	VBD
18637	8300	18	the	the	DT
18637	8300	19	operation	operation	NN
18637	8300	20	of	of	IN
18637	8300	21	a	a	DT
18637	8300	22	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	8300	23	statute	statute	NN
18637	8300	24	of	of	IN
18637	8300	25	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	8300	26	to	to	TO
18637	8300	27	bar	bar	VB
18637	8300	28	collection	collection	NN
18637	8300	29	of	of	IN
18637	8300	30	antecedent	antecedent	NN
18637	8300	31	debts	debt	NNS
18637	8300	32	.	.	.
18637	8301	1	In	in	IN
18637	8301	2	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	8301	3	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	8301	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	8301	5	the	the	DT
18637	8301	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8301	7	invariably	invariably	RB
18637	8301	8	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	8301	9	that	that	IN
18637	8301	10	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8301	11	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8301	12	supersede	supersede	VBP
18637	8301	13	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	8301	14	State	State	NNP
18637	8301	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	8301	16	governing	govern	VBG
18637	8301	17	the	the	DT
18637	8301	18	right	right	NN
18637	8301	19	of	of	IN
18637	8301	20	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	8301	21	to	to	TO
18637	8301	22	inherit	inherit	VB
18637	8301	23	real	real	JJ
18637	8301	24	estate	estate	NN
18637	8301	25	.	.	.
18637	8302	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8302	2	158	158	CD
18637	8302	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8302	4	Such	such	PDT
18637	8302	5	a	a	DT
18637	8302	6	case	case	NN
18637	8302	7	was	be	VBD
18637	8302	8	Hauenstein	Hauenstein	NNP
18637	8302	9	_	_	NNP
18637	8302	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	8302	11	_	_	NNP
18637	8302	12	Lynham,[159	Lynham,[159	NNP
18637	8302	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8302	14	in	in	IN
18637	8302	15	which	which	WDT
18637	8302	16	the	the	DT
18637	8302	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8302	18	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	8302	19	the	the	DT
18637	8302	20	right	right	NN
18637	8302	21	of	of	IN
18637	8302	22	a	a	DT
18637	8302	23	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	8302	24	of	of	IN
18637	8302	25	the	the	DT
18637	8302	26	Swiss	Swiss	NNP
18637	8302	27	Republic	Republic	NNP
18637	8302	28	,	,	,
18637	8302	29	under	under	IN
18637	8302	30	the	the	DT
18637	8302	31	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8302	32	of	of	IN
18637	8302	33	1850	1850	CD
18637	8302	34	with	with	IN
18637	8302	35	that	that	DT
18637	8302	36	country	country	NN
18637	8302	37	,	,	,
18637	8302	38	to	to	TO
18637	8302	39	recover	recover	VB
18637	8302	40	the	the	DT
18637	8302	41	estate	estate	NN
18637	8302	42	of	of	IN
18637	8302	43	a	a	DT
18637	8302	44	relative	relative	JJ
18637	8302	45	dying	die	VBG
18637	8302	46	intestate	intestate	NN
18637	8302	47	in	in	IN
18637	8302	48	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	8302	49	,	,	,
18637	8302	50	to	to	TO
18637	8302	51	sell	sell	VB
18637	8302	52	the	the	DT
18637	8302	53	same	same	JJ
18637	8302	54	and	and	CC
18637	8302	55	to	to	TO
18637	8302	56	export	export	VB
18637	8302	57	the	the	DT
18637	8302	58	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	8302	59	from	from	IN
18637	8302	60	the	the	DT
18637	8302	61	sale	sale	NN
18637	8302	62	.	.	.
18637	8303	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8303	2	160	160	CD
18637	8303	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8303	4	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	8303	5	Cases	case	NNS
18637	8303	6	Certain	certain	JJ
18637	8303	7	more	more	JJR
18637	8303	8	recent	recent	JJ
18637	8303	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	8303	10	stem	stem	VBP
18637	8303	11	from	from	IN
18637	8303	12	California	California	NNP
18637	8303	13	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8303	14	,	,	,
18637	8303	15	most	most	JJS
18637	8303	16	of	of	IN
18637	8303	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8303	18	directed	direct	VBD
18637	8303	19	against	against	IN
18637	8303	20	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	8303	21	immigrants	immigrant	NNS
18637	8303	22	.	.	.
18637	8304	1	A	a	DT
18637	8304	2	statute	statute	NN
18637	8304	3	which	which	WDT
18637	8304	4	excluded	exclude	VBD
18637	8304	5	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	8304	6	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	8304	7	to	to	IN
18637	8304	8	American	american	JJ
18637	8304	9	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	8304	10	from	from	IN
18637	8304	11	owning	own	VBG
18637	8304	12	real	real	JJ
18637	8304	13	estate	estate	NN
18637	8304	14	was	be	VBD
18637	8304	15	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	8304	16	in	in	IN
18637	8304	17	1923	1923	CD
18637	8304	18	on	on	IN
18637	8304	19	the	the	DT
18637	8304	20	ground	ground	NN
18637	8304	21	that	that	IN
18637	8304	22	the	the	DT
18637	8304	23	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8304	24	in	in	IN
18637	8304	25	question	question	NN
18637	8304	26	did	do	VBD
18637	8304	27	not	not	RB
18637	8304	28	secure	secure	VB
18637	8304	29	the	the	DT
18637	8304	30	rights	right	NNS
18637	8304	31	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	8304	32	.	.	.
18637	8305	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8305	2	161	161	CD
18637	8305	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8305	4	But	but	CC
18637	8305	5	in	in	IN
18637	8305	6	Oyama	Oyama	NNP
18637	8305	7	_	_	NNP
18637	8305	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	8305	9	_	_	NNP
18637	8305	10	California,[162	California,[162	NNP
18637	8305	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8305	12	decided	decide	VBD
18637	8305	13	in	in	IN
18637	8305	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	8305	15	,	,	,
18637	8305	16	a	a	DT
18637	8305	17	majority	majority	NN
18637	8305	18	of	of	IN
18637	8305	19	the	the	DT
18637	8305	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8305	21	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	8305	22	a	a	DT
18637	8305	23	strongly	strongly	RB
18637	8305	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	8305	25	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8305	26	that	that	IN
18637	8305	27	this	this	DT
18637	8305	28	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8305	29	conflicted	conflict	VBD
18637	8305	30	with	with	IN
18637	8305	31	the	the	DT
18637	8305	32	equal	equal	JJ
18637	8305	33	protection	protection	NN
18637	8305	34	clause	clause	NN
18637	8305	35	of	of	IN
18637	8305	36	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	8305	37	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	8305	38	,	,	,
18637	8305	39	a	a	DT
18637	8305	40	view	view	NN
18637	8305	41	which	which	WDT
18637	8305	42	has	have	VBZ
18637	8305	43	since	since	IN
18637	8305	44	received	receive	VBN
18637	8305	45	the	the	DT
18637	8305	46	endorsement	endorsement	NN
18637	8305	47	of	of	IN
18637	8305	48	the	the	DT
18637	8305	49	California	California	NNP
18637	8305	50	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8305	51	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8305	52	by	by	IN
18637	8305	53	a	a	DT
18637	8305	54	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	8305	55	majority	majority	NN
18637	8305	56	.	.	.
18637	8306	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8306	2	163	163	CD
18637	8306	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8306	4	Meantime	meantime	RB
18637	8306	5	,	,	,
18637	8306	6	California	California	NNP
18637	8306	7	was	be	VBD
18637	8306	8	informed	inform	VBN
18637	8306	9	that	that	IN
18637	8306	10	the	the	DT
18637	8306	11	rights	right	NNS
18637	8306	12	of	of	IN
18637	8306	13	German	german	JJ
18637	8306	14	nationals	national	NNS
18637	8306	15	,	,	,
18637	8306	16	under	under	IN
18637	8306	17	the	the	DT
18637	8306	18	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	8306	19	of	of	IN
18637	8306	20	December	December	NNP
18637	8306	21	8	8	CD
18637	8306	22	,	,	,
18637	8306	23	1923	1923	CD
18637	8306	24	between	between	IN
18637	8306	25	the	the	DT
18637	8306	26	United	United	NNP
18637	8306	27	States	States	NNP
18637	8306	28	and	and	CC
18637	8306	29	the	the	DT
18637	8306	30	Reich	Reich	NNP
18637	8306	31	,	,	,
18637	8306	32	to	to	TO
18637	8306	33	whom	whom	WP
18637	8306	34	real	real	JJ
18637	8306	35	property	property	NN
18637	8306	36	in	in	IN
18637	8306	37	the	the	DT
18637	8306	38	United	United	NNP
18637	8306	39	States	States	NNP
18637	8306	40	had	have	VBD
18637	8306	41	descended	descend	VBN
18637	8306	42	or	or	CC
18637	8306	43	been	be	VBN
18637	8306	44	devised	devise	VBN
18637	8306	45	,	,	,
18637	8306	46	to	to	TO
18637	8306	47	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	8306	48	of	of	IN
18637	8306	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8306	50	,	,	,
18637	8306	51	had	have	VBD
18637	8306	52	survived	survive	VBN
18637	8306	53	the	the	DT
18637	8306	54	recent	recent	JJ
18637	8306	55	war	war	NN
18637	8306	56	and	and	CC
18637	8306	57	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8306	58	war	war	NN
18637	8306	59	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8306	60	,	,	,
18637	8306	61	and	and	CC
18637	8306	62	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	8306	63	prevailed	prevail	VBD
18637	8306	64	over	over	IN
18637	8306	65	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	8306	66	State	State	NNP
18637	8306	67	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8306	68	.	.	.
18637	8307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8307	2	164	164	CD
18637	8307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8307	4	WHEN	when	WRB
18637	8307	5	IS	IS	NNP
18637	8307	6	A	a	DT
18637	8307	7	TREATY	TREATY	NNP
18637	8307	8	SELF	SELF	NNP
18637	8307	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	8307	10	EXECUTING	executing	NN
18637	8307	11	?	?	.
18637	8308	1	What	what	WP
18637	8308	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8308	3	the	the	DT
18637	8308	4	scope	scope	NN
18637	8308	5	of	of	IN
18637	8308	6	the	the	DT
18637	8308	7	power	power	NN
18637	8308	8	of	of	IN
18637	8308	9	American	american	JJ
18637	8308	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	8308	11	under	under	IN
18637	8308	12	article	article	NN
18637	8308	13	VI	VI	NNP
18637	8308	14	,	,	,
18637	8308	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	8308	16	2	2	CD
18637	8308	17	,	,	,
18637	8308	18	to	to	TO
18637	8308	19	lend	lend	VB
18637	8308	20	ear	ear	NN
18637	8308	21	to	to	IN
18637	8308	22	private	private	JJ
18637	8308	23	claims	claim	NNS
18637	8308	24	based	base	VBN
18637	8308	25	on	on	IN
18637	8308	26	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8308	27	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8308	28	,	,	,
18637	8308	29	on	on	IN
18637	8308	30	the	the	DT
18637	8308	31	ground	ground	NN
18637	8308	32	that	that	IN
18637	8308	33	such	such	JJ
18637	8308	34	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8308	35	are	be	VBP
18637	8308	36	self	self	NN
18637	8308	37	-	-	HYPH
18637	8308	38	executing	execute	VBG
18637	8308	39	?	?	.
18637	8309	1	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	8309	2	had	have	VBD
18637	8309	3	in	in	IN
18637	8309	4	mind	mind	NN
18637	8309	5	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8309	6	intended	intend	VBN
18637	8309	7	victims	victim	NNS
18637	8309	8	of	of	IN
18637	8309	9	State	State	NNP
18637	8309	10	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8309	11	;	;	:
18637	8309	12	and	and	CC
18637	8309	13	in	in	IN
18637	8309	14	fact	fact	NN
18637	8309	15	the	the	DT
18637	8309	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	8309	17	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	8309	18	above	above	IN
18637	8309	19	all	all	DT
18637	8309	20	arose	arise	VBD
18637	8309	21	within	within	IN
18637	8309	22	the	the	DT
18637	8309	23	normal	normal	JJ
18637	8309	24	field	field	NN
18637	8309	25	of	of	IN
18637	8309	26	State	state	NN
18637	8309	27	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8309	28	power	power	NN
18637	8309	29	.	.	.
18637	8310	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	8310	2	,	,	,
18637	8310	3	as	as	RB
18637	8310	4	early	early	RB
18637	8310	5	as	as	IN
18637	8310	6	1801	1801	CD
18637	8310	7	,	,	,
18637	8310	8	in	in	IN
18637	8310	9	United	United	NNP
18637	8310	10	States	States	NNP
18637	8310	11	_	_	NNP
18637	8310	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	8310	13	_	_	NNP
18637	8310	14	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
18637	8310	15	Peggy,[165	Peggy,[165	NNP
18637	8310	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8310	17	the	the	DT
18637	8310	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8310	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8310	20	,	,	,
18637	8310	21	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8310	22	by	by	IN
18637	8310	23	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8310	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8310	25	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	8310	26	,	,	,
18637	8310	27	took	take	VBD
18637	8310	28	notice	notice	NN
18637	8310	29	of	of	IN
18637	8310	30	a	a	DT
18637	8310	31	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8310	32	with	with	IN
18637	8310	33	France	France	NNP
18637	8310	34	,	,	,
18637	8310	35	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8310	36	after	after	IN
18637	8310	37	a	a	DT
18637	8310	38	court	court	NN
18637	8310	39	of	of	IN
18637	8310	40	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	8310	41	had	have	VBD
18637	8310	42	entered	enter	VBN
18637	8310	43	a	a	DT
18637	8310	44	final	final	JJ
18637	8310	45	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8310	46	condemning	condemn	VBG
18637	8310	47	a	a	DT
18637	8310	48	captured	capture	VBN
18637	8310	49	French	french	JJ
18637	8310	50	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	8310	51	,	,	,
18637	8310	52	and	and	CC
18637	8310	53	finding	find	VBG
18637	8310	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8310	55	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	8310	56	to	to	IN
18637	8310	57	the	the	DT
18637	8310	58	situation	situation	NN
18637	8310	59	before	before	IN
18637	8310	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8310	61	,	,	,
18637	8310	62	set	set	VBD
18637	8310	63	the	the	DT
18637	8310	64	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8310	65	aside	aside	RB
18637	8310	66	and	and	CC
18637	8310	67	ordered	order	VBD
18637	8310	68	the	the	DT
18637	8310	69	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	8310	70	restored	restore	VBN
18637	8310	71	to	to	IN
18637	8310	72	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8310	73	owners	owner	NNS
18637	8310	74	.	.	.
18637	8311	1	Since	since	IN
18637	8311	2	that	that	DT
18637	8311	3	time	time	NN
18637	8311	4	the	the	DT
18637	8311	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8311	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	8311	7	declared	declare	VBN
18637	8311	8	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	8311	9	in	in	IN
18637	8311	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	8311	11	in	in	IN
18637	8311	12	which	which	WDT
18637	8311	13	State	State	NNP
18637	8311	14	law	law	NN
18637	8311	15	was	be	VBD
18637	8311	16	not	not	RB
18637	8311	17	involved	involve	VBN
18637	8311	18	that	that	IN
18637	8311	19	when	when	WRB
18637	8311	20	a	a	DT
18637	8311	21	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8311	22	prescribes	prescribe	VBZ
18637	8311	23	a	a	DT
18637	8311	24	rule	rule	NN
18637	8311	25	by	by	IN
18637	8311	26	which	which	WDT
18637	8311	27	private	private	JJ
18637	8311	28	rights	right	NNS
18637	8311	29	are	be	VBP
18637	8311	30	to	to	TO
18637	8311	31	be	be	VB
18637	8311	32	determined	determine	VBN
18637	8311	33	,	,	,
18637	8311	34	the	the	DT
18637	8311	35	courts	court	NNS
18637	8311	36	are	be	VBP
18637	8311	37	bound	bind	VBN
18637	8311	38	to	to	TO
18637	8311	39	take	take	VB
18637	8311	40	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8311	41	notice	notice	NN
18637	8311	42	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8311	43	and	and	CC
18637	8311	44	to	to	TO
18637	8311	45	accept	accept	VB
18637	8311	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8311	47	as	as	IN
18637	8311	48	a	a	DT
18637	8311	49	rule	rule	NN
18637	8311	50	of	of	IN
18637	8311	51	decision	decision	NN
18637	8311	52	in	in	IN
18637	8311	53	any	any	DT
18637	8311	54	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	8311	55	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	8311	56	to	to	TO
18637	8311	57	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	8311	58	such	such	JJ
18637	8311	59	rights	right	NNS
18637	8311	60	.	.	.
18637	8312	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8312	2	166	166	CD
18637	8312	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8312	4	In	in	IN
18637	8312	5	short	short	JJ
18637	8312	6	,	,	,
18637	8312	7	whether	whether	IN
18637	8312	8	a	a	DT
18637	8312	9	given	give	VBN
18637	8312	10	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8312	11	provision	provision	NN
18637	8312	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	8312	13	self	self	NN
18637	8312	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	8312	15	executing	execute	VBG
18637	8312	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	8312	17	a	a	DT
18637	8312	18	question	question	NN
18637	8312	19	for	for	IN
18637	8312	20	the	the	DT
18637	8312	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8312	22	;	;	:
18637	8312	23	although	although	IN
18637	8312	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8312	25	does	do	VBZ
18637	8312	26	not	not	RB
18637	8312	27	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	8312	28	lack	lack	VB
18637	8312	29	guiding	guide	VBG
18637	8312	30	principles	principle	NNS
18637	8312	31	in	in	IN
18637	8312	32	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	8312	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8312	34	,	,	,
18637	8312	35	the	the	DT
18637	8312	36	most	most	RBS
18637	8312	37	important	important	JJ
18637	8312	38	of	of	IN
18637	8312	39	which	which	WDT
18637	8312	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	8312	41	the	the	DT
18637	8312	42	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	8312	43	of	of	IN
18637	8312	44	political	political	JJ
18637	8312	45	questions	question	NNS
18637	8312	46	.	.	.
18637	8313	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8313	2	167	167	CD
18637	8313	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8313	4	_	_	NNP
18637	8313	5	See	See	NNP
18637	8313	6	_	_	NNP
18637	8313	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	8313	8	.	.	.
18637	8314	1	426	426	CD
18637	8314	2	,	,	,
18637	8314	3	471	471	CD
18637	8314	4	-	-	SYM
18637	8314	5	472	472	CD
18637	8314	6	.	.	.
18637	8315	1	CONSTITUTIONAL	constitutional	JJ
18637	8315	2	FREEDOM	freedom	NN
18637	8315	3	OF	of	IN
18637	8315	4	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	8315	5	WITH	with	IN
18637	8315	6	RESPECT	RESPECT	NNS
18637	8315	7	TO	to	IN
18637	8315	8	TREATIES	treaties	NN
18637	8315	9	From	from	IN
18637	8315	10	the	the	DT
18637	8315	11	foregoing	foregoing	JJ
18637	8315	12	two	two	CD
18637	8315	13	other	other	JJ
18637	8315	14	questions	question	NNS
18637	8315	15	arise	arise	VBP
18637	8315	16	:	:	:
18637	8315	17	first	first	RB
18637	8315	18	,	,	,
18637	8315	19	are	be	VBP
18637	8315	20	there	there	EX
18637	8315	21	types	type	NNS
18637	8315	22	of	of	IN
18637	8315	23	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8315	24	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8315	25	which	which	WDT
18637	8315	26	only	only	RB
18637	8315	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8315	28	can	can	MD
18637	8315	29	put	put	VB
18637	8315	30	into	into	IN
18637	8315	31	effect	effect	NN
18637	8315	32	?	?	.
18637	8316	1	Second	second	RB
18637	8316	2	,	,	,
18637	8316	3	assuming	assume	VBG
18637	8316	4	an	an	DT
18637	8316	5	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	8316	6	answer	answer	NN
18637	8316	7	to	to	IN
18637	8316	8	the	the	DT
18637	8316	9	above	above	JJ
18637	8316	10	question	question	NN
18637	8316	11	,	,	,
18637	8316	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	8316	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8316	14	under	under	IN
18637	8316	15	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8316	16	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8316	17	to	to	TO
18637	8316	18	supply	supply	VB
18637	8316	19	such	such	JJ
18637	8316	20	implementation	implementation	NN
18637	8316	21	?	?	.
18637	8317	1	For	for	IN
18637	8317	2	such	such	JJ
18637	8317	3	answer	answer	NN
18637	8317	4	as	as	IN
18637	8317	5	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	8317	6	to	to	IN
18637	8317	7	the	the	DT
18637	8317	8	first	first	JJ
18637	8317	9	question	question	NN
18637	8317	10	resort	resort	NN
18637	8317	11	must	must	MD
18637	8317	12	be	be	VB
18637	8317	13	had	have	VBN
18637	8317	14	to	to	IN
18637	8317	15	the	the	DT
18637	8317	16	record	record	NN
18637	8317	17	of	of	IN
18637	8317	18	practice	practice	NN
18637	8317	19	and	and	CC
18637	8317	20	nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	8317	21	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8317	22	.	.	.
18637	8318	1	The	the	DT
18637	8318	2	question	question	NN
18637	8318	3	arose	arise	VBD
18637	8318	4	originally	originally	RB
18637	8318	5	in	in	IN
18637	8318	6	1796	1796	CD
18637	8318	7	in	in	IN
18637	8318	8	connection	connection	NN
18637	8318	9	with	with	IN
18637	8318	10	the	the	DT
18637	8318	11	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	8318	12	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	8318	13	,	,	,
18637	8318	14	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8318	15	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8318	16	of	of	IN
18637	8318	17	which	which	WDT
18637	8318	18	required	require	VBD
18637	8318	19	appropriations	appropriation	NNS
18637	8318	20	to	to	TO
18637	8318	21	carry	carry	VB
18637	8318	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8318	23	into	into	IN
18637	8318	24	effect	effect	NN
18637	8318	25	.	.	.
18637	8319	1	In	in	IN
18637	8319	2	view	view	NN
18637	8319	3	of	of	IN
18637	8319	4	the	the	DT
18637	8319	5	third	third	JJ
18637	8319	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	8319	7	of	of	IN
18637	8319	8	article	article	NN
18637	8319	9	I	i	NN
18637	8319	10	,	,	,
18637	8319	11	section	section	NN
18637	8319	12	9	9	CD
18637	8319	13	of	of	IN
18637	8319	14	the	the	DT
18637	8319	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8319	16	,	,	,
18637	8319	17	which	which	WDT
18637	8319	18	says	say	VBZ
18637	8319	19	that	that	IN
18637	8319	20	"	"	``
18637	8319	21	no	no	DT
18637	8319	22	money	money	NN
18637	8319	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	8319	24	be	be	VB
18637	8319	25	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	8319	26	from	from	IN
18637	8319	27	the	the	DT
18637	8319	28	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	8319	29	,	,	,
18637	8319	30	but	but	CC
18637	8319	31	in	in	IN
18637	8319	32	Consequence	Consequence	NNP
18637	8319	33	of	of	IN
18637	8319	34	Appropriations	Appropriations	NNPS
18637	8319	35	made	make	VBN
18637	8319	36	by	by	IN
18637	8319	37	law	law	NN
18637	8319	38	;	;	:
18637	8319	39	*	*	NFP
18637	8319	40	*	*	NFP
18637	8319	41	*	*	NFP
18637	8319	42	,	,	,
18637	8319	43	"	"	``
18637	8319	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8319	45	was	be	VBD
18637	8319	46	universally	universally	RB
18637	8319	47	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	8319	48	that	that	IN
18637	8319	49	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8319	50	must	must	MD
18637	8319	51	be	be	VB
18637	8319	52	applied	apply	VBN
18637	8319	53	to	to	IN
18637	8319	54	if	if	IN
18637	8319	55	the	the	DT
18637	8319	56	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8319	57	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8319	58	alluded	allude	VBD
18637	8319	59	to	to	TO
18637	8319	60	were	be	VBD
18637	8319	61	to	to	TO
18637	8319	62	be	be	VB
18637	8319	63	put	put	VBN
18637	8319	64	into	into	IN
18637	8319	65	execution	execution	NN
18637	8319	66	.	.	.
18637	8320	1	But	but	CC
18637	8320	2	at	at	IN
18637	8320	3	this	this	DT
18637	8320	4	point	point	NN
18637	8320	5	the	the	DT
18637	8320	6	second	second	JJ
18637	8320	7	question	question	NN
18637	8320	8	arose	arise	VBD
18637	8320	9	,	,	,
18637	8320	10	to	to	IN
18637	8320	11	the	the	DT
18637	8320	12	solution	solution	NN
18637	8320	13	of	of	IN
18637	8320	14	which	which	WDT
18637	8320	15	the	the	DT
18637	8320	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8320	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	8320	18	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	8320	19	contributed	contribute	VBN
18637	8320	20	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	8320	21	.	.	.
18637	8321	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8321	2	_	_	NNP
18637	8321	3	See	See	NNP
18637	8321	4	_	_	NNP
18637	8321	5	pp	pp	NNP
18637	8321	6	.	.	.
18637	8322	1	420	420	CD
18637	8322	2	-	-	SYM
18637	8322	3	421	421	CD
18637	8322	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8322	5	.	.	.
18637	8323	1	A	a	DT
18637	8323	2	bill	bill	NN
18637	8323	3	being	be	VBG
18637	8323	4	introduced	introduce	VBN
18637	8323	5	into	into	IN
18637	8323	6	the	the	DT
18637	8323	7	House	House	NNP
18637	8323	8	of	of	IN
18637	8323	9	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	8323	10	to	to	TO
18637	8323	11	vote	vote	VB
18637	8323	12	the	the	DT
18637	8323	13	needed	need	VBN
18637	8323	14	funds	fund	NNS
18637	8323	15	,	,	,
18637	8323	16	supporters	supporter	NNS
18637	8323	17	of	of	IN
18637	8323	18	the	the	DT
18637	8323	19	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8323	20	,	,	,
18637	8323	21	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	8323	22	,	,	,
18637	8323	23	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8323	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8323	25	Ellsworth	Ellsworth	NNP
18637	8323	26	,	,	,
18637	8323	27	and	and	CC
18637	8323	28	others	other	NNS
18637	8323	29	,	,	,
18637	8323	30	argued	argue	VBD
18637	8323	31	that	that	IN
18637	8323	32	the	the	DT
18637	8323	33	House	House	NNP
18637	8323	34	must	must	MD
18637	8323	35	make	make	VB
18637	8323	36	the	the	DT
18637	8323	37	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	8323	38	willy	willy	RB
18637	8323	39	nilly	nilly	RB
18637	8323	40	;	;	:
18637	8323	41	that	that	IN
18637	8323	42	the	the	DT
18637	8323	43	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8323	44	,	,	,
18637	8323	45	having	have	VBG
18637	8323	46	been	be	VBN
18637	8323	47	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	8323	48	by	by	IN
18637	8323	49	and	and	CC
18637	8323	50	with	with	IN
18637	8323	51	the	the	DT
18637	8323	52	advice	advice	NN
18637	8323	53	and	and	CC
18637	8323	54	consent	consent	NN
18637	8323	55	of	of	IN
18637	8323	56	the	the	DT
18637	8323	57	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8323	58	,	,	,
18637	8323	59	was	be	VBD
18637	8323	60	"	"	``
18637	8323	61	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	8323	62	law	law	NN
18637	8323	63	of	of	IN
18637	8323	64	the	the	DT
18637	8323	65	land	land	NN
18637	8323	66	,	,	,
18637	8323	67	"	"	''
18637	8323	68	and	and	CC
18637	8323	69	that	that	IN
18637	8323	70	the	the	DT
18637	8323	71	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8323	72	branch	branch	NN
18637	8323	73	was	be	VBD
18637	8323	74	bound	bind	VBN
18637	8323	75	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	8323	76	no	no	RB
18637	8323	77	less	less	JJR
18637	8323	78	than	than	IN
18637	8323	79	the	the	DT
18637	8323	80	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8323	81	and	and	CC
18637	8323	82	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8323	83	branches	branch	NNS
18637	8323	84	.	.	.
18637	8324	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8324	2	168	168	CD
18637	8324	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8324	4	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8324	5	,	,	,
18637	8324	6	a	a	DT
18637	8324	7	member	member	NN
18637	8324	8	of	of	IN
18637	8324	9	the	the	DT
18637	8324	10	House	House	NNP
18637	8324	11	,	,	,
18637	8324	12	opposed	oppose	VBD
18637	8324	13	this	this	DT
18637	8324	14	thesis	thesis	NN
18637	8324	15	in	in	IN
18637	8324	16	a	a	DT
18637	8324	17	series	series	NN
18637	8324	18	of	of	IN
18637	8324	19	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	8324	20	,	,	,
18637	8324	21	the	the	DT
18637	8324	22	nub	nub	NN
18637	8324	23	of	of	IN
18637	8324	24	which	which	WDT
18637	8324	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	8324	26	comprised	comprise	VBN
18637	8324	27	in	in	IN
18637	8324	28	the	the	DT
18637	8324	29	following	follow	VBG
18637	8324	30	statement	statement	NN
18637	8324	31	:	:	:
18637	8324	32	"	"	``
18637	8324	33	When	when	WRB
18637	8324	34	a	a	DT
18637	8324	35	Treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8324	36	stipulates	stipulate	VBZ
18637	8324	37	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	8324	38	on	on	IN
18637	8324	39	any	any	DT
18637	8324	40	of	of	IN
18637	8324	41	the	the	DT
18637	8324	42	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	8324	43	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	8324	44	by	by	IN
18637	8324	45	the	the	DT
18637	8324	46	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8324	47	to	to	IN
18637	8324	48	the	the	DT
18637	8324	49	power	power	NN
18637	8324	50	of	of	IN
18637	8324	51	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8324	52	,	,	,
18637	8324	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8324	54	must	must	MD
18637	8324	55	depend	depend	VB
18637	8324	56	for	for	IN
18637	8324	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8324	58	execution	execution	NN
18637	8324	59	,	,	,
18637	8324	60	as	as	IN
18637	8324	61	to	to	IN
18637	8324	62	such	such	JJ
18637	8324	63	stipulations	stipulation	NNS
18637	8324	64	,	,	,
18637	8324	65	on	on	IN
18637	8324	66	a	a	DT
18637	8324	67	law	law	NN
18637	8324	68	or	or	CC
18637	8324	69	laws	law	NNS
18637	8324	70	to	to	TO
18637	8324	71	be	be	VB
18637	8324	72	passed	pass	VBN
18637	8324	73	by	by	IN
18637	8324	74	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8324	75	.	.	.
18637	8325	1	And	and	CC
18637	8325	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8325	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8325	4	the	the	DT
18637	8325	5	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8325	6	right	right	NN
18637	8325	7	and	and	CC
18637	8325	8	duty	duty	NN
18637	8325	9	of	of	IN
18637	8325	10	the	the	DT
18637	8325	11	House	House	NNP
18637	8325	12	of	of	IN
18637	8325	13	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	8325	14	,	,	,
18637	8325	15	in	in	IN
18637	8325	16	all	all	DT
18637	8325	17	such	such	JJ
18637	8325	18	cases	case	NNS
18637	8325	19	,	,	,
18637	8325	20	to	to	TO
18637	8325	21	deliberate	deliberate	VB
18637	8325	22	on	on	IN
18637	8325	23	the	the	DT
18637	8325	24	expediency	expediency	NN
18637	8325	25	or	or	CC
18637	8325	26	inexpediency	inexpediency	NN
18637	8325	27	of	of	IN
18637	8325	28	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	8325	29	such	such	JJ
18637	8325	30	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	8325	31	into	into	IN
18637	8325	32	effect	effect	NN
18637	8325	33	,	,	,
18637	8325	34	and	and	CC
18637	8325	35	to	to	TO
18637	8325	36	determine	determine	VB
18637	8325	37	and	and	CC
18637	8325	38	act	act	VB
18637	8325	39	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	8325	40	,	,	,
18637	8325	41	as	as	IN
18637	8325	42	,	,	,
18637	8325	43	in	in	IN
18637	8325	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8325	45	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8325	46	,	,	,
18637	8325	47	may	may	MD
18637	8325	48	be	be	VB
18637	8325	49	most	most	RBS
18637	8325	50	conducive	conducive	JJ
18637	8325	51	to	to	IN
18637	8325	52	the	the	DT
18637	8325	53	public	public	JJ
18637	8325	54	good	good	NN
18637	8325	55	.	.	.
18637	8326	1	"	"	``
18637	8326	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8326	3	169	169	CD
18637	8326	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8326	5	The	the	DT
18637	8326	6	upshot	upshot	NN
18637	8326	7	of	of	IN
18637	8326	8	the	the	DT
18637	8326	9	matter	matter	NN
18637	8326	10	was	be	VBD
18637	8326	11	that	that	IN
18637	8326	12	the	the	DT
18637	8326	13	House	House	NNP
18637	8326	14	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	8326	15	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8326	16	's	's	POS
18637	8326	17	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	8326	18	,	,	,
18637	8326	19	while	while	IN
18637	8326	20	at	at	IN
18637	8326	21	the	the	DT
18637	8326	22	same	same	JJ
18637	8326	23	time	time	NN
18637	8326	24	voting	vote	VBG
18637	8326	25	the	the	DT
18637	8326	26	required	require	VBN
18637	8326	27	funds	fund	NNS
18637	8326	28	.	.	.
18637	8327	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8327	2	170	170	CD
18637	8327	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8327	4	THE	the	DT
18637	8327	5	TREATY	TREATY	NNP
18637	8327	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	8327	7	MAKING	make	VBG
18637	8327	8	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	8327	9	AND	and	CC
18637	8327	10	REVENUE	revenue	VB
18637	8327	11	LAWS	laws	NN
18637	8327	12	On	on	IN
18637	8327	13	the	the	DT
18637	8327	14	whole	whole	NN
18637	8327	15	,	,	,
18637	8327	16	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8327	17	's	's	POS
18637	8327	18	position	position	NN
18637	8327	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	8327	20	prospered	prosper	VBN
18637	8327	21	.	.	.
18637	8328	1	Discussion	discussion	NN
18637	8328	2	whether	whether	IN
18637	8328	3	there	there	EX
18637	8328	4	are	be	VBP
18637	8328	5	other	other	JJ
18637	8328	6	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8328	7	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8328	8	than	than	IN
18637	8328	9	those	those	DT
18637	8328	10	calling	call	VBG
18637	8328	11	for	for	IN
18637	8328	12	an	an	DT
18637	8328	13	expenditure	expenditure	NN
18637	8328	14	of	of	IN
18637	8328	15	money	money	NN
18637	8328	16	which	which	WDT
18637	8328	17	require	require	VBP
18637	8328	18	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8328	19	to	to	TO
18637	8328	20	render	render	VB
18637	8328	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8328	22	legally	legally	RB
18637	8328	23	operative	operative	JJ
18637	8328	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	8328	25	centered	center	VBN
18637	8328	26	chiefly	chiefly	RB
18637	8328	27	on	on	IN
18637	8328	28	the	the	DT
18637	8328	29	question	question	NN
18637	8328	30	whether	whether	IN
18637	8328	31	the	the	DT
18637	8328	32	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8328	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	8328	34	making	make	VBG
18637	8328	35	power	power	NN
18637	8328	36	can	can	MD
18637	8328	37	of	of	IN
18637	8328	38	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8328	39	alone	alone	RB
18637	8328	40	modify	modify	VB
18637	8328	41	the	the	DT
18637	8328	42	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	8328	43	laws	law	NNS
18637	8328	44	.	.	.
18637	8329	1	From	from	IN
18637	8329	2	an	an	DT
18637	8329	3	early	early	JJ
18637	8329	4	date	date	NN
18637	8329	5	spokesmen	spokesman	NNS
18637	8329	6	for	for	IN
18637	8329	7	the	the	DT
18637	8329	8	House	House	NNP
18637	8329	9	have	have	VBP
18637	8329	10	urged	urge	VBN
18637	8329	11	that	that	IN
18637	8329	12	a	a	DT
18637	8329	13	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8329	14	does	do	VBZ
18637	8329	15	not	not	RB
18637	8329	16	,	,	,
18637	8329	17	and	and	CC
18637	8329	18	can	can	MD
18637	8329	19	not	not	RB
18637	8329	20	,	,	,
18637	8329	21	_	_	NNP
18637	8329	22	ex	ex	NNP
18637	8329	23	proprio	proprio	NNP
18637	8329	24	vigore	vigore	NN
18637	8329	25	_	_	NNP
18637	8329	26	,	,	,
18637	8329	27	become	become	VB
18637	8329	28	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	8329	29	law	law	NNP
18637	8329	30	of	of	IN
18637	8329	31	the	the	DT
18637	8329	32	land	land	NN
18637	8329	33	on	on	IN
18637	8329	34	this	this	DT
18637	8329	35	subject	subject	NN
18637	8329	36	;	;	:
18637	8329	37	and	and	CC
18637	8329	38	while	while	IN
18637	8329	39	the	the	DT
18637	8329	40	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8329	41	has	have	VBZ
18637	8329	42	never	never	RB
18637	8329	43	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	8329	44	this	this	DT
18637	8329	45	claim	claim	NN
18637	8329	46	formally	formally	RB
18637	8329	47	,	,	,
18637	8329	48	yet	yet	CC
18637	8329	49	in	in	IN
18637	8329	50	a	a	DT
18637	8329	51	number	number	NN
18637	8329	52	of	of	IN
18637	8329	53	instances	instance	NNS
18637	8329	54	,	,	,
18637	8329	55	"	"	''
18637	8329	56	the	the	DT
18637	8329	57	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8329	58	-	-	HYPH
18637	8329	59	making	make	VBG
18637	8329	60	power	power	NN
18637	8329	61	has	have	VBZ
18637	8329	62	inserted	insert	VBN
18637	8329	63	in	in	IN
18637	8329	64	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8329	65	negotiated	negotiate	VBN
18637	8329	66	by	by	IN
18637	8329	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8329	68	and	and	CC
18637	8329	69	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	8329	70	the	the	DT
18637	8329	71	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	8329	72	laws	law	NNS
18637	8329	73	of	of	IN
18637	8329	74	the	the	DT
18637	8329	75	United	United	NNP
18637	8329	76	States	States	NNP
18637	8329	77	,	,	,
18637	8329	78	a	a	DT
18637	8329	79	proviso	proviso	NN
18637	8329	80	that	that	IN
18637	8329	81	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8329	82	should	should	MD
18637	8329	83	not	not	RB
18637	8329	84	be	be	VB
18637	8329	85	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	8329	86	effective	effective	JJ
18637	8329	87	until	until	IN
18637	8329	88	the	the	DT
18637	8329	89	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8329	90	laws	law	NNS
18637	8329	91	to	to	TO
18637	8329	92	carry	carry	VB
18637	8329	93	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8329	94	into	into	IN
18637	8329	95	operation	operation	NN
18637	8329	96	should	should	MD
18637	8329	97	be	be	VB
18637	8329	98	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	8329	99	by	by	IN
18637	8329	100	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8329	101	,	,	,
18637	8329	102	and	and	CC
18637	8329	103	the	the	DT
18637	8329	104	House	House	NNP
18637	8329	105	has	have	VBZ
18637	8329	106	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	8329	107	that	that	IN
18637	8329	108	the	the	DT
18637	8329	109	insertion	insertion	NN
18637	8329	110	of	of	IN
18637	8329	111	such	such	JJ
18637	8329	112	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	8329	113	has	have	VBZ
18637	8329	114	been	be	VBN
18637	8329	115	,	,	,
18637	8329	116	in	in	IN
18637	8329	117	substance	substance	NN
18637	8329	118	,	,	,
18637	8329	119	a	a	DT
18637	8329	120	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8329	121	of	of	IN
18637	8329	122	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8329	123	claim	claim	NN
18637	8329	124	in	in	IN
18637	8329	125	the	the	DT
18637	8329	126	premises,"[171	premises,"[171	NN
18637	8329	127	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8329	128	although	although	IN
18637	8329	129	there	there	EX
18637	8329	130	are	be	VBP
18637	8329	131	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8329	132	dicta	dicta	NN
18637	8329	133	which	which	WDT
18637	8329	134	inferentially	inferentially	RB
18637	8329	135	support	support	VBP
18637	8329	136	the	the	DT
18637	8329	137	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8329	138	's	's	POS
18637	8329	139	position	position	NN
18637	8329	140	.	.	.
18637	8330	1	Latterly	latterly	RB
18637	8330	2	the	the	DT
18637	8330	3	question	question	NN
18637	8330	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	8330	5	become	become	VBN
18637	8330	6	largely	largely	RB
18637	8330	7	academic	academic	JJ
18637	8330	8	.	.	.
18637	8331	1	Commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	8331	2	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8331	3	nowadays	nowadays	RB
18637	8331	4	are	be	VBP
18637	8331	5	usually	usually	RB
18637	8331	6	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8331	7	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8331	8	contracted	contract	VBN
18637	8331	9	by	by	IN
18637	8331	10	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	8331	11	of	of	IN
18637	8331	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8331	13	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8331	14	.	.	.
18637	8332	1	Today	today	NN
18637	8332	2	the	the	DT
18637	8332	3	vital	vital	JJ
18637	8332	4	issue	issue	NN
18637	8332	5	in	in	IN
18637	8332	6	this	this	DT
18637	8332	7	area	area	NN
18637	8332	8	of	of	IN
18637	8332	9	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	8332	10	Law	Law	NNP
18637	8332	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	8332	12	whether	whether	IN
18637	8332	13	the	the	DT
18637	8332	14	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8332	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	8332	16	making	make	VBG
18637	8332	17	power	power	NN
18637	8332	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	8332	19	competent	competent	JJ
18637	8332	20	to	to	TO
18637	8332	21	assume	assume	VB
18637	8332	22	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	8332	23	for	for	IN
18637	8332	24	the	the	DT
18637	8332	25	United	United	NNP
18637	8332	26	States	States	NNP
18637	8332	27	in	in	IN
18637	8332	28	the	the	DT
18637	8332	29	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8332	30	of	of	IN
18637	8332	31	which	which	WDT
18637	8332	32	the	the	DT
18637	8332	33	President	President	NNP
18637	8332	34	can	can	MD
18637	8332	35	,	,	,
18637	8332	36	without	without	IN
18637	8332	37	violation	violation	NN
18637	8332	38	of	of	IN
18637	8332	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8332	40	oath	oath	NN
18637	8332	41	to	to	TO
18637	8332	42	support	support	VB
18637	8332	43	the	the	DT
18637	8332	44	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8332	45	,	,	,
18637	8332	46	involve	involve	VBP
18637	8332	47	the	the	DT
18637	8332	48	country	country	NN
18637	8332	49	in	in	IN
18637	8332	50	large	large	JJ
18637	8332	51	scale	scale	NN
18637	8332	52	military	military	JJ
18637	8332	53	operations	operation	NNS
18637	8332	54	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	8332	55	without	without	IN
18637	8332	56	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	8332	57	by	by	IN
18637	8332	58	the	the	DT
18637	8332	59	war	war	NN
18637	8332	60	-	-	HYPH
18637	8332	61	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	8332	62	power	power	NN
18637	8332	63	,	,	,
18637	8332	64	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8332	65	to	to	IN
18637	8332	66	wit	wit	NN
18637	8332	67	.	.	.
18637	8333	1	Current	current	JJ
18637	8333	2	military	military	JJ
18637	8333	3	operations	operation	NNS
18637	8333	4	in	in	IN
18637	8333	5	Korea	Korea	NNP
18637	8333	6	appear	appear	VBP
18637	8333	7	to	to	TO
18637	8333	8	assume	assume	VB
18637	8333	9	an	an	DT
18637	8333	10	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	8333	11	answer	answer	NN
18637	8333	12	to	to	IN
18637	8333	13	this	this	DT
18637	8333	14	question	question	NN
18637	8333	15	.	.	.
18637	8334	1	CONGRESSIONAL	congressional	JJ
18637	8334	2	REPEAL	REPEAL	NNS
18637	8334	3	OF	of	IN
18637	8334	4	TREATIES	treaty	NNS
18637	8334	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8334	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	8334	7	in	in	IN
18637	8334	8	respect	respect	NN
18637	8334	9	to	to	IN
18637	8334	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8334	11	contention	contention	NN
18637	8334	12	that	that	IN
18637	8334	13	when	when	WRB
18637	8334	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8334	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	8334	16	asked	ask	VBN
18637	8334	17	to	to	TO
18637	8334	18	carry	carry	VB
18637	8334	19	a	a	DT
18637	8334	20	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8334	21	into	into	IN
18637	8334	22	effect	effect	NN
18637	8334	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8334	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	8334	25	the	the	DT
18637	8334	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8334	27	right	right	NN
18637	8334	28	,	,	,
18637	8334	29	and	and	CC
18637	8334	30	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	8334	31	the	the	DT
18637	8334	32	duty	duty	NN
18637	8334	33	,	,	,
18637	8334	34	to	to	TO
18637	8334	35	determine	determine	VB
18637	8334	36	the	the	DT
18637	8334	37	matter	matter	NN
18637	8334	38	according	accord	VBG
18637	8334	39	to	to	IN
18637	8334	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8334	41	own	own	JJ
18637	8334	42	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	8334	43	of	of	IN
18637	8334	44	what	what	WP
18637	8334	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	8334	46	expedient	expedient	JJ
18637	8334	47	,	,	,
18637	8334	48	that	that	IN
18637	8334	49	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8334	50	has	have	VBZ
18637	8334	51	been	be	VBN
18637	8334	52	most	most	RBS
18637	8334	53	completely	completely	RB
18637	8334	54	vindicated	vindicate	VBN
18637	8334	55	by	by	IN
18637	8334	56	developments	development	NNS
18637	8334	57	.	.	.
18637	8335	1	This	this	DT
18637	8335	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8335	3	seen	see	VBN
18637	8335	4	in	in	IN
18637	8335	5	the	the	DT
18637	8335	6	answer	answer	NN
18637	8335	7	which	which	WDT
18637	8335	8	the	the	DT
18637	8335	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8335	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	8335	11	returned	return	VBN
18637	8335	12	to	to	IN
18637	8335	13	the	the	DT
18637	8335	14	question	question	NN
18637	8335	15	,	,	,
18637	8335	16	as	as	IN
18637	8335	17	to	to	IN
18637	8335	18	what	what	WP
18637	8335	19	happens	happen	VBZ
18637	8335	20	when	when	WRB
18637	8335	21	a	a	DT
18637	8335	22	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8335	23	provision	provision	NN
18637	8335	24	and	and	CC
18637	8335	25	an	an	DT
18637	8335	26	act	act	NN
18637	8335	27	of	of	IN
18637	8335	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8335	29	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	8335	30	.	.	.
18637	8336	1	The	the	DT
18637	8336	2	answer	answer	NN
18637	8336	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8336	4	,	,	,
18637	8336	5	that	that	IN
18637	8336	6	neither	neither	DT
18637	8336	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	8336	8	any	any	DT
18637	8336	9	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
18637	8336	10	superiority	superiority	NN
18637	8336	11	over	over	IN
18637	8336	12	the	the	DT
18637	8336	13	other	other	JJ
18637	8336	14	and	and	CC
18637	8336	15	that	that	IN
18637	8336	16	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8336	17	the	the	DT
18637	8336	18	one	one	CD
18637	8336	19	of	of	IN
18637	8336	20	later	later	JJ
18637	8336	21	date	date	NN
18637	8336	22	will	will	MD
18637	8336	23	prevail	prevail	VB
18637	8336	24	_	_	NNP
18637	8336	25	leges	leges	NNP
18637	8336	26	posteriores	posteriore	NNS
18637	8336	27	priores	priores	NNP
18637	8336	28	contrarias	contrarias	NNP
18637	8336	29	abrogant	abrogant	NNP
18637	8336	30	_	_	NNP
18637	8336	31	.	.	.
18637	8337	1	In	in	IN
18637	8337	2	short	short	JJ
18637	8337	3	,	,	,
18637	8337	4	the	the	DT
18637	8337	5	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8337	6	commitments	commitment	NNS
18637	8337	7	of	of	IN
18637	8337	8	the	the	DT
18637	8337	9	United	United	NNP
18637	8337	10	States	States	NNP
18637	8337	11	in	in	IN
18637	8337	12	no	no	DT
18637	8337	13	wise	wise	JJ
18637	8337	14	diminish	diminish	NN
18637	8337	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8337	16	's	's	POS
18637	8337	17	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8337	18	powers	power	NNS
18637	8337	19	.	.	.
18637	8338	1	To	to	TO
18637	8338	2	be	be	VB
18637	8338	3	sure	sure	JJ
18637	8338	4	,	,	,
18637	8338	5	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8338	6	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	8338	7	of	of	IN
18637	8338	8	a	a	DT
18637	8338	9	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8338	10	as	as	IN
18637	8338	11	law	law	NN
18637	8338	12	of	of	IN
18637	8338	13	the	the	DT
18637	8338	14	land	land	NN
18637	8338	15	may	may	MD
18637	8338	16	amount	amount	VB
18637	8338	17	to	to	IN
18637	8338	18	a	a	DT
18637	8338	19	violation	violation	NN
18637	8338	20	of	of	IN
18637	8338	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8338	22	as	as	IN
18637	8338	23	an	an	DT
18637	8338	24	international	international	JJ
18637	8338	25	contract	contract	NN
18637	8338	26	in	in	IN
18637	8338	27	the	the	DT
18637	8338	28	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8338	29	of	of	IN
18637	8338	30	the	the	DT
18637	8338	31	other	other	JJ
18637	8338	32	party	party	NN
18637	8338	33	to	to	IN
18637	8338	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8338	35	.	.	.
18637	8339	1	In	in	IN
18637	8339	2	such	such	JJ
18637	8339	3	case	case	NN
18637	8339	4	,	,	,
18637	8339	5	as	as	IN
18637	8339	6	the	the	DT
18637	8339	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8339	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	8339	9	said	say	VBD
18637	8339	10	,	,	,
18637	8339	11	"	"	``
18637	8339	12	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8339	13	infraction	infraction	NN
18637	8339	14	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	8339	15	the	the	DT
18637	8339	16	subject	subject	NN
18637	8339	17	of	of	IN
18637	8339	18	international	international	JJ
18637	8339	19	negotiations	negotiation	NNS
18637	8339	20	and	and	CC
18637	8339	21	reclamations	reclamation	NNS
18637	8339	22	,	,	,
18637	8339	23	so	so	RB
18637	8339	24	far	far	RB
18637	8339	25	as	as	IN
18637	8339	26	the	the	DT
18637	8339	27	injured	injure	VBN
18637	8339	28	party	party	NN
18637	8339	29	chooses	choose	NNS
18637	8339	30	to	to	TO
18637	8339	31	seek	seek	VB
18637	8339	32	redress	redress	NN
18637	8339	33	,	,	,
18637	8339	34	which	which	WDT
18637	8339	35	may	may	MD
18637	8339	36	in	in	IN
18637	8339	37	the	the	DT
18637	8339	38	end	end	NN
18637	8339	39	be	be	VB
18637	8339	40	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	8339	41	by	by	IN
18637	8339	42	actual	actual	JJ
18637	8339	43	war	war	NN
18637	8339	44	.	.	.
18637	8340	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8340	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8340	3	obvious	obvious	JJ
18637	8340	4	that	that	IN
18637	8340	5	with	with	IN
18637	8340	6	all	all	PDT
18637	8340	7	this	this	DT
18637	8340	8	the	the	DT
18637	8340	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8340	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	8340	11	have	have	VBP
18637	8340	12	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	8340	13	to	to	TO
18637	8340	14	do	do	VB
18637	8340	15	and	and	CC
18637	8340	16	can	can	MD
18637	8340	17	give	give	VB
18637	8340	18	no	no	DT
18637	8340	19	redress	redress	NN
18637	8340	20	.	.	.
18637	8341	1	"	"	``
18637	8341	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8341	3	172	172	CD
18637	8341	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8341	5	TREATIES	TREATIES	NNP
18637	8341	6	_	_	NNP
18637	8341	7	Versus	Versus	NNP
18637	8341	8	_	_	NNP
18637	8341	9	PRIOR	PRIOR	NNP
18637	8341	10	ACTS	ACTS	NNP
18637	8341	11	OF	of	IN
18637	8341	12	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	8341	13	The	the	DT
18637	8341	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	8341	15	are	be	VBP
18637	8341	16	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	8341	17	in	in	IN
18637	8341	18	which	which	WDT
18637	8341	19	the	the	DT
18637	8341	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8341	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	8341	22	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	8341	23	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	8341	24	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8341	25	which	which	WDT
18637	8341	26	were	be	VBD
18637	8341	27	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	8341	28	by	by	IN
18637	8341	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8341	30	as	as	IN
18637	8341	31	superseding	supersede	VBG
18637	8341	32	prior	prior	JJ
18637	8341	33	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8341	34	engagements	engagement	NNS
18637	8341	35	.	.	.
18637	8342	1	How	how	WRB
18637	8342	2	as	as	IN
18637	8342	3	to	to	IN
18637	8342	4	the	the	DT
18637	8342	5	converse	converse	NN
18637	8342	6	situation	situation	NN
18637	8342	7	?	?	.
18637	8343	1	Two	two	CD
18637	8343	2	early	early	JJ
18637	8343	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	8343	4	in	in	IN
18637	8343	5	which	which	WDT
18637	8343	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8343	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8343	8	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	8343	9	spoke	speak	VBD
18637	8343	10	for	for	IN
18637	8343	11	the	the	DT
18637	8343	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8343	13	,	,	,
18637	8343	14	stand	stand	VB
18637	8343	15	for	for	IN
18637	8343	16	the	the	DT
18637	8343	17	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	8343	18	that	that	WDT
18637	8343	19	treaties	treatie	VBZ
18637	8343	20	,	,	,
18637	8343	21	so	so	RB
18637	8343	22	far	far	RB
18637	8343	23	as	as	IN
18637	8343	24	self	self	NN
18637	8343	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	8343	26	executing	execute	VBG
18637	8343	27	,	,	,
18637	8343	28	repeal	repeal	RB
18637	8343	29	earlier	early	RBR
18637	8343	30	conflicting	conflicting	JJ
18637	8343	31	acts	act	NNS
18637	8343	32	of	of	IN
18637	8343	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8343	34	.	.	.
18637	8344	1	In	in	IN
18637	8344	2	the	the	DT
18637	8344	3	case	case	NN
18637	8344	4	of	of	IN
18637	8344	5	the	the	DT
18637	8344	6	"	"	``
18637	8344	7	_	_	NNP
18637	8344	8	Peggy_,"[173	peggy_,"[173	NN
18637	8344	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8344	10	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8344	11	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	8344	12	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8344	13	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	8344	14	with	with	IN
18637	8344	15	the	the	DT
18637	8344	16	trial	trial	NN
18637	8344	17	of	of	IN
18637	8344	18	prize	prize	NN
18637	8344	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	8344	20	were	be	VBD
18637	8344	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	8344	22	to	to	TO
18637	8344	23	have	have	VB
18637	8344	24	been	be	VBN
18637	8344	25	modified	modify	VBN
18637	8344	26	by	by	IN
18637	8344	27	a	a	DT
18637	8344	28	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	8344	29	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8344	30	with	with	IN
18637	8344	31	France	France	NNP
18637	8344	32	;	;	:
18637	8344	33	and	and	CC
18637	8344	34	in	in	IN
18637	8344	35	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	8344	36	_	_	NNP
18637	8344	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	8344	38	_	_	NNP
18637	8344	39	.	.	.
18637	8345	1	Neilson,[174	Neilson,[174	NNP
18637	8345	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8345	3	while	while	IN
18637	8345	4	holding	hold	VBG
18637	8345	5	--	--	:
18637	8345	6	mistakenly	mistakenly	RB
18637	8345	7	as	as	IN
18637	8345	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8345	9	later	later	RBR
18637	8345	10	admitted[175]--that	admitted[175]--that	IN
18637	8345	11	the	the	DT
18637	8345	12	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8345	13	of	of	IN
18637	8345	14	January	January	NNP
18637	8345	15	24	24	CD
18637	8345	16	,	,	,
18637	8345	17	1818	1818	CD
18637	8345	18	with	with	IN
18637	8345	19	Spain	Spain	NNP
18637	8345	20	was	be	VBD
18637	8345	21	not	not	RB
18637	8345	22	self	self	NN
18637	8345	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	8345	24	executing	execute	VBG
18637	8345	25	with	with	IN
18637	8345	26	respect	respect	NN
18637	8345	27	to	to	IN
18637	8345	28	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8345	29	land	land	NN
18637	8345	30	grants	grant	NNS
18637	8345	31	,	,	,
18637	8345	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8345	33	went	go	VBD
18637	8345	34	on	on	RP
18637	8345	35	to	to	TO
18637	8345	36	say	say	VB
18637	8345	37	that	that	IN
18637	8345	38	if	if	IN
18637	8345	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8345	40	had	have	VBD
18637	8345	41	been	be	VBN
18637	8345	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8345	43	would	would	MD
18637	8345	44	have	have	VB
18637	8345	45	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	8345	46	acts	act	NNS
18637	8345	47	of	of	IN
18637	8345	48	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8345	49	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	8345	50	to	to	IN
18637	8345	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8345	52	.	.	.
18637	8346	1	With	with	IN
18637	8346	2	one	one	CD
18637	8346	3	exception	exception	NN
18637	8346	4	,	,	,
18637	8346	5	however	however	RB
18637	8346	6	,	,	,
18637	8346	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8346	8	dicta	dicta	NN
18637	8346	9	which	which	WDT
18637	8346	10	reiterate	reiterate	VBP
18637	8346	11	this	this	DT
18637	8346	12	idea	idea	NN
18637	8346	13	are	be	VBP
18637	8346	14	obiter	obiter	JJ
18637	8346	15	,	,	,
18637	8346	16	and	and	CC
18637	8346	17	are	be	VBP
18637	8346	18	disparaged	disparage	VBN
18637	8346	19	by	by	IN
18637	8346	20	Willoughby	Willoughby	NNP
18637	8346	21	,	,	,
18637	8346	22	as	as	IN
18637	8346	23	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	8346	24	:	:	:
18637	8346	25	"	"	``
18637	8346	26	In	in	IN
18637	8346	27	fact	fact	NN
18637	8346	28	,	,	,
18637	8346	29	however	however	RB
18637	8346	30	,	,	,
18637	8346	31	there	there	EX
18637	8346	32	have	have	VBP
18637	8346	33	been	be	VBN
18637	8346	34	few	few	JJ
18637	8346	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8346	36	the	the	DT
18637	8346	37	writer	writer	NN
18637	8346	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	8346	39	not	not	RB
18637	8346	40	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8346	41	that	that	IN
18637	8346	42	there	there	EX
18637	8346	43	have	have	VBP
18637	8346	44	been	be	VBN
18637	8346	45	any	any	DT
18637	8346	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8346	47	instances	instance	NNS
18637	8346	48	in	in	IN
18637	8346	49	which	which	WDT
18637	8346	50	a	a	DT
18637	8346	51	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8346	52	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	8346	53	with	with	IN
18637	8346	54	a	a	DT
18637	8346	55	prior	prior	JJ
18637	8346	56	act	act	NN
18637	8346	57	of	of	IN
18637	8346	58	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8346	59	has	have	VBZ
18637	8346	60	been	be	VBN
18637	8346	61	given	give	VBN
18637	8346	62	full	full	JJ
18637	8346	63	force	force	NN
18637	8346	64	and	and	CC
18637	8346	65	effect	effect	NN
18637	8346	66	as	as	IN
18637	8346	67	law	law	NN
18637	8346	68	in	in	IN
18637	8346	69	this	this	DT
18637	8346	70	country	country	NN
18637	8346	71	without	without	IN
18637	8346	72	the	the	DT
18637	8346	73	assent	assent	NN
18637	8346	74	of	of	IN
18637	8346	75	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8346	76	.	.	.
18637	8347	1	There	there	EX
18637	8347	2	may	may	MD
18637	8347	3	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	8347	4	have	have	VB
18637	8347	5	been	be	VBN
18637	8347	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	8347	7	in	in	IN
18637	8347	8	which	which	WDT
18637	8347	9	,	,	,
18637	8347	10	by	by	IN
18637	8347	11	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8347	12	,	,	,
18637	8347	13	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8347	14	action	action	NN
18637	8347	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	8347	16	been	be	VBN
18637	8347	17	taken	take	VBN
18637	8347	18	without	without	IN
18637	8347	19	reference	reference	NN
18637	8347	20	to	to	IN
18637	8347	21	existing	exist	VBG
18637	8347	22	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8347	23	laws	law	NNS
18637	8347	24	,	,	,
18637	8347	25	as	as	IN
18637	8347	26	,	,	,
18637	8347	27	for	for	IN
18637	8347	28	example	example	NN
18637	8347	29	,	,	,
18637	8347	30	where	where	WRB
18637	8347	31	by	by	IN
18637	8347	32	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8347	33	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8347	34	populations	population	NNS
18637	8347	35	have	have	VBP
18637	8347	36	been	be	VBN
18637	8347	37	collectively	collectively	RB
18637	8347	38	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	8347	39	,	,	,
18637	8347	40	but	but	CC
18637	8347	41	such	such	JJ
18637	8347	42	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8347	43	action	action	NN
18637	8347	44	has	have	VBZ
18637	8347	45	not	not	RB
18637	8347	46	operated	operate	VBN
18637	8347	47	to	to	TO
18637	8347	48	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	8347	49	or	or	CC
18637	8347	50	annul	annul	VB
18637	8347	51	the	the	DT
18637	8347	52	existing	exist	VBG
18637	8347	53	law	law	NN
18637	8347	54	upon	upon	IN
18637	8347	55	the	the	DT
18637	8347	56	subject	subject	NN
18637	8347	57	.	.	.
18637	8348	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	8348	2	,	,	,
18637	8348	3	with	with	IN
18637	8348	4	specific	specific	JJ
18637	8348	5	reference	reference	NN
18637	8348	6	to	to	IN
18637	8348	7	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	8348	8	arrangements	arrangement	NNS
18637	8348	9	with	with	IN
18637	8348	10	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8348	11	powers	power	NNS
18637	8348	12	,	,	,
18637	8348	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8348	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	8348	15	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	8348	16	denied	deny	VBN
18637	8348	17	that	that	IN
18637	8348	18	a	a	DT
18637	8348	19	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8348	20	can	can	MD
18637	8348	21	operate	operate	VB
18637	8348	22	to	to	TO
18637	8348	23	modify	modify	VB
18637	8348	24	the	the	DT
18637	8348	25	arrangements	arrangement	NNS
18637	8348	26	which	which	WDT
18637	8348	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8348	28	,	,	,
18637	8348	29	by	by	IN
18637	8348	30	statute	statute	NN
18637	8348	31	,	,	,
18637	8348	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	8348	33	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8348	34	,	,	,
18637	8348	35	and	and	CC
18637	8348	36	,	,	,
18637	8348	37	in	in	IN
18637	8348	38	actual	actual	JJ
18637	8348	39	practice	practice	NN
18637	8348	40	,	,	,
18637	8348	41	has	have	VBZ
18637	8348	42	in	in	IN
18637	8348	43	every	every	DT
18637	8348	44	instance	instance	NN
18637	8348	45	succeeded	succeed	VBN
18637	8348	46	in	in	IN
18637	8348	47	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	8348	48	this	this	DT
18637	8348	49	point	point	NN
18637	8348	50	.	.	.
18637	8349	1	"	"	``
18637	8349	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8349	3	176	176	CD
18637	8349	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8349	5	The	the	DT
18637	8349	6	single	single	JJ
18637	8349	7	exception	exception	NN
18637	8349	8	just	just	RB
18637	8349	9	alluded	allude	VBN
18637	8349	10	to	to	IN
18637	8349	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	8349	12	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	8349	13	_	_	NNP
18637	8349	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	8349	15	_	_	NNP
18637	8349	16	United	United	NNP
18637	8349	17	States,[177	States,[177	NNP
18637	8349	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8349	19	which	which	WDT
18637	8349	20	may	may	MD
18637	8349	21	be	be	VB
18637	8349	22	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	8349	23	as	as	IN
18637	8349	24	part	part	NN
18637	8349	25	of	of	IN
18637	8349	26	the	the	DT
18637	8349	27	aftermath	aftermath	NN
18637	8349	28	of	of	IN
18637	8349	29	National	National	NNP
18637	8349	30	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	8349	31	.	.	.
18637	8350	1	Here	here	RB
18637	8350	2	a	a	DT
18637	8350	3	divided	divide	VBN
18637	8350	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8350	5	,	,	,
18637	8350	6	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8350	7	by	by	IN
18637	8350	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8350	9	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	8350	10	,	,	,
18637	8350	11	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	8350	12	that	that	IN
18637	8350	13	the	the	DT
18637	8350	14	authority	authority	NN
18637	8350	15	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	8350	16	by	by	IN
18637	8350	17	§	§	NNP
18637	8350	18	581	581	CD
18637	8350	19	of	of	IN
18637	8350	20	the	the	DT
18637	8350	21	Tariff	Tariff	NNP
18637	8350	22	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8350	23	of	of	IN
18637	8350	24	1922	1922	CD
18637	8350	25	and	and	CC
18637	8350	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8350	27	reenactment	reenactment	NN
18637	8350	28	in	in	IN
18637	8350	29	the	the	DT
18637	8350	30	tariff	tariff	NN
18637	8350	31	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8350	32	of	of	IN
18637	8350	33	1930	1930	CD
18637	8350	34	,	,	,
18637	8350	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	8350	36	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8350	37	of	of	IN
18637	8350	38	the	the	DT
18637	8350	39	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	8350	40	Guard	Guard	NNP
18637	8350	41	to	to	TO
18637	8350	42	stop	stop	VB
18637	8350	43	and	and	CC
18637	8350	44	board	board	VB
18637	8350	45	any	any	DT
18637	8350	46	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	8350	47	at	at	IN
18637	8350	48	any	any	DT
18637	8350	49	place	place	NN
18637	8350	50	within	within	IN
18637	8350	51	four	four	CD
18637	8350	52	leagues	league	NNS
18637	8350	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8350	54	12	12	CD
18637	8350	55	miles	mile	NNS
18637	8350	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8350	57	of	of	IN
18637	8350	58	the	the	DT
18637	8350	59	coast	coast	NN
18637	8350	60	of	of	IN
18637	8350	61	the	the	DT
18637	8350	62	United	United	NNP
18637	8350	63	States	States	NNP
18637	8350	64	and	and	CC
18637	8350	65	to	to	TO
18637	8350	66	seize	seize	VB
18637	8350	67	the	the	DT
18637	8350	68	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	8350	69	,	,	,
18637	8350	70	if	if	IN
18637	8350	71	upon	upon	IN
18637	8350	72	examination	examination	NN
18637	8350	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8350	74	shall	shall	MD
18637	8350	75	appear	appear	VB
18637	8350	76	that	that	IN
18637	8350	77	any	any	DT
18637	8350	78	violation	violation	NN
18637	8350	79	of	of	IN
18637	8350	80	the	the	DT
18637	8350	81	law	law	NN
18637	8350	82	has	have	VBZ
18637	8350	83	been	be	VBN
18637	8350	84	committed	commit	VBN
18637	8350	85	by	by	IN
18637	8350	86	reason	reason	NN
18637	8350	87	of	of	IN
18637	8350	88	which	which	WDT
18637	8350	89	the	the	DT
18637	8350	90	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	8350	91	or	or	CC
18637	8350	92	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	8350	93	therein	therein	RB
18637	8350	94	is	be	VBZ
18637	8350	95	liable	liable	JJ
18637	8350	96	to	to	IN
18637	8350	97	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	8350	98	,	,	,
18637	8350	99	is	be	VBZ
18637	8350	100	,	,	,
18637	8350	101	as	as	IN
18637	8350	102	respects	respect	VBZ
18637	8350	103	British	british	JJ
18637	8350	104	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	8350	105	suspected	suspect	VBN
18637	8350	106	of	of	IN
18637	8350	107	being	be	VBG
18637	8350	108	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	8350	109	in	in	IN
18637	8350	110	attempting	attempt	VBG
18637	8350	111	to	to	TO
18637	8350	112	import	import	VB
18637	8350	113	alcoholic	alcoholic	JJ
18637	8350	114	beverages	beverage	NNS
18637	8350	115	into	into	IN
18637	8350	116	the	the	DT
18637	8350	117	United	United	NNP
18637	8350	118	States	States	NNP
18637	8350	119	in	in	IN
18637	8350	120	violation	violation	NN
18637	8350	121	of	of	IN
18637	8350	122	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8350	123	laws	law	NNS
18637	8350	124	,	,	,
18637	8350	125	modified	modify	VBN
18637	8350	126	by	by	IN
18637	8350	127	the	the	DT
18637	8350	128	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	8350	129	of	of	IN
18637	8350	130	May	May	NNP
18637	8350	131	22	22	CD
18637	8350	132	,	,	,
18637	8350	133	1924	1924	CD
18637	8350	134	,	,	,
18637	8350	135	between	between	IN
18637	8350	136	the	the	DT
18637	8350	137	United	United	NNP
18637	8350	138	States	States	NNP
18637	8350	139	and	and	CC
18637	8350	140	Great	Great	NNP
18637	8350	141	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	8350	142	,	,	,
18637	8350	143	so	so	IN
18637	8350	144	as	as	IN
18637	8350	145	to	to	TO
18637	8350	146	allow	allow	VB
18637	8350	147	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	8350	148	of	of	IN
18637	8350	149	such	such	JJ
18637	8350	150	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	8350	151	only	only	RB
18637	8350	152	within	within	IN
18637	8350	153	the	the	DT
18637	8350	154	distance	distance	NN
18637	8350	155	from	from	IN
18637	8350	156	the	the	DT
18637	8350	157	coast	coast	NN
18637	8350	158	which	which	WDT
18637	8350	159	can	can	MD
18637	8350	160	be	be	VB
18637	8350	161	traversed	traverse	VBN
18637	8350	162	in	in	IN
18637	8350	163	one	one	CD
18637	8350	164	hour	hour	NN
18637	8350	165	by	by	IN
18637	8350	166	the	the	DT
18637	8350	167	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	8350	168	suspected	suspect	VBN
18637	8350	169	of	of	IN
18637	8350	170	endeavoring	endeavor	VBG
18637	8350	171	to	to	TO
18637	8350	172	commit	commit	VB
18637	8350	173	the	the	DT
18637	8350	174	offense	offense	NN
18637	8350	175	.	.	.
18637	8351	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8351	2	178	178	CD
18637	8351	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8351	4	Only	only	RB
18637	8351	5	one	one	CD
18637	8351	6	case	case	NN
18637	8351	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	8351	8	cited	cite	VBN
18637	8351	9	in	in	IN
18637	8351	10	support	support	NN
18637	8351	11	of	of	IN
18637	8351	12	the	the	DT
18637	8351	13	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	8351	14	that	that	IN
18637	8351	15	the	the	DT
18637	8351	16	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8351	17	,	,	,
18637	8351	18	being	be	VBG
18637	8351	19	of	of	IN
18637	8351	20	later	late	JJR
18637	8351	21	date	date	NN
18637	8351	22	than	than	IN
18637	8351	23	the	the	DT
18637	8351	24	act	act	NN
18637	8351	25	of	of	IN
18637	8351	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8351	27	,	,	,
18637	8351	28	superseded	supersede	VBD
18637	8351	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8351	30	so	so	RB
18637	8351	31	far	far	RB
18637	8351	32	as	as	IN
18637	8351	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8351	34	were	be	VBD
18637	8351	35	in	in	IN
18637	8351	36	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	8351	37	.	.	.
18637	8352	1	This	this	DT
18637	8352	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8352	3	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	8352	4	_	_	NNP
18637	8352	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	8352	6	_	_	NNP
18637	8352	7	Robertson,[179	Robertson,[179	NNP
18637	8352	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8352	9	in	in	IN
18637	8352	10	which	which	WDT
18637	8352	11	an	an	DT
18637	8352	12	act	act	NN
18637	8352	13	of	of	IN
18637	8352	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8352	15	was	be	VBD
18637	8352	16	held	hold	VBN
18637	8352	17	to	to	TO
18637	8352	18	have	have	VB
18637	8352	19	superseded	supersede	VBN
18637	8352	20	conflicting	conflicting	JJ
18637	8352	21	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8352	22	of	of	IN
18637	8352	23	a	a	DT
18637	8352	24	prior	prior	JJ
18637	8352	25	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8352	26	.	.	.
18637	8353	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	8353	2	,	,	,
18637	8353	3	the	the	DT
18637	8353	4	act	act	NN
18637	8353	5	of	of	IN
18637	8353	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8353	7	involved	involve	VBN
18637	8353	8	in	in	IN
18637	8353	9	the	the	DT
18637	8353	10	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	8353	11	case	case	NN
18637	8353	12	had	have	VBD
18637	8353	13	,	,	,
18637	8353	14	as	as	IN
18637	8353	15	above	above	RB
18637	8353	16	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	8353	17	,	,	,
18637	8353	18	been	be	VBN
18637	8353	19	reenacted	reenact	VBN
18637	8353	20	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	8353	21	to	to	IN
18637	8353	22	the	the	DT
18637	8353	23	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8353	24	involved	involve	VBN
18637	8353	25	.	.	.
18637	8354	1	The	the	DT
18637	8354	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	8354	3	actually	actually	RB
18637	8354	4	accomplishes	accomplish	VBZ
18637	8354	5	the	the	DT
18637	8354	6	singular	singular	JJ
18637	8354	7	result	result	NN
18637	8354	8	of	of	IN
18637	8354	9	reversing	reverse	VBG
18637	8354	10	the	the	DT
18637	8354	11	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	8354	12	_	_	NNP
18637	8354	13	leges	lege	VBZ
18637	8354	14	posteriores	posteriore	NNS
18637	8354	15	_	_	NNP
18637	8354	16	.	.	.
18637	8355	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8355	2	may	may	MD
18637	8355	3	be	be	VB
18637	8355	4	suspected	suspect	VBN
18637	8355	5	that	that	IN
18637	8355	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8355	7	was	be	VBD
18637	8355	8	devised	devise	VBN
18637	8355	9	to	to	TO
18637	8355	10	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	8355	11	a	a	DT
18637	8355	12	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8355	13	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	8355	14	which	which	WDT
18637	8355	15	in	in	IN
18637	8355	16	the	the	DT
18637	8355	17	low	low	JJ
18637	8355	18	estate	estate	NN
18637	8355	19	of	of	IN
18637	8355	20	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	8355	21	at	at	IN
18637	8355	22	that	that	DT
18637	8355	23	date	date	NN
18637	8355	24	would	would	MD
18637	8355	25	not	not	RB
18637	8355	26	have	have	VB
18637	8355	27	been	be	VBN
18637	8355	28	worthwhile	worthwhile	JJ
18637	8355	29	.	.	.
18637	8356	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8356	2	180	180	CD
18637	8356	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8356	4	INTERPRETATION	INTERPRETATION	NNS
18637	8356	5	AND	and	CC
18637	8356	6	TERMINATION	termination	NN
18637	8356	7	OF	of	IN
18637	8356	8	TREATIES	TREATIES	NNP
18637	8356	9	AS	as	IN
18637	8356	10	INTERNATIONAL	INTERNATIONAL	NNP
18637	8356	11	COMPACTS	COMPACTS	NNP
18637	8356	12	The	the	DT
18637	8356	13	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	8356	14	by	by	IN
18637	8356	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8356	16	of	of	IN
18637	8356	17	the	the	DT
18637	8356	18	"	"	``
18637	8356	19	self	self	NN
18637	8356	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	8356	21	executing	execute	VBG
18637	8356	22	"	"	''
18637	8356	23	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	8356	24	of	of	IN
18637	8356	25	a	a	DT
18637	8356	26	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8356	27	as	as	IN
18637	8356	28	"	"	``
18637	8356	29	law	law	NN
18637	8356	30	of	of	IN
18637	8356	31	the	the	DT
18637	8356	32	land	land	NN
18637	8356	33	"	"	``
18637	8356	34	does	do	VBZ
18637	8356	35	not	not	RB
18637	8356	36	of	of	IN
18637	8356	37	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8356	38	terminate	terminate	VB
18637	8356	39	the	the	DT
18637	8356	40	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8356	41	as	as	IN
18637	8356	42	an	an	DT
18637	8356	43	international	international	JJ
18637	8356	44	contract	contract	NN
18637	8356	45	,	,	,
18637	8356	46	although	although	IN
18637	8356	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8356	48	may	may	MD
18637	8356	49	very	very	RB
18637	8356	50	well	well	RB
18637	8356	51	provoke	provoke	VB
18637	8356	52	the	the	DT
18637	8356	53	other	other	JJ
18637	8356	54	party	party	NN
18637	8356	55	to	to	IN
18637	8356	56	the	the	DT
18637	8356	57	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8356	58	to	to	TO
18637	8356	59	do	do	VB
18637	8356	60	so	so	RB
18637	8356	61	.	.	.
18637	8357	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	8357	2	the	the	DT
18637	8357	3	question	question	NN
18637	8357	4	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	8357	5	of	of	IN
18637	8357	6	where	where	WRB
18637	8357	7	the	the	DT
18637	8357	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8357	9	lodges	lodge	VBZ
18637	8357	10	this	this	DT
18637	8357	11	power	power	NN
18637	8357	12	;	;	:
18637	8357	13	also	also	RB
18637	8357	14	the	the	DT
18637	8357	15	closely	closely	RB
18637	8357	16	related	related	JJ
18637	8357	17	question	question	NN
18637	8357	18	of	of	IN
18637	8357	19	where	where	WRB
18637	8357	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8357	21	lodges	lodge	VBZ
18637	8357	22	the	the	DT
18637	8357	23	power	power	NN
18637	8357	24	to	to	TO
18637	8357	25	interpret	interpret	VB
18637	8357	26	the	the	DT
18637	8357	27	contractual	contractual	JJ
18637	8357	28	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8357	29	of	of	IN
18637	8357	30	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8357	31	.	.	.
18637	8358	1	The	the	DT
18637	8358	2	first	first	JJ
18637	8358	3	case	case	NN
18637	8358	4	of	of	IN
18637	8358	5	outright	outright	JJ
18637	8358	6	abrogation	abrogation	NN
18637	8358	7	of	of	IN
18637	8358	8	a	a	DT
18637	8358	9	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8358	10	by	by	IN
18637	8358	11	the	the	DT
18637	8358	12	United	United	NNP
18637	8358	13	States	States	NNP
18637	8358	14	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	8358	15	in	in	IN
18637	8358	16	1798	1798	CD
18637	8358	17	,	,	,
18637	8358	18	when	when	WRB
18637	8358	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8358	20	,	,	,
18637	8358	21	by	by	IN
18637	8358	22	the	the	DT
18637	8358	23	act	act	NN
18637	8358	24	of	of	IN
18637	8358	25	July	July	NNP
18637	8358	26	7	7	CD
18637	8358	27	of	of	IN
18637	8358	28	that	that	DT
18637	8358	29	year	year	NN
18637	8358	30	,	,	,
18637	8358	31	pronounced	pronounce	VBD
18637	8358	32	the	the	DT
18637	8358	33	United	United	NNP
18637	8358	34	States	States	NNP
18637	8358	35	freed	free	VBD
18637	8358	36	and	and	CC
18637	8358	37	exonerated	exonerate	VBD
18637	8358	38	from	from	IN
18637	8358	39	the	the	DT
18637	8358	40	stipulations	stipulation	NNS
18637	8358	41	of	of	IN
18637	8358	42	the	the	DT
18637	8358	43	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	8358	44	of	of	IN
18637	8358	45	1778	1778	CD
18637	8358	46	with	with	IN
18637	8358	47	France	France	NNP
18637	8358	48	.	.	.
18637	8359	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8359	2	181	181	CD
18637	8359	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8359	4	This	this	DT
18637	8359	5	act	act	NN
18637	8359	6	was	be	VBD
18637	8359	7	followed	follow	VBN
18637	8359	8	two	two	CD
18637	8359	9	days	day	NNS
18637	8359	10	later	later	RB
18637	8359	11	by	by	IN
18637	8359	12	one	one	CD
18637	8359	13	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	8359	14	limited	limited	JJ
18637	8359	15	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	8359	16	against	against	IN
18637	8359	17	the	the	DT
18637	8359	18	same	same	JJ
18637	8359	19	country	country	NN
18637	8359	20	;	;	:
18637	8359	21	and	and	CC
18637	8359	22	in	in	IN
18637	8359	23	the	the	DT
18637	8359	24	case	case	NN
18637	8359	25	of	of	IN
18637	8359	26	Bas	Bas	NNP
18637	8359	27	_	_	NNP
18637	8359	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	8359	29	_	_	NNP
18637	8359	30	Tingy[182	Tingy[182	NNP
18637	8359	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8359	32	the	the	DT
18637	8359	33	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8359	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8359	35	treated	treat	VBD
18637	8359	36	the	the	DT
18637	8359	37	act	act	NN
18637	8359	38	of	of	IN
18637	8359	39	abrogation	abrogation	NN
18637	8359	40	as	as	IN
18637	8359	41	simply	simply	RB
18637	8359	42	one	one	CD
18637	8359	43	of	of	IN
18637	8359	44	a	a	DT
18637	8359	45	bundle	bundle	NN
18637	8359	46	of	of	IN
18637	8359	47	acts	act	NNS
18637	8359	48	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	8359	49	"	"	``
18637	8359	50	public	public	JJ
18637	8359	51	war	war	NN
18637	8359	52	"	"	''
18637	8359	53	upon	upon	IN
18637	8359	54	the	the	DT
18637	8359	55	French	French	NNP
18637	8359	56	Republic	Republic	NNP
18637	8359	57	.	.	.
18637	8360	1	TERMINATION	termination	NN
18637	8360	2	OF	of	IN
18637	8360	3	TREATIES	treaty	NNS
18637	8360	4	BY	by	IN
18637	8360	5	NOTICE	notice	NN
18637	8360	6	The	the	DT
18637	8360	7	initial	initial	JJ
18637	8360	8	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	8360	9	in	in	IN
18637	8360	10	the	the	DT
18637	8360	11	matter	matter	NN
18637	8360	12	of	of	IN
18637	8360	13	termination	termination	NN
18637	8360	14	by	by	IN
18637	8360	15	notice	notice	NN
18637	8360	16	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	8360	17	in	in	IN
18637	8360	18	1846	1846	CD
18637	8360	19	,	,	,
18637	8360	20	when	when	WRB
18637	8360	21	by	by	IN
18637	8360	22	the	the	DT
18637	8360	23	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	8360	24	Resolution	Resolution	NNP
18637	8360	25	of	of	IN
18637	8360	26	April	April	NNP
18637	8360	27	27	27	CD
18637	8360	28	,	,	,
18637	8360	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8360	30	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	8360	31	the	the	DT
18637	8360	32	President	President	NNP
18637	8360	33	at	at	IN
18637	8360	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8360	35	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	8360	36	to	to	TO
18637	8360	37	notify	notify	VB
18637	8360	38	the	the	DT
18637	8360	39	British	british	JJ
18637	8360	40	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8360	41	of	of	IN
18637	8360	42	the	the	DT
18637	8360	43	abrogation	abrogation	NN
18637	8360	44	of	of	IN
18637	8360	45	the	the	DT
18637	8360	46	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	8360	47	of	of	IN
18637	8360	48	August	August	NNP
18637	8360	49	6	6	CD
18637	8360	50	,	,	,
18637	8360	51	1827	1827	CD
18637	8360	52	,	,	,
18637	8360	53	relative	relative	JJ
18637	8360	54	to	to	IN
18637	8360	55	the	the	DT
18637	8360	56	joint	joint	JJ
18637	8360	57	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	8360	58	of	of	IN
18637	8360	59	the	the	DT
18637	8360	60	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	8360	61	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	8360	62	.	.	.
18637	8361	1	As	as	IN
18637	8361	2	the	the	DT
18637	8361	3	President	President	NNP
18637	8361	4	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8361	5	had	have	VBD
18637	8361	6	requested	request	VBN
18637	8361	7	the	the	DT
18637	8361	8	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	8361	9	,	,	,
18637	8361	10	the	the	DT
18637	8361	11	episode	episode	NN
18637	8361	12	supports	support	VBZ
18637	8361	13	the	the	DT
18637	8361	14	theory	theory	NN
18637	8361	15	that	that	IN
18637	8361	16	international	international	JJ
18637	8361	17	conventions	convention	NNS
18637	8361	18	to	to	TO
18637	8361	19	which	which	WDT
18637	8361	20	the	the	DT
18637	8361	21	United	United	NNP
18637	8361	22	States	States	NNP
18637	8361	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	8361	24	party	party	NN
18637	8361	25	,	,	,
18637	8361	26	even	even	RB
18637	8361	27	those	those	DT
18637	8361	28	terminable	terminable	JJ
18637	8361	29	on	on	IN
18637	8361	30	notice	notice	NN
18637	8361	31	,	,	,
18637	8361	32	are	be	VBP
18637	8361	33	terminable	terminable	JJ
18637	8361	34	only	only	RB
18637	8361	35	by	by	IN
18637	8361	36	act	act	NN
18637	8361	37	of	of	IN
18637	8361	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8361	39	.	.	.
18637	8362	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8362	2	183	183	CD
18637	8362	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8362	4	Subsequently	Subsequently	NNP
18637	8362	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8362	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	8362	7	often	often	RB
18637	8362	8	passed	pass	VBN
18637	8362	9	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	8362	10	denouncing	denounce	VBG
18637	8362	11	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8362	12	or	or	CC
18637	8362	13	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8362	14	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8362	15	which	which	WDT
18637	8362	16	by	by	IN
18637	8362	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8362	18	own	own	JJ
18637	8362	19	terms	term	NNS
18637	8362	20	were	be	VBD
18637	8362	21	terminable	terminable	JJ
18637	8362	22	on	on	IN
18637	8362	23	notice	notice	NN
18637	8362	24	,	,	,
18637	8362	25	and	and	CC
18637	8362	26	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	8362	27	have	have	VBP
18637	8362	28	usually	usually	RB
18637	8362	29	carried	carry	VBN
18637	8362	30	out	out	RP
18637	8362	31	such	such	JJ
18637	8362	32	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	8362	33	,	,	,
18637	8362	34	though	though	IN
18637	8362	35	not	not	RB
18637	8362	36	invariably	invariably	RB
18637	8362	37	.	.	.
18637	8363	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8363	2	184	184	CD
18637	8363	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8363	4	By	by	IN
18637	8363	5	the	the	DT
18637	8363	6	La	La	NNP
18637	8363	7	Follette	Follette	NNP
18637	8363	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	8363	9	Furuseth	Furuseth	NNP
18637	8363	10	Seamen	Seamen	NNP
18637	8363	11	's	's	POS
18637	8363	12	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8363	13	,	,	,
18637	8363	14	approved	approve	VBD
18637	8363	15	March	March	NNP
18637	8363	16	4	4	CD
18637	8363	17	,	,	,
18637	8363	18	1915,[185	1915,[185	CD
18637	8363	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8363	20	President	President	NNP
18637	8363	21	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	8363	22	was	be	VBD
18637	8363	23	directed	direct	VBN
18637	8363	24	,	,	,
18637	8363	25	"	"	''
18637	8363	26	within	within	IN
18637	8363	27	ninety	ninety	CD
18637	8363	28	days	day	NNS
18637	8363	29	after	after	IN
18637	8363	30	the	the	DT
18637	8363	31	passage	passage	NN
18637	8363	32	of	of	IN
18637	8363	33	the	the	DT
18637	8363	34	act	act	NN
18637	8363	35	,	,	,
18637	8363	36	to	to	TO
18637	8363	37	give	give	VB
18637	8363	38	notice	notice	NN
18637	8363	39	to	to	IN
18637	8363	40	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8363	41	governments	government	NNS
18637	8363	42	that	that	WDT
18637	8363	43	so	so	RB
18637	8363	44	much	much	JJ
18637	8363	45	of	of	IN
18637	8363	46	any	any	DT
18637	8363	47	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8363	48	as	as	IN
18637	8363	49	might	may	MD
18637	8363	50	be	be	VB
18637	8363	51	in	in	IN
18637	8363	52	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	8363	53	with	with	IN
18637	8363	54	the	the	DT
18637	8363	55	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8363	56	of	of	IN
18637	8363	57	the	the	DT
18637	8363	58	act	act	NN
18637	8363	59	would	would	MD
18637	8363	60	terminate	terminate	VB
18637	8363	61	on	on	IN
18637	8363	62	the	the	DT
18637	8363	63	expiration	expiration	NN
18637	8363	64	of	of	IN
18637	8363	65	the	the	DT
18637	8363	66	periods	period	NNS
18637	8363	67	of	of	IN
18637	8363	68	notice	notice	NN
18637	8363	69	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8363	70	for	for	IN
18637	8363	71	in	in	IN
18637	8363	72	such	such	JJ
18637	8363	73	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8363	74	,	,	,
18637	8363	75	"	"	''
18637	8363	76	and	and	CC
18637	8363	77	the	the	DT
18637	8363	78	required	required	JJ
18637	8363	79	notice	notice	NN
18637	8363	80	was	be	VBD
18637	8363	81	given	give	VBN
18637	8363	82	.	.	.
18637	8364	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8364	2	186	186	CD
18637	8364	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8364	4	When	when	WRB
18637	8364	5	,	,	,
18637	8364	6	however	however	RB
18637	8364	7	,	,	,
18637	8364	8	by	by	IN
18637	8364	9	section	section	NN
18637	8364	10	34	34	CD
18637	8364	11	of	of	IN
18637	8364	12	the	the	DT
18637	8364	13	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	8364	14	Merchant	Merchant	NNP
18637	8364	15	Marine	Marine	NNP
18637	8364	16	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8364	17	of	of	IN
18637	8364	18	1920	1920	CD
18637	8364	19	the	the	DT
18637	8364	20	same	same	JJ
18637	8364	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8364	22	was	be	VBD
18637	8364	23	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8364	24	and	and	CC
18637	8364	25	directed	direct	VBN
18637	8364	26	within	within	IN
18637	8364	27	ninety	ninety	CD
18637	8364	28	days	day	NNS
18637	8364	29	to	to	TO
18637	8364	30	give	give	VB
18637	8364	31	notice	notice	NN
18637	8364	32	to	to	IN
18637	8364	33	the	the	DT
18637	8364	34	other	other	JJ
18637	8364	35	parties	party	NNS
18637	8364	36	to	to	IN
18637	8364	37	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8364	38	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8364	39	,	,	,
18637	8364	40	which	which	WDT
18637	8364	41	the	the	DT
18637	8364	42	act	act	NN
18637	8364	43	infracted	infract	VBD
18637	8364	44	,	,	,
18637	8364	45	of	of	IN
18637	8364	46	the	the	DT
18637	8364	47	termination	termination	NN
18637	8364	48	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8364	49	,	,	,
18637	8364	50	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8364	51	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	8364	52	to	to	TO
18637	8364	53	comply	comply	VB
18637	8364	54	,	,	,
18637	8364	55	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	8364	56	that	that	IN
18637	8364	57	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8364	58	"	"	``
18637	8364	59	did	do	VBD
18637	8364	60	not	not	RB
18637	8364	61	deem	deem	VB
18637	8364	62	the	the	DT
18637	8364	63	direction	direction	NN
18637	8364	64	contained	contain	VBN
18637	8364	65	in	in	IN
18637	8364	66	section	section	NN
18637	8364	67	34	34	CD
18637	8364	68	*	*	NFP
18637	8364	69	*	*	NFP
18637	8364	70	*	*	NFP
18637	8364	71	an	an	DT
18637	8364	72	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	8364	73	of	of	IN
18637	8364	74	any	any	DT
18637	8364	75	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8364	76	power	power	NN
18637	8364	77	possessed	possess	VBN
18637	8364	78	by	by	IN
18637	8364	79	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8364	80	.	.	.
18637	8365	1	"	"	``
18637	8365	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8365	3	187	187	CD
18637	8365	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8365	5	The	the	DT
18637	8365	6	same	same	JJ
18637	8365	7	intransigent	intransigent	JJ
18637	8365	8	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	8365	9	was	be	VBD
18637	8365	10	continued	continue	VBN
18637	8365	11	by	by	IN
18637	8365	12	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	8365	13	Harding	Harding	NNP
18637	8365	14	and	and	CC
18637	8365	15	Coolidge	Coolidge	NNP
18637	8365	16	.	.	.
18637	8366	1	DETERMINATION	DETERMINATION	NNP
18637	8366	2	WHETHER	whether	IN
18637	8366	3	A	a	DT
18637	8366	4	TREATY	treaty	NN
18637	8366	5	HAS	have	VBZ
18637	8366	6	LAPSED	lapse	VBN
18637	8366	7	At	at	IN
18637	8366	8	the	the	DT
18637	8366	9	same	same	JJ
18637	8366	10	time	time	NN
18637	8366	11	,	,	,
18637	8366	12	there	there	EX
18637	8366	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	8366	14	clear	clear	JJ
18637	8366	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8366	16	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8366	17	that	that	IN
18637	8366	18	the	the	DT
18637	8366	19	President	President	NNP
18637	8366	20	may	may	MD
18637	8366	21	without	without	IN
18637	8366	22	consulting	consult	VBG
18637	8366	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8366	24	validly	validly	RB
18637	8366	25	determine	determine	VBP
18637	8366	26	the	the	DT
18637	8366	27	question	question	NN
18637	8366	28	whether	whether	IN
18637	8366	29	specific	specific	JJ
18637	8366	30	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8366	31	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8366	32	have	have	VBP
18637	8366	33	lapsed	lapse	VBN
18637	8366	34	.	.	.
18637	8367	1	The	the	DT
18637	8367	2	following	follow	VBG
18637	8367	3	passage	passage	NN
18637	8367	4	from	from	IN
18637	8367	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8367	6	Lurton	Lurton	NNP
18637	8367	7	's	's	POS
18637	8367	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8367	9	in	in	IN
18637	8367	10	Charlton	Charlton	NNP
18637	8367	11	_	_	NNP
18637	8367	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	8367	13	_	_	NNP
18637	8367	14	Kelly[188	Kelly[188	NNP
18637	8367	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8367	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	8367	17	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	8367	18	:	:	:
18637	8367	19	"	"	``
18637	8367	20	If	if	IN
18637	8367	21	the	the	DT
18637	8367	22	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	8367	23	of	of	IN
18637	8367	24	Italy	Italy	NNP
18637	8367	25	was	be	VBD
18637	8367	26	,	,	,
18637	8367	27	as	as	IN
18637	8367	28	contended	contend	VBN
18637	8367	29	,	,	,
18637	8367	30	a	a	DT
18637	8367	31	violation	violation	NN
18637	8367	32	of	of	IN
18637	8367	33	the	the	DT
18637	8367	34	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8367	35	of	of	IN
18637	8367	36	the	the	DT
18637	8367	37	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8367	38	,	,	,
18637	8367	39	which	which	WDT
18637	8367	40	,	,	,
18637	8367	41	in	in	IN
18637	8367	42	international	international	JJ
18637	8367	43	law	law	NN
18637	8367	44	,	,	,
18637	8367	45	would	would	MD
18637	8367	46	have	have	VB
18637	8367	47	justified	justify	VBN
18637	8367	48	the	the	DT
18637	8367	49	United	United	NNP
18637	8367	50	States	States	NNP
18637	8367	51	in	in	IN
18637	8367	52	denouncing	denounce	VBG
18637	8367	53	the	the	DT
18637	8367	54	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8367	55	as	as	IN
18637	8367	56	no	no	RB
18637	8367	57	longer	long	RBR
18637	8367	58	obligatory	obligatory	JJ
18637	8367	59	,	,	,
18637	8367	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8367	61	did	do	VBD
18637	8367	62	not	not	RB
18637	8367	63	automatically	automatically	RB
18637	8367	64	have	have	VB
18637	8367	65	that	that	DT
18637	8367	66	effect	effect	NN
18637	8367	67	.	.	.
18637	8368	1	If	if	IN
18637	8368	2	the	the	DT
18637	8368	3	United	United	NNP
18637	8368	4	States	States	NNP
18637	8368	5	elected	elect	VBD
18637	8368	6	not	not	RB
18637	8368	7	to	to	TO
18637	8368	8	declare	declare	VB
18637	8368	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8368	10	abrogation	abrogation	NN
18637	8368	11	,	,	,
18637	8368	12	or	or	CC
18637	8368	13	come	come	VB
18637	8368	14	to	to	IN
18637	8368	15	a	a	DT
18637	8368	16	rupture	rupture	NN
18637	8368	17	,	,	,
18637	8368	18	the	the	DT
18637	8368	19	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8368	20	would	would	MD
18637	8368	21	remain	remain	VB
18637	8368	22	in	in	IN
18637	8368	23	force	force	NN
18637	8368	24	.	.	.
18637	8369	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8369	2	was	be	VBD
18637	8369	3	only	only	RB
18637	8369	4	voidable	voidable	JJ
18637	8369	5	,	,	,
18637	8369	6	not	not	RB
18637	8369	7	void	void	JJ
18637	8369	8	;	;	:
18637	8369	9	and	and	CC
18637	8369	10	if	if	IN
18637	8369	11	the	the	DT
18637	8369	12	United	United	NNP
18637	8369	13	States	States	NNP
18637	8369	14	should	should	MD
18637	8369	15	prefer	prefer	VB
18637	8369	16	,	,	,
18637	8369	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8369	18	might	may	MD
18637	8369	19	waive	waive	VB
18637	8369	20	any	any	DT
18637	8369	21	breach	breach	NN
18637	8369	22	which	which	WDT
18637	8369	23	in	in	IN
18637	8369	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8369	25	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8369	26	had	have	VBD
18637	8369	27	occurred	occur	VBN
18637	8369	28	and	and	CC
18637	8369	29	conform	conform	VB
18637	8369	30	to	to	IN
18637	8369	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8369	32	own	own	JJ
18637	8369	33	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8369	34	as	as	IN
18637	8369	35	if	if	IN
18637	8369	36	there	there	EX
18637	8369	37	had	have	VBD
18637	8369	38	been	be	VBN
18637	8369	39	no	no	DT
18637	8369	40	such	such	JJ
18637	8369	41	breach	breach	NN
18637	8369	42	.	.	.
18637	8370	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8370	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8370	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8370	4	That	that	IN
18637	8370	5	the	the	DT
18637	8370	6	political	political	JJ
18637	8370	7	branch	branch	NN
18637	8370	8	of	of	IN
18637	8370	9	the	the	DT
18637	8370	10	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8370	11	recognizes	recognize	VBZ
18637	8370	12	the	the	DT
18637	8370	13	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8370	14	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8370	15	as	as	IN
18637	8370	16	still	still	RB
18637	8370	17	existing	exist	VBG
18637	8370	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	8370	19	evidenced	evidence	VBN
18637	8370	20	by	by	IN
18637	8370	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8370	22	action	action	NN
18637	8370	23	in	in	IN
18637	8370	24	this	this	DT
18637	8370	25	case	case	NN
18637	8370	26	.	.	.
18637	8371	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8371	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8371	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8371	4	The	the	DT
18637	8371	5	executive	executive	NN
18637	8371	6	department	department	NN
18637	8371	7	having	have	VBG
18637	8371	8	thus	thus	RB
18637	8371	9	elected	elect	VBN
18637	8371	10	to	to	TO
18637	8371	11	waive	waive	VB
18637	8371	12	any	any	DT
18637	8371	13	right	right	NN
18637	8371	14	to	to	TO
18637	8371	15	free	free	VB
18637	8371	16	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8371	17	from	from	IN
18637	8371	18	the	the	DT
18637	8371	19	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8371	20	to	to	TO
18637	8371	21	deliver	deliver	VB
18637	8371	22	up	up	RP
18637	8371	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8371	24	own	own	JJ
18637	8371	25	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8371	26	,	,	,
18637	8371	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8371	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	8371	29	the	the	DT
18637	8371	30	plain	plain	JJ
18637	8371	31	duty	duty	NN
18637	8371	32	of	of	IN
18637	8371	33	this	this	DT
18637	8371	34	court	court	NN
18637	8371	35	to	to	TO
18637	8371	36	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	8371	37	the	the	DT
18637	8371	38	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8371	39	to	to	TO
18637	8371	40	surrender	surrender	VB
18637	8371	41	the	the	DT
18637	8371	42	appellant	appellant	NN
18637	8371	43	as	as	IN
18637	8371	44	one	one	CD
18637	8371	45	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	8371	46	by	by	IN
18637	8371	47	the	the	DT
18637	8371	48	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8371	49	as	as	IN
18637	8371	50	the	the	DT
18637	8371	51	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	8371	52	law	law	NNP
18637	8371	53	of	of	IN
18637	8371	54	the	the	DT
18637	8371	55	land	land	NN
18637	8371	56	as	as	IN
18637	8371	57	affording	afford	VBG
18637	8371	58	authority	authority	NN
18637	8371	59	for	for	IN
18637	8371	60	the	the	DT
18637	8371	61	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	8371	62	of	of	IN
18637	8371	63	extradition	extradition	NN
18637	8371	64	.	.	.
18637	8372	1	"	"	``
18637	8372	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8372	3	189	189	CD
18637	8372	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8372	5	So	so	RB
18637	8372	6	also	also	RB
18637	8372	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8372	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	8372	9	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	8372	10	for	for	IN
18637	8372	11	the	the	DT
18637	8372	12	political	political	JJ
18637	8372	13	departments	department	NNS
18637	8372	14	to	to	TO
18637	8372	15	determine	determine	VB
18637	8372	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	8372	17	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8372	18	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8372	19	of	of	IN
18637	8372	20	a	a	DT
18637	8372	21	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8372	22	have	have	VBP
18637	8372	23	survived	survive	VBN
18637	8372	24	a	a	DT
18637	8372	25	war	war	NN
18637	8372	26	in	in	IN
18637	8372	27	which	which	WDT
18637	8372	28	the	the	DT
18637	8372	29	other	other	JJ
18637	8372	30	contracting	contracting	NN
18637	8372	31	state	state	NN
18637	8372	32	ceased	cease	VBD
18637	8372	33	to	to	TO
18637	8372	34	exist	exist	VB
18637	8372	35	as	as	IN
18637	8372	36	a	a	DT
18637	8372	37	member	member	NN
18637	8372	38	of	of	IN
18637	8372	39	the	the	DT
18637	8372	40	international	international	JJ
18637	8372	41	community	community	NN
18637	8372	42	.	.	.
18637	8373	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8373	2	190	190	CD
18637	8373	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8373	4	STATUS	STATUS	NNP
18637	8373	5	OF	of	IN
18637	8373	6	A	a	DT
18637	8373	7	TREATY	TREATY	NNP
18637	8373	8	A	a	DT
18637	8373	9	POLITICAL	political	NN
18637	8373	10	QUESTION	QUESTION	VBN
18637	8373	11	All	all	RB
18637	8373	12	in	in	IN
18637	8373	13	all	all	DT
18637	8373	14	,	,	,
18637	8373	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8373	16	would	would	MD
18637	8373	17	seem	seem	VB
18637	8373	18	that	that	IN
18637	8373	19	the	the	DT
18637	8373	20	vast	vast	JJ
18637	8373	21	weight	weight	NN
18637	8373	22	both	both	DT
18637	8373	23	of	of	IN
18637	8373	24	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8373	25	practice	practice	NN
18637	8373	26	and	and	CC
18637	8373	27	of	of	IN
18637	8373	28	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8373	29	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8373	30	supports	support	VBZ
18637	8373	31	the	the	DT
18637	8373	32	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	8373	33	that	that	IN
18637	8373	34	the	the	DT
18637	8373	35	power	power	NN
18637	8373	36	of	of	IN
18637	8373	37	terminating	terminate	VBG
18637	8373	38	outright	outright	JJ
18637	8373	39	international	international	JJ
18637	8373	40	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	8373	41	to	to	TO
18637	8373	42	which	which	WDT
18637	8373	43	the	the	DT
18637	8373	44	United	United	NNP
18637	8373	45	States	States	NNP
18637	8373	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	8373	47	party	party	NN
18637	8373	48	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	8373	49	,	,	,
18637	8373	50	as	as	IN
18637	8373	51	a	a	DT
18637	8373	52	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	8373	53	of	of	IN
18637	8373	54	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	8373	55	,	,	,
18637	8373	56	to	to	IN
18637	8373	57	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8373	58	alone	alone	RB
18637	8373	59	,	,	,
18637	8373	60	but	but	CC
18637	8373	61	that	that	IN
18637	8373	62	the	the	DT
18637	8373	63	President	President	NNP
18637	8373	64	may	may	MD
18637	8373	65	,	,	,
18637	8373	66	as	as	IN
18637	8373	67	an	an	DT
18637	8373	68	incident	incident	NN
18637	8373	69	of	of	IN
18637	8373	70	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8373	71	function	function	NN
18637	8373	72	of	of	IN
18637	8373	73	interpreting	interpret	VBG
18637	8373	74	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8373	75	preparatory	preparatory	JJ
18637	8373	76	to	to	IN
18637	8373	77	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	8373	78	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8373	79	,	,	,
18637	8373	80	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	8373	81	authoritatively	authoritatively	RB
18637	8373	82	find	find	VBP
18637	8373	83	that	that	IN
18637	8373	84	a	a	DT
18637	8373	85	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8373	86	contract	contract	NN
18637	8373	87	with	with	IN
18637	8373	88	another	another	DT
18637	8373	89	power	power	NN
18637	8373	90	has	have	VBZ
18637	8373	91	or	or	CC
18637	8373	92	has	have	VBZ
18637	8373	93	not	not	RB
18637	8373	94	been	be	VBN
18637	8373	95	breached	breach	VBN
18637	8373	96	by	by	IN
18637	8373	97	the	the	DT
18637	8373	98	latter	latter	JJ
18637	8373	99	and	and	CC
18637	8373	100	whether	whether	IN
18637	8373	101	,	,	,
18637	8373	102	for	for	IN
18637	8373	103	that	that	DT
18637	8373	104	reason	reason	NN
18637	8373	105	,	,	,
18637	8373	106	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8373	107	is	be	VBZ
18637	8373	108	or	or	CC
18637	8373	109	is	be	VBZ
18637	8373	110	not	not	RB
18637	8373	111	longer	long	RBR
18637	8373	112	binding	bind	VBG
18637	8373	113	on	on	IN
18637	8373	114	the	the	DT
18637	8373	115	United	United	NNP
18637	8373	116	States	States	NNP
18637	8373	117	.	.	.
18637	8374	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8374	2	191	191	CD
18637	8374	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8374	4	At	at	IN
18637	8374	5	any	any	DT
18637	8374	6	rate	rate	NN
18637	8374	7	,	,	,
18637	8374	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8374	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	8374	10	clear	clear	JJ
18637	8374	11	that	that	IN
18637	8374	12	any	any	DT
18637	8374	13	such	such	JJ
18637	8374	14	questions	question	NNS
18637	8374	15	which	which	WDT
18637	8374	16	arise	arise	VBP
18637	8374	17	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	8374	18	a	a	DT
18637	8374	19	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8374	20	are	be	VBP
18637	8374	21	of	of	IN
18637	8374	22	a	a	DT
18637	8374	23	political	political	JJ
18637	8374	24	nature	nature	NN
18637	8374	25	and	and	CC
18637	8374	26	will	will	MD
18637	8374	27	not	not	RB
18637	8374	28	be	be	VB
18637	8374	29	decided	decide	VBN
18637	8374	30	by	by	IN
18637	8374	31	the	the	DT
18637	8374	32	courts	court	NNS
18637	8374	33	.	.	.
18637	8375	1	In	in	IN
18637	8375	2	the	the	DT
18637	8375	3	words	word	NNS
18637	8375	4	of	of	IN
18637	8375	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8375	6	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	8375	7	in	in	IN
18637	8375	8	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	8375	9	_	_	NNP
18637	8375	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	8375	11	_	_	NNP
18637	8375	12	Morton:[192	Morton:[192	NNP
18637	8375	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8375	14	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8375	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	8375	16	not	not	RB
18637	8375	17	"	"	``
18637	8375	18	a	a	DT
18637	8375	19	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8375	20	question	question	NN
18637	8375	21	,	,	,
18637	8375	22	whether	whether	IN
18637	8375	23	a	a	DT
18637	8375	24	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8375	25	with	with	IN
18637	8375	26	a	a	DT
18637	8375	27	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8375	28	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	8375	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	8375	30	been	be	VBN
18637	8375	31	violated	violate	VBN
18637	8375	32	by	by	IN
18637	8375	33	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8375	34	;	;	:
18637	8375	35	whether	whether	IN
18637	8375	36	the	the	DT
18637	8375	37	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	8375	38	of	of	IN
18637	8375	39	a	a	DT
18637	8375	40	particular	particular	JJ
18637	8375	41	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	8375	42	in	in	IN
18637	8375	43	a	a	DT
18637	8375	44	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8375	45	,	,	,
18637	8375	46	has	have	VBZ
18637	8375	47	been	be	VBN
18637	8375	48	voluntarily	voluntarily	RB
18637	8375	49	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	8375	50	by	by	IN
18637	8375	51	one	one	CD
18637	8375	52	party	party	NN
18637	8375	53	,	,	,
18637	8375	54	so	so	IN
18637	8375	55	that	that	IN
18637	8375	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8375	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	8375	58	no	no	DT
18637	8375	59	longer	longer	RB
18637	8375	60	obligatory	obligatory	JJ
18637	8375	61	on	on	IN
18637	8375	62	the	the	DT
18637	8375	63	other	other	JJ
18637	8375	64	;	;	:
18637	8375	65	whether	whether	IN
18637	8375	66	the	the	DT
18637	8375	67	views	view	NNS
18637	8375	68	and	and	CC
18637	8375	69	acts	act	NNS
18637	8375	70	of	of	IN
18637	8375	71	a	a	DT
18637	8375	72	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8375	73	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	8375	74	,	,	,
18637	8375	75	manifested	manifest	VBN
18637	8375	76	through	through	IN
18637	8375	77	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8375	78	representative	representative	NN
18637	8375	79	have	have	VBP
18637	8375	80	given	give	VBN
18637	8375	81	just	just	RB
18637	8375	82	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	8375	83	to	to	IN
18637	8375	84	the	the	DT
18637	8375	85	political	political	JJ
18637	8375	86	departments	department	NNS
18637	8375	87	of	of	IN
18637	8375	88	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8375	89	government	government	NN
18637	8375	90	to	to	TO
18637	8375	91	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	8375	92	the	the	DT
18637	8375	93	execution	execution	NN
18637	8375	94	of	of	IN
18637	8375	95	a	a	DT
18637	8375	96	promise	promise	NN
18637	8375	97	contained	contain	VBN
18637	8375	98	in	in	IN
18637	8375	99	a	a	DT
18637	8375	100	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8375	101	,	,	,
18637	8375	102	or	or	CC
18637	8375	103	to	to	TO
18637	8375	104	act	act	VB
18637	8375	105	in	in	IN
18637	8375	106	direct	direct	JJ
18637	8375	107	contravention	contravention	NN
18637	8375	108	of	of	IN
18637	8375	109	such	such	JJ
18637	8375	110	promise	promise	NN
18637	8375	111	.	.	.
18637	8376	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8376	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8376	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8376	4	These	these	DT
18637	8376	5	powers	power	NNS
18637	8376	6	have	have	VBP
18637	8376	7	not	not	RB
18637	8376	8	been	be	VBN
18637	8376	9	confided	confide	VBN
18637	8376	10	by	by	IN
18637	8376	11	the	the	DT
18637	8376	12	people	people	NNS
18637	8376	13	to	to	IN
18637	8376	14	the	the	DT
18637	8376	15	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	8376	16	,	,	,
18637	8376	17	which	which	WDT
18637	8376	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	8376	19	no	no	DT
18637	8376	20	suitable	suitable	JJ
18637	8376	21	means	mean	NNS
18637	8376	22	to	to	TO
18637	8376	23	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	8376	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8376	25	;	;	:
18637	8376	26	but	but	CC
18637	8376	27	to	to	IN
18637	8376	28	the	the	DT
18637	8376	29	executive	executive	NN
18637	8376	30	and	and	CC
18637	8376	31	the	the	DT
18637	8376	32	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8376	33	departments	department	NNS
18637	8376	34	of	of	IN
18637	8376	35	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8376	36	government	government	NN
18637	8376	37	.	.	.
18637	8377	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8377	2	belong	belong	VBP
18637	8377	3	to	to	IN
18637	8377	4	diplomacy	diplomacy	NN
18637	8377	5	and	and	CC
18637	8377	6	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8377	7	,	,	,
18637	8377	8	and	and	CC
18637	8377	9	not	not	RB
18637	8377	10	to	to	IN
18637	8377	11	the	the	DT
18637	8377	12	administration	administration	NN
18637	8377	13	of	of	IN
18637	8377	14	existing	exist	VBG
18637	8377	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	8377	16	.	.	.
18637	8378	1	And	and	CC
18637	8378	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8378	3	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	8378	4	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	8378	5	,	,	,
18637	8378	6	that	that	IN
18637	8378	7	if	if	IN
18637	8378	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8378	9	are	be	VBP
18637	8378	10	denied	deny	VBN
18637	8378	11	to	to	IN
18637	8378	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8378	13	and	and	CC
18637	8378	14	the	the	DT
18637	8378	15	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8378	16	,	,	,
18637	8378	17	in	in	IN
18637	8378	18	the	the	DT
18637	8378	19	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	8378	20	of	of	IN
18637	8378	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8378	22	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8378	23	power	power	NN
18637	8378	24	,	,	,
18637	8378	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8378	26	can	can	MD
18637	8378	27	be	be	VB
18637	8378	28	found	find	VBN
18637	8378	29	nowhere	nowhere	RB
18637	8378	30	,	,	,
18637	8378	31	in	in	IN
18637	8378	32	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8378	33	system	system	NN
18637	8378	34	of	of	IN
18637	8378	35	government	government	NN
18637	8378	36	.	.	.
18637	8378	37	"	"	''
18637	8379	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8379	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8379	3	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	8379	4	's	's	POS
18637	8379	5	language	language	NN
18637	8379	6	in	in	IN
18637	8379	7	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	8379	8	_	_	NNP
18637	8379	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	8379	10	_	_	NNP
18637	8379	11	Neilson[193	Neilson[193	NNP
18637	8379	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8379	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	8379	14	to	to	IN
18637	8379	15	the	the	DT
18637	8379	16	same	same	JJ
18637	8379	17	effect	effect	NN
18637	8379	18	.	.	.
18637	8380	1	TREATIES	treaty	NNS
18637	8380	2	AND	and	CC
18637	8380	3	THE	the	DT
18637	8380	4	NECESSARY	NECESSARY	NNP
18637	8380	5	AND	and	CC
18637	8380	6	PROPER	PROPER	NNP
18637	8380	7	CLAUSE	clause	NN
18637	8380	8	What	what	WP
18637	8380	9	power	power	NN
18637	8380	10	,	,	,
18637	8380	11	or	or	CC
18637	8380	12	powers	power	NNS
18637	8380	13	,	,	,
18637	8380	14	does	do	VBZ
18637	8380	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8380	16	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	8380	17	when	when	WRB
18637	8380	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8380	19	enacts	enact	VBZ
18637	8380	20	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8380	21	for	for	IN
18637	8380	22	the	the	DT
18637	8380	23	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8380	24	of	of	IN
18637	8380	25	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	8380	26	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8380	27	of	of	IN
18637	8380	28	the	the	DT
18637	8380	29	United	United	NNP
18637	8380	30	States	States	NNP
18637	8380	31	into	into	IN
18637	8380	32	effect	effect	NN
18637	8380	33	?	?	.
18637	8381	1	When	when	WRB
18637	8381	2	the	the	DT
18637	8381	3	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8381	4	matter	matter	NN
18637	8381	5	of	of	IN
18637	8381	6	the	the	DT
18637	8381	7	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8381	8	falls	fall	VBZ
18637	8381	9	within	within	IN
18637	8381	10	the	the	DT
18637	8381	11	ambit	ambit	NN
18637	8381	12	of	of	IN
18637	8381	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8381	14	's	's	POS
18637	8381	15	enumerated	enumerated	JJ
18637	8381	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	8381	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8381	18	those	those	DT
18637	8381	19	listed	list	VBN
18637	8381	20	in	in	IN
18637	8381	21	the	the	DT
18637	8381	22	first	first	JJ
18637	8381	23	17	17	CD
18637	8381	24	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	8381	25	of	of	IN
18637	8381	26	article	article	NN
18637	8381	27	I	i	NN
18637	8381	28	,	,	,
18637	8381	29	section	section	NN
18637	8381	30	8	8	CD
18637	8381	31	of	of	IN
18637	8381	32	the	the	DT
18637	8381	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8381	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8381	35	,	,	,
18637	8381	36	then	then	RB
18637	8381	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8381	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	8381	39	these	these	DT
18637	8381	40	powers	power	NNS
18637	8381	41	which	which	WDT
18637	8381	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8381	43	exercises	exercise	VBZ
18637	8381	44	in	in	IN
18637	8381	45	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	8381	46	such	such	JJ
18637	8381	47	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8381	48	into	into	IN
18637	8381	49	effect	effect	NN
18637	8381	50	.	.	.
18637	8382	1	But	but	CC
18637	8382	2	if	if	IN
18637	8382	3	the	the	DT
18637	8382	4	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8382	5	deals	deal	VBZ
18637	8382	6	with	with	IN
18637	8382	7	a	a	DT
18637	8382	8	subject	subject	NN
18637	8382	9	which	which	WDT
18637	8382	10	falls	fall	VBZ
18637	8382	11	normally	normally	RB
18637	8382	12	to	to	IN
18637	8382	13	the	the	DT
18637	8382	14	States	States	NNPS
18637	8382	15	to	to	TO
18637	8382	16	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	8382	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	8382	18	,	,	,
18637	8382	19	or	or	CC
18637	8382	20	a	a	DT
18637	8382	21	subject	subject	NN
18637	8382	22	which	which	WDT
18637	8382	23	falls	fall	VBZ
18637	8382	24	within	within	IN
18637	8382	25	the	the	DT
18637	8382	26	national	national	JJ
18637	8382	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	8382	28	because	because	IN
18637	8382	29	of	of	IN
18637	8382	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8382	31	international	international	JJ
18637	8382	32	character	character	NN
18637	8382	33	,	,	,
18637	8382	34	then	then	RB
18637	8382	35	recourse	recourse	NNP
18637	8382	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	8382	37	had	have	VBN
18637	8382	38	to	to	IN
18637	8382	39	the	the	DT
18637	8382	40	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8382	41	and	and	CC
18637	8382	42	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8382	43	clause	clause	NN
18637	8382	44	.	.	.
18637	8383	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	8383	2	,	,	,
18637	8383	3	of	of	IN
18637	8383	4	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8383	5	,	,	,
18637	8383	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8383	7	would	would	MD
18637	8383	8	have	have	VB
18637	8383	9	no	no	DT
18637	8383	10	power	power	NN
18637	8383	11	to	to	TO
18637	8383	12	confer	confer	VB
18637	8383	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8383	14	powers	power	NNS
18637	8383	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	8383	16	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8383	17	consuls	consul	NNS
18637	8383	18	in	in	IN
18637	8383	19	the	the	DT
18637	8383	20	United	United	NNP
18637	8383	21	States	States	NNP
18637	8383	22	,	,	,
18637	8383	23	but	but	CC
18637	8383	24	the	the	DT
18637	8383	25	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8383	26	-	-	HYPH
18637	8383	27	power	power	NN
18637	8383	28	can	can	MD
18637	8383	29	do	do	VB
18637	8383	30	this	this	DT
18637	8383	31	and	and	CC
18637	8383	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	8383	33	done	do	VBN
18637	8383	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8383	35	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	8383	36	and	and	CC
18637	8383	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8383	38	has	have	VBZ
18637	8383	39	supplemented	supplement	VBN
18637	8383	40	these	these	DT
18637	8383	41	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8383	42	by	by	IN
18637	8383	43	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	8383	44	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8383	45	.	.	.
18637	8384	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8384	2	194	194	CD
18637	8384	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8384	4	Again	again	RB
18637	8384	5	,	,	,
18637	8384	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8384	7	could	could	MD
18637	8384	8	not	not	RB
18637	8384	9	confer	confer	VB
18637	8384	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8384	11	power	power	NN
18637	8384	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	8384	13	American	american	JJ
18637	8384	14	consuls	consul	NNS
18637	8384	15	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	8384	16	to	to	TO
18637	8384	17	be	be	VB
18637	8384	18	there	there	RB
18637	8384	19	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	8384	20	over	over	IN
18637	8384	21	American	american	JJ
18637	8384	22	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8384	23	,	,	,
18637	8384	24	but	but	CC
18637	8384	25	the	the	DT
18637	8384	26	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8384	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	8384	28	power	power	NN
18637	8384	29	can	can	MD
18637	8384	30	and	and	CC
18637	8384	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	8384	32	,	,	,
18637	8384	33	and	and	CC
18637	8384	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8384	35	has	have	VBZ
18637	8384	36	passed	pass	VBN
18637	8384	37	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8384	38	perfecting	perfect	VBG
18637	8384	39	such	such	JJ
18637	8384	40	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8384	41	and	and	CC
18637	8384	42	such	such	JJ
18637	8384	43	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8384	44	has	have	VBZ
18637	8384	45	been	be	VBN
18637	8384	46	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	8384	47	.	.	.
18637	8385	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8385	2	195	195	CD
18637	8385	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8385	4	Again	again	RB
18637	8385	5	,	,	,
18637	8385	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8385	7	of	of	IN
18637	8385	8	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8385	9	could	could	MD
18637	8385	10	not	not	RB
18637	8385	11	provide	provide	VB
18637	8385	12	for	for	IN
18637	8385	13	the	the	DT
18637	8385	14	extradition	extradition	NN
18637	8385	15	of	of	IN
18637	8385	16	fugitives	fugitive	NNS
18637	8385	17	from	from	IN
18637	8385	18	justice	justice	NN
18637	8385	19	,	,	,
18637	8385	20	but	but	CC
18637	8385	21	the	the	DT
18637	8385	22	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8385	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	8385	24	power	power	NN
18637	8385	25	can	can	MD
18637	8385	26	and	and	CC
18637	8385	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	8385	28	done	do	VBN
18637	8385	29	so	so	RB
18637	8385	30	scores	score	NNS
18637	8385	31	of	of	IN
18637	8385	32	times	time	NNS
18637	8385	33	,	,	,
18637	8385	34	and	and	CC
18637	8385	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8385	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	8385	37	passed	pass	VBN
18637	8385	38	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8385	39	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	8385	40	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8385	41	extradition	extradition	NN
18637	8385	42	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8385	43	into	into	IN
18637	8385	44	effect	effect	NN
18637	8385	45	.	.	.
18637	8386	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8386	2	196	196	CD
18637	8386	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8386	4	Again	again	RB
18637	8386	5	,	,	,
18637	8386	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8386	7	could	could	MD
18637	8386	8	not	not	RB
18637	8386	9	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	8386	10	penalize	penalize	VB
18637	8386	11	private	private	JJ
18637	8386	12	acts	act	NNS
18637	8386	13	of	of	IN
18637	8386	14	violence	violence	NN
18637	8386	15	within	within	IN
18637	8386	16	a	a	DT
18637	8386	17	State	state	NN
18637	8386	18	,	,	,
18637	8386	19	but	but	CC
18637	8386	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8386	21	can	can	MD
18637	8386	22	punish	punish	VB
18637	8386	23	such	such	JJ
18637	8386	24	acts	act	NNS
18637	8386	25	if	if	IN
18637	8386	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8386	27	deprive	deprive	VBP
18637	8386	28	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	8386	29	of	of	IN
18637	8386	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8386	31	rights	right	NNS
18637	8386	32	under	under	IN
18637	8386	33	a	a	DT
18637	8386	34	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8386	35	.	.	.
18637	8387	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8387	2	197	197	CD
18637	8387	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8387	4	Referring	refer	VBG
18637	8387	5	to	to	IN
18637	8387	6	such	such	JJ
18637	8387	7	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8387	8	the	the	DT
18637	8387	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8387	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	8387	11	said	say	VBN
18637	8387	12	:	:	:
18637	8387	13	"	"	``
18637	8387	14	The	the	DT
18637	8387	15	power	power	NN
18637	8387	16	of	of	IN
18637	8387	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8387	18	to	to	TO
18637	8387	19	make	make	VB
18637	8387	20	all	all	DT
18637	8387	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	8387	22	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8387	23	and	and	CC
18637	8387	24	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8387	25	for	for	IN
18637	8387	26	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	8387	27	into	into	IN
18637	8387	28	execution	execution	NN
18637	8387	29	as	as	RB
18637	8387	30	well	well	RB
18637	8387	31	the	the	DT
18637	8387	32	powers	power	NNS
18637	8387	33	enumerated	enumerate	VBD
18637	8387	34	in	in	IN
18637	8387	35	section	section	NN
18637	8387	36	8	8	CD
18637	8387	37	of	of	IN
18637	8387	38	article	article	NN
18637	8387	39	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8387	40	of	of	IN
18637	8387	41	the	the	DT
18637	8387	42	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8387	43	,	,	,
18637	8387	44	as	as	IN
18637	8387	45	all	all	DT
18637	8387	46	others	other	NNS
18637	8387	47	vested	vest	VBD
18637	8387	48	in	in	IN
18637	8387	49	the	the	DT
18637	8387	50	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8387	51	of	of	IN
18637	8387	52	the	the	DT
18637	8387	53	United	United	NNP
18637	8387	54	States	States	NNP
18637	8387	55	,	,	,
18637	8387	56	or	or	CC
18637	8387	57	in	in	IN
18637	8387	58	any	any	DT
18637	8387	59	Department	Department	NNP
18637	8387	60	or	or	CC
18637	8387	61	the	the	DT
18637	8387	62	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8387	63	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8387	64	,	,	,
18637	8387	65	includes	include	VBZ
18637	8387	66	the	the	DT
18637	8387	67	power	power	NN
18637	8387	68	to	to	TO
18637	8387	69	enact	enact	VB
18637	8387	70	such	such	JJ
18637	8387	71	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8387	72	as	as	IN
18637	8387	73	is	be	VBZ
18637	8387	74	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	8387	75	to	to	TO
18637	8387	76	give	give	VB
18637	8387	77	efficacy	efficacy	NN
18637	8387	78	to	to	IN
18637	8387	79	any	any	DT
18637	8387	80	stipulations	stipulation	NNS
18637	8387	81	which	which	WDT
18637	8387	82	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8387	83	is	be	VBZ
18637	8387	84	competent	competent	JJ
18637	8387	85	for	for	IN
18637	8387	86	the	the	DT
18637	8387	87	President	President	NNP
18637	8387	88	by	by	IN
18637	8387	89	and	and	CC
18637	8387	90	with	with	IN
18637	8387	91	the	the	DT
18637	8387	92	advice	advice	NN
18637	8387	93	and	and	CC
18637	8387	94	consent	consent	NN
18637	8387	95	of	of	IN
18637	8387	96	the	the	DT
18637	8387	97	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8387	98	to	to	TO
18637	8387	99	insert	insert	VB
18637	8387	100	in	in	IN
18637	8387	101	a	a	DT
18637	8387	102	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8387	103	with	with	IN
18637	8387	104	a	a	DT
18637	8387	105	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8387	106	power	power	NN
18637	8387	107	.	.	.
18637	8388	1	"	"	``
18637	8388	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8388	3	198	198	CD
18637	8388	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8388	5	In	in	IN
18637	8388	6	a	a	DT
18637	8388	7	word	word	NN
18637	8388	8	,	,	,
18637	8388	9	the	the	DT
18637	8388	10	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8388	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	8388	12	power	power	NN
18637	8388	13	can	can	MD
18637	8388	14	not	not	RB
18637	8388	15	purport	purport	VB
18637	8388	16	to	to	TO
18637	8388	17	amend	amend	VB
18637	8388	18	the	the	DT
18637	8388	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8388	20	by	by	IN
18637	8388	21	adding	add	VBG
18637	8388	22	to	to	IN
18637	8388	23	the	the	DT
18637	8388	24	list	list	NN
18637	8388	25	of	of	IN
18637	8388	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8388	27	's	's	POS
18637	8388	28	enumerated	enumerated	JJ
18637	8388	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	8388	30	,	,	,
18637	8388	31	but	but	CC
18637	8388	32	having	have	VBG
18637	8388	33	acted	act	VBN
18637	8388	34	,	,	,
18637	8388	35	the	the	DT
18637	8388	36	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	8388	37	will	will	MD
18637	8388	38	often	often	RB
18637	8388	39	be	be	VB
18637	8388	40	that	that	IN
18637	8388	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8388	42	has	have	VBZ
18637	8388	43	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8388	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8388	45	with	with	IN
18637	8388	46	an	an	DT
18637	8388	47	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	8388	48	to	to	TO
18637	8388	49	enact	enact	VB
18637	8388	50	measures	measure	NNS
18637	8388	51	which	which	WDT
18637	8388	52	independently	independently	RB
18637	8388	53	of	of	IN
18637	8388	54	a	a	DT
18637	8388	55	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8388	56	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8388	57	could	could	MD
18637	8388	58	not	not	RB
18637	8388	59	pass	pass	VB
18637	8388	60	;	;	:
18637	8388	61	and	and	CC
18637	8388	62	the	the	DT
18637	8388	63	only	only	JJ
18637	8388	64	question	question	NN
18637	8388	65	that	that	WDT
18637	8388	66	can	can	MD
18637	8388	67	be	be	VB
18637	8388	68	raised	raise	VBN
18637	8388	69	as	as	IN
18637	8388	70	to	to	IN
18637	8388	71	such	such	JJ
18637	8388	72	measures	measure	NNS
18637	8388	73	will	will	MD
18637	8388	74	be	be	VB
18637	8388	75	whether	whether	IN
18637	8388	76	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8388	77	are	be	VBP
18637	8388	78	"	"	``
18637	8388	79	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8388	80	and	and	CC
18637	8388	81	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8388	82	"	"	''
18637	8388	83	measures	measure	NNS
18637	8388	84	for	for	IN
18637	8388	85	the	the	DT
18637	8388	86	carrying	carrying	NN
18637	8388	87	of	of	IN
18637	8388	88	the	the	DT
18637	8388	89	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8388	90	in	in	IN
18637	8388	91	question	question	NN
18637	8388	92	into	into	IN
18637	8388	93	operation	operation	NN
18637	8388	94	.	.	.
18637	8389	1	The	the	DT
18637	8389	2	matter	matter	NN
18637	8389	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8389	4	further	further	RB
18637	8389	5	treated	treat	VBN
18637	8389	6	under	under	IN
18637	8389	7	the	the	DT
18637	8389	8	next	next	JJ
18637	8389	9	heading	heading	NN
18637	8389	10	.	.	.
18637	8390	1	CONSTITUTIONAL	constitutional	JJ
18637	8390	2	LIMITS	limit	NNS
18637	8390	3	OF	of	IN
18637	8390	4	THE	the	DT
18637	8390	5	TREATY	treaty	NN
18637	8390	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	8390	7	MAKING	making	NN
18637	8390	8	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	8390	9	;	;	:
18637	8390	10	MISSOURI	MISSOURI	NNP
18637	8390	11	_	_	NNP
18637	8390	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	8390	13	_	_	NNP
18637	8390	14	HOLLAND	HOLLAND	NNP
18637	8390	15	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8390	16	system	system	NN
18637	8390	17	being	be	VBG
18637	8390	18	theoretically	theoretically	RB
18637	8390	19	opposed	opposed	JJ
18637	8390	20	to	to	IN
18637	8390	21	the	the	DT
18637	8390	22	lodgement	lodgement	NN
18637	8390	23	anywhere	anywhere	RB
18637	8390	24	in	in	IN
18637	8390	25	government	government	NN
18637	8390	26	of	of	IN
18637	8390	27	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	8390	28	power	power	NN
18637	8390	29	,	,	,
18637	8390	30	the	the	DT
18637	8390	31	question	question	NN
18637	8390	32	of	of	IN
18637	8390	33	the	the	DT
18637	8390	34	scope	scope	NN
18637	8390	35	of	of	IN
18637	8390	36	this	this	DT
18637	8390	37	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	8390	38	power	power	NN
18637	8390	39	has	have	VBZ
18637	8390	40	often	often	RB
18637	8390	41	been	be	VBN
18637	8390	42	pressed	press	VBN
18637	8390	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	8390	44	the	the	DT
18637	8390	45	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8390	46	,	,	,
18637	8390	47	which	which	WDT
18637	8390	48	has	have	VBZ
18637	8390	49	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	8390	50	used	use	VBN
18637	8390	51	language	language	NN
18637	8390	52	vaguely	vaguely	RB
18637	8390	53	suggestive	suggestive	JJ
18637	8390	54	of	of	IN
18637	8390	55	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	8390	56	,	,	,
18637	8390	57	as	as	IN
18637	8390	58	in	in	IN
18637	8390	59	the	the	DT
18637	8390	60	following	follow	VBG
18637	8390	61	passage	passage	NN
18637	8390	62	from	from	IN
18637	8390	63	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8390	64	Field	Field	NNP
18637	8390	65	's	's	POS
18637	8390	66	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8390	67	for	for	IN
18637	8390	68	the	the	DT
18637	8390	69	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8390	70	in	in	IN
18637	8390	71	Geofroy	Geofroy	NNP
18637	8390	72	_	_	NNP
18637	8390	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	8390	74	_	_	NNP
18637	8390	75	Riggs,[199	Riggs,[199	NNP
18637	8390	76	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8390	77	which	which	WDT
18637	8390	78	was	be	VBD
18637	8390	79	decided	decide	VBN
18637	8390	80	in	in	IN
18637	8390	81	1890	1890	CD
18637	8390	82	:	:	:
18637	8390	83	"	"	``
18637	8390	84	The	the	DT
18637	8390	85	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8390	86	power	power	NN
18637	8390	87	,	,	,
18637	8390	88	as	as	IN
18637	8390	89	expressed	express	VBN
18637	8390	90	in	in	IN
18637	8390	91	the	the	DT
18637	8390	92	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8390	93	,	,	,
18637	8390	94	is	be	VBZ
18637	8390	95	in	in	IN
18637	8390	96	terms	term	NNS
18637	8390	97	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	8390	98	except	except	IN
18637	8390	99	by	by	IN
18637	8390	100	those	those	DT
18637	8390	101	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	8390	102	which	which	WDT
18637	8390	103	are	be	VBP
18637	8390	104	found	find	VBN
18637	8390	105	in	in	IN
18637	8390	106	that	that	DT
18637	8390	107	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	8390	108	against	against	IN
18637	8390	109	the	the	DT
18637	8390	110	action	action	NN
18637	8390	111	of	of	IN
18637	8390	112	the	the	DT
18637	8390	113	government	government	NN
18637	8390	114	or	or	CC
18637	8390	115	of	of	IN
18637	8390	116	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8390	117	departments	department	NNS
18637	8390	118	,	,	,
18637	8390	119	and	and	CC
18637	8390	120	those	those	DT
18637	8390	121	arising	arise	VBG
18637	8390	122	from	from	IN
18637	8390	123	the	the	DT
18637	8390	124	nature	nature	NN
18637	8390	125	of	of	IN
18637	8390	126	the	the	DT
18637	8390	127	government	government	NN
18637	8390	128	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8390	129	and	and	CC
18637	8390	130	of	of	IN
18637	8390	131	that	that	DT
18637	8390	132	of	of	IN
18637	8390	133	the	the	DT
18637	8390	134	States	States	NNPS
18637	8390	135	.	.	.
18637	8391	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8391	2	would	would	MD
18637	8391	3	not	not	RB
18637	8391	4	be	be	VB
18637	8391	5	contended	contend	VBN
18637	8391	6	that	that	IN
18637	8391	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8391	8	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	8391	9	so	so	RB
18637	8391	10	far	far	RB
18637	8391	11	as	as	IN
18637	8391	12	to	to	TO
18637	8391	13	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	8391	14	what	what	WP
18637	8391	15	the	the	DT
18637	8391	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8391	17	forbids	forbid	NNS
18637	8391	18	,	,	,
18637	8391	19	or	or	CC
18637	8391	20	a	a	DT
18637	8391	21	change	change	NN
18637	8391	22	in	in	IN
18637	8391	23	the	the	DT
18637	8391	24	character	character	NN
18637	8391	25	of	of	IN
18637	8391	26	the	the	DT
18637	8391	27	government	government	NN
18637	8391	28	or	or	CC
18637	8391	29	in	in	IN
18637	8391	30	that	that	DT
18637	8391	31	of	of	IN
18637	8391	32	one	one	CD
18637	8391	33	of	of	IN
18637	8391	34	the	the	DT
18637	8391	35	States	States	NNPS
18637	8391	36	,	,	,
18637	8391	37	or	or	CC
18637	8391	38	a	a	DT
18637	8391	39	cession	cession	NN
18637	8391	40	of	of	IN
18637	8391	41	any	any	DT
18637	8391	42	portion	portion	NN
18637	8391	43	of	of	IN
18637	8391	44	the	the	DT
18637	8391	45	territory	territory	NN
18637	8391	46	of	of	IN
18637	8391	47	the	the	DT
18637	8391	48	latter	latter	JJ
18637	8391	49	,	,	,
18637	8391	50	without	without	IN
18637	8391	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8391	52	consent	consent	NN
18637	8391	53	.	.	.
18637	8392	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8392	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8392	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8392	4	But	but	CC
18637	8392	5	with	with	IN
18637	8392	6	these	these	DT
18637	8392	7	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	8392	8	,	,	,
18637	8392	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8392	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	8392	11	not	not	RB
18637	8392	12	perceived	perceive	VBN
18637	8392	13	that	that	IN
18637	8392	14	there	there	EX
18637	8392	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	8392	16	any	any	DT
18637	8392	17	limit	limit	NN
18637	8392	18	to	to	IN
18637	8392	19	the	the	DT
18637	8392	20	questions	question	NNS
18637	8392	21	which	which	WDT
18637	8392	22	can	can	MD
18637	8392	23	be	be	VB
18637	8392	24	adjusted	adjust	VBN
18637	8392	25	touching	touch	VBG
18637	8392	26	any	any	DT
18637	8392	27	matter	matter	NN
18637	8392	28	which	which	WDT
18637	8392	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	8392	30	properly	properly	RB
18637	8392	31	the	the	DT
18637	8392	32	subject	subject	NN
18637	8392	33	of	of	IN
18637	8392	34	negotiation	negotiation	NN
18637	8392	35	with	with	IN
18637	8392	36	a	a	DT
18637	8392	37	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8392	38	country	country	NN
18637	8392	39	.	.	.
18637	8393	1	"	"	``
18637	8393	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8393	3	200	200	CD
18637	8393	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8393	5	The	the	DT
18637	8393	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	8393	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	8393	8	none	none	NN
18637	8393	9	the	the	DT
18637	8393	10	less	less	JJR
18637	8393	11	,	,	,
18637	8393	12	that	that	IN
18637	8393	13	no	no	DT
18637	8393	14	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8393	15	of	of	IN
18637	8393	16	the	the	DT
18637	8393	17	United	United	NNP
18637	8393	18	States	States	NNP
18637	8393	19	nor	nor	CC
18637	8393	20	any	any	DT
18637	8393	21	provision	provision	NN
18637	8393	22	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8393	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	8393	24	ever	ever	RB
18637	8393	25	been	be	VBN
18637	8393	26	found	find	VBN
18637	8393	27	by	by	IN
18637	8393	28	the	the	DT
18637	8393	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8393	30	to	to	TO
18637	8393	31	be	be	VB
18637	8393	32	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	8393	33	.	.	.
18637	8394	1	The	the	DT
18637	8394	2	most	most	RBS
18637	8394	3	persistently	persistently	RB
18637	8394	4	urged	urge	VBD
18637	8394	5	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	8394	6	in	in	IN
18637	8394	7	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	8394	8	of	of	IN
18637	8394	9	the	the	DT
18637	8394	10	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8394	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	8394	12	making	make	VBG
18637	8394	13	power	power	NN
18637	8394	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	8394	15	been	be	VBN
18637	8394	16	that	that	IN
18637	8394	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8394	18	must	must	MD
18637	8394	19	not	not	RB
18637	8394	20	invade	invade	VB
18637	8394	21	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8394	22	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	8394	23	powers	power	NNS
18637	8394	24	of	of	IN
18637	8394	25	the	the	DT
18637	8394	26	States	States	NNP
18637	8394	27	.	.	.
18637	8395	1	In	in	IN
18637	8395	2	view	view	NN
18637	8395	3	of	of	IN
18637	8395	4	the	the	DT
18637	8395	5	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	8395	6	language	language	NN
18637	8395	7	of	of	IN
18637	8395	8	the	the	DT
18637	8395	9	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	8395	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	8395	11	,	,	,
18637	8395	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8395	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	8395	14	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	8395	15	surprising	surprising	JJ
18637	8395	16	that	that	IN
18637	8395	17	this	this	DT
18637	8395	18	argument	argument	NN
18637	8395	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	8395	20	not	not	RB
18637	8395	21	prevailed	prevail	VBN
18637	8395	22	.	.	.
18637	8396	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8396	2	201	201	CD
18637	8396	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8396	4	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	8396	5	,	,	,
18637	8396	6	the	the	DT
18637	8396	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8396	8	was	be	VBD
18637	8396	9	forced	force	VBN
18637	8396	10	to	to	TO
18637	8396	11	answer	answer	VB
18637	8396	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8396	13	as	as	RB
18637	8396	14	recently	recently	RB
18637	8396	15	as	as	IN
18637	8396	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	8396	17	.	.	.
18637	8397	1	This	this	DT
18637	8397	2	was	be	VBD
18637	8397	3	in	in	IN
18637	8397	4	the	the	DT
18637	8397	5	case	case	NN
18637	8397	6	of	of	IN
18637	8397	7	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	8397	8	_	_	NNP
18637	8397	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	8397	10	_	_	NNP
18637	8397	11	Holland,[202	Holland,[202	NNP
18637	8397	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8397	13	in	in	IN
18637	8397	14	which	which	WDT
18637	8397	15	the	the	DT
18637	8397	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8397	17	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	8397	18	a	a	DT
18637	8397	19	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8397	20	between	between	IN
18637	8397	21	the	the	DT
18637	8397	22	United	United	NNP
18637	8397	23	States	States	NNP
18637	8397	24	and	and	CC
18637	8397	25	Great	Great	NNP
18637	8397	26	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	8397	27	providing	provide	VBG
18637	8397	28	for	for	IN
18637	8397	29	the	the	DT
18637	8397	30	reciprocal	reciprocal	JJ
18637	8397	31	protection	protection	NN
18637	8397	32	of	of	IN
18637	8397	33	migratory	migratory	NN
18637	8397	34	birds	bird	NNS
18637	8397	35	which	which	WDT
18637	8397	36	make	make	VBP
18637	8397	37	seasonal	seasonal	JJ
18637	8397	38	flights	flight	NNS
18637	8397	39	from	from	IN
18637	8397	40	Canada	Canada	NNP
18637	8397	41	into	into	IN
18637	8397	42	the	the	DT
18637	8397	43	United	United	NNP
18637	8397	44	States	States	NNP
18637	8397	45	and	and	CC
18637	8397	46	vice	vice	NN
18637	8397	47	versa	versa	NN
18637	8397	48	,	,	,
18637	8397	49	and	and	CC
18637	8397	50	an	an	DT
18637	8397	51	act	act	NN
18637	8397	52	of	of	IN
18637	8397	53	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8397	54	passed	pass	VBD
18637	8397	55	in	in	IN
18637	8397	56	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	8397	57	thereof	thereof	IN
18637	8397	58	which	which	WDT
18637	8397	59	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	8397	60	the	the	DT
18637	8397	61	Department	Department	NNP
18637	8397	62	of	of	IN
18637	8397	63	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	8397	64	to	to	TO
18637	8397	65	draw	draw	VB
18637	8397	66	up	up	RP
18637	8397	67	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	8397	68	to	to	TO
18637	8397	69	govern	govern	VB
18637	8397	70	the	the	DT
18637	8397	71	hunting	hunting	NN
18637	8397	72	of	of	IN
18637	8397	73	such	such	JJ
18637	8397	74	birds	bird	NNS
18637	8397	75	,	,	,
18637	8397	76	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8397	77	to	to	IN
18637	8397	78	the	the	DT
18637	8397	79	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	8397	80	specified	specify	VBN
18637	8397	81	by	by	IN
18637	8397	82	the	the	DT
18637	8397	83	act	act	NN
18637	8397	84	.	.	.
18637	8398	1	To	to	IN
18637	8398	2	the	the	DT
18637	8398	3	objection	objection	NN
18637	8398	4	that	that	IN
18637	8398	5	the	the	DT
18637	8398	6	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8398	7	and	and	CC
18637	8398	8	implementing	implement	VBG
18637	8398	9	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8398	10	invaded	invade	VBD
18637	8398	11	the	the	DT
18637	8398	12	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	8398	13	police	police	NN
18637	8398	14	power	power	NN
18637	8398	15	of	of	IN
18637	8398	16	the	the	DT
18637	8398	17	State	State	NNP
18637	8398	18	in	in	IN
18637	8398	19	the	the	DT
18637	8398	20	protection	protection	NN
18637	8398	21	of	of	IN
18637	8398	22	game	game	NN
18637	8398	23	within	within	IN
18637	8398	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8398	25	borders	border	NNS
18637	8398	26	,	,	,
18637	8398	27	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8398	28	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	8398	29	,	,	,
18637	8398	30	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8398	31	for	for	IN
18637	8398	32	the	the	DT
18637	8398	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8398	34	,	,	,
18637	8398	35	answered	answer	VBD
18637	8398	36	:	:	:
18637	8398	37	"	"	``
18637	8398	38	Acts	act	NNS
18637	8398	39	of	of	IN
18637	8398	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8398	41	are	be	VBP
18637	8398	42	the	the	DT
18637	8398	43	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	8398	44	law	law	NNP
18637	8398	45	of	of	IN
18637	8398	46	the	the	DT
18637	8398	47	land	land	NN
18637	8398	48	only	only	RB
18637	8398	49	when	when	WRB
18637	8398	50	made	make	VBN
18637	8398	51	in	in	IN
18637	8398	52	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	8398	53	of	of	IN
18637	8398	54	the	the	DT
18637	8398	55	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8398	56	,	,	,
18637	8398	57	while	while	IN
18637	8398	58	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8398	59	are	be	VBP
18637	8398	60	declared	declare	VBN
18637	8398	61	to	to	TO
18637	8398	62	be	be	VB
18637	8398	63	so	so	RB
18637	8398	64	when	when	WRB
18637	8398	65	made	make	VBN
18637	8398	66	under	under	IN
18637	8398	67	the	the	DT
18637	8398	68	authority	authority	NN
18637	8398	69	of	of	IN
18637	8398	70	the	the	DT
18637	8398	71	United	United	NNP
18637	8398	72	States	States	NNP
18637	8398	73	.	.	.
18637	8399	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8399	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8399	3	open	open	JJ
18637	8399	4	to	to	TO
18637	8399	5	question	question	VB
18637	8399	6	whether	whether	IN
18637	8399	7	the	the	DT
18637	8399	8	authority	authority	NN
18637	8399	9	of	of	IN
18637	8399	10	the	the	DT
18637	8399	11	United	United	NNP
18637	8399	12	States	States	NNP
18637	8399	13	means	mean	VBZ
18637	8399	14	more	more	JJR
18637	8399	15	than	than	IN
18637	8399	16	the	the	DT
18637	8399	17	formal	formal	JJ
18637	8399	18	acts	act	NNS
18637	8399	19	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	8399	20	to	to	TO
18637	8399	21	make	make	VB
18637	8399	22	the	the	DT
18637	8399	23	convention	convention	NN
18637	8399	24	.	.	.
18637	8400	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8400	2	do	do	VBP
18637	8400	3	not	not	RB
18637	8400	4	mean	mean	VB
18637	8400	5	to	to	TO
18637	8400	6	imply	imply	VB
18637	8400	7	that	that	IN
18637	8400	8	there	there	EX
18637	8400	9	are	be	VBP
18637	8400	10	no	no	DT
18637	8400	11	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	8400	12	to	to	IN
18637	8400	13	the	the	DT
18637	8400	14	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8400	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	8400	16	making	make	VBG
18637	8400	17	power	power	NN
18637	8400	18	;	;	:
18637	8400	19	but	but	CC
18637	8400	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8400	21	must	must	MD
18637	8400	22	be	be	VB
18637	8400	23	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	8400	24	in	in	IN
18637	8400	25	a	a	DT
18637	8400	26	different	different	JJ
18637	8400	27	way	way	NN
18637	8400	28	.	.	.
18637	8401	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8401	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8401	3	obvious	obvious	JJ
18637	8401	4	that	that	IN
18637	8401	5	there	there	EX
18637	8401	6	may	may	MD
18637	8401	7	be	be	VB
18637	8401	8	matters	matter	NNS
18637	8401	9	of	of	IN
18637	8401	10	the	the	DT
18637	8401	11	sharpest	sharp	JJS
18637	8401	12	exigency	exigency	NN
18637	8401	13	for	for	IN
18637	8401	14	the	the	DT
18637	8401	15	national	national	JJ
18637	8401	16	well	well	NN
18637	8401	17	being	be	VBG
18637	8401	18	that	that	IN
18637	8401	19	an	an	DT
18637	8401	20	act	act	NN
18637	8401	21	of	of	IN
18637	8401	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8401	23	could	could	MD
18637	8401	24	not	not	RB
18637	8401	25	deal	deal	VB
18637	8401	26	with	with	IN
18637	8401	27	but	but	CC
18637	8401	28	that	that	IN
18637	8401	29	a	a	DT
18637	8401	30	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8401	31	followed	follow	VBN
18637	8401	32	by	by	IN
18637	8401	33	such	such	PDT
18637	8401	34	an	an	DT
18637	8401	35	act	act	NN
18637	8401	36	could	could	MD
18637	8401	37	,	,	,
18637	8401	38	and	and	CC
18637	8401	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8401	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	8401	41	not	not	RB
18637	8401	42	lightly	lightly	RB
18637	8401	43	to	to	TO
18637	8401	44	be	be	VB
18637	8401	45	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	8401	46	that	that	IN
18637	8401	47	,	,	,
18637	8401	48	in	in	IN
18637	8401	49	matters	matter	NNS
18637	8401	50	requiring	require	VBG
18637	8401	51	national	national	JJ
18637	8401	52	action	action	NN
18637	8401	53	,	,	,
18637	8401	54	'	'	''
18637	8401	55	a	a	DT
18637	8401	56	power	power	NN
18637	8401	57	which	which	WDT
18637	8401	58	must	must	MD
18637	8401	59	belong	belong	VB
18637	8401	60	to	to	IN
18637	8401	61	and	and	CC
18637	8401	62	somewhere	somewhere	RB
18637	8401	63	reside	reside	VB
18637	8401	64	in	in	IN
18637	8401	65	every	every	DT
18637	8401	66	civilized	civilized	JJ
18637	8401	67	government	government	NN
18637	8401	68	'	'	''
18637	8401	69	is	be	VBZ
18637	8401	70	not	not	RB
18637	8401	71	to	to	TO
18637	8401	72	be	be	VB
18637	8401	73	found	find	VBN
18637	8401	74	.	.	.
18637	8402	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8402	2	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
18637	8402	3	_	_	NNP
18637	8402	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	8402	5	_	_	NNP
18637	8402	6	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
18637	8402	7	,	,	,
18637	8402	8	188	188	CD
18637	8402	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	8402	10	14	14	CD
18637	8402	11	,	,	,
18637	8402	12	33	33	CD
18637	8402	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8402	14	1903	1903	CD
18637	8402	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8402	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8402	17	.	.	.
18637	8403	1	What	what	WP
18637	8403	2	was	be	VBD
18637	8403	3	said	say	VBN
18637	8403	4	in	in	IN
18637	8403	5	that	that	DT
18637	8403	6	case	case	NN
18637	8403	7	with	with	IN
18637	8403	8	regard	regard	NN
18637	8403	9	to	to	IN
18637	8403	10	the	the	DT
18637	8403	11	powers	power	NNS
18637	8403	12	of	of	IN
18637	8403	13	the	the	DT
18637	8403	14	States	States	NNP
18637	8403	15	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	8403	16	with	with	IN
18637	8403	17	equal	equal	JJ
18637	8403	18	force	force	NN
18637	8403	19	to	to	IN
18637	8403	20	the	the	DT
18637	8403	21	powers	power	NNS
18637	8403	22	of	of	IN
18637	8403	23	the	the	DT
18637	8403	24	nation	nation	NN
18637	8403	25	in	in	IN
18637	8403	26	cases	case	NNS
18637	8403	27	where	where	WRB
18637	8403	28	the	the	DT
18637	8403	29	States	States	NNPS
18637	8403	30	individually	individually	RB
18637	8403	31	are	be	VBP
18637	8403	32	incompetent	incompetent	JJ
18637	8403	33	to	to	TO
18637	8403	34	act	act	VB
18637	8403	35	.	.	.
18637	8404	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8404	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8404	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8404	4	The	the	DT
18637	8404	5	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8404	6	in	in	IN
18637	8404	7	question	question	NN
18637	8404	8	does	do	VBZ
18637	8404	9	not	not	RB
18637	8404	10	contravene	contravene	VB
18637	8404	11	any	any	DT
18637	8404	12	prohibitory	prohibitory	JJ
18637	8404	13	words	word	NNS
18637	8404	14	to	to	TO
18637	8404	15	be	be	VB
18637	8404	16	found	find	VBN
18637	8404	17	in	in	IN
18637	8404	18	the	the	DT
18637	8404	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8404	20	.	.	.
18637	8405	1	The	the	DT
18637	8405	2	only	only	JJ
18637	8405	3	question	question	NN
18637	8405	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	8405	5	whether	whether	IN
18637	8405	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8405	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	8405	8	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	8405	9	by	by	IN
18637	8405	10	some	some	DT
18637	8405	11	invisible	invisible	JJ
18637	8405	12	radiation	radiation	NN
18637	8405	13	from	from	IN
18637	8405	14	the	the	DT
18637	8405	15	general	general	JJ
18637	8405	16	terms	term	NNS
18637	8405	17	of	of	IN
18637	8405	18	the	the	DT
18637	8405	19	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	8405	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	8405	21	.	.	.
18637	8406	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8406	2	must	must	MD
18637	8406	3	consider	consider	VB
18637	8406	4	what	what	WP
18637	8406	5	this	this	DT
18637	8406	6	country	country	NN
18637	8406	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	8406	8	become	become	VBN
18637	8406	9	in	in	IN
18637	8406	10	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	8406	11	what	what	WP
18637	8406	12	that	that	IN
18637	8406	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	8406	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	8406	15	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	8406	16	.	.	.
18637	8407	1	"	"	``
18637	8407	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8407	3	203	203	CD
18637	8407	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8407	5	And	and	CC
18637	8407	6	again	again	RB
18637	8407	7	:	:	:
18637	8407	8	"	"	``
18637	8407	9	Here	here	RB
18637	8407	10	a	a	DT
18637	8407	11	national	national	JJ
18637	8407	12	interest	interest	NN
18637	8407	13	of	of	IN
18637	8407	14	very	very	RB
18637	8407	15	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	8407	16	the	the	DT
18637	8407	17	first	first	JJ
18637	8407	18	magnitude	magnitude	NN
18637	8407	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	8407	20	involved	involve	VBN
18637	8407	21	.	.	.
18637	8408	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8408	2	can	can	MD
18637	8408	3	be	be	VB
18637	8408	4	protected	protect	VBN
18637	8408	5	only	only	RB
18637	8408	6	by	by	IN
18637	8408	7	national	national	JJ
18637	8408	8	action	action	NN
18637	8408	9	in	in	IN
18637	8408	10	concert	concert	NN
18637	8408	11	with	with	IN
18637	8408	12	that	that	DT
18637	8408	13	of	of	IN
18637	8408	14	another	another	DT
18637	8408	15	power	power	NN
18637	8408	16	.	.	.
18637	8409	1	The	the	DT
18637	8409	2	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8409	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	8409	4	matter	matter	NN
18637	8409	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	8409	6	only	only	RB
18637	8409	7	transitorily	transitorily	RB
18637	8409	8	within	within	IN
18637	8409	9	the	the	DT
18637	8409	10	State	State	NNP
18637	8409	11	and	and	CC
18637	8409	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	8409	13	no	no	DT
18637	8409	14	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	8409	15	habitat	habitat	NN
18637	8409	16	therein	therein	RB
18637	8409	17	.	.	.
18637	8410	1	But	but	CC
18637	8410	2	for	for	IN
18637	8410	3	the	the	DT
18637	8410	4	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8410	5	and	and	CC
18637	8410	6	the	the	DT
18637	8410	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	8410	8	there	there	RB
18637	8410	9	soon	soon	RB
18637	8410	10	might	may	MD
18637	8410	11	be	be	VB
18637	8410	12	no	no	DT
18637	8410	13	birds	bird	NNS
18637	8410	14	for	for	IN
18637	8410	15	any	any	DT
18637	8410	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	8410	17	to	to	TO
18637	8410	18	deal	deal	VB
18637	8410	19	with	with	IN
18637	8410	20	.	.	.
18637	8411	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8411	2	see	see	VBP
18637	8411	3	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	8411	4	in	in	IN
18637	8411	5	the	the	DT
18637	8411	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8411	7	that	that	WDT
18637	8411	8	compels	compel	VBZ
18637	8411	9	the	the	DT
18637	8411	10	Government	government	NN
18637	8411	11	to	to	TO
18637	8411	12	sit	sit	VB
18637	8411	13	by	by	IN
18637	8411	14	while	while	IN
18637	8411	15	a	a	DT
18637	8411	16	food	food	NN
18637	8411	17	supply	supply	NN
18637	8411	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	8411	19	cut	cut	VBN
18637	8411	20	off	off	RP
18637	8411	21	and	and	CC
18637	8411	22	the	the	DT
18637	8411	23	protectors	protector	NNS
18637	8411	24	of	of	IN
18637	8411	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8411	26	forests	forest	NNS
18637	8411	27	and	and	CC
18637	8411	28	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8411	29	crops	crop	NNS
18637	8411	30	are	be	VBP
18637	8411	31	destroyed	destroy	VBN
18637	8411	32	.	.	.
18637	8412	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8412	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8412	3	not	not	RB
18637	8412	4	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	8412	5	to	to	TO
18637	8412	6	rely	rely	VB
18637	8412	7	upon	upon	IN
18637	8412	8	the	the	DT
18637	8412	9	States	States	NNP
18637	8412	10	.	.	.
18637	8413	1	The	the	DT
18637	8413	2	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	8413	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8413	4	vain	vain	JJ
18637	8413	5	,	,	,
18637	8413	6	and	and	CC
18637	8413	7	were	be	VBD
18637	8413	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8413	9	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	8413	10	,	,	,
18637	8413	11	the	the	DT
18637	8413	12	question	question	NN
18637	8413	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	8413	14	whether	whether	IN
18637	8413	15	the	the	DT
18637	8413	16	United	United	NNP
18637	8413	17	States	States	NNP
18637	8413	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	8413	19	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	8413	20	to	to	TO
18637	8413	21	act	act	VB
18637	8413	22	.	.	.
18637	8414	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8414	2	are	be	VBP
18637	8414	3	of	of	IN
18637	8414	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8414	5	that	that	IN
18637	8414	6	the	the	DT
18637	8414	7	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8414	8	and	and	CC
18637	8414	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	8414	10	must	must	MD
18637	8414	11	be	be	VB
18637	8414	12	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	8414	13	.	.	.
18637	8415	1	"	"	``
18637	8415	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8415	3	204	204	CD
18637	8415	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8415	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8415	6	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	8415	7	's	's	POS
18637	8415	8	later	later	JJ
18637	8415	9	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	8415	10	in	in	IN
18637	8415	11	the	the	DT
18637	8415	12	Curtiss	Curtiss	NNP
18637	8415	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	8415	14	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	8415	15	case[205	case[205	,
18637	8415	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8415	17	that	that	IN
18637	8415	18	the	the	DT
18637	8415	19	powers	power	NNS
18637	8415	20	"	"	''
18637	8415	21	to	to	TO
18637	8415	22	declare	declare	VB
18637	8415	23	and	and	CC
18637	8415	24	wage	wage	VB
18637	8415	25	war	war	NN
18637	8415	26	,	,	,
18637	8415	27	to	to	TO
18637	8415	28	conclude	conclude	VB
18637	8415	29	peace	peace	NN
18637	8415	30	,	,	,
18637	8415	31	to	to	TO
18637	8415	32	make	make	VB
18637	8415	33	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8415	34	,	,	,
18637	8415	35	"	"	''
18637	8415	36	etc	etc	FW
18637	8415	37	.	.	.
18637	8415	38	,	,	,
18637	8415	39	belong	belong	VBP
18637	8415	40	to	to	IN
18637	8415	41	"	"	``
18637	8415	42	the	the	DT
18637	8415	43	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8415	44	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8415	45	as	as	IN
18637	8415	46	the	the	DT
18637	8415	47	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8415	48	concomitants	concomitant	NNS
18637	8415	49	of	of	IN
18637	8415	50	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	8415	51	"	"	''
18637	8415	52	leaves	leave	NNS
18637	8415	53	even	even	RB
18637	8415	54	less	less	JJR
18637	8415	55	room	room	NN
18637	8415	56	for	for	IN
18637	8415	57	the	the	DT
18637	8415	58	notion	notion	NN
18637	8415	59	of	of	IN
18637	8415	60	a	a	DT
18637	8415	61	limited	limited	JJ
18637	8415	62	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8415	63	-	-	HYPH
18637	8415	64	making	make	VBG
18637	8415	65	power	power	NN
18637	8415	66	,	,	,
18637	8415	67	as	as	IN
18637	8415	68	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	8415	69	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	8415	70	from	from	IN
18637	8415	71	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8415	72	further	further	JJ
18637	8415	73	statement	statement	NN
18637	8415	74	that	that	IN
18637	8415	75	"	"	``
18637	8415	76	as	as	IN
18637	8415	77	a	a	DT
18637	8415	78	member	member	NN
18637	8415	79	of	of	IN
18637	8415	80	the	the	DT
18637	8415	81	family	family	NN
18637	8415	82	of	of	IN
18637	8415	83	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8415	84	,	,	,
18637	8415	85	the	the	DT
18637	8415	86	right	right	NN
18637	8415	87	and	and	CC
18637	8415	88	power	power	NN
18637	8415	89	of	of	IN
18637	8415	90	the	the	DT
18637	8415	91	United	United	NNP
18637	8415	92	States	States	NNP
18637	8415	93	*	*	NFP
18637	8415	94	*	*	NFP
18637	8415	95	*	*	NFP
18637	8415	96	are	be	VBP
18637	8415	97	equal	equal	JJ
18637	8415	98	to	to	IN
18637	8415	99	the	the	DT
18637	8415	100	right	right	NN
18637	8415	101	and	and	CC
18637	8415	102	power	power	NN
18637	8415	103	of	of	IN
18637	8415	104	the	the	DT
18637	8415	105	other	other	JJ
18637	8415	106	members	member	NNS
18637	8415	107	of	of	IN
18637	8415	108	the	the	DT
18637	8415	109	international	international	JJ
18637	8415	110	family	family	NN
18637	8415	111	.	.	.
18637	8416	1	"	"	``
18637	8416	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8416	3	206	206	CD
18637	8416	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8416	5	No	no	RB
18637	8416	6	doubt	doubt	RB
18637	8416	7	there	there	EX
18637	8416	8	are	be	VBP
18637	8416	9	specific	specific	JJ
18637	8416	10	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	8416	11	in	in	IN
18637	8416	12	the	the	DT
18637	8416	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8416	14	in	in	IN
18637	8416	15	favor	favor	NN
18637	8416	16	of	of	IN
18637	8416	17	private	private	JJ
18637	8416	18	rights	right	NNS
18637	8416	19	which	which	WDT
18637	8416	20	"	"	``
18637	8416	21	go	go	VBP
18637	8416	22	to	to	IN
18637	8416	23	the	the	DT
18637	8416	24	roots	root	NNS
18637	8416	25	"	"	''
18637	8416	26	of	of	IN
18637	8416	27	all	all	DT
18637	8416	28	power	power	NN
18637	8416	29	.	.	.
18637	8417	1	But	but	CC
18637	8417	2	these	these	DT
18637	8417	3	do	do	VBP
18637	8417	4	not	not	RB
18637	8417	5	include	include	VB
18637	8417	6	the	the	DT
18637	8417	7	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	8417	8	powers	power	NNS
18637	8417	9	of	of	IN
18637	8417	10	the	the	DT
18637	8417	11	States	States	NNPS
18637	8417	12	;	;	:
18637	8417	13	nor	nor	CC
18637	8417	14	do	do	VBP
18637	8417	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8417	16	appear	appear	VB
18637	8417	17	to	to	TO
18637	8417	18	limit	limit	VB
18637	8417	19	the	the	DT
18637	8417	20	National	National	NNP
18637	8417	21	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8417	22	in	in	IN
18637	8417	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8417	24	choice	choice	NN
18637	8417	25	of	of	IN
18637	8417	26	matters	matter	NNS
18637	8417	27	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	8417	28	which	which	WDT
18637	8417	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8417	30	may	may	MD
18637	8417	31	treat	treat	VB
18637	8417	32	with	with	IN
18637	8417	33	other	other	JJ
18637	8417	34	governments	government	NNS
18637	8417	35	.	.	.
18637	8418	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8418	2	207	207	CD
18637	8418	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8418	4	INDIAN	INDIAN	NNP
18637	8418	5	TREATIES	treaty	NNS
18637	8418	6	In	in	IN
18637	8418	7	the	the	DT
18637	8418	8	early	early	JJ
18637	8418	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	8418	10	of	of	IN
18637	8418	11	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	8418	12	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	8418	13	_	_	NNP
18637	8418	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	8418	15	_	_	NNP
18637	8418	16	Georgia[208	Georgia[208	NNP
18637	8418	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8418	18	and	and	CC
18637	8418	19	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
18637	8418	20	_	_	NNP
18637	8418	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	8418	22	_	_	NNP
18637	8418	23	Georgia[209	Georgia[209	NNP
18637	8418	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8418	25	the	the	DT
18637	8418	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8418	27	,	,	,
18637	8418	28	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8418	29	by	by	IN
18637	8418	30	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8418	31	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8418	32	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	8418	33	,	,	,
18637	8418	34	held	hold	VBD
18637	8418	35	,	,	,
18637	8418	36	first	first	RB
18637	8418	37	,	,	,
18637	8418	38	that	that	IN
18637	8418	39	the	the	DT
18637	8418	40	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	8418	41	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	8418	42	was	be	VBD
18637	8418	43	not	not	RB
18637	8418	44	a	a	DT
18637	8418	45	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8418	46	state	state	NN
18637	8418	47	within	within	IN
18637	8418	48	the	the	DT
18637	8418	49	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	8418	50	of	of	IN
18637	8418	51	that	that	DT
18637	8418	52	clause	clause	NN
18637	8418	53	of	of	IN
18637	8418	54	the	the	DT
18637	8418	55	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8418	56	which	which	WDT
18637	8418	57	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	8418	58	the	the	DT
18637	8418	59	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8418	60	power	power	NN
18637	8418	61	of	of	IN
18637	8418	62	the	the	DT
18637	8418	63	United	United	NNP
18637	8418	64	States	States	NNP
18637	8418	65	to	to	IN
18637	8418	66	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	8418	67	"	"	''
18637	8418	68	between	between	IN
18637	8418	69	a	a	DT
18637	8418	70	State	state	NN
18637	8418	71	or	or	CC
18637	8418	72	the	the	DT
18637	8418	73	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8418	74	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8418	75	and	and	CC
18637	8418	76	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8418	77	states	state	NNS
18637	8418	78	,	,	,
18637	8418	79	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8418	80	or	or	CC
18637	8418	81	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	8418	82	"	"	''
18637	8418	83	;	;	:
18637	8418	84	secondly	secondly	RB
18637	8418	85	,	,	,
18637	8418	86	that	that	DT
18637	8418	87	:	:	:
18637	8418	88	"	"	``
18637	8418	89	The	the	DT
18637	8418	90	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8418	91	,	,	,
18637	8418	92	by	by	IN
18637	8418	93	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	8418	94	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8418	95	already	already	RB
18637	8418	96	made	make	VBN
18637	8418	97	,	,	,
18637	8418	98	as	as	RB
18637	8418	99	well	well	RB
18637	8418	100	as	as	IN
18637	8418	101	those	those	DT
18637	8418	102	to	to	TO
18637	8418	103	be	be	VB
18637	8418	104	made	make	VBN
18637	8418	105	,	,	,
18637	8418	106	to	to	TO
18637	8418	107	be	be	VB
18637	8418	108	the	the	DT
18637	8418	109	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	8418	110	law	law	NNP
18637	8418	111	of	of	IN
18637	8418	112	the	the	DT
18637	8418	113	land	land	NN
18637	8418	114	,	,	,
18637	8418	115	had	have	VBD
18637	8418	116	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	8418	117	and	and	CC
18637	8418	118	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
18637	8418	119	the	the	DT
18637	8418	120	previous	previous	JJ
18637	8418	121	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8418	122	with	with	IN
18637	8418	123	the	the	DT
18637	8418	124	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	8418	125	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8418	126	,	,	,
18637	8418	127	and	and	CC
18637	8418	128	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	8418	129	admits	admit	VBZ
18637	8418	130	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8418	131	rank	rank	NN
18637	8418	132	among	among	IN
18637	8418	133	those	those	DT
18637	8418	134	powers	power	NNS
18637	8418	135	who	who	WP
18637	8418	136	are	be	VBP
18637	8418	137	capable	capable	JJ
18637	8418	138	of	of	IN
18637	8418	139	making	make	VBG
18637	8418	140	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8418	141	.	.	.
18637	8419	1	The	the	DT
18637	8419	2	words	word	NNS
18637	8419	3	'	'	POS
18637	8419	4	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8419	5	'	'	''
18637	8419	6	and	and	CC
18637	8419	7	'	'	``
18637	8419	8	nation	nation	NN
18637	8419	9	'	'	''
18637	8419	10	are	be	VBP
18637	8419	11	words	word	NNS
18637	8419	12	of	of	IN
18637	8419	13	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8419	14	own	own	JJ
18637	8419	15	language	language	NN
18637	8419	16	,	,	,
18637	8419	17	selected	select	VBN
18637	8419	18	in	in	IN
18637	8419	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8419	20	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8419	21	and	and	CC
18637	8419	22	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8419	23	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	8419	24	,	,	,
18637	8419	25	by	by	IN
18637	8419	26	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8419	27	,	,	,
18637	8419	28	having	have	VBG
18637	8419	29	each	each	DT
18637	8419	30	a	a	DT
18637	8419	31	definite	definite	JJ
18637	8419	32	and	and	CC
18637	8419	33	well	well	RB
18637	8419	34	understood	understand	VBD
18637	8419	35	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	8419	36	.	.	.
18637	8420	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8420	2	have	have	VBP
18637	8420	3	applied	apply	VBN
18637	8420	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8420	5	to	to	IN
18637	8420	6	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	8420	7	,	,	,
18637	8420	8	as	as	IN
18637	8420	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8420	10	have	have	VBP
18637	8420	11	applied	apply	VBN
18637	8420	12	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8420	13	to	to	IN
18637	8420	14	the	the	DT
18637	8420	15	other	other	JJ
18637	8420	16	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8420	17	of	of	IN
18637	8420	18	the	the	DT
18637	8420	19	earth	earth	NN
18637	8420	20	.	.	.
18637	8421	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8421	2	are	be	VBP
18637	8421	3	applied	apply	VBN
18637	8421	4	to	to	IN
18637	8421	5	all	all	DT
18637	8421	6	in	in	IN
18637	8421	7	the	the	DT
18637	8421	8	same	same	JJ
18637	8421	9	sense	sense	NN
18637	8421	10	.	.	.
18637	8422	1	"	"	``
18637	8422	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8422	3	210	210	CD
18637	8422	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8422	5	Later	late	JJR
18637	8422	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	8422	7	established	establish	VBN
18637	8422	8	that	that	IN
18637	8422	9	the	the	DT
18637	8422	10	power	power	NN
18637	8422	11	to	to	TO
18637	8422	12	make	make	VB
18637	8422	13	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8422	14	with	with	IN
18637	8422	15	the	the	DT
18637	8422	16	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	8422	17	tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	8422	18	was	be	VBD
18637	8422	19	coextensive	coextensive	JJ
18637	8422	20	with	with	IN
18637	8422	21	the	the	DT
18637	8422	22	power	power	NN
18637	8422	23	to	to	TO
18637	8422	24	make	make	VB
18637	8422	25	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8422	26	with	with	IN
18637	8422	27	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8422	28	nations;[211	nations;[211	NNPS
18637	8422	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8422	30	that	that	IN
18637	8422	31	the	the	DT
18637	8422	32	States	States	NNPS
18637	8422	33	were	be	VBD
18637	8422	34	incompetent	incompetent	JJ
18637	8422	35	to	to	TO
18637	8422	36	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	8422	37	with	with	IN
18637	8422	38	rights	right	NNS
18637	8422	39	created	create	VBN
18637	8422	40	by	by	IN
18637	8422	41	such	such	JJ
18637	8422	42	treaties;[212	treaties;[212	CD
18637	8422	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8422	44	that	that	IN
18637	8422	45	as	as	RB
18637	8422	46	long	long	RB
18637	8422	47	as	as	IN
18637	8422	48	the	the	DT
18637	8422	49	United	United	NNP
18637	8422	50	States	States	NNP
18637	8422	51	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	8422	52	the	the	DT
18637	8422	53	national	national	JJ
18637	8422	54	character	character	NN
18637	8422	55	of	of	IN
18637	8422	56	a	a	DT
18637	8422	57	tribe	tribe	NN
18637	8422	58	,	,	,
18637	8422	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8422	60	members	member	NNS
18637	8422	61	were	be	VBD
18637	8422	62	under	under	IN
18637	8422	63	the	the	DT
18637	8422	64	protection	protection	NN
18637	8422	65	of	of	IN
18637	8422	66	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8422	67	and	and	CC
18637	8422	68	of	of	IN
18637	8422	69	the	the	DT
18637	8422	70	laws	law	NNS
18637	8422	71	of	of	IN
18637	8422	72	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8422	73	and	and	CC
18637	8422	74	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8422	75	property	property	NN
18637	8422	76	immune	immune	NN
18637	8422	77	from	from	IN
18637	8422	78	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	8422	79	by	by	IN
18637	8422	80	a	a	DT
18637	8422	81	State;[213	state;[213	NN
18637	8422	82	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8422	83	that	that	IN
18637	8422	84	a	a	DT
18637	8422	85	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	8422	86	in	in	IN
18637	8422	87	an	an	DT
18637	8422	88	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	8422	89	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8422	90	that	that	WDT
18637	8422	91	laws	law	NNS
18637	8422	92	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	8422	93	the	the	DT
18637	8422	94	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	8422	95	of	of	IN
18637	8422	96	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	8422	97	into	into	IN
18637	8422	98	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	8422	99	territory	territory	NN
18637	8422	100	was	be	VBD
18637	8422	101	operative	operative	JJ
18637	8422	102	without	without	IN
18637	8422	103	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8422	104	,	,	,
18637	8422	105	and	and	CC
18637	8422	106	binding	bind	VBG
18637	8422	107	on	on	IN
18637	8422	108	the	the	DT
18637	8422	109	courts	court	NNS
18637	8422	110	although	although	IN
18637	8422	111	the	the	DT
18637	8422	112	territory	territory	NN
18637	8422	113	was	be	VBD
18637	8422	114	within	within	IN
18637	8422	115	an	an	DT
18637	8422	116	organized	organized	JJ
18637	8422	117	county	county	NN
18637	8422	118	of	of	IN
18637	8422	119	the	the	DT
18637	8422	120	States;[214	states;[214	XX
18637	8422	121	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8422	122	that	that	IN
18637	8422	123	an	an	DT
18637	8422	124	act	act	NN
18637	8422	125	of	of	IN
18637	8422	126	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8422	127	contrary	contrary	RB
18637	8422	128	to	to	IN
18637	8422	129	a	a	DT
18637	8422	130	prior	prior	JJ
18637	8422	131	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	8422	132	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8422	133	repealed	repeal	VBD
18637	8422	134	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8422	135	.	.	.
18637	8423	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8423	2	215	215	CD
18637	8423	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8423	4	Present	present	JJ
18637	8423	5	Status	Status	NNP
18637	8423	6	of	of	IN
18637	8423	7	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	8423	8	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	8423	9	Today	Today	NNP
18637	8423	10	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	8423	11	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8423	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	8423	13	a	a	DT
18637	8423	14	closed	closed	JJ
18637	8423	15	account	account	NN
18637	8423	16	in	in	IN
18637	8423	17	the	the	DT
18637	8423	18	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	8423	19	Law	Law	NNP
18637	8423	20	ledger	ledger	NN
18637	8423	21	.	.	.
18637	8424	1	By	by	IN
18637	8424	2	a	a	DT
18637	8424	3	rider	rider	NN
18637	8424	4	inserted	insert	VBN
18637	8424	5	in	in	IN
18637	8424	6	the	the	DT
18637	8424	7	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	8424	8	Appropriation	Appropriation	NNP
18637	8424	9	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8424	10	of	of	IN
18637	8424	11	March	March	NNP
18637	8424	12	3	3	CD
18637	8424	13	,	,	,
18637	8424	14	1871	1871	CD
18637	8424	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8424	16	was	be	VBD
18637	8424	17	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8424	18	"	"	``
18637	8424	19	That	that	DT
18637	8424	20	hereafter	hereafter	VBP
18637	8424	21	no	no	DT
18637	8424	22	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	8424	23	nation	nation	NN
18637	8424	24	or	or	CC
18637	8424	25	tribe	tribe	NN
18637	8424	26	within	within	IN
18637	8424	27	the	the	DT
18637	8424	28	territory	territory	NN
18637	8424	29	of	of	IN
18637	8424	30	the	the	DT
18637	8424	31	United	United	NNP
18637	8424	32	States	States	NNP
18637	8424	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	8424	34	be	be	VB
18637	8424	35	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	8424	36	or	or	CC
18637	8424	37	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	8424	38	as	as	IN
18637	8424	39	an	an	DT
18637	8424	40	independent	independent	JJ
18637	8424	41	nation	nation	NN
18637	8424	42	,	,	,
18637	8424	43	tribe	tribe	NN
18637	8424	44	,	,	,
18637	8424	45	or	or	CC
18637	8424	46	power	power	NN
18637	8424	47	with	with	IN
18637	8424	48	whom	whom	WP
18637	8424	49	the	the	DT
18637	8424	50	United	United	NNP
18637	8424	51	States	States	NNP
18637	8424	52	may	may	MD
18637	8424	53	contract	contract	VB
18637	8424	54	by	by	IN
18637	8424	55	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8424	56	:	:	:
18637	8424	57	_	_	NNP
18637	8424	58	Provided	Provided	NNP
18637	8424	59	,	,	,
18637	8424	60	further	further	JJ
18637	8424	61	_	_	NNP
18637	8424	62	,	,	,
18637	8424	63	that	that	IN
18637	8424	64	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	8424	65	herein	herein	NNP
18637	8424	66	contained	contain	VBD
18637	8424	67	shall	shall	MD
18637	8424	68	be	be	VB
18637	8424	69	construed	construe	VBN
18637	8424	70	to	to	TO
18637	8424	71	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	8424	72	or	or	CC
18637	8424	73	impair	impair	VB
18637	8424	74	the	the	DT
18637	8424	75	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8424	76	of	of	IN
18637	8424	77	any	any	DT
18637	8424	78	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8424	79	heretofore	heretofore	RB
18637	8424	80	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	8424	81	made	make	VBD
18637	8424	82	and	and	CC
18637	8424	83	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	8424	84	with	with	IN
18637	8424	85	any	any	DT
18637	8424	86	such	such	JJ
18637	8424	87	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	8424	88	nation	nation	NN
18637	8424	89	or	or	CC
18637	8424	90	tribe	tribe	NN
18637	8424	91	.	.	.
18637	8425	1	"	"	``
18637	8425	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8425	3	216	216	CD
18637	8425	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8425	5	Subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	8425	6	,	,	,
18637	8425	7	the	the	DT
18637	8425	8	power	power	NN
18637	8425	9	of	of	IN
18637	8425	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8425	11	to	to	TO
18637	8425	12	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	8425	13	or	or	CC
18637	8425	14	modify	modify	VB
18637	8425	15	tribal	tribal	JJ
18637	8425	16	rights	right	NNS
18637	8425	17	previously	previously	RB
18637	8425	18	granted	grant	VBN
18637	8425	19	by	by	IN
18637	8425	20	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8425	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	8425	22	been	be	VBN
18637	8425	23	invariably	invariably	RB
18637	8425	24	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	8425	25	.	.	.
18637	8426	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	8426	2	the	the	DT
18637	8426	3	admission	admission	NN
18637	8426	4	of	of	IN
18637	8426	5	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	8426	6	as	as	IN
18637	8426	7	a	a	DT
18637	8426	8	State	state	NN
18637	8426	9	was	be	VBD
18637	8426	10	found	find	VBN
18637	8426	11	to	to	TO
18637	8426	12	abrogate	abrogate	VB
18637	8426	13	,	,	,
18637	8426	14	_	_	NNP
18637	8426	15	pro	pro	NN
18637	8426	16	tanto	tanto	IN
18637	8426	17	_	_	NNP
18637	8426	18	,	,	,
18637	8426	19	a	a	DT
18637	8426	20	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8426	21	guaranteeing	guarantee	VBG
18637	8426	22	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8426	23	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	8426	24	the	the	DT
18637	8426	25	right	right	NN
18637	8426	26	to	to	TO
18637	8426	27	hunt	hunt	VB
18637	8426	28	on	on	IN
18637	8426	29	unoccupied	unoccupied	JJ
18637	8426	30	lands	land	NNS
18637	8426	31	of	of	IN
18637	8426	32	the	the	DT
18637	8426	33	United	United	NNP
18637	8426	34	States	States	NNP
18637	8426	35	so	so	RB
18637	8426	36	long	long	RB
18637	8426	37	as	as	IN
18637	8426	38	game	game	NN
18637	8426	39	may	may	MD
18637	8426	40	be	be	VB
18637	8426	41	found	find	VBN
18637	8426	42	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	8426	43	and	and	CC
18637	8426	44	to	to	TO
18637	8426	45	bring	bring	VB
18637	8426	46	hunting	hunting	NN
18637	8426	47	by	by	IN
18637	8426	48	the	the	DT
18637	8426	49	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	8426	50	within	within	IN
18637	8426	51	the	the	DT
18637	8426	52	police	police	NN
18637	8426	53	power	power	NN
18637	8426	54	of	of	IN
18637	8426	55	the	the	DT
18637	8426	56	State	State	NNP
18637	8426	57	.	.	.
18637	8427	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8427	2	217	217	CD
18637	8427	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8427	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	8427	5	,	,	,
18637	8427	6	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	8427	7	modifying	modify	VBG
18637	8427	8	rights	right	NNS
18637	8427	9	of	of	IN
18637	8427	10	members	member	NNS
18637	8427	11	in	in	IN
18637	8427	12	tribal	tribal	JJ
18637	8427	13	lands,[218	lands,[218	NNS
18637	8427	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8427	15	granting	grant	VBG
18637	8427	16	a	a	DT
18637	8427	17	right	right	NN
18637	8427	18	of	of	IN
18637	8427	19	way	way	NN
18637	8427	20	for	for	IN
18637	8427	21	a	a	DT
18637	8427	22	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	8427	23	through	through	IN
18637	8427	24	lands	land	NNS
18637	8427	25	ceded	cede	VBN
18637	8427	26	by	by	IN
18637	8427	27	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8427	28	to	to	IN
18637	8427	29	an	an	DT
18637	8427	30	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	8427	31	tribe,[219	tribe,[219	NNS
18637	8427	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8427	33	or	or	CC
18637	8427	34	extending	extend	VBG
18637	8427	35	the	the	DT
18637	8427	36	application	application	NN
18637	8427	37	of	of	IN
18637	8427	38	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	8427	39	laws	law	NNS
18637	8427	40	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	8427	41	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	8427	42	and	and	CC
18637	8427	43	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	8427	44	over	over	IN
18637	8427	45	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	8427	46	territories	territory	NNS
18637	8427	47	,	,	,
18637	8427	48	despite	despite	IN
18637	8427	49	an	an	DT
18637	8427	50	earlier	early	JJR
18637	8427	51	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8427	52	exemption,[220	exemption,[220	NN
18637	8427	53	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8427	54	have	have	VBP
18637	8427	55	been	be	VBN
18637	8427	56	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	8427	57	.	.	.
18637	8428	1	When	when	WRB
18637	8428	2	,	,	,
18637	8428	3	on	on	IN
18637	8428	4	the	the	DT
18637	8428	5	other	other	JJ
18637	8428	6	hand	hand	NN
18637	8428	7	,	,	,
18637	8428	8	definite	definite	JJ
18637	8428	9	property	property	NN
18637	8428	10	rights	right	NNS
18637	8428	11	have	have	VBP
18637	8428	12	been	be	VBN
18637	8428	13	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	8428	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	8428	15	individual	individual	JJ
18637	8428	16	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	8428	17	,	,	,
18637	8428	18	whether	whether	IN
18637	8428	19	by	by	IN
18637	8428	20	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8428	21	or	or	CC
18637	8428	22	under	under	IN
18637	8428	23	an	an	DT
18637	8428	24	act	act	NN
18637	8428	25	of	of	IN
18637	8428	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8428	27	,	,	,
18637	8428	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8428	29	are	be	VBP
18637	8428	30	protected	protect	VBN
18637	8428	31	by	by	IN
18637	8428	32	the	the	DT
18637	8428	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8428	34	to	to	IN
18637	8428	35	the	the	DT
18637	8428	36	same	same	JJ
18637	8428	37	extent	extent	NN
18637	8428	38	and	and	CC
18637	8428	39	in	in	IN
18637	8428	40	the	the	DT
18637	8428	41	same	same	JJ
18637	8428	42	way	way	NN
18637	8428	43	as	as	IN
18637	8428	44	the	the	DT
18637	8428	45	private	private	JJ
18637	8428	46	rights	right	NNS
18637	8428	47	of	of	IN
18637	8428	48	other	other	JJ
18637	8428	49	residents	resident	NNS
18637	8428	50	or	or	CC
18637	8428	51	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8428	52	of	of	IN
18637	8428	53	the	the	DT
18637	8428	54	United	United	NNP
18637	8428	55	States	States	NNP
18637	8428	56	.	.	.
18637	8429	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	8429	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8429	3	was	be	VBD
18637	8429	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	8429	5	that	that	IN
18637	8429	6	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8429	7	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	8429	8	allottees	allottee	NNS
18637	8429	9	under	under	IN
18637	8429	10	an	an	DT
18637	8429	11	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8429	12	according	accord	VBG
18637	8429	13	to	to	IN
18637	8429	14	which	which	WDT
18637	8429	15	,	,	,
18637	8429	16	in	in	IN
18637	8429	17	part	part	NN
18637	8429	18	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	8429	19	of	of	IN
18637	8429	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8429	21	relinquishment	relinquishment	NN
18637	8429	22	of	of	IN
18637	8429	23	all	all	DT
18637	8429	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8429	25	claim	claim	NN
18637	8429	26	to	to	IN
18637	8429	27	tribal	tribal	JJ
18637	8429	28	property	property	NN
18637	8429	29	,	,	,
18637	8429	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8429	31	were	be	VBD
18637	8429	32	to	to	TO
18637	8429	33	receive	receive	VB
18637	8429	34	in	in	IN
18637	8429	35	severalty	severalty	NN
18637	8429	36	allotments	allotment	NNS
18637	8429	37	of	of	IN
18637	8429	38	lands	land	NNS
18637	8429	39	which	which	WDT
18637	8429	40	were	be	VBD
18637	8429	41	to	to	TO
18637	8429	42	be	be	VB
18637	8429	43	nontaxable	nontaxable	JJ
18637	8429	44	for	for	IN
18637	8429	45	a	a	DT
18637	8429	46	specified	specified	JJ
18637	8429	47	period	period	NN
18637	8429	48	,	,	,
18637	8429	49	acquired	acquire	VBD
18637	8429	50	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8429	51	rights	right	NNS
18637	8429	52	of	of	IN
18637	8429	53	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	8429	54	from	from	IN
18637	8429	55	State	state	NN
18637	8429	56	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	8429	57	which	which	WDT
18637	8429	58	were	be	VBD
18637	8429	59	protected	protect	VBN
18637	8429	60	by	by	IN
18637	8429	61	the	the	DT
18637	8429	62	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	8429	63	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	8429	64	against	against	IN
18637	8429	65	abrogation	abrogation	NN
18637	8429	66	by	by	IN
18637	8429	67	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8429	68	.	.	.
18637	8430	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8430	2	221	221	CD
18637	8430	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8430	4	International	international	JJ
18637	8430	5	Agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8430	6	Without	without	IN
18637	8430	7	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8430	8	Approval	Approval	NNP
18637	8430	9	The	the	DT
18637	8430	10	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	8430	11	of	of	IN
18637	8430	12	the	the	DT
18637	8430	13	United	United	NNP
18637	8430	14	States	States	NNP
18637	8430	15	to	to	TO
18637	8430	16	enter	enter	VB
18637	8430	17	into	into	IN
18637	8430	18	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8430	19	with	with	IN
18637	8430	20	other	other	JJ
18637	8430	21	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8430	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	8430	23	not	not	RB
18637	8430	24	exhausted	exhaust	VBN
18637	8430	25	in	in	IN
18637	8430	26	the	the	DT
18637	8430	27	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8430	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	8430	29	making	make	VBG
18637	8430	30	power	power	NN
18637	8430	31	.	.	.
18637	8431	1	The	the	DT
18637	8431	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8431	3	recognizes	recognize	VBZ
18637	8431	4	a	a	DT
18637	8431	5	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	8431	6	between	between	IN
18637	8431	7	"	"	``
18637	8431	8	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8431	9	"	"	''
18637	8431	10	and	and	CC
18637	8431	11	"	"	``
18637	8431	12	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8431	13	"	"	''
18637	8431	14	or	or	CC
18637	8431	15	"	"	``
18637	8431	16	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	8431	17	,	,	,
18637	8431	18	"	"	''
18637	8431	19	but	but	CC
18637	8431	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	8431	21	not	not	RB
18637	8431	22	indicate	indicate	VB
18637	8431	23	what	what	WP
18637	8431	24	the	the	DT
18637	8431	25	difference	difference	NN
18637	8431	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	8431	27	;	;	:
18637	8431	28	and	and	CC
18637	8431	29	what	what	WDT
18637	8431	30	difference	difference	NN
18637	8431	31	there	there	RB
18637	8431	32	once	once	RB
18637	8431	33	may	may	MD
18637	8431	34	have	have	VB
18637	8431	35	been	be	VBN
18637	8431	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	8431	37	been	be	VBN
18637	8431	38	seriously	seriously	RB
18637	8431	39	blurred	blur	VBN
18637	8431	40	in	in	IN
18637	8431	41	practice	practice	NN
18637	8431	42	within	within	IN
18637	8431	43	recent	recent	JJ
18637	8431	44	decades	decade	NNS
18637	8431	45	.	.	.
18637	8432	1	The	the	DT
18637	8432	2	President	President	NNP
18637	8432	3	's	's	POS
18637	8432	4	power	power	NN
18637	8432	5	to	to	TO
18637	8432	6	enter	enter	VB
18637	8432	7	into	into	IN
18637	8432	8	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8432	9	or	or	CC
18637	8432	10	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	8432	11	with	with	IN
18637	8432	12	other	other	JJ
18637	8432	13	governments	government	NNS
18637	8432	14	without	without	IN
18637	8432	15	consulting	consult	VBG
18637	8432	16	the	the	DT
18637	8432	17	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8432	18	must	must	MD
18637	8432	19	be	be	VB
18637	8432	20	referred	refer	VBN
18637	8432	21	to	to	IN
18637	8432	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8432	23	powers	power	NNS
18637	8432	24	as	as	IN
18637	8432	25	organ	organ	NN
18637	8432	26	of	of	IN
18637	8432	27	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8432	28	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8432	29	and	and	CC
18637	8432	30	as	as	IN
18637	8432	31	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8432	32	in	in	IN
18637	8432	33	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8432	34	.	.	.
18637	8433	1	From	from	IN
18637	8433	2	an	an	DT
18637	8433	3	early	early	JJ
18637	8433	4	date	date	NN
18637	8433	5	,	,	,
18637	8433	6	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	8433	7	,	,	,
18637	8433	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8433	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	8433	10	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8433	11	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8433	12	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8433	13	within	within	IN
18637	8433	14	the	the	DT
18637	8433	15	field	field	NN
18637	8433	16	of	of	IN
18637	8433	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8433	18	powers	power	NNS
18637	8433	19	,	,	,
18637	8433	20	postal	postal	JJ
18637	8433	21	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8433	22	,	,	,
18637	8433	23	trade	trade	NN
18637	8433	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	8433	25	mark	mark	NN
18637	8433	26	and	and	CC
18637	8433	27	copyright	copyright	NN
18637	8433	28	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8433	29	,	,	,
18637	8433	30	reciprocal	reciprocal	JJ
18637	8433	31	trade	trade	NN
18637	8433	32	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8433	33	.	.	.
18637	8434	1	Executive	executive	JJ
18637	8434	2	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8434	3	may	may	MD
18637	8434	4	also	also	RB
18637	8434	5	stem	stem	VB
18637	8434	6	from	from	IN
18637	8434	7	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8434	8	.	.	.
18637	8435	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8435	2	222	222	CD
18637	8435	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8435	4	ROUTINE	ROUTINE	NNP
18637	8435	5	EXECUTIVE	executive	NN
18637	8435	6	AGREEMENTS	agreements	RB
18637	8435	7	Many	many	JJ
18637	8435	8	types	type	NNS
18637	8435	9	of	of	IN
18637	8435	10	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8435	11	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8435	12	comprise	comprise	VBP
18637	8435	13	the	the	DT
18637	8435	14	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	8435	15	daily	daily	JJ
18637	8435	16	grist	grist	NN
18637	8435	17	of	of	IN
18637	8435	18	the	the	DT
18637	8435	19	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8435	20	mill	mill	NN
18637	8435	21	.	.	.
18637	8436	1	Among	among	IN
18637	8436	2	these	these	DT
18637	8436	3	are	be	VBP
18637	8436	4	such	such	JJ
18637	8436	5	as	as	IN
18637	8436	6	apply	apply	VB
18637	8436	7	to	to	IN
18637	8436	8	minor	minor	JJ
18637	8436	9	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	8436	10	adjustments	adjustment	NNS
18637	8436	11	,	,	,
18637	8436	12	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	8436	13	rectifications	rectification	NNS
18637	8436	14	,	,	,
18637	8436	15	the	the	DT
18637	8436	16	policing	policing	NN
18637	8436	17	of	of	IN
18637	8436	18	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	8436	19	,	,	,
18637	8436	20	the	the	DT
18637	8436	21	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	8436	22	of	of	IN
18637	8436	23	fishing	fishing	NN
18637	8436	24	rights	right	NNS
18637	8436	25	,	,	,
18637	8436	26	private	private	JJ
18637	8436	27	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
18637	8436	28	claims	claim	NNS
18637	8436	29	against	against	IN
18637	8436	30	another	another	DT
18637	8436	31	government	government	NN
18637	8436	32	or	or	CC
18637	8436	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8436	34	nationals	national	NNS
18637	8436	35	,	,	,
18637	8436	36	in	in	IN
18637	8436	37	Story	Story	NNP
18637	8436	38	's	's	POS
18637	8436	39	words	word	NNS
18637	8436	40	,	,	,
18637	8436	41	"	"	''
18637	8436	42	the	the	DT
18637	8436	43	mere	mere	JJ
18637	8436	44	private	private	JJ
18637	8436	45	rights	right	NNS
18637	8436	46	of	of	IN
18637	8436	47	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	8436	48	.	.	.
18637	8437	1	"	"	``
18637	8437	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8437	3	223	223	CD
18637	8437	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8437	5	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	8437	6	lists	list	NNS
18637	8437	7	scores	score	NNS
18637	8437	8	of	of	IN
18637	8437	9	such	such	JJ
18637	8437	10	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8437	11	entered	enter	VBD
18637	8437	12	into	into	IN
18637	8437	13	with	with	IN
18637	8437	14	other	other	JJ
18637	8437	15	governments	government	NNS
18637	8437	16	by	by	IN
18637	8437	17	the	the	DT
18637	8437	18	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	8437	19	of	of	IN
18637	8437	20	the	the	DT
18637	8437	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8437	22	.	.	.
18637	8438	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8438	2	224	224	CD
18637	8438	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8438	4	Such	such	JJ
18637	8438	5	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8438	6	are	be	VBP
18637	8438	7	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	8438	8	directed	direct	VBN
18637	8438	9	to	to	IN
18637	8438	10	particular	particular	JJ
18637	8438	11	and	and	CC
18637	8438	12	comparatively	comparatively	RB
18637	8438	13	trivial	trivial	JJ
18637	8438	14	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	8438	15	and	and	CC
18637	8438	16	by	by	IN
18637	8438	17	the	the	DT
18637	8438	18	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	8438	19	the	the	DT
18637	8438	20	effect	effect	NN
18637	8438	21	of	of	IN
18637	8438	22	these	these	DT
18637	8438	23	cease	cease	NN
18637	8438	24	_	_	NNP
18637	8438	25	ipso	ipso	NN
18637	8438	26	facto	facto	FW
18637	8438	27	_	_	NNP
18637	8438	28	to	to	TO
18637	8438	29	be	be	VB
18637	8438	30	operative	operative	JJ
18637	8438	31	.	.	.
18637	8439	1	Also	also	RB
18637	8439	2	there	there	EX
18637	8439	3	are	be	VBP
18637	8439	4	such	such	JJ
18637	8439	5	time	time	NN
18637	8439	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	8439	7	honored	honor	VBN
18637	8439	8	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8439	9	devices	device	NNS
18637	8439	10	as	as	IN
18637	8439	11	the	the	DT
18637	8439	12	"	"	``
18637	8439	13	protocol	protocol	NN
18637	8439	14	"	"	''
18637	8439	15	which	which	WDT
18637	8439	16	marks	mark	VBZ
18637	8439	17	a	a	DT
18637	8439	18	stage	stage	NN
18637	8439	19	in	in	IN
18637	8439	20	the	the	DT
18637	8439	21	negotiation	negotiation	NN
18637	8439	22	of	of	IN
18637	8439	23	a	a	DT
18637	8439	24	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8439	25	,	,	,
18637	8439	26	and	and	CC
18637	8439	27	the	the	DT
18637	8439	28	_	_	NNP
18637	8439	29	modus	modus	FW
18637	8439	30	vivendi	vivendi	FW
18637	8439	31	_	_	NNP
18637	8439	32	,	,	,
18637	8439	33	which	which	WDT
18637	8439	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	8439	35	designed	design	VBN
18637	8439	36	to	to	TO
18637	8439	37	serve	serve	VB
18637	8439	38	as	as	IN
18637	8439	39	a	a	DT
18637	8439	40	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	8439	41	substitute	substitute	NN
18637	8439	42	for	for	IN
18637	8439	43	one	one	CD
18637	8439	44	.	.	.
18637	8440	1	Executive	executive	JJ
18637	8440	2	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8440	3	become	become	VBP
18637	8440	4	of	of	IN
18637	8440	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8440	6	significance	significance	NN
18637	8440	7	when	when	WRB
18637	8440	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8440	9	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	8440	10	a	a	DT
18637	8440	11	determinative	determinative	JJ
18637	8440	12	factor	factor	NN
18637	8440	13	of	of	IN
18637	8440	14	future	future	JJ
18637	8440	15	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8440	16	policy	policy	NN
18637	8440	17	and	and	CC
18637	8440	18	hence	hence	RB
18637	8440	19	of	of	IN
18637	8440	20	the	the	DT
18637	8440	21	country	country	NN
18637	8440	22	's	's	POS
18637	8440	23	destiny	destiny	NN
18637	8440	24	.	.	.
18637	8441	1	Within	within	IN
18637	8441	2	recent	recent	JJ
18637	8441	3	decades	decade	NNS
18637	8441	4	,	,	,
18637	8441	5	in	in	IN
18637	8441	6	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	8441	7	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	8441	8	of	of	IN
18637	8441	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8441	10	participation	participation	NN
18637	8441	11	in	in	IN
18637	8441	12	World	World	NNP
18637	8441	13	War	War	NNP
18637	8441	14	II	II	NNP
18637	8441	15	and	and	CC
18637	8441	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8441	17	immersion	immersion	NN
18637	8441	18	in	in	IN
18637	8441	19	the	the	DT
18637	8441	20	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	8441	21	of	of	IN
18637	8441	22	international	international	JJ
18637	8441	23	tension	tension	NN
18637	8441	24	which	which	WDT
18637	8441	25	have	have	VBP
18637	8441	26	prevailed	prevail	VBN
18637	8441	27	both	both	DT
18637	8441	28	before	before	IN
18637	8441	29	and	and	CC
18637	8441	30	after	after	IN
18637	8441	31	this	this	DT
18637	8441	32	war	war	NN
18637	8441	33	,	,	,
18637	8441	34	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	8441	35	have	have	VBP
18637	8441	36	entered	enter	VBN
18637	8441	37	into	into	IN
18637	8441	38	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8441	39	with	with	IN
18637	8441	40	other	other	JJ
18637	8441	41	governments	government	NNS
18637	8441	42	some	some	DT
18637	8441	43	of	of	IN
18637	8441	44	which	which	WDT
18637	8441	45	have	have	VBP
18637	8441	46	approximated	approximate	VBN
18637	8441	47	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	8441	48	alliances	alliance	NNS
18637	8441	49	.	.	.
18637	8442	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8442	2	can	can	MD
18637	8442	3	not	not	RB
18637	8442	4	be	be	VB
18637	8442	5	justly	justly	RB
18637	8442	6	said	say	VBN
18637	8442	7	,	,	,
18637	8442	8	however	however	RB
18637	8442	9	,	,	,
18637	8442	10	that	that	IN
18637	8442	11	in	in	IN
18637	8442	12	so	so	RB
18637	8442	13	doing	do	VBG
18637	8442	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8442	15	have	have	VBP
18637	8442	16	acted	act	VBN
18637	8442	17	without	without	IN
18637	8442	18	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	8442	19	support	support	NN
18637	8442	20	from	from	IN
18637	8442	21	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	8442	22	.	.	.
18637	8443	1	LAW	law	NN
18637	8443	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	8443	3	MAKING	making	NN
18637	8443	4	EXECUTIVE	executive	NN
18637	8443	5	AGREEMENTS	AGREEMENTS	NNP
18637	8443	6	An	an	DT
18637	8443	7	early	early	JJ
18637	8443	8	instance	instance	NN
18637	8443	9	of	of	IN
18637	8443	10	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8443	11	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8443	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	8443	13	making	making	NN
18637	8443	14	was	be	VBD
18637	8443	15	the	the	DT
18637	8443	16	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8443	17	by	by	IN
18637	8443	18	which	which	WDT
18637	8443	19	President	President	NNP
18637	8443	20	Monroe	Monroe	NNP
18637	8443	21	in	in	IN
18637	8443	22	1817	1817	CD
18637	8443	23	brought	bring	VBD
18637	8443	24	about	about	RP
18637	8443	25	a	a	DT
18637	8443	26	delimitation	delimitation	NN
18637	8443	27	of	of	IN
18637	8443	28	armaments	armament	NNS
18637	8443	29	on	on	IN
18637	8443	30	the	the	DT
18637	8443	31	Great	Great	NNP
18637	8443	32	Lakes	Lakes	NNPS
18637	8443	33	.	.	.
18637	8444	1	The	the	DT
18637	8444	2	arrangement	arrangement	NN
18637	8444	3	was	be	VBD
18637	8444	4	effected	effect	VBN
18637	8444	5	by	by	IN
18637	8444	6	an	an	DT
18637	8444	7	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	8444	8	of	of	IN
18637	8444	9	notes	note	NNS
18637	8444	10	,	,	,
18637	8444	11	which	which	WDT
18637	8444	12	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	8444	13	a	a	DT
18637	8444	14	year	year	NN
18637	8444	15	later	later	RB
18637	8444	16	was	be	VBD
18637	8444	17	laid	lay	VBN
18637	8444	18	before	before	IN
18637	8444	19	the	the	DT
18637	8444	20	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8444	21	with	with	IN
18637	8444	22	a	a	DT
18637	8444	23	query	query	NN
18637	8444	24	as	as	IN
18637	8444	25	to	to	IN
18637	8444	26	whether	whether	IN
18637	8444	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8444	28	was	be	VBD
18637	8444	29	within	within	IN
18637	8444	30	the	the	DT
18637	8444	31	President	President	NNP
18637	8444	32	's	's	POS
18637	8444	33	power	power	NN
18637	8444	34	,	,	,
18637	8444	35	or	or	CC
18637	8444	36	whether	whether	IN
18637	8444	37	advice	advice	NN
18637	8444	38	and	and	CC
18637	8444	39	consent	consent	NN
18637	8444	40	of	of	IN
18637	8444	41	the	the	DT
18637	8444	42	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8444	43	were	be	VBD
18637	8444	44	required	require	VBN
18637	8444	45	.	.	.
18637	8445	1	The	the	DT
18637	8445	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8445	3	approved	approve	VBD
18637	8445	4	the	the	DT
18637	8445	5	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8445	6	by	by	IN
18637	8445	7	the	the	DT
18637	8445	8	required	require	VBN
18637	8445	9	two	two	CD
18637	8445	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	8445	11	thirds	third	NNS
18637	8445	12	vote	vote	NN
18637	8445	13	,	,	,
18637	8445	14	and	and	CC
18637	8445	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8445	16	was	be	VBD
18637	8445	17	forthwith	forthwith	NNP
18637	8445	18	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
18637	8445	19	by	by	IN
18637	8445	20	the	the	DT
18637	8445	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8445	22	without	without	IN
18637	8445	23	there	there	EX
18637	8445	24	having	have	VBG
18637	8445	25	been	be	VBN
18637	8445	26	a	a	DT
18637	8445	27	formal	formal	JJ
18637	8445	28	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	8445	29	of	of	IN
18637	8445	30	ratifications	ratification	NNS
18637	8445	31	.	.	.
18637	8446	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8446	2	225	225	CD
18637	8446	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8446	4	Of	of	IN
18637	8446	5	a	a	DT
18637	8446	6	kindred	kindred	JJ
18637	8446	7	type	type	NN
18637	8446	8	,	,	,
18637	8446	9	and	and	CC
18637	8446	10	owing	owe	VBG
18637	8446	11	much	much	RB
18637	8446	12	to	to	IN
18637	8446	13	the	the	DT
18637	8446	14	President	President	NNP
18637	8446	15	's	's	POS
18637	8446	16	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	8446	17	as	as	IN
18637	8446	18	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8446	19	in	in	IN
18637	8446	20	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8446	21	,	,	,
18637	8446	22	was	be	VBD
18637	8446	23	a	a	DT
18637	8446	24	series	series	NN
18637	8446	25	of	of	IN
18637	8446	26	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8446	27	entered	enter	VBD
18637	8446	28	into	into	IN
18637	8446	29	with	with	IN
18637	8446	30	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	8446	31	between	between	IN
18637	8446	32	1882	1882	CD
18637	8446	33	and	and	CC
18637	8446	34	1896	1896	CD
18637	8446	35	according	accord	VBG
18637	8446	36	each	each	DT
18637	8446	37	country	country	NN
18637	8446	38	the	the	DT
18637	8446	39	right	right	NN
18637	8446	40	to	to	TO
18637	8446	41	pursue	pursue	VB
18637	8446	42	marauding	maraud	VBG
18637	8446	43	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	8446	44	across	across	IN
18637	8446	45	the	the	DT
18637	8446	46	common	common	JJ
18637	8446	47	border	border	NN
18637	8446	48	.	.	.
18637	8447	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8447	2	226	226	CD
18637	8447	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8447	4	Commenting	comment	VBG
18637	8447	5	on	on	IN
18637	8447	6	such	such	PDT
18637	8447	7	an	an	DT
18637	8447	8	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8447	9	,	,	,
18637	8447	10	the	the	DT
18637	8447	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8447	12	remarked	remark	VBD
18637	8447	13	,	,	,
18637	8447	14	a	a	DT
18637	8447	15	bit	bit	NN
18637	8447	16	uncertainly	uncertainly	RB
18637	8447	17	:	:	:
18637	8447	18	"	"	``
18637	8447	19	While	while	IN
18637	8447	20	no	no	DT
18637	8447	21	act	act	NN
18637	8447	22	of	of	IN
18637	8447	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8447	24	authorizes	authorize	VBZ
18637	8447	25	the	the	DT
18637	8447	26	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8447	27	department	department	NN
18637	8447	28	to	to	TO
18637	8447	29	permit	permit	VB
18637	8447	30	the	the	DT
18637	8447	31	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	8447	32	of	of	IN
18637	8447	33	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8447	34	troops	troop	NNS
18637	8447	35	,	,	,
18637	8447	36	the	the	DT
18637	8447	37	power	power	NN
18637	8447	38	to	to	TO
18637	8447	39	give	give	VB
18637	8447	40	such	such	JJ
18637	8447	41	permission	permission	NN
18637	8447	42	without	without	IN
18637	8447	43	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8447	44	assent	assent	NN
18637	8447	45	was	be	VBD
18637	8447	46	probably	probably	RB
18637	8447	47	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	8447	48	to	to	TO
18637	8447	49	exist	exist	VB
18637	8447	50	from	from	IN
18637	8447	51	the	the	DT
18637	8447	52	authority	authority	NN
18637	8447	53	of	of	IN
18637	8447	54	the	the	DT
18637	8447	55	President	President	NNP
18637	8447	56	as	as	IN
18637	8447	57	commander	commander	NN
18637	8447	58	in	in	IN
18637	8447	59	chief	chief	NN
18637	8447	60	of	of	IN
18637	8447	61	the	the	DT
18637	8447	62	military	military	JJ
18637	8447	63	and	and	CC
18637	8447	64	naval	naval	JJ
18637	8447	65	forces	force	NNS
18637	8447	66	of	of	IN
18637	8447	67	the	the	DT
18637	8447	68	United	United	NNP
18637	8447	69	States	States	NNP
18637	8447	70	.	.	.
18637	8448	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8448	2	may	may	MD
18637	8448	3	be	be	VB
18637	8448	4	doubted	doubt	VBN
18637	8448	5	,	,	,
18637	8448	6	however	however	RB
18637	8448	7	,	,	,
18637	8448	8	whether	whether	IN
18637	8448	9	such	such	JJ
18637	8448	10	power	power	NN
18637	8448	11	could	could	MD
18637	8448	12	be	be	VB
18637	8448	13	extended	extend	VBN
18637	8448	14	to	to	IN
18637	8448	15	the	the	DT
18637	8448	16	apprehension	apprehension	NN
18637	8448	17	of	of	IN
18637	8448	18	deserters	deserter	NNS
18637	8448	19	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8448	20	from	from	IN
18637	8448	21	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8448	22	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	8448	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8448	24	in	in	IN
18637	8448	25	the	the	DT
18637	8448	26	absence	absence	NN
18637	8448	27	of	of	IN
18637	8448	28	positive	positive	JJ
18637	8448	29	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8448	30	to	to	IN
18637	8448	31	that	that	DT
18637	8448	32	effect	effect	NN
18637	8448	33	.	.	.
18637	8449	1	"	"	``
18637	8449	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8449	3	227	227	CD
18637	8449	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8449	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8449	6	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	8449	7	and	and	CC
18637	8449	8	three	three	CD
18637	8449	9	other	other	JJ
18637	8449	10	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	8449	11	were	be	VBD
18637	8449	12	of	of	IN
18637	8449	13	the	the	DT
18637	8449	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8449	15	that	that	IN
18637	8449	16	such	such	JJ
18637	8449	17	action	action	NN
18637	8449	18	by	by	IN
18637	8449	19	the	the	DT
18637	8449	20	President	President	NNP
18637	8449	21	must	must	MD
18637	8449	22	rest	rest	VB
18637	8449	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	8449	24	express	express	JJ
18637	8449	25	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8449	26	or	or	CC
18637	8449	27	statute	statute	NN
18637	8449	28	.	.	.
18637	8450	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8450	2	228	228	CD
18637	8450	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8450	4	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	8450	5	McKINLEY	McKINLEY	NNP
18637	8450	6	'S	be	VBZ
18637	8450	7	CONTRIBUTION	contribution	NN
18637	8450	8	Notable	notable	JJ
18637	8450	9	expansion	expansion	NN
18637	8450	10	of	of	IN
18637	8450	11	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8450	12	power	power	NN
18637	8450	13	in	in	IN
18637	8450	14	this	this	DT
18637	8450	15	field	field	NN
18637	8450	16	first	first	RB
18637	8450	17	became	become	VBD
18637	8450	18	manifest	manifest	NN
18637	8450	19	in	in	IN
18637	8450	20	the	the	DT
18637	8450	21	administration	administration	NN
18637	8450	22	of	of	IN
18637	8450	23	President	President	NNP
18637	8450	24	McKinley	McKinley	NNP
18637	8450	25	.	.	.
18637	8451	1	At	at	IN
18637	8451	2	the	the	DT
18637	8451	3	outset	outset	NN
18637	8451	4	of	of	IN
18637	8451	5	war	war	NN
18637	8451	6	with	with	IN
18637	8451	7	Spain	Spain	NNP
18637	8451	8	the	the	DT
18637	8451	9	President	President	NNP
18637	8451	10	proclaimed	proclaim	VBD
18637	8451	11	that	that	IN
18637	8451	12	the	the	DT
18637	8451	13	United	United	NNP
18637	8451	14	States	States	NNP
18637	8451	15	would	would	MD
18637	8451	16	consider	consider	VB
18637	8451	17	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8451	18	bound	bind	VBN
18637	8451	19	for	for	IN
18637	8451	20	the	the	DT
18637	8451	21	duration	duration	NN
18637	8451	22	by	by	IN
18637	8451	23	the	the	DT
18637	8451	24	last	last	JJ
18637	8451	25	three	three	CD
18637	8451	26	principles	principle	NNS
18637	8451	27	of	of	IN
18637	8451	28	the	the	DT
18637	8451	29	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
18637	8451	30	of	of	IN
18637	8451	31	Paris	Paris	NNP
18637	8451	32	,	,	,
18637	8451	33	a	a	DT
18637	8451	34	course	course	NN
18637	8451	35	which	which	WDT
18637	8451	36	,	,	,
18637	8451	37	as	as	IN
18637	8451	38	Professor	Professor	NNP
18637	8451	39	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	8451	40	observes	observe	VBZ
18637	8451	41	,	,	,
18637	8451	42	"	"	``
18637	8451	43	would	would	MD
18637	8451	44	doubtless	doubtless	RB
18637	8451	45	go	go	VB
18637	8451	46	far	far	RB
18637	8451	47	toward	toward	IN
18637	8451	48	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	8451	49	these	these	DT
18637	8451	50	three	three	CD
18637	8451	51	principles	principle	NNS
18637	8451	52	as	as	IN
18637	8451	53	international	international	JJ
18637	8451	54	law	law	NN
18637	8451	55	obligatory	obligatory	NN
18637	8451	56	upon	upon	IN
18637	8451	57	the	the	DT
18637	8451	58	United	United	NNP
18637	8451	59	States	States	NNP
18637	8451	60	in	in	IN
18637	8451	61	future	future	JJ
18637	8451	62	wars	war	NNS
18637	8451	63	.	.	.
18637	8452	1	"	"	``
18637	8452	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8452	3	229	229	CD
18637	8452	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8452	5	Hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	8452	6	with	with	IN
18637	8452	7	Spain	Spain	NNP
18637	8452	8	were	be	VBD
18637	8452	9	brought	bring	VBN
18637	8452	10	to	to	IN
18637	8452	11	an	an	DT
18637	8452	12	end	end	NN
18637	8452	13	in	in	IN
18637	8452	14	August	August	NNP
18637	8452	15	1898	1898	CD
18637	8452	16	by	by	IN
18637	8452	17	an	an	DT
18637	8452	18	armistice	armistice	NN
18637	8452	19	the	the	DT
18637	8452	20	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	8452	21	of	of	IN
18637	8452	22	which	which	WDT
18637	8452	23	largely	largely	RB
18637	8452	24	determined	determine	VBD
18637	8452	25	the	the	DT
18637	8452	26	succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	8452	27	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8452	28	of	of	IN
18637	8452	29	peace,[230	peace,[230	NN
18637	8452	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8452	31	just	just	RB
18637	8452	32	as	as	IN
18637	8452	33	did	do	VBD
18637	8452	34	the	the	DT
18637	8452	35	Armistice	Armistice	NNP
18637	8452	36	of	of	IN
18637	8452	37	November	November	NNP
18637	8452	38	11	11	CD
18637	8452	39	,	,	,
18637	8452	40	1918	1918	CD
18637	8452	41	,	,	,
18637	8452	42	determine	determine	VBP
18637	8452	43	in	in	IN
18637	8452	44	great	great	JJ
18637	8452	45	measure	measure	NN
18637	8452	46	the	the	DT
18637	8452	47	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	8452	48	of	of	IN
18637	8452	49	the	the	DT
18637	8452	50	final	final	JJ
18637	8452	51	peace	peace	NN
18637	8452	52	with	with	IN
18637	8452	53	Germany	Germany	NNP
18637	8452	54	in	in	IN
18637	8452	55	1918	1918	CD
18637	8452	56	.	.	.
18637	8453	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8453	2	was	be	VBD
18637	8453	3	also	also	RB
18637	8453	4	President	President	NNP
18637	8453	5	McKinley	McKinley	NNP
18637	8453	6	who	who	WP
18637	8453	7	in	in	IN
18637	8453	8	1900	1900	CD
18637	8453	9	,	,	,
18637	8453	10	relying	rely	VBG
18637	8453	11	on	on	IN
18637	8453	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8453	13	own	own	JJ
18637	8453	14	sole	sole	JJ
18637	8453	15	authority	authority	NN
18637	8453	16	as	as	IN
18637	8453	17	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8453	18	in	in	IN
18637	8453	19	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8453	20	,	,	,
18637	8453	21	contributed	contribute	VBD
18637	8453	22	a	a	DT
18637	8453	23	land	land	NN
18637	8453	24	force	force	NN
18637	8453	25	of	of	IN
18637	8453	26	5,000	5,000	CD
18637	8453	27	men	man	NNS
18637	8453	28	and	and	CC
18637	8453	29	a	a	DT
18637	8453	30	naval	naval	JJ
18637	8453	31	force	force	NN
18637	8453	32	to	to	TO
18637	8453	33	cooperate	cooperate	VB
18637	8453	34	with	with	IN
18637	8453	35	similar	similar	JJ
18637	8453	36	contingents	contingent	NNS
18637	8453	37	from	from	IN
18637	8453	38	other	other	JJ
18637	8453	39	Powers	power	NNS
18637	8453	40	to	to	TO
18637	8453	41	rescue	rescue	VB
18637	8453	42	the	the	DT
18637	8453	43	legations	legation	NNS
18637	8453	44	in	in	IN
18637	8453	45	Peking	Peking	NNP
18637	8453	46	from	from	IN
18637	8453	47	the	the	DT
18637	8453	48	Boxers	Boxers	NNPS
18637	8453	49	;	;	:
18637	8453	50	and	and	CC
18637	8453	51	a	a	DT
18637	8453	52	year	year	NN
18637	8453	53	later	later	RB
18637	8453	54	,	,	,
18637	8453	55	again	again	RB
18637	8453	56	without	without	IN
18637	8453	57	consulting	consult	VBG
18637	8453	58	either	either	CC
18637	8453	59	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8453	60	or	or	CC
18637	8453	61	the	the	DT
18637	8453	62	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8453	63	,	,	,
18637	8453	64	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	8453	65	for	for	IN
18637	8453	66	the	the	DT
18637	8453	67	United	United	NNP
18637	8453	68	States	States	NNP
18637	8453	69	the	the	DT
18637	8453	70	Boxer	Boxer	NNP
18637	8453	71	Indemnity	Indemnity	NNP
18637	8453	72	Protocol	Protocol	NNP
18637	8453	73	between	between	IN
18637	8453	74	China	China	NNP
18637	8453	75	and	and	CC
18637	8453	76	the	the	DT
18637	8453	77	intervening	intervene	VBG
18637	8453	78	Powers	power	NNS
18637	8453	79	.	.	.
18637	8454	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8454	2	231	231	CD
18637	8454	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8454	4	Commenting	comment	VBG
18637	8454	5	on	on	IN
18637	8454	6	the	the	DT
18637	8454	7	Peking	Peking	NNP
18637	8454	8	protocol	protocol	NN
18637	8454	9	Willoughby	Willoughby	NNP
18637	8454	10	quotes	quote	VBZ
18637	8454	11	with	with	IN
18637	8454	12	approval	approval	NN
18637	8454	13	the	the	DT
18637	8454	14	following	following	JJ
18637	8454	15	remark	remark	NN
18637	8454	16	:	:	:
18637	8454	17	"	"	``
18637	8454	18	This	this	DT
18637	8454	19	case	case	NN
18637	8454	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	8454	21	interesting	interesting	JJ
18637	8454	22	,	,	,
18637	8454	23	because	because	IN
18637	8454	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8454	25	shows	show	VBZ
18637	8454	26	how	how	WRB
18637	8454	27	the	the	DT
18637	8454	28	force	force	NN
18637	8454	29	of	of	IN
18637	8454	30	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	8454	31	compelled	compel	VBD
18637	8454	32	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8454	33	to	to	TO
18637	8454	34	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	8454	35	the	the	DT
18637	8454	36	European	european	JJ
18637	8454	37	practice	practice	NN
18637	8454	38	with	with	IN
18637	8454	39	reference	reference	NN
18637	8454	40	to	to	IN
18637	8454	41	an	an	DT
18637	8454	42	international	international	JJ
18637	8454	43	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8454	44	,	,	,
18637	8454	45	which	which	WDT
18637	8454	46	,	,	,
18637	8454	47	aside	aside	RB
18637	8454	48	from	from	IN
18637	8454	49	the	the	DT
18637	8454	50	indemnity	indemnity	NN
18637	8454	51	question	question	NN
18637	8454	52	,	,	,
18637	8454	53	was	be	VBD
18637	8454	54	almost	almost	RB
18637	8454	55	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	8454	56	political	political	JJ
18637	8454	57	in	in	IN
18637	8454	58	character	character	NN
18637	8454	59	.	.	.
18637	8455	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8455	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8455	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8455	4	,	,	,
18637	8455	5	purely	purely	RB
18637	8455	6	political	political	JJ
18637	8455	7	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8455	8	are	be	VBP
18637	8455	9	,	,	,
18637	8455	10	under	under	IN
18637	8455	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8455	12	practice	practice	NN
18637	8455	13	in	in	IN
18637	8455	14	Europe	Europe	NNP
18637	8455	15	,	,	,
18637	8455	16	usually	usually	RB
18637	8455	17	made	make	VBN
18637	8455	18	by	by	IN
18637	8455	19	the	the	DT
18637	8455	20	executive	executive	NN
18637	8455	21	alone	alone	RB
18637	8455	22	.	.	.
18637	8456	1	The	the	DT
18637	8456	2	situation	situation	NN
18637	8456	3	in	in	IN
18637	8456	4	China	China	NNP
18637	8456	5	,	,	,
18637	8456	6	however	however	RB
18637	8456	7	,	,	,
18637	8456	8	abundantly	abundantly	RB
18637	8456	9	justified	justified	JJ
18637	8456	10	President	President	NNP
18637	8456	11	McKinley	McKinley	NNP
18637	8456	12	in	in	IN
18637	8456	13	not	not	RB
18637	8456	14	submitting	submit	VBG
18637	8456	15	the	the	DT
18637	8456	16	protocol	protocol	NN
18637	8456	17	to	to	IN
18637	8456	18	the	the	DT
18637	8456	19	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8456	20	.	.	.
18637	8457	1	The	the	DT
18637	8457	2	remoteness	remoteness	NN
18637	8457	3	of	of	IN
18637	8457	4	Pekin	Pekin	NNP
18637	8457	5	,	,	,
18637	8457	6	the	the	DT
18637	8457	7	jealousies	jealousy	NNS
18637	8457	8	between	between	IN
18637	8457	9	the	the	DT
18637	8457	10	allies	ally	NNS
18637	8457	11	,	,	,
18637	8457	12	and	and	CC
18637	8457	13	the	the	DT
18637	8457	14	shifting	shift	VBG
18637	8457	15	evasive	evasive	JJ
18637	8457	16	tactics	tactic	NNS
18637	8457	17	of	of	IN
18637	8457	18	the	the	DT
18637	8457	19	Chinese	Chinese	NNP
18637	8457	20	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8457	21	,	,	,
18637	8457	22	would	would	MD
18637	8457	23	have	have	VB
18637	8457	24	made	make	VBN
18637	8457	25	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	8457	26	anything	anything	NN
18637	8457	27	but	but	IN
18637	8457	28	an	an	DT
18637	8457	29	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8457	30	on	on	IN
18637	8457	31	the	the	DT
18637	8457	32	spot	spot	NN
18637	8457	33	.	.	.
18637	8458	1	"	"	``
18637	8458	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8458	3	232	232	CD
18637	8458	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8458	5	EXECUTIVE	executive	NN
18637	8458	6	AGREEMENTS	agreement	NNS
18637	8458	7	AFFECTING	affect	VBG
18637	8458	8	FAR	far	RB
18637	8458	9	EASTERN	EASTERN	NNS
18637	8458	10	RELATIONS	relations	VBP
18637	8458	11	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8458	12	was	be	VBD
18637	8458	13	during	during	IN
18637	8458	14	this	this	DT
18637	8458	15	period	period	NN
18637	8458	16	,	,	,
18637	8458	17	too	too	RB
18637	8458	18	,	,	,
18637	8458	19	that	that	IN
18637	8458	20	John	John	NNP
18637	8458	21	Hay	Hay	NNP
18637	8458	22	,	,	,
18637	8458	23	as	as	IN
18637	8458	24	McKinley	McKinley	NNP
18637	8458	25	's	's	POS
18637	8458	26	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8458	27	of	of	IN
18637	8458	28	State	State	NNP
18637	8458	29	,	,	,
18637	8458	30	initiated	initiate	VBD
18637	8458	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8458	32	"	"	``
18637	8458	33	Open	Open	NNP
18637	8458	34	Door	Door	NNP
18637	8458	35	"	"	''
18637	8458	36	policy	policy	NN
18637	8458	37	,	,	,
18637	8458	38	by	by	IN
18637	8458	39	notes	note	NNS
18637	8458	40	to	to	IN
18637	8458	41	Great	Great	NNP
18637	8458	42	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	8458	43	,	,	,
18637	8458	44	Germany	Germany	NNP
18637	8458	45	,	,	,
18637	8458	46	and	and	CC
18637	8458	47	Russia	Russia	NNP
18637	8458	48	,	,	,
18637	8458	49	which	which	WDT
18637	8458	50	were	be	VBD
18637	8458	51	soon	soon	RB
18637	8458	52	followed	follow	VBN
18637	8458	53	by	by	IN
18637	8458	54	similar	similar	JJ
18637	8458	55	notes	note	NNS
18637	8458	56	to	to	IN
18637	8458	57	France	France	NNP
18637	8458	58	,	,	,
18637	8458	59	Italy	Italy	NNP
18637	8458	60	and	and	CC
18637	8458	61	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	8458	62	.	.	.
18637	8459	1	These	these	DT
18637	8459	2	in	in	IN
18637	8459	3	substance	substance	NN
18637	8459	4	asked	ask	VBD
18637	8459	5	the	the	DT
18637	8459	6	recipients	recipient	NNS
18637	8459	7	to	to	TO
18637	8459	8	declare	declare	VB
18637	8459	9	formally	formally	RB
18637	8459	10	that	that	IN
18637	8459	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8459	12	would	would	MD
18637	8459	13	not	not	RB
18637	8459	14	seek	seek	VB
18637	8459	15	to	to	TO
18637	8459	16	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	8459	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8459	18	respective	respective	JJ
18637	8459	19	interests	interest	NNS
18637	8459	20	in	in	IN
18637	8459	21	China	China	NNP
18637	8459	22	at	at	IN
18637	8459	23	the	the	DT
18637	8459	24	expense	expense	NN
18637	8459	25	of	of	IN
18637	8459	26	any	any	DT
18637	8459	27	of	of	IN
18637	8459	28	the	the	DT
18637	8459	29	others	other	NNS
18637	8459	30	;	;	:
18637	8459	31	and	and	CC
18637	8459	32	all	all	DT
18637	8459	33	responded	respond	VBD
18637	8459	34	favorably	favorably	RB
18637	8459	35	.	.	.
18637	8460	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8460	2	233	233	CD
18637	8460	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8460	4	Then	then	RB
18637	8460	5	in	in	IN
18637	8460	6	1905	1905	CD
18637	8460	7	the	the	DT
18637	8460	8	first	first	JJ
18637	8460	9	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8460	10	,	,	,
18637	8460	11	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	8460	12	to	to	TO
18637	8460	13	arrive	arrive	VB
18637	8460	14	at	at	IN
18637	8460	15	a	a	DT
18637	8460	16	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8460	17	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	8460	18	with	with	IN
18637	8460	19	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	8460	20	,	,	,
18637	8460	21	instigated	instigate	VBD
18637	8460	22	an	an	DT
18637	8460	23	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	8460	24	of	of	IN
18637	8460	25	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	8460	26	between	between	IN
18637	8460	27	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8460	28	of	of	IN
18637	8460	29	War	War	NNP
18637	8460	30	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	8460	31	,	,	,
18637	8460	32	then	then	RB
18637	8460	33	in	in	IN
18637	8460	34	the	the	DT
18637	8460	35	Far	Far	NNP
18637	8460	36	East	East	NNP
18637	8460	37	,	,	,
18637	8460	38	and	and	CC
18637	8460	39	Count	Count	NNP
18637	8460	40	Katsura	Katsura	NNP
18637	8460	41	,	,	,
18637	8460	42	amounting	amount	VBG
18637	8460	43	to	to	IN
18637	8460	44	a	a	DT
18637	8460	45	secret	secret	JJ
18637	8460	46	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8460	47	,	,	,
18637	8460	48	by	by	IN
18637	8460	49	which	which	WDT
18637	8460	50	the	the	DT
18637	8460	51	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8460	52	administration	administration	NN
18637	8460	53	assented	assent	VBD
18637	8460	54	to	to	IN
18637	8460	55	the	the	DT
18637	8460	56	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	8460	57	by	by	IN
18637	8460	58	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	8460	59	of	of	IN
18637	8460	60	a	a	DT
18637	8460	61	military	military	JJ
18637	8460	62	protectorate	protectorate	NN
18637	8460	63	in	in	IN
18637	8460	64	Korea	Korea	NNP
18637	8460	65	.	.	.
18637	8461	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8461	2	234	234	CD
18637	8461	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8461	4	Three	three	CD
18637	8461	5	years	year	NNS
18637	8461	6	later	later	RB
18637	8461	7	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8461	8	of	of	IN
18637	8461	9	State	State	NNP
18637	8461	10	Root	Root	NNP
18637	8461	11	and	and	CC
18637	8461	12	the	the	DT
18637	8461	13	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	8461	14	ambassador	ambassador	NN
18637	8461	15	at	at	IN
18637	8461	16	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	8461	17	entered	enter	VBD
18637	8461	18	into	into	IN
18637	8461	19	the	the	DT
18637	8461	20	Root	Root	NNP
18637	8461	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	8461	22	Takahira	Takahira	NNP
18637	8461	23	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	8461	24	to	to	TO
18637	8461	25	uphold	uphold	VB
18637	8461	26	the	the	DT
18637	8461	27	status	status	NN
18637	8461	28	quo	quo	FW
18637	8461	29	in	in	IN
18637	8461	30	the	the	DT
18637	8461	31	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	8461	32	and	and	CC
18637	8461	33	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	8461	34	the	the	DT
18637	8461	35	principle	principle	NN
18637	8461	36	of	of	IN
18637	8461	37	equal	equal	JJ
18637	8461	38	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	8461	39	for	for	IN
18637	8461	40	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	8461	41	and	and	CC
18637	8461	42	industry	industry	NN
18637	8461	43	in	in	IN
18637	8461	44	China	China	NNP
18637	8461	45	.	.	.
18637	8462	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8462	2	235	235	CD
18637	8462	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8462	4	Meantime	meantime	RB
18637	8462	5	,	,	,
18637	8462	6	in	in	IN
18637	8462	7	1907	1907	CD
18637	8462	8	,	,	,
18637	8462	9	by	by	IN
18637	8462	10	a	a	DT
18637	8462	11	"	"	``
18637	8462	12	Gentlemen	Gentlemen	NNP
18637	8462	13	's	's	POS
18637	8462	14	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	8462	15	,	,	,
18637	8462	16	"	"	''
18637	8462	17	the	the	DT
18637	8462	18	Mikado	Mikado	NNP
18637	8462	19	's	's	POS
18637	8462	20	government	government	NN
18637	8462	21	had	have	VBD
18637	8462	22	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	8462	23	to	to	TO
18637	8462	24	curb	curb	VB
18637	8462	25	the	the	DT
18637	8462	26	emigration	emigration	NN
18637	8462	27	of	of	IN
18637	8462	28	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	8462	29	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	8462	30	to	to	IN
18637	8462	31	the	the	DT
18637	8462	32	United	United	NNP
18637	8462	33	States	States	NNP
18637	8462	34	,	,	,
18637	8462	35	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	8462	36	relieving	relieve	VBG
18637	8462	37	the	the	DT
18637	8462	38	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	8462	39	government	government	NN
18637	8462	40	from	from	IN
18637	8462	41	the	the	DT
18637	8462	42	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	8462	43	of	of	IN
18637	8462	44	taking	take	VBG
18637	8462	45	action	action	NN
18637	8462	46	that	that	WDT
18637	8462	47	would	would	MD
18637	8462	48	have	have	VB
18637	8462	49	cost	cost	VBN
18637	8462	50	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	8462	51	loss	loss	NN
18637	8462	52	of	of	IN
18637	8462	53	face	face	NN
18637	8462	54	.	.	.
18637	8463	1	The	the	DT
18637	8463	2	final	final	JJ
18637	8463	3	of	of	IN
18637	8463	4	this	this	DT
18637	8463	5	series	series	NN
18637	8463	6	of	of	IN
18637	8463	7	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8463	8	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8463	9	touching	touch	VBG
18637	8463	10	American	american	JJ
18637	8463	11	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8463	12	in	in	IN
18637	8463	13	and	and	CC
18637	8463	14	with	with	IN
18637	8463	15	the	the	DT
18637	8463	16	Far	Far	NNP
18637	8463	17	East	East	NNP
18637	8463	18	was	be	VBD
18637	8463	19	the	the	DT
18637	8463	20	product	product	NN
18637	8463	21	of	of	IN
18637	8463	22	President	President	NNP
18637	8463	23	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	8463	24	's	's	POS
18637	8463	25	diplomacy	diplomacy	NN
18637	8463	26	.	.	.
18637	8464	1	This	this	DT
18637	8464	2	was	be	VBD
18637	8464	3	the	the	DT
18637	8464	4	Lansing	Lansing	NNP
18637	8464	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	8464	6	Ishii	Ishii	NNP
18637	8464	7	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	8464	8	,	,	,
18637	8464	9	embodied	embody	VBD
18637	8464	10	in	in	IN
18637	8464	11	an	an	DT
18637	8464	12	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	8464	13	of	of	IN
18637	8464	14	letters	letter	NNS
18637	8464	15	dated	date	VBN
18637	8464	16	November	November	NNP
18637	8464	17	2	2	CD
18637	8464	18	,	,	,
18637	8464	19	1917	1917	CD
18637	8464	20	,	,	,
18637	8464	21	by	by	IN
18637	8464	22	which	which	WDT
18637	8464	23	the	the	DT
18637	8464	24	United	United	NNP
18637	8464	25	States	States	NNP
18637	8464	26	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	8464	27	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	8464	28	's	's	POS
18637	8464	29	"	"	``
18637	8464	30	special	special	JJ
18637	8464	31	interests	interest	NNS
18637	8464	32	"	"	''
18637	8464	33	in	in	IN
18637	8464	34	China	China	NNP
18637	8464	35	,	,	,
18637	8464	36	and	and	CC
18637	8464	37	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	8464	38	assented	assent	VBD
18637	8464	39	to	to	IN
18637	8464	40	the	the	DT
18637	8464	41	principle	principle	NN
18637	8464	42	of	of	IN
18637	8464	43	the	the	DT
18637	8464	44	Open	Open	NNP
18637	8464	45	Door	Door	NNP
18637	8464	46	in	in	IN
18637	8464	47	that	that	DT
18637	8464	48	country	country	NN
18637	8464	49	.	.	.
18637	8465	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8465	2	236	236	CD
18637	8465	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8465	4	THE	the	DT
18637	8465	5	INTERNATIONAL	INTERNATIONAL	NNP
18637	8465	6	OBLIGATION	obligation	NN
18637	8465	7	OF	of	IN
18637	8465	8	EXECUTIVE	executive	NN
18637	8465	9	AGREEMENTS	AGREEMENTS	NNP
18637	8465	10	The	the	DT
18637	8465	11	question	question	NN
18637	8465	12	naturally	naturally	RB
18637	8465	13	suggests	suggest	VBZ
18637	8465	14	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8465	15	:	:	:
18637	8465	16	What	what	WDT
18637	8465	17	sort	sort	NN
18637	8465	18	of	of	IN
18637	8465	19	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8465	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	8465	21	an	an	DT
18637	8465	22	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8465	23	of	of	IN
18637	8465	24	the	the	DT
18637	8465	25	above	above	JJ
18637	8465	26	description	description	NN
18637	8465	27	impose	impose	VBP
18637	8465	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	8465	29	the	the	DT
18637	8465	30	United	United	NNP
18637	8465	31	States	States	NNP
18637	8465	32	?	?	.
18637	8466	1	The	the	DT
18637	8466	2	question	question	NN
18637	8466	3	was	be	VBD
18637	8466	4	put	put	VBN
18637	8466	5	to	to	IN
18637	8466	6	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8466	7	Lansing	Lansing	NNP
18637	8466	8	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8466	9	in	in	IN
18637	8466	10	1918	1918	CD
18637	8466	11	by	by	IN
18637	8466	12	a	a	DT
18637	8466	13	member	member	NN
18637	8466	14	of	of	IN
18637	8466	15	the	the	DT
18637	8466	16	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	8466	17	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	8466	18	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	8466	19	,	,	,
18637	8466	20	as	as	IN
18637	8466	21	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	8466	22	:	:	:
18637	8466	23	"	"	``
18637	8466	24	Has	have	VBZ
18637	8466	25	the	the	DT
18637	8466	26	so	so	RB
18637	8466	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	8466	28	called	call	VBN
18637	8466	29	Lansing	Lansing	NNP
18637	8466	30	-	-	HYPH
18637	8466	31	Ishii	Ishii	NNP
18637	8466	32	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	8466	33	any	any	DT
18637	8466	34	binding	bind	VBG
18637	8466	35	force	force	NN
18637	8466	36	on	on	IN
18637	8466	37	this	this	DT
18637	8466	38	country	country	NN
18637	8466	39	?	?	.
18637	8466	40	"	"	''
18637	8467	1	and	and	CC
18637	8467	2	replied	reply	VBD
18637	8467	3	that	that	IN
18637	8467	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8467	5	had	have	VBD
18637	8467	6	not	not	RB
18637	8467	7	;	;	:
18637	8467	8	that	that	IN
18637	8467	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8467	10	was	be	VBD
18637	8467	11	simply	simply	RB
18637	8467	12	a	a	DT
18637	8467	13	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	8467	14	of	of	IN
18637	8467	15	American	american	JJ
18637	8467	16	policy	policy	NN
18637	8467	17	so	so	RB
18637	8467	18	long	long	RB
18637	8467	19	as	as	IN
18637	8467	20	the	the	DT
18637	8467	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8467	22	or	or	CC
18637	8467	23	State	State	NNP
18637	8467	24	Department	Department	NNP
18637	8467	25	might	may	MD
18637	8467	26	choose	choose	VB
18637	8467	27	to	to	TO
18637	8467	28	continue	continue	VB
18637	8467	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8467	30	.	.	.
18637	8468	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8468	2	237	237	CD
18637	8468	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8468	4	Actually	actually	RB
18637	8468	5	,	,	,
18637	8468	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8468	7	took	take	VBD
18637	8468	8	the	the	DT
18637	8468	9	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	8468	10	Conference	Conference	NNP
18637	8468	11	of	of	IN
18637	8468	12	1921	1921	CD
18637	8468	13	,	,	,
18637	8468	14	two	two	CD
18637	8468	15	solemn	solemn	JJ
18637	8468	16	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8468	17	and	and	CC
18637	8468	18	an	an	DT
18637	8468	19	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	8468	20	of	of	IN
18637	8468	21	notes	note	NNS
18637	8468	22	to	to	TO
18637	8468	23	get	get	VB
18637	8468	24	rid	rid	VBN
18637	8468	25	of	of	IN
18637	8468	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8468	27	;	;	:
18637	8468	28	while	while	IN
18637	8468	29	the	the	DT
18637	8468	30	"	"	``
18637	8468	31	Gentlemen	Gentlemen	NNP
18637	8468	32	's	's	POS
18637	8468	33	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	8468	34	,	,	,
18637	8468	35	"	"	''
18637	8468	36	first	first	RB
18637	8468	37	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	8468	38	in	in	IN
18637	8468	39	1907	1907	CD
18637	8468	40	,	,	,
18637	8468	41	was	be	VBD
18637	8468	42	finally	finally	RB
18637	8468	43	put	put	VBN
18637	8468	44	an	an	DT
18637	8468	45	end	end	NN
18637	8468	46	to	to	IN
18637	8468	47	,	,	,
18637	8468	48	after	after	IN
18637	8468	49	seventeen	seventeen	CD
18637	8468	50	years	year	NNS
18637	8468	51	,	,	,
18637	8468	52	only	only	RB
18637	8468	53	by	by	IN
18637	8468	54	an	an	DT
18637	8468	55	act	act	NN
18637	8468	56	of	of	IN
18637	8468	57	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8468	58	.	.	.
18637	8469	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8469	2	238	238	CD
18637	8469	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8469	4	That	that	IN
18637	8469	5	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8469	6	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8469	7	are	be	VBP
18637	8469	8	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	8469	9	cognizable	cognizable	JJ
18637	8469	10	by	by	IN
18637	8469	11	the	the	DT
18637	8469	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	8469	13	was	be	VBD
18637	8469	14	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	8469	15	earlier	early	RBR
18637	8469	16	.	.	.
18637	8470	1	The	the	DT
18637	8470	2	matter	matter	NN
18637	8470	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8470	4	further	further	RB
18637	8470	5	treated	treat	VBN
18637	8470	6	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	8470	7	below	below	RB
18637	8470	8	.	.	.
18637	8471	1	THE	the	DT
18637	8471	2	LITVINOV	LITVINOV	NNP
18637	8471	3	AGREEMENT	AGREEMENT	NNP
18637	8471	4	OF	of	IN
18637	8471	5	1933	1933	CD
18637	8471	6	The	the	DT
18637	8471	7	executive	executive	NN
18637	8471	8	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8471	9	attained	attain	VBD
18637	8471	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8471	11	fullest	full	JJS
18637	8471	12	development	development	NN
18637	8471	13	as	as	IN
18637	8471	14	an	an	DT
18637	8471	15	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	8471	16	of	of	IN
18637	8471	17	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8471	18	policy	policy	NN
18637	8471	19	under	under	IN
18637	8471	20	President	President	NNP
18637	8471	21	Franklin	Franklin	NNP
18637	8471	22	D.	D.	NNP
18637	8471	23	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8471	24	,	,	,
18637	8471	25	even	even	RB
18637	8471	26	at	at	IN
18637	8471	27	times	time	NNS
18637	8471	28	threatening	threaten	VBG
18637	8471	29	to	to	TO
18637	8471	30	replace	replace	VB
18637	8471	31	the	the	DT
18637	8471	32	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8471	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	8471	34	making	make	VBG
18637	8471	35	power	power	NN
18637	8471	36	,	,	,
18637	8471	37	if	if	IN
18637	8471	38	not	not	RB
18637	8471	39	formally	formally	RB
18637	8471	40	yet	yet	RB
18637	8471	41	actually	actually	RB
18637	8471	42	,	,	,
18637	8471	43	as	as	IN
18637	8471	44	a	a	DT
18637	8471	45	determinative	determinative	JJ
18637	8471	46	element	element	NN
18637	8471	47	in	in	IN
18637	8471	48	the	the	DT
18637	8471	49	field	field	NN
18637	8471	50	of	of	IN
18637	8471	51	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8471	52	policy	policy	NN
18637	8471	53	.	.	.
18637	8472	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	8472	2	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8472	3	's	's	POS
18637	8472	4	first	first	JJ
18637	8472	5	important	important	JJ
18637	8472	6	utilization	utilization	NN
18637	8472	7	of	of	IN
18637	8472	8	the	the	DT
18637	8472	9	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8472	10	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8472	11	device	device	NN
18637	8472	12	took	take	VBD
18637	8472	13	the	the	DT
18637	8472	14	form	form	NN
18637	8472	15	of	of	IN
18637	8472	16	an	an	DT
18637	8472	17	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	8472	18	of	of	IN
18637	8472	19	notes	note	NNS
18637	8472	20	on	on	IN
18637	8472	21	November	November	NNP
18637	8472	22	16	16	CD
18637	8472	23	,	,	,
18637	8472	24	1933	1933	CD
18637	8472	25	with	with	IN
18637	8472	26	Maxim	Maxim	NNP
18637	8472	27	M.	M.	NNP
18637	8472	28	Litvinov	Litvinov	NNP
18637	8472	29	,	,	,
18637	8472	30	People	People	NNPS
18637	8472	31	's	's	POS
18637	8472	32	Commissar	Commissar	NNP
18637	8472	33	for	for	IN
18637	8472	34	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	8472	35	Affairs	Affairs	NNPS
18637	8472	36	,	,	,
18637	8472	37	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	8472	38	American	american	JJ
18637	8472	39	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8472	40	was	be	VBD
18637	8472	41	extended	extend	VBN
18637	8472	42	to	to	IN
18637	8472	43	the	the	DT
18637	8472	44	Union	Union	NNP
18637	8472	45	of	of	IN
18637	8472	46	Soviet	Soviet	NNP
18637	8472	47	Socialist	Socialist	NNP
18637	8472	48	Republics	Republics	NNP
18637	8472	49	in	in	IN
18637	8472	50	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	8472	51	of	of	IN
18637	8472	52	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8472	53	pledges	pledge	NNS
18637	8472	54	,	,	,
18637	8472	55	the	the	DT
18637	8472	56	first	first	JJ
18637	8472	57	of	of	IN
18637	8472	58	which	which	WDT
18637	8472	59	was	be	VBD
18637	8472	60	the	the	DT
18637	8472	61	promise	promise	NN
18637	8472	62	to	to	TO
18637	8472	63	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	8472	64	any	any	DT
18637	8472	65	persons	person	NNS
18637	8472	66	or	or	CC
18637	8472	67	organizations	organization	NNS
18637	8472	68	"	"	''
18637	8472	69	under	under	IN
18637	8472	70	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8472	71	direct	direct	JJ
18637	8472	72	or	or	CC
18637	8472	73	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	8472	74	control	control	NN
18637	8472	75	,	,	,
18637	8472	76	*	*	NFP
18637	8472	77	*	*	NFP
18637	8472	78	*	*	NFP
18637	8472	79	,	,	,
18637	8472	80	from	from	IN
18637	8472	81	any	any	DT
18637	8472	82	act	act	NN
18637	8472	83	overt	overt	JJ
18637	8472	84	or	or	CC
18637	8472	85	covert	covert	JJ
18637	8472	86	liable	liable	JJ
18637	8472	87	in	in	IN
18637	8472	88	any	any	DT
18637	8472	89	way	way	NN
18637	8472	90	whatsoever	whatsoever	RB
18637	8472	91	to	to	TO
18637	8472	92	injure	injure	VB
18637	8472	93	the	the	DT
18637	8472	94	tranquillity	tranquillity	NN
18637	8472	95	,	,	,
18637	8472	96	prosperity	prosperity	NN
18637	8472	97	,	,	,
18637	8472	98	order	order	NN
18637	8472	99	,	,	,
18637	8472	100	or	or	CC
18637	8472	101	security	security	NN
18637	8472	102	of	of	IN
18637	8472	103	the	the	DT
18637	8472	104	whole	whole	NN
18637	8472	105	or	or	CC
18637	8472	106	any	any	DT
18637	8472	107	part	part	NN
18637	8472	108	of	of	IN
18637	8472	109	the	the	DT
18637	8472	110	United	United	NNP
18637	8472	111	States	States	NNP
18637	8472	112	,	,	,
18637	8472	113	*	*	NFP
18637	8472	114	*	*	NFP
18637	8472	115	*	*	NFP
18637	8472	116	"	"	''
18637	8472	117	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8472	118	239	239	CD
18637	8472	119	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8472	120	United	United	NNP
18637	8472	121	States	States	NNP
18637	8472	122	_	_	NNP
18637	8472	123	v.	v.	IN
18637	8472	124	_	_	NNP
18637	8472	125	Belmont	Belmont	NNP
18637	8472	126	The	the	DT
18637	8472	127	Litvinov	Litvinov	NNP
18637	8472	128	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	8472	129	is	be	VBZ
18637	8472	130	also	also	RB
18637	8472	131	noteworthy	noteworthy	JJ
18637	8472	132	for	for	IN
18637	8472	133	giving	give	VBG
18637	8472	134	rise	rise	NN
18637	8472	135	to	to	IN
18637	8472	136	two	two	CD
18637	8472	137	cases	case	NNS
18637	8472	138	which	which	WDT
18637	8472	139	afforded	afford	VBD
18637	8472	140	the	the	DT
18637	8472	141	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8472	142	the	the	DT
18637	8472	143	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	8472	144	to	to	TO
18637	8472	145	evaluate	evaluate	VB
18637	8472	146	the	the	DT
18637	8472	147	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8472	148	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8472	149	in	in	IN
18637	8472	150	terms	term	NNS
18637	8472	151	of	of	IN
18637	8472	152	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	8472	153	Law	Law	NNP
18637	8472	154	.	.	.
18637	8473	1	The	the	DT
18637	8473	2	earlier	early	JJR
18637	8473	3	of	of	IN
18637	8473	4	these	these	DT
18637	8473	5	was	be	VBD
18637	8473	6	United	United	NNP
18637	8473	7	States	States	NNP
18637	8473	8	_	_	NNP
18637	8473	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	8473	10	_	_	NNP
18637	8473	11	Belmont,[240	Belmont,[240	NNP
18637	8473	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8473	13	decided	decide	VBD
18637	8473	14	in	in	IN
18637	8473	15	1937	1937	CD
18637	8473	16	.	.	.
18637	8474	1	The	the	DT
18637	8474	2	point	point	NN
18637	8474	3	at	at	IN
18637	8474	4	issue	issue	NN
18637	8474	5	was	be	VBD
18637	8474	6	whether	whether	IN
18637	8474	7	a	a	DT
18637	8474	8	district	district	NN
18637	8474	9	court	court	NN
18637	8474	10	of	of	IN
18637	8474	11	the	the	DT
18637	8474	12	United	United	NNP
18637	8474	13	States	States	NNP
18637	8474	14	was	be	VBD
18637	8474	15	free	free	JJ
18637	8474	16	to	to	TO
18637	8474	17	dismiss	dismiss	VB
18637	8474	18	an	an	DT
18637	8474	19	action	action	NN
18637	8474	20	by	by	IN
18637	8474	21	the	the	DT
18637	8474	22	United	United	NNP
18637	8474	23	States	States	NNP
18637	8474	24	,	,	,
18637	8474	25	as	as	IN
18637	8474	26	assignee	assignee	NN
18637	8474	27	of	of	IN
18637	8474	28	the	the	DT
18637	8474	29	Soviet	soviet	JJ
18637	8474	30	government	government	NN
18637	8474	31	,	,	,
18637	8474	32	for	for	IN
18637	8474	33	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8474	34	moneys	money	NNS
18637	8474	35	which	which	WDT
18637	8474	36	were	be	VBD
18637	8474	37	once	once	RB
18637	8474	38	the	the	DT
18637	8474	39	property	property	NN
18637	8474	40	of	of	IN
18637	8474	41	a	a	DT
18637	8474	42	Russian	russian	JJ
18637	8474	43	metal	metal	NN
18637	8474	44	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	8474	45	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8474	46	assets	asset	NNS
18637	8474	47	had	have	VBD
18637	8474	48	been	be	VBN
18637	8474	49	appropriated	appropriate	VBN
18637	8474	50	by	by	IN
18637	8474	51	the	the	DT
18637	8474	52	Soviet	soviet	JJ
18637	8474	53	government	government	NN
18637	8474	54	.	.	.
18637	8475	1	The	the	DT
18637	8475	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8475	3	,	,	,
18637	8475	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8475	5	by	by	IN
18637	8475	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8475	7	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	8475	8	,	,	,
18637	8475	9	said	say	VBD
18637	8475	10	"	"	``
18637	8475	11	No	no	UH
18637	8475	12	.	.	.
18637	8475	13	"	"	''
18637	8476	1	The	the	DT
18637	8476	2	President	President	NNP
18637	8476	3	's	's	POS
18637	8476	4	act	act	NN
18637	8476	5	in	in	IN
18637	8476	6	recognizing	recognize	VBG
18637	8476	7	the	the	DT
18637	8476	8	Soviet	soviet	JJ
18637	8476	9	government	government	NN
18637	8476	10	,	,	,
18637	8476	11	and	and	CC
18637	8476	12	the	the	DT
18637	8476	13	accompanying	accompany	VBG
18637	8476	14	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8476	15	,	,	,
18637	8476	16	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	8476	17	,	,	,
18637	8476	18	said	say	VBD
18637	8476	19	the	the	DT
18637	8476	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8476	21	,	,	,
18637	8476	22	an	an	DT
18637	8476	23	international	international	JJ
18637	8476	24	compact	compact	NN
18637	8476	25	which	which	WDT
18637	8476	26	the	the	DT
18637	8476	27	President	President	NNP
18637	8476	28	,	,	,
18637	8476	29	"	"	''
18637	8476	30	as	as	IN
18637	8476	31	the	the	DT
18637	8476	32	sole	sole	JJ
18637	8476	33	organ	organ	NN
18637	8476	34	"	"	''
18637	8476	35	of	of	IN
18637	8476	36	international	international	JJ
18637	8476	37	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8476	38	for	for	IN
18637	8476	39	the	the	DT
18637	8476	40	United	United	NNP
18637	8476	41	States	States	NNP
18637	8476	42	,	,	,
18637	8476	43	was	be	VBD
18637	8476	44	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8476	45	to	to	TO
18637	8476	46	enter	enter	VB
18637	8476	47	upon	upon	IN
18637	8476	48	without	without	IN
18637	8476	49	consulting	consult	VBG
18637	8476	50	the	the	DT
18637	8476	51	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8476	52	.	.	.
18637	8477	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	8477	2	did	do	VBD
18637	8477	3	State	state	NN
18637	8477	4	laws	law	NNS
18637	8477	5	and	and	CC
18637	8477	6	policies	policy	NNS
18637	8477	7	make	make	VBP
18637	8477	8	any	any	DT
18637	8477	9	difference	difference	NN
18637	8477	10	in	in	IN
18637	8477	11	such	such	PDT
18637	8477	12	a	a	DT
18637	8477	13	situation	situation	NN
18637	8477	14	;	;	:
18637	8477	15	for	for	CC
18637	8477	16	while	while	IN
18637	8477	17	the	the	DT
18637	8477	18	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	8477	19	of	of	IN
18637	8477	20	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8477	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	8477	22	established	establish	VBN
18637	8477	23	by	by	IN
18637	8477	24	the	the	DT
18637	8477	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8477	26	in	in	IN
18637	8477	27	express	express	JJ
18637	8477	28	terms	term	NNS
18637	8477	29	,	,	,
18637	8477	30	yet	yet	CC
18637	8477	31	the	the	DT
18637	8477	32	same	same	JJ
18637	8477	33	rule	rule	NN
18637	8477	34	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	8477	35	"	"	``
18637	8477	36	in	in	IN
18637	8477	37	the	the	DT
18637	8477	38	case	case	NN
18637	8477	39	of	of	IN
18637	8477	40	all	all	DT
18637	8477	41	international	international	JJ
18637	8477	42	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	8477	43	and	and	CC
18637	8477	44	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8477	45	from	from	IN
18637	8477	46	the	the	DT
18637	8477	47	very	very	JJ
18637	8477	48	fact	fact	NN
18637	8477	49	that	that	IN
18637	8477	50	complete	complete	JJ
18637	8477	51	power	power	NN
18637	8477	52	over	over	IN
18637	8477	53	international	international	JJ
18637	8477	54	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	8477	55	is	be	VBZ
18637	8477	56	in	in	IN
18637	8477	57	the	the	DT
18637	8477	58	National	National	NNP
18637	8477	59	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8477	60	and	and	CC
18637	8477	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	8477	62	not	not	RB
18637	8477	63	and	and	CC
18637	8477	64	can	can	MD
18637	8477	65	not	not	RB
18637	8477	66	be	be	VB
18637	8477	67	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8477	68	to	to	IN
18637	8477	69	any	any	DT
18637	8477	70	curtailment	curtailment	NN
18637	8477	71	or	or	CC
18637	8477	72	interference	interference	NN
18637	8477	73	on	on	IN
18637	8477	74	the	the	DT
18637	8477	75	part	part	NN
18637	8477	76	of	of	IN
18637	8477	77	the	the	DT
18637	8477	78	several	several	JJ
18637	8477	79	States	state	NNS
18637	8477	80	.	.	.
18637	8478	1	"	"	``
18637	8478	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8478	3	241	241	CD
18637	8478	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8478	5	United	United	NNP
18637	8478	6	States	States	NNP
18637	8478	7	_	_	NNP
18637	8478	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	8478	9	_	_	NNP
18637	8478	10	Pink	Pink	NNP
18637	8478	11	;	;	:
18637	8478	12	National	National	NNP
18637	8478	13	Supremacy	Supremacy	NNP
18637	8478	14	In	in	IN
18637	8478	15	the	the	DT
18637	8478	16	United	United	NNP
18637	8478	17	States	States	NNP
18637	8478	18	_	_	NNP
18637	8478	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	8478	20	_	_	NNP
18637	8478	21	Pink,[242	Pink,[242	NNP
18637	8478	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8478	23	decided	decide	VBD
18637	8478	24	five	five	CD
18637	8478	25	years	year	NNS
18637	8478	26	later	later	RB
18637	8478	27	,	,	,
18637	8478	28	the	the	DT
18637	8478	29	same	same	JJ
18637	8478	30	course	course	NN
18637	8478	31	of	of	IN
18637	8478	32	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	8478	33	was	be	VBD
18637	8478	34	reiterated	reiterate	VBN
18637	8478	35	with	with	IN
18637	8478	36	added	add	VBN
18637	8478	37	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	8478	38	.	.	.
18637	8479	1	The	the	DT
18637	8479	2	question	question	NN
18637	8479	3	here	here	RB
18637	8479	4	involved	involve	VBN
18637	8479	5	was	be	VBD
18637	8479	6	whether	whether	IN
18637	8479	7	the	the	DT
18637	8479	8	United	United	NNP
18637	8479	9	States	States	NNP
18637	8479	10	was	be	VBD
18637	8479	11	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	8479	12	under	under	IN
18637	8479	13	the	the	DT
18637	8479	14	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8479	15	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	8479	16	of	of	IN
18637	8479	17	1933	1933	CD
18637	8479	18	to	to	TO
18637	8479	19	recover	recover	VB
18637	8479	20	the	the	DT
18637	8479	21	assets	asset	NNS
18637	8479	22	of	of	IN
18637	8479	23	the	the	DT
18637	8479	24	New	New	NNP
18637	8479	25	York	York	NNP
18637	8479	26	branch	branch	NN
18637	8479	27	of	of	IN
18637	8479	28	a	a	DT
18637	8479	29	Russian	russian	JJ
18637	8479	30	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	8479	31	company	company	NN
18637	8479	32	.	.	.
18637	8480	1	The	the	DT
18637	8480	2	company	company	NN
18637	8480	3	argued	argue	VBD
18637	8480	4	that	that	IN
18637	8480	5	the	the	DT
18637	8480	6	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	8480	7	of	of	IN
18637	8480	8	confiscation	confiscation	NN
18637	8480	9	of	of	IN
18637	8480	10	the	the	DT
18637	8480	11	Soviet	Soviet	NNP
18637	8480	12	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8480	13	did	do	VBD
18637	8480	14	not	not	RB
18637	8480	15	apply	apply	VB
18637	8480	16	to	to	IN
18637	8480	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8480	18	property	property	NN
18637	8480	19	in	in	IN
18637	8480	20	New	New	NNP
18637	8480	21	York	York	NNP
18637	8480	22	,	,	,
18637	8480	23	and	and	CC
18637	8480	24	could	could	MD
18637	8480	25	not	not	RB
18637	8480	26	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	8480	27	with	with	IN
18637	8480	28	the	the	DT
18637	8480	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8480	30	of	of	IN
18637	8480	31	the	the	DT
18637	8480	32	United	United	NNP
18637	8480	33	States	States	NNP
18637	8480	34	and	and	CC
18637	8480	35	that	that	IN
18637	8480	36	of	of	IN
18637	8480	37	New	New	NNP
18637	8480	38	York	York	NNP
18637	8480	39	.	.	.
18637	8481	1	The	the	DT
18637	8481	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8481	3	,	,	,
18637	8481	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8481	5	by	by	IN
18637	8481	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8481	7	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	8481	8	,	,	,
18637	8481	9	brushed	brush	VBD
18637	8481	10	these	these	DT
18637	8481	11	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	8481	12	aside	aside	RB
18637	8481	13	.	.	.
18637	8482	1	An	an	DT
18637	8482	2	official	official	JJ
18637	8482	3	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	8482	4	of	of	IN
18637	8482	5	the	the	DT
18637	8482	6	Russian	russian	JJ
18637	8482	7	government	government	NN
18637	8482	8	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8482	9	settled	settle	VBD
18637	8482	10	the	the	DT
18637	8482	11	question	question	NN
18637	8482	12	of	of	IN
18637	8482	13	the	the	DT
18637	8482	14	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	JJ
18637	8482	15	operation	operation	NN
18637	8482	16	of	of	IN
18637	8482	17	the	the	DT
18637	8482	18	Russian	russian	JJ
18637	8482	19	decree	decree	NN
18637	8482	20	of	of	IN
18637	8482	21	nationalization	nationalization	NN
18637	8482	22	and	and	CC
18637	8482	23	was	be	VBD
18637	8482	24	binding	bind	VBG
18637	8482	25	on	on	IN
18637	8482	26	American	american	JJ
18637	8482	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	8482	28	.	.	.
18637	8483	1	The	the	DT
18637	8483	2	power	power	NN
18637	8483	3	to	to	TO
18637	8483	4	remove	remove	VB
18637	8483	5	such	such	JJ
18637	8483	6	obstacles	obstacle	NNS
18637	8483	7	to	to	IN
18637	8483	8	full	full	JJ
18637	8483	9	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8483	10	as	as	IN
18637	8483	11	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	8483	12	of	of	IN
18637	8483	13	claims	claim	NNS
18637	8483	14	of	of	IN
18637	8483	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8483	16	nationals	national	NNS
18637	8483	17	was	be	VBD
18637	8483	18	"	"	``
18637	8483	19	a	a	DT
18637	8483	20	modest	modest	JJ
18637	8483	21	implied	imply	VBN
18637	8483	22	power	power	NN
18637	8483	23	of	of	IN
18637	8483	24	the	the	DT
18637	8483	25	President	President	NNP
18637	8483	26	who	who	WP
18637	8483	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	8483	28	the	the	DT
18637	8483	29	'	'	``
18637	8483	30	sole	sole	JJ
18637	8483	31	organ	organ	NN
18637	8483	32	of	of	IN
18637	8483	33	the	the	DT
18637	8483	34	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8483	35	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8483	36	in	in	IN
18637	8483	37	the	the	DT
18637	8483	38	field	field	NN
18637	8483	39	of	of	IN
18637	8483	40	international	international	JJ
18637	8483	41	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8483	42	'	'	POS
18637	8483	43	*	*	NFP
18637	8483	44	*	*	NFP
18637	8483	45	*	*	NFP
18637	8483	46	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8483	47	was	be	VBD
18637	8483	48	the	the	DT
18637	8483	49	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8483	50	of	of	IN
18637	8483	51	the	the	DT
18637	8483	52	political	political	JJ
18637	8483	53	department	department	NN
18637	8483	54	that	that	WDT
18637	8483	55	full	full	JJ
18637	8483	56	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8483	57	of	of	IN
18637	8483	58	the	the	DT
18637	8483	59	Soviet	Soviet	NNP
18637	8483	60	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8483	61	required	require	VBD
18637	8483	62	the	the	DT
18637	8483	63	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	8483	64	of	of	IN
18637	8483	65	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	8483	66	problems	problem	NNS
18637	8483	67	including	include	VBG
18637	8483	68	the	the	DT
18637	8483	69	claims	claim	NNS
18637	8483	70	of	of	IN
18637	8483	71	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8483	72	nationals	national	NNS
18637	8483	73	.	.	.
18637	8484	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8484	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8484	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8484	4	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8484	5	would	would	MD
18637	8484	6	usurp	usurp	VB
18637	8484	7	the	the	DT
18637	8484	8	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8484	9	function	function	NN
18637	8484	10	if	if	IN
18637	8484	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8484	12	held	hold	VBD
18637	8484	13	that	that	IN
18637	8484	14	that	that	DT
18637	8484	15	decision	decision	NN
18637	8484	16	was	be	VBD
18637	8484	17	not	not	RB
18637	8484	18	final	final	JJ
18637	8484	19	and	and	CC
18637	8484	20	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	8484	21	on	on	IN
18637	8484	22	the	the	DT
18637	8484	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	8484	24	.	.	.
18637	8485	1	'	'	``
18637	8485	2	All	all	DT
18637	8485	3	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8485	4	acts	act	NNS
18637	8485	5	of	of	IN
18637	8485	6	power	power	NN
18637	8485	7	,	,	,
18637	8485	8	whether	whether	IN
18637	8485	9	in	in	IN
18637	8485	10	the	the	DT
18637	8485	11	executive	executive	NN
18637	8485	12	or	or	CC
18637	8485	13	in	in	IN
18637	8485	14	the	the	DT
18637	8485	15	judicial	judicial	NNP
18637	8485	16	department	department	NN
18637	8485	17	,	,	,
18637	8485	18	have	have	VBP
18637	8485	19	as	as	RB
18637	8485	20	much	much	JJ
18637	8485	21	legal	legal	JJ
18637	8485	22	validity	validity	NN
18637	8485	23	and	and	CC
18637	8485	24	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8485	25	as	as	IN
18637	8485	26	if	if	IN
18637	8485	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8485	28	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	8485	29	from	from	IN
18637	8485	30	the	the	DT
18637	8485	31	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	8485	32	,	,	,
18637	8485	33	*	*	NFP
18637	8485	34	*	*	NFP
18637	8485	35	*	*	NFP
18637	8485	36	'	'	''
18637	8485	37	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8485	38	243	243	CD
18637	8485	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8485	40	*	*	NFP
18637	8485	41	*	*	NFP
18637	8485	42	*	*	NFP
18637	8485	43	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8485	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	8485	45	,	,	,
18637	8485	46	of	of	IN
18637	8485	47	course	course	NN
18637	8485	48	,	,	,
18637	8485	49	true	true	JJ
18637	8485	50	that	that	IN
18637	8485	51	even	even	RB
18637	8485	52	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8485	53	with	with	IN
18637	8485	54	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8485	55	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8485	56	will	will	MD
18637	8485	57	be	be	VB
18637	8485	58	carefully	carefully	RB
18637	8485	59	construed	construe	VBN
18637	8485	60	so	so	RB
18637	8485	61	as	as	IN
18637	8485	62	not	not	RB
18637	8485	63	to	to	TO
18637	8485	64	derogate	derogate	VB
18637	8485	65	from	from	IN
18637	8485	66	the	the	DT
18637	8485	67	authority	authority	NN
18637	8485	68	and	and	CC
18637	8485	69	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	8485	70	of	of	IN
18637	8485	71	the	the	DT
18637	8485	72	States	States	NNPS
18637	8485	73	of	of	IN
18637	8485	74	this	this	DT
18637	8485	75	nation	nation	NN
18637	8485	76	unless	unless	IN
18637	8485	77	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	8485	78	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8485	79	to	to	TO
18637	8485	80	effectuate	effectuate	VB
18637	8485	81	the	the	DT
18637	8485	82	national	national	JJ
18637	8485	83	policy	policy	NN
18637	8485	84	.	.	.
18637	8486	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8486	2	244	244	CD
18637	8486	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8486	4	But	but	CC
18637	8486	5	State	State	NNP
18637	8486	6	law	law	NN
18637	8486	7	must	must	MD
18637	8486	8	yield	yield	VB
18637	8486	9	when	when	WRB
18637	8486	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8486	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	8486	12	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	8486	13	with	with	IN
18637	8486	14	,	,	,
18637	8486	15	or	or	CC
18637	8486	16	impairs	impair	VBZ
18637	8486	17	the	the	DT
18637	8486	18	policy	policy	NN
18637	8486	19	or	or	CC
18637	8486	20	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8486	21	of	of	IN
18637	8486	22	,	,	,
18637	8486	23	a	a	DT
18637	8486	24	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8486	25	or	or	CC
18637	8486	26	of	of	IN
18637	8486	27	an	an	DT
18637	8486	28	international	international	JJ
18637	8486	29	compact	compact	NN
18637	8486	30	or	or	CC
18637	8486	31	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8486	32	.	.	.
18637	8487	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8487	2	245	245	CD
18637	8487	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8487	4	Then	then	RB
18637	8487	5	,	,	,
18637	8487	6	the	the	DT
18637	8487	7	power	power	NN
18637	8487	8	of	of	IN
18637	8487	9	a	a	DT
18637	8487	10	State	State	NNP
18637	8487	11	to	to	TO
18637	8487	12	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	8487	13	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	8487	14	of	of	IN
18637	8487	15	rights	right	NNS
18637	8487	16	based	base	VBN
18637	8487	17	on	on	IN
18637	8487	18	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8487	19	law	law	NN
18637	8487	20	which	which	WDT
18637	8487	21	runs	run	VBZ
18637	8487	22	counter	counter	RB
18637	8487	23	to	to	IN
18637	8487	24	the	the	DT
18637	8487	25	public	public	JJ
18637	8487	26	policy	policy	NN
18637	8487	27	of	of	IN
18637	8487	28	the	the	DT
18637	8487	29	form	form	NN
18637	8487	30	*	*	NFP
18637	8487	31	*	*	NFP
18637	8487	32	*	*	NFP
18637	8487	33	must	must	MD
18637	8487	34	give	give	VB
18637	8487	35	way	way	NN
18637	8487	36	before	before	IN
18637	8487	37	the	the	DT
18637	8487	38	superior	superior	JJ
18637	8487	39	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	8487	40	policy	policy	NN
18637	8487	41	evidenced	evidence	VBN
18637	8487	42	by	by	IN
18637	8487	43	a	a	DT
18637	8487	44	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8487	45	or	or	CC
18637	8487	46	international	international	JJ
18637	8487	47	compact	compact	JJ
18637	8487	48	or	or	CC
18637	8487	49	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8487	50	.	.	.
18637	8488	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8488	2	246	246	CD
18637	8488	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8488	4	*	*	NFP
18637	8488	5	*	*	NFP
18637	8488	6	*	*	NFP
18637	8488	7	The	the	DT
18637	8488	8	action	action	NN
18637	8488	9	of	of	IN
18637	8488	10	New	New	NNP
18637	8488	11	York	York	NNP
18637	8488	12	in	in	IN
18637	8488	13	this	this	DT
18637	8488	14	case	case	NN
18637	8488	15	amounts	amount	VBZ
18637	8488	16	in	in	IN
18637	8488	17	substance	substance	NN
18637	8488	18	to	to	IN
18637	8488	19	a	a	DT
18637	8488	20	rejection	rejection	NN
18637	8488	21	of	of	IN
18637	8488	22	a	a	DT
18637	8488	23	part	part	NN
18637	8488	24	of	of	IN
18637	8488	25	the	the	DT
18637	8488	26	policy	policy	NN
18637	8488	27	underlying	underlying	NN
18637	8488	28	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8488	29	by	by	IN
18637	8488	30	this	this	DT
18637	8488	31	nation	nation	NN
18637	8488	32	of	of	IN
18637	8488	33	Soviet	Soviet	NNP
18637	8488	34	Russia	Russia	NNP
18637	8488	35	.	.	.
18637	8489	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	8489	2	power	power	NN
18637	8489	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8489	4	not	not	RB
18637	8489	5	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	8489	6	a	a	DT
18637	8489	7	State	state	NN
18637	8489	8	in	in	IN
18637	8489	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8489	10	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8489	11	system	system	NN
18637	8489	12	.	.	.
18637	8490	1	To	to	TO
18637	8490	2	permit	permit	VB
18637	8490	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8490	4	would	would	MD
18637	8490	5	be	be	VB
18637	8490	6	to	to	TO
18637	8490	7	sanction	sanction	VB
18637	8490	8	a	a	DT
18637	8490	9	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	8490	10	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	8490	11	of	of	IN
18637	8490	12	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8490	13	authority	authority	NN
18637	8490	14	.	.	.
18637	8491	1	For	for	IN
18637	8491	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8491	3	would	would	MD
18637	8491	4	'	'	``
18637	8491	5	imperil	imperil	VB
18637	8491	6	the	the	DT
18637	8491	7	amicable	amicable	JJ
18637	8491	8	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8491	9	between	between	IN
18637	8491	10	governments	government	NNS
18637	8491	11	and	and	CC
18637	8491	12	vex	vex	VBP
18637	8491	13	the	the	DT
18637	8491	14	peace	peace	NN
18637	8491	15	of	of	IN
18637	8491	16	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8491	17	.	.	.
18637	8492	1	'	'	``
18637	8492	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8492	3	247	247	CD
18637	8492	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8492	5	*	*	NFP
18637	8492	6	*	*	NFP
18637	8492	7	*	*	NFP
18637	8492	8	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8492	9	would	would	MD
18637	8492	10	tend	tend	VB
18637	8492	11	to	to	TO
18637	8492	12	disturb	disturb	VB
18637	8492	13	that	that	IN
18637	8492	14	equilibrium	equilibrium	NN
18637	8492	15	in	in	IN
18637	8492	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8492	17	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8492	18	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8492	19	which	which	WDT
18637	8492	20	the	the	DT
18637	8492	21	political	political	JJ
18637	8492	22	departments	department	NNS
18637	8492	23	of	of	IN
18637	8492	24	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8492	25	national	national	JJ
18637	8492	26	government	government	NN
18637	8492	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	8492	28	diligently	diligently	RB
18637	8492	29	endeavored	endeavor	VBN
18637	8492	30	to	to	TO
18637	8492	31	establish	establish	VB
18637	8492	32	.	.	.
18637	8493	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8493	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8493	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8493	4	No	no	DT
18637	8493	5	State	state	NN
18637	8493	6	can	can	MD
18637	8493	7	rewrite	rewrite	VB
18637	8493	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8493	9	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8493	10	policy	policy	NN
18637	8493	11	to	to	TO
18637	8493	12	conform	conform	VB
18637	8493	13	to	to	IN
18637	8493	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8493	15	own	own	JJ
18637	8493	16	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	8493	17	policies	policy	NNS
18637	8493	18	.	.	.
18637	8494	1	Power	power	NN
18637	8494	2	over	over	IN
18637	8494	3	external	external	JJ
18637	8494	4	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	8494	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	8494	6	not	not	RB
18637	8494	7	shared	share	VBN
18637	8494	8	by	by	IN
18637	8494	9	the	the	DT
18637	8494	10	States	States	NNPS
18637	8494	11	;	;	:
18637	8494	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8494	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	8494	14	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8494	15	in	in	IN
18637	8494	16	the	the	DT
18637	8494	17	national	national	JJ
18637	8494	18	government	government	NN
18637	8494	19	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	8494	20	.	.	.
18637	8495	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8495	2	need	nee	MD
18637	8495	3	not	not	RB
18637	8495	4	be	be	VB
18637	8495	5	so	so	RB
18637	8495	6	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	8495	7	as	as	IN
18637	8495	8	to	to	TO
18637	8495	9	conform	conform	VB
18637	8495	10	to	to	IN
18637	8495	11	State	state	NN
18637	8495	12	laws	law	NNS
18637	8495	13	or	or	CC
18637	8495	14	State	state	NN
18637	8495	15	policies	policy	NNS
18637	8495	16	,	,	,
18637	8495	17	whether	whether	IN
18637	8495	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8495	19	be	be	VBP
18637	8495	20	expressed	express	VBN
18637	8495	21	in	in	IN
18637	8495	22	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	8495	23	,	,	,
18637	8495	24	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	8495	25	,	,	,
18637	8495	26	or	or	CC
18637	8495	27	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8495	28	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	8495	29	.	.	.
18637	8496	1	And	and	CC
18637	8496	2	the	the	DT
18637	8496	3	policies	policy	NNS
18637	8496	4	of	of	IN
18637	8496	5	the	the	DT
18637	8496	6	States	States	NNPS
18637	8496	7	become	become	VBP
18637	8496	8	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	8496	9	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
18637	8496	10	to	to	IN
18637	8496	11	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8496	12	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	8496	13	when	when	WRB
18637	8496	14	the	the	DT
18637	8496	15	United	United	NNP
18637	8496	16	States	States	NNP
18637	8496	17	,	,	,
18637	8496	18	acting	act	VBG
18637	8496	19	within	within	IN
18637	8496	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8496	21	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8496	22	sphere	sphere	NN
18637	8496	23	,	,	,
18637	8496	24	seeks	seek	VBZ
18637	8496	25	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	8496	26	of	of	IN
18637	8496	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8496	28	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8496	29	policy	policy	NN
18637	8496	30	in	in	IN
18637	8496	31	the	the	DT
18637	8496	32	courts	court	NNS
18637	8496	33	.	.	.
18637	8496	34	"	"	''
18637	8497	1	And	and	CC
18637	8497	2	while	while	IN
18637	8497	3	"	"	``
18637	8497	4	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	8497	5	as	as	RB
18637	8497	6	well	well	RB
18637	8497	7	as	as	IN
18637	8497	8	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8497	9	are	be	VBP
18637	8497	10	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	8497	11	to	to	IN
18637	8497	12	the	the	DT
18637	8497	13	protection	protection	NN
18637	8497	14	of	of	IN
18637	8497	15	the	the	DT
18637	8497	16	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	8497	17	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	8497	18	,	,	,
18637	8497	19	"	"	''
18637	8497	20	that	that	DT
18637	8497	21	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	8497	22	did	do	VBD
18637	8497	23	not	not	RB
18637	8497	24	bar	bar	VB
18637	8497	25	the	the	DT
18637	8497	26	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8497	27	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8497	28	"	"	''
18637	8497	29	from	from	IN
18637	8497	30	securing	secure	VBG
18637	8497	31	for	for	IN
18637	8497	32	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8497	33	and	and	CC
18637	8497	34	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8497	35	nationals	national	NNS
18637	8497	36	priority	priority	NN
18637	8497	37	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8497	38	against	against	IN
18637	8497	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8497	40	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	8497	41	who	who	WP
18637	8497	42	are	be	VBP
18637	8497	43	nationals	national	NNS
18637	8497	44	of	of	IN
18637	8497	45	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8497	46	countries	country	NNS
18637	8497	47	and	and	CC
18637	8497	48	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8497	49	claims	claim	NNS
18637	8497	50	arose	arise	VBD
18637	8497	51	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	8497	52	.	.	.
18637	8498	1	"	"	``
18637	8498	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8498	3	248	248	CD
18637	8498	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8498	5	THE	the	DT
18637	8498	6	HULL	HULL	NNP
18637	8498	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	8498	8	LOTHIAN	LOTHIAN	NNP
18637	8498	9	AGREEMENT	AGREEMENT	NNP
18637	8498	10	,	,	,
18637	8498	11	1940	1940	CD
18637	8498	12	The	the	DT
18637	8498	13	fall	fall	NN
18637	8498	14	of	of	IN
18637	8498	15	France	France	NNP
18637	8498	16	in	in	IN
18637	8498	17	June	June	NNP
18637	8498	18	1940	1940	CD
18637	8498	19	inspired	inspire	VBD
18637	8498	20	President	President	NNP
18637	8498	21	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8498	22	to	to	TO
18637	8498	23	enter	enter	VB
18637	8498	24	the	the	DT
18637	8498	25	following	follow	VBG
18637	8498	26	summer	summer	NN
18637	8498	27	into	into	IN
18637	8498	28	two	two	CD
18637	8498	29	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8498	30	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8498	31	the	the	DT
18637	8498	32	total	total	JJ
18637	8498	33	effect	effect	NN
18637	8498	34	of	of	IN
18637	8498	35	which	which	WDT
18637	8498	36	was	be	VBD
18637	8498	37	to	to	TO
18637	8498	38	transform	transform	VB
18637	8498	39	the	the	DT
18637	8498	40	role	role	NN
18637	8498	41	of	of	IN
18637	8498	42	the	the	DT
18637	8498	43	United	United	NNP
18637	8498	44	States	States	NNP
18637	8498	45	from	from	IN
18637	8498	46	one	one	CD
18637	8498	47	of	of	IN
18637	8498	48	strict	strict	JJ
18637	8498	49	neutrality	neutrality	NN
18637	8498	50	toward	toward	IN
18637	8498	51	the	the	DT
18637	8498	52	war	war	NN
18637	8498	53	then	then	RB
18637	8498	54	waging	wage	VBG
18637	8498	55	in	in	IN
18637	8498	56	Europe	Europe	NNP
18637	8498	57	to	to	IN
18637	8498	58	one	one	CD
18637	8498	59	of	of	IN
18637	8498	60	semi	semi	JJ
18637	8498	61	-	-	JJ
18637	8498	62	belligerency	belligerency	JJ
18637	8498	63	.	.	.
18637	8499	1	The	the	DT
18637	8499	2	first	first	JJ
18637	8499	3	of	of	IN
18637	8499	4	these	these	DT
18637	8499	5	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8499	6	was	be	VBD
18637	8499	7	with	with	IN
18637	8499	8	Canada	Canada	NNP
18637	8499	9	,	,	,
18637	8499	10	and	and	CC
18637	8499	11	provided	provide	VBD
18637	8499	12	that	that	IN
18637	8499	13	a	a	DT
18637	8499	14	Permanent	Permanent	NNP
18637	8499	15	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	8499	16	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8499	17	on	on	IN
18637	8499	18	Defense	Defense	NNP
18637	8499	19	was	be	VBD
18637	8499	20	to	to	TO
18637	8499	21	be	be	VB
18637	8499	22	set	set	VBN
18637	8499	23	up	up	RP
18637	8499	24	at	at	IN
18637	8499	25	once	once	RB
18637	8499	26	by	by	IN
18637	8499	27	the	the	DT
18637	8499	28	two	two	CD
18637	8499	29	countries	country	NNS
18637	8499	30	which	which	WDT
18637	8499	31	would	would	MD
18637	8499	32	"	"	``
18637	8499	33	consider	consider	VB
18637	8499	34	in	in	IN
18637	8499	35	the	the	DT
18637	8499	36	broad	broad	JJ
18637	8499	37	sense	sense	NN
18637	8499	38	the	the	DT
18637	8499	39	defense	defense	NN
18637	8499	40	of	of	IN
18637	8499	41	the	the	DT
18637	8499	42	north	north	JJ
18637	8499	43	half	half	NN
18637	8499	44	of	of	IN
18637	8499	45	the	the	DT
18637	8499	46	Western	Western	NNP
18637	8499	47	Hemisphere	Hemisphere	NNP
18637	8499	48	.	.	.
18637	8500	1	"	"	``
18637	8500	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8500	3	249	249	CD
18637	8500	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8500	5	The	the	DT
18637	8500	6	second	second	JJ
18637	8500	7	,	,	,
18637	8500	8	and	and	CC
18637	8500	9	more	more	RBR
18637	8500	10	important	important	JJ
18637	8500	11	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8500	12	,	,	,
18637	8500	13	was	be	VBD
18637	8500	14	the	the	DT
18637	8500	15	Hull	Hull	NNP
18637	8500	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	8500	17	Lothian	Lothian	NNP
18637	8500	18	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	8500	19	of	of	IN
18637	8500	20	September	September	NNP
18637	8500	21	2	2	CD
18637	8500	22	,	,	,
18637	8500	23	1940	1940	CD
18637	8500	24	,	,	,
18637	8500	25	under	under	IN
18637	8500	26	which	which	WDT
18637	8500	27	,	,	,
18637	8500	28	in	in	IN
18637	8500	29	return	return	NN
18637	8500	30	for	for	IN
18637	8500	31	the	the	DT
18637	8500	32	lease	lease	NN
18637	8500	33	to	to	IN
18637	8500	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8500	35	for	for	IN
18637	8500	36	ninety	ninety	CD
18637	8500	37	-	-	HYPH
18637	8500	38	nine	nine	CD
18637	8500	39	years	year	NNS
18637	8500	40	of	of	IN
18637	8500	41	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8500	42	sites	site	NNS
18637	8500	43	for	for	IN
18637	8500	44	naval	naval	JJ
18637	8500	45	bases	basis	NNS
18637	8500	46	in	in	IN
18637	8500	47	the	the	DT
18637	8500	48	British	British	NNP
18637	8500	49	West	West	NNP
18637	8500	50	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	8500	51	,	,	,
18637	8500	52	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8500	53	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8500	54	handed	hand	VBD
18637	8500	55	over	over	RP
18637	8500	56	to	to	IN
18637	8500	57	the	the	DT
18637	8500	58	British	British	NNP
18637	8500	59	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8500	60	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	8500	61	over	over	IN
18637	8500	62	-	-	HYPH
18637	8500	63	age	age	NN
18637	8500	64	destroyers	destroyer	NNS
18637	8500	65	which	which	WDT
18637	8500	66	had	have	VBD
18637	8500	67	been	be	VBN
18637	8500	68	recently	recently	RB
18637	8500	69	reconditioned	recondition	VBN
18637	8500	70	and	and	CC
18637	8500	71	recommissioned	recommissione	VBN
18637	8500	72	.	.	.
18637	8501	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8501	2	250	250	CD
18637	8501	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8501	4	The	the	DT
18637	8501	5	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	8501	6	,	,	,
18637	8501	7	as	as	IN
18637	8501	8	justified	justify	VBN
18637	8501	9	in	in	IN
18637	8501	10	an	an	DT
18637	8501	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8501	12	by	by	IN
18637	8501	13	the	the	DT
18637	8501	14	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8501	15	General	General	NNP
18637	8501	16	,	,	,
18637	8501	17	amounted	amount	VBD
18637	8501	18	to	to	IN
18637	8501	19	a	a	DT
18637	8501	20	claim	claim	NN
18637	8501	21	for	for	IN
18637	8501	22	the	the	DT
18637	8501	23	President	President	NNP
18637	8501	24	,	,	,
18637	8501	25	in	in	IN
18637	8501	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8501	27	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	8501	28	as	as	IN
18637	8501	29	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8501	30	in	in	IN
18637	8501	31	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8501	32	and	and	CC
18637	8501	33	organ	organ	NN
18637	8501	34	of	of	IN
18637	8501	35	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8501	36	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8501	37	,	,	,
18637	8501	38	to	to	TO
18637	8501	39	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	8501	40	of	of	IN
18637	8501	41	property	property	NN
18637	8501	42	of	of	IN
18637	8501	43	the	the	DT
18637	8501	44	United	United	NNP
18637	8501	45	States	States	NNP
18637	8501	46	,	,	,
18637	8501	47	although	although	IN
18637	8501	48	the	the	DT
18637	8501	49	only	only	JJ
18637	8501	50	power	power	NN
18637	8501	51	to	to	TO
18637	8501	52	do	do	VB
18637	8501	53	this	this	DT
18637	8501	54	which	which	WDT
18637	8501	55	the	the	DT
18637	8501	56	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8501	57	mentions	mention	NNS
18637	8501	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	8501	59	that	that	IN
18637	8501	60	which	which	WDT
18637	8501	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8501	62	assigns	assign	VBZ
18637	8501	63	to	to	IN
18637	8501	64	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8501	65	.	.	.
18637	8502	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8502	2	251	251	CD
18637	8502	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8502	4	On	on	IN
18637	8502	5	April	April	NNP
18637	8502	6	9	9	CD
18637	8502	7	,	,	,
18637	8502	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	8502	9	,	,	,
18637	8502	10	the	the	DT
18637	8502	11	State	State	NNP
18637	8502	12	Department	Department	NNP
18637	8502	13	,	,	,
18637	8502	14	in	in	IN
18637	8502	15	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	8502	16	of	of	IN
18637	8502	17	the	the	DT
18637	8502	18	fact	fact	NN
18637	8502	19	that	that	IN
18637	8502	20	Germany	Germany	NNP
18637	8502	21	had	have	VBD
18637	8502	22	,	,	,
18637	8502	23	on	on	IN
18637	8502	24	April	April	NNP
18637	8502	25	9	9	CD
18637	8502	26	,	,	,
18637	8502	27	1940	1940	CD
18637	8502	28	,	,	,
18637	8502	29	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	8502	30	Denmark	Denmark	NNP
18637	8502	31	,	,	,
18637	8502	32	entered	enter	VBD
18637	8502	33	into	into	IN
18637	8502	34	an	an	DT
18637	8502	35	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8502	36	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8502	37	with	with	IN
18637	8502	38	the	the	DT
18637	8502	39	Danish	danish	JJ
18637	8502	40	minister	minister	NN
18637	8502	41	at	at	IN
18637	8502	42	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	8502	43	,	,	,
18637	8502	44	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	8502	45	the	the	DT
18637	8502	46	United	United	NNP
18637	8502	47	States	States	NNP
18637	8502	48	acquired	acquire	VBD
18637	8502	49	the	the	DT
18637	8502	50	right	right	NN
18637	8502	51	to	to	TO
18637	8502	52	occupy	occupy	VB
18637	8502	53	Greenland	Greenland	NNP
18637	8502	54	for	for	IN
18637	8502	55	the	the	DT
18637	8502	56	duration	duration	NN
18637	8502	57	,	,	,
18637	8502	58	for	for	IN
18637	8502	59	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	8502	60	of	of	IN
18637	8502	61	defense	defense	NN
18637	8502	62	.	.	.
18637	8503	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8503	2	252	252	CD
18637	8503	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8503	4	WARTIME	WARTIME	NNP
18637	8503	5	AGREEMENTS	AGREEMENTS	NNP
18637	8503	6	That	that	IN
18637	8503	7	the	the	DT
18637	8503	8	post	post	JJ
18637	8503	9	-	-	JJ
18637	8503	10	war	war	JJ
18637	8503	11	diplomacy	diplomacy	NN
18637	8503	12	of	of	IN
18637	8503	13	the	the	DT
18637	8503	14	United	United	NNP
18637	8503	15	States	States	NNP
18637	8503	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	8503	17	been	be	VBN
18637	8503	18	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	8503	19	influenced	influence	VBN
18637	8503	20	by	by	IN
18637	8503	21	such	such	JJ
18637	8503	22	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8503	23	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8503	24	as	as	IN
18637	8503	25	those	those	DT
18637	8503	26	which	which	WDT
18637	8503	27	are	be	VBP
18637	8503	28	associated	associate	VBN
18637	8503	29	with	with	IN
18637	8503	30	Cairo	Cairo	NNP
18637	8503	31	,	,	,
18637	8503	32	Teheran	Teheran	NNP
18637	8503	33	,	,	,
18637	8503	34	Malta	Malta	NNP
18637	8503	35	,	,	,
18637	8503	36	and	and	CC
18637	8503	37	Potsdam	Potsdam	NNP
18637	8503	38	,	,	,
18637	8503	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	8503	40	evident	evident	JJ
18637	8503	41	.	.	.
18637	8504	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8504	2	253	253	CD
18637	8504	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8504	4	The	the	DT
18637	8504	5	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8504	6	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	8504	7	thus	thus	RB
18637	8504	8	became	become	VBD
18637	8504	9	,	,	,
18637	8504	10	in	in	IN
18637	8504	11	an	an	DT
18637	8504	12	era	era	NN
18637	8504	13	in	in	IN
18637	8504	14	which	which	WDT
18637	8504	15	the	the	DT
18637	8504	16	instability	instability	NN
18637	8504	17	of	of	IN
18637	8504	18	international	international	JJ
18637	8504	19	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8504	20	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	8504	21	successful	successful	JJ
18637	8504	22	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	8504	23	at	at	IN
18637	8504	24	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8504	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	8504	26	making	making	NN
18637	8504	27	,	,	,
18637	8504	28	the	the	DT
18637	8504	29	principal	principal	JJ
18637	8504	30	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	8504	31	of	of	IN
18637	8504	32	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8504	33	initiative	initiative	NN
18637	8504	34	in	in	IN
18637	8504	35	the	the	DT
18637	8504	36	field	field	NN
18637	8504	37	of	of	IN
18637	8504	38	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8504	39	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8504	40	.	.	.
18637	8505	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	8505	2	the	the	DT
18637	8505	3	United	United	NNP
18637	8505	4	Nations	Nations	NNPS
18637	8505	5	Charter	Charter	NNP
18637	8505	6	and	and	CC
18637	8505	7	the	the	DT
18637	8505	8	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	8505	9	Pact	Pact	NNP
18637	8505	10	signalize	signalize	VB
18637	8505	11	the	the	DT
18637	8505	12	end	end	NN
18637	8505	13	of	of	IN
18637	8505	14	this	this	DT
18637	8505	15	era	era	NN
18637	8505	16	will	will	MD
18637	8505	17	doubtless	doubtless	RB
18637	8505	18	appear	appear	VB
18637	8505	19	in	in	IN
18637	8505	20	due	due	JJ
18637	8505	21	course	course	NN
18637	8505	22	.	.	.
18637	8506	1	EXECUTIVE	executive	NN
18637	8506	2	AGREEMENTS	agreement	NNS
18637	8506	3	BY	by	IN
18637	8506	4	AUTHORIZATION	authorization	NN
18637	8506	5	OF	of	IN
18637	8506	6	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	8506	7	"	"	``
18637	8506	8	The	the	DT
18637	8506	9	first	first	JJ
18637	8506	10	known	know	VBN
18637	8506	11	use	use	NN
18637	8506	12	of	of	IN
18637	8506	13	the	the	DT
18637	8506	14	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8506	15	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8506	16	under	under	IN
18637	8506	17	the	the	DT
18637	8506	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8506	19	of	of	IN
18637	8506	20	the	the	DT
18637	8506	21	United	United	NNP
18637	8506	22	States	States	NNP
18637	8506	23	,	,	,
18637	8506	24	"	"	''
18637	8506	25	writes	write	VBZ
18637	8506	26	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
18637	8506	27	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	8506	28	,	,	,
18637	8506	29	"	"	``
18637	8506	30	was	be	VBD
18637	8506	31	for	for	IN
18637	8506	32	the	the	DT
18637	8506	33	development	development	NN
18637	8506	34	of	of	IN
18637	8506	35	international	international	JJ
18637	8506	36	communication	communication	NN
18637	8506	37	by	by	IN
18637	8506	38	means	mean	NNS
18637	8506	39	of	of	IN
18637	8506	40	the	the	DT
18637	8506	41	postal	postal	JJ
18637	8506	42	service	service	NN
18637	8506	43	.	.	.
18637	8507	1	The	the	DT
18637	8507	2	second	second	JJ
18637	8507	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8507	4	,	,	,
18637	8507	5	in	in	IN
18637	8507	6	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	8507	7	the	the	DT
18637	8507	8	Post	Post	NNP
18637	8507	9	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8507	10	,	,	,
18637	8507	11	which	which	WDT
18637	8507	12	had	have	VBD
18637	8507	13	theretofore	theretofore	NN
18637	8507	14	been	be	VBN
18637	8507	15	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	8507	16	with	with	IN
18637	8507	17	through	through	IN
18637	8507	18	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8507	19	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	8507	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8507	21	on	on	RP
18637	8507	22	from	from	IN
18637	8507	23	year	year	NN
18637	8507	24	to	to	IN
18637	8507	25	year	year	NN
18637	8507	26	,	,	,
18637	8507	27	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	8507	28	that	that	IN
18637	8507	29	'	'	''
18637	8507	30	the	the	DT
18637	8507	31	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
18637	8507	32	General	General	NNP
18637	8507	33	may	may	MD
18637	8507	34	make	make	VB
18637	8507	35	arrangements	arrangement	NNS
18637	8507	36	with	with	IN
18637	8507	37	the	the	DT
18637	8507	38	Postmasters	postmaster	NNS
18637	8507	39	in	in	IN
18637	8507	40	any	any	DT
18637	8507	41	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8507	42	country	country	NN
18637	8507	43	for	for	IN
18637	8507	44	the	the	DT
18637	8507	45	reciprocal	reciprocal	JJ
18637	8507	46	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	8507	47	and	and	CC
18637	8507	48	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	8507	49	of	of	IN
18637	8507	50	letters	letter	NNS
18637	8507	51	and	and	CC
18637	8507	52	packets	packet	NNS
18637	8507	53	,	,	,
18637	8507	54	through	through	IN
18637	8507	55	the	the	DT
18637	8507	56	post	post	NN
18637	8507	57	-	-	NNS
18637	8507	58	offices	office	NNS
18637	8507	59	.	.	.
18637	8507	60	'	'	''
18637	8508	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8508	2	was	be	VBD
18637	8508	3	further	further	RB
18637	8508	4	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8508	5	that	that	IN
18637	8508	6	this	this	DT
18637	8508	7	act	act	NN
18637	8508	8	,	,	,
18637	8508	9	of	of	IN
18637	8508	10	February	February	NNP
18637	8508	11	20	20	CD
18637	8508	12	,	,	,
18637	8508	13	1792	1792	CD
18637	8508	14	,	,	,
18637	8508	15	should	should	MD
18637	8508	16	'	'	''
18637	8508	17	be	be	VB
18637	8508	18	in	in	IN
18637	8508	19	force	force	NN
18637	8508	20	for	for	IN
18637	8508	21	the	the	DT
18637	8508	22	term	term	NN
18637	8508	23	of	of	IN
18637	8508	24	two	two	CD
18637	8508	25	years	year	NNS
18637	8508	26	,	,	,
18637	8508	27	from	from	IN
18637	8508	28	the	the	DT
18637	8508	29	*	*	NFP
18637	8508	30	*	*	NFP
18637	8508	31	*	*	NFP
18637	8508	32	first	first	JJ
18637	8508	33	day	day	NN
18637	8508	34	of	of	IN
18637	8508	35	June	June	NNP
18637	8508	36	next	next	RB
18637	8508	37	,	,	,
18637	8508	38	and	and	CC
18637	8508	39	no	no	RB
18637	8508	40	longer	long	RBR
18637	8508	41	.	.	.
18637	8509	1	'	'	``
18637	8509	2	"	"	``
18637	8509	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8509	4	254	254	CD
18637	8509	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8509	6	Reciprocal	Reciprocal	NNP
18637	8509	7	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	8509	8	Agreements	Agreements	NNPS
18637	8509	9	Under	under	IN
18637	8509	10	later	later	JJ
18637	8509	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8509	12	executive	executive	NN
18637	8509	13	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8509	14	,	,	,
18637	8509	15	or	or	CC
18637	8509	16	what	what	WP
18637	8509	17	in	in	IN
18637	8509	18	effect	effect	NN
18637	8509	19	were	be	VBD
18637	8509	20	such	such	JJ
18637	8509	21	,	,	,
18637	8509	22	have	have	VBP
18637	8509	23	been	be	VBN
18637	8509	24	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8509	25	by	by	IN
18637	8509	26	which	which	WDT
18637	8509	27	American	american	JJ
18637	8509	28	patents	patent	NNS
18637	8509	29	,	,	,
18637	8509	30	copyrights	copyright	NNS
18637	8509	31	,	,	,
18637	8509	32	and	and	CC
18637	8509	33	trade	trade	NN
18637	8509	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	8509	35	marks	mark	NNS
18637	8509	36	have	have	VBP
18637	8509	37	secured	secure	VBN
18637	8509	38	protection	protection	NN
18637	8509	39	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	8509	40	in	in	IN
18637	8509	41	return	return	NN
18637	8509	42	for	for	IN
18637	8509	43	like	like	JJ
18637	8509	44	protection	protection	NN
18637	8509	45	by	by	IN
18637	8509	46	the	the	DT
18637	8509	47	United	United	NNP
18637	8509	48	States	States	NNP
18637	8509	49	of	of	IN
18637	8509	50	similar	similar	JJ
18637	8509	51	rights	right	NNS
18637	8509	52	of	of	IN
18637	8509	53	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8509	54	origin	origin	NN
18637	8509	55	.	.	.
18637	8510	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8510	2	255	255	CD
18637	8510	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8510	4	But	but	CC
18637	8510	5	the	the	DT
18637	8510	6	most	most	RBS
18637	8510	7	copious	copious	JJ
18637	8510	8	source	source	NN
18637	8510	9	of	of	IN
18637	8510	10	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8510	11	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8510	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	8510	13	been	be	VBN
18637	8510	14	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8510	15	which	which	WDT
18637	8510	16	provided	provide	VBD
18637	8510	17	basis	basis	NN
18637	8510	18	for	for	IN
18637	8510	19	reciprocal	reciprocal	JJ
18637	8510	20	trade	trade	NN
18637	8510	21	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8510	22	,	,	,
18637	8510	23	with	with	IN
18637	8510	24	other	other	JJ
18637	8510	25	countries	country	NNS
18637	8510	26	.	.	.
18637	8511	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8511	2	256	256	CD
18637	8511	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8511	4	The	the	DT
18637	8511	5	culminating	culminate	VBG
18637	8511	6	act	act	NN
18637	8511	7	of	of	IN
18637	8511	8	this	this	DT
18637	8511	9	species	species	NN
18637	8511	10	was	be	VBD
18637	8511	11	that	that	DT
18637	8511	12	of	of	IN
18637	8511	13	June	June	NNP
18637	8511	14	12	12	CD
18637	8511	15	,	,	,
18637	8511	16	1934	1934	CD
18637	8511	17	,	,	,
18637	8511	18	which	which	WDT
18637	8511	19	provided	provide	VBD
18637	8511	20	,	,	,
18637	8511	21	in	in	IN
18637	8511	22	part	part	NN
18637	8511	23	,	,	,
18637	8511	24	as	as	IN
18637	8511	25	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	8511	26	:	:	:
18637	8511	27	"	"	``
18637	8511	28	*	*	NFP
18637	8511	29	*	*	NFP
18637	8511	30	*	*	NFP
18637	8511	31	,	,	,
18637	8511	32	the	the	DT
18637	8511	33	President	President	NNP
18637	8511	34	,	,	,
18637	8511	35	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	8511	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8511	37	finds	find	VBZ
18637	8511	38	as	as	IN
18637	8511	39	a	a	DT
18637	8511	40	fact	fact	NN
18637	8511	41	that	that	IN
18637	8511	42	any	any	DT
18637	8511	43	existing	exist	VBG
18637	8511	44	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8511	45	or	or	CC
18637	8511	46	other	other	JJ
18637	8511	47	import	import	NN
18637	8511	48	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	8511	49	of	of	IN
18637	8511	50	the	the	DT
18637	8511	51	United	United	NNP
18637	8511	52	States	States	NNP
18637	8511	53	or	or	CC
18637	8511	54	any	any	DT
18637	8511	55	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8511	56	country	country	NN
18637	8511	57	are	be	VBP
18637	8511	58	unduly	unduly	RB
18637	8511	59	burdening	burden	VBG
18637	8511	60	and	and	CC
18637	8511	61	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	8511	62	the	the	DT
18637	8511	63	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8511	64	trade	trade	NN
18637	8511	65	of	of	IN
18637	8511	66	the	the	DT
18637	8511	67	United	United	NNP
18637	8511	68	States	States	NNP
18637	8511	69	and	and	CC
18637	8511	70	that	that	IN
18637	8511	71	the	the	DT
18637	8511	72	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8511	73	above	above	IN
18637	8511	74	declared	declare	VBN
18637	8511	75	will	will	MD
18637	8511	76	be	be	VB
18637	8511	77	promoted	promote	VBN
18637	8511	78	by	by	IN
18637	8511	79	the	the	DT
18637	8511	80	means	means	NNP
18637	8511	81	hereinafter	hereinafter	NNP
18637	8511	82	specified	specify	VBD
18637	8511	83	,	,	,
18637	8511	84	is	be	VBZ
18637	8511	85	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8511	86	from	from	IN
18637	8511	87	time	time	NN
18637	8511	88	to	to	IN
18637	8511	89	time--'(1	time--'(1	DT
18637	8511	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8511	91	To	to	TO
18637	8511	92	enter	enter	VB
18637	8511	93	into	into	IN
18637	8511	94	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8511	95	trade	trade	NN
18637	8511	96	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8511	97	with	with	IN
18637	8511	98	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8511	99	governments	government	NNS
18637	8511	100	or	or	CC
18637	8511	101	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	8511	102	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8511	103	'	'	''
18637	8511	104	;	;	:
18637	8511	105	and	and	CC
18637	8511	106	'	'	''
18637	8511	107	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8511	108	2	2	LS
18637	8511	109	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8511	110	To	to	TO
18637	8511	111	proclaim	proclaim	VB
18637	8511	112	such	such	JJ
18637	8511	113	modifications	modification	NNS
18637	8511	114	of	of	IN
18637	8511	115	existing	exist	VBG
18637	8511	116	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8511	117	and	and	CC
18637	8511	118	other	other	JJ
18637	8511	119	import	import	NN
18637	8511	120	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	8511	121	,	,	,
18637	8511	122	or	or	CC
18637	8511	123	such	such	JJ
18637	8511	124	additional	additional	JJ
18637	8511	125	import	import	NN
18637	8511	126	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	8511	127	,	,	,
18637	8511	128	or	or	CC
18637	8511	129	such	such	JJ
18637	8511	130	continuance	continuance	NN
18637	8511	131	,	,	,
18637	8511	132	and	and	CC
18637	8511	133	for	for	IN
18637	8511	134	such	such	JJ
18637	8511	135	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	8511	136	periods	period	NNS
18637	8511	137	,	,	,
18637	8511	138	of	of	IN
18637	8511	139	existing	exist	VBG
18637	8511	140	customs	custom	NNS
18637	8511	141	or	or	CC
18637	8511	142	excise	excise	VB
18637	8511	143	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	8511	144	of	of	IN
18637	8511	145	any	any	DT
18637	8511	146	article	article	NN
18637	8511	147	covered	cover	VBN
18637	8511	148	by	by	IN
18637	8511	149	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8511	150	trade	trade	NN
18637	8511	151	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8511	152	,	,	,
18637	8511	153	as	as	IN
18637	8511	154	are	be	VBP
18637	8511	155	required	require	VBN
18637	8511	156	or	or	CC
18637	8511	157	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	8511	158	to	to	TO
18637	8511	159	carry	carry	VB
18637	8511	160	out	out	RP
18637	8511	161	any	any	DT
18637	8511	162	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8511	163	trade	trade	NN
18637	8511	164	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8511	165	that	that	WDT
18637	8511	166	the	the	DT
18637	8511	167	President	President	NNP
18637	8511	168	has	have	VBZ
18637	8511	169	entered	enter	VBN
18637	8511	170	into	into	IN
18637	8511	171	hereunder	hereunder	NN
18637	8511	172	.	.	.
18637	8512	1	No	no	DT
18637	8512	2	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	8512	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	8512	4	be	be	VB
18637	8512	5	made	make	VBN
18637	8512	6	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	8512	7	or	or	CC
18637	8512	8	decreasing	decrease	VBG
18637	8512	9	by	by	IN
18637	8512	10	more	more	JJR
18637	8512	11	than	than	IN
18637	8512	12	50	50	CD
18637	8512	13	per	per	IN
18637	8512	14	centum	centum	NN
18637	8512	15	any	any	DT
18637	8512	16	existing	exist	VBG
18637	8512	17	rate	rate	NN
18637	8512	18	of	of	IN
18637	8512	19	duty	duty	NN
18637	8512	20	or	or	CC
18637	8512	21	transferring	transfer	VBG
18637	8512	22	any	any	DT
18637	8512	23	article	article	NN
18637	8512	24	between	between	IN
18637	8512	25	the	the	DT
18637	8512	26	dutiable	dutiable	JJ
18637	8512	27	and	and	CC
18637	8512	28	free	free	JJ
18637	8512	29	lists	list	NNS
18637	8512	30	.	.	.
18637	8513	1	'	'	``
18637	8513	2	"	"	``
18637	8513	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8513	4	257	257	CD
18637	8513	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8513	6	This	this	DT
18637	8513	7	act	act	NN
18637	8513	8	,	,	,
18637	8513	9	renewed	renew	VBD
18637	8513	10	at	at	IN
18637	8513	11	three	three	CD
18637	8513	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	8513	13	year	year	NN
18637	8513	14	intervals	interval	NNS
18637	8513	15	,	,	,
18637	8513	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	8513	17	still	still	RB
18637	8513	18	in	in	IN
18637	8513	19	effect	effect	NN
18637	8513	20	,	,	,
18637	8513	21	and	and	CC
18637	8513	22	under	under	IN
18637	8513	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8513	24	many	many	JJ
18637	8513	25	trade	trade	NN
18637	8513	26	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8513	27	were	be	VBD
18637	8513	28	negotiated	negotiate	VBN
18637	8513	29	by	by	IN
18637	8513	30	former	former	JJ
18637	8513	31	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8513	32	of	of	IN
18637	8513	33	State	State	NNP
18637	8513	34	Hull	Hull	NNP
18637	8513	35	.	.	.
18637	8514	1	The	the	DT
18637	8514	2	Constitutionality	Constitutionality	NNP
18637	8514	3	of	of	IN
18637	8514	4	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	8514	5	Agreements	Agreements	NNPS
18637	8514	6	In	in	IN
18637	8514	7	Field	Field	NNP
18637	8514	8	_	_	NNP
18637	8514	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	8514	10	_	_	NNP
18637	8514	11	Clark,[258	Clark,[258	NNP
18637	8514	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8514	13	decided	decide	VBD
18637	8514	14	in	in	IN
18637	8514	15	1892	1892	CD
18637	8514	16	this	this	DT
18637	8514	17	type	type	NN
18637	8514	18	of	of	IN
18637	8514	19	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8514	20	was	be	VBD
18637	8514	21	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	8514	22	against	against	IN
18637	8514	23	the	the	DT
18637	8514	24	objection	objection	NN
18637	8514	25	that	that	IN
18637	8514	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8514	27	attempted	attempt	VBD
18637	8514	28	an	an	DT
18637	8514	29	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	8514	30	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	8514	31	"	"	''
18637	8514	32	of	of	IN
18637	8514	33	both	both	CC
18637	8514	34	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8514	35	and	and	CC
18637	8514	36	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8514	37	-	-	HYPH
18637	8514	38	making	make	VBG
18637	8514	39	powers	power	NNS
18637	8514	40	.	.	.
18637	8514	41	"	"	''
18637	8515	1	The	the	DT
18637	8515	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8515	3	met	meet	VBD
18637	8515	4	the	the	DT
18637	8515	5	first	first	JJ
18637	8515	6	objection	objection	NN
18637	8515	7	with	with	IN
18637	8515	8	an	an	DT
18637	8515	9	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	8515	10	review	review	NN
18637	8515	11	of	of	IN
18637	8515	12	similar	similar	JJ
18637	8515	13	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8515	14	from	from	IN
18637	8515	15	the	the	DT
18637	8515	16	inauguration	inauguration	NN
18637	8515	17	of	of	IN
18637	8515	18	government	government	NN
18637	8515	19	under	under	IN
18637	8515	20	the	the	DT
18637	8515	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8515	22	.	.	.
18637	8516	1	The	the	DT
18637	8516	2	second	second	JJ
18637	8516	3	objection	objection	NN
18637	8516	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8516	5	met	meet	VBD
18637	8516	6	with	with	IN
18637	8516	7	the	the	DT
18637	8516	8	court	court	NN
18637	8516	9	statement	statement	NN
18637	8516	10	that	that	IN
18637	8516	11	,	,	,
18637	8516	12	"	"	``
18637	8516	13	What	what	WP
18637	8516	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	8516	15	been	be	VBN
18637	8516	16	said	say	VBN
18637	8516	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	8516	18	equally	equally	RB
18637	8516	19	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	8516	20	to	to	IN
18637	8516	21	the	the	DT
18637	8516	22	objection	objection	NN
18637	8516	23	that	that	IN
18637	8516	24	the	the	DT
18637	8516	25	third	third	JJ
18637	8516	26	section	section	NN
18637	8516	27	of	of	IN
18637	8516	28	the	the	DT
18637	8516	29	act	act	NN
18637	8516	30	invests	invest	VBZ
18637	8516	31	the	the	DT
18637	8516	32	President	President	NNP
18637	8516	33	with	with	IN
18637	8516	34	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8516	35	-	-	HYPH
18637	8516	36	making	make	VBG
18637	8516	37	power	power	NN
18637	8516	38	.	.	.
18637	8517	1	The	the	DT
18637	8517	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8517	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8517	4	of	of	IN
18637	8517	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8517	6	that	that	IN
18637	8517	7	the	the	DT
18637	8517	8	third	third	JJ
18637	8517	9	section	section	NN
18637	8517	10	of	of	IN
18637	8517	11	the	the	DT
18637	8517	12	act	act	NN
18637	8517	13	of	of	IN
18637	8517	14	October	October	NNP
18637	8517	15	1	1	CD
18637	8517	16	,	,	,
18637	8517	17	1890	1890	CD
18637	8517	18	,	,	,
18637	8517	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	8517	20	not	not	RB
18637	8517	21	liable	liable	JJ
18637	8517	22	to	to	IN
18637	8517	23	the	the	DT
18637	8517	24	objection	objection	NN
18637	8517	25	that	that	WDT
18637	8517	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8517	27	transfers	transfer	VBZ
18637	8517	28	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8517	29	and	and	CC
18637	8517	30	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8517	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	8517	32	making	make	VBG
18637	8517	33	power	power	NN
18637	8517	34	to	to	IN
18637	8517	35	the	the	DT
18637	8517	36	President	President	NNP
18637	8517	37	.	.	.
18637	8518	1	"	"	``
18637	8518	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8518	3	259	259	CD
18637	8518	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8518	5	Although	although	IN
18637	8518	6	two	two	CD
18637	8518	7	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	8518	8	disagreed	disagree	VBD
18637	8518	9	,	,	,
18637	8518	10	the	the	DT
18637	8518	11	question	question	NN
18637	8518	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	8518	13	never	never	RB
18637	8518	14	been	be	VBN
18637	8518	15	revived	revive	VBN
18637	8518	16	.	.	.
18637	8519	1	However	however	RB
18637	8519	2	,	,	,
18637	8519	3	in	in	IN
18637	8519	4	Altman	Altman	NNP
18637	8519	5	and	and	CC
18637	8519	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	8519	7	_	_	NNP
18637	8519	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	8519	9	_	_	NNP
18637	8519	10	United	United	NNP
18637	8519	11	States,[260	States,[260	NNP
18637	8519	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8519	13	decided	decide	VBD
18637	8519	14	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	8519	15	years	year	NNS
18637	8519	16	later	later	RB
18637	8519	17	,	,	,
18637	8519	18	a	a	DT
18637	8519	19	collateral	collateral	JJ
18637	8519	20	question	question	NN
18637	8519	21	was	be	VBD
18637	8519	22	passed	pass	VBN
18637	8519	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	8519	24	.	.	.
18637	8520	1	This	this	DT
18637	8520	2	was	be	VBD
18637	8520	3	whether	whether	IN
18637	8520	4	an	an	DT
18637	8520	5	act	act	NN
18637	8520	6	of	of	IN
18637	8520	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8520	8	which	which	WDT
18637	8520	9	gave	give	VBD
18637	8520	10	the	the	DT
18637	8520	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	8520	12	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	8520	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	8520	14	of	of	IN
18637	8520	15	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	8520	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	8520	17	of	of	IN
18637	8520	18	cases	case	NNS
18637	8520	19	in	in	IN
18637	8520	20	which	which	WDT
18637	8520	21	"	"	``
18637	8520	22	the	the	DT
18637	8520	23	validity	validity	NN
18637	8520	24	or	or	CC
18637	8520	25	construction	construction	NN
18637	8520	26	of	of	IN
18637	8520	27	any	any	DT
18637	8520	28	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8520	29	,	,	,
18637	8520	30	*	*	NFP
18637	8520	31	*	*	NFP
18637	8520	32	*	*	NFP
18637	8520	33	,	,	,
18637	8520	34	was	be	VBD
18637	8520	35	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	8520	36	in	in	IN
18637	8520	37	question	question	NN
18637	8520	38	"	"	``
18637	8520	39	embraced	embrace	VBD
18637	8520	40	a	a	DT
18637	8520	41	case	case	NN
18637	8520	42	involving	involve	VBG
18637	8520	43	a	a	DT
18637	8520	44	trade	trade	NN
18637	8520	45	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8520	46	which	which	WDT
18637	8520	47	had	have	VBD
18637	8520	48	been	be	VBN
18637	8520	49	made	make	VBN
18637	8520	50	under	under	IN
18637	8520	51	the	the	DT
18637	8520	52	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	8520	53	of	of	IN
18637	8520	54	the	the	DT
18637	8520	55	Tariff	Tariff	NNP
18637	8520	56	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8520	57	of	of	IN
18637	8520	58	1897	1897	CD
18637	8520	59	.	.	.
18637	8521	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	8521	2	the	the	DT
18637	8521	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8521	4	:	:	:
18637	8521	5	"	"	``
18637	8521	6	While	while	IN
18637	8521	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8521	8	may	may	MD
18637	8521	9	be	be	VB
18637	8521	10	true	true	JJ
18637	8521	11	that	that	IN
18637	8521	12	this	this	DT
18637	8521	13	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	8521	14	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8521	15	,	,	,
18637	8521	16	made	make	VBN
18637	8521	17	under	under	IN
18637	8521	18	authority	authority	NN
18637	8521	19	of	of	IN
18637	8521	20	the	the	DT
18637	8521	21	Tariff	Tariff	NNP
18637	8521	22	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8521	23	of	of	IN
18637	8521	24	1897	1897	CD
18637	8521	25	,	,	,
18637	8521	26	§	§	NNP
18637	8521	27	3	3	CD
18637	8521	28	,	,	,
18637	8521	29	was	be	VBD
18637	8521	30	not	not	RB
18637	8521	31	a	a	DT
18637	8521	32	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8521	33	possessing	possess	VBG
18637	8521	34	the	the	DT
18637	8521	35	dignity	dignity	NN
18637	8521	36	of	of	IN
18637	8521	37	one	one	CD
18637	8521	38	requiring	require	VBG
18637	8521	39	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	8521	40	by	by	IN
18637	8521	41	the	the	DT
18637	8521	42	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8521	43	of	of	IN
18637	8521	44	the	the	DT
18637	8521	45	United	United	NNP
18637	8521	46	States	States	NNP
18637	8521	47	,	,	,
18637	8521	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8521	49	was	be	VBD
18637	8521	50	an	an	DT
18637	8521	51	international	international	JJ
18637	8521	52	compact	compact	NN
18637	8521	53	,	,	,
18637	8521	54	negotiated	negotiate	VBN
18637	8521	55	between	between	IN
18637	8521	56	the	the	DT
18637	8521	57	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	8521	58	of	of	IN
18637	8521	59	two	two	CD
18637	8521	60	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	8521	61	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8521	62	and	and	CC
18637	8521	63	made	make	VBN
18637	8521	64	in	in	IN
18637	8521	65	the	the	DT
18637	8521	66	name	name	NN
18637	8521	67	and	and	CC
18637	8521	68	on	on	IN
18637	8521	69	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	8521	70	of	of	IN
18637	8521	71	the	the	DT
18637	8521	72	contracting	contracting	NN
18637	8521	73	countries	country	NNS
18637	8521	74	,	,	,
18637	8521	75	and	and	CC
18637	8521	76	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	8521	77	with	with	IN
18637	8521	78	important	important	JJ
18637	8521	79	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	8521	80	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8521	81	between	between	IN
18637	8521	82	the	the	DT
18637	8521	83	two	two	CD
18637	8521	84	countries	country	NNS
18637	8521	85	,	,	,
18637	8521	86	and	and	CC
18637	8521	87	was	be	VBD
18637	8521	88	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
18637	8521	89	by	by	IN
18637	8521	90	the	the	DT
18637	8521	91	President	President	NNP
18637	8521	92	.	.	.
18637	8522	1	If	if	IN
18637	8522	2	not	not	RB
18637	8522	3	technically	technically	RB
18637	8522	4	a	a	DT
18637	8522	5	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8522	6	requiring	require	VBG
18637	8522	7	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	8522	8	,	,	,
18637	8522	9	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	8522	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8522	11	was	be	VBD
18637	8522	12	a	a	DT
18637	8522	13	compact	compact	NN
18637	8522	14	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8522	15	by	by	IN
18637	8522	16	the	the	DT
18637	8522	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8522	18	of	of	IN
18637	8522	19	the	the	DT
18637	8522	20	United	United	NNP
18637	8522	21	States	States	NNP
18637	8522	22	,	,	,
18637	8522	23	negotiated	negotiate	VBD
18637	8522	24	and	and	CC
18637	8522	25	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
18637	8522	26	under	under	IN
18637	8522	27	the	the	DT
18637	8522	28	authority	authority	NN
18637	8522	29	of	of	IN
18637	8522	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8522	31	President	President	NNP
18637	8522	32	.	.	.
18637	8523	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8523	2	think	think	VBP
18637	8523	3	such	such	PDT
18637	8523	4	a	a	DT
18637	8523	5	compact	compact	NN
18637	8523	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	8523	7	a	a	DT
18637	8523	8	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8523	9	under	under	IN
18637	8523	10	the	the	DT
18637	8523	11	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
18637	8523	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8523	13	of	of	IN
18637	8523	14	Appeals	Appeals	NNP
18637	8523	15	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8523	16	,	,	,
18637	8523	17	and	and	CC
18637	8523	18	,	,	,
18637	8523	19	where	where	WRB
18637	8523	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8523	21	construction	construction	NN
18637	8523	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	8523	23	directly	directly	RB
18637	8523	24	involved	involve	VBN
18637	8523	25	,	,	,
18637	8523	26	as	as	IN
18637	8523	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8523	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	8523	29	here	here	RB
18637	8523	30	,	,	,
18637	8523	31	there	there	EX
18637	8523	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	8523	33	a	a	DT
18637	8523	34	right	right	NN
18637	8523	35	of	of	IN
18637	8523	36	review	review	NN
18637	8523	37	by	by	IN
18637	8523	38	direct	direct	JJ
18637	8523	39	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	8523	40	to	to	IN
18637	8523	41	this	this	DT
18637	8523	42	court	court	NN
18637	8523	43	.	.	.
18637	8524	1	"	"	``
18637	8524	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8524	3	261	261	CD
18637	8524	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8524	5	The	the	DT
18637	8524	6	Lend	lend	VB
18637	8524	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	8524	8	Lease	Lease	NNP
18637	8524	9	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8524	10	The	the	DT
18637	8524	11	most	most	RBS
18637	8524	12	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	8524	13	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	8524	14	of	of	IN
18637	8524	15	authority	authority	NN
18637	8524	16	ever	ever	RB
18637	8524	17	made	make	VBN
18637	8524	18	by	by	IN
18637	8524	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8524	20	to	to	IN
18637	8524	21	the	the	DT
18637	8524	22	President	President	NNP
18637	8524	23	to	to	TO
18637	8524	24	enter	enter	VB
18637	8524	25	into	into	IN
18637	8524	26	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8524	27	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8524	28	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	8524	29	within	within	IN
18637	8524	30	the	the	DT
18637	8524	31	field	field	NN
18637	8524	32	of	of	IN
18637	8524	33	the	the	DT
18637	8524	34	cognate	cognate	NN
18637	8524	35	powers	power	NNS
18637	8524	36	of	of	IN
18637	8524	37	the	the	DT
18637	8524	38	two	two	CD
18637	8524	39	departments	department	NNS
18637	8524	40	,	,	,
18637	8524	41	the	the	DT
18637	8524	42	field	field	NN
18637	8524	43	of	of	IN
18637	8524	44	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8524	45	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8524	46	;	;	,
18637	8524	47	and	and	CC
18637	8524	48	took	take	VBD
18637	8524	49	place	place	NN
18637	8524	50	at	at	IN
18637	8524	51	a	a	DT
18637	8524	52	time	time	NN
18637	8524	53	when	when	WRB
18637	8524	54	war	war	NN
18637	8524	55	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	8524	56	to	to	TO
18637	8524	57	be	be	VB
18637	8524	58	in	in	IN
18637	8524	59	the	the	DT
18637	8524	60	offing	offing	NN
18637	8524	61	,	,	,
18637	8524	62	and	and	CC
18637	8524	63	was	be	VBD
18637	8524	64	in	in	IN
18637	8524	65	fact	fact	NN
18637	8524	66	only	only	RB
18637	8524	67	a	a	DT
18637	8524	68	few	few	JJ
18637	8524	69	months	month	NNS
18637	8524	70	away	away	RB
18637	8524	71	.	.	.
18637	8525	1	The	the	DT
18637	8525	2	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8525	3	referred	refer	VBD
18637	8525	4	to	to	IN
18637	8525	5	was	be	VBD
18637	8525	6	the	the	DT
18637	8525	7	Lend	Lend	NNP
18637	8525	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	8525	9	Lease	Lease	NNP
18637	8525	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8525	11	of	of	IN
18637	8525	12	March	March	NNP
18637	8525	13	11	11	CD
18637	8525	14	,	,	,
18637	8525	15	1941[262	1941[262	CD
18637	8525	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8525	17	by	by	IN
18637	8525	18	which	which	WDT
18637	8525	19	the	the	DT
18637	8525	20	President	President	NNP
18637	8525	21	was	be	VBD
18637	8525	22	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	8525	23	for	for	IN
18637	8525	24	something	something	NN
18637	8525	25	over	over	IN
18637	8525	26	two	two	CD
18637	8525	27	years	year	NNS
18637	8525	28	--	--	:
18637	8525	29	and	and	CC
18637	8525	30	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	8525	31	for	for	IN
18637	8525	32	additional	additional	JJ
18637	8525	33	periods	period	NNS
18637	8525	34	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	8525	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8525	36	deemed	deem	VBD
18637	8525	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8525	38	in	in	IN
18637	8525	39	the	the	DT
18637	8525	40	interest	interest	NN
18637	8525	41	of	of	IN
18637	8525	42	the	the	DT
18637	8525	43	national	national	JJ
18637	8525	44	defense	defense	NN
18637	8525	45	to	to	TO
18637	8525	46	do	do	VB
18637	8525	47	so	so	RB
18637	8525	48	,	,	,
18637	8525	49	to	to	TO
18637	8525	50	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	8525	51	"	"	``
18637	8525	52	the	the	DT
18637	8525	53	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8525	54	of	of	IN
18637	8525	55	War	War	NNP
18637	8525	56	,	,	,
18637	8525	57	the	the	DT
18637	8525	58	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8525	59	of	of	IN
18637	8525	60	the	the	DT
18637	8525	61	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	8525	62	,	,	,
18637	8525	63	or	or	CC
18637	8525	64	the	the	DT
18637	8525	65	head	head	NN
18637	8525	66	of	of	IN
18637	8525	67	any	any	DT
18637	8525	68	other	other	JJ
18637	8525	69	department	department	NN
18637	8525	70	or	or	CC
18637	8525	71	agency	agency	NN
18637	8525	72	of	of	IN
18637	8525	73	the	the	DT
18637	8525	74	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8525	75	,	,	,
18637	8525	76	"	"	''
18637	8525	77	to	to	TO
18637	8525	78	manufacture	manufacture	VB
18637	8525	79	in	in	IN
18637	8525	80	the	the	DT
18637	8525	81	government	government	NN
18637	8525	82	arsenals	arsenal	NNS
18637	8525	83	,	,	,
18637	8525	84	factories	factory	NNS
18637	8525	85	,	,	,
18637	8525	86	and	and	CC
18637	8525	87	shipyards	shipyard	NNS
18637	8525	88	,	,	,
18637	8525	89	or	or	CC
18637	8525	90	"	"	``
18637	8525	91	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	8525	92	procure	procure	NN
18637	8525	93	,	,	,
18637	8525	94	"	"	''
18637	8525	95	to	to	IN
18637	8525	96	the	the	DT
18637	8525	97	extent	extent	NN
18637	8525	98	that	that	IN
18637	8525	99	available	available	JJ
18637	8525	100	funds	fund	NNS
18637	8525	101	made	make	VBD
18637	8525	102	possible	possible	JJ
18637	8525	103	,	,	,
18637	8525	104	"	"	''
18637	8525	105	defense	defense	NN
18637	8525	106	articles"--later	articles"--later	NNP
18637	8525	107	amended	amend	VBN
18637	8525	108	to	to	TO
18637	8525	109	include	include	VB
18637	8525	110	foodstuffs	foodstuff	NNS
18637	8525	111	and	and	CC
18637	8525	112	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	8525	113	products	product	NNS
18637	8525	114	--	--	:
18637	8525	115	and	and	CC
18637	8525	116	"	"	``
18637	8525	117	sell	sell	VB
18637	8525	118	,	,	,
18637	8525	119	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	8525	120	title	title	NN
18637	8525	121	to	to	IN
18637	8525	122	,	,	,
18637	8525	123	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	8525	124	,	,	,
18637	8525	125	lease	lease	NN
18637	8525	126	,	,	,
18637	8525	127	lend	lend	VB
18637	8525	128	,	,	,
18637	8525	129	or	or	CC
18637	8525	130	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	8525	131	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	8525	132	of	of	IN
18637	8525	133	,	,	,
18637	8525	134	"	"	''
18637	8525	135	the	the	DT
18637	8525	136	same	same	JJ
18637	8525	137	to	to	IN
18637	8525	138	the	the	DT
18637	8525	139	"	"	``
18637	8525	140	government	government	NN
18637	8525	141	of	of	IN
18637	8525	142	any	any	DT
18637	8525	143	country	country	NN
18637	8525	144	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8525	145	defense	defense	NN
18637	8525	146	the	the	DT
18637	8525	147	President	President	NNP
18637	8525	148	deems	deem	VBZ
18637	8525	149	vital	vital	JJ
18637	8525	150	to	to	IN
18637	8525	151	the	the	DT
18637	8525	152	defense	defense	NN
18637	8525	153	of	of	IN
18637	8525	154	the	the	DT
18637	8525	155	United	United	NNP
18637	8525	156	States	States	NNP
18637	8525	157	,	,	,
18637	8525	158	"	"	''
18637	8525	159	and	and	CC
18637	8525	160	on	on	IN
18637	8525	161	any	any	DT
18637	8525	162	terms	term	NNS
18637	8525	163	that	that	IN
18637	8525	164	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8525	165	"	"	``
18637	8525	166	deems	deem	VBZ
18637	8525	167	satisfactory	satisfactory	JJ
18637	8525	168	.	.	.
18637	8525	169	"	"	''
18637	8526	1	Under	under	IN
18637	8526	2	this	this	DT
18637	8526	3	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	8526	4	the	the	DT
18637	8526	5	United	United	NNP
18637	8526	6	States	States	NNP
18637	8526	7	entered	enter	VBD
18637	8526	8	into	into	IN
18637	8526	9	Mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	8526	10	Aid	Aid	NNP
18637	8526	11	Agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8526	12	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	8526	13	the	the	DT
18637	8526	14	government	government	NN
18637	8526	15	furnished	furnish	VBD
18637	8526	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8526	17	allies	ally	NNS
18637	8526	18	in	in	IN
18637	8526	19	the	the	DT
18637	8526	20	recent	recent	JJ
18637	8526	21	war	war	NN
18637	8526	22	forty	forty	CD
18637	8526	23	billions	billion	NNS
18637	8526	24	of	of	IN
18637	8526	25	dollars	dollar	NNS
18637	8526	26	worth	worth	JJ
18637	8526	27	of	of	IN
18637	8526	28	munitions	munition	NNS
18637	8526	29	of	of	IN
18637	8526	30	war	war	NN
18637	8526	31	and	and	CC
18637	8526	32	other	other	JJ
18637	8526	33	supplies	supply	NNS
18637	8526	34	.	.	.
18637	8527	1	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	8527	2	PLUS	PLUS	NNP
18637	8527	3	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	8527	4	VERSUS	VERSUS	NNP
18637	8527	5	SENATE	SENATE	NNP
18637	8527	6	The	the	DT
18637	8527	7	partnership	partnership	NN
18637	8527	8	which	which	WDT
18637	8527	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	8527	10	developed	develop	VBN
18637	8527	11	within	within	IN
18637	8527	12	recent	recent	JJ
18637	8527	13	decades	decade	NNS
18637	8527	14	between	between	IN
18637	8527	15	the	the	DT
18637	8527	16	President	President	NNP
18637	8527	17	and	and	CC
18637	8527	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8527	19	within	within	IN
18637	8527	20	the	the	DT
18637	8527	21	field	field	NN
18637	8527	22	of	of	IN
18637	8527	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8527	24	cognate	cognate	NN
18637	8527	25	powers	power	NNS
18637	8527	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	8527	27	also	also	RB
18637	8527	28	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
18637	8527	29	by	by	IN
18637	8527	30	the	the	DT
18637	8527	31	act	act	NN
18637	8527	32	of	of	IN
18637	8527	33	February	February	NNP
18637	8527	34	9	9	CD
18637	8527	35	,	,	,
18637	8527	36	1922	1922	CD
18637	8527	37	,	,	,
18637	8527	38	creating	create	VBG
18637	8527	39	a	a	DT
18637	8527	40	commission	commission	NN
18637	8527	41	to	to	TO
18637	8527	42	effect	effect	VB
18637	8527	43	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8527	44	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	8527	45	debts	debt	NNS
18637	8527	46	owed	owe	VBD
18637	8527	47	this	this	DT
18637	8527	48	country	country	NN
18637	8527	49	by	by	IN
18637	8527	50	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8527	51	other	other	JJ
18637	8527	52	governments	government	NNS
18637	8527	53	,	,	,
18637	8527	54	the	the	DT
18637	8527	55	resulting	result	VBG
18637	8527	56	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8527	57	to	to	TO
18637	8527	58	be	be	VB
18637	8527	59	approved	approve	VBN
18637	8527	60	by	by	IN
18637	8527	61	Congress;[263	Congress;[263	NNP
18637	8527	62	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8527	63	by	by	IN
18637	8527	64	the	the	DT
18637	8527	65	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	8527	66	attending	attend	VBG
18637	8527	67	the	the	DT
18637	8527	68	drawing	drawing	NN
18637	8527	69	up	up	RP
18637	8527	70	in	in	IN
18637	8527	71	1944	1944	CD
18637	8527	72	of	of	IN
18637	8527	73	the	the	DT
18637	8527	74	United	United	NNP
18637	8527	75	Nations	Nations	NNP
18637	8527	76	Relief	Relief	NNP
18637	8527	77	and	and	CC
18637	8527	78	Rehabilitation	rehabilitation	NN
18637	8527	79	Convention;[264	Convention;[264	NNS
18637	8527	80	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8527	81	by	by	IN
18637	8527	82	the	the	DT
18637	8527	83	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	8527	84	Resolution	Resolution	NNP
18637	8527	85	of	of	IN
18637	8527	86	June	June	NNP
18637	8527	87	19	19	CD
18637	8527	88	,	,	,
18637	8527	89	1934	1934	CD
18637	8527	90	,	,	,
18637	8527	91	by	by	IN
18637	8527	92	which	which	WDT
18637	8527	93	the	the	DT
18637	8527	94	President	President	NNP
18637	8527	95	was	be	VBD
18637	8527	96	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8527	97	to	to	TO
18637	8527	98	accept	accept	VB
18637	8527	99	membership	membership	NN
18637	8527	100	for	for	IN
18637	8527	101	the	the	DT
18637	8527	102	United	United	NNP
18637	8527	103	States	States	NNP
18637	8527	104	in	in	IN
18637	8527	105	the	the	DT
18637	8527	106	International	International	NNP
18637	8527	107	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8527	108	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8527	109	.	.	.
18637	8528	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8528	2	265	265	CD
18637	8528	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8528	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8528	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	8528	6	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	8528	7	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	8528	8	in	in	IN
18637	8528	9	view	view	NN
18637	8528	10	of	of	IN
18637	8528	11	developments	development	NNS
18637	8528	12	like	like	IN
18637	8528	13	these	these	DT
18637	8528	14	that	that	WDT
18637	8528	15	the	the	DT
18637	8528	16	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8528	17	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8528	18	power	power	NN
18637	8528	19	,	,	,
18637	8528	20	especially	especially	RB
18637	8528	21	when	when	WRB
18637	8528	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8528	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	8528	24	supported	support	VBN
18637	8528	25	by	by	IN
18637	8528	26	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	8528	27	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8528	28	,	,	,
18637	8528	29	today	today	NN
18637	8528	30	overlaps	overlap	VBZ
18637	8528	31	the	the	DT
18637	8528	32	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8528	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	8528	34	making	make	VBG
18637	8528	35	power	power	NN
18637	8528	36	.	.	.
18637	8529	1	ARBITRATION	ARBITRATION	NNP
18637	8529	2	AGREEMENTS	AGREEMENTS	NNP
18637	8529	3	In	in	IN
18637	8529	4	1904	1904	CD
18637	8529	5	-	-	SYM
18637	8529	6	1905	1905	CD
18637	8529	7	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8529	8	of	of	IN
18637	8529	9	State	State	NNP
18637	8529	10	John	John	NNP
18637	8529	11	Hay	Hay	NNP
18637	8529	12	negotiated	negotiate	VBD
18637	8529	13	a	a	DT
18637	8529	14	series	series	NN
18637	8529	15	of	of	IN
18637	8529	16	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8529	17	providing	provide	VBG
18637	8529	18	for	for	IN
18637	8529	19	the	the	DT
18637	8529	20	general	general	JJ
18637	8529	21	arbitration	arbitration	NN
18637	8529	22	of	of	IN
18637	8529	23	international	international	JJ
18637	8529	24	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	8529	25	.	.	.
18637	8530	1	Article	Article	NNP
18637	8530	2	II	ii	CD
18637	8530	3	of	of	IN
18637	8530	4	the	the	DT
18637	8530	5	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8530	6	with	with	IN
18637	8530	7	Great	Great	NNP
18637	8530	8	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	8530	9	,	,	,
18637	8530	10	for	for	IN
18637	8530	11	example	example	NN
18637	8530	12	,	,	,
18637	8530	13	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8530	14	as	as	IN
18637	8530	15	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	8530	16	:	:	:
18637	8530	17	"	"	``
18637	8530	18	In	in	IN
18637	8530	19	each	each	DT
18637	8530	20	individual	individual	JJ
18637	8530	21	case	case	NN
18637	8530	22	the	the	DT
18637	8530	23	High	High	NNP
18637	8530	24	Contracting	Contracting	NNP
18637	8530	25	Parties	Parties	NNPS
18637	8530	26	,	,	,
18637	8530	27	before	before	IN
18637	8530	28	appealing	appeal	VBG
18637	8530	29	to	to	IN
18637	8530	30	the	the	DT
18637	8530	31	Permanent	Permanent	NNP
18637	8530	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8530	33	of	of	IN
18637	8530	34	Arbitration	Arbitration	NNP
18637	8530	35	,	,	,
18637	8530	36	shall	shall	MD
18637	8530	37	conclude	conclude	VB
18637	8530	38	a	a	DT
18637	8530	39	special	special	JJ
18637	8530	40	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	8530	41	defining	define	VBG
18637	8530	42	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	8530	43	the	the	DT
18637	8530	44	matter	matter	NN
18637	8530	45	in	in	IN
18637	8530	46	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	8530	47	and	and	CC
18637	8530	48	the	the	DT
18637	8530	49	scope	scope	NN
18637	8530	50	of	of	IN
18637	8530	51	the	the	DT
18637	8530	52	powers	power	NNS
18637	8530	53	of	of	IN
18637	8530	54	the	the	DT
18637	8530	55	Arbitrators	Arbitrators	NNPS
18637	8530	56	,	,	,
18637	8530	57	and	and	CC
18637	8530	58	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	8530	59	the	the	DT
18637	8530	60	periods	period	NNS
18637	8530	61	for	for	IN
18637	8530	62	the	the	DT
18637	8530	63	formation	formation	NN
18637	8530	64	of	of	IN
18637	8530	65	the	the	DT
18637	8530	66	Arbitral	Arbitral	NNP
18637	8530	67	Tribunal	Tribunal	NNP
18637	8530	68	and	and	CC
18637	8530	69	the	the	DT
18637	8530	70	several	several	JJ
18637	8530	71	stages	stage	NNS
18637	8530	72	of	of	IN
18637	8530	73	the	the	DT
18637	8530	74	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	8530	75	.	.	.
18637	8531	1	"	"	``
18637	8531	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8531	3	266	266	CD
18637	8531	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8531	5	The	the	DT
18637	8531	6	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8531	7	approved	approve	VBD
18637	8531	8	the	the	DT
18637	8531	9	British	british	JJ
18637	8531	10	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8531	11	by	by	IN
18637	8531	12	the	the	DT
18637	8531	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8531	14	majority	majority	NN
18637	8531	15	having	have	VBG
18637	8531	16	,	,	,
18637	8531	17	however	however	RB
18637	8531	18	,	,	,
18637	8531	19	first	first	RB
18637	8531	20	amended	amend	VBD
18637	8531	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8531	22	by	by	IN
18637	8531	23	substituting	substitute	VBG
18637	8531	24	the	the	DT
18637	8531	25	word	word	NN
18637	8531	26	"	"	``
18637	8531	27	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8531	28	"	"	''
18637	8531	29	for	for	IN
18637	8531	30	"	"	``
18637	8531	31	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8531	32	.	.	.
18637	8531	33	"	"	''
18637	8532	1	President	President	NNP
18637	8532	2	Theodore	Theodore	NNP
18637	8532	3	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8532	4	,	,	,
18637	8532	5	characterizing	characterize	VBG
18637	8532	6	the	the	DT
18637	8532	7	"	"	``
18637	8532	8	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	8532	9	"	"	''
18637	8532	10	as	as	IN
18637	8532	11	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
18637	8532	12	to	to	IN
18637	8532	13	rejection	rejection	NN
18637	8532	14	,	,	,
18637	8532	15	sent	send	VBD
18637	8532	16	the	the	DT
18637	8532	17	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8532	18	to	to	TO
18637	8532	19	repose	repose	VB
18637	8532	20	in	in	IN
18637	8532	21	the	the	DT
18637	8532	22	archives	archive	NNS
18637	8532	23	.	.	.
18637	8533	1	"	"	``
18637	8533	2	As	as	IN
18637	8533	3	a	a	DT
18637	8533	4	matter	matter	NN
18637	8533	5	of	of	IN
18637	8533	6	historical	historical	JJ
18637	8533	7	practice	practice	NN
18637	8533	8	,	,	,
18637	8533	9	"	"	''
18637	8533	10	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
18637	8533	11	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	8533	12	comments	comment	VBZ
18637	8533	13	,	,	,
18637	8533	14	"	"	''
18637	8533	15	the	the	DT
18637	8533	16	_	_	NNP
18637	8533	17	compromis	compromis	NN
18637	8533	18	_	_	NNP
18637	8533	19	under	under	IN
18637	8533	20	which	which	WDT
18637	8533	21	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	8533	22	have	have	VBP
18637	8533	23	been	be	VBN
18637	8533	24	arbitrated	arbitrate	VBN
18637	8533	25	include	include	VBP
18637	8533	26	both	both	DT
18637	8533	27	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8533	28	and	and	CC
18637	8533	29	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8533	30	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8533	31	in	in	IN
18637	8533	32	goodly	goodly	RB
18637	8533	33	numbers,"[267	numbers,"[267	JJ
18637	8533	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8533	35	a	a	DT
18637	8533	36	statement	statement	NN
18637	8533	37	supported	support	VBN
18637	8533	38	by	by	IN
18637	8533	39	both	both	DT
18637	8533	40	Willoughby	Willoughby	NNP
18637	8533	41	and	and	CC
18637	8533	42	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	8533	43	.	.	.
18637	8534	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8534	2	268	268	CD
18637	8534	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8534	4	AGREEMENTS	agreement	NNS
18637	8534	5	UNDER	under	IN
18637	8534	6	THE	the	DT
18637	8534	7	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	8534	8	NATIONS	NATIONS	NNP
18637	8534	9	CHARTER	CHARTER	NNP
18637	8534	10	Article	Article	NNP
18637	8534	11	43	43	CD
18637	8534	12	of	of	IN
18637	8534	13	the	the	DT
18637	8534	14	United	United	NNP
18637	8534	15	Nations	Nations	NNPS
18637	8534	16	Charter	Charter	NNP
18637	8534	17	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	8534	18	:	:	:
18637	8534	19	"	"	``
18637	8534	20	1	1	CD
18637	8534	21	.	.	.
18637	8535	1	All	all	DT
18637	8535	2	Members	member	NNS
18637	8535	3	of	of	IN
18637	8535	4	the	the	DT
18637	8535	5	United	United	NNP
18637	8535	6	Nations	Nations	NNP
18637	8535	7	,	,	,
18637	8535	8	in	in	IN
18637	8535	9	order	order	NN
18637	8535	10	to	to	TO
18637	8535	11	contribute	contribute	VB
18637	8535	12	to	to	IN
18637	8535	13	the	the	DT
18637	8535	14	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	8535	15	of	of	IN
18637	8535	16	international	international	JJ
18637	8535	17	peace	peace	NN
18637	8535	18	and	and	CC
18637	8535	19	security	security	NN
18637	8535	20	,	,	,
18637	8535	21	undertake	undertake	VBP
18637	8535	22	to	to	TO
18637	8535	23	make	make	VB
18637	8535	24	available	available	JJ
18637	8535	25	to	to	IN
18637	8535	26	the	the	DT
18637	8535	27	Security	Security	NNP
18637	8535	28	Council	Council	NNP
18637	8535	29	,	,	,
18637	8535	30	on	on	IN
18637	8535	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8535	32	call	call	NN
18637	8535	33	and	and	CC
18637	8535	34	in	in	IN
18637	8535	35	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	8535	36	with	with	IN
18637	8535	37	a	a	DT
18637	8535	38	special	special	JJ
18637	8535	39	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8535	40	or	or	CC
18637	8535	41	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8535	42	,	,	,
18637	8535	43	armed	armed	JJ
18637	8535	44	forces	force	NNS
18637	8535	45	,	,	,
18637	8535	46	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	8535	47	,	,	,
18637	8535	48	and	and	CC
18637	8535	49	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	8535	50	,	,	,
18637	8535	51	including	include	VBG
18637	8535	52	rights	right	NNS
18637	8535	53	of	of	IN
18637	8535	54	passage	passage	NN
18637	8535	55	,	,	,
18637	8535	56	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8535	57	for	for	IN
18637	8535	58	the	the	DT
18637	8535	59	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8535	60	of	of	IN
18637	8535	61	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	8535	62	international	international	JJ
18637	8535	63	peace	peace	NN
18637	8535	64	and	and	CC
18637	8535	65	security	security	NN
18637	8535	66	.	.	.
18637	8536	1	2	2	LS
18637	8536	2	.	.	.
18637	8537	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	8537	2	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8537	3	or	or	CC
18637	8537	4	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8537	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	8537	6	govern	govern	VB
18637	8537	7	the	the	DT
18637	8537	8	numbers	number	NNS
18637	8537	9	and	and	CC
18637	8537	10	types	type	NNS
18637	8537	11	of	of	IN
18637	8537	12	forces	force	NNS
18637	8537	13	,	,	,
18637	8537	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8537	15	degree	degree	NN
18637	8537	16	of	of	IN
18637	8537	17	readiness	readiness	NN
18637	8537	18	and	and	CC
18637	8537	19	general	general	JJ
18637	8537	20	location	location	NN
18637	8537	21	,	,	,
18637	8537	22	and	and	CC
18637	8537	23	the	the	DT
18637	8537	24	nature	nature	NN
18637	8537	25	of	of	IN
18637	8537	26	the	the	DT
18637	8537	27	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	8537	28	and	and	CC
18637	8537	29	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	8537	30	to	to	TO
18637	8537	31	be	be	VB
18637	8537	32	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8537	33	.	.	.
18637	8538	1	3	3	LS
18637	8538	2	.	.	.
18637	8539	1	The	the	DT
18637	8539	2	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8539	3	or	or	CC
18637	8539	4	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8539	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	8539	6	be	be	VB
18637	8539	7	negotiated	negotiate	VBN
18637	8539	8	as	as	RB
18637	8539	9	soon	soon	RB
18637	8539	10	as	as	IN
18637	8539	11	possible	possible	JJ
18637	8539	12	on	on	IN
18637	8539	13	the	the	DT
18637	8539	14	initiative	initiative	NN
18637	8539	15	of	of	IN
18637	8539	16	the	the	DT
18637	8539	17	Security	Security	NNP
18637	8539	18	Council	Council	NNP
18637	8539	19	.	.	.
18637	8540	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8540	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	8540	3	be	be	VB
18637	8540	4	concluded	conclude	VBN
18637	8540	5	between	between	IN
18637	8540	6	the	the	DT
18637	8540	7	Security	Security	NNP
18637	8540	8	Council	Council	NNP
18637	8540	9	and	and	CC
18637	8540	10	Members	Members	NNP
18637	8540	11	or	or	CC
18637	8540	12	between	between	IN
18637	8540	13	the	the	DT
18637	8540	14	Security	Security	NNP
18637	8540	15	Council	Council	NNP
18637	8540	16	and	and	CC
18637	8540	17	groups	group	NNS
18637	8540	18	of	of	IN
18637	8540	19	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	8540	20	and	and	CC
18637	8540	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	8540	22	be	be	VB
18637	8540	23	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8540	24	to	to	IN
18637	8540	25	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	8540	26	by	by	IN
18637	8540	27	the	the	DT
18637	8540	28	signatory	signatory	NN
18637	8540	29	states	state	NNS
18637	8540	30	in	in	IN
18637	8540	31	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	8540	32	with	with	IN
18637	8540	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8540	34	respective	respective	JJ
18637	8540	35	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8540	36	processes	process	NNS
18637	8540	37	.	.	.
18637	8541	1	"	"	``
18637	8541	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8541	3	269	269	CD
18637	8541	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8541	5	This	this	DT
18637	8541	6	time	time	NN
18637	8541	7	the	the	DT
18637	8541	8	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8541	9	did	do	VBD
18637	8541	10	not	not	RB
18637	8541	11	boggle	boggle	VB
18637	8541	12	over	over	IN
18637	8541	13	the	the	DT
18637	8541	14	word	word	NN
18637	8541	15	"	"	''
18637	8541	16	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8541	17	.	.	.
18637	8541	18	"	"	''
18637	8542	1	The	the	DT
18637	8542	2	United	United	NNP
18637	8542	3	Nations	Nations	NNP
18637	8542	4	Participation	Participation	NNP
18637	8542	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8542	6	The	the	DT
18637	8542	7	United	United	NNP
18637	8542	8	Nations	Nations	NNP
18637	8542	9	Participation	Participation	NNP
18637	8542	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8542	11	of	of	IN
18637	8542	12	December	December	NNP
18637	8542	13	20	20	CD
18637	8542	14	,	,	,
18637	8542	15	1945	1945	CD
18637	8542	16	implements	implement	VBZ
18637	8542	17	these	these	DT
18637	8542	18	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8542	19	as	as	IN
18637	8542	20	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	8542	21	:	:	:
18637	8542	22	"	"	``
18637	8542	23	The	the	DT
18637	8542	24	President	President	NNP
18637	8542	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	8542	26	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8542	27	to	to	TO
18637	8542	28	negotiate	negotiate	VB
18637	8542	29	a	a	DT
18637	8542	30	special	special	JJ
18637	8542	31	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8542	32	or	or	CC
18637	8542	33	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8542	34	with	with	IN
18637	8542	35	the	the	DT
18637	8542	36	Security	Security	NNP
18637	8542	37	Council	Council	NNP
18637	8542	38	which	which	WDT
18637	8542	39	shall	shall	MD
18637	8542	40	be	be	VB
18637	8542	41	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8542	42	to	to	IN
18637	8542	43	the	the	DT
18637	8542	44	approval	approval	NN
18637	8542	45	of	of	IN
18637	8542	46	the	the	DT
18637	8542	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8542	48	by	by	IN
18637	8542	49	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	8542	50	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8542	51	or	or	CC
18637	8542	52	joint	joint	JJ
18637	8542	53	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	8542	54	,	,	,
18637	8542	55	providing	provide	VBG
18637	8542	56	for	for	IN
18637	8542	57	the	the	DT
18637	8542	58	numbers	number	NNS
18637	8542	59	and	and	CC
18637	8542	60	types	type	NNS
18637	8542	61	of	of	IN
18637	8542	62	armed	armed	JJ
18637	8542	63	forces	force	NNS
18637	8542	64	,	,	,
18637	8542	65	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8542	66	degree	degree	NN
18637	8542	67	of	of	IN
18637	8542	68	readiness	readiness	NN
18637	8542	69	and	and	CC
18637	8542	70	general	general	JJ
18637	8542	71	location	location	NN
18637	8542	72	,	,	,
18637	8542	73	and	and	CC
18637	8542	74	the	the	DT
18637	8542	75	nature	nature	NN
18637	8542	76	of	of	IN
18637	8542	77	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	8542	78	and	and	CC
18637	8542	79	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	8542	80	,	,	,
18637	8542	81	including	include	VBG
18637	8542	82	rights	right	NNS
18637	8542	83	of	of	IN
18637	8542	84	passage	passage	NN
18637	8542	85	,	,	,
18637	8542	86	to	to	TO
18637	8542	87	be	be	VB
18637	8542	88	made	make	VBN
18637	8542	89	available	available	JJ
18637	8542	90	to	to	IN
18637	8542	91	the	the	DT
18637	8542	92	Security	Security	NNP
18637	8542	93	Council	Council	NNP
18637	8542	94	on	on	IN
18637	8542	95	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8542	96	call	call	NN
18637	8542	97	for	for	IN
18637	8542	98	the	the	DT
18637	8542	99	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8542	100	of	of	IN
18637	8542	101	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	8542	102	international	international	JJ
18637	8542	103	peace	peace	NN
18637	8542	104	and	and	CC
18637	8542	105	security	security	NN
18637	8542	106	in	in	IN
18637	8542	107	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	8542	108	with	with	IN
18637	8542	109	article	article	NN
18637	8542	110	43	43	CD
18637	8542	111	of	of	IN
18637	8542	112	said	say	VBD
18637	8542	113	Charter	Charter	NNP
18637	8542	114	.	.	.
18637	8543	1	The	the	DT
18637	8543	2	President	President	NNP
18637	8543	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	8543	4	not	not	RB
18637	8543	5	be	be	VB
18637	8543	6	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	8543	7	to	to	TO
18637	8543	8	require	require	VB
18637	8543	9	the	the	DT
18637	8543	10	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	8543	11	of	of	IN
18637	8543	12	the	the	DT
18637	8543	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8543	14	to	to	TO
18637	8543	15	make	make	VB
18637	8543	16	available	available	JJ
18637	8543	17	to	to	IN
18637	8543	18	the	the	DT
18637	8543	19	Security	Security	NNP
18637	8543	20	Council	Council	NNP
18637	8543	21	on	on	IN
18637	8543	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8543	23	call	call	NN
18637	8543	24	in	in	IN
18637	8543	25	order	order	NN
18637	8543	26	to	to	TO
18637	8543	27	take	take	VB
18637	8543	28	action	action	NN
18637	8543	29	under	under	IN
18637	8543	30	article	article	NN
18637	8543	31	42	42	CD
18637	8543	32	of	of	IN
18637	8543	33	said	say	VBN
18637	8543	34	Charter	Charter	NNP
18637	8543	35	and	and	CC
18637	8543	36	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	8543	37	to	to	IN
18637	8543	38	such	such	JJ
18637	8543	39	special	special	JJ
18637	8543	40	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8543	41	or	or	CC
18637	8543	42	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8543	43	the	the	DT
18637	8543	44	armed	armed	JJ
18637	8543	45	forces	force	NNS
18637	8543	46	,	,	,
18637	8543	47	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	8543	48	,	,	,
18637	8543	49	or	or	CC
18637	8543	50	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	8543	51	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8543	52	for	for	IN
18637	8543	53	therein	therein	RB
18637	8543	54	:	:	:
18637	8543	55	_	_	NNP
18637	8543	56	Provided	Provided	NNP
18637	8543	57	_	_	NNP
18637	8543	58	,	,	,
18637	8543	59	That	that	IN
18637	8543	60	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	8543	61	herein	herein	RB
18637	8543	62	contained	contain	VBD
18637	8543	63	shall	shall	MD
18637	8543	64	be	be	VB
18637	8543	65	construed	construe	VBN
18637	8543	66	as	as	IN
18637	8543	67	an	an	DT
18637	8543	68	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	8543	69	to	to	IN
18637	8543	70	the	the	DT
18637	8543	71	President	President	NNP
18637	8543	72	by	by	IN
18637	8543	73	the	the	DT
18637	8543	74	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8543	75	to	to	TO
18637	8543	76	make	make	VB
18637	8543	77	available	available	JJ
18637	8543	78	to	to	IN
18637	8543	79	the	the	DT
18637	8543	80	Security	Security	NNP
18637	8543	81	Council	Council	NNP
18637	8543	82	for	for	IN
18637	8543	83	such	such	JJ
18637	8543	84	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8543	85	armed	armed	JJ
18637	8543	86	forces	force	NNS
18637	8543	87	,	,	,
18637	8543	88	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	8543	89	,	,	,
18637	8543	90	or	or	CC
18637	8543	91	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	8543	92	in	in	IN
18637	8543	93	addition	addition	NN
18637	8543	94	to	to	IN
18637	8543	95	the	the	DT
18637	8543	96	forces	force	NNS
18637	8543	97	,	,	,
18637	8543	98	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	8543	99	,	,	,
18637	8543	100	and	and	CC
18637	8543	101	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	8543	102	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8543	103	for	for	IN
18637	8543	104	in	in	IN
18637	8543	105	such	such	JJ
18637	8543	106	special	special	JJ
18637	8543	107	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8543	108	or	or	CC
18637	8543	109	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8543	110	.	.	.
18637	8544	1	"	"	``
18637	8544	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8544	3	270	270	CD
18637	8544	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8544	5	The	the	DT
18637	8544	6	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8544	7	Establishment	Establishment	NNP
18637	8544	8	"	"	''
18637	8544	9	OFFICE	OFFICE	NNP
18637	8544	10	"	"	''
18637	8544	11	"	"	''
18637	8544	12	An	an	DT
18637	8544	13	office	office	NN
18637	8544	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8544	15	a	a	DT
18637	8544	16	public	public	JJ
18637	8544	17	station	station	NN
18637	8544	18	,	,	,
18637	8544	19	or	or	CC
18637	8544	20	employment	employment	NN
18637	8544	21	,	,	,
18637	8544	22	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	8544	23	by	by	IN
18637	8544	24	the	the	DT
18637	8544	25	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8544	26	of	of	IN
18637	8544	27	government	government	NN
18637	8544	28	,	,	,
18637	8544	29	"	"	''
18637	8544	30	and	and	CC
18637	8544	31	"	"	``
18637	8544	32	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	8544	33	the	the	DT
18637	8544	34	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	8544	35	of	of	IN
18637	8544	36	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	8544	37	duration	duration	NN
18637	8544	38	,	,	,
18637	8544	39	emolument	emolument	NN
18637	8544	40	,	,	,
18637	8544	41	and	and	CC
18637	8544	42	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8544	43	.	.	.
18637	8545	1	"	"	``
18637	8545	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8545	3	271	271	CD
18637	8545	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8545	5	"	"	``
18637	8545	6	AMBASSADORS	AMBASSADORS	NNP
18637	8545	7	AND	and	CC
18637	8545	8	OTHER	other	JJ
18637	8545	9	PUBLIC	public	JJ
18637	8545	10	MINISTERS	minister	NNS
18637	8545	11	"	"	``
18637	8545	12	The	the	DT
18637	8545	13	term	term	NN
18637	8545	14	"	"	``
18637	8545	15	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	8545	16	and	and	CC
18637	8545	17	other	other	JJ
18637	8545	18	public	public	JJ
18637	8545	19	ministers	minister	NNS
18637	8545	20	,	,	,
18637	8545	21	"	"	``
18637	8545	22	comprehends	comprehend	VBZ
18637	8545	23	"	"	''
18637	8545	24	all	all	DT
18637	8545	25	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8545	26	having	have	VBG
18637	8545	27	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8545	28	functions	function	NNS
18637	8545	29	,	,	,
18637	8545	30	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	8545	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8545	32	title	title	NN
18637	8545	33	or	or	CC
18637	8545	34	designation	designation	NN
18637	8545	35	.	.	.
18637	8546	1	"	"	``
18637	8546	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8546	3	272	272	CD
18637	8546	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8546	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8546	6	was	be	VBD
18637	8546	7	originally	originally	RB
18637	8546	8	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	8546	9	that	that	IN
18637	8546	10	such	such	JJ
18637	8546	11	offices	office	NNS
18637	8546	12	were	be	VBD
18637	8546	13	established	establish	VBN
18637	8546	14	by	by	IN
18637	8546	15	the	the	DT
18637	8546	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8546	17	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8546	18	,	,	,
18637	8546	19	by	by	IN
18637	8546	20	reference	reference	NN
18637	8546	21	to	to	IN
18637	8546	22	the	the	DT
18637	8546	23	Law	Law	NNP
18637	8546	24	of	of	IN
18637	8546	25	Nations	Nations	NNPS
18637	8546	26	,	,	,
18637	8546	27	with	with	IN
18637	8546	28	the	the	DT
18637	8546	29	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	8546	30	that	that	IN
18637	8546	31	appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	8546	32	might	may	MD
18637	8546	33	be	be	VB
18637	8546	34	made	make	VBN
18637	8546	35	to	to	IN
18637	8546	36	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8546	37	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	8546	38	the	the	DT
18637	8546	39	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	8546	40	authority	authority	NN
18637	8546	41	--	--	:
18637	8546	42	the	the	DT
18637	8546	43	President	President	NNP
18637	8546	44	and	and	CC
18637	8546	45	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8546	46	--	--	:
18637	8546	47	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	8546	48	desirable	desirable	JJ
18637	8546	49	.	.	.
18637	8547	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8547	2	273	273	CD
18637	8547	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8547	4	During	during	IN
18637	8547	5	the	the	DT
18637	8547	6	first	first	JJ
18637	8547	7	sixty	sixty	CD
18637	8547	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	8547	9	five	five	CD
18637	8547	10	years	year	NNS
18637	8547	11	of	of	IN
18637	8547	12	the	the	DT
18637	8547	13	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8547	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8547	15	passed	pass	VBD
18637	8547	16	no	no	DT
18637	8547	17	act	act	NN
18637	8547	18	purporting	purport	VBG
18637	8547	19	to	to	TO
18637	8547	20	create	create	VB
18637	8547	21	any	any	DT
18637	8547	22	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8547	23	rank	rank	NN
18637	8547	24	,	,	,
18637	8547	25	the	the	DT
18637	8547	26	entire	entire	JJ
18637	8547	27	question	question	NN
18637	8547	28	of	of	IN
18637	8547	29	grades	grade	NNS
18637	8547	30	being	be	VBG
18637	8547	31	left	leave	VBN
18637	8547	32	with	with	IN
18637	8547	33	the	the	DT
18637	8547	34	President	President	NNP
18637	8547	35	.	.	.
18637	8548	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	8548	2	,	,	,
18637	8548	3	during	during	IN
18637	8548	4	the	the	DT
18637	8548	5	administrations	administration	NNS
18637	8548	6	of	of	IN
18637	8548	7	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	8548	8	,	,	,
18637	8548	9	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	8548	10	and	and	CC
18637	8548	11	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	8548	12	,	,	,
18637	8548	13	and	and	CC
18637	8548	14	the	the	DT
18637	8548	15	first	first	JJ
18637	8548	16	term	term	NN
18637	8548	17	of	of	IN
18637	8548	18	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8548	19	,	,	,
18637	8548	20	no	no	DT
18637	8548	21	mention	mention	NN
18637	8548	22	occurs	occur	VBZ
18637	8548	23	in	in	IN
18637	8548	24	any	any	DT
18637	8548	25	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	8548	26	act	act	NN
18637	8548	27	even	even	RB
18637	8548	28	,	,	,
18637	8548	29	of	of	IN
18637	8548	30	ministers	minister	NNS
18637	8548	31	of	of	IN
18637	8548	32	a	a	DT
18637	8548	33	specified	specify	VBN
18637	8548	34	rank	rank	NN
18637	8548	35	at	at	IN
18637	8548	36	this	this	DT
18637	8548	37	or	or	CC
18637	8548	38	that	that	DT
18637	8548	39	place	place	NN
18637	8548	40	,	,	,
18637	8548	41	but	but	CC
18637	8548	42	the	the	DT
18637	8548	43	provision	provision	NN
18637	8548	44	for	for	IN
18637	8548	45	the	the	DT
18637	8548	46	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8548	47	corps	corps	NN
18637	8548	48	consisted	consist	VBD
18637	8548	49	of	of	IN
18637	8548	50	so	so	RB
18637	8548	51	much	much	JJ
18637	8548	52	money	money	NN
18637	8548	53	"	"	''
18637	8548	54	for	for	IN
18637	8548	55	the	the	DT
18637	8548	56	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	8548	57	of	of	IN
18637	8548	58	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8548	59	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	8548	60	,	,	,
18637	8548	61	"	"	''
18637	8548	62	to	to	TO
18637	8548	63	be	be	VB
18637	8548	64	expended	expend	VBN
18637	8548	65	at	at	IN
18637	8548	66	the	the	DT
18637	8548	67	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	8548	68	of	of	IN
18637	8548	69	the	the	DT
18637	8548	70	President	President	NNP
18637	8548	71	.	.	.
18637	8549	1	In	in	IN
18637	8549	2	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8549	3	's	's	POS
18637	8549	4	second	second	JJ
18637	8549	5	term	term	NN
18637	8549	6	the	the	DT
18637	8549	7	practice	practice	NN
18637	8549	8	was	be	VBD
18637	8549	9	introduced	introduce	VBN
18637	8549	10	of	of	IN
18637	8549	11	allocating	allocate	VBG
18637	8549	12	special	special	JJ
18637	8549	13	sums	sum	NNS
18637	8549	14	to	to	IN
18637	8549	15	the	the	DT
18637	8549	16	several	several	JJ
18637	8549	17	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8549	18	missions	mission	NNS
18637	8549	19	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	8549	20	by	by	IN
18637	8549	21	the	the	DT
18637	8549	22	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8549	23	,	,	,
18637	8549	24	but	but	CC
18637	8549	25	even	even	RB
18637	8549	26	then	then	RB
18637	8549	27	the	the	DT
18637	8549	28	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8549	29	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8549	30	did	do	VBD
18637	8549	31	not	not	RB
18637	8549	32	purport	purport	VB
18637	8549	33	to	to	TO
18637	8549	34	curtail	curtail	VB
18637	8549	35	the	the	DT
18637	8549	36	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	8549	37	of	of	IN
18637	8549	38	the	the	DT
18637	8549	39	President	President	NNP
18637	8549	40	in	in	IN
18637	8549	41	any	any	DT
18637	8549	42	way	way	NN
18637	8549	43	in	in	IN
18637	8549	44	the	the	DT
18637	8549	45	choice	choice	NN
18637	8549	46	of	of	IN
18637	8549	47	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8549	48	agents	agent	NNS
18637	8549	49	.	.	.
18637	8550	1	In	in	IN
18637	8550	2	1814	1814	CD
18637	8550	3	,	,	,
18637	8550	4	however	however	RB
18637	8550	5	,	,	,
18637	8550	6	when	when	WRB
18637	8550	7	President	President	NNP
18637	8550	8	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8550	9	appointed	appoint	VBD
18637	8550	10	,	,	,
18637	8550	11	during	during	IN
18637	8550	12	a	a	DT
18637	8550	13	recess	recess	NN
18637	8550	14	of	of	IN
18637	8550	15	the	the	DT
18637	8550	16	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8550	17	,	,	,
18637	8550	18	the	the	DT
18637	8550	19	Commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	8550	20	who	who	WP
18637	8550	21	negotiated	negotiate	VBD
18637	8550	22	the	the	DT
18637	8550	23	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	8550	24	of	of	IN
18637	8550	25	Ghent	Ghent	NNP
18637	8550	26	the	the	DT
18637	8550	27	theory	theory	NN
18637	8550	28	on	on	IN
18637	8550	29	which	which	WDT
18637	8550	30	the	the	DT
18637	8550	31	above	above	JJ
18637	8550	32	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8550	33	was	be	VBD
18637	8550	34	based	base	VBN
18637	8550	35	was	be	VBD
18637	8550	36	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	8550	37	into	into	IN
18637	8550	38	question	question	NN
18637	8550	39	.	.	.
18637	8551	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	RB
18637	8551	2	,	,	,
18637	8551	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8551	4	was	be	VBD
18637	8551	5	argued	argue	VBN
18637	8551	6	,	,	,
18637	8551	7	as	as	IN
18637	8551	8	these	these	DT
18637	8551	9	offices	office	NNS
18637	8551	10	had	have	VBD
18637	8551	11	never	never	RB
18637	8551	12	been	be	VBN
18637	8551	13	established	establish	VBN
18637	8551	14	by	by	IN
18637	8551	15	law	law	NN
18637	8551	16	,	,	,
18637	8551	17	no	no	DT
18637	8551	18	vacancy	vacancy	NN
18637	8551	19	existed	exist	VBD
18637	8551	20	to	to	TO
18637	8551	21	which	which	WDT
18637	8551	22	the	the	DT
18637	8551	23	President	President	NNP
18637	8551	24	could	could	MD
18637	8551	25	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	8551	26	make	make	VB
18637	8551	27	a	a	DT
18637	8551	28	recess	recess	NN
18637	8551	29	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8551	30	.	.	.
18637	8552	1	To	to	IN
18637	8552	2	this	this	DT
18637	8552	3	argument	argument	NN
18637	8552	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8552	5	was	be	VBD
18637	8552	6	answered	answer	VBN
18637	8552	7	that	that	IN
18637	8552	8	the	the	DT
18637	8552	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8552	10	recognizes	recognize	VBZ
18637	8552	11	"	"	``
18637	8552	12	two	two	CD
18637	8552	13	descriptions	description	NNS
18637	8552	14	of	of	IN
18637	8552	15	offices	office	NNS
18637	8552	16	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	8552	17	different	different	JJ
18637	8552	18	in	in	IN
18637	8552	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8552	20	nature	nature	NN
18637	8552	21	,	,	,
18637	8552	22	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8552	23	by	by	IN
18637	8552	24	the	the	DT
18637	8552	25	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	8552	26	--	--	:
18637	8552	27	one	one	NN
18637	8552	28	to	to	TO
18637	8552	29	be	be	VB
18637	8552	30	created	create	VBN
18637	8552	31	by	by	IN
18637	8552	32	law	law	NN
18637	8552	33	,	,	,
18637	8552	34	and	and	CC
18637	8552	35	the	the	DT
18637	8552	36	other	other	JJ
18637	8552	37	depending	depend	VBG
18637	8552	38	for	for	IN
18637	8552	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8552	40	existence	existence	NN
18637	8552	41	and	and	CC
18637	8552	42	continuance	continuance	NN
18637	8552	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	8552	44	contingencies	contingency	NNS
18637	8552	45	.	.	.
18637	8553	1	Of	of	IN
18637	8553	2	the	the	DT
18637	8553	3	first	first	JJ
18637	8553	4	kind	kind	NN
18637	8553	5	,	,	,
18637	8553	6	are	be	VBP
18637	8553	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8553	8	,	,	,
18637	8553	9	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	8553	10	,	,	,
18637	8553	11	and	and	CC
18637	8553	12	similar	similar	JJ
18637	8553	13	offices	office	NNS
18637	8553	14	.	.	.
18637	8554	1	Of	of	IN
18637	8554	2	the	the	DT
18637	8554	3	second	second	JJ
18637	8554	4	,	,	,
18637	8554	5	are	be	VBP
18637	8554	6	Ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	8554	7	,	,	,
18637	8554	8	other	other	JJ
18637	8554	9	public	public	JJ
18637	8554	10	Ministers	minister	NNS
18637	8554	11	,	,	,
18637	8554	12	and	and	CC
18637	8554	13	Consuls	Consuls	NNP
18637	8554	14	.	.	.
18637	8555	1	The	the	DT
18637	8555	2	first	first	JJ
18637	8555	3	description	description	NN
18637	8555	4	organize	organize	VBP
18637	8555	5	the	the	DT
18637	8555	6	Government	government	NN
18637	8555	7	and	and	CC
18637	8555	8	give	give	VB
18637	8555	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8555	10	efficacy	efficacy	NN
18637	8555	11	.	.	.
18637	8556	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8556	2	form	form	VBP
18637	8556	3	the	the	DT
18637	8556	4	internal	internal	JJ
18637	8556	5	system	system	NN
18637	8556	6	,	,	,
18637	8556	7	and	and	CC
18637	8556	8	are	be	VBP
18637	8556	9	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
18637	8556	10	of	of	IN
18637	8556	11	precise	precise	JJ
18637	8556	12	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	8556	13	.	.	.
18637	8557	1	When	when	WRB
18637	8557	2	and	and	CC
18637	8557	3	how	how	WRB
18637	8557	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8557	5	are	be	VBP
18637	8557	6	created	create	VBN
18637	8557	7	,	,	,
18637	8557	8	and	and	CC
18637	8557	9	when	when	WRB
18637	8557	10	and	and	CC
18637	8557	11	how	how	WRB
18637	8557	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8557	13	become	become	VBP
18637	8557	14	vacant	vacant	JJ
18637	8557	15	,	,	,
18637	8557	16	may	may	MD
18637	8557	17	always	always	RB
18637	8557	18	be	be	VB
18637	8557	19	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	8557	20	with	with	IN
18637	8557	21	perfect	perfect	JJ
18637	8557	22	precision	precision	NN
18637	8557	23	.	.	.
18637	8558	1	Not	not	RB
18637	8558	2	so	so	RB
18637	8558	3	with	with	IN
18637	8558	4	the	the	DT
18637	8558	5	second	second	JJ
18637	8558	6	description	description	NN
18637	8558	7	.	.	.
18637	8559	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8559	2	depend	depend	VBP
18637	8559	3	for	for	IN
18637	8559	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8559	5	original	original	JJ
18637	8559	6	existence	existence	NN
18637	8559	7	upon	upon	IN
18637	8559	8	the	the	DT
18637	8559	9	law	law	NN
18637	8559	10	,	,	,
18637	8559	11	but	but	CC
18637	8559	12	are	be	VBP
18637	8559	13	the	the	DT
18637	8559	14	offspring	offspring	NN
18637	8559	15	of	of	IN
18637	8559	16	the	the	DT
18637	8559	17	state	state	NN
18637	8559	18	of	of	IN
18637	8559	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8559	20	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8559	21	with	with	IN
18637	8559	22	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8559	23	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8559	24	,	,	,
18637	8559	25	and	and	CC
18637	8559	26	must	must	MD
18637	8559	27	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	8559	28	be	be	VB
18637	8559	29	governed	govern	VBN
18637	8559	30	by	by	IN
18637	8559	31	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	8559	32	rules	rule	NNS
18637	8559	33	.	.	.
18637	8560	1	As	as	IN
18637	8560	2	an	an	DT
18637	8560	3	independent	independent	JJ
18637	8560	4	power	power	NN
18637	8560	5	,	,	,
18637	8560	6	the	the	DT
18637	8560	7	United	United	NNP
18637	8560	8	States	States	NNP
18637	8560	9	have	have	VBP
18637	8560	10	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8560	11	with	with	IN
18637	8560	12	all	all	DT
18637	8560	13	other	other	JJ
18637	8560	14	independent	independent	JJ
18637	8560	15	powers	power	NNS
18637	8560	16	;	;	:
18637	8560	17	and	and	CC
18637	8560	18	the	the	DT
18637	8560	19	management	management	NN
18637	8560	20	of	of	IN
18637	8560	21	those	those	DT
18637	8560	22	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8560	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	8560	24	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8560	25	in	in	IN
18637	8560	26	the	the	DT
18637	8560	27	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8560	28	.	.	.
18637	8561	1	"	"	``
18637	8561	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8561	3	274	274	CD
18637	8561	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8561	5	By	by	IN
18637	8561	6	the	the	DT
18637	8561	7	opening	opening	NN
18637	8561	8	section	section	NN
18637	8561	9	of	of	IN
18637	8561	10	the	the	DT
18637	8561	11	act	act	NN
18637	8561	12	of	of	IN
18637	8561	13	March	March	NNP
18637	8561	14	1	1	CD
18637	8561	15	,	,	,
18637	8561	16	1855	1855	CD
18637	8561	17	,	,	,
18637	8561	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8561	19	was	be	VBD
18637	8561	20	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8561	21	that	that	IN
18637	8561	22	"	"	``
18637	8561	23	from	from	IN
18637	8561	24	and	and	CC
18637	8561	25	after	after	IN
18637	8561	26	the	the	DT
18637	8561	27	thirtieth	thirtieth	JJ
18637	8561	28	day	day	NN
18637	8561	29	of	of	IN
18637	8561	30	June	June	NNP
18637	8561	31	next	next	RB
18637	8561	32	,	,	,
18637	8561	33	the	the	DT
18637	8561	34	President	President	NNP
18637	8561	35	of	of	IN
18637	8561	36	the	the	DT
18637	8561	37	United	United	NNP
18637	8561	38	States	States	NNP
18637	8561	39	shall	shall	MD
18637	8561	40	,	,	,
18637	8561	41	by	by	RB
18637	8561	42	and	and	CC
18637	8561	43	with	with	IN
18637	8561	44	the	the	DT
18637	8561	45	advice	advice	NN
18637	8561	46	and	and	CC
18637	8561	47	consent	consent	NN
18637	8561	48	of	of	IN
18637	8561	49	the	the	DT
18637	8561	50	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8561	51	,	,	,
18637	8561	52	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	8561	53	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	8561	54	of	of	IN
18637	8561	55	the	the	DT
18637	8561	56	grade	grade	NN
18637	8561	57	of	of	IN
18637	8561	58	envoys	envoy	NNS
18637	8561	59	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	8561	60	and	and	CC
18637	8561	61	ministers	minister	NNS
18637	8561	62	plenipotentiary	plenipotentiary	JJ
18637	8561	63	,	,	,
18637	8561	64	"	"	''
18637	8561	65	with	with	IN
18637	8561	66	a	a	DT
18637	8561	67	specified	specify	VBN
18637	8561	68	annual	annual	JJ
18637	8561	69	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	8561	70	for	for	IN
18637	8561	71	each	each	DT
18637	8561	72	,	,	,
18637	8561	73	"	"	''
18637	8561	74	to	to	IN
18637	8561	75	the	the	DT
18637	8561	76	following	follow	VBG
18637	8561	77	countries	country	NNS
18637	8561	78	,	,	,
18637	8561	79	*	*	NFP
18637	8561	80	*	*	NFP
18637	8561	81	*	*	NFP
18637	8561	82	"	"	``
18637	8561	83	In	in	IN
18637	8561	84	the	the	DT
18637	8561	85	body	body	NN
18637	8561	86	of	of	IN
18637	8561	87	the	the	DT
18637	8561	88	act	act	NN
18637	8561	89	was	be	VBD
18637	8561	90	also	also	RB
18637	8561	91	this	this	DT
18637	8561	92	provision	provision	NN
18637	8561	93	:	:	:
18637	8561	94	"	"	``
18637	8561	95	The	the	DT
18637	8561	96	President	President	NNP
18637	8561	97	shall	shall	MD
18637	8561	98	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	8561	99	no	no	DT
18637	8561	100	other	other	JJ
18637	8561	101	than	than	IN
18637	8561	102	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8561	103	of	of	IN
18637	8561	104	the	the	DT
18637	8561	105	United	United	NNP
18637	8561	106	States	States	NNP
18637	8561	107	,	,	,
18637	8561	108	who	who	WP
18637	8561	109	are	be	VBP
18637	8561	110	residents	resident	NNS
18637	8561	111	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8561	112	,	,	,
18637	8561	113	or	or	CC
18637	8561	114	who	who	WP
18637	8561	115	shall	shall	MD
18637	8561	116	be	be	VB
18637	8561	117	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	8561	118	in	in	IN
18637	8561	119	the	the	DT
18637	8561	120	employment	employment	NN
18637	8561	121	of	of	IN
18637	8561	122	the	the	DT
18637	8561	123	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8561	124	at	at	IN
18637	8561	125	the	the	DT
18637	8561	126	time	time	NN
18637	8561	127	of	of	IN
18637	8561	128	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8561	129	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8561	130	,	,	,
18637	8561	131	*	*	NFP
18637	8561	132	*	*	NFP
18637	8561	133	*	*	NFP
18637	8561	134	.	.	.
18637	8562	1	"	"	``
18637	8562	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8562	3	275	275	CD
18637	8562	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8562	5	The	the	DT
18637	8562	6	question	question	NN
18637	8562	7	of	of	IN
18637	8562	8	the	the	DT
18637	8562	9	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	8562	10	of	of	IN
18637	8562	11	the	the	DT
18637	8562	12	act	act	NN
18637	8562	13	having	have	VBG
18637	8562	14	been	be	VBN
18637	8562	15	referred	refer	VBN
18637	8562	16	to	to	IN
18637	8562	17	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8562	18	General	General	NNP
18637	8562	19	Cushing	Cushing	NNP
18637	8562	20	,	,	,
18637	8562	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8562	22	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	8562	23	that	that	IN
18637	8562	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8562	25	total	total	JJ
18637	8562	26	effect	effect	NN
18637	8562	27	,	,	,
18637	8562	28	aside	aside	RB
18637	8562	29	from	from	IN
18637	8562	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8562	31	salary	salary	NN
18637	8562	32	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8562	33	,	,	,
18637	8562	34	was	be	VBD
18637	8562	35	recommendatory	recommendatory	NN
18637	8562	36	only	only	RB
18637	8562	37	.	.	.
18637	8563	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8563	2	was	be	VBD
18637	8563	3	"	"	``
18637	8563	4	to	to	TO
18637	8563	5	say	say	VB
18637	8563	6	,	,	,
18637	8563	7	that	that	IN
18637	8563	8	if	if	IN
18637	8563	9	,	,	,
18637	8563	10	and	and	CC
18637	8563	11	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	8563	12	,	,	,
18637	8563	13	the	the	DT
18637	8563	14	President	President	NNP
18637	8563	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	8563	16	,	,	,
18637	8563	17	by	by	RB
18637	8563	18	and	and	CC
18637	8563	19	with	with	IN
18637	8563	20	the	the	DT
18637	8563	21	advice	advice	NN
18637	8563	22	and	and	CC
18637	8563	23	consent	consent	NN
18637	8563	24	of	of	IN
18637	8563	25	the	the	DT
18637	8563	26	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8563	27	,	,	,
18637	8563	28	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	8563	29	an	an	DT
18637	8563	30	envoy	envoy	NN
18637	8563	31	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	8563	32	and	and	CC
18637	8563	33	minister	minister	NNP
18637	8563	34	plenipotentiary	plenipotentiary	NNP
18637	8563	35	to	to	IN
18637	8563	36	Great	Great	NNP
18637	8563	37	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	8563	38	,	,	,
18637	8563	39	or	or	CC
18637	8563	40	to	to	IN
18637	8563	41	Sweden	Sweden	NNP
18637	8563	42	,	,	,
18637	8563	43	the	the	DT
18637	8563	44	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	8563	45	of	of	IN
18637	8563	46	that	that	DT
18637	8563	47	minister	minister	NN
18637	8563	48	shall	shall	MD
18637	8563	49	be	be	VB
18637	8563	50	so	so	RB
18637	8563	51	much	much	JJ
18637	8563	52	and	and	CC
18637	8563	53	no	no	RB
18637	8563	54	more	more	JJR
18637	8563	55	.	.	.
18637	8564	1	"	"	``
18637	8564	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8564	3	276	276	CD
18637	8564	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8564	5	This	this	DT
18637	8564	6	line	line	NN
18637	8564	7	of	of	IN
18637	8564	8	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	8564	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	8564	10	today	today	NN
18637	8564	11	only	only	RB
18637	8564	12	partially	partially	RB
18637	8564	13	descriptive	descriptive	JJ
18637	8564	14	of	of	IN
18637	8564	15	facts	fact	NNS
18637	8564	16	.	.	.
18637	8565	1	The	the	DT
18637	8565	2	act	act	NN
18637	8565	3	of	of	IN
18637	8565	4	March	March	NNP
18637	8565	5	2	2	CD
18637	8565	6	,	,	,
18637	8565	7	1909	1909	CD
18637	8565	8	,	,	,
18637	8565	9	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	8565	10	that	that	IN
18637	8565	11	new	new	JJ
18637	8565	12	ambassadorships	ambassadorship	NNS
18637	8565	13	may	may	MD
18637	8565	14	be	be	VB
18637	8565	15	created	create	VBN
18637	8565	16	only	only	RB
18637	8565	17	with	with	IN
18637	8565	18	the	the	DT
18637	8565	19	consent	consent	NN
18637	8565	20	of	of	IN
18637	8565	21	Congress,[277	congress,[277	NN
18637	8565	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8565	23	while	while	IN
18637	8565	24	the	the	DT
18637	8565	25	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	8565	26	Service	Service	NNP
18637	8565	27	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8565	28	of	of	IN
18637	8565	29	1924[278	1924[278	CD
18637	8565	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8565	31	organizes	organize	VBZ
18637	8565	32	the	the	DT
18637	8565	33	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8565	34	service	service	NN
18637	8565	35	,	,	,
18637	8565	36	both	both	CC
18637	8565	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8565	38	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8565	39	and	and	CC
18637	8565	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8565	41	consular	consular	JJ
18637	8565	42	divisions	division	NNS
18637	8565	43	,	,	,
18637	8565	44	in	in	IN
18637	8565	45	detail	detail	NN
18637	8565	46	as	as	IN
18637	8565	47	to	to	IN
18637	8565	48	grades	grade	NNS
18637	8565	49	,	,	,
18637	8565	50	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	8565	51	,	,	,
18637	8565	52	appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	8565	53	,	,	,
18637	8565	54	promotions	promotion	NNS
18637	8565	55	,	,	,
18637	8565	56	and	and	CC
18637	8565	57	in	in	IN
18637	8565	58	part	part	NN
18637	8565	59	as	as	IN
18637	8565	60	to	to	IN
18637	8565	61	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8565	62	.	.	.
18637	8566	1	Theoretically	theoretically	RB
18637	8566	2	the	the	DT
18637	8566	3	act	act	NN
18637	8566	4	leaves	leave	VBZ
18637	8566	5	the	the	DT
18637	8566	6	power	power	NN
18637	8566	7	of	of	IN
18637	8566	8	the	the	DT
18637	8566	9	President	President	NNP
18637	8566	10	and	and	CC
18637	8566	11	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8566	12	to	to	TO
18637	8566	13	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	8566	14	consular	consular	JJ
18637	8566	15	and	and	CC
18637	8566	16	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8566	17	officials	official	NNS
18637	8566	18	intact	intact	JJ
18637	8566	19	,	,	,
18637	8566	20	but	but	CC
18637	8566	21	in	in	IN
18637	8566	22	practice	practice	NN
18637	8566	23	the	the	DT
18637	8566	24	vast	vast	JJ
18637	8566	25	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	8566	26	of	of	IN
18637	8566	27	the	the	DT
18637	8566	28	selections	selection	NNS
18637	8566	29	are	be	VBP
18637	8566	30	made	make	VBN
18637	8566	31	in	in	IN
18637	8566	32	conformance	conformance	NN
18637	8566	33	with	with	IN
18637	8566	34	the	the	DT
18637	8566	35	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8566	36	service	service	NN
18637	8566	37	rules	rule	NNS
18637	8566	38	.	.	.
18637	8567	1	PRESIDENTIAL	PRESIDENTIAL	NNP
18637	8567	2	DIPLOMATIC	DIPLOMATIC	VBN
18637	8567	3	AGENTS	agent	NNS
18637	8567	4	What	what	WP
18637	8567	5	the	the	DT
18637	8567	6	President	President	NNP
18637	8567	7	may	may	MD
18637	8567	8	have	have	VB
18637	8567	9	lost	lose	VBN
18637	8567	10	in	in	IN
18637	8567	11	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	8567	12	of	of	IN
18637	8567	13	the	the	DT
18637	8567	14	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	8567	15	of	of	IN
18637	8567	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8567	17	in	in	IN
18637	8567	18	this	this	DT
18637	8567	19	field	field	NN
18637	8567	20	,	,	,
18637	8567	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8567	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	8567	23	made	make	VBN
18637	8567	24	good	good	JJ
18637	8567	25	through	through	IN
18637	8567	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8567	27	early	early	JJ
18637	8567	28	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	8567	29	right	right	NN
18637	8567	30	to	to	TO
18637	8567	31	employ	employ	VB
18637	8567	32	,	,	,
18637	8567	33	in	in	IN
18637	8567	34	the	the	DT
18637	8567	35	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8567	36	of	of	IN
18637	8567	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8567	38	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8567	39	function	function	NN
18637	8567	40	,	,	,
18637	8567	41	so	so	RB
18637	8567	42	-	-	HYPH
18637	8567	43	called	call	VBN
18637	8567	44	"	"	``
18637	8567	45	special	special	JJ
18637	8567	46	,	,	,
18637	8567	47	"	"	''
18637	8567	48	"	"	``
18637	8567	49	personal	personal	JJ
18637	8567	50	,	,	,
18637	8567	51	"	"	''
18637	8567	52	or	or	CC
18637	8567	53	"	"	``
18637	8567	54	secret	secret	JJ
18637	8567	55	"	"	''
18637	8567	56	agents	agent	NNS
18637	8567	57	without	without	IN
18637	8567	58	consulting	consult	VBG
18637	8567	59	the	the	DT
18637	8567	60	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8567	61	.	.	.
18637	8568	1	When	when	WRB
18637	8568	2	President	President	NNP
18637	8568	3	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	8568	4	's	's	POS
18637	8568	5	right	right	NN
18637	8568	6	to	to	TO
18637	8568	7	resort	resort	VB
18637	8568	8	to	to	IN
18637	8568	9	this	this	DT
18637	8568	10	practice	practice	NN
18637	8568	11	was	be	VBD
18637	8568	12	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	8568	13	in	in	IN
18637	8568	14	the	the	DT
18637	8568	15	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8568	16	in	in	IN
18637	8568	17	1831	1831	CD
18637	8568	18	,	,	,
18637	8568	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8568	20	was	be	VBD
18637	8568	21	defended	defend	VBN
18637	8568	22	by	by	IN
18637	8568	23	Edward	Edward	NNP
18637	8568	24	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
18637	8568	25	,	,	,
18637	8568	26	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	8568	27	from	from	IN
18637	8568	28	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	8568	29	,	,	,
18637	8568	30	to	to	IN
18637	8568	31	such	such	JJ
18637	8568	32	good	good	JJ
18637	8568	33	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8568	34	that	that	WDT
18637	8568	35	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	8568	36	made	make	VBD
18637	8568	37	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8568	38	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8568	39	of	of	IN
18637	8568	40	State	State	NNP
18637	8568	41	.	.	.
18637	8569	1	"	"	``
18637	8569	2	The	the	DT
18637	8569	3	practice	practice	NN
18637	8569	4	of	of	IN
18637	8569	5	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	8569	6	secret	secret	JJ
18637	8569	7	agents	agent	NNS
18637	8569	8	,	,	,
18637	8569	9	"	"	''
18637	8569	10	said	say	VBD
18637	8569	11	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
18637	8569	12	,	,	,
18637	8569	13	"	"	``
18637	8569	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8569	15	coeval	coeval	NN
18637	8569	16	with	with	IN
18637	8569	17	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8569	18	existence	existence	NN
18637	8569	19	as	as	IN
18637	8569	20	a	a	DT
18637	8569	21	nation	nation	NN
18637	8569	22	,	,	,
18637	8569	23	and	and	CC
18637	8569	24	goes	go	VBZ
18637	8569	25	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	8569	26	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8569	27	acknowledgment	acknowledgment	NN
18637	8569	28	as	as	IN
18637	8569	29	such	such	JJ
18637	8569	30	by	by	IN
18637	8569	31	other	other	JJ
18637	8569	32	powers	power	NNS
18637	8569	33	.	.	.
18637	8570	1	All	all	PDT
18637	8570	2	those	those	DT
18637	8570	3	great	great	JJ
18637	8570	4	men	man	NNS
18637	8570	5	who	who	WP
18637	8570	6	have	have	VBP
18637	8570	7	figured	figure	VBN
18637	8570	8	in	in	IN
18637	8570	9	the	the	DT
18637	8570	10	history	history	NN
18637	8570	11	of	of	IN
18637	8570	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8570	13	diplomacy	diplomacy	NN
18637	8570	14	,	,	,
18637	8570	15	began	begin	VBD
18637	8570	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8570	17	career	career	NN
18637	8570	18	,	,	,
18637	8570	19	and	and	CC
18637	8570	20	performed	perform	VBD
18637	8570	21	some	some	DT
18637	8570	22	of	of	IN
18637	8570	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8570	24	most	most	RBS
18637	8570	25	important	important	JJ
18637	8570	26	services	service	NNS
18637	8570	27	in	in	IN
18637	8570	28	the	the	DT
18637	8570	29	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	8570	30	of	of	IN
18637	8570	31	secret	secret	JJ
18637	8570	32	agents	agent	NNS
18637	8570	33	,	,	,
18637	8570	34	with	with	IN
18637	8570	35	full	full	JJ
18637	8570	36	powers	power	NNS
18637	8570	37	.	.	.
18637	8571	1	Franklin	Franklin	NNP
18637	8571	2	,	,	,
18637	8571	3	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	8571	4	,	,	,
18637	8571	5	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	8571	6	,	,	,
18637	8571	7	were	be	VBD
18637	8571	8	only	only	RB
18637	8571	9	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	8571	10	;	;	:
18637	8571	11	and	and	CC
18637	8571	12	in	in	IN
18637	8571	13	negotiating	negotiate	VBG
18637	8571	14	a	a	DT
18637	8571	15	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8571	16	with	with	IN
18637	8571	17	the	the	DT
18637	8571	18	Emperor	Emperor	NNP
18637	8571	19	of	of	IN
18637	8571	20	Morocco	Morocco	NNP
18637	8571	21	,	,	,
18637	8571	22	the	the	DT
18637	8571	23	selection	selection	NN
18637	8571	24	of	of	IN
18637	8571	25	the	the	DT
18637	8571	26	secret	secret	JJ
18637	8571	27	agent	agent	NN
18637	8571	28	was	be	VBD
18637	8571	29	left	leave	VBN
18637	8571	30	to	to	IN
18637	8571	31	the	the	DT
18637	8571	32	Ministers	Ministers	NNPS
18637	8571	33	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	8571	34	to	to	TO
18637	8571	35	make	make	VB
18637	8571	36	the	the	DT
18637	8571	37	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8571	38	;	;	:
18637	8571	39	and	and	CC
18637	8571	40	,	,	,
18637	8571	41	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	8571	42	,	,	,
18637	8571	43	in	in	IN
18637	8571	44	the	the	DT
18637	8571	45	year	year	NN
18637	8571	46	1785	1785	CD
18637	8571	47	,	,	,
18637	8571	48	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	8571	49	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	8571	50	and	and	CC
18637	8571	51	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	8571	52	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	8571	53	appointed	appoint	VBD
18637	8571	54	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	8571	55	Barclay	Barclay	NNP
18637	8571	56	,	,	,
18637	8571	57	who	who	WP
18637	8571	58	went	go	VBD
18637	8571	59	to	to	IN
18637	8571	60	Morocco	Morocco	NNP
18637	8571	61	and	and	CC
18637	8571	62	made	make	VBD
18637	8571	63	a	a	DT
18637	8571	64	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8571	65	,	,	,
18637	8571	66	which	which	WDT
18637	8571	67	was	be	VBD
18637	8571	68	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	8571	69	by	by	IN
18637	8571	70	the	the	DT
18637	8571	71	Ministers	Ministers	NNPS
18637	8571	72	at	at	IN
18637	8571	73	Paris	Paris	NNP
18637	8571	74	.	.	.
18637	8572	1	"	"	``
18637	8572	2	These	these	DT
18637	8572	3	instances	instance	NNS
18637	8572	4	show	show	VBP
18637	8572	5	that	that	IN
18637	8572	6	,	,	,
18637	8572	7	even	even	RB
18637	8572	8	prior	prior	RB
18637	8572	9	to	to	IN
18637	8572	10	the	the	DT
18637	8572	11	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	8572	12	of	of	IN
18637	8572	13	the	the	DT
18637	8572	14	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8572	15	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8572	16	,	,	,
18637	8572	17	secret	secret	JJ
18637	8572	18	plenipotentiaries	plenipotentiary	NNS
18637	8572	19	were	be	VBD
18637	8572	20	known	know	VBN
18637	8572	21	,	,	,
18637	8572	22	as	as	RB
18637	8572	23	well	well	RB
18637	8572	24	in	in	IN
18637	8572	25	the	the	DT
18637	8572	26	practice	practice	NN
18637	8572	27	of	of	IN
18637	8572	28	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8572	29	own	own	JJ
18637	8572	30	country	country	NN
18637	8572	31	as	as	IN
18637	8572	32	in	in	IN
18637	8572	33	the	the	DT
18637	8572	34	general	general	JJ
18637	8572	35	law	law	NN
18637	8572	36	of	of	IN
18637	8572	37	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8572	38	:	:	:
18637	8572	39	and	and	CC
18637	8572	40	that	that	IN
18637	8572	41	these	these	DT
18637	8572	42	secret	secret	JJ
18637	8572	43	agents	agent	NNS
18637	8572	44	were	be	VBD
18637	8572	45	not	not	RB
18637	8572	46	on	on	IN
18637	8572	47	a	a	DT
18637	8572	48	level	level	NN
18637	8572	49	with	with	IN
18637	8572	50	messengers	messenger	NNS
18637	8572	51	,	,	,
18637	8572	52	letter	letter	NN
18637	8572	53	-	-	HYPH
18637	8572	54	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	8572	55	,	,	,
18637	8572	56	or	or	CC
18637	8572	57	spies	spy	NNS
18637	8572	58	,	,	,
18637	8572	59	to	to	TO
18637	8572	60	whom	whom	WP
18637	8572	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8572	62	has	have	VBZ
18637	8572	63	been	be	VBN
18637	8572	64	found	find	VBN
18637	8572	65	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8572	66	in	in	IN
18637	8572	67	argument	argument	NN
18637	8572	68	to	to	TO
18637	8572	69	assimilate	assimilate	VB
18637	8572	70	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8572	71	.	.	.
18637	8573	1	On	on	IN
18637	8573	2	the	the	DT
18637	8573	3	30th	30th	JJ
18637	8573	4	March	March	NNP
18637	8573	5	,	,	,
18637	8573	6	1795	1795	CD
18637	8573	7	,	,	,
18637	8573	8	in	in	IN
18637	8573	9	the	the	DT
18637	8573	10	recess	recess	NN
18637	8573	11	of	of	IN
18637	8573	12	the	the	DT
18637	8573	13	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8573	14	,	,	,
18637	8573	15	by	by	IN
18637	8573	16	letters	letter	NNS
18637	8573	17	patent	patent	NN
18637	8573	18	under	under	IN
18637	8573	19	the	the	DT
18637	8573	20	great	great	JJ
18637	8573	21	broad	broad	JJ
18637	8573	22	seal	seal	NN
18637	8573	23	of	of	IN
18637	8573	24	the	the	DT
18637	8573	25	United	United	NNP
18637	8573	26	States	States	NNP
18637	8573	27	,	,	,
18637	8573	28	and	and	CC
18637	8573	29	the	the	DT
18637	8573	30	signature	signature	NN
18637	8573	31	of	of	IN
18637	8573	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8573	33	President	President	NNP
18637	8573	34	,	,	,
18637	8573	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8573	36	that	that	IN
18637	8573	37	President	President	NNP
18637	8573	38	being	be	VBG
18637	8573	39	George	George	NNP
18637	8573	40	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	8573	41	,	,	,
18637	8573	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8573	43	countersigned	countersign	VBN
18637	8573	44	by	by	IN
18637	8573	45	the	the	DT
18637	8573	46	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8573	47	of	of	IN
18637	8573	48	State	State	NNP
18637	8573	49	,	,	,
18637	8573	50	David	David	NNP
18637	8573	51	Humphreys	Humphreys	NNP
18637	8573	52	was	be	VBD
18637	8573	53	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	8573	54	commissioner	commissioner	NN
18637	8573	55	plenipotentiary	plenipotentiary	JJ
18637	8573	56	for	for	IN
18637	8573	57	negotiating	negotiate	VBG
18637	8573	58	a	a	DT
18637	8573	59	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8573	60	of	of	IN
18637	8573	61	peace	peace	NN
18637	8573	62	with	with	IN
18637	8573	63	Algiers	Algiers	NNP
18637	8573	64	.	.	.
18637	8574	1	By	by	IN
18637	8574	2	instructions	instruction	NNS
18637	8574	3	from	from	IN
18637	8574	4	the	the	DT
18637	8574	5	President	President	NNP
18637	8574	6	,	,	,
18637	8574	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8574	8	was	be	VBD
18637	8574	9	afterwards	afterwards	RB
18637	8574	10	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8574	11	to	to	TO
18637	8574	12	employ	employ	VB
18637	8574	13	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
18637	8574	14	Donaldson	Donaldson	NNP
18637	8574	15	as	as	IN
18637	8574	16	agent	agent	NN
18637	8574	17	in	in	IN
18637	8574	18	that	that	DT
18637	8574	19	business	business	NN
18637	8574	20	.	.	.
18637	8575	1	In	in	IN
18637	8575	2	May	May	NNP
18637	8575	3	,	,	,
18637	8575	4	of	of	IN
18637	8575	5	the	the	DT
18637	8575	6	same	same	JJ
18637	8575	7	year	year	NN
18637	8575	8	,	,	,
18637	8575	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8575	10	did	do	VBD
18637	8575	11	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	8575	12	Donaldson	Donaldson	NNP
18637	8575	13	,	,	,
18637	8575	14	who	who	WP
18637	8575	15	went	go	VBD
18637	8575	16	to	to	IN
18637	8575	17	Algiers	Algiers	NNP
18637	8575	18	,	,	,
18637	8575	19	and	and	CC
18637	8575	20	in	in	IN
18637	8575	21	September	September	NNP
18637	8575	22	of	of	IN
18637	8575	23	the	the	DT
18637	8575	24	same	same	JJ
18637	8575	25	year	year	NN
18637	8575	26	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	8575	27	a	a	DT
18637	8575	28	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8575	29	with	with	IN
18637	8575	30	the	the	DT
18637	8575	31	Dey	Dey	NNP
18637	8575	32	and	and	CC
18637	8575	33	Divan	Divan	NNP
18637	8575	34	,	,	,
18637	8575	35	which	which	WDT
18637	8575	36	was	be	VBD
18637	8575	37	confirmed	confirm	VBN
18637	8575	38	by	by	IN
18637	8575	39	Humphreys	Humphreys	NNP
18637	8575	40	,	,	,
18637	8575	41	at	at	IN
18637	8575	42	Lisbon	Lisbon	NNP
18637	8575	43	,	,	,
18637	8575	44	on	on	IN
18637	8575	45	the	the	DT
18637	8575	46	28th	28th	JJ
18637	8575	47	November	November	NNP
18637	8575	48	in	in	IN
18637	8575	49	the	the	DT
18637	8575	50	same	same	JJ
18637	8575	51	year	year	NN
18637	8575	52	,	,	,
18637	8575	53	and	and	CC
18637	8575	54	afterwards	afterwards	RB
18637	8575	55	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	8575	56	by	by	IN
18637	8575	57	the	the	DT
18637	8575	58	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8575	59	on	on	IN
18637	8575	60	the	the	DT
18637	8575	61	----	----	CD
18637	8575	62	day	day	NN
18637	8575	63	of	of	IN
18637	8575	64	----	----	NNP
18637	8575	65	,	,	,
18637	8575	66	1796	1796	CD
18637	8575	67	,	,	,
18637	8575	68	and	and	CC
18637	8575	69	an	an	DT
18637	8575	70	act	act	NN
18637	8575	71	passed	pass	VBD
18637	8575	72	both	both	DT
18637	8575	73	Houses	Houses	NNP
18637	8575	74	on	on	IN
18637	8575	75	6th	6th	JJ
18637	8575	76	May	May	NNP
18637	8575	77	,	,	,
18637	8575	78	1796	1796	CD
18637	8575	79	,	,	,
18637	8575	80	appropriating	appropriate	VBG
18637	8575	81	a	a	DT
18637	8575	82	large	large	JJ
18637	8575	83	sum	sum	NN
18637	8575	84	,	,	,
18637	8575	85	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	8575	86	-	-	HYPH
18637	8575	87	five	five	CD
18637	8575	88	thousand	thousand	CD
18637	8575	89	dollars	dollar	NNS
18637	8575	90	annually	annually	RB
18637	8575	91	,	,	,
18637	8575	92	for	for	IN
18637	8575	93	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	8575	94	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8575	95	into	into	IN
18637	8575	96	effect	effect	NN
18637	8575	97	.	.	.
18637	8576	1	"	"	``
18637	8576	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8576	3	279	279	CD
18637	8576	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8576	5	The	the	DT
18637	8576	6	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	8576	7	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	8576	8	by	by	IN
18637	8576	9	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	8576	10	's	's	POS
18637	8576	11	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8576	12	without	without	IN
18637	8576	13	reference	reference	NN
18637	8576	14	to	to	IN
18637	8576	15	the	the	DT
18637	8576	16	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8576	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	8576	18	since	since	RB
18637	8576	19	been	be	VBN
18637	8576	20	multiplied	multiply	VBN
18637	8576	21	many	many	JJ
18637	8576	22	times	time	NNS
18637	8576	23	,	,	,
18637	8576	24	as	as	IN
18637	8576	25	witness	witness	NN
18637	8576	26	the	the	DT
18637	8576	27	mission	mission	NN
18637	8576	28	of	of	IN
18637	8576	29	A.	A.	NNP
18637	8576	30	Dudley	Dudley	NNP
18637	8576	31	Mann	Mann	NNP
18637	8576	32	to	to	IN
18637	8576	33	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
18637	8576	34	and	and	CC
18637	8576	35	other	other	JJ
18637	8576	36	German	german	JJ
18637	8576	37	states	state	NNS
18637	8576	38	in	in	IN
18637	8576	39	1846	1846	CD
18637	8576	40	,	,	,
18637	8576	41	of	of	IN
18637	8576	42	the	the	DT
18637	8576	43	same	same	JJ
18637	8576	44	gentleman	gentleman	NN
18637	8576	45	to	to	IN
18637	8576	46	Hungary	Hungary	NNP
18637	8576	47	in	in	IN
18637	8576	48	1849	1849	CD
18637	8576	49	,	,	,
18637	8576	50	of	of	IN
18637	8576	51	Nicholas	Nicholas	NNP
18637	8576	52	Trist	Trist	NNP
18637	8576	53	to	to	IN
18637	8576	54	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	8576	55	in	in	IN
18637	8576	56	1848	1848	CD
18637	8576	57	,	,	,
18637	8576	58	of	of	IN
18637	8576	59	Commodore	Commodore	NNP
18637	8576	60	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	8576	61	to	to	IN
18637	8576	62	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	8576	63	in	in	IN
18637	8576	64	1852	1852	CD
18637	8576	65	,	,	,
18637	8576	66	of	of	IN
18637	8576	67	J.H.	J.H.	NNP
18637	8577	1	Blount	blount	NN
18637	8577	2	to	to	IN
18637	8577	3	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	8577	4	in	in	IN
18637	8577	5	1893	1893	CD
18637	8577	6	.	.	.
18637	8578	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8578	2	280	280	CD
18637	8578	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8578	4	The	the	DT
18637	8578	5	last	last	JJ
18637	8578	6	named	name	VBN
18637	8578	7	case	case	NN
18637	8578	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	8578	9	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	8578	10	the	the	DT
18637	8578	11	extremest	extreme	JJS
18637	8578	12	of	of	IN
18637	8578	13	all	all	DT
18637	8578	14	.	.	.
18637	8579	1	Blount	Blount	NNP
18637	8579	2	,	,	,
18637	8579	3	who	who	WP
18637	8579	4	was	be	VBD
18637	8579	5	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	8579	6	while	while	IN
18637	8579	7	the	the	DT
18637	8579	8	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8579	9	was	be	VBD
18637	8579	10	in	in	IN
18637	8579	11	session	session	NN
18637	8579	12	but	but	CC
18637	8579	13	without	without	IN
18637	8579	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8579	15	advice	advice	NN
18637	8579	16	and	and	CC
18637	8579	17	consent	consent	NN
18637	8579	18	,	,	,
18637	8579	19	was	be	VBD
18637	8579	20	given	give	VBN
18637	8579	21	"	"	``
18637	8579	22	paramount	paramount	NNP
18637	8579	23	authority	authority	NN
18637	8579	24	"	"	''
18637	8579	25	over	over	IN
18637	8579	26	the	the	DT
18637	8579	27	American	american	JJ
18637	8579	28	resident	resident	NN
18637	8579	29	minister	minister	NN
18637	8579	30	at	at	IN
18637	8579	31	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	8579	32	and	and	CC
18637	8579	33	was	be	VBD
18637	8579	34	further	further	RB
18637	8579	35	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	8579	36	to	to	TO
18637	8579	37	employ	employ	VB
18637	8579	38	the	the	DT
18637	8579	39	military	military	JJ
18637	8579	40	and	and	CC
18637	8579	41	naval	naval	JJ
18637	8579	42	forces	force	NNS
18637	8579	43	of	of	IN
18637	8579	44	the	the	DT
18637	8579	45	United	United	NNP
18637	8579	46	States	States	NNP
18637	8579	47	,	,	,
18637	8579	48	if	if	IN
18637	8579	49	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8579	50	to	to	TO
18637	8579	51	protect	protect	VB
18637	8579	52	American	american	JJ
18637	8579	53	lives	life	NNS
18637	8579	54	and	and	CC
18637	8579	55	interests	interest	NNS
18637	8579	56	.	.	.
18637	8580	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8580	2	mission	mission	NN
18637	8580	3	raised	raise	VBD
18637	8580	4	a	a	DT
18637	8580	5	vigorous	vigorous	JJ
18637	8580	6	storm	storm	NN
18637	8580	7	of	of	IN
18637	8580	8	protest	protest	NN
18637	8580	9	in	in	IN
18637	8580	10	the	the	DT
18637	8580	11	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8580	12	,	,	,
18637	8580	13	but	but	CC
18637	8580	14	the	the	DT
18637	8580	15	majority	majority	NN
18637	8580	16	report	report	NN
18637	8580	17	of	of	IN
18637	8580	18	the	the	DT
18637	8580	19	committee	committee	NN
18637	8580	20	which	which	WDT
18637	8580	21	was	be	VBD
18637	8580	22	created	create	VBN
18637	8580	23	to	to	TO
18637	8580	24	investigate	investigate	VB
18637	8580	25	the	the	DT
18637	8580	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8580	27	question	question	NN
18637	8580	28	vindicated	vindicate	VBD
18637	8580	29	the	the	DT
18637	8580	30	President	President	NNP
18637	8580	31	in	in	IN
18637	8580	32	the	the	DT
18637	8580	33	following	following	JJ
18637	8580	34	terms	term	NNS
18637	8580	35	:	:	:
18637	8580	36	"	"	``
18637	8580	37	A	a	DT
18637	8580	38	question	question	NN
18637	8580	39	has	have	VBZ
18637	8580	40	been	be	VBN
18637	8580	41	made	make	VBN
18637	8580	42	as	as	IN
18637	8580	43	to	to	IN
18637	8580	44	the	the	DT
18637	8580	45	right	right	NN
18637	8580	46	of	of	IN
18637	8580	47	the	the	DT
18637	8580	48	President	President	NNP
18637	8580	49	of	of	IN
18637	8580	50	the	the	DT
18637	8580	51	United	United	NNP
18637	8580	52	States	States	NNP
18637	8580	53	to	to	TO
18637	8580	54	dispatch	dispatch	VB
18637	8580	55	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	8580	56	Blount	Blount	NNP
18637	8580	57	to	to	IN
18637	8580	58	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	8580	59	as	as	IN
18637	8580	60	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8580	61	personal	personal	JJ
18637	8580	62	representative	representative	NN
18637	8580	63	for	for	IN
18637	8580	64	the	the	DT
18637	8580	65	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8580	66	of	of	IN
18637	8580	67	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	8580	68	the	the	DT
18637	8580	69	further	further	JJ
18637	8580	70	information	information	NN
18637	8580	71	which	which	WDT
18637	8580	72	the	the	DT
18637	8580	73	President	President	NNP
18637	8580	74	believed	believe	VBD
18637	8580	75	was	be	VBD
18637	8580	76	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8580	77	in	in	IN
18637	8580	78	order	order	NN
18637	8580	79	to	to	TO
18637	8580	80	arrive	arrive	VB
18637	8580	81	at	at	IN
18637	8580	82	a	a	DT
18637	8580	83	just	just	JJ
18637	8580	84	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	8580	85	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	8580	86	the	the	DT
18637	8580	87	state	state	NN
18637	8580	88	of	of	IN
18637	8580	89	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	8580	90	in	in	IN
18637	8580	91	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	8580	92	.	.	.
18637	8581	1	Many	many	JJ
18637	8581	2	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	8581	3	could	could	MD
18637	8581	4	be	be	VB
18637	8581	5	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	8581	6	to	to	TO
18637	8581	7	show	show	VB
18637	8581	8	that	that	IN
18637	8581	9	such	such	JJ
18637	8581	10	power	power	NN
18637	8581	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	8581	12	been	be	VBN
18637	8581	13	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	8581	14	by	by	IN
18637	8581	15	the	the	DT
18637	8581	16	President	President	NNP
18637	8581	17	on	on	IN
18637	8581	18	various	various	JJ
18637	8581	19	occasions	occasion	NNS
18637	8581	20	,	,	,
18637	8581	21	without	without	IN
18637	8581	22	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	8581	23	on	on	IN
18637	8581	24	the	the	DT
18637	8581	25	part	part	NN
18637	8581	26	of	of	IN
18637	8581	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8581	28	or	or	CC
18637	8581	29	the	the	DT
18637	8581	30	people	people	NNS
18637	8581	31	of	of	IN
18637	8581	32	the	the	DT
18637	8581	33	United	United	NNP
18637	8581	34	States	States	NNP
18637	8581	35	.	.	.
18637	8582	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8582	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8582	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8582	4	These	these	DT
18637	8582	5	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	8582	6	also	also	RB
18637	8582	7	show	show	VBP
18637	8582	8	that	that	IN
18637	8582	9	the	the	DT
18637	8582	10	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8582	11	of	of	IN
18637	8582	12	the	the	DT
18637	8582	13	United	United	NNP
18637	8582	14	States	States	NNP
18637	8582	15	,	,	,
18637	8582	16	though	though	IN
18637	8582	17	in	in	IN
18637	8582	18	session	session	NN
18637	8582	19	,	,	,
18637	8582	20	need	nee	MD
18637	8582	21	not	not	RB
18637	8582	22	be	be	VB
18637	8582	23	consulted	consult	VBN
18637	8582	24	as	as	IN
18637	8582	25	to	to	IN
18637	8582	26	the	the	DT
18637	8582	27	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8582	28	of	of	IN
18637	8582	29	such	such	JJ
18637	8582	30	agents	agent	NNS
18637	8582	31	,	,	,
18637	8582	32	*	*	NFP
18637	8582	33	*	*	NFP
18637	8582	34	*	*	NFP
18637	8582	35	"	"	''
18637	8582	36	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8582	37	281	281	CD
18637	8582	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8582	39	For	for	IN
18637	8582	40	recent	recent	JJ
18637	8582	41	decades	decade	NNS
18637	8582	42	the	the	DT
18637	8582	43	continued	continue	VBN
18637	8582	44	vitality	vitality	NN
18637	8582	45	of	of	IN
18637	8582	46	the	the	DT
18637	8582	47	practice	practice	NN
18637	8582	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	8582	49	attested	attest	VBN
18637	8582	50	by	by	IN
18637	8582	51	such	such	JJ
18637	8582	52	names	name	NNS
18637	8582	53	as	as	IN
18637	8582	54	Colonel	Colonel	NNP
18637	8582	55	House	House	NNP
18637	8582	56	,	,	,
18637	8582	57	late	late	JJ
18637	8582	58	Norman	Norman	NNP
18637	8582	59	H.	H.	NNP
18637	8582	60	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	8582	61	,	,	,
18637	8582	62	who	who	WP
18637	8582	63	filled	fill	VBD
18637	8582	64	the	the	DT
18637	8582	65	role	role	NN
18637	8582	66	of	of	IN
18637	8582	67	"	"	``
18637	8582	68	ambassador	ambassador	NN
18637	8582	69	at	at	IN
18637	8582	70	large	large	JJ
18637	8582	71	"	"	''
18637	8582	72	for	for	IN
18637	8582	73	a	a	DT
18637	8582	74	succession	succession	NN
18637	8582	75	of	of	IN
18637	8582	76	administrations	administration	NNS
18637	8582	77	of	of	IN
18637	8582	78	both	both	DT
18637	8582	79	parties	party	NNS
18637	8582	80	,	,	,
18637	8582	81	and	and	CC
18637	8582	82	Professor	Professor	NNP
18637	8582	83	Philip	Philip	NNP
18637	8582	84	Jessup	Jessup	NNP
18637	8582	85	,	,	,
18637	8582	86	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	8582	87	Averell	Averell	NNP
18637	8582	88	Harriman	Harriman	NNP
18637	8582	89	,	,	,
18637	8582	90	and	and	CC
18637	8582	91	other	other	JJ
18637	8582	92	"	"	``
18637	8582	93	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	8582	94	at	at	IN
18637	8582	95	large	large	JJ
18637	8582	96	"	"	''
18637	8582	97	of	of	IN
18637	8582	98	the	the	DT
18637	8582	99	Truman	Truman	NNP
18637	8582	100	administration	administration	NN
18637	8582	101	.	.	.
18637	8583	1	How	how	WRB
18637	8583	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8583	3	this	this	DT
18637	8583	4	practice	practice	NN
18637	8583	5	to	to	TO
18637	8583	6	be	be	VB
18637	8583	7	squared	square	VBN
18637	8583	8	with	with	IN
18637	8583	9	the	the	DT
18637	8583	10	express	express	JJ
18637	8583	11	words	word	NNS
18637	8583	12	of	of	IN
18637	8583	13	the	the	DT
18637	8583	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8583	15	?	?	.
18637	8584	1	Apparently	apparently	RB
18637	8584	2	,	,	,
18637	8584	3	by	by	IN
18637	8584	4	stressing	stress	VBG
18637	8584	5	the	the	DT
18637	8584	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	8584	7	that	that	IN
18637	8584	8	such	such	JJ
18637	8584	9	appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	8584	10	or	or	CC
18637	8584	11	designations	designation	NNS
18637	8584	12	are	be	VBP
18637	8584	13	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	8584	14	merely	merely	RB
18637	8584	15	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	8584	16	and	and	CC
18637	8584	17	for	for	IN
18637	8584	18	special	special	JJ
18637	8584	19	tasks	task	NNS
18637	8584	20	,	,	,
18637	8584	21	and	and	CC
18637	8584	22	hence	hence	RB
18637	8584	23	do	do	VBP
18637	8584	24	not	not	RB
18637	8584	25	fulfill	fulfill	VB
18637	8584	26	the	the	DT
18637	8584	27	tests	test	NNS
18637	8584	28	of	of	IN
18637	8584	29	"	"	``
18637	8584	30	office	office	NN
18637	8584	31	"	"	''
18637	8584	32	in	in	IN
18637	8584	33	the	the	DT
18637	8584	34	strict	strict	JJ
18637	8584	35	sense	sense	NN
18637	8584	36	.	.	.
18637	8585	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8585	2	_	_	NNP
18637	8585	3	See	See	NNP
18637	8585	4	_	_	NNP
18637	8585	5	p.	p.	NN
18637	8585	6	445	445	CD
18637	8585	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8585	8	.	.	.
18637	8586	1	In	in	IN
18637	8586	2	the	the	DT
18637	8586	3	same	same	JJ
18637	8586	4	way	way	NN
18637	8586	5	the	the	DT
18637	8586	6	not	not	RB
18637	8586	7	infrequent	infrequent	JJ
18637	8586	8	practice	practice	NN
18637	8586	9	of	of	IN
18637	8586	10	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	8586	11	of	of	IN
18637	8586	12	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	8586	13	Members	member	NNS
18637	8586	14	of	of	IN
18637	8586	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8586	16	as	as	IN
18637	8586	17	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	8586	18	to	to	TO
18637	8586	19	negotiate	negotiate	VB
18637	8586	20	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8586	21	and	and	CC
18637	8586	22	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	8586	23	with	with	IN
18637	8586	24	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8586	25	governments	government	NNS
18637	8586	26	may	may	MD
18637	8586	27	be	be	VB
18637	8586	28	regularized	regularize	VBN
18637	8586	29	,	,	,
18637	8586	30	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	8586	31	the	the	DT
18637	8586	32	provision	provision	NN
18637	8586	33	of	of	IN
18637	8586	34	article	article	NN
18637	8586	35	I	i	NN
18637	8586	36	,	,	,
18637	8586	37	section	section	NN
18637	8586	38	6	6	CD
18637	8586	39	,	,	,
18637	8586	40	clause	clause	NN
18637	8586	41	2	2	CD
18637	8586	42	of	of	IN
18637	8586	43	the	the	DT
18637	8586	44	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8586	45	,	,	,
18637	8586	46	which	which	WDT
18637	8586	47	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	8586	48	that	that	IN
18637	8586	49	"	"	``
18637	8586	50	no	no	DT
18637	8586	51	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	8586	52	or	or	CC
18637	8586	53	Representative	Representative	NNP
18637	8586	54	shall	shall	MD
18637	8586	55	,	,	,
18637	8586	56	*	*	NFP
18637	8586	57	*	*	NFP
18637	8586	58	*	*	NFP
18637	8586	59	,	,	,
18637	8586	60	be	be	VB
18637	8586	61	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	8586	62	to	to	IN
18637	8586	63	any	any	DT
18637	8586	64	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8586	65	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8586	66	under	under	IN
18637	8586	67	the	the	DT
18637	8586	68	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	8586	69	of	of	IN
18637	8586	70	the	the	DT
18637	8586	71	United	United	NNP
18637	8586	72	States	States	NNP
18637	8586	73	,	,	,
18637	8586	74	which	which	WDT
18637	8586	75	shall	shall	MD
18637	8586	76	have	have	VB
18637	8586	77	been	be	VBN
18637	8586	78	created	create	VBN
18637	8586	79	,	,	,
18637	8586	80	"	"	''
18637	8586	81	during	during	IN
18637	8586	82	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8586	83	term	term	NN
18637	8586	84	;	;	:
18637	8586	85	and	and	CC
18637	8586	86	no	no	DT
18637	8586	87	officer	officer	NN
18637	8586	88	of	of	IN
18637	8586	89	the	the	DT
18637	8586	90	United	United	NNP
18637	8586	91	States	States	NNP
18637	8586	92	,	,	,
18637	8586	93	"	"	``
18637	8586	94	shall	shall	MD
18637	8586	95	be	be	VB
18637	8586	96	a	a	DT
18637	8586	97	Member	Member	NNP
18637	8586	98	of	of	IN
18637	8586	99	either	either	DT
18637	8586	100	House	House	NNP
18637	8586	101	during	during	IN
18637	8586	102	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8586	103	Continuance	Continuance	NNP
18637	8586	104	in	in	IN
18637	8586	105	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8586	106	.	.	.
18637	8587	1	"	"	``
18637	8587	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8587	3	282	282	CD
18637	8587	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8587	5	The	the	DT
18637	8587	6	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	8587	7	of	of	IN
18637	8587	8	Peace	Peace	NNP
18637	8587	9	with	with	IN
18637	8587	10	Spain	Spain	NNP
18637	8587	11	,	,	,
18637	8587	12	the	the	DT
18637	8587	13	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8587	14	to	to	TO
18637	8587	15	settle	settle	VB
18637	8587	16	the	the	DT
18637	8587	17	Behring	Behring	NNP
18637	8587	18	Sea	Sea	NNP
18637	8587	19	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	8587	20	,	,	,
18637	8587	21	the	the	DT
18637	8587	22	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8587	23	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	8587	24	the	the	DT
18637	8587	25	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	8587	26	line	line	NN
18637	8587	27	between	between	IN
18637	8587	28	Canada	Canada	NNP
18637	8587	29	and	and	CC
18637	8587	30	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	8587	31	,	,	,
18637	8587	32	were	be	VBD
18637	8587	33	negotiated	negotiate	VBN
18637	8587	34	by	by	IN
18637	8587	35	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	8587	36	containing	contain	VBG
18637	8587	37	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	8587	38	and	and	CC
18637	8587	39	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	8587	40	.	.	.
18637	8588	1	CONGRESSIONAL	congressional	JJ
18637	8588	2	REGULATION	regulation	NN
18637	8588	3	OF	of	IN
18637	8588	4	OFFICES	office	NNS
18637	8588	5	That	that	IN
18637	8588	6	the	the	DT
18637	8588	7	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8588	8	distinguishes	distinguish	VBZ
18637	8588	9	between	between	IN
18637	8588	10	the	the	DT
18637	8588	11	creation	creation	NN
18637	8588	12	of	of	IN
18637	8588	13	an	an	DT
18637	8588	14	office	office	NN
18637	8588	15	and	and	CC
18637	8588	16	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8588	17	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	8588	18	for	for	IN
18637	8588	19	the	the	DT
18637	8588	20	generality	generality	NN
18637	8588	21	of	of	IN
18637	8588	22	national	national	JJ
18637	8588	23	offices	office	NNS
18637	8588	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	8588	25	never	never	RB
18637	8588	26	been	be	VBN
18637	8588	27	questioned	question	VBN
18637	8588	28	.	.	.
18637	8589	1	The	the	DT
18637	8589	2	former	former	JJ
18637	8589	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8589	4	_	_	NNP
18637	8589	5	by	by	IN
18637	8589	6	law	law	NN
18637	8589	7	_	_	NNP
18637	8589	8	,	,	,
18637	8589	9	and	and	CC
18637	8589	10	takes	take	VBZ
18637	8589	11	place	place	NN
18637	8589	12	by	by	IN
18637	8589	13	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	8589	14	of	of	IN
18637	8589	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8589	16	's	's	POS
18637	8589	17	power	power	NN
18637	8589	18	to	to	TO
18637	8589	19	pass	pass	VB
18637	8589	20	all	all	DT
18637	8589	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	8589	22	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8589	23	and	and	CC
18637	8589	24	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8589	25	for	for	IN
18637	8589	26	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	8589	27	into	into	IN
18637	8589	28	execution	execution	NN
18637	8589	29	the	the	DT
18637	8589	30	powers	power	NNS
18637	8589	31	which	which	WDT
18637	8589	32	the	the	DT
18637	8589	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8589	34	confers	confer	NNS
18637	8589	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	8589	36	the	the	DT
18637	8589	37	government	government	NN
18637	8589	38	of	of	IN
18637	8589	39	the	the	DT
18637	8589	40	United	United	NNP
18637	8589	41	States	States	NNP
18637	8589	42	and	and	CC
18637	8589	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8589	44	departments	department	NNS
18637	8589	45	and	and	CC
18637	8589	46	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8589	47	.	.	.
18637	8590	1	As	as	IN
18637	8590	2	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	8590	3	to	to	IN
18637	8590	4	the	the	DT
18637	8590	5	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	8590	6	of	of	IN
18637	8590	7	an	an	DT
18637	8590	8	office	office	NN
18637	8590	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8590	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	8590	11	also	also	RB
18637	8590	12	the	the	DT
18637	8590	13	power	power	NN
18637	8590	14	to	to	TO
18637	8590	15	determine	determine	VB
18637	8590	16	the	the	DT
18637	8590	17	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	8590	18	of	of	IN
18637	8590	19	the	the	DT
18637	8590	20	officer	officer	NN
18637	8590	21	,	,	,
18637	8590	22	and	and	CC
18637	8590	23	in	in	IN
18637	8590	24	so	so	RB
18637	8590	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	8590	26	doing	do	VBG
18637	8590	27	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	8590	28	limits	limit	VBZ
18637	8590	29	the	the	DT
18637	8590	30	range	range	NN
18637	8590	31	of	of	IN
18637	8590	32	choice	choice	NN
18637	8590	33	of	of	IN
18637	8590	34	the	the	DT
18637	8590	35	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	8590	36	power	power	NN
18637	8590	37	.	.	.
18637	8591	1	First	first	RB
18637	8591	2	and	and	CC
18637	8591	3	last	last	JJ
18637	8591	4	,	,	,
18637	8591	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8591	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	8591	7	laid	lay	VBN
18637	8591	8	down	down	RP
18637	8591	9	a	a	DT
18637	8591	10	great	great	JJ
18637	8591	11	variety	variety	NN
18637	8591	12	of	of	IN
18637	8591	13	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	8591	14	,	,	,
18637	8591	15	depending	depend	VBG
18637	8591	16	on	on	IN
18637	8591	17	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	8591	18	,	,	,
18637	8591	19	residence	residence	NN
18637	8591	20	,	,	,
18637	8591	21	professional	professional	JJ
18637	8591	22	attainments	attainment	NNS
18637	8591	23	,	,	,
18637	8591	24	occupational	occupational	JJ
18637	8591	25	experience	experience	NN
18637	8591	26	,	,	,
18637	8591	27	age	age	NN
18637	8591	28	,	,	,
18637	8591	29	race	race	NN
18637	8591	30	,	,	,
18637	8591	31	property	property	NN
18637	8591	32	,	,	,
18637	8591	33	sound	sound	JJ
18637	8591	34	habits	habit	NNS
18637	8591	35	,	,	,
18637	8591	36	and	and	CC
18637	8591	37	so	so	RB
18637	8591	38	on	on	RB
18637	8591	39	.	.	.
18637	8592	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8592	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	8592	3	required	require	VBN
18637	8592	4	that	that	IN
18637	8592	5	appointees	appointee	NNS
18637	8592	6	be	be	VB
18637	8592	7	representative	representative	JJ
18637	8592	8	of	of	IN
18637	8592	9	a	a	DT
18637	8592	10	political	political	JJ
18637	8592	11	party	party	NN
18637	8592	12	,	,	,
18637	8592	13	of	of	IN
18637	8592	14	an	an	DT
18637	8592	15	industry	industry	NN
18637	8592	16	,	,	,
18637	8592	17	of	of	IN
18637	8592	18	a	a	DT
18637	8592	19	geographic	geographic	JJ
18637	8592	20	region	region	NN
18637	8592	21	,	,	,
18637	8592	22	or	or	CC
18637	8592	23	of	of	IN
18637	8592	24	a	a	DT
18637	8592	25	particular	particular	JJ
18637	8592	26	branch	branch	NN
18637	8592	27	of	of	IN
18637	8592	28	the	the	DT
18637	8592	29	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8592	30	.	.	.
18637	8593	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8593	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	8593	3	confined	confine	VBN
18637	8593	4	the	the	DT
18637	8593	5	President	President	NNP
18637	8593	6	's	's	POS
18637	8593	7	selection	selection	NN
18637	8593	8	to	to	IN
18637	8593	9	a	a	DT
18637	8593	10	small	small	JJ
18637	8593	11	number	number	NN
18637	8593	12	of	of	IN
18637	8593	13	persons	person	NNS
18637	8593	14	to	to	TO
18637	8593	15	be	be	VB
18637	8593	16	named	name	VBN
18637	8593	17	by	by	IN
18637	8593	18	others	other	NNS
18637	8593	19	.	.	.
18637	8594	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8594	2	283	283	CD
18637	8594	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8594	4	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	8594	5	,	,	,
18637	8594	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8594	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	8594	8	contrived	contrive	VBN
18637	8594	9	at	at	IN
18637	8594	10	times	time	NNS
18637	8594	11	to	to	TO
18637	8594	12	designate	designate	VB
18637	8594	13	a	a	DT
18637	8594	14	definite	definite	JJ
18637	8594	15	eligibility	eligibility	NN
18637	8594	16	,	,	,
18637	8594	17	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	8594	18	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	8594	19	usurping	usurping	JJ
18637	8594	20	the	the	DT
18637	8594	21	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	8594	22	power	power	NN
18637	8594	23	.	.	.
18637	8595	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8595	2	284	284	CD
18637	8595	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8595	4	CONDUCT	CONDUCT	NNP
18637	8595	5	IN	in	IN
18637	8595	6	OFFICE	OFFICE	NNP
18637	8595	7	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	8595	8	,	,	,
18637	8595	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8595	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	8595	11	very	very	RB
18637	8595	12	broad	broad	JJ
18637	8595	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	8595	14	in	in	IN
18637	8595	15	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	8595	16	the	the	DT
18637	8595	17	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	8595	18	in	in	IN
18637	8595	19	office	office	NN
18637	8595	20	of	of	IN
18637	8595	21	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8595	22	and	and	CC
18637	8595	23	employees	employee	NNS
18637	8595	24	of	of	IN
18637	8595	25	the	the	DT
18637	8595	26	United	United	NNP
18637	8595	27	States	States	NNP
18637	8595	28	,	,	,
18637	8595	29	especially	especially	RB
18637	8595	30	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	8595	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8595	32	political	political	JJ
18637	8595	33	activities	activity	NNS
18637	8595	34	.	.	.
18637	8596	1	By	by	IN
18637	8596	2	an	an	DT
18637	8596	3	act	act	NN
18637	8596	4	passed	pass	VBN
18637	8596	5	in	in	IN
18637	8596	6	1876	1876	CD
18637	8596	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8596	8	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	8596	9	"	"	``
18637	8596	10	all	all	DT
18637	8596	11	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8596	12	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8596	13	or	or	CC
18637	8596	14	employees	employee	NNS
18637	8596	15	of	of	IN
18637	8596	16	the	the	DT
18637	8596	17	United	United	NNP
18637	8596	18	States	States	NNP
18637	8596	19	not	not	RB
18637	8596	20	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	8596	21	by	by	IN
18637	8596	22	the	the	DT
18637	8596	23	President	President	NNP
18637	8596	24	,	,	,
18637	8596	25	with	with	IN
18637	8596	26	the	the	DT
18637	8596	27	advice	advice	NN
18637	8596	28	and	and	CC
18637	8596	29	consent	consent	NN
18637	8596	30	of	of	IN
18637	8596	31	the	the	DT
18637	8596	32	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8596	33	,	,	,
18637	8596	34	*	*	NFP
18637	8596	35	*	*	NFP
18637	8596	36	*	*	NFP
18637	8596	37	from	from	IN
18637	8596	38	requesting	request	VBG
18637	8596	39	,	,	,
18637	8596	40	giving	give	VBG
18637	8596	41	to	to	IN
18637	8596	42	,	,	,
18637	8596	43	or	or	CC
18637	8596	44	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	8596	45	from	from	IN
18637	8596	46	,	,	,
18637	8596	47	any	any	DT
18637	8596	48	other	other	JJ
18637	8596	49	officer	officer	NN
18637	8596	50	or	or	CC
18637	8596	51	employee	employee	NN
18637	8596	52	of	of	IN
18637	8596	53	the	the	DT
18637	8596	54	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8596	55	,	,	,
18637	8596	56	any	any	DT
18637	8596	57	money	money	NN
18637	8596	58	or	or	CC
18637	8596	59	property	property	NN
18637	8596	60	or	or	CC
18637	8596	61	other	other	JJ
18637	8596	62	thing	thing	NN
18637	8596	63	of	of	IN
18637	8596	64	value	value	NN
18637	8596	65	for	for	IN
18637	8596	66	political	political	JJ
18637	8596	67	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	8596	68	.	.	.
18637	8597	1	"	"	``
18637	8597	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8597	3	285	285	CD
18637	8597	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8597	5	The	the	DT
18637	8597	6	validity	validity	NN
18637	8597	7	of	of	IN
18637	8597	8	this	this	DT
18637	8597	9	measure	measure	NN
18637	8597	10	having	have	VBG
18637	8597	11	been	be	VBN
18637	8597	12	sustained,[286	sustained,[286	NN
18637	8597	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8597	14	the	the	DT
18637	8597	15	substance	substance	NN
18637	8597	16	of	of	IN
18637	8597	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8597	18	,	,	,
18637	8597	19	with	with	IN
18637	8597	20	some	some	DT
18637	8597	21	elaborations	elaboration	NNS
18637	8597	22	,	,	,
18637	8597	23	was	be	VBD
18637	8597	24	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	8597	25	in	in	IN
18637	8597	26	the	the	DT
18637	8597	27	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	8597	28	Service	Service	NNP
18637	8597	29	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8597	30	of	of	IN
18637	8597	31	1883	1883	CD
18637	8597	32	.	.	.
18637	8598	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8598	2	287	287	CD
18637	8598	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8598	4	By	by	IN
18637	8598	5	the	the	DT
18637	8598	6	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	8598	7	Act[288	Act[288	NNP
18637	8598	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8598	9	all	all	DT
18637	8598	10	persons	person	NNS
18637	8598	11	in	in	IN
18637	8598	12	the	the	DT
18637	8598	13	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8598	14	branch	branch	NN
18637	8598	15	of	of	IN
18637	8598	16	the	the	DT
18637	8598	17	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8598	18	,	,	,
18637	8598	19	or	or	CC
18637	8598	20	any	any	DT
18637	8598	21	department	department	NN
18637	8598	22	or	or	CC
18637	8598	23	agency	agency	NN
18637	8598	24	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8598	25	,	,	,
18637	8598	26	except	except	IN
18637	8598	27	the	the	DT
18637	8598	28	President	President	NNP
18637	8598	29	and	and	CC
18637	8598	30	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	8598	31	President	President	NNP
18637	8598	32	and	and	CC
18637	8598	33	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8598	34	"	"	``
18637	8598	35	policy	policy	NN
18637	8598	36	determining	determining	NN
18637	8598	37	"	"	''
18637	8598	38	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8598	39	,	,	,
18637	8598	40	are	be	VBP
18637	8598	41	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	8598	42	to	to	TO
18637	8598	43	"	"	``
18637	8598	44	take	take	VB
18637	8598	45	an	an	DT
18637	8598	46	active	active	JJ
18637	8598	47	part	part	NN
18637	8598	48	in	in	IN
18637	8598	49	political	political	JJ
18637	8598	50	management	management	NN
18637	8598	51	or	or	CC
18637	8598	52	political	political	JJ
18637	8598	53	campaigns	campaign	NNS
18637	8598	54	,	,	,
18637	8598	55	"	"	''
18637	8598	56	although	although	IN
18637	8598	57	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8598	58	are	be	VBP
18637	8598	59	still	still	RB
18637	8598	60	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	8598	61	to	to	TO
18637	8598	62	"	"	``
18637	8598	63	express	express	VB
18637	8598	64	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8598	65	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	8598	66	on	on	IN
18637	8598	67	all	all	DT
18637	8598	68	political	political	JJ
18637	8598	69	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	8598	70	and	and	CC
18637	8598	71	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	8598	72	.	.	.
18637	8598	73	"	"	''
18637	8599	1	In	in	IN
18637	8599	2	the	the	DT
18637	8599	3	United	United	NNP
18637	8599	4	Public	Public	NNP
18637	8599	5	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	8599	6	_	_	NNP
18637	8599	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	8599	8	_	_	NNP
18637	8599	9	Mitchell[289	Mitchell[289	NNP
18637	8599	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8599	11	these	these	DT
18637	8599	12	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8599	13	were	be	VBD
18637	8599	14	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	8599	15	as	as	IN
18637	8599	16	"	"	``
18637	8599	17	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	8599	18	"	"	''
18637	8599	19	against	against	IN
18637	8599	20	objections	objection	NNS
18637	8599	21	based	base	VBN
18637	8599	22	on	on	IN
18637	8599	23	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	8599	24	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8599	25	,	,	,
18637	8599	26	V	V	NNP
18637	8599	27	,	,	,
18637	8599	28	IX	IX	NNP
18637	8599	29	,	,	,
18637	8599	30	and	and	CC
18637	8599	31	X.	X.	NNP
18637	8600	1	THE	the	DT
18637	8600	2	LOYALTY	LOYALTY	NNP
18637	8600	3	ISSUE	ISSUE	VBD
18637	8600	4	By	by	IN
18637	8600	5	section	section	NN
18637	8600	6	9A	9a	NN
18637	8600	7	of	of	IN
18637	8600	8	the	the	DT
18637	8600	9	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	8600	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8600	11	of	of	IN
18637	8600	12	1939	1939	CD
18637	8600	13	,	,	,
18637	8600	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8600	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	8600	16	made	make	VBN
18637	8600	17	"	"	``
18637	8600	18	*	*	NFP
18637	8600	19	*	*	NFP
18637	8600	20	*	*	NFP
18637	8600	21	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	8600	22	for	for	IN
18637	8600	23	any	any	DT
18637	8600	24	person	person	NN
18637	8600	25	employed	employ	VBN
18637	8600	26	in	in	IN
18637	8600	27	any	any	DT
18637	8600	28	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	8600	29	by	by	IN
18637	8600	30	any	any	DT
18637	8600	31	agency	agency	NN
18637	8600	32	of	of	IN
18637	8600	33	the	the	DT
18637	8600	34	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8600	35	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8600	36	,	,	,
18637	8600	37	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8600	38	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	8600	39	,	,	,
18637	8600	40	or	or	CC
18637	8600	41	any	any	DT
18637	8600	42	part	part	NN
18637	8600	43	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8600	44	,	,	,
18637	8600	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	8600	46	paid	pay	VBN
18637	8600	47	from	from	IN
18637	8600	48	funds	fund	NNS
18637	8600	49	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8600	50	or	or	CC
18637	8600	51	appropriated	appropriate	VBN
18637	8600	52	by	by	IN
18637	8600	53	any	any	DT
18637	8600	54	act	act	NN
18637	8600	55	of	of	IN
18637	8600	56	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8600	57	,	,	,
18637	8600	58	to	to	TO
18637	8600	59	have	have	VB
18637	8600	60	membership	membership	NN
18637	8600	61	in	in	IN
18637	8600	62	any	any	DT
18637	8600	63	political	political	JJ
18637	8600	64	party	party	NN
18637	8600	65	or	or	CC
18637	8600	66	organization	organization	NN
18637	8600	67	which	which	WDT
18637	8600	68	advocates	advocate	VBZ
18637	8600	69	the	the	DT
18637	8600	70	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	8600	71	of	of	IN
18637	8600	72	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8600	73	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8600	74	form	form	NN
18637	8600	75	of	of	IN
18637	8600	76	government	government	NN
18637	8600	77	in	in	IN
18637	8600	78	the	the	DT
18637	8600	79	United	United	NNP
18637	8600	80	States	States	NNP
18637	8600	81	.	.	.
18637	8601	1	"	"	``
18637	8601	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8601	3	290	290	CD
18637	8601	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8601	5	In	in	IN
18637	8601	6	support	support	NN
18637	8601	7	of	of	IN
18637	8601	8	this	this	DT
18637	8601	9	provision	provision	NN
18637	8601	10	the	the	DT
18637	8601	11	79th	79th	JJ
18637	8601	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8601	13	in	in	IN
18637	8601	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8601	15	second	second	JJ
18637	8601	16	session	session	NN
18637	8601	17	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	8601	18	in	in	IN
18637	8601	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8601	20	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	8601	21	acts	act	VBZ
18637	8601	22	a	a	DT
18637	8601	23	series	series	NN
18637	8601	24	of	of	IN
18637	8601	25	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	8601	26	which	which	WDT
18637	8601	27	forbid	forbid	VBP
18637	8601	28	the	the	DT
18637	8601	29	use	use	NN
18637	8601	30	of	of	IN
18637	8601	31	any	any	DT
18637	8601	32	of	of	IN
18637	8601	33	the	the	DT
18637	8601	34	funds	fund	NNS
18637	8601	35	appropriated	appropriate	VBN
18637	8601	36	to	to	TO
18637	8601	37	pay	pay	VB
18637	8601	38	the	the	DT
18637	8601	39	salary	salary	NN
18637	8601	40	of	of	IN
18637	8601	41	any	any	DT
18637	8601	42	person	person	NN
18637	8601	43	who	who	WP
18637	8601	44	advocates	advocate	VBZ
18637	8601	45	,	,	,
18637	8601	46	or	or	CC
18637	8601	47	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	8601	48	to	to	IN
18637	8601	49	an	an	DT
18637	8601	50	organization	organization	NN
18637	8601	51	which	which	WDT
18637	8601	52	advocates	advocate	VBZ
18637	8601	53	,	,	,
18637	8601	54	the	the	DT
18637	8601	55	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	8601	56	of	of	IN
18637	8601	57	the	the	DT
18637	8601	58	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8601	59	by	by	IN
18637	8601	60	force	force	NN
18637	8601	61	;	;	:
18637	8601	62	or	or	CC
18637	8601	63	any	any	DT
18637	8601	64	person	person	NN
18637	8601	65	who	who	WP
18637	8601	66	strikes	strike	VBZ
18637	8601	67	,	,	,
18637	8601	68	or	or	CC
18637	8601	69	who	who	WP
18637	8601	70	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	8601	71	to	to	IN
18637	8601	72	an	an	DT
18637	8601	73	organization	organization	NN
18637	8601	74	of	of	IN
18637	8601	75	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8601	76	employees	employee	NNS
18637	8601	77	which	which	WDT
18637	8601	78	asserts	assert	VBZ
18637	8601	79	the	the	DT
18637	8601	80	right	right	NN
18637	8601	81	to	to	TO
18637	8601	82	strike	strike	VB
18637	8601	83	against	against	IN
18637	8601	84	the	the	DT
18637	8601	85	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8601	86	.	.	.
18637	8602	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8602	2	291	291	CD
18637	8602	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8602	4	The	the	DT
18637	8602	5	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	8602	6	intention	intention	NN
18637	8602	7	of	of	IN
18637	8602	8	this	this	DT
18637	8602	9	proviso	proviso	NN
18637	8602	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	8602	11	to	to	TO
18637	8602	12	lay	lay	VB
18637	8602	13	down	down	RP
18637	8602	14	a	a	DT
18637	8602	15	rule	rule	NN
18637	8602	16	by	by	IN
18637	8602	17	which	which	WDT
18637	8602	18	the	the	DT
18637	8602	19	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	8602	20	and	and	CC
18637	8602	21	disbursing	disbursing	NN
18637	8602	22	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	8602	23	will	will	MD
18637	8602	24	be	be	VB
18637	8602	25	bound	bind	VBN
18637	8602	26	.	.	.
18637	8603	1	Since	since	IN
18637	8603	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8603	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	8603	4	the	the	DT
18637	8603	5	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	8603	6	power	power	NN
18637	8603	7	to	to	TO
18637	8603	8	lay	lay	VB
18637	8603	9	down	down	RP
18637	8603	10	the	the	DT
18637	8603	11	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	8603	12	of	of	IN
18637	8603	13	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8603	14	and	and	CC
18637	8603	15	employees	employee	NNS
18637	8603	16	of	of	IN
18637	8603	17	the	the	DT
18637	8603	18	United	United	NNP
18637	8603	19	States	States	NNP
18637	8603	20	;	;	:
18637	8603	21	and	and	CC
18637	8603	22	since	since	IN
18637	8603	23	few	few	JJ
18637	8603	24	people	people	NNS
18637	8603	25	would	would	MD
18637	8603	26	contend	contend	VB
18637	8603	27	that	that	IN
18637	8603	28	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8603	29	or	or	CC
18637	8603	30	employees	employee	NNS
18637	8603	31	of	of	IN
18637	8603	32	the	the	DT
18637	8603	33	National	National	NNP
18637	8603	34	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8603	35	have	have	VBP
18637	8603	36	a	a	DT
18637	8603	37	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8603	38	right	right	NN
18637	8603	39	to	to	TO
18637	8603	40	advocate	advocate	VB
18637	8603	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8603	42	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	8603	43	or	or	CC
18637	8603	44	to	to	TO
18637	8603	45	strike	strike	VB
18637	8603	46	against	against	IN
18637	8603	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8603	48	,	,	,
18637	8603	49	the	the	DT
18637	8603	50	above	above	JJ
18637	8603	51	proviso	proviso	NN
18637	8603	52	would	would	MD
18637	8603	53	seem	seem	VB
18637	8603	54	to	to	TO
18637	8603	55	be	be	VB
18637	8603	56	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	8603	57	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8603	58	.	.	.
18637	8604	1	President	President	NNP
18637	8604	2	Truman	Truman	NNP
18637	8604	3	's	's	POS
18637	8604	4	"	"	``
18637	8604	5	Loyalty	loyalty	NN
18637	8604	6	Order"--Executive	order"--executive	JJ
18637	8604	7	Order	order	NN
18637	8604	8	9835	9835	CD
18637	8604	9	-	-	:
18637	8604	10	-of	-of	:
18637	8604	11	March	March	NNP
18637	8604	12	21	21	CD
18637	8604	13	,	,	,
18637	8604	14	1947[292	1947[292	CD
18637	8604	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8604	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	8604	17	an	an	DT
18637	8604	18	outgrowth	outgrowth	NN
18637	8604	19	in	in	IN
18637	8604	20	part	part	NN
18637	8604	21	of	of	IN
18637	8604	22	this	this	DT
18637	8604	23	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8604	24	.	.	.
18637	8605	1	LEGISLATION	legislation	NN
18637	8605	2	INCREASING	increase	VBG
18637	8605	3	DUTIES	duty	NNS
18637	8605	4	OF	of	IN
18637	8605	5	AN	an	DT
18637	8605	6	OFFICER	OFFICER	NNP
18637	8605	7	Finally	finally	RB
18637	8605	8	,	,	,
18637	8605	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8605	10	may	may	MD
18637	8605	11	devolve	devolve	VB
18637	8605	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	8605	13	one	one	CD
18637	8605	14	already	already	RB
18637	8605	15	in	in	IN
18637	8605	16	office	office	NN
18637	8605	17	additional	additional	JJ
18637	8605	18	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8605	19	which	which	WDT
18637	8605	20	are	be	VBP
18637	8605	21	germane	germane	NN
18637	8605	22	to	to	IN
18637	8605	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8605	24	office	office	NN
18637	8605	25	without	without	IN
18637	8605	26	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	8605	27	"	"	``
18637	8605	28	rendering	render	VBG
18637	8605	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8605	30	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8605	31	that	that	IN
18637	8605	32	the	the	DT
18637	8605	33	incumbent	incumbent	NN
18637	8605	34	should	should	MD
18637	8605	35	be	be	VB
18637	8605	36	again	again	RB
18637	8605	37	nominated	nominate	VBN
18637	8605	38	and	and	CC
18637	8605	39	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	8605	40	.	.	.
18637	8605	41	"	"	''
18637	8606	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	8606	2	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8606	3	does	do	VBZ
18637	8606	4	not	not	RB
18637	8606	5	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	8606	6	an	an	DT
18637	8606	7	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	8606	8	by	by	IN
18637	8606	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8606	10	to	to	TO
18637	8606	11	seize	seize	VB
18637	8606	12	the	the	DT
18637	8606	13	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	8606	14	power	power	NN
18637	8606	15	.	.	.
18637	8607	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8607	2	293	293	CD
18637	8607	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8607	4	"	"	``
18637	8607	5	INFERIOR	INFERIOR	NNP
18637	8607	6	OFFICERS	OFFICERS	NNP
18637	8607	7	"	"	''
18637	8607	8	;	;	:
18637	8607	9	"	"	``
18637	8607	10	EMPLOYEES	employees	RB
18637	8607	11	"	"	''
18637	8607	12	Except	except	IN
18637	8607	13	the	the	DT
18637	8607	14	President	President	NNP
18637	8607	15	and	and	CC
18637	8607	16	the	the	DT
18637	8607	17	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	8607	18	President	President	NNP
18637	8607	19	all	all	DT
18637	8607	20	persons	person	NNS
18637	8607	21	in	in	IN
18637	8607	22	the	the	DT
18637	8607	23	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8607	24	service	service	NN
18637	8607	25	of	of	IN
18637	8607	26	the	the	DT
18637	8607	27	National	National	NNP
18637	8607	28	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8607	29	are	be	VBP
18637	8607	30	appointive	appointive	JJ
18637	8607	31	,	,	,
18637	8607	32	and	and	CC
18637	8607	33	fall	fall	VB
18637	8607	34	into	into	IN
18637	8607	35	one	one	CD
18637	8607	36	of	of	IN
18637	8607	37	three	three	CD
18637	8607	38	categories	category	NNS
18637	8607	39	,	,	,
18637	8607	40	those	those	DT
18637	8607	41	who	who	WP
18637	8607	42	are	be	VBP
18637	8607	43	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	8607	44	by	by	IN
18637	8607	45	the	the	DT
18637	8607	46	President	President	NNP
18637	8607	47	,	,	,
18637	8607	48	"	"	''
18637	8607	49	by	by	IN
18637	8607	50	and	and	CC
18637	8607	51	with	with	IN
18637	8607	52	the	the	DT
18637	8607	53	advice	advice	NN
18637	8607	54	and	and	CC
18637	8607	55	consent	consent	NN
18637	8607	56	of	of	IN
18637	8607	57	the	the	DT
18637	8607	58	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8607	59	"	"	''
18637	8607	60	;	;	:
18637	8607	61	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	8607	62	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8607	63	,	,	,
18637	8607	64	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8607	65	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8607	66	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8607	67	has	have	VBZ
18637	8607	68	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8607	69	by	by	IN
18637	8607	70	law	law	NN
18637	8607	71	"	"	''
18637	8607	72	in	in	IN
18637	8607	73	the	the	DT
18637	8607	74	President	President	NNP
18637	8607	75	alone	alone	RB
18637	8607	76	,	,	,
18637	8607	77	in	in	IN
18637	8607	78	the	the	DT
18637	8607	79	courts	court	NNS
18637	8607	80	of	of	IN
18637	8607	81	law	law	NN
18637	8607	82	,	,	,
18637	8607	83	or	or	CC
18637	8607	84	in	in	IN
18637	8607	85	the	the	DT
18637	8607	86	heads	head	NNS
18637	8607	87	of	of	IN
18637	8607	88	departments	department	NNS
18637	8607	89	"	"	''
18637	8607	90	;	;	:
18637	8607	91	and	and	CC
18637	8607	92	employees	employee	NNS
18637	8607	93	,	,	,
18637	8607	94	a	a	DT
18637	8607	95	term	term	NN
18637	8607	96	which	which	WDT
18637	8607	97	is	be	VBZ
18637	8607	98	here	here	RB
18637	8607	99	used	use	VBN
18637	8607	100	in	in	IN
18637	8607	101	a	a	DT
18637	8607	102	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	8607	103	sense	sense	NN
18637	8607	104	.	.	.
18637	8608	1	Ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	8608	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8608	3	denotes	denote	VBZ
18637	8608	4	one	one	NN
18637	8608	5	who	who	WP
18637	8608	6	stands	stand	VBZ
18637	8608	7	in	in	IN
18637	8608	8	a	a	DT
18637	8608	9	contractual	contractual	JJ
18637	8608	10	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	8608	11	to	to	IN
18637	8608	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8608	13	employer	employer	NN
18637	8608	14	,	,	,
18637	8608	15	but	but	CC
18637	8608	16	here	here	RB
18637	8608	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8608	18	signifies	signify	VBZ
18637	8608	19	all	all	DT
18637	8608	20	subordinate	subordinate	JJ
18637	8608	21	officials	official	NNS
18637	8608	22	of	of	IN
18637	8608	23	the	the	DT
18637	8608	24	National	National	NNP
18637	8608	25	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8608	26	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	8608	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8608	28	appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	8608	29	at	at	IN
18637	8608	30	the	the	DT
18637	8608	31	hands	hand	NNS
18637	8608	32	of	of	IN
18637	8608	33	officials	official	NNS
18637	8608	34	who	who	WP
18637	8608	35	are	be	VBP
18637	8608	36	not	not	RB
18637	8608	37	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	8608	38	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	8608	39	by	by	IN
18637	8608	40	the	the	DT
18637	8608	41	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8608	42	as	as	IN
18637	8608	43	capable	capable	JJ
18637	8608	44	of	of	IN
18637	8608	45	being	be	VBG
18637	8608	46	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8608	47	by	by	IN
18637	8608	48	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8608	49	with	with	IN
18637	8608	50	the	the	DT
18637	8608	51	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	8608	52	power	power	NN
18637	8608	53	.	.	.
18637	8609	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8609	2	294	294	CD
18637	8609	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8609	4	Inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	8609	5	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8609	6	are	be	VBP
18637	8609	7	usually	usually	RB
18637	8609	8	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8609	9	intended	intend	VBN
18637	8609	10	to	to	TO
18637	8609	11	be	be	VB
18637	8609	12	subordinate	subordinate	JJ
18637	8609	13	to	to	IN
18637	8609	14	those	those	DT
18637	8609	15	in	in	IN
18637	8609	16	whom	whom	WP
18637	8609	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8609	18	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8609	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	8609	20	vested;[295	vested;[295	ADD
18637	8609	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8609	22	but	but	CC
18637	8609	23	the	the	DT
18637	8609	24	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	8609	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	8609	26	by	by	IN
18637	8609	27	no	no	DT
18637	8609	28	means	means	NN
18637	8609	29	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	8609	30	.	.	.
18637	8610	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8610	2	296	296	CD
18637	8610	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8610	4	STAGES	stages	NN
18637	8610	5	OF	of	IN
18637	8610	6	APPOINTMENT	appointment	NN
18637	8610	7	PROCESS	PROCESS	NNP
18637	8610	8	Nomination	nomination	NN
18637	8610	9	The	the	DT
18637	8610	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8610	11	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	8610	12	to	to	TO
18637	8610	13	distinguish	distinguish	VB
18637	8610	14	three	three	CD
18637	8610	15	stages	stage	NNS
18637	8610	16	in	in	IN
18637	8610	17	appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	8610	18	by	by	IN
18637	8610	19	the	the	DT
18637	8610	20	President	President	NNP
18637	8610	21	with	with	IN
18637	8610	22	the	the	DT
18637	8610	23	advice	advice	NN
18637	8610	24	and	and	CC
18637	8610	25	consent	consent	NN
18637	8610	26	of	of	IN
18637	8610	27	the	the	DT
18637	8610	28	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8610	29	.	.	.
18637	8611	1	The	the	DT
18637	8611	2	first	first	JJ
18637	8611	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8611	4	the	the	DT
18637	8611	5	"	"	``
18637	8611	6	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	8611	7	"	"	''
18637	8611	8	of	of	IN
18637	8611	9	the	the	DT
18637	8611	10	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	8611	11	by	by	IN
18637	8611	12	the	the	DT
18637	8611	13	President	President	NNP
18637	8611	14	alone	alone	RB
18637	8611	15	;	;	:
18637	8611	16	the	the	DT
18637	8611	17	second	second	JJ
18637	8611	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	8611	19	the	the	DT
18637	8611	20	assent	assent	NN
18637	8611	21	of	of	IN
18637	8611	22	the	the	DT
18637	8611	23	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8611	24	to	to	IN
18637	8611	25	the	the	DT
18637	8611	26	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	8611	27	's	's	POS
18637	8611	28	"	"	``
18637	8611	29	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8611	30	"	"	''
18637	8611	31	;	;	,
18637	8611	32	and	and	CC
18637	8611	33	the	the	DT
18637	8611	34	third	third	JJ
18637	8611	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	8611	36	the	the	DT
18637	8611	37	final	final	JJ
18637	8611	38	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8611	39	and	and	CC
18637	8611	40	commissioning	commissioning	NN
18637	8611	41	of	of	IN
18637	8611	42	the	the	DT
18637	8611	43	appointee	appointee	NN
18637	8611	44	,	,	,
18637	8611	45	by	by	IN
18637	8611	46	the	the	DT
18637	8611	47	President	President	NNP
18637	8611	48	.	.	.
18637	8612	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8612	2	297	297	CD
18637	8612	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8612	4	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8612	5	Approval	Approval	NNP
18637	8612	6	The	the	DT
18637	8612	7	fact	fact	NN
18637	8612	8	that	that	IN
18637	8612	9	the	the	DT
18637	8612	10	power	power	NN
18637	8612	11	of	of	IN
18637	8612	12	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	8612	13	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	8612	14	to	to	IN
18637	8612	15	the	the	DT
18637	8612	16	President	President	NNP
18637	8612	17	alone	alone	RB
18637	8612	18	prevents	prevent	VBZ
18637	8612	19	the	the	DT
18637	8612	20	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8612	21	from	from	IN
18637	8612	22	attaching	attach	VBG
18637	8612	23	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	8612	24	to	to	IN
18637	8612	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8612	26	approval	approval	NN
18637	8612	27	of	of	IN
18637	8612	28	an	an	DT
18637	8612	29	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8612	30	,	,	,
18637	8612	31	such	such	JJ
18637	8612	32	as	as	IN
18637	8612	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8612	34	may	may	MD
18637	8612	35	do	do	VB
18637	8612	36	to	to	IN
18637	8612	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8612	38	approval	approval	NN
18637	8612	39	of	of	IN
18637	8612	40	a	a	DT
18637	8612	41	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8612	42	.	.	.
18637	8613	1	In	in	IN
18637	8613	2	the	the	DT
18637	8613	3	words	word	NNS
18637	8613	4	of	of	IN
18637	8613	5	an	an	DT
18637	8613	6	early	early	JJ
18637	8613	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8613	8	of	of	IN
18637	8613	9	the	the	DT
18637	8613	10	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8613	11	General	General	NNP
18637	8613	12	:	:	:
18637	8613	13	"	"	``
18637	8613	14	The	the	DT
18637	8613	15	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8613	16	can	can	MD
18637	8613	17	not	not	RB
18637	8613	18	originate	originate	VB
18637	8613	19	an	an	DT
18637	8613	20	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8613	21	.	.	.
18637	8614	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8614	2	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8614	3	action	action	NN
18637	8614	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	8614	5	confined	confine	VBN
18637	8614	6	to	to	IN
18637	8614	7	the	the	DT
18637	8614	8	simple	simple	JJ
18637	8614	9	affirmation	affirmation	NN
18637	8614	10	or	or	CC
18637	8614	11	rejection	rejection	NN
18637	8614	12	of	of	IN
18637	8614	13	the	the	DT
18637	8614	14	President	President	NNP
18637	8614	15	's	's	POS
18637	8614	16	nominations	nomination	NNS
18637	8614	17	,	,	,
18637	8614	18	and	and	CC
18637	8614	19	such	such	JJ
18637	8614	20	nominations	nomination	NNS
18637	8614	21	fail	fail	VBP
18637	8614	22	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	8614	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8614	24	rejects	reject	VBZ
18637	8614	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8614	26	.	.	.
18637	8615	1	The	the	DT
18637	8615	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8615	3	may	may	MD
18637	8615	4	suggest	suggest	VB
18637	8615	5	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	8615	6	and	and	CC
18637	8615	7	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	8615	8	to	to	IN
18637	8615	9	the	the	DT
18637	8615	10	President	President	NNP
18637	8615	11	,	,	,
18637	8615	12	but	but	CC
18637	8615	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8615	14	can	can	MD
18637	8615	15	not	not	RB
18637	8615	16	vary	vary	VB
18637	8615	17	those	those	DT
18637	8615	18	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	8615	19	by	by	IN
18637	8615	20	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8615	21	,	,	,
18637	8615	22	for	for	IN
18637	8615	23	no	no	DT
18637	8615	24	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8615	25	can	can	MD
18637	8615	26	be	be	VB
18637	8615	27	made	make	VBN
18637	8615	28	except	except	IN
18637	8615	29	on	on	IN
18637	8615	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8615	31	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	8615	32	,	,	,
18637	8615	33	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	8615	34	to	to	IN
18637	8615	35	without	without	IN
18637	8615	36	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	8615	37	or	or	CC
18637	8615	38	alteration	alteration	NN
18637	8615	39	.	.	.
18637	8616	1	"	"	``
18637	8616	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8616	3	298	298	CD
18637	8616	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8616	5	This	this	DT
18637	8616	6	view	view	NN
18637	8616	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	8616	8	borne	bear	VBN
18637	8616	9	out	out	RP
18637	8616	10	by	by	IN
18637	8616	11	early	early	JJ
18637	8616	12	opinion[299	opinion[299	NNS
18637	8616	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8616	14	as	as	RB
18637	8616	15	well	well	RB
18637	8616	16	as	as	IN
18637	8616	17	by	by	IN
18637	8616	18	the	the	DT
18637	8616	19	record	record	NN
18637	8616	20	of	of	IN
18637	8616	21	practice	practice	NN
18637	8616	22	under	under	IN
18637	8616	23	the	the	DT
18637	8616	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8616	25	.	.	.
18637	8617	1	When	when	WRB
18637	8617	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8617	3	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	8617	4	Is	be	VBZ
18637	8617	5	Complete	complete	JJ
18637	8617	6	Early	early	RB
18637	8617	7	in	in	IN
18637	8617	8	January	January	NNP
18637	8617	9	,	,	,
18637	8617	10	1931	1931	CD
18637	8617	11	the	the	DT
18637	8617	12	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8617	13	requested	request	VBD
18637	8617	14	President	President	NNP
18637	8617	15	Hoover	Hoover	NNP
18637	8617	16	to	to	TO
18637	8617	17	return	return	VB
18637	8617	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8617	19	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	8617	20	notifying	notify	VBG
18637	8617	21	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8617	22	that	that	IN
18637	8617	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8617	24	advised	advise	VBD
18637	8617	25	and	and	CC
18637	8617	26	consented	consent	VBD
18637	8617	27	to	to	IN
18637	8617	28	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8617	29	nominations	nomination	NNS
18637	8617	30	to	to	IN
18637	8617	31	the	the	DT
18637	8617	32	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8617	33	Power	Power	NNP
18637	8617	34	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	8617	35	.	.	.
18637	8618	1	In	in	IN
18637	8618	2	support	support	NN
18637	8618	3	of	of	IN
18637	8618	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8618	5	action	action	NN
18637	8618	6	the	the	DT
18637	8618	7	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8618	8	invoked	invoke	VBD
18637	8618	9	a	a	DT
18637	8618	10	long	long	RB
18637	8618	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	8618	12	standing	stand	VBG
18637	8618	13	rule	rule	NN
18637	8618	14	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	8618	15	a	a	DT
18637	8618	16	motion	motion	NN
18637	8618	17	to	to	TO
18637	8618	18	reconsider	reconsider	VB
18637	8618	19	a	a	DT
18637	8618	20	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	8618	21	confirming	confirm	VBG
18637	8618	22	a	a	DT
18637	8618	23	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	8618	24	within	within	IN
18637	8618	25	"	"	``
18637	8618	26	the	the	DT
18637	8618	27	next	next	JJ
18637	8618	28	two	two	CD
18637	8618	29	days	day	NNS
18637	8618	30	of	of	IN
18637	8618	31	actual	actual	JJ
18637	8618	32	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8618	33	session	session	NN
18637	8618	34	of	of	IN
18637	8618	35	the	the	DT
18637	8618	36	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8618	37	"	"	''
18637	8618	38	and	and	CC
18637	8618	39	the	the	DT
18637	8618	40	recall	recall	NN
18637	8618	41	of	of	IN
18637	8618	42	the	the	DT
18637	8618	43	notification	notification	NN
18637	8618	44	to	to	IN
18637	8618	45	the	the	DT
18637	8618	46	President	President	NNP
18637	8618	47	of	of	IN
18637	8618	48	the	the	DT
18637	8618	49	confirmation	confirmation	NN
18637	8618	50	.	.	.
18637	8619	1	The	the	DT
18637	8619	2	nominees	nominee	NNS
18637	8619	3	involved	involve	VBN
18637	8619	4	having	have	VBG
18637	8619	5	meantime	meantime	RB
18637	8619	6	taken	take	VBN
18637	8619	7	the	the	DT
18637	8619	8	oath	oath	NN
18637	8619	9	of	of	IN
18637	8619	10	office	office	NN
18637	8619	11	and	and	CC
18637	8619	12	entered	enter	VBN
18637	8619	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	8619	14	the	the	DT
18637	8619	15	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8619	16	of	of	IN
18637	8619	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8619	18	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8619	19	,	,	,
18637	8619	20	the	the	DT
18637	8619	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8619	22	responded	respond	VBD
18637	8619	23	with	with	IN
18637	8619	24	a	a	DT
18637	8619	25	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	8619	26	,	,	,
18637	8619	27	saying	say	VBG
18637	8619	28	:	:	:
18637	8619	29	"	"	``
18637	8619	30	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8619	31	can	can	MD
18637	8619	32	not	not	RB
18637	8619	33	admit	admit	VB
18637	8619	34	the	the	DT
18637	8619	35	power	power	NN
18637	8619	36	in	in	IN
18637	8619	37	the	the	DT
18637	8619	38	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8619	39	to	to	TO
18637	8619	40	encroach	encroach	VB
18637	8619	41	upon	upon	IN
18637	8619	42	the	the	DT
18637	8619	43	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8619	44	functions	function	NNS
18637	8619	45	by	by	IN
18637	8619	46	removal	removal	NN
18637	8619	47	of	of	IN
18637	8619	48	a	a	DT
18637	8619	49	duly	duly	RB
18637	8619	50	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	8619	51	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8619	52	officer	officer	NN
18637	8619	53	under	under	IN
18637	8619	54	the	the	DT
18637	8619	55	guise	guise	NN
18637	8619	56	of	of	IN
18637	8619	57	reconsideration	reconsideration	NN
18637	8619	58	of	of	IN
18637	8619	59	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8619	60	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	8619	61	.	.	.
18637	8619	62	"	"	''
18637	8620	1	The	the	DT
18637	8620	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8620	3	thereupon	thereupon	RB
18637	8620	4	voted	vote	VBD
18637	8620	5	to	to	TO
18637	8620	6	reconsider	reconsider	VB
18637	8620	7	the	the	DT
18637	8620	8	nominations	nomination	NNS
18637	8620	9	in	in	IN
18637	8620	10	question	question	NN
18637	8620	11	,	,	,
18637	8620	12	again	again	RB
18637	8620	13	approving	approve	VBG
18637	8620	14	two	two	CD
18637	8620	15	of	of	IN
18637	8620	16	the	the	DT
18637	8620	17	nominees	nominee	NNS
18637	8620	18	,	,	,
18637	8620	19	but	but	CC
18637	8620	20	rejecting	reject	VBG
18637	8620	21	the	the	DT
18637	8620	22	third	third	JJ
18637	8620	23	,	,	,
18637	8620	24	against	against	IN
18637	8620	25	whom	whom	WP
18637	8620	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8620	27	instructed	instruct	VBD
18637	8620	28	the	the	DT
18637	8620	29	District	District	NNP
18637	8620	30	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8620	31	of	of	IN
18637	8620	32	the	the	DT
18637	8620	33	District	District	NNP
18637	8620	34	of	of	IN
18637	8620	35	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	8620	36	to	to	TO
18637	8620	37	institute	institute	NNP
18637	8620	38	_	_	NNP
18637	8620	39	quo	quo	NNP
18637	8620	40	warranto	warranto	NNP
18637	8620	41	_	_	NNP
18637	8620	42	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	8620	43	in	in	IN
18637	8620	44	the	the	DT
18637	8620	45	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8620	46	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8620	47	of	of	IN
18637	8620	48	the	the	DT
18637	8620	49	District	District	NNP
18637	8620	50	.	.	.
18637	8621	1	In	in	IN
18637	8621	2	United	United	NNP
18637	8621	3	States	States	NNP
18637	8621	4	_	_	NNP
18637	8621	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	8621	6	_	_	NNP
18637	8621	7	Smith[300	Smith[300	NNP
18637	8621	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8621	9	the	the	DT
18637	8621	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8621	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8621	12	overruled	overrule	VBD
18637	8621	13	the	the	DT
18637	8621	14	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	8621	15	on	on	IN
18637	8621	16	the	the	DT
18637	8621	17	ground	ground	NN
18637	8621	18	that	that	IN
18637	8621	19	the	the	DT
18637	8621	20	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8621	21	had	have	VBD
18637	8621	22	never	never	RB
18637	8621	23	before	before	RB
18637	8621	24	attempted	attempt	VBN
18637	8621	25	to	to	TO
18637	8621	26	apply	apply	VB
18637	8621	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8621	28	rule	rule	NN
18637	8621	29	in	in	IN
18637	8621	30	the	the	DT
18637	8621	31	case	case	NN
18637	8621	32	of	of	IN
18637	8621	33	an	an	DT
18637	8621	34	appointee	appointee	NN
18637	8621	35	who	who	WP
18637	8621	36	had	have	VBD
18637	8621	37	already	already	RB
18637	8621	38	been	be	VBN
18637	8621	39	installed	instal	VBN
18637	8621	40	in	in	IN
18637	8621	41	office	office	NN
18637	8621	42	on	on	IN
18637	8621	43	the	the	DT
18637	8621	44	faith	faith	NN
18637	8621	45	of	of	IN
18637	8621	46	the	the	DT
18637	8621	47	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8621	48	's	's	POS
18637	8621	49	initial	initial	JJ
18637	8621	50	consent	consent	NN
18637	8621	51	and	and	CC
18637	8621	52	notification	notification	NN
18637	8621	53	to	to	IN
18637	8621	54	the	the	DT
18637	8621	55	President	President	NNP
18637	8621	56	.	.	.
18637	8622	1	In	in	IN
18637	8622	2	1939	1939	CD
18637	8622	3	the	the	DT
18637	8622	4	late	late	JJ
18637	8622	5	President	President	NNP
18637	8622	6	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8622	7	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	8622	8	a	a	DT
18637	8622	9	similar	similar	JJ
18637	8622	10	demand	demand	NN
18637	8622	11	by	by	IN
18637	8622	12	the	the	DT
18637	8622	13	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8622	14	,	,	,
18637	8622	15	action	action	NN
18637	8622	16	which	which	WDT
18637	8622	17	was	be	VBD
18637	8622	18	not	not	RB
18637	8622	19	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	8622	20	.	.	.
18637	8623	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8623	2	301	301	CD
18637	8623	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8623	4	Section	section	NN
18637	8623	5	3	3	CD
18637	8623	6	.	.	.
18637	8624	1	The	the	DT
18637	8624	2	President	President	NNP
18637	8624	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8624	4	*	*	NFP
18637	8624	5	*	*	NFP
18637	8624	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	8624	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	8624	8	all	all	PDT
18637	8624	9	the	the	DT
18637	8624	10	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	8624	11	of	of	IN
18637	8624	12	the	the	DT
18637	8624	13	United	United	NNP
18637	8624	14	States	States	NNP
18637	8624	15	.	.	.
18637	8625	1	Commissioning	commission	VBG
18637	8625	2	the	the	DT
18637	8625	3	Officer	Officer	NNP
18637	8625	4	This	This	NNP
18637	8625	5	,	,	,
18637	8625	6	as	as	IN
18637	8625	7	applied	apply	VBN
18637	8625	8	in	in	IN
18637	8625	9	practice	practice	NN
18637	8625	10	,	,	,
18637	8625	11	does	do	VBZ
18637	8625	12	not	not	RB
18637	8625	13	mean	mean	VB
18637	8625	14	that	that	IN
18637	8625	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8625	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	8625	17	under	under	IN
18637	8625	18	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8625	19	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8625	20	to	to	TO
18637	8625	21	commission	commission	VB
18637	8625	22	those	those	DT
18637	8625	23	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8625	24	appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	8625	25	have	have	VBP
18637	8625	26	reached	reach	VBN
18637	8625	27	that	that	DT
18637	8625	28	stage	stage	NN
18637	8625	29	,	,	,
18637	8625	30	but	but	CC
18637	8625	31	merely	merely	RB
18637	8625	32	that	that	IN
18637	8625	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8625	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	8625	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8625	36	and	and	CC
18637	8625	37	no	no	DT
18637	8625	38	one	one	NN
18637	8625	39	else	else	RB
18637	8625	40	who	who	WP
18637	8625	41	has	have	VBZ
18637	8625	42	the	the	DT
18637	8625	43	power	power	NN
18637	8625	44	to	to	TO
18637	8625	45	commission	commission	VB
18637	8625	46	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8625	47	,	,	,
18637	8625	48	which	which	WDT
18637	8625	49	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8625	50	may	may	MD
18637	8625	51	do	do	VB
18637	8625	52	at	at	IN
18637	8625	53	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8625	54	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	8625	55	.	.	.
18637	8626	1	The	the	DT
18637	8626	2	sealing	sealing	NN
18637	8626	3	and	and	CC
18637	8626	4	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	8626	5	of	of	IN
18637	8626	6	the	the	DT
18637	8626	7	commission	commission	NN
18637	8626	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	8626	9	,	,	,
18637	8626	10	on	on	IN
18637	8626	11	the	the	DT
18637	8626	12	other	other	JJ
18637	8626	13	hand	hand	NN
18637	8626	14	,	,	,
18637	8626	15	by	by	IN
18637	8626	16	the	the	DT
18637	8626	17	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	8626	18	of	of	IN
18637	8626	19	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	8626	20	_	_	NNP
18637	8626	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	8626	22	_	_	NNP
18637	8626	23	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8626	24	,	,	,
18637	8626	25	in	in	IN
18637	8626	26	the	the	DT
18637	8626	27	case	case	NN
18637	8626	28	both	both	DT
18637	8626	29	of	of	IN
18637	8626	30	appointees	appointee	NNS
18637	8626	31	by	by	IN
18637	8626	32	the	the	DT
18637	8626	33	President	President	NNP
18637	8626	34	and	and	CC
18637	8626	35	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8626	36	and	and	CC
18637	8626	37	by	by	IN
18637	8626	38	the	the	DT
18637	8626	39	President	President	NNP
18637	8626	40	alone	alone	RB
18637	8626	41	,	,	,
18637	8626	42	a	a	DT
18637	8626	43	purely	purely	RB
18637	8626	44	ministerial	ministerial	JJ
18637	8626	45	act	act	NN
18637	8626	46	which	which	WDT
18637	8626	47	has	have	VBZ
18637	8626	48	been	be	VBN
18637	8626	49	lodged	lodge	VBN
18637	8626	50	by	by	IN
18637	8626	51	statute	statute	NN
18637	8626	52	with	with	IN
18637	8626	53	the	the	DT
18637	8626	54	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8626	55	of	of	IN
18637	8626	56	State	State	NNP
18637	8626	57	and	and	CC
18637	8626	58	the	the	DT
18637	8626	59	performance	performance	NN
18637	8626	60	of	of	IN
18637	8626	61	which	which	WDT
18637	8626	62	may	may	MD
18637	8626	63	be	be	VB
18637	8626	64	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	8626	65	by	by	IN
18637	8626	66	mandamus	mandamus	NNP
18637	8626	67	unless	unless	IN
18637	8626	68	the	the	DT
18637	8626	69	appointee	appointee	NN
18637	8626	70	has	have	VBZ
18637	8626	71	been	be	VBN
18637	8626	72	in	in	IN
18637	8626	73	the	the	DT
18637	8626	74	meantime	meantime	NN
18637	8626	75	validly	validly	RB
18637	8626	76	removed	remove	VBN
18637	8626	77	.	.	.
18637	8627	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8627	2	302	302	CD
18637	8627	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8627	4	By	by	IN
18637	8627	5	an	an	DT
18637	8627	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8627	7	of	of	IN
18637	8627	8	the	the	DT
18637	8627	9	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8627	10	General	General	NNP
18637	8627	11	many	many	JJ
18637	8627	12	years	year	NNS
18637	8627	13	later	later	RB
18637	8627	14	,	,	,
18637	8627	15	however	however	RB
18637	8627	16	,	,	,
18637	8627	17	the	the	DT
18637	8627	18	President	President	NNP
18637	8627	19	,	,	,
18637	8627	20	even	even	RB
18637	8627	21	after	after	IN
18637	8627	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8627	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	8627	24	signed	sign	VBN
18637	8627	25	a	a	DT
18637	8627	26	commission	commission	NN
18637	8627	27	,	,	,
18637	8627	28	still	still	RB
18637	8627	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	8627	30	a	a	DT
18637	8627	31	_	_	NNP
18637	8627	32	locus	locus	NN
18637	8627	33	poenitentiae	poenitentiae	NNS
18637	8627	34	_	_	NNP
18637	8627	35	and	and	CC
18637	8627	36	may	may	MD
18637	8627	37	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	8627	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8627	39	;	;	:
18637	8627	40	nor	nor	CC
18637	8627	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	8627	42	the	the	DT
18637	8627	43	appointee	appointee	NN
18637	8627	44	in	in	IN
18637	8627	45	office	office	NN
18637	8627	46	till	till	IN
18637	8627	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8627	48	has	have	VBZ
18637	8627	49	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8627	50	commission	commission	NN
18637	8627	51	.	.	.
18637	8628	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8628	2	303	303	CD
18637	8628	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8628	4	This	this	DT
18637	8628	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	8628	6	probably	probably	RB
18637	8628	7	the	the	DT
18637	8628	8	correct	correct	JJ
18637	8628	9	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	8628	10	.	.	.
18637	8629	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8629	2	304	304	CD
18637	8629	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8629	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	8629	5	3	3	CD
18637	8629	6	.	.	.
18637	8630	1	The	the	DT
18637	8630	2	President	President	NNP
18637	8630	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	8630	4	have	have	VB
18637	8630	5	Power	power	NN
18637	8630	6	to	to	TO
18637	8630	7	fill	fill	VB
18637	8630	8	up	up	RP
18637	8630	9	all	all	DT
18637	8630	10	Vacancies	Vacancies	NNPS
18637	8630	11	that	that	WDT
18637	8630	12	may	may	MD
18637	8630	13	happen	happen	VB
18637	8630	14	during	during	IN
18637	8630	15	the	the	DT
18637	8630	16	Recess	Recess	NNP
18637	8630	17	of	of	IN
18637	8630	18	the	the	DT
18637	8630	19	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8630	20	,	,	,
18637	8630	21	by	by	IN
18637	8630	22	granting	grant	VBG
18637	8630	23	Commissions	Commissions	NNPS
18637	8630	24	which	which	WDT
18637	8630	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	8630	26	expire	expire	VB
18637	8630	27	at	at	IN
18637	8630	28	the	the	DT
18637	8630	29	End	end	NN
18637	8630	30	of	of	IN
18637	8630	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8630	32	next	next	JJ
18637	8630	33	Session	session	NN
18637	8630	34	.	.	.
18637	8631	1	RECESS	recess	NN
18637	8631	2	APPOINTMENTS	appointment	NNS
18637	8631	3	Setting	set	VBG
18637	8631	4	out	out	RP
18637	8631	5	from	from	IN
18637	8631	6	the	the	DT
18637	8631	7	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	8631	8	that	that	IN
18637	8631	9	the	the	DT
18637	8631	10	very	very	JJ
18637	8631	11	nature	nature	NN
18637	8631	12	of	of	IN
18637	8631	13	the	the	DT
18637	8631	14	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8631	15	power	power	NN
18637	8631	16	requires	require	VBZ
18637	8631	17	that	that	IN
18637	8631	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8631	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	8631	20	always	always	RB
18637	8631	21	be	be	VB
18637	8631	22	"	"	``
18637	8631	23	in	in	IN
18637	8631	24	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	8631	25	for	for	IN
18637	8631	26	action	action	NN
18637	8631	27	,	,	,
18637	8631	28	"	"	``
18637	8631	29	Attorneys	Attorneys	NNP
18637	8631	30	General	General	NNP
18637	8631	31	early	early	RB
18637	8631	32	came	come	VBD
18637	8631	33	to	to	TO
18637	8631	34	interpret	interpret	VB
18637	8631	35	"	"	``
18637	8631	36	happen	happen	VB
18637	8631	37	"	"	''
18637	8631	38	to	to	TO
18637	8631	39	mean	mean	VB
18637	8631	40	"	"	``
18637	8631	41	happen	happen	VB
18637	8631	42	to	to	TO
18637	8631	43	exist	exist	VB
18637	8631	44	,	,	,
18637	8631	45	"	"	''
18637	8631	46	and	and	CC
18637	8631	47	long	long	JJ
18637	8631	48	continued	continue	VBN
18637	8631	49	practice	practice	NN
18637	8631	50	securely	securely	RB
18637	8631	51	establishes	establish	VBZ
18637	8631	52	this	this	DT
18637	8631	53	construction	construction	NN
18637	8631	54	.	.	.
18637	8632	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8632	2	results	result	VBZ
18637	8632	3	that	that	IN
18637	8632	4	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	8632	5	a	a	DT
18637	8632	6	vacancy	vacancy	NN
18637	8632	7	may	may	MD
18637	8632	8	have	have	VB
18637	8632	9	occurred	occur	VBN
18637	8632	10	in	in	IN
18637	8632	11	the	the	DT
18637	8632	12	first	first	JJ
18637	8632	13	instance	instance	NN
18637	8632	14	,	,	,
18637	8632	15	or	or	CC
18637	8632	16	for	for	IN
18637	8632	17	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	8632	18	reason	reason	NN
18637	8632	19	,	,	,
18637	8632	20	if	if	IN
18637	8632	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8632	22	still	still	RB
18637	8632	23	continues	continue	VBZ
18637	8632	24	after	after	IN
18637	8632	25	the	the	DT
18637	8632	26	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8632	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	8632	28	ceased	cease	VBN
18637	8632	29	to	to	TO
18637	8632	30	sit	sit	VB
18637	8632	31	and	and	CC
18637	8632	32	so	so	RB
18637	8632	33	can	can	MD
18637	8632	34	not	not	RB
18637	8632	35	be	be	VB
18637	8632	36	consulted	consult	VBN
18637	8632	37	,	,	,
18637	8632	38	the	the	DT
18637	8632	39	President	President	NNP
18637	8632	40	may	may	MD
18637	8632	41	fill	fill	VB
18637	8632	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8632	43	in	in	IN
18637	8632	44	the	the	DT
18637	8632	45	way	way	NN
18637	8632	46	described	describe	VBN
18637	8632	47	.	.	.
18637	8633	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8633	2	305	305	CD
18637	8633	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8633	4	But	but	CC
18637	8633	5	a	a	DT
18637	8633	6	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8633	7	"	"	``
18637	8633	8	recess	recess	NN
18637	8633	9	"	"	``
18637	8633	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	8633	11	not	not	RB
18637	8633	12	include	include	VB
18637	8633	13	holiday	holiday	NN
18637	8633	14	or	or	CC
18637	8633	15	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	8633	16	adjournments,[306	adjournments,[306	NN
18637	8633	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8633	18	while	while	IN
18637	8633	19	by	by	IN
18637	8633	20	an	an	DT
18637	8633	21	act	act	NN
18637	8633	22	of	of	IN
18637	8633	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8633	24	,	,	,
18637	8633	25	if	if	IN
18637	8633	26	the	the	DT
18637	8633	27	vacancy	vacancy	NN
18637	8633	28	existed	exist	VBD
18637	8633	29	when	when	WRB
18637	8633	30	the	the	DT
18637	8633	31	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8633	32	was	be	VBD
18637	8633	33	in	in	IN
18637	8633	34	session	session	NN
18637	8633	35	,	,	,
18637	8633	36	the	the	DT
18637	8633	37	_	_	NNP
18637	8633	38	ad	ad	NN
18637	8633	39	interim	interim	NN
18637	8633	40	_	_	NNP
18637	8633	41	appointee	appointee	NN
18637	8633	42	may	may	MD
18637	8633	43	receive	receive	VB
18637	8633	44	no	no	DT
18637	8633	45	salary	salary	NN
18637	8633	46	until	until	IN
18637	8633	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8633	48	has	have	VBZ
18637	8633	49	been	be	VBN
18637	8633	50	confirmed	confirm	VBN
18637	8633	51	by	by	IN
18637	8633	52	the	the	DT
18637	8633	53	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8633	54	.	.	.
18637	8634	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8634	2	307	307	CD
18637	8634	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8634	4	_	_	NNP
18637	8634	5	AD	AD	NNP
18637	8634	6	INTERIM	INTERIM	NNP
18637	8634	7	_	_	NNP
18637	8634	8	DESIGNATIONS	designation	NNS
18637	8634	9	To	to	TO
18637	8634	10	be	be	VB
18637	8634	11	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	8634	12	from	from	IN
18637	8634	13	the	the	DT
18637	8634	14	power	power	NN
18637	8634	15	to	to	TO
18637	8634	16	make	make	VB
18637	8634	17	recess	recess	NN
18637	8634	18	appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	8634	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	8634	20	the	the	DT
18637	8634	21	power	power	NN
18637	8634	22	of	of	IN
18637	8634	23	the	the	DT
18637	8634	24	President	President	NNP
18637	8634	25	to	to	TO
18637	8634	26	make	make	VB
18637	8634	27	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	8634	28	or	or	CC
18637	8634	29	_	_	NNP
18637	8634	30	ad	ad	NN
18637	8634	31	interim	interim	NN
18637	8634	32	_	_	NNP
18637	8634	33	designations	designation	NNS
18637	8634	34	of	of	IN
18637	8634	35	officials	official	NNS
18637	8634	36	to	to	TO
18637	8634	37	perform	perform	VB
18637	8634	38	the	the	DT
18637	8634	39	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8634	40	of	of	IN
18637	8634	41	other	other	JJ
18637	8634	42	absent	absent	JJ
18637	8634	43	officials	official	NNS
18637	8634	44	.	.	.
18637	8635	1	Usually	usually	RB
18637	8635	2	such	such	PDT
18637	8635	3	a	a	DT
18637	8635	4	situation	situation	NN
18637	8635	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	8635	6	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8635	7	for	for	IN
18637	8635	8	in	in	IN
18637	8635	9	advance	advance	NN
18637	8635	10	by	by	IN
18637	8635	11	a	a	DT
18637	8635	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	8635	13	which	which	WDT
18637	8635	14	designates	designate	VBZ
18637	8635	15	the	the	DT
18637	8635	16	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	8635	17	officer	officer	NN
18637	8635	18	who	who	WP
18637	8635	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	8635	20	to	to	TO
18637	8635	21	act	act	VB
18637	8635	22	in	in	IN
18637	8635	23	place	place	NN
18637	8635	24	of	of	IN
18637	8635	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8635	26	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	8635	27	superior	superior	NN
18637	8635	28	.	.	.
18637	8636	1	But	but	CC
18637	8636	2	in	in	IN
18637	8636	3	the	the	DT
18637	8636	4	lack	lack	NN
18637	8636	5	of	of	IN
18637	8636	6	such	such	JJ
18637	8636	7	provision	provision	NN
18637	8636	8	both	both	CC
18637	8636	9	theory	theory	NN
18637	8636	10	and	and	CC
18637	8636	11	practice	practice	NN
18637	8636	12	concede	concede	VBP
18637	8636	13	the	the	DT
18637	8636	14	President	President	NNP
18637	8636	15	the	the	DT
18637	8636	16	power	power	NN
18637	8636	17	to	to	TO
18637	8636	18	make	make	VB
18637	8636	19	the	the	DT
18637	8636	20	designation	designation	NN
18637	8636	21	.	.	.
18637	8637	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8637	2	308	308	CD
18637	8637	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8637	4	THE	the	DT
18637	8637	5	REMOVAL	REMOVAL	NNP
18637	8637	6	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	8637	7	;	;	:
18637	8637	8	THE	the	DT
18637	8637	9	MYERS	myer	NNS
18637	8637	10	CASE	case	NN
18637	8637	11	Save	save	VB
18637	8637	12	for	for	IN
18637	8637	13	the	the	DT
18637	8637	14	provision	provision	NN
18637	8637	15	which	which	WDT
18637	8637	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8637	17	makes	make	VBZ
18637	8637	18	for	for	IN
18637	8637	19	a	a	DT
18637	8637	20	power	power	NN
18637	8637	21	of	of	IN
18637	8637	22	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	8637	23	of	of	IN
18637	8637	24	"	"	``
18637	8637	25	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8637	26	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8637	27	of	of	IN
18637	8637	28	the	the	DT
18637	8637	29	United	United	NNP
18637	8637	30	States	States	NNP
18637	8637	31	,	,	,
18637	8637	32	"	"	''
18637	8637	33	the	the	DT
18637	8637	34	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8637	35	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	8637	36	no	no	DT
18637	8637	37	reference	reference	NN
18637	8637	38	to	to	IN
18637	8637	39	a	a	DT
18637	8637	40	power	power	NN
18637	8637	41	to	to	TO
18637	8637	42	remove	remove	VB
18637	8637	43	from	from	IN
18637	8637	44	office	office	NN
18637	8637	45	;	;	:
18637	8637	46	and	and	CC
18637	8637	47	until	until	IN
18637	8637	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8637	49	decision	decision	NN
18637	8637	50	in	in	IN
18637	8637	51	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	8637	52	_	_	NNP
18637	8637	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	8637	54	_	_	NNP
18637	8637	55	United	United	NNP
18637	8637	56	States,[309	States,[309	NNP
18637	8637	57	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8637	58	October	October	NNP
18637	8637	59	25	25	CD
18637	8637	60	,	,	,
18637	8637	61	1926	1926	CD
18637	8637	62	the	the	DT
18637	8637	63	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8637	64	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8637	65	had	have	VBD
18637	8637	66	contrived	contrive	VBN
18637	8637	67	to	to	TO
18637	8637	68	side	side	NN
18637	8637	69	-	-	HYPH
18637	8637	70	step	step	NN
18637	8637	71	every	every	DT
18637	8637	72	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	8637	73	for	for	IN
18637	8637	74	a	a	DT
18637	8637	75	decisive	decisive	JJ
18637	8637	76	pronouncement	pronouncement	NN
18637	8637	77	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	8637	78	the	the	DT
18637	8637	79	removal	removal	NN
18637	8637	80	power	power	NN
18637	8637	81	,	,	,
18637	8637	82	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8637	83	extent	extent	NN
18637	8637	84	,	,	,
18637	8637	85	and	and	CC
18637	8637	86	location	location	NN
18637	8637	87	.	.	.
18637	8638	1	The	the	DT
18637	8638	2	point	point	NN
18637	8638	3	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	8638	4	at	at	IN
18637	8638	5	issue	issue	NN
18637	8638	6	in	in	IN
18637	8638	7	the	the	DT
18637	8638	8	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	8638	9	case	case	NN
18637	8638	10	was	be	VBD
18637	8638	11	the	the	DT
18637	8638	12	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
18637	8638	13	of	of	IN
18637	8638	14	an	an	DT
18637	8638	15	order	order	NN
18637	8638	16	of	of	IN
18637	8638	17	the	the	DT
18637	8638	18	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
18637	8638	19	General	General	NNP
18637	8638	20	,	,	,
18637	8638	21	acting	act	VBG
18637	8638	22	by	by	IN
18637	8638	23	direction	direction	NN
18637	8638	24	of	of	IN
18637	8638	25	the	the	DT
18637	8638	26	President	President	NNP
18637	8638	27	,	,	,
18637	8638	28	to	to	TO
18637	8638	29	remove	remove	VB
18637	8638	30	from	from	IN
18637	8638	31	office	office	NN
18637	8638	32	a	a	DT
18637	8638	33	first	first	JJ
18637	8638	34	class	class	NN
18637	8638	35	postmaster	postmaster	NN
18637	8638	36	,	,	,
18637	8638	37	in	in	IN
18637	8638	38	face	face	NN
18637	8638	39	of	of	IN
18637	8638	40	the	the	DT
18637	8638	41	following	follow	VBG
18637	8638	42	provision	provision	NN
18637	8638	43	of	of	IN
18637	8638	44	an	an	DT
18637	8638	45	act	act	NN
18637	8638	46	of	of	IN
18637	8638	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8638	48	passed	pass	VBD
18637	8638	49	in	in	IN
18637	8638	50	1876	1876	CD
18637	8638	51	:	:	:
18637	8638	52	"	"	``
18637	8638	53	Postmasters	postmaster	NNS
18637	8638	54	of	of	IN
18637	8638	55	the	the	DT
18637	8638	56	first	first	JJ
18637	8638	57	,	,	,
18637	8638	58	second	second	JJ
18637	8638	59	,	,	,
18637	8638	60	and	and	CC
18637	8638	61	third	third	JJ
18637	8638	62	classes	class	NNS
18637	8638	63	shall	shall	MD
18637	8638	64	be	be	VB
18637	8638	65	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	8638	66	and	and	CC
18637	8638	67	may	may	MD
18637	8638	68	be	be	VB
18637	8638	69	removed	remove	VBN
18637	8638	70	by	by	IN
18637	8638	71	the	the	DT
18637	8638	72	President	President	NNP
18637	8638	73	by	by	IN
18637	8638	74	and	and	CC
18637	8638	75	with	with	IN
18637	8638	76	the	the	DT
18637	8638	77	advice	advice	NN
18637	8638	78	and	and	CC
18637	8638	79	consent	consent	NN
18637	8638	80	of	of	IN
18637	8638	81	the	the	DT
18637	8638	82	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8638	83	,	,	,
18637	8638	84	and	and	CC
18637	8638	85	shall	shall	MD
18637	8638	86	hold	hold	VB
18637	8638	87	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8638	88	offices	office	NNS
18637	8638	89	for	for	IN
18637	8638	90	four	four	CD
18637	8638	91	years	year	NNS
18637	8638	92	unless	unless	IN
18637	8638	93	sooner	soon	RBR
18637	8638	94	removed	remove	VBN
18637	8638	95	or	or	CC
18637	8638	96	suspended	suspend	VBN
18637	8638	97	according	accord	VBG
18637	8638	98	to	to	IN
18637	8638	99	law	law	NN
18637	8638	100	.	.	.
18637	8639	1	"	"	``
18637	8639	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8639	3	310	310	CD
18637	8639	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8639	5	A	a	DT
18637	8639	6	divided	divide	VBN
18637	8639	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8639	8	,	,	,
18637	8639	9	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8639	10	through	through	IN
18637	8639	11	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8639	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8639	13	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	8639	14	,	,	,
18637	8639	15	held	hold	VBD
18637	8639	16	the	the	DT
18637	8639	17	order	order	NN
18637	8639	18	of	of	IN
18637	8639	19	removal	removal	NN
18637	8639	20	valid	valid	JJ
18637	8639	21	,	,	,
18637	8639	22	and	and	CC
18637	8639	23	the	the	DT
18637	8639	24	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	8639	25	provision	provision	NN
18637	8639	26	just	just	RB
18637	8639	27	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	8639	28	void	void	RB
18637	8639	29	.	.	.
18637	8640	1	The	the	DT
18637	8640	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8640	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8640	4	's	's	POS
18637	8640	5	main	main	JJ
18637	8640	6	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	8640	7	was	be	VBD
18637	8640	8	on	on	IN
18637	8640	9	the	the	DT
18637	8640	10	so	so	RB
18637	8640	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	8640	12	called	call	VBN
18637	8640	13	"	"	``
18637	8640	14	decision	decision	NN
18637	8640	15	of	of	IN
18637	8640	16	1789	1789	CD
18637	8640	17	,	,	,
18637	8640	18	"	"	''
18637	8640	19	the	the	DT
18637	8640	20	reference	reference	NN
18637	8640	21	being	be	VBG
18637	8640	22	to	to	IN
18637	8640	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8640	24	's	's	POS
18637	8640	25	course	course	NN
18637	8640	26	that	that	DT
18637	8640	27	year	year	NN
18637	8640	28	in	in	IN
18637	8640	29	inserting	inserting	NN
18637	8640	30	in	in	IN
18637	8640	31	the	the	DT
18637	8640	32	act	act	NN
18637	8640	33	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	8640	34	the	the	DT
18637	8640	35	Department	Department	NNP
18637	8640	36	of	of	IN
18637	8640	37	State	State	NNP
18637	8640	38	a	a	DT
18637	8640	39	proviso	proviso	NN
18637	8640	40	which	which	WDT
18637	8640	41	was	be	VBD
18637	8640	42	meant	mean	VBN
18637	8640	43	to	to	TO
18637	8640	44	imply	imply	VB
18637	8640	45	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8640	46	that	that	IN
18637	8640	47	the	the	DT
18637	8640	48	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8640	49	would	would	MD
18637	8640	50	be	be	VB
18637	8640	51	removable	removable	JJ
18637	8640	52	by	by	IN
18637	8640	53	the	the	DT
18637	8640	54	President	President	NNP
18637	8640	55	at	at	IN
18637	8640	56	will	will	NN
18637	8640	57	.	.	.
18637	8641	1	The	the	DT
18637	8641	2	proviso	proviso	NN
18637	8641	3	was	be	VBD
18637	8641	4	especially	especially	RB
18637	8641	5	urged	urge	VBN
18637	8641	6	by	by	IN
18637	8641	7	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8641	8	,	,	,
18637	8641	9	who	who	WP
18637	8641	10	invoked	invoke	VBD
18637	8641	11	in	in	IN
18637	8641	12	support	support	NN
18637	8641	13	of	of	IN
18637	8641	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8641	15	the	the	DT
18637	8641	16	opening	open	VBG
18637	8641	17	words	word	NNS
18637	8641	18	of	of	IN
18637	8641	19	article	article	NN
18637	8641	20	II	ii	CD
18637	8641	21	and	and	CC
18637	8641	22	the	the	DT
18637	8641	23	President	President	NNP
18637	8641	24	's	's	POS
18637	8641	25	duty	duty	NN
18637	8641	26	to	to	TO
18637	8641	27	"	"	``
18637	8641	28	take	take	VB
18637	8641	29	care	care	NN
18637	8641	30	that	that	IN
18637	8641	31	the	the	DT
18637	8641	32	laws	law	NNS
18637	8641	33	be	be	VB
18637	8641	34	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8641	35	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8641	36	.	.	.
18637	8641	37	"	"	''
18637	8642	1	Succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	8642	2	passages	passage	NNS
18637	8642	3	of	of	IN
18637	8642	4	the	the	DT
18637	8642	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8642	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8642	7	's	's	POS
18637	8642	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8642	9	erect	erect	NN
18637	8642	10	on	on	IN
18637	8642	11	this	this	DT
18637	8642	12	basis	basis	NN
18637	8642	13	a	a	DT
18637	8642	14	highly	highly	RB
18637	8642	15	selective	selective	JJ
18637	8642	16	account	account	NN
18637	8642	17	of	of	IN
18637	8642	18	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	8642	19	and	and	CC
18637	8642	20	practice	practice	NN
18637	8642	21	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	8642	22	the	the	DT
18637	8642	23	removal	removal	NN
18637	8642	24	power	power	NN
18637	8642	25	down	down	IN
18637	8642	26	to	to	IN
18637	8642	27	the	the	DT
18637	8642	28	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	8642	29	War	War	NNP
18637	8642	30	which	which	WDT
18637	8642	31	was	be	VBD
18637	8642	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	8642	33	to	to	TO
18637	8642	34	yield	yield	VB
18637	8642	35	the	the	DT
18637	8642	36	following	following	JJ
18637	8642	37	results	result	NNS
18637	8642	38	:	:	:
18637	8642	39	"	"	``
18637	8642	40	That	that	DT
18637	8642	41	article	article	NN
18637	8642	42	II	II	NNP
18637	8642	43	grants	grant	NNS
18637	8642	44	to	to	IN
18637	8642	45	the	the	DT
18637	8642	46	President	President	NNP
18637	8642	47	the	the	DT
18637	8642	48	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8642	49	power	power	NN
18637	8642	50	of	of	IN
18637	8642	51	the	the	DT
18637	8642	52	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8642	53	,	,	,
18637	8642	54	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	8642	55	,	,	,
18637	8642	56	the	the	DT
18637	8642	57	general	general	JJ
18637	8642	58	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	8642	59	control	control	NN
18637	8642	60	of	of	IN
18637	8642	61	those	those	DT
18637	8642	62	executing	execute	VBG
18637	8642	63	the	the	DT
18637	8642	64	laws	law	NNS
18637	8642	65	,	,	,
18637	8642	66	including	include	VBG
18637	8642	67	the	the	DT
18637	8642	68	power	power	NN
18637	8642	69	of	of	IN
18637	8642	70	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8642	71	and	and	CC
18637	8642	72	removal	removal	NN
18637	8642	73	of	of	IN
18637	8642	74	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8642	75	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8642	76	--	--	:
18637	8642	77	a	a	DT
18637	8642	78	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	8642	79	confirmed	confirm	VBN
18637	8642	80	by	by	IN
18637	8642	81	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8642	82	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8642	83	to	to	TO
18637	8642	84	take	take	VB
18637	8642	85	care	care	NN
18637	8642	86	that	that	IN
18637	8642	87	the	the	DT
18637	8642	88	laws	law	NNS
18637	8642	89	be	be	VB
18637	8642	90	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8642	91	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8642	92	;	;	:
18637	8642	93	that	that	DT
18637	8642	94	article	article	NN
18637	8642	95	II	II	NNP
18637	8642	96	excludes	exclude	VBZ
18637	8642	97	the	the	DT
18637	8642	98	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	8642	99	of	of	IN
18637	8642	100	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8642	101	power	power	NN
18637	8642	102	by	by	IN
18637	8642	103	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8642	104	to	to	TO
18637	8642	105	provide	provide	VB
18637	8642	106	for	for	IN
18637	8642	107	appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	8642	108	and	and	CC
18637	8642	109	removals	removal	NNS
18637	8642	110	,	,	,
18637	8642	111	except	except	IN
18637	8642	112	only	only	RB
18637	8642	113	as	as	IN
18637	8642	114	granted	grant	VBN
18637	8642	115	therein	therein	RB
18637	8642	116	to	to	IN
18637	8642	117	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8642	118	in	in	IN
18637	8642	119	the	the	DT
18637	8642	120	matter	matter	NN
18637	8642	121	of	of	IN
18637	8642	122	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	8642	123	offices	office	NNS
18637	8642	124	;	;	:
18637	8642	125	that	that	IN
18637	8642	126	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8642	127	is	be	VBZ
18637	8642	128	only	only	RB
18637	8642	129	given	give	VBN
18637	8642	130	power	power	NN
18637	8642	131	to	to	TO
18637	8642	132	provide	provide	VB
18637	8642	133	for	for	IN
18637	8642	134	appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	8642	135	and	and	CC
18637	8642	136	removals	removal	NNS
18637	8642	137	of	of	IN
18637	8642	138	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	8642	139	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8642	140	after	after	IN
18637	8642	141	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8642	142	has	have	VBZ
18637	8642	143	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8642	144	,	,	,
18637	8642	145	and	and	CC
18637	8642	146	on	on	IN
18637	8642	147	condition	condition	NN
18637	8642	148	that	that	IN
18637	8642	149	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8642	150	does	do	VBZ
18637	8642	151	vest	vest	NN
18637	8642	152	,	,	,
18637	8642	153	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8642	154	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8642	155	in	in	IN
18637	8642	156	other	other	JJ
18637	8642	157	authority	authority	NN
18637	8642	158	than	than	IN
18637	8642	159	the	the	DT
18637	8642	160	President	President	NNP
18637	8642	161	with	with	IN
18637	8642	162	the	the	DT
18637	8642	163	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8642	164	's	's	POS
18637	8642	165	consent	consent	NN
18637	8642	166	;	;	:
18637	8642	167	that	that	IN
18637	8642	168	the	the	DT
18637	8642	169	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8642	170	of	of	IN
18637	8642	171	the	the	DT
18637	8642	172	second	second	JJ
18637	8642	173	section	section	NN
18637	8642	174	of	of	IN
18637	8642	175	article	article	NN
18637	8642	176	II	II	NNP
18637	8642	177	,	,	,
18637	8642	178	which	which	WDT
18637	8642	179	blend	blend	VBP
18637	8642	180	action	action	NN
18637	8642	181	by	by	IN
18637	8642	182	the	the	DT
18637	8642	183	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8642	184	branch	branch	NN
18637	8642	185	,	,	,
18637	8642	186	or	or	CC
18637	8642	187	by	by	IN
18637	8642	188	part	part	NN
18637	8642	189	of	of	IN
18637	8642	190	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8642	191	,	,	,
18637	8642	192	in	in	IN
18637	8642	193	the	the	DT
18637	8642	194	work	work	NN
18637	8642	195	of	of	IN
18637	8642	196	the	the	DT
18637	8642	197	executive	executive	NN
18637	8642	198	,	,	,
18637	8642	199	are	be	VBP
18637	8642	200	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	8642	201	to	to	TO
18637	8642	202	be	be	VB
18637	8642	203	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	8642	204	construed	construe	VBN
18637	8642	205	and	and	CC
18637	8642	206	not	not	RB
18637	8642	207	to	to	TO
18637	8642	208	be	be	VB
18637	8642	209	extended	extend	VBN
18637	8642	210	by	by	IN
18637	8642	211	implication	implication	NN
18637	8642	212	;	;	:
18637	8642	213	that	that	IN
18637	8642	214	the	the	DT
18637	8642	215	President	President	NNP
18637	8642	216	's	's	POS
18637	8642	217	power	power	NN
18637	8642	218	of	of	IN
18637	8642	219	removal	removal	NN
18637	8642	220	is	be	VBZ
18637	8642	221	further	further	RB
18637	8642	222	established	establish	VBN
18637	8642	223	as	as	IN
18637	8642	224	an	an	DT
18637	8642	225	incident	incident	NN
18637	8642	226	to	to	IN
18637	8642	227	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8642	228	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	8642	229	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	8642	230	function	function	NN
18637	8642	231	of	of	IN
18637	8642	232	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8642	233	by	by	IN
18637	8642	234	and	and	CC
18637	8642	235	with	with	IN
18637	8642	236	the	the	DT
18637	8642	237	advice	advice	NN
18637	8642	238	of	of	IN
18637	8642	239	the	the	DT
18637	8642	240	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8642	241	,	,	,
18637	8642	242	but	but	CC
18637	8642	243	that	that	IN
18637	8642	244	such	such	JJ
18637	8642	245	incident	incident	NN
18637	8642	246	does	do	VBZ
18637	8642	247	not	not	RB
18637	8642	248	by	by	IN
18637	8642	249	implication	implication	NN
18637	8642	250	extend	extend	VBP
18637	8642	251	to	to	IN
18637	8642	252	removals	removal	NNS
18637	8642	253	the	the	DT
18637	8642	254	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8642	255	's	's	POS
18637	8642	256	power	power	NN
18637	8642	257	of	of	IN
18637	8642	258	checking	check	VBG
18637	8642	259	appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	8642	260	;	;	:
18637	8642	261	and	and	CC
18637	8642	262	finally	finally	RB
18637	8642	263	that	that	DT
18637	8642	264	to	to	TO
18637	8642	265	hold	hold	VB
18637	8642	266	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	8642	267	would	would	MD
18637	8642	268	make	make	VB
18637	8642	269	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8642	270	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	8642	271	for	for	IN
18637	8642	272	the	the	DT
18637	8642	273	President	President	NNP
18637	8642	274	,	,	,
18637	8642	275	in	in	IN
18637	8642	276	case	case	NN
18637	8642	277	of	of	IN
18637	8642	278	political	political	JJ
18637	8642	279	or	or	CC
18637	8642	280	other	other	JJ
18637	8642	281	differences	difference	NNS
18637	8642	282	with	with	IN
18637	8642	283	the	the	DT
18637	8642	284	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8642	285	or	or	CC
18637	8642	286	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8642	287	,	,	,
18637	8642	288	to	to	TO
18637	8642	289	take	take	VB
18637	8642	290	care	care	NN
18637	8642	291	that	that	IN
18637	8642	292	the	the	DT
18637	8642	293	laws	law	NNS
18637	8642	294	be	be	VB
18637	8642	295	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8642	296	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8642	297	.	.	.
18637	8643	1	"	"	``
18637	8643	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8643	3	311	311	CD
18637	8643	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8643	5	The	the	DT
18637	8643	6	holding	holding	NN
18637	8643	7	in	in	IN
18637	8643	8	the	the	DT
18637	8643	9	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	8643	10	case	case	NN
18637	8643	11	boils	boil	VBZ
18637	8643	12	down	down	RP
18637	8643	13	to	to	IN
18637	8643	14	the	the	DT
18637	8643	15	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	8643	16	that	that	IN
18637	8643	17	the	the	DT
18637	8643	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8643	19	endows	endow	VBZ
18637	8643	20	the	the	DT
18637	8643	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8643	22	with	with	IN
18637	8643	23	an	an	DT
18637	8643	24	illimitable	illimitable	JJ
18637	8643	25	power	power	NN
18637	8643	26	to	to	TO
18637	8643	27	remove	remove	VB
18637	8643	28	all	all	DT
18637	8643	29	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8643	30	in	in	IN
18637	8643	31	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8643	32	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8643	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8643	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	8643	35	participated	participate	VBN
18637	8643	36	with	with	IN
18637	8643	37	the	the	DT
18637	8643	38	exception	exception	NN
18637	8643	39	of	of	IN
18637	8643	40	judges	judge	NNS
18637	8643	41	of	of	IN
18637	8643	42	the	the	DT
18637	8643	43	United	United	NNP
18637	8643	44	States	States	NNP
18637	8643	45	.	.	.
18637	8644	1	The	the	DT
18637	8644	2	motivation	motivation	NN
18637	8644	3	of	of	IN
18637	8644	4	the	the	DT
18637	8644	5	holding	holding	NN
18637	8644	6	was	be	VBD
18637	8644	7	not	not	RB
18637	8644	8	,	,	,
18637	8644	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8644	10	may	may	MD
18637	8644	11	be	be	VB
18637	8644	12	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	8644	13	,	,	,
18637	8644	14	any	any	DT
18637	8644	15	ambition	ambition	NN
18637	8644	16	on	on	IN
18637	8644	17	the	the	DT
18637	8644	18	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8644	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8644	20	's	's	POS
18637	8644	21	part	part	NN
18637	8644	22	to	to	TO
18637	8644	23	set	set	VB
18637	8644	24	history	history	NN
18637	8644	25	aright	aright	NN
18637	8644	26	--	--	:
18637	8644	27	or	or	CC
18637	8644	28	awry	awry	JJ
18637	8644	29	.	.	.
18637	8645	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8645	2	312	312	CD
18637	8645	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8645	4	Rather	rather	RB
18637	8645	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8645	6	was	be	VBD
18637	8645	7	the	the	DT
18637	8645	8	concern	concern	NN
18637	8645	9	which	which	WDT
18637	8645	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8645	11	voiced	voice	VBD
18637	8645	12	in	in	IN
18637	8645	13	the	the	DT
18637	8645	14	following	follow	VBG
18637	8645	15	passage	passage	NN
18637	8645	16	in	in	IN
18637	8645	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8645	18	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8645	19	:	:	:
18637	8645	20	"	"	``
18637	8645	21	There	there	EX
18637	8645	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	8645	23	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	8645	24	in	in	IN
18637	8645	25	the	the	DT
18637	8645	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8645	27	which	which	WDT
18637	8645	28	permits	permit	VBZ
18637	8645	29	a	a	DT
18637	8645	30	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	8645	31	between	between	IN
18637	8645	32	the	the	DT
18637	8645	33	removal	removal	NN
18637	8645	34	of	of	IN
18637	8645	35	the	the	DT
18637	8645	36	head	head	NN
18637	8645	37	of	of	IN
18637	8645	38	a	a	DT
18637	8645	39	department	department	NN
18637	8645	40	or	or	CC
18637	8645	41	a	a	DT
18637	8645	42	bureau	bureau	NN
18637	8645	43	,	,	,
18637	8645	44	when	when	WRB
18637	8645	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8645	46	discharges	discharge	VBZ
18637	8645	47	a	a	DT
18637	8645	48	political	political	JJ
18637	8645	49	duty	duty	NN
18637	8645	50	of	of	IN
18637	8645	51	the	the	DT
18637	8645	52	President	President	NNP
18637	8645	53	or	or	CC
18637	8645	54	exercises	exercise	VBZ
18637	8645	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8645	56	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	8645	57	,	,	,
18637	8645	58	and	and	CC
18637	8645	59	the	the	DT
18637	8645	60	removal	removal	NN
18637	8645	61	of	of	IN
18637	8645	62	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8645	63	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8645	64	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	8645	65	in	in	IN
18637	8645	66	the	the	DT
18637	8645	67	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8645	68	of	of	IN
18637	8645	69	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8645	70	other	other	JJ
18637	8645	71	normal	normal	JJ
18637	8645	72	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8645	73	.	.	.
18637	8646	1	The	the	DT
18637	8646	2	imperative	imperative	JJ
18637	8646	3	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	8646	4	requiring	require	VBG
18637	8646	5	an	an	DT
18637	8646	6	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
18637	8646	7	power	power	NN
18637	8646	8	to	to	TO
18637	8646	9	remove	remove	VB
18637	8646	10	the	the	DT
18637	8646	11	most	most	RBS
18637	8646	12	important	important	JJ
18637	8646	13	of	of	IN
18637	8646	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8646	15	subordinates	subordinate	NNS
18637	8646	16	in	in	IN
18637	8646	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8646	18	most	most	RBS
18637	8646	19	important	important	JJ
18637	8646	20	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8646	21	must	must	MD
18637	8646	22	,	,	,
18637	8646	23	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8646	24	,	,	,
18637	8646	25	control	control	VB
18637	8646	26	the	the	DT
18637	8646	27	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	8646	28	of	of	IN
18637	8646	29	the	the	DT
18637	8646	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8646	31	as	as	IN
18637	8646	32	to	to	IN
18637	8646	33	all	all	DT
18637	8646	34	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	8646	35	by	by	IN
18637	8646	36	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8646	37	.	.	.
18637	8647	1	"	"	``
18637	8647	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8647	3	313	313	CD
18637	8647	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8647	5	Thus	thus	RB
18637	8647	6	spoke	speak	VBD
18637	8647	7	the	the	DT
18637	8647	8	former	former	JJ
18637	8647	9	President	President	NNP
18637	8647	10	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	8647	11	,	,	,
18637	8647	12	and	and	CC
18637	8647	13	the	the	DT
18637	8647	14	result	result	NN
18637	8647	15	of	of	IN
18637	8647	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8647	17	prepossession	prepossession	NN
18637	8647	18	was	be	VBD
18637	8647	19	a	a	DT
18637	8647	20	rule	rule	NN
18637	8647	21	which	which	WDT
18637	8647	22	,	,	,
18637	8647	23	as	as	IN
18637	8647	24	was	be	VBD
18637	8647	25	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	8647	26	pointed	point	VBN
18637	8647	27	out	out	RP
18637	8647	28	,	,	,
18637	8647	29	exposed	expose	VBD
18637	8647	30	the	the	DT
18637	8647	31	so	so	RB
18637	8647	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	8647	33	called	call	VBN
18637	8647	34	"	"	``
18637	8647	35	independent	independent	JJ
18637	8647	36	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	8647	37	,	,	,
18637	8647	38	"	"	''
18637	8647	39	the	the	DT
18637	8647	40	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	8647	41	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	8647	42	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	8647	43	,	,	,
18637	8647	44	the	the	DT
18637	8647	45	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8647	46	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	8647	47	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	8647	48	,	,	,
18637	8647	49	and	and	CC
18637	8647	50	the	the	DT
18637	8647	51	like	like	JJ
18637	8647	52	,	,	,
18637	8647	53	to	to	IN
18637	8647	54	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8647	55	domination	domination	NN
18637	8647	56	.	.	.
18637	8648	1	"	"	``
18637	8648	2	The	the	DT
18637	8648	3	Nature	nature	NN
18637	8648	4	of	of	IN
18637	8648	5	the	the	DT
18637	8648	6	Office	Office	NNP
18637	8648	7	"	"	''
18637	8648	8	Concept	Concept	NNP
18637	8648	9	Unfortunately	unfortunately	RB
18637	8648	10	,	,	,
18637	8648	11	the	the	DT
18637	8648	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8648	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8648	14	,	,	,
18637	8648	15	while	while	IN
18637	8648	16	professing	profess	VBG
18637	8648	17	to	to	TO
18637	8648	18	follow	follow	VB
18637	8648	19	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8648	20	's	's	POS
18637	8648	21	leadership	leadership	NN
18637	8648	22	had	have	VBD
18637	8648	23	omitted	omit	VBN
18637	8648	24	to	to	TO
18637	8648	25	weigh	weigh	VB
18637	8648	26	properly	properly	RB
18637	8648	27	the	the	DT
18637	8648	28	very	very	RB
18637	8648	29	important	important	JJ
18637	8648	30	observation	observation	NN
18637	8648	31	which	which	WDT
18637	8648	32	the	the	DT
18637	8648	33	latter	latter	JJ
18637	8648	34	had	have	VBD
18637	8648	35	made	make	VBN
18637	8648	36	at	at	IN
18637	8648	37	the	the	DT
18637	8648	38	time	time	NN
18637	8648	39	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	8648	40	the	the	DT
18637	8648	41	office	office	NN
18637	8648	42	of	of	IN
18637	8648	43	Comptroller	Comptroller	NNP
18637	8648	44	of	of	IN
18637	8648	45	the	the	DT
18637	8648	46	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	8648	47	.	.	.
18637	8649	1	"	"	``
18637	8649	2	The	the	DT
18637	8649	3	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	8649	4	,	,	,
18637	8649	5	"	"	''
18637	8649	6	said	say	VBD
18637	8649	7	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8649	8	,	,	,
18637	8649	9	"	"	``
18637	8649	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	8649	11	gone	go	VBN
18637	8649	12	through	through	IN
18637	8649	13	the	the	DT
18637	8649	14	bill	bill	NN
18637	8649	15	without	without	IN
18637	8649	16	making	make	VBG
18637	8649	17	any	any	DT
18637	8649	18	provision	provision	NN
18637	8649	19	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	8649	20	the	the	DT
18637	8649	21	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	8649	22	by	by	IN
18637	8649	23	which	which	WDT
18637	8649	24	the	the	DT
18637	8649	25	comptroller	comptroller	NN
18637	8649	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	8649	27	to	to	TO
18637	8649	28	hold	hold	VB
18637	8649	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8649	30	office	office	NN
18637	8649	31	.	.	.
18637	8650	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8650	2	think	think	VBP
18637	8650	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8650	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	8650	5	a	a	DT
18637	8650	6	point	point	NN
18637	8650	7	worthy	worthy	JJ
18637	8650	8	of	of	IN
18637	8650	9	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	8650	10	,	,	,
18637	8650	11	and	and	CC
18637	8650	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	8650	13	,	,	,
18637	8650	14	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8650	15	,	,	,
18637	8650	16	submit	submit	VB
18637	8650	17	a	a	DT
18637	8650	18	few	few	JJ
18637	8650	19	observations	observation	NNS
18637	8650	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	8650	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8650	22	.	.	.
18637	8651	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8651	2	will	will	MD
18637	8651	3	be	be	VB
18637	8651	4	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8651	5	to	to	TO
18637	8651	6	consider	consider	VB
18637	8651	7	the	the	DT
18637	8651	8	nature	nature	NN
18637	8651	9	of	of	IN
18637	8651	10	this	this	DT
18637	8651	11	office	office	NN
18637	8651	12	,	,	,
18637	8651	13	to	to	TO
18637	8651	14	enable	enable	VB
18637	8651	15	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8651	16	to	to	TO
18637	8651	17	come	come	VB
18637	8651	18	to	to	IN
18637	8651	19	a	a	DT
18637	8651	20	right	right	JJ
18637	8651	21	decision	decision	NN
18637	8651	22	on	on	IN
18637	8651	23	the	the	DT
18637	8651	24	subject	subject	NN
18637	8651	25	;	;	:
18637	8651	26	in	in	IN
18637	8651	27	analyzing	analyze	VBG
18637	8651	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8651	29	properties	property	NNS
18637	8651	30	,	,	,
18637	8651	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8651	32	shall	shall	MD
18637	8651	33	easily	easily	RB
18637	8651	34	discover	discover	VB
18637	8651	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8651	36	are	be	VBP
18637	8651	37	not	not	RB
18637	8651	38	purely	purely	RB
18637	8651	39	of	of	IN
18637	8651	40	an	an	DT
18637	8651	41	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8651	42	nature	nature	NN
18637	8651	43	.	.	.
18637	8652	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8652	2	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	8652	3	to	to	IN
18637	8652	4	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8652	5	that	that	IN
18637	8652	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8652	7	partake	partake	VBP
18637	8652	8	of	of	IN
18637	8652	9	a	a	DT
18637	8652	10	judiciary	judiciary	JJ
18637	8652	11	quality	quality	NN
18637	8652	12	as	as	RB
18637	8652	13	well	well	RB
18637	8652	14	as	as	IN
18637	8652	15	executive	executive	NN
18637	8652	16	;	;	:
18637	8652	17	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	8652	18	the	the	DT
18637	8652	19	latter	latter	JJ
18637	8652	20	obtains	obtain	NNS
18637	8652	21	in	in	IN
18637	8652	22	the	the	DT
18637	8652	23	greatest	great	JJS
18637	8652	24	degree	degree	NN
18637	8652	25	.	.	.
18637	8653	1	The	the	DT
18637	8653	2	principal	principal	JJ
18637	8653	3	duty	duty	NN
18637	8653	4	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	8653	5	to	to	TO
18637	8653	6	be	be	VB
18637	8653	7	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	8653	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	8653	9	the	the	DT
18637	8653	10	lawfulness	lawfulness	NN
18637	8653	11	and	and	CC
18637	8653	12	justice	justice	NN
18637	8653	13	of	of	IN
18637	8653	14	the	the	DT
18637	8653	15	claims	claim	NNS
18637	8653	16	and	and	CC
18637	8653	17	accounts	account	VBZ
18637	8653	18	subsisting	subsisting	JJ
18637	8653	19	between	between	IN
18637	8653	20	the	the	DT
18637	8653	21	United	United	NNP
18637	8653	22	States	States	NNP
18637	8653	23	and	and	CC
18637	8653	24	particular	particular	JJ
18637	8653	25	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8653	26	:	:	:
18637	8653	27	this	this	DT
18637	8653	28	partakes	partake	VBZ
18637	8653	29	strongly	strongly	RB
18637	8653	30	of	of	IN
18637	8653	31	the	the	DT
18637	8653	32	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8653	33	character	character	NN
18637	8653	34	,	,	,
18637	8653	35	and	and	CC
18637	8653	36	there	there	EX
18637	8653	37	may	may	MD
18637	8653	38	be	be	VB
18637	8653	39	strong	strong	JJ
18637	8653	40	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	8653	41	why	why	WRB
18637	8653	42	an	an	DT
18637	8653	43	officer	officer	NN
18637	8653	44	of	of	IN
18637	8653	45	this	this	DT
18637	8653	46	kind	kind	NN
18637	8653	47	should	should	MD
18637	8653	48	not	not	RB
18637	8653	49	hold	hold	VB
18637	8653	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8653	51	office	office	NN
18637	8653	52	at	at	IN
18637	8653	53	the	the	DT
18637	8653	54	pleasure	pleasure	NN
18637	8653	55	of	of	IN
18637	8653	56	the	the	DT
18637	8653	57	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8653	58	branch	branch	NN
18637	8653	59	of	of	IN
18637	8653	60	the	the	DT
18637	8653	61	government	government	NN
18637	8653	62	.	.	.
18637	8654	1	"	"	``
18637	8654	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8654	3	314	314	CD
18637	8654	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8654	5	In	in	IN
18637	8654	6	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	8654	7	_	_	NNP
18637	8654	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	8654	9	_	_	NNP
18637	8654	10	United	United	NNP
18637	8654	11	States,[315	States,[315	NNP
18637	8654	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8654	13	decided	decide	VBD
18637	8654	14	in	in	IN
18637	8654	15	1935	1935	CD
18637	8654	16	,	,	,
18637	8654	17	the	the	DT
18637	8654	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8654	19	seized	seize	VBD
18637	8654	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	8654	21	"	"	``
18637	8654	22	the	the	DT
18637	8654	23	nature	nature	NN
18637	8654	24	of	of	IN
18637	8654	25	the	the	DT
18637	8654	26	office	office	NN
18637	8654	27	"	"	''
18637	8654	28	concept	concept	NN
18637	8654	29	and	and	CC
18637	8654	30	applied	apply	VBD
18637	8654	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8654	32	as	as	IN
18637	8654	33	a	a	DT
18637	8654	34	much	much	RB
18637	8654	35	needed	need	VBN
18637	8654	36	corrective	corrective	JJ
18637	8654	37	to	to	IN
18637	8654	38	the	the	DT
18637	8654	39	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	8654	40	holding	hold	VBG
18637	8654	41	.	.	.
18637	8655	1	The	the	DT
18637	8655	2	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	8655	3	Case	Case	NNP
18637	8655	4	The	the	DT
18637	8655	5	material	material	NN
18637	8655	6	element	element	NN
18637	8655	7	of	of	IN
18637	8655	8	this	this	DT
18637	8655	9	case	case	NN
18637	8655	10	was	be	VBD
18637	8655	11	that	that	IN
18637	8655	12	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	8655	13	,	,	,
18637	8655	14	a	a	DT
18637	8655	15	member	member	NN
18637	8655	16	of	of	IN
18637	8655	17	the	the	DT
18637	8655	18	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8655	19	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	8655	20	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	8655	21	,	,	,
18637	8655	22	was	be	VBD
18637	8655	23	on	on	IN
18637	8655	24	October	October	NNP
18637	8655	25	7	7	CD
18637	8655	26	,	,	,
18637	8655	27	1933	1933	CD
18637	8655	28	,	,	,
18637	8655	29	notified	notify	VBN
18637	8655	30	by	by	IN
18637	8655	31	President	President	NNP
18637	8655	32	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8655	33	that	that	IN
18637	8655	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8655	35	was	be	VBD
18637	8655	36	"	"	``
18637	8655	37	removed	remove	VBN
18637	8655	38	"	"	''
18637	8655	39	from	from	IN
18637	8655	40	office	office	NN
18637	8655	41	,	,	,
18637	8655	42	the	the	DT
18637	8655	43	reason	reason	NN
18637	8655	44	being	be	VBG
18637	8655	45	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8655	46	divergent	divergent	JJ
18637	8655	47	views	view	NNS
18637	8655	48	of	of	IN
18637	8655	49	public	public	JJ
18637	8655	50	policy	policy	NN
18637	8655	51	.	.	.
18637	8656	1	In	in	IN
18637	8656	2	due	due	JJ
18637	8656	3	course	course	NN
18637	8656	4	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	8656	5	sued	sue	VBD
18637	8656	6	for	for	IN
18637	8656	7	salary	salary	NN
18637	8656	8	.	.	.
18637	8657	1	Distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
18637	8657	2	the	the	DT
18637	8657	3	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	8657	4	case	case	NN
18637	8657	5	,	,	,
18637	8657	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8657	7	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	8657	8	,	,	,
18637	8657	9	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8657	10	for	for	IN
18637	8657	11	the	the	DT
18637	8657	12	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	8657	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8657	14	,	,	,
18637	8657	15	said	say	VBD
18637	8657	16	:	:	:
18637	8657	17	"	"	``
18637	8657	18	A	a	DT
18637	8657	19	postmaster	postmaster	NN
18637	8657	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	8657	21	an	an	DT
18637	8657	22	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8657	23	officer	officer	NN
18637	8657	24	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	8657	25	to	to	IN
18637	8657	26	the	the	DT
18637	8657	27	performance	performance	NN
18637	8657	28	of	of	IN
18637	8657	29	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8657	30	functions	function	NNS
18637	8657	31	.	.	.
18637	8658	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8658	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8658	3	charged	charge	VBN
18637	8658	4	with	with	IN
18637	8658	5	no	no	DT
18637	8658	6	duty	duty	NN
18637	8658	7	at	at	RB
18637	8658	8	all	all	RB
18637	8658	9	related	relate	VBN
18637	8658	10	to	to	IN
18637	8658	11	either	either	CC
18637	8658	12	the	the	DT
18637	8658	13	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8658	14	or	or	CC
18637	8658	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8658	16	power	power	NN
18637	8658	17	.	.	.
18637	8659	1	The	the	DT
18637	8659	2	actual	actual	JJ
18637	8659	3	decision	decision	NN
18637	8659	4	in	in	IN
18637	8659	5	the	the	DT
18637	8659	6	_	_	NNP
18637	8659	7	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	8659	8	_	_	NNP
18637	8659	9	Case	Case	NNP
18637	8659	10	finds	find	VBZ
18637	8659	11	support	support	NN
18637	8659	12	in	in	IN
18637	8659	13	the	the	DT
18637	8659	14	theory	theory	NN
18637	8659	15	that	that	IN
18637	8659	16	such	such	PDT
18637	8659	17	an	an	DT
18637	8659	18	office	office	NN
18637	8659	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	8659	20	merely	merely	RB
18637	8659	21	one	one	CD
18637	8659	22	of	of	IN
18637	8659	23	the	the	DT
18637	8659	24	units	unit	NNS
18637	8659	25	in	in	IN
18637	8659	26	the	the	DT
18637	8659	27	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8659	28	department	department	NN
18637	8659	29	and	and	CC
18637	8659	30	,	,	,
18637	8659	31	hence	hence	RB
18637	8659	32	,	,	,
18637	8659	33	inherently	inherently	RB
18637	8659	34	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8659	35	to	to	IN
18637	8659	36	the	the	DT
18637	8659	37	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	8659	38	and	and	CC
18637	8659	39	illimitable	illimitable	JJ
18637	8659	40	power	power	NN
18637	8659	41	of	of	IN
18637	8659	42	removal	removal	NN
18637	8659	43	by	by	IN
18637	8659	44	the	the	DT
18637	8659	45	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8659	46	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8659	47	,	,	,
18637	8659	48	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8659	49	subordinate	subordinate	JJ
18637	8659	50	and	and	CC
18637	8659	51	aid	aid	VB
18637	8659	52	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8659	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	8659	54	.	.	.
18637	8660	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8660	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8660	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8660	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8660	5	goes	go	VBZ
18637	8660	6	no	no	DT
18637	8660	7	farther;--much	farther;--much	NN
18637	8660	8	less	less	RBR
18637	8660	9	does	do	VBZ
18637	8660	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8660	11	include	include	VB
18637	8660	12	an	an	DT
18637	8660	13	officer	officer	NN
18637	8660	14	who	who	WP
18637	8660	15	occupies	occupy	VBZ
18637	8660	16	no	no	DT
18637	8660	17	place	place	NN
18637	8660	18	in	in	IN
18637	8660	19	the	the	DT
18637	8660	20	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8660	21	department	department	NN
18637	8660	22	and	and	CC
18637	8660	23	who	who	WP
18637	8660	24	exercise	exercise	VBP
18637	8660	25	no	no	DT
18637	8660	26	part	part	NN
18637	8660	27	of	of	IN
18637	8660	28	the	the	DT
18637	8660	29	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8660	30	power	power	NN
18637	8660	31	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8660	32	by	by	IN
18637	8660	33	the	the	DT
18637	8660	34	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8660	35	in	in	IN
18637	8660	36	the	the	DT
18637	8660	37	President	President	NNP
18637	8660	38	.	.	.
18637	8661	1	"	"	``
18637	8661	2	The	the	DT
18637	8661	3	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8661	4	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	8661	5	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	8661	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	8661	7	an	an	DT
18637	8661	8	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	8661	9	body	body	NN
18637	8661	10	created	create	VBN
18637	8661	11	by	by	IN
18637	8661	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8661	13	to	to	TO
18637	8661	14	carry	carry	VB
18637	8661	15	into	into	IN
18637	8661	16	effect	effect	NN
18637	8661	17	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8661	18	policies	policy	NNS
18637	8661	19	embodied	embody	VBN
18637	8661	20	in	in	IN
18637	8661	21	the	the	DT
18637	8661	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	8661	23	*	*	NFP
18637	8661	24	*	*	NFP
18637	8661	25	*	*	NFP
18637	8661	26	Such	such	PDT
18637	8661	27	a	a	DT
18637	8661	28	body	body	NN
18637	8661	29	can	can	MD
18637	8661	30	not	not	RB
18637	8661	31	in	in	IN
18637	8661	32	any	any	DT
18637	8661	33	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8661	34	sense	sense	NN
18637	8661	35	be	be	VB
18637	8661	36	characterized	characterize	VBN
18637	8661	37	as	as	IN
18637	8661	38	an	an	DT
18637	8661	39	arm	arm	NN
18637	8661	40	or	or	CC
18637	8661	41	eye	eye	NN
18637	8661	42	of	of	IN
18637	8661	43	the	the	DT
18637	8661	44	executive	executive	NN
18637	8661	45	.	.	.
18637	8662	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8662	2	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8662	3	are	be	VBP
18637	8662	4	performed	perform	VBN
18637	8662	5	without	without	IN
18637	8662	6	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8662	7	leave	leave	NN
18637	8662	8	and	and	CC
18637	8662	9	,	,	,
18637	8662	10	in	in	IN
18637	8662	11	the	the	DT
18637	8662	12	contemplation	contemplation	NN
18637	8662	13	of	of	IN
18637	8662	14	the	the	DT
18637	8662	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	8662	16	,	,	,
18637	8662	17	must	must	MD
18637	8662	18	be	be	VB
18637	8662	19	free	free	JJ
18637	8662	20	from	from	IN
18637	8662	21	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8662	22	control	control	NN
18637	8662	23	.	.	.
18637	8663	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8663	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8663	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8663	4	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8663	5	think	think	VBP
18637	8663	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8663	7	plain	plain	JJ
18637	8663	8	under	under	IN
18637	8663	9	the	the	DT
18637	8663	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8663	11	that	that	DT
18637	8663	12	illimitable	illimitable	JJ
18637	8663	13	power	power	NN
18637	8663	14	of	of	IN
18637	8663	15	removal	removal	NN
18637	8663	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	8663	17	not	not	RB
18637	8663	18	possessed	possess	VBN
18637	8663	19	by	by	IN
18637	8663	20	the	the	DT
18637	8663	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8663	22	in	in	IN
18637	8663	23	respect	respect	NN
18637	8663	24	of	of	IN
18637	8663	25	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8663	26	of	of	IN
18637	8663	27	the	the	DT
18637	8663	28	character	character	NN
18637	8663	29	of	of	IN
18637	8663	30	those	those	DT
18637	8663	31	just	just	RB
18637	8663	32	named	name	VBN
18637	8663	33	,	,	,
18637	8663	34	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8663	35	the	the	DT
18637	8663	36	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	8663	37	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	8663	38	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	8663	39	,	,	,
18637	8663	40	the	the	DT
18637	8663	41	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8663	42	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	8663	43	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	8663	44	,	,	,
18637	8663	45	the	the	DT
18637	8663	46	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8663	47	of	of	IN
18637	8663	48	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	8663	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8663	50	.	.	.
18637	8664	1	The	the	DT
18637	8664	2	authority	authority	NN
18637	8664	3	of	of	IN
18637	8664	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8664	5	,	,	,
18637	8664	6	in	in	IN
18637	8664	7	creating	create	VBG
18637	8664	8	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	8664	9	-	-	JJ
18637	8664	10	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8664	11	or	or	CC
18637	8664	12	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	8664	13	-	-	JJ
18637	8664	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8664	15	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	8664	16	,	,	,
18637	8664	17	to	to	TO
18637	8664	18	require	require	VB
18637	8664	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8664	20	to	to	TO
18637	8664	21	act	act	VB
18637	8664	22	in	in	IN
18637	8664	23	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8664	24	of	of	IN
18637	8664	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8664	26	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8664	27	independently	independently	RB
18637	8664	28	of	of	IN
18637	8664	29	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8664	30	control	control	NN
18637	8664	31	can	can	MD
18637	8664	32	not	not	RB
18637	8664	33	well	well	RB
18637	8664	34	be	be	VB
18637	8664	35	doubted	doubt	VBN
18637	8664	36	;	;	:
18637	8664	37	and	and	CC
18637	8664	38	that	that	IN
18637	8664	39	authority	authority	NN
18637	8664	40	includes	include	VBZ
18637	8664	41	,	,	,
18637	8664	42	as	as	IN
18637	8664	43	an	an	DT
18637	8664	44	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	8664	45	incident	incident	NN
18637	8664	46	,	,	,
18637	8664	47	power	power	NN
18637	8664	48	to	to	TO
18637	8664	49	fix	fix	VB
18637	8664	50	the	the	DT
18637	8664	51	period	period	NN
18637	8664	52	during	during	IN
18637	8664	53	which	which	WDT
18637	8664	54	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8664	55	shall	shall	MD
18637	8664	56	continue	continue	VB
18637	8664	57	in	in	IN
18637	8664	58	office	office	NN
18637	8664	59	,	,	,
18637	8664	60	and	and	CC
18637	8664	61	to	to	TO
18637	8664	62	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	8664	63	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8664	64	removal	removal	NN
18637	8664	65	except	except	IN
18637	8664	66	for	for	IN
18637	8664	67	cause	cause	NN
18637	8664	68	in	in	IN
18637	8664	69	the	the	DT
18637	8664	70	meantime	meantime	NN
18637	8664	71	.	.	.
18637	8665	1	For	for	IN
18637	8665	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8665	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8665	4	quite	quite	RB
18637	8665	5	evident	evident	JJ
18637	8665	6	that	that	IN
18637	8665	7	one	one	CD
18637	8665	8	who	who	WP
18637	8665	9	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	8665	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8665	11	office	office	NN
18637	8665	12	only	only	RB
18637	8665	13	during	during	IN
18637	8665	14	the	the	DT
18637	8665	15	pleasure	pleasure	NN
18637	8665	16	of	of	IN
18637	8665	17	another	another	DT
18637	8665	18	,	,	,
18637	8665	19	can	can	MD
18637	8665	20	not	not	RB
18637	8665	21	be	be	VB
18637	8665	22	depended	depend	VBN
18637	8665	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	8665	24	to	to	TO
18637	8665	25	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	8665	26	an	an	DT
18637	8665	27	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	8665	28	of	of	IN
18637	8665	29	independence	independence	NN
18637	8665	30	against	against	IN
18637	8665	31	the	the	DT
18637	8665	32	latter	latter	NN
18637	8665	33	's	's	POS
18637	8665	34	will	will	NN
18637	8665	35	.	.	.
18637	8666	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8666	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8666	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8666	4	"	"	``
18637	8666	5	The	the	DT
18637	8666	6	result	result	NN
18637	8666	7	of	of	IN
18637	8666	8	what	what	WP
18637	8666	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8666	10	now	now	RB
18637	8666	11	have	have	VBP
18637	8666	12	said	say	VBN
18637	8666	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	8666	14	this	this	DT
18637	8666	15	:	:	:
18637	8666	16	Whether	whether	IN
18637	8666	17	the	the	DT
18637	8666	18	power	power	NN
18637	8666	19	of	of	IN
18637	8666	20	the	the	DT
18637	8666	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8666	22	to	to	TO
18637	8666	23	remove	remove	VB
18637	8666	24	an	an	DT
18637	8666	25	officer	officer	NN
18637	8666	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	8666	27	prevail	prevail	VB
18637	8666	28	,	,	,
18637	8666	29	over	over	IN
18637	8666	30	the	the	DT
18637	8666	31	authority	authority	NN
18637	8666	32	of	of	IN
18637	8666	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8666	34	to	to	TO
18637	8666	35	condition	condition	VB
18637	8666	36	the	the	DT
18637	8666	37	power	power	NN
18637	8666	38	by	by	IN
18637	8666	39	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	8666	40	a	a	DT
18637	8666	41	definite	definite	JJ
18637	8666	42	term	term	NN
18637	8666	43	and	and	CC
18637	8666	44	precluding	preclude	VBG
18637	8666	45	a	a	DT
18637	8666	46	removal	removal	NN
18637	8666	47	except	except	IN
18637	8666	48	for	for	IN
18637	8666	49	cause	cause	NN
18637	8666	50	,	,	,
18637	8666	51	will	will	MD
18637	8666	52	depend	depend	VB
18637	8666	53	upon	upon	IN
18637	8666	54	the	the	DT
18637	8666	55	character	character	NN
18637	8666	56	of	of	IN
18637	8666	57	the	the	DT
18637	8666	58	office	office	NN
18637	8666	59	;	;	:
18637	8666	60	the	the	DT
18637	8666	61	_	_	NNP
18637	8666	62	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	8666	63	_	_	NNP
18637	8666	64	decision	decision	NN
18637	8666	65	,	,	,
18637	8666	66	affirming	affirm	VBG
18637	8666	67	the	the	DT
18637	8666	68	power	power	NN
18637	8666	69	of	of	IN
18637	8666	70	the	the	DT
18637	8666	71	President	President	NNP
18637	8666	72	alone	alone	RB
18637	8666	73	to	to	TO
18637	8666	74	make	make	VB
18637	8666	75	the	the	DT
18637	8666	76	removal	removal	NN
18637	8666	77	,	,	,
18637	8666	78	is	be	VBZ
18637	8666	79	confined	confine	VBN
18637	8666	80	to	to	TO
18637	8666	81	purely	purely	RB
18637	8666	82	executive	executive	VB
18637	8666	83	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8666	84	;	;	:
18637	8666	85	and	and	CC
18637	8666	86	as	as	IN
18637	8666	87	to	to	IN
18637	8666	88	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8666	89	of	of	IN
18637	8666	90	the	the	DT
18637	8666	91	kind	kind	NN
18637	8666	92	here	here	RB
18637	8666	93	under	under	IN
18637	8666	94	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	8666	95	,	,	,
18637	8666	96	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8666	97	hold	hold	VBP
18637	8666	98	that	that	IN
18637	8666	99	no	no	DT
18637	8666	100	removal	removal	NN
18637	8666	101	can	can	MD
18637	8666	102	be	be	VB
18637	8666	103	made	make	VBN
18637	8666	104	during	during	IN
18637	8666	105	the	the	DT
18637	8666	106	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	8666	107	term	term	NN
18637	8666	108	for	for	IN
18637	8666	109	which	which	WDT
18637	8666	110	the	the	DT
18637	8666	111	officer	officer	NN
18637	8666	112	is	be	VBZ
18637	8666	113	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	8666	114	,	,	,
18637	8666	115	except	except	IN
18637	8666	116	for	for	IN
18637	8666	117	one	one	CD
18637	8666	118	or	or	CC
18637	8666	119	more	more	JJR
18637	8666	120	of	of	IN
18637	8666	121	the	the	DT
18637	8666	122	causes	cause	NNS
18637	8666	123	named	name	VBN
18637	8666	124	in	in	IN
18637	8666	125	the	the	DT
18637	8666	126	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	8666	127	statute	statute	NN
18637	8666	128	.	.	.
18637	8667	1	"	"	``
18637	8667	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8667	3	316	316	CD
18637	8667	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8667	5	Other	other	JJ
18637	8667	6	Phases	Phases	NNPS
18637	8667	7	of	of	IN
18637	8667	8	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	8667	9	Removal	Removal	NNP
18637	8667	10	Power	Power	NNP
18637	8667	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8667	12	may	may	MD
18637	8667	13	"	"	``
18637	8667	14	limit	limit	VB
18637	8667	15	and	and	CC
18637	8667	16	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	8667	17	the	the	DT
18637	8667	18	power	power	NN
18637	8667	19	of	of	IN
18637	8667	20	removal	removal	NN
18637	8667	21	as	as	IN
18637	8667	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8667	23	deems	deem	VBZ
18637	8667	24	best	well	RBS
18637	8667	25	for	for	IN
18637	8667	26	the	the	DT
18637	8667	27	public	public	JJ
18637	8667	28	interests	interest	NNS
18637	8667	29	"	"	''
18637	8667	30	in	in	IN
18637	8667	31	the	the	DT
18637	8667	32	case	case	NN
18637	8667	33	of	of	IN
18637	8667	34	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	8667	35	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8667	36	.	.	.
18637	8668	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8668	2	317	317	CD
18637	8668	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8668	4	But	but	CC
18637	8668	5	in	in	IN
18637	8668	6	the	the	DT
18637	8668	7	absence	absence	NN
18637	8668	8	of	of	IN
18637	8668	9	specific	specific	JJ
18637	8668	10	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8668	11	provision	provision	NN
18637	8668	12	to	to	IN
18637	8668	13	the	the	DT
18637	8668	14	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	8668	15	,	,	,
18637	8668	16	the	the	DT
18637	8668	17	President	President	NNP
18637	8668	18	may	may	MD
18637	8668	19	remove	remove	VB
18637	8668	20	at	at	IN
18637	8668	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8668	22	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	8668	23	an	an	DT
18637	8668	24	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	8668	25	officer	officer	NN
18637	8668	26	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8668	27	term	term	NN
18637	8668	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	8668	29	limited	limit	VBN
18637	8668	30	by	by	IN
18637	8668	31	statute,[318	statute,[318	NNP
18637	8668	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8668	33	or	or	CC
18637	8668	34	one	one	CD
18637	8668	35	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	8668	36	with	with	IN
18637	8668	37	the	the	DT
18637	8668	38	consent	consent	NN
18637	8668	39	of	of	IN
18637	8668	40	the	the	DT
18637	8668	41	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8668	42	.	.	.
18637	8669	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8669	2	319	319	CD
18637	8669	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8669	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8669	5	may	may	MD
18637	8669	6	remove	remove	VB
18637	8669	7	an	an	DT
18637	8669	8	officer	officer	NN
18637	8669	9	of	of	IN
18637	8669	10	the	the	DT
18637	8669	11	army	army	NNP
18637	8669	12	or	or	CC
18637	8669	13	navy	navy	NNP
18637	8669	14	at	at	IN
18637	8669	15	any	any	DT
18637	8669	16	time	time	NN
18637	8669	17	by	by	IN
18637	8669	18	nominating	nominate	VBG
18637	8669	19	to	to	IN
18637	8669	20	the	the	DT
18637	8669	21	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8669	22	the	the	DT
18637	8669	23	officer	officer	NN
18637	8669	24	's	's	POS
18637	8669	25	successor	successor	NN
18637	8669	26	,	,	,
18637	8669	27	provided	provide	VBD
18637	8669	28	the	the	DT
18637	8669	29	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8669	30	approves	approve	VBZ
18637	8669	31	the	the	DT
18637	8669	32	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	8669	33	.	.	.
18637	8670	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8670	2	320	320	CD
18637	8670	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8670	4	In	in	IN
18637	8670	5	1940	1940	CD
18637	8670	6	the	the	DT
18637	8670	7	President	President	NNP
18637	8670	8	was	be	VBD
18637	8670	9	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	8670	10	in	in	IN
18637	8670	11	removing	remove	VBG
18637	8670	12	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
18637	8670	13	E.A.	E.A.	NNP
18637	8671	1	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	8671	2	from	from	IN
18637	8671	3	the	the	DT
18637	8671	4	chairmanship	chairmanship	NN
18637	8671	5	of	of	IN
18637	8671	6	TVA	TVA	NNP
18637	8671	7	for	for	IN
18637	8671	8	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	8671	9	to	to	TO
18637	8671	10	produce	produce	VB
18637	8671	11	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	8671	12	in	in	IN
18637	8671	13	substantiation	substantiation	NN
18637	8671	14	of	of	IN
18637	8671	15	charges	charge	NNS
18637	8671	16	which	which	WDT
18637	8671	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8671	18	had	have	VBD
18637	8671	19	levelled	level	VBN
18637	8671	20	at	at	IN
18637	8671	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8671	22	fellow	fellow	JJ
18637	8671	23	directors	director	NNS
18637	8671	24	.	.	.
18637	8672	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8672	2	321	321	CD
18637	8672	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8672	4	Although	although	IN
18637	8672	5	no	no	DT
18637	8672	6	such	such	JJ
18637	8672	7	cause	cause	NN
18637	8672	8	of	of	IN
18637	8672	9	removal	removal	NN
18637	8672	10	by	by	IN
18637	8672	11	the	the	DT
18637	8672	12	President	President	NNP
18637	8672	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	8672	14	stated	state	VBN
18637	8672	15	in	in	IN
18637	8672	16	the	the	DT
18637	8672	17	act	act	NN
18637	8672	18	creating	create	VBG
18637	8672	19	TVA	TVA	NNP
18637	8672	20	,	,	,
18637	8672	21	the	the	DT
18637	8672	22	President	President	NNP
18637	8672	23	's	's	POS
18637	8672	24	action	action	NN
18637	8672	25	,	,	,
18637	8672	26	being	be	VBG
18637	8672	27	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	8672	28	required	require	VBN
18637	8672	29	to	to	TO
18637	8672	30	promote	promote	VB
18637	8672	31	the	the	DT
18637	8672	32	smooth	smooth	JJ
18637	8672	33	functioning	functioning	NN
18637	8672	34	of	of	IN
18637	8672	35	TVA	TVA	NNP
18637	8672	36	,	,	,
18637	8672	37	was	be	VBD
18637	8672	38	within	within	IN
18637	8672	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8672	40	duty	duty	NN
18637	8672	41	to	to	TO
18637	8672	42	"	"	``
18637	8672	43	take	take	VB
18637	8672	44	care	care	NN
18637	8672	45	that	that	IN
18637	8672	46	the	the	DT
18637	8672	47	laws	law	NNS
18637	8672	48	be	be	VB
18637	8672	49	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8672	50	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8672	51	.	.	.
18637	8672	52	"	"	''
18637	8673	1	So	so	RB
18637	8673	2	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	8673	3	,	,	,
18637	8673	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8673	5	did	do	VBD
18637	8673	6	not	not	RB
18637	8673	7	violate	violate	VB
18637	8673	8	the	the	DT
18637	8673	9	principle	principle	NN
18637	8673	10	of	of	IN
18637	8673	11	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	8673	12	independence	independence	NN
18637	8673	13	set	set	VBN
18637	8673	14	forth	forth	RP
18637	8673	15	in	in	IN
18637	8673	16	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	8673	17	_	_	NNP
18637	8673	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	8673	19	_	_	NNP
18637	8673	20	United	United	NNP
18637	8673	21	States	States	NNP
18637	8673	22	.	.	.
18637	8674	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8674	2	322	322	CD
18637	8674	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8674	4	THE	the	DT
18637	8674	5	PRESIDENTIAL	PRESIDENTIAL	NNP
18637	8674	6	AEGIS	aegis	JJ
18637	8674	7	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	8674	8	have	have	VBP
18637	8674	9	more	more	JJR
18637	8674	10	than	than	IN
18637	8674	11	once	once	RB
18637	8674	12	had	have	VBN
18637	8674	13	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	8674	14	to	to	TO
18637	8674	15	stand	stand	VB
18637	8674	16	in	in	IN
18637	8674	17	a	a	DT
18637	8674	18	protective	protective	JJ
18637	8674	19	relation	relation	NN
18637	8674	20	to	to	IN
18637	8674	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8674	22	subordinates	subordinate	NNS
18637	8674	23	,	,	,
18637	8674	24	assuming	assume	VBG
18637	8674	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8674	26	defense	defense	NN
18637	8674	27	in	in	IN
18637	8674	28	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	8674	29	brought	bring	VBN
18637	8674	30	against	against	IN
18637	8674	31	them[323	them[323	NNP
18637	8674	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8674	33	or	or	CC
18637	8674	34	pressing	press	VBG
18637	8674	35	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	8674	36	in	in	IN
18637	8674	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8674	38	behalf,[324	behalf,[324	NN
18637	8674	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8674	40	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	8674	41	a	a	DT
18637	8674	42	call	call	NN
18637	8674	43	for	for	IN
18637	8674	44	papers	paper	NNS
18637	8674	45	from	from	IN
18637	8674	46	one	one	CD
18637	8674	47	of	of	IN
18637	8674	48	the	the	DT
18637	8674	49	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	8674	50	of	of	IN
18637	8674	51	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8674	52	which	which	WDT
18637	8674	53	might	may	MD
18637	8674	54	be	be	VB
18637	8674	55	used	use	VBN
18637	8674	56	,	,	,
18637	8674	57	in	in	IN
18637	8674	58	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8674	59	absence	absence	NN
18637	8674	60	from	from	IN
18637	8674	61	the	the	DT
18637	8674	62	seat	seat	NN
18637	8674	63	of	of	IN
18637	8674	64	government	government	NN
18637	8674	65	,	,	,
18637	8674	66	to	to	IN
18637	8674	67	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8674	68	disadvantage,[325	disadvantage,[325	NN
18637	8674	69	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8674	70	challenging	challenge	VBG
18637	8674	71	the	the	DT
18637	8674	72	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8674	73	validity	validity	NN
18637	8674	74	of	of	IN
18637	8674	75	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8674	76	which	which	WDT
18637	8674	77	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8674	78	deemed	deem	VBD
18637	8674	79	detrimental	detrimental	JJ
18637	8674	80	to	to	IN
18637	8674	81	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8674	82	interests	interest	NNS
18637	8674	83	.	.	.
18637	8675	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8675	2	326	326	CD
18637	8675	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8675	4	There	there	EX
18637	8675	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	8675	6	one	one	CD
18637	8675	7	matter	matter	NN
18637	8675	8	,	,	,
18637	8675	9	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	8675	10	,	,	,
18637	8675	11	as	as	IN
18637	8675	12	to	to	IN
18637	8675	13	which	which	WDT
18637	8675	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8675	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	8675	16	able	able	JJ
18637	8675	17	to	to	TO
18637	8675	18	spread	spread	VB
18637	8675	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8675	20	own	own	JJ
18637	8675	21	official	official	JJ
18637	8675	22	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	8675	23	to	to	IN
18637	8675	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8675	25	.	.	.
18637	8676	1	The	the	DT
18637	8676	2	courts	court	NNS
18637	8676	3	may	may	MD
18637	8676	4	not	not	RB
18637	8676	5	require	require	VB
18637	8676	6	the	the	DT
18637	8676	7	divulging	divulging	NN
18637	8676	8	of	of	IN
18637	8676	9	confidential	confidential	JJ
18637	8676	10	communications	communication	NNS
18637	8676	11	from	from	IN
18637	8676	12	or	or	CC
18637	8676	13	to	to	IN
18637	8676	14	the	the	DT
18637	8676	15	President	President	NNP
18637	8676	16	,	,	,
18637	8676	17	that	that	RB
18637	8676	18	is	is	RB
18637	8676	19	,	,	,
18637	8676	20	communications	communication	NNS
18637	8676	21	which	which	WDT
18637	8676	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8676	23	choose	choose	VBP
18637	8676	24	to	to	TO
18637	8676	25	regard	regard	VB
18637	8676	26	as	as	IN
18637	8676	27	confidential	confidential	JJ
18637	8676	28	.	.	.
18637	8677	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8677	2	327	327	CD
18637	8677	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8677	4	Whether	whether	IN
18637	8677	5	a	a	DT
18637	8677	6	Congressional	Congressional	NNP
18637	8677	7	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	8677	8	of	of	IN
18637	8677	9	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	8677	10	would	would	MD
18637	8677	11	be	be	VB
18637	8677	12	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	8677	13	powerless	powerless	JJ
18637	8677	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8677	15	an	an	DT
18637	8677	16	interesting	interesting	JJ
18637	8677	17	question	question	NN
18637	8677	18	which	which	WDT
18637	8677	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	8677	20	not	not	RB
18637	8677	21	been	be	VBN
18637	8677	22	adjudicated	adjudicate	VBN
18637	8677	23	.	.	.
18637	8678	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8678	2	328	328	CD
18637	8678	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8678	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	8678	5	far	far	RB
18637	8678	6	such	such	JJ
18637	8678	7	issues	issue	NNS
18637	8678	8	between	between	IN
18637	8678	9	the	the	DT
18637	8678	10	two	two	CD
18637	8678	11	departments	department	NNS
18637	8678	12	have	have	VBP
18637	8678	13	been	be	VBN
18637	8678	14	adjusted	adjust	VBN
18637	8678	15	politically	politically	RB
18637	8678	16	.	.	.
18637	8679	1	Section	section	NN
18637	8679	2	3	3	CD
18637	8679	3	.	.	.
18637	8680	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8680	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	8680	3	from	from	IN
18637	8680	4	time	time	NN
18637	8680	5	to	to	IN
18637	8680	6	time	time	NN
18637	8680	7	give	give	VB
18637	8680	8	to	to	IN
18637	8680	9	the	the	DT
18637	8680	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8680	11	Information	Information	NNP
18637	8680	12	of	of	IN
18637	8680	13	the	the	DT
18637	8680	14	State	State	NNP
18637	8680	15	of	of	IN
18637	8680	16	the	the	DT
18637	8680	17	Union	Union	NNP
18637	8680	18	,	,	,
18637	8680	19	and	and	CC
18637	8680	20	recommend	recommend	VB
18637	8680	21	to	to	IN
18637	8680	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8680	23	Consideration	consideration	NN
18637	8680	24	such	such	JJ
18637	8680	25	Measures	measure	NNS
18637	8680	26	as	as	IN
18637	8680	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8680	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	8680	29	judge	judge	VB
18637	8680	30	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8680	31	and	and	CC
18637	8680	32	expedient	expedient	JJ
18637	8680	33	;	;	:
18637	8680	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8680	35	may	may	MD
18637	8680	36	,	,	,
18637	8680	37	on	on	IN
18637	8680	38	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	8680	39	Occasions	Occasions	NNP
18637	8680	40	,	,	,
18637	8680	41	convene	convene	VB
18637	8680	42	both	both	DT
18637	8680	43	Houses	house	NNS
18637	8680	44	,	,	,
18637	8680	45	or	or	CC
18637	8680	46	either	either	DT
18637	8680	47	of	of	IN
18637	8680	48	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8680	49	,	,	,
18637	8680	50	and	and	CC
18637	8680	51	in	in	IN
18637	8680	52	Case	case	NN
18637	8680	53	of	of	IN
18637	8680	54	Disagreement	Disagreement	NNP
18637	8680	55	between	between	IN
18637	8680	56	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8680	57	,	,	,
18637	8680	58	with	with	IN
18637	8680	59	Respect	respect	NN
18637	8680	60	to	to	IN
18637	8680	61	the	the	DT
18637	8680	62	Time	Time	NNP
18637	8680	63	of	of	IN
18637	8680	64	Adjournment	Adjournment	NNP
18637	8680	65	,	,	,
18637	8680	66	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8680	67	may	may	MD
18637	8680	68	adjourn	adjourn	VB
18637	8680	69	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8680	70	to	to	IN
18637	8680	71	such	such	JJ
18637	8680	72	Time	time	NN
18637	8680	73	as	as	IN
18637	8680	74	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8680	75	shall	shall	MD
18637	8680	76	think	think	VB
18637	8680	77	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8680	78	;	;	:
18637	8680	79	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8680	80	shall	shall	MD
18637	8680	81	receive	receive	VB
18637	8680	82	Ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	8680	83	and	and	CC
18637	8680	84	other	other	JJ
18637	8680	85	public	public	JJ
18637	8680	86	Ministers	minister	NNS
18637	8680	87	;	;	:
18637	8680	88	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8680	89	shall	shall	MD
18637	8680	90	take	take	VB
18637	8680	91	Care	care	NN
18637	8680	92	that	that	IN
18637	8680	93	the	the	DT
18637	8680	94	Laws	law	NNS
18637	8680	95	be	be	VB
18637	8680	96	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8680	97	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8680	98	,	,	,
18637	8680	99	and	and	CC
18637	8680	100	*	*	NFP
18637	8680	101	*	*	NFP
18637	8680	102	*	*	NFP
18637	8680	103	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	8680	104	Role	Role	NNP
18637	8680	105	of	of	IN
18637	8680	106	the	the	DT
18637	8680	107	President	President	NNP
18637	8680	108	The	the	DT
18637	8680	109	above	above	JJ
18637	8680	110	clause	clause	NN
18637	8680	111	,	,	,
18637	8680	112	which	which	WDT
18637	8680	113	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	8680	114	a	a	DT
18637	8680	115	duty	duty	NN
18637	8680	116	rather	rather	RB
18637	8680	117	than	than	IN
18637	8680	118	confers	confer	VBZ
18637	8680	119	a	a	DT
18637	8680	120	power	power	NN
18637	8680	121	,	,	,
18637	8680	122	is	be	VBZ
18637	8680	123	the	the	DT
18637	8680	124	formal	formal	JJ
18637	8680	125	basis	basis	NN
18637	8680	126	of	of	IN
18637	8680	127	the	the	DT
18637	8680	128	President	President	NNP
18637	8680	129	's	's	POS
18637	8680	130	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8680	131	leadership	leadership	NN
18637	8680	132	,	,	,
18637	8680	133	which	which	WDT
18637	8680	134	has	have	VBZ
18637	8680	135	attained	attain	VBN
18637	8680	136	great	great	JJ
18637	8680	137	proportions	proportion	NNS
18637	8680	138	since	since	IN
18637	8680	139	1900	1900	CD
18637	8680	140	.	.	.
18637	8681	1	This	this	DT
18637	8681	2	development	development	NN
18637	8681	3	,	,	,
18637	8681	4	however	however	RB
18637	8681	5	,	,	,
18637	8681	6	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	8681	7	the	the	DT
18637	8681	8	play	play	NN
18637	8681	9	of	of	IN
18637	8681	10	political	political	JJ
18637	8681	11	and	and	CC
18637	8681	12	social	social	JJ
18637	8681	13	forces	force	NNS
18637	8681	14	rather	rather	RB
18637	8681	15	than	than	IN
18637	8681	16	any	any	DT
18637	8681	17	pronounced	pronounced	JJ
18637	8681	18	change	change	NN
18637	8681	19	in	in	IN
18637	8681	20	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8681	21	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	8681	22	.	.	.
18637	8682	1	Especially	especially	RB
18637	8682	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8682	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8682	4	the	the	DT
18637	8682	5	result	result	NN
18637	8682	6	of	of	IN
18637	8682	7	the	the	DT
18637	8682	8	rise	rise	NN
18637	8682	9	of	of	IN
18637	8682	10	parties	party	NNS
18637	8682	11	and	and	CC
18637	8682	12	the	the	DT
18637	8682	13	accompanying	accompanying	JJ
18637	8682	14	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8682	15	of	of	IN
18637	8682	16	the	the	DT
18637	8682	17	President	President	NNP
18637	8682	18	as	as	IN
18637	8682	19	party	party	NN
18637	8682	20	leader	leader	NN
18637	8682	21	,	,	,
18637	8682	22	of	of	IN
18637	8682	23	the	the	DT
18637	8682	24	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	8682	25	of	of	IN
18637	8682	26	the	the	DT
18637	8682	27	National	National	NNP
18637	8682	28	Nominating	Nominating	NNP
18637	8682	29	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	8682	30	and	and	CC
18637	8682	31	the	the	DT
18637	8682	32	Party	Party	NNP
18637	8682	33	Platform	Platform	NNP
18637	8682	34	,	,	,
18637	8682	35	and	and	CC
18637	8682	36	of	of	IN
18637	8682	37	the	the	DT
18637	8682	38	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	8682	39	of	of	IN
18637	8682	40	the	the	DT
18637	8682	41	Spoils	Spoils	NNP
18637	8682	42	System	System	NNP
18637	8682	43	,	,	,
18637	8682	44	an	an	DT
18637	8682	45	ever	ever	RB
18637	8682	46	present	present	JJ
18637	8682	47	help	help	NN
18637	8682	48	to	to	IN
18637	8682	49	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	8682	50	in	in	IN
18637	8682	51	times	time	NNS
18637	8682	52	of	of	IN
18637	8682	53	troubled	troubled	JJ
18637	8682	54	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8682	55	with	with	IN
18637	8682	56	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8682	57	.	.	.
18637	8683	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8683	2	329	329	CD
18637	8683	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8683	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8683	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	8683	6	true	true	JJ
18637	8683	7	that	that	IN
18637	8683	8	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8683	9	pre	pre	JJ
18637	8683	10	-	-	JJ
18637	8683	11	Civil	civil	JJ
18637	8683	12	War	War	NNP
18637	8683	13	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	8683	14	,	,	,
18637	8683	15	mostly	mostly	RB
18637	8683	16	of	of	IN
18637	8683	17	Whig	Whig	NNP
18637	8683	18	extraction	extraction	NN
18637	8683	19	,	,	,
18637	8683	20	professed	profess	VBD
18637	8683	21	to	to	TO
18637	8683	22	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	8683	23	nice	nice	JJ
18637	8683	24	scruples	scruple	NNS
18637	8683	25	on	on	IN
18637	8683	26	the	the	DT
18637	8683	27	score	score	NN
18637	8683	28	of	of	IN
18637	8683	29	"	"	``
18637	8683	30	usurping	usurping	JJ
18637	8683	31	"	"	''
18637	8683	32	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8683	33	powers;[330	powers;[330	NNPS
18637	8683	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8683	35	but	but	CC
18637	8683	36	still	still	RB
18637	8683	37	earlier	early	JJR
18637	8683	38	ones	one	NNS
18637	8683	39	,	,	,
18637	8683	40	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	8683	41	,	,	,
18637	8683	42	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	8683	43	,	,	,
18637	8683	44	and	and	CC
18637	8683	45	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	8683	46	among	among	IN
18637	8683	47	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8683	48	,	,	,
18637	8683	49	took	take	VBD
18637	8683	50	a	a	DT
18637	8683	51	very	very	RB
18637	8683	52	different	different	JJ
18637	8683	53	line	line	NN
18637	8683	54	,	,	,
18637	8683	55	albeit	albeit	IN
18637	8683	56	less	less	RBR
18637	8683	57	boldly	boldly	RB
18637	8683	58	and	and	CC
18637	8683	59	persistently	persistently	RB
18637	8683	60	than	than	IN
18637	8683	61	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8683	62	later	later	JJ
18637	8683	63	imitators	imitator	NNS
18637	8683	64	.	.	.
18637	8684	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8684	2	331	331	CD
18637	8684	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8684	4	Today	today	NN
18637	8684	5	there	there	EX
18637	8684	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	8684	7	no	no	DT
18637	8684	8	subject	subject	NN
18637	8684	9	on	on	IN
18637	8684	10	which	which	WDT
18637	8684	11	the	the	DT
18637	8684	12	President	President	NNP
18637	8684	13	may	may	MD
18637	8684	14	not	not	RB
18637	8684	15	appropriately	appropriately	RB
18637	8684	16	communicate	communicate	VB
18637	8684	17	to	to	IN
18637	8684	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8684	19	,	,	,
18637	8684	20	in	in	IN
18637	8684	21	as	as	RB
18637	8684	22	precise	precise	JJ
18637	8684	23	terms	term	NNS
18637	8684	24	as	as	IN
18637	8684	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8684	26	chooses	choose	VBZ
18637	8684	27	,	,	,
18637	8684	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8684	29	conception	conception	NN
18637	8684	30	of	of	IN
18637	8684	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8684	32	duty	duty	NN
18637	8684	33	.	.	.
18637	8685	1	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	8685	2	,	,	,
18637	8685	3	the	the	DT
18637	8685	4	President	President	NNP
18637	8685	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	8685	6	not	not	RB
18637	8685	7	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	8685	8	by	by	IN
18637	8685	9	this	this	DT
18637	8685	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	8685	11	to	to	TO
18637	8685	12	impart	impart	VB
18637	8685	13	information	information	NN
18637	8685	14	which	which	WDT
18637	8685	15	,	,	,
18637	8685	16	in	in	IN
18637	8685	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8685	18	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8685	19	,	,	,
18637	8685	20	should	should	MD
18637	8685	21	in	in	IN
18637	8685	22	the	the	DT
18637	8685	23	public	public	JJ
18637	8685	24	interest	interest	NN
18637	8685	25	be	be	VB
18637	8685	26	withheld	withhold	VBN
18637	8685	27	.	.	.
18637	8686	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8686	2	332	332	CD
18637	8686	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8686	4	The	the	DT
18637	8686	5	President	President	NNP
18637	8686	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	8686	7	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	8686	8	summoned	summon	VBN
18637	8686	9	both	both	DT
18637	8686	10	Houses	house	NNS
18637	8686	11	into	into	IN
18637	8686	12	"	"	``
18637	8686	13	extra	extra	JJ
18637	8686	14	"	"	''
18637	8686	15	or	or	CC
18637	8686	16	"	"	``
18637	8686	17	special	special	JJ
18637	8686	18	sessions	session	NNS
18637	8686	19	"	"	''
18637	8686	20	for	for	IN
18637	8686	21	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8686	22	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	8686	23	,	,	,
18637	8686	24	and	and	CC
18637	8686	25	the	the	DT
18637	8686	26	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8686	27	alone	alone	RB
18637	8686	28	for	for	IN
18637	8686	29	the	the	DT
18637	8686	30	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	8686	31	of	of	IN
18637	8686	32	nominations	nomination	NNS
18637	8686	33	and	and	CC
18637	8686	34	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8686	35	.	.	.
18637	8687	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8687	2	power	power	NN
18637	8687	3	to	to	TO
18637	8687	4	adjourn	adjourn	VB
18637	8687	5	the	the	DT
18637	8687	6	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	8687	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	8687	8	never	never	RB
18637	8687	9	been	be	VBN
18637	8687	10	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	8687	11	.	.	.
18637	8688	1	The	the	DT
18637	8688	2	Right	Right	NNP
18637	8688	3	of	of	IN
18637	8688	4	Reception	reception	NN
18637	8688	5	SCOPE	SCOPE	NNP
18637	8688	6	OF	of	IN
18637	8688	7	THE	the	DT
18637	8688	8	POWER	POWER	NNP
18637	8688	9	"	"	``
18637	8688	10	Ambassadors	Ambassadors	NNPS
18637	8688	11	and	and	CC
18637	8688	12	other	other	JJ
18637	8688	13	public	public	JJ
18637	8688	14	ministers	minister	NNS
18637	8688	15	"	"	''
18637	8688	16	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	8688	17	not	not	RB
18637	8688	18	only	only	RB
18637	8688	19	"	"	``
18637	8688	20	all	all	DT
18637	8688	21	possible	possible	JJ
18637	8688	22	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8688	23	agents	agent	NNS
18637	8688	24	which	which	WDT
18637	8688	25	any	any	DT
18637	8688	26	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8688	27	power	power	NN
18637	8688	28	may	may	MD
18637	8688	29	accredit	accredit	VB
18637	8688	30	to	to	IN
18637	8688	31	the	the	DT
18637	8688	32	United	United	NNP
18637	8688	33	States"[333	States"[333	NNP
18637	8688	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8688	35	but	but	CC
18637	8688	36	also	also	RB
18637	8688	37	,	,	,
18637	8688	38	as	as	IN
18637	8688	39	a	a	DT
18637	8688	40	practical	practical	JJ
18637	8688	41	construction	construction	NN
18637	8688	42	of	of	IN
18637	8688	43	the	the	DT
18637	8688	44	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8688	45	,	,	,
18637	8688	46	all	all	DT
18637	8688	47	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8688	48	consular	consular	JJ
18637	8688	49	agents	agent	NNS
18637	8688	50	,	,	,
18637	8688	51	who	who	WP
18637	8688	52	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8688	53	may	may	MD
18637	8688	54	not	not	RB
18637	8688	55	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	8688	56	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8688	57	functions	function	NNS
18637	8688	58	in	in	IN
18637	8688	59	the	the	DT
18637	8688	60	United	United	NNP
18637	8688	61	States	States	NNP
18637	8688	62	without	without	IN
18637	8688	63	an	an	DT
18637	8688	64	exequatur	exequatur	NN
18637	8688	65	from	from	IN
18637	8688	66	the	the	DT
18637	8688	67	President	President	NNP
18637	8688	68	.	.	.
18637	8689	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8689	2	334	334	CD
18637	8689	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8689	4	The	the	DT
18637	8689	5	power	power	NN
18637	8689	6	to	to	TO
18637	8689	7	"	"	``
18637	8689	8	receive	receive	VB
18637	8689	9	"	"	''
18637	8689	10	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	8689	11	,	,	,
18637	8689	12	etc	etc	FW
18637	8689	13	.	.	FW
18637	8689	14	,	,	,
18637	8689	15	includes	include	VBZ
18637	8689	16	,	,	,
18637	8689	17	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	8689	18	,	,	,
18637	8689	19	the	the	DT
18637	8689	20	right	right	NN
18637	8689	21	to	to	TO
18637	8689	22	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	8689	23	to	to	TO
18637	8689	24	receive	receive	VB
18637	8689	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8689	26	,	,	,
18637	8689	27	to	to	TO
18637	8689	28	request	request	VB
18637	8689	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8689	30	recall	recall	NN
18637	8689	31	,	,	,
18637	8689	32	to	to	TO
18637	8689	33	dismiss	dismiss	VB
18637	8689	34	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8689	35	,	,	,
18637	8689	36	and	and	CC
18637	8689	37	to	to	TO
18637	8689	38	determine	determine	VB
18637	8689	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8689	40	eligibility	eligibility	NN
18637	8689	41	under	under	IN
18637	8689	42	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8689	43	laws	law	NNS
18637	8689	44	.	.	.
18637	8690	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8690	2	335	335	CD
18637	8690	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8690	4	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	8690	5	,	,	,
18637	8690	6	this	this	DT
18637	8690	7	power	power	NN
18637	8690	8	makes	make	VBZ
18637	8690	9	the	the	DT
18637	8690	10	President	President	NNP
18637	8690	11	the	the	DT
18637	8690	12	sole	sole	JJ
18637	8690	13	mouthpiece	mouthpiece	NN
18637	8690	14	of	of	IN
18637	8690	15	the	the	DT
18637	8690	16	nation	nation	NN
18637	8690	17	in	in	IN
18637	8690	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8690	19	dealings	dealing	NNS
18637	8690	20	with	with	IN
18637	8690	21	other	other	JJ
18637	8690	22	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8690	23	.	.	.
18637	8691	1	A	a	DT
18637	8691	2	PRESIDENTIAL	presidential	JJ
18637	8691	3	MONOPOLY	MONOPOLY	NNS
18637	8691	4	Wrote	write	VBD
18637	8691	5	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	8691	6	in	in	IN
18637	8691	7	1790	1790	CD
18637	8691	8	:	:	:
18637	8691	9	"	"	``
18637	8691	10	The	the	DT
18637	8691	11	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	8691	12	of	of	IN
18637	8691	13	business	business	NN
18637	8691	14	with	with	IN
18637	8691	15	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8691	16	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8691	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	8691	18	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8691	19	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	8691	20	.	.	.
18637	8692	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8692	2	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	8692	3	,	,	,
18637	8692	4	then	then	RB
18637	8692	5	,	,	,
18637	8692	6	to	to	IN
18637	8692	7	the	the	DT
18637	8692	8	head	head	NN
18637	8692	9	of	of	IN
18637	8692	10	that	that	DT
18637	8692	11	department	department	NN
18637	8692	12	,	,	,
18637	8692	13	except	except	IN
18637	8692	14	as	as	IN
18637	8692	15	to	to	IN
18637	8692	16	such	such	JJ
18637	8692	17	portions	portion	NNS
18637	8692	18	of	of	IN
18637	8692	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8692	20	as	as	IN
18637	8692	21	are	be	VBP
18637	8692	22	specially	specially	RB
18637	8692	23	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	8692	24	to	to	IN
18637	8692	25	the	the	DT
18637	8692	26	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8692	27	.	.	.
18637	8693	1	Exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	8693	2	are	be	VBP
18637	8693	3	to	to	TO
18637	8693	4	be	be	VB
18637	8693	5	construed	construe	VBN
18637	8693	6	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	8693	7	.	.	.
18637	8694	1	"	"	``
18637	8694	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8694	3	336	336	CD
18637	8694	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8694	5	So	so	RB
18637	8694	6	when	when	WRB
18637	8694	7	Citizen	Citizen	NNP
18637	8694	8	Genet	Genet	NNP
18637	8694	9	,	,	,
18637	8694	10	envoy	envoy	NN
18637	8694	11	to	to	IN
18637	8694	12	the	the	DT
18637	8694	13	United	United	NNP
18637	8694	14	States	States	NNP
18637	8694	15	from	from	IN
18637	8694	16	the	the	DT
18637	8694	17	first	first	JJ
18637	8694	18	French	French	NNP
18637	8694	19	Republic	Republic	NNP
18637	8694	20	,	,	,
18637	8694	21	sought	seek	VBD
18637	8694	22	an	an	DT
18637	8694	23	exequatur	exequatur	NN
18637	8694	24	for	for	IN
18637	8694	25	a	a	DT
18637	8694	26	consul	consul	NN
18637	8694	27	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8694	28	commission	commission	NN
18637	8694	29	was	be	VBD
18637	8694	30	addressed	address	VBN
18637	8694	31	to	to	IN
18637	8694	32	the	the	DT
18637	8694	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8694	34	of	of	IN
18637	8694	35	the	the	DT
18637	8694	36	United	United	NNP
18637	8694	37	States	States	NNP
18637	8694	38	,	,	,
18637	8694	39	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	8694	40	informed	inform	VBD
18637	8694	41	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8694	42	that	that	IN
18637	8694	43	"	"	``
18637	8694	44	as	as	IN
18637	8694	45	the	the	DT
18637	8694	46	President	President	NNP
18637	8694	47	was	be	VBD
18637	8694	48	the	the	DT
18637	8694	49	only	only	JJ
18637	8694	50	channel	channel	NN
18637	8694	51	of	of	IN
18637	8694	52	communication	communication	NN
18637	8694	53	between	between	IN
18637	8694	54	the	the	DT
18637	8694	55	United	United	NNP
18637	8694	56	States	States	NNP
18637	8694	57	and	and	CC
18637	8694	58	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8694	59	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8694	60	,	,	,
18637	8694	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8694	62	was	be	VBD
18637	8694	63	from	from	IN
18637	8694	64	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8694	65	alone	alone	RB
18637	8694	66	'	'	''
18637	8694	67	that	that	IN
18637	8694	68	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8694	69	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8694	70	or	or	CC
18637	8694	71	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8694	72	agents	agent	NNS
18637	8694	73	are	be	VBP
18637	8694	74	to	to	TO
18637	8694	75	learn	learn	VB
18637	8694	76	what	what	WP
18637	8694	77	is	be	VBZ
18637	8694	78	or	or	CC
18637	8694	79	has	have	VBZ
18637	8694	80	been	be	VBN
18637	8694	81	the	the	DT
18637	8694	82	will	will	NN
18637	8694	83	of	of	IN
18637	8694	84	the	the	DT
18637	8694	85	nation	nation	NN
18637	8694	86	;	;	:
18637	8694	87	'	'	''
18637	8694	88	that	that	IN
18637	8694	89	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	8694	90	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8694	91	communicated	communicate	VBD
18637	8694	92	as	as	IN
18637	8694	93	such	such	JJ
18637	8694	94	,	,	,
18637	8694	95	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8694	96	had	have	VBD
18637	8694	97	a	a	DT
18637	8694	98	right	right	NN
18637	8694	99	and	and	CC
18637	8694	100	were	be	VBD
18637	8694	101	bound	bind	VBN
18637	8694	102	to	to	TO
18637	8694	103	consider	consider	VB
18637	8694	104	'	'	''
18637	8694	105	as	as	IN
18637	8694	106	the	the	DT
18637	8694	107	expression	expression	NN
18637	8694	108	of	of	IN
18637	8694	109	the	the	DT
18637	8694	110	nation	nation	NN
18637	8694	111	;	;	,
18637	8694	112	'	'	''
18637	8694	113	and	and	CC
18637	8694	114	that	that	IN
18637	8694	115	no	no	DT
18637	8694	116	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8694	117	agent	agent	NN
18637	8694	118	could	could	MD
18637	8694	119	be	be	VB
18637	8694	120	'	'	``
18637	8694	121	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	8694	122	to	to	TO
18637	8694	123	question	question	VB
18637	8694	124	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8694	125	,	,	,
18637	8694	126	'	'	''
18637	8694	127	or	or	CC
18637	8694	128	'	'	``
18637	8694	129	to	to	TO
18637	8694	130	interpose	interpose	VB
18637	8694	131	between	between	IN
18637	8694	132	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8694	133	and	and	CC
18637	8694	134	any	any	DT
18637	8694	135	other	other	JJ
18637	8694	136	branch	branch	NN
18637	8694	137	of	of	IN
18637	8694	138	government	government	NN
18637	8694	139	,	,	,
18637	8694	140	under	under	IN
18637	8694	141	the	the	DT
18637	8694	142	pretext	pretext	NN
18637	8694	143	of	of	IN
18637	8694	144	either	either	CC
18637	8694	145	's	's	POS
18637	8694	146	transgressing	transgress	VBG
18637	8694	147	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8694	148	functions	function	NNS
18637	8694	149	.	.	.
18637	8694	150	'	'	''
18637	8695	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	8695	2	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	8695	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8695	4	declined	decline	VBD
18637	8695	5	to	to	TO
18637	8695	6	enter	enter	VB
18637	8695	7	into	into	IN
18637	8695	8	any	any	DT
18637	8695	9	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	8695	10	of	of	IN
18637	8695	11	the	the	DT
18637	8695	12	question	question	NN
18637	8695	13	as	as	IN
18637	8695	14	to	to	IN
18637	8695	15	whether	whether	IN
18637	8695	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8695	17	belonged	belong	VBD
18637	8695	18	to	to	IN
18637	8695	19	the	the	DT
18637	8695	20	President	President	NNP
18637	8695	21	under	under	IN
18637	8695	22	the	the	DT
18637	8695	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8695	24	to	to	TO
18637	8695	25	admit	admit	VB
18637	8695	26	or	or	CC
18637	8695	27	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	8695	28	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8695	29	agents	agent	NNS
18637	8695	30	.	.	.
18637	8696	1	'	'	``
18637	8696	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8696	3	inform	inform	VBP
18637	8696	4	you	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8696	5	of	of	IN
18637	8696	6	the	the	DT
18637	8696	7	fact	fact	NN
18637	8696	8	,	,	,
18637	8696	9	'	'	''
18637	8696	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8696	11	said	say	VBD
18637	8696	12	,	,	,
18637	8696	13	'	'	''
18637	8696	14	by	by	IN
18637	8696	15	authority	authority	NN
18637	8696	16	from	from	IN
18637	8696	17	the	the	DT
18637	8696	18	President	President	NNP
18637	8696	19	.	.	.
18637	8696	20	'	'	''
18637	8697	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	8697	2	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	8697	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8697	4	returned	return	VBD
18637	8697	5	the	the	DT
18637	8697	6	consul	consul	NN
18637	8697	7	's	's	POS
18637	8697	8	commission	commission	NN
18637	8697	9	and	and	CC
18637	8697	10	declared	declare	VBD
18637	8697	11	that	that	IN
18637	8697	12	the	the	DT
18637	8697	13	President	President	NNP
18637	8697	14	would	would	MD
18637	8697	15	issue	issue	VB
18637	8697	16	no	no	DT
18637	8697	17	exequatur	exequatur	NN
18637	8697	18	to	to	IN
18637	8697	19	a	a	DT
18637	8697	20	consul	consul	NN
18637	8697	21	except	except	IN
18637	8697	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	8697	23	a	a	DT
18637	8697	24	commission	commission	NN
18637	8697	25	correctly	correctly	RB
18637	8697	26	addressed	address	VBD
18637	8697	27	.	.	.
18637	8698	1	"	"	``
18637	8698	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8698	3	337	337	CD
18637	8698	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8698	5	"	"	``
18637	8698	6	THE	the	DT
18637	8698	7	LOGAN	LOGAN	NNP
18637	8698	8	ACT	ACT	NNP
18637	8698	9	"	"	``
18637	8698	10	When	when	WRB
18637	8698	11	in	in	IN
18637	8698	12	1798	1798	CD
18637	8698	13	a	a	DT
18637	8698	14	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	8698	15	Quaker	Quaker	NNP
18637	8698	16	named	name	VBN
18637	8698	17	Logan	Logan	NNP
18637	8698	18	went	go	VBD
18637	8698	19	to	to	IN
18637	8698	20	Paris	Paris	NNP
18637	8698	21	on	on	IN
18637	8698	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8698	23	own	own	JJ
18637	8698	24	to	to	TO
18637	8698	25	undertake	undertake	VB
18637	8698	26	a	a	DT
18637	8698	27	negotiation	negotiation	NN
18637	8698	28	with	with	IN
18637	8698	29	the	the	DT
18637	8698	30	French	french	JJ
18637	8698	31	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8698	32	with	with	IN
18637	8698	33	a	a	DT
18637	8698	34	view	view	NN
18637	8698	35	to	to	IN
18637	8698	36	averting	avert	VBG
18637	8698	37	war	war	NN
18637	8698	38	between	between	IN
18637	8698	39	France	France	NNP
18637	8698	40	and	and	CC
18637	8698	41	the	the	DT
18637	8698	42	United	United	NNP
18637	8698	43	States	States	NNP
18637	8698	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8698	45	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	8698	46	stimulated	stimulate	VBD
18637	8698	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8698	48	to	to	TO
18637	8698	49	pass	pass	VB
18637	8698	50	"	"	``
18637	8698	51	An	an	DT
18637	8698	52	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8698	53	to	to	TO
18637	8698	54	Prevent	prevent	VB
18637	8698	55	Usurpation	Usurpation	NNP
18637	8698	56	of	of	IN
18637	8698	57	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8698	58	Functions,"[338	functions,"[338	NN
18637	8698	59	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8698	60	which	which	WDT
18637	8698	61	,	,	,
18637	8698	62	"	"	``
18637	8698	63	more	more	RBR
18637	8698	64	honored	honor	VBN
18637	8698	65	in	in	IN
18637	8698	66	the	the	DT
18637	8698	67	breach	breach	NN
18637	8698	68	than	than	IN
18637	8698	69	the	the	DT
18637	8698	70	observance	observance	NN
18637	8698	71	,	,	,
18637	8698	72	"	"	''
18637	8698	73	still	still	RB
18637	8698	74	survives	survive	VBZ
18637	8698	75	on	on	IN
18637	8698	76	the	the	DT
18637	8698	77	statute	statute	NN
18637	8698	78	books	book	NNS
18637	8698	79	.	.	.
18637	8699	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8699	2	339	339	CD
18637	8699	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8699	4	The	the	DT
18637	8699	5	year	year	NN
18637	8699	6	following	follow	VBG
18637	8699	7	John	John	NNP
18637	8699	8	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	8699	9	,	,	,
18637	8699	10	then	then	RB
18637	8699	11	a	a	DT
18637	8699	12	Member	Member	NNP
18637	8699	13	of	of	IN
18637	8699	14	the	the	DT
18637	8699	15	House	House	NNP
18637	8699	16	of	of	IN
18637	8699	17	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	8699	18	,	,	,
18637	8699	19	defended	defend	VBD
18637	8699	20	President	President	NNP
18637	8699	21	John	John	NNP
18637	8699	22	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	8699	23	for	for	IN
18637	8699	24	delivering	deliver	VBG
18637	8699	25	a	a	DT
18637	8699	26	fugitive	fugitive	NN
18637	8699	27	from	from	IN
18637	8699	28	justice	justice	NN
18637	8699	29	to	to	IN
18637	8699	30	Great	Great	NNP
18637	8699	31	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	8699	32	under	under	IN
18637	8699	33	the	the	DT
18637	8699	34	27th	27th	JJ
18637	8699	35	article	article	NN
18637	8699	36	of	of	IN
18637	8699	37	the	the	DT
18637	8699	38	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	8699	39	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	8699	40	,	,	,
18637	8699	41	instead	instead	RB
18637	8699	42	of	of	IN
18637	8699	43	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	8699	44	the	the	DT
18637	8699	45	business	business	NN
18637	8699	46	to	to	IN
18637	8699	47	the	the	DT
18637	8699	48	courts	court	NNS
18637	8699	49	.	.	.
18637	8700	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8700	2	said	say	VBD
18637	8700	3	:	:	:
18637	8700	4	"	"	``
18637	8700	5	The	the	DT
18637	8700	6	President	President	NNP
18637	8700	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	8700	8	the	the	DT
18637	8700	9	sole	sole	JJ
18637	8700	10	organ	organ	NN
18637	8700	11	of	of	IN
18637	8700	12	the	the	DT
18637	8700	13	nation	nation	NN
18637	8700	14	in	in	IN
18637	8700	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8700	16	external	external	JJ
18637	8700	17	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8700	18	,	,	,
18637	8700	19	and	and	CC
18637	8700	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8700	21	sole	sole	JJ
18637	8700	22	representative	representative	NN
18637	8700	23	with	with	IN
18637	8700	24	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8700	25	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8700	26	.	.	.
18637	8701	1	Of	of	IN
18637	8701	2	consequence	consequence	NNP
18637	8701	3	,	,	,
18637	8701	4	the	the	DT
18637	8701	5	demand	demand	NN
18637	8701	6	of	of	IN
18637	8701	7	a	a	DT
18637	8701	8	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8701	9	nation	nation	NN
18637	8701	10	can	can	MD
18637	8701	11	only	only	RB
18637	8701	12	be	be	VB
18637	8701	13	made	make	VBN
18637	8701	14	on	on	IN
18637	8701	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8701	16	.	.	.
18637	8702	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8702	2	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	8702	3	the	the	DT
18637	8702	4	whole	whole	JJ
18637	8702	5	Executive	executive	JJ
18637	8702	6	power	power	NN
18637	8702	7	.	.	.
18637	8703	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8703	2	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	8703	3	and	and	CC
18637	8703	4	directs	direct	VBZ
18637	8703	5	the	the	DT
18637	8703	6	force	force	NN
18637	8703	7	of	of	IN
18637	8703	8	the	the	DT
18637	8703	9	nation	nation	NN
18637	8703	10	.	.	.
18637	8704	1	Of	of	IN
18637	8704	2	consequence	consequence	NNP
18637	8704	3	,	,	,
18637	8704	4	any	any	DT
18637	8704	5	act	act	NN
18637	8704	6	to	to	TO
18637	8704	7	be	be	VB
18637	8704	8	performed	perform	VBN
18637	8704	9	by	by	IN
18637	8704	10	the	the	DT
18637	8704	11	force	force	NN
18637	8704	12	of	of	IN
18637	8704	13	the	the	DT
18637	8704	14	nation	nation	NN
18637	8704	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	8704	16	to	to	TO
18637	8704	17	be	be	VB
18637	8704	18	performed	perform	VBN
18637	8704	19	through	through	IN
18637	8704	20	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8704	21	.	.	.
18637	8705	1	"	"	``
18637	8705	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8705	3	340	340	CD
18637	8705	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8705	5	Ninety	ninety	CD
18637	8705	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	8705	7	nine	nine	CD
18637	8705	8	years	year	NNS
18637	8705	9	later	later	RB
18637	8705	10	a	a	DT
18637	8705	11	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8705	12	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	8705	13	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	8705	14	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	8705	15	took	take	VBD
18637	8705	16	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	8705	17	to	to	TO
18637	8705	18	reiterate	reiterate	VB
18637	8705	19	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	8705	20	's	's	POS
18637	8705	21	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	8705	22	with	with	IN
18637	8705	23	elaboration	elaboration	NN
18637	8705	24	.	.	.
18637	8706	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8706	2	341	341	CD
18637	8706	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8706	4	A	A	NNP
18637	8706	5	FORMAL	formal	NN
18637	8706	6	OR	or	CC
18637	8706	7	A	a	DT
18637	8706	8	FORMATIVE	formative	JJ
18637	8706	9	POWER	power	NN
18637	8706	10	?	?	.
18637	8707	1	In	in	IN
18637	8707	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8707	3	attack	attack	NN
18637	8707	4	,	,	,
18637	8707	5	instigated	instigate	VBN
18637	8707	6	by	by	IN
18637	8707	7	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	8707	8	,	,	,
18637	8707	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	8707	10	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	8707	11	's	's	POS
18637	8707	12	Proclamation	Proclamation	NNP
18637	8707	13	of	of	IN
18637	8707	14	Neutrality	Neutrality	NNP
18637	8707	15	in	in	IN
18637	8707	16	1793	1793	CD
18637	8707	17	,	,	,
18637	8707	18	at	at	IN
18637	8707	19	the	the	DT
18637	8707	20	outbreak	outbreak	NN
18637	8707	21	of	of	IN
18637	8707	22	war	war	NN
18637	8707	23	between	between	IN
18637	8707	24	France	France	NNP
18637	8707	25	and	and	CC
18637	8707	26	Great	Great	NNP
18637	8707	27	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	8707	28	,	,	,
18637	8707	29	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8707	30	advanced	advance	VBD
18637	8707	31	the	the	DT
18637	8707	32	argument	argument	NN
18637	8707	33	that	that	IN
18637	8707	34	all	all	DT
18637	8707	35	large	large	JJ
18637	8707	36	questions	question	NNS
18637	8707	37	of	of	IN
18637	8707	38	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8707	39	policy	policy	NN
18637	8707	40	fell	fall	VBD
18637	8707	41	within	within	IN
18637	8707	42	the	the	DT
18637	8707	43	ambit	ambit	NN
18637	8707	44	of	of	IN
18637	8707	45	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8707	46	,	,	,
18637	8707	47	by	by	IN
18637	8707	48	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	8707	49	of	of	IN
18637	8707	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8707	51	power	power	NN
18637	8707	52	"	"	''
18637	8707	53	to	to	TO
18637	8707	54	declare	declare	VB
18637	8707	55	war	war	NN
18637	8707	56	,	,	,
18637	8707	57	"	"	''
18637	8707	58	and	and	CC
18637	8707	59	in	in	IN
18637	8707	60	support	support	NN
18637	8707	61	of	of	IN
18637	8707	62	this	this	DT
18637	8707	63	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	8707	64	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8707	65	disparaged	disparage	VBD
18637	8707	66	the	the	DT
18637	8707	67	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8707	68	function	function	NN
18637	8707	69	of	of	IN
18637	8707	70	reception	reception	NN
18637	8707	71	,	,	,
18637	8707	72	in	in	IN
18637	8707	73	the	the	DT
18637	8707	74	following	follow	VBG
18637	8707	75	words	word	NNS
18637	8707	76	:	:	:
18637	8707	77	"	"	``
18637	8707	78	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8707	79	shall	shall	MD
18637	8707	80	not	not	RB
18637	8707	81	undertake	undertake	VB
18637	8707	82	to	to	TO
18637	8707	83	examine	examine	VB
18637	8707	84	,	,	,
18637	8707	85	what	what	WP
18637	8707	86	would	would	MD
18637	8707	87	be	be	VB
18637	8707	88	the	the	DT
18637	8707	89	precise	precise	JJ
18637	8707	90	extent	extent	NN
18637	8707	91	and	and	CC
18637	8707	92	effect	effect	NN
18637	8707	93	of	of	IN
18637	8707	94	this	this	DT
18637	8707	95	function	function	NN
18637	8707	96	in	in	IN
18637	8707	97	various	various	JJ
18637	8707	98	cases	case	NNS
18637	8707	99	which	which	WDT
18637	8707	100	fancy	fancy	JJ
18637	8707	101	may	may	MD
18637	8707	102	suggest	suggest	VB
18637	8707	103	,	,	,
18637	8707	104	or	or	CC
18637	8707	105	which	which	WDT
18637	8707	106	time	time	NN
18637	8707	107	may	may	MD
18637	8707	108	produce	produce	VB
18637	8707	109	.	.	.
18637	8708	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8708	2	will	will	MD
18637	8708	3	be	be	VB
18637	8708	4	more	more	RBR
18637	8708	5	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8708	6	to	to	TO
18637	8708	7	observe	observe	VB
18637	8708	8	,	,	,
18637	8708	9	in	in	IN
18637	8708	10	general	general	JJ
18637	8708	11	,	,	,
18637	8708	12	and	and	CC
18637	8708	13	every	every	DT
18637	8708	14	candid	candid	JJ
18637	8708	15	reader	reader	NN
18637	8708	16	will	will	MD
18637	8708	17	second	second	VB
18637	8708	18	the	the	DT
18637	8708	19	observation	observation	NN
18637	8708	20	,	,	,
18637	8708	21	that	that	DT
18637	8708	22	little	little	JJ
18637	8708	23	,	,	,
18637	8708	24	if	if	IN
18637	8708	25	anything	anything	NN
18637	8708	26	,	,	,
18637	8708	27	more	more	RBR
18637	8708	28	was	be	VBD
18637	8708	29	intended	intend	VBN
18637	8708	30	by	by	IN
18637	8708	31	the	the	DT
18637	8708	32	clause	clause	NN
18637	8708	33	,	,	,
18637	8708	34	than	than	IN
18637	8708	35	to	to	TO
18637	8708	36	provide	provide	VB
18637	8708	37	for	for	IN
18637	8708	38	a	a	DT
18637	8708	39	particular	particular	JJ
18637	8708	40	mode	mode	NN
18637	8708	41	of	of	IN
18637	8708	42	communication	communication	NN
18637	8708	43	,	,	,
18637	8708	44	_	_	NNP
18637	8708	45	almost	almost	RB
18637	8708	46	_	_	NNP
18637	8708	47	grown	grow	VBD
18637	8708	48	into	into	IN
18637	8708	49	a	a	DT
18637	8708	50	right	right	NN
18637	8708	51	among	among	IN
18637	8708	52	modern	modern	JJ
18637	8708	53	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8708	54	;	;	:
18637	8708	55	by	by	IN
18637	8708	56	pointing	point	VBG
18637	8708	57	out	out	RP
18637	8708	58	the	the	DT
18637	8708	59	department	department	NN
18637	8708	60	of	of	IN
18637	8708	61	the	the	DT
18637	8708	62	government	government	NN
18637	8708	63	,	,	,
18637	8708	64	most	most	RBS
18637	8708	65	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8708	66	for	for	IN
18637	8708	67	the	the	DT
18637	8708	68	ceremony	ceremony	NN
18637	8708	69	of	of	IN
18637	8708	70	admitting	admit	VBG
18637	8708	71	public	public	JJ
18637	8708	72	ministers	minister	NNS
18637	8708	73	,	,	,
18637	8708	74	of	of	IN
18637	8708	75	examining	examine	VBG
18637	8708	76	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8708	77	credentials	credential	NNS
18637	8708	78	,	,	,
18637	8708	79	and	and	CC
18637	8708	80	of	of	IN
18637	8708	81	authenticating	authenticate	VBG
18637	8708	82	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8708	83	title	title	NN
18637	8708	84	to	to	IN
18637	8708	85	the	the	DT
18637	8708	86	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	8708	87	annexed	annex	VBN
18637	8708	88	to	to	IN
18637	8708	89	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8708	90	character	character	NN
18637	8708	91	by	by	IN
18637	8708	92	the	the	DT
18637	8708	93	law	law	NN
18637	8708	94	of	of	IN
18637	8708	95	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8708	96	.	.	.
18637	8709	1	This	this	DT
18637	8709	2	being	be	VBG
18637	8709	3	the	the	DT
18637	8709	4	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	8709	5	design	design	NN
18637	8709	6	of	of	IN
18637	8709	7	the	the	DT
18637	8709	8	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	8709	9	,	,	,
18637	8709	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8709	11	would	would	MD
18637	8709	12	be	be	VB
18637	8709	13	highly	highly	RB
18637	8709	14	improper	improper	JJ
18637	8709	15	to	to	TO
18637	8709	16	magnify	magnify	VB
18637	8709	17	the	the	DT
18637	8709	18	function	function	NN
18637	8709	19	into	into	IN
18637	8709	20	an	an	DT
18637	8709	21	important	important	JJ
18637	8709	22	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	8709	23	,	,	,
18637	8709	24	even	even	RB
18637	8709	25	when	when	WRB
18637	8709	26	no	no	DT
18637	8709	27	rights	right	NNS
18637	8709	28	of	of	IN
18637	8709	29	other	other	JJ
18637	8709	30	departments	department	NNS
18637	8709	31	could	could	MD
18637	8709	32	be	be	VB
18637	8709	33	affected	affect	VBN
18637	8709	34	by	by	IN
18637	8709	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8709	36	.	.	.
18637	8710	1	"	"	``
18637	8710	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8710	3	342	342	CD
18637	8710	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8710	5	THE	the	DT
18637	8710	6	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	8710	7	'S	's	POS
18637	8710	8	DIPLOMATIC	DIPLOMATIC	NNP
18637	8710	9	ROLE	ROLE	NNP
18637	8710	10	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	8710	11	,	,	,
18637	8710	12	although	although	IN
18637	8710	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8710	14	had	have	VBD
18637	8710	15	expressed	express	VBN
18637	8710	16	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	8710	17	the	the	DT
18637	8710	18	same	same	JJ
18637	8710	19	view	view	NN
18637	8710	20	in	in	IN
18637	8710	21	The	the	DT
18637	8710	22	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	8710	23	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	8710	24	the	the	DT
18637	8710	25	power	power	NN
18637	8710	26	of	of	IN
18637	8710	27	reception,[343	reception,[343	NN
18637	8710	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8710	29	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	8710	30	a	a	DT
18637	8710	31	very	very	RB
18637	8710	32	different	different	JJ
18637	8710	33	conception	conception	NN
18637	8710	34	of	of	IN
18637	8710	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8710	36	in	in	IN
18637	8710	37	defense	defense	NN
18637	8710	38	of	of	IN
18637	8710	39	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	8710	40	's	's	POS
18637	8710	41	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	8710	42	.	.	.
18637	8711	1	Writing	write	VBG
18637	8711	2	over	over	IN
18637	8711	3	the	the	DT
18637	8711	4	pseudonym	pseudonym	NN
18637	8711	5	"	"	``
18637	8711	6	Pacificus	Pacificus	NNP
18637	8711	7	,	,	,
18637	8711	8	"	"	''
18637	8711	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8711	10	said	say	VBD
18637	8711	11	:	:	:
18637	8711	12	"	"	``
18637	8711	13	The	the	DT
18637	8711	14	right	right	NN
18637	8711	15	of	of	IN
18637	8711	16	the	the	DT
18637	8711	17	executive	executive	NN
18637	8711	18	to	to	TO
18637	8711	19	receive	receive	VB
18637	8711	20	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	8711	21	and	and	CC
18637	8711	22	other	other	JJ
18637	8711	23	public	public	JJ
18637	8711	24	ministers	minister	NNS
18637	8711	25	,	,	,
18637	8711	26	may	may	MD
18637	8711	27	serve	serve	VB
18637	8711	28	to	to	TO
18637	8711	29	illustrate	illustrate	VB
18637	8711	30	the	the	DT
18637	8711	31	relative	relative	JJ
18637	8711	32	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8711	33	of	of	IN
18637	8711	34	the	the	DT
18637	8711	35	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8711	36	and	and	CC
18637	8711	37	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8711	38	departments	department	NNS
18637	8711	39	.	.	.
18637	8712	1	This	this	DT
18637	8712	2	right	right	NN
18637	8712	3	includes	include	VBZ
18637	8712	4	that	that	DT
18637	8712	5	of	of	IN
18637	8712	6	judging	judging	NN
18637	8712	7	,	,	,
18637	8712	8	in	in	IN
18637	8712	9	the	the	DT
18637	8712	10	case	case	NN
18637	8712	11	of	of	IN
18637	8712	12	a	a	DT
18637	8712	13	revolution	revolution	NN
18637	8712	14	of	of	IN
18637	8712	15	government	government	NN
18637	8712	16	in	in	IN
18637	8712	17	a	a	DT
18637	8712	18	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8712	19	country	country	NN
18637	8712	20	,	,	,
18637	8712	21	whether	whether	IN
18637	8712	22	the	the	DT
18637	8712	23	new	new	JJ
18637	8712	24	rulers	ruler	NNS
18637	8712	25	are	be	VBP
18637	8712	26	competent	competent	JJ
18637	8712	27	organs	organ	NNS
18637	8712	28	of	of	IN
18637	8712	29	the	the	DT
18637	8712	30	national	national	JJ
18637	8712	31	will	will	NN
18637	8712	32	,	,	,
18637	8712	33	and	and	CC
18637	8712	34	ought	ought	MD
18637	8712	35	to	to	TO
18637	8712	36	be	be	VB
18637	8712	37	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	8712	38	,	,	,
18637	8712	39	or	or	CC
18637	8712	40	not	not	RB
18637	8712	41	;	;	:
18637	8712	42	which	which	WDT
18637	8712	43	,	,	,
18637	8712	44	where	where	WRB
18637	8712	45	a	a	DT
18637	8712	46	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8712	47	antecedently	antecedently	RB
18637	8712	48	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	8712	49	between	between	IN
18637	8712	50	the	the	DT
18637	8712	51	United	United	NNP
18637	8712	52	States	States	NNP
18637	8712	53	and	and	CC
18637	8712	54	such	such	JJ
18637	8712	55	nation	nation	NN
18637	8712	56	,	,	,
18637	8712	57	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	8712	58	the	the	DT
18637	8712	59	power	power	NN
18637	8712	60	of	of	IN
18637	8712	61	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	8712	62	or	or	CC
18637	8712	63	suspending	suspend	VBG
18637	8712	64	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8712	65	operation	operation	NN
18637	8712	66	.	.	.
18637	8713	1	For	for	IN
18637	8713	2	until	until	IN
18637	8713	3	the	the	DT
18637	8713	4	new	new	JJ
18637	8713	5	government	government	NN
18637	8713	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	8713	7	_	_	NNP
18637	8713	8	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBD
18637	8713	9	_	_	NNP
18637	8713	10	,	,	,
18637	8713	11	the	the	DT
18637	8713	12	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8713	13	between	between	IN
18637	8713	14	the	the	DT
18637	8713	15	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8713	16	,	,	,
18637	8713	17	so	so	RB
18637	8713	18	far	far	RB
18637	8713	19	at	at	IN
18637	8713	20	least	least	JJS
18637	8713	21	as	as	IN
18637	8713	22	regards	regard	NNS
18637	8713	23	_	_	NNP
18637	8713	24	public	public	JJ
18637	8713	25	_	_	NNP
18637	8713	26	rights	right	NNS
18637	8713	27	,	,	,
18637	8713	28	are	be	VBP
18637	8713	29	of	of	IN
18637	8713	30	course	course	NN
18637	8713	31	suspended	suspend	VBN
18637	8713	32	.	.	.
18637	8714	1	This	this	DT
18637	8714	2	power	power	NN
18637	8714	3	of	of	IN
18637	8714	4	determining	determine	VBG
18637	8714	5	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	8714	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	8714	7	the	the	DT
18637	8714	8	operation	operation	NN
18637	8714	9	of	of	IN
18637	8714	10	national	national	JJ
18637	8714	11	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8714	12	,	,	,
18637	8714	13	as	as	IN
18637	8714	14	a	a	DT
18637	8714	15	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	8714	16	of	of	IN
18637	8714	17	the	the	DT
18637	8714	18	power	power	NN
18637	8714	19	to	to	TO
18637	8714	20	receive	receive	VB
18637	8714	21	public	public	JJ
18637	8714	22	ministers	minister	NNS
18637	8714	23	,	,	,
18637	8714	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	8714	25	an	an	DT
18637	8714	26	important	important	JJ
18637	8714	27	instance	instance	NN
18637	8714	28	of	of	IN
18637	8714	29	the	the	DT
18637	8714	30	right	right	NN
18637	8714	31	of	of	IN
18637	8714	32	the	the	DT
18637	8714	33	executive	executive	NN
18637	8714	34	,	,	,
18637	8714	35	to	to	TO
18637	8714	36	decide	decide	VB
18637	8714	37	upon	upon	IN
18637	8714	38	the	the	DT
18637	8714	39	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	8714	40	of	of	IN
18637	8714	41	the	the	DT
18637	8714	42	country	country	NN
18637	8714	43	with	with	IN
18637	8714	44	regard	regard	NN
18637	8714	45	to	to	IN
18637	8714	46	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8714	47	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8714	48	.	.	.
18637	8715	1	To	to	TO
18637	8715	2	apply	apply	VB
18637	8715	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8715	4	to	to	IN
18637	8715	5	the	the	DT
18637	8715	6	case	case	NN
18637	8715	7	of	of	IN
18637	8715	8	France	France	NNP
18637	8715	9	,	,	,
18637	8715	10	if	if	IN
18637	8715	11	there	there	EX
18637	8715	12	had	have	VBD
18637	8715	13	been	be	VBN
18637	8715	14	a	a	DT
18637	8715	15	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8715	16	of	of	IN
18637	8715	17	alliance	alliance	NN
18637	8715	18	,	,	,
18637	8715	19	offensive	offensive	JJ
18637	8715	20	and	and	CC
18637	8715	21	defensive	defensive	JJ
18637	8715	22	,	,	,
18637	8715	23	between	between	IN
18637	8715	24	the	the	DT
18637	8715	25	United	United	NNP
18637	8715	26	States	States	NNP
18637	8715	27	and	and	CC
18637	8715	28	that	that	DT
18637	8715	29	country	country	NN
18637	8715	30	,	,	,
18637	8715	31	the	the	DT
18637	8715	32	unqualified	unqualified	JJ
18637	8715	33	acknowledgment	acknowledgment	NN
18637	8715	34	of	of	IN
18637	8715	35	the	the	DT
18637	8715	36	new	new	JJ
18637	8715	37	government	government	NN
18637	8715	38	would	would	MD
18637	8715	39	have	have	VB
18637	8715	40	put	put	VBN
18637	8715	41	the	the	DT
18637	8715	42	United	United	NNP
18637	8715	43	States	States	NNP
18637	8715	44	in	in	IN
18637	8715	45	a	a	DT
18637	8715	46	condition	condition	NN
18637	8715	47	to	to	TO
18637	8715	48	become	become	VB
18637	8715	49	an	an	DT
18637	8715	50	associate	associate	NN
18637	8715	51	in	in	IN
18637	8715	52	the	the	DT
18637	8715	53	war	war	NN
18637	8715	54	with	with	IN
18637	8715	55	France	France	NNP
18637	8715	56	,	,	,
18637	8715	57	and	and	CC
18637	8715	58	would	would	MD
18637	8715	59	have	have	VB
18637	8715	60	laid	lay	VBN
18637	8715	61	the	the	DT
18637	8715	62	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	8715	63	under	under	IN
18637	8715	64	an	an	DT
18637	8715	65	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8715	66	,	,	,
18637	8715	67	if	if	IN
18637	8715	68	required	require	VBN
18637	8715	69	,	,	,
18637	8715	70	and	and	CC
18637	8715	71	there	there	EX
18637	8715	72	was	be	VBD
18637	8715	73	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	8715	74	no	no	DT
18637	8715	75	valid	valid	JJ
18637	8715	76	excuse	excuse	NN
18637	8715	77	,	,	,
18637	8715	78	of	of	IN
18637	8715	79	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	8715	80	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8715	81	power	power	NN
18637	8715	82	of	of	IN
18637	8715	83	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	8715	84	war	war	NN
18637	8715	85	.	.	.
18637	8716	1	This	this	DT
18637	8716	2	serves	serve	VBZ
18637	8716	3	as	as	IN
18637	8716	4	an	an	DT
18637	8716	5	example	example	NN
18637	8716	6	of	of	IN
18637	8716	7	the	the	DT
18637	8716	8	right	right	NN
18637	8716	9	of	of	IN
18637	8716	10	the	the	DT
18637	8716	11	executive	executive	NN
18637	8716	12	,	,	,
18637	8716	13	in	in	IN
18637	8716	14	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8716	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	8716	16	,	,	,
18637	8716	17	to	to	TO
18637	8716	18	determine	determine	VB
18637	8716	19	the	the	DT
18637	8716	20	condition	condition	NN
18637	8716	21	of	of	IN
18637	8716	22	the	the	DT
18637	8716	23	nation	nation	NN
18637	8716	24	,	,	,
18637	8716	25	though	though	IN
18637	8716	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8716	27	may	may	MD
18637	8716	28	,	,	,
18637	8716	29	in	in	IN
18637	8716	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8716	31	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	8716	32	,	,	,
18637	8716	33	affect	affect	VB
18637	8716	34	the	the	DT
18637	8716	35	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	8716	36	of	of	IN
18637	8716	37	the	the	DT
18637	8716	38	power	power	NN
18637	8716	39	of	of	IN
18637	8716	40	the	the	DT
18637	8716	41	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	8716	42	to	to	TO
18637	8716	43	declare	declare	VB
18637	8716	44	war	war	NN
18637	8716	45	.	.	.
18637	8717	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	8717	2	,	,	,
18637	8717	3	the	the	DT
18637	8717	4	executive	executive	NN
18637	8717	5	can	can	MD
18637	8717	6	not	not	RB
18637	8717	7	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	8717	8	control	control	VB
18637	8717	9	the	the	DT
18637	8717	10	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	8717	11	of	of	IN
18637	8717	12	that	that	DT
18637	8717	13	power	power	NN
18637	8717	14	.	.	.
18637	8718	1	The	the	DT
18637	8718	2	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	8718	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8718	4	still	still	RB
18637	8718	5	free	free	JJ
18637	8718	6	to	to	TO
18637	8718	7	perform	perform	VB
18637	8718	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8718	9	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8718	10	,	,	,
18637	8718	11	according	accord	VBG
18637	8718	12	to	to	IN
18637	8718	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8718	14	own	own	JJ
18637	8718	15	sense	sense	NN
18637	8718	16	of	of	IN
18637	8718	17	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8718	18	;	;	:
18637	8718	19	though	though	IN
18637	8718	20	the	the	DT
18637	8718	21	executive	executive	NN
18637	8718	22	,	,	,
18637	8718	23	in	in	IN
18637	8718	24	the	the	DT
18637	8718	25	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	8718	26	of	of	IN
18637	8718	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8718	28	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8718	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	8718	30	,	,	,
18637	8718	31	may	may	MD
18637	8718	32	establish	establish	VB
18637	8718	33	an	an	DT
18637	8718	34	antecedent	antecedent	NN
18637	8718	35	state	state	NN
18637	8718	36	of	of	IN
18637	8718	37	things	thing	NNS
18637	8718	38	,	,	,
18637	8718	39	which	which	WDT
18637	8718	40	ought	ought	MD
18637	8718	41	to	to	TO
18637	8718	42	weigh	weigh	VB
18637	8718	43	in	in	IN
18637	8718	44	the	the	DT
18637	8718	45	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8718	46	decision	decision	NN
18637	8718	47	.	.	.
18637	8719	1	The	the	DT
18637	8719	2	division	division	NN
18637	8719	3	of	of	IN
18637	8719	4	the	the	DT
18637	8719	5	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8719	6	power	power	NN
18637	8719	7	in	in	IN
18637	8719	8	the	the	DT
18637	8719	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8719	10	,	,	,
18637	8719	11	creates	create	VBZ
18637	8719	12	a	a	DT
18637	8719	13	_	_	NNP
18637	8719	14	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	8719	15	_	_	NNP
18637	8719	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	8719	17	in	in	IN
18637	8719	18	the	the	DT
18637	8719	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	8719	20	to	to	TO
18637	8719	21	which	which	WDT
18637	8719	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8719	23	relates	relate	VBZ
18637	8719	24	.	.	.
18637	8720	1	"	"	``
18637	8720	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8720	3	344	344	CD
18637	8720	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8720	5	JEFFERSON	JEFFERSON	NNP
18637	8720	6	'S	's	POS
18637	8720	7	REAL	real	JJ
18637	8720	8	POSITION	position	NN
18637	8720	9	Nor	nor	CC
18637	8720	10	did	do	VBD
18637	8720	11	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	8720	12	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8720	13	officially	officially	RB
18637	8720	14	support	support	VBP
18637	8720	15	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8720	16	's	's	POS
18637	8720	17	point	point	NN
18637	8720	18	of	of	IN
18637	8720	19	view	view	NN
18637	8720	20	,	,	,
18637	8720	21	as	as	IN
18637	8720	22	the	the	DT
18637	8720	23	following	follow	VBG
18637	8720	24	extract	extract	NN
18637	8720	25	from	from	IN
18637	8720	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8720	27	"	"	``
18637	8720	28	minutes	minute	NNS
18637	8720	29	of	of	IN
18637	8720	30	a	a	DT
18637	8720	31	Conversation	Conversation	NNP
18637	8720	32	,	,	,
18637	8720	33	"	"	''
18637	8720	34	which	which	WDT
18637	8720	35	took	take	VBD
18637	8720	36	place	place	NN
18637	8720	37	July	July	NNP
18637	8720	38	10	10	CD
18637	8720	39	,	,	,
18637	8720	40	1793	1793	CD
18637	8720	41	,	,	,
18637	8720	42	between	between	IN
18637	8720	43	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8720	44	and	and	CC
18637	8720	45	Citizen	Citizen	NNP
18637	8720	46	Genet	Genet	NNP
18637	8720	47	,	,	,
18637	8720	48	show	show	VB
18637	8720	49	:	:	:
18637	8720	50	"	"	``
18637	8720	51	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8720	52	asked	ask	VBD
18637	8720	53	if	if	IN
18637	8720	54	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8720	55	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8720	56	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8720	57	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8720	58	were	be	VBD
18637	8720	59	not	not	RB
18637	8720	60	the	the	DT
18637	8720	61	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	8720	62	.	.	.
18637	8721	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8721	2	told	tell	VBD
18637	8721	3	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8721	4	no	no	UH
18637	8721	5	,	,	,
18637	8721	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8721	7	were	be	VBD
18637	8721	8	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	8721	9	in	in	IN
18637	8721	10	making	make	VBG
18637	8721	11	laws	law	NNS
18637	8721	12	only	only	RB
18637	8721	13	,	,	,
18637	8721	14	the	the	DT
18637	8721	15	executive	executive	NN
18637	8721	16	was	be	VBD
18637	8721	17	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	8721	18	in	in	IN
18637	8721	19	executing	execute	VBG
18637	8721	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8721	21	,	,	,
18637	8721	22	and	and	CC
18637	8721	23	the	the	DT
18637	8721	24	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	8721	25	in	in	IN
18637	8721	26	construing	construe	VBG
18637	8721	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8721	28	where	where	WRB
18637	8721	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8721	30	related	relate	VBD
18637	8721	31	to	to	IN
18637	8721	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8721	33	department	department	NN
18637	8721	34	.	.	.
18637	8722	1	'	'	``
18637	8722	2	But	but	CC
18637	8722	3	,	,	,
18637	8722	4	'	'	''
18637	8722	5	said	say	VBD
18637	8722	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8722	7	,	,	,
18637	8722	8	'	'	``
18637	8722	9	at	at	RB
18637	8722	10	least	least	JJS
18637	8722	11	,	,	,
18637	8722	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8722	13	are	be	VBP
18637	8722	14	bound	bind	VBN
18637	8722	15	to	to	TO
18637	8722	16	see	see	VB
18637	8722	17	that	that	IN
18637	8722	18	the	the	DT
18637	8722	19	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8722	20	are	be	VBP
18637	8722	21	observed	observe	VBN
18637	8722	22	.	.	.
18637	8722	23	'	'	''
18637	8723	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8723	2	told	tell	VBD
18637	8723	3	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8723	4	no	no	UH
18637	8723	5	;	;	:
18637	8723	6	there	there	EX
18637	8723	7	were	be	VBD
18637	8723	8	very	very	RB
18637	8723	9	few	few	JJ
18637	8723	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	8723	11	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	8723	12	arising	arise	VBG
18637	8723	13	out	out	IN
18637	8723	14	of	of	IN
18637	8723	15	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8723	16	,	,	,
18637	8723	17	which	which	WDT
18637	8723	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8723	19	could	could	MD
18637	8723	20	take	take	VB
18637	8723	21	notice	notice	NN
18637	8723	22	of	of	IN
18637	8723	23	;	;	:
18637	8723	24	that	that	IN
18637	8723	25	the	the	DT
18637	8723	26	President	President	NNP
18637	8723	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	8723	28	to	to	TO
18637	8723	29	see	see	VB
18637	8723	30	that	that	IN
18637	8723	31	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8723	32	are	be	VBP
18637	8723	33	observed	observe	VBN
18637	8723	34	.	.	.
18637	8724	1	'	'	``
18637	8724	2	If	if	IN
18637	8724	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8724	4	decides	decide	VBZ
18637	8724	5	against	against	IN
18637	8724	6	the	the	DT
18637	8724	7	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8724	8	,	,	,
18637	8724	9	to	to	IN
18637	8724	10	whom	whom	WP
18637	8724	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	8724	12	a	a	DT
18637	8724	13	nation	nation	NN
18637	8724	14	to	to	TO
18637	8724	15	appeal	appeal	VB
18637	8724	16	?	?	.
18637	8724	17	'	'	''
18637	8725	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8725	2	told	tell	VBD
18637	8725	3	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8725	4	the	the	DT
18637	8725	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8725	6	had	have	VBD
18637	8725	7	made	make	VBN
18637	8725	8	the	the	DT
18637	8725	9	President	President	NNP
18637	8725	10	the	the	DT
18637	8725	11	last	last	JJ
18637	8725	12	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	8725	13	.	.	.
18637	8726	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8726	2	made	make	VBD
18637	8726	3	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8726	4	a	a	DT
18637	8726	5	bow	bow	NN
18637	8726	6	,	,	,
18637	8726	7	and	and	CC
18637	8726	8	said	say	VBD
18637	8726	9	,	,	,
18637	8726	10	that	that	IN
18637	8726	11	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	8726	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8726	13	would	would	MD
18637	8726	14	not	not	RB
18637	8726	15	make	make	VB
18637	8726	16	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8726	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8726	18	compliments	compliment	NNS
18637	8726	19	on	on	IN
18637	8726	20	such	such	PDT
18637	8726	21	a	a	DT
18637	8726	22	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8726	23	,	,	,
18637	8726	24	expressed	express	VBD
18637	8726	25	the	the	DT
18637	8726	26	utmost	utmost	JJ
18637	8726	27	astonishment	astonishment	NN
18637	8726	28	at	at	IN
18637	8726	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8726	30	,	,	,
18637	8726	31	and	and	CC
18637	8726	32	seemed	seem	VBD
18637	8726	33	never	never	RB
18637	8726	34	before	before	RB
18637	8726	35	to	to	TO
18637	8726	36	have	have	VB
18637	8726	37	had	have	VBN
18637	8726	38	such	such	PDT
18637	8726	39	an	an	DT
18637	8726	40	idea	idea	NN
18637	8726	41	.	.	.
18637	8727	1	"	"	``
18637	8727	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8727	3	345	345	CD
18637	8727	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8727	5	THE	the	DT
18637	8727	6	POWER	power	NN
18637	8727	7	OF	of	IN
18637	8727	8	RECOGNITION	recognition	NN
18637	8727	9	In	in	IN
18637	8727	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8727	11	endeavor	endeavor	NN
18637	8727	12	in	in	IN
18637	8727	13	1793	1793	CD
18637	8727	14	to	to	TO
18637	8727	15	minimize	minimize	VB
18637	8727	16	the	the	DT
18637	8727	17	importance	importance	NN
18637	8727	18	of	of	IN
18637	8727	19	the	the	DT
18637	8727	20	President	President	NNP
18637	8727	21	's	's	POS
18637	8727	22	power	power	NN
18637	8727	23	of	of	IN
18637	8727	24	reception	reception	NN
18637	8727	25	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8727	26	denied	deny	VBD
18637	8727	27	that	that	IN
18637	8727	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8727	29	involved	involve	VBD
18637	8727	30	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	8727	31	of	of	IN
18637	8727	32	the	the	DT
18637	8727	33	question	question	NN
18637	8727	34	,	,	,
18637	8727	35	whether	whether	IN
18637	8727	36	those	those	DT
18637	8727	37	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	8727	38	the	the	DT
18637	8727	39	government	government	NN
18637	8727	40	of	of	IN
18637	8727	41	the	the	DT
18637	8727	42	accrediting	accredit	VBG
18637	8727	43	State	State	NNP
18637	8727	44	have	have	VBP
18637	8727	45	the	the	DT
18637	8727	46	right	right	NN
18637	8727	47	along	along	IN
18637	8727	48	with	with	IN
18637	8727	49	the	the	DT
18637	8727	50	possession	possession	NN
18637	8727	51	.	.	.
18637	8728	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8728	2	said	say	VBD
18637	8728	3	:	:	:
18637	8728	4	"	"	``
18637	8728	5	This	this	DT
18637	8728	6	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	8728	7	to	to	IN
18637	8728	8	the	the	DT
18637	8728	9	nation	nation	NN
18637	8728	10	,	,	,
18637	8728	11	and	and	CC
18637	8728	12	to	to	IN
18637	8728	13	the	the	DT
18637	8728	14	nation	nation	NN
18637	8728	15	alone	alone	RB
18637	8728	16	,	,	,
18637	8728	17	on	on	IN
18637	8728	18	whom	whom	WP
18637	8728	19	the	the	DT
18637	8728	20	government	government	NN
18637	8728	21	operates	operate	VBZ
18637	8728	22	.	.	.
18637	8729	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8729	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8729	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8729	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8729	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	8729	6	evident	evident	JJ
18637	8729	7	,	,	,
18637	8729	8	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8729	9	,	,	,
18637	8729	10	that	that	IN
18637	8729	11	if	if	IN
18637	8729	12	the	the	DT
18637	8729	13	executive	executive	NN
18637	8729	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	8729	15	a	a	DT
18637	8729	16	right	right	NN
18637	8729	17	to	to	TO
18637	8729	18	reject	reject	VB
18637	8729	19	a	a	DT
18637	8729	20	public	public	JJ
18637	8729	21	minister	minister	NN
18637	8729	22	,	,	,
18637	8729	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8729	24	must	must	MD
18637	8729	25	be	be	VB
18637	8729	26	founded	found	VBN
18637	8729	27	on	on	IN
18637	8729	28	some	some	DT
18637	8729	29	other	other	JJ
18637	8729	30	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	8729	31	than	than	IN
18637	8729	32	a	a	DT
18637	8729	33	change	change	NN
18637	8729	34	in	in	IN
18637	8729	35	the	the	DT
18637	8729	36	government	government	NN
18637	8729	37	,	,	,
18637	8729	38	or	or	CC
18637	8729	39	the	the	DT
18637	8729	40	newness	newness	NN
18637	8729	41	of	of	IN
18637	8729	42	the	the	DT
18637	8729	43	government	government	NN
18637	8729	44	;	;	:
18637	8729	45	and	and	CC
18637	8729	46	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	8729	47	a	a	DT
18637	8729	48	right	right	NN
18637	8729	49	to	to	TO
18637	8729	50	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	8729	51	to	to	TO
18637	8729	52	acknowledge	acknowledge	VB
18637	8729	53	a	a	DT
18637	8729	54	new	new	JJ
18637	8729	55	government	government	NN
18637	8729	56	can	can	MD
18637	8729	57	not	not	RB
18637	8729	58	be	be	VB
18637	8729	59	implied	imply	VBN
18637	8729	60	by	by	IN
18637	8729	61	the	the	DT
18637	8729	62	right	right	NN
18637	8729	63	to	to	TO
18637	8729	64	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	8729	65	a	a	DT
18637	8729	66	public	public	JJ
18637	8729	67	minister	minister	NN
18637	8729	68	.	.	.
18637	8730	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8730	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8730	3	not	not	RB
18637	8730	4	denied	deny	VBN
18637	8730	5	that	that	IN
18637	8730	6	there	there	EX
18637	8730	7	may	may	MD
18637	8730	8	be	be	VB
18637	8730	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	8730	10	in	in	IN
18637	8730	11	which	which	WDT
18637	8730	12	a	a	DT
18637	8730	13	respect	respect	NN
18637	8730	14	to	to	IN
18637	8730	15	the	the	DT
18637	8730	16	general	general	JJ
18637	8730	17	principles	principle	NNS
18637	8730	18	of	of	IN
18637	8730	19	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	8730	20	,	,	,
18637	8730	21	the	the	DT
18637	8730	22	essential	essential	JJ
18637	8730	23	rights	right	NNS
18637	8730	24	of	of	IN
18637	8730	25	the	the	DT
18637	8730	26	people	people	NNS
18637	8730	27	,	,	,
18637	8730	28	or	or	CC
18637	8730	29	the	the	DT
18637	8730	30	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	8730	31	sentiments	sentiment	NNS
18637	8730	32	of	of	IN
18637	8730	33	humanity	humanity	NN
18637	8730	34	,	,	,
18637	8730	35	might	may	MD
18637	8730	36	require	require	VB
18637	8730	37	a	a	DT
18637	8730	38	government	government	NN
18637	8730	39	,	,	,
18637	8730	40	whether	whether	IN
18637	8730	41	new	new	JJ
18637	8730	42	or	or	CC
18637	8730	43	old	old	JJ
18637	8730	44	,	,	,
18637	8730	45	to	to	TO
18637	8730	46	be	be	VB
18637	8730	47	treated	treat	VBN
18637	8730	48	as	as	IN
18637	8730	49	an	an	DT
18637	8730	50	illegitimate	illegitimate	JJ
18637	8730	51	despotism	despotism	NN
18637	8730	52	.	.	.
18637	8731	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	8731	2	are	be	VBP
18637	8731	3	in	in	IN
18637	8731	4	fact	fact	NN
18637	8731	5	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	8731	6	and	and	CC
18637	8731	7	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	8731	8	by	by	IN
18637	8731	9	the	the	DT
18637	8731	10	most	most	RBS
18637	8731	11	approved	approved	JJ
18637	8731	12	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	8731	13	.	.	.
18637	8732	1	But	but	CC
18637	8732	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8732	3	are	be	VBP
18637	8732	4	great	great	JJ
18637	8732	5	and	and	CC
18637	8732	6	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	8732	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	8732	8	,	,	,
18637	8732	9	by	by	IN
18637	8732	10	no	no	DT
18637	8732	11	means	means	NN
18637	8732	12	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	8732	13	to	to	IN
18637	8732	14	so	so	RB
18637	8732	15	limited	limit	VBD
18637	8732	16	an	an	DT
18637	8732	17	organ	organ	NN
18637	8732	18	of	of	IN
18637	8732	19	the	the	DT
18637	8732	20	national	national	JJ
18637	8732	21	will	will	NN
18637	8732	22	as	as	IN
18637	8732	23	the	the	DT
18637	8732	24	executive	executive	NN
18637	8732	25	of	of	IN
18637	8732	26	the	the	DT
18637	8732	27	United	United	NNP
18637	8732	28	States	States	NNP
18637	8732	29	;	;	:
18637	8732	30	and	and	CC
18637	8732	31	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	8732	32	not	not	RB
18637	8732	33	to	to	TO
18637	8732	34	be	be	VB
18637	8732	35	brought	bring	VBN
18637	8732	36	by	by	IN
18637	8732	37	any	any	DT
18637	8732	38	torture	torture	NN
18637	8732	39	of	of	IN
18637	8732	40	words	word	NNS
18637	8732	41	,	,	,
18637	8732	42	within	within	IN
18637	8732	43	the	the	DT
18637	8732	44	right	right	NN
18637	8732	45	to	to	TO
18637	8732	46	receive	receive	VB
18637	8732	47	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	8732	48	.	.	.
18637	8733	1	"	"	``
18637	8733	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8733	3	346	346	CD
18637	8733	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8733	5	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	8733	6	,	,	,
18637	8733	7	with	with	IN
18637	8733	8	the	the	DT
18637	8733	9	case	case	NN
18637	8733	10	of	of	IN
18637	8733	11	Genet	Genet	NNP
18637	8733	12	before	before	IN
18637	8733	13	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8733	14	,	,	,
18637	8733	15	had	have	VBD
18637	8733	16	taken	take	VBN
18637	8733	17	the	the	DT
18637	8733	18	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	8733	19	position	position	NN
18637	8733	20	,	,	,
18637	8733	21	which	which	WDT
18637	8733	22	history	history	NN
18637	8733	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	8733	24	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	8733	25	.	.	.
18637	8734	1	In	in	IN
18637	8734	2	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	8734	3	of	of	IN
18637	8734	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8734	5	power	power	NN
18637	8734	6	to	to	TO
18637	8734	7	receive	receive	VB
18637	8734	8	and	and	CC
18637	8734	9	dispatch	dispatch	VB
18637	8734	10	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8734	11	agents	agent	NNS
18637	8734	12	,	,	,
18637	8734	13	but	but	CC
18637	8734	14	more	more	RBR
18637	8734	15	especially	especially	RB
18637	8734	16	the	the	DT
18637	8734	17	former	former	JJ
18637	8734	18	,	,	,
18637	8734	19	the	the	DT
18637	8734	20	President	President	NNP
18637	8734	21	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	8734	22	the	the	DT
18637	8734	23	power	power	NN
18637	8734	24	to	to	TO
18637	8734	25	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	8734	26	new	new	JJ
18637	8734	27	States	States	NNPS
18637	8734	28	,	,	,
18637	8734	29	communities	community	NNS
18637	8734	30	claiming	claim	VBG
18637	8734	31	the	the	DT
18637	8734	32	status	status	NN
18637	8734	33	of	of	IN
18637	8734	34	belligerency	belligerency	NN
18637	8734	35	,	,	,
18637	8734	36	and	and	CC
18637	8734	37	changes	change	NNS
18637	8734	38	of	of	IN
18637	8734	39	government	government	NN
18637	8734	40	in	in	IN
18637	8734	41	established	establish	VBN
18637	8734	42	states	state	NNS
18637	8734	43	;	;	:
18637	8734	44	also	also	RB
18637	8734	45	,	,	,
18637	8734	46	by	by	IN
18637	8734	47	the	the	DT
18637	8734	48	same	same	JJ
18637	8734	49	token	token	NN
18637	8734	50	,	,	,
18637	8734	51	the	the	DT
18637	8734	52	power	power	NN
18637	8734	53	to	to	TO
18637	8734	54	decline	decline	VB
18637	8734	55	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8734	56	,	,	,
18637	8734	57	and	and	CC
18637	8734	58	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	8734	59	decline	decline	VBP
18637	8734	60	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8734	61	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8734	62	with	with	IN
18637	8734	63	such	such	JJ
18637	8734	64	new	new	JJ
18637	8734	65	States	state	NNS
18637	8734	66	or	or	CC
18637	8734	67	governments	government	NNS
18637	8734	68	.	.	.
18637	8735	1	The	the	DT
18637	8735	2	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	8735	3	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	8735	4	down	down	RP
18637	8735	5	to	to	IN
18637	8735	6	1906	1906	CD
18637	8735	7	are	be	VBP
18637	8735	8	succinctly	succinctly	RB
18637	8735	9	summarized	summarize	VBN
18637	8735	10	by	by	IN
18637	8735	11	John	John	NNP
18637	8735	12	Bassett	Bassett	NNP
18637	8735	13	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	8735	14	in	in	IN
18637	8735	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8735	16	famous	famous	JJ
18637	8735	17	Digest	Digest	NNP
18637	8735	18	,	,	,
18637	8735	19	as	as	IN
18637	8735	20	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	8735	21	:	:	:
18637	8735	22	"	"	``
18637	8735	23	In	in	IN
18637	8735	24	the	the	DT
18637	8735	25	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	8735	26	review	review	NN
18637	8735	27	of	of	IN
18637	8735	28	the	the	DT
18637	8735	29	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8735	30	,	,	,
18637	8735	31	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	8735	32	,	,	,
18637	8735	33	of	of	IN
18637	8735	34	the	the	DT
18637	8735	35	new	new	JJ
18637	8735	36	states	state	NNS
18637	8735	37	,	,	,
18637	8735	38	new	new	JJ
18637	8735	39	governments	government	NNS
18637	8735	40	,	,	,
18637	8735	41	and	and	CC
18637	8735	42	belligerency	belligerency	NN
18637	8735	43	,	,	,
18637	8735	44	there	there	EX
18637	8735	45	has	have	VBZ
18637	8735	46	been	be	VBN
18637	8735	47	made	make	VBN
18637	8735	48	in	in	IN
18637	8735	49	each	each	DT
18637	8735	50	case	case	NN
18637	8735	51	a	a	DT
18637	8735	52	precise	precise	JJ
18637	8735	53	statement	statement	NN
18637	8735	54	of	of	IN
18637	8735	55	facts	fact	NNS
18637	8735	56	,	,	,
18637	8735	57	showing	show	VBG
18637	8735	58	how	how	WRB
18637	8735	59	and	and	CC
18637	8735	60	by	by	IN
18637	8735	61	whom	whom	WP
18637	8735	62	the	the	DT
18637	8735	63	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8735	64	was	be	VBD
18637	8735	65	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	8735	66	.	.	.
18637	8736	1	In	in	IN
18637	8736	2	every	every	DT
18637	8736	3	case	case	NN
18637	8736	4	,	,	,
18637	8736	5	as	as	IN
18637	8736	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8736	7	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	8736	8	,	,	,
18637	8736	9	of	of	IN
18637	8736	10	a	a	DT
18637	8736	11	new	new	JJ
18637	8736	12	government	government	NN
18637	8736	13	and	and	CC
18637	8736	14	of	of	IN
18637	8736	15	belligerency	belligerency	NN
18637	8736	16	,	,	,
18637	8736	17	the	the	DT
18637	8736	18	question	question	NN
18637	8736	19	of	of	IN
18637	8736	20	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8736	21	was	be	VBD
18637	8736	22	determined	determine	VBN
18637	8736	23	solely	solely	RB
18637	8736	24	by	by	IN
18637	8736	25	the	the	DT
18637	8736	26	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8736	27	.	.	.
18637	8737	1	In	in	IN
18637	8737	2	the	the	DT
18637	8737	3	case	case	NN
18637	8737	4	of	of	IN
18637	8737	5	the	the	DT
18637	8737	6	Spanish	spanish	JJ
18637	8737	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	8737	8	American	american	JJ
18637	8737	9	republics	republic	NNS
18637	8737	10	,	,	,
18637	8737	11	of	of	IN
18637	8737	12	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	8737	13	,	,	,
18637	8737	14	of	of	IN
18637	8737	15	Hayti	hayti	NN
18637	8737	16	,	,	,
18637	8737	17	and	and	CC
18637	8737	18	of	of	IN
18637	8737	19	Liberia	Liberia	NNP
18637	8737	20	,	,	,
18637	8737	21	the	the	DT
18637	8737	22	President	President	NNP
18637	8737	23	,	,	,
18637	8737	24	before	before	IN
18637	8737	25	recognizing	recognize	VBG
18637	8737	26	the	the	DT
18637	8737	27	new	new	JJ
18637	8737	28	state	state	NN
18637	8737	29	,	,	,
18637	8737	30	invoked	invoke	VBD
18637	8737	31	the	the	DT
18637	8737	32	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8737	33	and	and	CC
18637	8737	34	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	8737	35	of	of	IN
18637	8737	36	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8737	37	;	;	:
18637	8737	38	and	and	CC
18637	8737	39	in	in	IN
18637	8737	40	each	each	DT
18637	8737	41	of	of	IN
18637	8737	42	these	these	DT
18637	8737	43	cases	case	NNS
18637	8737	44	provision	provision	NN
18637	8737	45	was	be	VBD
18637	8737	46	made	make	VBN
18637	8737	47	for	for	IN
18637	8737	48	the	the	DT
18637	8737	49	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	8737	50	of	of	IN
18637	8737	51	a	a	DT
18637	8737	52	minister	minister	NN
18637	8737	53	,	,	,
18637	8737	54	which	which	WDT
18637	8737	55	,	,	,
18637	8737	56	when	when	WRB
18637	8737	57	made	make	VBN
18637	8737	58	in	in	IN
18637	8737	59	due	due	JJ
18637	8737	60	form	form	NN
18637	8737	61	,	,	,
18637	8737	62	constitutes	constitute	NNS
18637	8737	63	,	,	,
18637	8737	64	as	as	IN
18637	8737	65	has	have	VBZ
18637	8737	66	been	be	VBN
18637	8737	67	seen	see	VBN
18637	8737	68	,	,	,
18637	8737	69	according	accord	VBG
18637	8737	70	to	to	IN
18637	8737	71	the	the	DT
18637	8737	72	rules	rule	NNS
18637	8737	73	of	of	IN
18637	8737	74	international	international	JJ
18637	8737	75	law	law	NN
18637	8737	76	,	,	,
18637	8737	77	a	a	DT
18637	8737	78	formal	formal	JJ
18637	8737	79	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8737	80	.	.	.
18637	8738	1	In	in	IN
18637	8738	2	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	8738	3	other	other	JJ
18637	8738	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	8738	5	,	,	,
18637	8738	6	the	the	DT
18637	8738	7	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8738	8	was	be	VBD
18637	8738	9	given	give	VBN
18637	8738	10	by	by	IN
18637	8738	11	the	the	DT
18637	8738	12	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8738	13	solely	solely	RB
18637	8738	14	on	on	IN
18637	8738	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8738	16	own	own	JJ
18637	8738	17	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	8738	18	.	.	.
18637	8739	1	"	"	``
18637	8739	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8739	3	347	347	CD
18637	8739	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8739	5	The	the	DT
18637	8739	6	Case	Case	NNP
18637	8739	7	of	of	IN
18637	8739	8	Cuba	Cuba	NNP
18637	8739	9	The	the	DT
18637	8739	10	question	question	NN
18637	8739	11	of	of	IN
18637	8739	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8739	13	's	's	POS
18637	8739	14	right	right	RB
18637	8739	15	also	also	RB
18637	8739	16	to	to	TO
18637	8739	17	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	8739	18	new	new	JJ
18637	8739	19	states	state	NNS
18637	8739	20	was	be	VBD
18637	8739	21	prominently	prominently	RB
18637	8739	22	raised	raise	VBN
18637	8739	23	in	in	IN
18637	8739	24	connection	connection	NN
18637	8739	25	with	with	IN
18637	8739	26	Cuba	Cuba	NNP
18637	8739	27	's	's	POS
18637	8739	28	final	final	JJ
18637	8739	29	and	and	CC
18637	8739	30	successful	successful	JJ
18637	8739	31	struggle	struggle	NN
18637	8739	32	for	for	IN
18637	8739	33	independence	independence	NN
18637	8739	34	.	.	.
18637	8740	1	Beset	beset	VB
18637	8740	2	by	by	IN
18637	8740	3	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	8740	4	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8740	5	proposals	proposal	NNS
18637	8740	6	of	of	IN
18637	8740	7	a	a	DT
18637	8740	8	more	more	RBR
18637	8740	9	or	or	CC
18637	8740	10	less	less	RBR
18637	8740	11	mandatory	mandatory	JJ
18637	8740	12	character	character	NN
18637	8740	13	,	,	,
18637	8740	14	urging	urge	VBG
18637	8740	15	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8740	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	8740	17	the	the	DT
18637	8740	18	President	President	NNP
18637	8740	19	,	,	,
18637	8740	20	the	the	DT
18637	8740	21	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8740	22	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	8740	23	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	8740	24	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	8740	25	,	,	,
18637	8740	26	in	in	IN
18637	8740	27	1897	1897	CD
18637	8740	28	,	,	,
18637	8740	29	made	make	VBD
18637	8740	30	an	an	DT
18637	8740	31	elaborate	elaborate	JJ
18637	8740	32	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	8740	33	of	of	IN
18637	8740	34	the	the	DT
18637	8740	35	whole	whole	JJ
18637	8740	36	subject	subject	NN
18637	8740	37	and	and	CC
18637	8740	38	came	come	VBD
18637	8740	39	to	to	IN
18637	8740	40	the	the	DT
18637	8740	41	following	follow	VBG
18637	8740	42	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
18637	8740	43	as	as	IN
18637	8740	44	to	to	IN
18637	8740	45	this	this	DT
18637	8740	46	power	power	NN
18637	8740	47	:	:	:
18637	8740	48	"	"	``
18637	8740	49	The	the	DT
18637	8740	50	'	'	``
18637	8740	51	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8740	52	'	'	''
18637	8740	53	of	of	IN
18637	8740	54	independence	independence	NN
18637	8740	55	or	or	CC
18637	8740	56	belligerency	belligerency	NN
18637	8740	57	of	of	IN
18637	8740	58	a	a	DT
18637	8740	59	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8740	60	power	power	NN
18637	8740	61	,	,	,
18637	8740	62	technically	technically	RB
18637	8740	63	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8740	64	,	,	,
18637	8740	65	is	be	VBZ
18637	8740	66	distinctly	distinctly	RB
18637	8740	67	a	a	DT
18637	8740	68	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8740	69	matter	matter	NN
18637	8740	70	.	.	.
18637	8741	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8741	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8741	3	properly	properly	RB
18637	8741	4	evidenced	evidence	VBN
18637	8741	5	either	either	CC
18637	8741	6	by	by	IN
18637	8741	7	sending	send	VBG
18637	8741	8	a	a	DT
18637	8741	9	public	public	JJ
18637	8741	10	minister	minister	NN
18637	8741	11	to	to	IN
18637	8741	12	the	the	DT
18637	8741	13	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8741	14	thus	thus	RB
18637	8741	15	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	8741	16	,	,	,
18637	8741	17	or	or	CC
18637	8741	18	by	by	IN
18637	8741	19	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	8741	20	a	a	DT
18637	8741	21	public	public	JJ
18637	8741	22	minister	minister	NN
18637	8741	23	therefrom	therefrom	NN
18637	8741	24	.	.	.
18637	8742	1	The	the	DT
18637	8742	2	latter	latter	NN
18637	8742	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8742	4	the	the	DT
18637	8742	5	usual	usual	JJ
18637	8742	6	and	and	CC
18637	8742	7	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8742	8	course	course	NN
18637	8742	9	.	.	.
18637	8743	1	Diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8743	2	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8743	3	with	with	IN
18637	8743	4	a	a	DT
18637	8743	5	new	new	JJ
18637	8743	6	power	power	NN
18637	8743	7	are	be	VBP
18637	8743	8	properly	properly	RB
18637	8743	9	,	,	,
18637	8743	10	and	and	CC
18637	8743	11	customarily	customarily	RB
18637	8743	12	inaugurated	inaugurate	VBN
18637	8743	13	at	at	IN
18637	8743	14	the	the	DT
18637	8743	15	request	request	NN
18637	8743	16	of	of	IN
18637	8743	17	that	that	DT
18637	8743	18	power	power	NN
18637	8743	19	,	,	,
18637	8743	20	expressed	express	VBD
18637	8743	21	through	through	IN
18637	8743	22	an	an	DT
18637	8743	23	envoy	envoy	NN
18637	8743	24	sent	send	VBN
18637	8743	25	for	for	IN
18637	8743	26	the	the	DT
18637	8743	27	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8743	28	.	.	.
18637	8744	1	The	the	DT
18637	8744	2	reception	reception	NN
18637	8744	3	of	of	IN
18637	8744	4	this	this	DT
18637	8744	5	envoy	envoy	NN
18637	8744	6	,	,	,
18637	8744	7	as	as	IN
18637	8744	8	pointed	point	VBN
18637	8744	9	out	out	RP
18637	8744	10	,	,	,
18637	8744	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	8744	12	the	the	DT
18637	8744	13	act	act	NN
18637	8744	14	of	of	IN
18637	8744	15	the	the	DT
18637	8744	16	President	President	NNP
18637	8744	17	alone	alone	RB
18637	8744	18	.	.	.
18637	8745	1	The	the	DT
18637	8745	2	next	next	JJ
18637	8745	3	step	step	NN
18637	8745	4	,	,	,
18637	8745	5	that	that	DT
18637	8745	6	of	of	IN
18637	8745	7	sending	send	VBG
18637	8745	8	a	a	DT
18637	8745	9	public	public	JJ
18637	8745	10	minister	minister	NN
18637	8745	11	to	to	IN
18637	8745	12	the	the	DT
18637	8745	13	nation	nation	NN
18637	8745	14	thus	thus	RB
18637	8745	15	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	8745	16	,	,	,
18637	8745	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	8745	18	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	8745	19	the	the	DT
18637	8745	20	act	act	NN
18637	8745	21	of	of	IN
18637	8745	22	the	the	DT
18637	8745	23	President	President	NNP
18637	8745	24	.	.	.
18637	8746	1	The	the	DT
18637	8746	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8746	3	can	can	MD
18637	8746	4	take	take	VB
18637	8746	5	no	no	DT
18637	8746	6	part	part	NN
18637	8746	7	in	in	IN
18637	8746	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8746	9	at	at	RB
18637	8746	10	all	all	RB
18637	8746	11	,	,	,
18637	8746	12	until	until	IN
18637	8746	13	the	the	DT
18637	8746	14	President	President	NNP
18637	8746	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	8746	16	sent	send	VBN
18637	8746	17	in	in	IN
18637	8746	18	a	a	DT
18637	8746	19	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	8746	20	.	.	.
18637	8747	1	Then	then	RB
18637	8747	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8747	3	acts	act	VBZ
18637	8747	4	in	in	IN
18637	8747	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8747	6	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8747	7	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	8747	8	,	,	,
18637	8747	9	and	and	CC
18637	8747	10	,	,	,
18637	8747	11	customarily	customarily	RB
18637	8747	12	,	,	,
18637	8747	13	in	in	IN
18637	8747	14	'	'	``
18637	8747	15	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8747	16	session	session	NN
18637	8747	17	.	.	.
18637	8747	18	'	'	''
18637	8748	1	The	the	DT
18637	8748	2	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8748	3	branch	branch	NN
18637	8748	4	of	of	IN
18637	8748	5	the	the	DT
18637	8748	6	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8748	7	can	can	MD
18637	8748	8	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	8748	9	no	no	DT
18637	8748	10	influence	influence	NN
18637	8748	11	over	over	IN
18637	8748	12	this	this	DT
18637	8748	13	step	step	NN
18637	8748	14	except	except	IN
18637	8748	15	,	,	,
18637	8748	16	very	very	RB
18637	8748	17	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	8748	18	,	,	,
18637	8748	19	by	by	IN
18637	8748	20	withholding	withhold	VBG
18637	8748	21	appropriations	appropriation	NNS
18637	8748	22	.	.	.
18637	8749	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8749	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8749	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8749	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	8749	5	can	can	MD
18637	8749	6	the	the	DT
18637	8749	7	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8749	8	branch	branch	NN
18637	8749	9	of	of	IN
18637	8749	10	the	the	DT
18637	8749	11	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8749	12	hold	hold	VBP
18637	8749	13	any	any	DT
18637	8749	14	communications	communication	NNS
18637	8749	15	with	with	IN
18637	8749	16	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8749	17	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8749	18	.	.	.
18637	8750	1	The	the	DT
18637	8750	2	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8750	3	branch	branch	NN
18637	8750	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	8750	5	the	the	DT
18637	8750	6	sole	sole	JJ
18637	8750	7	mouthpiece	mouthpiece	NN
18637	8750	8	of	of	IN
18637	8750	9	the	the	DT
18637	8750	10	nation	nation	NN
18637	8750	11	in	in	IN
18637	8750	12	communication	communication	NN
18637	8750	13	with	with	IN
18637	8750	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8750	15	sovereignties	sovereignty	NNS
18637	8750	16	.	.	.
18637	8751	1	Foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8751	2	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8751	3	communicate	communicate	VBP
18637	8751	4	only	only	RB
18637	8751	5	through	through	IN
18637	8751	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8751	7	respective	respective	JJ
18637	8751	8	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8751	9	departments	department	NNS
18637	8751	10	.	.	.
18637	8752	1	Resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	8752	2	of	of	IN
18637	8752	3	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8752	4	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8752	5	departments	department	NNS
18637	8752	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	8752	7	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8752	8	matters	matter	NNS
18637	8752	9	have	have	VBP
18637	8752	10	no	no	DT
18637	8752	11	status	status	NN
18637	8752	12	in	in	IN
18637	8752	13	international	international	JJ
18637	8752	14	law	law	NN
18637	8752	15	.	.	.
18637	8753	1	In	in	IN
18637	8753	2	the	the	DT
18637	8753	3	department	department	NN
18637	8753	4	of	of	IN
18637	8753	5	international	international	JJ
18637	8753	6	law	law	NN
18637	8753	7	,	,	,
18637	8753	8	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8753	9	,	,	,
18637	8753	10	properly	properly	RB
18637	8753	11	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8753	12	,	,	,
18637	8753	13	a	a	DT
18637	8753	14	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	8753	15	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8753	16	of	of	IN
18637	8753	17	belligerency	belligerency	NN
18637	8753	18	or	or	CC
18637	8753	19	independence	independence	NN
18637	8753	20	would	would	MD
18637	8753	21	be	be	VB
18637	8753	22	a	a	DT
18637	8753	23	nullity	nullity	NN
18637	8753	24	.	.	.
18637	8754	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8754	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8754	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8754	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8754	5	can	can	MD
18637	8754	6	help	help	VB
18637	8754	7	the	the	DT
18637	8754	8	Cuban	cuban	JJ
18637	8754	9	insurgents	insurgent	NNS
18637	8754	10	by	by	IN
18637	8754	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8754	12	in	in	IN
18637	8754	13	many	many	JJ
18637	8754	14	ways	way	NNS
18637	8754	15	,	,	,
18637	8754	16	but	but	CC
18637	8754	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8754	18	can	can	MD
18637	8754	19	not	not	RB
18637	8754	20	help	help	VB
18637	8754	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8754	22	legitimately	legitimately	RB
18637	8754	23	by	by	IN
18637	8754	24	mere	mere	JJ
18637	8754	25	declarations	declaration	NNS
18637	8754	26	,	,	,
18637	8754	27	or	or	CC
18637	8754	28	by	by	IN
18637	8754	29	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	8754	30	to	to	TO
18637	8754	31	engage	engage	VB
18637	8754	32	in	in	IN
18637	8754	33	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8754	34	negotiations	negotiation	NNS
18637	8754	35	,	,	,
18637	8754	36	if	if	IN
18637	8754	37	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8754	38	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	8754	39	of	of	IN
18637	8754	40	the	the	DT
18637	8754	41	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8754	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	8754	43	correct	correct	JJ
18637	8754	44	.	.	.
18637	8755	1	That	that	IN
18637	8755	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8755	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8755	4	correct	correct	JJ
18637	8755	5	*	*	NFP
18637	8755	6	*	*	NFP
18637	8755	7	*	*	NFP
18637	8755	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8755	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	8755	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8755	11	shown	show	VBN
18637	8755	12	by	by	IN
18637	8755	13	the	the	DT
18637	8755	14	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	8755	15	of	of	IN
18637	8755	16	jurists	jurist	NNS
18637	8755	17	and	and	CC
18637	8755	18	statesmen	statesman	NNS
18637	8755	19	of	of	IN
18637	8755	20	the	the	DT
18637	8755	21	past	past	NN
18637	8755	22	.	.	.
18637	8756	1	"	"	``
18637	8756	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8756	3	348	348	CD
18637	8756	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8756	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8756	6	was	be	VBD
18637	8756	7	able	able	JJ
18637	8756	8	ultimately	ultimately	RB
18637	8756	9	to	to	TO
18637	8756	10	bundle	bundle	VB
18637	8756	11	a	a	DT
18637	8756	12	clause	clause	NN
18637	8756	13	recognizing	recognize	VBG
18637	8756	14	the	the	DT
18637	8756	15	independence	independence	NN
18637	8756	16	of	of	IN
18637	8756	17	Cuba	Cuba	NNP
18637	8756	18	,	,	,
18637	8756	19	as	as	IN
18637	8756	20	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	8756	21	from	from	IN
18637	8756	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8756	23	government	government	NN
18637	8756	24	,	,	,
18637	8756	25	into	into	IN
18637	8756	26	the	the	DT
18637	8756	27	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	8756	28	of	of	IN
18637	8756	29	war	war	NN
18637	8756	30	of	of	IN
18637	8756	31	April	April	NNP
18637	8756	32	11	11	CD
18637	8756	33	,	,	,
18637	8756	34	1898	1898	CD
18637	8756	35	against	against	IN
18637	8756	36	Spain	Spain	NNP
18637	8756	37	.	.	.
18637	8757	1	For	for	IN
18637	8757	2	the	the	DT
18637	8757	3	most	most	JJS
18637	8757	4	part	part	NN
18637	8757	5	,	,	,
18637	8757	6	the	the	DT
18637	8757	7	sponsors	sponsor	NNS
18637	8757	8	of	of	IN
18637	8757	9	the	the	DT
18637	8757	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	8757	11	defended	defend	VBD
18637	8757	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8757	13	by	by	IN
18637	8757	14	the	the	DT
18637	8757	15	following	follow	VBG
18637	8757	16	line	line	NN
18637	8757	17	of	of	IN
18637	8757	18	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	8757	19	.	.	.
18637	8758	1	Diplomacy	diplomacy	NN
18637	8758	2	,	,	,
18637	8758	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8758	4	said	say	VBD
18637	8758	5	,	,	,
18637	8758	6	was	be	VBD
18637	8758	7	now	now	RB
18637	8758	8	at	at	IN
18637	8758	9	an	an	DT
18637	8758	10	end	end	NN
18637	8758	11	and	and	CC
18637	8758	12	the	the	DT
18637	8758	13	President	President	NNP
18637	8758	14	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8758	15	had	have	VBD
18637	8758	16	appealed	appeal	VBN
18637	8758	17	to	to	IN
18637	8758	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8758	19	to	to	TO
18637	8758	20	provide	provide	VB
18637	8758	21	a	a	DT
18637	8758	22	solution	solution	NN
18637	8758	23	for	for	IN
18637	8758	24	the	the	DT
18637	8758	25	Cuban	cuban	JJ
18637	8758	26	situation	situation	NN
18637	8758	27	.	.	.
18637	8759	1	In	in	IN
18637	8759	2	response	response	NN
18637	8759	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8759	4	was	be	VBD
18637	8759	5	about	about	JJ
18637	8759	6	to	to	TO
18637	8759	7	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	8759	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8759	9	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8759	10	power	power	NN
18637	8759	11	of	of	IN
18637	8759	12	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	8759	13	war	war	NN
18637	8759	14	,	,	,
18637	8759	15	and	and	CC
18637	8759	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8759	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	8759	18	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	8759	19	the	the	DT
18637	8759	20	right	right	NN
18637	8759	21	to	to	TO
18637	8759	22	state	state	VB
18637	8759	23	the	the	DT
18637	8759	24	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8759	25	of	of	IN
18637	8759	26	the	the	DT
18637	8759	27	war	war	NN
18637	8759	28	which	which	WDT
18637	8759	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8759	30	was	be	VBD
18637	8759	31	about	about	JJ
18637	8759	32	to	to	TO
18637	8759	33	declare	declare	VB
18637	8759	34	.	.	.
18637	8760	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8760	2	349	349	CD
18637	8760	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8760	4	The	the	DT
18637	8760	5	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8760	6	of	of	IN
18637	8760	7	the	the	DT
18637	8760	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	8760	9	of	of	IN
18637	8760	10	Soviet	Soviet	NNP
18637	8760	11	Socialist	Socialist	NNP
18637	8760	12	Republics	Republics	NNP
18637	8760	13	in	in	IN
18637	8760	14	1933	1933	CD
18637	8760	15	was	be	VBD
18637	8760	16	an	an	DT
18637	8760	17	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	8760	18	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8760	19	act	act	NN
18637	8760	20	.	.	.
18637	8761	1	THE	the	DT
18637	8761	2	POWER	POWER	NNP
18637	8761	3	OF	of	IN
18637	8761	4	NONRECOGNITION	nonrecognition	NN
18637	8761	5	The	the	DT
18637	8761	6	potentialities	potentiality	NNS
18637	8761	7	of	of	IN
18637	8761	8	nonrecognition	nonrecognition	NN
18637	8761	9	were	be	VBD
18637	8761	10	conspicuously	conspicuously	RB
18637	8761	11	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
18637	8761	12	by	by	IN
18637	8761	13	President	President	NNP
18637	8761	14	Woodrow	Woodrow	NNP
18637	8761	15	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	8761	16	when	when	WRB
18637	8761	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8761	18	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	8761	19	,	,	,
18637	8761	20	early	early	RB
18637	8761	21	in	in	IN
18637	8761	22	1913	1913	CD
18637	8761	23	,	,	,
18637	8761	24	to	to	TO
18637	8761	25	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	8761	26	Provisional	Provisional	NNP
18637	8761	27	President	President	NNP
18637	8761	28	Huerta	Huerta	NNP
18637	8761	29	as	as	IN
18637	8761	30	the	the	DT
18637	8761	31	_	_	NNP
18637	8761	32	de	de	FW
18637	8761	33	facto	facto	FW
18637	8761	34	_	_	NNP
18637	8761	35	government	government	NN
18637	8761	36	of	of	IN
18637	8761	37	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	8761	38	,	,	,
18637	8761	39	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	8761	40	contributing	contribute	VBG
18637	8761	41	materially	materially	RB
18637	8761	42	to	to	IN
18637	8761	43	Huerta	Huerta	NNP
18637	8761	44	's	's	POS
18637	8761	45	downfall	downfall	NN
18637	8761	46	the	the	DT
18637	8761	47	year	year	NN
18637	8761	48	following	follow	VBG
18637	8761	49	.	.	.
18637	8762	1	At	at	IN
18637	8762	2	the	the	DT
18637	8762	3	same	same	JJ
18637	8762	4	time	time	NN
18637	8762	5	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	8762	6	announced	announce	VBD
18637	8762	7	a	a	DT
18637	8762	8	general	general	JJ
18637	8762	9	policy	policy	NN
18637	8762	10	of	of	IN
18637	8762	11	nonrecognition	nonrecognition	NN
18637	8762	12	in	in	IN
18637	8762	13	the	the	DT
18637	8762	14	case	case	NN
18637	8762	15	of	of	IN
18637	8762	16	any	any	DT
18637	8762	17	government	government	NN
18637	8762	18	founded	found	VBN
18637	8762	19	on	on	IN
18637	8762	20	acts	act	NNS
18637	8762	21	of	of	IN
18637	8762	22	violence	violence	NN
18637	8762	23	;	;	:
18637	8762	24	and	and	CC
18637	8762	25	while	while	IN
18637	8762	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8762	27	observed	observe	VBD
18637	8762	28	this	this	DT
18637	8762	29	rule	rule	NN
18637	8762	30	with	with	IN
18637	8762	31	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	8762	32	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	8762	33	,	,	,
18637	8762	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8762	35	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	8762	36	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	8762	37	to	to	TO
18637	8762	38	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	8762	39	the	the	DT
18637	8762	40	Union	Union	NNP
18637	8762	41	of	of	IN
18637	8762	42	Soviet	Soviet	NNP
18637	8762	43	Socialist	Socialist	NNP
18637	8762	44	Republics	Republics	NNP
18637	8762	45	,	,	,
18637	8762	46	and	and	CC
18637	8762	47	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8762	48	successors	successor	NNS
18637	8762	49	prior	prior	RB
18637	8762	50	to	to	IN
18637	8762	51	President	President	NNP
18637	8762	52	Franklin	Franklin	NNP
18637	8762	53	D.	D.	NNP
18637	8762	54	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	8762	55	did	do	VBD
18637	8762	56	the	the	DT
18637	8762	57	same	same	JJ
18637	8762	58	.	.	.
18637	8763	1	The	the	DT
18637	8763	2	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	8763	3	of	of	IN
18637	8763	4	the	the	DT
18637	8763	5	Hoover	Hoover	NNP
18637	8763	6	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	8763	7	to	to	TO
18637	8763	8	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	8763	9	the	the	DT
18637	8763	10	independence	independence	NN
18637	8763	11	of	of	IN
18637	8763	12	the	the	DT
18637	8763	13	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	8763	14	puppet	puppet	NN
18637	8763	15	state	state	NN
18637	8763	16	of	of	IN
18637	8763	17	Manchukuo	Manchukuo	NNP
18637	8763	18	early	early	RB
18637	8763	19	in	in	IN
18637	8763	20	1932	1932	CD
18637	8763	21	was	be	VBD
18637	8763	22	based	base	VBN
18637	8763	23	on	on	IN
18637	8763	24	kindred	kindred	JJ
18637	8763	25	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	8763	26	.	.	.
18637	8764	1	Nonrecognition	nonrecognition	NN
18637	8764	2	of	of	IN
18637	8764	3	the	the	DT
18637	8764	4	Chinese	chinese	JJ
18637	8764	5	Communist	communist	JJ
18637	8764	6	government	government	NN
18637	8764	7	by	by	IN
18637	8764	8	the	the	DT
18637	8764	9	Truman	Truman	NNP
18637	8764	10	administration	administration	NN
18637	8764	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	8764	12	proved	prove	VBN
18637	8764	13	to	to	TO
18637	8764	14	be	be	VB
18637	8764	15	a	a	DT
18637	8764	16	decisive	decisive	JJ
18637	8764	17	element	element	NN
18637	8764	18	of	of	IN
18637	8764	19	the	the	DT
18637	8764	20	current	current	JJ
18637	8764	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8764	22	1952	1952	CD
18637	8764	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8764	24	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8764	25	policy	policy	NN
18637	8764	26	of	of	IN
18637	8764	27	the	the	DT
18637	8764	28	United	United	NNP
18637	8764	29	States	States	NNP
18637	8764	30	.	.	.
18637	8765	1	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	8765	2	AND	and	CC
18637	8765	3	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	8765	4	The	the	DT
18637	8765	5	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8765	6	of	of	IN
18637	8765	7	President	President	NNP
18637	8765	8	and	and	CC
18637	8765	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8765	10	in	in	IN
18637	8765	11	the	the	DT
18637	8765	12	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8765	13	field	field	NN
18637	8765	14	have	have	VBP
18637	8765	15	,	,	,
18637	8765	16	first	first	RB
18637	8765	17	and	and	CC
18637	8765	18	,	,	,
18637	8765	19	last	last	JJ
18637	8765	20	,	,	,
18637	8765	21	presented	present	VBD
18637	8765	22	a	a	DT
18637	8765	23	varied	varied	JJ
18637	8765	24	picture	picture	NN
18637	8765	25	of	of	IN
18637	8765	26	alternate	alternate	JJ
18637	8765	27	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	8765	28	and	and	CC
18637	8765	29	tension,[350	tension,[350	NNP
18637	8765	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8765	31	from	from	IN
18637	8765	32	which	which	WDT
18637	8765	33	emerge	emerge	NN
18637	8765	34	two	two	CD
18637	8765	35	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	8765	36	facts	fact	NNS
18637	8765	37	:	:	:
18637	8765	38	first	first	RB
18637	8765	39	,	,	,
18637	8765	40	the	the	DT
18637	8765	41	overwhelming	overwhelming	JJ
18637	8765	42	importance	importance	NN
18637	8765	43	of	of	IN
18637	8765	44	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8765	45	initiative	initiative	NN
18637	8765	46	in	in	IN
18637	8765	47	this	this	DT
18637	8765	48	area	area	NN
18637	8765	49	of	of	IN
18637	8765	50	power	power	NN
18637	8765	51	;	;	:
18637	8765	52	secondly	secondly	RB
18637	8765	53	,	,	,
18637	8765	54	the	the	DT
18637	8765	55	ever	ever	RB
18637	8765	56	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	8765	57	dependence	dependence	NN
18637	8765	58	of	of	IN
18637	8765	59	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8765	60	policy	policy	NN
18637	8765	61	on	on	IN
18637	8765	62	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	8765	63	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	8765	64	and	and	CC
18637	8765	65	support	support	NN
18637	8765	66	.	.	.
18637	8766	1	First	first	RB
18637	8766	2	one	one	CD
18637	8766	3	and	and	CC
18637	8766	4	then	then	RB
18637	8766	5	the	the	DT
18637	8766	6	other	other	JJ
18637	8766	7	aspect	aspect	NN
18637	8766	8	of	of	IN
18637	8766	9	the	the	DT
18637	8766	10	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	8766	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	8766	12	uppermost	uppermost	JJ
18637	8766	13	.	.	.
18637	8767	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	8767	2	the	the	DT
18637	8767	3	United	United	NNP
18637	8767	4	Nations	Nations	NNP
18637	8767	5	Participation	Participation	NNP
18637	8767	6	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8767	7	of	of	IN
18637	8767	8	December	December	NNP
18637	8767	9	20	20	CD
18637	8767	10	,	,	,
18637	8767	11	1945	1945	CD
18637	8767	12	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	8767	13	to	to	TO
18637	8767	14	contemplate	contemplate	VB
18637	8767	15	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	8767	16	between	between	IN
18637	8767	17	the	the	DT
18637	8767	18	President	President	NNP
18637	8767	19	and	and	CC
18637	8767	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8767	21	in	in	IN
18637	8767	22	the	the	DT
18637	8767	23	carrying	carrying	NN
18637	8767	24	out	out	IN
18637	8767	25	of	of	IN
18637	8767	26	the	the	DT
18637	8767	27	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8767	28	of	of	IN
18637	8767	29	the	the	DT
18637	8767	30	United	United	NNP
18637	8767	31	States	States	NNP
18637	8767	32	to	to	TO
18637	8767	33	back	back	VB
18637	8767	34	up	up	RP
18637	8767	35	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	8767	36	of	of	IN
18637	8767	37	the	the	DT
18637	8767	38	Security	Security	NNP
18637	8767	39	Council	Council	NNP
18637	8767	40	involving	involve	VBG
18637	8767	41	the	the	DT
18637	8767	42	use	use	NN
18637	8767	43	of	of	IN
18637	8767	44	armed	armed	JJ
18637	8767	45	force	force	NN
18637	8767	46	.	.	.
18637	8768	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8768	2	351	351	CD
18637	8768	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8768	4	When	when	WRB
18637	8768	5	,	,	,
18637	8768	6	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	8768	7	,	,	,
18637	8768	8	the	the	DT
18637	8768	9	first	first	JJ
18637	8768	10	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	8768	11	arose	arise	VBD
18637	8768	12	such	such	JJ
18637	8768	13	action	action	NN
18637	8768	14	,	,	,
18637	8768	15	namely	namely	RB
18637	8768	16	,	,	,
18637	8768	17	to	to	TO
18637	8768	18	repel	repel	VB
18637	8768	19	the	the	DT
18637	8768	20	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	8768	21	in	in	IN
18637	8768	22	June	June	NNP
18637	8768	23	,	,	,
18637	8768	24	1950	1950	CD
18637	8768	25	of	of	IN
18637	8768	26	South	South	NNP
18637	8768	27	Korea	Korea	NNP
18637	8768	28	by	by	IN
18637	8768	29	North	north	JJ
18637	8768	30	Korean	korean	JJ
18637	8768	31	forces	force	NNS
18637	8768	32	,	,	,
18637	8768	33	no	no	DT
18637	8768	34	such	such	JJ
18637	8768	35	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	8768	36	had	have	VBD
18637	8768	37	been	be	VBN
18637	8768	38	negotiated	negotiate	VBN
18637	8768	39	,	,	,
18637	8768	40	and	and	CC
18637	8768	41	the	the	DT
18637	8768	42	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	8768	43	of	of	IN
18637	8768	44	the	the	DT
18637	8768	45	United	United	NNP
18637	8768	46	States	States	NNP
18637	8768	47	was	be	VBD
18637	8768	48	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	8768	49	by	by	IN
18637	8768	50	the	the	DT
18637	8768	51	President	President	NNP
18637	8768	52	without	without	IN
18637	8768	53	referring	refer	VBG
18637	8768	54	the	the	DT
18637	8768	55	question	question	NN
18637	8768	56	to	to	IN
18637	8768	57	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8768	58	.	.	.
18637	8769	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8769	2	352	352	CD
18637	8769	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8769	4	CONGRESSIONAL	congressional	JJ
18637	8769	5	IMPLEMENTATION	IMPLEMENTATION	NNS
18637	8769	6	OF	of	IN
18637	8769	7	PRESIDENTIAL	presidential	JJ
18637	8769	8	POLICIES	policy	NNS
18637	8769	9	No	No	NNP
18637	8769	10	President	President	NNP
18637	8769	11	was	be	VBD
18637	8769	12	ever	ever	RB
18637	8769	13	more	more	RBR
18637	8769	14	jealous	jealous	JJ
18637	8769	15	of	of	IN
18637	8769	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8769	17	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	8769	18	in	in	IN
18637	8769	19	the	the	DT
18637	8769	20	realm	realm	NN
18637	8769	21	of	of	IN
18637	8769	22	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8769	23	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8769	24	than	than	IN
18637	8769	25	President	President	NNP
18637	8769	26	Woodrow	Woodrow	NNP
18637	8769	27	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	8769	28	.	.	.
18637	8770	1	When	when	WRB
18637	8770	2	,	,	,
18637	8770	3	however	however	RB
18637	8770	4	,	,	,
18637	8770	5	strong	strong	JJ
18637	8770	6	pressure	pressure	NN
18637	8770	7	was	be	VBD
18637	8770	8	brought	bring	VBN
18637	8770	9	to	to	TO
18637	8770	10	bear	bear	VB
18637	8770	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	8770	12	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8770	13	by	by	IN
18637	8770	14	Great	Great	NNP
18637	8770	15	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	8770	16	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	8770	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8770	18	Mexican	Mexican	NNP
18637	8770	19	Policy	Policy	NNP
18637	8770	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8770	21	was	be	VBD
18637	8770	22	constrained	constrain	VBN
18637	8770	23	to	to	TO
18637	8770	24	go	go	VB
18637	8770	25	before	before	IN
18637	8770	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8770	27	and	and	CC
18637	8770	28	ask	ask	VB
18637	8770	29	for	for	IN
18637	8770	30	a	a	DT
18637	8770	31	modification	modification	NN
18637	8770	32	of	of	IN
18637	8770	33	the	the	DT
18637	8770	34	Panama	Panama	NNP
18637	8770	35	Tolls	Tolls	NNPS
18637	8770	36	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8770	37	of	of	IN
18637	8770	38	1911	1911	CD
18637	8770	39	,	,	,
18637	8770	40	which	which	WDT
18637	8770	41	had	have	VBD
18637	8770	42	also	also	RB
18637	8770	43	aroused	arouse	VBN
18637	8770	44	British	british	JJ
18637	8770	45	ire	ire	NN
18637	8770	46	.	.	.
18637	8771	1	Addressing	address	VBG
18637	8771	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8771	3	,	,	,
18637	8771	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8771	5	said	say	VBD
18637	8771	6	"	"	``
18637	8771	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8771	8	ask	ask	VBP
18637	8771	9	this	this	DT
18637	8771	10	of	of	IN
18637	8771	11	you	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8771	12	in	in	IN
18637	8771	13	support	support	NN
18637	8771	14	of	of	IN
18637	8771	15	the	the	DT
18637	8771	16	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8771	17	policy	policy	NN
18637	8771	18	of	of	IN
18637	8771	19	the	the	DT
18637	8771	20	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	8771	21	.	.	.
18637	8772	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8772	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	8772	3	not	not	RB
18637	8772	4	know	know	VB
18637	8772	5	how	how	WRB
18637	8772	6	to	to	TO
18637	8772	7	deal	deal	VB
18637	8772	8	with	with	IN
18637	8772	9	other	other	JJ
18637	8772	10	matters	matter	NNS
18637	8772	11	of	of	IN
18637	8772	12	even	even	RB
18637	8772	13	greater	great	JJR
18637	8772	14	delicacy	delicacy	NN
18637	8772	15	and	and	CC
18637	8772	16	nearer	near	JJR
18637	8772	17	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	8772	18	if	if	IN
18637	8772	19	you	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8772	20	do	do	VBP
18637	8772	21	not	not	RB
18637	8772	22	grant	grant	VB
18637	8772	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8772	24	to	to	IN
18637	8772	25	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8772	26	in	in	IN
18637	8772	27	ungrudging	ungrudging	JJ
18637	8772	28	measure	measure	NN
18637	8772	29	.	.	.
18637	8773	1	"	"	``
18637	8773	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8773	3	353	353	CD
18637	8773	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8773	5	The	the	DT
18637	8773	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	8773	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	8773	8	,	,	,
18637	8773	9	of	of	IN
18637	8773	10	course	course	NN
18637	8773	11	,	,	,
18637	8773	12	that	that	IN
18637	8773	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8773	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	8773	15	enormous	enormous	JJ
18637	8773	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	8773	17	the	the	DT
18637	8773	18	support	support	NN
18637	8773	19	of	of	IN
18637	8773	20	which	which	WDT
18637	8773	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	8773	22	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
18637	8773	23	to	to	IN
18637	8773	24	any	any	DT
18637	8773	25	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8773	26	policy	policy	NN
18637	8773	27	.	.	.
18637	8774	1	In	in	IN
18637	8774	2	the	the	DT
18637	8774	3	long	long	JJ
18637	8774	4	run	run	NN
18637	8774	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8774	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	8774	7	the	the	DT
18637	8774	8	body	body	NN
18637	8774	9	that	that	WDT
18637	8774	10	lays	lay	VBZ
18637	8774	11	and	and	CC
18637	8774	12	collects	collect	VBZ
18637	8774	13	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	8774	14	for	for	IN
18637	8774	15	the	the	DT
18637	8774	16	common	common	JJ
18637	8774	17	defense	defense	NN
18637	8774	18	,	,	,
18637	8774	19	that	that	WDT
18637	8774	20	creates	create	VBZ
18637	8774	21	armies	army	NNS
18637	8774	22	and	and	CC
18637	8774	23	maintains	maintain	VBZ
18637	8774	24	navies	navy	NNS
18637	8774	25	,	,	,
18637	8774	26	although	although	IN
18637	8774	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8774	28	does	do	VBZ
18637	8774	29	not	not	RB
18637	8774	30	direct	direct	VB
18637	8774	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8774	32	,	,	,
18637	8774	33	that	that	WDT
18637	8774	34	pledges	pledge	VBZ
18637	8774	35	the	the	DT
18637	8774	36	public	public	JJ
18637	8774	37	credit	credit	NN
18637	8774	38	,	,	,
18637	8774	39	that	that	WDT
18637	8774	40	declares	declare	VBZ
18637	8774	41	war	war	NN
18637	8774	42	,	,	,
18637	8774	43	that	that	WDT
18637	8774	44	defines	define	VBZ
18637	8774	45	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	8774	46	against	against	IN
18637	8774	47	the	the	DT
18637	8774	48	law	law	NN
18637	8774	49	of	of	IN
18637	8774	50	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8774	51	,	,	,
18637	8774	52	that	that	WDT
18637	8774	53	regulates	regulate	VBZ
18637	8774	54	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8774	55	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	8774	56	;	;	:
18637	8774	57	and	and	CC
18637	8774	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8774	59	has	have	VBZ
18637	8774	60	the	the	DT
18637	8774	61	further	further	JJ
18637	8774	62	power	power	NN
18637	8774	63	"	"	''
18637	8774	64	to	to	TO
18637	8774	65	make	make	VB
18637	8774	66	all	all	DT
18637	8774	67	laws	law	NNS
18637	8774	68	which	which	WDT
18637	8774	69	shall	shall	MD
18637	8774	70	be	be	VB
18637	8774	71	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8774	72	and	and	CC
18637	8774	73	proper"--that	proper"--that	NN
18637	8774	74	is	be	VBZ
18637	8774	75	,	,	,
18637	8774	76	which	which	WDT
18637	8774	77	_	_	NNP
18637	8774	78	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8774	79	_	_	NNP
18637	8774	80	deems	deem	VBZ
18637	8774	81	to	to	TO
18637	8774	82	be	be	VB
18637	8774	83	such	such	JJ
18637	8774	84	--	--	:
18637	8774	85	for	for	IN
18637	8774	86	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	8774	87	into	into	IN
18637	8774	88	execution	execution	NN
18637	8774	89	not	not	RB
18637	8774	90	only	only	RB
18637	8774	91	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8774	92	own	own	JJ
18637	8774	93	powers	power	NNS
18637	8774	94	but	but	CC
18637	8774	95	all	all	PDT
18637	8774	96	the	the	DT
18637	8774	97	powers	power	NNS
18637	8774	98	"	"	''
18637	8774	99	of	of	IN
18637	8774	100	the	the	DT
18637	8774	101	government	government	NN
18637	8774	102	of	of	IN
18637	8774	103	the	the	DT
18637	8774	104	United	United	NNP
18637	8774	105	States	States	NNP
18637	8774	106	and	and	CC
18637	8774	107	of	of	IN
18637	8774	108	any	any	DT
18637	8774	109	department	department	NN
18637	8774	110	or	or	CC
18637	8774	111	officer	officer	NN
18637	8774	112	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8774	113	.	.	.
18637	8774	114	"	"	''
18637	8775	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	8775	2	,	,	,
18637	8775	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8775	4	laws	law	NNS
18637	8775	5	made	make	VBD
18637	8775	6	"	"	``
18637	8775	7	in	in	IN
18637	8775	8	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	8775	9	"	"	''
18637	8775	10	of	of	IN
18637	8775	11	these	these	DT
18637	8775	12	powers	power	NNS
18637	8775	13	are	be	VBP
18637	8775	14	"	"	``
18637	8775	15	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	8775	16	law	law	NN
18637	8775	17	of	of	IN
18637	8775	18	the	the	DT
18637	8775	19	land	land	NN
18637	8775	20	"	"	''
18637	8775	21	and	and	CC
18637	8775	22	the	the	DT
18637	8775	23	President	President	NNP
18637	8775	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	8775	25	bound	bind	VBN
18637	8775	26	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	8775	27	to	to	TO
18637	8775	28	"	"	``
18637	8775	29	take	take	VB
18637	8775	30	care	care	NN
18637	8775	31	that	that	IN
18637	8775	32	"	"	``
18637	8775	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8775	34	"	"	``
18637	8775	35	be	be	VB
18637	8775	36	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8775	37	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8775	38	.	.	.
18637	8775	39	"	"	''
18637	8776	1	In	in	IN
18637	8776	2	point	point	NN
18637	8776	3	of	of	IN
18637	8776	4	fact	fact	NN
18637	8776	5	,	,	,
18637	8776	6	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	8776	7	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8776	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	8776	9	operated	operate	VBN
18637	8776	10	to	to	IN
18637	8776	11	augment	augment	JJ
18637	8776	12	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8776	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	8776	14	in	in	IN
18637	8776	15	the	the	DT
18637	8776	16	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8776	17	field	field	NN
18637	8776	18	much	much	RB
18637	8776	19	more	more	RBR
18637	8776	20	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	8776	21	than	than	IN
18637	8776	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8776	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	8776	24	to	to	TO
18637	8776	25	curtail	curtail	VB
18637	8776	26	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8776	27	.	.	.
18637	8777	1	The	the	DT
18637	8777	2	Lend	Lend	NNP
18637	8777	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	8777	4	Lease	Lease	NNP
18637	8777	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8777	6	of	of	IN
18637	8777	7	March	March	NNP
18637	8777	8	11	11	CD
18637	8777	9	,	,	,
18637	8777	10	1941[354	1941[354	CD
18637	8777	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8777	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	8777	13	the	the	DT
18637	8777	14	classic	classic	JJ
18637	8777	15	example	example	NN
18637	8777	16	,	,	,
18637	8777	17	although	although	IN
18637	8777	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8777	19	only	only	RB
18637	8777	20	brought	bring	VBD
18637	8777	21	to	to	TO
18637	8777	22	culmination	culmination	VB
18637	8777	23	a	a	DT
18637	8777	24	whole	whole	JJ
18637	8777	25	series	series	NN
18637	8777	26	of	of	IN
18637	8777	27	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	8777	28	with	with	IN
18637	8777	29	which	which	WDT
18637	8777	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8777	31	had	have	VBD
18637	8777	32	aided	aid	VBN
18637	8777	33	and	and	CC
18637	8777	34	abetted	abet	VBN
18637	8777	35	the	the	DT
18637	8777	36	administration	administration	NN
18637	8777	37	's	's	POS
18637	8777	38	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8777	39	policy	policy	NN
18637	8777	40	in	in	IN
18637	8777	41	the	the	DT
18637	8777	42	years	year	NNS
18637	8777	43	between	between	IN
18637	8777	44	1934	1934	CD
18637	8777	45	and	and	CC
18637	8777	46	1941	1941	CD
18637	8777	47	.	.	.
18637	8778	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8778	2	355	355	LS
18637	8778	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8778	4	THE	the	DT
18637	8778	5	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNP
18637	8778	6	OF	of	IN
18637	8778	7	POLITICAL	political	JJ
18637	8778	8	QUESTIONS	questions	NN
18637	8778	9	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8778	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	8778	11	not	not	RB
18637	8778	12	within	within	IN
18637	8778	13	the	the	DT
18637	8778	14	province	province	NN
18637	8778	15	of	of	IN
18637	8778	16	the	the	DT
18637	8778	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	8778	18	to	to	TO
18637	8778	19	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	8778	20	into	into	IN
18637	8778	21	the	the	DT
18637	8778	22	policy	policy	NN
18637	8778	23	underlying	underlying	JJ
18637	8778	24	action	action	NN
18637	8778	25	taken	take	VBN
18637	8778	26	by	by	IN
18637	8778	27	the	the	DT
18637	8778	28	"	"	``
18637	8778	29	political	political	JJ
18637	8778	30	departments"--Congress	departments"--congress	NN
18637	8778	31	and	and	CC
18637	8778	32	the	the	DT
18637	8778	33	President	President	NNP
18637	8778	34	--	--	:
18637	8778	35	in	in	IN
18637	8778	36	the	the	DT
18637	8778	37	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	8778	38	of	of	IN
18637	8778	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8778	40	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	8778	41	powers	power	NNS
18637	8778	42	.	.	.
18637	8779	1	This	this	DT
18637	8779	2	commonplace	commonplace	JJ
18637	8779	3	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	8779	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	8779	5	,	,	,
18637	8779	6	however	however	RB
18637	8779	7	,	,	,
18637	8779	8	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	8779	9	given	give	VBN
18637	8779	10	an	an	DT
18637	8779	11	enlarged	enlarged	JJ
18637	8779	12	application	application	NN
18637	8779	13	so	so	IN
18637	8779	14	as	as	IN
18637	8779	15	to	to	TO
18637	8779	16	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	8779	17	questions	question	NNS
18637	8779	18	as	as	IN
18637	8779	19	to	to	IN
18637	8779	20	the	the	DT
18637	8779	21	existence	existence	NN
18637	8779	22	of	of	IN
18637	8779	23	facts	fact	NNS
18637	8779	24	and	and	CC
18637	8779	25	even	even	RB
18637	8779	26	questions	question	NNS
18637	8779	27	of	of	IN
18637	8779	28	law	law	NN
18637	8779	29	which	which	WDT
18637	8779	30	the	the	DT
18637	8779	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8779	32	would	would	MD
18637	8779	33	normally	normally	RB
18637	8779	34	regard	regard	VB
18637	8779	35	as	as	IN
18637	8779	36	falling	fall	VBG
18637	8779	37	within	within	IN
18637	8779	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8779	39	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	8779	40	.	.	.
18637	8780	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	8780	2	questions	question	NNS
18637	8780	3	are	be	VBP
18637	8780	4	termed	term	VBN
18637	8780	5	"	"	``
18637	8780	6	political	political	JJ
18637	8780	7	questions	question	NNS
18637	8780	8	,	,	,
18637	8780	9	"	"	''
18637	8780	10	and	and	CC
18637	8780	11	are	be	VBP
18637	8780	12	especially	especially	RB
18637	8780	13	common	common	JJ
18637	8780	14	in	in	IN
18637	8780	15	the	the	DT
18637	8780	16	field	field	NN
18637	8780	17	of	of	IN
18637	8780	18	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8780	19	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8780	20	.	.	.
18637	8781	1	The	the	DT
18637	8781	2	leading	leading	JJ
18637	8781	3	case	case	NN
18637	8781	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	8781	5	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	8781	6	_	_	NNP
18637	8781	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	8781	8	_	_	NNP
18637	8781	9	Neilson,[356	Neilson,[356	NNP
18637	8781	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8781	11	where	where	WRB
18637	8781	12	the	the	DT
18637	8781	13	matter	matter	NN
18637	8781	14	in	in	IN
18637	8781	15	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	8781	16	was	be	VBD
18637	8781	17	the	the	DT
18637	8781	18	validity	validity	NN
18637	8781	19	of	of	IN
18637	8781	20	a	a	DT
18637	8781	21	grant	grant	NN
18637	8781	22	made	make	VBN
18637	8781	23	by	by	IN
18637	8781	24	the	the	DT
18637	8781	25	Spanish	spanish	JJ
18637	8781	26	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8781	27	in	in	IN
18637	8781	28	1804	1804	CD
18637	8781	29	of	of	IN
18637	8781	30	land	land	NN
18637	8781	31	lying	lie	VBG
18637	8781	32	to	to	IN
18637	8781	33	the	the	DT
18637	8781	34	east	east	NN
18637	8781	35	of	of	IN
18637	8781	36	the	the	DT
18637	8781	37	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	8781	38	River	River	NNP
18637	8781	39	,	,	,
18637	8781	40	involved	involve	VBN
18637	8781	41	with	with	IN
18637	8781	42	which	which	WDT
18637	8781	43	question	question	NN
18637	8781	44	was	be	VBD
18637	8781	45	the	the	DT
18637	8781	46	further	further	JJ
18637	8781	47	one	one	NN
18637	8781	48	whether	whether	IN
18637	8781	49	the	the	DT
18637	8781	50	region	region	NN
18637	8781	51	between	between	IN
18637	8781	52	the	the	DT
18637	8781	53	Perdido	Perdido	NNP
18637	8781	54	and	and	CC
18637	8781	55	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	8781	56	Rivers	Rivers	NNP
18637	8781	57	belonged	belong	VBD
18637	8781	58	in	in	IN
18637	8781	59	1804	1804	CD
18637	8781	60	to	to	IN
18637	8781	61	Spain	Spain	NNP
18637	8781	62	or	or	CC
18637	8781	63	the	the	DT
18637	8781	64	United	United	NNP
18637	8781	65	States	States	NNP
18637	8781	66	.	.	.
18637	8782	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8782	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8782	3	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	8782	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	8782	5	that	that	IN
18637	8782	6	the	the	DT
18637	8782	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8782	8	was	be	VBD
18637	8782	9	bound	bind	VBN
18637	8782	10	by	by	IN
18637	8782	11	the	the	DT
18637	8782	12	action	action	NN
18637	8782	13	of	of	IN
18637	8782	14	the	the	DT
18637	8782	15	political	political	JJ
18637	8782	16	departments	department	NNS
18637	8782	17	,	,	,
18637	8782	18	the	the	DT
18637	8782	19	President	President	NNP
18637	8782	20	and	and	CC
18637	8782	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8782	22	,	,	,
18637	8782	23	in	in	IN
18637	8782	24	claiming	claim	VBG
18637	8782	25	the	the	DT
18637	8782	26	land	land	NN
18637	8782	27	for	for	IN
18637	8782	28	the	the	DT
18637	8782	29	United	United	NNP
18637	8782	30	States	States	NNP
18637	8782	31	.	.	.
18637	8783	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8783	2	said	say	VBD
18637	8783	3	:	:	:
18637	8783	4	"	"	``
18637	8783	5	If	if	IN
18637	8783	6	those	those	DT
18637	8783	7	departments	department	NNS
18637	8783	8	which	which	WDT
18637	8783	9	are	be	VBP
18637	8783	10	intrusted	intrust	VBN
18637	8783	11	with	with	IN
18637	8783	12	the	the	DT
18637	8783	13	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8783	14	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	8783	15	of	of	IN
18637	8783	16	the	the	DT
18637	8783	17	nation	nation	NN
18637	8783	18	,	,	,
18637	8783	19	which	which	WDT
18637	8783	20	assert	assert	VBP
18637	8783	21	and	and	CC
18637	8783	22	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	8783	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8783	24	interests	interest	NNS
18637	8783	25	against	against	IN
18637	8783	26	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8783	27	powers	power	NNS
18637	8783	28	,	,	,
18637	8783	29	have	have	VBP
18637	8783	30	unequivocally	unequivocally	RB
18637	8783	31	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	8783	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8783	33	right	right	NN
18637	8783	34	of	of	IN
18637	8783	35	dominion	dominion	NN
18637	8783	36	over	over	IN
18637	8783	37	a	a	DT
18637	8783	38	country	country	NN
18637	8783	39	of	of	IN
18637	8783	40	which	which	WDT
18637	8783	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8783	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	8783	43	in	in	IN
18637	8783	44	possession	possession	NN
18637	8783	45	,	,	,
18637	8783	46	and	and	CC
18637	8783	47	which	which	WDT
18637	8783	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8783	49	claims	claim	VBZ
18637	8783	50	under	under	IN
18637	8783	51	a	a	DT
18637	8783	52	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8783	53	;	;	:
18637	8783	54	if	if	IN
18637	8783	55	the	the	DT
18637	8783	56	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	8783	57	has	have	VBZ
18637	8783	58	acted	act	VBN
18637	8783	59	on	on	IN
18637	8783	60	the	the	DT
18637	8783	61	construction	construction	NN
18637	8783	62	thus	thus	RB
18637	8783	63	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	8783	64	,	,	,
18637	8783	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8783	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	8783	67	not	not	RB
18637	8783	68	in	in	IN
18637	8783	69	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8783	70	own	own	JJ
18637	8783	71	courts	court	NNS
18637	8783	72	that	that	WDT
18637	8783	73	this	this	DT
18637	8783	74	construction	construction	NN
18637	8783	75	is	be	VBZ
18637	8783	76	to	to	TO
18637	8783	77	be	be	VB
18637	8783	78	denied	deny	VBN
18637	8783	79	.	.	.
18637	8784	1	A	a	DT
18637	8784	2	question	question	NN
18637	8784	3	like	like	IN
18637	8784	4	this	this	DT
18637	8784	5	,	,	,
18637	8784	6	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	8784	7	the	the	DT
18637	8784	8	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	8784	9	of	of	IN
18637	8784	10	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8784	11	,	,	,
18637	8784	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	8784	13	,	,	,
18637	8784	14	as	as	IN
18637	8784	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	8784	16	been	be	VBN
18637	8784	17	truly	truly	RB
18637	8784	18	said	say	VBN
18637	8784	19	,	,	,
18637	8784	20	more	more	RBR
18637	8784	21	a	a	DT
18637	8784	22	political	political	JJ
18637	8784	23	than	than	IN
18637	8784	24	a	a	DT
18637	8784	25	legal	legal	JJ
18637	8784	26	question	question	NN
18637	8784	27	,	,	,
18637	8784	28	and	and	CC
18637	8784	29	in	in	IN
18637	8784	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8784	31	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	8784	32	,	,	,
18637	8784	33	the	the	DT
18637	8784	34	courts	court	NNS
18637	8784	35	of	of	IN
18637	8784	36	every	every	DT
18637	8784	37	country	country	NN
18637	8784	38	must	must	MD
18637	8784	39	respect	respect	VB
18637	8784	40	the	the	DT
18637	8784	41	pronounced	pronounced	JJ
18637	8784	42	will	will	NN
18637	8784	43	of	of	IN
18637	8784	44	the	the	DT
18637	8784	45	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	8784	46	.	.	.
18637	8785	1	"	"	``
18637	8785	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8785	3	357	357	CD
18637	8785	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8785	5	The	the	DT
18637	8785	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	8785	7	thus	thus	RB
18637	8785	8	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	8785	9	stated	state	VBN
18637	8785	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	8785	11	further	further	RB
18637	8785	12	exemplified	exemplify	VBN
18637	8785	13	,	,	,
18637	8785	14	with	with	IN
18637	8785	15	particular	particular	JJ
18637	8785	16	reference	reference	NN
18637	8785	17	to	to	IN
18637	8785	18	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8785	19	action	action	NN
18637	8785	20	,	,	,
18637	8785	21	by	by	IN
18637	8785	22	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	8785	23	_	_	NNP
18637	8785	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	8785	25	_	_	NNP
18637	8785	26	The	the	DT
18637	8785	27	Suffolk	Suffolk	NNP
18637	8785	28	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	8785	29	Company	Company	NNP
18637	8785	30	.	.	.
18637	8786	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8786	2	358	358	CD
18637	8786	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8786	4	In	in	IN
18637	8786	5	this	this	DT
18637	8786	6	case	case	NN
18637	8786	7	the	the	DT
18637	8786	8	underwriters	underwriter	NNS
18637	8786	9	of	of	IN
18637	8786	10	a	a	DT
18637	8786	11	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	8786	12	which	which	WDT
18637	8786	13	had	have	VBD
18637	8786	14	been	be	VBN
18637	8786	15	confiscated	confiscate	VBN
18637	8786	16	by	by	IN
18637	8786	17	the	the	DT
18637	8786	18	Argentine	Argentine	NNP
18637	8786	19	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8786	20	for	for	IN
18637	8786	21	catching	catch	VBG
18637	8786	22	seals	seal	NNS
18637	8786	23	off	off	IN
18637	8786	24	the	the	DT
18637	8786	25	Falkland	Falkland	NNP
18637	8786	26	Islands	Islands	NNPS
18637	8786	27	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	8786	28	to	to	IN
18637	8786	29	that	that	DT
18637	8786	30	government	government	NN
18637	8786	31	's	's	POS
18637	8786	32	orders	order	NNS
18637	8786	33	sought	seek	VBD
18637	8786	34	to	to	TO
18637	8786	35	escape	escape	VB
18637	8786	36	liability	liability	NN
18637	8786	37	by	by	IN
18637	8786	38	showing	show	VBG
18637	8786	39	that	that	IN
18637	8786	40	the	the	DT
18637	8786	41	Argentinian	argentinian	JJ
18637	8786	42	government	government	NN
18637	8786	43	was	be	VBD
18637	8786	44	the	the	DT
18637	8786	45	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	8786	46	over	over	IN
18637	8786	47	these	these	DT
18637	8786	48	islands	island	NNS
18637	8786	49	and	and	CC
18637	8786	50	that	that	IN
18637	8786	51	,	,	,
18637	8786	52	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	8786	53	,	,	,
18637	8786	54	the	the	DT
18637	8786	55	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	8786	56	had	have	VBD
18637	8786	57	been	be	VBN
18637	8786	58	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	8786	59	for	for	IN
18637	8786	60	wilful	wilful	JJ
18637	8786	61	disregard	disregard	NN
18637	8786	62	of	of	IN
18637	8786	63	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	8786	64	authority	authority	NN
18637	8786	65	.	.	.
18637	8787	1	The	the	DT
18637	8787	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8787	3	decided	decide	VBD
18637	8787	4	against	against	IN
18637	8787	5	the	the	DT
18637	8787	6	company	company	NN
18637	8787	7	on	on	IN
18637	8787	8	the	the	DT
18637	8787	9	ground	ground	NN
18637	8787	10	that	that	IN
18637	8787	11	the	the	DT
18637	8787	12	President	President	NNP
18637	8787	13	had	have	VBD
18637	8787	14	taken	take	VBN
18637	8787	15	the	the	DT
18637	8787	16	position	position	NN
18637	8787	17	that	that	IN
18637	8787	18	the	the	DT
18637	8787	19	Falkland	Falkland	NNP
18637	8787	20	Islands	Islands	NNPS
18637	8787	21	were	be	VBD
18637	8787	22	not	not	RB
18637	8787	23	a	a	DT
18637	8787	24	part	part	NN
18637	8787	25	of	of	IN
18637	8787	26	Argentina	Argentina	NNP
18637	8787	27	.	.	.
18637	8788	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8788	2	said	say	VBD
18637	8788	3	:	:	:
18637	8788	4	"	"	``
18637	8788	5	Can	Can	MD
18637	8788	6	there	there	EX
18637	8788	7	be	be	VB
18637	8788	8	any	any	DT
18637	8788	9	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	8788	10	,	,	,
18637	8788	11	that	that	IN
18637	8788	12	when	when	WRB
18637	8788	13	the	the	DT
18637	8788	14	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8788	15	branch	branch	NN
18637	8788	16	of	of	IN
18637	8788	17	the	the	DT
18637	8788	18	government	government	NN
18637	8788	19	,	,	,
18637	8788	20	which	which	WDT
18637	8788	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	8788	22	charged	charge	VBN
18637	8788	23	with	with	IN
18637	8788	24	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8788	25	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8788	26	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8788	27	,	,	,
18637	8788	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	8788	29	,	,	,
18637	8788	30	in	in	IN
18637	8788	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8788	32	correspondence	correspondence	NN
18637	8788	33	with	with	IN
18637	8788	34	a	a	DT
18637	8788	35	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8788	36	nation	nation	NN
18637	8788	37	,	,	,
18637	8788	38	assume	assume	VB
18637	8788	39	a	a	DT
18637	8788	40	fact	fact	NN
18637	8788	41	in	in	IN
18637	8788	42	regard	regard	NN
18637	8788	43	to	to	IN
18637	8788	44	the	the	DT
18637	8788	45	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	8788	46	of	of	IN
18637	8788	47	any	any	DT
18637	8788	48	island	island	NN
18637	8788	49	or	or	CC
18637	8788	50	country	country	NN
18637	8788	51	,	,	,
18637	8788	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8788	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	8788	54	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	8788	55	on	on	IN
18637	8788	56	the	the	DT
18637	8788	57	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8788	58	department	department	NN
18637	8788	59	?	?	.
18637	8789	1	And	and	CC
18637	8789	2	in	in	IN
18637	8789	3	this	this	DT
18637	8789	4	view	view	NN
18637	8789	5	,	,	,
18637	8789	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8789	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	8789	8	not	not	RB
18637	8789	9	material	material	JJ
18637	8789	10	to	to	TO
18637	8789	11	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	8789	12	,	,	,
18637	8789	13	nor	nor	CC
18637	8789	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8789	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8789	16	the	the	DT
18637	8789	17	province	province	NN
18637	8789	18	of	of	IN
18637	8789	19	the	the	DT
18637	8789	20	court	court	NN
18637	8789	21	to	to	TO
18637	8789	22	determine	determine	VB
18637	8789	23	,	,	,
18637	8789	24	whether	whether	IN
18637	8789	25	the	the	DT
18637	8789	26	executive	executive	NN
18637	8789	27	be	be	VB
18637	8789	28	right	right	JJ
18637	8789	29	or	or	CC
18637	8789	30	wrong	wrong	JJ
18637	8789	31	.	.	.
18637	8790	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8790	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8790	3	enough	enough	JJ
18637	8790	4	to	to	TO
18637	8790	5	know	know	VB
18637	8790	6	,	,	,
18637	8790	7	that	that	IN
18637	8790	8	in	in	IN
18637	8790	9	the	the	DT
18637	8790	10	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	8790	11	of	of	IN
18637	8790	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8790	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8790	14	functions	function	NNS
18637	8790	15	,	,	,
18637	8790	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8790	17	had	have	VBD
18637	8790	18	decided	decide	VBN
18637	8790	19	the	the	DT
18637	8790	20	question	question	NN
18637	8790	21	.	.	.
18637	8791	1	Having	have	VBG
18637	8791	2	done	do	VBN
18637	8791	3	this	this	DT
18637	8791	4	,	,	,
18637	8791	5	under	under	IN
18637	8791	6	the	the	DT
18637	8791	7	responsibilities	responsibility	NNS
18637	8791	8	which	which	WDT
18637	8791	9	belong	belong	VBP
18637	8791	10	to	to	IN
18637	8791	11	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8791	12	,	,	,
18637	8791	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8791	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8791	15	obligatory	obligatory	JJ
18637	8791	16	on	on	IN
18637	8791	17	the	the	DT
18637	8791	18	people	people	NNS
18637	8791	19	and	and	CC
18637	8791	20	government	government	NN
18637	8791	21	of	of	IN
18637	8791	22	the	the	DT
18637	8791	23	Union	Union	NNP
18637	8791	24	.	.	.
18637	8792	1	If	if	IN
18637	8792	2	this	this	DT
18637	8792	3	were	be	VBD
18637	8792	4	not	not	RB
18637	8792	5	the	the	DT
18637	8792	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	8792	7	,	,	,
18637	8792	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	8792	9	might	may	MD
18637	8792	10	often	often	RB
18637	8792	11	arise	arise	VB
18637	8792	12	,	,	,
18637	8792	13	in	in	IN
18637	8792	14	which	which	WDT
18637	8792	15	,	,	,
18637	8792	16	on	on	IN
18637	8792	17	most	most	RBS
18637	8792	18	important	important	JJ
18637	8792	19	questions	question	NNS
18637	8792	20	of	of	IN
18637	8792	21	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8792	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	8792	23	,	,	,
18637	8792	24	there	there	EX
18637	8792	25	would	would	MD
18637	8792	26	be	be	VB
18637	8792	27	an	an	DT
18637	8792	28	irreconcilable	irreconcilable	JJ
18637	8792	29	difference	difference	NN
18637	8792	30	between	between	IN
18637	8792	31	the	the	DT
18637	8792	32	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8792	33	and	and	CC
18637	8792	34	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8792	35	departments	department	NNS
18637	8792	36	.	.	.
18637	8793	1	By	by	IN
18637	8793	2	one	one	CD
18637	8793	3	of	of	IN
18637	8793	4	these	these	DT
18637	8793	5	departments	department	NNS
18637	8793	6	,	,	,
18637	8793	7	a	a	DT
18637	8793	8	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8793	9	island	island	NN
18637	8793	10	or	or	CC
18637	8793	11	country	country	NN
18637	8793	12	might	may	MD
18637	8793	13	be	be	VB
18637	8793	14	considered	consider	VBN
18637	8793	15	as	as	IN
18637	8793	16	at	at	IN
18637	8793	17	peace	peace	NN
18637	8793	18	with	with	IN
18637	8793	19	the	the	DT
18637	8793	20	United	United	NNP
18637	8793	21	States	States	NNP
18637	8793	22	;	;	:
18637	8793	23	whilst	whilst	IN
18637	8793	24	the	the	DT
18637	8793	25	other	other	JJ
18637	8793	26	would	would	MD
18637	8793	27	consider	consider	VB
18637	8793	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8793	29	in	in	IN
18637	8793	30	a	a	DT
18637	8793	31	state	state	NN
18637	8793	32	of	of	IN
18637	8793	33	war	war	NN
18637	8793	34	.	.	.
18637	8794	1	No	no	UH
18637	8794	2	well	well	RB
18637	8794	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	8794	4	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	8794	5	government	government	NN
18637	8794	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	8794	7	ever	ever	RB
18637	8794	8	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
18637	8794	9	a	a	DT
18637	8794	10	principle	principle	NN
18637	8794	11	so	so	RB
18637	8794	12	unwise	unwise	JJ
18637	8794	13	,	,	,
18637	8794	14	and	and	CC
18637	8794	15	so	so	RB
18637	8794	16	destructive	destructive	JJ
18637	8794	17	of	of	IN
18637	8794	18	national	national	JJ
18637	8794	19	character	character	NN
18637	8794	20	.	.	.
18637	8795	1	"	"	``
18637	8795	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8795	3	359	359	CD
18637	8795	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8795	5	Thus	thus	RB
18637	8795	6	the	the	DT
18637	8795	7	right	right	NN
18637	8795	8	to	to	TO
18637	8795	9	determine	determine	VB
18637	8795	10	the	the	DT
18637	8795	11	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	8795	12	of	of	IN
18637	8795	13	the	the	DT
18637	8795	14	country	country	NN
18637	8795	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	8795	16	a	a	DT
18637	8795	17	political	political	JJ
18637	8795	18	function;[360	function;[360	CD
18637	8795	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8795	20	as	as	IN
18637	8795	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	8795	22	also	also	RB
18637	8795	23	the	the	DT
18637	8795	24	right	right	NN
18637	8795	25	to	to	TO
18637	8795	26	determine	determine	VB
18637	8795	27	what	what	WDT
18637	8795	28	country	country	NN
18637	8795	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	8795	30	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	8795	31	of	of	IN
18637	8795	32	a	a	DT
18637	8795	33	particular	particular	JJ
18637	8795	34	region;[361	region;[361	NNS
18637	8795	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8795	36	to	to	TO
18637	8795	37	determine	determine	VB
18637	8795	38	whether	whether	IN
18637	8795	39	a	a	DT
18637	8795	40	community	community	NN
18637	8795	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	8795	42	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	8795	43	under	under	IN
18637	8795	44	International	International	NNP
18637	8795	45	Law	Law	NNP
18637	8795	46	to	to	TO
18637	8795	47	be	be	VB
18637	8795	48	considered	consider	VBN
18637	8795	49	a	a	DT
18637	8795	50	belligerent	belligerent	NN
18637	8795	51	or	or	CC
18637	8795	52	an	an	DT
18637	8795	53	independent	independent	JJ
18637	8795	54	state;[362	state;[362	,
18637	8795	55	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8795	56	to	to	TO
18637	8795	57	determine	determine	VB
18637	8795	58	whether	whether	IN
18637	8795	59	the	the	DT
18637	8795	60	other	other	JJ
18637	8795	61	party	party	NN
18637	8795	62	has	have	VBZ
18637	8795	63	duly	duly	RB
18637	8795	64	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	8795	65	a	a	DT
18637	8795	66	treaty;[363	treaty;[363	CD
18637	8795	67	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8795	68	to	to	TO
18637	8795	69	determine	determine	VB
18637	8795	70	who	who	WP
18637	8795	71	is	be	VBZ
18637	8795	72	the	the	DT
18637	8795	73	_	_	NNP
18637	8795	74	de	de	NNP
18637	8795	75	jure	jure	NNP
18637	8795	76	_	_	NNP
18637	8795	77	or	or	CC
18637	8795	78	_	_	NNP
18637	8795	79	de	de	FW
18637	8795	80	facto	facto	FW
18637	8795	81	_	_	NNP
18637	8795	82	ruler	ruler	NN
18637	8795	83	of	of	IN
18637	8795	84	a	a	DT
18637	8795	85	country;[364	country;[364	LS
18637	8795	86	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8795	87	to	to	TO
18637	8795	88	determine	determine	VB
18637	8795	89	whether	whether	IN
18637	8795	90	a	a	DT
18637	8795	91	particular	particular	JJ
18637	8795	92	person	person	NN
18637	8795	93	is	be	VBZ
18637	8795	94	a	a	DT
18637	8795	95	duly	duly	RB
18637	8795	96	accredited	accredit	VBN
18637	8795	97	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	8795	98	agent	agent	NN
18637	8795	99	to	to	IN
18637	8795	100	the	the	DT
18637	8795	101	United	United	NNP
18637	8795	102	States;[365	states;[365	NN
18637	8795	103	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8795	104	to	to	TO
18637	8795	105	determine	determine	VB
18637	8795	106	how	how	WRB
18637	8795	107	long	long	RB
18637	8795	108	a	a	DT
18637	8795	109	military	military	JJ
18637	8795	110	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	8795	111	shall	shall	MD
18637	8795	112	continue	continue	VB
18637	8795	113	in	in	IN
18637	8795	114	fulfillment	fulfillment	NN
18637	8795	115	of	of	IN
18637	8795	116	the	the	DT
18637	8795	117	terms	term	NNS
18637	8795	118	of	of	IN
18637	8795	119	a	a	DT
18637	8795	120	treaty;[366	treaty;[366	CD
18637	8795	121	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8795	122	to	to	TO
18637	8795	123	determine	determine	VB
18637	8795	124	whether	whether	IN
18637	8795	125	a	a	DT
18637	8795	126	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8795	127	is	be	VBZ
18637	8795	128	in	in	IN
18637	8795	129	effect	effect	NN
18637	8795	130	or	or	CC
18637	8795	131	not	not	RB
18637	8795	132	,	,	,
18637	8795	133	although	although	IN
18637	8795	134	doubtless	doubtless	RB
18637	8795	135	an	an	DT
18637	8795	136	extinguished	extinguish	VBN
18637	8795	137	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8795	138	could	could	MD
18637	8795	139	be	be	VB
18637	8795	140	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	8795	141	renewed	renew	VBN
18637	8795	142	by	by	IN
18637	8795	143	tacit	tacit	JJ
18637	8795	144	consent	consent	NN
18637	8795	145	.	.	.
18637	8796	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8796	2	367	367	CD
18637	8796	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8796	4	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	8796	5	Statements	statement	NNS
18637	8796	6	of	of	IN
18637	8796	7	the	the	DT
18637	8796	8	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	8796	9	The	the	DT
18637	8796	10	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	8796	11	underlying	underlie	VBG
18637	8796	12	the	the	DT
18637	8796	13	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	8796	14	of	of	IN
18637	8796	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	8796	16	to	to	TO
18637	8796	17	intervene	intervene	VB
18637	8796	18	in	in	IN
18637	8796	19	such	such	JJ
18637	8796	20	cases	case	NNS
18637	8796	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	8796	22	well	well	RB
18637	8796	23	stated	state	VBN
18637	8796	24	in	in	IN
18637	8796	25	the	the	DT
18637	8796	26	recent	recent	JJ
18637	8796	27	case	case	NN
18637	8796	28	of	of	IN
18637	8796	29	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	8796	30	&	&	CC
18637	8796	31	S.	S.	NNP
18637	8796	32	Airlines	Airlines	NNP
18637	8796	33	_	_	NNP
18637	8796	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	8796	35	_	_	NNP
18637	8796	36	Waterman	Waterman	NNP
18637	8796	37	Steamship	Steamship	NNP
18637	8796	38	Corp.[368	corp.[368	NN
18637	8796	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8796	40	Here	here	RB
18637	8796	41	the	the	DT
18637	8796	42	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8796	43	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	8796	44	to	to	TO
18637	8796	45	review	review	VB
18637	8796	46	orders	order	NNS
18637	8796	47	of	of	IN
18637	8796	48	the	the	DT
18637	8796	49	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	8796	50	Aeronautics	Aeronautics	NNP
18637	8796	51	Board	Board	NNP
18637	8796	52	granting	grant	VBG
18637	8796	53	or	or	CC
18637	8796	54	denying	deny	VBG
18637	8796	55	applications	application	NNS
18637	8796	56	by	by	IN
18637	8796	57	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	8796	58	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	8796	59	to	to	TO
18637	8796	60	engage	engage	VB
18637	8796	61	in	in	IN
18637	8796	62	overseas	overseas	JJ
18637	8796	63	and	and	CC
18637	8796	64	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8796	65	air	air	NN
18637	8796	66	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	8796	67	which	which	WDT
18637	8796	68	by	by	IN
18637	8796	69	the	the	DT
18637	8796	70	terms	term	NNS
18637	8796	71	of	of	IN
18637	8796	72	the	the	DT
18637	8796	73	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	8796	74	Aeronautics	Aeronautics	NNP
18637	8796	75	Act[369	Act[369	NNP
18637	8796	76	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8796	77	are	be	VBP
18637	8796	78	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8796	79	to	to	IN
18637	8796	80	approval	approval	NN
18637	8796	81	by	by	IN
18637	8796	82	the	the	DT
18637	8796	83	President	President	NNP
18637	8796	84	and	and	CC
18637	8796	85	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8796	86	impliedly	impliedly	RB
18637	8796	87	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	8796	88	those	those	DT
18637	8796	89	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8796	90	of	of	IN
18637	8796	91	the	the	DT
18637	8796	92	act	act	NN
18637	8796	93	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	8796	94	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8796	95	review	review	NN
18637	8796	96	of	of	IN
18637	8796	97	board	board	NN
18637	8796	98	orders	order	NNS
18637	8796	99	.	.	.
18637	8797	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8797	2	370	370	CD
18637	8797	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8797	4	Elaborating	elaborate	VBG
18637	8797	5	on	on	IN
18637	8797	6	the	the	DT
18637	8797	7	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	8797	8	of	of	IN
18637	8797	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8797	10	abstinence	abstinence	NN
18637	8797	11	in	in	IN
18637	8797	12	the	the	DT
18637	8797	13	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	8797	14	of	of	IN
18637	8797	15	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8797	16	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8797	17	,	,	,
18637	8797	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8797	19	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	8797	20	declared	declare	VBD
18637	8797	21	for	for	IN
18637	8797	22	the	the	DT
18637	8797	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8797	24	:	:	:
18637	8797	25	"	"	``
18637	8797	26	The	the	DT
18637	8797	27	President	President	NNP
18637	8797	28	,	,	,
18637	8797	29	both	both	CC
18637	8797	30	as	as	IN
18637	8797	31	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8797	32	in	in	IN
18637	8797	33	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8797	34	and	and	CC
18637	8797	35	as	as	IN
18637	8797	36	the	the	DT
18637	8797	37	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	8797	38	's	's	POS
18637	8797	39	organ	organ	NN
18637	8797	40	for	for	IN
18637	8797	41	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8797	42	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	8797	43	,	,	,
18637	8797	44	has	have	VBZ
18637	8797	45	available	available	JJ
18637	8797	46	intelligence	intelligence	NN
18637	8797	47	services	service	NNS
18637	8797	48	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8797	49	reports	report	NNS
18637	8797	50	are	be	VBP
18637	8797	51	not	not	RB
18637	8797	52	and	and	CC
18637	8797	53	ought	ought	MD
18637	8797	54	not	not	RB
18637	8797	55	to	to	TO
18637	8797	56	be	be	VB
18637	8797	57	published	publish	VBN
18637	8797	58	to	to	IN
18637	8797	59	the	the	DT
18637	8797	60	world	world	NN
18637	8797	61	.	.	.
18637	8798	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8798	2	would	would	MD
18637	8798	3	be	be	VB
18637	8798	4	intolerable	intolerable	JJ
18637	8798	5	that	that	IN
18637	8798	6	courts	court	NNS
18637	8798	7	,	,	,
18637	8798	8	without	without	IN
18637	8798	9	the	the	DT
18637	8798	10	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	8798	11	information	information	NN
18637	8798	12	,	,	,
18637	8798	13	should	should	MD
18637	8798	14	review	review	VB
18637	8798	15	and	and	CC
18637	8798	16	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	8798	17	nullify	nullify	VB
18637	8798	18	actions	action	NNS
18637	8798	19	of	of	IN
18637	8798	20	the	the	DT
18637	8798	21	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8798	22	taken	take	VBN
18637	8798	23	on	on	IN
18637	8798	24	information	information	NN
18637	8798	25	properly	properly	RB
18637	8798	26	held	hold	VBN
18637	8798	27	secret	secret	NN
18637	8798	28	.	.	.
18637	8799	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	8799	2	can	can	MD
18637	8799	3	courts	court	NNS
18637	8799	4	sit	sit	VB
18637	8799	5	_	_	NNP
18637	8799	6	in	in	IN
18637	8799	7	camera	camera	NN
18637	8799	8	_	_	NNP
18637	8799	9	in	in	IN
18637	8799	10	order	order	NN
18637	8799	11	to	to	TO
18637	8799	12	be	be	VB
18637	8799	13	taken	take	VBN
18637	8799	14	into	into	IN
18637	8799	15	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8799	16	confidences	confidence	NNS
18637	8799	17	.	.	.
18637	8800	1	But	but	CC
18637	8800	2	even	even	RB
18637	8800	3	if	if	IN
18637	8800	4	courts	court	NNS
18637	8800	5	could	could	MD
18637	8800	6	require	require	VB
18637	8800	7	full	full	JJ
18637	8800	8	disclosure	disclosure	NN
18637	8800	9	,	,	,
18637	8800	10	the	the	DT
18637	8800	11	very	very	JJ
18637	8800	12	nature	nature	NN
18637	8800	13	of	of	IN
18637	8800	14	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8800	15	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	8800	16	as	as	IN
18637	8800	17	to	to	IN
18637	8800	18	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8800	19	policy	policy	NN
18637	8800	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	8800	21	political	political	JJ
18637	8800	22	,	,	,
18637	8800	23	not	not	RB
18637	8800	24	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8800	25	.	.	.
18637	8801	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	8801	2	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	8801	3	are	be	VBP
18637	8801	4	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	8801	5	confided	confide	VBN
18637	8801	6	by	by	IN
18637	8801	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8801	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8801	9	on	on	IN
18637	8801	10	the	the	DT
18637	8801	11	political	political	JJ
18637	8801	12	departments	department	NNS
18637	8801	13	of	of	IN
18637	8801	14	the	the	DT
18637	8801	15	government	government	NN
18637	8801	16	,	,	,
18637	8801	17	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8801	18	and	and	CC
18637	8801	19	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	8801	20	.	.	.
18637	8802	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8802	2	are	be	VBP
18637	8802	3	delicate	delicate	JJ
18637	8802	4	,	,	,
18637	8802	5	complex	complex	JJ
18637	8802	6	,	,	,
18637	8802	7	and	and	CC
18637	8802	8	involve	involve	VB
18637	8802	9	large	large	JJ
18637	8802	10	elements	element	NNS
18637	8802	11	of	of	IN
18637	8802	12	prophecy	prophecy	NN
18637	8802	13	.	.	.
18637	8803	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8803	2	are	be	VBP
18637	8803	3	and	and	CC
18637	8803	4	should	should	MD
18637	8803	5	be	be	VB
18637	8803	6	undertaken	undertake	VBN
18637	8803	7	only	only	RB
18637	8803	8	by	by	IN
18637	8803	9	those	those	DT
18637	8803	10	directly	directly	RB
18637	8803	11	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	8803	12	to	to	IN
18637	8803	13	the	the	DT
18637	8803	14	people	people	NNS
18637	8803	15	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8803	16	welfare	welfare	VBP
18637	8803	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8803	18	advance	advance	VBP
18637	8803	19	or	or	CC
18637	8803	20	imperil	imperil	NN
18637	8803	21	.	.	.
18637	8804	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8804	2	are	be	VBP
18637	8804	3	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	8804	4	of	of	IN
18637	8804	5	a	a	DT
18637	8804	6	kind	kind	NN
18637	8804	7	for	for	IN
18637	8804	8	which	which	WDT
18637	8804	9	the	the	DT
18637	8804	10	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	8804	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	8804	12	neither	neither	DT
18637	8804	13	aptitude	aptitude	NN
18637	8804	14	,	,	,
18637	8804	15	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	8804	16	nor	nor	CC
18637	8804	17	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	8804	18	and	and	CC
18637	8804	19	which	which	WDT
18637	8804	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	8804	21	long	long	RB
18637	8804	22	been	be	VBN
18637	8804	23	held	hold	VBN
18637	8804	24	to	to	TO
18637	8804	25	belong	belong	VB
18637	8804	26	in	in	IN
18637	8804	27	the	the	DT
18637	8804	28	domain	domain	NN
18637	8804	29	of	of	IN
18637	8804	30	political	political	JJ
18637	8804	31	power	power	NN
18637	8804	32	not	not	RB
18637	8804	33	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8804	34	to	to	IN
18637	8804	35	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8804	36	intrusion	intrusion	NN
18637	8804	37	or	or	CC
18637	8804	38	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	8804	39	.	.	.
18637	8805	1	"	"	``
18637	8805	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8805	3	371	371	CD
18637	8805	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8805	5	To	to	IN
18637	8805	6	the	the	DT
18637	8805	7	same	same	JJ
18637	8805	8	effect	effect	NN
18637	8805	9	are	be	VBP
18637	8805	10	the	the	DT
18637	8805	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8805	12	's	's	POS
18637	8805	13	holding	holding	NN
18637	8805	14	and	and	CC
18637	8805	15	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8805	16	in	in	IN
18637	8805	17	Ludecke	Ludecke	NNP
18637	8805	18	_	_	NNP
18637	8805	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	8805	20	_	_	NNP
18637	8805	21	Watkins,[372	Watkins,[372	NNP
18637	8805	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8805	23	where	where	WRB
18637	8805	24	the	the	DT
18637	8805	25	question	question	NN
18637	8805	26	at	at	IN
18637	8805	27	issue	issue	NN
18637	8805	28	was	be	VBD
18637	8805	29	the	the	DT
18637	8805	30	power	power	NN
18637	8805	31	of	of	IN
18637	8805	32	the	the	DT
18637	8805	33	President	President	NNP
18637	8805	34	to	to	TO
18637	8805	35	order	order	VB
18637	8805	36	the	the	DT
18637	8805	37	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	8805	38	under	under	IN
18637	8805	39	the	the	DT
18637	8805	40	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	8805	41	Enemy	Enemy	NNP
18637	8805	42	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8805	43	of	of	IN
18637	8805	44	1798	1798	CD
18637	8805	45	of	of	IN
18637	8805	46	a	a	DT
18637	8805	47	German	german	JJ
18637	8805	48	alien	alien	JJ
18637	8805	49	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	8805	50	after	after	IN
18637	8805	51	the	the	DT
18637	8805	52	cessation	cessation	NN
18637	8805	53	of	of	IN
18637	8805	54	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	8805	55	with	with	IN
18637	8805	56	Germany	Germany	NNP
18637	8805	57	.	.	.
18637	8806	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	8806	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8806	3	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	8806	4	for	for	IN
18637	8806	5	the	the	DT
18637	8806	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8806	7	:	:	:
18637	8806	8	"	"	``
18637	8806	9	War	war	NN
18637	8806	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	8806	11	not	not	RB
18637	8806	12	cease	cease	VB
18637	8806	13	with	with	IN
18637	8806	14	a	a	DT
18637	8806	15	cease	cease	NN
18637	8806	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	8806	17	fire	fire	NN
18637	8806	18	order	order	NN
18637	8806	19	,	,	,
18637	8806	20	and	and	CC
18637	8806	21	power	power	NN
18637	8806	22	to	to	TO
18637	8806	23	be	be	VB
18637	8806	24	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	8806	25	by	by	IN
18637	8806	26	the	the	DT
18637	8806	27	President	President	NNP
18637	8806	28	such	such	JJ
18637	8806	29	as	as	IN
18637	8806	30	that	that	DT
18637	8806	31	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	8806	32	by	by	IN
18637	8806	33	the	the	DT
18637	8806	34	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8806	35	of	of	IN
18637	8806	36	1798	1798	CD
18637	8806	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	8806	38	a	a	DT
18637	8806	39	process	process	NN
18637	8806	40	which	which	WDT
18637	8806	41	begins	begin	VBZ
18637	8806	42	when	when	WRB
18637	8806	43	war	war	NN
18637	8806	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	8806	45	declared	declare	VBN
18637	8806	46	but	but	CC
18637	8806	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	8806	48	not	not	RB
18637	8806	49	exhausted	exhausted	JJ
18637	8806	50	when	when	WRB
18637	8806	51	the	the	DT
18637	8806	52	shooting	shooting	NN
18637	8806	53	stops	stop	VBZ
18637	8806	54	.	.	.
18637	8807	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8807	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8807	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8807	4	The	the	DT
18637	8807	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8807	6	would	would	MD
18637	8807	7	be	be	VB
18637	8807	8	assuming	assume	VBG
18637	8807	9	the	the	DT
18637	8807	10	functions	function	NNS
18637	8807	11	of	of	IN
18637	8807	12	the	the	DT
18637	8807	13	political	political	JJ
18637	8807	14	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	8807	15	of	of	IN
18637	8807	16	the	the	DT
18637	8807	17	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8807	18	to	to	TO
18637	8807	19	yield	yield	VB
18637	8807	20	to	to	IN
18637	8807	21	the	the	DT
18637	8807	22	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	8807	23	that	that	IN
18637	8807	24	the	the	DT
18637	8807	25	unconditional	unconditional	JJ
18637	8807	26	surrender	surrender	NN
18637	8807	27	of	of	IN
18637	8807	28	Germany	Germany	NNP
18637	8807	29	and	and	CC
18637	8807	30	the	the	DT
18637	8807	31	disintegration	disintegration	NN
18637	8807	32	of	of	IN
18637	8807	33	the	the	DT
18637	8807	34	Nazi	Nazi	NNP
18637	8807	35	Reich	Reich	NNP
18637	8807	36	have	have	VBP
18637	8807	37	left	leave	VBN
18637	8807	38	Germany	Germany	NNP
18637	8807	39	without	without	IN
18637	8807	40	a	a	DT
18637	8807	41	government	government	NN
18637	8807	42	capable	capable	JJ
18637	8807	43	of	of	IN
18637	8807	44	negotiating	negotiate	VBG
18637	8807	45	a	a	DT
18637	8807	46	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8807	47	of	of	IN
18637	8807	48	peace	peace	NN
18637	8807	49	.	.	.
18637	8808	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8808	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8808	3	not	not	RB
18637	8808	4	for	for	IN
18637	8808	5	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8808	6	to	to	TO
18637	8808	7	question	question	VB
18637	8808	8	a	a	DT
18637	8808	9	belief	belief	NN
18637	8808	10	by	by	IN
18637	8808	11	the	the	DT
18637	8808	12	President	President	NNP
18637	8808	13	that	that	IN
18637	8808	14	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	8808	15	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	8808	16	who	who	WP
18637	8808	17	were	be	VBD
18637	8808	18	justifiably	justifiably	RB
18637	8808	19	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	8808	20	fit	fit	JJ
18637	8808	21	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	8808	22	for	for	IN
18637	8808	23	internment	internment	NN
18637	8808	24	during	during	IN
18637	8808	25	active	active	JJ
18637	8808	26	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	8808	27	do	do	VBP
18637	8808	28	not	not	RB
18637	8808	29	lose	lose	VB
18637	8808	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8808	31	potency	potency	NN
18637	8808	32	for	for	IN
18637	8808	33	mischief	mischief	NN
18637	8808	34	during	during	IN
18637	8808	35	the	the	DT
18637	8808	36	period	period	NN
18637	8808	37	of	of	IN
18637	8808	38	confusion	confusion	NN
18637	8808	39	and	and	CC
18637	8808	40	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	8808	41	which	which	WDT
18637	8808	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	8808	43	characteristic	characteristic	JJ
18637	8808	44	of	of	IN
18637	8808	45	a	a	DT
18637	8808	46	state	state	NN
18637	8808	47	of	of	IN
18637	8808	48	war	war	NN
18637	8808	49	even	even	RB
18637	8808	50	when	when	WRB
18637	8808	51	the	the	DT
18637	8808	52	guns	gun	NNS
18637	8808	53	are	be	VBP
18637	8808	54	silent	silent	JJ
18637	8808	55	but	but	CC
18637	8808	56	the	the	DT
18637	8808	57	peace	peace	NN
18637	8808	58	of	of	IN
18637	8808	59	Peace	Peace	NNP
18637	8808	60	has	have	VBZ
18637	8808	61	not	not	RB
18637	8808	62	come	come	VBN
18637	8808	63	.	.	.
18637	8809	1	These	these	DT
18637	8809	2	are	be	VBP
18637	8809	3	matters	matter	NNS
18637	8809	4	of	of	IN
18637	8809	5	political	political	JJ
18637	8809	6	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8809	7	for	for	IN
18637	8809	8	which	which	WDT
18637	8809	9	judges	judge	NNS
18637	8809	10	have	have	VBP
18637	8809	11	neither	neither	CC
18637	8809	12	technical	technical	JJ
18637	8809	13	competence	competence	NN
18637	8809	14	nor	nor	CC
18637	8809	15	official	official	JJ
18637	8809	16	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	8809	17	.	.	.
18637	8810	1	"	"	``
18637	8810	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8810	3	373	373	CD
18637	8810	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8810	5	The	the	DT
18637	8810	6	President	President	NNP
18637	8810	7	as	as	IN
18637	8810	8	Law	Law	NNP
18637	8810	9	Enforcer	Enforcer	NNP
18637	8810	10	TYPES	TYPES	NNP
18637	8810	11	OF	of	IN
18637	8810	12	EXECUTIVE	executive	NN
18637	8810	13	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	8810	14	The	the	DT
18637	8810	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8810	16	does	do	VBZ
18637	8810	17	not	not	RB
18637	8810	18	say	say	VB
18637	8810	19	that	that	IN
18637	8810	20	the	the	DT
18637	8810	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8810	22	shall	shall	MD
18637	8810	23	execute	execute	VB
18637	8810	24	the	the	DT
18637	8810	25	laws	law	NNS
18637	8810	26	,	,	,
18637	8810	27	but	but	CC
18637	8810	28	that	that	IN
18637	8810	29	"	"	``
18637	8810	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8810	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	8810	32	take	take	VB
18637	8810	33	care	care	NN
18637	8810	34	that	that	IN
18637	8810	35	the	the	DT
18637	8810	36	laws	law	NNS
18637	8810	37	be	be	VB
18637	8810	38	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8810	39	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8810	40	,	,	,
18637	8810	41	"	"	''
18637	8810	42	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	8810	43	,	,	,
18637	8810	44	by	by	IN
18637	8810	45	others	other	NNS
18637	8810	46	,	,	,
18637	8810	47	who	who	WP
18637	8810	48	are	be	VBP
18637	8810	49	commonly	commonly	RB
18637	8810	50	,	,	,
18637	8810	51	but	but	CC
18637	8810	52	not	not	RB
18637	8810	53	always	always	RB
18637	8810	54	with	with	IN
18637	8810	55	strict	strict	JJ
18637	8810	56	accuracy	accuracy	NN
18637	8810	57	,	,	,
18637	8810	58	termed	term	VBD
18637	8810	59	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8810	60	subordinates	subordinate	NNS
18637	8810	61	.	.	.
18637	8811	1	What	what	WDT
18637	8811	2	powers	power	NNS
18637	8811	3	are	be	VBP
18637	8811	4	implied	imply	VBN
18637	8811	5	from	from	IN
18637	8811	6	this	this	DT
18637	8811	7	duty	duty	NN
18637	8811	8	?	?	.
18637	8812	1	In	in	IN
18637	8812	2	this	this	DT
18637	8812	3	connection	connection	NN
18637	8812	4	five	five	CD
18637	8812	5	categories	category	NNS
18637	8812	6	of	of	IN
18637	8812	7	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8812	8	power	power	NN
18637	8812	9	should	should	MD
18637	8812	10	be	be	VB
18637	8812	11	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	8812	12	:	:	:
18637	8812	13	first	first	RB
18637	8812	14	,	,	,
18637	8812	15	there	there	EX
18637	8812	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	8812	17	that	that	IN
18637	8812	18	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8812	19	power	power	NN
18637	8812	20	which	which	WDT
18637	8812	21	the	the	DT
18637	8812	22	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8812	23	confers	confer	NNS
18637	8812	24	directly	directly	RB
18637	8812	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	8812	26	the	the	DT
18637	8812	27	President	President	NNP
18637	8812	28	by	by	IN
18637	8812	29	the	the	DT
18637	8812	30	opening	opening	NN
18637	8812	31	clause	clause	NN
18637	8812	32	of	of	IN
18637	8812	33	article	article	NN
18637	8812	34	II	II	NNP
18637	8812	35	and	and	CC
18637	8812	36	,	,	,
18637	8812	37	in	in	IN
18637	8812	38	more	more	RBR
18637	8812	39	specific	specific	JJ
18637	8812	40	terms	term	NNS
18637	8812	41	,	,	,
18637	8812	42	by	by	IN
18637	8812	43	succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	8812	44	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	8812	45	of	of	IN
18637	8812	46	the	the	DT
18637	8812	47	same	same	JJ
18637	8812	48	article	article	NN
18637	8812	49	;	;	:
18637	8812	50	secondly	secondly	RB
18637	8812	51	,	,	,
18637	8812	52	there	there	EX
18637	8812	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	8812	54	the	the	DT
18637	8812	55	sum	sum	NN
18637	8812	56	total	total	NN
18637	8812	57	of	of	IN
18637	8812	58	the	the	DT
18637	8812	59	powers	power	NNS
18637	8812	60	which	which	WDT
18637	8812	61	acts	act	VBZ
18637	8812	62	of	of	IN
18637	8812	63	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8812	64	at	at	IN
18637	8812	65	any	any	DT
18637	8812	66	particular	particular	JJ
18637	8812	67	time	time	NN
18637	8812	68	confer	confer	VB
18637	8812	69	upon	upon	IN
18637	8812	70	the	the	DT
18637	8812	71	President	President	NNP
18637	8812	72	;	;	:
18637	8812	73	thirdly	thirdly	RB
18637	8812	74	,	,	,
18637	8812	75	there	there	EX
18637	8812	76	is	be	VBZ
18637	8812	77	the	the	DT
18637	8812	78	sum	sum	NN
18637	8812	79	total	total	NN
18637	8812	80	of	of	IN
18637	8812	81	discretionary	discretionary	JJ
18637	8812	82	powers	power	NNS
18637	8812	83	which	which	WDT
18637	8812	84	acts	act	VBZ
18637	8812	85	of	of	IN
18637	8812	86	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8812	87	at	at	IN
18637	8812	88	any	any	DT
18637	8812	89	particular	particular	JJ
18637	8812	90	time	time	NN
18637	8812	91	confer	confer	VB
18637	8812	92	upon	upon	IN
18637	8812	93	heads	head	NNS
18637	8812	94	of	of	IN
18637	8812	95	departments	department	NNS
18637	8812	96	and	and	CC
18637	8812	97	other	other	JJ
18637	8812	98	executive	executive	NN
18637	8812	99	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8812	100	"	"	``
18637	8812	101	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	8812	102	"	"	''
18637	8812	103	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8812	104	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	8812	105	of	of	IN
18637	8812	106	the	the	DT
18637	8812	107	National	National	NNP
18637	8812	108	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8812	109	;	;	:
18637	8812	110	fourthly	fourthly	RB
18637	8812	111	,	,	,
18637	8812	112	there	there	EX
18637	8812	113	is	be	VBZ
18637	8812	114	the	the	DT
18637	8812	115	power	power	NN
18637	8812	116	which	which	WDT
18637	8812	117	stems	stem	VBZ
18637	8812	118	from	from	IN
18637	8812	119	the	the	DT
18637	8812	120	duty	duty	NN
18637	8812	121	to	to	TO
18637	8812	122	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	8812	123	the	the	DT
18637	8812	124	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	8812	125	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	8812	126	of	of	IN
18637	8812	127	the	the	DT
18637	8812	128	United	United	NNP
18637	8812	129	States	States	NNP
18637	8812	130	;	;	:
18637	8812	131	finally	finally	RB
18637	8812	132	,	,	,
18637	8812	133	there	there	EX
18637	8812	134	are	be	VBP
18637	8812	135	so	so	RB
18637	8812	136	-	-	HYPH
18637	8812	137	called	call	VBN
18637	8812	138	"	"	``
18637	8812	139	ministerial	ministerial	JJ
18637	8812	140	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8812	141	"	"	''
18637	8812	142	which	which	WDT
18637	8812	143	admit	admit	VBP
18637	8812	144	of	of	IN
18637	8812	145	no	no	DT
18637	8812	146	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	8812	147	as	as	IN
18637	8812	148	to	to	IN
18637	8812	149	the	the	DT
18637	8812	150	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	8812	151	or	or	CC
18637	8812	152	the	the	DT
18637	8812	153	manner	manner	NN
18637	8812	154	of	of	IN
18637	8812	155	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8812	156	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8812	157	.	.	.
18637	8813	1	Three	three	CD
18637	8813	2	principal	principal	JJ
18637	8813	3	questions	question	NNS
18637	8813	4	arise	arise	VBP
18637	8813	5	:	:	:
18637	8813	6	first	first	RB
18637	8813	7	,	,	,
18637	8813	8	how	how	WRB
18637	8813	9	does	do	VBZ
18637	8813	10	the	the	DT
18637	8813	11	President	President	NNP
18637	8813	12	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	8813	13	the	the	DT
18637	8813	14	powers	power	NNS
18637	8813	15	which	which	WDT
18637	8813	16	the	the	DT
18637	8813	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8813	18	or	or	CC
18637	8813	19	the	the	DT
18637	8813	20	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	8813	21	confer	confer	VBP
18637	8813	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	8813	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8813	24	;	;	:
18637	8813	25	second	second	LS
18637	8813	26	,	,	,
18637	8813	27	in	in	IN
18637	8813	28	what	what	WDT
18637	8813	29	relation	relation	NN
18637	8813	30	does	do	VBZ
18637	8813	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8813	32	stand	stand	VB
18637	8813	33	by	by	IN
18637	8813	34	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	8813	35	of	of	IN
18637	8813	36	the	the	DT
18637	8813	37	"	"	``
18637	8813	38	take	take	VB
18637	8813	39	care	care	NN
18637	8813	40	"	"	''
18637	8813	41	clause	clause	NN
18637	8813	42	to	to	IN
18637	8813	43	the	the	DT
18637	8813	44	powers	power	NNS
18637	8813	45	of	of	IN
18637	8813	46	other	other	JJ
18637	8813	47	executive	executive	NN
18637	8813	48	,	,	,
18637	8813	49	or	or	CC
18637	8813	50	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	8813	51	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	8813	52	;	;	,
18637	8813	53	third	third	RB
18637	8813	54	,	,	,
18637	8813	55	in	in	IN
18637	8813	56	what	what	WDT
18637	8813	57	relation	relation	NN
18637	8813	58	does	do	VBZ
18637	8813	59	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8813	60	stand	stand	VB
18637	8813	61	to	to	IN
18637	8813	62	the	the	DT
18637	8813	63	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	8813	64	of	of	IN
18637	8813	65	the	the	DT
18637	8813	66	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	8813	67	laws	law	NNS
18637	8813	68	of	of	IN
18637	8813	69	the	the	DT
18637	8813	70	United	United	NNP
18637	8813	71	States	States	NNP
18637	8813	72	?	?	.
18637	8814	1	HOW	how	WRB
18637	8814	2	THE	the	DT
18637	8814	3	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	8814	4	'S	's	POS
18637	8814	5	OWN	own	JJ
18637	8814	6	POWERS	power	NNS
18637	8814	7	ARE	are	VBP
18637	8814	8	EXERCISED	EXERCISED	NNS
18637	8814	9	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	8814	10	the	the	DT
18637	8814	11	British	british	JJ
18637	8814	12	monarch	monarch	NN
18637	8814	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	8814	14	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	8814	15	under	under	IN
18637	8814	16	the	the	DT
18637	8814	17	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	8814	18	of	of	IN
18637	8814	19	acting	act	VBG
18637	8814	20	always	always	RB
18637	8814	21	through	through	IN
18637	8814	22	agents	agent	NNS
18637	8814	23	if	if	IN
18637	8814	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8814	25	acts	act	NNS
18637	8814	26	are	be	VBP
18637	8814	27	to	to	TO
18637	8814	28	receive	receive	VB
18637	8814	29	legal	legal	JJ
18637	8814	30	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	8814	31	,	,	,
18637	8814	32	the	the	DT
18637	8814	33	President	President	NNP
18637	8814	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	8814	35	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	8814	36	to	to	TO
18637	8814	37	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	8814	38	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8814	39	of	of	IN
18637	8814	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8814	41	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8814	42	powers	power	NNS
18637	8814	43	personally	personally	RB
18637	8814	44	.	.	.
18637	8815	1	In	in	IN
18637	8815	2	the	the	DT
18637	8815	3	words	word	NNS
18637	8815	4	of	of	IN
18637	8815	5	an	an	DT
18637	8815	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8815	7	by	by	IN
18637	8815	8	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8815	9	General	General	NNP
18637	8815	10	Cushing	Cushing	NNP
18637	8815	11	in	in	IN
18637	8815	12	1855	1855	CD
18637	8815	13	:	:	:
18637	8815	14	"	"	``
18637	8815	15	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8815	16	may	may	MD
18637	8815	17	be	be	VB
18637	8815	18	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	8815	19	that	that	IN
18637	8815	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8815	21	,	,	,
18637	8815	22	the	the	DT
18637	8815	23	man	man	NN
18637	8815	24	discharging	discharge	VBG
18637	8815	25	the	the	DT
18637	8815	26	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8815	27	office	office	NN
18637	8815	28	,	,	,
18637	8815	29	and	and	CC
18637	8815	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8815	31	alone	alone	RB
18637	8815	32	,	,	,
18637	8815	33	grants	grant	VBZ
18637	8815	34	reprieves	reprieve	NNS
18637	8815	35	and	and	CC
18637	8815	36	pardons	pardon	NNS
18637	8815	37	for	for	IN
18637	8815	38	offences	offence	NNS
18637	8815	39	against	against	IN
18637	8815	40	the	the	DT
18637	8815	41	United	United	NNP
18637	8815	42	States	States	NNP
18637	8815	43	,	,	,
18637	8815	44	*	*	NFP
18637	8815	45	*	*	NFP
18637	8815	46	*	*	NFP
18637	8815	47	So	so	IN
18637	8815	48	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8815	49	,	,	,
18637	8815	50	and	and	CC
18637	8815	51	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8815	52	alone	alone	RB
18637	8815	53	,	,	,
18637	8815	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	8815	55	the	the	DT
18637	8815	56	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	8815	57	commander	commander	NNP
18637	8815	58	in	in	IN
18637	8815	59	chief	chief	NN
18637	8815	60	of	of	IN
18637	8815	61	the	the	DT
18637	8815	62	Army	Army	NNP
18637	8815	63	and	and	CC
18637	8815	64	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	8815	65	of	of	IN
18637	8815	66	the	the	DT
18637	8815	67	United	United	NNP
18637	8815	68	States	States	NNP
18637	8815	69	,	,	,
18637	8815	70	and	and	CC
18637	8815	71	of	of	IN
18637	8815	72	the	the	DT
18637	8815	73	militia	militia	NN
18637	8815	74	of	of	IN
18637	8815	75	the	the	DT
18637	8815	76	several	several	JJ
18637	8815	77	States	States	NNP
18637	8815	78	when	when	WRB
18637	8815	79	called	call	VBD
18637	8815	80	into	into	IN
18637	8815	81	the	the	DT
18637	8815	82	actual	actual	JJ
18637	8815	83	service	service	NN
18637	8815	84	of	of	IN
18637	8815	85	the	the	DT
18637	8815	86	United	United	NNP
18637	8815	87	States	States	NNP
18637	8815	88	.	.	.
18637	8816	1	That	that	DT
18637	8816	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8816	3	a	a	DT
18637	8816	4	power	power	NN
18637	8816	5	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	8816	6	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	8816	7	in	in	IN
18637	8816	8	the	the	DT
18637	8816	9	person	person	NN
18637	8816	10	of	of	IN
18637	8816	11	the	the	DT
18637	8816	12	President	President	NNP
18637	8816	13	.	.	.
18637	8817	1	No	no	DT
18637	8817	2	act	act	NN
18637	8817	3	of	of	IN
18637	8817	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8817	5	,	,	,
18637	8817	6	no	no	DT
18637	8817	7	act	act	NN
18637	8817	8	even	even	RB
18637	8817	9	of	of	IN
18637	8817	10	the	the	DT
18637	8817	11	President	President	NNP
18637	8817	12	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8817	13	,	,	,
18637	8817	14	can	can	MD
18637	8817	15	,	,	,
18637	8817	16	by	by	IN
18637	8817	17	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8817	18	possibility	possibility	NN
18637	8817	19	,	,	,
18637	8817	20	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	8817	21	or	or	CC
18637	8817	22	create	create	VB
18637	8817	23	any	any	DT
18637	8817	24	military	military	JJ
18637	8817	25	officer	officer	NN
18637	8817	26	not	not	RB
18637	8817	27	subordinate	subordinate	JJ
18637	8817	28	to	to	IN
18637	8817	29	the	the	DT
18637	8817	30	President	President	NNP
18637	8817	31	.	.	.
18637	8818	1	"	"	``
18637	8818	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8818	3	374	374	CD
18637	8818	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8818	5	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	8818	6	,	,	,
18637	8818	7	the	the	DT
18637	8818	8	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8818	9	to	to	TO
18637	8818	10	act	act	VB
18637	8818	11	personally	personally	RB
18637	8818	12	may	may	MD
18637	8818	13	be	be	VB
18637	8818	14	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	8818	15	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
18637	8818	16	by	by	IN
18637	8818	17	statute	statute	NN
18637	8818	18	,	,	,
18637	8818	19	as	as	IN
18637	8818	20	,	,	,
18637	8818	21	for	for	IN
18637	8818	22	example	example	NN
18637	8818	23	,	,	,
18637	8818	24	by	by	IN
18637	8818	25	the	the	DT
18637	8818	26	act	act	NN
18637	8818	27	organizing	organize	VBG
18637	8818	28	the	the	DT
18637	8818	29	President	President	NNP
18637	8818	30	with	with	IN
18637	8818	31	other	other	JJ
18637	8818	32	designated	designate	VBN
18637	8818	33	officials	official	NNS
18637	8818	34	into	into	IN
18637	8818	35	"	"	``
18637	8818	36	an	an	DT
18637	8818	37	Establishment	Establishment	NNP
18637	8818	38	by	by	IN
18637	8818	39	name	name	NN
18637	8818	40	of	of	IN
18637	8818	41	the	the	DT
18637	8818	42	Smithsonian	Smithsonian	NNP
18637	8818	43	Institute	Institute	NNP
18637	8818	44	.	.	.
18637	8819	1	"	"	``
18637	8819	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8819	3	375	375	CD
18637	8819	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8819	5	Here	here	RB
18637	8819	6	,	,	,
18637	8819	7	says	say	VBZ
18637	8819	8	the	the	DT
18637	8819	9	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8819	10	General	General	NNP
18637	8819	11	,	,	,
18637	8819	12	"	"	''
18637	8819	13	the	the	DT
18637	8819	14	President	President	NNP
18637	8819	15	's	's	POS
18637	8819	16	name	name	NN
18637	8819	17	of	of	IN
18637	8819	18	office	office	NN
18637	8819	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	8819	20	_	_	NNP
18637	8819	21	designatio	designatio	NN
18637	8819	22	personae	personae	RB
18637	8819	23	_	_	NNP
18637	8819	24	.	.	.
18637	8819	25	"	"	''
18637	8820	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8820	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8820	3	also	also	RB
18637	8820	4	of	of	IN
18637	8820	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8820	6	that	that	IN
18637	8820	7	expenditures	expenditure	VBZ
18637	8820	8	from	from	IN
18637	8820	9	the	the	DT
18637	8820	10	"	"	``
18637	8820	11	secret	secret	JJ
18637	8820	12	service	service	NN
18637	8820	13	"	"	''
18637	8820	14	fund	fund	NN
18637	8820	15	in	in	IN
18637	8820	16	order	order	NN
18637	8820	17	to	to	TO
18637	8820	18	be	be	VB
18637	8820	19	valid	valid	JJ
18637	8820	20	,	,	,
18637	8820	21	must	must	MD
18637	8820	22	be	be	VB
18637	8820	23	vouched	vouch	VBN
18637	8820	24	for	for	IN
18637	8820	25	by	by	IN
18637	8820	26	the	the	DT
18637	8820	27	President	President	NNP
18637	8820	28	personally	personally	RB
18637	8820	29	.	.	.
18637	8821	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8821	2	376	376	CD
18637	8821	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8821	4	On	on	IN
18637	8821	5	like	like	IN
18637	8821	6	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	8821	7	the	the	DT
18637	8821	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8821	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8821	10	once	once	RB
18637	8821	11	held	hold	VBD
18637	8821	12	void	void	RB
18637	8821	13	a	a	DT
18637	8821	14	decree	decree	NN
18637	8821	15	of	of	IN
18637	8821	16	a	a	DT
18637	8821	17	court	court	NN
18637	8821	18	martial	martial	NN
18637	8821	19	,	,	,
18637	8821	20	because	because	IN
18637	8821	21	,	,	,
18637	8821	22	though	though	IN
18637	8821	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8821	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	8821	25	been	be	VBN
18637	8821	26	confirmed	confirm	VBN
18637	8821	27	by	by	IN
18637	8821	28	the	the	DT
18637	8821	29	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8821	30	of	of	IN
18637	8821	31	War	War	NNP
18637	8821	32	,	,	,
18637	8821	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8821	34	was	be	VBD
18637	8821	35	not	not	RB
18637	8821	36	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	8821	37	stated	state	VBN
18637	8821	38	to	to	TO
18637	8821	39	have	have	VB
18637	8821	40	received	receive	VBN
18637	8821	41	the	the	DT
18637	8821	42	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	8821	43	of	of	IN
18637	8821	44	the	the	DT
18637	8821	45	President	President	NNP
18637	8821	46	as	as	IN
18637	8821	47	required	require	VBN
18637	8821	48	by	by	IN
18637	8821	49	the	the	DT
18637	8821	50	65th	65th	JJ
18637	8821	51	Article	Article	NNP
18637	8821	52	of	of	IN
18637	8821	53	War	War	NNP
18637	8821	54	.	.	.
18637	8822	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8822	2	377	377	CD
18637	8822	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8822	4	This	this	DT
18637	8822	5	case	case	NN
18637	8822	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	8822	7	,	,	,
18637	8822	8	however	however	RB
18637	8822	9	,	,	,
18637	8822	10	been	be	VBN
18637	8822	11	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	8822	12	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	8822	13	,	,	,
18637	8822	14	and	and	CC
18637	8822	15	at	at	IN
18637	8822	16	any	any	DT
18637	8822	17	rate	rate	NN
18637	8822	18	such	such	JJ
18637	8822	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	8822	20	are	be	VBP
18637	8822	21	exceptional	exceptional	JJ
18637	8822	22	.	.	.
18637	8823	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8823	2	378	378	CD
18637	8823	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8823	4	The	the	DT
18637	8823	5	general	general	JJ
18637	8823	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	8823	7	,	,	,
18637	8823	8	as	as	IN
18637	8823	9	stated	state	VBN
18637	8823	10	by	by	IN
18637	8823	11	the	the	DT
18637	8823	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8823	13	,	,	,
18637	8823	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8823	15	that	that	IN
18637	8823	16	when	when	WRB
18637	8823	17	any	any	DT
18637	8823	18	duty	duty	NN
18637	8823	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	8823	20	cast	cast	VBN
18637	8823	21	by	by	IN
18637	8823	22	law	law	NN
18637	8823	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	8823	24	the	the	DT
18637	8823	25	President	President	NNP
18637	8823	26	,	,	,
18637	8823	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8823	28	may	may	MD
18637	8823	29	be	be	VB
18637	8823	30	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	8823	31	by	by	IN
18637	8823	32	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8823	33	through	through	IN
18637	8823	34	the	the	DT
18637	8823	35	head	head	NN
18637	8823	36	of	of	IN
18637	8823	37	the	the	DT
18637	8823	38	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	8823	39	department	department	NN
18637	8823	40	,	,	,
18637	8823	41	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8823	42	acts	act	NNS
18637	8823	43	,	,	,
18637	8823	44	if	if	IN
18637	8823	45	performed	perform	VBN
18637	8823	46	within	within	IN
18637	8823	47	the	the	DT
18637	8823	48	law	law	NN
18637	8823	49	,	,	,
18637	8823	50	thus	thus	RB
18637	8823	51	become	become	VBP
18637	8823	52	the	the	DT
18637	8823	53	President	President	NNP
18637	8823	54	's	's	POS
18637	8823	55	acts	act	NNS
18637	8823	56	.	.	.
18637	8824	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8824	2	379	379	CD
18637	8824	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8824	4	In	in	IN
18637	8824	5	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	8824	6	_	_	NNP
18637	8824	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	8824	8	_	_	NNP
18637	8824	9	United	United	NNP
18637	8824	10	States[380	States[380	NNP
18637	8824	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8824	12	was	be	VBD
18637	8824	13	involved	involve	VBN
18637	8824	14	an	an	DT
18637	8824	15	act	act	NN
18637	8824	16	of	of	IN
18637	8824	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8824	18	,	,	,
18637	8824	19	which	which	WDT
18637	8824	20	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	8824	21	the	the	DT
18637	8824	22	advance	advance	NN
18637	8824	23	of	of	IN
18637	8824	24	public	public	JJ
18637	8824	25	money	money	NN
18637	8824	26	in	in	IN
18637	8824	27	any	any	DT
18637	8824	28	case	case	NN
18637	8824	29	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	8824	30	to	to	IN
18637	8824	31	disbursing	disburse	VBG
18637	8824	32	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8824	33	of	of	IN
18637	8824	34	the	the	DT
18637	8824	35	United	United	NNP
18637	8824	36	States	States	NNP
18637	8824	37	,	,	,
18637	8824	38	except	except	IN
18637	8824	39	under	under	IN
18637	8824	40	special	special	JJ
18637	8824	41	direction	direction	NN
18637	8824	42	by	by	IN
18637	8824	43	the	the	DT
18637	8824	44	President	President	NNP
18637	8824	45	.	.	.
18637	8825	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8825	2	381	381	CD
18637	8825	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8825	4	The	the	DT
18637	8825	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8825	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8825	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	8825	8	that	that	IN
18637	8825	9	the	the	DT
18637	8825	10	act	act	NN
18637	8825	11	did	do	VBD
18637	8825	12	not	not	RB
18637	8825	13	require	require	VB
18637	8825	14	the	the	DT
18637	8825	15	personal	personal	JJ
18637	8825	16	performance	performance	NN
18637	8825	17	by	by	IN
18637	8825	18	the	the	DT
18637	8825	19	President	President	NNP
18637	8825	20	of	of	IN
18637	8825	21	this	this	DT
18637	8825	22	duty	duty	NN
18637	8825	23	.	.	.
18637	8826	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	8826	2	a	a	DT
18637	8826	3	practice	practice	NN
18637	8826	4	,	,	,
18637	8826	5	said	say	VBD
18637	8826	6	the	the	DT
18637	8826	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8826	8	,	,	,
18637	8826	9	if	if	IN
18637	8826	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8826	11	were	be	VBD
18637	8826	12	possible	possible	JJ
18637	8826	13	,	,	,
18637	8826	14	would	would	MD
18637	8826	15	absorb	absorb	VB
18637	8826	16	the	the	DT
18637	8826	17	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8826	18	of	of	IN
18637	8826	19	the	the	DT
18637	8826	20	various	various	JJ
18637	8826	21	departments	department	NNS
18637	8826	22	of	of	IN
18637	8826	23	the	the	DT
18637	8826	24	government	government	NN
18637	8826	25	in	in	IN
18637	8826	26	the	the	DT
18637	8826	27	personal	personal	JJ
18637	8826	28	acts	act	NNS
18637	8826	29	of	of	IN
18637	8826	30	one	one	CD
18637	8826	31	chief	chief	JJ
18637	8826	32	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8826	33	officer	officer	NN
18637	8826	34	,	,	,
18637	8826	35	and	and	CC
18637	8826	36	be	be	VB
18637	8826	37	fraught	fraught	JJ
18637	8826	38	with	with	IN
18637	8826	39	mischief	mischief	NN
18637	8826	40	to	to	IN
18637	8826	41	the	the	DT
18637	8826	42	public	public	JJ
18637	8826	43	service	service	NN
18637	8826	44	.	.	.
18637	8827	1	The	the	DT
18637	8827	2	President	President	NNP
18637	8827	3	's	's	POS
18637	8827	4	duty	duty	NN
18637	8827	5	in	in	IN
18637	8827	6	general	general	NNP
18637	8827	7	requires	require	VBZ
18637	8827	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8827	9	superintendence	superintendence	NN
18637	8827	10	of	of	IN
18637	8827	11	the	the	DT
18637	8827	12	administration	administration	NN
18637	8827	13	;	;	:
18637	8827	14	yet	yet	CC
18637	8827	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8827	16	can	can	MD
18637	8827	17	not	not	RB
18637	8827	18	be	be	VB
18637	8827	19	required	require	VBN
18637	8827	20	to	to	TO
18637	8827	21	become	become	VB
18637	8827	22	the	the	DT
18637	8827	23	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	8827	24	officer	officer	NN
18637	8827	25	of	of	IN
18637	8827	26	every	every	DT
18637	8827	27	department	department	NN
18637	8827	28	and	and	CC
18637	8827	29	bureau	bureau	NN
18637	8827	30	,	,	,
18637	8827	31	or	or	CC
18637	8827	32	to	to	TO
18637	8827	33	perform	perform	VB
18637	8827	34	in	in	IN
18637	8827	35	person	person	NN
18637	8827	36	the	the	DT
18637	8827	37	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	8827	38	details	detail	NNS
18637	8827	39	incident	incident	NN
18637	8827	40	to	to	IN
18637	8827	41	services	service	NNS
18637	8827	42	which	which	WDT
18637	8827	43	,	,	,
18637	8827	44	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	8827	45	,	,	,
18637	8827	46	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8827	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	8827	48	,	,	,
18637	8827	49	in	in	IN
18637	8827	50	a	a	DT
18637	8827	51	correct	correct	JJ
18637	8827	52	sense	sense	NN
18637	8827	53	,	,	,
18637	8827	54	by	by	IN
18637	8827	55	the	the	DT
18637	8827	56	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8827	57	and	and	CC
18637	8827	58	laws	law	NNS
18637	8827	59	required	require	VBN
18637	8827	60	and	and	CC
18637	8827	61	expected	expect	VBN
18637	8827	62	to	to	TO
18637	8827	63	perform	perform	VB
18637	8827	64	.	.	.
18637	8828	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8828	2	382	382	CD
18637	8828	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8828	4	As	as	IN
18637	8828	5	a	a	DT
18637	8828	6	matter	matter	NN
18637	8828	7	of	of	IN
18637	8828	8	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	8828	9	practice	practice	NN
18637	8828	10	,	,	,
18637	8828	11	in	in	IN
18637	8828	12	fact	fact	NN
18637	8828	13	,	,	,
18637	8828	14	most	most	JJS
18637	8828	15	orders	order	NNS
18637	8828	16	and	and	CC
18637	8828	17	instructions	instruction	NNS
18637	8828	18	emanating	emanate	VBG
18637	8828	19	from	from	IN
18637	8828	20	the	the	DT
18637	8828	21	heads	head	NNS
18637	8828	22	of	of	IN
18637	8828	23	the	the	DT
18637	8828	24	departments	department	NNS
18637	8828	25	,	,	,
18637	8828	26	even	even	RB
18637	8828	27	though	though	IN
18637	8828	28	in	in	IN
18637	8828	29	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	8828	30	of	of	IN
18637	8828	31	powers	power	NNS
18637	8828	32	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	8828	33	by	by	IN
18637	8828	34	statute	statute	NN
18637	8828	35	on	on	IN
18637	8828	36	the	the	DT
18637	8828	37	President	President	NNP
18637	8828	38	,	,	,
18637	8828	39	do	do	VBP
18637	8828	40	not	not	RB
18637	8828	41	even	even	RB
18637	8828	42	refer	refer	VB
18637	8828	43	to	to	IN
18637	8828	44	the	the	DT
18637	8828	45	President	President	NNP
18637	8828	46	.	.	.
18637	8829	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8829	2	383	383	CD
18637	8829	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8829	4	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	8829	5	AND	and	CC
18637	8829	6	DUTY	DUTY	NNS
18637	8829	7	OF	of	IN
18637	8829	8	THE	the	DT
18637	8829	9	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	8829	10	IN	in	IN
18637	8829	11	RELATION	relation	NN
18637	8829	12	TO	to	IN
18637	8829	13	SUBORDINATE	subordinate	JJ
18637	8829	14	EXECUTIVE	EXECUTIVE	NNP
18637	8829	15	OFFICERS	officer	NNS
18637	8829	16	Suppose	suppose	VB
18637	8829	17	,	,	,
18637	8829	18	that	that	IN
18637	8829	19	the	the	DT
18637	8829	20	law	law	NN
18637	8829	21	casts	cast	VBZ
18637	8829	22	a	a	DT
18637	8829	23	duty	duty	NN
18637	8829	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	8829	25	a	a	DT
18637	8829	26	head	head	NN
18637	8829	27	of	of	IN
18637	8829	28	department	department	NN
18637	8829	29	_	_	NNP
18637	8829	30	eo	eo	NNP
18637	8829	31	nomine	nomine	NN
18637	8829	32	_	_	NNP
18637	8829	33	,	,	,
18637	8829	34	does	do	VBZ
18637	8829	35	the	the	DT
18637	8829	36	President	President	NNP
18637	8829	37	thereupon	thereupon	RB
18637	8829	38	become	become	VBP
18637	8829	39	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	8829	40	by	by	IN
18637	8829	41	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	8829	42	of	of	IN
18637	8829	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8829	44	duty	duty	NN
18637	8829	45	to	to	TO
18637	8829	46	"	"	``
18637	8829	47	take	take	VB
18637	8829	48	care	care	NN
18637	8829	49	that	that	IN
18637	8829	50	the	the	DT
18637	8829	51	laws	law	NNS
18637	8829	52	be	be	VB
18637	8829	53	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8829	54	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8829	55	,	,	,
18637	8829	56	"	"	''
18637	8829	57	to	to	TO
18637	8829	58	substitute	substitute	VB
18637	8829	59	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8829	60	own	own	JJ
18637	8829	61	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8829	62	for	for	IN
18637	8829	63	that	that	DT
18637	8829	64	of	of	IN
18637	8829	65	the	the	DT
18637	8829	66	principal	principal	JJ
18637	8829	67	officer	officer	NN
18637	8829	68	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	8829	69	the	the	DT
18637	8829	70	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8829	71	of	of	IN
18637	8829	72	such	such	JJ
18637	8829	73	duty	duty	NN
18637	8829	74	?	?	.
18637	8830	1	In	in	IN
18637	8830	2	the	the	DT
18637	8830	3	debate	debate	NN
18637	8830	4	in	in	IN
18637	8830	5	the	the	DT
18637	8830	6	House	House	NNP
18637	8830	7	in	in	IN
18637	8830	8	1789	1789	CD
18637	8830	9	on	on	IN
18637	8830	10	the	the	DT
18637	8830	11	location	location	NN
18637	8830	12	of	of	IN
18637	8830	13	the	the	DT
18637	8830	14	removal	removal	NN
18637	8830	15	power	power	NN
18637	8830	16	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8830	17	argued	argue	VBD
18637	8830	18	that	that	IN
18637	8830	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8830	20	ought	ought	MD
18637	8830	21	to	to	TO
18637	8830	22	be	be	VB
18637	8830	23	attributed	attribute	VBN
18637	8830	24	to	to	IN
18637	8830	25	the	the	DT
18637	8830	26	President	President	NNP
18637	8830	27	alone	alone	RB
18637	8830	28	because	because	IN
18637	8830	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8830	30	was	be	VBD
18637	8830	31	"	"	``
18637	8830	32	the	the	DT
18637	8830	33	intention	intention	NN
18637	8830	34	of	of	IN
18637	8830	35	the	the	DT
18637	8830	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8830	37	,	,	,
18637	8830	38	expressed	express	VBD
18637	8830	39	especially	especially	RB
18637	8830	40	in	in	IN
18637	8830	41	the	the	DT
18637	8830	42	faithful	faithful	JJ
18637	8830	43	execution	execution	NN
18637	8830	44	clause	clause	NN
18637	8830	45	,	,	,
18637	8830	46	that	that	IN
18637	8830	47	the	the	DT
18637	8830	48	first	first	JJ
18637	8830	49	magistrate	magistrate	NN
18637	8830	50	should	should	MD
18637	8830	51	be	be	VB
18637	8830	52	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	8830	53	for	for	IN
18637	8830	54	the	the	DT
18637	8830	55	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8830	56	department	department	NN
18637	8830	57	"	"	''
18637	8830	58	;	;	,
18637	8830	59	and	and	CC
18637	8830	60	this	this	DT
18637	8830	61	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	8830	62	,	,	,
18637	8830	63	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8830	64	held	hold	VBD
18637	8830	65	,	,	,
18637	8830	66	carried	carry	VBN
18637	8830	67	with	with	IN
18637	8830	68	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8830	69	the	the	DT
18637	8830	70	power	power	NN
18637	8830	71	to	to	TO
18637	8830	72	"	"	``
18637	8830	73	inspect	inspect	VB
18637	8830	74	and	and	CC
18637	8830	75	control	control	VB
18637	8830	76	"	"	''
18637	8830	77	the	the	DT
18637	8830	78	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	8830	79	of	of	IN
18637	8830	80	subordinate	subordinate	JJ
18637	8830	81	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8830	82	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8830	83	.	.	.
18637	8831	1	"	"	``
18637	8831	2	Vest	Vest	NNP
18637	8831	3	,	,	,
18637	8831	4	"	"	''
18637	8831	5	said	say	VBD
18637	8831	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8831	7	,	,	,
18637	8831	8	"	"	``
18637	8831	9	the	the	DT
18637	8831	10	power	power	NN
18637	8831	11	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8831	12	of	of	IN
18637	8831	13	removal	removal	NN
18637	8831	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8831	15	in	in	IN
18637	8831	16	the	the	DT
18637	8831	17	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	8831	18	jointly	jointly	RB
18637	8831	19	with	with	IN
18637	8831	20	the	the	DT
18637	8831	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8831	22	,	,	,
18637	8831	23	and	and	CC
18637	8831	24	you	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8831	25	abolish	abolish	VBP
18637	8831	26	at	at	IN
18637	8831	27	once	once	RB
18637	8831	28	the	the	DT
18637	8831	29	great	great	JJ
18637	8831	30	principle	principle	NN
18637	8831	31	of	of	IN
18637	8831	32	unity	unity	NN
18637	8831	33	and	and	CC
18637	8831	34	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	8831	35	in	in	IN
18637	8831	36	the	the	DT
18637	8831	37	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8831	38	department	department	NN
18637	8831	39	,	,	,
18637	8831	40	which	which	WDT
18637	8831	41	was	be	VBD
18637	8831	42	intended	intend	VBN
18637	8831	43	for	for	IN
18637	8831	44	the	the	DT
18637	8831	45	security	security	NN
18637	8831	46	of	of	IN
18637	8831	47	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	8831	48	and	and	CC
18637	8831	49	the	the	DT
18637	8831	50	public	public	JJ
18637	8831	51	good	good	NN
18637	8831	52	.	.	.
18637	8832	1	"	"	``
18637	8832	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8832	3	384	384	CD
18637	8832	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8832	5	But	but	CC
18637	8832	6	this	this	DT
18637	8832	7	was	be	VBD
18637	8832	8	said	say	VBN
18637	8832	9	with	with	IN
18637	8832	10	respect	respect	NN
18637	8832	11	to	to	IN
18637	8832	12	the	the	DT
18637	8832	13	office	office	NN
18637	8832	14	of	of	IN
18637	8832	15	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8832	16	of	of	IN
18637	8832	17	State	State	NNP
18637	8832	18	;	;	:
18637	8832	19	and	and	CC
18637	8832	20	when	when	WRB
18637	8832	21	shortly	shortly	RB
18637	8832	22	afterward	afterward	RB
18637	8832	23	the	the	DT
18637	8832	24	question	question	NN
18637	8832	25	arose	arise	VBD
18637	8832	26	as	as	IN
18637	8832	27	to	to	IN
18637	8832	28	the	the	DT
18637	8832	29	power	power	NN
18637	8832	30	of	of	IN
18637	8832	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8832	32	to	to	TO
18637	8832	33	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	8832	34	the	the	DT
18637	8832	35	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	8832	36	of	of	IN
18637	8832	37	the	the	DT
18637	8832	38	Comptroller	Comptroller	NNP
18637	8832	39	of	of	IN
18637	8832	40	the	the	DT
18637	8832	41	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	8832	42	,	,	,
18637	8832	43	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8832	44	assumed	assume	VBD
18637	8832	45	a	a	DT
18637	8832	46	very	very	RB
18637	8832	47	different	different	JJ
18637	8832	48	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	8832	49	,	,	,
18637	8832	50	conceding	concede	VBG
18637	8832	51	in	in	IN
18637	8832	52	effect	effect	NN
18637	8832	53	that	that	IN
18637	8832	54	this	this	DT
18637	8832	55	officer	officer	NN
18637	8832	56	was	be	VBD
18637	8832	57	to	to	TO
18637	8832	58	be	be	VB
18637	8832	59	an	an	DT
18637	8832	60	arm	arm	NN
18637	8832	61	of	of	IN
18637	8832	62	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8832	63	of	of	IN
18637	8832	64	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8832	65	's	's	POS
18637	8832	66	own	own	JJ
18637	8832	67	powers	power	NNS
18637	8832	68	,	,	,
18637	8832	69	and	and	CC
18637	8832	70	should	should	MD
18637	8832	71	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8832	72	be	be	VB
18637	8832	73	protected	protect	VBN
18637	8832	74	against	against	IN
18637	8832	75	the	the	DT
18637	8832	76	removal	removal	NN
18637	8832	77	power	power	NN
18637	8832	78	.	.	.
18637	8833	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8833	2	385	385	CD
18637	8833	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8833	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8833	5	_	_	NNP
18637	8833	6	See	See	NNP
18637	8833	7	_	_	NNP
18637	8833	8	p.	p.	NN
18637	8833	9	458	458	CD
18637	8833	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8833	11	.	.	.
18637	8834	1	And	and	CC
18637	8834	2	in	in	IN
18637	8834	3	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	8834	4	_	_	NNP
18637	8834	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	8834	6	_	_	NNP
18637	8834	7	Madison,[386	Madison,[386	NNP
18637	8834	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8834	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8834	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8834	11	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	8834	12	traced	trace	VBD
18637	8834	13	a	a	DT
18637	8834	14	parallel	parallel	JJ
18637	8834	15	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	8834	16	between	between	IN
18637	8834	17	the	the	DT
18637	8834	18	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8834	19	of	of	IN
18637	8834	20	the	the	DT
18637	8834	21	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8834	22	of	of	IN
18637	8834	23	State	State	NNP
18637	8834	24	under	under	IN
18637	8834	25	the	the	DT
18637	8834	26	original	original	JJ
18637	8834	27	act	act	NN
18637	8834	28	which	which	WDT
18637	8834	29	had	have	VBD
18637	8834	30	created	create	VBN
18637	8834	31	a	a	DT
18637	8834	32	"	"	``
18637	8834	33	Department	Department	NNP
18637	8834	34	of	of	IN
18637	8834	35	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	8834	36	Affairs	Affairs	NNPS
18637	8834	37	"	"	''
18637	8834	38	and	and	CC
18637	8834	39	those	those	DT
18637	8834	40	which	which	WDT
18637	8834	41	had	have	VBD
18637	8834	42	been	be	VBN
18637	8834	43	added	add	VBN
18637	8834	44	by	by	IN
18637	8834	45	the	the	DT
18637	8834	46	later	later	JJ
18637	8834	47	act	act	NN
18637	8834	48	changing	change	VBG
18637	8834	49	the	the	DT
18637	8834	50	designation	designation	NN
18637	8834	51	of	of	IN
18637	8834	52	the	the	DT
18637	8834	53	department	department	NN
18637	8834	54	to	to	IN
18637	8834	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8834	56	present	present	JJ
18637	8834	57	one	one	CD
18637	8834	58	.	.	.
18637	8835	1	The	the	DT
18637	8835	2	former	former	JJ
18637	8835	3	were	be	VBD
18637	8835	4	,	,	,
18637	8835	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8835	6	pointed	point	VBD
18637	8835	7	out	out	RP
18637	8835	8	,	,	,
18637	8835	9	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	8835	10	in	in	IN
18637	8835	11	the	the	DT
18637	8835	12	"	"	``
18637	8835	13	political	political	JJ
18637	8835	14	field	field	NN
18637	8835	15	,	,	,
18637	8835	16	"	"	''
18637	8835	17	and	and	CC
18637	8835	18	hence	hence	RB
18637	8835	19	for	for	IN
18637	8835	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8835	21	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8835	22	the	the	DT
18637	8835	23	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8835	24	was	be	VBD
18637	8835	25	left	leave	VBN
18637	8835	26	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	8835	27	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	8835	28	to	to	IN
18637	8835	29	the	the	DT
18637	8835	30	President	President	NNP
18637	8835	31	.	.	.
18637	8836	1	The	the	DT
18637	8836	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	8836	3	,	,	,
18637	8836	4	on	on	IN
18637	8836	5	the	the	DT
18637	8836	6	other	other	JJ
18637	8836	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	8836	8	,	,	,
18637	8836	9	were	be	VBD
18637	8836	10	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	8836	11	of	of	IN
18637	8836	12	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	8836	13	origin	origin	NN
18637	8836	14	and	and	CC
18637	8836	15	sprang	spring	VBD
18637	8836	16	from	from	IN
18637	8836	17	the	the	DT
18637	8836	18	powers	power	NNS
18637	8836	19	of	of	IN
18637	8836	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8836	21	.	.	.
18637	8837	1	For	for	IN
18637	8837	2	these	these	DT
18637	8837	3	,	,	,
18637	8837	4	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8837	5	,	,	,
18637	8837	6	the	the	DT
18637	8837	7	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8837	8	was	be	VBD
18637	8837	9	"	"	``
18637	8837	10	an	an	DT
18637	8837	11	officer	officer	NN
18637	8837	12	of	of	IN
18637	8837	13	the	the	DT
18637	8837	14	law	law	NN
18637	8837	15	"	"	''
18637	8837	16	and	and	CC
18637	8837	17	"	"	``
18637	8837	18	amenable	amenable	JJ
18637	8837	19	to	to	IN
18637	8837	20	the	the	DT
18637	8837	21	law	law	NN
18637	8837	22	for	for	IN
18637	8837	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8837	24	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	8837	25	.	.	.
18637	8838	1	"	"	``
18637	8838	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8838	3	387	387	CD
18637	8838	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8838	5	ADMINISTRATIVE	administrative	NN
18637	8838	6	DECENTRALIZATION	decentralization	NN
18637	8838	7	VERSUS	versu	NNS
18637	8838	8	JACKSONIAN	JACKSONIAN	NNP
18637	8838	9	CENTRALISM	CENTRALISM	NNP
18637	8838	10	An	an	DT
18637	8838	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8838	12	rendered	render	VBN
18637	8838	13	by	by	IN
18637	8838	14	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8838	15	General	General	NNP
18637	8838	16	Wirt	Wirt	NNP
18637	8838	17	in	in	IN
18637	8838	18	1823	1823	CD
18637	8838	19	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	8838	20	the	the	DT
18637	8838	21	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	8838	22	that	that	IN
18637	8838	23	the	the	DT
18637	8838	24	President	President	NNP
18637	8838	25	's	's	POS
18637	8838	26	duty	duty	NN
18637	8838	27	under	under	IN
18637	8838	28	the	the	DT
18637	8838	29	"	"	``
18637	8838	30	take	take	VB
18637	8838	31	care	care	NN
18637	8838	32	"	"	''
18637	8838	33	clause	clause	NN
18637	8838	34	required	require	VBN
18637	8838	35	of	of	IN
18637	8838	36	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8838	37	scarcely	scarcely	RB
18637	8838	38	more	more	RBR
18637	8838	39	than	than	IN
18637	8838	40	that	that	IN
18637	8838	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8838	42	should	should	MD
18637	8838	43	bring	bring	VB
18637	8838	44	a	a	DT
18637	8838	45	criminally	criminally	RB
18637	8838	46	negligent	negligent	JJ
18637	8838	47	official	official	NN
18637	8838	48	to	to	TO
18637	8838	49	book	book	VB
18637	8838	50	for	for	IN
18637	8838	51	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8838	52	derelictions	dereliction	NNS
18637	8838	53	,	,	,
18637	8838	54	either	either	CC
18637	8838	55	by	by	IN
18637	8838	56	removing	remove	VBG
18637	8838	57	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8838	58	or	or	CC
18637	8838	59	by	by	IN
18637	8838	60	setting	set	VBG
18637	8838	61	in	in	RP
18637	8838	62	motion	motion	NN
18637	8838	63	against	against	IN
18637	8838	64	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8838	65	the	the	DT
18637	8838	66	processes	process	NNS
18637	8838	67	of	of	IN
18637	8838	68	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	8838	69	or	or	CC
18637	8838	70	of	of	IN
18637	8838	71	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	8838	72	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	8838	73	.	.	.
18637	8839	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8839	2	388	388	CD
18637	8839	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8839	4	The	the	DT
18637	8839	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8839	6	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	8839	7	overlooked	overlook	VBD
18637	8839	8	the	the	DT
18637	8839	9	important	important	JJ
18637	8839	10	question	question	NN
18637	8839	11	of	of	IN
18637	8839	12	the	the	DT
18637	8839	13	location	location	NN
18637	8839	14	of	of	IN
18637	8839	15	the	the	DT
18637	8839	16	power	power	NN
18637	8839	17	to	to	TO
18637	8839	18	interpret	interpret	VB
18637	8839	19	the	the	DT
18637	8839	20	law	law	NN
18637	8839	21	which	which	WDT
18637	8839	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	8839	23	inevitably	inevitably	RB
18637	8839	24	involved	involve	VBN
18637	8839	25	in	in	IN
18637	8839	26	any	any	DT
18637	8839	27	effort	effort	NN
18637	8839	28	to	to	TO
18637	8839	29	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	8839	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8839	31	.	.	.
18637	8840	1	The	the	DT
18637	8840	2	diametrically	diametrically	RB
18637	8840	3	opposed	opposed	JJ
18637	8840	4	theory	theory	NN
18637	8840	5	that	that	IN
18637	8840	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8840	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	8840	8	unable	unable	JJ
18637	8840	9	to	to	TO
18637	8840	10	vest	vest	VB
18637	8840	11	any	any	DT
18637	8840	12	head	head	NN
18637	8840	13	of	of	IN
18637	8840	14	an	an	DT
18637	8840	15	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8840	16	department	department	NN
18637	8840	17	,	,	,
18637	8840	18	even	even	RB
18637	8840	19	within	within	IN
18637	8840	20	the	the	DT
18637	8840	21	field	field	NN
18637	8840	22	of	of	IN
18637	8840	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8840	24	's	's	POS
18637	8840	25	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	8840	26	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	8840	27	powers	power	NNS
18637	8840	28	,	,	,
18637	8840	29	with	with	IN
18637	8840	30	any	any	DT
18637	8840	31	legal	legal	JJ
18637	8840	32	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	8840	33	which	which	WDT
18637	8840	34	the	the	DT
18637	8840	35	President	President	NNP
18637	8840	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	8840	37	not	not	RB
18637	8840	38	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	8840	39	to	to	IN
18637	8840	40	control	control	NN
18637	8840	41	was	be	VBD
18637	8840	42	first	first	RB
18637	8840	43	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	8840	44	in	in	IN
18637	8840	45	unambiguous	unambiguous	JJ
18637	8840	46	terms	term	NNS
18637	8840	47	in	in	IN
18637	8840	48	President	President	NNP
18637	8840	49	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	8840	50	's	's	POS
18637	8840	51	Protest	Protest	NNP
18637	8840	52	Message	Message	NNP
18637	8840	53	of	of	IN
18637	8840	54	April	April	NNP
18637	8840	55	15	15	CD
18637	8840	56	,	,	,
18637	8840	57	1834,[389	1834,[389	NNP
18637	8840	58	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8840	59	defending	defend	VBG
18637	8840	60	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8840	61	removal	removal	NN
18637	8840	62	of	of	IN
18637	8840	63	Duane	Duane	NNP
18637	8840	64	as	as	IN
18637	8840	65	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8840	66	of	of	IN
18637	8840	67	the	the	DT
18637	8840	68	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	8840	69	,	,	,
18637	8840	70	on	on	IN
18637	8840	71	account	account	NN
18637	8840	72	of	of	IN
18637	8840	73	the	the	DT
18637	8840	74	latter	latter	NN
18637	8840	75	's	's	POS
18637	8840	76	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	8840	77	to	to	TO
18637	8840	78	remove	remove	VB
18637	8840	79	the	the	DT
18637	8840	80	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	8840	81	from	from	IN
18637	8840	82	the	the	DT
18637	8840	83	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	8840	84	of	of	IN
18637	8840	85	the	the	DT
18637	8840	86	United	United	NNP
18637	8840	87	States	States	NNP
18637	8840	88	.	.	.
18637	8841	1	Here	here	RB
18637	8841	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8841	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8841	4	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	8841	5	"	"	''
18637	8841	6	that	that	IN
18637	8841	7	the	the	DT
18637	8841	8	entire	entire	JJ
18637	8841	9	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8841	10	power	power	NN
18637	8841	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	8841	12	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8841	13	in	in	IN
18637	8841	14	the	the	DT
18637	8841	15	President	President	NNP
18637	8841	16	"	"	''
18637	8841	17	;	;	:
18637	8841	18	that	that	IN
18637	8841	19	the	the	DT
18637	8841	20	power	power	NN
18637	8841	21	to	to	TO
18637	8841	22	remove	remove	VB
18637	8841	23	those	those	DT
18637	8841	24	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8841	25	who	who	WP
18637	8841	26	are	be	VBP
18637	8841	27	to	to	TO
18637	8841	28	aid	aid	VB
18637	8841	29	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8841	30	in	in	IN
18637	8841	31	the	the	DT
18637	8841	32	execution	execution	NN
18637	8841	33	of	of	IN
18637	8841	34	the	the	DT
18637	8841	35	laws	law	NNS
18637	8841	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	8841	37	an	an	DT
18637	8841	38	incident	incident	NN
18637	8841	39	of	of	IN
18637	8841	40	that	that	DT
18637	8841	41	power	power	NN
18637	8841	42	;	;	:
18637	8841	43	that	that	IN
18637	8841	44	the	the	DT
18637	8841	45	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8841	46	of	of	IN
18637	8841	47	the	the	DT
18637	8841	48	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	8841	49	was	be	VBD
18637	8841	50	such	such	PDT
18637	8841	51	an	an	DT
18637	8841	52	officer	officer	NN
18637	8841	53	;	;	:
18637	8841	54	that	that	IN
18637	8841	55	the	the	DT
18637	8841	56	custody	custody	NN
18637	8841	57	of	of	IN
18637	8841	58	the	the	DT
18637	8841	59	public	public	JJ
18637	8841	60	property	property	NN
18637	8841	61	and	and	CC
18637	8841	62	money	money	NN
18637	8841	63	was	be	VBD
18637	8841	64	an	an	DT
18637	8841	65	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8841	66	function	function	NN
18637	8841	67	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	8841	68	through	through	IN
18637	8841	69	the	the	DT
18637	8841	70	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8841	71	of	of	IN
18637	8841	72	the	the	DT
18637	8841	73	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	8841	74	and	and	CC
18637	8841	75	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8841	76	subordinates	subordinate	NNS
18637	8841	77	:	:	:
18637	8841	78	that	that	IN
18637	8841	79	in	in	IN
18637	8841	80	the	the	DT
18637	8841	81	performance	performance	NN
18637	8841	82	of	of	IN
18637	8841	83	these	these	DT
18637	8841	84	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8841	85	the	the	DT
18637	8841	86	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8841	87	was	be	VBD
18637	8841	88	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8841	89	to	to	IN
18637	8841	90	the	the	DT
18637	8841	91	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	8841	92	and	and	CC
18637	8841	93	control	control	NN
18637	8841	94	of	of	IN
18637	8841	95	the	the	DT
18637	8841	96	President	President	NNP
18637	8841	97	:	:	:
18637	8841	98	and	and	CC
18637	8841	99	finally	finally	RB
18637	8841	100	that	that	IN
18637	8841	101	the	the	DT
18637	8841	102	act	act	NN
18637	8841	103	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	8841	104	the	the	DT
18637	8841	105	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	8841	106	of	of	IN
18637	8841	107	the	the	DT
18637	8841	108	United	United	NNP
18637	8841	109	States	States	NNP
18637	8841	110	"	"	''
18637	8841	111	did	do	VBD
18637	8841	112	not	not	RB
18637	8841	113	,	,	,
18637	8841	114	as	as	IN
18637	8841	115	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8841	116	could	could	MD
18637	8841	117	not	not	RB
18637	8841	118	change	change	VB
18637	8841	119	the	the	DT
18637	8841	120	relation	relation	NN
18637	8841	121	between	between	IN
18637	8841	122	the	the	DT
18637	8841	123	President	President	NNP
18637	8841	124	and	and	CC
18637	8841	125	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8841	126	--	--	:
18637	8841	127	did	do	VBD
18637	8841	128	not	not	RB
18637	8841	129	release	release	VB
18637	8841	130	the	the	DT
18637	8841	131	former	former	JJ
18637	8841	132	from	from	IN
18637	8841	133	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8841	134	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8841	135	to	to	TO
18637	8841	136	see	see	VB
18637	8841	137	the	the	DT
18637	8841	138	law	law	NN
18637	8841	139	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8841	140	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8841	141	nor	nor	CC
18637	8841	142	the	the	DT
18637	8841	143	latter	latter	JJ
18637	8841	144	from	from	IN
18637	8841	145	the	the	DT
18637	8841	146	President	President	NNP
18637	8841	147	's	's	POS
18637	8841	148	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	8841	149	and	and	CC
18637	8841	150	control	control	NN
18637	8841	151	.	.	.
18637	8842	1	"	"	``
18637	8842	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8842	3	390	390	CD
18637	8842	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8842	5	In	in	IN
18637	8842	6	short	short	JJ
18637	8842	7	,	,	,
18637	8842	8	the	the	DT
18637	8842	9	President	President	NNP
18637	8842	10	's	's	POS
18637	8842	11	removal	removal	NN
18637	8842	12	power	power	NN
18637	8842	13	,	,	,
18637	8842	14	in	in	IN
18637	8842	15	this	this	DT
18637	8842	16	case	case	NN
18637	8842	17	unqualified	unqualified	JJ
18637	8842	18	,	,	,
18637	8842	19	was	be	VBD
18637	8842	20	the	the	DT
18637	8842	21	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	8842	22	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8842	23	by	by	IN
18637	8842	24	the	the	DT
18637	8842	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8842	26	for	for	IN
18637	8842	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8842	28	power	power	NN
18637	8842	29	and	and	CC
18637	8842	30	duty	duty	NN
18637	8842	31	to	to	TO
18637	8842	32	control	control	VB
18637	8842	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8842	34	"	"	``
18637	8842	35	subordinates	subordinate	NNS
18637	8842	36	"	"	''
18637	8842	37	in	in	IN
18637	8842	38	all	all	DT
18637	8842	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8842	40	official	official	JJ
18637	8842	41	actions	action	NNS
18637	8842	42	of	of	IN
18637	8842	43	public	public	JJ
18637	8842	44	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	8842	45	.	.	.
18637	8843	1	CONGRESSIONAL	congressional	JJ
18637	8843	2	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	8843	3	VERSUS	versu	NNS
18637	8843	4	PRESIDENTIAL	presidential	JJ
18637	8843	5	DUTY	DUTY	VBD
18637	8843	6	TO	to	IN
18637	8843	7	THE	the	DT
18637	8843	8	LAW	law	NN
18637	8843	9	Five	five	CD
18637	8843	10	years	year	NNS
18637	8843	11	later	later	RB
18637	8843	12	the	the	DT
18637	8843	13	case	case	NN
18637	8843	14	of	of	IN
18637	8843	15	Kendall	Kendall	NNP
18637	8843	16	_	_	NNP
18637	8843	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	8843	18	_	_	NNP
18637	8843	19	United	United	NNP
18637	8843	20	States[391	States[391	NNP
18637	8843	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8843	22	arose	arise	VBD
18637	8843	23	.	.	.
18637	8844	1	The	the	DT
18637	8844	2	United	United	NNP
18637	8844	3	States	States	NNP
18637	8844	4	owed	owe	VBD
18637	8844	5	one	one	CD
18637	8844	6	Stokes	Stokes	NNP
18637	8844	7	money	money	NN
18637	8844	8	,	,	,
18637	8844	9	and	and	CC
18637	8844	10	when	when	WRB
18637	8844	11	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
18637	8844	12	General	General	NNP
18637	8844	13	Kendall	Kendall	NNP
18637	8844	14	,	,	,
18637	8844	15	at	at	IN
18637	8844	16	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	8844	17	's	's	POS
18637	8844	18	instigation	instigation	NN
18637	8844	19	,	,	,
18637	8844	20	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	8844	21	to	to	TO
18637	8844	22	pay	pay	VB
18637	8844	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8844	24	,	,	,
18637	8844	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8844	26	passed	pass	VBD
18637	8844	27	a	a	DT
18637	8844	28	special	special	JJ
18637	8844	29	act	act	NN
18637	8844	30	ordering	ordering	NN
18637	8844	31	payment	payment	NN
18637	8844	32	.	.	.
18637	8845	1	Kendall	Kendall	NNP
18637	8845	2	,	,	,
18637	8845	3	however	however	RB
18637	8845	4	,	,	,
18637	8845	5	still	still	RB
18637	8845	6	proved	prove	VBD
18637	8845	7	noncompliant	noncompliant	JJ
18637	8845	8	,	,	,
18637	8845	9	whereupon	whereupon	NN
18637	8845	10	Stokes	Stokes	NNP
18637	8845	11	sought	seek	VBD
18637	8845	12	and	and	CC
18637	8845	13	obtained	obtain	VBD
18637	8845	14	a	a	DT
18637	8845	15	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	8845	16	in	in	IN
18637	8845	17	the	the	DT
18637	8845	18	United	United	NNP
18637	8845	19	States	States	NNP
18637	8845	20	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	8845	21	court	court	NN
18637	8845	22	for	for	IN
18637	8845	23	the	the	DT
18637	8845	24	District	District	NNP
18637	8845	25	of	of	IN
18637	8845	26	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	8845	27	,	,	,
18637	8845	28	and	and	CC
18637	8845	29	on	on	IN
18637	8845	30	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	8845	31	this	this	DT
18637	8845	32	decision	decision	NN
18637	8845	33	was	be	VBD
18637	8845	34	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	8845	35	by	by	IN
18637	8845	36	the	the	DT
18637	8845	37	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8845	38	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8845	39	.	.	.
18637	8846	1	While	while	IN
18637	8846	2	Kendall	Kendall	NNP
18637	8846	3	_	_	NNP
18637	8846	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	8846	5	_	_	NNP
18637	8846	6	United	United	NNP
18637	8846	7	States	States	NNP
18637	8846	8	,	,	,
18637	8846	9	like	like	IN
18637	8846	10	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	8846	11	_	_	NNP
18637	8846	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	8846	13	_	_	NNP
18637	8846	14	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	8846	15	,	,	,
18637	8846	16	involved	involve	VBD
18637	8846	17	the	the	DT
18637	8846	18	question	question	NN
18637	8846	19	of	of	IN
18637	8846	20	the	the	DT
18637	8846	21	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	8846	22	of	of	IN
18637	8846	23	a	a	DT
18637	8846	24	head	head	NN
18637	8846	25	of	of	IN
18637	8846	26	department	department	NN
18637	8846	27	for	for	IN
18637	8846	28	the	the	DT
18637	8846	29	performance	performance	NN
18637	8846	30	of	of	IN
18637	8846	31	a	a	DT
18637	8846	32	_	_	NNP
18637	8846	33	ministerial	ministerial	NN
18637	8846	34	_	_	NNP
18637	8846	35	duty	duty	NN
18637	8846	36	,	,	,
18637	8846	37	the	the	DT
18637	8846	38	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	8846	39	by	by	IN
18637	8846	40	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	8846	41	before	before	IN
18637	8846	42	the	the	DT
18637	8846	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8846	44	and	and	CC
18637	8846	45	the	the	DT
18637	8846	46	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8846	47	's	's	POS
18637	8846	48	own	own	JJ
18637	8846	49	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8846	50	covered	cover	VBD
18637	8846	51	the	the	DT
18637	8846	52	entire	entire	JJ
18637	8846	53	subject	subject	NN
18637	8846	54	of	of	IN
18637	8846	55	the	the	DT
18637	8846	56	relation	relation	NN
18637	8846	57	of	of	IN
18637	8846	58	the	the	DT
18637	8846	59	President	President	NNP
18637	8846	60	to	to	IN
18637	8846	61	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8846	62	subordinates	subordinate	NNS
18637	8846	63	in	in	IN
18637	8846	64	the	the	DT
18637	8846	65	performance	performance	NN
18637	8846	66	by	by	IN
18637	8846	67	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8846	68	of	of	IN
18637	8846	69	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	8846	70	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8846	71	.	.	.
18637	8847	1	The	the	DT
18637	8847	2	lower	low	JJR
18637	8847	3	court	court	NN
18637	8847	4	had	have	VBD
18637	8847	5	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	8847	6	that	that	IN
18637	8847	7	the	the	DT
18637	8847	8	duty	duty	NN
18637	8847	9	of	of	IN
18637	8847	10	the	the	DT
18637	8847	11	President	President	NNP
18637	8847	12	under	under	IN
18637	8847	13	the	the	DT
18637	8847	14	faithful	faithful	JJ
18637	8847	15	execution	execution	NN
18637	8847	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	8847	17	gave	give	VBD
18637	8847	18	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8847	19	no	no	DT
18637	8847	20	other	other	JJ
18637	8847	21	control	control	NN
18637	8847	22	over	over	IN
18637	8847	23	the	the	DT
18637	8847	24	officer	officer	NN
18637	8847	25	than	than	IN
18637	8847	26	to	to	TO
18637	8847	27	see	see	VB
18637	8847	28	that	that	IN
18637	8847	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8847	30	acts	act	VBZ
18637	8847	31	honestly	honestly	RB
18637	8847	32	,	,	,
18637	8847	33	with	with	IN
18637	8847	34	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8847	35	motives	motive	NNS
18637	8847	36	,	,	,
18637	8847	37	but	but	CC
18637	8847	38	no	no	DT
18637	8847	39	power	power	NN
18637	8847	40	to	to	TO
18637	8847	41	construe	construe	VB
18637	8847	42	the	the	DT
18637	8847	43	law	law	NN
18637	8847	44	,	,	,
18637	8847	45	and	and	CC
18637	8847	46	see	see	VB
18637	8847	47	that	that	IN
18637	8847	48	the	the	DT
18637	8847	49	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8847	50	action	action	NN
18637	8847	51	conforms	conform	VBZ
18637	8847	52	to	to	IN
18637	8847	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8847	54	.	.	.
18637	8848	1	Counsel	Counsel	NNP
18637	8848	2	for	for	IN
18637	8848	3	Kendall	Kendall	NNP
18637	8848	4	attacked	attack	VBD
18637	8848	5	this	this	DT
18637	8848	6	position	position	NN
18637	8848	7	vigorously	vigorously	RB
18637	8848	8	,	,	,
18637	8848	9	relying	rely	VBG
18637	8848	10	largely	largely	RB
18637	8848	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	8848	12	statements	statement	NNS
18637	8848	13	by	by	IN
18637	8848	14	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	8848	15	,	,	,
18637	8848	16	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	8848	17	,	,	,
18637	8848	18	James	James	NNP
18637	8848	19	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	8848	20	,	,	,
18637	8848	21	and	and	CC
18637	8848	22	Story	story	NN
18637	8848	23	having	have	VBG
18637	8848	24	to	to	TO
18637	8848	25	do	do	VB
18637	8848	26	with	with	IN
18637	8848	27	the	the	DT
18637	8848	28	President	President	NNP
18637	8848	29	's	's	POS
18637	8848	30	power	power	NN
18637	8848	31	in	in	IN
18637	8848	32	the	the	DT
18637	8848	33	field	field	NN
18637	8848	34	of	of	IN
18637	8848	35	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8848	36	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8848	37	.	.	.
18637	8849	1	The	the	DT
18637	8849	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8849	3	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	8849	4	the	the	DT
18637	8849	5	implication	implication	NN
18637	8849	6	with	with	IN
18637	8849	7	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	8849	8	.	.	.
18637	8850	1	There	there	EX
18637	8850	2	are	be	VBP
18637	8850	3	,	,	,
18637	8850	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8850	5	pointed	point	VBD
18637	8850	6	out	out	RP
18637	8850	7	,	,	,
18637	8850	8	"	"	``
18637	8850	9	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8850	10	political	political	JJ
18637	8850	11	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8850	12	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	8850	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	8850	14	many	many	JJ
18637	8850	15	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8850	16	in	in	IN
18637	8850	17	the	the	DT
18637	8850	18	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8850	19	department	department	NN
18637	8850	20	,	,	,
18637	8850	21	the	the	DT
18637	8850	22	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8850	23	of	of	IN
18637	8850	24	which	which	WDT
18637	8850	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	8850	26	under	under	IN
18637	8850	27	the	the	DT
18637	8850	28	direction	direction	NN
18637	8850	29	of	of	IN
18637	8850	30	the	the	DT
18637	8850	31	President	President	NNP
18637	8850	32	.	.	.
18637	8851	1	But	but	CC
18637	8851	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8851	3	would	would	MD
18637	8851	4	be	be	VB
18637	8851	5	an	an	DT
18637	8851	6	alarming	alarm	VBG
18637	8851	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	8851	8	,	,	,
18637	8851	9	that	that	IN
18637	8851	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8851	11	can	can	MD
18637	8851	12	not	not	RB
18637	8851	13	impose	impose	VB
18637	8851	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	8851	15	any	any	DT
18637	8851	16	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8851	17	officer	officer	NN
18637	8851	18	any	any	DT
18637	8851	19	duty	duty	NN
18637	8851	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8851	21	may	may	MD
18637	8851	22	think	think	VB
18637	8851	23	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8851	24	,	,	,
18637	8851	25	which	which	WDT
18637	8851	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	8851	27	not	not	RB
18637	8851	28	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	8851	29	to	to	IN
18637	8851	30	any	any	DT
18637	8851	31	rights	right	NNS
18637	8851	32	secured	secure	VBN
18637	8851	33	and	and	CC
18637	8851	34	protected	protect	VBN
18637	8851	35	by	by	IN
18637	8851	36	the	the	DT
18637	8851	37	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8851	38	;	;	:
18637	8851	39	and	and	CC
18637	8851	40	in	in	IN
18637	8851	41	such	such	JJ
18637	8851	42	cases	case	NNS
18637	8851	43	the	the	DT
18637	8851	44	duty	duty	NN
18637	8851	45	and	and	CC
18637	8851	46	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	8851	47	grow	grow	VBP
18637	8851	48	out	out	IN
18637	8851	49	of	of	IN
18637	8851	50	and	and	CC
18637	8851	51	are	be	VBP
18637	8851	52	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8851	53	to	to	IN
18637	8851	54	the	the	DT
18637	8851	55	control	control	NN
18637	8851	56	of	of	IN
18637	8851	57	the	the	DT
18637	8851	58	law	law	NN
18637	8851	59	,	,	,
18637	8851	60	and	and	CC
18637	8851	61	not	not	RB
18637	8851	62	to	to	IN
18637	8851	63	the	the	DT
18637	8851	64	direction	direction	NN
18637	8851	65	of	of	IN
18637	8851	66	the	the	DT
18637	8851	67	President	President	NNP
18637	8851	68	.	.	.
18637	8852	1	And	and	CC
18637	8852	2	this	this	DT
18637	8852	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8852	4	emphatically	emphatically	RB
18637	8852	5	the	the	DT
18637	8852	6	case	case	NN
18637	8852	7	,	,	,
18637	8852	8	where	where	WRB
18637	8852	9	the	the	DT
18637	8852	10	duty	duty	NN
18637	8852	11	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	8852	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	8852	13	of	of	IN
18637	8852	14	a	a	DT
18637	8852	15	mere	mere	JJ
18637	8852	16	ministerial	ministerial	JJ
18637	8852	17	character	character	NN
18637	8852	18	.	.	.
18637	8853	1	"	"	``
18637	8853	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8853	3	392	392	CD
18637	8853	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8853	5	In	in	IN
18637	8853	6	short	short	JJ
18637	8853	7	,	,	,
18637	8853	8	the	the	DT
18637	8853	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8853	10	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	8853	11	the	the	DT
18637	8853	12	underlying	underlying	JJ
18637	8853	13	question	question	NN
18637	8853	14	of	of	IN
18637	8853	15	the	the	DT
18637	8853	16	case	case	NN
18637	8853	17	to	to	TO
18637	8853	18	be	be	VB
18637	8853	19	whether	whether	IN
18637	8853	20	the	the	DT
18637	8853	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8853	22	's	's	POS
18637	8853	23	duty	duty	NN
18637	8853	24	to	to	TO
18637	8853	25	"	"	``
18637	8853	26	take	take	VB
18637	8853	27	care	care	NN
18637	8853	28	that	that	IN
18637	8853	29	the	the	DT
18637	8853	30	laws	law	NNS
18637	8853	31	be	be	VB
18637	8853	32	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8853	33	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8853	34	"	"	``
18637	8853	35	made	make	VBN
18637	8853	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8853	37	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	8853	38	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	8853	39	for	for	IN
18637	8853	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8853	41	ever	ever	RB
18637	8853	42	to	to	TO
18637	8853	43	entrust	entrust	VB
18637	8853	44	the	the	DT
18637	8853	45	construction	construction	NN
18637	8853	46	of	of	IN
18637	8853	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8853	48	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	8853	49	to	to	IN
18637	8853	50	anybody	anybody	NN
18637	8853	51	but	but	CC
18637	8853	52	the	the	DT
18637	8853	53	President	President	NNP
18637	8853	54	;	;	:
18637	8853	55	and	and	CC
18637	8853	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8853	57	answered	answer	VBD
18637	8853	58	this	this	DT
18637	8853	59	in	in	IN
18637	8853	60	the	the	DT
18637	8853	61	negative	negative	NN
18637	8853	62	.	.	.
18637	8854	1	MYERS	myer	NNS
18637	8854	2	CASE	case	NN
18637	8854	3	VERSUS	VERSUS	NNP
18637	8854	4	HUMPHREY	HUMPHREY	NNP
18637	8854	5	CASE	case	NN
18637	8854	6	How	how	WRB
18637	8854	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	8854	8	this	this	DT
18637	8854	9	issue	issue	NN
18637	8854	10	stand	stand	VB
18637	8854	11	today	today	NN
18637	8854	12	?	?	.
18637	8855	1	The	the	DT
18637	8855	2	answer	answer	NN
18637	8855	3	to	to	IN
18637	8855	4	this	this	DT
18637	8855	5	question	question	NN
18637	8855	6	,	,	,
18637	8855	7	so	so	RB
18637	8855	8	far	far	RB
18637	8855	9	as	as	IN
18637	8855	10	there	there	EX
18637	8855	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	8855	12	one	one	CD
18637	8855	13	,	,	,
18637	8855	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8855	15	to	to	TO
18637	8855	16	be	be	VB
18637	8855	17	sought	seek	VBN
18637	8855	18	in	in	IN
18637	8855	19	a	a	DT
18637	8855	20	comparison	comparison	NN
18637	8855	21	of	of	IN
18637	8855	22	the	the	DT
18637	8855	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8855	24	's	's	POS
18637	8855	25	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	8855	26	in	in	IN
18637	8855	27	the	the	DT
18637	8855	28	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	8855	29	and	and	CC
18637	8855	30	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	8855	31	cases	case	NNS
18637	8855	32	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	8855	33	.	.	.
18637	8856	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8856	2	393	393	CD
18637	8856	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8856	4	The	the	DT
18637	8856	5	former	former	JJ
18637	8856	6	decision	decision	NN
18637	8856	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	8856	8	still	still	RB
18637	8856	9	valid	valid	JJ
18637	8856	10	to	to	TO
18637	8856	11	support	support	VB
18637	8856	12	the	the	DT
18637	8856	13	President	President	NNP
18637	8856	14	's	's	POS
18637	8856	15	right	right	NN
18637	8856	16	to	to	TO
18637	8856	17	remove	remove	VB
18637	8856	18	,	,	,
18637	8856	19	and	and	CC
18637	8856	20	hence	hence	RB
18637	8856	21	to	to	TO
18637	8856	22	control	control	VB
18637	8856	23	the	the	DT
18637	8856	24	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	8856	25	of	of	IN
18637	8856	26	,	,	,
18637	8856	27	all	all	DT
18637	8856	28	officials	official	NNS
18637	8856	29	through	through	IN
18637	8856	30	whom	whom	WP
18637	8856	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8856	32	exercises	exercise	VBZ
18637	8856	33	the	the	DT
18637	8856	34	great	great	JJ
18637	8856	35	political	political	JJ
18637	8856	36	powers	power	NNS
18637	8856	37	which	which	WDT
18637	8856	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8856	39	derives	derive	VBZ
18637	8856	40	from	from	IN
18637	8856	41	the	the	DT
18637	8856	42	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8856	43	;	;	:
18637	8856	44	also	also	RB
18637	8856	45	all	all	DT
18637	8856	46	officials	official	NNS
18637	8856	47	--	--	:
18637	8856	48	usually	usually	RB
18637	8856	49	heads	head	NNS
18637	8856	50	of	of	IN
18637	8856	51	departments	department	NNS
18637	8856	52	--	--	:
18637	8856	53	through	through	IN
18637	8856	54	whom	whom	WP
18637	8856	55	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8856	56	exercises	exercise	VBZ
18637	8856	57	powers	power	NNS
18637	8856	58	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	8856	59	upon	upon	IN
18637	8856	60	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8856	61	by	by	IN
18637	8856	62	statute	statute	NN
18637	8856	63	.	.	.
18637	8857	1	The	the	DT
18637	8857	2	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	8857	3	decision	decision	NN
18637	8857	4	assures	assure	NNS
18637	8857	5	to	to	IN
18637	8857	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8857	7	the	the	DT
18637	8857	8	right	right	NN
18637	8857	9	to	to	TO
18637	8857	10	protect	protect	VB
18637	8857	11	the	the	DT
18637	8857	12	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	8857	13	,	,	,
18637	8857	14	and	and	CC
18637	8857	15	hence	hence	RB
18637	8857	16	the	the	DT
18637	8857	17	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	8857	18	of	of	IN
18637	8857	19	decision	decision	NN
18637	8857	20	of	of	IN
18637	8857	21	all	all	DT
18637	8857	22	officials	official	NNS
18637	8857	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	8857	24	whom	whom	WP
18637	8857	25	,	,	,
18637	8857	26	in	in	IN
18637	8857	27	the	the	DT
18637	8857	28	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	8857	29	of	of	IN
18637	8857	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8857	31	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	8857	32	powers	power	NNS
18637	8857	33	,	,	,
18637	8857	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8857	35	confers	confer	VBZ
18637	8857	36	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8857	37	of	of	IN
18637	8857	38	a	a	DT
18637	8857	39	"	"	``
18637	8857	40	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	8857	41	-	-	JJ
18637	8857	42	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	8857	43	"	"	''
18637	8857	44	or	or	CC
18637	8857	45	a	a	DT
18637	8857	46	"	"	``
18637	8857	47	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	8857	48	-	-	JJ
18637	8857	49	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8857	50	"	"	''
18637	8857	51	nature	nature	NN
18637	8857	52	.	.	.
18637	8858	1	The	the	DT
18637	8858	2	former	former	JJ
18637	8858	3	may	may	MD
18637	8858	4	be	be	VB
18637	8858	5	described	describe	VBN
18637	8858	6	as	as	IN
18637	8858	7	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8858	8	for	for	IN
18637	8858	9	the	the	DT
18637	8858	10	satisfactory	satisfactory	JJ
18637	8858	11	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8858	12	of	of	IN
18637	8858	13	which	which	WDT
18637	8858	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8858	15	justifiably	justifiably	RB
18637	8858	16	feels	feel	VBZ
18637	8858	17	that	that	IN
18637	8858	18	a	a	DT
18637	8858	19	specialized	specialized	JJ
18637	8858	20	and	and	CC
18637	8858	21	informed	informed	JJ
18637	8858	22	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8858	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	8858	24	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	8858	25	.	.	.
18637	8859	1	The	the	DT
18637	8859	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	8859	3	are	be	VBP
18637	8859	4	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8859	5	the	the	DT
18637	8859	6	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8859	7	of	of	IN
18637	8859	8	which	which	WDT
18637	8859	9	closely	closely	RB
18637	8859	10	touches	touch	VBZ
18637	8859	11	private	private	JJ
18637	8859	12	rights	right	NNS
18637	8859	13	and	and	CC
18637	8859	14	which	which	WDT
18637	8859	15	ought	ought	MD
18637	8859	16	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	8859	17	be	be	VB
18637	8859	18	accompanied	accompany	VBN
18637	8859	19	or	or	CC
18637	8859	20	preceded	precede	VBN
18637	8859	21	by	by	IN
18637	8859	22	a	a	DT
18637	8859	23	"	"	``
18637	8859	24	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	8859	25	-	-	JJ
18637	8859	26	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8859	27	"	"	''
18637	8859	28	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	8859	29	capable	capable	JJ
18637	8859	30	of	of	IN
18637	8859	31	affording	afford	VBG
18637	8859	32	the	the	DT
18637	8859	33	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	8859	34	of	of	IN
18637	8859	35	such	such	JJ
18637	8859	36	rights	right	NNS
18637	8859	37	the	the	DT
18637	8859	38	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	8859	39	to	to	TO
18637	8859	40	be	be	VB
18637	8859	41	heard	hear	VBN
18637	8859	42	.	.	.
18637	8860	1	In	in	IN
18637	8860	2	neither	neither	DT
18637	8860	3	case	case	NN
18637	8860	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	8860	5	the	the	DT
18637	8860	6	President	President	NNP
18637	8860	7	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	8860	8	to	to	TO
18637	8860	9	force	force	VB
18637	8860	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8860	11	reading	reading	NN
18637	8860	12	of	of	IN
18637	8860	13	the	the	DT
18637	8860	14	law	law	NN
18637	8860	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	8860	16	the	the	DT
18637	8860	17	officer	officer	NN
18637	8860	18	,	,	,
18637	8860	19	but	but	CC
18637	8860	20	only	only	RB
18637	8860	21	to	to	TO
18637	8860	22	take	take	VB
18637	8860	23	care	care	NN
18637	8860	24	that	that	IN
18637	8860	25	the	the	DT
18637	8860	26	latter	latter	JJ
18637	8860	27	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	8860	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8860	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	8860	30	according	accord	VBG
18637	8860	31	to	to	IN
18637	8860	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8860	33	own	own	JJ
18637	8860	34	best	good	JJS
18637	8860	35	lights	light	NNS
18637	8860	36	.	.	.
18637	8861	1	POWER	power	NN
18637	8861	2	OF	of	IN
18637	8861	3	THE	the	DT
18637	8861	4	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	8861	5	TO	to	IN
18637	8861	6	GUIDE	GUIDE	NNP
18637	8861	7	ENFORCEMENT	enforcement	JJ
18637	8861	8	OF	of	IN
18637	8861	9	THE	the	DT
18637	8861	10	PENAL	PENAL	NNP
18637	8861	11	LAW	law	NN
18637	8861	12	This	this	DT
18637	8861	13	matter	matter	NN
18637	8861	14	also	also	RB
18637	8861	15	came	come	VBD
18637	8861	16	to	to	IN
18637	8861	17	a	a	DT
18637	8861	18	head	head	NN
18637	8861	19	in	in	IN
18637	8861	20	"	"	``
18637	8861	21	the	the	DT
18637	8861	22	reign	reign	NN
18637	8861	23	of	of	IN
18637	8861	24	Andrew	Andrew	NNP
18637	8861	25	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	8861	26	,	,	,
18637	8861	27	"	"	``
18637	8861	28	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	8861	29	,	,	,
18637	8861	30	and	and	CC
18637	8861	31	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	8861	32	foreshadowing	foreshadow	VBG
18637	8861	33	,	,	,
18637	8861	34	the	the	DT
18637	8861	35	Duane	Duane	NNP
18637	8861	36	episode	episode	NN
18637	8861	37	by	by	IN
18637	8861	38	some	some	DT
18637	8861	39	months	month	NNS
18637	8861	40	.	.	.
18637	8862	1	"	"	``
18637	8862	2	At	at	IN
18637	8862	3	that	that	DT
18637	8862	4	epoch	epoch	NN
18637	8862	5	,	,	,
18637	8862	6	"	"	''
18637	8862	7	Wyman	Wyman	NNP
18637	8862	8	relates	relate	VBZ
18637	8862	9	in	in	IN
18637	8862	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8862	11	Principles	Principles	NNPS
18637	8862	12	of	of	IN
18637	8862	13	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	8862	14	Law	Law	NNP
18637	8862	15	,	,	,
18637	8862	16	"	"	''
18637	8862	17	the	the	DT
18637	8862	18	first	first	JJ
18637	8862	19	announcement	announcement	NN
18637	8862	20	of	of	IN
18637	8862	21	the	the	DT
18637	8862	22	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	8862	23	of	of	IN
18637	8862	24	centralism	centralism	NN
18637	8862	25	in	in	IN
18637	8862	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8862	27	entirety	entirety	NN
18637	8862	28	was	be	VBD
18637	8862	29	set	set	VBN
18637	8862	30	forth	forth	RP
18637	8862	31	in	in	IN
18637	8862	32	an	an	DT
18637	8862	33	obscure	obscure	JJ
18637	8862	34	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8862	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	8862	36	an	an	DT
18637	8862	37	unimportant	unimportant	JJ
18637	8862	38	matter	matter	NN
18637	8862	39	--	--	:
18637	8862	40	The	the	DT
18637	8862	41	Jewels	Jewels	NNPS
18637	8862	42	of	of	IN
18637	8862	43	the	the	DT
18637	8862	44	Princess	Princess	NNP
18637	8862	45	of	of	IN
18637	8862	46	Orange	Orange	NNP
18637	8862	47	,	,	,
18637	8862	48	2	2	CD
18637	8862	49	Opin	Opin	NNP
18637	8862	50	.	.	.
18637	8863	1	482	482	CD
18637	8863	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	8863	3	1831	1831	CD
18637	8863	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	8863	5	.	.	.
18637	8864	1	These	these	DT
18637	8864	2	jewels	jewel	NNS
18637	8864	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8864	4	*	*	NFP
18637	8864	5	*	*	NFP
18637	8864	6	were	be	VBD
18637	8864	7	stolen	steal	VBN
18637	8864	8	from	from	IN
18637	8864	9	the	the	DT
18637	8864	10	Princess	Princess	NNP
18637	8864	11	by	by	IN
18637	8864	12	one	one	CD
18637	8864	13	Polari	Polari	NNP
18637	8864	14	,	,	,
18637	8864	15	and	and	CC
18637	8864	16	were	be	VBD
18637	8864	17	seized	seize	VBN
18637	8864	18	by	by	IN
18637	8864	19	the	the	DT
18637	8864	20	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8864	21	of	of	IN
18637	8864	22	the	the	DT
18637	8864	23	United	United	NNP
18637	8864	24	States	States	NNP
18637	8864	25	Customs	Customs	NNP
18637	8864	26	in	in	IN
18637	8864	27	the	the	DT
18637	8864	28	hands	hand	NNS
18637	8864	29	of	of	IN
18637	8864	30	the	the	DT
18637	8864	31	thief	thief	NN
18637	8864	32	.	.	.
18637	8865	1	Representations	representation	NNS
18637	8865	2	were	be	VBD
18637	8865	3	made	make	VBN
18637	8865	4	to	to	IN
18637	8865	5	the	the	DT
18637	8865	6	President	President	NNP
18637	8865	7	of	of	IN
18637	8865	8	the	the	DT
18637	8865	9	United	United	NNP
18637	8865	10	States	States	NNP
18637	8865	11	by	by	IN
18637	8865	12	the	the	DT
18637	8865	13	Minister	Minister	NNP
18637	8865	14	of	of	IN
18637	8865	15	the	the	DT
18637	8865	16	Netherlands	Netherlands	NNP
18637	8865	17	of	of	IN
18637	8865	18	the	the	DT
18637	8865	19	facts	fact	NNS
18637	8865	20	in	in	IN
18637	8865	21	the	the	DT
18637	8865	22	matter	matter	NN
18637	8865	23	,	,	,
18637	8865	24	which	which	WDT
18637	8865	25	were	be	VBD
18637	8865	26	followed	follow	VBN
18637	8865	27	by	by	IN
18637	8865	28	request	request	NN
18637	8865	29	for	for	IN
18637	8865	30	return	return	NN
18637	8865	31	of	of	IN
18637	8865	32	the	the	DT
18637	8865	33	jewels	jewel	NNS
18637	8865	34	.	.	.
18637	8866	1	In	in	IN
18637	8866	2	the	the	DT
18637	8866	3	meantime	meantime	NN
18637	8866	4	the	the	DT
18637	8866	5	District	District	NNP
18637	8866	6	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8866	7	was	be	VBD
18637	8866	8	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
18637	8866	9	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	8866	10	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	8866	11	in	in	IN
18637	8866	12	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	8866	13	of	of	IN
18637	8866	14	the	the	DT
18637	8866	15	United	United	NNP
18637	8866	16	States	States	NNP
18637	8866	17	which	which	WDT
18637	8866	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8866	19	showed	show	VBD
18637	8866	20	no	no	DT
18637	8866	21	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	8866	22	to	to	TO
18637	8866	23	abandon	abandon	VB
18637	8866	24	.	.	.
18637	8867	1	The	the	DT
18637	8867	2	President	President	NNP
18637	8867	3	felt	feel	VBD
18637	8867	4	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8867	5	in	in	IN
18637	8867	6	a	a	DT
18637	8867	7	dilemma	dilemma	NN
18637	8867	8	,	,	,
18637	8867	9	whether	whether	IN
18637	8867	10	if	if	IN
18637	8867	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8867	12	was	be	VBD
18637	8867	13	by	by	IN
18637	8867	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	8867	15	the	the	DT
18637	8867	16	duty	duty	NN
18637	8867	17	of	of	IN
18637	8867	18	the	the	DT
18637	8867	19	District	District	NNP
18637	8867	20	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8867	21	to	to	TO
18637	8867	22	prosecute	prosecute	VB
18637	8867	23	or	or	CC
18637	8867	24	not	not	RB
18637	8867	25	,	,	,
18637	8867	26	the	the	DT
18637	8867	27	President	President	NNP
18637	8867	28	could	could	MD
18637	8867	29	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	8867	30	and	and	CC
18637	8867	31	direct	direct	VB
18637	8867	32	whether	whether	IN
18637	8867	33	to	to	TO
18637	8867	34	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	8867	35	or	or	CC
18637	8867	36	not	not	RB
18637	8867	37	.	.	.
18637	8868	1	The	the	DT
18637	8868	2	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8868	3	was	be	VBD
18637	8868	4	written	write	VBN
18637	8868	5	by	by	IN
18637	8868	6	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	8868	7	,	,	,
18637	8868	8	then	then	RB
18637	8868	9	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8868	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	8868	11	General	General	NNP
18637	8868	12	;	;	:
18637	8868	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8868	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8868	15	full	full	JJ
18637	8868	16	of	of	IN
18637	8868	17	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	8868	18	illustrations	illustration	NNS
18637	8868	19	as	as	IN
18637	8868	20	to	to	IN
18637	8868	21	the	the	DT
18637	8868	22	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	8868	23	in	in	IN
18637	8868	24	an	an	DT
18637	8868	25	administration	administration	NN
18637	8868	26	of	of	IN
18637	8868	27	full	full	JJ
18637	8868	28	power	power	NN
18637	8868	29	in	in	IN
18637	8868	30	the	the	DT
18637	8868	31	chief	chief	JJ
18637	8868	32	executive	executive	NN
18637	8868	33	as	as	IN
18637	8868	34	the	the	DT
18637	8868	35	concomitant	concomitant	NN
18637	8868	36	of	of	IN
18637	8868	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8868	38	full	full	JJ
18637	8868	39	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	8868	40	.	.	.
18637	8869	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8869	2	concludes	conclude	VBZ
18637	8869	3	:	:	:
18637	8869	4	If	if	IN
18637	8869	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8869	6	should	should	MD
18637	8869	7	be	be	VB
18637	8869	8	said	say	VBN
18637	8869	9	that	that	IN
18637	8869	10	,	,	,
18637	8869	11	the	the	DT
18637	8869	12	District	District	NNP
18637	8869	13	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8869	14	having	have	VBG
18637	8869	15	the	the	DT
18637	8869	16	power	power	NN
18637	8869	17	to	to	TO
18637	8869	18	discontinue	discontinue	VB
18637	8869	19	the	the	DT
18637	8869	20	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	8869	21	,	,	,
18637	8869	22	there	there	EX
18637	8869	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	8869	24	no	no	DT
18637	8869	25	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	8869	26	for	for	IN
18637	8869	27	inferring	infer	VBG
18637	8869	28	a	a	DT
18637	8869	29	right	right	NN
18637	8869	30	in	in	IN
18637	8869	31	the	the	DT
18637	8869	32	President	President	NNP
18637	8869	33	to	to	TO
18637	8869	34	direct	direct	VB
18637	8869	35	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8869	36	to	to	TO
18637	8869	37	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	8869	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8869	39	--	--	:
18637	8869	40	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8869	41	answer	answer	VBP
18637	8869	42	that	that	IN
18637	8869	43	the	the	DT
18637	8869	44	direction	direction	NN
18637	8869	45	of	of	IN
18637	8869	46	the	the	DT
18637	8869	47	President	President	NNP
18637	8869	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	8869	49	not	not	RB
18637	8869	50	required	require	VBN
18637	8869	51	to	to	TO
18637	8869	52	communicate	communicate	VB
18637	8869	53	any	any	DT
18637	8869	54	new	new	JJ
18637	8869	55	authority	authority	NN
18637	8869	56	to	to	IN
18637	8869	57	the	the	DT
18637	8869	58	District	District	NNP
18637	8869	59	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8869	60	,	,	,
18637	8869	61	but	but	CC
18637	8869	62	to	to	TO
18637	8869	63	direct	direct	VB
18637	8869	64	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8869	65	in	in	IN
18637	8869	66	the	the	DT
18637	8869	67	execution	execution	NN
18637	8869	68	of	of	IN
18637	8869	69	a	a	DT
18637	8869	70	power	power	NN
18637	8869	71	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8869	72	is	be	VBZ
18637	8869	73	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	8869	74	to	to	TO
18637	8869	75	possess	possess	VB
18637	8869	76	.	.	.
18637	8870	1	The	the	DT
18637	8870	2	most	most	RBS
18637	8870	3	valuable	valuable	JJ
18637	8870	4	and	and	CC
18637	8870	5	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8870	6	measure	measure	NN
18637	8870	7	may	may	MD
18637	8870	8	often	often	RB
18637	8870	9	be	be	VB
18637	8870	10	for	for	IN
18637	8870	11	the	the	DT
18637	8870	12	President	President	NNP
18637	8870	13	to	to	TO
18637	8870	14	order	order	VB
18637	8870	15	the	the	DT
18637	8870	16	District	District	NNP
18637	8870	17	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8870	18	to	to	TO
18637	8870	19	discontinue	discontinue	VB
18637	8870	20	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	8870	21	.	.	.
18637	8871	1	The	the	DT
18637	8871	2	District	District	NNP
18637	8871	3	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8871	4	might	may	MD
18637	8871	5	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	8871	6	to	to	TO
18637	8871	7	obey	obey	VB
18637	8871	8	the	the	DT
18637	8871	9	President	President	NNP
18637	8871	10	's	's	POS
18637	8871	11	order	order	NN
18637	8871	12	;	;	:
18637	8871	13	and	and	CC
18637	8871	14	if	if	IN
18637	8871	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8871	16	did	do	VBD
18637	8871	17	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	8871	18	,	,	,
18637	8871	19	the	the	DT
18637	8871	20	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	8871	21	,	,	,
18637	8871	22	while	while	IN
18637	8871	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8871	24	remained	remain	VBD
18637	8871	25	in	in	IN
18637	8871	26	office	office	NN
18637	8871	27	,	,	,
18637	8871	28	would	would	MD
18637	8871	29	still	still	RB
18637	8871	30	go	go	VB
18637	8871	31	on	on	RP
18637	8871	32	;	;	:
18637	8871	33	because	because	IN
18637	8871	34	the	the	DT
18637	8871	35	President	President	NNP
18637	8871	36	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8871	37	could	could	MD
18637	8871	38	give	give	VB
18637	8871	39	no	no	DT
18637	8871	40	order	order	NN
18637	8871	41	to	to	IN
18637	8871	42	the	the	DT
18637	8871	43	court	court	NN
18637	8871	44	or	or	CC
18637	8871	45	to	to	IN
18637	8871	46	the	the	DT
18637	8871	47	clerk	clerk	NN
18637	8871	48	to	to	TO
18637	8871	49	make	make	VB
18637	8871	50	any	any	DT
18637	8871	51	particular	particular	JJ
18637	8871	52	entry	entry	NN
18637	8871	53	.	.	.
18637	8872	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8872	2	could	could	MD
18637	8872	3	only	only	RB
18637	8872	4	act	act	VB
18637	8872	5	through	through	IN
18637	8872	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8872	7	subordinate	subordinate	JJ
18637	8872	8	officer	officer	NN
18637	8872	9	the	the	DT
18637	8872	10	District	District	NNP
18637	8872	11	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8872	12	,	,	,
18637	8872	13	who	who	WP
18637	8872	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8872	15	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	8872	16	to	to	IN
18637	8872	17	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8872	18	and	and	CC
18637	8872	19	who	who	WP
18637	8872	20	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	8872	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8872	22	office	office	NN
18637	8872	23	at	at	IN
18637	8872	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8872	25	pleasure	pleasure	NN
18637	8872	26	.	.	.
18637	8873	1	And	and	CC
18637	8873	2	if	if	IN
18637	8873	3	that	that	DT
18637	8873	4	officer	officer	NN
18637	8873	5	still	still	RB
18637	8873	6	continue	continue	VB
18637	8873	7	a	a	DT
18637	8873	8	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	8873	9	which	which	WDT
18637	8873	10	the	the	DT
18637	8873	11	President	President	NNP
18637	8873	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	8873	13	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	8873	14	ought	ought	MD
18637	8873	15	not	not	RB
18637	8873	16	to	to	TO
18637	8873	17	continue	continue	VB
18637	8873	18	,	,	,
18637	8873	19	the	the	DT
18637	8873	20	removal	removal	NN
18637	8873	21	of	of	IN
18637	8873	22	the	the	DT
18637	8873	23	disobedient	disobedient	JJ
18637	8873	24	officer	officer	NN
18637	8873	25	and	and	CC
18637	8873	26	the	the	DT
18637	8873	27	substitution	substitution	NN
18637	8873	28	of	of	IN
18637	8873	29	one	one	CD
18637	8873	30	more	more	RBR
18637	8873	31	worthy	worthy	JJ
18637	8873	32	in	in	IN
18637	8873	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8873	34	place	place	NN
18637	8873	35	would	would	MD
18637	8873	36	enable	enable	VB
18637	8873	37	the	the	DT
18637	8873	38	President	President	NNP
18637	8873	39	through	through	IN
18637	8873	40	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8873	41	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8873	42	to	to	TO
18637	8873	43	execute	execute	VB
18637	8873	44	the	the	DT
18637	8873	45	law	law	NN
18637	8873	46	.	.	.
18637	8874	1	And	and	CC
18637	8874	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8874	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8874	4	for	for	IN
18637	8874	5	this	this	DT
18637	8874	6	among	among	IN
18637	8874	7	other	other	JJ
18637	8874	8	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	8874	9	that	that	WDT
18637	8874	10	the	the	DT
18637	8874	11	power	power	NN
18637	8874	12	of	of	IN
18637	8874	13	removing	remove	VBG
18637	8874	14	the	the	DT
18637	8874	15	District	District	NNP
18637	8874	16	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8874	17	resides	reside	VBZ
18637	8874	18	in	in	IN
18637	8874	19	the	the	DT
18637	8874	20	President	President	NNP
18637	8874	21	.	.	.
18637	8875	1	"	"	``
18637	8875	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8875	3	394	394	CD
18637	8875	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8875	5	THE	the	DT
18637	8875	6	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	8875	7	AS	as	IN
18637	8875	8	LAW	law	NN
18637	8875	9	INTERPRETER	INTERPRETER	NNP
18637	8875	10	The	the	DT
18637	8875	11	power	power	NN
18637	8875	12	accruing	accrue	VBG
18637	8875	13	to	to	IN
18637	8875	14	the	the	DT
18637	8875	15	President	President	NNP
18637	8875	16	from	from	IN
18637	8875	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8875	18	function	function	NN
18637	8875	19	of	of	IN
18637	8875	20	law	law	NN
18637	8875	21	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	8875	22	preparatory	preparatory	JJ
18637	8875	23	to	to	IN
18637	8875	24	law	law	NN
18637	8875	25	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	8875	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	8875	27	daily	daily	RB
18637	8875	28	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
18637	8875	29	in	in	IN
18637	8875	30	relation	relation	NN
18637	8875	31	to	to	IN
18637	8875	32	such	such	JJ
18637	8875	33	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	8875	34	as	as	IN
18637	8875	35	the	the	DT
18637	8875	36	Anti	Anti	NNP
18637	8875	37	-	-	NNP
18637	8875	38	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	8875	39	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	8875	40	,	,	,
18637	8875	41	the	the	DT
18637	8875	42	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	8875	43	-	-	HYPH
18637	8875	44	Hartley	Hartley	NNP
18637	8875	45	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8875	46	,	,	,
18637	8875	47	the	the	DT
18637	8875	48	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	8875	49	Security	Security	NNP
18637	8875	50	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8875	51	,	,	,
18637	8875	52	and	and	CC
18637	8875	53	many	many	JJ
18637	8875	54	lesser	less	JJR
18637	8875	55	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	8875	56	.	.	.
18637	8876	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	8876	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8876	3	this	this	DT
18637	8876	4	the	the	DT
18637	8876	5	whole	whole	JJ
18637	8876	6	story	story	NN
18637	8876	7	.	.	.
18637	8877	1	Not	not	RB
18637	8877	2	only	only	RB
18637	8877	3	do	do	VBP
18637	8877	4	all	all	DT
18637	8877	5	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8877	6	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	8877	7	and	and	CC
18637	8877	8	orders	order	NNS
18637	8877	9	based	base	VBN
18637	8877	10	on	on	IN
18637	8877	11	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	8877	12	which	which	WDT
18637	8877	13	vest	vest	VBD
18637	8877	14	power	power	NN
18637	8877	15	in	in	IN
18637	8877	16	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8877	17	or	or	CC
18637	8877	18	on	on	IN
18637	8877	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8877	20	own	own	JJ
18637	8877	21	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8877	22	powers	power	NNS
18637	8877	23	have	have	VBP
18637	8877	24	the	the	DT
18637	8877	25	force	force	NN
18637	8877	26	of	of	IN
18637	8877	27	law	law	NN
18637	8877	28	,	,	,
18637	8877	29	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8877	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8877	31	do	do	VBP
18637	8877	32	not	not	RB
18637	8877	33	transgress	transgress	VB
18637	8877	34	the	the	DT
18637	8877	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8877	36	's	's	POS
18637	8877	37	reading	reading	NN
18637	8877	38	of	of	IN
18637	8877	39	such	such	JJ
18637	8877	40	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	8877	41	or	or	CC
18637	8877	42	of	of	IN
18637	8877	43	the	the	DT
18637	8877	44	Constitution,[395	constitution,[395	NN
18637	8877	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8877	46	but	but	CC
18637	8877	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8877	48	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	8877	49	makes	make	VBZ
18637	8877	50	law	law	NN
18637	8877	51	in	in	IN
18637	8877	52	a	a	DT
18637	8877	53	more	more	RBR
18637	8877	54	special	special	JJ
18637	8877	55	sense	sense	NN
18637	8877	56	.	.	.
18637	8878	1	In	in	IN
18637	8878	2	the	the	DT
18637	8878	3	famous	famous	JJ
18637	8878	4	Neagle	Neagle	NNP
18637	8878	5	case[396	case[396	NN
18637	8878	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8878	7	an	an	DT
18637	8878	8	order	order	NN
18637	8878	9	of	of	IN
18637	8878	10	the	the	DT
18637	8878	11	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8878	12	General	General	NNP
18637	8878	13	to	to	IN
18637	8878	14	a	a	DT
18637	8878	15	United	United	NNP
18637	8878	16	States	States	NNP
18637	8878	17	marshal	marshal	NN
18637	8878	18	to	to	TO
18637	8878	19	protect	protect	VB
18637	8878	20	a	a	DT
18637	8878	21	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8878	22	of	of	IN
18637	8878	23	the	the	DT
18637	8878	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8878	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8878	26	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8878	27	life	life	NN
18637	8878	28	had	have	VBD
18637	8878	29	been	be	VBN
18637	8878	30	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	8878	31	by	by	IN
18637	8878	32	a	a	DT
18637	8878	33	suitor	suitor	NN
18637	8878	34	was	be	VBD
18637	8878	35	attributed	attribute	VBN
18637	8878	36	to	to	IN
18637	8878	37	the	the	DT
18637	8878	38	President	President	NNP
18637	8878	39	and	and	CC
18637	8878	40	held	hold	VBD
18637	8878	41	to	to	TO
18637	8878	42	be	be	VB
18637	8878	43	"	"	``
18637	8878	44	a	a	DT
18637	8878	45	law	law	NN
18637	8878	46	of	of	IN
18637	8878	47	the	the	DT
18637	8878	48	United	United	NNP
18637	8878	49	States	States	NNP
18637	8878	50	"	"	''
18637	8878	51	in	in	IN
18637	8878	52	the	the	DT
18637	8878	53	sense	sense	NN
18637	8878	54	of	of	IN
18637	8878	55	section	section	NN
18637	8878	56	753	753	CD
18637	8878	57	of	of	IN
18637	8878	58	the	the	DT
18637	8878	59	Revised	Revised	NNP
18637	8878	60	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	8878	61	,	,	,
18637	8878	62	and	and	CC
18637	8878	63	as	as	IN
18637	8878	64	such	such	JJ
18637	8878	65	to	to	TO
18637	8878	66	afford	afford	VB
18637	8878	67	basis	basis	NN
18637	8878	68	for	for	IN
18637	8878	69	a	a	DT
18637	8878	70	writ	writ	NN
18637	8878	71	of	of	IN
18637	8878	72	_	_	NNP
18637	8878	73	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	8878	74	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	8878	75	_	_	NNP
18637	8878	76	transferring	transfer	VBG
18637	8878	77	the	the	DT
18637	8878	78	said	say	VBN
18637	8878	79	marshal	marshal	NN
18637	8878	80	,	,	,
18637	8878	81	who	who	WP
18637	8878	82	had	have	VBD
18637	8878	83	"	"	``
18637	8878	84	got	get	VBN
18637	8878	85	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8878	86	man	man	NN
18637	8878	87	,	,	,
18637	8878	88	"	"	''
18637	8878	89	from	from	IN
18637	8878	90	State	State	NNP
18637	8878	91	to	to	IN
18637	8878	92	national	national	JJ
18637	8878	93	custody	custody	NN
18637	8878	94	.	.	.
18637	8879	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8879	2	for	for	IN
18637	8879	3	the	the	DT
18637	8879	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8879	5	,	,	,
18637	8879	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8879	7	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	8879	8	inquired	inquire	VBD
18637	8879	9	:	:	:
18637	8879	10	"	"	``
18637	8879	11	Is	be	VBZ
18637	8879	12	this	this	DT
18637	8879	13	duty	duty	NN
18637	8879	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8879	15	the	the	DT
18637	8879	16	duty	duty	NN
18637	8879	17	of	of	IN
18637	8879	18	the	the	DT
18637	8879	19	President	President	NNP
18637	8879	20	to	to	TO
18637	8879	21	take	take	VB
18637	8879	22	care	care	NN
18637	8879	23	that	that	IN
18637	8879	24	the	the	DT
18637	8879	25	laws	law	NNS
18637	8879	26	be	be	VB
18637	8879	27	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8879	28	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8879	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8879	30	limited	limit	VBN
18637	8879	31	to	to	IN
18637	8879	32	the	the	DT
18637	8879	33	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	8879	34	of	of	IN
18637	8879	35	acts	act	NNS
18637	8879	36	of	of	IN
18637	8879	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8879	38	or	or	CC
18637	8879	39	of	of	IN
18637	8879	40	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	8879	41	of	of	IN
18637	8879	42	the	the	DT
18637	8879	43	United	United	NNP
18637	8879	44	States	States	NNP
18637	8879	45	according	accord	VBG
18637	8879	46	to	to	IN
18637	8879	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8879	48	_	_	NNP
18637	8879	49	express	express	JJ
18637	8879	50	terms	term	NNS
18637	8879	51	_	_	NNP
18637	8879	52	,	,	,
18637	8879	53	or	or	CC
18637	8879	54	does	do	VBZ
18637	8879	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8879	56	include	include	VB
18637	8879	57	the	the	DT
18637	8879	58	rights	right	NNS
18637	8879	59	,	,	,
18637	8879	60	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8879	61	and	and	CC
18637	8879	62	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	8879	63	growing	grow	VBG
18637	8879	64	out	out	IN
18637	8879	65	of	of	IN
18637	8879	66	the	the	DT
18637	8879	67	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8879	68	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8879	69	,	,	,
18637	8879	70	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8879	71	international	international	JJ
18637	8879	72	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8879	73	,	,	,
18637	8879	74	and	and	CC
18637	8879	75	all	all	PDT
18637	8879	76	the	the	DT
18637	8879	77	protection	protection	NN
18637	8879	78	implied	imply	VBN
18637	8879	79	by	by	IN
18637	8879	80	the	the	DT
18637	8879	81	nature	nature	NN
18637	8879	82	of	of	IN
18637	8879	83	the	the	DT
18637	8879	84	government	government	NN
18637	8879	85	under	under	IN
18637	8879	86	the	the	DT
18637	8879	87	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8879	88	?	?	.
18637	8880	1	"	"	``
18637	8880	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8880	3	397	397	CD
18637	8880	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8880	5	Obviously	obviously	RB
18637	8880	6	,	,	,
18637	8880	7	an	an	DT
18637	8880	8	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	8880	9	answer	answer	NN
18637	8880	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	8880	11	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	8880	12	to	to	IN
18637	8880	13	the	the	DT
18637	8880	14	second	second	JJ
18637	8880	15	branch	branch	NN
18637	8880	16	of	of	IN
18637	8880	17	this	this	DT
18637	8880	18	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	8880	19	,	,	,
18637	8880	20	an	an	DT
18637	8880	21	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	8880	22	which	which	WDT
18637	8880	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	8880	24	borne	bear	VBN
18637	8880	25	out	out	RP
18637	8880	26	by	by	IN
18637	8880	27	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	8880	28	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	8880	29	.	.	.
18637	8881	1	And	and	CC
18637	8881	2	in	in	IN
18637	8881	3	United	United	NNP
18637	8881	4	States	States	NNP
18637	8881	5	_	_	NNP
18637	8881	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	8881	7	_	_	NNP
18637	8881	8	Midwest	Midwest	NNP
18637	8881	9	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	8881	10	Company[398	Company[398	NNP
18637	8881	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8881	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8881	13	was	be	VBD
18637	8881	14	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	8881	15	that	that	IN
18637	8881	16	the	the	DT
18637	8881	17	President	President	NNP
18637	8881	18	had	have	VBD
18637	8881	19	,	,	,
18637	8881	20	by	by	IN
18637	8881	21	dint	dint	NN
18637	8881	22	of	of	IN
18637	8881	23	repeated	repeated	JJ
18637	8881	24	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	8881	25	of	of	IN
18637	8881	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8881	27	from	from	IN
18637	8881	28	an	an	DT
18637	8881	29	early	early	JJ
18637	8881	30	date	date	NN
18637	8881	31	,	,	,
18637	8881	32	acquired	acquire	VBD
18637	8881	33	the	the	DT
18637	8881	34	right	right	NN
18637	8881	35	to	to	TO
18637	8881	36	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	8881	37	,	,	,
18637	8881	38	via	via	IN
18637	8881	39	the	the	DT
18637	8881	40	Land	Land	NNP
18637	8881	41	Department	Department	NNP
18637	8881	42	,	,	,
18637	8881	43	public	public	JJ
18637	8881	44	lands	land	NNS
18637	8881	45	,	,	,
18637	8881	46	both	both	DT
18637	8881	47	mineral	mineral	NN
18637	8881	48	and	and	CC
18637	8881	49	nonmineral	nonmineral	NN
18637	8881	50	,	,	,
18637	8881	51	from	from	IN
18637	8881	52	private	private	JJ
18637	8881	53	acquisition	acquisition	NN
18637	8881	54	,	,	,
18637	8881	55	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8881	56	having	have	VBG
18637	8881	57	never	never	RB
18637	8881	58	repudiated	repudiate	VBN
18637	8881	59	the	the	DT
18637	8881	60	practice	practice	NN
18637	8881	61	.	.	.
18637	8882	1	MILITARY	MILITARY	NNP
18637	8882	2	POWER	POWER	NNP
18637	8882	3	IN	in	IN
18637	8882	4	LAW	law	NN
18637	8882	5	ENFORCEMENT	enforcement	NN
18637	8882	6	:	:	:
18637	8882	7	THE	the	DT
18637	8882	8	POSSE	POSSE	NNP
18637	8882	9	COMITATUS	COMITATUS	NNP
18637	8882	10	"	"	''
18637	8882	11	Whenever	Whenever	NNP
18637	8882	12	,	,	,
18637	8882	13	by	by	IN
18637	8882	14	reason	reason	NN
18637	8882	15	of	of	IN
18637	8882	16	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	8882	17	obstructions	obstruction	NNS
18637	8882	18	,	,	,
18637	8882	19	combinations	combination	NNS
18637	8882	20	,	,	,
18637	8882	21	or	or	CC
18637	8882	22	assemblages	assemblage	NNS
18637	8882	23	of	of	IN
18637	8882	24	persons	person	NNS
18637	8882	25	,	,	,
18637	8882	26	or	or	CC
18637	8882	27	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	8882	28	against	against	IN
18637	8882	29	the	the	DT
18637	8882	30	authority	authority	NN
18637	8882	31	of	of	IN
18637	8882	32	the	the	DT
18637	8882	33	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8882	34	of	of	IN
18637	8882	35	the	the	DT
18637	8882	36	United	United	NNP
18637	8882	37	States	States	NNP
18637	8882	38	,	,	,
18637	8882	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8882	40	shall	shall	MD
18637	8882	41	become	become	VB
18637	8882	42	impracticable	impracticable	JJ
18637	8882	43	,	,	,
18637	8882	44	in	in	IN
18637	8882	45	the	the	DT
18637	8882	46	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8882	47	of	of	IN
18637	8882	48	the	the	DT
18637	8882	49	President	President	NNP
18637	8882	50	,	,	,
18637	8882	51	to	to	TO
18637	8882	52	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	8882	53	,	,	,
18637	8882	54	by	by	IN
18637	8882	55	the	the	DT
18637	8882	56	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	8882	57	course	course	NN
18637	8882	58	of	of	IN
18637	8882	59	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8882	60	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	8882	61	,	,	,
18637	8882	62	the	the	DT
18637	8882	63	laws	law	NNS
18637	8882	64	of	of	IN
18637	8882	65	the	the	DT
18637	8882	66	United	United	NNP
18637	8882	67	States	States	NNP
18637	8882	68	within	within	IN
18637	8882	69	any	any	DT
18637	8882	70	State	State	NNP
18637	8882	71	or	or	CC
18637	8882	72	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	8882	73	,	,	,
18637	8882	74	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8882	75	shall	shall	MD
18637	8882	76	be	be	VB
18637	8882	77	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	8882	78	for	for	IN
18637	8882	79	the	the	DT
18637	8882	80	President	President	NNP
18637	8882	81	to	to	TO
18637	8882	82	call	call	VB
18637	8882	83	forth	forth	RB
18637	8882	84	the	the	DT
18637	8882	85	militia	militia	NN
18637	8882	86	of	of	IN
18637	8882	87	any	any	DT
18637	8882	88	or	or	CC
18637	8882	89	all	all	PDT
18637	8882	90	the	the	DT
18637	8882	91	States	States	NNPS
18637	8882	92	,	,	,
18637	8882	93	and	and	CC
18637	8882	94	to	to	TO
18637	8882	95	employ	employ	VB
18637	8882	96	such	such	JJ
18637	8882	97	parts	part	NNS
18637	8882	98	of	of	IN
18637	8882	99	the	the	DT
18637	8882	100	land	land	NN
18637	8882	101	and	and	CC
18637	8882	102	naval	naval	JJ
18637	8882	103	forces	force	NNS
18637	8882	104	of	of	IN
18637	8882	105	the	the	DT
18637	8882	106	United	United	NNP
18637	8882	107	States	States	NNP
18637	8882	108	as	as	IN
18637	8882	109	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8882	110	may	may	MD
18637	8882	111	deem	deem	VB
18637	8882	112	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8882	113	to	to	TO
18637	8882	114	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	8882	115	the	the	DT
18637	8882	116	faithful	faithful	JJ
18637	8882	117	execution	execution	NN
18637	8882	118	of	of	IN
18637	8882	119	the	the	DT
18637	8882	120	laws	law	NNS
18637	8882	121	of	of	IN
18637	8882	122	the	the	DT
18637	8882	123	United	United	NNP
18637	8882	124	States	States	NNP
18637	8882	125	,	,	,
18637	8882	126	or	or	CC
18637	8882	127	to	to	TO
18637	8882	128	suppress	suppress	VB
18637	8882	129	such	such	JJ
18637	8882	130	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	8882	131	,	,	,
18637	8882	132	in	in	IN
18637	8882	133	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	8882	134	State	State	NNP
18637	8882	135	or	or	CC
18637	8882	136	Territory	territory	NN
18637	8882	137	thereof	thereof	IN
18637	8882	138	the	the	DT
18637	8882	139	laws	law	NNS
18637	8882	140	of	of	IN
18637	8882	141	the	the	DT
18637	8882	142	United	United	NNP
18637	8882	143	States	States	NNP
18637	8882	144	may	may	MD
18637	8882	145	be	be	VB
18637	8882	146	forcibly	forcibly	RB
18637	8882	147	opposed	oppose	VBN
18637	8882	148	,	,	,
18637	8882	149	or	or	CC
18637	8882	150	the	the	DT
18637	8882	151	execution	execution	NN
18637	8882	152	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8882	153	forcibly	forcibly	RB
18637	8882	154	obstructed	obstruct	VBN
18637	8882	155	.	.	.
18637	8883	1	"	"	``
18637	8883	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8883	3	399	399	CD
18637	8883	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8883	5	This	this	DT
18637	8883	6	provision	provision	NN
18637	8883	7	of	of	IN
18637	8883	8	the	the	DT
18637	8883	9	United	United	NNP
18637	8883	10	States	States	NNP
18637	8883	11	Code	Code	NNP
18637	8883	12	consolidates	consolidate	VBZ
18637	8883	13	a	a	DT
18637	8883	14	course	course	NN
18637	8883	15	of	of	IN
18637	8883	16	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8883	17	which	which	WDT
18637	8883	18	began	begin	VBD
18637	8883	19	at	at	IN
18637	8883	20	the	the	DT
18637	8883	21	time	time	NN
18637	8883	22	of	of	IN
18637	8883	23	the	the	DT
18637	8883	24	Whiskey	Whiskey	NNP
18637	8883	25	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
18637	8883	26	of	of	IN
18637	8883	27	1792	1792	CD
18637	8883	28	.	.	.
18637	8884	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8884	2	400	400	CD
18637	8884	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8884	4	In	in	IN
18637	8884	5	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	8884	6	_	_	NNP
18637	8884	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	8884	8	_	_	NNP
18637	8884	9	Mott,[401	Mott,[401	NNP
18637	8884	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8884	11	which	which	WDT
18637	8884	12	arose	arise	VBD
18637	8884	13	out	out	IN
18637	8884	14	of	of	IN
18637	8884	15	the	the	DT
18637	8884	16	War	War	NNP
18637	8884	17	of	of	IN
18637	8884	18	1812	1812	CD
18637	8884	19	,	,	,
18637	8884	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8884	21	was	be	VBD
18637	8884	22	held	hold	VBN
18637	8884	23	that	that	IN
18637	8884	24	the	the	DT
18637	8884	25	authority	authority	NN
18637	8884	26	to	to	TO
18637	8884	27	decide	decide	VB
18637	8884	28	whether	whether	IN
18637	8884	29	the	the	DT
18637	8884	30	exigency	exigency	NN
18637	8884	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	8884	32	arisen	arise	VBN
18637	8884	33	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	8884	34	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	8884	35	to	to	IN
18637	8884	36	the	the	DT
18637	8884	37	President	President	NNP
18637	8884	38	.	.	.
18637	8885	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8885	2	402	402	CD
18637	8885	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8885	4	Even	even	RB
18637	8885	5	before	before	IN
18637	8885	6	that	that	DT
18637	8885	7	time	time	NN
18637	8885	8	,	,	,
18637	8885	9	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	8885	10	had	have	VBD
18637	8885	11	in	in	IN
18637	8885	12	1808	1808	CD
18637	8885	13	,	,	,
18637	8885	14	in	in	IN
18637	8885	15	the	the	DT
18637	8885	16	course	course	NN
18637	8885	17	of	of	IN
18637	8885	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8885	19	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	8885	20	to	to	TO
18637	8885	21	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	8885	22	the	the	DT
18637	8885	23	Embargo	Embargo	NNP
18637	8885	24	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	8885	25	,	,	,
18637	8885	26	issued	issue	VBD
18637	8885	27	a	a	DT
18637	8885	28	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	8885	29	ordering	order	VBG
18637	8885	30	"	"	``
18637	8885	31	all	all	DT
18637	8885	32	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8885	33	having	have	VBG
18637	8885	34	authority	authority	NN
18637	8885	35	,	,	,
18637	8885	36	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8885	37	or	or	CC
18637	8885	38	military	military	NN
18637	8885	39	,	,	,
18637	8885	40	who	who	WP
18637	8885	41	shall	shall	MD
18637	8885	42	be	be	VB
18637	8885	43	found	find	VBN
18637	8885	44	in	in	IN
18637	8885	45	the	the	DT
18637	8885	46	vicinity	vicinity	NN
18637	8885	47	"	"	''
18637	8885	48	of	of	IN
18637	8885	49	an	an	DT
18637	8885	50	unruly	unruly	JJ
18637	8885	51	combination	combination	NN
18637	8885	52	to	to	TO
18637	8885	53	aid	aid	VB
18637	8885	54	and	and	CC
18637	8885	55	assist	assist	VB
18637	8885	56	"	"	''
18637	8885	57	by	by	IN
18637	8885	58	all	all	DT
18637	8885	59	means	mean	NNS
18637	8885	60	in	in	IN
18637	8885	61	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8885	62	power	power	NN
18637	8885	63	,	,	,
18637	8885	64	by	by	IN
18637	8885	65	force	force	NN
18637	8885	66	of	of	IN
18637	8885	67	arms	arm	NNS
18637	8885	68	and	and	CC
18637	8885	69	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	8885	70	"	"	``
18637	8885	71	the	the	DT
18637	8885	72	suppression	suppression	NN
18637	8885	73	of	of	IN
18637	8885	74	such	such	JJ
18637	8885	75	combination	combination	NN
18637	8885	76	.	.	.
18637	8886	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8886	2	403	403	CD
18637	8886	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8886	4	Forty	forty	CD
18637	8886	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	8886	6	six	six	CD
18637	8886	7	years	year	NNS
18637	8886	8	later	later	RBR
18637	8886	9	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8886	10	General	General	NNP
18637	8886	11	Cushing	Cushing	NNP
18637	8886	12	advised	advise	VBD
18637	8886	13	President	President	NNP
18637	8886	14	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	8886	15	that	that	IN
18637	8886	16	in	in	IN
18637	8886	17	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	8886	18	the	the	DT
18637	8886	19	Fugitive	Fugitive	NNP
18637	8886	20	Slave	Slave	NNP
18637	8886	21	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8886	22	of	of	IN
18637	8886	23	1850	1850	CD
18637	8886	24	,	,	,
18637	8886	25	marshals	marshal	NNS
18637	8886	26	of	of	IN
18637	8886	27	the	the	DT
18637	8886	28	United	United	NNP
18637	8886	29	States	States	NNP
18637	8886	30	,	,	,
18637	8886	31	had	have	VBD
18637	8886	32	authority	authority	NN
18637	8886	33	when	when	WRB
18637	8886	34	opposed	oppose	VBN
18637	8886	35	by	by	IN
18637	8886	36	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	8886	37	combinations	combination	NNS
18637	8886	38	,	,	,
18637	8886	39	to	to	TO
18637	8886	40	summon	summon	VB
18637	8886	41	to	to	IN
18637	8886	42	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8886	43	aid	aid	NN
18637	8886	44	not	not	RB
18637	8886	45	only	only	RB
18637	8886	46	bystanders	bystander	NNS
18637	8886	47	and	and	CC
18637	8886	48	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8886	49	generally	generally	RB
18637	8886	50	,	,	,
18637	8886	51	but	but	CC
18637	8886	52	armed	armed	JJ
18637	8886	53	forces	force	NNS
18637	8886	54	within	within	IN
18637	8886	55	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8886	56	precincts	precinct	NNS
18637	8886	57	,	,	,
18637	8886	58	both	both	CC
18637	8886	59	State	State	NNP
18637	8886	60	militia	militia	NN
18637	8886	61	and	and	CC
18637	8886	62	United	United	NNP
18637	8886	63	States	States	NNP
18637	8886	64	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8886	65	,	,	,
18637	8886	66	soldiers	soldier	NNS
18637	8886	67	,	,	,
18637	8886	68	sailors	sailor	NNS
18637	8886	69	,	,	,
18637	8886	70	and	and	CC
18637	8886	71	marines,[404	marines,[404	NNP
18637	8886	72	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8886	73	a	a	DT
18637	8886	74	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	8886	75	which	which	WDT
18637	8886	76	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	8886	77	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8886	78	improved	improve	VBD
18637	8886	79	upon	upon	IN
18637	8886	80	two	two	CD
18637	8886	81	years	year	NNS
18637	8886	82	later	later	RB
18637	8886	83	by	by	IN
18637	8886	84	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	8886	85	,	,	,
18637	8886	86	with	with	IN
18637	8886	87	reference	reference	NN
18637	8886	88	to	to	IN
18637	8886	89	the	the	DT
18637	8886	90	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8886	91	war	war	NN
18637	8886	92	then	then	RB
18637	8886	93	raging	rage	VBG
18637	8886	94	in	in	IN
18637	8886	95	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	8886	96	,	,	,
18637	8886	97	that	that	IN
18637	8886	98	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8886	99	lay	lie	VBD
18637	8886	100	within	within	IN
18637	8886	101	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8886	102	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8886	103	to	to	TO
18637	8886	104	take	take	VB
18637	8886	105	care	care	NN
18637	8886	106	that	that	IN
18637	8886	107	the	the	DT
18637	8886	108	laws	law	NNS
18637	8886	109	be	be	VB
18637	8886	110	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8886	111	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8886	112	to	to	TO
18637	8886	113	place	place	VB
18637	8886	114	the	the	DT
18637	8886	115	forces	force	NNS
18637	8886	116	of	of	IN
18637	8886	117	the	the	DT
18637	8886	118	United	United	NNP
18637	8886	119	States	States	NNP
18637	8886	120	in	in	IN
18637	8886	121	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	8886	122	at	at	IN
18637	8886	123	the	the	DT
18637	8886	124	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	8886	125	of	of	IN
18637	8886	126	the	the	DT
18637	8886	127	marshal	marshal	NN
18637	8886	128	there	there	RB
18637	8886	129	,	,	,
18637	8886	130	to	to	TO
18637	8886	131	be	be	VB
18637	8886	132	used	use	VBN
18637	8886	133	as	as	IN
18637	8886	134	a	a	DT
18637	8886	135	portion	portion	NN
18637	8886	136	of	of	IN
18637	8886	137	the	the	DT
18637	8886	138	_	_	NNP
18637	8886	139	posse	posse	NN
18637	8886	140	comitatus	comitatus	NNP
18637	8886	141	_	_	NNP
18637	8886	142	.	.	.
18637	8887	1	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	8887	2	's	's	POS
18637	8887	3	call	call	NN
18637	8887	4	of	of	IN
18637	8887	5	April	April	NNP
18637	8887	6	15	15	CD
18637	8887	7	,	,	,
18637	8887	8	1861	1861	CD
18637	8887	9	,	,	,
18637	8887	10	for	for	IN
18637	8887	11	75,000	75,000	CD
18637	8887	12	volunteers	volunteer	NNS
18637	8887	13	was	be	VBD
18637	8887	14	,	,	,
18637	8887	15	on	on	IN
18637	8887	16	the	the	DT
18637	8887	17	other	other	JJ
18637	8887	18	hand	hand	NN
18637	8887	19	,	,	,
18637	8887	20	a	a	DT
18637	8887	21	fresh	fresh	JJ
18637	8887	22	invocation	invocation	NN
18637	8887	23	,	,	,
18637	8887	24	though	though	IN
18637	8887	25	of	of	IN
18637	8887	26	course	course	NN
18637	8887	27	on	on	IN
18637	8887	28	a	a	DT
18637	8887	29	vastly	vastly	RB
18637	8887	30	magnified	magnify	VBN
18637	8887	31	scale	scale	NN
18637	8887	32	,	,	,
18637	8887	33	of	of	IN
18637	8887	34	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	8887	35	's	's	POS
18637	8887	36	conception	conception	NN
18637	8887	37	of	of	IN
18637	8887	38	a	a	DT
18637	8887	39	_	_	NNP
18637	8887	40	posse	posse	NN
18637	8887	41	comitatus	comitatus	NN
18637	8887	42	_	_	NNP
18637	8887	43	subject	subject	NN
18637	8887	44	to	to	IN
18637	8887	45	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8887	46	call	call	NN
18637	8887	47	.	.	.
18637	8888	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8888	2	405	405	CD
18637	8888	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8888	4	The	the	DT
18637	8888	5	provision	provision	NN
18637	8888	6	above	above	IN
18637	8888	7	extracted	extract	VBN
18637	8888	8	from	from	IN
18637	8888	9	the	the	DT
18637	8888	10	United	United	NNP
18637	8888	11	States	States	NNP
18637	8888	12	Code	Code	NNP
18637	8888	13	ratifies	ratify	VBZ
18637	8888	14	this	this	DT
18637	8888	15	conception	conception	NN
18637	8888	16	as	as	IN
18637	8888	17	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	8888	18	the	the	DT
18637	8888	19	State	state	NN
18637	8888	20	militias	militia	NNS
18637	8888	21	and	and	CC
18637	8888	22	the	the	DT
18637	8888	23	national	national	JJ
18637	8888	24	forces	force	NNS
18637	8888	25	.	.	.
18637	8889	1	SUSPENSION	suspension	NN
18637	8889	2	OF	of	IN
18637	8889	3	HABEAS	HABEAS	NNP
18637	8889	4	CORPUS	CORPUS	NNP
18637	8889	5	BY	by	IN
18637	8889	6	THE	the	DT
18637	8889	7	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	8889	8	_	_	NNP
18637	8889	9	See	See	NNP
18637	8889	10	_	_	NNP
18637	8889	11	Article	Article	NNP
18637	8889	12	I	I	NNP
18637	8889	13	,	,	,
18637	8889	14	Section	section	NN
18637	8889	15	9	9	CD
18637	8889	16	,	,	,
18637	8889	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	8889	18	2	2	CD
18637	8889	19	,	,	,
18637	8889	20	pp	pp	NNP
18637	8889	21	.	.	.
18637	8890	1	312	312	CD
18637	8890	2	-	-	SYM
18637	8890	3	315	315	CD
18637	8890	4	.	.	.
18637	8891	1	PREVENTIVE	preventive	JJ
18637	8891	2	MARTIAL	MARTIAL	NNP
18637	8891	3	LAW	law	NN
18637	8891	4	The	the	DT
18637	8891	5	question	question	NN
18637	8891	6	of	of	IN
18637	8891	7	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8891	8	power	power	NN
18637	8891	9	in	in	IN
18637	8891	10	the	the	DT
18637	8891	11	presence	presence	NN
18637	8891	12	of	of	IN
18637	8891	13	civil	civil	JJ
18637	8891	14	disorder	disorder	NN
18637	8891	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	8891	16	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	8891	17	with	with	IN
18637	8891	18	in	in	IN
18637	8891	19	modern	modern	JJ
18637	8891	20	terms	term	NNS
18637	8891	21	in	in	IN
18637	8891	22	Moyer	Moyer	NNP
18637	8891	23	_	_	NNP
18637	8891	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	8891	25	_	_	NNP
18637	8891	26	Peabody,[406	Peabody,[406	NNP
18637	8891	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8891	28	decided	decide	VBD
18637	8891	29	in	in	IN
18637	8891	30	1909	1909	CD
18637	8891	31	,	,	,
18637	8891	32	to	to	TO
18637	8891	33	which	which	WDT
18637	8891	34	the	the	DT
18637	8891	35	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	8891	36	Case,[407	Case,[407	NNP
18637	8891	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8891	38	decided	decide	VBD
18637	8891	39	in	in	IN
18637	8891	40	1895	1895	CD
18637	8891	41	,	,	,
18637	8891	42	may	may	MD
18637	8891	43	be	be	VB
18637	8891	44	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	8891	45	as	as	IN
18637	8891	46	an	an	DT
18637	8891	47	addendum	addendum	NN
18637	8891	48	.	.	.
18637	8892	1	Moyer	Moyer	NNP
18637	8892	2	,	,	,
18637	8892	3	a	a	DT
18637	8892	4	labor	labor	NN
18637	8892	5	leader	leader	NN
18637	8892	6	,	,	,
18637	8892	7	brought	bring	VBD
18637	8892	8	suit	suit	NN
18637	8892	9	against	against	IN
18637	8892	10	Peabody	Peabody	NNP
18637	8892	11	,	,	,
18637	8892	12	for	for	IN
18637	8892	13	having	have	VBG
18637	8892	14	ordered	order	VBN
18637	8892	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8892	16	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	8892	17	during	during	IN
18637	8892	18	a	a	DT
18637	8892	19	labor	labor	NN
18637	8892	20	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	8892	21	which	which	WDT
18637	8892	22	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	8892	23	while	while	IN
18637	8892	24	Peabody	Peabody	NNP
18637	8892	25	was	be	VBD
18637	8892	26	governor	governor	NN
18637	8892	27	of	of	IN
18637	8892	28	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	8892	29	.	.	.
18637	8893	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8893	2	for	for	IN
18637	8893	3	a	a	DT
18637	8893	4	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	8893	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8893	6	,	,	,
18637	8893	7	one	one	CD
18637	8893	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8893	9	being	be	VBG
18637	8893	10	absent	absent	JJ
18637	8893	11	,	,	,
18637	8893	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8893	13	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	8893	14	said	say	VBD
18637	8893	15	:	:	:
18637	8893	16	"	"	``
18637	8893	17	Of	of	RB
18637	8893	18	course	course	RB
18637	8893	19	the	the	DT
18637	8893	20	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	8893	21	's	's	POS
18637	8893	22	position	position	NN
18637	8893	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	8893	24	that	that	IN
18637	8893	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8893	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	8893	27	been	be	VBN
18637	8893	28	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	8893	29	of	of	IN
18637	8893	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8893	31	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	8893	32	without	without	IN
18637	8893	33	due	due	JJ
18637	8893	34	process	process	NN
18637	8893	35	of	of	IN
18637	8893	36	law	law	NN
18637	8893	37	.	.	.
18637	8894	1	But	but	CC
18637	8894	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8894	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	8894	4	familiar	familiar	JJ
18637	8894	5	that	that	IN
18637	8894	6	what	what	WP
18637	8894	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	8894	8	due	due	JJ
18637	8894	9	process	process	NN
18637	8894	10	of	of	IN
18637	8894	11	law	law	NN
18637	8894	12	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	8894	13	on	on	IN
18637	8894	14	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	8894	15	.	.	.
18637	8895	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8895	2	varies	vary	VBZ
18637	8895	3	with	with	IN
18637	8895	4	the	the	DT
18637	8895	5	subject	subject	JJ
18637	8895	6	matter	matter	NN
18637	8895	7	and	and	CC
18637	8895	8	the	the	DT
18637	8895	9	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	8895	10	of	of	IN
18637	8895	11	the	the	DT
18637	8895	12	situation	situation	NN
18637	8895	13	.	.	.
18637	8896	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8896	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8896	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8896	4	The	the	DT
18637	8896	5	facts	fact	NNS
18637	8896	6	that	that	WDT
18637	8896	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8896	8	are	be	VBP
18637	8896	9	to	to	TO
18637	8896	10	assume	assume	VB
18637	8896	11	are	be	VBP
18637	8896	12	that	that	IN
18637	8896	13	a	a	DT
18637	8896	14	state	state	NN
18637	8896	15	of	of	IN
18637	8896	16	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	8896	17	existed	exist	VBD
18637	8896	18	and	and	CC
18637	8896	19	that	that	IN
18637	8896	20	the	the	DT
18637	8896	21	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	8896	22	,	,	,
18637	8896	23	without	without	IN
18637	8896	24	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	8896	25	reason	reason	NN
18637	8896	26	but	but	CC
18637	8896	27	in	in	IN
18637	8896	28	good	good	JJ
18637	8896	29	faith	faith	NN
18637	8896	30	,	,	,
18637	8896	31	in	in	IN
18637	8896	32	the	the	DT
18637	8896	33	course	course	NN
18637	8896	34	of	of	IN
18637	8896	35	putting	put	VBG
18637	8896	36	the	the	DT
18637	8896	37	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	8896	38	down	down	RB
18637	8896	39	held	hold	VBD
18637	8896	40	the	the	DT
18637	8896	41	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	8896	42	until	until	IN
18637	8896	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8896	44	thought	think	VBD
18637	8896	45	that	that	IN
18637	8896	46	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8896	47	safely	safely	RB
18637	8896	48	could	could	MD
18637	8896	49	release	release	VB
18637	8896	50	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8896	51	.	.	.
18637	8897	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8897	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8897	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8897	4	In	in	IN
18637	8897	5	such	such	PDT
18637	8897	6	a	a	DT
18637	8897	7	situation	situation	NN
18637	8897	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8897	9	must	must	MD
18637	8897	10	assume	assume	VB
18637	8897	11	that	that	IN
18637	8897	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8897	13	had	have	VBD
18637	8897	14	a	a	DT
18637	8897	15	right	right	NN
18637	8897	16	under	under	IN
18637	8897	17	the	the	DT
18637	8897	18	state	state	NN
18637	8897	19	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	8897	20	and	and	CC
18637	8897	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	8897	22	to	to	TO
18637	8897	23	call	call	VB
18637	8897	24	out	out	RP
18637	8897	25	troops	troop	NNS
18637	8897	26	,	,	,
18637	8897	27	as	as	IN
18637	8897	28	was	be	VBD
18637	8897	29	held	hold	VBN
18637	8897	30	by	by	IN
18637	8897	31	the	the	DT
18637	8897	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8897	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8897	34	of	of	IN
18637	8897	35	the	the	DT
18637	8897	36	State	State	NNP
18637	8897	37	.	.	.
18637	8898	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8898	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8898	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8898	4	That	that	DT
18637	8898	5	means	mean	VBZ
18637	8898	6	that	that	IN
18637	8898	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8898	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	8898	9	make	make	VB
18637	8898	10	the	the	DT
18637	8898	11	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	8898	12	use	use	NN
18637	8898	13	of	of	IN
18637	8898	14	the	the	DT
18637	8898	15	soldiers	soldier	NNS
18637	8898	16	to	to	IN
18637	8898	17	that	that	DT
18637	8898	18	end	end	NN
18637	8898	19	;	;	:
18637	8898	20	that	that	IN
18637	8898	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8898	22	may	may	MD
18637	8898	23	kill	kill	VB
18637	8898	24	persons	person	NNS
18637	8898	25	who	who	WP
18637	8898	26	resist	resist	VBP
18637	8898	27	and	and	CC
18637	8898	28	,	,	,
18637	8898	29	of	of	IN
18637	8898	30	course	course	NN
18637	8898	31	,	,	,
18637	8898	32	that	that	IN
18637	8898	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8898	34	may	may	MD
18637	8898	35	use	use	VB
18637	8898	36	the	the	DT
18637	8898	37	milder	milder	NN
18637	8898	38	measure	measure	NN
18637	8898	39	of	of	IN
18637	8898	40	seizing	seize	VBG
18637	8898	41	the	the	DT
18637	8898	42	bodies	body	NNS
18637	8898	43	of	of	IN
18637	8898	44	those	those	DT
18637	8898	45	whom	whom	WP
18637	8898	46	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8898	47	considers	consider	VBZ
18637	8898	48	to	to	TO
18637	8898	49	stand	stand	VB
18637	8898	50	in	in	IN
18637	8898	51	the	the	DT
18637	8898	52	way	way	NN
18637	8898	53	of	of	IN
18637	8898	54	restoring	restore	VBG
18637	8898	55	peace	peace	NN
18637	8898	56	.	.	.
18637	8899	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	8899	2	arrests	arrest	NNS
18637	8899	3	are	be	VBP
18637	8899	4	not	not	RB
18637	8899	5	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	8899	6	for	for	IN
18637	8899	7	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	8899	8	,	,	,
18637	8899	9	but	but	CC
18637	8899	10	are	be	VBP
18637	8899	11	by	by	IN
18637	8899	12	way	way	NN
18637	8899	13	of	of	IN
18637	8899	14	precaution	precaution	NN
18637	8899	15	to	to	TO
18637	8899	16	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	8899	17	the	the	DT
18637	8899	18	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	8899	19	of	of	IN
18637	8899	20	hostile	hostile	JJ
18637	8899	21	power	power	NN
18637	8899	22	.	.	.
18637	8900	1	So	so	RB
18637	8900	2	long	long	RB
18637	8900	3	as	as	IN
18637	8900	4	such	such	JJ
18637	8900	5	arrests	arrest	NNS
18637	8900	6	are	be	VBP
18637	8900	7	made	make	VBN
18637	8900	8	in	in	IN
18637	8900	9	good	good	JJ
18637	8900	10	faith	faith	NN
18637	8900	11	and	and	CC
18637	8900	12	in	in	IN
18637	8900	13	the	the	DT
18637	8900	14	honest	honest	JJ
18637	8900	15	belief	belief	NN
18637	8900	16	that	that	IN
18637	8900	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8900	18	are	be	VBP
18637	8900	19	needed	need	VBN
18637	8900	20	in	in	IN
18637	8900	21	order	order	NN
18637	8900	22	to	to	TO
18637	8900	23	head	head	VB
18637	8900	24	the	the	DT
18637	8900	25	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	8900	26	off	off	RP
18637	8900	27	,	,	,
18637	8900	28	the	the	DT
18637	8900	29	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	8900	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	8900	31	the	the	DT
18637	8900	32	final	final	JJ
18637	8900	33	judge	judge	NN
18637	8900	34	and	and	CC
18637	8900	35	can	can	MD
18637	8900	36	not	not	RB
18637	8900	37	be	be	VB
18637	8900	38	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	8900	39	to	to	IN
18637	8900	40	an	an	DT
18637	8900	41	action	action	NN
18637	8900	42	after	after	IN
18637	8900	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8900	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	8900	45	out	out	IN
18637	8900	46	of	of	IN
18637	8900	47	office	office	NN
18637	8900	48	on	on	IN
18637	8900	49	the	the	DT
18637	8900	50	ground	ground	NN
18637	8900	51	that	that	IN
18637	8900	52	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8900	53	had	have	VBD
18637	8900	54	not	not	RB
18637	8900	55	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	8900	56	ground	ground	NN
18637	8900	57	for	for	IN
18637	8900	58	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8900	59	belief	belief	NN
18637	8900	60	.	.	.
18637	8901	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8901	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8901	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8901	4	When	when	WRB
18637	8901	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8901	6	comes	come	VBZ
18637	8901	7	to	to	IN
18637	8901	8	a	a	DT
18637	8901	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	8901	10	by	by	IN
18637	8901	11	the	the	DT
18637	8901	12	head	head	NN
18637	8901	13	of	of	IN
18637	8901	14	the	the	DT
18637	8901	15	State	State	NNP
18637	8901	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	8901	17	a	a	DT
18637	8901	18	matter	matter	NN
18637	8901	19	involving	involve	VBG
18637	8901	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8901	21	life	life	NN
18637	8901	22	,	,	,
18637	8901	23	the	the	DT
18637	8901	24	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	8901	25	rights	right	NNS
18637	8901	26	of	of	IN
18637	8901	27	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	8901	28	must	must	MD
18637	8901	29	yield	yield	VB
18637	8901	30	to	to	IN
18637	8901	31	what	what	WP
18637	8901	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8901	33	deems	deem	VBZ
18637	8901	34	the	the	DT
18637	8901	35	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	8901	36	of	of	IN
18637	8901	37	the	the	DT
18637	8901	38	moment	moment	NN
18637	8901	39	.	.	.
18637	8902	1	Public	public	JJ
18637	8902	2	danger	danger	NN
18637	8902	3	warrants	warrant	VBZ
18637	8902	4	the	the	DT
18637	8902	5	substitution	substitution	NN
18637	8902	6	of	of	IN
18637	8902	7	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8902	8	process	process	NN
18637	8902	9	for	for	IN
18637	8902	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	8902	11	process	process	NN
18637	8902	12	.	.	.
18637	8903	1	"	"	``
18637	8903	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8903	3	408	408	CD
18637	8903	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8903	5	THE	THE	NNP
18637	8903	6	DEBS	DEBS	NNP
18637	8903	7	CASE	case	NN
18637	8903	8	The	the	DT
18637	8903	9	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	8903	10	case	case	NN
18637	8903	11	of	of	IN
18637	8903	12	1895	1895	CD
18637	8903	13	arose	arise	VBD
18637	8903	14	out	out	IN
18637	8903	15	of	of	IN
18637	8903	16	a	a	DT
18637	8903	17	railway	railway	NN
18637	8903	18	strike	strike	NN
18637	8903	19	which	which	WDT
18637	8903	20	had	have	VBD
18637	8903	21	caused	cause	VBN
18637	8903	22	the	the	DT
18637	8903	23	President	President	NNP
18637	8903	24	to	to	TO
18637	8903	25	dispatch	dispatch	VB
18637	8903	26	troops	troop	NNS
18637	8903	27	to	to	IN
18637	8903	28	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	8903	29	the	the	DT
18637	8903	30	previous	previous	JJ
18637	8903	31	year	year	NN
18637	8903	32	.	.	.
18637	8904	1	Coincidently	coincidently	RB
18637	8904	2	with	with	IN
18637	8904	3	this	this	DT
18637	8904	4	move	move	NN
18637	8904	5	,	,	,
18637	8904	6	the	the	DT
18637	8904	7	United	United	NNP
18637	8904	8	States	States	NNP
18637	8904	9	district	district	NN
18637	8904	10	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	8904	11	stationed	station	VBN
18637	8904	12	there	there	RB
18637	8904	13	,	,	,
18637	8904	14	acting	act	VBG
18637	8904	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	8904	16	orders	order	NNS
18637	8904	17	from	from	IN
18637	8904	18	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	8904	19	,	,	,
18637	8904	20	obtained	obtain	VBD
18637	8904	21	an	an	DT
18637	8904	22	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	8904	23	from	from	IN
18637	8904	24	the	the	DT
18637	8904	25	United	United	NNP
18637	8904	26	States	States	NNP
18637	8904	27	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	8904	28	court	court	NN
18637	8904	29	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	8904	30	the	the	DT
18637	8904	31	strike	strike	NN
18637	8904	32	on	on	IN
18637	8904	33	account	account	NN
18637	8904	34	of	of	IN
18637	8904	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8904	36	interference	interference	NN
18637	8904	37	with	with	IN
18637	8904	38	the	the	DT
18637	8904	39	mails	mail	NNS
18637	8904	40	and	and	CC
18637	8904	41	with	with	IN
18637	8904	42	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	8904	43	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	8904	44	.	.	.
18637	8905	1	The	the	DT
18637	8905	2	question	question	NN
18637	8905	3	before	before	IN
18637	8905	4	the	the	DT
18637	8905	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8905	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8905	7	was	be	VBD
18637	8905	8	whether	whether	IN
18637	8905	9	this	this	DT
18637	8905	10	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	8905	11	,	,	,
18637	8905	12	for	for	IN
18637	8905	13	violation	violation	NN
18637	8905	14	of	of	IN
18637	8905	15	which	which	WDT
18637	8905	16	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	8905	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	8905	18	been	be	VBN
18637	8905	19	jailed	jail	VBN
18637	8905	20	for	for	IN
18637	8905	21	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	8905	22	of	of	IN
18637	8905	23	court	court	NN
18637	8905	24	,	,	,
18637	8905	25	had	have	VBD
18637	8905	26	been	be	VBN
18637	8905	27	granted	grant	VBN
18637	8905	28	with	with	IN
18637	8905	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	8905	30	.	.	.
18637	8906	1	Conceding	Conceding	NNP
18637	8906	2	,	,	,
18637	8906	3	in	in	IN
18637	8906	4	effect	effect	NN
18637	8906	5	,	,	,
18637	8906	6	that	that	IN
18637	8906	7	there	there	EX
18637	8906	8	was	be	VBD
18637	8906	9	no	no	DT
18637	8906	10	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	8906	11	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	8906	12	for	for	IN
18637	8906	13	the	the	DT
18637	8906	14	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	8906	15	,	,	,
18637	8906	16	the	the	DT
18637	8906	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8906	18	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	8906	19	validated	validate	VBD
18637	8906	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8906	21	on	on	IN
18637	8906	22	the	the	DT
18637	8906	23	ground	ground	NN
18637	8906	24	that	that	IN
18637	8906	25	the	the	DT
18637	8906	26	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8906	27	was	be	VBD
18637	8906	28	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	8906	29	thus	thus	RB
18637	8906	30	to	to	TO
18637	8906	31	protect	protect	VB
18637	8906	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8906	33	property	property	NN
18637	8906	34	in	in	IN
18637	8906	35	the	the	DT
18637	8906	36	mails	mail	NNS
18637	8906	37	,	,	,
18637	8906	38	and	and	CC
18637	8906	39	on	on	IN
18637	8906	40	a	a	DT
18637	8906	41	much	much	RB
18637	8906	42	broader	broad	JJR
18637	8906	43	ground	ground	NN
18637	8906	44	which	which	WDT
18637	8906	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	8906	46	stated	state	VBN
18637	8906	47	in	in	IN
18637	8906	48	the	the	DT
18637	8906	49	following	follow	VBG
18637	8906	50	passage	passage	NN
18637	8906	51	of	of	IN
18637	8906	52	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8906	53	Brewer	Brewer	NNP
18637	8906	54	's	's	POS
18637	8906	55	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8906	56	for	for	IN
18637	8906	57	the	the	DT
18637	8906	58	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8906	59	:	:	:
18637	8906	60	"	"	``
18637	8906	61	Every	every	DT
18637	8906	62	government	government	NN
18637	8906	63	,	,	,
18637	8906	64	entrusted	entrust	VBN
18637	8906	65	,	,	,
18637	8906	66	by	by	IN
18637	8906	67	the	the	DT
18637	8906	68	very	very	JJ
18637	8906	69	terms	term	NNS
18637	8906	70	of	of	IN
18637	8906	71	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8906	72	being	being	NN
18637	8906	73	,	,	,
18637	8906	74	with	with	IN
18637	8906	75	powers	power	NNS
18637	8906	76	and	and	CC
18637	8906	77	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8906	78	to	to	TO
18637	8906	79	be	be	VB
18637	8906	80	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	8906	81	and	and	CC
18637	8906	82	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	8906	83	for	for	IN
18637	8906	84	the	the	DT
18637	8906	85	general	general	JJ
18637	8906	86	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	8906	87	,	,	,
18637	8906	88	has	have	VBZ
18637	8906	89	a	a	DT
18637	8906	90	right	right	NN
18637	8906	91	to	to	TO
18637	8906	92	apply	apply	VB
18637	8906	93	to	to	IN
18637	8906	94	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8906	95	own	own	JJ
18637	8906	96	courts	court	NNS
18637	8906	97	for	for	IN
18637	8906	98	any	any	DT
18637	8906	99	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8906	100	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	8906	101	in	in	IN
18637	8906	102	the	the	DT
18637	8906	103	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	8906	104	of	of	IN
18637	8906	105	the	the	DT
18637	8906	106	one	one	NN
18637	8906	107	and	and	CC
18637	8906	108	the	the	DT
18637	8906	109	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8906	110	of	of	IN
18637	8906	111	the	the	DT
18637	8906	112	other	other	JJ
18637	8906	113	.	.	.
18637	8907	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8907	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8907	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8907	4	While	while	IN
18637	8907	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8907	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	8907	7	not	not	RB
18637	8907	8	the	the	DT
18637	8907	9	province	province	NN
18637	8907	10	of	of	IN
18637	8907	11	the	the	DT
18637	8907	12	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8907	13	to	to	TO
18637	8907	14	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	8907	15	in	in	IN
18637	8907	16	any	any	DT
18637	8907	17	mere	mere	JJ
18637	8907	18	matter	matter	NN
18637	8907	19	of	of	IN
18637	8907	20	private	private	JJ
18637	8907	21	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	8907	22	between	between	IN
18637	8907	23	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	8907	24	,	,	,
18637	8907	25	or	or	CC
18637	8907	26	to	to	TO
18637	8907	27	use	use	VB
18637	8907	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8907	29	granted	grant	VBN
18637	8907	30	powers	power	NNS
18637	8907	31	to	to	TO
18637	8907	32	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	8907	33	the	the	DT
18637	8907	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	8907	35	of	of	IN
18637	8907	36	one	one	CD
18637	8907	37	against	against	IN
18637	8907	38	another	another	DT
18637	8907	39	,	,	,
18637	8907	40	yet	yet	RB
18637	8907	41	,	,	,
18637	8907	42	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	8907	43	the	the	DT
18637	8907	44	wrongs	wrong	NNS
18637	8907	45	complained	complain	VBD
18637	8907	46	of	of	IN
18637	8907	47	are	be	VBP
18637	8907	48	such	such	JJ
18637	8907	49	as	as	TO
18637	8907	50	affect	affect	VB
18637	8907	51	the	the	DT
18637	8907	52	public	public	NN
18637	8907	53	at	at	IN
18637	8907	54	large	large	JJ
18637	8907	55	,	,	,
18637	8907	56	and	and	CC
18637	8907	57	are	be	VBP
18637	8907	58	in	in	IN
18637	8907	59	respect	respect	NN
18637	8907	60	of	of	IN
18637	8907	61	matters	matter	NNS
18637	8907	62	which	which	WDT
18637	8907	63	by	by	IN
18637	8907	64	the	the	DT
18637	8907	65	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8907	66	are	be	VBP
18637	8907	67	entrusted	entrust	VBN
18637	8907	68	to	to	IN
18637	8907	69	the	the	DT
18637	8907	70	care	care	NN
18637	8907	71	of	of	IN
18637	8907	72	the	the	DT
18637	8907	73	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	8907	74	and	and	CC
18637	8907	75	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	8907	76	which	which	WDT
18637	8907	77	the	the	DT
18637	8907	78	Nation	nation	NN
18637	8907	79	owes	owe	VBZ
18637	8907	80	the	the	DT
18637	8907	81	duty	duty	NN
18637	8907	82	to	to	IN
18637	8907	83	all	all	PDT
18637	8907	84	the	the	DT
18637	8907	85	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8907	86	of	of	IN
18637	8907	87	securing	secure	VBG
18637	8907	88	to	to	IN
18637	8907	89	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8907	90	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8907	91	common	common	JJ
18637	8907	92	rights	right	NNS
18637	8907	93	,	,	,
18637	8907	94	then	then	RB
18637	8907	95	the	the	DT
18637	8907	96	mere	mere	JJ
18637	8907	97	fact	fact	NN
18637	8907	98	that	that	IN
18637	8907	99	the	the	DT
18637	8907	100	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8907	101	has	have	VBZ
18637	8907	102	no	no	DT
18637	8907	103	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
18637	8907	104	interest	interest	NN
18637	8907	105	in	in	IN
18637	8907	106	the	the	DT
18637	8907	107	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	8907	108	is	be	VBZ
18637	8907	109	not	not	RB
18637	8907	110	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	8907	111	to	to	TO
18637	8907	112	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	8907	113	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8907	114	from	from	IN
18637	8907	115	the	the	DT
18637	8907	116	courts	court	NNS
18637	8907	117	,	,	,
18637	8907	118	or	or	CC
18637	8907	119	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	8907	120	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8907	121	from	from	IN
18637	8907	122	taking	take	VBG
18637	8907	123	measures	measure	NNS
18637	8907	124	therein	therein	RB
18637	8907	125	to	to	TO
18637	8907	126	fully	fully	RB
18637	8907	127	discharge	discharge	VB
18637	8907	128	those	those	DT
18637	8907	129	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8907	130	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8907	131	.	.	.
18637	8908	1	"	"	``
18637	8908	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8908	3	409	409	CD
18637	8908	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8908	5	STATUS	STATUS	NNP
18637	8908	6	OF	of	IN
18637	8908	7	THE	the	DT
18637	8908	8	DEBS	DEBS	NNP
18637	8908	9	CASE	case	NN
18637	8908	10	TODAY	today	NN
18637	8908	11	The	the	DT
18637	8908	12	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	8908	13	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	8908	14	by	by	IN
18637	8908	15	the	the	DT
18637	8908	16	Norris	Norris	NNP
18637	8908	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	8908	18	LaGuardia	LaGuardia	NNP
18637	8908	19	Act[410	Act[410	NNP
18637	8908	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8908	21	on	on	IN
18637	8908	22	the	the	DT
18637	8908	23	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	8908	24	of	of	IN
18637	8908	25	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	8908	26	by	by	IN
18637	8908	27	the	the	DT
18637	8908	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	8908	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	8908	30	in	in	IN
18637	8908	31	cases	case	NNS
18637	8908	32	"	"	``
18637	8908	33	involving	involve	VBG
18637	8908	34	or	or	CC
18637	8908	35	growing	grow	VBG
18637	8908	36	out	out	IN
18637	8908	37	of	of	IN
18637	8908	38	any	any	DT
18637	8908	39	labor	labor	NN
18637	8908	40	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	8908	41	"	"	''
18637	8908	42	later	later	RB
18637	8908	43	cast	cast	VB
18637	8908	44	a	a	DT
18637	8908	45	shadow	shadow	NN
18637	8908	46	of	of	IN
18637	8908	47	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	8908	48	over	over	IN
18637	8908	49	the	the	DT
18637	8908	50	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	8908	51	case	case	NN
18637	8908	52	,	,	,
18637	8908	53	which	which	WDT
18637	8908	54	was	be	VBD
18637	8908	55	deepened	deepen	VBN
18637	8908	56	,	,	,
18637	8908	57	if	if	IN
18637	8908	58	anything	anything	NN
18637	8908	59	,	,	,
18637	8908	60	by	by	IN
18637	8908	61	the	the	DT
18637	8908	62	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8908	63	's	's	POS
18637	8908	64	decision	decision	NN
18637	8908	65	in	in	IN
18637	8908	66	1947	1947	CD
18637	8908	67	,	,	,
18637	8908	68	in	in	IN
18637	8908	69	United	United	NNP
18637	8908	70	States	States	NNP
18637	8908	71	_	_	NNP
18637	8908	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	8908	73	_	_	NNP
18637	8908	74	United	United	NNP
18637	8908	75	Mine	Mine	NNP
18637	8908	76	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	8908	77	.	.	.
18637	8909	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8909	2	411	411	CD
18637	8909	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8909	4	But	but	CC
18637	8909	5	such	such	JJ
18637	8909	6	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	8909	7	have	have	VBP
18637	8909	8	been	be	VBN
18637	8909	9	since	since	IN
18637	8909	10	dispelled	dispel	VBN
18637	8909	11	by	by	IN
18637	8909	12	the	the	DT
18637	8909	13	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	8909	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	8909	15	Hartley	Hartley	NNP
18637	8909	16	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8909	17	,	,	,
18637	8909	18	which	which	WDT
18637	8909	19	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	8909	20	that	that	IN
18637	8909	21	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	8909	22	in	in	IN
18637	8909	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8909	24	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8909	25	a	a	DT
18637	8909	26	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	8909	27	or	or	CC
18637	8909	28	actual	actual	JJ
18637	8909	29	strike	strike	NN
18637	8909	30	or	or	CC
18637	8909	31	lockout	lockout	IN
18637	8909	32	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	8909	33	the	the	DT
18637	8909	34	whole	whole	NN
18637	8909	35	or	or	CC
18637	8909	36	a	a	DT
18637	8909	37	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	8909	38	part	part	NN
18637	8909	39	of	of	IN
18637	8909	40	an	an	DT
18637	8909	41	industry	industry	NN
18637	8909	42	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	8909	43	in	in	IN
18637	8909	44	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	8909	45	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	8909	46	will	will	MD
18637	8909	47	,	,	,
18637	8909	48	"	"	``
18637	8909	49	if	if	IN
18637	8909	50	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	8909	51	to	to	TO
18637	8909	52	occur	occur	VB
18637	8909	53	or	or	CC
18637	8909	54	continue	continue	VB
18637	8909	55	,	,	,
18637	8909	56	imperil	imperil	VB
18637	8909	57	the	the	DT
18637	8909	58	national	national	JJ
18637	8909	59	health	health	NN
18637	8909	60	or	or	CC
18637	8909	61	safety	safety	NN
18637	8909	62	,	,	,
18637	8909	63	"	"	''
18637	8909	64	the	the	DT
18637	8909	65	President	President	NNP
18637	8909	66	may	may	MD
18637	8909	67	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	8909	68	a	a	DT
18637	8909	69	board	board	NN
18637	8909	70	of	of	IN
18637	8909	71	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	8909	72	and	and	CC
18637	8909	73	,	,	,
18637	8909	74	upon	upon	IN
18637	8909	75	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8909	76	so	so	RB
18637	8909	77	finding	finding	NN
18637	8909	78	,	,	,
18637	8909	79	"	"	``
18637	8909	80	may	may	MD
18637	8909	81	direct	direct	VB
18637	8909	82	the	the	DT
18637	8909	83	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8909	84	General	General	NNP
18637	8909	85	to	to	TO
18637	8909	86	petition	petition	VB
18637	8909	87	any	any	DT
18637	8909	88	district	district	NN
18637	8909	89	court	court	NN
18637	8909	90	of	of	IN
18637	8909	91	the	the	DT
18637	8909	92	United	United	NNP
18637	8909	93	States	States	NNP
18637	8909	94	having	have	VBG
18637	8909	95	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	8909	96	of	of	IN
18637	8909	97	the	the	DT
18637	8909	98	parties	party	NNS
18637	8909	99	to	to	TO
18637	8909	100	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	8909	101	such	such	JJ
18637	8909	102	strike	strike	NN
18637	8909	103	or	or	CC
18637	8909	104	lockout	lockout	NN
18637	8909	105	or	or	CC
18637	8909	106	the	the	DT
18637	8909	107	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	8909	108	thereof	thereof	IN
18637	8909	109	*	*	NFP
18637	8909	110	*	*	NFP
18637	8909	111	*	*	NFP
18637	8909	112	,	,	,
18637	8909	113	"	"	''
18637	8909	114	and	and	CC
18637	8909	115	the	the	DT
18637	8909	116	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8909	117	shall	shall	MD
18637	8909	118	have	have	VB
18637	8909	119	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	8909	120	to	to	TO
18637	8909	121	do	do	VB
18637	8909	122	so	so	RB
18637	8909	123	,	,	,
18637	8909	124	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8909	125	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8909	126	shares	share	VBZ
18637	8909	127	the	the	DT
18637	8909	128	President	President	NNP
18637	8909	129	's	's	POS
18637	8909	130	view	view	NN
18637	8909	131	of	of	IN
18637	8909	132	the	the	DT
18637	8909	133	situation	situation	NN
18637	8909	134	.	.	.
18637	8910	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8910	2	412	412	CD
18637	8910	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8910	4	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	8910	5	and	and	CC
18637	8910	6	labor	labor	NN
18637	8910	7	critics	critic	NNS
18637	8910	8	of	of	IN
18637	8910	9	the	the	DT
18637	8910	10	act	act	NN
18637	8910	11	did	do	VBD
18637	8910	12	not	not	RB
18637	8910	13	challenge	challenge	VB
18637	8910	14	the	the	DT
18637	8910	15	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	8910	16	of	of	IN
18637	8910	17	this	this	DT
18637	8910	18	provision	provision	NN
18637	8910	19	.	.	.
18637	8911	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8911	2	questioned	question	VBD
18637	8911	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8911	4	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	8911	5	in	in	IN
18637	8911	6	view	view	NN
18637	8911	7	of	of	IN
18637	8911	8	the	the	DT
18637	8911	9	President	President	NNP
18637	8911	10	's	's	POS
18637	8911	11	"	"	``
18637	8911	12	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	8911	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	8911	14	"	"	''
18637	8911	15	in	in	IN
18637	8911	16	the	the	DT
18637	8911	17	face	face	NN
18637	8911	18	of	of	IN
18637	8911	19	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	8911	20	.	.	.
18637	8912	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8912	2	413	413	CD
18637	8912	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8912	4	THE	the	DT
18637	8912	5	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	8912	6	'S	's	POS
18637	8912	7	DUTY	DUTY	NNS
18637	8912	8	IN	in	IN
18637	8912	9	CASES	case	NNS
18637	8912	10	OF	of	IN
18637	8912	11	DOMESTIC	domestic	JJ
18637	8912	12	VIOLENCE	violence	NN
18637	8912	13	IN	in	IN
18637	8912	14	THE	the	DT
18637	8912	15	STATES	state	NNS
18637	8912	16	_	_	NNP
18637	8912	17	See	See	NNP
18637	8912	18	_	_	NNP
18637	8912	19	Art	Art	NNP
18637	8912	20	.	.	.
18637	8913	1	IV	IV	NNP
18637	8913	2	,	,	,
18637	8913	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	8913	4	.	.	.
18637	8914	1	4	4	CD
18637	8914	2	,	,	,
18637	8914	3	p.	p.	NN
18637	8914	4	705	705	CD
18637	8914	5	.	.	.
18637	8915	1	THE	the	DT
18637	8915	2	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	8915	3	AS	as	IN
18637	8915	4	EXECUTIVE	executive	NN
18637	8915	5	OF	of	IN
18637	8915	6	THE	the	DT
18637	8915	7	LAW	LAW	NNP
18637	8915	8	OF	of	IN
18637	8915	9	NATIONS	NATIONS	NNP
18637	8915	10	Illustrative	Illustrative	NNP
18637	8915	11	of	of	IN
18637	8915	12	the	the	DT
18637	8915	13	President	President	NNP
18637	8915	14	's	's	POS
18637	8915	15	duty	duty	NN
18637	8915	16	to	to	TO
18637	8915	17	discharge	discharge	VB
18637	8915	18	the	the	DT
18637	8915	19	responsibilities	responsibility	NNS
18637	8915	20	of	of	IN
18637	8915	21	the	the	DT
18637	8915	22	United	United	NNP
18637	8915	23	States	States	NNP
18637	8915	24	at	at	IN
18637	8915	25	International	International	NNP
18637	8915	26	Law	Law	NNP
18637	8915	27	with	with	IN
18637	8915	28	a	a	DT
18637	8915	29	view	view	NN
18637	8915	30	to	to	IN
18637	8915	31	avoiding	avoid	VBG
18637	8915	32	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	8915	33	with	with	IN
18637	8915	34	other	other	JJ
18637	8915	35	governments	government	NNS
18637	8915	36	,	,	,
18637	8915	37	was	be	VBD
18637	8915	38	the	the	DT
18637	8915	39	action	action	NN
18637	8915	40	of	of	IN
18637	8915	41	President	President	NNP
18637	8915	42	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	8915	43	in	in	IN
18637	8915	44	closing	close	VBG
18637	8915	45	the	the	DT
18637	8915	46	Marconi	Marconi	NNP
18637	8915	47	Wireless	Wireless	NNP
18637	8915	48	Station	Station	NNP
18637	8915	49	at	at	IN
18637	8915	50	Siasconset	Siasconset	NNP
18637	8915	51	,	,	,
18637	8915	52	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	8915	53	on	on	IN
18637	8915	54	the	the	DT
18637	8915	55	outbreak	outbreak	NN
18637	8915	56	of	of	IN
18637	8915	57	the	the	DT
18637	8915	58	European	European	NNP
18637	8915	59	War	War	NNP
18637	8915	60	in	in	IN
18637	8915	61	1914	1914	CD
18637	8915	62	,	,	,
18637	8915	63	the	the	DT
18637	8915	64	company	company	NN
18637	8915	65	having	have	VBG
18637	8915	66	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	8915	67	assurance	assurance	NN
18637	8915	68	that	that	IN
18637	8915	69	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8915	70	would	would	MD
18637	8915	71	comply	comply	VB
18637	8915	72	with	with	IN
18637	8915	73	naval	naval	JJ
18637	8915	74	censorship	censorship	NN
18637	8915	75	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	8915	76	.	.	.
18637	8916	1	Justifying	justify	VBG
18637	8916	2	this	this	DT
18637	8916	3	drastic	drastic	JJ
18637	8916	4	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	8916	5	of	of	IN
18637	8916	6	private	private	JJ
18637	8916	7	rights	right	NNS
18637	8916	8	,	,	,
18637	8916	9	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8916	10	General	General	NNP
18637	8916	11	Gregory	Gregory	NNP
18637	8916	12	said	say	VBD
18637	8916	13	:	:	:
18637	8916	14	"	"	``
18637	8916	15	The	the	DT
18637	8916	16	President	President	NNP
18637	8916	17	of	of	IN
18637	8916	18	the	the	DT
18637	8916	19	United	United	NNP
18637	8916	20	States	States	NNP
18637	8916	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	8916	22	at	at	IN
18637	8916	23	the	the	DT
18637	8916	24	head	head	NN
18637	8916	25	of	of	IN
18637	8916	26	one	one	CD
18637	8916	27	of	of	IN
18637	8916	28	the	the	DT
18637	8916	29	three	three	CD
18637	8916	30	great	great	JJ
18637	8916	31	coordinate	coordinate	JJ
18637	8916	32	departments	department	NNS
18637	8916	33	of	of	IN
18637	8916	34	the	the	DT
18637	8916	35	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8916	36	.	.	.
18637	8917	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8917	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8917	3	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8917	4	in	in	IN
18637	8917	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8917	6	of	of	IN
18637	8917	7	the	the	DT
18637	8917	8	Army	Army	NNP
18637	8917	9	and	and	CC
18637	8917	10	the	the	DT
18637	8917	11	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	8917	12	.	.	.
18637	8918	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8918	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8918	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8918	4	If	if	IN
18637	8918	5	the	the	DT
18637	8918	6	President	President	NNP
18637	8918	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	8918	8	of	of	IN
18637	8918	9	the	the	DT
18637	8918	10	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8918	11	that	that	IN
18637	8918	12	the	the	DT
18637	8918	13	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8918	14	of	of	IN
18637	8918	15	this	this	DT
18637	8918	16	country	country	NN
18637	8918	17	with	with	IN
18637	8918	18	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8918	19	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8918	20	are	be	VBP
18637	8918	21	,	,	,
18637	8918	22	or	or	CC
18637	8918	23	are	be	VBP
18637	8918	24	likely	likely	JJ
18637	8918	25	to	to	TO
18637	8918	26	be	be	VB
18637	8918	27	,	,	,
18637	8918	28	endangered	endanger	VBN
18637	8918	29	by	by	IN
18637	8918	30	action	action	NN
18637	8918	31	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	8918	32	by	by	IN
18637	8918	33	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8918	34	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	8918	35	with	with	IN
18637	8918	36	a	a	DT
18637	8918	37	due	due	JJ
18637	8918	38	neutrality	neutrality	NN
18637	8918	39	,	,	,
18637	8918	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8918	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	8918	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8918	43	right	right	NN
18637	8918	44	and	and	CC
18637	8918	45	duty	duty	NN
18637	8918	46	to	to	TO
18637	8918	47	protect	protect	VB
18637	8918	48	such	such	JJ
18637	8918	49	relations	relation	NNS
18637	8918	50	;	;	:
18637	8918	51	and	and	CC
18637	8918	52	in	in	IN
18637	8918	53	doing	do	VBG
18637	8918	54	so	so	RB
18637	8918	55	,	,	,
18637	8918	56	in	in	IN
18637	8918	57	the	the	DT
18637	8918	58	absence	absence	NN
18637	8918	59	of	of	IN
18637	8918	60	any	any	DT
18637	8918	61	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	8918	62	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	8918	63	,	,	,
18637	8918	64	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8918	65	may	may	MD
18637	8918	66	act	act	VB
18637	8918	67	through	through	IN
18637	8918	68	such	such	JJ
18637	8918	69	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8918	70	office	office	NN
18637	8918	71	or	or	CC
18637	8918	72	department	department	NN
18637	8918	73	as	as	IN
18637	8918	74	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	8918	75	best	well	RBS
18637	8918	76	adapted	adapt	VBN
18637	8918	77	to	to	TO
18637	8918	78	effectuate	effectuate	VB
18637	8918	79	the	the	DT
18637	8918	80	desired	desire	VBN
18637	8918	81	end	end	NN
18637	8918	82	.	.	.
18637	8919	1	*	*	NFP
18637	8919	2	*	*	NFP
18637	8919	3	*	*	NFP
18637	8919	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8919	5	do	do	VBP
18637	8919	6	not	not	RB
18637	8919	7	hesitate	hesitate	VB
18637	8919	8	,	,	,
18637	8919	9	in	in	IN
18637	8919	10	view	view	NN
18637	8919	11	of	of	IN
18637	8919	12	the	the	DT
18637	8919	13	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	8919	14	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	8919	15	existing	exist	VBG
18637	8919	16	,	,	,
18637	8919	17	to	to	TO
18637	8919	18	advise	advise	VB
18637	8919	19	that	that	IN
18637	8919	20	the	the	DT
18637	8919	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8919	22	,	,	,
18637	8919	23	through	through	IN
18637	8919	24	the	the	DT
18637	8919	25	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8919	26	of	of	IN
18637	8919	27	the	the	DT
18637	8919	28	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	8919	29	or	or	CC
18637	8919	30	any	any	DT
18637	8919	31	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	8919	32	department	department	NN
18637	8919	33	,	,	,
18637	8919	34	close	close	VB
18637	8919	35	down	down	RP
18637	8919	36	,	,	,
18637	8919	37	or	or	CC
18637	8919	38	take	take	VB
18637	8919	39	charge	charge	NN
18637	8919	40	of	of	IN
18637	8919	41	and	and	CC
18637	8919	42	operate	operate	VB
18637	8919	43	,	,	,
18637	8919	44	the	the	DT
18637	8919	45	plant	plant	NN
18637	8919	46	*	*	NFP
18637	8919	47	*	*	NFP
18637	8919	48	*	*	NFP
18637	8919	49	,	,	,
18637	8919	50	should	should	MD
18637	8919	51	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8919	52	deem	deem	VB
18637	8919	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8919	54	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8919	55	in	in	IN
18637	8919	56	securing	secure	VBG
18637	8919	57	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	8919	58	to	to	IN
18637	8919	59	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8919	60	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	8919	61	of	of	IN
18637	8919	62	neutrality	neutrality	NN
18637	8919	63	.	.	.
18637	8920	1	"	"	``
18637	8920	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8920	3	414	414	CD
18637	8920	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8920	5	PROTECTION	PROTECTION	NNP
18637	8920	6	OF	of	IN
18637	8920	7	AMERICAN	AMERICAN	NNP
18637	8920	8	RIGHTS	right	NNS
18637	8920	9	OF	of	IN
18637	8920	10	PERSON	person	NN
18637	8920	11	AND	and	CC
18637	8920	12	PROPERTY	property	NN
18637	8920	13	ABROAD	abroad	RB
18637	8920	14	The	the	DT
18637	8920	15	right	right	NN
18637	8920	16	of	of	IN
18637	8920	17	the	the	DT
18637	8920	18	President	President	NNP
18637	8920	19	to	to	TO
18637	8920	20	use	use	VB
18637	8920	21	force	force	NN
18637	8920	22	in	in	IN
18637	8920	23	vindication	vindication	NN
18637	8920	24	of	of	IN
18637	8920	25	American	american	JJ
18637	8920	26	rights	right	NNS
18637	8920	27	of	of	IN
18637	8920	28	person	person	NN
18637	8920	29	and	and	CC
18637	8920	30	property	property	NN
18637	8920	31	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	8920	32	was	be	VBD
18637	8920	33	demonstrated	demonstrate	VBN
18637	8920	34	in	in	IN
18637	8920	35	1854	1854	CD
18637	8920	36	by	by	IN
18637	8920	37	the	the	DT
18637	8920	38	bombardment	bombardment	NN
18637	8920	39	of	of	IN
18637	8920	40	Greytown	Greytown	NNP
18637	8920	41	,	,	,
18637	8920	42	Nicaragua	Nicaragua	NNP
18637	8920	43	by	by	IN
18637	8920	44	Lieutenant	Lieutenant	NNP
18637	8920	45	Hollins	Hollins	NNP
18637	8920	46	of	of	IN
18637	8920	47	the	the	DT
18637	8920	48	U.S.S.	U.S.S.	NNP
18637	8921	1	Cyane	Cyane	NNP
18637	8921	2	,	,	,
18637	8921	3	in	in	IN
18637	8921	4	default	default	NN
18637	8921	5	of	of	IN
18637	8921	6	reparation	reparation	NN
18637	8921	7	from	from	IN
18637	8921	8	the	the	DT
18637	8921	9	local	local	JJ
18637	8921	10	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	8921	11	for	for	IN
18637	8921	12	an	an	DT
18637	8921	13	attack	attack	NN
18637	8921	14	by	by	IN
18637	8921	15	a	a	DT
18637	8921	16	mob	mob	NN
18637	8921	17	on	on	IN
18637	8921	18	the	the	DT
18637	8921	19	United	United	NNP
18637	8921	20	States	States	NNP
18637	8921	21	consul	consul	NN
18637	8921	22	at	at	IN
18637	8921	23	that	that	DT
18637	8921	24	place	place	NN
18637	8921	25	.	.	.
18637	8922	1	Upon	upon	IN
18637	8922	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8922	3	return	return	NN
18637	8922	4	to	to	IN
18637	8922	5	the	the	DT
18637	8922	6	United	United	NNP
18637	8922	7	States	States	NNP
18637	8922	8	Hollins	Hollins	NNP
18637	8922	9	was	be	VBD
18637	8922	10	sued	sue	VBN
18637	8922	11	in	in	IN
18637	8922	12	a	a	DT
18637	8922	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	8922	14	court	court	NN
18637	8922	15	by	by	IN
18637	8922	16	one	one	CD
18637	8922	17	Durand	Durand	NNP
18637	8922	18	for	for	IN
18637	8922	19	the	the	DT
18637	8922	20	value	value	NN
18637	8922	21	of	of	IN
18637	8922	22	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8922	23	property	property	NN
18637	8922	24	which	which	WDT
18637	8922	25	was	be	VBD
18637	8922	26	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	8922	27	to	to	TO
18637	8922	28	have	have	VB
18637	8922	29	been	be	VBN
18637	8922	30	destroyed	destroy	VBN
18637	8922	31	in	in	IN
18637	8922	32	the	the	DT
18637	8922	33	bombardment	bombardment	NN
18637	8922	34	.	.	.
18637	8923	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8923	2	defense	defense	NN
18637	8923	3	was	be	VBD
18637	8923	4	based	base	VBN
18637	8923	5	upon	upon	IN
18637	8923	6	the	the	DT
18637	8923	7	orders	order	NNS
18637	8923	8	of	of	IN
18637	8923	9	the	the	DT
18637	8923	10	President	President	NNP
18637	8923	11	and	and	CC
18637	8923	12	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8923	13	of	of	IN
18637	8923	14	the	the	DT
18637	8923	15	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	8923	16	,	,	,
18637	8923	17	and	and	CC
18637	8923	18	was	be	VBD
18637	8923	19	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	8923	20	by	by	IN
18637	8923	21	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8923	22	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	8923	23	,	,	,
18637	8923	24	then	then	RB
18637	8923	25	on	on	IN
18637	8923	26	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	8923	27	,	,	,
18637	8923	28	in	in	IN
18637	8923	29	the	the	DT
18637	8923	30	following	follow	VBG
18637	8923	31	words	word	NNS
18637	8923	32	:	:	:
18637	8923	33	"	"	``
18637	8923	34	As	as	IN
18637	8923	35	the	the	DT
18637	8923	36	Executive	executive	JJ
18637	8923	37	head	head	NN
18637	8923	38	of	of	IN
18637	8923	39	the	the	DT
18637	8923	40	nation	nation	NN
18637	8923	41	,	,	,
18637	8923	42	the	the	DT
18637	8923	43	President	President	NNP
18637	8923	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	8923	45	made	make	VBN
18637	8923	46	the	the	DT
18637	8923	47	only	only	JJ
18637	8923	48	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	8923	49	organ	organ	NN
18637	8923	50	of	of	IN
18637	8923	51	the	the	DT
18637	8923	52	General	General	NNP
18637	8923	53	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8923	54	,	,	,
18637	8923	55	to	to	TO
18637	8923	56	open	open	VB
18637	8923	57	and	and	CC
18637	8923	58	carry	carry	VB
18637	8923	59	on	on	RP
18637	8923	60	correspondence	correspondence	NN
18637	8923	61	or	or	CC
18637	8923	62	negotiations	negotiation	NNS
18637	8923	63	with	with	IN
18637	8923	64	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8923	65	nations	nation	NNS
18637	8923	66	,	,	,
18637	8923	67	in	in	IN
18637	8923	68	matters	matter	NNS
18637	8923	69	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	8923	70	the	the	DT
18637	8923	71	interests	interest	NNS
18637	8923	72	of	of	IN
18637	8923	73	the	the	DT
18637	8923	74	country	country	NN
18637	8923	75	or	or	CC
18637	8923	76	of	of	IN
18637	8923	77	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8923	78	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8923	79	.	.	.
18637	8924	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8924	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8924	3	to	to	IN
18637	8924	4	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8924	5	,	,	,
18637	8924	6	also	also	RB
18637	8924	7	,	,	,
18637	8924	8	the	the	DT
18637	8924	9	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	8924	10	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	8924	11	must	must	MD
18637	8924	12	look	look	VB
18637	8924	13	for	for	IN
18637	8924	14	protection	protection	NN
18637	8924	15	of	of	IN
18637	8924	16	person	person	NN
18637	8924	17	and	and	CC
18637	8924	18	of	of	IN
18637	8924	19	property	property	NN
18637	8924	20	,	,	,
18637	8924	21	and	and	CC
18637	8924	22	for	for	IN
18637	8924	23	the	the	DT
18637	8924	24	faithful	faithful	JJ
18637	8924	25	execution	execution	NN
18637	8924	26	of	of	IN
18637	8924	27	the	the	DT
18637	8924	28	laws	law	NNS
18637	8924	29	existing	exist	VBG
18637	8924	30	and	and	CC
18637	8924	31	intended	intend	VBD
18637	8924	32	for	for	IN
18637	8924	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8924	34	protection	protection	NN
18637	8924	35	.	.	.
18637	8925	1	For	for	IN
18637	8925	2	this	this	DT
18637	8925	3	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8925	4	,	,	,
18637	8925	5	the	the	DT
18637	8925	6	whole	whole	JJ
18637	8925	7	Executive	executive	JJ
18637	8925	8	power	power	NN
18637	8925	9	of	of	IN
18637	8925	10	the	the	DT
18637	8925	11	country	country	NN
18637	8925	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	8925	13	placed	place	VBN
18637	8925	14	in	in	IN
18637	8925	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8925	16	hands	hand	NNS
18637	8925	17	,	,	,
18637	8925	18	under	under	IN
18637	8925	19	the	the	DT
18637	8925	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8925	21	,	,	,
18637	8925	22	and	and	CC
18637	8925	23	the	the	DT
18637	8925	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	8925	25	passed	pass	VBN
18637	8925	26	in	in	IN
18637	8925	27	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	8925	28	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8925	29	;	;	:
18637	8925	30	and	and	CC
18637	8925	31	different	different	JJ
18637	8925	32	Departments	department	NNS
18637	8925	33	of	of	IN
18637	8925	34	government	government	NN
18637	8925	35	have	have	VBP
18637	8925	36	been	be	VBN
18637	8925	37	organized	organize	VBN
18637	8925	38	,	,	,
18637	8925	39	through	through	IN
18637	8925	40	which	which	WDT
18637	8925	41	this	this	DT
18637	8925	42	power	power	NN
18637	8925	43	may	may	MD
18637	8925	44	be	be	VB
18637	8925	45	most	most	RBS
18637	8925	46	conveniently	conveniently	RB
18637	8925	47	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8925	48	,	,	,
18637	8925	49	whether	whether	IN
18637	8925	50	by	by	IN
18637	8925	51	negotiation	negotiation	NN
18637	8925	52	or	or	CC
18637	8925	53	by	by	IN
18637	8925	54	force	force	NN
18637	8925	55	--	--	:
18637	8925	56	a	a	DT
18637	8925	57	Department	Department	NNP
18637	8925	58	of	of	IN
18637	8925	59	State	State	NNP
18637	8925	60	and	and	CC
18637	8925	61	a	a	DT
18637	8925	62	Department	Department	NNP
18637	8925	63	of	of	IN
18637	8925	64	the	the	DT
18637	8925	65	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	8925	66	.	.	.
18637	8926	1	"	"	``
18637	8926	2	Now	now	RB
18637	8926	3	,	,	,
18637	8926	4	as	as	IN
18637	8926	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8926	6	respects	respect	VBZ
18637	8926	7	the	the	DT
18637	8926	8	interposition	interposition	NN
18637	8926	9	of	of	IN
18637	8926	10	the	the	DT
18637	8926	11	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8926	12	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	8926	13	,	,	,
18637	8926	14	for	for	IN
18637	8926	15	the	the	DT
18637	8926	16	protection	protection	NN
18637	8926	17	of	of	IN
18637	8926	18	the	the	DT
18637	8926	19	lives	life	NNS
18637	8926	20	or	or	CC
18637	8926	21	property	property	NN
18637	8926	22	of	of	IN
18637	8926	23	the	the	DT
18637	8926	24	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	8926	25	,	,	,
18637	8926	26	the	the	DT
18637	8926	27	duty	duty	NN
18637	8926	28	must	must	MD
18637	8926	29	,	,	,
18637	8926	30	of	of	IN
18637	8926	31	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	8926	32	,	,	,
18637	8926	33	rest	rest	VB
18637	8926	34	in	in	IN
18637	8926	35	the	the	DT
18637	8926	36	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	8926	37	of	of	IN
18637	8926	38	the	the	DT
18637	8926	39	President	President	NNP
18637	8926	40	.	.	.
18637	8927	1	Acts	act	NNS
18637	8927	2	of	of	IN
18637	8927	3	lawless	lawless	JJ
18637	8927	4	violence	violence	NN
18637	8927	5	,	,	,
18637	8927	6	or	or	CC
18637	8927	7	of	of	IN
18637	8927	8	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	8927	9	violence	violence	NN
18637	8927	10	to	to	IN
18637	8927	11	the	the	DT
18637	8927	12	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	8927	13	or	or	CC
18637	8927	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8927	15	property	property	NN
18637	8927	16	,	,	,
18637	8927	17	can	can	MD
18637	8927	18	not	not	RB
18637	8927	19	be	be	VB
18637	8927	20	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
18637	8927	21	and	and	CC
18637	8927	22	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8927	23	for	for	IN
18637	8927	24	;	;	:
18637	8927	25	and	and	CC
18637	8927	26	the	the	DT
18637	8927	27	protection	protection	NN
18637	8927	28	,	,	,
18637	8927	29	to	to	TO
18637	8927	30	be	be	VB
18637	8927	31	effectual	effectual	JJ
18637	8927	32	or	or	CC
18637	8927	33	of	of	IN
18637	8927	34	any	any	DT
18637	8927	35	avail	avail	NN
18637	8927	36	,	,	,
18637	8927	37	may	may	MD
18637	8927	38	,	,	,
18637	8927	39	not	not	RB
18637	8927	40	unfrequently	unfrequently	RB
18637	8927	41	,	,	,
18637	8927	42	require	require	VB
18637	8927	43	the	the	DT
18637	8927	44	most	most	RBS
18637	8927	45	prompt	prompt	JJ
18637	8927	46	and	and	CC
18637	8927	47	decided	decide	VBD
18637	8927	48	action	action	NN
18637	8927	49	.	.	.
18637	8928	1	Under	under	IN
18637	8928	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8928	3	system	system	NN
18637	8928	4	of	of	IN
18637	8928	5	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8928	6	,	,	,
18637	8928	7	the	the	DT
18637	8928	8	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	8928	9	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	8928	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	8928	11	as	as	RB
18637	8928	12	much	much	JJ
18637	8928	13	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	8928	14	to	to	IN
18637	8928	15	protection	protection	NN
18637	8928	16	as	as	IN
18637	8928	17	the	the	DT
18637	8928	18	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	8928	19	at	at	IN
18637	8928	20	home	home	NN
18637	8928	21	.	.	.
18637	8929	1	The	the	DT
18637	8929	2	great	great	JJ
18637	8929	3	object	object	NN
18637	8929	4	and	and	CC
18637	8929	5	duty	duty	NN
18637	8929	6	of	of	IN
18637	8929	7	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8929	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	8929	9	the	the	DT
18637	8929	10	protection	protection	NN
18637	8929	11	of	of	IN
18637	8929	12	the	the	DT
18637	8929	13	lives	life	NNS
18637	8929	14	,	,	,
18637	8929	15	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	8929	16	,	,	,
18637	8929	17	and	and	CC
18637	8929	18	property	property	NN
18637	8929	19	of	of	IN
18637	8929	20	the	the	DT
18637	8929	21	people	people	NNS
18637	8929	22	composing	compose	VBG
18637	8929	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8929	24	,	,	,
18637	8929	25	whether	whether	IN
18637	8929	26	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	8929	27	or	or	CC
18637	8929	28	at	at	IN
18637	8929	29	home	home	NN
18637	8929	30	;	;	:
18637	8929	31	and	and	CC
18637	8929	32	any	any	DT
18637	8929	33	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8929	34	failing	fail	VBG
18637	8929	35	in	in	IN
18637	8929	36	the	the	DT
18637	8929	37	accomplishment	accomplishment	NN
18637	8929	38	of	of	IN
18637	8929	39	the	the	DT
18637	8929	40	object	object	NN
18637	8929	41	,	,	,
18637	8929	42	or	or	CC
18637	8929	43	the	the	DT
18637	8929	44	performance	performance	NN
18637	8929	45	of	of	IN
18637	8929	46	the	the	DT
18637	8929	47	duty	duty	NN
18637	8929	48	,	,	,
18637	8929	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	8929	50	not	not	RB
18637	8929	51	worth	worth	JJ
18637	8929	52	preserving	preserve	VBG
18637	8929	53	.	.	.
18637	8930	1	"	"	``
18637	8930	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8930	3	415	415	CD
18637	8930	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8930	5	PRESIDENTIAL	presidential	JJ
18637	8930	6	WORLD	world	NN
18637	8930	7	POLICING	policing	NN
18637	8930	8	In	in	IN
18637	8930	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8930	10	little	little	JJ
18637	8930	11	volume	volume	NN
18637	8930	12	on	on	IN
18637	8930	13	World	World	NNP
18637	8930	14	Policing	Policing	NNP
18637	8930	15	and	and	CC
18637	8930	16	the	the	DT
18637	8930	17	Constitution[416	Constitution[416	NNP
18637	8930	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8930	19	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	8930	20	James	James	NNP
18637	8930	21	Grafton	Grafton	NNP
18637	8930	22	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	8930	23	lists	list	VBZ
18637	8930	24	149	149	CD
18637	8930	25	episodes	episode	NNS
18637	8930	26	similar	similar	JJ
18637	8930	27	to	to	IN
18637	8930	28	the	the	DT
18637	8930	29	Greytown	Greytown	NNP
18637	8930	30	affair	affair	NN
18637	8930	31	,	,	,
18637	8930	32	stretching	stretch	VBG
18637	8930	33	between	between	IN
18637	8930	34	the	the	DT
18637	8930	35	undeclared	undeclared	JJ
18637	8930	36	war	war	NN
18637	8930	37	with	with	IN
18637	8930	38	France	France	NNP
18637	8930	39	in	in	IN
18637	8930	40	1798	1798	CD
18637	8930	41	and	and	CC
18637	8930	42	Pearl	Pearl	NNP
18637	8930	43	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	8930	44	.	.	.
18637	8931	1	While	while	IN
18637	8931	2	inviting	invite	VBG
18637	8931	3	some	some	DT
18637	8931	4	pruning	pruning	NN
18637	8931	5	,	,	,
18637	8931	6	the	the	DT
18637	8931	7	list	list	NN
18637	8931	8	demonstrates	demonstrate	VBZ
18637	8931	9	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	8931	10	peradventure	peradventure	NN
18637	8931	11	the	the	DT
18637	8931	12	existence	existence	NN
18637	8931	13	in	in	IN
18637	8931	14	the	the	DT
18637	8931	15	President	President	NNP
18637	8931	16	,	,	,
18637	8931	17	as	as	IN
18637	8931	18	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8931	19	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8931	20	and	and	CC
18637	8931	21	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8931	22	in	in	IN
18637	8931	23	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8931	24	,	,	,
18637	8931	25	of	of	IN
18637	8931	26	power	power	NN
18637	8931	27	to	to	TO
18637	8931	28	judge	judge	VB
18637	8931	29	whether	whether	IN
18637	8931	30	a	a	DT
18637	8931	31	situation	situation	NN
18637	8931	32	requires	require	VBZ
18637	8931	33	the	the	DT
18637	8931	34	use	use	NN
18637	8931	35	of	of	IN
18637	8931	36	available	available	JJ
18637	8931	37	forces	force	NNS
18637	8931	38	to	to	TO
18637	8931	39	protect	protect	VB
18637	8931	40	American	american	JJ
18637	8931	41	rights	right	NNS
18637	8931	42	of	of	IN
18637	8931	43	person	person	NN
18637	8931	44	and	and	CC
18637	8931	45	property	property	NN
18637	8931	46	outside	outside	IN
18637	8931	47	the	the	DT
18637	8931	48	United	United	NNP
18637	8931	49	States	States	NNP
18637	8931	50	and	and	CC
18637	8931	51	to	to	TO
18637	8931	52	take	take	VB
18637	8931	53	action	action	NN
18637	8931	54	in	in	IN
18637	8931	55	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	8931	56	with	with	IN
18637	8931	57	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8931	58	decision	decision	NN
18637	8931	59	.	.	.
18637	8932	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	8932	2	employment	employment	NN
18637	8932	3	of	of	IN
18637	8932	4	the	the	DT
18637	8932	5	forces	force	NNS
18637	8932	6	have	have	VBP
18637	8932	7	,	,	,
18637	8932	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8932	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	8932	10	true	true	JJ
18637	8932	11	,	,	,
18637	8932	12	been	be	VBN
18637	8932	13	usually	usually	RB
18637	8932	14	justifiable	justifiable	JJ
18637	8932	15	acts	act	NNS
18637	8932	16	of	of	IN
18637	8932	17	self	self	NN
18637	8932	18	defense	defense	NN
18637	8932	19	rather	rather	RB
18637	8932	20	than	than	IN
18637	8932	21	acts	act	NNS
18637	8932	22	of	of	IN
18637	8932	23	war	war	NN
18637	8932	24	,	,	,
18637	8932	25	but	but	CC
18637	8932	26	the	the	DT
18637	8932	27	countries	country	NNS
18637	8932	28	where	where	WRB
18637	8932	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8932	30	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	8932	31	were	be	VBD
18637	8932	32	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	8932	33	to	to	TO
18637	8932	34	treat	treat	VB
18637	8932	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8932	36	as	as	IN
18637	8932	37	acts	act	NNS
18637	8932	38	of	of	IN
18637	8932	39	war	war	NN
18637	8932	40	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	8932	41	,	,	,
18637	8932	42	although	although	IN
18637	8932	43	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8932	44	have	have	VBP
18637	8932	45	generally	generally	RB
18637	8932	46	been	be	VBN
18637	8932	47	too	too	RB
18637	8932	48	feeble	feeble	JJ
18637	8932	49	to	to	TO
18637	8932	50	assert	assert	VB
18637	8932	51	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8932	52	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	8932	53	in	in	IN
18637	8932	54	this	this	DT
18637	8932	55	respect	respect	NN
18637	8932	56	,	,	,
18637	8932	57	and	and	CC
18637	8932	58	have	have	VBP
18637	8932	59	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	8932	60	actually	actually	RB
18637	8932	61	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	8932	62	to	to	TO
18637	8932	63	turn	turn	VB
18637	8932	64	the	the	DT
18637	8932	65	other	other	JJ
18637	8932	66	cheek	cheek	NN
18637	8932	67	.	.	.
18637	8933	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	8933	2	when	when	WRB
18637	8933	3	in	in	IN
18637	8933	4	1900	1900	CD
18637	8933	5	President	President	NNP
18637	8933	6	McKinley	McKinley	NNP
18637	8933	7	,	,	,
18637	8933	8	without	without	IN
18637	8933	9	consulting	consult	VBG
18637	8933	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8933	11	,	,	,
18637	8933	12	contributed	contribute	VBD
18637	8933	13	a	a	DT
18637	8933	14	sizable	sizable	JJ
18637	8933	15	contingent	contingent	NN
18637	8933	16	to	to	IN
18637	8933	17	the	the	DT
18637	8933	18	joint	joint	JJ
18637	8933	19	forces	force	NNS
18637	8933	20	that	that	WDT
18637	8933	21	went	go	VBD
18637	8933	22	to	to	IN
18637	8933	23	the	the	DT
18637	8933	24	relief	relief	NN
18637	8933	25	of	of	IN
18637	8933	26	the	the	DT
18637	8933	27	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8933	28	legations	legation	NNS
18637	8933	29	in	in	IN
18637	8933	30	Peking	Peking	NNP
18637	8933	31	,	,	,
18637	8933	32	the	the	DT
18637	8933	33	Chinese	Chinese	NNP
18637	8933	34	Imperial	Imperial	NNP
18637	8933	35	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8933	36	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	8933	37	that	that	IN
18637	8933	38	this	this	DT
18637	8933	39	action	action	NN
18637	8933	40	had	have	VBD
18637	8933	41	not	not	RB
18637	8933	42	constituted	constitute	VBN
18637	8933	43	war	war	NN
18637	8933	44	.	.	.
18637	8934	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8934	2	417	417	CD
18637	8934	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8934	4	The	the	DT
18637	8934	5	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	8934	6	Pact	Pact	NNP
18637	8934	7	Article	Article	NNP
18637	8934	8	V	v	NN
18637	8934	9	of	of	IN
18637	8934	10	the	the	DT
18637	8934	11	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	8934	12	Pact	Pact	NNP
18637	8934	13	builds	build	VBZ
18637	8934	14	on	on	IN
18637	8934	15	such	such	JJ
18637	8934	16	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	8934	17	.	.	.
18637	8935	1	The	the	DT
18637	8935	2	novel	novel	JJ
18637	8935	3	feature	feature	NN
18637	8935	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	8935	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8935	6	enlarged	enlarged	JJ
18637	8935	7	conception	conception	NN
18637	8935	8	of	of	IN
18637	8935	9	defensible	defensible	JJ
18637	8935	10	American	american	JJ
18637	8935	11	interests	interest	NNS
18637	8935	12	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	8935	13	.	.	.
18637	8936	1	In	in	IN
18637	8936	2	the	the	DT
18637	8936	3	words	word	NNS
18637	8936	4	of	of	IN
18637	8936	5	the	the	DT
18637	8936	6	published	publish	VBN
18637	8936	7	abstract	abstract	NN
18637	8936	8	of	of	IN
18637	8936	9	the	the	DT
18637	8936	10	Report	Report	NNP
18637	8936	11	of	of	IN
18637	8936	12	the	the	DT
18637	8936	13	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	8936	14	on	on	IN
18637	8936	15	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	8936	16	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	8936	17	on	on	IN
18637	8936	18	the	the	DT
18637	8936	19	Pact	Pact	NNP
18637	8936	20	,	,	,
18637	8936	21	"	"	''
18637	8936	22	Article	article	NN
18637	8936	23	5	5	CD
18637	8936	24	records	record	NNS
18637	8936	25	what	what	WP
18637	8936	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	8936	27	a	a	DT
18637	8936	28	fact	fact	NN
18637	8936	29	,	,	,
18637	8936	30	namely	namely	RB
18637	8936	31	,	,	,
18637	8936	32	that	that	IN
18637	8936	33	an	an	DT
18637	8936	34	armed	armed	JJ
18637	8936	35	attack	attack	NN
18637	8936	36	within	within	IN
18637	8936	37	the	the	DT
18637	8936	38	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	8936	39	of	of	IN
18637	8936	40	the	the	DT
18637	8936	41	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8936	42	would	would	MD
18637	8936	43	in	in	IN
18637	8936	44	the	the	DT
18637	8936	45	present	present	JJ
18637	8936	46	-	-	HYPH
18637	8936	47	day	day	NN
18637	8936	48	world	world	NN
18637	8936	49	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	8936	50	an	an	DT
18637	8936	51	attack	attack	NN
18637	8936	52	upon	upon	IN
18637	8936	53	the	the	DT
18637	8936	54	entire	entire	JJ
18637	8936	55	community	community	NN
18637	8936	56	comprising	comprise	VBG
18637	8936	57	the	the	DT
18637	8936	58	parties	party	NNS
18637	8936	59	to	to	IN
18637	8936	60	the	the	DT
18637	8936	61	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8936	62	,	,	,
18637	8936	63	including	include	VBG
18637	8936	64	the	the	DT
18637	8936	65	United	United	NNP
18637	8936	66	States	States	NNP
18637	8936	67	.	.	.
18637	8937	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	8937	2	,	,	,
18637	8937	3	the	the	DT
18637	8937	4	President	President	NNP
18637	8937	5	and	and	CC
18637	8937	6	the	the	DT
18637	8937	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8937	8	,	,	,
18637	8937	9	each	each	DT
18637	8937	10	within	within	IN
18637	8937	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8937	12	sphere	sphere	NN
18637	8937	13	of	of	IN
18637	8937	14	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	8937	15	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8937	16	responsibilities	responsibility	NNS
18637	8937	17	,	,	,
18637	8937	18	would	would	MD
18637	8937	19	be	be	VB
18637	8937	20	expected	expect	VBN
18637	8937	21	to	to	TO
18637	8937	22	take	take	VB
18637	8937	23	all	all	DT
18637	8937	24	action	action	NN
18637	8937	25	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8937	26	and	and	CC
18637	8937	27	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	8937	28	to	to	TO
18637	8937	29	protect	protect	VB
18637	8937	30	the	the	DT
18637	8937	31	United	United	NNP
18637	8937	32	States	States	NNP
18637	8937	33	against	against	IN
18637	8937	34	the	the	DT
18637	8937	35	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	8937	36	and	and	CC
18637	8937	37	dangers	danger	NNS
18637	8937	38	of	of	IN
18637	8937	39	an	an	DT
18637	8937	40	armed	armed	JJ
18637	8937	41	attack	attack	NN
18637	8937	42	committed	commit	VBN
18637	8937	43	against	against	IN
18637	8937	44	any	any	DT
18637	8937	45	party	party	NN
18637	8937	46	to	to	IN
18637	8937	47	the	the	DT
18637	8937	48	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8937	49	.	.	.
18637	8938	1	"	"	``
18637	8938	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8938	3	418	418	CD
18637	8938	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8938	5	But	but	CC
18637	8938	6	from	from	IN
18637	8938	7	the	the	DT
18637	8938	8	very	very	JJ
18637	8938	9	nature	nature	NN
18637	8938	10	of	of	IN
18637	8938	11	things	thing	NNS
18637	8938	12	,	,	,
18637	8938	13	the	the	DT
18637	8938	14	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8938	15	of	of	IN
18637	8938	16	this	this	DT
18637	8938	17	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8938	18	against	against	IN
18637	8938	19	overt	overt	JJ
18637	8938	20	force	force	NN
18637	8938	21	will	will	MD
18637	8938	22	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	8938	23	rest	rest	VB
18637	8938	24	with	with	IN
18637	8938	25	the	the	DT
18637	8938	26	President	President	NNP
18637	8938	27	in	in	IN
18637	8938	28	the	the	DT
18637	8938	29	first	first	JJ
18637	8938	30	instance	instance	NN
18637	8938	31	,	,	,
18637	8938	32	just	just	RB
18637	8938	33	as	as	IN
18637	8938	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	8938	35	the	the	DT
18637	8938	36	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8938	37	in	in	IN
18637	8938	38	the	the	DT
18637	8938	39	past	past	NN
18637	8938	40	of	of	IN
18637	8938	41	the	the	DT
18637	8938	42	like	like	JJ
18637	8938	43	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8938	44	in	in	IN
18637	8938	45	the	the	DT
18637	8938	46	protection	protection	NN
18637	8938	47	of	of	IN
18637	8938	48	American	american	JJ
18637	8938	49	rights	right	NNS
18637	8938	50	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	8938	51	.	.	.
18637	8939	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	8939	2	,	,	,
18637	8939	3	in	in	IN
18637	8939	4	the	the	DT
18637	8939	5	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	8939	6	of	of	IN
18637	8939	7	this	this	DT
18637	8939	8	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	8939	9	the	the	DT
18637	8939	10	President	President	NNP
18637	8939	11	will	will	MD
18637	8939	12	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	8939	13	be	be	VB
18637	8939	14	required	require	VBN
18637	8939	15	to	to	TO
18637	8939	16	use	use	VB
18637	8939	17	force	force	NN
18637	8939	18	and	and	CC
18637	8939	19	perform	perform	VB
18637	8939	20	acts	act	NNS
18637	8939	21	of	of	IN
18637	8939	22	war	war	NN
18637	8939	23	.	.	.
18637	8940	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	8940	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	8940	3	the	the	DT
18637	8940	4	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	8940	5	of	of	IN
18637	8940	6	history	history	NN
18637	8940	7	,	,	,
18637	8940	8	a	a	DT
18637	8940	9	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	8940	10	which	which	WDT
18637	8940	11	was	be	VBD
18637	8940	12	foreseen	foresee	VBN
18637	8940	13	more	more	RBR
18637	8940	14	or	or	CC
18637	8940	15	less	less	RBR
18637	8940	16	definitely	definitely	RB
18637	8940	17	by	by	IN
18637	8940	18	the	the	DT
18637	8940	19	framers	framer	NNS
18637	8940	20	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8940	21	.	.	.
18637	8941	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8941	2	419	419	CD
18637	8941	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8941	4	PRESIDENTIAL	presidential	JJ
18637	8941	5	ACTION	action	NN
18637	8941	6	IN	in	IN
18637	8941	7	THE	the	DT
18637	8941	8	DOMAIN	DOMAIN	NNP
18637	8941	9	OF	of	IN
18637	8941	10	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	8941	11	:	:	:
18637	8941	12	THE	the	DT
18637	8941	13	STEEL	STEEL	NNP
18637	8941	14	SEIZURE	seizure	FW
18637	8941	15	CASE	case	NN
18637	8941	16	Facts[420	Facts[420	NNS
18637	8941	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8941	18	To	to	TO
18637	8941	19	avert	avert	VB
18637	8941	20	a	a	DT
18637	8941	21	nation	nation	NN
18637	8941	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	8941	23	wide	wide	JJ
18637	8941	24	strike	strike	NN
18637	8941	25	of	of	IN
18637	8941	26	steel	steel	NN
18637	8941	27	workers	worker	NNS
18637	8941	28	which	which	WDT
18637	8941	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8941	30	believed	believe	VBD
18637	8941	31	would	would	MD
18637	8941	32	jeopardize	jeopardize	VB
18637	8941	33	the	the	DT
18637	8941	34	national	national	JJ
18637	8941	35	defense	defense	NN
18637	8941	36	,	,	,
18637	8941	37	President	President	NNP
18637	8941	38	Truman	Truman	NNP
18637	8941	39	,	,	,
18637	8941	40	on	on	IN
18637	8941	41	April	April	NNP
18637	8941	42	8th	8th	NN
18637	8941	43	,	,	,
18637	8941	44	1952	1952	CD
18637	8941	45	,	,	,
18637	8941	46	issued	issue	VBD
18637	8941	47	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8941	48	Order	Order	NNP
18637	8941	49	10340[421	10340[421	.
18637	8941	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8941	51	directing	direct	VBG
18637	8941	52	the	the	DT
18637	8941	53	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8941	54	of	of	IN
18637	8941	55	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	8941	56	to	to	TO
18637	8941	57	seize	seize	VB
18637	8941	58	and	and	CC
18637	8941	59	operate	operate	VB
18637	8941	60	most	most	JJS
18637	8941	61	of	of	IN
18637	8941	62	the	the	DT
18637	8941	63	steel	steel	NN
18637	8941	64	mills	mill	NNS
18637	8941	65	of	of	IN
18637	8941	66	the	the	DT
18637	8941	67	country	country	NN
18637	8941	68	.	.	.
18637	8942	1	The	the	DT
18637	8942	2	Order	order	NN
18637	8942	3	cited	cite	VBD
18637	8942	4	no	no	DT
18637	8942	5	specific	specific	JJ
18637	8942	6	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	8942	7	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	8942	8	,	,	,
18637	8942	9	but	but	CC
18637	8942	10	invoked	invoke	VBD
18637	8942	11	generally	generally	RB
18637	8942	12	the	the	DT
18637	8942	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	8942	14	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8942	15	in	in	IN
18637	8942	16	the	the	DT
18637	8942	17	President	President	NNP
18637	8942	18	by	by	IN
18637	8942	19	the	the	DT
18637	8942	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8942	21	and	and	CC
18637	8942	22	laws	law	NNS
18637	8942	23	of	of	IN
18637	8942	24	the	the	DT
18637	8942	25	United	United	NNP
18637	8942	26	States	States	NNP
18637	8942	27	.	.	.
18637	8943	1	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8943	2	Sawyer	Sawyer	NNP
18637	8943	3	forthwith	forthwith	NN
18637	8943	4	issued	issue	VBD
18637	8943	5	an	an	DT
18637	8943	6	order	order	NN
18637	8943	7	seizing	seize	VBG
18637	8943	8	the	the	DT
18637	8943	9	mills	mill	NNS
18637	8943	10	and	and	CC
18637	8943	11	directing	direct	VBG
18637	8943	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8943	13	presidents	president	NNS
18637	8943	14	to	to	TO
18637	8943	15	operate	operate	VB
18637	8943	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8943	17	as	as	IN
18637	8943	18	operating	operating	NN
18637	8943	19	managers	manager	NNS
18637	8943	20	for	for	IN
18637	8943	21	the	the	DT
18637	8943	22	United	United	NNP
18637	8943	23	States	States	NNP
18637	8943	24	in	in	IN
18637	8943	25	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	8943	26	with	with	IN
18637	8943	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8943	28	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	8943	29	and	and	CC
18637	8943	30	directions	direction	NNS
18637	8943	31	.	.	.
18637	8944	1	The	the	DT
18637	8944	2	President	President	NNP
18637	8944	3	promptly	promptly	RB
18637	8944	4	reported	report	VBD
18637	8944	5	these	these	DT
18637	8944	6	events	event	NNS
18637	8944	7	to	to	IN
18637	8944	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8944	9	,	,	,
18637	8944	10	conceding	concede	VBG
18637	8944	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8944	12	's	's	POS
18637	8944	13	power	power	NN
18637	8944	14	to	to	TO
18637	8944	15	supersede	supersede	VB
18637	8944	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8944	17	Order	order	NN
18637	8944	18	;	;	:
18637	8944	19	but	but	CC
18637	8944	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8944	21	failed	fail	VBD
18637	8944	22	to	to	TO
18637	8944	23	do	do	VB
18637	8944	24	anything	anything	NN
18637	8944	25	about	about	IN
18637	8944	26	the	the	DT
18637	8944	27	matter	matter	NN
18637	8944	28	either	either	CC
18637	8944	29	then	then	RB
18637	8944	30	or	or	CC
18637	8944	31	a	a	DT
18637	8944	32	fortnight	fortnight	NN
18637	8944	33	later	later	RB
18637	8944	34	,	,	,
18637	8944	35	when	when	WRB
18637	8944	36	the	the	DT
18637	8944	37	President	President	NNP
18637	8944	38	again	again	RB
18637	8944	39	brought	bring	VBD
18637	8944	40	up	up	RP
18637	8944	41	the	the	DT
18637	8944	42	subject	subject	NN
18637	8944	43	in	in	IN
18637	8944	44	a	a	DT
18637	8944	45	special	special	JJ
18637	8944	46	message	message	NN
18637	8944	47	.	.	.
18637	8945	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8945	2	422	422	CD
18637	8945	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8945	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8945	5	had	have	VBD
18637	8945	6	in	in	IN
18637	8945	7	fact	fact	NN
18637	8945	8	provided	provide	VBN
18637	8945	9	other	other	JJ
18637	8945	10	methods	method	NNS
18637	8945	11	of	of	IN
18637	8945	12	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	8945	13	with	with	IN
18637	8945	14	such	such	JJ
18637	8945	15	situations	situation	NNS
18637	8945	16	,	,	,
18637	8945	17	in	in	IN
18637	8945	18	the	the	DT
18637	8945	19	elaboration	elaboration	NN
18637	8945	20	of	of	IN
18637	8945	21	which	which	WDT
18637	8945	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8945	23	had	have	VBD
18637	8945	24	declined	decline	VBN
18637	8945	25	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	8945	26	to	to	TO
18637	8945	27	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	8945	28	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	8945	29	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	8945	30	of	of	IN
18637	8945	31	property	property	NN
18637	8945	32	to	to	TO
18637	8945	33	settle	settle	VB
18637	8945	34	labor	labor	NN
18637	8945	35	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	8945	36	.	.	.
18637	8946	1	The	the	DT
18637	8946	2	steel	steel	NN
18637	8946	3	companies	company	NNS
18637	8946	4	sued	sue	VBD
18637	8946	5	the	the	DT
18637	8946	6	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8946	7	in	in	IN
18637	8946	8	a	a	DT
18637	8946	9	federal	federal	JJ
18637	8946	10	district	district	NN
18637	8946	11	court	court	NN
18637	8946	12	,	,	,
18637	8946	13	praying	pray	VBG
18637	8946	14	for	for	IN
18637	8946	15	a	a	DT
18637	8946	16	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	8946	17	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8946	18	and	and	CC
18637	8946	19	injunctive	injunctive	JJ
18637	8946	20	relief	relief	NN
18637	8946	21	.	.	.
18637	8947	1	The	the	DT
18637	8947	2	district	district	NN
18637	8947	3	court	court	NN
18637	8947	4	issued	issue	VBD
18637	8947	5	a	a	DT
18637	8947	6	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	8947	7	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	8947	8	,	,	,
18637	8947	9	which	which	WDT
18637	8947	10	the	the	DT
18637	8947	11	court	court	NN
18637	8947	12	of	of	IN
18637	8947	13	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	8947	14	stayed	stay	VBD
18637	8947	15	.	.	.
18637	8948	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8948	2	423	423	CD
18637	8948	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8948	4	On	on	IN
18637	8948	5	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	8948	6	to	to	IN
18637	8948	7	the	the	DT
18637	8948	8	court	court	NN
18637	8948	9	of	of	IN
18637	8948	10	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	8948	11	,	,	,
18637	8948	12	the	the	DT
18637	8948	13	district	district	NN
18637	8948	14	court	court	NN
18637	8948	15	's	's	POS
18637	8948	16	order	order	NN
18637	8948	17	was	be	VBD
18637	8948	18	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	8948	19	by	by	IN
18637	8948	20	the	the	DT
18637	8948	21	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8948	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8948	23	by	by	IN
18637	8948	24	a	a	DT
18637	8948	25	vote	vote	NN
18637	8948	26	of	of	IN
18637	8948	27	six	six	CD
18637	8948	28	justices	justice	NNS
18637	8948	29	to	to	IN
18637	8948	30	three	three	CD
18637	8948	31	.	.	.
18637	8949	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8949	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	8949	3	delivered	deliver	VBD
18637	8949	4	the	the	DT
18637	8949	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8949	6	of	of	IN
18637	8949	7	the	the	DT
18637	8949	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8949	9	in	in	IN
18637	8949	10	which	which	WDT
18637	8949	11	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	8949	12	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	8949	13	,	,	,
18637	8949	14	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	8949	15	,	,	,
18637	8949	16	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	8949	17	,	,	,
18637	8949	18	and	and	CC
18637	8949	19	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	8949	20	formally	formally	RB
18637	8949	21	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	8949	22	.	.	.
18637	8950	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8950	2	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	8950	3	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	8950	4	limited	limit	VBD
18637	8950	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8950	6	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	8950	7	to	to	IN
18637	8950	8	the	the	DT
18637	8950	9	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8950	10	of	of	IN
18637	8950	11	the	the	DT
18637	8950	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8950	13	.	.	.
18637	8951	1	All	all	PDT
18637	8951	2	these	these	DT
18637	8951	3	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	8951	4	presented	present	VBD
18637	8951	5	what	what	WP
18637	8951	6	are	be	VBP
18637	8951	7	termed	term	VBN
18637	8951	8	"	"	``
18637	8951	9	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	8951	10	"	"	''
18637	8951	11	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	8951	12	.	.	.
18637	8952	1	The	the	DT
18637	8952	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8952	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8952	4	,	,	,
18637	8952	5	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	8952	6	for	for	IN
18637	8952	7	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8952	8	and	and	CC
18637	8952	9	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	8952	10	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	8952	11	and	and	CC
18637	8952	12	Minton	Minton	NNP
18637	8952	13	,	,	,
18637	8952	14	presented	present	VBD
18637	8952	15	a	a	DT
18637	8952	16	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	8952	17	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8952	18	.	.	.
18637	8953	1	The	the	DT
18637	8953	2	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	8953	3	of	of	IN
18637	8953	4	the	the	DT
18637	8953	5	Opinion	Opinion	NNP
18637	8953	6	of	of	IN
18637	8953	7	the	the	DT
18637	8953	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8953	9	The	the	DT
18637	8953	10	chief	chief	JJ
18637	8953	11	points	point	NNS
18637	8953	12	urged	urge	VBN
18637	8953	13	in	in	IN
18637	8953	14	the	the	DT
18637	8953	15	Black	black	JJ
18637	8953	16	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8953	17	are	be	VBP
18637	8953	18	the	the	DT
18637	8953	19	following	follow	VBG
18637	8953	20	:	:	:
18637	8953	21	There	there	EX
18637	8953	22	was	be	VBD
18637	8953	23	no	no	DT
18637	8953	24	statute	statute	NN
18637	8953	25	which	which	WDT
18637	8953	26	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	8953	27	or	or	CC
18637	8953	28	impliedly	impliedly	RB
18637	8953	29	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	8953	30	the	the	DT
18637	8953	31	President	President	NNP
18637	8953	32	to	to	TO
18637	8953	33	take	take	VB
18637	8953	34	possession	possession	NN
18637	8953	35	of	of	IN
18637	8953	36	the	the	DT
18637	8953	37	property	property	NN
18637	8953	38	involved	involve	VBN
18637	8953	39	.	.	.
18637	8954	1	On	on	IN
18637	8954	2	the	the	DT
18637	8954	3	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	8954	4	,	,	,
18637	8954	5	in	in	IN
18637	8954	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8954	7	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	8954	8	of	of	IN
18637	8954	9	the	the	DT
18637	8954	10	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	8954	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	8954	12	Hartley	Hartley	NNP
18637	8954	13	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8954	14	in	in	IN
18637	8954	15	1947	1947	CD
18637	8954	16	,	,	,
18637	8954	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8954	18	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	8954	19	to	to	TO
18637	8954	20	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	8954	21	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	8954	22	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	8954	23	of	of	IN
18637	8954	24	property	property	NN
18637	8954	25	as	as	IN
18637	8954	26	a	a	DT
18637	8954	27	method	method	NN
18637	8954	28	of	of	IN
18637	8954	29	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	8954	30	work	work	NN
18637	8954	31	stoppages	stoppage	NNS
18637	8954	32	and	and	CC
18637	8954	33	settling	settle	VBG
18637	8954	34	labor	labor	NN
18637	8954	35	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	8954	36	.	.	.
18637	8955	1	Authority	authority	NN
18637	8955	2	to	to	TO
18637	8955	3	issue	issue	VB
18637	8955	4	such	such	PDT
18637	8955	5	an	an	DT
18637	8955	6	order	order	NN
18637	8955	7	in	in	IN
18637	8955	8	the	the	DT
18637	8955	9	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	8955	10	of	of	IN
18637	8955	11	the	the	DT
18637	8955	12	case	case	NN
18637	8955	13	was	be	VBD
18637	8955	14	not	not	RB
18637	8955	15	deducible	deducible	JJ
18637	8955	16	from	from	IN
18637	8955	17	the	the	DT
18637	8955	18	aggregate	aggregate	NN
18637	8955	19	of	of	IN
18637	8955	20	the	the	DT
18637	8955	21	President	President	NNP
18637	8955	22	's	's	POS
18637	8955	23	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8955	24	powers	power	NNS
18637	8955	25	under	under	IN
18637	8955	26	Article	Article	NNP
18637	8955	27	II	ii	CD
18637	8955	28	of	of	IN
18637	8955	29	the	the	DT
18637	8955	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8955	31	;	;	:
18637	8955	32	nor	nor	CC
18637	8955	33	was	be	VBD
18637	8955	34	the	the	DT
18637	8955	35	Order	order	NN
18637	8955	36	maintainable	maintainable	JJ
18637	8955	37	as	as	IN
18637	8955	38	an	an	DT
18637	8955	39	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	8955	40	of	of	IN
18637	8955	41	the	the	DT
18637	8955	42	President	President	NNP
18637	8955	43	's	's	POS
18637	8955	44	powers	power	NNS
18637	8955	45	as	as	IN
18637	8955	46	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	8955	47	in	in	IN
18637	8955	48	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8955	49	of	of	IN
18637	8955	50	the	the	DT
18637	8955	51	Armed	Armed	NNP
18637	8955	52	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	8955	53	.	.	.
18637	8956	1	The	the	DT
18637	8956	2	power	power	NN
18637	8956	3	sought	seek	VBD
18637	8956	4	to	to	TO
18637	8956	5	be	be	VB
18637	8956	6	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	8956	7	was	be	VBD
18637	8956	8	the	the	DT
18637	8956	9	lawmaking	lawmaking	NN
18637	8956	10	power	power	NN
18637	8956	11	,	,	,
18637	8956	12	which	which	WDT
18637	8956	13	the	the	DT
18637	8956	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8956	15	vests	vest	VBZ
18637	8956	16	in	in	IN
18637	8956	17	the	the	DT
18637	8956	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8956	19	alone	alone	RB
18637	8956	20	.	.	.
18637	8957	1	Even	even	RB
18637	8957	2	if	if	IN
18637	8957	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8957	4	were	be	VBD
18637	8957	5	true	true	JJ
18637	8957	6	that	that	IN
18637	8957	7	other	other	JJ
18637	8957	8	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	8957	9	have	have	VBP
18637	8957	10	taken	take	VBN
18637	8957	11	possession	possession	NN
18637	8957	12	of	of	IN
18637	8957	13	private	private	JJ
18637	8957	14	business	business	NN
18637	8957	15	enterprises	enterprise	NNS
18637	8957	16	without	without	IN
18637	8957	17	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	8957	18	authority	authority	NN
18637	8957	19	in	in	IN
18637	8957	20	order	order	NN
18637	8957	21	to	to	TO
18637	8957	22	settle	settle	VB
18637	8957	23	labor	labor	NN
18637	8957	24	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	8957	25	,	,	,
18637	8957	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8957	27	was	be	VBD
18637	8957	28	not	not	RB
18637	8957	29	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	8957	30	divested	divested	JJ
18637	8957	31	of	of	IN
18637	8957	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8957	33	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	8957	34	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	8957	35	authority	authority	NN
18637	8957	36	to	to	TO
18637	8957	37	make	make	VB
18637	8957	38	the	the	DT
18637	8957	39	laws	law	NNS
18637	8957	40	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	8957	41	and	and	CC
18637	8957	42	proper	proper	JJ
18637	8957	43	to	to	TO
18637	8957	44	carry	carry	VB
18637	8957	45	out	out	RP
18637	8957	46	all	all	DT
18637	8957	47	powers	power	NNS
18637	8957	48	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8957	49	by	by	IN
18637	8957	50	the	the	DT
18637	8957	51	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8957	52	"	"	''
18637	8957	53	in	in	IN
18637	8957	54	the	the	DT
18637	8957	55	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8957	56	of	of	IN
18637	8957	57	the	the	DT
18637	8957	58	United	United	NNP
18637	8957	59	States	States	NNP
18637	8957	60	,	,	,
18637	8957	61	or	or	CC
18637	8957	62	any	any	DT
18637	8957	63	Department	Department	NNP
18637	8957	64	or	or	CC
18637	8957	65	Officer	Officer	NNP
18637	8957	66	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	8957	67	.	.	.
18637	8958	1	"	"	``
18637	8958	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8958	3	424	424	CD
18637	8958	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8958	5	The	the	DT
18637	8958	6	Factual	Factual	NNP
18637	8958	7	Record	Record	NNP
18637	8958	8	The	the	DT
18637	8958	9	pivotal	pivotal	JJ
18637	8958	10	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	8958	11	of	of	IN
18637	8958	12	the	the	DT
18637	8958	13	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8958	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8958	15	,	,	,
18637	8958	16	in	in	IN
18637	8958	17	brief	brief	NN
18637	8958	18	,	,	,
18637	8958	19	that	that	DT
18637	8958	20	inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	8958	21	as	as	IN
18637	8958	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8958	23	could	could	MD
18637	8958	24	have	have	VB
18637	8958	25	ordered	order	VBN
18637	8958	26	the	the	DT
18637	8958	27	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	8958	28	of	of	IN
18637	8958	29	the	the	DT
18637	8958	30	steel	steel	NN
18637	8958	31	mills	mill	NNS
18637	8958	32	,	,	,
18637	8958	33	the	the	DT
18637	8958	34	President	President	NNP
18637	8958	35	had	have	VBD
18637	8958	36	no	no	DT
18637	8958	37	power	power	NN
18637	8958	38	to	to	TO
18637	8958	39	do	do	VB
18637	8958	40	so	so	RB
18637	8958	41	without	without	IN
18637	8958	42	prior	prior	JJ
18637	8958	43	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	8958	44	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	8958	45	.	.	.
18637	8959	1	To	to	TO
18637	8959	2	support	support	VB
18637	8959	3	this	this	DT
18637	8959	4	position	position	NN
18637	8959	5	no	no	DT
18637	8959	6	proof	proof	NN
18637	8959	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	8959	8	offered	offer	VBN
18637	8959	9	in	in	IN
18637	8959	10	the	the	DT
18637	8959	11	way	way	NN
18637	8959	12	of	of	IN
18637	8959	13	past	past	JJ
18637	8959	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8959	15	,	,	,
18637	8959	16	and	and	CC
18637	8959	17	the	the	DT
18637	8959	18	following	follow	VBG
18637	8959	19	extract	extract	NN
18637	8959	20	from	from	IN
18637	8959	21	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8959	22	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	8959	23	's	's	POS
18637	8959	24	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8959	25	presents	present	VBZ
18637	8959	26	a	a	DT
18637	8959	27	formidable	formidable	JJ
18637	8959	28	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	8959	29	to	to	IN
18637	8959	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8959	31	:	:	:
18637	8959	32	"	"	``
18637	8959	33	One	one	CD
18637	8959	34	of	of	IN
18637	8959	35	this	this	DT
18637	8959	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8959	37	's	's	POS
18637	8959	38	first	first	JJ
18637	8959	39	pronouncements	pronouncement	NNS
18637	8959	40	upon	upon	IN
18637	8959	41	the	the	DT
18637	8959	42	powers	power	NNS
18637	8959	43	of	of	IN
18637	8959	44	the	the	DT
18637	8959	45	President	President	NNP
18637	8959	46	under	under	IN
18637	8959	47	the	the	DT
18637	8959	48	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8959	49	was	be	VBD
18637	8959	50	made	make	VBN
18637	8959	51	by	by	IN
18637	8959	52	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	8959	53	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8959	54	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8959	55	John	John	NNP
18637	8959	56	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	8959	57	some	some	DT
18637	8959	58	one	one	CD
18637	8959	59	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	8959	60	and	and	CC
18637	8959	61	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	8959	62	years	year	NNS
18637	8959	63	ago	ago	RB
18637	8959	64	.	.	.
18637	8960	1	In	in	IN
18637	8960	2	Little	Little	NNP
18637	8960	3	_	_	NNP
18637	8960	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	8960	5	_	_	NNP
18637	8960	6	Barreme,[425	Barreme,[425	NNP
18637	8960	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8960	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8960	9	used	use	VBD
18637	8960	10	this	this	DT
18637	8960	11	characteristically	characteristically	RB
18637	8960	12	clear	clear	JJ
18637	8960	13	language	language	NN
18637	8960	14	in	in	IN
18637	8960	15	discussing	discuss	VBG
18637	8960	16	the	the	DT
18637	8960	17	power	power	NN
18637	8960	18	of	of	IN
18637	8960	19	the	the	DT
18637	8960	20	President	President	NNP
18637	8960	21	to	to	TO
18637	8960	22	instruct	instruct	VB
18637	8960	23	the	the	DT
18637	8960	24	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	8960	25	of	of	IN
18637	8960	26	the	the	DT
18637	8960	27	_	_	NNP
18637	8960	28	Flying	Flying	NNP
18637	8960	29	Fish	Fish	NNP
18637	8960	30	_	_	NNP
18637	8960	31	,	,	,
18637	8960	32	a	a	DT
18637	8960	33	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	8960	34	bound	bind	VBN
18637	8960	35	from	from	IN
18637	8960	36	a	a	DT
18637	8960	37	French	french	JJ
18637	8960	38	port	port	NN
18637	8960	39	:	:	:
18637	8960	40	'	'	''
18637	8960	41	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8960	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	8960	43	by	by	IN
18637	8960	44	no	no	DT
18637	8960	45	means	means	NN
18637	8960	46	clear	clear	JJ
18637	8960	47	that	that	IN
18637	8960	48	the	the	DT
18637	8960	49	president	president	NN
18637	8960	50	of	of	IN
18637	8960	51	the	the	DT
18637	8960	52	United	United	NNP
18637	8960	53	States	States	NNP
18637	8960	54	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8960	55	high	high	JJ
18637	8960	56	duty	duty	NN
18637	8960	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8960	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	8960	59	to	to	TO
18637	8960	60	"	"	``
18637	8960	61	take	take	VB
18637	8960	62	care	care	NN
18637	8960	63	that	that	IN
18637	8960	64	the	the	DT
18637	8960	65	laws	law	NNS
18637	8960	66	be	be	VB
18637	8960	67	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8960	68	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8960	69	,	,	,
18637	8960	70	"	"	''
18637	8960	71	and	and	CC
18637	8960	72	who	who	WP
18637	8960	73	is	be	VBZ
18637	8960	74	commander	commander	NN
18637	8960	75	in	in	IN
18637	8960	76	chief	chief	NN
18637	8960	77	of	of	IN
18637	8960	78	the	the	DT
18637	8960	79	armies	army	NNS
18637	8960	80	and	and	CC
18637	8960	81	navies	navy	NNS
18637	8960	82	of	of	IN
18637	8960	83	the	the	DT
18637	8960	84	United	United	NNP
18637	8960	85	States	States	NNP
18637	8960	86	,	,	,
18637	8960	87	might	may	MD
18637	8960	88	not	not	RB
18637	8960	89	,	,	,
18637	8960	90	without	without	IN
18637	8960	91	any	any	DT
18637	8960	92	special	special	JJ
18637	8960	93	authority	authority	NN
18637	8960	94	for	for	IN
18637	8960	95	that	that	DT
18637	8960	96	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8960	97	,	,	,
18637	8960	98	in	in	IN
18637	8960	99	the	the	DT
18637	8960	100	then	then	RB
18637	8960	101	existing	exist	VBG
18637	8960	102	state	state	NN
18637	8960	103	of	of	IN
18637	8960	104	things	thing	NNS
18637	8960	105	,	,	,
18637	8960	106	have	have	VBP
18637	8960	107	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	8960	108	the	the	DT
18637	8960	109	officers	officer	NNS
18637	8960	110	commanding	command	VBG
18637	8960	111	the	the	DT
18637	8960	112	armed	armed	JJ
18637	8960	113	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	8960	114	of	of	IN
18637	8960	115	the	the	DT
18637	8960	116	United	United	NNP
18637	8960	117	States	States	NNP
18637	8960	118	,	,	,
18637	8960	119	to	to	TO
18637	8960	120	seize	seize	VB
18637	8960	121	and	and	CC
18637	8960	122	send	send	VB
18637	8960	123	into	into	IN
18637	8960	124	port	port	NN
18637	8960	125	for	for	IN
18637	8960	126	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	8960	127	,	,	,
18637	8960	128	American	american	JJ
18637	8960	129	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	8960	130	which	which	WDT
18637	8960	131	were	be	VBD
18637	8960	132	forfeited	forfeit	VBN
18637	8960	133	by	by	IN
18637	8960	134	being	be	VBG
18637	8960	135	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	8960	136	in	in	IN
18637	8960	137	this	this	DT
18637	8960	138	illicit	illicit	NN
18637	8960	139	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	8960	140	.	.	.
18637	8961	1	But	but	CC
18637	8961	2	when	when	WRB
18637	8961	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8961	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	8961	5	observed	observe	VBN
18637	8961	6	that	that	WDT
18637	8961	7	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8961	8	an	an	DT
18637	8961	9	act	act	NN
18637	8961	10	of	of	IN
18637	8961	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8961	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8961	13	gives	give	VBZ
18637	8961	14	a	a	DT
18637	8961	15	special	special	JJ
18637	8961	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	8961	17	to	to	TO
18637	8961	18	seize	seize	VB
18637	8961	19	on	on	IN
18637	8961	20	the	the	DT
18637	8961	21	high	high	JJ
18637	8961	22	seas	sea	NNS
18637	8961	23	,	,	,
18637	8961	24	and	and	CC
18637	8961	25	limits	limit	NNS
18637	8961	26	that	that	IN
18637	8961	27	authority	authority	NN
18637	8961	28	to	to	IN
18637	8961	29	the	the	DT
18637	8961	30	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	8961	31	of	of	IN
18637	8961	32	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	8961	33	bound	bind	VBN
18637	8961	34	or	or	CC
18637	8961	35	sailing	sailing	NN
18637	8961	36	to	to	IN
18637	8961	37	a	a	DT
18637	8961	38	French	french	JJ
18637	8961	39	port	port	NN
18637	8961	40	,	,	,
18637	8961	41	the	the	DT
18637	8961	42	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	8961	43	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	8961	44	to	to	TO
18637	8961	45	have	have	VB
18637	8961	46	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	8961	47	that	that	IN
18637	8961	48	the	the	DT
18637	8961	49	manner	manner	NN
18637	8961	50	in	in	IN
18637	8961	51	which	which	WDT
18637	8961	52	this	this	DT
18637	8961	53	law	law	NN
18637	8961	54	shall	shall	MD
18637	8961	55	be	be	VB
18637	8961	56	carried	carry	VBN
18637	8961	57	into	into	IN
18637	8961	58	execution	execution	NN
18637	8961	59	,	,	,
18637	8961	60	was	be	VBD
18637	8961	61	to	to	TO
18637	8961	62	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	8961	63	a	a	DT
18637	8961	64	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	8961	65	of	of	IN
18637	8961	66	any	any	DT
18637	8961	67	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	8961	68	not	not	RB
18637	8961	69	bound	bind	VBN
18637	8961	70	to	to	IN
18637	8961	71	a	a	DT
18637	8961	72	French	french	JJ
18637	8961	73	port	port	NN
18637	8961	74	.	.	.
18637	8961	75	'	'	''
18637	8962	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	8962	2	,	,	,
18637	8962	3	a	a	DT
18637	8962	4	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	8962	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8962	6	held	hold	VBD
18637	8962	7	that	that	IN
18637	8962	8	the	the	DT
18637	8962	9	President	President	NNP
18637	8962	10	's	's	POS
18637	8962	11	instructions	instruction	NNS
18637	8962	12	had	have	VBD
18637	8962	13	been	be	VBN
18637	8962	14	issued	issue	VBN
18637	8962	15	without	without	IN
18637	8962	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	8962	17	and	and	CC
18637	8962	18	that	that	IN
18637	8962	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8962	20	could	could	MD
18637	8962	21	not	not	RB
18637	8962	22	'	'	``
18637	8962	23	legalize	legalize	VB
18637	8962	24	an	an	DT
18637	8962	25	act	act	NN
18637	8962	26	which	which	WDT
18637	8962	27	without	without	IN
18637	8962	28	those	those	DT
18637	8962	29	instructions	instruction	NNS
18637	8962	30	would	would	MD
18637	8962	31	have	have	VB
18637	8962	32	been	be	VBN
18637	8962	33	a	a	DT
18637	8962	34	plain	plain	JJ
18637	8962	35	trespass	trespass	NN
18637	8962	36	.	.	.
18637	8962	37	'	'	''
18637	8963	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8963	2	know	know	VBP
18637	8963	3	of	of	IN
18637	8963	4	no	no	DT
18637	8963	5	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	8963	6	holding	holding	NN
18637	8963	7	of	of	IN
18637	8963	8	this	this	DT
18637	8963	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8963	10	to	to	IN
18637	8963	11	the	the	DT
18637	8963	12	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	8963	13	.	.	.
18637	8964	1	"	"	``
18637	8964	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8964	3	426	426	CD
18637	8964	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8964	5	Another	another	DT
18637	8964	6	field	field	NN
18637	8964	7	which	which	WDT
18637	8964	8	the	the	DT
18637	8964	9	President	President	NNP
18637	8964	10	and	and	CC
18637	8964	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8964	12	have	have	VBP
18637	8964	13	each	each	DT
18637	8964	14	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	8964	15	at	at	IN
18637	8964	16	different	different	JJ
18637	8964	17	times	time	NNS
18637	8964	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	8964	19	extradition	extradition	NN
18637	8964	20	.	.	.
18637	8965	1	In	in	IN
18637	8965	2	1799	1799	CD
18637	8965	3	President	President	NNP
18637	8965	4	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	8965	5	,	,	,
18637	8965	6	in	in	IN
18637	8965	7	order	order	NN
18637	8965	8	to	to	TO
18637	8965	9	execute	execute	VB
18637	8965	10	the	the	DT
18637	8965	11	extradition	extradition	NN
18637	8965	12	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8965	13	of	of	IN
18637	8965	14	the	the	DT
18637	8965	15	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	8965	16	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	8965	17	,	,	,
18637	8965	18	issued	issue	VBD
18637	8965	19	a	a	DT
18637	8965	20	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	8965	21	for	for	IN
18637	8965	22	the	the	DT
18637	8965	23	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	8965	24	of	of	IN
18637	8965	25	one	one	CD
18637	8965	26	Jonathan	Jonathan	NNP
18637	8965	27	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	8965	28	.	.	.
18637	8966	1	As	as	IN
18637	8966	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8966	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8966	4	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	8966	5	recites	recite	VBZ
18637	8966	6	in	in	IN
18637	8966	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8966	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8966	9	:	:	:
18637	8966	10	"	"	``
18637	8966	11	This	this	DT
18637	8966	12	action	action	NN
18637	8966	13	was	be	VBD
18637	8966	14	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	8966	15	in	in	IN
18637	8966	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8966	17	on	on	IN
18637	8966	18	the	the	DT
18637	8966	19	ground	ground	NN
18637	8966	20	that	that	IN
18637	8966	21	no	no	DT
18637	8966	22	specific	specific	JJ
18637	8966	23	statute	statute	NN
18637	8966	24	prescribed	prescribe	VBD
18637	8966	25	the	the	DT
18637	8966	26	method	method	NN
18637	8966	27	to	to	TO
18637	8966	28	be	be	VB
18637	8966	29	used	use	VBN
18637	8966	30	in	in	IN
18637	8966	31	executing	execute	VBG
18637	8966	32	the	the	DT
18637	8966	33	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8966	34	.	.	.
18637	8967	1	John	John	NNP
18637	8967	2	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	8967	3	,	,	,
18637	8967	4	then	then	RB
18637	8967	5	a	a	DT
18637	8967	6	member	member	NN
18637	8967	7	of	of	IN
18637	8967	8	the	the	DT
18637	8967	9	House	House	NNP
18637	8967	10	of	of	IN
18637	8967	11	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	8967	12	,	,	,
18637	8967	13	in	in	IN
18637	8967	14	the	the	DT
18637	8967	15	course	course	NN
18637	8967	16	of	of	IN
18637	8967	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8967	18	successful	successful	JJ
18637	8967	19	defense	defense	NN
18637	8967	20	of	of	IN
18637	8967	21	the	the	DT
18637	8967	22	President	President	NNP
18637	8967	23	's	's	POS
18637	8967	24	action	action	NN
18637	8967	25	,	,	,
18637	8967	26	said	say	VBD
18637	8967	27	:	:	:
18637	8967	28	'	'	''
18637	8967	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8967	30	,	,	,
18637	8967	31	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
18637	8967	32	,	,	,
18637	8967	33	may	may	MD
18637	8967	34	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	8967	35	the	the	DT
18637	8967	36	mode	mode	NN
18637	8967	37	,	,	,
18637	8967	38	and	and	CC
18637	8967	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8967	40	may	may	MD
18637	8967	41	devolve	devolve	VB
18637	8967	42	on	on	IN
18637	8967	43	others	other	NNS
18637	8967	44	the	the	DT
18637	8967	45	whole	whole	JJ
18637	8967	46	execution	execution	NN
18637	8967	47	of	of	IN
18637	8967	48	the	the	DT
18637	8967	49	contract	contract	NN
18637	8967	50	;	;	:
18637	8967	51	but	but	CC
18637	8967	52	,	,	,
18637	8967	53	till	till	IN
18637	8967	54	this	this	DT
18637	8967	55	be	be	VB
18637	8967	56	done	do	VBN
18637	8967	57	,	,	,
18637	8967	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8967	59	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	8967	60	the	the	DT
18637	8967	61	duty	duty	NN
18637	8967	62	of	of	IN
18637	8967	63	the	the	DT
18637	8967	64	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	8967	65	department	department	NN
18637	8967	66	to	to	TO
18637	8967	67	execute	execute	VB
18637	8967	68	the	the	DT
18637	8967	69	contract	contract	NN
18637	8967	70	by	by	IN
18637	8967	71	any	any	DT
18637	8967	72	means	mean	NNS
18637	8967	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8967	74	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	8967	75	.	.	.
18637	8968	1	'	'	``
18637	8968	2	"	"	``
18637	8968	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8968	4	427	427	CD
18637	8968	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8968	6	In	in	IN
18637	8968	7	1848	1848	CD
18637	8968	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8968	9	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	8968	10	a	a	DT
18637	8968	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	8968	12	governing	govern	VBG
18637	8968	13	this	this	DT
18637	8968	14	subject	subject	NN
18637	8968	15	which	which	WDT
18637	8968	16	confers	confer	VBZ
18637	8968	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	8968	18	the	the	DT
18637	8968	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	8968	20	,	,	,
18637	8968	21	both	both	CC
18637	8968	22	State	State	NNP
18637	8968	23	and	and	CC
18637	8968	24	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	8968	25	,	,	,
18637	8968	26	the	the	DT
18637	8968	27	duty	duty	NN
18637	8968	28	of	of	IN
18637	8968	29	handling	handle	VBG
18637	8968	30	extradition	extradition	NN
18637	8968	31	cases	case	NNS
18637	8968	32	.	.	.
18637	8969	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8969	2	428	428	CD
18637	8969	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8969	4	The	the	DT
18637	8969	5	first	first	JJ
18637	8969	6	Neutrality	Neutrality	NNP
18637	8969	7	Proclamation	Proclamation	NNP
18637	8969	8	was	be	VBD
18637	8969	9	issued	issue	VBN
18637	8969	10	by	by	IN
18637	8969	11	President	President	NNP
18637	8969	12	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	8969	13	in	in	IN
18637	8969	14	1793	1793	CD
18637	8969	15	without	without	IN
18637	8969	16	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	8969	17	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	8969	18	.	.	.
18637	8970	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8970	2	429	429	CD
18637	8970	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8970	4	The	the	DT
18637	8970	5	following	following	JJ
18637	8970	6	year	year	NN
18637	8970	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8970	8	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	8970	9	the	the	DT
18637	8970	10	first	first	JJ
18637	8970	11	neutrality	neutrality	NN
18637	8970	12	statute,[430	statute,[430	NN
18637	8970	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8970	14	and	and	CC
18637	8970	15	since	since	IN
18637	8970	16	then	then	RB
18637	8970	17	proclamations	proclamation	NNS
18637	8970	18	of	of	IN
18637	8970	19	neutrality	neutrality	NN
18637	8970	20	have	have	VBP
18637	8970	21	been	be	VBN
18637	8970	22	based	base	VBN
18637	8970	23	on	on	IN
18637	8970	24	an	an	DT
18637	8970	25	act	act	NN
18637	8970	26	of	of	IN
18637	8970	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8970	28	governing	govern	VBG
18637	8970	29	the	the	DT
18637	8970	30	matter	matter	NN
18637	8970	31	.	.	.
18637	8971	1	The	the	DT
18637	8971	2	President	President	NNP
18637	8971	3	may	may	MD
18637	8971	4	,	,	,
18637	8971	5	in	in	IN
18637	8971	6	the	the	DT
18637	8971	7	absence	absence	NN
18637	8971	8	of	of	IN
18637	8971	9	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8971	10	by	by	IN
18637	8971	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8971	12	,	,	,
18637	8971	13	control	control	VB
18637	8971	14	the	the	DT
18637	8971	15	landing	landing	NN
18637	8971	16	of	of	IN
18637	8971	17	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8971	18	cables	cable	NNS
18637	8971	19	in	in	IN
18637	8971	20	the	the	DT
18637	8971	21	United	United	NNP
18637	8971	22	States	States	NNP
18637	8971	23	and	and	CC
18637	8971	24	the	the	DT
18637	8971	25	passage	passage	NN
18637	8971	26	of	of	IN
18637	8971	27	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	8971	28	troops	troop	NNS
18637	8971	29	through	through	IN
18637	8971	30	American	american	JJ
18637	8971	31	territory	territory	NN
18637	8971	32	,	,	,
18637	8971	33	and	and	CC
18637	8971	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	8971	35	done	do	VBN
18637	8971	36	so	so	RB
18637	8971	37	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	8971	38	.	.	.
18637	8972	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8972	2	431	431	CD
18637	8972	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8972	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	8972	5	,	,	,
18637	8972	6	until	until	IN
18637	8972	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8972	8	acts	act	VBZ
18637	8972	9	,	,	,
18637	8972	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8972	11	may	may	MD
18637	8972	12	govern	govern	VB
18637	8972	13	conquered	conquer	VBN
18637	8972	14	territory[432	territory[432	.
18637	8972	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8972	16	and	and	CC
18637	8972	17	,	,	,
18637	8972	18	"	"	``
18637	8972	19	in	in	IN
18637	8972	20	the	the	DT
18637	8972	21	absence	absence	NN
18637	8972	22	of	of	IN
18637	8972	23	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	8972	24	by	by	IN
18637	8972	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8972	26	to	to	TO
18637	8972	27	limit	limit	VB
18637	8972	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8972	29	power	power	NN
18637	8972	30	,	,	,
18637	8972	31	"	"	''
18637	8972	32	may	may	MD
18637	8972	33	set	set	VB
18637	8972	34	up	up	RP
18637	8972	35	military	military	JJ
18637	8972	36	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	8972	37	in	in	IN
18637	8972	38	territory	territory	NN
18637	8972	39	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	8972	40	by	by	IN
18637	8972	41	the	the	DT
18637	8972	42	armed	armed	JJ
18637	8972	43	forces	force	NNS
18637	8972	44	of	of	IN
18637	8972	45	the	the	DT
18637	8972	46	United	United	NNP
18637	8972	47	States	States	NNP
18637	8972	48	.	.	.
18637	8973	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8973	2	433	433	CD
18637	8973	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8973	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8973	5	may	may	MD
18637	8973	6	determine	determine	VB
18637	8973	7	,	,	,
18637	8973	8	in	in	IN
18637	8973	9	a	a	DT
18637	8973	10	way	way	NN
18637	8973	11	to	to	TO
18637	8973	12	bind	bind	VB
18637	8973	13	the	the	DT
18637	8973	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	8973	15	,	,	,
18637	8973	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	8973	17	a	a	DT
18637	8973	18	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	8973	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	8973	20	still	still	RB
18637	8973	21	in	in	IN
18637	8973	22	force	force	NN
18637	8973	23	as	as	IN
18637	8973	24	law	law	NN
18637	8973	25	of	of	IN
18637	8973	26	the	the	DT
18637	8973	27	land	land	NN
18637	8973	28	,	,	,
18637	8973	29	although	although	IN
18637	8973	30	again	again	RB
18637	8973	31	the	the	DT
18637	8973	32	final	final	JJ
18637	8973	33	power	power	NN
18637	8973	34	in	in	IN
18637	8973	35	the	the	DT
18637	8973	36	field	field	NN
18637	8973	37	rests	rest	NNS
18637	8973	38	with	with	IN
18637	8973	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8973	40	.	.	.
18637	8974	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8974	2	434	434	CD
18637	8974	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8974	4	One	one	CD
18637	8974	5	of	of	IN
18637	8974	6	the	the	DT
18637	8974	7	President	President	NNP
18637	8974	8	's	's	POS
18637	8974	9	most	most	RBS
18637	8974	10	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	8974	11	powers	power	NNS
18637	8974	12	and	and	CC
18637	8974	13	duties	duty	NNS
18637	8974	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	8974	15	that	that	DT
18637	8974	16	of	of	IN
18637	8974	17	ordering	order	VBG
18637	8974	18	the	the	DT
18637	8974	19	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	8974	20	of	of	IN
18637	8974	21	supposed	suppose	VBN
18637	8974	22	offenders	offender	NNS
18637	8974	23	against	against	IN
18637	8974	24	the	the	DT
18637	8974	25	laws	law	NNS
18637	8974	26	of	of	IN
18637	8974	27	the	the	DT
18637	8974	28	United	United	NNP
18637	8974	29	States	States	NNP
18637	8974	30	.	.	.
18637	8975	1	Yet	yet	CC
18637	8975	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8975	3	may	may	MD
18637	8975	4	do	do	VB
18637	8975	5	the	the	DT
18637	8975	6	same	same	JJ
18637	8975	7	thing	thing	NN
18637	8975	8	.	.	.
18637	8976	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8976	2	435	435	CD
18637	8976	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8976	4	On	on	IN
18637	8976	5	September	September	NNP
18637	8976	6	22	22	CD
18637	8976	7	,	,	,
18637	8976	8	1862	1862	CD
18637	8976	9	,	,	,
18637	8976	10	President	President	NNP
18637	8976	11	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	8976	12	issued	issue	VBD
18637	8976	13	a	a	DT
18637	8976	14	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	8976	15	suspending	suspend	VBG
18637	8976	16	the	the	DT
18637	8976	17	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	8976	18	of	of	IN
18637	8976	19	the	the	DT
18637	8976	20	writ	writ	NNP
18637	8976	21	of	of	IN
18637	8976	22	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	8976	23	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	8976	24	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	8976	25	the	the	DT
18637	8976	26	Union	Union	NNP
18637	8976	27	in	in	IN
18637	8976	28	certain	certain	JJ
18637	8976	29	classes	class	NNS
18637	8976	30	of	of	IN
18637	8976	31	cases	case	NNS
18637	8976	32	.	.	.
18637	8977	1	By	by	IN
18637	8977	2	an	an	DT
18637	8977	3	act	act	NN
18637	8977	4	passed	pass	VBN
18637	8977	5	March	March	NNP
18637	8977	6	3	3	CD
18637	8977	7	,	,	,
18637	8977	8	1863	1863	CD
18637	8977	9	,	,	,
18637	8977	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8977	11	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	8977	12	this	this	DT
18637	8977	13	action	action	NN
18637	8977	14	of	of	IN
18637	8977	15	the	the	DT
18637	8977	16	President	President	NNP
18637	8977	17	and	and	CC
18637	8977	18	at	at	IN
18637	8977	19	the	the	DT
18637	8977	20	same	same	JJ
18637	8977	21	time	time	NN
18637	8977	22	brought	bring	VBD
18637	8977	23	the	the	DT
18637	8977	24	whole	whole	JJ
18637	8977	25	subject	subject	NN
18637	8977	26	of	of	IN
18637	8977	27	military	military	JJ
18637	8977	28	arrests	arrest	NNS
18637	8977	29	in	in	IN
18637	8977	30	the	the	DT
18637	8977	31	United	United	NNP
18637	8977	32	States	States	NNP
18637	8977	33	under	under	IN
18637	8977	34	legal	legal	JJ
18637	8977	35	control	control	NN
18637	8977	36	.	.	.
18637	8978	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8978	2	436	436	CD
18637	8978	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8978	4	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	8978	5	,	,	,
18637	8978	6	when	when	WRB
18637	8978	7	President	President	NNP
18637	8978	8	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	8978	9	failed	fail	VBD
18637	8978	10	in	in	IN
18637	8978	11	March	March	NNP
18637	8978	12	1917	1917	CD
18637	8978	13	to	to	TO
18637	8978	14	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	8978	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8978	16	's	's	POS
18637	8978	17	consent	consent	NN
18637	8978	18	to	to	IN
18637	8978	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8978	20	arming	arm	VBG
18637	8978	21	American	american	JJ
18637	8978	22	merchant	merchant	NN
18637	8978	23	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	8978	24	with	with	IN
18637	8978	25	defensive	defensive	JJ
18637	8978	26	arms	arm	NNS
18637	8978	27	,	,	,
18637	8978	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8978	29	went	go	VBD
18637	8978	30	ahead	ahead	RB
18637	8978	31	and	and	CC
18637	8978	32	did	do	VBD
18637	8978	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8978	34	anyway	anyway	RB
18637	8978	35	,	,	,
18637	8978	36	"	"	``
18637	8978	37	fortified	fortify	VBD
18637	8978	38	not	not	RB
18637	8978	39	only	only	RB
18637	8978	40	by	by	IN
18637	8978	41	the	the	DT
18637	8978	42	known	know	VBN
18637	8978	43	sentiments	sentiment	NNS
18637	8978	44	of	of	IN
18637	8978	45	the	the	DT
18637	8978	46	majority	majority	NN
18637	8978	47	in	in	IN
18637	8978	48	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8978	49	but	but	CC
18637	8978	50	also	also	RB
18637	8978	51	by	by	IN
18637	8978	52	the	the	DT
18637	8978	53	advice	advice	NN
18637	8978	54	of	of	IN
18637	8978	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8978	56	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	8978	57	of	of	IN
18637	8978	58	State	State	NNP
18637	8978	59	and	and	CC
18637	8978	60	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8978	61	General	General	NNP
18637	8978	62	.	.	.
18637	8979	1	"	"	``
18637	8979	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8979	3	437	437	CD
18637	8979	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8979	5	On	on	IN
18637	8979	6	the	the	DT
18637	8979	7	specific	specific	JJ
18637	8979	8	matter	matter	NN
18637	8979	9	of	of	IN
18637	8979	10	property	property	NN
18637	8979	11	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	8979	12	,	,	,
18637	8979	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8979	14	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	8979	15	's	's	POS
18637	8979	16	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	8979	17	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8979	18	in	in	IN
18637	8979	19	the	the	DT
18637	8979	20	Youngstown	Youngstown	NNP
18637	8979	21	Case	Case	NNP
18637	8979	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	8979	23	accompanied	accompany	VBN
18637	8979	24	by	by	IN
18637	8979	25	appendices	appendix	NNS
18637	8979	26	containing	contain	VBG
18637	8979	27	a	a	DT
18637	8979	28	synoptic	synoptic	JJ
18637	8979	29	analysis	analysis	NN
18637	8979	30	of	of	IN
18637	8979	31	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	8979	32	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	8979	33	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	8979	34	of	of	IN
18637	8979	35	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	8979	36	property	property	NN
18637	8979	37	and	and	CC
18637	8979	38	also	also	RB
18637	8979	39	a	a	DT
18637	8979	40	summary	summary	NN
18637	8979	41	of	of	IN
18637	8979	42	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	8979	43	of	of	IN
18637	8979	44	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	8979	45	plants	plant	NNS
18637	8979	46	and	and	CC
18637	8979	47	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	8979	48	by	by	IN
18637	8979	49	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	8979	50	without	without	IN
18637	8979	51	definite	definite	JJ
18637	8979	52	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	8979	53	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	8979	54	.	.	.
18637	8980	1	Eighteen	eighteen	CD
18637	8980	2	such	such	JJ
18637	8980	3	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	8980	4	are	be	VBP
18637	8980	5	listed	list	VBN
18637	8980	6	,	,	,
18637	8980	7	all	all	DT
18637	8980	8	but	but	IN
18637	8980	9	the	the	DT
18637	8980	10	first	first	JJ
18637	8980	11	of	of	IN
18637	8980	12	which	which	WDT
18637	8980	13	were	be	VBD
18637	8980	14	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	8980	15	between	between	IN
18637	8980	16	1916	1916	CD
18637	8980	17	and	and	CC
18637	8980	18	1951	1951	CD
18637	8980	19	.	.	.
18637	8981	1	Of	of	IN
18637	8981	2	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8981	3	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	8981	4	unsupported	unsupporte	VBN
18637	8981	5	by	by	IN
18637	8981	6	reference	reference	NN
18637	8981	7	to	to	IN
18637	8981	8	specific	specific	JJ
18637	8981	9	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	8981	10	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	8981	11	,	,	,
18637	8981	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8981	13	lists	list	VBZ
18637	8981	14	eight	eight	CD
18637	8981	15	as	as	RB
18637	8981	16	occurring	occur	VBG
18637	8981	17	during	during	IN
18637	8981	18	World	World	NNP
18637	8981	19	War	War	NNP
18637	8981	20	I.	I.	NNP
18637	8982	1	To	to	TO
18637	8982	2	justify	justify	VB
18637	8982	3	these	these	DT
18637	8982	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8982	5	was	be	VBD
18637	8982	6	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	8982	7	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	8982	8	to	to	TO
18637	8982	9	refer	refer	VB
18637	8982	10	to	to	IN
18637	8982	11	"	"	``
18637	8982	12	the	the	DT
18637	8982	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8982	14	and	and	CC
18637	8982	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	8982	16	"	"	``
18637	8982	17	generally	generally	RB
18637	8982	18	.	.	.
18637	8983	1	For	for	IN
18637	8983	2	the	the	DT
18637	8983	3	World	World	NNP
18637	8983	4	War	War	NNP
18637	8983	5	II	II	NNP
18637	8983	6	period	period	NN
18637	8983	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8983	8	lists	list	VBZ
18637	8983	9	eleven	eleven	CD
18637	8983	10	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	8983	11	in	in	IN
18637	8983	12	justification	justification	NN
18637	8983	13	of	of	IN
18637	8983	14	which	which	WDT
18637	8983	15	no	no	DT
18637	8983	16	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	8983	17	authority	authority	NN
18637	8983	18	was	be	VBD
18637	8983	19	cited	cite	VBN
18637	8983	20	.	.	.
18637	8984	1	The	the	DT
18637	8984	2	first	first	JJ
18637	8984	3	of	of	IN
18637	8984	4	these	these	DT
18637	8984	5	was	be	VBD
18637	8984	6	the	the	DT
18637	8984	7	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	8984	8	of	of	IN
18637	8984	9	the	the	DT
18637	8984	10	North	North	NNP
18637	8984	11	American	American	NNP
18637	8984	12	Aviation	Aviation	NNP
18637	8984	13	,	,	,
18637	8984	14	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	8984	15	,	,	,
18637	8984	16	of	of	IN
18637	8984	17	Englewood	Englewood	NNP
18637	8984	18	,	,	,
18637	8984	19	California	California	NNP
18637	8984	20	.	.	.
18637	8985	1	In	in	IN
18637	8985	2	support	support	NN
18637	8985	3	of	of	IN
18637	8985	4	this	this	DT
18637	8985	5	action	action	NN
18637	8985	6	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8985	7	General	General	NNP
18637	8985	8	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	8985	9	,	,	,
18637	8985	10	as	as	IN
18637	8985	11	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8985	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8985	13	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	8985	14	points	point	VBZ
18637	8985	15	out	out	RP
18637	8985	16	in	in	IN
18637	8985	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8985	18	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	8985	19	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8985	20	,	,	,
18637	8985	21	"	"	''
18637	8985	22	vigorously	vigorously	RB
18637	8985	23	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
18637	8985	24	that	that	IN
18637	8985	25	the	the	DT
18637	8985	26	President	President	NNP
18637	8985	27	had	have	VBD
18637	8985	28	the	the	DT
18637	8985	29	moral	moral	JJ
18637	8985	30	duty	duty	NN
18637	8985	31	to	to	TO
18637	8985	32	keep	keep	VB
18637	8985	33	this	this	DT
18637	8985	34	nation	nation	NN
18637	8985	35	's	's	POS
18637	8985	36	defense	defense	NN
18637	8985	37	effort	effort	NN
18637	8985	38	a	a	DT
18637	8985	39	'	'	``
18637	8985	40	going	go	VBG
18637	8985	41	concern	concern	NN
18637	8985	42	.	.	.
18637	8986	1	'	'	``
18637	8986	2	"	"	``
18637	8986	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8986	4	438	438	CD
18637	8986	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8986	6	Said	say	VBD
18637	8986	7	the	the	DT
18637	8986	8	then	then	RB
18637	8986	9	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8986	10	General	General	NNP
18637	8986	11	,	,	,
18637	8986	12	"	"	``
18637	8986	13	The	the	DT
18637	8986	14	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8986	15	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	8986	16	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	8986	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	8986	18	the	the	DT
18637	8986	19	aggregate	aggregate	NN
18637	8986	20	of	of	IN
18637	8986	21	the	the	DT
18637	8986	22	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8986	23	powers	power	NNS
18637	8986	24	derived	derive	VBN
18637	8986	25	from	from	IN
18637	8986	26	the	the	DT
18637	8986	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8986	28	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8986	29	and	and	CC
18637	8986	30	from	from	IN
18637	8986	31	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	8986	32	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	8986	33	by	by	IN
18637	8986	34	the	the	DT
18637	8986	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8986	36	.	.	.
18637	8987	1	The	the	DT
18637	8987	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8987	3	lays	lay	VBZ
18637	8987	4	upon	upon	IN
18637	8987	5	the	the	DT
18637	8987	6	President	President	NNP
18637	8987	7	the	the	DT
18637	8987	8	duty	duty	NN
18637	8987	9	'	'	``
18637	8987	10	to	to	TO
18637	8987	11	take	take	VB
18637	8987	12	care	care	NN
18637	8987	13	that	that	IN
18637	8987	14	the	the	DT
18637	8987	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	8987	16	be	be	VB
18637	8987	17	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	8987	18	executed	execute	VBN
18637	8987	19	.	.	.
18637	8987	20	'	'	''
18637	8988	1	Among	among	IN
18637	8988	2	the	the	DT
18637	8988	3	laws	law	NNS
18637	8988	4	which	which	WDT
18637	8988	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8988	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	8988	7	required	require	VBN
18637	8988	8	to	to	TO
18637	8988	9	find	find	VB
18637	8988	10	means	mean	NNS
18637	8988	11	to	to	TO
18637	8988	12	execute	execute	VB
18637	8988	13	are	be	VBP
18637	8988	14	those	those	DT
18637	8988	15	which	which	WDT
18637	8988	16	direct	direct	VBP
18637	8988	17	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8988	18	to	to	TO
18637	8988	19	equip	equip	VB
18637	8988	20	an	an	DT
18637	8988	21	enlarged	enlarged	JJ
18637	8988	22	army	army	NN
18637	8988	23	,	,	,
18637	8988	24	to	to	TO
18637	8988	25	provide	provide	VB
18637	8988	26	for	for	IN
18637	8988	27	a	a	DT
18637	8988	28	strengthened	strengthen	VBN
18637	8988	29	navy	navy	NN
18637	8988	30	,	,	,
18637	8988	31	to	to	TO
18637	8988	32	protect	protect	VB
18637	8988	33	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8988	34	property	property	NN
18637	8988	35	,	,	,
18637	8988	36	to	to	TO
18637	8988	37	protect	protect	VB
18637	8988	38	those	those	DT
18637	8988	39	who	who	WP
18637	8988	40	are	be	VBP
18637	8988	41	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	8988	42	in	in	IN
18637	8988	43	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	8988	44	out	out	RP
18637	8988	45	the	the	DT
18637	8988	46	business	business	NN
18637	8988	47	of	of	IN
18637	8988	48	the	the	DT
18637	8988	49	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8988	50	,	,	,
18637	8988	51	and	and	CC
18637	8988	52	to	to	TO
18637	8988	53	carry	carry	VB
18637	8988	54	out	out	RP
18637	8988	55	the	the	DT
18637	8988	56	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	8988	57	of	of	IN
18637	8988	58	the	the	DT
18637	8988	59	Lend	Lend	NNP
18637	8988	60	-	-	HYPH
18637	8988	61	Lease	Lease	NNP
18637	8988	62	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8988	63	.	.	.
18637	8989	1	For	for	IN
18637	8989	2	the	the	DT
18637	8989	3	faithful	faithful	JJ
18637	8989	4	execution	execution	NN
18637	8989	5	of	of	IN
18637	8989	6	such	such	JJ
18637	8989	7	laws	law	NNS
18637	8989	8	the	the	DT
18637	8989	9	President	President	NNP
18637	8989	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	8989	11	back	back	RB
18637	8989	12	of	of	IN
18637	8989	13	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8989	14	not	not	RB
18637	8989	15	only	only	RB
18637	8989	16	each	each	DT
18637	8989	17	general	general	JJ
18637	8989	18	law	law	NN
18637	8989	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	8989	20	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	8989	21	power	power	NN
18637	8989	22	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	8989	23	by	by	IN
18637	8989	24	the	the	DT
18637	8989	25	various	various	JJ
18637	8989	26	acts	act	NNS
18637	8989	27	of	of	IN
18637	8989	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8989	29	but	but	CC
18637	8989	30	the	the	DT
18637	8989	31	aggregate	aggregate	NN
18637	8989	32	of	of	IN
18637	8989	33	all	all	DT
18637	8989	34	such	such	JJ
18637	8989	35	laws	law	NNS
18637	8989	36	plus	plus	CC
18637	8989	37	that	that	DT
18637	8989	38	wide	wide	JJ
18637	8989	39	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	8989	40	as	as	IN
18637	8989	41	to	to	TO
18637	8989	42	method	method	VB
18637	8989	43	vested	vest	VBN
18637	8989	44	in	in	IN
18637	8989	45	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8989	46	by	by	IN
18637	8989	47	the	the	DT
18637	8989	48	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	8989	49	for	for	IN
18637	8989	50	the	the	DT
18637	8989	51	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8989	52	of	of	IN
18637	8989	53	executing	execute	VBG
18637	8989	54	the	the	DT
18637	8989	55	laws	law	NNS
18637	8989	56	.	.	.
18637	8990	1	"	"	``
18637	8990	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8990	3	439	439	CD
18637	8990	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8990	5	In	in	IN
18637	8990	6	the	the	DT
18637	8990	7	War	War	NNP
18637	8990	8	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	8990	9	Disputes	Disputes	NNP
18637	8990	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	8990	11	of	of	IN
18637	8990	12	June	June	NNP
18637	8990	13	25	25	CD
18637	8990	14	,	,	,
18637	8990	15	1943,[440	1943,[440	CD
18637	8990	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8990	17	such	such	JJ
18637	8990	18	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	8990	19	were	be	VBD
18637	8990	20	put	put	VBN
18637	8990	21	on	on	IN
18637	8990	22	a	a	DT
18637	8990	23	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	8990	24	basis	basis	NN
18637	8990	25	.	.	.
18637	8991	1	As	as	IN
18637	8991	2	the	the	DT
18637	8991	3	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	8991	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8991	5	points	point	VBZ
18637	8991	6	out	out	RP
18637	8991	7	,	,	,
18637	8991	8	the	the	DT
18637	8991	9	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	8991	10	of	of	IN
18637	8991	11	this	this	DT
18637	8991	12	measure	measure	NN
18637	8991	13	,	,	,
18637	8991	14	as	as	IN
18637	8991	15	stated	state	VBN
18637	8991	16	by	by	IN
18637	8991	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8991	18	sponsor	sponsor	NN
18637	8991	19	,	,	,
18637	8991	20	was	be	VBD
18637	8991	21	not	not	RB
18637	8991	22	to	to	TO
18637	8991	23	augment	augment	VB
18637	8991	24	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	8991	25	power	power	NN
18637	8991	26	but	but	CC
18637	8991	27	to	to	TO
18637	8991	28	"	"	``
18637	8991	29	let	let	VB
18637	8991	30	the	the	DT
18637	8991	31	country	country	NN
18637	8991	32	know	know	VB
18637	8991	33	that	that	IN
18637	8991	34	the	the	DT
18637	8991	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8991	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	8991	37	squarely	squarely	RB
18637	8991	38	behind	behind	IN
18637	8991	39	the	the	DT
18637	8991	40	President	President	NNP
18637	8991	41	.	.	.
18637	8992	1	"	"	``
18637	8992	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8992	3	441	441	CD
18637	8992	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8992	5	In	in	IN
18637	8992	6	United	United	NNP
18637	8992	7	States	States	NNP
18637	8992	8	_	_	NNP
18637	8992	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	8992	10	_	_	NNP
18637	8992	11	Pewee	Pewee	NNP
18637	8992	12	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	8992	13	Company	Company	NNP
18637	8992	14	,	,	,
18637	8992	15	Inc.[442	inc.[442	LS
18637	8992	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8992	17	the	the	DT
18637	8992	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8992	19	had	have	VBD
18637	8992	20	before	before	IN
18637	8992	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8992	22	the	the	DT
18637	8992	23	claim	claim	NN
18637	8992	24	of	of	IN
18637	8992	25	a	a	DT
18637	8992	26	coal	coal	NN
18637	8992	27	mine	mine	NN
18637	8992	28	operator	operator	NN
18637	8992	29	whose	whose	WP$
18637	8992	30	property	property	NN
18637	8992	31	was	be	VBD
18637	8992	32	seized	seize	VBN
18637	8992	33	by	by	IN
18637	8992	34	the	the	DT
18637	8992	35	President	President	NNP
18637	8992	36	without	without	IN
18637	8992	37	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	8992	38	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	8992	39	,	,	,
18637	8992	40	"	"	''
18637	8992	41	to	to	TO
18637	8992	42	avert	avert	VB
18637	8992	43	a	a	DT
18637	8992	44	nation	nation	NN
18637	8992	45	-	-	HYPH
18637	8992	46	wide	wide	JJ
18637	8992	47	strike	strike	NN
18637	8992	48	of	of	IN
18637	8992	49	miners	miner	NNS
18637	8992	50	.	.	.
18637	8992	51	"	"	''
18637	8993	1	The	the	DT
18637	8993	2	company	company	NN
18637	8993	3	brought	bring	VBD
18637	8993	4	an	an	DT
18637	8993	5	action	action	NN
18637	8993	6	in	in	IN
18637	8993	7	the	the	DT
18637	8993	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8993	9	of	of	IN
18637	8993	10	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	8993	11	to	to	TO
18637	8993	12	recover	recover	VB
18637	8993	13	under	under	IN
18637	8993	14	the	the	DT
18637	8993	15	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	8993	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	8993	17	for	for	IN
18637	8993	18	the	the	DT
18637	8993	19	total	total	JJ
18637	8993	20	operating	operating	NN
18637	8993	21	losses	loss	NNS
18637	8993	22	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	8993	23	during	during	IN
18637	8993	24	the	the	DT
18637	8993	25	period	period	NN
18637	8993	26	in	in	IN
18637	8993	27	which	which	WDT
18637	8993	28	this	this	DT
18637	8993	29	property	property	NN
18637	8993	30	was	be	VBD
18637	8993	31	operated	operate	VBN
18637	8993	32	by	by	IN
18637	8993	33	the	the	DT
18637	8993	34	United	United	NNP
18637	8993	35	States	States	NNP
18637	8993	36	.	.	.
18637	8994	1	The	the	DT
18637	8994	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8994	3	awarded	award	VBD
18637	8994	4	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8994	5	for	for	IN
18637	8994	6	$	$	$
18637	8994	7	2,241.46	2,241.46	CD
18637	8994	8	and	and	CC
18637	8994	9	the	the	DT
18637	8994	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	8994	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	8994	12	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	8994	13	this	this	DT
18637	8994	14	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	8994	15	,	,	,
18637	8994	16	a	a	DT
18637	8994	17	result	result	NN
18637	8994	18	which	which	WDT
18637	8994	19	implied	imply	VBD
18637	8994	20	the	the	DT
18637	8994	21	validity	validity	NN
18637	8994	22	of	of	IN
18637	8994	23	the	the	DT
18637	8994	24	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	8994	25	.	.	.
18637	8995	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	8995	2	443	443	CD
18637	8995	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8995	4	Said	say	VBD
18637	8995	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8995	6	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	8995	7	,	,	,
18637	8995	8	in	in	IN
18637	8995	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8995	10	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	8995	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	8995	12	of	of	IN
18637	8995	13	the	the	DT
18637	8995	14	case	case	NN
18637	8995	15	:	:	:
18637	8995	16	"	"	``
18637	8995	17	The	the	DT
18637	8995	18	relatively	relatively	RB
18637	8995	19	new	new	JJ
18637	8995	20	technique	technique	NN
18637	8995	21	of	of	IN
18637	8995	22	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	8995	23	taking	taking	NN
18637	8995	24	by	by	IN
18637	8995	25	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	8995	26	domain	domain	NN
18637	8995	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	8995	28	a	a	DT
18637	8995	29	most	most	RBS
18637	8995	30	useful	useful	JJ
18637	8995	31	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	8995	32	device	device	NN
18637	8995	33	:	:	:
18637	8995	34	many	many	JJ
18637	8995	35	properties	property	NNS
18637	8995	36	,	,	,
18637	8995	37	such	such	JJ
18637	8995	38	as	as	IN
18637	8995	39	laundries	laundry	NNS
18637	8995	40	,	,	,
18637	8995	41	or	or	CC
18637	8995	42	coal	coal	NN
18637	8995	43	mines	mine	NNS
18637	8995	44	,	,	,
18637	8995	45	or	or	CC
18637	8995	46	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	8995	47	,	,	,
18637	8995	48	may	may	MD
18637	8995	49	be	be	VB
18637	8995	50	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	8995	51	to	to	IN
18637	8995	52	public	public	JJ
18637	8995	53	operation	operation	NN
18637	8995	54	only	only	RB
18637	8995	55	for	for	IN
18637	8995	56	a	a	DT
18637	8995	57	short	short	JJ
18637	8995	58	time	time	NN
18637	8995	59	to	to	TO
18637	8995	60	meet	meet	VB
18637	8995	61	war	war	NN
18637	8995	62	or	or	CC
18637	8995	63	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	8995	64	needs	need	VBZ
18637	8995	65	,	,	,
18637	8995	66	and	and	CC
18637	8995	67	can	can	MD
18637	8995	68	then	then	RB
18637	8995	69	be	be	VB
18637	8995	70	returned	return	VBN
18637	8995	71	to	to	IN
18637	8995	72	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	8995	73	owners	owner	NNS
18637	8995	74	.	.	.
18637	8995	75	"	"	''
18637	8996	1	The	the	DT
18637	8996	2	implications	implication	NNS
18637	8996	3	of	of	IN
18637	8996	4	United	United	NNP
18637	8996	5	States	States	NNP
18637	8996	6	_	_	NNP
18637	8996	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	8996	8	_	_	NNP
18637	8996	9	Pewee	Pewee	NNP
18637	8996	10	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	8996	11	Company	Company	NNP
18637	8996	12	,	,	,
18637	8996	13	Inc	Inc	NNP
18637	8996	14	.	.	.
18637	8996	15	,[444	,[444	NFP
18637	8996	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	8996	17	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	8996	18	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	8996	19	the	the	DT
18637	8996	20	Government	Government	NNP
18637	8996	21	in	in	IN
18637	8996	22	Youngstown	Youngstown	NNP
18637	8996	23	,	,	,
18637	8996	24	assuming	assume	VBG
18637	8996	25	that	that	IN
18637	8996	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	8996	27	had	have	VBD
18637	8996	28	not	not	RB
18637	8996	29	acted	act	VBN
18637	8996	30	in	in	IN
18637	8996	31	the	the	DT
18637	8996	32	latter	latter	JJ
18637	8996	33	case	case	NN
18637	8996	34	.	.	.
18637	8997	1	And	and	CC
18637	8997	2	one	one	CD
18637	8997	3	instance	instance	NN
18637	8997	4	of	of	IN
18637	8997	5	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	8997	6	by	by	IN
18637	8997	7	executive	executive	JJ
18637	8997	8	order	order	NN
18637	8997	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	8997	10	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	8997	11	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	8997	12	to	to	TO
18637	8997	13	mention	mention	VB
18637	8997	14	.	.	.
18637	8998	1	This	this	DT
18637	8998	2	was	be	VBD
18637	8998	3	the	the	DT
18637	8998	4	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	8998	5	by	by	IN
18637	8998	6	President	President	NNP
18637	8998	7	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	8998	8	in	in	IN
18637	8998	9	the	the	DT
18637	8998	10	late	late	JJ
18637	8998	11	summer	summer	NN
18637	8998	12	of	of	IN
18637	8998	13	1914	1914	CD
18637	8998	14	,	,	,
18637	8998	15	following	follow	VBG
18637	8998	16	the	the	DT
18637	8998	17	outbreak	outbreak	NN
18637	8998	18	of	of	IN
18637	8998	19	war	war	NN
18637	8998	20	in	in	IN
18637	8998	21	Europe	Europe	NNP
18637	8998	22	,	,	,
18637	8998	23	of	of	IN
18637	8998	24	the	the	DT
18637	8998	25	Marconi	Marconi	NNP
18637	8998	26	Wireless	Wireless	NNP
18637	8998	27	Station	Station	NNP
18637	8998	28	at	at	IN
18637	8998	29	Siasconset	siasconset	NN
18637	8998	30	when	when	WRB
18637	8998	31	the	the	DT
18637	8998	32	Company	company	NN
18637	8998	33	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	8998	34	assurance	assurance	NN
18637	8998	35	that	that	IN
18637	8998	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	8998	37	would	would	MD
18637	8998	38	comply	comply	VB
18637	8998	39	with	with	IN
18637	8998	40	naval	naval	JJ
18637	8998	41	censorship	censorship	NN
18637	8998	42	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	8998	43	.	.	.
18637	8999	1	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	8999	2	General	General	NNP
18637	8999	3	Gregory	Gregory	NNP
18637	8999	4	's	's	POS
18637	8999	5	justification	justification	NN
18637	8999	6	of	of	IN
18637	8999	7	this	this	DT
18637	8999	8	action	action	NN
18637	8999	9	at	at	IN
18637	8999	10	the	the	DT
18637	8999	11	time	time	NN
18637	8999	12	was	be	VBD
18637	8999	13	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	8999	14	on	on	IN
18637	8999	15	an	an	DT
18637	8999	16	earlier	early	JJR
18637	8999	17	page	page	NN
18637	8999	18	.	.	.
18637	9000	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9000	2	445	445	CD
18637	9000	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9000	4	The	the	DT
18637	9000	5	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	9000	6	dictated	dictate	VBN
18637	9000	7	by	by	IN
18637	9000	8	the	the	DT
18637	9000	9	above	above	JJ
18637	9000	10	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	9000	11	as	as	IN
18637	9000	12	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	9000	13	the	the	DT
18637	9000	14	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	9000	15	of	of	IN
18637	9000	16	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9000	17	power	power	NN
18637	9000	18	in	in	IN
18637	9000	19	the	the	DT
18637	9000	20	field	field	NN
18637	9000	21	of	of	IN
18637	9000	22	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	9000	23	power	power	NN
18637	9000	24	was	be	VBD
18637	9000	25	well	well	RB
18637	9000	26	stated	state	VBN
18637	9000	27	by	by	IN
18637	9000	28	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	9000	29	John	John	NNP
18637	9000	30	W.	W.	NNP
18637	9000	31	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	9000	32	,	,	,
18637	9000	33	principal	principal	JJ
18637	9000	34	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	9000	35	on	on	IN
18637	9000	36	the	the	DT
18637	9000	37	present	present	JJ
18637	9000	38	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	9000	39	for	for	IN
18637	9000	40	the	the	DT
18637	9000	41	steel	steel	NN
18637	9000	42	companies	company	NNS
18637	9000	43	,	,	,
18637	9000	44	in	in	IN
18637	9000	45	a	a	DT
18637	9000	46	brief	brief	NN
18637	9000	47	which	which	WDT
18637	9000	48	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9000	49	filed	file	VBD
18637	9000	50	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	9000	51	forty	forty	CD
18637	9000	52	years	year	NNS
18637	9000	53	ago	ago	RB
18637	9000	54	as	as	IN
18637	9000	55	Solicitor	Solicitor	NNP
18637	9000	56	General	General	NNP
18637	9000	57	,	,	,
18637	9000	58	in	in	IN
18637	9000	59	defense	defense	NN
18637	9000	60	of	of	IN
18637	9000	61	the	the	DT
18637	9000	62	action	action	NN
18637	9000	63	of	of	IN
18637	9000	64	the	the	DT
18637	9000	65	President	President	NNP
18637	9000	66	in	in	IN
18637	9000	67	withdrawing	withdraw	VBG
18637	9000	68	certain	certain	JJ
18637	9000	69	lands	land	NNS
18637	9000	70	from	from	IN
18637	9000	71	public	public	JJ
18637	9000	72	entry	entry	NN
18637	9000	73	although	although	IN
18637	9000	74	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9000	75	doing	do	VBG
18637	9000	76	so	so	RB
18637	9000	77	was	be	VBD
18637	9000	78	at	at	IN
18637	9000	79	the	the	DT
18637	9000	80	time	time	NN
18637	9000	81	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	9000	82	to	to	TO
18637	9000	83	express	express	VB
18637	9000	84	statute	statute	NN
18637	9000	85	.	.	.
18637	9001	1	"	"	``
18637	9001	2	Ours	our	NNS
18637	9001	3	,	,	,
18637	9001	4	"	"	''
18637	9001	5	the	the	DT
18637	9001	6	brief	brief	NN
18637	9001	7	reads	read	VBZ
18637	9001	8	,	,	,
18637	9001	9	"	"	``
18637	9001	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	9001	11	a	a	DT
18637	9001	12	self	self	NN
18637	9001	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	9001	14	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	9001	15	Government	government	NN
18637	9001	16	within	within	IN
18637	9001	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9001	18	sphere	sphere	NN
18637	9001	19	.	.	.
18637	9002	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9002	2	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	9002	3	parte	parte	NN
18637	9002	4	Siebold	Siebold	NNP
18637	9002	5	,	,	,
18637	9002	6	100	100	CD
18637	9002	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9002	8	371	371	CD
18637	9002	9	,	,	,
18637	9002	10	395	395	CD
18637	9002	11	;	;	:
18637	9002	12	in	in	IN
18637	9002	13	re	re	NN
18637	9002	14	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	9002	15	,	,	,
18637	9002	16	158	158	CD
18637	9002	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9002	18	564	564	CD
18637	9002	19	,	,	,
18637	9002	20	578	578	CD
18637	9002	21	.	.	.
18637	9002	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9003	1	'	'	``
18637	9003	2	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9003	3	means	mean	NNS
18637	9003	4	are	be	VBP
18637	9003	5	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	9003	6	to	to	IN
18637	9003	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9003	8	ends	end	NNS
18637	9003	9	'	'	''
18637	9003	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9003	11	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	9003	12	_	_	NNP
18637	9003	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	9003	14	_	_	NNP
18637	9003	15	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	9003	16	,	,	,
18637	9003	17	4	4	CD
18637	9003	18	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	9003	19	.	.	.
18637	9004	1	316	316	CD
18637	9004	2	,	,	,
18637	9004	3	424	424	CD
18637	9004	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9004	5	,	,	,
18637	9004	6	and	and	CC
18637	9004	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9004	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	9004	9	rational	rational	JJ
18637	9004	10	to	to	TO
18637	9004	11	assume	assume	VB
18637	9004	12	that	that	IN
18637	9004	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9004	14	active	active	JJ
18637	9004	15	forces	force	NNS
18637	9004	16	will	will	MD
18637	9004	17	be	be	VB
18637	9004	18	found	find	VBN
18637	9004	19	equal	equal	JJ
18637	9004	20	in	in	IN
18637	9004	21	most	most	JJS
18637	9004	22	things	thing	NNS
18637	9004	23	to	to	IN
18637	9004	24	the	the	DT
18637	9004	25	emergencies	emergency	NNS
18637	9004	26	that	that	WDT
18637	9004	27	confront	confront	VBP
18637	9004	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9004	29	.	.	.
18637	9005	1	While	while	IN
18637	9005	2	perfect	perfect	JJ
18637	9005	3	flexibility	flexibility	NN
18637	9005	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	9005	5	not	not	RB
18637	9005	6	to	to	TO
18637	9005	7	be	be	VB
18637	9005	8	expected	expect	VBN
18637	9005	9	in	in	IN
18637	9005	10	a	a	DT
18637	9005	11	Government	Government	NNP
18637	9005	12	of	of	IN
18637	9005	13	divided	divide	VBN
18637	9005	14	powers	power	NNS
18637	9005	15	,	,	,
18637	9005	16	and	and	CC
18637	9005	17	while	while	IN
18637	9005	18	division	division	NN
18637	9005	19	of	of	IN
18637	9005	20	power	power	NN
18637	9005	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	9005	22	one	one	CD
18637	9005	23	of	of	IN
18637	9005	24	the	the	DT
18637	9005	25	principal	principal	JJ
18637	9005	26	features	feature	NNS
18637	9005	27	of	of	IN
18637	9005	28	the	the	DT
18637	9005	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9005	30	,	,	,
18637	9005	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9005	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	9005	33	the	the	DT
18637	9005	34	plain	plain	JJ
18637	9005	35	duty	duty	NN
18637	9005	36	of	of	IN
18637	9005	37	those	those	DT
18637	9005	38	who	who	WP
18637	9005	39	are	be	VBP
18637	9005	40	called	call	VBN
18637	9005	41	upon	upon	IN
18637	9005	42	to	to	TO
18637	9005	43	draw	draw	VB
18637	9005	44	the	the	DT
18637	9005	45	dividing	divide	VBG
18637	9005	46	lines	line	NNS
18637	9005	47	to	to	TO
18637	9005	48	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	9005	49	the	the	DT
18637	9005	50	essential	essential	JJ
18637	9005	51	,	,	,
18637	9005	52	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	9005	53	the	the	DT
18637	9005	54	practical	practical	JJ
18637	9005	55	,	,	,
18637	9005	56	and	and	CC
18637	9005	57	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	9005	58	a	a	DT
18637	9005	59	slavish	slavish	JJ
18637	9005	60	formalism	formalism	NN
18637	9005	61	which	which	WDT
18637	9005	62	can	can	MD
18637	9005	63	only	only	RB
18637	9005	64	serve	serve	VB
18637	9005	65	to	to	TO
18637	9005	66	ossify	ossify	VB
18637	9005	67	the	the	DT
18637	9005	68	Government	Government	NNP
18637	9005	69	and	and	CC
18637	9005	70	reduce	reduce	VB
18637	9005	71	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9005	72	efficiency	efficiency	NN
18637	9005	73	without	without	IN
18637	9005	74	any	any	DT
18637	9005	75	compensating	compensating	JJ
18637	9005	76	good	good	NN
18637	9005	77	.	.	.
18637	9006	1	The	the	DT
18637	9006	2	function	function	NN
18637	9006	3	of	of	IN
18637	9006	4	making	make	VBG
18637	9006	5	laws	law	NNS
18637	9006	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	9006	7	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	9006	8	to	to	IN
18637	9006	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9006	10	,	,	,
18637	9006	11	and	and	CC
18637	9006	12	the	the	DT
18637	9006	13	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	9006	14	can	can	MD
18637	9006	15	not	not	RB
18637	9006	16	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	9006	17	that	that	DT
18637	9006	18	function	function	NN
18637	9006	19	to	to	IN
18637	9006	20	any	any	DT
18637	9006	21	degree	degree	NN
18637	9006	22	.	.	.
18637	9007	1	But	but	CC
18637	9007	2	this	this	DT
18637	9007	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	9007	4	not	not	RB
18637	9007	5	to	to	TO
18637	9007	6	say	say	VB
18637	9007	7	that	that	IN
18637	9007	8	all	all	DT
18637	9007	9	of	of	IN
18637	9007	10	the	the	DT
18637	9007	11	_	_	NNP
18637	9007	12	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	9007	13	_	_	NNP
18637	9007	14	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	9007	15	which	which	WDT
18637	9007	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	9007	17	might	may	MD
18637	9007	18	be	be	VB
18637	9007	19	made	make	VBN
18637	9007	20	are	be	VBP
18637	9007	21	perforce	perforce	NN
18637	9007	22	removed	remove	VBN
18637	9007	23	from	from	IN
18637	9007	24	the	the	DT
18637	9007	25	possibility	possibility	NN
18637	9007	26	of	of	IN
18637	9007	27	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	9007	28	influence	influence	NN
18637	9007	29	.	.	.
18637	9008	1	The	the	DT
18637	9008	2	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	9008	3	may	may	MD
18637	9008	4	act	act	VB
18637	9008	5	upon	upon	IN
18637	9008	6	things	thing	NNS
18637	9008	7	and	and	CC
18637	9008	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	9008	9	men	man	NNS
18637	9008	10	in	in	IN
18637	9008	11	many	many	JJ
18637	9008	12	relations	relation	NNS
18637	9008	13	which	which	WDT
18637	9008	14	have	have	VBP
18637	9008	15	not	not	RB
18637	9008	16	,	,	,
18637	9008	17	though	though	IN
18637	9008	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9008	19	might	may	MD
18637	9008	20	have	have	VB
18637	9008	21	,	,	,
18637	9008	22	been	be	VBN
18637	9008	23	actually	actually	RB
18637	9008	24	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	9008	25	by	by	IN
18637	9008	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9008	27	.	.	.
18637	9009	1	In	in	IN
18637	9009	2	other	other	JJ
18637	9009	3	words	word	NNS
18637	9009	4	,	,	,
18637	9009	5	just	just	RB
18637	9009	6	as	as	IN
18637	9009	7	there	there	EX
18637	9009	8	are	be	VBP
18637	9009	9	fields	field	NNS
18637	9009	10	which	which	WDT
18637	9009	11	are	be	VBP
18637	9009	12	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	9009	13	to	to	IN
18637	9009	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9009	15	and	and	CC
18637	9009	16	fields	field	NNS
18637	9009	17	which	which	WDT
18637	9009	18	are	be	VBP
18637	9009	19	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	9009	20	to	to	IN
18637	9009	21	the	the	DT
18637	9009	22	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	9009	23	,	,	,
18637	9009	24	so	so	CC
18637	9009	25	there	there	EX
18637	9009	26	are	be	VBP
18637	9009	27	fields	field	NNS
18637	9009	28	which	which	WDT
18637	9009	29	are	be	VBP
18637	9009	30	common	common	JJ
18637	9009	31	to	to	IN
18637	9009	32	both	both	DT
18637	9009	33	,	,	,
18637	9009	34	in	in	IN
18637	9009	35	the	the	DT
18637	9009	36	sense	sense	NN
18637	9009	37	that	that	IN
18637	9009	38	the	the	DT
18637	9009	39	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	9009	40	may	may	MD
18637	9009	41	move	move	VB
18637	9009	42	within	within	IN
18637	9009	43	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9009	44	until	until	IN
18637	9009	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9009	46	shall	shall	MD
18637	9009	47	have	have	VB
18637	9009	48	been	be	VBN
18637	9009	49	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	9009	50	by	by	IN
18637	9009	51	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	9009	52	action	action	NN
18637	9009	53	.	.	.
18637	9010	1	These	these	DT
18637	9010	2	are	be	VBP
18637	9010	3	not	not	RB
18637	9010	4	the	the	DT
18637	9010	5	fields	field	NNS
18637	9010	6	of	of	IN
18637	9010	7	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	9010	8	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	9010	9	,	,	,
18637	9010	10	but	but	CC
18637	9010	11	fields	field	NNS
18637	9010	12	within	within	IN
18637	9010	13	which	which	WDT
18637	9010	14	the	the	DT
18637	9010	15	lawmaking	lawmaking	NN
18637	9010	16	power	power	NN
18637	9010	17	may	may	MD
18637	9010	18	enter	enter	VB
18637	9010	19	and	and	CC
18637	9010	20	dominate	dominate	VB
18637	9010	21	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	9010	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9010	23	chooses	choose	VBZ
18637	9010	24	.	.	.
18637	9011	1	This	this	DT
18637	9011	2	situation	situation	NN
18637	9011	3	results	result	VBZ
18637	9011	4	from	from	IN
18637	9011	5	the	the	DT
18637	9011	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	9011	7	that	that	IN
18637	9011	8	the	the	DT
18637	9011	9	President	President	NNP
18637	9011	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	9011	11	the	the	DT
18637	9011	12	active	active	JJ
18637	9011	13	agent	agent	NN
18637	9011	14	,	,	,
18637	9011	15	not	not	RB
18637	9011	16	of	of	IN
18637	9011	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9011	18	,	,	,
18637	9011	19	but	but	CC
18637	9011	20	of	of	IN
18637	9011	21	the	the	DT
18637	9011	22	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	9011	23	.	.	.
18637	9012	1	As	as	IN
18637	9012	2	such	such	JJ
18637	9012	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9012	4	performs	perform	VBZ
18637	9012	5	the	the	DT
18637	9012	6	duties	duty	NNS
18637	9012	7	which	which	WDT
18637	9012	8	the	the	DT
18637	9012	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9012	10	lays	lay	VBZ
18637	9012	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	9012	12	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9012	13	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	9012	14	,	,	,
18637	9012	15	and	and	CC
18637	9012	16	as	as	IN
18637	9012	17	such	such	JJ
18637	9012	18	,	,	,
18637	9012	19	also	also	RB
18637	9012	20	,	,	,
18637	9012	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9012	22	executes	execute	VBZ
18637	9012	23	the	the	DT
18637	9012	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	9012	25	and	and	CC
18637	9012	26	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	9012	27	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	9012	28	by	by	IN
18637	9012	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9012	30	.	.	.
18637	9013	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9013	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	9013	3	the	the	DT
18637	9013	4	agent	agent	NN
18637	9013	5	of	of	IN
18637	9013	6	the	the	DT
18637	9013	7	people	people	NNS
18637	9013	8	of	of	IN
18637	9013	9	the	the	DT
18637	9013	10	United	United	NNP
18637	9013	11	States	States	NNP
18637	9013	12	,	,	,
18637	9013	13	deriving	derive	VBG
18637	9013	14	all	all	PDT
18637	9013	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9013	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	9013	17	from	from	IN
18637	9013	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9013	19	and	and	CC
18637	9013	20	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	9013	21	directly	directly	RB
18637	9013	22	to	to	IN
18637	9013	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9013	24	.	.	.
18637	9014	1	In	in	IN
18637	9014	2	no	no	DT
18637	9014	3	sense	sense	NN
18637	9014	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	9014	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9014	6	the	the	DT
18637	9014	7	agent	agent	NN
18637	9014	8	of	of	IN
18637	9014	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9014	10	.	.	.
18637	9015	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9015	2	obeys	obey	VBZ
18637	9015	3	and	and	CC
18637	9015	4	executes	execute	VBZ
18637	9015	5	the	the	DT
18637	9015	6	laws	law	NNS
18637	9015	7	of	of	IN
18637	9015	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9015	9	,	,	,
18637	9015	10	not	not	RB
18637	9015	11	because	because	IN
18637	9015	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9015	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	9015	14	enthroned	enthrone	VBN
18637	9015	15	in	in	IN
18637	9015	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	9015	17	over	over	IN
18637	9015	18	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9015	19	,	,	,
18637	9015	20	but	but	CC
18637	9015	21	because	because	IN
18637	9015	22	the	the	DT
18637	9015	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9015	24	directs	direct	VBZ
18637	9015	25	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9015	26	to	to	TO
18637	9015	27	do	do	VB
18637	9015	28	so	so	RB
18637	9015	29	.	.	.
18637	9016	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
18637	9016	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9016	3	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	9016	4	that	that	IN
18637	9016	5	in	in	IN
18637	9016	6	ways	way	NNS
18637	9016	7	short	short	RB
18637	9016	8	of	of	IN
18637	9016	9	making	make	VBG
18637	9016	10	laws	law	NNS
18637	9016	11	or	or	CC
18637	9016	12	disobeying	disobey	VBG
18637	9016	13	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9016	14	,	,	,
18637	9016	15	the	the	DT
18637	9016	16	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	9016	17	may	may	MD
18637	9016	18	be	be	VB
18637	9016	19	under	under	IN
18637	9016	20	a	a	DT
18637	9016	21	grave	grave	JJ
18637	9016	22	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	9016	23	duty	duty	NN
18637	9016	24	to	to	TO
18637	9016	25	act	act	VB
18637	9016	26	for	for	IN
18637	9016	27	the	the	DT
18637	9016	28	national	national	JJ
18637	9016	29	protection	protection	NN
18637	9016	30	in	in	IN
18637	9016	31	situations	situation	NNS
18637	9016	32	not	not	RB
18637	9016	33	covered	cover	VBN
18637	9016	34	by	by	IN
18637	9016	35	the	the	DT
18637	9016	36	acts	act	NNS
18637	9016	37	of	of	IN
18637	9016	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9016	39	,	,	,
18637	9016	40	and	and	CC
18637	9016	41	in	in	IN
18637	9016	42	which	which	WDT
18637	9016	43	,	,	,
18637	9016	44	even	even	RB
18637	9016	45	,	,	,
18637	9016	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9016	47	may	may	MD
18637	9016	48	not	not	RB
18637	9016	49	be	be	VB
18637	9016	50	said	say	VBN
18637	9016	51	that	that	IN
18637	9016	52	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9016	53	action	action	NN
18637	9016	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	9016	55	the	the	DT
18637	9016	56	direct	direct	JJ
18637	9016	57	expression	expression	NN
18637	9016	58	of	of	IN
18637	9016	59	any	any	DT
18637	9016	60	particular	particular	JJ
18637	9016	61	one	one	CD
18637	9016	62	of	of	IN
18637	9016	63	the	the	DT
18637	9016	64	independent	independent	JJ
18637	9016	65	powers	power	NNS
18637	9016	66	which	which	WDT
18637	9016	67	are	be	VBP
18637	9016	68	granted	grant	VBN
18637	9016	69	to	to	IN
18637	9016	70	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9016	71	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	9016	72	by	by	IN
18637	9016	73	the	the	DT
18637	9016	74	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9016	75	.	.	.
18637	9017	1	Instances	instance	NNS
18637	9017	2	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	9017	3	the	the	DT
18637	9017	4	President	President	NNP
18637	9017	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	9017	6	felt	feel	VBN
18637	9017	7	and	and	CC
18637	9017	8	fulfilled	fulfil	VBN
18637	9017	9	such	such	PDT
18637	9017	10	a	a	DT
18637	9017	11	duty	duty	NN
18637	9017	12	have	have	VBP
18637	9017	13	not	not	RB
18637	9017	14	been	be	VBN
18637	9017	15	rare	rare	JJ
18637	9017	16	in	in	IN
18637	9017	17	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9017	18	history	history	NN
18637	9017	19	,	,	,
18637	9017	20	though	though	RB
18637	9017	21	,	,	,
18637	9017	22	being	be	VBG
18637	9017	23	for	for	IN
18637	9017	24	the	the	DT
18637	9017	25	public	public	JJ
18637	9017	26	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	9017	27	and	and	CC
18637	9017	28	approved	approve	VBN
18637	9017	29	by	by	IN
18637	9017	30	all	all	DT
18637	9017	31	,	,	,
18637	9017	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9017	33	acts	act	NNS
18637	9017	34	have	have	VBP
18637	9017	35	seldom	seldom	RB
18637	9017	36	been	be	VBN
18637	9017	37	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	9017	38	in	in	IN
18637	9017	39	the	the	DT
18637	9017	40	courts	court	NNS
18637	9017	41	.	.	.
18637	9018	1	"	"	``
18637	9018	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9018	3	446	446	CD
18637	9018	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9018	5	Concurring	Concurring	NNP
18637	9018	6	Opinions	Opinions	NNPS
18637	9018	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9018	8	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	9018	9	begins	begin	VBZ
18637	9018	10	the	the	DT
18637	9018	11	material	material	JJ
18637	9018	12	part	part	NN
18637	9018	13	of	of	IN
18637	9018	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9018	15	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9018	16	with	with	IN
18637	9018	17	the	the	DT
18637	9018	18	statement	statement	NN
18637	9018	19	:	:	:
18637	9018	20	"	"	``
18637	9018	21	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9018	22	must	must	MD
18637	9018	23	*	*	NFP
18637	9018	24	*	*	NFP
18637	9018	25	*	*	NFP
18637	9018	26	put	put	VBD
18637	9018	27	to	to	IN
18637	9018	28	one	one	CD
18637	9018	29	side	side	NN
18637	9018	30	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	9018	31	of	of	IN
18637	9018	32	what	what	WP
18637	9018	33	powers	power	NNS
18637	9018	34	the	the	DT
18637	9018	35	President	President	NNP
18637	9018	36	would	would	MD
18637	9018	37	have	have	VB
18637	9018	38	had	have	VBN
18637	9018	39	if	if	IN
18637	9018	40	there	there	EX
18637	9018	41	had	have	VBD
18637	9018	42	been	be	VBN
18637	9018	43	no	no	DT
18637	9018	44	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	9018	45	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	9018	46	bearing	bear	VBG
18637	9018	47	on	on	IN
18637	9018	48	the	the	DT
18637	9018	49	authority	authority	NN
18637	9018	50	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	9018	51	by	by	IN
18637	9018	52	the	the	DT
18637	9018	53	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	9018	54	,	,	,
18637	9018	55	or	or	CC
18637	9018	56	if	if	IN
18637	9018	57	the	the	DT
18637	9018	58	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	9018	59	had	have	VBD
18637	9018	60	been	be	VBN
18637	9018	61	only	only	RB
18637	9018	62	for	for	IN
18637	9018	63	a	a	DT
18637	9018	64	short	short	JJ
18637	9018	65	,	,	,
18637	9018	66	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	9018	67	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	9018	68	period	period	NN
18637	9018	69	,	,	,
18637	9018	70	to	to	TO
18637	9018	71	be	be	VB
18637	9018	72	terminated	terminate	VBN
18637	9018	73	automatically	automatically	RB
18637	9018	74	unless	unless	IN
18637	9018	75	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	9018	76	approval	approval	NN
18637	9018	77	were	be	VBD
18637	9018	78	given	give	VBN
18637	9018	79	.	.	.
18637	9019	1	"	"	``
18637	9019	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9019	3	447	447	CD
18637	9019	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9019	5	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9019	6	then	then	RB
18637	9019	7	enters	enter	VBZ
18637	9019	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	9019	9	a	a	DT
18637	9019	10	review	review	NN
18637	9019	11	of	of	IN
18637	9019	12	the	the	DT
18637	9019	13	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	9019	14	of	of	IN
18637	9019	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9019	16	which	which	WDT
18637	9019	17	attended	attend	VBD
18637	9019	18	the	the	DT
18637	9019	19	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	9019	20	of	of	IN
18637	9019	21	the	the	DT
18637	9019	22	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	9019	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	9019	24	Hartley	Hartley	NNP
18637	9019	25	Act	Act	NNP
18637	9019	26	,	,	,
18637	9019	27	and	and	CC
18637	9019	28	concludes	conclude	VBZ
18637	9019	29	that	that	IN
18637	9019	30	"	"	``
18637	9019	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9019	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	9019	33	expressed	express	VBN
18637	9019	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9019	35	will	will	NN
18637	9019	36	to	to	TO
18637	9019	37	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	9019	38	this	this	DT
18637	9019	39	power	power	NN
18637	9019	40	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9019	41	of	of	IN
18637	9019	42	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	9019	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9019	44	from	from	IN
18637	9019	45	the	the	DT
18637	9019	46	President	President	NNP
18637	9019	47	as	as	IN
18637	9019	48	though	though	IN
18637	9019	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9019	50	had	have	VBD
18637	9019	51	said	say	VBN
18637	9019	52	so	so	RB
18637	9019	53	in	in	IN
18637	9019	54	so	so	RB
18637	9019	55	many	many	JJ
18637	9019	56	words	word	NNS
18637	9019	57	.	.	.
18637	9020	1	"	"	``
18637	9020	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9020	3	448	448	CD
18637	9020	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9020	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9020	6	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	9020	7	's	's	POS
18637	9020	8	contribution	contribution	NN
18637	9020	9	consists	consist	VBZ
18637	9020	10	in	in	IN
18637	9020	11	the	the	DT
18637	9020	12	argument	argument	NN
18637	9020	13	that	that	WDT
18637	9020	14	:	:	:
18637	9020	15	"	"	``
18637	9020	16	The	the	DT
18637	9020	17	branch	branch	NN
18637	9020	18	of	of	IN
18637	9020	19	government	government	NN
18637	9020	20	that	that	WDT
18637	9020	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	9020	22	the	the	DT
18637	9020	23	power	power	NN
18637	9020	24	to	to	TO
18637	9020	25	pay	pay	VB
18637	9020	26	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	9020	27	for	for	IN
18637	9020	28	a	a	DT
18637	9020	29	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	9020	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	9020	31	the	the	DT
18637	9020	32	only	only	JJ
18637	9020	33	one	one	NN
18637	9020	34	able	able	JJ
18637	9020	35	to	to	TO
18637	9020	36	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	9020	37	a	a	DT
18637	9020	38	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	9020	39	or	or	CC
18637	9020	40	make	make	VB
18637	9020	41	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	9020	42	one	one	NN
18637	9020	43	that	that	WDT
18637	9020	44	the	the	DT
18637	9020	45	President	President	NNP
18637	9020	46	has	have	VBZ
18637	9020	47	effected	effect	VBN
18637	9020	48	.	.	.
18637	9021	1	That	that	DT
18637	9021	2	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	9021	3	to	to	IN
18637	9021	4	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9021	5	to	to	TO
18637	9021	6	be	be	VB
18637	9021	7	the	the	DT
18637	9021	8	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	9021	9	result	result	NN
18637	9021	10	of	of	IN
18637	9021	11	the	the	DT
18637	9021	12	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	9021	13	provision	provision	NN
18637	9021	14	in	in	IN
18637	9021	15	the	the	DT
18637	9021	16	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	9021	17	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	9021	18	.	.	.
18637	9022	1	"	"	``
18637	9022	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9022	3	449	449	CD
18637	9022	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9022	5	This	this	DT
18637	9022	6	contention	contention	NN
18637	9022	7	overlooks	overlook	VBZ
18637	9022	8	such	such	JJ
18637	9022	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	9022	10	as	as	IN
18637	9022	11	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	9022	12	_	_	NNP
18637	9022	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	9022	14	_	_	NNP
18637	9022	15	Harmony;[450	Harmony;[450	NNP
18637	9022	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9022	17	United	United	NNP
18637	9022	18	States	States	NNP
18637	9022	19	_	_	NNP
18637	9022	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	9022	21	_	_	NNP
18637	9022	22	Russell;[451	Russell;[451	,
18637	9022	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9022	24	Portsmouth	Portsmouth	NNP
18637	9022	25	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	9022	26	Land	Land	NNP
18637	9022	27	and	and	CC
18637	9022	28	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	9022	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	9022	30	_	_	NNP
18637	9022	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	9022	32	_	_	NNP
18637	9022	33	United	United	NNP
18637	9022	34	States;[452	states;[452	NN
18637	9022	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9022	36	and	and	CC
18637	9022	37	United	United	NNP
18637	9022	38	States	States	NNP
18637	9022	39	_	_	NNP
18637	9022	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	9022	41	_	_	NNP
18637	9022	42	Pewee	Pewee	NNP
18637	9022	43	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	9022	44	Co.;[453	Co.;[453	NNP
18637	9022	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9022	46	in	in	IN
18637	9022	47	all	all	DT
18637	9022	48	of	of	IN
18637	9022	49	which	which	WDT
18637	9022	50	a	a	DT
18637	9022	51	right	right	NN
18637	9022	52	of	of	IN
18637	9022	53	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	9022	54	was	be	VBD
18637	9022	55	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	9022	56	to	to	TO
18637	9022	57	exist	exist	VB
18637	9022	58	in	in	IN
18637	9022	59	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	9022	60	of	of	IN
18637	9022	61	damage	damage	NN
18637	9022	62	to	to	IN
18637	9022	63	property	property	NN
18637	9022	64	which	which	WDT
18637	9022	65	resulted	result	VBD
18637	9022	66	from	from	IN
18637	9022	67	acts	act	NNS
18637	9022	68	stemming	stem	VBG
18637	9022	69	ultimately	ultimately	RB
18637	9022	70	from	from	IN
18637	9022	71	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	9022	72	powers	power	NNS
18637	9022	73	of	of	IN
18637	9022	74	the	the	DT
18637	9022	75	President	President	NNP
18637	9022	76	.	.	.
18637	9023	1	In	in	IN
18637	9023	2	United	United	NNP
18637	9023	3	States	States	NNP
18637	9023	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9023	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	9023	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9023	7	Pink,[454	Pink,[454	NNP
18637	9023	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9023	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9023	10	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	9023	11	quotes	quote	VBZ
18637	9023	12	with	with	IN
18637	9023	13	approval	approval	NN
18637	9023	14	the	the	DT
18637	9023	15	following	follow	VBG
18637	9023	16	words	word	NNS
18637	9023	17	from	from	IN
18637	9023	18	the	the	DT
18637	9023	19	Federalist,[455	Federalist,[455	NNP
18637	9023	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9023	21	"	"	``
18637	9023	22	all	all	DT
18637	9023	23	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	9023	24	acts	act	NNS
18637	9023	25	of	of	IN
18637	9023	26	power	power	NN
18637	9023	27	,	,	,
18637	9023	28	whether	whether	IN
18637	9023	29	in	in	IN
18637	9023	30	the	the	DT
18637	9023	31	executive	executive	NN
18637	9023	32	or	or	CC
18637	9023	33	in	in	IN
18637	9023	34	the	the	DT
18637	9023	35	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	9023	36	branch	branch	NN
18637	9023	37	,	,	,
18637	9023	38	have	have	VBP
18637	9023	39	as	as	RB
18637	9023	40	much	much	JJ
18637	9023	41	validity	validity	NN
18637	9023	42	and	and	CC
18637	9023	43	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	9023	44	as	as	IN
18637	9023	45	if	if	IN
18637	9023	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9023	47	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	9023	48	from	from	IN
18637	9023	49	the	the	DT
18637	9023	50	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	9023	51	.	.	.
18637	9023	52	"	"	''
18637	9024	1	If	if	IN
18637	9024	2	this	this	DT
18637	9024	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	9024	4	so	so	IN
18637	9024	5	as	as	IN
18637	9024	6	to	to	IN
18637	9024	7	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9024	8	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	9024	9	,	,	,
18637	9024	10	then	then	RB
18637	9024	11	all	all	PDT
18637	9024	12	the	the	DT
18637	9024	13	more	more	RBR
18637	9024	14	must	must	MD
18637	9024	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9024	16	be	be	VB
18637	9024	17	true	true	JJ
18637	9024	18	of	of	IN
18637	9024	19	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	9024	20	which	which	WDT
18637	9024	21	are	be	VBP
18637	9024	22	based	base	VBN
18637	9024	23	directly	directly	RB
18637	9024	24	on	on	IN
18637	9024	25	the	the	DT
18637	9024	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9024	27	.	.	.
18637	9025	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9025	2	456	456	CD
18637	9025	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9025	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9025	5	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	9025	6	's	's	POS
18637	9025	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9025	8	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	9025	9	little	little	JJ
18637	9025	10	that	that	WDT
18637	9025	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	9025	12	of	of	IN
18637	9025	13	direct	direct	JJ
18637	9025	14	pertinence	pertinence	NN
18637	9025	15	to	to	IN
18637	9025	16	the	the	DT
18637	9025	17	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	9025	18	issue	issue	NN
18637	9025	19	.	.	.
18637	9026	1	Important	important	JJ
18637	9026	2	,	,	,
18637	9026	3	however	however	RB
18637	9026	4	,	,	,
18637	9026	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	9026	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9026	7	contention	contention	NN
18637	9026	8	,	,	,
18637	9026	9	which	which	WDT
18637	9026	10	,	,	,
18637	9026	11	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	9026	12	to	to	TO
18637	9026	13	align	align	VB
18637	9026	14	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9026	15	with	with	IN
18637	9026	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9026	17	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	9026	18	,	,	,
18637	9026	19	that	that	IN
18637	9026	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9026	21	had	have	VBD
18637	9026	22	"	"	``
18637	9026	23	not	not	RB
18637	9026	24	left	leave	VBN
18637	9026	25	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	9026	26	of	of	IN
18637	9026	27	private	private	JJ
18637	9026	28	property	property	NN
18637	9026	29	an	an	DT
18637	9026	30	open	open	JJ
18637	9026	31	field	field	NN
18637	9026	32	but	but	CC
18637	9026	33	has	have	VBZ
18637	9026	34	covered	cover	VBN
18637	9026	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9026	36	by	by	IN
18637	9026	37	three	three	CD
18637	9026	38	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	9026	39	policies	policy	NNS
18637	9026	40	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	9026	41	with	with	IN
18637	9026	42	this	this	DT
18637	9026	43	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	9026	44	"	"	''
18637	9026	45	;	;	:
18637	9026	46	from	from	IN
18637	9026	47	which	which	WDT
18637	9026	48	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9026	49	concludes	conclude	VBZ
18637	9026	50	that	that	IN
18637	9026	51	"	"	``
18637	9026	52	*	*	NFP
18637	9026	53	*	*	NFP
18637	9026	54	*	*	NFP
18637	9026	55	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9026	56	can	can	MD
18637	9026	57	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	9026	58	the	the	DT
18637	9026	59	President	President	NNP
18637	9026	60	only	only	RB
18637	9026	61	by	by	IN
18637	9026	62	holding	hold	VBG
18637	9026	63	that	that	DT
18637	9026	64	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	9026	65	of	of	IN
18637	9026	66	such	such	JJ
18637	9026	67	strike	strike	NN
18637	9026	68	-	-	HYPH
18637	9026	69	bound	bind	VBN
18637	9026	70	industries	industry	NNS
18637	9026	71	is	be	VBZ
18637	9026	72	within	within	IN
18637	9026	73	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9026	74	domain	domain	NN
18637	9026	75	and	and	CC
18637	9026	76	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	9026	77	control	control	NN
18637	9026	78	by	by	IN
18637	9026	79	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9026	80	.	.	.
18637	9027	1	"	"	``
18637	9027	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9027	3	457	457	CD
18637	9027	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9027	5	The	the	DT
18637	9027	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9027	7	concludes	conclude	VBZ
18637	9027	8	:	:	:
18637	9027	9	"	"	``
18637	9027	10	In	in	IN
18637	9027	11	view	view	NN
18637	9027	12	of	of	IN
18637	9027	13	the	the	DT
18637	9027	14	ease	ease	NN
18637	9027	15	,	,	,
18637	9027	16	expedition	expedition	NN
18637	9027	17	and	and	CC
18637	9027	18	safety	safety	NN
18637	9027	19	with	with	IN
18637	9027	20	which	which	WDT
18637	9027	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9027	22	can	can	MD
18637	9027	23	grant	grant	VB
18637	9027	24	and	and	CC
18637	9027	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	9027	26	granted	grant	VBN
18637	9027	27	large	large	JJ
18637	9027	28	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	9027	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	9027	30	,	,	,
18637	9027	31	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	9027	32	ample	ample	JJ
18637	9027	33	to	to	TO
18637	9027	34	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	9027	35	this	this	DT
18637	9027	36	crisis	crisis	NN
18637	9027	37	,	,	,
18637	9027	38	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9027	39	am	be	VBP
18637	9027	40	quite	quite	RB
18637	9027	41	unimpressed	unimpressed	JJ
18637	9027	42	with	with	IN
18637	9027	43	the	the	DT
18637	9027	44	argument	argument	NN
18637	9027	45	that	that	IN
18637	9027	46	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9027	47	should	should	MD
18637	9027	48	affirm	affirm	VB
18637	9027	49	possession	possession	NN
18637	9027	50	of	of	IN
18637	9027	51	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9027	52	without	without	IN
18637	9027	53	statute	statute	NN
18637	9027	54	.	.	.
18637	9028	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	9028	2	power	power	NN
18637	9028	3	either	either	CC
18637	9028	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	9028	5	no	no	DT
18637	9028	6	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	9028	7	or	or	CC
18637	9028	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9028	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	9028	10	no	no	DT
18637	9028	11	end	end	NN
18637	9028	12	.	.	.
18637	9029	1	If	if	IN
18637	9029	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9029	3	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	9029	4	,	,	,
18637	9029	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9029	6	need	need	VBP
18637	9029	7	submit	submit	NN
18637	9029	8	to	to	IN
18637	9029	9	no	no	DT
18637	9029	10	legal	legal	JJ
18637	9029	11	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	9029	12	.	.	.
18637	9030	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9030	2	am	be	VBP
18637	9030	3	not	not	RB
18637	9030	4	alarmed	alarm	VBN
18637	9030	5	that	that	IN
18637	9030	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9030	7	would	would	MD
18637	9030	8	plunge	plunge	VB
18637	9030	9	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9030	10	straightway	straightway	RB
18637	9030	11	into	into	IN
18637	9030	12	dictatorship	dictatorship	NN
18637	9030	13	,	,	,
18637	9030	14	but	but	CC
18637	9030	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9030	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	9030	17	at	at	IN
18637	9030	18	least	least	JJS
18637	9030	19	a	a	DT
18637	9030	20	step	step	NN
18637	9030	21	in	in	IN
18637	9030	22	that	that	DT
18637	9030	23	wrong	wrong	JJ
18637	9030	24	direction	direction	NN
18637	9030	25	.	.	.
18637	9031	1	*	*	NFP
18637	9031	2	*	*	NFP
18637	9031	3	*	*	NFP
18637	9031	4	But	but	CC
18637	9031	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9031	6	have	have	VBP
18637	9031	7	no	no	DT
18637	9031	8	illusion	illusion	NN
18637	9031	9	that	that	IN
18637	9031	10	any	any	DT
18637	9031	11	decision	decision	NN
18637	9031	12	by	by	IN
18637	9031	13	this	this	DT
18637	9031	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9031	15	can	can	MD
18637	9031	16	keep	keep	VB
18637	9031	17	power	power	NN
18637	9031	18	in	in	IN
18637	9031	19	the	the	DT
18637	9031	20	hands	hand	NNS
18637	9031	21	of	of	IN
18637	9031	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9031	23	if	if	IN
18637	9031	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9031	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	9031	26	not	not	RB
18637	9031	27	wise	wise	JJ
18637	9031	28	and	and	CC
18637	9031	29	timely	timely	JJ
18637	9031	30	in	in	IN
18637	9031	31	meeting	meet	VBG
18637	9031	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9031	33	problems	problem	NNS
18637	9031	34	.	.	.
18637	9032	1	A	a	DT
18637	9032	2	crisis	crisis	NN
18637	9032	3	that	that	WDT
18637	9032	4	challenges	challenge	VBZ
18637	9032	5	the	the	DT
18637	9032	6	President	President	NNP
18637	9032	7	equally	equally	RB
18637	9032	8	,	,	,
18637	9032	9	or	or	CC
18637	9032	10	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	9032	11	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	9032	12	,	,	,
18637	9032	13	challenges	challenge	VBZ
18637	9032	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9032	15	.	.	.
18637	9033	1	If	if	IN
18637	9033	2	not	not	RB
18637	9033	3	good	good	JJ
18637	9033	4	law	law	NN
18637	9033	5	,	,	,
18637	9033	6	there	there	EX
18637	9033	7	was	be	VBD
18637	9033	8	worldly	worldly	RB
18637	9033	9	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	9033	10	in	in	IN
18637	9033	11	the	the	DT
18637	9033	12	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	9033	13	attributed	attribute	VBN
18637	9033	14	to	to	IN
18637	9033	15	Napoleon	Napoleon	NNP
18637	9033	16	that	that	DT
18637	9033	17	'	'	``
18637	9033	18	The	the	DT
18637	9033	19	tools	tool	NNS
18637	9033	20	belong	belong	VBP
18637	9033	21	to	to	IN
18637	9033	22	the	the	DT
18637	9033	23	man	man	NN
18637	9033	24	who	who	WP
18637	9033	25	can	can	MD
18637	9033	26	use	use	VB
18637	9033	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9033	28	.	.	.
18637	9033	29	'	'	''
18637	9034	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9034	2	may	may	MD
18637	9034	3	say	say	VB
18637	9034	4	that	that	DT
18637	9034	5	power	power	NN
18637	9034	6	to	to	TO
18637	9034	7	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	9034	8	for	for	IN
18637	9034	9	emergencies	emergency	NNS
18637	9034	10	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	9034	11	in	in	IN
18637	9034	12	the	the	DT
18637	9034	13	hands	hand	NNS
18637	9034	14	of	of	IN
18637	9034	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9034	16	,	,	,
18637	9034	17	but	but	CC
18637	9034	18	only	only	RB
18637	9034	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9034	20	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9034	21	can	can	MD
18637	9034	22	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	9034	23	power	power	NN
18637	9034	24	from	from	IN
18637	9034	25	slipping	slip	VBG
18637	9034	26	through	through	IN
18637	9034	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9034	28	fingers	finger	NNS
18637	9034	29	.	.	.
18637	9035	1	"	"	``
18637	9035	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9035	3	458	458	CD
18637	9035	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9035	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9035	6	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	9035	7	,	,	,
18637	9035	8	referring	refer	VBG
18637	9035	9	to	to	IN
18637	9035	10	the	the	DT
18637	9035	11	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	9035	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	9035	13	Hartley	Hartley	NNP
18637	9035	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	9035	15	,	,	,
18637	9035	16	says	say	VBZ
18637	9035	17	:	:	:
18637	9035	18	"	"	``
18637	9035	19	*	*	NFP
18637	9035	20	*	*	NFP
18637	9035	21	*	*	NFP
18637	9035	22	the	the	DT
18637	9035	23	most	most	RBS
18637	9035	24	significant	significant	JJ
18637	9035	25	feature	feature	NN
18637	9035	26	of	of	IN
18637	9035	27	that	that	DT
18637	9035	28	Act	Act	NNP
18637	9035	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	9035	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9035	31	omission	omission	NN
18637	9035	32	of	of	IN
18637	9035	33	authority	authority	NN
18637	9035	34	to	to	TO
18637	9035	35	seize	seize	VB
18637	9035	36	,	,	,
18637	9035	37	"	"	''
18637	9035	38	citing	cite	VBG
18637	9035	39	debate	debate	NN
18637	9035	40	on	on	IN
18637	9035	41	the	the	DT
18637	9035	42	measure	measure	NN
18637	9035	43	.	.	.
18637	9036	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9036	2	459	459	CD
18637	9036	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9036	4	"	"	``
18637	9036	5	In	in	IN
18637	9036	6	the	the	DT
18637	9036	7	case	case	NN
18637	9036	8	before	before	IN
18637	9036	9	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9036	10	,	,	,
18637	9036	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9036	12	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	9036	13	a	a	DT
18637	9036	14	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	9036	15	which	which	WDT
18637	9036	16	the	the	DT
18637	9036	17	President	President	NNP
18637	9036	18	declined	decline	VBD
18637	9036	19	to	to	TO
18637	9036	20	follow	follow	VB
18637	9036	21	.	.	.
18637	9037	1	"	"	``
18637	9037	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9037	3	460	460	CD
18637	9037	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9037	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9037	6	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	9037	7	bases	base	VBZ
18637	9037	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9037	9	position	position	NN
18637	9037	10	directly	directly	RB
18637	9037	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	9037	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	9037	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9037	14	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	9037	15	's	's	POS
18637	9037	16	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9037	17	in	in	IN
18637	9037	18	Little	Little	NNP
18637	9037	19	_	_	NNP
18637	9037	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	9037	21	_	_	NNP
18637	9037	22	Barreme	Barreme	NNP
18637	9037	23	.	.	.
18637	9038	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9038	2	461	461	CD
18637	9038	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9038	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9038	5	says	say	VBZ
18637	9038	6	:	:	:
18637	9038	7	"	"	``
18637	9038	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9038	9	conclude	conclude	VBP
18637	9038	10	that	that	IN
18637	9038	11	where	where	WRB
18637	9038	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9038	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	9038	14	laid	lay	VBN
18637	9038	15	down	down	RP
18637	9038	16	specific	specific	JJ
18637	9038	17	procedures	procedure	NNS
18637	9038	18	to	to	TO
18637	9038	19	deal	deal	VB
18637	9038	20	with	with	IN
18637	9038	21	the	the	DT
18637	9038	22	type	type	NN
18637	9038	23	of	of	IN
18637	9038	24	crisis	crisis	NN
18637	9038	25	confronting	confront	VBG
18637	9038	26	the	the	DT
18637	9038	27	President	President	NNP
18637	9038	28	,	,	,
18637	9038	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9038	30	must	must	MD
18637	9038	31	follow	follow	VB
18637	9038	32	these	these	DT
18637	9038	33	procedures	procedure	NNS
18637	9038	34	in	in	IN
18637	9038	35	meeting	meet	VBG
18637	9038	36	the	the	DT
18637	9038	37	crisis	crisis	NN
18637	9038	38	;	;	:
18637	9038	39	*	*	NFP
18637	9038	40	*	*	NFP
18637	9038	41	*	*	NFP
18637	9038	42	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9038	43	can	can	MD
18637	9038	44	not	not	RB
18637	9038	45	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	9038	46	the	the	DT
18637	9038	47	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	9038	48	in	in	IN
18637	9038	49	question	question	NN
18637	9038	50	because	because	IN
18637	9038	51	here	here	RB
18637	9038	52	,	,	,
18637	9038	53	as	as	IN
18637	9038	54	in	in	IN
18637	9038	55	Little	Little	NNP
18637	9038	56	_	_	NNP
18637	9038	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	9038	58	_	_	NNP
18637	9038	59	Barreme	Barreme	NNP
18637	9038	60	,	,	,
18637	9038	61	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9038	62	had	have	VBD
18637	9038	63	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	9038	64	methods	method	NNS
18637	9038	65	to	to	TO
18637	9038	66	be	be	VB
18637	9038	67	followed	follow	VBN
18637	9038	68	by	by	IN
18637	9038	69	the	the	DT
18637	9038	70	President	President	NNP
18637	9038	71	in	in	IN
18637	9038	72	meeting	meet	VBG
18637	9038	73	the	the	DT
18637	9038	74	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	9038	75	at	at	IN
18637	9038	76	hand	hand	NN
18637	9038	77	.	.	.
18637	9039	1	"	"	``
18637	9039	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9039	3	462	462	CD
18637	9039	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9039	5	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9039	6	reference	reference	NN
18637	9039	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	9039	8	to	to	IN
18637	9039	9	the	the	DT
18637	9039	10	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	9039	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	9039	12	Hartley	Hartley	NNP
18637	9039	13	Act	Act	NNP
18637	9039	14	.	.	.
18637	9040	1	At	at	IN
18637	9040	2	the	the	DT
18637	9040	3	same	same	JJ
18637	9040	4	time	time	NN
18637	9040	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9040	6	endorses	endorse	VBZ
18637	9040	7	the	the	DT
18637	9040	8	view	view	NN
18637	9040	9	,	,	,
18637	9040	10	"	"	''
18637	9040	11	taught	teach	VBD
18637	9040	12	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9040	13	not	not	RB
18637	9040	14	only	only	RB
18637	9040	15	by	by	IN
18637	9040	16	the	the	DT
18637	9040	17	decision	decision	NN
18637	9040	18	of	of	IN
18637	9040	19	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	9040	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9040	21	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	9040	22	in	in	IN
18637	9040	23	Little	Little	NNP
18637	9040	24	_	_	NNP
18637	9040	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	9040	26	_	_	NNP
18637	9040	27	Barreme	Barreme	NNP
18637	9040	28	,	,	,
18637	9040	29	but	but	CC
18637	9040	30	also	also	RB
18637	9040	31	by	by	IN
18637	9040	32	a	a	DT
18637	9040	33	score	score	NN
18637	9040	34	of	of	IN
18637	9040	35	other	other	JJ
18637	9040	36	pronouncements	pronouncement	NNS
18637	9040	37	of	of	IN
18637	9040	38	distinguished	distinguished	JJ
18637	9040	39	members	member	NNS
18637	9040	40	of	of	IN
18637	9040	41	this	this	DT
18637	9040	42	bench	bench	NN
18637	9040	43	,	,	,
18637	9040	44	"	"	''
18637	9040	45	that	that	IN
18637	9040	46	"	"	``
18637	9040	47	the	the	DT
18637	9040	48	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9040	49	does	do	VBZ
18637	9040	50	grant	grant	VB
18637	9040	51	to	to	IN
18637	9040	52	the	the	DT
18637	9040	53	President	President	NNP
18637	9040	54	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	9040	55	authority	authority	NN
18637	9040	56	in	in	IN
18637	9040	57	times	time	NNS
18637	9040	58	of	of	IN
18637	9040	59	grave	grave	NN
18637	9040	60	and	and	CC
18637	9040	61	imperative	imperative	JJ
18637	9040	62	national	national	JJ
18637	9040	63	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	9040	64	.	.	.
18637	9041	1	"	"	``
18637	9041	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9041	3	463	463	CD
18637	9041	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9041	5	Dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	9041	6	Opinion	Opinion	NNP
18637	9041	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	9041	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9041	9	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	9041	10	launched	launch	VBD
18637	9041	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9041	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9041	13	of	of	IN
18637	9041	14	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	9041	15	,	,	,
18637	9041	16	for	for	IN
18637	9041	17	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9041	18	and	and	CC
18637	9041	19	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	9041	20	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	9041	21	and	and	CC
18637	9041	22	Minton	Minton	NNP
18637	9041	23	,	,	,
18637	9041	24	with	with	IN
18637	9041	25	a	a	DT
18637	9041	26	survey	survey	NN
18637	9041	27	of	of	IN
18637	9041	28	the	the	DT
18637	9041	29	elements	element	NNS
18637	9041	30	of	of	IN
18637	9041	31	the	the	DT
18637	9041	32	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	9041	33	which	which	WDT
18637	9041	34	confronted	confront	VBD
18637	9041	35	the	the	DT
18637	9041	36	President	President	NNP
18637	9041	37	:	:	:
18637	9041	38	the	the	DT
18637	9041	39	Korean	korean	JJ
18637	9041	40	war	war	NN
18637	9041	41	;	;	,
18637	9041	42	the	the	DT
18637	9041	43	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	9041	44	of	of	IN
18637	9041	45	the	the	DT
18637	9041	46	United	United	NNP
18637	9041	47	States	States	NNP
18637	9041	48	under	under	IN
18637	9041	49	the	the	DT
18637	9041	50	United	United	NNP
18637	9041	51	Nations	Nations	NNPS
18637	9041	52	Charter	Charter	NNP
18637	9041	53	and	and	CC
18637	9041	54	the	the	DT
18637	9041	55	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	9041	56	Pact	Pact	NNP
18637	9041	57	;	;	:
18637	9041	58	the	the	DT
18637	9041	59	appropriations	appropriation	NNS
18637	9041	60	acts	act	VBZ
18637	9041	61	by	by	IN
18637	9041	62	which	which	WDT
18637	9041	63	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9041	64	has	have	VBZ
18637	9041	65	voted	vote	VBN
18637	9041	66	vast	vast	JJ
18637	9041	67	sums	sum	NNS
18637	9041	68	to	to	TO
18637	9041	69	be	be	VB
18637	9041	70	expended	expend	VBN
18637	9041	71	in	in	IN
18637	9041	72	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9041	73	defense	defense	NN
18637	9041	74	and	and	CC
18637	9041	75	that	that	DT
18637	9041	76	of	of	IN
18637	9041	77	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9041	78	Allies	Allies	NNPS
18637	9041	79	in	in	IN
18637	9041	80	Europe	Europe	NNP
18637	9041	81	;	;	:
18637	9041	82	the	the	DT
18637	9041	83	fact	fact	NN
18637	9041	84	that	that	IN
18637	9041	85	steel	steel	NN
18637	9041	86	is	be	VBZ
18637	9041	87	a	a	DT
18637	9041	88	basic	basic	JJ
18637	9041	89	constituent	constituent	NN
18637	9041	90	of	of	IN
18637	9041	91	war	war	NN
18637	9041	92	matÃ	matÃ	NNP
18637	9041	93	©	©	NNP
18637	9041	94	riel	riel	NNP
18637	9041	95	.	.	.
18637	9042	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9042	2	reproaches	reproach	VBZ
18637	9042	3	the	the	DT
18637	9042	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9042	5	for	for	IN
18637	9042	6	giving	give	VBG
18637	9042	7	no	no	DT
18637	9042	8	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	9042	9	to	to	IN
18637	9042	10	these	these	DT
18637	9042	11	things	thing	NNS
18637	9042	12	,	,	,
18637	9042	13	although	although	IN
18637	9042	14	no	no	DT
18637	9042	15	one	one	NN
18637	9042	16	had	have	VBD
18637	9042	17	ventured	venture	VBN
18637	9042	18	to	to	TO
18637	9042	19	challenge	challenge	VB
18637	9042	20	the	the	DT
18637	9042	21	President	President	NNP
18637	9042	22	's	's	POS
18637	9042	23	finding	finding	NN
18637	9042	24	of	of	IN
18637	9042	25	an	an	DT
18637	9042	26	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	9042	27	on	on	IN
18637	9042	28	the	the	DT
18637	9042	29	basis	basis	NN
18637	9042	30	of	of	IN
18637	9042	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9042	32	.	.	.
18637	9043	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9043	2	464	464	CD
18637	9043	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9043	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9043	5	asks	ask	VBZ
18637	9043	6	whether	whether	IN
18637	9043	7	the	the	DT
18637	9043	8	steel	steel	NN
18637	9043	9	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	9043	10	,	,	,
18637	9043	11	considering	consider	VBG
18637	9043	12	the	the	DT
18637	9043	13	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	9043	14	involved	involve	VBN
18637	9043	15	,	,	,
18637	9043	16	fits	fit	VBZ
18637	9043	17	into	into	IN
18637	9043	18	the	the	DT
18637	9043	19	picture	picture	NN
18637	9043	20	of	of	IN
18637	9043	21	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	9043	22	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	9043	23	action	action	NN
18637	9043	24	in	in	IN
18637	9043	25	the	the	DT
18637	9043	26	past	past	NN
18637	9043	27	and	and	CC
18637	9043	28	musters	muster	VBZ
18637	9043	29	impressive	impressive	JJ
18637	9043	30	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	9043	31	to	to	TO
18637	9043	32	show	show	VB
18637	9043	33	that	that	IN
18637	9043	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9043	35	does	do	VBZ
18637	9043	36	.	.	.
18637	9044	1	And	and	CC
18637	9044	2	"	"	``
18637	9044	3	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
18637	9044	4	admit	admit	VBP
18637	9044	5	,	,	,
18637	9044	6	"	"	''
18637	9044	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9044	8	asserts	assert	VBZ
18637	9044	9	,	,	,
18637	9044	10	more	more	RBR
18637	9044	11	questionably	questionably	RB
18637	9044	12	,	,	,
18637	9044	13	"	"	''
18637	9044	14	that	that	IN
18637	9044	15	the	the	DT
18637	9044	16	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	9044	17	procedures	procedure	NNS
18637	9044	18	of	of	IN
18637	9044	19	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	9044	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	9044	21	Hartley	Hartley	NNP
18637	9044	22	are	be	VBP
18637	9044	23	not	not	RB
18637	9044	24	mandatory	mandatory	JJ
18637	9044	25	.	.	.
18637	9045	1	"	"	``
18637	9045	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9045	3	465	465	CD
18637	9045	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9045	5	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9045	6	concludes	conclude	VBZ
18637	9045	7	as	as	IN
18637	9045	8	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	9045	9	:	:	:
18637	9045	10	"	"	``
18637	9045	11	The	the	DT
18637	9045	12	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	9045	13	of	of	IN
18637	9045	14	views	view	NNS
18637	9045	15	expressed	express	VBN
18637	9045	16	in	in	IN
18637	9045	17	the	the	DT
18637	9045	18	six	six	CD
18637	9045	19	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	9045	20	of	of	IN
18637	9045	21	the	the	DT
18637	9045	22	majority	majority	NN
18637	9045	23	,	,	,
18637	9045	24	the	the	DT
18637	9045	25	lack	lack	NN
18637	9045	26	of	of	IN
18637	9045	27	reference	reference	NN
18637	9045	28	to	to	IN
18637	9045	29	authoritative	authoritative	JJ
18637	9045	30	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	9045	31	,	,	,
18637	9045	32	the	the	DT
18637	9045	33	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	9045	34	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	9045	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	9045	36	prior	prior	RB
18637	9045	37	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	9045	38	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	9045	39	,	,	,
18637	9045	40	the	the	DT
18637	9045	41	complete	complete	JJ
18637	9045	42	disregard	disregard	NN
18637	9045	43	of	of	IN
18637	9045	44	the	the	DT
18637	9045	45	uncontroverted	uncontroverted	JJ
18637	9045	46	facts	fact	NNS
18637	9045	47	showing	show	VBG
18637	9045	48	the	the	DT
18637	9045	49	gravity	gravity	NN
18637	9045	50	of	of	IN
18637	9045	51	the	the	DT
18637	9045	52	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	9045	53	and	and	CC
18637	9045	54	the	the	DT
18637	9045	55	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	9045	56	nature	nature	NN
18637	9045	57	of	of	IN
18637	9045	58	the	the	DT
18637	9045	59	taking	take	VBG
18637	9045	60	all	all	DT
18637	9045	61	serve	serve	VBP
18637	9045	62	to	to	TO
18637	9045	63	demonstrate	demonstrate	VB
18637	9045	64	how	how	WRB
18637	9045	65	far	far	RB
18637	9045	66	afield	afield	RB
18637	9045	67	one	one	PRP
18637	9045	68	must	must	MD
18637	9045	69	go	go	VB
18637	9045	70	to	to	TO
18637	9045	71	affirm	affirm	VB
18637	9045	72	the	the	DT
18637	9045	73	order	order	NN
18637	9045	74	of	of	IN
18637	9045	75	the	the	DT
18637	9045	76	District	District	NNP
18637	9045	77	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9045	78	.	.	.
18637	9046	1	The	the	DT
18637	9046	2	broad	broad	JJ
18637	9046	3	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9046	4	power	power	NN
18637	9046	5	granted	grant	VBN
18637	9046	6	by	by	IN
18637	9046	7	Article	Article	NNP
18637	9046	8	II	ii	CD
18637	9046	9	to	to	IN
18637	9046	10	an	an	DT
18637	9046	11	officer	officer	NN
18637	9046	12	on	on	IN
18637	9046	13	duty	duty	NN
18637	9046	14	365	365	CD
18637	9046	15	days	day	NNS
18637	9046	16	a	a	DT
18637	9046	17	year	year	NN
18637	9046	18	can	can	MD
18637	9046	19	not	not	RB
18637	9046	20	,	,	,
18637	9046	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9046	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	9046	23	said	say	VBN
18637	9046	24	,	,	,
18637	9046	25	be	be	VB
18637	9046	26	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	9046	27	to	to	TO
18637	9046	28	avert	avert	VB
18637	9046	29	disaster	disaster	NN
18637	9046	30	.	.	.
18637	9047	1	Instead	instead	RB
18637	9047	2	,	,	,
18637	9047	3	the	the	DT
18637	9047	4	President	President	NNP
18637	9047	5	,	,	,
18637	9047	6	must	must	MD
18637	9047	7	confine	confine	VB
18637	9047	8	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9047	9	to	to	IN
18637	9047	10	sending	send	VBG
18637	9047	11	a	a	DT
18637	9047	12	message	message	NN
18637	9047	13	to	to	IN
18637	9047	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9047	15	recommending	recommend	VBG
18637	9047	16	action	action	NN
18637	9047	17	.	.	.
18637	9048	1	Under	under	IN
18637	9048	2	this	this	DT
18637	9048	3	messenger	messenger	NN
18637	9048	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	9048	5	boy	boy	NN
18637	9048	6	concept	concept	NN
18637	9048	7	of	of	IN
18637	9048	8	the	the	DT
18637	9048	9	Office	Office	NNP
18637	9048	10	,	,	,
18637	9048	11	the	the	DT
18637	9048	12	President	President	NNP
18637	9048	13	can	can	MD
18637	9048	14	not	not	RB
18637	9048	15	even	even	RB
18637	9048	16	act	act	VB
18637	9048	17	to	to	TO
18637	9048	18	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	9048	19	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	9048	20	programs	program	NNS
18637	9048	21	from	from	IN
18637	9048	22	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	9048	23	so	so	IN
18637	9048	24	that	that	IN
18637	9048	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9048	26	will	will	MD
18637	9048	27	have	have	VB
18637	9048	28	something	something	NN
18637	9048	29	left	leave	VBN
18637	9048	30	to	to	TO
18637	9048	31	act	act	VB
18637	9048	32	upon	upon	IN
18637	9048	33	.	.	.
18637	9049	1	There	there	EX
18637	9049	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	9049	3	no	no	DT
18637	9049	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	9049	5	finding	finding	NN
18637	9049	6	that	that	IN
18637	9049	7	the	the	DT
18637	9049	8	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9049	9	action	action	NN
18637	9049	10	was	be	VBD
18637	9049	11	unwarranted	unwarranted	JJ
18637	9049	12	because	because	IN
18637	9049	13	there	there	EX
18637	9049	14	was	be	VBD
18637	9049	15	in	in	IN
18637	9049	16	fact	fact	NN
18637	9049	17	no	no	DT
18637	9049	18	basis	basis	NN
18637	9049	19	for	for	IN
18637	9049	20	the	the	DT
18637	9049	21	President	President	NNP
18637	9049	22	's	's	POS
18637	9049	23	finding	finding	NN
18637	9049	24	of	of	IN
18637	9049	25	the	the	DT
18637	9049	26	existence	existence	NN
18637	9049	27	of	of	IN
18637	9049	28	an	an	DT
18637	9049	29	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	9049	30	for	for	IN
18637	9049	31	,	,	,
18637	9049	32	under	under	IN
18637	9049	33	this	this	DT
18637	9049	34	view	view	NN
18637	9049	35	,	,	,
18637	9049	36	the	the	DT
18637	9049	37	gravity	gravity	NN
18637	9049	38	of	of	IN
18637	9049	39	the	the	DT
18637	9049	40	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	9049	41	and	and	CC
18637	9049	42	the	the	DT
18637	9049	43	immediacy	immediacy	NN
18637	9049	44	of	of	IN
18637	9049	45	the	the	DT
18637	9049	46	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	9049	47	disaster	disaster	NN
18637	9049	48	are	be	VBP
18637	9049	49	considered	consider	VBN
18637	9049	50	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
18637	9049	51	as	as	IN
18637	9049	52	a	a	DT
18637	9049	53	matter	matter	NN
18637	9049	54	of	of	IN
18637	9049	55	law	law	NN
18637	9049	56	.	.	.
18637	9050	1	"	"	``
18637	9050	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9050	3	466	466	CD
18637	9050	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9050	5	Evaluation	evaluation	NN
18637	9050	6	;	;	,
18637	9050	7	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	9050	8	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	9050	9	Power	Power	NNP
18637	9050	10	The	the	DT
18637	9050	11	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	9050	12	of	of	IN
18637	9050	13	"	"	``
18637	9050	14	the	the	DT
18637	9050	15	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9050	16	of	of	IN
18637	9050	17	the	the	DT
18637	9050	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9050	19	"	"	''
18637	9050	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	9050	21	that	that	IN
18637	9050	22	,	,	,
18637	9050	23	if	if	IN
18637	9050	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9050	25	can	can	MD
18637	9050	26	do	do	VB
18637	9050	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9050	28	under	under	IN
18637	9050	29	,	,	,
18637	9050	30	say	say	UH
18637	9050	31	,	,	,
18637	9050	32	the	the	DT
18637	9050	33	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	9050	34	and	and	CC
18637	9050	35	proper	proper	JJ
18637	9050	36	clause	clause	NN
18637	9050	37	,	,	,
18637	9050	38	then	then	RB
18637	9050	39	the	the	DT
18637	9050	40	President	President	NNP
18637	9050	41	,	,	,
18637	9050	42	lacking	lack	VBG
18637	9050	43	authority	authority	NN
18637	9050	44	from	from	IN
18637	9050	45	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9050	46	,	,	,
18637	9050	47	can	can	MD
18637	9050	48	not	not	RB
18637	9050	49	do	do	VB
18637	9050	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9050	51	on	on	IN
18637	9050	52	the	the	DT
18637	9050	53	justification	justification	NN
18637	9050	54	that	that	IN
18637	9050	55	an	an	DT
18637	9050	56	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	9050	57	requires	require	VBZ
18637	9050	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9050	59	.	.	.
18637	9051	1	Although	although	IN
18637	9051	2	four	four	CD
18637	9051	3	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	9051	4	are	be	VBP
18637	9051	5	recorded	record	VBN
18637	9051	6	as	as	IN
18637	9051	7	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	9051	8	in	in	IN
18637	9051	9	the	the	DT
18637	9051	10	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9051	11	,	,	,
18637	9051	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9051	13	accompanying	accompanying	JJ
18637	9051	14	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	9051	15	whittle	whittle	VBP
18637	9051	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9051	17	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	9051	18	in	in	IN
18637	9051	19	some	some	DT
18637	9051	20	instances	instance	NNS
18637	9051	21	to	to	IN
18637	9051	22	the	the	DT
18637	9051	23	vanishing	vanish	VBG
18637	9051	24	point	point	NN
18637	9051	25	.	.	.
18637	9052	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9052	2	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	9052	3	's	's	POS
18637	9052	4	supplementary	supplementary	JJ
18637	9052	5	argument	argument	NN
18637	9052	6	on	on	IN
18637	9052	7	the	the	DT
18637	9052	8	basis	basis	NN
18637	9052	9	of	of	IN
18637	9052	10	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	9052	11	V	V	NNP
18637	9052	12	logically	logically	RB
18637	9052	13	confines	confine	VBZ
18637	9052	14	the	the	DT
18637	9052	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	9052	16	of	of	IN
18637	9052	17	the	the	DT
18637	9052	18	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9052	19	to	to	IN
18637	9052	20	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9052	21	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	9052	22	of	of	IN
18637	9052	23	property	property	NN
18637	9052	24	.	.	.
18637	9053	1	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	9053	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	9053	3	and	and	CC
18637	9053	4	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	9053	5	and	and	CC
18637	9053	6	,	,	,
18637	9053	7	less	less	RBR
18637	9053	8	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	9053	9	,	,	,
18637	9053	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9053	11	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	9053	12	insist	insist	VBP
18637	9053	13	in	in	IN
18637	9053	14	effect	effect	NN
18637	9053	15	that	that	IN
18637	9053	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9053	17	had	have	VBD
18637	9053	18	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	9053	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9053	20	power	power	NN
18637	9053	21	in	in	IN
18637	9053	22	the	the	DT
18637	9053	23	premises	premise	NNS
18637	9053	24	of	of	IN
18637	9053	25	the	the	DT
18637	9053	26	case	case	NN
18637	9053	27	in	in	IN
18637	9053	28	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	9053	29	to	to	TO
18637	9053	30	seizure	seizure	VB
18637	9053	31	.	.	.
18637	9054	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9054	2	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	9054	3	,	,	,
18637	9054	4	on	on	IN
18637	9054	5	the	the	DT
18637	9054	6	basis	basis	NN
18637	9054	7	of	of	IN
18637	9054	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	9054	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9054	10	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	9054	11	's	's	POS
18637	9054	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9054	13	in	in	IN
18637	9054	14	Little	Little	NNP
18637	9054	15	_	_	NNP
18637	9054	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	9054	17	_	_	NNP
18637	9054	18	Barreme	Barreme	NNP
18637	9054	19	,	,	,
18637	9054	20	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	9054	21	unambiguously	unambiguously	RB
18637	9054	22	that	that	IN
18637	9054	23	,	,	,
18637	9054	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9054	25	having	have	VBG
18637	9054	26	entered	enter	VBN
18637	9054	27	the	the	DT
18637	9054	28	field	field	NN
18637	9054	29	,	,	,
18637	9054	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9054	31	evident	evident	JJ
18637	9054	32	intention	intention	NN
18637	9054	33	to	to	TO
18637	9054	34	rule	rule	VB
18637	9054	35	out	out	RP
18637	9054	36	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	9054	37	supplied	supply	VBD
18637	9054	38	the	the	DT
18637	9054	39	law	law	NN
18637	9054	40	of	of	IN
18637	9054	41	the	the	DT
18637	9054	42	case	case	NN
18637	9054	43	.	.	.
18637	9055	1	That	that	IN
18637	9055	2	the	the	DT
18637	9055	3	President	President	NNP
18637	9055	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	9055	5	possess	possess	VB
18637	9055	6	a	a	DT
18637	9055	7	residual	residual	NN
18637	9055	8	of	of	IN
18637	9055	9	resultant	resultant	JJ
18637	9055	10	power	power	NN
18637	9055	11	above	above	RB
18637	9055	12	,	,	,
18637	9055	13	or	or	CC
18637	9055	14	in	in	IN
18637	9055	15	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	9055	16	of	of	IN
18637	9055	17	,	,	,
18637	9055	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9055	19	granted	grant	VBN
18637	9055	20	powers	power	NNS
18637	9055	21	to	to	TO
18637	9055	22	deal	deal	VB
18637	9055	23	with	with	IN
18637	9055	24	emergencies	emergency	NNS
18637	9055	25	in	in	IN
18637	9055	26	the	the	DT
18637	9055	27	absence	absence	NN
18637	9055	28	of	of	IN
18637	9055	29	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	9055	30	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	9055	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	9055	32	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	9055	33	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	9055	34	by	by	IN
18637	9055	35	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9055	36	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	9055	37	,	,	,
18637	9055	38	and	and	CC
18637	9055	39	impliedly	impliedly	RB
18637	9055	40	held	hold	VBN
18637	9055	41	,	,	,
18637	9055	42	with	with	IN
18637	9055	43	certain	certain	JJ
18637	9055	44	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	9055	45	,	,	,
18637	9055	46	by	by	IN
18637	9055	47	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9055	48	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	9055	49	and	and	CC
18637	9055	50	,	,	,
18637	9055	51	again	again	RB
18637	9055	52	less	less	RBR
18637	9055	53	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	9055	54	,	,	,
18637	9055	55	by	by	IN
18637	9055	56	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9055	57	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	9055	58	;	;	:
18637	9055	59	and	and	CC
18637	9055	60	is	be	VBZ
18637	9055	61	the	the	DT
18637	9055	62	essence	essence	NN
18637	9055	63	of	of	IN
18637	9055	64	the	the	DT
18637	9055	65	position	position	NN
18637	9055	66	of	of	IN
18637	9055	67	the	the	DT
18637	9055	68	three	three	CD
18637	9055	69	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	9055	70	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	9055	71	.	.	.
18637	9056	1	Finally	finally	RB
18637	9056	2	,	,	,
18637	9056	3	the	the	DT
18637	9056	4	entire	entire	JJ
18637	9056	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9056	6	would	would	MD
18637	9056	7	in	in	IN
18637	9056	8	all	all	DT
18637	9056	9	probability	probability	NN
18637	9056	10	agree	agree	VB
18637	9056	11	to	to	IN
18637	9056	12	the	the	DT
18637	9056	13	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	9056	14	that	that	IN
18637	9056	15	any	any	DT
18637	9056	16	action	action	NN
18637	9056	17	of	of	IN
18637	9056	18	the	the	DT
18637	9056	19	President	President	NNP
18637	9056	20	touching	touch	VBG
18637	9056	21	the	the	DT
18637	9056	22	internal	internal	JJ
18637	9056	23	economy	economy	NN
18637	9056	24	of	of	IN
18637	9056	25	the	the	DT
18637	9056	26	country	country	NN
18637	9056	27	for	for	IN
18637	9056	28	which	which	WDT
18637	9056	29	the	the	DT
18637	9056	30	justification	justification	NN
18637	9056	31	of	of	IN
18637	9056	32	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	9056	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	9056	34	pleaded	plead	VBN
18637	9056	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	9056	36	always	always	RB
18637	9056	37	subject	subject	JJ
18637	9056	38	to	to	IN
18637	9056	39	revision	revision	NN
18637	9056	40	and	and	CC
18637	9056	41	disallowance	disallowance	NN
18637	9056	42	by	by	IN
18637	9056	43	the	the	DT
18637	9056	44	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	9056	45	power	power	NN
18637	9056	46	.	.	.
18637	9057	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9057	2	would	would	MD
18637	9057	3	seem	seem	VB
18637	9057	4	to	to	TO
18637	9057	5	follow	follow	VB
18637	9057	6	that	that	IN
18637	9057	7	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	9057	8	the	the	DT
18637	9057	9	President	President	NNP
18637	9057	10	so	so	RB
18637	9057	11	acts	act	VBZ
18637	9057	12	on	on	IN
18637	9057	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9057	14	own	own	JJ
18637	9057	15	initiative	initiative	NN
18637	9057	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9057	17	should	should	MD
18637	9057	18	at	at	IN
18637	9057	19	once	once	RB
18637	9057	20	report	report	VB
18637	9057	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9057	22	action	action	NN
18637	9057	23	to	to	IN
18637	9057	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9057	25	,	,	,
18637	9057	26	and	and	CC
18637	9057	27	thenceforth	thenceforth	NN
18637	9057	28	bring	bring	VBP
18637	9057	29	the	the	DT
18637	9057	30	full	full	JJ
18637	9057	31	powers	power	NNS
18637	9057	32	of	of	IN
18637	9057	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9057	34	office	office	NN
18637	9057	35	to	to	IN
18637	9057	36	the	the	DT
18637	9057	37	support	support	NN
18637	9057	38	of	of	IN
18637	9057	39	the	the	DT
18637	9057	40	desires	desire	NNS
18637	9057	41	of	of	IN
18637	9057	42	the	the	DT
18637	9057	43	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	9057	44	once	once	IN
18637	9057	45	these	these	DT
18637	9057	46	are	be	VBP
18637	9057	47	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	9057	48	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	9057	49	.	.	.
18637	9058	1	PRESIDENTIAL	presidential	JJ
18637	9058	2	IMMUNITY	immunity	NN
18637	9058	3	FROM	from	IN
18637	9058	4	JUDICIAL	judicial	NN
18637	9058	5	DIRECTION	DIRECTION	NNS
18637	9058	6	By	by	IN
18637	9058	7	the	the	DT
18637	9058	8	decision	decision	NN
18637	9058	9	of	of	IN
18637	9058	10	the	the	DT
18637	9058	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9058	12	in	in	IN
18637	9058	13	State	State	NNP
18637	9058	14	of	of	IN
18637	9058	15	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	9058	16	_	_	NNP
18637	9058	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	9058	18	_	_	NNP
18637	9058	19	Johnson,[467	Johnson,[467	NNP
18637	9058	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9058	21	in	in	IN
18637	9058	22	1867	1867	CD
18637	9058	23	,	,	,
18637	9058	24	the	the	DT
18637	9058	25	President	President	NNP
18637	9058	26	was	be	VBD
18637	9058	27	put	put	VBN
18637	9058	28	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	9058	29	the	the	DT
18637	9058	30	reach	reach	NN
18637	9058	31	of	of	IN
18637	9058	32	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	9058	33	direction	direction	NN
18637	9058	34	in	in	IN
18637	9058	35	the	the	DT
18637	9058	36	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	9058	37	of	of	IN
18637	9058	38	any	any	DT
18637	9058	39	of	of	IN
18637	9058	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9058	41	powers	power	NNS
18637	9058	42	,	,	,
18637	9058	43	whether	whether	IN
18637	9058	44	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	9058	45	or	or	CC
18637	9058	46	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	9058	47	,	,	,
18637	9058	48	political	political	JJ
18637	9058	49	or	or	CC
18637	9058	50	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	9058	51	.	.	.
18637	9059	1	An	an	DT
18637	9059	2	application	application	NN
18637	9059	3	for	for	IN
18637	9059	4	an	an	DT
18637	9059	5	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	9059	6	to	to	TO
18637	9059	7	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	9059	8	President	President	NNP
18637	9059	9	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	9059	10	to	to	TO
18637	9059	11	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	9059	12	the	the	DT
18637	9059	13	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
18637	9059	14	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	9059	15	,	,	,
18637	9059	16	on	on	IN
18637	9059	17	the	the	DT
18637	9059	18	ground	ground	NN
18637	9059	19	of	of	IN
18637	9059	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9059	21	unconstitutionality	unconstitutionality	NN
18637	9059	22	,	,	,
18637	9059	23	was	be	VBD
18637	9059	24	answered	answer	VBN
18637	9059	25	by	by	IN
18637	9059	26	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	9059	27	General	General	NNP
18637	9059	28	Stanbery	Stanbery	NNP
18637	9059	29	as	as	IN
18637	9059	30	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	9059	31	:	:	:
18637	9059	32	"	"	``
18637	9059	33	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9059	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	9059	35	not	not	RB
18637	9059	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	9059	37	any	any	DT
18637	9059	38	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	9059	39	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	9059	40	that	that	IN
18637	9059	41	the	the	DT
18637	9059	42	individual	individual	NN
18637	9059	43	has	have	VBZ
18637	9059	44	who	who	WP
18637	9059	45	happens	happen	VBZ
18637	9059	46	to	to	TO
18637	9059	47	be	be	VB
18637	9059	48	President	President	NNP
18637	9059	49	;	;	:
18637	9059	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	9059	51	any	any	DT
18637	9059	52	idea	idea	NN
18637	9059	53	that	that	IN
18637	9059	54	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9059	55	can	can	MD
18637	9059	56	not	not	RB
18637	9059	57	do	do	VB
18637	9059	58	wrong	wrong	NN
18637	9059	59	;	;	:
18637	9059	60	upon	upon	IN
18637	9059	61	any	any	DT
18637	9059	62	idea	idea	NN
18637	9059	63	that	that	IN
18637	9059	64	there	there	EX
18637	9059	65	is	be	VBZ
18637	9059	66	any	any	DT
18637	9059	67	particular	particular	JJ
18637	9059	68	sanctity	sanctity	NN
18637	9059	69	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	9059	70	to	to	IN
18637	9059	71	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9059	72	as	as	IN
18637	9059	73	an	an	DT
18637	9059	74	individual	individual	NN
18637	9059	75	,	,	,
18637	9059	76	as	as	IN
18637	9059	77	is	be	VBZ
18637	9059	78	the	the	DT
18637	9059	79	case	case	NN
18637	9059	80	with	with	IN
18637	9059	81	one	one	CD
18637	9059	82	who	who	WP
18637	9059	83	has	have	VBZ
18637	9059	84	royal	royal	JJ
18637	9059	85	blood	blood	NN
18637	9059	86	in	in	IN
18637	9059	87	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9059	88	veins	vein	NNS
18637	9059	89	;	;	:
18637	9059	90	but	but	CC
18637	9059	91	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9059	92	is	be	VBZ
18637	9059	93	on	on	IN
18637	9059	94	account	account	NN
18637	9059	95	of	of	IN
18637	9059	96	the	the	DT
18637	9059	97	office	office	NN
18637	9059	98	that	that	WDT
18637	9059	99	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9059	100	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	9059	101	that	that	IN
18637	9059	102	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9059	103	say	say	VBP
18637	9059	104	the	the	DT
18637	9059	105	President	President	NNP
18637	9059	106	of	of	IN
18637	9059	107	the	the	DT
18637	9059	108	United	United	NNP
18637	9059	109	States	States	NNP
18637	9059	110	is	be	VBZ
18637	9059	111	above	above	IN
18637	9059	112	the	the	DT
18637	9059	113	process	process	NN
18637	9059	114	of	of	IN
18637	9059	115	any	any	DT
18637	9059	116	court	court	NN
18637	9059	117	or	or	CC
18637	9059	118	the	the	DT
18637	9059	119	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	9059	120	of	of	IN
18637	9059	121	any	any	DT
18637	9059	122	court	court	NN
18637	9059	123	to	to	TO
18637	9059	124	bring	bring	VB
18637	9059	125	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9059	126	to	to	TO
18637	9059	127	account	account	VB
18637	9059	128	as	as	IN
18637	9059	129	President	President	NNP
18637	9059	130	.	.	.
18637	9060	1	There	there	EX
18637	9060	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	9060	3	only	only	RB
18637	9060	4	one	one	CD
18637	9060	5	court	court	NN
18637	9060	6	or	or	CC
18637	9060	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9060	8	quasi	quasi	NNP
18637	9060	9	_	_	NNP
18637	9060	10	court	court	NN
18637	9060	11	that	that	IN
18637	9060	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9060	13	can	can	MD
18637	9060	14	be	be	VB
18637	9060	15	called	call	VBN
18637	9060	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	9060	17	to	to	TO
18637	9060	18	answer	answer	VB
18637	9060	19	to	to	IN
18637	9060	20	for	for	IN
18637	9060	21	any	any	DT
18637	9060	22	dereliction	dereliction	NN
18637	9060	23	of	of	IN
18637	9060	24	duty	duty	NN
18637	9060	25	,	,	,
18637	9060	26	for	for	IN
18637	9060	27	doing	do	VBG
18637	9060	28	anything	anything	NN
18637	9060	29	that	that	WDT
18637	9060	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	9060	31	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	9060	32	to	to	IN
18637	9060	33	law	law	NN
18637	9060	34	or	or	CC
18637	9060	35	failing	fail	VBG
18637	9060	36	to	to	TO
18637	9060	37	do	do	VB
18637	9060	38	anything	anything	NN
18637	9060	39	which	which	WDT
18637	9060	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	9060	41	according	accord	VBG
18637	9060	42	to	to	IN
18637	9060	43	law	law	NN
18637	9060	44	,	,	,
18637	9060	45	and	and	CC
18637	9060	46	that	that	DT
18637	9060	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	9060	48	not	not	RB
18637	9060	49	this	this	DT
18637	9060	50	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	9060	51	but	but	CC
18637	9060	52	one	one	NN
18637	9060	53	that	that	WDT
18637	9060	54	sits	sit	VBZ
18637	9060	55	in	in	IN
18637	9060	56	another	another	DT
18637	9060	57	chamber	chamber	NN
18637	9060	58	of	of	IN
18637	9060	59	this	this	DT
18637	9060	60	Capitol	Capitol	NNP
18637	9060	61	.	.	.
18637	9061	1	"	"	``
18637	9061	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9061	3	468	468	CD
18637	9061	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9061	5	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	9061	6	by	by	IN
18637	9061	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	9061	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9061	9	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	9061	10	,	,	,
18637	9061	11	the	the	DT
18637	9061	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9061	13	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	9061	14	:	:	:
18637	9061	15	"	"	``
18637	9061	16	The	the	DT
18637	9061	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9061	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	9061	19	the	the	DT
18637	9061	20	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	9061	21	department	department	NN
18637	9061	22	of	of	IN
18637	9061	23	the	the	DT
18637	9061	24	government	government	NN
18637	9061	25	;	;	:
18637	9061	26	the	the	DT
18637	9061	27	President	President	NNP
18637	9061	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	9061	29	the	the	DT
18637	9061	30	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9061	31	department	department	NN
18637	9061	32	.	.	.
18637	9062	1	Neither	neither	DT
18637	9062	2	can	can	MD
18637	9062	3	be	be	VB
18637	9062	4	restrained	restrain	VBN
18637	9062	5	in	in	IN
18637	9062	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9062	7	action	action	NN
18637	9062	8	by	by	IN
18637	9062	9	the	the	DT
18637	9062	10	judicial	judicial	NNP
18637	9062	11	department	department	NN
18637	9062	12	;	;	:
18637	9062	13	though	though	IN
18637	9062	14	the	the	DT
18637	9062	15	acts	act	NNS
18637	9062	16	of	of	IN
18637	9062	17	both	both	DT
18637	9062	18	,	,	,
18637	9062	19	when	when	WRB
18637	9062	20	performed	perform	VBN
18637	9062	21	,	,	,
18637	9062	22	are	be	VBP
18637	9062	23	,	,	,
18637	9062	24	in	in	IN
18637	9062	25	proper	proper	JJ
18637	9062	26	cases	case	NNS
18637	9062	27	,	,	,
18637	9062	28	subject	subject	JJ
18637	9062	29	to	to	IN
18637	9062	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9062	31	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	9062	32	.	.	.
18637	9063	1	The	the	DT
18637	9063	2	impropriety	impropriety	NN
18637	9063	3	of	of	IN
18637	9063	4	such	such	JJ
18637	9063	5	interference	interference	NN
18637	9063	6	will	will	MD
18637	9063	7	be	be	VB
18637	9063	8	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	9063	9	seen	see	VBN
18637	9063	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	9063	11	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	9063	12	of	of	IN
18637	9063	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9063	14	possible	possible	JJ
18637	9063	15	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	9063	16	.	.	.
18637	9064	1	Suppose	suppose	VB
18637	9064	2	the	the	DT
18637	9064	3	bill	bill	NN
18637	9064	4	filed	file	VBN
18637	9064	5	and	and	CC
18637	9064	6	the	the	DT
18637	9064	7	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	9064	8	prayed	pray	VBD
18637	9064	9	for	for	IN
18637	9064	10	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	9064	11	.	.	.
18637	9065	1	If	if	IN
18637	9065	2	the	the	DT
18637	9065	3	President	President	NNP
18637	9065	4	refuse	refuse	VBP
18637	9065	5	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	9065	6	,	,	,
18637	9065	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9065	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	9065	9	needless	needless	JJ
18637	9065	10	to	to	TO
18637	9065	11	observe	observe	VB
18637	9065	12	that	that	IN
18637	9065	13	the	the	DT
18637	9065	14	court	court	NN
18637	9065	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	9065	16	without	without	IN
18637	9065	17	power	power	NN
18637	9065	18	to	to	TO
18637	9065	19	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	9065	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9065	21	process	process	NN
18637	9065	22	.	.	.
18637	9066	1	If	if	IN
18637	9066	2	,	,	,
18637	9066	3	on	on	IN
18637	9066	4	the	the	DT
18637	9066	5	other	other	JJ
18637	9066	6	hand	hand	NN
18637	9066	7	,	,	,
18637	9066	8	the	the	DT
18637	9066	9	President	President	NNP
18637	9066	10	complies	comply	VBZ
18637	9066	11	with	with	IN
18637	9066	12	the	the	DT
18637	9066	13	order	order	NN
18637	9066	14	of	of	IN
18637	9066	15	the	the	DT
18637	9066	16	court	court	NN
18637	9066	17	and	and	CC
18637	9066	18	refuses	refuse	VBZ
18637	9066	19	to	to	TO
18637	9066	20	execute	execute	VB
18637	9066	21	the	the	DT
18637	9066	22	acts	act	NNS
18637	9066	23	of	of	IN
18637	9066	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9066	25	,	,	,
18637	9066	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	9066	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9066	28	not	not	RB
18637	9066	29	clear	clear	JJ
18637	9066	30	that	that	IN
18637	9066	31	a	a	DT
18637	9066	32	collision	collision	NN
18637	9066	33	may	may	MD
18637	9066	34	occur	occur	VB
18637	9066	35	between	between	IN
18637	9066	36	the	the	DT
18637	9066	37	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9066	38	and	and	CC
18637	9066	39	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	9066	40	departments	department	NNS
18637	9066	41	of	of	IN
18637	9066	42	the	the	DT
18637	9066	43	government	government	NN
18637	9066	44	?	?	.
18637	9067	1	May	May	MD
18637	9067	2	not	not	RB
18637	9067	3	the	the	DT
18637	9067	4	House	House	NNP
18637	9067	5	of	of	IN
18637	9067	6	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	9067	7	impeach	impeach	VBP
18637	9067	8	the	the	DT
18637	9067	9	President	President	NNP
18637	9067	10	for	for	IN
18637	9067	11	such	such	JJ
18637	9067	12	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	9067	13	?	?	.
18637	9068	1	And	and	CC
18637	9068	2	in	in	IN
18637	9068	3	that	that	DT
18637	9068	4	case	case	NN
18637	9068	5	could	could	MD
18637	9068	6	this	this	DT
18637	9068	7	court	court	NN
18637	9068	8	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	9068	9	,	,	,
18637	9068	10	in	in	IN
18637	9068	11	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	9068	12	of	of	IN
18637	9068	13	the	the	DT
18637	9068	14	President	President	NNP
18637	9068	15	,	,	,
18637	9068	16	thus	thus	RB
18637	9068	17	endangered	endanger	VBN
18637	9068	18	by	by	IN
18637	9068	19	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	9068	20	with	with	IN
18637	9068	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9068	22	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	9068	23	,	,	,
18637	9068	24	and	and	CC
18637	9068	25	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	9068	26	by	by	IN
18637	9068	27	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	9068	28	the	the	DT
18637	9068	29	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9068	30	of	of	IN
18637	9068	31	the	the	DT
18637	9068	32	United	United	NNP
18637	9068	33	States	States	NNP
18637	9068	34	from	from	IN
18637	9068	35	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	9068	36	as	as	IN
18637	9068	37	a	a	DT
18637	9068	38	court	court	NN
18637	9068	39	of	of	IN
18637	9068	40	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9068	41	?	?	.
18637	9069	1	Would	Would	MD
18637	9069	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9069	3	not	not	RB
18637	9069	4	?	?	.
18637	9069	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9070	1	the	the	DT
18637	9070	2	strange	strange	JJ
18637	9070	3	spectacle	spectacle	NN
18637	9070	4	be	be	VB
18637	9070	5	offered	offer	VBN
18637	9070	6	to	to	IN
18637	9070	7	the	the	DT
18637	9070	8	public	public	JJ
18637	9070	9	world	world	NN
18637	9070	10	of	of	IN
18637	9070	11	an	an	DT
18637	9070	12	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	9070	13	by	by	IN
18637	9070	14	this	this	DT
18637	9070	15	court	court	NN
18637	9070	16	to	to	TO
18637	9070	17	arrest	arrest	VB
18637	9070	18	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	9070	19	in	in	IN
18637	9070	20	that	that	DT
18637	9070	21	court	court	NN
18637	9070	22	?	?	.
18637	9071	1	"	"	``
18637	9071	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9071	3	469	469	CD
18637	9071	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9071	5	The	the	DT
18637	9071	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9071	7	further	further	RB
18637	9071	8	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	9071	9	that	that	IN
18637	9071	10	the	the	DT
18637	9071	11	same	same	JJ
18637	9071	12	principle	principle	NN
18637	9071	13	would	would	MD
18637	9071	14	apply	apply	VB
18637	9071	15	to	to	IN
18637	9071	16	an	an	DT
18637	9071	17	application	application	NN
18637	9071	18	for	for	IN
18637	9071	19	a	a	DT
18637	9071	20	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	9071	21	ordering	order	VBG
18637	9071	22	the	the	DT
18637	9071	23	President	President	NNP
18637	9071	24	to	to	TO
18637	9071	25	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	9071	26	any	any	DT
18637	9071	27	of	of	IN
18637	9071	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9071	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	9071	30	.	.	.
18637	9072	1	THE	the	DT
18637	9072	2	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	9072	3	'S	's	POS
18637	9072	4	SUBORDINATES	subordinate	NNS
18637	9072	5	AND	and	CC
18637	9072	6	THE	the	DT
18637	9072	7	COURTS	court	NNS
18637	9072	8	But	but	CC
18637	9072	9	while	while	IN
18637	9072	10	the	the	DT
18637	9072	11	courts	court	NNS
18637	9072	12	are	be	VBP
18637	9072	13	unable	unable	JJ
18637	9072	14	to	to	TO
18637	9072	15	compel	compel	VB
18637	9072	16	the	the	DT
18637	9072	17	President	President	NNP
18637	9072	18	to	to	TO
18637	9072	19	act	act	VB
18637	9072	20	or	or	CC
18637	9072	21	to	to	TO
18637	9072	22	keep	keep	VB
18637	9072	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9072	24	from	from	IN
18637	9072	25	acting	act	VBG
18637	9072	26	,	,	,
18637	9072	27	yet	yet	CC
18637	9072	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9072	29	acts	act	NNS
18637	9072	30	,	,	,
18637	9072	31	when	when	WRB
18637	9072	32	performed	perform	VBN
18637	9072	33	are	be	VBP
18637	9072	34	in	in	IN
18637	9072	35	proper	proper	JJ
18637	9072	36	cases	case	NNS
18637	9072	37	subject	subject	JJ
18637	9072	38	to	to	IN
18637	9072	39	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	9072	40	review	review	NN
18637	9072	41	and	and	CC
18637	9072	42	disallowance	disallowance	NN
18637	9072	43	.	.	.
18637	9073	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9073	2	470	470	CD
18637	9073	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9073	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	9073	5	,	,	,
18637	9073	6	the	the	DT
18637	9073	7	subordinates	subordinate	NNS
18637	9073	8	through	through	IN
18637	9073	9	whom	whom	WP
18637	9073	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9073	11	acts	act	VBZ
18637	9073	12	may	may	MD
18637	9073	13	always	always	RB
18637	9073	14	be	be	VB
18637	9073	15	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	9073	16	by	by	IN
18637	9073	17	writ	writ	NN
18637	9073	18	of	of	IN
18637	9073	19	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	9073	20	from	from	IN
18637	9073	21	doing	do	VBG
18637	9073	22	a	a	DT
18637	9073	23	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	9073	24	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	9073	25	act	act	NN
18637	9073	26	which	which	WDT
18637	9073	27	might	may	MD
18637	9073	28	lead	lead	VB
18637	9073	29	to	to	IN
18637	9073	30	irreparable	irreparable	JJ
18637	9073	31	damage,[471	damage,[471	NNP
18637	9073	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9073	33	or	or	CC
18637	9073	34	be	be	VB
18637	9073	35	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	9073	36	by	by	IN
18637	9073	37	writ	writ	NNP
18637	9073	38	of	of	IN
18637	9073	39	mandamus	mandamus	NNP
18637	9073	40	to	to	TO
18637	9073	41	perform	perform	VB
18637	9073	42	a	a	DT
18637	9073	43	duty	duty	NN
18637	9073	44	definitely	definitely	RB
18637	9073	45	required	require	VBN
18637	9073	46	by	by	IN
18637	9073	47	law,[472	law,[472	NNP
18637	9073	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9073	49	such	such	JJ
18637	9073	50	suits	suit	NNS
18637	9073	51	being	be	VBG
18637	9073	52	usually	usually	RB
18637	9073	53	brought	bring	VBN
18637	9073	54	in	in	RP
18637	9073	55	the	the	DT
18637	9073	56	United	United	NNP
18637	9073	57	States	States	NNP
18637	9073	58	District	District	NNP
18637	9073	59	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9073	60	for	for	IN
18637	9073	61	the	the	DT
18637	9073	62	District	District	NNP
18637	9073	63	of	of	IN
18637	9073	64	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	9073	65	.	.	.
18637	9074	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9074	2	473	473	CD
18637	9074	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9074	4	Also	also	RB
18637	9074	5	,	,	,
18637	9074	6	by	by	IN
18637	9074	7	common	common	JJ
18637	9074	8	law	law	NN
18637	9074	9	principles	principle	NNS
18637	9074	10	,	,	,
18637	9074	11	a	a	DT
18637	9074	12	subordinate	subordinate	JJ
18637	9074	13	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9074	14	officer	officer	NN
18637	9074	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	9074	16	personally	personally	RB
18637	9074	17	liable	liable	JJ
18637	9074	18	under	under	IN
18637	9074	19	the	the	DT
18637	9074	20	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	9074	21	law	law	NN
18637	9074	22	for	for	IN
18637	9074	23	any	any	DT
18637	9074	24	act	act	NN
18637	9074	25	done	do	VBN
18637	9074	26	in	in	IN
18637	9074	27	excess	excess	NN
18637	9074	28	of	of	IN
18637	9074	29	authority	authority	NN
18637	9074	30	.	.	.
18637	9075	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9075	2	474	474	CD
18637	9075	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9075	4	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	9075	5	,	,	,
18637	9075	6	by	by	IN
18637	9075	7	a	a	DT
18637	9075	8	recent	recent	JJ
18637	9075	9	holding	holding	NN
18637	9075	10	,	,	,
18637	9075	11	district	district	NN
18637	9075	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	9075	13	of	of	IN
18637	9075	14	the	the	DT
18637	9075	15	United	United	NNP
18637	9075	16	States	States	NNP
18637	9075	17	are	be	VBP
18637	9075	18	bound	bind	VBN
18637	9075	19	to	to	TO
18637	9075	20	entertain	entertain	JJ
18637	9075	21	suits	suit	NNS
18637	9075	22	for	for	IN
18637	9075	23	damages	damage	NNS
18637	9075	24	arising	arise	VBG
18637	9075	25	out	out	IN
18637	9075	26	of	of	IN
18637	9075	27	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	9075	28	violation	violation	NN
18637	9075	29	of	of	IN
18637	9075	30	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	9075	31	's	's	POS
18637	9075	32	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	9075	33	rights	right	NNS
18637	9075	34	,	,	,
18637	9075	35	even	even	RB
18637	9075	36	though	though	IN
18637	9075	37	as	as	IN
18637	9075	38	the	the	DT
18637	9075	39	law	law	NN
18637	9075	40	now	now	RB
18637	9075	41	stands	stand	VBZ
18637	9075	42	the	the	DT
18637	9075	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9075	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	9075	45	powerless	powerless	JJ
18637	9075	46	to	to	TO
18637	9075	47	award	award	VB
18637	9075	48	damages	damage	NNS
18637	9075	49	.	.	.
18637	9076	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9076	2	475	475	CD
18637	9076	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9076	4	But	but	CC
18637	9076	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9076	6	may	may	MD
18637	9076	7	,	,	,
18637	9076	8	in	in	IN
18637	9076	9	certain	certain	JJ
18637	9076	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	9076	11	,	,	,
18637	9076	12	exonerate	exonerate	VB
18637	9076	13	the	the	DT
18637	9076	14	officer	officer	NN
18637	9076	15	by	by	IN
18637	9076	16	a	a	DT
18637	9076	17	so	so	RB
18637	9076	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	9076	19	called	call	VBN
18637	9076	20	act	act	NN
18637	9076	21	of	of	IN
18637	9076	22	indemnity,[476	indemnity,[476	NNP
18637	9076	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9076	24	while	while	IN
18637	9076	25	as	as	IN
18637	9076	26	the	the	DT
18637	9076	27	law	law	NN
18637	9076	28	stands	stand	VBZ
18637	9076	29	at	at	IN
18637	9076	30	present	present	JJ
18637	9076	31	,	,	,
18637	9076	32	any	any	DT
18637	9076	33	officer	officer	NN
18637	9076	34	of	of	IN
18637	9076	35	the	the	DT
18637	9076	36	United	United	NNP
18637	9076	37	States	States	NNP
18637	9076	38	who	who	WP
18637	9076	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	9076	40	charged	charge	VBN
18637	9076	41	with	with	IN
18637	9076	42	a	a	DT
18637	9076	43	crime	crime	NN
18637	9076	44	under	under	IN
18637	9076	45	the	the	DT
18637	9076	46	laws	law	NNS
18637	9076	47	of	of	IN
18637	9076	48	a	a	DT
18637	9076	49	State	State	NNP
18637	9076	50	for	for	IN
18637	9076	51	an	an	DT
18637	9076	52	act	act	NN
18637	9076	53	done	do	VBN
18637	9076	54	under	under	IN
18637	9076	55	the	the	DT
18637	9076	56	authority	authority	NN
18637	9076	57	of	of	IN
18637	9076	58	the	the	DT
18637	9076	59	United	United	NNP
18637	9076	60	States	States	NNP
18637	9076	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	9076	62	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	9076	63	to	to	TO
18637	9076	64	have	have	VB
18637	9076	65	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9076	66	case	case	NN
18637	9076	67	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	9076	68	to	to	IN
18637	9076	69	the	the	DT
18637	9076	70	national	national	JJ
18637	9076	71	courts	court	NNS
18637	9076	72	.	.	.
18637	9077	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9077	2	477	477	CD
18637	9077	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9077	4	Section	section	NN
18637	9077	5	4	4	CD
18637	9077	6	.	.	.
18637	9078	1	The	the	DT
18637	9078	2	President	President	NNP
18637	9078	3	,	,	,
18637	9078	4	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	9078	5	President	President	NNP
18637	9078	6	and	and	CC
18637	9078	7	all	all	DT
18637	9078	8	civil	civil	JJ
18637	9078	9	Officers	officer	NNS
18637	9078	10	of	of	IN
18637	9078	11	the	the	DT
18637	9078	12	United	United	NNP
18637	9078	13	States	States	NNP
18637	9078	14	,	,	,
18637	9078	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	9078	16	be	be	VB
18637	9078	17	removed	remove	VBN
18637	9078	18	from	from	IN
18637	9078	19	Office	Office	NNP
18637	9078	20	on	on	IN
18637	9078	21	Impeachment	Impeachment	NNP
18637	9078	22	for	for	IN
18637	9078	23	,	,	,
18637	9078	24	and	and	CC
18637	9078	25	Conviction	Conviction	NNP
18637	9078	26	of	of	IN
18637	9078	27	,	,	,
18637	9078	28	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	9078	29	,	,	,
18637	9078	30	Bribery	Bribery	NNP
18637	9078	31	,	,	,
18637	9078	32	or	or	CC
18637	9078	33	other	other	JJ
18637	9078	34	high	high	JJ
18637	9078	35	Crimes	Crimes	NNPS
18637	9078	36	and	and	CC
18637	9078	37	Misdemeanors	Misdemeanors	NNPS
18637	9078	38	.	.	.
18637	9079	1	Impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9079	2	"	"	``
18637	9079	3	CIVIL	CIVIL	NNP
18637	9079	4	OFFICER	officer	NN
18637	9079	5	"	"	''
18637	9079	6	A	a	DT
18637	9079	7	Member	Member	NNP
18637	9079	8	of	of	IN
18637	9079	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9079	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	9079	11	not	not	RB
18637	9079	12	a	a	DT
18637	9079	13	civil	civil	JJ
18637	9079	14	officer	officer	NN
18637	9079	15	within	within	IN
18637	9079	16	the	the	DT
18637	9079	17	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	9079	18	of	of	IN
18637	9079	19	this	this	DT
18637	9079	20	section	section	NN
18637	9079	21	;	;	:
18637	9079	22	nor	nor	CC
18637	9079	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	9079	24	a	a	DT
18637	9079	25	private	private	JJ
18637	9079	26	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	9079	27	subject	subject	JJ
18637	9079	28	to	to	IN
18637	9079	29	impeachment;[478	impeachment;[478	NNPS
18637	9079	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9079	31	but	but	CC
18637	9079	32	resignation	resignation	NN
18637	9079	33	of	of	IN
18637	9079	34	an	an	DT
18637	9079	35	officer	officer	NN
18637	9079	36	does	do	VBZ
18637	9079	37	not	not	RB
18637	9079	38	give	give	VB
18637	9079	39	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	9079	40	from	from	IN
18637	9079	41	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9079	42	for	for	IN
18637	9079	43	acts	act	NNS
18637	9079	44	committed	commit	VBN
18637	9079	45	while	while	IN
18637	9079	46	in	in	IN
18637	9079	47	office	office	NN
18637	9079	48	.	.	.
18637	9080	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9080	2	479	479	CD
18637	9080	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9080	4	"	"	``
18637	9080	5	HIGH	high	JJ
18637	9080	6	CRIMES	crime	NNS
18637	9080	7	AND	and	CC
18637	9080	8	MISDEMEANORS	misdemeanors	NN
18637	9080	9	"	"	''
18637	9080	10	Most	Most	JJS
18637	9080	11	of	of	IN
18637	9080	12	the	the	DT
18637	9080	13	States	States	NNPS
18637	9080	14	have	have	VBP
18637	9080	15	drafted	draft	VBN
18637	9080	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9080	17	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	9080	18	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	9080	19	on	on	IN
18637	9080	20	this	this	DT
18637	9080	21	subject	subject	NN
18637	9080	22	in	in	IN
18637	9080	23	similar	similar	JJ
18637	9080	24	language	language	NN
18637	9080	25	.	.	.
18637	9081	1	As	as	IN
18637	9081	2	there	there	EX
18637	9081	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	9081	4	no	no	DT
18637	9081	5	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	9081	6	of	of	IN
18637	9081	7	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	9081	8	comprised	comprise	VBN
18637	9081	9	under	under	IN
18637	9081	10	the	the	DT
18637	9081	11	last	last	JJ
18637	9081	12	two	two	CD
18637	9081	13	categories	category	NNS
18637	9081	14	,	,	,
18637	9081	15	no	no	DT
18637	9081	16	little	little	JJ
18637	9081	17	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	9081	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	9081	19	been	be	VBN
18637	9081	20	experienced	experience	VBN
18637	9081	21	in	in	IN
18637	9081	22	defining	define	VBG
18637	9081	23	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	9081	24	in	in	IN
18637	9081	25	such	such	PDT
18637	9081	26	a	a	DT
18637	9081	27	way	way	NN
18637	9081	28	that	that	WDT
18637	9081	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9081	30	fall	fall	VBP
18637	9081	31	within	within	IN
18637	9081	32	the	the	DT
18637	9081	33	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	9081	34	of	of	IN
18637	9081	35	the	the	DT
18637	9081	36	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	9081	37	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	9081	38	.	.	.
18637	9082	1	But	but	CC
18637	9082	2	impeachable	impeachable	JJ
18637	9082	3	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	9082	4	were	be	VBD
18637	9082	5	not	not	RB
18637	9082	6	defined	define	VBN
18637	9082	7	in	in	IN
18637	9082	8	England	England	NNP
18637	9082	9	,	,	,
18637	9082	10	and	and	CC
18637	9082	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9082	12	was	be	VBD
18637	9082	13	not	not	RB
18637	9082	14	the	the	DT
18637	9082	15	intention	intention	NN
18637	9082	16	that	that	WDT
18637	9082	17	the	the	DT
18637	9082	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9082	19	should	should	MD
18637	9082	20	attempt	attempt	VB
18637	9082	21	an	an	DT
18637	9082	22	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	9082	23	of	of	IN
18637	9082	24	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	9082	25	or	or	CC
18637	9082	26	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	9082	27	for	for	IN
18637	9082	28	which	which	WDT
18637	9082	29	an	an	DT
18637	9082	30	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9082	31	would	would	MD
18637	9082	32	lie	lie	VB
18637	9082	33	.	.	.
18637	9083	1	Treason	treason	NN
18637	9083	2	and	and	CC
18637	9083	3	bribery	bribery	NN
18637	9083	4	have	have	VBP
18637	9083	5	always	always	RB
18637	9083	6	been	be	VBN
18637	9083	7	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	9083	8	whose	whose	WP$
18637	9083	9	nature	nature	NN
18637	9083	10	was	be	VBD
18637	9083	11	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	9083	12	understood	understand	VBN
18637	9083	13	.	.	.
18637	9084	1	Other	other	JJ
18637	9084	2	high	high	JJ
18637	9084	3	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	9084	4	and	and	CC
18637	9084	5	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
18637	9084	6	which	which	WDT
18637	9084	7	might	may	MD
18637	9084	8	be	be	VB
18637	9084	9	made	make	VBN
18637	9084	10	causes	cause	NNS
18637	9084	11	for	for	IN
18637	9084	12	the	the	DT
18637	9084	13	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9084	14	of	of	IN
18637	9084	15	civil	civil	JJ
18637	9084	16	officers	officer	NNS
18637	9084	17	were	be	VBD
18637	9084	18	those	those	DT
18637	9084	19	which	which	WDT
18637	9084	20	embraced	embrace	VBD
18637	9084	21	any	any	DT
18637	9084	22	misbehavior	misbehavior	JJ
18637	9084	23	while	while	IN
18637	9084	24	in	in	IN
18637	9084	25	office	office	NN
18637	9084	26	.	.	.
18637	9085	1	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	9085	2	,	,	,
18637	9085	3	whose	whose	WP$
18637	9085	4	objection	objection	NN
18637	9085	5	led	lead	VBD
18637	9085	6	to	to	IN
18637	9085	7	the	the	DT
18637	9085	8	insertion	insertion	NN
18637	9085	9	of	of	IN
18637	9085	10	the	the	DT
18637	9085	11	more	more	RBR
18637	9085	12	definite	definite	JJ
18637	9085	13	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	9085	14	high	high	JJ
18637	9085	15	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	9085	16	and	and	CC
18637	9085	17	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
18637	9085	18	,	,	,
18637	9085	19	was	be	VBD
18637	9085	20	the	the	DT
18637	9085	21	strongest	strong	JJS
18637	9085	22	advocate	advocate	NN
18637	9085	23	of	of	IN
18637	9085	24	a	a	DT
18637	9085	25	broad	broad	JJ
18637	9085	26	construction	construction	NN
18637	9085	27	of	of	IN
18637	9085	28	the	the	DT
18637	9085	29	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9085	30	power	power	NN
18637	9085	31	.	.	.
18637	9086	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9086	2	argued	argue	VBD
18637	9086	3	that	that	IN
18637	9086	4	incapacity	incapacity	NN
18637	9086	5	,	,	,
18637	9086	6	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	9086	7	,	,	,
18637	9086	8	or	or	CC
18637	9086	9	perfidy	perfidy	NN
18637	9086	10	of	of	IN
18637	9086	11	the	the	DT
18637	9086	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	9086	13	Magistrate	Magistrate	NNP
18637	9086	14	should	should	MD
18637	9086	15	be	be	VB
18637	9086	16	ground	grind	VBN
18637	9086	17	for	for	IN
18637	9086	18	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9086	19	.	.	.
18637	9087	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9087	2	480	480	CD
18637	9087	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9087	4	Again	again	RB
18637	9087	5	,	,	,
18637	9087	6	in	in	IN
18637	9087	7	discussing	discuss	VBG
18637	9087	8	the	the	DT
18637	9087	9	President	President	NNP
18637	9087	10	's	's	POS
18637	9087	11	power	power	NN
18637	9087	12	of	of	IN
18637	9087	13	removal	removal	NN
18637	9087	14	,	,	,
18637	9087	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9087	16	maintained	maintain	VBD
18637	9087	17	that	that	IN
18637	9087	18	the	the	DT
18637	9087	19	wanton	wanton	NNP
18637	9087	20	removal	removal	NN
18637	9087	21	from	from	IN
18637	9087	22	office	office	NNP
18637	9087	23	of	of	IN
18637	9087	24	meritorious	meritorious	JJ
18637	9087	25	officers	officer	NNS
18637	9087	26	would	would	MD
18637	9087	27	be	be	VB
18637	9087	28	an	an	DT
18637	9087	29	act	act	NN
18637	9087	30	of	of	IN
18637	9087	31	maladministration	maladministration	NN
18637	9087	32	,	,	,
18637	9087	33	and	and	CC
18637	9087	34	would	would	MD
18637	9087	35	render	render	VB
18637	9087	36	the	the	DT
18637	9087	37	President	President	NNP
18637	9087	38	liable	liable	JJ
18637	9087	39	to	to	TO
18637	9087	40	impeachment	impeachment	VB
18637	9087	41	.	.	.
18637	9088	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9088	2	481	481	CD
18637	9088	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9088	4	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	9088	5	thought	think	VBD
18637	9088	6	the	the	DT
18637	9088	7	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	9088	8	could	could	MD
18637	9088	9	"	"	``
18637	9088	10	never	never	RB
18637	9088	11	be	be	VB
18637	9088	12	tied	tie	VBN
18637	9088	13	down	down	RP
18637	9088	14	by	by	IN
18637	9088	15	such	such	JJ
18637	9088	16	strict	strict	JJ
18637	9088	17	rules	rule	NNS
18637	9088	18	,	,	,
18637	9088	19	either	either	CC
18637	9088	20	in	in	IN
18637	9088	21	the	the	DT
18637	9088	22	delineation	delineation	NN
18637	9088	23	of	of	IN
18637	9088	24	the	the	DT
18637	9088	25	offense	offense	NN
18637	9088	26	by	by	IN
18637	9088	27	the	the	DT
18637	9088	28	prosecutors	prosecutor	NNS
18637	9088	29	,	,	,
18637	9088	30	or	or	CC
18637	9088	31	in	in	IN
18637	9088	32	the	the	DT
18637	9088	33	construction	construction	NN
18637	9088	34	of	of	IN
18637	9088	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9088	36	by	by	IN
18637	9088	37	the	the	DT
18637	9088	38	judges	judge	NNS
18637	9088	39	,	,	,
18637	9088	40	as	as	IN
18637	9088	41	in	in	IN
18637	9088	42	common	common	JJ
18637	9088	43	cases	case	NNS
18637	9088	44	serve	serve	VBP
18637	9088	45	to	to	TO
18637	9088	46	limit	limit	VB
18637	9088	47	the	the	DT
18637	9088	48	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	9088	49	of	of	IN
18637	9088	50	the	the	DT
18637	9088	51	courts	court	NNS
18637	9088	52	in	in	IN
18637	9088	53	favor	favor	NN
18637	9088	54	of	of	IN
18637	9088	55	personal	personal	JJ
18637	9088	56	security	security	NN
18637	9088	57	.	.	.
18637	9089	1	"	"	``
18637	9089	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9089	3	482	482	CD
18637	9089	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9089	5	THE	the	DT
18637	9089	6	CHASE	CHASE	NNP
18637	9089	7	IMPEACHMENT	IMPEACHMENT	VBD
18637	9089	8	The	the	DT
18637	9089	9	above	above	RB
18637	9089	10	relatively	relatively	RB
18637	9089	11	flexible	flexible	JJ
18637	9089	12	conception	conception	NN
18637	9089	13	of	of	IN
18637	9089	14	"	"	``
18637	9089	15	high	high	JJ
18637	9089	16	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	9089	17	and	and	CC
18637	9089	18	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
18637	9089	19	"	"	''
18637	9089	20	was	be	VBD
18637	9089	21	,	,	,
18637	9089	22	however	however	RB
18637	9089	23	,	,	,
18637	9089	24	early	early	RB
18637	9089	25	replaced	replace	VBN
18637	9089	26	by	by	IN
18637	9089	27	a	a	DT
18637	9089	28	much	much	RB
18637	9089	29	more	more	RBR
18637	9089	30	rigid	rigid	JJ
18637	9089	31	one	one	CD
18637	9089	32	in	in	IN
18637	9089	33	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	9089	34	of	of	IN
18637	9089	35	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	9089	36	's	's	POS
18637	9089	37	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	9089	38	to	to	TO
18637	9089	39	diminish	diminish	VB
18637	9089	40	the	the	DT
18637	9089	41	importance	importance	NN
18637	9089	42	of	of	IN
18637	9089	43	the	the	DT
18637	9089	44	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	9089	45	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9089	46	,	,	,
18637	9089	47	the	the	DT
18637	9089	48	first	first	JJ
18637	9089	49	step	step	NN
18637	9089	50	in	in	IN
18637	9089	51	which	which	WDT
18637	9089	52	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	9089	53	was	be	VBD
18637	9089	54	the	the	DT
18637	9089	55	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9089	56	in	in	IN
18637	9089	57	1805	1805	CD
18637	9089	58	of	of	IN
18637	9089	59	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9089	60	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
18637	9089	61	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	9089	62	.	.	.
18637	9090	1	The	the	DT
18637	9090	2	theory	theory	NN
18637	9090	3	of	of	IN
18637	9090	4	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	9090	5	's	's	POS
18637	9090	6	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	9090	7	was	be	VBD
18637	9090	8	given	give	VBN
18637	9090	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9090	10	extremest	extreme	JJS
18637	9090	11	expression	expression	NN
18637	9090	12	by	by	IN
18637	9090	13	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	9090	14	's	's	POS
18637	9090	15	henchman	henchman	NN
18637	9090	16	,	,	,
18637	9090	17	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	9090	18	Giles	Giles	NNP
18637	9090	19	of	of	IN
18637	9090	20	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	9090	21	,	,	,
18637	9090	22	as	as	IN
18637	9090	23	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	9090	24	:	:	:
18637	9090	25	"	"	``
18637	9090	26	Impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9090	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	9090	28	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	9090	29	more	more	JJR
18637	9090	30	than	than	IN
18637	9090	31	an	an	DT
18637	9090	32	enquiry	enquiry	NN
18637	9090	33	,	,	,
18637	9090	34	by	by	IN
18637	9090	35	the	the	DT
18637	9090	36	two	two	CD
18637	9090	37	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	9090	38	of	of	IN
18637	9090	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9090	40	,	,	,
18637	9090	41	whether	whether	IN
18637	9090	42	the	the	DT
18637	9090	43	office	office	NN
18637	9090	44	of	of	IN
18637	9090	45	any	any	DT
18637	9090	46	public	public	JJ
18637	9090	47	man	man	NN
18637	9090	48	might	may	MD
18637	9090	49	not	not	RB
18637	9090	50	be	be	VB
18637	9090	51	better	well	RBR
18637	9090	52	filled	fill	VBN
18637	9090	53	by	by	IN
18637	9090	54	another	another	DT
18637	9090	55	.	.	.
18637	9091	1	*	*	NFP
18637	9091	2	*	*	NFP
18637	9091	3	*	*	NFP
18637	9091	4	The	the	DT
18637	9091	5	power	power	NN
18637	9091	6	of	of	IN
18637	9091	7	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9091	8	was	be	VBD
18637	9091	9	given	give	VBN
18637	9091	10	without	without	IN
18637	9091	11	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	9091	12	to	to	IN
18637	9091	13	the	the	DT
18637	9091	14	House	House	NNP
18637	9091	15	of	of	IN
18637	9091	16	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	9091	17	;	;	:
18637	9091	18	and	and	CC
18637	9091	19	the	the	DT
18637	9091	20	power	power	NN
18637	9091	21	of	of	IN
18637	9091	22	trying	try	VBG
18637	9091	23	impeachments	impeachment	NNS
18637	9091	24	was	be	VBD
18637	9091	25	given	give	VBN
18637	9091	26	equally	equally	RB
18637	9091	27	without	without	IN
18637	9091	28	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	9091	29	to	to	IN
18637	9091	30	the	the	DT
18637	9091	31	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9091	32	;	;	:
18637	9091	33	*	*	NFP
18637	9091	34	*	*	NFP
18637	9091	35	*	*	NFP
18637	9091	36	A	a	DT
18637	9091	37	trial	trial	NN
18637	9091	38	and	and	CC
18637	9091	39	removal	removal	NN
18637	9091	40	of	of	IN
18637	9091	41	a	a	DT
18637	9091	42	judge	judge	NN
18637	9091	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	9091	44	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9091	45	need	nee	MD
18637	9091	46	not	not	RB
18637	9091	47	imply	imply	VB
18637	9091	48	any	any	DT
18637	9091	49	criminality	criminality	NN
18637	9091	50	or	or	CC
18637	9091	51	corruption	corruption	NN
18637	9091	52	in	in	IN
18637	9091	53	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9091	54	.	.	.
18637	9092	1	*	*	NFP
18637	9092	2	*	*	NFP
18637	9092	3	*	*	NFP
18637	9092	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9092	5	but	but	CC
18637	9092	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9092	7	was	be	VBD
18637	9092	8	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	9092	9	more	more	JJR
18637	9092	10	than	than	IN
18637	9092	11	a	a	DT
18637	9092	12	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	9092	13	of	of	IN
18637	9092	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9092	15	to	to	IN
18637	9092	16	this	this	DT
18637	9092	17	effect	effect	NN
18637	9092	18	:	:	:
18637	9092	19	You	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9092	20	hold	hold	VBP
18637	9092	21	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	9092	22	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	9092	23	,	,	,
18637	9092	24	and	and	CC
18637	9092	25	if	if	IN
18637	9092	26	you	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9092	27	are	be	VBP
18637	9092	28	suffered	suffer	VBN
18637	9092	29	to	to	TO
18637	9092	30	carry	carry	VB
18637	9092	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9092	32	into	into	IN
18637	9092	33	effect	effect	NN
18637	9092	34	you	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9092	35	will	will	MD
18637	9092	36	work	work	VB
18637	9092	37	the	the	DT
18637	9092	38	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	9092	39	of	of	IN
18637	9092	40	the	the	DT
18637	9092	41	nation	nation	NN
18637	9092	42	.	.	.
18637	9093	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9093	2	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9093	3	want	want	VBP
18637	9093	4	your	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9093	5	offices	office	NNS
18637	9093	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9093	7	,	,	,
18637	9093	8	for	for	IN
18637	9093	9	the	the	DT
18637	9093	10	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	9093	11	of	of	IN
18637	9093	12	giving	give	VBG
18637	9093	13	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9093	14	to	to	IN
18637	9093	15	men	man	NNS
18637	9093	16	who	who	WP
18637	9093	17	will	will	MD
18637	9093	18	fill	fill	VB
18637	9093	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9093	20	better	well	RBR
18637	9093	21	.	.	.
18637	9094	1	"	"	``
18637	9094	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9094	3	483	483	CD
18637	9094	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9094	5	To	to	IN
18637	9094	6	this	this	DT
18637	9094	7	theory	theory	NN
18637	9094	8	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	9094	9	's	's	POS
18637	9094	10	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	9094	11	opposed	oppose	VBD
18637	9094	12	the	the	DT
18637	9094	13	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	9094	14	that	that	IN
18637	9094	15	"	"	``
18637	9094	16	high	high	JJ
18637	9094	17	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	9094	18	and	and	CC
18637	9094	19	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
18637	9094	20	"	"	``
18637	9094	21	meant	mean	VBN
18637	9094	22	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	9094	23	indictable	indictable	JJ
18637	9094	24	at	at	IN
18637	9094	25	common	common	JJ
18637	9094	26	law	law	NN
18637	9094	27	;	;	:
18637	9094	28	and	and	CC
18637	9094	29	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	9094	30	's	's	POS
18637	9094	31	acquittal	acquittal	NN
18637	9094	32	went	go	VBD
18637	9094	33	far	far	RB
18637	9094	34	to	to	TO
18637	9094	35	affix	affix	VB
18637	9094	36	this	this	DT
18637	9094	37	reading	reading	NN
18637	9094	38	to	to	IN
18637	9094	39	the	the	DT
18637	9094	40	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	9094	41	till	till	IN
18637	9094	42	after	after	IN
18637	9094	43	the	the	DT
18637	9094	44	War	War	NNP
18637	9094	45	between	between	IN
18637	9094	46	the	the	DT
18637	9094	47	States	States	NNP
18637	9094	48	.	.	.
18637	9095	1	THE	the	DT
18637	9095	2	JOHNSON	JOHNSON	NNP
18637	9095	3	IMPEACHMENT	IMPEACHMENT	NNP
18637	9095	4	But	but	CC
18637	9095	5	with	with	IN
18637	9095	6	the	the	DT
18637	9095	7	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9095	8	of	of	IN
18637	9095	9	President	President	NNP
18637	9095	10	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	9095	11	in	in	IN
18637	9095	12	1867	1867	CD
18637	9095	13	for	for	IN
18637	9095	14	"	"	``
18637	9095	15	high	high	JJ
18637	9095	16	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	9095	17	and	and	CC
18637	9095	18	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
18637	9095	19	,	,	,
18637	9095	20	"	"	''
18637	9095	21	the	the	DT
18637	9095	22	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	9095	23	was	be	VBD
18637	9095	24	revived	revive	VBN
18637	9095	25	.	.	.
18637	9096	1	Representative	Representative	NNP
18637	9096	2	Bingham	Bingham	NNP
18637	9096	3	,	,	,
18637	9096	4	leader	leader	NN
18637	9096	5	of	of	IN
18637	9096	6	the	the	DT
18637	9096	7	House	House	NNP
18637	9096	8	Managers	Managers	NNPS
18637	9096	9	of	of	IN
18637	9096	10	the	the	DT
18637	9096	11	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9096	12	,	,	,
18637	9096	13	defined	define	VBD
18637	9096	14	an	an	DT
18637	9096	15	impeachable	impeachable	JJ
18637	9096	16	offense	offense	NN
18637	9096	17	as	as	IN
18637	9096	18	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	9096	19	:	:	:
18637	9096	20	"	"	``
18637	9096	21	An	an	DT
18637	9096	22	impeachable	impeachable	JJ
18637	9096	23	high	high	JJ
18637	9096	24	crime	crime	NN
18637	9096	25	or	or	CC
18637	9096	26	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
18637	9096	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	9096	28	one	one	CD
18637	9096	29	in	in	IN
18637	9096	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9096	31	nature	nature	NN
18637	9096	32	or	or	CC
18637	9096	33	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	9096	34	subversive	subversive	JJ
18637	9096	35	of	of	IN
18637	9096	36	some	some	DT
18637	9096	37	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	9096	38	or	or	CC
18637	9096	39	essential	essential	JJ
18637	9096	40	principle	principle	NN
18637	9096	41	of	of	IN
18637	9096	42	government	government	NN
18637	9096	43	or	or	CC
18637	9096	44	highly	highly	RB
18637	9096	45	prejudicial	prejudicial	JJ
18637	9096	46	to	to	IN
18637	9096	47	the	the	DT
18637	9096	48	public	public	JJ
18637	9096	49	interest	interest	NN
18637	9096	50	,	,	,
18637	9096	51	and	and	CC
18637	9096	52	this	this	DT
18637	9096	53	may	may	MD
18637	9096	54	consist	consist	VB
18637	9096	55	of	of	IN
18637	9096	56	a	a	DT
18637	9096	57	violation	violation	NN
18637	9096	58	of	of	IN
18637	9096	59	the	the	DT
18637	9096	60	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9096	61	,	,	,
18637	9096	62	of	of	IN
18637	9096	63	law	law	NN
18637	9096	64	,	,	,
18637	9096	65	of	of	IN
18637	9096	66	an	an	DT
18637	9096	67	official	official	JJ
18637	9096	68	oath	oath	NN
18637	9096	69	,	,	,
18637	9096	70	or	or	CC
18637	9096	71	of	of	IN
18637	9096	72	duty	duty	NN
18637	9096	73	,	,	,
18637	9096	74	by	by	IN
18637	9096	75	an	an	DT
18637	9096	76	act	act	NN
18637	9096	77	committed	commit	VBN
18637	9096	78	or	or	CC
18637	9096	79	omitted	omit	VBN
18637	9096	80	,	,	,
18637	9096	81	or	or	CC
18637	9096	82	,	,	,
18637	9096	83	without	without	IN
18637	9096	84	violating	violate	VBG
18637	9096	85	a	a	DT
18637	9096	86	positive	positive	JJ
18637	9096	87	law	law	NN
18637	9096	88	,	,	,
18637	9096	89	by	by	IN
18637	9096	90	the	the	DT
18637	9096	91	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	9096	92	of	of	IN
18637	9096	93	discretionary	discretionary	JJ
18637	9096	94	powers	power	NNS
18637	9096	95	from	from	IN
18637	9096	96	improper	improper	JJ
18637	9096	97	motives	motive	NNS
18637	9096	98	or	or	CC
18637	9096	99	for	for	IN
18637	9096	100	an	an	DT
18637	9096	101	improper	improper	JJ
18637	9096	102	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	9096	103	.	.	.
18637	9097	1	"	"	``
18637	9097	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9097	3	484	484	CD
18637	9097	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9097	5	Former	Former	NNP
18637	9097	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9097	7	Benjamin	Benjamin	NNP
18637	9097	8	R.	R.	NNP
18637	9097	9	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	9097	10	stated	state	VBD
18637	9097	11	the	the	DT
18637	9097	12	position	position	NN
18637	9097	13	of	of	IN
18637	9097	14	the	the	DT
18637	9097	15	defense	defense	NN
18637	9097	16	in	in	IN
18637	9097	17	these	these	DT
18637	9097	18	words	word	NNS
18637	9097	19	:	:	:
18637	9097	20	"	"	``
18637	9097	21	My	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9097	22	first	first	JJ
18637	9097	23	position	position	NN
18637	9097	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	9097	25	,	,	,
18637	9097	26	that	that	IN
18637	9097	27	when	when	WRB
18637	9097	28	the	the	DT
18637	9097	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9097	30	speaks	speak	VBZ
18637	9097	31	of	of	IN
18637	9097	32	'	'	``
18637	9097	33	treason	treason	NN
18637	9097	34	,	,	,
18637	9097	35	bribery	bribery	NN
18637	9097	36	,	,	,
18637	9097	37	and	and	CC
18637	9097	38	other	other	JJ
18637	9097	39	high	high	JJ
18637	9097	40	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	9097	41	and	and	CC
18637	9097	42	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
18637	9097	43	,	,	,
18637	9097	44	'	'	''
18637	9097	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9097	46	refers	refer	VBZ
18637	9097	47	to	to	IN
18637	9097	48	,	,	,
18637	9097	49	and	and	CC
18637	9097	50	includes	include	VBZ
18637	9097	51	only	only	RB
18637	9097	52	,	,	,
18637	9097	53	high	high	JJ
18637	9097	54	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	9097	55	offences	offence	NNS
18637	9097	56	against	against	IN
18637	9097	57	the	the	DT
18637	9097	58	United	United	NNP
18637	9097	59	States	States	NNP
18637	9097	60	,	,	,
18637	9097	61	made	make	VBN
18637	9097	62	so	so	IN
18637	9097	63	by	by	IN
18637	9097	64	some	some	DT
18637	9097	65	law	law	NN
18637	9097	66	of	of	IN
18637	9097	67	the	the	DT
18637	9097	68	United	United	NNP
18637	9097	69	States	States	NNP
18637	9097	70	existing	exist	VBG
18637	9097	71	when	when	WRB
18637	9097	72	the	the	DT
18637	9097	73	acts	act	NNS
18637	9097	74	complained	complain	VBD
18637	9097	75	of	of	IN
18637	9097	76	were	be	VBD
18637	9097	77	done	do	VBN
18637	9097	78	,	,	,
18637	9097	79	and	and	CC
18637	9097	80	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9097	81	say	say	VBP
18637	9097	82	that	that	IN
18637	9097	83	this	this	DT
18637	9097	84	is	be	VBZ
18637	9097	85	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	9097	86	to	to	TO
18637	9097	87	be	be	VB
18637	9097	88	inferred	infer	VBN
18637	9097	89	from	from	IN
18637	9097	90	each	each	DT
18637	9097	91	and	and	CC
18637	9097	92	every	every	DT
18637	9097	93	provision	provision	NN
18637	9097	94	of	of	IN
18637	9097	95	the	the	DT
18637	9097	96	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9097	97	on	on	IN
18637	9097	98	the	the	DT
18637	9097	99	subject	subject	NN
18637	9097	100	of	of	IN
18637	9097	101	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9097	102	.	.	.
18637	9098	1	"	"	``
18637	9098	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9098	3	485	485	CD
18637	9098	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9098	5	LATER	later	JJ
18637	9098	6	IMPEACHMENTS	IMPEACHMENTS	NNP
18637	9098	7	With	with	IN
18637	9098	8	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	9098	9	's	's	POS
18637	9098	10	acquittal	acquittal	NN
18637	9098	11	,	,	,
18637	9098	12	the	the	DT
18637	9098	13	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	9098	14	view	view	NN
18637	9098	15	of	of	IN
18637	9098	16	"	"	``
18637	9098	17	high	high	JJ
18637	9098	18	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	9098	19	and	and	CC
18637	9098	20	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
18637	9098	21	"	"	``
18637	9098	22	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	9098	23	again	again	RB
18637	9098	24	to	to	TO
18637	9098	25	win	win	VB
18637	9098	26	out	out	RP
18637	9098	27	.	.	.
18637	9099	1	Two	two	CD
18637	9099	2	successful	successful	JJ
18637	9099	3	impeachments	impeachment	NNS
18637	9099	4	of	of	IN
18637	9099	5	lower	low	JJR
18637	9099	6	federal	federal	JJ
18637	9099	7	judges	judge	NNS
18637	9099	8	in	in	IN
18637	9099	9	recent	recent	JJ
18637	9099	10	years	year	NNS
18637	9099	11	have	have	VBP
18637	9099	12	,	,	,
18637	9099	13	however	however	RB
18637	9099	14	,	,	,
18637	9099	15	restored	restore	VBD
18637	9099	16	something	something	NN
18637	9099	17	like	like	IN
18637	9099	18	the	the	DT
18637	9099	19	broader	broad	JJR
18637	9099	20	conception	conception	NN
18637	9099	21	of	of	IN
18637	9099	22	the	the	DT
18637	9099	23	term	term	NN
18637	9099	24	which	which	WDT
18637	9099	25	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	9099	26	and	and	CC
18637	9099	27	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	9099	28	had	have	VBD
18637	9099	29	endorsed	endorse	VBN
18637	9099	30	.	.	.
18637	9100	1	In	in	IN
18637	9100	2	1913	1913	CD
18637	9100	3	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	9100	4	Archbald	Archbald	NNP
18637	9100	5	of	of	IN
18637	9100	6	the	the	DT
18637	9100	7	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	9100	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9100	9	was	be	VBD
18637	9100	10	removed	remove	VBN
18637	9100	11	from	from	IN
18637	9100	12	office	office	NN
18637	9100	13	by	by	IN
18637	9100	14	the	the	DT
18637	9100	15	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9100	16	process	process	NN
18637	9100	17	,	,	,
18637	9100	18	and	and	CC
18637	9100	19	disqualified	disqualify	VBD
18637	9100	20	to	to	TO
18637	9100	21	hold	hold	VB
18637	9100	22	and	and	CC
18637	9100	23	enjoy	enjoy	VB
18637	9100	24	any	any	DT
18637	9100	25	office	office	NN
18637	9100	26	of	of	IN
18637	9100	27	honor	honor	NN
18637	9100	28	,	,	,
18637	9100	29	profit	profit	NN
18637	9100	30	or	or	CC
18637	9100	31	trust	trust	NN
18637	9100	32	under	under	IN
18637	9100	33	the	the	DT
18637	9100	34	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9100	35	,	,	,
18637	9100	36	for	for	IN
18637	9100	37	soliciting	solicit	VBG
18637	9100	38	for	for	IN
18637	9100	39	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9100	40	and	and	CC
18637	9100	41	friends	friend	NNS
18637	9100	42	valuable	valuable	JJ
18637	9100	43	favors	favor	NNS
18637	9100	44	from	from	IN
18637	9100	45	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	9100	46	companies	company	NNS
18637	9100	47	some	some	DT
18637	9100	48	of	of	IN
18637	9100	49	which	which	WDT
18637	9100	50	were	be	VBD
18637	9100	51	at	at	IN
18637	9100	52	the	the	DT
18637	9100	53	time	time	NN
18637	9100	54	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	9100	55	in	in	IN
18637	9100	56	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9100	57	court	court	NN
18637	9100	58	,	,	,
18637	9100	59	although	although	IN
18637	9100	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9100	61	was	be	VBD
18637	9100	62	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	9100	63	that	that	IN
18637	9100	64	in	in	IN
18637	9100	65	so	so	RB
18637	9100	66	doing	do	VBG
18637	9100	67	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9100	68	had	have	VBD
18637	9100	69	not	not	RB
18637	9100	70	committed	commit	VBN
18637	9100	71	an	an	DT
18637	9100	72	indictable	indictable	JJ
18637	9100	73	offense;[486	offense;[486	NNS
18637	9100	74	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9100	75	and	and	CC
18637	9100	76	in	in	IN
18637	9100	77	1936	1936	CD
18637	9100	78	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	9100	79	Ritter	Ritter	NNP
18637	9100	80	of	of	IN
18637	9100	81	the	the	DT
18637	9100	82	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	9100	83	district	district	NN
18637	9100	84	court	court	NN
18637	9100	85	was	be	VBD
18637	9100	86	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	9100	87	removed	remove	VBN
18637	9100	88	for	for	IN
18637	9100	89	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	9100	90	in	in	IN
18637	9100	91	relation	relation	NN
18637	9100	92	to	to	IN
18637	9100	93	a	a	DT
18637	9100	94	receivership	receivership	NN
18637	9100	95	case	case	NN
18637	9100	96	which	which	WDT
18637	9100	97	evoked	evoke	VBD
18637	9100	98	serious	serious	JJ
18637	9100	99	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	9100	100	as	as	IN
18637	9100	101	to	to	IN
18637	9100	102	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9100	103	integrity	integrity	NN
18637	9100	104	,	,	,
18637	9100	105	although	although	IN
18637	9100	106	on	on	IN
18637	9100	107	the	the	DT
18637	9100	108	specific	specific	JJ
18637	9100	109	charges	charge	NNS
18637	9100	110	against	against	IN
18637	9100	111	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9100	112	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9100	113	was	be	VBD
18637	9100	114	acquitted	acquit	VBN
18637	9100	115	.	.	.
18637	9101	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9101	2	487	487	CD
18637	9101	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9101	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9101	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	9101	6	probable	probable	JJ
18637	9101	7	that	that	IN
18637	9101	8	in	in	IN
18637	9101	9	both	both	PDT
18637	9101	10	these	these	DT
18637	9101	11	instances	instance	NNS
18637	9101	12	the	the	DT
18637	9101	13	final	final	JJ
18637	9101	14	result	result	NN
18637	9101	15	was	be	VBD
18637	9101	16	influenced	influence	VBN
18637	9101	17	by	by	IN
18637	9101	18	the	the	DT
18637	9101	19	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	9101	20	that	that	IN
18637	9101	21	judges	judge	NNS
18637	9101	22	of	of	IN
18637	9101	23	the	the	DT
18637	9101	24	United	United	NNP
18637	9101	25	States	States	NNP
18637	9101	26	hold	hold	VBP
18637	9101	27	office	office	NN
18637	9101	28	during	during	IN
18637	9101	29	"	"	``
18637	9101	30	good	good	JJ
18637	9101	31	behavior	behavior	NN
18637	9101	32	"	"	''
18637	9101	33	and	and	CC
18637	9101	34	that	that	IN
18637	9101	35	the	the	DT
18637	9101	36	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9101	37	process	process	NN
18637	9101	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	9101	39	the	the	DT
18637	9101	40	only	only	JJ
18637	9101	41	method	method	NN
18637	9101	42	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	9101	43	by	by	IN
18637	9101	44	the	the	DT
18637	9101	45	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9101	46	for	for	IN
18637	9101	47	determining	determine	VBG
18637	9101	48	whether	whether	IN
18637	9101	49	a	a	DT
18637	9101	50	judge	judge	NN
18637	9101	51	's	's	POS
18637	9101	52	behavior	behavior	NN
18637	9101	53	has	have	VBZ
18637	9101	54	been	be	VBN
18637	9101	55	"	"	``
18637	9101	56	good	good	JJ
18637	9101	57	.	.	.
18637	9101	58	"	"	''
18637	9102	1	In	in	IN
18637	9102	2	other	other	JJ
18637	9102	3	words	word	NNS
18637	9102	4	,	,	,
18637	9102	5	as	as	IN
18637	9102	6	to	to	IN
18637	9102	7	judges	judge	NNS
18637	9102	8	of	of	IN
18637	9102	9	the	the	DT
18637	9102	10	United	United	NNP
18637	9102	11	States	States	NNP
18637	9102	12	at	at	IN
18637	9102	13	least	least	JJS
18637	9102	14	lack	lack	NN
18637	9102	15	of	of	IN
18637	9102	16	"	"	``
18637	9102	17	good	good	JJ
18637	9102	18	behavior	behavior	NN
18637	9102	19	"	"	''
18637	9102	20	and	and	CC
18637	9102	21	"	"	``
18637	9102	22	high	high	JJ
18637	9102	23	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	9102	24	and	and	CC
18637	9102	25	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
18637	9102	26	"	"	``
18637	9102	27	are	be	VBP
18637	9102	28	overlapping	overlap	VBG
18637	9102	29	if	if	IN
18637	9102	30	not	not	RB
18637	9102	31	precisely	precisely	RB
18637	9102	32	coincidental	coincidental	JJ
18637	9102	33	concepts	concept	NNS
18637	9102	34	.	.	.
18637	9103	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9103	2	488	488	CD
18637	9103	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9103	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	9103	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9103	6	1	1	CD
18637	9103	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9103	8	As	as	IN
18637	9103	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	9103	10	pointed	point	VBN
18637	9103	11	out	out	RP
18637	9103	12	by	by	IN
18637	9103	13	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	9103	14	in	in	IN
18637	9103	15	The	the	DT
18637	9103	16	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	9103	17	No	no	NN
18637	9103	18	.	.	.
18637	9104	1	69	69	CD
18637	9104	2	.	.	.
18637	9105	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9105	2	2	2	LS
18637	9105	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9105	4	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	9105	5	C.	C.	NNP
18637	9105	6	Thach	Thach	NNP
18637	9105	7	,	,	,
18637	9105	8	The	the	DT
18637	9105	9	Creation	Creation	NNP
18637	9105	10	of	of	IN
18637	9105	11	the	the	DT
18637	9105	12	Presidency	Presidency	NNP
18637	9105	13	,	,	,
18637	9105	14	1775	1775	CD
18637	9105	15	-	-	SYM
18637	9105	16	1789	1789	CD
18637	9105	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9105	18	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	9105	19	,	,	,
18637	9105	20	1922	1922	CD
18637	9105	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9105	22	,	,	,
18637	9105	23	36	36	CD
18637	9105	24	-	-	SYM
18637	9105	25	37	37	CD
18637	9105	26	.	.	.
18637	9106	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9106	2	3	3	LS
18637	9106	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9106	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9106	5	.	.	.
18637	9107	1	109	109	CD
18637	9107	2	.	.	.
18637	9108	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9108	2	4	4	LS
18637	9108	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9108	4	Max	Max	NNP
18637	9108	5	Farrand	Farrand	NNP
18637	9108	6	,	,	,
18637	9108	7	Records	Records	NNP
18637	9108	8	,	,	,
18637	9108	9	II	II	NNP
18637	9108	10	,	,	,
18637	9108	11	185	185	CD
18637	9108	12	.	.	.
18637	9109	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9109	2	5	5	CD
18637	9109	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9109	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9109	5	.	.	.
18637	9110	1	II	II	NNP
18637	9110	2	,	,	,
18637	9110	3	572	572	CD
18637	9110	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9110	5	September	September	NNP
18637	9110	6	10	10	CD
18637	9110	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9110	8	,	,	,
18637	9110	9	597	597	CD
18637	9110	10	.	.	.
18637	9111	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9111	2	6	6	CD
18637	9111	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9111	4	Annals	Annals	NNPS
18637	9111	5	of	of	IN
18637	9111	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9111	7	383	383	CD
18637	9111	8	ff	ff	NN
18637	9111	9	.	.	.
18637	9112	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9112	2	7	7	CD
18637	9112	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9112	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9112	5	.	.	.
18637	9113	1	396	396	CD
18637	9113	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9113	3	397	397	CD
18637	9113	4	;	;	:
18637	9113	5	481	481	CD
18637	9113	6	-	-	SYM
18637	9113	7	482	482	CD
18637	9113	8	.	.	.
18637	9114	1	For	for	IN
18637	9114	2	a	a	DT
18637	9114	3	thorough	thorough	JJ
18637	9114	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	9114	5	going	go	VBG
18637	9114	6	review	review	NN
18637	9114	7	and	and	CC
18637	9114	8	evaluation	evaluation	NN
18637	9114	9	of	of	IN
18637	9114	10	this	this	DT
18637	9114	11	debate	debate	NN
18637	9114	12	,	,	,
18637	9114	13	_	_	NNP
18637	9114	14	see	see	VBP
18637	9114	15	_	_	NNP
18637	9114	16	James	James	NNP
18637	9114	17	Hart	Hart	NNP
18637	9114	18	,	,	,
18637	9114	19	The	the	DT
18637	9114	20	American	American	NNP
18637	9114	21	Presidency	Presidency	NNP
18637	9114	22	in	in	IN
18637	9114	23	Action	Action	NNP
18637	9114	24	,	,	,
18637	9114	25	152	152	CD
18637	9114	26	-	-	HYPH
18637	9114	27	214	214	CD
18637	9114	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9114	29	New	New	NNP
18637	9114	30	York	York	NNP
18637	9114	31	,	,	,
18637	9114	32	1948	1948	CD
18637	9114	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9114	34	.	.	.
18637	9115	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9115	2	8	8	CD
18637	9115	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9115	4	Works	Works	NNP
18637	9115	5	of	of	IN
18637	9115	6	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	9115	7	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	9115	8	,	,	,
18637	9115	9	VII	VII	NNP
18637	9115	10	,	,	,
18637	9115	11	76	76	CD
18637	9115	12	,	,	,
18637	9115	13	80	80	CD
18637	9115	14	-	-	SYM
18637	9115	15	81	81	CD
18637	9115	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9115	17	J.C.	J.C.	NNP
18637	9115	18	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	9115	19	,	,	,
18637	9115	20	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9115	21	.	.	NNP
18637	9115	22	,	,	,
18637	9115	23	New	New	NNP
18637	9115	24	York	York	NNP
18637	9115	25	,	,	,
18637	9115	26	1851	1851	CD
18637	9115	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9115	28	.	.	.
18637	9116	1	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	9116	2	was	be	VBD
18637	9116	3	here	here	RB
18637	9116	4	simply	simply	RB
18637	9116	5	interpreting	interpret	VBG
18637	9116	6	the	the	DT
18637	9116	7	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9116	8	power	power	NN
18637	9116	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	9116	10	in	in	IN
18637	9116	11	light	light	NN
18637	9116	12	of	of	IN
18637	9116	13	the	the	DT
18637	9116	14	views	view	NNS
18637	9116	15	of	of	IN
18637	9116	16	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
18637	9116	17	,	,	,
18637	9116	18	Locke	Locke	NNP
18637	9116	19	,	,	,
18637	9116	20	and	and	CC
18637	9116	21	Montesquieu	Montesquieu	NNP
18637	9116	22	as	as	IN
18637	9116	23	to	to	IN
18637	9116	24	the	the	DT
18637	9116	25	location	location	NN
18637	9116	26	of	of	IN
18637	9116	27	power	power	NN
18637	9116	28	in	in	IN
18637	9116	29	the	the	DT
18637	9116	30	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	9116	31	of	of	IN
18637	9116	32	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9116	33	relations	relation	NNS
18637	9116	34	.	.	.
18637	9117	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9117	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9117	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9117	4	Edward	Edward	NNP
18637	9117	5	S.	S.	NNP
18637	9117	6	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	9117	7	,	,	,
18637	9117	8	The	the	DT
18637	9117	9	President	President	NNP
18637	9117	10	,	,	,
18637	9117	11	Office	Office	NNP
18637	9117	12	and	and	CC
18637	9117	13	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	9117	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9117	15	3d	3d	NNP
18637	9117	16	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9117	17	.	.	.
18637	9118	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9118	2	,	,	,
18637	9118	3	459	459	CD
18637	9118	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9118	5	460	460	CD
18637	9118	6	.	.	.
18637	9119	1	For	for	IN
18637	9119	2	a	a	DT
18637	9119	3	parallel	parallel	JJ
18637	9119	4	argument	argument	NN
18637	9119	5	to	to	IN
18637	9119	6	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	9119	7	's	's	POS
18637	9119	8	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	9119	9	"	"	``
18637	9119	10	the	the	DT
18637	9119	11	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	9119	12	power	power	NN
18637	9119	13	of	of	IN
18637	9119	14	the	the	DT
18637	9119	15	United	United	NNP
18637	9119	16	States	States	NNP
18637	9119	17	,	,	,
18637	9119	18	"	"	''
18637	9119	19	article	article	NN
18637	9119	20	1	1	CD
18637	9119	21	,	,	,
18637	9119	22	section	section	NN
18637	9119	23	1	1	CD
18637	9119	24	,	,	,
18637	9119	25	clause	clause	NN
18637	9119	26	1	1	CD
18637	9119	27	,	,	,
18637	9119	28	_	_	NNP
18637	9119	29	see	see	VBP
18637	9119	30	_	_	NNP
18637	9119	31	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9119	32	Brewer	Brewer	NNP
18637	9119	33	's	's	POS
18637	9119	34	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9119	35	in	in	IN
18637	9119	36	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	9119	37	_	_	NNP
18637	9119	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	9119	39	_	_	NNP
18637	9119	40	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	9119	41	,	,	,
18637	9119	42	206	206	CD
18637	9119	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9119	44	46	46	CD
18637	9119	45	,	,	,
18637	9119	46	82	82	CD
18637	9119	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9119	48	1907	1907	CD
18637	9119	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9119	50	.	.	.
18637	9120	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9120	2	9	9	CD
18637	9120	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9120	4	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	9120	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9120	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9120	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9120	8	United	United	NNP
18637	9120	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9120	10	,	,	,
18637	9120	11	272	272	CD
18637	9120	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9120	13	52	52	CD
18637	9120	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9120	15	1926	1926	CD
18637	9120	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9120	17	.	.	.
18637	9121	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9121	2	10	10	CD
18637	9121	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9121	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9121	5	.	.	.
18637	9122	1	118	118	CD
18637	9122	2	.	.	.
18637	9123	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9123	2	11	11	CD
18637	9123	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9123	4	299	299	CD
18637	9123	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9123	6	304	304	CD
18637	9123	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9123	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	9123	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9123	10	.	.	.
18637	9124	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9124	2	12	12	CD
18637	9124	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9124	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9124	5	.	.	.
18637	9125	1	315	315	CD
18637	9125	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9125	3	316	316	CD
18637	9125	4	,	,	,
18637	9125	5	318	318	CD
18637	9125	6	.	.	.
18637	9126	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9126	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9126	3	also	also	RB
18637	9126	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9126	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9126	6	.	.	.
18637	9127	1	319	319	CD
18637	9127	2	citing	cite	VBG
18637	9127	3	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9127	4	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9127	5	Reports	Reports	NNP
18637	9127	6	,	,	,
18637	9127	7	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	9127	8	on	on	IN
18637	9127	9	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	9127	10	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	9127	11	,	,	,
18637	9127	12	vol	vol	NNP
18637	9127	13	.	.	.
18637	9128	1	8	8	CD
18637	9128	2	,	,	,
18637	9128	3	p.	p.	NN
18637	9128	4	24	24	CD
18637	9128	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9128	6	February	February	NNP
18637	9128	7	15	15	CD
18637	9128	8	,	,	,
18637	9128	9	1816	1816	CD
18637	9128	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9128	11	.	.	.
18637	9129	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9129	2	13	13	CD
18637	9129	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9129	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9129	5	.	.	.
18637	9130	1	327	327	CD
18637	9130	2	,	,	,
18637	9130	3	citing	cite	VBG
18637	9130	4	Panama	Panama	NNP
18637	9130	5	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	9130	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	9130	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9130	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	9130	9	_	_	NNP
18637	9130	10	Ryan	Ryan	NNP
18637	9130	11	,	,	,
18637	9130	12	293	293	CD
18637	9130	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9130	14	388	388	CD
18637	9130	15	,	,	,
18637	9130	16	421	421	CD
18637	9130	17	-	-	SYM
18637	9130	18	422	422	CD
18637	9130	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9130	20	1935	1935	CD
18637	9130	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9130	22	.	.	.
18637	9131	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9131	2	14	14	CD
18637	9131	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9131	4	In	in	IN
18637	9131	5	Youngstown	Youngstown	NNP
18637	9131	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	9131	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9131	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	9131	9	_	_	NNP
18637	9131	10	Sawyer	Sawyer	NNP
18637	9131	11	,	,	,
18637	9131	12	343	343	CD
18637	9131	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9131	14	579	579	CD
18637	9131	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9131	16	1952	1952	CD
18637	9131	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9131	18	the	the	DT
18637	9131	19	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	9131	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	9131	21	advanced	advance	VBN
18637	9131	22	that	that	IN
18637	9131	23	the	the	DT
18637	9131	24	President	President	NNP
18637	9131	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	9131	26	no	no	DT
18637	9131	27	power	power	NN
18637	9131	28	in	in	IN
18637	9131	29	the	the	DT
18637	9131	30	field	field	NN
18637	9131	31	of	of	IN
18637	9131	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9131	33	'	'	POS
18637	9131	34	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	9131	35	powers	power	NNS
18637	9131	36	except	except	IN
18637	9131	37	such	such	JJ
18637	9131	38	as	as	IN
18637	9131	39	are	be	VBP
18637	9131	40	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	9131	41	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9131	42	by	by	IN
18637	9131	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9131	44	.	.	.
18637	9132	1	This	this	DT
18637	9132	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	9132	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	9132	4	considered	consider	VBN
18637	9132	5	below	below	RB
18637	9132	6	in	in	IN
18637	9132	7	the	the	DT
18637	9132	8	light	light	NN
18637	9132	9	of	of	IN
18637	9132	10	previous	previous	JJ
18637	9132	11	practice	practice	NN
18637	9132	12	and	and	CC
18637	9132	13	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	9132	14	.	.	.
18637	9133	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9133	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9133	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9133	4	pp	pp	NNP
18637	9133	5	.	.	.
18637	9134	1	489	489	CD
18637	9134	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9134	3	499	499	CD
18637	9134	4	.	.	.
18637	9135	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9135	2	15	15	CD
18637	9135	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9135	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9135	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9135	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9135	7	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	9135	8	,	,	,
18637	9135	9	Abel	Abel	NNP
18637	9135	10	Upshur	Upshur	NNP
18637	9135	11	,	,	,
18637	9135	12	A	a	DT
18637	9135	13	Brief	brief	JJ
18637	9135	14	Inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	9135	15	Into	into	IN
18637	9135	16	the	the	DT
18637	9135	17	True	True	NNP
18637	9135	18	Nature	Nature	NNP
18637	9135	19	and	and	CC
18637	9135	20	Character	character	NN
18637	9135	21	of	of	IN
18637	9135	22	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9135	23	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	9135	24	Government	Government	NNP
18637	9135	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9135	26	1840	1840	CD
18637	9135	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9135	28	,	,	,
18637	9135	29	116	116	CD
18637	9135	30	-	-	SYM
18637	9135	31	117	117	CD
18637	9135	32	.	.	.
18637	9136	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9136	2	16	16	CD
18637	9136	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9136	4	The	the	DT
18637	9136	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	9136	6	No	no	NN
18637	9136	7	.	.	.
18637	9137	1	67	67	CD
18637	9137	2	,	,	,
18637	9137	3	503	503	CD
18637	9137	4	.	.	.
18637	9138	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9138	2	17	17	CD
18637	9138	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9138	4	James	James	NNP
18637	9138	5	Hart	Hart	NNP
18637	9138	6	,	,	,
18637	9138	7	The	the	DT
18637	9138	8	American	American	NNP
18637	9138	9	Presidency	Presidency	NNP
18637	9138	10	in	in	IN
18637	9138	11	Action	Action	NNP
18637	9138	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9138	13	New	New	NNP
18637	9138	14	York	York	NNP
18637	9138	15	,	,	,
18637	9138	16	1918	1918	CD
18637	9138	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9138	18	,	,	,
18637	9138	19	28	28	CD
18637	9138	20	-	-	SYM
18637	9138	21	43	43	CD
18637	9138	22	.	.	.
18637	9139	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9139	2	18	18	CD
18637	9139	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9139	4	2	2	CD
18637	9139	5	Dall	dall	NN
18637	9139	6	.	.	.
18637	9140	1	400	400	CD
18637	9140	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9140	3	1790	1790	CD
18637	9140	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9140	5	.	.	.
18637	9141	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9141	2	19	19	CD
18637	9141	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9141	4	Messages	Messages	NNPS
18637	9141	5	and	and	CC
18637	9141	6	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	9141	7	of	of	IN
18637	9141	8	the	the	DT
18637	9141	9	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	9141	10	,	,	,
18637	9141	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9141	12	,	,	,
18637	9141	13	56	56	CD
18637	9141	14	.	.	.
18637	9142	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9142	2	20	20	CD
18637	9142	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9142	4	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	9142	5	,	,	,
18637	9142	6	The	the	DT
18637	9142	7	President	President	NNP
18637	9142	8	,	,	,
18637	9142	9	Office	Office	NNP
18637	9142	10	and	and	CC
18637	9142	11	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	9142	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9142	13	3d	3d	NNP
18637	9142	14	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9142	15	.	.	.
18637	9143	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9143	2	,	,	,
18637	9143	3	377	377	CD
18637	9143	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9143	5	378	378	CD
18637	9143	6	,	,	,
18637	9143	7	434	434	CD
18637	9143	8	-	-	SYM
18637	9143	9	435	435	CD
18637	9143	10	,	,	,
18637	9143	11	446	446	CD
18637	9143	12	,	,	,
18637	9143	13	465	465	CD
18637	9143	14	,	,	,
18637	9143	15	484	484	CD
18637	9143	16	.	.	.
18637	9144	1	"	"	``
18637	9144	2	The	the	DT
18637	9144	3	executive	executive	NN
18637	9144	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9144	5	branch	branch	NN
18637	9144	6	of	of	IN
18637	9144	7	the	the	DT
18637	9144	8	government	government	NN
18637	9144	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9144	10	,	,	,
18637	9144	11	possessing	possess	VBG
18637	9144	12	the	the	DT
18637	9144	13	rights	right	NNS
18637	9144	14	of	of	IN
18637	9144	15	self	self	NN
18637	9144	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	9144	17	government	government	NN
18637	9144	18	from	from	IN
18637	9144	19	nature	nature	NN
18637	9144	20	,	,	,
18637	9144	21	can	can	MD
18637	9144	22	not	not	RB
18637	9144	23	be	be	VB
18637	9144	24	controlled	control	VBN
18637	9144	25	in	in	IN
18637	9144	26	the	the	DT
18637	9144	27	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	9144	28	of	of	IN
18637	9144	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9144	30	but	but	CC
18637	9144	31	by	by	IN
18637	9144	32	a	a	DT
18637	9144	33	law	law	NN
18637	9144	34	,	,	,
18637	9144	35	passed	pass	VBN
18637	9144	36	in	in	IN
18637	9144	37	the	the	DT
18637	9144	38	forms	form	NNS
18637	9144	39	of	of	IN
18637	9144	40	the	the	DT
18637	9144	41	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9144	42	.	.	.
18637	9144	43	"	"	''
18637	9145	1	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	9145	2	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	9145	3	,	,	,
18637	9145	4	Official	Official	NNP
18637	9145	5	Opinion	Opinion	NNP
18637	9145	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9145	7	1790	1790	CD
18637	9145	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9145	9	5	5	CD
18637	9145	10	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	9145	11	,	,	,
18637	9145	12	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9145	13	.	.	.
18637	9146	1	209	209	CD
18637	9146	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9146	3	New	New	NNP
18637	9146	4	York	York	NNP
18637	9146	5	,	,	,
18637	9146	6	1892	1892	CD
18637	9146	7	-	-	SYM
18637	9146	8	1899	1899	CD
18637	9146	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9146	10	.	.	.
18637	9147	1	"	"	``
18637	9147	2	In	in	IN
18637	9147	3	times	time	NNS
18637	9147	4	of	of	IN
18637	9147	5	peace	peace	NN
18637	9147	6	the	the	DT
18637	9147	7	people	people	NNS
18637	9147	8	look	look	VBP
18637	9147	9	most	most	JJS
18637	9147	10	to	to	IN
18637	9147	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9147	12	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	9147	13	;	;	:
18637	9147	14	but	but	CC
18637	9147	15	in	in	IN
18637	9147	16	war	war	NN
18637	9147	17	,	,	,
18637	9147	18	to	to	IN
18637	9147	19	the	the	DT
18637	9147	20	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	9147	21	solely	solely	RB
18637	9147	22	.	.	.
18637	9147	23	"	"	''
18637	9148	1	Letter	letter	NN
18637	9148	2	to	to	IN
18637	9148	3	Caesar	Caesar	NNP
18637	9148	4	A.	A.	NNP
18637	9148	5	Rodney	Rodney	NNP
18637	9148	6	,	,	,
18637	9148	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9148	8	1810	1810	CD
18637	9148	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9148	10	Monticello	Monticello	NNP
18637	9148	11	,	,	,
18637	9148	12	9	9	CD
18637	9148	13	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	9148	14	,	,	,
18637	9148	15	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9148	16	.	.	.
18637	9149	1	272	272	CD
18637	9149	2	.	.	.
18637	9150	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9150	2	21	21	CD
18637	9150	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9150	4	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	9150	5	20	20	CD
18637	9150	6	-	-	SYM
18637	9150	7	21	21	CD
18637	9150	8	,	,	,
18637	9150	9	and	and	CC
18637	9150	10	citations	citation	NNS
18637	9150	11	.	.	.
18637	9151	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9151	2	22	22	CD
18637	9151	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9151	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9151	5	.	.	.
18637	9152	1	21	21	CD
18637	9152	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9152	3	22	22	CD
18637	9152	4	,	,	,
18637	9152	5	and	and	CC
18637	9152	6	citations	citation	NNS
18637	9152	7	.	.	.
18637	9153	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9153	2	23	23	CD
18637	9153	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9153	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9153	5	.	.	.
18637	9154	1	22	22	CD
18637	9154	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9154	3	24	24	CD
18637	9154	4	.	.	.
18637	9155	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9155	2	24	24	CD
18637	9155	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9155	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9155	5	.	.	.
18637	9156	1	386	386	CD
18637	9156	2	.	.	.
18637	9157	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9157	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9157	3	also	also	RB
18637	9157	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9157	5	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9157	6	.	.	.
18637	9158	1	281	281	CD
18637	9158	2	.	.	.
18637	9159	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9159	2	25	25	CD
18637	9159	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9159	4	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	9159	5	,	,	,
18637	9159	6	The	the	DT
18637	9159	7	Rise	Rise	NNP
18637	9159	8	and	and	CC
18637	9159	9	Growth	growth	NN
18637	9159	10	of	of	IN
18637	9159	11	American	american	JJ
18637	9159	12	Politics	Politics	NNPS
18637	9159	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9159	14	New	New	NNP
18637	9159	15	York	York	NNP
18637	9159	16	,	,	,
18637	9159	17	1914	1914	CD
18637	9159	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9159	19	,	,	,
18637	9159	20	293	293	CD
18637	9159	21	.	.	.
18637	9160	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9160	2	26	26	CD
18637	9160	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9160	4	As	as	IN
18637	9160	5	to	to	IN
18637	9160	6	the	the	DT
18637	9160	7	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	9160	8	of	of	IN
18637	9160	9	"	"	``
18637	9160	10	the	the	DT
18637	9160	11	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	9160	12	day	day	NN
18637	9160	13	of	of	IN
18637	9160	14	March	March	NNP
18637	9160	15	"	"	''
18637	9160	16	,	,	,
18637	9160	17	_	_	NNP
18637	9160	18	see	see	VBP
18637	9160	19	_	_	NNP
18637	9160	20	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	9160	21	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	9160	22	,	,	,
18637	9160	23	Political	Political	NNP
18637	9160	24	Practice	Practice	NNP
18637	9160	25	and	and	CC
18637	9160	26	the	the	DT
18637	9160	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9160	28	,	,	,
18637	9160	29	89	89	CD
18637	9160	30	Univ	Univ	NNS
18637	9160	31	.	.	.
18637	9161	1	of	of	IN
18637	9161	2	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	9161	3	L.	L.	NNP
18637	9161	4	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	9162	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9162	2	June	June	NNP
18637	9162	3	,	,	,
18637	9162	4	1941	1941	CD
18637	9162	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9162	6	1003	1003	CD
18637	9162	7	-	-	SYM
18637	9162	8	1025	1025	CD
18637	9162	9	.	.	.
18637	9163	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9163	2	27	27	CD
18637	9163	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9163	4	On	on	IN
18637	9163	5	the	the	DT
18637	9163	6	anti	anti	JJ
18637	9163	7	-	-	JJ
18637	9163	8	third	third	JJ
18637	9163	9	term	term	NN
18637	9163	10	tradition	tradition	NN
18637	9163	11	,	,	,
18637	9163	12	_	_	NNP
18637	9163	13	see	see	VBP
18637	9163	14	_	_	NNP
18637	9163	15	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	9163	16	,	,	,
18637	9163	17	The	the	DT
18637	9163	18	President	President	NNP
18637	9163	19	,	,	,
18637	9163	20	Office	Office	NNP
18637	9163	21	and	and	CC
18637	9163	22	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	9163	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9163	24	3d	3d	NNP
18637	9163	25	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9163	26	.	.	.
18637	9164	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9164	2	,	,	,
18637	9164	3	43	43	CD
18637	9164	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9164	5	49	49	CD
18637	9164	6	,	,	,
18637	9164	7	388	388	CD
18637	9164	8	-	-	SYM
18637	9164	9	392	392	CD
18637	9164	10	.	.	.
18637	9165	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9165	2	28	28	CD
18637	9165	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9165	4	McPherson	McPherson	NNP
18637	9165	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9165	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9165	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9165	8	Blacker	Blacker	NNP
18637	9165	9	,	,	,
18637	9165	10	146	146	CD
18637	9165	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9165	12	1	1	CD
18637	9165	13	,	,	,
18637	9165	14	27	27	CD
18637	9165	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9165	16	1892	1892	CD
18637	9165	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9165	18	.	.	.
18637	9166	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9166	2	29	29	CD
18637	9166	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9166	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9166	5	.	.	.
18637	9167	1	28	28	CD
18637	9167	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9167	3	29	29	CD
18637	9167	4	.	.	.
18637	9168	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9168	2	30	30	CD
18637	9168	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9168	4	Max	Max	NNP
18637	9168	5	Farrand	Farrand	NNP
18637	9168	6	,	,	,
18637	9168	7	II	II	NNP
18637	9168	8	,	,	,
18637	9168	9	97	97	CD
18637	9168	10	.	.	.
18637	9169	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9169	2	31	31	CD
18637	9169	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9169	4	In	in	IN
18637	9169	5	re	re	NN
18637	9169	6	Green	Green	NNP
18637	9169	7	,	,	,
18637	9169	8	134	134	CD
18637	9169	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9169	10	377	377	CD
18637	9169	11	,	,	,
18637	9169	12	379	379	CD
18637	9169	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	9169	14	380	380	CD
18637	9169	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9169	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	9169	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9169	18	.	.	.
18637	9170	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9170	2	32	32	CD
18637	9170	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9170	4	United	United	NNP
18637	9170	5	States	States	NNP
18637	9170	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9170	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9170	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9170	9	Hartwell	Hartwell	NNP
18637	9170	10	,	,	,
18637	9170	11	6	6	CD
18637	9170	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9170	13	.	.	.
18637	9171	1	385	385	CD
18637	9171	2	,	,	,
18637	9171	3	393	393	CD
18637	9171	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9171	5	1868	1868	CD
18637	9171	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9171	7	.	.	.
18637	9172	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9172	2	33	33	CD
18637	9172	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9172	4	Hawke	Hawke	NNP
18637	9172	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9172	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9172	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9172	8	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	9172	9	,	,	,
18637	9172	10	253	253	CD
18637	9172	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9172	12	221	221	CD
18637	9172	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9172	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	9172	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9172	16	.	.	.
18637	9173	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9173	2	34	34	CD
18637	9173	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9173	4	Burroughs	Burroughs	NNP
18637	9173	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9173	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9173	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9173	8	United	United	NNP
18637	9173	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9173	10	,	,	,
18637	9173	11	290	290	CD
18637	9173	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9173	13	534	534	CD
18637	9173	14	,	,	,
18637	9173	15	545	545	CD
18637	9173	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9173	17	1934	1934	CD
18637	9173	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9173	19	.	.	.
18637	9174	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9174	2	35	35	CD
18637	9174	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9174	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	9174	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	9174	6	Yarbrough	Yarbrough	NNP
18637	9174	7	,	,	,
18637	9174	8	110	110	CD
18637	9174	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9174	10	651	651	CD
18637	9174	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9174	12	1884	1884	CD
18637	9174	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9174	14	.	.	.
18637	9175	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9175	2	36	36	CD
18637	9175	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9175	4	Burroughs	Burroughs	NNP
18637	9175	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9175	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9175	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9175	8	United	United	NNP
18637	9175	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9175	10	,	,	,
18637	9175	11	290	290	CD
18637	9175	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9175	13	534	534	CD
18637	9175	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9175	15	1934	1934	CD
18637	9175	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9175	17	.	.	.
18637	9176	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9176	2	37	37	CD
18637	9176	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9176	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9176	5	.	.	.
18637	9177	1	546	546	CD
18637	9177	2	.	.	.
18637	9178	1	During	during	IN
18637	9178	2	the	the	DT
18637	9178	3	recent	recent	JJ
18637	9178	4	war	war	NN
18637	9178	5	,	,	,
18637	9178	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9178	7	laid	lay	VBD
18637	9178	8	claim	claim	NN
18637	9178	9	in	in	IN
18637	9178	10	the	the	DT
18637	9178	11	act	act	NN
18637	9178	12	of	of	IN
18637	9178	13	September	September	NNP
18637	9178	14	16	16	CD
18637	9178	15	,	,	,
18637	9178	16	1942	1942	CD
18637	9178	17	,	,	,
18637	9178	18	to	to	IN
18637	9178	19	the	the	DT
18637	9178	20	power	power	NN
18637	9178	21	"	"	''
18637	9178	22	in	in	IN
18637	9178	23	time	time	NN
18637	9178	24	of	of	IN
18637	9178	25	war	war	NN
18637	9178	26	"	"	''
18637	9178	27	to	to	TO
18637	9178	28	secure	secure	VB
18637	9178	29	to	to	IN
18637	9178	30	every	every	DT
18637	9178	31	member	member	NN
18637	9178	32	of	of	IN
18637	9178	33	the	the	DT
18637	9178	34	armed	armed	JJ
18637	9178	35	forces	force	NNS
18637	9178	36	the	the	DT
18637	9178	37	right	right	NN
18637	9178	38	to	to	TO
18637	9178	39	vote	vote	VB
18637	9178	40	for	for	IN
18637	9178	41	Members	member	NNS
18637	9178	42	of	of	IN
18637	9178	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9178	44	and	and	CC
18637	9178	45	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	9178	46	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	9178	47	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	9178	48	any	any	DT
18637	9178	49	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	9178	50	of	of	IN
18637	9178	51	State	State	NNP
18637	9178	52	law	law	NN
18637	9178	53	relating	relate	VBG
18637	9178	54	to	to	IN
18637	9178	55	the	the	DT
18637	9178	56	registration	registration	NN
18637	9178	57	of	of	IN
18637	9178	58	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	9178	59	voters	voter	NNS
18637	9178	60	or	or	CC
18637	9178	61	any	any	DT
18637	9178	62	poll	poll	JJ
18637	9178	63	tax	tax	NN
18637	9178	64	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	9178	65	under	under	IN
18637	9178	66	State	State	NNP
18637	9178	67	law	law	NN
18637	9178	68	.	.	.
18637	9179	1	The	the	DT
18637	9179	2	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	9179	3	validity	validity	NN
18637	9179	4	of	of	IN
18637	9179	5	this	this	DT
18637	9179	6	act	act	NN
18637	9179	7	was	be	VBD
18637	9179	8	open	open	JJ
18637	9179	9	to	to	IN
18637	9179	10	serious	serious	JJ
18637	9179	11	question	question	NN
18637	9179	12	and	and	CC
18637	9179	13	by	by	IN
18637	9179	14	the	the	DT
18637	9179	15	act	act	NN
18637	9179	16	of	of	IN
18637	9179	17	April	April	NNP
18637	9179	18	1	1	CD
18637	9179	19	,	,	,
18637	9179	20	1944	1944	CD
18637	9179	21	was	be	VBD
18637	9179	22	abandoned	abandon	VBN
18637	9179	23	.	.	.
18637	9180	1	The	the	DT
18637	9180	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	9180	3	act	act	NN
18637	9180	4	established	establish	VBD
18637	9180	5	a	a	DT
18637	9180	6	War	War	NNP
18637	9180	7	Ballot	Ballot	NNP
18637	9180	8	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	9180	9	which	which	WDT
18637	9180	10	was	be	VBD
18637	9180	11	directed	direct	VBN
18637	9180	12	to	to	TO
18637	9180	13	prepare	prepare	VB
18637	9180	14	an	an	DT
18637	9180	15	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	9180	16	number	number	NN
18637	9180	17	of	of	IN
18637	9180	18	official	official	JJ
18637	9180	19	war	war	NN
18637	9180	20	ballots	ballot	NNS
18637	9180	21	,	,	,
18637	9180	22	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	9180	23	the	the	DT
18637	9180	24	service	service	NN
18637	9180	25	men	man	NNS
18637	9180	26	would	would	MD
18637	9180	27	be	be	VB
18637	9180	28	enabled	enable	VBN
18637	9180	29	in	in	IN
18637	9180	30	certain	certain	JJ
18637	9180	31	contingencies	contingency	NNS
18637	9180	32	to	to	TO
18637	9180	33	vote	vote	VB
18637	9180	34	for	for	IN
18637	9180	35	Members	member	NNS
18637	9180	36	of	of	IN
18637	9180	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9180	38	and	and	CC
18637	9180	39	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	9180	40	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	9180	41	;	;	:
18637	9180	42	but	but	CC
18637	9180	43	the	the	DT
18637	9180	44	validity	validity	NN
18637	9180	45	of	of	IN
18637	9180	46	such	such	JJ
18637	9180	47	ballots	ballot	NNS
18637	9180	48	was	be	VBD
18637	9180	49	left	leave	VBN
18637	9180	50	to	to	TO
18637	9180	51	be	be	VB
18637	9180	52	determined	determine	VBN
18637	9180	53	by	by	IN
18637	9180	54	State	state	NN
18637	9180	55	election	election	NN
18637	9180	56	officials	official	NNS
18637	9180	57	under	under	IN
18637	9180	58	State	State	NNP
18637	9180	59	laws	law	NNS
18637	9180	60	.	.	.
18637	9181	1	50	50	CD
18637	9181	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9181	3	App	App	NNP
18637	9181	4	.	.	.
18637	9181	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9182	1	U.S.C.A.	U.S.C.A.	NNP
18637	9183	1	§§	§§	NFP
18637	9183	2	301	301	CD
18637	9183	3	-	-	SYM
18637	9183	4	302	302	CD
18637	9183	5	,	,	,
18637	9183	6	331	331	CD
18637	9183	7	,	,	,
18637	9183	8	341	341	CD
18637	9183	9	.	.	.
18637	9184	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9184	2	38	38	CD
18637	9184	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9184	4	343	343	CD
18637	9184	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9184	6	214	214	CD
18637	9184	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9184	8	1952	1952	CD
18637	9184	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9184	10	.	.	.
18637	9185	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9185	2	39	39	CD
18637	9185	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9185	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9185	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9185	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9185	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	9185	8	.	.	.
18637	9186	1	942	942	CD
18637	9186	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9186	3	944	944	CD
18637	9186	4	.	.	.
18637	9187	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9187	2	40	40	CD
18637	9187	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9187	4	1	1	CD
18637	9187	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9187	6	.	.	.
18637	9188	1	239	239	CD
18637	9188	2	.	.	.
18637	9189	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9189	2	41	41	CD
18637	9189	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9189	4	3	3	CD
18637	9189	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
18637	9190	1	§	§	NNP
18637	9190	2	23	23	CD
18637	9190	3	.	.	.
18637	9191	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9191	2	42	42	CD
18637	9191	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9191	4	3	3	CD
18637	9191	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
18637	9192	1	§	§	NNP
18637	9192	2	21	21	CD
18637	9192	3	.	.	.
18637	9193	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9193	2	43	43	CD
18637	9193	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9193	4	Public	Public	NNP
18637	9193	5	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9193	6	199	199	CD
18637	9193	7	,	,	,
18637	9193	8	80th	80th	NNP
18637	9193	9	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	9193	10	.	.	NNP
18637	9193	11	,	,	,
18637	9193	12	1st	1st	JJ
18637	9193	13	sess	sess	NN
18637	9193	14	.	.	.
18637	9194	1	By	by	IN
18637	9194	2	section	section	NN
18637	9194	3	202	202	CD
18637	9194	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9194	5	a	a	DT
18637	9194	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9194	7	of	of	IN
18637	9194	8	Public	Public	NNP
18637	9194	9	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9194	10	253	253	CD
18637	9194	11	of	of	IN
18637	9194	12	the	the	DT
18637	9194	13	80th	80th	JJ
18637	9194	14	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	9194	15	.	.	NNP
18637	9194	16	,	,	,
18637	9194	17	1st	1st	JJ
18637	9194	18	sess	sess	NN
18637	9194	19	.	.	.
18637	9194	20	,	,	,
18637	9194	21	approved	approve	VBN
18637	9194	22	July	July	NNP
18637	9194	23	26	26	CD
18637	9194	24	,	,	,
18637	9194	25	1947	1947	CD
18637	9194	26	,	,	,
18637	9194	27	that	that	RB
18637	9194	28	is	is	RB
18637	9194	29	,	,	,
18637	9194	30	eight	eight	CD
18637	9194	31	days	day	NNS
18637	9194	32	after	after	IN
18637	9194	33	Public	Public	NNP
18637	9194	34	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9194	35	199	199	CD
18637	9194	36	,	,	,
18637	9194	37	the	the	DT
18637	9194	38	"	"	``
18637	9194	39	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	9194	40	of	of	IN
18637	9194	41	War	War	NNP
18637	9194	42	"	"	''
18637	9194	43	and	and	CC
18637	9194	44	the	the	DT
18637	9194	45	"	"	``
18637	9194	46	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	9194	47	of	of	IN
18637	9194	48	the	the	DT
18637	9194	49	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	9194	50	"	"	''
18637	9194	51	were	be	VBD
18637	9194	52	stricken	stricken	VBN
18637	9194	53	from	from	IN
18637	9194	54	the	the	DT
18637	9194	55	line	line	NN
18637	9194	56	of	of	IN
18637	9194	57	succession	succession	NN
18637	9194	58	and	and	CC
18637	9194	59	the	the	DT
18637	9194	60	"	"	``
18637	9194	61	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	9194	62	of	of	IN
18637	9194	63	Defense	Defense	NNP
18637	9194	64	"	"	''
18637	9194	65	whose	whose	WP$
18637	9194	66	office	office	NN
18637	9194	67	Public	Public	NNP
18637	9194	68	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9194	69	253	253	CD
18637	9194	70	created	create	VBN
18637	9194	71	,	,	,
18637	9194	72	was	be	VBD
18637	9194	73	inserted	insert	VBN
18637	9194	74	instead	instead	RB
18637	9194	75	.	.	.
18637	9195	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9195	2	44	44	CD
18637	9195	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9195	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9195	5	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	9195	6	.	.	.
18637	9195	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9195	8	13	13	CD
18637	9195	9	Op	Op	NNP
18637	9195	10	.	.	.
18637	9196	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9196	2	.	.	.
18637	9197	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9197	2	161	161	CD
18637	9197	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9197	4	1869	1869	CD
18637	9197	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9197	6	,	,	,
18637	9197	7	holding	hold	VBG
18637	9197	8	that	that	IN
18637	9197	9	a	a	DT
18637	9197	10	specific	specific	JJ
18637	9197	11	tax	tax	NN
18637	9197	12	by	by	IN
18637	9197	13	the	the	DT
18637	9197	14	United	United	NNP
18637	9197	15	States	States	NNP
18637	9197	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	9197	17	the	the	DT
18637	9197	18	salary	salary	NN
18637	9197	19	of	of	IN
18637	9197	20	an	an	DT
18637	9197	21	officer	officer	NN
18637	9197	22	,	,	,
18637	9197	23	to	to	TO
18637	9197	24	be	be	VB
18637	9197	25	deducted	deduct	VBN
18637	9197	26	from	from	IN
18637	9197	27	the	the	DT
18637	9197	28	amount	amount	NN
18637	9197	29	which	which	WDT
18637	9197	30	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	9197	31	would	would	MD
18637	9197	32	by	by	IN
18637	9197	33	law	law	NN
18637	9197	34	be	be	VB
18637	9197	35	payable	payable	JJ
18637	9197	36	as	as	IN
18637	9197	37	such	such	JJ
18637	9197	38	salary	salary	NN
18637	9197	39	,	,	,
18637	9197	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	9197	41	a	a	DT
18637	9197	42	diminution	diminution	NN
18637	9197	43	of	of	IN
18637	9197	44	the	the	DT
18637	9197	45	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	9197	46	to	to	TO
18637	9197	47	be	be	VB
18637	9197	48	paid	pay	VBN
18637	9197	49	to	to	IN
18637	9197	50	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9197	51	,	,	,
18637	9197	52	which	which	WDT
18637	9197	53	,	,	,
18637	9197	54	in	in	IN
18637	9197	55	the	the	DT
18637	9197	56	case	case	NN
18637	9197	57	of	of	IN
18637	9197	58	the	the	DT
18637	9197	59	President	President	NNP
18637	9197	60	of	of	IN
18637	9197	61	the	the	DT
18637	9197	62	United	United	NNP
18637	9197	63	States	States	NNP
18637	9197	64	,	,	,
18637	9197	65	would	would	MD
18637	9197	66	be	be	VB
18637	9197	67	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	9197	68	if	if	IN
18637	9197	69	the	the	DT
18637	9197	70	act	act	NN
18637	9197	71	of	of	IN
18637	9197	72	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9197	73	levying	levy	VBG
18637	9197	74	the	the	DT
18637	9197	75	tax	tax	NN
18637	9197	76	was	be	VBD
18637	9197	77	passed	pass	VBN
18637	9197	78	during	during	IN
18637	9197	79	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9197	80	official	official	JJ
18637	9197	81	term	term	NN
18637	9197	82	.	.	.
18637	9198	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9198	2	45	45	CD
18637	9198	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9198	4	The	the	DT
18637	9198	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	9198	6	No	no	NN
18637	9198	7	.	.	.
18637	9199	1	69	69	CD
18637	9199	2	,	,	,
18637	9199	3	513	513	CD
18637	9199	4	,	,	,
18637	9199	5	515	515	CD
18637	9199	6	.	.	.
18637	9200	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9200	2	46	46	CD
18637	9200	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9200	4	Story	story	NN
18637	9200	5	's	's	POS
18637	9200	6	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	9200	7	,	,	,
18637	9200	8	II	II	NNP
18637	9200	9	,	,	,
18637	9200	10	§	â§	NN
18637	9200	11	1492	1492	CD
18637	9200	12	.	.	.
18637	9201	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9201	2	47	47	CD
18637	9201	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9201	4	Fleming	Fleming	NNP
18637	9201	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9201	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9201	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9201	8	Page	Page	NNP
18637	9201	9	,	,	,
18637	9201	10	9	9	CD
18637	9201	11	How	how	WRB
18637	9201	12	.	.	.
18637	9202	1	603	603	CD
18637	9202	2	,	,	,
18637	9202	3	615	615	CD
18637	9202	4	,	,	,
18637	9202	5	618	618	CD
18637	9202	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9202	7	1850	1850	CD
18637	9202	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9202	9	.	.	.
18637	9203	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9203	2	48	48	CD
18637	9203	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9203	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	9203	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	9203	6	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
18637	9203	7	,	,	,
18637	9203	8	4	4	CD
18637	9203	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9203	10	.	.	.
18637	9204	1	2	2	CD
18637	9204	2	,	,	,
18637	9204	3	139	139	CD
18637	9204	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9204	5	1866	1866	CD
18637	9204	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9204	7	.	.	.
18637	9205	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9205	2	49	49	CD
18637	9205	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9205	4	1	1	CD
18637	9205	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9205	6	.	.	.
18637	9206	1	424	424	CD
18637	9206	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9206	3	1795	1795	CD
18637	9206	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9206	5	;	;	:
18637	9206	6	2	2	CD
18637	9206	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	9206	8	.	.	.
18637	9207	1	443	443	CD
18637	9207	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9207	3	1807	1807	CD
18637	9207	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9207	5	.	.	.
18637	9208	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9208	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9208	3	also	also	RB
18637	9208	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9208	5	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	9208	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9208	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9208	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9208	9	Mott	Mott	NNP
18637	9208	10	,	,	,
18637	9208	11	12	12	CD
18637	9208	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	9208	13	.	.	.
18637	9209	1	19	19	CD
18637	9209	2	,	,	,
18637	9209	3	32	32	CD
18637	9209	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9209	5	33	33	CD
18637	9209	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9209	7	1827	1827	CD
18637	9209	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9209	9	,	,	,
18637	9209	10	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	9209	11	the	the	DT
18637	9209	12	finality	finality	NN
18637	9209	13	of	of	IN
18637	9209	14	the	the	DT
18637	9209	15	President	President	NNP
18637	9209	16	's	's	POS
18637	9209	17	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	9209	18	of	of	IN
18637	9209	19	the	the	DT
18637	9209	20	existence	existence	NN
18637	9209	21	of	of	IN
18637	9209	22	a	a	DT
18637	9209	23	state	state	NN
18637	9209	24	of	of	IN
18637	9209	25	facts	fact	NNS
18637	9209	26	requiring	require	VBG
18637	9209	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9209	28	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	9209	29	of	of	IN
18637	9209	30	the	the	DT
18637	9209	31	powers	power	NNS
18637	9209	32	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	9209	33	by	by	IN
18637	9209	34	the	the	DT
18637	9209	35	act	act	NN
18637	9209	36	of	of	IN
18637	9209	37	1795	1795	CD
18637	9209	38	.	.	.
18637	9210	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9210	2	50	50	CD
18637	9210	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9210	4	Messages	Messages	NNPS
18637	9210	5	and	and	CC
18637	9210	6	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	9210	7	of	of	IN
18637	9210	8	the	the	DT
18637	9210	9	Presidents	Presidents	NNPS
18637	9210	10	,	,	,
18637	9210	11	VII	VII	NNP
18637	9210	12	,	,	,
18637	9210	13	3221	3221	CD
18637	9210	14	.	.	.
18637	9211	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9211	2	51	51	CD
18637	9211	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9211	4	2	2	CD
18637	9211	5	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	9211	6	.	.	.
18637	9212	1	635	635	CD
18637	9212	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9212	3	1863	1863	CD
18637	9212	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9212	5	.	.	.
18637	9213	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9213	2	52	52	CD
18637	9213	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9213	4	Messages	Messages	NNPS
18637	9213	5	and	and	CC
18637	9213	6	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	9213	7	of	of	IN
18637	9213	8	the	the	DT
18637	9213	9	Presidents	Presidents	NNPS
18637	9213	10	,	,	,
18637	9213	11	VII	VII	NNP
18637	9213	12	,	,	,
18637	9213	13	3215	3215	CD
18637	9213	14	,	,	,
18637	9213	15	3216	3216	CD
18637	9213	16	,	,	,
18637	9213	17	3481	3481	CD
18637	9213	18	.	.	.
18637	9214	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9214	2	53	53	CD
18637	9214	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9214	4	2	2	CD
18637	9214	5	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	9214	6	.	.	.
18637	9215	1	at	at	IN
18637	9215	2	668	668	CD
18637	9215	3	-	-	SYM
18637	9215	4	670	670	CD
18637	9215	5	.	.	.
18637	9216	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9216	2	54	54	CD
18637	9216	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9216	4	12	12	CD
18637	9216	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	9216	6	.	.	.
18637	9217	1	326	326	CD
18637	9217	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9217	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	9217	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9217	5	.	.	.
18637	9218	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9218	2	55	55	CD
18637	9218	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9218	4	James	James	NNP
18637	9218	5	G.	G.	NNP
18637	9218	6	Randall	Randall	NNP
18637	9218	7	,	,	,
18637	9218	8	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	9218	9	Problems	Problems	NNPS
18637	9218	10	under	under	IN
18637	9218	11	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	9218	12	,	,	,
18637	9218	13	118	118	CD
18637	9218	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	9218	15	139	139	CD
18637	9218	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9218	17	New	New	NNP
18637	9218	18	York	York	NNP
18637	9218	19	,	,	,
18637	9218	20	1926	1926	CD
18637	9218	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9218	22	.	.	.
18637	9219	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9219	2	56	56	CD
18637	9219	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9219	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9219	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9219	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9219	7	the	the	DT
18637	9219	8	Government	Government	NNP
18637	9219	9	's	's	POS
18637	9219	10	brief	brief	NN
18637	9219	11	in	in	IN
18637	9219	12	United	United	NNP
18637	9219	13	States	States	NNP
18637	9219	14	_	_	NNP
18637	9219	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	9219	16	_	_	NNP
18637	9219	17	Montgomery	Montgomery	NNP
18637	9219	18	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	9219	19	and	and	CC
18637	9219	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	9219	21	,	,	,
18637	9219	22	150	150	CD
18637	9219	23	F.	F.	NNP
18637	9219	24	2d	2d	CD
18637	9219	25	369	369	CD
18637	9219	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9219	27	1945	1945	CD
18637	9219	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9219	29	.	.	.
18637	9220	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9220	2	57	57	CD
18637	9220	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9220	4	United	United	NNP
18637	9220	5	States	States	NNP
18637	9220	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9220	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9220	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9220	9	Curtiss	Curtiss	NNP
18637	9220	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	9220	11	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	9220	12	Export	Export	NNP
18637	9220	13	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	9220	14	,	,	,
18637	9220	15	299	299	CD
18637	9220	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9220	17	304	304	CD
18637	9220	18	,	,	,
18637	9220	19	327	327	CD
18637	9220	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9220	21	1936	1936	CD
18637	9220	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9220	23	.	.	.
18637	9221	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9221	2	58	58	CD
18637	9221	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9221	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9221	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9221	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9221	7	White	White	NNP
18637	9221	8	House	House	NNP
18637	9221	9	Digest	Digest	NNP
18637	9221	10	of	of	IN
18637	9221	11	Provisions	Provisions	NNPS
18637	9221	12	of	of	IN
18637	9221	13	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9221	14	Which	which	WDT
18637	9221	15	Would	Would	MD
18637	9221	16	Become	become	VB
18637	9221	17	Operative	operative	JJ
18637	9221	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	9221	19	Proclamation	Proclamation	NNP
18637	9221	20	of	of	IN
18637	9221	21	a	a	DT
18637	9221	22	National	National	NNP
18637	9221	23	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	9221	24	by	by	IN
18637	9221	25	the	the	DT
18637	9221	26	President	President	NNP
18637	9221	27	.	.	.
18637	9222	1	The	the	DT
18637	9222	2	Digest	Digest	NNP
18637	9222	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	9222	4	dated	date	VBN
18637	9222	5	December	December	NNP
18637	9222	6	11	11	CD
18637	9222	7	,	,	,
18637	9222	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	9222	9	.	.	.
18637	9223	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9223	2	was	be	VBD
18637	9223	3	released	release	VBN
18637	9223	4	to	to	IN
18637	9223	5	the	the	DT
18637	9223	6	press	press	NN
18637	9223	7	on	on	IN
18637	9223	8	December	December	NNP
18637	9223	9	16th	16th	NN
18637	9223	10	.	.	.
18637	9224	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9224	2	59	59	CD
18637	9224	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9224	4	56	56	CD
18637	9224	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9224	6	.	.	.
18637	9225	1	23	23	CD
18637	9225	2	.	.	.
18637	9226	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9226	2	60	60	CD
18637	9226	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9226	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	9226	5	.	.	.
18637	9227	1	Rec	Rec	NNP
18637	9227	2	.	.	.
18637	9228	1	77th	77th	NNP
18637	9228	2	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	9228	3	.	.	NNP
18637	9228	4	,	,	,
18637	9228	5	2d	2d	NNP
18637	9228	6	sess	sess	NN
18637	9228	7	.	.	.
18637	9228	8	,	,	,
18637	9228	9	vol	vol	NNP
18637	9228	10	.	.	.
18637	9229	1	88	88	CD
18637	9229	2	,	,	,
18637	9229	3	pt	pt	UH
18637	9229	4	.	.	.
18637	9230	1	5	5	CD
18637	9230	2	,	,	,
18637	9230	3	p.	p.	NN
18637	9230	4	7044	7044	CD
18637	9230	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9230	6	September	September	NNP
18637	9230	7	7	7	CD
18637	9230	8	,	,	,
18637	9230	9	1942	1942	CD
18637	9230	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9230	11	.	.	.
18637	9231	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9231	2	61	61	CD
18637	9231	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9231	4	50	50	CD
18637	9231	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	9232	1	War	War	NNP
18637	9232	2	,	,	,
18637	9232	3	App	App	NNP
18637	9232	4	.	.	.
18637	9233	1	1651	1651	CD
18637	9233	2	.	.	.
18637	9234	1	For	for	IN
18637	9234	2	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	9234	3	War	War	NNP
18637	9234	4	Agencies	Agencies	NNPS
18637	9234	5	that	that	WDT
18637	9234	6	were	be	VBD
18637	9234	7	functioning	function	VBG
18637	9234	8	at	at	IN
18637	9234	9	any	any	DT
18637	9234	10	particular	particular	JJ
18637	9234	11	time	time	NN
18637	9234	12	,	,	,
18637	9234	13	consult	consult	VB
18637	9234	14	the	the	DT
18637	9234	15	_	_	NNP
18637	9234	16	United	United	NNP
18637	9234	17	States	States	NNP
18637	9234	18	Government	Government	NNP
18637	9234	19	Manual	Manual	NNP
18637	9234	20	_	_	NNP
18637	9234	21	of	of	IN
18637	9234	22	the	the	DT
18637	9234	23	approximate	approximate	JJ
18637	9234	24	date	date	NN
18637	9234	25	.	.	.
18637	9235	1	The	the	DT
18637	9235	2	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9235	3	order	order	NN
18637	9235	4	creating	create	VBG
18637	9235	5	an	an	DT
18637	9235	6	agency	agency	NN
18637	9235	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	9235	8	cited	cite	VBN
18637	9235	9	by	by	IN
18637	9235	10	number	number	NN
18637	9235	11	.	.	.
18637	9236	1	For	for	IN
18637	9236	2	a	a	DT
18637	9236	3	Chronological	chronological	JJ
18637	9236	4	List	List	NNP
18637	9236	5	of	of	IN
18637	9236	6	Wartime	Wartime	NNP
18637	9236	7	Agencies	Agencies	NNPS
18637	9236	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9236	9	including	include	VBG
18637	9236	10	government	government	NN
18637	9236	11	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	9236	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9236	13	and	and	CC
18637	9236	14	some	some	DT
18637	9236	15	account	account	NN
18637	9236	16	of	of	IN
18637	9236	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9236	18	creation	creation	NN
18637	9236	19	down	down	RP
18637	9236	20	to	to	IN
18637	9236	21	the	the	DT
18637	9236	22	close	close	NN
18637	9236	23	of	of	IN
18637	9236	24	1942	1942	CD
18637	9236	25	,	,	,
18637	9236	26	_	_	NNP
18637	9236	27	see	see	VBP
18637	9236	28	_	_	NNP
18637	9236	29	chapter	chapter	NN
18637	9236	30	on	on	IN
18637	9236	31	War	War	NNP
18637	9236	32	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	9236	33	and	and	CC
18637	9236	34	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9236	35	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	9236	36	by	by	IN
18637	9236	37	Dean	Dean	NNP
18637	9236	38	Arthur	Arthur	NNP
18637	9236	39	T.	T.	NNP
18637	9236	40	Vanderbilt	Vanderbilt	NNP
18637	9236	41	in	in	IN
18637	9236	42	1942	1942	CD
18637	9236	43	Annual	Annual	NNP
18637	9236	44	Survey	Survey	NNP
18637	9236	45	of	of	IN
18637	9236	46	American	American	NNP
18637	9236	47	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9236	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9236	49	New	New	NNP
18637	9236	50	York	York	NNP
18637	9236	51	University	University	NNP
18637	9236	52	School	School	NNP
18637	9236	53	of	of	IN
18637	9236	54	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9236	55	,	,	,
18637	9236	56	1945	1945	CD
18637	9236	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9236	58	,	,	,
18637	9236	59	pp	pp	NNP
18637	9236	60	.	.	.
18637	9237	1	106	106	CD
18637	9237	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9237	3	231	231	CD
18637	9237	4	.	.	.
18637	9238	1	At	at	IN
18637	9238	2	the	the	DT
18637	9238	3	close	close	NN
18637	9238	4	of	of	IN
18637	9238	5	the	the	DT
18637	9238	6	war	war	NN
18637	9238	7	there	there	EX
18637	9238	8	were	be	VBD
18637	9238	9	29	29	CD
18637	9238	10	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	9238	11	grouped	group	VBN
18637	9238	12	under	under	IN
18637	9238	13	OEM	OEM	NNP
18637	9238	14	,	,	,
18637	9238	15	of	of	IN
18637	9238	16	which	which	WDT
18637	9238	17	OCD	OCD	NNP
18637	9238	18	,	,	,
18637	9238	19	WMC	WMC	NNP
18637	9238	20	,	,	,
18637	9238	21	and	and	CC
18637	9238	22	OC	OC	NNP
18637	9238	23	were	be	VBD
18637	9238	24	the	the	DT
18637	9238	25	first	first	JJ
18637	9238	26	to	to	TO
18637	9238	27	fold	fold	VB
18637	9238	28	up	up	RP
18637	9238	29	.	.	.
18637	9239	1	At	at	IN
18637	9239	2	the	the	DT
18637	9239	3	same	same	JJ
18637	9239	4	date	date	NN
18637	9239	5	there	there	EX
18637	9239	6	were	be	VBD
18637	9239	7	101	101	CD
18637	9239	8	separate	separate	JJ
18637	9239	9	government	government	NN
18637	9239	10	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	9239	11	,	,	,
18637	9239	12	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	9239	13	variously	variously	RB
18637	9239	14	in	in	IN
18637	9239	15	production	production	NN
18637	9239	16	,	,	,
18637	9239	17	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	9239	18	,	,	,
18637	9239	19	power	power	NN
18637	9239	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	9239	21	generation	generation	NN
18637	9239	22	,	,	,
18637	9239	23	banking	banking	NN
18637	9239	24	and	and	CC
18637	9239	25	lending	lending	NN
18637	9239	26	,	,	,
18637	9239	27	housing	housing	NN
18637	9239	28	,	,	,
18637	9239	29	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	9239	30	,	,	,
18637	9239	31	merchandising	merchandising	NN
18637	9239	32	,	,	,
18637	9239	33	and	and	CC
18637	9239	34	other	other	JJ
18637	9239	35	lines	line	NNS
18637	9239	36	of	of	IN
18637	9239	37	business	business	NN
18637	9239	38	and	and	CC
18637	9239	39	enjoying	enjoy	VBG
18637	9239	40	the	the	DT
18637	9239	41	independence	independence	NN
18637	9239	42	of	of	IN
18637	9239	43	autonomous	autonomous	JJ
18637	9239	44	republics	republic	NNS
18637	9239	45	,	,	,
18637	9239	46	being	be	VBG
18637	9239	47	subject	subject	JJ
18637	9239	48	to	to	IN
18637	9239	49	neither	neither	CC
18637	9239	50	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	9239	51	nor	nor	CC
18637	9239	52	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	9239	53	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
18637	9239	54	,	,	,
18637	9239	55	nor	nor	CC
18637	9239	56	to	to	TO
18637	9239	57	audit	audit	VB
18637	9239	58	by	by	IN
18637	9239	59	the	the	DT
18637	9239	60	General	General	NNP
18637	9239	61	Accounting	Accounting	NNP
18637	9239	62	Office	Office	NNP
18637	9239	63	.	.	.
18637	9240	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9240	2	62	62	CD
18637	9240	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9240	4	143	143	CD
18637	9240	5	F.	F.	NNP
18637	9240	6	2d	2d	NN
18637	9240	7	.	.	.
18637	9241	1	145	145	CD
18637	9241	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9241	3	1944	1944	CD
18637	9241	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9241	5	.	.	.
18637	9242	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9242	2	63	63	CD
18637	9242	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9242	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9242	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9242	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9242	7	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	9242	8	,	,	,
18637	9242	9	The	the	DT
18637	9242	10	President	President	NNP
18637	9242	11	,	,	,
18637	9242	12	Office	Office	NNP
18637	9242	13	and	and	CC
18637	9242	14	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	9242	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9242	16	3d	3d	NNP
18637	9242	17	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9242	18	.	.	.
18637	9242	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9243	1	296	296	CD
18637	9243	2	,	,	,
18637	9243	3	492	492	CD
18637	9243	4	.	.	.
18637	9244	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9244	2	64	64	CD
18637	9244	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9244	4	Exec	exec	JJ
18637	9244	5	.	.	.
18637	9245	1	Order	order	NN
18637	9245	2	9066	9066	CD
18637	9245	3	,	,	,
18637	9245	4	7	7	CD
18637	9245	5	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	9245	6	.	.	.
18637	9246	1	Reg	reg	NN
18637	9246	2	.	.	.
18637	9247	1	1407	1407	CD
18637	9247	2	.	.	.
18637	9248	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9248	2	65	65	CD
18637	9248	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9248	4	56	56	CD
18637	9248	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9248	6	.	.	.
18637	9249	1	173	173	CD
18637	9249	2	.	.	.
18637	9250	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9250	2	66	66	CD
18637	9250	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9250	4	Hirabayashi	Hirabayashi	NNP
18637	9250	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9250	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9250	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9250	8	United	United	NNP
18637	9250	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9250	10	,	,	,
18637	9250	11	320	320	CD
18637	9250	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9250	13	81	81	CD
18637	9250	14	,	,	,
18637	9250	15	91	91	CD
18637	9250	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	9250	17	92	92	CD
18637	9250	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9250	19	1943	1943	CD
18637	9250	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9250	21	.	.	.
18637	9251	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9251	2	67	67	CD
18637	9251	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9251	4	Korematsu	Korematsu	NNP
18637	9251	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9251	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9251	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9251	8	United	United	NNP
18637	9251	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9251	10	,	,	,
18637	9251	11	323	323	CD
18637	9251	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9251	13	214	214	CD
18637	9251	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9251	15	1944	1944	CD
18637	9251	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9251	17	.	.	.
18637	9252	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9252	2	68	68	CD
18637	9252	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9252	4	New	New	NNP
18637	9252	5	York	York	NNP
18637	9252	6	Times	Times	NNP
18637	9252	7	,	,	,
18637	9252	8	June	June	NNP
18637	9252	9	10	10	CD
18637	9252	10	,	,	,
18637	9252	11	1941	1941	CD
18637	9252	12	.	.	.
18637	9253	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9253	2	69	69	CD
18637	9253	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9253	4	7	7	CD
18637	9253	5	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	9253	6	.	.	.
18637	9254	1	Reg	reg	NN
18637	9254	2	.	.	.
18637	9255	1	237	237	CD
18637	9255	2	.	.	.
18637	9256	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9256	2	70	70	CD
18637	9256	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9256	4	57	57	CD
18637	9256	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9256	6	.	.	.
18637	9257	1	163	163	CD
18637	9257	2	.	.	.
18637	9258	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9258	2	71	71	CD
18637	9258	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9258	4	"	"	``
18637	9258	5	During	during	IN
18637	9258	6	the	the	DT
18637	9258	7	course	course	NN
18637	9258	8	of	of	IN
18637	9258	9	the	the	DT
18637	9258	10	year	year	NN
18637	9258	11	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9258	12	1945	1945	CD
18637	9258	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9258	14	the	the	DT
18637	9258	15	President	President	NNP
18637	9258	16	directed	direct	VBD
18637	9258	17	the	the	DT
18637	9258	18	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	9258	19	of	of	IN
18637	9258	20	many	many	JJ
18637	9258	21	of	of	IN
18637	9258	22	the	the	DT
18637	9258	23	nation	nation	NN
18637	9258	24	's	's	POS
18637	9258	25	industries	industry	NNS
18637	9258	26	in	in	IN
18637	9258	27	the	the	DT
18637	9258	28	course	course	NN
18637	9258	29	of	of	IN
18637	9258	30	labor	labor	NN
18637	9258	31	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	9258	32	.	.	.
18637	9259	1	The	the	DT
18637	9259	2	total	total	JJ
18637	9259	3	number	number	NN
18637	9259	4	of	of	IN
18637	9259	5	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	9259	6	taken	take	VBN
18637	9259	7	over	over	RP
18637	9259	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	9259	9	significant	significant	JJ
18637	9259	10	:	:	:
18637	9259	11	two	two	CD
18637	9259	12	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	9259	13	systems	system	NNS
18637	9259	14	,	,	,
18637	9259	15	one	one	CD
18637	9259	16	public	public	JJ
18637	9259	17	utility	utility	NN
18637	9259	18	,	,	,
18637	9259	19	nine	nine	CD
18637	9259	20	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	9259	21	companies	company	NNS
18637	9259	22	,	,	,
18637	9259	23	the	the	DT
18637	9259	24	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	9259	25	systems	system	NNS
18637	9259	26	of	of	IN
18637	9259	27	two	two	CD
18637	9259	28	cities	city	NNS
18637	9259	29	,	,	,
18637	9259	30	the	the	DT
18637	9259	31	motor	motor	NN
18637	9259	32	carriers	carrier	VBZ
18637	9259	33	in	in	IN
18637	9259	34	one	one	CD
18637	9259	35	city	city	NN
18637	9259	36	,	,	,
18637	9259	37	a	a	DT
18637	9259	38	towing	tow	VBG
18637	9259	39	company	company	NN
18637	9259	40	and	and	CC
18637	9259	41	a	a	DT
18637	9259	42	butadiene	butadiene	JJ
18637	9259	43	plant	plant	NN
18637	9259	44	.	.	.
18637	9260	1	In	in	IN
18637	9260	2	addition	addition	NN
18637	9260	3	thereto	thereto	VBP
18637	9260	4	the	the	DT
18637	9260	5	President	President	NNP
18637	9260	6	on	on	IN
18637	9260	7	April	April	NNP
18637	9260	8	10	10	CD
18637	9260	9	seized	seize	VBD
18637	9260	10	218	218	CD
18637	9260	11	bituminous	bituminous	JJ
18637	9260	12	coal	coal	NN
18637	9260	13	mines	mine	NNS
18637	9260	14	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	9260	15	to	to	IN
18637	9260	16	162	162	CD
18637	9260	17	companies	company	NNS
18637	9260	18	and	and	CC
18637	9260	19	on	on	IN
18637	9260	20	May	May	NNP
18637	9260	21	7	7	CD
18637	9260	22	,	,	,
18637	9260	23	33	33	CD
18637	9260	24	more	more	JJR
18637	9260	25	bituminous	bituminous	JJ
18637	9260	26	mines	mine	NNS
18637	9260	27	of	of	IN
18637	9260	28	24	24	CD
18637	9260	29	additional	additional	JJ
18637	9260	30	companies	company	NNS
18637	9260	31	.	.	.
18637	9261	1	The	the	DT
18637	9261	2	anthracite	anthracite	NN
18637	9261	3	coal	coal	NN
18637	9261	4	industry	industry	NN
18637	9261	5	fared	fare	VBD
18637	9261	6	no	no	RB
18637	9261	7	better	better	RB
18637	9261	8	;	;	,
18637	9261	9	on	on	IN
18637	9261	10	May	May	NNP
18637	9261	11	3	3	CD
18637	9261	12	and	and	CC
18637	9261	13	May	May	NNP
18637	9261	14	7	7	CD
18637	9261	15	all	all	PDT
18637	9261	16	the	the	DT
18637	9261	17	mines	mine	NNS
18637	9261	18	of	of	IN
18637	9261	19	365	365	CD
18637	9261	20	companies	company	NNS
18637	9261	21	and	and	CC
18637	9261	22	operators	operator	NNS
18637	9261	23	were	be	VBD
18637	9261	24	taken	take	VBN
18637	9261	25	away	away	RB
18637	9261	26	from	from	IN
18637	9261	27	the	the	DT
18637	9261	28	owners	owner	NNS
18637	9261	29	,	,	,
18637	9261	30	and	and	CC
18637	9261	31	on	on	IN
18637	9261	32	October	October	NNP
18637	9261	33	6	6	CD
18637	9261	34	the	the	DT
18637	9261	35	President	President	NNP
18637	9261	36	ordered	order	VBD
18637	9261	37	the	the	DT
18637	9261	38	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	9261	39	of	of	IN
18637	9261	40	54	54	CD
18637	9261	41	plants	plant	NNS
18637	9261	42	and	and	CC
18637	9261	43	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	9261	44	lines	line	NNS
18637	9261	45	of	of	IN
18637	9261	46	29	29	CD
18637	9261	47	petroleum	petroleum	NN
18637	9261	48	producing	produce	VBG
18637	9261	49	companies	company	NNS
18637	9261	50	in	in	IN
18637	9261	51	addition	addition	NN
18637	9261	52	to	to	IN
18637	9261	53	four	four	CD
18637	9261	54	taken	take	VBN
18637	9261	55	over	over	RP
18637	9261	56	prior	prior	JJ
18637	9261	57	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	9261	58	.	.	.
18637	9262	1	"	"	``
18637	9262	2	During	during	IN
18637	9262	3	the	the	DT
18637	9262	4	year	year	NN
18637	9262	5	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	9262	6	between	between	IN
18637	9262	7	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	9262	8	companies	company	NNS
18637	9262	9	and	and	CC
18637	9262	10	the	the	DT
18637	9262	11	Brotherhoods	Brotherhoods	NNPS
18637	9262	12	resulted	result	VBD
18637	9262	13	in	in	IN
18637	9262	14	the	the	DT
18637	9262	15	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	9262	16	of	of	IN
18637	9262	17	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	9262	18	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	9262	19	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	9262	20	Boards	Boards	NNPS
18637	9262	21	to	to	TO
18637	9262	22	investigate	investigate	VB
18637	9262	23	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	9262	24	and	and	CC
18637	9262	25	to	to	TO
18637	9262	26	report	report	VB
18637	9262	27	to	to	IN
18637	9262	28	the	the	DT
18637	9262	29	President	President	NNP
18637	9262	30	.	.	.
18637	9263	1	The	the	DT
18637	9263	2	President	President	NNP
18637	9263	3	also	also	RB
18637	9263	4	established	establish	VBD
18637	9263	5	on	on	IN
18637	9263	6	October	October	NNP
18637	9263	7	9	9	CD
18637	9263	8	a	a	DT
18637	9263	9	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	9263	10	Express	Express	NNP
18637	9263	11	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	9263	12	Board	Board	NNP
18637	9263	13	to	to	TO
18637	9263	14	investigate	investigate	VB
18637	9263	15	the	the	DT
18637	9263	16	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	9263	17	between	between	IN
18637	9263	18	the	the	DT
18637	9263	19	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	9263	20	Express	Express	NNP
18637	9263	21	and	and	CC
18637	9263	22	a	a	DT
18637	9263	23	union	union	NN
18637	9263	24	.	.	.
18637	9264	1	"	"	``
18637	9264	2	To	to	TO
18637	9264	3	implement	implement	VB
18637	9264	4	the	the	DT
18637	9264	5	directives	directive	NNS
18637	9264	6	of	of	IN
18637	9264	7	the	the	DT
18637	9264	8	National	National	NNP
18637	9264	9	War	War	NNP
18637	9264	10	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	9264	11	Board	Board	NNP
18637	9264	12	,	,	,
18637	9264	13	the	the	DT
18637	9264	14	Office	Office	NNP
18637	9264	15	of	of	IN
18637	9264	16	Economic	Economic	NNP
18637	9264	17	Stabilization	Stabilization	NNP
18637	9264	18	directed	direct	VBD
18637	9264	19	the	the	DT
18637	9264	20	cancellation	cancellation	NN
18637	9264	21	of	of	IN
18637	9264	22	all	all	DT
18637	9264	23	priority	priority	NN
18637	9264	24	applications	application	NNS
18637	9264	25	,	,	,
18637	9264	26	allocation	allocation	NN
18637	9264	27	applications	application	NNS
18637	9264	28	and	and	CC
18637	9264	29	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	9264	30	priorities	priority	NNS
18637	9264	31	and	and	CC
18637	9264	32	allocations	allocation	NNS
18637	9264	33	in	in	IN
18637	9264	34	the	the	DT
18637	9264	35	cases	case	NNS
18637	9264	36	of	of	IN
18637	9264	37	three	three	CD
18637	9264	38	clothing	clothing	NN
18637	9264	39	companies	company	NNS
18637	9264	40	and	and	CC
18637	9264	41	one	one	CD
18637	9264	42	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	9264	43	system	system	NN
18637	9264	44	which	which	WDT
18637	9264	45	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	9264	46	to	to	TO
18637	9264	47	comply	comply	VB
18637	9264	48	with	with	IN
18637	9264	49	orders	order	NNS
18637	9264	50	of	of	IN
18637	9264	51	the	the	DT
18637	9264	52	National	National	NNP
18637	9264	53	War	War	NNP
18637	9264	54	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	9264	55	Board	Board	NNP
18637	9264	56	.	.	.
18637	9264	57	"	"	''
18637	9265	1	Arthur	Arthur	NNP
18637	9265	2	T.	T.	NNP
18637	9265	3	Vanderbilt	Vanderbilt	NNP
18637	9265	4	,	,	,
18637	9265	5	War	War	NNP
18637	9265	6	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	9265	7	and	and	CC
18637	9265	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9265	9	Administration	administration	NN
18637	9265	10	,	,	,
18637	9265	11	1945	1945	CD
18637	9265	12	,	,	,
18637	9265	13	Annual	Annual	NNP
18637	9265	14	Survey	Survey	NNP
18637	9265	15	of	of	IN
18637	9265	16	American	American	NNP
18637	9265	17	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9265	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9265	19	New	New	NNP
18637	9265	20	York	York	NNP
18637	9265	21	University	University	NNP
18637	9265	22	School	School	NNP
18637	9265	23	of	of	IN
18637	9265	24	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9265	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9265	26	,	,	,
18637	9265	27	pp	pp	NNP
18637	9265	28	.	.	.
18637	9266	1	271	271	CD
18637	9266	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9266	3	273	273	CD
18637	9266	4	.	.	.
18637	9267	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9267	2	72	72	CD
18637	9267	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9267	4	8	8	CD
18637	9267	5	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	9267	6	.	.	.
18637	9268	1	Reg	reg	NN
18637	9268	2	.	.	.
18637	9269	1	11463	11463	CD
18637	9269	2	.	.	.
18637	9270	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9270	2	73	73	CD
18637	9270	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9270	4	56	56	CD
18637	9270	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9270	6	.	.	.
18637	9271	1	23	23	CD
18637	9271	2	.	.	.
18637	9272	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9272	2	74	74	CD
18637	9272	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9272	4	322	322	CD
18637	9272	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9272	6	398	398	CD
18637	9272	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9272	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	9272	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9272	10	.	.	.
18637	9273	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9273	2	75	75	CD
18637	9273	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9273	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9273	5	.	.	.
18637	9274	1	405	405	CD
18637	9274	2	-	-	CD
18637	9274	3	406	406	CD
18637	9274	4	.	.	.
18637	9275	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9275	2	76	76	CD
18637	9275	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9275	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9275	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9275	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9275	7	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	9275	8	,	,	,
18637	9275	9	The	the	DT
18637	9275	10	President	President	NNP
18637	9275	11	,	,	,
18637	9275	12	Office	Office	NNP
18637	9275	13	and	and	CC
18637	9275	14	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	9275	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9275	16	3d	3d	NNP
18637	9275	17	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9275	18	.	.	.
18637	9275	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9276	1	302	302	CD
18637	9276	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9276	3	303	303	CD
18637	9276	4	.	.	.
18637	9277	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9277	2	77	77	CD
18637	9277	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9277	4	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	9277	5	Fairman	Fairman	NNP
18637	9277	6	,	,	,
18637	9277	7	The	the	DT
18637	9277	8	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9277	9	of	of	IN
18637	9277	10	Martial	Martial	NNP
18637	9277	11	Rule	Rule	NNP
18637	9277	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9277	13	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	9277	14	,	,	,
18637	9277	15	1930	1930	CD
18637	9277	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9277	17	,	,	,
18637	9277	18	20	20	CD
18637	9277	19	-	-	SYM
18637	9277	20	22	22	CD
18637	9277	21	.	.	.
18637	9278	1	Albert	Albert	NNP
18637	9278	2	Venn	Venn	NNP
18637	9278	3	Dicey	Dicey	NNP
18637	9278	4	,	,	,
18637	9278	5	Introduction	introduction	NN
18637	9278	6	to	to	IN
18637	9278	7	the	the	DT
18637	9278	8	Study	Study	NNP
18637	9278	9	of	of	IN
18637	9278	10	the	the	DT
18637	9278	11	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9278	12	of	of	IN
18637	9278	13	the	the	DT
18637	9278	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9278	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9278	16	7th	7th	JJ
18637	9278	17	ed	ed	NN
18637	9278	18	.	.	.
18637	9279	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9279	2	,	,	,
18637	9279	3	283	283	CD
18637	9279	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9279	5	287	287	CD
18637	9279	6	.	.	.
18637	9280	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9280	2	78	78	CD
18637	9280	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9280	4	Dicey	Dicey	NNP
18637	9280	5	,	,	,
18637	9280	6	Introduction	introduction	NN
18637	9280	7	to	to	IN
18637	9280	8	the	the	DT
18637	9280	9	Study	Study	NNP
18637	9280	10	of	of	IN
18637	9280	11	the	the	DT
18637	9280	12	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9280	13	of	of	IN
18637	9280	14	the	the	DT
18637	9280	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9280	16	,	,	,
18637	9280	17	Chap	Chap	NNP
18637	9280	18	.	.	.
18637	9281	1	VIII	VIII	NNP
18637	9281	2	,	,	,
18637	9281	3	262	262	CD
18637	9281	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9281	5	271	271	CD
18637	9281	6	.	.	.
18637	9282	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9282	2	79	79	CD
18637	9282	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9282	4	7	7	CD
18637	9282	5	How	how	WRB
18637	9282	6	.	.	.
18637	9283	1	1	1	CD
18637	9283	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9283	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	9283	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9283	5	.	.	.
18637	9284	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9284	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9284	3	also	also	RB
18637	9284	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9284	5	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	9284	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9284	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9284	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9284	9	Mott	Mott	NNP
18637	9284	10	,	,	,
18637	9284	11	12	12	CD
18637	9284	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	9284	13	.	.	.
18637	9285	1	19	19	CD
18637	9285	2	,	,	,
18637	9285	3	32	32	CD
18637	9285	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9285	5	33	33	CD
18637	9285	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9285	7	1827	1827	CD
18637	9285	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9285	9	.	.	.
18637	9286	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9286	2	80	80	CD
18637	9286	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9286	4	2	2	CD
18637	9286	5	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	9286	6	.	.	.
18637	9287	1	635	635	CD
18637	9287	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9287	3	1863	1863	CD
18637	9287	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9287	5	.	.	.
18637	9288	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9288	2	81	81	CD
18637	9288	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9288	4	4	4	CD
18637	9288	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9288	6	.	.	.
18637	9289	1	2	2	CD
18637	9289	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9289	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	9289	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9289	5	.	.	.
18637	9290	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9290	2	82	82	CD
18637	9290	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9290	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9290	5	.	.	.
18637	9291	1	127	127	CD
18637	9291	2	.	.	.
18637	9292	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9292	2	83	83	CD
18637	9292	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9292	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9292	5	.	.	.
18637	9293	1	139	139	CD
18637	9293	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9293	3	140	140	CD
18637	9293	4	.	.	.
18637	9294	1	In	in	IN
18637	9294	2	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	9294	3	parte	parte	NN
18637	9294	4	Vallandigham	Vallandigham	NNP
18637	9294	5	the	the	DT
18637	9294	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9294	7	had	have	VBD
18637	9294	8	held	hold	VBN
18637	9294	9	while	while	IN
18637	9294	10	war	war	NN
18637	9294	11	was	be	VBD
18637	9294	12	still	still	RB
18637	9294	13	flagrant	flagrant	JJ
18637	9294	14	that	that	IN
18637	9294	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9294	16	had	have	VBD
18637	9294	17	no	no	DT
18637	9294	18	power	power	NN
18637	9294	19	to	to	TO
18637	9294	20	review	review	VB
18637	9294	21	by	by	IN
18637	9294	22	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	9294	23	the	the	DT
18637	9294	24	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	9294	25	of	of	IN
18637	9294	26	a	a	DT
18637	9294	27	military	military	JJ
18637	9294	28	commission	commission	NN
18637	9294	29	ordered	order	VBN
18637	9294	30	by	by	IN
18637	9294	31	a	a	DT
18637	9294	32	general	general	JJ
18637	9294	33	officer	officer	NN
18637	9294	34	of	of	IN
18637	9294	35	the	the	DT
18637	9294	36	Army	Army	NNP
18637	9294	37	,	,	,
18637	9294	38	commanding	command	VBG
18637	9294	39	a	a	DT
18637	9294	40	military	military	JJ
18637	9294	41	department	department	NN
18637	9294	42	.	.	.
18637	9295	1	1	1	CD
18637	9295	2	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9295	3	.	.	.
18637	9296	1	243	243	CD
18637	9296	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9296	3	1864	1864	CD
18637	9296	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9296	5	.	.	.
18637	9297	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9297	2	84	84	CD
18637	9297	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9297	4	31	31	CD
18637	9297	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9297	6	.	.	.
18637	9298	1	141	141	CD
18637	9298	2	,	,	,
18637	9298	3	153	153	CD
18637	9298	4	.	.	.
18637	9299	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9299	2	85	85	CD
18637	9299	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9299	4	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	9299	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9299	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9299	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9299	8	Kahanamoku	Kahanamoku	NNP
18637	9299	9	,	,	,
18637	9299	10	327	327	CD
18637	9299	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9299	12	304	304	CD
18637	9299	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9299	14	1946	1946	CD
18637	9299	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9299	16	.	.	.
18637	9300	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9300	2	86	86	CD
18637	9300	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9300	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9300	5	.	.	.
18637	9301	1	324	324	CD
18637	9301	2	.	.	.
18637	9302	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9302	2	87	87	CD
18637	9302	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9302	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9302	5	.	.	.
18637	9303	1	336	336	CD
18637	9303	2	.	.	.
18637	9304	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9304	2	88	88	CD
18637	9304	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9304	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9304	5	.	.	.
18637	9305	1	343	343	CD
18637	9305	2	.	.	.
18637	9306	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9306	2	89	89	CD
18637	9306	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9306	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	9306	5	parte	parte	NNP
18637	9306	6	Quirin	Quirin	NNP
18637	9306	7	,	,	,
18637	9306	8	317	317	CD
18637	9306	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9306	10	1	1	CD
18637	9306	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9306	12	1942	1942	CD
18637	9306	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9306	14	.	.	.
18637	9307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9307	2	90	90	CD
18637	9307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9307	4	317	317	CD
18637	9307	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9307	6	1	1	CD
18637	9307	7	,	,	,
18637	9307	8	29	29	CD
18637	9307	9	-	-	SYM
18637	9307	10	30	30	CD
18637	9307	11	,	,	,
18637	9307	12	35	35	CD
18637	9307	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9307	14	1942	1942	CD
18637	9307	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9307	16	.	.	.
18637	9308	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9308	2	91	91	CD
18637	9308	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9308	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9308	5	.	.	.
18637	9309	1	1	1	CD
18637	9309	2	,	,	,
18637	9309	3	41	41	CD
18637	9309	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9309	5	42	42	CD
18637	9309	6	.	.	.
18637	9310	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9310	2	92	92	CD
18637	9310	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9310	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9310	5	.	.	.
18637	9311	1	28	28	CD
18637	9311	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9311	3	29	29	CD
18637	9311	4	.	.	.
18637	9312	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9312	2	93	93	CD
18637	9312	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9312	4	1	1	CD
18637	9312	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9312	6	.	.	.
18637	9313	1	577	577	CD
18637	9313	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9313	3	1798	1798	CD
18637	9313	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9313	5	.	.	.
18637	9314	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9314	2	94	94	CD
18637	9314	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9314	4	327	327	CD
18637	9314	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9314	6	1	1	CD
18637	9314	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9314	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	9314	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9314	10	.	.	.
18637	9315	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9315	2	95	95	CD
18637	9315	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9315	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9315	5	.	.	.
18637	9316	1	81	81	CD
18637	9316	2	.	.	.
18637	9317	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9317	2	96	96	CD
18637	9317	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9317	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9317	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9317	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9317	7	Leo	Leo	NNP
18637	9317	8	Gross	Gross	NNP
18637	9317	9	,	,	,
18637	9317	10	The	the	DT
18637	9317	11	Criminality	Criminality	NNP
18637	9317	12	of	of	IN
18637	9317	13	Aggressive	Aggressive	NNP
18637	9317	14	War	War	NNP
18637	9317	15	,	,	,
18637	9317	16	41	41	CD
18637	9317	17	American	American	NNP
18637	9317	18	Political	Political	NNP
18637	9317	19	Science	Science	NNP
18637	9317	20	Review	Review	NNP
18637	9317	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9317	22	April	April	NNP
18637	9317	23	,	,	,
18637	9317	24	1947	1947	CD
18637	9317	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9317	26	,	,	,
18637	9317	27	205	205	CD
18637	9317	28	-	-	SYM
18637	9317	29	235	235	CD
18637	9317	30	.	.	.
18637	9318	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9318	2	97	97	CD
18637	9318	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9318	4	Fleming	Fleming	NNP
18637	9318	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9318	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9318	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9318	8	Page	Page	NNP
18637	9318	9	,	,	,
18637	9318	10	9	9	CD
18637	9318	11	How	how	WRB
18637	9318	12	.	.	.
18637	9319	1	603	603	CD
18637	9319	2	,	,	,
18637	9319	3	615	615	CD
18637	9319	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9319	5	1850	1850	CD
18637	9319	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9319	7	.	.	.
18637	9320	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9320	2	98	98	CD
18637	9320	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9320	4	Madsen	Madsen	NNP
18637	9320	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9320	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9320	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9320	8	Kinsella	Kinsella	NNP
18637	9320	9	,	,	,
18637	9320	10	343	343	CD
18637	9320	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9320	12	341	341	CD
18637	9320	13	,	,	,
18637	9320	14	348	348	CD
18637	9320	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9320	16	1952	1952	CD
18637	9320	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9320	18	.	.	.
18637	9321	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9321	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9321	3	also	also	RB
18637	9321	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9321	5	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	9321	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9321	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9321	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9321	9	Eisentrager	Eisentrager	NNP
18637	9321	10	,	,	,
18637	9321	11	339	339	CD
18637	9321	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9321	13	703	703	CD
18637	9321	14	,	,	,
18637	9321	15	789	789	CD
18637	9321	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9321	17	1950	1950	CD
18637	9321	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9321	19	.	.	.
18637	9322	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9322	2	99	99	CD
18637	9322	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9322	4	Totten	Totten	NNP
18637	9322	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9322	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9322	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9322	8	United	United	NNP
18637	9322	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9322	10	,	,	,
18637	9322	11	92	92	CD
18637	9322	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9322	13	105	105	CD
18637	9322	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9322	15	1876	1876	CD
18637	9322	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9322	17	.	.	.
18637	9323	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9323	2	100	100	CD
18637	9323	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9323	4	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	9323	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9323	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9323	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9323	8	Dillin	Dillin	NNP
18637	9323	9	,	,	,
18637	9323	10	21	21	CD
18637	9323	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9323	12	.	.	.
18637	9324	1	73	73	CD
18637	9324	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9324	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	9324	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9324	5	;	;	:
18637	9324	6	Haver	Haver	NNP
18637	9324	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9324	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	9324	9	_	_	NNP
18637	9324	10	Yaker	Yaker	NNP
18637	9324	11	,	,	,
18637	9324	12	9	9	CD
18637	9324	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9324	14	.	.	.
18637	9325	1	32	32	CD
18637	9325	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9325	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	9325	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9325	5	.	.	.
18637	9326	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9326	2	101	101	CD
18637	9326	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9326	4	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	9326	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9326	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9326	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9326	8	Harmony	Harmony	NNP
18637	9326	9	,	,	,
18637	9326	10	13	13	CD
18637	9326	11	How	how	WRB
18637	9326	12	.	.	.
18637	9327	1	115	115	CD
18637	9327	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9327	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	9327	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9327	5	;	;	:
18637	9327	6	United	United	NNP
18637	9327	7	States	States	NNP
18637	9327	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9327	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	9327	10	_	_	NNP
18637	9327	11	Russell	Russell	NNP
18637	9327	12	,	,	,
18637	9327	13	13	13	CD
18637	9327	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9327	15	.	.	.
18637	9328	1	623	623	CD
18637	9328	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9328	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	9328	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9328	5	;	;	:
18637	9328	6	Totten	Totten	NNP
18637	9328	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9328	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	9328	9	_	_	NNP
18637	9328	10	United	United	NNP
18637	9328	11	States	States	NNP
18637	9328	12	,	,	,
18637	9328	13	note	note	VBP
18637	9328	14	3	3	CD
18637	9328	15	above	above	RB
18637	9328	16	;	;	:
18637	9328	17	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9328	18	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	9328	19	's	's	POS
18637	9328	20	Note	note	NN
18637	9328	21	:	:	:
18637	9328	22	Reference	reference	NN
18637	9328	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	9328	24	to	to	IN
18637	9328	25	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	9328	26	99	99	CD
18637	9328	27	,	,	,
18637	9328	28	above	above	RB
18637	9328	29	.	.	.
18637	9328	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9329	1	40	40	CD
18637	9329	2	Op	Op	NNP
18637	9329	3	.	.	.
18637	9330	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9330	2	.	.	.
18637	9331	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9331	2	251	251	CD
18637	9331	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	9331	4	253	253	CD
18637	9331	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9331	6	1942	1942	CD
18637	9331	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9331	8	.	.	.
18637	9332	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9332	2	102	102	CD
18637	9332	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9332	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9332	5	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	9332	6	.	.	.
18637	9332	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9332	8	the	the	DT
18637	9332	9	Protocol	Protocol	NNP
18637	9332	10	of	of	IN
18637	9332	11	August	August	NNP
18637	9332	12	12	12	CD
18637	9332	13	,	,	,
18637	9332	14	1898	1898	CD
18637	9332	15	,	,	,
18637	9332	16	which	which	WDT
18637	9332	17	largely	largely	RB
18637	9332	18	foreshadowed	foreshadow	VBD
18637	9332	19	the	the	DT
18637	9332	20	Peace	Peace	NNP
18637	9332	21	of	of	IN
18637	9332	22	Paris	Paris	NNP
18637	9332	23	;	;	:
18637	9332	24	and	and	CC
18637	9332	25	President	President	NNP
18637	9332	26	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	9332	27	's	's	POS
18637	9332	28	Fourteen	Fourteen	NNP
18637	9332	29	Points	Points	NNPS
18637	9332	30	,	,	,
18637	9332	31	which	which	WDT
18637	9332	32	were	be	VBD
18637	9332	33	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	9332	34	in	in	IN
18637	9332	35	the	the	DT
18637	9332	36	Armistice	Armistice	NNP
18637	9332	37	of	of	IN
18637	9332	38	November	November	NNP
18637	9332	39	11	11	CD
18637	9332	40	,	,	,
18637	9332	41	1918	1918	CD
18637	9332	42	.	.	.
18637	9333	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9333	2	103	103	CD
18637	9333	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9333	4	Fleming	Fleming	NNP
18637	9333	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9333	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9333	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9333	8	Page	Page	NNP
18637	9333	9	,	,	,
18637	9333	10	9	9	CD
18637	9333	11	How	how	WRB
18637	9333	12	.	.	.
18637	9334	1	603	603	CD
18637	9334	2	,	,	,
18637	9334	3	615	615	CD
18637	9334	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9334	5	1850	1850	CD
18637	9334	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9334	7	.	.	.
18637	9335	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9335	2	104	104	CD
18637	9335	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9335	4	Santiago	Santiago	NNP
18637	9335	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9335	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9335	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9335	8	Nogueras	Nogueras	NNP
18637	9335	9	,	,	,
18637	9335	10	214	214	CD
18637	9335	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9335	12	260	260	CD
18637	9335	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9335	14	1909	1909	CD
18637	9335	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9335	16	.	.	.
18637	9336	1	As	as	IN
18637	9336	2	to	to	IN
18637	9336	3	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	9336	4	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	9336	5	territory	territory	NN
18637	9336	6	,	,	,
18637	9336	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9336	8	see	see	VBP
18637	9336	9	_	_	NNP
18637	9336	10	Dooley	Dooley	NNP
18637	9336	11	_	_	NNP
18637	9336	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	9336	13	_	_	NNP
18637	9336	14	United	United	NNP
18637	9336	15	States	States	NNP
18637	9336	16	,	,	,
18637	9336	17	182	182	CD
18637	9336	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9336	19	222	222	CD
18637	9336	20	,	,	,
18637	9336	21	230	230	CD
18637	9336	22	-	-	SYM
18637	9336	23	231	231	CD
18637	9336	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9336	25	1901	1901	CD
18637	9336	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9336	27	.	.	.
18637	9337	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9337	2	105	105	CD
18637	9337	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9337	4	Swaim	Swaim	NNP
18637	9337	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9337	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9337	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9337	8	United	United	NNP
18637	9337	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9337	10	,	,	,
18637	9337	11	165	165	CD
18637	9337	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9337	13	553	553	CD
18637	9337	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9337	15	1897	1897	CD
18637	9337	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9337	17	;	;	:
18637	9337	18	and	and	CC
18637	9337	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	9337	20	there	there	RB
18637	9337	21	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	9337	22	.	.	.
18637	9338	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9338	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9338	3	also	also	RB
18637	9338	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9338	5	Givens	Givens	NNP
18637	9338	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9338	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9338	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9338	9	Zerbst	Zerbst	NNP
18637	9338	10	,	,	,
18637	9338	11	255	255	CD
18637	9338	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9338	13	11	11	CD
18637	9338	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9338	15	1921	1921	CD
18637	9338	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9338	17	.	.	.
18637	9339	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9339	2	106	106	CD
18637	9339	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9339	4	15	15	CD
18637	9339	5	Op	op	NN
18637	9339	6	.	.	.
18637	9340	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9340	2	.	.	.
18637	9341	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9341	2	297	297	CD
18637	9341	3	and	and	CC
18637	9341	4	note	note	VB
18637	9341	5	;	;	:
18637	9341	6	30	30	CD
18637	9341	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9341	8	.	.	.
18637	9342	1	303	303	CD
18637	9342	2	;	;	:
18637	9342	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9342	4	cf	cf	NNP
18637	9342	5	.	.	.
18637	9342	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9342	7	1	1	CD
18637	9342	8	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9342	9	.	.	.
18637	9343	1	233	233	CD
18637	9343	2	,	,	,
18637	9343	3	234	234	CD
18637	9343	4	,	,	,
18637	9343	5	where	where	WRB
18637	9343	6	the	the	DT
18637	9343	7	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	9343	8	view	view	NN
18637	9343	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	9343	10	stated	state	VBN
18637	9343	11	by	by	IN
18637	9343	12	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	9343	13	General	General	NNP
18637	9343	14	Wirt	Wirt	NNP
18637	9343	15	.	.	.
18637	9344	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9344	2	107	107	LS
18637	9344	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9344	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	9344	5	parte	parte	NNP
18637	9344	6	Quirin	Quirin	NNP
18637	9344	7	,	,	,
18637	9344	8	317	317	CD
18637	9344	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9344	10	1	1	CD
18637	9344	11	,	,	,
18637	9344	12	28	28	CD
18637	9344	13	-	-	SYM
18637	9344	14	29	29	CD
18637	9344	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9344	16	1942	1942	CD
18637	9344	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9344	18	.	.	.
18637	9345	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9345	2	108	108	CD
18637	9345	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9345	4	General	General	NNP
18637	9345	5	Orders	Orders	NNPS
18637	9345	6	,	,	,
18637	9345	7	No	no	UH
18637	9345	8	.	.	.
18637	9346	1	100	100	CD
18637	9346	2	,	,	,
18637	9346	3	Official	Official	NNP
18637	9346	4	Records	Records	NNPS
18637	9346	5	,	,	,
18637	9346	6	War	War	NNP
18637	9346	7	of	of	IN
18637	9346	8	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
18637	9346	9	,	,	,
18637	9346	10	ser	ser	NN
18637	9346	11	.	.	.
18637	9347	1	III	III	NNP
18637	9347	2	,	,	,
18637	9347	3	vol	vol	NNP
18637	9347	4	.	.	.
18637	9348	1	III	iii	CD
18637	9348	2	;	;	:
18637	9348	3	April	April	NNP
18637	9348	4	24	24	CD
18637	9348	5	,	,	,
18637	9348	6	1863	1863	CD
18637	9348	7	.	.	.
18637	9349	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9349	2	109	109	CD
18637	9349	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9349	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9349	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9349	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9349	7	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	9349	8	,	,	,
18637	9349	9	Mimmack	Mimmack	NNP
18637	9349	10	_	_	NNP
18637	9349	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	9349	12	_	_	NNP
18637	9349	13	United	United	NNP
18637	9349	14	States	States	NNP
18637	9349	15	,	,	,
18637	9349	16	97	97	CD
18637	9349	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9349	18	426	426	CD
18637	9349	19	,	,	,
18637	9349	20	437	437	CD
18637	9349	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9349	22	1878	1878	CD
18637	9349	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9349	24	;	;	:
18637	9349	25	United	United	NNP
18637	9349	26	States	States	NNP
18637	9349	27	_	_	NNP
18637	9349	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	9349	29	_	_	NNP
18637	9349	30	Corson	Corson	NNP
18637	9349	31	,	,	,
18637	9349	32	114	114	CD
18637	9349	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9349	34	619	619	CD
18637	9349	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9349	36	1885	1885	CD
18637	9349	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9349	38	.	.	.
18637	9350	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9350	2	110	110	CD
18637	9350	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9350	4	10	10	CD
18637	9350	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	9351	1	§	§	NNP
18637	9351	2	1590	1590	CD
18637	9351	3	.	.	.
18637	9352	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9352	2	111	111	CD
18637	9352	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9352	4	Mullan	Mullan	NNP
18637	9352	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9352	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9352	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9352	8	United	United	NNP
18637	9352	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9352	10	,	,	,
18637	9352	11	140	140	CD
18637	9352	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9352	13	240	240	CD
18637	9352	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9352	15	1891	1891	CD
18637	9352	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9352	17	;	;	:
18637	9352	18	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	9352	19	_	_	NNP
18637	9352	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	9352	21	_	_	NNP
18637	9352	22	United	United	NNP
18637	9352	23	States	States	NNP
18637	9352	24	,	,	,
18637	9352	25	257	257	CD
18637	9352	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9352	27	541	541	CD
18637	9352	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9352	29	1922	1922	CD
18637	9352	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9352	31	.	.	.
18637	9353	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9353	2	112	112	CD
18637	9353	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9353	4	Surrogate	Surrogate	NNP
18637	9353	5	's	's	POS
18637	9353	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9353	7	,	,	,
18637	9353	8	Dutchess	Dutchess	NNP
18637	9353	9	County	County	NNP
18637	9353	10	,	,	,
18637	9353	11	New	New	NNP
18637	9353	12	York	York	NNP
18637	9353	13	,	,	,
18637	9353	14	ruling	rule	VBG
18637	9353	15	July	July	NNP
18637	9353	16	25	25	CD
18637	9353	17	,	,	,
18637	9353	18	1950	1950	CD
18637	9353	19	that	that	IN
18637	9353	20	the	the	DT
18637	9353	21	estate	estate	NN
18637	9353	22	of	of	IN
18637	9353	23	Franklin	Franklin	NNP
18637	9353	24	D.	D.	NNP
18637	9353	25	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	9353	26	was	be	VBD
18637	9353	27	not	not	RB
18637	9353	28	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	9353	29	to	to	IN
18637	9353	30	tax	tax	NN
18637	9353	31	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	9353	32	under	under	IN
18637	9353	33	sections	section	NNS
18637	9353	34	421	421	CD
18637	9353	35	and	and	CC
18637	9353	36	939	939	CD
18637	9353	37	of	of	IN
18637	9353	38	the	the	DT
18637	9353	39	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	9353	40	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	9353	41	Code	Code	NNP
18637	9353	42	,	,	,
18637	9353	43	which	which	WDT
18637	9353	44	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	9353	45	certain	certain	JJ
18637	9353	46	tax	tax	NN
18637	9353	47	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	9353	48	to	to	IN
18637	9353	49	persons	person	NNS
18637	9353	50	dying	die	VBG
18637	9353	51	in	in	IN
18637	9353	52	the	the	DT
18637	9353	53	military	military	JJ
18637	9353	54	service	service	NN
18637	9353	55	of	of	IN
18637	9353	56	the	the	DT
18637	9353	57	United	United	NNP
18637	9353	58	States	States	NNP
18637	9353	59	.	.	.
18637	9354	1	New	New	NNP
18637	9354	2	York	York	NNP
18637	9354	3	Times	Times	NNP
18637	9354	4	,	,	,
18637	9354	5	July	July	NNP
18637	9354	6	26	26	CD
18637	9354	7	,	,	,
18637	9354	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	9354	9	,	,	,
18637	9354	10	p.	p.	NN
18637	9354	11	27	27	CD
18637	9354	12	,	,	,
18637	9354	13	col	col	NNP
18637	9354	14	.	.	NNP
18637	9354	15	1	1	CD
18637	9354	16	.	.	.
18637	9355	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9355	2	113	113	CD
18637	9355	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9355	4	Farrand	Farrand	NNP
18637	9355	5	,	,	,
18637	9355	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9355	7	,	,	,
18637	9355	8	70	70	CD
18637	9355	9	,	,	,
18637	9355	10	97	97	CD
18637	9355	11	,	,	,
18637	9355	12	110	110	CD
18637	9355	13	;	;	:
18637	9355	14	II	II	NNP
18637	9355	15	,	,	,
18637	9355	16	285	285	CD
18637	9355	17	,	,	,
18637	9355	18	328	328	CD
18637	9355	19	,	,	,
18637	9355	20	335	335	CD
18637	9355	21	-	-	SYM
18637	9355	22	337	337	CD
18637	9355	23	,	,	,
18637	9355	24	367	367	CD
18637	9355	25	,	,	,
18637	9355	26	537	537	CD
18637	9355	27	-	-	SYM
18637	9355	28	542	542	CD
18637	9355	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9355	30	_	_	NNP
18637	9355	31	passim	passim	NNP
18637	9355	32	_	_	NNP
18637	9355	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9355	34	.	.	.
18637	9356	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9356	2	114	114	CD
18637	9356	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9356	4	Heads	head	NNS
18637	9356	5	of	of	IN
18637	9356	6	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	9356	7	Departments	Departments	NNP
18637	9356	8	except	except	IN
18637	9356	9	the	the	DT
18637	9356	10	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
18637	9356	11	General	General	NNP
18637	9356	12	have	have	VBP
18637	9356	13	no	no	DT
18637	9356	14	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	9356	15	legal	legal	JJ
18637	9356	16	terms	term	NNS
18637	9356	17	.	.	.
18637	9357	1	For	for	IN
18637	9357	2	the	the	DT
18637	9357	3	history	history	NN
18637	9357	4	of	of	IN
18637	9357	5	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	9357	6	on	on	IN
18637	9357	7	the	the	DT
18637	9357	8	subject	subject	NN
18637	9357	9	.	.	.
18637	9358	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9358	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9358	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9358	4	36	36	CD
18637	9358	5	Op	Op	NNP
18637	9358	6	.	.	.
18637	9359	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9359	2	.	.	.
18637	9360	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9360	2	12	12	CD
18637	9360	3	-	-	SYM
18637	9360	4	16	16	CD
18637	9360	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9360	6	April	April	NNP
18637	9360	7	18	18	CD
18637	9360	8	,	,	,
18637	9360	9	1929	1929	CD
18637	9360	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9360	11	;	;	:
18637	9360	12	_	_	NNP
18637	9360	13	also	also	RB
18637	9360	14	_	_	NNP
18637	9360	15	Everett	Everett	NNP
18637	9360	16	S.	S.	NNP
18637	9360	17	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	9360	18	,	,	,
18637	9360	19	The	the	DT
18637	9360	20	Tenure	Tenure	NNP
18637	9360	21	of	of	IN
18637	9360	22	Cabinet	Cabinet	NNP
18637	9360	23	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	9360	24	,	,	,
18637	9360	25	42	42	CD
18637	9360	26	American	American	NNP
18637	9360	27	Political	Political	NNP
18637	9360	28	Science	Science	NNP
18637	9360	29	Review	Review	NNP
18637	9360	30	529	529	NNP
18637	9360	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	9360	32	532	532	CD
18637	9360	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9360	34	June	June	NNP
18637	9360	35	,	,	,
18637	9360	36	1948	1948	CD
18637	9360	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9360	38	.	.	.
18637	9361	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9361	2	115	115	CD
18637	9361	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9361	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9361	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9361	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9361	7	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	9361	8	,	,	,
18637	9361	9	The	the	DT
18637	9361	10	President	President	NNP
18637	9361	11	,	,	,
18637	9361	12	Office	Office	NNP
18637	9361	13	and	and	CC
18637	9361	14	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	9361	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9361	16	3d	3d	NNP
18637	9361	17	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9361	18	.	.	.
18637	9362	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9362	2	,	,	,
18637	9362	3	New	New	NNP
18637	9362	4	York	York	NNP
18637	9362	5	University	University	NNP
18637	9362	6	Press	Press	NNP
18637	9362	7	,	,	,
18637	9362	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	9362	9	,	,	,
18637	9362	10	21	21	CD
18637	9362	11	-	-	SYM
18637	9362	12	22	22	CD
18637	9362	13	,	,	,
18637	9362	14	74	74	CD
18637	9362	15	,	,	,
18637	9362	16	98	98	CD
18637	9362	17	-	-	SYM
18637	9362	18	99	99	CD
18637	9362	19	,	,	,
18637	9362	20	257	257	CD
18637	9362	21	,	,	,
18637	9362	22	358	358	CD
18637	9362	23	-	-	SYM
18637	9362	24	364	364	CD
18637	9362	25	,	,	,
18637	9362	26	372	372	CD
18637	9362	27	-	-	SYM
18637	9362	28	373	373	CD
18637	9362	29	,	,	,
18637	9362	30	378	378	CD
18637	9362	31	-	-	SYM
18637	9362	32	381	381	CD
18637	9362	33	,	,	,
18637	9362	34	516	516	CD
18637	9362	35	-	-	SYM
18637	9362	36	519	519	CD
18637	9362	37	.	.	.
18637	9363	1	The	the	DT
18637	9363	2	only	only	JJ
18637	9363	3	question	question	NN
18637	9363	4	of	of	IN
18637	9363	5	a	a	DT
18637	9363	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	9363	7	nature	nature	NN
18637	9363	8	that	that	WDT
18637	9363	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	9363	10	arisen	arise	VBN
18637	9363	11	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	9363	12	the	the	DT
18637	9363	13	Cabinet	Cabinet	NNP
18637	9363	14	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	9363	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	9363	16	as	as	IN
18637	9363	17	to	to	IN
18637	9363	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9363	19	right	right	NN
18637	9363	20	to	to	TO
18637	9363	21	meet	meet	VB
18637	9363	22	,	,	,
18637	9363	23	on	on	IN
18637	9363	24	the	the	DT
18637	9363	25	call	call	NN
18637	9363	26	of	of	IN
18637	9363	27	the	the	DT
18637	9363	28	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	9363	29	of	of	IN
18637	9363	30	State	State	NNP
18637	9363	31	,	,	,
18637	9363	32	in	in	IN
18637	9363	33	the	the	DT
18637	9363	34	President	President	NNP
18637	9363	35	's	's	POS
18637	9363	36	absence	absence	NN
18637	9363	37	.	.	.
18637	9364	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	9364	2	.	.	.
18637	9365	1	402	402	CD
18637	9365	2	.	.	.
18637	9366	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9366	2	116	116	CD
18637	9366	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9366	4	United	United	NNP
18637	9366	5	States	States	NNP
18637	9366	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9366	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9366	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9366	9	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	9366	10	,	,	,
18637	9366	11	7	7	CD
18637	9366	12	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	9366	13	.	.	.
18637	9367	1	150	150	CD
18637	9367	2	,	,	,
18637	9367	3	160	160	CD
18637	9367	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9367	5	161	161	CD
18637	9367	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9367	7	1833	1833	CD
18637	9367	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9367	9	.	.	.
18637	9368	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9368	2	117	117	CD
18637	9368	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9368	4	236	236	CD
18637	9368	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9368	6	79	79	CD
18637	9368	7	,	,	,
18637	9368	8	86	86	CD
18637	9368	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9368	10	1915	1915	CD
18637	9368	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9368	12	.	.	.
18637	9369	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9369	2	118	118	CD
18637	9369	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9369	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9369	5	.	.	.
18637	9370	1	90	90	CD
18637	9370	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9370	3	91	91	CD
18637	9370	4	.	.	.
18637	9371	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9371	2	119	119	CD
18637	9371	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9371	4	Armstrong	Armstrong	NNP
18637	9371	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9371	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9371	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9371	8	United	United	NNP
18637	9371	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9371	10	,	,	,
18637	9371	11	13	13	CD
18637	9371	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9371	13	.	.	.
18637	9372	1	154	154	CD
18637	9372	2	,	,	,
18637	9372	3	156	156	CD
18637	9372	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9372	5	1872	1872	CD
18637	9372	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9372	7	.	.	.
18637	9373	1	In	in	IN
18637	9373	2	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	9373	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9373	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	9373	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9373	6	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	9373	7	,	,	,
18637	9373	8	161	161	CD
18637	9373	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9373	10	591	591	CD
18637	9373	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9373	12	1896	1896	CD
18637	9373	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9373	14	,	,	,
18637	9373	15	the	the	DT
18637	9373	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9373	17	had	have	VBD
18637	9373	18	said	say	VBN
18637	9373	19	:	:	:
18637	9373	20	"	"	``
18637	9373	21	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9373	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	9373	23	almost	almost	RB
18637	9373	24	a	a	DT
18637	9373	25	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	9373	26	corollary	corollary	NN
18637	9373	27	of	of	IN
18637	9373	28	the	the	DT
18637	9373	29	above	above	JJ
18637	9373	30	propositions	proposition	NNS
18637	9373	31	that	that	WDT
18637	9373	32	,	,	,
18637	9373	33	if	if	IN
18637	9373	34	the	the	DT
18637	9373	35	witness	witness	NN
18637	9373	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	9373	37	already	already	RB
18637	9373	38	received	receive	VBN
18637	9373	39	a	a	DT
18637	9373	40	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	9373	41	,	,	,
18637	9373	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9373	43	can	can	MD
18637	9373	44	not	not	RB
18637	9373	45	longer	long	RBR
18637	9373	46	set	set	VB
18637	9373	47	up	up	RP
18637	9373	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9373	49	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	9373	50	,	,	,
18637	9373	51	since	since	IN
18637	9373	52	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9373	53	stands	stand	VBZ
18637	9373	54	with	with	IN
18637	9373	55	respect	respect	NN
18637	9373	56	to	to	IN
18637	9373	57	such	such	JJ
18637	9373	58	offence	offence	NN
18637	9373	59	as	as	IN
18637	9373	60	if	if	IN
18637	9373	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9373	62	had	have	VBD
18637	9373	63	never	never	RB
18637	9373	64	been	be	VBN
18637	9373	65	committed	commit	VBN
18637	9373	66	.	.	.
18637	9373	67	"	"	''
18637	9374	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	9374	2	.	.	.
18637	9375	1	599	599	CD
18637	9375	2	,	,	,
18637	9375	3	citing	cite	VBG
18637	9375	4	British	british	JJ
18637	9375	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	9375	6	.	.	.
18637	9376	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9376	2	120	120	CD
18637	9376	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9376	4	Biddle	Biddle	NNP
18637	9376	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9376	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9376	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9376	8	Perovich	Perovich	NNP
18637	9376	9	,	,	,
18637	9376	10	274	274	CD
18637	9376	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9376	12	480	480	CD
18637	9376	13	,	,	,
18637	9376	14	486	486	CD
18637	9376	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9376	16	1927	1927	CD
18637	9376	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9376	18	.	.	.
18637	9377	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9377	2	121	121	CD
18637	9377	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9377	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9377	5	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	9377	6	.	.	.
18637	9377	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9377	8	W.H.	W.H.	NNP
18637	9378	1	Humbert	Humbert	NNP
18637	9378	2	,	,	,
18637	9378	3	The	the	DT
18637	9378	4	Pardoning	Pardoning	NNP
18637	9378	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	9378	6	of	of	IN
18637	9378	7	the	the	DT
18637	9378	8	President	President	NNP
18637	9378	9	,	,	,
18637	9378	10	American	American	NNP
18637	9378	11	Council	Council	NNP
18637	9378	12	on	on	IN
18637	9378	13	Public	Public	NNP
18637	9378	14	Affairs	Affairs	NNPS
18637	9378	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9378	16	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	9378	17	,	,	,
18637	9378	18	1941	1941	CD
18637	9378	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9378	20	73	73	CD
18637	9378	21	.	.	.
18637	9379	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9379	2	122	122	CD
18637	9379	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9379	4	274	274	CD
18637	9379	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9379	6	at	at	IN
18637	9379	7	486	486	CD
18637	9379	8	.	.	.
18637	9380	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9380	2	123	123	CD
18637	9380	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9380	4	23	23	CD
18637	9380	5	Op	Op	NNP
18637	9380	6	.	.	.
18637	9381	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9381	2	.	.	.
18637	9382	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9382	2	363	363	CD
18637	9382	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9382	4	1901	1901	CD
18637	9382	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9382	6	;	;	:
18637	9382	7	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	9382	8	Central	Central	NNP
18637	9382	9	R.	R.	NNP
18637	9382	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	9382	11	_	_	NNP
18637	9382	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	9382	13	_	_	NNP
18637	9382	14	Bosworth	Bosworth	NNP
18637	9382	15	,	,	,
18637	9382	16	133	133	CD
18637	9382	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9382	18	92	92	CD
18637	9382	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9382	20	1890	1890	CD
18637	9382	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9382	22	.	.	.
18637	9383	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9383	2	124	124	CD
18637	9383	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9383	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	9383	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	9383	6	Wells	Wells	NNP
18637	9383	7	,	,	,
18637	9383	8	18	18	CD
18637	9383	9	How	how	WRB
18637	9383	10	.	.	.
18637	9384	1	307	307	CD
18637	9384	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9384	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	9384	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9384	5	.	.	.
18637	9385	1	For	for	IN
18637	9385	2	the	the	DT
18637	9385	3	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	9385	4	view	view	NN
18637	9385	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9385	6	see	see	VBP
18637	9385	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9385	8	some	some	DT
18637	9385	9	early	early	JJ
18637	9385	10	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	9385	11	of	of	IN
18637	9385	12	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	9385	13	General	General	NNP
18637	9385	14	,	,	,
18637	9385	15	1	1	CD
18637	9385	16	Opins	Opins	NNP
18637	9385	17	.	.	.
18637	9386	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9386	2	.	.	.
18637	9387	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9387	2	342	342	CD
18637	9387	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9387	4	1820	1820	CD
18637	9387	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9387	6	;	;	:
18637	9387	7	2	2	CD
18637	9387	8	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9387	9	.	.	.
18637	9388	1	275	275	CD
18637	9388	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9388	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	9388	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9388	5	;	;	:
18637	9388	6	5	5	CD
18637	9388	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9388	8	.	.	.
18637	9389	1	687	687	CD
18637	9389	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9389	3	1795	1795	CD
18637	9389	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9389	5	;	;	:
18637	9389	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9389	7	cf	cf	NNP
18637	9389	8	.	.	.
18637	9389	9	_	_	NNP
18637	9389	10	4	4	CD
18637	9389	11	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9389	12	.	.	.
18637	9390	1	453	453	CD
18637	9390	2	;	;	:
18637	9390	3	United	United	NNP
18637	9390	4	States	States	NNP
18637	9390	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9390	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9390	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9390	8	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	9390	9	,	,	,
18637	9390	10	7	7	CD
18637	9390	11	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	9390	12	.	.	.
18637	9391	1	150	150	CD
18637	9391	2	,	,	,
18637	9391	3	161	161	CD
18637	9391	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9391	5	1833	1833	CD
18637	9391	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9391	7	.	.	.
18637	9392	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9392	2	125	125	CD
18637	9392	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9392	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	9392	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	9392	6	United	United	NNP
18637	9392	7	States	States	NNP
18637	9392	8	,	,	,
18637	9392	9	242	242	CD
18637	9392	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9392	11	27	27	CD
18637	9392	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9392	13	1916	1916	CD
18637	9392	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9392	15	.	.	.
18637	9393	1	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	9393	2	of	of	IN
18637	9393	3	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	9393	4	,	,	,
18637	9393	5	however	however	RB
18637	9393	6	,	,	,
18637	9393	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9393	8	within	within	IN
18637	9393	9	the	the	DT
18637	9393	10	same	same	JJ
18637	9393	11	term	term	NN
18637	9393	12	of	of	IN
18637	9393	13	court	court	NN
18637	9393	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9393	15	by	by	IN
18637	9393	16	shortening	shorten	VBG
18637	9393	17	the	the	DT
18637	9393	18	term	term	NN
18637	9393	19	of	of	IN
18637	9393	20	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	9393	21	,	,	,
18637	9393	22	although	although	IN
18637	9393	23	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	9393	24	had	have	VBD
18637	9393	25	already	already	RB
18637	9393	26	been	be	VBN
18637	9393	27	committed	commit	VBN
18637	9393	28	,	,	,
18637	9393	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	9393	30	a	a	DT
18637	9393	31	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	9393	32	act	act	NN
18637	9393	33	and	and	CC
18637	9393	34	no	no	DT
18637	9393	35	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	9393	36	of	of	IN
18637	9393	37	the	the	DT
18637	9393	38	pardoning	pardon	VBG
18637	9393	39	power	power	NN
18637	9393	40	.	.	.
18637	9394	1	United	United	NNP
18637	9394	2	States	States	NNP
18637	9394	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9394	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	9394	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9394	6	Benz	Benz	NNP
18637	9394	7	,	,	,
18637	9394	8	282	282	CD
18637	9394	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9394	10	304	304	CD
18637	9394	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9394	12	1931	1931	CD
18637	9394	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9394	14	.	.	.
18637	9395	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9395	2	126	126	CD
18637	9395	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9395	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9395	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9395	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9395	7	Messages	Messages	NNPS
18637	9395	8	and	and	CC
18637	9395	9	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	9395	10	of	of	IN
18637	9395	11	the	the	DT
18637	9395	12	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	9395	13	,	,	,
18637	9395	14	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9395	15	,	,	,
18637	9395	16	181	181	CD
18637	9395	17	,	,	,
18637	9395	18	303	303	CD
18637	9395	19	;	;	:
18637	9395	20	II	II	NNP
18637	9395	21	,	,	,
18637	9395	22	543	543	CD
18637	9395	23	;	;	:
18637	9395	24	VII	VII	NNP
18637	9395	25	,	,	,
18637	9395	26	3414	3414	CD
18637	9395	27	,	,	,
18637	9395	28	3508	3508	CD
18637	9395	29	;	;	:
18637	9395	30	VIII	VIII	NNP
18637	9395	31	,	,	,
18637	9395	32	3853	3853	CD
18637	9395	33	;	;	:
18637	9395	34	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	9395	35	,	,	,
18637	9395	36	6690	6690	CD
18637	9395	37	.	.	.
18637	9396	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9396	2	127	127	CD
18637	9396	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9396	4	United	United	NNP
18637	9396	5	States	States	NNP
18637	9396	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9396	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9396	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9396	9	Klein	Klein	NNP
18637	9396	10	,	,	,
18637	9396	11	13	13	CD
18637	9396	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9396	13	.	.	.
18637	9397	1	128	128	CD
18637	9397	2	,	,	,
18637	9397	3	147	147	CD
18637	9397	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9397	5	1872	1872	CD
18637	9397	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9397	7	.	.	.
18637	9398	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9398	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9398	3	also	also	RB
18637	9398	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9398	5	United	United	NNP
18637	9398	6	States	States	NNP
18637	9398	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9398	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	9398	9	_	_	NNP
18637	9398	10	Padelford	Padelford	NNP
18637	9398	11	,	,	,
18637	9398	12	9	9	CD
18637	9398	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9398	14	.	.	.
18637	9399	1	531	531	CD
18637	9399	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9399	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	9399	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9399	5	.	.	.
18637	9400	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9400	2	128	128	CD
18637	9400	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9400	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	9400	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	9400	6	Garland	Garland	NNP
18637	9400	7	,	,	,
18637	9400	8	4	4	CD
18637	9400	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9400	10	.	.	.
18637	9401	1	333	333	CD
18637	9401	2	,	,	,
18637	9401	3	380	380	CD
18637	9401	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9401	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	9401	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9401	7	.	.	.
18637	9402	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9402	2	129	129	CD
18637	9402	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9402	4	F.W.	F.W.	NNP
18637	9403	1	Maitland	Maitland	NNP
18637	9403	2	,	,	,
18637	9403	3	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	9403	4	History	History	NNP
18637	9403	5	of	of	IN
18637	9403	6	England	England	NNP
18637	9403	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9403	8	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
18637	9403	9	,	,	,
18637	9403	10	1903	1903	CD
18637	9403	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9403	12	,	,	,
18637	9403	13	302	302	CD
18637	9403	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	9403	15	306	306	CD
18637	9403	16	;	;	:
18637	9403	17	1	1	CD
18637	9403	18	Op	Op	NNP
18637	9403	19	.	.	.
18637	9404	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9404	2	.	.	.
18637	9405	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9405	2	342	342	CD
18637	9405	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9405	4	1820	1820	CD
18637	9405	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9405	6	.	.	.
18637	9406	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9406	2	130	130	CD
18637	9406	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9406	4	267	267	CD
18637	9406	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9406	6	87	87	CD
18637	9406	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9406	8	1925	1925	CD
18637	9406	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9406	10	.	.	.
18637	9407	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9407	2	131	131	CD
18637	9407	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9407	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9407	5	.	.	.
18637	9408	1	110	110	CD
18637	9408	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9408	3	111	111	CD
18637	9408	4	.	.	.
18637	9409	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9409	2	132	132	CD
18637	9409	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9409	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9409	5	.	.	.
18637	9410	1	121	121	CD
18637	9410	2	,	,	,
18637	9410	3	122	122	CD
18637	9410	4	.	.	.
18637	9411	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9411	2	133	133	CD
18637	9411	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9411	4	4	4	CD
18637	9411	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9411	6	.	.	.
18637	9412	1	333	333	CD
18637	9412	2	,	,	,
18637	9412	3	381	381	CD
18637	9412	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9412	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	9412	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9412	7	.	.	.
18637	9413	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9413	2	134	134	CD
18637	9413	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9413	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9413	5	.	.	.
18637	9414	1	380	380	CD
18637	9414	2	.	.	.
18637	9415	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9415	2	135	135	CD
18637	9415	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9415	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9415	5	.	.	.
18637	9416	1	396	396	CD
18637	9416	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9416	3	397	397	CD
18637	9416	4	.	.	.
18637	9417	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9417	2	136	136	CD
18637	9417	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9417	4	233	233	CD
18637	9417	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9417	6	51	51	CD
18637	9417	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9417	8	1914	1914	CD
18637	9417	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9417	10	.	.	.
18637	9418	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9418	2	137	137	CD
18637	9418	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9418	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9418	5	.	.	.
18637	9419	1	59	59	CD
18637	9419	2	.	.	.
18637	9420	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9420	2	138	138	CD
18637	9420	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9420	4	142	142	CD
18637	9420	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9420	6	450	450	CD
18637	9420	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9420	8	1892	1892	CD
18637	9420	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9420	10	.	.	.
18637	9421	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9421	2	139	139	CD
18637	9421	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9421	4	Knote	Knote	NNP
18637	9421	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9421	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9421	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9421	8	United	United	NNP
18637	9421	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9421	10	,	,	,
18637	9421	11	95	95	CD
18637	9421	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9421	13	149	149	CD
18637	9421	14	,	,	,
18637	9421	15	153	153	CD
18637	9421	16	-	-	SYM
18637	9421	17	154	154	CD
18637	9421	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9421	19	1877	1877	CD
18637	9421	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9421	21	.	.	.
18637	9422	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9422	2	140	140	CD
18637	9422	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9422	4	United	United	NNP
18637	9422	5	States	States	NNP
18637	9422	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9422	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9422	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9422	9	Klein	Klein	NNP
18637	9422	10	,	,	,
18637	9422	11	13	13	CD
18637	9422	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9422	13	.	.	.
18637	9423	1	128	128	CD
18637	9423	2	,	,	,
18637	9423	3	143	143	CD
18637	9423	4	,	,	,
18637	9423	5	148	148	CD
18637	9423	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9423	7	1872	1872	CD
18637	9423	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9423	9	.	.	.
18637	9424	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9424	2	141	141	CD
18637	9424	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9424	4	The	the	DT
18637	9424	5	Laura	Laura	NNP
18637	9424	6	,	,	,
18637	9424	7	114	114	CD
18637	9424	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9424	9	411	411	CD
18637	9424	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9424	11	1885	1885	CD
18637	9424	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9424	13	.	.	.
18637	9425	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9425	2	142	142	CD
18637	9425	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9425	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	9425	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9425	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9425	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9425	8	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	9425	9	,	,	,
18637	9425	10	161	161	CD
18637	9425	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9425	12	591	591	CD
18637	9425	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9425	14	1896	1896	CD
18637	9425	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9425	16	.	.	.
18637	9426	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9426	2	143	143	CD
18637	9426	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9426	4	Farrand	Farrand	NNP
18637	9426	5	,	,	,
18637	9426	6	II	II	NNP
18637	9426	7	,	,	,
18637	9426	8	183	183	CD
18637	9426	9	.	.	.
18637	9427	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9427	2	144	144	CD
18637	9427	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9427	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9427	5	.	.	.
18637	9428	1	538	538	CD
18637	9428	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9428	3	539	539	CD
18637	9428	4	.	.	.
18637	9429	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9429	2	145	145	CD
18637	9429	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9429	4	The	the	DT
18637	9429	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	9429	6	No	no	NN
18637	9429	7	.	.	.
18637	9430	1	64	64	CD
18637	9430	2	.	.	.
18637	9431	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9431	2	146	146	CD
18637	9431	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9431	4	Farrand	Farrand	NNP
18637	9431	5	,	,	,
18637	9431	6	III	III	NNP
18637	9431	7	,	,	,
18637	9431	8	424	424	CD
18637	9431	9	.	.	.
18637	9432	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9432	2	147	147	CD
18637	9432	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9432	4	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	9432	5	sought	seek	VBD
18637	9432	6	to	to	TO
18637	9432	7	use	use	VB
18637	9432	8	the	the	DT
18637	9432	9	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9432	10	as	as	IN
18637	9432	11	a	a	DT
18637	9432	12	council	council	NN
18637	9432	13	,	,	,
18637	9432	14	but	but	CC
18637	9432	15	the	the	DT
18637	9432	16	effort	effort	NN
18637	9432	17	proved	prove	VBD
18637	9432	18	futile	futile	JJ
18637	9432	19	,	,	,
18637	9432	20	principally	principally	RB
18637	9432	21	because	because	IN
18637	9432	22	the	the	DT
18637	9432	23	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9432	24	balked	balk	VBD
18637	9432	25	.	.	.
18637	9433	1	For	for	IN
18637	9433	2	the	the	DT
18637	9433	3	details	detail	NNS
18637	9433	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9433	5	see	see	VBP
18637	9433	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9433	7	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	9433	8	,	,	,
18637	9433	9	The	the	DT
18637	9433	10	President	President	NNP
18637	9433	11	,	,	,
18637	9433	12	Office	Office	NNP
18637	9433	13	and	and	CC
18637	9433	14	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	9433	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9433	16	3d	3d	NNP
18637	9433	17	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9433	18	.	.	.
18637	9434	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9434	2	,	,	,
18637	9434	3	253	253	CD
18637	9434	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9434	5	257	257	CD
18637	9434	6	.	.	.
18637	9435	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9435	2	148	148	CD
18637	9435	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9435	4	United	United	NNP
18637	9435	5	States	States	NNP
18637	9435	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9435	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9435	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9435	9	Curtiss	Curtiss	NNP
18637	9435	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	9435	11	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	9435	12	Export	Export	NNP
18637	9435	13	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	9435	14	,	,	,
18637	9435	15	299	299	CD
18637	9435	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9435	17	304	304	CD
18637	9435	18	,	,	,
18637	9435	19	319	319	CD
18637	9435	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9435	21	1936	1936	CD
18637	9435	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9435	23	.	.	.
18637	9436	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9436	2	149	149	CD
18637	9436	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9436	4	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	9436	5	,	,	,
18637	9436	6	The	the	DT
18637	9436	7	President	President	NNP
18637	9436	8	,	,	,
18637	9436	9	Office	Office	NNP
18637	9436	10	and	and	CC
18637	9436	11	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	9436	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9436	13	3d	3d	NNP
18637	9436	14	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9436	15	.	.	.
18637	9437	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9437	2	,	,	,
18637	9437	3	467	467	CD
18637	9437	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9437	5	468	468	CD
18637	9437	6	.	.	.
18637	9438	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9438	2	150	150	CD
18637	9438	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9438	4	"	"	``
18637	9438	5	Obviously	obviously	RB
18637	9438	6	the	the	DT
18637	9438	7	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9438	8	must	must	MD
18637	9438	9	contain	contain	VB
18637	9438	10	the	the	DT
18637	9438	11	whole	whole	JJ
18637	9438	12	contract	contract	NN
18637	9438	13	between	between	IN
18637	9438	14	the	the	DT
18637	9438	15	parties	party	NNS
18637	9438	16	,	,	,
18637	9438	17	and	and	CC
18637	9438	18	the	the	DT
18637	9438	19	power	power	NN
18637	9438	20	of	of	IN
18637	9438	21	the	the	DT
18637	9438	22	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9438	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	9438	24	limited	limit	VBN
18637	9438	25	to	to	IN
18637	9438	26	a	a	DT
18637	9438	27	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	9438	28	of	of	IN
18637	9438	29	such	such	JJ
18637	9438	30	terms	term	NNS
18637	9438	31	as	as	IN
18637	9438	32	have	have	VBP
18637	9438	33	already	already	RB
18637	9438	34	been	be	VBN
18637	9438	35	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	9438	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	9438	37	between	between	IN
18637	9438	38	the	the	DT
18637	9438	39	President	President	NNP
18637	9438	40	,	,	,
18637	9438	41	acting	act	VBG
18637	9438	42	for	for	IN
18637	9438	43	the	the	DT
18637	9438	44	United	United	NNP
18637	9438	45	States	States	NNP
18637	9438	46	,	,	,
18637	9438	47	and	and	CC
18637	9438	48	the	the	DT
18637	9438	49	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	9438	50	of	of	IN
18637	9438	51	the	the	DT
18637	9438	52	other	other	JJ
18637	9438	53	contracting	contracting	NN
18637	9438	54	power	power	NN
18637	9438	55	.	.	.
18637	9439	1	The	the	DT
18637	9439	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9439	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	9439	4	no	no	DT
18637	9439	5	right	right	NN
18637	9439	6	to	to	TO
18637	9439	7	ratify	ratify	VB
18637	9439	8	the	the	DT
18637	9439	9	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9439	10	and	and	CC
18637	9439	11	introduce	introduce	VB
18637	9439	12	new	new	JJ
18637	9439	13	terms	term	NNS
18637	9439	14	into	into	IN
18637	9439	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9439	16	,	,	,
18637	9439	17	which	which	WDT
18637	9439	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	9439	19	be	be	VB
18637	9439	20	obligatory	obligatory	JJ
18637	9439	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	9439	22	the	the	DT
18637	9439	23	other	other	JJ
18637	9439	24	power	power	NN
18637	9439	25	,	,	,
18637	9439	26	although	although	IN
18637	9439	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9439	28	may	may	MD
18637	9439	29	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	9439	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9439	31	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	9439	32	,	,	,
18637	9439	33	or	or	CC
18637	9439	34	make	make	VB
18637	9439	35	such	such	JJ
18637	9439	36	ratifications	ratification	NNS
18637	9439	37	conditional	conditional	JJ
18637	9439	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	9439	39	the	the	DT
18637	9439	40	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	9439	41	of	of	IN
18637	9439	42	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	9439	43	to	to	IN
18637	9439	44	the	the	DT
18637	9439	45	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9439	46	.	.	.
18637	9439	47	"	"	''
18637	9440	1	Fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	9440	2	Diamond	Diamond	NNP
18637	9440	3	Rings	Rings	NNPS
18637	9440	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9440	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	9440	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9440	7	United	United	NNP
18637	9440	8	States	States	NNP
18637	9440	9	,	,	,
18637	9440	10	183	183	CD
18637	9440	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9440	12	176	176	CD
18637	9440	13	,	,	,
18637	9440	14	183	183	CD
18637	9440	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9440	16	1901	1901	CD
18637	9440	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9440	18	.	.	.
18637	9441	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9441	2	151	151	CD
18637	9441	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9441	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9441	5	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	9441	6	.	.	.
18637	9441	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9441	8	Article	Article	NNP
18637	9441	9	I	I	NNP
18637	9441	10	,	,	,
18637	9441	11	section	section	NN
18637	9441	12	5	5	CD
18637	9441	13	,	,	,
18637	9441	14	clause	clause	NN
18637	9441	15	1	1	CD
18637	9441	16	;	;	:
18637	9441	17	_	_	NNP
18637	9441	18	also	also	RB
18637	9441	19	_	_	NNP
18637	9441	20	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	9441	21	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	9441	22	R.	R.	NNP
18637	9441	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	9441	24	_	_	NNP
18637	9441	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	9441	26	_	_	NNP
18637	9441	27	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	9441	28	,	,	,
18637	9441	29	248	248	CD
18637	9441	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9441	31	276	276	CD
18637	9441	32	,	,	,
18637	9441	33	283	283	CD
18637	9441	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	9441	35	284	284	CD
18637	9441	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9441	37	1919	1919	CD
18637	9441	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9441	39	.	.	.
18637	9442	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9442	2	152	152	CD
18637	9442	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9442	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9442	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9442	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9442	7	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
18637	9442	8	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	9442	9	,	,	,
18637	9442	10	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	9442	11	,	,	,
18637	9442	12	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9442	13	Making	making	NN
18637	9442	14	and	and	CC
18637	9442	15	Enforcement	Enforcement	NNP
18637	9442	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9442	17	2d	2d	NNP
18637	9442	18	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9442	19	.	.	NNP
18637	9442	20	,	,	,
18637	9442	21	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	9442	22	,	,	,
18637	9442	23	1916	1916	CD
18637	9442	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9442	25	,	,	,
18637	9442	26	§	§	NNP
18637	9442	27	53	53	CD
18637	9442	28	,	,	,
18637	9442	29	for	for	IN
18637	9442	30	instances	instance	NNS
18637	9442	31	.	.	.
18637	9443	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9443	2	153	153	CD
18637	9443	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9443	4	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	9443	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9443	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9443	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9443	8	Neilson	Neilson	NNP
18637	9443	9	,	,	,
18637	9443	10	2	2	CD
18637	9443	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	9443	12	.	.	.
18637	9444	1	253	253	CD
18637	9444	2	,	,	,
18637	9444	3	314	314	CD
18637	9444	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9444	5	1829	1829	CD
18637	9444	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9444	7	.	.	.
18637	9445	1	"	"	``
18637	9445	2	Though	though	IN
18637	9445	3	several	several	JJ
18637	9445	4	writers	writer	NNS
18637	9445	5	on	on	IN
18637	9445	6	the	the	DT
18637	9445	7	subject	subject	NN
18637	9445	8	of	of	IN
18637	9445	9	government	government	NN
18637	9445	10	place	place	NN
18637	9445	11	that	that	WDT
18637	9445	12	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9445	13	the	the	DT
18637	9445	14	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9445	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	9445	16	making	making	NN
18637	9445	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9445	18	power	power	NN
18637	9445	19	in	in	IN
18637	9445	20	the	the	DT
18637	9445	21	class	class	NN
18637	9445	22	of	of	IN
18637	9445	23	executive	executive	NN
18637	9445	24	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	9445	25	,	,	,
18637	9445	26	yet	yet	CC
18637	9445	27	this	this	DT
18637	9445	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	9445	29	evidently	evidently	RB
18637	9445	30	an	an	DT
18637	9445	31	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	9445	32	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	9445	33	;	;	:
18637	9445	34	for	for	IN
18637	9445	35	if	if	IN
18637	9445	36	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9445	37	attend	attend	VBP
18637	9445	38	carefully	carefully	RB
18637	9445	39	to	to	IN
18637	9445	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9445	41	operation	operation	NN
18637	9445	42	,	,	,
18637	9445	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9445	44	will	will	MD
18637	9445	45	be	be	VB
18637	9445	46	found	find	VBN
18637	9445	47	to	to	TO
18637	9445	48	partake	partake	VB
18637	9445	49	more	more	JJR
18637	9445	50	of	of	IN
18637	9445	51	the	the	DT
18637	9445	52	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	9445	53	than	than	IN
18637	9445	54	of	of	IN
18637	9445	55	the	the	DT
18637	9445	56	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9445	57	character	character	NN
18637	9445	58	,	,	,
18637	9445	59	though	though	IN
18637	9445	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9445	61	does	do	VBZ
18637	9445	62	not	not	RB
18637	9445	63	seem	seem	VB
18637	9445	64	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	9445	65	to	to	TO
18637	9445	66	fall	fall	VB
18637	9445	67	within	within	IN
18637	9445	68	the	the	DT
18637	9445	69	definition	definition	NN
18637	9445	70	of	of	IN
18637	9445	71	either	either	DT
18637	9445	72	.	.	.
18637	9446	1	The	the	DT
18637	9446	2	essence	essence	NN
18637	9446	3	of	of	IN
18637	9446	4	the	the	DT
18637	9446	5	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	9446	6	authority	authority	NN
18637	9446	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	9446	8	to	to	TO
18637	9446	9	enact	enact	VB
18637	9446	10	laws	law	NNS
18637	9446	11	,	,	,
18637	9446	12	or	or	CC
18637	9446	13	,	,	,
18637	9446	14	in	in	IN
18637	9446	15	other	other	JJ
18637	9446	16	words	word	NNS
18637	9446	17	,	,	,
18637	9446	18	to	to	TO
18637	9446	19	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	9446	20	rules	rule	NNS
18637	9446	21	for	for	IN
18637	9446	22	the	the	DT
18637	9446	23	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	9446	24	of	of	IN
18637	9446	25	the	the	DT
18637	9446	26	society	society	NN
18637	9446	27	;	;	:
18637	9446	28	while	while	IN
18637	9446	29	the	the	DT
18637	9446	30	execution	execution	NN
18637	9446	31	of	of	IN
18637	9446	32	the	the	DT
18637	9446	33	laws	law	NNS
18637	9446	34	,	,	,
18637	9446	35	and	and	CC
18637	9446	36	the	the	DT
18637	9446	37	employment	employment	NN
18637	9446	38	of	of	IN
18637	9446	39	the	the	DT
18637	9446	40	common	common	JJ
18637	9446	41	strength	strength	NN
18637	9446	42	,	,	,
18637	9446	43	either	either	CC
18637	9446	44	for	for	IN
18637	9446	45	this	this	DT
18637	9446	46	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	9446	47	,	,	,
18637	9446	48	or	or	CC
18637	9446	49	for	for	IN
18637	9446	50	the	the	DT
18637	9446	51	common	common	JJ
18637	9446	52	defence	defence	NN
18637	9446	53	,	,	,
18637	9446	54	seem	seem	VBP
18637	9446	55	to	to	TO
18637	9446	56	comprise	comprise	VB
18637	9446	57	all	all	PDT
18637	9446	58	the	the	DT
18637	9446	59	functions	function	NNS
18637	9446	60	of	of	IN
18637	9446	61	the	the	DT
18637	9446	62	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9446	63	magistrate	magistrate	NN
18637	9446	64	.	.	.
18637	9447	1	The	the	DT
18637	9447	2	power	power	NN
18637	9447	3	of	of	IN
18637	9447	4	making	make	VBG
18637	9447	5	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9447	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	9447	7	,	,	,
18637	9447	8	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	9447	9	,	,	,
18637	9447	10	neither	neither	CC
18637	9447	11	the	the	DT
18637	9447	12	one	one	CD
18637	9447	13	nor	nor	CC
18637	9447	14	the	the	DT
18637	9447	15	other	other	JJ
18637	9447	16	.	.	.
18637	9448	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9448	2	relates	relate	VBZ
18637	9448	3	neither	neither	CC
18637	9448	4	to	to	IN
18637	9448	5	the	the	DT
18637	9448	6	execution	execution	NN
18637	9448	7	of	of	IN
18637	9448	8	the	the	DT
18637	9448	9	subsisting	subsisting	JJ
18637	9448	10	laws	law	NNS
18637	9448	11	,	,	,
18637	9448	12	nor	nor	CC
18637	9448	13	to	to	IN
18637	9448	14	the	the	DT
18637	9448	15	enaction	enaction	NN
18637	9448	16	of	of	IN
18637	9448	17	new	new	JJ
18637	9448	18	ones	one	NNS
18637	9448	19	;	;	:
18637	9448	20	and	and	CC
18637	9448	21	still	still	RB
18637	9448	22	less	less	JJR
18637	9448	23	to	to	IN
18637	9448	24	an	an	DT
18637	9448	25	exertion	exertion	NN
18637	9448	26	of	of	IN
18637	9448	27	the	the	DT
18637	9448	28	common	common	JJ
18637	9448	29	strength	strength	NN
18637	9448	30	.	.	.
18637	9449	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9449	2	objects	object	NNS
18637	9449	3	are	be	VBP
18637	9449	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9449	5	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	9449	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9449	7	with	with	IN
18637	9449	8	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9449	9	nations	nation	NNS
18637	9449	10	,	,	,
18637	9449	11	which	which	WDT
18637	9449	12	have	have	VBP
18637	9449	13	the	the	DT
18637	9449	14	force	force	NN
18637	9449	15	of	of	IN
18637	9449	16	law	law	NN
18637	9449	17	,	,	,
18637	9449	18	but	but	CC
18637	9449	19	derive	derive	VB
18637	9449	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9449	21	from	from	IN
18637	9449	22	the	the	DT
18637	9449	23	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	9449	24	of	of	IN
18637	9449	25	good	good	JJ
18637	9449	26	faith	faith	NN
18637	9449	27	.	.	.
18637	9450	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9450	2	are	be	VBP
18637	9450	3	not	not	RB
18637	9450	4	rules	rule	NNS
18637	9450	5	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	9450	6	by	by	IN
18637	9450	7	the	the	DT
18637	9450	8	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	9450	9	to	to	IN
18637	9450	10	the	the	DT
18637	9450	11	subject	subject	NN
18637	9450	12	,	,	,
18637	9450	13	but	but	CC
18637	9450	14	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	9450	15	between	between	IN
18637	9450	16	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	9450	17	and	and	CC
18637	9450	18	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	9450	19	.	.	.
18637	9451	1	The	the	DT
18637	9451	2	power	power	NN
18637	9451	3	in	in	IN
18637	9451	4	question	question	NN
18637	9451	5	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	9451	6	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	9451	7	to	to	TO
18637	9451	8	form	form	VB
18637	9451	9	a	a	DT
18637	9451	10	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	9451	11	department	department	NN
18637	9451	12	,	,	,
18637	9451	13	and	and	CC
18637	9451	14	to	to	TO
18637	9451	15	belong	belong	VB
18637	9451	16	,	,	,
18637	9451	17	properly	properly	RB
18637	9451	18	,	,	,
18637	9451	19	neither	neither	CC
18637	9451	20	to	to	IN
18637	9451	21	the	the	DT
18637	9451	22	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	9451	23	nor	nor	CC
18637	9451	24	to	to	IN
18637	9451	25	the	the	DT
18637	9451	26	executive	executive	NN
18637	9451	27	.	.	.
18637	9451	28	"	"	''
18637	9452	1	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	9452	2	in	in	IN
18637	9452	3	The	the	DT
18637	9452	4	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	9452	5	No	no	NN
18637	9452	6	.	.	.
18637	9453	1	75	75	CD
18637	9453	2	.	.	.
18637	9454	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9454	2	154	154	CD
18637	9454	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9454	4	Head	Head	NNP
18637	9454	5	Money	Money	NNP
18637	9454	6	Cases	case	NNS
18637	9454	7	,	,	,
18637	9454	8	112	112	CD
18637	9454	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9454	10	589	589	CD
18637	9454	11	,	,	,
18637	9454	12	598	598	CD
18637	9454	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9454	14	1884	1884	CD
18637	9454	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9454	16	.	.	.
18637	9455	1	For	for	IN
18637	9455	2	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9455	3	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	9455	4	operative	operative	VBP
18637	9455	5	as	as	IN
18637	9455	6	"	"	``
18637	9455	7	law	law	NN
18637	9455	8	of	of	IN
18637	9455	9	the	the	DT
18637	9455	10	land	land	NN
18637	9455	11	"	"	''
18637	9455	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9455	13	"	"	``
18637	9455	14	self	self	NN
18637	9455	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	9455	16	executing	execute	VBG
18637	9455	17	"	"	''
18637	9455	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9455	19	,	,	,
18637	9455	20	_	_	NNP
18637	9455	21	see	see	VBP
18637	9455	22	_	_	NNP
18637	9455	23	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	9455	24	,	,	,
18637	9455	25	Treaties	Treaties	NNP
18637	9455	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9455	27	2d	2d	NNP
18637	9455	28	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9455	29	.	.	.
18637	9456	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9456	2	,	,	,
18637	9456	3	36	36	CD
18637	9456	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9456	5	42	42	CD
18637	9456	6	,	,	,
18637	9456	7	49	49	CD
18637	9456	8	-	-	SYM
18637	9456	9	62	62	CD
18637	9456	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9456	11	_	_	NNP
18637	9456	12	passim	passim	NNP
18637	9456	13	_	_	NNP
18637	9456	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9456	15	,	,	,
18637	9456	16	151	151	CD
18637	9456	17	,	,	,
18637	9456	18	153	153	CD
18637	9456	19	-	-	SYM
18637	9456	20	163	163	CD
18637	9456	21	,	,	,
18637	9456	22	179	179	CD
18637	9456	23	,	,	,
18637	9456	24	238	238	CD
18637	9456	25	-	-	SYM
18637	9456	26	239	239	CD
18637	9456	27	,	,	,
18637	9456	28	286	286	CD
18637	9456	29	,	,	,
18637	9456	30	321	321	CD
18637	9456	31	,	,	,
18637	9456	32	338	338	CD
18637	9456	33	,	,	,
18637	9456	34	345	345	CD
18637	9456	35	-	-	SYM
18637	9456	36	346	346	CD
18637	9456	37	.	.	.
18637	9457	1	For	for	IN
18637	9457	2	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9457	3	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	9457	4	of	of	IN
18637	9457	5	an	an	DT
18637	9457	6	"	"	``
18637	9457	7	executory	executory	JJ
18637	9457	8	"	"	''
18637	9457	9	character	character	NN
18637	9457	10	,	,	,
18637	9457	11	_	_	NNP
18637	9457	12	see	see	VBP
18637	9457	13	_	_	NNP
18637	9457	14	ibid	ibid	NNP
18637	9457	15	.	.	.
18637	9458	1	162	162	CD
18637	9458	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9458	3	163	163	CD
18637	9458	4	,	,	,
18637	9458	5	232	232	CD
18637	9458	6	,	,	,
18637	9458	7	236	236	CD
18637	9458	8	,	,	,
18637	9458	9	238	238	CD
18637	9458	10	,	,	,
18637	9458	11	493	493	CD
18637	9458	12	,	,	,
18637	9458	13	497	497	CD
18637	9458	14	,	,	,
18637	9458	15	532	532	CD
18637	9458	16	,	,	,
18637	9458	17	570	570	CD
18637	9458	18	,	,	,
18637	9458	19	589	589	CD
18637	9458	20	.	.	.
18637	9459	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9459	2	155	155	CD
18637	9459	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9459	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9459	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9459	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9459	7	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	9459	8	,	,	,
18637	9459	9	Chap	Chap	NNP
18637	9459	10	.	.	.
18637	9460	1	III	iii	CD
18637	9460	2	,	,	,
18637	9460	3	24	24	CD
18637	9460	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9460	5	42	42	CD
18637	9460	6	.	.	.
18637	9461	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9461	2	156	156	CD
18637	9461	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9461	4	3	3	CD
18637	9461	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	9461	6	.	.	.
18637	9462	1	199	199	CD
18637	9462	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9462	3	1796	1796	CD
18637	9462	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9462	5	.	.	.
18637	9463	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9463	2	157	157	CD
18637	9463	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9463	4	3	3	CD
18637	9463	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	9463	6	.	.	.
18637	9464	1	454	454	CD
18637	9464	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9464	3	1806	1806	CD
18637	9464	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9464	5	.	.	.
18637	9465	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9465	2	158	158	CD
18637	9465	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9465	4	"	"	``
18637	9465	5	In	in	IN
18637	9465	6	Chirac	Chirac	NNP
18637	9465	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9465	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	9465	9	_	_	NNP
18637	9465	10	Chirac	Chirac	NNP
18637	9465	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9465	12	2	2	CD
18637	9465	13	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	9465	14	.	.	.
18637	9466	1	259	259	CD
18637	9466	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9466	3	,	,	,
18637	9466	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9466	5	was	be	VBD
18637	9466	6	held	hold	VBN
18637	9466	7	by	by	IN
18637	9466	8	this	this	DT
18637	9466	9	court	court	NN
18637	9466	10	that	that	IN
18637	9466	11	a	a	DT
18637	9466	12	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9466	13	with	with	IN
18637	9466	14	France	France	NNP
18637	9466	15	gave	give	VBD
18637	9466	16	to	to	IN
18637	9466	17	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9466	18	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	9466	19	the	the	DT
18637	9466	20	right	right	NN
18637	9466	21	to	to	TO
18637	9466	22	purchase	purchase	VB
18637	9466	23	and	and	CC
18637	9466	24	hold	hold	VB
18637	9466	25	land	land	NN
18637	9466	26	in	in	IN
18637	9466	27	the	the	DT
18637	9466	28	United	United	NNP
18637	9466	29	States	States	NNP
18637	9466	30	,	,	,
18637	9466	31	removed	remove	VBD
18637	9466	32	the	the	DT
18637	9466	33	incapacity	incapacity	NN
18637	9466	34	of	of	IN
18637	9466	35	alienage	alienage	NN
18637	9466	36	and	and	CC
18637	9466	37	placed	place	VBD
18637	9466	38	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9466	39	in	in	IN
18637	9466	40	precisely	precisely	RB
18637	9466	41	the	the	DT
18637	9466	42	same	same	JJ
18637	9466	43	situation	situation	NN
18637	9466	44	as	as	IN
18637	9466	45	if	if	IN
18637	9466	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9466	47	had	have	VBD
18637	9466	48	been	be	VBN
18637	9466	49	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	9466	50	of	of	IN
18637	9466	51	this	this	DT
18637	9466	52	country	country	NN
18637	9466	53	.	.	.
18637	9467	1	The	the	DT
18637	9467	2	State	State	NNP
18637	9467	3	law	law	NN
18637	9467	4	was	be	VBD
18637	9467	5	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	9467	6	adverted	advert	VBN
18637	9467	7	to	to	IN
18637	9467	8	,	,	,
18637	9467	9	and	and	CC
18637	9467	10	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	9467	11	not	not	RB
18637	9467	12	to	to	TO
18637	9467	13	have	have	VB
18637	9467	14	been	be	VBN
18637	9467	15	considered	consider	VBN
18637	9467	16	a	a	DT
18637	9467	17	factor	factor	NN
18637	9467	18	of	of	IN
18637	9467	19	any	any	DT
18637	9467	20	importance	importance	NN
18637	9467	21	in	in	IN
18637	9467	22	this	this	DT
18637	9467	23	view	view	NN
18637	9467	24	of	of	IN
18637	9467	25	the	the	DT
18637	9467	26	case	case	NN
18637	9467	27	.	.	.
18637	9468	1	The	the	DT
18637	9468	2	same	same	JJ
18637	9468	3	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	9468	4	was	be	VBD
18637	9468	5	reaffirmed	reaffirm	VBN
18637	9468	6	touching	touch	VBG
18637	9468	7	this	this	DT
18637	9468	8	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9468	9	in	in	IN
18637	9468	10	Carneal	Carneal	NNP
18637	9468	11	_	_	NNP
18637	9468	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	9468	13	_	_	NNP
18637	9468	14	Banks	Banks	NNPS
18637	9468	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9468	16	10	10	CD
18637	9468	17	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	9468	18	.	.	.
18637	9469	1	181	181	LS
18637	9469	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9469	3	and	and	CC
18637	9469	4	with	with	IN
18637	9469	5	respect	respect	NN
18637	9469	6	to	to	IN
18637	9469	7	the	the	DT
18637	9469	8	British	British	NNP
18637	9469	9	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	9469	10	of	of	IN
18637	9469	11	1794	1794	CD
18637	9469	12	,	,	,
18637	9469	13	in	in	IN
18637	9469	14	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	9469	15	_	_	NNP
18637	9469	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	9469	17	_	_	NNP
18637	9469	18	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	9469	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9469	20	9	9	CD
18637	9469	21	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	9469	22	.	.	.
18637	9470	1	489	489	CD
18637	9470	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9470	3	.	.	.
18637	9471	1	A	a	DT
18637	9471	2	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9471	3	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	9471	4	may	may	MD
18637	9471	5	be	be	VB
18637	9471	6	effectual	effectual	JJ
18637	9471	7	to	to	TO
18637	9471	8	protect	protect	VB
18637	9471	9	the	the	DT
18637	9471	10	land	land	NN
18637	9471	11	of	of	IN
18637	9471	12	an	an	DT
18637	9471	13	alien	alien	NN
18637	9471	14	from	from	IN
18637	9471	15	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	9471	16	by	by	IN
18637	9471	17	escheat	escheat	NN
18637	9471	18	under	under	IN
18637	9471	19	the	the	DT
18637	9471	20	laws	law	NNS
18637	9471	21	of	of	IN
18637	9471	22	a	a	DT
18637	9471	23	State	state	NN
18637	9471	24	.	.	.
18637	9472	1	Orr	Orr	NNP
18637	9472	2	_	_	NNP
18637	9472	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	9472	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9472	5	Hodgson	Hodgson	NNP
18637	9472	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9472	7	4	4	CD
18637	9472	8	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	9472	9	.	.	.
18637	9473	1	458	458	CD
18637	9473	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9473	3	.	.	.
18637	9474	1	By	by	IN
18637	9474	2	the	the	DT
18637	9474	3	British	british	JJ
18637	9474	4	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9474	5	of	of	IN
18637	9474	6	1794	1794	CD
18637	9474	7	,	,	,
18637	9474	8	'	'	''
18637	9474	9	all	all	DT
18637	9474	10	impediment	impediment	NN
18637	9474	11	of	of	IN
18637	9474	12	alienage	alienage	NN
18637	9474	13	was	be	VBD
18637	9474	14	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	9474	15	levelled	level	VBN
18637	9474	16	with	with	IN
18637	9474	17	the	the	DT
18637	9474	18	ground	ground	NN
18637	9474	19	despite	despite	IN
18637	9474	20	the	the	DT
18637	9474	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	9474	22	of	of	IN
18637	9474	23	the	the	DT
18637	9474	24	States	States	NNP
18637	9474	25	.	.	.
18637	9475	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9475	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	9475	3	the	the	DT
18637	9475	4	direct	direct	JJ
18637	9475	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	9475	6	question	question	NN
18637	9475	7	in	in	IN
18637	9475	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9475	9	fullest	full	JJS
18637	9475	10	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	9475	11	.	.	.
18637	9476	1	Yet	yet	CC
18637	9476	2	the	the	DT
18637	9476	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	9476	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9476	5	held	hold	VBD
18637	9476	6	that	that	IN
18637	9476	7	the	the	DT
18637	9476	8	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	9476	9	was	be	VBD
18637	9476	10	within	within	IN
18637	9476	11	the	the	DT
18637	9476	12	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	9476	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	9476	14	of	of	IN
18637	9476	15	the	the	DT
18637	9476	16	Union	Union	NNP
18637	9476	17	.	.	.
18637	9477	1	Fairfax	Fairfax	NNP
18637	9477	2	's	's	POS
18637	9477	3	Devisees	Devisees	NNPS
18637	9477	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9477	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	9477	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9477	7	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	9477	8	's	's	POS
18637	9477	9	Lessee	Lessee	NNP
18637	9477	10	,	,	,
18637	9477	11	7	7	CD
18637	9477	12	Cr	cr	NN
18637	9477	13	.	.	.
18637	9478	1	627	627	CD
18637	9478	2	;	;	:
18637	9478	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9478	4	see	see	VB
18637	9478	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9478	6	Ware	Ware	NNP
18637	9478	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9478	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	9478	9	_	_	NNP
18637	9478	10	Hylton	Hylton	NNP
18637	9478	11	,	,	,
18637	9478	12	3	3	CD
18637	9478	13	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	9478	14	.	.	.
18637	9479	1	242	242	CD
18637	9479	2	.	.	.
18637	9479	3	'	'	''
18637	9480	1	8	8	CD
18637	9480	2	Op	op	NN
18637	9480	3	.	.	.
18637	9481	1	Attys	Attys	NNP
18637	9481	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	9481	3	Gen	Gen	NNP
18637	9481	4	.	.	.
18637	9481	5	417	417	CD
18637	9481	6	.	.	.
18637	9482	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	9482	2	Calhoun	Calhoun	NNP
18637	9482	3	,	,	,
18637	9482	4	after	after	IN
18637	9482	5	laying	lay	VBG
18637	9482	6	down	down	RP
18637	9482	7	certain	certain	JJ
18637	9482	8	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	9482	9	and	and	CC
18637	9482	10	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	9482	11	which	which	WDT
18637	9482	12	do	do	VBP
18637	9482	13	not	not	RB
18637	9482	14	affect	affect	VB
18637	9482	15	this	this	DT
18637	9482	16	case	case	NN
18637	9482	17	,	,	,
18637	9482	18	says	say	VBZ
18637	9482	19	:	:	:
18637	9482	20	'	'	``
18637	9482	21	Within	within	IN
18637	9482	22	these	these	DT
18637	9482	23	limits	limit	NNS
18637	9482	24	all	all	DT
18637	9482	25	questions	question	NNS
18637	9482	26	which	which	WDT
18637	9482	27	may	may	MD
18637	9482	28	arise	arise	VB
18637	9482	29	between	between	IN
18637	9482	30	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9482	31	and	and	CC
18637	9482	32	other	other	JJ
18637	9482	33	powers	power	NNS
18637	9482	34	,	,	,
18637	9482	35	be	be	VB
18637	9482	36	the	the	DT
18637	9482	37	subject	subject	NN
18637	9482	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	9482	39	matter	matter	NN
18637	9482	40	what	what	WP
18637	9482	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9482	42	may	may	MD
18637	9482	43	,	,	,
18637	9482	44	fall	fall	VB
18637	9482	45	within	within	IN
18637	9482	46	the	the	DT
18637	9482	47	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9482	48	-	-	HYPH
18637	9482	49	making	make	VBG
18637	9482	50	power	power	NN
18637	9482	51	and	and	CC
18637	9482	52	may	may	MD
18637	9482	53	be	be	VB
18637	9482	54	adjusted	adjust	VBN
18637	9482	55	by	by	IN
18637	9482	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9482	57	.	.	.
18637	9482	58	'	'	''
18637	9483	1	Treat	treat	VB
18637	9483	2	.	.	.
18637	9484	1	on	on	IN
18637	9484	2	the	the	DT
18637	9484	3	Const	Const	NNP
18637	9484	4	.	.	.
18637	9485	1	and	and	CC
18637	9485	2	Gov.	Gov.	NNP
18637	9486	1	of	of	IN
18637	9486	2	the	the	DT
18637	9486	3	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9486	4	204	204	CD
18637	9486	5	.	.	.
18637	9487	1	"	"	``
18637	9487	2	If	if	IN
18637	9487	3	the	the	DT
18637	9487	4	national	national	JJ
18637	9487	5	government	government	NN
18637	9487	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	9487	7	not	not	RB
18637	9487	8	the	the	DT
18637	9487	9	power	power	NN
18637	9487	10	to	to	TO
18637	9487	11	do	do	VB
18637	9487	12	what	what	WP
18637	9487	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	9487	14	done	do	VBN
18637	9487	15	by	by	IN
18637	9487	16	such	such	JJ
18637	9487	17	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9487	18	,	,	,
18637	9487	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9487	20	can	can	MD
18637	9487	21	not	not	RB
18637	9487	22	be	be	VB
18637	9487	23	done	do	VBN
18637	9487	24	at	at	RB
18637	9487	25	all	all	RB
18637	9487	26	,	,	,
18637	9487	27	for	for	IN
18637	9487	28	the	the	DT
18637	9487	29	States	States	NNPS
18637	9487	30	are	be	VBP
18637	9487	31	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	9487	32	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	9487	33	to	to	TO
18637	9487	34	'	'	''
18637	9487	35	enter	enter	VB
18637	9487	36	into	into	IN
18637	9487	37	any	any	DT
18637	9487	38	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9487	39	,	,	,
18637	9487	40	alliance	alliance	NN
18637	9487	41	,	,	,
18637	9487	42	or	or	CC
18637	9487	43	confederation	confederation	NN
18637	9487	44	.	.	.
18637	9487	45	'	'	''
18637	9488	1	Const	Const	NNP
18637	9488	2	.	.	NNP
18637	9488	3	,	,	,
18637	9488	4	art	art	NN
18637	9488	5	.	.	.
18637	9489	1	I.	I.	NNP
18637	9489	2	sect	sect	NN
18637	9489	3	.	.	.
18637	9490	1	10	10	CD
18637	9490	2	.	.	.
18637	9491	1	"	"	``
18637	9491	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9491	3	must	must	MD
18637	9491	4	always	always	RB
18637	9491	5	be	be	VB
18637	9491	6	borne	bear	VBN
18637	9491	7	in	in	IN
18637	9491	8	mind	mind	NN
18637	9491	9	that	that	IN
18637	9491	10	the	the	DT
18637	9491	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9491	12	,	,	,
18637	9491	13	laws	law	NNS
18637	9491	14	,	,	,
18637	9491	15	and	and	CC
18637	9491	16	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9491	17	of	of	IN
18637	9491	18	the	the	DT
18637	9491	19	United	United	NNP
18637	9491	20	States	States	NNP
18637	9491	21	are	be	VBP
18637	9491	22	as	as	RB
18637	9491	23	much	much	JJ
18637	9491	24	a	a	DT
18637	9491	25	part	part	NN
18637	9491	26	of	of	IN
18637	9491	27	the	the	DT
18637	9491	28	law	law	NN
18637	9491	29	of	of	IN
18637	9491	30	every	every	DT
18637	9491	31	State	State	NNP
18637	9491	32	as	as	IN
18637	9491	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9491	34	own	own	JJ
18637	9491	35	local	local	JJ
18637	9491	36	laws	law	NNS
18637	9491	37	and	and	CC
18637	9491	38	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9491	39	.	.	.
18637	9492	1	This	this	DT
18637	9492	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	9492	3	a	a	DT
18637	9492	4	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	9492	5	principle	principle	NN
18637	9492	6	in	in	IN
18637	9492	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9492	8	system	system	NN
18637	9492	9	of	of	IN
18637	9492	10	complex	complex	JJ
18637	9492	11	national	national	JJ
18637	9492	12	polity	polity	NN
18637	9492	13	.	.	.
18637	9492	14	"	"	''
18637	9493	1	100	100	CD
18637	9493	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9493	3	at	at	IN
18637	9493	4	489	489	CD
18637	9493	5	-	-	SYM
18637	9493	6	490	490	CD
18637	9493	7	.	.	.
18637	9494	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9494	2	159	159	CD
18637	9494	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9494	4	100	100	CD
18637	9494	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9494	6	483	483	CD
18637	9494	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9494	8	1880	1880	CD
18637	9494	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9494	10	.	.	.
18637	9495	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9495	2	160	160	CD
18637	9495	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9495	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9495	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9495	6	also	also	RB
18637	9495	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9495	8	De	De	NNP
18637	9495	9	Geofroy	Geofroy	NNP
18637	9495	10	_	_	NNP
18637	9495	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	9495	12	_	_	NNP
18637	9495	13	Riggs	Riggs	NNP
18637	9495	14	,	,	,
18637	9495	15	133	133	CD
18637	9495	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9495	17	258	258	CD
18637	9495	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9495	19	1890	1890	CD
18637	9495	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9495	21	;	;	:
18637	9495	22	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
18637	9495	23	_	_	NNP
18637	9495	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	9495	25	_	_	NNP
18637	9495	26	Kidd	Kidd	NNP
18637	9495	27	,	,	,
18637	9495	28	254	254	CD
18637	9495	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9495	30	433	433	CD
18637	9495	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9495	32	1921	1921	CD
18637	9495	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9495	34	;	;	:
18637	9495	35	Nielsen	Nielsen	NNP
18637	9495	36	_	_	NNP
18637	9495	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	9495	38	_	_	NNP
18637	9495	39	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	9495	40	,	,	,
18637	9495	41	279	279	CD
18637	9495	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9495	43	47	47	CD
18637	9495	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9495	45	1929	1929	CD
18637	9495	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9495	47	.	.	.
18637	9496	1	But	but	CC
18637	9496	2	a	a	DT
18637	9496	3	right	right	NN
18637	9496	4	under	under	IN
18637	9496	5	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9496	6	to	to	TO
18637	9496	7	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	9496	8	and	and	CC
18637	9496	9	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	9496	10	of	of	IN
18637	9496	11	property	property	NN
18637	9496	12	does	do	VBZ
18637	9496	13	not	not	RB
18637	9496	14	except	except	IN
18637	9496	15	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	9496	16	from	from	IN
18637	9496	17	the	the	DT
18637	9496	18	operation	operation	NN
18637	9496	19	of	of	IN
18637	9496	20	a	a	DT
18637	9496	21	State	State	NNP
18637	9496	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	9496	23	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	9496	24	conveyances	conveyance	NNS
18637	9496	25	of	of	IN
18637	9496	26	homestead	homestead	NN
18637	9496	27	property	property	NN
18637	9496	28	by	by	IN
18637	9496	29	any	any	DT
18637	9496	30	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	9496	31	not	not	RB
18637	9496	32	executed	execute	VBN
18637	9496	33	by	by	IN
18637	9496	34	both	both	CC
18637	9496	35	husband	husband	NN
18637	9496	36	and	and	CC
18637	9496	37	wife	wife	NN
18637	9496	38	.	.	.
18637	9497	1	Todok	Todok	NNP
18637	9497	2	_	_	NNP
18637	9497	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	9497	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9497	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	9497	6	State	State	NNP
18637	9497	7	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	9497	8	,	,	,
18637	9497	9	281	281	CD
18637	9497	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9497	11	449	449	CD
18637	9497	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9497	13	1930	1930	CD
18637	9497	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9497	15	.	.	.
18637	9498	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	9498	2	was	be	VBD
18637	9498	3	a	a	DT
18637	9498	4	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9498	5	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	9498	6	guaranteeing	guarantee	VBG
18637	9498	7	to	to	IN
18637	9498	8	the	the	DT
18637	9498	9	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	9498	10	of	of	IN
18637	9498	11	each	each	DT
18637	9498	12	country	country	NN
18637	9498	13	,	,	,
18637	9498	14	in	in	IN
18637	9498	15	the	the	DT
18637	9498	16	territory	territory	NN
18637	9498	17	of	of	IN
18637	9498	18	the	the	DT
18637	9498	19	other	other	JJ
18637	9498	20	,	,	,
18637	9498	21	equality	equality	NN
18637	9498	22	with	with	IN
18637	9498	23	the	the	DT
18637	9498	24	natives	native	NNS
18637	9498	25	of	of	IN
18637	9498	26	rights	right	NNS
18637	9498	27	and	and	CC
18637	9498	28	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	9498	29	in	in	IN
18637	9498	30	respect	respect	NN
18637	9498	31	to	to	IN
18637	9498	32	protection	protection	NN
18637	9498	33	and	and	CC
18637	9498	34	security	security	NN
18637	9498	35	of	of	IN
18637	9498	36	person	person	NN
18637	9498	37	and	and	CC
18637	9498	38	property	property	NN
18637	9498	39	,	,	,
18637	9498	40	violated	violate	VBN
18637	9498	41	by	by	IN
18637	9498	42	a	a	DT
18637	9498	43	State	State	NNP
18637	9498	44	statute	statute	NN
18637	9498	45	which	which	WDT
18637	9498	46	denied	deny	VBD
18637	9498	47	to	to	IN
18637	9498	48	a	a	DT
18637	9498	49	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	9498	50	alien	alien	JJ
18637	9498	51	_	_	NNP
18637	9498	52	wife	wife	NN
18637	9498	53	_	_	NNP
18637	9498	54	of	of	IN
18637	9498	55	a	a	DT
18637	9498	56	person	person	NN
18637	9498	57	killed	kill	VBN
18637	9498	58	within	within	IN
18637	9498	59	the	the	DT
18637	9498	60	State	State	NNP
18637	9498	61	,	,	,
18637	9498	62	the	the	DT
18637	9498	63	right	right	NN
18637	9498	64	to	to	TO
18637	9498	65	sue	sue	VB
18637	9498	66	for	for	IN
18637	9498	67	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
18637	9498	68	death	death	NN
18637	9498	69	,	,	,
18637	9498	70	although	although	IN
18637	9498	71	such	such	JJ
18637	9498	72	right	right	NN
18637	9498	73	was	be	VBD
18637	9498	74	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	9498	75	to	to	IN
18637	9498	76	native	native	JJ
18637	9498	77	resident	resident	NN
18637	9498	78	_	_	NNP
18637	9498	79	relatives	relative	NNS
18637	9498	80	_	_	NNP
18637	9498	81	.	.	.
18637	9499	1	Maiorano	Maiorano	NNP
18637	9499	2	_	_	NNP
18637	9499	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	9499	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9499	5	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	9499	6	&	&	CC
18637	9499	7	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	9500	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	9500	2	,	,	,
18637	9500	3	213	213	CD
18637	9500	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9500	5	268	268	CD
18637	9500	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9500	7	1909	1909	CD
18637	9500	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9500	9	.	.	.
18637	9501	1	The	the	DT
18637	9501	2	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9501	3	in	in	IN
18637	9501	4	question	question	NN
18637	9501	5	having	have	VBG
18637	9501	6	been	be	VBN
18637	9501	7	amended	amend	VBN
18637	9501	8	in	in	IN
18637	9501	9	view	view	NN
18637	9501	10	of	of	IN
18637	9501	11	this	this	DT
18637	9501	12	decision	decision	NN
18637	9501	13	,	,	,
18637	9501	14	the	the	DT
18637	9501	15	question	question	NN
18637	9501	16	arose	arise	VBD
18637	9501	17	whether	whether	IN
18637	9501	18	the	the	DT
18637	9501	19	new	new	JJ
18637	9501	20	provision	provision	NN
18637	9501	21	covered	cover	VBD
18637	9501	22	the	the	DT
18637	9501	23	case	case	NN
18637	9501	24	of	of	IN
18637	9501	25	death	death	NN
18637	9501	26	without	without	IN
18637	9501	27	fault	fault	NN
18637	9501	28	or	or	CC
18637	9501	29	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	9501	30	in	in	IN
18637	9501	31	which	which	WDT
18637	9501	32	,	,	,
18637	9501	33	by	by	IN
18637	9501	34	the	the	DT
18637	9501	35	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	9501	36	Workmen	Workmen	NNP
18637	9501	37	's	's	POS
18637	9501	38	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	9501	39	Act	Act	NNP
18637	9501	40	,	,	,
18637	9501	41	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	9501	42	was	be	VBD
18637	9501	43	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	9501	44	limited	limit	VBN
18637	9501	45	to	to	IN
18637	9501	46	resident	resident	JJ
18637	9501	47	parents	parent	NNS
18637	9501	48	;	;	:
18637	9501	49	the	the	DT
18637	9501	50	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	9501	51	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9501	52	held	hold	VBD
18637	9501	53	that	that	IN
18637	9501	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9501	55	did	do	VBD
18637	9501	56	not	not	RB
18637	9501	57	.	.	.
18637	9502	1	Liberato	Liberato	NNP
18637	9502	2	_	_	NNP
18637	9502	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	9502	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9502	5	Royer	Royer	NNP
18637	9502	6	,	,	,
18637	9502	7	270	270	CD
18637	9502	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9502	9	535	535	CD
18637	9502	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9502	11	1926	1926	CD
18637	9502	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9502	13	.	.	.
18637	9503	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9503	2	161	161	CD
18637	9503	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9503	4	Terrace	Terrace	NNP
18637	9503	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9503	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9503	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9503	8	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	9503	9	,	,	,
18637	9503	10	263	263	CD
18637	9503	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9503	12	197	197	CD
18637	9503	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9503	14	1923	1923	CD
18637	9503	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9503	16	.	.	.
18637	9504	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9504	2	162	162	CD
18637	9504	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9504	4	332	332	CD
18637	9504	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9504	6	633	633	CD
18637	9504	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9504	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	9504	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9504	10	.	.	.
18637	9505	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9505	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9505	3	also	also	RB
18637	9505	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9505	5	Takahashi	Takahashi	NNP
18637	9505	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9505	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9505	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9505	9	Fish	Fish	NNP
18637	9505	10	and	and	CC
18637	9505	11	Game	Game	NNP
18637	9505	12	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	9505	13	.	.	NNP
18637	9505	14	,	,	,
18637	9505	15	334	334	CD
18637	9505	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9505	17	410	410	CD
18637	9505	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9505	19	1948	1948	CD
18637	9505	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9505	21	,	,	,
18637	9505	22	in	in	IN
18637	9505	23	which	which	WDT
18637	9505	24	a	a	DT
18637	9505	25	California	California	NNP
18637	9505	26	statute	statute	NN
18637	9505	27	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	9505	28	the	the	DT
18637	9505	29	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	9505	30	of	of	IN
18637	9505	31	fishing	fishing	NN
18637	9505	32	licenses	license	NNS
18637	9505	33	to	to	IN
18637	9505	34	persons	person	NNS
18637	9505	35	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	9505	36	to	to	TO
18637	9505	37	citizenship	citizenship	VB
18637	9505	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	9505	39	disallowed	disallow	VBN
18637	9505	40	,	,	,
18637	9505	41	both	both	DT
18637	9505	42	on	on	IN
18637	9505	43	the	the	DT
18637	9505	44	basis	basis	NN
18637	9505	45	of	of	IN
18637	9505	46	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	9505	47	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	9505	48	and	and	CC
18637	9505	49	on	on	IN
18637	9505	50	the	the	DT
18637	9505	51	ground	ground	NN
18637	9505	52	that	that	IN
18637	9505	53	the	the	DT
18637	9505	54	statute	statute	NN
18637	9505	55	invaded	invade	VBD
18637	9505	56	a	a	DT
18637	9505	57	field	field	NN
18637	9505	58	of	of	IN
18637	9505	59	power	power	NN
18637	9505	60	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	9505	61	to	to	IN
18637	9505	62	the	the	DT
18637	9505	63	National	National	NNP
18637	9505	64	Government	Government	NNP
18637	9505	65	,	,	,
18637	9505	66	namely	namely	RB
18637	9505	67	,	,	,
18637	9505	68	the	the	DT
18637	9505	69	determination	determination	NN
18637	9505	70	of	of	IN
18637	9505	71	the	the	DT
18637	9505	72	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	9505	73	on	on	IN
18637	9505	74	which	which	WDT
18637	9505	75	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	9505	76	may	may	MD
18637	9505	77	be	be	VB
18637	9505	78	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	9505	79	,	,	,
18637	9505	80	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	9505	81	,	,	,
18637	9505	82	and	and	CC
18637	9505	83	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	9505	84	to	to	TO
18637	9505	85	reside	reside	VB
18637	9505	86	in	in	IN
18637	9505	87	the	the	DT
18637	9505	88	United	United	NNP
18637	9505	89	States	States	NNP
18637	9505	90	.	.	.
18637	9506	1	For	for	IN
18637	9506	2	the	the	DT
18637	9506	3	latter	latter	JJ
18637	9506	4	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	9506	5	Hines	Hines	NNP
18637	9506	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9506	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9506	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9506	9	Davidowitz	Davidowitz	NNP
18637	9506	10	,	,	,
18637	9506	11	312	312	CD
18637	9506	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9506	13	52	52	CD
18637	9506	14	,	,	,
18637	9506	15	66	66	CD
18637	9506	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9506	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	9506	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9506	19	was	be	VBD
18637	9506	20	relied	rely	VBN
18637	9506	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	9506	22	.	.	.
18637	9507	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9507	2	163	163	CD
18637	9507	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9507	4	This	this	DT
18637	9507	5	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	9507	6	in	in	IN
18637	9507	7	the	the	DT
18637	9507	8	much	much	RB
18637	9507	9	advertised	advertise	VBN
18637	9507	10	case	case	NN
18637	9507	11	of	of	IN
18637	9507	12	Sei	Sei	NNP
18637	9507	13	Fujii	Fujii	NNP
18637	9507	14	_	_	NNP
18637	9507	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	9507	16	_	_	NNP
18637	9507	17	State	State	NNP
18637	9507	18	of	of	IN
18637	9507	19	California	California	NNP
18637	9507	20	,	,	,
18637	9507	21	242	242	CD
18637	9507	22	P.	P.	NNP
18637	9507	23	2d	2d	CD
18637	9507	24	,	,	,
18637	9507	25	617	617	CD
18637	9507	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9507	27	1952	1952	CD
18637	9507	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9507	29	.	.	.
18637	9508	1	A	a	DT
18637	9508	2	lower	low	JJR
18637	9508	3	California	California	NNP
18637	9508	4	court	court	NN
18637	9508	5	had	have	VBD
18637	9508	6	held	hold	VBN
18637	9508	7	that	that	IN
18637	9508	8	the	the	DT
18637	9508	9	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	9508	10	involved	involve	VBN
18637	9508	11	was	be	VBD
18637	9508	12	void	void	JJ
18637	9508	13	under	under	IN
18637	9508	14	the	the	DT
18637	9508	15	United	United	NNP
18637	9508	16	Nations	Nations	NNPS
18637	9508	17	Charter	Charter	NNP
18637	9508	18	,	,	,
18637	9508	19	but	but	CC
18637	9508	20	the	the	DT
18637	9508	21	California	California	NNP
18637	9508	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	9508	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9508	24	was	be	VBD
18637	9508	25	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	9508	26	in	in	IN
18637	9508	27	rejecting	reject	VBG
18637	9508	28	this	this	DT
18637	9508	29	view	view	NN
18637	9508	30	.	.	.
18637	9509	1	The	the	DT
18637	9509	2	Charter	Charter	NNP
18637	9509	3	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	9509	4	invoked	invoke	VBD
18637	9509	5	in	in	IN
18637	9509	6	this	this	DT
18637	9509	7	connection	connection	NN
18637	9509	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9509	9	Arts	art	NNS
18637	9509	10	.	.	.
18637	9510	1	1	1	CD
18637	9510	2	,	,	,
18637	9510	3	55	55	CD
18637	9510	4	,	,	,
18637	9510	5	and	and	CC
18637	9510	6	56	56	CD
18637	9510	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9510	8	,	,	,
18637	9510	9	said	say	VBD
18637	9510	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	9510	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9510	12	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	9510	13	,	,	,
18637	9510	14	"	"	``
18637	9510	15	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9510	16	are	be	VBP
18637	9510	17	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	9510	18	*	*	NFP
18637	9510	19	*	*	NFP
18637	9510	20	*	*	NFP
18637	9510	21	were	be	VBD
18637	9510	22	not	not	RB
18637	9510	23	intended	intend	VBN
18637	9510	24	to	to	TO
18637	9510	25	supersede	supersede	VB
18637	9510	26	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	9510	27	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	9510	28	"	"	''
18637	9510	29	.	.	.
18637	9511	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9511	2	164	164	CD
18637	9511	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9511	4	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	9511	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9511	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9511	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9511	8	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	9511	9	,	,	,
18637	9511	10	331	331	CD
18637	9511	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9511	12	503	503	CD
18637	9511	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9511	14	1947	1947	CD
18637	9511	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9511	16	.	.	.
18637	9512	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9512	2	165	165	CD
18637	9512	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9512	4	1	1	CD
18637	9512	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	9512	6	.	.	.
18637	9513	1	103	103	CD
18637	9513	2	,	,	,
18637	9513	3	109	109	CD
18637	9513	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9513	5	1801	1801	CD
18637	9513	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9513	7	.	.	.
18637	9514	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9514	2	166	166	CD
18637	9514	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9514	4	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	9514	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9514	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9514	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9514	8	Neilson	Neilson	NNP
18637	9514	9	,	,	,
18637	9514	10	2	2	CD
18637	9514	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	9514	12	.	.	.
18637	9515	1	253	253	CD
18637	9515	2	,	,	,
18637	9515	3	314	314	CD
18637	9515	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9515	5	1829	1829	CD
18637	9515	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9515	7	;	;	:
18637	9515	8	Strother	Strother	NNP
18637	9515	9	_	_	NNP
18637	9515	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	9515	11	_	_	NNP
18637	9515	12	Lucas	Lucas	NNP
18637	9515	13	,	,	,
18637	9515	14	12	12	CD
18637	9515	15	Pet	pet	NN
18637	9515	16	.	.	.
18637	9516	1	410	410	CD
18637	9516	2	,	,	,
18637	9516	3	439	439	CD
18637	9516	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9516	5	1838	1838	CD
18637	9516	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9516	7	;	;	:
18637	9516	8	Edye	Edye	NNP
18637	9516	9	_	_	NNP
18637	9516	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	9516	11	_	_	NNP
18637	9516	12	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	9516	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9516	14	Head	Head	NNP
18637	9516	15	Money	Money	NNP
18637	9516	16	Cases	case	NNS
18637	9516	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9516	18	,	,	,
18637	9516	19	112	112	CD
18637	9516	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9516	21	580	580	CD
18637	9516	22	,	,	,
18637	9516	23	598	598	CD
18637	9516	24	,	,	,
18637	9516	25	599	599	CD
18637	9516	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9516	27	1884	1884	CD
18637	9516	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9516	29	;	;	:
18637	9516	30	United	United	NNP
18637	9516	31	States	States	NNP
18637	9516	32	_	_	NNP
18637	9516	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	9516	34	_	_	NNP
18637	9516	35	Rauscher	Rauscher	NNP
18637	9516	36	,	,	,
18637	9516	37	119	119	CD
18637	9516	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9516	39	407	407	CD
18637	9516	40	,	,	,
18637	9516	41	419	419	CD
18637	9516	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9516	43	1886	1886	CD
18637	9516	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9516	45	;	;	:
18637	9516	46	Bacardi	Bacardi	NNP
18637	9516	47	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	9516	48	_	_	NNP
18637	9516	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	9516	50	_	_	NNP
18637	9516	51	Domenech	Domenech	NNP
18637	9516	52	,	,	,
18637	9516	53	311	311	CD
18637	9516	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9516	55	150	150	CD
18637	9516	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9516	57	1940	1940	CD
18637	9516	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9516	59	.	.	.
18637	9517	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9517	2	167	167	CD
18637	9517	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9517	4	The	the	DT
18637	9517	5	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	9517	6	of	of	IN
18637	9517	7	political	political	JJ
18637	9517	8	questions	question	NNS
18637	9517	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	9517	10	not	not	RB
18637	9517	11	always	always	RB
18637	9517	12	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	9517	13	adhered	adhere	VBN
18637	9517	14	to	to	IN
18637	9517	15	in	in	IN
18637	9517	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	9517	17	of	of	IN
18637	9517	18	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9517	19	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	9517	20	.	.	.
18637	9518	1	In	in	IN
18637	9518	2	the	the	DT
18637	9518	3	case	case	NN
18637	9518	4	of	of	IN
18637	9518	5	the	the	DT
18637	9518	6	"	"	``
18637	9518	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9518	8	Appam	Appam	NNP
18637	9518	9	_	_	NNP
18637	9518	10	"	"	``
18637	9518	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9518	12	was	be	VBD
18637	9518	13	conspicuously	conspicuously	RB
18637	9518	14	departed	depart	VBN
18637	9518	15	from	from	IN
18637	9518	16	.	.	.
18637	9519	1	This	this	DT
18637	9519	2	was	be	VBD
18637	9519	3	a	a	DT
18637	9519	4	British	british	JJ
18637	9519	5	merchant	merchant	NN
18637	9519	6	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	9519	7	which	which	WDT
18637	9519	8	was	be	VBD
18637	9519	9	captured	capture	VBN
18637	9519	10	by	by	IN
18637	9519	11	a	a	DT
18637	9519	12	German	german	JJ
18637	9519	13	cruiser	cruiser	NN
18637	9519	14	early	early	RB
18637	9519	15	in	in	IN
18637	9519	16	1916	1916	CD
18637	9519	17	and	and	CC
18637	9519	18	brought	bring	VBN
18637	9519	19	by	by	RP
18637	9519	20	a	a	DT
18637	9519	21	German	german	JJ
18637	9519	22	crew	crew	NN
18637	9519	23	into	into	IN
18637	9519	24	Newport	Newport	NNP
18637	9519	25	News	News	NNP
18637	9519	26	,	,	,
18637	9519	27	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	9519	28	.	.	.
18637	9520	1	The	the	DT
18637	9520	2	German	German	NNP
18637	9520	3	Imperial	Imperial	NNP
18637	9520	4	Government	Government	NNP
18637	9520	5	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	9520	6	that	that	IN
18637	9520	7	under	under	IN
18637	9520	8	the	the	DT
18637	9520	9	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	9520	10	of	of	IN
18637	9520	11	1799	1799	CD
18637	9520	12	and	and	CC
18637	9520	13	1828	1828	CD
18637	9520	14	between	between	IN
18637	9520	15	the	the	DT
18637	9520	16	United	United	NNP
18637	9520	17	States	States	NNP
18637	9520	18	and	and	CC
18637	9520	19	Prussia	Prussia	NNP
18637	9520	20	,	,	,
18637	9520	21	the	the	DT
18637	9520	22	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	9520	23	was	be	VBD
18637	9520	24	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	9520	25	to	to	TO
18637	9520	26	remain	remain	VB
18637	9520	27	in	in	IN
18637	9520	28	American	american	JJ
18637	9520	29	waters	water	NNS
18637	9520	30	indefinitely	indefinitely	RB
18637	9520	31	.	.	.
18637	9521	1	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	9521	2	of	of	IN
18637	9521	3	State	State	NNP
18637	9521	4	Lansing	Lansing	NNP
18637	9521	5	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	9521	6	against	against	IN
18637	9521	7	the	the	DT
18637	9521	8	claim	claim	NN
18637	9521	9	,	,	,
18637	9521	10	and	and	CC
18637	9521	11	the	the	DT
18637	9521	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	9521	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9521	14	later	later	RB
18637	9521	15	did	do	VBD
18637	9521	16	the	the	DT
18637	9521	17	same	same	JJ
18637	9521	18	,	,	,
18637	9521	19	but	but	CC
18637	9521	20	ostensibly	ostensibly	RB
18637	9521	21	on	on	IN
18637	9521	22	independent	independent	JJ
18637	9521	23	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	9521	24	and	and	CC
18637	9521	25	without	without	IN
18637	9521	26	reference	reference	NN
18637	9521	27	to	to	IN
18637	9521	28	the	the	DT
18637	9521	29	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	9521	30	of	of	IN
18637	9521	31	the	the	DT
18637	9521	32	Department	Department	NNP
18637	9521	33	of	of	IN
18637	9521	34	State	State	NNP
18637	9521	35	.	.	.
18637	9522	1	The	the	DT
18637	9522	2	Steamship	Steamship	NNP
18637	9522	3	Appam	Appam	NNP
18637	9522	4	,	,	,
18637	9522	5	243	243	CD
18637	9522	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9522	7	124	124	CD
18637	9522	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9522	9	1917	1917	CD
18637	9522	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9522	11	.	.	.
18637	9523	1	Although	although	IN
18637	9523	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9523	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	9523	4	a	a	DT
18637	9523	5	principle	principle	NN
18637	9523	6	of	of	IN
18637	9523	7	International	International	NNP
18637	9523	8	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9523	9	that	that	IN
18637	9523	10	,	,	,
18637	9523	11	as	as	IN
18637	9523	12	respects	respect	VBZ
18637	9523	13	the	the	DT
18637	9523	14	rights	right	NNS
18637	9523	15	of	of	IN
18637	9523	16	the	the	DT
18637	9523	17	signatory	signatory	JJ
18637	9523	18	parties	party	NNS
18637	9523	19	,	,	,
18637	9523	20	a	a	DT
18637	9523	21	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9523	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	9523	23	binding	bind	VBG
18637	9523	24	from	from	IN
18637	9523	25	the	the	DT
18637	9523	26	date	date	NN
18637	9523	27	of	of	IN
18637	9523	28	signature	signature	NN
18637	9523	29	,	,	,
18637	9523	30	a	a	DT
18637	9523	31	different	different	JJ
18637	9523	32	rule	rule	NN
18637	9523	33	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	9523	34	in	in	IN
18637	9523	35	this	this	DT
18637	9523	36	country	country	NN
18637	9523	37	as	as	IN
18637	9523	38	to	to	IN
18637	9523	39	a	a	DT
18637	9523	40	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9523	41	as	as	IN
18637	9523	42	"	"	``
18637	9523	43	law	law	NN
18637	9523	44	of	of	IN
18637	9523	45	the	the	DT
18637	9523	46	land	land	NN
18637	9523	47	"	"	''
18637	9523	48	and	and	CC
18637	9523	49	as	as	IN
18637	9523	50	such	such	PDT
18637	9523	51	a	a	DT
18637	9523	52	source	source	NN
18637	9523	53	of	of	IN
18637	9523	54	human	human	JJ
18637	9523	55	rights	right	NNS
18637	9523	56	.	.	.
18637	9524	1	Before	before	IN
18637	9524	2	a	a	DT
18637	9524	3	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9524	4	can	can	MD
18637	9524	5	thus	thus	RB
18637	9524	6	operate	operate	VB
18637	9524	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9524	8	must	must	MD
18637	9524	9	have	have	VB
18637	9524	10	been	be	VBN
18637	9524	11	approved	approve	VBN
18637	9524	12	by	by	IN
18637	9524	13	the	the	DT
18637	9524	14	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9524	15	.	.	.
18637	9525	1	Haver	Haver	NNP
18637	9525	2	_	_	NNP
18637	9525	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	9525	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9525	5	Yaker	Yaker	NNP
18637	9525	6	,	,	,
18637	9525	7	9	9	CD
18637	9525	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9525	9	.	.	.
18637	9526	1	32	32	CD
18637	9526	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9526	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	9526	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9526	5	.	.	.
18637	9527	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9527	2	168	168	CD
18637	9527	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9527	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9527	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9527	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9527	7	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	9527	8	,	,	,
18637	9527	9	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	9527	10	,	,	,
18637	9527	11	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9527	12	Making	making	NN
18637	9527	13	and	and	CC
18637	9527	14	Enforcement	Enforcement	NNP
18637	9527	15	,	,	,
18637	9527	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9527	17	2d	2d	NNP
18637	9527	18	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9527	19	.	.	.
18637	9528	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9528	2	,	,	,
18637	9528	3	165	165	CD
18637	9528	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9528	5	171	171	CD
18637	9528	6	,	,	,
18637	9528	7	with	with	IN
18637	9528	8	citations	citation	NNS
18637	9528	9	.	.	.
18637	9529	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9529	2	169	169	CD
18637	9529	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9529	4	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	9529	5	Writings	Writings	NNP
18637	9529	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9529	7	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
18637	9529	8	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9529	9	.	.	.
18637	9530	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9530	2	,	,	,
18637	9530	3	264	264	CD
18637	9530	4	.	.	.
18637	9531	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9531	2	170	170	CD
18637	9531	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9531	4	"	"	``
18637	9531	5	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9531	6	express	express	VBP
18637	9531	7	no	no	DT
18637	9531	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9531	9	as	as	IN
18637	9531	10	to	to	IN
18637	9531	11	whether	whether	IN
18637	9531	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9531	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	9531	14	bound	bind	VBN
18637	9531	15	to	to	TO
18637	9531	16	appropriate	appropriate	VB
18637	9531	17	the	the	DT
18637	9531	18	money	money	NN
18637	9531	19	*	*	NFP
18637	9531	20	*	*	NFP
18637	9531	21	*	*	NFP
18637	9531	22	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9531	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	9531	24	not	not	RB
18637	9531	25	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	9531	26	to	to	TO
18637	9531	27	consider	consider	VB
18637	9531	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9531	29	in	in	IN
18637	9531	30	this	this	DT
18637	9531	31	case	case	NN
18637	9531	32	,	,	,
18637	9531	33	as	as	IN
18637	9531	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9531	35	made	make	VBD
18637	9531	36	prompt	prompt	JJ
18637	9531	37	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	9531	38	of	of	IN
18637	9531	39	the	the	DT
18637	9531	40	money	money	NN
18637	9531	41	stipulated	stipulate	VBN
18637	9531	42	in	in	IN
18637	9531	43	the	the	DT
18637	9531	44	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9531	45	"	"	''
18637	9531	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9531	47	the	the	DT
18637	9531	48	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	9531	49	of	of	IN
18637	9531	50	Paris	Paris	NNP
18637	9531	51	of	of	IN
18637	9531	52	1899	1899	CD
18637	9531	53	between	between	IN
18637	9531	54	Spain	Spain	NNP
18637	9531	55	and	and	CC
18637	9531	56	the	the	DT
18637	9531	57	United	United	NNP
18637	9531	58	States	States	NNP
18637	9531	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9531	60	.	.	.
18637	9532	1	De	De	NNP
18637	9532	2	Lima	Lima	NNP
18637	9532	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9532	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	9532	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9532	6	Bidwell	Bidwell	NNP
18637	9532	7	,	,	,
18637	9532	8	182	182	CD
18637	9532	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9532	10	1	1	CD
18637	9532	11	,	,	,
18637	9532	12	198	198	CD
18637	9532	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9532	14	1901	1901	CD
18637	9532	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9532	16	.	.	.
18637	9533	1	For	for	IN
18637	9533	2	a	a	DT
18637	9533	3	list	list	NN
18637	9533	4	of	of	IN
18637	9533	5	earlier	early	JJR
18637	9533	6	appropriations	appropriation	NNS
18637	9533	7	of	of	IN
18637	9533	8	the	the	DT
18637	9533	9	same	same	JJ
18637	9533	10	kind	kind	NN
18637	9533	11	,	,	,
18637	9533	12	_	_	NNP
18637	9533	13	see	see	VBP
18637	9533	14	_	_	NNP
18637	9533	15	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	9533	16	,	,	,
18637	9533	17	179	179	CD
18637	9533	18	-	-	SYM
18637	9533	19	180	180	CD
18637	9533	20	,	,	,
18637	9533	21	n.	n.	NNP
18637	9533	22	35	35	CD
18637	9533	23	.	.	.
18637	9534	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9534	2	171	171	CD
18637	9534	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9534	4	Willoughby	Willoughby	NNP
18637	9534	5	,	,	,
18637	9534	6	On	on	IN
18637	9534	7	the	the	DT
18637	9534	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9534	9	,	,	,
18637	9534	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9534	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9534	12	2d	2d	NNP
18637	9534	13	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9534	14	.	.	NNP
18637	9534	15	,	,	,
18637	9534	16	New	New	NNP
18637	9534	17	York	York	NNP
18637	9534	18	,	,	,
18637	9534	19	1929	1929	CD
18637	9534	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9534	21	,	,	,
18637	9534	22	558	558	CD
18637	9534	23	.	.	.
18637	9535	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9535	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9535	3	also	also	RB
18637	9535	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9535	5	H.	H.	NNP
18637	9535	6	Rept	Rept	NNP
18637	9535	7	.	.	.
18637	9536	1	2630	2630	CD
18637	9536	2	,	,	,
18637	9536	3	48th	48th	NNP
18637	9536	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	9536	5	.	.	.
18637	9536	6	,	,	,
18637	9536	7	2d	2d	NNP
18637	9536	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	9536	9	.	.	.
18637	9536	10	,	,	,
18637	9536	11	for	for	IN
18637	9536	12	an	an	DT
18637	9536	13	exhaustive	exhaustive	JJ
18637	9536	14	review	review	NN
18637	9536	15	of	of	IN
18637	9536	16	the	the	DT
18637	9536	17	subject	subject	NN
18637	9536	18	.	.	.
18637	9537	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9537	2	172	172	CD
18637	9537	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9537	4	Edye	Edye	NNP
18637	9537	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9537	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9537	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9537	8	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	9537	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9537	10	Head	Head	NNP
18637	9537	11	Money	Money	NNP
18637	9537	12	Cases	case	NNS
18637	9537	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9537	14	,	,	,
18637	9537	15	112	112	CD
18637	9537	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9537	17	580	580	CD
18637	9537	18	,	,	,
18637	9537	19	598	598	CD
18637	9537	20	-	-	SYM
18637	9537	21	599	599	CD
18637	9537	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9537	23	1884	1884	CD
18637	9537	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9537	25	.	.	.
18637	9538	1	The	the	DT
18637	9538	2	repealability	repealability	NN
18637	9538	3	of	of	IN
18637	9538	4	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9538	5	by	by	IN
18637	9538	6	act	act	NN
18637	9538	7	of	of	IN
18637	9538	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9538	9	was	be	VBD
18637	9538	10	first	first	RB
18637	9538	11	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	9538	12	in	in	IN
18637	9538	13	an	an	DT
18637	9538	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9538	15	of	of	IN
18637	9538	16	the	the	DT
18637	9538	17	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	9538	18	General	General	NNP
18637	9538	19	in	in	IN
18637	9538	20	1854	1854	CD
18637	9538	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9538	22	6	6	CD
18637	9538	23	Op	Op	NNP
18637	9538	24	.	.	.
18637	9539	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9539	2	.	.	.
18637	9540	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9540	2	291	291	CD
18637	9540	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9540	4	.	.	.
18637	9541	1	The	the	DT
18637	9541	2	year	year	NN
18637	9541	3	following	follow	VBG
18637	9541	4	the	the	DT
18637	9541	5	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	9541	6	was	be	VBD
18637	9541	7	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	9541	8	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	9541	9	in	in	IN
18637	9541	10	a	a	DT
18637	9541	11	lengthy	lengthy	JJ
18637	9541	12	and	and	CC
18637	9541	13	cogently	cogently	RB
18637	9541	14	argued	argue	VBD
18637	9541	15	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9541	16	of	of	IN
18637	9541	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9541	18	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	9541	19	,	,	,
18637	9541	20	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	9541	21	for	for	IN
18637	9541	22	a	a	DT
18637	9541	23	United	United	NNP
18637	9541	24	States	States	NNP
18637	9541	25	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	9541	26	court	court	NN
18637	9541	27	in	in	IN
18637	9541	28	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	9541	29	_	_	NNP
18637	9541	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	9541	31	_	_	NNP
18637	9541	32	Morton	Morton	NNP
18637	9541	33	,	,	,
18637	9541	34	23	23	CD
18637	9541	35	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	9541	36	.	.	.
18637	9542	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	9542	2	.	.	.
18637	9543	1	No	no	UH
18637	9543	2	.	.	.
18637	9544	1	13,799	13,799	CD
18637	9544	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9544	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	9544	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9544	5	.	.	.
18637	9545	1	The	the	DT
18637	9545	2	case	case	NN
18637	9545	3	turned	turn	VBD
18637	9545	4	on	on	RP
18637	9545	5	the	the	DT
18637	9545	6	following	following	JJ
18637	9545	7	question	question	NN
18637	9545	8	:	:	:
18637	9545	9	"	"	``
18637	9545	10	If	if	IN
18637	9545	11	an	an	DT
18637	9545	12	act	act	NN
18637	9545	13	of	of	IN
18637	9545	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9545	15	should	should	MD
18637	9545	16	levy	levy	VB
18637	9545	17	a	a	DT
18637	9545	18	duty	duty	NN
18637	9545	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	9545	20	imports	import	NNS
18637	9545	21	,	,	,
18637	9545	22	which	which	WDT
18637	9545	23	an	an	DT
18637	9545	24	existing	exist	VBG
18637	9545	25	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	9545	26	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9545	27	declares	declare	NNS
18637	9545	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	9545	29	not	not	RB
18637	9545	30	be	be	VB
18637	9545	31	levied	levy	VBN
18637	9545	32	,	,	,
18637	9545	33	so	so	IN
18637	9545	34	that	that	IN
18637	9545	35	the	the	DT
18637	9545	36	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9545	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	9545	38	in	in	IN
18637	9545	39	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	9545	40	with	with	IN
18637	9545	41	the	the	DT
18637	9545	42	act	act	NN
18637	9545	43	,	,	,
18637	9545	44	does	do	VBZ
18637	9545	45	the	the	DT
18637	9545	46	former	former	JJ
18637	9545	47	or	or	CC
18637	9545	48	the	the	DT
18637	9545	49	latter	latter	JJ
18637	9545	50	give	give	VB
18637	9545	51	the	the	DT
18637	9545	52	rule	rule	NN
18637	9545	53	of	of	IN
18637	9545	54	decision	decision	NN
18637	9545	55	in	in	IN
18637	9545	56	a	a	DT
18637	9545	57	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	9545	58	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	9545	59	of	of	IN
18637	9545	60	the	the	DT
18637	9545	61	United	United	NNP
18637	9545	62	States	States	NNP
18637	9545	63	,	,	,
18637	9545	64	in	in	IN
18637	9545	65	a	a	DT
18637	9545	66	case	case	NN
18637	9545	67	to	to	IN
18637	9545	68	which	which	WDT
18637	9545	69	one	one	CD
18637	9545	70	rule	rule	NN
18637	9545	71	or	or	CC
18637	9545	72	the	the	DT
18637	9545	73	other	other	JJ
18637	9545	74	must	must	MD
18637	9545	75	be	be	VB
18637	9545	76	applied	apply	VBN
18637	9545	77	?	?	.
18637	9545	78	"	"	''
18637	9546	1	Citing	cite	VBG
18637	9546	2	the	the	DT
18637	9546	3	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	9546	4	clause	clause	NN
18637	9546	5	of	of	IN
18637	9546	6	the	the	DT
18637	9546	7	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9546	8	,	,	,
18637	9546	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9546	10	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	9546	11	said	say	VBD
18637	9546	12	:	:	:
18637	9546	13	"	"	``
18637	9546	14	There	there	EX
18637	9546	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	9546	16	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	9546	17	in	in	IN
18637	9546	18	the	the	DT
18637	9546	19	language	language	NN
18637	9546	20	of	of	IN
18637	9546	21	this	this	DT
18637	9546	22	clause	clause	NN
18637	9546	23	which	which	WDT
18637	9546	24	enables	enable	VBZ
18637	9546	25	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9546	26	to	to	TO
18637	9546	27	say	say	VB
18637	9546	28	,	,	,
18637	9546	29	that	that	IN
18637	9546	30	in	in	IN
18637	9546	31	the	the	DT
18637	9546	32	case	case	NN
18637	9546	33	supposed	suppose	VBN
18637	9546	34	,	,	,
18637	9546	35	the	the	DT
18637	9546	36	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9546	37	,	,	,
18637	9546	38	and	and	CC
18637	9546	39	not	not	RB
18637	9546	40	the	the	DT
18637	9546	41	act	act	NN
18637	9546	42	of	of	IN
18637	9546	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9546	44	,	,	,
18637	9546	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	9546	46	to	to	TO
18637	9546	47	afford	afford	VB
18637	9546	48	the	the	DT
18637	9546	49	rule	rule	NN
18637	9546	50	.	.	.
18637	9547	1	Ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	9547	2	,	,	,
18637	9547	3	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9547	4	are	be	VBP
18637	9547	5	not	not	RB
18637	9547	6	rules	rule	NNS
18637	9547	7	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	9547	8	by	by	IN
18637	9547	9	sovereigns	sovereign	NNS
18637	9547	10	for	for	IN
18637	9547	11	the	the	DT
18637	9547	12	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	9547	13	of	of	IN
18637	9547	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9547	15	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	9547	16	,	,	,
18637	9547	17	but	but	CC
18637	9547	18	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	9547	19	,	,	,
18637	9547	20	by	by	IN
18637	9547	21	which	which	WDT
18637	9547	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9547	23	agree	agree	VBP
18637	9547	24	to	to	TO
18637	9547	25	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	9547	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9547	27	own	own	JJ
18637	9547	28	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	9547	29	.	.	.
18637	9548	1	This	this	DT
18637	9548	2	provision	provision	NN
18637	9548	3	of	of	IN
18637	9548	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9548	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9548	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	9548	7	made	make	VBN
18637	9548	8	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9548	9	part	part	NN
18637	9548	10	of	of	IN
18637	9548	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9548	12	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	9548	13	law	law	NN
18637	9548	14	.	.	.
18637	9549	1	But	but	CC
18637	9549	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9549	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	9549	4	not	not	RB
18637	9549	5	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	9549	6	to	to	IN
18637	9549	7	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9549	8	any	any	DT
18637	9549	9	particular	particular	JJ
18637	9549	10	degree	degree	NN
18637	9549	11	of	of	IN
18637	9549	12	authority	authority	NN
18637	9549	13	in	in	IN
18637	9549	14	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9549	15	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	9549	16	law	law	NN
18637	9549	17	,	,	,
18637	9549	18	nor	nor	CC
18637	9549	19	declared	declare	VBD
18637	9549	20	whether	whether	IN
18637	9549	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	9549	22	so	so	RB
18637	9549	23	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	9549	24	shall	shall	MD
18637	9549	25	or	or	CC
18637	9549	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	9549	27	not	not	RB
18637	9549	28	be	be	VB
18637	9549	29	paramount	paramount	JJ
18637	9549	30	to	to	IN
18637	9549	31	laws	law	NNS
18637	9549	32	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	9549	33	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	9549	34	.	.	.
18637	9550	1	*	*	NFP
18637	9550	2	*	*	NFP
18637	9550	3	*	*	NFP
18637	9550	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9550	5	This	this	DT
18637	9550	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9550	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	9550	8	solely	solely	RB
18637	9550	9	a	a	DT
18637	9550	10	question	question	NN
18637	9550	11	of	of	IN
18637	9550	12	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	9550	13	,	,	,
18637	9550	14	as	as	IN
18637	9550	15	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	9550	16	from	from	IN
18637	9550	17	public	public	JJ
18637	9550	18	law	law	NN
18637	9550	19	.	.	.
18637	9551	1	The	the	DT
18637	9551	2	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9551	3	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	9551	4	between	between	IN
18637	9551	5	whom	whom	WP
18637	9551	6	and	and	CC
18637	9551	7	the	the	DT
18637	9551	8	United	United	NNP
18637	9551	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9551	10	a	a	DT
18637	9551	11	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9551	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	9551	13	been	be	VBN
18637	9551	14	made	make	VBN
18637	9551	15	,	,	,
18637	9551	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	9551	17	a	a	DT
18637	9551	18	right	right	NN
18637	9551	19	to	to	TO
18637	9551	20	expect	expect	VB
18637	9551	21	and	and	CC
18637	9551	22	require	require	VB
18637	9551	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9551	24	stipulations	stipulation	NNS
18637	9551	25	to	to	TO
18637	9551	26	be	be	VB
18637	9551	27	kept	keep	VBN
18637	9551	28	with	with	IN
18637	9551	29	scrupulous	scrupulous	JJ
18637	9551	30	good	good	JJ
18637	9551	31	faith	faith	NN
18637	9551	32	;	;	:
18637	9551	33	but	but	CC
18637	9551	34	through	through	IN
18637	9551	35	what	what	WP
18637	9551	36	internal	internal	JJ
18637	9551	37	arrangements	arrangement	NNS
18637	9551	38	this	this	DT
18637	9551	39	shall	shall	MD
18637	9551	40	be	be	VB
18637	9551	41	done	do	VBN
18637	9551	42	,	,	,
18637	9551	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	9551	44	,	,	,
18637	9551	45	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	9551	46	,	,	,
18637	9551	47	for	for	IN
18637	9551	48	the	the	DT
18637	9551	49	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	9551	50	of	of	IN
18637	9551	51	the	the	DT
18637	9551	52	United	United	NNP
18637	9551	53	States	States	NNP
18637	9551	54	.	.	.
18637	9552	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	9552	2	the	the	DT
18637	9552	3	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9552	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	9552	5	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9552	6	be	be	VB
18637	9552	7	the	the	DT
18637	9552	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	9552	9	of	of	IN
18637	9552	10	action	action	NN
18637	9552	11	of	of	IN
18637	9552	12	the	the	DT
18637	9552	13	people	people	NNS
18637	9552	14	as	as	RB
18637	9552	15	well	well	RB
18637	9552	16	as	as	IN
18637	9552	17	the	the	DT
18637	9552	18	government	government	NN
18637	9552	19	,	,	,
18637	9552	20	whether	whether	IN
18637	9552	21	the	the	DT
18637	9552	22	power	power	NN
18637	9552	23	to	to	TO
18637	9552	24	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	9552	25	and	and	CC
18637	9552	26	apply	apply	VB
18637	9552	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9552	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	9552	29	reside	reside	VB
18637	9552	30	in	in	IN
18637	9552	31	one	one	CD
18637	9552	32	department	department	NN
18637	9552	33	,	,	,
18637	9552	34	or	or	CC
18637	9552	35	another	another	DT
18637	9552	36	,	,	,
18637	9552	37	neither	neither	CC
18637	9552	38	the	the	DT
18637	9552	39	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9552	40	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9552	41	,	,	,
18637	9552	42	nor	nor	CC
18637	9552	43	any	any	DT
18637	9552	44	implication	implication	NN
18637	9552	45	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	9552	46	from	from	IN
18637	9552	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9552	48	,	,	,
18637	9552	49	gives	give	VBZ
18637	9552	50	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9552	51	any	any	DT
18637	9552	52	right	right	NN
18637	9552	53	to	to	TO
18637	9552	54	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	9552	55	.	.	.
18637	9553	1	If	if	IN
18637	9553	2	the	the	DT
18637	9553	3	people	people	NNS
18637	9553	4	of	of	IN
18637	9553	5	the	the	DT
18637	9553	6	United	United	NNP
18637	9553	7	States	States	NNP
18637	9553	8	were	be	VBD
18637	9553	9	to	to	TO
18637	9553	10	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	9553	11	so	so	RB
18637	9553	12	much	much	JJ
18637	9553	13	of	of	IN
18637	9553	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9553	15	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	9553	16	as	as	IN
18637	9553	17	makes	make	VBZ
18637	9553	18	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9553	19	part	part	NN
18637	9553	20	of	of	IN
18637	9553	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9553	22	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	9553	23	law	law	NN
18637	9553	24	,	,	,
18637	9553	25	no	no	DT
18637	9553	26	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9553	27	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	9553	28	with	with	IN
18637	9553	29	whom	whom	WP
18637	9553	30	a	a	DT
18637	9553	31	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9553	32	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	9553	33	could	could	MD
18637	9553	34	justly	justly	RB
18637	9553	35	complain	complain	VB
18637	9553	36	,	,	,
18637	9553	37	for	for	IN
18637	9553	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9553	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	9553	40	not	not	RB
18637	9553	41	a	a	DT
18637	9553	42	matter	matter	NN
18637	9553	43	with	with	IN
18637	9553	44	which	which	WDT
18637	9553	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9553	46	has	have	VBZ
18637	9553	47	any	any	DT
18637	9553	48	concern	concern	NN
18637	9553	49	.	.	.
18637	9554	1	*	*	NFP
18637	9554	2	*	*	NFP
18637	9554	3	*	*	NFP
18637	9554	4	By	by	IN
18637	9554	5	the	the	DT
18637	9554	6	eighth	eighth	JJ
18637	9554	7	section	section	NN
18637	9554	8	of	of	IN
18637	9554	9	the	the	DT
18637	9554	10	first	first	JJ
18637	9554	11	article	article	NN
18637	9554	12	of	of	IN
18637	9554	13	the	the	DT
18637	9554	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9554	15	,	,	,
18637	9554	16	power	power	NN
18637	9554	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	9554	18	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	9554	19	on	on	IN
18637	9554	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9554	21	to	to	TO
18637	9554	22	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	9554	23	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	9554	24	with	with	IN
18637	9554	25	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9554	26	nations	nation	NNS
18637	9554	27	,	,	,
18637	9554	28	and	and	CC
18637	9554	29	to	to	TO
18637	9554	30	lay	lay	VB
18637	9554	31	duties	duty	NNS
18637	9554	32	,	,	,
18637	9554	33	and	and	CC
18637	9554	34	to	to	TO
18637	9554	35	make	make	VB
18637	9554	36	all	all	DT
18637	9554	37	laws	law	NNS
18637	9554	38	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	9554	39	and	and	CC
18637	9554	40	proper	proper	JJ
18637	9554	41	for	for	IN
18637	9554	42	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	9554	43	those	those	DT
18637	9554	44	powers	power	NNS
18637	9554	45	into	into	IN
18637	9554	46	execution	execution	NN
18637	9554	47	.	.	.
18637	9555	1	That	that	IN
18637	9555	2	the	the	DT
18637	9555	3	act	act	NN
18637	9555	4	now	now	RB
18637	9555	5	in	in	IN
18637	9555	6	question	question	NN
18637	9555	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	9555	8	within	within	IN
18637	9555	9	the	the	DT
18637	9555	10	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	9555	11	power	power	NN
18637	9555	12	of	of	IN
18637	9555	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9555	14	,	,	,
18637	9555	15	unless	unless	IN
18637	9555	16	that	that	DT
18637	9555	17	power	power	NN
18637	9555	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	9555	19	controlled	control	VBN
18637	9555	20	by	by	IN
18637	9555	21	the	the	DT
18637	9555	22	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9555	23	,	,	,
18637	9555	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	9555	25	not	not	RB
18637	9555	26	doubted	doubt	VBN
18637	9555	27	.	.	.
18637	9556	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9556	2	must	must	MD
18637	9556	3	be	be	VB
18637	9556	4	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	9556	5	,	,	,
18637	9556	6	also	also	RB
18637	9556	7	,	,	,
18637	9556	8	that	that	IN
18637	9556	9	in	in	IN
18637	9556	10	general	general	JJ
18637	9556	11	,	,	,
18637	9556	12	power	power	NN
18637	9556	13	to	to	TO
18637	9556	14	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	9556	15	on	on	IN
18637	9556	16	a	a	DT
18637	9556	17	particular	particular	JJ
18637	9556	18	subject	subject	NN
18637	9556	19	,	,	,
18637	9556	20	includes	include	VBZ
18637	9556	21	power	power	NN
18637	9556	22	to	to	TO
18637	9556	23	modify	modify	VB
18637	9556	24	and	and	CC
18637	9556	25	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	9556	26	existing	exist	VBG
18637	9556	27	laws	law	NNS
18637	9556	28	on	on	IN
18637	9556	29	that	that	DT
18637	9556	30	subject	subject	NN
18637	9556	31	,	,	,
18637	9556	32	and	and	CC
18637	9556	33	either	either	CC
18637	9556	34	substitute	substitute	VB
18637	9556	35	new	new	JJ
18637	9556	36	laws	law	NNS
18637	9556	37	in	in	IN
18637	9556	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9556	39	place	place	NN
18637	9556	40	,	,	,
18637	9556	41	or	or	CC
18637	9556	42	leave	leave	VB
18637	9556	43	the	the	DT
18637	9556	44	subject	subject	NN
18637	9556	45	without	without	IN
18637	9556	46	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	9556	47	,	,	,
18637	9556	48	in	in	IN
18637	9556	49	those	those	DT
18637	9556	50	particulars	particular	NNS
18637	9556	51	to	to	TO
18637	9556	52	which	which	WDT
18637	9556	53	the	the	DT
18637	9556	54	repealed	repealed	JJ
18637	9556	55	laws	law	NNS
18637	9556	56	applied	apply	VBD
18637	9556	57	.	.	.
18637	9557	1	There	there	EX
18637	9557	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	9557	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	9557	4	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	9557	5	in	in	IN
18637	9557	6	the	the	DT
18637	9557	7	mere	mere	JJ
18637	9557	8	fact	fact	NN
18637	9557	9	that	that	IN
18637	9557	10	a	a	DT
18637	9557	11	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9557	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	9557	13	a	a	DT
18637	9557	14	law	law	NN
18637	9557	15	,	,	,
18637	9557	16	which	which	WDT
18637	9557	17	would	would	MD
18637	9557	18	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	9557	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9557	20	from	from	IN
18637	9557	21	repealing	repeal	VBG
18637	9557	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9557	23	.	.	.
18637	9558	1	Unless	unless	IN
18637	9558	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9558	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	9558	4	for	for	IN
18637	9558	5	some	some	DT
18637	9558	6	reason	reason	NN
18637	9558	7	distinguishable	distinguishable	JJ
18637	9558	8	from	from	IN
18637	9558	9	other	other	JJ
18637	9558	10	laws	law	NNS
18637	9558	11	,	,	,
18637	9558	12	the	the	DT
18637	9558	13	rule	rule	NN
18637	9558	14	which	which	WDT
18637	9558	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9558	16	gives	give	VBZ
18637	9558	17	may	may	MD
18637	9558	18	be	be	VB
18637	9558	19	displaced	displace	VBN
18637	9558	20	by	by	IN
18637	9558	21	the	the	DT
18637	9558	22	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	9558	23	power	power	NN
18637	9558	24	,	,	,
18637	9558	25	at	at	IN
18637	9558	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9558	27	pleasure	pleasure	NN
18637	9558	28	.	.	.
18637	9559	1	*	*	NFP
18637	9559	2	*	*	NFP
18637	9559	3	*	*	NFP
18637	9559	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9559	5	think	think	VBP
18637	9559	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9559	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	9559	8	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	9559	9	to	to	TO
18637	9559	10	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	9559	11	that	that	IN
18637	9559	12	,	,	,
18637	9559	13	under	under	IN
18637	9559	14	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9559	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9559	16	,	,	,
18637	9559	17	the	the	DT
18637	9559	18	President	President	NNP
18637	9559	19	and	and	CC
18637	9559	20	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9559	21	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	9559	22	,	,	,
18637	9559	23	possess	possess	VBP
18637	9559	24	the	the	DT
18637	9559	25	power	power	NN
18637	9559	26	to	to	TO
18637	9559	27	modify	modify	VB
18637	9559	28	or	or	CC
18637	9559	29	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	9559	30	a	a	DT
18637	9559	31	law	law	NN
18637	9559	32	found	find	VBN
18637	9559	33	in	in	IN
18637	9559	34	a	a	DT
18637	9559	35	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9559	36	.	.	.
18637	9560	1	If	if	IN
18637	9560	2	this	this	DT
18637	9560	3	were	be	VBD
18637	9560	4	so	so	RB
18637	9560	5	,	,	,
18637	9560	6	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	9560	7	as	as	IN
18637	9560	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9560	9	can	can	MD
18637	9560	10	change	change	VB
18637	9560	11	or	or	CC
18637	9560	12	abrogate	abrogate	VB
18637	9560	13	one	one	CD
18637	9560	14	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9560	15	,	,	,
18637	9560	16	only	only	RB
18637	9560	17	by	by	IN
18637	9560	18	making	make	VBG
18637	9560	19	another	another	DT
18637	9560	20	inconsistent	inconsistent	NN
18637	9560	21	with	with	IN
18637	9560	22	the	the	DT
18637	9560	23	first	first	JJ
18637	9560	24	,	,	,
18637	9560	25	the	the	DT
18637	9560	26	government	government	NN
18637	9560	27	of	of	IN
18637	9560	28	the	the	DT
18637	9560	29	United	United	NNP
18637	9560	30	States	States	NNP
18637	9560	31	could	could	MD
18637	9560	32	not	not	RB
18637	9560	33	act	act	VB
18637	9560	34	at	at	RB
18637	9560	35	all	all	RB
18637	9560	36	,	,	,
18637	9560	37	to	to	IN
18637	9560	38	that	that	DT
18637	9560	39	effect	effect	NN
18637	9560	40	,	,	,
18637	9560	41	without	without	IN
18637	9560	42	the	the	DT
18637	9560	43	consent	consent	NN
18637	9560	44	of	of	IN
18637	9560	45	some	some	DT
18637	9560	46	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9560	47	government	government	NN
18637	9560	48	;	;	:
18637	9560	49	for	for	IN
18637	9560	50	no	no	DT
18637	9560	51	new	new	JJ
18637	9560	52	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9560	53	,	,	,
18637	9560	54	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	9560	55	,	,	,
18637	9560	56	in	in	IN
18637	9560	57	any	any	DT
18637	9560	58	manner	manner	NN
18637	9560	59	,	,	,
18637	9560	60	one	one	NN
18637	9560	61	already	already	RB
18637	9560	62	in	in	IN
18637	9560	63	existence	existence	NN
18637	9560	64	,	,	,
18637	9560	65	can	can	MD
18637	9560	66	be	be	VB
18637	9560	67	made	make	VBN
18637	9560	68	without	without	IN
18637	9560	69	the	the	DT
18637	9560	70	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	9560	71	of	of	IN
18637	9560	72	two	two	CD
18637	9560	73	parties	party	NNS
18637	9560	74	,	,	,
18637	9560	75	one	one	CD
18637	9560	76	of	of	IN
18637	9560	77	whom	whom	WP
18637	9560	78	must	must	MD
18637	9560	79	be	be	VB
18637	9560	80	a	a	DT
18637	9560	81	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9560	82	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	9560	83	.	.	.
18637	9561	1	That	that	IN
18637	9561	2	the	the	DT
18637	9561	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9561	4	was	be	VBD
18637	9561	5	designed	design	VBN
18637	9561	6	to	to	TO
18637	9561	7	place	place	VB
18637	9561	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9561	9	country	country	NN
18637	9561	10	in	in	IN
18637	9561	11	this	this	DT
18637	9561	12	helpless	helpless	JJ
18637	9561	13	condition	condition	NN
18637	9561	14	,	,	,
18637	9561	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	9561	16	a	a	DT
18637	9561	17	supposition	supposition	NN
18637	9561	18	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	9561	19	inadmissible	inadmissible	JJ
18637	9561	20	.	.	.
18637	9562	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9562	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	9562	3	not	not	RB
18637	9562	4	only	only	RB
18637	9562	5	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	9562	6	with	with	IN
18637	9562	7	the	the	DT
18637	9562	8	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	9562	9	of	of	IN
18637	9562	10	a	a	DT
18637	9562	11	nation	nation	NN
18637	9562	12	,	,	,
18637	9562	13	but	but	CC
18637	9562	14	negatived	negative	VBN
18637	9562	15	by	by	IN
18637	9562	16	the	the	DT
18637	9562	17	express	express	JJ
18637	9562	18	words	word	NNS
18637	9562	19	of	of	IN
18637	9562	20	the	the	DT
18637	9562	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9562	22	.	.	.
18637	9563	1	*	*	NFP
18637	9563	2	*	*	NFP
18637	9563	3	*	*	NFP
18637	9563	4	"	"	``
18637	9563	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9563	6	See	See	NNP
18637	9563	7	also	also	RB
18637	9563	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9563	9	The	the	DT
18637	9563	10	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	9563	11	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	9563	12	,	,	,
18637	9563	13	11	11	CD
18637	9563	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9563	15	.	.	.
18637	9564	1	616	616	CD
18637	9564	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9564	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	9564	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9564	5	;	;	:
18637	9564	6	United	United	NNP
18637	9564	7	States	States	NNP
18637	9564	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9564	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	9564	10	_	_	NNP
18637	9564	11	Forty	Forty	NNP
18637	9564	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	9564	13	Three	Three	NNP
18637	9564	14	Gallons	Gallons	NNPS
18637	9564	15	of	of	IN
18637	9564	16	Whiskey	Whiskey	NNP
18637	9564	17	,	,	,
18637	9564	18	108	108	CD
18637	9564	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9564	20	491	491	CD
18637	9564	21	,	,	,
18637	9564	22	496	496	CD
18637	9564	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9564	24	1883	1883	CD
18637	9564	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9564	26	;	;	:
18637	9564	27	Botiller	Botiller	NNP
18637	9564	28	_	_	NNP
18637	9564	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	9564	30	_	_	NNP
18637	9564	31	Dominguez	Dominguez	NNP
18637	9564	32	,	,	,
18637	9564	33	130	130	CD
18637	9564	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9564	35	238	238	CD
18637	9564	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9564	37	1889	1889	CD
18637	9564	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9564	39	;	;	:
18637	9564	40	Chae	Chae	NNP
18637	9564	41	Chan	Chan	NNP
18637	9564	42	Ping	Ping	NNP
18637	9564	43	_	_	NNP
18637	9564	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	9564	45	_	_	NNP
18637	9564	46	United	United	NNP
18637	9564	47	States	States	NNP
18637	9564	48	,	,	,
18637	9564	49	130	130	CD
18637	9564	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9564	51	581	581	CD
18637	9564	52	,	,	,
18637	9564	53	600	600	CD
18637	9564	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9564	55	1889	1889	CD
18637	9564	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9564	57	;	;	:
18637	9564	58	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	9564	59	_	_	NNP
18637	9564	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	9564	61	_	_	NNP
18637	9564	62	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	9564	63	,	,	,
18637	9564	64	124	124	CD
18637	9564	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9564	66	190	190	CD
18637	9564	67	,	,	,
18637	9564	68	194	194	CD
18637	9564	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9564	70	1888	1888	CD
18637	9564	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9564	72	;	;	:
18637	9564	73	Fong	Fong	NNP
18637	9564	74	Yue	Yue	NNP
18637	9564	75	Ting	Ting	NNP
18637	9564	76	_	_	NNP
18637	9564	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	9564	78	_	_	NNP
18637	9564	79	United	United	NNP
18637	9564	80	States	States	NNP
18637	9564	81	,	,	,
18637	9564	82	149	149	CD
18637	9564	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9564	84	688	688	CD
18637	9564	85	,	,	,
18637	9564	86	721	721	CD
18637	9564	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9564	88	1893	1893	CD
18637	9564	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9564	90	;	;	,
18637	9564	91	etc	etc	FW
18637	9564	92	.	.	.
18637	9565	1	"	"	``
18637	9565	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9565	3	by	by	IN
18637	9565	4	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	9565	5	,	,	,
18637	9565	6	and	and	CC
18637	9565	7	so	so	RB
18637	9565	8	far	far	RB
18637	9565	9	as	as	IN
18637	9565	10	the	the	DT
18637	9565	11	people	people	NNS
18637	9565	12	and	and	CC
18637	9565	13	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	9565	14	of	of	IN
18637	9565	15	the	the	DT
18637	9565	16	United	United	NNP
18637	9565	17	States	States	NNP
18637	9565	18	are	be	VBP
18637	9565	19	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	9565	20	,	,	,
18637	9565	21	could	could	MD
18637	9565	22	abrogate	abrogate	VB
18637	9565	23	a	a	DT
18637	9565	24	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9565	25	made	make	VBN
18637	9565	26	between	between	IN
18637	9565	27	this	this	DT
18637	9565	28	country	country	NN
18637	9565	29	and	and	CC
18637	9565	30	another	another	DT
18637	9565	31	country	country	NN
18637	9565	32	which	which	WDT
18637	9565	33	had	have	VBD
18637	9565	34	been	be	VBN
18637	9565	35	negotiated	negotiate	VBN
18637	9565	36	by	by	IN
18637	9565	37	the	the	DT
18637	9565	38	President	President	NNP
18637	9565	39	and	and	CC
18637	9565	40	approved	approve	VBN
18637	9565	41	by	by	IN
18637	9565	42	the	the	DT
18637	9565	43	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9565	44	.	.	.
18637	9565	45	"	"	''
18637	9566	1	La	La	NNP
18637	9566	2	Abra	Abra	NNP
18637	9566	3	Silver	Silver	NNP
18637	9566	4	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	9566	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	9566	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9566	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9566	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9566	9	United	United	NNP
18637	9566	10	States	States	NNP
18637	9566	11	,	,	,
18637	9566	12	175	175	CD
18637	9566	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9566	14	423	423	CD
18637	9566	15	,	,	,
18637	9566	16	460	460	CD
18637	9566	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9566	18	1899	1899	CD
18637	9566	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9566	20	.	.	.
18637	9567	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9567	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	9567	3	.	.	.
18637	9567	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9567	5	Reichert	Reichert	NNP
18637	9567	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9567	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9567	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9567	9	Felps	Felps	NNP
18637	9567	10	,	,	,
18637	9567	11	6	6	CD
18637	9567	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9567	13	.	.	.
18637	9568	1	160	160	CD
18637	9568	2	,	,	,
18637	9568	3	165	165	CD
18637	9568	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9568	5	166	166	CD
18637	9568	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9568	7	1868	1868	CD
18637	9568	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9568	9	,	,	,
18637	9568	10	where	where	WRB
18637	9568	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9568	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	9568	13	stated	state	VBN
18637	9568	14	obiter	obiter	NN
18637	9568	15	that	that	IN
18637	9568	16	"	"	``
18637	9568	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9568	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	9568	19	bound	bind	VBN
18637	9568	20	to	to	TO
18637	9568	21	regard	regard	VB
18637	9568	22	the	the	DT
18637	9568	23	public	public	JJ
18637	9568	24	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9568	25	,	,	,
18637	9568	26	and	and	CC
18637	9568	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9568	28	had	have	VBD
18637	9568	29	no	no	DT
18637	9568	30	power	power	NN
18637	9568	31	*	*	NFP
18637	9568	32	*	*	NFP
18637	9568	33	*	*	NFP
18637	9568	34	to	to	TO
18637	9568	35	nullify	nullify	VB
18637	9568	36	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9568	37	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	9568	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9568	39	titles	title	NNS
18637	9568	40	confirmed	confirm	VBD
18637	9568	41	many	many	JJ
18637	9568	42	years	year	NNS
18637	9568	43	before	before	IN
18637	9568	44	*	*	NFP
18637	9568	45	*	*	NFP
18637	9568	46	*	*	NFP
18637	9568	47	"	"	''
18637	9568	48	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9568	49	173	173	CD
18637	9568	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9568	51	United	United	NNP
18637	9568	52	States	States	NNP
18637	9568	53	_	_	NNP
18637	9568	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	9568	55	_	_	NNP
18637	9568	56	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
18637	9568	57	Peggy	Peggy	NNP
18637	9568	58	,	,	,
18637	9568	59	1	1	CD
18637	9568	60	Cr	cr	NN
18637	9568	61	.	.	.
18637	9569	1	103	103	CD
18637	9569	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9569	3	1801	1801	CD
18637	9569	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9569	5	.	.	.
18637	9570	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9570	2	174	174	CD
18637	9570	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9570	4	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	9570	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9570	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9570	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9570	8	Neilson	Neilson	NNP
18637	9570	9	,	,	,
18637	9570	10	2	2	CD
18637	9570	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	9570	12	.	.	.
18637	9571	1	253	253	CD
18637	9571	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9571	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	9571	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9571	5	.	.	.
18637	9572	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9572	2	175	175	CD
18637	9572	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9572	4	United	United	NNP
18637	9572	5	States	States	NNP
18637	9572	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9572	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9572	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9572	9	Percheman	Percheman	NNP
18637	9572	10	,	,	,
18637	9572	11	7	7	CD
18637	9572	12	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	9572	13	.	.	.
18637	9573	1	51	51	CD
18637	9573	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9573	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	9573	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9573	5	.	.	.
18637	9574	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9574	2	176	176	CD
18637	9574	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9574	4	Willoughby	Willoughby	NNP
18637	9574	5	,	,	,
18637	9574	6	On	on	IN
18637	9574	7	the	the	DT
18637	9574	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9574	9	,	,	,
18637	9574	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9574	11	,	,	,
18637	9574	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9574	13	2d	2d	NNP
18637	9574	14	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9574	15	.	.	.
18637	9575	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9575	2	,	,	,
18637	9575	3	555	555	CD
18637	9575	4	.	.	.
18637	9576	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9576	2	177	177	CD
18637	9576	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9576	4	288	288	CD
18637	9576	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9576	6	102	102	CD
18637	9576	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9576	8	1933	1933	CD
18637	9576	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9576	10	.	.	.
18637	9577	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9577	2	178	178	CD
18637	9577	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9577	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9577	5	.	.	.
18637	9578	1	107	107	CD
18637	9578	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9578	3	122	122	CD
18637	9578	4	.	.	.
18637	9579	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9579	2	179	179	CD
18637	9579	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9579	4	124	124	CD
18637	9579	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9579	6	190	190	CD
18637	9579	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9579	8	1888	1888	CD
18637	9579	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9579	10	.	.	.
18637	9580	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9580	2	180	180	CD
18637	9580	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9580	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9580	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	9580	6	arguable	arguable	JJ
18637	9580	7	that	that	IN
18637	9580	8	the	the	DT
18637	9580	9	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	9580	10	_	_	NNP
18637	9580	11	leget	leget	NN
18637	9580	12	posteriores	posteriore	NNS
18637	9580	13	_	_	NNP
18637	9580	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	9580	15	not	not	RB
18637	9580	16	the	the	DT
18637	9580	17	most	most	RBS
18637	9580	18	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	9580	19	rule	rule	NN
18637	9580	20	for	for	IN
18637	9580	21	determining	determine	VBG
18637	9580	22	conflicts	conflict	NNS
18637	9580	23	between	between	IN
18637	9580	24	"	"	``
18637	9580	25	laws	law	NNS
18637	9580	26	of	of	IN
18637	9580	27	the	the	DT
18637	9580	28	United	United	NNP
18637	9580	29	States	States	NNP
18637	9580	30	*	*	NFP
18637	9580	31	*	*	NFP
18637	9580	32	*	*	NFP
18637	9580	33	made	make	VBN
18637	9580	34	in	in	IN
18637	9580	35	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	9580	36	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	9580	37	"	"	''
18637	9580	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9580	39	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	9581	1	of	of	IN
18637	9581	2	the	the	DT
18637	9581	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9581	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9581	5	and	and	CC
18637	9581	6	"	"	``
18637	9581	7	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9581	8	made	make	VBN
18637	9581	9	*	*	NFP
18637	9581	10	*	*	NFP
18637	9581	11	*	*	NFP
18637	9581	12	under	under	IN
18637	9581	13	the	the	DT
18637	9581	14	authority	authority	NN
18637	9581	15	of	of	IN
18637	9581	16	the	the	DT
18637	9581	17	United	United	NNP
18637	9581	18	States	States	NNP
18637	9581	19	"	"	''
18637	9581	20	.	.	.
18637	9582	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9582	2	may	may	MD
18637	9582	3	be	be	VB
18637	9582	4	that	that	IN
18637	9582	5	the	the	DT
18637	9582	6	former	former	JJ
18637	9582	7	,	,	,
18637	9582	8	being	be	VBG
18637	9582	9	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	9582	10	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	9582	11	after	after	IN
18637	9582	12	"	"	``
18637	9582	13	this	this	DT
18637	9582	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9582	15	"	"	''
18637	9582	16	and	and	CC
18637	9582	17	before	before	IN
18637	9582	18	"	"	``
18637	9582	19	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9582	20	,	,	,
18637	9582	21	"	"	''
18637	9582	22	are	be	VBP
18637	9582	23	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	9582	24	always	always	RB
18637	9582	25	to	to	TO
18637	9582	26	prevail	prevail	VB
18637	9582	27	over	over	IN
18637	9582	28	the	the	DT
18637	9582	29	latter	latter	JJ
18637	9582	30	,	,	,
18637	9582	31	just	just	RB
18637	9582	32	as	as	IN
18637	9582	33	both	both	DT
18637	9582	34	acts	act	NNS
18637	9582	35	of	of	IN
18637	9582	36	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9582	37	and	and	CC
18637	9582	38	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9582	39	yield	yield	VBP
18637	9582	40	to	to	IN
18637	9582	41	the	the	DT
18637	9582	42	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9582	43	.	.	.
18637	9583	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9583	2	181	181	CD
18637	9583	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9583	4	1	1	CD
18637	9583	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9583	6	.	.	.
18637	9584	1	578	578	CD
18637	9584	2	.	.	.
18637	9585	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9585	2	182	182	CD
18637	9585	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9585	4	4	4	CD
18637	9585	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	9585	6	.	.	.
18637	9586	1	37	37	CD
18637	9586	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9586	3	1800	1800	CD
18637	9586	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9586	5	.	.	.
18637	9587	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9587	2	183	183	CD
18637	9587	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9587	4	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	9587	5	,	,	,
18637	9587	6	Treaties	Treaties	NNP
18637	9587	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9587	8	2d	2d	NNP
18637	9587	9	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9587	10	.	.	.
18637	9588	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9588	2	,	,	,
18637	9588	3	458	458	CD
18637	9588	4	;	;	:
18637	9588	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9588	6	See	See	NNP
18637	9588	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9588	8	Messages	Messages	NNPS
18637	9588	9	and	and	CC
18637	9588	10	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	9588	11	of	of	IN
18637	9588	12	the	the	DT
18637	9588	13	Presidents	Presidents	NNPS
18637	9588	14	,	,	,
18637	9588	15	IV	IV	NNP
18637	9588	16	,	,	,
18637	9588	17	2245	2245	CD
18637	9588	18	;	;	:
18637	9588	19	and	and	CC
18637	9588	20	Benton	Benton	NNP
18637	9588	21	,	,	,
18637	9588	22	15	15	CD
18637	9588	23	Abridgment	abridgment	NN
18637	9588	24	of	of	IN
18637	9588	25	the	the	DT
18637	9588	26	Debates	Debates	NNPS
18637	9588	27	of	of	IN
18637	9588	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9588	29	,	,	,
18637	9588	30	478	478	CD
18637	9588	31	.	.	.
18637	9589	1	Mangum	Mangum	NNP
18637	9589	2	of	of	IN
18637	9589	3	North	North	NNP
18637	9589	4	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	9589	5	denied	deny	VBD
18637	9589	6	that	that	IN
18637	9589	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9589	8	could	could	MD
18637	9589	9	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	9589	10	the	the	DT
18637	9589	11	President	President	NNP
18637	9589	12	to	to	TO
18637	9589	13	give	give	VB
18637	9589	14	notice	notice	NN
18637	9589	15	:	:	:
18637	9589	16	"	"	``
18637	9589	17	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9589	18	entertained	entertain	VBD
18637	9589	19	not	not	RB
18637	9589	20	a	a	DT
18637	9589	21	particle	particle	NN
18637	9589	22	of	of	IN
18637	9589	23	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	9589	24	that	that	IN
18637	9589	25	the	the	DT
18637	9589	26	question	question	NN
18637	9589	27	never	never	RB
18637	9589	28	could	could	MD
18637	9589	29	have	have	VB
18637	9589	30	been	be	VBN
18637	9589	31	thrown	throw	VBN
18637	9589	32	upon	upon	IN
18637	9589	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9589	34	unless	unless	IN
18637	9589	35	as	as	IN
18637	9589	36	a	a	DT
18637	9589	37	war	war	NN
18637	9589	38	or	or	CC
18637	9589	39	_	_	NNP
18637	9589	40	quasi	quasi	NNP
18637	9589	41	_	_	NNP
18637	9589	42	war	war	NN
18637	9589	43	measure	measure	NN
18637	9589	44	.	.	.
18637	9590	1	*	*	NFP
18637	9590	2	*	*	NFP
18637	9590	3	*	*	NFP
18637	9590	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9590	5	had	have	VBD
18637	9590	6	no	no	DT
18637	9590	7	power	power	NN
18637	9590	8	of	of	IN
18637	9590	9	making	make	VBG
18637	9590	10	or	or	CC
18637	9590	11	breaking	break	VBG
18637	9590	12	a	a	DT
18637	9590	13	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9590	14	.	.	.
18637	9590	15	"	"	''
18637	9591	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9591	2	owned	own	VBD
18637	9591	3	,	,	,
18637	9591	4	however	however	RB
18637	9591	5	,	,	,
18637	9591	6	that	that	IN
18637	9591	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9591	8	might	may	MD
18637	9591	9	appear	appear	VB
18637	9591	10	singular	singular	JJ
18637	9591	11	in	in	IN
18637	9591	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9591	13	view	view	NN
18637	9591	14	of	of	IN
18637	9591	15	the	the	DT
18637	9591	16	matter	matter	NN
18637	9591	17	.	.	.
18637	9592	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	9592	2	.	.	.
18637	9593	1	472	472	CD
18637	9593	2	.	.	.
18637	9594	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9594	2	184	184	CD
18637	9594	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9594	4	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	9594	5	,	,	,
18637	9594	6	458	458	CD
18637	9594	7	-	-	SYM
18637	9594	8	462	462	CD
18637	9594	9	;	;	:
18637	9594	10	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	9594	11	,	,	,
18637	9594	12	The	the	DT
18637	9594	13	Control	Control	NNP
18637	9594	14	of	of	IN
18637	9594	15	American	American	NNP
18637	9594	16	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	9594	17	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	9594	18	,	,	,
18637	9594	19	258	258	CD
18637	9594	20	.	.	.
18637	9595	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9595	2	185	185	CD
18637	9595	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9595	4	38	38	CD
18637	9595	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9595	6	.	.	.
18637	9596	1	1164	1164	CD
18637	9596	2	.	.	.
18637	9597	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9597	2	186	186	CD
18637	9597	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9597	4	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	9597	5	,	,	,
18637	9597	6	460	460	CD
18637	9597	7	.	.	.
18637	9598	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9598	2	187	187	CD
18637	9598	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9598	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9598	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9598	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9598	7	Jesse	Jesse	NNP
18637	9598	8	S.	S.	NNP
18637	9598	9	Reeves	Reeves	NNP
18637	9598	10	,	,	,
18637	9598	11	The	the	DT
18637	9598	12	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	9598	13	Act	Act	NNP
18637	9598	14	and	and	CC
18637	9598	15	the	the	DT
18637	9598	16	Denunciation	Denunciation	NNP
18637	9598	17	of	of	IN
18637	9598	18	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	9598	19	,	,	,
18637	9598	20	15	15	CD
18637	9598	21	American	American	NNP
18637	9598	22	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	9598	23	of	of	IN
18637	9598	24	International	International	NNP
18637	9598	25	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9598	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9598	27	January	January	NNP
18637	9598	28	,	,	,
18637	9598	29	1921	1921	CD
18637	9598	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9598	31	33	33	CD
18637	9598	32	-	-	SYM
18637	9598	33	38	38	CD
18637	9598	34	.	.	.
18637	9599	1	Among	among	IN
18637	9599	2	other	other	JJ
18637	9599	3	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	9599	4	which	which	WDT
18637	9599	5	call	call	VBP
18637	9599	6	into	into	IN
18637	9599	7	question	question	NN
18637	9599	8	the	the	DT
18637	9599	9	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	9599	10	significance	significance	NN
18637	9599	11	of	of	IN
18637	9599	12	the	the	DT
18637	9599	13	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	9599	14	role	role	NN
18637	9599	15	in	in	IN
18637	9599	16	the	the	DT
18637	9599	17	termination	termination	NN
18637	9599	18	of	of	IN
18637	9599	19	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9599	20	as	as	IN
18637	9599	21	international	international	JJ
18637	9599	22	conventions	convention	NNS
18637	9599	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	9599	24	one	one	CD
18637	9599	25	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	9599	26	by	by	IN
18637	9599	27	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	9599	28	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	9599	29	:	:	:
18637	9599	30	"	"	``
18637	9599	31	In	in	IN
18637	9599	32	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9599	33	administration	administration	NN
18637	9599	34	the	the	DT
18637	9599	35	lower	low	JJR
18637	9599	36	house	house	NN
18637	9599	37	passed	pass	VBD
18637	9599	38	a	a	DT
18637	9599	39	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	9599	40	directing	direct	VBG
18637	9599	41	the	the	DT
18637	9599	42	abrogation	abrogation	NN
18637	9599	43	of	of	IN
18637	9599	44	the	the	DT
18637	9599	45	Russian	Russian	NNP
18637	9599	46	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	9599	47	of	of	IN
18637	9599	48	1832	1832	CD
18637	9599	49	,	,	,
18637	9599	50	couched	couch	VBN
18637	9599	51	in	in	IN
18637	9599	52	terms	term	NNS
18637	9599	53	which	which	WDT
18637	9599	54	would	would	MD
18637	9599	55	have	have	VB
18637	9599	56	been	be	VBN
18637	9599	57	most	most	RBS
18637	9599	58	offensive	offensive	JJ
18637	9599	59	to	to	IN
18637	9599	60	Russia	Russia	NNP
18637	9599	61	,	,	,
18637	9599	62	and	and	CC
18637	9599	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9599	64	did	do	VBD
18637	9599	65	this	this	DT
18637	9599	66	by	by	IN
18637	9599	67	a	a	DT
18637	9599	68	vote	vote	NN
18637	9599	69	so	so	RB
18637	9599	70	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	9599	71	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	9599	72	as	as	IN
18637	9599	73	to	to	TO
18637	9599	74	indicate	indicate	VB
18637	9599	75	that	that	IN
18637	9599	76	in	in	IN
18637	9599	77	the	the	DT
18637	9599	78	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9599	79	,	,	,
18637	9599	80	too	too	RB
18637	9599	81	,	,	,
18637	9599	82	the	the	DT
18637	9599	83	same	same	JJ
18637	9599	84	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	9599	85	would	would	MD
18637	9599	86	pass	pass	VB
18637	9599	87	.	.	.
18637	9600	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9600	2	would	would	MD
18637	9600	3	have	have	VB
18637	9600	4	strained	strain	VBN
18637	9600	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9600	6	relations	relation	NNS
18637	9600	7	with	with	IN
18637	9600	8	Russia	Russia	NNP
18637	9600	9	in	in	IN
18637	9600	10	a	a	DT
18637	9600	11	way	way	NN
18637	9600	12	that	that	WDT
18637	9600	13	seemed	seem	VBD
18637	9600	14	unwise	unwise	JJ
18637	9600	15	.	.	.
18637	9601	1	The	the	DT
18637	9601	2	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9601	3	was	be	VBD
18637	9601	4	an	an	DT
18637	9601	5	old	old	JJ
18637	9601	6	one	one	CD
18637	9601	7	,	,	,
18637	9601	8	and	and	CC
18637	9601	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9601	10	construction	construction	NN
18637	9601	11	had	have	VBD
18637	9601	12	been	be	VBN
18637	9601	13	constantly	constantly	RB
18637	9601	14	the	the	DT
18637	9601	15	subject	subject	NN
18637	9601	16	of	of	IN
18637	9601	17	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	9601	18	between	between	IN
18637	9601	19	the	the	DT
18637	9601	20	two	two	CD
18637	9601	21	countries	country	NNS
18637	9601	22	,	,	,
18637	9601	23	and	and	CC
18637	9601	24	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	9601	25	,	,	,
18637	9601	26	to	to	TO
18637	9601	27	obviate	obviate	VB
18637	9601	28	what	what	WP
18637	9601	29	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9601	30	felt	feel	VBD
18637	9601	31	would	would	MD
18637	9601	32	produce	produce	VB
18637	9601	33	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	9601	34	trouble	trouble	NN
18637	9601	35	in	in	IN
18637	9601	36	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9601	37	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9601	38	relations	relation	NNS
18637	9601	39	,	,	,
18637	9601	40	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9601	41	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	9601	42	to	to	IN
18637	9601	43	the	the	DT
18637	9601	44	Russian	russian	JJ
18637	9601	45	ambassador	ambassador	NN
18637	9601	46	the	the	DT
18637	9601	47	situation	situation	NN
18637	9601	48	,	,	,
18637	9601	49	and	and	CC
18637	9601	50	advised	advise	VBD
18637	9601	51	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9601	52	that	that	IN
18637	9601	53	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9601	54	deemed	deem	VBD
18637	9601	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9601	56	wise	wise	JJ
18637	9601	57	to	to	TO
18637	9601	58	abrogate	abrogate	VB
18637	9601	59	the	the	DT
18637	9601	60	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9601	61	,	,	,
18637	9601	62	which	which	WDT
18637	9601	63	,	,	,
18637	9601	64	as	as	IN
18637	9601	65	President	President	NNP
18637	9601	66	,	,	,
18637	9601	67	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9601	68	had	have	VBD
18637	9601	69	the	the	DT
18637	9601	70	right	right	NN
18637	9601	71	to	to	TO
18637	9601	72	do	do	VB
18637	9601	73	by	by	IN
18637	9601	74	due	due	JJ
18637	9601	75	notice	notice	NN
18637	9601	76	couched	couch	VBN
18637	9601	77	in	in	IN
18637	9601	78	a	a	DT
18637	9601	79	friendly	friendly	JJ
18637	9601	80	and	and	CC
18637	9601	81	courteous	courteous	JJ
18637	9601	82	tone	tone	NN
18637	9601	83	and	and	CC
18637	9601	84	accompanied	accompany	VBN
18637	9601	85	by	by	IN
18637	9601	86	an	an	DT
18637	9601	87	invitation	invitation	NN
18637	9601	88	to	to	TO
18637	9601	89	begin	begin	VB
18637	9601	90	negotiations	negotiation	NNS
18637	9601	91	for	for	IN
18637	9601	92	a	a	DT
18637	9601	93	new	new	JJ
18637	9601	94	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9601	95	.	.	.
18637	9602	1	Having	have	VBG
18637	9602	2	done	do	VBN
18637	9602	3	this	this	DT
18637	9602	4	,	,	,
18637	9602	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9602	6	notified	notify	VBD
18637	9602	7	the	the	DT
18637	9602	8	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9602	9	of	of	IN
18637	9602	10	the	the	DT
18637	9602	11	fact	fact	NN
18637	9602	12	,	,	,
18637	9602	13	and	and	CC
18637	9602	14	this	this	DT
18637	9602	15	enabled	enable	VBD
18637	9602	16	the	the	DT
18637	9602	17	wiser	wise	JJR
18637	9602	18	heads	head	NNS
18637	9602	19	of	of	IN
18637	9602	20	the	the	DT
18637	9602	21	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9602	22	to	to	TO
18637	9602	23	substitute	substitute	VB
18637	9602	24	for	for	IN
18637	9602	25	the	the	DT
18637	9602	26	house	house	NNP
18637	9602	27	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	9602	28	a	a	DT
18637	9602	29	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	9602	30	approving	approve	VBG
18637	9602	31	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9602	32	action	action	NN
18637	9602	33	,	,	,
18637	9602	34	and	and	CC
18637	9602	35	in	in	IN
18637	9602	36	this	this	DT
18637	9602	37	way	way	NN
18637	9602	38	the	the	DT
18637	9602	39	passage	passage	NN
18637	9602	40	of	of	IN
18637	9602	41	the	the	DT
18637	9602	42	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	9602	43	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	9602	44	was	be	VBD
18637	9602	45	avoided	avoid	VBN
18637	9602	46	.	.	.
18637	9602	47	"	"	''
18637	9603	1	The	the	DT
18637	9603	2	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	9603	3	in	in	IN
18637	9603	4	question	question	NN
18637	9603	5	,	,	,
18637	9603	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9603	7	should	should	MD
18637	9603	8	be	be	VB
18637	9603	9	added	add	VBN
18637	9603	10	,	,	,
18637	9603	11	was	be	VBD
18637	9603	12	a	a	DT
18637	9603	13	joint	joint	JJ
18637	9603	14	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	9603	15	,	,	,
18637	9603	16	and	and	CC
18637	9603	17	purported	purport	VBD
18637	9603	18	to	to	TO
18637	9603	19	ratify	ratify	VB
18637	9603	20	the	the	DT
18637	9603	21	President	President	NNP
18637	9603	22	's	's	POS
18637	9603	23	action	action	NN
18637	9603	24	.	.	.
18637	9604	1	The	the	DT
18637	9604	2	President	President	NNP
18637	9604	3	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9604	4	had	have	VBD
18637	9604	5	asked	ask	VBN
18637	9604	6	only	only	RB
18637	9604	7	for	for	IN
18637	9604	8	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	9604	9	and	and	CC
18637	9604	10	approval	approval	NN
18637	9604	11	of	of	IN
18637	9604	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9604	13	course	course	NN
18637	9604	14	by	by	IN
18637	9604	15	the	the	DT
18637	9604	16	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9604	17	.	.	.
18637	9605	1	William	William	NNP
18637	9605	2	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	9605	3	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	9605	4	,	,	,
18637	9605	5	The	the	DT
18637	9605	6	Presidency	Presidency	NNP
18637	9605	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9605	8	New	New	NNP
18637	9605	9	York	York	NNP
18637	9605	10	,	,	,
18637	9605	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	9605	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9605	13	,	,	,
18637	9605	14	112	112	CD
18637	9605	15	-	-	SYM
18637	9605	16	114	114	CD
18637	9605	17	.	.	.
18637	9606	1	Two	two	CD
18637	9606	2	other	other	JJ
18637	9606	3	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	9606	4	bearing	bear	VBG
18637	9606	5	on	on	IN
18637	9606	6	outright	outright	JJ
18637	9606	7	abrogation	abrogation	NN
18637	9606	8	of	of	IN
18637	9606	9	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9606	10	are	be	VBP
18637	9606	11	the	the	DT
18637	9606	12	following	follow	VBG
18637	9606	13	.	.	.
18637	9607	1	The	the	DT
18637	9607	2	question	question	NN
18637	9607	3	whether	whether	IN
18637	9607	4	to	to	TO
18637	9607	5	regard	regard	VB
18637	9607	6	the	the	DT
18637	9607	7	extradition	extradition	NN
18637	9607	8	article	article	NN
18637	9607	9	of	of	IN
18637	9607	10	the	the	DT
18637	9607	11	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	9607	12	of	of	IN
18637	9607	13	1842	1842	CD
18637	9607	14	with	with	IN
18637	9607	15	Great	Great	NNP
18637	9607	16	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	9607	17	as	as	IN
18637	9607	18	void	void	JJ
18637	9607	19	on	on	IN
18637	9607	20	account	account	NN
18637	9607	21	of	of	IN
18637	9607	22	certain	certain	JJ
18637	9607	23	acts	act	NNS
18637	9607	24	of	of	IN
18637	9607	25	the	the	DT
18637	9607	26	British	British	NNP
18637	9607	27	Government	Government	NNP
18637	9607	28	was	be	VBD
18637	9607	29	laid	lay	VBN
18637	9607	30	before	before	IN
18637	9607	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9607	32	by	by	IN
18637	9607	33	President	President	NNP
18637	9607	34	Grant	Grant	NNP
18637	9607	35	in	in	IN
18637	9607	36	a	a	DT
18637	9607	37	special	special	JJ
18637	9607	38	message	message	NN
18637	9607	39	dated	date	VBN
18637	9607	40	June	June	NNP
18637	9607	41	20	20	CD
18637	9607	42	,	,	,
18637	9607	43	1876	1876	CD
18637	9607	44	,	,	,
18637	9607	45	in	in	IN
18637	9607	46	the	the	DT
18637	9607	47	following	following	JJ
18637	9607	48	terms	term	NNS
18637	9607	49	:	:	:
18637	9607	50	"	"	``
18637	9607	51	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9607	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	9607	53	for	for	IN
18637	9607	54	the	the	DT
18637	9607	55	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	9607	56	of	of	IN
18637	9607	57	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9607	58	to	to	TO
18637	9607	59	determine	determine	VB
18637	9607	60	whether	whether	IN
18637	9607	61	the	the	DT
18637	9607	62	article	article	NN
18637	9607	63	of	of	IN
18637	9607	64	the	the	DT
18637	9607	65	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9607	66	relating	relate	VBG
18637	9607	67	to	to	IN
18637	9607	68	extradition	extradition	NN
18637	9607	69	is	be	VBZ
18637	9607	70	to	to	TO
18637	9607	71	be	be	VB
18637	9607	72	any	any	RB
18637	9607	73	longer	long	RBR
18637	9607	74	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	9607	75	as	as	IN
18637	9607	76	obligatory	obligatory	JJ
18637	9607	77	on	on	IN
18637	9607	78	the	the	DT
18637	9607	79	Government	Government	NNP
18637	9607	80	of	of	IN
18637	9607	81	the	the	DT
18637	9607	82	United	United	NNP
18637	9607	83	States	States	NNP
18637	9607	84	or	or	CC
18637	9607	85	as	as	IN
18637	9607	86	forming	form	VBG
18637	9607	87	part	part	NN
18637	9607	88	of	of	IN
18637	9607	89	the	the	DT
18637	9607	90	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	9607	91	law	law	NNP
18637	9607	92	of	of	IN
18637	9607	93	the	the	DT
18637	9607	94	land	land	NN
18637	9607	95	.	.	.
18637	9608	1	Should	Should	MD
18637	9608	2	the	the	DT
18637	9608	3	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	9608	4	of	of	IN
18637	9608	5	the	the	DT
18637	9608	6	British	British	NNP
18637	9608	7	Government	Government	NNP
18637	9608	8	remain	remain	VBP
18637	9608	9	unchanged	unchanged	JJ
18637	9608	10	,	,	,
18637	9608	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9608	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	9608	13	not	not	RB
18637	9608	14	,	,	,
18637	9608	15	without	without	IN
18637	9608	16	an	an	DT
18637	9608	17	expression	expression	NN
18637	9608	18	of	of	IN
18637	9608	19	the	the	DT
18637	9608	20	wish	wish	NN
18637	9608	21	of	of	IN
18637	9608	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9608	23	that	that	IN
18637	9608	24	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9608	25	should	should	MD
18637	9608	26	do	do	VB
18637	9608	27	so	so	RB
18637	9608	28	,	,	,
18637	9608	29	take	take	VB
18637	9608	30	any	any	DT
18637	9608	31	action	action	NN
18637	9608	32	either	either	CC
18637	9608	33	in	in	IN
18637	9608	34	making	make	VBG
18637	9608	35	or	or	CC
18637	9608	36	granting	grant	VBG
18637	9608	37	requisitions	requisition	NNS
18637	9608	38	for	for	IN
18637	9608	39	the	the	DT
18637	9608	40	surrender	surrender	NN
18637	9608	41	of	of	IN
18637	9608	42	fugitive	fugitive	JJ
18637	9608	43	criminals	criminal	NNS
18637	9608	44	under	under	IN
18637	9608	45	the	the	DT
18637	9608	46	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9608	47	of	of	IN
18637	9608	48	1842	1842	CD
18637	9608	49	.	.	.
18637	9608	50	"	"	''
18637	9609	1	Messages	message	NNS
18637	9609	2	and	and	CC
18637	9609	3	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	9609	4	of	of	IN
18637	9609	5	the	the	DT
18637	9609	6	Presidents	Presidents	NNPS
18637	9609	7	,	,	,
18637	9609	8	IX	IX	NNP
18637	9609	9	,	,	,
18637	9609	10	4324	4324	CD
18637	9609	11	,	,	,
18637	9609	12	4327	4327	CD
18637	9609	13	.	.	.
18637	9610	1	Three	three	CD
18637	9610	2	years	year	NNS
18637	9610	3	later	later	RBR
18637	9610	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9610	5	passed	pass	VBD
18637	9610	6	a	a	DT
18637	9610	7	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	9610	8	requiring	require	VBG
18637	9610	9	the	the	DT
18637	9610	10	President	President	NNP
18637	9610	11	to	to	TO
18637	9610	12	abrogate	abrogate	VB
18637	9610	13	articles	article	NNS
18637	9610	14	V	V	NNP
18637	9610	15	and	and	CC
18637	9610	16	VI	VI	NNP
18637	9610	17	of	of	IN
18637	9610	18	the	the	DT
18637	9610	19	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	9610	20	of	of	IN
18637	9610	21	1868	1868	CD
18637	9610	22	with	with	IN
18637	9610	23	China	China	NNP
18637	9610	24	.	.	.
18637	9611	1	President	President	NNP
18637	9611	2	Hayes	Hayes	NNP
18637	9611	3	vetoed	veto	VBD
18637	9611	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9611	5	,	,	,
18637	9611	6	partly	partly	RB
18637	9611	7	on	on	IN
18637	9611	8	the	the	DT
18637	9611	9	ground	ground	NN
18637	9611	10	that	that	IN
18637	9611	11	"	"	``
18637	9611	12	the	the	DT
18637	9611	13	power	power	NN
18637	9611	14	of	of	IN
18637	9611	15	modifying	modify	VBG
18637	9611	16	an	an	DT
18637	9611	17	existing	exist	VBG
18637	9611	18	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9611	19	,	,	,
18637	9611	20	whether	whether	IN
18637	9611	21	by	by	IN
18637	9611	22	adding	add	VBG
18637	9611	23	or	or	CC
18637	9611	24	striking	strike	VBG
18637	9611	25	out	out	RP
18637	9611	26	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	9611	27	,	,	,
18637	9611	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	9611	29	a	a	DT
18637	9611	30	part	part	NN
18637	9611	31	of	of	IN
18637	9611	32	the	the	DT
18637	9611	33	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9611	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	9611	35	making	make	VBG
18637	9611	36	power	power	NN
18637	9611	37	under	under	IN
18637	9611	38	the	the	DT
18637	9611	39	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9611	40	.	.	.
18637	9612	1	*	*	NFP
18637	9612	2	*	*	NFP
18637	9612	3	*	*	NFP
18637	9612	4	"	"	``
18637	9612	5	At	at	IN
18637	9612	6	the	the	DT
18637	9612	7	same	same	JJ
18637	9612	8	time	time	NN
18637	9612	9	,	,	,
18637	9612	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9612	11	also	also	RB
18637	9612	12	wrote	write	VBD
18637	9612	13	:	:	:
18637	9612	14	"	"	``
18637	9612	15	The	the	DT
18637	9612	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	9612	17	of	of	IN
18637	9612	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9612	19	to	to	TO
18637	9612	20	terminate	terminate	VB
18637	9612	21	a	a	DT
18637	9612	22	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9612	23	with	with	IN
18637	9612	24	a	a	DT
18637	9612	25	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9612	26	power	power	NN
18637	9612	27	by	by	IN
18637	9612	28	expressing	express	VBG
18637	9612	29	the	the	DT
18637	9612	30	will	will	NN
18637	9612	31	of	of	IN
18637	9612	32	the	the	DT
18637	9612	33	nation	nation	NN
18637	9612	34	no	no	RB
18637	9612	35	longer	longer	RB
18637	9612	36	to	to	TO
18637	9612	37	adhere	adhere	VB
18637	9612	38	to	to	IN
18637	9612	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9612	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	9612	41	as	as	RB
18637	9612	42	free	free	JJ
18637	9612	43	from	from	IN
18637	9612	44	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	9612	45	under	under	IN
18637	9612	46	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9612	47	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9612	48	as	as	IN
18637	9612	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	9612	50	the	the	DT
18637	9612	51	further	further	JJ
18637	9612	52	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	9612	53	that	that	IN
18637	9612	54	the	the	DT
18637	9612	55	power	power	NN
18637	9612	56	of	of	IN
18637	9612	57	making	make	VBG
18637	9612	58	new	new	JJ
18637	9612	59	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9612	60	or	or	CC
18637	9612	61	modifying	modify	VBG
18637	9612	62	existing	exist	VBG
18637	9612	63	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9612	64	is	be	VBZ
18637	9612	65	not	not	RB
18637	9612	66	lodged	lodge	VBN
18637	9612	67	by	by	IN
18637	9612	68	the	the	DT
18637	9612	69	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9612	70	in	in	IN
18637	9612	71	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9612	72	,	,	,
18637	9612	73	but	but	CC
18637	9612	74	in	in	IN
18637	9612	75	the	the	DT
18637	9612	76	President	President	NNP
18637	9612	77	,	,	,
18637	9612	78	by	by	RB
18637	9612	79	and	and	CC
18637	9612	80	with	with	IN
18637	9612	81	the	the	DT
18637	9612	82	advice	advice	NN
18637	9612	83	and	and	CC
18637	9612	84	consent	consent	NN
18637	9612	85	of	of	IN
18637	9612	86	the	the	DT
18637	9612	87	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9612	88	,	,	,
18637	9612	89	as	as	IN
18637	9612	90	shown	show	VBN
18637	9612	91	by	by	IN
18637	9612	92	the	the	DT
18637	9612	93	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	9612	94	of	of	IN
18637	9612	95	two	two	CD
18637	9612	96	-	-	HYPH
18637	9612	97	thirds	third	NNS
18637	9612	98	of	of	IN
18637	9612	99	that	that	DT
18637	9612	100	body	body	NN
18637	9612	101	.	.	.
18637	9612	102	"	"	''
18637	9613	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	9613	2	.	.	.
18637	9614	1	4470	4470	CD
18637	9614	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9614	3	4471	4471	CD
18637	9614	4	.	.	.
18637	9615	1	The	the	DT
18637	9615	2	veto	veto	NN
18637	9615	3	would	would	MD
18637	9615	4	seem	seem	VB
18637	9615	5	to	to	TO
18637	9615	6	have	have	VB
18637	9615	7	been	be	VBN
18637	9615	8	based	base	VBN
18637	9615	9	on	on	IN
18637	9615	10	a	a	DT
18637	9615	11	quibble	quibble	NN
18637	9615	12	.	.	.
18637	9616	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9616	2	188	188	CD
18637	9616	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9616	4	229	229	CD
18637	9616	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9616	6	447	447	CD
18637	9616	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9616	8	1913	1913	CD
18637	9616	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9616	10	.	.	.
18637	9617	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9617	2	189	189	CD
18637	9617	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9617	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9617	5	.	.	.
18637	9618	1	473	473	CD
18637	9618	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9618	3	476	476	CD
18637	9618	4	.	.	.
18637	9619	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9619	2	190	190	CD
18637	9619	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9619	4	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	9619	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9619	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9619	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9619	8	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	9619	9	,	,	,
18637	9619	10	331	331	CD
18637	9619	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9619	12	503	503	CD
18637	9619	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9619	14	1947	1947	CD
18637	9619	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9619	16	.	.	.
18637	9620	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9620	2	191	191	CD
18637	9620	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9620	4	Charlton	Charlton	NNP
18637	9620	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9620	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9620	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9620	8	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
18637	9620	9	,	,	,
18637	9620	10	229	229	CD
18637	9620	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9620	12	447	447	CD
18637	9620	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9620	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	9620	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9620	16	.	.	.
18637	9621	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9621	2	192	192	CD
18637	9621	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9621	4	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	9621	5	.	.	.
18637	9622	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	9622	2	.	.	.
18637	9623	1	No	no	UH
18637	9623	2	.	.	.
18637	9624	1	13,799	13,799	CD
18637	9624	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9624	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	9624	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9624	5	.	.	.
18637	9625	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9625	2	193	193	CD
18637	9625	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9625	4	2	2	CD
18637	9625	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	9625	6	.	.	.
18637	9626	1	253	253	CD
18637	9626	2	,	,	,
18637	9626	3	309	309	CD
18637	9626	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9626	5	1829	1829	CD
18637	9626	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9626	7	.	.	.
18637	9627	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9627	2	194	194	CD
18637	9627	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9627	4	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	9627	5	of	of	IN
18637	9627	6	March	March	NNP
18637	9627	7	2	2	CD
18637	9627	8	,	,	,
18637	9627	9	1829	1829	CD
18637	9627	10	and	and	CC
18637	9627	11	of	of	IN
18637	9627	12	February	February	NNP
18637	9627	13	24	24	CD
18637	9627	14	,	,	,
18637	9627	15	1855	1855	CD
18637	9627	16	;	;	SYM
18637	9627	17	4	4	CD
18637	9627	18	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	9627	19	.	.	.
18637	9628	1	359	359	CD
18637	9628	2	and	and	CC
18637	9628	3	10	10	CD
18637	9628	4	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	9628	5	.	.	.
18637	9629	1	614	614	CD
18637	9629	2	.	.	.
18637	9630	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9630	2	195	195	CD
18637	9630	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9630	4	In	in	IN
18637	9630	5	re	re	NNP
18637	9630	6	Ross	Ross	NNP
18637	9630	7	,	,	,
18637	9630	8	140	140	CD
18637	9630	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9630	10	453	453	CD
18637	9630	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9630	12	1891	1891	CD
18637	9630	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9630	14	,	,	,
18637	9630	15	where	where	WRB
18637	9630	16	the	the	DT
18637	9630	17	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9630	18	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	9630	19	involved	involve	VBN
18637	9630	20	are	be	VBP
18637	9630	21	given	give	VBN
18637	9630	22	.	.	.
18637	9631	1	The	the	DT
18637	9631	2	supplementary	supplementary	JJ
18637	9631	3	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	9631	4	was	be	VBD
18637	9631	5	later	later	RB
18637	9631	6	reenacted	reenact	VBN
18637	9631	7	as	as	IN
18637	9631	8	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	9632	1	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	9632	2	.	.	.
18637	9633	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	9633	2	4083	4083	CD
18637	9633	3	-	-	SYM
18637	9633	4	4091	4091	CD
18637	9633	5	.	.	.
18637	9634	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9634	2	196	196	CD
18637	9634	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9634	4	18	18	CD
18637	9634	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	9635	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	9635	2	3181	3181	CD
18637	9635	3	-	-	SYM
18637	9635	4	3195	3195	CD
18637	9635	5	.	.	.
18637	9636	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9636	2	197	197	CD
18637	9636	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9636	4	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	9636	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9636	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9636	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9636	8	Franks	Franks	NNP
18637	9636	9	,	,	,
18637	9636	10	120	120	CD
18637	9636	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9636	12	678	678	CD
18637	9636	13	,	,	,
18637	9636	14	683	683	CD
18637	9636	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9636	16	1887	1887	CD
18637	9636	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9636	18	.	.	.
18637	9637	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9637	2	198	198	CD
18637	9637	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9637	4	Neely	neely	RB
18637	9637	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9637	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9637	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9637	8	Henkel	Henkel	NNP
18637	9637	9	,	,	,
18637	9637	10	180	180	CD
18637	9637	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9637	12	109	109	CD
18637	9637	13	,	,	,
18637	9637	14	121	121	CD
18637	9637	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9637	16	1901	1901	CD
18637	9637	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9637	18	.	.	.
18637	9638	1	A	a	DT
18637	9638	2	different	different	JJ
18637	9638	3	theory	theory	NN
18637	9638	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	9638	5	offered	offer	VBN
18637	9638	6	by	by	IN
18637	9638	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9638	8	Story	Story	NNP
18637	9638	9	in	in	IN
18637	9638	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9638	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9638	12	for	for	IN
18637	9638	13	the	the	DT
18637	9638	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9638	15	in	in	IN
18637	9638	16	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
18637	9638	17	_	_	NNP
18637	9638	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	9638	19	_	_	NNP
18637	9638	20	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	9638	21	,	,	,
18637	9638	22	16	16	CD
18637	9638	23	Pet	pet	NN
18637	9638	24	.	.	.
18637	9639	1	539	539	CD
18637	9639	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9639	3	1842	1842	CD
18637	9639	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9639	5	,	,	,
18637	9639	6	in	in	IN
18637	9639	7	the	the	DT
18637	9639	8	following	follow	VBG
18637	9639	9	words	word	NNS
18637	9639	10	:	:	:
18637	9639	11	"	"	``
18637	9639	12	Treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9639	13	made	make	VBN
18637	9639	14	between	between	IN
18637	9639	15	the	the	DT
18637	9639	16	United	United	NNP
18637	9639	17	States	States	NNP
18637	9639	18	and	and	CC
18637	9639	19	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9639	20	powers	power	NNS
18637	9639	21	,	,	,
18637	9639	22	often	often	RB
18637	9639	23	contain	contain	VBP
18637	9639	24	special	special	JJ
18637	9639	25	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	9639	26	,	,	,
18637	9639	27	which	which	WDT
18637	9639	28	do	do	VBP
18637	9639	29	not	not	RB
18637	9639	30	execute	execute	VB
18637	9639	31	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9639	32	,	,	,
18637	9639	33	but	but	CC
18637	9639	34	require	require	VBP
18637	9639	35	the	the	DT
18637	9639	36	interposition	interposition	NN
18637	9639	37	of	of	IN
18637	9639	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9639	39	to	to	TO
18637	9639	40	carry	carry	VB
18637	9639	41	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9639	42	into	into	IN
18637	9639	43	effect	effect	NN
18637	9639	44	,	,	,
18637	9639	45	and	and	CC
18637	9639	46	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9639	47	has	have	VBZ
18637	9639	48	constantly	constantly	RB
18637	9639	49	,	,	,
18637	9639	50	in	in	IN
18637	9639	51	such	such	JJ
18637	9639	52	cases	case	NNS
18637	9639	53	,	,	,
18637	9639	54	legislated	legislate	VBN
18637	9639	55	on	on	IN
18637	9639	56	the	the	DT
18637	9639	57	subject	subject	NN
18637	9639	58	;	;	:
18637	9639	59	yet	yet	CC
18637	9639	60	,	,	,
18637	9639	61	although	although	IN
18637	9639	62	the	the	DT
18637	9639	63	power	power	NN
18637	9639	64	is	be	VBZ
18637	9639	65	given	give	VBN
18637	9639	66	to	to	IN
18637	9639	67	the	the	DT
18637	9639	68	executive	executive	NN
18637	9639	69	,	,	,
18637	9639	70	with	with	IN
18637	9639	71	the	the	DT
18637	9639	72	consent	consent	NN
18637	9639	73	of	of	IN
18637	9639	74	the	the	DT
18637	9639	75	senate	senate	NNP
18637	9639	76	,	,	,
18637	9639	77	to	to	TO
18637	9639	78	make	make	VB
18637	9639	79	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9639	80	,	,	,
18637	9639	81	the	the	DT
18637	9639	82	power	power	NN
18637	9639	83	is	be	VBZ
18637	9639	84	nowhere	nowhere	RB
18637	9639	85	in	in	IN
18637	9639	86	positive	positive	JJ
18637	9639	87	terms	term	NNS
18637	9639	88	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	9639	89	upon	upon	IN
18637	9639	90	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9639	91	to	to	TO
18637	9639	92	make	make	VB
18637	9639	93	laws	law	NNS
18637	9639	94	to	to	TO
18637	9639	95	carry	carry	VB
18637	9639	96	the	the	DT
18637	9639	97	stipulations	stipulation	NNS
18637	9639	98	of	of	IN
18637	9639	99	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9639	100	into	into	IN
18637	9639	101	effect	effect	NN
18637	9639	102	.	.	.
18637	9640	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9640	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	9640	3	been	be	VBN
18637	9640	4	supposed	suppose	VBN
18637	9640	5	to	to	TO
18637	9640	6	result	result	VB
18637	9640	7	from	from	IN
18637	9640	8	the	the	DT
18637	9640	9	duty	duty	NN
18637	9640	10	of	of	IN
18637	9640	11	the	the	DT
18637	9640	12	national	national	JJ
18637	9640	13	government	government	NN
18637	9640	14	to	to	TO
18637	9640	15	fulfil	fulfil	VB
18637	9640	16	all	all	PDT
18637	9640	17	the	the	DT
18637	9640	18	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	9640	19	of	of	IN
18637	9640	20	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9640	21	.	.	.
18637	9640	22	"	"	''
18637	9641	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	9641	2	.	.	.
18637	9642	1	619	619	CD
18637	9642	2	.	.	.
18637	9643	1	Story	story	NN
18637	9643	2	was	be	VBD
18637	9643	3	here	here	RB
18637	9643	4	in	in	IN
18637	9643	5	quest	quest	NN
18637	9643	6	of	of	IN
18637	9643	7	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	9643	8	to	to	TO
18637	9643	9	prove	prove	VB
18637	9643	10	that	that	IN
18637	9643	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9643	12	had	have	VBD
18637	9643	13	power	power	NN
18637	9643	14	to	to	TO
18637	9643	15	enact	enact	VB
18637	9643	16	a	a	DT
18637	9643	17	fugitive	fugitive	JJ
18637	9643	18	slave	slave	NN
18637	9643	19	law	law	NN
18637	9643	20	,	,	,
18637	9643	21	which	which	WDT
18637	9643	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9643	23	based	base	VBD
18637	9643	24	on	on	IN
18637	9643	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9643	26	power	power	NN
18637	9643	27	"	"	''
18637	9643	28	to	to	TO
18637	9643	29	carry	carry	VB
18637	9643	30	into	into	IN
18637	9643	31	effect	effect	NN
18637	9643	32	rights	right	NNS
18637	9643	33	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	9643	34	given	give	VBN
18637	9643	35	and	and	CC
18637	9643	36	duties	duty	NNS
18637	9643	37	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	9643	38	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	9643	39	"	"	''
18637	9643	40	by	by	IN
18637	9643	41	the	the	DT
18637	9643	42	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9643	43	.	.	.
18637	9644	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	9644	2	.	.	.
18637	9645	1	618	618	CD
18637	9645	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9645	3	619	619	CD
18637	9645	4	.	.	.
18637	9646	1	But	but	CC
18637	9646	2	the	the	DT
18637	9646	3	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9646	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	9646	5	making	make	VBG
18637	9646	6	power	power	NN
18637	9646	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	9646	8	neither	neither	CC
18637	9646	9	a	a	DT
18637	9646	10	right	right	NN
18637	9646	11	nor	nor	CC
18637	9646	12	a	a	DT
18637	9646	13	duty	duty	NN
18637	9646	14	,	,	,
18637	9646	15	but	but	CC
18637	9646	16	one	one	CD
18637	9646	17	of	of	IN
18637	9646	18	the	the	DT
18637	9646	19	powers	power	NNS
18637	9646	20	"	"	``
18637	9646	21	vested	vest	VBN
18637	9646	22	by	by	IN
18637	9646	23	this	this	DT
18637	9646	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9646	25	in	in	IN
18637	9646	26	the	the	DT
18637	9646	27	Government	Government	NNP
18637	9646	28	of	of	IN
18637	9646	29	the	the	DT
18637	9646	30	United	United	NNP
18637	9646	31	States	States	NNP
18637	9646	32	.	.	.
18637	9646	33	"	"	''
18637	9647	1	Article	article	NN
18637	9647	2	I	i	NN
18637	9647	3	,	,	,
18637	9647	4	section	section	NN
18637	9647	5	8	8	CD
18637	9647	6	,	,	,
18637	9647	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	9647	8	18	18	CD
18637	9647	9	.	.	.
18637	9648	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9648	2	199	199	CD
18637	9648	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9648	4	Geofroy	Geofroy	NNP
18637	9648	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9648	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9648	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9648	8	Riggs	Riggs	NNP
18637	9648	9	,	,	,
18637	9648	10	133	133	CD
18637	9648	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9648	12	258	258	CD
18637	9648	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9648	14	1890	1890	CD
18637	9648	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9648	16	.	.	.
18637	9649	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9649	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9649	3	also	also	RB
18637	9649	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9649	5	Fort	Fort	NNP
18637	9649	6	Leavenworth	Leavenworth	NNP
18637	9649	7	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	9649	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	9649	9	_	_	NNP
18637	9649	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	9649	11	_	_	NNP
18637	9649	12	Lowe	Lowe	NNP
18637	9649	13	,	,	,
18637	9649	14	114	114	CD
18637	9649	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9649	16	525	525	CD
18637	9649	17	,	,	,
18637	9649	18	541	541	CD
18637	9649	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9649	20	1885	1885	CD
18637	9649	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9649	22	,	,	,
18637	9649	23	which	which	WDT
18637	9649	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	9649	25	cited	cite	VBN
18637	9649	26	in	in	IN
18637	9649	27	the	the	DT
18637	9649	28	Field	field	NN
18637	9649	29	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9649	30	in	in	IN
18637	9649	31	support	support	NN
18637	9649	32	of	of	IN
18637	9649	33	the	the	DT
18637	9649	34	idea	idea	NN
18637	9649	35	that	that	IN
18637	9649	36	no	no	DT
18637	9649	37	cession	cession	NN
18637	9649	38	of	of	IN
18637	9649	39	any	any	DT
18637	9649	40	portion	portion	NN
18637	9649	41	of	of	IN
18637	9649	42	a	a	DT
18637	9649	43	State	state	NN
18637	9649	44	's	's	POS
18637	9649	45	territory	territory	NN
18637	9649	46	could	could	MD
18637	9649	47	be	be	VB
18637	9649	48	effected	effect	VBN
18637	9649	49	without	without	IN
18637	9649	50	the	the	DT
18637	9649	51	State	state	NN
18637	9649	52	's	's	POS
18637	9649	53	consent	consent	NN
18637	9649	54	.	.	.
18637	9650	1	The	the	DT
18637	9650	2	statement	statement	NN
18637	9650	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	9650	4	the	the	DT
18637	9650	5	purest	pure	JJS
18637	9650	6	obiter	obiter	NN
18637	9650	7	.	.	.
18637	9651	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9651	2	200	200	CD
18637	9651	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9651	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9651	5	.	.	.
18637	9652	1	267	267	CD
18637	9652	2	.	.	.
18637	9653	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9653	2	201	201	CD
18637	9653	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9653	4	The	the	DT
18637	9653	5	majority	majority	NN
18637	9653	6	of	of	IN
18637	9653	7	the	the	DT
18637	9653	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	9653	9	,	,	,
18637	9653	10	as	as	IN
18637	9653	11	was	be	VBD
18637	9653	12	pointed	point	VBN
18637	9653	13	out	out	RP
18637	9653	14	earlier	early	RBR
18637	9653	15	,	,	,
18637	9653	16	dealt	deal	VBD
18637	9653	17	with	with	IN
18637	9653	18	the	the	DT
18637	9653	19	competence	competence	NN
18637	9653	20	of	of	IN
18637	9653	21	the	the	DT
18637	9653	22	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9653	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	9653	24	making	make	VBG
18637	9653	25	power	power	NN
18637	9653	26	to	to	TO
18637	9653	27	grant	grant	VB
18637	9653	28	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	9653	29	the	the	DT
18637	9653	30	right	right	NN
18637	9653	31	to	to	TO
18637	9653	32	inherit	inherit	VB
18637	9653	33	real	real	JJ
18637	9653	34	property	property	NN
18637	9653	35	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	9653	36	to	to	IN
18637	9653	37	State	State	NNP
18637	9653	38	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9653	39	.	.	.
18637	9654	1	The	the	DT
18637	9654	2	nearest	near	JJS
18637	9654	3	the	the	DT
18637	9654	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9654	5	ever	ever	RB
18637	9654	6	came	come	VBD
18637	9654	7	to	to	IN
18637	9654	8	lending	lend	VBG
18637	9654	9	countenance	countenance	NN
18637	9654	10	to	to	IN
18637	9654	11	the	the	DT
18637	9654	12	State	State	NNP
18637	9654	13	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	9654	14	argument	argument	NN
18637	9654	15	in	in	IN
18637	9654	16	this	this	DT
18637	9654	17	connection	connection	NN
18637	9654	18	was	be	VBD
18637	9654	19	in	in	IN
18637	9654	20	Frederickson	Frederickson	NNP
18637	9654	21	_	_	NNP
18637	9654	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	9654	23	_	_	NNP
18637	9654	24	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	9654	25	,	,	,
18637	9654	26	23	23	CD
18637	9654	27	How	how	WRB
18637	9654	28	.	.	.
18637	9655	1	445	445	CD
18637	9655	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9655	3	1860	1860	CD
18637	9655	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9655	5	.	.	.
18637	9656	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9656	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9656	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9656	4	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9656	5	.	.	.
18637	9657	1	448	448	CD
18637	9657	2	.	.	.
18637	9658	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9658	2	202	202	CD
18637	9658	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9658	4	252	252	CD
18637	9658	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9658	6	416	416	CD
18637	9658	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9658	8	1920	1920	CD
18637	9658	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9658	10	.	.	.
18637	9659	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9659	2	203	203	CD
18637	9659	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9659	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9659	5	.	.	.
18637	9660	1	433	433	CD
18637	9660	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9660	3	434	434	CD
18637	9660	4	.	.	.
18637	9661	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9661	2	204	204	CD
18637	9661	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9661	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9661	5	.	.	.
18637	9662	1	435	435	CD
18637	9662	2	.	.	.
18637	9663	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9663	2	205	205	CD
18637	9663	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9663	4	299	299	CD
18637	9663	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9663	6	304	304	CD
18637	9663	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9663	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	9663	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9663	10	.	.	.
18637	9664	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9664	2	206	206	CD
18637	9664	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9664	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9664	5	.	.	.
18637	9665	1	318	318	CD
18637	9665	2	.	.	.
18637	9666	1	"	"	``
18637	9666	2	The	the	DT
18637	9666	3	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9666	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	9666	5	making	make	VBG
18637	9666	6	power	power	NN
18637	9666	7	vested	vest	VBN
18637	9666	8	in	in	IN
18637	9666	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9666	10	government	government	NN
18637	9666	11	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	9666	12	to	to	IN
18637	9666	13	all	all	DT
18637	9666	14	proper	proper	JJ
18637	9666	15	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	9666	16	of	of	IN
18637	9666	17	negotiation	negotiation	NN
18637	9666	18	with	with	IN
18637	9666	19	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9666	20	governments	government	NNS
18637	9666	21	.	.	.
18637	9667	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9667	2	can	can	MD
18637	9667	3	,	,	,
18637	9667	4	equally	equally	RB
18637	9667	5	with	with	IN
18637	9667	6	any	any	DT
18637	9667	7	of	of	IN
18637	9667	8	the	the	DT
18637	9667	9	former	former	JJ
18637	9667	10	or	or	CC
18637	9667	11	present	present	JJ
18637	9667	12	governments	government	NNS
18637	9667	13	of	of	IN
18637	9667	14	Europe	Europe	NNP
18637	9667	15	,	,	,
18637	9667	16	make	make	VB
18637	9667	17	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9667	18	providing	provide	VBG
18637	9667	19	for	for	IN
18637	9667	20	the	the	DT
18637	9667	21	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	9667	22	of	of	IN
18637	9667	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	9667	24	authority	authority	NN
18637	9667	25	in	in	IN
18637	9667	26	other	other	JJ
18637	9667	27	countries	country	NNS
18637	9667	28	by	by	IN
18637	9667	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9667	30	officers	officer	NNS
18637	9667	31	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	9667	32	to	to	TO
18637	9667	33	reside	reside	VB
18637	9667	34	therein	therein	RB
18637	9667	35	.	.	.
18637	9667	36	"	"	''
18637	9668	1	In	in	IN
18637	9668	2	re	re	NNP
18637	9668	3	Ross	Ross	NNP
18637	9668	4	,	,	,
18637	9668	5	140	140	CD
18637	9668	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9668	7	453	453	CD
18637	9668	8	,	,	,
18637	9668	9	463	463	CD
18637	9668	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9668	11	1891	1891	CD
18637	9668	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9668	13	.	.	.
18637	9669	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9669	2	207	207	CD
18637	9669	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9669	4	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	9669	5	excepted	except	VBD
18637	9669	6	out	out	IN
18637	9669	7	of	of	IN
18637	9669	8	the	the	DT
18637	9669	9	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9669	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	9669	11	making	make	VBG
18637	9669	12	power	power	NN
18637	9669	13	the	the	DT
18637	9669	14	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	9669	15	powers	power	NNS
18637	9669	16	of	of	IN
18637	9669	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9669	18	,	,	,
18637	9669	19	though	though	IN
18637	9669	20	just	just	RB
18637	9669	21	what	what	WP
18637	9669	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9669	23	meant	mean	VBD
18637	9669	24	by	by	IN
18637	9669	25	this	this	DT
18637	9669	26	exception	exception	NN
18637	9669	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	9669	28	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
18637	9669	29	.	.	.
18637	9670	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9670	2	may	may	MD
18637	9670	3	have	have	VB
18637	9670	4	meant	mean	VBN
18637	9670	5	that	that	IN
18637	9670	6	no	no	DT
18637	9670	7	international	international	JJ
18637	9670	8	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	9670	9	could	could	MD
18637	9670	10	be	be	VB
18637	9670	11	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	9670	12	entered	enter	VBN
18637	9670	13	into	into	IN
18637	9670	14	by	by	IN
18637	9670	15	the	the	DT
18637	9670	16	United	United	NNP
18637	9670	17	States	States	NNP
18637	9670	18	within	within	IN
18637	9670	19	the	the	DT
18637	9670	20	sphere	sphere	NN
18637	9670	21	of	of	IN
18637	9670	22	such	such	JJ
18637	9670	23	powers	power	NNS
18637	9670	24	,	,	,
18637	9670	25	or	or	CC
18637	9670	26	only	only	RB
18637	9670	27	that	that	DT
18637	9670	28	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9670	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	9670	30	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	9670	31	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	9670	32	with	with	IN
18637	9670	33	matters	matter	NNS
18637	9670	34	which	which	WDT
18637	9670	35	are	be	VBP
18637	9670	36	also	also	RB
18637	9670	37	subject	subject	JJ
18637	9670	38	to	to	IN
18637	9670	39	the	the	DT
18637	9670	40	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	9670	41	power	power	NN
18637	9670	42	of	of	IN
18637	9670	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9670	44	must	must	MD
18637	9670	45	,	,	,
18637	9670	46	in	in	IN
18637	9670	47	order	order	NN
18637	9670	48	to	to	TO
18637	9670	49	become	become	VB
18637	9670	50	law	law	NN
18637	9670	51	of	of	IN
18637	9670	52	the	the	DT
18637	9670	53	land	land	NN
18637	9670	54	,	,	,
18637	9670	55	receive	receive	VBP
18637	9670	56	the	the	DT
18637	9670	57	assent	assent	NN
18637	9670	58	of	of	IN
18637	9670	59	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9670	60	.	.	.
18637	9671	1	The	the	DT
18637	9671	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	9671	3	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	9671	4	,	,	,
18637	9671	5	however	however	RB
18637	9671	6	,	,	,
18637	9671	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	9671	8	not	not	RB
18637	9671	9	state	state	VB
18637	9671	10	a	a	DT
18637	9671	11	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	9671	12	on	on	IN
18637	9671	13	the	the	DT
18637	9671	14	power	power	NN
18637	9671	15	of	of	IN
18637	9671	16	making	make	VBG
18637	9671	17	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9671	18	in	in	IN
18637	9671	19	the	the	DT
18637	9671	20	sense	sense	NN
18637	9671	21	of	of	IN
18637	9671	22	international	international	JJ
18637	9671	23	conventions	convention	NNS
18637	9671	24	,	,	,
18637	9671	25	but	but	CC
18637	9671	26	rather	rather	RB
18637	9671	27	a	a	DT
18637	9671	28	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	9671	29	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	9671	30	before	before	IN
18637	9671	31	certain	certain	JJ
18637	9671	32	conventions	convention	NNS
18637	9671	33	are	be	VBP
18637	9671	34	cognizable	cognizable	JJ
18637	9671	35	by	by	IN
18637	9671	36	the	the	DT
18637	9671	37	courts	court	NNS
18637	9671	38	in	in	IN
18637	9671	39	the	the	DT
18637	9671	40	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	9671	41	of	of	IN
18637	9671	42	rights	right	NNS
18637	9671	43	under	under	IN
18637	9671	44	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9671	45	,	,	,
18637	9671	46	while	while	IN
18637	9671	47	the	the	DT
18637	9671	48	former	former	JJ
18637	9671	49	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	9671	50	has	have	VBZ
18637	9671	51	been	be	VBN
18637	9671	52	contradicted	contradict	VBN
18637	9671	53	in	in	IN
18637	9671	54	practice	practice	NN
18637	9671	55	from	from	IN
18637	9671	56	the	the	DT
18637	9671	57	outset	outset	NN
18637	9671	58	.	.	.
18637	9672	1	Various	various	JJ
18637	9672	2	other	other	JJ
18637	9672	3	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	9672	4	to	to	IN
18637	9672	5	the	the	DT
18637	9672	6	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9672	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	9672	8	making	make	VBG
18637	9672	9	power	power	NN
18637	9672	10	have	have	VBP
18637	9672	11	been	be	VBN
18637	9672	12	suggested	suggest	VBN
18637	9672	13	from	from	IN
18637	9672	14	time	time	NN
18637	9672	15	to	to	IN
18637	9672	16	time	time	NN
18637	9672	17	.	.	.
18637	9673	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	9673	2	,	,	,
18637	9673	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9673	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	9673	5	been	be	VBN
18637	9673	6	contended	contend	VBN
18637	9673	7	that	that	IN
18637	9673	8	the	the	DT
18637	9673	9	territory	territory	NN
18637	9673	10	of	of	IN
18637	9673	11	a	a	DT
18637	9673	12	State	State	NNP
18637	9673	13	of	of	IN
18637	9673	14	the	the	DT
18637	9673	15	Union	Union	NNP
18637	9673	16	could	could	MD
18637	9673	17	not	not	RB
18637	9673	18	be	be	VB
18637	9673	19	ceded	cede	VBN
18637	9673	20	without	without	IN
18637	9673	21	such	such	JJ
18637	9673	22	State	State	NNP
18637	9673	23	's	's	POS
18637	9673	24	consent	consent	NN
18637	9673	25	,	,	,
18637	9673	26	_	_	NNP
18637	9673	27	see	see	VBP
18637	9673	28	above	above	IN
18637	9673	29	_	_	NNP
18637	9673	30	;	;	:
18637	9673	31	also	also	RB
18637	9673	32	,	,	,
18637	9673	33	that	that	IN
18637	9673	34	while	while	IN
18637	9673	35	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9673	36	territory	territory	NN
18637	9673	37	can	can	MD
18637	9673	38	be	be	VB
18637	9673	39	annexed	annex	VBN
18637	9673	40	to	to	IN
18637	9673	41	the	the	DT
18637	9673	42	United	United	NNP
18637	9673	43	States	States	NNP
18637	9673	44	by	by	IN
18637	9673	45	the	the	DT
18637	9673	46	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9673	47	-	-	HYPH
18637	9673	48	making	make	VBG
18637	9673	49	power	power	NN
18637	9673	50	,	,	,
18637	9673	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9673	52	could	could	MD
18637	9673	53	not	not	RB
18637	9673	54	be	be	VB
18637	9673	55	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	9673	56	with	with	IN
18637	9673	57	the	the	DT
18637	9673	58	United	United	NNP
18637	9673	59	States	States	NNP
18637	9673	60	except	except	IN
18637	9673	61	with	with	IN
18637	9673	62	the	the	DT
18637	9673	63	consent	consent	NN
18637	9673	64	of	of	IN
18637	9673	65	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9673	66	;	;	:
18637	9673	67	also	also	RB
18637	9673	68	,	,	,
18637	9673	69	that	that	IN
18637	9673	70	while	while	IN
18637	9673	71	the	the	DT
18637	9673	72	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9673	73	-	-	HYPH
18637	9673	74	making	make	VBG
18637	9673	75	power	power	NN
18637	9673	76	can	can	MD
18637	9673	77	consent	consent	VB
18637	9673	78	to	to	IN
18637	9673	79	the	the	DT
18637	9673	80	United	United	NNP
18637	9673	81	States	States	NNP
18637	9673	82	being	be	VBG
18637	9673	83	sued	sue	VBN
18637	9673	84	for	for	IN
18637	9673	85	damages	damage	NNS
18637	9673	86	in	in	IN
18637	9673	87	an	an	DT
18637	9673	88	international	international	JJ
18637	9673	89	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	9673	90	for	for	IN
18637	9673	91	an	an	DT
18637	9673	92	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	9673	93	incorrect	incorrect	JJ
18637	9673	94	decision	decision	NN
18637	9673	95	of	of	IN
18637	9673	96	a	a	DT
18637	9673	97	court	court	NN
18637	9673	98	of	of	IN
18637	9673	99	the	the	DT
18637	9673	100	United	United	NNP
18637	9673	101	States	States	NNP
18637	9673	102	,	,	,
18637	9673	103	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9673	104	could	could	MD
18637	9673	105	not	not	RB
18637	9673	106	consent	consent	VB
18637	9673	107	to	to	IN
18637	9673	108	an	an	DT
18637	9673	109	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	9673	110	being	be	VBG
18637	9673	111	taken	take	VBN
18637	9673	112	from	from	IN
18637	9673	113	one	one	CD
18637	9673	114	of	of	IN
18637	9673	115	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9673	116	courts	court	NNS
18637	9673	117	to	to	IN
18637	9673	118	an	an	DT
18637	9673	119	international	international	JJ
18637	9673	120	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	9673	121	.	.	.
18637	9674	1	The	the	DT
18637	9674	2	first	first	JJ
18637	9674	3	of	of	IN
18637	9674	4	these	these	DT
18637	9674	5	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	9674	6	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	9674	7	may	may	MD
18637	9674	8	be	be	VB
18637	9674	9	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
18637	9674	10	as	as	IN
18637	9674	11	resting	rest	VBG
18637	9674	12	on	on	IN
18637	9674	13	the	the	DT
18637	9674	14	unallowable	unallowable	JJ
18637	9674	15	idea	idea	NN
18637	9674	16	that	that	IN
18637	9674	17	the	the	DT
18637	9674	18	United	United	NNP
18637	9674	19	States	States	NNP
18637	9674	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	9674	21	not	not	RB
18637	9674	22	as	as	IN
18637	9674	23	to	to	IN
18637	9674	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9674	25	powers	power	NNS
18637	9674	26	a	a	DT
18637	9674	27	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	9674	28	government	government	NN
18637	9674	29	,	,	,
18637	9674	30	but	but	CC
18637	9674	31	only	only	RB
18637	9674	32	the	the	DT
18637	9674	33	agent	agent	NN
18637	9674	34	of	of	IN
18637	9674	35	the	the	DT
18637	9674	36	States	States	NNP
18637	9674	37	.	.	.
18637	9675	1	In	in	IN
18637	9675	2	the	the	DT
18637	9675	3	words	word	NNS
18637	9675	4	of	of	IN
18637	9675	5	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
18637	9675	6	Kent	Kent	NNP
18637	9675	7	:	:	:
18637	9675	8	"	"	``
18637	9675	9	The	the	DT
18637	9675	10	better	well	JJR
18637	9675	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9675	12	would	would	MD
18637	9675	13	seem	seem	VB
18637	9675	14	to	to	TO
18637	9675	15	be	be	VB
18637	9675	16	,	,	,
18637	9675	17	that	that	IN
18637	9675	18	such	such	PDT
18637	9675	19	a	a	DT
18637	9675	20	power	power	NN
18637	9675	21	of	of	IN
18637	9675	22	cession	cession	NN
18637	9675	23	of	of	IN
18637	9675	24	the	the	DT
18637	9675	25	territory	territory	NN
18637	9675	26	of	of	IN
18637	9675	27	a	a	DT
18637	9675	28	State	State	NNP
18637	9675	29	without	without	IN
18637	9675	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9675	31	consent	consent	NN
18637	9675	32	does	do	VBZ
18637	9675	33	reside	reside	VB
18637	9675	34	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	9675	35	in	in	IN
18637	9675	36	the	the	DT
18637	9675	37	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9675	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	9675	39	making	make	VBG
18637	9675	40	power	power	NN
18637	9675	41	,	,	,
18637	9675	42	under	under	IN
18637	9675	43	the	the	DT
18637	9675	44	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9675	45	of	of	IN
18637	9675	46	the	the	DT
18637	9675	47	United	United	NNP
18637	9675	48	States	States	NNP
18637	9675	49	,	,	,
18637	9675	50	yet	yet	CC
18637	9675	51	sound	sound	JJ
18637	9675	52	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	9675	53	would	would	MD
18637	9675	54	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	9675	55	the	the	DT
18637	9675	56	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	9675	57	of	of	IN
18637	9675	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9675	59	without	without	IN
18637	9675	60	the	the	DT
18637	9675	61	consent	consent	NN
18637	9675	62	of	of	IN
18637	9675	63	the	the	DT
18637	9675	64	local	local	JJ
18637	9675	65	government	government	NN
18637	9675	66	who	who	WP
18637	9675	67	are	be	VBP
18637	9675	68	interested	interested	JJ
18637	9675	69	,	,	,
18637	9675	70	except	except	IN
18637	9675	71	in	in	IN
18637	9675	72	cases	case	NNS
18637	9675	73	of	of	IN
18637	9675	74	great	great	JJ
18637	9675	75	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	9675	76	,	,	,
18637	9675	77	in	in	IN
18637	9675	78	which	which	WDT
18637	9675	79	the	the	DT
18637	9675	80	consent	consent	NN
18637	9675	81	might	may	MD
18637	9675	82	be	be	VB
18637	9675	83	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	9675	84	.	.	.
18637	9675	85	"	"	''
18637	9676	1	1	1	CD
18637	9676	2	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	9676	3	.	.	.
18637	9677	1	166	166	CD
18637	9677	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9677	3	167	167	CD
18637	9677	4	and	and	CC
18637	9677	5	note	note	NN
18637	9677	6	.	.	.
18637	9678	1	This	this	DT
18637	9678	2	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	9678	3	also	also	RB
18637	9678	4	to	to	TO
18637	9678	5	have	have	VB
18637	9678	6	been	be	VBN
18637	9678	7	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	9678	8	the	the	DT
18637	9678	9	view	view	NN
18637	9678	10	of	of	IN
18637	9678	11	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	9678	12	and	and	CC
18637	9678	13	Story	Story	NNP
18637	9678	14	.	.	.
18637	9679	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9679	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9679	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9679	4	Willoughby	Willoughby	NNP
18637	9679	5	,	,	,
18637	9679	6	On	on	IN
18637	9679	7	the	the	DT
18637	9679	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9679	9	,	,	,
18637	9679	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9679	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9679	12	2d	2d	NNP
18637	9679	13	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9679	14	.	.	NNP
18637	9679	15	,	,	,
18637	9679	16	1929	1929	CD
18637	9679	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9679	18	,	,	,
18637	9679	19	575	575	CD
18637	9679	20	-	-	SYM
18637	9679	21	576	576	CD
18637	9679	22	.	.	.
18637	9680	1	The	the	DT
18637	9680	2	second	second	JJ
18637	9680	3	suggested	suggest	VBN
18637	9680	4	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	9680	5	,	,	,
18637	9680	6	which	which	WDT
18637	9680	7	was	be	VBD
18637	9680	8	urged	urge	VBN
18637	9680	9	at	at	IN
18637	9680	10	tremendous	tremendous	JJ
18637	9680	11	length	length	NN
18637	9680	12	by	by	IN
18637	9680	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	9680	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9680	15	White	White	NNP
18637	9680	16	in	in	IN
18637	9680	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9680	18	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	9680	19	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9680	20	for	for	IN
18637	9680	21	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9680	22	and	and	CC
18637	9680	23	three	three	CD
18637	9680	24	other	other	JJ
18637	9680	25	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	9680	26	,	,	,
18637	9680	27	in	in	IN
18637	9680	28	Downes	Downes	NNP
18637	9680	29	_	_	NNP
18637	9680	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	9680	31	_	_	NNP
18637	9680	32	Bidwell	Bidwell	NNP
18637	9680	33	,	,	,
18637	9680	34	182	182	CD
18637	9680	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9680	36	244	244	CD
18637	9680	37	,	,	,
18637	9680	38	310	310	CD
18637	9680	39	-	-	SYM
18637	9680	40	344	344	CD
18637	9680	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9680	42	1901	1901	CD
18637	9680	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9680	44	,	,	,
18637	9680	45	boils	boil	VBZ
18637	9680	46	down	down	RP
18637	9680	47	simply	simply	RB
18637	9680	48	to	to	IN
18637	9680	49	the	the	DT
18637	9680	50	question	question	NN
18637	9680	51	of	of	IN
18637	9680	52	correct	correct	JJ
18637	9680	53	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	9680	54	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	9680	55	for	for	IN
18637	9680	56	the	the	DT
18637	9680	57	effectuation	effectuation	NN
18637	9680	58	of	of	IN
18637	9680	59	a	a	DT
18637	9680	60	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9680	61	;	;	:
18637	9680	62	and	and	CC
18637	9680	63	much	much	RB
18637	9680	64	the	the	DT
18637	9680	65	same	same	JJ
18637	9680	66	may	may	MD
18637	9680	67	be	be	VB
18637	9680	68	said	say	VBN
18637	9680	69	of	of	IN
18637	9680	70	the	the	DT
18637	9680	71	third	third	JJ
18637	9680	72	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	9680	73	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	9680	74	.	.	.
18637	9681	1	This	this	DT
18637	9681	2	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	9681	3	was	be	VBD
18637	9681	4	first	first	RB
18637	9681	5	suggested	suggest	VBN
18637	9681	6	in	in	IN
18637	9681	7	connection	connection	NN
18637	9681	8	with	with	IN
18637	9681	9	the	the	DT
18637	9681	10	Hague	Hague	NNP
18637	9681	11	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	9681	12	of	of	IN
18637	9681	13	1907	1907	CD
18637	9681	14	providing	provide	VBG
18637	9681	15	for	for	IN
18637	9681	16	an	an	DT
18637	9681	17	International	International	NNP
18637	9681	18	Prize	Prize	NNP
18637	9681	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9681	20	as	as	IN
18637	9681	21	a	a	DT
18637	9681	22	result	result	NN
18637	9681	23	of	of	IN
18637	9681	24	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	9681	25	from	from	IN
18637	9681	26	the	the	DT
18637	9681	27	prize	prize	NN
18637	9681	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	9681	29	of	of	IN
18637	9681	30	belligerents	belligerent	NNS
18637	9681	31	.	.	.
18637	9682	1	To	to	IN
18637	9682	2	this	this	DT
18637	9682	3	arrangement	arrangement	NN
18637	9682	4	President	President	NNP
18637	9682	5	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	9682	6	objected	object	VBD
18637	9682	7	that	that	IN
18637	9682	8	the	the	DT
18637	9682	9	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9682	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	9682	11	making	make	VBG
18637	9682	12	power	power	NN
18637	9682	13	could	could	MD
18637	9682	14	not	not	RB
18637	9682	15	transfer	transfer	VB
18637	9682	16	to	to	IN
18637	9682	17	a	a	DT
18637	9682	18	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	9682	19	not	not	RB
18637	9682	20	known	know	VBN
18637	9682	21	to	to	IN
18637	9682	22	the	the	DT
18637	9682	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9682	24	part	part	NN
18637	9682	25	of	of	IN
18637	9682	26	the	the	DT
18637	9682	27	"	"	``
18637	9682	28	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	9682	29	power	power	NN
18637	9682	30	of	of	IN
18637	9682	31	the	the	DT
18637	9682	32	United	United	NNP
18637	9682	33	States	States	NNP
18637	9682	34	,	,	,
18637	9682	35	"	"	''
18637	9682	36	and	and	CC
18637	9682	37	upon	upon	IN
18637	9682	38	this	this	DT
18637	9682	39	view	view	NN
18637	9682	40	of	of	IN
18637	9682	41	the	the	DT
18637	9682	42	matter	matter	NN
18637	9682	43	dispensation	dispensation	NN
18637	9682	44	was	be	VBD
18637	9682	45	finally	finally	RB
18637	9682	46	granted	grant	VBN
18637	9682	47	the	the	DT
18637	9682	48	United	United	NNP
18637	9682	49	States	States	NNP
18637	9682	50	in	in	IN
18637	9682	51	a	a	DT
18637	9682	52	special	special	JJ
18637	9682	53	protocol	protocol	NN
18637	9682	54	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	9682	55	this	this	DT
18637	9682	56	nation	nation	NN
18637	9682	57	was	be	VBD
18637	9682	58	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	9682	59	,	,	,
18637	9682	60	in	in	IN
18637	9682	61	lieu	lieu	NN
18637	9682	62	of	of	IN
18637	9682	63	granting	grant	VBG
18637	9682	64	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	9682	65	from	from	IN
18637	9682	66	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9682	67	prize	prize	NN
18637	9682	68	courts	court	NNS
18637	9682	69	to	to	IN
18637	9682	70	the	the	DT
18637	9682	71	International	International	NNP
18637	9682	72	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9682	73	,	,	,
18637	9682	74	to	to	TO
18637	9682	75	be	be	VB
18637	9682	76	mulcted	mulct	VBN
18637	9682	77	in	in	IN
18637	9682	78	damages	damage	NNS
18637	9682	79	in	in	IN
18637	9682	80	the	the	DT
18637	9682	81	latter	latter	JJ
18637	9682	82	for	for	IN
18637	9682	83	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
18637	9682	84	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	9682	85	in	in	IN
18637	9682	86	the	the	DT
18637	9682	87	former	former	JJ
18637	9682	88	.	.	.
18637	9683	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9683	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	9683	3	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	9683	4	that	that	IN
18637	9683	5	President	President	NNP
18637	9683	6	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	9683	7	's	's	POS
18637	9683	8	position	position	NN
18637	9683	9	was	be	VBD
18637	9683	10	fallacious	fallacious	JJ
18637	9683	11	,	,	,
18637	9683	12	for	for	IN
18637	9683	13	the	the	DT
18637	9683	14	simple	simple	JJ
18637	9683	15	reason	reason	NN
18637	9683	16	that	that	IN
18637	9683	17	not	not	RB
18637	9683	18	even	even	RB
18637	9683	19	the	the	DT
18637	9683	20	whole	whole	JJ
18637	9683	21	American	american	JJ
18637	9683	22	nation	nation	NN
18637	9683	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	9683	24	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	9683	25	to	to	TO
18637	9683	26	judge	judge	VB
18637	9683	27	finally	finally	RB
18637	9683	28	of	of	IN
18637	9683	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9683	30	rights	right	NNS
18637	9683	31	or	or	CC
18637	9683	32	of	of	IN
18637	9683	33	those	those	DT
18637	9683	34	of	of	IN
18637	9683	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9683	36	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	9683	37	under	under	IN
18637	9683	38	the	the	DT
18637	9683	39	law	law	NN
18637	9683	40	which	which	WDT
18637	9683	41	binds	bind	VBZ
18637	9683	42	all	all	DT
18637	9683	43	nations	nation	NNS
18637	9683	44	and	and	CC
18637	9683	45	determines	determine	VBZ
18637	9683	46	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9683	47	rights	right	NNS
18637	9683	48	;	;	:
18637	9683	49	and	and	CC
18637	9683	50	that	that	IN
18637	9683	51	,	,	,
18637	9683	52	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	9683	53	,	,	,
18637	9683	54	the	the	DT
18637	9683	55	whole	whole	JJ
18637	9683	56	American	american	JJ
18637	9683	57	nation	nation	NN
18637	9683	58	never	never	RB
18637	9683	59	had	have	VBD
18637	9683	60	any	any	DT
18637	9683	61	authority	authority	NN
18637	9683	62	to	to	TO
18637	9683	63	create	create	VB
18637	9683	64	a	a	DT
18637	9683	65	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	9683	66	power	power	NN
18637	9683	67	vested	vest	VBN
18637	9683	68	with	with	IN
18637	9683	69	any	any	DT
18637	9683	70	such	such	JJ
18637	9683	71	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	9683	72	.	.	.
18637	9684	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9684	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9684	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9684	4	Edye	Edye	NNP
18637	9684	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9684	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9684	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9684	8	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	9684	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9684	10	Head	Head	NNP
18637	9684	11	Money	Money	NNP
18637	9684	12	Cases	case	NNS
18637	9684	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9684	14	,	,	,
18637	9684	15	112	112	CD
18637	9684	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9684	17	580	580	CD
18637	9684	18	,	,	,
18637	9684	19	598	598	CD
18637	9684	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9684	21	1884	1884	CD
18637	9684	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9684	23	.	.	.
18637	9685	1	The	the	DT
18637	9685	2	law	law	NN
18637	9685	3	of	of	IN
18637	9685	4	nations	nation	NNS
18637	9685	5	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	9685	6	of	of	IN
18637	9685	7	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9685	8	to	to	TO
18637	9685	9	presuppose	presuppose	VB
18637	9685	10	a	a	DT
18637	9685	11	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	9685	12	of	of	IN
18637	9685	13	nations	nation	NNS
18637	9685	14	with	with	IN
18637	9685	15	coextensive	coextensive	JJ
18637	9685	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	9685	17	.	.	.
18637	9686	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	9686	2	there	there	EX
18637	9686	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	9686	4	no	no	DT
18637	9686	5	reason	reason	NN
18637	9686	6	why	why	WRB
18637	9686	7	a	a	DT
18637	9686	8	completely	completely	RB
18637	9686	9	independent	independent	JJ
18637	9686	10	nation	nation	NN
18637	9686	11	like	like	IN
18637	9686	12	the	the	DT
18637	9686	13	United	United	NNP
18637	9686	14	States	States	NNP
18637	9686	15	may	may	MD
18637	9686	16	not	not	RB
18637	9686	17	consent	consent	VB
18637	9686	18	to	to	TO
18637	9686	19	be	be	VB
18637	9686	20	bound	bind	VBN
18637	9686	21	by	by	IN
18637	9686	22	the	the	DT
18637	9686	23	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	9686	24	of	of	IN
18637	9686	25	such	such	PDT
18637	9686	26	a	a	DT
18637	9686	27	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	9686	28	without	without	IN
18637	9686	29	any	any	DT
18637	9686	30	derogation	derogation	NN
18637	9686	31	from	from	IN
18637	9686	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9686	33	rightful	rightful	JJ
18637	9686	34	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	9686	35	.	.	.
18637	9687	1	And	and	CC
18637	9687	2	if	if	IN
18637	9687	3	"	"	``
18637	9687	4	the	the	DT
18637	9687	5	authority	authority	NN
18637	9687	6	of	of	IN
18637	9687	7	the	the	DT
18637	9687	8	United	United	NNP
18637	9687	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9687	10	"	"	''
18637	9687	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	9687	12	the	the	DT
18637	9687	13	authority	authority	NN
18637	9687	14	of	of	IN
18637	9687	15	the	the	DT
18637	9687	16	nation	nation	NN
18637	9687	17	in	in	IN
18637	9687	18	the	the	DT
18637	9687	19	field	field	NN
18637	9687	20	of	of	IN
18637	9687	21	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9687	22	relations	relation	NNS
18637	9687	23	--	--	:
18637	9687	24	if	if	IN
18637	9687	25	the	the	DT
18637	9687	26	National	National	NNP
18637	9687	27	Government	Government	NNP
18637	9687	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	9687	29	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	9687	30	powers	power	NNS
18637	9687	31	coextensive	coextensive	JJ
18637	9687	32	with	with	IN
18637	9687	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9687	34	international	international	JJ
18637	9687	35	responsibilities	responsibility	NNS
18637	9687	36	--	--	:
18637	9687	37	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9687	38	must	must	MD
18637	9687	39	conclude	conclude	VB
18637	9687	40	that	that	IN
18637	9687	41	such	such	JJ
18637	9687	42	consent	consent	NN
18637	9687	43	can	can	MD
18637	9687	44	be	be	VB
18637	9687	45	validly	validly	RB
18637	9687	46	given	give	VBN
18637	9687	47	through	through	IN
18637	9687	48	the	the	DT
18637	9687	49	existing	exist	VBG
18637	9687	50	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	9687	51	-	-	HYPH
18637	9687	52	making	make	VBG
18637	9687	53	power	power	NN
18637	9687	54	.	.	.
18637	9688	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9688	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9688	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9688	4	Favoring	Favoring	NNP
18637	9688	5	Membership	Membership	NNP
18637	9688	6	of	of	IN
18637	9688	7	the	the	DT
18637	9688	8	United	United	NNP
18637	9688	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9688	10	in	in	IN
18637	9688	11	the	the	DT
18637	9688	12	Permanent	Permanent	NNP
18637	9688	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9688	14	of	of	IN
18637	9688	15	International	International	NNP
18637	9688	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9688	17	,	,	,
18637	9688	18	H.	H.	NNP
18637	9688	19	Rept	Rept	NNP
18637	9688	20	.	.	.
18637	9689	1	1569	1569	CD
18637	9689	2	,	,	,
18637	9689	3	68th	68th	NN
18637	9689	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	9689	5	.	.	NNP
18637	9689	6	,	,	,
18637	9689	7	2d	2d	CD
18637	9689	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	9689	9	.	.	.
18637	9690	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9690	2	208	208	CD
18637	9690	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9690	4	5	5	CD
18637	9690	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	9690	6	.	.	.
18637	9691	1	1	1	CD
18637	9691	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9691	3	1831	1831	CD
18637	9691	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9691	5	.	.	.
18637	9692	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9692	2	209	209	CD
18637	9692	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9692	4	6	6	CD
18637	9692	5	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	9692	6	.	.	.
18637	9693	1	515	515	CD
18637	9693	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9693	3	1832	1832	CD
18637	9693	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9693	5	.	.	.
18637	9694	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9694	2	210	210	CD
18637	9694	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9694	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9694	5	.	.	.
18637	9695	1	558	558	CD
18637	9695	2	.	.	.
18637	9696	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9696	2	211	211	CD
18637	9696	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9696	4	Holden	Holden	NNP
18637	9696	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9696	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9696	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9696	8	Joy	Joy	NNP
18637	9696	9	,	,	,
18637	9696	10	17	17	CD
18637	9696	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9696	12	.	.	.
18637	9697	1	211	211	CD
18637	9697	2	,	,	,
18637	9697	3	242	242	CD
18637	9697	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9697	5	1872	1872	CD
18637	9697	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9697	7	;	;	:
18637	9697	8	United	United	NNP
18637	9697	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9697	10	_	_	NNP
18637	9697	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	9697	12	_	_	NNP
18637	9697	13	43	43	CD
18637	9697	14	Gallons	Gallons	NNPS
18637	9697	15	of	of	IN
18637	9697	16	Whiskey	Whiskey	NNP
18637	9697	17	,	,	,
18637	9697	18	etc	etc	FW
18637	9697	19	.	.	NN
18637	9697	20	,	,	,
18637	9697	21	93	93	CD
18637	9697	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9697	23	188	188	CD
18637	9697	24	,	,	,
18637	9697	25	192	192	CD
18637	9697	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9697	27	1876	1876	CD
18637	9697	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9697	29	;	;	:
18637	9697	30	Dick	Dick	NNP
18637	9697	31	_	_	NNP
18637	9697	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	9697	33	_	_	NNP
18637	9697	34	United	United	NNP
18637	9697	35	States	States	NNP
18637	9697	36	,	,	,
18637	9697	37	208	208	CD
18637	9697	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9697	39	340	340	CD
18637	9697	40	,	,	,
18637	9697	41	355	355	CD
18637	9697	42	-	-	SYM
18637	9697	43	356	356	CD
18637	9697	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9697	45	1908	1908	CD
18637	9697	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9697	47	.	.	.
18637	9698	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9698	2	212	212	CD
18637	9698	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9698	4	The	the	DT
18637	9698	5	New	New	NNP
18637	9698	6	York	York	NNP
18637	9698	7	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	9698	8	,	,	,
18637	9698	9	5	5	CD
18637	9698	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9698	11	.	.	.
18637	9699	1	761	761	CD
18637	9699	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9699	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	9699	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9699	5	.	.	.
18637	9700	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9700	2	213	213	CD
18637	9700	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9700	4	The	the	DT
18637	9700	5	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	9700	6	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	9700	7	,	,	,
18637	9700	8	5	5	CD
18637	9700	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9700	10	.	.	.
18637	9701	1	737	737	CD
18637	9701	2	,	,	,
18637	9701	3	757	757	CD
18637	9701	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9701	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	9701	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9701	7	.	.	.
18637	9702	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9702	2	214	214	CD
18637	9702	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9702	4	United	United	NNP
18637	9702	5	States	States	NNP
18637	9702	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9702	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9702	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9702	9	43	43	CD
18637	9702	10	Gallons	Gallons	NNPS
18637	9702	11	of	of	IN
18637	9702	12	Whiskey	Whiskey	NNP
18637	9702	13	,	,	,
18637	9702	14	etc	etc	FW
18637	9702	15	.	.	NN
18637	9702	16	,	,	,
18637	9702	17	93	93	CD
18637	9702	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9702	19	188	188	CD
18637	9702	20	,	,	,
18637	9702	21	196	196	CD
18637	9702	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9702	23	1876	1876	CD
18637	9702	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9702	25	.	.	.
18637	9703	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9703	2	215	215	CD
18637	9703	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9703	4	The	the	DT
18637	9703	5	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	9703	6	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	9703	7	,	,	,
18637	9703	8	11	11	CD
18637	9703	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9703	10	.	.	.
18637	9704	1	616	616	CD
18637	9704	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9704	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	9704	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9704	5	.	.	.
18637	9705	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9705	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9705	3	also	also	RB
18637	9705	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9705	5	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	9705	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9705	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9705	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9705	9	Race	Race	NNP
18637	9705	10	Horse	Horse	NNP
18637	9705	11	,	,	,
18637	9705	12	163	163	CD
18637	9705	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9705	14	504	504	CD
18637	9705	15	,	,	,
18637	9705	16	511	511	CD
18637	9705	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9705	18	1896	1896	CD
18637	9705	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9705	20	;	;	:
18637	9705	21	and	and	CC
18637	9705	22	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	9705	23	_	_	NNP
18637	9705	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	9705	25	_	_	NNP
18637	9705	26	.	.	.
18637	9706	1	Gay	Gay	NNP
18637	9706	2	,	,	,
18637	9706	3	169	169	CD
18637	9706	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9706	5	264	264	CD
18637	9706	6	,	,	,
18637	9706	7	270	270	CD
18637	9706	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9706	9	1898	1898	CD
18637	9706	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9706	11	.	.	.
18637	9707	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9707	2	216	216	CD
18637	9707	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9707	4	16	16	CD
18637	9707	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9707	6	.	.	.
18637	9708	1	544	544	CD
18637	9708	2	,	,	,
18637	9708	3	566	566	CD
18637	9708	4	;	;	:
18637	9708	5	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	9709	1	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	9709	2	§	â§	NN
18637	9709	3	2079	2079	CD
18637	9709	4	.	.	.
18637	9710	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9710	2	217	217	CD
18637	9710	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9710	4	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	9710	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9710	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9710	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9710	8	Race	Race	NNP
18637	9710	9	Horse	Horse	NNP
18637	9710	10	,	,	,
18637	9710	11	163	163	CD
18637	9710	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9710	13	504	504	CD
18637	9710	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9710	15	1896	1896	CD
18637	9710	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9710	17	.	.	.
18637	9711	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9711	2	218	218	CD
18637	9711	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9711	4	Lone	Lone	NNP
18637	9711	5	Wolf	Wolf	NNP
18637	9711	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9711	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9711	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9711	9	Hitchcock	Hitchcock	NNP
18637	9711	10	,	,	,
18637	9711	11	187	187	CD
18637	9711	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9711	13	553	553	CD
18637	9711	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9711	15	1903	1903	CD
18637	9711	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9711	17	.	.	.
18637	9712	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9712	2	219	219	CD
18637	9712	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9712	4	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	9712	5	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	9712	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9712	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9712	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9712	9	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	9712	10	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	9712	11	R.	R.	NNP
18637	9712	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	9712	13	,	,	,
18637	9712	14	135	135	CD
18637	9712	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9712	16	641	641	CD
18637	9712	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9712	18	1890	1890	CD
18637	9712	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9712	20	.	.	.
18637	9713	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9713	2	220	220	CD
18637	9713	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9713	4	The	the	DT
18637	9713	5	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	9713	6	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	9713	7	,	,	,
18637	9713	8	11	11	CD
18637	9713	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9713	10	.	.	.
18637	9714	1	616	616	CD
18637	9714	2	,	,	,
18637	9714	3	621	621	CD
18637	9714	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9714	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	9714	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9714	7	.	.	.
18637	9715	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9715	2	221	221	CD
18637	9715	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9715	4	Choate	Choate	NNP
18637	9715	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9715	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9715	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9715	8	Trapp	Trapp	NNP
18637	9715	9	,	,	,
18637	9715	10	224	224	CD
18637	9715	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9715	12	665	665	CD
18637	9715	13	,	,	,
18637	9715	14	677	677	CD
18637	9715	15	-	-	SYM
18637	9715	16	678	678	CD
18637	9715	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9715	18	1912	1912	CD
18637	9715	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9715	20	;	;	:
18637	9715	21	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	9715	22	_	_	NNP
18637	9715	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	9715	24	_	_	NNP
18637	9715	25	Meehan	Meehan	NNP
18637	9715	26	,	,	,
18637	9715	27	175	175	CD
18637	9715	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9715	29	1	1	CD
18637	9715	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9715	31	1899	1899	CD
18637	9715	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9715	33	.	.	.
18637	9716	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9716	2	222	222	CD
18637	9716	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9716	4	For	for	IN
18637	9716	5	an	an	DT
18637	9716	6	effort	effort	NN
18637	9716	7	to	to	TO
18637	9716	8	distinguish	distinguish	VB
18637	9716	9	"	"	``
18637	9716	10	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9716	11	,	,	,
18637	9716	12	"	"	''
18637	9716	13	"	"	``
18637	9716	14	compacts	compact	NNS
18637	9716	15	,	,	,
18637	9716	16	"	"	''
18637	9716	17	"	"	``
18637	9716	18	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	9716	19	,	,	,
18637	9716	20	"	"	''
18637	9716	21	"	"	``
18637	9716	22	conventions	convention	NNS
18637	9716	23	,	,	,
18637	9716	24	"	"	''
18637	9716	25	etc	etc	FW
18637	9716	26	.	.	.
18637	9716	27	,	,	,
18637	9716	28	_	_	NNP
18637	9716	29	see	see	VBP
18637	9716	30	_	_	NNP
18637	9716	31	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	9716	32	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9716	33	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	9716	34	's	's	POS
18637	9716	35	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9716	36	in	in	IN
18637	9716	37	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	9716	38	_	_	NNP
18637	9716	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	9716	40	_	_	NNP
18637	9716	41	Jennison	Jennison	NNP
18637	9716	42	,	,	,
18637	9716	43	14	14	CD
18637	9716	44	Pet	pet	NN
18637	9716	45	.	.	.
18637	9717	1	540	540	CD
18637	9717	2	,	,	,
18637	9717	3	570	570	CD
18637	9717	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9717	5	572	572	CD
18637	9717	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9717	7	1840	1840	CD
18637	9717	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9717	9	.	.	.
18637	9718	1	Vattel	Vattel	NNP
18637	9718	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	9718	3	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	9718	4	's	's	POS
18637	9718	5	chief	chief	JJ
18637	9718	6	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	9718	7	.	.	.
18637	9719	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9719	2	223	223	CD
18637	9719	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9719	4	Story	Story	NNP
18637	9719	5	,	,	,
18637	9719	6	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	9719	7	.	.	.
18637	9720	1	§	§	NNP
18637	9720	2	1403	1403	CD
18637	9720	3	.	.	.
18637	9721	1	The	the	DT
18637	9721	2	President	President	NNP
18637	9721	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	9721	4	the	the	DT
18637	9721	5	power	power	NN
18637	9721	6	in	in	IN
18637	9721	7	the	the	DT
18637	9721	8	absence	absence	NN
18637	9721	9	of	of	IN
18637	9721	10	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	9721	11	by	by	IN
18637	9721	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9721	13	,	,	,
18637	9721	14	to	to	TO
18637	9721	15	control	control	VB
18637	9721	16	the	the	DT
18637	9721	17	landing	landing	NN
18637	9721	18	of	of	IN
18637	9721	19	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9721	20	cables	cable	NNS
18637	9721	21	on	on	IN
18637	9721	22	the	the	DT
18637	9721	23	shores	shore	NNS
18637	9721	24	of	of	IN
18637	9721	25	the	the	DT
18637	9721	26	United	United	NNP
18637	9721	27	States	States	NNP
18637	9721	28	,	,	,
18637	9721	29	22	22	CD
18637	9721	30	Op	op	NN
18637	9721	31	.	.	.
18637	9722	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9722	2	.	.	.
18637	9723	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9723	2	13	13	CD
18637	9723	3	and	and	CC
18637	9723	4	408	408	CD
18637	9723	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9723	6	1898	1898	CD
18637	9723	7	,	,	,
18637	9723	8	1899	1899	CD
18637	9723	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9723	10	.	.	.
18637	9724	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9724	2	224	224	CD
18637	9724	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9724	4	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	9724	5	,	,	,
18637	9724	6	Treaties	Treaties	NNP
18637	9724	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9724	8	2d	2d	NNP
18637	9724	9	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9724	10	.	.	.
18637	9724	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9725	1	Chap	Chap	NNP
18637	9725	2	.	.	.
18637	9726	1	VIII	VIII	NNP
18637	9726	2	.	.	.
18637	9727	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9727	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9727	3	also	also	RB
18637	9727	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9727	5	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	9727	6	,	,	,
18637	9727	7	International	International	NNP
18637	9727	8	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	9727	9	Agreements	Agreements	NNP
18637	9727	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9727	11	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	9727	12	University	University	NNP
18637	9727	13	Press	Press	NNP
18637	9727	14	,	,	,
18637	9727	15	1941	1941	CD
18637	9727	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9727	17	,	,	,
18637	9727	18	Chaps	Chaps	NNP
18637	9727	19	.	.	.
18637	9728	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9728	2	and	and	CC
18637	9728	3	II	II	NNP
18637	9728	4	.	.	.
18637	9729	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9729	2	225	225	CD
18637	9729	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9729	4	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	9729	5	,	,	,
18637	9729	6	102	102	CD
18637	9729	7	;	;	:
18637	9729	8	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	9729	9	,	,	,
18637	9729	10	49	49	CD
18637	9729	11	-	-	SYM
18637	9729	12	50	50	CD
18637	9729	13	.	.	.
18637	9730	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9730	2	226	226	CD
18637	9730	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9730	4	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	9730	5	,	,	,
18637	9730	6	104	104	CD
18637	9730	7	-	-	SYM
18637	9730	8	106	106	CD
18637	9730	9	;	;	:
18637	9730	10	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	9730	11	,	,	,
18637	9730	12	81	81	CD
18637	9730	13	-	-	SYM
18637	9730	14	82	82	CD
18637	9730	15	.	.	.
18637	9731	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9731	2	227	227	CD
18637	9731	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9731	4	Tucker	Tucker	NNP
18637	9731	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9731	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9731	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9731	8	Alexandroff	Alexandroff	NNP
18637	9731	9	,	,	,
18637	9731	10	183	183	CD
18637	9731	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9731	12	424	424	CD
18637	9731	13	,	,	,
18637	9731	14	435	435	CD
18637	9731	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9731	16	1902	1902	CD
18637	9731	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9731	18	.	.	.
18637	9732	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9732	2	228	228	CD
18637	9732	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9732	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9732	5	.	.	.
18637	9733	1	467	467	CD
18637	9733	2	.	.	.
18637	9734	1	The	the	DT
18637	9734	2	first	first	JJ
18637	9734	3	of	of	IN
18637	9734	4	these	these	DT
18637	9734	5	conventions	convention	NNS
18637	9734	6	,	,	,
18637	9734	7	signed	sign	VBD
18637	9734	8	July	July	NNP
18637	9734	9	29	29	CD
18637	9734	10	,	,	,
18637	9734	11	1882	1882	CD
18637	9734	12	,	,	,
18637	9734	13	had	have	VBD
18637	9734	14	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	9734	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9734	16	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	9734	17	in	in	IN
18637	9734	18	very	very	RB
18637	9734	19	positive	positive	JJ
18637	9734	20	terms	term	NNS
18637	9734	21	.	.	.
18637	9735	1	"	"	``
18637	9735	2	The	the	DT
18637	9735	3	power	power	NN
18637	9735	4	to	to	TO
18637	9735	5	make	make	VB
18637	9735	6	and	and	CC
18637	9735	7	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	9735	8	such	such	PDT
18637	9735	9	a	a	DT
18637	9735	10	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	9735	11	convention	convention	NN
18637	9735	12	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	9735	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9735	14	own	own	JJ
18637	9735	15	territory	territory	NN
18637	9735	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	9735	17	a	a	DT
18637	9735	18	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	9735	19	incident	incident	NN
18637	9735	20	to	to	IN
18637	9735	21	every	every	DT
18637	9735	22	national	national	JJ
18637	9735	23	government	government	NN
18637	9735	24	,	,	,
18637	9735	25	and	and	CC
18637	9735	26	adheres	adhere	NNS
18637	9735	27	where	where	WRB
18637	9735	28	the	the	DT
18637	9735	29	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9735	30	power	power	NN
18637	9735	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	9735	32	vested	vest	VBN
18637	9735	33	.	.	.
18637	9736	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	9736	2	conventions	convention	NNS
18637	9736	3	are	be	VBP
18637	9736	4	not	not	RB
18637	9736	5	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9736	6	within	within	IN
18637	9736	7	the	the	DT
18637	9736	8	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	9736	9	of	of	IN
18637	9736	10	the	the	DT
18637	9736	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9736	12	,	,	,
18637	9736	13	and	and	CC
18637	9736	14	,	,	,
18637	9736	15	as	as	IN
18637	9736	16	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9736	17	,	,	,
18637	9736	18	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	9736	19	law	law	NNP
18637	9736	20	of	of	IN
18637	9736	21	the	the	DT
18637	9736	22	land	land	NN
18637	9736	23	,	,	,
18637	9736	24	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	9736	25	on	on	IN
18637	9736	26	the	the	DT
18637	9736	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	9736	28	,	,	,
18637	9736	29	but	but	CC
18637	9736	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9736	31	are	be	VBP
18637	9736	32	provisional	provisional	JJ
18637	9736	33	arrangements	arrangement	NNS
18637	9736	34	,	,	,
18637	9736	35	rendered	render	VBN
18637	9736	36	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	9736	37	by	by	IN
18637	9736	38	national	national	JJ
18637	9736	39	differences	difference	NNS
18637	9736	40	involving	involve	VBG
18637	9736	41	the	the	DT
18637	9736	42	faith	faith	NN
18637	9736	43	of	of	IN
18637	9736	44	the	the	DT
18637	9736	45	nation	nation	NN
18637	9736	46	and	and	CC
18637	9736	47	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	9736	48	to	to	IN
18637	9736	49	the	the	DT
18637	9736	50	respect	respect	NN
18637	9736	51	of	of	IN
18637	9736	52	the	the	DT
18637	9736	53	courts	court	NNS
18637	9736	54	.	.	.
18637	9737	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9737	2	are	be	VBP
18637	9737	3	not	not	RB
18637	9737	4	a	a	DT
18637	9737	5	casting	casting	NN
18637	9737	6	of	of	IN
18637	9737	7	the	the	DT
18637	9737	8	national	national	JJ
18637	9737	9	will	will	NN
18637	9737	10	into	into	IN
18637	9737	11	the	the	DT
18637	9737	12	firm	firm	JJ
18637	9737	13	and	and	CC
18637	9737	14	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	9737	15	condition	condition	NN
18637	9737	16	of	of	IN
18637	9737	17	law	law	NN
18637	9737	18	,	,	,
18637	9737	19	and	and	CC
18637	9737	20	yet	yet	RB
18637	9737	21	in	in	IN
18637	9737	22	some	some	DT
18637	9737	23	sort	sort	NN
18637	9737	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9737	25	are	be	VBP
18637	9737	26	for	for	IN
18637	9737	27	the	the	DT
18637	9737	28	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	9737	29	an	an	DT
18637	9737	30	expression	expression	NN
18637	9737	31	of	of	IN
18637	9737	32	the	the	DT
18637	9737	33	will	will	NN
18637	9737	34	of	of	IN
18637	9737	35	the	the	DT
18637	9737	36	people	people	NNS
18637	9737	37	through	through	IN
18637	9737	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9737	39	political	political	JJ
18637	9737	40	organ	organ	NN
18637	9737	41	,	,	,
18637	9737	42	touching	touch	VBG
18637	9737	43	the	the	DT
18637	9737	44	matters	matter	NNS
18637	9737	45	affected	affect	VBN
18637	9737	46	;	;	:
18637	9737	47	and	and	CC
18637	9737	48	to	to	TO
18637	9737	49	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	9737	50	unhappy	unhappy	JJ
18637	9737	51	collision	collision	NN
18637	9737	52	between	between	IN
18637	9737	53	the	the	DT
18637	9737	54	political	political	JJ
18637	9737	55	and	and	CC
18637	9737	56	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	9737	57	branches	branch	NNS
18637	9737	58	of	of	IN
18637	9737	59	the	the	DT
18637	9737	60	government	government	NN
18637	9737	61	,	,	,
18637	9737	62	both	both	DT
18637	9737	63	which	which	WDT
18637	9737	64	are	be	VBP
18637	9737	65	in	in	IN
18637	9737	66	theory	theory	NN
18637	9737	67	inseparably	inseparably	RB
18637	9737	68	all	all	DT
18637	9737	69	one	one	CD
18637	9737	70	,	,	,
18637	9737	71	such	such	PDT
18637	9737	72	an	an	DT
18637	9737	73	expression	expression	NN
18637	9737	74	to	to	IN
18637	9737	75	a	a	DT
18637	9737	76	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	9737	77	limit	limit	NN
18637	9737	78	should	should	MD
18637	9737	79	be	be	VB
18637	9737	80	followed	follow	VBN
18637	9737	81	by	by	IN
18637	9737	82	the	the	DT
18637	9737	83	courts	court	NNS
18637	9737	84	and	and	CC
18637	9737	85	not	not	RB
18637	9737	86	opposed	oppose	VBN
18637	9737	87	,	,	,
18637	9737	88	though	though	IN
18637	9737	89	extending	extend	VBG
18637	9737	90	to	to	IN
18637	9737	91	the	the	DT
18637	9737	92	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	9737	93	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	9737	94	or	or	CC
18637	9737	95	modification	modification	NN
18637	9737	96	of	of	IN
18637	9737	97	the	the	DT
18637	9737	98	operation	operation	NN
18637	9737	99	of	of	IN
18637	9737	100	existing	existing	JJ
18637	9737	101	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	9737	102	.	.	.
18637	9738	1	Just	just	RB
18637	9738	2	as	as	IN
18637	9738	3	here	here	RB
18637	9738	4	,	,	,
18637	9738	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9738	6	think	think	VBP
18637	9738	7	,	,	,
18637	9738	8	this	this	DT
18637	9738	9	particular	particular	JJ
18637	9738	10	convention	convention	NN
18637	9738	11	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	9738	12	San	San	NNP
18637	9738	13	Juan	Juan	NNP
18637	9738	14	should	should	MD
18637	9738	15	be	be	VB
18637	9738	16	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	9738	17	to	to	TO
18637	9738	18	modify	modify	VB
18637	9738	19	for	for	IN
18637	9738	20	the	the	DT
18637	9738	21	time	time	NN
18637	9738	22	being	be	VBG
18637	9738	23	the	the	DT
18637	9738	24	operation	operation	NN
18637	9738	25	of	of	IN
18637	9738	26	the	the	DT
18637	9738	27	organic	organic	JJ
18637	9738	28	act	act	NN
18637	9738	29	of	of	IN
18637	9738	30	this	this	DT
18637	9738	31	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	9738	32	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9738	33	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	9738	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9738	35	so	so	RB
18637	9738	36	far	far	RB
18637	9738	37	forth	forth	RB
18637	9738	38	as	as	IN
18637	9738	39	to	to	TO
18637	9738	40	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	9738	41	to	to	IN
18637	9738	42	the	the	DT
18637	9738	43	extent	extent	NN
18637	9738	44	demanded	demand	VBN
18637	9738	45	by	by	IN
18637	9738	46	the	the	DT
18637	9738	47	political	political	JJ
18637	9738	48	branch	branch	NN
18637	9738	49	of	of	IN
18637	9738	50	the	the	DT
18637	9738	51	government	government	NN
18637	9738	52	of	of	IN
18637	9738	53	the	the	DT
18637	9738	54	United	United	NNP
18637	9738	55	States	States	NNP
18637	9738	56	,	,	,
18637	9738	57	in	in	IN
18637	9738	58	the	the	DT
18637	9738	59	interest	interest	NN
18637	9738	60	of	of	IN
18637	9738	61	peace	peace	NN
18637	9738	62	,	,	,
18637	9738	63	all	all	DT
18637	9738	64	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	9738	65	interference	interference	NN
18637	9738	66	for	for	IN
18637	9738	67	the	the	DT
18637	9738	68	government	government	NN
18637	9738	69	of	of	IN
18637	9738	70	that	that	DT
18637	9738	71	island	island	NN
18637	9738	72	.	.	.
18637	9738	73	"	"	''
18637	9739	1	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	9739	2	,	,	,
18637	9739	3	The	the	DT
18637	9739	4	Control	Control	NNP
18637	9739	5	of	of	IN
18637	9739	6	American	American	NNP
18637	9739	7	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	9739	8	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	9739	9	,	,	,
18637	9739	10	239	239	CD
18637	9739	11	,	,	,
18637	9739	12	quoting	quote	VBG
18637	9739	13	Watts	Watts	NNP
18637	9739	14	_	_	NNP
18637	9739	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	9739	16	_	_	NNP
18637	9739	17	United	United	NNP
18637	9739	18	States	States	NNP
18637	9739	19	,	,	,
18637	9739	20	1	1	CD
18637	9739	21	Wash.	Washington	NNP
18637	9740	1	Terr	Terr	NNP
18637	9740	2	.	.	NNP
18637	9740	3	,	,	,
18637	9740	4	288	288	CD
18637	9740	5	,	,	,
18637	9740	6	294	294	CD
18637	9740	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9740	8	1870	1870	CD
18637	9740	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9740	10	.	.	.
18637	9741	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9741	2	229	229	CD
18637	9741	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9741	4	Quincy	Quincy	NNP
18637	9741	5	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	9741	6	,	,	,
18637	9741	7	The	the	DT
18637	9741	8	Control	Control	NNP
18637	9741	9	of	of	IN
18637	9741	10	American	American	NNP
18637	9741	11	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	9741	12	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	9741	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9741	14	New	New	NNP
18637	9741	15	York	York	NNP
18637	9741	16	,	,	,
18637	9741	17	1922	1922	CD
18637	9741	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9741	19	,	,	,
18637	9741	20	245	245	CD
18637	9741	21	.	.	.
18637	9742	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9742	2	230	230	CD
18637	9742	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9742	4	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	9742	5	,	,	,
18637	9742	6	103	103	CD
18637	9742	7	-	-	SYM
18637	9742	8	104	104	CD
18637	9742	9	.	.	.
18637	9743	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9743	2	231	231	CD
18637	9743	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9743	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9743	5	.	.	.
18637	9744	1	104	104	CD
18637	9744	2	.	.	.
18637	9745	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9745	2	232	232	CD
18637	9745	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9745	4	Willoughby	Willoughby	NNP
18637	9745	5	,	,	,
18637	9745	6	On	on	IN
18637	9745	7	the	the	DT
18637	9745	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9745	9	,	,	,
18637	9745	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9745	11	,	,	,
18637	9745	12	539	539	CD
18637	9745	13	.	.	.
18637	9746	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9746	2	233	233	CD
18637	9746	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9746	4	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	9746	5	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	9746	6	,	,	,
18637	9746	7	International	International	NNP
18637	9746	8	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	9746	9	Agreements	Agreements	NNP
18637	9746	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9746	11	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	9746	12	University	University	NNP
18637	9746	13	Press	Press	NNP
18637	9746	14	,	,	,
18637	9746	15	1941	1941	CD
18637	9746	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9746	17	,	,	,
18637	9746	18	98	98	CD
18637	9746	19	.	.	.
18637	9747	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9747	2	234	234	CD
18637	9747	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9747	4	Tyler	Tyler	NNP
18637	9747	5	Dennett	Dennett	NNP
18637	9747	6	,	,	,
18637	9747	7	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	9747	8	and	and	CC
18637	9747	9	the	the	DT
18637	9747	10	Russo	russo	JJ
18637	9747	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	9747	12	Japanese	Japanese	NNP
18637	9747	13	War	War	NNP
18637	9747	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9747	15	New	New	NNP
18637	9747	16	York	York	NNP
18637	9747	17	,	,	,
18637	9747	18	1925	1925	CD
18637	9747	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9747	20	,	,	,
18637	9747	21	112	112	CD
18637	9747	22	-	-	SYM
18637	9747	23	114	114	CD
18637	9747	24	.	.	.
18637	9748	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9748	2	235	235	CD
18637	9748	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9748	4	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	9748	5	,	,	,
18637	9748	6	International	International	NNP
18637	9748	7	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	9748	8	Agreements	Agreements	NNPS
18637	9748	9	,	,	,
18637	9748	10	98	98	CD
18637	9748	11	-	-	SYM
18637	9748	12	99	99	CD
18637	9748	13	.	.	.
18637	9749	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9749	2	236	236	CD
18637	9749	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9749	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9749	5	.	.	.
18637	9750	1	99	99	CD
18637	9750	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9750	3	100	100	CD
18637	9750	4	.	.	.
18637	9751	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9751	2	237	237	CD
18637	9751	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9751	4	Willoughby	Willoughby	NNP
18637	9751	5	,	,	,
18637	9751	6	On	on	IN
18637	9751	7	the	the	DT
18637	9751	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9751	9	,	,	,
18637	9751	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9751	11	,	,	,
18637	9751	12	547	547	CD
18637	9751	13	.	.	.
18637	9752	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9752	2	238	238	CD
18637	9752	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9752	4	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	9752	5	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	9752	6	,	,	,
18637	9752	7	International	International	NNP
18637	9752	8	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	9752	9	Agreements	Agreements	NNP
18637	9752	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9752	11	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	9752	12	University	University	NNP
18637	9752	13	Press	Press	NNP
18637	9752	14	,	,	,
18637	9752	15	1941	1941	CD
18637	9752	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9752	17	,	,	,
18637	9752	18	97	97	CD
18637	9752	19	,	,	,
18637	9752	20	100	100	CD
18637	9752	21	.	.	.
18637	9753	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9753	2	239	239	CD
18637	9753	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9753	4	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	9753	5	,	,	,
18637	9753	6	International	International	NNP
18637	9753	7	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	9753	8	Agreements	Agreements	NNPS
18637	9753	9	,	,	,
18637	9753	10	141	141	CD
18637	9753	11	.	.	.
18637	9754	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9754	2	240	240	CD
18637	9754	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9754	4	301	301	CD
18637	9754	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9754	6	324	324	CD
18637	9754	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9754	8	1937	1937	CD
18637	9754	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9754	10	.	.	.
18637	9755	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9755	2	241	241	CD
18637	9755	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9755	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9755	5	.	.	.
18637	9756	1	330	330	CD
18637	9756	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9756	3	332	332	CD
18637	9756	4	.	.	.
18637	9757	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9757	2	242	242	CD
18637	9757	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9757	4	315	315	CD
18637	9757	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9757	6	203	203	CD
18637	9757	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9757	8	1942	1942	CD
18637	9757	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9757	10	.	.	.
18637	9758	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9758	2	243	243	CD
18637	9758	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9758	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9758	5	.	.	.
18637	9759	1	229	229	CD
18637	9759	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9759	3	230	230	CD
18637	9759	4	.	.	.
18637	9760	1	Citing	cite	VBG
18637	9760	2	The	the	DT
18637	9760	3	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	9760	4	,	,	,
18637	9760	5	No	no	UH
18637	9760	6	.	.	.
18637	9761	1	64	64	CD
18637	9761	2	.	.	.
18637	9762	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9762	2	244	244	CD
18637	9762	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9762	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9762	5	.	.	.
18637	9763	1	230	230	CD
18637	9763	2	.	.	.
18637	9764	1	Citing	Citing	NNP
18637	9764	2	Guaranty	Guaranty	NNP
18637	9764	3	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	9764	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	9764	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9764	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9764	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9764	8	United	United	NNP
18637	9764	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9764	10	,	,	,
18637	9764	11	304	304	CD
18637	9764	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9764	13	126	126	CD
18637	9764	14	,	,	,
18637	9764	15	143	143	CD
18637	9764	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9764	17	1938	1938	CD
18637	9764	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9764	19	.	.	.
18637	9765	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9765	2	245	245	CD
18637	9765	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9765	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9765	5	.	.	.
18637	9766	1	230	230	CD
18637	9766	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9766	3	231	231	CD
18637	9766	4	.	.	.
18637	9767	1	Citing	cite	VBG
18637	9767	2	Nielsen	Nielsen	NNP
18637	9767	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9767	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	9767	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9767	6	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	9767	7	,	,	,
18637	9767	8	279	279	CD
18637	9767	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9767	10	47	47	CD
18637	9767	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9767	12	1929	1929	CD
18637	9767	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9767	14	.	.	.
18637	9768	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9768	2	246	246	CD
18637	9768	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9768	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9768	5	.	.	.
18637	9769	1	231	231	CD
18637	9769	2	.	.	.
18637	9770	1	Citing	cite	VBG
18637	9770	2	Santovincenzo	Santovincenzo	NNP
18637	9770	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9770	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	9770	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9770	6	Egan	Egan	NNP
18637	9770	7	,	,	,
18637	9770	8	284	284	CD
18637	9770	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9770	10	30	30	CD
18637	9770	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9770	12	1931	1931	CD
18637	9770	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9770	14	;	;	:
18637	9770	15	United	United	NNP
18637	9770	16	States	States	NNP
18637	9770	17	_	_	NNP
18637	9770	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	9770	19	_	_	NNP
18637	9770	20	Belmont	Belmont	NNP
18637	9770	21	,	,	,
18637	9770	22	301	301	CD
18637	9770	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9770	24	324	324	CD
18637	9770	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9770	26	1937	1937	CD
18637	9770	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9770	28	.	.	.
18637	9771	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9771	2	247	247	CD
18637	9771	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9771	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9771	5	.	.	.
18637	9772	1	233	233	CD
18637	9772	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	9772	3	234	234	CD
18637	9772	4	.	.	.
18637	9773	1	Citing	cite	VBG
18637	9773	2	Oetjen	Oetjen	NNP
18637	9773	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9773	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	9773	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9773	6	Central	Central	NNP
18637	9773	7	Leather	Leather	NNP
18637	9773	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	9773	9	,	,	,
18637	9773	10	246	246	CD
18637	9773	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9773	12	297	297	CD
18637	9773	13	,	,	,
18637	9773	14	304	304	CD
18637	9773	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9773	16	1918	1918	CD
18637	9773	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9773	18	.	.	.
18637	9774	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9774	2	248	248	CD
18637	9774	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9774	4	315	315	CD
18637	9774	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9774	6	at	at	IN
18637	9774	7	228	228	CD
18637	9774	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	9774	9	234	234	CD
18637	9774	10	_	_	NNP
18637	9774	11	passim	passim	NN
18637	9774	12	_	_	NNP
18637	9774	13	.	.	.
18637	9775	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	9775	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9775	3	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	9775	4	and	and	CC
18637	9775	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9775	6	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	9775	7	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	9775	8	,	,	,
18637	9775	9	chiefly	chiefly	RB
18637	9775	10	on	on	IN
18637	9775	11	the	the	DT
18637	9775	12	question	question	NN
18637	9775	13	of	of	IN
18637	9775	14	the	the	DT
18637	9775	15	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	9775	16	of	of	IN
18637	9775	17	the	the	DT
18637	9775	18	Litvinov	Litvinov	NNP
18637	9775	19	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	9775	20	,	,	,
18637	9775	21	citing	cite	VBG
18637	9775	22	Guaranty	Guaranty	NNP
18637	9775	23	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	9775	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	9775	25	_	_	NNP
18637	9775	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	9775	27	_	_	NNP
18637	9775	28	United	United	NNP
18637	9775	29	States	States	NNP
18637	9775	30	,	,	,
18637	9775	31	Note	note	VBP
18637	9775	32	3	3	CD
18637	9775	33	above	above	RB
18637	9775	34	.	.	.
18637	9776	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9776	2	249	249	CD
18637	9776	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9776	4	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	9776	5	,	,	,
18637	9776	6	p.	p.	NN
18637	9776	7	391	391	CD
18637	9776	8	.	.	.
18637	9777	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9777	2	250	250	CD
18637	9777	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9777	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9777	5	.	.	.
18637	9778	1	391	391	CD
18637	9778	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9778	3	393	393	CD
18637	9778	4	;	;	:
18637	9778	5	United	United	NNP
18637	9778	6	States	States	NNP
18637	9778	7	Department	Department	NNP
18637	9778	8	of	of	IN
18637	9778	9	State	State	NNP
18637	9778	10	Bulletin	Bulletin	NNP
18637	9778	11	,	,	,
18637	9778	12	September	September	NNP
18637	9778	13	7	7	CD
18637	9778	14	,	,	,
18637	9778	15	1940	1940	CD
18637	9778	16	,	,	,
18637	9778	17	pp	pp	NNP
18637	9778	18	.	.	.
18637	9779	1	199	199	CD
18637	9779	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	9779	3	200	200	CD
18637	9779	4	.	.	.
18637	9780	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9780	2	251	251	CD
18637	9780	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9780	4	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	9780	5	,	,	,
18637	9780	6	394	394	CD
18637	9780	7	-	-	SYM
18637	9780	8	403	403	CD
18637	9780	9	;	;	:
18637	9780	10	_	_	NNP
18637	9780	11	cf	cf	NNP
18637	9780	12	.	.	.
18637	9780	13	_	_	NNP
18637	9780	14	The	the	DT
18637	9780	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9780	16	,	,	,
18637	9780	17	article	article	NN
18637	9780	18	IV	IV	NNP
18637	9780	19	,	,	,
18637	9780	20	section	section	NN
18637	9780	21	3	3	CD
18637	9780	22	,	,	,
18637	9780	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	9780	24	2	2	CD
18637	9780	25	.	.	.
18637	9781	1	When	when	WRB
18637	9781	2	President	President	NNP
18637	9781	3	John	John	NNP
18637	9781	4	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	9781	5	signed	sign	VBD
18637	9781	6	a	a	DT
18637	9781	7	deed	deed	NN
18637	9781	8	conveying	convey	VBG
18637	9781	9	property	property	NN
18637	9781	10	for	for	IN
18637	9781	11	a	a	DT
18637	9781	12	legation	legation	NN
18637	9781	13	to	to	IN
18637	9781	14	the	the	DT
18637	9781	15	Queen	Queen	NNP
18637	9781	16	of	of	IN
18637	9781	17	Portugal	Portugal	NNP
18637	9781	18	,	,	,
18637	9781	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9781	20	was	be	VBD
18637	9781	21	informed	inform	VBN
18637	9781	22	by	by	IN
18637	9781	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9781	24	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	9781	25	General	General	NNP
18637	9781	26	that	that	IN
18637	9781	27	only	only	RB
18637	9781	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9781	29	was	be	VBD
18637	9781	30	competent	competent	JJ
18637	9781	31	to	to	TO
18637	9781	32	grant	grant	VB
18637	9781	33	away	away	RP
18637	9781	34	public	public	JJ
18637	9781	35	property	property	NN
18637	9781	36	.	.	.
18637	9782	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9782	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9782	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9782	4	W.B.	W.B.	NNP
18637	9783	1	Bryan	Bryan	NNP
18637	9783	2	,	,	,
18637	9783	3	A	a	DT
18637	9783	4	History	history	NN
18637	9783	5	of	of	IN
18637	9783	6	the	the	DT
18637	9783	7	National	National	NNP
18637	9783	8	Capitol	Capitol	NNP
18637	9783	9	From	from	IN
18637	9783	10	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9783	11	Foundation	Foundation	NNP
18637	9783	12	Through	through	IN
18637	9783	13	the	the	DT
18637	9783	14	Period	Period	NNP
18637	9783	15	of	of	IN
18637	9783	16	the	the	DT
18637	9783	17	Adoption	Adoption	NNP
18637	9783	18	of	of	IN
18637	9783	19	the	the	DT
18637	9783	20	Organic	Organic	NNP
18637	9783	21	Act	Act	NNP
18637	9783	22	,	,	,
18637	9783	23	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9783	24	,	,	,
18637	9783	25	328	328	CD
18637	9783	26	-	-	SYM
18637	9783	27	329	329	CD
18637	9783	28	;	;	:
18637	9783	29	1	1	CD
18637	9783	30	American	American	NNP
18637	9783	31	State	State	NNP
18637	9783	32	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	9783	33	,	,	,
18637	9783	34	Misc	Misc	NNP
18637	9783	35	.	.	NNP
18637	9783	36	,	,	,
18637	9783	37	334	334	CD
18637	9783	38	.	.	.
18637	9784	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9784	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9784	3	also	also	RB
18637	9784	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9784	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	9784	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9784	7	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	9784	8	,	,	,
18637	9784	9	for	for	IN
18637	9784	10	the	the	DT
18637	9784	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9784	12	,	,	,
18637	9784	13	in	in	IN
18637	9784	14	Ashwander	Ashwander	NNP
18637	9784	15	_	_	NNP
18637	9784	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	9784	17	_	_	NNP
18637	9784	18	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	9784	19	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	9784	20	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	9784	21	,	,	,
18637	9784	22	297	297	CD
18637	9784	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9784	24	288	288	CD
18637	9784	25	,	,	,
18637	9784	26	330	330	CD
18637	9784	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9784	28	1936	1936	CD
18637	9784	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9784	30	.	.	.
18637	9785	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9785	2	252	252	CD
18637	9785	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9785	4	4	4	CD
18637	9785	5	State	State	NNP
18637	9785	6	Department	Department	NNP
18637	9785	7	Bulletin	Bulletin	NNP
18637	9785	8	,	,	,
18637	9785	9	April	April	NNP
18637	9785	10	12	12	CD
18637	9785	11	,	,	,
18637	9785	12	1941	1941	CD
18637	9785	13	,	,	,
18637	9785	14	pp	pp	NNP
18637	9785	15	.	.	.
18637	9786	1	443	443	CD
18637	9786	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9786	3	447	447	CD
18637	9786	4	.	.	.
18637	9787	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9787	2	253	253	CD
18637	9787	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9787	4	What	what	WP
18637	9787	5	purports	purport	VBZ
18637	9787	6	to	to	TO
18637	9787	7	be	be	VB
18637	9787	8	the	the	DT
18637	9787	9	correct	correct	JJ
18637	9787	10	text	text	NN
18637	9787	11	of	of	IN
18637	9787	12	these	these	DT
18637	9787	13	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	9787	14	was	be	VBD
18637	9787	15	published	publish	VBN
18637	9787	16	in	in	IN
18637	9787	17	the	the	DT
18637	9787	18	New	New	NNP
18637	9787	19	York	York	NNP
18637	9787	20	Times	Times	NNP
18637	9787	21	of	of	IN
18637	9787	22	March	March	NNP
18637	9787	23	11	11	CD
18637	9787	24	,	,	,
18637	9787	25	1947	1947	CD
18637	9787	26	.	.	.
18637	9788	1	The	the	DT
18637	9788	2	joint	joint	JJ
18637	9788	3	statement	statement	NN
18637	9788	4	by	by	IN
18637	9788	5	the	the	DT
18637	9788	6	United	United	NNP
18637	9788	7	States	States	NNP
18637	9788	8	,	,	,
18637	9788	9	Great	Great	NNP
18637	9788	10	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	9788	11	,	,	,
18637	9788	12	and	and	CC
18637	9788	13	France	France	NNP
18637	9788	14	on	on	IN
18637	9788	15	arms	arm	NNS
18637	9788	16	aid	aid	NN
18637	9788	17	for	for	IN
18637	9788	18	the	the	DT
18637	9788	19	Middle	Middle	NNP
18637	9788	20	East	East	NNP
18637	9788	21	which	which	WDT
18637	9788	22	was	be	VBD
18637	9788	23	released	release	VBN
18637	9788	24	by	by	IN
18637	9788	25	the	the	DT
18637	9788	26	White	White	NNP
18637	9788	27	House	House	NNP
18637	9788	28	on	on	IN
18637	9788	29	May	May	NNP
18637	9788	30	25	25	CD
18637	9788	31	,	,	,
18637	9788	32	1950	1950	CD
18637	9788	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9788	34	_	_	NNP
18637	9788	35	See	See	NNP
18637	9788	36	_	_	NNP
18637	9788	37	A.P.	A.P.	NNP
18637	9789	1	dispatches	dispatch	NNS
18637	9789	2	of	of	IN
18637	9789	3	that	that	DT
18637	9789	4	date	date	NN
18637	9789	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9789	6	bears	bear	VBZ
18637	9789	7	the	the	DT
18637	9789	8	earmarks	earmark	NNS
18637	9789	9	of	of	IN
18637	9789	10	an	an	DT
18637	9789	11	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9789	12	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	9789	13	.	.	.
18637	9790	1	And	and	CC
18637	9790	2	the	the	DT
18637	9790	3	same	same	JJ
18637	9790	4	may	may	MD
18637	9790	5	be	be	VB
18637	9790	6	said	say	VBN
18637	9790	7	of	of	IN
18637	9790	8	the	the	DT
18637	9790	9	following	follow	VBG
18637	9790	10	communique	communique	NN
18637	9790	11	issued	issue	VBN
18637	9790	12	by	by	IN
18637	9790	13	the	the	DT
18637	9790	14	North	North	NNP
18637	9790	15	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	9790	16	Council	Council	NNP
18637	9790	17	at	at	IN
18637	9790	18	the	the	DT
18637	9790	19	close	close	NN
18637	9790	20	of	of	IN
18637	9790	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9790	22	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	9790	23	Session	Session	NNP
18637	9790	24	at	at	IN
18637	9790	25	Brussels	Brussels	NNP
18637	9790	26	on	on	IN
18637	9790	27	December	December	NNP
18637	9790	28	19	19	CD
18637	9790	29	,	,	,
18637	9790	30	1950	1950	CD
18637	9790	31	.	.	.
18637	9791	1	"	"	``
18637	9791	2	The	the	DT
18637	9791	3	North	North	NNP
18637	9791	4	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	9791	5	Council	Council	NNP
18637	9791	6	acting	act	VBG
18637	9791	7	on	on	IN
18637	9791	8	recommendations	recommendation	NNS
18637	9791	9	of	of	IN
18637	9791	10	the	the	DT
18637	9791	11	Defense	Defense	NNP
18637	9791	12	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	9791	13	today	today	NN
18637	9791	14	completed	complete	VBD
18637	9791	15	the	the	DT
18637	9791	16	arrangements	arrangement	NNS
18637	9791	17	initiated	initiate	VBN
18637	9791	18	in	in	IN
18637	9791	19	September	September	NNP
18637	9791	20	last	last	JJ
18637	9791	21	for	for	IN
18637	9791	22	the	the	DT
18637	9791	23	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	9791	24	in	in	IN
18637	9791	25	Europe	Europe	NNP
18637	9791	26	of	of	IN
18637	9791	27	an	an	DT
18637	9791	28	integrated	integrated	JJ
18637	9791	29	force	force	NN
18637	9791	30	under	under	IN
18637	9791	31	centralized	centralized	JJ
18637	9791	32	control	control	NN
18637	9791	33	and	and	CC
18637	9791	34	command	command	NN
18637	9791	35	.	.	.
18637	9792	1	This	this	DT
18637	9792	2	force	force	NN
18637	9792	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	9792	4	to	to	TO
18637	9792	5	be	be	VB
18637	9792	6	composed	compose	VBN
18637	9792	7	of	of	IN
18637	9792	8	contingents	contingent	NNS
18637	9792	9	contributed	contribute	VBN
18637	9792	10	by	by	IN
18637	9792	11	the	the	DT
18637	9792	12	participating	participate	VBG
18637	9792	13	governments	government	NNS
18637	9792	14	.	.	.
18637	9793	1	"	"	``
18637	9793	2	The	the	DT
18637	9793	3	Council	Council	NNP
18637	9793	4	yesterday	yesterday	NN
18637	9793	5	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	9793	6	decided	decide	VBD
18637	9793	7	to	to	TO
18637	9793	8	ask	ask	VB
18637	9793	9	the	the	DT
18637	9793	10	President	President	NNP
18637	9793	11	of	of	IN
18637	9793	12	the	the	DT
18637	9793	13	United	United	NNP
18637	9793	14	States	States	NNP
18637	9793	15	to	to	TO
18637	9793	16	make	make	VB
18637	9793	17	available	available	JJ
18637	9793	18	General	General	NNP
18637	9793	19	of	of	IN
18637	9793	20	the	the	DT
18637	9793	21	Army	Army	NNP
18637	9793	22	Dwight	Dwight	NNP
18637	9793	23	D.	D.	NNP
18637	9793	24	Eisenhower	Eisenhower	NNP
18637	9793	25	to	to	TO
18637	9793	26	serve	serve	VB
18637	9793	27	as	as	IN
18637	9793	28	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	9793	29	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	9793	30	.	.	.
18637	9794	1	Following	follow	VBG
18637	9794	2	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	9794	3	this	this	DT
18637	9794	4	morning	morning	NN
18637	9794	5	of	of	IN
18637	9794	6	a	a	DT
18637	9794	7	message	message	NN
18637	9794	8	from	from	IN
18637	9794	9	the	the	DT
18637	9794	10	President	President	NNP
18637	9794	11	of	of	IN
18637	9794	12	the	the	DT
18637	9794	13	United	United	NNP
18637	9794	14	States	States	NNP
18637	9794	15	that	that	IN
18637	9794	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9794	17	had	have	VBD
18637	9794	18	made	make	VBN
18637	9794	19	General	General	NNP
18637	9794	20	Eisenhower	Eisenhower	NNP
18637	9794	21	available	available	JJ
18637	9794	22	,	,	,
18637	9794	23	the	the	DT
18637	9794	24	Council	Council	NNP
18637	9794	25	appointed	appoint	VBD
18637	9794	26	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9794	27	.	.	.
18637	9795	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9795	2	will	will	MD
18637	9795	3	assume	assume	VB
18637	9795	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9795	5	command	command	NN
18637	9795	6	and	and	CC
18637	9795	7	establish	establish	VB
18637	9795	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9795	9	headquarters	headquarters	NN
18637	9795	10	in	in	IN
18637	9795	11	Europe	Europe	NNP
18637	9795	12	early	early	RB
18637	9795	13	in	in	IN
18637	9795	14	the	the	DT
18637	9795	15	New	New	NNP
18637	9795	16	Year	Year	NNP
18637	9795	17	.	.	.
18637	9796	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9796	2	will	will	MD
18637	9796	3	have	have	VB
18637	9796	4	the	the	DT
18637	9796	5	authority	authority	NN
18637	9796	6	to	to	TO
18637	9796	7	train	train	VB
18637	9796	8	the	the	DT
18637	9796	9	national	national	JJ
18637	9796	10	units	unit	NNS
18637	9796	11	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	9796	12	to	to	IN
18637	9796	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9796	14	command	command	NN
18637	9796	15	and	and	CC
18637	9796	16	to	to	TO
18637	9796	17	organize	organize	VB
18637	9796	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9796	19	into	into	IN
18637	9796	20	an	an	DT
18637	9796	21	effective	effective	JJ
18637	9796	22	integrated	integrate	VBN
18637	9796	23	defense	defense	NN
18637	9796	24	force	force	NN
18637	9796	25	.	.	.
18637	9797	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9797	2	will	will	MD
18637	9797	3	be	be	VB
18637	9797	4	supported	support	VBN
18637	9797	5	by	by	IN
18637	9797	6	an	an	DT
18637	9797	7	international	international	JJ
18637	9797	8	staff	staff	NN
18637	9797	9	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	9797	10	from	from	IN
18637	9797	11	the	the	DT
18637	9797	12	nations	nation	NNS
18637	9797	13	contributing	contribute	VBG
18637	9797	14	to	to	IN
18637	9797	15	the	the	DT
18637	9797	16	force	force	NN
18637	9797	17	.	.	.
18637	9798	1	"	"	``
18637	9798	2	The	the	DT
18637	9798	3	Council	Council	NNP
18637	9798	4	,	,	,
18637	9798	5	desiring	desire	VBG
18637	9798	6	to	to	TO
18637	9798	7	simplify	simplify	VB
18637	9798	8	the	the	DT
18637	9798	9	structure	structure	NN
18637	9798	10	of	of	IN
18637	9798	11	the	the	DT
18637	9798	12	North	North	NNP
18637	9798	13	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	9798	14	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	9798	15	Organization	Organization	NNP
18637	9798	16	in	in	IN
18637	9798	17	order	order	NN
18637	9798	18	to	to	TO
18637	9798	19	make	make	VB
18637	9798	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9798	21	more	more	RBR
18637	9798	22	effective	effective	JJ
18637	9798	23	,	,	,
18637	9798	24	asked	ask	VBD
18637	9798	25	the	the	DT
18637	9798	26	Council	Council	NNP
18637	9798	27	Deputies	Deputies	NNPS
18637	9798	28	to	to	TO
18637	9798	29	initiate	initiate	VB
18637	9798	30	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	9798	31	action	action	NN
18637	9798	32	.	.	.
18637	9799	1	In	in	IN
18637	9799	2	this	this	DT
18637	9799	3	connection	connection	NN
18637	9799	4	the	the	DT
18637	9799	5	Defense	Defense	NNP
18637	9799	6	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	9799	7	,	,	,
18637	9799	8	meeting	meet	VBG
18637	9799	9	separately	separately	RB
18637	9799	10	on	on	IN
18637	9799	11	December	December	NNP
18637	9799	12	18th	18th	NN
18637	9799	13	,	,	,
18637	9799	14	had	have	VBD
18637	9799	15	already	already	RB
18637	9799	16	taken	take	VBN
18637	9799	17	action	action	NN
18637	9799	18	to	to	TO
18637	9799	19	establish	establish	VB
18637	9799	20	a	a	DT
18637	9799	21	defense	defense	NN
18637	9799	22	production	production	NN
18637	9799	23	board	board	NN
18637	9799	24	with	with	IN
18637	9799	25	greater	great	JJR
18637	9799	26	powers	power	NNS
18637	9799	27	than	than	IN
18637	9799	28	those	those	DT
18637	9799	29	of	of	IN
18637	9799	30	the	the	DT
18637	9799	31	Military	Military	NNP
18637	9799	32	Production	Production	NNP
18637	9799	33	and	and	CC
18637	9799	34	Supply	Supply	NNP
18637	9799	35	Board	Board	NNP
18637	9799	36	which	which	WDT
18637	9799	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9799	38	supersedes	supersede	VBZ
18637	9799	39	.	.	.
18637	9800	1	The	the	DT
18637	9800	2	new	new	JJ
18637	9800	3	board	board	NN
18637	9800	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	9800	5	charged	charge	VBN
18637	9800	6	with	with	IN
18637	9800	7	expanding	expand	VBG
18637	9800	8	and	and	CC
18637	9800	9	accelerating	accelerate	VBG
18637	9800	10	production	production	NN
18637	9800	11	and	and	CC
18637	9800	12	with	with	IN
18637	9800	13	furthering	further	VBG
18637	9800	14	the	the	DT
18637	9800	15	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	9800	16	use	use	NN
18637	9800	17	of	of	IN
18637	9800	18	the	the	DT
18637	9800	19	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	9800	20	capacities	capacity	NNS
18637	9800	21	of	of	IN
18637	9800	22	the	the	DT
18637	9800	23	member	member	NN
18637	9800	24	nations	nation	NNS
18637	9800	25	.	.	.
18637	9801	1	"	"	``
18637	9801	2	The	the	DT
18637	9801	3	Council	Council	NNP
18637	9801	4	also	also	RB
18637	9801	5	reached	reach	VBD
18637	9801	6	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	9801	7	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	9801	8	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	9801	9	the	the	DT
18637	9801	10	part	part	NN
18637	9801	11	which	which	WDT
18637	9801	12	Germany	Germany	NNP
18637	9801	13	might	may	MD
18637	9801	14	assume	assume	VB
18637	9801	15	in	in	IN
18637	9801	16	the	the	DT
18637	9801	17	common	common	JJ
18637	9801	18	defense	defense	NN
18637	9801	19	.	.	.
18637	9802	1	The	the	DT
18637	9802	2	German	german	JJ
18637	9802	3	participation	participation	NN
18637	9802	4	would	would	MD
18637	9802	5	strengthen	strengthen	VB
18637	9802	6	the	the	DT
18637	9802	7	defense	defense	NN
18637	9802	8	of	of	IN
18637	9802	9	Europe	Europe	NNP
18637	9802	10	without	without	IN
18637	9802	11	altering	alter	VBG
18637	9802	12	in	in	IN
18637	9802	13	any	any	DT
18637	9802	14	way	way	NN
18637	9802	15	the	the	DT
18637	9802	16	purely	purely	RB
18637	9802	17	defensive	defensive	JJ
18637	9802	18	character	character	NN
18637	9802	19	of	of	IN
18637	9802	20	the	the	DT
18637	9802	21	North	North	NNP
18637	9802	22	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	9802	23	Treaty	Treaty	NNP
18637	9802	24	Organization	Organization	NNP
18637	9802	25	.	.	.
18637	9803	1	The	the	DT
18637	9803	2	Council	Council	NNP
18637	9803	3	invited	invite	VBD
18637	9803	4	the	the	DT
18637	9803	5	Governments	Governments	NNPS
18637	9803	6	of	of	IN
18637	9803	7	France	France	NNP
18637	9803	8	,	,	,
18637	9803	9	the	the	DT
18637	9803	10	United	United	NNP
18637	9803	11	Kingdom	Kingdom	NNP
18637	9803	12	and	and	CC
18637	9803	13	the	the	DT
18637	9803	14	United	United	NNP
18637	9803	15	States	States	NNP
18637	9803	16	to	to	TO
18637	9803	17	explore	explore	VB
18637	9803	18	the	the	DT
18637	9803	19	matter	matter	NN
18637	9803	20	with	with	IN
18637	9803	21	the	the	DT
18637	9803	22	Government	Government	NNP
18637	9803	23	of	of	IN
18637	9803	24	the	the	DT
18637	9803	25	German	German	NNP
18637	9803	26	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	9803	27	Republic	Republic	NNP
18637	9803	28	.	.	.
18637	9804	1	"	"	``
18637	9804	2	The	the	DT
18637	9804	3	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	9804	4	taken	take	VBN
18637	9804	5	and	and	CC
18637	9804	6	the	the	DT
18637	9804	7	measures	measure	NNS
18637	9804	8	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
18637	9804	9	have	have	VBP
18637	9804	10	the	the	DT
18637	9804	11	sole	sole	JJ
18637	9804	12	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	9804	13	of	of	IN
18637	9804	14	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	9804	15	and	and	CC
18637	9804	16	consolidating	consolidate	VBG
18637	9804	17	peace	peace	NN
18637	9804	18	.	.	.
18637	9805	1	The	the	DT
18637	9805	2	North	North	NNP
18637	9805	3	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	9805	4	nations	nation	NNS
18637	9805	5	are	be	VBP
18637	9805	6	determined	determined	JJ
18637	9805	7	to	to	TO
18637	9805	8	pursue	pursue	VB
18637	9805	9	this	this	DT
18637	9805	10	policy	policy	NN
18637	9805	11	until	until	IN
18637	9805	12	peace	peace	NN
18637	9805	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	9805	14	secure	secure	JJ
18637	9805	15	.	.	.
18637	9805	16	"	"	''
18637	9806	1	Department	Department	NNP
18637	9806	2	of	of	IN
18637	9806	3	State	State	NNP
18637	9806	4	release	release	NN
18637	9806	5	to	to	IN
18637	9806	6	the	the	DT
18637	9806	7	press	press	NN
18637	9806	8	of	of	IN
18637	9806	9	December	December	NNP
18637	9806	10	19	19	CD
18637	9806	11	,	,	,
18637	9806	12	1950	1950	CD
18637	9806	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9806	14	No	no	UH
18637	9806	15	.	.	.
18637	9807	1	1247	1247	CD
18637	9807	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9807	3	.	.	.
18637	9808	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9808	2	254	254	CD
18637	9808	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9808	4	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	9808	5	,	,	,
18637	9808	6	International	International	NNP
18637	9808	7	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	9808	8	Agreements	Agreements	NNP
18637	9808	9	,	,	,
18637	9808	10	38	38	CD
18637	9808	11	;	;	:
18637	9808	12	1	1	CD
18637	9808	13	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	9808	14	.	.	.
18637	9809	1	232	232	CD
18637	9809	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9809	3	239	239	CD
18637	9809	4	;	;	:
18637	9809	5	reenacted	reenact	VBN
18637	9809	6	in	in	IN
18637	9809	7	1	1	CD
18637	9809	8	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9809	9	.	.	.
18637	9810	1	354	354	CD
18637	9810	2	,	,	,
18637	9810	3	366	366	CD
18637	9810	4	.	.	.
18637	9811	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9811	2	255	255	CD
18637	9811	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9811	4	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	9811	5	,	,	,
18637	9811	6	78	78	CD
18637	9811	7	-	-	SYM
18637	9811	8	81	81	CD
18637	9811	9	;	;	:
18637	9811	10	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	9811	11	,	,	,
18637	9811	12	127	127	CD
18637	9811	13	-	-	SYM
18637	9811	14	131	131	CD
18637	9811	15	.	.	.
18637	9812	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9812	2	256	256	CD
18637	9812	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9812	4	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	9812	5	,	,	,
18637	9812	6	121	121	CD
18637	9812	7	-	-	SYM
18637	9812	8	127	127	CD
18637	9812	9	.	.	.
18637	9813	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9813	2	257	257	CD
18637	9813	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9813	4	48	48	CD
18637	9813	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9813	6	.	.	.
18637	9814	1	943	943	CD
18637	9814	2	.	.	.
18637	9815	1	Section	section	NN
18637	9815	2	802	802	CD
18637	9815	3	of	of	IN
18637	9815	4	the	the	DT
18637	9815	5	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	9815	6	Aeronautics	Aeronautics	NNP
18637	9815	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	9815	8	of	of	IN
18637	9815	9	1938	1938	CD
18637	9815	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9815	11	52	52	CD
18637	9815	12	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9815	13	.	.	.
18637	9816	1	973	973	CD
18637	9816	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9816	3	"	"	''
18637	9816	4	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	9816	5	anticipates	anticipate	VBZ
18637	9816	6	the	the	DT
18637	9816	7	making	making	NN
18637	9816	8	of	of	IN
18637	9816	9	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	9816	10	with	with	IN
18637	9816	11	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9816	12	countries	country	NNS
18637	9816	13	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	9816	14	civil	civil	JJ
18637	9816	15	aviation	aviation	NN
18637	9816	16	.	.	.
18637	9816	17	"	"	''
18637	9817	1	40	40	CD
18637	9817	2	Op	Op	NNP
18637	9817	3	.	.	.
18637	9818	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9818	2	.	.	.
18637	9819	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9819	2	451	451	CD
18637	9819	3	,	,	,
18637	9819	4	452	452	CD
18637	9819	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9819	6	1946	1946	CD
18637	9819	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9819	8	.	.	.
18637	9820	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9820	2	258	258	CD
18637	9820	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9820	4	143	143	CD
18637	9820	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9820	6	649	649	CD
18637	9820	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9820	8	1892	1892	CD
18637	9820	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9820	10	.	.	.
18637	9821	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9821	2	259	259	CD
18637	9821	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9821	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9821	5	.	.	.
18637	9822	1	694	694	CD
18637	9822	2	.	.	.
18637	9823	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9823	2	260	260	CD
18637	9823	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9823	4	224	224	CD
18637	9823	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9823	6	583	583	CD
18637	9823	7	,	,	,
18637	9823	8	596	596	CD
18637	9823	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9823	10	1912	1912	CD
18637	9823	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9823	12	.	.	.
18637	9824	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9824	2	261	261	CD
18637	9824	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9824	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9824	5	.	.	.
18637	9825	1	601	601	CD
18637	9825	2	.	.	.
18637	9826	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9826	2	262	262	CD
18637	9826	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9826	4	55	55	CD
18637	9826	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9826	6	.	.	.
18637	9827	1	31	31	CD
18637	9827	2	.	.	.
18637	9828	1	One	one	CD
18637	9828	2	specific	specific	JJ
18637	9828	3	donation	donation	NN
18637	9828	4	was	be	VBD
18637	9828	5	of	of	IN
18637	9828	6	a	a	DT
18637	9828	7	destroyer	destroyer	NN
18637	9828	8	to	to	IN
18637	9828	9	the	the	DT
18637	9828	10	Queen	Queen	NNP
18637	9828	11	of	of	IN
18637	9828	12	Holland	Holland	NNP
18637	9828	13	,	,	,
18637	9828	14	a	a	DT
18637	9828	15	refugee	refugee	NN
18637	9828	16	at	at	IN
18637	9828	17	the	the	DT
18637	9828	18	time	time	NN
18637	9828	19	in	in	IN
18637	9828	20	Great	Great	NNP
18637	9828	21	Britain	Britain	NNP
18637	9828	22	.	.	.
18637	9829	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9829	2	263	263	CD
18637	9829	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9829	4	42	42	CD
18637	9829	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9829	6	.	.	.
18637	9830	1	363	363	CD
18637	9830	2	,	,	,
18637	9830	3	1325	1325	CD
18637	9830	4	,	,	,
18637	9830	5	1326	1326	CD
18637	9830	6	-	-	SYM
18637	9830	7	1327	1327	CD
18637	9830	8	;	;	,
18637	9830	9	extended	extend	VBN
18637	9830	10	by	by	IN
18637	9830	11	43	43	CD
18637	9830	12	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9830	13	.	.	.
18637	9831	1	763	763	CD
18637	9831	2	.	.	.
18637	9832	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9832	2	264	264	CD
18637	9832	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9832	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9832	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9832	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9832	7	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	9832	8	,	,	,
18637	9832	9	The	the	DT
18637	9832	10	President	President	NNP
18637	9832	11	,	,	,
18637	9832	12	Office	Office	NNP
18637	9832	13	and	and	CC
18637	9832	14	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	9832	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9832	16	3d	3d	NNP
18637	9832	17	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9832	18	.	.	.
18637	9832	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9833	1	264	264	CD
18637	9833	2	and	and	CC
18637	9833	3	notes	note	NNS
18637	9833	4	.	.	.
18637	9834	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9834	2	265	265	CD
18637	9834	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9834	4	48	48	CD
18637	9834	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9834	6	.	.	.
18637	9835	1	1182	1182	CD
18637	9835	2	.	.	.
18637	9836	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9836	2	266	266	CD
18637	9836	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9836	4	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	9836	5	,	,	,
18637	9836	6	13	13	CD
18637	9836	7	-	-	SYM
18637	9836	8	14	14	CD
18637	9836	9	.	.	.
18637	9837	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9837	2	267	267	CD
18637	9837	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9837	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	9837	5	.	.	.
18637	9838	1	14	14	CD
18637	9838	2	.	.	.
18637	9839	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9839	2	268	268	CD
18637	9839	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9839	4	"	"	``
18637	9839	5	There	there	EX
18637	9839	6	have	have	VBP
18637	9839	7	been	be	VBN
18637	9839	8	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	9839	9	instances	instance	NNS
18637	9839	10	in	in	IN
18637	9839	11	which	which	WDT
18637	9839	12	the	the	DT
18637	9839	13	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9839	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	9839	15	approved	approve	VBN
18637	9839	16	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	9839	17	providing	provide	VBG
18637	9839	18	for	for	IN
18637	9839	19	the	the	DT
18637	9839	20	submission	submission	NN
18637	9839	21	of	of	IN
18637	9839	22	specific	specific	JJ
18637	9839	23	matters	matter	NNS
18637	9839	24	to	to	IN
18637	9839	25	arbitration	arbitration	NN
18637	9839	26	,	,	,
18637	9839	27	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	9839	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9839	29	to	to	IN
18637	9839	30	the	the	DT
18637	9839	31	President	President	NNP
18637	9839	32	to	to	TO
18637	9839	33	determine	determine	VB
18637	9839	34	exactly	exactly	RB
18637	9839	35	the	the	DT
18637	9839	36	form	form	NN
18637	9839	37	and	and	CC
18637	9839	38	scope	scope	NN
18637	9839	39	of	of	IN
18637	9839	40	the	the	DT
18637	9839	41	matter	matter	NN
18637	9839	42	to	to	TO
18637	9839	43	be	be	VB
18637	9839	44	arbitrated	arbitrate	VBN
18637	9839	45	and	and	CC
18637	9839	46	to	to	TO
18637	9839	47	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	9839	48	the	the	DT
18637	9839	49	arbitrators	arbitrator	NNS
18637	9839	50	.	.	.
18637	9840	1	Professor	Professor	NNP
18637	9840	2	J.B.	J.B.	NNP
18637	9840	3	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	9840	4	,	,	,
18637	9840	5	in	in	IN
18637	9840	6	the	the	DT
18637	9840	7	article	article	NN
18637	9840	8	to	to	TO
18637	9840	9	which	which	WDT
18637	9840	10	reference	reference	NN
18637	9840	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	9840	12	already	already	RB
18637	9840	13	been	be	VBN
18637	9840	14	made	make	VBN
18637	9840	15	,	,	,
18637	9840	16	enumerates	enumerate	VBZ
18637	9840	17	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	9840	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	9840	19	nine	nine	CD
18637	9840	20	instances	instance	NNS
18637	9840	21	in	in	IN
18637	9840	22	which	which	WDT
18637	9840	23	provision	provision	NN
18637	9840	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	9840	25	thus	thus	RB
18637	9840	26	been	be	VBN
18637	9840	27	made	make	VBN
18637	9840	28	for	for	IN
18637	9840	29	the	the	DT
18637	9840	30	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	9840	31	of	of	IN
18637	9840	32	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
18637	9840	33	claims	claim	NNS
18637	9840	34	.	.	.
18637	9841	1	Twenty	twenty	CD
18637	9841	2	of	of	IN
18637	9841	3	these	these	DT
18637	9841	4	were	be	VBD
18637	9841	5	claims	claim	NNS
18637	9841	6	against	against	IN
18637	9841	7	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	9841	8	governments	government	NNS
18637	9841	9	,	,	,
18637	9841	10	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	9841	11	were	be	VBD
18637	9841	12	claims	claim	NNS
18637	9841	13	against	against	IN
18637	9841	14	both	both	DT
18637	9841	15	governments	government	NNS
18637	9841	16	,	,	,
18637	9841	17	and	and	CC
18637	9841	18	five	five	CD
18637	9841	19	against	against	IN
18637	9841	20	the	the	DT
18637	9841	21	United	United	NNP
18637	9841	22	States	States	NNP
18637	9841	23	alone	alone	RB
18637	9841	24	.	.	.
18637	9841	25	"	"	''
18637	9842	1	Willoughby	Willoughby	NNP
18637	9842	2	,	,	,
18637	9842	3	On	on	IN
18637	9842	4	the	the	DT
18637	9842	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9842	6	,	,	,
18637	9842	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9842	8	,	,	,
18637	9842	9	543	543	CD
18637	9842	10	.	.	.
18637	9843	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9843	2	269	269	CD
18637	9843	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9843	4	A	A	NNP
18637	9843	5	Decade	Decade	NNP
18637	9843	6	of	of	IN
18637	9843	7	American	American	NNP
18637	9843	8	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	9843	9	Policy	Policy	NNP
18637	9843	10	,	,	,
18637	9843	11	S.	S.	NNP
18637	9843	12	Doc	Doc	NNP
18637	9843	13	.	.	.
18637	9844	1	123	123	CD
18637	9844	2	,	,	,
18637	9844	3	81st	81st	NNP
18637	9844	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	9844	5	.	.	NNP
18637	9844	6	,	,	,
18637	9844	7	1st	1st	JJ
18637	9844	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	9844	9	.	.	.
18637	9844	10	,	,	,
18637	9844	11	126	126	CD
18637	9844	12	.	.	.
18637	9845	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9845	2	270	270	CD
18637	9845	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9845	4	A	A	NNP
18637	9845	5	Decade	Decade	NNP
18637	9845	6	of	of	IN
18637	9845	7	American	American	NNP
18637	9845	8	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	9845	9	Policy	Policy	NNP
18637	9845	10	,	,	,
18637	9845	11	S.	S.	NNP
18637	9845	12	Doc	Doc	NNP
18637	9845	13	.	.	.
18637	9846	1	123	123	CD
18637	9846	2	,	,	,
18637	9846	3	81st	81st	NNP
18637	9846	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	9846	5	.	.	NNP
18637	9846	6	,	,	,
18637	9846	7	1st	1st	JJ
18637	9846	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	9846	9	.	.	.
18637	9846	10	,	,	,
18637	9846	11	158	158	CD
18637	9846	12	.	.	.
18637	9847	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9847	2	271	271	CD
18637	9847	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9847	4	United	United	NNP
18637	9847	5	States	States	NNP
18637	9847	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9847	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9847	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9847	9	Hartwell	Hartwell	NNP
18637	9847	10	,	,	,
18637	9847	11	6	6	CD
18637	9847	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	9847	13	.	.	.
18637	9848	1	385	385	CD
18637	9848	2	,	,	,
18637	9848	3	393	393	CD
18637	9848	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9848	5	1868	1868	CD
18637	9848	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9848	7	.	.	.
18637	9849	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9849	2	272	272	CD
18637	9849	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9849	4	7	7	CD
18637	9849	5	Op	Op	NNP
18637	9849	6	.	.	.
18637	9850	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9850	2	.	.	.
18637	9851	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9851	2	168	168	CD
18637	9851	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9851	4	1855	1855	CD
18637	9851	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9851	6	.	.	.
18637	9852	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9852	2	273	273	CD
18637	9852	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9852	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9852	5	was	be	VBD
18637	9852	6	so	so	RB
18637	9852	7	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	9852	8	by	by	IN
18637	9852	9	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	9852	10	William	William	NNP
18637	9852	11	Maclay	Maclay	NNP
18637	9852	12	.	.	.
18637	9853	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9853	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9853	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9853	4	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	9853	5	of	of	IN
18637	9853	6	William	William	NNP
18637	9853	7	Maclay	Maclay	NNP
18637	9853	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9853	9	New	New	NNP
18637	9853	10	York	York	NNP
18637	9853	11	,	,	,
18637	9853	12	1890	1890	CD
18637	9853	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9853	14	,	,	,
18637	9853	15	109	109	CD
18637	9853	16	-	-	SYM
18637	9853	17	110	110	CD
18637	9853	18	.	.	.
18637	9854	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9854	2	274	274	CD
18637	9854	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9854	4	5	5	CD
18637	9854	5	Benton	Benton	NNP
18637	9854	6	,	,	,
18637	9854	7	Abridgment	Abridgment	NNP
18637	9854	8	of	of	IN
18637	9854	9	the	the	DT
18637	9854	10	Debates	Debates	NNPS
18637	9854	11	of	of	IN
18637	9854	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9854	13	,	,	,
18637	9854	14	90	90	CD
18637	9854	15	-	-	SYM
18637	9854	16	91	91	CD
18637	9854	17	;	;	:
18637	9854	18	3	3	CD
18637	9854	19	Letters	Letters	NNPS
18637	9854	20	and	and	CC
18637	9854	21	Other	other	JJ
18637	9854	22	Writings	Writings	NNPS
18637	9854	23	of	of	IN
18637	9854	24	James	James	NNP
18637	9854	25	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	9854	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9854	27	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	9854	28	,	,	,
18637	9854	29	1867	1867	CD
18637	9854	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9854	31	,	,	,
18637	9854	32	350	350	CD
18637	9854	33	-	-	SYM
18637	9854	34	353	353	CD
18637	9854	35	,	,	,
18637	9854	36	360	360	CD
18637	9854	37	-	-	SYM
18637	9854	38	371	371	CD
18637	9854	39	.	.	.
18637	9855	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9855	2	275	275	CD
18637	9855	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9855	4	10	10	CD
18637	9855	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9855	6	.	.	.
18637	9856	1	619	619	CD
18637	9856	2	,	,	,
18637	9856	3	623	623	CD
18637	9856	4	.	.	.
18637	9857	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9857	2	276	276	CD
18637	9857	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9857	4	7	7	CD
18637	9857	5	Op	Op	NNP
18637	9857	6	.	.	.
18637	9858	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9858	2	.	.	.
18637	9859	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9859	2	220	220	CD
18637	9859	3	.	.	.
18637	9860	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9860	2	277	277	CD
18637	9860	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9860	4	35	35	CD
18637	9860	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9860	6	.	.	.
18637	9861	1	672	672	CD
18637	9861	2	;	;	:
18637	9861	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9861	4	see	see	VB
18637	9861	5	also	also	RB
18637	9861	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9861	7	The	the	DT
18637	9861	8	act	act	NN
18637	9861	9	of	of	IN
18637	9861	10	March	March	NNP
18637	9861	11	1	1	CD
18637	9861	12	,	,	,
18637	9861	13	1893	1893	CD
18637	9861	14	,	,	,
18637	9861	15	27	27	CD
18637	9861	16	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	9861	17	.	.	.
18637	9862	1	497	497	CD
18637	9862	2	,	,	,
18637	9862	3	which	which	WDT
18637	9862	4	purported	purport	VBD
18637	9862	5	to	to	TO
18637	9862	6	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	9862	7	the	the	DT
18637	9862	8	President	President	NNP
18637	9862	9	to	to	TO
18637	9862	10	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	9862	11	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	9862	12	in	in	IN
18637	9862	13	certain	certain	JJ
18637	9862	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	9862	15	.	.	.
18637	9863	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9863	2	278	278	CD
18637	9863	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9863	4	22	22	CD
18637	9863	5	U.S.C.	u.s.c.	NN
18637	9864	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	9864	2	1	1	CD
18637	9864	3	-	-	SYM
18637	9864	4	231	231	CD
18637	9864	5	.	.	.
18637	9865	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9865	2	279	279	CD
18637	9865	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9865	4	11	11	CD
18637	9865	5	Benton	Benton	NNP
18637	9865	6	,	,	,
18637	9865	7	Abridgement	Abridgement	NNP
18637	9865	8	of	of	IN
18637	9865	9	the	the	DT
18637	9865	10	Debates	Debates	NNPS
18637	9865	11	of	of	IN
18637	9865	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9865	13	,	,	,
18637	9865	14	221	221	CD
18637	9865	15	-	-	SYM
18637	9865	16	222	222	CD
18637	9865	17	.	.	.
18637	9866	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9866	2	280	280	CD
18637	9866	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9866	4	S.	S.	NNP
18637	9866	5	Misc	Misc	NNP
18637	9866	6	.	.	.
18637	9867	1	Doc	doc	UH
18637	9867	2	.	.	.
18637	9868	1	109	109	CD
18637	9868	2	,	,	,
18637	9868	3	50th	50th	NNP
18637	9868	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	9868	5	.	.	NNP
18637	9868	6	,	,	,
18637	9868	7	1st	1st	JJ
18637	9868	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	9868	9	.	.	.
18637	9868	10	,	,	,
18637	9868	11	104	104	CD
18637	9868	12	.	.	.
18637	9869	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9869	2	281	281	CD
18637	9869	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9869	4	S.	S.	NNP
18637	9869	5	Rept	Rept	NNP
18637	9869	6	.	.	.
18637	9870	1	227	227	CD
18637	9870	2	,	,	,
18637	9870	3	53d	53d	NNPS
18637	9870	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	9870	5	.	.	NNP
18637	9870	6	,	,	,
18637	9870	7	2d	2d	CD
18637	9870	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	9870	9	.	.	.
18637	9870	10	,	,	,
18637	9870	11	25	25	CD
18637	9870	12	.	.	.
18637	9871	1	At	at	IN
18637	9871	2	the	the	DT
18637	9871	3	outset	outset	NN
18637	9871	4	of	of	IN
18637	9871	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9871	6	entrance	entrance	NN
18637	9871	7	into	into	IN
18637	9871	8	World	World	NNP
18637	9871	9	War	War	NNP
18637	9871	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9871	11	President	President	NNP
18637	9871	12	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	9871	13	dispatched	dispatch	VBD
18637	9871	14	a	a	DT
18637	9871	15	mission	mission	NN
18637	9871	16	to	to	IN
18637	9871	17	"	"	``
18637	9871	18	Petrograd	Petrograd	NNP
18637	9871	19	,	,	,
18637	9871	20	"	"	''
18637	9871	21	as	as	IN
18637	9871	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9871	23	was	be	VBD
18637	9871	24	then	then	RB
18637	9871	25	called	call	VBN
18637	9871	26	,	,	,
18637	9871	27	without	without	IN
18637	9871	28	nominating	nominate	VBG
18637	9871	29	the	the	DT
18637	9871	30	Members	member	NNS
18637	9871	31	of	of	IN
18637	9871	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9871	33	to	to	IN
18637	9871	34	the	the	DT
18637	9871	35	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9871	36	.	.	.
18637	9872	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9872	2	was	be	VBD
18637	9872	3	headed	head	VBN
18637	9872	4	by	by	IN
18637	9872	5	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	9872	6	Elihu	Elihu	NNP
18637	9872	7	Root	Root	NNP
18637	9872	8	,	,	,
18637	9872	9	with	with	IN
18637	9872	10	"	"	``
18637	9872	11	the	the	DT
18637	9872	12	rank	rank	NN
18637	9872	13	of	of	IN
18637	9872	14	ambassador	ambassador	NN
18637	9872	15	,	,	,
18637	9872	16	"	"	``
18637	9872	17	while	while	IN
18637	9872	18	some	some	DT
18637	9872	19	of	of	IN
18637	9872	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9872	21	associates	associate	NNS
18637	9872	22	bore	bore	NN
18637	9872	23	"	"	``
18637	9872	24	the	the	DT
18637	9872	25	rank	rank	NN
18637	9872	26	of	of	IN
18637	9872	27	envoy	envoy	NN
18637	9872	28	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	9872	29	.	.	.
18637	9872	30	"	"	''
18637	9873	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9873	2	282	282	CD
18637	9873	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9873	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9873	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9873	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9873	7	George	George	NNP
18637	9873	8	Frisbie	Frisbie	NNP
18637	9873	9	Hoar	Hoar	NNP
18637	9873	10	,	,	,
18637	9873	11	Autobiography	Autobiography	NNP
18637	9873	12	,	,	,
18637	9873	13	II	II	NNP
18637	9873	14	,	,	,
18637	9873	15	48	48	CD
18637	9873	16	-	-	SYM
18637	9873	17	51	51	CD
18637	9873	18	.	.	.
18637	9874	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9874	2	283	283	CD
18637	9874	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9874	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9874	5	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	9874	6	,	,	,
18637	9874	7	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	9874	8	in	in	IN
18637	9874	9	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	9874	10	_	_	NNP
18637	9874	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	9874	12	_	_	NNP
18637	9874	13	United	United	NNP
18637	9874	14	States	States	NNP
18637	9874	15	,	,	,
18637	9874	16	272	272	CD
18637	9874	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9874	18	52	52	CD
18637	9874	19	,	,	,
18637	9874	20	264	264	CD
18637	9874	21	-	-	SYM
18637	9874	22	274	274	CD
18637	9874	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9874	24	1926	1926	CD
18637	9874	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9874	26	.	.	.
18637	9875	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9875	2	284	284	CD
18637	9875	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9875	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9875	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9875	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9875	7	data	datum	NNS
18637	9875	8	in	in	IN
18637	9875	9	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	9875	10	,	,	,
18637	9875	11	The	the	DT
18637	9875	12	President	President	NNP
18637	9875	13	,	,	,
18637	9875	14	Office	Office	NNP
18637	9875	15	and	and	CC
18637	9875	16	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	9875	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9875	18	3d	3d	NNP
18637	9875	19	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9875	20	.	.	.
18637	9875	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9876	1	418	418	CD
18637	9876	2	.	.	.
18637	9877	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9877	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	9877	3	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	9877	4	designated	designate	VBN
18637	9877	5	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	9877	6	,	,	,
18637	9877	7	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	9877	8	by	by	IN
18637	9877	9	name	name	NN
18637	9877	10	,	,	,
18637	9877	11	more	more	RBR
18637	9877	12	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	9877	13	by	by	IN
18637	9877	14	reference	reference	NN
18637	9877	15	to	to	IN
18637	9877	16	a	a	DT
18637	9877	17	particular	particular	JJ
18637	9877	18	office	office	NN
18637	9877	19	,	,	,
18637	9877	20	for	for	IN
18637	9877	21	the	the	DT
18637	9877	22	performance	performance	NN
18637	9877	23	of	of	IN
18637	9877	24	specified	specified	JJ
18637	9877	25	acts	act	NNS
18637	9877	26	or	or	CC
18637	9877	27	for	for	IN
18637	9877	28	posts	post	NNS
18637	9877	29	of	of	IN
18637	9877	30	a	a	DT
18637	9877	31	nongovernmental	nongovernmental	JJ
18637	9877	32	character	character	NN
18637	9877	33	;	;	:
18637	9877	34	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	9877	35	,	,	,
18637	9877	36	to	to	TO
18637	9877	37	paint	paint	VB
18637	9877	38	a	a	DT
18637	9877	39	picture	picture	NN
18637	9877	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9877	41	Jonathan	Jonathan	NNP
18637	9877	42	Trumbull	Trumbull	NNP
18637	9877	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9877	44	,	,	,
18637	9877	45	to	to	TO
18637	9877	46	lay	lay	VB
18637	9877	47	out	out	RP
18637	9877	48	a	a	DT
18637	9877	49	town	town	NN
18637	9877	50	,	,	,
18637	9877	51	to	to	TO
18637	9877	52	act	act	VB
18637	9877	53	as	as	IN
18637	9877	54	Regents	Regents	NNPS
18637	9877	55	of	of	IN
18637	9877	56	Smithsonian	Smithsonian	NNP
18637	9877	57	Institution	Institution	NNP
18637	9877	58	,	,	,
18637	9877	59	to	to	TO
18637	9877	60	be	be	VB
18637	9877	61	managers	manager	NNS
18637	9877	62	of	of	IN
18637	9877	63	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	9877	64	Institute	Institute	NNP
18637	9877	65	,	,	,
18637	9877	66	to	to	TO
18637	9877	67	select	select	VB
18637	9877	68	a	a	DT
18637	9877	69	site	site	NN
18637	9877	70	for	for	IN
18637	9877	71	a	a	DT
18637	9877	72	post	post	NN
18637	9877	73	office	office	NN
18637	9877	74	or	or	CC
18637	9877	75	a	a	DT
18637	9877	76	prison	prison	NN
18637	9877	77	,	,	,
18637	9877	78	to	to	TO
18637	9877	79	restore	restore	VB
18637	9877	80	the	the	DT
18637	9877	81	manuscript	manuscript	NN
18637	9877	82	of	of	IN
18637	9877	83	the	the	DT
18637	9877	84	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
18637	9877	85	of	of	IN
18637	9877	86	Independence	Independence	NNP
18637	9877	87	,	,	,
18637	9877	88	to	to	TO
18637	9877	89	erect	erect	VB
18637	9877	90	a	a	DT
18637	9877	91	monument	monument	NN
18637	9877	92	at	at	IN
18637	9877	93	Yorktown	Yorktown	NNP
18637	9877	94	,	,	,
18637	9877	95	to	to	TO
18637	9877	96	erect	erect	VB
18637	9877	97	a	a	DT
18637	9877	98	statue	statue	NN
18637	9877	99	of	of	IN
18637	9877	100	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	9877	101	,	,	,
18637	9877	102	and	and	CC
18637	9877	103	so	so	RB
18637	9877	104	on	on	RB
18637	9877	105	and	and	CC
18637	9877	106	so	so	RB
18637	9877	107	forth	forth	RB
18637	9877	108	.	.	.
18637	9878	1	42	42	CD
18637	9878	2	Harvard	Harvard	NNP
18637	9878	3	Law	Law	NNP
18637	9878	4	Review	Review	NNP
18637	9878	5	,	,	,
18637	9878	6	426	426	CD
18637	9878	7	,	,	,
18637	9878	8	430	430	CD
18637	9878	9	-	-	SYM
18637	9878	10	431	431	CD
18637	9878	11	.	.	.
18637	9879	1	In	in	IN
18637	9879	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9879	3	message	message	NN
18637	9879	4	of	of	IN
18637	9879	5	April	April	NNP
18637	9879	6	13	13	CD
18637	9879	7	,	,	,
18637	9879	8	1822	1822	CD
18637	9879	9	,	,	,
18637	9879	10	President	President	NNP
18637	9879	11	Monroe	Monroe	NNP
18637	9879	12	stated	state	VBD
18637	9879	13	the	the	DT
18637	9879	14	thesis	thesis	NN
18637	9879	15	that	that	IN
18637	9879	16	,	,	,
18637	9879	17	"	"	``
18637	9879	18	as	as	IN
18637	9879	19	a	a	DT
18637	9879	20	general	general	JJ
18637	9879	21	principle	principle	NN
18637	9879	22	,	,	,
18637	9879	23	*	*	NFP
18637	9879	24	*	*	NFP
18637	9879	25	*	*	NFP
18637	9879	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9879	27	have	have	VBP
18637	9879	28	no	no	DT
18637	9879	29	right	right	NN
18637	9879	30	under	under	IN
18637	9879	31	the	the	DT
18637	9879	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9879	33	to	to	TO
18637	9879	34	impose	impose	VB
18637	9879	35	any	any	DT
18637	9879	36	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	9879	37	by	by	IN
18637	9879	38	law	law	NN
18637	9879	39	on	on	IN
18637	9879	40	the	the	DT
18637	9879	41	power	power	NN
18637	9879	42	granted	grant	VBN
18637	9879	43	to	to	IN
18637	9879	44	the	the	DT
18637	9879	45	President	President	NNP
18637	9879	46	so	so	IN
18637	9879	47	as	as	IN
18637	9879	48	to	to	TO
18637	9879	49	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	9879	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9879	51	making	make	VBG
18637	9879	52	a	a	DT
18637	9879	53	free	free	JJ
18637	9879	54	selection	selection	NN
18637	9879	55	of	of	IN
18637	9879	56	proper	proper	JJ
18637	9879	57	persons	person	NNS
18637	9879	58	for	for	IN
18637	9879	59	these	these	DT
18637	9879	60	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9879	61	newly	newly	RB
18637	9879	62	created	create	VBN
18637	9879	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9879	64	offices	office	NNS
18637	9879	65	from	from	IN
18637	9879	66	the	the	DT
18637	9879	67	whole	whole	JJ
18637	9879	68	body	body	NN
18637	9879	69	of	of	IN
18637	9879	70	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9879	71	fellow	fellow	JJ
18637	9879	72	-	-	HYPH
18637	9879	73	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	9879	74	.	.	.
18637	9879	75	"	"	''
18637	9880	1	Messages	message	NNS
18637	9880	2	and	and	CC
18637	9880	3	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	9880	4	of	of	IN
18637	9880	5	the	the	DT
18637	9880	6	Presidents	Presidents	NNPS
18637	9880	7	,	,	,
18637	9880	8	II	II	NNP
18637	9880	9	,	,	,
18637	9880	10	698	698	CD
18637	9880	11	,	,	,
18637	9880	12	701	701	CD
18637	9880	13	.	.	.
18637	9881	1	The	the	DT
18637	9881	2	statement	statement	NN
18637	9881	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	9881	4	ambiguous	ambiguous	JJ
18637	9881	5	,	,	,
18637	9881	6	but	but	CC
18637	9881	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9881	8	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	9881	9	intention	intention	NN
18637	9881	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	9881	11	to	to	TO
18637	9881	12	claim	claim	VB
18637	9881	13	for	for	IN
18637	9881	14	the	the	DT
18637	9881	15	President	President	NNP
18637	9881	16	unrestricted	unrestricte	VBD
18637	9881	17	power	power	NN
18637	9881	18	in	in	IN
18637	9881	19	determining	determine	VBG
18637	9881	20	who	who	WP
18637	9881	21	are	be	VBP
18637	9881	22	proper	proper	JJ
18637	9881	23	persons	person	NNS
18637	9881	24	to	to	TO
18637	9881	25	fill	fill	VB
18637	9881	26	newly	newly	RB
18637	9881	27	created	create	VBN
18637	9881	28	offices	office	NNS
18637	9881	29	.	.	.
18637	9882	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9882	2	285	285	CD
18637	9882	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9882	4	19	19	CD
18637	9882	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9882	6	.	.	.
18637	9883	1	143	143	CD
18637	9883	2	,	,	,
18637	9883	3	169	169	CD
18637	9883	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9883	5	1876	1876	CD
18637	9883	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9883	7	.	.	.
18637	9884	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9884	2	286	286	CD
18637	9884	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9884	4	In	in	IN
18637	9884	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	9884	6	parte	parte	NN
18637	9884	7	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	9884	8	,	,	,
18637	9884	9	106	106	CD
18637	9884	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9884	11	371	371	CD
18637	9884	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9884	13	1882	1882	CD
18637	9884	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9884	15	,	,	,
18637	9884	16	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	9884	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	9884	18	Waite	Waite	NNP
18637	9884	19	reviews	review	VBZ
18637	9884	20	early	early	JJ
18637	9884	21	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	9884	22	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	9884	23	regulative	regulative	NN
18637	9884	24	of	of	IN
18637	9884	25	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	9884	26	in	in	IN
18637	9884	27	office	office	NN
18637	9884	28	.	.	.
18637	9885	1	"	"	``
18637	9885	2	The	the	DT
18637	9885	3	act	act	NN
18637	9885	4	now	now	RB
18637	9885	5	in	in	IN
18637	9885	6	question	question	NN
18637	9885	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	9885	8	one	one	CD
18637	9885	9	regulating	regulating	NN
18637	9885	10	in	in	IN
18637	9885	11	some	some	DT
18637	9885	12	particulars	particular	NNS
18637	9885	13	the	the	DT
18637	9885	14	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	9885	15	of	of	IN
18637	9885	16	certain	certain	JJ
18637	9885	17	officers	officer	NNS
18637	9885	18	and	and	CC
18637	9885	19	employÃ	employÃ	NNP
18637	9885	20	©	©	NNP
18637	9885	21	s	s	NNP
18637	9885	22	of	of	IN
18637	9885	23	the	the	DT
18637	9885	24	United	United	NNP
18637	9885	25	States	States	NNP
18637	9885	26	.	.	.
18637	9886	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9886	2	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	9886	3	on	on	IN
18637	9886	4	the	the	DT
18637	9886	5	same	same	JJ
18637	9886	6	principle	principle	NN
18637	9886	7	as	as	IN
18637	9886	8	that	that	DT
18637	9886	9	originally	originally	RB
18637	9886	10	passed	pass	VBD
18637	9886	11	in	in	IN
18637	9886	12	1789	1789	CD
18637	9886	13	at	at	IN
18637	9886	14	the	the	DT
18637	9886	15	first	first	JJ
18637	9886	16	session	session	NN
18637	9886	17	of	of	IN
18637	9886	18	the	the	DT
18637	9886	19	first	first	JJ
18637	9886	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9886	21	,	,	,
18637	9886	22	which	which	WDT
18637	9886	23	makes	make	VBZ
18637	9886	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9886	25	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	9886	26	for	for	IN
18637	9886	27	certain	certain	JJ
18637	9886	28	officers	officer	NNS
18637	9886	29	of	of	IN
18637	9886	30	the	the	DT
18637	9886	31	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	9886	32	Department	Department	NNP
18637	9886	33	to	to	TO
18637	9886	34	engage	engage	VB
18637	9886	35	in	in	IN
18637	9886	36	the	the	DT
18637	9886	37	business	business	NN
18637	9886	38	of	of	IN
18637	9886	39	trade	trade	NN
18637	9886	40	or	or	CC
18637	9886	41	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	9886	42	,	,	,
18637	9886	43	or	or	CC
18637	9886	44	to	to	TO
18637	9886	45	own	own	VB
18637	9886	46	a	a	DT
18637	9886	47	sea	sea	NN
18637	9886	48	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	9886	49	,	,	,
18637	9886	50	or	or	CC
18637	9886	51	to	to	TO
18637	9886	52	purchase	purchase	VB
18637	9886	53	public	public	JJ
18637	9886	54	lands	land	NNS
18637	9886	55	or	or	CC
18637	9886	56	other	other	JJ
18637	9886	57	public	public	JJ
18637	9886	58	property	property	NN
18637	9886	59	,	,	,
18637	9886	60	or	or	CC
18637	9886	61	to	to	TO
18637	9886	62	be	be	VB
18637	9886	63	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	9886	64	in	in	IN
18637	9886	65	the	the	DT
18637	9886	66	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	9886	67	or	or	CC
18637	9886	68	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	9886	69	of	of	IN
18637	9886	70	the	the	DT
18637	9886	71	public	public	JJ
18637	9886	72	securities	security	NNS
18637	9886	73	of	of	IN
18637	9886	74	a	a	DT
18637	9886	75	State	State	NNP
18637	9886	76	,	,	,
18637	9886	77	or	or	CC
18637	9886	78	of	of	IN
18637	9886	79	the	the	DT
18637	9886	80	United	United	NNP
18637	9886	81	States	States	NNP
18637	9886	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9886	83	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	9887	1	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9887	2	.	.	.
18637	9887	3	,	,	,
18637	9887	4	sect	sect	NN
18637	9887	5	.	.	.
18637	9888	1	243	243	CD
18637	9888	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9888	3	;	;	:
18637	9888	4	and	and	CC
18637	9888	5	that	that	DT
18637	9888	6	passed	pass	VBD
18637	9888	7	in	in	IN
18637	9888	8	1791	1791	CD
18637	9888	9	,	,	,
18637	9888	10	which	which	WDT
18637	9888	11	makes	make	VBZ
18637	9888	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9888	13	an	an	DT
18637	9888	14	offence	offence	NN
18637	9888	15	for	for	IN
18637	9888	16	a	a	DT
18637	9888	17	clerk	clerk	NN
18637	9888	18	in	in	IN
18637	9888	19	the	the	DT
18637	9888	20	same	same	JJ
18637	9888	21	department	department	NN
18637	9888	22	to	to	TO
18637	9888	23	carry	carry	VB
18637	9888	24	on	on	RP
18637	9888	25	trade	trade	NN
18637	9888	26	or	or	CC
18637	9888	27	business	business	NN
18637	9888	28	in	in	IN
18637	9888	29	the	the	DT
18637	9888	30	funds	fund	NNS
18637	9888	31	or	or	CC
18637	9888	32	debts	debt	NNS
18637	9888	33	of	of	IN
18637	9888	34	the	the	DT
18637	9888	35	States	States	NNPS
18637	9888	36	or	or	CC
18637	9888	37	of	of	IN
18637	9888	38	the	the	DT
18637	9888	39	United	United	NNP
18637	9888	40	States	States	NNP
18637	9888	41	,	,	,
18637	9888	42	or	or	CC
18637	9888	43	in	in	IN
18637	9888	44	any	any	DT
18637	9888	45	kind	kind	NN
18637	9888	46	of	of	IN
18637	9888	47	public	public	JJ
18637	9888	48	property	property	NN
18637	9888	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9888	50	i	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9888	51	d	d	NNP
18637	9888	52	.	.	NNP
18637	9888	53	,	,	,
18637	9888	54	sect	sect	NN
18637	9888	55	.	.	.
18637	9889	1	244	244	CD
18637	9889	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9889	3	;	;	:
18637	9889	4	and	and	CC
18637	9889	5	that	that	DT
18637	9889	6	passed	pass	VBD
18637	9889	7	in	in	IN
18637	9889	8	1812	1812	CD
18637	9889	9	,	,	,
18637	9889	10	which	which	WDT
18637	9889	11	makes	make	VBZ
18637	9889	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	9889	13	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	9889	14	for	for	IN
18637	9889	15	a	a	DT
18637	9889	16	judge	judge	NN
18637	9889	17	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	9889	18	under	under	IN
18637	9889	19	the	the	DT
18637	9889	20	authority	authority	NN
18637	9889	21	of	of	IN
18637	9889	22	the	the	DT
18637	9889	23	United	United	NNP
18637	9889	24	States	States	NNP
18637	9889	25	to	to	TO
18637	9889	26	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	9889	27	the	the	DT
18637	9889	28	profession	profession	NN
18637	9889	29	of	of	IN
18637	9889	30	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	9889	31	or	or	CC
18637	9889	32	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	9889	33	,	,	,
18637	9889	34	or	or	CC
18637	9889	35	to	to	TO
18637	9889	36	be	be	VB
18637	9889	37	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	9889	38	in	in	IN
18637	9889	39	the	the	DT
18637	9889	40	practice	practice	NN
18637	9889	41	of	of	IN
18637	9889	42	the	the	DT
18637	9889	43	law	law	NN
18637	9889	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9889	45	i	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9889	46	d	d	NNP
18637	9889	47	.	.	NNP
18637	9889	48	,	,	,
18637	9889	49	sect	sect	NN
18637	9889	50	.	.	.
18637	9890	1	713	713	CD
18637	9890	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9890	3	;	;	:
18637	9890	4	and	and	CC
18637	9890	5	that	that	DT
18637	9890	6	passed	pass	VBD
18637	9890	7	in	in	IN
18637	9890	8	1853	1853	CD
18637	9890	9	,	,	,
18637	9890	10	which	which	WDT
18637	9890	11	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	9890	12	every	every	DT
18637	9890	13	officer	officer	NN
18637	9890	14	of	of	IN
18637	9890	15	the	the	DT
18637	9890	16	United	United	NNP
18637	9890	17	States	States	NNP
18637	9890	18	or	or	CC
18637	9890	19	person	person	NN
18637	9890	20	holding	hold	VBG
18637	9890	21	any	any	DT
18637	9890	22	place	place	NN
18637	9890	23	of	of	IN
18637	9890	24	trust	trust	NN
18637	9890	25	or	or	CC
18637	9890	26	profit	profit	NN
18637	9890	27	,	,	,
18637	9890	28	or	or	CC
18637	9890	29	discharging	discharge	VBG
18637	9890	30	any	any	DT
18637	9890	31	official	official	JJ
18637	9890	32	function	function	NN
18637	9890	33	under	under	IN
18637	9890	34	or	or	CC
18637	9890	35	in	in	IN
18637	9890	36	connection	connection	NN
18637	9890	37	with	with	IN
18637	9890	38	any	any	DT
18637	9890	39	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9890	40	department	department	NN
18637	9890	41	of	of	IN
18637	9890	42	the	the	DT
18637	9890	43	government	government	NN
18637	9890	44	of	of	IN
18637	9890	45	the	the	DT
18637	9890	46	United	United	NNP
18637	9890	47	States	States	NNP
18637	9890	48	,	,	,
18637	9890	49	or	or	CC
18637	9890	50	under	under	IN
18637	9890	51	the	the	DT
18637	9890	52	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9890	53	or	or	CC
18637	9890	54	House	House	NNP
18637	9890	55	of	of	IN
18637	9890	56	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	9890	57	,	,	,
18637	9890	58	from	from	IN
18637	9890	59	acting	act	VBG
18637	9890	60	as	as	IN
18637	9890	61	an	an	DT
18637	9890	62	agent	agent	NN
18637	9890	63	or	or	CC
18637	9890	64	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	9890	65	for	for	IN
18637	9890	66	the	the	DT
18637	9890	67	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	9890	68	of	of	IN
18637	9890	69	any	any	DT
18637	9890	70	claim	claim	NN
18637	9890	71	against	against	IN
18637	9890	72	the	the	DT
18637	9890	73	United	United	NNP
18637	9890	74	States	States	NNP
18637	9890	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9890	76	i	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9890	77	d	d	NNP
18637	9890	78	.	.	NNP
18637	9890	79	,	,	,
18637	9890	80	sect	sect	NN
18637	9890	81	.	.	.
18637	9891	1	5498	5498	CD
18637	9891	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9891	3	;	;	:
18637	9891	4	and	and	CC
18637	9891	5	that	that	DT
18637	9891	6	passed	pass	VBD
18637	9891	7	in	in	IN
18637	9891	8	1863	1863	CD
18637	9891	9	,	,	,
18637	9891	10	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	9891	11	members	member	NNS
18637	9891	12	of	of	IN
18637	9891	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9891	14	from	from	IN
18637	9891	15	practicing	practice	VBG
18637	9891	16	in	in	IN
18637	9891	17	the	the	DT
18637	9891	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9891	19	of	of	IN
18637	9891	20	Claims	Claims	NNP
18637	9891	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9891	22	i	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9891	23	d	d	NNP
18637	9891	24	.	.	NNP
18637	9891	25	,	,	,
18637	9891	26	sect	sect	NN
18637	9891	27	.	.	.
18637	9892	1	1058	1058	CD
18637	9892	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9892	3	;	;	:
18637	9892	4	and	and	CC
18637	9892	5	that	that	DT
18637	9892	6	passed	pass	VBD
18637	9892	7	in	in	IN
18637	9892	8	1867	1867	CD
18637	9892	9	,	,	,
18637	9892	10	punishing	punish	VBG
18637	9892	11	,	,	,
18637	9892	12	by	by	IN
18637	9892	13	dismissal	dismissal	NN
18637	9892	14	from	from	IN
18637	9892	15	service	service	NN
18637	9892	16	,	,	,
18637	9892	17	an	an	DT
18637	9892	18	officer	officer	NN
18637	9892	19	or	or	CC
18637	9892	20	employÃ	employÃ	NNP
18637	9892	21	©	©	NNP
18637	9892	22	of	of	IN
18637	9892	23	the	the	DT
18637	9892	24	government	government	NN
18637	9892	25	who	who	WP
18637	9892	26	requires	require	VBZ
18637	9892	27	or	or	CC
18637	9892	28	requests	request	VBZ
18637	9892	29	any	any	DT
18637	9892	30	workingman	workingman	NN
18637	9892	31	in	in	IN
18637	9892	32	a	a	DT
18637	9892	33	navy	navy	NNP
18637	9892	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	9892	35	yard	yard	NN
18637	9892	36	to	to	TO
18637	9892	37	contribute	contribute	VB
18637	9892	38	or	or	CC
18637	9892	39	pay	pay	VB
18637	9892	40	any	any	DT
18637	9892	41	money	money	NN
18637	9892	42	for	for	IN
18637	9892	43	political	political	JJ
18637	9892	44	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	9892	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9892	46	i	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9892	47	d	d	NNP
18637	9892	48	.	.	NNP
18637	9892	49	,	,	,
18637	9892	50	sect	sect	NN
18637	9892	51	.	.	.
18637	9893	1	1546	1546	CD
18637	9893	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9893	3	;	;	:
18637	9893	4	and	and	CC
18637	9893	5	that	that	DT
18637	9893	6	passed	pass	VBD
18637	9893	7	in	in	IN
18637	9893	8	1868	1868	CD
18637	9893	9	,	,	,
18637	9893	10	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	9893	11	members	member	NNS
18637	9893	12	of	of	IN
18637	9893	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9893	14	from	from	IN
18637	9893	15	being	be	VBG
18637	9893	16	interested	interested	JJ
18637	9893	17	in	in	IN
18637	9893	18	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	9893	19	with	with	IN
18637	9893	20	the	the	DT
18637	9893	21	United	United	NNP
18637	9893	22	States	States	NNP
18637	9893	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9893	24	i	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9893	25	d	d	NNP
18637	9893	26	.	.	NNP
18637	9893	27	,	,	,
18637	9893	28	sect	sect	NN
18637	9893	29	.	.	.
18637	9894	1	3739	3739	CD
18637	9894	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9894	3	;	;	:
18637	9894	4	and	and	CC
18637	9894	5	another	another	DT
18637	9894	6	,	,	,
18637	9894	7	passed	pass	VBN
18637	9894	8	in	in	IN
18637	9894	9	1870	1870	CD
18637	9894	10	,	,	,
18637	9894	11	which	which	WDT
18637	9894	12	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	9894	13	that	that	IN
18637	9894	14	no	no	DT
18637	9894	15	officer	officer	NN
18637	9894	16	,	,	,
18637	9894	17	clerk	clerk	NN
18637	9894	18	,	,	,
18637	9894	19	or	or	CC
18637	9894	20	employÃ	employÃ	NNP
18637	9894	21	©	©	NNP
18637	9894	22	in	in	IN
18637	9894	23	the	the	DT
18637	9894	24	government	government	NN
18637	9894	25	of	of	IN
18637	9894	26	the	the	DT
18637	9894	27	United	United	NNP
18637	9894	28	States	States	NNP
18637	9894	29	shall	shall	MD
18637	9894	30	solicit	solicit	VB
18637	9894	31	contributions	contribution	NNS
18637	9894	32	from	from	IN
18637	9894	33	other	other	JJ
18637	9894	34	officers	officer	NNS
18637	9894	35	,	,	,
18637	9894	36	clerks	clerk	NNS
18637	9894	37	,	,	,
18637	9894	38	or	or	CC
18637	9894	39	employÃ	employÃ	NNP
18637	9894	40	©	©	NNP
18637	9894	41	s	s	VBZ
18637	9894	42	for	for	IN
18637	9894	43	a	a	DT
18637	9894	44	gift	gift	NN
18637	9894	45	to	to	IN
18637	9894	46	those	those	DT
18637	9894	47	in	in	IN
18637	9894	48	a	a	DT
18637	9894	49	superior	superior	JJ
18637	9894	50	official	official	JJ
18637	9894	51	position	position	NN
18637	9894	52	,	,	,
18637	9894	53	and	and	CC
18637	9894	54	that	that	IN
18637	9894	55	no	no	DT
18637	9894	56	officials	official	NNS
18637	9894	57	or	or	CC
18637	9894	58	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9894	59	clerical	clerical	JJ
18637	9894	60	superiors	superior	NNS
18637	9894	61	shall	shall	MD
18637	9894	62	receive	receive	VB
18637	9894	63	any	any	DT
18637	9894	64	gift	gift	NN
18637	9894	65	or	or	CC
18637	9894	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9894	67	present	present	JJ
18637	9894	68	as	as	IN
18637	9894	69	a	a	DT
18637	9894	70	contribution	contribution	NN
18637	9894	71	to	to	IN
18637	9894	72	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9894	73	from	from	IN
18637	9894	74	persons	person	NNS
18637	9894	75	in	in	IN
18637	9894	76	government	government	NN
18637	9894	77	employ	employ	NN
18637	9894	78	getting	get	VBG
18637	9894	79	a	a	DT
18637	9894	80	less	less	JJR
18637	9894	81	salary	salary	NN
18637	9894	82	than	than	IN
18637	9894	83	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9894	84	,	,	,
18637	9894	85	and	and	CC
18637	9894	86	that	that	IN
18637	9894	87	no	no	DT
18637	9894	88	officer	officer	NN
18637	9894	89	or	or	CC
18637	9894	90	clerk	clerk	NN
18637	9894	91	shall	shall	MD
18637	9894	92	make	make	VB
18637	9894	93	a	a	DT
18637	9894	94	donation	donation	NN
18637	9894	95	as	as	IN
18637	9894	96	a	a	DT
18637	9894	97	gift	gift	NN
18637	9894	98	or	or	CC
18637	9894	99	present	present	JJ
18637	9894	100	to	to	IN
18637	9894	101	any	any	DT
18637	9894	102	official	official	JJ
18637	9894	103	superior	superior	NN
18637	9894	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9894	105	i	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9894	106	d	d	NNP
18637	9894	107	.	.	NNP
18637	9894	108	,	,	,
18637	9894	109	sect	sect	NN
18637	9894	110	.	.	.
18637	9895	1	1784	1784	CD
18637	9895	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9895	3	.	.	.
18637	9896	1	Many	many	JJ
18637	9896	2	others	other	NNS
18637	9896	3	of	of	IN
18637	9896	4	a	a	DT
18637	9896	5	kindred	kindred	JJ
18637	9896	6	character	character	NN
18637	9896	7	might	may	MD
18637	9896	8	be	be	VB
18637	9896	9	referred	refer	VBN
18637	9896	10	to	to	IN
18637	9896	11	,	,	,
18637	9896	12	but	but	CC
18637	9896	13	these	these	DT
18637	9896	14	are	be	VBP
18637	9896	15	enough	enough	JJ
18637	9896	16	to	to	TO
18637	9896	17	show	show	VB
18637	9896	18	what	what	WP
18637	9896	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	9896	20	been	be	VBN
18637	9896	21	the	the	DT
18637	9896	22	practice	practice	NN
18637	9896	23	in	in	IN
18637	9896	24	the	the	DT
18637	9896	25	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	9896	26	Department	Department	NNP
18637	9896	27	of	of	IN
18637	9896	28	the	the	DT
18637	9896	29	Government	Government	NNP
18637	9896	30	from	from	IN
18637	9896	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9896	32	organization	organization	NN
18637	9896	33	,	,	,
18637	9896	34	and	and	CC
18637	9896	35	,	,	,
18637	9896	36	so	so	RB
18637	9896	37	far	far	RB
18637	9896	38	as	as	IN
18637	9896	39	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9896	40	know	know	VBP
18637	9896	41	,	,	,
18637	9896	42	this	this	DT
18637	9896	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	9896	44	the	the	DT
18637	9896	45	first	first	JJ
18637	9896	46	time	time	NN
18637	9896	47	the	the	DT
18637	9896	48	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	9896	49	of	of	IN
18637	9896	50	such	such	JJ
18637	9896	51	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	9896	52	has	have	VBZ
18637	9896	53	ever	ever	RB
18637	9896	54	been	be	VBN
18637	9896	55	presented	present	VBN
18637	9896	56	for	for	IN
18637	9896	57	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	9896	58	determination	determination	NN
18637	9896	59	.	.	.
18637	9896	60	"	"	''
18637	9897	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	9897	2	.	.	.
18637	9898	1	372	372	CD
18637	9898	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9898	3	373	373	CD
18637	9898	4	.	.	.
18637	9899	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9899	2	287	287	CD
18637	9899	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9899	4	5	5	CD
18637	9899	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	9900	1	§§	§§	NFP
18637	9900	2	631	631	CD
18637	9900	3	-	-	SYM
18637	9900	4	642	642	CD
18637	9900	5	.	.	.
18637	9901	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9901	2	288	288	CD
18637	9901	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9901	4	54	54	CD
18637	9901	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9901	6	.	.	.
18637	9902	1	767	767	CD
18637	9902	2	,	,	,
18637	9902	3	771	771	CD
18637	9902	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9902	5	1940	1940	CD
18637	9902	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9902	7	.	.	.
18637	9903	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9903	2	289	289	CD
18637	9903	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9903	4	330	330	CD
18637	9903	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9903	6	75	75	CD
18637	9903	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9903	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	9903	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9903	10	.	.	.
18637	9904	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9904	2	290	290	CD
18637	9904	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9904	4	18	18	CD
18637	9904	5	U.S.C.	u.s.c.	NN
18637	9905	1	611	611	CD
18637	9905	2	.	.	.
18637	9906	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9906	2	291	291	CD
18637	9906	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9906	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9906	5	See	See	NNP
18637	9906	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9906	7	Bills	Bills	NNPS
18637	9906	8	Listed	list	VBN
18637	9906	9	in	in	IN
18637	9906	10	Index	Index	NNP
18637	9906	11	to	to	IN
18637	9906	12	Digest	Digest	NNP
18637	9906	13	of	of	IN
18637	9906	14	Public	Public	NNP
18637	9906	15	General	General	NNP
18637	9906	16	Bills	Bills	NNPS
18637	9906	17	,	,	,
18637	9906	18	79th	79th	NN
18637	9906	19	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	9906	20	.	.	NNP
18637	9906	21	,	,	,
18637	9906	22	2d	2d	CD
18637	9906	23	sess	sess	NN
18637	9906	24	.	.	.
18637	9907	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9907	2	292	292	CD
18637	9907	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9907	4	12	12	CD
18637	9907	5	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	9907	6	Reg	Reg	NNP
18637	9907	7	.	.	.
18637	9908	1	1935	1935	CD
18637	9908	2	.	.	.
18637	9909	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9909	2	293	293	CD
18637	9909	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9909	4	Shoemaker	Shoemaker	NNP
18637	9909	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9909	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9909	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9909	8	Unite	Unite	NNP
18637	9909	9	States	States	NNP
18637	9909	10	,	,	,
18637	9909	11	147	147	CD
18637	9909	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9909	13	282	282	CD
18637	9909	14	,	,	,
18637	9909	15	301	301	CD
18637	9909	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9909	17	1893	1893	CD
18637	9909	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9909	19	.	.	.
18637	9910	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9910	2	294	294	CD
18637	9910	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9910	4	United	United	NNP
18637	9910	5	States	States	NNP
18637	9910	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9910	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	9910	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9910	9	Germaine	Germaine	NNP
18637	9910	10	,	,	,
18637	9910	11	99	99	CD
18637	9910	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9910	13	508	508	CD
18637	9910	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9910	15	1879	1879	CD
18637	9910	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9910	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	9910	18	the	the	DT
18637	9910	19	leading	leading	JJ
18637	9910	20	case	case	NN
18637	9910	21	.	.	.
18637	9911	1	For	for	IN
18637	9911	2	further	further	JJ
18637	9911	3	citations	citation	NNS
18637	9911	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9911	5	see	see	VBP
18637	9911	6	_	_	NNP
18637	9911	7	Auffmordt	Auffmordt	NNP
18637	9911	8	_	_	NNP
18637	9911	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	9911	10	_	_	NNP
18637	9911	11	Hedden	Hedden	NNP
18637	9911	12	,	,	,
18637	9911	13	137	137	CD
18637	9911	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9911	15	310	310	CD
18637	9911	16	,	,	,
18637	9911	17	327	327	CD
18637	9911	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9911	19	1890	1890	CD
18637	9911	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9911	21	.	.	.
18637	9912	1	The	the	DT
18637	9912	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	9912	3	will	will	MD
18637	9912	4	,	,	,
18637	9912	5	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	9912	6	,	,	,
18637	9912	7	be	be	VB
18637	9912	8	astute	astute	JJ
18637	9912	9	to	to	TO
18637	9912	10	ascribe	ascribe	VB
18637	9912	11	to	to	IN
18637	9912	12	a	a	DT
18637	9912	13	head	head	NN
18637	9912	14	of	of	IN
18637	9912	15	department	department	NN
18637	9912	16	an	an	DT
18637	9912	17	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	9912	18	made	make	VBN
18637	9912	19	by	by	IN
18637	9912	20	an	an	DT
18637	9912	21	inferior	inferior	NN
18637	9912	22	of	of	IN
18637	9912	23	such	such	JJ
18637	9912	24	head	head	NN
18637	9912	25	.	.	.
18637	9913	1	Nishimura	Nishimura	NNP
18637	9913	2	Ekiu	Ekiu	NNP
18637	9913	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9913	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	9913	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9913	6	United	United	NNP
18637	9913	7	States	States	NNP
18637	9913	8	,	,	,
18637	9913	9	142	142	CD
18637	9913	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9913	11	651	651	CD
18637	9913	12	,	,	,
18637	9913	13	663	663	CD
18637	9913	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9913	15	1892	1892	CD
18637	9913	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9913	17	.	.	.
18637	9914	1	For	for	IN
18637	9914	2	the	the	DT
18637	9914	3	view	view	NN
18637	9914	4	that	that	IN
18637	9914	5	there	there	EX
18637	9914	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	9914	7	an	an	DT
18637	9914	8	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
18637	9914	9	difference	difference	NN
18637	9914	10	between	between	IN
18637	9914	11	a	a	DT
18637	9914	12	"	"	``
18637	9914	13	public	public	JJ
18637	9914	14	office	office	NN
18637	9914	15	"	"	''
18637	9914	16	and	and	CC
18637	9914	17	a	a	DT
18637	9914	18	"	"	``
18637	9914	19	public	public	JJ
18637	9914	20	employment	employment	NN
18637	9914	21	"	"	''
18637	9914	22	_	_	NNP
18637	9914	23	see	see	VBP
18637	9914	24	_	_	NNP
18637	9914	25	Mechem	Mechem	NNP
18637	9914	26	,	,	,
18637	9914	27	Public	Public	NNP
18637	9914	28	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	9914	29	,	,	,
18637	9914	30	pp	pp	NNP
18637	9914	31	.	.	.
18637	9915	1	3	3	CD
18637	9915	2	-	-	SYM
18637	9915	3	5	5	CD
18637	9915	4	.	.	.
18637	9916	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9916	2	295	295	CD
18637	9916	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9916	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	9916	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	9916	6	Hennen	Hennen	NNP
18637	9916	7	,	,	,
18637	9916	8	13	13	CD
18637	9916	9	Pet	pet	NN
18637	9916	10	.	.	.
18637	9917	1	230	230	CD
18637	9917	2	,	,	,
18637	9917	3	257	257	CD
18637	9917	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9917	5	258	258	CD
18637	9917	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9917	7	1839	1839	CD
18637	9917	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9917	9	;	;	:
18637	9917	10	United	United	NNP
18637	9917	11	States	States	NNP
18637	9917	12	_	_	NNP
18637	9917	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	9917	14	_	_	NNP
18637	9917	15	Germaine	Germaine	NNP
18637	9917	16	,	,	,
18637	9917	17	99	99	CD
18637	9917	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9917	19	508	508	CD
18637	9917	20	,	,	,
18637	9917	21	509	509	CD
18637	9917	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9917	23	1879	1879	CD
18637	9917	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9917	25	.	.	.
18637	9918	1	The	the	DT
18637	9918	2	statement	statement	NN
18637	9918	3	on	on	IN
18637	9918	4	the	the	DT
18637	9918	5	point	point	NN
18637	9918	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	9918	7	in	in	IN
18637	9918	8	both	both	DT
18637	9918	9	instances	instance	NNS
18637	9918	10	obiter	obiter	VBP
18637	9918	11	.	.	.
18637	9919	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9919	2	296	296	CD
18637	9919	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9919	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	9919	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	9919	6	Siebold	Siebold	NNP
18637	9919	7	,	,	,
18637	9919	8	100	100	CD
18637	9919	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9919	10	371	371	CD
18637	9919	11	,	,	,
18637	9919	12	397	397	CD
18637	9919	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9919	14	1880	1880	CD
18637	9919	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9919	16	.	.	.
18637	9920	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9920	2	297	297	CD
18637	9920	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9920	4	"	"	``
18637	9920	5	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9920	6	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9920	7	the	the	DT
18637	9920	8	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	9920	9	of	of	IN
18637	9920	10	the	the	DT
18637	9920	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9920	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9920	13	seem	seem	VBP
18637	9920	14	to	to	TO
18637	9920	15	contemplate	contemplate	VB
18637	9920	16	three	three	CD
18637	9920	17	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	9920	18	operations	operation	NNS
18637	9920	19	:	:	:
18637	9920	20	1st	1st	NN
18637	9920	21	.	.	.
18637	9921	1	The	the	DT
18637	9921	2	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	9921	3	.	.	.
18637	9922	1	This	this	DT
18637	9922	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	9922	3	the	the	DT
18637	9922	4	sole	sole	JJ
18637	9922	5	act	act	NN
18637	9922	6	of	of	IN
18637	9922	7	the	the	DT
18637	9922	8	President	President	NNP
18637	9922	9	,	,	,
18637	9922	10	and	and	CC
18637	9922	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	9922	12	completely	completely	RB
18637	9922	13	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	9922	14	.	.	.
18637	9923	1	2d	2d	LS
18637	9923	2	.	.	.
18637	9924	1	The	the	DT
18637	9924	2	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	9924	3	.	.	.
18637	9925	1	This	this	DT
18637	9925	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	9925	3	also	also	RB
18637	9925	4	the	the	DT
18637	9925	5	act	act	NN
18637	9925	6	of	of	IN
18637	9925	7	the	the	DT
18637	9925	8	President	President	NNP
18637	9925	9	,	,	,
18637	9925	10	and	and	CC
18637	9925	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	9925	12	also	also	RB
18637	9925	13	a	a	DT
18637	9925	14	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	9925	15	act	act	NN
18637	9925	16	,	,	,
18637	9925	17	though	though	IN
18637	9925	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9925	19	can	can	MD
18637	9925	20	only	only	RB
18637	9925	21	be	be	VB
18637	9925	22	performed	perform	VBN
18637	9925	23	by	by	IN
18637	9925	24	and	and	CC
18637	9925	25	with	with	IN
18637	9925	26	the	the	DT
18637	9925	27	advice	advice	NN
18637	9925	28	and	and	CC
18637	9925	29	consent	consent	NN
18637	9925	30	of	of	IN
18637	9925	31	the	the	DT
18637	9925	32	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9925	33	.	.	.
18637	9926	1	3d	3d	LS
18637	9926	2	.	.	.
18637	9927	1	The	the	DT
18637	9927	2	commission	commission	NN
18637	9927	3	.	.	.
18637	9928	1	To	to	TO
18637	9928	2	grant	grant	VB
18637	9928	3	a	a	DT
18637	9928	4	commission	commission	NN
18637	9928	5	to	to	IN
18637	9928	6	a	a	DT
18637	9928	7	person	person	NN
18637	9928	8	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	9928	9	,	,	,
18637	9928	10	might	may	MD
18637	9928	11	,	,	,
18637	9928	12	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	9928	13	,	,	,
18637	9928	14	be	be	VB
18637	9928	15	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	9928	16	a	a	DT
18637	9928	17	duty	duty	NN
18637	9928	18	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	9928	19	by	by	IN
18637	9928	20	the	the	DT
18637	9928	21	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	9928	22	.	.	.
18637	9929	1	'	'	``
18637	9929	2	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9929	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	9929	4	,	,	,
18637	9929	5	'	'	''
18637	9929	6	says	say	VBZ
18637	9929	7	that	that	IN
18637	9929	8	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	9929	9	,	,	,
18637	9929	10	'	'	''
18637	9929	11	commission	commission	NN
18637	9929	12	all	all	PDT
18637	9929	13	the	the	DT
18637	9929	14	officers	officer	NNS
18637	9929	15	of	of	IN
18637	9929	16	the	the	DT
18637	9929	17	United	United	NNP
18637	9929	18	States	States	NNP
18637	9929	19	.	.	.
18637	9929	20	'	'	''
18637	9929	21	"	"	''
18637	9930	1	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	9930	2	_	_	NNP
18637	9930	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	9930	4	_	_	NNP
18637	9930	5	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	9930	6	,	,	,
18637	9930	7	1	1	CD
18637	9930	8	Cr	cr	NN
18637	9930	9	.	.	.
18637	9931	1	137	137	CD
18637	9931	2	,	,	,
18637	9931	3	155	155	CD
18637	9931	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9931	5	156	156	CD
18637	9931	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9931	7	1803	1803	CD
18637	9931	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9931	9	.	.	.
18637	9932	1	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	9932	2	's	's	POS
18637	9932	3	statement	statement	NN
18637	9932	4	that	that	IN
18637	9932	5	the	the	DT
18637	9932	6	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	9932	7	"	"	``
18637	9932	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	9932	9	the	the	DT
18637	9932	10	act	act	NN
18637	9932	11	of	of	IN
18637	9932	12	the	the	DT
18637	9932	13	President	President	NNP
18637	9932	14	,	,	,
18637	9932	15	"	"	''
18637	9932	16	conflicts	conflict	NNS
18637	9932	17	with	with	IN
18637	9932	18	the	the	DT
18637	9932	19	more	more	RBR
18637	9932	20	generally	generally	RB
18637	9932	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	9932	22	,	,	,
18637	9932	23	and	and	CC
18637	9932	24	sensible	sensible	JJ
18637	9932	25	view	view	NN
18637	9932	26	that	that	IN
18637	9932	27	when	when	WRB
18637	9932	28	an	an	DT
18637	9932	29	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	9932	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	9932	31	made	make	VBN
18637	9932	32	with	with	IN
18637	9932	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9932	34	consent	consent	NN
18637	9932	35	,	,	,
18637	9932	36	the	the	DT
18637	9932	37	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9932	38	shares	share	VBZ
18637	9932	39	the	the	DT
18637	9932	40	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	9932	41	power	power	NN
18637	9932	42	.	.	.
18637	9933	1	1	1	CD
18637	9933	2	Kent	Kent	NNP
18637	9933	3	's	's	POS
18637	9933	4	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	9933	5	.	.	.
18637	9934	1	310	310	CD
18637	9934	2	;	;	:
18637	9934	3	2	2	CD
18637	9934	4	Story	Story	NNP
18637	9934	5	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	9934	6	.	.	.
18637	9935	1	§	§	NNP
18637	9935	2	1539	1539	CD
18637	9935	3	;	;	:
18637	9935	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	9935	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	9935	6	Hennen	Hennen	NNP
18637	9935	7	,	,	,
18637	9935	8	13	13	CD
18637	9935	9	Pet	pet	NN
18637	9935	10	.	.	.
18637	9936	1	225	225	CD
18637	9936	2	,	,	,
18637	9936	3	259	259	CD
18637	9936	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9936	5	1839	1839	CD
18637	9936	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9936	7	.	.	.
18637	9937	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9937	2	298	298	CD
18637	9937	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9937	4	3	3	CD
18637	9937	5	Op	Op	NNP
18637	9937	6	.	.	.
18637	9938	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9938	2	.	.	.
18637	9939	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9939	2	188	188	CD
18637	9939	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9939	4	1837	1837	CD
18637	9939	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9939	6	.	.	.
18637	9940	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9940	2	299	299	CD
18637	9940	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9940	4	2	2	CD
18637	9940	5	Story	Story	NNP
18637	9940	6	Comms	Comms	NNP
18637	9940	7	.	.	NNP
18637	9940	8	,	,	,
18637	9940	9	§	§	NNP
18637	9940	10	1531	1531	CD
18637	9940	11	;	;	:
18637	9940	12	5	5	CD
18637	9940	13	Writings	Writings	NNPS
18637	9940	14	of	of	IN
18637	9940	15	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	9940	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9940	17	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	9940	18	,	,	,
18637	9940	19	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9940	20	.	.	.
18637	9941	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9941	2	,	,	,
18637	9941	3	161	161	CD
18637	9941	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9941	5	1790	1790	CD
18637	9941	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9941	7	;	;	:
18637	9941	8	9	9	CD
18637	9941	9	Writings	writing	NNS
18637	9941	10	of	of	IN
18637	9941	11	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	9941	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9941	13	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
18637	9941	14	,	,	,
18637	9941	15	ed	ed	NN
18637	9941	16	.	.	.
18637	9942	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9942	2	,	,	,
18637	9942	3	111	111	CD
18637	9942	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9942	5	113	113	CD
18637	9942	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9942	7	1822	1822	CD
18637	9942	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9942	9	.	.	.
18637	9943	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9943	2	300	300	CD
18637	9943	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9943	4	286	286	CD
18637	9943	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9943	6	6	6	CD
18637	9943	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9943	8	1932	1932	CD
18637	9943	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9943	10	.	.	.
18637	9944	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9944	2	301	301	CD
18637	9944	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9944	4	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	9944	5	,	,	,
18637	9944	6	The	the	DT
18637	9944	7	President	President	NNP
18637	9944	8	,	,	,
18637	9944	9	Office	Office	NNP
18637	9944	10	and	and	CC
18637	9944	11	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	9944	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9944	13	3d	3d	NNP
18637	9944	14	ed	ed	NNP
18637	9944	15	.	.	.
18637	9945	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9945	2	,	,	,
18637	9945	3	92	92	CD
18637	9945	4	.	.	.
18637	9946	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9946	2	302	302	CD
18637	9946	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9946	4	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	9946	5	_	_	NNP
18637	9946	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	9946	7	_	_	NNP
18637	9946	8	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	9946	9	,	,	,
18637	9946	10	1	1	CD
18637	9946	11	Cr	cr	NN
18637	9946	12	.	.	.
18637	9947	1	137	137	CD
18637	9947	2	,	,	,
18637	9947	3	157	157	CD
18637	9947	4	-	-	SYM
18637	9947	5	158	158	CD
18637	9947	6	,	,	,
18637	9947	7	182	182	CD
18637	9947	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9947	9	1803	1803	CD
18637	9947	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9947	11	.	.	.
18637	9948	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9948	2	303	303	CD
18637	9948	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9948	4	12	12	CD
18637	9948	5	Op	Op	NNP
18637	9948	6	.	.	.
18637	9949	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9949	2	.	.	.
18637	9950	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9950	2	306	306	CD
18637	9950	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9950	4	1867	1867	CD
18637	9950	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9950	6	.	.	.
18637	9951	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9951	2	304	304	CD
18637	9951	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9951	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9951	5	should	should	MD
18637	9951	6	be	be	VB
18637	9951	7	remembered	remember	VBN
18637	9951	8	that	that	IN
18637	9951	9	,	,	,
18637	9951	10	for	for	IN
18637	9951	11	various	various	JJ
18637	9951	12	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	9951	13	,	,	,
18637	9951	14	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	9951	15	got	get	VBD
18637	9951	16	neither	neither	CC
18637	9951	17	commission	commission	NN
18637	9951	18	nor	nor	CC
18637	9951	19	office	office	NN
18637	9951	20	.	.	.
18637	9952	1	The	the	DT
18637	9952	2	case	case	NN
18637	9952	3	assumes	assume	VBZ
18637	9952	4	,	,	,
18637	9952	5	in	in	IN
18637	9952	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	9952	7	,	,	,
18637	9952	8	the	the	DT
18637	9952	9	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	9952	10	of	of	IN
18637	9952	11	possession	possession	NN
18637	9952	12	of	of	IN
18637	9952	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9952	14	commission	commission	NN
18637	9952	15	by	by	IN
18637	9952	16	the	the	DT
18637	9952	17	appointee	appointee	NN
18637	9952	18	.	.	.
18637	9953	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9953	2	305	305	CD
18637	9953	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9953	4	Opins	Opins	NNP
18637	9953	5	.	.	.
18637	9954	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9954	2	.	.	.
18637	9955	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9955	2	631	631	CD
18637	9955	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9955	4	1823	1823	CD
18637	9955	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9955	6	;	;	:
18637	9955	7	2	2	CD
18637	9955	8	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9955	9	.	.	.
18637	9956	1	525	525	CD
18637	9956	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9956	3	1832	1832	CD
18637	9956	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9956	5	;	;	:
18637	9956	6	3	3	CD
18637	9956	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9956	8	.	.	.
18637	9957	1	673	673	CD
18637	9957	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9957	3	1841	1841	CD
18637	9957	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9957	5	;	;	:
18637	9957	6	4	4	CD
18637	9957	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9957	8	.	.	.
18637	9958	1	523	523	CD
18637	9958	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9958	3	1846	1846	CD
18637	9958	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9958	5	;	;	:
18637	9958	6	10	10	CD
18637	9958	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9958	8	.	.	.
18637	9959	1	356	356	CD
18637	9959	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9959	3	1862	1862	CD
18637	9959	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9959	5	;	;	:
18637	9959	6	11	11	CD
18637	9959	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9959	8	.	.	.
18637	9960	1	179	179	CD
18637	9960	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9960	3	1865	1865	CD
18637	9960	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9960	5	;	;	:
18637	9960	6	12	12	CD
18637	9960	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9960	8	.	.	.
18637	9961	1	32	32	CD
18637	9961	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9961	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	9961	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9961	5	;	;	:
18637	9961	6	12	12	CD
18637	9961	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9961	8	.	.	.
18637	9962	1	455	455	CD
18637	9962	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9962	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	9962	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9962	5	;	;	:
18637	9962	6	14	14	CD
18637	9962	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9962	8	.	.	.
18637	9963	1	563	563	CD
18637	9963	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9963	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	9963	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9963	5	;	;	:
18637	9963	6	15	15	CD
18637	9963	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9963	8	.	.	.
18637	9964	1	207	207	CD
18637	9964	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9964	3	1877	1877	CD
18637	9964	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9964	5	;	;	:
18637	9964	6	16	16	CD
18637	9964	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9964	8	.	.	.
18637	9965	1	523	523	CD
18637	9965	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9965	3	1880	1880	CD
18637	9965	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9965	5	;	;	:
18637	9965	6	18	18	CD
18637	9965	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9965	8	.	.	.
18637	9966	1	28	28	CD
18637	9966	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9966	3	1884	1884	CD
18637	9966	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9966	5	;	;	:
18637	9966	6	19	19	CD
18637	9966	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9966	8	.	.	.
18637	9967	1	261	261	CD
18637	9967	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9967	3	1889	1889	CD
18637	9967	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9967	5	;	;	:
18637	9967	6	26	26	CD
18637	9967	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9967	8	.	.	.
18637	9968	1	234	234	CD
18637	9968	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9968	3	1907	1907	CD
18637	9968	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9968	5	;	;	:
18637	9968	6	30	30	CD
18637	9968	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9968	8	.	.	.
18637	9969	1	314	314	CD
18637	9969	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9969	3	1914	1914	CD
18637	9969	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9969	5	;	;	:
18637	9969	6	33	33	CD
18637	9969	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9969	8	.	.	.
18637	9970	1	20	20	CD
18637	9970	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9970	3	1921	1921	CD
18637	9970	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9970	5	.	.	.
18637	9971	1	In	in	IN
18637	9971	2	4	4	CD
18637	9971	3	Opins	Opins	NNPS
18637	9971	4	.	.	.
18637	9972	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9972	2	.	.	.
18637	9973	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9973	2	361	361	CD
18637	9973	3	,	,	,
18637	9973	4	363	363	CD
18637	9973	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9973	6	1845	1845	CD
18637	9973	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9973	8	,	,	,
18637	9973	9	the	the	DT
18637	9973	10	general	general	JJ
18637	9973	11	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	9973	12	was	be	VBD
18637	9973	13	held	hold	VBN
18637	9973	14	not	not	RB
18637	9973	15	to	to	TO
18637	9973	16	apply	apply	VB
18637	9973	17	to	to	IN
18637	9973	18	a	a	DT
18637	9973	19	yet	yet	RB
18637	9973	20	unfilled	unfilled	JJ
18637	9973	21	office	office	NN
18637	9973	22	which	which	WDT
18637	9973	23	was	be	VBD
18637	9973	24	created	create	VBN
18637	9973	25	during	during	IN
18637	9973	26	the	the	DT
18637	9973	27	previous	previous	JJ
18637	9973	28	session	session	NN
18637	9973	29	of	of	IN
18637	9973	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9973	31	,	,	,
18637	9973	32	but	but	CC
18637	9973	33	this	this	DT
18637	9973	34	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	9973	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	9973	36	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	9973	37	in	in	IN
18637	9973	38	12	12	CD
18637	9973	39	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9973	40	.	.	.
18637	9974	1	455	455	CD
18637	9974	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9974	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	9974	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9974	5	;	;	:
18637	9974	6	18	18	CD
18637	9974	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9974	8	.	.	.
18637	9975	1	28	28	CD
18637	9975	2	;	;	:
18637	9975	3	and	and	CC
18637	9975	4	19	19	CD
18637	9975	5	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9975	6	.	.	.
18637	9976	1	261	261	CD
18637	9976	2	.	.	.
18637	9977	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9977	2	306	306	CD
18637	9977	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9977	4	23	23	CD
18637	9977	5	Opins	Opins	NNPS
18637	9977	6	.	.	.
18637	9978	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9978	2	.	.	.
18637	9979	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9979	2	599	599	CD
18637	9979	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9979	4	1901	1901	CD
18637	9979	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9979	6	;	;	:
18637	9979	7	22	22	CD
18637	9979	8	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9979	9	.	.	.
18637	9980	1	82	82	CD
18637	9980	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9980	3	1898	1898	CD
18637	9980	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9980	5	.	.	.
18637	9981	1	A	a	DT
18637	9981	2	"	"	``
18637	9981	3	recess	recess	NN
18637	9981	4	"	"	''
18637	9981	5	may	may	MD
18637	9981	6	,	,	,
18637	9981	7	however	however	RB
18637	9981	8	,	,	,
18637	9981	9	be	be	VB
18637	9981	10	merely	merely	RB
18637	9981	11	"	"	``
18637	9981	12	constructive	constructive	JJ
18637	9981	13	,	,	,
18637	9981	14	"	"	''
18637	9981	15	as	as	IN
18637	9981	16	when	when	WRB
18637	9981	17	a	a	DT
18637	9981	18	regular	regular	JJ
18637	9981	19	session	session	NN
18637	9981	20	succeeds	succeed	VBZ
18637	9981	21	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	9981	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	9981	23	a	a	DT
18637	9981	24	special	special	JJ
18637	9981	25	session	session	NN
18637	9981	26	.	.	.
18637	9982	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	9982	2	was	be	VBD
18637	9982	3	this	this	DT
18637	9982	4	kind	kind	NN
18637	9982	5	of	of	IN
18637	9982	6	situation	situation	NN
18637	9982	7	that	that	WDT
18637	9982	8	gave	give	VBD
18637	9982	9	rise	rise	NN
18637	9982	10	to	to	IN
18637	9982	11	the	the	DT
18637	9982	12	once	once	RB
18637	9982	13	famous	famous	JJ
18637	9982	14	_	_	NNP
18637	9982	15	Crum	Crum	NNP
18637	9982	16	_	_	NNP
18637	9982	17	incident	incident	NN
18637	9982	18	.	.	.
18637	9983	1	_	_	NNP
18637	9983	2	See	See	NNP
18637	9983	3	_	_	NNP
18637	9983	4	Willoughby	Willoughby	NNP
18637	9983	5	,	,	,
18637	9983	6	III	III	NNP
18637	9983	7	,	,	,
18637	9983	8	1508	1508	CD
18637	9983	9	-	-	SYM
18637	9983	10	1509	1509	CD
18637	9983	11	.	.	.
18637	9984	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9984	2	307	307	CD
18637	9984	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9984	4	5	5	CD
18637	9984	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
18637	9985	1	§	§	NNP
18637	9985	2	56	56	CD
18637	9985	3	.	.	.
18637	9986	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9986	2	308	308	CD
18637	9986	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9986	4	6	6	CD
18637	9986	5	Opins	Opins	NNPS
18637	9986	6	.	.	.
18637	9987	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	9987	2	.	.	.
18637	9988	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	9988	2	358	358	CD
18637	9988	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9988	4	1854	1854	CD
18637	9988	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9988	6	;	;	:
18637	9988	7	12	12	CD
18637	9988	8	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9988	9	.	.	.
18637	9989	1	41	41	CD
18637	9989	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9989	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	9989	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9989	5	;	;	:
18637	9989	6	25	25	CD
18637	9989	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9989	8	.	.	.
18637	9990	1	259	259	CD
18637	9990	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9990	3	1904	1904	CD
18637	9990	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9990	5	;	;	:
18637	9990	6	28	28	CD
18637	9990	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	9990	8	.	.	.
18637	9991	1	95	95	CD
18637	9991	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9991	3	1909	1909	CD
18637	9991	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9991	5	.	.	.
18637	9992	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9992	2	309	309	CD
18637	9992	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9992	4	272	272	CD
18637	9992	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9992	6	52	52	CD
18637	9992	7	.	.	.
18637	9993	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9993	2	310	310	CD
18637	9993	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9993	4	19	19	CD
18637	9993	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	9993	6	.	.	.
18637	9994	1	78	78	CD
18637	9994	2	,	,	,
18637	9994	3	80	80	CD
18637	9994	4	.	.	.
18637	9995	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9995	2	311	311	CD
18637	9995	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9995	4	272	272	CD
18637	9995	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	9995	6	163	163	CD
18637	9995	7	-	-	SYM
18637	9995	8	164	164	CD
18637	9995	9	.	.	.
18637	9996	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	9996	2	312	312	CD
18637	9996	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	9996	4	The	the	DT
18637	9996	5	reticence	reticence	NN
18637	9996	6	of	of	IN
18637	9996	7	the	the	DT
18637	9996	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9996	9	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	9996	10	removal	removal	NN
18637	9996	11	left	leave	VBD
18637	9996	12	room	room	NN
18637	9996	13	for	for	IN
18637	9996	14	four	four	CD
18637	9996	15	possibilities	possibility	NNS
18637	9996	16	,	,	,
18637	9996	17	_	_	NNP
18637	9996	18	first	first	JJ
18637	9996	19	_	_	NNP
18637	9996	20	,	,	,
18637	9996	21	the	the	DT
18637	9996	22	one	one	NN
18637	9996	23	suggested	suggest	VBN
18637	9996	24	by	by	IN
18637	9996	25	the	the	DT
18637	9996	26	common	common	JJ
18637	9996	27	law	law	NN
18637	9996	28	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	9996	29	of	of	IN
18637	9996	30	"	"	``
18637	9996	31	estate	estate	NNP
18637	9996	32	in	in	IN
18637	9996	33	office	office	NN
18637	9996	34	,	,	,
18637	9996	35	"	"	''
18637	9996	36	from	from	IN
18637	9996	37	which	which	WDT
18637	9996	38	the	the	DT
18637	9996	39	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	9996	40	followed	follow	VBD
18637	9996	41	that	that	IN
18637	9996	42	the	the	DT
18637	9996	43	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	9996	44	power	power	NN
18637	9996	45	was	be	VBD
18637	9996	46	the	the	DT
18637	9996	47	only	only	JJ
18637	9996	48	power	power	NN
18637	9996	49	of	of	IN
18637	9996	50	removal	removal	NN
18637	9996	51	intended	intend	VBN
18637	9996	52	by	by	IN
18637	9996	53	the	the	DT
18637	9996	54	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9996	55	;	;	:
18637	9996	56	_	_	NNP
18637	9996	57	second	second	JJ
18637	9996	58	_	_	NNP
18637	9996	59	,	,	,
18637	9996	60	that	that	IN
18637	9996	61	the	the	DT
18637	9996	62	power	power	NN
18637	9996	63	of	of	IN
18637	9996	64	removal	removal	NN
18637	9996	65	was	be	VBD
18637	9996	66	an	an	DT
18637	9996	67	incident	incident	NN
18637	9996	68	of	of	IN
18637	9996	69	the	the	DT
18637	9996	70	power	power	NN
18637	9996	71	of	of	IN
18637	9996	72	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	9996	73	and	and	CC
18637	9996	74	hence	hence	RB
18637	9996	75	belonged	belong	VBN
18637	9996	76	,	,	,
18637	9996	77	at	at	IN
18637	9996	78	any	any	DT
18637	9996	79	rate	rate	NN
18637	9996	80	in	in	IN
18637	9996	81	the	the	DT
18637	9996	82	absence	absence	NN
18637	9996	83	of	of	IN
18637	9996	84	legal	legal	JJ
18637	9996	85	or	or	CC
18637	9996	86	other	other	JJ
18637	9996	87	provision	provision	NN
18637	9996	88	to	to	IN
18637	9996	89	the	the	DT
18637	9996	90	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	9996	91	,	,	,
18637	9996	92	to	to	IN
18637	9996	93	the	the	DT
18637	9996	94	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	9996	95	authority	authority	NN
18637	9996	96	;	;	:
18637	9996	97	_	_	NNP
18637	9996	98	third	third	JJ
18637	9996	99	_	_	NNP
18637	9996	100	,	,	,
18637	9996	101	that	that	IN
18637	9996	102	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9996	103	could	could	MD
18637	9996	104	,	,	,
18637	9996	105	by	by	IN
18637	9996	106	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	9996	107	of	of	IN
18637	9996	108	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9996	109	power	power	NN
18637	9996	110	"	"	''
18637	9996	111	to	to	TO
18637	9996	112	make	make	VB
18637	9996	113	all	all	DT
18637	9996	114	laws	law	NNS
18637	9996	115	which	which	WDT
18637	9996	116	shall	shall	MD
18637	9996	117	be	be	VB
18637	9996	118	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	9996	119	and	and	CC
18637	9996	120	proper	proper	JJ
18637	9996	121	,	,	,
18637	9996	122	"	"	''
18637	9996	123	etc	etc	FW
18637	9996	124	.	.	.
18637	9996	125	,	,	,
18637	9996	126	determine	determine	VB
18637	9996	127	the	the	DT
18637	9996	128	location	location	NN
18637	9996	129	of	of	IN
18637	9996	130	the	the	DT
18637	9996	131	removal	removal	NN
18637	9996	132	of	of	IN
18637	9996	133	power	power	NN
18637	9996	134	;	;	:
18637	9996	135	_	_	NNP
18637	9996	136	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	9996	137	_	_	NNP
18637	9996	138	,	,	,
18637	9996	139	that	that	IN
18637	9996	140	the	the	DT
18637	9996	141	President	President	NNP
18637	9996	142	by	by	IN
18637	9996	143	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	9996	144	of	of	IN
18637	9996	145	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9996	146	"	"	``
18637	9996	147	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9996	148	power	power	NN
18637	9996	149	"	"	''
18637	9996	150	and	and	CC
18637	9996	151	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9996	152	duty	duty	NN
18637	9996	153	"	"	''
18637	9996	154	to	to	TO
18637	9996	155	take	take	VB
18637	9996	156	care	care	NN
18637	9996	157	that	that	IN
18637	9996	158	the	the	DT
18637	9996	159	laws	law	NNS
18637	9996	160	be	be	VB
18637	9996	161	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	9996	162	executed	execute	VBN
18637	9996	163	,	,	,
18637	9996	164	"	"	''
18637	9996	165	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	9996	166	the	the	DT
18637	9996	167	power	power	NN
18637	9996	168	of	of	IN
18637	9996	169	removal	removal	NN
18637	9996	170	over	over	IN
18637	9996	171	all	all	DT
18637	9996	172	officers	officer	NNS
18637	9996	173	of	of	IN
18637	9996	174	the	the	DT
18637	9996	175	United	United	NNP
18637	9996	176	States	States	NNP
18637	9996	177	except	except	IN
18637	9996	178	judges	judge	NNS
18637	9996	179	.	.	.
18637	9997	1	In	in	IN
18637	9997	2	the	the	DT
18637	9997	3	course	course	NN
18637	9997	4	of	of	IN
18637	9997	5	the	the	DT
18637	9997	6	debate	debate	NN
18637	9997	7	on	on	IN
18637	9997	8	the	the	DT
18637	9997	9	act	act	NN
18637	9997	10	to	to	TO
18637	9997	11	establish	establish	VB
18637	9997	12	a	a	DT
18637	9997	13	Department	Department	NNP
18637	9997	14	of	of	IN
18637	9997	15	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	9997	16	Affairs	Affairs	NNPS
18637	9997	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	9997	18	later	later	RB
18637	9997	19	changed	change	VBN
18637	9997	20	to	to	IN
18637	9997	21	Department	Department	NNP
18637	9997	22	of	of	IN
18637	9997	23	State	State	NNP
18637	9997	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	9997	25	all	all	DT
18637	9997	26	of	of	IN
18637	9997	27	these	these	DT
18637	9997	28	views	view	NNS
18637	9997	29	were	be	VBD
18637	9997	30	put	put	VBN
18637	9997	31	forward	forward	RB
18637	9997	32	,	,	,
18637	9997	33	with	with	IN
18637	9997	34	the	the	DT
18637	9997	35	final	final	JJ
18637	9997	36	result	result	NN
18637	9997	37	that	that	IN
18637	9997	38	a	a	DT
18637	9997	39	clause	clause	NN
18637	9997	40	was	be	VBD
18637	9997	41	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	9997	42	in	in	IN
18637	9997	43	the	the	DT
18637	9997	44	measure	measure	NN
18637	9997	45	which	which	WDT
18637	9997	46	implied	imply	VBD
18637	9997	47	,	,	,
18637	9997	48	as	as	IN
18637	9997	49	pointed	point	VBN
18637	9997	50	out	out	RP
18637	9997	51	above	above	RB
18637	9997	52	,	,	,
18637	9997	53	that	that	IN
18637	9997	54	the	the	DT
18637	9997	55	head	head	NN
18637	9997	56	of	of	IN
18637	9997	57	the	the	DT
18637	9997	58	department	department	NN
18637	9997	59	would	would	MD
18637	9997	60	be	be	VB
18637	9997	61	removable	removable	JJ
18637	9997	62	by	by	IN
18637	9997	63	the	the	DT
18637	9997	64	President	President	NNP
18637	9997	65	at	at	IN
18637	9997	66	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	9997	67	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	9997	68	.	.	.
18637	9998	1	Contemporaneously	contemporaneously	RB
18637	9998	2	and	and	CC
18637	9998	3	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	9998	4	until	until	IN
18637	9998	5	after	after	IN
18637	9998	6	the	the	DT
18637	9998	7	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	9998	8	War	War	NNP
18637	9998	9	,	,	,
18637	9998	10	this	this	DT
18637	9998	11	action	action	NN
18637	9998	12	by	by	IN
18637	9998	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	9998	14	,	,	,
18637	9998	15	in	in	IN
18637	9998	16	other	other	JJ
18637	9998	17	words	word	NNS
18637	9998	18	"	"	``
18637	9998	19	the	the	DT
18637	9998	20	decision	decision	NN
18637	9998	21	of	of	IN
18637	9998	22	1789	1789	CD
18637	9998	23	,	,	,
18637	9998	24	"	"	''
18637	9998	25	was	be	VBD
18637	9998	26	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	9998	27	as	as	IN
18637	9998	28	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	9998	29	"	"	``
18637	9998	30	a	a	DT
18637	9998	31	practical	practical	JJ
18637	9998	32	construction	construction	NN
18637	9998	33	of	of	IN
18637	9998	34	the	the	DT
18637	9998	35	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9998	36	"	"	''
18637	9998	37	with	with	IN
18637	9998	38	respect	respect	NN
18637	9998	39	to	to	IN
18637	9998	40	executive	executive	JJ
18637	9998	41	officers	officer	NNS
18637	9998	42	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	9998	43	without	without	IN
18637	9998	44	stated	stated	JJ
18637	9998	45	terms	term	NNS
18637	9998	46	.	.	.
18637	9999	1	However	however	RB
18637	9999	2	,	,	,
18637	9999	3	in	in	IN
18637	9999	4	the	the	DT
18637	9999	5	dominant	dominant	JJ
18637	9999	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	9999	7	of	of	IN
18637	9999	8	those	those	DT
18637	9999	9	best	well	RBS
18637	9999	10	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	9999	11	to	to	TO
18637	9999	12	speak	speak	VB
18637	9999	13	on	on	IN
18637	9999	14	the	the	DT
18637	9999	15	subject	subject	NN
18637	9999	16	,	,	,
18637	9999	17	the	the	DT
18637	9999	18	"	"	``
18637	9999	19	correct	correct	JJ
18637	9999	20	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	9999	21	"	"	''
18637	9999	22	of	of	IN
18637	9999	23	the	the	DT
18637	9999	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	9999	25	was	be	VBD
18637	9999	26	that	that	IN
18637	9999	27	the	the	DT
18637	9999	28	power	power	NN
18637	9999	29	of	of	IN
18637	9999	30	removal	removal	NN
18637	9999	31	was	be	VBD
18637	9999	32	always	always	RB
18637	9999	33	an	an	DT
18637	9999	34	incident	incident	NN
18637	9999	35	of	of	IN
18637	9999	36	the	the	DT
18637	9999	37	power	power	NN
18637	9999	38	of	of	IN
18637	9999	39	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	9999	40	,	,	,
18637	9999	41	and	and	CC
18637	9999	42	that	that	IN
18637	9999	43	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	9999	44	in	in	IN
18637	9999	45	the	the	DT
18637	9999	46	case	case	NN
18637	9999	47	of	of	IN
18637	9999	48	officers	officer	NNS
18637	9999	49	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	9999	50	by	by	IN
18637	9999	51	the	the	DT
18637	9999	52	President	President	NNP
18637	9999	53	with	with	IN
18637	9999	54	the	the	DT
18637	9999	55	advice	advice	NN
18637	9999	56	and	and	CC
18637	9999	57	consent	consent	NN
18637	9999	58	of	of	IN
18637	9999	59	the	the	DT
18637	9999	60	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9999	61	the	the	DT
18637	9999	62	removal	removal	NN
18637	9999	63	power	power	NN
18637	9999	64	was	be	VBD
18637	9999	65	exercisable	exercisable	JJ
18637	9999	66	by	by	IN
18637	9999	67	the	the	DT
18637	9999	68	President	President	NNP
18637	9999	69	only	only	RB
18637	9999	70	with	with	IN
18637	9999	71	the	the	DT
18637	9999	72	advice	advice	NN
18637	9999	73	and	and	CC
18637	9999	74	consent	consent	NN
18637	9999	75	of	of	IN
18637	9999	76	the	the	DT
18637	9999	77	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	9999	78	.	.	.
18637	10000	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10000	2	See	See	NNP
18637	10000	3	_	_	NNP
18637	10000	4	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	10000	5	in	in	IN
18637	10000	6	the	the	DT
18637	10000	7	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	10000	8	No	no	NN
18637	10000	9	.	.	.
18637	10001	1	77	77	CD
18637	10001	2	;	;	:
18637	10001	3	1	1	CD
18637	10001	4	Kent	Kent	NNP
18637	10001	5	's	's	POS
18637	10001	6	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	10001	7	.	.	.
18637	10002	1	310	310	CD
18637	10002	2	;	;	:
18637	10002	3	2	2	CD
18637	10002	4	Story	Story	NNP
18637	10002	5	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	10002	6	.	.	.
18637	10003	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	10003	2	1539	1539	CD
18637	10003	3	and	and	CC
18637	10003	4	1544	1544	CD
18637	10003	5	;	;	:
18637	10003	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	10003	7	parte	parte	NN
18637	10003	8	Hennen	Hennen	NNP
18637	10003	9	,	,	,
18637	10003	10	13	13	CD
18637	10003	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	10003	12	.	.	.
18637	10004	1	225	225	CD
18637	10004	2	,	,	,
18637	10004	3	258	258	CD
18637	10004	4	-	-	SYM
18637	10004	5	259	259	CD
18637	10004	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10004	7	1839	1839	CD
18637	10004	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10004	9	.	.	.
18637	10005	1	The	the	DT
18637	10005	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	10005	3	of	of	IN
18637	10005	4	estate	estate	NN
18637	10005	5	in	in	IN
18637	10005	6	office	office	NN
18637	10005	7	was	be	VBD
18637	10005	8	countenanced	countenance	VBN
18637	10005	9	by	by	IN
18637	10005	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10005	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10005	12	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	10005	13	in	in	IN
18637	10005	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10005	15	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10005	16	in	in	IN
18637	10005	17	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	10005	18	_	_	NNP
18637	10005	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	10005	20	_	_	NNP
18637	10005	21	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	10005	22	,	,	,
18637	10005	23	1	1	CD
18637	10005	24	Cr	cr	NN
18637	10005	25	.	.	.
18637	10006	1	137	137	CD
18637	10006	2	,	,	,
18637	10006	3	162	162	CD
18637	10006	4	-	-	SYM
18637	10006	5	165	165	CD
18637	10006	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10006	7	1803	1803	CD
18637	10006	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10006	9	,	,	,
18637	10006	10	but	but	CC
18637	10006	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	10006	12	long	long	RB
18637	10006	13	been	be	VBN
18637	10006	14	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	10006	15	.	.	.
18637	10007	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10007	2	See	See	NNP
18637	10007	3	_	_	NNP
18637	10007	4	Crenshaw	Crenshaw	NNP
18637	10007	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10007	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10007	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10007	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10007	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10007	10	,	,	,
18637	10007	11	134	134	CD
18637	10007	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10007	13	99	99	CD
18637	10007	14	,	,	,
18637	10007	15	108	108	CD
18637	10007	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10007	17	1890	1890	CD
18637	10007	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10007	19	.	.	.
18637	10008	1	The	the	DT
18637	10008	2	three	three	CD
18637	10008	3	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	10008	4	views	view	NNS
18637	10008	5	are	be	VBP
18637	10008	6	treated	treat	VBN
18637	10008	7	by	by	IN
18637	10008	8	the	the	DT
18637	10008	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10008	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10008	11	,	,	,
18637	10008	12	at	at	IN
18637	10008	13	some	some	DT
18637	10008	14	cost	cost	NN
18637	10008	15	in	in	IN
18637	10008	16	terms	term	NNS
18637	10008	17	of	of	IN
18637	10008	18	logic	logic	NN
18637	10008	19	as	as	RB
18637	10008	20	well	well	RB
18637	10008	21	as	as	IN
18637	10008	22	of	of	IN
18637	10008	23	history	history	NN
18637	10008	24	,	,	,
18637	10008	25	as	as	IN
18637	10008	26	grist	grist	NN
18637	10008	27	to	to	IN
18637	10008	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10008	29	mill	mill	NN
18637	10008	30	.	.	.
18637	10009	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10009	2	313	313	CD
18637	10009	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10009	4	272	272	CD
18637	10009	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10009	6	at	at	IN
18637	10009	7	134	134	CD
18637	10009	8	.	.	.
18637	10010	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10010	2	314	314	CD
18637	10010	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10010	4	Annals	Annals	NNP
18637	10010	5	of	of	IN
18637	10010	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10010	7	,	,	,
18637	10010	8	cols	col	NNS
18637	10010	9	.	.	.
18637	10011	1	635	635	CD
18637	10011	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10011	3	636	636	CD
18637	10011	4	.	.	.
18637	10012	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10012	2	315	315	CD
18637	10012	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10012	4	295	295	CD
18637	10012	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10012	6	602	602	CD
18637	10012	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10012	8	1935	1935	CD
18637	10012	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10012	10	.	.	.
18637	10013	1	The	the	DT
18637	10013	2	case	case	NN
18637	10013	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	10013	4	also	also	RB
18637	10013	5	styled	style	VBN
18637	10013	6	Rathbun	Rathbun	NNP
18637	10013	7	,	,	,
18637	10013	8	Executor	Executor	NNP
18637	10013	9	_	_	NNP
18637	10013	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	10013	11	_	_	NNP
18637	10013	12	United	United	NNP
18637	10013	13	States	States	NNP
18637	10013	14	,	,	,
18637	10013	15	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	10013	16	having	have	VBG
18637	10013	17	,	,	,
18637	10013	18	like	like	IN
18637	10013	19	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	10013	20	before	before	IN
18637	10013	21	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10013	22	,	,	,
18637	10013	23	died	die	VBD
18637	10013	24	in	in	IN
18637	10013	25	the	the	DT
18637	10013	26	course	course	NN
18637	10013	27	of	of	IN
18637	10013	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10013	29	suit	suit	NN
18637	10013	30	for	for	IN
18637	10013	31	salary	salary	NN
18637	10013	32	.	.	.
18637	10014	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10014	2	316	316	CD
18637	10014	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10014	4	295	295	CD
18637	10014	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10014	6	at	at	IN
18637	10014	7	.	.	.
18637	10015	1	627	627	CD
18637	10015	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10015	3	629	629	CD
18637	10015	4	,	,	,
18637	10015	5	631	631	CD
18637	10015	6	-	-	SYM
18637	10015	7	632	632	CD
18637	10015	8	.	.	.
18637	10016	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10016	2	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	10016	3	's	's	POS
18637	10016	4	statement	statement	NN
18637	10016	5	,	,	,
18637	10016	6	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	10016	7	above	above	RB
18637	10016	8	,	,	,
18637	10016	9	that	that	IN
18637	10016	10	a	a	DT
18637	10016	11	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10016	12	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	10016	13	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	10016	14	"	"	''
18637	10016	15	occupies	occupy	VBZ
18637	10016	16	no	no	DT
18637	10016	17	place	place	NN
18637	10016	18	in	in	IN
18637	10016	19	the	the	DT
18637	10016	20	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10016	21	department	department	NN
18637	10016	22	"	"	''
18637	10016	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10016	24	_	_	NNP
18637	10016	25	See	See	NNP
18637	10016	26	also	also	RB
18637	10016	27	_	_	NNP
18637	10016	28	to	to	IN
18637	10016	29	the	the	DT
18637	10016	30	same	same	JJ
18637	10016	31	effect	effect	NN
18637	10016	32	p.	p.	NN
18637	10016	33	630	630	CD
18637	10016	34	of	of	IN
18637	10016	35	the	the	DT
18637	10016	36	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10016	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10016	38	was	be	VBD
18637	10016	39	not	not	RB
18637	10016	40	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10016	41	to	to	IN
18637	10016	42	the	the	DT
18637	10016	43	decision	decision	NN
18637	10016	44	of	of	IN
18637	10016	45	the	the	DT
18637	10016	46	case	case	NN
18637	10016	47	,	,	,
18637	10016	48	was	be	VBD
18637	10016	49	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	10016	50	out	out	IN
18637	10016	51	of	of	IN
18637	10016	52	line	line	NN
18637	10016	53	with	with	IN
18637	10016	54	the	the	DT
18637	10016	55	same	same	JJ
18637	10016	56	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10016	57	's	's	POS
18637	10016	58	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	10016	59	in	in	IN
18637	10016	60	Springer	Springer	NNP
18637	10016	61	_	_	NNP
18637	10016	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	10016	63	_	_	NNP
18637	10016	64	Philippine	Philippine	NNP
18637	10016	65	Islands	Islands	NNPS
18637	10016	66	,	,	,
18637	10016	67	277	277	CD
18637	10016	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10016	69	189	189	CD
18637	10016	70	,	,	,
18637	10016	71	201	201	CD
18637	10016	72	-	-	SYM
18637	10016	73	202	202	CD
18637	10016	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10016	75	1928	1928	CD
18637	10016	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10016	77	,	,	,
18637	10016	78	and	and	CC
18637	10016	79	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	10016	80	later	later	RB
18637	10016	81	to	to	TO
18637	10016	82	have	have	VB
18637	10016	83	caused	cause	VBN
18637	10016	84	the	the	DT
18637	10016	85	author	author	NN
18637	10016	86	of	of	IN
18637	10016	87	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10016	88	much	much	JJ
18637	10016	89	perplexity	perplexity	NN
18637	10016	90	.	.	.
18637	10017	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10017	2	See	See	NNP
18637	10017	3	_	_	NNP
18637	10017	4	Robert	Robert	NNP
18637	10017	5	E.	E.	NNP
18637	10017	6	Cushman	Cushman	NNP
18637	10017	7	,	,	,
18637	10017	8	The	the	DT
18637	10017	9	Independent	Independent	NNP
18637	10017	10	Regulatory	Regulatory	NNP
18637	10017	11	Commissions	Commissions	NNPS
18637	10017	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10017	13	Oxford	Oxford	NNP
18637	10017	14	University	University	NNP
18637	10017	15	Press	Press	NNP
18637	10017	16	,	,	,
18637	10017	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	10017	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10017	19	,	,	,
18637	10017	20	447	447	CD
18637	10017	21	-	-	SYM
18637	10017	22	448	448	CD
18637	10017	23	.	.	.
18637	10018	1	As	as	IN
18637	10018	2	Professor	Professor	NNP
18637	10018	3	Cushman	Cushman	NNP
18637	10018	4	adds	add	VBZ
18637	10018	5	:	:	:
18637	10018	6	"	"	``
18637	10018	7	Every	every	DT
18637	10018	8	officer	officer	NN
18637	10018	9	and	and	CC
18637	10018	10	agency	agency	NN
18637	10018	11	created	create	VBN
18637	10018	12	by	by	IN
18637	10018	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10018	14	to	to	TO
18637	10018	15	carry	carry	VB
18637	10018	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	10018	17	into	into	IN
18637	10018	18	effect	effect	NN
18637	10018	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	10018	20	an	an	DT
18637	10018	21	arm	arm	NN
18637	10018	22	of	of	IN
18637	10018	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10018	24	.	.	.
18637	10019	1	*	*	NFP
18637	10019	2	*	*	NFP
18637	10019	3	*	*	NFP
18637	10019	4	The	the	DT
18637	10019	5	term	term	NN
18637	10019	6	may	may	MD
18637	10019	7	be	be	VB
18637	10019	8	a	a	DT
18637	10019	9	synonym	synonym	NN
18637	10019	10	;	;	:
18637	10019	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10019	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	10019	13	not	not	RB
18637	10019	14	an	an	DT
18637	10019	15	argument	argument	NN
18637	10019	16	.	.	.
18637	10019	17	"	"	''
18637	10020	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	10020	2	.	.	.
18637	10021	1	451	451	CD
18637	10021	2	.	.	.
18637	10022	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10022	2	317	317	CD
18637	10022	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10022	4	United	United	NNP
18637	10022	5	States	States	NNP
18637	10022	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10022	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10022	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10022	9	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
18637	10022	10	,	,	,
18637	10022	11	116	116	CD
18637	10022	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10022	13	483	483	CD
18637	10022	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10022	15	1886	1886	CD
18637	10022	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10022	17	.	.	.
18637	10023	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10023	2	318	318	CD
18637	10023	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10023	4	Parsons	Parsons	NNPS
18637	10023	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10023	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10023	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10023	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10023	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10023	10	,	,	,
18637	10023	11	167	167	CD
18637	10023	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10023	13	324	324	CD
18637	10023	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10023	15	1897	1897	CD
18637	10023	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10023	17	.	.	.
18637	10024	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10024	2	319	319	CD
18637	10024	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10024	4	Shurtleff	Shurtleff	NNP
18637	10024	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10024	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10024	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10024	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10024	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10024	10	,	,	,
18637	10024	11	189	189	CD
18637	10024	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10024	13	311	311	CD
18637	10024	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10024	15	1903	1903	CD
18637	10024	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10024	17	.	.	.
18637	10025	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10025	2	320	320	CD
18637	10025	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10025	4	Blake	Blake	NNP
18637	10025	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10025	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10025	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10025	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10025	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10025	10	,	,	,
18637	10025	11	103	103	CD
18637	10025	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10025	13	227	227	CD
18637	10025	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10025	15	1881	1881	CD
18637	10025	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10025	17	;	;	:
18637	10025	18	Quackenbush	Quackenbush	NNP
18637	10025	19	_	_	NNP
18637	10025	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	10025	21	_	_	NNP
18637	10025	22	United	United	NNP
18637	10025	23	States	States	NNP
18637	10025	24	,	,	,
18637	10025	25	177	177	CD
18637	10025	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10025	27	20	20	CD
18637	10025	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10025	29	1900	1900	CD
18637	10025	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10025	31	;	;	:
18637	10025	32	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	10025	33	_	_	NNP
18637	10025	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	10025	35	_	_	NNP
18637	10025	36	United	United	NNP
18637	10025	37	States	States	NNP
18637	10025	38	,	,	,
18637	10025	39	257	257	CD
18637	10025	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10025	41	541	541	CD
18637	10025	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10025	43	1922	1922	CD
18637	10025	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10025	45	.	.	.
18637	10026	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10026	2	321	321	CD
18637	10026	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10026	4	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	10026	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10026	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10026	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10026	8	TVA	TVA	NNP
18637	10026	9	,	,	,
18637	10026	10	28	28	CD
18637	10026	11	F.	F.	NNP
18637	10026	12	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	10026	13	.	.	.
18637	10027	1	732	732	CD
18637	10027	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10027	3	1939	1939	CD
18637	10027	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10027	5	,	,	,
18637	10027	6	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	10027	7	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	10027	8	March	March	NNP
18637	10027	9	17	17	CD
18637	10027	10	,	,	,
18637	10027	11	1941	1941	CD
18637	10027	12	.	.	.
18637	10028	1	312	312	CD
18637	10028	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10028	3	701	701	CD
18637	10028	4	,	,	,
18637	10028	5	702	702	CD
18637	10028	6	.	.	.
18637	10029	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10029	2	322	322	CD
18637	10029	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10029	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10029	5	See	See	NNP
18637	10029	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10029	7	United	United	NNP
18637	10029	8	Public	Public	NNP
18637	10029	9	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	10029	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10029	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	10029	12	_	_	NNP
18637	10029	13	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	10029	14	,	,	,
18637	10029	15	330	330	CD
18637	10029	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10029	17	75	75	CD
18637	10029	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10029	19	1947	1947	CD
18637	10029	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10029	21	;	;	:
18637	10029	22	_	_	NNP
18637	10029	23	also	also	RB
18637	10029	24	_	_	NNP
18637	10029	25	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	10029	26	parte	parte	NN
18637	10029	27	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	10029	28	,	,	,
18637	10029	29	106	106	CD
18637	10029	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10029	31	371	371	CD
18637	10029	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10029	33	1882	1882	CD
18637	10029	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10029	35	;	;	:
18637	10029	36	and	and	CC
18637	10029	37	39	39	CD
18637	10029	38	Op	Op	NNP
18637	10029	39	.	.	.
18637	10030	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	10030	2	.	.	.
18637	10031	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	10031	2	145	145	CD
18637	10031	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10031	4	1938	1938	CD
18637	10031	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10031	6	.	.	.
18637	10032	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10032	2	323	323	CD
18637	10032	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10032	4	6	6	CD
18637	10032	5	Op	Op	NNP
18637	10032	6	.	.	.
18637	10033	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	10033	2	.	.	.
18637	10034	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	10034	2	220	220	CD
18637	10034	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10034	4	1853	1853	CD
18637	10034	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10034	6	;	;	:
18637	10034	7	In	in	IN
18637	10034	8	re	re	IN
18637	10034	9	Neagle	Neagle	NNP
18637	10034	10	,	,	,
18637	10034	11	135	135	CD
18637	10034	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10034	13	1	1	CD
18637	10034	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10034	15	1890	1890	CD
18637	10034	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10034	17	.	.	.
18637	10035	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10035	2	324	324	CD
18637	10035	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10035	4	United	United	NNP
18637	10035	5	States	States	NNP
18637	10035	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10035	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10035	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10035	9	Lovett	Lovett	NNP
18637	10035	10	,	,	,
18637	10035	11	328	328	CD
18637	10035	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10035	13	303	303	CD
18637	10035	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10035	15	1946	1946	CD
18637	10035	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10035	17	.	.	.
18637	10036	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10036	2	325	325	CD
18637	10036	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10036	4	Messages	Messages	NNPS
18637	10036	5	and	and	CC
18637	10036	6	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	10036	7	of	of	IN
18637	10036	8	the	the	DT
18637	10036	9	Presidents	Presidents	NNPS
18637	10036	10	,	,	,
18637	10036	11	II	II	NNP
18637	10036	12	,	,	,
18637	10036	13	847	847	CD
18637	10036	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10036	15	January	January	NNP
18637	10036	16	10	10	CD
18637	10036	17	,	,	,
18637	10036	18	1825	1825	CD
18637	10036	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10036	20	.	.	.
18637	10037	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10037	2	326	326	CD
18637	10037	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10037	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10037	5	See	See	NNP
18637	10037	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10037	7	328	328	CD
18637	10037	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10037	9	at	at	IN
18637	10037	10	313	313	CD
18637	10037	11	.	.	.
18637	10038	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10038	2	327	327	CD
18637	10038	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10038	4	In	in	IN
18637	10038	5	this	this	DT
18637	10038	6	connection	connection	NN
18637	10038	7	the	the	DT
18637	10038	8	following	follow	VBG
18637	10038	9	colloquy	colloquy	NN
18637	10038	10	between	between	IN
18637	10038	11	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10038	12	General	General	NNP
18637	10038	13	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	10038	14	and	and	CC
18637	10038	15	the	the	DT
18637	10038	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10038	17	in	in	IN
18637	10038	18	course	course	NN
18637	10038	19	of	of	IN
18637	10038	20	the	the	DT
18637	10038	21	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10038	22	in	in	IN
18637	10038	23	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	10038	24	_	_	NNP
18637	10038	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	10038	26	_	_	NNP
18637	10038	27	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	10038	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	10038	29	of	of	IN
18637	10038	30	first	first	JJ
18637	10038	31	importance	importance	NN
18637	10038	32	:	:	:
18637	10038	33	"	"	``
18637	10038	34	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	10038	35	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	10038	36	,	,	,
18637	10038	37	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	10038	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	10038	39	general	general	JJ
18637	10038	40	,	,	,
18637	10038	41	having	have	VBG
18637	10038	42	been	be	VBN
18637	10038	43	summoned	summon	VBN
18637	10038	44	,	,	,
18637	10038	45	and	and	CC
18637	10038	46	now	now	RB
18637	10038	47	called	call	VBN
18637	10038	48	,	,	,
18637	10038	49	objected	object	VBN
18637	10038	50	to	to	IN
18637	10038	51	answering	answer	VBG
18637	10038	52	.	.	.
18637	10039	1	*	*	NFP
18637	10039	2	*	*	NFP
18637	10039	3	*	*	NFP
18637	10039	4	On	on	IN
18637	10039	5	the	the	DT
18637	10039	6	one	one	CD
18637	10039	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	10039	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10039	9	respected	respect	VBD
18637	10039	10	the	the	DT
18637	10039	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10039	12	of	of	IN
18637	10039	13	this	this	DT
18637	10039	14	court	court	NN
18637	10039	15	,	,	,
18637	10039	16	and	and	CC
18637	10039	17	on	on	IN
18637	10039	18	the	the	DT
18637	10039	19	other	other	JJ
18637	10039	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10039	21	felt	feel	VBD
18637	10039	22	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10039	23	bound	bind	VBN
18637	10039	24	to	to	TO
18637	10039	25	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	10039	26	the	the	DT
18637	10039	27	rights	right	NNS
18637	10039	28	of	of	IN
18637	10039	29	the	the	DT
18637	10039	30	executive	executive	NN
18637	10039	31	.	.	.
18637	10040	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10040	2	was	be	VBD
18637	10040	3	acting	act	VBG
18637	10040	4	as	as	IN
18637	10040	5	secretary	secretary	NN
18637	10040	6	of	of	IN
18637	10040	7	state	state	NN
18637	10040	8	at	at	IN
18637	10040	9	the	the	DT
18637	10040	10	time	time	NN
18637	10040	11	when	when	WRB
18637	10040	12	this	this	DT
18637	10040	13	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	10040	14	happened	happen	VBD
18637	10040	15	.	.	.
18637	10041	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10041	2	was	be	VBD
18637	10041	3	of	of	IN
18637	10041	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10041	5	,	,	,
18637	10041	6	and	and	CC
18637	10041	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10041	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10041	9	was	be	VBD
18637	10041	10	supported	support	VBN
18637	10041	11	by	by	IN
18637	10041	12	that	that	DT
18637	10041	13	of	of	IN
18637	10041	14	others	other	NNS
18637	10041	15	whom	whom	WP
18637	10041	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10041	17	highly	highly	RB
18637	10041	18	respected	respect	VBD
18637	10041	19	,	,	,
18637	10041	20	that	that	IN
18637	10041	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10041	22	was	be	VBD
18637	10041	23	not	not	RB
18637	10041	24	bound	bind	VBN
18637	10041	25	,	,	,
18637	10041	26	and	and	CC
18637	10041	27	ought	ought	MD
18637	10041	28	not	not	RB
18637	10041	29	to	to	TO
18637	10041	30	answer	answer	VB
18637	10041	31	,	,	,
18637	10041	32	as	as	IN
18637	10041	33	to	to	IN
18637	10041	34	any	any	DT
18637	10041	35	facts	fact	NNS
18637	10041	36	which	which	WDT
18637	10041	37	came	come	VBD
18637	10041	38	officially	officially	RB
18637	10041	39	to	to	IN
18637	10041	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10041	41	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	10041	42	while	while	IN
18637	10041	43	acting	act	VBG
18637	10041	44	as	as	IN
18637	10041	45	secretary	secretary	NN
18637	10041	46	of	of	IN
18637	10041	47	state	state	NN
18637	10041	48	.	.	.
18637	10042	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10042	2	did	do	VBD
18637	10042	3	not	not	RB
18637	10042	4	think	think	VB
18637	10042	5	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10042	6	bound	bind	VBN
18637	10042	7	to	to	TO
18637	10042	8	disclose	disclose	VB
18637	10042	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10042	10	official	official	JJ
18637	10042	11	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	10042	12	while	while	IN
18637	10042	13	acting	act	VBG
18637	10042	14	as	as	IN
18637	10042	15	secretary	secretary	NN
18637	10042	16	of	of	IN
18637	10042	17	state	state	NNP
18637	10042	18	;	;	:
18637	10042	19	*	*	NFP
18637	10042	20	*	*	NFP
18637	10042	21	*	*	NFP
18637	10042	22	The	the	DT
18637	10042	23	court	court	NN
18637	10042	24	said	say	VBD
18637	10042	25	,	,	,
18637	10042	26	that	that	IN
18637	10042	27	if	if	IN
18637	10042	28	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	10042	29	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	10042	30	wished	wish	VBD
18637	10042	31	time	time	NN
18637	10042	32	to	to	TO
18637	10042	33	consider	consider	VB
18637	10042	34	what	what	WP
18637	10042	35	answers	answer	NNS
18637	10042	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10042	37	should	should	MD
18637	10042	38	make	make	VB
18637	10042	39	,	,	,
18637	10042	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10042	41	would	would	MD
18637	10042	42	give	give	VB
18637	10042	43	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10042	44	time	time	NN
18637	10042	45	;	;	:
18637	10042	46	but	but	CC
18637	10042	47	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10042	48	had	have	VBD
18637	10042	49	no	no	DT
18637	10042	50	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	10042	51	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10042	52	ought	ought	MD
18637	10042	53	to	to	TO
18637	10042	54	answer	answer	VB
18637	10042	55	.	.	.
18637	10043	1	There	there	EX
18637	10043	2	was	be	VBD
18637	10043	3	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	10043	4	confidential	confidential	JJ
18637	10043	5	required	require	VBN
18637	10043	6	to	to	TO
18637	10043	7	be	be	VB
18637	10043	8	disclosed	disclose	VBN
18637	10043	9	.	.	.
18637	10044	1	If	if	IN
18637	10044	2	there	there	EX
18637	10044	3	had	have	VBD
18637	10044	4	been	be	VBN
18637	10044	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10044	6	was	be	VBD
18637	10044	7	not	not	RB
18637	10044	8	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	10044	9	to	to	TO
18637	10044	10	answer	answer	VB
18637	10044	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10044	12	;	;	:
18637	10044	13	and	and	CC
18637	10044	14	if	if	IN
18637	10044	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10044	16	thought	think	VBD
18637	10044	17	that	that	IN
18637	10044	18	any	any	DT
18637	10044	19	thing	thing	NN
18637	10044	20	was	be	VBD
18637	10044	21	communicated	communicate	VBN
18637	10044	22	to	to	IN
18637	10044	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10044	24	in	in	IN
18637	10044	25	confidence	confidence	NN
18637	10044	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10044	27	was	be	VBD
18637	10044	28	not	not	RB
18637	10044	29	bound	bind	VBN
18637	10044	30	to	to	TO
18637	10044	31	disclose	disclose	VB
18637	10044	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10044	33	;	;	:
18637	10044	34	*	*	NFP
18637	10044	35	*	*	NFP
18637	10044	36	*	*	NFP
18637	10044	37	"	"	``
18637	10044	38	1	1	CD
18637	10044	39	Cr	cr	NN
18637	10044	40	.	.	.
18637	10045	1	137	137	CD
18637	10045	2	,	,	,
18637	10045	3	143	143	CD
18637	10045	4	-	-	SYM
18637	10045	5	145	145	CD
18637	10045	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10045	7	1803	1803	CD
18637	10045	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10045	9	.	.	.
18637	10046	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10046	2	328	328	CD
18637	10046	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10046	4	The	the	DT
18637	10046	5	following	follow	VBG
18637	10046	6	letter	letter	NN
18637	10046	7	,	,	,
18637	10046	8	dated	date	VBN
18637	10046	9	April	April	NNP
18637	10046	10	30	30	CD
18637	10046	11	,	,	,
18637	10046	12	1941	1941	CD
18637	10046	13	,	,	,
18637	10046	14	from	from	IN
18637	10046	15	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10046	16	General	General	NNP
18637	10046	17	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	10046	18	to	to	IN
18637	10046	19	Hon	Hon	NNP
18637	10046	20	.	.	.
18637	10047	1	Carl	Carl	NNP
18637	10047	2	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	10047	3	,	,	,
18637	10047	4	Chairman	Chairman	NNP
18637	10047	5	of	of	IN
18637	10047	6	the	the	DT
18637	10047	7	House	House	NNP
18637	10047	8	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	10047	9	on	on	IN
18637	10047	10	Naval	Naval	NNP
18637	10047	11	Affairs	Affairs	NNPS
18637	10047	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	10047	13	of	of	IN
18637	10047	14	interest	interest	NN
18637	10047	15	in	in	IN
18637	10047	16	this	this	DT
18637	10047	17	connection	connection	NN
18637	10047	18	:	:	:
18637	10047	19	"	"	``
18637	10047	20	My	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10047	21	Dear	dear	JJ
18637	10047	22	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	10047	23	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	10047	24	:	:	:
18637	10047	25	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10047	26	have	have	VBP
18637	10047	27	your	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10047	28	letter	letter	NN
18637	10047	29	of	of	IN
18637	10047	30	April	April	NNP
18637	10047	31	23	23	CD
18637	10047	32	,	,	,
18637	10047	33	requesting	request	VBG
18637	10047	34	that	that	IN
18637	10047	35	your	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10047	36	committee	committee	NN
18637	10047	37	be	be	VB
18637	10047	38	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	10047	39	with	with	IN
18637	10047	40	all	all	DT
18637	10047	41	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10047	42	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
18637	10047	43	of	of	IN
18637	10047	44	Investigation	Investigation	NNP
18637	10047	45	reports	report	VBZ
18637	10047	46	since	since	IN
18637	10047	47	June	June	NNP
18637	10047	48	1939	1939	CD
18637	10047	49	,	,	,
18637	10047	50	together	together	RB
18637	10047	51	with	with	IN
18637	10047	52	all	all	DT
18637	10047	53	future	future	JJ
18637	10047	54	reports	report	NNS
18637	10047	55	,	,	,
18637	10047	56	memoranda	memorandum	NNS
18637	10047	57	,	,	,
18637	10047	58	and	and	CC
18637	10047	59	correspondence	correspondence	NN
18637	10047	60	of	of	IN
18637	10047	61	the	the	DT
18637	10047	62	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10047	63	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
18637	10047	64	of	of	IN
18637	10047	65	Investigation	Investigation	NNP
18637	10047	66	,	,	,
18637	10047	67	or	or	CC
18637	10047	68	the	the	DT
18637	10047	69	Department	Department	NNP
18637	10047	70	of	of	IN
18637	10047	71	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10047	72	,	,	,
18637	10047	73	in	in	IN
18637	10047	74	connection	connection	NN
18637	10047	75	with	with	IN
18637	10047	76	'	'	``
18637	10047	77	investigations	investigation	NNS
18637	10047	78	made	make	VBN
18637	10047	79	by	by	IN
18637	10047	80	the	the	DT
18637	10047	81	Department	Department	NNP
18637	10047	82	of	of	IN
18637	10047	83	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10047	84	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10047	85	out	out	IN
18637	10047	86	of	of	IN
18637	10047	87	strikes	strike	NNS
18637	10047	88	,	,	,
18637	10047	89	subversive	subversive	JJ
18637	10047	90	activities	activity	NNS
18637	10047	91	in	in	IN
18637	10047	92	connection	connection	NN
18637	10047	93	with	with	IN
18637	10047	94	labor	labor	NN
18637	10047	95	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	10047	96	,	,	,
18637	10047	97	or	or	CC
18637	10047	98	labor	labor	NN
18637	10047	99	disturbances	disturbance	NNS
18637	10047	100	of	of	IN
18637	10047	101	any	any	DT
18637	10047	102	kind	kind	NN
18637	10047	103	in	in	IN
18637	10047	104	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	10047	105	establishments	establishment	NNS
18637	10047	106	which	which	WDT
18637	10047	107	have	have	VBP
18637	10047	108	naval	naval	JJ
18637	10047	109	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	10047	110	,	,	,
18637	10047	111	either	either	CC
18637	10047	112	as	as	IN
18637	10047	113	prime	prime	JJ
18637	10047	114	contractors	contractor	NNS
18637	10047	115	or	or	CC
18637	10047	116	subcontractors	subcontractor	NNS
18637	10047	117	.	.	.
18637	10047	118	'	'	''
18637	10048	1	Your	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10048	2	request	request	NN
18637	10048	3	to	to	TO
18637	10048	4	be	be	VB
18637	10048	5	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	10048	6	reports	report	NNS
18637	10048	7	of	of	IN
18637	10048	8	the	the	DT
18637	10048	9	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10048	10	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
18637	10048	11	of	of	IN
18637	10048	12	Investigation	Investigation	NNP
18637	10048	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	10048	14	one	one	CD
18637	10048	15	of	of	IN
18637	10048	16	the	the	DT
18637	10048	17	many	many	JJ
18637	10048	18	made	make	VBN
18637	10048	19	by	by	IN
18637	10048	20	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	10048	21	committees	committee	NNS
18637	10048	22	.	.	.
18637	10049	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10049	2	have	have	VBP
18637	10049	3	on	on	IN
18637	10049	4	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10049	5	desk	desk	NN
18637	10049	6	at	at	IN
18637	10049	7	this	this	DT
18637	10049	8	time	time	NN
18637	10049	9	two	two	CD
18637	10049	10	other	other	JJ
18637	10049	11	such	such	JJ
18637	10049	12	requests	request	NNS
18637	10049	13	for	for	IN
18637	10049	14	access	access	NN
18637	10049	15	to	to	IN
18637	10049	16	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10049	17	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
18637	10049	18	of	of	IN
18637	10049	19	Investigation	Investigation	NNP
18637	10049	20	files	file	NNS
18637	10049	21	.	.	.
18637	10050	1	The	the	DT
18637	10050	2	number	number	NN
18637	10050	3	of	of	IN
18637	10050	4	these	these	DT
18637	10050	5	requests	request	NNS
18637	10050	6	would	would	MD
18637	10050	7	alone	alone	RB
18637	10050	8	make	make	VB
18637	10050	9	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	10050	10	impracticable	impracticable	JJ
18637	10050	11	,	,	,
18637	10050	12	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	10050	13	where	where	WRB
18637	10050	14	the	the	DT
18637	10050	15	requests	request	NNS
18637	10050	16	are	be	VBP
18637	10050	17	of	of	IN
18637	10050	18	so	so	RB
18637	10050	19	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	10050	20	a	a	DT
18637	10050	21	character	character	NN
18637	10050	22	as	as	IN
18637	10050	23	those	those	DT
18637	10050	24	contained	contain	VBN
18637	10050	25	in	in	IN
18637	10050	26	your	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10050	27	letter	letter	NN
18637	10050	28	.	.	.
18637	10051	1	In	in	IN
18637	10051	2	view	view	NN
18637	10051	3	of	of	IN
18637	10051	4	the	the	DT
18637	10051	5	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	10051	6	frequency	frequency	NN
18637	10051	7	of	of	IN
18637	10051	8	these	these	DT
18637	10051	9	requests	request	NNS
18637	10051	10	,	,	,
18637	10051	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10051	12	desire	desire	VBP
18637	10051	13	to	to	TO
18637	10051	14	restate	restate	VB
18637	10051	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10051	16	policy	policy	NN
18637	10051	17	at	at	IN
18637	10051	18	some	some	DT
18637	10051	19	length	length	NN
18637	10051	20	,	,	,
18637	10051	21	together	together	RB
18637	10051	22	with	with	IN
18637	10051	23	the	the	DT
18637	10051	24	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	10051	25	which	which	WDT
18637	10051	26	require	require	VBP
18637	10051	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10051	28	.	.	.
18637	10052	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10052	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	10052	3	the	the	DT
18637	10052	4	position	position	NN
18637	10052	5	of	of	IN
18637	10052	6	this	this	DT
18637	10052	7	Department	Department	NNP
18637	10052	8	,	,	,
18637	10052	9	restated	restate	VBN
18637	10052	10	now	now	RB
18637	10052	11	with	with	IN
18637	10052	12	the	the	DT
18637	10052	13	approval	approval	NN
18637	10052	14	of	of	IN
18637	10052	15	and	and	CC
18637	10052	16	at	at	IN
18637	10052	17	the	the	DT
18637	10052	18	direction	direction	NN
18637	10052	19	of	of	IN
18637	10052	20	the	the	DT
18637	10052	21	President	President	NNP
18637	10052	22	,	,	,
18637	10052	23	that	that	IN
18637	10052	24	all	all	DT
18637	10052	25	investigative	investigative	JJ
18637	10052	26	reports	report	NNS
18637	10052	27	are	be	VBP
18637	10052	28	confidential	confidential	JJ
18637	10052	29	documents	document	NNS
18637	10052	30	of	of	IN
18637	10052	31	the	the	DT
18637	10052	32	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10052	33	department	department	NN
18637	10052	34	of	of	IN
18637	10052	35	the	the	DT
18637	10052	36	Government	Government	NNP
18637	10052	37	,	,	,
18637	10052	38	to	to	TO
18637	10052	39	aid	aid	VB
18637	10052	40	in	in	IN
18637	10052	41	the	the	DT
18637	10052	42	duty	duty	NN
18637	10052	43	laid	lay	VBN
18637	10052	44	upon	upon	IN
18637	10052	45	the	the	DT
18637	10052	46	President	President	NNP
18637	10052	47	by	by	IN
18637	10052	48	the	the	DT
18637	10052	49	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10052	50	to	to	TO
18637	10052	51	'	'	``
18637	10052	52	take	take	VB
18637	10052	53	care	care	NN
18637	10052	54	that	that	IN
18637	10052	55	the	the	DT
18637	10052	56	laws	law	NNS
18637	10052	57	be	be	VB
18637	10052	58	faithfully	faithfully	RB
18637	10052	59	executed	execute	VBN
18637	10052	60	,	,	,
18637	10052	61	'	'	''
18637	10052	62	and	and	CC
18637	10052	63	that	that	IN
18637	10052	64	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	10052	65	or	or	CC
18637	10052	66	public	public	JJ
18637	10052	67	access	access	NN
18637	10052	68	to	to	IN
18637	10052	69	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10052	70	would	would	MD
18637	10052	71	not	not	RB
18637	10052	72	be	be	VB
18637	10052	73	in	in	IN
18637	10052	74	the	the	DT
18637	10052	75	public	public	JJ
18637	10052	76	interest	interest	NN
18637	10052	77	.	.	.
18637	10053	1	"	"	``
18637	10053	2	Disclosure	disclosure	NN
18637	10053	3	of	of	IN
18637	10053	4	the	the	DT
18637	10053	5	reports	report	NNS
18637	10053	6	could	could	MD
18637	10053	7	not	not	RB
18637	10053	8	do	do	VB
18637	10053	9	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	10053	10	than	than	IN
18637	10053	11	seriously	seriously	RB
18637	10053	12	prejudice	prejudice	NN
18637	10053	13	law	law	NN
18637	10053	14	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10053	15	.	.	.
18637	10054	1	Counsel	counsel	NN
18637	10054	2	for	for	IN
18637	10054	3	a	a	DT
18637	10054	4	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	10054	5	or	or	CC
18637	10054	6	prospective	prospective	JJ
18637	10054	7	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	10054	8	,	,	,
18637	10054	9	could	could	MD
18637	10054	10	have	have	VB
18637	10054	11	no	no	DT
18637	10054	12	greater	great	JJR
18637	10054	13	help	help	NN
18637	10054	14	than	than	IN
18637	10054	15	to	to	TO
18637	10054	16	know	know	VB
18637	10054	17	how	how	WRB
18637	10054	18	much	much	JJ
18637	10054	19	or	or	CC
18637	10054	20	how	how	WRB
18637	10054	21	little	little	JJ
18637	10054	22	information	information	NN
18637	10054	23	the	the	DT
18637	10054	24	Government	Government	NNP
18637	10054	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	10054	26	,	,	,
18637	10054	27	and	and	CC
18637	10054	28	what	what	WP
18637	10054	29	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	10054	30	or	or	CC
18637	10054	31	sources	source	NNS
18637	10054	32	of	of	IN
18637	10054	33	information	information	NN
18637	10054	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10054	35	can	can	MD
18637	10054	36	rely	rely	VB
18637	10054	37	upon	upon	IN
18637	10054	38	.	.	.
18637	10055	1	This	this	DT
18637	10055	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	10055	3	exactly	exactly	RB
18637	10055	4	what	what	WP
18637	10055	5	these	these	DT
18637	10055	6	reports	report	NNS
18637	10055	7	are	be	VBP
18637	10055	8	intended	intend	VBN
18637	10055	9	to	to	TO
18637	10055	10	contain	contain	VB
18637	10055	11	.	.	.
18637	10056	1	*	*	NFP
18637	10056	2	*	*	NFP
18637	10056	3	*	*	NFP
18637	10056	4	"	"	``
18637	10056	5	In	in	IN
18637	10056	6	concluding	conclude	VBG
18637	10056	7	that	that	IN
18637	10056	8	the	the	DT
18637	10056	9	public	public	JJ
18637	10056	10	interest	interest	NN
18637	10056	11	does	do	VBZ
18637	10056	12	not	not	RB
18637	10056	13	permit	permit	VB
18637	10056	14	general	general	JJ
18637	10056	15	access	access	NN
18637	10056	16	to	to	IN
18637	10056	17	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10056	18	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
18637	10056	19	of	of	IN
18637	10056	20	Investigation	Investigation	NNP
18637	10056	21	reports	report	VBZ
18637	10056	22	for	for	IN
18637	10056	23	information	information	NN
18637	10056	24	by	by	IN
18637	10056	25	the	the	DT
18637	10056	26	many	many	JJ
18637	10056	27	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	10056	28	committees	committee	NNS
18637	10056	29	who	who	WP
18637	10056	30	from	from	IN
18637	10056	31	time	time	NN
18637	10056	32	to	to	IN
18637	10056	33	time	time	NN
18637	10056	34	ask	ask	VB
18637	10056	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10056	36	,	,	,
18637	10056	37	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10056	38	am	be	VBP
18637	10056	39	following	follow	VBG
18637	10056	40	the	the	DT
18637	10056	41	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
18637	10056	42	reached	reach	VBN
18637	10056	43	by	by	IN
18637	10056	44	a	a	DT
18637	10056	45	long	long	JJ
18637	10056	46	line	line	NN
18637	10056	47	of	of	IN
18637	10056	48	distinguished	distinguished	JJ
18637	10056	49	predecessors	predecessor	NNS
18637	10056	50	in	in	IN
18637	10056	51	this	this	DT
18637	10056	52	office	office	NN
18637	10056	53	who	who	WP
18637	10056	54	have	have	VBP
18637	10056	55	uniformly	uniformly	RB
18637	10056	56	taken	take	VBN
18637	10056	57	the	the	DT
18637	10056	58	same	same	JJ
18637	10056	59	view	view	NN
18637	10056	60	.	.	.
18637	10057	1	Example	example	NN
18637	10057	2	of	of	IN
18637	10057	3	this	this	DT
18637	10057	4	are	be	VBP
18637	10057	5	to	to	TO
18637	10057	6	be	be	VB
18637	10057	7	found	find	VBN
18637	10057	8	in	in	IN
18637	10057	9	the	the	DT
18637	10057	10	following	follow	VBG
18637	10057	11	letters	letter	NNS
18637	10057	12	,	,	,
18637	10057	13	among	among	IN
18637	10057	14	others	other	NNS
18637	10057	15	:	:	:
18637	10057	16	"	"	``
18637	10057	17	Letter	Letter	NNP
18637	10057	18	of	of	IN
18637	10057	19	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10057	20	General	General	NNP
18637	10057	21	Knox	Knox	NNP
18637	10057	22	to	to	IN
18637	10057	23	the	the	DT
18637	10057	24	Speaker	Speaker	NNP
18637	10057	25	of	of	IN
18637	10057	26	the	the	DT
18637	10057	27	House	House	NNP
18637	10057	28	,	,	,
18637	10057	29	dated	date	VBN
18637	10057	30	April	April	NNP
18637	10057	31	27	27	CD
18637	10057	32	,	,	,
18637	10057	33	1904	1904	CD
18637	10057	34	,	,	,
18637	10057	35	declining	decline	VBG
18637	10057	36	to	to	TO
18637	10057	37	comply	comply	VB
18637	10057	38	with	with	IN
18637	10057	39	a	a	DT
18637	10057	40	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	10057	41	of	of	IN
18637	10057	42	the	the	DT
18637	10057	43	House	House	NNP
18637	10057	44	requesting	request	VBG
18637	10057	45	the	the	DT
18637	10057	46	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10057	47	General	General	NNP
18637	10057	48	to	to	TO
18637	10057	49	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	10057	50	the	the	DT
18637	10057	51	House	House	NNP
18637	10057	52	with	with	IN
18637	10057	53	all	all	DT
18637	10057	54	papers	paper	NNS
18637	10057	55	and	and	CC
18637	10057	56	documents	document	NNS
18637	10057	57	and	and	CC
18637	10057	58	other	other	JJ
18637	10057	59	information	information	NN
18637	10057	60	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	10057	61	the	the	DT
18637	10057	62	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	10057	63	of	of	IN
18637	10057	64	the	the	DT
18637	10057	65	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	10057	66	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	10057	67	case	case	NN
18637	10057	68	.	.	.
18637	10058	1	"	"	``
18637	10058	2	Letter	Letter	NNP
18637	10058	3	of	of	IN
18637	10058	4	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10058	5	General	General	NNP
18637	10058	6	Bonaparte	Bonaparte	NNP
18637	10058	7	to	to	IN
18637	10058	8	the	the	DT
18637	10058	9	Speaker	Speaker	NNP
18637	10058	10	of	of	IN
18637	10058	11	the	the	DT
18637	10058	12	House	House	NNP
18637	10058	13	,	,	,
18637	10058	14	dated	date	VBN
18637	10058	15	April	April	NNP
18637	10058	16	13	13	CD
18637	10058	17	,	,	,
18637	10058	18	1908	1908	CD
18637	10058	19	,	,	,
18637	10058	20	declining	decline	VBG
18637	10058	21	to	to	TO
18637	10058	22	comply	comply	VB
18637	10058	23	with	with	IN
18637	10058	24	a	a	DT
18637	10058	25	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	10058	26	of	of	IN
18637	10058	27	the	the	DT
18637	10058	28	House	House	NNP
18637	10058	29	requesting	request	VBG
18637	10058	30	the	the	DT
18637	10058	31	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10058	32	General	General	NNP
18637	10058	33	to	to	TO
18637	10058	34	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	10058	35	to	to	IN
18637	10058	36	the	the	DT
18637	10058	37	House	House	NNP
18637	10058	38	information	information	NN
18637	10058	39	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	10058	40	the	the	DT
18637	10058	41	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	10058	42	of	of	IN
18637	10058	43	certain	certain	JJ
18637	10058	44	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	10058	45	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	10058	46	in	in	IN
18637	10058	47	the	the	DT
18637	10058	48	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	10058	49	of	of	IN
18637	10058	50	wood	wood	NN
18637	10058	51	pulp	pulp	NN
18637	10058	52	or	or	CC
18637	10058	53	print	print	NN
18637	10058	54	paper	paper	NN
18637	10058	55	.	.	.
18637	10059	1	"	"	``
18637	10059	2	Letter	Letter	NNP
18637	10059	3	of	of	IN
18637	10059	4	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10059	5	General	General	NNP
18637	10059	6	Wickersham	Wickersham	NNP
18637	10059	7	to	to	IN
18637	10059	8	the	the	DT
18637	10059	9	Speaker	Speaker	NNP
18637	10059	10	of	of	IN
18637	10059	11	the	the	DT
18637	10059	12	House	House	NNP
18637	10059	13	,	,	,
18637	10059	14	dated	date	VBN
18637	10059	15	March	March	NNP
18637	10059	16	18	18	CD
18637	10059	17	,	,	,
18637	10059	18	1912	1912	CD
18637	10059	19	,	,	,
18637	10059	20	declining	decline	VBG
18637	10059	21	to	to	TO
18637	10059	22	comply	comply	VB
18637	10059	23	with	with	IN
18637	10059	24	a	a	DT
18637	10059	25	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	10059	26	of	of	IN
18637	10059	27	the	the	DT
18637	10059	28	House	House	NNP
18637	10059	29	directing	direct	VBG
18637	10059	30	the	the	DT
18637	10059	31	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10059	32	General	General	NNP
18637	10059	33	to	to	TO
18637	10059	34	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	10059	35	to	to	IN
18637	10059	36	the	the	DT
18637	10059	37	House	House	NNP
18637	10059	38	information	information	NN
18637	10059	39	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	10059	40	an	an	DT
18637	10059	41	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	10059	42	of	of	IN
18637	10059	43	the	the	DT
18637	10059	44	smelter	smelter	NNP
18637	10059	45	trust	trust	NNP
18637	10059	46	.	.	.
18637	10060	1	"	"	``
18637	10060	2	Letter	Letter	NNP
18637	10060	3	of	of	IN
18637	10060	4	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10060	5	General	General	NNP
18637	10060	6	McReynolds	McReynolds	NNP
18637	10060	7	to	to	IN
18637	10060	8	the	the	DT
18637	10060	9	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10060	10	to	to	IN
18637	10060	11	the	the	DT
18637	10060	12	President	President	NNP
18637	10060	13	,	,	,
18637	10060	14	dated	date	VBN
18637	10060	15	August	August	NNP
18637	10060	16	28	28	CD
18637	10060	17	,	,	,
18637	10060	18	1914	1914	CD
18637	10060	19	,	,	,
18637	10060	20	stating	state	VBG
18637	10060	21	that	that	IN
18637	10060	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10060	23	would	would	MD
18637	10060	24	be	be	VB
18637	10060	25	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
18637	10060	26	with	with	IN
18637	10060	27	the	the	DT
18637	10060	28	public	public	JJ
18637	10060	29	interest	interest	NN
18637	10060	30	to	to	TO
18637	10060	31	send	send	VB
18637	10060	32	to	to	IN
18637	10060	33	the	the	DT
18637	10060	34	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	10060	35	in	in	IN
18637	10060	36	response	response	NN
18637	10060	37	to	to	IN
18637	10060	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10060	39	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	10060	40	,	,	,
18637	10060	41	reports	report	NNS
18637	10060	42	made	make	VBN
18637	10060	43	to	to	IN
18637	10060	44	the	the	DT
18637	10060	45	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10060	46	General	General	NNP
18637	10060	47	by	by	IN
18637	10060	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10060	49	associates	associate	NNS
18637	10060	50	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	10060	51	violations	violation	NNS
18637	10060	52	of	of	IN
18637	10060	53	law	law	NN
18637	10060	54	by	by	IN
18637	10060	55	the	the	DT
18637	10060	56	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	10060	57	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	10060	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10060	59	"	"	''
18637	10060	60	Letter	Letter	NNP
18637	10060	61	of	of	IN
18637	10060	62	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10060	63	General	General	NNP
18637	10060	64	Gregory	Gregory	NNP
18637	10060	65	to	to	IN
18637	10060	66	the	the	DT
18637	10060	67	President	President	NNP
18637	10060	68	of	of	IN
18637	10060	69	the	the	DT
18637	10060	70	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	10060	71	,	,	,
18637	10060	72	dated	date	VBN
18637	10060	73	February	February	NNP
18637	10060	74	23	23	CD
18637	10060	75	,	,	,
18637	10060	76	1915	1915	CD
18637	10060	77	,	,	,
18637	10060	78	declining	decline	VBG
18637	10060	79	to	to	TO
18637	10060	80	comply	comply	VB
18637	10060	81	with	with	IN
18637	10060	82	a	a	DT
18637	10060	83	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	10060	84	of	of	IN
18637	10060	85	the	the	DT
18637	10060	86	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	10060	87	requesting	request	VBG
18637	10060	88	the	the	DT
18637	10060	89	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10060	90	General	General	NNP
18637	10060	91	to	to	TO
18637	10060	92	report	report	VB
18637	10060	93	to	to	IN
18637	10060	94	the	the	DT
18637	10060	95	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	10060	96	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10060	97	findings	finding	NNS
18637	10060	98	and	and	CC
18637	10060	99	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
18637	10060	100	in	in	IN
18637	10060	101	the	the	DT
18637	10060	102	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	10060	103	of	of	IN
18637	10060	104	the	the	DT
18637	10060	105	smelting	smelting	NN
18637	10060	106	industry	industry	NN
18637	10060	107	.	.	.
18637	10061	1	"	"	``
18637	10061	2	Letter	Letter	NNP
18637	10061	3	of	of	IN
18637	10061	4	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10061	5	General	General	NNP
18637	10061	6	Sargent	Sargent	NNP
18637	10061	7	to	to	IN
18637	10061	8	the	the	DT
18637	10061	9	chairman	chairman	NN
18637	10061	10	of	of	IN
18637	10061	11	the	the	DT
18637	10061	12	House	House	NNP
18637	10061	13	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	10061	14	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	10061	15	,	,	,
18637	10061	16	dated	date	VBN
18637	10061	17	June	June	NNP
18637	10061	18	8	8	CD
18637	10061	19	,	,	,
18637	10061	20	1926	1926	CD
18637	10061	21	,	,	,
18637	10061	22	declining	decline	VBG
18637	10061	23	to	to	TO
18637	10061	24	comply	comply	VB
18637	10061	25	with	with	IN
18637	10061	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10061	27	request	request	NN
18637	10061	28	to	to	TO
18637	10061	29	turn	turn	VB
18637	10061	30	over	over	RP
18637	10061	31	to	to	IN
18637	10061	32	the	the	DT
18637	10061	33	committee	committee	NN
18637	10061	34	all	all	DT
18637	10061	35	papers	paper	NNS
18637	10061	36	in	in	IN
18637	10061	37	the	the	DT
18637	10061	38	files	file	NNS
18637	10061	39	of	of	IN
18637	10061	40	the	the	DT
18637	10061	41	Department	Department	NNP
18637	10061	42	relating	relate	VBG
18637	10061	43	to	to	IN
18637	10061	44	the	the	DT
18637	10061	45	merger	merger	NN
18637	10061	46	of	of	IN
18637	10061	47	certain	certain	JJ
18637	10061	48	oil	oil	NN
18637	10061	49	companies	company	NNS
18637	10061	50	.	.	.
18637	10062	1	*	*	NFP
18637	10062	2	*	*	NFP
18637	10062	3	*	*	NFP
18637	10062	4	"	"	``
18637	10062	5	This	this	DT
18637	10062	6	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	10062	7	in	in	IN
18637	10062	8	the	the	DT
18637	10062	9	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10062	10	branch	branch	NN
18637	10062	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	10062	12	been	be	VBN
18637	10062	13	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	10062	14	and	and	CC
18637	10062	15	respected	respect	VBN
18637	10062	16	by	by	IN
18637	10062	17	the	the	DT
18637	10062	18	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	10062	19	.	.	.
18637	10063	1	The	the	DT
18637	10063	2	courts	court	NNS
18637	10063	3	have	have	VBP
18637	10063	4	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	10063	5	held	hold	VBN
18637	10063	6	that	that	IN
18637	10063	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10063	8	will	will	MD
18637	10063	9	not	not	RB
18637	10063	10	and	and	CC
18637	10063	11	can	can	MD
18637	10063	12	not	not	RB
18637	10063	13	require	require	VB
18637	10063	14	the	the	DT
18637	10063	15	executive	executive	NN
18637	10063	16	to	to	TO
18637	10063	17	produce	produce	VB
18637	10063	18	such	such	JJ
18637	10063	19	papers	paper	NNS
18637	10063	20	when	when	WRB
18637	10063	21	in	in	IN
18637	10063	22	the	the	DT
18637	10063	23	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10063	24	of	of	IN
18637	10063	25	the	the	DT
18637	10063	26	executive	executive	NN
18637	10063	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10063	28	production	production	NN
18637	10063	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	10063	30	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	10063	31	to	to	IN
18637	10063	32	the	the	DT
18637	10063	33	public	public	JJ
18637	10063	34	interests	interest	NNS
18637	10063	35	.	.	.
18637	10064	1	The	the	DT
18637	10064	2	courts	court	NNS
18637	10064	3	have	have	VBP
18637	10064	4	also	also	RB
18637	10064	5	held	hold	VBN
18637	10064	6	that	that	IN
18637	10064	7	the	the	DT
18637	10064	8	question	question	NN
18637	10064	9	whether	whether	IN
18637	10064	10	the	the	DT
18637	10064	11	production	production	NN
18637	10064	12	of	of	IN
18637	10064	13	the	the	DT
18637	10064	14	papers	paper	NNS
18637	10064	15	would	would	MD
18637	10064	16	be	be	VB
18637	10064	17	against	against	IN
18637	10064	18	the	the	DT
18637	10064	19	public	public	JJ
18637	10064	20	interest	interest	NN
18637	10064	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	10064	22	one	one	CD
18637	10064	23	for	for	IN
18637	10064	24	the	the	DT
18637	10064	25	executive	executive	NN
18637	10064	26	and	and	CC
18637	10064	27	not	not	RB
18637	10064	28	for	for	IN
18637	10064	29	the	the	DT
18637	10064	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	10064	31	to	to	TO
18637	10064	32	determine	determine	VB
18637	10064	33	.	.	.
18637	10064	34	"	"	''
18637	10065	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	10065	2	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	10065	3	cites	cite	VBZ
18637	10065	4	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	10065	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10065	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10065	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10065	8	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	10065	9	,	,	,
18637	10065	10	1	1	CD
18637	10065	11	Cr	cr	NN
18637	10065	12	.	.	.
18637	10066	1	137	137	CD
18637	10066	2	,	,	,
18637	10066	3	169	169	CD
18637	10066	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10066	5	1803	1803	CD
18637	10066	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10066	7	;	;	:
18637	10066	8	and	and	CC
18637	10066	9	more	more	JJR
18637	10066	10	than	than	IN
18637	10066	11	a	a	DT
18637	10066	12	dozen	dozen	NN
18637	10066	13	other	other	JJ
18637	10066	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	10066	15	,	,	,
18637	10066	16	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10066	17	and	and	CC
18637	10066	18	State	State	NNP
18637	10066	19	,	,	,
18637	10066	20	most	most	JJS
18637	10066	21	of	of	IN
18637	10066	22	which	which	WDT
18637	10066	23	involved	involve	VBD
18637	10066	24	"	"	``
18637	10066	25	privileged	privileged	JJ
18637	10066	26	communications	communication	NNS
18637	10066	27	"	"	''
18637	10066	28	in	in	IN
18637	10066	29	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	10066	30	court	court	NN
18637	10066	31	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10066	32	.	.	.
18637	10067	1	The	the	DT
18637	10067	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	10067	3	of	of	IN
18637	10067	4	the	the	DT
18637	10067	5	equality	equality	NN
18637	10067	6	of	of	IN
18637	10067	7	the	the	DT
18637	10067	8	three	three	CD
18637	10067	9	departments	department	NNS
18637	10067	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	10067	11	also	also	RB
18637	10067	12	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	10067	13	by	by	IN
18637	10067	14	him.--10	him.--10	ADD
18637	10067	15	Op	op	NN
18637	10067	16	.	.	.
18637	10068	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	10068	2	.	.	.
18637	10069	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	10069	2	45	45	CD
18637	10069	3	.	.	.
18637	10070	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10070	2	329	329	CD
18637	10070	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10070	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10070	5	See	See	NNP
18637	10070	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10070	7	Norman	Norman	NNP
18637	10070	8	J.	J.	NNP
18637	10071	1	Small	small	JJ
18637	10071	2	,	,	,
18637	10071	3	Some	some	DT
18637	10071	4	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	10071	5	Interpretations	Interpretations	NNPS
18637	10071	6	of	of	IN
18637	10071	7	the	the	DT
18637	10071	8	Presidency	Presidency	NNP
18637	10071	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10071	10	Johns	Johns	NNP
18637	10071	11	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	10071	12	Press	Press	NNP
18637	10071	13	,	,	,
18637	10071	14	1932	1932	CD
18637	10071	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10071	16	;	;	:
18637	10071	17	Henry	Henry	NNP
18637	10071	18	C.	C.	NNP
18637	10071	19	Black	Black	NNP
18637	10071	20	,	,	,
18637	10071	21	The	the	DT
18637	10071	22	Relation	Relation	NNP
18637	10071	23	of	of	IN
18637	10071	24	the	the	DT
18637	10071	25	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	10071	26	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10071	27	to	to	IN
18637	10071	28	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
18637	10071	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10071	30	Princeton	Princeton	NNP
18637	10071	31	,	,	,
18637	10071	32	1919	1919	CD
18637	10071	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10071	34	;	;	:
18637	10071	35	W.E.	W.E.	NNP
18637	10072	1	Binkley	Binkley	NNP
18637	10072	2	,	,	,
18637	10072	3	The	the	DT
18637	10072	4	President	President	NNP
18637	10072	5	and	and	CC
18637	10072	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10072	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10072	8	New	New	NNP
18637	10072	9	York	York	NNP
18637	10072	10	,	,	,
18637	10072	11	1947	1947	CD
18637	10072	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10072	13	;	;	:
18637	10072	14	Edward	Edward	NNP
18637	10072	15	S.	S.	NNP
18637	10072	16	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	10072	17	,	,	,
18637	10072	18	The	the	DT
18637	10072	19	President	President	NNP
18637	10072	20	,	,	,
18637	10072	21	Office	Office	NNP
18637	10072	22	and	and	CC
18637	10072	23	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	10072	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10072	25	3d	3d	NNP
18637	10072	26	ed	ed	NNP
18637	10072	27	.	.	NNP
18637	10072	28	,	,	,
18637	10072	29	1948	1948	CD
18637	10072	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10072	31	,	,	,
18637	10072	32	Chaps	Chaps	NNP
18637	10072	33	.	.	.
18637	10073	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10073	2	and	and	CC
18637	10073	3	VII	VII	NNP
18637	10073	4	,	,	,
18637	10073	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10073	6	passim	passim	NN
18637	10073	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10073	8	.	.	.
18637	10074	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10074	2	330	330	CD
18637	10074	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10074	4	The	the	DT
18637	10074	5	first	first	JJ
18637	10074	6	Harrison	Harrison	NNP
18637	10074	7	,	,	,
18637	10074	8	Polk	Polk	NNP
18637	10074	9	,	,	,
18637	10074	10	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	10074	11	,	,	,
18637	10074	12	and	and	CC
18637	10074	13	Fillmore	Fillmore	NNP
18637	10074	14	all	all	DT
18637	10074	15	fathered	father	VBD
18637	10074	16	sentiments	sentiment	NNS
18637	10074	17	to	to	IN
18637	10074	18	this	this	DT
18637	10074	19	general	general	JJ
18637	10074	20	effect	effect	NN
18637	10074	21	.	.	.
18637	10075	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10075	2	See	See	NNP
18637	10075	3	_	_	NNP
18637	10075	4	Messages	Messages	NNPS
18637	10075	5	and	and	CC
18637	10075	6	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	10075	7	of	of	IN
18637	10075	8	the	the	DT
18637	10075	9	President	President	NNP
18637	10075	10	,	,	,
18637	10075	11	IV	IV	NNP
18637	10075	12	,	,	,
18637	10075	13	1864	1864	CD
18637	10075	14	;	;	:
18637	10075	15	V	v	NN
18637	10075	16	,	,	,
18637	10075	17	2493	2493	CD
18637	10075	18	;	;	:
18637	10075	19	VI	VI	NNP
18637	10075	20	,	,	,
18637	10075	21	2513	2513	CD
18637	10075	22	-	-	SYM
18637	10075	23	2519	2519	CD
18637	10075	24	,	,	,
18637	10075	25	2561	2561	CD
18637	10075	26	-	-	SYM
18637	10075	27	2562	2562	CD
18637	10075	28	,	,	,
18637	10075	29	2608	2608	CD
18637	10075	30	,	,	,
18637	10075	31	2615	2615	CD
18637	10075	32	.	.	.
18637	10076	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10076	2	331	331	CD
18637	10076	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10076	4	Note	note	NN
18637	10076	5	1	1	CD
18637	10076	6	,	,	,
18637	10076	7	above	above	RB
18637	10076	8	.	.	.
18637	10077	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10077	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	10077	3	's	's	POS
18637	10077	4	Note	note	NN
18637	10077	5	:	:	:
18637	10077	6	Reference	reference	NN
18637	10077	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	10077	8	to	to	IN
18637	10077	9	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	10077	10	329	329	CD
18637	10077	11	,	,	,
18637	10077	12	above	above	RB
18637	10077	13	.	.	.
18637	10077	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10078	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10078	2	332	332	CD
18637	10078	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10078	4	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	10078	5	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	10078	6	,	,	,
18637	10078	7	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	10078	8	Declarations	Declarations	NNPS
18637	10078	9	of	of	IN
18637	10078	10	Independence	Independence	NNP
18637	10078	11	,	,	,
18637	10078	12	10	10	CD
18637	10078	13	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	10078	14	University	University	NNP
18637	10078	15	Law	Law	NNP
18637	10078	16	Review	Review	NNP
18637	10078	17	,	,	,
18637	10078	18	No	no	UH
18637	10078	19	.	.	.
18637	10079	1	1	1	LS
18637	10079	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10079	3	January	January	NNP
18637	10079	4	,	,	,
18637	10079	5	1930	1930	CD
18637	10079	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10079	7	;	;	:
18637	10079	8	Willoughby	Willoughby	NNP
18637	10079	9	,	,	,
18637	10079	10	On	on	IN
18637	10079	11	the	the	DT
18637	10079	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10079	13	,	,	,
18637	10079	14	III	III	NNP
18637	10079	15	,	,	,
18637	10079	16	1488	1488	CD
18637	10079	17	-	-	SYM
18637	10079	18	1492	1492	CD
18637	10079	19	.	.	.
18637	10080	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10080	2	333	333	CD
18637	10080	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10080	4	7	7	CD
18637	10080	5	Op	Op	NNP
18637	10080	6	.	.	.
18637	10081	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	10081	2	.	.	.
18637	10082	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	10082	2	186	186	CD
18637	10082	3	,	,	,
18637	10082	4	209	209	CD
18637	10082	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10082	6	1855	1855	CD
18637	10082	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10082	8	.	.	.
18637	10083	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10083	2	334	334	CD
18637	10083	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10083	4	5	5	CD
18637	10083	5	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	10083	6	,	,	,
18637	10083	7	International	International	NNP
18637	10083	8	Law	Law	NNP
18637	10083	9	Digest	Digest	NNP
18637	10083	10	,	,	,
18637	10083	11	15	15	CD
18637	10083	12	-	-	SYM
18637	10083	13	19	19	CD
18637	10083	14	.	.	.
18637	10084	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10084	2	335	335	CD
18637	10084	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10084	4	4	4	CD
18637	10084	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10084	6	.	.	.
18637	10085	1	473	473	CD
18637	10085	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10085	3	548	548	CD
18637	10085	4	;	;	:
18637	10085	5	5	5	CD
18637	10085	6	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10085	7	.	.	.
18637	10086	1	19	19	CD
18637	10086	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10086	3	32	32	CD
18637	10086	4	.	.	.
18637	10087	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10087	2	336	336	CD
18637	10087	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10087	4	Opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10087	5	on	on	IN
18637	10087	6	the	the	DT
18637	10087	7	Question	Question	NNP
18637	10087	8	Whether	whether	IN
18637	10087	9	the	the	DT
18637	10087	10	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	10087	11	Has	have	VBZ
18637	10087	12	the	the	DT
18637	10087	13	Right	right	NN
18637	10087	14	to	to	IN
18637	10087	15	Negative	Negative	NNP
18637	10087	16	the	the	DT
18637	10087	17	Grade	Grade	NNP
18637	10087	18	of	of	IN
18637	10087	19	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	10087	20	Appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	10087	21	by	by	IN
18637	10087	22	the	the	DT
18637	10087	23	Executive	executive	NN
18637	10087	24	to	to	TO
18637	10087	25	Fill	fill	VB
18637	10087	26	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	10087	27	Missions	Missions	NNPS
18637	10087	28	,	,	,
18637	10087	29	April	April	NNP
18637	10087	30	24	24	CD
18637	10087	31	,	,	,
18637	10087	32	1790	1790	CD
18637	10087	33	;	;	:
18637	10087	34	Padover	Padover	NNP
18637	10087	35	,	,	,
18637	10087	36	The	the	DT
18637	10087	37	Complete	Complete	NNP
18637	10087	38	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	10087	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10087	40	New	New	NNP
18637	10087	41	York	York	NNP
18637	10087	42	,	,	,
18637	10087	43	1943	1943	CD
18637	10087	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10087	45	,	,	,
18637	10087	46	138	138	CD
18637	10087	47	.	.	.
18637	10088	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10088	2	337	337	CD
18637	10088	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10088	4	4	4	CD
18637	10088	5	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	10088	6	,	,	,
18637	10088	7	International	International	NNP
18637	10088	8	Law	Law	NNP
18637	10088	9	Digest	Digest	NNP
18637	10088	10	,	,	,
18637	10088	11	680	680	CD
18637	10088	12	-	-	SYM
18637	10088	13	681	681	CD
18637	10088	14	.	.	.
18637	10089	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10089	2	338	338	CD
18637	10089	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10089	4	This	this	DT
18637	10089	5	measure	measure	NN
18637	10089	6	,	,	,
18637	10089	7	amended	amend	VBN
18637	10089	8	by	by	IN
18637	10089	9	the	the	DT
18637	10089	10	act	act	NN
18637	10089	11	of	of	IN
18637	10089	12	March	March	NNP
18637	10089	13	4	4	CD
18637	10089	14	,	,	,
18637	10089	15	1909	1909	CD
18637	10089	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10089	17	35	35	CD
18637	10089	18	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	10089	19	.	.	.
18637	10090	1	1088	1088	CD
18637	10090	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10090	3	,	,	,
18637	10090	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	10090	5	now	now	RB
18637	10090	6	18	18	CD
18637	10090	7	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	10091	1	§	§	NNP
18637	10091	2	953	953	CD
18637	10091	3	.	.	.
18637	10092	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10092	2	339	339	CD
18637	10092	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10092	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10092	5	See	See	NNP
18637	10092	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10092	7	Memorandum	Memorandum	NNP
18637	10092	8	on	on	IN
18637	10092	9	the	the	DT
18637	10092	10	History	History	NNP
18637	10092	11	and	and	CC
18637	10092	12	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	10092	13	of	of	IN
18637	10092	14	the	the	DT
18637	10092	15	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	10092	16	Prohibiting	Prohibiting	NNP
18637	10092	17	Correspondence	Correspondence	NNP
18637	10092	18	with	with	IN
18637	10092	19	a	a	DT
18637	10092	20	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	10092	21	Government	Government	NNP
18637	10092	22	,	,	,
18637	10092	23	S.	S.	NNP
18637	10092	24	Doc	Doc	NNP
18637	10092	25	.	.	.
18637	10093	1	696	696	CD
18637	10093	2	,	,	,
18637	10093	3	64th	64th	NNP
18637	10093	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	10093	5	.	.	NNP
18637	10093	6	,	,	,
18637	10093	7	2d	2d	CD
18637	10093	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	10093	9	.	.	.
18637	10093	10	,	,	,
18637	10093	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10093	12	1917	1917	CD
18637	10093	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10093	14	.	.	.
18637	10094	1	The	the	DT
18637	10094	2	author	author	NN
18637	10094	3	was	be	VBD
18637	10094	4	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	10094	5	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	10094	6	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	10094	7	,	,	,
18637	10094	8	then	then	RB
18637	10094	9	Assistant	Assistant	NNP
18637	10094	10	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10094	11	General	General	NNP
18637	10094	12	.	.	.
18637	10095	1	Further	further	JJ
18637	10095	2	details	detail	NNS
18637	10095	3	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	10095	4	the	the	DT
18637	10095	5	observance	observance	NN
18637	10095	6	of	of	IN
18637	10095	7	the	the	DT
18637	10095	8	"	"	``
18637	10095	9	Logan	Logan	NNP
18637	10095	10	"	"	''
18637	10095	11	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10095	12	are	be	VBP
18637	10095	13	given	give	VBN
18637	10095	14	in	in	IN
18637	10095	15	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	10095	16	,	,	,
18637	10095	17	The	the	DT
18637	10095	18	President	President	NNP
18637	10095	19	,	,	,
18637	10095	20	Office	Office	NNP
18637	10095	21	and	and	CC
18637	10095	22	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	10095	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10095	24	3d	3d	NNP
18637	10095	25	ed	ed	NNP
18637	10095	26	.	.	.
18637	10095	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10096	1	223	223	CD
18637	10096	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10096	3	224	224	CD
18637	10096	4	,	,	,
18637	10096	5	469	469	CD
18637	10096	6	-	-	SYM
18637	10096	7	470	470	CD
18637	10096	8	.	.	.
18637	10097	1	Early	early	RB
18637	10097	2	in	in	IN
18637	10097	3	October	October	NNP
18637	10097	4	,	,	,
18637	10097	5	1950	1950	CD
18637	10097	6	President	President	NNP
18637	10097	7	Harold	Harold	NNP
18637	10097	8	Stassen	Stassen	NNP
18637	10097	9	of	of	IN
18637	10097	10	the	the	DT
18637	10097	11	University	University	NNP
18637	10097	12	of	of	IN
18637	10097	13	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	10097	14	announced	announce	VBD
18637	10097	15	that	that	IN
18637	10097	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10097	17	had	have	VBD
18637	10097	18	written	write	VBN
18637	10097	19	Premier	Premier	NNP
18637	10097	20	Stalin	Stalin	NNP
18637	10097	21	offering	offer	VBG
18637	10097	22	to	to	TO
18637	10097	23	confer	confer	VB
18637	10097	24	with	with	IN
18637	10097	25	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10097	26	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	10097	27	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10097	28	between	between	IN
18637	10097	29	the	the	DT
18637	10097	30	two	two	CD
18637	10097	31	governments	government	NNS
18637	10097	32	.	.	.
18637	10098	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10098	2	340	340	CD
18637	10098	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10098	4	Benton	Benton	NNP
18637	10098	5	Abridgment	Abridgment	NNP
18637	10098	6	of	of	IN
18637	10098	7	the	the	DT
18637	10098	8	Debates	Debates	NNPS
18637	10098	9	of	of	IN
18637	10098	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10098	11	,	,	,
18637	10098	12	466	466	CD
18637	10098	13	-	-	SYM
18637	10098	14	467	467	CD
18637	10098	15	.	.	.
18637	10099	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10099	2	341	341	CD
18637	10099	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10099	4	S.	S.	NNP
18637	10099	5	Doc	Doc	NNP
18637	10099	6	.	.	.
18637	10100	1	56	56	CD
18637	10100	2	,	,	,
18637	10100	3	54th	54th	JJ
18637	10100	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	10100	5	.	.	NNP
18637	10100	6	,	,	,
18637	10100	7	2d	2d	CD
18637	10100	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	10100	9	.	.	.
18637	10100	10	,	,	,
18637	10100	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10100	12	1897	1897	CD
18637	10100	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10100	14	.	.	.
18637	10101	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10101	2	342	342	CD
18637	10101	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10101	4	The	the	DT
18637	10101	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	10101	6	,	,	,
18637	10101	7	containing	contain	VBG
18637	10101	8	the	the	DT
18637	10101	9	Letters	Letters	NNPS
18637	10101	10	of	of	IN
18637	10101	11	Pacificus	Pacificus	NNP
18637	10101	12	and	and	CC
18637	10101	13	Helvidius	Helvidius	NNP
18637	10101	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10101	15	New	New	NNP
18637	10101	16	ed	ed	NNP
18637	10101	17	.	.	NNP
18637	10101	18	,	,	,
18637	10101	19	1852	1852	CD
18637	10101	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10101	21	444	444	CD
18637	10101	22	;	;	:
18637	10101	23	_	_	NNP
18637	10101	24	see	see	VB
18637	10101	25	also	also	RB
18637	10101	26	_	_	NNP
18637	10101	27	p.	p.	NN
18637	10101	28	493	493	CD
18637	10101	29	,	,	,
18637	10101	30	n.	n.	NNP
18637	10101	31	1	1	CD
18637	10101	32	.	.	.
18637	10102	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10102	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	10102	3	's	's	POS
18637	10102	4	Note	note	NN
18637	10102	5	:	:	:
18637	10102	6	Reference	reference	NN
18637	10102	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	10102	8	to	to	IN
18637	10102	9	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	10102	10	344	344	CD
18637	10102	11	,	,	,
18637	10102	12	below	below	RB
18637	10102	13	.	.	.
18637	10102	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10103	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10103	2	343	343	CD
18637	10103	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10103	4	The	the	DT
18637	10103	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	10103	6	No	no	NN
18637	10103	7	.	.	.
18637	10104	1	69	69	CD
18637	10104	2	,	,	,
18637	10104	3	where	where	WRB
18637	10104	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10104	5	wrote	write	VBD
18637	10104	6	:	:	:
18637	10104	7	"	"	``
18637	10104	8	The	the	DT
18637	10104	9	president	president	NN
18637	10104	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	10104	11	also	also	RB
18637	10104	12	to	to	TO
18637	10104	13	be	be	VB
18637	10104	14	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	10104	15	to	to	TO
18637	10104	16	receive	receive	VB
18637	10104	17	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	10104	18	,	,	,
18637	10104	19	and	and	CC
18637	10104	20	other	other	JJ
18637	10104	21	public	public	JJ
18637	10104	22	ministers	minister	NNS
18637	10104	23	.	.	.
18637	10105	1	This	this	DT
18637	10105	2	,	,	,
18637	10105	3	though	though	IN
18637	10105	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10105	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	10105	6	been	be	VBN
18637	10105	7	a	a	DT
18637	10105	8	rich	rich	JJ
18637	10105	9	theme	theme	NN
18637	10105	10	of	of	IN
18637	10105	11	declamation	declamation	NN
18637	10105	12	,	,	,
18637	10105	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	10105	14	more	more	RBR
18637	10105	15	a	a	DT
18637	10105	16	matter	matter	NN
18637	10105	17	of	of	IN
18637	10105	18	dignity	dignity	NN
18637	10105	19	than	than	IN
18637	10105	20	of	of	IN
18637	10105	21	authority	authority	NN
18637	10105	22	.	.	.
18637	10106	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10106	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	10106	3	a	a	DT
18637	10106	4	circumstance	circumstance	NN
18637	10106	5	which	which	WDT
18637	10106	6	will	will	MD
18637	10106	7	be	be	VB
18637	10106	8	without	without	IN
18637	10106	9	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	10106	10	in	in	IN
18637	10106	11	the	the	DT
18637	10106	12	administration	administration	NN
18637	10106	13	of	of	IN
18637	10106	14	the	the	DT
18637	10106	15	government	government	NN
18637	10106	16	;	;	:
18637	10106	17	and	and	CC
18637	10106	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10106	19	was	be	VBD
18637	10106	20	far	far	RB
18637	10106	21	more	more	RBR
18637	10106	22	convenient	convenient	JJ
18637	10106	23	that	that	IN
18637	10106	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10106	25	should	should	MD
18637	10106	26	be	be	VB
18637	10106	27	arranged	arrange	VBN
18637	10106	28	in	in	IN
18637	10106	29	this	this	DT
18637	10106	30	manner	manner	NN
18637	10106	31	,	,	,
18637	10106	32	than	than	IN
18637	10106	33	that	that	IN
18637	10106	34	there	there	EX
18637	10106	35	should	should	MD
18637	10106	36	be	be	VB
18637	10106	37	a	a	DT
18637	10106	38	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	10106	39	of	of	IN
18637	10106	40	convening	convene	VBG
18637	10106	41	the	the	DT
18637	10106	42	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	10106	43	,	,	,
18637	10106	44	or	or	CC
18637	10106	45	one	one	CD
18637	10106	46	of	of	IN
18637	10106	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10106	48	branches	branch	NNS
18637	10106	49	,	,	,
18637	10106	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	10106	51	every	every	DT
18637	10106	52	arrival	arrival	NN
18637	10106	53	of	of	IN
18637	10106	54	a	a	DT
18637	10106	55	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	10106	56	minister	minister	NN
18637	10106	57	;	;	:
18637	10106	58	though	though	IN
18637	10106	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10106	60	were	be	VBD
18637	10106	61	merely	merely	RB
18637	10106	62	to	to	TO
18637	10106	63	take	take	VB
18637	10106	64	the	the	DT
18637	10106	65	place	place	NN
18637	10106	66	of	of	IN
18637	10106	67	a	a	DT
18637	10106	68	departed	depart	VBN
18637	10106	69	predecessor	predecessor	NN
18637	10106	70	.	.	.
18637	10106	71	"	"	''
18637	10107	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	10107	2	.	.	.
18637	10108	1	518	518	CD
18637	10108	2	.	.	.
18637	10109	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10109	2	344	344	CD
18637	10109	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10109	4	"	"	``
18637	10109	5	Letters	Letters	NNPS
18637	10109	6	of	of	IN
18637	10109	7	Pacificus	Pacificus	NNP
18637	10109	8	,	,	,
18637	10109	9	"	"	''
18637	10109	10	7	7	CD
18637	10109	11	Works	Works	NNP
18637	10109	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10109	13	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	10109	14	ed	ed	NNP
18637	10109	15	.	.	.
18637	10109	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10110	1	76	76	CD
18637	10110	2	,	,	,
18637	10110	3	82	82	CD
18637	10110	4	-	-	SYM
18637	10110	5	83	83	CD
18637	10110	6	.	.	.
18637	10111	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10111	2	345	345	CD
18637	10111	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10111	4	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	10111	5	,	,	,
18637	10111	6	International	International	NNP
18637	10111	7	Law	Law	NNP
18637	10111	8	Digest	Digest	NNP
18637	10111	9	,	,	,
18637	10111	10	IV	IV	NNP
18637	10111	11	,	,	,
18637	10111	12	680	680	CD
18637	10111	13	-	-	SYM
18637	10111	14	681	681	CD
18637	10111	15	.	.	.
18637	10112	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10112	2	346	346	CD
18637	10112	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10112	4	The	the	DT
18637	10112	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	10112	6	containing	contain	VBG
18637	10112	7	the	the	DT
18637	10112	8	Letters	Letters	NNPS
18637	10112	9	of	of	IN
18637	10112	10	Pacificus	Pacificus	NNP
18637	10112	11	and	and	CC
18637	10112	12	Helvidius	Helvidius	NNP
18637	10112	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10112	14	New	New	NNP
18637	10112	15	ed	ed	NN
18637	10112	16	.	.	.
18637	10113	1	1852	1852	CD
18637	10113	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10113	3	445	445	CD
18637	10113	4	-	-	SYM
18637	10113	5	446	446	CD
18637	10113	6	.	.	.
18637	10114	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10114	2	347	347	CD
18637	10114	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10114	4	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	10114	5	,	,	,
18637	10114	6	International	International	NNP
18637	10114	7	Law	Law	NNP
18637	10114	8	Digest	Digest	NNP
18637	10114	9	,	,	,
18637	10114	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10114	11	,	,	,
18637	10114	12	243	243	CD
18637	10114	13	-	-	SYM
18637	10114	14	244	244	CD
18637	10114	15	.	.	.
18637	10115	1	The	the	DT
18637	10115	2	course	course	NN
18637	10115	3	of	of	IN
18637	10115	4	the	the	DT
18637	10115	5	Monroe	Monroe	NNP
18637	10115	6	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	10115	7	in	in	IN
18637	10115	8	inviting	invite	VBG
18637	10115	9	the	the	DT
18637	10115	10	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	10115	11	of	of	IN
18637	10115	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10115	13	in	in	IN
18637	10115	14	connection	connection	NN
18637	10115	15	with	with	IN
18637	10115	16	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	10115	17	of	of	IN
18637	10115	18	the	the	DT
18637	10115	19	Spanish	spanish	JJ
18637	10115	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	10115	21	American	American	NNP
18637	10115	22	Republics	Republics	NNP
18637	10115	23	,	,	,
18637	10115	24	although	although	IN
18637	10115	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10115	26	was	be	VBD
18637	10115	27	prompted	prompt	VBN
18637	10115	28	mainly	mainly	RB
18637	10115	29	by	by	IN
18637	10115	30	the	the	DT
18637	10115	31	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	10115	32	that	that	IN
18637	10115	33	war	war	NN
18637	10115	34	with	with	IN
18637	10115	35	Spain	Spain	NNP
18637	10115	36	might	may	MD
18637	10115	37	result	result	VB
18637	10115	38	,	,	,
18637	10115	39	was	be	VBD
18637	10115	40	nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
18637	10115	41	opposed	oppose	VBN
18637	10115	42	by	by	IN
18637	10115	43	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10115	44	of	of	IN
18637	10115	45	State	State	NNP
18637	10115	46	John	John	NNP
18637	10115	47	Quincy	Quincy	NNP
18637	10115	48	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	10115	49	.	.	.
18637	10116	1	"	"	``
18637	10116	2	Instead	instead	RB
18637	10116	3	,	,	,
18637	10116	4	"	"	''
18637	10116	5	said	say	VBD
18637	10116	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10116	7	,	,	,
18637	10116	8	"	"	``
18637	10116	9	of	of	IN
18637	10116	10	admitting	admit	VBG
18637	10116	11	the	the	DT
18637	10116	12	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	10116	13	or	or	CC
18637	10116	14	House	House	NNP
18637	10116	15	of	of	IN
18637	10116	16	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	10116	17	to	to	IN
18637	10116	18	any	any	DT
18637	10116	19	share	share	NN
18637	10116	20	in	in	IN
18637	10116	21	the	the	DT
18637	10116	22	act	act	NN
18637	10116	23	of	of	IN
18637	10116	24	recognition	recognition	NNP
18637	10116	25	,	,	,
18637	10116	26	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10116	27	would	would	MD
18637	10116	28	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	10116	29	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	10116	30	that	that	DT
18637	10116	31	form	form	NN
18637	10116	32	of	of	IN
18637	10116	33	doing	do	VBG
18637	10116	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10116	35	which	which	WDT
18637	10116	36	would	would	MD
18637	10116	37	require	require	VB
18637	10116	38	the	the	DT
18637	10116	39	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	10116	40	of	of	IN
18637	10116	41	those	those	DT
18637	10116	42	bodies	body	NNS
18637	10116	43	.	.	.
18637	10117	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10117	2	was	be	VBD
18637	10117	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10117	4	had	have	VBD
18637	10117	5	no	no	RB
18637	10117	6	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	10117	7	,	,	,
18637	10117	8	by	by	IN
18637	10117	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10117	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10117	11	an	an	DT
18637	10117	12	act	act	NN
18637	10117	13	of	of	IN
18637	10117	14	the	the	DT
18637	10117	15	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	10117	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	10117	17	.	.	.
18637	10118	1	General	General	NNP
18637	10118	2	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	10118	3	had	have	VBD
18637	10118	4	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	10118	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10118	6	in	in	IN
18637	10118	7	recognizing	recognize	VBG
18637	10118	8	the	the	DT
18637	10118	9	French	French	NNP
18637	10118	10	Republic	Republic	NNP
18637	10118	11	by	by	IN
18637	10118	12	the	the	DT
18637	10118	13	reception	reception	NN
18637	10118	14	of	of	IN
18637	10118	15	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	10118	16	Genet	Genet	NNP
18637	10118	17	.	.	.
18637	10119	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	10119	2	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	10119	3	had	have	VBD
18637	10119	4	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	10119	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10119	6	by	by	IN
18637	10119	7	declining	decline	VBG
18637	10119	8	several	several	JJ
18637	10119	9	years	year	NNS
18637	10119	10	to	to	TO
18637	10119	11	receive	receive	VB
18637	10119	12	,	,	,
18637	10119	13	and	and	CC
18637	10119	14	by	by	IN
18637	10119	15	finally	finally	RB
18637	10119	16	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	10119	17	,	,	,
18637	10119	18	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	10119	19	Onis	Onis	NNP
18637	10119	20	;	;	:
18637	10119	21	and	and	CC
18637	10119	22	in	in	IN
18637	10119	23	this	this	DT
18637	10119	24	instance	instance	NN
18637	10119	25	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10119	26	thought	think	VBD
18637	10119	27	the	the	DT
18637	10119	28	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	10119	29	ought	ought	MD
18637	10119	30	carefully	carefully	RB
18637	10119	31	to	to	TO
18637	10119	32	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	10119	33	entire	entire	JJ
18637	10119	34	the	the	DT
18637	10119	35	authority	authority	NN
18637	10119	36	given	give	VBN
18637	10119	37	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10119	38	by	by	IN
18637	10119	39	the	the	DT
18637	10119	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10119	41	,	,	,
18637	10119	42	and	and	CC
18637	10119	43	not	not	RB
18637	10119	44	weaken	weaken	VB
18637	10119	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10119	46	by	by	IN
18637	10119	47	setting	set	VBG
18637	10119	48	the	the	DT
18637	10119	49	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	10119	50	of	of	IN
18637	10119	51	making	make	VBG
18637	10119	52	either	either	CC
18637	10119	53	House	House	NNP
18637	10119	54	of	of	IN
18637	10119	55	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10119	56	a	a	DT
18637	10119	57	party	party	NN
18637	10119	58	to	to	IN
18637	10119	59	an	an	DT
18637	10119	60	act	act	NN
18637	10119	61	which	which	WDT
18637	10119	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10119	63	was	be	VBD
18637	10119	64	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10119	65	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	10119	66	right	right	NN
18637	10119	67	and	and	CC
18637	10119	68	duty	duty	NN
18637	10119	69	to	to	TO
18637	10119	70	perform	perform	VB
18637	10119	71	.	.	.
18637	10120	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	10120	2	Crawford	Crawford	NNP
18637	10120	3	said	say	VBD
18637	10120	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10120	5	did	do	VBD
18637	10120	6	not	not	RB
18637	10120	7	think	think	VB
18637	10120	8	there	there	EX
18637	10120	9	was	be	VBD
18637	10120	10	anything	anything	NN
18637	10120	11	in	in	IN
18637	10120	12	the	the	DT
18637	10120	13	objection	objection	NN
18637	10120	14	to	to	IN
18637	10120	15	sending	send	VBG
18637	10120	16	a	a	DT
18637	10120	17	minister	minister	NN
18637	10120	18	on	on	IN
18637	10120	19	the	the	DT
18637	10120	20	score	score	NN
18637	10120	21	of	of	IN
18637	10120	22	national	national	JJ
18637	10120	23	dignity	dignity	NN
18637	10120	24	,	,	,
18637	10120	25	and	and	CC
18637	10120	26	that	that	IN
18637	10120	27	there	there	EX
18637	10120	28	was	be	VBD
18637	10120	29	a	a	DT
18637	10120	30	difference	difference	NN
18637	10120	31	between	between	IN
18637	10120	32	the	the	DT
18637	10120	33	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	10120	34	of	of	IN
18637	10120	35	a	a	DT
18637	10120	36	change	change	NN
18637	10120	37	of	of	IN
18637	10120	38	government	government	NN
18637	10120	39	in	in	IN
18637	10120	40	a	a	DT
18637	10120	41	nation	nation	NN
18637	10120	42	already	already	RB
18637	10120	43	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	10120	44	as	as	IN
18637	10120	45	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	10120	46	,	,	,
18637	10120	47	and	and	CC
18637	10120	48	the	the	DT
18637	10120	49	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	10120	50	of	of	IN
18637	10120	51	a	a	DT
18637	10120	52	new	new	JJ
18637	10120	53	nation	nation	NN
18637	10120	54	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10120	55	.	.	.
18637	10121	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10121	2	did	do	VBD
18637	10121	3	not	not	RB
18637	10121	4	,	,	,
18637	10121	5	however	however	RB
18637	10121	6	,	,	,
18637	10121	7	deny	deny	VB
18637	10121	8	,	,	,
18637	10121	9	but	but	CC
18637	10121	10	admitted	admit	VBD
18637	10121	11	,	,	,
18637	10121	12	that	that	IN
18637	10121	13	the	the	DT
18637	10121	14	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	10121	15	was	be	VBD
18637	10121	16	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	10121	17	within	within	IN
18637	10121	18	the	the	DT
18637	10121	19	powers	power	NNS
18637	10121	20	of	of	IN
18637	10121	21	the	the	DT
18637	10121	22	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	10121	23	alone	alone	RB
18637	10121	24	,	,	,
18637	10121	25	and	and	CC
18637	10121	26	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10121	27	did	do	VBD
18637	10121	28	not	not	RB
18637	10121	29	press	press	VB
18637	10121	30	the	the	DT
18637	10121	31	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	10121	32	further	further	RB
18637	10121	33	.	.	.
18637	10121	34	'	'	''
18637	10121	35	"	"	''
18637	10122	1	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10122	2	.	.	.
18637	10122	3	,	,	,
18637	10122	4	244	244	CD
18637	10122	5	-	-	SYM
18637	10122	6	245	245	CD
18637	10122	7	;	;	:
18637	10122	8	citing	cite	VBG
18637	10122	9	Memoirs	Memoirs	NNP
18637	10122	10	of	of	IN
18637	10122	11	John	John	NNP
18637	10122	12	Quincy	Quincy	NNP
18637	10122	13	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	10122	14	,	,	,
18637	10122	15	IV	IV	NNP
18637	10122	16	,	,	,
18637	10122	17	205	205	CD
18637	10122	18	-	-	SYM
18637	10122	19	206	206	CD
18637	10122	20	.	.	.
18637	10123	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10123	2	348	348	CD
18637	10123	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10123	4	S.	S.	NNP
18637	10123	5	Doc	Doc	NNP
18637	10123	6	.	.	.
18637	10124	1	56	56	CD
18637	10124	2	,	,	,
18637	10124	3	54th	54th	JJ
18637	10124	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	10124	5	.	.	NNP
18637	10124	6	,	,	,
18637	10124	7	2d	2d	NNP
18637	10124	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	10124	9	.	.	.
18637	10124	10	,	,	,
18637	10124	11	pp	pp	NNP
18637	10124	12	.	.	.
18637	10125	1	20	20	CD
18637	10125	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10125	3	22	22	CD
18637	10125	4	.	.	.
18637	10126	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10126	2	349	349	CD
18637	10126	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10126	4	Said	Said	NNP
18637	10126	5	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	10126	6	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	10126	7	of	of	IN
18637	10126	8	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	10126	9	:	:	:
18637	10126	10	"	"	``
18637	10126	11	The	the	DT
18637	10126	12	President	President	NNP
18637	10126	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	10126	14	asked	ask	VBN
18637	10126	15	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10126	16	to	to	TO
18637	10126	17	give	give	VB
18637	10126	18	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10126	19	the	the	DT
18637	10126	20	right	right	NN
18637	10126	21	to	to	TO
18637	10126	22	make	make	VB
18637	10126	23	war	war	NN
18637	10126	24	to	to	TO
18637	10126	25	expel	expel	VB
18637	10126	26	the	the	DT
18637	10126	27	Spaniards	Spaniards	NNPS
18637	10126	28	from	from	IN
18637	10126	29	Cuba	Cuba	NNP
18637	10126	30	.	.	.
18637	10127	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10127	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	10127	3	asked	ask	VBN
18637	10127	4	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10127	5	to	to	TO
18637	10127	6	put	put	VB
18637	10127	7	that	that	DT
18637	10127	8	power	power	NN
18637	10127	9	in	in	IN
18637	10127	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10127	11	hands	hand	NNS
18637	10127	12	;	;	:
18637	10127	13	and	and	CC
18637	10127	14	when	when	WRB
18637	10127	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10127	16	are	be	VBP
18637	10127	17	asked	ask	VBN
18637	10127	18	to	to	TO
18637	10127	19	grant	grant	VB
18637	10127	20	that	that	DT
18637	10127	21	power	power	NN
18637	10127	22	--	--	:
18637	10127	23	the	the	DT
18637	10127	24	highest	high	JJS
18637	10127	25	power	power	NN
18637	10127	26	given	give	VBN
18637	10127	27	under	under	IN
18637	10127	28	the	the	DT
18637	10127	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10127	30	--	--	:
18637	10127	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10127	32	have	have	VBP
18637	10127	33	the	the	DT
18637	10127	34	right	right	NN
18637	10127	35	,	,	,
18637	10127	36	the	the	DT
18637	10127	37	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
18637	10127	38	right	right	NN
18637	10127	39	,	,	,
18637	10127	40	vested	vest	VBN
18637	10127	41	in	in	IN
18637	10127	42	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10127	43	by	by	IN
18637	10127	44	the	the	DT
18637	10127	45	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10127	46	,	,	,
18637	10127	47	to	to	TO
18637	10127	48	say	say	VB
18637	10127	49	how	how	WRB
18637	10127	50	and	and	CC
18637	10127	51	under	under	IN
18637	10127	52	what	what	WDT
18637	10127	53	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	10127	54	and	and	CC
18637	10127	55	with	with	IN
18637	10127	56	what	what	WP
18637	10127	57	allies	ally	NNS
18637	10127	58	that	that	IN
18637	10127	59	war	war	NN
18637	10127	60	-	-	HYPH
18637	10127	61	making	make	VBG
18637	10127	62	power	power	NN
18637	10127	63	shall	shall	MD
18637	10127	64	be	be	VB
18637	10127	65	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	10127	66	.	.	.
18637	10127	67	"	"	''
18637	10128	1	31	31	CD
18637	10128	2	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	10128	3	.	.	.
18637	10129	1	Record	Record	NNP
18637	10129	2	,	,	,
18637	10129	3	Pt	Pt	NNP
18637	10129	4	.	.	.
18637	10130	1	4	4	CD
18637	10130	2	,	,	,
18637	10130	3	p.	p.	NN
18637	10130	4	3984	3984	CD
18637	10130	5	.	.	.
18637	10131	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10131	2	350	350	CD
18637	10131	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10131	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10131	5	See	See	NNP
18637	10131	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10131	7	in	in	IN
18637	10131	8	this	this	DT
18637	10131	9	connection	connection	NN
18637	10131	10	a	a	DT
18637	10131	11	long	long	JJ
18637	10131	12	list	list	NN
18637	10131	13	of	of	IN
18637	10131	14	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	10131	15	or	or	CC
18637	10131	16	bills	bill	NNS
18637	10131	17	originating	originate	VBG
18637	10131	18	in	in	IN
18637	10131	19	the	the	DT
18637	10131	20	House	House	NNP
18637	10131	21	of	of	IN
18637	10131	22	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	10131	23	appertaining	appertain	VBG
18637	10131	24	to	to	IN
18637	10131	25	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	10131	26	relations	relation	NNS
18637	10131	27	.	.	.
18637	10132	1	H.	H.	NNP
18637	10132	2	Rept	Rept	NNP
18637	10132	3	.	.	.
18637	10133	1	1569	1569	CD
18637	10133	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10133	3	"	"	``
18637	10133	4	Confidential	Confidential	NNP
18637	10133	5	"	"	''
18637	10133	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10133	7	,	,	,
18637	10133	8	68th	68th	NNP
18637	10133	9	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	10133	10	.	.	NNP
18637	10133	11	,	,	,
18637	10133	12	2d	2d	CD
18637	10133	13	sess	sess	NN
18637	10133	14	.	.	.
18637	10134	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10134	2	February	February	NNP
18637	10134	3	24	24	CD
18637	10134	4	,	,	,
18637	10134	5	1925	1925	CD
18637	10134	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10134	7	.	.	.
18637	10135	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10135	2	351	351	CD
18637	10135	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10135	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10135	5	See	See	NNP
18637	10135	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10135	7	A	A	NNP
18637	10135	8	Decade	Decade	NNP
18637	10135	9	of	of	IN
18637	10135	10	American	American	NNP
18637	10135	11	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	10135	12	Policy	Policy	NNP
18637	10135	13	,	,	,
18637	10135	14	S.	S.	NNP
18637	10135	15	Doc	Doc	NNP
18637	10135	16	.	.	.
18637	10136	1	123	123	CD
18637	10136	2	,	,	,
18637	10136	3	81st	81st	NNP
18637	10136	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	10136	5	.	.	NNP
18637	10136	6	,	,	,
18637	10136	7	1st	1st	JJ
18637	10136	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	10136	9	.	.	.
18637	10136	10	,	,	,
18637	10136	11	p.	p.	NN
18637	10136	12	158	158	CD
18637	10136	13	.	.	.
18637	10137	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10137	2	352	352	CD
18637	10137	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10137	4	President	President	NNP
18637	10137	5	Truman	Truman	NNP
18637	10137	6	's	's	POS
18637	10137	7	Statement	Statement	NNP
18637	10137	8	of	of	IN
18637	10137	9	June	June	NNP
18637	10137	10	28	28	CD
18637	10137	11	,	,	,
18637	10137	12	1950	1950	CD
18637	10137	13	,	,	,
18637	10137	14	A.P.	A.P.	NNP
18637	10138	1	release	release	NN
18637	10138	2	:	:	:
18637	10138	3	"	"	``
18637	10138	4	The	the	DT
18637	10138	5	Security	Security	NNP
18637	10138	6	Council	Council	NNP
18637	10138	7	called	call	VBD
18637	10138	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	10138	9	all	all	DT
18637	10138	10	members	member	NNS
18637	10138	11	of	of	IN
18637	10138	12	the	the	DT
18637	10138	13	United	United	NNP
18637	10138	14	Nations	Nations	NNP
18637	10138	15	to	to	TO
18637	10138	16	render	render	VB
18637	10138	17	every	every	DT
18637	10138	18	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	10138	19	to	to	IN
18637	10138	20	the	the	DT
18637	10138	21	United	United	NNP
18637	10138	22	Nations	Nations	NNP
18637	10138	23	in	in	IN
18637	10138	24	the	the	DT
18637	10138	25	execution	execution	NN
18637	10138	26	of	of	IN
18637	10138	27	this	this	DT
18637	10138	28	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	10138	29	.	.	.
18637	10139	1	"	"	``
18637	10139	2	In	in	IN
18637	10139	3	these	these	DT
18637	10139	4	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	10139	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10139	6	have	have	VBP
18637	10139	7	ordered	order	VBN
18637	10139	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10139	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10139	10	air	air	NN
18637	10139	11	and	and	CC
18637	10139	12	sea	sea	NN
18637	10139	13	forces	force	NNS
18637	10139	14	to	to	TO
18637	10139	15	give	give	VB
18637	10139	16	the	the	DT
18637	10139	17	Korean	korean	JJ
18637	10139	18	Government	Government	NNP
18637	10139	19	troops	troop	NNS
18637	10139	20	cover	cover	NN
18637	10139	21	and	and	CC
18637	10139	22	support	support	VBP
18637	10139	23	.	.	.
18637	10140	1	"	"	``
18637	10140	2	The	the	DT
18637	10140	3	attack	attack	NN
18637	10140	4	upon	upon	IN
18637	10140	5	Korea	Korea	NNP
18637	10140	6	makes	make	VBZ
18637	10140	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10140	8	plain	plain	JJ
18637	10140	9	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	10140	10	all	all	DT
18637	10140	11	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	10140	12	that	that	IN
18637	10140	13	communism	communism	NN
18637	10140	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	10140	15	passed	pass	VBN
18637	10140	16	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	10140	17	the	the	DT
18637	10140	18	use	use	NN
18637	10140	19	of	of	IN
18637	10140	20	subversion	subversion	NN
18637	10140	21	to	to	TO
18637	10140	22	conquer	conquer	VB
18637	10140	23	independent	independent	JJ
18637	10140	24	nations	nation	NNS
18637	10140	25	and	and	CC
18637	10140	26	will	will	MD
18637	10140	27	now	now	RB
18637	10140	28	use	use	VB
18637	10140	29	armed	armed	JJ
18637	10140	30	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	10140	31	and	and	CC
18637	10140	32	war	war	NN
18637	10140	33	.	.	.
18637	10141	1	"	"	``
18637	10141	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10141	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	10141	4	defied	defy	VBN
18637	10141	5	the	the	DT
18637	10141	6	orders	order	NNS
18637	10141	7	of	of	IN
18637	10141	8	the	the	DT
18637	10141	9	Security	Security	NNP
18637	10141	10	Council	Council	NNP
18637	10141	11	of	of	IN
18637	10141	12	the	the	DT
18637	10141	13	United	United	NNP
18637	10141	14	Nations	Nations	NNP
18637	10141	15	issued	issue	VBD
18637	10141	16	to	to	TO
18637	10141	17	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	10141	18	international	international	JJ
18637	10141	19	peace	peace	NN
18637	10141	20	and	and	CC
18637	10141	21	security	security	NN
18637	10141	22	.	.	.
18637	10142	1	In	in	IN
18637	10142	2	these	these	DT
18637	10142	3	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	10142	4	the	the	DT
18637	10142	5	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	10142	6	of	of	IN
18637	10142	7	Formosa	Formosa	NNP
18637	10142	8	by	by	IN
18637	10142	9	Communist	communist	JJ
18637	10142	10	forces	force	NNS
18637	10142	11	would	would	MD
18637	10142	12	be	be	VB
18637	10142	13	a	a	DT
18637	10142	14	direct	direct	JJ
18637	10142	15	threat	threat	NN
18637	10142	16	to	to	IN
18637	10142	17	the	the	DT
18637	10142	18	security	security	NN
18637	10142	19	of	of	IN
18637	10142	20	the	the	DT
18637	10142	21	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	10142	22	area	area	NN
18637	10142	23	and	and	CC
18637	10142	24	to	to	IN
18637	10142	25	United	United	NNP
18637	10142	26	States	States	NNP
18637	10142	27	forces	force	NNS
18637	10142	28	performing	perform	VBG
18637	10142	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10142	30	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	10142	31	and	and	CC
18637	10142	32	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10142	33	functions	function	NNS
18637	10142	34	in	in	IN
18637	10142	35	that	that	DT
18637	10142	36	area	area	NN
18637	10142	37	.	.	.
18637	10143	1	"	"	``
18637	10143	2	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	10143	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10143	4	have	have	VBP
18637	10143	5	ordered	order	VBN
18637	10143	6	the	the	DT
18637	10143	7	Seventh	Seventh	NNP
18637	10143	8	Fleet	Fleet	NNP
18637	10143	9	to	to	TO
18637	10143	10	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	10143	11	any	any	DT
18637	10143	12	attack	attack	NN
18637	10143	13	on	on	IN
18637	10143	14	Formosa	Formosa	NNP
18637	10143	15	.	.	.
18637	10144	1	As	as	IN
18637	10144	2	a	a	DT
18637	10144	3	corollary	corollary	NN
18637	10144	4	of	of	IN
18637	10144	5	this	this	DT
18637	10144	6	action	action	NN
18637	10144	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10144	8	am	be	VBP
18637	10144	9	calling	call	VBG
18637	10144	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	10144	11	the	the	DT
18637	10144	12	Chinese	chinese	JJ
18637	10144	13	Government	Government	NNP
18637	10144	14	on	on	IN
18637	10144	15	Formosa	Formosa	NNP
18637	10144	16	to	to	TO
18637	10144	17	cease	cease	VB
18637	10144	18	all	all	DT
18637	10144	19	air	air	NN
18637	10144	20	and	and	CC
18637	10144	21	sea	sea	NN
18637	10144	22	operations	operation	NNS
18637	10144	23	against	against	IN
18637	10144	24	the	the	DT
18637	10144	25	mainland	mainland	NN
18637	10144	26	.	.	.
18637	10145	1	The	the	DT
18637	10145	2	Seventh	Seventh	NNP
18637	10145	3	Fleet	Fleet	NNP
18637	10145	4	will	will	MD
18637	10145	5	see	see	VB
18637	10145	6	that	that	IN
18637	10145	7	this	this	DT
18637	10145	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	10145	9	done	do	VBN
18637	10145	10	.	.	.
18637	10146	1	The	the	DT
18637	10146	2	determination	determination	NN
18637	10146	3	of	of	IN
18637	10146	4	the	the	DT
18637	10146	5	future	future	JJ
18637	10146	6	status	status	NN
18637	10146	7	of	of	IN
18637	10146	8	Formosa	Formosa	NNP
18637	10146	9	must	must	MD
18637	10146	10	await	await	VB
18637	10146	11	the	the	DT
18637	10146	12	restoration	restoration	NN
18637	10146	13	of	of	IN
18637	10146	14	security	security	NN
18637	10146	15	in	in	IN
18637	10146	16	the	the	DT
18637	10146	17	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	10146	18	,	,	,
18637	10146	19	a	a	DT
18637	10146	20	peace	peace	NN
18637	10146	21	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	10146	22	with	with	IN
18637	10146	23	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	10146	24	,	,	,
18637	10146	25	or	or	CC
18637	10146	26	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	10146	27	by	by	IN
18637	10146	28	the	the	DT
18637	10146	29	United	United	NNP
18637	10146	30	Nations	Nations	NNP
18637	10146	31	.	.	.
18637	10147	1	"	"	``
18637	10147	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10147	3	have	have	VBP
18637	10147	4	also	also	RB
18637	10147	5	directed	direct	VBN
18637	10147	6	that	that	IN
18637	10147	7	United	United	NNP
18637	10147	8	States	States	NNP
18637	10147	9	forces	force	NNS
18637	10147	10	in	in	IN
18637	10147	11	the	the	DT
18637	10147	12	Philippines	Philippines	NNPS
18637	10147	13	be	be	VB
18637	10147	14	strengthened	strengthen	VBN
18637	10147	15	and	and	CC
18637	10147	16	that	that	IN
18637	10147	17	military	military	JJ
18637	10147	18	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	10147	19	to	to	IN
18637	10147	20	the	the	DT
18637	10147	21	Philippine	Philippine	NNP
18637	10147	22	Government	Government	NNP
18637	10147	23	be	be	VB
18637	10147	24	accelerated	accelerate	VBN
18637	10147	25	.	.	.
18637	10148	1	"	"	``
18637	10148	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10148	3	have	have	VBP
18637	10148	4	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	10148	5	directed	direct	VBN
18637	10148	6	acceleration	acceleration	NN
18637	10148	7	in	in	IN
18637	10148	8	the	the	DT
18637	10148	9	furnishing	furnishing	NN
18637	10148	10	of	of	IN
18637	10148	11	military	military	JJ
18637	10148	12	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	10148	13	to	to	IN
18637	10148	14	the	the	DT
18637	10148	15	forces	force	NNS
18637	10148	16	of	of	IN
18637	10148	17	France	France	NNP
18637	10148	18	and	and	CC
18637	10148	19	the	the	DT
18637	10148	20	associated	associate	VBN
18637	10148	21	states	state	NNS
18637	10148	22	in	in	IN
18637	10148	23	Indo	Indo	NNP
18637	10148	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	10148	25	China	China	NNP
18637	10148	26	and	and	CC
18637	10148	27	the	the	DT
18637	10148	28	dispatch	dispatch	NN
18637	10148	29	of	of	IN
18637	10148	30	a	a	DT
18637	10148	31	military	military	JJ
18637	10148	32	mission	mission	NN
18637	10148	33	to	to	TO
18637	10148	34	provide	provide	VB
18637	10148	35	close	close	JJ
18637	10148	36	working	working	NN
18637	10148	37	relations	relation	NNS
18637	10148	38	with	with	IN
18637	10148	39	those	those	DT
18637	10148	40	forces	force	NNS
18637	10148	41	.	.	.
18637	10148	42	"	"	''
18637	10149	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10149	2	353	353	CD
18637	10149	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10149	4	Messages	message	NNS
18637	10149	5	and	and	CC
18637	10149	6	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	10149	7	of	of	IN
18637	10149	8	the	the	DT
18637	10149	9	Presidents	Presidents	NNPS
18637	10149	10	,	,	,
18637	10149	11	XVII	XVII	NNP
18637	10149	12	,	,	,
18637	10149	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10149	14	1914	1914	CD
18637	10149	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10149	16	,	,	,
18637	10149	17	7934	7934	CD
18637	10149	18	.	.	.
18637	10150	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10150	2	354	354	CD
18637	10150	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10150	4	55	55	CD
18637	10150	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	10150	6	.	.	.
18637	10151	1	31	31	CD
18637	10151	2	;	;	:
18637	10151	3	22	22	CD
18637	10151	4	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	10152	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10152	2	1940	1940	CD
18637	10152	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10152	4	,	,	,
18637	10152	5	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	10152	6	.	.	.
18637	10153	1	IV	IV	NNP
18637	10153	2	,	,	,
18637	10153	3	§§	§§	NNP
18637	10153	4	411	411	CD
18637	10153	5	-	-	SYM
18637	10153	6	413	413	CD
18637	10153	7	.	.	.
18637	10154	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10154	2	355	355	CD
18637	10154	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10154	4	James	James	NNP
18637	10154	5	F.	F.	NNP
18637	10154	6	Green	Green	NNP
18637	10154	7	,	,	,
18637	10154	8	The	the	DT
18637	10154	9	President	President	NNP
18637	10154	10	's	's	POS
18637	10154	11	Control	Control	NNP
18637	10154	12	of	of	IN
18637	10154	13	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	10154	14	Policy	Policy	NNP
18637	10154	15	,	,	,
18637	10154	16	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	10154	17	Policy	Policy	NNP
18637	10154	18	Reports	Reports	NNPS
18637	10154	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10154	20	April	April	NNP
18637	10154	21	1	1	CD
18637	10154	22	,	,	,
18637	10154	23	1939	1939	CD
18637	10154	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10154	25	,	,	,
18637	10154	26	17	17	CD
18637	10154	27	-	-	SYM
18637	10154	28	18	18	CD
18637	10154	29	;	;	:
18637	10154	30	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	10154	31	,	,	,
18637	10154	32	The	the	DT
18637	10154	33	President	President	NNP
18637	10154	34	,	,	,
18637	10154	35	Office	Office	NNP
18637	10154	36	and	and	CC
18637	10154	37	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	10154	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10154	39	3d	3d	NNP
18637	10154	40	ed	ed	NNP
18637	10154	41	.	.	.
18637	10155	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10155	2	,	,	,
18637	10155	3	224	224	CD
18637	10155	4	-	-	SYM
18637	10155	5	235	235	CD
18637	10155	6	;	;	:
18637	10155	7	463	463	CD
18637	10155	8	-	-	SYM
18637	10155	9	465	465	CD
18637	10155	10	,	,	,
18637	10155	11	473	473	CD
18637	10155	12	-	-	SYM
18637	10155	13	474	474	CD
18637	10155	14	.	.	.
18637	10156	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10156	2	356	356	CD
18637	10156	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10156	4	2	2	CD
18637	10156	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	10156	6	.	.	.
18637	10157	1	253	253	CD
18637	10157	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10157	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	10157	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10157	5	.	.	.
18637	10158	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10158	2	357	357	CD
18637	10158	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10158	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10158	5	.	.	.
18637	10159	1	308	308	CD
18637	10159	2	.	.	.
18637	10160	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10160	2	358	358	CD
18637	10160	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10160	4	13	13	CD
18637	10160	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	10160	6	.	.	.
18637	10161	1	415	415	CD
18637	10161	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10161	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	10161	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10161	5	.	.	.
18637	10162	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10162	2	359	359	CD
18637	10162	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10162	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10162	5	.	.	.
18637	10163	1	420	420	CD
18637	10163	2	.	.	.
18637	10164	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10164	2	360	360	CD
18637	10164	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10164	4	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	10164	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10164	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10164	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10164	8	Neilson	Neilson	NNP
18637	10164	9	,	,	,
18637	10164	10	supra	supra	NNP
18637	10164	11	.	.	.
18637	10165	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10165	2	361	361	CD
18637	10165	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10165	4	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	10165	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10165	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10165	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10165	8	Suffolk	Suffolk	NNP
18637	10165	9	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	10165	10	.	.	.
18637	10166	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10166	2	,	,	,
18637	10166	3	13	13	CD
18637	10166	4	Pet	pet	NN
18637	10166	5	.	.	.
18637	10167	1	415	415	CD
18637	10167	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10167	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	10167	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10167	5	.	.	.
18637	10168	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10168	2	362	362	CD
18637	10168	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10168	4	United	United	NNP
18637	10168	5	States	States	NNP
18637	10168	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10168	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10168	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10168	9	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	10168	10	,	,	,
18637	10168	11	3	3	CD
18637	10168	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	10168	13	.	.	.
18637	10169	1	610	610	CD
18637	10169	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10169	3	1818	1818	CD
18637	10169	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10169	5	.	.	.
18637	10170	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10170	2	363	363	CD
18637	10170	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10170	4	Doe	Doe	NNP
18637	10170	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10170	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10170	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10170	8	Braden	Braden	NNP
18637	10170	9	,	,	,
18637	10170	10	16	16	CD
18637	10170	11	How	how	WRB
18637	10170	12	.	.	.
18637	10171	1	636	636	CD
18637	10171	2	,	,	,
18637	10171	3	657	657	CD
18637	10171	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10171	5	1853	1853	CD
18637	10171	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10171	7	.	.	.
18637	10172	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10172	2	364	364	CD
18637	10172	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10172	4	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	10172	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10172	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10172	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10172	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10172	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10172	10	,	,	,
18637	10172	11	137	137	CD
18637	10172	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10172	13	202	202	CD
18637	10172	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10172	15	1890	1890	CD
18637	10172	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10172	17	;	;	:
18637	10172	18	Oetjen	Oetjen	NNP
18637	10172	19	_	_	NNP
18637	10172	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	10172	21	_	_	NNP
18637	10172	22	Central	Central	NNP
18637	10172	23	Leather	Leather	NNP
18637	10172	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10172	25	,	,	,
18637	10172	26	246	246	CD
18637	10172	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10172	28	297	297	CD
18637	10172	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10172	30	1918	1918	CD
18637	10172	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10172	32	.	.	.
18637	10173	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10173	2	365	365	CD
18637	10173	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10173	4	In	in	IN
18637	10173	5	re	re	NN
18637	10173	6	Baiz	Baiz	NNP
18637	10173	7	,	,	,
18637	10173	8	135	135	CD
18637	10173	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10173	10	403	403	CD
18637	10173	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10173	12	1890	1890	CD
18637	10173	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10173	14	.	.	.
18637	10174	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10174	2	366	366	CD
18637	10174	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10174	4	Neely	neely	RB
18637	10174	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10174	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10174	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10174	8	Henkel	Henkel	NNP
18637	10174	9	,	,	,
18637	10174	10	180	180	CD
18637	10174	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10174	12	109	109	CD
18637	10174	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10174	14	1901	1901	CD
18637	10174	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10174	16	.	.	.
18637	10175	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10175	2	367	367	CD
18637	10175	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10175	4	Terlinden	Terlinden	NNP
18637	10175	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10175	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10175	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10175	8	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	10175	9	,	,	,
18637	10175	10	184	184	CD
18637	10175	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10175	12	270	270	CD
18637	10175	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10175	14	1902	1902	CD
18637	10175	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10175	16	;	;	:
18637	10175	17	Charlton	Charlton	NNP
18637	10175	18	_	_	NNP
18637	10175	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	10175	20	_	_	NNP
18637	10175	21	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
18637	10175	22	,	,	,
18637	10175	23	229	229	CD
18637	10175	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10175	25	447	447	CD
18637	10175	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10175	27	1913	1913	CD
18637	10175	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10175	29	.	.	.
18637	10176	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10176	2	368	368	CD
18637	10176	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10176	4	333	333	CD
18637	10176	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10176	6	103	103	CD
18637	10176	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10176	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	10176	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10176	10	.	.	.
18637	10177	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10177	2	369	369	CD
18637	10177	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10177	4	49	49	CD
18637	10177	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	10178	1	§	§	NNP
18637	10178	2	601	601	CD
18637	10178	3	.	.	.
18637	10179	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10179	2	370	370	CD
18637	10179	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10179	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10179	5	.	.	.
18637	10180	1	§	§	NNP
18637	10180	2	646	646	CD
18637	10180	3	.	.	.
18637	10181	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10181	2	371	371	CD
18637	10181	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10181	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	10181	5	&	&	CC
18637	10181	6	S.	S.	NNP
18637	10181	7	Airlines	Airlines	NNP
18637	10181	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10181	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	10181	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10181	11	Waterman	Waterman	NNP
18637	10181	12	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	10181	13	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	10181	14	,	,	,
18637	10181	15	333	333	CD
18637	10181	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10181	17	103	103	CD
18637	10181	18	,	,	,
18637	10181	19	111	111	CD
18637	10181	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10181	21	1948	1948	CD
18637	10181	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10181	23	.	.	.
18637	10182	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10182	2	See	See	NNP
18637	10182	3	also	also	RB
18637	10182	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10182	5	Oetjen	Oetjen	NNP
18637	10182	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10182	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10182	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10182	9	Central	Central	NNP
18637	10182	10	Leather	Leather	NNP
18637	10182	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10182	12	,	,	,
18637	10182	13	246	246	CD
18637	10182	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10182	15	297	297	CD
18637	10182	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10182	17	1918	1918	CD
18637	10182	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10182	19	;	;	:
18637	10182	20	Ricaud	Ricaud	NNP
18637	10182	21	_	_	NNP
18637	10182	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	10182	23	_	_	NNP
18637	10182	24	American	American	NNP
18637	10182	25	Metal	Metal	NNP
18637	10182	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10182	27	,	,	,
18637	10182	28	246	246	CD
18637	10182	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10182	30	304	304	CD
18637	10182	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10182	32	1918	1918	CD
18637	10182	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10182	34	;	;	:
18637	10182	35	and	and	CC
18637	10182	36	Compania	Compania	NNP
18637	10182	37	Espanola	Espanola	NNP
18637	10182	38	de	de	NNP
18637	10182	39	Navegacion	Navegacion	NNP
18637	10182	40	Maritima	Maritima	NNP
18637	10182	41	,	,	,
18637	10182	42	S.A.	S.A.	NNP
18637	10182	43	_	_	NNP
18637	10182	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	10182	45	_	_	NNP
18637	10182	46	The	the	DT
18637	10182	47	Navemar	Navemar	NNP
18637	10182	48	,	,	,
18637	10182	49	303	303	CD
18637	10182	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10182	51	68	68	CD
18637	10182	52	,	,	,
18637	10182	53	74	74	CD
18637	10182	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10182	55	1938	1938	CD
18637	10182	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10182	57	.	.	.
18637	10183	1	In	in	IN
18637	10183	2	this	this	DT
18637	10183	3	last	last	JJ
18637	10183	4	case	case	NN
18637	10183	5	the	the	DT
18637	10183	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10183	7	declared	declare	VBD
18637	10183	8	:	:	:
18637	10183	9	"	"	``
18637	10183	10	The	the	DT
18637	10183	11	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	10183	12	of	of	IN
18637	10183	13	a	a	DT
18637	10183	14	friendly	friendly	JJ
18637	10183	15	government	government	NN
18637	10183	16	in	in	IN
18637	10183	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10183	18	possession	possession	NN
18637	10183	19	and	and	CC
18637	10183	20	service	service	NN
18637	10183	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	10183	22	a	a	DT
18637	10183	23	public	public	JJ
18637	10183	24	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	10183	25	,	,	,
18637	10183	26	even	even	RB
18637	10183	27	though	though	IN
18637	10183	28	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	10183	29	in	in	IN
18637	10183	30	the	the	DT
18637	10183	31	carriage	carriage	NN
18637	10183	32	of	of	IN
18637	10183	33	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	10183	34	for	for	IN
18637	10183	35	hire	hire	NN
18637	10183	36	,	,	,
18637	10183	37	and	and	CC
18637	10183	38	as	as	IN
18637	10183	39	such	such	JJ
18637	10183	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	10183	41	immune	immune	JJ
18637	10183	42	from	from	IN
18637	10183	43	suit	suit	NN
18637	10183	44	in	in	IN
18637	10183	45	the	the	DT
18637	10183	46	courts	court	NNS
18637	10183	47	of	of	IN
18637	10183	48	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	10183	49	of	of	IN
18637	10183	50	the	the	DT
18637	10183	51	United	United	NNP
18637	10183	52	States	States	NNP
18637	10183	53	.	.	.
18637	10184	1	*	*	NFP
18637	10184	2	*	*	NFP
18637	10184	3	*	*	NFP
18637	10184	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10184	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	10184	6	open	open	JJ
18637	10184	7	to	to	IN
18637	10184	8	a	a	DT
18637	10184	9	friendly	friendly	JJ
18637	10184	10	government	government	NN
18637	10184	11	to	to	TO
18637	10184	12	assert	assert	VB
18637	10184	13	that	that	IN
18637	10184	14	such	such	JJ
18637	10184	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	10184	16	the	the	DT
18637	10184	17	public	public	JJ
18637	10184	18	status	status	NN
18637	10184	19	of	of	IN
18637	10184	20	the	the	DT
18637	10184	21	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	10184	22	and	and	CC
18637	10184	23	to	to	TO
18637	10184	24	claim	claim	VB
18637	10184	25	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10184	26	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	10184	27	from	from	IN
18637	10184	28	suit	suit	NN
18637	10184	29	,	,	,
18637	10184	30	either	either	CC
18637	10184	31	through	through	IN
18637	10184	32	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	10184	33	channels	channel	NNS
18637	10184	34	or	or	CC
18637	10184	35	,	,	,
18637	10184	36	if	if	IN
18637	10184	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10184	38	chooses	choose	VBZ
18637	10184	39	,	,	,
18637	10184	40	as	as	IN
18637	10184	41	a	a	DT
18637	10184	42	claimant	claimant	NN
18637	10184	43	in	in	IN
18637	10184	44	the	the	DT
18637	10184	45	courts	court	NNS
18637	10184	46	of	of	IN
18637	10184	47	the	the	DT
18637	10184	48	United	United	NNP
18637	10184	49	States	States	NNP
18637	10184	50	.	.	.
18637	10185	1	If	if	IN
18637	10185	2	the	the	DT
18637	10185	3	claim	claim	NN
18637	10185	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	10185	5	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	10185	6	and	and	CC
18637	10185	7	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	10185	8	by	by	IN
18637	10185	9	the	the	DT
18637	10185	10	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10185	11	branch	branch	NN
18637	10185	12	of	of	IN
18637	10185	13	the	the	DT
18637	10185	14	government	government	NN
18637	10185	15	,	,	,
18637	10185	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10185	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	10185	18	then	then	RB
18637	10185	19	the	the	DT
18637	10185	20	duty	duty	NN
18637	10185	21	of	of	IN
18637	10185	22	the	the	DT
18637	10185	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	10185	24	to	to	TO
18637	10185	25	release	release	VB
18637	10185	26	the	the	DT
18637	10185	27	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	10185	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	10185	29	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	10185	30	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	10185	31	by	by	IN
18637	10185	32	the	the	DT
18637	10185	33	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10185	34	General	General	NNP
18637	10185	35	of	of	IN
18637	10185	36	the	the	DT
18637	10185	37	United	United	NNP
18637	10185	38	States	States	NNP
18637	10185	39	,	,	,
18637	10185	40	or	or	CC
18637	10185	41	other	other	JJ
18637	10185	42	officer	officer	NN
18637	10185	43	acting	act	VBG
18637	10185	44	under	under	IN
18637	10185	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10185	46	direction	direction	NN
18637	10185	47	.	.	.
18637	10186	1	*	*	NFP
18637	10186	2	*	*	NFP
18637	10186	3	*	*	NFP
18637	10186	4	The	the	DT
18637	10186	5	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	10186	6	government	government	NN
18637	10186	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	10186	8	also	also	RB
18637	10186	9	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	10186	10	as	as	IN
18637	10186	11	of	of	IN
18637	10186	12	right	right	RB
18637	10186	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	10186	14	a	a	DT
18637	10186	15	proper	proper	JJ
18637	10186	16	showing	showing	NN
18637	10186	17	,	,	,
18637	10186	18	to	to	TO
18637	10186	19	appear	appear	VB
18637	10186	20	in	in	IN
18637	10186	21	a	a	DT
18637	10186	22	pending	pende	VBG
18637	10186	23	suit	suit	NN
18637	10186	24	,	,	,
18637	10186	25	there	there	RB
18637	10186	26	to	to	TO
18637	10186	27	assert	assert	VB
18637	10186	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10186	29	claim	claim	NN
18637	10186	30	to	to	IN
18637	10186	31	the	the	DT
18637	10186	32	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	10186	33	,	,	,
18637	10186	34	and	and	CC
18637	10186	35	to	to	TO
18637	10186	36	raise	raise	VB
18637	10186	37	the	the	DT
18637	10186	38	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	10186	39	question	question	NN
18637	10186	40	in	in	IN
18637	10186	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10186	42	own	own	JJ
18637	10186	43	name	name	NN
18637	10186	44	or	or	CC
18637	10186	45	that	that	DT
18637	10186	46	of	of	IN
18637	10186	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10186	48	accredited	accredit	VBN
18637	10186	49	and	and	CC
18637	10186	50	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	10186	51	representative	representative	NN
18637	10186	52	.	.	.
18637	10186	53	"	"	''
18637	10187	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	10187	2	,	,	,
18637	10187	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10187	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	10187	5	been	be	VBN
18637	10187	6	held	hold	VBN
18637	10187	7	that	that	IN
18637	10187	8	courts	court	NNS
18637	10187	9	may	may	MD
18637	10187	10	not	not	RB
18637	10187	11	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	10187	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10187	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10187	14	by	by	IN
18637	10187	15	the	the	DT
18637	10187	16	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	10187	17	and	and	CC
18637	10187	18	detention	detention	NN
18637	10187	19	of	of	IN
18637	10187	20	the	the	DT
18637	10187	21	property	property	NN
18637	10187	22	of	of	IN
18637	10187	23	a	a	DT
18637	10187	24	friendly	friendly	JJ
18637	10187	25	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	10187	26	,	,	,
18637	10187	27	so	so	IN
18637	10187	28	as	as	IN
18637	10187	29	to	to	TO
18637	10187	30	embarrass	embarrass	VB
18637	10187	31	the	the	DT
18637	10187	32	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10187	33	arm	arm	NN
18637	10187	34	of	of	IN
18637	10187	35	the	the	DT
18637	10187	36	government	government	NN
18637	10187	37	in	in	IN
18637	10187	38	conducting	conduct	VBG
18637	10187	39	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	10187	40	relations	relation	NNS
18637	10187	41	.	.	.
18637	10188	1	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	10188	2	parte	parte	NNP
18637	10188	3	Republic	Republic	NNP
18637	10188	4	of	of	IN
18637	10188	5	Peru	Peru	NNP
18637	10188	6	,	,	,
18637	10188	7	318	318	CD
18637	10188	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10188	9	578	578	CD
18637	10188	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10188	11	1943	1943	CD
18637	10188	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10188	13	.	.	.
18637	10189	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10189	2	372	372	CD
18637	10189	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10189	4	335	335	CD
18637	10189	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10189	6	160	160	CD
18637	10189	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10189	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	10189	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10189	10	.	.	.
18637	10190	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10190	2	373	373	CD
18637	10190	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10190	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10190	5	.	.	.
18637	10191	1	167	167	CD
18637	10191	2	,	,	,
18637	10191	3	170	170	CD
18637	10191	4	.	.	.
18637	10192	1	Four	four	CD
18637	10192	2	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	10192	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	10192	4	,	,	,
18637	10192	5	by	by	IN
18637	10192	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10192	7	Black	Black	NNP
18637	10192	8	,	,	,
18637	10192	9	who	who	WP
18637	10192	10	said	say	VBD
18637	10192	11	:	:	:
18637	10192	12	"	"	``
18637	10192	13	The	the	DT
18637	10192	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10192	15	*	*	NFP
18637	10192	16	*	*	NFP
18637	10192	17	*	*	NFP
18637	10192	18	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	10192	19	,	,	,
18637	10192	20	as	as	IN
18637	10192	21	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10192	22	understand	understand	VBP
18637	10192	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10192	24	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10192	25	,	,	,
18637	10192	26	that	that	IN
18637	10192	27	the	the	DT
18637	10192	28	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10192	29	General	General	NNP
18637	10192	30	can	can	MD
18637	10192	31	deport	deport	VB
18637	10192	32	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10192	33	whether	whether	IN
18637	10192	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10192	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	10192	36	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	10192	37	or	or	CC
18637	10192	38	not	not	RB
18637	10192	39	.	.	.
18637	10193	1	The	the	DT
18637	10193	2	effect	effect	NN
18637	10193	3	of	of	IN
18637	10193	4	this	this	DT
18637	10193	5	holding	holding	NN
18637	10193	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	10193	7	that	that	IN
18637	10193	8	any	any	DT
18637	10193	9	unnaturalized	unnaturalized	JJ
18637	10193	10	person	person	NN
18637	10193	11	,	,	,
18637	10193	12	good	good	JJ
18637	10193	13	or	or	CC
18637	10193	14	bad	bad	JJ
18637	10193	15	,	,	,
18637	10193	16	loyal	loyal	JJ
18637	10193	17	or	or	CC
18637	10193	18	disloyal	disloyal	JJ
18637	10193	19	to	to	IN
18637	10193	20	this	this	DT
18637	10193	21	country	country	NN
18637	10193	22	,	,	,
18637	10193	23	if	if	IN
18637	10193	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10193	25	was	be	VBD
18637	10193	26	a	a	DT
18637	10193	27	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	10193	28	of	of	IN
18637	10193	29	Germany	Germany	NNP
18637	10193	30	before	before	IN
18637	10193	31	coming	come	VBG
18637	10193	32	here	here	RB
18637	10193	33	,	,	,
18637	10193	34	can	can	MD
18637	10193	35	be	be	VB
18637	10193	36	summarily	summarily	RB
18637	10193	37	seized	seize	VBN
18637	10193	38	,	,	,
18637	10193	39	interned	intern	VBN
18637	10193	40	and	and	CC
18637	10193	41	deported	deport	VBN
18637	10193	42	from	from	IN
18637	10193	43	the	the	DT
18637	10193	44	United	United	NNP
18637	10193	45	States	States	NNP
18637	10193	46	by	by	IN
18637	10193	47	the	the	DT
18637	10193	48	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10193	49	General	General	NNP
18637	10193	50	,	,	,
18637	10193	51	and	and	CC
18637	10193	52	that	that	IN
18637	10193	53	no	no	DT
18637	10193	54	court	court	NN
18637	10193	55	of	of	IN
18637	10193	56	the	the	DT
18637	10193	57	United	United	NNP
18637	10193	58	States	States	NNP
18637	10193	59	has	have	VBZ
18637	10193	60	any	any	DT
18637	10193	61	power	power	NN
18637	10193	62	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	10193	63	to	to	TO
18637	10193	64	review	review	VB
18637	10193	65	,	,	,
18637	10193	66	modify	modify	VB
18637	10193	67	,	,	,
18637	10193	68	vacate	vacate	NN
18637	10193	69	,	,	,
18637	10193	70	reverse	reverse	VB
18637	10193	71	,	,	,
18637	10193	72	or	or	CC
18637	10193	73	in	in	IN
18637	10193	74	any	any	DT
18637	10193	75	manner	manner	NN
18637	10193	76	affect	affect	VB
18637	10193	77	the	the	DT
18637	10193	78	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10193	79	General	General	NNP
18637	10193	80	's	's	POS
18637	10193	81	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	10193	82	order	order	NN
18637	10193	83	.	.	.
18637	10194	1	*	*	NFP
18637	10194	2	*	*	NFP
18637	10194	3	*	*	NFP
18637	10194	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10194	5	think	think	VBP
18637	10194	6	the	the	DT
18637	10194	7	idea	idea	NN
18637	10194	8	that	that	IN
18637	10194	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10194	10	are	be	VBP
18637	10194	11	still	still	RB
18637	10194	12	at	at	IN
18637	10194	13	war	war	NN
18637	10194	14	with	with	IN
18637	10194	15	Germany	Germany	NNP
18637	10194	16	in	in	IN
18637	10194	17	the	the	DT
18637	10194	18	sense	sense	NN
18637	10194	19	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
18637	10194	20	by	by	IN
18637	10194	21	the	the	DT
18637	10194	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	10194	23	controlling	control	VBG
18637	10194	24	here	here	RB
18637	10194	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	10194	26	a	a	DT
18637	10194	27	pure	pure	JJ
18637	10194	28	fiction	fiction	NN
18637	10194	29	.	.	.
18637	10195	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	10195	2	,	,	,
18637	10195	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10195	4	think	think	VBP
18637	10195	5	there	there	EX
18637	10195	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	10195	7	no	no	DT
18637	10195	8	act	act	NN
18637	10195	9	of	of	IN
18637	10195	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10195	11	which	which	WDT
18637	10195	12	lends	lend	VBZ
18637	10195	13	the	the	DT
18637	10195	14	slightest	slight	JJS
18637	10195	15	basis	basis	NN
18637	10195	16	to	to	IN
18637	10195	17	the	the	DT
18637	10195	18	claim	claim	NN
18637	10195	19	that	that	IN
18637	10195	20	after	after	IN
18637	10195	21	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	10195	22	with	with	IN
18637	10195	23	a	a	DT
18637	10195	24	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	10195	25	country	country	NN
18637	10195	26	have	have	VBP
18637	10195	27	ended	end	VBN
18637	10195	28	the	the	DT
18637	10195	29	President	President	NNP
18637	10195	30	or	or	CC
18637	10195	31	the	the	DT
18637	10195	32	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10195	33	General	General	NNP
18637	10195	34	,	,	,
18637	10195	35	one	one	CD
18637	10195	36	or	or	CC
18637	10195	37	both	both	DT
18637	10195	38	,	,	,
18637	10195	39	can	can	MD
18637	10195	40	deport	deport	VB
18637	10195	41	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	10195	42	without	without	IN
18637	10195	43	a	a	DT
18637	10195	44	fair	fair	JJ
18637	10195	45	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	10195	46	reviewable	reviewable	JJ
18637	10195	47	in	in	IN
18637	10195	48	the	the	DT
18637	10195	49	courts	court	NNS
18637	10195	50	.	.	.
18637	10196	1	On	on	IN
18637	10196	2	the	the	DT
18637	10196	3	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	10196	4	,	,	,
18637	10196	5	when	when	WRB
18637	10196	6	this	this	DT
18637	10196	7	very	very	JJ
18637	10196	8	question	question	NN
18637	10196	9	came	come	VBD
18637	10196	10	before	before	IN
18637	10196	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10196	12	after	after	IN
18637	10196	13	World	World	NNP
18637	10196	14	War	War	NNP
18637	10196	15	I	I	NNP
18637	10196	16	in	in	IN
18637	10196	17	the	the	DT
18637	10196	18	interval	interval	NN
18637	10196	19	between	between	IN
18637	10196	20	the	the	DT
18637	10196	21	Armistice	Armistice	NNP
18637	10196	22	and	and	CC
18637	10196	23	the	the	DT
18637	10196	24	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	10196	25	of	of	IN
18637	10196	26	formal	formal	JJ
18637	10196	27	peace	peace	NN
18637	10196	28	with	with	IN
18637	10196	29	Germany	Germany	NNP
18637	10196	30	,	,	,
18637	10196	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10196	32	unequivocally	unequivocally	RB
18637	10196	33	required	require	VBD
18637	10196	34	that	that	IN
18637	10196	35	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	10196	36	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	10196	37	be	be	VB
18637	10196	38	given	give	VBN
18637	10196	39	a	a	DT
18637	10196	40	fair	fair	JJ
18637	10196	41	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	10196	42	before	before	IN
18637	10196	43	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10196	44	could	could	MD
18637	10196	45	be	be	VB
18637	10196	46	deported	deport	VBN
18637	10196	47	.	.	.
18637	10196	48	"	"	''
18637	10197	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	10197	2	.	.	.
18637	10198	1	174	174	CD
18637	10198	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10198	3	175	175	CD
18637	10198	4	.	.	.
18637	10199	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10199	2	See	See	NNP
18637	10199	3	also	also	RB
18637	10199	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10199	5	Woods	Woods	NNP
18637	10199	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10199	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10199	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10199	9	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	10199	10	,	,	,
18637	10199	11	333	333	CD
18637	10199	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10199	13	138	138	CD
18637	10199	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10199	15	1948	1948	CD
18637	10199	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10199	17	,	,	,
18637	10199	18	where	where	WRB
18637	10199	19	the	the	DT
18637	10199	20	continuation	continuation	NN
18637	10199	21	of	of	IN
18637	10199	22	rent	rent	NN
18637	10199	23	control	control	NN
18637	10199	24	under	under	IN
18637	10199	25	the	the	DT
18637	10199	26	Housing	Housing	NNP
18637	10199	27	and	and	CC
18637	10199	28	Rent	Rent	NNP
18637	10199	29	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10199	30	of	of	IN
18637	10199	31	1947	1947	CD
18637	10199	32	,	,	,
18637	10199	33	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	10199	34	after	after	IN
18637	10199	35	the	the	DT
18637	10199	36	termination	termination	NN
18637	10199	37	of	of	IN
18637	10199	38	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	10199	39	was	be	VBD
18637	10199	40	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	10199	41	held	hold	VBN
18637	10199	42	to	to	TO
18637	10199	43	be	be	VB
18637	10199	44	a	a	DT
18637	10199	45	valid	valid	JJ
18637	10199	46	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10199	47	of	of	IN
18637	10199	48	the	the	DT
18637	10199	49	war	war	NN
18637	10199	50	power	power	NN
18637	10199	51	,	,	,
18637	10199	52	but	but	CC
18637	10199	53	the	the	DT
18637	10199	54	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10199	55	question	question	NN
18637	10199	56	raised	raise	VBN
18637	10199	57	was	be	VBD
18637	10199	58	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	10199	59	to	to	TO
18637	10199	60	be	be	VB
18637	10199	61	a	a	DT
18637	10199	62	proper	proper	JJ
18637	10199	63	one	one	NN
18637	10199	64	for	for	IN
18637	10199	65	the	the	DT
18637	10199	66	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10199	67	.	.	.
18637	10200	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	10200	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10200	3	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	10200	4	,	,	,
18637	10200	5	in	in	IN
18637	10200	6	a	a	DT
18637	10200	7	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	10200	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10200	9	:	:	:
18637	10200	10	"	"	``
18637	10200	11	Particularly	particularly	RB
18637	10200	12	when	when	WRB
18637	10200	13	the	the	DT
18637	10200	14	war	war	NN
18637	10200	15	power	power	NN
18637	10200	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	10200	17	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	10200	18	to	to	TO
18637	10200	19	do	do	VB
18637	10200	20	things	thing	NNS
18637	10200	21	to	to	IN
18637	10200	22	the	the	DT
18637	10200	23	liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	10200	24	of	of	IN
18637	10200	25	people	people	NNS
18637	10200	26	,	,	,
18637	10200	27	or	or	CC
18637	10200	28	to	to	IN
18637	10200	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10200	30	property	property	NN
18637	10200	31	or	or	CC
18637	10200	32	economy	economy	NN
18637	10200	33	that	that	WDT
18637	10200	34	only	only	RB
18637	10200	35	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	10200	36	affect	affect	VBP
18637	10200	37	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	10200	38	of	of	IN
18637	10200	39	the	the	DT
18637	10200	40	war	war	NN
18637	10200	41	and	and	CC
18637	10200	42	do	do	VBP
18637	10200	43	not	not	RB
18637	10200	44	relate	relate	VB
18637	10200	45	to	to	IN
18637	10200	46	the	the	DT
18637	10200	47	management	management	NN
18637	10200	48	of	of	IN
18637	10200	49	the	the	DT
18637	10200	50	war	war	NN
18637	10200	51	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10200	52	,	,	,
18637	10200	53	the	the	DT
18637	10200	54	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10200	55	basis	basis	NN
18637	10200	56	should	should	MD
18637	10200	57	be	be	VB
18637	10200	58	scrutinized	scrutinize	VBN
18637	10200	59	with	with	IN
18637	10200	60	care	care	NN
18637	10200	61	.	.	.
18637	10200	62	"	"	''
18637	10201	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	10201	2	.	.	.
18637	10202	1	146	146	CD
18637	10202	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10202	3	147	147	CD
18637	10202	4	.	.	.
18637	10203	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10203	2	374	374	CD
18637	10203	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10203	4	7	7	CD
18637	10203	5	Op	Op	NNP
18637	10203	6	.	.	.
18637	10204	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	10204	2	.	.	.
18637	10205	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	10205	2	453	453	CD
18637	10205	3	,	,	,
18637	10205	4	464	464	CD
18637	10205	5	-	-	SYM
18637	10205	6	465	465	CD
18637	10205	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10205	8	1855	1855	CD
18637	10205	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10205	10	.	.	.
18637	10206	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10206	2	375	375	CD
18637	10206	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10206	4	9	9	CD
18637	10206	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	10206	6	.	.	.
18637	10207	1	102	102	CD
18637	10207	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10207	3	1846	1846	CD
18637	10207	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10207	5	;	;	:
18637	10207	6	20	20	CD
18637	10207	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	10208	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	10208	2	41	41	CD
18637	10208	3	and	and	CC
18637	10208	4	48	48	CD
18637	10208	5	.	.	.
18637	10209	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10209	2	376	376	CD
18637	10209	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10209	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10209	5	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	10209	6	.	.	.
18637	10209	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10209	8	2	2	CD
18637	10209	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	10209	10	.	.	.
18637	10210	1	78	78	CD
18637	10210	2	.	.	.
18637	10211	1	The	the	DT
18637	10211	2	provision	provision	NN
18637	10211	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	10211	4	long	long	RB
18637	10211	5	since	since	IN
18637	10211	6	dropped	drop	VBN
18637	10211	7	out	out	IN
18637	10211	8	of	of	IN
18637	10211	9	the	the	DT
18637	10211	10	statute	statute	NN
18637	10211	11	book	book	NN
18637	10211	12	.	.	.
18637	10212	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10212	2	377	377	CD
18637	10212	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10212	4	Runkle	Runkle	NNP
18637	10212	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10212	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10212	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10212	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10212	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10212	10	,	,	,
18637	10212	11	122	122	CD
18637	10212	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10212	13	543	543	CD
18637	10212	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10212	15	1887	1887	CD
18637	10212	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10212	17	.	.	.
18637	10213	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10213	2	378	378	CD
18637	10213	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10213	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10213	5	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	10213	6	.	.	.
18637	10213	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10213	8	In	In	NNP
18637	10213	9	re	re	IN
18637	10213	10	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	10213	11	,	,	,
18637	10213	12	166	166	CD
18637	10213	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10213	14	661	661	CD
18637	10213	15	,	,	,
18637	10213	16	670	670	CD
18637	10213	17	-	-	SYM
18637	10213	18	671	671	CD
18637	10213	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10213	20	1897	1897	CD
18637	10213	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10213	22	,	,	,
18637	10213	23	where	where	WRB
18637	10213	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10213	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	10213	26	held	hold	VBN
18637	10213	27	that	that	IN
18637	10213	28	presumptions	presumption	NNS
18637	10213	29	in	in	IN
18637	10213	30	favor	favor	NN
18637	10213	31	of	of	IN
18637	10213	32	official	official	JJ
18637	10213	33	action	action	NN
18637	10213	34	"	"	''
18637	10213	35	preclude	preclude	JJ
18637	10213	36	collateral	collateral	JJ
18637	10213	37	attack	attack	NN
18637	10213	38	on	on	IN
18637	10213	39	the	the	DT
18637	10213	40	sentences	sentence	NNS
18637	10213	41	of	of	IN
18637	10213	42	courts	court	NNS
18637	10213	43	-	-	HYPH
18637	10213	44	martial	martial	JJ
18637	10213	45	.	.	.
18637	10213	46	"	"	''
18637	10214	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10214	2	See	See	NNP
18637	10214	3	also	also	RB
18637	10214	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10214	5	United	United	NNP
18637	10214	6	States	States	NNP
18637	10214	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10214	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	10214	9	_	_	NNP
18637	10214	10	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	10214	11	,	,	,
18637	10214	12	148	148	CD
18637	10214	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10214	14	84	84	CD
18637	10214	15	,	,	,
18637	10214	16	88	88	CD
18637	10214	17	-	-	SYM
18637	10214	18	89	89	CD
18637	10214	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10214	20	1893	1893	CD
18637	10214	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10214	22	;	;	:
18637	10214	23	and	and	CC
18637	10214	24	Bishop	Bishop	NNP
18637	10214	25	_	_	NNP
18637	10214	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	10214	27	_	_	NNP
18637	10214	28	United	United	NNP
18637	10214	29	States	States	NNP
18637	10214	30	,	,	,
18637	10214	31	197	197	CD
18637	10214	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10214	33	334	334	CD
18637	10214	34	,	,	,
18637	10214	35	341	341	CD
18637	10214	36	-	-	SYM
18637	10214	37	342	342	CD
18637	10214	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10214	39	1905	1905	CD
18637	10214	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10214	41	;	;	:
18637	10214	42	both	both	DT
18637	10214	43	of	of	IN
18637	10214	44	which	which	WDT
18637	10214	45	in	in	IN
18637	10214	46	effect	effect	NN
18637	10214	47	repudiate	repudiate	NN
18637	10214	48	Runkle	Runkle	NNP
18637	10214	49	_	_	NNP
18637	10214	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	10214	51	_	_	NNP
18637	10214	52	United	United	NNP
18637	10214	53	States	States	NNP
18637	10214	54	.	.	.
18637	10215	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10215	2	379	379	CD
18637	10215	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10215	4	"	"	``
18637	10215	5	The	the	DT
18637	10215	6	President	President	NNP
18637	10215	7	,	,	,
18637	10215	8	in	in	IN
18637	10215	9	the	the	DT
18637	10215	10	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10215	11	of	of	IN
18637	10215	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10215	13	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10215	14	powers	power	NNS
18637	10215	15	under	under	IN
18637	10215	16	the	the	DT
18637	10215	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10215	18	,	,	,
18637	10215	19	may	may	MD
18637	10215	20	act	act	VB
18637	10215	21	through	through	IN
18637	10215	22	the	the	DT
18637	10215	23	head	head	NN
18637	10215	24	of	of	IN
18637	10215	25	the	the	DT
18637	10215	26	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	10215	27	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10215	28	department	department	NN
18637	10215	29	.	.	.
18637	10216	1	The	the	DT
18637	10216	2	heads	head	NNS
18637	10216	3	of	of	IN
18637	10216	4	departments	department	NNS
18637	10216	5	are	be	VBP
18637	10216	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10216	7	authorized	authorized	JJ
18637	10216	8	assistants	assistant	NNS
18637	10216	9	in	in	IN
18637	10216	10	the	the	DT
18637	10216	11	performance	performance	NN
18637	10216	12	of	of	IN
18637	10216	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10216	14	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10216	15	duties	duty	NNS
18637	10216	16	,	,	,
18637	10216	17	and	and	CC
18637	10216	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10216	19	official	official	JJ
18637	10216	20	acts	act	NNS
18637	10216	21	,	,	,
18637	10216	22	promulgated	promulgate	VBN
18637	10216	23	in	in	IN
18637	10216	24	the	the	DT
18637	10216	25	regular	regular	JJ
18637	10216	26	course	course	NN
18637	10216	27	of	of	IN
18637	10216	28	business	business	NN
18637	10216	29	,	,	,
18637	10216	30	are	be	VBP
18637	10216	31	presumptively	presumptively	RB
18637	10216	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10216	33	acts	act	NNS
18637	10216	34	.	.	.
18637	10216	35	"	"	''
18637	10217	1	Wilcox	Wilcox	NNP
18637	10217	2	_	_	NNP
18637	10217	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	10217	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10217	5	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	10217	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	10217	7	dem	dem	NNP
18637	10217	8	McConnel	McConnel	NNP
18637	10217	9	,	,	,
18637	10217	10	13	13	CD
18637	10217	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	10217	12	.	.	.
18637	10218	1	498	498	CD
18637	10218	2	,	,	,
18637	10218	3	513	513	CD
18637	10218	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10218	5	1839	1839	CD
18637	10218	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10218	7	.	.	.
18637	10219	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10219	2	See	See	NNP
18637	10219	3	also	also	RB
18637	10219	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10219	5	,	,	,
18637	10219	6	United	United	NNP
18637	10219	7	States	States	NNP
18637	10219	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10219	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	10219	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10219	11	Eliason	Eliason	NNP
18637	10219	12	,	,	,
18637	10219	13	16	16	CD
18637	10219	14	Pet	pet	NN
18637	10219	15	.	.	.
18637	10220	1	291	291	CD
18637	10220	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10220	3	1842	1842	CD
18637	10220	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10220	5	;	;	:
18637	10220	6	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	10220	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10220	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	10220	9	_	_	NNP
18637	10220	10	United	United	NNP
18637	10220	11	States	States	NNP
18637	10220	12	,	,	,
18637	10220	13	1	1	CD
18637	10220	14	How	how	WRB
18637	10220	15	.	.	.
18637	10221	1	290	290	CD
18637	10221	2	,	,	,
18637	10221	3	297	297	CD
18637	10221	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10221	5	1843	1843	CD
18637	10221	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10221	7	;	;	:
18637	10221	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10221	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10221	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10221	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	10221	12	_	_	NNP
18637	10221	13	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	10221	14	,	,	,
18637	10221	15	18	18	CD
18637	10221	16	How	how	WRB
18637	10221	17	.	.	.
18637	10222	1	92	92	CD
18637	10222	2	,	,	,
18637	10222	3	95	95	CD
18637	10222	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10222	5	1856	1856	CD
18637	10222	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10222	7	;	;	:
18637	10222	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10222	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10222	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10222	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	10222	12	_	_	NNP
18637	10222	13	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	10222	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10222	15	Confiscation	Confiscation	NNP
18637	10222	16	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	10222	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10222	18	,	,	,
18637	10222	19	20	20	CD
18637	10222	20	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	10222	21	.	.	.
18637	10223	1	92	92	CD
18637	10223	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10223	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	10223	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10223	5	;	;	:
18637	10223	6	United	United	NNP
18637	10223	7	States	States	NNP
18637	10223	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10223	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	10223	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10223	11	Farden	Farden	NNP
18637	10223	12	,	,	,
18637	10223	13	99	99	CD
18637	10223	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10223	15	10	10	CD
18637	10223	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10223	17	1879	1879	CD
18637	10223	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10223	19	;	;	:
18637	10223	20	Wolsey	Wolsey	NNP
18637	10223	21	_	_	NNP
18637	10223	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	10223	23	_	_	NNP
18637	10223	24	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	10223	25	,	,	,
18637	10223	26	101	101	CD
18637	10223	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10223	28	755	755	CD
18637	10223	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10223	30	1880	1880	CD
18637	10223	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10223	32	.	.	.
18637	10224	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10224	2	380	380	CD
18637	10224	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10224	4	1	1	CD
18637	10224	5	How	how	WRB
18637	10224	6	.	.	.
18637	10225	1	290	290	CD
18637	10225	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10225	3	1843	1843	CD
18637	10225	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10225	5	.	.	.
18637	10226	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10226	2	381	381	CD
18637	10226	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10226	4	3	3	CD
18637	10226	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	10226	6	.	.	.
18637	10227	1	723	723	CD
18637	10227	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10227	3	1823	1823	CD
18637	10227	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10227	5	.	.	.
18637	10228	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10228	2	382	382	CD
18637	10228	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10228	4	1	1	CD
18637	10228	5	How	how	WRB
18637	10228	6	.	.	.
18637	10229	1	at	at	IN
18637	10229	2	297	297	CD
18637	10229	3	-	-	SYM
18637	10229	4	298	298	CD
18637	10229	5	.	.	.
18637	10230	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10230	2	383	383	CD
18637	10230	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10230	4	"	"	``
18637	10230	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10230	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	10230	7	manifestly	manifestly	RB
18637	10230	8	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	10230	9	for	for	IN
18637	10230	10	the	the	DT
18637	10230	11	President	President	NNP
18637	10230	12	to	to	TO
18637	10230	13	execute	execute	VB
18637	10230	14	every	every	DT
18637	10230	15	duty	duty	NN
18637	10230	16	,	,	,
18637	10230	17	and	and	CC
18637	10230	18	every	every	DT
18637	10230	19	detail	detail	NN
18637	10230	20	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	10230	21	,	,	,
18637	10230	22	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	10230	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	10230	24	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10230	25	by	by	IN
18637	10230	26	the	the	DT
18637	10230	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10230	28	.	.	.
18637	10231	1	The	the	DT
18637	10231	2	courts	court	NNS
18637	10231	3	have	have	VBP
18637	10231	4	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	10231	5	this	this	DT
18637	10231	6	and	and	CC
18637	10231	7	have	have	VBP
18637	10231	8	further	further	RB
18637	10231	9	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	10231	10	that	that	IN
18637	10231	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10231	12	usually	usually	RB
18637	10231	13	and	and	CC
18637	10231	14	properly	properly	RB
18637	10231	15	acts	act	VBZ
18637	10231	16	through	through	IN
18637	10231	17	the	the	DT
18637	10231	18	several	several	JJ
18637	10231	19	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10231	20	departments	department	NNS
18637	10231	21	.	.	.
18637	10232	1	Every	every	DT
18637	10232	2	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	10232	3	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	10232	4	of	of	IN
18637	10232	5	validity	validity	NN
18637	10232	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	10232	7	to	to	TO
18637	10232	8	be	be	VB
18637	10232	9	indulged	indulge	VBN
18637	10232	10	with	with	IN
18637	10232	11	respect	respect	NN
18637	10232	12	to	to	IN
18637	10232	13	the	the	DT
18637	10232	14	performance	performance	NN
18637	10232	15	by	by	IN
18637	10232	16	the	the	DT
18637	10232	17	head	head	NN
18637	10232	18	of	of	IN
18637	10232	19	a	a	DT
18637	10232	20	department	department	NN
18637	10232	21	of	of	IN
18637	10232	22	a	a	DT
18637	10232	23	duty	duty	NN
18637	10232	24	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	10232	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	10232	26	the	the	DT
18637	10232	27	President	President	NNP
18637	10232	28	and	and	CC
18637	10232	29	executed	execute	VBN
18637	10232	30	by	by	IN
18637	10232	31	the	the	DT
18637	10232	32	department	department	NN
18637	10232	33	head	head	NN
18637	10232	34	ostensibly	ostensibly	RB
18637	10232	35	in	in	IN
18637	10232	36	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	10232	37	of	of	IN
18637	10232	38	the	the	DT
18637	10232	39	President	President	NNP
18637	10232	40	.	.	.
18637	10233	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	10233	2	,	,	,
18637	10233	3	the	the	DT
18637	10233	4	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	10233	5	indicate	indicate	VBP
18637	10233	6	that	that	IN
18637	10233	7	the	the	DT
18637	10233	8	President	President	NNP
18637	10233	9	can	can	MD
18637	10233	10	not	not	RB
18637	10233	11	,	,	,
18637	10233	12	without	without	IN
18637	10233	13	statutory	statutory	NNP
18637	10233	14	authority	authority	NNP
18637	10233	15	,	,	,
18637	10233	16	delegate	delegate	VBP
18637	10233	17	a	a	DT
18637	10233	18	discretionary	discretionary	JJ
18637	10233	19	duty	duty	NN
18637	10233	20	,	,	,
18637	10233	21	relieving	relieve	VBG
18637	10233	22	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10233	23	of	of	IN
18637	10233	24	all	all	DT
18637	10233	25	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	10233	26	,	,	,
18637	10233	27	so	so	IN
18637	10233	28	that	that	IN
18637	10233	29	the	the	DT
18637	10233	30	duty	duty	NN
18637	10233	31	when	when	WRB
18637	10233	32	performed	perform	VBN
18637	10233	33	will	will	MD
18637	10233	34	not	not	RB
18637	10233	35	be	be	VB
18637	10233	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10233	37	act	act	NN
18637	10233	38	but	but	CC
18637	10233	39	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	10233	40	the	the	DT
18637	10233	41	act	act	NN
18637	10233	42	of	of	IN
18637	10233	43	another	another	DT
18637	10233	44	.	.	.
18637	10234	1	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	10234	2	_	_	NNP
18637	10234	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	10234	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10234	5	United	United	NNP
18637	10234	6	States	States	NNP
18637	10234	7	,	,	,
18637	10234	8	1	1	CD
18637	10234	9	How	how	WRB
18637	10234	10	.	.	.
18637	10235	1	290	290	CD
18637	10235	2	,	,	,
18637	10235	3	297	297	CD
18637	10235	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10235	5	1843	1843	CD
18637	10235	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10235	7	;	;	:
18637	10235	8	Runkle	Runkle	NNP
18637	10235	9	_	_	NNP
18637	10235	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	10235	11	_	_	NNP
18637	10235	12	United	United	NNP
18637	10235	13	States	States	NNP
18637	10235	14	,	,	,
18637	10235	15	122	122	CD
18637	10235	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10235	17	543	543	CD
18637	10235	18	,	,	,
18637	10235	19	557	557	CD
18637	10235	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10235	21	1887	1887	CD
18637	10235	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10235	23	;	;	:
18637	10235	24	United	United	NNP
18637	10235	25	States	States	NNP
18637	10235	26	_	_	NNP
18637	10235	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	10235	28	_	_	NNP
18637	10235	29	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	10235	30	,	,	,
18637	10235	31	148	148	CD
18637	10235	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10235	33	84	84	CD
18637	10235	34	,	,	,
18637	10235	35	88	88	CD
18637	10235	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10235	37	1893	1893	CD
18637	10235	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10235	39	;	;	:
18637	10235	40	French	French	NNP
18637	10235	41	_	_	NNP
18637	10235	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	10235	43	_	_	NNP
18637	10235	44	Weeks	Weeks	NNP
18637	10235	45	,	,	,
18637	10235	46	259	259	CD
18637	10235	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10235	48	326	326	CD
18637	10235	49	,	,	,
18637	10235	50	334	334	CD
18637	10235	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10235	52	1922	1922	CD
18637	10235	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10235	54	"	"	''
18637	10235	55	;	;	:
18637	10235	56	38	38	CD
18637	10235	57	Op	Op	NNP
18637	10235	58	.	.	.
18637	10236	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	10236	2	.	.	.
18637	10237	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	10237	2	457	457	CD
18637	10237	3	-	-	SYM
18637	10237	4	459	459	CD
18637	10237	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10237	6	1936	1936	CD
18637	10237	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10237	8	.	.	.
18637	10238	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10238	2	384	384	CD
18637	10238	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10238	4	1	1	CD
18637	10238	5	Annals	Annals	NNPS
18637	10238	6	of	of	IN
18637	10238	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10238	8	,	,	,
18637	10238	9	cols	col	NNS
18637	10238	10	.	.	.
18637	10239	1	515	515	CD
18637	10239	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10239	3	516	516	CD
18637	10239	4	.	.	.
18637	10240	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10240	2	385	385	CD
18637	10240	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10240	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10240	5	.	.	.
18637	10241	1	cols	col	NNS
18637	10241	2	.	.	.
18637	10242	1	635	635	CD
18637	10242	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10242	3	636	636	CD
18637	10242	4	.	.	.
18637	10243	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10243	2	386	386	CD
18637	10243	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10243	4	1	1	CD
18637	10243	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	10243	6	.	.	.
18637	10244	1	137	137	CD
18637	10244	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10244	3	1803	1803	CD
18637	10244	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10244	5	.	.	.
18637	10245	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10245	2	387	387	CD
18637	10245	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10245	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10245	5	.	.	.
18637	10246	1	165	165	CD
18637	10246	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10246	3	166	166	CD
18637	10246	4	.	.	.
18637	10247	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10247	2	388	388	CD
18637	10247	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10247	4	Op	Op	NNP
18637	10247	5	.	.	.
18637	10248	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	10248	2	.	.	.
18637	10249	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	10249	2	624	624	CD
18637	10249	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10249	4	1823	1823	CD
18637	10249	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10249	6	.	.	.
18637	10250	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10250	2	389	389	CD
18637	10250	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10250	4	Messages	Messages	NNPS
18637	10250	5	and	and	CC
18637	10250	6	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	10250	7	of	of	IN
18637	10250	8	the	the	DT
18637	10250	9	Presidents	Presidents	NNPS
18637	10250	10	,	,	,
18637	10250	11	III	III	NNP
18637	10250	12	,	,	,
18637	10250	13	1288	1288	CD
18637	10250	14	.	.	.
18637	10251	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10251	2	390	390	CD
18637	10251	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10251	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10251	5	.	.	.
18637	10252	1	1304	1304	CD
18637	10252	2	.	.	.
18637	10253	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10253	2	391	391	CD
18637	10253	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10253	4	12	12	CD
18637	10253	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	10253	6	.	.	.
18637	10254	1	524	524	CD
18637	10254	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10254	3	1838	1838	CD
18637	10254	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10254	5	.	.	.
18637	10255	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10255	2	392	392	CD
18637	10255	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10255	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10255	5	.	.	.
18637	10256	1	610	610	CD
18637	10256	2	.	.	.
18637	10257	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10257	2	393	393	CD
18637	10257	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10257	4	272	272	CD
18637	10257	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10257	6	52	52	CD
18637	10257	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10257	8	1926	1926	CD
18637	10257	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10257	10	;	;	:
18637	10257	11	295	295	CD
18637	10257	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10257	13	602	602	CD
18637	10257	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10257	15	1935	1935	CD
18637	10257	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10257	17	.	.	.
18637	10258	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10258	2	394	394	CD
18637	10258	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10258	4	Bruce	Bruce	NNP
18637	10258	5	Wyman	Wyman	NNP
18637	10258	6	,	,	,
18637	10258	7	The	the	DT
18637	10258	8	Principles	Principles	NNPS
18637	10258	9	of	of	IN
18637	10258	10	the	the	DT
18637	10258	11	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	10258	12	Law	Law	NNP
18637	10258	13	Governing	govern	VBG
18637	10258	14	the	the	DT
18637	10258	15	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	10258	16	of	of	IN
18637	10258	17	Public	Public	NNP
18637	10258	18	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	10258	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10258	20	St.	St.	NNP
18637	10258	21	Paul	Paul	NNP
18637	10258	22	,	,	,
18637	10258	23	1903	1903	CD
18637	10258	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10258	25	,	,	,
18637	10258	26	231	231	CD
18637	10258	27	-	-	SYM
18637	10258	28	232	232	CD
18637	10258	29	.	.	.
18637	10259	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10259	2	395	395	CD
18637	10259	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10259	4	United	United	NNP
18637	10259	5	States	States	NNP
18637	10259	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10259	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10259	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10259	9	Eliason	Eliason	NNP
18637	10259	10	,	,	,
18637	10259	11	16	16	CD
18637	10259	12	Pet	pet	NN
18637	10259	13	.	.	.
18637	10260	1	291	291	CD
18637	10260	2	,	,	,
18637	10260	3	301	301	CD
18637	10260	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	10260	5	302	302	CD
18637	10260	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10260	7	1842	1842	CD
18637	10260	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10260	9	;	;	:
18637	10260	10	Kurtz	Kurtz	NNP
18637	10260	11	_	_	NNP
18637	10260	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	10260	13	_	_	NNP
18637	10260	14	Moffitt	Moffitt	NNP
18637	10260	15	,	,	,
18637	10260	16	115	115	CD
18637	10260	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10260	18	487	487	CD
18637	10260	19	,	,	,
18637	10260	20	503	503	CD
18637	10260	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10260	22	1885	1885	CD
18637	10260	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10260	24	;	;	:
18637	10260	25	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	10260	26	_	_	NNP
18637	10260	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	10260	28	_	_	NNP
18637	10260	29	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	10260	30	,	,	,
18637	10260	31	116	116	CD
18637	10260	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10260	33	167	167	CD
18637	10260	34	,	,	,
18637	10260	35	180	180	CD
18637	10260	36	-	-	SYM
18637	10260	37	181	181	CD
18637	10260	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10260	39	1886	1886	CD
18637	10260	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10260	41	.	.	.
18637	10261	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10261	2	396	396	CD
18637	10261	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10261	4	135	135	CD
18637	10261	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10261	6	1	1	CD
18637	10261	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10261	8	1890	1890	CD
18637	10261	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10261	10	.	.	.
18637	10262	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10262	2	397	397	CD
18637	10262	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10262	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10262	5	.	.	.
18637	10263	1	64	64	CD
18637	10263	2	.	.	.
18637	10264	1	The	the	DT
18637	10264	2	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	10264	3	"	"	``
18637	10264	4	a	a	DT
18637	10264	5	law	law	NN
18637	10264	6	of	of	IN
18637	10264	7	the	the	DT
18637	10264	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10264	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10264	10	"	"	''
18637	10264	11	came	come	VBD
18637	10264	12	from	from	IN
18637	10264	13	the	the	DT
18637	10264	14	act	act	NN
18637	10264	15	of	of	IN
18637	10264	16	March	March	NNP
18637	10264	17	2	2	CD
18637	10264	18	,	,	,
18637	10264	19	1833	1833	CD
18637	10264	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10264	21	4	4	CD
18637	10264	22	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	10264	23	.	.	.
18637	10265	1	632	632	CD
18637	10265	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10265	3	.	.	.
18637	10266	1	However	however	RB
18637	10266	2	,	,	,
18637	10266	3	in	in	IN
18637	10266	4	28	28	CD
18637	10266	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
18637	10267	1	2241	2241	CD
18637	10267	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10267	3	c	c	NN
18637	10267	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10267	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10267	6	2	2	CD
18637	10267	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10267	8	,	,	,
18637	10267	9	as	as	IN
18637	10267	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10267	11	stands	stand	VBZ
18637	10267	12	following	follow	VBG
18637	10267	13	the	the	DT
18637	10267	14	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	10267	15	of	of	IN
18637	10267	16	May	May	NNP
18637	10267	17	24	24	CD
18637	10267	18	,	,	,
18637	10267	19	1949	1949	CD
18637	10267	20	,	,	,
18637	10267	21	c.	c.	NNP
18637	10267	22	139	139	CD
18637	10267	23	,	,	,
18637	10267	24	the	the	DT
18637	10267	25	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	10267	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	10267	27	replaced	replace	VBN
18637	10267	28	by	by	IN
18637	10267	29	the	the	DT
18637	10267	30	term	term	NN
18637	10267	31	an	an	DT
18637	10267	32	act	act	NN
18637	10267	33	of	of	IN
18637	10267	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10267	35	,	,	,
18637	10267	36	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	10267	37	eliminating	eliminate	VBG
18637	10267	38	the	the	DT
18637	10267	39	basis	basis	NN
18637	10267	40	of	of	IN
18637	10267	41	the	the	DT
18637	10267	42	holding	holding	NN
18637	10267	43	in	in	RP
18637	10267	44	In	in	IN
18637	10267	45	re	re	IN
18637	10267	46	Neagle	Neagle	NNP
18637	10267	47	.	.	.
18637	10268	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10268	2	398	398	CD
18637	10268	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10268	4	236	236	CD
18637	10268	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10268	6	459	459	CD
18637	10268	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10268	8	1915	1915	CD
18637	10268	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10268	10	;	;	:
18637	10268	11	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	10268	12	_	_	NNP
18637	10268	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	10268	14	_	_	NNP
18637	10268	15	United	United	NNP
18637	10268	16	States	States	NNP
18637	10268	17	,	,	,
18637	10268	18	260	260	CD
18637	10268	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10268	20	545	545	CD
18637	10268	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10268	22	1923	1923	CD
18637	10268	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10268	24	.	.	.
18637	10269	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10269	2	399	399	CD
18637	10269	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10269	4	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	10270	1	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	10270	2	.	.	.
18637	10271	1	§	§	NNP
18637	10271	2	5298	5298	CD
18637	10271	3	;	;	:
18637	10271	4	50	50	CD
18637	10271	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	10272	1	§	§	NNP
18637	10272	2	202	202	CD
18637	10272	3	.	.	.
18637	10273	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10273	2	400	400	CD
18637	10273	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10273	4	1	1	CD
18637	10273	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	10273	6	.	.	.
18637	10274	1	264	264	CD
18637	10274	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10274	3	1792	1792	CD
18637	10274	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10274	5	;	;	:
18637	10274	6	1	1	CD
18637	10274	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	10274	8	.	.	.
18637	10275	1	424	424	CD
18637	10275	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10275	3	1795	1795	CD
18637	10275	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10275	5	;	;	:
18637	10275	6	2	2	CD
18637	10275	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	10275	8	.	.	.
18637	10276	1	443	443	CD
18637	10276	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10276	3	1807	1807	CD
18637	10276	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10276	5	;	;	:
18637	10276	6	12	12	CD
18637	10276	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	10276	8	.	.	.
18637	10277	1	281	281	CD
18637	10277	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10277	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	10277	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10277	5	.	.	.
18637	10278	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10278	2	401	401	CD
18637	10278	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10278	4	12	12	CD
18637	10278	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	10278	6	.	.	.
18637	10279	1	19	19	CD
18637	10279	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10279	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	10279	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10279	5	.	.	.
18637	10280	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10280	2	402	402	CD
18637	10280	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10280	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10280	5	.	.	.
18637	10281	1	31	31	CD
18637	10281	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10281	3	32	32	CD
18637	10281	4	.	.	.
18637	10282	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10282	2	403	403	CD
18637	10282	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10282	4	"	"	``
18637	10282	5	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10282	6	Aid	Aid	NNP
18637	10282	7	in	in	IN
18637	10282	8	Domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	10282	9	Disturbances	Disturbances	NNPS
18637	10282	10	,	,	,
18637	10282	11	"	"	''
18637	10282	12	S.	S.	NNP
18637	10282	13	Doc	Doc	NNP
18637	10282	14	.	.	.
18637	10283	1	209	209	CD
18637	10283	2	,	,	,
18637	10283	3	59th	59th	JJ
18637	10283	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	10283	5	.	.	NNP
18637	10283	6	,	,	,
18637	10283	7	2	2	CD
18637	10283	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	10283	9	.	.	.
18637	10283	10	,	,	,
18637	10283	11	p.	p.	NN
18637	10283	12	51	51	CD
18637	10283	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10283	14	1907	1907	CD
18637	10283	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10283	16	.	.	.
18637	10284	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10284	2	404	404	CD
18637	10284	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10284	4	Op	Op	NNP
18637	10284	5	.	.	.
18637	10285	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	10285	2	.	.	.
18637	10286	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	10286	2	466	466	CD
18637	10286	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10286	4	1854	1854	CD
18637	10286	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10286	6	.	.	.
18637	10287	1	By	by	IN
18637	10287	2	the	the	DT
18637	10287	3	Posse	Posse	NNP
18637	10287	4	Comitatus	Comitatus	NNP
18637	10287	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10287	6	of	of	IN
18637	10287	7	1878	1878	CD
18637	10287	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10287	9	20	20	CD
18637	10287	10	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	10287	11	.	.	.
18637	10288	1	152	152	CD
18637	10288	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10288	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10288	4	was	be	VBD
18637	10288	5	provided	provide	VBN
18637	10288	6	that	that	IN
18637	10288	7	"	"	``
18637	10288	8	*	*	NFP
18637	10288	9	*	*	NFP
18637	10288	10	*	*	NFP
18637	10288	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10288	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	10288	13	not	not	RB
18637	10288	14	be	be	VB
18637	10288	15	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	10288	16	to	to	TO
18637	10288	17	employ	employ	VB
18637	10288	18	any	any	DT
18637	10288	19	part	part	NN
18637	10288	20	of	of	IN
18637	10288	21	the	the	DT
18637	10288	22	Army	Army	NNP
18637	10288	23	of	of	IN
18637	10288	24	the	the	DT
18637	10288	25	United	United	NNP
18637	10288	26	States	States	NNP
18637	10288	27	,	,	,
18637	10288	28	as	as	IN
18637	10288	29	a	a	DT
18637	10288	30	_	_	NNP
18637	10288	31	posse	posse	NN
18637	10288	32	comitatus	comitatus	NN
18637	10288	33	_	_	NNP
18637	10288	34	,	,	,
18637	10288	35	or	or	CC
18637	10288	36	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	10288	37	,	,	,
18637	10288	38	for	for	IN
18637	10288	39	the	the	DT
18637	10288	40	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	10288	41	of	of	IN
18637	10288	42	executing	execute	VBG
18637	10288	43	the	the	DT
18637	10288	44	laws	law	NNS
18637	10288	45	,	,	,
18637	10288	46	except	except	IN
18637	10288	47	in	in	IN
18637	10288	48	such	such	JJ
18637	10288	49	cases	case	NNS
18637	10288	50	and	and	CC
18637	10288	51	under	under	IN
18637	10288	52	such	such	JJ
18637	10288	53	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	10288	54	as	as	IN
18637	10288	55	such	such	JJ
18637	10288	56	employment	employment	NN
18637	10288	57	of	of	IN
18637	10288	58	said	say	VBD
18637	10288	59	force	force	NN
18637	10288	60	may	may	MD
18637	10288	61	be	be	VB
18637	10288	62	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	10288	63	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	10288	64	by	by	IN
18637	10288	65	the	the	DT
18637	10288	66	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10288	67	or	or	CC
18637	10288	68	by	by	IN
18637	10288	69	act	act	NN
18637	10288	70	of	of	IN
18637	10288	71	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10288	72	*	*	NFP
18637	10288	73	*	*	NFP
18637	10288	74	*	*	NFP
18637	10288	75	"	"	``
18637	10288	76	The	the	DT
18637	10288	77	effect	effect	NN
18637	10288	78	of	of	IN
18637	10288	79	this	this	DT
18637	10288	80	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	10288	81	,	,	,
18637	10288	82	however	however	RB
18637	10288	83	,	,	,
18637	10288	84	was	be	VBD
18637	10288	85	largely	largely	RB
18637	10288	86	nullified	nullify	VBN
18637	10288	87	by	by	IN
18637	10288	88	a	a	DT
18637	10288	89	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	10288	90	of	of	IN
18637	10288	91	the	the	DT
18637	10288	92	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10288	93	General	General	NNP
18637	10288	94	"	"	''
18637	10288	95	that	that	IN
18637	10288	96	by	by	IN
18637	10288	97	Revised	Revised	NNP
18637	10288	98	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	10288	99	§§	§§	-LRB-
18637	10288	100	5298	5298	CD
18637	10288	101	and	and	CC
18637	10288	102	5300	5300	CD
18637	10288	103	,	,	,
18637	10288	104	the	the	DT
18637	10288	105	military	military	JJ
18637	10288	106	forces	force	NNS
18637	10288	107	,	,	,
18637	10288	108	under	under	IN
18637	10288	109	the	the	DT
18637	10288	110	direction	direction	NN
18637	10288	111	of	of	IN
18637	10288	112	the	the	DT
18637	10288	113	President	President	NNP
18637	10288	114	,	,	,
18637	10288	115	could	could	MD
18637	10288	116	be	be	VB
18637	10288	117	used	use	VBN
18637	10288	118	to	to	TO
18637	10288	119	assist	assist	VB
18637	10288	120	a	a	DT
18637	10288	121	marshal	marshal	NN
18637	10288	122	.	.	.
18637	10289	1	16	16	CD
18637	10289	2	Op	op	NN
18637	10289	3	.	.	.
18637	10290	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	10290	2	.	.	.
18637	10291	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	10292	1	162	162	CD
18637	10292	2	.	.	.
18637	10292	3	"	"	''
18637	10293	1	Bennett	Bennett	NNP
18637	10293	2	Milton	Milton	NNP
18637	10293	3	Rich	Rich	NNP
18637	10293	4	,	,	,
18637	10293	5	The	the	DT
18637	10293	6	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	10293	7	and	and	CC
18637	10293	8	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	10293	9	Disorder	Disorder	NNP
18637	10293	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10293	11	The	the	DT
18637	10293	12	Brookings	Brookings	NNP
18637	10293	13	Institution	Institution	NNP
18637	10293	14	,	,	,
18637	10293	15	1941	1941	CD
18637	10293	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10293	17	,	,	,
18637	10293	18	196	196	CD
18637	10293	19	fn	fn	CD
18637	10293	20	.	.	.
18637	10294	1	21	21	CD
18637	10294	2	.	.	.
18637	10295	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10295	2	405	405	CD
18637	10295	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10295	4	12	12	CD
18637	10295	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	10295	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10295	7	App	App	NNP
18637	10295	8	.	.	.
18637	10295	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10296	1	1258	1258	CD
18637	10296	2	.	.	.
18637	10297	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10297	2	406	406	CD
18637	10297	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10297	4	212	212	CD
18637	10297	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10297	6	78	78	CD
18637	10297	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10297	8	1909	1909	CD
18637	10297	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10297	10	.	.	.
18637	10298	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10298	2	407	407	CD
18637	10298	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10298	4	In	in	IN
18637	10298	5	re	re	NN
18637	10298	6	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	10298	7	,	,	,
18637	10298	8	158	158	CD
18637	10298	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10298	10	565	565	CD
18637	10298	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10298	12	1895	1895	CD
18637	10298	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10298	14	.	.	.
18637	10299	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10299	2	408	408	CD
18637	10299	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10299	4	212	212	CD
18637	10299	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10299	6	at	at	IN
18637	10299	7	84	84	CD
18637	10299	8	-	-	SYM
18637	10299	9	85	85	CD
18637	10299	10	.	.	.
18637	10300	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10300	2	See	See	NNP
18637	10300	3	also	also	RB
18637	10300	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10300	5	Sterling	Sterling	NNP
18637	10300	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10300	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10300	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10300	9	Constantin	Constantin	NNP
18637	10300	10	,	,	,
18637	10300	11	287	287	CD
18637	10300	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10300	13	378	378	CD
18637	10300	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10300	15	1932	1932	CD
18637	10300	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10300	17	,	,	,
18637	10300	18	which	which	WDT
18637	10300	19	endorses	endorse	VBZ
18637	10300	20	Moyer	Moyer	NNP
18637	10300	21	_	_	NNP
18637	10300	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	10300	23	_	_	NNP
18637	10300	24	Peabody	Peabody	NNP
18637	10300	25	,	,	,
18637	10300	26	while	while	IN
18637	10300	27	emphasizing	emphasize	VBG
18637	10300	28	the	the	DT
18637	10300	29	fact	fact	NN
18637	10300	30	that	that	IN
18637	10300	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10300	32	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	10300	33	only	only	RB
18637	10300	34	to	to	IN
18637	10300	35	a	a	DT
18637	10300	36	condition	condition	NN
18637	10300	37	of	of	IN
18637	10300	38	disorder	disorder	NN
18637	10300	39	.	.	.
18637	10301	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10301	2	409	409	CD
18637	10301	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10301	4	158	158	CD
18637	10301	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNS
18637	10301	6	at	at	IN
18637	10301	7	584	584	CD
18637	10301	8	,	,	,
18637	10301	9	586	586	CD
18637	10301	10	.	.	.
18637	10302	1	Some	some	DT
18637	10302	2	years	year	NNS
18637	10302	3	earlier	early	RBR
18637	10302	4	,	,	,
18637	10302	5	in	in	IN
18637	10302	6	the	the	DT
18637	10302	7	United	United	NNP
18637	10302	8	States	States	NNP
18637	10302	9	_	_	NNP
18637	10302	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	10302	11	_	_	NNP
18637	10302	12	San	San	NNP
18637	10302	13	Jacinto	Jacinto	NNP
18637	10302	14	Tin	Tin	NNP
18637	10302	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10302	16	,	,	,
18637	10302	17	the	the	DT
18637	10302	18	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	10302	19	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	10302	20	the	the	DT
18637	10302	21	right	right	NN
18637	10302	22	of	of	IN
18637	10302	23	the	the	DT
18637	10302	24	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10302	25	General	General	NNP
18637	10302	26	and	and	CC
18637	10302	27	of	of	IN
18637	10302	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10302	29	assistants	assistant	NNS
18637	10302	30	to	to	IN
18637	10302	31	institute	institute	VB
18637	10302	32	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10302	33	simply	simply	RB
18637	10302	34	by	by	IN
18637	10302	35	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	10302	36	of	of	IN
18637	10302	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10302	38	general	general	JJ
18637	10302	39	official	official	JJ
18637	10302	40	powers	power	NNS
18637	10302	41	.	.	.
18637	10303	1	"	"	``
18637	10303	2	If	if	IN
18637	10303	3	,	,	,
18637	10303	4	"	"	''
18637	10303	5	the	the	DT
18637	10303	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10303	7	said	say	VBD
18637	10303	8	,	,	,
18637	10303	9	"	"	``
18637	10303	10	the	the	DT
18637	10303	11	United	United	NNP
18637	10303	12	States	States	NNP
18637	10303	13	in	in	IN
18637	10303	14	any	any	DT
18637	10303	15	particular	particular	JJ
18637	10303	16	case	case	NN
18637	10303	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	10303	18	a	a	DT
18637	10303	19	just	just	RB
18637	10303	20	cause	cause	NN
18637	10303	21	for	for	IN
18637	10303	22	calling	call	VBG
18637	10303	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	10303	24	the	the	DT
18637	10303	25	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	10303	26	of	of	IN
18637	10303	27	the	the	DT
18637	10303	28	country	country	NN
18637	10303	29	,	,	,
18637	10303	30	in	in	IN
18637	10303	31	any	any	DT
18637	10303	32	of	of	IN
18637	10303	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10303	34	courts	court	NNS
18637	10303	35	,	,	,
18637	10303	36	for	for	IN
18637	10303	37	relief	relief	NN
18637	10303	38	*	*	NFP
18637	10303	39	*	*	NFP
18637	10303	40	*	*	NFP
18637	10303	41	"	"	''
18637	10303	42	in	in	IN
18637	10303	43	the	the	DT
18637	10303	44	question	question	NN
18637	10303	45	of	of	IN
18637	10303	46	appealing	appeal	VBG
18637	10303	47	to	to	IN
18637	10303	48	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10303	49	"	"	``
18637	10303	50	must	must	MD
18637	10303	51	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	10303	52	be	be	VB
18637	10303	53	decided	decide	VBN
18637	10303	54	by	by	IN
18637	10303	55	the	the	DT
18637	10303	56	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10303	57	General	General	NNP
18637	10303	58	*	*	NFP
18637	10303	59	*	*	NFP
18637	10303	60	*	*	NFP
18637	10303	61	"	"	''
18637	10303	62	and	and	CC
18637	10303	63	if	if	IN
18637	10303	64	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	10303	65	are	be	VBP
18637	10303	66	to	to	TO
18637	10303	67	be	be	VB
18637	10303	68	placed	place	VBN
18637	10303	69	upon	upon	IN
18637	10303	70	the	the	DT
18637	10303	71	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10303	72	of	of	IN
18637	10303	73	this	this	DT
18637	10303	74	authority	authority	NN
18637	10303	75	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10303	76	is	be	VBZ
18637	10303	77	for	for	IN
18637	10303	78	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10303	79	to	to	TO
18637	10303	80	enact	enact	VB
18637	10303	81	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10303	82	.	.	.
18637	10304	1	125	125	CD
18637	10304	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10304	3	273	273	CD
18637	10304	4	,	,	,
18637	10304	5	279	279	CD
18637	10304	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10304	7	1888	1888	CD
18637	10304	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10304	9	.	.	.
18637	10305	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10305	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	10305	3	.	.	.
18637	10305	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10305	5	Hayburn	Hayburn	NNP
18637	10305	6	's	's	POS
18637	10305	7	case	case	NN
18637	10305	8	,	,	,
18637	10305	9	2	2	CD
18637	10305	10	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	10305	11	.	.	.
18637	10306	1	409	409	CD
18637	10306	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10306	3	1792	1792	CD
18637	10306	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10306	5	,	,	,
18637	10306	6	in	in	IN
18637	10306	7	which	which	WDT
18637	10306	8	the	the	DT
18637	10306	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10306	10	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	10306	11	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10306	12	General	General	NNP
18637	10306	13	Randolph	Randolph	NNP
18637	10306	14	's	's	POS
18637	10306	15	contention	contention	NN
18637	10306	16	that	that	IN
18637	10306	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10306	18	had	have	VBD
18637	10306	19	the	the	DT
18637	10306	20	right	right	JJ
18637	10306	21	_	_	NNP
18637	10306	22	ex	ex	NNP
18637	10306	23	officio	officio	NNP
18637	10306	24	_	_	NNP
18637	10306	25	to	to	TO
18637	10306	26	move	move	VB
18637	10306	27	for	for	IN
18637	10306	28	a	a	DT
18637	10306	29	writ	writ	NN
18637	10306	30	of	of	IN
18637	10306	31	_	_	NNP
18637	10306	32	mandamus	mandamus	NNP
18637	10306	33	_	_	NNP
18637	10306	34	ordering	order	VBG
18637	10306	35	the	the	DT
18637	10306	36	United	United	NNP
18637	10306	37	States	States	NNP
18637	10306	38	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	10306	39	court	court	NN
18637	10306	40	for	for	IN
18637	10306	41	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	10306	42	to	to	TO
18637	10306	43	put	put	VB
18637	10306	44	the	the	DT
18637	10306	45	Invalid	Invalid	NNP
18637	10306	46	Pension	Pension	NNP
18637	10306	47	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10306	48	into	into	IN
18637	10306	49	effect	effect	NN
18637	10306	50	.	.	.
18637	10307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10307	2	410	410	CD
18637	10307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10307	4	29	29	CD
18637	10307	5	U.S.C.	u.s.c.	NN
18637	10308	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	10308	2	101	101	CD
18637	10308	3	-	-	SYM
18637	10308	4	105	105	CD
18637	10308	5	;	;	:
18637	10308	6	47	47	CD
18637	10308	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	10308	8	.	.	.
18637	10309	1	70	70	CD
18637	10309	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10309	3	1932	1932	CD
18637	10309	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10309	5	.	.	.
18637	10310	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10310	2	411	411	CD
18637	10310	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10310	4	330	330	CD
18637	10310	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10310	6	258	258	CD
18637	10310	7	.	.	.
18637	10311	1	Here	here	RB
18637	10311	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10311	3	was	be	VBD
18637	10311	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	10311	5	that	that	IN
18637	10311	6	the	the	DT
18637	10311	7	Norris	Norris	NNP
18637	10311	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	10311	9	LaGuardia	LaGuardia	NNP
18637	10311	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10311	11	did	do	VBD
18637	10311	12	not	not	RB
18637	10311	13	apply	apply	VB
18637	10311	14	to	to	IN
18637	10311	15	a	a	DT
18637	10311	16	case	case	NN
18637	10311	17	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10311	18	by	by	IN
18637	10311	19	the	the	DT
18637	10311	20	government	government	NN
18637	10311	21	as	as	IN
18637	10311	22	operator	operator	NN
18637	10311	23	,	,	,
18637	10311	24	under	under	IN
18637	10311	25	the	the	DT
18637	10311	26	War	War	NNP
18637	10311	27	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	10311	28	Disputes	Disputes	NNP
18637	10311	29	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10311	30	of	of	IN
18637	10311	31	1943	1943	CD
18637	10311	32	,	,	,
18637	10311	33	of	of	IN
18637	10311	34	a	a	DT
18637	10311	35	large	large	JJ
18637	10311	36	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	10311	37	of	of	IN
18637	10311	38	the	the	DT
18637	10311	39	nation	nation	NN
18637	10311	40	's	's	POS
18637	10311	41	soft	soft	JJ
18637	10311	42	coal	coal	NN
18637	10311	43	mines	mine	NNS
18637	10311	44	.	.	.
18637	10312	1	In	in	IN
18637	10312	2	reaching	reach	VBG
18637	10312	3	this	this	DT
18637	10312	4	result	result	NN
18637	10312	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10312	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10312	7	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	10312	8	invoked	invoke	VBD
18637	10312	9	the	the	DT
18637	10312	10	"	"	``
18637	10312	11	rule	rule	NN
18637	10312	12	that	that	IN
18637	10312	13	statutes	statute	VBZ
18637	10312	14	which	which	WDT
18637	10312	15	in	in	IN
18637	10312	16	general	general	JJ
18637	10312	17	terms	term	NNS
18637	10312	18	divest	divest	VBP
18637	10312	19	preexisting	preexisting	NN
18637	10312	20	rights	right	NNS
18637	10312	21	or	or	CC
18637	10312	22	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	10312	23	will	will	MD
18637	10312	24	not	not	RB
18637	10312	25	be	be	VB
18637	10312	26	applied	apply	VBN
18637	10312	27	to	to	IN
18637	10312	28	the	the	DT
18637	10312	29	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	10312	30	without	without	IN
18637	10312	31	express	express	JJ
18637	10312	32	words	word	NNS
18637	10312	33	to	to	IN
18637	10312	34	that	that	DT
18637	10312	35	effect	effect	NN
18637	10312	36	.	.	.
18637	10312	37	"	"	''
18637	10313	1	Standing	stand	VBG
18637	10313	2	by	by	IN
18637	10313	3	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10313	4	these	these	DT
18637	10313	5	words	word	NNS
18637	10313	6	would	would	MD
18637	10313	7	seem	seem	VB
18637	10313	8	to	to	TO
18637	10313	9	save	save	VB
18637	10313	10	the	the	DT
18637	10313	11	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	10313	12	case	case	NN
18637	10313	13	.	.	.
18637	10314	1	But	but	CC
18637	10314	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10314	3	do	do	VBP
18637	10314	4	not	not	RB
18637	10314	5	stand	stand	VB
18637	10314	6	by	by	IN
18637	10314	7	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10314	8	,	,	,
18637	10314	9	for	for	IN
18637	10314	10	the	the	DT
18637	10314	11	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10314	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10314	13	presently	presently	RB
18637	10314	14	added	add	VBD
18637	10314	15	"	"	''
18637	10314	16	that	that	IN
18637	10314	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10314	18	,	,	,
18637	10314	19	in	in	IN
18637	10314	20	passing	pass	VBG
18637	10314	21	the	the	DT
18637	10314	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10314	23	Norris	Norris	NNP
18637	10314	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	10314	25	LaGuardia	LaGuardia	NNP
18637	10314	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10314	27	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10314	28	,	,	,
18637	10314	29	did	do	VBD
18637	10314	30	not	not	RB
18637	10314	31	intend	intend	VB
18637	10314	32	to	to	TO
18637	10314	33	permit	permit	VB
18637	10314	34	the	the	DT
18637	10314	35	United	United	NNP
18637	10314	36	States	States	NNP
18637	10314	37	to	to	TO
18637	10314	38	continue	continue	VB
18637	10314	39	to	to	TO
18637	10314	40	intervene	intervene	VB
18637	10314	41	by	by	IN
18637	10314	42	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	10314	43	in	in	IN
18637	10314	44	purely	purely	RB
18637	10314	45	private	private	JJ
18637	10314	46	labor	labor	NN
18637	10314	47	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	10314	48	.	.	.
18637	10315	1	*	*	NFP
18637	10315	2	*	*	NFP
18637	10315	3	*	*	NFP
18637	10315	4	where	where	WRB
18637	10315	5	some	some	DT
18637	10315	6	public	public	JJ
18637	10315	7	interest	interest	NN
18637	10315	8	was	be	VBD
18637	10315	9	thought	think	VBN
18637	10315	10	to	to	TO
18637	10315	11	have	have	VB
18637	10315	12	become	become	VBN
18637	10315	13	involved	involve	VBN
18637	10315	14	,	,	,
18637	10315	15	"	"	''
18637	10315	16	words	word	NNS
18637	10315	17	which	which	WDT
18637	10315	18	seem	seem	VBP
18637	10315	19	intended	intend	VBN
18637	10315	20	to	to	TO
18637	10315	21	repudiate	repudiate	VB
18637	10315	22	the	the	DT
18637	10315	23	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	10315	24	case	case	NN
18637	10315	25	.	.	.
18637	10316	1	However	however	RB
18637	10316	2	,	,	,
18637	10316	3	the	the	DT
18637	10316	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10316	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10316	6	goes	go	VBZ
18637	10316	7	on	on	RP
18637	10316	8	at	at	IN
18637	10316	9	once	once	RB
18637	10316	10	to	to	TO
18637	10316	11	say	say	VB
18637	10316	12	,	,	,
18637	10316	13	"	"	''
18637	10316	14	*	*	NFP
18637	10316	15	*	*	NFP
18637	10316	16	*	*	NFP
18637	10316	17	whether	whether	IN
18637	10316	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10316	19	so	so	RB
18637	10316	20	intended	intend	VBD
18637	10316	21	or	or	CC
18637	10316	22	not	not	RB
18637	10316	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	10316	24	a	a	DT
18637	10316	25	question	question	NN
18637	10316	26	different	different	JJ
18637	10316	27	from	from	IN
18637	10316	28	the	the	DT
18637	10316	29	one	one	NN
18637	10316	30	before	before	IN
18637	10316	31	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10316	32	now	now	RB
18637	10316	33	.	.	.
18637	10316	34	"	"	''
18637	10317	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	10317	2	.	.	.
18637	10318	1	272	272	CD
18637	10318	2	,	,	,
18637	10318	3	278	278	CD
18637	10318	4	.	.	.
18637	10319	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10319	2	412	412	CD
18637	10319	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10319	4	Public	Public	NNP
18637	10319	5	Law	Law	NNP
18637	10319	6	101	101	CD
18637	10319	7	,	,	,
18637	10319	8	80th	80th	NNP
18637	10319	9	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	10319	10	.	.	NNP
18637	10319	11	,	,	,
18637	10319	12	1st	1st	JJ
18637	10319	13	sess	sess	NN
18637	10319	14	.	.	.
18637	10319	15	,	,	,
18637	10319	16	§§	§§	NNP
18637	10319	17	206	206	CD
18637	10319	18	-	-	SYM
18637	10319	19	210	210	CD
18637	10319	20	.	.	.
18637	10320	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10320	2	413	413	CD
18637	10320	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10320	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10320	5	See	See	NNP
18637	10320	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10320	7	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	10320	8	Stark	Stark	NNP
18637	10320	9	in	in	IN
18637	10320	10	New	New	NNP
18637	10320	11	York	York	NNP
18637	10320	12	Times	Times	NNP
18637	10320	13	,	,	,
18637	10320	14	February	February	NNP
18637	10320	15	4	4	CD
18637	10320	16	,	,	,
18637	10320	17	1949	1949	CD
18637	10320	18	;	;	:
18637	10320	19	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	10320	20	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	10320	21	,	,	,
18637	10320	22	Hearings	Hearings	NNPS
18637	10320	23	before	before	IN
18637	10320	24	the	the	DT
18637	10320	25	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	10320	26	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	10320	27	on	on	IN
18637	10320	28	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	10320	29	and	and	CC
18637	10320	30	Public	Public	NNP
18637	10320	31	Welfare	Welfare	NNP
18637	10320	32	on	on	IN
18637	10320	33	S.	S.	NNP
18637	10320	34	249	249	CD
18637	10320	35	,	,	,
18637	10320	36	81st	81st	NNP
18637	10320	37	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	10320	38	.	.	NNP
18637	10320	39	,	,	,
18637	10320	40	1st	1st	NNP
18637	10320	41	sess	sess	NN
18637	10320	42	.	.	.
18637	10320	43	,	,	,
18637	10320	44	pp	pp	NNP
18637	10320	45	.	.	.
18637	10321	1	263	263	CD
18637	10321	2	,	,	,
18637	10321	3	285	285	CD
18637	10321	4	,	,	,
18637	10321	5	295	295	CD
18637	10321	6	,	,	,
18637	10321	7	905	905	CD
18637	10321	8	,	,	,
18637	10321	9	911	911	CD
18637	10321	10	;	;	:
18637	10321	11	Julius	Julius	NNP
18637	10321	12	and	and	CC
18637	10321	13	Lillian	Lillian	NNP
18637	10321	14	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
18637	10321	15	,	,	,
18637	10321	16	The	the	DT
18637	10321	17	Divine	Divine	NNP
18637	10321	18	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	10321	19	of	of	IN
18637	10321	20	Presidents	Presidents	NNPS
18637	10321	21	,	,	,
18637	10321	22	29	29	CD
18637	10321	23	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	10321	24	Law	Law	NNP
18637	10321	25	Review	Review	NNP
18637	10321	26	,	,	,
18637	10321	27	p.	p.	NN
18637	10321	28	416	416	CD
18637	10321	29	,	,	,
18637	10321	30	March	March	NNP
18637	10321	31	1950	1950	CD
18637	10321	32	.	.	.
18637	10322	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10322	2	414	414	CD
18637	10322	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10322	4	30	30	CD
18637	10322	5	Op	op	NN
18637	10322	6	.	.	.
18637	10323	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	10323	2	.	.	.
18637	10324	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	10324	2	291	291	CD
18637	10324	3	,	,	,
18637	10324	4	292	292	CD
18637	10324	5	,	,	,
18637	10324	6	293	293	CD
18637	10324	7	.	.	.
18637	10325	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10325	2	415	415	CD
18637	10325	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10325	4	Durand	Durand	NNP
18637	10325	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10325	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10325	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10325	8	Hollins	Hollins	NNP
18637	10325	9	,	,	,
18637	10325	10	4	4	CD
18637	10325	11	Blatch	Blatch	NNP
18637	10325	12	.	.	.
18637	10326	1	451	451	CD
18637	10326	2	,	,	,
18637	10326	3	454	454	CD
18637	10326	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10326	5	1860	1860	CD
18637	10326	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10326	7	.	.	.
18637	10327	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10327	2	416	416	CD
18637	10327	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10327	4	Published	publish	VBN
18637	10327	5	by	by	IN
18637	10327	6	World	World	NNP
18637	10327	7	Peace	Peace	NNP
18637	10327	8	Foundation	Foundation	NNP
18637	10327	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10327	10	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	10327	11	,	,	,
18637	10327	12	1945	1945	CD
18637	10327	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10327	14	_	_	NNP
18637	10327	15	See	See	NNP
18637	10327	16	also	also	RB
18637	10327	17	_	_	NNP
18637	10327	18	,	,	,
18637	10327	19	for	for	IN
18637	10327	20	the	the	DT
18637	10327	21	period	period	NN
18637	10327	22	1811	1811	CD
18637	10327	23	to	to	IN
18637	10327	24	1934	1934	CD
18637	10327	25	,	,	,
18637	10327	26	J.	J.	NNP
18637	10327	27	Reuben	Reuben	NNP
18637	10327	28	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	10327	29	's	's	POS
18637	10327	30	Memorandum	Memorandum	NNP
18637	10327	31	as	as	IN
18637	10327	32	Solicitor	Solicitor	NNP
18637	10327	33	of	of	IN
18637	10327	34	the	the	DT
18637	10327	35	Department	Department	NNP
18637	10327	36	of	of	IN
18637	10327	37	State	State	NNP
18637	10327	38	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	10327	39	Right	right	UH
18637	10327	40	to	to	IN
18637	10327	41	Protect	protect	VB
18637	10327	42	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	10327	43	in	in	IN
18637	10327	44	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	10327	45	Countries	country	NNS
18637	10327	46	by	by	IN
18637	10327	47	Landing	Landing	NNP
18637	10327	48	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	10327	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10327	50	Government	Government	NNP
18637	10327	51	Printing	Printing	NNP
18637	10327	52	Office	Office	NNP
18637	10327	53	,	,	,
18637	10327	54	1912	1912	CD
18637	10327	55	,	,	,
18637	10327	56	1934	1934	CD
18637	10327	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10327	58	.	.	.
18637	10328	1	The	the	DT
18637	10328	2	great	great	JJ
18637	10328	3	majority	majority	NN
18637	10328	4	of	of	IN
18637	10328	5	the	the	DT
18637	10328	6	landings	landing	NNS
18637	10328	7	were	be	VBD
18637	10328	8	for	for	IN
18637	10328	9	"	"	``
18637	10328	10	the	the	DT
18637	10328	11	simple	simple	JJ
18637	10328	12	protection	protection	NN
18637	10328	13	of	of	IN
18637	10328	14	American	american	JJ
18637	10328	15	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	10328	16	in	in	IN
18637	10328	17	disturbed	disturb	VBN
18637	10328	18	areas	area	NNS
18637	10328	19	,	,	,
18637	10328	20	"	"	''
18637	10328	21	and	and	CC
18637	10328	22	only	only	RB
18637	10328	23	about	about	RB
18637	10328	24	a	a	DT
18637	10328	25	third	third	JJ
18637	10328	26	involved	involved	JJ
18637	10328	27	belligerent	belligerent	NN
18637	10328	28	action	action	NN
18637	10328	29	.	.	.
18637	10329	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10329	2	417	417	CD
18637	10329	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10329	4	5	5	CD
18637	10329	5	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	10329	6	,	,	,
18637	10329	7	International	International	NNP
18637	10329	8	Law	Law	NNP
18637	10329	9	Digest	Digest	NNP
18637	10329	10	,	,	,
18637	10329	11	478	478	CD
18637	10329	12	-	-	SYM
18637	10329	13	510	510	CD
18637	10329	14	,	,	,
18637	10329	15	_	_	NNP
18637	10329	16	passim	passim	NN
18637	10329	17	_	_	NNP
18637	10329	18	.	.	.
18637	10330	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10330	2	418	418	CD
18637	10330	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10330	4	A	A	NNP
18637	10330	5	Decade	Decade	NNP
18637	10330	6	of	of	IN
18637	10330	7	American	American	NNP
18637	10330	8	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	10330	9	Policy	Policy	NNP
18637	10330	10	,	,	,
18637	10330	11	S.	S.	NNP
18637	10330	12	Doc	Doc	NNP
18637	10330	13	.	.	.
18637	10331	1	123	123	CD
18637	10331	2	,	,	,
18637	10331	3	81st	81st	NNP
18637	10331	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	10331	5	.	.	NNP
18637	10331	6	,	,	,
18637	10331	7	1st	1st	NNP
18637	10331	8	Sess	Sess	NNP
18637	10331	9	.	.	NNP
18637	10331	10	,	,	,
18637	10331	11	p.	p.	NN
18637	10331	12	1347	1347	CD
18637	10331	13	.	.	.
18637	10332	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10332	2	419	419	CD
18637	10332	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10332	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10332	5	See	See	NNP
18637	10332	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10332	7	Max	Max	NNP
18637	10332	8	Farrand	Farrand	NNP
18637	10332	9	,	,	,
18637	10332	10	Records	Records	NNP
18637	10332	11	,	,	,
18637	10332	12	II	II	NNP
18637	10332	13	,	,	,
18637	10332	14	318	318	CD
18637	10332	15	-	-	SYM
18637	10332	16	319	319	CD
18637	10332	17	.	.	.
18637	10333	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10333	2	420	420	CD
18637	10333	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10333	4	Youngstown	Youngstown	NNP
18637	10333	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10333	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10333	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10333	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10333	9	Sawyer	Sawyer	NNP
18637	10333	10	,	,	,
18637	10333	11	343	343	CD
18637	10333	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10333	13	579	579	CD
18637	10333	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10333	15	1952	1952	CD
18637	10333	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10333	17	.	.	.
18637	10334	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10334	2	421	421	CD
18637	10334	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10334	4	17	17	CD
18637	10334	5	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	10334	6	.	.	.
18637	10335	1	Reg	reg	NN
18637	10335	2	.	.	.
18637	10336	1	3139	3139	CD
18637	10336	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10336	3	3143	3143	CD
18637	10336	4	.	.	.
18637	10337	1	"	"	``
18637	10337	2	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	10337	3	on	on	IN
18637	10337	4	December	December	NNP
18637	10337	5	16	16	CD
18637	10337	6	,	,	,
18637	10337	7	1950	1950	CD
18637	10337	8	,	,	,
18637	10337	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10337	10	proclaimed	proclaim	VBD
18637	10337	11	the	the	DT
18637	10337	12	existence	existence	NN
18637	10337	13	of	of	IN
18637	10337	14	a	a	DT
18637	10337	15	national	national	JJ
18637	10337	16	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	10337	17	which	which	WDT
18637	10337	18	requires	require	VBZ
18637	10337	19	that	that	IN
18637	10337	20	the	the	DT
18637	10337	21	military	military	NN
18637	10337	22	,	,	,
18637	10337	23	naval	naval	JJ
18637	10337	24	,	,	,
18637	10337	25	air	air	NN
18637	10337	26	,	,	,
18637	10337	27	and	and	CC
18637	10337	28	civilian	civilian	JJ
18637	10337	29	defenses	defense	NNS
18637	10337	30	of	of	IN
18637	10337	31	this	this	DT
18637	10337	32	country	country	NN
18637	10337	33	be	be	VB
18637	10337	34	strengthened	strengthen	VBN
18637	10337	35	as	as	RB
18637	10337	36	speedily	speedily	RB
18637	10337	37	as	as	IN
18637	10337	38	possible	possible	JJ
18637	10337	39	to	to	IN
18637	10337	40	the	the	DT
18637	10337	41	end	end	NN
18637	10337	42	that	that	WDT
18637	10337	43	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10337	44	may	may	MD
18637	10337	45	be	be	VB
18637	10337	46	able	able	JJ
18637	10337	47	to	to	TO
18637	10337	48	repel	repel	VB
18637	10337	49	any	any	DT
18637	10337	50	and	and	CC
18637	10337	51	all	all	DT
18637	10337	52	threats	threat	NNS
18637	10337	53	against	against	IN
18637	10337	54	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10337	55	national	national	JJ
18637	10337	56	security	security	NN
18637	10337	57	and	and	CC
18637	10337	58	to	to	TO
18637	10337	59	fulfill	fulfill	VB
18637	10337	60	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10337	61	responsibilities	responsibility	NNS
18637	10337	62	in	in	IN
18637	10337	63	the	the	DT
18637	10337	64	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	10337	65	being	be	VBG
18637	10337	66	made	make	VBN
18637	10337	67	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	10337	68	the	the	DT
18637	10337	69	United	United	NNP
18637	10337	70	Nations	Nations	NNP
18637	10337	71	and	and	CC
18637	10337	72	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	10337	73	to	to	TO
18637	10337	74	bring	bring	VB
18637	10337	75	about	about	RP
18637	10337	76	a	a	DT
18637	10337	77	lasting	last	VBG
18637	10337	78	peace	peace	NN
18637	10337	79	;	;	:
18637	10337	80	and	and	CC
18637	10337	81	"	"	``
18637	10337	82	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	10337	83	American	american	JJ
18637	10337	84	fighting	fight	VBG
18637	10337	85	men	man	NNS
18637	10337	86	and	and	CC
18637	10337	87	fighting	fight	VBG
18637	10337	88	men	man	NNS
18637	10337	89	of	of	IN
18637	10337	90	other	other	JJ
18637	10337	91	nations	nation	NNS
18637	10337	92	of	of	IN
18637	10337	93	the	the	DT
18637	10337	94	United	United	NNP
18637	10337	95	Nations	Nations	NNPS
18637	10337	96	are	be	VBP
18637	10337	97	now	now	RB
18637	10337	98	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	10337	99	in	in	IN
18637	10337	100	deadly	deadly	JJ
18637	10337	101	combat	combat	NN
18637	10337	102	with	with	IN
18637	10337	103	the	the	DT
18637	10337	104	forces	force	NNS
18637	10337	105	of	of	IN
18637	10337	106	aggression	aggression	NN
18637	10337	107	in	in	IN
18637	10337	108	Korea	Korea	NNP
18637	10337	109	,	,	,
18637	10337	110	and	and	CC
18637	10337	111	forces	force	NNS
18637	10337	112	of	of	IN
18637	10337	113	the	the	DT
18637	10337	114	United	United	NNP
18637	10337	115	States	States	NNP
18637	10337	116	are	be	VBP
18637	10337	117	stationed	station	VBN
18637	10337	118	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	10337	119	overseas	overseas	RB
18637	10337	120	for	for	IN
18637	10337	121	the	the	DT
18637	10337	122	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	10337	123	of	of	IN
18637	10337	124	participating	participate	VBG
18637	10337	125	in	in	IN
18637	10337	126	the	the	DT
18637	10337	127	defense	defense	NN
18637	10337	128	of	of	IN
18637	10337	129	the	the	DT
18637	10337	130	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	10337	131	Community	Community	NNP
18637	10337	132	against	against	IN
18637	10337	133	aggression	aggression	NN
18637	10337	134	;	;	:
18637	10337	135	and	and	CC
18637	10337	136	"	"	``
18637	10337	137	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	10337	138	the	the	DT
18637	10337	139	weapons	weapon	NNS
18637	10337	140	and	and	CC
18637	10337	141	other	other	JJ
18637	10337	142	materials	material	NNS
18637	10337	143	needed	need	VBN
18637	10337	144	by	by	IN
18637	10337	145	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10337	146	armed	armed	JJ
18637	10337	147	forces	force	NNS
18637	10337	148	and	and	CC
18637	10337	149	by	by	IN
18637	10337	150	those	those	DT
18637	10337	151	joined	join	VBN
18637	10337	152	with	with	IN
18637	10337	153	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10337	154	in	in	IN
18637	10337	155	the	the	DT
18637	10337	156	defense	defense	NN
18637	10337	157	of	of	IN
18637	10337	158	the	the	DT
18637	10337	159	free	free	JJ
18637	10337	160	world	world	NN
18637	10337	161	are	be	VBP
18637	10337	162	produced	produce	VBN
18637	10337	163	to	to	IN
18637	10337	164	a	a	DT
18637	10337	165	great	great	JJ
18637	10337	166	extent	extent	NN
18637	10337	167	in	in	IN
18637	10337	168	this	this	DT
18637	10337	169	country	country	NN
18637	10337	170	,	,	,
18637	10337	171	and	and	CC
18637	10337	172	steel	steel	NN
18637	10337	173	is	be	VBZ
18637	10337	174	an	an	DT
18637	10337	175	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
18637	10337	176	component	component	NN
18637	10337	177	of	of	IN
18637	10337	178	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	10337	179	all	all	DT
18637	10337	180	of	of	IN
18637	10337	181	such	such	JJ
18637	10337	182	weapons	weapon	NNS
18637	10337	183	and	and	CC
18637	10337	184	materials	material	NNS
18637	10337	185	;	;	,
18637	10337	186	and	and	CC
18637	10337	187	"	"	``
18637	10337	188	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	10337	189	steel	steel	NN
18637	10337	190	is	be	VBZ
18637	10337	191	likewise	likewise	RB
18637	10337	192	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
18637	10337	193	to	to	IN
18637	10337	194	the	the	DT
18637	10337	195	carrying	carrying	NN
18637	10337	196	out	out	IN
18637	10337	197	of	of	IN
18637	10337	198	programs	program	NNS
18637	10337	199	of	of	IN
18637	10337	200	the	the	DT
18637	10337	201	Atomic	Atomic	NNP
18637	10337	202	Energy	Energy	NNP
18637	10337	203	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	10337	204	of	of	IN
18637	10337	205	vital	vital	JJ
18637	10337	206	importance	importance	NN
18637	10337	207	to	to	IN
18637	10337	208	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10337	209	defense	defense	NN
18637	10337	210	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	10337	211	;	;	:
18637	10337	212	and	and	CC
18637	10337	213	"	"	``
18637	10337	214	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	10337	215	a	a	DT
18637	10337	216	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	10337	217	and	and	CC
18637	10337	218	uninterrupted	uninterrupted	JJ
18637	10337	219	supply	supply	NN
18637	10337	220	of	of	IN
18637	10337	221	steel	steel	NN
18637	10337	222	is	be	VBZ
18637	10337	223	also	also	RB
18637	10337	224	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
18637	10337	225	to	to	IN
18637	10337	226	the	the	DT
18637	10337	227	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	10337	228	of	of	IN
18637	10337	229	the	the	DT
18637	10337	230	economy	economy	NN
18637	10337	231	of	of	IN
18637	10337	232	the	the	DT
18637	10337	233	United	United	NNP
18637	10337	234	States	States	NNP
18637	10337	235	,	,	,
18637	10337	236	upon	upon	IN
18637	10337	237	which	which	WDT
18637	10337	238	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10337	239	military	military	JJ
18637	10337	240	strength	strength	NN
18637	10337	241	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	10337	242	;	;	:
18637	10337	243	and	and	CC
18637	10337	244	"	"	``
18637	10337	245	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	10337	246	a	a	DT
18637	10337	247	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10337	248	has	have	VBZ
18637	10337	249	arisen	arise	VBN
18637	10337	250	between	between	IN
18637	10337	251	certain	certain	JJ
18637	10337	252	companies	company	NNS
18637	10337	253	in	in	IN
18637	10337	254	the	the	DT
18637	10337	255	United	United	NNP
18637	10337	256	States	States	NNP
18637	10337	257	producing	produce	VBG
18637	10337	258	and	and	CC
18637	10337	259	fabricating	fabricate	VBG
18637	10337	260	steel	steel	NN
18637	10337	261	and	and	CC
18637	10337	262	the	the	DT
18637	10337	263	elements	element	NNS
18637	10337	264	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	10337	265	and	and	CC
18637	10337	266	certain	certain	JJ
18637	10337	267	of	of	IN
18637	10337	268	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10337	269	workers	worker	NNS
18637	10337	270	represented	represent	VBN
18637	10337	271	by	by	IN
18637	10337	272	the	the	DT
18637	10337	273	United	United	NNP
18637	10337	274	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	10337	275	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	10337	276	of	of	IN
18637	10337	277	America	America	NNP
18637	10337	278	,	,	,
18637	10337	279	CIO	CIO	NNP
18637	10337	280	,	,	,
18637	10337	281	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	10337	282	terms	term	NNS
18637	10337	283	and	and	CC
18637	10337	284	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	10337	285	of	of	IN
18637	10337	286	employment	employment	NN
18637	10337	287	;	;	:
18637	10337	288	and	and	CC
18637	10337	289	"	"	``
18637	10337	290	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	10337	291	the	the	DT
18637	10337	292	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10337	293	has	have	VBZ
18637	10337	294	not	not	RB
18637	10337	295	been	be	VBN
18637	10337	296	settled	settle	VBN
18637	10337	297	through	through	IN
18637	10337	298	the	the	DT
18637	10337	299	processes	process	NNS
18637	10337	300	of	of	IN
18637	10337	301	collective	collective	JJ
18637	10337	302	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	10337	303	or	or	CC
18637	10337	304	through	through	IN
18637	10337	305	the	the	DT
18637	10337	306	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	10337	307	of	of	IN
18637	10337	308	the	the	DT
18637	10337	309	Government	Government	NNP
18637	10337	310	,	,	,
18637	10337	311	including	include	VBG
18637	10337	312	those	those	DT
18637	10337	313	of	of	IN
18637	10337	314	the	the	DT
18637	10337	315	Wage	Wage	NNP
18637	10337	316	Stabilization	Stabilization	NNP
18637	10337	317	Board	Board	NNP
18637	10337	318	,	,	,
18637	10337	319	to	to	TO
18637	10337	320	which	which	WDT
18637	10337	321	the	the	DT
18637	10337	322	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10337	323	was	be	VBD
18637	10337	324	referred	refer	VBN
18637	10337	325	on	on	IN
18637	10337	326	December	December	NNP
18637	10337	327	22	22	CD
18637	10337	328	,	,	,
18637	10337	329	1951	1951	CD
18637	10337	330	,	,	,
18637	10337	331	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	10337	332	to	to	IN
18637	10337	333	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	10337	334	Order	Order	NNP
18637	10337	335	No	no	UH
18637	10337	336	.	.	.
18637	10338	1	10233	10233	CD
18637	10338	2	,	,	,
18637	10338	3	and	and	CC
18637	10338	4	a	a	DT
18637	10338	5	strike	strike	NN
18637	10338	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	10338	7	been	be	VBN
18637	10338	8	called	call	VBN
18637	10338	9	for	for	IN
18637	10338	10	12:01	12:01	CD
18637	10338	11	A.M.	A.M.	NNP
18637	10338	12	,	,	,
18637	10338	13	April	April	NNP
18637	10338	14	9	9	CD
18637	10338	15	,	,	,
18637	10338	16	1952	1952	CD
18637	10338	17	;	;	:
18637	10338	18	and	and	CC
18637	10338	19	"	"	``
18637	10338	20	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	10338	21	a	a	DT
18637	10338	22	work	work	NN
18637	10338	23	stoppage	stoppage	NN
18637	10338	24	would	would	MD
18637	10338	25	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	10338	26	jeopardize	jeopardize	VB
18637	10338	27	and	and	CC
18637	10338	28	imperil	imperil	VB
18637	10338	29	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10338	30	national	national	JJ
18637	10338	31	defense	defense	NN
18637	10338	32	and	and	CC
18637	10338	33	the	the	DT
18637	10338	34	defense	defense	NN
18637	10338	35	of	of	IN
18637	10338	36	those	those	DT
18637	10338	37	joined	join	VBN
18637	10338	38	with	with	IN
18637	10338	39	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10338	40	in	in	IN
18637	10338	41	resisting	resist	VBG
18637	10338	42	aggression	aggression	NN
18637	10338	43	,	,	,
18637	10338	44	and	and	CC
18637	10338	45	would	would	MD
18637	10338	46	add	add	VB
18637	10338	47	to	to	IN
18637	10338	48	the	the	DT
18637	10338	49	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	10338	50	danger	danger	NN
18637	10338	51	of	of	IN
18637	10338	52	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10338	53	soldiers	soldier	NNS
18637	10338	54	,	,	,
18637	10338	55	sailors	sailor	NNS
18637	10338	56	,	,	,
18637	10338	57	and	and	CC
18637	10338	58	airmen	airman	NNS
18637	10338	59	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	10338	60	in	in	IN
18637	10338	61	combat	combat	NN
18637	10338	62	in	in	IN
18637	10338	63	the	the	DT
18637	10338	64	field	field	NN
18637	10338	65	;	;	:
18637	10338	66	and	and	CC
18637	10338	67	"	"	``
18637	10338	68	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	10338	69	in	in	IN
18637	10338	70	order	order	NN
18637	10338	71	to	to	TO
18637	10338	72	assure	assure	VB
18637	10338	73	the	the	DT
18637	10338	74	continued	continued	JJ
18637	10338	75	availability	availability	NN
18637	10338	76	of	of	IN
18637	10338	77	steel	steel	NN
18637	10338	78	and	and	CC
18637	10338	79	steel	steel	NN
18637	10338	80	products	product	NNS
18637	10338	81	during	during	IN
18637	10338	82	the	the	DT
18637	10338	83	existing	exist	VBG
18637	10338	84	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	10338	85	,	,	,
18637	10338	86	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10338	87	is	be	VBZ
18637	10338	88	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10338	89	that	that	IN
18637	10338	90	the	the	DT
18637	10338	91	United	United	NNP
18637	10338	92	States	States	NNP
18637	10338	93	take	take	VBP
18637	10338	94	possession	possession	NN
18637	10338	95	of	of	IN
18637	10338	96	and	and	CC
18637	10338	97	operate	operate	VB
18637	10338	98	the	the	DT
18637	10338	99	plants	plant	NNS
18637	10338	100	,	,	,
18637	10338	101	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	10338	102	,	,	,
18637	10338	103	and	and	CC
18637	10338	104	other	other	JJ
18637	10338	105	property	property	NN
18637	10338	106	of	of	IN
18637	10338	107	the	the	DT
18637	10338	108	said	say	VBN
18637	10338	109	companies	company	NNS
18637	10338	110	as	as	IN
18637	10338	111	hereinafter	hereinafter	NN
18637	10338	112	provided	provide	VBD
18637	10338	113	:	:	:
18637	10338	114	"	"	``
18637	10338	115	Now	now	RB
18637	10338	116	,	,	,
18637	10338	117	Therefore	therefore	RB
18637	10338	118	,	,	,
18637	10338	119	by	by	IN
18637	10338	120	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	10338	121	of	of	IN
18637	10338	122	the	the	DT
18637	10338	123	authority	authority	NN
18637	10338	124	vested	vest	VBN
18637	10338	125	in	in	IN
18637	10338	126	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10338	127	by	by	IN
18637	10338	128	the	the	DT
18637	10338	129	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10338	130	and	and	CC
18637	10338	131	laws	law	NNS
18637	10338	132	of	of	IN
18637	10338	133	the	the	DT
18637	10338	134	United	United	NNP
18637	10338	135	States	States	NNP
18637	10338	136	,	,	,
18637	10338	137	and	and	CC
18637	10338	138	as	as	IN
18637	10338	139	President	President	NNP
18637	10338	140	of	of	IN
18637	10338	141	the	the	DT
18637	10338	142	United	United	NNP
18637	10338	143	States	States	NNP
18637	10338	144	and	and	CC
18637	10338	145	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	10338	146	in	in	IN
18637	10338	147	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10338	148	of	of	IN
18637	10338	149	the	the	DT
18637	10338	150	armed	armed	JJ
18637	10338	151	forces	force	NNS
18637	10338	152	of	of	IN
18637	10338	153	the	the	DT
18637	10338	154	United	United	NNP
18637	10338	155	States	States	NNP
18637	10338	156	,	,	,
18637	10338	157	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10338	158	is	be	VBZ
18637	10338	159	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	10338	160	ordered	order	VBN
18637	10338	161	as	as	IN
18637	10338	162	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	10338	163	:	:	:
18637	10338	164	"	"	``
18637	10338	165	1	1	CD
18637	10338	166	.	.	.
18637	10339	1	The	the	DT
18637	10339	2	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10339	3	of	of	IN
18637	10339	4	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10339	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	10339	6	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	10339	7	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	10339	8	and	and	CC
18637	10339	9	directed	direct	VBN
18637	10339	10	to	to	TO
18637	10339	11	take	take	VB
18637	10339	12	possession	possession	NN
18637	10339	13	of	of	IN
18637	10339	14	all	all	DT
18637	10339	15	or	or	CC
18637	10339	16	such	such	JJ
18637	10339	17	of	of	IN
18637	10339	18	the	the	DT
18637	10339	19	plants	plant	NNS
18637	10339	20	,	,	,
18637	10339	21	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	10339	22	,	,	,
18637	10339	23	and	and	CC
18637	10339	24	other	other	JJ
18637	10339	25	property	property	NN
18637	10339	26	of	of	IN
18637	10339	27	the	the	DT
18637	10339	28	companies	company	NNS
18637	10339	29	named	name	VBN
18637	10339	30	in	in	IN
18637	10339	31	the	the	DT
18637	10339	32	list	list	NN
18637	10339	33	attached	attach	VBD
18637	10339	34	hereto	hereto	NNP
18637	10339	35	,	,	,
18637	10339	36	or	or	CC
18637	10339	37	any	any	DT
18637	10339	38	part	part	NN
18637	10339	39	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	10339	40	,	,	,
18637	10339	41	as	as	IN
18637	10339	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10339	43	may	may	MD
18637	10339	44	deem	deem	VB
18637	10339	45	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10339	46	in	in	IN
18637	10339	47	the	the	DT
18637	10339	48	interests	interest	NNS
18637	10339	49	of	of	IN
18637	10339	50	national	national	JJ
18637	10339	51	defense	defense	NN
18637	10339	52	;	;	:
18637	10339	53	and	and	CC
18637	10339	54	to	to	TO
18637	10339	55	operate	operate	VB
18637	10339	56	or	or	CC
18637	10339	57	to	to	TO
18637	10339	58	arrange	arrange	VB
18637	10339	59	for	for	IN
18637	10339	60	the	the	DT
18637	10339	61	operation	operation	NN
18637	10339	62	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	10339	63	and	and	CC
18637	10339	64	to	to	TO
18637	10339	65	do	do	VB
18637	10339	66	all	all	DT
18637	10339	67	things	thing	NNS
18637	10339	68	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10339	69	for	for	IN
18637	10339	70	,	,	,
18637	10339	71	or	or	CC
18637	10339	72	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	10339	73	to	to	IN
18637	10339	74	,	,	,
18637	10339	75	such	such	JJ
18637	10339	76	operation	operation	NN
18637	10339	77	.	.	.
18637	10340	1	"	"	``
18637	10340	2	2	2	CD
18637	10340	3	.	.	.
18637	10341	1	In	in	IN
18637	10341	2	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	10341	3	out	out	RP
18637	10341	4	this	this	DT
18637	10341	5	order	order	NN
18637	10341	6	the	the	DT
18637	10341	7	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10341	8	of	of	IN
18637	10341	9	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10341	10	may	may	MD
18637	10341	11	act	act	VB
18637	10341	12	through	through	IN
18637	10341	13	or	or	CC
18637	10341	14	with	with	IN
18637	10341	15	the	the	DT
18637	10341	16	aid	aid	NN
18637	10341	17	of	of	IN
18637	10341	18	such	such	JJ
18637	10341	19	public	public	JJ
18637	10341	20	or	or	CC
18637	10341	21	private	private	JJ
18637	10341	22	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	10341	23	or	or	CC
18637	10341	24	persons	person	NNS
18637	10341	25	as	as	IN
18637	10341	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10341	27	may	may	MD
18637	10341	28	designate	designate	VB
18637	10341	29	;	;	:
18637	10341	30	and	and	CC
18637	10341	31	all	all	DT
18637	10341	32	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10341	33	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	10341	34	shall	shall	MD
18637	10341	35	cooperate	cooperate	VB
18637	10341	36	with	with	IN
18637	10341	37	the	the	DT
18637	10341	38	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10341	39	of	of	IN
18637	10341	40	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10341	41	to	to	IN
18637	10341	42	the	the	DT
18637	10341	43	fullest	full	JJS
18637	10341	44	extent	extent	NN
18637	10341	45	possible	possible	JJ
18637	10341	46	in	in	IN
18637	10341	47	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	10341	48	out	out	RP
18637	10341	49	the	the	DT
18637	10341	50	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	10341	51	of	of	IN
18637	10341	52	this	this	DT
18637	10341	53	order	order	NN
18637	10341	54	.	.	.
18637	10342	1	"	"	``
18637	10342	2	3	3	CD
18637	10342	3	.	.	.
18637	10343	1	The	the	DT
18637	10343	2	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10343	3	of	of	IN
18637	10343	4	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10343	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	10343	6	determine	determine	VB
18637	10343	7	and	and	CC
18637	10343	8	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	10343	9	terms	term	NNS
18637	10343	10	and	and	CC
18637	10343	11	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	10343	12	of	of	IN
18637	10343	13	employment	employment	NN
18637	10343	14	under	under	IN
18637	10343	15	which	which	WDT
18637	10343	16	the	the	DT
18637	10343	17	plants	plant	NNS
18637	10343	18	,	,	,
18637	10343	19	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	10343	20	,	,	,
18637	10343	21	and	and	CC
18637	10343	22	other	other	JJ
18637	10343	23	properties	property	NNS
18637	10343	24	possession	possession	NN
18637	10343	25	of	of	IN
18637	10343	26	which	which	WDT
18637	10343	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	10343	28	taken	take	VBN
18637	10343	29	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	10343	30	to	to	IN
18637	10343	31	this	this	DT
18637	10343	32	order	order	NN
18637	10343	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	10343	34	be	be	VB
18637	10343	35	operated	operate	VBN
18637	10343	36	.	.	.
18637	10344	1	The	the	DT
18637	10344	2	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10344	3	of	of	IN
18637	10344	4	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10344	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	10344	6	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	10344	7	the	the	DT
18637	10344	8	rights	right	NNS
18637	10344	9	of	of	IN
18637	10344	10	workers	worker	NNS
18637	10344	11	to	to	TO
18637	10344	12	bargain	bargain	NN
18637	10344	13	collectively	collectively	RB
18637	10344	14	through	through	IN
18637	10344	15	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	10344	16	of	of	IN
18637	10344	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10344	18	own	own	JJ
18637	10344	19	choosing	choosing	NN
18637	10344	20	and	and	CC
18637	10344	21	to	to	TO
18637	10344	22	engage	engage	VB
18637	10344	23	in	in	IN
18637	10344	24	concerted	concerted	JJ
18637	10344	25	activities	activity	NNS
18637	10344	26	for	for	IN
18637	10344	27	the	the	DT
18637	10344	28	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	10344	29	of	of	IN
18637	10344	30	collective	collective	JJ
18637	10344	31	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	10344	32	,	,	,
18637	10344	33	adjustment	adjustment	NN
18637	10344	34	of	of	IN
18637	10344	35	grievances	grievance	NNS
18637	10344	36	or	or	CC
18637	10344	37	other	other	JJ
18637	10344	38	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	10344	39	aid	aid	NN
18637	10344	40	or	or	CC
18637	10344	41	protection	protection	NN
18637	10344	42	,	,	,
18637	10344	43	provided	provide	VBN
18637	10344	44	that	that	IN
18637	10344	45	such	such	JJ
18637	10344	46	activities	activity	NNS
18637	10344	47	do	do	VBP
18637	10344	48	not	not	RB
18637	10344	49	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	10344	50	with	with	IN
18637	10344	51	the	the	DT
18637	10344	52	operation	operation	NN
18637	10344	53	of	of	IN
18637	10344	54	such	such	JJ
18637	10344	55	plants	plant	NNS
18637	10344	56	,	,	,
18637	10344	57	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	10344	58	,	,	,
18637	10344	59	and	and	CC
18637	10344	60	other	other	JJ
18637	10344	61	properties	property	NNS
18637	10344	62	.	.	.
18637	10345	1	"	"	``
18637	10345	2	4	4	CD
18637	10345	3	.	.	.
18637	10346	1	Except	except	IN
18637	10346	2	so	so	RB
18637	10346	3	far	far	RB
18637	10346	4	as	as	IN
18637	10346	5	the	the	DT
18637	10346	6	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10346	7	of	of	IN
18637	10346	8	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10346	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	10346	10	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	10346	11	provide	provide	VB
18637	10346	12	from	from	IN
18637	10346	13	time	time	NN
18637	10346	14	to	to	IN
18637	10346	15	time	time	NN
18637	10346	16	,	,	,
18637	10346	17	the	the	DT
18637	10346	18	managements	management	NNS
18637	10346	19	of	of	IN
18637	10346	20	the	the	DT
18637	10346	21	plants	plant	NNS
18637	10346	22	,	,	,
18637	10346	23	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	10346	24	,	,	,
18637	10346	25	and	and	CC
18637	10346	26	other	other	JJ
18637	10346	27	properties	property	NNS
18637	10346	28	possession	possession	NN
18637	10346	29	of	of	IN
18637	10346	30	which	which	WDT
18637	10346	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	10346	32	taken	take	VBN
18637	10346	33	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	10346	34	to	to	IN
18637	10346	35	this	this	DT
18637	10346	36	order	order	NN
18637	10346	37	shall	shall	MD
18637	10346	38	continue	continue	VB
18637	10346	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10346	40	functions	function	NNS
18637	10346	41	,	,	,
18637	10346	42	including	include	VBG
18637	10346	43	the	the	DT
18637	10346	44	collection	collection	NN
18637	10346	45	and	and	CC
18637	10346	46	disbursement	disbursement	NN
18637	10346	47	of	of	IN
18637	10346	48	funds	fund	NNS
18637	10346	49	in	in	IN
18637	10346	50	the	the	DT
18637	10346	51	usual	usual	JJ
18637	10346	52	and	and	CC
18637	10346	53	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	10346	54	course	course	NN
18637	10346	55	of	of	IN
18637	10346	56	business	business	NN
18637	10346	57	in	in	IN
18637	10346	58	the	the	DT
18637	10346	59	names	name	NNS
18637	10346	60	of	of	IN
18637	10346	61	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10346	62	respective	respective	JJ
18637	10346	63	companies	company	NNS
18637	10346	64	and	and	CC
18637	10346	65	by	by	IN
18637	10346	66	means	mean	NNS
18637	10346	67	of	of	IN
18637	10346	68	any	any	DT
18637	10346	69	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	10346	70	used	use	VBN
18637	10346	71	by	by	IN
18637	10346	72	such	such	JJ
18637	10346	73	companies	company	NNS
18637	10346	74	.	.	.
18637	10347	1	"	"	``
18637	10347	2	5	5	CD
18637	10347	3	.	.	.
18637	10348	1	Except	except	IN
18637	10348	2	so	so	RB
18637	10348	3	far	far	RB
18637	10348	4	as	as	IN
18637	10348	5	the	the	DT
18637	10348	6	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10348	7	of	of	IN
18637	10348	8	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10348	9	may	may	MD
18637	10348	10	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	10348	11	direct	direct	VB
18637	10348	12	,	,	,
18637	10348	13	existing	exist	VBG
18637	10348	14	rights	right	NNS
18637	10348	15	and	and	CC
18637	10348	16	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	10348	17	of	of	IN
18637	10348	18	such	such	JJ
18637	10348	19	companies	company	NNS
18637	10348	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	10348	21	remain	remain	VB
18637	10348	22	in	in	IN
18637	10348	23	full	full	JJ
18637	10348	24	force	force	NN
18637	10348	25	and	and	CC
18637	10348	26	effect	effect	NN
18637	10348	27	,	,	,
18637	10348	28	and	and	CC
18637	10348	29	there	there	EX
18637	10348	30	may	may	MD
18637	10348	31	be	be	VB
18637	10348	32	made	make	VBN
18637	10348	33	,	,	,
18637	10348	34	in	in	IN
18637	10348	35	due	due	JJ
18637	10348	36	course	course	NN
18637	10348	37	,	,	,
18637	10348	38	payments	payment	NNS
18637	10348	39	of	of	IN
18637	10348	40	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	10348	41	on	on	IN
18637	10348	42	stock	stock	NN
18637	10348	43	,	,	,
18637	10348	44	and	and	CC
18637	10348	45	of	of	IN
18637	10348	46	principal	principal	NN
18637	10348	47	,	,	,
18637	10348	48	interest	interest	NN
18637	10348	49	,	,	,
18637	10348	50	sinking	sink	VBG
18637	10348	51	funds	fund	NNS
18637	10348	52	,	,	,
18637	10348	53	and	and	CC
18637	10348	54	all	all	DT
18637	10348	55	other	other	JJ
18637	10348	56	distributions	distribution	NNS
18637	10348	57	upon	upon	IN
18637	10348	58	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	10348	59	,	,	,
18637	10348	60	debentures	debenture	NNS
18637	10348	61	,	,	,
18637	10348	62	and	and	CC
18637	10348	63	other	other	JJ
18637	10348	64	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	10348	65	,	,	,
18637	10348	66	and	and	CC
18637	10348	67	expenditures	expenditure	NNS
18637	10348	68	may	may	MD
18637	10348	69	be	be	VB
18637	10348	70	made	make	VBN
18637	10348	71	for	for	IN
18637	10348	72	other	other	JJ
18637	10348	73	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	10348	74	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	10348	75	or	or	CC
18637	10348	76	business	business	NN
18637	10348	77	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	10348	78	.	.	.
18637	10349	1	"	"	``
18637	10349	2	6	6	CD
18637	10349	3	.	.	.
18637	10350	1	Whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	10350	2	in	in	IN
18637	10350	3	the	the	DT
18637	10350	4	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10350	5	of	of	IN
18637	10350	6	the	the	DT
18637	10350	7	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10350	8	of	of	IN
18637	10350	9	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10350	10	further	further	JJ
18637	10350	11	possession	possession	NN
18637	10350	12	and	and	CC
18637	10350	13	operation	operation	NN
18637	10350	14	by	by	IN
18637	10350	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10350	16	of	of	IN
18637	10350	17	any	any	DT
18637	10350	18	plant	plant	NN
18637	10350	19	,	,	,
18637	10350	20	facility	facility	NN
18637	10350	21	,	,	,
18637	10350	22	or	or	CC
18637	10350	23	other	other	JJ
18637	10350	24	property	property	NN
18637	10350	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	10350	26	no	no	DT
18637	10350	27	longer	long	RBR
18637	10350	28	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10350	29	or	or	CC
18637	10350	30	expedient	expedient	NN
18637	10350	31	in	in	IN
18637	10350	32	the	the	DT
18637	10350	33	interest	interest	NN
18637	10350	34	of	of	IN
18637	10350	35	national	national	JJ
18637	10350	36	defense	defense	NN
18637	10350	37	,	,	,
18637	10350	38	and	and	CC
18637	10350	39	the	the	DT
18637	10350	40	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10350	41	has	have	VBZ
18637	10350	42	reason	reason	NN
18637	10350	43	to	to	TO
18637	10350	44	believe	believe	VB
18637	10350	45	that	that	IN
18637	10350	46	effective	effective	JJ
18637	10350	47	future	future	JJ
18637	10350	48	operation	operation	NN
18637	10350	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	10350	50	assured	assure	VBN
18637	10350	51	,	,	,
18637	10350	52	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10350	53	shall	shall	MD
18637	10350	54	return	return	VB
18637	10350	55	the	the	DT
18637	10350	56	possession	possession	NN
18637	10350	57	and	and	CC
18637	10350	58	operation	operation	NN
18637	10350	59	of	of	IN
18637	10350	60	such	such	JJ
18637	10350	61	plant	plant	NN
18637	10350	62	,	,	,
18637	10350	63	facility	facility	NN
18637	10350	64	,	,	,
18637	10350	65	or	or	CC
18637	10350	66	other	other	JJ
18637	10350	67	property	property	NN
18637	10350	68	to	to	IN
18637	10350	69	the	the	DT
18637	10350	70	company	company	NN
18637	10350	71	in	in	IN
18637	10350	72	possession	possession	NN
18637	10350	73	and	and	CC
18637	10350	74	control	control	NN
18637	10350	75	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	10350	76	at	at	IN
18637	10350	77	the	the	DT
18637	10350	78	time	time	NN
18637	10350	79	possession	possession	NN
18637	10350	80	was	be	VBD
18637	10350	81	taken	take	VBN
18637	10350	82	under	under	IN
18637	10350	83	this	this	DT
18637	10350	84	order	order	NN
18637	10350	85	.	.	.
18637	10351	1	"	"	``
18637	10351	2	7	7	CD
18637	10351	3	.	.	.
18637	10352	1	The	the	DT
18637	10352	2	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10352	3	of	of	IN
18637	10352	4	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10352	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	10352	6	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	10352	7	to	to	TO
18637	10352	8	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	10352	9	and	and	CC
18637	10352	10	issue	issue	VB
18637	10352	11	such	such	JJ
18637	10352	12	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	10352	13	and	and	CC
18637	10352	14	orders	order	NNS
18637	10352	15	not	not	RB
18637	10352	16	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	10352	17	herewith	herewith	NN
18637	10352	18	as	as	IN
18637	10352	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10352	20	may	may	MD
18637	10352	21	deem	deem	VB
18637	10352	22	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10352	23	or	or	CC
18637	10352	24	desirable	desirable	JJ
18637	10352	25	for	for	IN
18637	10352	26	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	10352	27	out	out	RP
18637	10352	28	the	the	DT
18637	10352	29	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	10352	30	of	of	IN
18637	10352	31	this	this	DT
18637	10352	32	order	order	NN
18637	10352	33	;	;	:
18637	10352	34	and	and	CC
18637	10352	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10352	36	may	may	MD
18637	10352	37	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	10352	38	and	and	CC
18637	10352	39	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	10352	40	subdelegation	subdelegation	NN
18637	10352	41	of	of	IN
18637	10352	42	such	such	JJ
18637	10352	43	of	of	IN
18637	10352	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10352	45	functions	function	NNS
18637	10352	46	under	under	IN
18637	10352	47	this	this	DT
18637	10352	48	order	order	NN
18637	10352	49	as	as	IN
18637	10352	50	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10352	51	may	may	MD
18637	10352	52	deem	deem	VB
18637	10352	53	desirable	desirable	JJ
18637	10352	54	.	.	.
18637	10353	1	Harry	Harry	NNP
18637	10353	2	S.	S.	NNP
18637	10353	3	Truman	Truman	NNP
18637	10353	4	.	.	.
18637	10354	1	The	the	DT
18637	10354	2	White	White	NNP
18637	10354	3	House	House	NNP
18637	10354	4	,	,	,
18637	10354	5	April	April	NNP
18637	10354	6	8	8	CD
18637	10354	7	,	,	,
18637	10354	8	1952	1952	CD
18637	10354	9	.	.	.
18637	10354	10	"	"	''
18637	10355	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10355	2	422	422	CD
18637	10355	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10355	4	343	343	CD
18637	10355	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10355	6	579	579	CD
18637	10355	7	,	,	,
18637	10355	8	583	583	CD
18637	10355	9	.	.	.
18637	10356	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10356	2	423	423	CD
18637	10356	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10356	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10356	5	.	.	.
18637	10357	1	584	584	CD
18637	10357	2	.	.	.
18637	10358	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10358	2	424	424	CD
18637	10358	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10358	4	343	343	CD
18637	10358	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10358	6	579	579	CD
18637	10358	7	,	,	,
18637	10358	8	585	585	CD
18637	10358	9	-	-	SYM
18637	10358	10	589	589	CD
18637	10358	11	.	.	.
18637	10359	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10359	2	425	425	CD
18637	10359	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10359	4	2	2	CD
18637	10359	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	10359	6	.	.	.
18637	10360	1	170	170	CD
18637	10360	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10360	3	1804	1804	CD
18637	10360	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10360	5	.	.	.
18637	10361	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10361	2	426	426	CD
18637	10361	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10361	4	343	343	CD
18637	10361	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10361	6	579	579	CD
18637	10361	7	,	,	,
18637	10361	8	660	660	CD
18637	10361	9	,	,	,
18637	10361	10	661	661	CD
18637	10361	11	.	.	.
18637	10362	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10362	2	427	427	CD
18637	10362	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10362	4	343	343	CD
18637	10362	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10362	6	579	579	CD
18637	10362	7	,	,	,
18637	10362	8	684	684	CD
18637	10362	9	,	,	,
18637	10362	10	citing	cite	VBG
18637	10362	11	10	10	CD
18637	10362	12	Annals	Annals	NNPS
18637	10362	13	of	of	IN
18637	10362	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10362	15	,	,	,
18637	10362	16	619	619	CD
18637	10362	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10362	18	1800	1800	CD
18637	10362	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10362	20	.	.	.
18637	10363	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10363	2	See	See	NNP
18637	10363	3	also	also	RB
18637	10363	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10363	5	p.	p.	NN
18637	10363	6	418	418	CD
18637	10363	7	.	.	.
18637	10364	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10364	2	428	428	CD
18637	10364	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10364	4	9	9	CD
18637	10364	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	10364	6	.	.	.
18637	10365	1	302	302	CD
18637	10365	2	;	;	:
18637	10365	3	R.S.	R.S.	NNP
18637	10366	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	10366	2	5270	5270	CD
18637	10366	3	-	-	SYM
18637	10366	4	5279	5279	CD
18637	10366	5	.	.	.
18637	10367	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10367	2	429	429	CD
18637	10367	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10367	4	For	for	IN
18637	10367	5	the	the	DT
18637	10367	6	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10367	7	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	10367	8	precipitated	precipitate	VBN
18637	10367	9	between	between	IN
18637	10367	10	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	10367	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10367	12	"	"	``
18637	10367	13	Pacificus	Pacificus	NNP
18637	10367	14	"	"	''
18637	10367	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10367	16	and	and	CC
18637	10367	17	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	10367	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10367	19	Helvidius	Helvidius	NNP
18637	10367	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10367	21	,	,	,
18637	10367	22	_	_	NNP
18637	10367	23	see	see	VBP
18637	10367	24	_	_	NNP
18637	10367	25	Edward	Edward	NNP
18637	10367	26	S.	S.	NNP
18637	10367	27	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	10367	28	,	,	,
18637	10367	29	The	the	DT
18637	10367	30	President	President	NNP
18637	10367	31	's	's	POS
18637	10367	32	Control	Control	NNP
18637	10367	33	of	of	IN
18637	10367	34	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	10367	35	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	10367	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10367	37	Princeton	Princeton	NNP
18637	10367	38	University	University	NNP
18637	10367	39	Press	Press	NNP
18637	10367	40	,	,	,
18637	10367	41	1916	1916	CD
18637	10367	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10367	43	,	,	,
18637	10367	44	Chap	Chap	NNP
18637	10367	45	.	.	.
18637	10368	1	I.	I.	NNP
18637	10369	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10369	2	430	430	CD
18637	10369	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10369	4	The	the	DT
18637	10369	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10369	6	of	of	IN
18637	10369	7	June	June	NNP
18637	10369	8	5	5	CD
18637	10369	9	,	,	,
18637	10369	10	1794	1794	CD
18637	10369	11	;	;	:
18637	10369	12	1	1	CD
18637	10369	13	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	10369	14	.	.	.
18637	10370	1	381	381	CD
18637	10370	2	.	.	.
18637	10371	1	The	the	DT
18637	10371	2	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10371	3	was	be	VBD
18637	10371	4	the	the	DT
18637	10371	5	direct	direct	JJ
18637	10371	6	outcome	outcome	NN
18637	10371	7	of	of	IN
18637	10371	8	suggestions	suggestion	NNS
18637	10371	9	made	make	VBN
18637	10371	10	by	by	IN
18637	10371	11	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	10371	12	in	in	IN
18637	10371	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10371	14	message	message	NN
18637	10371	15	of	of	IN
18637	10371	16	December	December	NNP
18637	10371	17	5	5	CD
18637	10371	18	,	,	,
18637	10371	19	1793	1793	CD
18637	10371	20	.	.	.
18637	10372	1	1	1	CD
18637	10372	2	Richardson	Richardson	NNP
18637	10372	3	139	139	CD
18637	10372	4	.	.	.
18637	10373	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10373	2	431	431	CD
18637	10373	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10373	4	22	22	CD
18637	10373	5	Opins	opin	NNS
18637	10373	6	.	.	.
18637	10374	1	A.G.	A.G.	NNP
18637	10374	2	13	13	CD
18637	10374	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10374	4	1898	1898	CD
18637	10374	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10374	6	;	;	:
18637	10374	7	Tucker	Tucker	NNP
18637	10374	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10374	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	10374	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10374	11	Alexandroff	Alexandroff	NNP
18637	10374	12	,	,	,
18637	10374	13	183	183	CD
18637	10374	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10374	15	424	424	CD
18637	10374	16	,	,	,
18637	10374	17	435	435	CD
18637	10374	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10374	19	1902	1902	CD
18637	10374	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10374	21	.	.	.
18637	10375	1	An	an	DT
18637	10375	2	act	act	NN
18637	10375	3	was	be	VBD
18637	10375	4	passed	pass	VBN
18637	10375	5	May	May	NNP
18637	10375	6	27	27	CD
18637	10375	7	,	,	,
18637	10375	8	1921	1921	CD
18637	10375	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10375	10	42	42	CD
18637	10375	11	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	10375	12	.	.	.
18637	10376	1	8)	8)	CD
18637	10376	2	which	which	WDT
18637	10376	3	requires	require	VBZ
18637	10376	4	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	10376	5	license	license	NN
18637	10376	6	for	for	IN
18637	10376	7	the	the	DT
18637	10376	8	landing	landing	NN
18637	10376	9	and	and	CC
18637	10376	10	operation	operation	NN
18637	10376	11	of	of	IN
18637	10376	12	cables	cable	NNS
18637	10376	13	connecting	connect	VBG
18637	10376	14	the	the	DT
18637	10376	15	United	United	NNP
18637	10376	16	States	States	NNP
18637	10376	17	with	with	IN
18637	10376	18	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	10376	19	countries	country	NNS
18637	10376	20	.	.	.
18637	10377	1	Quincy	Quincy	NNP
18637	10377	2	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	10377	3	,	,	,
18637	10377	4	The	the	DT
18637	10377	5	Control	Control	NNP
18637	10377	6	of	of	IN
18637	10377	7	American	American	NNP
18637	10377	8	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	10377	9	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	10377	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10377	11	New	New	NNP
18637	10377	12	York	York	NNP
18637	10377	13	,	,	,
18637	10377	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	10377	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10377	16	302	302	CD
18637	10377	17	fn	fn	CD
18637	10377	18	.	.	.
18637	10378	1	75	75	CD
18637	10378	2	.	.	.
18637	10379	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10379	2	432	432	CD
18637	10379	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10379	4	Santiago	Santiago	NNP
18637	10379	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10379	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10379	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10379	8	Nogueras	Nogueras	NNP
18637	10379	9	,	,	,
18637	10379	10	214	214	CD
18637	10379	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10379	12	260	260	CD
18637	10379	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10379	14	1909	1909	CD
18637	10379	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10379	16	.	.	.
18637	10380	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10380	2	433	433	CD
18637	10380	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10380	4	Madsen	Madsen	NNP
18637	10380	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10380	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10380	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10380	8	Kinsella	Kinsella	NNP
18637	10380	9	,	,	,
18637	10380	10	343	343	CD
18637	10380	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10380	12	341	341	CD
18637	10380	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10380	14	1952	1952	CD
18637	10380	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10380	16	.	.	.
18637	10381	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10381	2	434	434	CD
18637	10381	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10381	4	Charlton	Charlton	NNP
18637	10381	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10381	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10381	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10381	8	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
18637	10381	9	,	,	,
18637	10381	10	229	229	CD
18637	10381	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10381	12	447	447	CD
18637	10381	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10381	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	10381	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10381	16	.	.	.
18637	10382	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10382	2	See	See	NNP
18637	10382	3	also	also	RB
18637	10382	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10382	5	Botiller	Botiller	NNP
18637	10382	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10382	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10382	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10382	9	Dominguez	Dominguez	NNP
18637	10382	10	,	,	,
18637	10382	11	130	130	CD
18637	10382	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10382	13	238	238	CD
18637	10382	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10382	15	1889	1889	CD
18637	10382	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10382	17	.	.	.
18637	10383	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10383	2	435	435	CD
18637	10383	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10383	4	Sinclair	Sinclair	NNP
18637	10383	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10383	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10383	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10383	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10383	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10383	10	,	,	,
18637	10383	11	279	279	CD
18637	10383	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10383	13	263	263	CD
18637	10383	14	,	,	,
18637	10383	15	289	289	CD
18637	10383	16	,	,	,
18637	10383	17	297	297	CD
18637	10383	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10383	19	1929	1929	CD
18637	10383	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10383	21	.	.	.
18637	10384	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10384	2	436	436	CD
18637	10384	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10384	4	12	12	CD
18637	10384	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	10384	6	.	.	.
18637	10385	1	755	755	CD
18637	10385	2	.	.	.
18637	10386	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10386	2	437	437	CD
18637	10386	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10386	4	Berdahl	Berdahl	NNP
18637	10386	5	,	,	,
18637	10386	6	War	War	NNP
18637	10386	7	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	10386	8	of	of	IN
18637	10386	9	the	the	DT
18637	10386	10	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	10386	11	in	in	IN
18637	10386	12	the	the	DT
18637	10386	13	United	United	NNP
18637	10386	14	States	States	NNP
18637	10386	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10386	16	University	University	NNP
18637	10386	17	of	of	IN
18637	10386	18	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	10386	19	,	,	,
18637	10386	20	1921	1921	CD
18637	10386	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10386	22	,	,	,
18637	10386	23	69	69	CD
18637	10386	24	.	.	.
18637	10387	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10387	2	438	438	CD
18637	10387	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10387	4	343	343	CD
18637	10387	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10387	6	579	579	CD
18637	10387	7	,	,	,
18637	10387	8	695	695	CD
18637	10387	9	.	.	.
18637	10388	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10388	2	439	439	CD
18637	10388	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10388	4	89	89	CD
18637	10388	5	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	10388	6	.	.	.
18637	10389	1	Rec	Rec	NNP
18637	10389	2	.	.	.
18637	10390	1	3992	3992	CD
18637	10390	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10390	3	1943	1943	CD
18637	10390	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10390	5	.	.	.
18637	10391	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10391	2	440	440	CD
18637	10391	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10391	4	57	57	CD
18637	10391	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	10391	6	.	.	.
18637	10392	1	163	163	CD
18637	10392	2	.	.	.
18637	10393	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10393	2	441	441	CD
18637	10393	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10393	4	343	343	CD
18637	10393	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10393	6	579	579	CD
18637	10393	7	,	,	,
18637	10393	8	697	697	CD
18637	10393	9	.	.	.
18637	10394	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10394	2	442	442	CD
18637	10394	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10394	4	341	341	CD
18637	10394	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10394	6	114	114	CD
18637	10394	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10394	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	10394	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10394	10	.	.	.
18637	10395	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10395	2	443	443	CD
18637	10395	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10395	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10395	5	See	See	NNP
18637	10395	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10395	7	Hooe	Hooe	NNP
18637	10395	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10395	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	10395	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10395	11	United	United	NNP
18637	10395	12	States	States	NNP
18637	10395	13	,	,	,
18637	10395	14	218	218	CD
18637	10395	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10395	16	322	322	CD
18637	10395	17	,	,	,
18637	10395	18	335	335	CD
18637	10395	19	-	-	SYM
18637	10395	20	336	336	CD
18637	10395	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10395	22	1910	1910	CD
18637	10395	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10395	24	;	;	:
18637	10395	25	United	United	NNP
18637	10395	26	States	States	NNP
18637	10395	27	_	_	NNP
18637	10395	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	10395	29	_	_	NNP
18637	10395	30	North	North	NNP
18637	10395	31	American	American	NNP
18637	10395	32	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10395	33	,	,	,
18637	10395	34	253	253	CD
18637	10395	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10395	36	330	330	CD
18637	10395	37	,	,	,
18637	10395	38	333	333	CD
18637	10395	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10395	40	1920	1920	CD
18637	10395	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10395	42	.	.	.
18637	10396	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10396	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	10396	3	.	.	.
18637	10396	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10396	5	Larson	Larson	NNP
18637	10396	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10396	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10396	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10396	9	Domestic	Domestic	NNP
18637	10396	10	and	and	CC
18637	10396	11	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	10396	12	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	10396	13	,	,	,
18637	10396	14	337	337	CD
18637	10396	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10396	16	682	682	CD
18637	10396	17	,	,	,
18637	10396	18	701	701	CD
18637	10396	19	-	-	SYM
18637	10396	20	702	702	CD
18637	10396	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10396	22	1949	1949	CD
18637	10396	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10396	24	.	.	.
18637	10397	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10397	2	444	444	CD
18637	10397	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10397	4	341	341	CD
18637	10397	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10397	6	114	114	CD
18637	10397	7	,	,	,
18637	10397	8	119	119	CD
18637	10397	9	.	.	.
18637	10398	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10398	2	445	445	CD
18637	10398	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10398	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10398	5	See	See	NNP
18637	10398	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10398	7	p.	p.	NN
18637	10398	8	486	486	CD
18637	10398	9	.	.	.
18637	10399	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10399	2	446	446	CD
18637	10399	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10399	4	Brief	brief	NN
18637	10399	5	for	for	IN
18637	10399	6	the	the	DT
18637	10399	7	United	United	NNP
18637	10399	8	States	States	NNP
18637	10399	9	,	,	,
18637	10399	10	No	no	UH
18637	10399	11	.	.	.
18637	10400	1	278	278	CD
18637	10400	2	,	,	,
18637	10400	3	October	October	NNP
18637	10400	4	Term	Term	NNP
18637	10400	5	,	,	,
18637	10400	6	1914	1914	CD
18637	10400	7	,	,	,
18637	10400	8	pp	pp	NNP
18637	10400	9	.	.	.
18637	10401	1	11	11	CD
18637	10401	2	,	,	,
18637	10401	3	75	75	CD
18637	10401	4	-	-	SYM
18637	10401	5	77	77	CD
18637	10401	6	,	,	,
18637	10401	7	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	10401	8	by	by	IN
18637	10401	9	the	the	DT
18637	10401	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10401	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10401	12	in	in	IN
18637	10401	13	343	343	CD
18637	10401	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10401	15	579	579	CD
18637	10401	16	,	,	,
18637	10401	17	689	689	CD
18637	10401	18	-	-	SYM
18637	10401	19	691	691	CD
18637	10401	20	.	.	.
18637	10402	1	Assistant	Assistant	NNP
18637	10402	2	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10402	3	General	General	NNP
18637	10402	4	Knaebel	Knaebel	NNP
18637	10402	5	's	's	POS
18637	10402	6	name	name	NN
18637	10402	7	was	be	VBD
18637	10402	8	also	also	RB
18637	10402	9	on	on	IN
18637	10402	10	the	the	DT
18637	10402	11	Brief	brief	NN
18637	10402	12	.	.	.
18637	10403	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10403	2	447	447	CD
18637	10403	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10403	4	343	343	CD
18637	10403	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10403	6	579	579	CD
18637	10403	7	,	,	,
18637	10403	8	597	597	CD
18637	10403	9	.	.	.
18637	10404	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10404	2	448	448	CD
18637	10404	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10404	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10404	5	.	.	.
18637	10405	1	602	602	CD
18637	10405	2	.	.	.
18637	10406	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10406	2	449	449	CD
18637	10406	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10406	4	343	343	CD
18637	10406	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10406	6	579	579	CD
18637	10406	7	,	,	,
18637	10406	8	631	631	CD
18637	10406	9	-	-	SYM
18637	10406	10	632	632	CD
18637	10406	11	.	.	.
18637	10407	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10407	2	450	450	CD
18637	10407	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10407	4	13	13	CD
18637	10407	5	How	how	WRB
18637	10407	6	.	.	.
18637	10408	1	115	115	CD
18637	10408	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10408	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	10408	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10408	5	.	.	.
18637	10409	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10409	2	451	451	CD
18637	10409	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10409	4	13	13	CD
18637	10409	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	10409	6	.	.	.
18637	10410	1	623	623	CD
18637	10410	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10410	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	10410	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10410	5	.	.	.
18637	10411	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10411	2	452	452	CD
18637	10411	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10411	4	260	260	CD
18637	10411	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10411	6	327	327	CD
18637	10411	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10411	8	1922	1922	CD
18637	10411	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10411	10	.	.	.
18637	10412	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10412	2	453	453	CD
18637	10412	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10412	4	341	341	CD
18637	10412	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10412	6	114	114	CD
18637	10412	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10412	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	10412	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10412	10	.	.	.
18637	10413	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10413	2	454	454	CD
18637	10413	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10413	4	315	315	CD
18637	10413	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10413	6	203	203	CD
18637	10413	7	,	,	,
18637	10413	8	230	230	CD
18637	10413	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10413	10	1942	1942	CD
18637	10413	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10413	12	.	.	.
18637	10414	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10414	2	455	455	CD
18637	10414	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10414	4	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	10414	5	No	no	NN
18637	10414	6	.	.	.
18637	10415	1	64	64	CD
18637	10415	2	.	.	.
18637	10416	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10416	2	456	456	CD
18637	10416	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10416	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10416	5	See	See	NNP
18637	10416	6	also	also	RB
18637	10416	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10416	8	40	40	CD
18637	10416	9	Op	Op	NNP
18637	10416	10	.	.	.
18637	10417	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	10417	2	.	.	.
18637	10418	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	10418	2	250	250	CD
18637	10418	3	,	,	,
18637	10418	4	253	253	CD
18637	10418	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10418	6	1942	1942	CD
18637	10418	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10418	8	.	.	.
18637	10419	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10419	2	457	457	CD
18637	10419	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10419	4	343	343	CD
18637	10419	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10419	6	579	579	CD
18637	10419	7	,	,	,
18637	10419	8	639	639	CD
18637	10419	9	,	,	,
18637	10419	10	640	640	CD
18637	10419	11	.	.	.
18637	10420	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10420	2	458	458	CD
18637	10420	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10420	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10420	5	.	.	.
18637	10421	1	653	653	CD
18637	10421	2	,	,	,
18637	10421	3	654	654	CD
18637	10421	4	.	.	.
18637	10422	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10422	2	459	459	CD
18637	10422	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10422	4	343	343	CD
18637	10422	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10422	6	579	579	CD
18637	10422	7	,	,	,
18637	10422	8	657	657	CD
18637	10422	9	.	.	.
18637	10423	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10423	2	460	460	CD
18637	10423	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10423	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10423	5	.	.	.
18637	10424	1	659	659	CD
18637	10424	2	.	.	.
18637	10425	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10425	2	461	461	CD
18637	10425	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10425	4	2	2	CD
18637	10425	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	10425	6	.	.	.
18637	10426	1	170	170	CD
18637	10426	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10426	3	1804	1804	CD
18637	10426	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10426	5	.	.	.
18637	10427	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10427	2	462	462	CD
18637	10427	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10427	4	343	343	CD
18637	10427	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10427	6	579	579	CD
18637	10427	7	,	,	,
18637	10427	8	662	662	CD
18637	10427	9	,	,	,
18637	10427	10	663	663	CD
18637	10427	11	.	.	.
18637	10428	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10428	2	463	463	CD
18637	10428	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10428	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10428	5	.	.	.
18637	10429	1	662	662	CD
18637	10429	2	.	.	.
18637	10430	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10430	2	464	464	CD
18637	10430	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10430	4	343	343	CD
18637	10430	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10430	6	579	579	CD
18637	10430	7	,	,	,
18637	10430	8	678	678	CD
18637	10430	9	,	,	,
18637	10430	10	679	679	CD
18637	10430	11	.	.	.
18637	10431	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10431	2	465	465	CD
18637	10431	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10431	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10431	5	.	.	.
18637	10432	1	705	705	CD
18637	10432	2	.	.	.
18637	10433	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10433	2	466	466	CD
18637	10433	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10433	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10433	5	.	.	.
18637	10434	1	708	708	CD
18637	10434	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10434	3	709	709	CD
18637	10434	4	.	.	.
18637	10435	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10435	2	467	467	CD
18637	10435	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10435	4	4	4	CD
18637	10435	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	10435	6	.	.	.
18637	10436	1	475	475	CD
18637	10436	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10436	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	10436	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10436	5	.	.	.
18637	10437	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10437	2	468	468	CD
18637	10437	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10437	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10437	5	.	.	.
18637	10438	1	484	484	CD
18637	10438	2	.	.	.
18637	10439	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10439	2	469	469	CD
18637	10439	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10439	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10439	5	.	.	.
18637	10440	1	500	500	CD
18637	10440	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10440	3	501	501	CD
18637	10440	4	.	.	.
18637	10441	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10441	2	470	470	CD
18637	10441	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10441	4	Kendall	Kendall	NNP
18637	10441	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10441	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10441	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10441	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10441	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10441	10	,	,	,
18637	10441	11	12	12	CD
18637	10441	12	Pet	pet	NN
18637	10441	13	.	.	.
18637	10442	1	524	524	CD
18637	10442	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10442	3	1838	1838	CD
18637	10442	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10442	5	;	;	:
18637	10442	6	United	United	NNP
18637	10442	7	States	States	NNP
18637	10442	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10442	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	10442	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10442	11	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	10442	12	,	,	,
18637	10442	13	106	106	CD
18637	10442	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10442	15	196	196	CD
18637	10442	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10442	17	1882	1882	CD
18637	10442	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10442	19	.	.	.
18637	10443	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10443	2	should	should	MD
18637	10443	3	be	be	VB
18637	10443	4	noted	note	VBN
18637	10443	5	,	,	,
18637	10443	6	however	however	RB
18637	10443	7	,	,	,
18637	10443	8	that	that	IN
18637	10443	9	if	if	IN
18637	10443	10	the	the	DT
18637	10443	11	President	President	NNP
18637	10443	12	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	10443	13	to	to	TO
18637	10443	14	act	act	VB
18637	10443	15	,	,	,
18637	10443	16	or	or	CC
18637	10443	17	if	if	IN
18637	10443	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10443	19	adopts	adopt	VBZ
18637	10443	20	a	a	DT
18637	10443	21	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	10443	22	construction	construction	NN
18637	10443	23	of	of	IN
18637	10443	24	a	a	DT
18637	10443	25	statute	statute	NN
18637	10443	26	which	which	WDT
18637	10443	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10443	28	dislikes	dislike	VBZ
18637	10443	29	,	,	,
18637	10443	30	and	and	CC
18637	10443	31	on	on	IN
18637	10443	32	this	this	DT
18637	10443	33	ground	ground	NN
18637	10443	34	professes	profess	VBZ
18637	10443	35	inability	inability	NN
18637	10443	36	to	to	TO
18637	10443	37	act	act	VB
18637	10443	38	,	,	,
18637	10443	39	the	the	DT
18637	10443	40	only	only	JJ
18637	10443	41	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	10443	42	available	available	JJ
18637	10443	43	against	against	IN
18637	10443	44	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10443	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	10443	46	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	10443	47	.	.	.
18637	10444	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10444	2	471	471	CD
18637	10444	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10444	4	Noble	Noble	NNP
18637	10444	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10444	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10444	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10444	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	10444	9	River	River	NNP
18637	10444	10	Logging	Logging	NNP
18637	10444	11	R.	R.	NNP
18637	10444	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10444	13	,	,	,
18637	10444	14	147	147	CD
18637	10444	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10444	16	165	165	CD
18637	10444	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10444	18	1893	1893	CD
18637	10444	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10444	20	;	;	:
18637	10444	21	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	10444	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10444	23	_	_	NNP
18637	10444	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	10444	25	_	_	NNP
18637	10444	26	Stimson	Stimson	NNP
18637	10444	27	,	,	,
18637	10444	28	223	223	CD
18637	10444	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10444	30	605	605	CD
18637	10444	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10444	32	1912	1912	CD
18637	10444	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10444	34	.	.	.
18637	10445	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10445	2	472	472	CD
18637	10445	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10445	4	Kendall	Kendall	NNP
18637	10445	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10445	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10445	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10445	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10445	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10445	10	,	,	,
18637	10445	11	above	above	RB
18637	10445	12	;	;	:
18637	10445	13	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10445	14	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	10445	15	's	's	POS
18637	10445	16	Note	note	NN
18637	10445	17	:	:	:
18637	10445	18	Reference	reference	NN
18637	10445	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	10445	20	to	to	IN
18637	10445	21	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	10445	22	470	470	CD
18637	10445	23	,	,	,
18637	10445	24	above	above	RB
18637	10445	25	.	.	.
18637	10445	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10446	1	United	United	NNP
18637	10446	2	States	States	NNP
18637	10446	3	_	_	NNP
18637	10446	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	10446	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10446	6	Schurz	Schurz	NNP
18637	10446	7	,	,	,
18637	10446	8	102	102	CD
18637	10446	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10446	10	378	378	CD
18637	10446	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10446	12	1880	1880	CD
18637	10446	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10446	14	;	;	:
18637	10446	15	United	United	NNP
18637	10446	16	States	States	NNP
18637	10446	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	10446	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	10446	19	.	.	.
18637	10447	1	Dunlap	Dunlap	NNP
18637	10447	2	_	_	NNP
18637	10447	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	10447	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10447	5	Black	Black	NNP
18637	10447	6	,	,	,
18637	10447	7	128	128	CD
18637	10447	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10447	9	40	40	CD
18637	10447	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10447	11	1888	1888	CD
18637	10447	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10447	13	.	.	.
18637	10448	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10448	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	10448	3	.	.	.
18637	10448	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10448	5	Decatur	Decatur	NNP
18637	10448	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10448	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10448	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10448	9	Paulding	Paulding	NNP
18637	10448	10	,	,	,
18637	10448	11	14	14	CD
18637	10448	12	Pet	pet	NN
18637	10448	13	.	.	.
18637	10449	1	497	497	CD
18637	10449	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10449	3	1840	1840	CD
18637	10449	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10449	5	;	;	:
18637	10449	6	and	and	CC
18637	10449	7	Riverside	Riverside	NNP
18637	10449	8	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	10449	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10449	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10449	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	10449	12	_	_	NNP
18637	10449	13	Hitchcock	Hitchcock	NNP
18637	10449	14	,	,	,
18637	10449	15	190	190	CD
18637	10449	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10449	17	316	316	CD
18637	10449	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10449	19	1903	1903	CD
18637	10449	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10449	21	,	,	,
18637	10449	22	where	where	WRB
18637	10449	23	the	the	DT
18637	10449	24	rule	rule	NN
18637	10449	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	10449	26	reiterated	reiterate	VBN
18637	10449	27	that	that	IN
18637	10449	28	neither	neither	DT
18637	10449	29	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	10449	30	nor	nor	CC
18637	10449	31	mandamus	mandamus	NNP
18637	10449	32	will	will	MD
18637	10449	33	lie	lie	VB
18637	10449	34	against	against	IN
18637	10449	35	an	an	DT
18637	10449	36	officer	officer	NN
18637	10449	37	to	to	TO
18637	10449	38	control	control	VB
18637	10449	39	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10449	40	in	in	IN
18637	10449	41	the	the	DT
18637	10449	42	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10449	43	of	of	IN
18637	10449	44	an	an	DT
18637	10449	45	official	official	JJ
18637	10449	46	duty	duty	NN
18637	10449	47	which	which	WDT
18637	10449	48	requires	require	VBZ
18637	10449	49	the	the	DT
18637	10449	50	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10449	51	of	of	IN
18637	10449	52	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10449	53	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10449	54	and	and	CC
18637	10449	55	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	10449	56	.	.	.
18637	10450	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10450	2	473	473	CD
18637	10450	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10450	4	This	this	DT
18637	10450	5	was	be	VBD
18637	10450	6	originally	originally	RB
18637	10450	7	on	on	IN
18637	10450	8	the	the	DT
18637	10450	9	theory	theory	NN
18637	10450	10	that	that	IN
18637	10450	11	the	the	DT
18637	10450	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10450	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10450	14	of	of	IN
18637	10450	15	the	the	DT
18637	10450	16	District	District	NNP
18637	10450	17	had	have	VBD
18637	10450	18	inherited	inherit	VBN
18637	10450	19	,	,	,
18637	10450	20	via	via	IN
18637	10450	21	the	the	DT
18637	10450	22	common	common	JJ
18637	10450	23	law	law	NN
18637	10450	24	of	of	IN
18637	10450	25	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	10450	26	,	,	,
18637	10450	27	the	the	DT
18637	10450	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10450	29	of	of	IN
18637	10450	30	the	the	DT
18637	10450	31	King	King	NNP
18637	10450	32	's	's	POS
18637	10450	33	Bench	Bench	NNP
18637	10450	34	"	"	''
18637	10450	35	over	over	IN
18637	10450	36	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	10450	37	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NNS
18637	10450	38	and	and	CC
18637	10450	39	officers	officer	NNS
18637	10450	40	.	.	.
18637	10450	41	"	"	''
18637	10451	1	12	12	CD
18637	10451	2	Pet	pet	NN
18637	10451	3	.	.	.
18637	10452	1	at	at	IN
18637	10452	2	614	614	CD
18637	10452	3	and	and	CC
18637	10452	4	620	620	CD
18637	10452	5	-	-	SYM
18637	10452	6	621	621	CD
18637	10452	7	.	.	.
18637	10453	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10453	2	474	474	CD
18637	10453	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10453	4	Little	Little	NNP
18637	10453	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10453	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10453	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10453	8	Barreme	Barreme	NNP
18637	10453	9	,	,	,
18637	10453	10	2	2	CD
18637	10453	11	Cr	cr	NN
18637	10453	12	.	.	.
18637	10454	1	170	170	CD
18637	10454	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10454	3	1804	1804	CD
18637	10454	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10454	5	;	;	:
18637	10454	6	United	United	NNP
18637	10454	7	States	States	NNP
18637	10454	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10454	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	10454	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10454	11	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	10454	12	,	,	,
18637	10454	13	above	above	RB
18637	10454	14	;	;	:
18637	10454	15	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10454	16	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	10454	17	's	's	POS
18637	10454	18	Note	note	NN
18637	10454	19	:	:	:
18637	10454	20	Reference	reference	NN
18637	10454	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	10454	22	to	to	IN
18637	10454	23	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	10454	24	470	470	CD
18637	10454	25	,	,	,
18637	10454	26	above	above	RB
18637	10454	27	.	.	.
18637	10454	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10455	1	Spaulding	spaulde	VBG
18637	10455	2	_	_	NNP
18637	10455	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	10455	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10455	5	Vilas	Vilas	NNP
18637	10455	6	,	,	,
18637	10455	7	161	161	CD
18637	10455	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10455	9	483	483	CD
18637	10455	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10455	11	1896	1896	CD
18637	10455	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10455	13	.	.	.
18637	10456	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10456	2	475	475	CD
18637	10456	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10456	4	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	10456	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10456	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10456	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10456	8	Hood	Hood	NNP
18637	10456	9	,	,	,
18637	10456	10	327	327	CD
18637	10456	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10456	12	678	678	CD
18637	10456	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10456	14	1946	1946	CD
18637	10456	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10456	16	.	.	.
18637	10457	1	The	the	DT
18637	10457	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	10457	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	10457	4	based	base	VBN
18637	10457	5	on	on	IN
18637	10457	6	an	an	DT
18637	10457	7	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	10457	8	of	of	IN
18637	10457	9	28	28	CD
18637	10457	10	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
18637	10458	1	§	§	NNP
18637	10458	2	41	41	CD
18637	10458	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10458	4	1	1	CD
18637	10458	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10458	6	.	.	.
18637	10459	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10459	2	476	476	CD
18637	10459	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10459	4	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	10459	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10459	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10459	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10459	8	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	10459	9	,	,	,
18637	10459	10	110	110	CD
18637	10459	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10459	12	633	633	CD
18637	10459	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10459	14	1884	1884	CD
18637	10459	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10459	16	.	.	.
18637	10460	1	An	an	DT
18637	10460	2	official	official	JJ
18637	10460	3	action	action	NN
18637	10460	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	10460	5	indemnifiable	indemnifiable	JJ
18637	10460	6	if	if	IN
18637	10460	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10460	8	could	could	MD
18637	10460	9	have	have	VB
18637	10460	10	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	10460	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10460	12	in	in	IN
18637	10460	13	the	the	DT
18637	10460	14	first	first	JJ
18637	10460	15	place	place	NN
18637	10460	16	,	,	,
18637	10460	17	or	or	CC
18637	10460	18	if	if	IN
18637	10460	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10460	20	was	be	VBD
18637	10460	21	done	do	VBN
18637	10460	22	under	under	IN
18637	10460	23	"	"	``
18637	10460	24	imperative	imperative	JJ
18637	10460	25	orders	order	NNS
18637	10460	26	which	which	WDT
18637	10460	27	could	could	MD
18637	10460	28	not	not	RB
18637	10460	29	be	be	VB
18637	10460	30	resisted	resist	VBN
18637	10460	31	,	,	,
18637	10460	32	"	"	''
18637	10460	33	or	or	CC
18637	10460	34	"	"	``
18637	10460	35	under	under	IN
18637	10460	36	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	10460	37	or	or	CC
18637	10460	38	mistake	mistake	NN
18637	10460	39	.	.	.
18637	10460	40	"	"	''
18637	10461	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	10461	2	.	.	.
18637	10462	1	640	640	CD
18637	10462	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10462	3	641	641	CD
18637	10462	4	.	.	.
18637	10463	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10463	2	477	477	CD
18637	10463	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10463	4	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	10463	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10463	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10463	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10463	8	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	10463	9	,	,	,
18637	10463	10	100	100	CD
18637	10463	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10463	12	257	257	CD
18637	10463	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10463	14	1880	1880	CD
18637	10463	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10463	16	;	;	:
18637	10463	17	In	in	IN
18637	10463	18	re	re	IN
18637	10463	19	Neagle	Neagle	NNP
18637	10463	20	,	,	,
18637	10463	21	135	135	CD
18637	10463	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10463	23	1	1	CD
18637	10463	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10463	25	1890	1890	CD
18637	10463	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10463	27	.	.	.
18637	10464	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10464	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	10464	3	.	.	.
18637	10464	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10464	5	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	10464	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10464	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10464	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10464	9	Soper	Soper	NNP
18637	10464	10	,	,	,
18637	10464	11	270	270	CD
18637	10464	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	10464	13	9	9	CD
18637	10464	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10464	15	1926	1926	CD
18637	10464	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10464	17	.	.	.
18637	10465	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10465	2	478	478	CD
18637	10465	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10465	4	17	17	CD
18637	10465	5	Op	Op	NNP
18637	10465	6	.	.	.
18637	10466	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	10466	2	.	.	.
18637	10467	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	10467	2	419	419	CD
18637	10467	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10467	4	1882	1882	CD
18637	10467	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10467	6	.	.	.
18637	10468	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10468	2	See	See	NNP
18637	10468	3	also	also	RB
18637	10468	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10468	5	Hinds	Hinds	NNP
18637	10468	6	'	'	POS
18637	10468	7	Precedents	Precedents	NNPS
18637	10468	8	,	,	,
18637	10468	9	III	III	NNP
18637	10468	10	,	,	,
18637	10468	11	§§	§§	NNP
18637	10468	12	2315	2315	CD
18637	10468	13	-	-	SYM
18637	10468	14	2318	2318	CD
18637	10468	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10468	16	1907	1907	CD
18637	10468	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10468	18	.	.	.
18637	10469	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10469	2	479	479	CD
18637	10469	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10469	4	The	the	DT
18637	10469	5	Belknap	Belknap	NNP
18637	10469	6	Case	Case	NNP
18637	10469	7	,	,	,
18637	10469	8	ibid	ibid	NNP
18637	10469	9	.	.	.
18637	10470	1	§	§	NNP
18637	10470	2	2445	2445	CD
18637	10470	3	.	.	.
18637	10471	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10471	2	480	480	CD
18637	10471	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10471	4	Elliot	Elliot	NNP
18637	10471	5	,	,	,
18637	10471	6	Debates	Debates	NNP
18637	10471	7	,	,	,
18637	10471	8	V	V	NNP
18637	10471	9	,	,	,
18637	10471	10	341	341	CD
18637	10471	11	,	,	,
18637	10471	12	528	528	CD
18637	10471	13	.	.	.
18637	10472	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10472	2	481	481	CD
18637	10472	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10472	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10472	5	.	.	.
18637	10473	1	IV	IV	NNP
18637	10473	2	,	,	,
18637	10473	3	375	375	CD
18637	10473	4	.	.	.
18637	10474	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10474	2	482	482	CD
18637	10474	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10474	4	The	the	DT
18637	10474	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	10474	6	No	no	NN
18637	10474	7	.	.	.
18637	10475	1	65	65	CD
18637	10475	2	.	.	.
18637	10476	1	For	for	IN
18637	10476	2	the	the	DT
18637	10476	3	above	above	JJ
18637	10476	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10476	5	see	see	VB
18637	10476	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10476	7	William	William	NNP
18637	10476	8	S.	S.	NNP
18637	10476	9	Carpenter	Carpenter	NNP
18637	10476	10	,	,	,
18637	10476	11	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	10476	12	Tenure	Tenure	NNP
18637	10476	13	in	in	IN
18637	10476	14	the	the	DT
18637	10476	15	United	United	NNP
18637	10476	16	States	States	NNP
18637	10476	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10476	18	Yale	Yale	NNP
18637	10476	19	University	University	NNP
18637	10476	20	Press	Press	NNP
18637	10476	21	,	,	,
18637	10476	22	1918	1918	CD
18637	10476	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10476	24	,	,	,
18637	10476	25	105	105	CD
18637	10476	26	-	-	SYM
18637	10476	27	106	106	CD
18637	10476	28	.	.	.
18637	10477	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10477	2	483	483	CD
18637	10477	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10477	4	John	John	NNP
18637	10477	5	Quincy	Quincy	NNP
18637	10477	6	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	10477	7	,	,	,
18637	10477	8	Memoirs	Memoirs	NNP
18637	10477	9	,	,	,
18637	10477	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10477	11	,	,	,
18637	10477	12	321	321	CD
18637	10477	13	,	,	,
18637	10477	14	322	322	CD
18637	10477	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10477	16	1874	1874	CD
18637	10477	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10477	18	.	.	.
18637	10478	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10478	2	484	484	CD
18637	10478	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10478	4	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	10478	5	of	of	IN
18637	10478	6	Andrew	Andrew	NNP
18637	10478	7	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	10478	8	,	,	,
18637	10478	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10478	10	,	,	,
18637	10478	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10478	12	Government	Government	NNP
18637	10478	13	Printing	Printing	NNP
18637	10478	14	Office	Office	NNP
18637	10478	15	,	,	,
18637	10478	16	1868	1868	CD
18637	10478	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10478	18	,	,	,
18637	10478	19	147	147	CD
18637	10478	20	.	.	.
18637	10479	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10479	2	485	485	CD
18637	10479	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10479	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	10479	5	.	.	.
18637	10480	1	409	409	CD
18637	10480	2	.	.	.
18637	10481	1	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	10481	2	and	and	CC
18637	10481	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10481	4	Cabinet	Cabinet	NNP
18637	10481	5	were	be	VBD
18637	10481	6	much	much	RB
18637	10481	7	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	10481	8	over	over	IN
18637	10481	9	rumors	rumor	NNS
18637	10481	10	that	that	IN
18637	10481	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10481	12	was	be	VBD
18637	10481	13	the	the	DT
18637	10481	14	intention	intention	NN
18637	10481	15	of	of	IN
18637	10481	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10481	17	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	10481	18	in	in	IN
18637	10481	19	the	the	DT
18637	10481	20	House	House	NNP
18637	10481	21	,	,	,
18637	10481	22	following	follow	VBG
18637	10481	23	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	10481	24	and	and	CC
18637	10481	25	pending	pende	VBG
18637	10481	26	the	the	DT
18637	10481	27	trial	trial	NN
18637	10481	28	,	,	,
18637	10481	29	to	to	TO
18637	10481	30	put	put	VB
18637	10481	31	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10481	32	under	under	IN
18637	10481	33	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	10481	34	and/or	and/or	CC
18637	10481	35	suspend	suspend	VB
18637	10481	36	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10481	37	from	from	IN
18637	10481	38	office	office	NN
18637	10481	39	.	.	.
18637	10482	1	Gideon	Gideon	NNP
18637	10482	2	Welles	Welles	NNP
18637	10482	3	,	,	,
18637	10482	4	Diary	Diary	NNP
18637	10482	5	,	,	,
18637	10482	6	III	III	NNP
18637	10482	7	,	,	,
18637	10482	8	21	21	CD
18637	10482	9	,	,	,
18637	10482	10	27	27	CD
18637	10482	11	,	,	,
18637	10482	12	50	50	CD
18637	10482	13	,	,	,
18637	10482	14	57	57	CD
18637	10482	15	,	,	,
18637	10482	16	60	60	CD
18637	10482	17	,	,	,
18637	10482	18	62	62	CD
18637	10482	19	,	,	,
18637	10482	20	151	151	CD
18637	10482	21	,	,	,
18637	10482	22	200	200	CD
18637	10482	23	,	,	,
18637	10482	24	235	235	CD
18637	10482	25	,	,	,
18637	10482	26	237	237	CD
18637	10482	27	,	,	,
18637	10482	28	238	238	CD
18637	10482	29	,	,	,
18637	10482	30	291	291	CD
18637	10482	31	,	,	,
18637	10482	32	313	313	CD
18637	10482	33	.	.	.
18637	10483	1	But	but	CC
18637	10483	2	no	no	DT
18637	10483	3	such	such	JJ
18637	10483	4	step	step	NN
18637	10483	5	was	be	VBD
18637	10483	6	attempted	attempt	VBN
18637	10483	7	.	.	.
18637	10484	1	Several	several	JJ
18637	10484	2	state	state	NN
18637	10484	3	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	10484	4	contain	contain	VBP
18637	10484	5	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	10484	6	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	10484	7	suspension	suspension	NN
18637	10484	8	from	from	IN
18637	10484	9	office	office	NN
18637	10484	10	in	in	IN
18637	10484	11	such	such	PDT
18637	10484	12	a	a	DT
18637	10484	13	case	case	NN
18637	10484	14	.	.	.
18637	10485	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10485	2	486	486	CD
18637	10485	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10485	4	Carpenter	Carpenter	NNP
18637	10485	5	,	,	,
18637	10485	6	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	10485	7	Tenure	Tenure	NNP
18637	10485	8	,	,	,
18637	10485	9	145	145	CD
18637	10485	10	-	-	SYM
18637	10485	11	153	153	CD
18637	10485	12	.	.	.
18637	10486	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10486	2	487	487	CD
18637	10486	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10486	4	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	10486	5	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10486	6	in	in	IN
18637	10486	7	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	10486	8	.	.	.
18637	10487	1	Record	Record	NNP
18637	10487	2	,	,	,
18637	10487	3	vol	vol	NNP
18637	10487	4	.	.	.
18637	10488	1	80	80	CD
18637	10488	2	,	,	,
18637	10488	3	pp	pp	NNP
18637	10488	4	.	.	.
18637	10489	1	5558	5558	CD
18637	10489	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10489	3	5559	5559	CD
18637	10489	4	,	,	,
18637	10489	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10489	6	April	April	NNP
18637	10489	7	16	16	CD
18637	10489	8	,	,	,
18637	10489	9	1936	1936	CD
18637	10489	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10489	11	.	.	.
18637	10490	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10490	2	488	488	CD
18637	10490	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10490	4	On	on	IN
18637	10490	5	this	this	DT
18637	10490	6	account	account	NN
18637	10490	7	,	,	,
18637	10490	8	as	as	RB
18637	10490	9	well	well	RB
18637	10490	10	as	as	IN
18637	10490	11	because	because	IN
18637	10490	12	of	of	IN
18637	10490	13	the	the	DT
18637	10490	14	cumbersomeness	cumbersomeness	NN
18637	10490	15	of	of	IN
18637	10490	16	the	the	DT
18637	10490	17	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	10490	18	process	process	NN
18637	10490	19	and	and	CC
18637	10490	20	the	the	DT
18637	10490	21	amount	amount	NN
18637	10490	22	of	of	IN
18637	10490	23	time	time	NN
18637	10490	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10490	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	10490	26	apt	apt	JJ
18637	10490	27	to	to	TO
18637	10490	28	consume	consume	VB
18637	10490	29	,	,	,
18637	10490	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10490	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	10490	32	been	be	VBN
18637	10490	33	suggested	suggest	VBN
18637	10490	34	that	that	IN
18637	10490	35	a	a	DT
18637	10490	36	special	special	JJ
18637	10490	37	court	court	NN
18637	10490	38	could	could	MD
18637	10490	39	,	,	,
18637	10490	40	and	and	CC
18637	10490	41	should	should	MD
18637	10490	42	,	,	,
18637	10490	43	be	be	VB
18637	10490	44	created	create	VBN
18637	10490	45	to	to	TO
18637	10490	46	try	try	VB
18637	10490	47	cases	case	NNS
18637	10490	48	of	of	IN
18637	10490	49	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	10490	50	misbehavior	misbehavior	NN
18637	10490	51	in	in	IN
18637	10490	52	office	office	NN
18637	10490	53	of	of	IN
18637	10490	54	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	10490	55	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10490	56	of	of	IN
18637	10490	57	the	the	DT
18637	10490	58	United	United	NNP
18637	10490	59	States	States	NNP
18637	10490	60	,	,	,
18637	10490	61	this	this	DT
18637	10490	62	type	type	NN
18637	10490	63	of	of	IN
18637	10490	64	officer	officer	NN
18637	10490	65	having	have	VBG
18637	10490	66	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	10490	67	the	the	DT
18637	10490	68	great	great	JJ
18637	10490	69	majority	majority	NN
18637	10490	70	of	of	IN
18637	10490	71	cases	case	NNS
18637	10490	72	of	of	IN
18637	10490	73	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	10490	74	under	under	IN
18637	10490	75	the	the	DT
18637	10490	76	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10490	77	.	.	.
18637	10491	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10491	2	See	See	NNP
18637	10491	3	_	_	NNP
18637	10491	4	Memorandum	Memorandum	NNP
18637	10491	5	on	on	IN
18637	10491	6	Removal	Removal	NNP
18637	10491	7	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10491	8	of	of	IN
18637	10491	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10491	10	with	with	IN
18637	10491	11	Respect	respect	NN
18637	10491	12	to	to	IN
18637	10491	13	the	the	DT
18637	10491	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10491	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10491	16	,	,	,
18637	10491	17	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	10491	18	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	10491	19	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	10491	20	,	,	,
18637	10491	21	80th	80th	NNP
18637	10491	22	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	10491	23	.	.	NNP
18637	10491	24	,	,	,
18637	10491	25	1st	1st	JJ
18637	10491	26	sess	sess	NN
18637	10491	27	.	.	.
18637	10492	1	;	;	:
18637	10492	2	_	_	NNP
18637	10492	3	also	also	RB
18637	10492	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10492	5	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	10492	6	Shartel	Shartel	NNP
18637	10492	7	,	,	,
18637	10492	8	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10492	9	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	10492	10	--	--	:
18637	10492	11	Appointment	Appointment	NNP
18637	10492	12	,	,	,
18637	10492	13	Supervision	Supervision	NNP
18637	10492	14	,	,	,
18637	10492	15	and	and	CC
18637	10492	16	Removal	removal	NN
18637	10492	17	--	--	:
18637	10492	18	Some	some	DT
18637	10492	19	Possibilities	possibility	NNS
18637	10492	20	under	under	IN
18637	10492	21	the	the	DT
18637	10492	22	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10492	23	,	,	,
18637	10492	24	28	28	CD
18637	10492	25	Mich.	Michigan	NNP
18637	10492	26	L.	L.	NNP
18637	10493	1	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	10493	2	,	,	,
18637	10493	3	870	870	CD
18637	10493	4	-	-	SYM
18637	10493	5	907	907	CD
18637	10493	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10493	7	May	May	NNP
18637	10493	8	1930	1930	CD
18637	10493	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10493	10	.	.	.
18637	10494	1	Is	be	VBZ
18637	10494	2	impeachment	impeachment	VB
18637	10494	3	the	the	DT
18637	10494	4	only	only	JJ
18637	10494	5	way	way	NN
18637	10494	6	in	in	IN
18637	10494	7	which	which	WDT
18637	10494	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10494	9	,	,	,
18637	10494	10	or	or	CC
18637	10494	11	either	either	CC
18637	10494	12	house	house	NN
18637	10494	13	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	10494	14	,	,	,
18637	10494	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	10494	16	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	10494	17	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	10494	18	to	to	TO
18637	10494	19	call	call	VB
18637	10494	20	the	the	DT
18637	10494	21	President	President	NNP
18637	10494	22	to	to	TO
18637	10494	23	account	account	VB
18637	10494	24	for	for	IN
18637	10494	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10494	26	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	10494	27	in	in	IN
18637	10494	28	office	office	NN
18637	10494	29	?	?	.
18637	10495	1	_	_	NNP
18637	10495	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	10495	3	.	.	.
18637	10495	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10495	5	George	George	NNP
18637	10495	6	Wharton	Wharton	NNP
18637	10495	7	Pepper	Pepper	NNP
18637	10495	8	,	,	,
18637	10495	9	Family	Family	NNP
18637	10495	10	Quarrels	Quarrels	NNPS
18637	10495	11	,	,	,
18637	10495	12	The	the	DT
18637	10495	13	President	President	NNP
18637	10495	14	,	,	,
18637	10495	15	the	the	DT
18637	10495	16	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	10495	17	,	,	,
18637	10495	18	and	and	CC
18637	10495	19	the	the	DT
18637	10495	20	House	House	NNP
18637	10495	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10495	22	New	New	NNP
18637	10495	23	York	York	NNP
18637	10495	24	,	,	,
18637	10495	25	1931	1931	CD
18637	10495	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10495	27	,	,	,
18637	10495	28	138	138	CD
18637	10495	29	ff	ff	NNS
18637	10495	30	.	.	.
18637	10496	1	;	;	:
18637	10496	2	and	and	CC
18637	10496	3	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	10496	4	,	,	,
18637	10496	5	The	the	DT
18637	10496	6	President	President	NNP
18637	10496	7	,	,	,
18637	10496	8	Office	Office	NNP
18637	10496	9	and	and	CC
18637	10496	10	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	10496	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10496	12	3d	3d	NNP
18637	10496	13	ed	ed	NNP
18637	10496	14	.	.	.
18637	10497	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10497	2	,	,	,
18637	10497	3	411	411	CD
18637	10497	4	-	-	SYM
18637	10497	5	413	413	CD
18637	10497	6	.	.	.
18637	10498	1	ARTICLE	article	NN
18637	10498	2	III	III	NNP
18637	10498	3	THE	the	DT
18637	10498	4	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	10498	5	DEPARTMENT	DEPARTMENT	NNP
18637	10498	6	Section	Section	NNP
18637	10498	7	1	1	CD
18637	10498	8	.	.	.
18637	10499	1	The	the	DT
18637	10499	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10499	3	power	power	NN
18637	10499	4	,	,	,
18637	10499	5	courts	court	NNS
18637	10499	6	,	,	,
18637	10499	7	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10499	8	:	:	:
18637	10499	9	Page	page	NN
18637	10499	10	Characteristics	Characteristics	NNPS
18637	10499	11	and	and	CC
18637	10499	12	attributes	attribute	NNS
18637	10499	13	of	of	IN
18637	10499	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10499	15	power	power	NN
18637	10499	16	511	511	CD
18637	10499	17	"	"	``
18637	10499	18	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10499	19	power	power	NN
18637	10499	20	"	"	``
18637	10499	21	511	511	CD
18637	10499	22	"	"	``
18637	10499	23	Shall	Shall	MD
18637	10499	24	be	be	VB
18637	10499	25	vested	vest	VBN
18637	10499	26	"	"	``
18637	10499	27	512	512	CD
18637	10499	28	Finality	finality	NN
18637	10499	29	of	of	IN
18637	10499	30	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10499	31	512	512	CD
18637	10499	32	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	10499	33	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	10499	34	513	513	CD
18637	10499	35	Award	award	NN
18637	10499	36	of	of	IN
18637	10499	37	execution	execution	NN
18637	10499	38	514	514	CD
18637	10499	39	Ancillary	ancillary	JJ
18637	10499	40	powers	power	NNS
18637	10499	41	515	515	CD
18637	10499	42	Contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10499	43	power	power	NN
18637	10499	44	;	;	:
18637	10499	45	the	the	DT
18637	10499	46	act	act	NN
18637	10499	47	of	of	IN
18637	10499	48	1789	1789	CD
18637	10499	49	515	515	CD
18637	10499	50	An	an	DT
18637	10499	51	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10499	52	power	power	NN
18637	10499	53	515	515	CD
18637	10499	54	Contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10499	55	power	power	NN
18637	10499	56	exalted	exalt	VBD
18637	10499	57	516	516	CD
18637	10499	58	Recession	recession	NN
18637	10499	59	of	of	IN
18637	10499	60	the	the	DT
18637	10499	61	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	10499	62	517	517	CD
18637	10499	63	Bridges	Bridges	NNPS
18637	10499	64	_	_	NNP
18637	10499	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	10499	66	_	_	NNP
18637	10499	67	California	California	NNP
18637	10499	68	517	517	CD
18637	10499	69	Summary	Summary	NNP
18637	10499	70	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	10499	71	of	of	IN
18637	10499	72	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10499	73	;	;	:
18637	10499	74	misbehavior	misbehavior	NNP
18637	10499	75	of	of	IN
18637	10499	76	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	10499	77	517	517	CD
18637	10499	78	Punishment	punishment	NN
18637	10499	79	of	of	IN
18637	10499	80	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	10499	81	;	;	:
18637	10499	82	The	the	DT
18637	10499	83	Sacher	Sacher	NNP
18637	10499	84	Case	case	NN
18637	10499	85	519	519	CD
18637	10499	86	Contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10499	87	by	by	IN
18637	10499	88	disobedience	disobedience	NN
18637	10499	89	of	of	IN
18637	10499	90	orders	order	NNS
18637	10499	91	520	520	CD
18637	10499	92	Criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10499	93	versus	versus	IN
18637	10499	94	civil	civil	JJ
18637	10499	95	contempts	contempt	VBZ
18637	10499	96	521	521	CD
18637	10499	97	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10499	98	power	power	NN
18637	10499	99	aids	aids	NNP
18637	10499	100	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	10499	101	power	power	NN
18637	10499	102	521	521	CD
18637	10499	103	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10499	104	to	to	TO
18637	10499	105	issue	issue	VB
18637	10499	106	writs	writ	NNS
18637	10499	107	;	;	:
18637	10499	108	the	the	DT
18637	10499	109	act	act	NN
18637	10499	110	of	of	IN
18637	10499	111	1789	1789	CD
18637	10499	112	522	522	CD
18637	10499	113	Common	common	JJ
18637	10499	114	law	law	NN
18637	10499	115	powers	power	NNS
18637	10499	116	of	of	IN
18637	10499	117	the	the	DT
18637	10499	118	District	District	NNP
18637	10499	119	of	of	IN
18637	10499	120	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	10499	121	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	10499	122	522	522	CD
18637	10499	123	Habeas	Habeas	NNP
18637	10499	124	corpus	corpus	NN
18637	10499	125	523	523	CD
18637	10499	126	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10499	127	limits	limit	VBZ
18637	10499	128	the	the	DT
18637	10499	129	inquisition	inquisition	NN
18637	10499	130	power	power	NN
18637	10499	131	523	523	CD
18637	10499	132	Injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	10499	133	under	under	IN
18637	10499	134	the	the	DT
18637	10499	135	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	10499	136	Price	Price	NNP
18637	10499	137	Control	Control	NNP
18637	10499	138	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10499	139	of	of	IN
18637	10499	140	1942	1942	CD
18637	10499	141	525	525	CD
18637	10499	142	Rule	Rule	NNP
18637	10499	143	-	-	HYPH
18637	10499	144	making	make	VBG
18637	10499	145	power	power	NN
18637	10499	146	and	and	CC
18637	10499	147	powers	power	NNS
18637	10499	148	over	over	IN
18637	10499	149	process	process	NN
18637	10499	150	525	525	CD
18637	10499	151	Limits	limit	NNS
18637	10499	152	to	to	IN
18637	10499	153	the	the	DT
18637	10499	154	power	power	NN
18637	10499	155	526	526	CD
18637	10499	156	Appointment	Appointment	NNP
18637	10499	157	of	of	IN
18637	10499	158	referees	referee	NNS
18637	10499	159	,	,	,
18637	10499	160	masters	master	NNS
18637	10499	161	,	,	,
18637	10499	162	and	and	CC
18637	10499	163	special	special	JJ
18637	10499	164	aids	aids	NNP
18637	10499	165	527	527	CD
18637	10499	166	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10499	167	to	to	TO
18637	10499	168	admit	admit	VB
18637	10499	169	and	and	CC
18637	10499	170	disbar	disbar	NN
18637	10499	171	attorneys	attorney	NNS
18637	10499	172	527	527	CD
18637	10499	173	Organization	Organization	NNP
18637	10499	174	of	of	IN
18637	10499	175	courts	court	NNS
18637	10499	176	;	;	:
18637	10499	177	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	10499	178	of	of	IN
18637	10499	179	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10499	180	528	528	CD
18637	10499	181	"	"	``
18637	10499	182	One	one	CD
18637	10499	183	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	10499	184	court	court	NNP
18637	10499	185	"	"	''
18637	10499	186	528	528	CD
18637	10499	187	Inferior	Inferior	NNP
18637	10499	188	courts	court	NNS
18637	10499	189	made	make	VBD
18637	10499	190	and	and	CC
18637	10499	191	abolished	abolish	VBD
18637	10499	192	528	528	CD
18637	10499	193	Abolition	Abolition	NNP
18637	10499	194	of	of	IN
18637	10499	195	the	the	DT
18637	10499	196	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	10499	197	court	court	NNP
18637	10499	198	529	529	CD
18637	10499	199	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	10499	200	530	530	CD
18637	10499	201	Diminution	diminution	NN
18637	10499	202	of	of	IN
18637	10499	203	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	10499	204	530	530	CD
18637	10499	205	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	10499	206	of	of	IN
18637	10499	207	specialized	specialized	JJ
18637	10499	208	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10499	209	531	531	CD
18637	10499	210	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	10499	211	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10499	212	of	of	IN
18637	10499	213	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	10499	214	of	of	IN
18637	10499	215	1942	1942	CD
18637	10499	216	531	531	CD
18637	10499	217	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10499	218	review	review	NN
18637	10499	219	restrained	restrain	VBD
18637	10499	220	532	532	CD
18637	10499	221	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10499	222	courts	court	NNS
18637	10499	223	;	;	:
18637	10499	224	Canter	Canter	NNP
18637	10499	225	case	case	NN
18637	10499	226	533	533	CD
18637	10499	227	Other	other	JJ
18637	10499	228	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10499	229	courts	court	NNS
18637	10499	230	534	534	CD
18637	10499	231	Powers	power	NNS
18637	10499	232	of	of	IN
18637	10499	233	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10499	234	over	over	IN
18637	10499	235	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10499	236	courts	court	NNS
18637	10499	237	534	534	CD
18637	10499	238	Status	Status	NNP
18637	10499	239	of	of	IN
18637	10499	240	the	the	DT
18637	10499	241	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10499	242	of	of	IN
18637	10499	243	Claims	Claims	NNP
18637	10499	244	535	535	CD
18637	10499	245	A	a	DT
18637	10499	246	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10499	247	paradox	paradox	NN
18637	10499	248	536	536	CD
18637	10499	249	Status	Status	NNP
18637	10499	250	of	of	IN
18637	10499	251	the	the	DT
18637	10499	252	courts	court	NNS
18637	10499	253	of	of	IN
18637	10499	254	the	the	DT
18637	10499	255	District	District	NNP
18637	10499	256	of	of	IN
18637	10499	257	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	10499	258	.	.	.
18637	10499	259	'	'	''
18637	10500	1	536	536	CD
18637	10500	2	Section	section	NN
18637	10500	3	2	2	CD
18637	10500	4	.	.	.
18637	10501	1	Jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10501	2	538	538	CD
18637	10501	3	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	10501	4	1	1	CD
18637	10501	5	.	.	.
18637	10502	1	Scope	scope	NN
18637	10502	2	of	of	IN
18637	10502	3	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10502	4	538	538	CD
18637	10502	5	"	"	``
18637	10502	6	Cases	case	NNS
18637	10502	7	and	and	CC
18637	10502	8	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	10502	9	"	"	``
18637	10502	10	538	538	CD
18637	10502	11	Two	two	CD
18637	10502	12	classes	class	NNS
18637	10502	13	of	of	IN
18637	10502	14	"	"	``
18637	10502	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	10502	16	and	and	CC
18637	10502	17	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	10502	18	"	"	``
18637	10502	19	538	538	CD
18637	10502	20	Adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	10502	21	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	10502	22	539	539	CD
18637	10502	23	Stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	10502	24	'	'	POS
18637	10502	25	suits	suit	VBZ
18637	10502	26	541	541	CD
18637	10502	27	Substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	10502	28	interest	interest	NN
18637	10502	29	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	10502	30	542	542	CD
18637	10502	31	Substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	10502	32	interest	interest	NN
18637	10502	33	in	in	IN
18637	10502	34	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10502	35	by	by	IN
18637	10502	36	States	state	NNS
18637	10502	37	543	543	CD
18637	10502	38	Abstract	Abstract	NNP
18637	10502	39	,	,	,
18637	10502	40	contingent	contingent	JJ
18637	10502	41	,	,	,
18637	10502	42	and	and	CC
18637	10502	43	hypothetical	hypothetical	JJ
18637	10502	44	questions	question	NNS
18637	10502	45	544	544	CD
18637	10502	46	Political	political	JJ
18637	10502	47	questions	question	NNS
18637	10502	48	546	546	CD
18637	10502	49	Origin	origin	NN
18637	10502	50	of	of	IN
18637	10502	51	the	the	DT
18637	10502	52	concept	concept	NN
18637	10502	53	546	546	CD
18637	10502	54	Exemplifications	Exemplifications	NNPS
18637	10502	55	of	of	IN
18637	10502	56	the	the	DT
18637	10502	57	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	10502	58	547	547	CD
18637	10502	59	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	10502	60	cases	case	NNS
18637	10502	61	548	548	CD
18637	10502	62	Advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	10502	63	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	10502	64	549	549	CD
18637	10502	65	Declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	10502	66	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	10502	67	551	551	CD
18637	10502	68	Declaratory	Declaratory	NNP
18637	10502	69	Judgment	Judgment	NNP
18637	10502	70	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10502	71	of	of	IN
18637	10502	72	1934	1934	CD
18637	10502	73	551	551	CD
18637	10502	74	"	"	``
18637	10502	75	Case	case	NN
18637	10502	76	or	or	CC
18637	10502	77	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10502	78	"	"	''
18637	10502	79	test	test	NN
18637	10502	80	in	in	IN
18637	10502	81	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	10502	82	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10502	83	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10502	84	552	552	CD
18637	10502	85	Cases	case	NNS
18637	10502	86	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10502	87	under	under	IN
18637	10502	88	the	the	DT
18637	10502	89	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10502	90	,	,	,
18637	10502	91	laws	law	NNS
18637	10502	92	,	,	,
18637	10502	93	and	and	CC
18637	10502	94	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	10502	95	of	of	IN
18637	10502	96	the	the	DT
18637	10502	97	United	United	NNP
18637	10502	98	States	States	NNP
18637	10502	99	553	553	CD
18637	10502	100	Definition	Definition	NNP
18637	10502	101	553	553	CD
18637	10502	102	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10502	103	review	review	NN
18637	10502	104	554	554	CD
18637	10502	105	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10502	106	review	review	NN
18637	10502	107	and	and	CC
18637	10502	108	national	national	JJ
18637	10502	109	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	10502	110	554	554	CD
18637	10502	111	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10502	112	review	review	NN
18637	10502	113	of	of	IN
18637	10502	114	acts	act	NNS
18637	10502	115	of	of	IN
18637	10502	116	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10502	117	556	556	NNP
18637	10502	118	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	10502	119	's	's	POS
18637	10502	120	argument	argument	NN
18637	10502	121	558	558	CD
18637	10502	122	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	10502	123	_	_	NNP
18637	10502	124	v.	v.	IN
18637	10502	125	_	_	NNP
18637	10502	126	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	10502	127	559	559	CD
18637	10502	128	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	10502	129	's	's	POS
18637	10502	130	argument	argument	NN
18637	10502	131	559	559	CD
18637	10502	132	Importance	Importance	NNP
18637	10502	133	of	of	IN
18637	10502	134	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	10502	135	_	_	NNP
18637	10502	136	v.	v.	IN
18637	10502	137	_	_	NNP
18637	10502	138	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	10502	139	560	560	CD
18637	10502	140	Limits	Limits	NNPS
18637	10502	141	to	to	IN
18637	10502	142	the	the	DT
18637	10502	143	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10502	144	of	of	IN
18637	10502	145	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10502	146	review	review	NN
18637	10502	147	561	561	CD
18637	10502	148	The	the	DT
18637	10502	149	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	10502	150	of	of	IN
18637	10502	151	"	"	``
18637	10502	152	strict	strict	JJ
18637	10502	153	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	10502	154	"	"	''
18637	10502	155	562	562	CD
18637	10502	156	The	the	DT
18637	10502	157	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	10502	158	of	of	IN
18637	10502	159	political	political	JJ
18637	10502	160	questions	question	NNS
18637	10502	161	562	562	CD
18637	10502	162	The	the	DT
18637	10502	163	"	"	``
18637	10502	164	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	10502	165	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	10502	166	"	"	''
18637	10502	167	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	10502	168	563	563	CD
18637	10502	169	Exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	10502	170	of	of	IN
18637	10502	171	extra	extra	JJ
18637	10502	172	-	-	HYPH
18637	10502	173	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10502	174	tests	test	NNS
18637	10502	175	564	564	CD
18637	10502	176	Disallowance	disallowance	NN
18637	10502	177	by	by	IN
18637	10502	178	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	10502	179	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	10502	180	565	565	CD
18637	10502	181	Stare	Stare	NNP
18637	10502	182	decisis	decisis	NN
18637	10502	183	in	in	IN
18637	10502	184	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10502	185	law	law	NN
18637	10502	186	565	565	CD
18637	10502	187	Allegations	Allegations	NNPS
18637	10502	188	of	of	IN
18637	10502	189	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10502	190	question	question	NN
18637	10502	191	566	566	CD
18637	10502	192	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	10502	193	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	10502	194	by	by	IN
18637	10502	195	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10502	196	568	568	CD
18637	10502	197	Removal	Removal	NNP
18637	10502	198	from	from	IN
18637	10502	199	State	state	NN
18637	10502	200	courts	court	NNS
18637	10502	201	of	of	IN
18637	10502	202	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10502	203	against	against	IN
18637	10502	204	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10502	205	officials	official	NNS
18637	10502	206	568	568	CD
18637	10502	207	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	10502	208	_	_	NNP
18637	10502	209	v.	v.	IN
18637	10502	210	_	_	NNP
18637	10502	211	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	10502	212	569	569	CD
18637	10502	213	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10502	214	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10502	215	review	review	NN
18637	10502	216	of	of	IN
18637	10502	217	State	State	NNP
18637	10502	218	court	court	NN
18637	10502	219	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	10502	220	570	570	CD
18637	10502	221	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	10502	222	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	10502	223	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	10502	224	,	,	,
18637	10502	225	other	other	JJ
18637	10502	226	public	public	JJ
18637	10502	227	ministers	minister	NNS
18637	10502	228	,	,	,
18637	10502	229	and	and	CC
18637	10502	230	consuls	consuls	RB
18637	10502	231	571	571	CD
18637	10502	232	When	when	WRB
18637	10502	233	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	10502	234	,	,	,
18637	10502	235	etc	etc	FW
18637	10502	236	.	.	.
18637	10502	237	,	,	,
18637	10502	238	are	be	VBP
18637	10502	239	affected	affect	VBN
18637	10502	240	571	571	CD
18637	10502	241	Cases	case	NNS
18637	10502	242	of	of	IN
18637	10502	243	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	10502	244	and	and	CC
18637	10502	245	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	10502	246	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10502	247	572	572	CD
18637	10502	248	Origin	origin	NN
18637	10502	249	and	and	CC
18637	10502	250	characteristics	characteristic	NNS
18637	10502	251	572	572	CD
18637	10502	252	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	10502	253	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	10502	254	of	of	IN
18637	10502	255	the	the	DT
18637	10502	256	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	10502	257	clause	clause	NN
18637	10502	258	572	572	CD
18637	10502	259	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10502	260	approval	approval	NN
18637	10502	261	of	of	IN
18637	10502	262	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	10502	263	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	10502	264	573	573	CD
18637	10502	265	Two	two	CD
18637	10502	266	types	type	NNS
18637	10502	267	of	of	IN
18637	10502	268	cases	case	NNS
18637	10502	269	573	573	CD
18637	10502	270	Maritime	Maritime	NNP
18637	10502	271	torts	tort	VBZ
18637	10502	272	574	574	CD
18637	10502	273	Prize	Prize	NNP
18637	10502	274	cases	case	NNS
18637	10502	275	,	,	,
18637	10502	276	forfeitures	forfeiture	NNS
18637	10502	277	,	,	,
18637	10502	278	etc	etc	FW
18637	10502	279	.	.	.
18637	10503	1	575	575	CD
18637	10503	2	Proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10503	3	in	in	IN
18637	10503	4	rem	rem	NN
18637	10503	5	575	575	CD
18637	10503	6	Absence	absence	NN
18637	10503	7	of	of	IN
18637	10503	8	a	a	DT
18637	10503	9	jury	jury	NN
18637	10503	10	576	576	CD
18637	10503	11	Territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	10503	12	extent	extent	NN
18637	10503	13	of	of	IN
18637	10503	14	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	10503	15	and	and	CC
18637	10503	16	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	10503	17	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10503	18	576	576	CD
18637	10503	19	Admiralty	Admiralty	NNP
18637	10503	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10503	21	versus	versus	IN
18637	10503	22	State	state	NN
18637	10503	23	power	power	NN
18637	10503	24	578	578	CD
18637	10503	25	Exclusive	Exclusive	NNP
18637	10503	26	of	of	IN
18637	10503	27	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	10503	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10503	29	578	578	CD
18637	10503	30	Concessions	concession	NNS
18637	10503	31	to	to	IN
18637	10503	32	State	state	NN
18637	10503	33	power	power	NN
18637	10503	34	579	579	CD
18637	10503	35	The	the	DT
18637	10503	36	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	10503	37	case	case	NN
18637	10503	38	and	and	CC
18637	10503	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10503	40	sequelae	sequelae	NN
18637	10503	41	580	580	CD
18637	10503	42	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10503	43	of	of	IN
18637	10503	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10503	45	to	to	TO
18637	10503	46	modify	modify	VB
18637	10503	47	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	10503	48	law	law	NN
18637	10503	49	;	;	:
18637	10503	50	the	the	DT
18637	10503	51	"	"	``
18637	10503	52	Lottawanna	Lottawanna	NNP
18637	10503	53	"	"	''
18637	10503	54	582	582	CD
18637	10503	55	Cases	case	NNS
18637	10503	56	to	to	TO
18637	10503	57	which	which	WDT
18637	10503	58	the	the	DT
18637	10503	59	United	United	NNP
18637	10503	60	States	States	NNP
18637	10503	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	10503	62	a	a	DT
18637	10503	63	party	party	NN
18637	10503	64	;	;	:
18637	10503	65	right	right	RB
18637	10503	66	of	of	IN
18637	10503	67	United	United	NNP
18637	10503	68	States	States	NNP
18637	10503	69	to	to	TO
18637	10503	70	sue	sue	VB
18637	10503	71	584	584	CD
18637	10503	72	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	10503	73	against	against	IN
18637	10503	74	States	States	NNP
18637	10503	75	584	584	CD
18637	10503	76	Immunity	immunity	NN
18637	10503	77	of	of	IN
18637	10503	78	United	United	NNP
18637	10503	79	States	States	NNP
18637	10503	80	from	from	IN
18637	10503	81	suit	suit	NN
18637	10503	82	585	585	CD
18637	10503	83	Waiver	Waiver	NNP
18637	10503	84	of	of	IN
18637	10503	85	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	10503	86	by	by	IN
18637	10503	87	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10503	88	586	586	CD
18637	10503	89	United	United	NNP
18637	10503	90	States	States	NNP
18637	10503	91	_	_	NNP
18637	10503	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	10503	93	_	_	NNP
18637	10503	94	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	10503	95	587	587	CD
18637	10503	96	Difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	10503	97	created	create	VBN
18637	10503	98	by	by	IN
18637	10503	99	the	the	DT
18637	10503	100	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	10503	101	case	case	NN
18637	10503	102	588	588	CD
18637	10503	103	Official	official	JJ
18637	10503	104	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	10503	105	today	today	NN
18637	10503	106	589	589	CD
18637	10503	107	Classification	classification	NN
18637	10503	108	of	of	IN
18637	10503	109	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10503	110	against	against	IN
18637	10503	111	officers	officer	NNS
18637	10503	112	590	590	CD
18637	10503	113	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	10503	114	against	against	IN
18637	10503	115	government	government	NN
18637	10503	116	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	10503	117	590	590	CD
18637	10503	118	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	10503	119	between	between	IN
18637	10503	120	two	two	CD
18637	10503	121	or	or	CC
18637	10503	122	more	more	JJR
18637	10503	123	States	state	NNS
18637	10503	124	591	591	CD
18637	10503	125	Boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	10503	126	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	10503	127	;	;	:
18637	10503	128	the	the	DT
18637	10503	129	law	law	NN
18637	10503	130	applied	apply	VBD
18637	10503	131	591	591	CD
18637	10503	132	Modern	modern	JJ
18637	10503	133	types	type	NNS
18637	10503	134	of	of	IN
18637	10503	135	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10503	136	between	between	IN
18637	10503	137	States	States	NNP
18637	10503	138	592	592	CD
18637	10503	139	Cases	case	NNS
18637	10503	140	in	in	IN
18637	10503	141	which	which	WDT
18637	10503	142	the	the	DT
18637	10503	143	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10503	144	has	have	VBZ
18637	10503	145	declined	decline	VBN
18637	10503	146	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10503	147	594	594	CD
18637	10503	148	Problem	problem	NN
18637	10503	149	of	of	IN
18637	10503	150	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10503	151	;	;	:
18637	10503	152	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	10503	153	_	_	NNP
18637	10503	154	v.	v.	IN
18637	10503	155	_	_	NNP
18637	10503	156	West	West	NNP
18637	10503	157	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	10503	158	595	595	CD
18637	10503	159	Controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	10503	160	between	between	IN
18637	10503	161	a	a	DT
18637	10503	162	State	state	NN
18637	10503	163	and	and	CC
18637	10503	164	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	10503	165	of	of	IN
18637	10503	166	another	another	DT
18637	10503	167	State	state	NN
18637	10503	168	596	596	CD
18637	10503	169	Nonjusticiable	nonjusticiable	JJ
18637	10503	170	controversies	controversie	VBZ
18637	10503	171	596	596	CD
18637	10503	172	Jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10503	173	confined	confine	VBN
18637	10503	174	to	to	IN
18637	10503	175	civil	civil	JJ
18637	10503	176	cases	case	NNS
18637	10503	177	597	597	CD
18637	10503	178	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	10503	179	by	by	IN
18637	10503	180	a	a	DT
18637	10503	181	State	State	NNP
18637	10503	182	as	as	IN
18637	10503	183	parens	paren	NNS
18637	10503	184	patriae	patriae	NNS
18637	10503	185	;	;	:
18637	10503	186	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10503	187	declined	decline	VBD
18637	10503	188	597	597	CD
18637	10503	189	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	10503	190	by	by	IN
18637	10503	191	a	a	DT
18637	10503	192	State	State	NNP
18637	10503	193	as	as	IN
18637	10503	194	parens	paren	NNS
18637	10503	195	patriae	patriae	NNS
18637	10503	196	;	;	:
18637	10503	197	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10503	198	accepted	accept	VBD
18637	10503	199	598	598	CD
18637	10503	200	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	10503	201	_	_	NNP
18637	10503	202	v.	v.	IN
18637	10503	203	_	_	NNP
18637	10503	204	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	10503	205	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	10503	206	598	598	CD
18637	10503	207	Controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	10503	208	between	between	IN
18637	10503	209	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	10503	210	of	of	IN
18637	10503	211	different	different	JJ
18637	10503	212	States	state	NNS
18637	10503	213	599	599	CD
18637	10503	214	The	the	DT
18637	10503	215	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	10503	216	of	of	IN
18637	10503	217	"	"	``
18637	10503	218	State	State	NNP
18637	10503	219	,	,	,
18637	10503	220	"	"	''
18637	10503	221	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	10503	222	_	_	NNP
18637	10503	223	v.	v.	IN
18637	10503	224	_	_	NNP
18637	10503	225	Ellzey	Ellzey	NNP
18637	10503	226	599	599	CD
18637	10503	227	Extension	Extension	NNP
18637	10503	228	of	of	IN
18637	10503	229	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10503	230	by	by	IN
18637	10503	231	act	act	NN
18637	10503	232	of	of	IN
18637	10503	233	1940	1940	CD
18637	10503	234	600	600	CD
18637	10503	235	Citizenship	Citizenship	NNP
18637	10503	236	,	,	,
18637	10503	237	natural	natural	JJ
18637	10503	238	persons	person	NNS
18637	10503	239	600	600	CD
18637	10503	240	Citizenship	Citizenship	NNP
18637	10503	241	,	,	,
18637	10503	242	corporations	corporation	VBZ
18637	10503	243	601	601	CD
18637	10503	244	Black	black	JJ
18637	10503	245	and	and	CC
18637	10503	246	White	White	NNP
18637	10503	247	Taxicab	Taxicab	NNP
18637	10503	248	case	case	NN
18637	10503	249	603	603	CD
18637	10503	250	The	the	DT
18637	10503	251	law	law	NN
18637	10503	252	applied	apply	VBD
18637	10503	253	in	in	IN
18637	10503	254	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	10503	255	cases	case	NNS
18637	10503	256	;	;	:
18637	10503	257	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	10503	258	_	_	NNP
18637	10503	259	v.	v.	IN
18637	10503	260	_	_	NNP
18637	10503	261	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	10503	262	603	603	CD
18637	10503	263	Extension	Extension	NNP
18637	10503	264	of	of	IN
18637	10503	265	the	the	DT
18637	10503	266	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	10503	267	case	case	NN
18637	10503	268	604	604	CD
18637	10503	269	The	the	DT
18637	10503	270	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	10503	271	rule	rule	NN
18637	10503	272	protested	protest	VBD
18637	10503	273	604	604	CD
18637	10503	274	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	10503	275	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	10503	276	_	_	NNP
18637	10503	277	v.	v.	IN
18637	10503	278	_	_	NNP
18637	10503	279	Tompkins	Tompkins	NNPS
18637	10503	280	;	;	:
18637	10503	281	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	10503	282	case	case	NN
18637	10503	283	overruled	overrule	VBD
18637	10503	284	605	605	CD
18637	10503	285	Extension	Extension	NNP
18637	10503	286	of	of	IN
18637	10503	287	the	the	DT
18637	10503	288	Tompkins	Tompkins	NNP
18637	10503	289	rule	rule	NN
18637	10503	290	607	607	CD
18637	10503	291	Controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	10503	292	between	between	IN
18637	10503	293	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	10503	294	of	of	IN
18637	10503	295	the	the	DT
18637	10503	296	same	same	JJ
18637	10503	297	State	State	NNP
18637	10503	298	claiming	claiming	NN
18637	10503	299	lands	land	NNS
18637	10503	300	under	under	IN
18637	10503	301	grants	grant	NNS
18637	10503	302	of	of	IN
18637	10503	303	different	different	JJ
18637	10503	304	States	state	NNS
18637	10503	305	608	608	CD
18637	10503	306	Controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	10503	307	between	between	IN
18637	10503	308	a	a	DT
18637	10503	309	State	state	NN
18637	10503	310	,	,	,
18637	10503	311	or	or	CC
18637	10503	312	the	the	DT
18637	10503	313	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	10503	314	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	10503	315	,	,	,
18637	10503	316	and	and	CC
18637	10503	317	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	10503	318	States	state	NNS
18637	10503	319	,	,	,
18637	10503	320	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	10503	321	,	,	,
18637	10503	322	or	or	CC
18637	10503	323	subjects	subject	VBZ
18637	10503	324	609	609	CD
18637	10503	325	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	10503	326	by	by	IN
18637	10503	327	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	10503	328	States	state	NNS
18637	10503	329	609	609	CD
18637	10503	330	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	10503	331	tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	10503	332	610	610	CD
18637	10503	333	Narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	10503	334	construction	construction	NN
18637	10503	335	of	of	IN
18637	10503	336	the	the	DT
18637	10503	337	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10503	338	610	610	CD
18637	10503	339	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	10503	340	2	2	CD
18637	10503	341	.	.	.
18637	10504	1	Original	original	JJ
18637	10504	2	and	and	CC
18637	10504	3	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	10504	4	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10504	5	of	of	IN
18637	10504	6	the	the	DT
18637	10504	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10504	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10504	9	611	611	CD
18637	10504	10	Original	original	JJ
18637	10504	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10504	12	of	of	IN
18637	10504	13	the	the	DT
18637	10504	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10504	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10504	16	611	611	CD
18637	10504	17	An	an	DT
18637	10504	18	autonomous	autonomous	JJ
18637	10504	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10504	20	611	611	CD
18637	10504	21	Can	can	MD
18637	10504	22	not	not	RB
18637	10504	23	be	be	VB
18637	10504	24	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
18637	10504	25	;	;	:
18637	10504	26	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	10504	27	_	_	NNP
18637	10504	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	10504	29	_	_	NNP
18637	10504	30	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	10504	31	612	612	CD
18637	10504	32	Concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	10504	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10504	34	of	of	IN
18637	10504	35	the	the	DT
18637	10504	36	lower	low	JJR
18637	10504	37	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10504	38	courts	court	NNS
18637	10504	39	613	613	CD
18637	10504	40	Appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	10504	41	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10504	42	of	of	IN
18637	10504	43	the	the	DT
18637	10504	44	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10504	45	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10504	46	614	614	CD
18637	10504	47	Subject	subject	JJ
18637	10504	48	to	to	IN
18637	10504	49	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	10504	50	by	by	IN
18637	10504	51	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10504	52	614	614	CD
18637	10504	53	McCardle	McCardle	NNP
18637	10504	54	case	case	NN
18637	10504	55	614	614	CD
18637	10504	56	Power	power	NN
18637	10504	57	of	of	IN
18637	10504	58	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10504	59	to	to	TO
18637	10504	60	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	10504	61	the	the	DT
18637	10504	62	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10504	63	of	of	IN
18637	10504	64	lower	low	JJR
18637	10504	65	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10504	66	courts	court	NNS
18637	10504	67	616	616	CD
18637	10504	68	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	10504	69	_	_	NNP
18637	10504	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	10504	71	_	_	NNP
18637	10504	72	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	10504	73	's	's	POS
18637	10504	74	lessee	lessee	NN
18637	10504	75	616	616	CD
18637	10504	76	Plenary	Plenary	NNP
18637	10504	77	power	power	NN
18637	10504	78	of	of	IN
18637	10504	79	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10504	80	over	over	IN
18637	10504	81	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10504	82	616	616	CD
18637	10504	83	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10504	84	power	power	NN
18637	10504	85	under	under	IN
18637	10504	86	the	the	DT
18637	10504	87	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	10504	88	Price	Price	NNP
18637	10504	89	Control	Control	NNP
18637	10504	90	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10504	91	620	620	CD
18637	10504	92	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10504	93	control	control	NN
18637	10504	94	over	over	IN
18637	10504	95	writs	writ	NNS
18637	10504	96	621	621	CD
18637	10504	97	Injunctions	Injunctions	NNPS
18637	10504	98	in	in	IN
18637	10504	99	labor	labor	NN
18637	10504	100	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	10504	101	;	;	:
18637	10504	102	Norris	Norris	NNP
18637	10504	103	-	-	HYPH
18637	10504	104	LaGuardia	LaGuardia	NNP
18637	10504	105	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10504	106	621	621	CD
18637	10504	107	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10504	108	power	power	NN
18637	10504	109	equated	equate	VBD
18637	10504	110	with	with	IN
18637	10504	111	due	due	JJ
18637	10504	112	process	process	NN
18637	10504	113	of	of	IN
18637	10504	114	law	law	NN
18637	10504	115	622	622	CD
18637	10504	116	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10504	117	versus	versus	IN
18637	10504	118	nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	10504	119	functions	function	NNS
18637	10504	120	623	623	CD
18637	10504	121	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10504	122	-	-	HYPH
18637	10504	123	State	State	NNP
18637	10504	124	court	court	NN
18637	10504	125	relations	relation	NNS
18637	10504	126	624	624	CD
18637	10504	127	Problems	problem	NNS
18637	10504	128	raised	raise	VBN
18637	10504	129	by	by	IN
18637	10504	130	concurrency	concurrency	NN
18637	10504	131	624	624	CD
18637	10504	132	Disobedience	Disobedience	NNP
18637	10504	133	of	of	IN
18637	10504	134	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10504	135	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10504	136	orders	order	NNS
18637	10504	137	by	by	IN
18637	10504	138	State	state	NN
18637	10504	139	courts	court	NNS
18637	10504	140	625	625	CD
18637	10504	141	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
18637	10504	142	_	_	NNP
18637	10504	143	v.	v.	IN
18637	10504	144	_	_	NNP
18637	10504	145	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	10504	146	625	625	CD
18637	10504	147	Conflicts	Conflicts	NNPS
18637	10504	148	of	of	IN
18637	10504	149	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10504	150	;	;	:
18637	10504	151	comity	comity	NN
18637	10504	152	626	626	CD
18637	10504	153	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	10504	154	of	of	IN
18637	10504	155	the	the	DT
18637	10504	156	_	_	NNP
18637	10504	157	res	res	NNP
18637	10504	158	_	_	NNP
18637	10504	159	626	626	CD
18637	10504	160	State	State	NNP
18637	10504	161	interference	interference	NN
18637	10504	162	by	by	IN
18637	10504	163	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	10504	164	with	with	IN
18637	10504	165	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10504	166	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10504	167	627	627	CD
18637	10504	168	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10504	169	interference	interference	NN
18637	10504	170	by	by	IN
18637	10504	171	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	10504	172	with	with	IN
18637	10504	173	State	State	NNP
18637	10504	174	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10504	175	628	628	CD
18637	10504	176	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10504	177	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	10504	178	against	against	IN
18637	10504	179	State	State	NNP
18637	10504	180	official	official	JJ
18637	10504	181	action	action	NN
18637	10504	182	629	629	CD
18637	10504	183	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	10504	184	parte	parte	NN
18637	10504	185	Young	Young	NNP
18637	10504	186	630	630	CD
18637	10504	187	State	State	NNP
18637	10504	188	interference	interference	NN
18637	10504	189	by	by	IN
18637	10504	190	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	10504	191	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	10504	192	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10504	193	with	with	IN
18637	10504	194	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10504	195	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10504	196	631	631	CD
18637	10504	197	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10504	198	interference	interference	NN
18637	10504	199	,	,	,
18637	10504	200	by	by	IN
18637	10504	201	removal	removal	NN
18637	10504	202	and	and	CC
18637	10504	203	habeas	habea	NNS
18637	10504	204	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	10504	205	632	632	CD
18637	10504	206	Comity	comity	NN
18637	10504	207	as	as	IN
18637	10504	208	a	a	DT
18637	10504	209	principle	principle	NN
18637	10504	210	of	of	IN
18637	10504	211	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	10504	212	construction	construction	NN
18637	10504	213	633	633	CD
18637	10504	214	Comity	Comity	NNP
18637	10504	215	as	as	IN
18637	10504	216	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	10504	217	634	634	CD
18637	10504	218	Early	early	JJ
18637	10504	219	use	use	NN
18637	10504	220	of	of	IN
18637	10504	221	State	state	NN
18637	10504	222	courts	court	NNS
18637	10504	223	in	in	IN
18637	10504	224	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10504	225	of	of	IN
18637	10504	226	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10504	227	law	law	NN
18637	10504	228	635	635	CD
18637	10504	229	Retreat	Retreat	NNP
18637	10504	230	from	from	IN
18637	10504	231	this	this	DT
18637	10504	232	practice	practice	NN
18637	10504	233	636	636	CD
18637	10504	234	Resumption	resumption	NN
18637	10504	235	of	of	IN
18637	10504	236	this	this	DT
18637	10504	237	practice	practice	NN
18637	10504	238	636	636	CD
18637	10504	239	State	state	NN
18637	10504	240	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	10504	241	to	to	TO
18637	10504	242	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	10504	243	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10504	244	law	law	NN
18637	10504	245	637	637	CD
18637	10504	246	Right	right	NN
18637	10504	247	of	of	IN
18637	10504	248	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	10504	249	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	10504	250	to	to	TO
18637	10504	251	resort	resort	VB
18637	10504	252	to	to	IN
18637	10504	253	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10504	254	courts	court	NNS
18637	10504	255	638	638	CD
18637	10504	256	Clause	clause	NN
18637	10504	257	3	3	CD
18637	10504	258	.	.	.
18637	10505	1	Trial	trial	NN
18637	10505	2	by	by	IN
18637	10505	3	jury	jury	NN
18637	10505	4	.	.	.
18637	10506	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10506	2	_	_	NNP
18637	10506	3	See	See	NNP
18637	10506	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10506	5	pp	pp	NNP
18637	10506	6	.	.	.
18637	10507	1	878	878	CD
18637	10507	2	-	-	SYM
18637	10507	3	880	880	CD
18637	10507	4	under	under	IN
18637	10507	5	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	10507	6	VI	VI	NNP
18637	10507	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10507	8	638	638	CD
18637	10507	9	Section	section	NN
18637	10507	10	3	3	CD
18637	10507	11	.	.	.
18637	10508	1	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	10508	2	638	638	CD
18637	10508	3	Clause	clause	NN
18637	10508	4	1	1	CD
18637	10508	5	.	.	.
18637	10509	1	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	10509	2	defined	define	VBD
18637	10509	3	638	638	CD
18637	10509	4	Definition	definition	NN
18637	10509	5	638	638	CD
18637	10509	6	Levying	levy	VBG
18637	10509	7	war	war	NN
18637	10509	8	639	639	CD
18637	10509	9	The	the	DT
18637	10509	10	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	10509	11	trial	trial	NN
18637	10509	12	640	640	CD
18637	10509	13	Aid	aid	NN
18637	10509	14	and	and	CC
18637	10509	15	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	10509	16	to	to	IN
18637	10509	17	the	the	DT
18637	10509	18	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	10509	19	;	;	:
18637	10509	20	the	the	DT
18637	10509	21	Cramer	Cramer	NNP
18637	10509	22	Case	Case	NNP
18637	10509	23	640	640	CD
18637	10509	24	The	the	DT
18637	10509	25	Haupt	Haupt	NNP
18637	10509	26	Case	case	NN
18637	10509	27	641	641	CD
18637	10509	28	The	the	DT
18637	10509	29	Kawakita	Kawakita	NNP
18637	10509	30	Case	case	NN
18637	10509	31	643	643	CD
18637	10509	32	Doubtful	Doubtful	NNP
18637	10509	33	State	State	NNP
18637	10509	34	of	of	IN
18637	10509	35	the	the	DT
18637	10509	36	law	law	NN
18637	10509	37	of	of	IN
18637	10509	38	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	10509	39	today	today	NN
18637	10509	40	644	644	CD
18637	10509	41	Clause	clause	NN
18637	10509	42	2	2	CD
18637	10509	43	.	.	.
18637	10510	1	Punishment	punishment	NN
18637	10510	2	of	of	IN
18637	10510	3	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	10510	4	645	645	CD
18637	10510	5	Corruption	Corruption	NNP
18637	10510	6	of	of	IN
18637	10510	7	blood	blood	NN
18637	10510	8	and	and	CC
18637	10510	9	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	10510	10	645	645	CD
18637	10510	11	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	10510	12	DEPARTMENT	DEPARTMENT	NNP
18637	10510	13	Article	Article	NNP
18637	10510	14	III	III	NNP
18637	10510	15	Section	Section	NNP
18637	10510	16	1	1	CD
18637	10510	17	.	.	.
18637	10511	1	The	the	DT
18637	10511	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10511	3	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10511	4	of	of	IN
18637	10511	5	the	the	DT
18637	10511	6	United	United	NNP
18637	10511	7	States	States	NNP
18637	10511	8	,	,	,
18637	10511	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	10511	10	be	be	VB
18637	10511	11	vested	vest	VBN
18637	10511	12	in	in	IN
18637	10511	13	one	one	CD
18637	10511	14	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	10511	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10511	16	,	,	,
18637	10511	17	and	and	CC
18637	10511	18	in	in	IN
18637	10511	19	such	such	JJ
18637	10511	20	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	10511	21	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	10511	22	as	as	IN
18637	10511	23	the	the	DT
18637	10511	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10511	25	may	may	MD
18637	10511	26	from	from	IN
18637	10511	27	time	time	NN
18637	10511	28	to	to	IN
18637	10511	29	time	time	NN
18637	10511	30	ordain	ordain	NN
18637	10511	31	and	and	CC
18637	10511	32	establish	establish	VB
18637	10511	33	.	.	.
18637	10512	1	The	the	DT
18637	10512	2	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	10512	3	,	,	,
18637	10512	4	both	both	DT
18637	10512	5	of	of	IN
18637	10512	6	the	the	DT
18637	10512	7	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	10512	8	and	and	CC
18637	10512	9	inferior	inferior	NNP
18637	10512	10	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	10512	11	,	,	,
18637	10512	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	10512	13	hold	hold	VB
18637	10512	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10512	15	Offices	office	NNS
18637	10512	16	during	during	IN
18637	10512	17	good	good	JJ
18637	10512	18	Behaviour	Behaviour	NNP
18637	10512	19	,	,	,
18637	10512	20	and	and	CC
18637	10512	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	10512	22	,	,	,
18637	10512	23	at	at	IN
18637	10512	24	stated	state	VBN
18637	10512	25	Times	Times	NNP
18637	10512	26	,	,	,
18637	10512	27	receive	receive	VB
18637	10512	28	for	for	IN
18637	10512	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10512	30	Services	Services	NNPS
18637	10512	31	,	,	,
18637	10512	32	a	a	DT
18637	10512	33	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	10512	34	,	,	,
18637	10512	35	which	which	WDT
18637	10512	36	shall	shall	MD
18637	10512	37	not	not	RB
18637	10512	38	be	be	VB
18637	10512	39	diminished	diminish	VBN
18637	10512	40	during	during	IN
18637	10512	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10512	42	Continuance	Continuance	NNP
18637	10512	43	in	in	IN
18637	10512	44	Office	Office	NNP
18637	10512	45	.	.	.
18637	10513	1	Characteristics	Characteristics	NNP
18637	10513	2	and	and	CC
18637	10513	3	Attributes	Attributes	NNPS
18637	10513	4	of	of	IN
18637	10513	5	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	10513	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10513	7	"	"	''
18637	10513	8	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	10513	9	POWER	POWER	NNP
18637	10513	10	"	"	''
18637	10513	11	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10513	12	power	power	NN
18637	10513	13	,	,	,
18637	10513	14	as	as	IN
18637	10513	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10513	16	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	10513	17	defined	define	VBD
18637	10513	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10513	19	in	in	IN
18637	10513	20	1891	1891	CD
18637	10513	21	,	,	,
18637	10513	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	10513	23	the	the	DT
18637	10513	24	power	power	NN
18637	10513	25	"	"	''
18637	10513	26	of	of	IN
18637	10513	27	a	a	DT
18637	10513	28	court	court	NN
18637	10513	29	to	to	TO
18637	10513	30	decide	decide	VB
18637	10513	31	and	and	CC
18637	10513	32	pronounce	pronounce	VB
18637	10513	33	a	a	DT
18637	10513	34	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10513	35	and	and	CC
18637	10513	36	carry	carry	VB
18637	10513	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10513	38	into	into	IN
18637	10513	39	effect	effect	NN
18637	10513	40	between	between	IN
18637	10513	41	persons	person	NNS
18637	10513	42	and	and	CC
18637	10513	43	parties	party	NNS
18637	10513	44	who	who	WP
18637	10513	45	bring	bring	VBP
18637	10513	46	a	a	DT
18637	10513	47	case	case	NN
18637	10513	48	before	before	IN
18637	10513	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10513	50	for	for	IN
18637	10513	51	decision";[1	decision";[1	NNS
18637	10513	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10513	53	or	or	CC
18637	10513	54	in	in	IN
18637	10513	55	the	the	DT
18637	10513	56	words	word	NNS
18637	10513	57	of	of	IN
18637	10513	58	the	the	DT
18637	10513	59	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10513	60	in	in	IN
18637	10513	61	Muskrat	Muskrat	NNP
18637	10513	62	_	_	NNP
18637	10513	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	10513	64	_	_	NNP
18637	10513	65	United	United	NNP
18637	10513	66	States,[2	States,[2	NNP
18637	10513	67	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10513	68	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10513	69	is	be	VBZ
18637	10513	70	"	"	``
18637	10513	71	the	the	DT
18637	10513	72	right	right	NN
18637	10513	73	to	to	TO
18637	10513	74	determine	determine	VB
18637	10513	75	actual	actual	JJ
18637	10513	76	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	10513	77	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10513	78	between	between	IN
18637	10513	79	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	10513	80	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	10513	81	,	,	,
18637	10513	82	duly	duly	RB
18637	10513	83	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	10513	84	in	in	IN
18637	10513	85	courts	court	NNS
18637	10513	86	of	of	IN
18637	10513	87	proper	proper	JJ
18637	10513	88	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10513	89	.	.	.
18637	10514	1	"	"	``
18637	10514	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10514	3	3	3	CD
18637	10514	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10514	5	Although	although	IN
18637	10514	6	the	the	DT
18637	10514	7	terms	term	NNS
18637	10514	8	"	"	``
18637	10514	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10514	10	power	power	NN
18637	10514	11	"	"	''
18637	10514	12	and	and	CC
18637	10514	13	"	"	``
18637	10514	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10514	15	"	"	''
18637	10514	16	are	be	VBP
18637	10514	17	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	10514	18	used	use	VBN
18637	10514	19	interchangeably	interchangeably	RB
18637	10514	20	and	and	CC
18637	10514	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10514	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	10514	23	defined	define	VBN
18637	10514	24	as	as	IN
18637	10514	25	the	the	DT
18637	10514	26	power	power	NN
18637	10514	27	to	to	TO
18637	10514	28	hear	hear	VB
18637	10514	29	and	and	CC
18637	10514	30	determine	determine	VB
18637	10514	31	the	the	DT
18637	10514	32	subject	subject	JJ
18637	10514	33	matter	matter	NN
18637	10514	34	in	in	IN
18637	10514	35	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10514	36	between	between	IN
18637	10514	37	parties	party	NNS
18637	10514	38	to	to	IN
18637	10514	39	a	a	DT
18637	10514	40	suit,[4	suit,[4	XX
18637	10514	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10514	42	or	or	CC
18637	10514	43	as	as	IN
18637	10514	44	the	the	DT
18637	10514	45	"	"	``
18637	10514	46	power	power	NN
18637	10514	47	to	to	TO
18637	10514	48	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	10514	49	the	the	DT
18637	10514	50	suit	suit	NN
18637	10514	51	,	,	,
18637	10514	52	consider	consider	VB
18637	10514	53	the	the	DT
18637	10514	54	merits	merit	NNS
18637	10514	55	and	and	CC
18637	10514	56	render	render	VB
18637	10514	57	a	a	DT
18637	10514	58	binding	bind	VBG
18637	10514	59	decision	decision	NN
18637	10514	60	thereon,"[5	thereon,"[5	CD
18637	10514	61	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10514	62	the	the	DT
18637	10514	63	cases	case	NNS
18637	10514	64	and	and	CC
18637	10514	65	commentaries	commentary	NNS
18637	10514	66	support	support	VBP
18637	10514	67	and	and	CC
18637	10514	68	,	,	,
18637	10514	69	for	for	IN
18637	10514	70	that	that	DT
18637	10514	71	matter	matter	NN
18637	10514	72	,	,	,
18637	10514	73	necessitate	necessitate	VBP
18637	10514	74	a	a	DT
18637	10514	75	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	10514	76	between	between	IN
18637	10514	77	the	the	DT
18637	10514	78	two	two	CD
18637	10514	79	concepts	concept	NNS
18637	10514	80	.	.	.
18637	10515	1	Jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10515	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	10515	3	the	the	DT
18637	10515	4	authority	authority	NN
18637	10515	5	of	of	IN
18637	10515	6	a	a	DT
18637	10515	7	court	court	NN
18637	10515	8	to	to	TO
18637	10515	9	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	10515	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10515	11	power	power	NN
18637	10515	12	in	in	IN
18637	10515	13	a	a	DT
18637	10515	14	specific	specific	JJ
18637	10515	15	case	case	NN
18637	10515	16	and	and	CC
18637	10515	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	10515	18	,	,	,
18637	10515	19	of	of	IN
18637	10515	20	course	course	NN
18637	10515	21	,	,	,
18637	10515	22	a	a	DT
18637	10515	23	prerequisite	prerequisite	NN
18637	10515	24	to	to	IN
18637	10515	25	the	the	DT
18637	10515	26	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10515	27	of	of	IN
18637	10515	28	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10515	29	power	power	NN
18637	10515	30	,	,	,
18637	10515	31	which	which	WDT
18637	10515	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	10515	33	the	the	DT
18637	10515	34	totality	totality	NN
18637	10515	35	of	of	IN
18637	10515	36	powers	power	NNS
18637	10515	37	a	a	DT
18637	10515	38	court	court	NN
18637	10515	39	exercises	exercise	VBZ
18637	10515	40	when	when	WRB
18637	10515	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10515	42	assumes	assume	VBZ
18637	10515	43	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10515	44	and	and	CC
18637	10515	45	hears	hear	NNS
18637	10515	46	and	and	CC
18637	10515	47	decides	decide	VBZ
18637	10515	48	a	a	DT
18637	10515	49	case	case	NN
18637	10515	50	.	.	.
18637	10516	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10516	2	6	6	CD
18637	10516	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10516	4	Included	include	VBN
18637	10516	5	with	with	IN
18637	10516	6	the	the	DT
18637	10516	7	general	general	JJ
18637	10516	8	power	power	NN
18637	10516	9	to	to	TO
18637	10516	10	decide	decide	VB
18637	10516	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	10516	12	are	be	VBP
18637	10516	13	the	the	DT
18637	10516	14	ancillary	ancillary	JJ
18637	10516	15	powers	power	NNS
18637	10516	16	of	of	IN
18637	10516	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	10516	18	to	to	TO
18637	10516	19	punish	punish	VB
18637	10516	20	for	for	IN
18637	10516	21	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	10516	22	of	of	IN
18637	10516	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10516	24	authority,[7	authority,[7	NNS
18637	10516	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10516	26	to	to	TO
18637	10516	27	issue	issue	VB
18637	10516	28	writs	writ	NNS
18637	10516	29	in	in	IN
18637	10516	30	aid	aid	NN
18637	10516	31	of	of	IN
18637	10516	32	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10516	33	when	when	WRB
18637	10516	34	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	10516	35	by	by	IN
18637	10516	36	statute;[8	statute;[8	NN
18637	10516	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10516	38	to	to	TO
18637	10516	39	make	make	VB
18637	10516	40	rules	rule	NNS
18637	10516	41	governing	govern	VBG
18637	10516	42	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10516	43	process	process	NN
18637	10516	44	in	in	IN
18637	10516	45	the	the	DT
18637	10516	46	absence	absence	NN
18637	10516	47	of	of	IN
18637	10516	48	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	10516	49	authorizations	authorization	NNS
18637	10516	50	or	or	CC
18637	10516	51	prohibitions;[9	prohibitions;[9	JJ
18637	10516	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10516	53	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10516	54	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	10516	55	powers	power	NNS
18637	10516	56	over	over	IN
18637	10516	57	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10516	58	own	own	JJ
18637	10516	59	process	process	NN
18637	10516	60	to	to	TO
18637	10516	61	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	10516	62	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	10516	63	,	,	,
18637	10516	64	oppression	oppression	NN
18637	10516	65	and	and	CC
18637	10516	66	injustice	injustice	NN
18637	10516	67	,	,	,
18637	10516	68	and	and	CC
18637	10516	69	to	to	TO
18637	10516	70	protect	protect	VB
18637	10516	71	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10516	72	own	own	JJ
18637	10516	73	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10516	74	and	and	CC
18637	10516	75	officers	officer	NNS
18637	10516	76	in	in	IN
18637	10516	77	the	the	DT
18637	10516	78	protection	protection	NN
18637	10516	79	of	of	IN
18637	10516	80	property	property	NN
18637	10516	81	in	in	IN
18637	10516	82	custody	custody	NN
18637	10516	83	of	of	IN
18637	10516	84	law;[10	law;[10	NNP
18637	10516	85	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10516	86	the	the	DT
18637	10516	87	power	power	NN
18637	10516	88	to	to	TO
18637	10516	89	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	10516	90	masters	master	NNS
18637	10516	91	in	in	IN
18637	10516	92	chancery	chancery	NN
18637	10516	93	,	,	,
18637	10516	94	referees	referee	NNS
18637	10516	95	,	,	,
18637	10516	96	auditors	auditor	NNS
18637	10516	97	,	,	,
18637	10516	98	and	and	CC
18637	10516	99	other	other	JJ
18637	10516	100	investigators;[11	investigators;[11	NNP
18637	10516	101	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10516	102	and	and	CC
18637	10516	103	to	to	TO
18637	10516	104	admit	admit	VB
18637	10516	105	and	and	CC
18637	10516	106	disbar	disbar	NN
18637	10516	107	attorneys	attorney	NNS
18637	10516	108	.	.	.
18637	10517	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10517	2	12	12	CD
18637	10517	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10517	4	"	"	``
18637	10517	5	SHALL	SHALL	NNP
18637	10517	6	BE	be	VB
18637	10517	7	VESTED	vest	VBN
18637	10517	8	"	"	``
18637	10517	9	The	the	DT
18637	10517	10	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	10517	11	between	between	IN
18637	10517	12	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10517	13	power	power	NN
18637	10517	14	and	and	CC
18637	10517	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10517	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	10517	17	especially	especially	RB
18637	10517	18	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	10517	19	to	to	IN
18637	10517	20	the	the	DT
18637	10517	21	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	10517	22	of	of	IN
18637	10517	23	the	the	DT
18637	10517	24	words	word	NNS
18637	10517	25	"	"	``
18637	10517	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	10517	27	be	be	VB
18637	10517	28	vested	vest	VBN
18637	10517	29	.	.	.
18637	10517	30	"	"	''
18637	10518	1	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	10518	2	all	all	DT
18637	10518	3	of	of	IN
18637	10518	4	the	the	DT
18637	10518	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10518	6	power	power	NN
18637	10518	7	of	of	IN
18637	10518	8	the	the	DT
18637	10518	9	United	United	NNP
18637	10518	10	States	States	NNP
18637	10518	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	10518	12	vested	vest	VBN
18637	10518	13	in	in	IN
18637	10518	14	the	the	DT
18637	10518	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10518	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10518	17	and	and	CC
18637	10518	18	the	the	DT
18637	10518	19	lower	low	JJR
18637	10518	20	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10518	21	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	10518	22	,	,	,
18637	10518	23	neither	neither	DT
18637	10518	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	10518	25	ever	ever	RB
18637	10518	26	been	be	VBN
18637	10518	27	vested	vest	VBN
18637	10518	28	with	with	IN
18637	10518	29	all	all	PDT
18637	10518	30	the	the	DT
18637	10518	31	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10518	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10518	33	are	be	VBP
18637	10518	34	capable	capable	JJ
18637	10518	35	of	of	IN
18637	10518	36	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	10518	37	under	under	IN
18637	10518	38	article	article	NN
18637	10518	39	III	iii	CD
18637	10518	40	.	.	.
18637	10519	1	Except	except	IN
18637	10519	2	for	for	IN
18637	10519	3	the	the	DT
18637	10519	4	original	original	JJ
18637	10519	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10519	6	of	of	IN
18637	10519	7	the	the	DT
18637	10519	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10519	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10519	10	,	,	,
18637	10519	11	which	which	WDT
18637	10519	12	flows	flow	VBZ
18637	10519	13	directly	directly	RB
18637	10519	14	from	from	IN
18637	10519	15	the	the	DT
18637	10519	16	Constitution,[13	constitution,[13	NN
18637	10519	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10519	18	two	two	CD
18637	10519	19	prerequisites	prerequisite	NNS
18637	10519	20	to	to	IN
18637	10519	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10519	22	must	must	MD
18637	10519	23	be	be	VB
18637	10519	24	present	present	JJ
18637	10519	25	.	.	.
18637	10520	1	First	first	RB
18637	10520	2	,	,	,
18637	10520	3	the	the	DT
18637	10520	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10520	5	must	must	MD
18637	10520	6	have	have	VB
18637	10520	7	given	give	VBN
18637	10520	8	the	the	DT
18637	10520	9	courts	court	NNS
18637	10520	10	the	the	DT
18637	10520	11	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	10520	12	to	to	TO
18637	10520	13	receive	receive	VB
18637	10520	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10520	15	;	;	:
18637	10520	16	second	second	LS
18637	10520	17	,	,	,
18637	10520	18	an	an	DT
18637	10520	19	act	act	NN
18637	10520	20	of	of	IN
18637	10520	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10520	22	must	must	MD
18637	10520	23	have	have	VB
18637	10520	24	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	10520	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10520	26	.	.	.
18637	10521	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10521	2	14	14	CD
18637	10521	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10521	4	FINALITY	finality	NN
18637	10521	5	OF	of	IN
18637	10521	6	JUDGMENT	JUDGMENT	NNP
18637	10521	7	Since	since	IN
18637	10521	8	1792	1792	CD
18637	10521	9	the	the	DT
18637	10521	10	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10521	11	courts	court	NNS
18637	10521	12	have	have	VBP
18637	10521	13	emphasized	emphasize	VBN
18637	10521	14	finality	finality	NN
18637	10521	15	of	of	IN
18637	10521	16	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10521	17	as	as	IN
18637	10521	18	an	an	DT
18637	10521	19	essential	essential	JJ
18637	10521	20	attribute	attribute	NN
18637	10521	21	of	of	IN
18637	10521	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10521	23	_	_	NNP
18637	10521	24	power	power	NN
18637	10521	25	_	_	NNP
18637	10521	26	.	.	.
18637	10522	1	In	in	IN
18637	10522	2	Hayburn	Hayburn	NNP
18637	10522	3	's	's	POS
18637	10522	4	Case[15	case[15	NN
18637	10522	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10522	6	a	a	DT
18637	10522	7	motion	motion	NN
18637	10522	8	for	for	IN
18637	10522	9	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	10522	10	was	be	VBD
18637	10522	11	filed	file	VBN
18637	10522	12	in	in	IN
18637	10522	13	the	the	DT
18637	10522	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10522	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10522	16	to	to	TO
18637	10522	17	direct	direct	VB
18637	10522	18	the	the	DT
18637	10522	19	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
18637	10522	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10522	21	for	for	IN
18637	10522	22	the	the	DT
18637	10522	23	District	District	NNP
18637	10522	24	of	of	IN
18637	10522	25	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	10522	26	to	to	TO
18637	10522	27	act	act	VB
18637	10522	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	10522	29	a	a	DT
18637	10522	30	petition	petition	NN
18637	10522	31	for	for	IN
18637	10522	32	a	a	DT
18637	10522	33	pension	pension	NN
18637	10522	34	under	under	IN
18637	10522	35	the	the	DT
18637	10522	36	pensions	pension	NNS
18637	10522	37	act	act	NN
18637	10522	38	which	which	WDT
18637	10522	39	placed	place	VBD
18637	10522	40	the	the	DT
18637	10522	41	administration	administration	NN
18637	10522	42	of	of	IN
18637	10522	43	pensions	pension	NNS
18637	10522	44	in	in	IN
18637	10522	45	the	the	DT
18637	10522	46	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10522	47	of	of	IN
18637	10522	48	the	the	DT
18637	10522	49	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10522	50	courts	court	NNS
18637	10522	51	,	,	,
18637	10522	52	but	but	CC
18637	10522	53	which	which	WDT
18637	10522	54	made	make	VBD
18637	10522	55	the	the	DT
18637	10522	56	action	action	NN
18637	10522	57	of	of	IN
18637	10522	58	the	the	DT
18637	10522	59	courts	court	NNS
18637	10522	60	on	on	IN
18637	10522	61	application	application	NN
18637	10522	62	subject	subject	JJ
18637	10522	63	to	to	IN
18637	10522	64	review	review	NN
18637	10522	65	by	by	IN
18637	10522	66	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10522	67	and	and	CC
18637	10522	68	the	the	DT
18637	10522	69	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10522	70	of	of	IN
18637	10522	71	War	War	NNP
18637	10522	72	.	.	.
18637	10523	1	The	the	DT
18637	10523	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10523	3	took	take	VBD
18637	10523	4	the	the	DT
18637	10523	5	case	case	NN
18637	10523	6	under	under	IN
18637	10523	7	advisement	advisement	NN
18637	10523	8	,	,	,
18637	10523	9	but	but	CC
18637	10523	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10523	11	changed	change	VBD
18637	10523	12	the	the	DT
18637	10523	13	law	law	NN
18637	10523	14	by	by	IN
18637	10523	15	the	the	DT
18637	10523	16	act	act	NN
18637	10523	17	of	of	IN
18637	10523	18	February	February	NNP
18637	10523	19	28	28	CD
18637	10523	20	,	,	,
18637	10523	21	1793	1793	CD
18637	10523	22	,	,	,
18637	10523	23	before	before	IN
18637	10523	24	decision	decision	NN
18637	10523	25	was	be	VBD
18637	10523	26	rendered	render	VBN
18637	10523	27	.	.	.
18637	10524	1	In	in	IN
18637	10524	2	view	view	NN
18637	10524	3	of	of	IN
18637	10524	4	the	the	DT
18637	10524	5	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	10524	6	of	of	IN
18637	10524	7	the	the	DT
18637	10524	8	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	10524	9	courts	court	NNS
18637	10524	10	of	of	IN
18637	10524	11	the	the	DT
18637	10524	12	United	United	NNP
18637	10524	13	States	States	NNP
18637	10524	14	for	for	IN
18637	10524	15	the	the	DT
18637	10524	16	districts	district	NNS
18637	10524	17	of	of	IN
18637	10524	18	New	New	NNP
18637	10524	19	York	York	NNP
18637	10524	20	,	,	,
18637	10524	21	North	North	NNP
18637	10524	22	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	10524	23	and	and	CC
18637	10524	24	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	10524	25	there	there	EX
18637	10524	26	can	can	MD
18637	10524	27	be	be	VB
18637	10524	28	no	no	RB
18637	10524	29	doubt	doubt	RB
18637	10524	30	what	what	WP
18637	10524	31	the	the	DT
18637	10524	32	decision	decision	NN
18637	10524	33	would	would	MD
18637	10524	34	have	have	VB
18637	10524	35	been	be	VBN
18637	10524	36	.	.	.
18637	10525	1	The	the	DT
18637	10525	2	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10525	3	of	of	IN
18637	10525	4	the	the	DT
18637	10525	5	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	10525	6	courts	court	NNS
18637	10525	7	in	in	IN
18637	10525	8	each	each	DT
18637	10525	9	of	of	IN
18637	10525	10	these	these	DT
18637	10525	11	districts	district	NNS
18637	10525	12	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	10525	13	to	to	TO
18637	10525	14	administer	administer	VB
18637	10525	15	the	the	DT
18637	10525	16	pensions	pension	NNS
18637	10525	17	,	,	,
18637	10525	18	because	because	IN
18637	10525	19	the	the	DT
18637	10525	20	revisory	revisory	JJ
18637	10525	21	powers	power	NNS
18637	10525	22	of	of	IN
18637	10525	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10525	24	and	and	CC
18637	10525	25	the	the	DT
18637	10525	26	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10525	27	of	of	IN
18637	10525	28	War	War	NNP
18637	10525	29	were	be	VBD
18637	10525	30	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	10525	31	as	as	IN
18637	10525	32	making	make	VBG
18637	10525	33	the	the	DT
18637	10525	34	administration	administration	NN
18637	10525	35	of	of	IN
18637	10525	36	the	the	DT
18637	10525	37	law	law	NN
18637	10525	38	nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	10525	39	in	in	IN
18637	10525	40	nature	nature	NN
18637	10525	41	.	.	.
18637	10526	1	At	at	IN
18637	10526	2	the	the	DT
18637	10526	3	time	time	NN
18637	10526	4	of	of	IN
18637	10526	5	this	this	DT
18637	10526	6	episode	episode	NN
18637	10526	7	,	,	,
18637	10526	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10526	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10526	10	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	10526	11	and	and	CC
18637	10526	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10526	13	Cushing	Cushing	NNP
18637	10526	14	were	be	VBD
18637	10526	15	members	member	NNS
18637	10526	16	of	of	IN
18637	10526	17	the	the	DT
18637	10526	18	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
18637	10526	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10526	20	in	in	IN
18637	10526	21	the	the	DT
18637	10526	22	New	New	NNP
18637	10526	23	York	York	NNP
18637	10526	24	district	district	NN
18637	10526	25	,	,	,
18637	10526	26	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	10526	27	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	10526	28	and	and	CC
18637	10526	29	Blair	Blair	NNP
18637	10526	30	in	in	IN
18637	10526	31	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	10526	32	and	and	CC
18637	10526	33	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10526	34	Iredell	Iredell	NNP
18637	10526	35	in	in	IN
18637	10526	36	North	North	NNP
18637	10526	37	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	10526	38	.	.	.
18637	10527	1	The	the	DT
18637	10527	2	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	10527	3	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	10527	4	On	on	IN
18637	10527	5	these	these	DT
18637	10527	6	foundations	foundation	NNS
18637	10527	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10527	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10527	9	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	10527	10	posthumously	posthumously	RB
18637	10527	11	erected	erect	VBD
18637	10527	12	finality	finality	NN
18637	10527	13	into	into	IN
18637	10527	14	a	a	DT
18637	10527	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10527	16	absolute	absolute	NN
18637	10527	17	.	.	.
18637	10528	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10528	2	16	16	CD
18637	10528	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10528	4	The	the	DT
18637	10528	5	original	original	JJ
18637	10528	6	act	act	NN
18637	10528	7	creating	create	VBG
18637	10528	8	the	the	DT
18637	10528	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10528	10	of	of	IN
18637	10528	11	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	10528	12	provided	provide	VBD
18637	10528	13	for	for	IN
18637	10528	14	an	an	DT
18637	10528	15	analogous	analogous	JJ
18637	10528	16	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	10528	17	with	with	IN
18637	10528	18	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	10528	19	to	to	IN
18637	10528	20	the	the	DT
18637	10528	21	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10528	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10528	23	after	after	IN
18637	10528	24	which	which	WDT
18637	10528	25	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	10528	26	in	in	IN
18637	10528	27	favor	favor	NN
18637	10528	28	of	of	IN
18637	10528	29	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	10528	30	were	be	VBD
18637	10528	31	to	to	TO
18637	10528	32	be	be	VB
18637	10528	33	referred	refer	VBN
18637	10528	34	to	to	IN
18637	10528	35	the	the	DT
18637	10528	36	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10528	37	of	of	IN
18637	10528	38	the	the	DT
18637	10528	39	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	10528	40	for	for	IN
18637	10528	41	payments	payment	NNS
18637	10528	42	out	out	IN
18637	10528	43	of	of	IN
18637	10528	44	the	the	DT
18637	10528	45	general	general	JJ
18637	10528	46	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	10528	47	for	for	IN
18637	10528	48	the	the	DT
18637	10528	49	payment	payment	NN
18637	10528	50	of	of	IN
18637	10528	51	private	private	JJ
18637	10528	52	claims	claim	NNS
18637	10528	53	.	.	.
18637	10529	1	However	however	RB
18637	10529	2	,	,	,
18637	10529	3	section	section	NN
18637	10529	4	14	14	CD
18637	10529	5	of	of	IN
18637	10529	6	the	the	DT
18637	10529	7	act	act	NN
18637	10529	8	provided	provide	VBD
18637	10529	9	that	that	IN
18637	10529	10	no	no	DT
18637	10529	11	money	money	NN
18637	10529	12	should	should	MD
18637	10529	13	be	be	VB
18637	10529	14	paid	pay	VBN
18637	10529	15	out	out	IN
18637	10529	16	of	of	IN
18637	10529	17	the	the	DT
18637	10529	18	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	10529	19	for	for	IN
18637	10529	20	any	any	DT
18637	10529	21	claims	claim	NNS
18637	10529	22	"	"	''
18637	10529	23	till	till	IN
18637	10529	24	after	after	IN
18637	10529	25	an	an	DT
18637	10529	26	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	10529	27	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	10529	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	10529	29	be	be	VB
18637	10529	30	estimated	estimate	VBN
18637	10529	31	by	by	IN
18637	10529	32	the	the	DT
18637	10529	33	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10529	34	of	of	IN
18637	10529	35	the	the	DT
18637	10529	36	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	10529	37	.	.	.
18637	10529	38	"	"	''
18637	10530	1	In	in	IN
18637	10530	2	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	10530	3	_	_	NNP
18637	10530	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	10530	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10530	6	United	United	NNP
18637	10530	7	States,[17	States,[17	NNP
18637	10530	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10530	9	the	the	DT
18637	10530	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10530	11	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	10530	12	to	to	TO
18637	10530	13	hear	hear	VB
18637	10530	14	an	an	DT
18637	10530	15	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	10530	16	,	,	,
18637	10530	17	probably	probably	RB
18637	10530	18	for	for	IN
18637	10530	19	the	the	DT
18637	10530	20	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	10530	21	given	give	VBN
18637	10530	22	in	in	IN
18637	10530	23	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10530	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10530	25	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	10530	26	's	's	POS
18637	10530	27	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10530	28	which	which	WDT
18637	10530	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10530	30	did	do	VBD
18637	10530	31	not	not	RB
18637	10530	32	deliver	deliver	VB
18637	10530	33	because	because	IN
18637	10530	34	of	of	IN
18637	10530	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10530	36	death	death	NN
18637	10530	37	before	before	IN
18637	10530	38	the	the	DT
18637	10530	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10530	40	reconvened	reconvene	VBD
18637	10530	41	but	but	CC
18637	10530	42	which	which	WDT
18637	10530	43	was	be	VBD
18637	10530	44	published	publish	VBN
18637	10530	45	many	many	JJ
18637	10530	46	year	year	NN
18637	10530	47	later	later	RB
18637	10530	48	.	.	.
18637	10531	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10531	2	18	18	CD
18637	10531	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10531	4	In	in	IN
18637	10531	5	any	any	DT
18637	10531	6	event	event	NN
18637	10531	7	the	the	DT
18637	10531	8	reiteration	reiteration	NN
18637	10531	9	of	of	IN
18637	10531	10	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	10531	11	's	's	POS
18637	10531	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10531	13	in	in	IN
18637	10531	14	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	10531	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	10531	16	made	make	VBD
18637	10531	17	much	much	JJ
18637	10531	18	of	of	IN
18637	10531	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10531	20	good	good	JJ
18637	10531	21	law	law	NN
18637	10531	22	.	.	.
18637	10532	1	Because	because	IN
18637	10532	2	the	the	DT
18637	10532	3	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10532	4	of	of	IN
18637	10532	5	the	the	DT
18637	10532	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10532	7	of	of	IN
18637	10532	8	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	10532	9	and	and	CC
18637	10532	10	the	the	DT
18637	10532	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10532	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10532	13	depended	depend	VBD
18637	10532	14	for	for	IN
18637	10532	15	execution	execution	NN
18637	10532	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	10532	17	future	future	JJ
18637	10532	18	action	action	NN
18637	10532	19	of	of	IN
18637	10532	20	the	the	DT
18637	10532	21	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10532	22	of	of	IN
18637	10532	23	the	the	DT
18637	10532	24	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	10532	25	and	and	CC
18637	10532	26	of	of	IN
18637	10532	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10532	28	,	,	,
18637	10532	29	the	the	DT
18637	10532	30	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10532	31	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10532	32	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	10532	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10532	34	as	as	IN
18637	10532	35	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	10532	36	more	more	JJR
18637	10532	37	than	than	IN
18637	10532	38	a	a	DT
18637	10532	39	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	10532	40	of	of	IN
18637	10532	41	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10532	42	and	and	CC
18637	10532	43	in	in	IN
18637	10532	44	no	no	DT
18637	10532	45	sense	sense	NN
18637	10532	46	a	a	DT
18637	10532	47	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10532	48	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10532	49	.	.	.
18637	10533	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10533	2	,	,	,
18637	10533	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	10533	4	,	,	,
18637	10533	5	could	could	MD
18637	10533	6	not	not	RB
18637	10533	7	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	10533	8	the	the	DT
18637	10533	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10533	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10533	11	to	to	TO
18637	10533	12	take	take	VB
18637	10533	13	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	10533	14	from	from	IN
18637	10533	15	an	an	DT
18637	10533	16	auditor	auditor	NN
18637	10533	17	or	or	CC
18637	10533	18	require	require	VB
18637	10533	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10533	20	to	to	TO
18637	10533	21	express	express	VB
18637	10533	22	an	an	DT
18637	10533	23	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10533	24	in	in	IN
18637	10533	25	a	a	DT
18637	10533	26	case	case	NN
18637	10533	27	where	where	WRB
18637	10533	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10533	29	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10533	30	power	power	NN
18637	10533	31	could	could	MD
18637	10533	32	not	not	RB
18637	10533	33	be	be	VB
18637	10533	34	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	10533	35	,	,	,
18637	10533	36	where	where	WRB
18637	10533	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10533	38	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10533	39	would	would	MD
18637	10533	40	not	not	RB
18637	10533	41	be	be	VB
18637	10533	42	final	final	JJ
18637	10533	43	and	and	CC
18637	10533	44	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	10533	45	upon	upon	IN
18637	10533	46	the	the	DT
18637	10533	47	parties	party	NNS
18637	10533	48	,	,	,
18637	10533	49	and	and	CC
18637	10533	50	where	where	WRB
18637	10533	51	processes	process	NNS
18637	10533	52	of	of	IN
18637	10533	53	execution	execution	NN
18637	10533	54	were	be	VBD
18637	10533	55	not	not	RB
18637	10533	56	awarded	award	VBN
18637	10533	57	to	to	TO
18637	10533	58	carry	carry	VB
18637	10533	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10533	60	into	into	IN
18637	10533	61	effect	effect	NN
18637	10533	62	.	.	.
18637	10534	1	The	the	DT
18637	10534	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10534	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10534	4	then	then	RB
18637	10534	5	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	10534	6	to	to	TO
18637	10534	7	formulate	formulate	VB
18637	10534	8	a	a	DT
18637	10534	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	10534	10	,	,	,
18637	10534	11	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	10534	12	in	in	IN
18637	10534	13	many	many	JJ
18637	10534	14	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	10534	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	10534	16	until	until	IN
18637	10534	17	modified	modify	VBN
18637	10534	18	in	in	IN
18637	10534	19	1927	1927	CD
18637	10534	20	and	and	CC
18637	10534	21	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	10534	22	in	in	IN
18637	10534	23	1933	1933	CD
18637	10534	24	,	,	,
18637	10534	25	to	to	IN
18637	10534	26	the	the	DT
18637	10534	27	effect	effect	NN
18637	10534	28	that	that	IN
18637	10534	29	the	the	DT
18637	10534	30	award	award	NN
18637	10534	31	of	of	IN
18637	10534	32	execution	execution	NN
18637	10534	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	10534	34	a	a	DT
18637	10534	35	part	part	NN
18637	10534	36	and	and	CC
18637	10534	37	an	an	DT
18637	10534	38	essential	essential	JJ
18637	10534	39	part	part	NN
18637	10534	40	of	of	IN
18637	10534	41	every	every	DT
18637	10534	42	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10534	43	passed	pass	VBN
18637	10534	44	by	by	IN
18637	10534	45	a	a	DT
18637	10534	46	court	court	NN
18637	10534	47	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	10534	48	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10534	49	powers	power	NNS
18637	10534	50	;	;	:
18637	10534	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10534	52	was	be	VBD
18637	10534	53	no	no	DT
18637	10534	54	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10534	55	in	in	IN
18637	10534	56	the	the	DT
18637	10534	57	legal	legal	JJ
18637	10534	58	sense	sense	NN
18637	10534	59	of	of	IN
18637	10534	60	the	the	DT
18637	10534	61	term	term	NN
18637	10534	62	without	without	IN
18637	10534	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10534	64	.	.	.
18637	10535	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10535	2	19	19	CD
18637	10535	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10535	4	This	this	DT
18637	10535	5	rule	rule	NN
18637	10535	6	was	be	VBD
18637	10535	7	given	give	VBN
18637	10535	8	rigid	rigid	JJ
18637	10535	9	application	application	NN
18637	10535	10	in	in	IN
18637	10535	11	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	10535	12	Warehouse	Warehouse	NNP
18637	10535	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10535	14	_	_	NNP
18637	10535	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	10535	16	_	_	NNP
18637	10535	17	Grannis,[20	Grannis,[20	NNP
18637	10535	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10535	19	where	where	WRB
18637	10535	20	the	the	DT
18637	10535	21	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10535	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10535	23	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	10535	24	a	a	DT
18637	10535	25	district	district	NN
18637	10535	26	court	court	NN
18637	10535	27	in	in	IN
18637	10535	28	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	10535	29	to	to	TO
18637	10535	30	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	10535	31	a	a	DT
18637	10535	32	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	10535	33	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	10535	34	for	for	IN
18637	10535	35	lack	lack	NN
18637	10535	36	of	of	IN
18637	10535	37	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10535	38	because	because	IN
18637	10535	39	such	such	PDT
18637	10535	40	a	a	DT
18637	10535	41	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	10535	42	was	be	VBD
18637	10535	43	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	10535	44	as	as	IN
18637	10535	45	nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	10535	46	.	.	.
18637	10536	1	One	one	CD
18637	10536	2	year	year	NN
18637	10536	3	later	later	RB
18637	10536	4	,	,	,
18637	10536	5	the	the	DT
18637	10536	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10536	7	applied	apply	VBD
18637	10536	8	the	the	DT
18637	10536	9	extreme	extreme	NN
18637	10536	10	of	of	IN
18637	10536	11	the	the	DT
18637	10536	12	rule	rule	NN
18637	10536	13	in	in	IN
18637	10536	14	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	10536	15	Warehouse	Warehouse	NNP
18637	10536	16	_	_	NNP
18637	10536	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	10536	18	_	_	NNP
18637	10536	19	Burley	Burley	NNP
18637	10536	20	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	10536	21	Growers	Growers	NNPS
18637	10536	22	Association,[21	Association,[21	NNP
18637	10536	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10536	24	when	when	WRB
18637	10536	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10536	26	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	10536	27	that	that	IN
18637	10536	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10536	29	could	could	MD
18637	10536	30	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	10536	31	no	no	DT
18637	10536	32	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	10536	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10536	34	in	in	IN
18637	10536	35	a	a	DT
18637	10536	36	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	10536	37	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	10536	38	in	in	IN
18637	10536	39	a	a	DT
18637	10536	40	State	State	NNP
18637	10536	41	court	court	NN
18637	10536	42	.	.	.
18637	10537	1	Award	award	NN
18637	10537	2	of	of	IN
18637	10537	3	Execution	Execution	NNP
18637	10537	4	Meanwhile	meanwhile	RB
18637	10537	5	in	in	IN
18637	10537	6	1927	1927	CD
18637	10537	7	the	the	DT
18637	10537	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10537	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10537	10	began	begin	VBD
18637	10537	11	to	to	TO
18637	10537	12	qualify	qualify	VB
18637	10537	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10537	14	insistence	insistence	NN
18637	10537	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	10537	16	an	an	DT
18637	10537	17	award	award	NN
18637	10537	18	of	of	IN
18637	10537	19	execution	execution	NN
18637	10537	20	,	,	,
18637	10537	21	holding	hold	VBG
18637	10537	22	in	in	IN
18637	10537	23	Fidelity	Fidelity	NNP
18637	10537	24	National	National	NNP
18637	10537	25	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	10537	26	and	and	CC
18637	10537	27	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	10537	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10537	29	_	_	NNP
18637	10537	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	10537	31	_	_	NNP
18637	10537	32	Swope[22	Swope[22	NNP
18637	10537	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10537	34	that	that	IN
18637	10537	35	an	an	DT
18637	10537	36	award	award	NN
18637	10537	37	of	of	IN
18637	10537	38	execution	execution	NN
18637	10537	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	10537	40	not	not	RB
18637	10537	41	an	an	DT
18637	10537	42	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
18637	10537	43	adjunct	adjunct	NN
18637	10537	44	of	of	IN
18637	10537	45	the	the	DT
18637	10537	46	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10537	47	process	process	NN
18637	10537	48	.	.	.
18637	10538	1	This	this	DT
18637	10538	2	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	10538	3	prepared	prepare	VBD
18637	10538	4	the	the	DT
18637	10538	5	way	way	NN
18637	10538	6	for	for	IN
18637	10538	7	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	10538	8	,	,	,
18637	10538	9	Chattanooga	Chattanooga	NNP
18637	10538	10	and	and	CC
18637	10538	11	St.	St.	NNP
18637	10538	12	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	10538	13	R.	R.	NNP
18637	10538	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10538	15	_	_	NNP
18637	10538	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	10538	17	_	_	NNP
18637	10538	18	Wallace[23	Wallace[23	NNP
18637	10538	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10538	20	which	which	WDT
18637	10538	21	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	10538	22	the	the	DT
18637	10538	23	decision	decision	NN
18637	10538	24	in	in	IN
18637	10538	25	the	the	DT
18637	10538	26	Grannis	Grannis	NNP
18637	10538	27	case	case	NN
18637	10538	28	,	,	,
18637	10538	29	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	10538	30	an	an	DT
18637	10538	31	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	10538	32	from	from	IN
18637	10538	33	a	a	DT
18637	10538	34	State	State	NNP
18637	10538	35	court	court	NN
18637	10538	36	to	to	IN
18637	10538	37	the	the	DT
18637	10538	38	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10538	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10538	40	in	in	IN
18637	10538	41	a	a	DT
18637	10538	42	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	10538	43	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	10538	44	,	,	,
18637	10538	45	and	and	CC
18637	10538	46	effectively	effectively	RB
18637	10538	47	interred	inter	VBD
18637	10538	48	the	the	DT
18637	10538	49	rule	rule	NN
18637	10538	50	that	that	DT
18637	10538	51	award	award	NN
18637	10538	52	of	of	IN
18637	10538	53	execution	execution	NN
18637	10538	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	10538	55	essential	essential	JJ
18637	10538	56	to	to	IN
18637	10538	57	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10538	58	power	power	NN
18637	10538	59	.	.	.
18637	10539	1	Regardless	regardless	RB
18637	10539	2	,	,	,
18637	10539	3	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	10539	4	,	,	,
18637	10539	5	of	of	IN
18637	10539	6	the	the	DT
18637	10539	7	fate	fate	NN
18637	10539	8	of	of	IN
18637	10539	9	an	an	DT
18637	10539	10	award	award	NN
18637	10539	11	of	of	IN
18637	10539	12	execution	execution	NN
18637	10539	13	,	,	,
18637	10539	14	the	the	DT
18637	10539	15	rule	rule	NN
18637	10539	16	that	that	IN
18637	10539	17	finality	finality	NN
18637	10539	18	of	of	IN
18637	10539	19	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10539	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	10539	21	an	an	DT
18637	10539	22	essential	essential	JJ
18637	10539	23	attribute	attribute	NN
18637	10539	24	of	of	IN
18637	10539	25	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10539	26	power	power	NN
18637	10539	27	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	10539	28	unimpaired	unimpaired	JJ
18637	10539	29	.	.	.
18637	10540	1	Ancillary	Ancillary	NNP
18637	10540	2	Powers	power	NNS
18637	10540	3	THE	the	DT
18637	10540	4	CONTEMPT	CONTEMPT	NNP
18637	10540	5	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	10540	6	;	;	:
18637	10540	7	THE	the	DT
18637	10540	8	ACT	act	NN
18637	10540	9	OF	of	IN
18637	10540	10	1789	1789	CD
18637	10540	11	The	the	DT
18637	10540	12	summary	summary	NN
18637	10540	13	power	power	NN
18637	10540	14	of	of	IN
18637	10540	15	the	the	DT
18637	10540	16	courts	court	NNS
18637	10540	17	of	of	IN
18637	10540	18	the	the	DT
18637	10540	19	United	United	NNP
18637	10540	20	States	States	NNP
18637	10540	21	to	to	TO
18637	10540	22	punish	punish	VB
18637	10540	23	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	10540	24	of	of	IN
18637	10540	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10540	26	authority	authority	NN
18637	10540	27	had	have	VBD
18637	10540	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10540	29	origin	origin	NN
18637	10540	30	in	in	IN
18637	10540	31	the	the	DT
18637	10540	32	law	law	NN
18637	10540	33	and	and	CC
18637	10540	34	practice	practice	NN
18637	10540	35	of	of	IN
18637	10540	36	England	England	NNP
18637	10540	37	where	where	WRB
18637	10540	38	disobedience	disobedience	NN
18637	10540	39	of	of	IN
18637	10540	40	court	court	NN
18637	10540	41	orders	order	NNS
18637	10540	42	was	be	VBD
18637	10540	43	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	10540	44	as	as	IN
18637	10540	45	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10540	46	of	of	IN
18637	10540	47	the	the	DT
18637	10540	48	King	King	NNP
18637	10540	49	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10540	50	and	and	CC
18637	10540	51	attachment	attachment	NN
18637	10540	52	was	be	VBD
18637	10540	53	a	a	DT
18637	10540	54	prerogative	prerogative	JJ
18637	10540	55	process	process	NN
18637	10540	56	derived	derive	VBN
18637	10540	57	from	from	IN
18637	10540	58	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	10540	59	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10540	60	of	of	IN
18637	10540	61	the	the	DT
18637	10540	62	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	10540	63	.	.	.
18637	10541	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10541	2	24	24	CD
18637	10541	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10541	4	By	by	IN
18637	10541	5	the	the	DT
18637	10541	6	latter	latter	JJ
18637	10541	7	part	part	NN
18637	10541	8	of	of	IN
18637	10541	9	the	the	DT
18637	10541	10	eighteenth	eighteenth	NNP
18637	10541	11	century	century	NN
18637	10541	12	summary	summary	NN
18637	10541	13	power	power	NN
18637	10541	14	to	to	TO
18637	10541	15	punish	punish	VB
18637	10541	16	was	be	VBD
18637	10541	17	extended	extend	VBN
18637	10541	18	to	to	IN
18637	10541	19	all	all	DT
18637	10541	20	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	10541	21	whether	whether	IN
18637	10541	22	committed	commit	VBD
18637	10541	23	in	in	IN
18637	10541	24	or	or	CC
18637	10541	25	out	out	IN
18637	10541	26	of	of	IN
18637	10541	27	court	court	NN
18637	10541	28	.	.	.
18637	10542	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10542	2	25	25	CD
18637	10542	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10542	4	In	in	IN
18637	10542	5	the	the	DT
18637	10542	6	United	United	NNP
18637	10542	7	States	States	NNP
18637	10542	8	,	,	,
18637	10542	9	the	the	DT
18637	10542	10	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	10542	11	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10542	12	of	of	IN
18637	10542	13	1789	1789	CD
18637	10542	14	in	in	IN
18637	10542	15	section	section	NN
18637	10542	16	17[26	17[26	CD
18637	10542	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10542	18	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	10542	19	power	power	NN
18637	10542	20	on	on	IN
18637	10542	21	all	all	DT
18637	10542	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	10542	23	of	of	IN
18637	10542	24	the	the	DT
18637	10542	25	United	United	NNP
18637	10542	26	States	States	NNP
18637	10542	27	"	"	''
18637	10542	28	to	to	TO
18637	10542	29	punish	punish	VB
18637	10542	30	by	by	IN
18637	10542	31	fine	fine	JJ
18637	10542	32	or	or	CC
18637	10542	33	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	10542	34	,	,	,
18637	10542	35	at	at	IN
18637	10542	36	the	the	DT
18637	10542	37	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	10542	38	of	of	IN
18637	10542	39	said	say	VBN
18637	10542	40	courts	court	NNS
18637	10542	41	,	,	,
18637	10542	42	all	all	DT
18637	10542	43	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	10542	44	of	of	IN
18637	10542	45	authority	authority	NN
18637	10542	46	in	in	IN
18637	10542	47	any	any	DT
18637	10542	48	cause	cause	NN
18637	10542	49	or	or	CC
18637	10542	50	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	10542	51	before	before	IN
18637	10542	52	the	the	DT
18637	10542	53	same	same	JJ
18637	10542	54	.	.	.
18637	10542	55	"	"	''
18637	10543	1	The	the	DT
18637	10543	2	only	only	JJ
18637	10543	3	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	10543	4	placed	place	VBN
18637	10543	5	on	on	IN
18637	10543	6	this	this	DT
18637	10543	7	power	power	NN
18637	10543	8	was	be	VBD
18637	10543	9	that	that	IN
18637	10543	10	summary	summary	NN
18637	10543	11	attachment	attachment	NN
18637	10543	12	was	be	VBD
18637	10543	13	made	make	VBN
18637	10543	14	a	a	DT
18637	10543	15	negation	negation	NN
18637	10543	16	of	of	IN
18637	10543	17	all	all	DT
18637	10543	18	other	other	JJ
18637	10543	19	modes	mode	NNS
18637	10543	20	of	of	IN
18637	10543	21	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	10543	22	.	.	.
18637	10544	1	The	the	DT
18637	10544	2	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	10544	3	of	of	IN
18637	10544	4	this	this	DT
18637	10544	5	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	10544	6	power	power	NN
18637	10544	7	led	lead	VBD
18637	10544	8	,	,	,
18637	10544	9	following	follow	VBG
18637	10544	10	the	the	DT
18637	10544	11	unsuccessful	unsuccessful	JJ
18637	10544	12	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	10544	13	of	of	IN
18637	10544	14	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	10544	15	James	James	NNP
18637	10544	16	H.	H.	NNP
18637	10544	17	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	10544	18	of	of	IN
18637	10544	19	the	the	DT
18637	10544	20	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10544	21	District	District	NNP
18637	10544	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10544	23	of	of	IN
18637	10544	24	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	10544	25	,	,	,
18637	10544	26	to	to	IN
18637	10544	27	the	the	DT
18637	10544	28	passage	passage	NN
18637	10544	29	of	of	IN
18637	10544	30	the	the	DT
18637	10544	31	act	act	NN
18637	10544	32	of	of	IN
18637	10544	33	1831	1831	CD
18637	10544	34	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	10544	35	the	the	DT
18637	10544	36	power	power	NN
18637	10544	37	of	of	IN
18637	10544	38	the	the	DT
18637	10544	39	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10544	40	courts	court	NNS
18637	10544	41	to	to	TO
18637	10544	42	punish	punish	VB
18637	10544	43	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	10544	44	to	to	IN
18637	10544	45	misbehavior	misbehavior	NNP
18637	10544	46	in	in	IN
18637	10544	47	the	the	DT
18637	10544	48	presence	presence	NN
18637	10544	49	of	of	IN
18637	10544	50	the	the	DT
18637	10544	51	courts	court	NNS
18637	10544	52	,	,	,
18637	10544	53	"	"	''
18637	10544	54	or	or	CC
18637	10544	55	so	so	RB
18637	10544	56	near	near	IN
18637	10544	57	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	10544	58	as	as	IN
18637	10544	59	to	to	TO
18637	10544	60	obstruct	obstruct	VB
18637	10544	61	the	the	DT
18637	10544	62	administration	administration	NN
18637	10544	63	of	of	IN
18637	10544	64	justice	justice	NN
18637	10544	65	,	,	,
18637	10544	66	"	"	''
18637	10544	67	to	to	IN
18637	10544	68	the	the	DT
18637	10544	69	misbehavior	misbehavior	NN
18637	10544	70	of	of	IN
18637	10544	71	officers	officer	NNS
18637	10544	72	of	of	IN
18637	10544	73	courts	court	NNS
18637	10544	74	in	in	IN
18637	10544	75	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10544	76	official	official	JJ
18637	10544	77	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	10544	78	,	,	,
18637	10544	79	and	and	CC
18637	10544	80	to	to	IN
18637	10544	81	disobedience	disobedience	NN
18637	10544	82	or	or	CC
18637	10544	83	resistance	resistance	NN
18637	10544	84	to	to	IN
18637	10544	85	any	any	DT
18637	10544	86	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	10544	87	writ	writ	NN
18637	10544	88	,	,	,
18637	10544	89	process	process	NN
18637	10544	90	or	or	CC
18637	10544	91	order	order	NN
18637	10544	92	of	of	IN
18637	10544	93	the	the	DT
18637	10544	94	court	court	NN
18637	10544	95	.	.	.
18637	10545	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10545	2	27	27	CD
18637	10545	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10545	4	An	an	DT
18637	10545	5	Inherent	Inherent	NNP
18637	10545	6	Power	power	NN
18637	10545	7	The	the	DT
18637	10545	8	validity	validity	NN
18637	10545	9	of	of	IN
18637	10545	10	the	the	DT
18637	10545	11	act	act	NN
18637	10545	12	of	of	IN
18637	10545	13	1831	1831	CD
18637	10545	14	was	be	VBD
18637	10545	15	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	10545	16	forty	forty	CD
18637	10545	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	10545	18	three	three	CD
18637	10545	19	years	year	NNS
18637	10545	20	later	later	RB
18637	10545	21	in	in	IN
18637	10545	22	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	10545	23	parte	parte	NNP
18637	10545	24	Robinson,[28	robinson,[28	NN
18637	10545	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10545	26	where	where	WRB
18637	10545	27	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10545	28	Field	Field	NNP
18637	10545	29	for	for	IN
18637	10545	30	the	the	DT
18637	10545	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10545	32	propounded	propound	VBD
18637	10545	33	principles	principle	NNS
18637	10545	34	full	full	JJ
18637	10545	35	of	of	IN
18637	10545	36	potentialities	potentiality	NNS
18637	10545	37	for	for	IN
18637	10545	38	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	10545	39	.	.	.
18637	10546	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10546	2	declared	declare	VBD
18637	10546	3	:	:	:
18637	10546	4	"	"	``
18637	10546	5	The	the	DT
18637	10546	6	power	power	NN
18637	10546	7	to	to	TO
18637	10546	8	punish	punish	VB
18637	10546	9	for	for	IN
18637	10546	10	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	10546	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	10546	12	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10546	13	in	in	IN
18637	10546	14	all	all	DT
18637	10546	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	10546	16	;	;	:
18637	10546	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10546	18	existence	existence	NN
18637	10546	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	10546	20	essential	essential	JJ
18637	10546	21	to	to	IN
18637	10546	22	the	the	DT
18637	10546	23	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	10546	24	of	of	IN
18637	10546	25	order	order	NN
18637	10546	26	in	in	IN
18637	10546	27	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10546	28	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10546	29	,	,	,
18637	10546	30	and	and	CC
18637	10546	31	to	to	IN
18637	10546	32	the	the	DT
18637	10546	33	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10546	34	of	of	IN
18637	10546	35	the	the	DT
18637	10546	36	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	10546	37	,	,	,
18637	10546	38	orders	order	NNS
18637	10546	39	,	,	,
18637	10546	40	and	and	CC
18637	10546	41	writs	writ	NNS
18637	10546	42	of	of	IN
18637	10546	43	the	the	DT
18637	10546	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	10546	45	,	,	,
18637	10546	46	and	and	CC
18637	10546	47	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	10546	48	to	to	IN
18637	10546	49	the	the	DT
18637	10546	50	due	due	JJ
18637	10546	51	administration	administration	NN
18637	10546	52	of	of	IN
18637	10546	53	justice	justice	NN
18637	10546	54	.	.	.
18637	10547	1	The	the	DT
18637	10547	2	moment	moment	NN
18637	10547	3	the	the	DT
18637	10547	4	courts	court	NNS
18637	10547	5	of	of	IN
18637	10547	6	the	the	DT
18637	10547	7	United	United	NNP
18637	10547	8	States	States	NNP
18637	10547	9	were	be	VBD
18637	10547	10	called	call	VBN
18637	10547	11	into	into	IN
18637	10547	12	existence	existence	NN
18637	10547	13	and	and	CC
18637	10547	14	invested	invest	VBN
18637	10547	15	with	with	IN
18637	10547	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10547	17	over	over	IN
18637	10547	18	any	any	DT
18637	10547	19	subject	subject	NN
18637	10547	20	,	,	,
18637	10547	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10547	22	become	become	VBP
18637	10547	23	possessed	possessed	JJ
18637	10547	24	of	of	IN
18637	10547	25	this	this	DT
18637	10547	26	power	power	NN
18637	10547	27	.	.	.
18637	10547	28	"	"	''
18637	10548	1	Expressing	express	VBG
18637	10548	2	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	10548	3	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	10548	4	the	the	DT
18637	10548	5	validity	validity	NN
18637	10548	6	of	of	IN
18637	10548	7	the	the	DT
18637	10548	8	act	act	NN
18637	10548	9	as	as	IN
18637	10548	10	to	to	IN
18637	10548	11	the	the	DT
18637	10548	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10548	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10548	14	,	,	,
18637	10548	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10548	16	declared	declare	VBD
18637	10548	17	,	,	,
18637	10548	18	however	however	RB
18637	10548	19	,	,	,
18637	10548	20	there	there	EX
18637	10548	21	could	could	MD
18637	10548	22	be	be	VB
18637	10548	23	no	no	DT
18637	10548	24	question	question	NN
18637	10548	25	of	of	IN
18637	10548	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10548	27	validity	validity	NN
18637	10548	28	as	as	IN
18637	10548	29	applied	apply	VBN
18637	10548	30	to	to	IN
18637	10548	31	the	the	DT
18637	10548	32	lower	low	JJR
18637	10548	33	courts	court	NNS
18637	10548	34	on	on	IN
18637	10548	35	the	the	DT
18637	10548	36	ground	ground	NN
18637	10548	37	that	that	IN
18637	10548	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10548	39	are	be	VBP
18637	10548	40	created	create	VBN
18637	10548	41	by	by	IN
18637	10548	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10548	43	and	and	CC
18637	10548	44	that	that	IN
18637	10548	45	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10548	46	"	"	``
18637	10548	47	powers	power	NNS
18637	10548	48	and	and	CC
18637	10548	49	duties	duty	NNS
18637	10548	50	depend	depend	VBP
18637	10548	51	upon	upon	IN
18637	10548	52	the	the	DT
18637	10548	53	act	act	NN
18637	10548	54	calling	call	VBG
18637	10548	55	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10548	56	into	into	IN
18637	10548	57	existence	existence	NN
18637	10548	58	,	,	,
18637	10548	59	or	or	CC
18637	10548	60	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	10548	61	acts	act	NNS
18637	10548	62	extending	extend	VBG
18637	10548	63	or	or	CC
18637	10548	64	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	10548	65	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10548	66	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10548	67	.	.	.
18637	10549	1	"	"	``
18637	10549	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10549	3	29	29	CD
18637	10549	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10549	5	With	with	IN
18637	10549	6	the	the	DT
18637	10549	7	passage	passage	NN
18637	10549	8	of	of	IN
18637	10549	9	time	time	NN
18637	10549	10	,	,	,
18637	10549	11	later	later	JJ
18637	10549	12	adjudications	adjudication	NNS
18637	10549	13	,	,	,
18637	10549	14	especially	especially	RB
18637	10549	15	after	after	IN
18637	10549	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	10549	17	,	,	,
18637	10549	18	came	come	VBD
18637	10549	19	to	to	TO
18637	10549	20	place	place	VB
18637	10549	21	more	more	JJR
18637	10549	22	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	10549	23	on	on	IN
18637	10549	24	the	the	DT
18637	10549	25	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10549	26	power	power	NN
18637	10549	27	of	of	IN
18637	10549	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	10549	29	to	to	TO
18637	10549	30	punish	punish	VB
18637	10549	31	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	10549	32	than	than	IN
18637	10549	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	10549	34	the	the	DT
18637	10549	35	power	power	NN
18637	10549	36	of	of	IN
18637	10549	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10549	38	to	to	TO
18637	10549	39	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	10549	40	summary	summary	NN
18637	10549	41	attachment	attachment	NN
18637	10549	42	.	.	.
18637	10550	1	By	by	IN
18637	10550	2	1911	1911	CD
18637	10550	3	the	the	DT
18637	10550	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10550	5	was	be	VBD
18637	10550	6	saying	say	VBG
18637	10550	7	that	that	IN
18637	10550	8	the	the	DT
18637	10550	9	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10550	10	power	power	NN
18637	10550	11	must	must	MD
18637	10550	12	be	be	VB
18637	10550	13	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	10550	14	by	by	IN
18637	10550	15	a	a	DT
18637	10550	16	court	court	NN
18637	10550	17	without	without	IN
18637	10550	18	referring	refer	VBG
18637	10550	19	the	the	DT
18637	10550	20	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10550	21	of	of	IN
18637	10550	22	fact	fact	NN
18637	10550	23	or	or	CC
18637	10550	24	law	law	NN
18637	10550	25	to	to	IN
18637	10550	26	another	another	DT
18637	10550	27	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	10550	28	or	or	CC
18637	10550	29	to	to	IN
18637	10550	30	a	a	DT
18637	10550	31	jury	jury	NN
18637	10550	32	in	in	IN
18637	10550	33	the	the	DT
18637	10550	34	same	same	JJ
18637	10550	35	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	10550	36	.	.	.
18637	10551	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10551	2	30	30	CD
18637	10551	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10551	4	In	in	IN
18637	10551	5	Michaelson	Michaelson	NNP
18637	10551	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10551	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10551	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10551	9	United	United	NNP
18637	10551	10	States[31	States[31	NNP
18637	10551	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10551	12	the	the	DT
18637	10551	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10551	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10551	15	intentionally	intentionally	RB
18637	10551	16	placed	place	VBD
18637	10551	17	a	a	DT
18637	10551	18	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	10551	19	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	10551	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	10551	21	those	those	DT
18637	10551	22	sections	section	NNS
18637	10551	23	of	of	IN
18637	10551	24	the	the	DT
18637	10551	25	Clayton	Clayton	NNP
18637	10551	26	Act[32	Act[32	NFP
18637	10551	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10551	28	relating	relate	VBG
18637	10551	29	to	to	IN
18637	10551	30	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	10551	31	for	for	IN
18637	10551	32	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10551	33	of	of	IN
18637	10551	34	court	court	NN
18637	10551	35	by	by	IN
18637	10551	36	disobedience	disobedience	NN
18637	10551	37	to	to	IN
18637	10551	38	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	10551	39	in	in	IN
18637	10551	40	labor	labor	NN
18637	10551	41	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	10551	42	.	.	.
18637	10552	1	The	the	DT
18637	10552	2	sections	section	NNS
18637	10552	3	in	in	IN
18637	10552	4	question	question	NN
18637	10552	5	provided	provide	VBN
18637	10552	6	for	for	IN
18637	10552	7	a	a	DT
18637	10552	8	jury	jury	NN
18637	10552	9	trial	trial	NN
18637	10552	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	10552	11	the	the	DT
18637	10552	12	demand	demand	NN
18637	10552	13	of	of	IN
18637	10552	14	the	the	DT
18637	10552	15	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	10552	16	in	in	IN
18637	10552	17	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10552	18	cases	case	NNS
18637	10552	19	in	in	IN
18637	10552	20	which	which	WDT
18637	10552	21	the	the	DT
18637	10552	22	acts	act	NNS
18637	10552	23	committed	commit	VBD
18637	10552	24	in	in	IN
18637	10552	25	violation	violation	NN
18637	10552	26	of	of	IN
18637	10552	27	district	district	NN
18637	10552	28	court	court	NN
18637	10552	29	orders	order	NNS
18637	10552	30	also	also	RB
18637	10552	31	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	10552	32	a	a	DT
18637	10552	33	crime	crime	NN
18637	10552	34	under	under	IN
18637	10552	35	the	the	DT
18637	10552	36	laws	law	NNS
18637	10552	37	of	of	IN
18637	10552	38	the	the	DT
18637	10552	39	United	United	NNP
18637	10552	40	States	States	NNP
18637	10552	41	or	or	CC
18637	10552	42	of	of	IN
18637	10552	43	those	those	DT
18637	10552	44	of	of	IN
18637	10552	45	the	the	DT
18637	10552	46	State	State	NNP
18637	10552	47	where	where	WRB
18637	10552	48	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10552	49	were	be	VBD
18637	10552	50	committed	commit	VBN
18637	10552	51	.	.	.
18637	10553	1	Although	although	IN
18637	10553	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10553	3	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	10553	4	reaffirmed	reaffirm	VBD
18637	10553	5	earlier	early	JJR
18637	10553	6	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	10553	7	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	10553	8	the	the	DT
18637	10553	9	authority	authority	NN
18637	10553	10	of	of	IN
18637	10553	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10553	12	to	to	TO
18637	10553	13	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	10553	14	the	the	DT
18637	10553	15	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10553	16	power	power	NN
18637	10553	17	,	,	,
18637	10553	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10553	19	went	go	VBD
18637	10553	20	on	on	RP
18637	10553	21	to	to	TO
18637	10553	22	qualify	qualify	VB
18637	10553	23	this	this	DT
18637	10553	24	authority	authority	NN
18637	10553	25	and	and	CC
18637	10553	26	declared	declare	VBD
18637	10553	27	that	that	IN
18637	10553	28	"	"	``
18637	10553	29	the	the	DT
18637	10553	30	attributes	attribute	NNS
18637	10553	31	which	which	WDT
18637	10553	32	inhere	inhere	VBP
18637	10553	33	in	in	IN
18637	10553	34	that	that	DT
18637	10553	35	power	power	NN
18637	10553	36	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10553	37	to	to	TO
18637	10553	38	punish	punish	VB
18637	10553	39	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10553	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10553	41	and	and	CC
18637	10553	42	are	be	VBP
18637	10553	43	inseparable	inseparable	JJ
18637	10553	44	from	from	IN
18637	10553	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10553	46	can	can	MD
18637	10553	47	neither	neither	CC
18637	10553	48	be	be	VB
18637	10553	49	abrogated	abrogate	VBN
18637	10553	50	nor	nor	CC
18637	10553	51	rendered	render	VBN
18637	10553	52	practically	practically	RB
18637	10553	53	inoperative	inoperative	JJ
18637	10553	54	.	.	.
18637	10553	55	"	"	''
18637	10554	1	The	the	DT
18637	10554	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10554	3	mentioned	mention	VBD
18637	10554	4	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	10554	5	"	"	``
18637	10554	6	the	the	DT
18637	10554	7	power	power	NN
18637	10554	8	to	to	TO
18637	10554	9	deal	deal	VB
18637	10554	10	summarily	summarily	RB
18637	10554	11	with	with	IN
18637	10554	12	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	10554	13	committed	commit	VBN
18637	10554	14	in	in	IN
18637	10554	15	the	the	DT
18637	10554	16	presence	presence	NN
18637	10554	17	of	of	IN
18637	10554	18	the	the	DT
18637	10554	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	10554	20	or	or	CC
18637	10554	21	so	so	RB
18637	10554	22	near	near	IN
18637	10554	23	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	10554	24	as	as	IN
18637	10554	25	to	to	TO
18637	10554	26	obstruct	obstruct	VB
18637	10554	27	the	the	DT
18637	10554	28	administration	administration	NN
18637	10554	29	of	of	IN
18637	10554	30	justice	justice	NN
18637	10554	31	,	,	,
18637	10554	32	"	"	''
18637	10554	33	and	and	CC
18637	10554	34	the	the	DT
18637	10554	35	power	power	NN
18637	10554	36	to	to	TO
18637	10554	37	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	10554	38	mandatory	mandatory	JJ
18637	10554	39	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	10554	40	by	by	IN
18637	10554	41	coercive	coercive	JJ
18637	10554	42	means	mean	NNS
18637	10554	43	.	.	.
18637	10555	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10555	2	33	33	CD
18637	10555	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10555	4	The	the	DT
18637	10555	5	Contempt	Contempt	NNP
18637	10555	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10555	7	Exalted	Exalted	NNP
18637	10555	8	The	the	DT
18637	10555	9	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	10555	10	"	"	``
18637	10555	11	in	in	IN
18637	10555	12	the	the	DT
18637	10555	13	presence	presence	NN
18637	10555	14	of	of	IN
18637	10555	15	the	the	DT
18637	10555	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10555	17	or	or	CC
18637	10555	18	so	so	RB
18637	10555	19	near	near	IN
18637	10555	20	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	10555	21	as	as	IN
18637	10555	22	to	to	TO
18637	10555	23	obstruct	obstruct	VB
18637	10555	24	the	the	DT
18637	10555	25	administration	administration	NN
18637	10555	26	of	of	IN
18637	10555	27	justice	justice	NNP
18637	10555	28	"	"	''
18637	10555	29	was	be	VBD
18637	10555	30	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	10555	31	in	in	IN
18637	10555	32	Toledo	Toledo	NNP
18637	10555	33	Newspaper	Newspaper	NNP
18637	10555	34	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10555	35	_	_	NNP
18637	10555	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	10555	37	_	_	NNP
18637	10555	38	United	United	NNP
18637	10555	39	States[34	States[34	NNP
18637	10555	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10555	41	so	so	RB
18637	10555	42	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	10555	43	as	as	IN
18637	10555	44	to	to	TO
18637	10555	45	uphold	uphold	VB
18637	10555	46	the	the	DT
18637	10555	47	action	action	NN
18637	10555	48	of	of	IN
18637	10555	49	a	a	DT
18637	10555	50	district	district	NN
18637	10555	51	court	court	NN
18637	10555	52	judge	judge	NN
18637	10555	53	in	in	IN
18637	10555	54	punishing	punish	VBG
18637	10555	55	for	for	IN
18637	10555	56	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10555	57	a	a	DT
18637	10555	58	newspaper	newspaper	NN
18637	10555	59	for	for	IN
18637	10555	60	publishing	publish	VBG
18637	10555	61	spirited	spirit	VBN
18637	10555	62	editorials	editorial	NNS
18637	10555	63	and	and	CC
18637	10555	64	cartoons	cartoon	NNS
18637	10555	65	on	on	IN
18637	10555	66	questions	question	NNS
18637	10555	67	at	at	IN
18637	10555	68	issue	issue	NN
18637	10555	69	in	in	IN
18637	10555	70	a	a	DT
18637	10555	71	contest	contest	NN
18637	10555	72	between	between	IN
18637	10555	73	a	a	DT
18637	10555	74	street	street	NN
18637	10555	75	railway	railway	NN
18637	10555	76	company	company	NN
18637	10555	77	and	and	CC
18637	10555	78	the	the	DT
18637	10555	79	public	public	NN
18637	10555	80	over	over	IN
18637	10555	81	rates	rate	NNS
18637	10555	82	.	.	.
18637	10556	1	A	a	DT
18637	10556	2	majority	majority	NN
18637	10556	3	of	of	IN
18637	10556	4	the	the	DT
18637	10556	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10556	6	held	hold	VBD
18637	10556	7	that	that	IN
18637	10556	8	the	the	DT
18637	10556	9	test	test	NN
18637	10556	10	to	to	TO
18637	10556	11	be	be	VB
18637	10556	12	applied	apply	VBN
18637	10556	13	in	in	IN
18637	10556	14	determining	determine	VBG
18637	10556	15	the	the	DT
18637	10556	16	obstruction	obstruction	NN
18637	10556	17	of	of	IN
18637	10556	18	the	the	DT
18637	10556	19	administration	administration	NN
18637	10556	20	of	of	IN
18637	10556	21	justice	justice	NNP
18637	10556	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	10556	23	not	not	RB
18637	10556	24	the	the	DT
18637	10556	25	actual	actual	JJ
18637	10556	26	obstruction	obstruction	NN
18637	10556	27	resulting	result	VBG
18637	10556	28	from	from	IN
18637	10556	29	an	an	DT
18637	10556	30	act	act	NN
18637	10556	31	,	,	,
18637	10556	32	but	but	CC
18637	10556	33	"	"	``
18637	10556	34	the	the	DT
18637	10556	35	character	character	NN
18637	10556	36	of	of	IN
18637	10556	37	the	the	DT
18637	10556	38	act	act	NN
18637	10556	39	done	do	VBN
18637	10556	40	and	and	CC
18637	10556	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10556	42	direct	direct	JJ
18637	10556	43	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	10556	44	to	to	TO
18637	10556	45	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	10556	46	and	and	CC
18637	10556	47	obstruct	obstruct	VB
18637	10556	48	the	the	DT
18637	10556	49	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	10556	50	of	of	IN
18637	10556	51	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10556	52	duty	duty	NN
18637	10556	53	.	.	.
18637	10556	54	"	"	''
18637	10557	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	10557	2	the	the	DT
18637	10557	3	test	test	NN
18637	10557	4	of	of	IN
18637	10557	5	whether	whether	IN
18637	10557	6	a	a	DT
18637	10557	7	particular	particular	JJ
18637	10557	8	act	act	NN
18637	10557	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	10557	10	an	an	DT
18637	10557	11	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	10557	12	to	to	TO
18637	10557	13	influence	influence	VB
18637	10557	14	or	or	CC
18637	10557	15	intimidate	intimidate	VB
18637	10557	16	a	a	DT
18637	10557	17	court	court	NN
18637	10557	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	10557	19	not	not	RB
18637	10557	20	the	the	DT
18637	10557	21	influence	influence	NN
18637	10557	22	exerted	exert	VBN
18637	10557	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	10557	24	the	the	DT
18637	10557	25	mind	mind	NN
18637	10557	26	of	of	IN
18637	10557	27	a	a	DT
18637	10557	28	particular	particular	JJ
18637	10557	29	judge	judge	NN
18637	10557	30	but	but	CC
18637	10557	31	"	"	``
18637	10557	32	the	the	DT
18637	10557	33	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	10557	34	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	10557	35	of	of	IN
18637	10557	36	the	the	DT
18637	10557	37	acts	act	NNS
18637	10557	38	done	do	VBN
18637	10557	39	to	to	TO
18637	10557	40	influence	influence	VB
18637	10557	41	or	or	CC
18637	10557	42	bring	bring	VB
18637	10557	43	about	about	RP
18637	10557	44	the	the	DT
18637	10557	45	baleful	baleful	JJ
18637	10557	46	result	result	NN
18637	10557	47	*	*	NFP
18637	10557	48	*	*	NFP
18637	10557	49	*	*	NFP
18637	10557	50	without	without	IN
18637	10557	51	reference	reference	NN
18637	10557	52	to	to	IN
18637	10557	53	the	the	DT
18637	10557	54	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	10557	55	of	of	IN
18637	10557	56	how	how	WRB
18637	10557	57	far	far	RB
18637	10557	58	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10557	59	may	may	MD
18637	10557	60	have	have	VB
18637	10557	61	been	be	VBN
18637	10557	62	without	without	IN
18637	10557	63	influence	influence	NN
18637	10557	64	in	in	IN
18637	10557	65	a	a	DT
18637	10557	66	particular	particular	JJ
18637	10557	67	case	case	NN
18637	10557	68	.	.	.
18637	10558	1	"	"	``
18637	10558	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10558	3	35	35	CD
18637	10558	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10558	5	In	in	IN
18637	10558	6	Craig	Craig	NNP
18637	10558	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10558	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	10558	9	_	_	NNP
18637	10558	10	Hecht[36	hecht[36	ADD
18637	10558	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10558	12	these	these	DT
18637	10558	13	criteria	criterion	NNS
18637	10558	14	were	be	VBD
18637	10558	15	applied	apply	VBN
18637	10558	16	to	to	TO
18637	10558	17	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	10558	18	the	the	DT
18637	10558	19	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	10558	20	of	of	IN
18637	10558	21	the	the	DT
18637	10558	22	comptroller	comptroller	NN
18637	10558	23	of	of	IN
18637	10558	24	New	New	NNP
18637	10558	25	York	York	NNP
18637	10558	26	City	City	NNP
18637	10558	27	for	for	IN
18637	10558	28	writing	writing	NN
18637	10558	29	and	and	CC
18637	10558	30	publishing	publish	VBG
18637	10558	31	a	a	DT
18637	10558	32	letter	letter	NN
18637	10558	33	to	to	IN
18637	10558	34	a	a	DT
18637	10558	35	public	public	JJ
18637	10558	36	service	service	NN
18637	10558	37	commissioner	commissioner	NN
18637	10558	38	which	which	WDT
18637	10558	39	criticized	criticize	VBD
18637	10558	40	the	the	DT
18637	10558	41	action	action	NN
18637	10558	42	of	of	IN
18637	10558	43	a	a	DT
18637	10558	44	United	United	NNP
18637	10558	45	States	States	NNP
18637	10558	46	district	district	NN
18637	10558	47	judge	judge	NN
18637	10558	48	in	in	IN
18637	10558	49	receivership	receivership	NN
18637	10558	50	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10558	51	.	.	.
18637	10559	1	Recession	recession	NN
18637	10559	2	of	of	IN
18637	10559	3	the	the	DT
18637	10559	4	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	10559	5	The	the	DT
18637	10559	6	decision	decision	NN
18637	10559	7	in	in	IN
18637	10559	8	the	the	DT
18637	10559	9	Toledo	Toledo	NNP
18637	10559	10	Newspaper	Newspaper	NNP
18637	10559	11	case	case	NN
18637	10559	12	did	do	VBD
18637	10559	13	not	not	RB
18637	10559	14	follow	follow	VB
18637	10559	15	earlier	early	JJR
18637	10559	16	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	10559	17	interpreting	interpret	VBG
18637	10559	18	the	the	DT
18637	10559	19	act	act	NN
18637	10559	20	of	of	IN
18637	10559	21	1831	1831	CD
18637	10559	22	and	and	CC
18637	10559	23	was	be	VBD
18637	10559	24	grounded	ground	VBN
18637	10559	25	on	on	IN
18637	10559	26	historical	historical	JJ
18637	10559	27	error	error	NN
18637	10559	28	.	.	.
18637	10560	1	For	for	IN
18637	10560	2	these	these	DT
18637	10560	3	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	10560	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10560	5	was	be	VBD
18637	10560	6	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	10560	7	in	in	IN
18637	10560	8	Nye	Nye	NNP
18637	10560	9	_	_	NNP
18637	10560	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	10560	11	_	_	NNP
18637	10560	12	United	United	NNP
18637	10560	13	States[37	States[37	NNP
18637	10560	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10560	15	and	and	CC
18637	10560	16	the	the	DT
18637	10560	17	theory	theory	NN
18637	10560	18	of	of	IN
18637	10560	19	constructive	constructive	JJ
18637	10560	20	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10560	21	based	base	VBN
18637	10560	22	on	on	IN
18637	10560	23	the	the	DT
18637	10560	24	"	"	``
18637	10560	25	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	10560	26	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	10560	27	"	"	''
18637	10560	28	rule	rule	NN
18637	10560	29	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	10560	30	in	in	IN
18637	10560	31	a	a	DT
18637	10560	32	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	10560	33	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	10560	34	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	10560	35	in	in	IN
18637	10560	36	a	a	DT
18637	10560	37	civil	civil	JJ
18637	10560	38	suit	suit	NN
18637	10560	39	,	,	,
18637	10560	40	by	by	IN
18637	10560	41	persuasion	persuasion	NN
18637	10560	42	and	and	CC
18637	10560	43	the	the	DT
18637	10560	44	use	use	NN
18637	10560	45	of	of	IN
18637	10560	46	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	10560	47	,	,	,
18637	10560	48	induced	induce	VBD
18637	10560	49	a	a	DT
18637	10560	50	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	10560	51	feeble	feeble	NN
18637	10560	52	in	in	IN
18637	10560	53	mind	mind	NN
18637	10560	54	and	and	CC
18637	10560	55	body	body	NN
18637	10560	56	to	to	TO
18637	10560	57	ask	ask	VB
18637	10560	58	for	for	IN
18637	10560	59	dismissal	dismissal	NN
18637	10560	60	of	of	IN
18637	10560	61	the	the	DT
18637	10560	62	suit	suit	NN
18637	10560	63	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10560	64	had	have	VBD
18637	10560	65	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10560	66	against	against	IN
18637	10560	67	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10560	68	.	.	.
18637	10561	1	The	the	DT
18637	10561	2	events	event	NNS
18637	10561	3	in	in	IN
18637	10561	4	the	the	DT
18637	10561	5	episode	episode	NN
18637	10561	6	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	10561	7	more	more	JJR
18637	10561	8	than	than	IN
18637	10561	9	100	100	CD
18637	10561	10	miles	mile	NNS
18637	10561	11	from	from	IN
18637	10561	12	where	where	WRB
18637	10561	13	the	the	DT
18637	10561	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10561	15	was	be	VBD
18637	10561	16	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	10561	17	,	,	,
18637	10561	18	and	and	CC
18637	10561	19	were	be	VBD
18637	10561	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	10561	21	not	not	RB
18637	10561	22	to	to	TO
18637	10561	23	put	put	VB
18637	10561	24	the	the	DT
18637	10561	25	persons	person	NNS
18637	10561	26	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	10561	27	for	for	IN
18637	10561	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10561	29	in	in	IN
18637	10561	30	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10561	31	of	of	IN
18637	10561	32	court	court	NN
18637	10561	33	.	.	.
18637	10562	1	Bridges	Bridges	NNPS
18637	10562	2	_	_	NNP
18637	10562	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	10562	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10562	5	California	California	NNP
18637	10562	6	Although	although	IN
18637	10562	7	Nye	Nye	NNP
18637	10562	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10562	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	10562	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10562	11	United	United	NNP
18637	10562	12	States	States	NNP
18637	10562	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	10562	14	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	10562	15	a	a	DT
18637	10562	16	case	case	NN
18637	10562	17	of	of	IN
18637	10562	18	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	10562	19	construction	construction	NN
18637	10562	20	,	,	,
18637	10562	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10562	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	10562	23	significant	significant	JJ
18637	10562	24	from	from	IN
18637	10562	25	a	a	DT
18637	10562	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10562	27	point	point	NN
18637	10562	28	of	of	IN
18637	10562	29	view	view	NN
18637	10562	30	in	in	IN
18637	10562	31	that	that	IN
18637	10562	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10562	33	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	10562	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	10562	35	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	10562	36	to	to	IN
18637	10562	37	that	that	DT
18637	10562	38	of	of	IN
18637	10562	39	earlier	early	JJR
18637	10562	40	cases	case	NNS
18637	10562	41	narrowly	narrowly	RB
18637	10562	42	construing	construe	VBG
18637	10562	43	the	the	DT
18637	10562	44	act	act	NN
18637	10562	45	of	of	IN
18637	10562	46	1831	1831	CD
18637	10562	47	and	and	CC
18637	10562	48	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	10562	49	broad	broad	JJ
18637	10562	50	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10562	51	powers	power	NNS
18637	10562	52	of	of	IN
18637	10562	53	courts	court	NNS
18637	10562	54	to	to	TO
18637	10562	55	punish	punish	VB
18637	10562	56	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	10562	57	independently	independently	RB
18637	10562	58	of	of	IN
18637	10562	59	and	and	CC
18637	10562	60	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	10562	61	to	to	IN
18637	10562	62	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	10562	63	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	10562	64	of	of	IN
18637	10562	65	this	this	DT
18637	10562	66	power	power	NN
18637	10562	67	.	.	.
18637	10563	1	Bridges	Bridges	NNPS
18637	10563	2	_	_	NNP
18637	10563	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	10563	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10563	5	California,[38	California,[38	NNP
18637	10563	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10563	7	though	though	IN
18637	10563	8	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	10563	9	with	with	IN
18637	10563	10	the	the	DT
18637	10563	11	power	power	NN
18637	10563	12	of	of	IN
18637	10563	13	State	State	NNP
18637	10563	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	10563	15	to	to	TO
18637	10563	16	punish	punish	VB
18637	10563	17	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	10563	18	,	,	,
18637	10563	19	in	in	IN
18637	10563	20	the	the	DT
18637	10563	21	face	face	NN
18637	10563	22	of	of	IN
18637	10563	23	the	the	DT
18637	10563	24	due	due	JJ
18637	10563	25	process	process	NN
18637	10563	26	clause	clause	NN
18637	10563	27	of	of	IN
18637	10563	28	the	the	DT
18637	10563	29	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	10563	30	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	10563	31	,	,	,
18637	10563	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	10563	33	significant	significant	JJ
18637	10563	34	for	for	IN
18637	10563	35	the	the	DT
18637	10563	36	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	10563	37	of	of	IN
18637	10563	38	the	the	DT
18637	10563	39	majority	majority	NN
18637	10563	40	that	that	WDT
18637	10563	41	the	the	DT
18637	10563	42	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10563	43	power	power	NN
18637	10563	44	of	of	IN
18637	10563	45	all	all	DT
18637	10563	46	courts	court	NNS
18637	10563	47	,	,	,
18637	10563	48	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10563	49	as	as	RB
18637	10563	50	well	well	RB
18637	10563	51	as	as	IN
18637	10563	52	State	State	NNP
18637	10563	53	,	,	,
18637	10563	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	10563	55	limited	limit	VBN
18637	10563	56	by	by	IN
18637	10563	57	the	the	DT
18637	10563	58	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	10563	59	of	of	IN
18637	10563	60	the	the	DT
18637	10563	61	First	First	NNP
18637	10563	62	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	10563	63	against	against	IN
18637	10563	64	interference	interference	NN
18637	10563	65	with	with	IN
18637	10563	66	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	10563	67	of	of	IN
18637	10563	68	speech	speech	NN
18637	10563	69	or	or	CC
18637	10563	70	of	of	IN
18637	10563	71	the	the	DT
18637	10563	72	press	press	NN
18637	10563	73	.	.	.
18637	10564	1	Summary	summary	JJ
18637	10564	2	Punishment	punishment	NN
18637	10564	3	of	of	IN
18637	10564	4	Contempt	Contempt	NNP
18637	10564	5	;	;	:
18637	10564	6	Misbehavior	Misbehavior	NNP
18637	10564	7	of	of	IN
18637	10564	8	Counsel	Counsel	NNP
18637	10564	9	There	there	EX
18637	10564	10	have	have	VBP
18637	10564	11	been	be	VBN
18637	10564	12	three	three	CD
18637	10564	13	notable	notable	JJ
18637	10564	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	10564	15	within	within	IN
18637	10564	16	the	the	DT
18637	10564	17	last	last	JJ
18637	10564	18	half	half	JJ
18637	10564	19	century	century	NN
18637	10564	20	raising	raise	VBG
18637	10564	21	questions	question	NNS
18637	10564	22	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	10564	23	the	the	DT
18637	10564	24	power	power	NN
18637	10564	25	of	of	IN
18637	10564	26	a	a	DT
18637	10564	27	trial	trial	NN
18637	10564	28	judge	judge	NN
18637	10564	29	to	to	TO
18637	10564	30	punish	punish	JJ
18637	10564	31	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	10564	32	summarily	summarily	RB
18637	10564	33	for	for	IN
18637	10564	34	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	10564	35	misbehavior	misbehavior	NN
18637	10564	36	in	in	IN
18637	10564	37	the	the	DT
18637	10564	38	course	course	NN
18637	10564	39	of	of	IN
18637	10564	40	a	a	DT
18637	10564	41	trial	trial	NN
18637	10564	42	.	.	.
18637	10565	1	In	in	IN
18637	10565	2	_	_	NNP
18637	10565	3	ex	ex	NNP
18637	10565	4	parte	parte	NNP
18637	10565	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10565	6	Terry,[39	Terry,[39	NNP
18637	10565	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10565	8	decided	decide	VBN
18637	10565	9	in	in	IN
18637	10565	10	1888	1888	CD
18637	10565	11	,	,	,
18637	10565	12	Terry	Terry	NNP
18637	10565	13	had	have	VBD
18637	10565	14	been	be	VBN
18637	10565	15	jailed	jail	VBN
18637	10565	16	by	by	IN
18637	10565	17	the	the	DT
18637	10565	18	United	United	NNP
18637	10565	19	States	States	NNP
18637	10565	20	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
18637	10565	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10565	22	of	of	IN
18637	10565	23	California	California	NNP
18637	10565	24	for	for	IN
18637	10565	25	assaulting	assault	VBG
18637	10565	26	in	in	IN
18637	10565	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10565	28	presence	presence	NN
18637	10565	29	a	a	DT
18637	10565	30	United	United	NNP
18637	10565	31	States	States	NNP
18637	10565	32	marshal	marshal	NN
18637	10565	33	.	.	.
18637	10566	1	The	the	DT
18637	10566	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10566	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10566	4	denied	deny	VBD
18637	10566	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10566	6	petition	petition	NN
18637	10566	7	for	for	IN
18637	10566	8	a	a	DT
18637	10566	9	writ	writ	NN
18637	10566	10	of	of	IN
18637	10566	11	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	10566	12	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	10566	13	.	.	.
18637	10567	1	In	in	IN
18637	10567	2	Cooke	Cooke	NNP
18637	10567	3	_	_	NNP
18637	10567	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	10567	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10567	6	United	United	NNP
18637	10567	7	States,[40	States,[40	NNP
18637	10567	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10567	9	however	however	RB
18637	10567	10	,	,	,
18637	10567	11	decided	decide	VBD
18637	10567	12	in	in	IN
18637	10567	13	1925	1925	CD
18637	10567	14	,	,	,
18637	10567	15	the	the	DT
18637	10567	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10567	17	remanded	remand	VBD
18637	10567	18	for	for	IN
18637	10567	19	further	further	JJ
18637	10567	20	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10567	21	a	a	DT
18637	10567	22	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10567	23	of	of	IN
18637	10567	24	the	the	DT
18637	10567	25	United	United	NNP
18637	10567	26	States	States	NNP
18637	10567	27	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
18637	10567	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10567	29	of	of	IN
18637	10567	30	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	10567	31	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	10567	32	the	the	DT
18637	10567	33	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10567	34	of	of	IN
18637	10567	35	a	a	DT
18637	10567	36	United	United	NNP
18637	10567	37	States	States	NNP
18637	10567	38	District	District	NNP
18637	10567	39	judge	judge	NN
18637	10567	40	sentencing	sentence	VBG
18637	10567	41	to	to	TO
18637	10567	42	jail	jail	NN
18637	10567	43	an	an	DT
18637	10567	44	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	10567	45	and	and	CC
18637	10567	46	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10567	47	client	client	NN
18637	10567	48	for	for	IN
18637	10567	49	presenting	present	VBG
18637	10567	50	the	the	DT
18637	10567	51	judge	judge	NN
18637	10567	52	a	a	DT
18637	10567	53	letter	letter	NN
18637	10567	54	which	which	WDT
18637	10567	55	impugned	impugn	VBD
18637	10567	56	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10567	57	impartiality	impartiality	NN
18637	10567	58	with	with	IN
18637	10567	59	respect	respect	NN
18637	10567	60	to	to	IN
18637	10567	61	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10567	62	case	case	NN
18637	10567	63	,	,	,
18637	10567	64	still	still	RB
18637	10567	65	pending	pende	VBG
18637	10567	66	before	before	IN
18637	10567	67	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10567	68	.	.	.
18637	10568	1	Distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
18637	10568	2	the	the	DT
18637	10568	3	case	case	NN
18637	10568	4	from	from	IN
18637	10568	5	that	that	DT
18637	10568	6	of	of	IN
18637	10568	7	Terry	Terry	NNP
18637	10568	8	,	,	,
18637	10568	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10568	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10568	11	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	10568	12	,	,	,
18637	10568	13	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	10568	14	for	for	IN
18637	10568	15	the	the	DT
18637	10568	16	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	10568	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10568	18	,	,	,
18637	10568	19	said	say	VBD
18637	10568	20	:	:	:
18637	10568	21	"	"	``
18637	10568	22	The	the	DT
18637	10568	23	important	important	JJ
18637	10568	24	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	10568	25	*	*	NFP
18637	10568	26	*	*	NFP
18637	10568	27	*	*	NFP
18637	10568	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	10568	29	that	that	IN
18637	10568	30	this	this	DT
18637	10568	31	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10568	32	was	be	VBD
18637	10568	33	not	not	RB
18637	10568	34	in	in	IN
18637	10568	35	open	open	JJ
18637	10568	36	court	court	NN
18637	10568	37	.	.	.
18637	10569	1	*	*	NFP
18637	10569	2	*	*	NFP
18637	10569	3	*	*	NFP
18637	10569	4	To	to	TO
18637	10569	5	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	10569	6	order	order	NN
18637	10569	7	in	in	IN
18637	10569	8	the	the	DT
18637	10569	9	court	court	NN
18637	10569	10	room	room	NN
18637	10569	11	for	for	IN
18637	10569	12	the	the	DT
18637	10569	13	proper	proper	JJ
18637	10569	14	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	10569	15	of	of	IN
18637	10569	16	business	business	NN
18637	10569	17	,	,	,
18637	10569	18	the	the	DT
18637	10569	19	court	court	NN
18637	10569	20	must	must	MD
18637	10569	21	act	act	VB
18637	10569	22	instantly	instantly	RB
18637	10569	23	to	to	TO
18637	10569	24	suppress	suppress	VB
18637	10569	25	disturbance	disturbance	NN
18637	10569	26	or	or	CC
18637	10569	27	violence	violence	NN
18637	10569	28	or	or	CC
18637	10569	29	physical	physical	JJ
18637	10569	30	obstruction	obstruction	NN
18637	10569	31	or	or	CC
18637	10569	32	disrespect	disrespect	NN
18637	10569	33	to	to	IN
18637	10569	34	the	the	DT
18637	10569	35	court	court	NN
18637	10569	36	when	when	WRB
18637	10569	37	occurring	occur	VBG
18637	10569	38	in	in	IN
18637	10569	39	open	open	JJ
18637	10569	40	court	court	NN
18637	10569	41	.	.	.
18637	10570	1	There	there	EX
18637	10570	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	10570	3	no	no	DT
18637	10570	4	need	need	NN
18637	10570	5	of	of	IN
18637	10570	6	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	10570	7	or	or	CC
18637	10570	8	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	10570	9	of	of	IN
18637	10570	10	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	10570	11	before	before	IN
18637	10570	12	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	10570	13	,	,	,
18637	10570	14	because	because	IN
18637	10570	15	the	the	DT
18637	10570	16	court	court	NN
18637	10570	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	10570	18	seen	see	VBN
18637	10570	19	the	the	DT
18637	10570	20	offense	offense	NN
18637	10570	21	.	.	.
18637	10571	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	10571	2	summary	summary	NN
18637	10571	3	vindication	vindication	NN
18637	10571	4	of	of	IN
18637	10571	5	the	the	DT
18637	10571	6	court	court	NN
18637	10571	7	's	's	POS
18637	10571	8	dignity	dignity	NN
18637	10571	9	and	and	CC
18637	10571	10	authority	authority	NN
18637	10571	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	10571	12	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10571	13	.	.	.
18637	10572	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10572	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	10572	3	always	always	RB
18637	10572	4	been	be	VBN
18637	10572	5	so	so	RB
18637	10572	6	in	in	IN
18637	10572	7	the	the	DT
18637	10572	8	courts	court	NNS
18637	10572	9	of	of	IN
18637	10572	10	the	the	DT
18637	10572	11	common	common	JJ
18637	10572	12	law	law	NN
18637	10572	13	and	and	CC
18637	10572	14	the	the	DT
18637	10572	15	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	10572	16	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	10572	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	10572	18	due	due	JJ
18637	10572	19	process	process	NN
18637	10572	20	of	of	IN
18637	10572	21	law	law	NN
18637	10572	22	.	.	.
18637	10573	1	"	"	``
18637	10573	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10573	3	41	41	CD
18637	10573	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10573	5	The	the	DT
18637	10573	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10573	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10573	8	then	then	RB
18637	10573	9	added	add	VBD
18637	10573	10	:	:	:
18637	10573	11	"	"	``
18637	10573	12	Another	another	DT
18637	10573	13	feature	feature	NN
18637	10573	14	of	of	IN
18637	10573	15	this	this	DT
18637	10573	16	case	case	NN
18637	10573	17	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	10573	18	to	to	TO
18637	10573	19	call	call	VB
18637	10573	20	for	for	IN
18637	10573	21	remark	remark	NN
18637	10573	22	.	.	.
18637	10574	1	The	the	DT
18637	10574	2	power	power	NN
18637	10574	3	of	of	IN
18637	10574	4	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10574	5	which	which	WDT
18637	10574	6	a	a	DT
18637	10574	7	judge	judge	NN
18637	10574	8	must	must	MD
18637	10574	9	have	have	VB
18637	10574	10	and	and	CC
18637	10574	11	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	10574	12	in	in	IN
18637	10574	13	protecting	protect	VBG
18637	10574	14	the	the	DT
18637	10574	15	due	due	JJ
18637	10574	16	and	and	CC
18637	10574	17	orderly	orderly	JJ
18637	10574	18	administration	administration	NN
18637	10574	19	of	of	IN
18637	10574	20	justice	justice	NN
18637	10574	21	and	and	CC
18637	10574	22	in	in	IN
18637	10574	23	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	10574	24	the	the	DT
18637	10574	25	authority	authority	NN
18637	10574	26	and	and	CC
18637	10574	27	dignity	dignity	NN
18637	10574	28	of	of	IN
18637	10574	29	the	the	DT
18637	10574	30	court	court	NN
18637	10574	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	10574	32	most	most	RBS
18637	10574	33	important	important	JJ
18637	10574	34	and	and	CC
18637	10574	35	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
18637	10574	36	.	.	.
18637	10575	1	But	but	CC
18637	10575	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10575	3	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10575	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	10575	5	a	a	DT
18637	10575	6	delicate	delicate	JJ
18637	10575	7	one	one	NN
18637	10575	8	and	and	CC
18637	10575	9	care	care	NN
18637	10575	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	10575	11	needed	need	VBN
18637	10575	12	to	to	TO
18637	10575	13	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	10575	14	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	10575	15	or	or	CC
18637	10575	16	oppressive	oppressive	JJ
18637	10575	17	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
18637	10575	18	.	.	.
18637	10576	1	This	this	DT
18637	10576	2	rule	rule	NN
18637	10576	3	of	of	IN
18637	10576	4	caution	caution	NN
18637	10576	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	10576	6	more	more	RBR
18637	10576	7	mandatory	mandatory	JJ
18637	10576	8	where	where	WRB
18637	10576	9	the	the	DT
18637	10576	10	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10576	11	charged	charge	VBN
18637	10576	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	10576	13	in	in	IN
18637	10576	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10576	15	the	the	DT
18637	10576	16	element	element	NN
18637	10576	17	of	of	IN
18637	10576	18	personal	personal	JJ
18637	10576	19	criticism	criticism	NN
18637	10576	20	or	or	CC
18637	10576	21	attack	attack	NN
18637	10576	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	10576	23	the	the	DT
18637	10576	24	judge	judge	NN
18637	10576	25	.	.	.
18637	10577	1	The	the	DT
18637	10577	2	judge	judge	NN
18637	10577	3	must	must	MD
18637	10577	4	banish	banish	VB
18637	10577	5	the	the	DT
18637	10577	6	slightest	slight	JJS
18637	10577	7	personal	personal	JJ
18637	10577	8	impulse	impulse	NN
18637	10577	9	to	to	TO
18637	10577	10	reprisal	reprisal	VB
18637	10577	11	,	,	,
18637	10577	12	but	but	CC
18637	10577	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10577	14	should	should	MD
18637	10577	15	not	not	RB
18637	10577	16	bend	bend	VB
18637	10577	17	backward	backward	RB
18637	10577	18	and	and	CC
18637	10577	19	injure	injure	VB
18637	10577	20	the	the	DT
18637	10577	21	authority	authority	NN
18637	10577	22	of	of	IN
18637	10577	23	the	the	DT
18637	10577	24	court	court	NN
18637	10577	25	by	by	IN
18637	10577	26	too	too	RB
18637	10577	27	great	great	JJ
18637	10577	28	leniency	leniency	NN
18637	10577	29	.	.	.
18637	10578	1	The	the	DT
18637	10578	2	substitution	substitution	NN
18637	10578	3	of	of	IN
18637	10578	4	another	another	DT
18637	10578	5	judge	judge	NN
18637	10578	6	would	would	MD
18637	10578	7	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	10578	8	either	either	DT
18637	10578	9	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	10578	10	but	but	CC
18637	10578	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10578	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	10578	13	not	not	RB
18637	10578	14	always	always	RB
18637	10578	15	possible	possible	JJ
18637	10578	16	.	.	.
18637	10579	1	Of	of	RB
18637	10579	2	course	course	RB
18637	10579	3	where	where	WRB
18637	10579	4	acts	act	NNS
18637	10579	5	of	of	IN
18637	10579	6	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10579	7	are	be	VBP
18637	10579	8	palpably	palpably	RB
18637	10579	9	aggravated	aggravate	VBN
18637	10579	10	by	by	IN
18637	10579	11	a	a	DT
18637	10579	12	personal	personal	JJ
18637	10579	13	attack	attack	NN
18637	10579	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	10579	15	the	the	DT
18637	10579	16	judge	judge	NN
18637	10579	17	in	in	IN
18637	10579	18	order	order	NN
18637	10579	19	to	to	TO
18637	10579	20	drive	drive	VB
18637	10579	21	the	the	DT
18637	10579	22	judge	judge	NN
18637	10579	23	out	out	IN
18637	10579	24	of	of	IN
18637	10579	25	the	the	DT
18637	10579	26	case	case	NN
18637	10579	27	for	for	IN
18637	10579	28	ulterior	ulterior	JJ
18637	10579	29	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	10579	30	,	,	,
18637	10579	31	the	the	DT
18637	10579	32	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	10579	33	should	should	MD
18637	10579	34	not	not	RB
18637	10579	35	be	be	VB
18637	10579	36	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	10579	37	to	to	TO
18637	10579	38	succeed	succeed	VB
18637	10579	39	.	.	.
18637	10580	1	But	but	CC
18637	10580	2	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	10580	3	of	of	IN
18637	10580	4	this	this	DT
18637	10580	5	kind	kind	NN
18637	10580	6	are	be	VBP
18637	10580	7	rare	rare	JJ
18637	10580	8	.	.	.
18637	10581	1	All	all	DT
18637	10581	2	of	of	IN
18637	10581	3	such	such	JJ
18637	10581	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	10581	5	,	,	,
18637	10581	6	however	however	RB
18637	10581	7	,	,	,
18637	10581	8	present	present	JJ
18637	10581	9	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	10581	10	questions	question	NNS
18637	10581	11	for	for	IN
18637	10581	12	the	the	DT
18637	10581	13	judge	judge	NN
18637	10581	14	.	.	.
18637	10582	1	All	all	DT
18637	10582	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10582	3	can	can	MD
18637	10582	4	say	say	VB
18637	10582	5	upon	upon	IN
18637	10582	6	the	the	DT
18637	10582	7	whole	whole	JJ
18637	10582	8	matter	matter	NN
18637	10582	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	10582	10	that	that	IN
18637	10582	11	where	where	WRB
18637	10582	12	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	10582	13	do	do	VBP
18637	10582	14	not	not	RB
18637	10582	15	make	make	VB
18637	10582	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10582	17	impracticable	impracticable	JJ
18637	10582	18	,	,	,
18637	10582	19	or	or	CC
18637	10582	20	where	where	WRB
18637	10582	21	the	the	DT
18637	10582	22	delay	delay	NN
18637	10582	23	may	may	MD
18637	10582	24	not	not	RB
18637	10582	25	injure	injure	VB
18637	10582	26	public	public	JJ
18637	10582	27	or	or	CC
18637	10582	28	private	private	JJ
18637	10582	29	right	right	NN
18637	10582	30	,	,	,
18637	10582	31	a	a	DT
18637	10582	32	judge	judge	NN
18637	10582	33	called	call	VBN
18637	10582	34	upon	upon	IN
18637	10582	35	to	to	TO
18637	10582	36	act	act	VB
18637	10582	37	in	in	IN
18637	10582	38	a	a	DT
18637	10582	39	case	case	NN
18637	10582	40	of	of	IN
18637	10582	41	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10582	42	by	by	IN
18637	10582	43	personal	personal	JJ
18637	10582	44	attack	attack	NN
18637	10582	45	upon	upon	IN
18637	10582	46	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10582	47	,	,	,
18637	10582	48	may	may	MD
18637	10582	49	,	,	,
18637	10582	50	without	without	IN
18637	10582	51	flinching	flinch	VBG
18637	10582	52	from	from	IN
18637	10582	53	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10582	54	duty	duty	NN
18637	10582	55	,	,	,
18637	10582	56	properly	properly	RB
18637	10582	57	ask	ask	VB
18637	10582	58	that	that	IN
18637	10582	59	one	one	CD
18637	10582	60	of	of	IN
18637	10582	61	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10582	62	fellow	fellow	JJ
18637	10582	63	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10582	64	take	take	VBP
18637	10582	65	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10582	66	place	place	NN
18637	10582	67	.	.	.
18637	10583	1	Cornish	Cornish	NNP
18637	10583	2	_	_	NNP
18637	10583	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	10583	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10583	5	United	United	NNP
18637	10583	6	States	States	NNP
18637	10583	7	,	,	,
18637	10583	8	299	299	CD
18637	10583	9	F.	F.	NNP
18637	10583	10	283	283	CD
18637	10583	11	,	,	,
18637	10583	12	285	285	CD
18637	10583	13	;	;	:
18637	10583	14	Toledo	Toledo	NNP
18637	10583	15	Newspaper	Newspaper	NNP
18637	10583	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10583	17	_	_	NNP
18637	10583	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	10583	19	_	_	NNP
18637	10583	20	United	United	NNP
18637	10583	21	States	States	NNP
18637	10583	22	,	,	,
18637	10583	23	237	237	CD
18637	10583	24	F.	F.	NNP
18637	10583	25	986	986	CD
18637	10583	26	,	,	,
18637	10583	27	988	988	CD
18637	10583	28	.	.	.
18637	10584	1	The	the	DT
18637	10584	2	case	case	NN
18637	10584	3	before	before	IN
18637	10584	4	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10584	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	10584	6	one	one	CD
18637	10584	7	in	in	IN
18637	10584	8	which	which	WDT
18637	10584	9	the	the	DT
18637	10584	10	issue	issue	NN
18637	10584	11	between	between	IN
18637	10584	12	the	the	DT
18637	10584	13	judge	judge	NN
18637	10584	14	and	and	CC
18637	10584	15	the	the	DT
18637	10584	16	parties	party	NNS
18637	10584	17	had	have	VBD
18637	10584	18	come	come	VBN
18637	10584	19	to	to	TO
18637	10584	20	involve	involve	VB
18637	10584	21	marked	mark	VBN
18637	10584	22	personal	personal	JJ
18637	10584	23	feeling	feeling	NN
18637	10584	24	that	that	WDT
18637	10584	25	did	do	VBD
18637	10584	26	not	not	RB
18637	10584	27	make	make	VB
18637	10584	28	for	for	IN
18637	10584	29	an	an	DT
18637	10584	30	impartial	impartial	JJ
18637	10584	31	and	and	CC
18637	10584	32	calm	calm	JJ
18637	10584	33	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10584	34	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	10584	35	and	and	CC
18637	10584	36	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	10584	37	,	,	,
18637	10584	38	as	as	IN
18637	10584	39	the	the	DT
18637	10584	40	statement	statement	NN
18637	10584	41	of	of	IN
18637	10584	42	the	the	DT
18637	10584	43	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10584	44	abundantly	abundantly	RB
18637	10584	45	shows	show	VBZ
18637	10584	46	.	.	.
18637	10585	1	"	"	``
18637	10585	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10585	3	42	42	CD
18637	10585	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10585	5	Contempt	Contempt	NNP
18637	10585	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10585	7	:	:	:
18637	10585	8	Punishment	punishment	NN
18637	10585	9	of	of	IN
18637	10585	10	Counsel	Counsel	NNP
18637	10585	11	;	;	:
18637	10585	12	Sacher	Sacher	NNP
18637	10585	13	Case	Case	NNP
18637	10585	14	This	this	DT
18637	10585	15	case[43	case[43	NN
18637	10585	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10585	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	10585	18	an	an	DT
18637	10585	19	outgrowth	outgrowth	NN
18637	10585	20	of	of	IN
18637	10585	21	the	the	DT
18637	10585	22	trial	trial	NN
18637	10585	23	of	of	IN
18637	10585	24	the	the	DT
18637	10585	25	eleven	eleven	CD
18637	10585	26	Communists,[44	communists,[44	NN
18637	10585	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10585	28	in	in	IN
18637	10585	29	which	which	WDT
18637	10585	30	Sacher	Sacher	NNP
18637	10585	31	et	et	NNP
18637	10585	32	al	al	NNP
18637	10585	33	.	.	.
18637	10586	1	were	be	VBD
18637	10586	2	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	10586	3	for	for	IN
18637	10586	4	the	the	DT
18637	10586	5	defense	defense	NN
18637	10586	6	.	.	.
18637	10587	1	The	the	DT
18637	10587	2	facts	fact	NNS
18637	10587	3	of	of	IN
18637	10587	4	the	the	DT
18637	10587	5	case	case	NN
18637	10587	6	were	be	VBD
18637	10587	7	as	as	IN
18637	10587	8	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	10587	9	:	:	:
18637	10587	10	On	on	IN
18637	10587	11	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	10587	12	the	the	DT
18637	10587	13	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	10587	14	of	of	IN
18637	10587	15	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	10587	16	of	of	IN
18637	10587	17	the	the	DT
18637	10587	18	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	10587	19	,	,	,
18637	10587	20	trial	trial	NN
18637	10587	21	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	10587	22	Medina	Medina	NNP
18637	10587	23	at	at	IN
18637	10587	24	once	once	RB
18637	10587	25	issued	issue	VBD
18637	10587	26	a	a	DT
18637	10587	27	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	10587	28	under	under	IN
18637	10587	29	Rule	Rule	NNP
18637	10587	30	42	42	CD
18637	10587	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10587	32	a	a	DT
18637	10587	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10587	34	of	of	IN
18637	10587	35	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10587	36	Rules	Rules	NNPS
18637	10587	37	of	of	IN
18637	10587	38	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
18637	10587	39	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	10587	40	,	,	,
18637	10587	41	finding	find	VBG
18637	10587	42	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	10587	43	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	10587	44	of	of	IN
18637	10587	45	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10587	46	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10587	47	and	and	CC
18637	10587	48	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	10587	49	various	various	JJ
18637	10587	50	jail	jail	NN
18637	10587	51	terms	term	NNS
18637	10587	52	up	up	IN
18637	10587	53	to	to	TO
18637	10587	54	six	six	CD
18637	10587	55	months	month	NNS
18637	10587	56	.	.	.
18637	10588	1	The	the	DT
18637	10588	2	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	10588	3	question	question	NN
18637	10588	4	raised	raise	VBN
18637	10588	5	was	be	VBD
18637	10588	6	whether	whether	IN
18637	10588	7	the	the	DT
18637	10588	8	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10588	9	charged	charge	VBN
18637	10588	10	was	be	VBD
18637	10588	11	one	one	CD
18637	10588	12	which	which	WDT
18637	10588	13	the	the	DT
18637	10588	14	judge	judge	NN
18637	10588	15	was	be	VBD
18637	10588	16	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	10588	17	to	to	TO
18637	10588	18	determine	determine	VB
18637	10588	19	for	for	IN
18637	10588	20	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10588	21	,	,	,
18637	10588	22	or	or	CC
18637	10588	23	one	one	CD
18637	10588	24	which	which	WDT
18637	10588	25	under	under	IN
18637	10588	26	Rule	Rule	NNP
18637	10588	27	42	42	CD
18637	10588	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10588	29	b	b	NN
18637	10588	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10588	31	could	could	MD
18637	10588	32	only	only	RB
18637	10588	33	be	be	VB
18637	10588	34	passed	pass	VBN
18637	10588	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	10588	36	by	by	IN
18637	10588	37	another	another	DT
18637	10588	38	judge	judge	NN
18637	10588	39	and	and	CC
18637	10588	40	after	after	IN
18637	10588	41	notice	notice	NN
18637	10588	42	and	and	CC
18637	10588	43	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	10588	44	;	;	:
18637	10588	45	but	but	CC
18637	10588	46	behind	behind	IN
18637	10588	47	this	this	DT
18637	10588	48	issue	issue	NN
18637	10588	49	loomed	loom	VBD
18637	10588	50	the	the	DT
18637	10588	51	same	same	JJ
18637	10588	52	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10588	53	issue	issue	NN
18637	10588	54	which	which	WDT
18637	10588	55	was	be	VBD
18637	10588	56	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	10588	57	with	with	IN
18637	10588	58	by	by	IN
18637	10588	59	the	the	DT
18637	10588	60	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10588	61	in	in	IN
18637	10588	62	the	the	DT
18637	10588	63	Cooke	Cooke	NNP
18637	10588	64	case	case	NN
18637	10588	65	,	,	,
18637	10588	66	of	of	IN
18637	10588	67	the	the	DT
18637	10588	68	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	10588	69	of	of	IN
18637	10588	70	due	due	JJ
18637	10588	71	process	process	NN
18637	10588	72	of	of	IN
18637	10588	73	law	law	NN
18637	10588	74	.	.	.
18637	10589	1	The	the	DT
18637	10589	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10589	3	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	10589	4	the	the	DT
18637	10589	5	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
18637	10589	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10589	7	of	of	IN
18637	10589	8	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	10589	9	in	in	IN
18637	10589	10	affirming	affirm	VBG
18637	10589	11	the	the	DT
18637	10589	12	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	10589	13	and	and	CC
18637	10589	14	sentences	sentence	NNS
18637	10589	15	,	,	,
18637	10589	16	at	at	IN
18637	10589	17	the	the	DT
18637	10589	18	same	same	JJ
18637	10589	19	time	time	NN
18637	10589	20	,	,	,
18637	10589	21	however	however	RB
18637	10589	22	,	,	,
18637	10589	23	reversing	reverse	VBG
18637	10589	24	some	some	DT
18637	10589	25	of	of	IN
18637	10589	26	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	10589	27	Medina	Medina	NNP
18637	10589	28	's	's	POS
18637	10589	29	specifications	specification	NNS
18637	10589	30	of	of	IN
18637	10589	31	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10589	32	,	,	,
18637	10589	33	one	one	CD
18637	10589	34	of	of	IN
18637	10589	35	these	these	DT
18637	10589	36	being	be	VBG
18637	10589	37	the	the	DT
18637	10589	38	charge	charge	NN
18637	10589	39	that	that	IN
18637	10589	40	the	the	DT
18637	10589	41	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	10589	42	entered	enter	VBD
18637	10589	43	into	into	IN
18637	10589	44	an	an	DT
18637	10589	45	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	10589	46	deliberately	deliberately	RB
18637	10589	47	to	to	TO
18637	10589	48	"	"	``
18637	10589	49	impair	impair	VB
18637	10589	50	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10589	51	health	health	NN
18637	10589	52	.	.	.
18637	10589	53	"	"	''
18637	10590	1	"	"	``
18637	10590	2	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10590	3	hold	hold	VBP
18637	10590	4	,	,	,
18637	10590	5	"	"	''
18637	10590	6	said	say	VBD
18637	10590	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10590	8	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	10590	9	,	,	,
18637	10590	10	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	10590	11	for	for	IN
18637	10590	12	the	the	DT
18637	10590	13	majority	majority	NN
18637	10590	14	,	,	,
18637	10590	15	"	"	''
18637	10590	16	that	that	WDT
18637	10590	17	Rule	Rule	NNP
18637	10590	18	42	42	CD
18637	10590	19	allows	allow	VBZ
18637	10590	20	the	the	DT
18637	10590	21	trial	trial	NN
18637	10590	22	judge	judge	NN
18637	10590	23	,	,	,
18637	10590	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	10590	25	the	the	DT
18637	10590	26	occurrence	occurrence	NN
18637	10590	27	in	in	IN
18637	10590	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10590	29	presence	presence	NN
18637	10590	30	of	of	IN
18637	10590	31	a	a	DT
18637	10590	32	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10590	33	,	,	,
18637	10590	34	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	10590	35	and	and	CC
18637	10590	36	summarily	summarily	RB
18637	10590	37	to	to	TO
18637	10590	38	punish	punish	VB
18637	10590	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10590	40	,	,	,
18637	10590	41	if	if	IN
18637	10590	42	,	,	,
18637	10590	43	in	in	IN
18637	10590	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10590	45	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10590	46	,	,	,
18637	10590	47	delay	delay	NNP
18637	10590	48	will	will	MD
18637	10590	49	prejudice	prejudice	VB
18637	10590	50	the	the	DT
18637	10590	51	trial	trial	NN
18637	10590	52	.	.	.
18637	10591	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10591	2	hold	hold	VBP
18637	10591	3	,	,	,
18637	10591	4	on	on	IN
18637	10591	5	the	the	DT
18637	10591	6	other	other	JJ
18637	10591	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	10591	8	,	,	,
18637	10591	9	that	that	IN
18637	10591	10	if	if	IN
18637	10591	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10591	12	believes	believe	VBZ
18637	10591	13	the	the	DT
18637	10591	14	exigencies	exigency	NNS
18637	10591	15	of	of	IN
18637	10591	16	the	the	DT
18637	10591	17	trial	trial	NN
18637	10591	18	require	require	VBP
18637	10591	19	that	that	IN
18637	10591	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10591	21	defer	defer	VBP
18637	10591	22	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10591	23	until	until	IN
18637	10591	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10591	25	completion	completion	NN
18637	10591	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10591	27	may	may	MD
18637	10591	28	do	do	VB
18637	10591	29	so	so	RB
18637	10591	30	without	without	IN
18637	10591	31	extinguishing	extinguish	VBG
18637	10591	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10591	33	power	power	NN
18637	10591	34	.	.	.
18637	10592	1	*	*	NFP
18637	10592	2	*	*	NFP
18637	10592	3	*	*	NFP
18637	10592	4	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10592	5	are	be	VBP
18637	10592	6	not	not	RB
18637	10592	7	unaware	unaware	JJ
18637	10592	8	or	or	CC
18637	10592	9	unconcerned	unconcerned	JJ
18637	10592	10	that	that	IN
18637	10592	11	persons	person	NNS
18637	10592	12	identified	identify	VBN
18637	10592	13	with	with	IN
18637	10592	14	unpopular	unpopular	JJ
18637	10592	15	causes	cause	NNS
18637	10592	16	may	may	MD
18637	10592	17	find	find	VB
18637	10592	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10592	19	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	10592	20	to	to	TO
18637	10592	21	enlist	enlist	VB
18637	10592	22	the	the	DT
18637	10592	23	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	10592	24	of	of	IN
18637	10592	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10592	26	choice	choice	NN
18637	10592	27	.	.	.
18637	10593	1	But	but	CC
18637	10593	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10593	3	think	think	VBP
18637	10593	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10593	5	must	must	MD
18637	10593	6	be	be	VB
18637	10593	7	ascribed	ascribe	VBN
18637	10593	8	to	to	IN
18637	10593	9	causes	cause	VBZ
18637	10593	10	quite	quite	RB
18637	10593	11	apart	apart	RB
18637	10593	12	from	from	IN
18637	10593	13	fear	fear	NN
18637	10593	14	of	of	IN
18637	10593	15	being	be	VBG
18637	10593	16	held	hold	VBN
18637	10593	17	in	in	IN
18637	10593	18	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10593	19	,	,	,
18637	10593	20	for	for	IN
18637	10593	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10593	22	think	think	VBP
18637	10593	23	few	few	JJ
18637	10593	24	effective	effective	JJ
18637	10593	25	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
18637	10593	26	would	would	MD
18637	10593	27	regard	regard	VB
18637	10593	28	the	the	DT
18637	10593	29	tactics	tactic	NNS
18637	10593	30	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	10593	31	here	here	RB
18637	10593	32	as	as	IN
18637	10593	33	either	either	CC
18637	10593	34	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10593	35	or	or	CC
18637	10593	36	helpful	helpful	JJ
18637	10593	37	to	to	IN
18637	10593	38	a	a	DT
18637	10593	39	successful	successful	JJ
18637	10593	40	defense	defense	NN
18637	10593	41	.	.	.
18637	10594	1	That	that	IN
18637	10594	2	such	such	JJ
18637	10594	3	clients	client	NNS
18637	10594	4	seem	seem	VBP
18637	10594	5	to	to	TO
18637	10594	6	have	have	VB
18637	10594	7	thought	think	VBN
18637	10594	8	these	these	DT
18637	10594	9	tactics	tactic	NNS
18637	10594	10	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10594	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	10594	12	likely	likely	JJ
18637	10594	13	to	to	TO
18637	10594	14	contribute	contribute	VB
18637	10594	15	to	to	IN
18637	10594	16	the	the	DT
18637	10594	17	bar	bar	NN
18637	10594	18	's	's	POS
18637	10594	19	reluctance	reluctance	NN
18637	10594	20	to	to	TO
18637	10594	21	appear	appear	VB
18637	10594	22	for	for	IN
18637	10594	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10594	24	rather	rather	RB
18637	10594	25	more	more	JJR
18637	10594	26	than	than	IN
18637	10594	27	fear	fear	NN
18637	10594	28	of	of	IN
18637	10594	29	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10594	30	.	.	.
18637	10595	1	But	but	CC
18637	10595	2	that	that	IN
18637	10595	3	there	there	EX
18637	10595	4	may	may	MD
18637	10595	5	be	be	VB
18637	10595	6	no	no	DT
18637	10595	7	misunderstanding	misunderstanding	NN
18637	10595	8	,	,	,
18637	10595	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10595	10	make	make	VBP
18637	10595	11	clear	clear	JJ
18637	10595	12	that	that	IN
18637	10595	13	this	this	DT
18637	10595	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10595	15	,	,	,
18637	10595	16	if	if	IN
18637	10595	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10595	18	aid	aid	NN
18637	10595	19	be	be	VB
18637	10595	20	needed	need	VBN
18637	10595	21	,	,	,
18637	10595	22	will	will	MD
18637	10595	23	unhesitatingly	unhesitatingly	RB
18637	10595	24	protect	protect	VB
18637	10595	25	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	10595	26	in	in	IN
18637	10595	27	fearless	fearless	NN
18637	10595	28	,	,	,
18637	10595	29	vigorous	vigorous	JJ
18637	10595	30	and	and	CC
18637	10595	31	effective	effective	JJ
18637	10595	32	performance	performance	NN
18637	10595	33	of	of	IN
18637	10595	34	every	every	DT
18637	10595	35	duty	duty	NN
18637	10595	36	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	10595	37	to	to	IN
18637	10595	38	the	the	DT
18637	10595	39	office	office	NN
18637	10595	40	of	of	IN
18637	10595	41	the	the	DT
18637	10595	42	advocate	advocate	NN
18637	10595	43	on	on	IN
18637	10595	44	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	10595	45	of	of	IN
18637	10595	46	any	any	DT
18637	10595	47	person	person	NN
18637	10595	48	whatsoever	whatsoever	RB
18637	10595	49	.	.	.
18637	10596	1	But	but	CC
18637	10596	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10596	3	will	will	MD
18637	10596	4	not	not	RB
18637	10596	5	equate	equate	VB
18637	10596	6	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10596	7	with	with	IN
18637	10596	8	courage	courage	NN
18637	10596	9	or	or	CC
18637	10596	10	insults	insult	NNS
18637	10596	11	with	with	IN
18637	10596	12	independence	independence	NN
18637	10596	13	.	.	.
18637	10597	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10597	2	will	will	MD
18637	10597	3	also	also	RB
18637	10597	4	protect	protect	VB
18637	10597	5	the	the	DT
18637	10597	6	processes	process	NNS
18637	10597	7	of	of	IN
18637	10597	8	orderly	orderly	JJ
18637	10597	9	trial	trial	NN
18637	10597	10	,	,	,
18637	10597	11	which	which	WDT
18637	10597	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	10597	13	the	the	DT
18637	10597	14	supreme	supreme	JJ
18637	10597	15	object	object	NN
18637	10597	16	of	of	IN
18637	10597	17	the	the	DT
18637	10597	18	lawyer	lawyer	NN
18637	10597	19	's	's	POS
18637	10597	20	calling	calling	NN
18637	10597	21	.	.	.
18637	10598	1	"	"	``
18637	10598	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10598	3	45	45	CD
18637	10598	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10598	5	Contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10598	6	by	by	IN
18637	10598	7	Disobedience	disobedience	NN
18637	10598	8	of	of	IN
18637	10598	9	Orders	Orders	NNP
18637	10598	10	Disobedience	Disobedience	NNP
18637	10598	11	of	of	IN
18637	10598	12	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	10598	13	orders	order	NNS
18637	10598	14	,	,	,
18637	10598	15	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	10598	16	in	in	IN
18637	10598	17	labor	labor	NN
18637	10598	18	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	10598	19	,	,	,
18637	10598	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	10598	21	been	be	VBN
18637	10598	22	a	a	DT
18637	10598	23	fruitful	fruitful	JJ
18637	10598	24	source	source	NN
18637	10598	25	of	of	IN
18637	10598	26	cases	case	NNS
18637	10598	27	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	10598	28	with	with	IN
18637	10598	29	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10598	30	of	of	IN
18637	10598	31	court	court	NN
18637	10598	32	.	.	.
18637	10599	1	In	in	IN
18637	10599	2	United	United	NNP
18637	10599	3	States	States	NNP
18637	10599	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10599	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	10599	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10599	7	United	United	NNP
18637	10599	8	Mine	Mine	NNP
18637	10599	9	Workers[46	Workers[46	NNP
18637	10599	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10599	11	the	the	DT
18637	10599	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10599	13	held	hold	VBD
18637	10599	14	that	that	IN
18637	10599	15	disobedience	disobedience	NN
18637	10599	16	of	of	IN
18637	10599	17	a	a	DT
18637	10599	18	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	10599	19	restraining	restraining	NN
18637	10599	20	order	order	NN
18637	10599	21	issued	issue	VBN
18637	10599	22	for	for	IN
18637	10599	23	the	the	DT
18637	10599	24	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	10599	25	of	of	IN
18637	10599	26	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	10599	27	existing	exist	VBG
18637	10599	28	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	10599	29	,	,	,
18637	10599	30	pending	pende	VBG
18637	10599	31	the	the	DT
18637	10599	32	determination	determination	NN
18637	10599	33	of	of	IN
18637	10599	34	the	the	DT
18637	10599	35	court	court	NN
18637	10599	36	's	's	POS
18637	10599	37	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10599	38	,	,	,
18637	10599	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	10599	40	punishable	punishable	JJ
18637	10599	41	as	as	IN
18637	10599	42	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10599	43	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10599	44	where	where	WRB
18637	10599	45	the	the	DT
18637	10599	46	issue	issue	NN
18637	10599	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	10599	48	not	not	RB
18637	10599	49	frivolous	frivolous	JJ
18637	10599	50	but	but	CC
18637	10599	51	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	10599	52	.	.	.
18637	10600	1	Secondly	secondly	RB
18637	10600	2	,	,	,
18637	10600	3	the	the	DT
18637	10600	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10600	5	held	hold	VBD
18637	10600	6	that	that	IN
18637	10600	7	an	an	DT
18637	10600	8	order	order	NN
18637	10600	9	issued	issue	VBN
18637	10600	10	by	by	IN
18637	10600	11	a	a	DT
18637	10600	12	court	court	NN
18637	10600	13	with	with	IN
18637	10600	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10600	15	over	over	IN
18637	10600	16	the	the	DT
18637	10600	17	subject	subject	JJ
18637	10600	18	matter	matter	NN
18637	10600	19	and	and	CC
18637	10600	20	person	person	NN
18637	10600	21	must	must	MD
18637	10600	22	be	be	VB
18637	10600	23	obeyed	obey	VBN
18637	10600	24	by	by	IN
18637	10600	25	the	the	DT
18637	10600	26	parties	party	NNS
18637	10600	27	until	until	IN
18637	10600	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10600	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	10600	30	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	10600	31	by	by	IN
18637	10600	32	orderly	orderly	JJ
18637	10600	33	and	and	CC
18637	10600	34	proper	proper	JJ
18637	10600	35	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10600	36	,	,	,
18637	10600	37	even	even	RB
18637	10600	38	though	though	IN
18637	10600	39	the	the	DT
18637	10600	40	statute	statute	NN
18637	10600	41	under	under	IN
18637	10600	42	which	which	WDT
18637	10600	43	the	the	DT
18637	10600	44	order	order	NN
18637	10600	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	10600	46	issued	issue	VBN
18637	10600	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	10600	48	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	10600	49	.	.	.
18637	10601	1	Thirdly	thirdly	RB
18637	10601	2	,	,	,
18637	10601	3	on	on	IN
18637	10601	4	the	the	DT
18637	10601	5	basis	basis	NN
18637	10601	6	of	of	IN
18637	10601	7	United	United	NNP
18637	10601	8	States	States	NNP
18637	10601	9	_	_	NNP
18637	10601	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	10601	11	_	_	NNP
18637	10601	12	Shipp,[47	Shipp,[47	NNP
18637	10601	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10601	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10601	15	was	be	VBD
18637	10601	16	held	hold	VBN
18637	10601	17	that	that	IN
18637	10601	18	violations	violation	NNS
18637	10601	19	of	of	IN
18637	10601	20	a	a	DT
18637	10601	21	court	court	NN
18637	10601	22	's	's	POS
18637	10601	23	order	order	NN
18637	10601	24	are	be	VBP
18637	10601	25	punishable	punishable	JJ
18637	10601	26	as	as	IN
18637	10601	27	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10601	28	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10601	29	even	even	RB
18637	10601	30	though	though	IN
18637	10601	31	the	the	DT
18637	10601	32	order	order	NN
18637	10601	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	10601	34	set	set	VBN
18637	10601	35	aside	aside	RB
18637	10601	36	on	on	IN
18637	10601	37	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	10601	38	as	as	IN
18637	10601	39	in	in	IN
18637	10601	40	excess	excess	NN
18637	10601	41	of	of	IN
18637	10601	42	the	the	DT
18637	10601	43	court	court	NN
18637	10601	44	's	's	POS
18637	10601	45	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10601	46	or	or	CC
18637	10601	47	though	though	IN
18637	10601	48	the	the	DT
18637	10601	49	basic	basic	JJ
18637	10601	50	action	action	NN
18637	10601	51	has	have	VBZ
18637	10601	52	become	become	VBN
18637	10601	53	moot	moot	JJ
18637	10601	54	.	.	.
18637	10602	1	Finally	finally	RB
18637	10602	2	,	,	,
18637	10602	3	the	the	DT
18637	10602	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10602	5	held	hold	VBD
18637	10602	6	that	that	DT
18637	10602	7	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	10602	8	can	can	MD
18637	10602	9	amount	amount	VB
18637	10602	10	to	to	IN
18637	10602	11	both	both	CC
18637	10602	12	civil	civil	JJ
18637	10602	13	and	and	CC
18637	10602	14	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10602	15	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10602	16	,	,	,
18637	10602	17	and	and	CC
18637	10602	18	the	the	DT
18637	10602	19	same	same	JJ
18637	10602	20	acts	act	NNS
18637	10602	21	may	may	MD
18637	10602	22	justify	justify	VB
18637	10602	23	a	a	DT
18637	10602	24	court	court	NN
18637	10602	25	in	in	IN
18637	10602	26	resorting	resort	VBG
18637	10602	27	to	to	IN
18637	10602	28	coercive	coercive	VB
18637	10602	29	and	and	CC
18637	10602	30	to	to	IN
18637	10602	31	punitive	punitive	JJ
18637	10602	32	measures	measure	NNS
18637	10602	33	,	,	,
18637	10602	34	which	which	WDT
18637	10602	35	may	may	MD
18637	10602	36	be	be	VB
18637	10602	37	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	10602	38	in	in	IN
18637	10602	39	a	a	DT
18637	10602	40	single	single	JJ
18637	10602	41	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	10602	42	.	.	.
18637	10603	1	Criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10603	2	Versus	Versus	NNP
18637	10603	3	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	10603	4	Contempts	Contempts	NNP
18637	10603	5	Prior	prior	RB
18637	10603	6	to	to	IN
18637	10603	7	the	the	DT
18637	10603	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10603	9	Mine	Mine	NNP
18637	10603	10	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	10603	11	Case	Case	NNP
18637	10603	12	,	,	,
18637	10603	13	the	the	DT
18637	10603	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10603	15	had	have	VBD
18637	10603	16	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	10603	17	between	between	IN
18637	10603	18	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10603	19	and	and	CC
18637	10603	20	civil	civil	JJ
18637	10603	21	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	10603	22	on	on	IN
18637	10603	23	the	the	DT
18637	10603	24	basis	basis	NN
18637	10603	25	of	of	IN
18637	10603	26	the	the	DT
18637	10603	27	vindication	vindication	NN
18637	10603	28	of	of	IN
18637	10603	29	the	the	DT
18637	10603	30	authority	authority	NN
18637	10603	31	of	of	IN
18637	10603	32	the	the	DT
18637	10603	33	courts	court	NNS
18637	10603	34	on	on	IN
18637	10603	35	the	the	DT
18637	10603	36	one	one	CD
18637	10603	37	hand	hand	NN
18637	10603	38	and	and	CC
18637	10603	39	the	the	DT
18637	10603	40	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	10603	41	and	and	CC
18637	10603	42	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10603	43	of	of	IN
18637	10603	44	the	the	DT
18637	10603	45	rights	right	NNS
18637	10603	46	of	of	IN
18637	10603	47	the	the	DT
18637	10603	48	parties	party	NNS
18637	10603	49	on	on	IN
18637	10603	50	the	the	DT
18637	10603	51	other	other	JJ
18637	10603	52	.	.	.
18637	10604	1	A	a	DT
18637	10604	2	civil	civil	JJ
18637	10604	3	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10604	4	consists	consist	VBZ
18637	10604	5	of	of	IN
18637	10604	6	the	the	DT
18637	10604	7	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	10604	8	of	of	IN
18637	10604	9	a	a	DT
18637	10604	10	person	person	NN
18637	10604	11	in	in	IN
18637	10604	12	a	a	DT
18637	10604	13	civil	civil	JJ
18637	10604	14	case	case	NN
18637	10604	15	to	to	TO
18637	10604	16	obey	obey	VB
18637	10604	17	a	a	DT
18637	10604	18	mandatory	mandatory	JJ
18637	10604	19	order	order	NN
18637	10604	20	.	.	.
18637	10605	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10605	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	10605	3	incomplete	incomplete	JJ
18637	10605	4	in	in	IN
18637	10605	5	nature	nature	NN
18637	10605	6	and	and	CC
18637	10605	7	may	may	MD
18637	10605	8	be	be	VB
18637	10605	9	purged	purge	VBN
18637	10605	10	by	by	IN
18637	10605	11	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	10605	12	to	to	IN
18637	10605	13	the	the	DT
18637	10605	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10605	15	order	order	NN
18637	10605	16	.	.	.
18637	10606	1	In	in	IN
18637	10606	2	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10606	3	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10606	4	,	,	,
18637	10606	5	however	however	RB
18637	10606	6	,	,	,
18637	10606	7	the	the	DT
18637	10606	8	act	act	NN
18637	10606	9	of	of	IN
18637	10606	10	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10606	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	10606	12	been	be	VBN
18637	10606	13	completed	complete	VBN
18637	10606	14	,	,	,
18637	10606	15	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	10606	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	10606	17	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	10606	18	to	to	TO
18637	10606	19	vindicate	vindicate	VB
18637	10606	20	the	the	DT
18637	10606	21	authority	authority	NN
18637	10606	22	of	of	IN
18637	10606	23	the	the	DT
18637	10606	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10606	25	,	,	,
18637	10606	26	and	and	CC
18637	10606	27	a	a	DT
18637	10606	28	person	person	NN
18637	10606	29	can	can	MD
18637	10606	30	not	not	RB
18637	10606	31	by	by	IN
18637	10606	32	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	10606	33	action	action	NN
18637	10606	34	purge	purge	NN
18637	10606	35	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10606	36	of	of	IN
18637	10606	37	such	such	JJ
18637	10606	38	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10606	39	.	.	.
18637	10607	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10607	2	48	48	CD
18637	10607	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10607	4	In	in	IN
18637	10607	5	a	a	DT
18637	10607	6	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	10607	7	in	in	IN
18637	10607	8	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	10607	9	parte	parte	NNP
18637	10607	10	Grossman,[49	Grossman,[49	NNP
18637	10607	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10607	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10607	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10607	14	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	10607	15	,	,	,
18637	10607	16	while	while	IN
18637	10607	17	holding	hold	VBG
18637	10607	18	for	for	IN
18637	10607	19	the	the	DT
18637	10607	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10607	21	on	on	IN
18637	10607	22	the	the	DT
18637	10607	23	main	main	JJ
18637	10607	24	issue	issue	NN
18637	10607	25	that	that	IN
18637	10607	26	the	the	DT
18637	10607	27	President	President	NNP
18637	10607	28	may	may	MD
18637	10607	29	pardon	pardon	VB
18637	10607	30	a	a	DT
18637	10607	31	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10607	32	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10607	33	,	,	,
18637	10607	34	declared	declare	VBD
18637	10607	35	that	that	IN
18637	10607	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10607	37	may	may	MD
18637	10607	38	not	not	RB
18637	10607	39	pardon	pardon	VB
18637	10607	40	a	a	DT
18637	10607	41	civil	civil	JJ
18637	10607	42	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10607	43	.	.	.
18637	10608	1	In	in	IN
18637	10608	2	an	an	DT
18637	10608	3	analogous	analogous	JJ
18637	10608	4	case	case	NN
18637	10608	5	,	,	,
18637	10608	6	the	the	DT
18637	10608	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10608	8	was	be	VBD
18637	10608	9	emphatic	emphatic	JJ
18637	10608	10	in	in	IN
18637	10608	11	a	a	DT
18637	10608	12	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	10608	13	that	that	IN
18637	10608	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10608	15	can	can	MD
18637	10608	16	not	not	RB
18637	10608	17	require	require	VB
18637	10608	18	a	a	DT
18637	10608	19	jury	jury	NN
18637	10608	20	trial	trial	NN
18637	10608	21	where	where	WRB
18637	10608	22	the	the	DT
18637	10608	23	contemnor	contemnor	NN
18637	10608	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	10608	25	failed	fail	VBN
18637	10608	26	to	to	TO
18637	10608	27	perform	perform	VB
18637	10608	28	a	a	DT
18637	10608	29	positive	positive	JJ
18637	10608	30	act	act	NN
18637	10608	31	for	for	IN
18637	10608	32	the	the	DT
18637	10608	33	relief	relief	NN
18637	10608	34	of	of	IN
18637	10608	35	private	private	JJ
18637	10608	36	parties	party	NNS
18637	10608	37	.	.	.
18637	10609	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10609	2	50	50	CD
18637	10609	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10609	4	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	10609	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10609	6	Aids	Aids	NNP
18637	10609	7	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	10609	8	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10609	9	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNPS
18637	10609	10	to	to	TO
18637	10609	11	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	10609	12	the	the	DT
18637	10609	13	orders	order	NNS
18637	10609	14	of	of	IN
18637	10609	15	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	10609	16	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	10609	17	and	and	CC
18637	10609	18	subpoenas	subpoena	NNS
18637	10609	19	issued	issue	VBN
18637	10609	20	by	by	IN
18637	10609	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10609	22	to	to	TO
18637	10609	23	appear	appear	VB
18637	10609	24	and	and	CC
18637	10609	25	produce	produce	VB
18637	10609	26	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	10609	27	have	have	VBP
18637	10609	28	become	become	VBN
18637	10609	29	increasingly	increasingly	RB
18637	10609	30	common	common	JJ
18637	10609	31	since	since	IN
18637	10609	32	the	the	DT
18637	10609	33	leading	leading	JJ
18637	10609	34	case	case	NN
18637	10609	35	of	of	IN
18637	10609	36	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	10609	37	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10609	38	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	10609	39	_	_	NNP
18637	10609	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	10609	41	_	_	NNP
18637	10609	42	Brimson,[51	Brimson,[51	NNP
18637	10609	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10609	44	where	where	WRB
18637	10609	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10609	46	was	be	VBD
18637	10609	47	held	hold	VBN
18637	10609	48	that	that	IN
18637	10609	49	the	the	DT
18637	10609	50	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10609	51	power	power	NN
18637	10609	52	of	of	IN
18637	10609	53	the	the	DT
18637	10609	54	courts	court	NNS
18637	10609	55	might	may	MD
18637	10609	56	by	by	IN
18637	10609	57	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	10609	58	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	10609	59	be	be	VB
18637	10609	60	utilized	utilize	VBN
18637	10609	61	in	in	IN
18637	10609	62	aid	aid	NN
18637	10609	63	of	of	IN
18637	10609	64	the	the	DT
18637	10609	65	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	10609	66	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10609	67	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	10609	68	in	in	IN
18637	10609	69	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	10609	70	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	10609	71	with	with	IN
18637	10609	72	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10609	73	orders	order	NNS
18637	10609	74	.	.	.
18637	10610	1	In	in	IN
18637	10610	2	1947	1947	CD
18637	10610	3	a	a	DT
18637	10610	4	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	10610	5	to	to	TO
18637	10610	6	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	10610	7	a	a	DT
18637	10610	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10610	9	subpoena	subpoena	NN
18637	10610	10	duces	duce	NNS
18637	10610	11	tecum	tecum	VBP
18637	10610	12	_	_	NNP
18637	10610	13	issued	issue	VBN
18637	10610	14	by	by	IN
18637	10610	15	the	the	DT
18637	10610	16	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	10610	17	and	and	CC
18637	10610	18	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	10610	19	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	10610	20	during	during	IN
18637	10610	21	the	the	DT
18637	10610	22	Course	course	NN
18637	10610	23	of	of	IN
18637	10610	24	an	an	DT
18637	10610	25	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	10610	26	was	be	VBD
18637	10610	27	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	10610	28	to	to	TO
18637	10610	29	be	be	VB
18637	10610	30	civil	civil	JJ
18637	10610	31	in	in	IN
18637	10610	32	character	character	NN
18637	10610	33	on	on	IN
18637	10610	34	the	the	DT
18637	10610	35	ground	ground	NN
18637	10610	36	that	that	IN
18637	10610	37	the	the	DT
18637	10610	38	only	only	JJ
18637	10610	39	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	10610	40	was	be	VBD
18637	10610	41	a	a	DT
18637	10610	42	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	10610	43	designed	design	VBN
18637	10610	44	to	to	TO
18637	10610	45	compel	compel	VB
18637	10610	46	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	10610	47	.	.	.
18637	10611	1	The	the	DT
18637	10611	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10611	3	then	then	RB
18637	10611	4	enunciated	enunciate	VBD
18637	10611	5	the	the	DT
18637	10611	6	principle	principle	NN
18637	10611	7	that	that	IN
18637	10611	8	where	where	WRB
18637	10611	9	a	a	DT
18637	10611	10	fine	fine	JJ
18637	10611	11	or	or	CC
18637	10611	12	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	10611	13	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	10611	14	on	on	IN
18637	10611	15	the	the	DT
18637	10611	16	contemnor	contemnor	NN
18637	10611	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	10611	18	designed	design	VBN
18637	10611	19	to	to	TO
18637	10611	20	coerce	coerce	VB
18637	10611	21	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10611	22	to	to	TO
18637	10611	23	do	do	VB
18637	10611	24	what	what	WP
18637	10611	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10611	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	10611	27	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	10611	28	to	to	TO
18637	10611	29	do	do	VB
18637	10611	30	,	,	,
18637	10611	31	the	the	DT
18637	10611	32	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	10611	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	10611	34	one	one	CD
18637	10611	35	for	for	IN
18637	10611	36	civil	civil	JJ
18637	10611	37	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	10611	38	.	.	.
18637	10612	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10612	2	52	52	CD
18637	10612	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10612	4	POWER	power	NN
18637	10612	5	TO	to	IN
18637	10612	6	ISSUE	ISSUE	NNP
18637	10612	7	WRITS	WRITS	NNP
18637	10612	8	;	;	:
18637	10612	9	THE	the	DT
18637	10612	10	ACT	ACT	NNP
18637	10612	11	OF	of	IN
18637	10612	12	1789	1789	CD
18637	10612	13	From	from	IN
18637	10612	14	the	the	DT
18637	10612	15	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	10612	16	of	of	IN
18637	10612	17	government	government	NN
18637	10612	18	under	under	IN
18637	10612	19	the	the	DT
18637	10612	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10612	21	of	of	IN
18637	10612	22	1789	1789	CD
18637	10612	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10612	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	10612	25	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	10612	26	under	under	IN
18637	10612	27	the	the	DT
18637	10612	28	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10612	29	and	and	CC
18637	10612	30	proper	proper	JJ
18637	10612	31	clause	clause	NN
18637	10612	32	,	,	,
18637	10612	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10612	34	power	power	NN
18637	10612	35	to	to	TO
18637	10612	36	establish	establish	VB
18637	10612	37	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	10612	38	courts	court	NNS
18637	10612	39	,	,	,
18637	10612	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10612	41	power	power	NN
18637	10612	42	to	to	TO
18637	10612	43	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	10612	44	the	the	DT
18637	10612	45	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10612	46	of	of	IN
18637	10612	47	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10612	48	courts	court	NNS
18637	10612	49	and	and	CC
18637	10612	50	the	the	DT
18637	10612	51	power	power	NN
18637	10612	52	to	to	TO
18637	10612	53	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	10612	54	the	the	DT
18637	10612	55	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	10612	56	of	of	IN
18637	10612	57	writs	writ	NNS
18637	10612	58	.	.	.
18637	10613	1	The	the	DT
18637	10613	2	Thirteenth	Thirteenth	NNP
18637	10613	3	section	section	NN
18637	10613	4	of	of	IN
18637	10613	5	the	the	DT
18637	10613	6	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	10613	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10613	8	of	of	IN
18637	10613	9	1789	1789	CD
18637	10613	10	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	10613	11	the	the	DT
18637	10613	12	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	10613	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	10613	14	to	to	TO
18637	10613	15	issue	issue	VB
18637	10613	16	writs	writ	NNS
18637	10613	17	of	of	IN
18637	10613	18	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	10613	19	to	to	IN
18637	10613	20	the	the	DT
18637	10613	21	district	district	NN
18637	10613	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	10613	23	,	,	,
18637	10613	24	and	and	CC
18637	10613	25	the	the	DT
18637	10613	26	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10613	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10613	28	to	to	TO
18637	10613	29	issue	issue	VB
18637	10613	30	such	such	JJ
18637	10613	31	writs	writ	NNS
18637	10613	32	to	to	IN
18637	10613	33	the	the	DT
18637	10613	34	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	10613	35	courts	court	NNS
18637	10613	36	.	.	.
18637	10614	1	The	the	DT
18637	10614	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10614	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10614	4	was	be	VBD
18637	10614	5	also	also	RB
18637	10614	6	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	10614	7	to	to	TO
18637	10614	8	issue	issue	VB
18637	10614	9	writs	writ	NNS
18637	10614	10	of	of	IN
18637	10614	11	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	10614	12	"	"	''
18637	10614	13	in	in	IN
18637	10614	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	10614	15	warranted	warrant	VBN
18637	10614	16	by	by	IN
18637	10614	17	the	the	DT
18637	10614	18	principles	principle	NNS
18637	10614	19	and	and	CC
18637	10614	20	usages	usage	NNS
18637	10614	21	of	of	IN
18637	10614	22	law	law	NN
18637	10614	23	,	,	,
18637	10614	24	to	to	IN
18637	10614	25	any	any	DT
18637	10614	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	10614	27	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	10614	28	,	,	,
18637	10614	29	or	or	CC
18637	10614	30	persons	person	NNS
18637	10614	31	holding	hold	VBG
18637	10614	32	office	office	NN
18637	10614	33	,	,	,
18637	10614	34	under	under	IN
18637	10614	35	the	the	DT
18637	10614	36	authority	authority	NN
18637	10614	37	of	of	IN
18637	10614	38	the	the	DT
18637	10614	39	United	United	NNP
18637	10614	40	States	States	NNP
18637	10614	41	.	.	.
18637	10615	1	"	"	``
18637	10615	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10615	3	53	53	CD
18637	10615	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10615	5	Section	section	NN
18637	10615	6	14	14	CD
18637	10615	7	provided	provide	VBD
18637	10615	8	that	that	IN
18637	10615	9	all	all	DT
18637	10615	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	10615	11	of	of	IN
18637	10615	12	the	the	DT
18637	10615	13	United	United	NNP
18637	10615	14	States	States	NNP
18637	10615	15	should	should	MD
18637	10615	16	"	"	``
18637	10615	17	have	have	VB
18637	10615	18	power	power	NN
18637	10615	19	to	to	TO
18637	10615	20	issue	issue	VB
18637	10615	21	writs	writ	NNS
18637	10615	22	of	of	IN
18637	10615	23	_	_	NNP
18637	10615	24	scire	scire	NN
18637	10615	25	facias	facias	NNP
18637	10615	26	_	_	NNP
18637	10615	27	,	,	,
18637	10615	28	_	_	NNP
18637	10615	29	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	10615	30	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	10615	31	_	_	NNP
18637	10615	32	,	,	,
18637	10615	33	and	and	CC
18637	10615	34	all	all	DT
18637	10615	35	other	other	JJ
18637	10615	36	writs	writ	NNS
18637	10615	37	not	not	RB
18637	10615	38	specially	specially	RB
18637	10615	39	provided	provide	VBN
18637	10615	40	for	for	IN
18637	10615	41	by	by	IN
18637	10615	42	statute	statute	NN
18637	10615	43	,	,	,
18637	10615	44	which	which	WDT
18637	10615	45	may	may	MD
18637	10615	46	be	be	VB
18637	10615	47	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10615	48	for	for	IN
18637	10615	49	the	the	DT
18637	10615	50	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10615	51	of	of	IN
18637	10615	52	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10615	53	respective	respective	JJ
18637	10615	54	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NNS
18637	10615	55	,	,	,
18637	10615	56	and	and	CC
18637	10615	57	agreeable	agreeable	JJ
18637	10615	58	to	to	IN
18637	10615	59	the	the	DT
18637	10615	60	principles	principle	NNS
18637	10615	61	and	and	CC
18637	10615	62	usages	usage	NNS
18637	10615	63	of	of	IN
18637	10615	64	law	law	NN
18637	10615	65	.	.	.
18637	10616	1	"	"	``
18637	10616	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10616	3	54	54	CD
18637	10616	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10616	5	Issuance	issuance	NN
18637	10616	6	of	of	IN
18637	10616	7	the	the	DT
18637	10616	8	writ	writ	NNP
18637	10616	9	of	of	IN
18637	10616	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10616	11	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	10616	12	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	10616	13	_	_	NNP
18637	10616	14	was	be	VBD
18637	10616	15	limited	limit	VBN
18637	10616	16	in	in	IN
18637	10616	17	that	that	IN
18637	10616	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10616	19	was	be	VBD
18637	10616	20	to	to	TO
18637	10616	21	extend	extend	VB
18637	10616	22	only	only	RB
18637	10616	23	to	to	IN
18637	10616	24	persons	person	NNS
18637	10616	25	in	in	IN
18637	10616	26	custody	custody	NN
18637	10616	27	under	under	IN
18637	10616	28	or	or	CC
18637	10616	29	by	by	IN
18637	10616	30	color	color	NN
18637	10616	31	of	of	IN
18637	10616	32	authority	authority	NN
18637	10616	33	of	of	IN
18637	10616	34	the	the	DT
18637	10616	35	United	United	NNP
18637	10616	36	States	States	NNP
18637	10616	37	.	.	.
18637	10617	1	Although	although	IN
18637	10617	2	the	the	DT
18637	10617	3	act	act	NN
18637	10617	4	of	of	IN
18637	10617	5	1789	1789	CD
18637	10617	6	left	leave	VBD
18637	10617	7	the	the	DT
18637	10617	8	power	power	NN
18637	10617	9	over	over	IN
18637	10617	10	writs	writ	NNS
18637	10617	11	subject	subject	JJ
18637	10617	12	largely	largely	RB
18637	10617	13	to	to	IN
18637	10617	14	the	the	DT
18637	10617	15	common	common	JJ
18637	10617	16	law	law	NN
18637	10617	17	,	,	,
18637	10617	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10617	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	10617	20	significant	significant	JJ
18637	10617	21	as	as	IN
18637	10617	22	a	a	DT
18637	10617	23	reflection	reflection	NN
18637	10617	24	of	of	IN
18637	10617	25	the	the	DT
18637	10617	26	belief	belief	NN
18637	10617	27	,	,	,
18637	10617	28	in	in	IN
18637	10617	29	which	which	WDT
18637	10617	30	the	the	DT
18637	10617	31	courts	court	NNS
18637	10617	32	have	have	VBP
18637	10617	33	on	on	IN
18637	10617	34	the	the	DT
18637	10617	35	whole	whole	JJ
18637	10617	36	concurred	concurred	NN
18637	10617	37	,	,	,
18637	10617	38	that	that	IN
18637	10617	39	an	an	DT
18637	10617	40	act	act	NN
18637	10617	41	of	of	IN
18637	10617	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10617	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	10617	44	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10617	45	to	to	TO
18637	10617	46	confer	confer	VB
18637	10617	47	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10617	48	power	power	NN
18637	10617	49	to	to	TO
18637	10617	50	issue	issue	VB
18637	10617	51	writs	writ	NNS
18637	10617	52	.	.	.
18637	10618	1	Common	Common	NNP
18637	10618	2	Law	Law	NNP
18637	10618	3	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	10618	4	of	of	IN
18637	10618	5	the	the	DT
18637	10618	6	District	District	NNP
18637	10618	7	of	of	IN
18637	10618	8	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	10618	9	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	10618	10	That	that	DT
18637	10618	11	portion	portion	NN
18637	10618	12	of	of	IN
18637	10618	13	section	section	NN
18637	10618	14	13	13	CD
18637	10618	15	which	which	WDT
18637	10618	16	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	10618	17	the	the	DT
18637	10618	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10618	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10618	20	to	to	TO
18637	10618	21	issue	issue	VB
18637	10618	22	writs	writ	NNS
18637	10618	23	of	of	IN
18637	10618	24	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	10618	25	in	in	IN
18637	10618	26	the	the	DT
18637	10618	27	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10618	28	of	of	IN
18637	10618	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10618	30	original	original	JJ
18637	10618	31	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10618	32	was	be	VBD
18637	10618	33	held	hold	VBN
18637	10618	34	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	10618	35	in	in	IN
18637	10618	36	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	10618	37	_	_	NNP
18637	10618	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	10618	39	_	_	NNP
18637	10618	40	Madison,[55	Madison,[55	NNP
18637	10618	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10618	42	as	as	IN
18637	10618	43	an	an	DT
18637	10618	44	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	10618	45	enlargement	enlargement	NN
18637	10618	46	of	of	IN
18637	10618	47	the	the	DT
18637	10618	48	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10618	49	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10618	50	's	's	POS
18637	10618	51	original	original	JJ
18637	10618	52	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10618	53	.	.	.
18637	10619	1	After	after	IN
18637	10619	2	two	two	CD
18637	10619	3	more	more	JJR
18637	10619	4	futile	futile	JJ
18637	10619	5	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	10619	6	to	to	TO
18637	10619	7	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	10619	8	a	a	DT
18637	10619	9	writ	writ	NNP
18637	10619	10	of	of	IN
18637	10619	11	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	10619	12	,	,	,
18637	10619	13	in	in	IN
18637	10619	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	10619	15	in	in	IN
18637	10619	16	which	which	WDT
18637	10619	17	the	the	DT
18637	10619	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10619	19	found	find	VBD
18637	10619	20	that	that	DT
18637	10619	21	power	power	NN
18637	10619	22	to	to	TO
18637	10619	23	issue	issue	VB
18637	10619	24	the	the	DT
18637	10619	25	writ	writ	NNP
18637	10619	26	had	have	VBD
18637	10619	27	not	not	RB
18637	10619	28	been	be	VBN
18637	10619	29	vested	vest	VBN
18637	10619	30	by	by	IN
18637	10619	31	statute	statute	NN
18637	10619	32	in	in	IN
18637	10619	33	the	the	DT
18637	10619	34	courts	court	NNS
18637	10619	35	of	of	IN
18637	10619	36	the	the	DT
18637	10619	37	United	United	NNP
18637	10619	38	States	States	NNP
18637	10619	39	except	except	IN
18637	10619	40	in	in	IN
18637	10619	41	aid	aid	NN
18637	10619	42	of	of	IN
18637	10619	43	already	already	RB
18637	10619	44	existing	exist	VBG
18637	10619	45	jurisdiction,[56	jurisdiction,[56	NNP
18637	10619	46	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10619	47	a	a	DT
18637	10619	48	litigant	litigant	NN
18637	10619	49	was	be	VBD
18637	10619	50	successful	successful	JJ
18637	10619	51	in	in	IN
18637	10619	52	Kendall	Kendall	NNP
18637	10619	53	_	_	NNP
18637	10619	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	10619	55	_	_	NNP
18637	10619	56	United	United	NNP
18637	10619	57	States	States	NNP
18637	10619	58	ex	ex	NNP
18637	10619	59	rel	rel	NN
18637	10619	60	.	.	.
18637	10620	1	Stokes[57	stokes[57	LS
18637	10620	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10620	3	in	in	IN
18637	10620	4	finding	find	VBG
18637	10620	5	a	a	DT
18637	10620	6	court	court	NN
18637	10620	7	which	which	WDT
18637	10620	8	would	would	MD
18637	10620	9	take	take	VB
18637	10620	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10620	11	in	in	IN
18637	10620	12	a	a	DT
18637	10620	13	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	10620	14	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	10620	15	.	.	.
18637	10621	1	This	this	DT
18637	10621	2	was	be	VBD
18637	10621	3	the	the	DT
18637	10621	4	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	10621	5	court	court	NN
18637	10621	6	of	of	IN
18637	10621	7	the	the	DT
18637	10621	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10621	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10621	10	for	for	IN
18637	10621	11	the	the	DT
18637	10621	12	District	District	NNP
18637	10621	13	of	of	IN
18637	10621	14	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	10621	15	which	which	WDT
18637	10621	16	was	be	VBD
18637	10621	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	10621	18	to	to	TO
18637	10621	19	have	have	VB
18637	10621	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10621	21	,	,	,
18637	10621	22	on	on	IN
18637	10621	23	the	the	DT
18637	10621	24	theory	theory	NN
18637	10621	25	that	that	IN
18637	10621	26	the	the	DT
18637	10621	27	common	common	JJ
18637	10621	28	law	law	NN
18637	10621	29	,	,	,
18637	10621	30	in	in	IN
18637	10621	31	force	force	NN
18637	10621	32	in	in	IN
18637	10621	33	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	10621	34	when	when	WRB
18637	10621	35	the	the	DT
18637	10621	36	cession	cession	NN
18637	10621	37	of	of	IN
18637	10621	38	that	that	DT
18637	10621	39	part	part	NN
18637	10621	40	of	of	IN
18637	10621	41	the	the	DT
18637	10621	42	State	State	NNP
18637	10621	43	which	which	WDT
18637	10621	44	became	become	VBD
18637	10621	45	the	the	DT
18637	10621	46	District	District	NNP
18637	10621	47	of	of	IN
18637	10621	48	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	10621	49	was	be	VBD
18637	10621	50	made	make	VBN
18637	10621	51	to	to	IN
18637	10621	52	the	the	DT
18637	10621	53	United	United	NNP
18637	10621	54	States	States	NNP
18637	10621	55	,	,	,
18637	10621	56	remained	remain	VBD
18637	10621	57	in	in	IN
18637	10621	58	force	force	NN
18637	10621	59	in	in	IN
18637	10621	60	the	the	DT
18637	10621	61	District	District	NNP
18637	10621	62	.	.	.
18637	10622	1	At	at	IN
18637	10622	2	an	an	DT
18637	10622	3	early	early	JJ
18637	10622	4	time	time	NN
18637	10622	5	,	,	,
18637	10622	6	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	10622	7	,	,	,
18637	10622	8	the	the	DT
18637	10622	9	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10622	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	10622	11	established	establish	VBD
18637	10622	12	the	the	DT
18637	10622	13	rule	rule	NN
18637	10622	14	that	that	IN
18637	10622	15	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	10622	16	can	can	MD
18637	10622	17	be	be	VB
18637	10622	18	issued	issue	VBN
18637	10622	19	only	only	RB
18637	10622	20	when	when	WRB
18637	10622	21	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	10622	22	by	by	IN
18637	10622	23	a	a	DT
18637	10622	24	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10622	25	statute	statute	NN
18637	10622	26	and	and	CC
18637	10622	27	within	within	IN
18637	10622	28	the	the	DT
18637	10622	29	limits	limit	NNS
18637	10622	30	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	10622	31	by	by	IN
18637	10622	32	the	the	DT
18637	10622	33	common	common	JJ
18637	10622	34	law	law	NN
18637	10622	35	and	and	CC
18637	10622	36	the	the	DT
18637	10622	37	separation	separation	NN
18637	10622	38	of	of	IN
18637	10622	39	powers	power	NNS
18637	10622	40	.	.	.
18637	10623	1	Habeas	Habeas	NNP
18637	10623	2	Corpus	Corpus	NNP
18637	10623	3	Although	although	IN
18637	10623	4	the	the	DT
18637	10623	5	writ	writ	NN
18637	10623	6	of	of	IN
18637	10623	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10623	8	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	10623	9	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	10623	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10623	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	10623	12	something	something	NN
18637	10623	13	of	of	IN
18637	10623	14	a	a	DT
18637	10623	15	special	special	JJ
18637	10623	16	status	status	NN
18637	10623	17	by	by	IN
18637	10623	18	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	10623	19	of	of	IN
18637	10623	20	article	article	NN
18637	10623	21	I	i	NN
18637	10623	22	,	,	,
18637	10623	23	section	section	NN
18637	10623	24	9	9	CD
18637	10623	25	,	,	,
18637	10623	26	paragraph	paragraph	NN
18637	10623	27	2	2	CD
18637	10623	28	,	,	,
18637	10623	29	the	the	DT
18637	10623	30	power	power	NN
18637	10623	31	of	of	IN
18637	10623	32	a	a	DT
18637	10623	33	specific	specific	JJ
18637	10623	34	court	court	NN
18637	10623	35	to	to	TO
18637	10623	36	issue	issue	VB
18637	10623	37	the	the	DT
18637	10623	38	writ	writ	NNP
18637	10623	39	has	have	VBZ
18637	10623	40	long	long	RB
18637	10623	41	been	be	VBN
18637	10623	42	held	hold	VBN
18637	10623	43	to	to	TO
18637	10623	44	have	have	VB
18637	10623	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10623	46	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	10623	47	only	only	RB
18637	10623	48	in	in	IN
18637	10623	49	written	write	VBN
18637	10623	50	law	law	NN
18637	10623	51	.	.	.
18637	10624	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10624	2	58	58	CD
18637	10624	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10624	4	In	in	IN
18637	10624	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	10624	6	parte	parte	NNP
18637	10624	7	Yerger,[59	Yerger,[59	NNP
18637	10624	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10624	9	where	where	WRB
18637	10624	10	the	the	DT
18637	10624	11	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	10624	12	was	be	VBD
18637	10624	13	held	hold	VBN
18637	10624	14	in	in	IN
18637	10624	15	custody	custody	NN
18637	10624	16	by	by	IN
18637	10624	17	the	the	DT
18637	10624	18	military	military	JJ
18637	10624	19	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	10624	20	under	under	IN
18637	10624	21	the	the	DT
18637	10624	22	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
18637	10624	23	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	10624	24	,	,	,
18637	10624	25	the	the	DT
18637	10624	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10624	27	,	,	,
18637	10624	28	referring	refer	VBG
18637	10624	29	to	to	IN
18637	10624	30	the	the	DT
18637	10624	31	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	10624	32	against	against	IN
18637	10624	33	the	the	DT
18637	10624	34	suspension	suspension	NN
18637	10624	35	of	of	IN
18637	10624	36	the	the	DT
18637	10624	37	writ	writ	NNP
18637	10624	38	of	of	IN
18637	10624	39	_	_	NNP
18637	10624	40	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	10624	41	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	10624	42	_	_	NNP
18637	10624	43	,	,	,
18637	10624	44	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	10624	45	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	10624	46	that	that	IN
18637	10624	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10624	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	10624	49	not	not	RB
18637	10624	50	bound	bind	VBN
18637	10624	51	to	to	TO
18637	10624	52	provide	provide	VB
18637	10624	53	for	for	IN
18637	10624	54	the	the	DT
18637	10624	55	protection	protection	NN
18637	10624	56	of	of	IN
18637	10624	57	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10624	58	rights	right	NNS
18637	10624	59	by	by	IN
18637	10624	60	investing	invest	VBG
18637	10624	61	the	the	DT
18637	10624	62	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10624	63	courts	court	NNS
18637	10624	64	with	with	IN
18637	10624	65	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10624	66	to	to	TO
18637	10624	67	protect	protect	VB
18637	10624	68	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10624	69	.	.	.
18637	10625	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	10625	2	,	,	,
18637	10625	3	the	the	DT
18637	10625	4	case	case	NN
18637	10625	5	also	also	RB
18637	10625	6	incorporates	incorporate	VBZ
18637	10625	7	the	the	DT
18637	10625	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	10625	9	that	that	DT
18637	10625	10	power	power	NN
18637	10625	11	to	to	TO
18637	10625	12	issue	issue	VB
18637	10625	13	the	the	DT
18637	10625	14	writ	writ	NNP
18637	10625	15	may	may	MD
18637	10625	16	be	be	VB
18637	10625	17	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	10625	18	even	even	RB
18637	10625	19	in	in	IN
18637	10625	20	pending	pende	VBG
18637	10625	21	cases	case	NNS
18637	10625	22	.	.	.
18637	10626	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10626	2	60	60	CD
18637	10626	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10626	4	The	the	DT
18637	10626	5	rules	rule	NNS
18637	10626	6	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	10626	7	to	to	IN
18637	10626	8	mandamus	mandamus	NNP
18637	10626	9	and	and	CC
18637	10626	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10626	11	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	10626	12	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	10626	13	_	_	NNP
18637	10626	14	are	be	VBP
18637	10626	15	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	10626	16	to	to	IN
18637	10626	17	the	the	DT
18637	10626	18	other	other	JJ
18637	10626	19	common	common	JJ
18637	10626	20	law	law	NN
18637	10626	21	and	and	CC
18637	10626	22	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	10626	23	writs	writ	NNS
18637	10626	24	,	,	,
18637	10626	25	the	the	DT
18637	10626	26	power	power	NN
18637	10626	27	to	to	TO
18637	10626	28	issue	issue	VB
18637	10626	29	which	which	WDT
18637	10626	30	,	,	,
18637	10626	31	though	though	IN
18637	10626	32	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10626	33	in	in	IN
18637	10626	34	nature	nature	NN
18637	10626	35	,	,	,
18637	10626	36	must	must	MD
18637	10626	37	be	be	VB
18637	10626	38	derived	derive	VBN
18637	10626	39	from	from	IN
18637	10626	40	the	the	DT
18637	10626	41	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	10626	42	and	and	CC
18637	10626	43	can	can	MD
18637	10626	44	not	not	RB
18637	10626	45	go	go	VB
18637	10626	46	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	10626	47	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10626	48	.	.	.
18637	10627	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10627	2	Limits	limit	VBZ
18637	10627	3	the	the	DT
18637	10627	4	Inquisition	Inquisition	NNP
18637	10627	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10627	6	Although	although	IN
18637	10627	7	the	the	DT
18637	10627	8	speculations	speculation	NNS
18637	10627	9	of	of	IN
18637	10627	10	some	some	DT
18637	10627	11	publicists	publicist	NNS
18637	10627	12	and	and	CC
18637	10627	13	some	some	DT
18637	10627	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10627	15	dicta[61	dicta[61	NN
18637	10627	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10627	17	support	support	VB
18637	10627	18	the	the	DT
18637	10627	19	idea	idea	NN
18637	10627	20	of	of	IN
18637	10627	21	an	an	DT
18637	10627	22	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10627	23	power	power	NN
18637	10627	24	of	of	IN
18637	10627	25	the	the	DT
18637	10627	26	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10627	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	10627	28	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	10627	29	in	in	IN
18637	10627	30	equity	equity	NN
18637	10627	31	to	to	TO
18637	10627	32	issue	issue	VB
18637	10627	33	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	10627	34	independently	independently	RB
18637	10627	35	of	of	IN
18637	10627	36	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	10627	37	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	10627	38	,	,	,
18637	10627	39	neither	neither	CC
18637	10627	40	the	the	DT
18637	10627	41	course	course	NN
18637	10627	42	taken	take	VBN
18637	10627	43	by	by	IN
18637	10627	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10627	45	nor	nor	CC
18637	10627	46	the	the	DT
18637	10627	47	specific	specific	JJ
18637	10627	48	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	10627	49	of	of	IN
18637	10627	50	the	the	DT
18637	10627	51	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10627	52	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10627	53	support	support	VBP
18637	10627	54	any	any	DT
18637	10627	55	such	such	JJ
18637	10627	56	principle	principle	NN
18637	10627	57	.	.	.
18637	10628	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10628	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	10628	3	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	10628	4	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	10628	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10628	6	power	power	NN
18637	10628	7	to	to	TO
18637	10628	8	limit	limit	VB
18637	10628	9	the	the	DT
18637	10628	10	use	use	NN
18637	10628	11	of	of	IN
18637	10628	12	the	the	DT
18637	10628	13	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	10628	14	in	in	IN
18637	10628	15	the	the	DT
18637	10628	16	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10628	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	10628	18	.	.	.
18637	10629	1	The	the	DT
18637	10629	2	first	first	JJ
18637	10629	3	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	10629	4	on	on	IN
18637	10629	5	the	the	DT
18637	10629	6	equity	equity	NN
18637	10629	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10629	8	of	of	IN
18637	10629	9	the	the	DT
18637	10629	10	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10629	11	courts	court	NNS
18637	10629	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	10629	13	to	to	TO
18637	10629	14	be	be	VB
18637	10629	15	found	find	VBN
18637	10629	16	in	in	IN
18637	10629	17	section	section	NN
18637	10629	18	16	16	CD
18637	10629	19	of	of	IN
18637	10629	20	the	the	DT
18637	10629	21	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	10629	22	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10629	23	of	of	IN
18637	10629	24	1789	1789	CD
18637	10629	25	,	,	,
18637	10629	26	which	which	WDT
18637	10629	27	provided	provide	VBD
18637	10629	28	that	that	IN
18637	10629	29	no	no	DT
18637	10629	30	equity	equity	NN
18637	10629	31	suit	suit	NN
18637	10629	32	should	should	MD
18637	10629	33	be	be	VB
18637	10629	34	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	10629	35	where	where	WRB
18637	10629	36	there	there	EX
18637	10629	37	was	be	VBD
18637	10629	38	a	a	DT
18637	10629	39	full	full	JJ
18637	10629	40	and	and	CC
18637	10629	41	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	10629	42	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	10629	43	at	at	IN
18637	10629	44	law	law	NN
18637	10629	45	.	.	.
18637	10630	1	Although	although	IN
18637	10630	2	this	this	DT
18637	10630	3	provision	provision	NN
18637	10630	4	did	do	VBD
18637	10630	5	no	no	RB
18637	10630	6	more	more	RBR
18637	10630	7	than	than	IN
18637	10630	8	declare	declare	VB
18637	10630	9	a	a	DT
18637	10630	10	pre	pre	JJ
18637	10630	11	-	-	JJ
18637	10630	12	existing	exist	VBG
18637	10630	13	rule	rule	NN
18637	10630	14	long	long	RB
18637	10630	15	applied	apply	VBN
18637	10630	16	in	in	IN
18637	10630	17	chancery	chancery	NN
18637	10630	18	courts,[62	courts,[62	CD
18637	10630	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10630	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10630	21	did	do	VBD
18637	10630	22	assert	assert	VB
18637	10630	23	the	the	DT
18637	10630	24	power	power	NN
18637	10630	25	of	of	IN
18637	10630	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10630	27	to	to	TO
18637	10630	28	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	10630	29	the	the	DT
18637	10630	30	equity	equity	NN
18637	10630	31	powers	power	NNS
18637	10630	32	of	of	IN
18637	10630	33	the	the	DT
18637	10630	34	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10630	35	courts	court	NNS
18637	10630	36	.	.	.
18637	10631	1	The	the	DT
18637	10631	2	act	act	NN
18637	10631	3	of	of	IN
18637	10631	4	March	March	NNP
18637	10631	5	2	2	CD
18637	10631	6	,	,	,
18637	10631	7	1793,[63	1793,[63	CD
18637	10631	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10631	9	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	10631	10	the	the	DT
18637	10631	11	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	10631	12	of	of	IN
18637	10631	13	any	any	DT
18637	10631	14	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	10631	15	by	by	IN
18637	10631	16	any	any	DT
18637	10631	17	court	court	NN
18637	10631	18	of	of	IN
18637	10631	19	the	the	DT
18637	10631	20	United	United	NNP
18637	10631	21	States	States	NNP
18637	10631	22	to	to	TO
18637	10631	23	stay	stay	VB
18637	10631	24	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10631	25	in	in	IN
18637	10631	26	State	State	NNP
18637	10631	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	10631	28	except	except	IN
18637	10631	29	where	where	WRB
18637	10631	30	such	such	JJ
18637	10631	31	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	10631	32	may	may	MD
18637	10631	33	be	be	VB
18637	10631	34	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	10631	35	by	by	IN
18637	10631	36	any	any	DT
18637	10631	37	law	law	NN
18637	10631	38	relating	relate	VBG
18637	10631	39	to	to	IN
18637	10631	40	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	10631	41	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10631	42	.	.	.
18637	10632	1	In	in	IN
18637	10632	2	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	10632	3	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	10632	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10632	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	10632	6	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	10632	7	the	the	DT
18637	10632	8	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	10632	9	of	of	IN
18637	10632	10	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	10632	11	in	in	IN
18637	10632	12	the	the	DT
18637	10632	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10632	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	10632	15	to	to	TO
18637	10632	16	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	10632	17	the	the	DT
18637	10632	18	collection	collection	NN
18637	10632	19	of	of	IN
18637	10632	20	taxes;[64	taxes;[64	NNP
18637	10632	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10632	22	provided	provide	VBN
18637	10632	23	for	for	IN
18637	10632	24	a	a	DT
18637	10632	25	three	three	CD
18637	10632	26	-	-	HYPH
18637	10632	27	judge	judge	NN
18637	10632	28	court	court	NN
18637	10632	29	,	,	,
18637	10632	30	as	as	IN
18637	10632	31	a	a	DT
18637	10632	32	prerequisite	prerequisite	NN
18637	10632	33	to	to	IN
18637	10632	34	the	the	DT
18637	10632	35	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	10632	36	of	of	IN
18637	10632	37	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	10632	38	to	to	TO
18637	10632	39	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	10632	40	the	the	DT
18637	10632	41	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10632	42	of	of	IN
18637	10632	43	State	state	NN
18637	10632	44	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	10632	45	for	for	IN
18637	10632	46	unconstitutionality,[65	unconstitutionality,[65	NN
18637	10632	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10632	48	for	for	IN
18637	10632	49	enjoining	enjoin	VBG
18637	10632	50	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10632	51	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	10632	52	for	for	IN
18637	10632	53	unconstitutionality,[66	unconstitutionality,[66	CD
18637	10632	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10632	55	and	and	CC
18637	10632	56	for	for	IN
18637	10632	57	enjoining	enjoin	VBG
18637	10632	58	orders	order	NNS
18637	10632	59	of	of	IN
18637	10632	60	the	the	DT
18637	10632	61	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	10632	62	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10632	63	Commission;[67	Commission;[67	NNP
18637	10632	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10632	65	limited	limit	VBD
18637	10632	66	the	the	DT
18637	10632	67	power	power	NN
18637	10632	68	to	to	TO
18637	10632	69	issue	issue	VB
18637	10632	70	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	10632	71	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	10632	72	rate	rate	NN
18637	10632	73	orders	order	NNS
18637	10632	74	of	of	IN
18637	10632	75	State	state	NN
18637	10632	76	public	public	JJ
18637	10632	77	utility	utility	NN
18637	10632	78	commissions,[68	commissions,[68	CD
18637	10632	79	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10632	80	and	and	CC
18637	10632	81	the	the	DT
18637	10632	82	use	use	NN
18637	10632	83	of	of	IN
18637	10632	84	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	10632	85	in	in	IN
18637	10632	86	labor	labor	NN
18637	10632	87	disputes;[69	disputes;[69	NNP
18637	10632	88	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10632	89	and	and	CC
18637	10632	90	placed	place	VBD
18637	10632	91	a	a	DT
18637	10632	92	very	very	RB
18637	10632	93	rigid	rigid	JJ
18637	10632	94	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	10632	95	of	of	IN
18637	10632	96	the	the	DT
18637	10632	97	power	power	NN
18637	10632	98	to	to	TO
18637	10632	99	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	10632	100	orders	order	NNS
18637	10632	101	of	of	IN
18637	10632	102	the	the	DT
18637	10632	103	administrator	administrator	NN
18637	10632	104	under	under	IN
18637	10632	105	the	the	DT
18637	10632	106	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	10632	107	Price	Price	NNP
18637	10632	108	Control	Control	NNP
18637	10632	109	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10632	110	.	.	.
18637	10633	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10633	2	70	70	CD
18637	10633	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10633	4	All	all	DT
18637	10633	5	of	of	IN
18637	10633	6	these	these	DT
18637	10633	7	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	10633	8	have	have	VBP
18637	10633	9	been	be	VBN
18637	10633	10	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	10633	11	by	by	IN
18637	10633	12	the	the	DT
18637	10633	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10633	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10633	15	as	as	IN
18637	10633	16	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10633	17	and	and	CC
18637	10633	18	applied	apply	VBN
18637	10633	19	with	with	IN
18637	10633	20	varying	vary	VBG
18637	10633	21	degrees	degree	NNS
18637	10633	22	of	of	IN
18637	10633	23	thoroughness	thoroughness	NN
18637	10633	24	.	.	.
18637	10634	1	The	the	DT
18637	10634	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10634	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	10634	4	made	make	VBN
18637	10634	5	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	10634	6	to	to	IN
18637	10634	7	the	the	DT
18637	10634	8	application	application	NN
18637	10634	9	of	of	IN
18637	10634	10	the	the	DT
18637	10634	11	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	10634	12	against	against	IN
18637	10634	13	the	the	DT
18637	10634	14	stay	stay	NN
18637	10634	15	of	of	IN
18637	10634	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10634	17	in	in	IN
18637	10634	18	State	State	NNP
18637	10634	19	courts,[71	courts,[71	NNP
18637	10634	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10634	21	but	but	CC
18637	10634	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	10634	23	on	on	IN
18637	10634	24	the	the	DT
18637	10634	25	whole	whole	NN
18637	10634	26	adhered	adhere	VBN
18637	10634	27	to	to	IN
18637	10634	28	the	the	DT
18637	10634	29	statute	statute	NN
18637	10634	30	.	.	.
18637	10635	1	The	the	DT
18637	10635	2	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	10635	3	raise	raise	VBP
18637	10635	4	no	no	DT
18637	10635	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10635	6	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10635	7	,	,	,
18637	10635	8	and	and	CC
18637	10635	9	the	the	DT
18637	10635	10	later	later	JJ
18637	10635	11	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	10635	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	10635	13	to	to	TO
18637	10635	14	contract	contract	VB
18637	10635	15	the	the	DT
18637	10635	16	scope	scope	NN
18637	10635	17	of	of	IN
18637	10635	18	the	the	DT
18637	10635	19	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	10635	20	.	.	.
18637	10636	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10636	2	72	72	CD
18637	10636	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10636	4	In	in	IN
18637	10636	5	Duplex	Duplex	NNP
18637	10636	6	Printing	Printing	NNP
18637	10636	7	Company	Company	NNP
18637	10636	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10636	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	10636	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10636	11	Deering,[73	Deering,[73	NNP
18637	10636	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10636	13	the	the	DT
18637	10636	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10636	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10636	16	placed	place	VBD
18637	10636	17	a	a	DT
18637	10636	18	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	10636	19	construction	construction	NN
18637	10636	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	10636	21	the	the	DT
18637	10636	22	labor	labor	NN
18637	10636	23	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	10636	24	of	of	IN
18637	10636	25	the	the	DT
18637	10636	26	Clayton	Clayton	NNP
18637	10636	27	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10636	28	and	and	CC
18637	10636	29	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	10636	30	contributed	contribute	VBN
18637	10636	31	in	in	IN
18637	10636	32	part	part	NN
18637	10636	33	to	to	IN
18637	10636	34	the	the	DT
18637	10636	35	more	more	RBR
18637	10636	36	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	10636	37	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	10636	38	by	by	IN
18637	10636	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10636	40	of	of	IN
18637	10636	41	the	the	DT
18637	10636	42	use	use	NN
18637	10636	43	of	of	IN
18637	10636	44	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	10636	45	in	in	IN
18637	10636	46	labor	labor	NN
18637	10636	47	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	10636	48	in	in	IN
18637	10636	49	the	the	DT
18637	10636	50	Norris	Norris	NNP
18637	10636	51	-	-	HYPH
18637	10636	52	LaGuardia	LaGuardia	NNP
18637	10636	53	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10636	54	of	of	IN
18637	10636	55	1932	1932	CD
18637	10636	56	which	which	WDT
18637	10636	57	has	have	VBZ
18637	10636	58	not	not	RB
18637	10636	59	only	only	RB
18637	10636	60	been	be	VBN
18637	10636	61	declared	declare	VBN
18637	10636	62	constitutional,[74	constitutional,[74	CD
18637	10636	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10636	64	but	but	CC
18637	10636	65	has	have	VBZ
18637	10636	66	been	be	VBN
18637	10636	67	applied	apply	VBN
18637	10636	68	liberally,[75	liberally,[75	NN
18637	10636	69	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10636	70	and	and	CC
18637	10636	71	in	in	IN
18637	10636	72	such	such	PDT
18637	10636	73	a	a	DT
18637	10636	74	manner	manner	NN
18637	10636	75	as	as	IN
18637	10636	76	to	to	TO
18637	10636	77	repudiate	repudiate	VB
18637	10636	78	the	the	DT
18637	10636	79	notion	notion	NN
18637	10636	80	of	of	IN
18637	10636	81	an	an	DT
18637	10636	82	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10636	83	power	power	NN
18637	10636	84	to	to	TO
18637	10636	85	issue	issue	VB
18637	10636	86	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	10636	87	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	10636	88	to	to	IN
18637	10636	89	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	10636	90	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	10636	91	.	.	.
18637	10637	1	Injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	10637	2	Under	under	IN
18637	10637	3	the	the	DT
18637	10637	4	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	10637	5	Price	Price	NNP
18637	10637	6	Control	Control	NNP
18637	10637	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10637	8	of	of	IN
18637	10637	9	1942	1942	CD
18637	10637	10	Lockerty	Lockerty	NNP
18637	10637	11	_	_	NNP
18637	10637	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	10637	13	_	_	NNP
18637	10637	14	Phillips[76	Phillips[76	NNP
18637	10637	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10637	16	justifies	justify	VBZ
18637	10637	17	the	the	DT
18637	10637	18	same	same	JJ
18637	10637	19	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	10637	20	.	.	.
18637	10638	1	Here	here	RB
18637	10638	2	the	the	DT
18637	10638	3	validity	validity	NN
18637	10638	4	of	of	IN
18637	10638	5	the	the	DT
18637	10638	6	special	special	JJ
18637	10638	7	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	10638	8	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	10638	9	of	of	IN
18637	10638	10	the	the	DT
18637	10638	11	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	10638	12	Price	Price	NNP
18637	10638	13	Control	Control	NNP
18637	10638	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10638	15	of	of	IN
18637	10638	16	1942	1942	CD
18637	10638	17	was	be	VBD
18637	10638	18	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	10638	19	.	.	.
18637	10639	1	This	this	DT
18637	10639	2	act	act	NN
18637	10639	3	provided	provide	VBD
18637	10639	4	for	for	IN
18637	10639	5	a	a	DT
18637	10639	6	special	special	JJ
18637	10639	7	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	10639	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10639	9	of	of	IN
18637	10639	10	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	10639	11	which	which	WDT
18637	10639	12	,	,	,
18637	10639	13	subject	subject	JJ
18637	10639	14	to	to	IN
18637	10639	15	review	review	NN
18637	10639	16	by	by	IN
18637	10639	17	the	the	DT
18637	10639	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10639	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10639	20	,	,	,
18637	10639	21	was	be	VBD
18637	10639	22	given	give	VBN
18637	10639	23	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	10639	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10639	25	to	to	TO
18637	10639	26	determine	determine	VB
18637	10639	27	the	the	DT
18637	10639	28	validity	validity	NN
18637	10639	29	of	of	IN
18637	10639	30	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	10639	31	,	,	,
18637	10639	32	orders	order	NNS
18637	10639	33	,	,	,
18637	10639	34	and	and	CC
18637	10639	35	price	price	NN
18637	10639	36	schedules	schedule	NNS
18637	10639	37	issued	issue	VBN
18637	10639	38	by	by	IN
18637	10639	39	the	the	DT
18637	10639	40	Office	Office	NNP
18637	10639	41	of	of	IN
18637	10639	42	Price	Price	NNP
18637	10639	43	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	10639	44	.	.	.
18637	10640	1	The	the	DT
18637	10640	2	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	10640	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10640	4	and	and	CC
18637	10640	5	the	the	DT
18637	10640	6	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	10640	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10640	8	alone	alone	RB
18637	10640	9	was	be	VBD
18637	10640	10	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	10640	11	to	to	TO
18637	10640	12	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	10640	13	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	10640	14	or	or	CC
18637	10640	15	orders	order	NNS
18637	10640	16	of	of	IN
18637	10640	17	OPA	opa	NN
18637	10640	18	,	,	,
18637	10640	19	and	and	CC
18637	10640	20	even	even	RB
18637	10640	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10640	22	could	could	MD
18637	10640	23	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	10640	24	such	such	JJ
18637	10640	25	orders	order	NNS
18637	10640	26	only	only	RB
18637	10640	27	after	after	IN
18637	10640	28	finding	find	VBG
18637	10640	29	that	that	IN
18637	10640	30	the	the	DT
18637	10640	31	order	order	NN
18637	10640	32	was	be	VBD
18637	10640	33	not	not	RB
18637	10640	34	in	in	IN
18637	10640	35	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	10640	36	with	with	IN
18637	10640	37	law	law	NN
18637	10640	38	,	,	,
18637	10640	39	or	or	CC
18637	10640	40	was	be	VBD
18637	10640	41	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	10640	42	or	or	CC
18637	10640	43	capricious	capricious	JJ
18637	10640	44	.	.	.
18637	10641	1	The	the	DT
18637	10641	2	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	10641	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10641	4	was	be	VBD
18637	10641	5	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	10641	6	denied	deny	VBN
18637	10641	7	power	power	NN
18637	10641	8	to	to	TO
18637	10641	9	issue	issue	VB
18637	10641	10	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	10641	11	restraining	restraining	NN
18637	10641	12	orders	order	NNS
18637	10641	13	or	or	CC
18637	10641	14	interlocutory	interlocutory	JJ
18637	10641	15	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	10641	16	;	;	:
18637	10641	17	and	and	CC
18637	10641	18	in	in	IN
18637	10641	19	addition	addition	NN
18637	10641	20	the	the	DT
18637	10641	21	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
18637	10641	22	of	of	IN
18637	10641	23	any	any	DT
18637	10641	24	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	10641	25	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	10641	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10641	27	might	may	MD
18637	10641	28	issue	issue	VB
18637	10641	29	was	be	VBD
18637	10641	30	to	to	TO
18637	10641	31	be	be	VB
18637	10641	32	postponed	postpone	VBN
18637	10641	33	for	for	IN
18637	10641	34	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	10641	35	days	day	NNS
18637	10641	36	.	.	.
18637	10642	1	If	if	IN
18637	10642	2	review	review	NN
18637	10642	3	was	be	VBD
18637	10642	4	sought	seek	VBN
18637	10642	5	in	in	IN
18637	10642	6	the	the	DT
18637	10642	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10642	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10642	9	by	by	IN
18637	10642	10	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	10642	11	,	,	,
18637	10642	12	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
18637	10642	13	was	be	VBD
18637	10642	14	to	to	TO
18637	10642	15	be	be	VB
18637	10642	16	postponed	postpone	VBN
18637	10642	17	until	until	IN
18637	10642	18	final	final	JJ
18637	10642	19	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	10642	20	.	.	.
18637	10643	1	A	a	DT
18637	10643	2	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	10643	3	court	court	NN
18637	10643	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	10643	5	through	through	IN
18637	10643	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10643	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10643	8	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	10643	9	declared	declare	VBD
18637	10643	10	that	that	IN
18637	10643	11	there	there	EX
18637	10643	12	"	"	``
18637	10643	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	10643	14	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	10643	15	in	in	IN
18637	10643	16	the	the	DT
18637	10643	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10643	18	which	which	WDT
18637	10643	19	requires	require	VBZ
18637	10643	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10643	21	to	to	TO
18637	10643	22	confer	confer	VB
18637	10643	23	equity	equity	NN
18637	10643	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10643	25	on	on	IN
18637	10643	26	any	any	DT
18637	10643	27	particular	particular	JJ
18637	10643	28	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	10643	29	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10643	30	court	court	NN
18637	10643	31	.	.	.
18637	10643	32	"	"	''
18637	10644	1	All	all	DT
18637	10644	2	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10644	3	courts	court	NNS
18637	10644	4	,	,	,
18637	10644	5	other	other	JJ
18637	10644	6	than	than	IN
18637	10644	7	the	the	DT
18637	10644	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10644	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10644	10	,	,	,
18637	10644	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10644	12	was	be	VBD
18637	10644	13	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	10644	14	,	,	,
18637	10644	15	derive	derive	VB
18637	10644	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10644	17	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10644	18	solely	solely	RB
18637	10644	19	from	from	IN
18637	10644	20	the	the	DT
18637	10644	21	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10644	22	of	of	IN
18637	10644	23	the	the	DT
18637	10644	24	authority	authority	NN
18637	10644	25	to	to	TO
18637	10644	26	ordain	ordain	VB
18637	10644	27	and	and	CC
18637	10644	28	establish	establish	VB
18637	10644	29	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	10644	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	10644	31	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	10644	32	on	on	IN
18637	10644	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10644	34	by	by	IN
18637	10644	35	article	article	NN
18637	10644	36	III	III	NNP
18637	10644	37	,	,	,
18637	10644	38	§	§	NNP
18637	10644	39	1	1	CD
18637	10644	40	,	,	,
18637	10644	41	of	of	IN
18637	10644	42	the	the	DT
18637	10644	43	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10644	44	.	.	.
18637	10645	1	This	this	DT
18637	10645	2	power	power	NN
18637	10645	3	,	,	,
18637	10645	4	which	which	WDT
18637	10645	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10645	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	10645	7	left	leave	VBN
18637	10645	8	free	free	JJ
18637	10645	9	to	to	TO
18637	10645	10	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	10645	11	or	or	CC
18637	10645	12	not	not	RB
18637	10645	13	,	,	,
18637	10645	14	was	be	VBD
18637	10645	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	10645	16	to	to	TO
18637	10645	17	include	include	VB
18637	10645	18	the	the	DT
18637	10645	19	power	power	NN
18637	10645	20	"	"	''
18637	10645	21	'	'	''
18637	10645	22	of	of	IN
18637	10645	23	investing	invest	VBG
18637	10645	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10645	25	with	with	IN
18637	10645	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10645	27	either	either	CC
18637	10645	28	limited	limited	JJ
18637	10645	29	,	,	,
18637	10645	30	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	10645	31	,	,	,
18637	10645	32	or	or	CC
18637	10645	33	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	10645	34	,	,	,
18637	10645	35	and	and	CC
18637	10645	36	of	of	IN
18637	10645	37	withholding	withhold	VBG
18637	10645	38	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10645	39	from	from	IN
18637	10645	40	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10645	41	in	in	IN
18637	10645	42	the	the	DT
18637	10645	43	exact	exact	JJ
18637	10645	44	degrees	degree	NNS
18637	10645	45	and	and	CC
18637	10645	46	character	character	NN
18637	10645	47	which	which	WDT
18637	10645	48	to	to	IN
18637	10645	49	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10645	50	may	may	MD
18637	10645	51	seem	seem	VB
18637	10645	52	proper	proper	JJ
18637	10645	53	for	for	IN
18637	10645	54	the	the	DT
18637	10645	55	public	public	JJ
18637	10645	56	good	good	NN
18637	10645	57	.	.	.
18637	10646	1	'	'	``
18637	10646	2	"	"	``
18637	10646	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10646	4	77	77	CD
18637	10646	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10646	6	Although	although	IN
18637	10646	7	the	the	DT
18637	10646	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10646	9	avoided	avoid	VBD
18637	10646	10	passing	pass	VBG
18637	10646	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	10646	12	the	the	DT
18637	10646	13	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	10646	14	of	of	IN
18637	10646	15	the	the	DT
18637	10646	16	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	10646	17	against	against	IN
18637	10646	18	interlocutory	interlocutory	JJ
18637	10646	19	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	10646	20	,	,	,
18637	10646	21	the	the	DT
18637	10646	22	language	language	NN
18637	10646	23	of	of	IN
18637	10646	24	the	the	DT
18637	10646	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10646	26	was	be	VBD
18637	10646	27	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	10646	28	broad	broad	JJ
18637	10646	29	enough	enough	RB
18637	10646	30	to	to	TO
18637	10646	31	support	support	VB
18637	10646	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10646	33	,	,	,
18637	10646	34	as	as	IN
18637	10646	35	was	be	VBD
18637	10646	36	the	the	DT
18637	10646	37	language	language	NN
18637	10646	38	of	of	IN
18637	10646	39	Yakus	Yakus	NNP
18637	10646	40	_	_	NNP
18637	10646	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	10646	42	_	_	NNP
18637	10646	43	United	United	NNP
18637	10646	44	States[78	States[78	NNP
18637	10646	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10646	46	which	which	WDT
18637	10646	47	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	10646	48	a	a	DT
18637	10646	49	different	different	JJ
18637	10646	50	phase	phase	NN
18637	10646	51	of	of	IN
18637	10646	52	the	the	DT
18637	10646	53	special	special	JJ
18637	10646	54	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	10646	55	for	for	IN
18637	10646	56	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	10646	57	under	under	IN
18637	10646	58	the	the	DT
18637	10646	59	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	10646	60	Price	Price	NNP
18637	10646	61	Control	Control	NNP
18637	10646	62	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10646	63	.	.	.
18637	10647	1	THE	the	DT
18637	10647	2	RULE	RULE	NNP
18637	10647	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	10647	4	MAKING	making	NN
18637	10647	5	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	10647	6	AND	and	CC
18637	10647	7	POWERS	power	NNS
18637	10647	8	OVER	over	IN
18637	10647	9	PROCESS	process	NN
18637	10647	10	Among	among	IN
18637	10647	11	the	the	DT
18637	10647	12	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	10647	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	10647	14	of	of	IN
18637	10647	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	10647	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	10647	17	that	that	DT
18637	10647	18	of	of	IN
18637	10647	19	making	make	VBG
18637	10647	20	all	all	DT
18637	10647	21	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10647	22	rules	rule	NNS
18637	10647	23	governing	govern	VBG
18637	10647	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10647	25	process	process	NN
18637	10647	26	and	and	CC
18637	10647	27	practice	practice	NN
18637	10647	28	and	and	CC
18637	10647	29	for	for	IN
18637	10647	30	the	the	DT
18637	10647	31	orderly	orderly	JJ
18637	10647	32	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	10647	33	of	of	IN
18637	10647	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10647	35	business	business	NN
18637	10647	36	.	.	.
18637	10648	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10648	2	79	79	CD
18637	10648	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10648	4	However	however	RB
18637	10648	5	,	,	,
18637	10648	6	this	this	DT
18637	10648	7	power	power	NN
18637	10648	8	too	too	RB
18637	10648	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	10648	10	derived	derive	VBN
18637	10648	11	from	from	IN
18637	10648	12	the	the	DT
18637	10648	13	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	10648	14	and	and	CC
18637	10648	15	can	can	MD
18637	10648	16	not	not	RB
18637	10648	17	go	go	VB
18637	10648	18	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	10648	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10648	20	.	.	.
18637	10649	1	The	the	DT
18637	10649	2	landmark	landmark	NN
18637	10649	3	case	case	NN
18637	10649	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	10649	5	Wayman	Wayman	NNP
18637	10649	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10649	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10649	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10649	9	Southard[80	Southard[80	NNP
18637	10649	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10649	11	which	which	WDT
18637	10649	12	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	10649	13	the	the	DT
18637	10649	14	validity	validity	NN
18637	10649	15	of	of	IN
18637	10649	16	the	the	DT
18637	10649	17	process	process	NN
18637	10649	18	acts	act	NNS
18637	10649	19	of	of	IN
18637	10649	20	1789	1789	CD
18637	10649	21	and	and	CC
18637	10649	22	1792	1792	CD
18637	10649	23	as	as	IN
18637	10649	24	a	a	DT
18637	10649	25	valid	valid	JJ
18637	10649	26	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10649	27	of	of	IN
18637	10649	28	authority	authority	NN
18637	10649	29	under	under	IN
18637	10649	30	the	the	DT
18637	10649	31	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10649	32	and	and	CC
18637	10649	33	proper	proper	JJ
18637	10649	34	clause	clause	NN
18637	10649	35	.	.	.
18637	10650	1	Although	although	IN
18637	10650	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10650	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10650	4	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	10650	5	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	10650	6	the	the	DT
18637	10650	7	rule	rule	NN
18637	10650	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	10650	9	making	make	VBG
18637	10650	10	power	power	NN
18637	10650	11	as	as	IN
18637	10650	12	essentially	essentially	RB
18637	10650	13	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10650	14	in	in	IN
18637	10650	15	nature	nature	NN
18637	10650	16	,	,	,
18637	10650	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10650	18	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	10650	19	that	that	IN
18637	10650	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10650	21	could	could	MD
18637	10650	22	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	10650	23	to	to	IN
18637	10650	24	the	the	DT
18637	10650	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	10650	26	the	the	DT
18637	10650	27	power	power	NN
18637	10650	28	to	to	TO
18637	10650	29	vary	vary	VB
18637	10650	30	minor	minor	JJ
18637	10650	31	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	10650	32	in	in	IN
18637	10650	33	the	the	DT
18637	10650	34	outlines	outline	NNS
18637	10650	35	marked	mark	VBN
18637	10650	36	out	out	RP
18637	10650	37	by	by	IN
18637	10650	38	the	the	DT
18637	10650	39	statute	statute	NN
18637	10650	40	.	.	.
18637	10651	1	Fifty	fifty	CD
18637	10651	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	10651	3	seven	seven	CD
18637	10651	4	years	year	NNS
18637	10651	5	later	later	RB
18637	10651	6	in	in	IN
18637	10651	7	Fink	Fink	NNP
18637	10651	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10651	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	10651	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10651	11	O'Neil,[81	o'neil,[81	NN
18637	10651	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10651	13	in	in	IN
18637	10651	14	which	which	WDT
18637	10651	15	the	the	DT
18637	10651	16	United	United	NNP
18637	10651	17	States	States	NNP
18637	10651	18	sought	seek	VBD
18637	10651	19	to	to	TO
18637	10651	20	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	10651	21	by	by	IN
18637	10651	22	summary	summary	NN
18637	10651	23	process	process	NN
18637	10651	24	the	the	DT
18637	10651	25	payment	payment	NN
18637	10651	26	of	of	IN
18637	10651	27	a	a	DT
18637	10651	28	debt	debt	NN
18637	10651	29	,	,	,
18637	10651	30	the	the	DT
18637	10651	31	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10651	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10651	33	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	10651	34	that	that	IN
18637	10651	35	under	under	IN
18637	10651	36	the	the	DT
18637	10651	37	process	process	NN
18637	10651	38	acts	act	VBZ
18637	10651	39	the	the	DT
18637	10651	40	law	law	NN
18637	10651	41	of	of	IN
18637	10651	42	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	10651	43	was	be	VBD
18637	10651	44	the	the	DT
18637	10651	45	law	law	NN
18637	10651	46	of	of	IN
18637	10651	47	the	the	DT
18637	10651	48	United	United	NNP
18637	10651	49	States	States	NNP
18637	10651	50	and	and	CC
18637	10651	51	hence	hence	RB
18637	10651	52	the	the	DT
18637	10651	53	Government	Government	NNP
18637	10651	54	was	be	VBD
18637	10651	55	required	require	VBN
18637	10651	56	to	to	TO
18637	10651	57	bring	bring	VB
18637	10651	58	a	a	DT
18637	10651	59	suit	suit	NN
18637	10651	60	,	,	,
18637	10651	61	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	10651	62	a	a	DT
18637	10651	63	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10651	64	,	,	,
18637	10651	65	and	and	CC
18637	10651	66	cause	cause	VB
18637	10651	67	execution	execution	NN
18637	10651	68	to	to	TO
18637	10651	69	issue	issue	VB
18637	10651	70	.	.	.
18637	10652	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10652	2	Matthews	Matthews	NNP
18637	10652	3	for	for	IN
18637	10652	4	a	a	DT
18637	10652	5	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	10652	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10652	7	declared	declare	VBD
18637	10652	8	that	that	IN
18637	10652	9	the	the	DT
18637	10652	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	10652	11	have	have	VBP
18637	10652	12	"	"	``
18637	10652	13	no	no	DT
18637	10652	14	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10652	15	authority	authority	NN
18637	10652	16	to	to	TO
18637	10652	17	take	take	VB
18637	10652	18	any	any	DT
18637	10652	19	one	one	CD
18637	10652	20	of	of	IN
18637	10652	21	these	these	DT
18637	10652	22	steps	step	NNS
18637	10652	23	,	,	,
18637	10652	24	except	except	IN
18637	10652	25	as	as	IN
18637	10652	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10652	27	may	may	MD
18637	10652	28	have	have	VB
18637	10652	29	been	be	VBN
18637	10652	30	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	10652	31	by	by	IN
18637	10652	32	the	the	DT
18637	10652	33	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10652	34	department	department	NN
18637	10652	35	;	;	:
18637	10652	36	for	for	IN
18637	10652	37	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10652	38	can	can	MD
18637	10652	39	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	10652	40	no	no	DT
18637	10652	41	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10652	42	,	,	,
18637	10652	43	except	except	IN
18637	10652	44	as	as	IN
18637	10652	45	the	the	DT
18637	10652	46	law	law	NN
18637	10652	47	confers	confer	VBZ
18637	10652	48	and	and	CC
18637	10652	49	limits	limit	VBZ
18637	10652	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10652	51	.	.	.
18637	10652	52	"	"	''
18637	10653	1	Limits	limit	NNS
18637	10653	2	to	to	IN
18637	10653	3	the	the	DT
18637	10653	4	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10653	5	The	the	DT
18637	10653	6	principal	principal	JJ
18637	10653	7	function	function	NN
18637	10653	8	of	of	IN
18637	10653	9	court	court	NN
18637	10653	10	rules	rule	NNS
18637	10653	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	10653	12	that	that	DT
18637	10653	13	of	of	IN
18637	10653	14	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	10653	15	the	the	DT
18637	10653	16	practice	practice	NN
18637	10653	17	of	of	IN
18637	10653	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	10653	19	as	as	IN
18637	10653	20	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	10653	21	forms	form	NNS
18637	10653	22	,	,	,
18637	10653	23	the	the	DT
18637	10653	24	operation	operation	NN
18637	10653	25	and	and	CC
18637	10653	26	effect	effect	NN
18637	10653	27	of	of	IN
18637	10653	28	process	process	NN
18637	10653	29	,	,	,
18637	10653	30	and	and	CC
18637	10653	31	the	the	DT
18637	10653	32	mode	mode	NN
18637	10653	33	and	and	CC
18637	10653	34	time	time	NN
18637	10653	35	of	of	IN
18637	10653	36	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10653	37	.	.	.
18637	10654	1	However	however	RB
18637	10654	2	,	,	,
18637	10654	3	rules	rule	NNS
18637	10654	4	are	be	VBP
18637	10654	5	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	10654	6	employed	employ	VBN
18637	10654	7	to	to	TO
18637	10654	8	state	state	NN
18637	10654	9	in	in	IN
18637	10654	10	convenient	convenient	JJ
18637	10654	11	form	form	NN
18637	10654	12	principles	principle	NNS
18637	10654	13	of	of	IN
18637	10654	14	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	10654	15	law	law	NN
18637	10654	16	previously	previously	RB
18637	10654	17	established	establish	VBN
18637	10654	18	by	by	IN
18637	10654	19	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	10654	20	or	or	CC
18637	10654	21	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	10654	22	.	.	.
18637	10655	1	But	but	CC
18637	10655	2	no	no	DT
18637	10655	3	such	such	JJ
18637	10655	4	rule	rule	NN
18637	10655	5	"	"	``
18637	10655	6	can	can	MD
18637	10655	7	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	10655	8	or	or	CC
18637	10655	9	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	10655	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10655	11	.	.	.
18637	10656	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	10656	2	can	can	MD
18637	10656	3	a	a	DT
18637	10656	4	rule	rule	NN
18637	10656	5	abrogate	abrogate	VB
18637	10656	6	or	or	CC
18637	10656	7	modify	modify	VB
18637	10656	8	the	the	DT
18637	10656	9	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	10656	10	law	law	NN
18637	10656	11	.	.	.
18637	10656	12	"	"	''
18637	10657	1	This	this	DT
18637	10657	2	rule	rule	NN
18637	10657	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	10657	4	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	10657	5	equally	equally	RB
18637	10657	6	to	to	IN
18637	10657	7	courts	court	NNS
18637	10657	8	of	of	IN
18637	10657	9	law	law	NN
18637	10657	10	,	,	,
18637	10657	11	equity	equity	NN
18637	10657	12	,	,	,
18637	10657	13	and	and	CC
18637	10657	14	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	10657	15	,	,	,
18637	10657	16	to	to	IN
18637	10657	17	rules	rule	NNS
18637	10657	18	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	10657	19	by	by	IN
18637	10657	20	the	the	DT
18637	10657	21	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10657	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10657	23	for	for	IN
18637	10657	24	the	the	DT
18637	10657	25	guidance	guidance	NN
18637	10657	26	of	of	IN
18637	10657	27	lower	low	JJR
18637	10657	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	10657	29	,	,	,
18637	10657	30	and	and	CC
18637	10657	31	to	to	IN
18637	10657	32	rules	rule	NNS
18637	10657	33	"	"	''
18637	10657	34	which	which	WDT
18637	10657	35	lower	low	JJR
18637	10657	36	courts	court	NNS
18637	10657	37	make	make	VBP
18637	10657	38	for	for	IN
18637	10657	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10657	40	own	own	JJ
18637	10657	41	guidance	guidance	NN
18637	10657	42	under	under	IN
18637	10657	43	authority	authority	NN
18637	10657	44	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	10657	45	.	.	.
18637	10658	1	"	"	``
18637	10658	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10658	3	82	82	CD
18637	10658	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10658	5	As	as	IN
18637	10658	6	incident	incident	NN
18637	10658	7	to	to	IN
18637	10658	8	the	the	DT
18637	10658	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10658	10	power	power	NN
18637	10658	11	,	,	,
18637	10658	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	10658	13	of	of	IN
18637	10658	14	the	the	DT
18637	10658	15	United	United	NNP
18637	10658	16	States	States	NNP
18637	10658	17	possess	possess	VBP
18637	10658	18	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10658	19	authority	authority	NN
18637	10658	20	to	to	TO
18637	10658	21	supervise	supervise	VB
18637	10658	22	the	the	DT
18637	10658	23	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	10658	24	of	of	IN
18637	10658	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10658	26	officers	officer	NNS
18637	10658	27	,	,	,
18637	10658	28	parties	party	NNS
18637	10658	29	,	,	,
18637	10658	30	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	10658	31	,	,	,
18637	10658	32	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	10658	33	,	,	,
18637	10658	34	and	and	CC
18637	10658	35	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	10658	36	by	by	IN
18637	10658	37	self	self	NN
18637	10658	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	10658	39	preserving	preserve	VBG
18637	10658	40	rules	rule	NNS
18637	10658	41	for	for	IN
18637	10658	42	the	the	DT
18637	10658	43	protection	protection	NN
18637	10658	44	of	of	IN
18637	10658	45	the	the	DT
18637	10658	46	rights	right	NNS
18637	10658	47	of	of	IN
18637	10658	48	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	10658	49	and	and	CC
18637	10658	50	the	the	DT
18637	10658	51	orderly	orderly	JJ
18637	10658	52	administration	administration	NN
18637	10658	53	of	of	IN
18637	10658	54	justice	justice	NN
18637	10658	55	.	.	.
18637	10659	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10659	2	83	83	CD
18637	10659	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10659	4	The	the	DT
18637	10659	5	courts	court	NNS
18637	10659	6	of	of	IN
18637	10659	7	the	the	DT
18637	10659	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10659	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10659	10	possess	possess	VBP
18637	10659	11	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10659	12	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	10659	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	10659	14	over	over	IN
18637	10659	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10659	16	process	process	NN
18637	10659	17	to	to	TO
18637	10659	18	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	10659	19	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	10659	20	,	,	,
18637	10659	21	oppression	oppression	NN
18637	10659	22	and	and	CC
18637	10659	23	injustice	injustice	NN
18637	10659	24	,	,	,
18637	10659	25	and	and	CC
18637	10659	26	to	to	TO
18637	10659	27	protect	protect	VB
18637	10659	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10659	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10659	30	and	and	CC
18637	10659	31	officers	officer	NNS
18637	10659	32	in	in	IN
18637	10659	33	the	the	DT
18637	10659	34	protection	protection	NN
18637	10659	35	of	of	IN
18637	10659	36	property	property	NN
18637	10659	37	in	in	IN
18637	10659	38	the	the	DT
18637	10659	39	custody	custody	NN
18637	10659	40	of	of	IN
18637	10659	41	law	law	NN
18637	10659	42	.	.	.
18637	10660	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10660	2	84	84	CD
18637	10660	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10660	4	Such	such	JJ
18637	10660	5	powers	power	NNS
18637	10660	6	are	be	VBP
18637	10660	7	said	say	VBN
18637	10660	8	to	to	TO
18637	10660	9	be	be	VB
18637	10660	10	essential	essential	JJ
18637	10660	11	to	to	IN
18637	10660	12	and	and	CC
18637	10660	13	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10660	14	in	in	IN
18637	10660	15	the	the	DT
18637	10660	16	organization	organization	NN
18637	10660	17	of	of	IN
18637	10660	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	10660	19	of	of	IN
18637	10660	20	justice	justice	NN
18637	10660	21	.	.	.
18637	10661	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10661	2	85	85	CD
18637	10661	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10661	4	The	the	DT
18637	10661	5	courts	court	NNS
18637	10661	6	of	of	IN
18637	10661	7	the	the	DT
18637	10661	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10661	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10661	10	also	also	RB
18637	10661	11	possess	possess	VBP
18637	10661	12	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10661	13	power	power	NN
18637	10661	14	to	to	TO
18637	10661	15	amend	amend	VB
18637	10661	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10661	17	records	record	NNS
18637	10661	18	,	,	,
18637	10661	19	correct	correct	VB
18637	10661	20	the	the	DT
18637	10661	21	errors	error	NNS
18637	10661	22	of	of	IN
18637	10661	23	the	the	DT
18637	10661	24	clerk	clerk	NN
18637	10661	25	or	or	CC
18637	10661	26	other	other	JJ
18637	10661	27	court	court	NN
18637	10661	28	officers	officer	NNS
18637	10661	29	,	,	,
18637	10661	30	and	and	CC
18637	10661	31	to	to	TO
18637	10661	32	rectify	rectify	VB
18637	10661	33	defects	defect	NNS
18637	10661	34	or	or	CC
18637	10661	35	omissions	omission	NNS
18637	10661	36	in	in	IN
18637	10661	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10661	38	records	record	NNS
18637	10661	39	even	even	RB
18637	10661	40	after	after	IN
18637	10661	41	the	the	DT
18637	10661	42	lapse	lapse	NN
18637	10661	43	of	of	IN
18637	10661	44	a	a	DT
18637	10661	45	term	term	NN
18637	10661	46	,	,	,
18637	10661	47	subject	subject	JJ
18637	10661	48	,	,	,
18637	10661	49	however	however	RB
18637	10661	50	,	,	,
18637	10661	51	to	to	IN
18637	10661	52	the	the	DT
18637	10661	53	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	10661	54	that	that	IN
18637	10661	55	the	the	DT
18637	10661	56	power	power	NN
18637	10661	57	to	to	TO
18637	10661	58	amend	amend	VB
18637	10661	59	records	record	NNS
18637	10661	60	conveys	convey	VBZ
18637	10661	61	no	no	DT
18637	10661	62	power	power	NN
18637	10661	63	to	to	TO
18637	10661	64	create	create	VB
18637	10661	65	a	a	DT
18637	10661	66	record	record	NN
18637	10661	67	or	or	CC
18637	10661	68	re	re	NN
18637	10661	69	-	-	VB
18637	10661	70	create	create	VB
18637	10661	71	one	one	CD
18637	10661	72	of	of	IN
18637	10661	73	which	which	WDT
18637	10661	74	no	no	DT
18637	10661	75	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	10661	76	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	10661	77	.	.	.
18637	10662	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10662	2	86	86	CD
18637	10662	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10662	4	APPOINTMENT	APPOINTMENT	NNP
18637	10662	5	OF	of	IN
18637	10662	6	REFEREES	REFEREES	NNP
18637	10662	7	,	,	,
18637	10662	8	MASTERS	MASTERS	NNP
18637	10662	9	,	,	,
18637	10662	10	AND	and	CC
18637	10662	11	SPECIAL	SPECIAL	NNP
18637	10662	12	AIDS	AIDS	NNP
18637	10662	13	The	the	DT
18637	10662	14	administration	administration	NN
18637	10662	15	of	of	IN
18637	10662	16	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
18637	10662	17	enterprises	enterprise	NNS
18637	10662	18	,	,	,
18637	10662	19	investigations	investigation	NNS
18637	10662	20	into	into	IN
18637	10662	21	the	the	DT
18637	10662	22	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	10662	23	of	of	IN
18637	10662	24	public	public	JJ
18637	10662	25	utility	utility	NN
18637	10662	26	rates	rate	NNS
18637	10662	27	,	,	,
18637	10662	28	and	and	CC
18637	10662	29	the	the	DT
18637	10662	30	performance	performance	NN
18637	10662	31	of	of	IN
18637	10662	32	other	other	JJ
18637	10662	33	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10662	34	functions	function	NNS
18637	10662	35	often	often	RB
18637	10662	36	require	require	VBP
18637	10662	37	the	the	DT
18637	10662	38	special	special	JJ
18637	10662	39	services	service	NNS
18637	10662	40	of	of	IN
18637	10662	41	masters	master	NNS
18637	10662	42	in	in	IN
18637	10662	43	chancery	chancery	NN
18637	10662	44	,	,	,
18637	10662	45	referees	referee	NNS
18637	10662	46	,	,	,
18637	10662	47	auditors	auditor	NNS
18637	10662	48	,	,	,
18637	10662	49	and	and	CC
18637	10662	50	other	other	JJ
18637	10662	51	special	special	JJ
18637	10662	52	aids	aid	NNS
18637	10662	53	.	.	.
18637	10663	1	The	the	DT
18637	10663	2	practice	practice	NN
18637	10663	3	of	of	IN
18637	10663	4	referring	refer	VBG
18637	10663	5	pending	pende	VBG
18637	10663	6	actions	action	NNS
18637	10663	7	to	to	IN
18637	10663	8	a	a	DT
18637	10663	9	referee	referee	NN
18637	10663	10	was	be	VBD
18637	10663	11	held	hold	VBN
18637	10663	12	in	in	IN
18637	10663	13	Heckers	Heckers	NNP
18637	10663	14	_	_	NNP
18637	10663	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	10663	16	_	_	NNP
18637	10663	17	Fowler[87	Fowler[87	NNP
18637	10663	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10663	19	to	to	TO
18637	10663	20	be	be	VB
18637	10663	21	coeval	coeval	NN
18637	10663	22	with	with	IN
18637	10663	23	the	the	DT
18637	10663	24	organization	organization	NN
18637	10663	25	of	of	IN
18637	10663	26	the	the	DT
18637	10663	27	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10663	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	10663	29	.	.	.
18637	10664	1	In	in	IN
18637	10664	2	the	the	DT
18637	10664	3	leading	leading	JJ
18637	10664	4	case	case	NN
18637	10664	5	of	of	IN
18637	10664	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	10664	7	parte	parte	NNP
18637	10664	8	Peterson[88	peterson[88	ADD
18637	10664	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10664	10	a	a	DT
18637	10664	11	United	United	NNP
18637	10664	12	States	States	NNP
18637	10664	13	district	district	NN
18637	10664	14	court	court	NN
18637	10664	15	appointed	appoint	VBD
18637	10664	16	an	an	DT
18637	10664	17	auditor	auditor	NN
18637	10664	18	with	with	IN
18637	10664	19	power	power	NN
18637	10664	20	to	to	TO
18637	10664	21	compel	compel	VB
18637	10664	22	the	the	DT
18637	10664	23	attendance	attendance	NN
18637	10664	24	of	of	IN
18637	10664	25	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	10664	26	and	and	CC
18637	10664	27	the	the	DT
18637	10664	28	production	production	NN
18637	10664	29	of	of	IN
18637	10664	30	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	10664	31	.	.	.
18637	10665	1	The	the	DT
18637	10665	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10665	3	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	10665	4	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10665	5	to	to	TO
18637	10665	6	conduct	conduct	VB
18637	10665	7	a	a	DT
18637	10665	8	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	10665	9	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	10665	10	of	of	IN
18637	10665	11	facts	fact	NNS
18637	10665	12	and	and	CC
18637	10665	13	file	file	VB
18637	10665	14	a	a	DT
18637	10665	15	report	report	NN
18637	10665	16	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	10665	17	for	for	IN
18637	10665	18	the	the	DT
18637	10665	19	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	10665	20	of	of	IN
18637	10665	21	simplifying	simplify	VBG
18637	10665	22	the	the	DT
18637	10665	23	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10665	24	for	for	IN
18637	10665	25	the	the	DT
18637	10665	26	jury	jury	NN
18637	10665	27	.	.	.
18637	10666	1	This	this	DT
18637	10666	2	action	action	NN
18637	10666	3	was	be	VBD
18637	10666	4	neither	neither	CC
18637	10666	5	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	10666	6	nor	nor	CC
18637	10666	7	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	10666	8	by	by	IN
18637	10666	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	10666	10	.	.	.
18637	10667	1	In	in	IN
18637	10667	2	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	10667	3	the	the	DT
18637	10667	4	action	action	NN
18637	10667	5	of	of	IN
18637	10667	6	the	the	DT
18637	10667	7	district	district	NN
18637	10667	8	judge	judge	NN
18637	10667	9	,	,	,
18637	10667	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10667	11	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	10667	12	,	,	,
18637	10667	13	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	10667	14	for	for	IN
18637	10667	15	the	the	DT
18637	10667	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10667	17	,	,	,
18637	10667	18	declared	declare	VBD
18637	10667	19	:	:	:
18637	10667	20	"	"	``
18637	10667	21	Courts	court	NNS
18637	10667	22	have	have	VBP
18637	10667	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10667	24	at	at	IN
18637	10667	25	least	least	JJS
18637	10667	26	in	in	IN
18637	10667	27	the	the	DT
18637	10667	28	absence	absence	NN
18637	10667	29	of	of	IN
18637	10667	30	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10667	31	to	to	IN
18637	10667	32	the	the	DT
18637	10667	33	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	10667	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10667	35	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10667	36	power	power	NN
18637	10667	37	to	to	TO
18637	10667	38	provide	provide	VB
18637	10667	39	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10667	40	with	with	IN
18637	10667	41	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	10667	42	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	10667	43	required	require	VBN
18637	10667	44	for	for	IN
18637	10667	45	the	the	DT
18637	10667	46	performance	performance	NN
18637	10667	47	of	of	IN
18637	10667	48	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10667	49	duties	duty	NNS
18637	10667	50	.	.	.
18637	10668	1	*	*	NFP
18637	10668	2	*	*	NFP
18637	10668	3	*	*	NFP
18637	10668	4	This	this	DT
18637	10668	5	power	power	NN
18637	10668	6	includes	include	VBZ
18637	10668	7	authority	authority	NN
18637	10668	8	to	to	TO
18637	10668	9	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	10668	10	persons	person	NNS
18637	10668	11	unconnected	unconnecte	VBN
18637	10668	12	with	with	IN
18637	10668	13	the	the	DT
18637	10668	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10668	15	to	to	TO
18637	10668	16	aid	aid	VB
18637	10668	17	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10668	18	in	in	IN
18637	10668	19	the	the	DT
18637	10668	20	performance	performance	NN
18637	10668	21	of	of	IN
18637	10668	22	specific	specific	JJ
18637	10668	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10668	24	duties	duty	NNS
18637	10668	25	,	,	,
18637	10668	26	as	as	IN
18637	10668	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10668	28	may	may	MD
18637	10668	29	arise	arise	VB
18637	10668	30	in	in	IN
18637	10668	31	the	the	DT
18637	10668	32	progress	progress	NN
18637	10668	33	of	of	IN
18637	10668	34	a	a	DT
18637	10668	35	cause	cause	NN
18637	10668	36	.	.	.
18637	10669	1	"	"	``
18637	10669	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10669	3	89	89	CD
18637	10669	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10669	5	The	the	DT
18637	10669	6	power	power	NN
18637	10669	7	to	to	TO
18637	10669	8	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	10669	9	auditors	auditor	NNS
18637	10669	10	by	by	IN
18637	10669	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10669	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	10669	13	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	10669	14	in	in	IN
18637	10669	15	equity	equity	NN
18637	10669	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	10669	17	been	be	VBN
18637	10669	18	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	10669	19	from	from	IN
18637	10669	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10669	21	very	very	JJ
18637	10669	22	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	10669	23	,	,	,
18637	10669	24	and	and	CC
18637	10669	25	here	here	RB
18637	10669	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10669	27	was	be	VBD
18637	10669	28	held	hold	VBN
18637	10669	29	that	that	IN
18637	10669	30	this	this	DT
18637	10669	31	power	power	NN
18637	10669	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	10669	33	the	the	DT
18637	10669	34	same	same	JJ
18637	10669	35	whether	whether	IN
18637	10669	36	the	the	DT
18637	10669	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10669	38	sits	sit	VBZ
18637	10669	39	in	in	IN
18637	10669	40	law	law	NN
18637	10669	41	or	or	CC
18637	10669	42	equity	equity	NN
18637	10669	43	.	.	.
18637	10670	1	THE	the	DT
18637	10670	2	POWER	power	NN
18637	10670	3	TO	to	IN
18637	10670	4	ADMIT	ADMIT	NNP
18637	10670	5	AND	and	CC
18637	10670	6	DISBAR	DISBAR	NNP
18637	10670	7	ATTORNEYS	ATTORNEYS	NNP
18637	10670	8	Subject	subject	JJ
18637	10670	9	to	to	IN
18637	10670	10	general	general	JJ
18637	10670	11	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	10670	12	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	10670	13	for	for	IN
18637	10670	14	attorneys	attorney	NNS
18637	10670	15	,	,	,
18637	10670	16	the	the	DT
18637	10670	17	power	power	NN
18637	10670	18	of	of	IN
18637	10670	19	the	the	DT
18637	10670	20	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10670	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	10670	22	to	to	TO
18637	10670	23	admit	admit	VB
18637	10670	24	and	and	CC
18637	10670	25	disbar	disbar	NN
18637	10670	26	attorneys	attorney	NNS
18637	10670	27	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	10670	28	on	on	IN
18637	10670	29	the	the	DT
18637	10670	30	common	common	JJ
18637	10670	31	law	law	NN
18637	10670	32	from	from	IN
18637	10670	33	which	which	WDT
18637	10670	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10670	35	was	be	VBD
18637	10670	36	originally	originally	RB
18637	10670	37	derived	derive	VBN
18637	10670	38	.	.	.
18637	10671	1	According	accord	VBG
18637	10671	2	to	to	IN
18637	10671	3	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10671	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10671	5	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	10671	6	,	,	,
18637	10671	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10671	8	was	be	VBD
18637	10671	9	well	well	RB
18637	10671	10	settled	settle	VBN
18637	10671	11	by	by	IN
18637	10671	12	the	the	DT
18637	10671	13	common	common	JJ
18637	10671	14	law	law	NN
18637	10671	15	that	that	IN
18637	10671	16	"	"	``
18637	10671	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10671	18	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	10671	19	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	10671	20	with	with	IN
18637	10671	21	the	the	DT
18637	10671	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10671	23	to	to	TO
18637	10671	24	determine	determine	VB
18637	10671	25	who	who	WP
18637	10671	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	10671	27	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	10671	28	to	to	TO
18637	10671	29	become	become	VB
18637	10671	30	one	one	CD
18637	10671	31	of	of	IN
18637	10671	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10671	33	officers	officer	NNS
18637	10671	34	,	,	,
18637	10671	35	as	as	IN
18637	10671	36	an	an	DT
18637	10671	37	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	10671	38	and	and	CC
18637	10671	39	counsellor	counsellor	NN
18637	10671	40	,	,	,
18637	10671	41	and	and	CC
18637	10671	42	for	for	IN
18637	10671	43	what	what	WP
18637	10671	44	cause	cause	IN
18637	10671	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10671	46	ought	ought	MD
18637	10671	47	to	to	TO
18637	10671	48	be	be	VB
18637	10671	49	removed	remove	VBN
18637	10671	50	.	.	.
18637	10671	51	"	"	''
18637	10672	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	10672	2	power	power	NN
18637	10672	3	,	,	,
18637	10672	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10672	5	made	make	VBD
18637	10672	6	clear	clear	JJ
18637	10672	7	,	,	,
18637	10672	8	however	however	RB
18637	10672	9	,	,	,
18637	10672	10	"	"	``
18637	10672	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	10672	12	not	not	RB
18637	10672	13	an	an	DT
18637	10672	14	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	10672	15	and	and	CC
18637	10672	16	despotic	despotic	JJ
18637	10672	17	one	one	NN
18637	10672	18	,	,	,
18637	10672	19	to	to	TO
18637	10672	20	be	be	VB
18637	10672	21	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	10672	22	at	at	IN
18637	10672	23	the	the	DT
18637	10672	24	pleasure	pleasure	NN
18637	10672	25	of	of	IN
18637	10672	26	the	the	DT
18637	10672	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10672	28	,	,	,
18637	10672	29	or	or	CC
18637	10672	30	from	from	IN
18637	10672	31	passion	passion	NN
18637	10672	32	,	,	,
18637	10672	33	prejudice	prejudice	NN
18637	10672	34	,	,	,
18637	10672	35	or	or	CC
18637	10672	36	personal	personal	JJ
18637	10672	37	hostility	hostility	NN
18637	10672	38	;	;	:
18637	10672	39	but	but	CC
18637	10672	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10672	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	10672	42	the	the	DT
18637	10672	43	duty	duty	NN
18637	10672	44	of	of	IN
18637	10672	45	the	the	DT
18637	10672	46	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10672	47	to	to	TO
18637	10672	48	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	10672	49	and	and	CC
18637	10672	50	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	10672	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10672	52	by	by	IN
18637	10672	53	a	a	DT
18637	10672	54	sound	sound	NN
18637	10672	55	and	and	CC
18637	10672	56	just	just	RB
18637	10672	57	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10672	58	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	10672	59	,	,	,
18637	10672	60	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	10672	61	the	the	DT
18637	10672	62	rights	right	NNS
18637	10672	63	and	and	CC
18637	10672	64	independence	independence	NN
18637	10672	65	of	of	IN
18637	10672	66	the	the	DT
18637	10672	67	bar	bar	NN
18637	10672	68	may	may	MD
18637	10672	69	be	be	VB
18637	10672	70	as	as	RB
18637	10672	71	scrupulously	scrupulously	RB
18637	10672	72	guarded	guard	VBN
18637	10672	73	and	and	CC
18637	10672	74	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	10672	75	by	by	IN
18637	10672	76	the	the	DT
18637	10672	77	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10672	78	,	,	,
18637	10672	79	as	as	IN
18637	10672	80	the	the	DT
18637	10672	81	right	right	NN
18637	10672	82	and	and	CC
18637	10672	83	dignity	dignity	NN
18637	10672	84	of	of	IN
18637	10672	85	the	the	DT
18637	10672	86	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10672	87	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10672	88	.	.	.
18637	10673	1	"	"	``
18637	10673	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10673	3	90	90	CD
18637	10673	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10673	5	The	the	DT
18637	10673	6	Test	Test	NNP
18637	10673	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	10673	8	Oath	Oath	NNP
18637	10673	9	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10673	10	of	of	IN
18637	10673	11	July	July	NNP
18637	10673	12	2	2	CD
18637	10673	13	,	,	,
18637	10673	14	1862	1862	CD
18637	10673	15	,	,	,
18637	10673	16	which	which	WDT
18637	10673	17	purported	purport	VBD
18637	10673	18	to	to	TO
18637	10673	19	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	10673	20	former	former	JJ
18637	10673	21	Confederates	Confederates	NNPS
18637	10673	22	from	from	IN
18637	10673	23	the	the	DT
18637	10673	24	practice	practice	NN
18637	10673	25	of	of	IN
18637	10673	26	law	law	NN
18637	10673	27	in	in	IN
18637	10673	28	the	the	DT
18637	10673	29	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10673	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	10673	31	,	,	,
18637	10673	32	was	be	VBD
18637	10673	33	invalidated	invalidate	VBN
18637	10673	34	in	in	IN
18637	10673	35	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	10673	36	parte	parte	NNP
18637	10673	37	Garland	Garland	NNP
18637	10673	38	.	.	.
18637	10674	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10674	2	91	91	CD
18637	10674	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10674	4	In	in	IN
18637	10674	5	the	the	DT
18637	10674	6	course	course	NN
18637	10674	7	of	of	IN
18637	10674	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10674	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10674	10	for	for	IN
18637	10674	11	the	the	DT
18637	10674	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10674	13	,	,	,
18637	10674	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10674	15	Field	Field	NNP
18637	10674	16	discussed	discuss	VBD
18637	10674	17	generally	generally	RB
18637	10674	18	the	the	DT
18637	10674	19	power	power	NN
18637	10674	20	to	to	TO
18637	10674	21	admit	admit	VB
18637	10674	22	and	and	CC
18637	10674	23	disbar	disbar	NN
18637	10674	24	attorneys	attorney	NNS
18637	10674	25	.	.	.
18637	10675	1	The	the	DT
18637	10675	2	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10675	3	of	of	IN
18637	10675	4	such	such	PDT
18637	10675	5	a	a	DT
18637	10675	6	power	power	NN
18637	10675	7	,	,	,
18637	10675	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10675	9	declared	declare	VBD
18637	10675	10	,	,	,
18637	10675	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	10675	12	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10675	13	power	power	NN
18637	10675	14	.	.	.
18637	10676	1	The	the	DT
18637	10676	2	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	10676	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	10676	4	an	an	DT
18637	10676	5	officer	officer	NN
18637	10676	6	of	of	IN
18637	10676	7	the	the	DT
18637	10676	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10676	9	and	and	CC
18637	10676	10	though	though	IN
18637	10676	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10676	12	may	may	MD
18637	10676	13	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	10676	14	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	10676	15	for	for	IN
18637	10676	16	the	the	DT
18637	10676	17	practice	practice	NN
18637	10676	18	of	of	IN
18637	10676	19	law	law	NN
18637	10676	20	in	in	IN
18637	10676	21	the	the	DT
18637	10676	22	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10676	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	10676	24	,	,	,
18637	10676	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10676	26	may	may	MD
18637	10676	27	not	not	RB
18637	10676	28	do	do	VB
18637	10676	29	so	so	RB
18637	10676	30	in	in	IN
18637	10676	31	such	such	PDT
18637	10676	32	a	a	DT
18637	10676	33	way	way	NN
18637	10676	34	as	as	IN
18637	10676	35	to	to	TO
18637	10676	36	inflict	inflict	VB
18637	10676	37	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	10676	38	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	10676	39	to	to	IN
18637	10676	40	the	the	DT
18637	10676	41	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10676	42	or	or	CC
18637	10676	43	to	to	TO
18637	10676	44	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	10676	45	a	a	DT
18637	10676	46	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	10676	47	of	of	IN
18637	10676	48	the	the	DT
18637	10676	49	President	President	NNP
18637	10676	50	of	of	IN
18637	10676	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10676	52	legal	legal	JJ
18637	10676	53	effect	effect	NN
18637	10676	54	.	.	.
18637	10677	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10677	2	92	92	CD
18637	10677	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10677	4	Organization	Organization	NNP
18637	10677	5	of	of	IN
18637	10677	6	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	10677	7	,	,	,
18637	10677	8	Tenure	Tenure	NNP
18637	10677	9	and	and	CC
18637	10677	10	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	10677	11	of	of	IN
18637	10677	12	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	10677	13	"	"	''
18637	10677	14	ONE	one	CD
18637	10677	15	SUPREME	SUPREME	NNP
18637	10677	16	COURT	court	NN
18637	10677	17	"	"	''
18637	10677	18	The	the	DT
18637	10677	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10677	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	10677	21	almost	almost	RB
18637	10677	22	completely	completely	RB
18637	10677	23	silent	silent	JJ
18637	10677	24	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	10677	25	the	the	DT
18637	10677	26	organization	organization	NN
18637	10677	27	of	of	IN
18637	10677	28	the	the	DT
18637	10677	29	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10677	30	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	10677	31	.	.	.
18637	10678	1	Although	although	IN
18637	10678	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10678	3	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	10678	4	for	for	IN
18637	10678	5	one	one	CD
18637	10678	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10678	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10678	8	,	,	,
18637	10678	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10678	10	makes	make	VBZ
18637	10678	11	no	no	DT
18637	10678	12	reference	reference	NN
18637	10678	13	to	to	IN
18637	10678	14	the	the	DT
18637	10678	15	size	size	NN
18637	10678	16	and	and	CC
18637	10678	17	composition	composition	NN
18637	10678	18	of	of	IN
18637	10678	19	the	the	DT
18637	10678	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10678	21	,	,	,
18637	10678	22	the	the	DT
18637	10678	23	time	time	NN
18637	10678	24	or	or	CC
18637	10678	25	place	place	NN
18637	10678	26	for	for	IN
18637	10678	27	sitting	sitting	NN
18637	10678	28	,	,	,
18637	10678	29	or	or	CC
18637	10678	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10678	31	internal	internal	JJ
18637	10678	32	organization	organization	NN
18637	10678	33	save	save	NN
18637	10678	34	for	for	IN
18637	10678	35	the	the	DT
18637	10678	36	reference	reference	NN
18637	10678	37	to	to	IN
18637	10678	38	the	the	DT
18637	10678	39	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10678	40	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10678	41	in	in	IN
18637	10678	42	the	the	DT
18637	10678	43	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	10678	44	provision	provision	NN
18637	10678	45	of	of	IN
18637	10678	46	article	article	NN
18637	10678	47	I	i	NN
18637	10678	48	,	,	,
18637	10678	49	§	§	NNP
18637	10678	50	3	3	CD
18637	10678	51	,	,	,
18637	10678	52	relating	relate	VBG
18637	10678	53	to	to	IN
18637	10678	54	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	10678	55	of	of	IN
18637	10678	56	the	the	DT
18637	10678	57	President	President	NNP
18637	10678	58	.	.	.
18637	10679	1	All	all	PDT
18637	10679	2	these	these	DT
18637	10679	3	matters	matter	NNS
18637	10679	4	are	be	VBP
18637	10679	5	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	10679	6	confided	confide	VBN
18637	10679	7	to	to	IN
18637	10679	8	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	10679	9	determination	determination	NN
18637	10679	10	.	.	.
18637	10680	1	Under	under	IN
18637	10680	2	the	the	DT
18637	10680	3	terms	term	NNS
18637	10680	4	of	of	IN
18637	10680	5	the	the	DT
18637	10680	6	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	10680	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10680	8	of	of	IN
18637	10680	9	1789	1789	CD
18637	10680	10	,	,	,
18637	10680	11	the	the	DT
18637	10680	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10680	13	consisted	consist	VBD
18637	10680	14	of	of	IN
18637	10680	15	a	a	DT
18637	10680	16	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10680	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10680	18	and	and	CC
18637	10680	19	five	five	CD
18637	10680	20	Associate	Associate	NNP
18637	10680	21	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	10680	22	.	.	.
18637	10681	1	This	this	DT
18637	10681	2	number	number	NN
18637	10681	3	was	be	VBD
18637	10681	4	gradually	gradually	RB
18637	10681	5	increased	increase	VBN
18637	10681	6	until	until	IN
18637	10681	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10681	8	reached	reach	VBD
18637	10681	9	a	a	DT
18637	10681	10	total	total	NN
18637	10681	11	of	of	IN
18637	10681	12	ten	ten	CD
18637	10681	13	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10681	14	under	under	IN
18637	10681	15	the	the	DT
18637	10681	16	act	act	NN
18637	10681	17	of	of	IN
18637	10681	18	March	March	NNP
18637	10681	19	3	3	CD
18637	10681	20	,	,	,
18637	10681	21	1863	1863	CD
18637	10681	22	.	.	.
18637	10682	1	Due	due	IN
18637	10682	2	to	to	IN
18637	10682	3	the	the	DT
18637	10682	4	exigencies	exigency	NNS
18637	10682	5	of	of	IN
18637	10682	6	Reconstruction	reconstruction	NN
18637	10682	7	and	and	CC
18637	10682	8	the	the	DT
18637	10682	9	tension	tension	NN
18637	10682	10	existing	exist	VBG
18637	10682	11	between	between	IN
18637	10682	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10682	13	and	and	CC
18637	10682	14	the	the	DT
18637	10682	15	President	President	NNP
18637	10682	16	the	the	DT
18637	10682	17	number	number	NN
18637	10682	18	was	be	VBD
18637	10682	19	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	10682	20	to	to	IN
18637	10682	21	seven	seven	CD
18637	10682	22	as	as	IN
18637	10682	23	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	10682	24	should	should	MD
18637	10682	25	occur	occur	VB
18637	10682	26	,	,	,
18637	10682	27	by	by	IN
18637	10682	28	the	the	DT
18637	10682	29	act	act	NN
18637	10682	30	of	of	IN
18637	10682	31	April	April	NNP
18637	10682	32	16	16	CD
18637	10682	33	,	,	,
18637	10682	34	1866	1866	CD
18637	10682	35	.	.	.
18637	10683	1	The	the	DT
18637	10683	2	number	number	NN
18637	10683	3	never	never	RB
18637	10683	4	actually	actually	RB
18637	10683	5	fell	fall	VBD
18637	10683	6	below	below	IN
18637	10683	7	eight	eight	CD
18637	10683	8	,	,	,
18637	10683	9	and	and	CC
18637	10683	10	on	on	IN
18637	10683	11	April	April	NNP
18637	10683	12	10	10	CD
18637	10683	13	,	,	,
18637	10683	14	1869	1869	CD
18637	10683	15	,	,	,
18637	10683	16	with	with	IN
18637	10683	17	Andrew	Andrew	NNP
18637	10683	18	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	10683	19	out	out	IN
18637	10683	20	of	of	IN
18637	10683	21	the	the	DT
18637	10683	22	White	White	NNP
18637	10683	23	House	House	NNP
18637	10683	24	,	,	,
18637	10683	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10683	26	restored	restore	VBD
18637	10683	27	the	the	DT
18637	10683	28	number	number	NN
18637	10683	29	to	to	IN
18637	10683	30	nine	nine	CD
18637	10683	31	,	,	,
18637	10683	32	where	where	WRB
18637	10683	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10683	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	10683	35	since	since	IN
18637	10683	36	remained	remain	VBN
18637	10683	37	.	.	.
18637	10684	1	There	there	EX
18637	10684	2	have	have	VBP
18637	10684	3	been	be	VBN
18637	10684	4	proposals	proposal	NNS
18637	10684	5	at	at	IN
18637	10684	6	various	various	JJ
18637	10684	7	times	time	NNS
18637	10684	8	for	for	IN
18637	10684	9	an	an	DT
18637	10684	10	organization	organization	NN
18637	10684	11	of	of	IN
18637	10684	12	the	the	DT
18637	10684	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10684	14	into	into	IN
18637	10684	15	sections	section	NNS
18637	10684	16	or	or	CC
18637	10684	17	divisions	division	NNS
18637	10684	18	.	.	.
18637	10685	1	No	no	DT
18637	10685	2	authoritative	authoritative	JJ
18637	10685	3	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10685	4	expression	expression	NN
18637	10685	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	10685	6	available	available	JJ
18637	10685	7	,	,	,
18637	10685	8	although	although	IN
18637	10685	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10685	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10685	11	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	10685	12	in	in	IN
18637	10685	13	a	a	DT
18637	10685	14	letter	letter	NN
18637	10685	15	to	to	IN
18637	10685	16	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	10685	17	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	10685	18	of	of	IN
18637	10685	19	March	March	NNP
18637	10685	20	21	21	CD
18637	10685	21	,	,	,
18637	10685	22	1937	1937	CD
18637	10685	23	,	,	,
18637	10685	24	expressed	express	VBD
18637	10685	25	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	10685	26	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	10685	27	the	the	DT
18637	10685	28	validity	validity	NN
18637	10685	29	of	of	IN
18637	10685	30	such	such	PDT
18637	10685	31	a	a	DT
18637	10685	32	device	device	NN
18637	10685	33	and	and	CC
18637	10685	34	stated	state	VBD
18637	10685	35	that	that	IN
18637	10685	36	"	"	``
18637	10685	37	the	the	DT
18637	10685	38	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10685	39	does	do	VBZ
18637	10685	40	not	not	RB
18637	10685	41	appear	appear	VB
18637	10685	42	to	to	TO
18637	10685	43	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	10685	44	two	two	CD
18637	10685	45	or	or	CC
18637	10685	46	more	more	JJR
18637	10685	47	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10685	48	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	10685	49	functioning	function	VBG
18637	10685	50	in	in	IN
18637	10685	51	effect	effect	NN
18637	10685	52	as	as	IN
18637	10685	53	separate	separate	JJ
18637	10685	54	courts	court	NNS
18637	10685	55	.	.	.
18637	10686	1	"	"	``
18637	10686	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10686	3	93	93	CD
18637	10686	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10686	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10686	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	10686	7	also	also	RB
18637	10686	8	determined	determine	VBN
18637	10686	9	the	the	DT
18637	10686	10	time	time	NN
18637	10686	11	and	and	CC
18637	10686	12	place	place	NN
18637	10686	13	of	of	IN
18637	10686	14	sessions	session	NNS
18637	10686	15	of	of	IN
18637	10686	16	the	the	DT
18637	10686	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10686	18	,	,	,
18637	10686	19	going	go	VBG
18637	10686	20	so	so	RB
18637	10686	21	far	far	RB
18637	10686	22	in	in	IN
18637	10686	23	1801	1801	CD
18637	10686	24	as	as	IN
18637	10686	25	to	to	TO
18637	10686	26	change	change	VB
18637	10686	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10686	28	terms	term	NNS
18637	10686	29	so	so	IN
18637	10686	30	that	that	IN
18637	10686	31	for	for	IN
18637	10686	32	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	10686	33	months	month	NNS
18637	10686	34	,	,	,
18637	10686	35	between	between	IN
18637	10686	36	December	December	NNP
18637	10686	37	,	,	,
18637	10686	38	1801	1801	CD
18637	10686	39	and	and	CC
18637	10686	40	February	February	NNP
18637	10686	41	,	,	,
18637	10686	42	1803	1803	CD
18637	10686	43	the	the	DT
18637	10686	44	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10686	45	did	do	VBD
18637	10686	46	not	not	RB
18637	10686	47	convene	convene	VB
18637	10686	48	.	.	.
18637	10687	1	INFERIOR	inferior	JJ
18637	10687	2	COURTS	court	NNS
18637	10687	3	MADE	make	VBD
18637	10687	4	AND	and	CC
18637	10687	5	ABOLISHED	ABOLISHED	NNS
18637	10687	6	By	by	IN
18637	10687	7	article	article	NN
18637	10687	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10687	9	,	,	,
18637	10687	10	§	§	NNP
18637	10687	11	8	8	CD
18637	10687	12	,	,	,
18637	10687	13	paragraph	paragraph	NN
18637	10687	14	9	9	CD
18637	10687	15	,	,	,
18637	10687	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10687	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	10687	18	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	10687	19	declared	declare	VBN
18637	10687	20	to	to	TO
18637	10687	21	have	have	VB
18637	10687	22	the	the	DT
18637	10687	23	power	power	NN
18637	10687	24	to	to	TO
18637	10687	25	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	10687	26	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	10687	27	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	10687	28	to	to	IN
18637	10687	29	the	the	DT
18637	10687	30	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10687	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10687	32	,	,	,
18637	10687	33	and	and	CC
18637	10687	34	the	the	DT
18637	10687	35	power	power	NN
18637	10687	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	10687	37	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	10687	38	in	in	IN
18637	10687	39	a	a	DT
18637	10687	40	different	different	JJ
18637	10687	41	formula	formula	NN
18637	10687	42	in	in	IN
18637	10687	43	article	article	NN
18637	10687	44	III	III	NNP
18637	10687	45	,	,	,
18637	10687	46	§	§	NNP
18637	10687	47	1	1	CD
18637	10687	48	,	,	,
18637	10687	49	when	when	WRB
18637	10687	50	provision	provision	NN
18637	10687	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	10687	52	also	also	RB
18637	10687	53	made	make	VBN
18637	10687	54	for	for	IN
18637	10687	55	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	10687	56	during	during	IN
18637	10687	57	good	good	JJ
18637	10687	58	behavior	behavior	NN
18637	10687	59	and	and	CC
18637	10687	60	for	for	IN
18637	10687	61	a	a	DT
18637	10687	62	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	10687	63	which	which	WDT
18637	10687	64	shall	shall	MD
18637	10687	65	not	not	RB
18637	10687	66	be	be	VB
18637	10687	67	diminished	diminish	VBN
18637	10687	68	.	.	.
18637	10688	1	Since	since	IN
18637	10688	2	1789	1789	CD
18637	10688	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10688	4	,	,	,
18637	10688	5	with	with	IN
18637	10688	6	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	10688	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10688	8	acquiescence	acquiescence	NN
18637	10688	9	and	and	CC
18637	10688	10	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	10688	11	,	,	,
18637	10688	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	10688	13	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	10688	14	both	both	DT
18637	10688	15	of	of	IN
18637	10688	16	these	these	DT
18637	10688	17	sections	section	NNS
18637	10688	18	as	as	IN
18637	10688	19	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	10688	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10688	21	free	free	JJ
18637	10688	22	to	to	TO
18637	10688	23	establish	establish	VB
18637	10688	24	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	10688	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	10688	26	or	or	CC
18637	10688	27	not	not	RB
18637	10688	28	,	,	,
18637	10688	29	as	as	IN
18637	10688	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10688	31	deems	deem	VBZ
18637	10688	32	fit	fit	JJ
18637	10688	33	in	in	IN
18637	10688	34	the	the	DT
18637	10688	35	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10688	36	of	of	IN
18637	10688	37	a	a	DT
18637	10688	38	boundless	boundless	JJ
18637	10688	39	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	10688	40	.	.	.
18637	10689	1	By	by	IN
18637	10689	2	the	the	DT
18637	10689	3	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	10689	4	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10689	5	of	of	IN
18637	10689	6	1789	1789	CD
18637	10689	7	,	,	,
18637	10689	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10689	9	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	10689	10	thirteen	thirteen	CD
18637	10689	11	district	district	NN
18637	10689	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	10689	13	which	which	WDT
18637	10689	14	were	be	VBD
18637	10689	15	to	to	TO
18637	10689	16	have	have	VB
18637	10689	17	four	four	CD
18637	10689	18	sessions	session	NNS
18637	10689	19	annually[94	annually[94	NNP
18637	10689	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10689	21	and	and	CC
18637	10689	22	three	three	CD
18637	10689	23	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	10689	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	10689	25	which	which	WDT
18637	10689	26	were	be	VBD
18637	10689	27	to	to	TO
18637	10689	28	consist	consist	VB
18637	10689	29	jointly	jointly	RB
18637	10689	30	of	of	IN
18637	10689	31	the	the	DT
18637	10689	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10689	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10689	34	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10689	35	and	and	CC
18637	10689	36	the	the	DT
18637	10689	37	district	district	NN
18637	10689	38	judge	judge	NN
18637	10689	39	of	of	IN
18637	10689	40	such	such	JJ
18637	10689	41	districts	district	NNS
18637	10689	42	which	which	WDT
18637	10689	43	were	be	VBD
18637	10689	44	to	to	TO
18637	10689	45	meet	meet	VB
18637	10689	46	annually	annually	RB
18637	10689	47	at	at	IN
18637	10689	48	the	the	DT
18637	10689	49	time	time	NN
18637	10689	50	and	and	CC
18637	10689	51	places	place	NNS
18637	10689	52	designated	designate	VBN
18637	10689	53	by	by	IN
18637	10689	54	the	the	DT
18637	10689	55	statute	statute	NN
18637	10689	56	.	.	.
18637	10690	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10690	2	95	95	CD
18637	10690	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10690	4	By	by	IN
18637	10690	5	the	the	DT
18637	10690	6	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	10690	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10690	8	of	of	IN
18637	10690	9	February	February	NNP
18637	10690	10	13	13	CD
18637	10690	11	,	,	,
18637	10690	12	1801	1801	CD
18637	10690	13	,	,	,
18637	10690	14	passed	pass	VBN
18637	10690	15	in	in	IN
18637	10690	16	the	the	DT
18637	10690	17	closing	close	VBG
18637	10690	18	weeks	week	NNS
18637	10690	19	of	of	IN
18637	10690	20	the	the	DT
18637	10690	21	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	10690	22	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	10690	23	,	,	,
18637	10690	24	the	the	DT
18637	10690	25	number	number	NN
18637	10690	26	of	of	IN
18637	10690	27	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10690	28	of	of	IN
18637	10690	29	the	the	DT
18637	10690	30	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10690	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10690	32	was	be	VBD
18637	10690	33	to	to	TO
18637	10690	34	be	be	VB
18637	10690	35	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	10690	36	to	to	IN
18637	10690	37	five	five	CD
18637	10690	38	after	after	IN
18637	10690	39	the	the	DT
18637	10690	40	next	next	JJ
18637	10690	41	vacancy	vacancy	NN
18637	10690	42	,	,	,
18637	10690	43	the	the	DT
18637	10690	44	districts	district	NNS
18637	10690	45	were	be	VBD
18637	10690	46	reorganized	reorganize	VBN
18637	10690	47	,	,	,
18637	10690	48	and	and	CC
18637	10690	49	six	six	CD
18637	10690	50	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	10690	51	courts	court	NNS
18637	10690	52	consisting	consist	VBG
18637	10690	53	of	of	IN
18637	10690	54	three	three	CD
18637	10690	55	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10690	56	each	each	DT
18637	10690	57	and	and	CC
18637	10690	58	organized	organize	VBN
18637	10690	59	independently	independently	RB
18637	10690	60	of	of	IN
18637	10690	61	the	the	DT
18637	10690	62	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10690	63	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10690	64	and	and	CC
18637	10690	65	the	the	DT
18637	10690	66	district	district	NN
18637	10690	67	courts	court	NNS
18637	10690	68	were	be	VBD
18637	10690	69	created	create	VBN
18637	10690	70	.	.	.
18637	10691	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10691	2	96	96	CD
18637	10691	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10691	4	Whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	10691	5	merits	merit	NNS
18637	10691	6	this	this	DT
18637	10691	7	plan	plan	NN
18637	10691	8	of	of	IN
18637	10691	9	organization	organization	NN
18637	10691	10	possessed	possess	VBN
18637	10691	11	were	be	VBD
18637	10691	12	lost	lose	VBN
18637	10691	13	in	in	IN
18637	10691	14	the	the	DT
18637	10691	15	fierce	fierce	JJ
18637	10691	16	partisanship	partisanship	NN
18637	10691	17	of	of	IN
18637	10691	18	the	the	DT
18637	10691	19	period	period	NN
18637	10691	20	,	,	,
18637	10691	21	which	which	WDT
18637	10691	22	led	lead	VBD
18637	10691	23	the	the	DT
18637	10691	24	expiring	expire	VBG
18637	10691	25	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	10691	26	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	10691	27	to	to	TO
18637	10691	28	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	10691	29	Federalists	federalist	NNS
18637	10691	30	almost	almost	RB
18637	10691	31	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	10691	32	to	to	IN
18637	10691	33	the	the	DT
18637	10691	34	new	new	JJ
18637	10691	35	judgeships	judgeship	NNS
18637	10691	36	to	to	IN
18637	10691	37	the	the	DT
18637	10691	38	dismay	dismay	NN
18637	10691	39	of	of	IN
18637	10691	40	the	the	DT
18637	10691	41	Jeffersonians	Jeffersonians	NNPS
18637	10691	42	who	who	WP
18637	10691	43	,	,	,
18637	10691	44	upon	upon	IN
18637	10691	45	coming	come	VBG
18637	10691	46	into	into	IN
18637	10691	47	power	power	NN
18637	10691	48	,	,	,
18637	10691	49	set	set	VBN
18637	10691	50	plans	plan	NNS
18637	10691	51	in	in	IN
18637	10691	52	motion	motion	NN
18637	10691	53	to	to	TO
18637	10691	54	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	10691	55	the	the	DT
18637	10691	56	act	act	NN
18637	10691	57	.	.	.
18637	10692	1	In	in	IN
18637	10692	2	a	a	DT
18637	10692	3	bitter	bitter	JJ
18637	10692	4	debate	debate	NN
18637	10692	5	the	the	DT
18637	10692	6	major	major	JJ
18637	10692	7	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10692	8	issue	issue	NN
18637	10692	9	to	to	TO
18637	10692	10	emerge	emerge	VB
18637	10692	11	centered	center	VBN
18637	10692	12	about	about	IN
18637	10692	13	the	the	DT
18637	10692	14	abolition	abolition	NN
18637	10692	15	of	of	IN
18637	10692	16	courts	court	NNS
18637	10692	17	once	once	IN
18637	10692	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10692	19	were	be	VBD
18637	10692	20	created	create	VBN
18637	10692	21	in	in	IN
18637	10692	22	the	the	DT
18637	10692	23	light	light	NN
18637	10692	24	of	of	IN
18637	10692	25	the	the	DT
18637	10692	26	provision	provision	NN
18637	10692	27	for	for	IN
18637	10692	28	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	10692	29	during	during	IN
18637	10692	30	good	good	JJ
18637	10692	31	behavior	behavior	NN
18637	10692	32	.	.	.
18637	10693	1	Suffice	suffice	VB
18637	10693	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10693	3	to	to	TO
18637	10693	4	say	say	VB
18637	10693	5	,	,	,
18637	10693	6	the	the	DT
18637	10693	7	repeal	repeal	JJ
18637	10693	8	bill	bill	NN
18637	10693	9	was	be	VBD
18637	10693	10	passed	pass	VBN
18637	10693	11	and	and	CC
18637	10693	12	approved	approve	VBN
18637	10693	13	by	by	IN
18637	10693	14	the	the	DT
18637	10693	15	President	President	NNP
18637	10693	16	on	on	IN
18637	10693	17	March	March	NNP
18637	10693	18	8	8	CD
18637	10693	19	,	,	,
18637	10693	20	1802[97	1802[97	LS
18637	10693	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10693	22	without	without	IN
18637	10693	23	any	any	DT
18637	10693	24	provision	provision	NN
18637	10693	25	for	for	IN
18637	10693	26	the	the	DT
18637	10693	27	displaced	displace	VBN
18637	10693	28	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10693	29	.	.	.
18637	10694	1	The	the	DT
18637	10694	2	validity	validity	NN
18637	10694	3	of	of	IN
18637	10694	4	the	the	DT
18637	10694	5	act	act	NN
18637	10694	6	of	of	IN
18637	10694	7	1802	1802	CD
18637	10694	8	was	be	VBD
18637	10694	9	questioned	question	VBN
18637	10694	10	in	in	IN
18637	10694	11	Stuart	Stuart	NNP
18637	10694	12	_	_	NNP
18637	10694	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	10694	14	_	_	NNP
18637	10694	15	Laird,[98	Laird,[98	NNP
18637	10694	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10694	17	where	where	WRB
18637	10694	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10694	19	Paterson	Paterson	NNP
18637	10694	20	in	in	IN
18637	10694	21	a	a	DT
18637	10694	22	terse	terse	JJ
18637	10694	23	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10694	24	,	,	,
18637	10694	25	which	which	WDT
18637	10694	26	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	10694	27	touched	touch	VBD
18637	10694	28	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	10694	29	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	10694	30	's	's	POS
18637	10694	31	argument	argument	NN
18637	10694	32	that	that	IN
18637	10694	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10694	34	lacked	lack	VBD
18637	10694	35	power	power	NN
18637	10694	36	to	to	TO
18637	10694	37	abolish	abolish	VB
18637	10694	38	or	or	CC
18637	10694	39	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	10694	40	courts	court	NNS
18637	10694	41	and	and	CC
18637	10694	42	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10694	43	,	,	,
18637	10694	44	held	hold	VBN
18637	10694	45	for	for	IN
18637	10694	46	the	the	DT
18637	10694	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10694	48	that	that	WDT
18637	10694	49	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10694	50	has	have	VBZ
18637	10694	51	the	the	DT
18637	10694	52	power	power	NN
18637	10694	53	to	to	TO
18637	10694	54	establish	establish	VB
18637	10694	55	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	10694	56	courts	court	NNS
18637	10694	57	from	from	IN
18637	10694	58	time	time	NN
18637	10694	59	to	to	IN
18637	10694	60	time	time	NN
18637	10694	61	as	as	IN
18637	10694	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10694	63	may	may	MD
18637	10694	64	think	think	VB
18637	10694	65	proper	proper	JJ
18637	10694	66	and	and	CC
18637	10694	67	to	to	TO
18637	10694	68	transfer	transfer	VB
18637	10694	69	a	a	DT
18637	10694	70	cause	cause	NN
18637	10694	71	from	from	IN
18637	10694	72	one	one	CD
18637	10694	73	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	10694	74	to	to	IN
18637	10694	75	another	another	DT
18637	10694	76	.	.	.
18637	10695	1	In	in	IN
18637	10695	2	answer	answer	NN
18637	10695	3	to	to	IN
18637	10695	4	the	the	DT
18637	10695	5	argument	argument	NN
18637	10695	6	that	that	IN
18637	10695	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10695	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10695	9	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	10695	10	could	could	MD
18637	10695	11	not	not	RB
18637	10695	12	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	10695	13	sit	sit	VB
18637	10695	14	as	as	IN
18637	10695	15	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	10695	16	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10695	17	,	,	,
18637	10695	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10695	19	pointed	point	VBD
18637	10695	20	to	to	TO
18637	10695	21	practice	practice	VB
18637	10695	22	and	and	CC
18637	10695	23	acquiescence	acquiescence	VB
18637	10695	24	contemporaneous	contemporaneous	JJ
18637	10695	25	with	with	IN
18637	10695	26	the	the	DT
18637	10695	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10695	28	as	as	IN
18637	10695	29	an	an	DT
18637	10695	30	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	10695	31	too	too	RB
18637	10695	32	strong	strong	JJ
18637	10695	33	and	and	CC
18637	10695	34	obstinate	obstinate	VBP
18637	10695	35	to	to	TO
18637	10695	36	be	be	VB
18637	10695	37	shaken	shake	VBN
18637	10695	38	or	or	CC
18637	10695	39	controlled	control	VBN
18637	10695	40	.	.	.
18637	10696	1	Abolition	abolition	NN
18637	10696	2	of	of	IN
18637	10696	3	the	the	DT
18637	10696	4	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10696	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10696	6	Since	since	IN
18637	10696	7	1802	1802	CD
18637	10696	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10696	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	10696	10	many	many	JJ
18637	10696	11	times	time	NNS
18637	10696	12	exercised	exercise	VBD
18637	10696	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10696	14	power	power	NN
18637	10696	15	to	to	TO
18637	10696	16	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	10696	17	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	10696	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	10696	19	,	,	,
18637	10696	20	but	but	CC
18637	10696	21	not	not	RB
18637	10696	22	until	until	IN
18637	10696	23	1913	1913	CD
18637	10696	24	did	do	VBD
18637	10696	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10696	26	again	again	RB
18637	10696	27	abolish	abolish	VB
18637	10696	28	a	a	DT
18637	10696	29	court	court	NN
18637	10696	30	.	.	.
18637	10697	1	This	this	DT
18637	10697	2	was	be	VBD
18637	10697	3	the	the	DT
18637	10697	4	unfortunately	unfortunately	RB
18637	10697	5	launched	launch	VBN
18637	10697	6	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10697	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10697	8	from	from	IN
18637	10697	9	which	which	WDT
18637	10697	10	so	so	RB
18637	10697	11	much	much	JJ
18637	10697	12	was	be	VBD
18637	10697	13	expected	expect	VBN
18637	10697	14	and	and	CC
18637	10697	15	so	so	RB
18637	10697	16	little	little	JJ
18637	10697	17	came	come	VBD
18637	10697	18	.	.	.
18637	10698	1	Again	again	RB
18637	10698	2	,	,	,
18637	10698	3	as	as	IN
18637	10698	4	in	in	IN
18637	10698	5	1802	1802	CD
18637	10698	6	,	,	,
18637	10698	7	there	there	EX
18637	10698	8	was	be	VBD
18637	10698	9	a	a	DT
18637	10698	10	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10698	11	debate	debate	NN
18637	10698	12	on	on	IN
18637	10698	13	the	the	DT
18637	10698	14	power	power	NN
18637	10698	15	of	of	IN
18637	10698	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10698	17	to	to	TO
18637	10698	18	abolish	abolish	VB
18637	10698	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	10698	20	without	without	IN
18637	10698	21	providing	provide	VBG
18637	10698	22	for	for	IN
18637	10698	23	the	the	DT
18637	10698	24	displaced	displace	VBN
18637	10698	25	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10698	26	,	,	,
18637	10698	27	but	but	CC
18637	10698	28	unlike	unlike	IN
18637	10698	29	the	the	DT
18637	10698	30	act	act	NN
18637	10698	31	of	of	IN
18637	10698	32	1802	1802	CD
18637	10698	33	the	the	DT
18637	10698	34	act	act	NN
18637	10698	35	of	of	IN
18637	10698	36	1913[99	1913[99	NNP
18637	10698	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10698	38	provided	provide	VBN
18637	10698	39	for	for	IN
18637	10698	40	the	the	DT
18637	10698	41	redistribution	redistribution	NN
18637	10698	42	of	of	IN
18637	10698	43	the	the	DT
18637	10698	44	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10698	45	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10698	46	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10698	47	among	among	IN
18637	10698	48	the	the	DT
18637	10698	49	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
18637	10698	50	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	10698	51	of	of	IN
18637	10698	52	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	10698	53	and	and	CC
18637	10698	54	the	the	DT
18637	10698	55	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	10698	56	of	of	IN
18637	10698	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10698	58	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10698	59	to	to	IN
18637	10698	60	the	the	DT
18637	10698	61	district	district	NN
18637	10698	62	courts	court	NNS
18637	10698	63	.	.	.
18637	10699	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10699	2	100	100	CD
18637	10699	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10699	4	COMPENSATION	COMPENSATION	VBN
18637	10699	5	The	the	DT
18637	10699	6	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	10699	7	against	against	IN
18637	10699	8	the	the	DT
18637	10699	9	diminution	diminution	NN
18637	10699	10	of	of	IN
18637	10699	11	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10699	12	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	10699	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	10699	14	presented	present	VBN
18637	10699	15	very	very	RB
18637	10699	16	little	little	JJ
18637	10699	17	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	10699	18	.	.	.
18637	10700	1	In	in	IN
18637	10700	2	1920	1920	CD
18637	10700	3	in	in	IN
18637	10700	4	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	10700	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10700	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10700	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10700	8	Gore[101	Gore[101	VBD
18637	10700	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10700	10	the	the	DT
18637	10700	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10700	12	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
18637	10700	13	the	the	DT
18637	10700	14	application	application	NN
18637	10700	15	of	of	IN
18637	10700	16	the	the	DT
18637	10700	17	Income	Income	NNP
18637	10700	18	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	10700	19	as	as	IN
18637	10700	20	applied	apply	VBN
18637	10700	21	to	to	IN
18637	10700	22	a	a	DT
18637	10700	23	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10700	24	judge	judge	NN
18637	10700	25	,	,	,
18637	10700	26	over	over	IN
18637	10700	27	the	the	DT
18637	10700	28	strong	strong	JJ
18637	10700	29	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	10700	30	of	of	IN
18637	10700	31	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10700	32	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	10700	33	,	,	,
18637	10700	34	who	who	WP
18637	10700	35	was	be	VBD
18637	10700	36	joined	join	VBN
18637	10700	37	by	by	IN
18637	10700	38	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10700	39	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	10700	40	.	.	.
18637	10701	1	This	this	DT
18637	10701	2	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	10701	3	was	be	VBD
18637	10701	4	extended	extend	VBN
18637	10701	5	in	in	IN
18637	10701	6	Miles	Miles	NNP
18637	10701	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10701	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	10701	9	_	_	NNP
18637	10701	10	Graham[102	Graham[102	NNP
18637	10701	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10701	12	to	to	TO
18637	10701	13	exempt	exempt	VB
18637	10701	14	the	the	DT
18637	10701	15	salary	salary	NN
18637	10701	16	of	of	IN
18637	10701	17	a	a	DT
18637	10701	18	judge	judge	NN
18637	10701	19	of	of	IN
18637	10701	20	the	the	DT
18637	10701	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10701	22	of	of	IN
18637	10701	23	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	10701	24	appointed	appoint	VBD
18637	10701	25	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	10701	26	to	to	IN
18637	10701	27	the	the	DT
18637	10701	28	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	10701	29	of	of	IN
18637	10701	30	the	the	DT
18637	10701	31	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	10701	32	act	act	NN
18637	10701	33	.	.	.
18637	10702	1	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	10702	2	_	_	NNP
18637	10702	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	10702	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10702	5	Gore	Gore	NNP
18637	10702	6	was	be	VBD
18637	10702	7	disapproved	disapprove	VBN
18637	10702	8	and	and	CC
18637	10702	9	Miles	Miles	NNP
18637	10702	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10702	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	10702	12	_	_	NNP
18637	10702	13	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	10702	14	in	in	IN
18637	10702	15	effect	effect	NN
18637	10702	16	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	10702	17	in	in	IN
18637	10702	18	O'Malley	O'Malley	NNP
18637	10702	19	,	,	,
18637	10702	20	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	10702	21	of	of	IN
18637	10702	22	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	10702	23	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	10702	24	_	_	NNP
18637	10702	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	10702	26	_	_	NNP
18637	10702	27	Woodrough,[103	Woodrough,[103	NNP
18637	10702	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10702	29	where	where	WRB
18637	10702	30	the	the	DT
18637	10702	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10702	32	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	10702	33	section	section	NN
18637	10702	34	22	22	CD
18637	10702	35	of	of	IN
18637	10702	36	the	the	DT
18637	10702	37	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	10702	38	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10702	39	of	of	IN
18637	10702	40	1932	1932	CD
18637	10702	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10702	42	now	now	RB
18637	10702	43	26	26	CD
18637	10702	44	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	10703	1	22	22	CD
18637	10703	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10703	3	a	a	DT
18637	10703	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10703	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10703	6	which	which	WDT
18637	10703	7	extended	extend	VBD
18637	10703	8	the	the	DT
18637	10703	9	application	application	NN
18637	10703	10	of	of	IN
18637	10703	11	the	the	DT
18637	10703	12	Income	Income	NNP
18637	10703	13	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	10703	14	to	to	IN
18637	10703	15	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	10703	16	of	of	IN
18637	10703	17	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10703	18	taking	take	VBG
18637	10703	19	office	office	NN
18637	10703	20	after	after	IN
18637	10703	21	June	June	NNP
18637	10703	22	6	6	CD
18637	10703	23	,	,	,
18637	10703	24	1932	1932	CD
18637	10703	25	.	.	.
18637	10704	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	10704	2	a	a	DT
18637	10704	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	10704	4	was	be	VBD
18637	10704	5	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	10704	6	neither	neither	CC
18637	10704	7	as	as	IN
18637	10704	8	an	an	DT
18637	10704	9	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	10704	10	diminution	diminution	NN
18637	10704	11	of	of	IN
18637	10704	12	the	the	DT
18637	10704	13	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	10704	14	of	of	IN
18637	10704	15	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10704	16	nor	nor	CC
18637	10704	17	as	as	IN
18637	10704	18	an	an	DT
18637	10704	19	encroachment	encroachment	NN
18637	10704	20	on	on	IN
18637	10704	21	the	the	DT
18637	10704	22	independence	independence	NN
18637	10704	23	of	of	IN
18637	10704	24	the	the	DT
18637	10704	25	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	10704	26	.	.	.
18637	10705	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10705	2	104	104	CD
18637	10705	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10705	4	To	to	TO
18637	10705	5	subject	subject	JJ
18637	10705	6	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10705	7	who	who	WP
18637	10705	8	take	take	VBP
18637	10705	9	office	office	NN
18637	10705	10	after	after	IN
18637	10705	11	a	a	DT
18637	10705	12	stipulated	stipulate	VBN
18637	10705	13	date	date	NN
18637	10705	14	to	to	IN
18637	10705	15	a	a	DT
18637	10705	16	nondiscriminatory	nondiscriminatory	JJ
18637	10705	17	tax	tax	NN
18637	10705	18	laid	lay	VBN
18637	10705	19	generally	generally	RB
18637	10705	20	on	on	IN
18637	10705	21	an	an	DT
18637	10705	22	income	income	NN
18637	10705	23	,	,	,
18637	10705	24	said	say	VBD
18637	10705	25	the	the	DT
18637	10705	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10705	27	,	,	,
18637	10705	28	"	"	''
18637	10705	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	10705	30	merely	merely	RB
18637	10705	31	to	to	TO
18637	10705	32	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	10705	33	that	that	IN
18637	10705	34	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10705	35	are	be	VBP
18637	10705	36	also	also	RB
18637	10705	37	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	10705	38	,	,	,
18637	10705	39	and	and	CC
18637	10705	40	that	that	IN
18637	10705	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10705	42	particular	particular	JJ
18637	10705	43	function	function	NN
18637	10705	44	in	in	IN
18637	10705	45	government	government	NN
18637	10705	46	does	do	VBZ
18637	10705	47	not	not	RB
18637	10705	48	generate	generate	VB
18637	10705	49	an	an	DT
18637	10705	50	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	10705	51	from	from	IN
18637	10705	52	sharing	share	VBG
18637	10705	53	with	with	IN
18637	10705	54	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10705	55	fellow	fellow	JJ
18637	10705	56	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	10705	57	the	the	DT
18637	10705	58	material	material	NN
18637	10705	59	burden	burden	NN
18637	10705	60	of	of	IN
18637	10705	61	the	the	DT
18637	10705	62	government	government	NN
18637	10705	63	whose	whose	WP$
18637	10705	64	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10705	65	and	and	CC
18637	10705	66	laws	law	NNS
18637	10705	67	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10705	68	are	be	VBP
18637	10705	69	charged	charge	VBN
18637	10705	70	with	with	IN
18637	10705	71	administering	administer	VBG
18637	10705	72	.	.	.
18637	10706	1	"	"	``
18637	10706	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10706	3	105	105	CD
18637	10706	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10706	5	Diminution	diminution	NN
18637	10706	6	of	of	IN
18637	10706	7	Salaries	Salaries	NNP
18637	10706	8	The	the	DT
18637	10706	9	Appropriations	Appropriations	NNPS
18637	10706	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10706	11	of	of	IN
18637	10706	12	1932	1932	CD
18637	10706	13	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	10706	14	"	"	''
18637	10706	15	the	the	DT
18637	10706	16	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	10706	17	and	and	CC
18637	10706	18	retired	retired	JJ
18637	10706	19	pay	pay	NN
18637	10706	20	of	of	IN
18637	10706	21	all	all	DT
18637	10706	22	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10706	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10706	24	except	except	IN
18637	10706	25	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10706	26	whose	whose	WP$
18637	10706	27	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	10706	28	may	may	MD
18637	10706	29	not	not	RB
18637	10706	30	,	,	,
18637	10706	31	under	under	IN
18637	10706	32	the	the	DT
18637	10706	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10706	34	,	,	,
18637	10706	35	be	be	VB
18637	10706	36	diminished	diminish	VBN
18637	10706	37	during	during	IN
18637	10706	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10706	39	continuance	continuance	NN
18637	10706	40	in	in	IN
18637	10706	41	office	office	NN
18637	10706	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10706	43	,	,	,
18637	10706	44	"	"	''
18637	10706	45	by	by	IN
18637	10706	46	8	8	CD
18637	10706	47	-	-	SYM
18637	10706	48	1/3	1/3	CD
18637	10706	49	per	per	NN
18637	10706	50	cent	cent	NN
18637	10706	51	if	if	IN
18637	10706	52	below	below	IN
18637	10706	53	$	$	$
18637	10706	54	10,000	10,000	CD
18637	10706	55	,	,	,
18637	10706	56	or	or	CC
18637	10706	57	to	to	IN
18637	10706	58	$	$	$
18637	10706	59	10,000	10,000	CD
18637	10706	60	if	if	IN
18637	10706	61	above	above	IN
18637	10706	62	that	that	DT
18637	10706	63	figure	figure	NN
18637	10706	64	.	.	.
18637	10707	1	While	while	IN
18637	10707	2	this	this	DT
18637	10707	3	provision	provision	NN
18637	10707	4	presented	present	VBD
18637	10707	5	no	no	DT
18637	10707	6	questions	question	NNS
18637	10707	7	of	of	IN
18637	10707	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10707	9	own	own	JJ
18637	10707	10	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	10707	11	,	,	,
18637	10707	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10707	13	did	do	VBD
18637	10707	14	raise	raise	VB
18637	10707	15	the	the	DT
18637	10707	16	question	question	NN
18637	10707	17	of	of	IN
18637	10707	18	what	what	WP
18637	10707	19	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10707	20	'	'	POS
18637	10707	21	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	10707	22	could	could	MD
18637	10707	23	be	be	VB
18637	10707	24	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	10707	25	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	10707	26	.	.	.
18637	10708	1	In	in	IN
18637	10708	2	O'Donoghue	O'Donoghue	NNP
18637	10708	3	_	_	NNP
18637	10708	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	10708	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10708	6	United	United	NNP
18637	10708	7	States[106	States[106	NNP
18637	10708	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10708	9	the	the	DT
18637	10708	10	section	section	NN
18637	10708	11	was	be	VBD
18637	10708	12	held	hold	VBN
18637	10708	13	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	10708	14	to	to	IN
18637	10708	15	the	the	DT
18637	10708	16	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	10708	17	of	of	IN
18637	10708	18	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10708	19	of	of	IN
18637	10708	20	the	the	DT
18637	10708	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	10708	22	of	of	IN
18637	10708	23	the	the	DT
18637	10708	24	District	District	NNP
18637	10708	25	of	of	IN
18637	10708	26	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	10708	27	on	on	IN
18637	10708	28	the	the	DT
18637	10708	29	ground	ground	NN
18637	10708	30	that	that	IN
18637	10708	31	as	as	IN
18637	10708	32	to	to	IN
18637	10708	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10708	34	organization	organization	NN
18637	10708	35	and	and	CC
18637	10708	36	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	10708	37	and	and	CC
18637	10708	38	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	10708	39	,	,	,
18637	10708	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10708	41	was	be	VBD
18637	10708	42	limited	limit	VBN
18637	10708	43	by	by	IN
18637	10708	44	the	the	DT
18637	10708	45	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	10708	46	of	of	IN
18637	10708	47	article	article	NN
18637	10708	48	III	iii	CD
18637	10708	49	.	.	.
18637	10709	1	In	in	IN
18637	10709	2	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	10709	3	_	_	NNP
18637	10709	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	10709	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10709	6	United	United	NNP
18637	10709	7	States,[107	States,[107	NNP
18637	10709	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10709	9	on	on	IN
18637	10709	10	the	the	DT
18637	10709	11	other	other	JJ
18637	10709	12	hand	hand	NN
18637	10709	13	,	,	,
18637	10709	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10709	15	was	be	VBD
18637	10709	16	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	10709	17	that	that	IN
18637	10709	18	the	the	DT
18637	10709	19	reduction	reduction	NN
18637	10709	20	was	be	VBD
18637	10709	21	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	10709	22	to	to	IN
18637	10709	23	the	the	DT
18637	10709	24	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	10709	25	of	of	IN
18637	10709	26	the	the	DT
18637	10709	27	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10709	28	of	of	IN
18637	10709	29	the	the	DT
18637	10709	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10709	31	of	of	IN
18637	10709	32	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	10709	33	,	,	,
18637	10709	34	that	that	IN
18637	10709	35	being	be	VBG
18637	10709	36	a	a	DT
18637	10709	37	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10709	38	court	court	NN
18637	10709	39	created	create	VBN
18637	10709	40	in	in	IN
18637	10709	41	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	10709	42	of	of	IN
18637	10709	43	the	the	DT
18637	10709	44	power	power	NN
18637	10709	45	of	of	IN
18637	10709	46	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10709	47	to	to	TO
18637	10709	48	pay	pay	VB
18637	10709	49	the	the	DT
18637	10709	50	debts	debt	NNS
18637	10709	51	of	of	IN
18637	10709	52	the	the	DT
18637	10709	53	United	United	NNP
18637	10709	54	States	States	NNP
18637	10709	55	and	and	CC
18637	10709	56	to	to	TO
18637	10709	57	consent	consent	VB
18637	10709	58	to	to	IN
18637	10709	59	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10709	60	against	against	IN
18637	10709	61	the	the	DT
18637	10709	62	United	United	NNP
18637	10709	63	States	States	NNP
18637	10709	64	.	.	.
18637	10710	1	As	as	IN
18637	10710	2	such	such	JJ
18637	10710	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10710	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	10710	5	not	not	RB
18637	10710	6	within	within	IN
18637	10710	7	the	the	DT
18637	10710	8	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	10710	9	of	of	IN
18637	10710	10	article	article	NN
18637	10710	11	III	iii	CD
18637	10710	12	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	10710	13	the	the	DT
18637	10710	14	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	10710	15	and	and	CC
18637	10710	16	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	10710	17	of	of	IN
18637	10710	18	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10710	19	.	.	.
18637	10711	1	COURTS	courts	NN
18637	10711	2	OF	of	IN
18637	10711	3	SPECIALIZED	SPECIALIZED	NNP
18637	10711	4	JURISDICTION	JURISDICTION	NNP
18637	10711	5	By	by	IN
18637	10711	6	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	10711	7	of	of	IN
18637	10711	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10711	9	power	power	NN
18637	10711	10	"	"	''
18637	10711	11	to	to	TO
18637	10711	12	ordain	ordain	VB
18637	10711	13	and	and	CC
18637	10711	14	establish	establish	VB
18637	10711	15	"	"	''
18637	10711	16	courts	court	NNS
18637	10711	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10711	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	10711	19	occasionally	occasionally	RB
18637	10711	20	created	create	VBN
18637	10711	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	10711	22	under	under	IN
18637	10711	23	article	article	NN
18637	10711	24	III	iii	CD
18637	10711	25	to	to	TO
18637	10711	26	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	10711	27	a	a	DT
18637	10711	28	specialized	specialized	JJ
18637	10711	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10711	30	.	.	.
18637	10712	1	Otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	10712	2	these	these	DT
18637	10712	3	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	10712	4	are	be	VBP
18637	10712	5	like	like	IN
18637	10712	6	other	other	JJ
18637	10712	7	article	article	NN
18637	10712	8	III	iii	CD
18637	10712	9	courts	court	NNS
18637	10712	10	in	in	IN
18637	10712	11	that	that	DT
18637	10712	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10712	13	exercise	exercise	VBP
18637	10712	14	"	"	''
18637	10712	15	the	the	DT
18637	10712	16	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10712	17	power	power	NN
18637	10712	18	of	of	IN
18637	10712	19	the	the	DT
18637	10712	20	United	United	NNP
18637	10712	21	States	States	NNP
18637	10712	22	,	,	,
18637	10712	23	"	"	''
18637	10712	24	and	and	CC
18637	10712	25	only	only	RB
18637	10712	26	that	that	DT
18637	10712	27	power	power	NN
18637	10712	28	,	,	,
18637	10712	29	that	that	IN
18637	10712	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10712	31	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10712	32	must	must	MD
18637	10712	33	be	be	VB
18637	10712	34	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	10712	35	by	by	IN
18637	10712	36	the	the	DT
18637	10712	37	President	President	NNP
18637	10712	38	and	and	CC
18637	10712	39	the	the	DT
18637	10712	40	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	10712	41	and	and	CC
18637	10712	42	must	must	MD
18637	10712	43	hold	hold	VB
18637	10712	44	office	office	NN
18637	10712	45	during	during	IN
18637	10712	46	good	good	JJ
18637	10712	47	behavior	behavior	NN
18637	10712	48	subject	subject	JJ
18637	10712	49	to	to	IN
18637	10712	50	removal	removal	NN
18637	10712	51	by	by	IN
18637	10712	52	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	10712	53	only	only	RB
18637	10712	54	,	,	,
18637	10712	55	and	and	CC
18637	10712	56	that	that	IN
18637	10712	57	the	the	DT
18637	10712	58	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	10712	59	of	of	IN
18637	10712	60	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10712	61	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10712	62	can	can	MD
18637	10712	63	not	not	RB
18637	10712	64	be	be	VB
18637	10712	65	diminished	diminish	VBN
18637	10712	66	during	during	IN
18637	10712	67	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10712	68	continuance	continuance	NN
18637	10712	69	in	in	IN
18637	10712	70	office	office	NN
18637	10712	71	.	.	.
18637	10713	1	One	one	CD
18637	10713	2	example	example	NN
18637	10713	3	of	of	IN
18637	10713	4	such	such	JJ
18637	10713	5	courts	court	NNS
18637	10713	6	was	be	VBD
18637	10713	7	the	the	DT
18637	10713	8	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10713	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10713	10	created	create	VBN
18637	10713	11	by	by	IN
18637	10713	12	the	the	DT
18637	10713	13	Mann	Mann	NNP
18637	10713	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	10713	15	Elkins	Elkins	NNP
18637	10713	16	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10713	17	of	of	IN
18637	10713	18	1910,[108	1910,[108	NNP
18637	10713	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10713	20	which	which	WDT
18637	10713	21	was	be	VBD
18637	10713	22	given	give	VBN
18637	10713	23	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	10713	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10713	25	of	of	IN
18637	10713	26	all	all	DT
18637	10713	27	cases	case	NNS
18637	10713	28	to	to	TO
18637	10713	29	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	10713	30	orders	order	NNS
18637	10713	31	of	of	IN
18637	10713	32	the	the	DT
18637	10713	33	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	10713	34	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10713	35	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	10713	36	except	except	IN
18637	10713	37	those	those	DT
18637	10713	38	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10713	39	money	money	NN
18637	10713	40	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	10713	41	and	and	CC
18637	10713	42	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10713	43	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	10713	44	;	;	,
18637	10713	45	of	of	IN
18637	10713	46	cases	case	NNS
18637	10713	47	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10713	48	to	to	TO
18637	10713	49	enjoin	enjoin	NN
18637	10713	50	,	,	,
18637	10713	51	annul	annul	NNP
18637	10713	52	,	,	,
18637	10713	53	or	or	CC
18637	10713	54	set	set	VBD
18637	10713	55	aside	aside	RP
18637	10713	56	orders	order	NNS
18637	10713	57	of	of	IN
18637	10713	58	the	the	DT
18637	10713	59	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	10713	60	;	;	:
18637	10713	61	of	of	IN
18637	10713	62	cases	case	NNS
18637	10713	63	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10713	64	under	under	IN
18637	10713	65	the	the	DT
18637	10713	66	act	act	NN
18637	10713	67	of	of	IN
18637	10713	68	1903	1903	CD
18637	10713	69	to	to	TO
18637	10713	70	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	10713	71	unjust	unjust	JJ
18637	10713	72	discriminations	discrimination	NNS
18637	10713	73	;	;	:
18637	10713	74	and	and	CC
18637	10713	75	of	of	IN
18637	10713	76	all	all	DT
18637	10713	77	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	10713	78	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10713	79	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	10713	80	by	by	IN
18637	10713	81	the	the	DT
18637	10713	82	act	act	NN
18637	10713	83	of	of	IN
18637	10713	84	1903	1903	CD
18637	10713	85	.	.	.
18637	10714	1	This	this	DT
18637	10714	2	court	court	NN
18637	10714	3	actually	actually	RB
18637	10714	4	functioned	function	VBD
18637	10714	5	for	for	IN
18637	10714	6	less	less	JJR
18637	10714	7	than	than	IN
18637	10714	8	three	three	CD
18637	10714	9	years	year	NNS
18637	10714	10	,	,	,
18637	10714	11	being	be	VBG
18637	10714	12	abolished	abolish	VBN
18637	10714	13	in	in	IN
18637	10714	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	10714	15	,	,	,
18637	10714	16	as	as	IN
18637	10714	17	was	be	VBD
18637	10714	18	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	10714	19	above	above	RB
18637	10714	20	.	.	.
18637	10715	1	The	the	DT
18637	10715	2	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	10715	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10715	4	of	of	IN
18637	10715	5	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	10715	6	of	of	IN
18637	10715	7	1942	1942	CD
18637	10715	8	Another	another	DT
18637	10715	9	court	court	NN
18637	10715	10	of	of	IN
18637	10715	11	specialized	specialized	JJ
18637	10715	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10715	13	but	but	CC
18637	10715	14	created	create	VBD
18637	10715	15	for	for	IN
18637	10715	16	a	a	DT
18637	10715	17	limited	limited	JJ
18637	10715	18	time	time	NN
18637	10715	19	only	only	RB
18637	10715	20	was	be	VBD
18637	10715	21	the	the	DT
18637	10715	22	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	10715	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10715	24	of	of	IN
18637	10715	25	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	10715	26	organized	organize	VBN
18637	10715	27	by	by	IN
18637	10715	28	the	the	DT
18637	10715	29	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	10715	30	Price	Price	NNP
18637	10715	31	Control	Control	NNP
18637	10715	32	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10715	33	of	of	IN
18637	10715	34	January	January	NNP
18637	10715	35	30	30	CD
18637	10715	36	,	,	,
18637	10715	37	1942	1942	CD
18637	10715	38	.	.	.
18637	10716	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10716	2	109	109	CD
18637	10716	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10716	4	By	by	IN
18637	10716	5	the	the	DT
18637	10716	6	terms	term	NNS
18637	10716	7	of	of	IN
18637	10716	8	the	the	DT
18637	10716	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	10716	10	this	this	DT
18637	10716	11	court	court	NN
18637	10716	12	consisted	consist	VBD
18637	10716	13	of	of	IN
18637	10716	14	three	three	CD
18637	10716	15	or	or	CC
18637	10716	16	more	more	JJR
18637	10716	17	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10716	18	designated	designate	VBN
18637	10716	19	by	by	IN
18637	10716	20	the	the	DT
18637	10716	21	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10716	22	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10716	23	from	from	IN
18637	10716	24	the	the	DT
18637	10716	25	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10716	26	of	of	IN
18637	10716	27	the	the	DT
18637	10716	28	United	United	NNP
18637	10716	29	States	States	NNP
18637	10716	30	district	district	NN
18637	10716	31	courts	court	NNS
18637	10716	32	and	and	CC
18637	10716	33	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	10716	34	courts	court	NNS
18637	10716	35	of	of	IN
18637	10716	36	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	10716	37	.	.	.
18637	10717	1	The	the	DT
18637	10717	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10717	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10717	4	was	be	VBD
18637	10717	5	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	10717	6	to	to	TO
18637	10717	7	designate	designate	VB
18637	10717	8	one	one	CD
18637	10717	9	of	of	IN
18637	10717	10	the	the	DT
18637	10717	11	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10717	12	as	as	IN
18637	10717	13	chief	chief	JJ
18637	10717	14	judge	judge	NN
18637	10717	15	,	,	,
18637	10717	16	to	to	TO
18637	10717	17	designate	designate	VB
18637	10717	18	additional	additional	JJ
18637	10717	19	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10717	20	from	from	IN
18637	10717	21	time	time	NN
18637	10717	22	to	to	IN
18637	10717	23	time	time	NN
18637	10717	24	,	,	,
18637	10717	25	and	and	CC
18637	10717	26	to	to	TO
18637	10717	27	revoke	revoke	VB
18637	10717	28	designations	designation	NNS
18637	10717	29	.	.	.
18637	10718	1	The	the	DT
18637	10718	2	chief	chief	JJ
18637	10718	3	judge	judge	NN
18637	10718	4	in	in	IN
18637	10718	5	turn	turn	NN
18637	10718	6	was	be	VBD
18637	10718	7	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	10718	8	to	to	TO
18637	10718	9	divide	divide	VB
18637	10718	10	the	the	DT
18637	10718	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10718	12	into	into	IN
18637	10718	13	divisions	division	NNS
18637	10718	14	of	of	IN
18637	10718	15	three	three	CD
18637	10718	16	or	or	CC
18637	10718	17	more	more	JJR
18637	10718	18	members	member	NNS
18637	10718	19	each	each	DT
18637	10718	20	,	,	,
18637	10718	21	with	with	IN
18637	10718	22	any	any	DT
18637	10718	23	such	such	JJ
18637	10718	24	division	division	NN
18637	10718	25	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	10718	26	to	to	TO
18637	10718	27	render	render	VB
18637	10718	28	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10718	29	as	as	IN
18637	10718	30	the	the	DT
18637	10718	31	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10718	32	of	of	IN
18637	10718	33	the	the	DT
18637	10718	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10718	35	.	.	.
18637	10719	1	The	the	DT
18637	10719	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10719	3	was	be	VBD
18637	10719	4	vested	vest	VBN
18637	10719	5	with	with	IN
18637	10719	6	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10719	7	and	and	CC
18637	10719	8	powers	power	NNS
18637	10719	9	of	of	IN
18637	10719	10	a	a	DT
18637	10719	11	district	district	NN
18637	10719	12	court	court	NN
18637	10719	13	to	to	TO
18637	10719	14	hear	hear	VB
18637	10719	15	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	10719	16	filed	file	VBD
18637	10719	17	within	within	IN
18637	10719	18	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	10719	19	days	day	NNS
18637	10719	20	against	against	IN
18637	10719	21	denials	denial	NNS
18637	10719	22	of	of	IN
18637	10719	23	protests	protest	NNS
18637	10719	24	by	by	IN
18637	10719	25	the	the	DT
18637	10719	26	Price	Price	NNP
18637	10719	27	Administrator	Administrator	NNP
18637	10719	28	and	and	CC
18637	10719	29	with	with	IN
18637	10719	30	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	10719	31	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10719	32	to	to	TO
18637	10719	33	set	set	VB
18637	10719	34	aside	aside	RP
18637	10719	35	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	10719	36	,	,	,
18637	10719	37	orders	order	NNS
18637	10719	38	,	,	,
18637	10719	39	or	or	CC
18637	10719	40	price	price	NN
18637	10719	41	schedules	schedule	NNS
18637	10719	42	,	,	,
18637	10719	43	in	in	IN
18637	10719	44	whole	whole	NN
18637	10719	45	or	or	CC
18637	10719	46	in	in	IN
18637	10719	47	part	part	NN
18637	10719	48	,	,	,
18637	10719	49	or	or	CC
18637	10719	50	to	to	TO
18637	10719	51	remand	remand	VB
18637	10719	52	the	the	DT
18637	10719	53	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	10719	54	.	.	.
18637	10720	1	But	but	CC
18637	10720	2	no	no	DT
18637	10720	3	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	10720	4	or	or	CC
18637	10720	5	price	price	NN
18637	10720	6	schedule	schedule	NN
18637	10720	7	could	could	MD
18637	10720	8	be	be	VB
18637	10720	9	set	set	VBN
18637	10720	10	aside	aside	RB
18637	10720	11	or	or	CC
18637	10720	12	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	10720	13	unless	unless	IN
18637	10720	14	the	the	DT
18637	10720	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10720	16	was	be	VBD
18637	10720	17	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	10720	18	that	that	IN
18637	10720	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10720	20	was	be	VBD
18637	10720	21	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	10720	22	to	to	IN
18637	10720	23	law	law	NN
18637	10720	24	or	or	CC
18637	10720	25	was	be	VBD
18637	10720	26	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	10720	27	or	or	CC
18637	10720	28	capricious	capricious	JJ
18637	10720	29	.	.	.
18637	10721	1	Even	even	RB
18637	10721	2	then	then	RB
18637	10721	3	the	the	DT
18637	10721	4	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
18637	10721	5	of	of	IN
18637	10721	6	a	a	DT
18637	10721	7	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	10721	8	order	order	NN
18637	10721	9	was	be	VBD
18637	10721	10	to	to	TO
18637	10721	11	be	be	VB
18637	10721	12	suspended	suspend	VBN
18637	10721	13	for	for	IN
18637	10721	14	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	10721	15	days	day	NNS
18637	10721	16	and	and	CC
18637	10721	17	,	,	,
18637	10721	18	if	if	IN
18637	10721	19	appealed	appeal	VBD
18637	10721	20	to	to	IN
18637	10721	21	the	the	DT
18637	10721	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10721	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10721	24	within	within	IN
18637	10721	25	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	10721	26	days	day	NNS
18637	10721	27	,	,	,
18637	10721	28	until	until	IN
18637	10721	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10721	30	final	final	JJ
18637	10721	31	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	10721	32	.	.	.
18637	10722	1	Although	although	IN
18637	10722	2	the	the	DT
18637	10722	3	act	act	NN
18637	10722	4	deprived	deprive	VBD
18637	10722	5	the	the	DT
18637	10722	6	district	district	NN
18637	10722	7	courts	court	NNS
18637	10722	8	of	of	IN
18637	10722	9	the	the	DT
18637	10722	10	power	power	NN
18637	10722	11	to	to	TO
18637	10722	12	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	10722	13	the	the	DT
18637	10722	14	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10722	15	of	of	IN
18637	10722	16	orders	order	NNS
18637	10722	17	and	and	CC
18637	10722	18	price	price	NN
18637	10722	19	schedules	schedule	NNS
18637	10722	20	,	,	,
18637	10722	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10722	22	vested	vest	VBD
18637	10722	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10722	24	with	with	IN
18637	10722	25	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10722	26	to	to	TO
18637	10722	27	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	10722	28	the	the	DT
18637	10722	29	act	act	NN
18637	10722	30	and	and	CC
18637	10722	31	orders	order	NNS
18637	10722	32	issued	issue	VBD
18637	10722	33	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	10722	34	in	in	IN
18637	10722	35	actions	action	NNS
18637	10722	36	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10722	37	by	by	IN
18637	10722	38	the	the	DT
18637	10722	39	Administrator	administrator	NN
18637	10722	40	to	to	TO
18637	10722	41	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	10722	42	violations	violation	NNS
18637	10722	43	and	and	CC
18637	10722	44	to	to	TO
18637	10722	45	try	try	VB
18637	10722	46	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10722	47	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	10722	48	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10722	49	by	by	IN
18637	10722	50	the	the	DT
18637	10722	51	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	10722	52	General	General	NNP
18637	10722	53	.	.	.
18637	10723	1	Since	since	IN
18637	10723	2	the	the	DT
18637	10723	3	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	10723	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10723	5	of	of	IN
18637	10723	6	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	10723	7	,	,	,
18637	10723	8	subject	subject	JJ
18637	10723	9	to	to	IN
18637	10723	10	review	review	NN
18637	10723	11	by	by	IN
18637	10723	12	the	the	DT
18637	10723	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10723	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10723	15	,	,	,
18637	10723	16	was	be	VBD
18637	10723	17	given	give	VBN
18637	10723	18	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	10723	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10723	20	to	to	TO
18637	10723	21	determine	determine	VB
18637	10723	22	the	the	DT
18637	10723	23	validity	validity	NN
18637	10723	24	of	of	IN
18637	10723	25	any	any	DT
18637	10723	26	order	order	NN
18637	10723	27	issued	issue	VBN
18637	10723	28	under	under	IN
18637	10723	29	the	the	DT
18637	10723	30	act	act	NN
18637	10723	31	,	,	,
18637	10723	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10723	33	resulted	result	VBD
18637	10723	34	that	that	IN
18637	10723	35	the	the	DT
18637	10723	36	district	district	NN
18637	10723	37	courts	court	NNS
18637	10723	38	were	be	VBD
18637	10723	39	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	10723	40	of	of	IN
18637	10723	41	the	the	DT
18637	10723	42	power	power	NN
18637	10723	43	to	to	TO
18637	10723	44	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	10723	45	into	into	IN
18637	10723	46	the	the	DT
18637	10723	47	validity	validity	NN
18637	10723	48	of	of	IN
18637	10723	49	orders	order	NNS
18637	10723	50	involved	involve	VBN
18637	10723	51	in	in	IN
18637	10723	52	civil	civil	JJ
18637	10723	53	or	or	CC
18637	10723	54	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10723	55	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10723	56	in	in	IN
18637	10723	57	which	which	WDT
18637	10723	58	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10723	59	had	have	VBD
18637	10723	60	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10723	61	.	.	.
18637	10724	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10724	2	110	110	CD
18637	10724	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10724	4	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	10724	5	Review	Review	NNP
18637	10724	6	Restrained	Restrained	NNP
18637	10724	7	In	in	IN
18637	10724	8	Yakus	Yakus	NNP
18637	10724	9	_	_	NNP
18637	10724	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	10724	11	_	_	NNP
18637	10724	12	United	United	NNP
18637	10724	13	States[111	States[111	NNP
18637	10724	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10724	15	the	the	DT
18637	10724	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10724	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	10724	18	in	in	IN
18637	10724	19	an	an	DT
18637	10724	20	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10724	21	by	by	IN
18637	10724	22	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10724	23	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10724	24	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	10724	25	that	that	IN
18637	10724	26	there	there	EX
18637	10724	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	10724	28	"	"	``
18637	10724	29	no	no	DT
18637	10724	30	principle	principle	NN
18637	10724	31	of	of	IN
18637	10724	32	law	law	NN
18637	10724	33	or	or	CC
18637	10724	34	provision	provision	NN
18637	10724	35	of	of	IN
18637	10724	36	the	the	DT
18637	10724	37	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10724	38	which	which	WDT
18637	10724	39	precludes	preclude	VBZ
18637	10724	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10724	41	from	from	IN
18637	10724	42	making	make	VBG
18637	10724	43	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10724	44	the	the	DT
18637	10724	45	violation	violation	NN
18637	10724	46	of	of	IN
18637	10724	47	an	an	DT
18637	10724	48	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	10724	49	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	10724	50	,	,	,
18637	10724	51	by	by	IN
18637	10724	52	one	one	CD
18637	10724	53	who	who	WP
18637	10724	54	has	have	VBZ
18637	10724	55	failed	fail	VBN
18637	10724	56	to	to	TO
18637	10724	57	avail	avail	VB
18637	10724	58	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10724	59	of	of	IN
18637	10724	60	an	an	DT
18637	10724	61	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	10724	62	separate	separate	JJ
18637	10724	63	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	10724	64	for	for	IN
18637	10724	65	the	the	DT
18637	10724	66	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	10724	67	of	of	IN
18637	10724	68	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10724	69	validity	validity	NN
18637	10724	70	,	,	,
18637	10724	71	or	or	CC
18637	10724	72	which	which	WDT
18637	10724	73	precludes	preclude	VBZ
18637	10724	74	the	the	DT
18637	10724	75	practice	practice	NN
18637	10724	76	,	,	,
18637	10724	77	in	in	IN
18637	10724	78	many	many	JJ
18637	10724	79	ways	way	NNS
18637	10724	80	desirable	desirable	JJ
18637	10724	81	,	,	,
18637	10724	82	of	of	IN
18637	10724	83	splitting	split	VBG
18637	10724	84	the	the	DT
18637	10724	85	trial	trial	NN
18637	10724	86	for	for	IN
18637	10724	87	violations	violation	NNS
18637	10724	88	of	of	IN
18637	10724	89	an	an	DT
18637	10724	90	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	10724	91	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	10724	92	by	by	IN
18637	10724	93	committing	commit	VBG
18637	10724	94	the	the	DT
18637	10724	95	determination	determination	NN
18637	10724	96	of	of	IN
18637	10724	97	the	the	DT
18637	10724	98	issue	issue	NN
18637	10724	99	of	of	IN
18637	10724	100	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10724	101	validity	validity	NN
18637	10724	102	to	to	IN
18637	10724	103	the	the	DT
18637	10724	104	agency	agency	NN
18637	10724	105	which	which	WDT
18637	10724	106	created	create	VBD
18637	10724	107	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10724	108	,	,	,
18637	10724	109	and	and	CC
18637	10724	110	the	the	DT
18637	10724	111	issue	issue	NN
18637	10724	112	of	of	IN
18637	10724	113	violation	violation	NN
18637	10724	114	to	to	IN
18637	10724	115	a	a	DT
18637	10724	116	court	court	NN
18637	10724	117	which	which	WDT
18637	10724	118	is	be	VBZ
18637	10724	119	given	give	VBN
18637	10724	120	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10724	121	to	to	TO
18637	10724	122	punish	punish	VB
18637	10724	123	violations	violation	NNS
18637	10724	124	.	.	.
18637	10725	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	10725	2	a	a	DT
18637	10725	3	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	10725	4	presents	present	VBZ
18637	10725	5	no	no	DT
18637	10725	6	novel	novel	JJ
18637	10725	7	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10725	8	issue	issue	NN
18637	10725	9	.	.	.
18637	10726	1	"	"	``
18637	10726	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10726	3	112	112	CD
18637	10726	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10726	5	In	in	IN
18637	10726	6	a	a	DT
18637	10726	7	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	10726	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10726	9	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	10726	10	took	take	VBD
18637	10726	11	issue	issue	NN
18637	10726	12	with	with	IN
18637	10726	13	this	this	DT
18637	10726	14	holding	holding	NN
18637	10726	15	,	,	,
18637	10726	16	saying	say	VBG
18637	10726	17	:	:	:
18637	10726	18	"	"	``
18637	10726	19	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10726	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	10726	21	one	one	CD
18637	10726	22	thing	thing	NN
18637	10726	23	for	for	IN
18637	10726	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10726	25	to	to	TO
18637	10726	26	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	10726	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10726	28	.	.	.
18637	10727	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10727	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	10727	3	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	10727	4	another	another	DT
18637	10727	5	to	to	TO
18637	10727	6	confer	confer	VB
18637	10727	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10727	8	and	and	CC
18637	10727	9	direct	direct	JJ
18637	10727	10	that	that	IN
18637	10727	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10727	12	be	be	VB
18637	10727	13	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	10727	14	in	in	IN
18637	10727	15	a	a	DT
18637	10727	16	manner	manner	NN
18637	10727	17	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	10727	18	with	with	IN
18637	10727	19	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10727	20	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	10727	21	or	or	CC
18637	10727	22	,	,	,
18637	10727	23	what	what	WP
18637	10727	24	in	in	IN
18637	10727	25	some	some	DT
18637	10727	26	instances	instance	NNS
18637	10727	27	may	may	MD
18637	10727	28	be	be	VB
18637	10727	29	the	the	DT
18637	10727	30	same	same	JJ
18637	10727	31	thing	thing	NN
18637	10727	32	,	,	,
18637	10727	33	without	without	IN
18637	10727	34	regard	regard	NN
18637	10727	35	to	to	IN
18637	10727	36	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10727	37	.	.	.
18637	10728	1	Once	once	IN
18637	10728	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10728	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	10728	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	10728	5	that	that	IN
18637	10728	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10728	7	can	can	MD
18637	10728	8	require	require	VB
18637	10728	9	the	the	DT
18637	10728	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	10728	11	criminally	criminally	RB
18637	10728	12	to	to	TO
18637	10728	13	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	10728	14	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	10728	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	10728	16	or	or	CC
18637	10728	17	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	10728	18	,	,	,
18637	10728	19	including	include	VBG
18637	10728	20	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	10728	21	,	,	,
18637	10728	22	or	or	CC
18637	10728	23	to	to	TO
18637	10728	24	do	do	VB
18637	10728	25	so	so	RB
18637	10728	26	without	without	IN
18637	10728	27	regard	regard	NN
18637	10728	28	for	for	IN
18637	10728	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10728	30	validity	validity	NN
18637	10728	31	,	,	,
18637	10728	32	the	the	DT
18637	10728	33	way	way	NN
18637	10728	34	will	will	MD
18637	10728	35	have	have	VB
18637	10728	36	been	be	VBN
18637	10728	37	found	find	VBN
18637	10728	38	to	to	TO
18637	10728	39	circumvent	circumvent	VB
18637	10728	40	the	the	DT
18637	10728	41	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	10728	42	law	law	NNP
18637	10728	43	and	and	CC
18637	10728	44	,	,	,
18637	10728	45	what	what	WP
18637	10728	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	10728	47	more	more	JJR
18637	10728	48	,	,	,
18637	10728	49	to	to	TO
18637	10728	50	make	make	VB
18637	10728	51	the	the	DT
18637	10728	52	courts	court	NNS
18637	10728	53	parties	party	NNS
18637	10728	54	to	to	IN
18637	10728	55	doing	do	VBG
18637	10728	56	so	so	RB
18637	10728	57	.	.	.
18637	10729	1	This	this	DT
18637	10729	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10729	3	can	can	MD
18637	10729	4	not	not	RB
18637	10729	5	do	do	VB
18637	10729	6	.	.	.
18637	10730	1	There	there	EX
18637	10730	2	are	be	VBP
18637	10730	3	limits	limit	NNS
18637	10730	4	to	to	IN
18637	10730	5	the	the	DT
18637	10730	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10730	7	power	power	NN
18637	10730	8	.	.	.
18637	10731	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10731	2	may	may	MD
18637	10731	3	impose	impose	VB
18637	10731	4	others	other	NNS
18637	10731	5	.	.	.
18637	10732	1	And	and	CC
18637	10732	2	in	in	IN
18637	10732	3	some	some	DT
18637	10732	4	matters	matter	NNS
18637	10732	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10732	6	or	or	CC
18637	10732	7	the	the	DT
18637	10732	8	President	President	NNP
18637	10732	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	10732	10	final	final	JJ
18637	10732	11	say	say	NN
18637	10732	12	under	under	IN
18637	10732	13	the	the	DT
18637	10732	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10732	15	.	.	.
18637	10733	1	But	but	CC
18637	10733	2	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	10733	3	the	the	DT
18637	10733	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10733	5	power	power	NN
18637	10733	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	10733	7	called	call	VBN
18637	10733	8	into	into	IN
18637	10733	9	play	play	NN
18637	10733	10	,	,	,
18637	10733	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10733	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	10733	13	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	10733	14	directly	directly	RB
18637	10733	15	to	to	IN
18637	10733	16	the	the	DT
18637	10733	17	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	10733	18	law	law	NN
18637	10733	19	and	and	CC
18637	10733	20	no	no	DT
18637	10733	21	other	other	JJ
18637	10733	22	authority	authority	NN
18637	10733	23	can	can	MD
18637	10733	24	intervene	intervene	VB
18637	10733	25	to	to	TO
18637	10733	26	force	force	VB
18637	10733	27	or	or	CC
18637	10733	28	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	10733	29	the	the	DT
18637	10733	30	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10733	31	body	body	NN
18637	10733	32	to	to	TO
18637	10733	33	disregard	disregard	VB
18637	10733	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10733	35	.	.	.
18637	10734	1	The	the	DT
18637	10734	2	problem	problem	NN
18637	10734	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	10734	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	10734	5	not	not	RB
18637	10734	6	solely	solely	RB
18637	10734	7	one	one	CD
18637	10734	8	of	of	IN
18637	10734	9	individual	individual	JJ
18637	10734	10	right	right	JJ
18637	10734	11	or	or	CC
18637	10734	12	due	due	JJ
18637	10734	13	process	process	NN
18637	10734	14	of	of	IN
18637	10734	15	law	law	NN
18637	10734	16	.	.	.
18637	10735	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10735	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	10735	3	equally	equally	RB
18637	10735	4	one	one	CD
18637	10735	5	of	of	IN
18637	10735	6	the	the	DT
18637	10735	7	separation	separation	NN
18637	10735	8	and	and	CC
18637	10735	9	independence	independence	NN
18637	10735	10	of	of	IN
18637	10735	11	the	the	DT
18637	10735	12	powers	power	NNS
18637	10735	13	of	of	IN
18637	10735	14	government	government	NN
18637	10735	15	and	and	CC
18637	10735	16	of	of	IN
18637	10735	17	the	the	DT
18637	10735	18	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10735	19	integrity	integrity	NN
18637	10735	20	of	of	IN
18637	10735	21	the	the	DT
18637	10735	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10735	23	process	process	NN
18637	10735	24	,	,	,
18637	10735	25	more	more	RBR
18637	10735	26	especially	especially	RB
18637	10735	27	in	in	IN
18637	10735	28	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10735	29	trials	trial	NNS
18637	10735	30	.	.	.
18637	10736	1	"	"	``
18637	10736	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10736	3	113	113	CD
18637	10736	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10736	5	LEGISLATIVE	legislative	JJ
18637	10736	6	COURTS	court	NNS
18637	10736	7	:	:	:
18637	10736	8	THE	the	DT
18637	10736	9	CANTER	CANTER	NNP
18637	10736	10	CASE	case	NN
18637	10736	11	Quite	quite	RB
18637	10736	12	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	10736	13	from	from	IN
18637	10736	14	special	special	JJ
18637	10736	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	10736	16	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	10736	17	the	the	DT
18637	10736	18	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10736	19	power	power	NN
18637	10736	20	of	of	IN
18637	10736	21	the	the	DT
18637	10736	22	United	United	NNP
18637	10736	23	States	States	NNP
18637	10736	24	,	,	,
18637	10736	25	but	but	CC
18637	10736	26	at	at	IN
18637	10736	27	the	the	DT
18637	10736	28	same	same	JJ
18637	10736	29	time	time	NN
18637	10736	30	a	a	DT
18637	10736	31	significant	significant	JJ
18637	10736	32	part	part	NN
18637	10736	33	of	of	IN
18637	10736	34	the	the	DT
18637	10736	35	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10736	36	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	10736	37	,	,	,
18637	10736	38	are	be	VBP
18637	10736	39	the	the	DT
18637	10736	40	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10736	41	courts	court	NNS
18637	10736	42	,	,	,
18637	10736	43	so	so	RB
18637	10736	44	called	call	VBD
18637	10736	45	because	because	IN
18637	10736	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10736	47	are	be	VBP
18637	10736	48	created	create	VBN
18637	10736	49	by	by	IN
18637	10736	50	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10736	51	in	in	IN
18637	10736	52	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	10736	53	of	of	IN
18637	10736	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10736	55	general	general	JJ
18637	10736	56	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10736	57	powers	power	NNS
18637	10736	58	.	.	.
18637	10737	1	The	the	DT
18637	10737	2	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	10737	3	between	between	IN
18637	10737	4	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10737	5	courts	court	NNS
18637	10737	6	and	and	CC
18637	10737	7	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10737	8	courts	court	NNS
18637	10737	9	was	be	VBD
18637	10737	10	first	first	RB
18637	10737	11	made	make	VBN
18637	10737	12	in	in	IN
18637	10737	13	American	American	NNP
18637	10737	14	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	10737	15	Company	Company	NNP
18637	10737	16	_	_	NNP
18637	10737	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	10737	18	_	_	NNP
18637	10737	19	Canter,[114	Canter,[114	NNP
18637	10737	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10737	21	which	which	WDT
18637	10737	22	involved	involve	VBD
18637	10737	23	the	the	DT
18637	10737	24	question	question	NN
18637	10737	25	of	of	IN
18637	10737	26	the	the	DT
18637	10737	27	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	10737	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10737	29	of	of	IN
18637	10737	30	the	the	DT
18637	10737	31	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	10737	32	court	court	NN
18637	10737	33	of	of	IN
18637	10737	34	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	10737	35	,	,	,
18637	10737	36	the	the	DT
18637	10737	37	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10737	38	of	of	IN
18637	10737	39	which	which	WDT
18637	10737	40	were	be	VBD
18637	10737	41	limited	limit	VBN
18637	10737	42	to	to	IN
18637	10737	43	a	a	DT
18637	10737	44	four	four	CD
18637	10737	45	-	-	HYPH
18637	10737	46	year	year	NN
18637	10737	47	term	term	NN
18637	10737	48	in	in	IN
18637	10737	49	office	office	NN
18637	10737	50	.	.	.
18637	10738	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	10738	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10738	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10738	4	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	10738	5	for	for	IN
18637	10738	6	the	the	DT
18637	10738	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10738	8	:	:	:
18637	10738	9	"	"	``
18637	10738	10	These	these	DT
18637	10738	11	courts	court	NNS
18637	10738	12	,	,	,
18637	10738	13	then	then	RB
18637	10738	14	,	,	,
18637	10738	15	are	be	VBP
18637	10738	16	not	not	RB
18637	10738	17	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10738	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	10738	19	,	,	,
18637	10738	20	in	in	IN
18637	10738	21	which	which	WDT
18637	10738	22	the	the	DT
18637	10738	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10738	24	power	power	NN
18637	10738	25	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	10738	26	by	by	IN
18637	10738	27	the	the	DT
18637	10738	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10738	29	on	on	IN
18637	10738	30	the	the	DT
18637	10738	31	general	general	JJ
18637	10738	32	government	government	NN
18637	10738	33	,	,	,
18637	10738	34	can	can	MD
18637	10738	35	be	be	VB
18637	10738	36	deposited	deposit	VBN
18637	10738	37	.	.	.
18637	10739	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10739	2	are	be	VBP
18637	10739	3	incapable	incapable	JJ
18637	10739	4	of	of	IN
18637	10739	5	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	10739	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10739	7	.	.	.
18637	10740	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10740	2	are	be	VBP
18637	10740	3	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10740	4	courts	court	NNS
18637	10740	5	,	,	,
18637	10740	6	created	create	VBN
18637	10740	7	in	in	IN
18637	10740	8	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	10740	9	of	of	IN
18637	10740	10	the	the	DT
18637	10740	11	general	general	JJ
18637	10740	12	right	right	NN
18637	10740	13	of	of	IN
18637	10740	14	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	10740	15	which	which	WDT
18637	10740	16	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	10740	17	in	in	IN
18637	10740	18	the	the	DT
18637	10740	19	government	government	NN
18637	10740	20	,	,	,
18637	10740	21	or	or	CC
18637	10740	22	in	in	IN
18637	10740	23	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	10740	24	of	of	IN
18637	10740	25	that	that	DT
18637	10740	26	clause	clause	NN
18637	10740	27	which	which	WDT
18637	10740	28	enables	enable	VBZ
18637	10740	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10740	30	to	to	TO
18637	10740	31	make	make	VB
18637	10740	32	all	all	DT
18637	10740	33	needful	needful	JJ
18637	10740	34	rules	rule	NNS
18637	10740	35	and	and	CC
18637	10740	36	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	10740	37	,	,	,
18637	10740	38	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	10740	39	the	the	DT
18637	10740	40	territory	territory	NN
18637	10740	41	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	10740	42	to	to	IN
18637	10740	43	the	the	DT
18637	10740	44	United	United	NNP
18637	10740	45	States	States	NNP
18637	10740	46	.	.	.
18637	10741	1	The	the	DT
18637	10741	2	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10741	3	with	with	IN
18637	10741	4	which	which	WDT
18637	10741	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10741	6	are	be	VBP
18637	10741	7	invested	invest	VBN
18637	10741	8	,	,	,
18637	10741	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	10741	10	not	not	RB
18637	10741	11	a	a	DT
18637	10741	12	part	part	NN
18637	10741	13	of	of	IN
18637	10741	14	that	that	DT
18637	10741	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10741	16	power	power	NN
18637	10741	17	which	which	WDT
18637	10741	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	10741	19	defined	define	VBN
18637	10741	20	in	in	IN
18637	10741	21	the	the	DT
18637	10741	22	3rd	3rd	JJ
18637	10741	23	article	article	NN
18637	10741	24	of	of	IN
18637	10741	25	the	the	DT
18637	10741	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10741	27	,	,	,
18637	10741	28	but	but	CC
18637	10741	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	10741	30	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	10741	31	by	by	IN
18637	10741	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10741	33	,	,	,
18637	10741	34	in	in	IN
18637	10741	35	the	the	DT
18637	10741	36	execution	execution	NN
18637	10741	37	of	of	IN
18637	10741	38	those	those	DT
18637	10741	39	general	general	JJ
18637	10741	40	powers	power	NNS
18637	10741	41	which	which	WDT
18637	10741	42	that	that	WDT
18637	10741	43	body	body	NN
18637	10741	44	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	10741	45	over	over	IN
18637	10741	46	the	the	DT
18637	10741	47	territories	territory	NNS
18637	10741	48	of	of	IN
18637	10741	49	the	the	DT
18637	10741	50	United	United	NNP
18637	10741	51	States	States	NNP
18637	10741	52	.	.	.
18637	10742	1	"	"	``
18637	10742	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10742	3	115	115	CD
18637	10742	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10742	5	The	the	DT
18637	10742	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10742	7	went	go	VBD
18637	10742	8	on	on	RP
18637	10742	9	to	to	TO
18637	10742	10	hold	hold	VB
18637	10742	11	that	that	DT
18637	10742	12	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	10742	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10742	14	can	can	MD
18637	10742	15	be	be	VB
18637	10742	16	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	10742	17	in	in	IN
18637	10742	18	the	the	DT
18637	10742	19	States	States	NNPS
18637	10742	20	in	in	IN
18637	10742	21	those	those	DT
18637	10742	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	10742	23	only	only	RB
18637	10742	24	which	which	WDT
18637	10742	25	are	be	VBP
18637	10742	26	established	establish	VBN
18637	10742	27	in	in	IN
18637	10742	28	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	10742	29	of	of	IN
18637	10742	30	article	article	NN
18637	10742	31	III	iii	CD
18637	10742	32	,	,	,
18637	10742	33	but	but	CC
18637	10742	34	that	that	IN
18637	10742	35	the	the	DT
18637	10742	36	same	same	JJ
18637	10742	37	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	10742	38	does	do	VBZ
18637	10742	39	not	not	RB
18637	10742	40	apply	apply	VB
18637	10742	41	to	to	IN
18637	10742	42	the	the	DT
18637	10742	43	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	10742	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	10742	45	;	;	:
18637	10742	46	for	for	IN
18637	10742	47	,	,	,
18637	10742	48	in	in	IN
18637	10742	49	legislating	legislate	VBG
18637	10742	50	for	for	IN
18637	10742	51	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10742	52	,	,	,
18637	10742	53	"	"	''
18637	10742	54	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10742	55	exercises	exercise	VBZ
18637	10742	56	the	the	DT
18637	10742	57	combined	combined	JJ
18637	10742	58	powers	power	NNS
18637	10742	59	of	of	IN
18637	10742	60	the	the	DT
18637	10742	61	general	general	NN
18637	10742	62	,	,	,
18637	10742	63	and	and	CC
18637	10742	64	of	of	IN
18637	10742	65	a	a	DT
18637	10742	66	State	State	NNP
18637	10742	67	government	government	NN
18637	10742	68	.	.	.
18637	10743	1	"	"	``
18637	10743	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10743	3	116	116	CD
18637	10743	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10743	5	Other	other	JJ
18637	10743	6	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	10743	7	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	10743	8	The	the	DT
18637	10743	9	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	10743	10	made	make	VBN
18637	10743	11	in	in	IN
18637	10743	12	the	the	DT
18637	10743	13	Canter	Canter	NNP
18637	10743	14	case	case	NN
18637	10743	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	10743	16	been	be	VBN
18637	10743	17	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	10743	18	with	with	IN
18637	10743	19	elaborations	elaboration	NNS
18637	10743	20	since	since	IN
18637	10743	21	1828	1828	CD
18637	10743	22	,	,	,
18637	10743	23	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	10743	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10743	25	fullest	full	JJS
18637	10743	26	exposition	exposition	NN
18637	10743	27	in	in	IN
18637	10743	28	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	10743	29	parte	parte	NN
18637	10743	30	Bakelite	Bakelite	NNP
18637	10743	31	Corporation,[117	Corporation,[117	NNP
18637	10743	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10743	33	which	which	WDT
18637	10743	34	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	10743	35	a	a	DT
18637	10743	36	review	review	NN
18637	10743	37	of	of	IN
18637	10743	38	the	the	DT
18637	10743	39	history	history	NN
18637	10743	40	of	of	IN
18637	10743	41	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10743	42	courts	court	NNS
18637	10743	43	and	and	CC
18637	10743	44	the	the	DT
18637	10743	45	cases	case	NNS
18637	10743	46	supporting	support	VBG
18637	10743	47	the	the	DT
18637	10743	48	power	power	NN
18637	10743	49	of	of	IN
18637	10743	50	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10743	51	to	to	TO
18637	10743	52	create	create	VB
18637	10743	53	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10743	54	.	.	.
18637	10744	1	In	in	IN
18637	10744	2	addition	addition	NN
18637	10744	3	to	to	IN
18637	10744	4	discussing	discuss	VBG
18637	10744	5	the	the	DT
18637	10744	6	derivation	derivation	NN
18637	10744	7	of	of	IN
18637	10744	8	power	power	NN
18637	10744	9	to	to	TO
18637	10744	10	establish	establish	VB
18637	10744	11	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10744	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	10744	13	,	,	,
18637	10744	14	the	the	DT
18637	10744	15	Bakelite	Bakelite	NNP
18637	10744	16	case	case	NN
18637	10744	17	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	10744	18	that	that	IN
18637	10744	19	such	such	JJ
18637	10744	20	courts	court	NNS
18637	10744	21	"	"	''
18637	10744	22	also	also	RB
18637	10744	23	may	may	MD
18637	10744	24	be	be	VB
18637	10744	25	created	create	VBN
18637	10744	26	as	as	IN
18637	10744	27	special	special	JJ
18637	10744	28	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	10744	29	to	to	TO
18637	10744	30	examine	examine	VB
18637	10744	31	and	and	CC
18637	10744	32	determine	determine	VB
18637	10744	33	various	various	JJ
18637	10744	34	matters	matter	NNS
18637	10744	35	,	,	,
18637	10744	36	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10744	37	between	between	IN
18637	10744	38	the	the	DT
18637	10744	39	government	government	NN
18637	10744	40	and	and	CC
18637	10744	41	others	other	NNS
18637	10744	42	,	,	,
18637	10744	43	which	which	WDT
18637	10744	44	from	from	IN
18637	10744	45	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10744	46	nature	nature	NN
18637	10744	47	do	do	VBP
18637	10744	48	not	not	RB
18637	10744	49	require	require	VB
18637	10744	50	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10744	51	determination	determination	NN
18637	10744	52	and	and	CC
18637	10744	53	yet	yet	RB
18637	10744	54	are	be	VBP
18637	10744	55	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
18637	10744	56	of	of	IN
18637	10744	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10744	58	.	.	.
18637	10745	1	The	the	DT
18637	10745	2	mode	mode	NN
18637	10745	3	of	of	IN
18637	10745	4	determining	determine	VBG
18637	10745	5	matters	matter	NNS
18637	10745	6	of	of	IN
18637	10745	7	this	this	DT
18637	10745	8	class	class	NN
18637	10745	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	10745	10	completely	completely	RB
18637	10745	11	within	within	IN
18637	10745	12	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	10745	13	control	control	NN
18637	10745	14	.	.	.
18637	10746	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10746	2	may	may	MD
18637	10746	3	reserve	reserve	VB
18637	10746	4	to	to	IN
18637	10746	5	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10746	6	the	the	DT
18637	10746	7	power	power	NN
18637	10746	8	to	to	TO
18637	10746	9	decide	decide	VB
18637	10746	10	,	,	,
18637	10746	11	may	may	MD
18637	10746	12	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	10746	13	that	that	DT
18637	10746	14	power	power	NN
18637	10746	15	to	to	IN
18637	10746	16	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10746	17	officers	officer	NNS
18637	10746	18	,	,	,
18637	10746	19	or	or	CC
18637	10746	20	may	may	MD
18637	10746	21	commit	commit	VB
18637	10746	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10746	23	to	to	IN
18637	10746	24	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10746	25	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	10746	26	.	.	.
18637	10747	1	"	"	``
18637	10747	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10747	3	118	118	CD
18637	10747	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10747	5	Among	among	IN
18637	10747	6	the	the	DT
18637	10747	7	matters	matter	NNS
18637	10747	8	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
18637	10747	9	of	of	IN
18637	10747	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10747	11	determination	determination	NN
18637	10747	12	but	but	CC
18637	10747	13	not	not	RB
18637	10747	14	requiring	require	VBG
18637	10747	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10747	16	are	be	VBP
18637	10747	17	claims	claim	NNS
18637	10747	18	against	against	IN
18637	10747	19	the	the	DT
18637	10747	20	States,[119	States,[119	NNP
18637	10747	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10747	22	the	the	DT
18637	10747	23	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	10747	24	of	of	IN
18637	10747	25	the	the	DT
18637	10747	26	public	public	JJ
18637	10747	27	lands	land	NNS
18637	10747	28	and	and	CC
18637	10747	29	claims	claim	NNS
18637	10747	30	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10747	31	therefrom,[120	therefrom,[120	NN
18637	10747	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10747	33	questions	question	NNS
18637	10747	34	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	10747	35	membership	membership	NN
18637	10747	36	in	in	IN
18637	10747	37	the	the	DT
18637	10747	38	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	10747	39	tribes,[121	tribes,[121	NN
18637	10747	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10747	41	and	and	CC
18637	10747	42	questions	question	NNS
18637	10747	43	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10747	44	out	out	IN
18637	10747	45	of	of	IN
18637	10747	46	the	the	DT
18637	10747	47	administration	administration	NN
18637	10747	48	of	of	IN
18637	10747	49	the	the	DT
18637	10747	50	customs	custom	NNS
18637	10747	51	and	and	CC
18637	10747	52	internal	internal	JJ
18637	10747	53	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	10747	54	laws	law	NNS
18637	10747	55	.	.	.
18637	10748	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10748	2	122	122	CD
18637	10748	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10748	4	For	for	IN
18637	10748	5	the	the	DT
18637	10748	6	determination	determination	NN
18637	10748	7	of	of	IN
18637	10748	8	these	these	DT
18637	10748	9	matters	matter	NNS
18637	10748	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10748	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	10748	12	created	create	VBN
18637	10748	13	the	the	DT
18637	10748	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10748	15	of	of	IN
18637	10748	16	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	10748	17	,	,	,
18637	10748	18	the	the	DT
18637	10748	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10748	20	of	of	IN
18637	10748	21	Private	Private	NNP
18637	10748	22	Land	Land	NNP
18637	10748	23	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	10748	24	,	,	,
18637	10748	25	the	the	DT
18637	10748	26	Choctaw	Choctaw	NNP
18637	10748	27	and	and	CC
18637	10748	28	Chickasaw	Chickasaw	NNP
18637	10748	29	Citizenship	Citizenship	NNP
18637	10748	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10748	31	,	,	,
18637	10748	32	the	the	DT
18637	10748	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10748	34	of	of	IN
18637	10748	35	Customs	Customs	NNP
18637	10748	36	,	,	,
18637	10748	37	the	the	DT
18637	10748	38	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10748	39	of	of	IN
18637	10748	40	Customs	Customs	NNP
18637	10748	41	and	and	CC
18637	10748	42	Patent	Patent	NNP
18637	10748	43	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	10748	44	,	,	,
18637	10748	45	and	and	CC
18637	10748	46	the	the	DT
18637	10748	47	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	10748	48	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10748	49	of	of	IN
18637	10748	50	the	the	DT
18637	10748	51	United	United	NNP
18637	10748	52	States	States	NNP
18637	10748	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10748	54	formerly	formerly	RB
18637	10748	55	the	the	DT
18637	10748	56	Board	Board	NNP
18637	10748	57	of	of	IN
18637	10748	58	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	10748	59	Appeals	Appeals	NNP
18637	10748	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10748	61	.	.	.
18637	10749	1	Power	power	NN
18637	10749	2	of	of	IN
18637	10749	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10749	4	Over	over	IN
18637	10749	5	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	10749	6	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	10749	7	In	in	IN
18637	10749	8	creating	create	VBG
18637	10749	9	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10749	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	10749	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10749	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	10749	13	not	not	RB
18637	10749	14	limited	limit	VBN
18637	10749	15	by	by	IN
18637	10749	16	the	the	DT
18637	10749	17	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	10749	18	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	10749	19	in	in	IN
18637	10749	20	article	article	NN
18637	10749	21	III	iii	CD
18637	10749	22	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	10749	23	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	10749	24	during	during	IN
18637	10749	25	good	good	JJ
18637	10749	26	behavior	behavior	NN
18637	10749	27	and	and	CC
18637	10749	28	the	the	DT
18637	10749	29	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	10749	30	against	against	IN
18637	10749	31	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	10749	32	of	of	IN
18637	10749	33	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	10749	34	.	.	.
18637	10750	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10750	2	may	may	MD
18637	10750	3	limit	limit	VB
18637	10750	4	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	10750	5	to	to	IN
18637	10750	6	a	a	DT
18637	10750	7	term	term	NN
18637	10750	8	of	of	IN
18637	10750	9	years	year	NNS
18637	10750	10	,	,	,
18637	10750	11	as	as	IN
18637	10750	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10750	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	10750	14	done	do	VBN
18637	10750	15	in	in	IN
18637	10750	16	acts	act	NNS
18637	10750	17	creating	create	VBG
18637	10750	18	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	10750	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	10750	20	and	and	CC
18637	10750	21	the	the	DT
18637	10750	22	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	10750	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10750	24	of	of	IN
18637	10750	25	the	the	DT
18637	10750	26	United	United	NNP
18637	10750	27	States	States	NNP
18637	10750	28	,	,	,
18637	10750	29	and	and	CC
18637	10750	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10750	31	may	may	MD
18637	10750	32	subject	subject	VB
18637	10750	33	the	the	DT
18637	10750	34	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10750	35	of	of	IN
18637	10750	36	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10750	37	courts	court	NNS
18637	10750	38	to	to	IN
18637	10750	39	removal	removal	NN
18637	10750	40	by	by	IN
18637	10750	41	the	the	DT
18637	10750	42	President	President	NNP
18637	10750	43	.	.	.
18637	10751	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10751	2	123	123	CD
18637	10751	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10751	4	In	in	IN
18637	10751	5	McAllister	McAllister	NNP
18637	10751	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10751	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10751	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10751	9	United	United	NNP
18637	10751	10	States,[124	States,[124	NNP
18637	10751	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10751	12	the	the	DT
18637	10751	13	removal	removal	NN
18637	10751	14	of	of	IN
18637	10751	15	a	a	DT
18637	10751	16	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	10751	17	judge	judge	NN
18637	10751	18	was	be	VBD
18637	10751	19	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	10751	20	on	on	IN
18637	10751	21	the	the	DT
18637	10751	22	basis	basis	NN
18637	10751	23	of	of	IN
18637	10751	24	the	the	DT
18637	10751	25	principle	principle	NN
18637	10751	26	that	that	WDT
18637	10751	27	:	:	:
18637	10751	28	"	"	``
18637	10751	29	The	the	DT
18637	10751	30	whole	whole	JJ
18637	10751	31	subject	subject	NN
18637	10751	32	of	of	IN
18637	10751	33	the	the	DT
18637	10751	34	organization	organization	NN
18637	10751	35	of	of	IN
18637	10751	36	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	10751	37	courts	court	NNS
18637	10751	38	,	,	,
18637	10751	39	the	the	DT
18637	10751	40	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	10751	41	by	by	IN
18637	10751	42	which	which	WDT
18637	10751	43	the	the	DT
18637	10751	44	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10751	45	of	of	IN
18637	10751	46	such	such	JJ
18637	10751	47	courts	court	NNS
18637	10751	48	shall	shall	MD
18637	10751	49	hold	hold	VB
18637	10751	50	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10751	51	offices	office	NNS
18637	10751	52	,	,	,
18637	10751	53	the	the	DT
18637	10751	54	salary	salary	NN
18637	10751	55	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10751	56	receive	receive	VBP
18637	10751	57	and	and	CC
18637	10751	58	the	the	DT
18637	10751	59	manner	manner	NN
18637	10751	60	in	in	IN
18637	10751	61	which	which	WDT
18637	10751	62	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10751	63	may	may	MD
18637	10751	64	be	be	VB
18637	10751	65	removed	remove	VBN
18637	10751	66	or	or	CC
18637	10751	67	suspended	suspend	VBN
18637	10751	68	from	from	IN
18637	10751	69	office	office	NN
18637	10751	70	,	,	,
18637	10751	71	was	be	VBD
18637	10751	72	left	leave	VBN
18637	10751	73	,	,	,
18637	10751	74	by	by	IN
18637	10751	75	the	the	DT
18637	10751	76	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10751	77	,	,	,
18637	10751	78	with	with	IN
18637	10751	79	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10751	80	under	under	IN
18637	10751	81	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10751	82	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	10751	83	power	power	NN
18637	10751	84	over	over	IN
18637	10751	85	the	the	DT
18637	10751	86	Territories	Territories	NNPS
18637	10751	87	of	of	IN
18637	10751	88	the	the	DT
18637	10751	89	United	United	NNP
18637	10751	90	States	States	NNP
18637	10751	91	.	.	.
18637	10752	1	"	"	``
18637	10752	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10752	3	125	125	CD
18637	10752	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10752	5	Long	long	RB
18637	10752	6	afterwards	afterwards	RB
18637	10752	7	the	the	DT
18637	10752	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10752	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	10752	10	in	in	IN
18637	10752	11	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	10752	12	_	_	NNP
18637	10752	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	10752	14	_	_	NNP
18637	10752	15	United	United	NNP
18637	10752	16	States[126	States[126	NNP
18637	10752	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10752	18	that	that	IN
18637	10752	19	the	the	DT
18637	10752	20	reduction	reduction	NN
18637	10752	21	of	of	IN
18637	10752	22	the	the	DT
18637	10752	23	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	10752	24	of	of	IN
18637	10752	25	the	the	DT
18637	10752	26	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10752	27	of	of	IN
18637	10752	28	the	the	DT
18637	10752	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10752	30	of	of	IN
18637	10752	31	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	10752	32	,	,	,
18637	10752	33	and	and	CC
18637	10752	34	inferentially	inferentially	RB
18637	10752	35	of	of	IN
18637	10752	36	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10752	37	of	of	IN
18637	10752	38	other	other	JJ
18637	10752	39	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10752	40	courts	court	NNS
18637	10752	41	,	,	,
18637	10752	42	to	to	IN
18637	10752	43	$	$	$
18637	10752	44	10,000	10,000	CD
18637	10752	45	per	per	IN
18637	10752	46	year	year	NN
18637	10752	47	by	by	IN
18637	10752	48	the	the	DT
18637	10752	49	Appropriation	Appropriation	NNP
18637	10752	50	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10752	51	of	of	IN
18637	10752	52	June	June	NNP
18637	10752	53	30	30	CD
18637	10752	54	,	,	,
18637	10752	55	1932	1932	CD
18637	10752	56	,	,	,
18637	10752	57	was	be	VBD
18637	10752	58	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10752	59	.	.	.
18637	10753	1	In	in	IN
18637	10753	2	so	so	RB
18637	10753	3	doing	do	VBG
18637	10753	4	the	the	DT
18637	10753	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10753	6	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	10753	7	dicta	dicta	NN
18637	10753	8	in	in	IN
18637	10753	9	earlier	early	JJR
18637	10753	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	10753	11	which	which	WDT
18637	10753	12	classified	classify	VBD
18637	10753	13	the	the	DT
18637	10753	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10753	15	of	of	IN
18637	10753	16	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	10753	17	as	as	IN
18637	10753	18	a	a	DT
18637	10753	19	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10753	20	court	court	NN
18637	10753	21	and	and	CC
18637	10753	22	silently	silently	RB
18637	10753	23	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	10753	24	Miles	Miles	NNP
18637	10753	25	_	_	NNP
18637	10753	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	10753	27	_	_	NNP
18637	10753	28	Graham,[127	Graham,[127	NNP
18637	10753	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10753	30	which	which	WDT
18637	10753	31	had	have	VBD
18637	10753	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	10753	33	that	that	IN
18637	10753	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10753	35	could	could	MD
18637	10753	36	not	not	RB
18637	10753	37	include	include	VB
18637	10753	38	the	the	DT
18637	10753	39	salary	salary	NN
18637	10753	40	of	of	IN
18637	10753	41	a	a	DT
18637	10753	42	judge	judge	NN
18637	10753	43	of	of	IN
18637	10753	44	the	the	DT
18637	10753	45	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10753	46	of	of	IN
18637	10753	47	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	10753	48	in	in	IN
18637	10753	49	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10753	50	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	10753	51	income	income	NN
18637	10753	52	.	.	.
18637	10754	1	Status	status	NN
18637	10754	2	of	of	IN
18637	10754	3	the	the	DT
18637	10754	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10754	5	of	of	IN
18637	10754	6	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	10754	7	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10754	8	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	10754	9	,	,	,
18637	10754	10	too	too	RB
18637	10754	11	,	,	,
18637	10754	12	that	that	IN
18637	10754	13	in	in	IN
18637	10754	14	creating	create	VBG
18637	10754	15	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10754	16	courts	court	NNS
18637	10754	17	,	,	,
18637	10754	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10754	19	can	can	MD
18637	10754	20	vest	vest	VB
18637	10754	21	in	in	IN
18637	10754	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10754	23	nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	10754	24	functions	function	NNS
18637	10754	25	of	of	IN
18637	10754	26	a	a	DT
18637	10754	27	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10754	28	or	or	CC
18637	10754	29	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	10754	30	nature	nature	NN
18637	10754	31	and	and	CC
18637	10754	32	deprive	deprive	VBP
18637	10754	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10754	34	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	10754	35	of	of	IN
18637	10754	36	finality	finality	NN
18637	10754	37	.	.	.
18637	10755	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	10755	2	in	in	IN
18637	10755	3	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	10755	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10755	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	10755	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10755	7	United	United	NNP
18637	10755	8	States[128	States[128	NNP
18637	10755	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10755	10	there	there	EX
18637	10755	11	was	be	VBD
18637	10755	12	no	no	DT
18637	10755	13	objection	objection	NN
18637	10755	14	to	to	IN
18637	10755	15	the	the	DT
18637	10755	16	power	power	NN
18637	10755	17	of	of	IN
18637	10755	18	the	the	DT
18637	10755	19	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10755	20	of	of	IN
18637	10755	21	the	the	DT
18637	10755	22	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	10755	23	and	and	CC
18637	10755	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10755	25	to	to	TO
18637	10755	26	revise	revise	VB
18637	10755	27	or	or	CC
18637	10755	28	suspend	suspend	VB
18637	10755	29	the	the	DT
18637	10755	30	early	early	JJ
18637	10755	31	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	10755	32	of	of	IN
18637	10755	33	the	the	DT
18637	10755	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10755	35	of	of	IN
18637	10755	36	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	10755	37	.	.	.
18637	10756	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	10756	2	in	in	IN
18637	10756	3	United	United	NNP
18637	10756	4	States	States	NNP
18637	10756	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10756	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10756	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10756	8	Ferreira[129	Ferreira[129	NNP
18637	10756	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10756	10	the	the	DT
18637	10756	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10756	12	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	10756	13	the	the	DT
18637	10756	14	act	act	NN
18637	10756	15	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	10756	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	10756	17	on	on	IN
18637	10756	18	the	the	DT
18637	10756	19	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	10756	20	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	10756	21	court	court	NN
18637	10756	22	to	to	TO
18637	10756	23	examine	examine	VB
18637	10756	24	claims	claim	NNS
18637	10756	25	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10756	26	under	under	IN
18637	10756	27	the	the	DT
18637	10756	28	Spanish	spanish	JJ
18637	10756	29	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	10756	30	and	and	CC
18637	10756	31	to	to	TO
18637	10756	32	report	report	VB
18637	10756	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10756	34	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	10756	35	and	and	CC
18637	10756	36	the	the	DT
18637	10756	37	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	10756	38	on	on	IN
18637	10756	39	which	which	WDT
18637	10756	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10756	41	were	be	VBD
18637	10756	42	based	base	VBN
18637	10756	43	to	to	IN
18637	10756	44	the	the	DT
18637	10756	45	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10756	46	of	of	IN
18637	10756	47	the	the	DT
18637	10756	48	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	10756	49	for	for	IN
18637	10756	50	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	10756	51	action	action	NN
18637	10756	52	.	.	.
18637	10757	1	"	"	``
18637	10757	2	A	a	DT
18637	10757	3	power	power	NN
18637	10757	4	of	of	IN
18637	10757	5	this	this	DT
18637	10757	6	description	description	NN
18637	10757	7	,	,	,
18637	10757	8	"	"	''
18637	10757	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10757	10	was	be	VBD
18637	10757	11	said	say	VBN
18637	10757	12	,	,	,
18637	10757	13	"	"	``
18637	10757	14	may	may	MD
18637	10757	15	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	10757	16	be	be	VB
18637	10757	17	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	10757	18	on	on	IN
18637	10757	19	a	a	DT
18637	10757	20	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10757	21	as	as	RB
18637	10757	22	well	well	RB
18637	10757	23	as	as	IN
18637	10757	24	on	on	IN
18637	10757	25	a	a	DT
18637	10757	26	commissioner	commissioner	NN
18637	10757	27	.	.	.
18637	10758	1	But	but	CC
18637	10758	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10758	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10758	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10758	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	10758	6	not	not	RB
18637	10758	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10758	8	in	in	IN
18637	10758	9	either	either	DT
18637	10758	10	case	case	NN
18637	10758	11	,	,	,
18637	10758	12	in	in	IN
18637	10758	13	the	the	DT
18637	10758	14	sense	sense	NN
18637	10758	15	in	in	IN
18637	10758	16	which	which	WDT
18637	10758	17	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10758	18	power	power	NN
18637	10758	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	10758	20	granted	grant	VBN
18637	10758	21	by	by	IN
18637	10758	22	the	the	DT
18637	10758	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10758	24	to	to	IN
18637	10758	25	the	the	DT
18637	10758	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	10758	27	of	of	IN
18637	10758	28	the	the	DT
18637	10758	29	United	United	NNP
18637	10758	30	States	States	NNP
18637	10758	31	.	.	.
18637	10758	32	"	"	''
18637	10759	1	A	a	DT
18637	10759	2	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	10759	3	Paradox	Paradox	NNP
18637	10759	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10759	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10759	6	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	10759	7	's	's	POS
18637	10759	8	view	view	NN
18637	10759	9	in	in	IN
18637	10759	10	the	the	DT
18637	10759	11	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	10759	12	case	case	NN
18637	10759	13	that	that	IN
18637	10759	14	the	the	DT
18637	10759	15	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	10759	16	of	of	IN
18637	10759	17	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10759	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	10759	19	could	could	MD
18637	10759	20	never	never	RB
18637	10759	21	be	be	VB
18637	10759	22	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	10759	23	by	by	IN
18637	10759	24	the	the	DT
18637	10759	25	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10759	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10759	27	was	be	VBD
18637	10759	28	tacitly	tacitly	RB
18637	10759	29	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	10759	30	in	in	IN
18637	10759	31	De	De	NNP
18637	10759	32	Groot	Groot	NNP
18637	10759	33	_	_	NNP
18637	10759	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	10759	35	_	_	NNP
18637	10759	36	United	United	NNP
18637	10759	37	States,[130	States,[130	NNP
18637	10759	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10759	39	when	when	WRB
18637	10759	40	the	the	DT
18637	10759	41	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10759	42	took	take	VBD
18637	10759	43	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10759	44	from	from	IN
18637	10759	45	a	a	DT
18637	10759	46	final	final	JJ
18637	10759	47	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10759	48	of	of	IN
18637	10759	49	the	the	DT
18637	10759	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10759	51	of	of	IN
18637	10759	52	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	10759	53	.	.	.
18637	10760	1	Since	since	IN
18637	10760	2	the	the	DT
18637	10760	3	decision	decision	NN
18637	10760	4	of	of	IN
18637	10760	5	this	this	DT
18637	10760	6	case	case	NN
18637	10760	7	in	in	IN
18637	10760	8	1867	1867	CD
18637	10760	9	the	the	DT
18637	10760	10	authority	authority	NN
18637	10760	11	of	of	IN
18637	10760	12	the	the	DT
18637	10760	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10760	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10760	15	to	to	TO
18637	10760	16	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	10760	17	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	10760	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10760	19	over	over	IN
18637	10760	20	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10760	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	10760	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	10760	23	turned	turn	VBN
18637	10760	24	not	not	RB
18637	10760	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	10760	26	the	the	DT
18637	10760	27	nature	nature	NN
18637	10760	28	or	or	CC
18637	10760	29	status	status	NN
18637	10760	30	of	of	IN
18637	10760	31	such	such	JJ
18637	10760	32	courts	court	NNS
18637	10760	33	,	,	,
18637	10760	34	but	but	CC
18637	10760	35	rather	rather	RB
18637	10760	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	10760	37	the	the	DT
18637	10760	38	nature	nature	NN
18637	10760	39	of	of	IN
18637	10760	40	the	the	DT
18637	10760	41	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	10760	42	before	before	IN
18637	10760	43	the	the	DT
18637	10760	44	lower	low	JJR
18637	10760	45	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10760	46	and	and	CC
18637	10760	47	the	the	DT
18637	10760	48	finality	finality	NN
18637	10760	49	of	of	IN
18637	10760	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10760	51	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10760	52	.	.	.
18637	10761	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	10761	2	in	in	IN
18637	10761	3	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10761	4	before	before	IN
18637	10761	5	a	a	DT
18637	10761	6	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10761	7	court	court	NN
18637	10761	8	which	which	WDT
18637	10761	9	are	be	VBP
18637	10761	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10761	11	in	in	IN
18637	10761	12	nature	nature	NN
18637	10761	13	and	and	CC
18637	10761	14	admit	admit	NN
18637	10761	15	of	of	IN
18637	10761	16	a	a	DT
18637	10761	17	final	final	JJ
18637	10761	18	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10761	19	the	the	DT
18637	10761	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10761	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10761	22	may	may	MD
18637	10761	23	be	be	VB
18637	10761	24	vested	vest	VBN
18637	10761	25	with	with	IN
18637	10761	26	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	10761	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10761	28	.	.	.
18637	10762	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	10762	2	there	there	EX
18637	10762	3	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	10762	4	the	the	DT
18637	10762	5	workable	workable	JJ
18637	10762	6	anomaly	anomaly	IN
18637	10762	7	that	that	IN
18637	10762	8	though	though	IN
18637	10762	9	the	the	DT
18637	10762	10	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10762	11	courts	court	NNS
18637	10762	12	can	can	MD
18637	10762	13	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	10762	14	no	no	DT
18637	10762	15	part	part	NN
18637	10762	16	of	of	IN
18637	10762	17	the	the	DT
18637	10762	18	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10762	19	power	power	NN
18637	10762	20	of	of	IN
18637	10762	21	the	the	DT
18637	10762	22	United	United	NNP
18637	10762	23	States	States	NNP
18637	10762	24	and	and	CC
18637	10762	25	the	the	DT
18637	10762	26	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10762	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10762	28	can	can	MD
18637	10762	29	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	10762	30	only	only	RB
18637	10762	31	that	that	DT
18637	10762	32	power	power	NN
18637	10762	33	,	,	,
18637	10762	34	the	the	DT
18637	10762	35	latter	latter	JJ
18637	10762	36	nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
18637	10762	37	can	can	MD
18637	10762	38	review	review	VB
18637	10762	39	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	10762	40	of	of	IN
18637	10762	41	the	the	DT
18637	10762	42	former	former	JJ
18637	10762	43	.	.	.
18637	10763	1	However	however	RB
18637	10763	2	,	,	,
18637	10763	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10763	4	should	should	MD
18637	10763	5	be	be	VB
18637	10763	6	emphasized	emphasize	VBN
18637	10763	7	that	that	IN
18637	10763	8	the	the	DT
18637	10763	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10763	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10763	11	will	will	MD
18637	10763	12	neither	neither	CC
18637	10763	13	review	review	VB
18637	10763	14	the	the	DT
18637	10763	15	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	10763	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10763	17	of	of	IN
18637	10763	18	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10763	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	10763	20	nor	nor	CC
18637	10763	21	entertain	entertain	JJ
18637	10763	22	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	10763	23	from	from	IN
18637	10763	24	the	the	DT
18637	10763	25	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	10763	26	or	or	CC
18637	10763	27	interlocutory	interlocutory	JJ
18637	10763	28	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	10763	29	of	of	IN
18637	10763	30	such	such	JJ
18637	10763	31	courts	court	NNS
18637	10763	32	.	.	.
18637	10764	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10764	2	131	131	CD
18637	10764	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10764	4	STATUS	STATUS	NNP
18637	10764	5	OF	of	IN
18637	10764	6	THE	the	DT
18637	10764	7	COURTS	COURTS	NNP
18637	10764	8	OF	of	IN
18637	10764	9	THE	the	DT
18637	10764	10	DISTRICT	district	NN
18637	10764	11	OF	of	IN
18637	10764	12	COLUMBIA	columbia	NN
18637	10764	13	Through	through	IN
18637	10764	14	a	a	DT
18637	10764	15	long	long	JJ
18637	10764	16	course	course	NN
18637	10764	17	of	of	IN
18637	10764	18	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	10764	19	the	the	DT
18637	10764	20	courts	court	NNS
18637	10764	21	of	of	IN
18637	10764	22	the	the	DT
18637	10764	23	District	District	NNP
18637	10764	24	of	of	IN
18637	10764	25	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	10764	26	were	be	VBD
18637	10764	27	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	10764	28	as	as	IN
18637	10764	29	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10764	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	10764	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	10764	32	which	which	WDT
18637	10764	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10764	34	could	could	MD
18637	10764	35	impose	impose	VB
18637	10764	36	nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	10764	37	functions	function	NNS
18637	10764	38	.	.	.
18637	10765	1	In	in	IN
18637	10765	2	Butterworth	Butterworth	NNP
18637	10765	3	_	_	NNP
18637	10765	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	10765	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10765	6	United	United	NNP
18637	10765	7	States	States	NNP
18637	10765	8	ex	ex	NNP
18637	10765	9	rel	rel	NN
18637	10765	10	.	.	.
18637	10766	1	Hoe,[132	Hoe,[132	NNP
18637	10766	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10766	3	the	the	DT
18637	10766	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10766	5	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	10766	6	an	an	DT
18637	10766	7	act	act	NN
18637	10766	8	of	of	IN
18637	10766	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10766	10	which	which	WDT
18637	10766	11	conferred	confer	VBD
18637	10766	12	revisionary	revisionary	JJ
18637	10766	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	10766	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	10766	15	the	the	DT
18637	10766	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10766	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10766	18	of	of	IN
18637	10766	19	the	the	DT
18637	10766	20	District	District	NNP
18637	10766	21	in	in	IN
18637	10766	22	patent	patent	NN
18637	10766	23	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	10766	24	and	and	CC
18637	10766	25	made	make	VBD
18637	10766	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10766	27	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	10766	28	binding	bind	VBG
18637	10766	29	only	only	RB
18637	10766	30	upon	upon	IN
18637	10766	31	the	the	DT
18637	10766	32	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	10766	33	of	of	IN
18637	10766	34	Patents	Patents	NNPS
18637	10766	35	.	.	.
18637	10767	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	10767	2	,	,	,
18637	10767	3	the	the	DT
18637	10767	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10767	5	later	later	RB
18637	10767	6	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	10767	7	the	the	DT
18637	10767	8	authority	authority	NN
18637	10767	9	of	of	IN
18637	10767	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10767	11	to	to	TO
18637	10767	12	vest	vest	VB
18637	10767	13	revisionary	revisionary	JJ
18637	10767	14	powers	power	NNS
18637	10767	15	in	in	IN
18637	10767	16	the	the	DT
18637	10767	17	same	same	JJ
18637	10767	18	court	court	NN
18637	10767	19	over	over	IN
18637	10767	20	rates	rate	NNS
18637	10767	21	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	10767	22	by	by	IN
18637	10767	23	a	a	DT
18637	10767	24	public	public	JJ
18637	10767	25	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	10767	26	commission	commission	NN
18637	10767	27	.	.	.
18637	10768	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10768	2	133	133	CD
18637	10768	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10768	4	Not	not	RB
18637	10768	5	long	long	RB
18637	10768	6	after	after	IN
18637	10768	7	this	this	DT
18637	10768	8	the	the	DT
18637	10768	9	same	same	JJ
18637	10768	10	rule	rule	NN
18637	10768	11	was	be	VBD
18637	10768	12	applied	apply	VBN
18637	10768	13	to	to	IN
18637	10768	14	the	the	DT
18637	10768	15	revisionary	revisionary	JJ
18637	10768	16	power	power	NN
18637	10768	17	of	of	IN
18637	10768	18	the	the	DT
18637	10768	19	District	District	NNP
18637	10768	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10768	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10768	22	over	over	IN
18637	10768	23	orders	order	NNS
18637	10768	24	of	of	IN
18637	10768	25	the	the	DT
18637	10768	26	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10768	27	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	10768	28	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	10768	29	.	.	.
18637	10769	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10769	2	134	134	CD
18637	10769	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10769	4	These	these	DT
18637	10769	5	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	10769	6	were	be	VBD
18637	10769	7	based	base	VBN
18637	10769	8	on	on	IN
18637	10769	9	the	the	DT
18637	10769	10	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	10769	11	,	,	,
18637	10769	12	express	express	JJ
18637	10769	13	or	or	CC
18637	10769	14	implied	imply	VBN
18637	10769	15	,	,	,
18637	10769	16	that	that	IN
18637	10769	17	the	the	DT
18637	10769	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	10769	19	of	of	IN
18637	10769	20	the	the	DT
18637	10769	21	District	District	NNP
18637	10769	22	were	be	VBD
18637	10769	23	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10769	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	10769	25	,	,	,
18637	10769	26	created	create	VBN
18637	10769	27	by	by	IN
18637	10769	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10769	29	in	in	IN
18637	10769	30	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	10769	31	of	of	IN
18637	10769	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10769	33	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	10769	34	power	power	NN
18637	10769	35	to	to	TO
18637	10769	36	govern	govern	VB
18637	10769	37	the	the	DT
18637	10769	38	District	District	NNP
18637	10769	39	of	of	IN
18637	10769	40	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	10769	41	.	.	.
18637	10770	1	In	in	IN
18637	10770	2	an	an	DT
18637	10770	3	obiter	obiter	NN
18637	10770	4	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	10770	5	in	in	IN
18637	10770	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	10770	7	parte	parte	NN
18637	10770	8	Bakelite	Bakelite	NNP
18637	10770	9	Corporation,[135	Corporation,[135	NNP
18637	10770	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10770	11	while	while	IN
18637	10770	12	reviewing	review	VBG
18637	10770	13	the	the	DT
18637	10770	14	history	history	NN
18637	10770	15	and	and	CC
18637	10770	16	analyzing	analyze	VBG
18637	10770	17	the	the	DT
18637	10770	18	nature	nature	NN
18637	10770	19	of	of	IN
18637	10770	20	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10770	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	10770	22	,	,	,
18637	10770	23	the	the	DT
18637	10770	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10770	25	stated	state	VBD
18637	10770	26	that	that	IN
18637	10770	27	the	the	DT
18637	10770	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	10770	29	of	of	IN
18637	10770	30	the	the	DT
18637	10770	31	District	District	NNP
18637	10770	32	were	be	VBD
18637	10770	33	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10770	34	courts	court	NNS
18637	10770	35	.	.	.
18637	10771	1	In	in	IN
18637	10771	2	1933	1933	CD
18637	10771	3	,	,	,
18637	10771	4	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	10771	5	,	,	,
18637	10771	6	the	the	DT
18637	10771	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10771	8	,	,	,
18637	10771	9	abandoning	abandon	VBG
18637	10771	10	all	all	DT
18637	10771	11	previous	previous	JJ
18637	10771	12	dicta	dicta	NN
18637	10771	13	on	on	IN
18637	10771	14	the	the	DT
18637	10771	15	subject	subject	NN
18637	10771	16	,	,	,
18637	10771	17	found	find	VBD
18637	10771	18	the	the	DT
18637	10771	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	10771	20	of	of	IN
18637	10771	21	the	the	DT
18637	10771	22	District	District	NNP
18637	10771	23	of	of	IN
18637	10771	24	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	10771	25	to	to	TO
18637	10771	26	be	be	VB
18637	10771	27	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10771	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	10771	29	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	10771	30	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10771	31	power	power	NN
18637	10771	32	of	of	IN
18637	10771	33	the	the	DT
18637	10771	34	United	United	NNP
18637	10771	35	States,[136	States,[136	NNP
18637	10771	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10771	37	with	with	IN
18637	10771	38	the	the	DT
18637	10771	39	result	result	NN
18637	10771	40	of	of	IN
18637	10771	41	shouldering	shoulder	VBG
18637	10771	42	the	the	DT
18637	10771	43	task	task	NN
18637	10771	44	of	of	IN
18637	10771	45	reconciling	reconcile	VBG
18637	10771	46	the	the	DT
18637	10771	47	performance	performance	NN
18637	10771	48	of	of	IN
18637	10771	49	nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	10771	50	functions	function	NNS
18637	10771	51	by	by	IN
18637	10771	52	such	such	JJ
18637	10771	53	courts	court	NNS
18637	10771	54	with	with	IN
18637	10771	55	the	the	DT
18637	10771	56	rule	rule	NN
18637	10771	57	that	that	IN
18637	10771	58	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10771	59	courts	court	NNS
18637	10771	60	can	can	MD
18637	10771	61	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	10771	62	only	only	RB
18637	10771	63	the	the	DT
18637	10771	64	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10771	65	power	power	NN
18637	10771	66	of	of	IN
18637	10771	67	the	the	DT
18637	10771	68	United	United	NNP
18637	10771	69	States	States	NNP
18637	10771	70	.	.	.
18637	10772	1	This	this	DT
18637	10772	2	task	task	NN
18637	10772	3	was	be	VBD
18637	10772	4	easily	easily	RB
18637	10772	5	accomplished	accomplish	VBN
18637	10772	6	by	by	IN
18637	10772	7	the	the	DT
18637	10772	8	argument	argument	NN
18637	10772	9	that	that	IN
18637	10772	10	in	in	IN
18637	10772	11	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	10772	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	10772	13	for	for	IN
18637	10772	14	the	the	DT
18637	10772	15	District	District	NNP
18637	10772	16	,	,	,
18637	10772	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10772	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	10772	19	performing	perform	VBG
18637	10772	20	dual	dual	JJ
18637	10772	21	functions	function	NNS
18637	10772	22	in	in	IN
18637	10772	23	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	10772	24	of	of	IN
18637	10772	25	two	two	CD
18637	10772	26	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	10772	27	powers	power	NNS
18637	10772	28	,	,	,
18637	10772	29	the	the	DT
18637	10772	30	power	power	NN
18637	10772	31	to	to	TO
18637	10772	32	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	10772	33	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	10772	34	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	10772	35	to	to	IN
18637	10772	36	the	the	DT
18637	10772	37	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10772	38	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10772	39	,	,	,
18637	10772	40	and	and	CC
18637	10772	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10772	42	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	10772	43	and	and	CC
18637	10772	44	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	10772	45	power	power	NN
18637	10772	46	to	to	TO
18637	10772	47	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	10772	48	for	for	IN
18637	10772	49	the	the	DT
18637	10772	50	District	District	NNP
18637	10772	51	of	of	IN
18637	10772	52	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	10772	53	.	.	.
18637	10773	1	However	however	RB
18637	10773	2	,	,	,
18637	10773	3	article	article	NN
18637	10773	4	III	iii	CD
18637	10773	5	,	,	,
18637	10773	6	§	§	NNP
18637	10773	7	1	1	CD
18637	10773	8	,	,	,
18637	10773	9	limits	limit	VBZ
18637	10773	10	this	this	DT
18637	10773	11	latter	latter	JJ
18637	10773	12	power	power	NN
18637	10773	13	with	with	IN
18637	10773	14	respect	respect	NN
18637	10773	15	to	to	IN
18637	10773	16	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	10773	17	and	and	CC
18637	10773	18	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	10773	19	,	,	,
18637	10773	20	but	but	CC
18637	10773	21	not	not	RB
18637	10773	22	with	with	IN
18637	10773	23	regard	regard	NN
18637	10773	24	to	to	IN
18637	10773	25	vesting	vest	VBG
18637	10773	26	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10773	27	and	and	CC
18637	10773	28	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	10773	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	10773	30	in	in	IN
18637	10773	31	such	such	JJ
18637	10773	32	courts	court	NNS
18637	10773	33	.	.	.
18637	10774	1	Subject	subject	JJ
18637	10774	2	to	to	IN
18637	10774	3	the	the	DT
18637	10774	4	guarantees	guarantee	NNS
18637	10774	5	of	of	IN
18637	10774	6	personal	personal	JJ
18637	10774	7	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	10774	8	in	in	IN
18637	10774	9	the	the	DT
18637	10774	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10774	11	,	,	,
18637	10774	12	"	"	``
18637	10774	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10774	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	10774	15	as	as	RB
18637	10774	16	much	much	JJ
18637	10774	17	power	power	NN
18637	10774	18	to	to	TO
18637	10774	19	vest	vest	VB
18637	10774	20	courts	court	NNS
18637	10774	21	of	of	IN
18637	10774	22	the	the	DT
18637	10774	23	District	District	NNP
18637	10774	24	with	with	IN
18637	10774	25	a	a	DT
18637	10774	26	variety	variety	NN
18637	10774	27	of	of	IN
18637	10774	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10774	29	and	and	CC
18637	10774	30	powers	power	NNS
18637	10774	31	as	as	IN
18637	10774	32	a	a	DT
18637	10774	33	State	State	NNP
18637	10774	34	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	10774	35	has	have	VBZ
18637	10774	36	in	in	IN
18637	10774	37	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	10774	38	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10774	39	on	on	IN
18637	10774	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10774	41	courts	court	NNS
18637	10774	42	.	.	.
18637	10775	1	"	"	``
18637	10775	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10775	3	137	137	CD
18637	10775	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10775	5	The	the	DT
18637	10775	6	effect	effect	NN
18637	10775	7	of	of	IN
18637	10775	8	the	the	DT
18637	10775	9	O'Donoghue	O'Donoghue	NNP
18637	10775	10	decision	decision	NN
18637	10775	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	10775	12	to	to	TO
18637	10775	13	confer	confer	VB
18637	10775	14	a	a	DT
18637	10775	15	dual	dual	JJ
18637	10775	16	status	status	NN
18637	10775	17	on	on	IN
18637	10775	18	the	the	DT
18637	10775	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	10775	20	of	of	IN
18637	10775	21	the	the	DT
18637	10775	22	District	District	NNP
18637	10775	23	of	of	IN
18637	10775	24	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	10775	25	.	.	.
18637	10776	1	As	as	IN
18637	10776	2	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	10776	3	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10776	4	organization	organization	NN
18637	10776	5	,	,	,
18637	10776	6	and	and	CC
18637	10776	7	the	the	DT
18637	10776	8	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	10776	9	and	and	CC
18637	10776	10	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	10776	11	of	of	IN
18637	10776	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10776	13	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10776	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10776	15	are	be	VBP
18637	10776	16	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10776	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	10776	18	,	,	,
18637	10776	19	as	as	IN
18637	10776	20	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	10776	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10776	22	and	and	CC
18637	10776	23	powers	power	NNS
18637	10776	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10776	25	are	be	VBP
18637	10776	26	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
18637	10776	27	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10776	28	and	and	CC
18637	10776	29	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10776	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	10776	31	,	,	,
18637	10776	32	and	and	CC
18637	10776	33	as	as	IN
18637	10776	34	such	such	JJ
18637	10776	35	can	can	MD
18637	10776	36	be	be	VB
18637	10776	37	vested	vest	VBN
18637	10776	38	with	with	IN
18637	10776	39	nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	10776	40	powers	power	NNS
18637	10776	41	while	while	IN
18637	10776	42	sharing	share	VBG
18637	10776	43	the	the	DT
18637	10776	44	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10776	45	power	power	NN
18637	10776	46	of	of	IN
18637	10776	47	the	the	DT
18637	10776	48	United	United	NNP
18637	10776	49	States	States	NNP
18637	10776	50	.	.	.
18637	10777	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10777	2	138	138	CD
18637	10777	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10777	4	Jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10777	5	:	:	:
18637	10777	6	Cases	case	NNS
18637	10777	7	and	and	CC
18637	10777	8	Controversies	Controversies	NNPS
18637	10777	9	Section	Section	NNP
18637	10777	10	2	2	CD
18637	10777	11	.	.	.
18637	10778	1	The	the	DT
18637	10778	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10778	3	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10778	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	10778	5	extend	extend	VB
18637	10778	6	to	to	IN
18637	10778	7	all	all	DT
18637	10778	8	Cases	case	NNS
18637	10778	9	,	,	,
18637	10778	10	in	in	IN
18637	10778	11	Law	Law	NNP
18637	10778	12	and	and	CC
18637	10778	13	Equity	Equity	NNP
18637	10778	14	,	,	,
18637	10778	15	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10778	16	under	under	IN
18637	10778	17	this	this	DT
18637	10778	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10778	19	,	,	,
18637	10778	20	the	the	DT
18637	10778	21	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	10778	22	of	of	IN
18637	10778	23	the	the	DT
18637	10778	24	United	United	NNP
18637	10778	25	States	States	NNP
18637	10778	26	,	,	,
18637	10778	27	and	and	CC
18637	10778	28	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	10778	29	made	make	VBD
18637	10778	30	,	,	,
18637	10778	31	or	or	CC
18637	10778	32	which	which	WDT
18637	10778	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	10778	34	be	be	VB
18637	10778	35	made	make	VBN
18637	10778	36	,	,	,
18637	10778	37	under	under	IN
18637	10778	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10778	39	Authority;--to	Authority;--to	NNP
18637	10778	40	all	all	DT
18637	10778	41	Cases	case	NNS
18637	10778	42	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	10778	43	Ambassadors	Ambassadors	NNPS
18637	10778	44	,	,	,
18637	10778	45	other	other	JJ
18637	10778	46	public	public	JJ
18637	10778	47	Ministers	Ministers	NNP
18637	10778	48	and	and	CC
18637	10778	49	Consuls;--to	Consuls;--to	NNP
18637	10778	50	all	all	DT
18637	10778	51	Cases	case	NNS
18637	10778	52	of	of	IN
18637	10778	53	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	10778	54	and	and	CC
18637	10778	55	maritime	maritime	NN
18637	10778	56	Jurisdiction;--to	Jurisdiction;--to	NNP
18637	10778	57	Controversies	Controversies	NNPS
18637	10778	58	to	to	TO
18637	10778	59	which	which	WDT
18637	10778	60	the	the	DT
18637	10778	61	United	United	NNP
18637	10778	62	States	States	NNP
18637	10778	63	shall	shall	MD
18637	10778	64	be	be	VB
18637	10778	65	a	a	DT
18637	10778	66	Party;--to	Party;--to	NNP
18637	10778	67	Controversies	Controversies	NNPS
18637	10778	68	between	between	IN
18637	10778	69	two	two	CD
18637	10778	70	or	or	CC
18637	10778	71	more	more	JJR
18637	10778	72	States;--between	states;--between	IN
18637	10778	73	a	a	DT
18637	10778	74	State	State	NNP
18637	10778	75	and	and	CC
18637	10778	76	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	10778	77	of	of	IN
18637	10778	78	another	another	DT
18637	10778	79	State;--between	State;--between	NNP
18637	10778	80	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	10778	81	of	of	IN
18637	10778	82	different	different	JJ
18637	10778	83	States;--between	states;--between	JJ
18637	10778	84	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	10778	85	of	of	IN
18637	10778	86	the	the	DT
18637	10778	87	same	same	JJ
18637	10778	88	State	State	NNP
18637	10778	89	claiming	claim	VBG
18637	10778	90	Lands	Lands	NNPS
18637	10778	91	under	under	IN
18637	10778	92	Grants	Grants	NNPS
18637	10778	93	of	of	IN
18637	10778	94	different	different	JJ
18637	10778	95	States	state	NNS
18637	10778	96	,	,	,
18637	10778	97	and	and	CC
18637	10778	98	between	between	IN
18637	10778	99	a	a	DT
18637	10778	100	State	state	NN
18637	10778	101	,	,	,
18637	10778	102	or	or	CC
18637	10778	103	the	the	DT
18637	10778	104	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	10778	105	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	10778	106	,	,	,
18637	10778	107	and	and	CC
18637	10778	108	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	10778	109	States	state	NNS
18637	10778	110	,	,	,
18637	10778	111	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	10778	112	or	or	CC
18637	10778	113	Subjects	subject	NNS
18637	10778	114	.	.	.
18637	10779	1	THE	the	DT
18637	10779	2	TWO	two	CD
18637	10779	3	CLASSES	class	NNS
18637	10779	4	OF	of	IN
18637	10779	5	CASES	case	NNS
18637	10779	6	AND	and	CC
18637	10779	7	CONTROVERSIES	controversy	NNS
18637	10779	8	By	by	IN
18637	10779	9	the	the	DT
18637	10779	10	terms	term	NNS
18637	10779	11	of	of	IN
18637	10779	12	the	the	DT
18637	10779	13	foregoing	foregoing	NN
18637	10779	14	section	section	NN
18637	10779	15	the	the	DT
18637	10779	16	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10779	17	power	power	NN
18637	10779	18	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	10779	19	to	to	IN
18637	10779	20	nine	nine	CD
18637	10779	21	classes	class	NNS
18637	10779	22	of	of	IN
18637	10779	23	cases	case	NNS
18637	10779	24	and	and	CC
18637	10779	25	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	10779	26	,	,	,
18637	10779	27	which	which	WDT
18637	10779	28	fall	fall	VBP
18637	10779	29	into	into	IN
18637	10779	30	two	two	CD
18637	10779	31	general	general	JJ
18637	10779	32	groups	group	NNS
18637	10779	33	.	.	.
18637	10780	1	In	in	IN
18637	10780	2	the	the	DT
18637	10780	3	words	word	NNS
18637	10780	4	of	of	IN
18637	10780	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10780	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10780	7	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	10780	8	in	in	IN
18637	10780	9	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	10780	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10780	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	10780	12	_	_	NNP
18637	10780	13	Virginia:[139	Virginia:[139	NNP
18637	10780	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10780	15	"	"	``
18637	10780	16	In	in	IN
18637	10780	17	the	the	DT
18637	10780	18	first	first	JJ
18637	10780	19	,	,	,
18637	10780	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10780	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10780	22	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	10780	23	on	on	IN
18637	10780	24	the	the	DT
18637	10780	25	character	character	NN
18637	10780	26	of	of	IN
18637	10780	27	the	the	DT
18637	10780	28	cause	cause	NN
18637	10780	29	,	,	,
18637	10780	30	whoever	whoever	WP
18637	10780	31	may	may	MD
18637	10780	32	be	be	VB
18637	10780	33	the	the	DT
18637	10780	34	parties	party	NNS
18637	10780	35	.	.	.
18637	10781	1	This	this	DT
18637	10781	2	class	class	NN
18637	10781	3	comprehends	comprehend	VBZ
18637	10781	4	'	'	``
18637	10781	5	all	all	DT
18637	10781	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	10781	7	in	in	IN
18637	10781	8	law	law	NN
18637	10781	9	and	and	CC
18637	10781	10	equity	equity	NN
18637	10781	11	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10781	12	under	under	IN
18637	10781	13	this	this	DT
18637	10781	14	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	10781	15	,	,	,
18637	10781	16	the	the	DT
18637	10781	17	laws	law	NNS
18637	10781	18	of	of	IN
18637	10781	19	the	the	DT
18637	10781	20	United	United	NNP
18637	10781	21	States	States	NNP
18637	10781	22	,	,	,
18637	10781	23	and	and	CC
18637	10781	24	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	10781	25	made	make	VBN
18637	10781	26	,	,	,
18637	10781	27	or	or	CC
18637	10781	28	which	which	WDT
18637	10781	29	shall	shall	MD
18637	10781	30	be	be	VB
18637	10781	31	made	make	VBN
18637	10781	32	,	,	,
18637	10781	33	under	under	IN
18637	10781	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10781	35	authority	authority	NN
18637	10781	36	.	.	.
18637	10781	37	'	'	''
18637	10782	1	This	this	DT
18637	10782	2	cause	cause	NN
18637	10782	3	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	10782	4	the	the	DT
18637	10782	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10782	6	of	of	IN
18637	10782	7	the	the	DT
18637	10782	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10782	9	to	to	IN
18637	10782	10	all	all	PDT
18637	10782	11	the	the	DT
18637	10782	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	10782	13	described	describe	VBN
18637	10782	14	,	,	,
18637	10782	15	without	without	IN
18637	10782	16	making	make	VBG
18637	10782	17	in	in	IN
18637	10782	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10782	19	terms	term	NNS
18637	10782	20	any	any	DT
18637	10782	21	exception	exception	NN
18637	10782	22	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	10782	23	,	,	,
18637	10782	24	and	and	CC
18637	10782	25	without	without	IN
18637	10782	26	any	any	DT
18637	10782	27	regard	regard	NN
18637	10782	28	to	to	IN
18637	10782	29	the	the	DT
18637	10782	30	condition	condition	NN
18637	10782	31	of	of	IN
18637	10782	32	the	the	DT
18637	10782	33	party	party	NN
18637	10782	34	.	.	.
18637	10783	1	If	if	IN
18637	10783	2	there	there	EX
18637	10783	3	be	be	VBP
18637	10783	4	any	any	DT
18637	10783	5	exception	exception	NN
18637	10783	6	,	,	,
18637	10783	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10783	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	10783	9	to	to	TO
18637	10783	10	be	be	VB
18637	10783	11	implied	imply	VBN
18637	10783	12	,	,	,
18637	10783	13	against	against	IN
18637	10783	14	the	the	DT
18637	10783	15	express	express	JJ
18637	10783	16	words	word	NNS
18637	10783	17	of	of	IN
18637	10783	18	the	the	DT
18637	10783	19	article	article	NN
18637	10783	20	.	.	.
18637	10784	1	In	in	IN
18637	10784	2	the	the	DT
18637	10784	3	second	second	JJ
18637	10784	4	class	class	NN
18637	10784	5	,	,	,
18637	10784	6	the	the	DT
18637	10784	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10784	8	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	10784	9	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	10784	10	on	on	IN
18637	10784	11	the	the	DT
18637	10784	12	character	character	NN
18637	10784	13	of	of	IN
18637	10784	14	the	the	DT
18637	10784	15	parties	party	NNS
18637	10784	16	.	.	.
18637	10785	1	In	in	IN
18637	10785	2	this	this	DT
18637	10785	3	are	be	VBP
18637	10785	4	comprehended	comprehend	VBN
18637	10785	5	'	'	''
18637	10785	6	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	10785	7	between	between	IN
18637	10785	8	two	two	CD
18637	10785	9	or	or	CC
18637	10785	10	more	more	JJR
18637	10785	11	States	States	NNPS
18637	10785	12	,	,	,
18637	10785	13	between	between	IN
18637	10785	14	a	a	DT
18637	10785	15	State	state	NN
18637	10785	16	and	and	CC
18637	10785	17	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	10785	18	of	of	IN
18637	10785	19	another	another	DT
18637	10785	20	State	state	NN
18637	10785	21	,	,	,
18637	10785	22	'	'	''
18637	10785	23	and	and	CC
18637	10785	24	'	'	''
18637	10785	25	between	between	IN
18637	10785	26	a	a	DT
18637	10785	27	State	state	NN
18637	10785	28	and	and	CC
18637	10785	29	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	10785	30	States	state	NNS
18637	10785	31	,	,	,
18637	10785	32	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	10785	33	or	or	CC
18637	10785	34	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	10785	35	.	.	.
18637	10785	36	'	'	''
18637	10786	1	If	if	IN
18637	10786	2	these	these	DT
18637	10786	3	be	be	VBP
18637	10786	4	the	the	DT
18637	10786	5	parties	party	NNS
18637	10786	6	,	,	,
18637	10786	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10786	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	10786	9	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	10786	10	unimportant	unimportant	JJ
18637	10786	11	,	,	,
18637	10786	12	what	what	WP
18637	10786	13	may	may	MD
18637	10786	14	be	be	VB
18637	10786	15	the	the	DT
18637	10786	16	subject	subject	NN
18637	10786	17	of	of	IN
18637	10786	18	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10786	19	.	.	.
18637	10787	1	Be	be	VB
18637	10787	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10787	3	what	what	WP
18637	10787	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10787	5	may	may	MD
18637	10787	6	,	,	,
18637	10787	7	these	these	DT
18637	10787	8	parties	party	NNS
18637	10787	9	have	have	VBP
18637	10787	10	a	a	DT
18637	10787	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10787	12	right	right	NN
18637	10787	13	to	to	TO
18637	10787	14	come	come	VB
18637	10787	15	into	into	IN
18637	10787	16	the	the	DT
18637	10787	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	10787	18	of	of	IN
18637	10787	19	the	the	DT
18637	10787	20	Union	Union	NNP
18637	10787	21	.	.	.
18637	10788	1	"	"	``
18637	10788	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10788	3	140	140	CD
18637	10788	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10788	5	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10788	6	power	power	NN
18637	10788	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	10788	8	"	"	``
18637	10788	9	the	the	DT
18637	10788	10	power	power	NN
18637	10788	11	of	of	IN
18637	10788	12	a	a	DT
18637	10788	13	court	court	NN
18637	10788	14	to	to	TO
18637	10788	15	decide	decide	VB
18637	10788	16	and	and	CC
18637	10788	17	pronounce	pronounce	VB
18637	10788	18	a	a	DT
18637	10788	19	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10788	20	and	and	CC
18637	10788	21	carry	carry	VB
18637	10788	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10788	23	into	into	IN
18637	10788	24	effect	effect	NN
18637	10788	25	between	between	IN
18637	10788	26	persons	person	NNS
18637	10788	27	and	and	CC
18637	10788	28	parties	party	NNS
18637	10788	29	who	who	WP
18637	10788	30	bring	bring	VBP
18637	10788	31	a	a	DT
18637	10788	32	case	case	NN
18637	10788	33	before	before	IN
18637	10788	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10788	35	for	for	IN
18637	10788	36	decision	decision	NN
18637	10788	37	.	.	.
18637	10789	1	"	"	``
18637	10789	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10789	3	141	141	CD
18637	10789	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10789	5	The	the	DT
18637	10789	6	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	10789	7	attached	attach	VBN
18637	10789	8	to	to	IN
18637	10789	9	the	the	DT
18637	10789	10	terms	term	NNS
18637	10789	11	"	"	``
18637	10789	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	10789	13	"	"	''
18637	10789	14	and	and	CC
18637	10789	15	"	"	``
18637	10789	16	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	10789	17	"	"	''
18637	10789	18	determines	determine	VBZ
18637	10789	19	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	10789	20	the	the	DT
18637	10789	21	extent	extent	NN
18637	10789	22	of	of	IN
18637	10789	23	the	the	DT
18637	10789	24	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10789	25	power	power	NN
18637	10789	26	,	,	,
18637	10789	27	as	as	RB
18637	10789	28	well	well	RB
18637	10789	29	as	as	IN
18637	10789	30	the	the	DT
18637	10789	31	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	10789	32	of	of	IN
18637	10789	33	the	the	DT
18637	10789	34	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10789	35	courts	court	NNS
18637	10789	36	to	to	TO
18637	10789	37	receive	receive	VB
18637	10789	38	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10789	39	.	.	.
18637	10790	1	As	as	IN
18637	10790	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10790	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10790	4	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	10790	5	declared	declare	VBD
18637	10790	6	in	in	IN
18637	10790	7	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	10790	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10790	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	10790	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10790	11	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	10790	12	of	of	IN
18637	10790	13	the	the	DT
18637	10790	14	United	United	NNP
18637	10790	15	States	States	NNP
18637	10790	16	,	,	,
18637	10790	17	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10790	18	power	power	NN
18637	10790	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	10790	20	capable	capable	JJ
18637	10790	21	of	of	IN
18637	10790	22	acting	act	VBG
18637	10790	23	only	only	RB
18637	10790	24	when	when	WRB
18637	10790	25	the	the	DT
18637	10790	26	subject	subject	NN
18637	10790	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	10790	28	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	10790	29	in	in	IN
18637	10790	30	a	a	DT
18637	10790	31	case	case	NN
18637	10790	32	,	,	,
18637	10790	33	and	and	CC
18637	10790	34	a	a	DT
18637	10790	35	case	case	NN
18637	10790	36	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	10790	37	only	only	RB
18637	10790	38	when	when	WRB
18637	10790	39	a	a	DT
18637	10790	40	party	party	NN
18637	10790	41	asserts	assert	VBZ
18637	10790	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10790	43	rights	right	NNS
18637	10790	44	"	"	''
18637	10790	45	in	in	IN
18637	10790	46	a	a	DT
18637	10790	47	form	form	NN
18637	10790	48	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	10790	49	by	by	IN
18637	10790	50	law	law	NN
18637	10790	51	.	.	.
18637	10791	1	"	"	``
18637	10791	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10791	3	142	142	CD
18637	10791	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10791	5	Many	many	JJ
18637	10791	6	years	year	NNS
18637	10791	7	later	later	RBR
18637	10791	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10791	9	Field	Field	NNP
18637	10791	10	,	,	,
18637	10791	11	relying	rely	VBG
18637	10791	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	10791	13	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
18637	10791	14	_	_	NNP
18637	10791	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	10791	16	_	_	NNP
18637	10791	17	Georgia,[143	Georgia,[143	NNP
18637	10791	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10791	19	and	and	CC
18637	10791	20	Tucker	Tucker	NNP
18637	10791	21	's	's	POS
18637	10791	22	edition	edition	NN
18637	10791	23	of	of	IN
18637	10791	24	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
18637	10791	25	,	,	,
18637	10791	26	amended	amend	VBD
18637	10791	27	this	this	DT
18637	10791	28	definition	definition	NN
18637	10791	29	by	by	IN
18637	10791	30	holding	hold	VBG
18637	10791	31	that	that	IN
18637	10791	32	"	"	``
18637	10791	33	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	10791	34	,	,	,
18637	10791	35	"	"	''
18637	10791	36	to	to	IN
18637	10791	37	the	the	DT
18637	10791	38	extent	extent	NN
18637	10791	39	that	that	WDT
18637	10791	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10791	41	differ	differ	VBP
18637	10791	42	from	from	IN
18637	10791	43	"	"	``
18637	10791	44	cases	case	NNS
18637	10791	45	,	,	,
18637	10791	46	"	"	''
18637	10791	47	include	include	VBP
18637	10791	48	only	only	JJ
18637	10791	49	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10791	50	of	of	IN
18637	10791	51	a	a	DT
18637	10791	52	civil	civil	JJ
18637	10791	53	nature	nature	NN
18637	10791	54	.	.	.
18637	10792	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10792	2	continued	continue	VBD
18637	10792	3	:	:	:
18637	10792	4	"	"	``
18637	10792	5	By	by	IN
18637	10792	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	10792	7	and	and	CC
18637	10792	8	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	10792	9	are	be	VBP
18637	10792	10	intended	intend	VBN
18637	10792	11	the	the	DT
18637	10792	12	claims	claim	NNS
18637	10792	13	of	of	IN
18637	10792	14	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	10792	15	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10792	16	before	before	RB
18637	10792	17	the	the	DT
18637	10792	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	10792	19	for	for	IN
18637	10792	20	determination	determination	NN
18637	10792	21	by	by	IN
18637	10792	22	such	such	JJ
18637	10792	23	regular	regular	JJ
18637	10792	24	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10792	25	as	as	IN
18637	10792	26	are	be	VBP
18637	10792	27	established	establish	VBN
18637	10792	28	by	by	IN
18637	10792	29	law	law	NN
18637	10792	30	or	or	CC
18637	10792	31	custom	custom	NN
18637	10792	32	for	for	IN
18637	10792	33	the	the	DT
18637	10792	34	protection	protection	NN
18637	10792	35	or	or	CC
18637	10792	36	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10792	37	of	of	IN
18637	10792	38	rights	right	NNS
18637	10792	39	,	,	,
18637	10792	40	or	or	CC
18637	10792	41	the	the	DT
18637	10792	42	prevention	prevention	NN
18637	10792	43	,	,	,
18637	10792	44	redress	redress	NN
18637	10792	45	,	,	,
18637	10792	46	or	or	CC
18637	10792	47	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	10792	48	of	of	IN
18637	10792	49	wrongs	wrong	NNS
18637	10792	50	.	.	.
18637	10793	1	Whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	10793	2	the	the	DT
18637	10793	3	claim	claim	NN
18637	10793	4	of	of	IN
18637	10793	5	a	a	DT
18637	10793	6	party	party	NN
18637	10793	7	under	under	IN
18637	10793	8	the	the	DT
18637	10793	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10793	10	,	,	,
18637	10793	11	laws	law	NNS
18637	10793	12	,	,	,
18637	10793	13	or	or	CC
18637	10793	14	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	10793	15	of	of	IN
18637	10793	16	the	the	DT
18637	10793	17	United	United	NNP
18637	10793	18	States	States	NNP
18637	10793	19	takes	take	VBZ
18637	10793	20	such	such	PDT
18637	10793	21	a	a	DT
18637	10793	22	form	form	NN
18637	10793	23	that	that	WDT
18637	10793	24	the	the	DT
18637	10793	25	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10793	26	power	power	NN
18637	10793	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	10793	28	capable	capable	JJ
18637	10793	29	of	of	IN
18637	10793	30	acting	act	VBG
18637	10793	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	10793	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10793	33	,	,	,
18637	10793	34	then	then	RB
18637	10793	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10793	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	10793	37	become	become	VBN
18637	10793	38	a	a	DT
18637	10793	39	case	case	NN
18637	10793	40	.	.	.
18637	10794	1	The	the	DT
18637	10794	2	term	term	NN
18637	10794	3	implies	imply	VBZ
18637	10794	4	the	the	DT
18637	10794	5	existence	existence	NN
18637	10794	6	of	of	IN
18637	10794	7	present	present	JJ
18637	10794	8	or	or	CC
18637	10794	9	possible	possible	JJ
18637	10794	10	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	10794	11	parties	party	NNS
18637	10794	12	whose	whose	WP$
18637	10794	13	contentions	contention	NNS
18637	10794	14	are	be	VBP
18637	10794	15	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	10794	16	to	to	IN
18637	10794	17	the	the	DT
18637	10794	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10794	19	for	for	IN
18637	10794	20	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	10794	21	.	.	.
18637	10795	1	"	"	``
18637	10795	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10795	3	144	144	CD
18637	10795	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10795	5	The	the	DT
18637	10795	6	definitions	definition	NNS
18637	10795	7	propounded	propound	VBN
18637	10795	8	by	by	IN
18637	10795	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10795	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10795	11	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	10795	12	and	and	CC
18637	10795	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10795	14	Field	Field	NNP
18637	10795	15	were	be	VBD
18637	10795	16	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	10795	17	with	with	IN
18637	10795	18	approval	approval	NN
18637	10795	19	in	in	IN
18637	10795	20	Muskrat	Muskrat	NNP
18637	10795	21	_	_	NNP
18637	10795	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	10795	23	_	_	NNP
18637	10795	24	United	United	NNP
18637	10795	25	States,[145	States,[145	NNP
18637	10795	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10795	27	where	where	WRB
18637	10795	28	the	the	DT
18637	10795	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10795	30	held	hold	VBD
18637	10795	31	that	that	IN
18637	10795	32	the	the	DT
18637	10795	33	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10795	34	of	of	IN
18637	10795	35	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10795	36	power	power	NN
18637	10795	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	10795	38	limited	limit	VBN
18637	10795	39	to	to	IN
18637	10795	40	cases	case	NNS
18637	10795	41	and	and	CC
18637	10795	42	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	10795	43	and	and	CC
18637	10795	44	emphasized	emphasize	VBD
18637	10795	45	"	"	``
18637	10795	46	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	10795	47	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	10795	48	,	,	,
18637	10795	49	"	"	''
18637	10795	50	"	"	``
18637	10795	51	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	10795	52	interests	interest	NNS
18637	10795	53	,	,	,
18637	10795	54	"	"	''
18637	10795	55	an	an	DT
18637	10795	56	"	"	``
18637	10795	57	actual	actual	JJ
18637	10795	58	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10795	59	,	,	,
18637	10795	60	"	"	''
18637	10795	61	and	and	CC
18637	10795	62	conclusiveness	conclusiveness	NN
18637	10795	63	or	or	CC
18637	10795	64	finality	finality	NN
18637	10795	65	of	of	IN
18637	10795	66	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10795	67	as	as	IN
18637	10795	68	essential	essential	JJ
18637	10795	69	elements	element	NNS
18637	10795	70	of	of	IN
18637	10795	71	a	a	DT
18637	10795	72	case	case	NN
18637	10795	73	.	.	.
18637	10796	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10796	2	146	146	CD
18637	10796	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10796	4	ADVERSE	adverse	JJ
18637	10796	5	LITIGANTS	LITIGANTS	NNP
18637	10796	6	The	the	DT
18637	10796	7	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	10796	8	of	of	IN
18637	10796	9	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	10796	10	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	10796	11	with	with	IN
18637	10796	12	real	real	JJ
18637	10796	13	interests	interest	NNS
18637	10796	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	10796	15	been	be	VBN
18637	10796	16	stressed	stress	VBN
18637	10796	17	in	in	IN
18637	10796	18	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	10796	19	cases,[147	cases,[147	NN
18637	10796	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10796	21	and	and	CC
18637	10796	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	10796	23	been	be	VBN
18637	10796	24	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	10796	25	emphasized	emphasize	VBN
18637	10796	26	in	in	IN
18637	10796	27	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10796	28	to	to	TO
18637	10796	29	contest	contest	VB
18637	10796	30	the	the	DT
18637	10796	31	validity	validity	NN
18637	10796	32	of	of	IN
18637	10796	33	a	a	DT
18637	10796	34	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10796	35	or	or	CC
18637	10796	36	State	state	NN
18637	10796	37	statute	statute	NN
18637	10796	38	.	.	.
18637	10797	1	A	a	DT
18637	10797	2	few	few	JJ
18637	10797	3	illustrations	illustration	NNS
18637	10797	4	will	will	MD
18637	10797	5	suffice	suffice	VB
18637	10797	6	to	to	TO
18637	10797	7	describe	describe	VB
18637	10797	8	the	the	DT
18637	10797	9	practical	practical	JJ
18637	10797	10	operation	operation	NN
18637	10797	11	of	of	IN
18637	10797	12	these	these	DT
18637	10797	13	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	10797	14	.	.	.
18637	10798	1	In	in	IN
18637	10798	2	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	10798	3	and	and	CC
18637	10798	4	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	10798	5	Trunk	Trunk	NNP
18637	10798	6	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	10798	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10798	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10798	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	10798	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10798	11	Wellman,[148	Wellman,[148	NNP
18637	10798	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10798	13	which	which	WDT
18637	10798	14	originated	originate	VBD
18637	10798	15	in	in	IN
18637	10798	16	the	the	DT
18637	10798	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	10798	18	of	of	IN
18637	10798	19	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	10798	20	on	on	IN
18637	10798	21	an	an	DT
18637	10798	22	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	10798	23	statement	statement	NN
18637	10798	24	of	of	IN
18637	10798	25	facts	fact	NNS
18637	10798	26	between	between	IN
18637	10798	27	friendly	friendly	JJ
18637	10798	28	parties	party	NNS
18637	10798	29	desiring	desire	VBG
18637	10798	30	to	to	TO
18637	10798	31	contest	contest	VB
18637	10798	32	a	a	DT
18637	10798	33	rate	rate	NN
18637	10798	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	10798	35	making	make	VBG
18637	10798	36	statute	statute	NN
18637	10798	37	,	,	,
18637	10798	38	the	the	DT
18637	10798	39	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10798	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10798	41	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	10798	42	there	there	EX
18637	10798	43	was	be	VBD
18637	10798	44	no	no	DT
18637	10798	45	case	case	NN
18637	10798	46	or	or	CC
18637	10798	47	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10798	48	.	.	.
18637	10799	1	In	in	IN
18637	10799	2	the	the	DT
18637	10799	3	course	course	NN
18637	10799	4	of	of	IN
18637	10799	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10799	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10799	7	,	,	,
18637	10799	8	which	which	WDT
18637	10799	9	held	hold	VBD
18637	10799	10	that	that	IN
18637	10799	11	the	the	DT
18637	10799	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	10799	13	have	have	VBP
18637	10799	14	no	no	DT
18637	10799	15	"	"	``
18637	10799	16	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	10799	17	and	and	CC
18637	10799	18	general	general	JJ
18637	10799	19	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	10799	20	"	"	''
18637	10799	21	of	of	IN
18637	10799	22	the	the	DT
18637	10799	23	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	10799	24	of	of	IN
18637	10799	25	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10799	26	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	10799	27	,	,	,
18637	10799	28	the	the	DT
18637	10799	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10799	30	said	say	VBD
18637	10799	31	:	:	:
18637	10799	32	"	"	``
18637	10799	33	Whenever	Whenever	NNP
18637	10799	34	,	,	,
18637	10799	35	in	in	IN
18637	10799	36	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	10799	37	of	of	IN
18637	10799	38	an	an	DT
18637	10799	39	honest	honest	JJ
18637	10799	40	and	and	CC
18637	10799	41	actual	actual	JJ
18637	10799	42	antagonistic	antagonistic	JJ
18637	10799	43	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	10799	44	of	of	IN
18637	10799	45	rights	right	NNS
18637	10799	46	by	by	IN
18637	10799	47	one	one	CD
18637	10799	48	individual	individual	NN
18637	10799	49	against	against	IN
18637	10799	50	another	another	DT
18637	10799	51	,	,	,
18637	10799	52	there	there	EX
18637	10799	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	10799	54	presented	present	VBN
18637	10799	55	a	a	DT
18637	10799	56	question	question	NN
18637	10799	57	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10799	58	the	the	DT
18637	10799	59	validity	validity	NN
18637	10799	60	of	of	IN
18637	10799	61	any	any	DT
18637	10799	62	act	act	NN
18637	10799	63	of	of	IN
18637	10799	64	any	any	DT
18637	10799	65	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	10799	66	,	,	,
18637	10799	67	State	State	NNP
18637	10799	68	or	or	CC
18637	10799	69	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10799	70	,	,	,
18637	10799	71	and	and	CC
18637	10799	72	the	the	DT
18637	10799	73	decision	decision	NN
18637	10799	74	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	10799	75	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	10799	76	on	on	IN
18637	10799	77	the	the	DT
18637	10799	78	competency	competency	NN
18637	10799	79	of	of	IN
18637	10799	80	the	the	DT
18637	10799	81	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	10799	82	to	to	TO
18637	10799	83	so	so	RB
18637	10799	84	enact	enact	VB
18637	10799	85	,	,	,
18637	10799	86	the	the	DT
18637	10799	87	court	court	NN
18637	10799	88	must	must	MD
18637	10799	89	,	,	,
18637	10799	90	in	in	IN
18637	10799	91	the	the	DT
18637	10799	92	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10799	93	of	of	IN
18637	10799	94	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10799	95	solemn	solemn	JJ
18637	10799	96	duties	duty	NNS
18637	10799	97	,	,	,
18637	10799	98	determine	determine	VBP
18637	10799	99	whether	whether	IN
18637	10799	100	the	the	DT
18637	10799	101	act	act	NN
18637	10799	102	be	be	VB
18637	10799	103	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10799	104	or	or	CC
18637	10799	105	not	not	RB
18637	10799	106	;	;	:
18637	10799	107	but	but	CC
18637	10799	108	such	such	PDT
18637	10799	109	an	an	DT
18637	10799	110	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10799	111	of	of	IN
18637	10799	112	power	power	NN
18637	10799	113	is	be	VBZ
18637	10799	114	the	the	DT
18637	10799	115	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	10799	116	and	and	CC
18637	10799	117	supreme	supreme	JJ
18637	10799	118	function	function	NN
18637	10799	119	of	of	IN
18637	10799	120	courts	court	NNS
18637	10799	121	.	.	.
18637	10800	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10800	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	10800	3	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	10800	4	only	only	RB
18637	10800	5	in	in	IN
18637	10800	6	the	the	DT
18637	10800	7	last	last	JJ
18637	10800	8	resort	resort	NN
18637	10800	9	,	,	,
18637	10800	10	and	and	CC
18637	10800	11	as	as	IN
18637	10800	12	a	a	DT
18637	10800	13	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	10800	14	in	in	IN
18637	10800	15	the	the	DT
18637	10800	16	determination	determination	NN
18637	10800	17	of	of	IN
18637	10800	18	real	real	JJ
18637	10800	19	,	,	,
18637	10800	20	earnest	earnest	JJ
18637	10800	21	and	and	CC
18637	10800	22	vital	vital	JJ
18637	10800	23	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10800	24	between	between	IN
18637	10800	25	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	10800	26	.	.	.
18637	10801	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10801	2	never	never	RB
18637	10801	3	was	be	VBD
18637	10801	4	the	the	DT
18637	10801	5	thought	thought	NN
18637	10801	6	that	that	IN
18637	10801	7	,	,	,
18637	10801	8	by	by	IN
18637	10801	9	means	mean	NNS
18637	10801	10	of	of	IN
18637	10801	11	a	a	DT
18637	10801	12	friendly	friendly	JJ
18637	10801	13	suit	suit	NN
18637	10801	14	,	,	,
18637	10801	15	a	a	DT
18637	10801	16	party	party	NN
18637	10801	17	beaten	beat	VBN
18637	10801	18	in	in	IN
18637	10801	19	the	the	DT
18637	10801	20	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	10801	21	could	could	MD
18637	10801	22	transfer	transfer	VB
18637	10801	23	to	to	IN
18637	10801	24	the	the	DT
18637	10801	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	10801	26	an	an	DT
18637	10801	27	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	10801	28	as	as	IN
18637	10801	29	to	to	IN
18637	10801	30	the	the	DT
18637	10801	31	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	10801	32	of	of	IN
18637	10801	33	the	the	DT
18637	10801	34	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10801	35	act	act	NN
18637	10801	36	.	.	.
18637	10802	1	"	"	``
18637	10802	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10802	3	149	149	CD
18637	10802	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10802	5	In	in	IN
18637	10802	6	applying	apply	VBG
18637	10802	7	the	the	DT
18637	10802	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	10802	9	requiring	require	VBG
18637	10802	10	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	10802	11	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	10802	12	to	to	TO
18637	10802	13	present	present	VB
18637	10802	14	an	an	DT
18637	10802	15	honest	honest	JJ
18637	10802	16	and	and	CC
18637	10802	17	actual	actual	JJ
18637	10802	18	antagonistic	antagonistic	JJ
18637	10802	19	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	10802	20	of	of	IN
18637	10802	21	rights	right	NNS
18637	10802	22	,	,	,
18637	10802	23	the	the	DT
18637	10802	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10802	25	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
18637	10802	26	an	an	DT
18637	10802	27	act	act	NN
18637	10802	28	of	of	IN
18637	10802	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10802	30	which	which	WDT
18637	10802	31	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	10802	32	certain	certain	JJ
18637	10802	33	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	10802	34	to	to	TO
18637	10802	35	bring	bring	VB
18637	10802	36	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10802	37	against	against	IN
18637	10802	38	the	the	DT
18637	10802	39	United	United	NNP
18637	10802	40	States	States	NNP
18637	10802	41	to	to	TO
18637	10802	42	test	test	VB
18637	10802	43	the	the	DT
18637	10802	44	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	10802	45	of	of	IN
18637	10802	46	the	the	DT
18637	10802	47	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	10802	48	allotment	allotment	NN
18637	10802	49	acts	act	VBZ
18637	10802	50	,	,	,
18637	10802	51	on	on	IN
18637	10802	52	the	the	DT
18637	10802	53	ground	ground	NN
18637	10802	54	that	that	IN
18637	10802	55	such	such	PDT
18637	10802	56	a	a	DT
18637	10802	57	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	10802	58	was	be	VBD
18637	10802	59	not	not	RB
18637	10802	60	a	a	DT
18637	10802	61	case	case	NN
18637	10802	62	or	or	CC
18637	10802	63	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10802	64	in	in	IN
18637	10802	65	that	that	IN
18637	10802	66	the	the	DT
18637	10802	67	United	United	NNP
18637	10802	68	States	States	NNP
18637	10802	69	had	have	VBD
18637	10802	70	no	no	DT
18637	10802	71	interest	interest	NN
18637	10802	72	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	10802	73	to	to	IN
18637	10802	74	the	the	DT
18637	10802	75	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	10802	76	.	.	.
18637	10803	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10803	2	150	150	CD
18637	10803	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10803	4	The	the	DT
18637	10803	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10803	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	10803	7	also	also	RB
18637	10803	8	held	hold	VBN
18637	10803	9	that	that	IN
18637	10803	10	in	in	IN
18637	10803	11	contesting	contest	VBG
18637	10803	12	the	the	DT
18637	10803	13	validity	validity	NN
18637	10803	14	of	of	IN
18637	10803	15	a	a	DT
18637	10803	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	10803	17	,	,	,
18637	10803	18	the	the	DT
18637	10803	19	issue	issue	NN
18637	10803	20	must	must	MD
18637	10803	21	be	be	VB
18637	10803	22	raised	raise	VBN
18637	10803	23	by	by	IN
18637	10803	24	one	one	CD
18637	10803	25	adversely	adversely	RB
18637	10803	26	affected	affect	VBN
18637	10803	27	and	and	CC
18637	10803	28	not	not	RB
18637	10803	29	a	a	DT
18637	10803	30	stranger	stranger	NN
18637	10803	31	to	to	IN
18637	10803	32	the	the	DT
18637	10803	33	operation	operation	NN
18637	10803	34	of	of	IN
18637	10803	35	the	the	DT
18637	10803	36	statute,[151	statute,[151	NN
18637	10803	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10803	38	and	and	CC
18637	10803	39	that	that	IN
18637	10803	40	the	the	DT
18637	10803	41	interest	interest	NN
18637	10803	42	must	must	MD
18637	10803	43	be	be	VB
18637	10803	44	of	of	IN
18637	10803	45	a	a	DT
18637	10803	46	personal	personal	JJ
18637	10803	47	as	as	IN
18637	10803	48	contrasted	contrast	VBN
18637	10803	49	with	with	IN
18637	10803	50	an	an	DT
18637	10803	51	official	official	JJ
18637	10803	52	interest	interest	NN
18637	10803	53	.	.	.
18637	10804	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10804	2	152	152	CD
18637	10804	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10804	4	Hence	hence	RB
18637	10804	5	a	a	DT
18637	10804	6	county	county	NN
18637	10804	7	court	court	NN
18637	10804	8	can	can	MD
18637	10804	9	not	not	RB
18637	10804	10	contest	contest	VB
18637	10804	11	the	the	DT
18637	10804	12	validity	validity	NN
18637	10804	13	of	of	IN
18637	10804	14	a	a	DT
18637	10804	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	10804	16	in	in	IN
18637	10804	17	the	the	DT
18637	10804	18	interest	interest	NN
18637	10804	19	of	of	IN
18637	10804	20	third	third	JJ
18637	10804	21	parties,[153	parties,[153	NNP
18637	10804	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10804	23	nor	nor	CC
18637	10804	24	can	can	MD
18637	10804	25	a	a	DT
18637	10804	26	county	county	NN
18637	10804	27	auditor	auditor	NN
18637	10804	28	contest	contest	VB
18637	10804	29	the	the	DT
18637	10804	30	validity	validity	NN
18637	10804	31	of	of	IN
18637	10804	32	a	a	DT
18637	10804	33	statute	statute	NN
18637	10804	34	even	even	RB
18637	10804	35	though	though	IN
18637	10804	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10804	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	10804	38	charged	charge	VBN
18637	10804	39	with	with	IN
18637	10804	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10804	41	enforcement,[154	enforcement,[154	NN
18637	10804	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10804	43	nor	nor	CC
18637	10804	44	can	can	MD
18637	10804	45	directors	director	NNS
18637	10804	46	of	of	IN
18637	10804	47	an	an	DT
18637	10804	48	irrigation	irrigation	NN
18637	10804	49	district	district	NN
18637	10804	50	occupy	occupy	VBP
18637	10804	51	a	a	DT
18637	10804	52	position	position	NN
18637	10804	53	antagonistic	antagonistic	JJ
18637	10804	54	to	to	IN
18637	10804	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10804	56	.	.	.
18637	10805	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10805	2	155	155	CD
18637	10805	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10805	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10805	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	10805	6	a	a	DT
18637	10805	7	well	well	RB
18637	10805	8	settled	settle	VBN
18637	10805	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	10805	10	that	that	IN
18637	10805	11	:	:	:
18637	10805	12	"	"	``
18637	10805	13	The	the	DT
18637	10805	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10805	15	will	will	MD
18637	10805	16	not	not	RB
18637	10805	17	pass	pass	VB
18637	10805	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	10805	19	the	the	DT
18637	10805	20	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	10805	21	of	of	IN
18637	10805	22	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10805	23	*	*	NFP
18637	10805	24	*	*	NFP
18637	10805	25	*	*	NFP
18637	10805	26	,	,	,
18637	10805	27	or	or	CC
18637	10805	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	10805	29	the	the	DT
18637	10805	30	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	10805	31	of	of	IN
18637	10805	32	one	one	NN
18637	10805	33	who	who	WP
18637	10805	34	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	10805	35	to	to	TO
18637	10805	36	show	show	VB
18637	10805	37	that	that	IN
18637	10805	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10805	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	10805	40	injured	injure	VBN
18637	10805	41	by	by	IN
18637	10805	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10805	43	operation	operation	NN
18637	10805	44	,	,	,
18637	10805	45	*	*	NFP
18637	10805	46	*	*	NFP
18637	10805	47	*	*	NFP
18637	10805	48	"	"	''
18637	10805	49	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10805	50	156	156	CD
18637	10805	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10805	52	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10805	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	10805	54	equally	equally	RB
18637	10805	55	well	well	RB
18637	10805	56	established	establish	VBN
18637	10805	57	as	as	IN
18637	10805	58	a	a	DT
18637	10805	59	corollary	corollary	NN
18637	10805	60	that	that	IN
18637	10805	61	,	,	,
18637	10805	62	"	"	``
18637	10805	63	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	10805	64	may	may	MD
18637	10805	65	challenge	challenge	VB
18637	10805	66	the	the	DT
18637	10805	67	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	10805	68	of	of	IN
18637	10805	69	a	a	DT
18637	10805	70	statute	statute	NN
18637	10805	71	only	only	RB
18637	10805	72	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	10805	73	as	as	IN
18637	10805	74	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10805	75	affects	affect	VBZ
18637	10805	76	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10805	77	.	.	.
18637	10806	1	"	"	``
18637	10806	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10806	3	157	157	CD
18637	10806	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10806	5	STOCKHOLDERS	stockholder	NNS
18637	10806	6	'	'	POS
18637	10806	7	SUITS	suits	NN
18637	10806	8	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10806	9	must	must	MD
18637	10806	10	be	be	VB
18637	10806	11	noted	note	VBN
18637	10806	12	,	,	,
18637	10806	13	however	however	RB
18637	10806	14	,	,	,
18637	10806	15	that	that	DT
18637	10806	16	adversity	adversity	NN
18637	10806	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	10806	18	a	a	DT
18637	10806	19	relative	relative	JJ
18637	10806	20	element	element	NN
18637	10806	21	which	which	WDT
18637	10806	22	the	the	DT
18637	10806	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	10806	24	may	may	MD
18637	10806	25	or	or	CC
18637	10806	26	may	may	MD
18637	10806	27	not	not	RB
18637	10806	28	discover	discover	VB
18637	10806	29	.	.	.
18637	10807	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	10807	2	in	in	IN
18637	10807	3	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	10807	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10807	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	10807	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10807	7	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	10807	8	'	'	POS
18637	10807	9	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	10807	10	and	and	CC
18637	10807	11	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	10807	12	Co	Co	NNP
18637	10807	13	.	.	.
18637	10807	14	,[158	,[158	NFP
18637	10807	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10807	16	the	the	DT
18637	10807	17	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10807	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10807	19	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	10807	20	the	the	DT
18637	10807	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10807	22	of	of	IN
18637	10807	23	a	a	DT
18637	10807	24	district	district	NN
18637	10807	25	court	court	NN
18637	10807	26	which	which	WDT
18637	10807	27	had	have	VBD
18637	10807	28	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	10807	29	the	the	DT
18637	10807	30	company	company	NN
18637	10807	31	from	from	IN
18637	10807	32	paying	pay	VBG
18637	10807	33	an	an	DT
18637	10807	34	income	income	NN
18637	10807	35	tax	tax	NN
18637	10807	36	even	even	RB
18637	10807	37	though	though	IN
18637	10807	38	the	the	DT
18637	10807	39	suit	suit	NN
18637	10807	40	was	be	VBD
18637	10807	41	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10807	42	by	by	IN
18637	10807	43	a	a	DT
18637	10807	44	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	10807	45	against	against	IN
18637	10807	46	the	the	DT
18637	10807	47	company	company	NN
18637	10807	48	,	,	,
18637	10807	49	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	10807	50	circumventing	circumvent	VBG
18637	10807	51	section	section	NN
18637	10807	52	3224	3224	CD
18637	10807	53	of	of	IN
18637	10807	54	the	the	DT
18637	10807	55	Revised	Revised	NNP
18637	10807	56	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	10807	57	,	,	,
18637	10807	58	which	which	WDT
18637	10807	59	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	10807	60	the	the	DT
18637	10807	61	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	10807	62	in	in	IN
18637	10807	63	any	any	DT
18637	10807	64	court	court	NN
18637	10807	65	of	of	IN
18637	10807	66	a	a	DT
18637	10807	67	suit	suit	NN
18637	10807	68	"	"	''
18637	10807	69	for	for	IN
18637	10807	70	the	the	DT
18637	10807	71	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	10807	72	of	of	IN
18637	10807	73	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	10807	74	the	the	DT
18637	10807	75	collection	collection	NN
18637	10807	76	of	of	IN
18637	10807	77	any	any	DT
18637	10807	78	tax	tax	NN
18637	10807	79	.	.	.
18637	10808	1	"	"	``
18637	10808	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10808	3	159	159	CD
18637	10808	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10808	5	Subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	10808	6	the	the	DT
18637	10808	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10808	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	10808	9	found	find	VBN
18637	10808	10	adversity	adversity	NN
18637	10808	11	of	of	IN
18637	10808	12	parties	party	NNS
18637	10808	13	in	in	IN
18637	10808	14	a	a	DT
18637	10808	15	suit	suit	NN
18637	10808	16	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10808	17	by	by	IN
18637	10808	18	a	a	DT
18637	10808	19	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	10808	20	to	to	TO
18637	10808	21	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	10808	22	a	a	DT
18637	10808	23	title	title	NN
18637	10808	24	company	company	NN
18637	10808	25	from	from	IN
18637	10808	26	investing	invest	VBG
18637	10808	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10808	28	funds	fund	NNS
18637	10808	29	in	in	IN
18637	10808	30	farm	farm	NN
18637	10808	31	loan	loan	NN
18637	10808	32	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	10808	33	issued	issue	VBN
18637	10808	34	by	by	IN
18637	10808	35	the	the	DT
18637	10808	36	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10808	37	land	land	NN
18637	10808	38	banks,[160	banks,[160	NNP
18637	10808	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10808	40	and	and	CC
18637	10808	41	in	in	IN
18637	10808	42	a	a	DT
18637	10808	43	suit	suit	NN
18637	10808	44	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10808	45	by	by	IN
18637	10808	46	certain	certain	JJ
18637	10808	47	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	10808	48	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	10808	49	against	against	IN
18637	10808	50	the	the	DT
18637	10808	51	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	10808	52	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10808	53	Company	Company	NNP
18637	10808	54	and	and	CC
18637	10808	55	the	the	DT
18637	10808	56	TVA	TVA	NNP
18637	10808	57	to	to	TO
18637	10808	58	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	10808	59	the	the	DT
18637	10808	60	performance	performance	NN
18637	10808	61	of	of	IN
18637	10808	62	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	10808	63	between	between	IN
18637	10808	64	the	the	DT
18637	10808	65	company	company	NN
18637	10808	66	and	and	CC
18637	10808	67	the	the	DT
18637	10808	68	authority	authority	NN
18637	10808	69	and	and	CC
18637	10808	70	a	a	DT
18637	10808	71	subsidiary	subsidiary	NN
18637	10808	72	,	,	,
18637	10808	73	the	the	DT
18637	10808	74	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	10808	75	Home	Home	NNP
18637	10808	76	and	and	CC
18637	10808	77	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	10808	78	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	10808	79	,	,	,
18637	10808	80	on	on	IN
18637	10808	81	the	the	DT
18637	10808	82	ground	ground	NN
18637	10808	83	that	that	IN
18637	10808	84	the	the	DT
18637	10808	85	act	act	NN
18637	10808	86	creating	create	VBG
18637	10808	87	these	these	DT
18637	10808	88	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	10808	89	was	be	VBD
18637	10808	90	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	10808	91	.	.	.
18637	10809	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10809	2	161	161	CD
18637	10809	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10809	4	The	the	DT
18637	10809	5	ability	ability	NN
18637	10809	6	to	to	TO
18637	10809	7	find	find	VB
18637	10809	8	adversity	adversity	NN
18637	10809	9	in	in	IN
18637	10809	10	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	10809	11	crevices	crevice	NNS
18637	10809	12	of	of	IN
18637	10809	13	casual	casual	JJ
18637	10809	14	disagreement	disagreement	NN
18637	10809	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	10809	16	well	well	RB
18637	10809	17	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
18637	10809	18	by	by	IN
18637	10809	19	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	10809	20	_	_	NNP
18637	10809	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	10809	22	_	_	NNP
18637	10809	23	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	10809	24	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	10809	25	Co	Co	NNP
18637	10809	26	.	.	.
18637	10809	27	,[162	,[162	NFP
18637	10809	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10809	29	where	where	WRB
18637	10809	30	the	the	DT
18637	10809	31	President	President	NNP
18637	10809	32	of	of	IN
18637	10809	33	the	the	DT
18637	10809	34	company	company	NN
18637	10809	35	brought	bring	VBD
18637	10809	36	suit	suit	NN
18637	10809	37	against	against	IN
18637	10809	38	the	the	DT
18637	10809	39	company	company	NN
18637	10809	40	and	and	CC
18637	10809	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10809	42	officials	official	NNS
18637	10809	43	,	,	,
18637	10809	44	among	among	IN
18637	10809	45	whom	whom	WP
18637	10809	46	was	be	VBD
18637	10809	47	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	10809	48	's	's	POS
18637	10809	49	father	father	NN
18637	10809	50	who	who	WP
18637	10809	51	was	be	VBD
18637	10809	52	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	10809	53	President	President	NNP
18637	10809	54	of	of	IN
18637	10809	55	the	the	DT
18637	10809	56	Company	Company	NNP
18637	10809	57	.	.	.
18637	10810	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10810	2	163	163	CD
18637	10810	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10810	4	The	the	DT
18637	10810	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10810	6	entertained	entertain	VBD
18637	10810	7	the	the	DT
18637	10810	8	suit	suit	NN
18637	10810	9	and	and	CC
18637	10810	10	decided	decide	VBD
18637	10810	11	the	the	DT
18637	10810	12	case	case	NN
18637	10810	13	on	on	IN
18637	10810	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10810	15	merits	merit	NNS
18637	10810	16	.	.	.
18637	10811	1	SUBSTANTIAL	substantial	JJ
18637	10811	2	INTEREST	interest	NN
18637	10811	3	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNP
18637	10811	4	Equally	equally	RB
18637	10811	5	important	important	JJ
18637	10811	6	as	as	IN
18637	10811	7	an	an	DT
18637	10811	8	essential	essential	JJ
18637	10811	9	element	element	NN
18637	10811	10	of	of	IN
18637	10811	11	a	a	DT
18637	10811	12	case	case	NN
18637	10811	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	10811	14	the	the	DT
18637	10811	15	concept	concept	NN
18637	10811	16	of	of	IN
18637	10811	17	real	real	JJ
18637	10811	18	or	or	CC
18637	10811	19	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	10811	20	interests	interest	NNS
18637	10811	21	.	.	.
18637	10812	1	As	as	IN
18637	10812	2	a	a	DT
18637	10812	3	general	general	JJ
18637	10812	4	rule	rule	NN
18637	10812	5	the	the	DT
18637	10812	6	interest	interest	NN
18637	10812	7	of	of	IN
18637	10812	8	taxpayers	taxpayer	NNS
18637	10812	9	in	in	IN
18637	10812	10	the	the	DT
18637	10812	11	general	general	JJ
18637	10812	12	funds	fund	NNS
18637	10812	13	of	of	IN
18637	10812	14	the	the	DT
18637	10812	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10812	16	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	10812	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	10812	18	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	10812	19	to	to	TO
18637	10812	20	give	give	VB
18637	10812	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10812	22	a	a	DT
18637	10812	23	standing	standing	NN
18637	10812	24	in	in	IN
18637	10812	25	court	court	NN
18637	10812	26	to	to	TO
18637	10812	27	contest	contest	VB
18637	10812	28	the	the	DT
18637	10812	29	expenditure	expenditure	NN
18637	10812	30	of	of	IN
18637	10812	31	public	public	JJ
18637	10812	32	funds	fund	NNS
18637	10812	33	on	on	IN
18637	10812	34	the	the	DT
18637	10812	35	ground	ground	NN
18637	10812	36	that	that	IN
18637	10812	37	this	this	DT
18637	10812	38	interest	interest	NN
18637	10812	39	"	"	''
18637	10812	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	10812	41	shared	share	VBN
18637	10812	42	with	with	IN
18637	10812	43	millions	million	NNS
18637	10812	44	of	of	IN
18637	10812	45	others	other	NNS
18637	10812	46	;	;	:
18637	10812	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	10812	48	comparatively	comparatively	RB
18637	10812	49	minute	minute	JJ
18637	10812	50	and	and	CC
18637	10812	51	indeterminable	indeterminable	JJ
18637	10812	52	;	;	:
18637	10812	53	and	and	CC
18637	10812	54	the	the	DT
18637	10812	55	effect	effect	NN
18637	10812	56	upon	upon	IN
18637	10812	57	future	future	JJ
18637	10812	58	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	10812	59	,	,	,
18637	10812	60	of	of	IN
18637	10812	61	any	any	DT
18637	10812	62	payment	payment	NN
18637	10812	63	out	out	IN
18637	10812	64	of	of	IN
18637	10812	65	the	the	DT
18637	10812	66	funds	fund	NNS
18637	10812	67	,	,	,
18637	10812	68	so	so	RB
18637	10812	69	remote	remote	JJ
18637	10812	70	,	,	,
18637	10812	71	fluctuating	fluctuating	JJ
18637	10812	72	and	and	CC
18637	10812	73	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
18637	10812	74	,	,	,
18637	10812	75	that	that	IN
18637	10812	76	no	no	DT
18637	10812	77	basis	basis	NN
18637	10812	78	is	be	VBZ
18637	10812	79	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	10812	80	for	for	IN
18637	10812	81	an	an	DT
18637	10812	82	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	10812	83	to	to	IN
18637	10812	84	the	the	DT
18637	10812	85	preventive	preventive	JJ
18637	10812	86	powers	power	NNS
18637	10812	87	of	of	IN
18637	10812	88	a	a	DT
18637	10812	89	court	court	NN
18637	10812	90	of	of	IN
18637	10812	91	equity	equity	NN
18637	10812	92	.	.	.
18637	10813	1	"	"	``
18637	10813	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10813	3	164	164	CD
18637	10813	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10813	5	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	10813	6	,	,	,
18637	10813	7	the	the	DT
18637	10813	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10813	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	10813	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	10813	11	that	that	IN
18637	10813	12	the	the	DT
18637	10813	13	general	general	JJ
18637	10813	14	interest	interest	NN
18637	10813	15	of	of	IN
18637	10813	16	a	a	DT
18637	10813	17	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	10813	18	in	in	IN
18637	10813	19	having	have	VBG
18637	10813	20	the	the	DT
18637	10813	21	government	government	NN
18637	10813	22	administered	administer	VBN
18637	10813	23	by	by	IN
18637	10813	24	law	law	NN
18637	10813	25	does	do	VBZ
18637	10813	26	not	not	RB
18637	10813	27	give	give	VB
18637	10813	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10813	29	a	a	DT
18637	10813	30	standing	standing	NN
18637	10813	31	to	to	TO
18637	10813	32	contest	contest	VB
18637	10813	33	the	the	DT
18637	10813	34	validity	validity	NN
18637	10813	35	of	of	IN
18637	10813	36	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	10813	37	action	action	NN
18637	10813	38	.	.	.
18637	10814	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10814	2	165	165	CD
18637	10814	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10814	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	10814	5	can	can	MD
18637	10814	6	a	a	DT
18637	10814	7	member	member	NN
18637	10814	8	of	of	IN
18637	10814	9	the	the	DT
18637	10814	10	bar	bar	NN
18637	10814	11	of	of	IN
18637	10814	12	the	the	DT
18637	10814	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10814	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10814	15	challenge	challenge	VBP
18637	10814	16	the	the	DT
18637	10814	17	validity	validity	NN
18637	10814	18	of	of	IN
18637	10814	19	an	an	DT
18637	10814	20	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	10814	21	to	to	IN
18637	10814	22	the	the	DT
18637	10814	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10814	24	since	since	IN
18637	10814	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10814	26	"	"	``
18637	10814	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	10814	28	merely	merely	RB
18637	10814	29	a	a	DT
18637	10814	30	general	general	JJ
18637	10814	31	interest	interest	NN
18637	10814	32	common	common	JJ
18637	10814	33	to	to	IN
18637	10814	34	all	all	DT
18637	10814	35	members	member	NNS
18637	10814	36	of	of	IN
18637	10814	37	the	the	DT
18637	10814	38	public	public	NN
18637	10814	39	.	.	.
18637	10815	1	"	"	``
18637	10815	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10815	3	166	166	CD
18637	10815	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10815	5	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	10815	6	an	an	DT
18637	10815	7	electric	electric	JJ
18637	10815	8	power	power	NN
18637	10815	9	company	company	NN
18637	10815	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	10815	11	been	be	VBN
18637	10815	12	held	hold	VBN
18637	10815	13	not	not	RB
18637	10815	14	to	to	TO
18637	10815	15	have	have	VB
18637	10815	16	a	a	DT
18637	10815	17	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	10815	18	interest	interest	NN
18637	10815	19	to	to	TO
18637	10815	20	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	10815	21	an	an	DT
18637	10815	22	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	10815	23	suit	suit	NN
18637	10815	24	to	to	TO
18637	10815	25	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	10815	26	the	the	DT
18637	10815	27	making	making	NN
18637	10815	28	of	of	IN
18637	10815	29	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10815	30	loans	loan	NNS
18637	10815	31	and	and	CC
18637	10815	32	grants	grant	NNS
18637	10815	33	to	to	IN
18637	10815	34	municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	10815	35	for	for	IN
18637	10815	36	the	the	DT
18637	10815	37	construction	construction	NN
18637	10815	38	or	or	CC
18637	10815	39	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	10815	40	of	of	IN
18637	10815	41	electric	electric	JJ
18637	10815	42	power	power	NN
18637	10815	43	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	10815	44	plants	plant	NNS
18637	10815	45	on	on	IN
18637	10815	46	the	the	DT
18637	10815	47	ground	ground	NN
18637	10815	48	that	that	IN
18637	10815	49	the	the	DT
18637	10815	50	"	"	``
18637	10815	51	lender	lender	NN
18637	10815	52	owes	owe	VBZ
18637	10815	53	the	the	DT
18637	10815	54	sufferer	sufferer	NN
18637	10815	55	no	no	DT
18637	10815	56	enforcible	enforcible	JJ
18637	10815	57	duty	duty	NN
18637	10815	58	to	to	TO
18637	10815	59	refrain	refrain	VB
18637	10815	60	from	from	IN
18637	10815	61	making	make	VBG
18637	10815	62	the	the	DT
18637	10815	63	unauthorized	unauthorized	JJ
18637	10815	64	loan	loan	NN
18637	10815	65	;	;	:
18637	10815	66	and	and	CC
18637	10815	67	the	the	DT
18637	10815	68	borrower	borrower	NN
18637	10815	69	owes	owe	VBZ
18637	10815	70	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10815	71	no	no	DT
18637	10815	72	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	10815	73	to	to	TO
18637	10815	74	refrain	refrain	VB
18637	10815	75	from	from	IN
18637	10815	76	using	use	VBG
18637	10815	77	the	the	DT
18637	10815	78	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	10815	79	in	in	IN
18637	10815	80	any	any	DT
18637	10815	81	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	10815	82	way	way	NN
18637	10815	83	the	the	DT
18637	10815	84	borrower	borrower	NN
18637	10815	85	may	may	MD
18637	10815	86	choose	choose	VB
18637	10815	87	.	.	.
18637	10816	1	"	"	``
18637	10816	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10816	3	167	167	CD
18637	10816	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10816	5	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	10816	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	10816	7	,	,	,
18637	10816	8	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10816	9	the	the	DT
18637	10816	10	issue	issue	NN
18637	10816	11	of	of	IN
18637	10816	12	religion	religion	NN
18637	10816	13	in	in	IN
18637	10816	14	the	the	DT
18637	10816	15	schools	school	NNS
18637	10816	16	,	,	,
18637	10816	17	reach	reach	VB
18637	10816	18	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	10816	19	divergent	divergent	JJ
18637	10816	20	results	result	NNS
18637	10816	21	.	.	.
18637	10817	1	In	in	IN
18637	10817	2	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	10817	3	ex	ex	NNP
18637	10817	4	rel	rel	NN
18637	10817	5	.	.	.
18637	10818	1	McCollum	McCollum	NNP
18637	10818	2	_	_	NNP
18637	10818	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	10818	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10818	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	10818	6	of	of	IN
18637	10818	7	Education,[168	Education,[168	NNP
18637	10818	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10818	9	the	the	DT
18637	10818	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10818	11	held	hold	VBD
18637	10818	12	that	that	IN
18637	10818	13	a	a	DT
18637	10818	14	litigant	litigant	NN
18637	10818	15	had	have	VBD
18637	10818	16	the	the	DT
18637	10818	17	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	10818	18	standing	standing	NN
18637	10818	19	to	to	TO
18637	10818	20	bring	bring	VB
18637	10818	21	a	a	DT
18637	10818	22	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	10818	23	suit	suit	NN
18637	10818	24	challenging	challenge	VBG
18637	10818	25	,	,	,
18637	10818	26	on	on	IN
18637	10818	27	the	the	DT
18637	10818	28	basis	basis	NN
18637	10818	29	of	of	IN
18637	10818	30	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10818	31	interests	interest	NNS
18637	10818	32	as	as	IN
18637	10818	33	a	a	DT
18637	10818	34	resident	resident	NN
18637	10818	35	and	and	CC
18637	10818	36	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	10818	37	of	of	IN
18637	10818	38	the	the	DT
18637	10818	39	school	school	NN
18637	10818	40	district	district	NN
18637	10818	41	and	and	CC
18637	10818	42	the	the	DT
18637	10818	43	parent	parent	NN
18637	10818	44	of	of	IN
18637	10818	45	a	a	DT
18637	10818	46	child	child	NN
18637	10818	47	required	require	VBN
18637	10818	48	by	by	IN
18637	10818	49	law	law	NN
18637	10818	50	to	to	TO
18637	10818	51	attend	attend	VB
18637	10818	52	the	the	DT
18637	10818	53	school	school	NN
18637	10818	54	or	or	CC
18637	10818	55	one	one	CD
18637	10818	56	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	10818	57	the	the	DT
18637	10818	58	State	state	NN
18637	10818	59	's	's	POS
18637	10818	60	educational	educational	JJ
18637	10818	61	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	10818	62	,	,	,
18637	10818	63	the	the	DT
18637	10818	64	validity	validity	NN
18637	10818	65	of	of	IN
18637	10818	66	a	a	DT
18637	10818	67	religious	religious	JJ
18637	10818	68	education	education	NN
18637	10818	69	program	program	NN
18637	10818	70	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10818	71	the	the	DT
18637	10818	72	use	use	NN
18637	10818	73	of	of	IN
18637	10818	74	public	public	JJ
18637	10818	75	school	school	NN
18637	10818	76	rooms	room	NNS
18637	10818	77	one	one	CD
18637	10818	78	half	half	JJ
18637	10818	79	hour	hour	NN
18637	10818	80	each	each	DT
18637	10818	81	week	week	NN
18637	10818	82	.	.	.
18637	10819	1	But	but	CC
18637	10819	2	in	in	IN
18637	10819	3	Doremus	Doremus	NNP
18637	10819	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10819	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	10819	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10819	7	Board	Board	NNP
18637	10819	8	of	of	IN
18637	10819	9	Education,[169	Education,[169	NNP
18637	10819	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10819	11	decided	decide	VBN
18637	10819	12	early	early	RB
18637	10819	13	in	in	IN
18637	10819	14	1952	1952	CD
18637	10819	15	,	,	,
18637	10819	16	the	the	DT
18637	10819	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10819	18	declined	decline	VBD
18637	10819	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10819	20	in	in	IN
18637	10819	21	a	a	DT
18637	10819	22	case	case	NN
18637	10819	23	challenging	challenge	VBG
18637	10819	24	the	the	DT
18637	10819	25	validity	validity	NN
18637	10819	26	of	of	IN
18637	10819	27	a	a	DT
18637	10819	28	New	New	NNP
18637	10819	29	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	10819	30	statute	statute	NN
18637	10819	31	which	which	WDT
18637	10819	32	requires	require	VBZ
18637	10819	33	the	the	DT
18637	10819	34	reading	reading	NN
18637	10819	35	at	at	IN
18637	10819	36	the	the	DT
18637	10819	37	opening	opening	NN
18637	10819	38	of	of	IN
18637	10819	39	each	each	DT
18637	10819	40	public	public	JJ
18637	10819	41	school	school	NN
18637	10819	42	day	day	NN
18637	10819	43	of	of	IN
18637	10819	44	five	five	CD
18637	10819	45	verses	verse	NNS
18637	10819	46	of	of	IN
18637	10819	47	the	the	DT
18637	10819	48	Old	Old	NNP
18637	10819	49	Testament	Testament	NNP
18637	10819	50	.	.	.
18637	10820	1	Appellants	appellant	NNS
18637	10820	2	'	'	POS
18637	10820	3	interest	interest	NN
18637	10820	4	as	as	IN
18637	10820	5	taxpayers	taxpayer	NNS
18637	10820	6	was	be	VBD
18637	10820	7	found	find	VBN
18637	10820	8	to	to	TO
18637	10820	9	be	be	VB
18637	10820	10	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	10820	11	to	to	TO
18637	10820	12	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	10820	13	the	the	DT
18637	10820	14	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	10820	15	.	.	.
18637	10821	1	Substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	10821	2	Interest	interest	NN
18637	10821	3	in	in	IN
18637	10821	4	Suits	Suits	NNP
18637	10821	5	by	by	IN
18637	10821	6	States	state	NNS
18637	10821	7	These	these	DT
18637	10821	8	principles	principle	NNS
18637	10821	9	have	have	VBP
18637	10821	10	been	be	VBN
18637	10821	11	applied	apply	VBN
18637	10821	12	in	in	IN
18637	10821	13	a	a	DT
18637	10821	14	number	number	NN
18637	10821	15	of	of	IN
18637	10821	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	10821	17	to	to	TO
18637	10821	18	which	which	WDT
18637	10821	19	a	a	DT
18637	10821	20	State	state	NN
18637	10821	21	was	be	VBD
18637	10821	22	one	one	CD
18637	10821	23	of	of	IN
18637	10821	24	the	the	DT
18637	10821	25	parties	party	NNS
18637	10821	26	and	and	CC
18637	10821	27	in	in	IN
18637	10821	28	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10821	29	between	between	IN
18637	10821	30	States	States	NNP
18637	10821	31	.	.	.
18637	10822	1	One	one	CD
18637	10822	2	of	of	IN
18637	10822	3	the	the	DT
18637	10822	4	most	most	RBS
18637	10822	5	important	important	JJ
18637	10822	6	of	of	IN
18637	10822	7	these	these	DT
18637	10822	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	10822	9	State	State	NNP
18637	10822	10	of	of	IN
18637	10822	11	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	10822	12	_	_	NNP
18637	10822	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	10822	14	_	_	NNP
18637	10822	15	Stanton,[170	Stanton,[170	NNP
18637	10822	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10822	17	which	which	WDT
18637	10822	18	was	be	VBD
18637	10822	19	an	an	DT
18637	10822	20	original	original	JJ
18637	10822	21	suit	suit	NN
18637	10822	22	in	in	IN
18637	10822	23	equity	equity	NN
18637	10822	24	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10822	25	by	by	IN
18637	10822	26	the	the	DT
18637	10822	27	State	State	NNP
18637	10822	28	of	of	IN
18637	10822	29	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	10822	30	against	against	IN
18637	10822	31	the	the	DT
18637	10822	32	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10822	33	of	of	IN
18637	10822	34	War	War	NNP
18637	10822	35	and	and	CC
18637	10822	36	others	other	NNS
18637	10822	37	to	to	TO
18637	10822	38	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	10822	39	the	the	DT
18637	10822	40	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10822	41	of	of	IN
18637	10822	42	the	the	DT
18637	10822	43	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
18637	10822	44	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	10822	45	.	.	.
18637	10823	1	The	the	DT
18637	10823	2	State	State	NNP
18637	10823	3	's	's	POS
18637	10823	4	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	10823	5	contended	contend	VBD
18637	10823	6	that	that	IN
18637	10823	7	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10823	8	of	of	IN
18637	10823	9	the	the	DT
18637	10823	10	acts	act	NNS
18637	10823	11	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10823	12	about	about	RP
18637	10823	13	"	"	``
18637	10823	14	an	an	DT
18637	10823	15	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	10823	16	paralysis	paralysis	NN
18637	10823	17	of	of	IN
18637	10823	18	all	all	PDT
18637	10823	19	the	the	DT
18637	10823	20	authority	authority	NN
18637	10823	21	and	and	CC
18637	10823	22	power	power	NN
18637	10823	23	of	of	IN
18637	10823	24	the	the	DT
18637	10823	25	State	State	NNP
18637	10823	26	government	government	NN
18637	10823	27	by	by	IN
18637	10823	28	military	military	JJ
18637	10823	29	force	force	NN
18637	10823	30	;	;	:
18637	10823	31	*	*	NFP
18637	10823	32	*	*	NFP
18637	10823	33	*	*	NFP
18637	10823	34	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10823	35	which	which	WDT
18637	10823	36	was	be	VBD
18637	10823	37	divesting	divest	VBG
18637	10823	38	the	the	DT
18637	10823	39	State	state	NN
18637	10823	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10823	41	of	of	IN
18637	10823	42	her	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10823	43	legally	legally	RB
18637	10823	44	and	and	CC
18637	10823	45	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	10823	46	established	establish	VBN
18637	10823	47	and	and	CC
18637	10823	48	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	10823	49	existence	existence	NN
18637	10823	50	as	as	IN
18637	10823	51	a	a	DT
18637	10823	52	body	body	NN
18637	10823	53	politic	politic	NN
18637	10823	54	and	and	CC
18637	10823	55	a	a	DT
18637	10823	56	member	member	NN
18637	10823	57	of	of	IN
18637	10823	58	the	the	DT
18637	10823	59	Union	Union	NNP
18637	10823	60	.	.	.
18637	10823	61	"	"	''
18637	10824	1	The	the	DT
18637	10824	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10824	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10824	4	dismissed	dismiss	VBD
18637	10824	5	the	the	DT
18637	10824	6	suit	suit	NN
18637	10824	7	for	for	IN
18637	10824	8	want	want	NN
18637	10824	9	of	of	IN
18637	10824	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10824	11	,	,	,
18637	10824	12	holding	hold	VBG
18637	10824	13	that	that	DT
18637	10824	14	for	for	IN
18637	10824	15	a	a	DT
18637	10824	16	case	case	NN
18637	10824	17	to	to	TO
18637	10824	18	be	be	VB
18637	10824	19	presented	present	VBN
18637	10824	20	for	for	IN
18637	10824	21	the	the	DT
18637	10824	22	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10824	23	of	of	IN
18637	10824	24	the	the	DT
18637	10824	25	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10824	26	power	power	NN
18637	10824	27	,	,	,
18637	10824	28	the	the	DT
18637	10824	29	rights	right	NNS
18637	10824	30	threatened	threaten	VBD
18637	10824	31	"	"	``
18637	10824	32	must	must	MD
18637	10824	33	be	be	VB
18637	10824	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	10824	35	of	of	IN
18637	10824	36	persons	person	NNS
18637	10824	37	or	or	CC
18637	10824	38	property	property	NN
18637	10824	39	,	,	,
18637	10824	40	not	not	RB
18637	10824	41	merely	merely	RB
18637	10824	42	political	political	JJ
18637	10824	43	rights	right	NNS
18637	10824	44	,	,	,
18637	10824	45	which	which	WDT
18637	10824	46	do	do	VBP
18637	10824	47	not	not	RB
18637	10824	48	belong	belong	VB
18637	10824	49	to	to	IN
18637	10824	50	the	the	DT
18637	10824	51	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10824	52	of	of	IN
18637	10824	53	a	a	DT
18637	10824	54	court	court	NN
18637	10824	55	,	,	,
18637	10824	56	either	either	CC
18637	10824	57	in	in	IN
18637	10824	58	law	law	NN
18637	10824	59	or	or	CC
18637	10824	60	equity	equity	NN
18637	10824	61	.	.	.
18637	10825	1	"	"	``
18637	10825	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10825	3	171	171	CD
18637	10825	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10825	5	The	the	DT
18637	10825	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	10825	7	of	of	IN
18637	10825	8	the	the	DT
18637	10825	9	Stanton	Stanton	NNP
18637	10825	10	case	case	NN
18637	10825	11	was	be	VBD
18637	10825	12	applied	apply	VBN
18637	10825	13	and	and	CC
18637	10825	14	elaborated	elaborate	VBN
18637	10825	15	in	in	IN
18637	10825	16	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	10825	17	_	_	NNP
18637	10825	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	10825	19	_	_	NNP
18637	10825	20	Mellon,[172	Mellon,[172	NNP
18637	10825	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10825	22	where	where	WRB
18637	10825	23	the	the	DT
18637	10825	24	State	State	NNP
18637	10825	25	in	in	IN
18637	10825	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10825	27	own	own	JJ
18637	10825	28	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	10825	29	and	and	CC
18637	10825	30	as	as	IN
18637	10825	31	_	_	NNP
18637	10825	32	parens	paren	VBZ
18637	10825	33	patriae	patriae	NNS
18637	10825	34	_	_	NNP
18637	10825	35	sought	seek	VBD
18637	10825	36	to	to	TO
18637	10825	37	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	10825	38	the	the	DT
18637	10825	39	administration	administration	NN
18637	10825	40	of	of	IN
18637	10825	41	the	the	DT
18637	10825	42	Maternity	Maternity	NNP
18637	10825	43	Act[173	Act[173	NNP
18637	10825	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10825	45	which	which	WDT
18637	10825	46	,	,	,
18637	10825	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10825	48	was	be	VBD
18637	10825	49	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	10825	50	,	,	,
18637	10825	51	was	be	VBD
18637	10825	52	an	an	DT
18637	10825	53	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	10825	54	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	10825	55	of	of	IN
18637	10825	56	the	the	DT
18637	10825	57	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	10825	58	rights	right	NNS
18637	10825	59	of	of	IN
18637	10825	60	the	the	DT
18637	10825	61	State	State	NNP
18637	10825	62	and	and	CC
18637	10825	63	an	an	DT
18637	10825	64	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	10825	65	of	of	IN
18637	10825	66	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10825	67	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	10825	68	.	.	.
18637	10826	1	The	the	DT
18637	10826	2	suit	suit	NN
18637	10826	3	was	be	VBD
18637	10826	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	10826	5	not	not	RB
18637	10826	6	justiciable	justiciable	NN
18637	10826	7	on	on	IN
18637	10826	8	the	the	DT
18637	10826	9	ground	ground	NN
18637	10826	10	that	that	IN
18637	10826	11	a	a	DT
18637	10826	12	State	state	NN
18637	10826	13	can	can	MD
18637	10826	14	not	not	RB
18637	10826	15	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	10826	16	a	a	DT
18637	10826	17	suit	suit	NN
18637	10826	18	either	either	CC
18637	10826	19	to	to	TO
18637	10826	20	protect	protect	VB
18637	10826	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10826	22	political	political	JJ
18637	10826	23	rights	right	NNS
18637	10826	24	or	or	CC
18637	10826	25	as	as	IN
18637	10826	26	_	_	NNP
18637	10826	27	parens	paren	NNS
18637	10826	28	patriae	patriae	NNS
18637	10826	29	_	_	NNP
18637	10826	30	to	to	TO
18637	10826	31	protect	protect	VB
18637	10826	32	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	10826	33	of	of	IN
18637	10826	34	the	the	DT
18637	10826	35	United	United	NNP
18637	10826	36	States	States	NNP
18637	10826	37	against	against	IN
18637	10826	38	the	the	DT
18637	10826	39	operation	operation	NN
18637	10826	40	of	of	IN
18637	10826	41	a	a	DT
18637	10826	42	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10826	43	law	law	NN
18637	10826	44	.	.	.
18637	10827	1	Concerning	concern	VBG
18637	10827	2	the	the	DT
18637	10827	3	right	right	NN
18637	10827	4	of	of	IN
18637	10827	5	a	a	DT
18637	10827	6	State	State	NNP
18637	10827	7	to	to	TO
18637	10827	8	sue	sue	VB
18637	10827	9	in	in	IN
18637	10827	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10827	11	own	own	JJ
18637	10827	12	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	10827	13	to	to	TO
18637	10827	14	protect	protect	VB
18637	10827	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10827	16	political	political	JJ
18637	10827	17	rights	right	NNS
18637	10827	18	,	,	,
18637	10827	19	the	the	DT
18637	10827	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10827	21	said	say	VBD
18637	10827	22	:	:	:
18637	10827	23	"	"	``
18637	10827	24	In	in	IN
18637	10827	25	that	that	DT
18637	10827	26	aspect	aspect	NN
18637	10827	27	of	of	IN
18637	10827	28	the	the	DT
18637	10827	29	case	case	NN
18637	10827	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10827	31	are	be	VBP
18637	10827	32	called	call	VBN
18637	10827	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	10827	34	to	to	TO
18637	10827	35	adjudicate	adjudicate	VB
18637	10827	36	,	,	,
18637	10827	37	not	not	RB
18637	10827	38	rights	right	NNS
18637	10827	39	of	of	IN
18637	10827	40	person	person	NN
18637	10827	41	or	or	CC
18637	10827	42	property	property	NN
18637	10827	43	,	,	,
18637	10827	44	not	not	RB
18637	10827	45	rights	right	NNS
18637	10827	46	of	of	IN
18637	10827	47	dominion	dominion	NN
18637	10827	48	over	over	IN
18637	10827	49	physical	physical	JJ
18637	10827	50	domain	domain	NN
18637	10827	51	,	,	,
18637	10827	52	not	not	RB
18637	10827	53	quasi	quasi	VB
18637	10827	54	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	10827	55	rights	right	NNS
18637	10827	56	actually	actually	RB
18637	10827	57	invaded	invade	VBN
18637	10827	58	or	or	CC
18637	10827	59	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	10827	60	,	,	,
18637	10827	61	but	but	CC
18637	10827	62	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	10827	63	questions	question	NNS
18637	10827	64	of	of	IN
18637	10827	65	political	political	JJ
18637	10827	66	power	power	NN
18637	10827	67	,	,	,
18637	10827	68	of	of	IN
18637	10827	69	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	10827	70	,	,	,
18637	10827	71	of	of	IN
18637	10827	72	government	government	NN
18637	10827	73	.	.	.
18637	10828	1	"	"	``
18637	10828	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10828	3	174	174	CD
18637	10828	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10828	5	However	however	RB
18637	10828	6	,	,	,
18637	10828	7	these	these	DT
18637	10828	8	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	10828	9	do	do	VBP
18637	10828	10	not	not	RB
18637	10828	11	affect	affect	VB
18637	10828	12	the	the	DT
18637	10828	13	right	right	NN
18637	10828	14	of	of	IN
18637	10828	15	a	a	DT
18637	10828	16	State	State	NNP
18637	10828	17	as	as	IN
18637	10828	18	_	_	NNP
18637	10828	19	parens	paren	VBZ
18637	10828	20	patriae	patriae	NNS
18637	10828	21	_	_	NNP
18637	10828	22	to	to	TO
18637	10828	23	intervene	intervene	VB
18637	10828	24	in	in	IN
18637	10828	25	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	10828	26	of	of	IN
18637	10828	27	the	the	DT
18637	10828	28	economic	economic	JJ
18637	10828	29	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	10828	30	of	of	IN
18637	10828	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10828	32	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	10828	33	against	against	IN
18637	10828	34	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	10828	35	rates	rate	NNS
18637	10828	36	set	set	VBN
18637	10828	37	by	by	IN
18637	10828	38	an	an	DT
18637	10828	39	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	10828	40	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	10828	41	combination	combination	NN
18637	10828	42	of	of	IN
18637	10828	43	carriers,[175	carriers,[175	NN
18637	10828	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10828	45	or	or	CC
18637	10828	46	the	the	DT
18637	10828	47	right	right	NN
18637	10828	48	of	of	IN
18637	10828	49	a	a	DT
18637	10828	50	State	State	NNP
18637	10828	51	to	to	TO
18637	10828	52	assert	assert	VB
18637	10828	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10828	54	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	10828	55	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	10828	56	rights	right	NNS
18637	10828	57	over	over	IN
18637	10828	58	wild	wild	JJ
18637	10828	59	life	life	NN
18637	10828	60	within	within	IN
18637	10828	61	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10828	62	domain,[176	domain,[176	NN
18637	10828	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10828	64	or	or	CC
18637	10828	65	to	to	TO
18637	10828	66	protect	protect	VB
18637	10828	67	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10828	68	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	10828	69	against	against	IN
18637	10828	70	the	the	DT
18637	10828	71	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	10828	72	of	of	IN
18637	10828	73	noxious	noxious	JJ
18637	10828	74	gases	gas	NNS
18637	10828	75	by	by	IN
18637	10828	76	an	an	DT
18637	10828	77	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	10828	78	plant	plant	NN
18637	10828	79	in	in	IN
18637	10828	80	an	an	DT
18637	10828	81	adjacent	adjacent	JJ
18637	10828	82	State	state	NN
18637	10828	83	.	.	.
18637	10829	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10829	2	177	177	CD
18637	10829	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10829	4	ABSTRACT	ABSTRACT	NNP
18637	10829	5	,	,	,
18637	10829	6	CONTINGENT	CONTINGENT	NNP
18637	10829	7	,	,	,
18637	10829	8	AND	and	CC
18637	10829	9	HYPOTHETICAL	HYPOTHETICAL	NNP
18637	10829	10	QUESTIONS	questions	VBP
18637	10829	11	Closely	closely	RB
18637	10829	12	related	relate	VBN
18637	10829	13	to	to	IN
18637	10829	14	the	the	DT
18637	10829	15	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	10829	16	of	of	IN
18637	10829	17	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	10829	18	parties	party	NNS
18637	10829	19	and	and	CC
18637	10829	20	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	10829	21	interests	interest	NNS
18637	10829	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	10829	23	that	that	DT
18637	10829	24	of	of	IN
18637	10829	25	a	a	DT
18637	10829	26	_	_	NNP
18637	10829	27	real	real	JJ
18637	10829	28	_	_	NNP
18637	10829	29	issue	issue	NN
18637	10829	30	as	as	IN
18637	10829	31	contrasted	contrast	VBN
18637	10829	32	with	with	IN
18637	10829	33	_	_	NNP
18637	10829	34	speculative	speculative	JJ
18637	10829	35	_	_	NNP
18637	10829	36	,	,	,
18637	10829	37	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	10829	38	,	,	,
18637	10829	39	hypothetical	hypothetical	JJ
18637	10829	40	,	,	,
18637	10829	41	or	or	CC
18637	10829	42	moot	moot	JJ
18637	10829	43	cases	case	NNS
18637	10829	44	.	.	.
18637	10830	1	As	as	IN
18637	10830	2	put	put	VBN
18637	10830	3	by	by	IN
18637	10830	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10830	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10830	6	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	10830	7	in	in	IN
18637	10830	8	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	10830	9	State	State	NNP
18637	10830	10	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	10830	11	of	of	IN
18637	10830	12	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	10830	13	_	_	NNP
18637	10830	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	10830	15	_	_	NNP
18637	10830	16	McAdory,[178	McAdory,[178	NNP
18637	10830	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10830	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10830	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	10830	20	long	long	RB
18637	10830	21	been	be	VBN
18637	10830	22	the	the	DT
18637	10830	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10830	24	's	's	POS
18637	10830	25	"	"	``
18637	10830	26	considered	consider	VBN
18637	10830	27	practice	practice	NN
18637	10830	28	not	not	RB
18637	10830	29	to	to	TO
18637	10830	30	decide	decide	VB
18637	10830	31	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	10830	32	,	,	,
18637	10830	33	hypothetical	hypothetical	JJ
18637	10830	34	or	or	CC
18637	10830	35	contingent	contingent	JJ
18637	10830	36	questions	question	NNS
18637	10830	37	,	,	,
18637	10830	38	"	"	''
18637	10830	39	or	or	CC
18637	10830	40	as	as	IN
18637	10830	41	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10830	42	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	10830	43	said	say	VBD
18637	10830	44	years	year	NNS
18637	10830	45	earlier	early	RBR
18637	10830	46	by	by	IN
18637	10830	47	way	way	NN
18637	10830	48	of	of	IN
18637	10830	49	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	10830	50	,	,	,
18637	10830	51	a	a	DT
18637	10830	52	party	party	NN
18637	10830	53	can	can	MD
18637	10830	54	not	not	RB
18637	10830	55	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	10830	56	a	a	DT
18637	10830	57	suit	suit	NN
18637	10830	58	"	"	''
18637	10830	59	for	for	IN
18637	10830	60	a	a	DT
18637	10830	61	mere	mere	JJ
18637	10830	62	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	10830	63	in	in	IN
18637	10830	64	the	the	DT
18637	10830	65	air	air	NN
18637	10830	66	.	.	.
18637	10831	1	"	"	``
18637	10831	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10831	3	179	179	CD
18637	10831	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10831	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	10831	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10831	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10831	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10831	9	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	10831	10	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	10831	11	Commission,[180	Commission,[180	NNP
18637	10831	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10831	13	presents	present	VBZ
18637	10831	14	a	a	DT
18637	10831	15	good	good	JJ
18637	10831	16	illustration	illustration	NN
18637	10831	17	of	of	IN
18637	10831	18	an	an	DT
18637	10831	19	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	10831	20	question	question	NN
18637	10831	21	.	.	.
18637	10832	1	Here	here	RB
18637	10832	2	,	,	,
18637	10832	3	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	10832	4	attempted	attempt	VBD
18637	10832	5	to	to	TO
18637	10832	6	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	10832	7	the	the	DT
18637	10832	8	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10832	9	of	of	IN
18637	10832	10	the	the	DT
18637	10832	11	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	10832	12	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10832	13	of	of	IN
18637	10832	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	10832	15	on	on	IN
18637	10832	16	the	the	DT
18637	10832	17	ground	ground	NN
18637	10832	18	that	that	IN
18637	10832	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10832	20	invaded	invade	VBD
18637	10832	21	the	the	DT
18637	10832	22	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	10832	23	rights	right	NNS
18637	10832	24	of	of	IN
18637	10832	25	the	the	DT
18637	10832	26	State	State	NNP
18637	10832	27	.	.	.
18637	10833	1	The	the	DT
18637	10833	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10833	3	dismissed	dismiss	VBD
18637	10833	4	the	the	DT
18637	10833	5	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	10833	6	as	as	IN
18637	10833	7	presenting	present	VBG
18637	10833	8	no	no	DT
18637	10833	9	case	case	NN
18637	10833	10	or	or	CC
18637	10833	11	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10833	12	,	,	,
18637	10833	13	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	10833	14	:	:	:
18637	10833	15	"	"	``
18637	10833	16	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10833	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	10833	18	only	only	RB
18637	10833	19	where	where	WRB
18637	10833	20	rights	right	NNS
18637	10833	21	,	,	,
18637	10833	22	in	in	IN
18637	10833	23	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10833	24	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	10833	25	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	10833	26	of	of	IN
18637	10833	27	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10833	28	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	10833	29	,	,	,
18637	10833	30	are	be	VBP
18637	10833	31	being	be	VBG
18637	10833	32	,	,	,
18637	10833	33	or	or	CC
18637	10833	34	about	about	IN
18637	10833	35	to	to	TO
18637	10833	36	be	be	VB
18637	10833	37	,	,	,
18637	10833	38	affected	affect	VBN
18637	10833	39	prejudicially	prejudicially	RB
18637	10833	40	by	by	IN
18637	10833	41	the	the	DT
18637	10833	42	application	application	NN
18637	10833	43	or	or	CC
18637	10833	44	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10833	45	of	of	IN
18637	10833	46	a	a	DT
18637	10833	47	statute	statute	NN
18637	10833	48	that	that	IN
18637	10833	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10833	50	validity	validity	NN
18637	10833	51	may	may	MD
18637	10833	52	be	be	VB
18637	10833	53	called	call	VBN
18637	10833	54	in	in	IN
18637	10833	55	question	question	NN
18637	10833	56	by	by	IN
18637	10833	57	a	a	DT
18637	10833	58	suitor	suitor	NN
18637	10833	59	and	and	CC
18637	10833	60	determined	determine	VBN
18637	10833	61	by	by	IN
18637	10833	62	an	an	DT
18637	10833	63	exertion	exertion	NN
18637	10833	64	of	of	IN
18637	10833	65	the	the	DT
18637	10833	66	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10833	67	power	power	NN
18637	10833	68	.	.	.
18637	10834	1	"	"	``
18637	10834	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10834	3	181	181	CD
18637	10834	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10834	5	Again	again	RB
18637	10834	6	in	in	IN
18637	10834	7	Ashwander	Ashwander	NNP
18637	10834	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10834	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	10834	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10834	11	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	10834	12	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	10834	13	Authority,[182	authority,[182	CD
18637	10834	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10834	15	the	the	DT
18637	10834	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10834	17	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	10834	18	to	to	TO
18637	10834	19	decide	decide	VB
18637	10834	20	any	any	DT
18637	10834	21	issue	issue	NN
18637	10834	22	save	save	IN
18637	10834	23	that	that	DT
18637	10834	24	of	of	IN
18637	10834	25	the	the	DT
18637	10834	26	validity	validity	NN
18637	10834	27	of	of	IN
18637	10834	28	the	the	DT
18637	10834	29	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	10834	30	between	between	IN
18637	10834	31	the	the	DT
18637	10834	32	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	10834	33	and	and	CC
18637	10834	34	the	the	DT
18637	10834	35	Company	Company	NNP
18637	10834	36	because	because	IN
18637	10834	37	,	,	,
18637	10834	38	"	"	``
18637	10834	39	The	the	DT
18637	10834	40	pronouncements	pronouncement	NNS
18637	10834	41	,	,	,
18637	10834	42	policies	policy	NNS
18637	10834	43	and	and	CC
18637	10834	44	program	program	NN
18637	10834	45	of	of	IN
18637	10834	46	the	the	DT
18637	10834	47	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	10834	48	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	10834	49	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	10834	50	and	and	CC
18637	10834	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10834	52	directors	director	NNS
18637	10834	53	,	,	,
18637	10834	54	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10834	55	motives	motive	NNS
18637	10834	56	and	and	CC
18637	10834	57	desires	desire	NNS
18637	10834	58	,	,	,
18637	10834	59	did	do	VBD
18637	10834	60	not	not	RB
18637	10834	61	give	give	VB
18637	10834	62	rise	rise	NN
18637	10834	63	to	to	IN
18637	10834	64	a	a	DT
18637	10834	65	justiciable	justiciable	JJ
18637	10834	66	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10834	67	save	save	VB
18637	10834	68	as	as	IN
18637	10834	69	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10834	70	had	have	VBD
18637	10834	71	fruition	fruition	NN
18637	10834	72	in	in	IN
18637	10834	73	action	action	NN
18637	10834	74	of	of	IN
18637	10834	75	a	a	DT
18637	10834	76	definite	definite	JJ
18637	10834	77	and	and	CC
18637	10834	78	concrete	concrete	JJ
18637	10834	79	character	character	NN
18637	10834	80	constituting	constitute	VBG
18637	10834	81	an	an	DT
18637	10834	82	actual	actual	JJ
18637	10834	83	or	or	CC
18637	10834	84	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	10834	85	interference	interference	NN
18637	10834	86	with	with	IN
18637	10834	87	the	the	DT
18637	10834	88	rights	right	NNS
18637	10834	89	of	of	IN
18637	10834	90	the	the	DT
18637	10834	91	persons	person	NNS
18637	10834	92	complaining	complain	VBG
18637	10834	93	.	.	.
18637	10834	94	"	"	''
18637	10835	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10835	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10835	3	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	10835	4	cited	cite	VBD
18637	10835	5	New	New	NNP
18637	10835	6	York	York	NNP
18637	10835	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10835	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	10835	9	_	_	NNP
18637	10835	10	Illinois,[183	Illinois,[183	NNP
18637	10835	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10835	12	where	where	WRB
18637	10835	13	the	the	DT
18637	10835	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10835	15	dismissed	dismiss	VBD
18637	10835	16	a	a	DT
18637	10835	17	suit	suit	NN
18637	10835	18	as	as	IN
18637	10835	19	presenting	present	VBG
18637	10835	20	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	10835	21	questions	question	NNS
18637	10835	22	"	"	''
18637	10835	23	as	as	IN
18637	10835	24	to	to	IN
18637	10835	25	the	the	DT
18637	10835	26	possible	possible	JJ
18637	10835	27	effect	effect	NN
18637	10835	28	of	of	IN
18637	10835	29	the	the	DT
18637	10835	30	diversion	diversion	NN
18637	10835	31	of	of	IN
18637	10835	32	water	water	NN
18637	10835	33	from	from	IN
18637	10835	34	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	10835	35	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	10835	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	10835	37	hypothetical	hypothetical	JJ
18637	10835	38	water	water	NN
18637	10835	39	power	power	NN
18637	10835	40	developments	development	NNS
18637	10835	41	in	in	IN
18637	10835	42	the	the	DT
18637	10835	43	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	10835	44	future	future	NN
18637	10835	45	.	.	.
18637	10836	1	"	"	``
18637	10836	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10836	3	184	184	CD
18637	10836	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10836	5	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10836	6	also	also	RB
18637	10836	7	cited	cite	VBD
18637	10836	8	among	among	IN
18637	10836	9	other	other	JJ
18637	10836	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	10836	11	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	10836	12	_	_	NNP
18637	10836	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	10836	14	_	_	NNP
18637	10836	15	California,[185	California,[185	NNP
18637	10836	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10836	17	where	where	WRB
18637	10836	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10836	19	was	be	VBD
18637	10836	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	10836	21	that	that	IN
18637	10836	22	claims	claim	NNS
18637	10836	23	based	base	VBN
18637	10836	24	merely	merely	RB
18637	10836	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	10836	26	assumed	assumed	JJ
18637	10836	27	potential	potential	JJ
18637	10836	28	invasions	invasion	NNS
18637	10836	29	of	of	IN
18637	10836	30	rights	right	NNS
18637	10836	31	were	be	VBD
18637	10836	32	not	not	RB
18637	10836	33	enough	enough	JJ
18637	10836	34	to	to	TO
18637	10836	35	warrant	warrant	VB
18637	10836	36	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10836	37	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	10836	38	.	.	.
18637	10837	1	The	the	DT
18637	10837	2	concepts	concept	NNS
18637	10837	3	of	of	IN
18637	10837	4	real	real	JJ
18637	10837	5	interests	interest	NNS
18637	10837	6	and	and	CC
18637	10837	7	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	10837	8	questions	question	NNS
18637	10837	9	again	again	RB
18637	10837	10	appear	appear	VBP
18637	10837	11	prominently	prominently	RB
18637	10837	12	in	in	IN
18637	10837	13	United	United	NNP
18637	10837	14	Public	Public	NNP
18637	10837	15	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	10837	16	of	of	IN
18637	10837	17	America	America	NNP
18637	10837	18	_	_	NNP
18637	10837	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	10837	20	_	_	NNP
18637	10837	21	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	10837	22	.	.	.
18637	10838	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10838	2	186	186	CD
18637	10838	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10838	4	Here	here	RB
18637	10838	5	a	a	DT
18637	10838	6	number	number	NN
18637	10838	7	of	of	IN
18637	10838	8	government	government	NN
18637	10838	9	employees	employee	NNS
18637	10838	10	sued	sue	VBD
18637	10838	11	to	to	TO
18637	10838	12	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	10838	13	the	the	DT
18637	10838	14	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	10838	15	Service	Service	NNP
18637	10838	16	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	10838	17	from	from	IN
18637	10838	18	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	10838	19	the	the	DT
18637	10838	20	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
18637	10838	21	of	of	IN
18637	10838	22	the	the	DT
18637	10838	23	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	10838	24	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10838	25	against	against	IN
18637	10838	26	activity	activity	NN
18637	10838	27	in	in	IN
18637	10838	28	political	political	JJ
18637	10838	29	management	management	NN
18637	10838	30	or	or	CC
18637	10838	31	campaigns	campaign	NNS
18637	10838	32	,	,	,
18637	10838	33	and	and	CC
18637	10838	34	to	to	TO
18637	10838	35	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	10838	36	a	a	DT
18637	10838	37	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	10838	38	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10838	39	that	that	IN
18637	10838	40	the	the	DT
18637	10838	41	act	act	NN
18637	10838	42	was	be	VBD
18637	10838	43	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	10838	44	.	.	.
18637	10839	1	Except	except	IN
18637	10839	2	for	for	IN
18637	10839	3	one	one	CD
18637	10839	4	of	of	IN
18637	10839	5	the	the	DT
18637	10839	6	employees	employee	NNS
18637	10839	7	none	none	NN
18637	10839	8	had	have	VBD
18637	10839	9	violated	violate	VBN
18637	10839	10	the	the	DT
18637	10839	11	act	act	NN
18637	10839	12	,	,	,
18637	10839	13	but	but	CC
18637	10839	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10839	15	did	do	VBD
18637	10839	16	state	state	NN
18637	10839	17	that	that	IN
18637	10839	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10839	19	desired	desire	VBD
18637	10839	20	to	to	TO
18637	10839	21	engage	engage	VB
18637	10839	22	in	in	IN
18637	10839	23	the	the	DT
18637	10839	24	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	10839	25	political	political	JJ
18637	10839	26	activities	activity	NNS
18637	10839	27	.	.	.
18637	10840	1	The	the	DT
18637	10840	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10840	3	held	hold	VBD
18637	10840	4	that	that	IN
18637	10840	5	as	as	IN
18637	10840	6	to	to	IN
18637	10840	7	all	all	PDT
18637	10840	8	the	the	DT
18637	10840	9	parties	party	NNS
18637	10840	10	save	save	VB
18637	10840	11	the	the	DT
18637	10840	12	one	one	NN
18637	10840	13	who	who	WP
18637	10840	14	had	have	VBD
18637	10840	15	violated	violate	VBN
18637	10840	16	the	the	DT
18637	10840	17	act	act	NN
18637	10840	18	there	there	EX
18637	10840	19	was	be	VBD
18637	10840	20	no	no	DT
18637	10840	21	justiciable	justiciable	JJ
18637	10840	22	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10840	23	.	.	.
18637	10841	1	"	"	``
18637	10841	2	Concrete	concrete	JJ
18637	10841	3	legal	legal	JJ
18637	10841	4	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10841	5	,	,	,
18637	10841	6	presented	present	VBN
18637	10841	7	in	in	IN
18637	10841	8	actual	actual	JJ
18637	10841	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	10841	10	,	,	,
18637	10841	11	not	not	RB
18637	10841	12	abstractions	abstraction	NNS
18637	10841	13	"	"	''
18637	10841	14	were	be	VBD
18637	10841	15	declared	declare	VBN
18637	10841	16	to	to	TO
18637	10841	17	be	be	VB
18637	10841	18	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	10841	19	.	.	.
18637	10842	1	The	the	DT
18637	10842	2	generality	generality	NN
18637	10842	3	of	of	IN
18637	10842	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10842	5	objection	objection	NN
18637	10842	6	was	be	VBD
18637	10842	7	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	10842	8	as	as	IN
18637	10842	9	really	really	RB
18637	10842	10	an	an	DT
18637	10842	11	attack	attack	NN
18637	10842	12	on	on	IN
18637	10842	13	the	the	DT
18637	10842	14	political	political	JJ
18637	10842	15	expediency	expediency	NN
18637	10842	16	of	of	IN
18637	10842	17	the	the	DT
18637	10842	18	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	10842	19	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10842	20	.	.	.
18637	10843	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10843	2	187	187	CD
18637	10843	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10843	4	From	from	IN
18637	10843	5	the	the	DT
18637	10843	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	10843	7	that	that	IN
18637	10843	8	courts	court	NNS
18637	10843	9	will	will	MD
18637	10843	10	not	not	RB
18637	10843	11	render	render	VB
18637	10843	12	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	10843	13	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	10843	14	or	or	CC
18637	10843	15	write	write	VB
18637	10843	16	essays	essay	NNS
18637	10843	17	in	in	IN
18637	10843	18	political	political	JJ
18637	10843	19	theory	theory	NN
18637	10843	20	on	on	IN
18637	10843	21	speculative	speculative	JJ
18637	10843	22	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10843	23	,	,	,
18637	10843	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10843	25	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	10843	26	logically	logically	RB
18637	10843	27	that	that	IN
18637	10843	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10843	29	will	will	MD
18637	10843	30	not	not	RB
18637	10843	31	determine	determine	VB
18637	10843	32	moot	moot	JJ
18637	10843	33	cases	case	NNS
18637	10843	34	or	or	CC
18637	10843	35	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10843	36	arranged	arrange	VBN
18637	10843	37	by	by	IN
18637	10843	38	collusion	collusion	NN
18637	10843	39	between	between	IN
18637	10843	40	parties	party	NNS
18637	10843	41	who	who	WP
18637	10843	42	have	have	VBP
18637	10843	43	no	no	DT
18637	10843	44	opposing	oppose	VBG
18637	10843	45	interests	interest	NNS
18637	10843	46	.	.	.
18637	10844	1	A	a	DT
18637	10844	2	moot	moot	JJ
18637	10844	3	case	case	NN
18637	10844	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	10844	5	been	be	VBN
18637	10844	6	defined	define	VBN
18637	10844	7	as	as	IN
18637	10844	8	"	"	``
18637	10844	9	one	one	CD
18637	10844	10	which	which	WDT
18637	10844	11	seeks	seek	VBZ
18637	10844	12	to	to	TO
18637	10844	13	get	get	VB
18637	10844	14	a	a	DT
18637	10844	15	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10844	16	on	on	IN
18637	10844	17	a	a	DT
18637	10844	18	pretended	pretend	VBN
18637	10844	19	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10844	20	,	,	,
18637	10844	21	when	when	WRB
18637	10844	22	in	in	IN
18637	10844	23	reality	reality	NN
18637	10844	24	there	there	EX
18637	10844	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	10844	26	none	none	NN
18637	10844	27	,	,	,
18637	10844	28	or	or	CC
18637	10844	29	a	a	DT
18637	10844	30	decision	decision	NN
18637	10844	31	in	in	IN
18637	10844	32	advance	advance	NN
18637	10844	33	about	about	IN
18637	10844	34	a	a	DT
18637	10844	35	right	right	NN
18637	10844	36	before	before	IN
18637	10844	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10844	38	has	have	VBZ
18637	10844	39	been	be	VBN
18637	10844	40	actually	actually	RB
18637	10844	41	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	10844	42	and	and	CC
18637	10844	43	contested	contest	VBN
18637	10844	44	,	,	,
18637	10844	45	or	or	CC
18637	10844	46	a	a	DT
18637	10844	47	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10844	48	upon	upon	IN
18637	10844	49	some	some	DT
18637	10844	50	matter	matter	NN
18637	10844	51	which	which	WDT
18637	10844	52	,	,	,
18637	10844	53	when	when	WRB
18637	10844	54	rendered	render	VBN
18637	10844	55	,	,	,
18637	10844	56	for	for	IN
18637	10844	57	any	any	DT
18637	10844	58	reason	reason	NN
18637	10844	59	,	,	,
18637	10844	60	can	can	MD
18637	10844	61	not	not	RB
18637	10844	62	have	have	VB
18637	10844	63	any	any	DT
18637	10844	64	practical	practical	JJ
18637	10844	65	legal	legal	JJ
18637	10844	66	effect	effect	NN
18637	10844	67	upon	upon	IN
18637	10844	68	a	a	DT
18637	10844	69	then	then	RB
18637	10844	70	existing	exist	VBG
18637	10844	71	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10844	72	.	.	.
18637	10845	1	"	"	``
18637	10845	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10845	3	188	188	CD
18637	10845	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10845	5	Cases	case	NNS
18637	10845	6	may	may	MD
18637	10845	7	become	become	VB
18637	10845	8	moot	moot	JJ
18637	10845	9	because	because	IN
18637	10845	10	of	of	IN
18637	10845	11	a	a	DT
18637	10845	12	change	change	NN
18637	10845	13	in	in	IN
18637	10845	14	the	the	DT
18637	10845	15	law	law	NN
18637	10845	16	,	,	,
18637	10845	17	or	or	CC
18637	10845	18	the	the	DT
18637	10845	19	status	status	NN
18637	10845	20	of	of	IN
18637	10845	21	the	the	DT
18637	10845	22	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	10845	23	,	,	,
18637	10845	24	or	or	CC
18637	10845	25	because	because	IN
18637	10845	26	of	of	IN
18637	10845	27	some	some	DT
18637	10845	28	act	act	NN
18637	10845	29	of	of	IN
18637	10845	30	the	the	DT
18637	10845	31	parties	party	NNS
18637	10845	32	which	which	WDT
18637	10845	33	dissolves	dissolve	VBZ
18637	10845	34	the	the	DT
18637	10845	35	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10845	36	.	.	.
18637	10846	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10846	2	189	189	CD
18637	10846	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10846	4	Just	just	RB
18637	10846	5	as	as	IN
18637	10846	6	courts	court	NNS
18637	10846	7	will	will	MD
18637	10846	8	not	not	RB
18637	10846	9	speculate	speculate	VB
18637	10846	10	an	an	DT
18637	10846	11	hypothetical	hypothetical	JJ
18637	10846	12	question	question	NN
18637	10846	13	,	,	,
18637	10846	14	so	so	IN
18637	10846	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10846	16	will	will	MD
18637	10846	17	not	not	RB
18637	10846	18	analyze	analyze	VB
18637	10846	19	dead	dead	JJ
18637	10846	20	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10846	21	.	.	.
18637	10847	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10847	2	190	190	LS
18637	10847	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10847	4	The	the	DT
18637	10847	5	duty	duty	NN
18637	10847	6	of	of	IN
18637	10847	7	every	every	DT
18637	10847	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10847	9	court	court	NN
18637	10847	10	,	,	,
18637	10847	11	said	say	VBD
18637	10847	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10847	13	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	10847	14	,	,	,
18637	10847	15	"	"	''
18637	10847	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	10847	17	to	to	TO
18637	10847	18	decide	decide	VB
18637	10847	19	actual	actual	JJ
18637	10847	20	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	10847	21	by	by	IN
18637	10847	22	a	a	DT
18637	10847	23	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10847	24	which	which	WDT
18637	10847	25	can	can	MD
18637	10847	26	be	be	VB
18637	10847	27	carried	carry	VBN
18637	10847	28	into	into	IN
18637	10847	29	effect	effect	NN
18637	10847	30	,	,	,
18637	10847	31	and	and	CC
18637	10847	32	not	not	RB
18637	10847	33	give	give	VB
18637	10847	34	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	10847	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	10847	36	moot	moot	JJ
18637	10847	37	questions	question	NNS
18637	10847	38	or	or	CC
18637	10847	39	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	10847	40	propositions	proposition	NNS
18637	10847	41	,	,	,
18637	10847	42	or	or	CC
18637	10847	43	to	to	TO
18637	10847	44	declare	declare	VB
18637	10847	45	principles	principle	NNS
18637	10847	46	or	or	CC
18637	10847	47	rules	rule	NNS
18637	10847	48	of	of	IN
18637	10847	49	law	law	NN
18637	10847	50	which	which	WDT
18637	10847	51	can	can	MD
18637	10847	52	not	not	RB
18637	10847	53	affect	affect	VB
18637	10847	54	the	the	DT
18637	10847	55	matter	matter	NN
18637	10847	56	at	at	IN
18637	10847	57	issue	issue	NN
18637	10847	58	in	in	IN
18637	10847	59	the	the	DT
18637	10847	60	case	case	NN
18637	10847	61	before	before	IN
18637	10847	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10847	63	.	.	.
18637	10848	1	"	"	``
18637	10848	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10848	3	191	191	CD
18637	10848	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10848	5	POLITICAL	POLITICAL	NNP
18637	10848	6	QUESTIONS	questions	NN
18637	10848	7	The	the	DT
18637	10848	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	10848	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	10848	10	been	be	VBN
18637	10848	11	long	long	RB
18637	10848	12	established	establish	VBN
18637	10848	13	that	that	IN
18637	10848	14	the	the	DT
18637	10848	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	10848	16	have	have	VBP
18637	10848	17	no	no	DT
18637	10848	18	general	general	JJ
18637	10848	19	supervisory	supervisory	JJ
18637	10848	20	power	power	NN
18637	10848	21	over	over	IN
18637	10848	22	the	the	DT
18637	10848	23	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10848	24	or	or	CC
18637	10848	25	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	10848	26	branches	branch	NNS
18637	10848	27	of	of	IN
18637	10848	28	government	government	NN
18637	10848	29	.	.	.
18637	10849	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10849	2	192	192	CD
18637	10849	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10849	4	In	in	IN
18637	10849	5	Decatur	Decatur	NNP
18637	10849	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10849	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10849	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10849	9	Paulding,[193	Paulding,[193	NNP
18637	10849	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10849	11	which	which	WDT
18637	10849	12	involved	involve	VBD
18637	10849	13	an	an	DT
18637	10849	14	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	10849	15	by	by	IN
18637	10849	16	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	10849	17	to	to	TO
18637	10849	18	compel	compel	VB
18637	10849	19	the	the	DT
18637	10849	20	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10849	21	of	of	IN
18637	10849	22	the	the	DT
18637	10849	23	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	10849	24	to	to	TO
18637	10849	25	pay	pay	VB
18637	10849	26	a	a	DT
18637	10849	27	pension	pension	NN
18637	10849	28	,	,	,
18637	10849	29	the	the	DT
18637	10849	30	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10849	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10849	32	in	in	IN
18637	10849	33	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	10849	34	denial	denial	NN
18637	10849	35	of	of	IN
18637	10849	36	relief	relief	NN
18637	10849	37	stated	state	VBD
18637	10849	38	:	:	:
18637	10849	39	"	"	``
18637	10849	40	The	the	DT
18637	10849	41	interference	interference	NN
18637	10849	42	of	of	IN
18637	10849	43	the	the	DT
18637	10849	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	10849	45	with	with	IN
18637	10849	46	the	the	DT
18637	10849	47	performance	performance	NN
18637	10849	48	of	of	IN
18637	10849	49	the	the	DT
18637	10849	50	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	10849	51	duties	duty	NNS
18637	10849	52	of	of	IN
18637	10849	53	the	the	DT
18637	10849	54	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10849	55	departments	department	NNS
18637	10849	56	of	of	IN
18637	10849	57	the	the	DT
18637	10849	58	government	government	NN
18637	10849	59	,	,	,
18637	10849	60	would	would	MD
18637	10849	61	be	be	VB
18637	10849	62	productive	productive	JJ
18637	10849	63	of	of	IN
18637	10849	64	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	10849	65	but	but	IN
18637	10849	66	mischief	mischief	NN
18637	10849	67	;	;	:
18637	10849	68	and	and	CC
18637	10849	69	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10849	70	are	be	VBP
18637	10849	71	quite	quite	RB
18637	10849	72	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	10849	73	,	,	,
18637	10849	74	that	that	IN
18637	10849	75	such	such	PDT
18637	10849	76	a	a	DT
18637	10849	77	power	power	NN
18637	10849	78	was	be	VBD
18637	10849	79	never	never	RB
18637	10849	80	intended	intend	VBN
18637	10849	81	to	to	TO
18637	10849	82	be	be	VB
18637	10849	83	given	give	VBN
18637	10849	84	to	to	IN
18637	10849	85	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10849	86	.	.	.
18637	10850	1	"	"	``
18637	10850	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10850	3	194	194	CD
18637	10850	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10850	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10850	6	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	10850	7	,	,	,
18637	10850	8	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	10850	9	,	,	,
18637	10850	10	that	that	IN
18637	10850	11	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	10850	12	will	will	MD
18637	10850	13	lie	lie	VB
18637	10850	14	against	against	IN
18637	10850	15	an	an	DT
18637	10850	16	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10850	17	official	official	NN
18637	10850	18	only	only	RB
18637	10850	19	to	to	TO
18637	10850	20	compel	compel	VB
18637	10850	21	the	the	DT
18637	10850	22	performance	performance	NN
18637	10850	23	of	of	IN
18637	10850	24	a	a	DT
18637	10850	25	ministerial	ministerial	JJ
18637	10850	26	duty	duty	NN
18637	10850	27	which	which	WDT
18637	10850	28	admits	admit	VBZ
18637	10850	29	of	of	IN
18637	10850	30	no	no	DT
18637	10850	31	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	10850	32	as	as	IN
18637	10850	33	contrasted	contrast	VBN
18637	10850	34	with	with	IN
18637	10850	35	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10850	36	or	or	CC
18637	10850	37	political	political	JJ
18637	10850	38	duties	duty	NNS
18637	10850	39	which	which	WDT
18637	10850	40	admit	admit	VBP
18637	10850	41	of	of	IN
18637	10850	42	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	10850	43	.	.	.
18637	10851	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10851	2	195	195	CD
18637	10851	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10851	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10851	5	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	10851	6	,	,	,
18637	10851	7	too	too	RB
18637	10851	8	,	,	,
18637	10851	9	that	that	IN
18637	10851	10	an	an	DT
18637	10851	11	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	10851	12	will	will	MD
18637	10851	13	not	not	RB
18637	10851	14	lie	lie	VB
18637	10851	15	against	against	IN
18637	10851	16	the	the	DT
18637	10851	17	President,[196	President,[196	NNP
18637	10851	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10851	19	or	or	CC
18637	10851	20	against	against	IN
18637	10851	21	the	the	DT
18637	10851	22	head	head	NN
18637	10851	23	of	of	IN
18637	10851	24	an	an	DT
18637	10851	25	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10851	26	department	department	NN
18637	10851	27	to	to	TO
18637	10851	28	control	control	VB
18637	10851	29	the	the	DT
18637	10851	30	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10851	31	of	of	IN
18637	10851	32	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10851	33	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	10851	34	.	.	.
18637	10852	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10852	2	197	197	CD
18637	10852	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10852	4	These	these	DT
18637	10852	5	principles	principle	NNS
18637	10852	6	are	be	VBP
18637	10852	7	well	well	RB
18637	10852	8	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
18637	10852	9	by	by	IN
18637	10852	10	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	10852	11	_	_	NNP
18637	10852	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	10852	13	_	_	NNP
18637	10852	14	Stanton,[198	Stanton,[198	NNP
18637	10852	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10852	16	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	10852	17	_	_	NNP
18637	10852	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	10852	19	_	_	NNP
18637	10852	20	Johnson,[199	Johnson,[199	NNP
18637	10852	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10852	22	and	and	CC
18637	10852	23	Kendall	Kendall	NNP
18637	10852	24	_	_	NNP
18637	10852	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	10852	26	_	_	NNP
18637	10852	27	United	United	NNP
18637	10852	28	States	States	NNP
18637	10852	29	ex	ex	NNP
18637	10852	30	rel	rel	NN
18637	10852	31	.	.	.
18637	10853	1	Stokes	stoke	NNS
18637	10853	2	.	.	.
18637	10854	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10854	2	200	200	CD
18637	10854	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10854	4	Origin	Origin	NNP
18637	10854	5	of	of	IN
18637	10854	6	the	the	DT
18637	10854	7	Concept	Concept	NNP
18637	10854	8	The	the	DT
18637	10854	9	concept	concept	NN
18637	10854	10	of	of	IN
18637	10854	11	"	"	``
18637	10854	12	political	political	JJ
18637	10854	13	question	question	NN
18637	10854	14	"	"	''
18637	10854	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	10854	16	an	an	DT
18637	10854	17	old	old	JJ
18637	10854	18	one	one	CD
18637	10854	19	.	.	.
18637	10855	1	As	as	RB
18637	10855	2	early	early	RB
18637	10855	3	as	as	IN
18637	10855	4	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	10855	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10855	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10855	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10855	8	Madison,[201	Madison,[201	NNP
18637	10855	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10855	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10855	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10855	12	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	10855	13	stated	state	VBD
18637	10855	14	:	:	:
18637	10855	15	"	"	``
18637	10855	16	The	the	DT
18637	10855	17	province	province	NN
18637	10855	18	of	of	IN
18637	10855	19	the	the	DT
18637	10855	20	court	court	NN
18637	10855	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	10855	22	,	,	,
18637	10855	23	solely	solely	RB
18637	10855	24	,	,	,
18637	10855	25	to	to	TO
18637	10855	26	decide	decide	VB
18637	10855	27	on	on	IN
18637	10855	28	the	the	DT
18637	10855	29	rights	right	NNS
18637	10855	30	of	of	IN
18637	10855	31	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	10855	32	,	,	,
18637	10855	33	not	not	RB
18637	10855	34	to	to	TO
18637	10855	35	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	10855	36	how	how	WRB
18637	10855	37	the	the	DT
18637	10855	38	executive	executive	NN
18637	10855	39	,	,	,
18637	10855	40	or	or	CC
18637	10855	41	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10855	42	officers	officer	NNS
18637	10855	43	,	,	,
18637	10855	44	perform	perform	VB
18637	10855	45	duties	duty	NNS
18637	10855	46	in	in	IN
18637	10855	47	which	which	WDT
18637	10855	48	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10855	49	have	have	VBP
18637	10855	50	a	a	DT
18637	10855	51	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	10855	52	.	.	.
18637	10856	1	Questions	question	NNS
18637	10856	2	in	in	IN
18637	10856	3	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10856	4	nature	nature	NN
18637	10856	5	political	political	JJ
18637	10856	6	,	,	,
18637	10856	7	or	or	CC
18637	10856	8	which	which	WDT
18637	10856	9	are	be	VBP
18637	10856	10	,	,	,
18637	10856	11	by	by	IN
18637	10856	12	the	the	DT
18637	10856	13	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	10856	14	and	and	CC
18637	10856	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	10856	16	,	,	,
18637	10856	17	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	10856	18	to	to	IN
18637	10856	19	the	the	DT
18637	10856	20	executive	executive	NN
18637	10856	21	,	,	,
18637	10856	22	can	can	MD
18637	10856	23	never	never	RB
18637	10856	24	be	be	VB
18637	10856	25	made	make	VBN
18637	10856	26	in	in	IN
18637	10856	27	this	this	DT
18637	10856	28	court	court	NN
18637	10856	29	.	.	.
18637	10856	30	"	"	''
18637	10857	1	The	the	DT
18637	10857	2	concept	concept	NN
18637	10857	3	,	,	,
18637	10857	4	as	as	IN
18637	10857	5	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	10857	6	from	from	IN
18637	10857	7	that	that	DT
18637	10857	8	of	of	IN
18637	10857	9	interference	interference	NN
18637	10857	10	with	with	IN
18637	10857	11	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10857	12	functions	function	NNS
18637	10857	13	,	,	,
18637	10857	14	was	be	VBD
18637	10857	15	first	first	RB
18637	10857	16	elaborated	elaborate	VBN
18637	10857	17	in	in	IN
18637	10857	18	Luther	Luther	NNP
18637	10857	19	_	_	NNP
18637	10857	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	10857	21	_	_	NNP
18637	10857	22	Borden,[202	Borden,[202	NNP
18637	10857	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10857	24	which	which	WDT
18637	10857	25	involved	involve	VBD
18637	10857	26	the	the	DT
18637	10857	27	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	10857	28	of	of	IN
18637	10857	29	"	"	``
18637	10857	30	a	a	DT
18637	10857	31	republican	republican	JJ
18637	10857	32	form	form	NN
18637	10857	33	"	"	''
18637	10857	34	of	of	IN
18637	10857	35	government	government	NN
18637	10857	36	and	and	CC
18637	10857	37	the	the	DT
18637	10857	38	question	question	NN
18637	10857	39	of	of	IN
18637	10857	40	the	the	DT
18637	10857	41	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	10857	42	government	government	NN
18637	10857	43	of	of	IN
18637	10857	44	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	10857	45	Island	Island	NNP
18637	10857	46	among	among	IN
18637	10857	47	two	two	CD
18637	10857	48	competing	compete	VBG
18637	10857	49	groups	group	NNS
18637	10857	50	purporting	purport	VBG
18637	10857	51	to	to	TO
18637	10857	52	act	act	VB
18637	10857	53	as	as	IN
18637	10857	54	the	the	DT
18637	10857	55	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	10857	56	authority	authority	NN
18637	10857	57	.	.	.
18637	10858	1	"	"	``
18637	10858	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10858	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	10858	4	the	the	DT
18637	10858	5	province	province	NN
18637	10858	6	of	of	IN
18637	10858	7	a	a	DT
18637	10858	8	court	court	NN
18637	10858	9	to	to	TO
18637	10858	10	expound	expound	VB
18637	10858	11	the	the	DT
18637	10858	12	law	law	NN
18637	10858	13	,	,	,
18637	10858	14	not	not	RB
18637	10858	15	to	to	TO
18637	10858	16	make	make	VB
18637	10858	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10858	18	,	,	,
18637	10858	19	"	"	''
18637	10858	20	declared	declare	VBD
18637	10858	21	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10858	22	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10858	23	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	10858	24	.	.	.
18637	10859	1	"	"	``
18637	10859	2	And	and	CC
18637	10859	3	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	10859	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10859	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	10859	6	no	no	DT
18637	10859	7	part	part	NN
18637	10859	8	of	of	IN
18637	10859	9	the	the	DT
18637	10859	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10859	11	functions	function	NNS
18637	10859	12	of	of	IN
18637	10859	13	any	any	DT
18637	10859	14	court	court	NN
18637	10859	15	of	of	IN
18637	10859	16	the	the	DT
18637	10859	17	United	United	NNP
18637	10859	18	States	States	NNP
18637	10859	19	to	to	TO
18637	10859	20	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	10859	21	the	the	DT
18637	10859	22	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	10859	23	of	of	IN
18637	10859	24	voters	voter	NNS
18637	10859	25	in	in	IN
18637	10859	26	a	a	DT
18637	10859	27	State	state	NN
18637	10859	28	,	,	,
18637	10859	29	*	*	NFP
18637	10859	30	*	*	NFP
18637	10859	31	*	*	NFP
18637	10859	32	;	;	:
18637	10859	33	nor	nor	CC
18637	10859	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	10859	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10859	36	the	the	DT
18637	10859	37	right	right	NN
18637	10859	38	to	to	TO
18637	10859	39	determine	determine	VB
18637	10859	40	what	what	WP
18637	10859	41	political	political	JJ
18637	10859	42	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	10859	43	the	the	DT
18637	10859	44	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	10859	45	of	of	IN
18637	10859	46	a	a	DT
18637	10859	47	State	state	NN
18637	10859	48	are	be	VBP
18637	10859	49	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	10859	50	to	to	IN
18637	10859	51	,	,	,
18637	10859	52	unless	unless	IN
18637	10859	53	there	there	EX
18637	10859	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	10859	55	an	an	DT
18637	10859	56	established	established	JJ
18637	10859	57	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	10859	58	or	or	CC
18637	10859	59	law	law	NN
18637	10859	60	to	to	TO
18637	10859	61	govern	govern	VB
18637	10859	62	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10859	63	decision	decision	NN
18637	10859	64	.	.	.
18637	10860	1	"	"	``
18637	10860	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10860	3	203	203	CD
18637	10860	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10860	5	The	the	DT
18637	10860	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10860	7	went	go	VBD
18637	10860	8	on	on	RP
18637	10860	9	to	to	TO
18637	10860	10	hold	hold	VB
18637	10860	11	that	that	IN
18637	10860	12	such	such	JJ
18637	10860	13	matters	matter	NNS
18637	10860	14	as	as	IN
18637	10860	15	the	the	DT
18637	10860	16	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	10860	17	to	to	IN
18637	10860	18	a	a	DT
18637	10860	19	State	state	NN
18637	10860	20	of	of	IN
18637	10860	21	a	a	DT
18637	10860	22	republican	republican	JJ
18637	10860	23	form	form	NN
18637	10860	24	of	of	IN
18637	10860	25	government	government	NN
18637	10860	26	and	and	CC
18637	10860	27	of	of	IN
18637	10860	28	protection	protection	NN
18637	10860	29	against	against	IN
18637	10860	30	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	10860	31	and	and	CC
18637	10860	32	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	10860	33	violence	violence	NN
18637	10860	34	are	be	VBP
18637	10860	35	political	political	JJ
18637	10860	36	questions	question	NNS
18637	10860	37	committed	commit	VBN
18637	10860	38	to	to	IN
18637	10860	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10860	40	and	and	CC
18637	10860	41	the	the	DT
18637	10860	42	President	President	NNP
18637	10860	43	whose	whose	WP$
18637	10860	44	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	10860	45	are	be	VBP
18637	10860	46	binding	bind	VBG
18637	10860	47	upon	upon	IN
18637	10860	48	the	the	DT
18637	10860	49	courts	court	NNS
18637	10860	50	.	.	.
18637	10861	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10861	2	204	204	CD
18637	10861	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10861	4	Exemplifications	exemplification	NNS
18637	10861	5	of	of	IN
18637	10861	6	the	the	DT
18637	10861	7	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	10861	8	From	from	IN
18637	10861	9	this	this	DT
18637	10861	10	case	case	NN
18637	10861	11	and	and	CC
18637	10861	12	later	later	JJ
18637	10861	13	applications	application	NNS
18637	10861	14	of	of	IN
18637	10861	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10861	16	,	,	,
18637	10861	17	a	a	DT
18637	10861	18	political	political	JJ
18637	10861	19	question	question	NN
18637	10861	20	may	may	MD
18637	10861	21	be	be	VB
18637	10861	22	defined	define	VBN
18637	10861	23	as	as	IN
18637	10861	24	a	a	DT
18637	10861	25	question	question	NN
18637	10861	26	relating	relate	VBG
18637	10861	27	to	to	IN
18637	10861	28	the	the	DT
18637	10861	29	possession	possession	NN
18637	10861	30	of	of	IN
18637	10861	31	political	political	JJ
18637	10861	32	power	power	NN
18637	10861	33	,	,	,
18637	10861	34	of	of	IN
18637	10861	35	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	10861	36	,	,	,
18637	10861	37	of	of	IN
18637	10861	38	government	government	NN
18637	10861	39	,	,	,
18637	10861	40	the	the	DT
18637	10861	41	determination	determination	NN
18637	10861	42	of	of	IN
18637	10861	43	which	which	WDT
18637	10861	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	10861	45	vested	vest	VBN
18637	10861	46	in	in	IN
18637	10861	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10861	48	and	and	CC
18637	10861	49	the	the	DT
18637	10861	50	President	President	NNP
18637	10861	51	whose	whose	WP$
18637	10861	52	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	10861	53	are	be	VBP
18637	10861	54	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	10861	55	upon	upon	IN
18637	10861	56	the	the	DT
18637	10861	57	courts	court	NNS
18637	10861	58	.	.	.
18637	10862	1	The	the	DT
18637	10862	2	more	more	RBR
18637	10862	3	common	common	JJ
18637	10862	4	classifications[205	classifications[205	NN
18637	10862	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10862	6	of	of	IN
18637	10862	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	10862	8	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10862	9	political	political	JJ
18637	10862	10	questions	question	NNS
18637	10862	11	are	be	VBP
18637	10862	12	:	:	:
18637	10862	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10862	14	1	1	LS
18637	10862	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10862	16	those	those	DT
18637	10862	17	which	which	WDT
18637	10862	18	raise	raise	VBP
18637	10862	19	the	the	DT
18637	10862	20	issue	issue	NN
18637	10862	21	of	of	IN
18637	10862	22	what	what	WDT
18637	10862	23	proof	proof	NN
18637	10862	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	10862	25	required	require	VBN
18637	10862	26	that	that	IN
18637	10862	27	a	a	DT
18637	10862	28	statute	statute	NN
18637	10862	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	10862	30	been	be	VBN
18637	10862	31	enacted,[206	enacted,[206	NNP
18637	10862	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10862	33	or	or	CC
18637	10862	34	a	a	DT
18637	10862	35	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10862	36	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	10862	37	ratified;[207	ratified;[207	NNPS
18637	10862	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10862	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10862	40	2	2	LS
18637	10862	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10862	42	questions	question	NNS
18637	10862	43	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10862	44	out	out	IN
18637	10862	45	of	of	IN
18637	10862	46	the	the	DT
18637	10862	47	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	10862	48	of	of	IN
18637	10862	49	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	10862	50	relations;[208	relations;[208	NNPS
18637	10862	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10862	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	10862	53	3	3	LS
18637	10862	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	10862	55	the	the	DT
18637	10862	56	termination	termination	NN
18637	10862	57	of	of	IN
18637	10862	58	wars,[209	wars,[209	NNP
18637	10862	59	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10862	60	or	or	CC
18637	10862	61	rebellions;[210	rebellions;[210	LS
18637	10862	62	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10862	63	the	the	DT
18637	10862	64	questions	question	NNS
18637	10862	65	of	of	IN
18637	10862	66	what	what	WP
18637	10862	67	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	10862	68	a	a	DT
18637	10862	69	republican	republican	JJ
18637	10862	70	form	form	NN
18637	10862	71	of	of	IN
18637	10862	72	government,[211	government,[211	NN
18637	10862	73	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10862	74	and	and	CC
18637	10862	75	the	the	DT
18637	10862	76	right	right	NN
18637	10862	77	of	of	IN
18637	10862	78	a	a	DT
18637	10862	79	state	state	NN
18637	10862	80	to	to	TO
18637	10862	81	protection	protection	VB
18637	10862	82	against	against	IN
18637	10862	83	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	10862	84	or	or	CC
18637	10862	85	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	10862	86	violence;[212	violence;[212	:
18637	10862	87	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10862	88	questions	question	NNS
18637	10862	89	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10862	90	out	out	IN
18637	10862	91	of	of	IN
18637	10862	92	political	political	JJ
18637	10862	93	actions	action	NNS
18637	10862	94	of	of	IN
18637	10862	95	States	States	NNPS
18637	10862	96	in	in	IN
18637	10862	97	determining	determine	VBG
18637	10862	98	the	the	DT
18637	10862	99	mode	mode	NN
18637	10862	100	of	of	IN
18637	10862	101	choosing	choose	VBG
18637	10862	102	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	10862	103	electors,[213	electors,[213	NN
18637	10862	104	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10862	105	State	State	NNP
18637	10862	106	officials,[214	officials,[214	NNP
18637	10862	107	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10862	108	and	and	CC
18637	10862	109	reapportionment	reapportionment	NN
18637	10862	110	of	of	IN
18637	10862	111	districts	district	NNS
18637	10862	112	for	for	IN
18637	10862	113	Congressional	Congressional	NNP
18637	10862	114	representation;[215	representation;[215	NNPS
18637	10862	115	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10862	116	and	and	CC
18637	10862	117	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10862	118	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10862	119	by	by	IN
18637	10862	120	States	state	NNS
18637	10862	121	to	to	TO
18637	10862	122	test	test	VB
18637	10862	123	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10862	124	political	political	JJ
18637	10862	125	and	and	CC
18637	10862	126	so	so	RB
18637	10862	127	-	-	HYPH
18637	10862	128	called	call	VBN
18637	10862	129	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	10862	130	rights	right	NNS
18637	10862	131	.	.	.
18637	10863	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10863	2	216	216	CD
18637	10863	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10863	4	The	the	DT
18637	10863	5	leading	leading	JJ
18637	10863	6	case	case	NN
18637	10863	7	on	on	IN
18637	10863	8	the	the	DT
18637	10863	9	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	10863	10	required	require	VBN
18637	10863	11	to	to	TO
18637	10863	12	prove	prove	VB
18637	10863	13	the	the	DT
18637	10863	14	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	10863	15	of	of	IN
18637	10863	16	a	a	DT
18637	10863	17	statute	statute	NN
18637	10863	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	10863	19	Field	Field	NNP
18637	10863	20	_	_	NNP
18637	10863	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	10863	22	_	_	NNP
18637	10863	23	Clark,[217	Clark,[217	NNP
18637	10863	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10863	25	where	where	WRB
18637	10863	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10863	27	was	be	VBD
18637	10863	28	held	hold	VBN
18637	10863	29	that	that	IN
18637	10863	30	the	the	DT
18637	10863	31	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	10863	32	of	of	IN
18637	10863	33	a	a	DT
18637	10863	34	statute	statute	NN
18637	10863	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	10863	36	conclusively	conclusively	RB
18637	10863	37	proved	prove	VBN
18637	10863	38	by	by	IN
18637	10863	39	the	the	DT
18637	10863	40	enrolled	enrolled	JJ
18637	10863	41	act	act	NN
18637	10863	42	signed	sign	VBN
18637	10863	43	by	by	IN
18637	10863	44	the	the	DT
18637	10863	45	speaker	speaker	NN
18637	10863	46	of	of	IN
18637	10863	47	the	the	DT
18637	10863	48	House	House	NNP
18637	10863	49	of	of	IN
18637	10863	50	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	10863	51	and	and	CC
18637	10863	52	the	the	DT
18637	10863	53	President	President	NNP
18637	10863	54	of	of	IN
18637	10863	55	the	the	DT
18637	10863	56	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	10863	57	,	,	,
18637	10863	58	and	and	CC
18637	10863	59	the	the	DT
18637	10863	60	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10863	61	will	will	MD
18637	10863	62	not	not	RB
18637	10863	63	look	look	VB
18637	10863	64	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	10863	65	these	these	DT
18637	10863	66	formalities	formality	NNS
18637	10863	67	of	of	IN
18637	10863	68	record	record	NN
18637	10863	69	by	by	IN
18637	10863	70	examining	examine	VBG
18637	10863	71	the	the	DT
18637	10863	72	journals	journal	NNS
18637	10863	73	of	of	IN
18637	10863	74	the	the	DT
18637	10863	75	two	two	CD
18637	10863	76	houses	house	NNS
18637	10863	77	of	of	IN
18637	10863	78	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10863	79	or	or	CC
18637	10863	80	other	other	JJ
18637	10863	81	records	record	NNS
18637	10863	82	.	.	.
18637	10864	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	10864	2	,	,	,
18637	10864	3	the	the	DT
18637	10864	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10864	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	10864	6	held	hold	VBN
18637	10864	7	that	that	IN
18637	10864	8	the	the	DT
18637	10864	9	efficacy	efficacy	NN
18637	10864	10	of	of	IN
18637	10864	11	the	the	DT
18637	10864	12	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	10864	13	of	of	IN
18637	10864	14	a	a	DT
18637	10864	15	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	10864	16	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10864	17	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	10864	18	in	in	IN
18637	10864	19	the	the	DT
18637	10864	20	light	light	NN
18637	10864	21	of	of	IN
18637	10864	22	previous	previous	JJ
18637	10864	23	rejection	rejection	NN
18637	10864	24	or	or	CC
18637	10864	25	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	10864	26	attempted	attempt	VBN
18637	10864	27	withdrawal	withdrawal	NN
18637	10864	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	10864	29	political	political	JJ
18637	10864	30	in	in	IN
18637	10864	31	nature	nature	NN
18637	10864	32	,	,	,
18637	10864	33	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	10864	34	to	to	IN
18637	10864	35	the	the	DT
18637	10864	36	political	political	JJ
18637	10864	37	departments	department	NNS
18637	10864	38	,	,	,
18637	10864	39	with	with	IN
18637	10864	40	the	the	DT
18637	10864	41	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	10864	42	authority	authority	NN
18637	10864	43	in	in	IN
18637	10864	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10864	45	by	by	IN
18637	10864	46	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	10864	47	of	of	IN
18637	10864	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10864	49	control	control	NN
18637	10864	50	over	over	IN
18637	10864	51	the	the	DT
18637	10864	52	promulgation	promulgation	NN
18637	10864	53	of	of	IN
18637	10864	54	the	the	DT
18637	10864	55	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	10864	56	of	of	IN
18637	10864	57	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	10864	58	.	.	.
18637	10865	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10865	2	218	218	CD
18637	10865	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10865	4	Simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
18637	10865	5	,	,	,
18637	10865	6	the	the	DT
18637	10865	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10865	8	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	10865	9	that	that	IN
18637	10865	10	the	the	DT
18637	10865	11	question	question	NN
18637	10865	12	of	of	IN
18637	10865	13	the	the	DT
18637	10865	14	lapse	lapse	NN
18637	10865	15	of	of	IN
18637	10865	16	a	a	DT
18637	10865	17	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	10865	18	length	length	NN
18637	10865	19	of	of	IN
18637	10865	20	time	time	NN
18637	10865	21	between	between	IN
18637	10865	22	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	10865	23	and	and	CC
18637	10865	24	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	10865	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	10865	26	for	for	IN
18637	10865	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10865	28	to	to	TO
18637	10865	29	determine	determine	VB
18637	10865	30	and	and	CC
18637	10865	31	not	not	RB
18637	10865	32	the	the	DT
18637	10865	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10865	34	.	.	.
18637	10866	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10866	2	219	219	CD
18637	10866	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10866	4	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	10866	5	Cases	case	NNS
18637	10866	6	A	a	DT
18637	10866	7	few	few	JJ
18637	10866	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	10866	9	will	will	MD
18637	10866	10	suffice	suffice	VB
18637	10866	11	to	to	TO
18637	10866	12	illustrate	illustrate	VB
18637	10866	13	the	the	DT
18637	10866	14	application	application	NN
18637	10866	15	of	of	IN
18637	10866	16	the	the	DT
18637	10866	17	concept	concept	NN
18637	10866	18	of	of	IN
18637	10866	19	political	political	JJ
18637	10866	20	questions	question	NNS
18637	10866	21	since	since	IN
18637	10866	22	1938	1938	CD
18637	10866	23	.	.	.
18637	10867	1	In	in	IN
18637	10867	2	Colegrove	Colegrove	NNP
18637	10867	3	_	_	NNP
18637	10867	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	10867	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10867	6	Green,[220	Green,[220	NNP
18637	10867	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10867	8	a	a	DT
18637	10867	9	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	10867	10	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10867	11	was	be	VBD
18637	10867	12	sought	seek	VBN
18637	10867	13	to	to	TO
18637	10867	14	have	have	VB
18637	10867	15	the	the	DT
18637	10867	16	division	division	NN
18637	10867	17	of	of	IN
18637	10867	18	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	10867	19	into	into	IN
18637	10867	20	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	10867	21	districts	district	NNS
18637	10867	22	declared	declare	VBN
18637	10867	23	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	10867	24	as	as	IN
18637	10867	25	a	a	DT
18637	10867	26	violation	violation	NN
18637	10867	27	of	of	IN
18637	10867	28	the	the	DT
18637	10867	29	equal	equal	JJ
18637	10867	30	protection	protection	NN
18637	10867	31	of	of	IN
18637	10867	32	the	the	DT
18637	10867	33	laws	law	NNS
18637	10867	34	.	.	.
18637	10868	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10868	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	10868	3	in	in	IN
18637	10868	4	announcing	announce	VBG
18637	10868	5	the	the	DT
18637	10868	6	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10868	7	of	of	IN
18637	10868	8	the	the	DT
18637	10868	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10868	10	,	,	,
18637	10868	11	in	in	IN
18637	10868	12	an	an	DT
18637	10868	13	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10868	14	in	in	IN
18637	10868	15	which	which	WDT
18637	10868	16	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	10868	17	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	10868	18	and	and	CC
18637	10868	19	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	10868	20	joined	join	VBD
18637	10868	21	,	,	,
18637	10868	22	was	be	VBD
18637	10868	23	of	of	IN
18637	10868	24	the	the	DT
18637	10868	25	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10868	26	that	that	IN
18637	10868	27	dismissal	dismissal	NN
18637	10868	28	of	of	IN
18637	10868	29	the	the	DT
18637	10868	30	suit	suit	NN
18637	10868	31	was	be	VBD
18637	10868	32	required	require	VBN
18637	10868	33	both	both	CC
18637	10868	34	by	by	IN
18637	10868	35	the	the	DT
18637	10868	36	decision	decision	NN
18637	10868	37	in	in	IN
18637	10868	38	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	10868	39	_	_	NNP
18637	10868	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	10868	41	_	_	NNP
18637	10868	42	Broom,[221	Broom,[221	NNP
18637	10868	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10868	44	that	that	IN
18637	10868	45	there	there	EX
18637	10868	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	10868	47	no	no	DT
18637	10868	48	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10868	49	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	10868	50	that	that	IN
18637	10868	51	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	10868	52	districts	district	NNS
18637	10868	53	shall	shall	MD
18637	10868	54	contain	contain	VB
18637	10868	55	as	as	RB
18637	10868	56	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	10868	57	as	as	RB
18637	10868	58	practicable	practicable	JJ
18637	10868	59	an	an	DT
18637	10868	60	equal	equal	JJ
18637	10868	61	number	number	NN
18637	10868	62	of	of	IN
18637	10868	63	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	10868	64	,	,	,
18637	10868	65	and	and	CC
18637	10868	66	because	because	IN
18637	10868	67	the	the	DT
18637	10868	68	question	question	NN
18637	10868	69	was	be	VBD
18637	10868	70	not	not	RB
18637	10868	71	justiciable	justiciable	JJ
18637	10868	72	.	.	.
18637	10869	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10869	2	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	10869	3	thought	think	VBD
18637	10869	4	that	that	IN
18637	10869	5	Smiley	Smiley	NNP
18637	10869	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10869	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10869	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10869	9	Holm[222	holm[222	NN
18637	10869	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10869	11	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	10869	12	that	that	IN
18637	10869	13	the	the	DT
18637	10869	14	question	question	NN
18637	10869	15	was	be	VBD
18637	10869	16	justiciable	justiciable	JJ
18637	10869	17	but	but	CC
18637	10869	18	concurred	concur	VBN
18637	10869	19	in	in	IN
18637	10869	20	the	the	DT
18637	10869	21	result	result	NN
18637	10869	22	on	on	IN
18637	10869	23	the	the	DT
18637	10869	24	ground	ground	NN
18637	10869	25	that	that	IN
18637	10869	26	the	the	DT
18637	10869	27	case	case	NN
18637	10869	28	was	be	VBD
18637	10869	29	one	one	CD
18637	10869	30	in	in	IN
18637	10869	31	which	which	WDT
18637	10869	32	the	the	DT
18637	10869	33	courts	court	NNS
18637	10869	34	should	should	MD
18637	10869	35	decline	decline	VB
18637	10869	36	to	to	TO
18637	10869	37	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	10869	38	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10869	39	.	.	.
18637	10870	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10870	2	223	223	CD
18637	10870	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10870	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10870	5	Black	Black	NNP
18637	10870	6	in	in	IN
18637	10870	7	a	a	DT
18637	10870	8	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	10870	9	supported	support	VBN
18637	10870	10	by	by	IN
18637	10870	11	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	10870	12	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	10870	13	and	and	CC
18637	10870	14	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	10870	15	thought	think	VBD
18637	10870	16	that	that	IN
18637	10870	17	the	the	DT
18637	10870	18	case	case	NN
18637	10870	19	was	be	VBD
18637	10870	20	justiciable	justiciable	JJ
18637	10870	21	and	and	CC
18637	10870	22	would	would	MD
18637	10870	23	have	have	VB
18637	10870	24	invalidated	invalidate	VBN
18637	10870	25	the	the	DT
18637	10870	26	reapportionment	reapportionment	NN
18637	10870	27	,	,	,
18637	10870	28	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	10870	29	the	the	DT
18637	10870	30	State	state	NN
18637	10870	31	free	free	JJ
18637	10870	32	to	to	TO
18637	10870	33	elect	elect	VB
18637	10870	34	all	all	DT
18637	10870	35	of	of	IN
18637	10870	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10870	37	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	10870	38	from	from	IN
18637	10870	39	the	the	DT
18637	10870	40	State	State	NNP
18637	10870	41	at	at	IN
18637	10870	42	large	large	JJ
18637	10870	43	.	.	.
18637	10871	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10871	2	224	224	CD
18637	10871	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10871	4	In	in	IN
18637	10871	5	MacDougall	MacDougall	NNP
18637	10871	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10871	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10871	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10871	9	Green,[225	Green,[225	NNP
18637	10871	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10871	11	however	however	RB
18637	10871	12	,	,	,
18637	10871	13	the	the	DT
18637	10871	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10871	15	seemed	seem	VBD
18637	10871	16	to	to	TO
18637	10871	17	regard	regard	VB
18637	10871	18	as	as	IN
18637	10871	19	justiciable	justiciable	NN
18637	10871	20	the	the	DT
18637	10871	21	question	question	NN
18637	10871	22	of	of	IN
18637	10871	23	the	the	DT
18637	10871	24	validity	validity	NN
18637	10871	25	of	of	IN
18637	10871	26	the	the	DT
18637	10871	27	provision	provision	NN
18637	10871	28	of	of	IN
18637	10871	29	the	the	DT
18637	10871	30	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	10871	31	Election	Election	NNP
18637	10871	32	Code	Code	NNP
18637	10871	33	requiring	require	VBG
18637	10871	34	that	that	IN
18637	10871	35	a	a	DT
18637	10871	36	petition	petition	NN
18637	10871	37	for	for	IN
18637	10871	38	the	the	DT
18637	10871	39	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	10871	40	of	of	IN
18637	10871	41	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	10871	42	of	of	IN
18637	10871	43	a	a	DT
18637	10871	44	new	new	JJ
18637	10871	45	political	political	JJ
18637	10871	46	party	party	NN
18637	10871	47	be	be	VB
18637	10871	48	signed	sign	VBN
18637	10871	49	by	by	IN
18637	10871	50	25,000	25,000	CD
18637	10871	51	voters	voter	NNS
18637	10871	52	including	include	VBG
18637	10871	53	at	at	RB
18637	10871	54	least	least	RBS
18637	10871	55	200	200	CD
18637	10871	56	from	from	IN
18637	10871	57	each	each	DT
18637	10871	58	of	of	IN
18637	10871	59	at	at	RB
18637	10871	60	least	least	JJS
18637	10871	61	50	50	CD
18637	10871	62	of	of	IN
18637	10871	63	the	the	DT
18637	10871	64	States	States	NNP
18637	10871	65	'	'	POS
18637	10871	66	102	102	CD
18637	10871	67	counties	county	NNS
18637	10871	68	,	,	,
18637	10871	69	for	for	IN
18637	10871	70	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10871	71	went	go	VBD
18637	10871	72	on	on	RP
18637	10871	73	to	to	TO
18637	10871	74	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	10871	75	the	the	DT
18637	10871	76	provision	provision	NN
18637	10871	77	in	in	IN
18637	10871	78	a	a	DT
18637	10871	79	brief	brief	JJ
18637	10871	80	_	_	NNP
18637	10871	81	per	per	IN
18637	10871	82	curiam	curiam	NNP
18637	10871	83	_	_	NNP
18637	10871	84	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10871	85	.	.	.
18637	10872	1	In	in	IN
18637	10872	2	Ludecke	Ludecke	NNP
18637	10872	3	_	_	NNP
18637	10872	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	10872	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10872	6	Watkins,[226	Watkins,[226	NNP
18637	10872	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10872	8	the	the	DT
18637	10872	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10872	10	held	hold	VBD
18637	10872	11	,	,	,
18637	10872	12	as	as	IN
18637	10872	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10872	14	had	have	VBD
18637	10872	15	earlier	early	RBR
18637	10872	16	,	,	,
18637	10872	17	that	that	IN
18637	10872	18	the	the	DT
18637	10872	19	determination	determination	NN
18637	10872	20	of	of	IN
18637	10872	21	the	the	DT
18637	10872	22	cessation	cessation	NN
18637	10872	23	of	of	IN
18637	10872	24	a	a	DT
18637	10872	25	state	state	NN
18637	10872	26	of	of	IN
18637	10872	27	war	war	NN
18637	10872	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	10872	29	a	a	DT
18637	10872	30	question	question	NN
18637	10872	31	for	for	IN
18637	10872	32	the	the	DT
18637	10872	33	political	political	JJ
18637	10872	34	branch	branch	NN
18637	10872	35	of	of	IN
18637	10872	36	the	the	DT
18637	10872	37	Government	Government	NNP
18637	10872	38	and	and	CC
18637	10872	39	not	not	RB
18637	10872	40	for	for	IN
18637	10872	41	the	the	DT
18637	10872	42	courts	court	NNS
18637	10872	43	.	.	.
18637	10873	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	10873	2	,	,	,
18637	10873	3	the	the	DT
18637	10873	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10873	5	actually	actually	RB
18637	10873	6	found	find	VBD
18637	10873	7	a	a	DT
18637	10873	8	state	state	NN
18637	10873	9	of	of	IN
18637	10873	10	war	war	NN
18637	10873	11	to	to	TO
18637	10873	12	exist	exist	VB
18637	10873	13	between	between	IN
18637	10873	14	the	the	DT
18637	10873	15	United	United	NNP
18637	10873	16	States	States	NNP
18637	10873	17	and	and	CC
18637	10873	18	Germany	Germany	NNP
18637	10873	19	after	after	IN
18637	10873	20	the	the	DT
18637	10873	21	end	end	NN
18637	10873	22	of	of	IN
18637	10873	23	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	10873	24	,	,	,
18637	10873	25	and	and	CC
18637	10873	26	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	10873	27	that	that	IN
18637	10873	28	an	an	DT
18637	10873	29	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	10873	30	alien	alien	NN
18637	10873	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	10873	32	not	not	RB
18637	10873	33	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	10873	34	to	to	IN
18637	10873	35	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10873	36	review	review	NN
18637	10873	37	in	in	IN
18637	10873	38	a	a	DT
18637	10873	39	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	10873	40	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	10873	41	.	.	.
18637	10874	1	Very	very	RB
18637	10874	2	recently	recently	RB
18637	10874	3	in	in	IN
18637	10874	4	South	South	NNP
18637	10874	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10874	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10874	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10874	8	Peters,[227	Peters,[227	NNP
18637	10874	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10874	10	the	the	DT
18637	10874	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10874	12	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	10874	13	to	to	TO
18637	10874	14	pass	pass	VB
18637	10874	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	10874	16	the	the	DT
18637	10874	17	validity	validity	NN
18637	10874	18	of	of	IN
18637	10874	19	the	the	DT
18637	10874	20	county	county	NN
18637	10874	21	unit	unit	NN
18637	10874	22	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	10874	23	used	use	VBN
18637	10874	24	in	in	IN
18637	10874	25	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	10874	26	for	for	IN
18637	10874	27	the	the	DT
18637	10874	28	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	10874	29	of	of	IN
18637	10874	30	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	10874	31	in	in	IN
18637	10874	32	primary	primary	JJ
18637	10874	33	elections	election	NNS
18637	10874	34	.	.	.
18637	10875	1	ADVISORY	ADVISORY	NNP
18637	10875	2	OPINIONS	OPINIONS	NNP
18637	10875	3	Perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	10875	4	no	no	DT
18637	10875	5	portion	portion	NN
18637	10875	6	of	of	IN
18637	10875	7	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10875	8	Law	Law	NNP
18637	10875	9	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	10875	10	to	to	IN
18637	10875	11	the	the	DT
18637	10875	12	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	10875	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	10875	14	evoked	evoke	VBN
18637	10875	15	such	such	JJ
18637	10875	16	unanimity	unanimity	NN
18637	10875	17	as	as	IN
18637	10875	18	the	the	DT
18637	10875	19	rule	rule	NN
18637	10875	20	that	that	IN
18637	10875	21	the	the	DT
18637	10875	22	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10875	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	10875	24	will	will	MD
18637	10875	25	not	not	RB
18637	10875	26	render	render	VB
18637	10875	27	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	10875	28	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	10875	29	.	.	.
18637	10876	1	In	in	IN
18637	10876	2	1793	1793	CD
18637	10876	3	the	the	DT
18637	10876	4	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10876	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10876	6	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	10876	7	to	to	TO
18637	10876	8	grant	grant	VB
18637	10876	9	the	the	DT
18637	10876	10	request	request	NN
18637	10876	11	of	of	IN
18637	10876	12	President	President	NNP
18637	10876	13	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	10876	14	and	and	CC
18637	10876	15	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10876	16	of	of	IN
18637	10876	17	State	State	NNP
18637	10876	18	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	10876	19	to	to	TO
18637	10876	20	construe	construe	VB
18637	10876	21	the	the	DT
18637	10876	22	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	10876	23	and	and	CC
18637	10876	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	10876	25	of	of	IN
18637	10876	26	the	the	DT
18637	10876	27	United	United	NNP
18637	10876	28	States	States	NNP
18637	10876	29	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	10876	30	to	to	IN
18637	10876	31	questions	question	NNS
18637	10876	32	of	of	IN
18637	10876	33	international	international	JJ
18637	10876	34	law	law	NN
18637	10876	35	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10876	36	out	out	IN
18637	10876	37	of	of	IN
18637	10876	38	the	the	DT
18637	10876	39	wars	war	NNS
18637	10876	40	of	of	IN
18637	10876	41	the	the	DT
18637	10876	42	French	French	NNP
18637	10876	43	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
18637	10876	44	.	.	.
18637	10877	1	After	after	IN
18637	10877	2	convening	convene	VBG
18637	10877	3	the	the	DT
18637	10877	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10877	5	which	which	WDT
18637	10877	6	considered	consider	VBD
18637	10877	7	the	the	DT
18637	10877	8	request	request	NN
18637	10877	9	,	,	,
18637	10877	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10877	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10877	12	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	10877	13	replied	reply	VBD
18637	10877	14	to	to	IN
18637	10877	15	President	President	NNP
18637	10877	16	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	10877	17	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	10877	18	the	the	DT
18637	10877	19	functions	function	NNS
18637	10877	20	of	of	IN
18637	10877	21	the	the	DT
18637	10877	22	three	three	CD
18637	10877	23	departments	department	NNS
18637	10877	24	of	of	IN
18637	10877	25	government	government	NN
18637	10877	26	:	:	:
18637	10877	27	"	"	``
18637	10877	28	These	these	DT
18637	10877	29	being	be	VBG
18637	10877	30	in	in	IN
18637	10877	31	certain	certain	JJ
18637	10877	32	respects	respect	NNS
18637	10877	33	checks	check	NNS
18637	10877	34	upon	upon	IN
18637	10877	35	each	each	DT
18637	10877	36	other	other	JJ
18637	10877	37	,	,	,
18637	10877	38	and	and	CC
18637	10877	39	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10877	40	being	be	VBG
18637	10877	41	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	10877	42	of	of	IN
18637	10877	43	a	a	DT
18637	10877	44	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10877	45	in	in	IN
18637	10877	46	the	the	DT
18637	10877	47	last	last	JJ
18637	10877	48	resort	resort	NN
18637	10877	49	,	,	,
18637	10877	50	are	be	VBP
18637	10877	51	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	10877	52	which	which	WDT
18637	10877	53	afford	afford	VBP
18637	10877	54	strong	strong	JJ
18637	10877	55	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	10877	56	against	against	IN
18637	10877	57	the	the	DT
18637	10877	58	propriety	propriety	NN
18637	10877	59	of	of	IN
18637	10877	60	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10877	61	extra	extra	JJ
18637	10877	62	-	-	NN
18637	10877	63	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	10877	64	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	10877	65	the	the	DT
18637	10877	66	questions	question	NNS
18637	10877	67	alluded	allude	VBN
18637	10877	68	to	to	IN
18637	10877	69	,	,	,
18637	10877	70	especially	especially	RB
18637	10877	71	as	as	IN
18637	10877	72	the	the	DT
18637	10877	73	power	power	NN
18637	10877	74	given	give	VBN
18637	10877	75	by	by	IN
18637	10877	76	the	the	DT
18637	10877	77	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10877	78	to	to	IN
18637	10877	79	the	the	DT
18637	10877	80	President	President	NNP
18637	10877	81	,	,	,
18637	10877	82	of	of	IN
18637	10877	83	calling	call	VBG
18637	10877	84	on	on	IN
18637	10877	85	the	the	DT
18637	10877	86	heads	head	NNS
18637	10877	87	of	of	IN
18637	10877	88	departments	department	NNS
18637	10877	89	for	for	IN
18637	10877	90	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	10877	91	,	,	,
18637	10877	92	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	10877	93	to	to	TO
18637	10877	94	have	have	VB
18637	10877	95	been	be	VBN
18637	10877	96	_	_	NNP
18637	10877	97	purposely	purposely	RB
18637	10877	98	_	_	NNP
18637	10877	99	as	as	RB
18637	10877	100	well	well	RB
18637	10877	101	as	as	IN
18637	10877	102	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	10877	103	united	unite	VBN
18637	10877	104	to	to	IN
18637	10877	105	the	the	DT
18637	10877	106	_	_	NNP
18637	10877	107	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	10877	108	_	_	NNP
18637	10877	109	departments	department	NNS
18637	10877	110	.	.	.
18637	10878	1	"	"	``
18637	10878	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10878	3	228	228	CD
18637	10878	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10878	5	Since	since	IN
18637	10878	6	1793	1793	CD
18637	10878	7	the	the	DT
18637	10878	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10878	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	10878	10	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	10878	11	reiterated	reiterate	VBN
18637	10878	12	the	the	DT
18637	10878	13	early	early	JJ
18637	10878	14	view	view	NN
18637	10878	15	that	that	IN
18637	10878	16	the	the	DT
18637	10878	17	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10878	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	10878	19	organized	organize	VBN
18637	10878	20	under	under	IN
18637	10878	21	article	article	NN
18637	10878	22	III	III	NNP
18637	10878	23	can	can	MD
18637	10878	24	not	not	RB
18637	10878	25	render	render	VB
18637	10878	26	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	10878	27	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	10878	28	or	or	CC
18637	10878	29	that	that	IN
18637	10878	30	the	the	DT
18637	10878	31	rendition	rendition	NN
18637	10878	32	of	of	IN
18637	10878	33	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	10878	34	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	10878	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	10878	36	not	not	RB
18637	10878	37	a	a	DT
18637	10878	38	part	part	NN
18637	10878	39	of	of	IN
18637	10878	40	the	the	DT
18637	10878	41	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10878	42	power	power	NN
18637	10878	43	of	of	IN
18637	10878	44	the	the	DT
18637	10878	45	United	United	NNP
18637	10878	46	States	States	NNP
18637	10878	47	.	.	.
18637	10879	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10879	2	229	229	CD
18637	10879	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10879	4	Even	even	RB
18637	10879	5	in	in	IN
18637	10879	6	the	the	DT
18637	10879	7	absence	absence	NN
18637	10879	8	of	of	IN
18637	10879	9	this	this	DT
18637	10879	10	early	early	JJ
18637	10879	11	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	10879	12	,	,	,
18637	10879	13	the	the	DT
18637	10879	14	rule	rule	NN
18637	10879	15	that	that	IN
18637	10879	16	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10879	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	10879	18	will	will	MD
18637	10879	19	render	render	VB
18637	10879	20	no	no	DT
18637	10879	21	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	10879	22	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	10879	23	would	would	MD
18637	10879	24	have	have	VB
18637	10879	25	logically	logically	RB
18637	10879	26	emerged	emerge	VBN
18637	10879	27	from	from	IN
18637	10879	28	the	the	DT
18637	10879	29	rule	rule	NN
18637	10879	30	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	10879	31	developed	develop	VBD
18637	10879	32	,	,	,
18637	10879	33	that	that	IN
18637	10879	34	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10879	35	courts	court	NNS
18637	10879	36	can	can	MD
18637	10879	37	only	only	RB
18637	10879	38	decide	decide	VB
18637	10879	39	cases	case	NNS
18637	10879	40	and	and	CC
18637	10879	41	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	10879	42	in	in	IN
18637	10879	43	which	which	WDT
18637	10879	44	an	an	DT
18637	10879	45	essential	essential	JJ
18637	10879	46	element	element	NN
18637	10879	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	10879	48	a	a	DT
18637	10879	49	final	final	JJ
18637	10879	50	and	and	CC
18637	10879	51	binding	bind	VBG
18637	10879	52	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10879	53	on	on	IN
18637	10879	54	the	the	DT
18637	10879	55	parties	party	NNS
18637	10879	56	.	.	.
18637	10880	1	As	as	IN
18637	10880	2	stated	state	VBN
18637	10880	3	by	by	IN
18637	10880	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10880	5	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	10880	6	,	,	,
18637	10880	7	when	when	WRB
18637	10880	8	the	the	DT
18637	10880	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10880	10	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	10880	11	to	to	TO
18637	10880	12	review	review	VB
18637	10880	13	an	an	DT
18637	10880	14	order	order	NN
18637	10880	15	of	of	IN
18637	10880	16	the	the	DT
18637	10880	17	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	10880	18	Aeronautics	Aeronautics	NNP
18637	10880	19	Board	Board	NNP
18637	10880	20	,	,	,
18637	10880	21	which	which	WDT
18637	10880	22	in	in	IN
18637	10880	23	effect	effect	NN
18637	10880	24	was	be	VBD
18637	10880	25	a	a	DT
18637	10880	26	mere	mere	JJ
18637	10880	27	recommendation	recommendation	NN
18637	10880	28	to	to	IN
18637	10880	29	the	the	DT
18637	10880	30	President	President	NNP
18637	10880	31	for	for	IN
18637	10880	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10880	33	final	final	JJ
18637	10880	34	action	action	NN
18637	10880	35	,	,	,
18637	10880	36	"	"	''
18637	10880	37	To	to	TO
18637	10880	38	revise	revise	VB
18637	10880	39	or	or	CC
18637	10880	40	review	review	VB
18637	10880	41	an	an	DT
18637	10880	42	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	10880	43	decision	decision	NN
18637	10880	44	which	which	WDT
18637	10880	45	has	have	VBZ
18637	10880	46	only	only	RB
18637	10880	47	the	the	DT
18637	10880	48	force	force	NN
18637	10880	49	of	of	IN
18637	10880	50	a	a	DT
18637	10880	51	recommendation	recommendation	NN
18637	10880	52	to	to	IN
18637	10880	53	the	the	DT
18637	10880	54	President	President	NNP
18637	10880	55	would	would	MD
18637	10880	56	be	be	VB
18637	10880	57	to	to	TO
18637	10880	58	render	render	VB
18637	10880	59	an	an	DT
18637	10880	60	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	10880	61	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10880	62	in	in	IN
18637	10880	63	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10880	64	most	most	RBS
18637	10880	65	obnoxious	obnoxious	JJ
18637	10880	66	form	form	NN
18637	10880	67	--	--	:
18637	10880	68	advice	advice	NN
18637	10880	69	that	that	WDT
18637	10880	70	the	the	DT
18637	10880	71	President	President	NNP
18637	10880	72	has	have	VBZ
18637	10880	73	not	not	RB
18637	10880	74	asked	ask	VBN
18637	10880	75	,	,	,
18637	10880	76	tendered	tender	VBN
18637	10880	77	at	at	IN
18637	10880	78	the	the	DT
18637	10880	79	demand	demand	NN
18637	10880	80	of	of	IN
18637	10880	81	a	a	DT
18637	10880	82	private	private	JJ
18637	10880	83	litigant	litigant	NN
18637	10880	84	,	,	,
18637	10880	85	on	on	IN
18637	10880	86	a	a	DT
18637	10880	87	subject	subject	NN
18637	10880	88	concededly	concededly	RB
18637	10880	89	within	within	IN
18637	10880	90	the	the	DT
18637	10880	91	President	President	NNP
18637	10880	92	's	's	POS
18637	10880	93	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	10880	94	,	,	,
18637	10880	95	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	10880	96	control	control	NN
18637	10880	97	.	.	.
18637	10881	1	This	this	DT
18637	10881	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10881	3	early	early	RB
18637	10881	4	and	and	CC
18637	10881	5	wisely	wisely	RB
18637	10881	6	determined	determine	VBD
18637	10881	7	that	that	IN
18637	10881	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10881	9	would	would	MD
18637	10881	10	not	not	RB
18637	10881	11	give	give	VB
18637	10881	12	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	10881	13	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	10881	14	even	even	RB
18637	10881	15	when	when	WRB
18637	10881	16	asked	ask	VBN
18637	10881	17	by	by	IN
18637	10881	18	the	the	DT
18637	10881	19	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10881	20	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	10881	21	.	.	.
18637	10882	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10882	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	10882	3	also	also	RB
18637	10882	4	been	be	VBN
18637	10882	5	the	the	DT
18637	10882	6	firm	firm	NN
18637	10882	7	and	and	CC
18637	10882	8	unvarying	unvarye	VBG
18637	10882	9	practice	practice	NN
18637	10882	10	of	of	IN
18637	10882	11	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	10882	12	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	10882	13	to	to	TO
18637	10882	14	render	render	VB
18637	10882	15	no	no	DT
18637	10882	16	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	10882	17	not	not	RB
18637	10882	18	binding	bind	VBG
18637	10882	19	and	and	CC
18637	10882	20	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	10882	21	on	on	IN
18637	10882	22	the	the	DT
18637	10882	23	parties	party	NNS
18637	10882	24	and	and	CC
18637	10882	25	none	none	NN
18637	10882	26	that	that	WDT
18637	10882	27	are	be	VBP
18637	10882	28	subject	subject	JJ
18637	10882	29	to	to	IN
18637	10882	30	later	later	RB
18637	10882	31	review	review	NN
18637	10882	32	or	or	CC
18637	10882	33	alteration	alteration	NN
18637	10882	34	by	by	IN
18637	10882	35	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	10882	36	action	action	NN
18637	10882	37	.	.	.
18637	10883	1	"	"	``
18637	10883	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10883	3	230	230	CD
18637	10883	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10883	5	The	the	DT
18637	10883	6	early	early	JJ
18637	10883	7	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	10883	8	of	of	IN
18637	10883	9	the	the	DT
18637	10883	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10883	11	to	to	TO
18637	10883	12	render	render	VB
18637	10883	13	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	10883	14	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	10883	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	10883	16	discouraged	discourage	VBN
18637	10883	17	direct	direct	JJ
18637	10883	18	requests	request	NNS
18637	10883	19	for	for	IN
18637	10883	20	advice	advice	NN
18637	10883	21	so	so	IN
18637	10883	22	that	that	IN
18637	10883	23	the	the	DT
18637	10883	24	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	10883	25	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10883	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	10883	27	appeared	appear	VBN
18637	10883	28	only	only	RB
18637	10883	29	collaterally	collaterally	RB
18637	10883	30	in	in	IN
18637	10883	31	cases	case	NNS
18637	10883	32	where	where	WRB
18637	10883	33	there	there	EX
18637	10883	34	was	be	VBD
18637	10883	35	a	a	DT
18637	10883	36	lack	lack	NN
18637	10883	37	of	of	IN
18637	10883	38	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	10883	39	parties,[231	parties,[231	NN
18637	10883	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10883	41	or	or	CC
18637	10883	42	where	where	WRB
18637	10883	43	the	the	DT
18637	10883	44	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10883	45	of	of	IN
18637	10883	46	the	the	DT
18637	10883	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10883	48	was	be	VBD
18637	10883	49	subject	subject	JJ
18637	10883	50	to	to	IN
18637	10883	51	later	later	RB
18637	10883	52	review	review	NN
18637	10883	53	or	or	CC
18637	10883	54	action	action	NN
18637	10883	55	by	by	IN
18637	10883	56	the	the	DT
18637	10883	57	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10883	58	or	or	CC
18637	10883	59	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10883	60	branches	branch	NNS
18637	10883	61	of	of	IN
18637	10883	62	government,[232	government,[232	NNP
18637	10883	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10883	64	or	or	CC
18637	10883	65	where	where	WRB
18637	10883	66	the	the	DT
18637	10883	67	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10883	68	involved	involve	VBN
18637	10883	69	were	be	VBD
18637	10883	70	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	10883	71	or	or	CC
18637	10883	72	contingent	contingent	JJ
18637	10883	73	.	.	.
18637	10884	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10884	2	233	233	CD
18637	10884	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10884	4	DECLARATORY	DECLARATORY	NNP
18637	10884	5	JUDGMENTS	judgments	NN
18637	10884	6	The	the	DT
18637	10884	7	rigid	rigid	JJ
18637	10884	8	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	10884	9	placed	place	VBN
18637	10884	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	10884	11	such	such	JJ
18637	10884	12	elements	element	NNS
18637	10884	13	of	of	IN
18637	10884	14	the	the	DT
18637	10884	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10884	16	power	power	NN
18637	10884	17	as	as	IN
18637	10884	18	finality	finality	NN
18637	10884	19	of	of	IN
18637	10884	20	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10884	21	and	and	CC
18637	10884	22	an	an	DT
18637	10884	23	award	award	NN
18637	10884	24	of	of	IN
18637	10884	25	execution	execution	NN
18637	10884	26	in	in	IN
18637	10884	27	United	United	NNP
18637	10884	28	States	States	NNP
18637	10884	29	_	_	NNP
18637	10884	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	10884	31	_	_	NNP
18637	10884	32	Ferreira,[234	Ferreira,[234	NNP
18637	10884	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10884	34	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	10884	35	_	_	NNP
18637	10884	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	10884	37	_	_	NNP
18637	10884	38	United	United	NNP
18637	10884	39	States[235	States[235	NNP
18637	10884	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10884	41	,	,	,
18637	10884	42	and	and	CC
18637	10884	43	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	10884	44	Warehouse	Warehouse	NNP
18637	10884	45	_	_	NNP
18637	10884	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	10884	47	_	_	NNP
18637	10884	48	Grannis,[236	Grannis,[236	NNP
18637	10884	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10884	50	coupled	couple	VBN
18637	10884	51	with	with	IN
18637	10884	52	the	the	DT
18637	10884	53	equally	equally	RB
18637	10884	54	rigid	rigid	JJ
18637	10884	55	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	10884	56	upon	upon	IN
18637	10884	57	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	10884	58	parties	party	NNS
18637	10884	59	and	and	CC
18637	10884	60	real	real	JJ
18637	10884	61	interests	interest	NNS
18637	10884	62	as	as	IN
18637	10884	63	essential	essential	JJ
18637	10884	64	elements	element	NNS
18637	10884	65	of	of	IN
18637	10884	66	a	a	DT
18637	10884	67	case	case	NN
18637	10884	68	or	or	CC
18637	10884	69	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10884	70	in	in	IN
18637	10884	71	Muskrat	Muskrat	NNP
18637	10884	72	_	_	NNP
18637	10884	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	10884	74	_	_	NNP
18637	10884	75	United	United	NNP
18637	10884	76	States,[237	States,[237	NNP
18637	10884	77	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10884	78	created	create	VBN
18637	10884	79	serious	serious	JJ
18637	10884	80	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	10884	81	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	10884	82	the	the	DT
18637	10884	83	validity	validity	NN
18637	10884	84	of	of	IN
18637	10884	85	a	a	DT
18637	10884	86	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	10884	87	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10884	88	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	10884	89	judgment	judgment	NNP
18637	10884	90	act	act	NNP
18637	10884	91	.	.	.
18637	10885	1	These	these	DT
18637	10885	2	were	be	VBD
18637	10885	3	dispelled	dispel	VBN
18637	10885	4	to	to	IN
18637	10885	5	some	some	DT
18637	10885	6	extent	extent	NN
18637	10885	7	by	by	IN
18637	10885	8	Fidelity	Fidelity	NNP
18637	10885	9	National	National	NNP
18637	10885	10	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	10885	11	_	_	NNP
18637	10885	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	10885	13	_	_	NNP
18637	10885	14	Swope,[238	Swope,[238	NNP
18637	10885	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10885	16	which	which	WDT
18637	10885	17	held	hold	VBD
18637	10885	18	that	that	IN
18637	10885	19	an	an	DT
18637	10885	20	award	award	NN
18637	10885	21	of	of	IN
18637	10885	22	execution	execution	NN
18637	10885	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	10885	24	not	not	RB
18637	10885	25	an	an	DT
18637	10885	26	essential	essential	JJ
18637	10885	27	part	part	NN
18637	10885	28	of	of	IN
18637	10885	29	every	every	DT
18637	10885	30	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10885	31	and	and	CC
18637	10885	32	contained	contain	VBD
18637	10885	33	general	general	JJ
18637	10885	34	statements	statement	NNS
18637	10885	35	in	in	IN
18637	10885	36	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	10885	37	to	to	IN
18637	10885	38	the	the	DT
18637	10885	39	principles	principle	NNS
18637	10885	40	of	of	IN
18637	10885	41	the	the	DT
18637	10885	42	Grannis	Grannis	NNP
18637	10885	43	and	and	CC
18637	10885	44	Willing	willing	JJ
18637	10885	45	cases	case	NNS
18637	10885	46	.	.	.
18637	10886	1	Then	then	RB
18637	10886	2	in	in	IN
18637	10886	3	1933	1933	CD
18637	10886	4	the	the	DT
18637	10886	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10886	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10886	7	entertained	entertain	VBD
18637	10886	8	an	an	DT
18637	10886	9	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	10886	10	from	from	IN
18637	10886	11	a	a	DT
18637	10886	12	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	10886	13	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10886	14	rendered	render	VBN
18637	10886	15	by	by	IN
18637	10886	16	the	the	DT
18637	10886	17	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	10886	18	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	10886	19	in	in	IN
18637	10886	20	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	10886	21	,	,	,
18637	10886	22	C.	C.	NNP
18637	10886	23	&	&	CC
18637	10886	24	St.	St.	NNP
18637	10886	25	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	10887	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10887	2	_	_	NNP
18637	10887	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	10887	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10887	5	Wallace,[239	Wallace,[239	NNP
18637	10887	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10887	7	and	and	CC
18637	10887	8	in	in	IN
18637	10887	9	doing	do	VBG
18637	10887	10	so	so	RB
18637	10887	11	declared	declare	VBD
18637	10887	12	that	that	IN
18637	10887	13	the	the	DT
18637	10887	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10887	15	does	do	VBZ
18637	10887	16	not	not	RB
18637	10887	17	require	require	VB
18637	10887	18	that	that	IN
18637	10887	19	a	a	DT
18637	10887	20	case	case	NN
18637	10887	21	or	or	CC
18637	10887	22	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10887	23	be	be	VB
18637	10887	24	presented	present	VBN
18637	10887	25	by	by	IN
18637	10887	26	traditional	traditional	JJ
18637	10887	27	forms	form	NNS
18637	10887	28	of	of	IN
18637	10887	29	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	10887	30	,	,	,
18637	10887	31	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10887	32	only	only	RB
18637	10887	33	traditional	traditional	JJ
18637	10887	34	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	10887	35	,	,	,
18637	10887	36	and	and	CC
18637	10887	37	that	that	IN
18637	10887	38	article	article	NN
18637	10887	39	III	iii	CD
18637	10887	40	defined	define	VBD
18637	10887	41	and	and	CC
18637	10887	42	limited	limited	JJ
18637	10887	43	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10887	44	power	power	NN
18637	10887	45	not	not	RB
18637	10887	46	the	the	DT
18637	10887	47	particular	particular	JJ
18637	10887	48	method	method	NN
18637	10887	49	by	by	IN
18637	10887	50	which	which	WDT
18637	10887	51	that	that	DT
18637	10887	52	power	power	NN
18637	10887	53	may	may	MD
18637	10887	54	be	be	VB
18637	10887	55	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	10887	56	or	or	CC
18637	10887	57	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	10887	58	.	.	.
18637	10888	1	The	the	DT
18637	10888	2	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10888	3	Declaratory	Declaratory	NNP
18637	10888	4	Judgments	Judgments	NNP
18637	10888	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10888	6	of	of	IN
18637	10888	7	1934	1934	CD
18637	10888	8	was	be	VBD
18637	10888	9	in	in	IN
18637	10888	10	due	due	JJ
18637	10888	11	course	course	NN
18637	10888	12	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	10888	13	in	in	IN
18637	10888	14	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	10888	15	Life	Life	NNP
18637	10888	16	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	10888	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10888	18	_	_	NNP
18637	10888	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	10888	20	_	_	NNP
18637	10888	21	Haworth,[240	Haworth,[240	NNP
18637	10888	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10888	23	as	as	IN
18637	10888	24	a	a	DT
18637	10888	25	valid	valid	JJ
18637	10888	26	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10888	27	of	of	IN
18637	10888	28	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	10888	29	power	power	NN
18637	10888	30	over	over	IN
18637	10888	31	the	the	DT
18637	10888	32	practice	practice	NN
18637	10888	33	and	and	CC
18637	10888	34	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	10888	35	of	of	IN
18637	10888	36	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10888	37	courts	court	NNS
18637	10888	38	which	which	WDT
18637	10888	39	includes	include	VBZ
18637	10888	40	the	the	DT
18637	10888	41	power	power	NN
18637	10888	42	to	to	TO
18637	10888	43	create	create	VB
18637	10888	44	and	and	CC
18637	10888	45	improve	improve	VB
18637	10888	46	as	as	RB
18637	10888	47	well	well	RB
18637	10888	48	as	as	IN
18637	10888	49	to	to	TO
18637	10888	50	abolish	abolish	VB
18637	10888	51	or	or	CC
18637	10888	52	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	10888	53	.	.	.
18637	10889	1	The	the	DT
18637	10889	2	Declaratory	Declaratory	NNP
18637	10889	3	Judgment	Judgment	NNP
18637	10889	4	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10889	5	of	of	IN
18637	10889	6	1934	1934	CD
18637	10889	7	The	the	DT
18637	10889	8	act	act	NN
18637	10889	9	of	of	IN
18637	10889	10	1934	1934	CD
18637	10889	11	was	be	VBD
18637	10889	12	carefully	carefully	RB
18637	10889	13	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	10889	14	,	,	,
18637	10889	15	and	and	CC
18637	10889	16	provided	provide	VBD
18637	10889	17	that	that	DT
18637	10889	18	:	:	:
18637	10889	19	"	"	``
18637	10889	20	In	in	IN
18637	10889	21	cases	case	NNS
18637	10889	22	of	of	IN
18637	10889	23	actual	actual	JJ
18637	10889	24	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10889	25	the	the	DT
18637	10889	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	10889	27	of	of	IN
18637	10889	28	the	the	DT
18637	10889	29	United	United	NNP
18637	10889	30	States	States	NNP
18637	10889	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	10889	32	have	have	VB
18637	10889	33	power	power	NN
18637	10889	34	*	*	NFP
18637	10889	35	*	*	NFP
18637	10889	36	*	*	NFP
18637	10889	37	to	to	TO
18637	10889	38	declare	declare	VB
18637	10889	39	rights	right	NNS
18637	10889	40	and	and	CC
18637	10889	41	other	other	JJ
18637	10889	42	legal	legal	JJ
18637	10889	43	relations	relation	NNS
18637	10889	44	of	of	IN
18637	10889	45	any	any	DT
18637	10889	46	interested	interested	JJ
18637	10889	47	party	party	NN
18637	10889	48	petitioning	petitioning	NN
18637	10889	49	for	for	IN
18637	10889	50	such	such	JJ
18637	10889	51	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	10889	52	,	,	,
18637	10889	53	whether	whether	IN
18637	10889	54	or	or	CC
18637	10889	55	not	not	RB
18637	10889	56	further	further	JJ
18637	10889	57	relief	relief	NN
18637	10889	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	10889	59	or	or	CC
18637	10889	60	could	could	MD
18637	10889	61	be	be	VB
18637	10889	62	prayed	pray	VBN
18637	10889	63	,	,	,
18637	10889	64	and	and	CC
18637	10889	65	such	such	JJ
18637	10889	66	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	10889	67	shall	shall	MD
18637	10889	68	have	have	VB
18637	10889	69	the	the	DT
18637	10889	70	force	force	NN
18637	10889	71	and	and	CC
18637	10889	72	effect	effect	NN
18637	10889	73	of	of	IN
18637	10889	74	a	a	DT
18637	10889	75	final	final	JJ
18637	10889	76	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10889	77	or	or	CC
18637	10889	78	decree	decree	NN
18637	10889	79	and	and	CC
18637	10889	80	be	be	VB
18637	10889	81	reviewable	reviewable	JJ
18637	10889	82	as	as	IN
18637	10889	83	such	such	JJ
18637	10889	84	.	.	.
18637	10889	85	"	"	''
18637	10890	1	The	the	DT
18637	10890	2	other	other	JJ
18637	10890	3	two	two	CD
18637	10890	4	sections	section	NNS
18637	10890	5	provided	provide	VBN
18637	10890	6	for	for	IN
18637	10890	7	further	further	JJ
18637	10890	8	relief	relief	NN
18637	10890	9	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	10890	10	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10890	11	and	and	CC
18637	10890	12	proper	proper	JJ
18637	10890	13	and	and	CC
18637	10890	14	for	for	IN
18637	10890	15	jury	jury	NN
18637	10890	16	trials	trial	NNS
18637	10890	17	of	of	IN
18637	10890	18	matters	matter	NNS
18637	10890	19	of	of	IN
18637	10890	20	fact	fact	NN
18637	10890	21	.	.	.
18637	10891	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10891	2	241	241	CD
18637	10891	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10891	4	In	in	IN
18637	10891	5	the	the	DT
18637	10891	6	first	first	JJ
18637	10891	7	case	case	NN
18637	10891	8	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10891	9	private	private	JJ
18637	10891	10	parties	party	NNS
18637	10891	11	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	10891	12	to	to	TO
18637	10891	13	arise	arise	VB
18637	10891	14	under	under	IN
18637	10891	15	the	the	DT
18637	10891	16	act	act	NN
18637	10891	17	,	,	,
18637	10891	18	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	10891	19	Life	Life	NNP
18637	10891	20	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	10891	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10891	22	_	_	NNP
18637	10891	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	10891	24	_	_	NNP
18637	10891	25	Haworth,[242	Haworth,[242	NNP
18637	10891	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10891	27	the	the	DT
18637	10891	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10891	29	held	hold	VBD
18637	10891	30	that	that	IN
18637	10891	31	a	a	DT
18637	10891	32	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	10891	33	should	should	MD
18637	10891	34	have	have	VB
18637	10891	35	been	be	VBN
18637	10891	36	issued	issue	VBN
18637	10891	37	by	by	IN
18637	10891	38	the	the	DT
18637	10891	39	district	district	NN
18637	10891	40	court	court	NN
18637	10891	41	,	,	,
18637	10891	42	although	although	IN
18637	10891	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10891	44	reiterated	reiterate	VBD
18637	10891	45	with	with	IN
18637	10891	46	the	the	DT
18637	10891	47	usual	usual	JJ
18637	10891	48	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	10891	49	the	the	DT
18637	10891	50	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	10891	51	of	of	IN
18637	10891	52	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	10891	53	parties	party	NNS
18637	10891	54	,	,	,
18637	10891	55	a	a	DT
18637	10891	56	justiciable	justiciable	JJ
18637	10891	57	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10891	58	and	and	CC
18637	10891	59	specific	specific	JJ
18637	10891	60	relief	relief	NN
18637	10891	61	.	.	.
18637	10892	1	In	in	IN
18637	10892	2	the	the	DT
18637	10892	3	Ashwander	Ashwander	NNP
18637	10892	4	case	case	NN
18637	10892	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10892	6	approved	approve	VBD
18637	10892	7	the	the	DT
18637	10892	8	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	10892	9	of	of	IN
18637	10892	10	the	the	DT
18637	10892	11	lower	low	JJR
18637	10892	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10892	13	to	to	TO
18637	10892	14	issue	issue	VB
18637	10892	15	a	a	DT
18637	10892	16	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	10892	17	generally	generally	RB
18637	10892	18	on	on	IN
18637	10892	19	the	the	DT
18637	10892	20	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	10892	21	of	of	IN
18637	10892	22	the	the	DT
18637	10892	23	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	10892	24	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	10892	25	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	10892	26	,	,	,
18637	10892	27	because	because	IN
18637	10892	28	the	the	DT
18637	10892	29	act	act	NN
18637	10892	30	of	of	IN
18637	10892	31	1934	1934	CD
18637	10892	32	applied	apply	VBD
18637	10892	33	only	only	RB
18637	10892	34	to	to	IN
18637	10892	35	"	"	``
18637	10892	36	cases	case	NNS
18637	10892	37	of	of	IN
18637	10892	38	actual	actual	JJ
18637	10892	39	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10892	40	.	.	.
18637	10892	41	"	"	''
18637	10893	1	In	in	IN
18637	10893	2	the	the	DT
18637	10893	3	same	same	JJ
18637	10893	4	case	case	NN
18637	10893	5	the	the	DT
18637	10893	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10893	7	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10893	8	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	10893	9	to	to	TO
18637	10893	10	pass	pass	VB
18637	10893	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	10893	12	the	the	DT
18637	10893	13	navigability	navigability	NN
18637	10893	14	of	of	IN
18637	10893	15	the	the	DT
18637	10893	16	New	New	NNP
18637	10893	17	and	and	CC
18637	10893	18	Kanawha	Kanawha	NNP
18637	10893	19	rivers	river	NNS
18637	10893	20	and	and	CC
18637	10893	21	the	the	DT
18637	10893	22	authority	authority	NN
18637	10893	23	of	of	IN
18637	10893	24	the	the	DT
18637	10893	25	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10893	26	Power	Power	NNP
18637	10893	27	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	10893	28	even	even	RB
18637	10893	29	at	at	IN
18637	10893	30	the	the	DT
18637	10893	31	request	request	NN
18637	10893	32	of	of	IN
18637	10893	33	the	the	DT
18637	10893	34	United	United	NNP
18637	10893	35	States	States	NNP
18637	10893	36	,	,	,
18637	10893	37	on	on	IN
18637	10893	38	the	the	DT
18637	10893	39	ground	ground	NN
18637	10893	40	that	that	IN
18637	10893	41	the	the	DT
18637	10893	42	bill	bill	NN
18637	10893	43	did	do	VBD
18637	10893	44	no	no	RB
18637	10893	45	more	more	JJR
18637	10893	46	than	than	IN
18637	10893	47	state	state	NN
18637	10893	48	a	a	DT
18637	10893	49	difference	difference	NN
18637	10893	50	of	of	IN
18637	10893	51	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10893	52	between	between	IN
18637	10893	53	the	the	DT
18637	10893	54	United	United	NNP
18637	10893	55	States	States	NNP
18637	10893	56	and	and	CC
18637	10893	57	West	West	NNP
18637	10893	58	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	10893	59	to	to	TO
18637	10893	60	which	which	WDT
18637	10893	61	the	the	DT
18637	10893	62	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10893	63	power	power	NN
18637	10893	64	did	do	VBD
18637	10893	65	not	not	RB
18637	10893	66	extend	extend	VB
18637	10893	67	.	.	.
18637	10894	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10894	2	243	243	CD
18637	10894	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10894	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	10894	5	,	,	,
18637	10894	6	in	in	IN
18637	10894	7	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	10894	8	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	10894	9	&	&	CC
18637	10894	10	Share	Share	NNP
18637	10894	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10894	12	_	_	NNP
18637	10894	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	10894	14	_	_	NNP
18637	10894	15	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	10894	16	and	and	CC
18637	10894	17	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	10894	18	Commission,[244	Commission,[244	.
18637	10894	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10894	20	the	the	DT
18637	10894	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10894	22	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	10894	23	to	to	TO
18637	10894	24	decide	decide	VB
18637	10894	25	any	any	DT
18637	10894	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10894	27	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10894	28	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10894	29	out	out	IN
18637	10894	30	of	of	IN
18637	10894	31	the	the	DT
18637	10894	32	Public	Public	NNP
18637	10894	33	Utility	Utility	NNP
18637	10894	34	Holding	Holding	NNP
18637	10894	35	Company	Company	NNP
18637	10894	36	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10894	37	of	of	IN
18637	10894	38	1935	1935	CD
18637	10894	39	except	except	IN
18637	10894	40	the	the	DT
18637	10894	41	registration	registration	NN
18637	10894	42	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	10894	43	because	because	IN
18637	10894	44	the	the	DT
18637	10894	45	cross	cross	NN
18637	10894	46	bill	bill	NN
18637	10894	47	in	in	IN
18637	10894	48	which	which	WDT
18637	10894	49	the	the	DT
18637	10894	50	company	company	NN
18637	10894	51	had	have	VBD
18637	10894	52	asked	ask	VBN
18637	10894	53	for	for	IN
18637	10894	54	a	a	DT
18637	10894	55	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	10894	56	that	that	IN
18637	10894	57	the	the	DT
18637	10894	58	whole	whole	JJ
18637	10894	59	act	act	NN
18637	10894	60	was	be	VBD
18637	10894	61	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	10894	62	was	be	VBD
18637	10894	63	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	10894	64	as	as	IN
18637	10894	65	presenting	present	VBG
18637	10894	66	a	a	DT
18637	10894	67	variety	variety	NN
18637	10894	68	of	of	IN
18637	10894	69	hypothetical	hypothetical	JJ
18637	10894	70	questions	question	NNS
18637	10894	71	that	that	WDT
18637	10894	72	might	may	MD
18637	10894	73	never	never	RB
18637	10894	74	become	become	VB
18637	10894	75	real	real	JJ
18637	10894	76	.	.	.
18637	10895	1	The	the	DT
18637	10895	2	"	"	``
18637	10895	3	Case	Case	NNP
18637	10895	4	"	"	''
18637	10895	5	or	or	CC
18637	10895	6	"	"	``
18637	10895	7	Controversy	Controversy	NNP
18637	10895	8	"	"	''
18637	10895	9	Test	test	NN
18637	10895	10	in	in	IN
18637	10895	11	Declaratory	Declaratory	NNP
18637	10895	12	Judgment	Judgment	NNP
18637	10895	13	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNP
18637	10895	14	The	the	DT
18637	10895	15	insistence	insistence	NN
18637	10895	16	of	of	IN
18637	10895	17	the	the	DT
18637	10895	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10895	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	10895	20	the	the	DT
18637	10895	21	rule	rule	NN
18637	10895	22	that	that	IN
18637	10895	23	"	"	``
18637	10895	24	the	the	DT
18637	10895	25	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	10895	26	for	for	IN
18637	10895	27	a	a	DT
18637	10895	28	justiciable	justiciable	JJ
18637	10895	29	case	case	NN
18637	10895	30	or	or	CC
18637	10895	31	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10895	32	are	be	VBP
18637	10895	33	no	no	RB
18637	10895	34	less	less	RBR
18637	10895	35	strict	strict	JJ
18637	10895	36	in	in	IN
18637	10895	37	a	a	DT
18637	10895	38	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	10895	39	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10895	40	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	10895	41	than	than	IN
18637	10895	42	in	in	IN
18637	10895	43	any	any	DT
18637	10895	44	other	other	JJ
18637	10895	45	type	type	NN
18637	10895	46	of	of	IN
18637	10895	47	suit,"[245	suit,"[245	NN
18637	10895	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10895	49	and	and	CC
18637	10895	50	the	the	DT
18637	10895	51	fact	fact	NN
18637	10895	52	that	that	IN
18637	10895	53	many	many	JJ
18637	10895	54	actions	action	NNS
18637	10895	55	for	for	IN
18637	10895	56	a	a	DT
18637	10895	57	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	10895	58	of	of	IN
18637	10895	59	rights	right	NNS
18637	10895	60	have	have	VBP
18637	10895	61	involved	involve	VBN
18637	10895	62	the	the	DT
18637	10895	63	validity	validity	NN
18637	10895	64	of	of	IN
18637	10895	65	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10895	66	,	,	,
18637	10895	67	where	where	WRB
18637	10895	68	the	the	DT
18637	10895	69	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10895	70	is	be	VBZ
18637	10895	71	even	even	RB
18637	10895	72	more	more	RBR
18637	10895	73	insistent	insistent	JJ
18637	10895	74	upon	upon	IN
18637	10895	75	the	the	DT
18637	10895	76	essentials	essential	NNS
18637	10895	77	of	of	IN
18637	10895	78	a	a	DT
18637	10895	79	case	case	NN
18637	10895	80	,	,	,
18637	10895	81	have	have	VBP
18637	10895	82	done	do	VBN
18637	10895	83	much	much	RB
18637	10895	84	to	to	TO
18637	10895	85	limit	limit	VB
18637	10895	86	the	the	DT
18637	10895	87	use	use	NN
18637	10895	88	of	of	IN
18637	10895	89	the	the	DT
18637	10895	90	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	10895	91	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10895	92	.	.	.
18637	10896	1	There	there	EX
18637	10896	2	are	be	VBP
18637	10896	3	,	,	,
18637	10896	4	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	10896	5	,	,	,
18637	10896	6	a	a	DT
18637	10896	7	number	number	NN
18637	10896	8	of	of	IN
18637	10896	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	10896	10	,	,	,
18637	10896	11	some	some	DT
18637	10896	12	of	of	IN
18637	10896	13	which	which	WDT
18637	10896	14	involved	involve	VBD
18637	10896	15	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10896	16	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10896	17	,	,	,
18637	10896	18	in	in	IN
18637	10896	19	which	which	WDT
18637	10896	20	a	a	DT
18637	10896	21	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	10896	22	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10896	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	10896	24	been	be	VBN
18637	10896	25	rendered	render	VBN
18637	10896	26	.	.	.
18637	10897	1	Among	among	IN
18637	10897	2	these	these	DT
18637	10897	3	are	be	VBP
18637	10897	4	Currin	Currin	NNP
18637	10897	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10897	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	10897	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10897	8	Wallace,[246	Wallace,[246	NNP
18637	10897	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10897	10	where	where	WRB
18637	10897	11	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	10897	12	warehousemen	warehouseman	NNS
18637	10897	13	and	and	CC
18637	10897	14	auctioneers	auctioneer	NNS
18637	10897	15	contested	contest	VBD
18637	10897	16	the	the	DT
18637	10897	17	validity	validity	NN
18637	10897	18	of	of	IN
18637	10897	19	the	the	DT
18637	10897	20	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	10897	21	Inspection	Inspection	NNP
18637	10897	22	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10897	23	under	under	IN
18637	10897	24	which	which	WDT
18637	10897	25	the	the	DT
18637	10897	26	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10897	27	of	of	IN
18637	10897	28	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	10897	29	had	have	VBD
18637	10897	30	already	already	RB
18637	10897	31	designated	designate	VBN
18637	10897	32	a	a	DT
18637	10897	33	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	10897	34	market	market	NN
18637	10897	35	for	for	IN
18637	10897	36	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	10897	37	and	and	CC
18637	10897	38	grading	grade	VBG
18637	10897	39	;	;	:
18637	10897	40	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
18637	10897	41	_	_	NNP
18637	10897	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	10897	43	_	_	NNP
18637	10897	44	Elg,[247	Elg,[247	NNP
18637	10897	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10897	46	where	where	WRB
18637	10897	47	a	a	DT
18637	10897	48	natural	natural	RB
18637	10897	49	-	-	HYPH
18637	10897	50	born	bear	VBN
18637	10897	51	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	10897	52	of	of	IN
18637	10897	53	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	10897	54	parents	parent	NNS
18637	10897	55	who	who	WP
18637	10897	56	left	leave	VBD
18637	10897	57	the	the	DT
18637	10897	58	country	country	NN
18637	10897	59	during	during	IN
18637	10897	60	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10897	61	minority	minority	NN
18637	10897	62	sought	seek	VBD
18637	10897	63	to	to	TO
18637	10897	64	establish	establish	VB
18637	10897	65	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10897	66	status	status	NN
18637	10897	67	as	as	IN
18637	10897	68	a	a	DT
18637	10897	69	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	10897	70	;	;	:
18637	10897	71	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	10897	72	Casualty	Casualty	NNP
18637	10897	73	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10897	74	_	_	NNP
18637	10897	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	10897	76	_	_	NNP
18637	10897	77	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	10897	78	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	10897	79	and	and	CC
18637	10897	80	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	10897	81	Co	Co	NNP
18637	10897	82	.	.	.
18637	10897	83	,[248	,[248	NFP
18637	10897	84	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10897	85	where	where	WRB
18637	10897	86	a	a	DT
18637	10897	87	liability	liability	NN
18637	10897	88	insurer	insurer	NN
18637	10897	89	sought	seek	VBD
18637	10897	90	to	to	TO
18637	10897	91	establish	establish	VB
18637	10897	92	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10897	93	lack	lack	NN
18637	10897	94	of	of	IN
18637	10897	95	liability	liability	NN
18637	10897	96	in	in	IN
18637	10897	97	an	an	DT
18637	10897	98	automobile	automobile	NN
18637	10897	99	collision	collision	NN
18637	10897	100	case	case	NN
18637	10897	101	;	;	,
18637	10897	102	and	and	CC
18637	10897	103	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	10897	104	Life	Life	NNP
18637	10897	105	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	10897	106	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	10897	107	_	_	NNP
18637	10897	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	10897	109	_	_	NNP
18637	10897	110	Haworth,[249	Haworth,[249	NNP
18637	10897	111	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10897	112	where	where	WRB
18637	10897	113	a	a	DT
18637	10897	114	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	10897	115	was	be	VBD
18637	10897	116	sought	seek	VBN
18637	10897	117	under	under	IN
18637	10897	118	the	the	DT
18637	10897	119	disability	disability	NN
18637	10897	120	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	10897	121	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	10897	122	of	of	IN
18637	10897	123	an	an	DT
18637	10897	124	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	10897	125	policy	policy	NN
18637	10897	126	.	.	.
18637	10898	1	As	as	IN
18637	10898	2	stated	state	VBN
18637	10898	3	by	by	IN
18637	10898	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10898	5	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	10898	6	for	for	IN
18637	10898	7	the	the	DT
18637	10898	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10898	9	in	in	IN
18637	10898	10	the	the	DT
18637	10898	11	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	10898	12	Casualty	Casualty	NNP
18637	10898	13	case	case	NN
18637	10898	14	:	:	:
18637	10898	15	"	"	``
18637	10898	16	The	the	DT
18637	10898	17	difference	difference	NN
18637	10898	18	between	between	IN
18637	10898	19	an	an	DT
18637	10898	20	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	10898	21	question	question	NN
18637	10898	22	and	and	CC
18637	10898	23	a	a	DT
18637	10898	24	'	'	``
18637	10898	25	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10898	26	'	'	''
18637	10898	27	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
18637	10898	28	by	by	IN
18637	10898	29	the	the	DT
18637	10898	30	Declaratory	Declaratory	NNP
18637	10898	31	Judgment	Judgment	NNP
18637	10898	32	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10898	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	10898	34	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	10898	35	one	one	CD
18637	10898	36	of	of	IN
18637	10898	37	degree	degree	NN
18637	10898	38	,	,	,
18637	10898	39	and	and	CC
18637	10898	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10898	41	would	would	MD
18637	10898	42	be	be	VB
18637	10898	43	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	10898	44	,	,	,
18637	10898	45	if	if	IN
18637	10898	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10898	47	would	would	MD
18637	10898	48	be	be	VB
18637	10898	49	possible	possible	JJ
18637	10898	50	,	,	,
18637	10898	51	to	to	TO
18637	10898	52	fashion	fashion	VB
18637	10898	53	a	a	DT
18637	10898	54	precise	precise	JJ
18637	10898	55	test	test	NN
18637	10898	56	for	for	IN
18637	10898	57	determining	determine	VBG
18637	10898	58	in	in	IN
18637	10898	59	every	every	DT
18637	10898	60	case	case	NN
18637	10898	61	whether	whether	IN
18637	10898	62	there	there	EX
18637	10898	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	10898	64	such	such	PDT
18637	10898	65	a	a	DT
18637	10898	66	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10898	67	.	.	.
18637	10899	1	Basically	basically	RB
18637	10899	2	,	,	,
18637	10899	3	the	the	DT
18637	10899	4	question	question	NN
18637	10899	5	in	in	IN
18637	10899	6	each	each	DT
18637	10899	7	case	case	NN
18637	10899	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	10899	9	whether	whether	IN
18637	10899	10	the	the	DT
18637	10899	11	facts	fact	NNS
18637	10899	12	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	10899	13	,	,	,
18637	10899	14	under	under	IN
18637	10899	15	all	all	PDT
18637	10899	16	the	the	DT
18637	10899	17	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	10899	18	,	,	,
18637	10899	19	show	show	VBP
18637	10899	20	that	that	IN
18637	10899	21	there	there	EX
18637	10899	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	10899	23	a	a	DT
18637	10899	24	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	10899	25	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10899	26	,	,	,
18637	10899	27	between	between	IN
18637	10899	28	parties	party	NNS
18637	10899	29	having	have	VBG
18637	10899	30	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	10899	31	legal	legal	JJ
18637	10899	32	interests	interest	NNS
18637	10899	33	,	,	,
18637	10899	34	of	of	IN
18637	10899	35	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	10899	36	immediacy	immediacy	NN
18637	10899	37	and	and	CC
18637	10899	38	reality	reality	NN
18637	10899	39	to	to	TO
18637	10899	40	warrant	warrant	VB
18637	10899	41	the	the	DT
18637	10899	42	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	10899	43	of	of	IN
18637	10899	44	a	a	DT
18637	10899	45	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	10899	46	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10899	47	.	.	.
18637	10900	1	"	"	``
18637	10900	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10900	3	250	250	CD
18637	10900	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10900	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10900	6	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	10900	7	,	,	,
18637	10900	8	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	10900	9	,	,	,
18637	10900	10	for	for	IN
18637	10900	11	the	the	DT
18637	10900	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	10900	13	to	to	TO
18637	10900	14	determine	determine	VB
18637	10900	15	in	in	IN
18637	10900	16	each	each	DT
18637	10900	17	case	case	NN
18637	10900	18	the	the	DT
18637	10900	19	degree	degree	NN
18637	10900	20	of	of	IN
18637	10900	21	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10900	22	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10900	23	to	to	TO
18637	10900	24	establish	establish	VB
18637	10900	25	a	a	DT
18637	10900	26	case	case	NN
18637	10900	27	for	for	IN
18637	10900	28	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	10900	29	of	of	IN
18637	10900	30	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10900	31	.	.	.
18637	10901	1	Even	even	RB
18637	10901	2	,	,	,
18637	10901	3	then	then	RB
18637	10901	4	,	,	,
18637	10901	5	however	however	RB
18637	10901	6	,	,	,
18637	10901	7	the	the	DT
18637	10901	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10901	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	10901	10	under	under	IN
18637	10901	11	no	no	DT
18637	10901	12	compulsion	compulsion	NN
18637	10901	13	to	to	TO
18637	10901	14	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	10901	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10901	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10901	17	.	.	.
18637	10902	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10902	2	251	251	CD
18637	10902	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10902	4	Cases	case	NNS
18637	10902	5	Arising	arise	VBG
18637	10902	6	Under	under	IN
18637	10902	7	the	the	DT
18637	10902	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10902	9	,	,	,
18637	10902	10	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	10902	11	and	and	CC
18637	10902	12	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	10902	13	of	of	IN
18637	10902	14	the	the	DT
18637	10902	15	United	United	NNP
18637	10902	16	States	States	NNP
18637	10902	17	DEFINITION	DEFINITION	NNP
18637	10902	18	Cases	case	NNS
18637	10902	19	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10902	20	under	under	IN
18637	10902	21	the	the	DT
18637	10902	22	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10902	23	are	be	VBP
18637	10902	24	cases	case	NNS
18637	10902	25	which	which	WDT
18637	10902	26	require	require	VBP
18637	10902	27	an	an	DT
18637	10902	28	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	10902	29	of	of	IN
18637	10902	30	the	the	DT
18637	10902	31	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10902	32	for	for	IN
18637	10902	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10902	34	correct	correct	JJ
18637	10902	35	decision	decision	NN
18637	10902	36	.	.	.
18637	10903	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10903	2	252	252	CD
18637	10903	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10903	4	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10903	5	arise	arise	VBP
18637	10903	6	when	when	WRB
18637	10903	7	a	a	DT
18637	10903	8	litigant	litigant	NN
18637	10903	9	claims	claim	VBZ
18637	10903	10	an	an	DT
18637	10903	11	actual	actual	JJ
18637	10903	12	or	or	CC
18637	10903	13	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	10903	14	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	10903	15	of	of	IN
18637	10903	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10903	17	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10903	18	rights	right	NNS
18637	10903	19	by	by	IN
18637	10903	20	the	the	DT
18637	10903	21	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10903	22	of	of	IN
18637	10903	23	some	some	DT
18637	10903	24	act	act	NN
18637	10903	25	of	of	IN
18637	10903	26	public	public	JJ
18637	10903	27	authority	authority	NN
18637	10903	28	,	,	,
18637	10903	29	usually	usually	RB
18637	10903	30	an	an	DT
18637	10903	31	act	act	NN
18637	10903	32	of	of	IN
18637	10903	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10903	34	or	or	CC
18637	10903	35	of	of	IN
18637	10903	36	a	a	DT
18637	10903	37	State	State	NNP
18637	10903	38	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	10903	39	,	,	,
18637	10903	40	and	and	CC
18637	10903	41	asks	ask	VBZ
18637	10903	42	for	for	IN
18637	10903	43	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10903	44	relief	relief	NN
18637	10903	45	.	.	.
18637	10904	1	The	the	DT
18637	10904	2	clause	clause	NN
18637	10904	3	furnishes	furnish	VBZ
18637	10904	4	the	the	DT
18637	10904	5	textual	textual	JJ
18637	10904	6	basis	basis	NN
18637	10904	7	for	for	IN
18637	10904	8	the	the	DT
18637	10904	9	fountain	fountain	NN
18637	10904	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	10904	11	head	head	NN
18637	10904	12	of	of	IN
18637	10904	13	American	American	NNP
18637	10904	14	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	10904	15	Law	Law	NNP
18637	10904	16	,	,	,
18637	10904	17	in	in	IN
18637	10904	18	the	the	DT
18637	10904	19	strict	strict	JJ
18637	10904	20	sense	sense	NN
18637	10904	21	of	of	IN
18637	10904	22	the	the	DT
18637	10904	23	term	term	NN
18637	10904	24	,	,	,
18637	10904	25	which	which	WDT
18637	10904	26	fountain	fountain	NN
18637	10904	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	10904	28	head	head	NN
18637	10904	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	10904	30	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	10904	31	Review	Review	NNP
18637	10904	32	,	,	,
18637	10904	33	or	or	CC
18637	10904	34	the	the	DT
18637	10904	35	power	power	NN
18637	10904	36	and	and	CC
18637	10904	37	duty	duty	NN
18637	10904	38	of	of	IN
18637	10904	39	the	the	DT
18637	10904	40	courts	court	NNS
18637	10904	41	to	to	TO
18637	10904	42	pass	pass	VB
18637	10904	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	10904	44	the	the	DT
18637	10904	45	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10904	46	validity	validity	NN
18637	10904	47	of	of	IN
18637	10904	48	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10904	49	acts	act	NNS
18637	10904	50	which	which	WDT
18637	10904	51	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10904	52	are	be	VBP
18637	10904	53	called	call	VBN
18637	10904	54	upon	upon	IN
18637	10904	55	to	to	TO
18637	10904	56	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	10904	57	and	and	CC
18637	10904	58	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	10904	59	in	in	IN
18637	10904	60	cases	case	NNS
18637	10904	61	coming	come	VBG
18637	10904	62	before	before	IN
18637	10904	63	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10904	64	,	,	,
18637	10904	65	and	and	CC
18637	10904	66	to	to	TO
18637	10904	67	declare	declare	VB
18637	10904	68	void	void	JJ
18637	10904	69	and	and	CC
18637	10904	70	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	10904	71	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10904	72	to	to	IN
18637	10904	73	such	such	JJ
18637	10904	74	as	as	IN
18637	10904	75	do	do	VBP
18637	10904	76	not	not	RB
18637	10904	77	accord	accord	VB
18637	10904	78	with	with	IN
18637	10904	79	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10904	80	own	own	JJ
18637	10904	81	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	10904	82	of	of	IN
18637	10904	83	the	the	DT
18637	10904	84	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10904	85	.	.	.
18637	10905	1	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	10905	2	REVIEW	REVIEW	NNP
18637	10905	3	The	the	DT
18637	10905	4	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	10905	5	clause	clause	NN
18637	10905	6	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	10905	7	recognizes	recognize	VBZ
18637	10905	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10905	9	review	review	NN
18637	10905	10	of	of	IN
18637	10905	11	State	State	NNP
18637	10905	12	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10905	13	acts	act	NNS
18637	10905	14	in	in	IN
18637	10905	15	relation	relation	NN
18637	10905	16	not	not	RB
18637	10905	17	only	only	RB
18637	10905	18	to	to	IN
18637	10905	19	the	the	DT
18637	10905	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10905	21	,	,	,
18637	10905	22	but	but	CC
18637	10905	23	also	also	RB
18637	10905	24	in	in	IN
18637	10905	25	relation	relation	NN
18637	10905	26	to	to	IN
18637	10905	27	acts	act	NNS
18637	10905	28	of	of	IN
18637	10905	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10905	30	which	which	WDT
18637	10905	31	are	be	VBP
18637	10905	32	"	"	``
18637	10905	33	in	in	IN
18637	10905	34	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	10905	35	of	of	IN
18637	10905	36	the	the	DT
18637	10905	37	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10905	38	,	,	,
18637	10905	39	"	"	''
18637	10905	40	and	and	CC
18637	10905	41	in	in	IN
18637	10905	42	relation	relation	NN
18637	10905	43	to	to	IN
18637	10905	44	"	"	``
18637	10905	45	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	10905	46	made	make	VBN
18637	10905	47	or	or	CC
18637	10905	48	which	which	WDT
18637	10905	49	shall	shall	MD
18637	10905	50	be	be	VB
18637	10905	51	made	make	VBN
18637	10905	52	under	under	IN
18637	10905	53	the	the	DT
18637	10905	54	authority	authority	NN
18637	10905	55	of	of	IN
18637	10905	56	the	the	DT
18637	10905	57	United	United	NNP
18637	10905	58	States	States	NNP
18637	10905	59	.	.	.
18637	10905	60	"	"	''
18637	10906	1	These	these	DT
18637	10906	2	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	10906	3	"	"	``
18637	10906	4	the	the	DT
18637	10906	5	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	10906	6	law	law	NNP
18637	10906	7	of	of	IN
18637	10906	8	the	the	DT
18637	10906	9	land	land	NN
18637	10906	10	,	,	,
18637	10906	11	"	"	''
18637	10906	12	and	and	CC
18637	10906	13	"	"	``
18637	10906	14	the	the	DT
18637	10906	15	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10906	16	in	in	IN
18637	10906	17	every	every	DT
18637	10906	18	State	state	NN
18637	10906	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	10906	20	be	be	VB
18637	10906	21	bound	bind	VBN
18637	10906	22	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	10906	23	,	,	,
18637	10906	24	anything	anything	NN
18637	10906	25	in	in	IN
18637	10906	26	the	the	DT
18637	10906	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10906	28	or	or	CC
18637	10906	29	laws	law	NNS
18637	10906	30	of	of	IN
18637	10906	31	any	any	DT
18637	10906	32	State	State	NNP
18637	10906	33	to	to	IN
18637	10906	34	the	the	DT
18637	10906	35	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	10906	36	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	10906	37	.	.	.
18637	10906	38	"	"	''
18637	10907	1	This	this	DT
18637	10907	2	provision	provision	NN
18637	10907	3	was	be	VBD
18637	10907	4	originally	originally	RB
18637	10907	5	implemented	implement	VBN
18637	10907	6	by	by	IN
18637	10907	7	the	the	DT
18637	10907	8	famous	famous	JJ
18637	10907	9	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	10907	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	10907	11	fifth	fifth	JJ
18637	10907	12	section	section	NN
18637	10907	13	of	of	IN
18637	10907	14	the	the	DT
18637	10907	15	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	10907	16	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10907	17	of	of	IN
18637	10907	18	1789	1789	CD
18637	10907	19	which	which	WDT
18637	10907	20	provided	provide	VBD
18637	10907	21	that	that	IN
18637	10907	22	final	final	JJ
18637	10907	23	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	10907	24	or	or	CC
18637	10907	25	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	10907	26	of	of	IN
18637	10907	27	the	the	DT
18637	10907	28	highest	high	JJS
18637	10907	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	10907	30	of	of	IN
18637	10907	31	law	law	NN
18637	10907	32	or	or	CC
18637	10907	33	equity	equity	NN
18637	10907	34	in	in	IN
18637	10907	35	the	the	DT
18637	10907	36	States	States	NNP
18637	10907	37	in	in	IN
18637	10907	38	which	which	WDT
18637	10907	39	a	a	DT
18637	10907	40	decision	decision	NN
18637	10907	41	could	could	MD
18637	10907	42	be	be	VB
18637	10907	43	had	have	VBN
18637	10907	44	,	,	,
18637	10907	45	"	"	``
18637	10907	46	where	where	WRB
18637	10907	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	10907	48	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	10907	49	in	in	IN
18637	10907	50	question	question	NN
18637	10907	51	the	the	DT
18637	10907	52	validity	validity	NN
18637	10907	53	of	of	IN
18637	10907	54	a	a	DT
18637	10907	55	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	10907	56	or	or	CC
18637	10907	57	statute	statute	NN
18637	10907	58	of	of	IN
18637	10907	59	,	,	,
18637	10907	60	or	or	CC
18637	10907	61	an	an	DT
18637	10907	62	authority	authority	NN
18637	10907	63	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	10907	64	under	under	IN
18637	10907	65	the	the	DT
18637	10907	66	United	United	NNP
18637	10907	67	States	States	NNP
18637	10907	68	,	,	,
18637	10907	69	and	and	CC
18637	10907	70	the	the	DT
18637	10907	71	decision	decision	NN
18637	10907	72	is	be	VBZ
18637	10907	73	against	against	IN
18637	10907	74	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10907	75	validity	validity	NN
18637	10907	76	;	;	:
18637	10907	77	or	or	CC
18637	10907	78	where	where	WRB
18637	10907	79	is	be	VBZ
18637	10907	80	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	10907	81	in	in	IN
18637	10907	82	question	question	NN
18637	10907	83	the	the	DT
18637	10907	84	validity	validity	NN
18637	10907	85	of	of	IN
18637	10907	86	a	a	DT
18637	10907	87	statute	statute	NN
18637	10907	88	of	of	IN
18637	10907	89	,	,	,
18637	10907	90	or	or	CC
18637	10907	91	an	an	DT
18637	10907	92	authority	authority	NN
18637	10907	93	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	10907	94	under	under	IN
18637	10907	95	any	any	DT
18637	10907	96	State	State	NNP
18637	10907	97	,	,	,
18637	10907	98	on	on	IN
18637	10907	99	the	the	DT
18637	10907	100	ground	ground	NN
18637	10907	101	of	of	IN
18637	10907	102	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10907	103	being	be	VBG
18637	10907	104	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	10907	105	to	to	IN
18637	10907	106	the	the	DT
18637	10907	107	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10907	108	,	,	,
18637	10907	109	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	10907	110	or	or	CC
18637	10907	111	laws	law	NNS
18637	10907	112	of	of	IN
18637	10907	113	the	the	DT
18637	10907	114	United	United	NNP
18637	10907	115	States	States	NNP
18637	10907	116	,	,	,
18637	10907	117	and	and	CC
18637	10907	118	the	the	DT
18637	10907	119	decision	decision	NN
18637	10907	120	is	be	VBZ
18637	10907	121	in	in	IN
18637	10907	122	favour	favour	NN
18637	10907	123	of	of	IN
18637	10907	124	such	such	PDT
18637	10907	125	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10907	126	validity	validity	NN
18637	10907	127	,	,	,
18637	10907	128	or	or	CC
18637	10907	129	where	where	WRB
18637	10907	130	is	be	VBZ
18637	10907	131	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	10907	132	in	in	IN
18637	10907	133	question	question	NN
18637	10907	134	the	the	DT
18637	10907	135	construction	construction	NN
18637	10907	136	of	of	IN
18637	10907	137	any	any	DT
18637	10907	138	clause	clause	NN
18637	10907	139	of	of	IN
18637	10907	140	the	the	DT
18637	10907	141	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10907	142	,	,	,
18637	10907	143	or	or	CC
18637	10907	144	of	of	IN
18637	10907	145	a	a	DT
18637	10907	146	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	10907	147	,	,	,
18637	10907	148	or	or	CC
18637	10907	149	statute	statute	NN
18637	10907	150	of	of	IN
18637	10907	151	,	,	,
18637	10907	152	or	or	CC
18637	10907	153	commission	commission	NN
18637	10907	154	held	hold	VBN
18637	10907	155	under	under	IN
18637	10907	156	the	the	DT
18637	10907	157	United	United	NNP
18637	10907	158	States	States	NNP
18637	10907	159	,	,	,
18637	10907	160	and	and	CC
18637	10907	161	the	the	DT
18637	10907	162	decision	decision	NN
18637	10907	163	is	be	VBZ
18637	10907	164	against	against	IN
18637	10907	165	the	the	DT
18637	10907	166	title	title	NN
18637	10907	167	,	,	,
18637	10907	168	right	right	UH
18637	10907	169	,	,	,
18637	10907	170	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	10907	171	or	or	CC
18637	10907	172	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	10907	173	specially	specially	RB
18637	10907	174	set	set	VBN
18637	10907	175	up	up	RP
18637	10907	176	or	or	CC
18637	10907	177	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	10907	178	by	by	IN
18637	10907	179	either	either	DT
18637	10907	180	party	party	NN
18637	10907	181	,	,	,
18637	10907	182	under	under	IN
18637	10907	183	such	such	JJ
18637	10907	184	clause	clause	NN
18637	10907	185	of	of	IN
18637	10907	186	the	the	DT
18637	10907	187	said	say	VBD
18637	10907	188	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10907	189	,	,	,
18637	10907	190	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	10907	191	,	,	,
18637	10907	192	statute	statute	NN
18637	10907	193	or	or	CC
18637	10907	194	commission	commission	NN
18637	10907	195	,	,	,
18637	10907	196	may	may	MD
18637	10907	197	be	be	VB
18637	10907	198	re	re	VBN
18637	10907	199	-	-	VBN
18637	10907	200	examined	examine	VBN
18637	10907	201	and	and	CC
18637	10907	202	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	10907	203	or	or	CC
18637	10907	204	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	10907	205	in	in	IN
18637	10907	206	the	the	DT
18637	10907	207	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10907	208	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10907	209	of	of	IN
18637	10907	210	the	the	DT
18637	10907	211	United	United	NNP
18637	10907	212	States	States	NNP
18637	10907	213	upon	upon	IN
18637	10907	214	a	a	DT
18637	10907	215	writ	writ	NN
18637	10907	216	of	of	IN
18637	10907	217	error	error	NN
18637	10907	218	,	,	,
18637	10907	219	*	*	NFP
18637	10907	220	*	*	NFP
18637	10907	221	*	*	NFP
18637	10907	222	"	"	''
18637	10907	223	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10907	224	253	253	CD
18637	10907	225	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10907	226	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	10907	227	REVIEW	REVIEW	NNP
18637	10907	228	AND	and	CC
18637	10907	229	NATIONAL	NATIONAL	NNP
18637	10907	230	SUPREMACY	SUPREMACY	NNP
18637	10907	231	A	a	DT
18637	10907	232	quarter	quarter	NN
18637	10907	233	of	of	IN
18637	10907	234	a	a	DT
18637	10907	235	century	century	NN
18637	10907	236	after	after	IN
18637	10907	237	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10907	238	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	10907	239	the	the	DT
18637	10907	240	validity	validity	NN
18637	10907	241	of	of	IN
18637	10907	242	this	this	DT
18637	10907	243	section	section	NN
18637	10907	244	was	be	VBD
18637	10907	245	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	10907	246	on	on	IN
18637	10907	247	States	state	NNS
18637	10907	248	'	'	POS
18637	10907	249	Rights	right	NNS
18637	10907	250	premises	premise	NNS
18637	10907	251	in	in	IN
18637	10907	252	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	10907	253	_	_	NNP
18637	10907	254	v.	v.	IN
18637	10907	255	_	_	NNP
18637	10907	256	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	10907	257	's	's	POS
18637	10907	258	Lessee,[254	lessee,[254	NN
18637	10907	259	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10907	260	and	and	CC
18637	10907	261	seven	seven	CD
18637	10907	262	years	year	NNS
18637	10907	263	after	after	IN
18637	10907	264	that	that	DT
18637	10907	265	in	in	IN
18637	10907	266	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	10907	267	_	_	NNP
18637	10907	268	v.	v.	IN
18637	10907	269	_	_	NNP
18637	10907	270	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	10907	271	.	.	.
18637	10908	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10908	2	255	255	CD
18637	10908	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10908	4	The	the	DT
18637	10908	5	States	States	NNPS
18637	10908	6	'	'	POS
18637	10908	7	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	10908	8	argument	argument	NN
18637	10908	9	was	be	VBD
18637	10908	10	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	10908	11	the	the	DT
18637	10908	12	same	same	JJ
18637	10908	13	in	in	IN
18637	10908	14	both	both	DT
18637	10908	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	10908	16	.	.	.
18637	10909	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10909	2	amounted	amount	VBD
18637	10909	3	to	to	IN
18637	10909	4	the	the	DT
18637	10909	5	contention	contention	NN
18637	10909	6	that	that	IN
18637	10909	7	while	while	IN
18637	10909	8	the	the	DT
18637	10909	9	courts	court	NNS
18637	10909	10	of	of	IN
18637	10909	11	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	10909	12	were	be	VBD
18637	10909	13	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	10909	14	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	10909	15	to	to	TO
18637	10909	16	prefer	prefer	VB
18637	10909	17	"	"	``
18637	10909	18	the	the	DT
18637	10909	19	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	10909	20	law	law	NNP
18637	10909	21	of	of	IN
18637	10909	22	the	the	DT
18637	10909	23	land	land	NN
18637	10909	24	"	"	''
18637	10909	25	as	as	IN
18637	10909	26	defined	define	VBN
18637	10909	27	in	in	IN
18637	10909	28	the	the	DT
18637	10909	29	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	10909	30	clause	clause	NN
18637	10909	31	over	over	IN
18637	10909	32	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	10909	33	State	state	NN
18637	10909	34	laws	law	NNS
18637	10909	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10909	36	was	be	VBD
18637	10909	37	only	only	RB
18637	10909	38	by	by	IN
18637	10909	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10909	40	own	own	JJ
18637	10909	41	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	10909	42	of	of	IN
18637	10909	43	the	the	DT
18637	10909	44	said	say	VBN
18637	10909	45	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	10909	46	law	law	NNP
18637	10909	47	that	that	IN
18637	10909	48	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10909	49	,	,	,
18637	10909	50	as	as	IN
18637	10909	51	the	the	DT
18637	10909	52	courts	court	NNS
18637	10909	53	of	of	IN
18637	10909	54	a	a	DT
18637	10909	55	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	10909	56	State	state	NN
18637	10909	57	,	,	,
18637	10909	58	were	be	VBD
18637	10909	59	bound	bind	VBN
18637	10909	60	.	.	.
18637	10910	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	10910	2	,	,	,
18637	10910	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10910	4	was	be	VBD
18637	10910	5	contended	contend	VBN
18637	10910	6	that	that	IN
18637	10910	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	10910	8	did	do	VBD
18637	10910	9	not	not	RB
18637	10910	10	"	"	``
18637	10910	11	arise	arise	VB
18637	10910	12	"	"	''
18637	10910	13	under	under	IN
18637	10910	14	the	the	DT
18637	10910	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10910	16	unless	unless	IN
18637	10910	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10910	18	were	be	VBD
18637	10910	19	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10910	20	in	in	IN
18637	10910	21	the	the	DT
18637	10910	22	first	first	JJ
18637	10910	23	instance	instance	NN
18637	10910	24	by	by	IN
18637	10910	25	some	some	DT
18637	10910	26	one	one	NN
18637	10910	27	claiming	claim	VBG
18637	10910	28	such	such	PDT
18637	10910	29	a	a	DT
18637	10910	30	right	right	NN
18637	10910	31	,	,	,
18637	10910	32	from	from	IN
18637	10910	33	which	which	WDT
18637	10910	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10910	35	followed	follow	VBD
18637	10910	36	that	that	IN
18637	10910	37	"	"	``
18637	10910	38	the	the	DT
18637	10910	39	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10910	40	power	power	NN
18637	10910	41	of	of	IN
18637	10910	42	the	the	DT
18637	10910	43	United	United	NNP
18637	10910	44	States	States	NNP
18637	10910	45	"	"	''
18637	10910	46	did	do	VBD
18637	10910	47	not	not	RB
18637	10910	48	"	"	``
18637	10910	49	extend	extend	VB
18637	10910	50	"	"	''
18637	10910	51	to	to	IN
18637	10910	52	such	such	JJ
18637	10910	53	cases	case	NNS
18637	10910	54	unless	unless	IN
18637	10910	55	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10910	56	were	be	VBD
18637	10910	57	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10910	58	in	in	IN
18637	10910	59	the	the	DT
18637	10910	60	first	first	JJ
18637	10910	61	instance	instance	NN
18637	10910	62	in	in	IN
18637	10910	63	the	the	DT
18637	10910	64	courts	court	NNS
18637	10910	65	of	of	IN
18637	10910	66	the	the	DT
18637	10910	67	United	United	NNP
18637	10910	68	States	States	NNP
18637	10910	69	.	.	.
18637	10911	1	In	in	IN
18637	10911	2	answer	answer	NN
18637	10911	3	to	to	IN
18637	10911	4	these	these	DT
18637	10911	5	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	10911	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10911	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10911	8	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	10911	9	declared	declare	VBD
18637	10911	10	that	that	DT
18637	10911	11	:	:	:
18637	10911	12	"	"	``
18637	10911	13	A	a	DT
18637	10911	14	case	case	NN
18637	10911	15	in	in	IN
18637	10911	16	law	law	NN
18637	10911	17	or	or	CC
18637	10911	18	equity	equity	NN
18637	10911	19	consists	consist	VBZ
18637	10911	20	of	of	IN
18637	10911	21	the	the	DT
18637	10911	22	right	right	NN
18637	10911	23	of	of	IN
18637	10911	24	the	the	DT
18637	10911	25	one	one	CD
18637	10911	26	party	party	NN
18637	10911	27	,	,	,
18637	10911	28	as	as	RB
18637	10911	29	well	well	RB
18637	10911	30	as	as	IN
18637	10911	31	of	of	IN
18637	10911	32	the	the	DT
18637	10911	33	other	other	JJ
18637	10911	34	,	,	,
18637	10911	35	and	and	CC
18637	10911	36	may	may	MD
18637	10911	37	truly	truly	RB
18637	10911	38	be	be	VB
18637	10911	39	said	say	VBN
18637	10911	40	to	to	TO
18637	10911	41	arise	arise	VB
18637	10911	42	under	under	IN
18637	10911	43	the	the	DT
18637	10911	44	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10911	45	or	or	CC
18637	10911	46	a	a	DT
18637	10911	47	law	law	NN
18637	10911	48	of	of	IN
18637	10911	49	the	the	DT
18637	10911	50	United	United	NNP
18637	10911	51	States	States	NNP
18637	10911	52	,	,	,
18637	10911	53	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	10911	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10911	55	correct	correct	JJ
18637	10911	56	decision	decision	NN
18637	10911	57	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	10911	58	upon	upon	IN
18637	10911	59	the	the	DT
18637	10911	60	construction	construction	NN
18637	10911	61	of	of	IN
18637	10911	62	either	either	DT
18637	10911	63	.	.	.
18637	10912	1	"	"	``
18637	10912	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10912	3	256	256	CD
18637	10912	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10912	5	Passing	pass	VBG
18637	10912	6	then	then	RB
18637	10912	7	to	to	IN
18637	10912	8	broader	broad	JJR
18637	10912	9	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	10912	10	,	,	,
18637	10912	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10912	12	continued	continue	VBD
18637	10912	13	:	:	:
18637	10912	14	"	"	``
18637	10912	15	Let	let	VB
18637	10912	16	the	the	DT
18637	10912	17	nature	nature	NN
18637	10912	18	and	and	CC
18637	10912	19	objects	object	NNS
18637	10912	20	of	of	IN
18637	10912	21	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10912	22	Union	Union	NNP
18637	10912	23	be	be	VB
18637	10912	24	considered	consider	VBN
18637	10912	25	;	;	:
18637	10912	26	let	let	VB
18637	10912	27	the	the	DT
18637	10912	28	great	great	JJ
18637	10912	29	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	10912	30	principles	principle	NNS
18637	10912	31	,	,	,
18637	10912	32	on	on	IN
18637	10912	33	which	which	WDT
18637	10912	34	the	the	DT
18637	10912	35	fabric	fabric	NN
18637	10912	36	stands	stand	VBZ
18637	10912	37	,	,	,
18637	10912	38	be	be	VB
18637	10912	39	examined	examine	VBN
18637	10912	40	;	;	:
18637	10912	41	and	and	CC
18637	10912	42	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10912	43	think	think	VBP
18637	10912	44	,	,	,
18637	10912	45	the	the	DT
18637	10912	46	result	result	NN
18637	10912	47	must	must	MD
18637	10912	48	be	be	VB
18637	10912	49	,	,	,
18637	10912	50	that	that	IN
18637	10912	51	there	there	EX
18637	10912	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	10912	53	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	10912	54	so	so	RB
18637	10912	55	extravagantly	extravagantly	RB
18637	10912	56	absurd	absurd	JJ
18637	10912	57	,	,	,
18637	10912	58	in	in	IN
18637	10912	59	giving	give	VBG
18637	10912	60	to	to	IN
18637	10912	61	the	the	DT
18637	10912	62	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10912	63	of	of	IN
18637	10912	64	the	the	DT
18637	10912	65	nation	nation	NN
18637	10912	66	the	the	DT
18637	10912	67	power	power	NN
18637	10912	68	of	of	IN
18637	10912	69	revising	revise	VBG
18637	10912	70	the	the	DT
18637	10912	71	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	10912	72	of	of	IN
18637	10912	73	local	local	JJ
18637	10912	74	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	10912	75	,	,	,
18637	10912	76	on	on	IN
18637	10912	77	questions	question	NNS
18637	10912	78	which	which	WDT
18637	10912	79	affect	affect	VBP
18637	10912	80	the	the	DT
18637	10912	81	nation	nation	NN
18637	10912	82	,	,	,
18637	10912	83	as	as	IN
18637	10912	84	to	to	TO
18637	10912	85	require	require	VB
18637	10912	86	that	that	IN
18637	10912	87	words	word	NNS
18637	10912	88	which	which	WDT
18637	10912	89	import	import	VBP
18637	10912	90	this	this	DT
18637	10912	91	power	power	NN
18637	10912	92	should	should	MD
18637	10912	93	be	be	VB
18637	10912	94	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	10912	95	by	by	IN
18637	10912	96	a	a	DT
18637	10912	97	forced	force	VBN
18637	10912	98	construction	construction	NN
18637	10912	99	.	.	.
18637	10913	1	"	"	``
18637	10913	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10913	3	257	257	CD
18637	10913	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10913	5	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	10913	6	REVIEW	REVIEW	NNP
18637	10913	7	OF	of	IN
18637	10913	8	ACTS	ACTS	NNP
18637	10913	9	OF	of	IN
18637	10913	10	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	10913	11	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	10913	12	review	review	NN
18637	10913	13	of	of	IN
18637	10913	14	acts	act	NNS
18637	10913	15	of	of	IN
18637	10913	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10913	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	10913	18	not	not	RB
18637	10913	19	provided	provide	VBN
18637	10913	20	for	for	IN
18637	10913	21	in	in	IN
18637	10913	22	the	the	DT
18637	10913	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10913	24	in	in	IN
18637	10913	25	such	such	JJ
18637	10913	26	explicit	explicit	JJ
18637	10913	27	terms	term	NNS
18637	10913	28	as	as	IN
18637	10913	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	10913	30	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10913	31	review	review	NN
18637	10913	32	of	of	IN
18637	10913	33	State	State	NNP
18637	10913	34	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10913	35	,	,	,
18637	10913	36	but	but	CC
18637	10913	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10913	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	10913	39	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	10913	40	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	10913	41	evident	evident	JJ
18637	10913	42	that	that	IN
18637	10913	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10913	44	existence	existence	NN
18637	10913	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	10913	46	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	10913	47	.	.	.
18637	10914	1	In	in	IN
18637	10914	2	the	the	DT
18637	10914	3	first	first	JJ
18637	10914	4	place	place	NN
18637	10914	5	,	,	,
18637	10914	6	the	the	DT
18637	10914	7	term	term	NN
18637	10914	8	"	"	``
18637	10914	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	10914	10	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10914	11	under	under	IN
18637	10914	12	the	the	DT
18637	10914	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10914	14	"	"	''
18637	10914	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	10914	16	just	just	RB
18637	10914	17	as	as	RB
18637	10914	18	valid	valid	JJ
18637	10914	19	a	a	DT
18637	10914	20	textual	textual	JJ
18637	10914	21	basis	basis	NN
18637	10914	22	for	for	IN
18637	10914	23	the	the	DT
18637	10914	24	one	one	CD
18637	10914	25	type	type	NN
18637	10914	26	of	of	IN
18637	10914	27	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10914	28	case	case	NN
18637	10914	29	as	as	IN
18637	10914	30	for	for	IN
18637	10914	31	the	the	DT
18637	10914	32	other	other	JJ
18637	10914	33	;	;	:
18637	10914	34	and	and	CC
18637	10914	35	,	,	,
18637	10914	36	in	in	IN
18637	10914	37	the	the	DT
18637	10914	38	second	second	JJ
18637	10914	39	place	place	NN
18637	10914	40	,	,	,
18637	10914	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10914	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	10914	43	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	10914	44	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	10914	45	that	that	IN
18637	10914	46	acts	act	NNS
18637	10914	47	of	of	IN
18637	10914	48	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10914	49	are	be	VBP
18637	10914	50	not	not	RB
18637	10914	51	"	"	``
18637	10914	52	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	10914	53	law	law	NN
18637	10914	54	of	of	IN
18637	10914	55	the	the	DT
18637	10914	56	land	land	NN
18637	10914	57	"	"	''
18637	10914	58	unless	unless	IN
18637	10914	59	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10914	60	are	be	VBP
18637	10914	61	"	"	``
18637	10914	62	in	in	IN
18637	10914	63	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	10914	64	of	of	IN
18637	10914	65	the	the	DT
18637	10914	66	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10914	67	,	,	,
18637	10914	68	"	"	''
18637	10914	69	thus	thus	RB
18637	10914	70	evoking	evoke	VBG
18637	10914	71	a	a	DT
18637	10914	72	question	question	NN
18637	10914	73	which	which	WDT
18637	10914	74	must	must	MD
18637	10914	75	be	be	VB
18637	10914	76	resolved	resolve	VBN
18637	10914	77	in	in	IN
18637	10914	78	the	the	DT
18637	10914	79	first	first	JJ
18637	10914	80	instance	instance	NN
18637	10914	81	by	by	IN
18637	10914	82	State	State	NNP
18637	10914	83	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10914	84	,	,	,
18637	10914	85	when	when	WRB
18637	10914	86	State	state	NN
18637	10914	87	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10914	88	coming	come	VBG
18637	10914	89	before	before	IN
18637	10914	90	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10914	91	for	for	IN
18637	10914	92	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10914	93	is	be	VBZ
18637	10914	94	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	10914	95	in	in	IN
18637	10914	96	relation	relation	NN
18637	10914	97	to	to	IN
18637	10914	98	"	"	``
18637	10914	99	the	the	DT
18637	10914	100	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	10914	101	law	law	NNP
18637	10914	102	of	of	IN
18637	10914	103	the	the	DT
18637	10914	104	land	land	NN
18637	10914	105	.	.	.
18637	10914	106	"	"	''
18637	10915	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	10915	2	,	,	,
18637	10915	3	most	most	JJS
18637	10915	4	of	of	IN
18637	10915	5	the	the	DT
18637	10915	6	leading	lead	VBG
18637	10915	7	members	member	NNS
18637	10915	8	of	of	IN
18637	10915	9	the	the	DT
18637	10915	10	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	10915	11	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	10915	12	are	be	VBP
18637	10915	13	on	on	IN
18637	10915	14	record	record	NN
18637	10915	15	contemporaneously	contemporaneously	RB
18637	10915	16	,	,	,
18637	10915	17	though	though	IN
18637	10915	18	not	not	RB
18637	10915	19	always	always	RB
18637	10915	20	in	in	IN
18637	10915	21	the	the	DT
18637	10915	22	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	10915	23	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10915	24	,	,	,
18637	10915	25	as	as	IN
18637	10915	26	accepting	accept	VBG
18637	10915	27	the	the	DT
18637	10915	28	idea	idea	NN
18637	10915	29	.	.	.
18637	10916	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10916	2	258	258	CD
18637	10916	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10916	4	HAMILTON	HAMILTON	NNP
18637	10916	5	'S	'S	NNP
18637	10916	6	ARGUMENT	ARGUMENT	NNP
18637	10916	7	The	the	DT
18637	10916	8	argument	argument	NN
18637	10916	9	for	for	IN
18637	10916	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10916	11	review	review	NN
18637	10916	12	of	of	IN
18637	10916	13	acts	act	NNS
18637	10916	14	of	of	IN
18637	10916	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10916	16	was	be	VBD
18637	10916	17	first	first	RB
18637	10916	18	elaborated	elaborate	VBN
18637	10916	19	in	in	IN
18637	10916	20	full	full	JJ
18637	10916	21	by	by	IN
18637	10916	22	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	10916	23	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	10916	24	in	in	IN
18637	10916	25	the	the	DT
18637	10916	26	Seventy	seventy	CD
18637	10916	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	10916	28	eighth	eighth	JJ
18637	10916	29	Number	Number	NNP
18637	10916	30	of	of	IN
18637	10916	31	_	_	NNP
18637	10916	32	The	the	DT
18637	10916	33	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	10916	34	_	_	NNP
18637	10916	35	while	while	IN
18637	10916	36	the	the	DT
18637	10916	37	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	10916	38	of	of	IN
18637	10916	39	the	the	DT
18637	10916	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10916	41	was	be	VBD
18637	10916	42	pending	pende	VBG
18637	10916	43	.	.	.
18637	10917	1	Said	Said	NNP
18637	10917	2	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	10917	3	:	:	:
18637	10917	4	"	"	``
18637	10917	5	The	the	DT
18637	10917	6	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	10917	7	of	of	IN
18637	10917	8	the	the	DT
18637	10917	9	laws	law	NNS
18637	10917	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	10917	11	the	the	DT
18637	10917	12	proper	proper	JJ
18637	10917	13	and	and	CC
18637	10917	14	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	10917	15	province	province	NN
18637	10917	16	of	of	IN
18637	10917	17	the	the	DT
18637	10917	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	10917	19	.	.	.
18637	10918	1	A	a	DT
18637	10918	2	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	10918	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	10918	4	,	,	,
18637	10918	5	in	in	IN
18637	10918	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	10918	7	,	,	,
18637	10918	8	and	and	CC
18637	10918	9	must	must	MD
18637	10918	10	be	be	VB
18637	10918	11	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	10918	12	by	by	IN
18637	10918	13	the	the	DT
18637	10918	14	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10918	15	as	as	IN
18637	10918	16	a	a	DT
18637	10918	17	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	10918	18	law	law	NN
18637	10918	19	.	.	.
18637	10919	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10919	2	must	must	MD
18637	10919	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	10919	4	belong	belong	VB
18637	10919	5	to	to	IN
18637	10919	6	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10919	7	to	to	TO
18637	10919	8	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	10919	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10919	10	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	10919	11	,	,	,
18637	10919	12	as	as	RB
18637	10919	13	well	well	RB
18637	10919	14	as	as	IN
18637	10919	15	the	the	DT
18637	10919	16	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	10919	17	of	of	IN
18637	10919	18	any	any	DT
18637	10919	19	particular	particular	JJ
18637	10919	20	act	act	NN
18637	10919	21	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	10919	22	from	from	IN
18637	10919	23	the	the	DT
18637	10919	24	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10919	25	body	body	NN
18637	10919	26	.	.	.
18637	10920	1	If	if	IN
18637	10920	2	there	there	EX
18637	10920	3	should	should	MD
18637	10920	4	happen	happen	VB
18637	10920	5	to	to	TO
18637	10920	6	be	be	VB
18637	10920	7	an	an	DT
18637	10920	8	irreconcilable	irreconcilable	JJ
18637	10920	9	variance	variance	NN
18637	10920	10	between	between	IN
18637	10920	11	the	the	DT
18637	10920	12	two	two	CD
18637	10920	13	,	,	,
18637	10920	14	that	that	WDT
18637	10920	15	which	which	WDT
18637	10920	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	10920	17	the	the	DT
18637	10920	18	superior	superior	JJ
18637	10920	19	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	10920	20	and	and	CC
18637	10920	21	validity	validity	NN
18637	10920	22	ought	ought	MD
18637	10920	23	,	,	,
18637	10920	24	of	of	IN
18637	10920	25	course	course	NN
18637	10920	26	,	,	,
18637	10920	27	to	to	TO
18637	10920	28	be	be	VB
18637	10920	29	preferred	prefer	VBN
18637	10920	30	;	;	:
18637	10920	31	or	or	CC
18637	10920	32	in	in	IN
18637	10920	33	other	other	JJ
18637	10920	34	words	word	NNS
18637	10920	35	,	,	,
18637	10920	36	the	the	DT
18637	10920	37	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10920	38	ought	ought	MD
18637	10920	39	to	to	TO
18637	10920	40	be	be	VB
18637	10920	41	preferred	prefer	VBN
18637	10920	42	to	to	IN
18637	10920	43	the	the	DT
18637	10920	44	statute	statute	NN
18637	10920	45	,	,	,
18637	10920	46	the	the	DT
18637	10920	47	intention	intention	NN
18637	10920	48	of	of	IN
18637	10920	49	the	the	DT
18637	10920	50	people	people	NNS
18637	10920	51	to	to	IN
18637	10920	52	the	the	DT
18637	10920	53	intention	intention	NN
18637	10920	54	of	of	IN
18637	10920	55	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10920	56	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10920	57	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10920	58	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10920	59	agents	agent	NNS
18637	10920	60	.	.	.
18637	10921	1	"	"	``
18637	10921	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10921	3	259	259	CD
18637	10921	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10921	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10921	6	was	be	VBD
18637	10921	7	also	also	RB
18637	10921	8	set	set	VBN
18637	10921	9	forth	forth	RP
18637	10921	10	as	as	IN
18637	10921	11	something	something	NN
18637	10921	12	commonly	commonly	RB
18637	10921	13	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	10921	14	by	by	IN
18637	10921	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10921	16	Iredell	Iredell	NNP
18637	10921	17	in	in	IN
18637	10921	18	1798	1798	CD
18637	10921	19	in	in	IN
18637	10921	20	Calder	Calder	NNP
18637	10921	21	_	_	NNP
18637	10921	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	10921	23	_	_	NNP
18637	10921	24	Bull[260	Bull[260	NNP
18637	10921	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10921	26	in	in	IN
18637	10921	27	the	the	DT
18637	10921	28	following	follow	VBG
18637	10921	29	words	word	NNS
18637	10921	30	:	:	:
18637	10921	31	"	"	``
18637	10921	32	If	if	IN
18637	10921	33	any	any	DT
18637	10921	34	act	act	NN
18637	10921	35	of	of	IN
18637	10921	36	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10921	37	,	,	,
18637	10921	38	or	or	CC
18637	10921	39	of	of	IN
18637	10921	40	the	the	DT
18637	10921	41	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	10921	42	of	of	IN
18637	10921	43	a	a	DT
18637	10921	44	state	state	NN
18637	10921	45	,	,	,
18637	10921	46	violates	violate	VBZ
18637	10921	47	those	those	DT
18637	10921	48	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10921	49	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	10921	50	,	,	,
18637	10921	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10921	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	10921	53	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
18637	10921	54	void	void	JJ
18637	10921	55	;	;	,
18637	10921	56	though	though	RB
18637	10921	57	,	,	,
18637	10921	58	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10921	59	admit	admit	VBP
18637	10921	60	,	,	,
18637	10921	61	that	that	IN
18637	10921	62	as	as	IN
18637	10921	63	the	the	DT
18637	10921	64	authority	authority	NN
18637	10921	65	to	to	TO
18637	10921	66	declare	declare	VB
18637	10921	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10921	68	void	void	RB
18637	10921	69	is	be	VBZ
18637	10921	70	of	of	IN
18637	10921	71	a	a	DT
18637	10921	72	delicate	delicate	JJ
18637	10921	73	and	and	CC
18637	10921	74	awful	awful	JJ
18637	10921	75	nature	nature	NN
18637	10921	76	,	,	,
18637	10921	77	the	the	DT
18637	10921	78	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10921	79	will	will	MD
18637	10921	80	never	never	RB
18637	10921	81	resort	resort	VB
18637	10921	82	to	to	IN
18637	10921	83	that	that	DT
18637	10921	84	authority	authority	NN
18637	10921	85	,	,	,
18637	10921	86	but	but	CC
18637	10921	87	in	in	IN
18637	10921	88	a	a	DT
18637	10921	89	clear	clear	JJ
18637	10921	90	and	and	CC
18637	10921	91	urgent	urgent	JJ
18637	10921	92	case	case	NN
18637	10921	93	.	.	.
18637	10921	94	"	"	''
18637	10922	1	And	and	CC
18637	10922	2	between	between	IN
18637	10922	3	these	these	DT
18637	10922	4	two	two	CD
18637	10922	5	formulations	formulation	NNS
18637	10922	6	of	of	IN
18637	10922	7	the	the	DT
18637	10922	8	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	10922	9	,	,	,
18637	10922	10	the	the	DT
18637	10922	11	membership	membership	NN
18637	10922	12	of	of	IN
18637	10922	13	the	the	DT
18637	10922	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10922	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10922	16	had	have	VBD
18637	10922	17	given	give	VBN
18637	10922	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10922	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10922	20	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	10922	21	first	first	RB
18637	10922	22	individually	individually	RB
18637	10922	23	,	,	,
18637	10922	24	then	then	RB
18637	10922	25	as	as	IN
18637	10922	26	a	a	DT
18637	10922	27	body	body	NN
18637	10922	28	.	.	.
18637	10923	1	In	in	IN
18637	10923	2	Hayburn	Hayburn	NNP
18637	10923	3	's	's	POS
18637	10923	4	Case,[261	Case,[261	NNS
18637	10923	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10923	6	the	the	DT
18637	10923	7	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	10923	8	while	while	IN
18637	10923	9	on	on	IN
18637	10923	10	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	10923	11	court	court	NN
18637	10923	12	duty	duty	NN
18637	10923	13	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	10923	14	to	to	TO
18637	10923	15	administer	administer	VB
18637	10923	16	the	the	DT
18637	10923	17	Invalid	Invalid	NNP
18637	10923	18	Pensions	Pensions	NNPS
18637	10923	19	Act,[262	Act,[262	NNP
18637	10923	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10923	21	which	which	WDT
18637	10923	22	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	10923	23	the	the	DT
18637	10923	24	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	10923	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	10923	26	to	to	TO
18637	10923	27	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	10923	28	of	of	IN
18637	10923	29	pension	pension	NN
18637	10923	30	applications	application	NNS
18637	10923	31	subject	subject	JJ
18637	10923	32	to	to	IN
18637	10923	33	review	review	NN
18637	10923	34	by	by	IN
18637	10923	35	the	the	DT
18637	10923	36	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10923	37	of	of	IN
18637	10923	38	War	War	NNP
18637	10923	39	and	and	CC
18637	10923	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10923	41	on	on	IN
18637	10923	42	the	the	DT
18637	10923	43	ground	ground	NN
18637	10923	44	that	that	IN
18637	10923	45	the	the	DT
18637	10923	46	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10923	47	courts	court	NNS
18637	10923	48	could	could	MD
18637	10923	49	be	be	VB
18637	10923	50	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	10923	51	only	only	RB
18637	10923	52	those	those	DT
18637	10923	53	functions	function	NNS
18637	10923	54	such	such	JJ
18637	10923	55	as	as	IN
18637	10923	56	are	be	VBP
18637	10923	57	properly	properly	RB
18637	10923	58	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10923	59	and	and	CC
18637	10923	60	to	to	TO
18637	10923	61	be	be	VB
18637	10923	62	performed	perform	VBN
18637	10923	63	in	in	IN
18637	10923	64	a	a	DT
18637	10923	65	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10923	66	manner	manner	NN
18637	10923	67	.	.	.
18637	10924	1	In	in	IN
18637	10924	2	Hylton	Hylton	NNP
18637	10924	3	_	_	NNP
18637	10924	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	10924	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10924	6	United	United	NNP
18637	10924	7	States,[263	States,[263	NNP
18637	10924	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10924	9	a	a	DT
18637	10924	10	made	make	VBN
18637	10924	11	case	case	NN
18637	10924	12	in	in	IN
18637	10924	13	which	which	WDT
18637	10924	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10924	15	appropriated	appropriate	VBD
18637	10924	16	money	money	NN
18637	10924	17	to	to	TO
18637	10924	18	pay	pay	VB
18637	10924	19	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	10924	20	on	on	IN
18637	10924	21	both	both	DT
18637	10924	22	sides	side	NNS
18637	10924	23	of	of	IN
18637	10924	24	the	the	DT
18637	10924	25	argument	argument	NN
18637	10924	26	,	,	,
18637	10924	27	the	the	DT
18637	10924	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10924	29	passed	pass	VBD
18637	10924	30	on	on	IN
18637	10924	31	the	the	DT
18637	10924	32	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	10924	33	of	of	IN
18637	10924	34	the	the	DT
18637	10924	35	carriage	carriage	NN
18637	10924	36	tax	tax	NN
18637	10924	37	and	and	CC
18637	10924	38	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	10924	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10924	40	as	as	RB
18637	10924	41	valid	valid	JJ
18637	10924	42	,	,	,
18637	10924	43	and	and	CC
18637	10924	44	in	in	IN
18637	10924	45	so	so	RB
18637	10924	46	doing	do	VBG
18637	10924	47	tacitly	tacitly	RB
18637	10924	48	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	10924	49	that	that	IN
18637	10924	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10924	51	had	have	VBD
18637	10924	52	the	the	DT
18637	10924	53	power	power	NN
18637	10924	54	to	to	TO
18637	10924	55	review	review	VB
18637	10924	56	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	10924	57	acts	act	NNS
18637	10924	58	.	.	.
18637	10925	1	MARBURY	MARBURY	NNP
18637	10925	2	_	_	NNP
18637	10925	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	10925	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10925	5	MADISON	MADISON	NNPS
18637	10925	6	All	all	PDT
18637	10925	7	the	the	DT
18637	10925	8	above	above	JJ
18637	10925	9	developments	development	NNS
18637	10925	10	were	be	VBD
18637	10925	11	,	,	,
18637	10925	12	however	however	RB
18637	10925	13	,	,	,
18637	10925	14	only	only	RB
18637	10925	15	preparatory	preparatory	JJ
18637	10925	16	.	.	.
18637	10926	1	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10926	2	review	review	NN
18637	10926	3	of	of	IN
18637	10926	4	acts	act	NNS
18637	10926	5	of	of	IN
18637	10926	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10926	7	was	be	VBD
18637	10926	8	made	make	VBN
18637	10926	9	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	10926	10	Law	Law	NNP
18637	10926	11	,	,	,
18637	10926	12	and	and	CC
18637	10926	13	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	10926	14	the	the	DT
18637	10926	15	cornerstone	cornerstone	NN
18637	10926	16	of	of	IN
18637	10926	17	American	american	JJ
18637	10926	18	constitutionalism	constitutionalism	NN
18637	10926	19	,	,	,
18637	10926	20	by	by	IN
18637	10926	21	the	the	DT
18637	10926	22	decision	decision	NN
18637	10926	23	of	of	IN
18637	10926	24	the	the	DT
18637	10926	25	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10926	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10926	27	,	,	,
18637	10926	28	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	10926	29	through	through	IN
18637	10926	30	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10926	31	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10926	32	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	10926	33	in	in	IN
18637	10926	34	the	the	DT
18637	10926	35	famous	famous	JJ
18637	10926	36	case	case	NN
18637	10926	37	of	of	IN
18637	10926	38	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	10926	39	_	_	NNP
18637	10926	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	10926	41	_	_	NNP
18637	10926	42	Madison[264	Madison[264	NNP
18637	10926	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10926	44	decided	decide	VBD
18637	10926	45	in	in	IN
18637	10926	46	February	February	NNP
18637	10926	47	,	,	,
18637	10926	48	1803	1803	CD
18637	10926	49	.	.	.
18637	10927	1	The	the	DT
18637	10927	2	facts	fact	NNS
18637	10927	3	of	of	IN
18637	10927	4	the	the	DT
18637	10927	5	case	case	NN
18637	10927	6	briefly	briefly	RB
18637	10927	7	stated	state	VBD
18637	10927	8	are	be	VBP
18637	10927	9	that	that	IN
18637	10927	10	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	10927	11	had	have	VBD
18637	10927	12	been	be	VBN
18637	10927	13	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	10927	14	a	a	DT
18637	10927	15	justice	justice	NN
18637	10927	16	of	of	IN
18637	10927	17	the	the	DT
18637	10927	18	peace	peace	NN
18637	10927	19	in	in	IN
18637	10927	20	the	the	DT
18637	10927	21	District	District	NNP
18637	10927	22	of	of	IN
18637	10927	23	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	10927	24	by	by	IN
18637	10927	25	John	John	NNP
18637	10927	26	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	10927	27	almost	almost	RB
18637	10927	28	at	at	IN
18637	10927	29	the	the	DT
18637	10927	30	close	close	NN
18637	10927	31	of	of	IN
18637	10927	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10927	33	administration	administration	NN
18637	10927	34	,	,	,
18637	10927	35	and	and	CC
18637	10927	36	John	John	NNP
18637	10927	37	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	10927	38	who	who	WP
18637	10927	39	was	be	VBD
18637	10927	40	serving	serve	VBG
18637	10927	41	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
18637	10927	42	as	as	IN
18637	10927	43	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10927	44	of	of	IN
18637	10927	45	State	State	NNP
18637	10927	46	failed	fail	VBD
18637	10927	47	to	to	TO
18637	10927	48	deliver	deliver	VB
18637	10927	49	to	to	IN
18637	10927	50	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	10927	51	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10927	52	commission	commission	NN
18637	10927	53	which	which	WDT
18637	10927	54	had	have	VBD
18637	10927	55	been	be	VBN
18637	10927	56	signed	sign	VBN
18637	10927	57	before	before	IN
18637	10927	58	the	the	DT
18637	10927	59	new	new	JJ
18637	10927	60	administration	administration	NN
18637	10927	61	had	have	VBD
18637	10927	62	begun	begin	VBN
18637	10927	63	.	.	.
18637	10928	1	One	one	CD
18637	10928	2	of	of	IN
18637	10928	3	the	the	DT
18637	10928	4	first	first	JJ
18637	10928	5	acts	act	NNS
18637	10928	6	of	of	IN
18637	10928	7	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	10928	8	was	be	VBD
18637	10928	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10928	10	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	10928	11	to	to	IN
18637	10928	12	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	10928	13	of	of	IN
18637	10928	14	State	State	NNP
18637	10928	15	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	10928	16	to	to	TO
18637	10928	17	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	10928	18	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	10928	19	to	to	IN
18637	10928	20	office	office	NN
18637	10928	21	which	which	WDT
18637	10928	22	remained	remain	VBD
18637	10928	23	undelivered	undelivered	JJ
18637	10928	24	.	.	.
18637	10929	1	Thereupon	thereupon	JJ
18637	10929	2	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	10929	3	sought	seek	VBD
18637	10929	4	to	to	TO
18637	10929	5	compel	compel	VB
18637	10929	6	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	10929	7	to	to	TO
18637	10929	8	deliver	deliver	VB
18637	10929	9	the	the	DT
18637	10929	10	commission	commission	NN
18637	10929	11	by	by	IN
18637	10929	12	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	10929	13	a	a	DT
18637	10929	14	writ	writ	NN
18637	10929	15	of	of	IN
18637	10929	16	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	10929	17	in	in	IN
18637	10929	18	the	the	DT
18637	10929	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10929	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10929	21	in	in	IN
18637	10929	22	the	the	DT
18637	10929	23	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10929	24	of	of	IN
18637	10929	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10929	26	original	original	JJ
18637	10929	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10929	28	and	and	CC
18637	10929	29	in	in	IN
18637	10929	30	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	10929	31	of	of	IN
18637	10929	32	section	section	NN
18637	10929	33	13	13	CD
18637	10929	34	of	of	IN
18637	10929	35	the	the	DT
18637	10929	36	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	10929	37	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10929	38	of	of	IN
18637	10929	39	1789[265	1789[265	CD
18637	10929	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10929	41	which	which	WDT
18637	10929	42	prescribed	prescribe	VBD
18637	10929	43	the	the	DT
18637	10929	44	original	original	JJ
18637	10929	45	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10929	46	of	of	IN
18637	10929	47	the	the	DT
18637	10929	48	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10929	49	and	and	CC
18637	10929	50	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	10929	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10929	52	to	to	TO
18637	10929	53	issue	issue	VB
18637	10929	54	writs	writ	NNS
18637	10929	55	of	of	IN
18637	10929	56	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	10929	57	"	"	''
18637	10929	58	in	in	IN
18637	10929	59	cases	case	NNS
18637	10929	60	warranted	warrant	VBN
18637	10929	61	by	by	IN
18637	10929	62	the	the	DT
18637	10929	63	principles	principle	NNS
18637	10929	64	and	and	CC
18637	10929	65	usages	usage	NNS
18637	10929	66	of	of	IN
18637	10929	67	law	law	NN
18637	10929	68	,	,	,
18637	10929	69	to	to	IN
18637	10929	70	any	any	DT
18637	10929	71	courts	court	NNS
18637	10929	72	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	10929	73	,	,	,
18637	10929	74	or	or	CC
18637	10929	75	persons	person	NNS
18637	10929	76	holding	hold	VBG
18637	10929	77	office	office	NN
18637	10929	78	,	,	,
18637	10929	79	under	under	IN
18637	10929	80	the	the	DT
18637	10929	81	authority	authority	NN
18637	10929	82	of	of	IN
18637	10929	83	the	the	DT
18637	10929	84	United	United	NNP
18637	10929	85	States	States	NNP
18637	10929	86	.	.	.
18637	10929	87	"	"	''
18637	10930	1	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	10930	2	's	's	POS
18637	10930	3	Argument	argument	NN
18637	10930	4	In	in	IN
18637	10930	5	the	the	DT
18637	10930	6	portion	portion	NN
18637	10930	7	of	of	IN
18637	10930	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10930	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10930	10	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	10930	11	with	with	IN
18637	10930	12	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10930	13	review	review	NN
18637	10930	14	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	10930	15	began	begin	VBD
18637	10930	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10930	17	argument	argument	NN
18637	10930	18	with	with	IN
18637	10930	19	the	the	DT
18637	10930	20	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	10930	21	that	that	IN
18637	10930	22	"	"	``
18637	10930	23	the	the	DT
18637	10930	24	people	people	NNS
18637	10930	25	have	have	VBP
18637	10930	26	an	an	DT
18637	10930	27	original	original	JJ
18637	10930	28	right	right	NN
18637	10930	29	to	to	TO
18637	10930	30	establish	establish	VB
18637	10930	31	,	,	,
18637	10930	32	for	for	IN
18637	10930	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10930	34	future	future	JJ
18637	10930	35	government	government	NN
18637	10930	36	,	,	,
18637	10930	37	such	such	JJ
18637	10930	38	principles	principle	NNS
18637	10930	39	as	as	IN
18637	10930	40	,	,	,
18637	10930	41	in	in	IN
18637	10930	42	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10930	43	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10930	44	,	,	,
18637	10930	45	shall	shall	MD
18637	10930	46	most	most	RBS
18637	10930	47	conduce	conduce	VB
18637	10930	48	to	to	IN
18637	10930	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10930	50	own	own	JJ
18637	10930	51	happiness	happiness	NN
18637	10930	52	*	*	NFP
18637	10930	53	*	*	NFP
18637	10930	54	*	*	NFP
18637	10930	55	"	"	''
18637	10930	56	and	and	CC
18637	10930	57	,	,	,
18637	10930	58	once	once	RB
18637	10930	59	established	establish	VBN
18637	10930	60	,	,	,
18637	10930	61	these	these	DT
18637	10930	62	principles	principle	NNS
18637	10930	63	are	be	VBP
18637	10930	64	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	10930	65	.	.	.
18637	10931	1	Second	second	JJ
18637	10931	2	,	,	,
18637	10931	3	the	the	DT
18637	10931	4	Government	Government	NNP
18637	10931	5	of	of	IN
18637	10931	6	the	the	DT
18637	10931	7	United	United	NNP
18637	10931	8	States	States	NNP
18637	10931	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	10931	10	limited	limit	VBN
18637	10931	11	in	in	IN
18637	10931	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10931	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	10931	14	by	by	IN
18637	10931	15	a	a	DT
18637	10931	16	written	write	VBN
18637	10931	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10931	18	.	.	.
18637	10932	1	The	the	DT
18637	10932	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10932	3	either	either	CC
18637	10932	4	"	"	``
18637	10932	5	controls	control	VBZ
18637	10932	6	any	any	DT
18637	10932	7	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10932	8	act	act	NN
18637	10932	9	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	10932	10	to	to	IN
18637	10932	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10932	12	;	;	:
18637	10932	13	or	or	CC
18637	10932	14	,	,	,
18637	10932	15	*	*	NFP
18637	10932	16	*	*	NFP
18637	10932	17	*	*	NFP
18637	10932	18	the	the	DT
18637	10932	19	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	10932	20	may	may	MD
18637	10932	21	alter	alter	VB
18637	10932	22	the	the	DT
18637	10932	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10932	24	by	by	IN
18637	10932	25	an	an	DT
18637	10932	26	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	10932	27	act	act	NN
18637	10932	28	.	.	.
18637	10932	29	"	"	''
18637	10933	1	But	but	CC
18637	10933	2	the	the	DT
18637	10933	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10933	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	10933	5	paramount	paramount	JJ
18637	10933	6	law	law	NN
18637	10933	7	and	and	CC
18637	10933	8	written	write	VBN
18637	10933	9	as	as	IN
18637	10933	10	such	such	JJ
18637	10933	11	.	.	.
18637	10934	1	"	"	``
18637	10934	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10934	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	10934	4	emphatically	emphatically	RB
18637	10934	5	the	the	DT
18637	10934	6	province	province	NN
18637	10934	7	and	and	CC
18637	10934	8	duty	duty	NN
18637	10934	9	of	of	IN
18637	10934	10	the	the	DT
18637	10934	11	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10934	12	department	department	NN
18637	10934	13	to	to	TO
18637	10934	14	say	say	VB
18637	10934	15	what	what	WP
18637	10934	16	the	the	DT
18637	10934	17	law	law	NN
18637	10934	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	10934	19	.	.	.
18637	10935	1	*	*	NFP
18637	10935	2	*	*	NFP
18637	10935	3	*	*	NFP
18637	10935	4	If	if	IN
18637	10935	5	two	two	CD
18637	10935	6	laws	law	NNS
18637	10935	7	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	10935	8	with	with	IN
18637	10935	9	each	each	DT
18637	10935	10	other	other	JJ
18637	10935	11	,	,	,
18637	10935	12	the	the	DT
18637	10935	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	10935	14	must	must	MD
18637	10935	15	decide	decide	VB
18637	10935	16	on	on	IN
18637	10935	17	the	the	DT
18637	10935	18	operation	operation	NN
18637	10935	19	of	of	IN
18637	10935	20	each	each	DT
18637	10935	21	.	.	.
18637	10936	1	*	*	NFP
18637	10936	2	*	*	NFP
18637	10936	3	*	*	NFP
18637	10936	4	If	if	IN
18637	10936	5	,	,	,
18637	10936	6	then	then	RB
18637	10936	7	,	,	,
18637	10936	8	the	the	DT
18637	10936	9	courts	court	NNS
18637	10936	10	are	be	VBP
18637	10936	11	to	to	TO
18637	10936	12	regard	regard	VB
18637	10936	13	the	the	DT
18637	10936	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10936	15	,	,	,
18637	10936	16	and	and	CC
18637	10936	17	the	the	DT
18637	10936	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10936	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	10936	20	superior	superior	JJ
18637	10936	21	to	to	IN
18637	10936	22	any	any	DT
18637	10936	23	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	10936	24	act	act	NN
18637	10936	25	of	of	IN
18637	10936	26	the	the	DT
18637	10936	27	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	10936	28	,	,	,
18637	10936	29	the	the	DT
18637	10936	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10936	31	,	,	,
18637	10936	32	and	and	CC
18637	10936	33	not	not	RB
18637	10936	34	such	such	JJ
18637	10936	35	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	10936	36	act	act	NN
18637	10936	37	,	,	,
18637	10936	38	must	must	MD
18637	10936	39	govern	govern	VB
18637	10936	40	the	the	DT
18637	10936	41	case	case	NN
18637	10936	42	to	to	IN
18637	10936	43	which	which	WDT
18637	10936	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10936	45	both	both	DT
18637	10936	46	apply	apply	VBP
18637	10936	47	.	.	.
18637	10936	48	"	"	''
18637	10937	1	To	to	TO
18637	10937	2	declare	declare	VB
18637	10937	3	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	10937	4	,	,	,
18637	10937	5	the	the	DT
18637	10937	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10937	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10937	8	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	10937	9	,	,	,
18637	10937	10	would	would	MD
18637	10937	11	be	be	VB
18637	10937	12	subversive	subversive	JJ
18637	10937	13	of	of	IN
18637	10937	14	the	the	DT
18637	10937	15	very	very	JJ
18637	10937	16	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	10937	17	of	of	IN
18637	10937	18	all	all	DT
18637	10937	19	written	write	VBN
18637	10937	20	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	10937	21	,	,	,
18637	10937	22	would	would	MD
18637	10937	23	force	force	VB
18637	10937	24	the	the	DT
18637	10937	25	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10937	26	to	to	TO
18637	10937	27	close	close	VB
18637	10937	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10937	29	eyes	eye	NNS
18637	10937	30	to	to	IN
18637	10937	31	the	the	DT
18637	10937	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10937	33	,	,	,
18637	10937	34	and	and	CC
18637	10937	35	would	would	MD
18637	10937	36	make	make	VB
18637	10937	37	the	the	DT
18637	10937	38	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10937	39	oath	oath	NN
18637	10937	40	"	"	``
18637	10937	41	a	a	DT
18637	10937	42	solemn	solemn	JJ
18637	10937	43	mockery	mockery	NN
18637	10937	44	.	.	.
18637	10938	1	"	"	``
18637	10938	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10938	3	266	266	CD
18637	10938	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10938	5	The	the	DT
18637	10938	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10938	7	must	must	MD
18637	10938	8	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	10938	9	look	look	VB
18637	10938	10	into	into	IN
18637	10938	11	some	some	DT
18637	10938	12	portions	portion	NNS
18637	10938	13	of	of	IN
18637	10938	14	the	the	DT
18637	10938	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10938	16	,	,	,
18637	10938	17	and	and	CC
18637	10938	18	if	if	IN
18637	10938	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10938	20	can	can	MD
18637	10938	21	open	open	VB
18637	10938	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10938	23	at	at	RB
18637	10938	24	all	all	RB
18637	10938	25	,	,	,
18637	10938	26	what	what	WDT
18637	10938	27	part	part	NN
18637	10938	28	of	of	IN
18637	10938	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10938	30	are	be	VBP
18637	10938	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10938	32	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	10938	33	to	to	TO
18637	10938	34	read	read	VB
18637	10938	35	or	or	CC
18637	10938	36	obey	obey	VB
18637	10938	37	?	?	.
18637	10939	1	In	in	IN
18637	10939	2	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	10939	3	the	the	DT
18637	10939	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	10939	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10939	6	declared	declare	VBD
18637	10939	7	that	that	IN
18637	10939	8	the	the	DT
18637	10939	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10939	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	10939	11	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	10939	12	first	first	RB
18637	10939	13	in	in	IN
18637	10939	14	the	the	DT
18637	10939	15	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	10939	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	10939	17	and	and	CC
18637	10939	18	that	that	IN
18637	10939	19	"	"	``
18637	10939	20	the	the	DT
18637	10939	21	particular	particular	JJ
18637	10939	22	phraseology	phraseology	NN
18637	10939	23	of	of	IN
18637	10939	24	the	the	DT
18637	10939	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10939	26	*	*	NFP
18637	10939	27	*	*	NFP
18637	10939	28	*	*	NFP
18637	10939	29	confirms	confirm	VBZ
18637	10939	30	and	and	CC
18637	10939	31	strengthens	strengthen	VBZ
18637	10939	32	the	the	DT
18637	10939	33	principle	principle	NN
18637	10939	34	,	,	,
18637	10939	35	supposed	suppose	VBN
18637	10939	36	to	to	TO
18637	10939	37	be	be	VB
18637	10939	38	essential	essential	JJ
18637	10939	39	to	to	IN
18637	10939	40	all	all	DT
18637	10939	41	written	write	VBN
18637	10939	42	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	10939	43	,	,	,
18637	10939	44	that	that	IN
18637	10939	45	a	a	DT
18637	10939	46	law	law	NN
18637	10939	47	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	10939	48	to	to	IN
18637	10939	49	the	the	DT
18637	10939	50	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10939	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	10939	52	void	void	JJ
18637	10939	53	;	;	:
18637	10939	54	and	and	CC
18637	10939	55	that	that	IN
18637	10939	56	courts	court	NNS
18637	10939	57	,	,	,
18637	10939	58	as	as	RB
18637	10939	59	well	well	RB
18637	10939	60	as	as	IN
18637	10939	61	other	other	JJ
18637	10939	62	departments	department	NNS
18637	10939	63	,	,	,
18637	10939	64	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10939	65	of	of	IN
18637	10939	66	government	government	NN
18637	10939	67	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10939	68	are	be	VBP
18637	10939	69	bound	bind	VBN
18637	10939	70	by	by	IN
18637	10939	71	that	that	DT
18637	10939	72	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	10939	73	.	.	.
18637	10940	1	"	"	``
18637	10940	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10940	3	267	267	CD
18637	10940	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10940	5	Importance	Importance	NNP
18637	10940	6	of	of	IN
18637	10940	7	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	10940	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10940	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	10940	10	_	_	NNP
18637	10940	11	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	10940	12	The	the	DT
18637	10940	13	decision	decision	NN
18637	10940	14	in	in	IN
18637	10940	15	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	10940	16	_	_	NNP
18637	10940	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	10940	18	_	_	NNP
18637	10940	19	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	10940	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	10940	21	never	never	RB
18637	10940	22	been	be	VBN
18637	10940	23	disturbed	disturb	VBN
18637	10940	24	,	,	,
18637	10940	25	although	although	IN
18637	10940	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10940	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	10940	28	often	often	RB
18637	10940	29	been	be	VBN
18637	10940	30	criticized	criticize	VBN
18637	10940	31	.	.	.
18637	10941	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	10941	2	was	be	VBD
18637	10941	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10941	4	contemporary	contemporary	JJ
18637	10941	5	effect	effect	NN
18637	10941	6	confined	confine	VBN
18637	10941	7	to	to	IN
18637	10941	8	the	the	DT
18637	10941	9	national	national	JJ
18637	10941	10	field	field	NN
18637	10941	11	.	.	.
18637	10942	1	From	from	IN
18637	10942	2	that	that	DT
18637	10942	3	time	time	NN
18637	10942	4	on	on	IN
18637	10942	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10942	6	review	review	NN
18637	10942	7	by	by	IN
18637	10942	8	State	State	NNP
18637	10942	9	courts	court	NNS
18637	10942	10	of	of	IN
18637	10942	11	local	local	JJ
18637	10942	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10942	13	in	in	IN
18637	10942	14	relation	relation	NN
18637	10942	15	to	to	IN
18637	10942	16	the	the	DT
18637	10942	17	local	local	JJ
18637	10942	18	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	10942	19	made	make	VBD
18637	10942	20	rapid	rapid	JJ
18637	10942	21	progress	progress	NN
18637	10942	22	and	and	CC
18637	10942	23	was	be	VBD
18637	10942	24	securely	securely	RB
18637	10942	25	established	establish	VBN
18637	10942	26	in	in	IN
18637	10942	27	all	all	DT
18637	10942	28	States	state	NNS
18637	10942	29	by	by	IN
18637	10942	30	1850	1850	CD
18637	10942	31	under	under	IN
18637	10942	32	the	the	DT
18637	10942	33	influence	influence	NN
18637	10942	34	not	not	RB
18637	10942	35	only	only	RB
18637	10942	36	of	of	IN
18637	10942	37	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	10942	38	_	_	NNP
18637	10942	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	10942	40	_	_	NNP
18637	10942	41	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	10942	42	,	,	,
18637	10942	43	but	but	CC
18637	10942	44	also	also	RB
18637	10942	45	of	of	IN
18637	10942	46	early	early	JJ
18637	10942	47	principles	principle	NNS
18637	10942	48	of	of	IN
18637	10942	49	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10942	50	review	review	NN
18637	10942	51	established	establish	VBN
18637	10942	52	in	in	IN
18637	10942	53	the	the	DT
18637	10942	54	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	10942	55	courts	court	NNS
18637	10942	56	of	of	IN
18637	10942	57	the	the	DT
18637	10942	58	United	United	NNP
18637	10942	59	States	States	NNP
18637	10942	60	.	.	.
18637	10943	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10943	2	268	268	CD
18637	10943	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10943	4	LIMITS	LIMITS	NNP
18637	10943	5	TO	to	IN
18637	10943	6	THE	the	DT
18637	10943	7	EXERCISE	EXERCISE	NNP
18637	10943	8	OF	of	IN
18637	10943	9	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	10943	10	REVIEW	REVIEW	NNP
18637	10943	11	Because	because	IN
18637	10943	12	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10943	13	review	review	NN
18637	10943	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	10943	15	an	an	DT
18637	10943	16	outgrowth	outgrowth	NN
18637	10943	17	of	of	IN
18637	10943	18	the	the	DT
18637	10943	19	fiction	fiction	NN
18637	10943	20	that	that	WDT
18637	10943	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	10943	22	only	only	RB
18637	10943	23	declare	declare	VB
18637	10943	24	what	what	WP
18637	10943	25	the	the	DT
18637	10943	26	law	law	NN
18637	10943	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	10943	28	in	in	IN
18637	10943	29	specific	specific	JJ
18637	10943	30	cases,[269	cases,[269	NN
18637	10943	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10943	32	and	and	CC
18637	10943	33	are	be	VBP
18637	10943	34	without	without	IN
18637	10943	35	will	will	MD
18637	10943	36	or	or	CC
18637	10943	37	discretion,[270	discretion,[270	NNP
18637	10943	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10943	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10943	40	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10943	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	10943	42	surrounded	surround	VBN
18637	10943	43	by	by	IN
18637	10943	44	the	the	DT
18637	10943	45	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10943	46	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	10943	47	of	of	IN
18637	10943	48	the	the	DT
18637	10943	49	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10943	50	process	process	NN
18637	10943	51	and	and	CC
18637	10943	52	notably	notably	RB
18637	10943	53	the	the	DT
18637	10943	54	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	10943	55	of	of	IN
18637	10943	56	a	a	DT
18637	10943	57	case	case	NN
18637	10943	58	or	or	CC
18637	10943	59	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10943	60	between	between	IN
18637	10943	61	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	10943	62	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	10943	63	with	with	IN
18637	10943	64	a	a	DT
18637	10943	65	standing	standing	NN
18637	10943	66	in	in	IN
18637	10943	67	court	court	NN
18637	10943	68	to	to	TO
18637	10943	69	present	present	VB
18637	10943	70	the	the	DT
18637	10943	71	issue	issue	NN
18637	10943	72	of	of	IN
18637	10943	73	unconstitutionality	unconstitutionality	NN
18637	10943	74	in	in	IN
18637	10943	75	which	which	WDT
18637	10943	76	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10943	77	are	be	VBP
18637	10943	78	directly	directly	RB
18637	10943	79	interested	interested	JJ
18637	10943	80	.	.	.
18637	10944	1	The	the	DT
18637	10944	2	requisites	requisite	NNS
18637	10944	3	to	to	IN
18637	10944	4	a	a	DT
18637	10944	5	case	case	NN
18637	10944	6	or	or	CC
18637	10944	7	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10944	8	have	have	VBP
18637	10944	9	been	be	VBN
18637	10944	10	treated	treat	VBN
18637	10944	11	more	more	RBR
18637	10944	12	extensively	extensively	RB
18637	10944	13	above	above	RB
18637	10944	14	,	,	,
18637	10944	15	but	but	CC
18637	10944	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10944	17	may	may	MD
18637	10944	18	be	be	VB
18637	10944	19	noted	note	VBN
18637	10944	20	that	that	IN
18637	10944	21	the	the	DT
18637	10944	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10944	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10944	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	10944	25	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	10944	26	emphasized	emphasize	VBN
18637	10944	27	the	the	DT
18637	10944	28	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	10944	29	of	of	IN
18637	10944	30	"	"	``
18637	10944	31	an	an	DT
18637	10944	32	honest	honest	JJ
18637	10944	33	and	and	CC
18637	10944	34	actual	actual	JJ
18637	10944	35	antagonistic	antagonistic	JJ
18637	10944	36	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	10944	37	of	of	IN
18637	10944	38	rights	right	NNS
18637	10944	39	by	by	IN
18637	10944	40	one	one	CD
18637	10944	41	individual	individual	NN
18637	10944	42	against	against	IN
18637	10944	43	another,"[271	another,"[271	NN
18637	10944	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10944	45	and	and	CC
18637	10944	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10944	47	lack	lack	NN
18637	10944	48	of	of	IN
18637	10944	49	power	power	NN
18637	10944	50	to	to	TO
18637	10944	51	supervise	supervise	VB
18637	10944	52	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10944	53	functions	function	NNS
18637	10944	54	in	in	IN
18637	10944	55	friendly	friendly	JJ
18637	10944	56	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	10944	57	,	,	,
18637	10944	58	moot	moot	JJ
18637	10944	59	cases	case	NNS
18637	10944	60	,	,	,
18637	10944	61	or	or	CC
18637	10944	62	cases	case	NNS
18637	10944	63	which	which	WDT
18637	10944	64	present	present	VBP
18637	10944	65	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	10944	66	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10944	67	.	.	.
18637	10945	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10945	2	272	272	CD
18637	10945	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10945	4	The	the	DT
18637	10945	5	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	10945	6	of	of	IN
18637	10945	7	"	"	``
18637	10945	8	Strict	Strict	NNP
18637	10945	9	Necessity	Necessity	NNP
18637	10945	10	"	"	''
18637	10945	11	But	but	CC
18637	10945	12	even	even	RB
18637	10945	13	when	when	WRB
18637	10945	14	a	a	DT
18637	10945	15	case	case	NN
18637	10945	16	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10945	17	a	a	DT
18637	10945	18	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10945	19	issue	issue	NN
18637	10945	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	10945	21	presented	present	VBN
18637	10945	22	,	,	,
18637	10945	23	the	the	DT
18637	10945	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10945	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	10945	26	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	10945	27	stated	state	VBN
18637	10945	28	that	that	IN
18637	10945	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10945	30	will	will	MD
18637	10945	31	decide	decide	VB
18637	10945	32	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10945	33	questions	question	NNS
18637	10945	34	only	only	RB
18637	10945	35	if	if	IN
18637	10945	36	strict	strict	JJ
18637	10945	37	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	10945	38	requires	require	VBZ
18637	10945	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10945	40	to	to	TO
18637	10945	41	do	do	VB
18637	10945	42	so	so	RB
18637	10945	43	.	.	.
18637	10946	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	10946	2	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10946	3	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10946	4	will	will	MD
18637	10946	5	not	not	RB
18637	10946	6	be	be	VB
18637	10946	7	decided	decide	VBN
18637	10946	8	in	in	IN
18637	10946	9	broader	broad	JJR
18637	10946	10	terms	term	NNS
18637	10946	11	than	than	IN
18637	10946	12	are	be	VBP
18637	10946	13	required	require	VBN
18637	10946	14	by	by	IN
18637	10946	15	the	the	DT
18637	10946	16	precise	precise	JJ
18637	10946	17	state	state	NN
18637	10946	18	of	of	IN
18637	10946	19	facts	fact	NNS
18637	10946	20	to	to	TO
18637	10946	21	which	which	WDT
18637	10946	22	the	the	DT
18637	10946	23	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	10946	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	10946	25	to	to	TO
18637	10946	26	be	be	VB
18637	10946	27	applied	apply	VBN
18637	10946	28	;	;	:
18637	10946	29	nor	nor	CC
18637	10946	30	if	if	IN
18637	10946	31	the	the	DT
18637	10946	32	record	record	NN
18637	10946	33	presents	present	VBZ
18637	10946	34	some	some	DT
18637	10946	35	other	other	JJ
18637	10946	36	ground	ground	NN
18637	10946	37	upon	upon	IN
18637	10946	38	which	which	WDT
18637	10946	39	to	to	TO
18637	10946	40	decide	decide	VB
18637	10946	41	the	the	DT
18637	10946	42	case	case	NN
18637	10946	43	;	;	,
18637	10946	44	nor	nor	CC
18637	10946	45	at	at	IN
18637	10946	46	the	the	DT
18637	10946	47	instance	instance	NN
18637	10946	48	of	of	IN
18637	10946	49	one	one	NN
18637	10946	50	who	who	WP
18637	10946	51	has	have	VBZ
18637	10946	52	availed	avail	VBN
18637	10946	53	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10946	54	of	of	IN
18637	10946	55	the	the	DT
18637	10946	56	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	10946	57	of	of	IN
18637	10946	58	a	a	DT
18637	10946	59	statute	statute	NN
18637	10946	60	or	or	CC
18637	10946	61	who	who	WP
18637	10946	62	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	10946	63	to	to	TO
18637	10946	64	show	show	VB
18637	10946	65	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10946	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	10946	67	injured	injure	VBN
18637	10946	68	by	by	IN
18637	10946	69	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10946	70	operation	operation	NN
18637	10946	71	;	;	:
18637	10946	72	nor	nor	CC
18637	10946	73	if	if	IN
18637	10946	74	a	a	DT
18637	10946	75	construction	construction	NN
18637	10946	76	of	of	IN
18637	10946	77	the	the	DT
18637	10946	78	statute	statute	NN
18637	10946	79	is	be	VBZ
18637	10946	80	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	10946	81	possible	possible	JJ
18637	10946	82	by	by	IN
18637	10946	83	which	which	WDT
18637	10946	84	the	the	DT
18637	10946	85	question	question	NN
18637	10946	86	may	may	MD
18637	10946	87	be	be	VB
18637	10946	88	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	10946	89	avoided	avoid	VBN
18637	10946	90	.	.	.
18637	10947	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10947	2	273	273	CD
18637	10947	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10947	4	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	10947	5	of	of	IN
18637	10947	6	the	the	DT
18637	10947	7	policy	policy	NN
18637	10947	8	of	of	IN
18637	10947	9	avoiding	avoid	VBG
18637	10947	10	the	the	DT
18637	10947	11	decision	decision	NN
18637	10947	12	of	of	IN
18637	10947	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10947	14	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10947	15	except	except	IN
18637	10947	16	when	when	WRB
18637	10947	17	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	10947	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10947	19	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	10947	20	,	,	,
18637	10947	21	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	10947	22	for	for	IN
18637	10947	23	the	the	DT
18637	10947	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10947	25	,	,	,
18637	10947	26	declared	declare	VBD
18637	10947	27	in	in	IN
18637	10947	28	1947	1947	CD
18637	10947	29	:	:	:
18637	10947	30	"	"	``
18637	10947	31	The	the	DT
18637	10947	32	policy	policy	NN
18637	10947	33	's	's	POS
18637	10947	34	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	10947	35	foundations	foundation	NNS
18637	10947	36	,	,	,
18637	10947	37	some	some	DT
18637	10947	38	if	if	IN
18637	10947	39	not	not	RB
18637	10947	40	all	all	DT
18637	10947	41	of	of	IN
18637	10947	42	which	which	WDT
18637	10947	43	also	also	RB
18637	10947	44	sustain	sustain	VBP
18637	10947	45	the	the	DT
18637	10947	46	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	10947	47	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	10947	48	,	,	,
18637	10947	49	lie	lie	VBP
18637	10947	50	in	in	IN
18637	10947	51	all	all	DT
18637	10947	52	that	that	WDT
18637	10947	53	goes	go	VBZ
18637	10947	54	to	to	TO
18637	10947	55	make	make	VB
18637	10947	56	up	up	RP
18637	10947	57	the	the	DT
18637	10947	58	unique	unique	JJ
18637	10947	59	place	place	NN
18637	10947	60	and	and	CC
18637	10947	61	character	character	NN
18637	10947	62	,	,	,
18637	10947	63	in	in	IN
18637	10947	64	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10947	65	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	10947	66	,	,	,
18637	10947	67	of	of	IN
18637	10947	68	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10947	69	review	review	NN
18637	10947	70	of	of	IN
18637	10947	71	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	10947	72	action	action	NN
18637	10947	73	for	for	IN
18637	10947	74	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	10947	75	.	.	.
18637	10948	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10948	2	are	be	VBP
18637	10948	3	found	find	VBN
18637	10948	4	in	in	IN
18637	10948	5	the	the	DT
18637	10948	6	delicacy	delicacy	NN
18637	10948	7	of	of	IN
18637	10948	8	that	that	DT
18637	10948	9	function	function	NN
18637	10948	10	,	,	,
18637	10948	11	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	10948	12	in	in	IN
18637	10948	13	view	view	NN
18637	10948	14	of	of	IN
18637	10948	15	possible	possible	JJ
18637	10948	16	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	10948	17	for	for	IN
18637	10948	18	others	other	NNS
18637	10948	19	stemming	stem	VBG
18637	10948	20	also	also	RB
18637	10948	21	from	from	IN
18637	10948	22	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10948	23	roots	root	NNS
18637	10948	24	;	;	:
18637	10948	25	the	the	DT
18637	10948	26	comparative	comparative	JJ
18637	10948	27	finality	finality	NN
18637	10948	28	of	of	IN
18637	10948	29	those	those	DT
18637	10948	30	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	10948	31	;	;	:
18637	10948	32	the	the	DT
18637	10948	33	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	10948	34	due	due	IN
18637	10948	35	to	to	IN
18637	10948	36	the	the	DT
18637	10948	37	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	10948	38	of	of	IN
18637	10948	39	other	other	JJ
18637	10948	40	repositories	repository	NNS
18637	10948	41	of	of	IN
18637	10948	42	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10948	43	power	power	NN
18637	10948	44	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	10948	45	the	the	DT
18637	10948	46	scope	scope	NN
18637	10948	47	of	of	IN
18637	10948	48	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10948	49	authority	authority	NN
18637	10948	50	;	;	:
18637	10948	51	the	the	DT
18637	10948	52	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	10948	53	,	,	,
18637	10948	54	if	if	IN
18637	10948	55	government	government	NN
18637	10948	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	10948	57	to	to	TO
18637	10948	58	function	function	VB
18637	10948	59	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	10948	60	,	,	,
18637	10948	61	for	for	IN
18637	10948	62	each	each	DT
18637	10948	63	to	to	TO
18637	10948	64	keep	keep	VB
18637	10948	65	within	within	IN
18637	10948	66	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10948	67	power	power	NN
18637	10948	68	,	,	,
18637	10948	69	including	include	VBG
18637	10948	70	the	the	DT
18637	10948	71	courts	court	NNS
18637	10948	72	;	;	:
18637	10948	73	the	the	DT
18637	10948	74	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10948	75	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	10948	76	of	of	IN
18637	10948	77	the	the	DT
18637	10948	78	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10948	79	process	process	NN
18637	10948	80	,	,	,
18637	10948	81	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10948	82	especially	especially	RB
18637	10948	83	from	from	IN
18637	10948	84	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10948	85	largely	largely	RB
18637	10948	86	negative	negative	JJ
18637	10948	87	character	character	NN
18637	10948	88	and	and	CC
18637	10948	89	limited	limited	JJ
18637	10948	90	resources	resource	NNS
18637	10948	91	of	of	IN
18637	10948	92	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	10948	93	;	;	:
18637	10948	94	withal	withal	VB
18637	10948	95	in	in	IN
18637	10948	96	the	the	DT
18637	10948	97	paramount	paramount	JJ
18637	10948	98	importance	importance	NN
18637	10948	99	of	of	IN
18637	10948	100	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10948	101	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	10948	102	in	in	IN
18637	10948	103	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10948	104	system	system	NN
18637	10948	105	.	.	.
18637	10949	1	"	"	``
18637	10949	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10949	3	274	274	CD
18637	10949	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10949	5	The	the	DT
18637	10949	6	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	10949	7	of	of	IN
18637	10949	8	Political	political	JJ
18637	10949	9	Questions	Questions	NNPS
18637	10949	10	A	a	DT
18637	10949	11	third	third	JJ
18637	10949	12	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	10949	13	to	to	IN
18637	10949	14	the	the	DT
18637	10949	15	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10949	16	of	of	IN
18637	10949	17	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10949	18	review	review	NN
18637	10949	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	10949	20	the	the	DT
18637	10949	21	rule	rule	NN
18637	10949	22	,	,	,
18637	10949	23	partly	partly	RB
18637	10949	24	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	10949	25	in	in	IN
18637	10949	26	the	the	DT
18637	10949	27	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10949	28	process	process	NN
18637	10949	29	,	,	,
18637	10949	30	but	but	CC
18637	10949	31	also	also	RB
18637	10949	32	partly	partly	RB
18637	10949	33	a	a	DT
18637	10949	34	precautionary	precautionary	JJ
18637	10949	35	rule	rule	NN
18637	10949	36	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	10949	37	by	by	IN
18637	10949	38	the	the	DT
18637	10949	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10949	40	in	in	IN
18637	10949	41	order	order	NN
18637	10949	42	to	to	TO
18637	10949	43	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	10949	44	clashes	clash	NNS
18637	10949	45	with	with	IN
18637	10949	46	the	the	DT
18637	10949	47	"	"	``
18637	10949	48	political	political	JJ
18637	10949	49	branches	branch	NNS
18637	10949	50	,	,	,
18637	10949	51	"	"	''
18637	10949	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	10949	53	that	that	IN
18637	10949	54	the	the	DT
18637	10949	55	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10949	56	courts	court	NNS
18637	10949	57	will	will	MD
18637	10949	58	not	not	RB
18637	10949	59	decide	decide	VB
18637	10949	60	"	"	``
18637	10949	61	political	political	JJ
18637	10949	62	questions	question	NNS
18637	10949	63	.	.	.
18637	10950	1	"	"	``
18637	10950	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10950	3	275	275	CD
18637	10950	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10950	5	The	the	DT
18637	10950	6	"	"	``
18637	10950	7	Reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	10950	8	Doubt	doubt	NN
18637	10950	9	"	"	''
18637	10950	10	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	10950	11	A	a	DT
18637	10950	12	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	10950	13	rule	rule	NN
18637	10950	14	,	,	,
18637	10950	15	of	of	IN
18637	10950	16	a	a	DT
18637	10950	17	precautionary	precautionary	JJ
18637	10950	18	nature	nature	NN
18637	10950	19	,	,	,
18637	10950	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	10950	21	that	that	IN
18637	10950	22	no	no	DT
18637	10950	23	act	act	NN
18637	10950	24	of	of	IN
18637	10950	25	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10950	26	will	will	MD
18637	10950	27	be	be	VB
18637	10950	28	declared	declare	VBN
18637	10950	29	void	void	JJ
18637	10950	30	except	except	IN
18637	10950	31	in	in	IN
18637	10950	32	a	a	DT
18637	10950	33	very	very	RB
18637	10950	34	clear	clear	JJ
18637	10950	35	case	case	NN
18637	10950	36	,	,	,
18637	10950	37	or	or	CC
18637	10950	38	unless	unless	IN
18637	10950	39	the	the	DT
18637	10950	40	act	act	NN
18637	10950	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	10950	42	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	10950	43	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	10950	44	all	all	DT
18637	10950	45	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	10950	46	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	10950	47	.	.	.
18637	10951	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10951	2	276	276	CD
18637	10951	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10951	4	Sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	10951	5	this	this	DT
18637	10951	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	10951	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	10951	8	expressed	express	VBN
18637	10951	9	in	in	IN
18637	10951	10	another	another	DT
18637	10951	11	way	way	NN
18637	10951	12	,	,	,
18637	10951	13	in	in	IN
18637	10951	14	the	the	DT
18637	10951	15	formula	formula	NN
18637	10951	16	that	that	WDT
18637	10951	17	an	an	DT
18637	10951	18	act	act	NN
18637	10951	19	of	of	IN
18637	10951	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10951	21	or	or	CC
18637	10951	22	a	a	DT
18637	10951	23	State	State	NNP
18637	10951	24	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	10951	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	10951	26	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	10951	27	to	to	TO
18637	10951	28	be	be	VB
18637	10951	29	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10951	30	until	until	IN
18637	10951	31	proved	prove	VBN
18637	10951	32	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	10951	33	"	"	''
18637	10951	34	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	10951	35	all	all	DT
18637	10951	36	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	10951	37	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	10951	38	.	.	.
18637	10952	1	"	"	``
18637	10952	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10952	3	277	277	CD
18637	10952	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10952	5	In	in	IN
18637	10952	6	operation	operation	NN
18637	10952	7	this	this	DT
18637	10952	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	10952	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	10952	10	subject	subject	JJ
18637	10952	11	to	to	IN
18637	10952	12	two	two	CD
18637	10952	13	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	10952	14	which	which	WDT
18637	10952	15	seriously	seriously	RB
18637	10952	16	impair	impair	VBP
18637	10952	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10952	18	efficacy	efficacy	NN
18637	10952	19	.	.	.
18637	10953	1	The	the	DT
18637	10953	2	first	first	JJ
18637	10953	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	10953	4	that	that	IN
18637	10953	5	the	the	DT
18637	10953	6	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	10953	7	which	which	WDT
18637	10953	8	are	be	VBP
18637	10953	9	effective	effective	JJ
18637	10953	10	are	be	VBP
18637	10953	11	the	the	DT
18637	10953	12	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	10953	13	of	of	IN
18637	10953	14	the	the	DT
18637	10953	15	majority	majority	NN
18637	10953	16	only	only	RB
18637	10953	17	.	.	.
18637	10954	1	If	if	IN
18637	10954	2	five	five	CD
18637	10954	3	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	10954	4	of	of	IN
18637	10954	5	learning	learning	NN
18637	10954	6	and	and	CC
18637	10954	7	attachment	attachment	NN
18637	10954	8	to	to	IN
18637	10954	9	the	the	DT
18637	10954	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10954	11	are	be	VBP
18637	10954	12	convinced	convince	VBN
18637	10954	13	that	that	IN
18637	10954	14	the	the	DT
18637	10954	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	10954	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	10954	17	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	10954	18	and	and	CC
18637	10954	19	four	four	CD
18637	10954	20	others	other	NNS
18637	10954	21	of	of	IN
18637	10954	22	equal	equal	JJ
18637	10954	23	learning	learning	NN
18637	10954	24	and	and	CC
18637	10954	25	attachment	attachment	NN
18637	10954	26	to	to	IN
18637	10954	27	the	the	DT
18637	10954	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10954	29	are	be	VBP
18637	10954	30	convinced	convinced	JJ
18637	10954	31	that	that	IN
18637	10954	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10954	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	10954	34	valid	valid	JJ
18637	10954	35	or	or	CC
18637	10954	36	are	be	VBP
18637	10954	37	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
18637	10954	38	that	that	IN
18637	10954	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10954	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	10954	41	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	10954	42	,	,	,
18637	10954	43	the	the	DT
18637	10954	44	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	10954	45	of	of	IN
18637	10954	46	the	the	DT
18637	10954	47	five	five	CD
18637	10954	48	prevail	prevail	NN
18637	10954	49	over	over	IN
18637	10954	50	the	the	DT
18637	10954	51	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	10954	52	or	or	CC
18637	10954	53	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	10954	54	of	of	IN
18637	10954	55	the	the	DT
18637	10954	56	four	four	CD
18637	10954	57	,	,	,
18637	10954	58	and	and	CC
18637	10954	59	vice	vice	NN
18637	10954	60	versa	versa	RB
18637	10954	61	.	.	.
18637	10955	1	Second	second	JJ
18637	10955	2	,	,	,
18637	10955	3	the	the	DT
18637	10955	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10955	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	10955	6	made	make	VBN
18637	10955	7	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	10955	8	to	to	IN
18637	10955	9	this	this	DT
18637	10955	10	rule	rule	NN
18637	10955	11	in	in	IN
18637	10955	12	certain	certain	JJ
18637	10955	13	categories	category	NNS
18637	10955	14	of	of	IN
18637	10955	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	10955	16	.	.	.
18637	10956	1	At	at	IN
18637	10956	2	one	one	CD
18637	10956	3	time	time	NN
18637	10956	4	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	10956	5	interfering	interfere	VBG
18637	10956	6	with	with	IN
18637	10956	7	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	10956	8	of	of	IN
18637	10956	9	contract	contract	NN
18637	10956	10	were	be	VBD
18637	10956	11	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	10956	12	to	to	TO
18637	10956	13	be	be	VB
18637	10956	14	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	10956	15	until	until	IN
18637	10956	16	proved	prove	VBN
18637	10956	17	valid,[278	valid,[278	NN
18637	10956	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10956	19	and	and	CC
18637	10956	20	more	more	RBR
18637	10956	21	recently	recently	RB
18637	10956	22	presumptions	presumption	NNS
18637	10956	23	of	of	IN
18637	10956	24	invalidity	invalidity	NN
18637	10956	25	have	have	VBP
18637	10956	26	appeared	appear	VBN
18637	10956	27	to	to	TO
18637	10956	28	prevail	prevail	VB
18637	10956	29	against	against	IN
18637	10956	30	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	10956	31	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	10956	32	to	to	TO
18637	10956	33	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	10956	34	with	with	IN
18637	10956	35	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	10956	36	of	of	IN
18637	10956	37	expression	expression	NN
18637	10956	38	and	and	CC
18637	10956	39	of	of	IN
18637	10956	40	religious	religious	JJ
18637	10956	41	worship	worship	NN
18637	10956	42	,	,	,
18637	10956	43	which	which	WDT
18637	10956	44	have	have	VBP
18637	10956	45	been	be	VBN
18637	10956	46	said	say	VBN
18637	10956	47	to	to	TO
18637	10956	48	occupy	occupy	VB
18637	10956	49	a	a	DT
18637	10956	50	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	10956	51	position	position	NN
18637	10956	52	in	in	IN
18637	10956	53	the	the	DT
18637	10956	54	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10956	55	.	.	.
18637	10957	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10957	2	279	279	CD
18637	10957	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10957	4	Exclusion	Exclusion	NNP
18637	10957	5	of	of	IN
18637	10957	6	Extra	extra	JJ
18637	10957	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	10957	8	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	10957	9	Tests	test	NNS
18637	10957	10	A	a	DT
18637	10957	11	fifth	fifth	JJ
18637	10957	12	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	10957	13	of	of	IN
18637	10957	14	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10957	15	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	10957	16	runs	run	VBZ
18637	10957	17	to	to	IN
18637	10957	18	the	the	DT
18637	10957	19	effect	effect	NN
18637	10957	20	that	that	WDT
18637	10957	21	the	the	DT
18637	10957	22	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	10957	23	are	be	VBP
18637	10957	24	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	10957	25	only	only	RB
18637	10957	26	with	with	IN
18637	10957	27	the	the	DT
18637	10957	28	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	10957	29	of	of	IN
18637	10957	30	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10957	31	and	and	CC
18637	10957	32	not	not	RB
18637	10957	33	with	with	IN
18637	10957	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10957	35	motives	motive	NNS
18637	10957	36	,	,	,
18637	10957	37	policy	policy	NN
18637	10957	38	or	or	CC
18637	10957	39	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	10957	40	,	,	,
18637	10957	41	or	or	CC
18637	10957	42	with	with	IN
18637	10957	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10957	44	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	10957	45	with	with	IN
18637	10957	46	natural	natural	JJ
18637	10957	47	justice	justice	NN
18637	10957	48	,	,	,
18637	10957	49	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	10957	50	principles	principle	NNS
18637	10957	51	of	of	IN
18637	10957	52	government	government	NN
18637	10957	53	,	,	,
18637	10957	54	or	or	CC
18637	10957	55	spirit	spirit	NN
18637	10957	56	of	of	IN
18637	10957	57	the	the	DT
18637	10957	58	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10957	59	.	.	.
18637	10958	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10958	2	280	280	CD
18637	10958	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10958	4	In	in	IN
18637	10958	5	various	various	JJ
18637	10958	6	forms	form	NNS
18637	10958	7	this	this	DT
18637	10958	8	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	10958	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	10958	10	been	be	VBN
18637	10958	11	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	10958	12	to	to	IN
18637	10958	13	such	such	PDT
18637	10958	14	an	an	DT
18637	10958	15	extent	extent	NN
18637	10958	16	that	that	IN
18637	10958	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10958	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	10958	19	become	become	VBN
18637	10958	20	trite	trite	NNP
18637	10958	21	and	and	CC
18637	10958	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	10958	23	increasingly	increasingly	RB
18637	10958	24	come	come	VBN
18637	10958	25	to	to	TO
18637	10958	26	be	be	VB
18637	10958	27	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	10958	28	in	in	IN
18637	10958	29	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10958	30	cases	case	NNS
18637	10958	31	as	as	IN
18637	10958	32	a	a	DT
18637	10958	33	reason	reason	NN
18637	10958	34	for	for	IN
18637	10958	35	fortifying	fortify	VBG
18637	10958	36	a	a	DT
18637	10958	37	finding	finding	NN
18637	10958	38	of	of	IN
18637	10958	39	unconstitutionality	unconstitutionality	NN
18637	10958	40	.	.	.
18637	10959	1	Through	through	IN
18637	10959	2	absorption	absorption	NN
18637	10959	3	of	of	IN
18637	10959	4	natural	natural	JJ
18637	10959	5	rights	right	NNS
18637	10959	6	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	10959	7	into	into	IN
18637	10959	8	the	the	DT
18637	10959	9	text	text	NN
18637	10959	10	of	of	IN
18637	10959	11	the	the	DT
18637	10959	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10959	13	,	,	,
18637	10959	14	the	the	DT
18637	10959	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10959	16	was	be	VBD
18637	10959	17	enabled	enable	VBN
18637	10959	18	to	to	TO
18637	10959	19	reject	reject	VB
18637	10959	20	natural	natural	JJ
18637	10959	21	law	law	NN
18637	10959	22	and	and	CC
18637	10959	23	still	still	RB
18637	10959	24	to	to	TO
18637	10959	25	partake	partake	VB
18637	10959	26	of	of	IN
18637	10959	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10959	28	fruits	fruit	NNS
18637	10959	29	,	,	,
18637	10959	30	and	and	CC
18637	10959	31	the	the	DT
18637	10959	32	same	same	JJ
18637	10959	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	10959	34	true	true	JJ
18637	10959	35	of	of	IN
18637	10959	36	the	the	DT
18637	10959	37	_	_	NNP
18637	10959	38	laissez	laissez	NN
18637	10959	39	faire	faire	NN
18637	10959	40	_	_	NNP
18637	10959	41	principles	principle	NNS
18637	10959	42	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	10959	43	in	in	IN
18637	10959	44	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10959	45	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	10959	46	from	from	IN
18637	10959	47	about	about	IN
18637	10959	48	1890	1890	CD
18637	10959	49	to	to	IN
18637	10959	50	1937	1937	CD
18637	10959	51	.	.	.
18637	10960	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	10960	2	protective	protective	JJ
18637	10960	3	coloration	coloration	NN
18637	10960	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	10960	5	transparent	transparent	JJ
18637	10960	6	in	in	IN
18637	10960	7	such	such	JJ
18637	10960	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	10960	9	as	as	IN
18637	10960	10	Lochner	Lochner	NNP
18637	10960	11	_	_	NNP
18637	10960	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	10960	13	_	_	NNP
18637	10960	14	New	New	NNP
18637	10960	15	York[281	york[281	NN
18637	10960	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10960	17	and	and	CC
18637	10960	18	United	United	NNP
18637	10960	19	States	States	NNP
18637	10960	20	_	_	NNP
18637	10960	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	10960	22	_	_	NNP
18637	10960	23	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	10960	24	.	.	.
18637	10961	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10961	2	282	282	CD
18637	10961	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10961	4	Disallowance	Disallowance	NNP
18637	10961	5	by	by	IN
18637	10961	6	Statutory	Statutory	NNP
18637	10961	7	Interpretation	Interpretation	NNP
18637	10961	8	A	a	DT
18637	10961	9	sixth	sixth	JJ
18637	10961	10	principle	principle	NN
18637	10961	11	of	of	IN
18637	10961	12	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10961	13	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	10961	14	designed	design	VBN
18637	10961	15	by	by	IN
18637	10961	16	the	the	DT
18637	10961	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	10961	18	to	to	TO
18637	10961	19	discourage	discourage	VB
18637	10961	20	invalidation	invalidation	NN
18637	10961	21	of	of	IN
18637	10961	22	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	10961	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	10961	24	that	that	IN
18637	10961	25	if	if	IN
18637	10961	26	at	at	RB
18637	10961	27	all	all	RB
18637	10961	28	possible	possible	JJ
18637	10961	29	the	the	DT
18637	10961	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	10961	31	will	will	MD
18637	10961	32	construe	construe	VB
18637	10961	33	the	the	DT
18637	10961	34	statute	statute	NN
18637	10961	35	so	so	IN
18637	10961	36	as	as	IN
18637	10961	37	to	to	TO
18637	10961	38	bring	bring	VB
18637	10961	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10961	40	within	within	IN
18637	10961	41	the	the	DT
18637	10961	42	law	law	NN
18637	10961	43	of	of	IN
18637	10961	44	the	the	DT
18637	10961	45	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10961	46	.	.	.
18637	10962	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10962	2	283	283	CD
18637	10962	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10962	4	At	at	IN
18637	10962	5	times	time	NNS
18637	10962	6	this	this	DT
18637	10962	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	10962	8	meant	mean	VBN
18637	10962	9	that	that	IN
18637	10962	10	a	a	DT
18637	10962	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	10962	12	was	be	VBD
18637	10962	13	construed	construe	VBN
18637	10962	14	so	so	RB
18637	10962	15	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	10962	16	in	in	IN
18637	10962	17	order	order	NN
18637	10962	18	to	to	TO
18637	10962	19	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	10962	20	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10962	21	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	10962	22	that	that	WDT
18637	10962	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10962	24	efficacy	efficacy	NN
18637	10962	25	was	be	VBD
18637	10962	26	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	10962	27	if	if	IN
18637	10962	28	not	not	RB
18637	10962	29	lost	lose	VBN
18637	10962	30	.	.	.
18637	10963	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10963	2	284	284	CD
18637	10963	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10963	4	A	a	DT
18637	10963	5	seventh	seventh	JJ
18637	10963	6	principle	principle	NN
18637	10963	7	closely	closely	RB
18637	10963	8	related	related	JJ
18637	10963	9	to	to	IN
18637	10963	10	the	the	DT
18637	10963	11	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	10963	12	one	one	CD
18637	10963	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	10963	14	that	that	IN
18637	10963	15	in	in	IN
18637	10963	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	10963	17	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10963	18	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	10963	19	,	,	,
18637	10963	20	portions	portion	NNS
18637	10963	21	of	of	IN
18637	10963	22	which	which	WDT
18637	10963	23	are	be	VBP
18637	10963	24	valid	valid	JJ
18637	10963	25	and	and	CC
18637	10963	26	other	other	JJ
18637	10963	27	portions	portion	NNS
18637	10963	28	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	10963	29	,	,	,
18637	10963	30	the	the	DT
18637	10963	31	courts	court	NNS
18637	10963	32	will	will	MD
18637	10963	33	separate	separate	VB
18637	10963	34	the	the	DT
18637	10963	35	valid	valid	JJ
18637	10963	36	from	from	IN
18637	10963	37	the	the	DT
18637	10963	38	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	10963	39	and	and	CC
18637	10963	40	throw	throw	VB
18637	10963	41	out	out	RP
18637	10963	42	only	only	RB
18637	10963	43	the	the	DT
18637	10963	44	latter	latter	JJ
18637	10963	45	unless	unless	IN
18637	10963	46	such	such	JJ
18637	10963	47	portions	portion	NNS
18637	10963	48	are	be	VBP
18637	10963	49	inextricably	inextricably	RB
18637	10963	50	connected	connect	VBN
18637	10963	51	.	.	.
18637	10964	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10964	2	285	285	CD
18637	10964	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10964	4	Sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	10964	5	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	10964	6	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	10964	7	provide	provide	VBP
18637	10964	8	for	for	IN
18637	10964	9	the	the	DT
18637	10964	10	separability	separability	NN
18637	10964	11	of	of	IN
18637	10964	12	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	10964	13	,	,	,
18637	10964	14	but	but	CC
18637	10964	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10964	16	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	10964	17	for	for	IN
18637	10964	18	the	the	DT
18637	10964	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	10964	20	in	in	IN
18637	10964	21	the	the	DT
18637	10964	22	last	last	JJ
18637	10964	23	resort	resort	NN
18637	10964	24	to	to	TO
18637	10964	25	determine	determine	VB
18637	10964	26	whether	whether	IN
18637	10964	27	the	the	DT
18637	10964	28	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	10964	29	are	be	VBP
18637	10964	30	separable	separable	JJ
18637	10964	31	.	.	.
18637	10965	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10965	2	286	286	CD
18637	10965	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10965	4	_	_	NNP
18637	10965	5	Stare	Stare	NNP
18637	10965	6	Decisis	Decisis	NNP
18637	10965	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10965	8	in	in	IN
18637	10965	9	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	10965	10	Law	Law	NNP
18637	10965	11	An	an	DT
18637	10965	12	eighth	eighth	JJ
18637	10965	13	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	10965	14	on	on	IN
18637	10965	15	the	the	DT
18637	10965	16	power	power	NN
18637	10965	17	of	of	IN
18637	10965	18	the	the	DT
18637	10965	19	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10965	20	courts	court	NNS
18637	10965	21	to	to	TO
18637	10965	22	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	10965	23	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10965	24	springs	spring	NNS
18637	10965	25	from	from	IN
18637	10965	26	the	the	DT
18637	10965	27	principle	principle	NN
18637	10965	28	of	of	IN
18637	10965	29	_	_	NNP
18637	10965	30	stare	stare	NN
18637	10965	31	decisis	decisis	NN
18637	10965	32	_	_	NNP
18637	10965	33	,	,	,
18637	10965	34	a	a	DT
18637	10965	35	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	10965	36	which	which	WDT
18637	10965	37	has	have	VBZ
18637	10965	38	been	be	VBN
18637	10965	39	progressively	progressively	RB
18637	10965	40	weakened	weaken	VBN
18637	10965	41	since	since	IN
18637	10965	42	the	the	DT
18637	10965	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10965	44	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	10965	45	to	to	TO
18637	10965	46	correct	correct	VB
18637	10965	47	"	"	``
18637	10965	48	a	a	DT
18637	10965	49	century	century	NN
18637	10965	50	of	of	IN
18637	10965	51	error	error	NN
18637	10965	52	"	"	''
18637	10965	53	in	in	IN
18637	10965	54	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	10965	55	_	_	NNP
18637	10965	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	10965	57	_	_	NNP
18637	10965	58	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	10965	59	'	'	POS
18637	10965	60	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	10965	61	&	&	CC
18637	10965	62	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	10965	63	Co.[287	Co.[287	NNP
18637	10965	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10965	65	Because	because	IN
18637	10965	66	of	of	IN
18637	10965	67	the	the	DT
18637	10965	68	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	10965	69	of	of	IN
18637	10965	70	amending	amend	VBG
18637	10965	71	the	the	DT
18637	10965	72	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10965	73	the	the	DT
18637	10965	74	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10965	75	has	have	VBZ
18637	10965	76	long	long	RB
18637	10965	77	taken	take	VBN
18637	10965	78	the	the	DT
18637	10965	79	position	position	NN
18637	10965	80	that	that	IN
18637	10965	81	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10965	82	will	will	MD
18637	10965	83	reverse	reverse	VB
18637	10965	84	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10965	85	previous	previous	JJ
18637	10965	86	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	10965	87	on	on	IN
18637	10965	88	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10965	89	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10965	90	when	when	WRB
18637	10965	91	convinced	convinced	JJ
18637	10965	92	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10965	93	are	be	VBP
18637	10965	94	grounded	ground	VBN
18637	10965	95	on	on	IN
18637	10965	96	error	error	NN
18637	10965	97	more	more	RBR
18637	10965	98	quickly	quickly	RB
18637	10965	99	than	than	IN
18637	10965	100	in	in	IN
18637	10965	101	other	other	JJ
18637	10965	102	types	type	NNS
18637	10965	103	of	of	IN
18637	10965	104	cases	case	NNS
18637	10965	105	in	in	IN
18637	10965	106	which	which	WDT
18637	10965	107	earlier	early	JJR
18637	10965	108	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	10965	109	are	be	VBP
18637	10965	110	not	not	RB
18637	10965	111	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	10965	112	binding	binding	JJ
18637	10965	113	.	.	.
18637	10966	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10966	2	288	288	CD
18637	10966	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10966	4	The	the	DT
18637	10966	5	"	"	``
18637	10966	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10966	7	revolution	revolution	NN
18637	10966	8	"	"	''
18637	10966	9	of	of	IN
18637	10966	10	1937	1937	CD
18637	10966	11	produced	produce	VBD
18637	10966	12	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	10966	13	reversals	reversal	NNS
18637	10966	14	of	of	IN
18637	10966	15	earlier	early	JJR
18637	10966	16	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	10966	17	as	as	IN
18637	10966	18	other	other	JJ
18637	10966	19	sections	section	NNS
18637	10966	20	of	of	IN
18637	10966	21	this	this	DT
18637	10966	22	study	study	NN
18637	10966	23	disclose	disclose	VB
18637	10966	24	,	,	,
18637	10966	25	and	and	CC
18637	10966	26	the	the	DT
18637	10966	27	process	process	NN
18637	10966	28	continues	continue	VBZ
18637	10966	29	.	.	.
18637	10967	1	In	in	IN
18637	10967	2	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	10967	3	_	_	NNP
18637	10967	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	10967	5	_	_	NNP
18637	10967	6	Allwright,[289	Allwright,[289	NNP
18637	10967	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10967	8	which	which	WDT
18637	10967	9	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	10967	10	Grovey	Grovey	NNP
18637	10967	11	_	_	NNP
18637	10967	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	10967	13	_	_	NNP
18637	10967	14	Townsend,[290	Townsend,[290	NNP
18637	10967	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10967	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10967	17	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	10967	18	cited	cite	VBD
18637	10967	19	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	10967	20	cases	case	NNS
18637	10967	21	decided	decide	VBN
18637	10967	22	between	between	IN
18637	10967	23	March	March	NNP
18637	10967	24	27	27	CD
18637	10967	25	,	,	,
18637	10967	26	1937	1937	CD
18637	10967	27	,	,	,
18637	10967	28	and	and	CC
18637	10967	29	June	June	NNP
18637	10967	30	14	14	CD
18637	10967	31	,	,	,
18637	10967	32	1943	1943	CD
18637	10967	33	,	,	,
18637	10967	34	in	in	IN
18637	10967	35	which	which	WDT
18637	10967	36	one	one	CD
18637	10967	37	or	or	CC
18637	10967	38	more	more	JJR
18637	10967	39	earlier	early	JJR
18637	10967	40	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	10967	41	of	of	IN
18637	10967	42	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10967	43	questions	question	NNS
18637	10967	44	were	be	VBD
18637	10967	45	overturned	overturn	VBN
18637	10967	46	.	.	.
18637	10968	1	Although	although	IN
18637	10968	2	the	the	DT
18637	10968	3	general	general	JJ
18637	10968	4	effect	effect	NN
18637	10968	5	of	of	IN
18637	10968	6	the	the	DT
18637	10968	7	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	10968	8	reversals	reversal	NNS
18637	10968	9	of	of	IN
18637	10968	10	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	10968	11	between	between	IN
18637	10968	12	1937	1937	CD
18637	10968	13	and	and	CC
18637	10968	14	1950	1950	CD
18637	10968	15	was	be	VBD
18637	10968	16	to	to	TO
18637	10968	17	bring	bring	VB
18637	10968	18	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10968	19	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	10968	20	more	more	RBR
18637	10968	21	generally	generally	RB
18637	10968	22	into	into	IN
18637	10968	23	accord	accord	NN
18637	10968	24	with	with	IN
18637	10968	25	the	the	DT
18637	10968	26	formal	formal	JJ
18637	10968	27	text	text	NN
18637	10968	28	of	of	IN
18637	10968	29	the	the	DT
18637	10968	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10968	31	,	,	,
18637	10968	32	and	and	CC
18637	10968	33	to	to	TO
18637	10968	34	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	10968	35	of	of	IN
18637	10968	36	a	a	DT
18637	10968	37	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	10968	38	amount	amount	NN
18637	10968	39	of	of	IN
18637	10968	40	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10968	41	chaff	chaff	NN
18637	10968	42	,	,	,
18637	10968	43	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10968	44	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	10968	45	was	be	VBD
18637	10968	46	moved	move	VBN
18637	10968	47	to	to	TO
18637	10968	48	say	say	VB
18637	10968	49	in	in	IN
18637	10968	50	the	the	DT
18637	10968	51	Allwright	Allwright	NNP
18637	10968	52	case	case	NN
18637	10968	53	that	that	IN
18637	10968	54	frequent	frequent	JJ
18637	10968	55	reversals	reversal	NNS
18637	10968	56	of	of	IN
18637	10968	57	earlier	early	JJR
18637	10968	58	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	10968	59	tended	tend	VBD
18637	10968	60	to	to	TO
18637	10968	61	bring	bring	VB
18637	10968	62	adjudications	adjudication	NNS
18637	10968	63	of	of	IN
18637	10968	64	the	the	DT
18637	10968	65	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10968	66	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10968	67	"	"	''
18637	10968	68	into	into	IN
18637	10968	69	the	the	DT
18637	10968	70	same	same	JJ
18637	10968	71	class	class	NN
18637	10968	72	as	as	IN
18637	10968	73	a	a	DT
18637	10968	74	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	10968	75	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	10968	76	ticket	ticket	NN
18637	10968	77	,	,	,
18637	10968	78	good	good	JJ
18637	10968	79	for	for	IN
18637	10968	80	this	this	DT
18637	10968	81	day	day	NN
18637	10968	82	and	and	CC
18637	10968	83	train	train	NN
18637	10968	84	only	only	RB
18637	10968	85	.	.	.
18637	10969	1	"	"	``
18637	10969	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10969	3	291	291	CD
18637	10969	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10969	5	A	a	DT
18637	10969	6	ninth	ninth	JJ
18637	10969	7	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	10969	8	which	which	WDT
18637	10969	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	10969	10	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	10969	11	to	to	TO
18637	10969	12	do	do	VB
18637	10969	13	with	with	IN
18637	10969	14	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	10969	15	or	or	CC
18637	10969	16	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10969	17	construction	construction	NN
18637	10969	18	as	as	IN
18637	10969	19	such	such	JJ
18637	10969	20	and	and	CC
18637	10969	21	which	which	WDT
18637	10969	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	10969	23	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	10969	24	precautionary	precautionary	JJ
18637	10969	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	10969	26	that	that	IN
18637	10969	27	the	the	DT
18637	10969	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10969	29	will	will	MD
18637	10969	30	declare	declare	VB
18637	10969	31	no	no	DT
18637	10969	32	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	10969	33	act	act	NN
18637	10969	34	void	void	NN
18637	10969	35	unless	unless	IN
18637	10969	36	a	a	DT
18637	10969	37	majority	majority	NN
18637	10969	38	of	of	IN
18637	10969	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10969	40	full	full	JJ
18637	10969	41	membership	membership	NN
18637	10969	42	so	so	IN
18637	10969	43	concurs	concur	VBZ
18637	10969	44	.	.	.
18637	10970	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10970	2	292	292	CD
18637	10970	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10970	4	The	the	DT
18637	10970	5	cumulative	cumulative	JJ
18637	10970	6	effect	effect	NN
18637	10970	7	of	of	IN
18637	10970	8	these	these	DT
18637	10970	9	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	10970	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	10970	11	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	10970	12	to	to	TO
18637	10970	13	measure	measure	VB
18637	10970	14	.	.	.
18637	10971	1	The	the	DT
18637	10971	2	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	10971	3	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	10971	4	by	by	IN
18637	10971	5	the	the	DT
18637	10971	6	case	case	NN
18637	10971	7	concept	concept	NN
18637	10971	8	definitely	definitely	RB
18637	10971	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	10971	10	the	the	DT
18637	10971	11	effect	effect	NN
18637	10971	12	of	of	IN
18637	10971	13	postponing	postpone	VBG
18637	10971	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10971	15	nullification	nullification	NN
18637	10971	16	,	,	,
18637	10971	17	but	but	CC
18637	10971	18	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	10971	19	this	this	DT
18637	10971	20	the	the	DT
18637	10971	21	most	most	JJS
18637	10971	22	that	that	WDT
18637	10971	23	can	can	MD
18637	10971	24	be	be	VB
18637	10971	25	said	say	VBN
18637	10971	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	10971	27	that	that	IN
18637	10971	28	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10971	29	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10971	30	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	10971	31	important	important	JJ
18637	10971	32	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10971	33	can	can	MD
18637	10971	34	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	10971	35	be	be	VB
18637	10971	36	presented	present	VBN
18637	10971	37	in	in	IN
18637	10971	38	a	a	DT
18637	10971	39	case	case	NN
18637	10971	40	and	and	CC
18637	10971	41	so	so	RB
18637	10971	42	will	will	MD
18637	10971	43	sooner	sooner	RB
18637	10971	44	or	or	CC
18637	10971	45	later	later	RB
18637	10971	46	reach	reach	VB
18637	10971	47	the	the	DT
18637	10971	48	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10971	49	.	.	.
18637	10972	1	The	the	DT
18637	10972	2	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	10972	3	of	of	IN
18637	10972	4	the	the	DT
18637	10972	5	presumptions	presumption	NNS
18637	10972	6	of	of	IN
18637	10972	7	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	10972	8	validity	validity	NN
18637	10972	9	,	,	,
18637	10972	10	lack	lack	NN
18637	10972	11	of	of	IN
18637	10972	12	concern	concern	NN
18637	10972	13	with	with	IN
18637	10972	14	the	the	DT
18637	10972	15	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	10972	16	of	of	IN
18637	10972	17	the	the	DT
18637	10972	18	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10972	19	,	,	,
18637	10972	20	alternative	alternative	JJ
18637	10972	21	construction	construction	NN
18637	10972	22	,	,	,
18637	10972	23	separability	separability	NN
18637	10972	24	of	of	IN
18637	10972	25	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	10972	26	and	and	CC
18637	10972	27	the	the	DT
18637	10972	28	like	like	JJ
18637	10972	29	depend	depend	VB
18637	10972	30	for	for	IN
18637	10972	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10972	32	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
18637	10972	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	10972	34	the	the	DT
18637	10972	35	consciousness	consciousness	NN
18637	10972	36	of	of	IN
18637	10972	37	the	the	DT
18637	10972	38	individual	individual	JJ
18637	10972	39	judge	judge	NN
18637	10972	40	of	of	IN
18637	10972	41	the	the	DT
18637	10972	42	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10972	43	proprieties	propriety	NNS
18637	10972	44	and	and	CC
18637	10972	45	have	have	VBP
18637	10972	46	been	be	VBN
18637	10972	47	equally	equally	RB
18637	10972	48	endorsed	endorse	VBN
18637	10972	49	by	by	IN
18637	10972	50	those	those	DT
18637	10972	51	judges	judge	NNS
18637	10972	52	most	most	RBS
18637	10972	53	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	10972	54	addressing	address	VBG
18637	10972	55	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10972	56	to	to	IN
18637	10972	57	the	the	DT
18637	10972	58	task	task	NN
18637	10972	59	of	of	IN
18637	10972	60	finding	find	VBG
18637	10972	61	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10972	62	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	10972	63	.	.	.
18637	10973	1	The	the	DT
18637	10973	2	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	10973	3	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	10973	4	by	by	IN
18637	10973	5	the	the	DT
18637	10973	6	concept	concept	NN
18637	10973	7	of	of	IN
18637	10973	8	political	political	JJ
18637	10973	9	questions	question	NNS
18637	10973	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	10973	11	not	not	RB
18637	10973	12	limit	limit	VB
18637	10973	13	in	in	IN
18637	10973	14	any	any	DT
18637	10973	15	significant	significant	JJ
18637	10973	16	way	way	NN
18637	10973	17	the	the	DT
18637	10973	18	power	power	NN
18637	10973	19	of	of	IN
18637	10973	20	the	the	DT
18637	10973	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10973	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	10973	23	to	to	TO
18637	10973	24	review	review	VB
18637	10973	25	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10973	26	,	,	,
18637	10973	27	but	but	CC
18637	10973	28	does	do	VBZ
18637	10973	29	remove	remove	VB
18637	10973	30	from	from	IN
18637	10973	31	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10973	32	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
18637	10973	33	vast	vast	JJ
18637	10973	34	areas	area	NNS
18637	10973	35	of	of	IN
18637	10973	36	executive	executive	JJ
18637	10973	37	action	action	NN
18637	10973	38	.	.	.
18637	10974	1	In	in	IN
18637	10974	2	general	general	JJ
18637	10974	3	,	,	,
18637	10974	4	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	10974	5	,	,	,
18637	10974	6	the	the	DT
18637	10974	7	extent	extent	NN
18637	10974	8	to	to	IN
18637	10974	9	and	and	CC
18637	10974	10	manner	manner	NN
18637	10974	11	in	in	IN
18637	10974	12	which	which	WDT
18637	10974	13	the	the	DT
18637	10974	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	10974	15	will	will	MD
18637	10974	16	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	10974	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10974	18	power	power	NN
18637	10974	19	to	to	TO
18637	10974	20	review	review	VB
18637	10974	21	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10974	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	10974	23	a	a	DT
18637	10974	24	matter	matter	NN
18637	10974	25	of	of	IN
18637	10974	26	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	10974	27	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	10974	28	.	.	.
18637	10975	1	ALLEGATIONS	allegation	NNS
18637	10975	2	OF	of	IN
18637	10975	3	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	10975	4	QUESTION	question	NN
18637	10975	5	The	the	DT
18637	10975	6	question	question	NN
18637	10975	7	of	of	IN
18637	10975	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10975	9	of	of	IN
18637	10975	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	10975	11	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10975	12	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10975	13	questions	question	NNS
18637	10975	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	10975	15	determined	determine	VBN
18637	10975	16	by	by	IN
18637	10975	17	the	the	DT
18637	10975	18	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	10975	19	made	make	VBN
18637	10975	20	by	by	IN
18637	10975	21	the	the	DT
18637	10975	22	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	10975	23	and	and	CC
18637	10975	24	not	not	RB
18637	10975	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	10975	26	the	the	DT
18637	10975	27	facts	fact	NNS
18637	10975	28	as	as	IN
18637	10975	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10975	30	may	may	MD
18637	10975	31	emerge	emerge	VB
18637	10975	32	or	or	CC
18637	10975	33	by	by	IN
18637	10975	34	a	a	DT
18637	10975	35	decision	decision	NN
18637	10975	36	of	of	IN
18637	10975	37	the	the	DT
18637	10975	38	merits	merit	NNS
18637	10975	39	.	.	.
18637	10976	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10976	2	293	293	CD
18637	10976	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10976	4	Plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
18637	10976	5	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	10976	6	to	to	TO
18637	10976	7	docket	docket	VB
18637	10976	8	such	such	JJ
18637	10976	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	10976	10	in	in	IN
18637	10976	11	the	the	DT
18637	10976	12	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10976	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	10976	14	must	must	MD
18637	10976	15	set	set	VB
18637	10976	16	forth	forth	RP
18637	10976	17	a	a	DT
18637	10976	18	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	10976	19	claim	claim	NN
18637	10976	20	under	under	IN
18637	10976	21	the	the	DT
18637	10976	22	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10976	23	,	,	,
18637	10976	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	10976	25	or	or	CC
18637	10976	26	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	10976	27	of	of	IN
18637	10976	28	the	the	DT
18637	10976	29	United	United	NNP
18637	10976	30	States	States	NNP
18637	10976	31	.	.	.
18637	10977	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10977	2	294	294	CD
18637	10977	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10977	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	10977	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	10977	6	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10977	7	arise	arise	VB
18637	10977	8	simply	simply	RB
18637	10977	9	because	because	IN
18637	10977	10	an	an	DT
18637	10977	11	averment	averment	NN
18637	10977	12	of	of	IN
18637	10977	13	a	a	DT
18637	10977	14	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10977	15	right	right	NN
18637	10977	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	10977	17	made	make	VBN
18637	10977	18	,	,	,
18637	10977	19	"	"	``
18637	10977	20	if	if	IN
18637	10977	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10977	22	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	10977	23	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	10977	24	that	that	IN
18637	10977	25	such	such	JJ
18637	10977	26	averment	averment	NN
18637	10977	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	10977	28	not	not	RB
18637	10977	29	real	real	JJ
18637	10977	30	and	and	CC
18637	10977	31	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	10977	32	,	,	,
18637	10977	33	but	but	CC
18637	10977	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	10977	35	without	without	IN
18637	10977	36	color	color	NN
18637	10977	37	of	of	IN
18637	10977	38	merit	merit	NN
18637	10977	39	.	.	.
18637	10978	1	"	"	``
18637	10978	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10978	3	295	295	CD
18637	10978	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10978	5	The	the	DT
18637	10978	6	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10978	7	question	question	NN
18637	10978	8	averred	aver	VBN
18637	10978	9	may	may	MD
18637	10978	10	be	be	VB
18637	10978	11	insubstantial	insubstantial	JJ
18637	10978	12	because	because	IN
18637	10978	13	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	10978	14	without	without	IN
18637	10978	15	merit	merit	NN
18637	10978	16	,	,	,
18637	10978	17	or	or	CC
18637	10978	18	because	because	IN
18637	10978	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10978	20	unsoundness	unsoundness	NN
18637	10978	21	so	so	RB
18637	10978	22	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	10978	23	results	result	VBZ
18637	10978	24	from	from	IN
18637	10978	25	previous	previous	JJ
18637	10978	26	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	10978	27	of	of	IN
18637	10978	28	the	the	DT
18637	10978	29	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10978	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10978	31	as	as	IN
18637	10978	32	to	to	TO
18637	10978	33	foreclose	foreclose	VB
18637	10978	34	the	the	DT
18637	10978	35	issue	issue	NN
18637	10978	36	and	and	CC
18637	10978	37	leaves	leave	VBZ
18637	10978	38	no	no	DT
18637	10978	39	room	room	NN
18637	10978	40	for	for	IN
18637	10978	41	the	the	DT
18637	10978	42	inference	inference	NN
18637	10978	43	that	that	IN
18637	10978	44	the	the	DT
18637	10978	45	questions	question	NNS
18637	10978	46	sought	seek	VBD
18637	10978	47	to	to	TO
18637	10978	48	be	be	VB
18637	10978	49	raised	raise	VBN
18637	10978	50	can	can	MD
18637	10978	51	be	be	VB
18637	10978	52	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	10978	53	of	of	IN
18637	10978	54	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10978	55	.	.	.
18637	10979	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10979	2	296	296	CD
18637	10979	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10979	4	In	in	IN
18637	10979	5	Gully	Gully	NNP
18637	10979	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10979	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10979	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10979	9	First	First	NNP
18637	10979	10	National	National	NNP
18637	10979	11	Bank[297	bank[297	CD
18637	10979	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10979	13	the	the	DT
18637	10979	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10979	15	reviewed	review	VBD
18637	10979	16	earlier	early	JJR
18637	10979	17	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	10979	18	and	and	CC
18637	10979	19	endeavored	endeavor	VBD
18637	10979	20	to	to	TO
18637	10979	21	restate	restate	VB
18637	10979	22	the	the	DT
18637	10979	23	rules	rule	NNS
18637	10979	24	for	for	IN
18637	10979	25	determining	determine	VBG
18637	10979	26	when	when	WRB
18637	10979	27	a	a	DT
18637	10979	28	case	case	NN
18637	10979	29	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	10979	30	.	.	.
18637	10980	1	First	first	RB
18637	10980	2	there	there	EX
18637	10980	3	must	must	MD
18637	10980	4	be	be	VB
18637	10980	5	a	a	DT
18637	10980	6	right	right	NN
18637	10980	7	or	or	CC
18637	10980	8	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	10980	9	created	create	VBN
18637	10980	10	by	by	IN
18637	10980	11	the	the	DT
18637	10980	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10980	13	,	,	,
18637	10980	14	laws	law	NNS
18637	10980	15	,	,	,
18637	10980	16	or	or	CC
18637	10980	17	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	10980	18	of	of	IN
18637	10980	19	the	the	DT
18637	10980	20	United	United	NNP
18637	10980	21	States	States	NNP
18637	10980	22	which	which	WDT
18637	10980	23	must	must	MD
18637	10980	24	be	be	VB
18637	10980	25	such	such	JJ
18637	10980	26	that	that	IN
18637	10980	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10980	28	will	will	MD
18637	10980	29	be	be	VB
18637	10980	30	supported	support	VBN
18637	10980	31	if	if	IN
18637	10980	32	the	the	DT
18637	10980	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10980	34	,	,	,
18637	10980	35	laws	law	NNS
18637	10980	36	,	,	,
18637	10980	37	or	or	CC
18637	10980	38	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	10980	39	are	be	VBP
18637	10980	40	given	give	VBN
18637	10980	41	one	one	CD
18637	10980	42	construction	construction	NN
18637	10980	43	,	,	,
18637	10980	44	or	or	CC
18637	10980	45	defeated	defeat	VBN
18637	10980	46	if	if	IN
18637	10980	47	given	give	VBN
18637	10980	48	another	another	DT
18637	10980	49	.	.	.
18637	10981	1	Second	second	JJ
18637	10981	2	,	,	,
18637	10981	3	a	a	DT
18637	10981	4	genuine	genuine	JJ
18637	10981	5	and	and	CC
18637	10981	6	present	present	JJ
18637	10981	7	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10981	8	as	as	IN
18637	10981	9	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	10981	10	from	from	IN
18637	10981	11	a	a	DT
18637	10981	12	possible	possible	JJ
18637	10981	13	or	or	CC
18637	10981	14	conjectural	conjectural	JJ
18637	10981	15	one	one	PRP
18637	10981	16	must	must	MD
18637	10981	17	exist	exist	VB
18637	10981	18	with	with	IN
18637	10981	19	reference	reference	NN
18637	10981	20	to	to	IN
18637	10981	21	the	the	DT
18637	10981	22	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10981	23	right	right	NN
18637	10981	24	.	.	.
18637	10982	1	Third	third	JJ
18637	10982	2	,	,	,
18637	10982	3	the	the	DT
18637	10982	4	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	10982	5	must	must	MD
18637	10982	6	be	be	VB
18637	10982	7	disclosed	disclose	VBN
18637	10982	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	10982	9	the	the	DT
18637	10982	10	face	face	NN
18637	10982	11	of	of	IN
18637	10982	12	the	the	DT
18637	10982	13	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	10982	14	unaided	unaide	VBN
18637	10982	15	by	by	IN
18637	10982	16	the	the	DT
18637	10982	17	answer	answer	NN
18637	10982	18	.	.	.
18637	10983	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10983	2	298	298	CD
18637	10983	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10983	4	CORPORATIONS	corporations	NN
18637	10983	5	CHARTERED	chartered	NN
18637	10983	6	BY	by	IN
18637	10983	7	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	10983	8	The	the	DT
18637	10983	9	earlier	early	JJR
18637	10983	10	hospitality	hospitality	NN
18637	10983	11	of	of	IN
18637	10983	12	the	the	DT
18637	10983	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10983	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	10983	15	to	to	IN
18637	10983	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	10983	17	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10983	18	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10983	19	questions	question	NNS
18637	10983	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	10983	21	also	also	RB
18637	10983	22	manifested	manifest	VBN
18637	10983	23	in	in	IN
18637	10983	24	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10983	25	by	by	IN
18637	10983	26	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	10983	27	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	10983	28	by	by	IN
18637	10983	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10983	30	.	.	.
18637	10984	1	Although	although	IN
18637	10984	2	in	in	IN
18637	10984	3	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	10984	4	of	of	IN
18637	10984	5	United	United	NNP
18637	10984	6	States	States	NNP
18637	10984	7	_	_	NNP
18637	10984	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	10984	9	_	_	NNP
18637	10984	10	Deveaux[299	Deveaux[299	NNP
18637	10984	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10984	12	the	the	DT
18637	10984	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10984	14	held	hold	VBD
18637	10984	15	that	that	IN
18637	10984	16	the	the	DT
18637	10984	17	first	first	JJ
18637	10984	18	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	10984	19	of	of	IN
18637	10984	20	the	the	DT
18637	10984	21	United	United	NNP
18637	10984	22	States	States	NNP
18637	10984	23	could	could	MD
18637	10984	24	not	not	RB
18637	10984	25	sue	sue	VB
18637	10984	26	in	in	IN
18637	10984	27	the	the	DT
18637	10984	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10984	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	10984	30	merely	merely	RB
18637	10984	31	because	because	IN
18637	10984	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10984	33	was	be	VBD
18637	10984	34	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	10984	35	by	by	IN
18637	10984	36	an	an	DT
18637	10984	37	act	act	NN
18637	10984	38	of	of	IN
18637	10984	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10984	40	,	,	,
18637	10984	41	the	the	DT
18637	10984	42	act	act	NN
18637	10984	43	incorporating	incorporate	VBG
18637	10984	44	the	the	DT
18637	10984	45	second	second	JJ
18637	10984	46	bank	bank	NN
18637	10984	47	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	10984	48	such	such	JJ
18637	10984	49	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10984	50	and	and	CC
18637	10984	51	this	this	DT
18637	10984	52	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	10984	53	was	be	VBD
18637	10984	54	not	not	RB
18637	10984	55	only	only	RB
18637	10984	56	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	10984	57	in	in	IN
18637	10984	58	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	10984	59	_	_	NNP
18637	10984	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	10984	61	_	_	NNP
18637	10984	62	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	10984	63	of	of	IN
18637	10984	64	United	United	NNP
18637	10984	65	States,[300	States,[300	NNP
18637	10984	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10984	67	but	but	CC
18637	10984	68	an	an	DT
18637	10984	69	act	act	NN
18637	10984	70	of	of	IN
18637	10984	71	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	10984	72	was	be	VBD
18637	10984	73	declared	declare	VBN
18637	10984	74	to	to	TO
18637	10984	75	be	be	VB
18637	10984	76	a	a	DT
18637	10984	77	law	law	NN
18637	10984	78	of	of	IN
18637	10984	79	the	the	DT
18637	10984	80	United	United	NNP
18637	10984	81	States	States	NNP
18637	10984	82	for	for	IN
18637	10984	83	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	10984	84	of	of	IN
18637	10984	85	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10984	86	in	in	IN
18637	10984	87	cases	case	NNS
18637	10984	88	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10984	89	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10984	90	questions	question	NNS
18637	10984	91	.	.	.
18637	10985	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	10985	2	,	,	,
18637	10985	3	the	the	DT
18637	10985	4	door	door	NN
18637	10985	5	was	be	VBD
18637	10985	6	opened	open	VBN
18637	10985	7	to	to	IN
18637	10985	8	other	other	JJ
18637	10985	9	federally	federally	RB
18637	10985	10	chartered	chartered	JJ
18637	10985	11	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	10985	12	to	to	TO
18637	10985	13	go	go	VB
18637	10985	14	into	into	IN
18637	10985	15	the	the	DT
18637	10985	16	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10985	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	10985	18	after	after	IN
18637	10985	19	the	the	DT
18637	10985	20	act	act	NN
18637	10985	21	of	of	IN
18637	10985	22	1875	1875	CD
18637	10985	23	vested	vested	JJ
18637	10985	24	original	original	JJ
18637	10985	25	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10985	26	generally	generally	RB
18637	10985	27	in	in	IN
18637	10985	28	the	the	DT
18637	10985	29	lower	low	JJR
18637	10985	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	10985	31	of	of	IN
18637	10985	32	such	such	JJ
18637	10985	33	questions	question	NNS
18637	10985	34	.	.	.
18637	10986	1	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	10986	2	,	,	,
18637	10986	3	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	10986	4	by	by	IN
18637	10986	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10986	6	,	,	,
18637	10986	7	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	10986	8	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	10986	9	,	,	,
18637	10986	10	quickly	quickly	RB
18637	10986	11	availed	avail	VBD
18637	10986	12	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10986	13	of	of	IN
18637	10986	14	this	this	DT
18637	10986	15	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	10986	16	,	,	,
18637	10986	17	and	and	CC
18637	10986	18	succeeded	succeed	VBD
18637	10986	19	in	in	IN
18637	10986	20	the	the	DT
18637	10986	21	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	10986	22	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	10986	23	Removal	Removal	NNP
18637	10986	24	Cases[301	Cases[301	NNP
18637	10986	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10986	26	in	in	IN
18637	10986	27	removing	remove	VBG
18637	10986	28	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10986	29	from	from	IN
18637	10986	30	the	the	DT
18637	10986	31	State	State	NNP
18637	10986	32	to	to	IN
18637	10986	33	the	the	DT
18637	10986	34	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10986	35	courts	court	NNS
18637	10986	36	in	in	IN
18637	10986	37	cases	case	NNS
18637	10986	38	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10986	39	no	no	DT
18637	10986	40	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10986	41	question	question	NN
18637	10986	42	solely	solely	RB
18637	10986	43	on	on	IN
18637	10986	44	the	the	DT
18637	10986	45	basis	basis	NN
18637	10986	46	of	of	IN
18637	10986	47	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10986	48	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	10986	49	.	.	.
18637	10987	1	The	the	DT
18637	10987	2	result	result	NN
18637	10987	3	of	of	IN
18637	10987	4	this	this	DT
18637	10987	5	and	and	CC
18637	10987	6	similar	similar	JJ
18637	10987	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	10987	8	was	be	VBD
18637	10987	9	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	10987	10	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10987	11	depriving	deprive	VBG
18637	10987	12	national	national	JJ
18637	10987	13	banks	bank	NNS
18637	10987	14	of	of	IN
18637	10987	15	the	the	DT
18637	10987	16	right	right	NN
18637	10987	17	to	to	TO
18637	10987	18	sue	sue	VB
18637	10987	19	in	in	IN
18637	10987	20	the	the	DT
18637	10987	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10987	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	10987	23	solely	solely	RB
18637	10987	24	on	on	IN
18637	10987	25	the	the	DT
18637	10987	26	basis	basis	NN
18637	10987	27	of	of	IN
18637	10987	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10987	29	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	10987	30	in	in	IN
18637	10987	31	1882,[302	1882,[302	CD
18637	10987	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10987	33	depriving	deprive	VBG
18637	10987	34	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	10987	35	holding	hold	VBG
18637	10987	36	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10987	37	charters	charter	NNS
18637	10987	38	of	of	IN
18637	10987	39	this	this	DT
18637	10987	40	right	right	NN
18637	10987	41	in	in	IN
18637	10987	42	1915,[303	1915,[303	CD
18637	10987	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10987	44	and	and	CC
18637	10987	45	finally	finally	RB
18637	10987	46	in	in	IN
18637	10987	47	1925	1925	CD
18637	10987	48	removing	remove	VBG
18637	10987	49	from	from	IN
18637	10987	50	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10987	51	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10987	52	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10987	53	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10987	54	questions	question	NNS
18637	10987	55	all	all	DT
18637	10987	56	suits	suit	NNS
18637	10987	57	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10987	58	by	by	IN
18637	10987	59	federally	federally	RB
18637	10987	60	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	10987	61	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	10987	62	,	,	,
18637	10987	63	solely	solely	RB
18637	10987	64	on	on	IN
18637	10987	65	the	the	DT
18637	10987	66	basis	basis	NN
18637	10987	67	of	of	IN
18637	10987	68	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10987	69	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	10987	70	,	,	,
18637	10987	71	except	except	IN
18637	10987	72	where	where	WRB
18637	10987	73	the	the	DT
18637	10987	74	United	United	NNP
18637	10987	75	States	States	NNP
18637	10987	76	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	10987	77	half	half	NN
18637	10987	78	of	of	IN
18637	10987	79	the	the	DT
18637	10987	80	stock	stock	NN
18637	10987	81	.	.	.
18637	10988	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10988	2	304	304	CD
18637	10988	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10988	4	REMOVAL	REMOVAL	NNP
18637	10988	5	FROM	from	IN
18637	10988	6	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	10988	7	COURTS	court	NNS
18637	10988	8	OF	of	IN
18637	10988	9	SUITS	suits	JJ
18637	10988	10	AGAINST	against	IN
18637	10988	11	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	10988	12	OFFICIALS	official	NNS
18637	10988	13	Of	of	IN
18637	10988	14	greater	great	JJR
18637	10988	15	significance	significance	NN
18637	10988	16	and	and	CC
18637	10988	17	of	of	IN
18637	10988	18	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	10988	19	importance	importance	NN
18637	10988	20	to	to	IN
18637	10988	21	the	the	DT
18637	10988	22	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	10988	23	of	of	IN
18637	10988	24	national	national	JJ
18637	10988	25	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	10988	26	are	be	VBP
18637	10988	27	those	those	DT
18637	10988	28	cases	case	NNS
18637	10988	29	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10988	30	State	state	NN
18637	10988	31	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	10988	32	of	of	IN
18637	10988	33	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10988	34	officials	official	NNS
18637	10988	35	for	for	IN
18637	10988	36	acts	act	NNS
18637	10988	37	committed	commit	VBN
18637	10988	38	under	under	IN
18637	10988	39	the	the	DT
18637	10988	40	color	color	NN
18637	10988	41	of	of	IN
18637	10988	42	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10988	43	authority	authority	NN
18637	10988	44	.	.	.
18637	10989	1	As	as	RB
18637	10989	2	early	early	RB
18637	10989	3	as	as	IN
18637	10989	4	1815	1815	CD
18637	10989	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10989	6	provided	provide	VBD
18637	10989	7	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	10989	8	for	for	IN
18637	10989	9	the	the	DT
18637	10989	10	removal	removal	NN
18637	10989	11	of	of	IN
18637	10989	12	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	10989	13	against	against	IN
18637	10989	14	customs	custom	NNS
18637	10989	15	officials	official	NNS
18637	10989	16	for	for	IN
18637	10989	17	acts	act	NNS
18637	10989	18	done	do	VBN
18637	10989	19	or	or	CC
18637	10989	20	omitted	omit	VBN
18637	10989	21	as	as	IN
18637	10989	22	an	an	DT
18637	10989	23	officer	officer	NN
18637	10989	24	or	or	CC
18637	10989	25	under	under	IN
18637	10989	26	color	color	NN
18637	10989	27	of	of	IN
18637	10989	28	an	an	DT
18637	10989	29	act	act	NN
18637	10989	30	of	of	IN
18637	10989	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10989	32	,	,	,
18637	10989	33	except	except	IN
18637	10989	34	for	for	IN
18637	10989	35	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	10989	36	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10989	37	corporal	corporal	JJ
18637	10989	38	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	10989	39	.	.	.
18637	10990	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10990	2	305	305	CD
18637	10990	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10990	4	In	in	IN
18637	10990	5	1833	1833	CD
18637	10990	6	,	,	,
18637	10990	7	in	in	IN
18637	10990	8	partial	partial	JJ
18637	10990	9	answer	answer	NN
18637	10990	10	to	to	IN
18637	10990	11	South	South	NNP
18637	10990	12	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	10990	13	's	's	POS
18637	10990	14	Nullification	Nullification	NNP
18637	10990	15	Proclamation	Proclamation	NNP
18637	10990	16	,	,	,
18637	10990	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10990	18	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	10990	19	the	the	DT
18637	10990	20	so	so	RB
18637	10990	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	10990	22	called	call	VBN
18637	10990	23	Force	Force	NNP
18637	10990	24	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10990	25	providing	provide	VBG
18637	10990	26	for	for	IN
18637	10990	27	removal	removal	NN
18637	10990	28	from	from	IN
18637	10990	29	State	State	NNP
18637	10990	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	10990	31	of	of	IN
18637	10990	32	all	all	DT
18637	10990	33	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	10990	34	against	against	IN
18637	10990	35	any	any	DT
18637	10990	36	officer	officer	NN
18637	10990	37	of	of	IN
18637	10990	38	the	the	DT
18637	10990	39	United	United	NNP
18637	10990	40	States	States	NNP
18637	10990	41	or	or	CC
18637	10990	42	under	under	IN
18637	10990	43	color	color	NN
18637	10990	44	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	10990	45	.	.	.
18637	10991	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10991	2	306	306	CD
18637	10991	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10991	4	As	as	IN
18637	10991	5	a	a	DT
18637	10991	6	part	part	NN
18637	10991	7	of	of	IN
18637	10991	8	the	the	DT
18637	10991	9	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	10991	10	War	War	NNP
18637	10991	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10991	12	and	and	CC
18637	10991	13	limited	limit	VBN
18637	10991	14	to	to	IN
18637	10991	15	the	the	DT
18637	10991	16	war	war	NN
18637	10991	17	period	period	NN
18637	10991	18	,	,	,
18637	10991	19	an	an	DT
18637	10991	20	act	act	NN
18637	10991	21	in	in	IN
18637	10991	22	1863	1863	CD
18637	10991	23	provided	provide	VBN
18637	10991	24	for	for	IN
18637	10991	25	removal	removal	NN
18637	10991	26	from	from	IN
18637	10991	27	State	State	NNP
18637	10991	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	10991	29	of	of	IN
18637	10991	30	cases	case	NNS
18637	10991	31	brought	bring	VBN
18637	10991	32	against	against	IN
18637	10991	33	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10991	34	officials	official	NNS
18637	10991	35	for	for	IN
18637	10991	36	acts	act	NNS
18637	10991	37	committed	commit	VBN
18637	10991	38	during	during	IN
18637	10991	39	the	the	DT
18637	10991	40	war	war	NN
18637	10991	41	and	and	CC
18637	10991	42	justified	justify	VBN
18637	10991	43	under	under	IN
18637	10991	44	the	the	DT
18637	10991	45	authority	authority	NN
18637	10991	46	of	of	IN
18637	10991	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10991	48	and	and	CC
18637	10991	49	the	the	DT
18637	10991	50	President	President	NNP
18637	10991	51	.	.	.
18637	10992	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10992	2	307	307	CD
18637	10992	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10992	4	The	the	DT
18637	10992	5	act	act	NN
18637	10992	6	of	of	IN
18637	10992	7	1833	1833	CD
18637	10992	8	,	,	,
18637	10992	9	with	with	IN
18637	10992	10	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	10992	11	,	,	,
18637	10992	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	10992	13	been	be	VBN
18637	10992	14	kept	keep	VBN
18637	10992	15	in	in	IN
18637	10992	16	force	force	NN
18637	10992	17	.	.	.
18637	10993	1	Since	since	IN
18637	10993	2	1948	1948	CD
18637	10993	3	the	the	DT
18637	10993	4	United	United	NNP
18637	10993	5	States	States	NNP
18637	10993	6	Code	Code	NNP
18637	10993	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	10993	8	provided	provide	VBN
18637	10993	9	for	for	IN
18637	10993	10	the	the	DT
18637	10993	11	removal	removal	NN
18637	10993	12	to	to	IN
18637	10993	13	a	a	DT
18637	10993	14	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10993	15	district	district	NN
18637	10993	16	court	court	NN
18637	10993	17	of	of	IN
18637	10993	18	civil	civil	JJ
18637	10993	19	actions	action	NNS
18637	10993	20	or	or	CC
18637	10993	21	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10993	22	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	10993	23	in	in	IN
18637	10993	24	State	state	NN
18637	10993	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	10993	26	against	against	IN
18637	10993	27	"	"	``
18637	10993	28	any	any	DT
18637	10993	29	officer	officer	NN
18637	10993	30	of	of	IN
18637	10993	31	the	the	DT
18637	10993	32	United	United	NNP
18637	10993	33	States	States	NNP
18637	10993	34	or	or	CC
18637	10993	35	any	any	DT
18637	10993	36	agency	agency	NN
18637	10993	37	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	10993	38	,	,	,
18637	10993	39	or	or	CC
18637	10993	40	person	person	NN
18637	10993	41	acting	act	VBG
18637	10993	42	under	under	IN
18637	10993	43	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10993	44	,	,	,
18637	10993	45	for	for	IN
18637	10993	46	any	any	DT
18637	10993	47	act	act	NN
18637	10993	48	under	under	IN
18637	10993	49	color	color	NN
18637	10993	50	of	of	IN
18637	10993	51	such	such	JJ
18637	10993	52	office	office	NN
18637	10993	53	or	or	CC
18637	10993	54	on	on	IN
18637	10993	55	account	account	NN
18637	10993	56	of	of	IN
18637	10993	57	any	any	DT
18637	10993	58	right	right	JJ
18637	10993	59	,	,	,
18637	10993	60	title	title	NN
18637	10993	61	or	or	CC
18637	10993	62	authority	authority	NN
18637	10993	63	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	10993	64	under	under	IN
18637	10993	65	any	any	DT
18637	10993	66	Act	Act	NNP
18637	10993	67	of	of	IN
18637	10993	68	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10993	69	for	for	IN
18637	10993	70	the	the	DT
18637	10993	71	apprehension	apprehension	NN
18637	10993	72	or	or	CC
18637	10993	73	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	10993	74	of	of	IN
18637	10993	75	criminals	criminal	NNS
18637	10993	76	or	or	CC
18637	10993	77	the	the	DT
18637	10993	78	collection	collection	NN
18637	10993	79	of	of	IN
18637	10993	80	the	the	DT
18637	10993	81	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	10993	82	.	.	.
18637	10994	1	"	"	``
18637	10994	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10994	3	308	308	CD
18637	10994	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10994	5	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	10994	6	_	_	NNP
18637	10994	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	10994	8	_	_	NNP
18637	10994	9	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	10994	10	The	the	DT
18637	10994	11	validity	validity	NN
18637	10994	12	of	of	IN
18637	10994	13	the	the	DT
18637	10994	14	act	act	NN
18637	10994	15	of	of	IN
18637	10994	16	1833	1833	CD
18637	10994	17	as	as	IN
18637	10994	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10994	19	was	be	VBD
18637	10994	20	carried	carry	VBN
18637	10994	21	over	over	RP
18637	10994	22	into	into	IN
18637	10994	23	the	the	DT
18637	10994	24	Revised	Revised	NNP
18637	10994	25	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	10994	26	,	,	,
18637	10994	27	§	§	NNP
18637	10994	28	643	643	CD
18637	10994	29	,	,	,
18637	10994	30	was	be	VBD
18637	10994	31	contested	contest	VBN
18637	10994	32	in	in	IN
18637	10994	33	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	10994	34	_	_	NNP
18637	10994	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	10994	36	_	_	NNP
18637	10994	37	Davis,[309	Davis,[309	NNP
18637	10994	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10994	39	which	which	WDT
18637	10994	40	involved	involve	VBD
18637	10994	41	the	the	DT
18637	10994	42	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	10994	43	of	of	IN
18637	10994	44	a	a	DT
18637	10994	45	State	State	NNP
18637	10994	46	to	to	TO
18637	10994	47	prosecute	prosecute	VB
18637	10994	48	a	a	DT
18637	10994	49	deputy	deputy	JJ
18637	10994	50	collector	collector	NN
18637	10994	51	of	of	IN
18637	10994	52	internal	internal	JJ
18637	10994	53	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	10994	54	who	who	WP
18637	10994	55	had	have	VBD
18637	10994	56	killed	kill	VBN
18637	10994	57	a	a	DT
18637	10994	58	man	man	NN
18637	10994	59	while	while	IN
18637	10994	60	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	10994	61	to	to	TO
18637	10994	62	seize	seize	VB
18637	10994	63	an	an	DT
18637	10994	64	illicit	illicit	NN
18637	10994	65	distilling	distil	VBG
18637	10994	66	apparatus	apparatus	NN
18637	10994	67	.	.	.
18637	10995	1	In	in	IN
18637	10995	2	an	an	DT
18637	10995	3	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	10995	4	in	in	IN
18637	10995	5	the	the	DT
18637	10995	6	tradition	tradition	NN
18637	10995	7	of	of	IN
18637	10995	8	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	10995	9	_	_	NNP
18637	10995	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	10995	11	_	_	NNP
18637	10995	12	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	10995	13	's	's	POS
18637	10995	14	Lessee[310	Lessee[310	NNP
18637	10995	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10995	16	and	and	CC
18637	10995	17	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	10995	18	_	_	NNP
18637	10995	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	10995	20	_	_	NNP
18637	10995	21	Virginia,[311	Virginia,[311	NNP
18637	10995	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10995	23	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	10995	24	Strong	Strong	NNP
18637	10995	25	emphasized	emphasize	VBD
18637	10995	26	the	the	DT
18637	10995	27	power	power	NN
18637	10995	28	of	of	IN
18637	10995	29	the	the	DT
18637	10995	30	National	National	NNP
18637	10995	31	Government	Government	NNP
18637	10995	32	to	to	TO
18637	10995	33	protect	protect	VB
18637	10995	34	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10995	35	in	in	IN
18637	10995	36	the	the	DT
18637	10995	37	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10995	38	of	of	IN
18637	10995	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10995	40	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10995	41	powers	power	NNS
18637	10995	42	,	,	,
18637	10995	43	the	the	DT
18637	10995	44	inability	inability	NN
18637	10995	45	of	of	IN
18637	10995	46	a	a	DT
18637	10995	47	State	State	NNP
18637	10995	48	to	to	TO
18637	10995	49	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	10995	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10995	51	from	from	IN
18637	10995	52	the	the	DT
18637	10995	53	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	10995	54	of	of	IN
18637	10995	55	any	any	DT
18637	10995	56	authority	authority	NN
18637	10995	57	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	10995	58	by	by	IN
18637	10995	59	the	the	DT
18637	10995	60	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10995	61	,	,	,
18637	10995	62	and	and	CC
18637	10995	63	the	the	DT
18637	10995	64	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	10995	65	nature	nature	NN
18637	10995	66	of	of	IN
18637	10995	67	the	the	DT
18637	10995	68	term	term	NN
18637	10995	69	"	"	``
18637	10995	70	cases	case	NNS
18637	10995	71	in	in	IN
18637	10995	72	law	law	NN
18637	10995	73	and	and	CC
18637	10995	74	equity	equity	NN
18637	10995	75	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10995	76	under	under	IN
18637	10995	77	the	the	DT
18637	10995	78	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10995	79	,	,	,
18637	10995	80	the	the	DT
18637	10995	81	laws	law	NNS
18637	10995	82	of	of	IN
18637	10995	83	the	the	DT
18637	10995	84	United	United	NNP
18637	10995	85	States	States	NNP
18637	10995	86	,	,	,
18637	10995	87	and	and	CC
18637	10995	88	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	10995	89	*	*	NFP
18637	10995	90	*	*	NFP
18637	10995	91	*	*	NFP
18637	10995	92	"	"	''
18637	10995	93	which	which	WDT
18637	10995	94	was	be	VBD
18637	10995	95	held	hold	VBN
18637	10995	96	to	to	TO
18637	10995	97	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	10995	98	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	10995	99	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	10995	100	as	as	RB
18637	10995	101	well	well	RB
18637	10995	102	as	as	IN
18637	10995	103	civil	civil	JJ
18637	10995	104	actions	action	NNS
18637	10995	105	.	.	.
18637	10996	1	Then	then	RB
18637	10996	2	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	10996	3	of	of	IN
18637	10996	4	a	a	DT
18637	10996	5	case	case	NN
18637	10996	6	involving	involve	VBG
18637	10996	7	federal	federal	JJ
18637	10996	8	questions	question	NNS
18637	10996	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10996	10	said	say	VBD
18637	10996	11	:	:	:
18637	10996	12	"	"	``
18637	10996	13	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10996	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	10996	15	not	not	RB
18637	10996	16	merely	merely	RB
18637	10996	17	one	one	CD
18637	10996	18	where	where	WRB
18637	10996	19	a	a	DT
18637	10996	20	party	party	NN
18637	10996	21	comes	come	VBZ
18637	10996	22	into	into	IN
18637	10996	23	court	court	NN
18637	10996	24	to	to	TO
18637	10996	25	demand	demand	VB
18637	10996	26	something	something	NN
18637	10996	27	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	10996	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	10996	29	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10996	30	by	by	IN
18637	10996	31	the	the	DT
18637	10996	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10996	33	or	or	CC
18637	10996	34	by	by	IN
18637	10996	35	a	a	DT
18637	10996	36	law	law	NN
18637	10996	37	or	or	CC
18637	10996	38	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	10996	39	.	.	.
18637	10997	1	A	a	DT
18637	10997	2	case	case	NN
18637	10997	3	consists	consist	VBZ
18637	10997	4	of	of	IN
18637	10997	5	the	the	DT
18637	10997	6	right	right	NN
18637	10997	7	of	of	IN
18637	10997	8	one	one	CD
18637	10997	9	party	party	NN
18637	10997	10	as	as	RB
18637	10997	11	well	well	RB
18637	10997	12	as	as	IN
18637	10997	13	the	the	DT
18637	10997	14	other	other	JJ
18637	10997	15	,	,	,
18637	10997	16	and	and	CC
18637	10997	17	may	may	MD
18637	10997	18	truly	truly	RB
18637	10997	19	be	be	VB
18637	10997	20	said	say	VBN
18637	10997	21	to	to	TO
18637	10997	22	arise	arise	VB
18637	10997	23	under	under	IN
18637	10997	24	the	the	DT
18637	10997	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	10997	26	or	or	CC
18637	10997	27	a	a	DT
18637	10997	28	law	law	NN
18637	10997	29	or	or	CC
18637	10997	30	a	a	DT
18637	10997	31	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	10997	32	of	of	IN
18637	10997	33	the	the	DT
18637	10997	34	United	United	NNP
18637	10997	35	States	States	NNP
18637	10997	36	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	10997	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10997	38	correct	correct	JJ
18637	10997	39	decision	decision	NN
18637	10997	40	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	10997	41	upon	upon	IN
18637	10997	42	the	the	DT
18637	10997	43	construction	construction	NN
18637	10997	44	of	of	IN
18637	10997	45	either	either	DT
18637	10997	46	.	.	.
18637	10998	1	Cases	case	NNS
18637	10998	2	arising	arise	VBG
18637	10998	3	under	under	IN
18637	10998	4	the	the	DT
18637	10998	5	laws	law	NNS
18637	10998	6	of	of	IN
18637	10998	7	the	the	DT
18637	10998	8	United	United	NNP
18637	10998	9	States	States	NNP
18637	10998	10	are	be	VBP
18637	10998	11	such	such	JJ
18637	10998	12	as	as	IN
18637	10998	13	grow	grow	VB
18637	10998	14	out	out	IN
18637	10998	15	of	of	IN
18637	10998	16	the	the	DT
18637	10998	17	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	10998	18	of	of	IN
18637	10998	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	10998	20	,	,	,
18637	10998	21	whether	whether	IN
18637	10998	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10998	23	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	10998	24	the	the	DT
18637	10998	25	right	right	NN
18637	10998	26	or	or	CC
18637	10998	27	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	10998	28	,	,	,
18637	10998	29	or	or	CC
18637	10998	30	claim	claim	NN
18637	10998	31	or	or	CC
18637	10998	32	protection	protection	NN
18637	10998	33	,	,	,
18637	10998	34	or	or	CC
18637	10998	35	defense	defense	NN
18637	10998	36	of	of	IN
18637	10998	37	the	the	DT
18637	10998	38	party	party	NN
18637	10998	39	,	,	,
18637	10998	40	in	in	IN
18637	10998	41	whole	whole	NN
18637	10998	42	or	or	CC
18637	10998	43	in	in	IN
18637	10998	44	part	part	NN
18637	10998	45	,	,	,
18637	10998	46	by	by	IN
18637	10998	47	whom	whom	WP
18637	10998	48	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	10998	49	are	be	VBP
18637	10998	50	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	10998	51	.	.	.
18637	10999	1	"	"	``
18637	10999	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	10999	3	312	312	CD
18637	10999	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	10999	5	SUPREME	SUPREME	NNP
18637	10999	6	COURT	COURT	NNP
18637	10999	7	REVIEW	REVIEW	NNP
18637	10999	8	OF	of	IN
18637	10999	9	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	10999	10	COURT	COURT	NNP
18637	10999	11	DECISIONS	decisions	NN
18637	10999	12	In	in	IN
18637	10999	13	addition	addition	NN
18637	10999	14	to	to	IN
18637	10999	15	the	the	DT
18637	10999	16	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	10999	17	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10999	18	presented	present	VBN
18637	10999	19	earlier	early	RBR
18637	10999	20	by	by	IN
18637	10999	21	§	§	NNP
18637	10999	22	25	25	CD
18637	10999	23	of	of	IN
18637	10999	24	the	the	DT
18637	10999	25	act	act	NN
18637	10999	26	of	of	IN
18637	10999	27	1789	1789	CD
18637	10999	28	,	,	,
18637	10999	29	which	which	WDT
18637	10999	30	was	be	VBD
18637	10999	31	superseded	supersede	VBN
18637	10999	32	in	in	IN
18637	10999	33	1934	1934	CD
18637	10999	34	when	when	WRB
18637	10999	35	the	the	DT
18637	10999	36	"	"	``
18637	10999	37	Writ	Writ	NNP
18637	10999	38	of	of	IN
18637	10999	39	error	error	NN
18637	10999	40	"	"	''
18637	10999	41	was	be	VBD
18637	10999	42	replaced	replace	VBN
18637	10999	43	by	by	IN
18637	10999	44	"	"	``
18637	10999	45	Appeal	appeal	NN
18637	10999	46	,	,	,
18637	10999	47	"	"	''
18637	10999	48	issues	issue	NNS
18637	10999	49	have	have	VBP
18637	10999	50	continued	continue	VBN
18637	10999	51	to	to	TO
18637	10999	52	arise	arise	VB
18637	10999	53	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	10999	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	10999	55	application	application	NN
18637	10999	56	which	which	WDT
18637	10999	57	go	go	VBP
18637	10999	58	directly	directly	RB
18637	10999	59	to	to	IN
18637	10999	60	the	the	DT
18637	10999	61	nature	nature	NN
18637	10999	62	and	and	CC
18637	10999	63	extent	extent	NN
18637	10999	64	of	of	IN
18637	10999	65	the	the	DT
18637	10999	66	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	10999	67	Court	Court	NNP
18637	10999	68	's	's	POS
18637	10999	69	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	10999	70	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	10999	71	.	.	.
18637	11000	1	These	these	DT
18637	11000	2	have	have	VBP
18637	11000	3	to	to	TO
18637	11000	4	do	do	VB
18637	11000	5	with	with	IN
18637	11000	6	such	such	JJ
18637	11000	7	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11000	8	as	as	IN
18637	11000	9	the	the	DT
18637	11000	10	existence	existence	NN
18637	11000	11	of	of	IN
18637	11000	12	a	a	DT
18637	11000	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11000	14	question	question	NN
18637	11000	15	,	,	,
18637	11000	16	exhaustion	exhaustion	NN
18637	11000	17	of	of	IN
18637	11000	18	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	11000	19	in	in	IN
18637	11000	20	State	State	NNP
18637	11000	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	11000	22	,	,	,
18637	11000	23	and	and	CC
18637	11000	24	review	review	NN
18637	11000	25	of	of	IN
18637	11000	26	findings	finding	NNS
18637	11000	27	of	of	IN
18637	11000	28	fact	fact	NN
18637	11000	29	by	by	IN
18637	11000	30	State	state	NN
18637	11000	31	courts	court	NNS
18637	11000	32	.	.	.
18637	11001	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	11001	2	a	a	DT
18637	11001	3	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11001	4	question	question	NN
18637	11001	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	11001	6	been	be	VBN
18637	11001	7	adequately	adequately	RB
18637	11001	8	presented	present	VBN
18637	11001	9	to	to	IN
18637	11001	10	and	and	CC
18637	11001	11	decided	decide	VBN
18637	11001	12	by	by	IN
18637	11001	13	a	a	DT
18637	11001	14	State	State	NNP
18637	11001	15	court	court	NN
18637	11001	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	11001	17	been	be	VBN
18637	11001	18	held	hold	VBN
18637	11001	19	to	to	TO
18637	11001	20	be	be	VB
18637	11001	21	in	in	IN
18637	11001	22	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11001	23	a	a	DT
18637	11001	24	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11001	25	question	question	NN
18637	11001	26	,	,	,
18637	11001	27	to	to	TO
18637	11001	28	be	be	VB
18637	11001	29	decided	decide	VBN
18637	11001	30	by	by	IN
18637	11001	31	the	the	DT
18637	11001	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11001	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11001	34	on	on	IN
18637	11001	35	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	11001	36	.	.	.
18637	11002	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11002	2	313	313	CD
18637	11002	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11002	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	11002	5	a	a	DT
18637	11002	6	contention	contention	NN
18637	11002	7	that	that	IN
18637	11002	8	a	a	DT
18637	11002	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	11002	10	of	of	IN
18637	11002	11	a	a	DT
18637	11002	12	State	State	NNP
18637	11002	13	court	court	NN
18637	11002	14	disregarded	disregard	VBD
18637	11002	15	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	11002	16	of	of	IN
18637	11002	17	a	a	DT
18637	11002	18	United	United	NNP
18637	11002	19	States	States	NNP
18637	11002	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11002	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	11002	22	been	be	VBN
18637	11002	23	held	hold	VBN
18637	11002	24	to	to	TO
18637	11002	25	bring	bring	VB
18637	11002	26	a	a	DT
18637	11002	27	case	case	NN
18637	11002	28	within	within	IN
18637	11002	29	the	the	DT
18637	11002	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11002	31	's	's	POS
18637	11002	32	jurisdiction;[314	jurisdiction;[314	CD
18637	11002	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11002	34	also	also	RB
18637	11002	35	a	a	DT
18637	11002	36	decision	decision	NN
18637	11002	37	by	by	IN
18637	11002	38	a	a	DT
18637	11002	39	State	State	NNP
18637	11002	40	court	court	NN
18637	11002	41	which	which	WDT
18637	11002	42	was	be	VBD
18637	11002	43	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	11002	44	to	to	IN
18637	11002	45	an	an	DT
18637	11002	46	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	11002	47	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11002	48	right	right	NN
18637	11002	49	although	although	IN
18637	11002	50	,	,	,
18637	11002	51	as	as	IN
18637	11002	52	the	the	DT
18637	11002	53	record	record	NN
18637	11002	54	of	of	IN
18637	11002	55	the	the	DT
18637	11002	56	case	case	NN
18637	11002	57	showed	show	VBD
18637	11002	58	,	,	,
18637	11002	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11002	60	might	may	MD
18637	11002	61	have	have	VB
18637	11002	62	been	be	VBN
18637	11002	63	based	base	VBN
18637	11002	64	upon	upon	IN
18637	11002	65	an	an	DT
18637	11002	66	independent	independent	JJ
18637	11002	67	and	and	CC
18637	11002	68	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	11002	69	nonfederal	nonfederal	JJ
18637	11002	70	ground	ground	NN
18637	11002	71	.	.	.
18637	11003	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11003	2	315	315	CD
18637	11003	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11003	4	This	this	DT
18637	11003	5	latter	latter	JJ
18637	11003	6	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	11003	7	,	,	,
18637	11003	8	however	however	RB
18637	11003	9	,	,	,
18637	11003	10	was	be	VBD
18637	11003	11	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	11003	12	during	during	IN
18637	11003	13	the	the	DT
18637	11003	14	same	same	JJ
18637	11003	15	term	term	NN
18637	11003	16	of	of	IN
18637	11003	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11003	18	in	in	IN
18637	11003	19	a	a	DT
18637	11003	20	case	case	NN
18637	11003	21	which	which	WDT
18637	11003	22	held	hold	VBD
18637	11003	23	that	that	IN
18637	11003	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11003	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	11003	26	essential	essential	JJ
18637	11003	27	to	to	IN
18637	11003	28	the	the	DT
18637	11003	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11003	30	of	of	IN
18637	11003	31	the	the	DT
18637	11003	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11003	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11003	34	,	,	,
18637	11003	35	in	in	IN
18637	11003	36	reviewing	review	VBG
18637	11003	37	a	a	DT
18637	11003	38	decision	decision	NN
18637	11003	39	of	of	IN
18637	11003	40	a	a	DT
18637	11003	41	State	State	NNP
18637	11003	42	court	court	NN
18637	11003	43	that	that	IN
18637	11003	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11003	45	must	must	MD
18637	11003	46	appear	appear	VB
18637	11003	47	affirmatively	affirmatively	RB
18637	11003	48	from	from	IN
18637	11003	49	the	the	DT
18637	11003	50	record	record	NN
18637	11003	51	,	,	,
18637	11003	52	not	not	RB
18637	11003	53	only	only	RB
18637	11003	54	that	that	IN
18637	11003	55	a	a	DT
18637	11003	56	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11003	57	question	question	NN
18637	11003	58	was	be	VBD
18637	11003	59	presented	present	VBN
18637	11003	60	for	for	IN
18637	11003	61	determination	determination	NN
18637	11003	62	,	,	,
18637	11003	63	but	but	CC
18637	11003	64	that	that	IN
18637	11003	65	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11003	66	decision	decision	NN
18637	11003	67	was	be	VBD
18637	11003	68	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11003	69	to	to	IN
18637	11003	70	the	the	DT
18637	11003	71	determination	determination	NN
18637	11003	72	of	of	IN
18637	11003	73	the	the	DT
18637	11003	74	cause	cause	NN
18637	11003	75	;	;	:
18637	11003	76	that	that	IN
18637	11003	77	the	the	DT
18637	11003	78	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11003	79	question	question	NN
18637	11003	80	was	be	VBD
18637	11003	81	actually	actually	RB
18637	11003	82	decided	decide	VBN
18637	11003	83	,	,	,
18637	11003	84	or	or	CC
18637	11003	85	that	that	IN
18637	11003	86	the	the	DT
18637	11003	87	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11003	88	could	could	MD
18637	11003	89	not	not	RB
18637	11003	90	have	have	VB
18637	11003	91	been	be	VBN
18637	11003	92	given	give	VBN
18637	11003	93	without	without	IN
18637	11003	94	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	11003	95	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11003	96	.	.	.
18637	11004	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11004	2	316	316	CD
18637	11004	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11004	4	These	these	DT
18637	11004	5	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11004	6	all	all	DT
18637	11004	7	flow	flow	VBP
18637	11004	8	from	from	IN
18637	11004	9	the	the	DT
18637	11004	10	broader	broad	JJR
18637	11004	11	principle	principle	NN
18637	11004	12	that	that	IN
18637	11004	13	if	if	IN
18637	11004	14	the	the	DT
18637	11004	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	11004	16	and	and	CC
18637	11004	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11004	18	of	of	IN
18637	11004	19	the	the	DT
18637	11004	20	United	United	NNP
18637	11004	21	States	States	NNP
18637	11004	22	are	be	VBP
18637	11004	23	to	to	TO
18637	11004	24	be	be	VB
18637	11004	25	observed	observe	VBN
18637	11004	26	,	,	,
18637	11004	27	the	the	DT
18637	11004	28	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11004	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11004	30	can	can	MD
18637	11004	31	not	not	RB
18637	11004	32	accept	accept	VB
18637	11004	33	as	as	IN
18637	11004	34	final	final	JJ
18637	11004	35	the	the	DT
18637	11004	36	decision	decision	NN
18637	11004	37	of	of	IN
18637	11004	38	a	a	DT
18637	11004	39	State	State	NNP
18637	11004	40	court	court	NN
18637	11004	41	on	on	IN
18637	11004	42	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11004	43	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	11004	44	to	to	TO
18637	11004	45	give	give	VB
18637	11004	46	rise	rise	NN
18637	11004	47	to	to	IN
18637	11004	48	an	an	DT
18637	11004	49	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	11004	50	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11004	51	right	right	NN
18637	11004	52	.	.	.
18637	11005	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11005	2	317	317	CD
18637	11005	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11005	4	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	11005	5	,	,	,
18637	11005	6	the	the	DT
18637	11005	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11005	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11005	9	will	will	MD
18637	11005	10	review	review	VB
18637	11005	11	the	the	DT
18637	11005	12	findings	finding	NNS
18637	11005	13	of	of	IN
18637	11005	14	fact	fact	NN
18637	11005	15	by	by	IN
18637	11005	16	a	a	DT
18637	11005	17	State	State	NNP
18637	11005	18	court	court	NN
18637	11005	19	where	where	WRB
18637	11005	20	a	a	DT
18637	11005	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11005	22	right	right	NN
18637	11005	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	11005	24	been	be	VBN
18637	11005	25	denied	deny	VBN
18637	11005	26	by	by	IN
18637	11005	27	a	a	DT
18637	11005	28	finding	finding	NN
18637	11005	29	shown	show	VBN
18637	11005	30	by	by	IN
18637	11005	31	the	the	DT
18637	11005	32	record	record	NN
18637	11005	33	to	to	TO
18637	11005	34	be	be	VB
18637	11005	35	without	without	IN
18637	11005	36	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	11005	37	to	to	TO
18637	11005	38	support	support	VB
18637	11005	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11005	40	,	,	,
18637	11005	41	and	and	CC
18637	11005	42	where	where	WRB
18637	11005	43	a	a	DT
18637	11005	44	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	11005	45	of	of	IN
18637	11005	46	law	law	NN
18637	11005	47	as	as	IN
18637	11005	48	to	to	IN
18637	11005	49	a	a	DT
18637	11005	50	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11005	51	right	right	NN
18637	11005	52	and	and	CC
18637	11005	53	findings	finding	NNS
18637	11005	54	of	of	IN
18637	11005	55	facts	fact	NNS
18637	11005	56	are	be	VBP
18637	11005	57	so	so	RB
18637	11005	58	intermingled	intermingled	JJ
18637	11005	59	as	as	IN
18637	11005	60	to	to	TO
18637	11005	61	make	make	VB
18637	11005	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11005	63	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11005	64	to	to	TO
18637	11005	65	analyze	analyze	VB
18637	11005	66	the	the	DT
18637	11005	67	facts	fact	NNS
18637	11005	68	in	in	IN
18637	11005	69	order	order	NN
18637	11005	70	to	to	TO
18637	11005	71	pass	pass	VB
18637	11005	72	upon	upon	IN
18637	11005	73	the	the	DT
18637	11005	74	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11005	75	question	question	NN
18637	11005	76	.	.	.
18637	11006	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11006	2	318	318	CD
18637	11006	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11006	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11006	5	should	should	MD
18637	11006	6	be	be	VB
18637	11006	7	noted	note	VBN
18637	11006	8	,	,	,
18637	11006	9	too	too	RB
18637	11006	10	,	,	,
18637	11006	11	that	that	IN
18637	11006	12	barring	bar	VBG
18637	11006	13	exceptional	exceptional	JJ
18637	11006	14	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	11006	15	such	such	JJ
18637	11006	16	as	as	IN
18637	11006	17	those	those	DT
18637	11006	18	in	in	IN
18637	11006	19	Gilchrist	Gilchrist	NNP
18637	11006	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11006	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	11006	22	_	_	NNP
18637	11006	23	Interborough	Interborough	NNP
18637	11006	24	Rapid	Rapid	NNP
18637	11006	25	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	11006	26	Co	Co	NNP
18637	11006	27	.	.	.
18637	11006	28	,[319	,[319	NFP
18637	11006	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11006	30	which	which	WDT
18637	11006	31	involved	involve	VBD
18637	11006	32	intricate	intricate	JJ
18637	11006	33	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	11006	34	between	between	IN
18637	11006	35	the	the	DT
18637	11006	36	City	City	NNP
18637	11006	37	of	of	IN
18637	11006	38	New	New	NNP
18637	11006	39	York	York	NNP
18637	11006	40	and	and	CC
18637	11006	41	the	the	DT
18637	11006	42	company	company	NN
18637	11006	43	,	,	,
18637	11006	44	the	the	DT
18637	11006	45	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	11006	46	of	of	IN
18637	11006	47	which	which	WDT
18637	11006	48	had	have	VBD
18637	11006	49	not	not	RB
18637	11006	50	been	be	VBN
18637	11006	51	determined	determine	VBN
18637	11006	52	by	by	IN
18637	11006	53	the	the	DT
18637	11006	54	State	State	NNP
18637	11006	55	courts	court	NNS
18637	11006	56	,	,	,
18637	11006	57	or	or	CC
18637	11006	58	explicit	explicit	JJ
18637	11006	59	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	11006	60	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	11006	61	as	as	IN
18637	11006	62	in	in	IN
18637	11006	63	28	28	CD
18637	11006	64	U.S.C.A.	U.S.C.A.	NNP
18637	11007	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	11007	2	1331	1331	CD
18637	11007	3	-	-	SYM
18637	11007	4	1332	1332	CD
18637	11007	5	,	,	,
18637	11007	6	1345	1345	CD
18637	11007	7	,	,	,
18637	11007	8	1359	1359	CD
18637	11007	9	,	,	,
18637	11007	10	resort	resort	VBP
18637	11007	11	to	to	IN
18637	11007	12	a	a	DT
18637	11007	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11007	14	court	court	NN
18637	11007	15	may	may	MD
18637	11007	16	precede	precede	VB
18637	11007	17	the	the	DT
18637	11007	18	exhaustion	exhaustion	NN
18637	11007	19	of	of	IN
18637	11007	20	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	11007	21	of	of	IN
18637	11007	22	State	State	NNP
18637	11007	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	11007	24	.	.	.
18637	11008	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11008	2	320	320	CD
18637	11008	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11008	4	Suits	Suits	NNP
18637	11008	5	Affecting	Affecting	NNP
18637	11008	6	Ambassadors	Ambassadors	NNPS
18637	11008	7	,	,	,
18637	11008	8	Other	Other	NNP
18637	11008	9	Public	Public	NNP
18637	11008	10	Ministers	Ministers	NNPS
18637	11008	11	,	,	,
18637	11008	12	and	and	CC
18637	11008	13	Consuls	Consuls	NNP
18637	11008	14	The	the	DT
18637	11008	15	earliest	early	JJS
18637	11008	16	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11008	17	of	of	IN
18637	11008	18	the	the	DT
18637	11008	19	grant	grant	NN
18637	11008	20	of	of	IN
18637	11008	21	original	original	JJ
18637	11008	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11008	23	to	to	IN
18637	11008	24	the	the	DT
18637	11008	25	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11008	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11008	27	came	come	VBD
18637	11008	28	in	in	IN
18637	11008	29	the	the	DT
18637	11008	30	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11008	31	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11008	32	of	of	IN
18637	11008	33	1789	1789	CD
18637	11008	34	,	,	,
18637	11008	35	which	which	WDT
18637	11008	36	conferred	confer	VBD
18637	11008	37	on	on	IN
18637	11008	38	the	the	DT
18637	11008	39	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11008	40	district	district	NN
18637	11008	41	courts	court	NNS
18637	11008	42	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11008	43	of	of	IN
18637	11008	44	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11008	45	to	to	TO
18637	11008	46	which	which	WDT
18637	11008	47	a	a	DT
18637	11008	48	consul	consul	NN
18637	11008	49	might	may	MD
18637	11008	50	be	be	VB
18637	11008	51	a	a	DT
18637	11008	52	party	party	NN
18637	11008	53	.	.	.
18637	11009	1	This	this	DT
18637	11009	2	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	11009	3	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11009	4	was	be	VBD
18637	11009	5	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	11009	6	in	in	IN
18637	11009	7	1793	1793	CD
18637	11009	8	in	in	IN
18637	11009	9	a	a	DT
18637	11009	10	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	11009	11	court	court	NN
18637	11009	12	case	case	NN
18637	11009	13	in	in	IN
18637	11009	14	which	which	WDT
18637	11009	15	the	the	DT
18637	11009	16	judges	judge	NNS
18637	11009	17	held	hold	VBD
18637	11009	18	that	that	IN
18637	11009	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11009	20	might	may	MD
18637	11009	21	vest	vest	VB
18637	11009	22	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	11009	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11009	24	involving	involve	VBG
18637	11009	25	consuls	consul	NNS
18637	11009	26	in	in	IN
18637	11009	27	the	the	DT
18637	11009	28	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	11009	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	11009	30	and	and	CC
18637	11009	31	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	11009	32	an	an	DT
18637	11009	33	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	11009	34	against	against	IN
18637	11009	35	a	a	DT
18637	11009	36	consul	consul	NN
18637	11009	37	.	.	.
18637	11010	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11010	2	321	321	CD
18637	11010	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11010	4	Many	many	JJ
18637	11010	5	years	year	NNS
18637	11010	6	later	later	RB
18637	11010	7	,	,	,
18637	11010	8	in	in	IN
18637	11010	9	1884	1884	CD
18637	11010	10	,	,	,
18637	11010	11	the	the	DT
18637	11010	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11010	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11010	14	held	hold	VBD
18637	11010	15	that	that	IN
18637	11010	16	consuls	consul	NNS
18637	11010	17	could	could	MD
18637	11010	18	be	be	VB
18637	11010	19	sued	sue	VBN
18637	11010	20	in	in	IN
18637	11010	21	the	the	DT
18637	11010	22	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11010	23	courts,[322	courts,[322	NNP
18637	11010	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11010	25	and	and	CC
18637	11010	26	in	in	IN
18637	11010	27	another	another	DT
18637	11010	28	case	case	NN
18637	11010	29	in	in	IN
18637	11010	30	the	the	DT
18637	11010	31	same	same	JJ
18637	11010	32	year	year	NN
18637	11010	33	declared	declare	VBD
18637	11010	34	sweepingly	sweepingly	RB
18637	11010	35	that	that	IN
18637	11010	36	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11010	37	could	could	MD
18637	11010	38	grant	grant	VB
18637	11010	39	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	11010	40	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11010	41	to	to	IN
18637	11010	42	the	the	DT
18637	11010	43	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	11010	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	11010	45	in	in	IN
18637	11010	46	cases	case	NNS
18637	11010	47	where	where	WRB
18637	11010	48	the	the	DT
18637	11010	49	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11010	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11010	51	has	have	VBZ
18637	11010	52	been	be	VBN
18637	11010	53	invested	invest	VBN
18637	11010	54	with	with	IN
18637	11010	55	original	original	JJ
18637	11010	56	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11010	57	.	.	.
18637	11011	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11011	2	323	323	CD
18637	11011	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11011	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	11011	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	11011	6	the	the	DT
18637	11011	7	grant	grant	NN
18637	11011	8	of	of	IN
18637	11011	9	original	original	JJ
18637	11011	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11011	11	to	to	IN
18637	11011	12	the	the	DT
18637	11011	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11011	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11011	15	in	in	IN
18637	11011	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	11011	17	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	11011	18	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	11011	19	and	and	CC
18637	11011	20	consuls	consul	NNS
18637	11011	21	of	of	IN
18637	11011	22	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11011	23	preclude	preclude	VBP
18637	11011	24	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11011	25	in	in	IN
18637	11011	26	State	State	NNP
18637	11011	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	11011	28	against	against	IN
18637	11011	29	consular	consular	JJ
18637	11011	30	officials	official	NNS
18637	11011	31	.	.	.
18637	11012	1	The	the	DT
18637	11012	2	leading	leading	JJ
18637	11012	3	case	case	NN
18637	11012	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	11012	5	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	11012	6	ex	ex	FW
18637	11012	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	11012	8	.	.	.
18637	11013	1	Popovici	Popovici	NNP
18637	11013	2	_	_	NNP
18637	11013	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	11013	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11013	5	Agler[324	Agler[324	NNP
18637	11013	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11013	7	in	in	IN
18637	11013	8	which	which	WDT
18637	11013	9	a	a	DT
18637	11013	10	Rumanian	rumanian	JJ
18637	11013	11	vice	vice	NN
18637	11013	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	11013	13	consul	consul	NN
18637	11013	14	contested	contest	VBD
18637	11013	15	an	an	DT
18637	11013	16	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	11013	17	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11013	18	against	against	IN
18637	11013	19	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11013	20	for	for	IN
18637	11013	21	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	11013	22	and	and	CC
18637	11013	23	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	11013	24	.	.	.
18637	11014	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11014	2	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	11014	3	,	,	,
18637	11014	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	11014	5	for	for	IN
18637	11014	6	the	the	DT
18637	11014	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11014	8	,	,	,
18637	11014	9	said	say	VBD
18637	11014	10	:	:	:
18637	11014	11	"	"	``
18637	11014	12	The	the	DT
18637	11014	13	words	word	NNS
18637	11014	14	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	11014	15	from	from	IN
18637	11014	16	the	the	DT
18637	11014	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11014	18	do	do	VBP
18637	11014	19	not	not	RB
18637	11014	20	of	of	IN
18637	11014	21	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11014	22	and	and	CC
18637	11014	23	without	without	IN
18637	11014	24	more	more	JJR
18637	11014	25	exclude	exclude	VBP
18637	11014	26	the	the	DT
18637	11014	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11014	28	of	of	IN
18637	11014	29	the	the	DT
18637	11014	30	State	State	NNP
18637	11014	31	.	.	.
18637	11015	1	*	*	NFP
18637	11015	2	*	*	NFP
18637	11015	3	*	*	NFP
18637	11015	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11015	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	11015	6	been	be	VBN
18637	11015	7	understood	understand	VBN
18637	11015	8	that	that	IN
18637	11015	9	,	,	,
18637	11015	10	'	'	''
18637	11015	11	the	the	DT
18637	11015	12	whole	whole	JJ
18637	11015	13	subject	subject	NN
18637	11015	14	of	of	IN
18637	11015	15	the	the	DT
18637	11015	16	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	11015	17	relations	relation	NNS
18637	11015	18	of	of	IN
18637	11015	19	husband	husband	NN
18637	11015	20	and	and	CC
18637	11015	21	wife	wife	NN
18637	11015	22	,	,	,
18637	11015	23	parent	parent	NN
18637	11015	24	and	and	CC
18637	11015	25	child	child	NN
18637	11015	26	,	,	,
18637	11015	27	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	11015	28	to	to	IN
18637	11015	29	the	the	DT
18637	11015	30	laws	law	NNS
18637	11015	31	of	of	IN
18637	11015	32	the	the	DT
18637	11015	33	States	States	NNPS
18637	11015	34	and	and	CC
18637	11015	35	not	not	RB
18637	11015	36	to	to	IN
18637	11015	37	the	the	DT
18637	11015	38	laws	law	NNS
18637	11015	39	of	of	IN
18637	11015	40	the	the	DT
18637	11015	41	United	United	NNP
18637	11015	42	States	States	NNP
18637	11015	43	.	.	.
18637	11015	44	'	'	''
18637	11016	1	*	*	NFP
18637	11016	2	*	*	NFP
18637	11016	3	*	*	NFP
18637	11016	4	In	in	IN
18637	11016	5	the	the	DT
18637	11016	6	absence	absence	NN
18637	11016	7	of	of	IN
18637	11016	8	any	any	DT
18637	11016	9	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	11016	10	in	in	IN
18637	11016	11	the	the	DT
18637	11016	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11016	13	or	or	CC
18637	11016	14	laws	law	NNS
18637	11016	15	of	of	IN
18637	11016	16	the	the	DT
18637	11016	17	United	United	NNP
18637	11016	18	States	States	NNP
18637	11016	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11016	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	11016	21	for	for	IN
18637	11016	22	the	the	DT
18637	11016	23	State	State	NNP
18637	11016	24	to	to	TO
18637	11016	25	decide	decide	VB
18637	11016	26	how	how	WRB
18637	11016	27	far	far	RB
18637	11016	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11016	29	will	will	MD
18637	11016	30	go	go	VB
18637	11016	31	.	.	.
18637	11016	32	"	"	''
18637	11017	1	WHEN	when	WRB
18637	11017	2	"	"	``
18637	11017	3	AMBASSADORS	AMBASSADORS	NNP
18637	11017	4	"	"	''
18637	11017	5	ETC	ETC	NNP
18637	11017	6	.	.	NNP
18637	11017	7	,	,	,
18637	11017	8	ARE	are	VBP
18637	11017	9	"	"	``
18637	11017	10	AFFECTED	affect	VBD
18637	11017	11	"	"	``
18637	11017	12	A	a	DT
18637	11017	13	number	number	NN
18637	11017	14	of	of	IN
18637	11017	15	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	11017	16	questions	question	NNS
18637	11017	17	arise	arise	VBP
18637	11017	18	in	in	IN
18637	11017	19	connection	connection	NN
18637	11017	20	with	with	IN
18637	11017	21	the	the	DT
18637	11017	22	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	11017	23	"	"	``
18637	11017	24	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	11017	25	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	11017	26	and	and	CC
18637	11017	27	consuls	consul	NNS
18637	11017	28	.	.	.
18637	11017	29	"	"	''
18637	11018	1	Does	do	VBZ
18637	11018	2	the	the	DT
18637	11018	3	ambassador	ambassador	NN
18637	11018	4	or	or	CC
18637	11018	5	consul	consul	NN
18637	11018	6	to	to	TO
18637	11018	7	be	be	VB
18637	11018	8	affected	affect	VBN
18637	11018	9	have	have	VBP
18637	11018	10	to	to	TO
18637	11018	11	be	be	VB
18637	11018	12	a	a	DT
18637	11018	13	party	party	NN
18637	11018	14	in	in	IN
18637	11018	15	interest	interest	NN
18637	11018	16	,	,	,
18637	11018	17	or	or	CC
18637	11018	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	11018	19	a	a	DT
18637	11018	20	mere	mere	JJ
18637	11018	21	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	11018	22	interest	interest	NN
18637	11018	23	in	in	IN
18637	11018	24	the	the	DT
18637	11018	25	outcome	outcome	NN
18637	11018	26	of	of	IN
18637	11018	27	the	the	DT
18637	11018	28	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	11018	29	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	11018	30	?	?	.
18637	11019	1	In	in	IN
18637	11019	2	United	United	NNP
18637	11019	3	States	States	NNP
18637	11019	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11019	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	11019	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11019	7	Ortega,[325	Ortega,[325	NNP
18637	11019	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11019	9	the	the	DT
18637	11019	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11019	11	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	11019	12	that	that	IN
18637	11019	13	a	a	DT
18637	11019	14	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	11019	15	of	of	IN
18637	11019	16	a	a	DT
18637	11019	17	person	person	NN
18637	11019	18	for	for	IN
18637	11019	19	violating	violate	VBG
18637	11019	20	international	international	JJ
18637	11019	21	law	law	NN
18637	11019	22	and	and	CC
18637	11019	23	the	the	DT
18637	11019	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	11019	25	of	of	IN
18637	11019	26	the	the	DT
18637	11019	27	United	United	NNP
18637	11019	28	States	States	NNP
18637	11019	29	by	by	IN
18637	11019	30	offering	offer	VBG
18637	11019	31	violence	violence	NN
18637	11019	32	to	to	IN
18637	11019	33	the	the	DT
18637	11019	34	person	person	NN
18637	11019	35	of	of	IN
18637	11019	36	a	a	DT
18637	11019	37	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11019	38	minister	minister	NN
18637	11019	39	was	be	VBD
18637	11019	40	not	not	RB
18637	11019	41	a	a	DT
18637	11019	42	suit	suit	NN
18637	11019	43	"	"	``
18637	11019	44	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	11019	45	"	"	''
18637	11019	46	the	the	DT
18637	11019	47	minister	minister	NN
18637	11019	48	,	,	,
18637	11019	49	but	but	CC
18637	11019	50	a	a	DT
18637	11019	51	public	public	JJ
18637	11019	52	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	11019	53	for	for	IN
18637	11019	54	vindication	vindication	NN
18637	11019	55	of	of	IN
18637	11019	56	the	the	DT
18637	11019	57	laws	law	NNS
18637	11019	58	of	of	IN
18637	11019	59	nations	nation	NNS
18637	11019	60	and	and	CC
18637	11019	61	the	the	DT
18637	11019	62	United	United	NNP
18637	11019	63	States	States	NNP
18637	11019	64	.	.	.
18637	11020	1	Another	another	DT
18637	11020	2	question	question	NN
18637	11020	3	concerns	concern	VBZ
18637	11020	4	the	the	DT
18637	11020	5	official	official	JJ
18637	11020	6	status	status	NN
18637	11020	7	of	of	IN
18637	11020	8	a	a	DT
18637	11020	9	person	person	NN
18637	11020	10	claiming	claim	VBG
18637	11020	11	to	to	TO
18637	11020	12	be	be	VB
18637	11020	13	an	an	DT
18637	11020	14	ambassador	ambassador	NN
18637	11020	15	,	,	,
18637	11020	16	etc	etc	FW
18637	11020	17	.	.	.
18637	11021	1	In	in	IN
18637	11021	2	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11021	3	parte	parte	NN
18637	11021	4	Baiz,[326	Baiz,[326	NNP
18637	11021	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11021	6	the	the	DT
18637	11021	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11021	8	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	11021	9	to	to	TO
18637	11021	10	review	review	VB
18637	11021	11	the	the	DT
18637	11021	12	decision	decision	NN
18637	11021	13	of	of	IN
18637	11021	14	the	the	DT
18637	11021	15	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	11021	16	with	with	IN
18637	11021	17	respect	respect	NN
18637	11021	18	to	to	IN
18637	11021	19	the	the	DT
18637	11021	20	public	public	JJ
18637	11021	21	character	character	NN
18637	11021	22	of	of	IN
18637	11021	23	a	a	DT
18637	11021	24	person	person	NN
18637	11021	25	claiming	claim	VBG
18637	11021	26	to	to	TO
18637	11021	27	be	be	VB
18637	11021	28	a	a	DT
18637	11021	29	public	public	JJ
18637	11021	30	minister	minister	NN
18637	11021	31	and	and	CC
18637	11021	32	laid	lay	VBD
18637	11021	33	down	down	RP
18637	11021	34	the	the	DT
18637	11021	35	rule	rule	NN
18637	11021	36	that	that	IN
18637	11021	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11021	38	has	have	VBZ
18637	11021	39	the	the	DT
18637	11021	40	right	right	NN
18637	11021	41	to	to	TO
18637	11021	42	accept	accept	VB
18637	11021	43	a	a	DT
18637	11021	44	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	11021	45	from	from	IN
18637	11021	46	the	the	DT
18637	11021	47	Department	Department	NNP
18637	11021	48	of	of	IN
18637	11021	49	State	State	NNP
18637	11021	50	on	on	IN
18637	11021	51	such	such	PDT
18637	11021	52	a	a	DT
18637	11021	53	question	question	NN
18637	11021	54	.	.	.
18637	11022	1	A	a	DT
18637	11022	2	third	third	JJ
18637	11022	3	question	question	NN
18637	11022	4	was	be	VBD
18637	11022	5	whether	whether	IN
18637	11022	6	the	the	DT
18637	11022	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	11022	8	included	include	VBD
18637	11022	9	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	11022	10	and	and	CC
18637	11022	11	consuls	consul	NNS
18637	11022	12	accredited	accredit	VBN
18637	11022	13	by	by	IN
18637	11022	14	the	the	DT
18637	11022	15	United	United	NNP
18637	11022	16	States	States	NNP
18637	11022	17	to	to	IN
18637	11022	18	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11022	19	governments	government	NNS
18637	11022	20	.	.	.
18637	11023	1	The	the	DT
18637	11023	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11023	3	held	hold	VBD
18637	11023	4	that	that	IN
18637	11023	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11023	6	includes	include	VBZ
18637	11023	7	only	only	RB
18637	11023	8	persons	person	NNS
18637	11023	9	accredited	accredit	VBN
18637	11023	10	to	to	IN
18637	11023	11	the	the	DT
18637	11023	12	United	United	NNP
18637	11023	13	States	States	NNP
18637	11023	14	by	by	IN
18637	11023	15	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11023	16	governments	government	NNS
18637	11023	17	.	.	.
18637	11024	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11024	2	327	327	CD
18637	11024	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11024	4	However	however	RB
18637	11024	5	,	,	,
18637	11024	6	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11024	7	of	of	IN
18637	11024	8	especial	especial	JJ
18637	11024	9	delicacy	delicacy	NN
18637	11024	10	such	such	JJ
18637	11024	11	as	as	IN
18637	11024	12	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11024	13	against	against	IN
18637	11024	14	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	11024	15	and	and	CC
18637	11024	16	public	public	JJ
18637	11024	17	ministers	minister	NNS
18637	11024	18	or	or	CC
18637	11024	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11024	20	servants	servant	NNS
18637	11024	21	,	,	,
18637	11024	22	where	where	WRB
18637	11024	23	the	the	DT
18637	11024	24	law	law	NN
18637	11024	25	of	of	IN
18637	11024	26	nations	nation	NNS
18637	11024	27	permits	permit	VBZ
18637	11024	28	such	such	JJ
18637	11024	29	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11024	30	,	,	,
18637	11024	31	and	and	CC
18637	11024	32	in	in	IN
18637	11024	33	all	all	DT
18637	11024	34	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11024	35	of	of	IN
18637	11024	36	a	a	DT
18637	11024	37	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11024	38	nature	nature	NN
18637	11024	39	to	to	TO
18637	11024	40	which	which	WDT
18637	11024	41	a	a	DT
18637	11024	42	State	state	NN
18637	11024	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	11024	44	a	a	DT
18637	11024	45	party,[328	party,[328	NN
18637	11024	46	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11024	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11024	48	has	have	VBZ
18637	11024	49	made	make	VBN
18637	11024	50	the	the	DT
18637	11024	51	original	original	JJ
18637	11024	52	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11024	53	of	of	IN
18637	11024	54	the	the	DT
18637	11024	55	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11024	56	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11024	57	exclusive	exclusive	NN
18637	11024	58	of	of	IN
18637	11024	59	that	that	DT
18637	11024	60	of	of	IN
18637	11024	61	other	other	JJ
18637	11024	62	courts	court	NNS
18637	11024	63	.	.	.
18637	11025	1	By	by	IN
18637	11025	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11025	3	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	11025	4	with	with	IN
18637	11025	5	the	the	DT
18637	11025	6	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	11025	7	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	11025	8	of	of	IN
18637	11025	9	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11025	10	and	and	CC
18637	11025	11	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	11025	12	original	original	JJ
18637	11025	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11025	14	,	,	,
18637	11025	15	the	the	DT
18637	11025	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11025	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	11025	18	tacitly	tacitly	RB
18637	11025	19	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
18637	11025	20	the	the	DT
18637	11025	21	power	power	NN
18637	11025	22	of	of	IN
18637	11025	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11025	24	to	to	TO
18637	11025	25	make	make	VB
18637	11025	26	such	such	JJ
18637	11025	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11025	28	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11025	29	or	or	CC
18637	11025	30	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	11025	31	as	as	IN
18637	11025	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11025	33	may	may	MD
18637	11025	34	choose	choose	VB
18637	11025	35	.	.	.
18637	11026	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	11026	2	,	,	,
18637	11026	3	as	as	IN
18637	11026	4	in	in	IN
18637	11026	5	the	the	DT
18637	11026	6	Popovici	Popovici	NNP
18637	11026	7	case	case	NN
18637	11026	8	,	,	,
18637	11026	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11026	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	11026	11	implied	imply	VBN
18637	11026	12	that	that	IN
18637	11026	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11026	14	,	,	,
18637	11026	15	if	if	IN
18637	11026	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11026	17	chose	choose	VBD
18637	11026	18	,	,	,
18637	11026	19	could	could	MD
18637	11026	20	make	make	VB
18637	11026	21	the	the	DT
18637	11026	22	court	court	NN
18637	11026	23	's	's	POS
18637	11026	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11026	25	of	of	IN
18637	11026	26	consular	consular	JJ
18637	11026	27	officials	official	NNS
18637	11026	28	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11026	29	of	of	IN
18637	11026	30	State	State	NNP
18637	11026	31	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	11026	32	.	.	.
18637	11027	1	Cases	case	NNS
18637	11027	2	of	of	IN
18637	11027	3	Admiralty	Admiralty	NNP
18637	11027	4	and	and	CC
18637	11027	5	Maritime	Maritime	NNP
18637	11027	6	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	11027	7	ORIGIN	ORIGIN	NNS
18637	11027	8	AND	and	CC
18637	11027	9	CHARACTERISTICS	CHARACTERISTICS	NNP
18637	11027	10	The	the	DT
18637	11027	11	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11027	12	and	and	CC
18637	11027	13	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11027	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11027	15	of	of	IN
18637	11027	16	the	the	DT
18637	11027	17	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11027	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	11027	19	had	have	VBD
18637	11027	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11027	21	origin	origin	NN
18637	11027	22	in	in	IN
18637	11027	23	the	the	DT
18637	11027	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11027	25	vested	vest	VBN
18637	11027	26	in	in	IN
18637	11027	27	the	the	DT
18637	11027	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	11027	29	of	of	IN
18637	11027	30	the	the	DT
18637	11027	31	Admiral	Admiral	NNP
18637	11027	32	of	of	IN
18637	11027	33	the	the	DT
18637	11027	34	English	English	NNP
18637	11027	35	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	11027	36	.	.	.
18637	11028	1	Prior	prior	RB
18637	11028	2	to	to	IN
18637	11028	3	independence	independence	NN
18637	11028	4	,	,	,
18637	11028	5	vice	vice	NN
18637	11028	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	11028	7	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11028	8	courts	court	NNS
18637	11028	9	were	be	VBD
18637	11028	10	created	create	VBN
18637	11028	11	in	in	IN
18637	11028	12	the	the	DT
18637	11028	13	Colonies	Colonies	NNPS
18637	11028	14	by	by	IN
18637	11028	15	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	11028	16	from	from	IN
18637	11028	17	the	the	DT
18637	11028	18	English	English	NNP
18637	11028	19	High	High	NNP
18637	11028	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11028	21	of	of	IN
18637	11028	22	Admiralty	Admiralty	NNP
18637	11028	23	.	.	.
18637	11029	1	After	after	IN
18637	11029	2	independence	independence	NN
18637	11029	3	,	,	,
18637	11029	4	the	the	DT
18637	11029	5	States	States	NNP
18637	11029	6	established	establish	VBD
18637	11029	7	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11029	8	courts	court	NNS
18637	11029	9	,	,	,
18637	11029	10	from	from	IN
18637	11029	11	which	which	WDT
18637	11029	12	at	at	IN
18637	11029	13	a	a	DT
18637	11029	14	later	later	JJ
18637	11029	15	date	date	NN
18637	11029	16	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	11029	17	could	could	MD
18637	11029	18	be	be	VB
18637	11029	19	taken	take	VBN
18637	11029	20	to	to	IN
18637	11029	21	a	a	DT
18637	11029	22	court	court	NN
18637	11029	23	of	of	IN
18637	11029	24	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	11029	25	set	set	VBN
18637	11029	26	up	up	RP
18637	11029	27	by	by	IN
18637	11029	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11029	29	under	under	IN
18637	11029	30	the	the	DT
18637	11029	31	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	11029	32	of	of	IN
18637	11029	33	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	11029	34	.	.	.
18637	11030	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11030	2	329	329	CD
18637	11030	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11030	4	Since	since	IN
18637	11030	5	one	one	CD
18637	11030	6	of	of	IN
18637	11030	7	the	the	DT
18637	11030	8	objectives	objective	NNS
18637	11030	9	of	of	IN
18637	11030	10	the	the	DT
18637	11030	11	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	11030	12	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	11030	13	was	be	VBD
18637	11030	14	the	the	DT
18637	11030	15	promotion	promotion	NN
18637	11030	16	of	of	IN
18637	11030	17	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	11030	18	and	and	CC
18637	11030	19	the	the	DT
18637	11030	20	removal	removal	NN
18637	11030	21	of	of	IN
18637	11030	22	obstacles	obstacle	NNS
18637	11030	23	to	to	IN
18637	11030	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11030	25	,	,	,
18637	11030	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11030	27	was	be	VBD
18637	11030	28	only	only	RB
18637	11030	29	logical	logical	JJ
18637	11030	30	that	that	IN
18637	11030	31	the	the	DT
18637	11030	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11030	33	should	should	MD
18637	11030	34	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	11030	35	the	the	DT
18637	11030	36	States	States	NNPS
18637	11030	37	of	of	IN
18637	11030	38	all	all	DT
18637	11030	39	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11030	40	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11030	41	and	and	CC
18637	11030	42	vest	vest	VBP
18637	11030	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11030	44	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	11030	45	in	in	IN
18637	11030	46	the	the	DT
18637	11030	47	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11030	48	courts	court	NNS
18637	11030	49	.	.	.
18637	11031	1	CONGRESSIONAL	congressional	JJ
18637	11031	2	INTERPRETATION	INTERPRETATION	NNS
18637	11031	3	OF	of	IN
18637	11031	4	THE	the	DT
18637	11031	5	ADMIRALTY	ADMIRALTY	NNP
18637	11031	6	CLAUSE	CLAUSE	NNP
18637	11031	7	The	the	DT
18637	11031	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11031	9	uses	use	VBZ
18637	11031	10	the	the	DT
18637	11031	11	terms	term	NNS
18637	11031	12	"	"	``
18637	11031	13	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11031	14	and	and	CC
18637	11031	15	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11031	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11031	17	"	"	''
18637	11031	18	without	without	IN
18637	11031	19	defining	define	VBG
18637	11031	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11031	21	.	.	.
18637	11032	1	Though	though	IN
18637	11032	2	closely	closely	RB
18637	11032	3	related	relate	VBN
18637	11032	4	the	the	DT
18637	11032	5	words	word	NNS
18637	11032	6	are	be	VBP
18637	11032	7	not	not	RB
18637	11032	8	synonyms	synonyms	JJ
18637	11032	9	.	.	.
18637	11033	1	In	in	IN
18637	11033	2	England	England	NNP
18637	11033	3	the	the	DT
18637	11033	4	word	word	NN
18637	11033	5	"	"	``
18637	11033	6	maritime	maritime	NN
18637	11033	7	"	"	''
18637	11033	8	referred	refer	VBN
18637	11033	9	to	to	IN
18637	11033	10	the	the	DT
18637	11033	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	11033	12	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11033	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	11033	14	the	the	DT
18637	11033	15	high	high	JJ
18637	11033	16	seas	sea	NNS
18637	11033	17	,	,	,
18637	11033	18	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	11033	19	"	"	``
18637	11033	20	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11033	21	"	"	''
18637	11033	22	meant	mean	VBN
18637	11033	23	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	11033	24	cases	case	NNS
18637	11033	25	of	of	IN
18637	11033	26	a	a	DT
18637	11033	27	local	local	JJ
18637	11033	28	nature	nature	NN
18637	11033	29	involving	involve	VBG
18637	11033	30	police	police	NN
18637	11033	31	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	11033	32	of	of	IN
18637	11033	33	shipping	shipping	NN
18637	11033	34	,	,	,
18637	11033	35	harbors	harbor	NNS
18637	11033	36	,	,	,
18637	11033	37	fishing	fishing	NN
18637	11033	38	,	,	,
18637	11033	39	and	and	CC
18637	11033	40	the	the	DT
18637	11033	41	like	like	JJ
18637	11033	42	.	.	.
18637	11034	1	A	a	DT
18637	11034	2	long	long	JJ
18637	11034	3	struggle	struggle	NN
18637	11034	4	between	between	IN
18637	11034	5	the	the	DT
18637	11034	6	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11034	7	and	and	CC
18637	11034	8	common	common	JJ
18637	11034	9	law	law	NN
18637	11034	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	11034	11	had	have	VBD
18637	11034	12	,	,	,
18637	11034	13	however	however	RB
18637	11034	14	,	,	,
18637	11034	15	in	in	IN
18637	11034	16	the	the	DT
18637	11034	17	course	course	NN
18637	11034	18	of	of	IN
18637	11034	19	time	time	NN
18637	11034	20	resulted	result	VBD
18637	11034	21	in	in	IN
18637	11034	22	a	a	DT
18637	11034	23	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	11034	24	curtailment	curtailment	NN
18637	11034	25	of	of	IN
18637	11034	26	English	english	JJ
18637	11034	27	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11034	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11034	29	.	.	.
18637	11035	1	For	for	IN
18637	11035	2	this	this	DT
18637	11035	3	and	and	CC
18637	11035	4	other	other	JJ
18637	11035	5	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	11035	6	,	,	,
18637	11035	7	a	a	DT
18637	11035	8	much	much	RB
18637	11035	9	broader	broad	JJR
18637	11035	10	conception	conception	NN
18637	11035	11	of	of	IN
18637	11035	12	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11035	13	and	and	CC
18637	11035	14	maritime	maritime	NN
18637	11035	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11035	16	existed	exist	VBD
18637	11035	17	in	in	IN
18637	11035	18	the	the	DT
18637	11035	19	United	United	NNP
18637	11035	20	States	States	NNP
18637	11035	21	at	at	IN
18637	11035	22	the	the	DT
18637	11035	23	time	time	NN
18637	11035	24	of	of	IN
18637	11035	25	the	the	DT
18637	11035	26	framing	framing	NN
18637	11035	27	of	of	IN
18637	11035	28	the	the	DT
18637	11035	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11035	30	than	than	IN
18637	11035	31	in	in	IN
18637	11035	32	the	the	DT
18637	11035	33	Mother	Mother	NNP
18637	11035	34	Country	Country	NNP
18637	11035	35	.	.	.
18637	11036	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11036	2	330	330	CD
18637	11036	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11036	4	At	at	IN
18637	11036	5	the	the	DT
18637	11036	6	very	very	JJ
18637	11036	7	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	11036	8	of	of	IN
18637	11036	9	government	government	NN
18637	11036	10	under	under	IN
18637	11036	11	the	the	DT
18637	11036	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11036	13	,	,	,
18637	11036	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11036	15	conferred	confer	VBD
18637	11036	16	on	on	IN
18637	11036	17	the	the	DT
18637	11036	18	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11036	19	district	district	NN
18637	11036	20	courts	court	NNS
18637	11036	21	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11036	22	original	original	JJ
18637	11036	23	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	11036	24	"	"	''
18637	11036	25	of	of	IN
18637	11036	26	all	all	DT
18637	11036	27	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11036	28	causes	cause	NNS
18637	11036	29	of	of	IN
18637	11036	30	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11036	31	and	and	CC
18637	11036	32	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11036	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11036	34	,	,	,
18637	11036	35	including	include	VBG
18637	11036	36	all	all	DT
18637	11036	37	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	11036	38	under	under	IN
18637	11036	39	laws	law	NNS
18637	11036	40	of	of	IN
18637	11036	41	impost	impost	NN
18637	11036	42	,	,	,
18637	11036	43	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	11036	44	or	or	CC
18637	11036	45	trade	trade	NN
18637	11036	46	of	of	IN
18637	11036	47	the	the	DT
18637	11036	48	United	United	NNP
18637	11036	49	States	States	NNP
18637	11036	50	,	,	,
18637	11036	51	where	where	WRB
18637	11036	52	the	the	DT
18637	11036	53	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	11036	54	are	be	VBP
18637	11036	55	made	make	VBN
18637	11036	56	,	,	,
18637	11036	57	on	on	IN
18637	11036	58	waters	water	NNS
18637	11036	59	which	which	WDT
18637	11036	60	are	be	VBP
18637	11036	61	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11036	62	from	from	IN
18637	11036	63	the	the	DT
18637	11036	64	sea	sea	NN
18637	11036	65	by	by	IN
18637	11036	66	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	11036	67	of	of	IN
18637	11036	68	ten	ten	CD
18637	11036	69	or	or	CC
18637	11036	70	more	more	JJR
18637	11036	71	tons	ton	NNS
18637	11036	72	burthen	burthen	NN
18637	11036	73	,	,	,
18637	11036	74	within	within	IN
18637	11036	75	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11036	76	respective	respective	JJ
18637	11036	77	districts	district	NNS
18637	11036	78	,	,	,
18637	11036	79	as	as	RB
18637	11036	80	well	well	RB
18637	11036	81	as	as	IN
18637	11036	82	upon	upon	IN
18637	11036	83	the	the	DT
18637	11036	84	high	high	JJ
18637	11036	85	seas	sea	NNS
18637	11036	86	;	;	:
18637	11036	87	saving	save	VBG
18637	11036	88	to	to	IN
18637	11036	89	suitors	suitor	NNS
18637	11036	90	,	,	,
18637	11036	91	in	in	IN
18637	11036	92	all	all	DT
18637	11036	93	cases	case	NNS
18637	11036	94	,	,	,
18637	11036	95	the	the	DT
18637	11036	96	right	right	NN
18637	11036	97	of	of	IN
18637	11036	98	a	a	DT
18637	11036	99	common	common	JJ
18637	11036	100	law	law	NN
18637	11036	101	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	11036	102	,	,	,
18637	11036	103	where	where	WRB
18637	11036	104	the	the	DT
18637	11036	105	common	common	JJ
18637	11036	106	law	law	NN
18637	11036	107	is	be	VBZ
18637	11036	108	competent	competent	JJ
18637	11036	109	to	to	TO
18637	11036	110	give	give	VB
18637	11036	111	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11036	112	;	;	:
18637	11036	113	*	*	NFP
18637	11036	114	*	*	NFP
18637	11036	115	*	*	NFP
18637	11036	116	"	"	''
18637	11036	117	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11036	118	331	331	CD
18637	11036	119	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11036	120	This	this	DT
18637	11036	121	broad	broad	JJ
18637	11036	122	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	11036	123	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11036	124	of	of	IN
18637	11036	125	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11036	126	and	and	CC
18637	11036	127	maritime	maritime	NN
18637	11036	128	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11036	129	soon	soon	RB
18637	11036	130	won	win	VBD
18637	11036	131	the	the	DT
18637	11036	132	approval	approval	NN
18637	11036	133	of	of	IN
18637	11036	134	the	the	DT
18637	11036	135	federal	federal	NNP
18637	11036	136	circuit	circuit	NNP
18637	11036	137	courts	court	NNS
18637	11036	138	,	,	,
18637	11036	139	which	which	WDT
18637	11036	140	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	11036	141	that	that	IN
18637	11036	142	the	the	DT
18637	11036	143	extent	extent	NN
18637	11036	144	of	of	IN
18637	11036	145	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11036	146	and	and	CC
18637	11036	147	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11036	148	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11036	149	was	be	VBD
18637	11036	150	not	not	RB
18637	11036	151	to	to	TO
18637	11036	152	be	be	VB
18637	11036	153	determined	determine	VBN
18637	11036	154	by	by	IN
18637	11036	155	English	english	JJ
18637	11036	156	law	law	NN
18637	11036	157	but	but	CC
18637	11036	158	by	by	IN
18637	11036	159	the	the	DT
18637	11036	160	principles	principle	NNS
18637	11036	161	of	of	IN
18637	11036	162	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11036	163	law	law	NN
18637	11036	164	"	"	''
18637	11036	165	as	as	IN
18637	11036	166	respected	respect	VBN
18637	11036	167	by	by	IN
18637	11036	168	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11036	169	courts	court	NNS
18637	11036	170	of	of	IN
18637	11036	171	all	all	DT
18637	11036	172	nations	nation	NNS
18637	11036	173	and	and	CC
18637	11036	174	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	11036	175	by	by	IN
18637	11036	176	most	most	JJS
18637	11036	177	,	,	,
18637	11036	178	if	if	IN
18637	11036	179	not	not	RB
18637	11036	180	by	by	IN
18637	11036	181	all	all	DT
18637	11036	182	,	,	,
18637	11036	183	of	of	IN
18637	11036	184	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11036	185	on	on	IN
18637	11036	186	the	the	DT
18637	11036	187	continent	continent	NN
18637	11036	188	of	of	IN
18637	11036	189	Europe	Europe	NNP
18637	11036	190	.	.	.
18637	11037	1	"	"	``
18637	11037	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11037	3	332	332	CD
18637	11037	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11037	5	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	11037	6	APPROVAL	APPROVAL	NNP
18637	11037	7	OF	of	IN
18637	11037	8	CONGRESSIONAL	congressional	JJ
18637	11037	9	INTERPRETATION	INTERPRETATION	NNP
18637	11037	10	Although	although	IN
18637	11037	11	a	a	DT
18637	11037	12	number	number	NN
18637	11037	13	of	of	IN
18637	11037	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11037	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11037	16	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11037	17	had	have	VBD
18637	11037	18	earlier	early	RBR
18637	11037	19	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	11037	20	the	the	DT
18637	11037	21	broader	broad	JJR
18637	11037	22	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11037	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11037	24	on	on	IN
18637	11037	25	specific	specific	JJ
18637	11037	26	issues,[333	issues,[333	NN
18637	11037	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11037	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11037	29	was	be	VBD
18637	11037	30	not	not	RB
18637	11037	31	until	until	IN
18637	11037	32	1848	1848	CD
18637	11037	33	that	that	IN
18637	11037	34	the	the	DT
18637	11037	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11037	36	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	11037	37	squarely	squarely	RB
18637	11037	38	in	in	IN
18637	11037	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11037	40	favor	favor	NN
18637	11037	41	,	,	,
18637	11037	42	which	which	WDT
18637	11037	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11037	44	did	do	VBD
18637	11037	45	by	by	IN
18637	11037	46	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	11037	47	that	that	DT
18637	11037	48	,	,	,
18637	11037	49	"	"	``
18637	11037	50	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	11037	51	may	may	MD
18637	11037	52	have	have	VB
18637	11037	53	been	be	VBN
18637	11037	54	the	the	DT
18637	11037	55	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	11037	56	,	,	,
18637	11037	57	originally	originally	RB
18637	11037	58	,	,	,
18637	11037	59	as	as	IN
18637	11037	60	to	to	IN
18637	11037	61	the	the	DT
18637	11037	62	true	true	JJ
18637	11037	63	construction	construction	NN
18637	11037	64	of	of	IN
18637	11037	65	the	the	DT
18637	11037	66	grant	grant	NN
18637	11037	67	,	,	,
18637	11037	68	whether	whether	IN
18637	11037	69	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11037	70	had	have	VBD
18637	11037	71	reference	reference	NN
18637	11037	72	to	to	IN
18637	11037	73	the	the	DT
18637	11037	74	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11037	75	in	in	IN
18637	11037	76	England	England	NNP
18637	11037	77	,	,	,
18637	11037	78	or	or	CC
18637	11037	79	to	to	IN
18637	11037	80	the	the	DT
18637	11037	81	more	more	RBR
18637	11037	82	enlarged	enlarged	JJ
18637	11037	83	one	one	NN
18637	11037	84	that	that	WDT
18637	11037	85	existed	exist	VBD
18637	11037	86	in	in	IN
18637	11037	87	other	other	JJ
18637	11037	88	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11037	89	countries	country	NNS
18637	11037	90	,	,	,
18637	11037	91	the	the	DT
18637	11037	92	question	question	NN
18637	11037	93	has	have	VBZ
18637	11037	94	become	become	VBN
18637	11037	95	settled	settle	VBN
18637	11037	96	by	by	IN
18637	11037	97	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	11037	98	and	and	CC
18637	11037	99	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11037	100	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11037	101	,	,	,
18637	11037	102	which	which	WDT
18637	11037	103	ought	ought	MD
18637	11037	104	not	not	RB
18637	11037	105	now	now	RB
18637	11037	106	to	to	TO
18637	11037	107	be	be	VB
18637	11037	108	disturbed	disturb	VBN
18637	11037	109	.	.	.
18637	11038	1	"	"	``
18637	11038	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11038	3	334	334	CD
18637	11038	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11038	5	The	the	DT
18637	11038	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11038	7	thereupon	thereupon	RB
18637	11038	8	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	11038	9	to	to	TO
18637	11038	10	hold	hold	VB
18637	11038	11	that	that	DT
18637	11038	12	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11038	13	had	have	VBD
18637	11038	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11038	15	_	_	NNP
18637	11038	16	in	in	IN
18637	11038	17	personam	personam	NNP
18637	11038	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11038	19	as	as	RB
18637	11038	20	well	well	RB
18637	11038	21	as	as	IN
18637	11038	22	_	_	NNP
18637	11038	23	in	in	IN
18637	11038	24	rem	rem	NNP
18637	11038	25	_	_	NNP
18637	11038	26	,	,	,
18637	11038	27	over	over	IN
18637	11038	28	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11038	29	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11038	30	out	out	IN
18637	11038	31	of	of	IN
18637	11038	32	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	11038	33	of	of	IN
18637	11038	34	affreightment	affreightment	NN
18637	11038	35	between	between	IN
18637	11038	36	New	New	NNP
18637	11038	37	York	York	NNP
18637	11038	38	and	and	CC
18637	11038	39	Providence	Providence	NNP
18637	11038	40	.	.	.
18637	11039	1	TWO	two	CD
18637	11039	2	TYPES	type	NNS
18637	11039	3	OF	of	IN
18637	11039	4	CASES	CASES	NNP
18637	11039	5	Admiralty	Admiralty	NNP
18637	11039	6	and	and	CC
18637	11039	7	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11039	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11039	9	comprises	comprise	VBZ
18637	11039	10	two	two	CD
18637	11039	11	types	type	NNS
18637	11039	12	of	of	IN
18637	11039	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	11039	14	:	:	:
18637	11039	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11039	16	1	1	LS
18637	11039	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11039	18	those	those	DT
18637	11039	19	involving	involve	VBG
18637	11039	20	acts	act	NNS
18637	11039	21	committed	commit	VBN
18637	11039	22	on	on	IN
18637	11039	23	the	the	DT
18637	11039	24	high	high	JJ
18637	11039	25	seas	sea	NNS
18637	11039	26	or	or	CC
18637	11039	27	other	other	JJ
18637	11039	28	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11039	29	waters	water	NNS
18637	11039	30	;	;	,
18637	11039	31	and	and	CC
18637	11039	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11039	33	2	2	LS
18637	11039	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11039	35	those	those	DT
18637	11039	36	involving	involve	VBG
18637	11039	37	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	11039	38	and	and	CC
18637	11039	39	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	11039	40	connected	connect	VBN
18637	11039	41	with	with	IN
18637	11039	42	shipping	shipping	NN
18637	11039	43	employed	employ	VBN
18637	11039	44	on	on	IN
18637	11039	45	the	the	DT
18637	11039	46	seas	sea	NNS
18637	11039	47	or	or	CC
18637	11039	48	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11039	49	waters	water	NNS
18637	11039	50	.	.	.
18637	11040	1	In	in	IN
18637	11040	2	the	the	DT
18637	11040	3	first	first	JJ
18637	11040	4	category	category	NN
18637	11040	5	,	,	,
18637	11040	6	which	which	WDT
18637	11040	7	includes	include	VBZ
18637	11040	8	prize	prize	NN
18637	11040	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	11040	10	,	,	,
18637	11040	11	and	and	CC
18637	11040	12	torts	tort	NNS
18637	11040	13	,	,	,
18637	11040	14	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	11040	15	,	,	,
18637	11040	16	and	and	CC
18637	11040	17	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	11040	18	committed	commit	VBN
18637	11040	19	on	on	IN
18637	11040	20	the	the	DT
18637	11040	21	high	high	JJ
18637	11040	22	seas	sea	NNS
18637	11040	23	,	,	,
18637	11040	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11040	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	11040	26	determined	determine	VBN
18637	11040	27	by	by	IN
18637	11040	28	the	the	DT
18637	11040	29	locality	locality	NN
18637	11040	30	of	of	IN
18637	11040	31	the	the	DT
18637	11040	32	act	act	NN
18637	11040	33	;	;	:
18637	11040	34	while	while	IN
18637	11040	35	in	in	IN
18637	11040	36	the	the	DT
18637	11040	37	second	second	JJ
18637	11040	38	category	category	NN
18637	11040	39	subject	subject	JJ
18637	11040	40	matter	matter	NN
18637	11040	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	11040	42	the	the	DT
18637	11040	43	primary	primary	JJ
18637	11040	44	determinative	determinative	JJ
18637	11040	45	factor	factor	NN
18637	11040	46	.	.	.
18637	11041	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11041	2	335	335	CD
18637	11041	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11041	4	Specifically	specifically	RB
18637	11041	5	,	,	,
18637	11041	6	contract	contract	NN
18637	11041	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	11041	8	include	include	VBP
18637	11041	9	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11041	10	by	by	IN
18637	11041	11	seamen	seaman	NNS
18637	11041	12	for	for	IN
18637	11041	13	wages,[336	wages,[336	NNP
18637	11041	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11041	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	11041	16	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11041	17	out	out	IN
18637	11041	18	of	of	IN
18637	11041	19	marine	marine	JJ
18637	11041	20	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	11041	21	policies,[337	policies,[337	NN
18637	11041	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11041	23	actions	action	NNS
18637	11041	24	for	for	IN
18637	11041	25	towage[338	towage[338	NNS
18637	11041	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11041	27	or	or	CC
18637	11041	28	pilotage[339	pilotage[339	FW
18637	11041	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11041	30	charges	charge	NNS
18637	11041	31	,	,	,
18637	11041	32	actions	action	NNS
18637	11041	33	on	on	IN
18637	11041	34	bottomry	bottomry	NNS
18637	11041	35	or	or	CC
18637	11041	36	respondentia	respondentia	NN
18637	11041	37	bonds,[340	bonds,[340	NNP
18637	11041	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11041	39	actions	action	NNS
18637	11041	40	for	for	IN
18637	11041	41	repairs	repair	NNS
18637	11041	42	on	on	IN
18637	11041	43	a	a	DT
18637	11041	44	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	11041	45	already	already	RB
18637	11041	46	used	use	VBN
18637	11041	47	in	in	IN
18637	11041	48	navigation,[341	navigation,[341	NN
18637	11041	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11041	50	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	11041	51	of	of	IN
18637	11041	52	affreightment,[342	affreightment,[342	NN
18637	11041	53	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11041	54	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	11041	55	for	for	IN
18637	11041	56	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	11041	57	wharfage,[343	wharfage,[343	NN
18637	11041	58	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11041	59	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	11041	60	of	of	IN
18637	11041	61	consortship	consortship	NN
18637	11041	62	between	between	IN
18637	11041	63	the	the	DT
18637	11041	64	masters	master	NNS
18637	11041	65	of	of	IN
18637	11041	66	two	two	CD
18637	11041	67	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	11041	68	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	11041	69	in	in	IN
18637	11041	70	wrecking,[344	wrecking,[344	NNP
18637	11041	71	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11041	72	and	and	CC
18637	11041	73	surveys	survey	NNS
18637	11041	74	of	of	IN
18637	11041	75	damaged	damaged	JJ
18637	11041	76	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	11041	77	.	.	.
18637	11042	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11042	2	345	345	CD
18637	11042	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11042	4	In	in	IN
18637	11042	5	the	the	DT
18637	11042	6	words	word	NNS
18637	11042	7	of	of	IN
18637	11042	8	the	the	DT
18637	11042	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11042	10	in	in	IN
18637	11042	11	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11042	12	parte	parte	NNP
18637	11042	13	Easton,[346	easton,[346	NN
18637	11042	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11042	15	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11042	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11042	17	"	"	''
18637	11042	18	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	11042	19	to	to	IN
18637	11042	20	all	all	DT
18637	11042	21	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	11042	22	,	,	,
18637	11042	23	claims	claim	NNS
18637	11042	24	and	and	CC
18637	11042	25	services	service	NNS
18637	11042	26	essentially	essentially	RB
18637	11042	27	maritime	maritime	RB
18637	11042	28	.	.	.
18637	11042	29	"	"	''
18637	11043	1	MARITIME	MARITIME	NNP
18637	11043	2	TORTS	TORTS	NNP
18637	11043	3	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	11043	4	of	of	IN
18637	11043	5	maritime	maritime	NN
18637	11043	6	torts	tort	NNS
18637	11043	7	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	11043	8	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	11043	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	11043	10	the	the	DT
18637	11043	11	commission	commission	NN
18637	11043	12	of	of	IN
18637	11043	13	the	the	DT
18637	11043	14	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
18637	11043	15	act	act	NN
18637	11043	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	11043	17	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11043	18	waters[347	waters[347	.
18637	11043	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11043	20	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	11043	21	of	of	IN
18637	11043	22	the	the	DT
18637	11043	23	voyage	voyage	NN
18637	11043	24	and	and	CC
18637	11043	25	the	the	DT
18637	11043	26	destination	destination	NN
18637	11043	27	of	of	IN
18637	11043	28	the	the	DT
18637	11043	29	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	11043	30	.	.	.
18637	11044	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11044	2	348	348	CD
18637	11044	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11044	4	By	by	IN
18637	11044	5	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	11044	6	elaboration	elaboration	NN
18637	11044	7	,	,	,
18637	11044	8	as	as	RB
18637	11044	9	well	well	RB
18637	11044	10	as	as	IN
18637	11044	11	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11044	12	decision	decision	NN
18637	11044	13	,	,	,
18637	11044	14	maritime	maritime	NN
18637	11044	15	torts	tort	NNS
18637	11044	16	include	include	VBP
18637	11044	17	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	11044	18	to	to	IN
18637	11044	19	persons,[349	persons,[349	NNP
18637	11044	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11044	21	damages	damage	NNS
18637	11044	22	to	to	IN
18637	11044	23	property	property	NN
18637	11044	24	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11044	25	out	out	IN
18637	11044	26	of	of	IN
18637	11044	27	collisions	collision	NNS
18637	11044	28	or	or	CC
18637	11044	29	other	other	JJ
18637	11044	30	negligent	negligent	JJ
18637	11044	31	acts,[350	acts,[350	NNP
18637	11044	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11044	33	and	and	CC
18637	11044	34	violent	violent	JJ
18637	11044	35	dispossession	dispossession	NN
18637	11044	36	of	of	IN
18637	11044	37	property	property	NN
18637	11044	38	.	.	.
18637	11045	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11045	2	351	351	CD
18637	11045	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11045	4	But	but	CC
18637	11045	5	until	until	IN
18637	11045	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11045	7	makes	make	VBZ
18637	11045	8	some	some	DT
18637	11045	9	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	11045	10	touching	touch	VBG
18637	11045	11	the	the	DT
18637	11045	12	liability	liability	NN
18637	11045	13	of	of	IN
18637	11045	14	parties	party	NNS
18637	11045	15	for	for	IN
18637	11045	16	marine	marine	JJ
18637	11045	17	torts	tort	NNS
18637	11045	18	resulting	result	VBG
18637	11045	19	in	in	IN
18637	11045	20	the	the	DT
18637	11045	21	death	death	NN
18637	11045	22	of	of	IN
18637	11045	23	the	the	DT
18637	11045	24	persons	person	NNS
18637	11045	25	injured	injure	VBN
18637	11045	26	,	,	,
18637	11045	27	a	a	DT
18637	11045	28	State	state	NN
18637	11045	29	statute	statute	NN
18637	11045	30	providing	provide	VBG
18637	11045	31	"	"	``
18637	11045	32	that	that	IN
18637	11045	33	when	when	WRB
18637	11045	34	the	the	DT
18637	11045	35	death	death	NN
18637	11045	36	of	of	IN
18637	11045	37	one	one	CD
18637	11045	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	11045	39	caused	cause	VBN
18637	11045	40	by	by	IN
18637	11045	41	the	the	DT
18637	11045	42	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
18637	11045	43	act	act	NN
18637	11045	44	or	or	CC
18637	11045	45	omission	omission	NN
18637	11045	46	of	of	IN
18637	11045	47	another	another	DT
18637	11045	48	,	,	,
18637	11045	49	the	the	DT
18637	11045	50	personal	personal	JJ
18637	11045	51	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	11045	52	of	of	IN
18637	11045	53	the	the	DT
18637	11045	54	former	former	JJ
18637	11045	55	may	may	MD
18637	11045	56	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	11045	57	an	an	DT
18637	11045	58	action	action	NN
18637	11045	59	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	11045	60	against	against	IN
18637	11045	61	the	the	DT
18637	11045	62	latter	latter	JJ
18637	11045	63	,	,	,
18637	11045	64	if	if	IN
18637	11045	65	the	the	DT
18637	11045	66	former	former	JJ
18637	11045	67	might	may	MD
18637	11045	68	have	have	VB
18637	11045	69	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	11045	70	an	an	DT
18637	11045	71	action	action	NN
18637	11045	72	,	,	,
18637	11045	73	had	have	VBD
18637	11045	74	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11045	75	lived	live	VBD
18637	11045	76	,	,	,
18637	11045	77	against	against	IN
18637	11045	78	the	the	DT
18637	11045	79	latter	latter	JJ
18637	11045	80	for	for	IN
18637	11045	81	an	an	DT
18637	11045	82	injury	injury	NN
18637	11045	83	for	for	IN
18637	11045	84	the	the	DT
18637	11045	85	same	same	JJ
18637	11045	86	act	act	NN
18637	11045	87	or	or	CC
18637	11045	88	omission	omission	NN
18637	11045	89	,	,	,
18637	11045	90	"	"	''
18637	11045	91	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	11045	92	,	,	,
18637	11045	93	and	and	CC
18637	11045	94	,	,	,
18637	11045	95	as	as	IN
18637	11045	96	thus	thus	RB
18637	11045	97	applied	apply	VBN
18637	11045	98	,	,	,
18637	11045	99	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11045	100	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	11045	101	no	no	DT
18637	11045	102	encroachment	encroachment	NN
18637	11045	103	upon	upon	IN
18637	11045	104	the	the	DT
18637	11045	105	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	11045	106	power	power	NN
18637	11045	107	of	of	IN
18637	11045	108	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11045	109	.	.	.
18637	11046	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11046	2	352	352	CD
18637	11046	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11046	4	PRIZE	prize	NN
18637	11046	5	CASES	case	NNS
18637	11046	6	,	,	,
18637	11046	7	FORFEITURES	FORFEITURES	NNP
18637	11046	8	,	,	,
18637	11046	9	ETC	ETC	NNP
18637	11046	10	.	.	.
18637	11047	1	From	from	IN
18637	11047	2	the	the	DT
18637	11047	3	earliest	early	JJS
18637	11047	4	days	day	NNS
18637	11047	5	of	of	IN
18637	11047	6	the	the	DT
18637	11047	7	Republic	Republic	NNP
18637	11047	8	,	,	,
18637	11047	9	the	the	DT
18637	11047	10	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11047	11	courts	court	NNS
18637	11047	12	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	11047	13	in	in	IN
18637	11047	14	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11047	15	have	have	VBP
18637	11047	16	been	be	VBN
18637	11047	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	11047	18	to	to	TO
18637	11047	19	have	have	VB
18637	11047	20	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11047	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11047	22	of	of	IN
18637	11047	23	prize	prize	NN
18637	11047	24	cases	case	NNS
18637	11047	25	.	.	.
18637	11048	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11048	2	353	353	CD
18637	11048	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11048	4	Also	also	RB
18637	11048	5	,	,	,
18637	11048	6	in	in	IN
18637	11048	7	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	11048	8	to	to	IN
18637	11048	9	other	other	JJ
18637	11048	10	phases	phase	NNS
18637	11048	11	of	of	IN
18637	11048	12	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11048	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11048	14	prize	prize	NN
18637	11048	15	law	law	NN
18637	11048	16	as	as	IN
18637	11048	17	applied	apply	VBN
18637	11048	18	by	by	IN
18637	11048	19	the	the	DT
18637	11048	20	British	british	JJ
18637	11048	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	11048	22	continued	continue	VBD
18637	11048	23	to	to	TO
18637	11048	24	provide	provide	VB
18637	11048	25	the	the	DT
18637	11048	26	basis	basis	NN
18637	11048	27	of	of	IN
18637	11048	28	American	american	JJ
18637	11048	29	law	law	NN
18637	11048	30	so	so	RB
18637	11048	31	far	far	RB
18637	11048	32	as	as	IN
18637	11048	33	practicable,[354	practicable,[354	NNP
18637	11048	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11048	35	and	and	CC
18637	11048	36	so	so	RB
18637	11048	37	far	far	RB
18637	11048	38	as	as	IN
18637	11048	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11048	40	was	be	VBD
18637	11048	41	not	not	RB
18637	11048	42	modified	modify	VBN
18637	11048	43	by	by	IN
18637	11048	44	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	11048	45	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	11048	46	,	,	,
18637	11048	47	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	11048	48	,	,	,
18637	11048	49	or	or	CC
18637	11048	50	executive	executive	JJ
18637	11048	51	proclamations	proclamation	NNS
18637	11048	52	.	.	.
18637	11049	1	Finally	finally	RB
18637	11049	2	,	,	,
18637	11049	3	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11049	4	and	and	CC
18637	11049	5	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11049	6	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11049	7	comprises	comprise	VBZ
18637	11049	8	the	the	DT
18637	11049	9	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	11049	10	and	and	CC
18637	11049	11	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	11049	12	of	of	IN
18637	11049	13	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	11049	14	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	11049	15	in	in	IN
18637	11049	16	activities	activity	NNS
18637	11049	17	in	in	IN
18637	11049	18	violation	violation	NN
18637	11049	19	of	of	IN
18637	11049	20	the	the	DT
18637	11049	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	11049	22	of	of	IN
18637	11049	23	nations	nation	NNS
18637	11049	24	or	or	CC
18637	11049	25	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	11049	26	law	law	NN
18637	11049	27	,	,	,
18637	11049	28	such	such	JJ
18637	11049	29	as	as	IN
18637	11049	30	illicit	illicit	JJ
18637	11049	31	trade,[355	trade,[355	NN
18637	11049	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11049	33	infraction	infraction	NN
18637	11049	34	of	of	IN
18637	11049	35	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	11049	36	laws,[356	laws,[356	NN
18637	11049	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11049	38	and	and	CC
18637	11049	39	the	the	DT
18637	11049	40	like	like	JJ
18637	11049	41	.	.	.
18637	11050	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11050	2	357	357	CD
18637	11050	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11050	4	PROCEEDINGS	PROCEEDINGS	NNP
18637	11050	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11050	6	IN	IN	NNP
18637	11050	7	REM	REM	NNP
18637	11050	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11050	9	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	11050	10	in	in	IN
18637	11050	11	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11050	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11050	13	differs	differ	NNS
18637	11050	14	in	in	IN
18637	11050	15	few	few	JJ
18637	11050	16	respects	respect	NNS
18637	11050	17	from	from	IN
18637	11050	18	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	11050	19	in	in	IN
18637	11050	20	actions	action	NNS
18637	11050	21	at	at	IN
18637	11050	22	law	law	NN
18637	11050	23	,	,	,
18637	11050	24	but	but	CC
18637	11050	25	the	the	DT
18637	11050	26	differences	difference	NNS
18637	11050	27	that	that	WDT
18637	11050	28	do	do	VBP
18637	11050	29	exist	exist	VB
18637	11050	30	are	be	VBP
18637	11050	31	significant	significant	JJ
18637	11050	32	.	.	.
18637	11051	1	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	11051	2	in	in	IN
18637	11051	3	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11051	4	take	take	VBP
18637	11051	5	the	the	DT
18637	11051	6	form	form	NN
18637	11051	7	of	of	IN
18637	11051	8	a	a	DT
18637	11051	9	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	11051	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11051	11	in	in	IN
18637	11051	12	rem	rem	NNP
18637	11051	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11051	14	against	against	IN
18637	11051	15	the	the	DT
18637	11051	16	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	11051	17	and	and	CC
18637	11051	18	,	,	,
18637	11051	19	with	with	IN
18637	11051	20	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	11051	21	to	to	TO
18637	11051	22	be	be	VB
18637	11051	23	noted	note	VBN
18637	11051	24	,	,	,
18637	11051	25	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11051	26	_	_	NNP
18637	11051	27	in	in	IN
18637	11051	28	rem	rem	NNP
18637	11051	29	_	_	NNP
18637	11051	30	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	11051	31	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11051	32	waters	water	NNS
18637	11051	33	are	be	VBP
18637	11051	34	confined	confine	VBN
18637	11051	35	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	11051	36	to	to	IN
18637	11051	37	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11051	38	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11051	39	courts	court	NNS
18637	11051	40	.	.	.
18637	11052	1	However	however	RB
18637	11052	2	,	,	,
18637	11052	3	if	if	IN
18637	11052	4	a	a	DT
18637	11052	5	common	common	JJ
18637	11052	6	law	law	NN
18637	11052	7	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	11052	8	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	11052	9	,	,	,
18637	11052	10	a	a	DT
18637	11052	11	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11052	12	may	may	MD
18637	11052	13	bring	bring	VB
18637	11052	14	an	an	DT
18637	11052	15	action	action	NN
18637	11052	16	at	at	IN
18637	11052	17	law	law	NN
18637	11052	18	in	in	IN
18637	11052	19	either	either	CC
18637	11052	20	a	a	DT
18637	11052	21	State	State	NNP
18637	11052	22	or	or	CC
18637	11052	23	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11052	24	court	court	NN
18637	11052	25	of	of	IN
18637	11052	26	competent	competent	NNP
18637	11052	27	jurisdiction,[358	jurisdiction,[358	NNP
18637	11052	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11052	29	but	but	CC
18637	11052	30	in	in	IN
18637	11052	31	this	this	DT
18637	11052	32	event	event	NN
18637	11052	33	the	the	DT
18637	11052	34	action	action	NN
18637	11052	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	11052	36	a	a	DT
18637	11052	37	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	11052	38	_	_	NNP
18637	11052	39	in	in	IN
18637	11052	40	personam	personam	NNP
18637	11052	41	_	_	NNP
18637	11052	42	against	against	IN
18637	11052	43	the	the	DT
18637	11052	44	owner	owner	NN
18637	11052	45	of	of	IN
18637	11052	46	the	the	DT
18637	11052	47	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	11052	48	.	.	.
18637	11053	1	On	on	IN
18637	11053	2	the	the	DT
18637	11053	3	other	other	JJ
18637	11053	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	11053	5	,	,	,
18637	11053	6	although	although	IN
18637	11053	7	the	the	DT
18637	11053	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11053	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	11053	10	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	11053	11	used	use	VBN
18637	11053	12	language	language	NN
18637	11053	13	which	which	WDT
18637	11053	14	would	would	MD
18637	11053	15	confine	confine	VB
18637	11053	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11053	17	_	_	NNP
18637	11053	18	in	in	IN
18637	11053	19	rem	rem	NNP
18637	11053	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11053	21	to	to	IN
18637	11053	22	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11053	23	courts,[359	courts,[359	NN
18637	11053	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11053	25	yet	yet	CC
18637	11053	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11053	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	11053	28	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	11053	29	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11053	30	_	_	NNP
18637	11053	31	in	in	IN
18637	11053	32	rem	rem	NNP
18637	11053	33	_	_	NNP
18637	11053	34	in	in	IN
18637	11053	35	the	the	DT
18637	11053	36	State	State	NNP
18637	11053	37	courts	court	NNS
18637	11053	38	in	in	IN
18637	11053	39	actions	action	NNS
18637	11053	40	of	of	IN
18637	11053	41	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	11053	42	.	.	.
18637	11054	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	11054	2	in	in	IN
18637	11054	3	the	the	DT
18637	11054	4	case	case	NN
18637	11054	5	of	of	IN
18637	11054	6	C.J.	C.J.	NNP
18637	11055	1	Hendry	Hendry	NNP
18637	11055	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11055	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11055	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	11055	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11055	6	Moore,[360	Moore,[360	NNP
18637	11055	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11055	8	the	the	DT
18637	11055	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11055	10	held	hold	VBD
18637	11055	11	that	that	IN
18637	11055	12	a	a	DT
18637	11055	13	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	11055	14	_	_	NNP
18637	11055	15	in	in	IN
18637	11055	16	rem	rem	NNP
18637	11055	17	_	_	NNP
18637	11055	18	in	in	IN
18637	11055	19	a	a	DT
18637	11055	20	State	State	NNP
18637	11055	21	court	court	NN
18637	11055	22	against	against	IN
18637	11055	23	fishing	fishing	NN
18637	11055	24	nets	net	NNS
18637	11055	25	in	in	IN
18637	11055	26	the	the	DT
18637	11055	27	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11055	28	waters	water	NNS
18637	11055	29	of	of	IN
18637	11055	30	California	California	NNP
18637	11055	31	was	be	VBD
18637	11055	32	a	a	DT
18637	11055	33	common	common	JJ
18637	11055	34	law	law	NN
18637	11055	35	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	11055	36	within	within	IN
18637	11055	37	the	the	DT
18637	11055	38	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	11055	39	of	of	IN
18637	11055	40	§	§	NNP
18637	11055	41	9	9	CD
18637	11055	42	of	of	IN
18637	11055	43	the	the	DT
18637	11055	44	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11055	45	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11055	46	of	of	IN
18637	11055	47	1789	1789	CD
18637	11055	48	,	,	,
18637	11055	49	and	and	CC
18637	11055	50	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11055	51	within	within	IN
18637	11055	52	the	the	DT
18637	11055	53	exception	exception	NN
18637	11055	54	to	to	IN
18637	11055	55	the	the	DT
18637	11055	56	grant	grant	NN
18637	11055	57	of	of	IN
18637	11055	58	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11055	59	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11055	60	to	to	IN
18637	11055	61	the	the	DT
18637	11055	62	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11055	63	courts	court	NNS
18637	11055	64	.	.	.
18637	11056	1	At	at	IN
18637	11056	2	the	the	DT
18637	11056	3	same	same	JJ
18637	11056	4	time	time	NN
18637	11056	5	,	,	,
18637	11056	6	however	however	RB
18637	11056	7	,	,	,
18637	11056	8	the	the	DT
18637	11056	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11056	10	was	be	VBD
18637	11056	11	careful	careful	JJ
18637	11056	12	to	to	TO
18637	11056	13	confine	confine	VB
18637	11056	14	such	such	JJ
18637	11056	15	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11056	16	to	to	IN
18637	11056	17	forfeitures	forfeiture	NNS
18637	11056	18	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11056	19	out	out	IN
18637	11056	20	of	of	IN
18637	11056	21	violations	violation	NNS
18637	11056	22	of	of	IN
18637	11056	23	State	State	NNP
18637	11056	24	law	law	NN
18637	11056	25	.	.	.
18637	11057	1	ABSENCE	absence	NN
18637	11057	2	OF	of	IN
18637	11057	3	A	a	DT
18637	11057	4	JURY	jury	NN
18637	11057	5	Another	another	DT
18637	11057	6	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	11057	7	difference	difference	NN
18637	11057	8	between	between	IN
18637	11057	9	actions	action	NNS
18637	11057	10	at	at	IN
18637	11057	11	law	law	NN
18637	11057	12	and	and	CC
18637	11057	13	in	in	IN
18637	11057	14	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11057	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	11057	16	the	the	DT
18637	11057	17	absence	absence	NN
18637	11057	18	of	of	IN
18637	11057	19	jury	jury	NN
18637	11057	20	trial	trial	NN
18637	11057	21	in	in	IN
18637	11057	22	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11057	23	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11057	24	in	in	IN
18637	11057	25	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11057	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	11057	27	unless	unless	IN
18637	11057	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11057	29	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	11057	30	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	11057	31	for	for	IN
18637	11057	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11057	33	.	.	.
18637	11058	1	Otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	11058	2	the	the	DT
18637	11058	3	judge	judge	NN
18637	11058	4	of	of	IN
18637	11058	5	an	an	DT
18637	11058	6	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11058	7	court	court	NN
18637	11058	8	tries	try	VBZ
18637	11058	9	issues	issue	NNS
18637	11058	10	of	of	IN
18637	11058	11	fact	fact	NN
18637	11058	12	as	as	RB
18637	11058	13	well	well	RB
18637	11058	14	as	as	IN
18637	11058	15	of	of	IN
18637	11058	16	law	law	NN
18637	11058	17	.	.	.
18637	11059	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11059	2	361	361	CD
18637	11059	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11059	4	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	11059	5	,	,	,
18637	11059	6	the	the	DT
18637	11059	7	absence	absence	NN
18637	11059	8	of	of	IN
18637	11059	9	a	a	DT
18637	11059	10	jury	jury	NN
18637	11059	11	in	in	IN
18637	11059	12	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11059	13	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11059	14	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	11059	15	to	to	TO
18637	11059	16	have	have	VB
18637	11059	17	been	be	VBN
18637	11059	18	one	one	CD
18637	11059	19	of	of	IN
18637	11059	20	the	the	DT
18637	11059	21	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	11059	22	why	why	WRB
18637	11059	23	the	the	DT
18637	11059	24	English	english	JJ
18637	11059	25	government	government	NN
18637	11059	26	vested	vest	VBD
18637	11059	27	a	a	DT
18637	11059	28	broad	broad	JJ
18637	11059	29	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11059	30	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11059	31	in	in	IN
18637	11059	32	the	the	DT
18637	11059	33	colonial	colonial	JJ
18637	11059	34	vice	vice	NN
18637	11059	35	-	-	HYPH
18637	11059	36	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11059	37	courts	court	NNS
18637	11059	38	of	of	IN
18637	11059	39	America	America	NNP
18637	11059	40	,	,	,
18637	11059	41	since	since	IN
18637	11059	42	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11059	43	provided	provide	VBD
18637	11059	44	a	a	DT
18637	11059	45	forum	forum	NN
18637	11059	46	where	where	WRB
18637	11059	47	the	the	DT
18637	11059	48	English	english	JJ
18637	11059	49	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	11059	50	could	could	MD
18637	11059	51	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11059	52	the	the	DT
18637	11059	53	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	11059	54	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	11059	55	without	without	IN
18637	11059	56	what	what	WP
18637	11059	57	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11059	58	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11059	59	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	11059	60	called	call	VBD
18637	11059	61	"	"	``
18637	11059	62	the	the	DT
18637	11059	63	obstinate	obstinate	NN
18637	11059	64	resistance	resistance	NN
18637	11059	65	of	of	IN
18637	11059	66	American	american	JJ
18637	11059	67	juries	jury	NNS
18637	11059	68	.	.	.
18637	11060	1	"	"	``
18637	11060	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11060	3	362	362	CD
18637	11060	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11060	5	TERRITORIAL	territorial	NN
18637	11060	6	EXTENT	extent	NN
18637	11060	7	OF	of	IN
18637	11060	8	ADMIRALTY	ADMIRALTY	NNP
18637	11060	9	AND	and	CC
18637	11060	10	MARITIME	MARITIME	NNP
18637	11060	11	JURISDICTION	JURISDICTION	NNP
18637	11060	12	As	as	RB
18637	11060	13	early	early	RB
18637	11060	14	as	as	IN
18637	11060	15	1821	1821	CD
18637	11060	16	a	a	DT
18637	11060	17	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11060	18	district	district	NN
18637	11060	19	court	court	NN
18637	11060	20	in	in	IN
18637	11060	21	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	11060	22	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	11060	23	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11060	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11060	25	over	over	IN
18637	11060	26	inland	inland	JJ
18637	11060	27	waterways	waterway	NNS
18637	11060	28	to	to	IN
18637	11060	29	the	the	DT
18637	11060	30	consternation	consternation	NN
18637	11060	31	of	of	IN
18637	11060	32	certain	certain	JJ
18637	11060	33	interests	interest	NNS
18637	11060	34	in	in	IN
18637	11060	35	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	11060	36	which	which	WDT
18637	11060	37	succeeded	succeed	VBD
18637	11060	38	in	in	IN
18637	11060	39	inducing	induce	VBG
18637	11060	40	the	the	DT
18637	11060	41	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	11060	42	to	to	TO
18637	11060	43	pass	pass	VB
18637	11060	44	a	a	DT
18637	11060	45	bill	bill	NN
18637	11060	46	confining	confine	VBG
18637	11060	47	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11060	48	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11060	49	to	to	IN
18637	11060	50	the	the	DT
18637	11060	51	ebb	ebb	NN
18637	11060	52	and	and	CC
18637	11060	53	flow	flow	NN
18637	11060	54	of	of	IN
18637	11060	55	the	the	DT
18637	11060	56	tide	tide	NN
18637	11060	57	,	,	,
18637	11060	58	only	only	RB
18637	11060	59	to	to	TO
18637	11060	60	see	see	VB
18637	11060	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11060	62	defeated	defeat	VBN
18637	11060	63	in	in	IN
18637	11060	64	the	the	DT
18637	11060	65	House	House	NNP
18637	11060	66	.	.	.
18637	11061	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11061	2	363	363	CD
18637	11061	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11061	4	However	however	RB
18637	11061	5	,	,	,
18637	11061	6	in	in	IN
18637	11061	7	1825	1825	CD
18637	11061	8	,	,	,
18637	11061	9	in	in	IN
18637	11061	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11061	11	The	the	DT
18637	11061	12	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	11061	13	Jefferson_[364	Jefferson_[364	NNP
18637	11061	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11061	15	the	the	DT
18637	11061	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11061	17	relieved	relieve	VBD
18637	11061	18	these	these	DT
18637	11061	19	tensions	tension	NNS
18637	11061	20	by	by	IN
18637	11061	21	confining	confine	VBG
18637	11061	22	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11061	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11061	24	to	to	IN
18637	11061	25	the	the	DT
18637	11061	26	high	high	JJ
18637	11061	27	seas	sea	NNS
18637	11061	28	and	and	CC
18637	11061	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	11061	30	rivers	river	NNS
18637	11061	31	as	as	RB
18637	11061	32	far	far	RB
18637	11061	33	as	as	IN
18637	11061	34	the	the	DT
18637	11061	35	ebb	ebb	NN
18637	11061	36	and	and	CC
18637	11061	37	flow	flow	NN
18637	11061	38	of	of	IN
18637	11061	39	the	the	DT
18637	11061	40	tide	tide	NN
18637	11061	41	extended	extend	VBN
18637	11061	42	in	in	IN
18637	11061	43	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	11061	44	with	with	IN
18637	11061	45	the	the	DT
18637	11061	46	English	English	NNP
18637	11061	47	rule	rule	NN
18637	11061	48	.	.	.
18637	11062	1	Twenty	twenty	CD
18637	11062	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	11062	3	two	two	CD
18637	11062	4	years	year	NNS
18637	11062	5	later	later	RB
18637	11062	6	this	this	DT
18637	11062	7	rule	rule	NN
18637	11062	8	was	be	VBD
18637	11062	9	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	11062	10	in	in	IN
18637	11062	11	Waring	Waring	NNP
18637	11062	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11062	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	11062	14	_	_	NNP
18637	11062	15	Clarke,[365	Clarke,[365	NNP
18637	11062	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11062	17	when	when	WRB
18637	11062	18	the	the	DT
18637	11062	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11062	20	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	11062	21	that	that	IN
18637	11062	22	the	the	DT
18637	11062	23	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11062	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11062	25	under	under	IN
18637	11062	26	the	the	DT
18637	11062	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11062	28	was	be	VBD
18637	11062	29	not	not	RB
18637	11062	30	to	to	TO
18637	11062	31	be	be	VB
18637	11062	32	limited	limit	VBN
18637	11062	33	or	or	CC
18637	11062	34	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	11062	35	by	by	IN
18637	11062	36	English	english	JJ
18637	11062	37	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11062	38	of	of	IN
18637	11062	39	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11062	40	and	and	CC
18637	11062	41	extended	extend	VBD
18637	11062	42	the	the	DT
18637	11062	43	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11062	44	of	of	IN
18637	11062	45	the	the	DT
18637	11062	46	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11062	47	courts	court	NNS
18637	11062	48	to	to	IN
18637	11062	49	a	a	DT
18637	11062	50	collision	collision	NN
18637	11062	51	on	on	IN
18637	11062	52	the	the	DT
18637	11062	53	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	11062	54	River	River	NNP
18637	11062	55	ninety	ninety	CD
18637	11062	56	-	-	HYPH
18637	11062	57	five	five	CD
18637	11062	58	miles	mile	NNS
18637	11062	59	above	above	IN
18637	11062	60	New	New	NNP
18637	11062	61	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	11062	62	.	.	.
18637	11063	1	In	in	IN
18637	11063	2	this	this	DT
18637	11063	3	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	11063	4	the	the	DT
18637	11063	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11063	6	moved	move	VBD
18637	11063	7	in	in	IN
18637	11063	8	the	the	DT
18637	11063	9	direction	direction	NN
18637	11063	10	of	of	IN
18637	11063	11	accommodating	accommodate	VBG
18637	11063	12	the	the	DT
18637	11063	13	rising	rise	VBG
18637	11063	14	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	11063	15	on	on	IN
18637	11063	16	the	the	DT
18637	11063	17	inland	inland	NN
18637	11063	18	waterways	waterway	NNS
18637	11063	19	and	and	CC
18637	11063	20	prepared	prepare	VBD
18637	11063	21	the	the	DT
18637	11063	22	way	way	NN
18637	11063	23	for	for	IN
18637	11063	24	the	the	DT
18637	11063	25	Genesee	Genesee	NNP
18637	11063	26	Chief,[366	Chief,[366	NNP
18637	11063	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11063	28	which	which	WDT
18637	11063	29	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	11063	30	The	the	DT
18637	11063	31	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	11063	32	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	11063	33	and	and	CC
18637	11063	34	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	11063	35	the	the	DT
18637	11063	36	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	11063	37	of	of	IN
18637	11063	38	an	an	DT
18637	11063	39	act	act	NN
18637	11063	40	of	of	IN
18637	11063	41	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11063	42	passed	pass	VBD
18637	11063	43	in	in	IN
18637	11063	44	1845	1845	CD
18637	11063	45	giving	give	VBG
18637	11063	46	the	the	DT
18637	11063	47	district	district	NN
18637	11063	48	courts	court	NNS
18637	11063	49	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11063	50	over	over	IN
18637	11063	51	the	the	DT
18637	11063	52	Great	Great	NNP
18637	11063	53	Lakes	Lakes	NNPS
18637	11063	54	and	and	CC
18637	11063	55	connecting	connect	VBG
18637	11063	56	waters	water	NNS
18637	11063	57	,	,	,
18637	11063	58	and	and	CC
18637	11063	59	so	so	RB
18637	11063	60	in	in	IN
18637	11063	61	effect	effect	NN
18637	11063	62	extended	extend	VBD
18637	11063	63	the	the	DT
18637	11063	64	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11063	65	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11063	66	to	to	IN
18637	11063	67	all	all	PDT
18637	11063	68	the	the	DT
18637	11063	69	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11063	70	waters	water	NNS
18637	11063	71	of	of	IN
18637	11063	72	the	the	DT
18637	11063	73	United	United	NNP
18637	11063	74	States	States	NNP
18637	11063	75	.	.	.
18637	11064	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11064	2	367	367	CD
18637	11064	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11064	4	The	the	DT
18637	11064	5	Genesee	Genesee	NNP
18637	11064	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11064	7	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11064	8	vastly	vastly	RB
18637	11064	9	expanded	expand	VBD
18637	11064	10	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11064	11	power,[368	power,[368	NN
18637	11064	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11064	13	and	and	CC
18637	11064	14	marked	mark	VBD
18637	11064	15	a	a	DT
18637	11064	16	trend	trend	NN
18637	11064	17	which	which	WDT
18637	11064	18	was	be	VBD
18637	11064	19	continued	continue	VBN
18637	11064	20	in	in	IN
18637	11064	21	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11064	22	parte	parte	NNP
18637	11064	23	Boyer,[369	Boyer,[369	NNP
18637	11064	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11064	25	where	where	WRB
18637	11064	26	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11064	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11064	28	was	be	VBD
18637	11064	29	extended	extend	VBN
18637	11064	30	to	to	IN
18637	11064	31	canals	canal	NNS
18637	11064	32	,	,	,
18637	11064	33	and	and	CC
18637	11064	34	in	in	IN
18637	11064	35	The	the	DT
18637	11064	36	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	11064	37	Ball,[370	Ball,[370	NNP
18637	11064	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11064	39	where	where	WRB
18637	11064	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11064	41	was	be	VBD
18637	11064	42	extended	extend	VBN
18637	11064	43	to	to	IN
18637	11064	44	waters	water	NNS
18637	11064	45	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	11064	46	within	within	IN
18637	11064	47	a	a	DT
18637	11064	48	given	give	VBN
18637	11064	49	State	state	NN
18637	11064	50	provided	provide	VBN
18637	11064	51	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11064	52	form	form	VBP
18637	11064	53	a	a	DT
18637	11064	54	connecting	connect	VBG
18637	11064	55	link	link	NN
18637	11064	56	in	in	IN
18637	11064	57	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	11064	58	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	11064	59	.	.	.
18637	11065	1	This	this	DT
18637	11065	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	11065	3	case	case	NN
18637	11065	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	11065	5	also	also	RB
18637	11065	6	significant	significant	JJ
18637	11065	7	for	for	IN
18637	11065	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11065	9	definition	definition	NN
18637	11065	10	of	of	IN
18637	11065	11	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11065	12	waters	water	NNS
18637	11065	13	of	of	IN
18637	11065	14	the	the	DT
18637	11065	15	United	United	NNP
18637	11065	16	States	States	NNP
18637	11065	17	as	as	IN
18637	11065	18	those	those	DT
18637	11065	19	that	that	WDT
18637	11065	20	are	be	VBP
18637	11065	21	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11065	22	in	in	IN
18637	11065	23	fact	fact	NN
18637	11065	24	,	,	,
18637	11065	25	and	and	CC
18637	11065	26	as	as	IN
18637	11065	27	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11065	28	in	in	IN
18637	11065	29	fact	fact	NN
18637	11065	30	when	when	WRB
18637	11065	31	so	so	RB
18637	11065	32	"	"	``
18637	11065	33	used	use	VBN
18637	11065	34	,	,	,
18637	11065	35	or	or	CC
18637	11065	36	*	*	NFP
18637	11065	37	*	*	NFP
18637	11065	38	*	*	NFP
18637	11065	39	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
18637	11065	40	of	of	IN
18637	11065	41	being	be	VBG
18637	11065	42	used	use	VBN
18637	11065	43	,	,	,
18637	11065	44	in	in	IN
18637	11065	45	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11065	46	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	11065	47	condition	condition	NN
18637	11065	48	,	,	,
18637	11065	49	as	as	IN
18637	11065	50	highways	highway	NNS
18637	11065	51	for	for	IN
18637	11065	52	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	11065	53	,	,	,
18637	11065	54	over	over	IN
18637	11065	55	which	which	WDT
18637	11065	56	trade	trade	NN
18637	11065	57	and	and	CC
18637	11065	58	travel	travel	NN
18637	11065	59	are	be	VBP
18637	11065	60	or	or	CC
18637	11065	61	may	may	MD
18637	11065	62	be	be	VB
18637	11065	63	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	11065	64	in	in	IN
18637	11065	65	the	the	DT
18637	11065	66	customary	customary	JJ
18637	11065	67	modes	mode	NNS
18637	11065	68	of	of	IN
18637	11065	69	trade	trade	NN
18637	11065	70	and	and	CC
18637	11065	71	travel	travel	NN
18637	11065	72	on	on	IN
18637	11065	73	water	water	NN
18637	11065	74	.	.	.
18637	11066	1	"	"	``
18637	11066	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11066	3	371	371	CD
18637	11066	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11066	5	The	the	DT
18637	11066	6	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	11066	7	left	leave	VBN
18637	11066	8	by	by	IN
18637	11066	9	the	the	DT
18637	11066	10	Ball	Ball	NNP
18637	11066	11	case	case	NN
18637	11066	12	in	in	IN
18637	11066	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11066	14	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	11066	15	between	between	IN
18637	11066	16	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11066	17	waters	water	NNS
18637	11066	18	of	of	IN
18637	11066	19	the	the	DT
18637	11066	20	United	United	NNP
18637	11066	21	States	States	NNP
18637	11066	22	and	and	CC
18637	11066	23	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11066	24	waters	water	NNS
18637	11066	25	of	of	IN
18637	11066	26	the	the	DT
18637	11066	27	States	States	NNPS
18637	11066	28	were	be	VBD
18637	11066	29	clarified	clarify	VBN
18637	11066	30	by	by	IN
18637	11066	31	In	in	IN
18637	11066	32	re	re	NN
18637	11066	33	Garnett,[372	garnett,[372	NN
18637	11066	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11066	35	where	where	WRB
18637	11066	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11066	37	was	be	VBD
18637	11066	38	held	hold	VBN
18637	11066	39	that	that	IN
18637	11066	40	the	the	DT
18637	11066	41	power	power	NN
18637	11066	42	of	of	IN
18637	11066	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11066	44	to	to	TO
18637	11066	45	amend	amend	VB
18637	11066	46	the	the	DT
18637	11066	47	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11066	48	law	law	NN
18637	11066	49	was	be	VBD
18637	11066	50	coextensive	coextensive	JJ
18637	11066	51	with	with	IN
18637	11066	52	that	that	DT
18637	11066	53	law	law	NN
18637	11066	54	and	and	CC
18637	11066	55	not	not	RB
18637	11066	56	confined	confine	VBN
18637	11066	57	"	"	''
18637	11066	58	to	to	IN
18637	11066	59	the	the	DT
18637	11066	60	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	11066	61	or	or	CC
18637	11066	62	class	class	NN
18637	11066	63	of	of	IN
18637	11066	64	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	11066	65	which	which	WDT
18637	11066	66	limit	limit	VBP
18637	11066	67	and	and	CC
18637	11066	68	characterize	characterize	VB
18637	11066	69	the	the	DT
18637	11066	70	power	power	NN
18637	11066	71	to	to	TO
18637	11066	72	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	11066	73	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	11066	74	,	,	,
18637	11066	75	"	"	''
18637	11066	76	and	and	CC
18637	11066	77	that	that	IN
18637	11066	78	the	the	DT
18637	11066	79	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11066	80	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11066	81	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	11066	82	"	"	''
18637	11066	83	to	to	IN
18637	11066	84	all	all	DT
18637	11066	85	public	public	JJ
18637	11066	86	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11066	87	lakes	lake	NNS
18637	11066	88	and	and	CC
18637	11066	89	rivers	river	NNS
18637	11066	90	.	.	.
18637	11066	91	"	"	''
18637	11067	1	In	in	IN
18637	11067	2	United	United	NNP
18637	11067	3	States	States	NNP
18637	11067	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11067	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	11067	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11067	7	Appalachian	Appalachian	NNP
18637	11067	8	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	11067	9	Power	Power	NNP
18637	11067	10	Co	Co	NNP
18637	11067	11	.	.	.
18637	11067	12	,[373	,[373	,
18637	11067	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11067	14	the	the	DT
18637	11067	15	concept	concept	NN
18637	11067	16	of	of	IN
18637	11067	17	"	"	``
18637	11067	18	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11067	19	waters	water	NNS
18637	11067	20	of	of	IN
18637	11067	21	the	the	DT
18637	11067	22	United	United	NNP
18637	11067	23	States	States	NNP
18637	11067	24	"	"	''
18637	11067	25	was	be	VBD
18637	11067	26	further	further	RB
18637	11067	27	expanded	expand	VBN
18637	11067	28	to	to	TO
18637	11067	29	include	include	VB
18637	11067	30	waterways	waterway	NNS
18637	11067	31	which	which	WDT
18637	11067	32	by	by	IN
18637	11067	33	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	11067	34	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	11067	35	can	can	MD
18637	11067	36	be	be	VB
18637	11067	37	made	make	VBN
18637	11067	38	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11067	39	for	for	IN
18637	11067	40	use	use	NN
18637	11067	41	in	in	IN
18637	11067	42	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	11067	43	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	11067	44	provided	provide	VBN
18637	11067	45	there	there	EX
18637	11067	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	11067	47	a	a	DT
18637	11067	48	balance	balance	NN
18637	11067	49	between	between	IN
18637	11067	50	cost	cost	NN
18637	11067	51	and	and	CC
18637	11067	52	need	need	VBP
18637	11067	53	at	at	IN
18637	11067	54	a	a	DT
18637	11067	55	time	time	NN
18637	11067	56	when	when	WRB
18637	11067	57	the	the	DT
18637	11067	58	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	11067	59	would	would	MD
18637	11067	60	be	be	VB
18637	11067	61	useful	useful	JJ
18637	11067	62	.	.	.
18637	11068	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	11068	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	11068	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11068	4	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11068	5	that	that	IN
18637	11068	6	the	the	DT
18637	11068	7	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	11068	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	11068	9	have	have	VB
18637	11068	10	been	be	VBN
18637	11068	11	undertaken	undertake	VBN
18637	11068	12	or	or	CC
18637	11068	13	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	11068	14	.	.	.
18637	11069	1	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	11069	2	,	,	,
18637	11069	3	a	a	DT
18637	11069	4	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11069	5	waterway	waterway	NN
18637	11069	6	of	of	IN
18637	11069	7	the	the	DT
18637	11069	8	United	United	NNP
18637	11069	9	States	States	NNP
18637	11069	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	11069	11	not	not	RB
18637	11069	12	cease	cease	VB
18637	11069	13	to	to	TO
18637	11069	14	be	be	VB
18637	11069	15	so	so	RB
18637	11069	16	because	because	IN
18637	11069	17	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	11069	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	11069	19	ceased	cease	VBN
18637	11069	20	,	,	,
18637	11069	21	and	and	CC
18637	11069	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11069	23	may	may	MD
18637	11069	24	be	be	VB
18637	11069	25	a	a	DT
18637	11069	26	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11069	27	waterway	waterway	NN
18637	11069	28	for	for	IN
18637	11069	29	only	only	JJ
18637	11069	30	part	part	NN
18637	11069	31	of	of	IN
18637	11069	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11069	33	course	course	NN
18637	11069	34	.	.	.
18637	11070	1	Although	although	IN
18637	11070	2	this	this	DT
18637	11070	3	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	11070	4	was	be	VBD
18637	11070	5	announced	announce	VBN
18637	11070	6	as	as	IN
18637	11070	7	an	an	DT
18637	11070	8	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11070	9	of	of	IN
18637	11070	10	the	the	DT
18637	11070	11	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	11070	12	clause	clause	NNP
18637	11070	13	,	,	,
18637	11070	14	the	the	DT
18637	11070	15	Garnett	Garnett	NNP
18637	11070	16	case	case	NN
18637	11070	17	and	and	CC
18637	11070	18	the	the	DT
18637	11070	19	decision	decision	NN
18637	11070	20	rendered	render	VBN
18637	11070	21	in	in	IN
18637	11070	22	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	11070	23	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	11070	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11070	25	_	_	NNP
18637	11070	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	11070	27	_	_	NNP
18637	11070	28	National	National	NNP
18637	11070	29	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	11070	30	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	11070	31	Board,[374	Board,[374	NNP
18637	11070	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11070	33	to	to	IN
18637	11070	34	the	the	DT
18637	11070	35	effect	effect	NN
18637	11070	36	that	that	WDT
18637	11070	37	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11070	38	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11070	39	includes	include	VBZ
18637	11070	40	all	all	DT
18637	11070	41	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11070	42	waters	water	NNS
18637	11070	43	within	within	IN
18637	11070	44	the	the	DT
18637	11070	45	country	country	NN
18637	11070	46	,	,	,
18637	11070	47	makes	make	VBZ
18637	11070	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11070	49	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	11070	50	also	also	RB
18637	11070	51	to	to	IN
18637	11070	52	the	the	DT
18637	11070	53	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11070	54	and	and	CC
18637	11070	55	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11070	56	clause	clause	NN
18637	11070	57	.	.	.
18637	11071	1	ADMIRALTY	ADMIRALTY	NNP
18637	11071	2	JURISDICTION	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11071	3	VERSUS	VERSUS	NNP
18637	11071	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	11071	5	POWER	power	NN
18637	11071	6	The	the	DT
18637	11071	7	extension	extension	NN
18637	11071	8	of	of	IN
18637	11071	9	the	the	DT
18637	11071	10	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11071	11	and	and	CC
18637	11071	12	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11071	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11071	14	to	to	IN
18637	11071	15	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11071	16	waters	water	NNS
18637	11071	17	within	within	IN
18637	11071	18	a	a	DT
18637	11071	19	State	state	NN
18637	11071	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	11071	21	not	not	RB
18637	11071	22	,	,	,
18637	11071	23	however	however	RB
18637	11071	24	,	,	,
18637	11071	25	of	of	IN
18637	11071	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11071	27	own	own	JJ
18637	11071	28	force	force	NN
18637	11071	29	include	include	VBP
18637	11071	30	general	general	JJ
18637	11071	31	or	or	CC
18637	11071	32	political	political	JJ
18637	11071	33	powers	power	NNS
18637	11071	34	of	of	IN
18637	11071	35	government	government	NN
18637	11071	36	.	.	.
18637	11072	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	11072	2	in	in	IN
18637	11072	3	the	the	DT
18637	11072	4	absence	absence	NN
18637	11072	5	of	of	IN
18637	11072	6	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	11072	7	by	by	IN
18637	11072	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11072	9	,	,	,
18637	11072	10	the	the	DT
18637	11072	11	States	States	NNPS
18637	11072	12	through	through	IN
18637	11072	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11072	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	11072	15	may	may	MD
18637	11072	16	punish	punish	VB
18637	11072	17	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	11072	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	11072	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11072	20	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	11072	21	waters	water	NNS
18637	11072	22	and	and	CC
18637	11072	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	11072	24	the	the	DT
18637	11072	25	sea	sea	NN
18637	11072	26	within	within	IN
18637	11072	27	one	one	CD
18637	11072	28	marine	marine	JJ
18637	11072	29	league	league	NN
18637	11072	30	of	of	IN
18637	11072	31	the	the	DT
18637	11072	32	shore	shore	NN
18637	11072	33	.	.	.
18637	11073	1	In	in	IN
18637	11073	2	United	United	NNP
18637	11073	3	States	States	NNP
18637	11073	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11073	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	11073	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11073	7	Bevans[375	Bevans[375	NNP
18637	11073	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11073	9	the	the	DT
18637	11073	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11073	11	denied	deny	VBD
18637	11073	12	the	the	DT
18637	11073	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11073	14	of	of	IN
18637	11073	15	a	a	DT
18637	11073	16	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11073	17	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	11073	18	court	court	NN
18637	11073	19	to	to	TO
18637	11073	20	try	try	VB
18637	11073	21	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	11073	22	for	for	IN
18637	11073	23	a	a	DT
18637	11073	24	murder	murder	NN
18637	11073	25	committed	commit	VBN
18637	11073	26	in	in	IN
18637	11073	27	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	11073	28	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	11073	29	in	in	IN
18637	11073	30	the	the	DT
18637	11073	31	absence	absence	NN
18637	11073	32	of	of	IN
18637	11073	33	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	11073	34	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	11073	35	of	of	IN
18637	11073	36	trials	trial	NNS
18637	11073	37	in	in	IN
18637	11073	38	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11073	39	courts	court	NNS
18637	11073	40	for	for	IN
18637	11073	41	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	11073	42	committed	commit	VBN
18637	11073	43	within	within	IN
18637	11073	44	the	the	DT
18637	11073	45	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11073	46	of	of	IN
18637	11073	47	a	a	DT
18637	11073	48	State	state	NN
18637	11073	49	.	.	.
18637	11074	1	While	while	IN
18637	11074	2	admitting	admit	VBG
18637	11074	3	that	that	IN
18637	11074	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11074	5	may	may	MD
18637	11074	6	pass	pass	VB
18637	11074	7	all	all	DT
18637	11074	8	laws	law	NNS
18637	11074	9	which	which	WDT
18637	11074	10	are	be	VBP
18637	11074	11	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11074	12	and	and	CC
18637	11074	13	proper	proper	JJ
18637	11074	14	for	for	IN
18637	11074	15	giving	give	VBG
18637	11074	16	complete	complete	JJ
18637	11074	17	effect	effect	NN
18637	11074	18	to	to	IN
18637	11074	19	admiralty	admiralty	VB
18637	11074	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11074	21	,	,	,
18637	11074	22	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11074	23	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11074	24	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11074	25	at	at	IN
18637	11074	26	the	the	DT
18637	11074	27	same	same	JJ
18637	11074	28	time	time	NN
18637	11074	29	declared	declare	VBD
18637	11074	30	that	that	IN
18637	11074	31	"	"	``
18637	11074	32	the	the	DT
18637	11074	33	general	general	JJ
18637	11074	34	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11074	35	over	over	IN
18637	11074	36	the	the	DT
18637	11074	37	place	place	NN
18637	11074	38	,	,	,
18637	11074	39	subject	subject	JJ
18637	11074	40	to	to	IN
18637	11074	41	this	this	DT
18637	11074	42	grant	grant	NN
18637	11074	43	of	of	IN
18637	11074	44	power	power	NN
18637	11074	45	,	,	,
18637	11074	46	adheres	adhere	VBZ
18637	11074	47	to	to	IN
18637	11074	48	the	the	DT
18637	11074	49	territory	territory	NN
18637	11074	50	,	,	,
18637	11074	51	as	as	IN
18637	11074	52	a	a	DT
18637	11074	53	portion	portion	NN
18637	11074	54	of	of	IN
18637	11074	55	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	11074	56	not	not	RB
18637	11074	57	yet	yet	RB
18637	11074	58	given	give	VBN
18637	11074	59	away	away	RP
18637	11074	60	.	.	.
18637	11075	1	The	the	DT
18637	11075	2	residuary	residuary	JJ
18637	11075	3	powers	power	NNS
18637	11075	4	of	of	IN
18637	11075	5	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	11075	6	are	be	VBP
18637	11075	7	still	still	RB
18637	11075	8	in	in	IN
18637	11075	9	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	11075	10	.	.	.
18637	11076	1	"	"	``
18637	11076	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11076	3	376	376	CD
18637	11076	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11076	5	Exclusiveness	Exclusiveness	NNP
18637	11076	6	of	of	IN
18637	11076	7	the	the	DT
18637	11076	8	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	11076	9	Determination	Determination	NNP
18637	11076	10	of	of	IN
18637	11076	11	the	the	DT
18637	11076	12	bounds	bound	NNS
18637	11076	13	of	of	IN
18637	11076	14	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11076	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11076	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	11076	17	a	a	DT
18637	11076	18	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11076	19	function	function	NN
18637	11076	20	,	,	,
18637	11076	21	and	and	CC
18637	11076	22	"	"	``
18637	11076	23	no	no	DT
18637	11076	24	State	State	NNP
18637	11076	25	law	law	NN
18637	11076	26	can	can	MD
18637	11076	27	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	11076	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11076	29	,	,	,
18637	11076	30	nor	nor	CC
18637	11076	31	can	can	MD
18637	11076	32	an	an	DT
18637	11076	33	act	act	NN
18637	11076	34	of	of	IN
18637	11076	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11076	36	or	or	CC
18637	11076	37	a	a	DT
18637	11076	38	rule	rule	NN
18637	11076	39	of	of	IN
18637	11076	40	court	court	NN
18637	11076	41	make	make	VB
18637	11076	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11076	43	broader	broad	JJR
18637	11076	44	than	than	IN
18637	11076	45	the	the	DT
18637	11076	46	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11076	47	power	power	NN
18637	11076	48	may	may	MD
18637	11076	49	determine	determine	VB
18637	11076	50	to	to	TO
18637	11076	51	be	be	VB
18637	11076	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11076	53	true	true	JJ
18637	11076	54	limits	limit	NNS
18637	11076	55	.	.	.
18637	11077	1	"	"	``
18637	11077	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11077	3	377	377	CD
18637	11077	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11077	5	Nor	nor	CC
18637	11077	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	11077	7	the	the	DT
18637	11077	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11077	9	self	self	NN
18637	11077	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	11077	11	executing	execute	VBG
18637	11077	12	.	.	.
18637	11078	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11078	2	can	can	MD
18637	11078	3	only	only	RB
18637	11078	4	be	be	VB
18637	11078	5	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	11078	6	under	under	IN
18637	11078	7	acts	act	NNS
18637	11078	8	of	of	IN
18637	11078	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11078	10	vesting	vest	VBG
18637	11078	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11078	12	in	in	IN
18637	11078	13	the	the	DT
18637	11078	14	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11078	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	11078	16	.	.	.
18637	11079	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11079	2	378	378	CD
18637	11079	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11079	4	The	the	DT
18637	11079	5	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11079	6	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11079	7	of	of	IN
18637	11079	8	the	the	DT
18637	11079	9	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11079	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	11079	11	was	be	VBD
18637	11079	12	made	make	VBN
18637	11079	13	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11079	14	of	of	IN
18637	11079	15	State	State	NNP
18637	11079	16	court	court	NN
18637	11079	17	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11079	18	by	by	IN
18637	11079	19	the	the	DT
18637	11079	20	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11079	21	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11079	22	of	of	IN
18637	11079	23	1789	1789	CD
18637	11079	24	according	accord	VBG
18637	11079	25	to	to	IN
18637	11079	26	The	the	DT
18637	11079	27	"	"	``
18637	11079	28	Moses	Moses	NNP
18637	11079	29	Taylor,"[379	Taylor,"[379	''
18637	11079	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11079	31	which	which	WDT
18637	11079	32	also	also	RB
18637	11079	33	held	hold	VBD
18637	11079	34	that	that	IN
18637	11079	35	State	State	NNP
18637	11079	36	laws	law	NNS
18637	11079	37	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	11079	38	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	11079	39	_	_	NNP
18637	11079	40	in	in	IN
18637	11079	41	rem	rem	NN
18637	11079	42	_	_	NNP
18637	11079	43	could	could	MD
18637	11079	44	only	only	RB
18637	11079	45	be	be	VB
18637	11079	46	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	11079	47	in	in	IN
18637	11079	48	the	the	DT
18637	11079	49	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11079	50	courts	court	NNS
18637	11079	51	.	.	.
18637	11080	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	11080	2	,	,	,
18637	11080	3	the	the	DT
18637	11080	4	State	State	NNP
18637	11080	5	courts	court	NNS
18637	11080	6	were	be	VBD
18637	11080	7	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	11080	8	of	of	IN
18637	11080	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11080	10	of	of	IN
18637	11080	11	a	a	DT
18637	11080	12	great	great	JJ
18637	11080	13	number	number	NN
18637	11080	14	of	of	IN
18637	11080	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	11080	16	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11080	17	out	out	IN
18637	11080	18	of	of	IN
18637	11080	19	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11080	20	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	11080	21	and	and	CC
18637	11080	22	torts	tort	NNS
18637	11080	23	over	over	IN
18637	11080	24	which	which	WDT
18637	11080	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11080	26	had	have	VBD
18637	11080	27	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	11080	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11080	29	prior	prior	RB
18637	11080	30	to	to	IN
18637	11080	31	1866	1866	CD
18637	11080	32	.	.	.
18637	11081	1	However	however	RB
18637	11081	2	,	,	,
18637	11081	3	as	as	IN
18637	11081	4	before	before	RB
18637	11081	5	noted	note	VBN
18637	11081	6	,	,	,
18637	11081	7	the	the	DT
18637	11081	8	ninth	ninth	JJ
18637	11081	9	section	section	NN
18637	11081	10	of	of	IN
18637	11081	11	the	the	DT
18637	11081	12	act	act	NN
18637	11081	13	of	of	IN
18637	11081	14	1789	1789	CD
18637	11081	15	contained	contain	VBD
18637	11081	16	a	a	DT
18637	11081	17	provision	provision	NN
18637	11081	18	,	,	,
18637	11081	19	still	still	RB
18637	11081	20	in	in	IN
18637	11081	21	effect	effect	NN
18637	11081	22	,	,	,
18637	11081	23	which	which	WDT
18637	11081	24	enables	enable	VBZ
18637	11081	25	parties	party	NNS
18637	11081	26	to	to	TO
18637	11081	27	avail	avail	VB
18637	11081	28	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11081	29	in	in	IN
18637	11081	30	State	state	NN
18637	11081	31	courts	court	NNS
18637	11081	32	of	of	IN
18637	11081	33	such	such	JJ
18637	11081	34	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	11081	35	as	as	IN
18637	11081	36	the	the	DT
18637	11081	37	common	common	JJ
18637	11081	38	law	law	NN
18637	11081	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	11081	40	competent	competent	JJ
18637	11081	41	to	to	IN
18637	11081	42	give,[380	give,[380	NNP
18637	11081	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11081	44	but	but	CC
18637	11081	45	in	in	IN
18637	11081	46	such	such	JJ
18637	11081	47	cases	case	NNS
18637	11081	48	the	the	DT
18637	11081	49	rights	right	NNS
18637	11081	50	and	and	CC
18637	11081	51	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	11081	52	involved	involve	VBN
18637	11081	53	are	be	VBP
18637	11081	54	still	still	RB
18637	11081	55	determined	determine	VBN
18637	11081	56	by	by	IN
18637	11081	57	the	the	DT
18637	11081	58	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11081	59	law	law	NN
18637	11081	60	.	.	.
18637	11082	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11082	2	381	381	CD
18637	11082	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11082	4	Concessions	concession	NNS
18637	11082	5	to	to	IN
18637	11082	6	State	State	NNP
18637	11082	7	Power	Power	NNP
18637	11082	8	Nor	nor	CC
18637	11082	9	does	do	VBZ
18637	11082	10	the	the	DT
18637	11082	11	exclusiveness	exclusiveness	NN
18637	11082	12	of	of	IN
18637	11082	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11082	14	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11082	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11082	16	preclude	preclude	IN
18637	11082	17	the	the	DT
18637	11082	18	States	States	NNPS
18637	11082	19	from	from	IN
18637	11082	20	creating	create	VBG
18637	11082	21	rights	right	NNS
18637	11082	22	enforceable	enforceable	JJ
18637	11082	23	in	in	IN
18637	11082	24	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11082	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	11082	26	.	.	.
18637	11083	1	In	in	IN
18637	11083	2	The	the	DT
18637	11083	3	"	"	``
18637	11083	4	Lottawanna,"[382	lottawanna,"[382	NN
18637	11083	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11083	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11083	7	was	be	VBD
18637	11083	8	held	hold	VBN
18637	11083	9	that	that	DT
18637	11083	10	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11083	11	district	district	NN
18637	11083	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	11083	13	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	11083	14	in	in	IN
18637	11083	15	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11083	16	could	could	MD
18637	11083	17	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11083	18	liens	lien	NNS
18637	11083	19	given	give	VBN
18637	11083	20	for	for	IN
18637	11083	21	security	security	NN
18637	11083	22	of	of	IN
18637	11083	23	a	a	DT
18637	11083	24	contract	contract	NN
18637	11083	25	even	even	RB
18637	11083	26	when	when	WRB
18637	11083	27	created	create	VBN
18637	11083	28	by	by	IN
18637	11083	29	State	State	NNP
18637	11083	30	laws	law	NNS
18637	11083	31	.	.	.
18637	11084	1	Likewise	likewise	JJ
18637	11084	2	liabilities	liability	NNS
18637	11084	3	created	create	VBN
18637	11084	4	by	by	IN
18637	11084	5	State	state	NN
18637	11084	6	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	11084	7	for	for	IN
18637	11084	8	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	11084	9	resulting	result	VBG
18637	11084	10	in	in	IN
18637	11084	11	death	death	NN
18637	11084	12	have	have	VBP
18637	11084	13	been	be	VBN
18637	11084	14	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	11084	15	by	by	IN
18637	11084	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11084	17	_	_	NNP
18637	11084	18	in	in	IN
18637	11084	19	rem	rem	NNP
18637	11084	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11084	21	in	in	IN
18637	11084	22	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11084	23	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11084	24	courts,[383	courts,[383	NNP
18637	11084	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11084	26	and	and	CC
18637	11084	27	,	,	,
18637	11084	28	in	in	IN
18637	11084	29	the	the	DT
18637	11084	30	absence	absence	NN
18637	11084	31	of	of	IN
18637	11084	32	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	11084	33	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	11084	34	,	,	,
18637	11084	35	a	a	DT
18637	11084	36	State	state	NN
18637	11084	37	may	may	MD
18637	11084	38	enact	enact	VB
18637	11084	39	laws	law	NNS
18637	11084	40	governing	govern	VBG
18637	11084	41	the	the	DT
18637	11084	42	rights	right	NNS
18637	11084	43	and	and	CC
18637	11084	44	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	11084	45	of	of	IN
18637	11084	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11084	47	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11084	48	on	on	IN
18637	11084	49	the	the	DT
18637	11084	50	high	high	JJ
18637	11084	51	seas	sea	NNS
18637	11084	52	.	.	.
18637	11085	1	Under	under	IN
18637	11085	2	this	this	DT
18637	11085	3	general	general	JJ
18637	11085	4	rule	rule	NN
18637	11085	5	a	a	DT
18637	11085	6	law	law	NN
18637	11085	7	of	of	IN
18637	11085	8	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	11085	9	providing	provide	VBG
18637	11085	10	for	for	IN
18637	11085	11	damages	damage	NNS
18637	11085	12	for	for	IN
18637	11085	13	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
18637	11085	14	death	death	NN
18637	11085	15	was	be	VBD
18637	11085	16	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	11085	17	in	in	IN
18637	11085	18	an	an	DT
18637	11085	19	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11085	20	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	11085	21	against	against	IN
18637	11085	22	a	a	DT
18637	11085	23	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	11085	24	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11085	25	out	out	IN
18637	11085	26	of	of	IN
18637	11085	27	a	a	DT
18637	11085	28	collision	collision	NN
18637	11085	29	at	at	IN
18637	11085	30	sea	sea	NN
18637	11085	31	of	of	IN
18637	11085	32	two	two	CD
18637	11085	33	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	11085	34	owned	own	VBN
18637	11085	35	by	by	IN
18637	11085	36	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	11085	37	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	11085	38	.	.	.
18637	11086	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11086	2	384	384	CD
18637	11086	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11086	4	And	and	CC
18637	11086	5	in	in	IN
18637	11086	6	1940	1940	CD
18637	11086	7	,	,	,
18637	11086	8	in	in	IN
18637	11086	9	Just	Just	NNP
18637	11086	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11086	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	11086	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11086	13	Chambers,[385	Chambers,[385	NNP
18637	11086	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11086	15	the	the	DT
18637	11086	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11086	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11086	18	held	hold	VBD
18637	11086	19	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	11086	20	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	11086	21	in	in	IN
18637	11086	22	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11086	23	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11086	24	the	the	DT
18637	11086	25	law	law	NN
18637	11086	26	of	of	IN
18637	11086	27	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	11086	28	whereby	whereby	IN
18637	11086	29	a	a	DT
18637	11086	30	cause	cause	NN
18637	11086	31	of	of	IN
18637	11086	32	action	action	NN
18637	11086	33	for	for	IN
18637	11086	34	personal	personal	JJ
18637	11086	35	injury	injury	NN
18637	11086	36	due	due	IN
18637	11086	37	to	to	IN
18637	11086	38	another	another	DT
18637	11086	39	's	's	POS
18637	11086	40	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	11086	41	survives	survive	VBZ
18637	11086	42	the	the	DT
18637	11086	43	death	death	NN
18637	11086	44	of	of	IN
18637	11086	45	the	the	DT
18637	11086	46	tort	tort	NN
18637	11086	47	-	-	HYPH
18637	11086	48	feasor	feasor	NN
18637	11086	49	against	against	IN
18637	11086	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11086	51	estate	estate	NN
18637	11086	52	and	and	CC
18637	11086	53	against	against	IN
18637	11086	54	the	the	DT
18637	11086	55	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	11086	56	.	.	.
18637	11087	1	The	the	DT
18637	11087	2	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	11087	3	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11087	4	and	and	CC
18637	11087	5	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11087	6	Sequelae	Sequelae	NNP
18637	11087	7	In	in	IN
18637	11087	8	the	the	DT
18637	11087	9	face	face	NN
18637	11087	10	of	of	IN
18637	11087	11	these	these	DT
18637	11087	12	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11087	13	,	,	,
18637	11087	14	except	except	IN
18637	11087	15	the	the	DT
18637	11087	16	last	last	JJ
18637	11087	17	,	,	,
18637	11087	18	the	the	DT
18637	11087	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11087	20	,	,	,
18637	11087	21	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	11087	22	,	,	,
18637	11087	23	held	hold	VBN
18637	11087	24	in	in	IN
18637	11087	25	1917	1917	CD
18637	11087	26	in	in	IN
18637	11087	27	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	11087	28	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	11087	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11087	30	_	_	NNP
18637	11087	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	11087	32	_	_	NNP
18637	11087	33	Jensen[386	Jensen[386	NNP
18637	11087	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11087	35	that	that	IN
18637	11087	36	a	a	DT
18637	11087	37	New	New	NNP
18637	11087	38	York	York	NNP
18637	11087	39	Workman	Workman	NNP
18637	11087	40	's	's	POS
18637	11087	41	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	11087	42	statute	statute	NN
18637	11087	43	was	be	VBD
18637	11087	44	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	11087	45	as	as	IN
18637	11087	46	applied	apply	VBN
18637	11087	47	to	to	IN
18637	11087	48	employees	employee	NNS
18637	11087	49	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	11087	50	in	in	IN
18637	11087	51	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11087	52	work	work	NN
18637	11087	53	.	.	.
18637	11088	1	Proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	11088	2	on	on	IN
18637	11088	3	the	the	DT
18637	11088	4	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	11088	5	that	that	IN
18637	11088	6	"	"	``
18637	11088	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11088	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	11088	9	paramount	paramount	JJ
18637	11088	10	power	power	NN
18637	11088	11	to	to	TO
18637	11088	12	fix	fix	VB
18637	11088	13	and	and	CC
18637	11088	14	determine	determine	VB
18637	11088	15	the	the	DT
18637	11088	16	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11088	17	law	law	NN
18637	11088	18	which	which	WDT
18637	11088	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	11088	20	prevail	prevail	VB
18637	11088	21	through	through	IN
18637	11088	22	the	the	DT
18637	11088	23	country	country	NN
18637	11088	24	,	,	,
18637	11088	25	"	"	''
18637	11088	26	and	and	CC
18637	11088	27	that	that	IN
18637	11088	28	in	in	IN
18637	11088	29	the	the	DT
18637	11088	30	absence	absence	NN
18637	11088	31	of	of	IN
18637	11088	32	a	a	DT
18637	11088	33	controlling	control	VBG
18637	11088	34	statute	statute	NN
18637	11088	35	the	the	DT
18637	11088	36	general	general	JJ
18637	11088	37	maritime	maritime	NNP
18637	11088	38	law	law	NN
18637	11088	39	as	as	IN
18637	11088	40	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	11088	41	by	by	IN
18637	11088	42	the	the	DT
18637	11088	43	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11088	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	11088	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	11088	46	a	a	DT
18637	11088	47	part	part	NN
18637	11088	48	of	of	IN
18637	11088	49	American	american	JJ
18637	11088	50	national	national	JJ
18637	11088	51	law	law	NN
18637	11088	52	,	,	,
18637	11088	53	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11088	54	McReynolds	McReynolds	NNP
18637	11088	55	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	11088	56	to	to	TO
18637	11088	57	draw	draw	VB
18637	11088	58	an	an	DT
18637	11088	59	analogy	analogy	NN
18637	11088	60	between	between	IN
18637	11088	61	the	the	DT
18637	11088	62	power	power	NN
18637	11088	63	of	of	IN
18637	11088	64	the	the	DT
18637	11088	65	States	States	NNPS
18637	11088	66	to	to	TO
18637	11088	67	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	11088	68	on	on	IN
18637	11088	69	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11088	70	and	and	CC
18637	11088	71	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11088	72	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11088	73	and	and	CC
18637	11088	74	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11088	75	power	power	NN
18637	11088	76	to	to	TO
18637	11088	77	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	11088	78	on	on	IN
18637	11088	79	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11088	80	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	11088	81	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	11088	82	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	11088	83	.	.	.
18637	11089	1	Just	just	RB
18637	11089	2	as	as	IN
18637	11089	3	the	the	DT
18637	11089	4	States	States	NNP
18637	11089	5	may	may	MD
18637	11089	6	not	not	RB
18637	11089	7	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	11089	8	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	11089	9	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	11089	10	where	where	WRB
18637	11089	11	the	the	DT
18637	11089	12	subject	subject	NN
18637	11089	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	11089	14	national	national	JJ
18637	11089	15	in	in	IN
18637	11089	16	character	character	NN
18637	11089	17	and	and	CC
18637	11089	18	requires	require	VBZ
18637	11089	19	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	11089	20	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	11089	21	,	,	,
18637	11089	22	so	so	CC
18637	11089	23	,	,	,
18637	11089	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11089	25	argued	argue	VBD
18637	11089	26	,	,	,
18637	11089	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11089	28	may	may	MD
18637	11089	29	not	not	RB
18637	11089	30	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	11089	31	on	on	IN
18637	11089	32	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11089	33	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11089	34	in	in	IN
18637	11089	35	such	such	JJ
18637	11089	36	fashion	fashion	NN
18637	11089	37	as	as	IN
18637	11089	38	to	to	TO
18637	11089	39	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	11089	40	"	"	``
18637	11089	41	the	the	DT
18637	11089	42	very	very	JJ
18637	11089	43	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	11089	44	in	in	IN
18637	11089	45	respect	respect	NN
18637	11089	46	to	to	IN
18637	11089	47	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11089	48	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11089	49	which	which	WDT
18637	11089	50	the	the	DT
18637	11089	51	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11089	52	was	be	VBD
18637	11089	53	designed	design	VBN
18637	11089	54	to	to	TO
18637	11089	55	establish	establish	VB
18637	11089	56	"	"	''
18637	11089	57	or	or	CC
18637	11089	58	to	to	TO
18637	11089	59	hamper	hamper	VB
18637	11089	60	and	and	CC
18637	11089	61	impede	impede	VB
18637	11089	62	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	11089	63	of	of	IN
18637	11089	64	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	11089	65	between	between	IN
18637	11089	66	the	the	DT
18637	11089	67	States	States	NNP
18637	11089	68	and	and	CC
18637	11089	69	with	with	IN
18637	11089	70	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11089	71	countries	country	NNS
18637	11089	72	.	.	.
18637	11090	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	11090	2	could	could	MD
18637	11090	3	the	the	DT
18637	11090	4	act	act	NN
18637	11090	5	be	be	VB
18637	11090	6	covered	cover	VBN
18637	11090	7	by	by	IN
18637	11090	8	the	the	DT
18637	11090	9	saving	save	VBG
18637	11090	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	11090	11	of	of	IN
18637	11090	12	the	the	DT
18637	11090	13	act	act	NN
18637	11090	14	of	of	IN
18637	11090	15	1789	1789	CD
18637	11090	16	governing	govern	VBG
18637	11090	17	common	common	JJ
18637	11090	18	law	law	NN
18637	11090	19	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	11090	20	,	,	,
18637	11090	21	since	since	IN
18637	11090	22	the	the	DT
18637	11090	23	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	11090	24	provided	provide	VBN
18637	11090	25	by	by	IN
18637	11090	26	the	the	DT
18637	11090	27	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	11090	28	statute	statute	NN
18637	11090	29	was	be	VBD
18637	11090	30	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	11090	31	to	to	IN
18637	11090	32	the	the	DT
18637	11090	33	common	common	JJ
18637	11090	34	law	law	NN
18637	11090	35	.	.	.
18637	11091	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11091	2	387	387	CD
18637	11091	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11091	4	Following	follow	VBG
18637	11091	5	the	the	DT
18637	11091	6	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	11091	7	decision	decision	NN
18637	11091	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11091	9	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	11091	10	a	a	DT
18637	11091	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	11091	12	saving	save	VBG
18637	11091	13	to	to	TO
18637	11091	14	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	11091	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11091	16	rights	right	NNS
18637	11091	17	and	and	CC
18637	11091	18	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	11091	19	under	under	IN
18637	11091	20	State	State	NNP
18637	11091	21	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	11091	22	's	's	POS
18637	11091	23	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	11091	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	11091	25	.	.	.
18637	11092	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11092	2	388	388	CD
18637	11092	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11092	4	In	in	IN
18637	11092	5	Knickerbocker	Knickerbocker	NNP
18637	11092	6	Ice	Ice	NNP
18637	11092	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11092	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11092	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	11092	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11092	11	Stewart[389	Stewart[389	NNP
18637	11092	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11092	13	the	the	DT
18637	11092	14	same	same	JJ
18637	11092	15	majority	majority	NN
18637	11092	16	of	of	IN
18637	11092	17	judges	judge	NNS
18637	11092	18	,	,	,
18637	11092	19	with	with	IN
18637	11092	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11092	21	McReynolds	McReynolds	NNP
18637	11092	22	again	again	RB
18637	11092	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11092	24	spokesman	spokesman	NN
18637	11092	25	,	,	,
18637	11092	26	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
18637	11092	27	this	this	DT
18637	11092	28	statute	statute	NN
18637	11092	29	as	as	IN
18637	11092	30	an	an	DT
18637	11092	31	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	11092	32	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	11092	33	of	of	IN
18637	11092	34	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	11092	35	power	power	NN
18637	11092	36	to	to	IN
18637	11092	37	the	the	DT
18637	11092	38	States	States	NNP
18637	11092	39	.	.	.
18637	11093	1	The	the	DT
18637	11093	2	holding	holding	NN
18637	11093	3	was	be	VBD
18637	11093	4	based	base	VBN
18637	11093	5	on	on	IN
18637	11093	6	the	the	DT
18637	11093	7	premise	premise	NN
18637	11093	8	,	,	,
18637	11093	9	stated	state	VBN
18637	11093	10	as	as	IN
18637	11093	11	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	11093	12	:	:	:
18637	11093	13	"	"	``
18637	11093	14	The	the	DT
18637	11093	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11093	16	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11093	17	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	11093	18	and	and	CC
18637	11093	19	established	establish	VBN
18637	11093	20	,	,	,
18637	11093	21	as	as	IN
18637	11093	22	part	part	NN
18637	11093	23	of	of	IN
18637	11093	24	the	the	DT
18637	11093	25	laws	law	NNS
18637	11093	26	of	of	IN
18637	11093	27	the	the	DT
18637	11093	28	United	United	NNP
18637	11093	29	States	States	NNP
18637	11093	30	,	,	,
18637	11093	31	approved	approve	VBD
18637	11093	32	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11093	33	of	of	IN
18637	11093	34	the	the	DT
18637	11093	35	general	general	JJ
18637	11093	36	maritime	maritime	NNP
18637	11093	37	law	law	NN
18637	11093	38	and	and	CC
18637	11093	39	empowered	empower	VBD
18637	11093	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11093	41	to	to	TO
18637	11093	42	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	11093	43	in	in	IN
18637	11093	44	respect	respect	NN
18637	11093	45	of	of	IN
18637	11093	46	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11093	47	and	and	CC
18637	11093	48	other	other	JJ
18637	11093	49	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11093	50	within	within	IN
18637	11093	51	the	the	DT
18637	11093	52	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11093	53	and	and	CC
18637	11093	54	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11093	55	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11093	56	.	.	.
18637	11094	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	11094	2	,	,	,
18637	11094	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11094	4	took	take	VBD
18637	11094	5	from	from	IN
18637	11094	6	the	the	DT
18637	11094	7	States	States	NNP
18637	11094	8	all	all	DT
18637	11094	9	power	power	NN
18637	11094	10	,	,	,
18637	11094	11	by	by	IN
18637	11094	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	11094	13	or	or	CC
18637	11094	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11094	15	decision	decision	NN
18637	11094	16	,	,	,
18637	11094	17	to	to	TO
18637	11094	18	contravene	contravene	VB
18637	11094	19	the	the	DT
18637	11094	20	essential	essential	JJ
18637	11094	21	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	11094	22	of	of	IN
18637	11094	23	,	,	,
18637	11094	24	or	or	CC
18637	11094	25	to	to	TO
18637	11094	26	work	work	VB
18637	11094	27	material	material	NN
18637	11094	28	injury	injury	NN
18637	11094	29	to	to	IN
18637	11094	30	,	,	,
18637	11094	31	characteristic	characteristic	JJ
18637	11094	32	features	feature	NNS
18637	11094	33	of	of	IN
18637	11094	34	such	such	JJ
18637	11094	35	law	law	NN
18637	11094	36	or	or	CC
18637	11094	37	to	to	TO
18637	11094	38	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	11094	39	with	with	IN
18637	11094	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11094	41	proper	proper	JJ
18637	11094	42	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	11094	43	and	and	CC
18637	11094	44	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	11094	45	in	in	IN
18637	11094	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11094	47	international	international	JJ
18637	11094	48	and	and	CC
18637	11094	49	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	11094	50	relations	relation	NNS
18637	11094	51	.	.	.
18637	11095	1	"	"	``
18637	11095	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11095	3	390	390	CD
18637	11095	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11095	5	And	and	CC
18637	11095	6	a	a	DT
18637	11095	7	like	like	JJ
18637	11095	8	fate	fate	NN
18637	11095	9	overtook	overtake	VBD
18637	11095	10	the	the	DT
18637	11095	11	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	11095	12	of	of	IN
18637	11095	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11095	14	in	in	IN
18637	11095	15	1922	1922	CD
18637	11095	16	to	to	TO
18637	11095	17	protect	protect	VB
18637	11095	18	longshoremen	longshoreman	NNS
18637	11095	19	and	and	CC
18637	11095	20	other	other	JJ
18637	11095	21	workers	worker	NNS
18637	11095	22	under	under	IN
18637	11095	23	State	state	NN
18637	11095	24	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	11095	25	laws	law	NNS
18637	11095	26	by	by	IN
18637	11095	27	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	11095	28	masters	master	NNS
18637	11095	29	and	and	CC
18637	11095	30	crew	crew	NN
18637	11095	31	members	member	NNS
18637	11095	32	of	of	IN
18637	11095	33	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	11095	34	from	from	IN
18637	11095	35	those	those	DT
18637	11095	36	who	who	WP
18637	11095	37	might	may	MD
18637	11095	38	claim	claim	VB
18637	11095	39	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	11095	40	for	for	IN
18637	11095	41	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11095	42	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	11095	43	.	.	.
18637	11096	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11096	2	391	391	CD
18637	11096	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11096	4	Finally	finally	RB
18637	11096	5	,	,	,
18637	11096	6	in	in	IN
18637	11096	7	1927	1927	CD
18637	11096	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11096	9	passed	pass	VBD
18637	11096	10	the	the	DT
18637	11096	11	Longshoremen	Longshoremen	NNP
18637	11096	12	's	's	POS
18637	11096	13	and	and	CC
18637	11096	14	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	11096	15	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	11096	16	'	'	POS
18637	11096	17	Act,[392	Act,[392	NNP
18637	11096	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11096	19	which	which	WDT
18637	11096	20	provided	provide	VBD
18637	11096	21	accident	accident	NN
18637	11096	22	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	11096	23	for	for	IN
18637	11096	24	those	those	DT
18637	11096	25	workers	worker	NNS
18637	11096	26	who	who	WP
18637	11096	27	could	could	MD
18637	11096	28	not	not	RB
18637	11096	29	validly	validly	RB
18637	11096	30	be	be	VB
18637	11096	31	compensated	compensate	VBN
18637	11096	32	under	under	IN
18637	11096	33	State	State	NNP
18637	11096	34	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	11096	35	.	.	.
18637	11097	1	This	this	DT
18637	11097	2	time	time	NN
18637	11097	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11097	4	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	11097	5	to	to	TO
18637	11097	6	have	have	VB
18637	11097	7	succeeded	succeed	VBN
18637	11097	8	,	,	,
18637	11097	9	the	the	DT
18637	11097	10	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	11097	11	of	of	IN
18637	11097	12	the	the	DT
18637	11097	13	1927	1927	CD
18637	11097	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	11097	15	being	be	VBG
18637	11097	16	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	11097	17	taken	take	VBN
18637	11097	18	for	for	IN
18637	11097	19	granted	grant	VBN
18637	11097	20	.	.	.
18637	11098	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11098	2	393	393	CD
18637	11098	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11098	4	The	the	DT
18637	11098	5	net	net	JJ
18637	11098	6	result	result	NN
18637	11098	7	of	of	IN
18637	11098	8	the	the	DT
18637	11098	9	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	11098	10	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11098	11	and	and	CC
18637	11098	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11098	13	progeny	progeny	NN
18637	11098	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	11098	15	been	be	VBN
18637	11098	16	a	a	DT
18637	11098	17	series	series	NN
18637	11098	18	of	of	IN
18637	11098	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	11098	20	which	which	WDT
18637	11098	21	hold	hold	VBP
18637	11098	22	that	that	IN
18637	11098	23	in	in	IN
18637	11098	24	some	some	DT
18637	11098	25	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	11098	26	the	the	DT
18637	11098	27	States	States	NNPS
18637	11098	28	can	can	MD
18637	11098	29	apply	apply	VB
18637	11098	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11098	31	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	11098	32	laws	law	NNS
18637	11098	33	to	to	IN
18637	11098	34	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11098	35	employees	employee	NNS
18637	11098	36	and	and	CC
18637	11098	37	in	in	IN
18637	11098	38	other	other	JJ
18637	11098	39	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	11098	40	can	can	MD
18637	11098	41	not	not	RB
18637	11098	42	,	,	,
18637	11098	43	if	if	IN
18637	11098	44	to	to	TO
18637	11098	45	do	do	VB
18637	11098	46	so	so	RB
18637	11098	47	"	"	``
18637	11098	48	works	work	VBZ
18637	11098	49	material	material	NNP
18637	11098	50	prejudice	prejudice	NN
18637	11098	51	to	to	IN
18637	11098	52	the	the	DT
18637	11098	53	characteristic	characteristic	JJ
18637	11098	54	features	feature	NNS
18637	11098	55	of	of	IN
18637	11098	56	the	the	DT
18637	11098	57	general	general	JJ
18637	11098	58	maritime	maritime	NNP
18637	11098	59	law	law	NN
18637	11098	60	or	or	CC
18637	11098	61	interferes	interfere	VBZ
18637	11098	62	with	with	IN
18637	11098	63	the	the	DT
18637	11098	64	proper	proper	JJ
18637	11098	65	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	11098	66	and	and	CC
18637	11098	67	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	11098	68	of	of	IN
18637	11098	69	that	that	DT
18637	11098	70	law	law	NN
18637	11098	71	in	in	IN
18637	11098	72	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11098	73	international	international	JJ
18637	11098	74	and	and	CC
18637	11098	75	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	11098	76	relations	relation	NNS
18637	11098	77	.	.	.
18637	11099	1	"	"	``
18637	11099	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11099	3	394	394	CD
18637	11099	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11099	5	But	but	CC
18637	11099	6	,	,	,
18637	11099	7	as	as	IN
18637	11099	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11099	9	Black	Black	NNP
18637	11099	10	pointed	point	VBD
18637	11099	11	out	out	RP
18637	11099	12	in	in	IN
18637	11099	13	1942	1942	CD
18637	11099	14	in	in	IN
18637	11099	15	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	11099	16	_	_	NNP
18637	11099	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	11099	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11099	19	Department	Department	NNP
18637	11099	20	of	of	IN
18637	11099	21	Labor,[395	Labor,[395	NNP
18637	11099	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11099	23	"	"	``
18637	11099	24	when	when	WRB
18637	11099	25	a	a	DT
18637	11099	26	State	state	NN
18637	11099	27	could	could	MD
18637	11099	28	,	,	,
18637	11099	29	and	and	CC
18637	11099	30	when	when	WRB
18637	11099	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11099	32	could	could	MD
18637	11099	33	not	not	RB
18637	11099	34	,	,	,
18637	11099	35	grant	grant	VB
18637	11099	36	protection	protection	NN
18637	11099	37	under	under	IN
18637	11099	38	a	a	DT
18637	11099	39	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	11099	40	act	act	NN
18637	11099	41	was	be	VBD
18637	11099	42	left	leave	VBN
18637	11099	43	as	as	IN
18637	11099	44	a	a	DT
18637	11099	45	perplexing	perplexing	NN
18637	11099	46	problem	problem	NN
18637	11099	47	,	,	,
18637	11099	48	for	for	IN
18637	11099	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11099	50	was	be	VBD
18637	11099	51	held	hold	VBN
18637	11099	52	'	'	``
18637	11099	53	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	11099	54	,	,	,
18637	11099	55	if	if	IN
18637	11099	56	not	not	RB
18637	11099	57	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	11099	58	,	,	,
18637	11099	59	'	'	''
18637	11099	60	to	to	TO
18637	11099	61	define	define	VB
18637	11099	62	this	this	DT
18637	11099	63	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	11099	64	with	with	IN
18637	11099	65	exactness	exactness	NN
18637	11099	66	.	.	.
18637	11100	1	"	"	``
18637	11100	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11100	3	396	396	CD
18637	11100	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11100	5	Nor	nor	CC
18637	11100	6	,	,	,
18637	11100	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11100	8	continued	continue	VBD
18637	11100	9	,	,	,
18637	11100	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	11100	11	the	the	DT
18637	11100	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11100	13	been	be	VBN
18637	11100	14	able	able	JJ
18637	11100	15	"	"	''
18637	11100	16	to	to	TO
18637	11100	17	give	give	VB
18637	11100	18	any	any	DT
18637	11100	19	guiding	guiding	NN
18637	11100	20	,	,	,
18637	11100	21	definite	definite	JJ
18637	11100	22	rule	rule	NN
18637	11100	23	to	to	TO
18637	11100	24	determine	determine	VB
18637	11100	25	the	the	DT
18637	11100	26	extent	extent	NN
18637	11100	27	of	of	IN
18637	11100	28	state	state	NN
18637	11100	29	power	power	NN
18637	11100	30	in	in	IN
18637	11100	31	advance	advance	NN
18637	11100	32	of	of	IN
18637	11100	33	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	11100	34	,	,	,
18637	11100	35	and	and	CC
18637	11100	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	11100	37	held	hold	VBN
18637	11100	38	that	that	IN
18637	11100	39	the	the	DT
18637	11100	40	margins	margin	NNS
18637	11100	41	of	of	IN
18637	11100	42	state	state	NN
18637	11100	43	authority	authority	NN
18637	11100	44	must	must	MD
18637	11100	45	'	'	''
18637	11100	46	be	be	VB
18637	11100	47	determined	determine	VBN
18637	11100	48	in	in	IN
18637	11100	49	view	view	NN
18637	11100	50	of	of	IN
18637	11100	51	surrounding	surround	VBG
18637	11100	52	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	11100	53	as	as	IN
18637	11100	54	cases	case	NNS
18637	11100	55	arise	arise	VBP
18637	11100	56	.	.	.
18637	11101	1	'	'	``
18637	11101	2	"	"	``
18637	11101	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11101	4	397	397	CD
18637	11101	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11101	6	As	as	IN
18637	11101	7	to	to	IN
18637	11101	8	the	the	DT
18637	11101	9	specific	specific	JJ
18637	11101	10	claim	claim	NN
18637	11101	11	involved	involve	VBN
18637	11101	12	in	in	IN
18637	11101	13	the	the	DT
18637	11101	14	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	11101	15	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11101	16	,	,	,
18637	11101	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11101	18	Black	Black	NNP
18637	11101	19	stated	state	VBD
18637	11101	20	further	further	RB
18637	11101	21	that	that	IN
18637	11101	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11101	23	was	be	VBD
18637	11101	24	"	"	``
18637	11101	25	fair	fair	JJ
18637	11101	26	to	to	TO
18637	11101	27	say	say	VB
18637	11101	28	that	that	IN
18637	11101	29	a	a	DT
18637	11101	30	number	number	NN
18637	11101	31	of	of	IN
18637	11101	32	cases	case	NNS
18637	11101	33	can	can	MD
18637	11101	34	be	be	VB
18637	11101	35	cited	cite	VBN
18637	11101	36	both	both	CC
18637	11101	37	in	in	IN
18637	11101	38	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	11101	39	of	of	IN
18637	11101	40	and	and	CC
18637	11101	41	in	in	IN
18637	11101	42	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	11101	43	to	to	IN
18637	11101	44	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	11101	45	here	here	RB
18637	11101	46	.	.	.
18637	11102	1	"	"	``
18637	11102	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11102	3	398	398	CD
18637	11102	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11102	5	Concurring	concur	VBG
18637	11102	6	in	in	IN
18637	11102	7	the	the	DT
18637	11102	8	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	11102	9	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11102	10	,	,	,
18637	11102	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11102	12	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11102	13	referred	refer	VBD
18637	11102	14	to	to	IN
18637	11102	15	the	the	DT
18637	11102	16	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	11102	17	case	case	NN
18637	11102	18	as	as	IN
18637	11102	19	"	"	``
18637	11102	20	that	that	IN
18637	11102	21	ill	ill	JJ
18637	11102	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	11102	23	starred	star	VBN
18637	11102	24	decision	decision	NN
18637	11102	25	,	,	,
18637	11102	26	"	"	''
18637	11102	27	but	but	CC
18637	11102	28	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	11102	29	that	that	DT
18637	11102	30	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	11102	31	would	would	MD
18637	11102	32	not	not	RB
18637	11102	33	eliminate	eliminate	VB
18637	11102	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11102	35	resultant	resultant	JJ
18637	11102	36	complexities	complexity	NNS
18637	11102	37	and	and	CC
18637	11102	38	confusions	confusion	NNS
18637	11102	39	until	until	IN
18637	11102	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11102	41	attempted	attempt	VBD
18637	11102	42	another	another	DT
18637	11102	43	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	11102	44	solution	solution	NN
18637	11102	45	of	of	IN
18637	11102	46	the	the	DT
18637	11102	47	problem	problem	NN
18637	11102	48	.	.	.
18637	11103	1	Until	until	IN
18637	11103	2	then	then	RB
18637	11103	3	all	all	PDT
18637	11103	4	the	the	DT
18637	11103	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11103	6	could	could	MD
18637	11103	7	do	do	VB
18637	11103	8	was	be	VBD
18637	11103	9	"	"	``
18637	11103	10	to	to	TO
18637	11103	11	bring	bring	VB
18637	11103	12	order	order	NN
18637	11103	13	out	out	IN
18637	11103	14	of	of	IN
18637	11103	15	the	the	DT
18637	11103	16	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	11103	17	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11103	18	chaos	chaos	NN
18637	11103	19	as	as	IN
18637	11103	20	marginal	marginal	JJ
18637	11103	21	situations	situation	NNS
18637	11103	22	"	"	''
18637	11103	23	were	be	VBD
18637	11103	24	presented	present	VBN
18637	11103	25	.	.	.
18637	11104	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11104	2	399	399	CD
18637	11104	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11104	4	POWER	power	NN
18637	11104	5	OF	of	IN
18637	11104	6	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	11104	7	TO	to	IN
18637	11104	8	MODIFY	MODIFY	NNP
18637	11104	9	THE	the	DT
18637	11104	10	MARITIME	MARITIME	NNP
18637	11104	11	LAW	law	NN
18637	11104	12	;	;	:
18637	11104	13	THE	the	DT
18637	11104	14	"	"	``
18637	11104	15	LOTTAWANNA	LOTTAWANNA	NNP
18637	11104	16	"	"	''
18637	11104	17	In	in	IN
18637	11104	18	view	view	NN
18637	11104	19	of	of	IN
18637	11104	20	the	the	DT
18637	11104	21	chaos	chaos	NN
18637	11104	22	created	create	VBN
18637	11104	23	by	by	IN
18637	11104	24	the	the	DT
18637	11104	25	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	11104	26	case	case	NN
18637	11104	27	and	and	CC
18637	11104	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11104	29	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	11104	30	disharmony	disharmony	NN
18637	11104	31	with	with	IN
18637	11104	32	earlier	early	RBR
18637	11104	33	as	as	RB
18637	11104	34	well	well	RB
18637	11104	35	as	as	IN
18637	11104	36	some	some	DT
18637	11104	37	later	later	JJ
18637	11104	38	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11104	39	the	the	DT
18637	11104	40	question	question	NN
18637	11104	41	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	11104	42	as	as	IN
18637	11104	43	to	to	IN
18637	11104	44	the	the	DT
18637	11104	45	scope	scope	NN
18637	11104	46	of	of	IN
18637	11104	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11104	48	's	's	POS
18637	11104	49	power	power	NN
18637	11104	50	to	to	TO
18637	11104	51	revise	revise	VB
18637	11104	52	and	and	CC
18637	11104	53	codify	codify	VB
18637	11104	54	the	the	DT
18637	11104	55	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11104	56	law	law	NN
18637	11104	57	.	.	.
18637	11105	1	In	in	IN
18637	11105	2	the	the	DT
18637	11105	3	"	"	``
18637	11105	4	Lottawanna"[400	Lottawanna"[400	NNP
18637	11105	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11105	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11105	7	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	11105	8	as	as	IN
18637	11105	9	spokesman	spokesman	NN
18637	11105	10	of	of	IN
18637	11105	11	the	the	DT
18637	11105	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11105	13	,	,	,
18637	11105	14	while	while	IN
18637	11105	15	admitting	admit	VBG
18637	11105	16	the	the	DT
18637	11105	17	existence	existence	NN
18637	11105	18	of	of	IN
18637	11105	19	a	a	DT
18637	11105	20	general	general	JJ
18637	11105	21	body	body	NN
18637	11105	22	of	of	IN
18637	11105	23	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11105	24	law	law	NN
18637	11105	25	,	,	,
18637	11105	26	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	11105	27	that	that	IN
18637	11105	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11105	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	11105	30	operative	operative	JJ
18637	11105	31	as	as	IN
18637	11105	32	law	law	NN
18637	11105	33	only	only	RB
18637	11105	34	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	11105	35	"	"	''
18637	11105	36	as	as	IN
18637	11105	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11105	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	11105	39	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	11105	40	by	by	IN
18637	11105	41	the	the	DT
18637	11105	42	laws	law	NNS
18637	11105	43	and	and	CC
18637	11105	44	usages	usage	NNS
18637	11105	45	of	of	IN
18637	11105	46	that	that	DT
18637	11105	47	country,"[401	country,"[401	NN
18637	11105	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11105	49	subject	subject	JJ
18637	11105	50	to	to	IN
18637	11105	51	such	such	JJ
18637	11105	52	modifications	modification	NNS
18637	11105	53	and	and	CC
18637	11105	54	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	11105	55	as	as	IN
18637	11105	56	may	may	MD
18637	11105	57	be	be	VB
18637	11105	58	made	make	VBN
18637	11105	59	.	.	.
18637	11106	1	So	so	RB
18637	11106	2	adopted	adopted	JJ
18637	11106	3	and	and	CC
18637	11106	4	qualified	qualify	VBD
18637	11106	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11106	6	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	11106	7	the	the	DT
18637	11106	8	law	law	NN
18637	11106	9	of	of	IN
18637	11106	10	a	a	DT
18637	11106	11	particular	particular	JJ
18637	11106	12	nation	nation	NN
18637	11106	13	,	,	,
18637	11106	14	but	but	CC
18637	11106	15	not	not	RB
18637	11106	16	until	until	IN
18637	11106	17	then	then	RB
18637	11106	18	.	.	.
18637	11107	1	"	"	``
18637	11107	2	That	that	IN
18637	11107	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11107	4	have	have	VBP
18637	11107	5	a	a	DT
18637	11107	6	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11107	7	law	law	NN
18637	11107	8	of	of	IN
18637	11107	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11107	10	own	own	JJ
18637	11107	11	,	,	,
18637	11107	12	operative	operative	JJ
18637	11107	13	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	11107	14	the	the	DT
18637	11107	15	United	United	NNP
18637	11107	16	States	States	NNP
18637	11107	17	,	,	,
18637	11107	18	can	can	MD
18637	11107	19	not	not	RB
18637	11107	20	be	be	VB
18637	11107	21	doubted	doubt	VBN
18637	11107	22	.	.	.
18637	11108	1	The	the	DT
18637	11108	2	general	general	JJ
18637	11108	3	system	system	NN
18637	11108	4	of	of	IN
18637	11108	5	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11108	6	law	law	NN
18637	11108	7	which	which	WDT
18637	11108	8	was	be	VBD
18637	11108	9	familiar	familiar	JJ
18637	11108	10	to	to	IN
18637	11108	11	the	the	DT
18637	11108	12	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
18637	11108	13	and	and	CC
18637	11108	14	statesmen	statesman	NNS
18637	11108	15	of	of	IN
18637	11108	16	the	the	DT
18637	11108	17	country	country	NN
18637	11108	18	when	when	WRB
18637	11108	19	the	the	DT
18637	11108	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11108	21	was	be	VBD
18637	11108	22	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	11108	23	,	,	,
18637	11108	24	was	be	VBD
18637	11108	25	most	most	RBS
18637	11108	26	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	11108	27	intended	intend	VBN
18637	11108	28	and	and	CC
18637	11108	29	referred	refer	VBD
18637	11108	30	to	to	IN
18637	11108	31	when	when	WRB
18637	11108	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11108	33	was	be	VBD
18637	11108	34	declared	declare	VBN
18637	11108	35	in	in	IN
18637	11108	36	that	that	DT
18637	11108	37	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	11108	38	that	that	IN
18637	11108	39	the	the	DT
18637	11108	40	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11108	41	power	power	NN
18637	11108	42	of	of	IN
18637	11108	43	the	the	DT
18637	11108	44	United	United	NNP
18637	11108	45	States	States	NNP
18637	11108	46	shall	shall	MD
18637	11108	47	extend	extend	VB
18637	11108	48	'	'	''
18637	11108	49	to	to	IN
18637	11108	50	all	all	DT
18637	11108	51	cases	case	NNS
18637	11108	52	of	of	IN
18637	11108	53	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11108	54	and	and	CC
18637	11108	55	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11108	56	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11108	57	.	.	.
18637	11108	58	'	'	''
18637	11108	59	"	"	''
18637	11109	1	Continuing	continue	VBG
18637	11109	2	,	,	,
18637	11109	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11109	4	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	11109	5	stated	state	VBD
18637	11109	6	that	that	IN
18637	11109	7	"	"	``
18637	11109	8	the	the	DT
18637	11109	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11109	10	must	must	MD
18637	11109	11	have	have	VB
18637	11109	12	referred	refer	VBN
18637	11109	13	to	to	IN
18637	11109	14	a	a	DT
18637	11109	15	system	system	NN
18637	11109	16	of	of	IN
18637	11109	17	law	law	NN
18637	11109	18	coextensive	coextensive	JJ
18637	11109	19	with	with	IN
18637	11109	20	and	and	CC
18637	11109	21	operating	operate	VBG
18637	11109	22	uniformly	uniformly	RB
18637	11109	23	in	in	IN
18637	11109	24	,	,	,
18637	11109	25	the	the	DT
18637	11109	26	whole	whole	JJ
18637	11109	27	country	country	NN
18637	11109	28	.	.	.
18637	11110	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11110	2	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	11110	3	could	could	MD
18637	11110	4	not	not	RB
18637	11110	5	have	have	VB
18637	11110	6	been	be	VBN
18637	11110	7	the	the	DT
18637	11110	8	intention	intention	NN
18637	11110	9	to	to	TO
18637	11110	10	place	place	VB
18637	11110	11	the	the	DT
18637	11110	12	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11110	13	and	and	CC
18637	11110	14	limits	limit	NNS
18637	11110	15	of	of	IN
18637	11110	16	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11110	17	law	law	NN
18637	11110	18	under	under	IN
18637	11110	19	the	the	DT
18637	11110	20	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	11110	21	and	and	CC
18637	11110	22	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	11110	23	of	of	IN
18637	11110	24	the	the	DT
18637	11110	25	several	several	JJ
18637	11110	26	States	States	NNPS
18637	11110	27	,	,	,
18637	11110	28	as	as	IN
18637	11110	29	that	that	DT
18637	11110	30	would	would	MD
18637	11110	31	have	have	VB
18637	11110	32	defeated	defeat	VBN
18637	11110	33	the	the	DT
18637	11110	34	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	11110	35	and	and	CC
18637	11110	36	consistency	consistency	NN
18637	11110	37	at	at	IN
18637	11110	38	which	which	WDT
18637	11110	39	the	the	DT
18637	11110	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11110	41	aimed	aim	VBD
18637	11110	42	on	on	IN
18637	11110	43	all	all	DT
18637	11110	44	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	11110	45	of	of	IN
18637	11110	46	a	a	DT
18637	11110	47	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	11110	48	character	character	NN
18637	11110	49	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	11110	50	the	the	DT
18637	11110	51	intercourse	intercourse	NN
18637	11110	52	of	of	IN
18637	11110	53	the	the	DT
18637	11110	54	States	States	NNPS
18637	11110	55	with	with	IN
18637	11110	56	each	each	DT
18637	11110	57	other	other	JJ
18637	11110	58	or	or	CC
18637	11110	59	with	with	IN
18637	11110	60	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11110	61	states	state	NNS
18637	11110	62	.	.	.
18637	11111	1	"	"	``
18637	11111	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11111	3	402	402	CD
18637	11111	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11111	5	However	however	RB
18637	11111	6	,	,	,
18637	11111	7	the	the	DT
18637	11111	8	framers	framer	NNS
18637	11111	9	of	of	IN
18637	11111	10	the	the	DT
18637	11111	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11111	12	could	could	MD
18637	11111	13	not	not	RB
18637	11111	14	have	have	VB
18637	11111	15	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
18637	11111	16	that	that	IN
18637	11111	17	the	the	DT
18637	11111	18	law	law	NN
18637	11111	19	should	should	MD
18637	11111	20	remain	remain	VB
18637	11111	21	ever	ever	RB
18637	11111	22	the	the	DT
18637	11111	23	same	same	JJ
18637	11111	24	,	,	,
18637	11111	25	especially	especially	RB
18637	11111	26	as	as	IN
18637	11111	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11111	28	"	"	''
18637	11111	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	11111	30	authority	authority	NN
18637	11111	31	under	under	IN
18637	11111	32	the	the	DT
18637	11111	33	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	11111	34	power	power	NN
18637	11111	35	,	,	,
18637	11111	36	if	if	IN
18637	11111	37	no	no	DT
18637	11111	38	other	other	JJ
18637	11111	39	,	,	,
18637	11111	40	to	to	TO
18637	11111	41	introduce	introduce	VB
18637	11111	42	such	such	JJ
18637	11111	43	changes	change	NNS
18637	11111	44	as	as	IN
18637	11111	45	are	be	VBP
18637	11111	46	likely	likely	JJ
18637	11111	47	to	to	TO
18637	11111	48	be	be	VB
18637	11111	49	needed	need	VBN
18637	11111	50	.	.	.
18637	11112	1	"	"	``
18637	11112	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11112	3	403	403	CD
18637	11112	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11112	5	Sixteen	sixteen	CD
18637	11112	6	years	year	NNS
18637	11112	7	later	later	RB
18637	11112	8	in	in	IN
18637	11112	9	the	the	DT
18637	11112	10	Garnett	Garnett	NNP
18637	11112	11	case[404	case[404	NN
18637	11112	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11112	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11112	14	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	11112	15	,	,	,
18637	11112	16	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	11112	17	for	for	IN
18637	11112	18	a	a	DT
18637	11112	19	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	11112	20	court	court	NN
18637	11112	21	,	,	,
18637	11112	22	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	11112	23	that	that	IN
18637	11112	24	the	the	DT
18637	11112	25	power	power	NN
18637	11112	26	of	of	IN
18637	11112	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11112	28	to	to	TO
18637	11112	29	amend	amend	VB
18637	11112	30	the	the	DT
18637	11112	31	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11112	32	law	law	NN
18637	11112	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	11112	34	coextensive	coextensive	JJ
18637	11112	35	with	with	IN
18637	11112	36	that	that	DT
18637	11112	37	law	law	NN
18637	11112	38	and	and	CC
18637	11112	39	not	not	RB
18637	11112	40	limited	limit	VBN
18637	11112	41	by	by	IN
18637	11112	42	the	the	DT
18637	11112	43	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	11112	44	of	of	IN
18637	11112	45	the	the	DT
18637	11112	46	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	11112	47	clause	clause	NNP
18637	11112	48	,	,	,
18637	11112	49	and	and	CC
18637	11112	50	that	that	IN
18637	11112	51	the	the	DT
18637	11112	52	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11112	53	law	law	NN
18637	11112	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	11112	55	"	"	``
18637	11112	56	subject	subject	JJ
18637	11112	57	to	to	IN
18637	11112	58	such	such	JJ
18637	11112	59	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	11112	60	as	as	IN
18637	11112	61	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11112	62	may	may	MD
18637	11112	63	see	see	VB
18637	11112	64	fit	fit	JJ
18637	11112	65	to	to	TO
18637	11112	66	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	11112	67	.	.	.
18637	11113	1	"	"	``
18637	11113	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11113	3	405	405	CD
18637	11113	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11113	5	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	11113	6	,	,	,
18637	11113	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11113	8	McReynolds	McReynolds	NNP
18637	11113	9	in	in	IN
18637	11113	10	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	11113	11	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	11113	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11113	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11113	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	11113	15	_	_	NNP
18637	11113	16	Jensen[406	Jensen[406	NNP
18637	11113	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11113	18	emphasizes	emphasize	VBZ
18637	11113	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11113	20	'	'	POS
18637	11113	21	"	"	``
18637	11113	22	paramount	paramount	JJ
18637	11113	23	power	power	NN
18637	11113	24	to	to	TO
18637	11113	25	fix	fix	VB
18637	11113	26	and	and	CC
18637	11113	27	determine	determine	VB
18637	11113	28	the	the	DT
18637	11113	29	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11113	30	law	law	NN
18637	11113	31	which	which	WDT
18637	11113	32	shall	shall	MD
18637	11113	33	prevail	prevail	VB
18637	11113	34	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	11113	35	the	the	DT
18637	11113	36	country	country	NN
18637	11113	37	,	,	,
18637	11113	38	"	"	''
18637	11113	39	albeit	albeit	IN
18637	11113	40	in	in	IN
18637	11113	41	the	the	DT
18637	11113	42	absence	absence	NN
18637	11113	43	of	of	IN
18637	11113	44	a	a	DT
18637	11113	45	controlling	control	VBG
18637	11113	46	statute	statute	NN
18637	11113	47	the	the	DT
18637	11113	48	general	general	JJ
18637	11113	49	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11113	50	law	law	NN
18637	11113	51	prevails	prevail	VBZ
18637	11113	52	;	;	:
18637	11113	53	and	and	CC
18637	11113	54	the	the	DT
18637	11113	55	language	language	NN
18637	11113	56	of	of	IN
18637	11113	57	Knickerbocker	Knickerbocker	NNP
18637	11113	58	Ice	Ice	NNP
18637	11113	59	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11113	60	_	_	NNP
18637	11113	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	11113	62	_	_	NNP
18637	11113	63	Stewart[407	Stewart[407	NNP
18637	11113	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11113	65	is	be	VBZ
18637	11113	66	to	to	TO
18637	11113	67	like	like	UH
18637	11113	68	effect	effect	NN
18637	11113	69	,	,	,
18637	11113	70	as	as	IN
18637	11113	71	is	be	VBZ
18637	11113	72	also	also	RB
18637	11113	73	that	that	DT
18637	11113	74	of	of	IN
18637	11113	75	Swanson	Swanson	NNP
18637	11113	76	_	_	NNP
18637	11113	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	11113	78	_	_	NNP
18637	11113	79	Marra	Marra	NNP
18637	11113	80	Bros	Bros	NNP
18637	11113	81	.	.	.
18637	11113	82	,[408	,[408	NFP
18637	11113	83	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11113	84	decided	decide	VBN
18637	11113	85	in	in	IN
18637	11113	86	1946	1946	CD
18637	11113	87	.	.	.
18637	11114	1	The	the	DT
18637	11114	2	law	law	NN
18637	11114	3	administered	administer	VBN
18637	11114	4	by	by	IN
18637	11114	5	the	the	DT
18637	11114	6	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11114	7	courts	court	NNS
18637	11114	8	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	11114	9	in	in	IN
18637	11114	10	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11114	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	11114	12	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11114	13	an	an	DT
18637	11114	14	amalgam	amalgam	NN
18637	11114	15	of	of	IN
18637	11114	16	the	the	DT
18637	11114	17	general	general	NNP
18637	11114	18	maritime	maritime	NNP
18637	11114	19	law	law	NN
18637	11114	20	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	11114	21	as	as	IN
18637	11114	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11114	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	11114	24	acceptable	acceptable	JJ
18637	11114	25	to	to	IN
18637	11114	26	the	the	DT
18637	11114	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	11114	28	,	,	,
18637	11114	29	modifications	modification	NNS
18637	11114	30	of	of	IN
18637	11114	31	that	that	DT
18637	11114	32	law	law	NN
18637	11114	33	by	by	IN
18637	11114	34	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	11114	35	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	11114	36	,	,	,
18637	11114	37	the	the	DT
18637	11114	38	common	common	JJ
18637	11114	39	law	law	NN
18637	11114	40	of	of	IN
18637	11114	41	torts	tort	NNS
18637	11114	42	and	and	CC
18637	11114	43	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	11114	44	as	as	IN
18637	11114	45	modified	modify	VBN
18637	11114	46	by	by	IN
18637	11114	47	State	State	NNP
18637	11114	48	or	or	CC
18637	11114	49	National	national	JJ
18637	11114	50	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	11114	51	,	,	,
18637	11114	52	and	and	CC
18637	11114	53	international	international	JJ
18637	11114	54	prize	prize	NN
18637	11114	55	law	law	NN
18637	11114	56	.	.	.
18637	11115	1	This	this	DT
18637	11115	2	body	body	NN
18637	11115	3	of	of	IN
18637	11115	4	law	law	NN
18637	11115	5	,	,	,
18637	11115	6	however	however	RB
18637	11115	7	,	,	,
18637	11115	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	11115	9	subject	subject	JJ
18637	11115	10	at	at	IN
18637	11115	11	all	all	DT
18637	11115	12	times	time	NNS
18637	11115	13	to	to	IN
18637	11115	14	the	the	DT
18637	11115	15	paramount	paramount	NNP
18637	11115	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	11115	17	of	of	IN
18637	11115	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11115	19	to	to	TO
18637	11115	20	change	change	VB
18637	11115	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11115	22	in	in	IN
18637	11115	23	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	11115	24	of	of	IN
18637	11115	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11115	26	powers	power	NNS
18637	11115	27	under	under	IN
18637	11115	28	the	the	DT
18637	11115	29	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	11115	30	clause	clause	NNP
18637	11115	31	,	,	,
18637	11115	32	the	the	DT
18637	11115	33	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11115	34	and	and	CC
18637	11115	35	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11115	36	clause	clause	NN
18637	11115	37	,	,	,
18637	11115	38	and	and	CC
18637	11115	39	the	the	DT
18637	11115	40	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11115	41	and	and	CC
18637	11115	42	proper	proper	JJ
18637	11115	43	clause	clause	NN
18637	11115	44	.	.	.
18637	11116	1	That	that	DT
18637	11116	2	portion	portion	NN
18637	11116	3	of	of	IN
18637	11116	4	the	the	DT
18637	11116	5	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	11116	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11116	7	emphasizing	emphasize	VBG
18637	11116	8	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	11116	9	power	power	NN
18637	11116	10	in	in	IN
18637	11116	11	this	this	DT
18637	11116	12	respect	respect	NN
18637	11116	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	11116	14	never	never	RB
18637	11116	15	been	be	VBN
18637	11116	16	in	in	IN
18637	11116	17	issue	issue	NN
18637	11116	18	in	in	IN
18637	11116	19	either	either	CC
18637	11116	20	the	the	DT
18637	11116	21	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	11116	22	of	of	IN
18637	11116	23	the	the	DT
18637	11116	24	dissenters	dissenter	NNS
18637	11116	25	in	in	IN
18637	11116	26	that	that	DT
18637	11116	27	case	case	NN
18637	11116	28	or	or	CC
18637	11116	29	in	in	IN
18637	11116	30	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	11116	31	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	11116	32	critical	critical	JJ
18637	11116	33	of	of	IN
18637	11116	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11116	35	,	,	,
18637	11116	36	which	which	WDT
18637	11116	37	in	in	IN
18637	11116	38	effect	effect	NN
18637	11116	39	invite	invite	VBP
18637	11116	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11116	41	to	to	TO
18637	11116	42	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	11116	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11116	44	power	power	NN
18637	11116	45	to	to	TO
18637	11116	46	modify	modify	VB
18637	11116	47	the	the	DT
18637	11116	48	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11116	49	law	law	NN
18637	11116	50	.	.	.
18637	11117	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11117	2	409	409	CD
18637	11117	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11117	4	Cases	case	NNS
18637	11117	5	to	to	TO
18637	11117	6	Which	which	WDT
18637	11117	7	the	the	DT
18637	11117	8	United	United	NNP
18637	11117	9	States	States	NNP
18637	11117	10	Is	be	VBZ
18637	11117	11	a	a	DT
18637	11117	12	Party	Party	NNP
18637	11117	13	:	:	:
18637	11117	14	Right	right	UH
18637	11117	15	of	of	IN
18637	11117	16	the	the	DT
18637	11117	17	United	United	NNP
18637	11117	18	States	States	NNP
18637	11117	19	To	to	IN
18637	11117	20	Sue	Sue	NNP
18637	11117	21	As	as	IN
18637	11117	22	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11117	23	Story	Story	NNP
18637	11117	24	pointed	point	VBD
18637	11117	25	out	out	RP
18637	11117	26	in	in	IN
18637	11117	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11117	28	Commentaries	commentary	NNS
18637	11117	29	,	,	,
18637	11117	30	"	"	``
18637	11117	31	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11117	32	would	would	MD
18637	11117	33	be	be	VB
18637	11117	34	a	a	DT
18637	11117	35	perfect	perfect	JJ
18637	11117	36	novelty	novelty	NN
18637	11117	37	in	in	IN
18637	11117	38	the	the	DT
18637	11117	39	history	history	NN
18637	11117	40	of	of	IN
18637	11117	41	national	national	JJ
18637	11117	42	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
18637	11117	43	,	,	,
18637	11117	44	as	as	RB
18637	11117	45	well	well	RB
18637	11117	46	as	as	IN
18637	11117	47	of	of	IN
18637	11117	48	public	public	JJ
18637	11117	49	law	law	NN
18637	11117	50	,	,	,
18637	11117	51	that	that	IN
18637	11117	52	a	a	DT
18637	11117	53	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	11117	54	had	have	VBD
18637	11117	55	no	no	DT
18637	11117	56	authority	authority	NN
18637	11117	57	to	to	TO
18637	11117	58	sue	sue	VB
18637	11117	59	in	in	IN
18637	11117	60	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11117	61	own	own	JJ
18637	11117	62	courts	court	NNS
18637	11117	63	.	.	.
18637	11118	1	"	"	``
18637	11118	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11118	3	410	410	CD
18637	11118	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11118	5	As	as	RB
18637	11118	6	early	early	RB
18637	11118	7	as	as	IN
18637	11118	8	1818	1818	CD
18637	11118	9	the	the	DT
18637	11118	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11118	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11118	12	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	11118	13	that	that	IN
18637	11118	14	the	the	DT
18637	11118	15	United	United	NNP
18637	11118	16	States	States	NNP
18637	11118	17	could	could	MD
18637	11118	18	sue	sue	VB
18637	11118	19	in	in	IN
18637	11118	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11118	21	own	own	JJ
18637	11118	22	name	name	NN
18637	11118	23	in	in	IN
18637	11118	24	all	all	DT
18637	11118	25	cases	case	NNS
18637	11118	26	of	of	IN
18637	11118	27	contract	contract	NN
18637	11118	28	without	without	IN
18637	11118	29	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	11118	30	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	11118	31	of	of	IN
18637	11118	32	such	such	JJ
18637	11118	33	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11118	34	.	.	.
18637	11119	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11119	2	411	411	CD
18637	11119	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11119	4	Later	later	RB
18637	11119	5	this	this	DT
18637	11119	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	11119	7	was	be	VBD
18637	11119	8	extended	extend	VBN
18637	11119	9	to	to	IN
18637	11119	10	other	other	JJ
18637	11119	11	types	type	NNS
18637	11119	12	of	of	IN
18637	11119	13	actions	action	NNS
18637	11119	14	.	.	.
18637	11120	1	In	in	IN
18637	11120	2	the	the	DT
18637	11120	3	absence	absence	NN
18637	11120	4	of	of	IN
18637	11120	5	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	11120	6	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	11120	7	to	to	IN
18637	11120	8	the	the	DT
18637	11120	9	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	11120	10	such	such	JJ
18637	11120	11	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11120	12	are	be	VBP
18637	11120	13	initiated	initiate	VBN
18637	11120	14	by	by	IN
18637	11120	15	the	the	DT
18637	11120	16	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	11120	17	General	General	NNP
18637	11120	18	in	in	IN
18637	11120	19	the	the	DT
18637	11120	20	name	name	NN
18637	11120	21	of	of	IN
18637	11120	22	the	the	DT
18637	11120	23	United	United	NNP
18637	11120	24	States	States	NNP
18637	11120	25	.	.	.
18637	11121	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11121	2	412	412	CD
18637	11121	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11121	4	As	as	IN
18637	11121	5	in	in	IN
18637	11121	6	other	other	JJ
18637	11121	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11121	8	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11121	9	,	,	,
18637	11121	10	the	the	DT
18637	11121	11	United	United	NNP
18637	11121	12	States	States	NNP
18637	11121	13	,	,	,
18637	11121	14	like	like	IN
18637	11121	15	any	any	DT
18637	11121	16	other	other	JJ
18637	11121	17	party	party	NN
18637	11121	18	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11121	19	,	,	,
18637	11121	20	must	must	MD
18637	11121	21	have	have	VB
18637	11121	22	an	an	DT
18637	11121	23	interest	interest	NN
18637	11121	24	in	in	IN
18637	11121	25	the	the	DT
18637	11121	26	subject	subject	JJ
18637	11121	27	matter	matter	NN
18637	11121	28	and	and	CC
18637	11121	29	a	a	DT
18637	11121	30	legal	legal	JJ
18637	11121	31	right	right	NN
18637	11121	32	to	to	IN
18637	11121	33	the	the	DT
18637	11121	34	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	11121	35	sought	seek	VBN
18637	11121	36	.	.	.
18637	11122	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11122	2	413	413	CD
18637	11122	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11122	4	By	by	IN
18637	11122	5	the	the	DT
18637	11122	6	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11122	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11122	8	of	of	IN
18637	11122	9	1789	1789	CD
18637	11122	10	and	and	CC
18637	11122	11	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	11122	12	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	11122	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11122	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	11122	15	vested	vest	VBN
18637	11122	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11122	17	in	in	IN
18637	11122	18	the	the	DT
18637	11122	19	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11122	20	district	district	NN
18637	11122	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	11122	22	to	to	TO
18637	11122	23	hear	hear	VB
18637	11122	24	all	all	DT
18637	11122	25	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11122	26	of	of	IN
18637	11122	27	a	a	DT
18637	11122	28	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11122	29	nature	nature	NN
18637	11122	30	at	at	IN
18637	11122	31	law	law	NN
18637	11122	32	or	or	CC
18637	11122	33	in	in	IN
18637	11122	34	equity	equity	NN
18637	11122	35	,	,	,
18637	11122	36	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11122	37	by	by	IN
18637	11122	38	the	the	DT
18637	11122	39	United	United	NNP
18637	11122	40	States	States	NNP
18637	11122	41	as	as	IN
18637	11122	42	a	a	DT
18637	11122	43	party	party	NN
18637	11122	44	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11122	45	.	.	.
18637	11123	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11123	2	414	414	CD
18637	11123	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11123	4	SUITS	SUITS	NNP
18637	11123	5	AGAINST	against	IN
18637	11123	6	STATES	state	NNS
18637	11123	7	Controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11123	8	to	to	TO
18637	11123	9	which	which	WDT
18637	11123	10	the	the	DT
18637	11123	11	United	United	NNP
18637	11123	12	States	States	NNP
18637	11123	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	11123	14	a	a	DT
18637	11123	15	party	party	NN
18637	11123	16	include	include	VBP
18637	11123	17	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11123	18	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11123	19	against	against	IN
18637	11123	20	States	States	NNP
18637	11123	21	as	as	IN
18637	11123	22	party	party	NN
18637	11123	23	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	11123	24	.	.	.
18637	11124	1	The	the	DT
18637	11124	2	first	first	JJ
18637	11124	3	such	such	JJ
18637	11124	4	suit	suit	NN
18637	11124	5	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	11124	6	in	in	IN
18637	11124	7	United	United	NNP
18637	11124	8	States	States	NNP
18637	11124	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11124	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	11124	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11124	12	North	North	NNP
18637	11124	13	Carolina[415	Carolina[415	NNP
18637	11124	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11124	15	which	which	WDT
18637	11124	16	was	be	VBD
18637	11124	17	an	an	DT
18637	11124	18	action	action	NN
18637	11124	19	by	by	IN
18637	11124	20	the	the	DT
18637	11124	21	United	United	NNP
18637	11124	22	States	States	NNP
18637	11124	23	to	to	TO
18637	11124	24	recover	recover	VB
18637	11124	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	11124	26	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	11124	27	issued	issue	VBN
18637	11124	28	by	by	IN
18637	11124	29	North	North	NNP
18637	11124	30	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	11124	31	.	.	.
18637	11125	1	Although	although	IN
18637	11125	2	no	no	DT
18637	11125	3	question	question	NN
18637	11125	4	of	of	IN
18637	11125	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11125	6	was	be	VBD
18637	11125	7	raised	raise	VBN
18637	11125	8	,	,	,
18637	11125	9	in	in	IN
18637	11125	10	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	11125	11	the	the	DT
18637	11125	12	case	case	NN
18637	11125	13	on	on	IN
18637	11125	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11125	15	merits	merit	NNS
18637	11125	16	in	in	IN
18637	11125	17	favor	favor	NN
18637	11125	18	of	of	IN
18637	11125	19	the	the	DT
18637	11125	20	State	State	NNP
18637	11125	21	,	,	,
18637	11125	22	the	the	DT
18637	11125	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11125	24	tacitly	tacitly	RB
18637	11125	25	assumed	assume	VBD
18637	11125	26	that	that	IN
18637	11125	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11125	28	had	have	VBD
18637	11125	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11125	30	of	of	IN
18637	11125	31	such	such	JJ
18637	11125	32	cases	case	NNS
18637	11125	33	.	.	.
18637	11126	1	The	the	DT
18637	11126	2	issue	issue	NN
18637	11126	3	of	of	IN
18637	11126	4	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11126	5	was	be	VBD
18637	11126	6	directly	directly	RB
18637	11126	7	raised	raise	VBN
18637	11126	8	by	by	IN
18637	11126	9	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	11126	10	a	a	DT
18637	11126	11	few	few	JJ
18637	11126	12	years	year	NNS
18637	11126	13	later	later	RB
18637	11126	14	in	in	IN
18637	11126	15	a	a	DT
18637	11126	16	bill	bill	NN
18637	11126	17	in	in	IN
18637	11126	18	equity	equity	NN
18637	11126	19	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11126	20	by	by	IN
18637	11126	21	the	the	DT
18637	11126	22	United	United	NNP
18637	11126	23	States	States	NNP
18637	11126	24	to	to	TO
18637	11126	25	determine	determine	VB
18637	11126	26	the	the	DT
18637	11126	27	boundary	boundary	NN
18637	11126	28	between	between	IN
18637	11126	29	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	11126	30	and	and	CC
18637	11126	31	the	the	DT
18637	11126	32	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	11126	33	of	of	IN
18637	11126	34	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	11126	35	,	,	,
18637	11126	36	and	and	CC
18637	11126	37	the	the	DT
18637	11126	38	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11126	39	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	11126	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11126	41	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11126	42	over	over	IN
18637	11126	43	strong	strong	JJ
18637	11126	44	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	11126	45	by	by	IN
18637	11126	46	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	11126	47	to	to	IN
18637	11126	48	the	the	DT
18637	11126	49	effect	effect	NN
18637	11126	50	that	that	IN
18637	11126	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11126	52	could	could	MD
18637	11126	53	not	not	RB
18637	11126	54	be	be	VB
18637	11126	55	sued	sue	VBN
18637	11126	56	by	by	IN
18637	11126	57	the	the	DT
18637	11126	58	United	United	NNP
18637	11126	59	States	States	NNP
18637	11126	60	without	without	IN
18637	11126	61	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11126	62	consent	consent	NN
18637	11126	63	and	and	CC
18637	11126	64	that	that	IN
18637	11126	65	the	the	DT
18637	11126	66	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11126	67	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11126	68	's	's	POS
18637	11126	69	original	original	JJ
18637	11126	70	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11126	71	did	do	VBD
18637	11126	72	not	not	RB
18637	11126	73	extend	extend	VB
18637	11126	74	to	to	IN
18637	11126	75	cases	case	NNS
18637	11126	76	to	to	TO
18637	11126	77	which	which	WDT
18637	11126	78	the	the	DT
18637	11126	79	United	United	NNP
18637	11126	80	States	States	NNP
18637	11126	81	is	be	VBZ
18637	11126	82	a	a	DT
18637	11126	83	party	party	NN
18637	11126	84	.	.	.
18637	11127	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11127	2	416	416	CD
18637	11127	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11127	4	Stressing	stress	VBG
18637	11127	5	the	the	DT
18637	11127	6	inclusion	inclusion	NN
18637	11127	7	within	within	IN
18637	11127	8	the	the	DT
18637	11127	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11127	10	power	power	NN
18637	11127	11	of	of	IN
18637	11127	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	11127	13	to	to	TO
18637	11127	14	which	which	WDT
18637	11127	15	the	the	DT
18637	11127	16	United	United	NNP
18637	11127	17	States	States	NNP
18637	11127	18	and	and	CC
18637	11127	19	a	a	DT
18637	11127	20	State	state	NN
18637	11127	21	are	be	VBP
18637	11127	22	parties	party	NNS
18637	11127	23	,	,	,
18637	11127	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11127	25	Harlan	Harlan	NNP
18637	11127	26	pointed	point	VBD
18637	11127	27	out	out	RP
18637	11127	28	that	that	IN
18637	11127	29	the	the	DT
18637	11127	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11127	31	made	make	VBD
18637	11127	32	no	no	DT
18637	11127	33	exception	exception	NN
18637	11127	34	of	of	IN
18637	11127	35	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11127	36	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11127	37	by	by	IN
18637	11127	38	the	the	DT
18637	11127	39	United	United	NNP
18637	11127	40	States	States	NNP
18637	11127	41	.	.	.
18637	11128	1	In	in	IN
18637	11128	2	effect	effect	NN
18637	11128	3	,	,	,
18637	11128	4	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11128	5	,	,	,
18637	11128	6	consent	consent	NN
18637	11128	7	to	to	TO
18637	11128	8	be	be	VB
18637	11128	9	sued	sue	VBN
18637	11128	10	by	by	IN
18637	11128	11	the	the	DT
18637	11128	12	United	United	NNP
18637	11128	13	States	States	NNP
18637	11128	14	"	"	''
18637	11128	15	was	be	VBD
18637	11128	16	given	give	VBN
18637	11128	17	by	by	IN
18637	11128	18	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	11128	19	when	when	WRB
18637	11128	20	admitted	admit	VBD
18637	11128	21	to	to	IN
18637	11128	22	the	the	DT
18637	11128	23	Union	Union	NNP
18637	11128	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	11128	25	an	an	DT
18637	11128	26	equal	equal	JJ
18637	11128	27	footing	footing	NN
18637	11128	28	in	in	IN
18637	11128	29	all	all	DT
18637	11128	30	respects	respect	NNS
18637	11128	31	with	with	IN
18637	11128	32	the	the	DT
18637	11128	33	other	other	JJ
18637	11128	34	States	States	NNPS
18637	11128	35	.	.	.
18637	11129	1	"	"	``
18637	11129	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11129	3	417	417	CD
18637	11129	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11129	5	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	11129	6	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11129	7	by	by	IN
18637	11129	8	the	the	DT
18637	11129	9	United	United	NNP
18637	11129	10	States	States	NNP
18637	11129	11	against	against	IN
18637	11129	12	States	States	NNPS
18637	11129	13	have	have	VBP
18637	11129	14	,	,	,
18637	11129	15	however	however	RB
18637	11129	16	,	,	,
18637	11129	17	been	be	VBN
18637	11129	18	infrequent	infrequent	JJ
18637	11129	19	.	.	.
18637	11130	1	All	all	DT
18637	11130	2	of	of	IN
18637	11130	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11130	4	have	have	VBP
18637	11130	5	arisen	arise	VBN
18637	11130	6	since	since	IN
18637	11130	7	1889	1889	CD
18637	11130	8	,	,	,
18637	11130	9	and	and	CC
18637	11130	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11130	11	have	have	VBP
18637	11130	12	become	become	VBN
18637	11130	13	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	11130	14	more	more	RBR
18637	11130	15	common	common	JJ
18637	11130	16	since	since	IN
18637	11130	17	1926	1926	CD
18637	11130	18	.	.	.
18637	11131	1	That	that	DT
18637	11131	2	year	year	NN
18637	11131	3	the	the	DT
18637	11131	4	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11131	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11131	6	decided	decide	VBD
18637	11131	7	a	a	DT
18637	11131	8	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	11131	9	between	between	IN
18637	11131	10	the	the	DT
18637	11131	11	United	United	NNP
18637	11131	12	States	States	NNP
18637	11131	13	and	and	CC
18637	11131	14	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	11131	15	over	over	IN
18637	11131	16	land	land	NN
18637	11131	17	patents	patent	NNS
18637	11131	18	issued	issue	VBN
18637	11131	19	to	to	IN
18637	11131	20	the	the	DT
18637	11131	21	State	State	NNP
18637	11131	22	by	by	IN
18637	11131	23	the	the	DT
18637	11131	24	United	United	NNP
18637	11131	25	States	States	NNP
18637	11131	26	in	in	IN
18637	11131	27	breach	breach	NN
18637	11131	28	of	of	IN
18637	11131	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11131	30	trust	trust	NN
18637	11131	31	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	11131	32	to	to	IN
18637	11131	33	the	the	DT
18637	11131	34	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	11131	35	.	.	.
18637	11132	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11132	2	418	418	CD
18637	11132	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11132	4	In	in	IN
18637	11132	5	United	United	NNP
18637	11132	6	States	States	NNP
18637	11132	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11132	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11132	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11132	10	West	West	NNP
18637	11132	11	Virginia,[419	Virginia,[419	NNP
18637	11132	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11132	13	the	the	DT
18637	11132	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11132	15	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	11132	16	to	to	TO
18637	11132	17	take	take	VB
18637	11132	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11132	19	of	of	IN
18637	11132	20	a	a	DT
18637	11132	21	suit	suit	NN
18637	11132	22	in	in	IN
18637	11132	23	equity	equity	NN
18637	11132	24	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11132	25	by	by	IN
18637	11132	26	the	the	DT
18637	11132	27	United	United	NNP
18637	11132	28	States	States	NNP
18637	11132	29	to	to	TO
18637	11132	30	determine	determine	VB
18637	11132	31	the	the	DT
18637	11132	32	navigability	navigability	NN
18637	11132	33	of	of	IN
18637	11132	34	the	the	DT
18637	11132	35	New	New	NNP
18637	11132	36	and	and	CC
18637	11132	37	Kanawha	Kanawha	NNP
18637	11132	38	Rivers	Rivers	NNP
18637	11132	39	on	on	IN
18637	11132	40	the	the	DT
18637	11132	41	ground	ground	NN
18637	11132	42	that	that	IN
18637	11132	43	the	the	DT
18637	11132	44	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11132	45	in	in	IN
18637	11132	46	such	such	JJ
18637	11132	47	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11132	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	11132	49	limited	limit	VBN
18637	11132	50	to	to	IN
18637	11132	51	cases	case	NNS
18637	11132	52	and	and	CC
18637	11132	53	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11132	54	and	and	CC
18637	11132	55	does	do	VBZ
18637	11132	56	not	not	RB
18637	11132	57	extend	extend	VB
18637	11132	58	to	to	IN
18637	11132	59	the	the	DT
18637	11132	60	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	11132	61	of	of	IN
18637	11132	62	mere	mere	JJ
18637	11132	63	differences	difference	NNS
18637	11132	64	of	of	IN
18637	11132	65	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11132	66	between	between	IN
18637	11132	67	the	the	DT
18637	11132	68	officials	official	NNS
18637	11132	69	of	of	IN
18637	11132	70	the	the	DT
18637	11132	71	two	two	CD
18637	11132	72	governments	government	NNS
18637	11132	73	.	.	.
18637	11133	1	A	a	DT
18637	11133	2	few	few	JJ
18637	11133	3	years	year	NNS
18637	11133	4	earlier	early	RBR
18637	11133	5	,	,	,
18637	11133	6	however	however	RB
18637	11133	7	,	,	,
18637	11133	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11133	9	had	have	VBD
18637	11133	10	taken	take	VBN
18637	11133	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11133	12	of	of	IN
18637	11133	13	a	a	DT
18637	11133	14	suit	suit	NN
18637	11133	15	by	by	IN
18637	11133	16	the	the	DT
18637	11133	17	United	United	NNP
18637	11133	18	States	States	NNP
18637	11133	19	against	against	IN
18637	11133	20	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	11133	21	to	to	IN
18637	11133	22	quiet	quiet	JJ
18637	11133	23	title	title	NN
18637	11133	24	to	to	TO
18637	11133	25	land	land	NN
18637	11133	26	forming	form	VBG
18637	11133	27	the	the	DT
18637	11133	28	beds	bed	NNS
18637	11133	29	of	of	IN
18637	11133	30	certain	certain	JJ
18637	11133	31	sections	section	NNS
18637	11133	32	of	of	IN
18637	11133	33	the	the	DT
18637	11133	34	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	11133	35	River	River	NNP
18637	11133	36	and	and	CC
18637	11133	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11133	38	tributaries	tributary	NNS
18637	11133	39	within	within	IN
18637	11133	40	the	the	DT
18637	11133	41	States	States	NNP
18637	11133	42	.	.	.
18637	11134	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11134	2	420	420	CD
18637	11134	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11134	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	11134	5	,	,	,
18637	11134	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11134	7	took	take	VBD
18637	11134	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11134	9	of	of	IN
18637	11134	10	a	a	DT
18637	11134	11	suit	suit	NN
18637	11134	12	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11134	13	by	by	IN
18637	11134	14	the	the	DT
18637	11134	15	United	United	NNP
18637	11134	16	States	States	NNP
18637	11134	17	against	against	IN
18637	11134	18	California	California	NNP
18637	11134	19	to	to	TO
18637	11134	20	determine	determine	VB
18637	11134	21	the	the	DT
18637	11134	22	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	11134	23	of	of	IN
18637	11134	24	and	and	CC
18637	11134	25	paramount	paramount	JJ
18637	11134	26	rights	right	NNS
18637	11134	27	over	over	IN
18637	11134	28	the	the	DT
18637	11134	29	submerged	submerge	VBN
18637	11134	30	land	land	NN
18637	11134	31	and	and	CC
18637	11134	32	the	the	DT
18637	11134	33	oil	oil	NN
18637	11134	34	and	and	CC
18637	11134	35	gas	gas	NN
18637	11134	36	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	11134	37	off	off	IN
18637	11134	38	the	the	DT
18637	11134	39	coast	coast	NN
18637	11134	40	of	of	IN
18637	11134	41	California	California	NNP
18637	11134	42	between	between	IN
18637	11134	43	the	the	DT
18637	11134	44	low	low	JJ
18637	11134	45	-	-	HYPH
18637	11134	46	water	water	NN
18637	11134	47	mark	mark	NN
18637	11134	48	and	and	CC
18637	11134	49	the	the	DT
18637	11134	50	three	three	CD
18637	11134	51	-	-	HYPH
18637	11134	52	mile	mile	NN
18637	11134	53	limit	limit	NN
18637	11134	54	.	.	.
18637	11135	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11135	2	421	421	CD
18637	11135	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11135	4	Like	like	IN
18637	11135	5	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11135	6	were	be	VBD
18637	11135	7	decided	decide	VBN
18637	11135	8	against	against	IN
18637	11135	9	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	11135	10	and	and	CC
18637	11135	11	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	11135	12	in	in	IN
18637	11135	13	1950	1950	CD
18637	11135	14	.	.	.
18637	11136	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11136	2	422	422	CD
18637	11136	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11136	4	IMMUNITY	immunity	NN
18637	11136	5	OF	of	IN
18637	11136	6	THE	the	DT
18637	11136	7	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	11136	8	STATES	state	NNS
18637	11136	9	FROM	from	IN
18637	11136	10	SUIT	SUIT	NNP
18637	11136	11	In	in	IN
18637	11136	12	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	11136	13	of	of	IN
18637	11136	14	the	the	DT
18637	11136	15	general	general	JJ
18637	11136	16	rule	rule	NN
18637	11136	17	that	that	IN
18637	11136	18	a	a	DT
18637	11136	19	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	11136	20	can	can	MD
18637	11136	21	not	not	RB
18637	11136	22	be	be	VB
18637	11136	23	sued	sue	VBN
18637	11136	24	in	in	IN
18637	11136	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11136	26	own	own	JJ
18637	11136	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	11136	28	,	,	,
18637	11136	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11136	30	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	11136	31	that	that	IN
18637	11136	32	the	the	DT
18637	11136	33	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11136	34	power	power	NN
18637	11136	35	does	do	VBZ
18637	11136	36	not	not	RB
18637	11136	37	extend	extend	VB
18637	11136	38	to	to	IN
18637	11136	39	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11136	40	against	against	IN
18637	11136	41	the	the	DT
18637	11136	42	United	United	NNP
18637	11136	43	States	States	NNP
18637	11136	44	unless	unless	IN
18637	11136	45	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11136	46	by	by	IN
18637	11136	47	general	general	JJ
18637	11136	48	or	or	CC
18637	11136	49	special	special	JJ
18637	11136	50	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	11136	51	consents	consent	NNS
18637	11136	52	to	to	IN
18637	11136	53	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11136	54	against	against	IN
18637	11136	55	the	the	DT
18637	11136	56	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11136	57	.	.	.
18637	11137	1	This	this	DT
18637	11137	2	rule	rule	NN
18637	11137	3	first	first	RB
18637	11137	4	emanated	emanate	VBN
18637	11137	5	in	in	IN
18637	11137	6	embryo	embryo	NN
18637	11137	7	form	form	NN
18637	11137	8	in	in	IN
18637	11137	9	an	an	DT
18637	11137	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11137	11	obiter	obiter	NN
18637	11137	12	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	11137	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11137	14	by	by	IN
18637	11137	15	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11137	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11137	17	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	11137	18	in	in	IN
18637	11137	19	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
18637	11137	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11137	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	11137	22	_	_	NNP
18637	11137	23	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11137	24	,	,	,
18637	11137	25	where	where	WRB
18637	11137	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11137	27	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	11137	28	that	that	IN
18637	11137	29	a	a	DT
18637	11137	30	suit	suit	NN
18637	11137	31	would	would	MD
18637	11137	32	not	not	RB
18637	11137	33	lie	lie	VB
18637	11137	34	against	against	IN
18637	11137	35	the	the	DT
18637	11137	36	United	United	NNP
18637	11137	37	States	States	NNP
18637	11137	38	because	because	IN
18637	11137	39	"	"	``
18637	11137	40	there	there	EX
18637	11137	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	11137	42	no	no	DT
18637	11137	43	power	power	NN
18637	11137	44	which	which	WDT
18637	11137	45	the	the	DT
18637	11137	46	courts	court	NNS
18637	11137	47	can	can	MD
18637	11137	48	call	call	VB
18637	11137	49	to	to	IN
18637	11137	50	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11137	51	aid	aid	NN
18637	11137	52	.	.	.
18637	11138	1	"	"	``
18637	11138	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11138	3	423	423	CD
18637	11138	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11138	5	In	in	IN
18637	11138	6	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	11138	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11138	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11138	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11138	10	Virginia,[424	Virginia,[424	NNP
18637	11138	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11138	12	also	also	RB
18637	11138	13	by	by	IN
18637	11138	14	way	way	NN
18637	11138	15	of	of	IN
18637	11138	16	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	11138	17	,	,	,
18637	11138	18	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11138	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11138	20	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11138	21	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	11138	22	,	,	,
18637	11138	23	"	"	``
18637	11138	24	the	the	DT
18637	11138	25	universally	universally	RB
18637	11138	26	received	receive	VBN
18637	11138	27	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11138	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	11138	29	,	,	,
18637	11138	30	that	that	IN
18637	11138	31	no	no	DT
18637	11138	32	suit	suit	NN
18637	11138	33	can	can	MD
18637	11138	34	be	be	VB
18637	11138	35	commenced	commence	VBN
18637	11138	36	or	or	CC
18637	11138	37	prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
18637	11138	38	against	against	IN
18637	11138	39	the	the	DT
18637	11138	40	United	United	NNP
18637	11138	41	States	States	NNP
18637	11138	42	.	.	.
18637	11138	43	"	"	''
18637	11139	1	The	the	DT
18637	11139	2	issue	issue	NN
18637	11139	3	was	be	VBD
18637	11139	4	more	more	RBR
18637	11139	5	directly	directly	RB
18637	11139	6	in	in	IN
18637	11139	7	question	question	NN
18637	11139	8	in	in	IN
18637	11139	9	United	United	NNP
18637	11139	10	States	States	NNP
18637	11139	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11139	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	11139	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11139	14	Clarke[425	Clarke[425	NNP
18637	11139	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11139	16	where	where	WRB
18637	11139	17	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11139	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11139	19	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11139	20	stated	state	VBD
18637	11139	21	that	that	IN
18637	11139	22	as	as	IN
18637	11139	23	the	the	DT
18637	11139	24	United	United	NNP
18637	11139	25	States	States	NNP
18637	11139	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	11139	27	"	"	``
18637	11139	28	not	not	RB
18637	11139	29	suable	suable	JJ
18637	11139	30	of	of	IN
18637	11139	31	common	common	JJ
18637	11139	32	right	right	NN
18637	11139	33	,	,	,
18637	11139	34	the	the	DT
18637	11139	35	party	party	NN
18637	11139	36	who	who	WP
18637	11139	37	institutes	institute	VBZ
18637	11139	38	such	such	JJ
18637	11139	39	suit	suit	NN
18637	11139	40	must	must	MD
18637	11139	41	bring	bring	VB
18637	11139	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11139	43	case	case	NN
18637	11139	44	within	within	IN
18637	11139	45	the	the	DT
18637	11139	46	authority	authority	NN
18637	11139	47	of	of	IN
18637	11139	48	some	some	DT
18637	11139	49	act	act	NN
18637	11139	50	of	of	IN
18637	11139	51	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11139	52	,	,	,
18637	11139	53	or	or	CC
18637	11139	54	the	the	DT
18637	11139	55	court	court	NN
18637	11139	56	can	can	MD
18637	11139	57	not	not	RB
18637	11139	58	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	11139	59	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11139	60	over	over	IN
18637	11139	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11139	62	.	.	.
18637	11139	63	"	"	''
18637	11140	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11140	2	thereupon	thereupon	RB
18637	11140	3	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	11140	4	that	that	IN
18637	11140	5	the	the	DT
18637	11140	6	act	act	NN
18637	11140	7	of	of	IN
18637	11140	8	May	May	NNP
18637	11140	9	26	26	CD
18637	11140	10	,	,	,
18637	11140	11	1830	1830	CD
18637	11140	12	,	,	,
18637	11140	13	for	for	IN
18637	11140	14	the	the	DT
18637	11140	15	final	final	JJ
18637	11140	16	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	11140	17	of	of	IN
18637	11140	18	land	land	NN
18637	11140	19	claims	claim	NNS
18637	11140	20	in	in	IN
18637	11140	21	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	11140	22	condoned	condone	VBD
18637	11140	23	the	the	DT
18637	11140	24	suit	suit	NN
18637	11140	25	.	.	.
18637	11141	1	The	the	DT
18637	11141	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	11141	3	of	of	IN
18637	11141	4	the	the	DT
18637	11141	5	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	11141	6	of	of	IN
18637	11141	7	the	the	DT
18637	11141	8	United	United	NNP
18637	11141	9	States	States	NNP
18637	11141	10	from	from	IN
18637	11141	11	suit	suit	NN
18637	11141	12	was	be	VBD
18637	11141	13	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	11141	14	in	in	IN
18637	11141	15	various	various	JJ
18637	11141	16	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	11141	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	11141	18	,	,	,
18637	11141	19	without	without	IN
18637	11141	20	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	11141	21	or	or	CC
18637	11141	22	examination	examination	NN
18637	11141	23	.	.	.
18637	11142	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11142	2	426	426	CD
18637	11142	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11142	4	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	11142	5	,	,	,
18637	11142	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11142	7	was	be	VBD
18637	11142	8	not	not	RB
18637	11142	9	until	until	IN
18637	11142	10	United	United	NNP
18637	11142	11	States	States	NNP
18637	11142	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11142	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	11142	14	_	_	NNP
18637	11142	15	Lee[427	Lee[427	NNP
18637	11142	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11142	17	that	that	IN
18637	11142	18	the	the	DT
18637	11142	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11142	20	examined	examine	VBD
18637	11142	21	the	the	DT
18637	11142	22	rule	rule	NN
18637	11142	23	and	and	CC
18637	11142	24	the	the	DT
18637	11142	25	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	11142	26	for	for	IN
18637	11142	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11142	28	,	,	,
18637	11142	29	and	and	CC
18637	11142	30	limited	limit	VBD
18637	11142	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11142	32	application	application	NN
18637	11142	33	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	11142	34	.	.	.
18637	11143	1	Waiver	waiver	NN
18637	11143	2	of	of	IN
18637	11143	3	Immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11143	4	by	by	IN
18637	11143	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11143	6	Since	Since	NNP
18637	11143	7	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11143	8	against	against	IN
18637	11143	9	the	the	DT
18637	11143	10	United	United	NNP
18637	11143	11	States	States	NNP
18637	11143	12	can	can	MD
18637	11143	13	be	be	VB
18637	11143	14	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	11143	15	only	only	RB
18637	11143	16	by	by	IN
18637	11143	17	permission	permission	NN
18637	11143	18	,	,	,
18637	11143	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11143	20	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	11143	21	that	that	IN
18637	11143	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11143	23	can	can	MD
18637	11143	24	be	be	VB
18637	11143	25	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11143	26	only	only	RB
18637	11143	27	in	in	IN
18637	11143	28	the	the	DT
18637	11143	29	manner	manner	NN
18637	11143	30	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	11143	31	by	by	IN
18637	11143	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11143	33	and	and	CC
18637	11143	34	subject	subject	JJ
18637	11143	35	to	to	IN
18637	11143	36	the	the	DT
18637	11143	37	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	11143	38	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	11143	39	.	.	.
18637	11144	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11144	2	428	428	CD
18637	11144	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11144	4	Only	only	RB
18637	11144	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11144	6	can	can	MD
18637	11144	7	take	take	VB
18637	11144	8	the	the	DT
18637	11144	9	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11144	10	steps	step	NNS
18637	11144	11	to	to	TO
18637	11144	12	waive	waive	VB
18637	11144	13	the	the	DT
18637	11144	14	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11144	15	of	of	IN
18637	11144	16	the	the	DT
18637	11144	17	United	United	NNP
18637	11144	18	States	States	NNP
18637	11144	19	from	from	IN
18637	11144	20	liability	liability	NN
18637	11144	21	for	for	IN
18637	11144	22	claims	claim	NNS
18637	11144	23	,	,	,
18637	11144	24	and	and	CC
18637	11144	25	hence	hence	RB
18637	11144	26	officers	officer	NNS
18637	11144	27	of	of	IN
18637	11144	28	the	the	DT
18637	11144	29	United	United	NNP
18637	11144	30	States	States	NNP
18637	11144	31	are	be	VBP
18637	11144	32	powerless	powerless	JJ
18637	11144	33	by	by	IN
18637	11144	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11144	35	actions	action	NNS
18637	11144	36	either	either	CC
18637	11144	37	to	to	TO
18637	11144	38	waive	waive	VB
18637	11144	39	such	such	JJ
18637	11144	40	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11144	41	or	or	CC
18637	11144	42	to	to	TO
18637	11144	43	confer	confer	VB
18637	11144	44	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11144	45	on	on	IN
18637	11144	46	a	a	DT
18637	11144	47	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11144	48	court	court	NN
18637	11144	49	.	.	.
18637	11145	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11145	2	429	429	CD
18637	11145	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11145	4	Even	even	RB
18637	11145	5	when	when	WRB
18637	11145	6	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	11145	7	,	,	,
18637	11145	8	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11145	9	can	can	MD
18637	11145	10	be	be	VB
18637	11145	11	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11145	12	only	only	RB
18637	11145	13	in	in	IN
18637	11145	14	designated	designate	VBN
18637	11145	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	11145	16	.	.	.
18637	11146	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11146	2	430	430	CD
18637	11146	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11146	4	These	these	DT
18637	11146	5	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11146	6	apply	apply	VBP
18637	11146	7	equally	equally	RB
18637	11146	8	to	to	IN
18637	11146	9	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11146	10	by	by	IN
18637	11146	11	States	state	NNS
18637	11146	12	against	against	IN
18637	11146	13	the	the	DT
18637	11146	14	United	United	NNP
18637	11146	15	States	States	NNP
18637	11146	16	.	.	.
18637	11147	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11147	2	431	431	CD
18637	11147	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11147	4	Although	although	IN
18637	11147	5	an	an	DT
18637	11147	6	officer	officer	NN
18637	11147	7	acting	act	VBG
18637	11147	8	as	as	IN
18637	11147	9	a	a	DT
18637	11147	10	public	public	JJ
18637	11147	11	instrumentality	instrumentality	NN
18637	11147	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	11147	13	liable	liable	JJ
18637	11147	14	for	for	IN
18637	11147	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11147	16	own	own	JJ
18637	11147	17	torts	tort	NNS
18637	11147	18	,	,	,
18637	11147	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11147	20	may	may	MD
18637	11147	21	grant	grant	VB
18637	11147	22	or	or	CC
18637	11147	23	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	11147	24	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11147	25	from	from	IN
18637	11147	26	suit	suit	NN
18637	11147	27	on	on	IN
18637	11147	28	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	11147	29	of	of	IN
18637	11147	30	government	government	NN
18637	11147	31	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	11147	32	.	.	.
18637	11148	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11148	2	432	432	CD
18637	11148	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11148	4	United	United	NNP
18637	11148	5	States	States	NNP
18637	11148	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11148	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	11148	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11148	9	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	11148	10	United	United	NNP
18637	11148	11	States	States	NNP
18637	11148	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11148	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	11148	14	_	_	NNP
18637	11148	15	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	11148	16	,	,	,
18637	11148	17	a	a	DT
18637	11148	18	five	five	CD
18637	11148	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	11148	20	to	to	IN
18637	11148	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	11148	22	four	four	CD
18637	11148	23	decision	decision	NN
18637	11148	24	,	,	,
18637	11148	25	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	11148	26	earlier	early	JJR
18637	11148	27	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	11148	28	to	to	IN
18637	11148	29	the	the	DT
18637	11148	30	effect	effect	NN
18637	11148	31	that	that	IN
18637	11148	32	where	where	WRB
18637	11148	33	a	a	DT
18637	11148	34	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11148	35	affected	affect	VBD
18637	11148	36	the	the	DT
18637	11148	37	property	property	NN
18637	11148	38	of	of	IN
18637	11148	39	the	the	DT
18637	11148	40	United	United	NNP
18637	11148	41	States	States	NNP
18637	11148	42	the	the	DT
18637	11148	43	suit	suit	NN
18637	11148	44	was	be	VBD
18637	11148	45	in	in	IN
18637	11148	46	effect	effect	NN
18637	11148	47	against	against	IN
18637	11148	48	the	the	DT
18637	11148	49	United	United	NNP
18637	11148	50	States	States	NNP
18637	11148	51	,	,	,
18637	11148	52	by	by	IN
18637	11148	53	ruling	rule	VBG
18637	11148	54	that	that	DT
18637	11148	55	title	title	NN
18637	11148	56	to	to	IN
18637	11148	57	the	the	DT
18637	11148	58	Arlington	Arlington	NNP
18637	11148	59	estate	estate	NN
18637	11148	60	of	of	IN
18637	11148	61	the	the	DT
18637	11148	62	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	11148	63	family	family	NN
18637	11148	64	,	,	,
18637	11148	65	then	then	RB
18637	11148	66	being	be	VBG
18637	11148	67	used	use	VBN
18637	11148	68	as	as	IN
18637	11148	69	a	a	DT
18637	11148	70	national	national	JJ
18637	11148	71	cemetery	cemetery	NN
18637	11148	72	,	,	,
18637	11148	73	was	be	VBD
18637	11148	74	not	not	RB
18637	11148	75	legally	legally	RB
18637	11148	76	vested	vest	VBN
18637	11148	77	in	in	IN
18637	11148	78	the	the	DT
18637	11148	79	United	United	NNP
18637	11148	80	States	States	NNP
18637	11148	81	but	but	CC
18637	11148	82	was	be	VBD
18637	11148	83	being	be	VBG
18637	11148	84	held	hold	VBN
18637	11148	85	illegally	illegally	RB
18637	11148	86	by	by	IN
18637	11148	87	army	army	NN
18637	11148	88	officers	officer	NNS
18637	11148	89	under	under	IN
18637	11148	90	an	an	DT
18637	11148	91	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	11148	92	order	order	NN
18637	11148	93	of	of	IN
18637	11148	94	the	the	DT
18637	11148	95	President	President	NNP
18637	11148	96	.	.	.
18637	11149	1	In	in	IN
18637	11149	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11149	3	examination	examination	NN
18637	11149	4	of	of	IN
18637	11149	5	the	the	DT
18637	11149	6	sources	source	NNS
18637	11149	7	and	and	CC
18637	11149	8	application	application	NN
18637	11149	9	of	of	IN
18637	11149	10	the	the	DT
18637	11149	11	rule	rule	NN
18637	11149	12	of	of	IN
18637	11149	13	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	11149	14	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11149	15	,	,	,
18637	11149	16	the	the	DT
18637	11149	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11149	18	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	11149	19	that	that	IN
18637	11149	20	the	the	DT
18637	11149	21	rule	rule	NN
18637	11149	22	"	"	``
18637	11149	23	if	if	IN
18637	11149	24	not	not	RB
18637	11149	25	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	11149	26	limited	limit	VBN
18637	11149	27	to	to	IN
18637	11149	28	cases	case	NNS
18637	11149	29	in	in	IN
18637	11149	30	which	which	WDT
18637	11149	31	the	the	DT
18637	11149	32	United	United	NNP
18637	11149	33	States	States	NNP
18637	11149	34	are	be	VBP
18637	11149	35	made	make	VBN
18637	11149	36	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	11149	37	by	by	IN
18637	11149	38	name	name	NN
18637	11149	39	,	,	,
18637	11149	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	11149	41	not	not	RB
18637	11149	42	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	11149	43	to	to	TO
18637	11149	44	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	11149	45	with	with	IN
18637	11149	46	the	the	DT
18637	11149	47	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11149	48	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11149	49	of	of	IN
18637	11149	50	the	the	DT
18637	11149	51	rights	right	NNS
18637	11149	52	of	of	IN
18637	11149	53	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
18637	11149	54	when	when	WRB
18637	11149	55	the	the	DT
18637	11149	56	United	United	NNP
18637	11149	57	States	States	NNP
18637	11149	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	11149	59	not	not	RB
18637	11149	60	a	a	DT
18637	11149	61	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	11149	62	or	or	CC
18637	11149	63	a	a	DT
18637	11149	64	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11149	65	party	party	NN
18637	11149	66	to	to	IN
18637	11149	67	the	the	DT
18637	11149	68	suit	suit	NN
18637	11149	69	.	.	.
18637	11150	1	"	"	``
18637	11150	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11150	3	433	433	CD
18637	11150	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11150	5	Except	except	IN
18637	11150	6	,	,	,
18637	11150	7	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	11150	8	,	,	,
18637	11150	9	for	for	IN
18637	11150	10	an	an	DT
18637	11150	11	occasional	occasional	JJ
18637	11150	12	case	case	NN
18637	11150	13	like	like	IN
18637	11150	14	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	11150	15	_	_	NNP
18637	11150	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	11150	17	_	_	NNP
18637	11150	18	United	United	NNP
18637	11150	19	States,[434	States,[434	NNP
18637	11150	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11150	21	which	which	WDT
18637	11150	22	held	hold	VBD
18637	11150	23	that	that	IN
18637	11150	24	a	a	DT
18637	11150	25	State	state	NN
18637	11150	26	can	can	MD
18637	11150	27	not	not	RB
18637	11150	28	sue	sue	VB
18637	11150	29	the	the	DT
18637	11150	30	United	United	NNP
18637	11150	31	States	States	NNP
18637	11150	32	,	,	,
18637	11150	33	most	most	JJS
18637	11150	34	of	of	IN
18637	11150	35	the	the	DT
18637	11150	36	cases	case	NNS
18637	11150	37	involving	involve	VBG
18637	11150	38	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	11150	39	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11150	40	from	from	IN
18637	11150	41	suit	suit	NN
18637	11150	42	since	since	IN
18637	11150	43	1883	1883	CD
18637	11150	44	have	have	VBP
18637	11150	45	been	be	VBN
18637	11150	46	cases	case	NNS
18637	11150	47	against	against	IN
18637	11150	48	officers	officer	NNS
18637	11150	49	,	,	,
18637	11150	50	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	11150	51	,	,	,
18637	11150	52	or	or	CC
18637	11150	53	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	11150	54	of	of	IN
18637	11150	55	the	the	DT
18637	11150	56	United	United	NNP
18637	11150	57	States	States	NNP
18637	11150	58	where	where	WRB
18637	11150	59	the	the	DT
18637	11150	60	United	United	NNP
18637	11150	61	States	States	NNP
18637	11150	62	has	have	VBZ
18637	11150	63	not	not	RB
18637	11150	64	been	be	VBN
18637	11150	65	named	name	VBN
18637	11150	66	as	as	IN
18637	11150	67	a	a	DT
18637	11150	68	party	party	NN
18637	11150	69	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	11150	70	.	.	.
18637	11151	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	11151	2	,	,	,
18637	11151	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11151	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	11151	5	been	be	VBN
18637	11151	6	held	hold	VBN
18637	11151	7	that	that	IN
18637	11151	8	a	a	DT
18637	11151	9	suit	suit	NN
18637	11151	10	against	against	IN
18637	11151	11	the	the	DT
18637	11151	12	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	11151	13	of	of	IN
18637	11151	14	the	the	DT
18637	11151	15	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	11151	16	to	to	TO
18637	11151	17	review	review	VB
18637	11151	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11151	19	decision	decision	NN
18637	11151	20	on	on	IN
18637	11151	21	the	the	DT
18637	11151	22	rate	rate	NN
18637	11151	23	of	of	IN
18637	11151	24	duty	duty	NN
18637	11151	25	to	to	TO
18637	11151	26	be	be	VB
18637	11151	27	exacted	exact	VBN
18637	11151	28	on	on	IN
18637	11151	29	imported	import	VBN
18637	11151	30	sugar	sugar	NN
18637	11151	31	would	would	MD
18637	11151	32	disturb	disturb	VB
18637	11151	33	the	the	DT
18637	11151	34	whole	whole	JJ
18637	11151	35	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	11151	36	system	system	NN
18637	11151	37	of	of	IN
18637	11151	38	the	the	DT
18637	11151	39	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11151	40	and	and	CC
18637	11151	41	would	would	MD
18637	11151	42	in	in	IN
18637	11151	43	effect	effect	NN
18637	11151	44	be	be	VB
18637	11151	45	a	a	DT
18637	11151	46	suit	suit	NN
18637	11151	47	against	against	IN
18637	11151	48	the	the	DT
18637	11151	49	United	United	NNP
18637	11151	50	States	States	NNP
18637	11151	51	.	.	.
18637	11152	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11152	2	435	435	CD
18637	11152	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11152	4	Even	even	RB
18637	11152	5	more	more	RBR
18637	11152	6	significant	significant	JJ
18637	11152	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	11152	8	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
18637	11152	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11152	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	11152	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11152	12	Schwalby,[436	Schwalby,[436	NNP
18637	11152	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11152	14	which	which	WDT
18637	11152	15	resembles	resemble	VBZ
18637	11152	16	without	without	IN
18637	11152	17	paralleling	parallel	VBG
18637	11152	18	United	United	NNP
18637	11152	19	States	States	NNP
18637	11152	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11152	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	11152	22	_	_	NNP
18637	11152	23	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	11152	24	,	,	,
18637	11152	25	where	where	WRB
18637	11152	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11152	27	was	be	VBD
18637	11152	28	held	hold	VBN
18637	11152	29	that	that	IN
18637	11152	30	an	an	DT
18637	11152	31	action	action	NN
18637	11152	32	of	of	IN
18637	11152	33	trespass	trespass	NN
18637	11152	34	against	against	IN
18637	11152	35	an	an	DT
18637	11152	36	army	army	NN
18637	11152	37	officer	officer	NN
18637	11152	38	to	to	TO
18637	11152	39	try	try	VB
18637	11152	40	title	title	NN
18637	11152	41	in	in	IN
18637	11152	42	a	a	DT
18637	11152	43	parcel	parcel	NN
18637	11152	44	of	of	IN
18637	11152	45	land	land	NN
18637	11152	46	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	11152	47	by	by	IN
18637	11152	48	the	the	DT
18637	11152	49	United	United	NNP
18637	11152	50	States	States	NNP
18637	11152	51	as	as	IN
18637	11152	52	a	a	DT
18637	11152	53	military	military	JJ
18637	11152	54	reservation	reservation	NN
18637	11152	55	was	be	VBD
18637	11152	56	a	a	DT
18637	11152	57	suit	suit	NN
18637	11152	58	against	against	IN
18637	11152	59	the	the	DT
18637	11152	60	United	United	NNP
18637	11152	61	States	States	NNP
18637	11152	62	because	because	IN
18637	11152	63	a	a	DT
18637	11152	64	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11152	65	in	in	IN
18637	11152	66	favor	favor	NN
18637	11152	67	of	of	IN
18637	11152	68	the	the	DT
18637	11152	69	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
18637	11152	70	would	would	MD
18637	11152	71	have	have	VB
18637	11152	72	been	be	VBN
18637	11152	73	a	a	DT
18637	11152	74	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11152	75	against	against	IN
18637	11152	76	the	the	DT
18637	11152	77	United	United	NNP
18637	11152	78	States	States	NNP
18637	11152	79	.	.	.
18637	11153	1	Difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	11153	2	Created	create	VBN
18637	11153	3	by	by	IN
18637	11153	4	the	the	DT
18637	11153	5	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	11153	6	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11153	7	Subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	11153	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	11153	9	repeat	repeat	VBP
18637	11153	10	and	and	CC
18637	11153	11	reaffirm	reaffirm	VBP
18637	11153	12	the	the	DT
18637	11153	13	rule	rule	NN
18637	11153	14	of	of	IN
18637	11153	15	United	United	NNP
18637	11153	16	States	States	NNP
18637	11153	17	_	_	NNP
18637	11153	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	11153	19	_	_	NNP
18637	11153	20	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	11153	21	that	that	IN
18637	11153	22	where	where	WRB
18637	11153	23	the	the	DT
18637	11153	24	right	right	NN
18637	11153	25	to	to	IN
18637	11153	26	possession	possession	NN
18637	11153	27	or	or	CC
18637	11153	28	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	11153	29	of	of	IN
18637	11153	30	property	property	NN
18637	11153	31	under	under	IN
18637	11153	32	general	general	JJ
18637	11153	33	law	law	NN
18637	11153	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	11153	35	in	in	IN
18637	11153	36	issue	issue	NN
18637	11153	37	,	,	,
18637	11153	38	the	the	DT
18637	11153	39	fact	fact	NN
18637	11153	40	that	that	IN
18637	11153	41	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	11153	42	claim	claim	VBP
18637	11153	43	the	the	DT
18637	11153	44	property	property	NN
18637	11153	45	as	as	IN
18637	11153	46	officers	officer	NNS
18637	11153	47	or	or	CC
18637	11153	48	agents	agent	NNS
18637	11153	49	of	of	IN
18637	11153	50	the	the	DT
18637	11153	51	United	United	NNP
18637	11153	52	States	States	NNP
18637	11153	53	,	,	,
18637	11153	54	does	do	VBZ
18637	11153	55	not	not	RB
18637	11153	56	make	make	VB
18637	11153	57	the	the	DT
18637	11153	58	action	action	NN
18637	11153	59	one	one	CD
18637	11153	60	against	against	IN
18637	11153	61	the	the	DT
18637	11153	62	United	United	NNP
18637	11153	63	States	States	NNP
18637	11153	64	until	until	IN
18637	11153	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11153	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	11153	67	determined	determine	VBN
18637	11153	68	that	that	IN
18637	11153	69	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11153	70	were	be	VBD
18637	11153	71	acting	act	VBG
18637	11153	72	within	within	IN
18637	11153	73	the	the	DT
18637	11153	74	scope	scope	NN
18637	11153	75	of	of	IN
18637	11153	76	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11153	77	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	11153	78	authority	authority	NN
18637	11153	79	.	.	.
18637	11154	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11154	2	437	437	CD
18637	11154	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11154	4	Contrariwise	Contrariwise	NNP
18637	11154	5	,	,	,
18637	11154	6	the	the	DT
18637	11154	7	rule	rule	NN
18637	11154	8	that	that	IN
18637	11154	9	a	a	DT
18637	11154	10	suit	suit	NN
18637	11154	11	in	in	IN
18637	11154	12	which	which	WDT
18637	11154	13	the	the	DT
18637	11154	14	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11154	15	would	would	MD
18637	11154	16	affect	affect	VB
18637	11154	17	the	the	DT
18637	11154	18	United	United	NNP
18637	11154	19	States	States	NNP
18637	11154	20	or	or	CC
18637	11154	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11154	22	property	property	NN
18637	11154	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	11154	24	a	a	DT
18637	11154	25	suit	suit	NN
18637	11154	26	against	against	IN
18637	11154	27	the	the	DT
18637	11154	28	United	United	NNP
18637	11154	29	States	States	NNP
18637	11154	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	11154	31	also	also	RB
18637	11154	32	been	be	VBN
18637	11154	33	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	11154	34	approved	approve	VBN
18637	11154	35	and	and	CC
18637	11154	36	reaffirmed	reaffirm	VBN
18637	11154	37	.	.	.
18637	11155	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11155	2	438	438	CD
18637	11155	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11155	4	But	but	CC
18637	11155	5	,	,	,
18637	11155	6	as	as	IN
18637	11155	7	the	the	DT
18637	11155	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11155	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	11155	10	pointed	point	VBN
18637	11155	11	out	out	RP
18637	11155	12	,	,	,
18637	11155	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11155	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	11155	15	not	not	RB
18637	11155	16	"	"	``
18637	11155	17	an	an	DT
18637	11155	18	easy	easy	JJ
18637	11155	19	matter	matter	NN
18637	11155	20	to	to	TO
18637	11155	21	reconcile	reconcile	VB
18637	11155	22	all	all	DT
18637	11155	23	of	of	IN
18637	11155	24	the	the	DT
18637	11155	25	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11155	26	of	of	IN
18637	11155	27	the	the	DT
18637	11155	28	court	court	NN
18637	11155	29	in	in	IN
18637	11155	30	this	this	DT
18637	11155	31	class	class	NN
18637	11155	32	of	of	IN
18637	11155	33	cases,"[439	cases,"[439	NNS
18637	11155	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11155	35	and	and	CC
18637	11155	36	,	,	,
18637	11155	37	as	as	IN
18637	11155	38	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11155	39	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11155	40	quite	quite	RB
18637	11155	41	justifiably	justifiably	RB
18637	11155	42	stated	state	VBD
18637	11155	43	in	in	IN
18637	11155	44	a	a	DT
18637	11155	45	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11155	46	,	,	,
18637	11155	47	"	"	''
18637	11155	48	the	the	DT
18637	11155	49	subject	subject	NN
18637	11155	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	11155	51	not	not	RB
18637	11155	52	free	free	JJ
18637	11155	53	from	from	IN
18637	11155	54	casuistry	casuistry	NN
18637	11155	55	.	.	.
18637	11156	1	"	"	``
18637	11156	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11156	3	440	440	CD
18637	11156	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11156	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11156	6	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	11156	7	'	'	POS
18637	11156	8	characterization	characterization	NN
18637	11156	9	of	of	IN
18637	11156	10	Land	Land	NNP
18637	11156	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11156	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	11156	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11156	14	Dollar	Dollar	NNP
18637	11156	15	,	,	,
18637	11156	16	"	"	``
18637	11156	17	this	this	DT
18637	11156	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	11156	19	the	the	DT
18637	11156	20	type	type	NN
18637	11156	21	of	of	IN
18637	11156	22	case	case	NN
18637	11156	23	where	where	WRB
18637	11156	24	the	the	DT
18637	11156	25	question	question	NN
18637	11156	26	of	of	IN
18637	11156	27	_	_	NNP
18637	11156	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11156	29	_	_	NNP
18637	11156	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	11156	31	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	11156	32	on	on	IN
18637	11156	33	decision	decision	NN
18637	11156	34	of	of	IN
18637	11156	35	the	the	DT
18637	11156	36	_	_	NNP
18637	11156	37	merits_,"[441	merits_,"[441	NNP
18637	11156	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11156	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	11156	40	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	11156	41	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	11156	42	.	.	.
18637	11157	1	Official	official	JJ
18637	11157	2	Immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11157	3	Today	today	NN
18637	11157	4	The	the	DT
18637	11157	5	recent	recent	JJ
18637	11157	6	case	case	NN
18637	11157	7	of	of	IN
18637	11157	8	Larson	Larson	NNP
18637	11157	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11157	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	11157	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11157	12	Domestic	Domestic	NNP
18637	11157	13	and	and	CC
18637	11157	14	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	11157	15	Corp	Corp	NNP
18637	11157	16	.	.	NNP
18637	11157	17	,[442	,[442	,
18637	11157	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11157	19	illuminates	illuminate	VBZ
18637	11157	20	these	these	DT
18637	11157	21	obscurities	obscurity	NNS
18637	11157	22	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	11157	23	.	.	.
18637	11158	1	Here	here	RB
18637	11158	2	a	a	DT
18637	11158	3	private	private	JJ
18637	11158	4	company	company	NN
18637	11158	5	sought	seek	VBD
18637	11158	6	to	to	TO
18637	11158	7	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	11158	8	the	the	DT
18637	11158	9	Administrator	administrator	NN
18637	11158	10	of	of	IN
18637	11158	11	the	the	DT
18637	11158	12	War	War	NNP
18637	11158	13	Assets	Assets	NNPS
18637	11158	14	in	in	IN
18637	11158	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11158	16	official	official	JJ
18637	11158	17	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	11158	18	from	from	IN
18637	11158	19	selling	sell	VBG
18637	11158	20	surplus	surplus	JJ
18637	11158	21	coal	coal	NN
18637	11158	22	to	to	IN
18637	11158	23	others	other	NNS
18637	11158	24	than	than	IN
18637	11158	25	the	the	DT
18637	11158	26	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11158	27	who	who	WP
18637	11158	28	had	have	VBD
18637	11158	29	originally	originally	RB
18637	11158	30	bought	buy	VBN
18637	11158	31	the	the	DT
18637	11158	32	coal	coal	NN
18637	11158	33	,	,	,
18637	11158	34	only	only	RB
18637	11158	35	to	to	TO
18637	11158	36	have	have	VB
18637	11158	37	the	the	DT
18637	11158	38	sale	sale	NN
18637	11158	39	cancelled	cancel	VBN
18637	11158	40	by	by	IN
18637	11158	41	the	the	DT
18637	11158	42	Administrator	Administrator	NNP
18637	11158	43	because	because	IN
18637	11158	44	of	of	IN
18637	11158	45	the	the	DT
18637	11158	46	company	company	NN
18637	11158	47	's	's	POS
18637	11158	48	failure	failure	NN
18637	11158	49	to	to	TO
18637	11158	50	make	make	VB
18637	11158	51	an	an	DT
18637	11158	52	advance	advance	JJ
18637	11158	53	payment	payment	NN
18637	11158	54	.	.	.
18637	11159	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11159	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11159	3	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	11159	4	and	and	CC
18637	11159	5	a	a	DT
18637	11159	6	majority	majority	NN
18637	11159	7	of	of	IN
18637	11159	8	the	the	DT
18637	11159	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11159	10	looked	look	VBD
18637	11159	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	11159	12	the	the	DT
18637	11159	13	suit	suit	NN
18637	11159	14	as	as	IN
18637	11159	15	one	one	CD
18637	11159	16	brought	bring	VBD
18637	11159	17	against	against	IN
18637	11159	18	the	the	DT
18637	11159	19	Administrator	administrator	NN
18637	11159	20	in	in	IN
18637	11159	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11159	22	official	official	JJ
18637	11159	23	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	11159	24	,	,	,
18637	11159	25	acting	act	VBG
18637	11159	26	under	under	IN
18637	11159	27	a	a	DT
18637	11159	28	valid	valid	JJ
18637	11159	29	statute	statute	NN
18637	11159	30	,	,	,
18637	11159	31	and	and	CC
18637	11159	32	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11159	33	a	a	DT
18637	11159	34	suit	suit	NN
18637	11159	35	against	against	IN
18637	11159	36	the	the	DT
18637	11159	37	United	United	NNP
18637	11159	38	States	States	NNP
18637	11159	39	.	.	.
18637	11160	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11160	2	held	hold	VBD
18637	11160	3	that	that	IN
18637	11160	4	although	although	IN
18637	11160	5	an	an	DT
18637	11160	6	officer	officer	NN
18637	11160	7	in	in	IN
18637	11160	8	such	such	PDT
18637	11160	9	a	a	DT
18637	11160	10	situation	situation	NN
18637	11160	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	11160	12	not	not	RB
18637	11160	13	immune	immune	JJ
18637	11160	14	from	from	IN
18637	11160	15	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11160	16	for	for	IN
18637	11160	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11160	18	own	own	JJ
18637	11160	19	torts	tort	NNS
18637	11160	20	,	,	,
18637	11160	21	yet	yet	CC
18637	11160	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11160	23	official	official	JJ
18637	11160	24	action	action	NN
18637	11160	25	,	,	,
18637	11160	26	though	though	IN
18637	11160	27	tortious	tortious	JJ
18637	11160	28	can	can	MD
18637	11160	29	not	not	RB
18637	11160	30	be	be	VB
18637	11160	31	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	11160	32	or	or	CC
18637	11160	33	diverted	divert	VBN
18637	11160	34	,	,	,
18637	11160	35	since	since	IN
18637	11160	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11160	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	11160	38	also	also	RB
18637	11160	39	the	the	DT
18637	11160	40	action	action	NN
18637	11160	41	of	of	IN
18637	11160	42	the	the	DT
18637	11160	43	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	11160	44	.	.	.
18637	11161	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11161	2	443	443	CD
18637	11161	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11161	4	The	the	DT
18637	11161	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11161	6	then	then	RB
18637	11161	7	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	11161	8	to	to	TO
18637	11161	9	repeat	repeat	VB
18637	11161	10	the	the	DT
18637	11161	11	rule	rule	NN
18637	11161	12	that	that	IN
18637	11161	13	"	"	``
18637	11161	14	the	the	DT
18637	11161	15	action	action	NN
18637	11161	16	of	of	IN
18637	11161	17	an	an	DT
18637	11161	18	officer	officer	NN
18637	11161	19	of	of	IN
18637	11161	20	the	the	DT
18637	11161	21	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	11161	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11161	23	be	be	VB
18637	11161	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11161	25	holding	hold	VBG
18637	11161	26	,	,	,
18637	11161	27	taking	take	VBG
18637	11161	28	,	,	,
18637	11161	29	or	or	CC
18637	11161	30	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	11161	31	legally	legally	RB
18637	11161	32	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	11161	33	the	the	DT
18637	11161	34	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11161	35	's	's	POS
18637	11161	36	property	property	NN
18637	11161	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11161	38	can	can	MD
18637	11161	39	be	be	VB
18637	11161	40	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	11161	41	as	as	IN
18637	11161	42	so	so	RB
18637	11161	43	individual	individual	JJ
18637	11161	44	only	only	RB
18637	11161	45	if	if	IN
18637	11161	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11161	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	11161	48	not	not	RB
18637	11161	49	within	within	IN
18637	11161	50	the	the	DT
18637	11161	51	officer	officer	NN
18637	11161	52	's	's	POS
18637	11161	53	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	11161	54	powers	power	NNS
18637	11161	55	,	,	,
18637	11161	56	or	or	CC
18637	11161	57	,	,	,
18637	11161	58	if	if	IN
18637	11161	59	within	within	IN
18637	11161	60	those	those	DT
18637	11161	61	powers	power	NNS
18637	11161	62	,	,	,
18637	11161	63	only	only	RB
18637	11161	64	if	if	IN
18637	11161	65	the	the	DT
18637	11161	66	powers	power	NNS
18637	11161	67	or	or	CC
18637	11161	68	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11161	69	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11161	70	in	in	IN
18637	11161	71	the	the	DT
18637	11161	72	particular	particular	JJ
18637	11161	73	case	case	NN
18637	11161	74	,	,	,
18637	11161	75	are	be	VBP
18637	11161	76	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	11161	77	void	void	JJ
18637	11161	78	.	.	.
18637	11162	1	"	"	``
18637	11162	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11162	3	444	444	CD
18637	11162	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11162	5	The	the	DT
18637	11162	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11162	7	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	11162	8	the	the	DT
18637	11162	9	contention	contention	NN
18637	11162	10	that	that	IN
18637	11162	11	the	the	DT
18637	11162	12	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	11162	13	of	of	IN
18637	11162	14	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	11162	15	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11162	16	should	should	MD
18637	11162	17	be	be	VB
18637	11162	18	relaxed	relax	VBN
18637	11162	19	as	as	IN
18637	11162	20	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	11162	21	to	to	IN
18637	11162	22	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11162	23	for	for	IN
18637	11162	24	specific	specific	JJ
18637	11162	25	relief	relief	NN
18637	11162	26	as	as	IN
18637	11162	27	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	11162	28	from	from	IN
18637	11162	29	damage	damage	NN
18637	11162	30	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11162	31	,	,	,
18637	11162	32	saying	say	VBG
18637	11162	33	:	:	:
18637	11162	34	"	"	``
18637	11162	35	The	the	DT
18637	11162	36	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11162	37	,	,	,
18637	11162	38	as	as	IN
18637	11162	39	representative	representative	NN
18637	11162	40	of	of	IN
18637	11162	41	the	the	DT
18637	11162	42	community	community	NN
18637	11162	43	as	as	IN
18637	11162	44	a	a	DT
18637	11162	45	whole	whole	NN
18637	11162	46	,	,	,
18637	11162	47	can	can	MD
18637	11162	48	not	not	RB
18637	11162	49	be	be	VB
18637	11162	50	stopped	stop	VBN
18637	11162	51	in	in	IN
18637	11162	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11162	53	tracks	track	NNS
18637	11162	54	by	by	IN
18637	11162	55	any	any	DT
18637	11162	56	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11162	57	who	who	WP
18637	11162	58	presents	present	VBZ
18637	11162	59	a	a	DT
18637	11162	60	disputed	dispute	VBN
18637	11162	61	question	question	NN
18637	11162	62	of	of	IN
18637	11162	63	property	property	NN
18637	11162	64	or	or	CC
18637	11162	65	contract	contract	NN
18637	11162	66	right	right	RB
18637	11162	67	.	.	.
18637	11163	1	"	"	``
18637	11163	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11163	3	445	445	CD
18637	11163	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11163	5	CLASSIFICATION	classification	NN
18637	11163	6	OF	of	IN
18637	11163	7	SUITS	SUITS	NNP
18637	11163	8	AGAINST	against	IN
18637	11163	9	OFFICERS	OFFICERS	NNP
18637	11163	10	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	11163	11	against	against	IN
18637	11163	12	officers	officer	NNS
18637	11163	13	involving	involve	VBG
18637	11163	14	the	the	DT
18637	11163	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	11163	16	of	of	IN
18637	11163	17	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	11163	18	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11163	19	have	have	VBP
18637	11163	20	been	be	VBN
18637	11163	21	classified	classify	VBN
18637	11163	22	by	by	IN
18637	11163	23	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11163	24	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11163	25	in	in	IN
18637	11163	26	a	a	DT
18637	11163	27	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	11163	28	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11163	29	into	into	IN
18637	11163	30	four	four	CD
18637	11163	31	general	general	JJ
18637	11163	32	groups	group	NNS
18637	11163	33	.	.	.
18637	11164	1	First	first	RB
18637	11164	2	,	,	,
18637	11164	3	there	there	EX
18637	11164	4	are	be	VBP
18637	11164	5	those	those	DT
18637	11164	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	11164	7	in	in	IN
18637	11164	8	which	which	WDT
18637	11164	9	the	the	DT
18637	11164	10	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11164	11	seeks	seek	VBZ
18637	11164	12	an	an	DT
18637	11164	13	interest	interest	NN
18637	11164	14	in	in	IN
18637	11164	15	property	property	NN
18637	11164	16	which	which	WDT
18637	11164	17	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	11164	18	to	to	IN
18637	11164	19	the	the	DT
18637	11164	20	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11164	21	,	,	,
18637	11164	22	or	or	CC
18637	11164	23	calls	call	VBZ
18637	11164	24	"	"	''
18637	11164	25	for	for	IN
18637	11164	26	an	an	DT
18637	11164	27	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	11164	28	of	of	IN
18637	11164	29	what	what	WP
18637	11164	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	11164	31	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
18637	11164	32	official	official	JJ
18637	11164	33	authority	authority	NN
18637	11164	34	.	.	.
18637	11165	1	"	"	``
18637	11165	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11165	3	446	446	CD
18637	11165	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11165	5	Such	such	JJ
18637	11165	6	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11165	7	,	,	,
18637	11165	8	of	of	IN
18637	11165	9	course	course	NN
18637	11165	10	,	,	,
18637	11165	11	can	can	MD
18637	11165	12	not	not	RB
18637	11165	13	be	be	VB
18637	11165	14	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	11165	15	.	.	.
18637	11166	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11166	2	447	447	CD
18637	11166	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11166	4	Second	second	JJ
18637	11166	5	,	,	,
18637	11166	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	11166	7	in	in	IN
18637	11166	8	which	which	WDT
18637	11166	9	action	action	NN
18637	11166	10	adverse	adverse	RB
18637	11166	11	to	to	IN
18637	11166	12	the	the	DT
18637	11166	13	interests	interest	NNS
18637	11166	14	of	of	IN
18637	11166	15	a	a	DT
18637	11166	16	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11166	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	11166	18	taken	take	VBN
18637	11166	19	under	under	IN
18637	11166	20	an	an	DT
18637	11166	21	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	11166	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	11166	23	or	or	CC
18637	11166	24	one	one	CD
18637	11166	25	alleged	allege	VBD
18637	11166	26	to	to	TO
18637	11166	27	be	be	VB
18637	11166	28	so	so	RB
18637	11166	29	.	.	.
18637	11167	1	In	in	IN
18637	11167	2	general	general	JJ
18637	11167	3	these	these	DT
18637	11167	4	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11167	5	are	be	VBP
18637	11167	6	maintainable	maintainable	JJ
18637	11167	7	.	.	.
18637	11168	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11168	2	448	448	CD
18637	11168	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11168	4	Third	third	JJ
18637	11168	5	,	,	,
18637	11168	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	11168	7	involving	involve	VBG
18637	11168	8	injury	injury	NN
18637	11168	9	to	to	IN
18637	11168	10	a	a	DT
18637	11168	11	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11168	12	because	because	IN
18637	11168	13	the	the	DT
18637	11168	14	official	official	NN
18637	11168	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	11168	16	exceeded	exceed	VBN
18637	11168	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11168	18	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	11168	19	authority	authority	NN
18637	11168	20	.	.	.
18637	11169	1	In	in	IN
18637	11169	2	general	general	JJ
18637	11169	3	these	these	DT
18637	11169	4	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11169	5	are	be	VBP
18637	11169	6	also	also	RB
18637	11169	7	maintainable	maintainable	JJ
18637	11169	8	.	.	.
18637	11170	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11170	2	449	449	CD
18637	11170	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11170	4	Fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	11170	5	,	,	,
18637	11170	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	11170	7	in	in	IN
18637	11170	8	which	which	WDT
18637	11170	9	an	an	DT
18637	11170	10	officer	officer	NN
18637	11170	11	seeks	seek	VBZ
18637	11170	12	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11170	13	behind	behind	IN
18637	11170	14	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	11170	15	authority	authority	NN
18637	11170	16	or	or	CC
18637	11170	17	some	some	DT
18637	11170	18	other	other	JJ
18637	11170	19	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	11170	20	command	command	NN
18637	11170	21	for	for	IN
18637	11170	22	the	the	DT
18637	11170	23	commission	commission	NN
18637	11170	24	of	of	IN
18637	11170	25	a	a	DT
18637	11170	26	common	common	JJ
18637	11170	27	law	law	NN
18637	11170	28	tort	tort	NN
18637	11170	29	.	.	.
18637	11171	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11171	2	450	450	CD
18637	11171	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11171	4	This	this	DT
18637	11171	5	category	category	NN
18637	11171	6	of	of	IN
18637	11171	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	11171	8	presents	present	VBZ
18637	11171	9	the	the	DT
18637	11171	10	greatest	great	JJS
18637	11171	11	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	11171	12	since	since	IN
18637	11171	13	these	these	DT
18637	11171	14	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11171	15	can	can	MD
18637	11171	16	as	as	RB
18637	11171	17	readily	readily	RB
18637	11171	18	be	be	VB
18637	11171	19	classified	classify	VBN
18637	11171	20	as	as	IN
18637	11171	21	falling	fall	VBG
18637	11171	22	into	into	IN
18637	11171	23	the	the	DT
18637	11171	24	first	first	JJ
18637	11171	25	group	group	NN
18637	11171	26	if	if	IN
18637	11171	27	the	the	DT
18637	11171	28	action	action	NN
18637	11171	29	directly	directly	RB
18637	11171	30	or	or	CC
18637	11171	31	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	11171	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	11171	33	one	one	CD
18637	11171	34	for	for	IN
18637	11171	35	specific	specific	JJ
18637	11171	36	performance	performance	NN
18637	11171	37	or	or	CC
18637	11171	38	if	if	IN
18637	11171	39	the	the	DT
18637	11171	40	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11171	41	would	would	MD
18637	11171	42	affect	affect	VB
18637	11171	43	the	the	DT
18637	11171	44	United	United	NNP
18637	11171	45	States	States	NNP
18637	11171	46	.	.	.
18637	11172	1	SUITS	SUITS	NNP
18637	11172	2	AGAINST	against	IN
18637	11172	3	GOVERNMENT	GOVERNMENT	NNP
18637	11172	4	CORPORATIONS	corporations	VBP
18637	11172	5	The	the	DT
18637	11172	6	multiplication	multiplication	NN
18637	11172	7	of	of	IN
18637	11172	8	government	government	NN
18637	11172	9	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	11172	10	during	during	IN
18637	11172	11	periods	period	NNS
18637	11172	12	of	of	IN
18637	11172	13	war	war	NN
18637	11172	14	and	and	CC
18637	11172	15	depression	depression	NN
18637	11172	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	11172	17	provided	provide	VBN
18637	11172	18	one	one	CD
18637	11172	19	motivation	motivation	NN
18637	11172	20	for	for	IN
18637	11172	21	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	11172	22	the	the	DT
18637	11172	23	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	11172	24	of	of	IN
18637	11172	25	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	11172	26	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11172	27	.	.	.
18637	11173	1	In	in	IN
18637	11173	2	Keifer	Keifer	NNP
18637	11173	3	&	&	CC
18637	11173	4	Keifer	Keifer	NNP
18637	11173	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11173	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11173	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11173	8	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
18637	11173	9	Finance	Finance	NNP
18637	11173	10	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	11173	11	and	and	CC
18637	11173	12	Regional	Regional	NNP
18637	11173	13	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	11173	14	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	11173	15	Corp	Corp	NNP
18637	11173	16	.	.	NNP
18637	11173	17	,[451	,[451	,
18637	11173	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11173	19	the	the	DT
18637	11173	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11173	21	held	hold	VBD
18637	11173	22	that	that	IN
18637	11173	23	the	the	DT
18637	11173	24	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11173	25	does	do	VBZ
18637	11173	26	not	not	RB
18637	11173	27	become	become	VB
18637	11173	28	a	a	DT
18637	11173	29	conduit	conduit	NN
18637	11173	30	of	of	IN
18637	11173	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11173	32	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11173	33	in	in	IN
18637	11173	34	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11173	35	against	against	IN
18637	11173	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11173	37	agents	agent	NNS
18637	11173	38	or	or	CC
18637	11173	39	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	11173	40	merely	merely	RB
18637	11173	41	because	because	IN
18637	11173	42	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11173	43	do	do	VBP
18637	11173	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11173	45	work	work	NN
18637	11173	46	.	.	.
18637	11174	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	11174	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	11174	3	the	the	DT
18637	11174	4	creation	creation	NN
18637	11174	5	of	of	IN
18637	11174	6	a	a	DT
18637	11174	7	government	government	NN
18637	11174	8	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11174	9	confer	confer	VBP
18637	11174	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	11174	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11174	12	legal	legal	JJ
18637	11174	13	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11174	14	.	.	.
18637	11175	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	11175	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11175	3	endows	endow	VBZ
18637	11175	4	a	a	DT
18637	11175	5	public	public	JJ
18637	11175	6	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11175	7	with	with	IN
18637	11175	8	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	11175	9	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11175	10	in	in	IN
18637	11175	11	a	a	DT
18637	11175	12	specific	specific	JJ
18637	11175	13	instance	instance	NN
18637	11175	14	,	,	,
18637	11175	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	11175	16	a	a	DT
18637	11175	17	matter	matter	NN
18637	11175	18	of	of	IN
18637	11175	19	ascertaining	ascertain	VBG
18637	11175	20	the	the	DT
18637	11175	21	Congressional	Congressional	NNP
18637	11175	22	will	will	NN
18637	11175	23	.	.	.
18637	11176	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	11176	2	,	,	,
18637	11176	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11176	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	11176	5	been	be	VBN
18637	11176	6	held	hold	VBN
18637	11176	7	that	that	IN
18637	11176	8	waivers	waiver	NNS
18637	11176	9	of	of	IN
18637	11176	10	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	11176	11	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11176	12	in	in	IN
18637	11176	13	the	the	DT
18637	11176	14	case	case	NN
18637	11176	15	of	of	IN
18637	11176	16	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11176	17	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	11176	18	and	and	CC
18637	11176	19	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	11176	20	should	should	MD
18637	11176	21	be	be	VB
18637	11176	22	construed	construe	VBN
18637	11176	23	liberally	liberally	RB
18637	11176	24	.	.	.
18637	11177	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11177	2	452	452	CD
18637	11177	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11177	4	On	on	IN
18637	11177	5	the	the	DT
18637	11177	6	other	other	JJ
18637	11177	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	11177	8	,	,	,
18637	11177	9	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	11177	10	nations	nation	NNS
18637	11177	11	are	be	VBP
18637	11177	12	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	11177	13	from	from	IN
18637	11177	14	suit	suit	NN
18637	11177	15	without	without	IN
18637	11177	16	further	further	JJ
18637	11177	17	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	11177	18	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	11177	19	;	;	:
18637	11177	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11177	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	11177	22	as	as	IN
18637	11177	23	though	though	IN
18637	11177	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11177	25	former	former	JJ
18637	11177	26	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11177	27	as	as	IN
18637	11177	28	sovereigns	sovereign	NNS
18637	11177	29	passed	pass	VBD
18637	11177	30	to	to	IN
18637	11177	31	the	the	DT
18637	11177	32	United	United	NNP
18637	11177	33	States	States	NNP
18637	11177	34	for	for	IN
18637	11177	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11177	36	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	11177	37	,	,	,
18637	11177	38	as	as	IN
18637	11177	39	did	do	VBD
18637	11177	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11177	41	tribal	tribal	JJ
18637	11177	42	properties	property	NNS
18637	11177	43	.	.	.
18637	11178	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11178	2	453	453	CD
18637	11178	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11178	4	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	11178	5	Between	between	IN
18637	11178	6	Two	two	CD
18637	11178	7	or	or	CC
18637	11178	8	More	More	JJR
18637	11178	9	States	state	NNS
18637	11178	10	The	the	DT
18637	11178	11	extension	extension	NN
18637	11178	12	of	of	IN
18637	11178	13	the	the	DT
18637	11178	14	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11178	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11178	16	power	power	NN
18637	11178	17	to	to	IN
18637	11178	18	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11178	19	between	between	IN
18637	11178	20	States	state	NNS
18637	11178	21	and	and	CC
18637	11178	22	the	the	DT
18637	11178	23	vesting	vesting	NN
18637	11178	24	of	of	IN
18637	11178	25	original	original	JJ
18637	11178	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11178	27	in	in	IN
18637	11178	28	the	the	DT
18637	11178	29	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11178	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11178	31	of	of	IN
18637	11178	32	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11178	33	to	to	TO
18637	11178	34	which	which	WDT
18637	11178	35	a	a	DT
18637	11178	36	State	state	NN
18637	11178	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	11178	38	a	a	DT
18637	11178	39	party	party	NN
18637	11178	40	had	have	VBD
18637	11178	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11178	42	origin	origin	NN
18637	11178	43	in	in	IN
18637	11178	44	experience	experience	NN
18637	11178	45	.	.	.
18637	11179	1	Prior	prior	RB
18637	11179	2	to	to	IN
18637	11179	3	independence	independence	NN
18637	11179	4	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	11179	5	between	between	IN
18637	11179	6	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	11179	7	claiming	claim	VBG
18637	11179	8	charter	charter	NN
18637	11179	9	rights	right	NNS
18637	11179	10	to	to	IN
18637	11179	11	territory	territory	NN
18637	11179	12	were	be	VBD
18637	11179	13	settled	settle	VBN
18637	11179	14	by	by	IN
18637	11179	15	the	the	DT
18637	11179	16	Privy	Privy	NNP
18637	11179	17	Council	Council	NNP
18637	11179	18	.	.	.
18637	11180	1	Under	under	IN
18637	11180	2	the	the	DT
18637	11180	3	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	11180	4	of	of	IN
18637	11180	5	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	11180	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11180	7	was	be	VBD
18637	11180	8	made	make	VBN
18637	11180	9	"	"	``
18637	11180	10	the	the	DT
18637	11180	11	last	last	JJ
18637	11180	12	resort	resort	NN
18637	11180	13	on	on	IN
18637	11180	14	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	11180	15	"	"	''
18637	11180	16	to	to	TO
18637	11180	17	resolve	resolve	VB
18637	11180	18	"	"	``
18637	11180	19	all	all	DT
18637	11180	20	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	11180	21	and	and	CC
18637	11180	22	differences	difference	NNS
18637	11180	23	*	*	NFP
18637	11180	24	*	*	NFP
18637	11180	25	*	*	NFP
18637	11180	26	between	between	IN
18637	11180	27	two	two	CD
18637	11180	28	or	or	CC
18637	11180	29	more	more	JJR
18637	11180	30	States	state	NNS
18637	11180	31	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	11180	32	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	11180	33	,	,	,
18637	11180	34	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11180	35	,	,	,
18637	11180	36	or	or	CC
18637	11180	37	any	any	DT
18637	11180	38	other	other	JJ
18637	11180	39	cause	cause	NN
18637	11180	40	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	11180	41	,	,	,
18637	11180	42	"	"	''
18637	11180	43	and	and	CC
18637	11180	44	to	to	TO
18637	11180	45	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	11180	46	what	what	WP
18637	11180	47	in	in	IN
18637	11180	48	effect	effect	NN
18637	11180	49	were	be	VBD
18637	11180	50	_	_	NNP
18637	11180	51	ad	ad	NN
18637	11180	52	hoc	hoc	FW
18637	11180	53	_	_	NNP
18637	11180	54	arbitral	arbitral	JJ
18637	11180	55	courts	court	NNS
18637	11180	56	for	for	IN
18637	11180	57	determining	determine	VBG
18637	11180	58	such	such	JJ
18637	11180	59	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	11180	60	and	and	CC
18637	11180	61	rendering	render	VBG
18637	11180	62	a	a	DT
18637	11180	63	final	final	JJ
18637	11180	64	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11180	65	therein	therein	RB
18637	11180	66	.	.	.
18637	11181	1	When	when	WRB
18637	11181	2	the	the	DT
18637	11181	3	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	11181	4	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	11181	5	met	meet	VBD
18637	11181	6	in	in	IN
18637	11181	7	1787	1787	CD
18637	11181	8	,	,	,
18637	11181	9	serious	serious	JJ
18637	11181	10	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	11181	11	over	over	IN
18637	11181	12	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	11181	13	,	,	,
18637	11181	14	lands	land	NNS
18637	11181	15	,	,	,
18637	11181	16	and	and	CC
18637	11181	17	river	river	NN
18637	11181	18	rights	right	NNS
18637	11181	19	involved	involve	VBD
18637	11181	20	ten	ten	CD
18637	11181	21	States	state	NNS
18637	11181	22	.	.	.
18637	11182	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11182	2	454	454	CD
18637	11182	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11182	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11182	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	11182	6	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	11182	7	surprising	surprising	JJ
18637	11182	8	,	,	,
18637	11182	9	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11182	10	,	,	,
18637	11182	11	that	that	IN
18637	11182	12	during	during	IN
18637	11182	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11182	14	first	first	JJ
18637	11182	15	sixty	sixty	CD
18637	11182	16	years	year	NNS
18637	11182	17	the	the	DT
18637	11182	18	only	only	JJ
18637	11182	19	State	state	NN
18637	11182	20	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	11182	21	coming	come	VBG
18637	11182	22	to	to	IN
18637	11182	23	the	the	DT
18637	11182	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11182	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11182	26	were	be	VBD
18637	11182	27	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	11182	28	disputes[455	disputes[455	FW
18637	11182	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11182	30	or	or	CC
18637	11182	31	that	that	IN
18637	11182	32	such	such	JJ
18637	11182	33	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	11182	34	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	11182	35	the	the	DT
18637	11182	36	largest	large	JJS
18637	11182	37	single	single	JJ
18637	11182	38	number	number	NN
18637	11182	39	of	of	IN
18637	11182	40	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11182	41	between	between	IN
18637	11182	42	States	States	NNP
18637	11182	43	.	.	.
18637	11183	1	Since	since	IN
18637	11183	2	1900	1900	CD
18637	11183	3	,	,	,
18637	11183	4	however	however	RB
18637	11183	5	,	,	,
18637	11183	6	as	as	IN
18637	11183	7	the	the	DT
18637	11183	8	result	result	NN
18637	11183	9	of	of	IN
18637	11183	10	the	the	DT
18637	11183	11	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	11183	12	mobility	mobility	NN
18637	11183	13	of	of	IN
18637	11183	14	population	population	NN
18637	11183	15	and	and	CC
18637	11183	16	wealth	wealth	NN
18637	11183	17	and	and	CC
18637	11183	18	the	the	DT
18637	11183	19	effects	effect	NNS
18637	11183	20	of	of	IN
18637	11183	21	technology	technology	NN
18637	11183	22	and	and	CC
18637	11183	23	industrialization	industrialization	NN
18637	11183	24	other	other	JJ
18637	11183	25	types	type	NNS
18637	11183	26	of	of	IN
18637	11183	27	cases	case	NNS
18637	11183	28	have	have	VBP
18637	11183	29	occurred	occur	VBN
18637	11183	30	with	with	IN
18637	11183	31	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	11183	32	frequency	frequency	NN
18637	11183	33	.	.	.
18637	11184	1	BOUNDARY	BOUNDARY	NNP
18637	11184	2	DISPUTES	dispute	NNS
18637	11184	3	;	;	:
18637	11184	4	THE	the	DT
18637	11184	5	LAW	law	NN
18637	11184	6	APPLIED	APPLIED	NNP
18637	11184	7	Of	of	IN
18637	11184	8	the	the	DT
18637	11184	9	earlier	early	JJR
18637	11184	10	examples	example	NNS
18637	11184	11	of	of	IN
18637	11184	12	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11184	13	between	between	IN
18637	11184	14	States	States	NNP
18637	11184	15	,	,	,
18637	11184	16	that	that	IN
18637	11184	17	between	between	IN
18637	11184	18	New	New	NNP
18637	11184	19	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	11184	20	and	and	CC
18637	11184	21	New	New	NNP
18637	11184	22	York	York	NNP
18637	11184	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	11184	24	significant	significant	JJ
18637	11184	25	for	for	IN
18637	11184	26	the	the	DT
18637	11184	27	application	application	NN
18637	11184	28	of	of	IN
18637	11184	29	the	the	DT
18637	11184	30	rule	rule	NN
18637	11184	31	laid	lay	VBD
18637	11184	32	down	down	RP
18637	11184	33	earlier	early	RBR
18637	11184	34	in	in	IN
18637	11184	35	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
18637	11184	36	_	_	NNP
18637	11184	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	11184	38	_	_	NNP
18637	11184	39	Georgia,[456	Georgia,[456	NNP
18637	11184	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11184	41	that	that	IN
18637	11184	42	the	the	DT
18637	11184	43	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11184	44	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11184	45	may	may	MD
18637	11184	46	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	11184	47	_	_	NNP
18637	11184	48	ex	ex	NNP
18637	11184	49	parte	parte	NNP
18637	11184	50	_	_	NNP
18637	11184	51	if	if	IN
18637	11184	52	a	a	DT
18637	11184	53	State	state	NN
18637	11184	54	refuses	refuse	VBZ
18637	11184	55	to	to	TO
18637	11184	56	appear	appear	VB
18637	11184	57	when	when	WRB
18637	11184	58	duly	duly	RB
18637	11184	59	summoned	summon	VBN
18637	11184	60	.	.	.
18637	11185	1	The	the	DT
18637	11185	2	long	long	JJ
18637	11185	3	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	11185	4	out	out	RP
18637	11185	5	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	11185	6	between	between	IN
18637	11185	7	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	11185	8	Island	Island	NNP
18637	11185	9	and	and	CC
18637	11185	10	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	11185	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	11185	12	of	of	IN
18637	11185	13	even	even	RB
18637	11185	14	greater	great	JJR
18637	11185	15	significance	significance	NN
18637	11185	16	for	for	IN
18637	11185	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11185	18	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	11185	19	,	,	,
18637	11185	20	after	after	IN
18637	11185	21	the	the	DT
18637	11185	22	case	case	NN
18637	11185	23	had	have	VBD
18637	11185	24	been	be	VBN
18637	11185	25	pending	pende	VBG
18637	11185	26	for	for	IN
18637	11185	27	seven	seven	CD
18637	11185	28	years	year	NNS
18637	11185	29	,	,	,
18637	11185	30	that	that	IN
18637	11185	31	though	though	IN
18637	11185	32	the	the	DT
18637	11185	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11185	34	does	do	VBZ
18637	11185	35	not	not	RB
18637	11185	36	extend	extend	VB
18637	11185	37	the	the	DT
18637	11185	38	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11185	39	power	power	NN
18637	11185	40	to	to	IN
18637	11185	41	all	all	DT
18637	11185	42	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11185	43	between	between	IN
18637	11185	44	States	States	NNP
18637	11185	45	,	,	,
18637	11185	46	yet	yet	CC
18637	11185	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11185	48	does	do	VBZ
18637	11185	49	not	not	RB
18637	11185	50	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	11185	51	any;[457	any;[457	NNPS
18637	11185	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11185	53	that	that	IN
18637	11185	54	a	a	DT
18637	11185	55	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	11185	56	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	11185	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	11185	58	a	a	DT
18637	11185	59	justiciable	justiciable	NN
18637	11185	60	and	and	CC
18637	11185	61	not	not	RB
18637	11185	62	a	a	DT
18637	11185	63	political	political	JJ
18637	11185	64	question;[458	question;[458	NNPS
18637	11185	65	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11185	66	and	and	CC
18637	11185	67	that	that	IN
18637	11185	68	a	a	DT
18637	11185	69	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	11185	70	rule	rule	NN
18637	11185	71	of	of	IN
18637	11185	72	decision	decision	NN
18637	11185	73	is	be	VBZ
18637	11185	74	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	11185	75	in	in	IN
18637	11185	76	such	such	JJ
18637	11185	77	cases	case	NNS
18637	11185	78	.	.	.
18637	11186	1	On	on	IN
18637	11186	2	the	the	DT
18637	11186	3	last	last	JJ
18637	11186	4	point	point	NN
18637	11186	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11186	6	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	11186	7	stated	state	VBD
18637	11186	8	:	:	:
18637	11186	9	"	"	``
18637	11186	10	The	the	DT
18637	11186	11	submission	submission	NN
18637	11186	12	by	by	IN
18637	11186	13	the	the	DT
18637	11186	14	sovereigns	sovereign	NNS
18637	11186	15	,	,	,
18637	11186	16	or	or	CC
18637	11186	17	states	state	NNS
18637	11186	18	,	,	,
18637	11186	19	to	to	IN
18637	11186	20	a	a	DT
18637	11186	21	court	court	NN
18637	11186	22	of	of	IN
18637	11186	23	law	law	NN
18637	11186	24	or	or	CC
18637	11186	25	equity	equity	NN
18637	11186	26	,	,	,
18637	11186	27	of	of	IN
18637	11186	28	a	a	DT
18637	11186	29	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	11186	30	between	between	IN
18637	11186	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11186	32	,	,	,
18637	11186	33	without	without	IN
18637	11186	34	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	11186	35	any	any	DT
18637	11186	36	rule	rule	NN
18637	11186	37	of	of	IN
18637	11186	38	decision	decision	NN
18637	11186	39	,	,	,
18637	11186	40	gives	give	VBZ
18637	11186	41	power	power	NN
18637	11186	42	to	to	TO
18637	11186	43	decide	decide	VB
18637	11186	44	according	accord	VBG
18637	11186	45	to	to	IN
18637	11186	46	the	the	DT
18637	11186	47	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	11186	48	law	law	NN
18637	11186	49	of	of	IN
18637	11186	50	the	the	DT
18637	11186	51	case	case	NN
18637	11186	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11186	53	11	11	CD
18637	11186	54	Ves	Ves	NNP
18637	11186	55	.	.	.
18637	11187	1	294	294	CD
18637	11187	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11187	3	;	;	:
18637	11187	4	which	which	WDT
18637	11187	5	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	11187	6	on	on	IN
18637	11187	7	the	the	DT
18637	11187	8	subject	subject	NN
18637	11187	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	11187	10	matter	matter	NN
18637	11187	11	,	,	,
18637	11187	12	the	the	DT
18637	11187	13	source	source	NN
18637	11187	14	and	and	CC
18637	11187	15	nature	nature	NN
18637	11187	16	of	of	IN
18637	11187	17	the	the	DT
18637	11187	18	claims	claim	NNS
18637	11187	19	of	of	IN
18637	11187	20	the	the	DT
18637	11187	21	parties	party	NNS
18637	11187	22	,	,	,
18637	11187	23	and	and	CC
18637	11187	24	the	the	DT
18637	11187	25	law	law	NN
18637	11187	26	which	which	WDT
18637	11187	27	governs	govern	VBZ
18637	11187	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11187	29	.	.	.
18637	11188	1	From	from	IN
18637	11188	2	the	the	DT
18637	11188	3	time	time	NN
18637	11188	4	of	of	IN
18637	11188	5	such	such	JJ
18637	11188	6	submission	submission	NN
18637	11188	7	,	,	,
18637	11188	8	the	the	DT
18637	11188	9	question	question	NN
18637	11188	10	ceases	cease	VBZ
18637	11188	11	to	to	TO
18637	11188	12	be	be	VB
18637	11188	13	a	a	DT
18637	11188	14	political	political	JJ
18637	11188	15	one	one	NN
18637	11188	16	,	,	,
18637	11188	17	to	to	TO
18637	11188	18	be	be	VB
18637	11188	19	decided	decide	VBN
18637	11188	20	by	by	IN
18637	11188	21	the	the	DT
18637	11188	22	_	_	NNP
18637	11188	23	sic	sic	NN
18637	11188	24	volo	volo	NN
18637	11188	25	_	_	NNP
18637	11188	26	,	,	,
18637	11188	27	_	_	NNP
18637	11188	28	sic	sic	NN
18637	11188	29	jubeo	jubeo	NN
18637	11188	30	_	_	NNP
18637	11188	31	,	,	,
18637	11188	32	of	of	IN
18637	11188	33	political	political	JJ
18637	11188	34	power	power	NN
18637	11188	35	;	;	:
18637	11188	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11188	37	comes	come	VBZ
18637	11188	38	to	to	IN
18637	11188	39	the	the	DT
18637	11188	40	court	court	NN
18637	11188	41	,	,	,
18637	11188	42	to	to	TO
18637	11188	43	be	be	VB
18637	11188	44	decided	decide	VBN
18637	11188	45	by	by	IN
18637	11188	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11188	47	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11188	48	,	,	,
18637	11188	49	legal	legal	JJ
18637	11188	50	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	11188	51	and	and	CC
18637	11188	52	solemn	solemn	JJ
18637	11188	53	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	11188	54	of	of	IN
18637	11188	55	the	the	DT
18637	11188	56	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11188	57	of	of	IN
18637	11188	58	law	law	NN
18637	11188	59	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	11188	60	to	to	IN
18637	11188	61	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11188	62	nature	nature	NN
18637	11188	63	as	as	IN
18637	11188	64	a	a	DT
18637	11188	65	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11188	66	question	question	NN
18637	11188	67	,	,	,
18637	11188	68	depending	depend	VBG
18637	11188	69	on	on	IN
18637	11188	70	the	the	DT
18637	11188	71	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11188	72	of	of	IN
18637	11188	73	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11188	74	power	power	NN
18637	11188	75	;	;	:
18637	11188	76	as	as	IN
18637	11188	77	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11188	78	is	be	VBZ
18637	11188	79	bound	bind	VBN
18637	11188	80	to	to	TO
18637	11188	81	act	act	VB
18637	11188	82	by	by	IN
18637	11188	83	known	know	VBN
18637	11188	84	and	and	CC
18637	11188	85	settled	settle	VBD
18637	11188	86	principles	principle	NNS
18637	11188	87	of	of	IN
18637	11188	88	national	national	JJ
18637	11188	89	or	or	CC
18637	11188	90	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	11188	91	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
18637	11188	92	,	,	,
18637	11188	93	as	as	IN
18637	11188	94	the	the	DT
18637	11188	95	case	case	NN
18637	11188	96	requires	require	VBZ
18637	11188	97	.	.	.
18637	11189	1	"	"	``
18637	11189	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11189	3	459	459	CD
18637	11189	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11189	5	MODERN	modern	NN
18637	11189	6	TYPES	type	NNS
18637	11189	7	OF	of	IN
18637	11189	8	SUITS	suits	JJ
18637	11189	9	BETWEEN	between	IN
18637	11189	10	STATES	state	NNS
18637	11189	11	Beginning	begin	VBG
18637	11189	12	with	with	IN
18637	11189	13	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	11189	14	_	_	NNP
18637	11189	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	11189	16	_	_	NNP
18637	11189	17	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	11189	18	and	and	CC
18637	11189	19	the	the	DT
18637	11189	20	Sanitary	Sanitary	NNP
18637	11189	21	District	District	NNP
18637	11189	22	of	of	IN
18637	11189	23	Chicago,[460	Chicago,[460	NNP
18637	11189	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11189	25	which	which	WDT
18637	11189	26	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	11189	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11189	28	to	to	TO
18637	11189	29	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	11189	30	an	an	DT
18637	11189	31	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	11189	32	suit	suit	NN
18637	11189	33	to	to	TO
18637	11189	34	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	11189	35	the	the	DT
18637	11189	36	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	11189	37	of	of	IN
18637	11189	38	sewage	sewage	NN
18637	11189	39	into	into	IN
18637	11189	40	the	the	DT
18637	11189	41	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	11189	42	River	River	NNP
18637	11189	43	,	,	,
18637	11189	44	water	water	NN
18637	11189	45	rights	right	NNS
18637	11189	46	,	,	,
18637	11189	47	the	the	DT
18637	11189	48	use	use	NN
18637	11189	49	of	of	IN
18637	11189	50	water	water	NN
18637	11189	51	resources	resource	NNS
18637	11189	52	,	,	,
18637	11189	53	and	and	CC
18637	11189	54	the	the	DT
18637	11189	55	like	like	JJ
18637	11189	56	have	have	VBP
18637	11189	57	become	become	VBN
18637	11189	58	an	an	DT
18637	11189	59	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	11189	60	source	source	NN
18637	11189	61	of	of	IN
18637	11189	62	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11189	63	between	between	IN
18637	11189	64	States	States	NNP
18637	11189	65	.	.	.
18637	11190	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	11190	2	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11190	3	have	have	VBP
18637	11190	4	been	be	VBN
18637	11190	5	especially	especially	RB
18637	11190	6	frequent	frequent	JJ
18637	11190	7	in	in	IN
18637	11190	8	the	the	DT
18637	11190	9	western	western	JJ
18637	11190	10	States	States	NNP
18637	11190	11	,	,	,
18637	11190	12	where	where	WRB
18637	11190	13	water	water	NN
18637	11190	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	11190	15	even	even	RB
18637	11190	16	more	more	JJR
18637	11190	17	of	of	IN
18637	11190	18	a	a	DT
18637	11190	19	treasure	treasure	NN
18637	11190	20	than	than	IN
18637	11190	21	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	11190	22	,	,	,
18637	11190	23	but	but	CC
18637	11190	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11190	25	have	have	VBP
18637	11190	26	not	not	RB
18637	11190	27	been	be	VBN
18637	11190	28	confined	confine	VBN
18637	11190	29	to	to	IN
18637	11190	30	any	any	DT
18637	11190	31	one	one	CD
18637	11190	32	region	region	NN
18637	11190	33	.	.	.
18637	11191	1	In	in	IN
18637	11191	2	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	11191	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11191	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	11191	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11191	6	Colorado,[461	Colorado,[461	NNP
18637	11191	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11191	8	the	the	DT
18637	11191	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11191	10	established	establish	VBD
18637	11191	11	the	the	DT
18637	11191	12	principle	principle	NN
18637	11191	13	of	of	IN
18637	11191	14	the	the	DT
18637	11191	15	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	11191	16	division	division	NN
18637	11191	17	of	of	IN
18637	11191	18	river	river	NN
18637	11191	19	or	or	CC
18637	11191	20	water	water	NN
18637	11191	21	resources	resource	NNS
18637	11191	22	between	between	IN
18637	11191	23	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	11191	24	State	state	NN
18637	11191	25	interests	interest	NNS
18637	11191	26	.	.	.
18637	11192	1	In	in	IN
18637	11192	2	New	New	NNP
18637	11192	3	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	11192	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11192	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	11192	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11192	7	New	New	NNP
18637	11192	8	York[462	york[462	NN
18637	11192	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11192	10	where	where	WRB
18637	11192	11	New	New	NNP
18637	11192	12	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	11192	13	sought	seek	VBD
18637	11192	14	to	to	TO
18637	11192	15	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	11192	16	the	the	DT
18637	11192	17	diversion	diversion	NN
18637	11192	18	of	of	IN
18637	11192	19	waters	water	NNS
18637	11192	20	into	into	IN
18637	11192	21	the	the	DT
18637	11192	22	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	11192	23	River	River	NNP
18637	11192	24	watershed	watershed	JJ
18637	11192	25	for	for	IN
18637	11192	26	New	New	NNP
18637	11192	27	York	York	NNP
18637	11192	28	in	in	IN
18637	11192	29	such	such	PDT
18637	11192	30	a	a	DT
18637	11192	31	way	way	NN
18637	11192	32	as	as	IN
18637	11192	33	to	to	TO
18637	11192	34	diminish	diminish	VB
18637	11192	35	the	the	DT
18637	11192	36	flow	flow	NN
18637	11192	37	of	of	IN
18637	11192	38	the	the	DT
18637	11192	39	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	11192	40	River	River	NNP
18637	11192	41	in	in	IN
18637	11192	42	New	New	NNP
18637	11192	43	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	11192	44	,	,	,
18637	11192	45	injure	injure	VB
18637	11192	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11192	47	shad	shad	NN
18637	11192	48	fisheries	fishery	NNS
18637	11192	49	,	,	,
18637	11192	50	and	and	CC
18637	11192	51	increase	increase	VB
18637	11192	52	harmfully	harmfully	RB
18637	11192	53	the	the	DT
18637	11192	54	saline	saline	JJS
18637	11192	55	contents	content	NNS
18637	11192	56	of	of	IN
18637	11192	57	the	the	DT
18637	11192	58	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	11192	59	,	,	,
18637	11192	60	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11192	61	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	11192	62	stated	state	VBD
18637	11192	63	for	for	IN
18637	11192	64	the	the	DT
18637	11192	65	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11192	66	:	:	:
18637	11192	67	"	"	``
18637	11192	68	A	a	DT
18637	11192	69	river	river	NN
18637	11192	70	is	be	VBZ
18637	11192	71	more	more	JJR
18637	11192	72	than	than	IN
18637	11192	73	an	an	DT
18637	11192	74	amenity	amenity	NN
18637	11192	75	,	,	,
18637	11192	76	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11192	77	is	be	VBZ
18637	11192	78	a	a	DT
18637	11192	79	treasure	treasure	NN
18637	11192	80	.	.	.
18637	11193	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11193	2	offers	offer	VBZ
18637	11193	3	a	a	DT
18637	11193	4	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	11193	5	of	of	IN
18637	11193	6	life	life	NN
18637	11193	7	that	that	WDT
18637	11193	8	must	must	MD
18637	11193	9	be	be	VB
18637	11193	10	rationed	ration	VBN
18637	11193	11	among	among	IN
18637	11193	12	those	those	DT
18637	11193	13	who	who	WP
18637	11193	14	have	have	VBP
18637	11193	15	power	power	NN
18637	11193	16	over	over	IN
18637	11193	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11193	18	.	.	.
18637	11194	1	New	New	NNP
18637	11194	2	York	York	NNP
18637	11194	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	11194	4	the	the	DT
18637	11194	5	physical	physical	JJ
18637	11194	6	power	power	NN
18637	11194	7	to	to	TO
18637	11194	8	cut	cut	VB
18637	11194	9	off	off	RP
18637	11194	10	all	all	PDT
18637	11194	11	the	the	DT
18637	11194	12	water	water	NN
18637	11194	13	within	within	IN
18637	11194	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11194	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11194	16	.	.	.
18637	11195	1	But	but	CC
18637	11195	2	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	11195	3	the	the	DT
18637	11195	4	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11195	5	of	of	IN
18637	11195	6	such	such	PDT
18637	11195	7	a	a	DT
18637	11195	8	power	power	NN
18637	11195	9	to	to	IN
18637	11195	10	the	the	DT
18637	11195	11	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	11195	12	of	of	IN
18637	11195	13	the	the	DT
18637	11195	14	interest	interest	NN
18637	11195	15	of	of	IN
18637	11195	16	lower	low	JJR
18637	11195	17	States	States	NNP
18637	11195	18	could	could	MD
18637	11195	19	not	not	RB
18637	11195	20	be	be	VB
18637	11195	21	tolerated	tolerate	VBN
18637	11195	22	.	.	.
18637	11196	1	And	and	CC
18637	11196	2	,	,	,
18637	11196	3	on	on	IN
18637	11196	4	the	the	DT
18637	11196	5	other	other	JJ
18637	11196	6	hand	hand	NN
18637	11196	7	,	,	,
18637	11196	8	equally	equally	RB
18637	11196	9	little	little	JJ
18637	11196	10	could	could	MD
18637	11196	11	New	New	NNP
18637	11196	12	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	11196	13	be	be	VB
18637	11196	14	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	11196	15	to	to	TO
18637	11196	16	require	require	VB
18637	11196	17	New	New	NNP
18637	11196	18	York	York	NNP
18637	11196	19	to	to	TO
18637	11196	20	give	give	VB
18637	11196	21	up	up	RP
18637	11196	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11196	23	power	power	NN
18637	11196	24	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	11196	25	in	in	IN
18637	11196	26	order	order	NN
18637	11196	27	that	that	IN
18637	11196	28	the	the	DT
18637	11196	29	river	river	NN
18637	11196	30	might	may	MD
18637	11196	31	come	come	VB
18637	11196	32	down	down	RP
18637	11196	33	to	to	IN
18637	11196	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11196	35	undiminished	undiminishe	VBD
18637	11196	36	.	.	.
18637	11197	1	Both	both	DT
18637	11197	2	States	state	NNS
18637	11197	3	have	have	VBP
18637	11197	4	real	real	JJ
18637	11197	5	and	and	CC
18637	11197	6	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	11197	7	interests	interest	NNS
18637	11197	8	in	in	IN
18637	11197	9	the	the	DT
18637	11197	10	river	river	NN
18637	11197	11	that	that	WDT
18637	11197	12	must	must	MD
18637	11197	13	be	be	VB
18637	11197	14	reconciled	reconcile	VBN
18637	11197	15	as	as	IN
18637	11197	16	best	best	RB
18637	11197	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11197	18	may	may	MD
18637	11197	19	be	be	VB
18637	11197	20	.	.	.
18637	11198	1	"	"	``
18637	11198	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11198	3	463	463	CD
18637	11198	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11198	5	Other	other	JJ
18637	11198	6	types	type	NNS
18637	11198	7	of	of	IN
18637	11198	8	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	11198	9	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	11198	10	of	of	IN
18637	11198	11	which	which	WDT
18637	11198	12	the	the	DT
18637	11198	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11198	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	11198	15	taken	take	VBN
18637	11198	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11198	17	include	include	VBP
18637	11198	18	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11198	19	by	by	IN
18637	11198	20	a	a	DT
18637	11198	21	State	State	NNP
18637	11198	22	as	as	IN
18637	11198	23	the	the	DT
18637	11198	24	donee	donee	NN
18637	11198	25	of	of	IN
18637	11198	26	the	the	DT
18637	11198	27	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	11198	28	of	of	IN
18637	11198	29	another	another	DT
18637	11198	30	to	to	TO
18637	11198	31	collect	collect	VB
18637	11198	32	thereon,[464	thereon,[464	NNP
18637	11198	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11198	34	by	by	IN
18637	11198	35	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11198	36	against	against	IN
18637	11198	37	West	West	NNP
18637	11198	38	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11198	39	to	to	TO
18637	11198	40	determine	determine	VB
18637	11198	41	the	the	DT
18637	11198	42	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	11198	43	of	of	IN
18637	11198	44	the	the	DT
18637	11198	45	public	public	JJ
18637	11198	46	debt	debt	NN
18637	11198	47	of	of	IN
18637	11198	48	the	the	DT
18637	11198	49	original	original	JJ
18637	11198	50	State	State	NNP
18637	11198	51	of	of	IN
18637	11198	52	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11198	53	which	which	WDT
18637	11198	54	the	the	DT
18637	11198	55	latter	latter	NN
18637	11198	56	owed	owe	VBD
18637	11198	57	the	the	DT
18637	11198	58	former,[465	former,[465	NN
18637	11198	59	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11198	60	of	of	IN
18637	11198	61	one	one	CD
18637	11198	62	State	State	NNP
18637	11198	63	against	against	IN
18637	11198	64	another	another	DT
18637	11198	65	to	to	TO
18637	11198	66	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11198	67	a	a	DT
18637	11198	68	contract	contract	NN
18637	11198	69	between	between	IN
18637	11198	70	the	the	DT
18637	11198	71	two,[466	two,[466	NNS
18637	11198	72	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11198	73	of	of	IN
18637	11198	74	a	a	DT
18637	11198	75	suit	suit	NN
18637	11198	76	in	in	IN
18637	11198	77	equity	equity	NN
18637	11198	78	between	between	IN
18637	11198	79	States	States	NNP
18637	11198	80	for	for	IN
18637	11198	81	the	the	DT
18637	11198	82	determination	determination	NN
18637	11198	83	of	of	IN
18637	11198	84	a	a	DT
18637	11198	85	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	11198	86	's	's	POS
18637	11198	87	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	11198	88	for	for	IN
18637	11198	89	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	11198	90	tax	tax	NN
18637	11198	91	purposes,[467	purposes,[467	NNP
18637	11198	92	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11198	93	and	and	CC
18637	11198	94	of	of	IN
18637	11198	95	a	a	DT
18637	11198	96	suit	suit	NN
18637	11198	97	by	by	IN
18637	11198	98	two	two	CD
18637	11198	99	States	States	NNPS
18637	11198	100	to	to	TO
18637	11198	101	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	11198	102	a	a	DT
18637	11198	103	third	third	NN
18637	11198	104	from	from	IN
18637	11198	105	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	11198	106	a	a	DT
18637	11198	107	natural	natural	JJ
18637	11198	108	gas	gas	NN
18637	11198	109	measure	measure	NN
18637	11198	110	which	which	WDT
18637	11198	111	purported	purport	VBD
18637	11198	112	to	to	TO
18637	11198	113	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	11198	114	the	the	DT
18637	11198	115	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	11198	116	flow	flow	NN
18637	11198	117	of	of	IN
18637	11198	118	natural	natural	JJ
18637	11198	119	gas	gas	NN
18637	11198	120	from	from	IN
18637	11198	121	the	the	DT
18637	11198	122	State	State	NNP
18637	11198	123	in	in	IN
18637	11198	124	the	the	DT
18637	11198	125	event	event	NN
18637	11198	126	of	of	IN
18637	11198	127	a	a	DT
18637	11198	128	shortage	shortage	NN
18637	11198	129	.	.	.
18637	11199	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11199	2	468	468	CD
18637	11199	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11199	4	In	in	IN
18637	11199	5	general	general	NN
18637	11199	6	in	in	IN
18637	11199	7	taking	take	VBG
18637	11199	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11199	9	of	of	IN
18637	11199	10	these	these	DT
18637	11199	11	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11199	12	,	,	,
18637	11199	13	along	along	IN
18637	11199	14	with	with	IN
18637	11199	15	those	those	DT
18637	11199	16	involving	involve	VBG
18637	11199	17	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	11199	18	and	and	CC
18637	11199	19	the	the	DT
18637	11199	20	diversion	diversion	NN
18637	11199	21	or	or	CC
18637	11199	22	pollution	pollution	NN
18637	11199	23	of	of	IN
18637	11199	24	water	water	NN
18637	11199	25	resources	resource	NNS
18637	11199	26	,	,	,
18637	11199	27	the	the	DT
18637	11199	28	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11199	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11199	30	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	11199	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	11199	32	the	the	DT
18637	11199	33	liberal	liberal	JJ
18637	11199	34	construction	construction	NN
18637	11199	35	of	of	IN
18637	11199	36	the	the	DT
18637	11199	37	term	term	NN
18637	11199	38	"	"	``
18637	11199	39	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11199	40	between	between	IN
18637	11199	41	two	two	CD
18637	11199	42	or	or	CC
18637	11199	43	more	more	JJR
18637	11199	44	States	States	NNPS
18637	11199	45	"	"	''
18637	11199	46	enunciated	enunciate	VBD
18637	11199	47	in	in	IN
18637	11199	48	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	11199	49	Island	Island	NNP
18637	11199	50	_	_	NNP
18637	11199	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	11199	52	_	_	NNP
18637	11199	53	Massachusetts,[469	Massachusetts,[469	NNP
18637	11199	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11199	55	and	and	CC
18637	11199	56	fortified	fortify	VBN
18637	11199	57	by	by	IN
18637	11199	58	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11199	59	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11199	60	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11199	61	's	's	POS
18637	11199	62	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	11199	63	in	in	IN
18637	11199	64	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	11199	65	_	_	NNP
18637	11199	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	11199	67	_	_	NNP
18637	11199	68	Virginia[470	Virginia[470	NNP
18637	11199	69	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11199	70	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	11199	71	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11199	72	because	because	IN
18637	11199	73	of	of	IN
18637	11199	74	the	the	DT
18637	11199	75	parties	party	NNS
18637	11199	76	to	to	IN
18637	11199	77	a	a	DT
18637	11199	78	case	case	NN
18637	11199	79	,	,	,
18637	11199	80	that	that	IN
18637	11199	81	"	"	``
18637	11199	82	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11199	83	is	be	VBZ
18637	11199	84	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	11199	85	unimportant	unimportant	JJ
18637	11199	86	,	,	,
18637	11199	87	what	what	WP
18637	11199	88	may	may	MD
18637	11199	89	be	be	VB
18637	11199	90	the	the	DT
18637	11199	91	subject	subject	NN
18637	11199	92	of	of	IN
18637	11199	93	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	11199	94	.	.	.
18637	11200	1	Be	be	VB
18637	11200	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11200	3	what	what	WP
18637	11200	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11200	5	may	may	MD
18637	11200	6	,	,	,
18637	11200	7	these	these	DT
18637	11200	8	parties	party	NNS
18637	11200	9	have	have	VBP
18637	11200	10	a	a	DT
18637	11200	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11200	12	right	right	NN
18637	11200	13	to	to	TO
18637	11200	14	come	come	VB
18637	11200	15	into	into	IN
18637	11200	16	the	the	DT
18637	11200	17	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	11200	18	of	of	IN
18637	11200	19	the	the	DT
18637	11200	20	Union	Union	NNP
18637	11200	21	.	.	.
18637	11200	22	"	"	''
18637	11201	1	CASES	case	NNS
18637	11201	2	OF	of	IN
18637	11201	3	WHICH	which	WDT
18637	11201	4	THE	the	DT
18637	11201	5	COURT	COURT	NNP
18637	11201	6	HAS	have	VBZ
18637	11201	7	DECLINED	declined	NN
18637	11201	8	JURISDICTION	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11201	9	In	in	IN
18637	11201	10	other	other	JJ
18637	11201	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	11201	12	,	,	,
18637	11201	13	however	however	RB
18637	11201	14	,	,	,
18637	11201	15	the	the	DT
18637	11201	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11201	17	,	,	,
18637	11201	18	centering	center	VBG
18637	11201	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11201	20	attention	attention	NN
18637	11201	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	11201	22	the	the	DT
18637	11201	23	elements	element	NNS
18637	11201	24	of	of	IN
18637	11201	25	a	a	DT
18637	11201	26	case	case	NN
18637	11201	27	or	or	CC
18637	11201	28	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	11201	29	,	,	,
18637	11201	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	11201	31	declined	decline	VBN
18637	11201	32	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11201	33	.	.	.
18637	11202	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	11202	2	in	in	IN
18637	11202	3	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	11202	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11202	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	11202	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11202	7	Arizona[471	Arizona[471	NNP
18637	11202	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11202	9	where	where	WRB
18637	11202	10	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	11202	11	sought	seek	VBD
18637	11202	12	to	to	TO
18637	11202	13	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	11202	14	19	19	CD
18637	11202	15	States	state	NNS
18637	11202	16	from	from	IN
18637	11202	17	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	11202	18	or	or	CC
18637	11202	19	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	11202	20	the	the	DT
18637	11202	21	sale	sale	NN
18637	11202	22	of	of	IN
18637	11202	23	convict	convict	NN
18637	11202	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	11202	25	made	make	VBN
18637	11202	26	goods	good	NNS
18637	11202	27	,	,	,
18637	11202	28	the	the	DT
18637	11202	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11202	30	went	go	VBD
18637	11202	31	far	far	RB
18637	11202	32	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	11202	33	holding	hold	VBG
18637	11202	34	that	that	IN
18637	11202	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11202	36	had	have	VBD
18637	11202	37	no	no	DT
18637	11202	38	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11202	39	,	,	,
18637	11202	40	and	and	CC
18637	11202	41	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	11202	42	that	that	IN
18637	11202	43	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11202	44	of	of	IN
18637	11202	45	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11202	46	between	between	IN
18637	11202	47	States	state	NNS
18637	11202	48	will	will	MD
18637	11202	49	be	be	VB
18637	11202	50	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	11202	51	only	only	RB
18637	11202	52	when	when	WRB
18637	11202	53	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	11202	54	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11202	55	,	,	,
18637	11202	56	that	that	IN
18637	11202	57	the	the	DT
18637	11202	58	equity	equity	NN
18637	11202	59	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	11202	60	in	in	IN
18637	11202	61	a	a	DT
18637	11202	62	suit	suit	NN
18637	11202	63	between	between	IN
18637	11202	64	States	state	NNS
18637	11202	65	are	be	VBP
18637	11202	66	more	more	RBR
18637	11202	67	exacting	exacting	JJ
18637	11202	68	than	than	IN
18637	11202	69	in	in	IN
18637	11202	70	a	a	DT
18637	11202	71	suit	suit	NN
18637	11202	72	between	between	IN
18637	11202	73	private	private	JJ
18637	11202	74	persons	person	NNS
18637	11202	75	,	,	,
18637	11202	76	that	that	IN
18637	11202	77	the	the	DT
18637	11202	78	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	11202	79	injury	injury	NN
18637	11202	80	to	to	IN
18637	11202	81	a	a	DT
18637	11202	82	plaintiff	plaintiff	JJ
18637	11202	83	State	State	NNP
18637	11202	84	must	must	MD
18637	11202	85	be	be	VB
18637	11202	86	of	of	IN
18637	11202	87	great	great	JJ
18637	11202	88	magnitude	magnitude	NN
18637	11202	89	and	and	CC
18637	11202	90	imminent	imminent	JJ
18637	11202	91	,	,	,
18637	11202	92	and	and	CC
18637	11202	93	that	that	IN
18637	11202	94	the	the	DT
18637	11202	95	burden	burden	NN
18637	11202	96	on	on	IN
18637	11202	97	the	the	DT
18637	11202	98	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11202	99	State	State	NNP
18637	11202	100	to	to	TO
18637	11202	101	establish	establish	VB
18637	11202	102	all	all	PDT
18637	11202	103	the	the	DT
18637	11202	104	elements	element	NNS
18637	11202	105	of	of	IN
18637	11202	106	a	a	DT
18637	11202	107	case	case	NN
18637	11202	108	is	be	VBZ
18637	11202	109	greater	great	JJR
18637	11202	110	than	than	IN
18637	11202	111	that	that	DT
18637	11202	112	generally	generally	RB
18637	11202	113	required	require	VBN
18637	11202	114	by	by	IN
18637	11202	115	a	a	DT
18637	11202	116	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	11202	117	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	11202	118	an	an	DT
18637	11202	119	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	11202	120	suit	suit	NN
18637	11202	121	in	in	IN
18637	11202	122	cases	case	NNS
18637	11202	123	between	between	IN
18637	11202	124	private	private	JJ
18637	11202	125	parties	party	NNS
18637	11202	126	.	.	.
18637	11203	1	Pursuing	pursue	VBG
18637	11203	2	a	a	DT
18637	11203	3	similar	similar	JJ
18637	11203	4	line	line	NN
18637	11203	5	of	of	IN
18637	11203	6	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	11203	7	,	,	,
18637	11203	8	the	the	DT
18637	11203	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11203	10	declined	decline	VBD
18637	11203	11	to	to	TO
18637	11203	12	take	take	VB
18637	11203	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11203	14	of	of	IN
18637	11203	15	a	a	DT
18637	11203	16	suit	suit	NN
18637	11203	17	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11203	18	by	by	IN
18637	11203	19	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	11203	20	against	against	IN
18637	11203	21	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	11203	22	and	and	CC
18637	11203	23	certain	certain	JJ
18637	11203	24	of	of	IN
18637	11203	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11203	26	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11203	27	to	to	TO
18637	11203	28	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	11203	29	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	11203	30	from	from	IN
18637	11203	31	levying	levy	VBG
18637	11203	32	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	11203	33	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	11203	34	upon	upon	IN
18637	11203	35	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	11203	36	held	hold	VBN
18637	11203	37	in	in	IN
18637	11203	38	trust	trust	NN
18637	11203	39	in	in	IN
18637	11203	40	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	11203	41	by	by	IN
18637	11203	42	resident	resident	JJ
18637	11203	43	trustees	trustee	NNS
18637	11203	44	.	.	.
18637	11204	1	In	in	IN
18637	11204	2	holding	hold	VBG
18637	11204	3	that	that	IN
18637	11204	4	the	the	DT
18637	11204	5	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	11204	6	presented	present	VBD
18637	11204	7	no	no	DT
18637	11204	8	justiciable	justiciable	NN
18637	11204	9	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	11204	10	,	,	,
18637	11204	11	the	the	DT
18637	11204	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11204	13	declared	declare	VBD
18637	11204	14	that	that	DT
18637	11204	15	to	to	TO
18637	11204	16	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	11204	17	such	such	PDT
18637	11204	18	a	a	DT
18637	11204	19	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	11204	20	,	,	,
18637	11204	21	the	the	DT
18637	11204	22	complainant	complainant	JJ
18637	11204	23	State	State	NNP
18637	11204	24	must	must	MD
18637	11204	25	show	show	VB
18637	11204	26	that	that	IN
18637	11204	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11204	28	"	"	``
18637	11204	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	11204	30	suffered	suffer	VBN
18637	11204	31	a	a	DT
18637	11204	32	wrong	wrong	NN
18637	11204	33	through	through	IN
18637	11204	34	the	the	DT
18637	11204	35	action	action	NN
18637	11204	36	of	of	IN
18637	11204	37	the	the	DT
18637	11204	38	other	other	JJ
18637	11204	39	State	State	NNP
18637	11204	40	,	,	,
18637	11204	41	furnishing	furnish	VBG
18637	11204	42	ground	ground	NN
18637	11204	43	for	for	IN
18637	11204	44	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11204	45	redress	redress	NN
18637	11204	46	,	,	,
18637	11204	47	or	or	CC
18637	11204	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	11204	49	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	11204	50	a	a	DT
18637	11204	51	right	right	NN
18637	11204	52	against	against	IN
18637	11204	53	the	the	DT
18637	11204	54	other	other	JJ
18637	11204	55	State	State	NNP
18637	11204	56	which	which	WDT
18637	11204	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	11204	58	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
18637	11204	59	of	of	IN
18637	11204	60	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11204	61	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11204	62	according	accord	VBG
18637	11204	63	to	to	IN
18637	11204	64	*	*	NFP
18637	11204	65	*	*	NFP
18637	11204	66	*	*	NFP
18637	11204	67	the	the	DT
18637	11204	68	common	common	JJ
18637	11204	69	law	law	NN
18637	11204	70	or	or	CC
18637	11204	71	equity	equity	NN
18637	11204	72	systems	system	NNS
18637	11204	73	of	of	IN
18637	11204	74	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
18637	11204	75	.	.	.
18637	11205	1	"	"	``
18637	11205	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11205	3	472	472	CD
18637	11205	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11205	5	The	the	DT
18637	11205	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	11205	7	that	that	IN
18637	11205	8	the	the	DT
18637	11205	9	trust	trust	NN
18637	11205	10	property	property	NN
18637	11205	11	was	be	VBD
18637	11205	12	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	11205	13	to	to	TO
18637	11205	14	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	11205	15	the	the	DT
18637	11205	16	claims	claim	NNS
18637	11205	17	of	of	IN
18637	11205	18	both	both	DT
18637	11205	19	States	state	NNS
18637	11205	20	and	and	CC
18637	11205	21	that	that	DT
18637	11205	22	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	11205	23	by	by	IN
18637	11205	24	either	either	CC
18637	11205	25	would	would	MD
18637	11205	26	not	not	RB
18637	11205	27	impair	impair	VB
18637	11205	28	any	any	DT
18637	11205	29	rights	right	NNS
18637	11205	30	of	of	IN
18637	11205	31	the	the	DT
18637	11205	32	other	other	JJ
18637	11205	33	distinguished	distinguish	VBD
18637	11205	34	the	the	DT
18637	11205	35	case	case	NN
18637	11205	36	from	from	IN
18637	11205	37	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	11205	38	_	_	NNP
18637	11205	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	11205	40	_	_	NNP
18637	11205	41	Florida,[473	Florida,[473	NNP
18637	11205	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11205	43	where	where	WRB
18637	11205	44	the	the	DT
18637	11205	45	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	11205	46	situation	situation	NN
18637	11205	47	obtained	obtain	VBD
18637	11205	48	.	.	.
18637	11206	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	11206	2	,	,	,
18637	11206	3	the	the	DT
18637	11206	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	11206	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	11206	6	providing	provide	VBG
18637	11206	7	for	for	IN
18637	11206	8	reciprocal	reciprocal	JJ
18637	11206	9	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	11206	10	in	in	IN
18637	11206	11	levying	levy	VBG
18637	11206	12	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	11206	13	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	11206	14	did	do	VBD
18637	11206	15	not	not	RB
18637	11206	16	confer	confer	VB
18637	11206	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	11206	18	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	11206	19	any	any	DT
18637	11206	20	contractual	contractual	JJ
18637	11206	21	right	right	NN
18637	11206	22	.	.	.
18637	11207	1	The	the	DT
18637	11207	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11207	3	then	then	RB
18637	11207	4	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	11207	5	to	to	TO
18637	11207	6	reiterate	reiterate	VB
18637	11207	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11207	8	earlier	early	JJR
18637	11207	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	11207	10	that	that	IN
18637	11207	11	a	a	DT
18637	11207	12	State	state	NN
18637	11207	13	may	may	MD
18637	11207	14	not	not	RB
18637	11207	15	invoke	invoke	VB
18637	11207	16	the	the	DT
18637	11207	17	original	original	JJ
18637	11207	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11207	19	of	of	IN
18637	11207	20	the	the	DT
18637	11207	21	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11207	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11207	23	for	for	IN
18637	11207	24	the	the	DT
18637	11207	25	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	11207	26	of	of	IN
18637	11207	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11207	28	residents	resident	NNS
18637	11207	29	or	or	CC
18637	11207	30	to	to	TO
18637	11207	31	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11207	32	the	the	DT
18637	11207	33	individual	individual	JJ
18637	11207	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	11207	35	of	of	IN
18637	11207	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11207	37	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11207	38	.	.	.
18637	11208	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11208	2	474	474	CD
18637	11208	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11208	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	11208	5	,	,	,
18637	11208	6	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	11208	7	could	could	MD
18637	11208	8	not	not	RB
18637	11208	9	invoke	invoke	VB
18637	11208	10	the	the	DT
18637	11208	11	original	original	JJ
18637	11208	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11208	13	of	of	IN
18637	11208	14	the	the	DT
18637	11208	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11208	16	by	by	IN
18637	11208	17	the	the	DT
18637	11208	18	expedient	expedient	NN
18637	11208	19	of	of	IN
18637	11208	20	making	make	VBG
18637	11208	21	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11208	22	of	of	IN
18637	11208	23	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	11208	24	parties	party	NNS
18637	11208	25	to	to	IN
18637	11208	26	a	a	DT
18637	11208	27	suit	suit	NN
18637	11208	28	not	not	RB
18637	11208	29	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	11208	30	maintainable	maintainable	JJ
18637	11208	31	.	.	.
18637	11209	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11209	2	475	475	CD
18637	11209	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11209	4	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	11209	5	,	,	,
18637	11209	6	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	11209	7	was	be	VBD
18637	11209	8	held	hold	VBN
18637	11209	9	not	not	RB
18637	11209	10	to	to	TO
18637	11209	11	be	be	VB
18637	11209	12	without	without	IN
18637	11209	13	an	an	DT
18637	11209	14	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	11209	15	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	11209	16	in	in	IN
18637	11209	17	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	11209	18	's	's	POS
18637	11209	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	11209	20	or	or	CC
18637	11209	21	in	in	IN
18637	11209	22	a	a	DT
18637	11209	23	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11209	24	district	district	NN
18637	11209	25	court	court	NN
18637	11209	26	in	in	IN
18637	11209	27	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	11209	28	.	.	.
18637	11210	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11210	2	476	476	CD
18637	11210	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11210	4	THE	the	DT
18637	11210	5	PROBLEM	problem	NN
18637	11210	6	OF	of	IN
18637	11210	7	ENFORCEMENT	ENFORCEMENT	NNP
18637	11210	8	;	;	:
18637	11210	9	VIRGINIA	VIRGINIA	NNP
18637	11210	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11210	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	11210	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11210	13	WEST	WEST	NNP
18637	11210	14	VIRGINIA	VIRGINIA	NNP
18637	11210	15	A	a	DT
18637	11210	16	very	very	RB
18637	11210	17	important	important	JJ
18637	11210	18	issue	issue	NN
18637	11210	19	that	that	WDT
18637	11210	20	presents	present	VBZ
18637	11210	21	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11210	22	in	in	IN
18637	11210	23	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	11210	24	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	11210	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	11210	26	the	the	DT
18637	11210	27	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11210	28	of	of	IN
18637	11210	29	the	the	DT
18637	11210	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11210	31	's	's	POS
18637	11210	32	decree	decree	NN
18637	11210	33	,	,	,
18637	11210	34	once	once	IN
18637	11210	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11210	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	11210	37	been	be	VBN
18637	11210	38	entered	enter	VBN
18637	11210	39	.	.	.
18637	11211	1	In	in	IN
18637	11211	2	some	some	DT
18637	11211	3	types	type	NNS
18637	11211	4	of	of	IN
18637	11211	5	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11211	6	,	,	,
18637	11211	7	as	as	IN
18637	11211	8	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	11211	9	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	11211	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	11211	11	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	11211	12	,	,	,
18637	11211	13	this	this	DT
18637	11211	14	issue	issue	NN
18637	11211	15	may	may	MD
18637	11211	16	not	not	RB
18637	11211	17	arise	arise	VB
18637	11211	18	;	;	:
18637	11211	19	and	and	CC
18637	11211	20	if	if	IN
18637	11211	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11211	22	does	do	VBZ
18637	11211	23	,	,	,
18637	11211	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11211	25	may	may	MD
18637	11211	26	be	be	VB
18637	11211	27	easily	easily	RB
18637	11211	28	met	meet	VBN
18637	11211	29	.	.	.
18637	11212	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	11212	2	a	a	DT
18637	11212	3	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11212	4	putting	put	VBG
18637	11212	5	a	a	DT
18637	11212	6	State	state	NN
18637	11212	7	in	in	IN
18637	11212	8	possession	possession	NN
18637	11212	9	of	of	IN
18637	11212	10	disputed	dispute	VBN
18637	11212	11	territory	territory	NN
18637	11212	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	11212	13	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	11212	14	self	self	NN
18637	11212	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	11212	16	executing	execute	VBG
18637	11212	17	.	.	.
18637	11213	1	But	but	CC
18637	11213	2	if	if	IN
18637	11213	3	the	the	DT
18637	11213	4	losing	lose	VBG
18637	11213	5	State	state	NN
18637	11213	6	should	should	MD
18637	11213	7	oppose	oppose	VB
18637	11213	8	execution	execution	NN
18637	11213	9	,	,	,
18637	11213	10	refractory	refractory	NN
18637	11213	11	State	State	NNP
18637	11213	12	officials	official	NNS
18637	11213	13	,	,	,
18637	11213	14	as	as	IN
18637	11213	15	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	11213	16	,	,	,
18637	11213	17	would	would	MD
18637	11213	18	be	be	VB
18637	11213	19	liable	liable	JJ
18637	11213	20	to	to	IN
18637	11213	21	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11213	22	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11213	23	or	or	CC
18637	11213	24	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	11213	25	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	11213	26	in	in	IN
18637	11213	27	the	the	DT
18637	11213	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11213	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	11213	30	.	.	.
18637	11214	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	11214	2	an	an	DT
18637	11214	3	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	11214	4	decree	decree	NN
18637	11214	5	may	may	MD
18637	11214	6	be	be	VB
18637	11214	7	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	11214	8	against	against	IN
18637	11214	9	State	State	NNP
18637	11214	10	officials	official	NNS
18637	11214	11	as	as	IN
18637	11214	12	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	11214	13	by	by	IN
18637	11214	14	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11214	15	or	or	CC
18637	11214	16	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	11214	17	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11214	18	.	.	.
18637	11215	1	Those	those	DT
18637	11215	2	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	11215	3	,	,	,
18637	11215	4	on	on	IN
18637	11215	5	the	the	DT
18637	11215	6	other	other	JJ
18637	11215	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	11215	8	,	,	,
18637	11215	9	which	which	WDT
18637	11215	10	require	require	VBP
18637	11215	11	a	a	DT
18637	11215	12	State	state	NN
18637	11215	13	in	in	IN
18637	11215	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11215	15	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	11215	16	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	11215	17	to	to	TO
18637	11215	18	perform	perform	VB
18637	11215	19	some	some	DT
18637	11215	20	positive	positive	JJ
18637	11215	21	act	act	NN
18637	11215	22	present	present	IN
18637	11215	23	the	the	DT
18637	11215	24	issue	issue	NN
18637	11215	25	of	of	IN
18637	11215	26	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11215	27	in	in	IN
18637	11215	28	more	more	RBR
18637	11215	29	serious	serious	JJ
18637	11215	30	form	form	NN
18637	11215	31	.	.	.
18637	11216	1	The	the	DT
18637	11216	2	issue	issue	NN
18637	11216	3	arose	arise	VBD
18637	11216	4	directly	directly	RB
18637	11216	5	in	in	IN
18637	11216	6	the	the	DT
18637	11216	7	long	long	JJ
18637	11216	8	and	and	CC
18637	11216	9	much	much	JJ
18637	11216	10	litigated	litigate	VBN
18637	11216	11	case	case	NN
18637	11216	12	between	between	IN
18637	11216	13	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11216	14	and	and	CC
18637	11216	15	West	West	NNP
18637	11216	16	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11216	17	over	over	IN
18637	11216	18	the	the	DT
18637	11216	19	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	11216	20	of	of	IN
18637	11216	21	the	the	DT
18637	11216	22	State	State	NNP
18637	11216	23	debt	debt	NN
18637	11216	24	of	of	IN
18637	11216	25	original	original	JJ
18637	11216	26	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11216	27	owed	owe	VBN
18637	11216	28	by	by	IN
18637	11216	29	West	West	NNP
18637	11216	30	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11216	31	after	after	IN
18637	11216	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11216	33	separate	separate	JJ
18637	11216	34	admission	admission	NN
18637	11216	35	to	to	IN
18637	11216	36	the	the	DT
18637	11216	37	Union	Union	NNP
18637	11216	38	under	under	IN
18637	11216	39	a	a	DT
18637	11216	40	compact	compact	NN
18637	11216	41	which	which	WDT
18637	11216	42	provided	provide	VBN
18637	11216	43	that	that	IN
18637	11216	44	West	West	NNP
18637	11216	45	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11216	46	assume	assume	VBP
18637	11216	47	a	a	DT
18637	11216	48	share	share	NN
18637	11216	49	of	of	IN
18637	11216	50	the	the	DT
18637	11216	51	debt	debt	NN
18637	11216	52	.	.	.
18637	11217	1	The	the	DT
18637	11217	2	suit	suit	NN
18637	11217	3	was	be	VBD
18637	11217	4	begun	begin	VBN
18637	11217	5	in	in	IN
18637	11217	6	1906	1906	CD
18637	11217	7	,	,	,
18637	11217	8	and	and	CC
18637	11217	9	a	a	DT
18637	11217	10	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11217	11	was	be	VBD
18637	11217	12	rendered	render	VBN
18637	11217	13	against	against	IN
18637	11217	14	West	West	NNP
18637	11217	15	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11217	16	in	in	IN
18637	11217	17	1915	1915	CD
18637	11217	18	.	.	.
18637	11218	1	Finally	finally	RB
18637	11218	2	in	in	IN
18637	11218	3	1917	1917	CD
18637	11218	4	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11218	5	filed	file	VBD
18637	11218	6	a	a	DT
18637	11218	7	suit	suit	NN
18637	11218	8	against	against	IN
18637	11218	9	West	West	NNP
18637	11218	10	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11218	11	to	to	TO
18637	11218	12	show	show	VB
18637	11218	13	cause	cause	NN
18637	11218	14	why	why	WRB
18637	11218	15	,	,	,
18637	11218	16	in	in	IN
18637	11218	17	default	default	NN
18637	11218	18	of	of	IN
18637	11218	19	payment	payment	NN
18637	11218	20	of	of	IN
18637	11218	21	the	the	DT
18637	11218	22	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11218	23	,	,	,
18637	11218	24	an	an	DT
18637	11218	25	order	order	NN
18637	11218	26	should	should	MD
18637	11218	27	not	not	RB
18637	11218	28	be	be	VB
18637	11218	29	entered	enter	VBN
18637	11218	30	directing	direct	VBG
18637	11218	31	the	the	DT
18637	11218	32	West	West	NNP
18637	11218	33	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11218	34	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	11218	35	to	to	TO
18637	11218	36	levy	levy	VB
18637	11218	37	a	a	DT
18637	11218	38	tax	tax	NN
18637	11218	39	for	for	IN
18637	11218	40	payment	payment	NN
18637	11218	41	of	of	IN
18637	11218	42	the	the	DT
18637	11218	43	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11218	44	.	.	.
18637	11219	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11219	2	477	477	CD
18637	11219	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11219	4	Starting	start	VBG
18637	11219	5	with	with	IN
18637	11219	6	the	the	DT
18637	11219	7	rule	rule	NN
18637	11219	8	that	that	IN
18637	11219	9	the	the	DT
18637	11219	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11219	11	power	power	NN
18637	11219	12	essentially	essentially	RB
18637	11219	13	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	11219	14	the	the	DT
18637	11219	15	right	right	NN
18637	11219	16	to	to	TO
18637	11219	17	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11219	18	the	the	DT
18637	11219	19	results	result	NNS
18637	11219	20	of	of	IN
18637	11219	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11219	22	exertion,[478	exertion,[478	NN
18637	11219	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11219	24	the	the	DT
18637	11219	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11219	26	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	11219	27	to	to	TO
18637	11219	28	hold	hold	VB
18637	11219	29	that	that	IN
18637	11219	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11219	31	applied	apply	VBD
18637	11219	32	with	with	IN
18637	11219	33	the	the	DT
18637	11219	34	same	same	JJ
18637	11219	35	force	force	NN
18637	11219	36	to	to	IN
18637	11219	37	States	States	NNP
18637	11219	38	as	as	IN
18637	11219	39	to	to	IN
18637	11219	40	other	other	JJ
18637	11219	41	litigants,[479	litigants,[479	NN
18637	11219	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11219	43	and	and	CC
18637	11219	44	to	to	TO
18637	11219	45	consider	consider	VB
18637	11219	46	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	11219	47	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	11219	48	for	for	IN
18637	11219	49	the	the	DT
18637	11219	50	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11219	51	of	of	IN
18637	11219	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11219	53	authority	authority	NN
18637	11219	54	.	.	.
18637	11220	1	In	in	IN
18637	11220	2	this	this	DT
18637	11220	3	connection	connection	NN
18637	11220	4	,	,	,
18637	11220	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11220	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11220	7	White	White	NNP
18637	11220	8	declared	declare	VBD
18637	11220	9	:	:	:
18637	11220	10	"	"	``
18637	11220	11	As	as	IN
18637	11220	12	the	the	DT
18637	11220	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	11220	14	to	to	TO
18637	11220	15	render	render	VB
18637	11220	16	the	the	DT
18637	11220	17	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11220	18	and	and	CC
18637	11220	19	to	to	TO
18637	11220	20	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11220	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11220	22	arise	arise	VB
18637	11220	23	from	from	IN
18637	11220	24	the	the	DT
18637	11220	25	grant	grant	NN
18637	11220	26	in	in	IN
18637	11220	27	the	the	DT
18637	11220	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11220	29	on	on	IN
18637	11220	30	that	that	DT
18637	11220	31	subject	subject	NN
18637	11220	32	,	,	,
18637	11220	33	looked	look	VBD
18637	11220	34	at	at	IN
18637	11220	35	from	from	IN
18637	11220	36	a	a	DT
18637	11220	37	generic	generic	JJ
18637	11220	38	point	point	NN
18637	11220	39	of	of	IN
18637	11220	40	view	view	NN
18637	11220	41	,	,	,
18637	11220	42	both	both	DT
18637	11220	43	are	be	VBP
18637	11220	44	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11220	45	powers	power	NNS
18637	11220	46	and	and	CC
18637	11220	47	,	,	,
18637	11220	48	comprehensively	comprehensively	RB
18637	11220	49	considered	consider	VBN
18637	11220	50	,	,	,
18637	11220	51	are	be	VBP
18637	11220	52	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	11220	53	by	by	IN
18637	11220	54	every	every	DT
18637	11220	55	authority	authority	NN
18637	11220	56	of	of	IN
18637	11220	57	the	the	DT
18637	11220	58	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11220	59	government	government	NN
18637	11220	60	,	,	,
18637	11220	61	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11220	62	,	,	,
18637	11220	63	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	11220	64	,	,	,
18637	11220	65	or	or	CC
18637	11220	66	executive	executive	NN
18637	11220	67	,	,	,
18637	11220	68	which	which	WDT
18637	11220	69	may	may	MD
18637	11220	70	be	be	VB
18637	11220	71	appropriately	appropriately	RB
18637	11220	72	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	11220	73	.	.	.
18637	11221	1	"	"	``
18637	11221	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11221	3	480	480	CD
18637	11221	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11221	5	The	the	DT
18637	11221	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11221	7	,	,	,
18637	11221	8	however	however	RB
18637	11221	9	,	,	,
18637	11221	10	left	leave	VBD
18637	11221	11	open	open	VB
18637	11221	12	the	the	DT
18637	11221	13	question	question	NN
18637	11221	14	of	of	IN
18637	11221	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11221	16	power	power	NN
18637	11221	17	to	to	TO
18637	11221	18	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11221	19	the	the	DT
18637	11221	20	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11221	21	under	under	IN
18637	11221	22	existing	exist	VBG
18637	11221	23	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	11221	24	and	and	CC
18637	11221	25	scheduled	schedule	VBD
18637	11221	26	the	the	DT
18637	11221	27	case	case	NN
18637	11221	28	for	for	IN
18637	11221	29	reargument	reargument	NN
18637	11221	30	at	at	IN
18637	11221	31	the	the	DT
18637	11221	32	next	next	JJ
18637	11221	33	term	term	NN
18637	11221	34	,	,	,
18637	11221	35	but	but	CC
18637	11221	36	in	in	IN
18637	11221	37	the	the	DT
18637	11221	38	meantime	meantime	NN
18637	11221	39	West	West	NNP
18637	11221	40	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11221	41	accepted	accept	VBD
18637	11221	42	the	the	DT
18637	11221	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11221	44	's	's	POS
18637	11221	45	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11221	46	and	and	CC
18637	11221	47	entered	enter	VBD
18637	11221	48	into	into	IN
18637	11221	49	an	an	DT
18637	11221	50	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	11221	51	with	with	IN
18637	11221	52	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11221	53	to	to	TO
18637	11221	54	pay	pay	VB
18637	11221	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11221	56	.	.	.
18637	11222	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11222	2	481	481	CD
18637	11222	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11222	4	Controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11222	5	Between	between	IN
18637	11222	6	a	a	DT
18637	11222	7	State	State	NNP
18637	11222	8	and	and	CC
18637	11222	9	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	11222	10	of	of	IN
18637	11222	11	Another	another	DT
18637	11222	12	State	state	NN
18637	11222	13	The	the	DT
18637	11222	14	decision	decision	NN
18637	11222	15	in	in	IN
18637	11222	16	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
18637	11222	17	_	_	NNP
18637	11222	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	11222	19	_	_	NNP
18637	11222	20	Georgia[482	Georgia[482	NNP
18637	11222	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11222	22	that	that	IN
18637	11222	23	this	this	DT
18637	11222	24	category	category	NN
18637	11222	25	of	of	IN
18637	11222	26	cases	case	NNS
18637	11222	27	included	include	VBN
18637	11222	28	equally	equally	RB
18637	11222	29	those	those	DT
18637	11222	30	where	where	WRB
18637	11222	31	a	a	DT
18637	11222	32	State	state	NN
18637	11222	33	was	be	VBD
18637	11222	34	a	a	DT
18637	11222	35	party	party	NN
18637	11222	36	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	11222	37	provoked	provoke	VBD
18637	11222	38	the	the	DT
18637	11222	39	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	11222	40	and	and	CC
18637	11222	41	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	11222	42	of	of	IN
18637	11222	43	the	the	DT
18637	11222	44	Eleventh	Eleventh	NNP
18637	11222	45	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	11222	46	,	,	,
18637	11222	47	and	and	CC
18637	11222	48	since	since	IN
18637	11222	49	then	then	RB
18637	11222	50	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11222	51	between	between	IN
18637	11222	52	a	a	DT
18637	11222	53	State	state	NN
18637	11222	54	and	and	CC
18637	11222	55	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11222	56	of	of	IN
18637	11222	57	another	another	DT
18637	11222	58	State	state	NN
18637	11222	59	have	have	VBP
18637	11222	60	included	include	VBN
18637	11222	61	only	only	RB
18637	11222	62	those	those	DT
18637	11222	63	cases	case	NNS
18637	11222	64	where	where	WRB
18637	11222	65	the	the	DT
18637	11222	66	State	State	NNP
18637	11222	67	has	have	VBZ
18637	11222	68	been	be	VBN
18637	11222	69	a	a	DT
18637	11222	70	party	party	NN
18637	11222	71	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11222	72	or	or	CC
18637	11222	73	has	have	VBZ
18637	11222	74	consented	consent	VBN
18637	11222	75	to	to	TO
18637	11222	76	be	be	VB
18637	11222	77	sued	sue	VBN
18637	11222	78	.	.	.
18637	11223	1	As	as	IN
18637	11223	2	a	a	DT
18637	11223	3	party	party	NN
18637	11223	4	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11223	5	,	,	,
18637	11223	6	a	a	DT
18637	11223	7	State	State	NNP
18637	11223	8	may	may	MD
18637	11223	9	bring	bring	VB
18637	11223	10	actions	action	NNS
18637	11223	11	against	against	IN
18637	11223	12	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11223	13	of	of	IN
18637	11223	14	other	other	JJ
18637	11223	15	States	States	NNPS
18637	11223	16	to	to	TO
18637	11223	17	protect	protect	VB
18637	11223	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11223	19	legal	legal	JJ
18637	11223	20	rights	right	NNS
18637	11223	21	or	or	CC
18637	11223	22	as	as	IN
18637	11223	23	_	_	NNP
18637	11223	24	parens	paren	NNS
18637	11223	25	patriae	patriae	NNS
18637	11223	26	_	_	NNP
18637	11223	27	to	to	TO
18637	11223	28	protect	protect	VB
18637	11223	29	the	the	DT
18637	11223	30	health	health	NN
18637	11223	31	and	and	CC
18637	11223	32	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	11223	33	of	of	IN
18637	11223	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11223	35	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11223	36	.	.	.
18637	11224	1	In	in	IN
18637	11224	2	general	general	JJ
18637	11224	3	,	,	,
18637	11224	4	the	the	DT
18637	11224	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11224	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	11224	7	tended	tend	VBN
18637	11224	8	to	to	TO
18637	11224	9	construe	construe	VB
18637	11224	10	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	11224	11	this	this	DT
18637	11224	12	grant	grant	NN
18637	11224	13	of	of	IN
18637	11224	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11224	15	power	power	NN
18637	11224	16	which	which	WDT
18637	11224	17	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
18637	11224	18	comes	come	VBZ
18637	11224	19	within	within	IN
18637	11224	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11224	21	original	original	JJ
18637	11224	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11224	23	by	by	IN
18637	11224	24	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	11224	25	an	an	DT
18637	11224	26	even	even	RB
18637	11224	27	more	more	RBR
18637	11224	28	rigorous	rigorous	JJ
18637	11224	29	application	application	NN
18637	11224	30	of	of	IN
18637	11224	31	the	the	DT
18637	11224	32	concepts	concept	NNS
18637	11224	33	of	of	IN
18637	11224	34	cases	case	NNS
18637	11224	35	and	and	CC
18637	11224	36	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11224	37	than	than	IN
18637	11224	38	that	that	DT
18637	11224	39	in	in	IN
18637	11224	40	cases	case	NNS
18637	11224	41	between	between	IN
18637	11224	42	private	private	JJ
18637	11224	43	parties	party	NNS
18637	11224	44	.	.	.
18637	11225	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11225	2	483	483	CD
18637	11225	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11225	4	This	this	DT
18637	11225	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11225	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	11225	7	by	by	IN
18637	11225	8	holding	hold	VBG
18637	11225	9	rigorously	rigorously	RB
18637	11225	10	to	to	IN
18637	11225	11	the	the	DT
18637	11225	12	rule	rule	NN
18637	11225	13	that	that	IN
18637	11225	14	all	all	PDT
18637	11225	15	the	the	DT
18637	11225	16	party	party	NN
18637	11225	17	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	11225	18	be	be	VB
18637	11225	19	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11225	20	of	of	IN
18637	11225	21	other	other	JJ
18637	11225	22	States,[484	states,[484	CD
18637	11225	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11225	24	and	and	CC
18637	11225	25	by	by	IN
18637	11225	26	adhering	adhere	VBG
18637	11225	27	to	to	IN
18637	11225	28	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	11225	29	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	11225	30	of	of	IN
18637	11225	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11225	32	original	original	JJ
18637	11225	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11225	34	concurrently	concurrently	RB
18637	11225	35	with	with	IN
18637	11225	36	that	that	DT
18637	11225	37	of	of	IN
18637	11225	38	other	other	JJ
18637	11225	39	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11225	40	courts	court	NNS
18637	11225	41	.	.	.
18637	11226	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11226	2	485	485	CD
18637	11226	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11226	4	NON	NON	NNP
18637	11226	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	11226	6	JUSTICIABLE	justiciable	JJ
18637	11226	7	CONTROVERSIES	controversie	VBZ
18637	11226	8	The	the	DT
18637	11226	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11226	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11226	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	11226	12	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	11226	13	to	to	TO
18637	11226	14	take	take	VB
18637	11226	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11226	16	of	of	IN
18637	11226	17	a	a	DT
18637	11226	18	number	number	NN
18637	11226	19	of	of	IN
18637	11226	20	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11226	21	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11226	22	by	by	IN
18637	11226	23	States	state	NNS
18637	11226	24	because	because	IN
18637	11226	25	of	of	IN
18637	11226	26	the	the	DT
18637	11226	27	lack	lack	NN
18637	11226	28	of	of	IN
18637	11226	29	a	a	DT
18637	11226	30	justiciable	justiciable	JJ
18637	11226	31	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	11226	32	.	.	.
18637	11227	1	In	in	IN
18637	11227	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	11227	3	like	like	IN
18637	11227	4	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	11227	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11227	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11227	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11227	8	Johnson[486	Johnson[486	NNP
18637	11227	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11227	10	and	and	CC
18637	11227	11	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11227	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11227	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	11227	14	_	_	NNP
18637	11227	15	Stanton,[487	Stanton,[487	NNP
18637	11227	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11227	17	the	the	DT
18637	11227	18	political	political	JJ
18637	11227	19	nature	nature	NN
18637	11227	20	of	of	IN
18637	11227	21	the	the	DT
18637	11227	22	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	11227	23	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	11227	24	the	the	DT
18637	11227	25	dominant	dominant	JJ
18637	11227	26	reason	reason	NN
18637	11227	27	.	.	.
18637	11228	1	In	in	IN
18637	11228	2	others	other	NNS
18637	11228	3	,	,	,
18637	11228	4	like	like	IN
18637	11228	5	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	11228	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11228	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	11228	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11228	9	Mellon[488	Mellon[488	NNP
18637	11228	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11228	11	and	and	CC
18637	11228	12	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	11228	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11228	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	11228	15	_	_	NNP
18637	11228	16	Mellon,[489	Mellon,[489	NNP
18637	11228	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11228	18	the	the	DT
18637	11228	19	political	political	JJ
18637	11228	20	issue	issue	NN
18637	11228	21	,	,	,
18637	11228	22	though	though	IN
18637	11228	23	present	present	JJ
18637	11228	24	,	,	,
18637	11228	25	was	be	VBD
18637	11228	26	accompanied	accompany	VBN
18637	11228	27	by	by	IN
18637	11228	28	the	the	DT
18637	11228	29	inability	inability	NN
18637	11228	30	of	of	IN
18637	11228	31	a	a	DT
18637	11228	32	State	State	NNP
18637	11228	33	to	to	TO
18637	11228	34	sue	sue	VB
18637	11228	35	in	in	IN
18637	11228	36	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	11228	37	of	of	IN
18637	11228	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11228	39	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11228	40	as	as	IN
18637	11228	41	_	_	NNP
18637	11228	42	parens	paren	VBZ
18637	11228	43	patriae	patriae	NNS
18637	11228	44	_	_	NNP
18637	11228	45	to	to	TO
18637	11228	46	contest	contest	VB
18637	11228	47	the	the	DT
18637	11228	48	validity	validity	NN
18637	11228	49	of	of	IN
18637	11228	50	an	an	DT
18637	11228	51	act	act	NN
18637	11228	52	of	of	IN
18637	11228	53	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11228	54	when	when	WRB
18637	11228	55	in	in	IN
18637	11228	56	national	national	JJ
18637	11228	57	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11228	58	the	the	DT
18637	11228	59	National	National	NNP
18637	11228	60	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11228	61	bore	bear	VBD
18637	11228	62	the	the	DT
18637	11228	63	relation	relation	NN
18637	11228	64	of	of	IN
18637	11228	65	_	_	NNP
18637	11228	66	parens	paren	NNS
18637	11228	67	patriae	patriae	NNS
18637	11228	68	_	_	NNP
18637	11228	69	to	to	IN
18637	11228	70	the	the	DT
18637	11228	71	same	same	JJ
18637	11228	72	persons	person	NNS
18637	11228	73	as	as	IN
18637	11228	74	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11228	75	of	of	IN
18637	11228	76	the	the	DT
18637	11228	77	United	United	NNP
18637	11228	78	States	States	NNP
18637	11228	79	.	.	.
18637	11229	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	11229	2	,	,	,
18637	11229	3	a	a	DT
18637	11229	4	State	state	NN
18637	11229	5	may	may	MD
18637	11229	6	not	not	RB
18637	11229	7	bring	bring	VB
18637	11229	8	a	a	DT
18637	11229	9	suit	suit	NN
18637	11229	10	in	in	IN
18637	11229	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11229	12	own	own	JJ
18637	11229	13	name	name	NN
18637	11229	14	for	for	IN
18637	11229	15	the	the	DT
18637	11229	16	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	11229	17	of	of	IN
18637	11229	18	particular	particular	JJ
18637	11229	19	persons	person	NNS
18637	11229	20	.	.	.
18637	11230	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11230	2	490	490	CD
18637	11230	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11230	4	JURISDICTION	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11230	5	CONFINED	confined	NN
18637	11230	6	TO	to	IN
18637	11230	7	CIVIL	civil	NN
18637	11230	8	CASES	case	NNS
18637	11230	9	In	in	IN
18637	11230	10	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	11230	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11230	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	11230	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11230	14	Virginia[491	Virginia[491	NNP
18637	11230	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11230	16	there	there	EX
18637	11230	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	11230	18	a	a	DT
18637	11230	19	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	11230	20	to	to	IN
18637	11230	21	the	the	DT
18637	11230	22	effect	effect	NN
18637	11230	23	that	that	IN
18637	11230	24	the	the	DT
18637	11230	25	original	original	JJ
18637	11230	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11230	27	of	of	IN
18637	11230	28	the	the	DT
18637	11230	29	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11230	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11230	31	does	do	VBZ
18637	11230	32	not	not	RB
18637	11230	33	include	include	VB
18637	11230	34	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11230	35	between	between	IN
18637	11230	36	a	a	DT
18637	11230	37	State	state	NN
18637	11230	38	and	and	CC
18637	11230	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11230	40	own	own	JJ
18637	11230	41	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11230	42	.	.	.
18637	11231	1	Long	long	RB
18637	11231	2	afterwards	afterwards	RB
18637	11231	3	,	,	,
18637	11231	4	the	the	DT
18637	11231	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11231	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11231	7	dismissed	dismiss	VBD
18637	11231	8	an	an	DT
18637	11231	9	action	action	NN
18637	11231	10	for	for	IN
18637	11231	11	want	want	NN
18637	11231	12	of	of	IN
18637	11231	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11231	14	because	because	IN
18637	11231	15	the	the	DT
18637	11231	16	record	record	NN
18637	11231	17	did	do	VBD
18637	11231	18	not	not	RB
18637	11231	19	show	show	VB
18637	11231	20	the	the	DT
18637	11231	21	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11231	22	against	against	IN
18637	11231	23	which	which	WDT
18637	11231	24	the	the	DT
18637	11231	25	suit	suit	NN
18637	11231	26	was	be	VBD
18637	11231	27	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11231	28	was	be	VBD
18637	11231	29	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	11231	30	in	in	IN
18637	11231	31	another	another	DT
18637	11231	32	State	state	NN
18637	11231	33	.	.	.
18637	11232	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11232	2	492	492	CD
18637	11232	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11232	4	Subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	11232	5	the	the	DT
18637	11232	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11232	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	11232	8	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	11232	9	that	that	IN
18637	11232	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11232	11	will	will	MD
18637	11232	12	not	not	RB
18637	11232	13	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	11232	14	an	an	DT
18637	11232	15	action	action	NN
18637	11232	16	by	by	IN
18637	11232	17	a	a	DT
18637	11232	18	State	State	NNP
18637	11232	19	to	to	TO
18637	11232	20	which	which	WDT
18637	11232	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11232	22	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11232	23	are	be	VBP
18637	11232	24	either	either	DT
18637	11232	25	parties	party	NNS
18637	11232	26	of	of	IN
18637	11232	27	record	record	NN
18637	11232	28	,	,	,
18637	11232	29	or	or	CC
18637	11232	30	would	would	MD
18637	11232	31	have	have	VB
18637	11232	32	to	to	TO
18637	11232	33	be	be	VB
18637	11232	34	joined	join	VBN
18637	11232	35	because	because	RB
18637	11232	36	of	of	IN
18637	11232	37	the	the	DT
18637	11232	38	effect	effect	NN
18637	11232	39	of	of	IN
18637	11232	40	a	a	DT
18637	11232	41	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11232	42	upon	upon	IN
18637	11232	43	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11232	44	.	.	.
18637	11233	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11233	2	493	493	CD
18637	11233	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11233	4	In	in	IN
18637	11233	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11233	6	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	11233	7	in	in	IN
18637	11233	8	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	11233	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11233	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	11233	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11233	12	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11233	13	,	,	,
18637	11233	14	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11233	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11233	16	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11233	17	also	also	RB
18637	11233	18	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	11233	19	that	that	IN
18637	11233	20	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	11233	21	no	no	DT
18637	11233	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11233	23	existed	exist	VBD
18637	11233	24	over	over	IN
18637	11233	25	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11233	26	by	by	IN
18637	11233	27	States	state	NNS
18637	11233	28	to	to	TO
18637	11233	29	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11233	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11233	31	penal	penal	JJ
18637	11233	32	laws	law	NNS
18637	11233	33	.	.	.
18637	11234	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11234	2	494	494	CD
18637	11234	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11234	4	Sixty	sixty	CD
18637	11234	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	11234	6	seven	seven	CD
18637	11234	7	years	year	NNS
18637	11234	8	later	later	RBR
18637	11234	9	the	the	DT
18637	11234	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11234	11	wrote	write	VBD
18637	11234	12	this	this	DT
18637	11234	13	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	11234	14	into	into	IN
18637	11234	15	law	law	NN
18637	11234	16	in	in	IN
18637	11234	17	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	11234	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11234	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	11234	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11234	21	Pelican	Pelican	NNP
18637	11234	22	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	11234	23	Co.[495	Co.[495	NNP
18637	11234	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11234	25	Here	here	RB
18637	11234	26	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	11234	27	sued	sue	VBD
18637	11234	28	a	a	DT
18637	11234	29	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	11234	30	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11234	31	to	to	TO
18637	11234	32	recover	recover	VB
18637	11234	33	a	a	DT
18637	11234	34	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11234	35	rendered	render	VBN
18637	11234	36	in	in	IN
18637	11234	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11234	38	favor	favor	NN
18637	11234	39	by	by	IN
18637	11234	40	one	one	CD
18637	11234	41	of	of	IN
18637	11234	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11234	43	own	own	JJ
18637	11234	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	11234	45	.	.	.
18637	11235	1	Relying	rely	VBG
18637	11235	2	partly	partly	RB
18637	11235	3	on	on	IN
18637	11235	4	the	the	DT
18637	11235	5	rule	rule	NN
18637	11235	6	of	of	IN
18637	11235	7	international	international	JJ
18637	11235	8	law	law	NN
18637	11235	9	that	that	WDT
18637	11235	10	the	the	DT
18637	11235	11	courts	court	NNS
18637	11235	12	of	of	IN
18637	11235	13	no	no	DT
18637	11235	14	country	country	NN
18637	11235	15	execute	execute	VB
18637	11235	16	the	the	DT
18637	11235	17	penal	penal	JJ
18637	11235	18	laws	law	NNS
18637	11235	19	of	of	IN
18637	11235	20	another	another	DT
18637	11235	21	,	,	,
18637	11235	22	partly	partly	RB
18637	11235	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	11235	24	the	the	DT
18637	11235	25	13th	13th	JJ
18637	11235	26	section	section	NN
18637	11235	27	of	of	IN
18637	11235	28	the	the	DT
18637	11235	29	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11235	30	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11235	31	of	of	IN
18637	11235	32	1789	1789	CD
18637	11235	33	which	which	WDT
18637	11235	34	vested	vest	VBD
18637	11235	35	the	the	DT
18637	11235	36	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11235	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11235	38	with	with	IN
18637	11235	39	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11235	40	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11235	41	of	of	IN
18637	11235	42	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11235	43	of	of	IN
18637	11235	44	a	a	DT
18637	11235	45	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11235	46	nature	nature	NN
18637	11235	47	where	where	WRB
18637	11235	48	a	a	DT
18637	11235	49	State	state	NN
18637	11235	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	11235	51	a	a	DT
18637	11235	52	party	party	NN
18637	11235	53	,	,	,
18637	11235	54	and	and	CC
18637	11235	55	partly	partly	RB
18637	11235	56	on	on	IN
18637	11235	57	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11235	58	Iredell	Iredell	NNP
18637	11235	59	's	's	POS
18637	11235	60	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11235	61	in	in	IN
18637	11235	62	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
18637	11235	63	_	_	NNP
18637	11235	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	11235	65	_	_	NNP
18637	11235	66	Georgia,[496	Georgia,[496	NNP
18637	11235	67	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11235	68	where	where	WRB
18637	11235	69	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11235	70	confined	confine	VBD
18637	11235	71	the	the	DT
18637	11235	72	term	term	NN
18637	11235	73	"	"	``
18637	11235	74	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11235	75	"	"	''
18637	11235	76	to	to	IN
18637	11235	77	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11235	78	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11235	79	,	,	,
18637	11235	80	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11235	81	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	11235	82	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	11235	83	for	for	IN
18637	11235	84	the	the	DT
18637	11235	85	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11235	86	that	that	IN
18637	11235	87	for	for	IN
18637	11235	88	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	11235	89	of	of	IN
18637	11235	90	original	original	JJ
18637	11235	91	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11235	92	,	,	,
18637	11235	93	"	"	''
18637	11235	94	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11235	95	between	between	IN
18637	11235	96	a	a	DT
18637	11235	97	State	state	NN
18637	11235	98	and	and	CC
18637	11235	99	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11235	100	of	of	IN
18637	11235	101	another	another	DT
18637	11235	102	State	State	NNP
18637	11235	103	"	"	''
18637	11235	104	are	be	VBP
18637	11235	105	confined	confine	VBN
18637	11235	106	to	to	IN
18637	11235	107	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11235	108	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11235	109	.	.	.
18637	11236	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11236	2	497	497	CD
18637	11236	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11236	4	SUITS	SUITS	NNP
18637	11236	5	BY	by	IN
18637	11236	6	A	a	DT
18637	11236	7	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	11236	8	AS	as	IN
18637	11236	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11236	10	PARENS	PARENS	NNP
18637	11236	11	PATRIAE	PATRIAE	NNP
18637	11236	12	_	_	XX
18637	11236	13	;	;	:
18637	11236	14	JURISDICTION	JURISDICTION	NNP
18637	11236	15	DECLINED	decline	VBD
18637	11236	16	The	the	DT
18637	11236	17	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	11236	18	between	between	IN
18637	11236	19	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11236	20	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11236	21	by	by	IN
18637	11236	22	States	state	NNS
18637	11236	23	to	to	TO
18637	11236	24	protect	protect	VB
18637	11236	25	the	the	DT
18637	11236	26	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	11236	27	of	of	IN
18637	11236	28	the	the	DT
18637	11236	29	people	people	NNS
18637	11236	30	as	as	IN
18637	11236	31	a	a	DT
18637	11236	32	whole	whole	NN
18637	11236	33	and	and	CC
18637	11236	34	suits	suit	VBZ
18637	11236	35	to	to	TO
18637	11236	36	protect	protect	VB
18637	11236	37	the	the	DT
18637	11236	38	private	private	JJ
18637	11236	39	interests	interest	NNS
18637	11236	40	of	of	IN
18637	11236	41	individual	individual	JJ
18637	11236	42	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11236	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	11236	44	not	not	RB
18637	11236	45	easily	easily	RB
18637	11236	46	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	11236	47	.	.	.
18637	11237	1	In	in	IN
18637	11237	2	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	11237	3	ex	ex	NN
18637	11237	4	rel	rel	NN
18637	11237	5	.	.	.
18637	11238	1	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	11238	2	_	_	NNP
18637	11238	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	11238	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11238	5	Cook,[498	Cook,[498	NNP
18637	11238	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11238	7	the	the	DT
18637	11238	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11238	9	dismissed	dismiss	VBD
18637	11238	10	a	a	DT
18637	11238	11	suit	suit	NN
18637	11238	12	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11238	13	by	by	IN
18637	11238	14	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	11238	15	to	to	TO
18637	11238	16	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11238	17	the	the	DT
18637	11238	18	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	11238	19	liability	liability	NN
18637	11238	20	of	of	IN
18637	11238	21	a	a	DT
18637	11238	22	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	11238	23	of	of	IN
18637	11238	24	a	a	DT
18637	11238	25	State	State	NNP
18637	11238	26	bank	bank	NN
18637	11238	27	then	then	RB
18637	11238	28	in	in	IN
18637	11238	29	the	the	DT
18637	11238	30	process	process	NN
18637	11238	31	of	of	IN
18637	11238	32	liquidation	liquidation	NN
18637	11238	33	through	through	IN
18637	11238	34	a	a	DT
18637	11238	35	State	state	NN
18637	11238	36	officer	officer	NN
18637	11238	37	.	.	.
18637	11239	1	Although	although	IN
18637	11239	2	the	the	DT
18637	11239	3	State	State	NNP
18637	11239	4	was	be	VBD
18637	11239	5	vested	vest	VBN
18637	11239	6	with	with	IN
18637	11239	7	legal	legal	JJ
18637	11239	8	title	title	NN
18637	11239	9	to	to	IN
18637	11239	10	the	the	DT
18637	11239	11	assets	asset	NNS
18637	11239	12	under	under	IN
18637	11239	13	the	the	DT
18637	11239	14	liquidation	liquidation	NN
18637	11239	15	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	11239	16	,	,	,
18637	11239	17	the	the	DT
18637	11239	18	State	State	NNP
18637	11239	19	's	's	POS
18637	11239	20	action	action	NN
18637	11239	21	was	be	VBD
18637	11239	22	independent	independent	JJ
18637	11239	23	of	of	IN
18637	11239	24	that	that	DT
18637	11239	25	and	and	CC
18637	11239	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11239	27	was	be	VBD
18637	11239	28	acting	act	VBG
18637	11239	29	merely	merely	RB
18637	11239	30	for	for	IN
18637	11239	31	the	the	DT
18637	11239	32	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	11239	33	of	of	IN
18637	11239	34	the	the	DT
18637	11239	35	bank	bank	NN
18637	11239	36	's	's	POS
18637	11239	37	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	11239	38	and	and	CC
18637	11239	39	depositors	depositor	NNS
18637	11239	40	.	.	.
18637	11240	1	A	a	DT
18637	11240	2	generation	generation	NN
18637	11240	3	earlier	early	RBR
18637	11240	4	the	the	DT
18637	11240	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11240	6	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	11240	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11240	8	of	of	IN
18637	11240	9	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	11240	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11240	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	11240	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11240	13	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	11240	14	,	,	,
18637	11240	15	Topeka	Topeka	NNP
18637	11240	16	&	&	CC
18637	11240	17	Santa	Santa	NNP
18637	11240	18	Fe	Fe	NNP
18637	11240	19	R.	R.	NNP
18637	11240	20	Co.[499	Co.[499	NNP
18637	11240	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11240	22	in	in	IN
18637	11240	23	which	which	WDT
18637	11240	24	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	11240	25	sought	seek	VBD
18637	11240	26	to	to	TO
18637	11240	27	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	11240	28	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	11240	29	rate	rate	NN
18637	11240	30	charges	charge	NNS
18637	11240	31	by	by	IN
18637	11240	32	a	a	DT
18637	11240	33	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	11240	34	on	on	IN
18637	11240	35	the	the	DT
18637	11240	36	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	11240	37	of	of	IN
18637	11240	38	specified	specify	VBN
18637	11240	39	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	11240	40	,	,	,
18637	11240	41	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	11240	42	as	as	IN
18637	11240	43	the	the	DT
18637	11240	44	State	State	NNP
18637	11240	45	was	be	VBD
18637	11240	46	not	not	RB
18637	11240	47	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	11240	48	in	in	IN
18637	11240	49	shipping	ship	VBG
18637	11240	50	these	these	DT
18637	11240	51	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	11240	52	and	and	CC
18637	11240	53	had	have	VBD
18637	11240	54	no	no	DT
18637	11240	55	proprietary	proprietary	JJ
18637	11240	56	interest	interest	NN
18637	11240	57	in	in	IN
18637	11240	58	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11240	59	.	.	.
18637	11241	1	SUITS	SUITS	NNP
18637	11241	2	BY	by	IN
18637	11241	3	A	a	DT
18637	11241	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	11241	5	AS	as	IN
18637	11241	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11241	7	PARENS	PARENS	NNP
18637	11241	8	PATRIAE	PATRIAE	NNP
18637	11241	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11241	10	;	;	:
18637	11241	11	JURISDICTION	JURISDICTION	NNP
18637	11241	12	ACCEPTED	accept	VBD
18637	11241	13	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11241	14	_	_	NNP
18637	11241	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	11241	16	_	_	NNP
18637	11241	17	Evans,[500	Evans,[500	NNP
18637	11241	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11241	19	on	on	IN
18637	11241	20	the	the	DT
18637	11241	21	other	other	JJ
18637	11241	22	hand	hand	NN
18637	11241	23	,	,	,
18637	11241	24	presents	present	VBZ
18637	11241	25	the	the	DT
18637	11241	26	case	case	NN
18637	11241	27	of	of	IN
18637	11241	28	a	a	DT
18637	11241	29	clear	clear	JJ
18637	11241	30	State	State	NNP
18637	11241	31	interest	interest	NN
18637	11241	32	as	as	IN
18637	11241	33	a	a	DT
18637	11241	34	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	11241	35	of	of	IN
18637	11241	36	materials	material	NNS
18637	11241	37	.	.	.
18637	11242	1	Here	here	RB
18637	11242	2	,	,	,
18637	11242	3	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11242	4	sued	sue	VBD
18637	11242	5	certain	certain	JJ
18637	11242	6	asphalt	asphalt	NN
18637	11242	7	companies	company	NNS
18637	11242	8	for	for	IN
18637	11242	9	treble	treble	JJ
18637	11242	10	damages	damage	NNS
18637	11242	11	under	under	IN
18637	11242	12	the	the	DT
18637	11242	13	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	11242	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11242	15	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11242	16	allegedly	allegedly	RB
18637	11242	17	out	out	IN
18637	11242	18	of	of	IN
18637	11242	19	a	a	DT
18637	11242	20	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	11242	21	to	to	TO
18637	11242	22	control	control	VB
18637	11242	23	the	the	DT
18637	11242	24	prices	price	NNS
18637	11242	25	of	of	IN
18637	11242	26	asphalt	asphalt	NN
18637	11242	27	of	of	IN
18637	11242	28	which	which	WDT
18637	11242	29	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11242	30	was	be	VBD
18637	11242	31	a	a	DT
18637	11242	32	large	large	JJ
18637	11242	33	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	11242	34	.	.	.
18637	11243	1	The	the	DT
18637	11243	2	matter	matter	NN
18637	11243	3	of	of	IN
18637	11243	4	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11243	5	's	's	POS
18637	11243	6	interest	interest	NN
18637	11243	7	was	be	VBD
18637	11243	8	not	not	RB
18637	11243	9	contested	contest	VBN
18637	11243	10	and	and	CC
18637	11243	11	did	do	VBD
18637	11243	12	not	not	RB
18637	11243	13	arise	arise	VB
18637	11243	14	.	.	.
18637	11244	1	The	the	DT
18637	11244	2	case	case	NN
18637	11244	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	11244	4	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	11244	5	significant	significant	JJ
18637	11244	6	for	for	IN
18637	11244	7	the	the	DT
18637	11244	8	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	11244	9	that	that	IN
18637	11244	10	a	a	DT
18637	11244	11	State	state	NN
18637	11244	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	11244	13	a	a	DT
18637	11244	14	person	person	NN
18637	11244	15	under	under	IN
18637	11244	16	section	section	NN
18637	11244	17	7	7	CD
18637	11244	18	of	of	IN
18637	11244	19	the	the	DT
18637	11244	20	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	11244	21	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11244	22	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	11244	23	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11244	24	by	by	IN
18637	11244	25	"	"	``
18637	11244	26	any	any	DT
18637	11244	27	person	person	NN
18637	11244	28	"	"	''
18637	11244	29	for	for	IN
18637	11244	30	treble	treble	JJ
18637	11244	31	damages	damage	NNS
18637	11244	32	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11244	33	out	out	IN
18637	11244	34	of	of	IN
18637	11244	35	violations	violation	NNS
18637	11244	36	of	of	IN
18637	11244	37	the	the	DT
18637	11244	38	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	11244	39	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11244	40	.	.	.
18637	11245	1	A	a	DT
18637	11245	2	less	less	RBR
18637	11245	3	clear	clear	RB
18637	11245	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	11245	5	cut	cut	VBN
18637	11245	6	case	case	NN
18637	11245	7	,	,	,
18637	11245	8	and	and	CC
18637	11245	9	one	one	NN
18637	11245	10	not	not	RB
18637	11245	11	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	11245	12	in	in	IN
18637	11245	13	accord	accord	NN
18637	11245	14	with	with	IN
18637	11245	15	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	11245	16	_	_	NNP
18637	11245	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	11245	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11245	19	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	11245	20	,	,	,
18637	11245	21	Topeka	Topeka	NNP
18637	11245	22	&	&	CC
18637	11245	23	Santa	Santa	NNP
18637	11245	24	Fe	Fe	NNP
18637	11245	25	R.	R.	NNP
18637	11245	26	Co	Co	NNP
18637	11245	27	.	.	.
18637	11245	28	,[501	,[501	NFP
18637	11245	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11245	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	11245	31	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11245	32	_	_	NNP
18637	11245	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	11245	34	_	_	NNP
18637	11245	35	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	11245	36	R.	R.	NNP
18637	11245	37	Co.[502	Co.[502	NNP
18637	11245	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11245	39	in	in	IN
18637	11245	40	which	which	WDT
18637	11245	41	the	the	DT
18637	11245	42	State	State	NNP
18637	11245	43	,	,	,
18637	11245	44	suing	sue	VBG
18637	11245	45	as	as	IN
18637	11245	46	_	_	NNP
18637	11245	47	parens	paren	NNS
18637	11245	48	patriae	patriae	NNS
18637	11245	49	_	_	NNP
18637	11245	50	and	and	CC
18637	11245	51	in	in	IN
18637	11245	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11245	53	proprietary	proprietary	JJ
18637	11245	54	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	11245	55	,	,	,
18637	11245	56	was	be	VBD
18637	11245	57	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	11245	58	to	to	TO
18637	11245	59	file	file	VB
18637	11245	60	a	a	DT
18637	11245	61	bill	bill	NN
18637	11245	62	of	of	IN
18637	11245	63	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	11245	64	against	against	IN
18637	11245	65	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	11245	66	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	11245	67	for	for	IN
18637	11245	68	injunctive	injunctive	JJ
18637	11245	69	relief	relief	NN
18637	11245	70	from	from	IN
18637	11245	71	freight	freight	NN
18637	11245	72	rates	rate	NNS
18637	11245	73	,	,	,
18637	11245	74	allegedly	allegedly	RB
18637	11245	75	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	11245	76	against	against	IN
18637	11245	77	the	the	DT
18637	11245	78	State	State	NNP
18637	11245	79	and	and	CC
18637	11245	80	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	11245	81	to	to	TO
18637	11245	82	have	have	VB
18637	11245	83	been	be	VBN
18637	11245	84	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	11245	85	through	through	IN
18637	11245	86	coercive	coercive	JJ
18637	11245	87	action	action	NN
18637	11245	88	by	by	IN
18637	11245	89	the	the	DT
18637	11245	90	northern	northern	JJ
18637	11245	91	roads	road	NNS
18637	11245	92	against	against	IN
18637	11245	93	the	the	DT
18637	11245	94	southern	southern	JJ
18637	11245	95	roads	road	NNS
18637	11245	96	in	in	IN
18637	11245	97	violation	violation	NN
18637	11245	98	of	of	IN
18637	11245	99	the	the	DT
18637	11245	100	16th	16th	JJ
18637	11245	101	section	section	NN
18637	11245	102	of	of	IN
18637	11245	103	the	the	DT
18637	11245	104	Clayton	Clayton	NNP
18637	11245	105	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11245	106	.	.	.
18637	11246	1	Although	although	IN
18637	11246	2	the	the	DT
18637	11246	3	rights	right	NNS
18637	11246	4	of	of	IN
18637	11246	5	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11246	6	were	be	VBD
18637	11246	7	admittedly	admittedly	RB
18637	11246	8	based	base	VBN
18637	11246	9	on	on	IN
18637	11246	10	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11246	11	laws	law	NNS
18637	11246	12	,	,	,
18637	11246	13	the	the	DT
18637	11246	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11246	15	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	11246	16	that	that	IN
18637	11246	17	the	the	DT
18637	11246	18	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11246	19	of	of	IN
18637	11246	20	the	the	DT
18637	11246	21	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	11246	22	and	and	CC
18637	11246	23	Clayton	Clayton	NNP
18637	11246	24	acts	act	VBZ
18637	11246	25	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	11246	26	upon	upon	IN
18637	11246	27	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11246	28	as	as	RB
18637	11246	29	well	well	RB
18637	11246	30	as	as	IN
18637	11246	31	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	11246	32	sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	11246	33	.	.	.
18637	11247	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	11247	2	,	,	,
18637	11247	3	the	the	DT
18637	11247	4	interests	interest	NNS
18637	11247	5	of	of	IN
18637	11247	6	a	a	DT
18637	11247	7	State	State	NNP
18637	11247	8	for	for	IN
18637	11247	9	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	11247	10	of	of	IN
18637	11247	11	invoking	invoke	VBG
18637	11247	12	the	the	DT
18637	11247	13	original	original	JJ
18637	11247	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11247	15	of	of	IN
18637	11247	16	the	the	DT
18637	11247	17	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11247	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11247	19	were	be	VBD
18637	11247	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	11247	21	,	,	,
18637	11247	22	as	as	IN
18637	11247	23	in	in	IN
18637	11247	24	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11247	25	_	_	NNP
18637	11247	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	11247	27	_	_	NNP
18637	11247	28	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	11247	29	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	11247	30	Co	Co	NNP
18637	11247	31	.	.	.
18637	11247	32	,[503	,[503	NFP
18637	11247	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11247	34	not	not	RB
18637	11247	35	to	to	TO
18637	11247	36	be	be	VB
18637	11247	37	confined	confine	VBN
18637	11247	38	to	to	IN
18637	11247	39	those	those	DT
18637	11247	40	which	which	WDT
18637	11247	41	are	be	VBP
18637	11247	42	proprietary	proprietary	JJ
18637	11247	43	but	but	CC
18637	11247	44	to	to	TO
18637	11247	45	"	"	``
18637	11247	46	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	11247	47	the	the	DT
18637	11247	48	so	so	RB
18637	11247	49	-	-	HYPH
18637	11247	50	called	call	VBN
18637	11247	51	'	'	''
18637	11247	52	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	11247	53	-	-	JJ
18637	11247	54	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	11247	55	'	'	''
18637	11247	56	interests	interest	NNS
18637	11247	57	which	which	WDT
18637	11247	58	*	*	NFP
18637	11247	59	*	*	NFP
18637	11247	60	*	*	NFP
18637	11247	61	are	be	VBP
18637	11247	62	'	'	``
18637	11247	63	independent	independent	JJ
18637	11247	64	of	of	IN
18637	11247	65	and	and	CC
18637	11247	66	behind	behind	IN
18637	11247	67	the	the	DT
18637	11247	68	titles	title	NNS
18637	11247	69	of	of	IN
18637	11247	70	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11247	71	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11247	72	,	,	,
18637	11247	73	in	in	IN
18637	11247	74	all	all	PDT
18637	11247	75	the	the	DT
18637	11247	76	earth	earth	NN
18637	11247	77	and	and	CC
18637	11247	78	air	air	NN
18637	11247	79	within	within	IN
18637	11247	80	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11247	81	domain	domain	NN
18637	11247	82	.	.	.
18637	11248	1	'	'	``
18637	11248	2	"	"	``
18637	11248	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11248	4	504	504	CD
18637	11248	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11248	6	GEORGIA	GEORGIA	NNP
18637	11248	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11248	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11248	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11248	10	PENNSYLVANIA	PENNSYLVANIA	NNP
18637	11248	11	RAILROAD	RAILROAD	VBN
18637	11248	12	In	in	IN
18637	11248	13	the	the	DT
18637	11248	14	course	course	NN
18637	11248	15	of	of	IN
18637	11248	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11248	17	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11248	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11248	19	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	11248	20	,	,	,
18637	11248	21	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	11248	22	for	for	IN
18637	11248	23	a	a	DT
18637	11248	24	narrowly	narrowly	RB
18637	11248	25	divided	divide	VBN
18637	11248	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11248	27	,	,	,
18637	11248	28	treated	treat	VBD
18637	11248	29	the	the	DT
18637	11248	30	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	11248	31	injury	injury	NN
18637	11248	32	to	to	IN
18637	11248	33	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11248	34	as	as	IN
18637	11248	35	a	a	DT
18637	11248	36	proprietor	proprietor	NN
18637	11248	37	as	as	IN
18637	11248	38	a	a	DT
18637	11248	39	"	"	``
18637	11248	40	makeweight	makeweight	NN
18637	11248	41	,	,	,
18637	11248	42	"	"	''
18637	11248	43	and	and	CC
18637	11248	44	remarked	remark	VBD
18637	11248	45	that	that	IN
18637	11248	46	the	the	DT
18637	11248	47	"	"	``
18637	11248	48	original	original	JJ
18637	11248	49	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11248	50	of	of	IN
18637	11248	51	this	this	DT
18637	11248	52	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11248	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	11248	54	one	one	CD
18637	11248	55	of	of	IN
18637	11248	56	the	the	DT
18637	11248	57	mighty	mighty	JJ
18637	11248	58	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	11248	59	which	which	WDT
18637	11248	60	the	the	DT
18637	11248	61	framers	framer	NNS
18637	11248	62	of	of	IN
18637	11248	63	the	the	DT
18637	11248	64	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11248	65	provided	provide	VBN
18637	11248	66	so	so	IN
18637	11248	67	that	that	IN
18637	11248	68	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	11248	69	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	11248	70	might	may	MD
18637	11248	71	be	be	VB
18637	11248	72	available	available	JJ
18637	11248	73	for	for	IN
18637	11248	74	the	the	DT
18637	11248	75	peaceful	peaceful	JJ
18637	11248	76	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	11248	77	of	of	IN
18637	11248	78	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	11248	79	between	between	IN
18637	11248	80	States	state	NNS
18637	11248	81	and	and	CC
18637	11248	82	between	between	IN
18637	11248	83	a	a	DT
18637	11248	84	State	state	NN
18637	11248	85	and	and	CC
18637	11248	86	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11248	87	of	of	IN
18637	11248	88	another	another	DT
18637	11248	89	State	state	NN
18637	11248	90	*	*	NFP
18637	11248	91	*	*	NFP
18637	11248	92	*	*	NFP
18637	11248	93	Trade	trade	NN
18637	11248	94	barriers	barrier	NNS
18637	11248	95	,	,	,
18637	11248	96	recriminations	recrimination	NNS
18637	11248	97	,	,	,
18637	11248	98	intense	intense	JJ
18637	11248	99	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	11248	100	rivalries	rivalry	NNS
18637	11248	101	had	have	VBD
18637	11248	102	plagued	plague	VBN
18637	11248	103	the	the	DT
18637	11248	104	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	11248	105	.	.	.
18637	11249	1	The	the	DT
18637	11249	2	traditional	traditional	JJ
18637	11249	3	methods	method	NNS
18637	11249	4	available	available	JJ
18637	11249	5	to	to	IN
18637	11249	6	a	a	DT
18637	11249	7	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	11249	8	for	for	IN
18637	11249	9	the	the	DT
18637	11249	10	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	11249	11	of	of	IN
18637	11249	12	such	such	JJ
18637	11249	13	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	11249	14	were	be	VBD
18637	11249	15	diplomacy	diplomacy	NN
18637	11249	16	and	and	CC
18637	11249	17	war	war	NN
18637	11249	18	.	.	.
18637	11250	1	Suit	suit	NN
18637	11250	2	in	in	IN
18637	11250	3	this	this	DT
18637	11250	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11250	5	was	be	VBD
18637	11250	6	provided	provide	VBN
18637	11250	7	as	as	IN
18637	11250	8	an	an	DT
18637	11250	9	alternative	alternative	NN
18637	11250	10	.	.	.
18637	11251	1	"	"	``
18637	11251	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11251	3	505	505	CD
18637	11251	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11251	5	Discriminatory	Discriminatory	NNP
18637	11251	6	freight	freight	NN
18637	11251	7	rates	rate	NNS
18637	11251	8	,	,	,
18637	11251	9	said	say	VBD
18637	11251	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11251	11	,	,	,
18637	11251	12	may	may	MD
18637	11251	13	cause	cause	VB
18637	11251	14	a	a	DT
18637	11251	15	blight	blight	NN
18637	11251	16	no	no	RB
18637	11251	17	less	less	RBR
18637	11251	18	serious	serious	JJ
18637	11251	19	than	than	IN
18637	11251	20	noxious	noxious	JJ
18637	11251	21	gases	gas	NNS
18637	11251	22	in	in	IN
18637	11251	23	that	that	IN
18637	11251	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11251	25	may	may	MD
18637	11251	26	arrest	arrest	VB
18637	11251	27	the	the	DT
18637	11251	28	development	development	NN
18637	11251	29	of	of	IN
18637	11251	30	a	a	DT
18637	11251	31	State	state	NN
18637	11251	32	and	and	CC
18637	11251	33	put	put	VBD
18637	11251	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11251	35	at	at	IN
18637	11251	36	a	a	DT
18637	11251	37	competitive	competitive	JJ
18637	11251	38	disadvantage	disadvantage	NN
18637	11251	39	.	.	.
18637	11252	1	"	"	``
18637	11252	2	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11252	3	as	as	IN
18637	11252	4	a	a	DT
18637	11252	5	representative	representative	NN
18637	11252	6	of	of	IN
18637	11252	7	the	the	DT
18637	11252	8	public	public	NN
18637	11252	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	11252	10	complaining	complain	VBG
18637	11252	11	of	of	IN
18637	11252	12	a	a	DT
18637	11252	13	wrong	wrong	JJ
18637	11252	14	which	which	WDT
18637	11252	15	,	,	,
18637	11252	16	if	if	IN
18637	11252	17	proven	prove	VBN
18637	11252	18	,	,	,
18637	11252	19	limits	limit	VBZ
18637	11252	20	the	the	DT
18637	11252	21	opportunities	opportunity	NNS
18637	11252	22	of	of	IN
18637	11252	23	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11252	24	people	people	NNS
18637	11252	25	,	,	,
18637	11252	26	shackles	shackle	VBZ
18637	11252	27	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11252	28	industries	industry	NNS
18637	11252	29	,	,	,
18637	11252	30	retards	retard	VBZ
18637	11252	31	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11252	32	development	development	NN
18637	11252	33	,	,	,
18637	11252	34	and	and	CC
18637	11252	35	relegates	relegate	VBZ
18637	11252	36	her	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11252	37	to	to	IN
18637	11252	38	an	an	DT
18637	11252	39	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	11252	40	economic	economic	JJ
18637	11252	41	position	position	NN
18637	11252	42	among	among	IN
18637	11252	43	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11252	44	sister	sister	NN
18637	11252	45	States	States	NNP
18637	11252	46	.	.	.
18637	11253	1	These	these	DT
18637	11253	2	are	be	VBP
18637	11253	3	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11253	4	of	of	IN
18637	11253	5	grave	grave	JJ
18637	11253	6	public	public	JJ
18637	11253	7	concern	concern	NN
18637	11253	8	in	in	IN
18637	11253	9	which	which	WDT
18637	11253	10	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11253	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	11253	12	an	an	DT
18637	11253	13	interest	interest	NN
18637	11253	14	apart	apart	RB
18637	11253	15	from	from	IN
18637	11253	16	that	that	DT
18637	11253	17	of	of	IN
18637	11253	18	particular	particular	JJ
18637	11253	19	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	11253	20	who	who	WP
18637	11253	21	may	may	MD
18637	11253	22	be	be	VB
18637	11253	23	affected	affect	VBN
18637	11253	24	.	.	.
18637	11254	1	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11254	2	's	's	POS
18637	11254	3	interest	interest	NN
18637	11254	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	11254	5	not	not	RB
18637	11254	6	remote	remote	JJ
18637	11254	7	;	;	:
18637	11254	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11254	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	11254	10	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	11254	11	.	.	.
18637	11255	1	If	if	IN
18637	11255	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11255	3	denied	deny	VBD
18637	11255	4	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11255	5	as	as	IN
18637	11255	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11255	7	parens	paren	VBZ
18637	11255	8	patriae	patriae	NNS
18637	11255	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11255	10	the	the	DT
18637	11255	11	right	right	NN
18637	11255	12	to	to	TO
18637	11255	13	invoke	invoke	VB
18637	11255	14	the	the	DT
18637	11255	15	original	original	JJ
18637	11255	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11255	17	of	of	IN
18637	11255	18	the	the	DT
18637	11255	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11255	20	in	in	IN
18637	11255	21	a	a	DT
18637	11255	22	matter	matter	NN
18637	11255	23	of	of	IN
18637	11255	24	that	that	DT
18637	11255	25	gravity	gravity	NN
18637	11255	26	,	,	,
18637	11255	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11255	28	would	would	MD
18637	11255	29	whittle	whittle	VB
18637	11255	30	the	the	DT
18637	11255	31	concept	concept	NN
18637	11255	32	of	of	IN
18637	11255	33	justiciability	justiciability	NN
18637	11255	34	down	down	RP
18637	11255	35	to	to	IN
18637	11255	36	the	the	DT
18637	11255	37	stature	stature	NN
18637	11255	38	of	of	IN
18637	11255	39	minor	minor	JJ
18637	11255	40	or	or	CC
18637	11255	41	conventional	conventional	JJ
18637	11255	42	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11255	43	.	.	.
18637	11256	1	There	there	EX
18637	11256	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	11256	3	no	no	DT
18637	11256	4	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	11256	5	for	for	IN
18637	11256	6	such	such	PDT
18637	11256	7	a	a	DT
18637	11256	8	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	11256	9	.	.	.
18637	11257	1	"	"	``
18637	11257	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11257	3	506	506	CD
18637	11257	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11257	5	Controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11257	6	Between	between	IN
18637	11257	7	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	11257	8	of	of	IN
18637	11257	9	Different	Different	NNP
18637	11257	10	States	state	NNS
18637	11257	11	THE	THE	NNP
18637	11257	12	MEANING	meaning	NN
18637	11257	13	OF	of	IN
18637	11257	14	"	"	``
18637	11257	15	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	11257	16	"	"	''
18637	11257	17	;	;	:
18637	11257	18	HEPBURN	HEPBURN	NNP
18637	11257	19	_	_	NNP
18637	11257	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	11257	21	_	_	NNP
18637	11257	22	ELLZEY	ELLZEY	NNP
18637	11257	23	Despite	despite	IN
18637	11257	24	stringent	stringent	JJ
18637	11257	25	definitions	definition	NNS
18637	11257	26	of	of	IN
18637	11257	27	the	the	DT
18637	11257	28	words	word	NNS
18637	11257	29	"	"	``
18637	11257	30	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11257	31	"	"	''
18637	11257	32	and	and	CC
18637	11257	33	"	"	``
18637	11257	34	State	State	NNP
18637	11257	35	"	"	''
18637	11257	36	and	and	CC
18637	11257	37	strict	strict	JJ
18637	11257	38	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	11257	39	safeguards	safeguard	NNS
18637	11257	40	against	against	IN
18637	11257	41	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	11257	42	of	of	IN
18637	11257	43	the	the	DT
18637	11257	44	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11257	45	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11257	46	out	out	IN
18637	11257	47	of	of	IN
18637	11257	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11257	49	,	,	,
18637	11257	50	the	the	DT
18637	11257	51	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11257	52	of	of	IN
18637	11257	53	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11257	54	clause	clause	NN
18637	11257	55	is	be	VBZ
18637	11257	56	one	one	CD
18637	11257	57	of	of	IN
18637	11257	58	the	the	DT
18637	11257	59	more	more	JJR
18637	11257	60	prolific	prolific	JJ
18637	11257	61	sources	source	NNS
18637	11257	62	of	of	IN
18637	11257	63	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11257	64	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11257	65	.	.	.
18637	11258	1	In	in	IN
18637	11258	2	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	11258	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11258	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	11258	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11258	6	Ellzey,[507	Ellzey,[507	NNP
18637	11258	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11258	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11258	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11258	10	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11258	11	,	,	,
18637	11258	12	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	11258	13	for	for	IN
18637	11258	14	the	the	DT
18637	11258	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11258	16	,	,	,
18637	11258	17	confined	confine	VBD
18637	11258	18	the	the	DT
18637	11258	19	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	11258	20	of	of	IN
18637	11258	21	the	the	DT
18637	11258	22	word	word	NN
18637	11258	23	"	"	``
18637	11258	24	State	State	NNP
18637	11258	25	,	,	,
18637	11258	26	"	"	''
18637	11258	27	as	as	IN
18637	11258	28	used	use	VBN
18637	11258	29	in	in	IN
18637	11258	30	the	the	DT
18637	11258	31	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11258	32	,	,	,
18637	11258	33	to	to	IN
18637	11258	34	"	"	``
18637	11258	35	the	the	DT
18637	11258	36	members	member	NNS
18637	11258	37	of	of	IN
18637	11258	38	the	the	DT
18637	11258	39	American	american	JJ
18637	11258	40	confederacy	confederacy	NN
18637	11258	41	"	"	''
18637	11258	42	and	and	CC
18637	11258	43	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	11258	44	that	that	IN
18637	11258	45	a	a	DT
18637	11258	46	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11258	47	of	of	IN
18637	11258	48	the	the	DT
18637	11258	49	District	District	NNP
18637	11258	50	of	of	IN
18637	11258	51	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	11258	52	could	could	MD
18637	11258	53	not	not	RB
18637	11258	54	sue	sue	VB
18637	11258	55	a	a	DT
18637	11258	56	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11258	57	of	of	IN
18637	11258	58	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11258	59	on	on	IN
18637	11258	60	the	the	DT
18637	11258	61	basis	basis	NN
18637	11258	62	of	of	IN
18637	11258	63	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11258	64	of	of	IN
18637	11258	65	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11258	66	.	.	.
18637	11259	1	In	in	IN
18637	11259	2	the	the	DT
18637	11259	3	course	course	NN
18637	11259	4	of	of	IN
18637	11259	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11259	6	brief	brief	JJ
18637	11259	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11259	8	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11259	9	owned	own	VBD
18637	11259	10	that	that	IN
18637	11259	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11259	12	was	be	VBD
18637	11259	13	"	"	``
18637	11259	14	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	11259	15	that	that	IN
18637	11259	16	the	the	DT
18637	11259	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	11259	18	of	of	IN
18637	11259	19	the	the	DT
18637	11259	20	United	United	NNP
18637	11259	21	States	States	NNP
18637	11259	22	,	,	,
18637	11259	23	which	which	WDT
18637	11259	24	are	be	VBP
18637	11259	25	open	open	JJ
18637	11259	26	to	to	IN
18637	11259	27	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	11259	28	,	,	,
18637	11259	29	and	and	CC
18637	11259	30	to	to	IN
18637	11259	31	the	the	DT
18637	11259	32	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11259	33	of	of	IN
18637	11259	34	every	every	DT
18637	11259	35	State	State	NNP
18637	11259	36	in	in	IN
18637	11259	37	the	the	DT
18637	11259	38	union	union	NN
18637	11259	39	should	should	MD
18637	11259	40	be	be	VB
18637	11259	41	closed	close	VBN
18637	11259	42	"	"	''
18637	11259	43	to	to	IN
18637	11259	44	the	the	DT
18637	11259	45	residents	resident	NNS
18637	11259	46	of	of	IN
18637	11259	47	the	the	DT
18637	11259	48	District	District	NNP
18637	11259	49	,	,	,
18637	11259	50	but	but	CC
18637	11259	51	the	the	DT
18637	11259	52	situation	situation	NN
18637	11259	53	,	,	,
18637	11259	54	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11259	55	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	11259	56	,	,	,
18637	11259	57	was	be	VBD
18637	11259	58	"	"	``
18637	11259	59	a	a	DT
18637	11259	60	subject	subject	NN
18637	11259	61	for	for	IN
18637	11259	62	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	11259	63	,	,	,
18637	11259	64	not	not	RB
18637	11259	65	for	for	IN
18637	11259	66	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11259	67	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	11259	68	.	.	.
18637	11260	1	"	"	``
18637	11260	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11260	3	508	508	CD
18637	11260	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11260	5	The	the	DT
18637	11260	6	same	same	JJ
18637	11260	7	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	11260	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	11260	9	was	be	VBD
18637	11260	10	later	later	RB
18637	11260	11	extended	extend	VBN
18637	11260	12	to	to	IN
18637	11260	13	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11260	14	of	of	IN
18637	11260	15	territories	territory	NNS
18637	11260	16	of	of	IN
18637	11260	17	the	the	DT
18637	11260	18	United	United	NNP
18637	11260	19	States	States	NNP
18637	11260	20	.	.	.
18637	11261	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11261	2	509	509	CD
18637	11261	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11261	4	Extension	extension	NN
18637	11261	5	of	of	IN
18637	11261	6	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	11261	7	by	by	IN
18637	11261	8	the	the	DT
18637	11261	9	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11261	10	of	of	IN
18637	11261	11	1940	1940	CD
18637	11261	12	Whether	Whether	NNP
18637	11261	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11261	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11261	15	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11261	16	had	have	VBD
18637	11261	17	in	in	IN
18637	11261	18	mind	mind	NN
18637	11261	19	a	a	DT
18637	11261	20	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11261	21	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	11261	22	or	or	CC
18637	11261	23	an	an	DT
18637	11261	24	act	act	NN
18637	11261	25	of	of	IN
18637	11261	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11261	27	when	when	WRB
18637	11261	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11261	29	spoke	speak	VBD
18637	11261	30	of	of	IN
18637	11261	31	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	11261	32	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	11261	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	11261	34	not	not	RB
18637	11261	35	clear	clear	JJ
18637	11261	36	.	.	.
18637	11262	1	At	at	IN
18637	11262	2	any	any	DT
18637	11262	3	rate	rate	NN
18637	11262	4	,	,	,
18637	11262	5	not	not	RB
18637	11262	6	until	until	IN
18637	11262	7	1940	1940	CD
18637	11262	8	did	do	VBD
18637	11262	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11262	10	enact	enact	VB
18637	11262	11	a	a	DT
18637	11262	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	11262	13	to	to	TO
18637	11262	14	confer	confer	VB
18637	11262	15	on	on	IN
18637	11262	16	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11262	17	district	district	NN
18637	11262	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	11262	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11262	20	of	of	IN
18637	11262	21	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11262	22	actions	action	NNS
18637	11262	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11262	24	involving	involve	VBG
18637	11262	25	no	no	DT
18637	11262	26	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11262	27	question	question	NN
18637	11262	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11262	29	"	"	''
18637	11262	30	between	between	IN
18637	11262	31	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11262	32	of	of	IN
18637	11262	33	different	different	JJ
18637	11262	34	States	state	NNS
18637	11262	35	,	,	,
18637	11262	36	or	or	CC
18637	11262	37	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11262	38	of	of	IN
18637	11262	39	the	the	DT
18637	11262	40	District	District	NNP
18637	11262	41	of	of	IN
18637	11262	42	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	11262	43	,	,	,
18637	11262	44	the	the	DT
18637	11262	45	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	11262	46	of	of	IN
18637	11262	47	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	11262	48	,	,	,
18637	11262	49	or	or	CC
18637	11262	50	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	11262	51	and	and	CC
18637	11262	52	any	any	DT
18637	11262	53	State	State	NNP
18637	11262	54	or	or	CC
18637	11262	55	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	11262	56	.	.	.
18637	11263	1	"	"	``
18637	11263	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11263	3	510	510	CD
18637	11263	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11263	5	In	in	IN
18637	11263	6	National	National	NNP
18637	11263	7	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	11263	8	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	11263	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11263	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11263	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	11263	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11263	13	Tidewater	Tidewater	NNP
18637	11263	14	Transfer	Transfer	NNP
18637	11263	15	Co	Co	NNP
18637	11263	16	.	.	.
18637	11263	17	,[511	,[511	NFP
18637	11263	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11263	19	this	this	DT
18637	11263	20	act	act	NN
18637	11263	21	was	be	VBD
18637	11263	22	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	11263	23	by	by	IN
18637	11263	24	five	five	CD
18637	11263	25	judges	judge	NNS
18637	11263	26	,	,	,
18637	11263	27	but	but	CC
18637	11263	28	for	for	IN
18637	11263	29	widely	widely	RB
18637	11263	30	different	different	JJ
18637	11263	31	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	11263	32	.	.	.
18637	11264	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11264	2	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	11264	3	,	,	,
18637	11264	4	in	in	IN
18637	11264	5	an	an	DT
18637	11264	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11264	7	in	in	IN
18637	11264	8	which	which	WDT
18637	11264	9	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	11264	10	Black	Black	NNP
18637	11264	11	and	and	CC
18637	11264	12	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	11264	13	joined	join	VBD
18637	11264	14	,	,	,
18637	11264	15	was	be	VBD
18637	11264	16	for	for	IN
18637	11264	17	adhering	adhere	VBG
18637	11264	18	to	to	IN
18637	11264	19	the	the	DT
18637	11264	20	rule	rule	NN
18637	11264	21	that	that	IN
18637	11264	22	the	the	DT
18637	11264	23	District	District	NNP
18637	11264	24	of	of	IN
18637	11264	25	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	11264	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	11264	27	not	not	RB
18637	11264	28	a	a	DT
18637	11264	29	State	state	NN
18637	11264	30	,	,	,
18637	11264	31	but	but	CC
18637	11264	32	held	hold	VBD
18637	11264	33	the	the	DT
18637	11264	34	act	act	NN
18637	11264	35	to	to	TO
18637	11264	36	be	be	VB
18637	11264	37	valid	valid	JJ
18637	11264	38	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	11264	39	because	because	IN
18637	11264	40	of	of	IN
18637	11264	41	the	the	DT
18637	11264	42	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11264	43	and	and	CC
18637	11264	44	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	11264	45	power	power	NN
18637	11264	46	of	of	IN
18637	11264	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11264	48	to	to	TO
18637	11264	49	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	11264	50	for	for	IN
18637	11264	51	the	the	DT
18637	11264	52	District	District	NNP
18637	11264	53	and	and	CC
18637	11264	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11264	55	broad	broad	JJ
18637	11264	56	powers	power	NNS
18637	11264	57	under	under	IN
18637	11264	58	the	the	DT
18637	11264	59	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11264	60	and	and	CC
18637	11264	61	proper	proper	JJ
18637	11264	62	clause	clause	NN
18637	11264	63	.	.	.
18637	11265	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11265	2	512	512	CD
18637	11265	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11265	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11265	5	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	11265	6	,	,	,
18637	11265	7	in	in	IN
18637	11265	8	a	a	DT
18637	11265	9	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	11265	10	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11265	11	,	,	,
18637	11265	12	in	in	IN
18637	11265	13	which	which	WDT
18637	11265	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11265	15	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	11265	16	joined	join	VBD
18637	11265	17	,	,	,
18637	11265	18	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	11265	19	that	that	IN
18637	11265	20	the	the	DT
18637	11265	21	act	act	NN
18637	11265	22	was	be	VBD
18637	11265	23	valid	valid	JJ
18637	11265	24	and	and	CC
18637	11265	25	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	11265	26	that	that	IN
18637	11265	27	the	the	DT
18637	11265	28	Ellzey	Ellzey	NNP
18637	11265	29	case	case	NN
18637	11265	30	should	should	MD
18637	11265	31	be	be	VB
18637	11265	32	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	11265	33	.	.	.
18637	11266	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11266	2	513	513	CD
18637	11266	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11266	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11266	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11266	6	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	11266	7	in	in	IN
18637	11266	8	a	a	DT
18637	11266	9	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11266	10	in	in	IN
18637	11266	11	which	which	WDT
18637	11266	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11266	13	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	11266	14	concurred[514	concurred[514	NN
18637	11266	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11266	16	and	and	CC
18637	11266	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11266	18	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11266	19	in	in	IN
18637	11266	20	a	a	DT
18637	11266	21	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11266	22	in	in	IN
18637	11266	23	which	which	WDT
18637	11266	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11266	25	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	11266	26	joined[515	joined[515	NNP
18637	11266	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11266	28	thought	think	VBD
18637	11266	29	the	the	DT
18637	11266	30	act	act	NN
18637	11266	31	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	11266	32	and	and	CC
18637	11266	33	would	would	MD
18637	11266	34	have	have	VB
18637	11266	35	adhered	adhere	VBN
18637	11266	36	to	to	IN
18637	11266	37	the	the	DT
18637	11266	38	rule	rule	NN
18637	11266	39	in	in	IN
18637	11266	40	the	the	DT
18637	11266	41	Ellzey	Ellzey	NNP
18637	11266	42	case	case	NN
18637	11266	43	.	.	.
18637	11267	1	The	the	DT
18637	11267	2	net	net	JJ
18637	11267	3	result	result	NN
18637	11267	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	11267	5	that	that	IN
18637	11267	6	the	the	DT
18637	11267	7	Ellzey	Ellzey	NNP
18637	11267	8	case	case	NN
18637	11267	9	still	still	RB
18637	11267	10	stands	stand	VBZ
18637	11267	11	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	11267	12	as	as	IN
18637	11267	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11267	14	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	11267	15	that	that	IN
18637	11267	16	the	the	DT
18637	11267	17	District	District	NNP
18637	11267	18	of	of	IN
18637	11267	19	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	11267	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	11267	21	not	not	RB
18637	11267	22	a	a	DT
18637	11267	23	State	state	NN
18637	11267	24	,	,	,
18637	11267	25	but	but	CC
18637	11267	26	that	that	IN
18637	11267	27	under	under	IN
18637	11267	28	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	11267	29	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	11267	30	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11267	31	of	of	IN
18637	11267	32	the	the	DT
18637	11267	33	District	District	NNP
18637	11267	34	may	may	MD
18637	11267	35	now	now	RB
18637	11267	36	sue	sue	VB
18637	11267	37	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11267	38	of	of	IN
18637	11267	39	States	States	NNPS
18637	11267	40	in	in	IN
18637	11267	41	the	the	DT
18637	11267	42	absence	absence	NN
18637	11267	43	of	of	IN
18637	11267	44	a	a	DT
18637	11267	45	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11267	46	question	question	NN
18637	11267	47	,	,	,
18637	11267	48	on	on	IN
18637	11267	49	the	the	DT
18637	11267	50	basis	basis	NN
18637	11267	51	of	of	IN
18637	11267	52	no	no	DT
18637	11267	53	statable	statable	JJ
18637	11267	54	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11267	55	principle	principle	NN
18637	11267	56	,	,	,
18637	11267	57	but	but	CC
18637	11267	58	through	through	IN
18637	11267	59	the	the	DT
18637	11267	60	grace	grace	NN
18637	11267	61	of	of	IN
18637	11267	62	what	what	WP
18637	11267	63	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11267	64	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11267	65	called	call	VBD
18637	11267	66	"	"	``
18637	11267	67	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	11267	68	minorities	minority	NNS
18637	11267	69	in	in	IN
18637	11267	70	combination	combination	NN
18637	11267	71	.	.	.
18637	11268	1	"	"	``
18637	11268	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11268	3	516	516	CD
18637	11268	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11268	5	CITIZENSHIP	CITIZENSHIP	NNP
18637	11268	6	,	,	,
18637	11268	7	NATURAL	natural	JJ
18637	11268	8	PERSONS	person	NNS
18637	11268	9	For	for	IN
18637	11268	10	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	11268	11	of	of	IN
18637	11268	12	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11268	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11268	14	State	State	NNP
18637	11268	15	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11268	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	11268	17	determined	determine	VBN
18637	11268	18	by	by	IN
18637	11268	19	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	11268	20	or	or	CC
18637	11268	21	residence	residence	NN
18637	11268	22	,	,	,
18637	11268	23	for	for	IN
18637	11268	24	the	the	DT
18637	11268	25	determination	determination	NN
18637	11268	26	of	of	IN
18637	11268	27	which	which	WDT
18637	11268	28	various	various	JJ
18637	11268	29	tests	test	NNS
18637	11268	30	have	have	VBP
18637	11268	31	been	be	VBN
18637	11268	32	stated	state	VBN
18637	11268	33	:	:	:
18637	11268	34	removal	removal	NN
18637	11268	35	to	to	IN
18637	11268	36	a	a	DT
18637	11268	37	State	state	NN
18637	11268	38	,	,	,
18637	11268	39	acquiring	acquire	VBG
18637	11268	40	real	real	JJ
18637	11268	41	estate	estate	NN
18637	11268	42	there	there	RB
18637	11268	43	,	,	,
18637	11268	44	and	and	CC
18637	11268	45	paying	pay	VBG
18637	11268	46	taxes;[517	taxes;[517	CD
18637	11268	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11268	48	residence	residence	NN
18637	11268	49	in	in	IN
18637	11268	50	a	a	DT
18637	11268	51	State	state	NN
18637	11268	52	for	for	IN
18637	11268	53	a	a	DT
18637	11268	54	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	11268	55	time;[518	time;[518	CD
18637	11268	56	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11268	57	and	and	CC
18637	11268	58	removal	removal	NN
18637	11268	59	to	to	IN
18637	11268	60	a	a	DT
18637	11268	61	State	state	NN
18637	11268	62	with	with	IN
18637	11268	63	the	the	DT
18637	11268	64	intent	intent	NN
18637	11268	65	of	of	IN
18637	11268	66	making	make	VBG
18637	11268	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11268	68	one	one	NN
18637	11268	69	's	's	POS
18637	11268	70	home	home	NN
18637	11268	71	for	for	IN
18637	11268	72	an	an	DT
18637	11268	73	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	11268	74	period	period	NN
18637	11268	75	of	of	IN
18637	11268	76	time	time	NN
18637	11268	77	.	.	.
18637	11269	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11269	2	519	519	CD
18637	11269	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11269	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	11269	5	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11269	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	11269	7	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	11269	8	on	on	IN
18637	11269	9	intention	intention	NN
18637	11269	10	,	,	,
18637	11269	11	acts	act	NNS
18637	11269	12	may	may	MD
18637	11269	13	disclose	disclose	VB
18637	11269	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11269	15	more	more	RBR
18637	11269	16	satisfactorily	satisfactorily	RB
18637	11269	17	than	than	IN
18637	11269	18	declarations	declaration	NNS
18637	11269	19	.	.	.
18637	11270	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11270	2	520	520	CD
18637	11270	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11270	4	The	the	DT
18637	11270	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	11270	6	that	that	IN
18637	11270	7	removal	removal	NN
18637	11270	8	to	to	IN
18637	11270	9	another	another	DT
18637	11270	10	State	state	NN
18637	11270	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	11270	12	motivated	motivate	VBN
18637	11270	13	solely	solely	RB
18637	11270	14	by	by	IN
18637	11270	15	a	a	DT
18637	11270	16	desire	desire	NN
18637	11270	17	to	to	TO
18637	11270	18	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	11270	19	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11270	20	for	for	IN
18637	11270	21	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11270	22	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	11270	23	does	do	VBZ
18637	11270	24	not	not	RB
18637	11270	25	oust	oust	VB
18637	11270	26	the	the	DT
18637	11270	27	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11270	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	11270	29	of	of	IN
18637	11270	30	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11270	31	so	so	RB
18637	11270	32	long	long	RB
18637	11270	33	as	as	IN
18637	11270	34	the	the	DT
18637	11270	35	new	new	JJ
18637	11270	36	residence	residence	NN
18637	11270	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	11270	38	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	11270	39	or	or	CC
18637	11270	40	the	the	DT
18637	11270	41	intention	intention	NN
18637	11270	42	to	to	TO
18637	11270	43	reside	reside	VB
18637	11270	44	there	there	RB
18637	11270	45	indefinitely	indefinitely	RB
18637	11270	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	11270	47	shown	show	VBN
18637	11270	48	.	.	.
18637	11271	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11271	2	521	521	CD
18637	11271	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11271	4	But	but	CC
18637	11271	5	a	a	DT
18637	11271	6	mere	mere	JJ
18637	11271	7	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	11271	8	change	change	NN
18637	11271	9	of	of	IN
18637	11271	10	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	11271	11	for	for	IN
18637	11271	12	the	the	DT
18637	11271	13	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	11271	14	of	of	IN
18637	11271	15	suing	sue	VBG
18637	11271	16	in	in	IN
18637	11271	17	a	a	DT
18637	11271	18	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11271	19	court	court	NN
18637	11271	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	11271	21	not	not	RB
18637	11271	22	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	11271	23	to	to	TO
18637	11271	24	effectuate	effectuate	VB
18637	11271	25	a	a	DT
18637	11271	26	change	change	NN
18637	11271	27	in	in	IN
18637	11271	28	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11271	29	.	.	.
18637	11272	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11272	2	522	522	CD
18637	11272	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11272	4	Exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11272	5	of	of	IN
18637	11272	6	the	the	DT
18637	11272	7	right	right	NN
18637	11272	8	of	of	IN
18637	11272	9	suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	11272	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	11272	11	a	a	DT
18637	11272	12	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	11272	13	test	test	NN
18637	11272	14	of	of	IN
18637	11272	15	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11272	16	in	in	IN
18637	11272	17	a	a	DT
18637	11272	18	State	State	NNP
18637	11272	19	,	,	,
18637	11272	20	and	and	CC
18637	11272	21	the	the	DT
18637	11272	22	acquisition	acquisition	NN
18637	11272	23	of	of	IN
18637	11272	24	the	the	DT
18637	11272	25	right	right	NN
18637	11272	26	to	to	TO
18637	11272	27	vote	vote	VB
18637	11272	28	without	without	IN
18637	11272	29	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	11272	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11272	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	11272	32	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	11272	33	to	to	TO
18637	11272	34	establish	establish	VB
18637	11272	35	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11272	36	.	.	.
18637	11273	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11273	2	523	523	CD
18637	11273	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11273	4	CITIZENSHIP	citizenship	VB
18637	11273	5	,	,	,
18637	11273	6	CORPORATIONS	corporations	NN
18637	11273	7	In	in	IN
18637	11273	8	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	11273	9	of	of	IN
18637	11273	10	United	United	NNP
18637	11273	11	States	States	NNP
18637	11273	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11273	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	11273	14	_	_	NNP
18637	11273	15	Deveaux,[524	Deveaux,[524	NNP
18637	11273	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11273	17	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11273	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11273	19	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11273	20	declared	declare	VBD
18637	11273	21	:	:	:
18637	11273	22	"	"	``
18637	11273	23	That	that	DT
18637	11273	24	invisible	invisible	JJ
18637	11273	25	,	,	,
18637	11273	26	intangible	intangible	JJ
18637	11273	27	,	,	,
18637	11273	28	and	and	CC
18637	11273	29	artificial	artificial	JJ
18637	11273	30	being	being	NN
18637	11273	31	,	,	,
18637	11273	32	that	that	IN
18637	11273	33	mere	mere	JJ
18637	11273	34	legal	legal	JJ
18637	11273	35	entity	entity	NN
18637	11273	36	,	,	,
18637	11273	37	a	a	DT
18637	11273	38	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11273	39	aggregate	aggregate	NN
18637	11273	40	,	,	,
18637	11273	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	11273	42	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	11273	43	not	not	RB
18637	11273	44	a	a	DT
18637	11273	45	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11273	46	;	;	:
18637	11273	47	and	and	CC
18637	11273	48	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	11273	49	can	can	MD
18637	11273	50	not	not	RB
18637	11273	51	sue	sue	VB
18637	11273	52	or	or	CC
18637	11273	53	be	be	VB
18637	11273	54	sued	sue	VBN
18637	11273	55	in	in	IN
18637	11273	56	the	the	DT
18637	11273	57	courts	court	NNS
18637	11273	58	of	of	IN
18637	11273	59	the	the	DT
18637	11273	60	United	United	NNP
18637	11273	61	States	States	NNP
18637	11273	62	,	,	,
18637	11273	63	unless	unless	IN
18637	11273	64	the	the	DT
18637	11273	65	rights	right	NNS
18637	11273	66	of	of	IN
18637	11273	67	the	the	DT
18637	11273	68	members	member	NNS
18637	11273	69	,	,	,
18637	11273	70	in	in	IN
18637	11273	71	this	this	DT
18637	11273	72	respect	respect	NN
18637	11273	73	,	,	,
18637	11273	74	can	can	MD
18637	11273	75	be	be	VB
18637	11273	76	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	11273	77	in	in	IN
18637	11273	78	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11273	79	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	11273	80	name	name	NN
18637	11273	81	.	.	.
18637	11273	82	"	"	''
18637	11274	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11274	2	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	11274	3	then	then	RB
18637	11274	4	to	to	TO
18637	11274	5	look	look	VB
18637	11274	6	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	11274	7	the	the	DT
18637	11274	8	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	11274	9	entity	entity	NN
18637	11274	10	and	and	CC
18637	11274	11	hold	hold	VB
18637	11274	12	that	that	IN
18637	11274	13	the	the	DT
18637	11274	14	bank	bank	NN
18637	11274	15	could	could	MD
18637	11274	16	sue	sue	VB
18637	11274	17	under	under	IN
18637	11274	18	the	the	DT
18637	11274	19	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11274	20	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	11274	21	of	of	IN
18637	11274	22	the	the	DT
18637	11274	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11274	24	and	and	CC
18637	11274	25	the	the	DT
18637	11274	26	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11274	27	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11274	28	of	of	IN
18637	11274	29	1789	1789	CD
18637	11274	30	because	because	IN
18637	11274	31	the	the	DT
18637	11274	32	members	member	NNS
18637	11274	33	of	of	IN
18637	11274	34	the	the	DT
18637	11274	35	bank	bank	NN
18637	11274	36	as	as	IN
18637	11274	37	a	a	DT
18637	11274	38	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11274	39	were	be	VBD
18637	11274	40	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11274	41	of	of	IN
18637	11274	42	one	one	CD
18637	11274	43	State	State	NNP
18637	11274	44	and	and	CC
18637	11274	45	Deveaux	Deveaux	NNP
18637	11274	46	was	be	VBD
18637	11274	47	a	a	DT
18637	11274	48	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11274	49	of	of	IN
18637	11274	50	another	another	DT
18637	11274	51	.	.	.
18637	11275	1	This	this	DT
18637	11275	2	holding	holding	NN
18637	11275	3	was	be	VBD
18637	11275	4	reaffirmed	reaffirm	VBN
18637	11275	5	a	a	DT
18637	11275	6	generation	generation	NN
18637	11275	7	later	later	RB
18637	11275	8	,	,	,
18637	11275	9	in	in	IN
18637	11275	10	Commercial	Commercial	NNP
18637	11275	11	and	and	CC
18637	11275	12	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	11275	13	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	11275	14	of	of	IN
18637	11275	15	Vicksburg	Vicksburg	NNP
18637	11275	16	_	_	NNP
18637	11275	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	11275	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11275	19	Slocomb,[525	Slocomb,[525	NNP
18637	11275	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11275	21	at	at	IN
18637	11275	22	a	a	DT
18637	11275	23	time	time	NN
18637	11275	24	when	when	WRB
18637	11275	25	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	11275	26	were	be	VBD
18637	11275	27	coming	come	VBG
18637	11275	28	to	to	TO
18637	11275	29	play	play	VB
18637	11275	30	a	a	DT
18637	11275	31	more	more	RBR
18637	11275	32	important	important	JJ
18637	11275	33	role	role	NN
18637	11275	34	in	in	IN
18637	11275	35	the	the	DT
18637	11275	36	national	national	JJ
18637	11275	37	economy	economy	NN
18637	11275	38	.	.	.
18637	11276	1	The	the	DT
18637	11276	2	same	same	JJ
18637	11276	3	rule	rule	NN
18637	11276	4	,	,	,
18637	11276	5	combined	combine	VBN
18637	11276	6	with	with	IN
18637	11276	7	the	the	DT
18637	11276	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	11276	9	that	that	IN
18637	11276	10	in	in	IN
18637	11276	11	a	a	DT
18637	11276	12	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11276	13	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	11276	14	all	all	PDT
18637	11276	15	the	the	DT
18637	11276	16	persons	person	NNS
18637	11276	17	on	on	IN
18637	11276	18	one	one	CD
18637	11276	19	side	side	NN
18637	11276	20	of	of	IN
18637	11276	21	a	a	DT
18637	11276	22	suit	suit	NN
18637	11276	23	must	must	MD
18637	11276	24	be	be	VB
18637	11276	25	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11276	26	of	of	IN
18637	11276	27	different	different	JJ
18637	11276	28	States	state	NNS
18637	11276	29	from	from	IN
18637	11276	30	all	all	DT
18637	11276	31	persons	person	NNS
18637	11276	32	on	on	IN
18637	11276	33	the	the	DT
18637	11276	34	other	other	JJ
18637	11276	35	side,[526	side,[526	NN
18637	11276	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11276	37	could	could	MD
18637	11276	38	in	in	IN
18637	11276	39	the	the	DT
18637	11276	40	course	course	NN
18637	11276	41	of	of	IN
18637	11276	42	time	time	NN
18637	11276	43	have	have	VBP
18637	11276	44	closed	close	VBN
18637	11276	45	the	the	DT
18637	11276	46	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11276	47	courts	court	NNS
18637	11276	48	in	in	IN
18637	11276	49	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11276	50	cases	case	NNS
18637	11276	51	to	to	IN
18637	11276	52	the	the	DT
18637	11276	53	larger	large	JJR
18637	11276	54	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	11276	55	having	have	VBG
18637	11276	56	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	11276	57	in	in	IN
18637	11276	58	all	all	DT
18637	11276	59	or	or	CC
18637	11276	60	most	most	JJS
18637	11276	61	of	of	IN
18637	11276	62	the	the	DT
18637	11276	63	States	States	NNP
18637	11276	64	.	.	.
18637	11277	1	If	if	IN
18637	11277	2	such	such	JJ
18637	11277	3	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	11277	4	were	be	VBD
18637	11277	5	to	to	TO
18637	11277	6	have	have	VB
18637	11277	7	the	the	DT
18637	11277	8	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	11277	9	of	of	IN
18637	11277	10	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11277	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11277	12	,	,	,
18637	11277	13	either	either	CC
18637	11277	14	the	the	DT
18637	11277	15	Deveaux	Deveaux	NNP
18637	11277	16	or	or	CC
18637	11277	17	the	the	DT
18637	11277	18	Strawbridge	Strawbridge	NNP
18637	11277	19	rule	rule	NN
18637	11277	20	would	would	MD
18637	11277	21	have	have	VB
18637	11277	22	to	to	TO
18637	11277	23	yield	yield	VB
18637	11277	24	.	.	.
18637	11278	1	By	by	IN
18637	11278	2	1844	1844	CD
18637	11278	3	,	,	,
18637	11278	4	only	only	RB
18637	11278	5	four	four	CD
18637	11278	6	years	year	NNS
18637	11278	7	after	after	IN
18637	11278	8	the	the	DT
18637	11278	9	Slocomb	Slocomb	NNP
18637	11278	10	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11278	11	,	,	,
18637	11278	12	the	the	DT
18637	11278	13	interests	interest	NNS
18637	11278	14	of	of	IN
18637	11278	15	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	11278	16	in	in	IN
18637	11278	17	docketing	docket	VBG
18637	11278	18	cases	case	NNS
18637	11278	19	in	in	IN
18637	11278	20	the	the	DT
18637	11278	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11278	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	11278	23	as	as	IN
18637	11278	24	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11278	25	of	of	IN
18637	11278	26	different	different	JJ
18637	11278	27	States	state	NNS
18637	11278	28	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	11278	29	more	more	RBR
18637	11278	30	important	important	JJ
18637	11278	31	to	to	IN
18637	11278	32	the	the	DT
18637	11278	33	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11278	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11278	35	than	than	IN
18637	11278	36	the	the	DT
18637	11278	37	weight	weight	NN
18637	11278	38	to	to	TO
18637	11278	39	be	be	VB
18637	11278	40	attached	attach	VBN
18637	11278	41	to	to	IN
18637	11278	42	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	11278	43	,	,	,
18637	11278	44	even	even	RB
18637	11278	45	those	those	DT
18637	11278	46	set	set	VBN
18637	11278	47	by	by	IN
18637	11278	48	John	John	NNP
18637	11278	49	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11278	50	,	,	,
18637	11278	51	and	and	CC
18637	11278	52	in	in	IN
18637	11278	53	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	11278	54	,	,	,
18637	11278	55	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	11278	56	,	,	,
18637	11278	57	and	and	CC
18637	11278	58	Charleston	Charleston	NNP
18637	11278	59	R.	R.	NNP
18637	11278	60	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11278	61	_	_	NNP
18637	11278	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	11278	63	_	_	NNP
18637	11278	64	Letson,[527	Letson,[527	NNP
18637	11278	65	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11278	66	both	both	CC
18637	11278	67	the	the	DT
18637	11278	68	Deveaux	Deveaux	NNP
18637	11278	69	and	and	CC
18637	11278	70	Slocomb	Slocomb	NNP
18637	11278	71	cases	case	NNS
18637	11278	72	were	be	VBD
18637	11278	73	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	11278	74	.	.	.
18637	11279	1	After	after	IN
18637	11279	2	elaborate	elaborate	JJ
18637	11279	3	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	11279	4	by	by	IN
18637	11279	5	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	11279	6	,	,	,
18637	11279	7	the	the	DT
18637	11279	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11279	9	,	,	,
18637	11279	10	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	11279	11	through	through	IN
18637	11279	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11279	13	Wayne	Wayne	NNP
18637	11279	14	,	,	,
18637	11279	15	held	hold	VBD
18637	11279	16	that	that	IN
18637	11279	17	"	"	``
18637	11279	18	a	a	DT
18637	11279	19	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11279	20	created	create	VBN
18637	11279	21	by	by	IN
18637	11279	22	and	and	CC
18637	11279	23	doing	do	VBG
18637	11279	24	business	business	NN
18637	11279	25	in	in	IN
18637	11279	26	a	a	DT
18637	11279	27	particular	particular	JJ
18637	11279	28	State	state	NN
18637	11279	29	,	,	,
18637	11279	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	11279	31	to	to	TO
18637	11279	32	be	be	VB
18637	11279	33	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	11279	34	to	to	IN
18637	11279	35	all	all	DT
18637	11279	36	intents	intent	NNS
18637	11279	37	and	and	CC
18637	11279	38	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	11279	39	as	as	IN
18637	11279	40	a	a	DT
18637	11279	41	person	person	NN
18637	11279	42	,	,	,
18637	11279	43	although	although	IN
18637	11279	44	an	an	DT
18637	11279	45	artificial	artificial	JJ
18637	11279	46	person	person	NN
18637	11279	47	,	,	,
18637	11279	48	an	an	DT
18637	11279	49	inhabitant	inhabitant	NN
18637	11279	50	of	of	IN
18637	11279	51	the	the	DT
18637	11279	52	same	same	JJ
18637	11279	53	State	State	NNP
18637	11279	54	,	,	,
18637	11279	55	for	for	IN
18637	11279	56	the	the	DT
18637	11279	57	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	11279	58	of	of	IN
18637	11279	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11279	60	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	11279	61	,	,	,
18637	11279	62	capable	capable	JJ
18637	11279	63	of	of	IN
18637	11279	64	being	be	VBG
18637	11279	65	treated	treat	VBN
18637	11279	66	as	as	IN
18637	11279	67	a	a	DT
18637	11279	68	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11279	69	of	of	IN
18637	11279	70	that	that	DT
18637	11279	71	State	State	NNP
18637	11279	72	,	,	,
18637	11279	73	as	as	RB
18637	11279	74	much	much	JJ
18637	11279	75	as	as	IN
18637	11279	76	a	a	DT
18637	11279	77	natural	natural	JJ
18637	11279	78	person	person	NN
18637	11279	79	.	.	.
18637	11280	1	"	"	``
18637	11280	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11280	3	528	528	CD
18637	11280	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11280	5	In	in	IN
18637	11280	6	the	the	DT
18637	11280	7	Letson	Letson	NNP
18637	11280	8	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11280	9	the	the	DT
18637	11280	10	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	11280	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	11280	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	11280	13	the	the	DT
18637	11280	14	place	place	NN
18637	11280	15	of	of	IN
18637	11280	16	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	11280	17	of	of	IN
18637	11280	18	a	a	DT
18637	11280	19	joint	joint	JJ
18637	11280	20	stock	stock	NN
18637	11280	21	company	company	NN
18637	11280	22	as	as	IN
18637	11280	23	something	something	NN
18637	11280	24	completely	completely	RB
18637	11280	25	separate	separate	JJ
18637	11280	26	from	from	IN
18637	11280	27	the	the	DT
18637	11280	28	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11280	29	of	of	IN
18637	11280	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11280	31	members	member	NNS
18637	11280	32	.	.	.
18637	11281	1	In	in	IN
18637	11281	2	succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	11281	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	11281	4	,	,	,
18637	11281	5	however	however	RB
18637	11281	6	,	,	,
18637	11281	7	this	this	DT
18637	11281	8	fiction	fiction	NN
18637	11281	9	of	of	IN
18637	11281	10	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	11281	11	personality	personality	NN
18637	11281	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	11281	13	undergone	undergo	VBN
18637	11281	14	modifications	modification	NNS
18637	11281	15	so	so	IN
18637	11281	16	that	that	IN
18637	11281	17	a	a	DT
18637	11281	18	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11281	19	,	,	,
18637	11281	20	though	though	IN
18637	11281	21	still	still	RB
18637	11281	22	a	a	DT
18637	11281	23	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11281	24	of	of	IN
18637	11281	25	the	the	DT
18637	11281	26	State	State	NNP
18637	11281	27	where	where	WRB
18637	11281	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11281	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	11281	30	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	11281	31	,	,	,
18637	11281	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	11281	33	such	such	JJ
18637	11281	34	by	by	IN
18637	11281	35	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	11281	36	of	of	IN
18637	11281	37	the	the	DT
18637	11281	38	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	11281	39	fiction	fiction	NN
18637	11281	40	that	that	IN
18637	11281	41	all	all	PDT
18637	11281	42	the	the	DT
18637	11281	43	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	11281	44	are	be	VBP
18637	11281	45	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11281	46	of	of	IN
18637	11281	47	the	the	DT
18637	11281	48	State	State	NNP
18637	11281	49	which	which	WDT
18637	11281	50	by	by	IN
18637	11281	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11281	52	laws	law	NNS
18637	11281	53	created	create	VBD
18637	11281	54	the	the	DT
18637	11281	55	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11281	56	.	.	.
18637	11282	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11282	2	529	529	CD
18637	11282	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11282	4	This	this	DT
18637	11282	5	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	11282	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	11282	7	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	11282	8	and	and	CC
18637	11282	9	irrebuttable	irrebuttable	JJ
18637	11282	10	and	and	CC
18637	11282	11	resembles	resemble	VBZ
18637	11282	12	in	in	IN
18637	11282	13	many	many	JJ
18637	11282	14	ways	way	NNS
18637	11282	15	the	the	DT
18637	11282	16	English	english	JJ
18637	11282	17	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	11282	18	fiction	fiction	NN
18637	11282	19	that	that	IN
18637	11282	20	for	for	IN
18637	11282	21	providing	provide	VBG
18637	11282	22	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	11282	23	for	for	IN
18637	11282	24	wrongs	wrong	NNS
18637	11282	25	done	do	VBN
18637	11282	26	in	in	IN
18637	11282	27	the	the	DT
18637	11282	28	Mediterranean	Mediterranean	NNP
18637	11282	29	"	"	``
18637	11282	30	the	the	DT
18637	11282	31	Island	Island	NNP
18637	11282	32	of	of	IN
18637	11282	33	Minorca	Minorca	NNP
18637	11282	34	was	be	VBD
18637	11282	35	at	at	IN
18637	11282	36	London	London	NNP
18637	11282	37	,	,	,
18637	11282	38	in	in	IN
18637	11282	39	the	the	DT
18637	11282	40	Parish	Parish	NNP
18637	11282	41	of	of	IN
18637	11282	42	St.	St.	NNP
18637	11282	43	Mary	Mary	NNP
18637	11282	44	Le	Le	NNP
18637	11282	45	Bow	Bow	NNP
18637	11282	46	in	in	IN
18637	11282	47	the	the	DT
18637	11282	48	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	11282	49	of	of	IN
18637	11282	50	Cheap	Cheap	NNP
18637	11282	51	.	.	.
18637	11283	1	"	"	``
18637	11283	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11283	3	530	530	CD
18637	11283	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11283	5	This	this	DT
18637	11283	6	fiction	fiction	NN
18637	11283	7	creates	create	VBZ
18637	11283	8	a	a	DT
18637	11283	9	logical	logical	JJ
18637	11283	10	anomaly	anomaly	NNS
18637	11283	11	,	,	,
18637	11283	12	which	which	WDT
18637	11283	13	the	the	DT
18637	11283	14	Letson	Letson	NNP
18637	11283	15	rule	rule	NN
18637	11283	16	had	have	VBD
18637	11283	17	avoided	avoid	VBN
18637	11283	18	,	,	,
18637	11283	19	in	in	IN
18637	11283	20	those	those	DT
18637	11283	21	cases	case	NNS
18637	11283	22	in	in	IN
18637	11283	23	which	which	WDT
18637	11283	24	a	a	DT
18637	11283	25	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	11283	26	of	of	IN
18637	11283	27	one	one	CD
18637	11283	28	State	State	NNP
18637	11283	29	sues	sue	VBZ
18637	11283	30	a	a	DT
18637	11283	31	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11283	32	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	11283	33	in	in	IN
18637	11283	34	another	another	DT
18637	11283	35	State	state	NN
18637	11283	36	.	.	.
18637	11284	1	Although	although	IN
18637	11284	2	all	all	DT
18637	11284	3	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	11284	4	are	be	VBP
18637	11284	5	conclusively	conclusively	RB
18637	11284	6	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	11284	7	to	to	TO
18637	11284	8	be	be	VB
18637	11284	9	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11284	10	of	of	IN
18637	11284	11	the	the	DT
18637	11284	12	State	State	NNP
18637	11284	13	where	where	WRB
18637	11284	14	the	the	DT
18637	11284	15	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11284	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	11284	17	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	11284	18	,	,	,
18637	11284	19	an	an	DT
18637	11284	20	individual	individual	JJ
18637	11284	21	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	11284	22	from	from	IN
18637	11284	23	a	a	DT
18637	11284	24	different	different	JJ
18637	11284	25	State	state	NN
18637	11284	26	may	may	MD
18637	11284	27	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	11284	28	aver	aver	VB
18637	11284	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11284	30	actual	actual	JJ
18637	11284	31	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11284	32	so	so	IN
18637	11284	33	as	as	IN
18637	11284	34	to	to	TO
18637	11284	35	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	11284	36	a	a	DT
18637	11284	37	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11284	38	suit	suit	NN
18637	11284	39	against	against	IN
18637	11284	40	the	the	DT
18637	11284	41	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11284	42	.	.	.
18637	11285	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11285	2	531	531	CD
18637	11285	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11285	4	These	these	DT
18637	11285	5	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	11285	6	lead	lead	VBP
18637	11285	7	to	to	IN
18637	11285	8	some	some	DT
18637	11285	9	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	11285	10	results	result	NNS
18637	11285	11	,	,	,
18637	11285	12	as	as	IN
18637	11285	13	John	John	NNP
18637	11285	14	Chipman	Chipman	NNP
18637	11285	15	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	11285	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	11285	17	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	11285	18	:	:	:
18637	11285	19	"	"	``
18637	11285	20	The	the	DT
18637	11285	21	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11285	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	11285	23	take	take	VBP
18637	11285	24	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	11285	25	of	of	IN
18637	11285	26	a	a	DT
18637	11285	27	suit	suit	NN
18637	11285	28	by	by	IN
18637	11285	29	a	a	DT
18637	11285	30	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	11285	31	who	who	WP
18637	11285	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	11285	33	a	a	DT
18637	11285	34	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11285	35	,	,	,
18637	11285	36	say	say	VBP
18637	11285	37	,	,	,
18637	11285	38	of	of	IN
18637	11285	39	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	11285	40	,	,	,
18637	11285	41	against	against	IN
18637	11285	42	the	the	DT
18637	11285	43	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11285	44	in	in	IN
18637	11285	45	which	which	WDT
18637	11285	46	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11285	47	owns	own	VBZ
18637	11285	48	stock	stock	NN
18637	11285	49	,	,	,
18637	11285	50	which	which	WDT
18637	11285	51	has	have	VBZ
18637	11285	52	been	be	VBN
18637	11285	53	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	11285	54	,	,	,
18637	11285	55	say	say	VB
18637	11285	56	,	,	,
18637	11285	57	by	by	IN
18637	11285	58	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	11285	59	.	.	.
18637	11286	1	Since	since	IN
18637	11286	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11286	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	11286	4	a	a	DT
18637	11286	5	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	11286	6	of	of	IN
18637	11286	7	an	an	DT
18637	11286	8	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	11286	9	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11286	10	,	,	,
18637	11286	11	the	the	DT
18637	11286	12	court	court	NN
18637	11286	13	conclusively	conclusively	RB
18637	11286	14	presumes	presume	VBZ
18637	11286	15	that	that	IN
18637	11286	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11286	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	11286	18	a	a	DT
18637	11286	19	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11286	20	of	of	IN
18637	11286	21	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	11286	22	,	,	,
18637	11286	23	but	but	CC
18637	11286	24	if	if	IN
18637	11286	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11286	26	were	be	VBD
18637	11286	27	a	a	DT
18637	11286	28	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11286	29	of	of	IN
18637	11286	30	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	11286	31	,	,	,
18637	11286	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11286	33	could	could	MD
18637	11286	34	not	not	RB
18637	11286	35	sue	sue	VB
18637	11286	36	an	an	DT
18637	11286	37	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	11286	38	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11286	39	in	in	IN
18637	11286	40	the	the	DT
18637	11286	41	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11286	42	courts	court	NNS
18637	11286	43	.	.	.
18637	11287	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11287	2	the	the	DT
18637	11287	3	court	court	NN
18637	11287	4	considers	consider	VBZ
18637	11287	5	that	that	IN
18637	11287	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11287	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	11287	8	and	and	CC
18637	11287	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11287	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	11287	11	not	not	RB
18637	11287	12	at	at	IN
18637	11287	13	the	the	DT
18637	11287	14	same	same	JJ
18637	11287	15	time	time	NN
18637	11287	16	a	a	DT
18637	11287	17	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11287	18	of	of	IN
18637	11287	19	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	11287	20	,	,	,
18637	11287	21	and	and	CC
18637	11287	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11287	23	would	would	MD
18637	11287	24	have	have	VB
18637	11287	25	no	no	DT
18637	11287	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11287	27	unless	unless	IN
18637	11287	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11287	29	considered	consider	VBD
18637	11287	30	that	that	IN
18637	11287	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11287	32	both	both	DT
18637	11287	33	was	be	VBD
18637	11287	34	and	and	CC
18637	11287	35	was	be	VBD
18637	11287	36	not	not	RB
18637	11287	37	at	at	IN
18637	11287	38	the	the	DT
18637	11287	39	same	same	JJ
18637	11287	40	time	time	NN
18637	11287	41	a	a	DT
18637	11287	42	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11287	43	both	both	DT
18637	11287	44	of	of	IN
18637	11287	45	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	11287	46	and	and	CC
18637	11287	47	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	11287	48	.	.	.
18637	11288	1	"	"	``
18637	11288	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11288	3	532	532	CD
18637	11288	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11288	5	The	the	DT
18637	11288	6	Black	Black	NNP
18637	11288	7	and	and	CC
18637	11288	8	White	White	NNP
18637	11288	9	Taxicab	Taxicab	NNPS
18637	11288	10	Case	case	NN
18637	11288	11	These	these	DT
18637	11288	12	fictions	fiction	NNS
18637	11288	13	of	of	IN
18637	11288	14	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	11288	15	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11288	16	make	make	VBP
18637	11288	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11288	18	easy	easy	JJ
18637	11288	19	for	for	IN
18637	11288	20	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	11288	21	to	to	TO
18637	11288	22	go	go	VB
18637	11288	23	into	into	IN
18637	11288	24	the	the	DT
18637	11288	25	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11288	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	11288	27	on	on	IN
18637	11288	28	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11288	29	of	of	IN
18637	11288	30	law	law	NN
18637	11288	31	that	that	WDT
18637	11288	32	are	be	VBP
18637	11288	33	purely	purely	RB
18637	11288	34	local	local	JJ
18637	11288	35	in	in	IN
18637	11288	36	nature	nature	NN
18637	11288	37	,	,	,
18637	11288	38	and	and	CC
18637	11288	39	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11288	40	have	have	VBP
18637	11288	41	availed	avail	VBN
18637	11288	42	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11288	43	of	of	IN
18637	11288	44	the	the	DT
18637	11288	45	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	11288	46	to	to	IN
18637	11288	47	the	the	DT
18637	11288	48	full	full	JJ
18637	11288	49	.	.	.
18637	11289	1	For	for	IN
18637	11289	2	a	a	DT
18637	11289	3	time	time	NN
18637	11289	4	the	the	DT
18637	11289	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11289	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11289	7	tended	tend	VBD
18637	11289	8	to	to	TO
18637	11289	9	look	look	VB
18637	11289	10	askance	askance	NN
18637	11289	11	at	at	IN
18637	11289	12	collusory	collusory	JJ
18637	11289	13	incorporations	incorporation	NNS
18637	11289	14	and	and	CC
18637	11289	15	the	the	DT
18637	11289	16	creation	creation	NN
18637	11289	17	of	of	IN
18637	11289	18	dummy	dummy	JJ
18637	11289	19	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	11289	20	for	for	IN
18637	11289	21	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	11289	22	of	of	IN
18637	11289	23	getting	get	VBG
18637	11289	24	cases	case	NNS
18637	11289	25	into	into	IN
18637	11289	26	the	the	DT
18637	11289	27	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11289	28	courts,[533	courts,[533	NN
18637	11289	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11289	30	but	but	CC
18637	11289	31	as	as	IN
18637	11289	32	a	a	DT
18637	11289	33	result	result	NN
18637	11289	34	of	of	IN
18637	11289	35	the	the	DT
18637	11289	36	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	11289	37	Taxicab	Taxicab	NNP
18637	11289	38	Case,[534	Case,[534	NNP
18637	11289	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11289	40	decided	decide	VBD
18637	11289	41	in	in	IN
18637	11289	42	1928	1928	CD
18637	11289	43	,	,	,
18637	11289	44	the	the	DT
18637	11289	45	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	11289	46	of	of	IN
18637	11289	47	collusion	collusion	NN
18637	11289	48	lost	lose	VBD
18637	11289	49	much	much	JJ
18637	11289	50	of	of	IN
18637	11289	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11289	52	force	force	NN
18637	11289	53	.	.	.
18637	11290	1	Here	here	RB
18637	11290	2	the	the	DT
18637	11290	3	Black	Black	NNP
18637	11290	4	and	and	CC
18637	11290	5	White	white	JJ
18637	11290	6	company	company	NN
18637	11290	7	,	,	,
18637	11290	8	a	a	DT
18637	11290	9	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	11290	10	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11290	11	,	,	,
18637	11290	12	dissolved	dissolve	VBD
18637	11290	13	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11290	14	and	and	CC
18637	11290	15	obtained	obtain	VBD
18637	11290	16	a	a	DT
18637	11290	17	charter	charter	NN
18637	11290	18	as	as	IN
18637	11290	19	a	a	DT
18637	11290	20	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	11290	21	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11290	22	in	in	IN
18637	11290	23	order	order	NN
18637	11290	24	to	to	TO
18637	11290	25	get	get	VB
18637	11290	26	the	the	DT
18637	11290	27	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	11290	28	of	of	IN
18637	11290	29	a	a	DT
18637	11290	30	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11290	31	rule	rule	NN
18637	11290	32	which	which	WDT
18637	11290	33	would	would	MD
18637	11290	34	condone	condone	VB
18637	11290	35	an	an	DT
18637	11290	36	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11290	37	contract	contract	NN
18637	11290	38	with	with	IN
18637	11290	39	a	a	DT
18637	11290	40	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	11290	41	to	to	TO
18637	11290	42	park	park	VB
18637	11290	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11290	44	cabs	cab	NNS
18637	11290	45	in	in	IN
18637	11290	46	and	and	CC
18637	11290	47	around	around	IN
18637	11290	48	a	a	DT
18637	11290	49	station	station	NN
18637	11290	50	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	11290	51	the	the	DT
18637	11290	52	State	State	NNP
18637	11290	53	rule	rule	NN
18637	11290	54	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	11290	55	such	such	JJ
18637	11290	56	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	11290	57	.	.	.
18637	11291	1	The	the	DT
18637	11291	2	only	only	JJ
18637	11291	3	change	change	NN
18637	11291	4	made	make	VBN
18637	11291	5	was	be	VBD
18637	11291	6	of	of	IN
18637	11291	7	the	the	DT
18637	11291	8	State	State	NNP
18637	11291	9	of	of	IN
18637	11291	10	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	11291	11	.	.	.
18637	11292	1	The	the	DT
18637	11292	2	name	name	NN
18637	11292	3	of	of	IN
18637	11292	4	the	the	DT
18637	11292	5	company	company	NN
18637	11292	6	,	,	,
18637	11292	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11292	8	officers	officer	NNS
18637	11292	9	,	,	,
18637	11292	10	and	and	CC
18637	11292	11	shareholders	shareholder	NNS
18637	11292	12	,	,	,
18637	11292	13	and	and	CC
18637	11292	14	the	the	DT
18637	11292	15	location	location	NN
18637	11292	16	of	of	IN
18637	11292	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11292	18	business	business	NN
18637	11292	19	all	all	DT
18637	11292	20	remained	remain	VBD
18637	11292	21	the	the	DT
18637	11292	22	same	same	JJ
18637	11292	23	.	.	.
18637	11293	1	Yet	yet	CC
18637	11293	2	no	no	DT
18637	11293	3	collusion	collusion	NN
18637	11293	4	was	be	VBD
18637	11293	5	found	find	VBN
18637	11293	6	,	,	,
18637	11293	7	and	and	CC
18637	11293	8	the	the	DT
18637	11293	9	company	company	NN
18637	11293	10	received	receive	VBD
18637	11293	11	the	the	DT
18637	11293	12	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	11293	13	of	of	IN
18637	11293	14	the	the	DT
18637	11293	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11293	16	rule	rule	NN
18637	11293	17	--	--	:
18637	11293	18	a	a	DT
18637	11293	19	measure	measure	NN
18637	11293	20	of	of	IN
18637	11293	21	salvation	salvation	NN
18637	11293	22	by	by	IN
18637	11293	23	being	be	VBG
18637	11293	24	born	bear	VBN
18637	11293	25	again	again	RB
18637	11293	26	in	in	IN
18637	11293	27	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	11293	28	.	.	.
18637	11294	1	The	the	DT
18637	11294	2	odd	odd	JJ
18637	11294	3	result	result	NN
18637	11294	4	in	in	IN
18637	11294	5	the	the	DT
18637	11294	6	Taxicab	Taxicab	NNP
18637	11294	7	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11294	8	,	,	,
18637	11294	9	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	11294	10	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11294	11	of	of	IN
18637	11294	12	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	11294	13	could	could	MD
18637	11294	14	conduct	conduct	VB
18637	11294	15	business	business	NN
18637	11294	16	there	there	RB
18637	11294	17	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	11294	18	to	to	IN
18637	11294	19	State	state	NN
18637	11294	20	law	law	NN
18637	11294	21	with	with	IN
18637	11294	22	the	the	DT
18637	11294	23	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	11294	24	of	of	IN
18637	11294	25	the	the	DT
18637	11294	26	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11294	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11294	28	of	of	IN
18637	11294	29	the	the	DT
18637	11294	30	United	United	NNP
18637	11294	31	States	States	NNP
18637	11294	32	,	,	,
18637	11294	33	did	do	VBD
18637	11294	34	not	not	RB
18637	11294	35	stem	stem	VB
18637	11294	36	solely	solely	RB
18637	11294	37	from	from	IN
18637	11294	38	the	the	DT
18637	11294	39	rule	rule	NN
18637	11294	40	that	that	IN
18637	11294	41	the	the	DT
18637	11294	42	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11294	43	of	of	IN
18637	11294	44	a	a	DT
18637	11294	45	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11294	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	11294	47	determined	determine	VBN
18637	11294	48	by	by	IN
18637	11294	49	the	the	DT
18637	11294	50	State	State	NNP
18637	11294	51	of	of	IN
18637	11294	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11294	53	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	11294	54	,	,	,
18637	11294	55	but	but	CC
18637	11294	56	also	also	RB
18637	11294	57	from	from	IN
18637	11294	58	this	this	DT
18637	11294	59	rule	rule	NN
18637	11294	60	combined	combine	VBN
18637	11294	61	with	with	IN
18637	11294	62	the	the	DT
18637	11294	63	rule	rule	NN
18637	11294	64	of	of	IN
18637	11294	65	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	11294	66	_	_	NNP
18637	11294	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	11294	68	_	_	NNP
18637	11294	69	Tyson,[535	Tyson,[535	NNP
18637	11294	70	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11294	71	another	another	DT
18637	11294	72	by	by	IN
18637	11294	73	-	-	HYPH
18637	11294	74	product	product	NN
18637	11294	75	of	of	IN
18637	11294	76	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11294	77	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11294	78	.	.	.
18637	11295	1	THE	the	DT
18637	11295	2	LAW	law	NN
18637	11295	3	APPLIED	apply	VBD
18637	11295	4	IN	in	IN
18637	11295	5	DIVERSITY	DIVERSITY	NNP
18637	11295	6	CASES	case	NNS
18637	11295	7	:	:	:
18637	11295	8	SWIFT	SWIFT	NNP
18637	11295	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11295	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	11295	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11295	12	TYSON	TYSON	NNP
18637	11295	13	Section	Section	NNP
18637	11295	14	34	34	CD
18637	11295	15	of	of	IN
18637	11295	16	the	the	DT
18637	11295	17	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11295	18	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11295	19	of	of	IN
18637	11295	20	1789	1789	CD
18637	11295	21	provided	provide	VBD
18637	11295	22	that	that	IN
18637	11295	23	in	in	IN
18637	11295	24	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11295	25	cases	case	NNS
18637	11295	26	at	at	IN
18637	11295	27	common	common	JJ
18637	11295	28	law	law	NN
18637	11295	29	the	the	DT
18637	11295	30	laws	law	NNS
18637	11295	31	of	of	IN
18637	11295	32	the	the	DT
18637	11295	33	several	several	JJ
18637	11295	34	States	state	NNS
18637	11295	35	should	should	MD
18637	11295	36	be	be	VB
18637	11295	37	the	the	DT
18637	11295	38	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11295	39	of	of	IN
18637	11295	40	decision	decision	NN
18637	11295	41	in	in	IN
18637	11295	42	the	the	DT
18637	11295	43	United	United	NNP
18637	11295	44	States	States	NNP
18637	11295	45	courts	court	NNS
18637	11295	46	.	.	.
18637	11296	1	However	however	RB
18637	11296	2	,	,	,
18637	11296	3	in	in	IN
18637	11296	4	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	11296	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11296	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11296	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11296	8	Tyson[536	Tyson[536	NNP
18637	11296	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11296	10	the	the	DT
18637	11296	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11296	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11296	13	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	11296	14	to	to	TO
18637	11296	15	apply	apply	VB
18637	11296	16	this	this	DT
18637	11296	17	section	section	NN
18637	11296	18	on	on	IN
18637	11296	19	the	the	DT
18637	11296	20	ground	ground	NN
18637	11296	21	that	that	IN
18637	11296	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11296	23	did	do	VBD
18637	11296	24	not	not	RB
18637	11296	25	extend	extend	VB
18637	11296	26	to	to	IN
18637	11296	27	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	11296	28	or	or	CC
18637	11296	29	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	11296	30	of	of	IN
18637	11296	31	a	a	DT
18637	11296	32	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	11296	33	nature	nature	NN
18637	11296	34	,	,	,
18637	11296	35	the	the	DT
18637	11296	36	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11296	37	of	of	IN
18637	11296	38	which	which	WDT
18637	11296	39	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11296	40	ought	ought	MD
18637	11296	41	to	to	TO
18637	11296	42	be	be	VB
18637	11296	43	according	accord	VBG
18637	11296	44	to	to	IN
18637	11296	45	"	"	``
18637	11296	46	the	the	DT
18637	11296	47	general	general	JJ
18637	11296	48	principles	principle	NNS
18637	11296	49	and	and	CC
18637	11296	50	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	11296	51	of	of	IN
18637	11296	52	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
18637	11296	53	"	"	''
18637	11296	54	;	;	:
18637	11296	55	and	and	CC
18637	11296	56	while	while	IN
18637	11296	57	the	the	DT
18637	11296	58	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11296	59	of	of	IN
18637	11296	60	State	State	NNP
18637	11296	61	courts	court	NNS
18637	11296	62	on	on	IN
18637	11296	63	such	such	JJ
18637	11296	64	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	11296	65	were	be	VBD
18637	11296	66	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	11296	67	to	to	IN
18637	11296	68	and	and	CC
18637	11296	69	would	would	MD
18637	11296	70	receive	receive	VB
18637	11296	71	attention	attention	NN
18637	11296	72	and	and	CC
18637	11296	73	respect	respect	NN
18637	11296	74	,	,	,
18637	11296	75	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11296	76	could	could	MD
18637	11296	77	not	not	RB
18637	11296	78	be	be	VB
18637	11296	79	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	11296	80	or	or	CC
18637	11296	81	binding	bind	VBG
18637	11296	82	upon	upon	IN
18637	11296	83	the	the	DT
18637	11296	84	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11296	85	courts	court	NNS
18637	11296	86	.	.	.
18637	11297	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11297	2	537	537	CD
18637	11297	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11297	4	Extension	extension	NN
18637	11297	5	of	of	IN
18637	11297	6	the	the	DT
18637	11297	7	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	11297	8	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11297	9	For	for	IN
18637	11297	10	ninety	ninety	CD
18637	11297	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	11297	12	six	six	CD
18637	11297	13	years	year	NNS
18637	11297	14	the	the	DT
18637	11297	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11297	16	followed	follow	VBD
18637	11297	17	this	this	DT
18637	11297	18	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11297	19	,	,	,
18637	11297	20	which	which	WDT
18637	11297	21	the	the	DT
18637	11297	22	other	other	JJ
18637	11297	23	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	11297	24	saw	see	VBD
18637	11297	25	only	only	RB
18637	11297	26	the	the	DT
18637	11297	27	evening	evening	NN
18637	11297	28	before	before	IN
18637	11297	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11297	30	was	be	VBD
18637	11297	31	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	11297	32	,	,	,
18637	11297	33	and	and	CC
18637	11297	34	which	which	WDT
18637	11297	35	invoked	invoke	VBD
18637	11297	36	a	a	DT
18637	11297	37	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	11297	38	of	of	IN
18637	11297	39	Lord	Lord	NNP
18637	11297	40	Mansfield	Mansfield	NNP
18637	11297	41	on	on	IN
18637	11297	42	the	the	DT
18637	11297	43	law	law	NN
18637	11297	44	of	of	IN
18637	11297	45	the	the	DT
18637	11297	46	sea	sea	NN
18637	11297	47	and	and	CC
18637	11297	48	an	an	DT
18637	11297	49	epigram	epigram	NN
18637	11297	50	of	of	IN
18637	11297	51	Cicero	Cicero	NNP
18637	11297	52	on	on	IN
18637	11297	53	the	the	DT
18637	11297	54	law	law	NN
18637	11297	55	of	of	IN
18637	11297	56	nature	nature	NN
18637	11297	57	.	.	.
18637	11298	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11298	2	538	538	CD
18637	11298	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11298	4	Later	late	JJR
18637	11298	5	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11298	6	expanded	expand	VBD
18637	11298	7	the	the	DT
18637	11298	8	concept	concept	NN
18637	11298	9	of	of	IN
18637	11298	10	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11298	11	of	of	IN
18637	11298	12	a	a	DT
18637	11298	13	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	11298	14	nature	nature	NN
18637	11298	15	so	so	IN
18637	11298	16	that	that	IN
18637	11298	17	the	the	DT
18637	11298	18	scope	scope	NN
18637	11298	19	of	of	IN
18637	11298	20	the	the	DT
18637	11298	21	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	11298	22	rule	rule	NN
18637	11298	23	was	be	VBD
18637	11298	24	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	11298	25	extended	extended	JJ
18637	11298	26	.	.	.
18637	11299	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11299	2	539	539	CD
18637	11299	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11299	4	In	in	IN
18637	11299	5	many	many	JJ
18637	11299	6	instances	instance	NNS
18637	11299	7	the	the	DT
18637	11299	8	State	state	NN
18637	11299	9	courts	court	NNS
18637	11299	10	followed	follow	VBD
18637	11299	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11299	12	own	own	JJ
18637	11299	13	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11299	14	of	of	IN
18637	11299	15	decision	decision	NN
18637	11299	16	even	even	RB
18637	11299	17	when	when	WRB
18637	11299	18	contrary	contrary	RB
18637	11299	19	to	to	IN
18637	11299	20	the	the	DT
18637	11299	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11299	22	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11299	23	,	,	,
18637	11299	24	so	so	IN
18637	11299	25	that	that	IN
18637	11299	26	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11299	27	Story	Story	NNP
18637	11299	28	's	's	POS
18637	11299	29	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	11299	30	at	at	IN
18637	11299	31	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	11299	32	in	in	IN
18637	11299	33	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11299	34	of	of	IN
18637	11299	35	a	a	DT
18637	11299	36	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	11299	37	nature	nature	NN
18637	11299	38	paradoxically	paradoxically	RB
18637	11299	39	led	lead	VBD
18637	11299	40	to	to	IN
18637	11299	41	a	a	DT
18637	11299	42	greater	great	JJR
18637	11299	43	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11299	44	and	and	CC
18637	11299	45	to	to	IN
18637	11299	46	the	the	DT
18637	11299	47	mischief	mischief	NN
18637	11299	48	in	in	IN
18637	11299	49	many	many	JJ
18637	11299	50	instances	instance	NNS
18637	11299	51	of	of	IN
18637	11299	52	two	two	CD
18637	11299	53	conflicting	conflicting	JJ
18637	11299	54	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11299	55	of	of	IN
18637	11299	56	law	law	NN
18637	11299	57	in	in	IN
18637	11299	58	the	the	DT
18637	11299	59	same	same	JJ
18637	11299	60	State	State	NNP
18637	11299	61	,	,	,
18637	11299	62	with	with	IN
18637	11299	63	the	the	DT
18637	11299	64	outcome	outcome	NN
18637	11299	65	of	of	IN
18637	11299	66	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11299	67	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	11299	68	upon	upon	IN
18637	11299	69	whether	whether	IN
18637	11299	70	the	the	DT
18637	11299	71	case	case	NN
18637	11299	72	was	be	VBD
18637	11299	73	docketed	docket	VBN
18637	11299	74	in	in	IN
18637	11299	75	a	a	DT
18637	11299	76	State	state	NN
18637	11299	77	or	or	CC
18637	11299	78	a	a	DT
18637	11299	79	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11299	80	court	court	NN
18637	11299	81	.	.	.
18637	11300	1	Simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
18637	11300	2	,	,	,
18637	11300	3	the	the	DT
18637	11300	4	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11300	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11300	6	was	be	VBD
18637	11300	7	holding	hold	VBG
18637	11300	8	under	under	IN
18637	11300	9	the	the	DT
18637	11300	10	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	11300	11	rule	rule	NN
18637	11300	12	that	that	IN
18637	11300	13	the	the	DT
18637	11300	14	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11300	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	11300	16	were	be	VBD
18637	11300	17	not	not	RB
18637	11300	18	bound	bind	VBN
18637	11300	19	by	by	IN
18637	11300	20	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11300	21	of	of	IN
18637	11300	22	State	State	NNP
18637	11300	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	11300	24	interpreting	interpret	VBG
18637	11300	25	State	State	NNP
18637	11300	26	constitutions[540	constitutions[540	NNP
18637	11300	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11300	28	or	or	CC
18637	11300	29	State	state	NN
18637	11300	30	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	11300	31	.	.	.
18637	11301	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11301	2	541	541	CD
18637	11301	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11301	4	The	the	DT
18637	11301	5	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	11301	6	Rule	Rule	NNP
18637	11301	7	Protested	Protested	NNP
18637	11301	8	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	11301	9	,	,	,
18637	11301	10	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11301	11	extending	extend	VBG
18637	11301	12	the	the	DT
18637	11301	13	scope	scope	NN
18637	11301	14	of	of	IN
18637	11301	15	the	the	DT
18637	11301	16	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	11301	17	rule	rule	NN
18637	11301	18	were	be	VBD
18637	11301	19	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	11301	20	rendered	render	VBN
18637	11301	21	by	by	IN
18637	11301	22	a	a	DT
18637	11301	23	divided	divide	VBN
18637	11301	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11301	25	over	over	IN
18637	11301	26	the	the	DT
18637	11301	27	strong	strong	JJ
18637	11301	28	protests	protest	NNS
18637	11301	29	of	of	IN
18637	11301	30	dissenters	dissenter	NNS
18637	11301	31	.	.	.
18637	11302	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11302	2	542	542	CD
18637	11302	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11302	4	In	in	IN
18637	11302	5	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	11302	6	and	and	CC
18637	11302	7	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	11302	8	R.	R.	NNP
18637	11302	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11302	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11302	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	11302	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11302	13	Baugh,[543	Baugh,[543	NNP
18637	11302	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11302	15	which	which	WDT
18637	11302	16	further	further	RB
18637	11302	17	projected	project	VBD
18637	11302	18	the	the	DT
18637	11302	19	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	11302	20	rule	rule	NN
18637	11302	21	into	into	IN
18637	11302	22	the	the	DT
18637	11302	23	law	law	NN
18637	11302	24	of	of	IN
18637	11302	25	torts	tort	NNS
18637	11302	26	in	in	IN
18637	11302	27	disregard	disregard	NN
18637	11302	28	of	of	IN
18637	11302	29	State	State	NNP
18637	11302	30	law	law	NN
18637	11302	31	,	,	,
18637	11302	32	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11302	33	Field	Field	NNP
18637	11302	34	wrote	write	VBD
18637	11302	35	a	a	DT
18637	11302	36	sharp	sharp	JJ
18637	11302	37	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11302	38	in	in	IN
18637	11302	39	which	which	WDT
18637	11302	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11302	41	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	11302	42	an	an	DT
18637	11302	43	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11302	44	that	that	IN
18637	11302	45	the	the	DT
18637	11302	46	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11302	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11302	48	's	's	POS
18637	11302	49	disregard	disregard	NN
18637	11302	50	of	of	IN
18637	11302	51	State	State	NNP
18637	11302	52	court	court	NN
18637	11302	53	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11302	54	was	be	VBD
18637	11302	55	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	11302	56	.	.	.
18637	11303	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	11303	2	disregard	disregard	NN
18637	11303	3	,	,	,
18637	11303	4	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	11303	5	,	,	,
18637	11303	6	was	be	VBD
18637	11303	7	further	further	RB
18637	11303	8	aggravated	aggravate	VBN
18637	11303	9	in	in	IN
18637	11303	10	Kuhn	Kuhn	NNP
18637	11303	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11303	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	11303	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11303	14	Fairmont	Fairmont	NNP
18637	11303	15	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	11303	16	Co	Co	NNP
18637	11303	17	.	.	.
18637	11303	18	,[544	,[544	NFP
18637	11303	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11303	20	where	where	WRB
18637	11303	21	the	the	DT
18637	11303	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11303	23	held	hold	VBD
18637	11303	24	that	that	IN
18637	11303	25	in	in	IN
18637	11303	26	construing	construe	VBG
18637	11303	27	a	a	DT
18637	11303	28	contract	contract	NN
18637	11303	29	in	in	IN
18637	11303	30	a	a	DT
18637	11303	31	case	case	NN
18637	11303	32	involving	involve	VBG
18637	11303	33	real	real	JJ
18637	11303	34	estate	estate	NN
18637	11303	35	and	and	CC
18637	11303	36	mining	mining	NN
18637	11303	37	law	law	NN
18637	11303	38	a	a	DT
18637	11303	39	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11303	40	court	court	NN
18637	11303	41	was	be	VBD
18637	11303	42	not	not	RB
18637	11303	43	bound	bind	VBN
18637	11303	44	by	by	IN
18637	11303	45	a	a	DT
18637	11303	46	West	West	NNP
18637	11303	47	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11303	48	decision	decision	NN
18637	11303	49	touching	touch	VBG
18637	11303	50	the	the	DT
18637	11303	51	same	same	JJ
18637	11303	52	subject	subject	NN
18637	11303	53	.	.	.
18637	11304	1	This	this	DT
18637	11304	2	evoked	evoke	VBD
18637	11304	3	a	a	DT
18637	11304	4	provocative	provocative	JJ
18637	11304	5	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11304	6	from	from	IN
18637	11304	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11304	8	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	11304	9	,	,	,
18637	11304	10	who	who	WP
18637	11304	11	later	later	RB
18637	11304	12	wrote	write	VBD
18637	11304	13	one	one	CD
18637	11304	14	of	of	IN
18637	11304	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11304	16	more	more	RBR
18637	11304	17	famous	famous	JJ
18637	11304	18	dissents	dissent	NNS
18637	11304	19	in	in	IN
18637	11304	20	the	the	DT
18637	11304	21	Black	Black	NNP
18637	11304	22	and	and	CC
18637	11304	23	White	White	NNP
18637	11304	24	Taxicab	Taxicab	NNPS
18637	11304	25	Company	Company	NNP
18637	11304	26	case,[545	case,[545	NN
18637	11304	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11304	28	in	in	IN
18637	11304	29	which	which	WDT
18637	11304	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11304	31	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	11304	32	emphatically	emphatically	RB
18637	11304	33	that	that	IN
18637	11304	34	the	the	DT
18637	11304	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11304	36	's	's	POS
18637	11304	37	extensions	extension	NNS
18637	11304	38	of	of	IN
18637	11304	39	the	the	DT
18637	11304	40	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	11304	41	rule	rule	NN
18637	11304	42	were	be	VBD
18637	11304	43	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	11304	44	.	.	.
18637	11305	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11305	2	546	546	CD
18637	11305	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11305	4	ERIE	ERIE	NNP
18637	11305	5	RAILROAD	RAILROAD	NNP
18637	11305	6	CO	CO	NNP
18637	11305	7	.	.	.
18637	11305	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11305	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	11305	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11305	11	TOMPKINS	TOMPKINS	NNPS
18637	11305	12	;	;	:
18637	11305	13	TYSON	tyson	NN
18637	11305	14	OVERRULED	overruled	NN
18637	11305	15	Increasing	increase	VBG
18637	11305	16	criticism	criticism	NN
18637	11305	17	of	of	IN
18637	11305	18	the	the	DT
18637	11305	19	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	11305	20	rule	rule	NN
18637	11305	21	led	lead	VBD
18637	11305	22	to	to	IN
18637	11305	23	a	a	DT
18637	11305	24	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	11305	25	of	of	IN
18637	11305	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11305	27	in	in	IN
18637	11305	28	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	11305	29	Life	Life	NNP
18637	11305	30	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	11305	31	.	.	.
18637	11306	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11306	2	_	_	NNP
18637	11306	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	11306	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11306	5	Johnson,[547	Johnson,[547	NNP
18637	11306	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11306	7	where	where	WRB
18637	11306	8	the	the	DT
18637	11306	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11306	10	chose	choose	VBD
18637	11306	11	to	to	TO
18637	11306	12	apply	apply	VB
18637	11306	13	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11306	14	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11306	15	rather	rather	RB
18637	11306	16	than	than	IN
18637	11306	17	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	11306	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11306	19	independent	independent	JJ
18637	11306	20	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11306	21	on	on	IN
18637	11306	22	the	the	DT
18637	11306	23	ground	ground	NN
18637	11306	24	that	that	IN
18637	11306	25	the	the	DT
18637	11306	26	case	case	NN
18637	11306	27	was	be	VBD
18637	11306	28	"	"	``
18637	11306	29	balanced	balanced	JJ
18637	11306	30	with	with	IN
18637	11306	31	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	11306	32	.	.	.
18637	11307	1	"	"	``
18637	11307	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11307	3	548	548	CD
18637	11307	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11307	5	The	the	DT
18637	11307	6	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11307	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11307	8	power	power	NN
18637	11307	9	was	be	VBD
18637	11307	10	subordinated	subordinate	VBN
18637	11307	11	to	to	IN
18637	11307	12	what	what	WP
18637	11307	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11307	14	Cardozo	Cardozo	NNP
18637	11307	15	called	call	VBD
18637	11307	16	"	"	``
18637	11307	17	a	a	DT
18637	11307	18	benign	benign	JJ
18637	11307	19	and	and	CC
18637	11307	20	prudent	prudent	JJ
18637	11307	21	comity	comity	NN
18637	11307	22	.	.	.
18637	11308	1	"	"	``
18637	11308	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11308	3	549	549	CD
18637	11308	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11308	5	Four	four	CD
18637	11308	6	years	year	NNS
18637	11308	7	later	later	RB
18637	11308	8	,	,	,
18637	11308	9	and	and	CC
18637	11308	10	without	without	IN
18637	11308	11	further	further	JJ
18637	11308	12	preparation	preparation	NN
18637	11308	13	other	other	JJ
18637	11308	14	than	than	IN
18637	11308	15	a	a	DT
18637	11308	16	change	change	NN
18637	11308	17	in	in	IN
18637	11308	18	two	two	CD
18637	11308	19	of	of	IN
18637	11308	20	the	the	DT
18637	11308	21	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	11308	22	,	,	,
18637	11308	23	the	the	DT
18637	11308	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11308	25	overturned	overturn	VBD
18637	11308	26	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	11308	27	_	_	NNP
18637	11308	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	11308	29	_	_	NNP
18637	11308	30	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	11308	31	and	and	CC
18637	11308	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11308	33	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11308	34	progeny	progeny	NN
18637	11308	35	in	in	IN
18637	11308	36	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	11308	37	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	11308	38	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11308	39	_	_	NNP
18637	11308	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	11308	41	_	_	NNP
18637	11308	42	Tompkins,[550	Tompkins,[550	NNP
18637	11308	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11308	44	in	in	IN
18637	11308	45	an	an	DT
18637	11308	46	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11308	47	by	by	IN
18637	11308	48	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11308	49	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	11308	50	which	which	WDT
18637	11308	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	11308	52	remarkable	remarkable	JJ
18637	11308	53	in	in	IN
18637	11308	54	a	a	DT
18637	11308	55	number	number	NN
18637	11308	56	of	of	IN
18637	11308	57	ways	way	NNS
18637	11308	58	.	.	.
18637	11309	1	In	in	IN
18637	11309	2	the	the	DT
18637	11309	3	first	first	JJ
18637	11309	4	place	place	NN
18637	11309	5	,	,	,
18637	11309	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11309	7	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	11309	8	a	a	DT
18637	11309	9	ninety	ninety	CD
18637	11309	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	11309	11	six	six	CD
18637	11309	12	year	year	NN
18637	11309	13	old	old	JJ
18637	11309	14	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	11309	15	which	which	WDT
18637	11309	16	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	11309	17	had	have	VBD
18637	11309	18	not	not	RB
18637	11309	19	questioned	question	VBN
18637	11309	20	;	;	:
18637	11309	21	secondly	secondly	RB
18637	11309	22	,	,	,
18637	11309	23	for	for	IN
18637	11309	24	the	the	DT
18637	11309	25	first	first	JJ
18637	11309	26	and	and	CC
18637	11309	27	only	only	JJ
18637	11309	28	time	time	NN
18637	11309	29	in	in	IN
18637	11309	30	American	american	JJ
18637	11309	31	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11309	32	history	history	NN
18637	11309	33	,	,	,
18637	11309	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11309	35	held	hold	VBD
18637	11309	36	action	action	NN
18637	11309	37	of	of	IN
18637	11309	38	the	the	DT
18637	11309	39	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11309	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11309	41	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11309	42	to	to	TO
18637	11309	43	have	have	VB
18637	11309	44	been	be	VBN
18637	11309	45	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	11309	46	,	,	,
18637	11309	47	to	to	IN
18637	11309	48	wit	wit	NN
18637	11309	49	,	,	,
18637	11309	50	action	action	NN
18637	11309	51	taken	take	VBN
18637	11309	52	by	by	IN
18637	11309	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11309	54	in	in	IN
18637	11309	55	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	11309	56	on	on	IN
18637	11309	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11309	58	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11309	59	of	of	IN
18637	11309	60	the	the	DT
18637	11309	61	34th	34th	JJ
18637	11309	62	section	section	NN
18637	11309	63	of	of	IN
18637	11309	64	the	the	DT
18637	11309	65	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11309	66	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11309	67	of	of	IN
18637	11309	68	1789	1789	CD
18637	11309	69	,	,	,
18637	11309	70	a	a	DT
18637	11309	71	question	question	NN
18637	11309	72	which	which	WDT
18637	11309	73	also	also	RB
18637	11309	74	was	be	VBD
18637	11309	75	not	not	RB
18637	11309	76	before	before	IN
18637	11309	77	the	the	DT
18637	11309	78	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11309	79	;	;	:
18637	11309	80	and	and	CC
18637	11309	81	thirdly	thirdly	RB
18637	11309	82	,	,	,
18637	11309	83	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11309	84	completely	completely	RB
18637	11309	85	ignored	ignore	VBD
18637	11309	86	the	the	DT
18637	11309	87	power	power	NN
18637	11309	88	of	of	IN
18637	11309	89	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11309	90	under	under	IN
18637	11309	91	the	the	DT
18637	11309	92	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	11309	93	clause	clause	NN
18637	11309	94	,	,	,
18637	11309	95	as	as	RB
18637	11309	96	well	well	RB
18637	11309	97	as	as	IN
18637	11309	98	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11309	99	power	power	NN
18637	11309	100	to	to	TO
18637	11309	101	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	11309	102	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11309	103	of	of	IN
18637	11309	104	decision	decision	NN
18637	11309	105	for	for	IN
18637	11309	106	the	the	DT
18637	11309	107	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11309	108	courts	court	NNS
18637	11309	109	in	in	IN
18637	11309	110	the	the	DT
18637	11309	111	cases	case	NNS
18637	11309	112	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	11309	113	in	in	IN
18637	11309	114	article	article	NN
18637	11309	115	III	iii	CD
18637	11309	116	.	.	.
18637	11310	1	Like	like	IN
18637	11310	2	the	the	DT
18637	11310	3	Fairmont	Fairmont	NNP
18637	11310	4	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	11310	5	and	and	CC
18637	11310	6	Taxicab	Taxicab	NNP
18637	11310	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	11310	8	,	,	,
18637	11310	9	the	the	DT
18637	11310	10	Tompkins	Tompkins	NNP
18637	11310	11	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11310	12	presented	present	VBD
18637	11310	13	the	the	DT
18637	11310	14	possibility	possibility	NN
18637	11310	15	of	of	IN
18637	11310	16	a	a	DT
18637	11310	17	head	head	NN
18637	11310	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	11310	19	on	on	RP
18637	11310	20	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	11310	21	between	between	IN
18637	11310	22	State	State	NNP
18637	11310	23	and	and	CC
18637	11310	24	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11310	25	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11310	26	of	of	IN
18637	11310	27	decision	decision	NN
18637	11310	28	.	.	.
18637	11311	1	Tompkins	tompkin	NNS
18637	11311	2	was	be	VBD
18637	11311	3	seriously	seriously	RB
18637	11311	4	injured	injure	VBN
18637	11311	5	by	by	IN
18637	11311	6	a	a	DT
18637	11311	7	passing	pass	VBG
18637	11311	8	freight	freight	NN
18637	11311	9	train	train	NN
18637	11311	10	while	while	IN
18637	11311	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11311	12	was	be	VBD
18637	11311	13	walking	walk	VBG
18637	11311	14	along	along	IN
18637	11311	15	the	the	DT
18637	11311	16	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	11311	17	's	's	POS
18637	11311	18	right	right	NN
18637	11311	19	of	of	IN
18637	11311	20	way	way	NN
18637	11311	21	in	in	IN
18637	11311	22	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	11311	23	.	.	.
18637	11312	1	As	as	IN
18637	11312	2	a	a	DT
18637	11312	3	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11312	4	of	of	IN
18637	11312	5	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	11312	6	,	,	,
18637	11312	7	Tompkins	Tompkins	NNP
18637	11312	8	could	could	MD
18637	11312	9	have	have	VB
18637	11312	10	sued	sue	VBN
18637	11312	11	in	in	IN
18637	11312	12	that	that	DT
18637	11312	13	State	state	NN
18637	11312	14	,	,	,
18637	11312	15	but	but	CC
18637	11312	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11312	17	could	could	MD
18637	11312	18	also	also	RB
18637	11312	19	have	have	VB
18637	11312	20	sued	sue	VBN
18637	11312	21	in	in	IN
18637	11312	22	the	the	DT
18637	11312	23	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11312	24	district	district	NN
18637	11312	25	court	court	NN
18637	11312	26	in	in	IN
18637	11312	27	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	11312	28	,	,	,
18637	11312	29	or	or	CC
18637	11312	30	in	in	IN
18637	11312	31	New	New	NNP
18637	11312	32	York	York	NNP
18637	11312	33	because	because	IN
18637	11312	34	the	the	DT
18637	11312	35	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	11312	36	was	be	VBD
18637	11312	37	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	11312	38	in	in	IN
18637	11312	39	the	the	DT
18637	11312	40	latter	latter	JJ
18637	11312	41	State	State	NNP
18637	11312	42	.	.	.
18637	11313	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11313	2	elected	elect	VBD
18637	11313	3	to	to	TO
18637	11313	4	sue	sue	VB
18637	11313	5	in	in	IN
18637	11313	6	the	the	DT
18637	11313	7	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11313	8	court	court	NN
18637	11313	9	for	for	IN
18637	11313	10	the	the	DT
18637	11313	11	southern	southern	JJ
18637	11313	12	district	district	NN
18637	11313	13	of	of	IN
18637	11313	14	New	New	NNP
18637	11313	15	York	York	NNP
18637	11313	16	,	,	,
18637	11313	17	where	where	WRB
18637	11313	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11313	19	obtained	obtain	VBD
18637	11313	20	a	a	DT
18637	11313	21	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	11313	22	for	for	IN
18637	11313	23	$	$	$
18637	11313	24	30,000	30,000	CD
18637	11313	25	after	after	IN
18637	11313	26	the	the	DT
18637	11313	27	trial	trial	NN
18637	11313	28	judge	judge	NN
18637	11313	29	had	have	VBD
18637	11313	30	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	11313	31	that	that	IN
18637	11313	32	the	the	DT
18637	11313	33	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	11313	34	law	law	NN
18637	11313	35	did	do	VBD
18637	11313	36	not	not	RB
18637	11313	37	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	11313	38	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	11313	39	.	.	.
18637	11314	1	The	the	DT
18637	11314	2	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	11314	3	court	court	NN
18637	11314	4	of	of	IN
18637	11314	5	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	11314	6	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	11314	7	the	the	DT
18637	11314	8	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11314	9	because	because	IN
18637	11314	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11314	11	thought	think	VBD
18637	11314	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11314	13	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	11314	14	to	to	TO
18637	11314	15	consider	consider	VB
18637	11314	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	11314	17	the	the	DT
18637	11314	18	law	law	NN
18637	11314	19	of	of	IN
18637	11314	20	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	11314	21	precluded	preclude	VBD
18637	11314	22	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	11314	23	,	,	,
18637	11314	24	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	11314	25	as	as	IN
18637	11314	26	the	the	DT
18637	11314	27	question	question	NN
18637	11314	28	was	be	VBD
18637	11314	29	one	one	CD
18637	11314	30	of	of	IN
18637	11314	31	general	general	JJ
18637	11314	32	law	law	NN
18637	11314	33	to	to	TO
18637	11314	34	be	be	VB
18637	11314	35	decided	decide	VBN
18637	11314	36	by	by	IN
18637	11314	37	the	the	DT
18637	11314	38	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11314	39	courts	court	NNS
18637	11314	40	in	in	IN
18637	11314	41	the	the	DT
18637	11314	42	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11314	43	of	of	IN
18637	11314	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11314	45	independent	independent	JJ
18637	11314	46	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11314	47	.	.	.
18637	11315	1	Citing	cite	VBG
18637	11315	2	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	11315	3	's	's	POS
18637	11315	4	discovery	discovery	NN
18637	11315	5	that	that	IN
18637	11315	6	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	11315	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11315	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11315	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11315	10	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	11315	11	was	be	VBD
18637	11315	12	an	an	DT
18637	11315	13	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
18637	11315	14	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11315	15	of	of	IN
18637	11315	16	the	the	DT
18637	11315	17	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11315	18	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11315	19	of	of	IN
18637	11315	20	1789	1789	CD
18637	11315	21	,	,	,
18637	11315	22	criticism	criticism	NN
18637	11315	23	of	of	IN
18637	11315	24	the	the	DT
18637	11315	25	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	11315	26	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	11315	27	both	both	DT
18637	11315	28	on	on	IN
18637	11315	29	and	and	CC
18637	11315	30	off	off	IN
18637	11315	31	the	the	DT
18637	11315	32	bench	bench	NN
18637	11315	33	,	,	,
18637	11315	34	and	and	CC
18637	11315	35	the	the	DT
18637	11315	36	political	political	JJ
18637	11315	37	and	and	CC
18637	11315	38	social	social	JJ
18637	11315	39	defects	defect	NNS
18637	11315	40	of	of	IN
18637	11315	41	the	the	DT
18637	11315	42	rule	rule	NN
18637	11315	43	in	in	IN
18637	11315	44	working	work	VBG
18637	11315	45	discriminations	discrimination	NNS
18637	11315	46	against	against	IN
18637	11315	47	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11315	48	of	of	IN
18637	11315	49	a	a	DT
18637	11315	50	State	state	NN
18637	11315	51	in	in	IN
18637	11315	52	favor	favor	NN
18637	11315	53	of	of	IN
18637	11315	54	noncitizens	noncitizen	NNS
18637	11315	55	and	and	CC
18637	11315	56	in	in	IN
18637	11315	57	producing	produce	VBG
18637	11315	58	injustice	injustice	NN
18637	11315	59	and	and	CC
18637	11315	60	confusion	confusion	NN
18637	11315	61	,	,	,
18637	11315	62	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11315	63	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	11315	64	declared	declare	VBD
18637	11315	65	:	:	:
18637	11315	66	"	"	``
18637	11315	67	If	if	IN
18637	11315	68	only	only	RB
18637	11315	69	a	a	DT
18637	11315	70	question	question	NN
18637	11315	71	of	of	IN
18637	11315	72	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	11315	73	construction	construction	NN
18637	11315	74	were	be	VBD
18637	11315	75	involved	involve	VBN
18637	11315	76	,	,	,
18637	11315	77	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11315	78	should	should	MD
18637	11315	79	not	not	RB
18637	11315	80	be	be	VB
18637	11315	81	prepared	prepared	JJ
18637	11315	82	to	to	TO
18637	11315	83	abandon	abandon	VB
18637	11315	84	a	a	DT
18637	11315	85	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	11315	86	so	so	RB
18637	11315	87	widely	widely	RB
18637	11315	88	*	*	NFP
18637	11315	89	*	*	NFP
18637	11315	90	*	*	NFP
18637	11315	91	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11315	92	followed	follow	VBN
18637	11315	93	for	for	IN
18637	11315	94	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11315	95	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	11315	96	a	a	DT
18637	11315	97	century	century	NN
18637	11315	98	.	.	.
18637	11316	1	But	but	CC
18637	11316	2	the	the	DT
18637	11316	3	unconstitutionality	unconstitutionality	NN
18637	11316	4	of	of	IN
18637	11316	5	the	the	DT
18637	11316	6	course	course	NN
18637	11316	7	pursued	pursue	VBN
18637	11316	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	11316	9	now	now	RB
18637	11316	10	been	be	VBN
18637	11316	11	made	make	VBN
18637	11316	12	clear	clear	JJ
18637	11316	13	and	and	CC
18637	11316	14	compels	compel	VBZ
18637	11316	15	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11316	16	to	to	TO
18637	11316	17	do	do	VB
18637	11316	18	so	so	RB
18637	11316	19	.	.	.
18637	11317	1	*	*	NFP
18637	11317	2	*	*	NFP
18637	11317	3	*	*	NFP
18637	11317	4	There	there	EX
18637	11317	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	11317	6	,	,	,
18637	11317	7	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11317	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11317	9	continued	continue	VBD
18637	11317	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11317	11	,	,	,
18637	11317	12	no	no	DT
18637	11317	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11317	14	general	general	JJ
18637	11317	15	common	common	JJ
18637	11317	16	law	law	NN
18637	11317	17	.	.	.
18637	11318	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11318	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	11318	3	no	no	DT
18637	11318	4	power	power	NN
18637	11318	5	to	to	TO
18637	11318	6	declare	declare	VB
18637	11318	7	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	11318	8	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11318	9	of	of	IN
18637	11318	10	common	common	JJ
18637	11318	11	law	law	NN
18637	11318	12	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	11318	13	in	in	IN
18637	11318	14	a	a	DT
18637	11318	15	State	State	NNP
18637	11318	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	11318	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11318	18	be	be	VBP
18637	11318	19	local	local	JJ
18637	11318	20	in	in	IN
18637	11318	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11318	22	nature	nature	NN
18637	11318	23	or	or	CC
18637	11318	24	'	'	``
18637	11318	25	general	general	JJ
18637	11318	26	,	,	,
18637	11318	27	'	'	''
18637	11318	28	be	be	VB
18637	11318	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11318	30	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	11318	31	law	law	NN
18637	11318	32	or	or	CC
18637	11318	33	a	a	DT
18637	11318	34	part	part	NN
18637	11318	35	of	of	IN
18637	11318	36	the	the	DT
18637	11318	37	law	law	NN
18637	11318	38	of	of	IN
18637	11318	39	torts	tort	NNS
18637	11318	40	.	.	.
18637	11319	1	And	and	CC
18637	11319	2	no	no	DT
18637	11319	3	clause	clause	NN
18637	11319	4	in	in	IN
18637	11319	5	the	the	DT
18637	11319	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11319	7	purports	purport	VBZ
18637	11319	8	to	to	TO
18637	11319	9	confer	confer	VB
18637	11319	10	such	such	PDT
18637	11319	11	a	a	DT
18637	11319	12	power	power	NN
18637	11319	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	11319	14	the	the	DT
18637	11319	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11319	16	courts	court	NNS
18637	11319	17	.	.	.
18637	11320	1	"	"	``
18637	11320	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11320	3	551	551	CD
18637	11320	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11320	5	After	after	IN
18637	11320	6	quoting	quote	VBG
18637	11320	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11320	8	Field	Field	NNP
18637	11320	9	and	and	CC
18637	11320	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11320	11	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	11320	12	on	on	IN
18637	11320	13	the	the	DT
18637	11320	14	unconstitutionality	unconstitutionality	NN
18637	11320	15	of	of	IN
18637	11320	16	the	the	DT
18637	11320	17	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	11320	18	rule	rule	NN
18637	11320	19	,	,	,
18637	11320	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11320	21	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	11320	22	made	make	VBD
18637	11320	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11320	24	clear	clear	JJ
18637	11320	25	that	that	IN
18637	11320	26	the	the	DT
18637	11320	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11320	28	was	be	VBD
18637	11320	29	not	not	RB
18637	11320	30	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
18637	11320	31	§	§	NNP
18637	11320	32	34	34	CD
18637	11320	33	of	of	IN
18637	11320	34	the	the	DT
18637	11320	35	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11320	36	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11320	37	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11320	38	of	of	IN
18637	11320	39	1789	1789	CD
18637	11320	40	,	,	,
18637	11320	41	but	but	CC
18637	11320	42	was	be	VBD
18637	11320	43	merely	merely	RB
18637	11320	44	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	11320	45	that	that	IN
18637	11320	46	the	the	DT
18637	11320	47	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11320	48	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11320	49	and	and	CC
18637	11320	50	the	the	DT
18637	11320	51	lower	low	JJR
18637	11320	52	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11320	53	courts	court	NNS
18637	11320	54	had	have	VBD
18637	11320	55	,	,	,
18637	11320	56	in	in	IN
18637	11320	57	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11320	58	application	application	NN
18637	11320	59	of	of	IN
18637	11320	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11320	61	,	,	,
18637	11320	62	"	"	''
18637	11320	63	invaded	invade	VBN
18637	11320	64	rights	right	NNS
18637	11320	65	which	which	WDT
18637	11320	66	*	*	NFP
18637	11320	67	*	*	NFP
18637	11320	68	*	*	NFP
18637	11320	69	are	be	VBP
18637	11320	70	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	11320	71	by	by	IN
18637	11320	72	the	the	DT
18637	11320	73	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11320	74	to	to	IN
18637	11320	75	the	the	DT
18637	11320	76	several	several	JJ
18637	11320	77	States	state	NNS
18637	11320	78	.	.	.
18637	11321	1	"	"	``
18637	11321	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11321	3	552	552	CD
18637	11321	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11321	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11321	6	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	11321	7	,	,	,
18637	11321	8	joined	join	VBN
18637	11321	9	by	by	IN
18637	11321	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11321	11	McReynolds	McReynolds	NNP
18637	11321	12	,	,	,
18637	11321	13	concurred	concur	VBN
18637	11321	14	in	in	IN
18637	11321	15	the	the	DT
18637	11321	16	result	result	NN
18637	11321	17	,	,	,
18637	11321	18	because	because	IN
18637	11321	19	in	in	IN
18637	11321	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11321	21	view	view	NN
18637	11321	22	Tompkins	Tompkins	NNP
18637	11321	23	was	be	VBD
18637	11321	24	not	not	RB
18637	11321	25	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	11321	26	to	to	IN
18637	11321	27	damages	damage	NNS
18637	11321	28	under	under	IN
18637	11321	29	general	general	JJ
18637	11321	30	law	law	NN
18637	11321	31	,	,	,
18637	11321	32	but	but	CC
18637	11321	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11321	34	deprecated	deprecate	VBD
18637	11321	35	the	the	DT
18637	11321	36	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	11321	37	of	of	IN
18637	11321	38	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	11321	39	_	_	NNP
18637	11321	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	11321	41	_	_	NNP
18637	11321	42	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	11321	43	.	.	.
18637	11322	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11322	2	also	also	RB
18637	11322	3	objected	object	VBD
18637	11322	4	to	to	IN
18637	11322	5	the	the	DT
18637	11322	6	decision	decision	NN
18637	11322	7	of	of	IN
18637	11322	8	the	the	DT
18637	11322	9	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11322	10	issue	issue	NN
18637	11322	11	as	as	IN
18637	11322	12	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	11322	13	.	.	.
18637	11323	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11323	2	553	553	CD
18637	11323	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11323	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11323	5	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	11323	6	likewise	likewise	RB
18637	11323	7	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	11323	8	,	,	,
18637	11323	9	but	but	CC
18637	11323	10	thought	think	VBD
18637	11323	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11323	12	questionable	questionable	JJ
18637	11323	13	to	to	TO
18637	11323	14	raise	raise	VB
18637	11323	15	the	the	DT
18637	11323	16	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11323	17	issue	issue	NN
18637	11323	18	.	.	.
18637	11324	1	"	"	``
18637	11324	2	If	if	IN
18637	11324	3	the	the	DT
18637	11324	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11324	5	,	,	,
18637	11324	6	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11324	7	said	say	VBD
18637	11324	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11324	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11324	10	,	,	,
18637	11324	11	commits	commit	VBZ
18637	11324	12	this	this	DT
18637	11324	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11324	14	to	to	IN
18637	11324	15	the	the	DT
18637	11324	16	position	position	NN
18637	11324	17	that	that	IN
18637	11324	18	the	the	DT
18637	11324	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11324	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	11324	21	without	without	IN
18637	11324	22	power	power	NN
18637	11324	23	to	to	TO
18637	11324	24	declare	declare	VB
18637	11324	25	what	what	WP
18637	11324	26	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11324	27	of	of	IN
18637	11324	28	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	11324	29	law	law	NN
18637	11324	30	shall	shall	MD
18637	11324	31	govern	govern	VB
18637	11324	32	the	the	DT
18637	11324	33	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11324	34	courts	court	NNS
18637	11324	35	,	,	,
18637	11324	36	that	that	DT
18637	11324	37	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	11324	38	also	also	RB
18637	11324	39	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	11324	40	questionable	questionable	JJ
18637	11324	41	.	.	.
18637	11325	1	"	"	``
18637	11325	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11325	3	554	554	CD
18637	11325	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11325	5	Extension	extension	NN
18637	11325	6	of	of	IN
18637	11325	7	the	the	DT
18637	11325	8	Tompkins	Tompkins	NNP
18637	11325	9	Rule	Rule	NNP
18637	11325	10	Since	since	IN
18637	11325	11	1938	1938	CD
18637	11325	12	the	the	DT
18637	11325	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11325	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	11325	15	have	have	VBP
18637	11325	16	been	be	VBN
18637	11325	17	most	most	RBS
18637	11325	18	assiduous	assiduous	JJ
18637	11325	19	in	in	IN
18637	11325	20	following	follow	VBG
18637	11325	21	the	the	DT
18637	11325	22	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11325	23	of	of	IN
18637	11325	24	the	the	DT
18637	11325	25	State	State	NNP
18637	11325	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	11325	27	in	in	IN
18637	11325	28	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11325	29	cases	case	NNS
18637	11325	30	.	.	.
18637	11326	1	The	the	DT
18637	11326	2	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11326	3	followed	follow	VBD
18637	11326	4	,	,	,
18637	11326	5	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	11326	6	,	,	,
18637	11326	7	include	include	VBP
18637	11326	8	not	not	RB
18637	11326	9	only	only	RB
18637	11326	10	those	those	DT
18637	11326	11	of	of	IN
18637	11326	12	the	the	DT
18637	11326	13	highest	high	JJS
18637	11326	14	State	State	NNP
18637	11326	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	11326	16	,	,	,
18637	11326	17	but	but	CC
18637	11326	18	those	those	DT
18637	11326	19	also	also	RB
18637	11326	20	of	of	IN
18637	11326	21	intermediate	intermediate	JJ
18637	11326	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	11326	23	.	.	.
18637	11327	1	In	in	IN
18637	11327	2	West	West	NNP
18637	11327	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11327	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	11327	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11327	6	American	American	NNP
18637	11327	7	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	11327	8	and	and	CC
18637	11327	9	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	11327	10	Co.[555	Co.[555	NNP
18637	11327	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11327	12	the	the	DT
18637	11327	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11327	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11327	15	held	hold	VBD
18637	11327	16	that	that	IN
18637	11327	17	a	a	DT
18637	11327	18	decision	decision	NN
18637	11327	19	of	of	IN
18637	11327	20	an	an	DT
18637	11327	21	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	11327	22	county	county	NN
18637	11327	23	court	court	NN
18637	11327	24	of	of	IN
18637	11327	25	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	11327	26	which	which	WDT
18637	11327	27	the	the	DT
18637	11327	28	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11327	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11327	30	of	of	IN
18637	11327	31	the	the	DT
18637	11327	32	State	State	NNP
18637	11327	33	had	have	VBD
18637	11327	34	declined	decline	VBN
18637	11327	35	to	to	TO
18637	11327	36	review	review	VB
18637	11327	37	was	be	VBD
18637	11327	38	binding	bind	VBG
18637	11327	39	on	on	IN
18637	11327	40	the	the	DT
18637	11327	41	lower	low	JJR
18637	11327	42	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11327	43	courts	court	NNS
18637	11327	44	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	11327	45	of	of	IN
18637	11327	46	the	the	DT
18637	11327	47	desirability	desirability	NN
18637	11327	48	of	of	IN
18637	11327	49	the	the	DT
18637	11327	50	rule	rule	NN
18637	11327	51	of	of	IN
18637	11327	52	the	the	DT
18637	11327	53	decision	decision	NN
18637	11327	54	or	or	CC
18637	11327	55	of	of	IN
18637	11327	56	the	the	DT
18637	11327	57	belief	belief	NN
18637	11327	58	that	that	IN
18637	11327	59	the	the	DT
18637	11327	60	highest	high	JJS
18637	11327	61	court	court	NN
18637	11327	62	of	of	IN
18637	11327	63	the	the	DT
18637	11327	64	State	State	NNP
18637	11327	65	might	may	MD
18637	11327	66	establish	establish	VB
18637	11327	67	a	a	DT
18637	11327	68	different	different	JJ
18637	11327	69	rule	rule	NN
18637	11327	70	in	in	IN
18637	11327	71	future	future	JJ
18637	11327	72	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	11327	73	.	.	.
18637	11328	1	In	in	IN
18637	11328	2	Fidelity	Fidelity	NNP
18637	11328	3	Union	Union	NNP
18637	11328	4	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	11328	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11328	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11328	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	11328	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11328	9	Field[556	Field[556	NNP
18637	11328	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11328	11	the	the	DT
18637	11328	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11328	13	went	go	VBD
18637	11328	14	even	even	RB
18637	11328	15	farther	farther	RB
18637	11328	16	and	and	CC
18637	11328	17	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	11328	18	that	that	IN
18637	11328	19	the	the	DT
18637	11328	20	lower	low	JJR
18637	11328	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	11328	22	were	be	VBD
18637	11328	23	bound	bind	VBN
18637	11328	24	to	to	TO
18637	11328	25	follow	follow	VB
18637	11328	26	the	the	DT
18637	11328	27	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11328	28	of	of	IN
18637	11328	29	two	two	CD
18637	11328	30	chancery	chancery	NN
18637	11328	31	courts	court	NNS
18637	11328	32	in	in	IN
18637	11328	33	New	New	NNP
18637	11328	34	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	11328	35	although	although	IN
18637	11328	36	there	there	EX
18637	11328	37	had	have	VBD
18637	11328	38	been	be	VBN
18637	11328	39	no	no	DT
18637	11328	40	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	11328	41	to	to	IN
18637	11328	42	the	the	DT
18637	11328	43	highest	high	JJS
18637	11328	44	State	State	NNP
18637	11328	45	court	court	NN
18637	11328	46	,	,	,
18637	11328	47	and	and	CC
18637	11328	48	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	11328	49	other	other	JJ
18637	11328	50	New	New	NNP
18637	11328	51	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	11328	52	courts	court	NNS
18637	11328	53	were	be	VBD
18637	11328	54	not	not	RB
18637	11328	55	bound	bind	VBN
18637	11328	56	by	by	IN
18637	11328	57	the	the	DT
18637	11328	58	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11328	59	of	of	IN
18637	11328	60	two	two	CD
18637	11328	61	vice	vice	NN
18637	11328	62	-	-	HYPH
18637	11328	63	chancellors	chancellor	NNS
18637	11328	64	.	.	.
18637	11329	1	The	the	DT
18637	11329	2	anomaly	anomaly	JJ
18637	11329	3	of	of	IN
18637	11329	4	this	this	DT
18637	11329	5	decision	decision	NN
18637	11329	6	was	be	VBD
18637	11329	7	partially	partially	RB
18637	11329	8	removed	remove	VBN
18637	11329	9	in	in	IN
18637	11329	10	King	King	NNP
18637	11329	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11329	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	11329	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11329	14	Order	Order	NNP
18637	11329	15	of	of	IN
18637	11329	16	United	United	NNP
18637	11329	17	Commercial	Commercial	NNP
18637	11329	18	Travelers,[557	Travelers,[557	NNP
18637	11329	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11329	20	where	where	WRB
18637	11329	21	the	the	DT
18637	11329	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11329	23	held	hold	VBD
18637	11329	24	that	that	IN
18637	11329	25	the	the	DT
18637	11329	26	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11329	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	11329	28	were	be	VBD
18637	11329	29	not	not	RB
18637	11329	30	bound	bind	VBN
18637	11329	31	by	by	IN
18637	11329	32	the	the	DT
18637	11329	33	decision	decision	NN
18637	11329	34	of	of	IN
18637	11329	35	a	a	DT
18637	11329	36	court	court	NN
18637	11329	37	of	of	IN
18637	11329	38	first	first	JJ
18637	11329	39	instance	instance	NN
18637	11329	40	of	of	IN
18637	11329	41	South	South	NNP
18637	11329	42	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	11329	43	,	,	,
18637	11329	44	which	which	WDT
18637	11329	45	was	be	VBD
18637	11329	46	the	the	DT
18637	11329	47	only	only	JJ
18637	11329	48	decision	decision	NN
18637	11329	49	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	11329	50	to	to	IN
18637	11329	51	the	the	DT
18637	11329	52	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11329	53	of	of	IN
18637	11329	54	the	the	DT
18637	11329	55	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	11329	56	policy	policy	NN
18637	11329	57	in	in	IN
18637	11329	58	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	11329	59	.	.	.
18637	11330	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	11330	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	11330	3	this	this	DT
18637	11330	4	the	the	DT
18637	11330	5	whole	whole	JJ
18637	11330	6	story	story	NN
18637	11330	7	.	.	.
18637	11331	1	In	in	IN
18637	11331	2	the	the	DT
18637	11331	3	event	event	NN
18637	11331	4	of	of	IN
18637	11331	5	a	a	DT
18637	11331	6	State	State	NNP
18637	11331	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11331	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11331	9	's	's	POS
18637	11331	10	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	11331	11	of	of	IN
18637	11331	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11331	13	earlier	early	JJR
18637	11331	14	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11331	15	the	the	DT
18637	11331	16	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11331	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	11331	18	are	be	VBP
18637	11331	19	bound	bind	VBN
18637	11331	20	by	by	IN
18637	11331	21	the	the	DT
18637	11331	22	latest	late	JJS
18637	11331	23	decision	decision	NN
18637	11331	24	.	.	.
18637	11332	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	11332	2	a	a	DT
18637	11332	3	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11332	4	of	of	IN
18637	11332	5	a	a	DT
18637	11332	6	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11332	7	district	district	NN
18637	11332	8	court	court	NN
18637	11332	9	,	,	,
18637	11332	10	correctly	correctly	RB
18637	11332	11	applying	apply	VBG
18637	11332	12	State	State	NNP
18637	11332	13	law	law	NN
18637	11332	14	as	as	IN
18637	11332	15	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	11332	16	by	by	IN
18637	11332	17	the	the	DT
18637	11332	18	State	State	NNP
18637	11332	19	's	's	POS
18637	11332	20	highest	high	JJS
18637	11332	21	court	court	NN
18637	11332	22	,	,	,
18637	11332	23	must	must	MD
18637	11332	24	be	be	VB
18637	11332	25	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	11332	26	on	on	IN
18637	11332	27	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	11332	28	if	if	IN
18637	11332	29	the	the	DT
18637	11332	30	State	State	NNP
18637	11332	31	court	court	NN
18637	11332	32	in	in	IN
18637	11332	33	the	the	DT
18637	11332	34	meantime	meantime	NN
18637	11332	35	has	have	VBZ
18637	11332	36	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	11332	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11332	38	earlier	early	JJR
18637	11332	39	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	11332	40	and	and	CC
18637	11332	41	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	11332	42	a	a	DT
18637	11332	43	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	11332	44	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11332	45	.	.	.
18637	11333	1	Though	though	IN
18637	11333	2	aware	aware	JJ
18637	11333	3	of	of	IN
18637	11333	4	possible	possible	JJ
18637	11333	5	complications	complication	NNS
18637	11333	6	from	from	IN
18637	11333	7	this	this	DT
18637	11333	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	11333	9	,	,	,
18637	11333	10	the	the	DT
18637	11333	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11333	12	insisted	insist	VBD
18637	11333	13	that	that	IN
18637	11333	14	"	"	``
18637	11333	15	until	until	IN
18637	11333	16	such	such	JJ
18637	11333	17	time	time	NN
18637	11333	18	as	as	IN
18637	11333	19	a	a	DT
18637	11333	20	case	case	NN
18637	11333	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	11333	22	no	no	RB
18637	11333	23	longer	long	RBR
18637	11333	24	_	_	NNP
18637	11333	25	sub	sub	NN
18637	11333	26	judice	judice	NN
18637	11333	27	_	_	NNP
18637	11333	28	,	,	,
18637	11333	29	the	the	DT
18637	11333	30	duty	duty	NN
18637	11333	31	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	11333	32	upon	upon	IN
18637	11333	33	the	the	DT
18637	11333	34	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11333	35	courts	court	NNS
18637	11333	36	to	to	TO
18637	11333	37	apply	apply	VB
18637	11333	38	the	the	DT
18637	11333	39	Rules	Rules	NNPS
18637	11333	40	of	of	IN
18637	11333	41	Decision	Decision	NNP
18637	11333	42	statute	statute	NN
18637	11333	43	in	in	IN
18637	11333	44	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	11333	45	with	with	IN
18637	11333	46	the	the	DT
18637	11333	47	then	then	RB
18637	11333	48	controlling	control	VBG
18637	11333	49	decision	decision	NN
18637	11333	50	of	of	IN
18637	11333	51	the	the	DT
18637	11333	52	highest	high	JJS
18637	11333	53	state	state	NN
18637	11333	54	court	court	NN
18637	11333	55	.	.	.
18637	11334	1	"	"	``
18637	11334	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11334	3	558	558	CD
18637	11334	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11334	5	Although	although	IN
18637	11334	6	the	the	DT
18637	11334	7	Rules	Rules	NNPS
18637	11334	8	of	of	IN
18637	11334	9	Decision	Decision	NNP
18637	11334	10	Act[559	Act[559	''
18637	11334	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11334	12	requires	require	VBZ
18637	11334	13	the	the	DT
18637	11334	14	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11334	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	11334	16	to	to	TO
18637	11334	17	follow	follow	VB
18637	11334	18	State	state	NN
18637	11334	19	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11334	20	only	only	RB
18637	11334	21	in	in	IN
18637	11334	22	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11334	23	cases	case	NNS
18637	11334	24	,	,	,
18637	11334	25	the	the	DT
18637	11334	26	application	application	NN
18637	11334	27	of	of	IN
18637	11334	28	the	the	DT
18637	11334	29	Tompkins	Tompkins	NNP
18637	11334	30	rule	rule	NN
18637	11334	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	11334	32	been	be	VBN
18637	11334	33	extended	extend	VBN
18637	11334	34	to	to	IN
18637	11334	35	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11334	36	in	in	IN
18637	11334	37	equity	equity	NN
18637	11334	38	.	.	.
18637	11335	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11335	2	560	560	CD
18637	11335	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11335	4	In	in	IN
18637	11335	5	Guaranty	Guaranty	NNP
18637	11335	6	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	11335	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11335	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11335	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	11335	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11335	11	York,[561	York,[561	NNP
18637	11335	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11335	13	the	the	DT
18637	11335	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11335	15	held	hold	VBD
18637	11335	16	that	that	IN
18637	11335	17	when	when	WRB
18637	11335	18	a	a	DT
18637	11335	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	11335	20	of	of	IN
18637	11335	21	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	11335	22	barred	bar	VBD
18637	11335	23	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	11335	24	in	in	IN
18637	11335	25	a	a	DT
18637	11335	26	State	State	NNP
18637	11335	27	court	court	NN
18637	11335	28	,	,	,
18637	11335	29	a	a	DT
18637	11335	30	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11335	31	court	court	NN
18637	11335	32	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	11335	33	in	in	IN
18637	11335	34	equity	equity	NN
18637	11335	35	could	could	MD
18637	11335	36	not	not	RB
18637	11335	37	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	11335	38	the	the	DT
18637	11335	39	suit	suit	NN
18637	11335	40	because	because	IN
18637	11335	41	of	of	IN
18637	11335	42	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11335	43	of	of	IN
18637	11335	44	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11335	45	.	.	.
18637	11336	1	This	this	DT
18637	11336	2	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	11336	3	was	be	VBD
18637	11336	4	based	base	VBN
18637	11336	5	on	on	IN
18637	11336	6	the	the	DT
18637	11336	7	express	express	JJ
18637	11336	8	premise	premise	NN
18637	11336	9	that	that	IN
18637	11336	10	"	"	``
18637	11336	11	a	a	DT
18637	11336	12	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11336	13	court	court	NN
18637	11336	14	adjudicating	adjudicate	VBG
18637	11336	15	a	a	DT
18637	11336	16	State	state	NN
18637	11336	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	11336	18	created	create	VBN
18637	11336	19	right	right	RB
18637	11336	20	solely	solely	RB
18637	11336	21	because	because	IN
18637	11336	22	of	of	IN
18637	11336	23	the	the	DT
18637	11336	24	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11336	25	of	of	IN
18637	11336	26	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11336	27	of	of	IN
18637	11336	28	the	the	DT
18637	11336	29	parties	party	NNS
18637	11336	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	11336	31	for	for	IN
18637	11336	32	that	that	DT
18637	11336	33	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	11336	34	,	,	,
18637	11336	35	in	in	IN
18637	11336	36	effect	effect	NN
18637	11336	37	,	,	,
18637	11336	38	only	only	RB
18637	11336	39	another	another	DT
18637	11336	40	court	court	NN
18637	11336	41	of	of	IN
18637	11336	42	the	the	DT
18637	11336	43	State	State	NNP
18637	11336	44	,	,	,
18637	11336	45	*	*	NFP
18637	11336	46	*	*	NFP
18637	11336	47	*	*	NFP
18637	11336	48	"	"	''
18637	11336	49	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11336	50	562	562	CD
18637	11336	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11336	52	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11336	53	was	be	VBD
18637	11336	54	held	hold	VBN
18637	11336	55	to	to	TO
18637	11336	56	be	be	VB
18637	11336	57	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
18637	11336	58	,	,	,
18637	11336	59	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11336	60	,	,	,
18637	11336	61	whether	whether	IN
18637	11336	62	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	11336	63	of	of	IN
18637	11336	64	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	11336	65	were	be	VBD
18637	11336	66	designated	designate	VBN
18637	11336	67	as	as	IN
18637	11336	68	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	11336	69	or	or	CC
18637	11336	70	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	11336	71	.	.	.
18637	11337	1	The	the	DT
18637	11337	2	Tompkins	Tompkins	NNPS
18637	11337	3	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11337	4	,	,	,
18637	11337	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11337	6	was	be	VBD
18637	11337	7	said	say	VBN
18637	11337	8	,	,	,
18637	11337	9	was	be	VBD
18637	11337	10	not	not	RB
18637	11337	11	an	an	DT
18637	11337	12	endeavor	endeavor	NN
18637	11337	13	to	to	TO
18637	11337	14	formulate	formulate	VB
18637	11337	15	scientific	scientific	JJ
18637	11337	16	legal	legal	JJ
18637	11337	17	terminology	terminology	NN
18637	11337	18	.	.	.
18637	11338	1	"	"	``
18637	11338	2	In	in	IN
18637	11338	3	essence	essence	NN
18637	11338	4	,	,	,
18637	11338	5	the	the	DT
18637	11338	6	intent	intent	NN
18637	11338	7	of	of	IN
18637	11338	8	that	that	DT
18637	11338	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	11338	10	was	be	VBD
18637	11338	11	to	to	TO
18637	11338	12	insure	insure	VB
18637	11338	13	that	that	DT
18637	11338	14	,	,	,
18637	11338	15	in	in	IN
18637	11338	16	all	all	DT
18637	11338	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	11338	18	where	where	WRB
18637	11338	19	a	a	DT
18637	11338	20	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11338	21	court	court	NN
18637	11338	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	11338	23	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	11338	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11338	25	solely	solely	RB
18637	11338	26	because	because	IN
18637	11338	27	of	of	IN
18637	11338	28	the	the	DT
18637	11338	29	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11338	30	of	of	IN
18637	11338	31	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11338	32	of	of	IN
18637	11338	33	the	the	DT
18637	11338	34	parties	party	NNS
18637	11338	35	,	,	,
18637	11338	36	the	the	DT
18637	11338	37	outcome	outcome	NN
18637	11338	38	of	of	IN
18637	11338	39	the	the	DT
18637	11338	40	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	11338	41	in	in	IN
18637	11338	42	the	the	DT
18637	11338	43	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11338	44	court	court	NN
18637	11338	45	should	should	MD
18637	11338	46	be	be	VB
18637	11338	47	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	11338	48	the	the	DT
18637	11338	49	same	same	JJ
18637	11338	50	,	,	,
18637	11338	51	so	so	RB
18637	11338	52	far	far	RB
18637	11338	53	as	as	IN
18637	11338	54	legal	legal	JJ
18637	11338	55	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11338	56	determine	determine	VBP
18637	11338	57	the	the	DT
18637	11338	58	outcome	outcome	NN
18637	11338	59	of	of	IN
18637	11338	60	a	a	DT
18637	11338	61	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	11338	62	,	,	,
18637	11338	63	as	as	IN
18637	11338	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11338	65	would	would	MD
18637	11338	66	be	be	VB
18637	11338	67	if	if	IN
18637	11338	68	tried	try	VBN
18637	11338	69	in	in	IN
18637	11338	70	a	a	DT
18637	11338	71	State	State	NNP
18637	11338	72	court	court	NN
18637	11338	73	.	.	.
18637	11339	1	"	"	``
18637	11339	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11339	3	563	563	CD
18637	11339	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11339	5	Controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11339	6	Between	between	IN
18637	11339	7	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	11339	8	of	of	IN
18637	11339	9	the	the	DT
18637	11339	10	Same	same	JJ
18637	11339	11	State	State	NNP
18637	11339	12	Claiming	Claiming	NNP
18637	11339	13	Lands	Lands	NNPS
18637	11339	14	Under	under	IN
18637	11339	15	Grants	Grants	NNPS
18637	11339	16	of	of	IN
18637	11339	17	Different	different	JJ
18637	11339	18	States	state	NNS
18637	11339	19	This	this	DT
18637	11339	20	clause	clause	NN
18637	11339	21	was	be	VBD
18637	11339	22	not	not	RB
18637	11339	23	in	in	IN
18637	11339	24	the	the	DT
18637	11339	25	first	first	JJ
18637	11339	26	draft	draft	NN
18637	11339	27	of	of	IN
18637	11339	28	the	the	DT
18637	11339	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11339	30	,	,	,
18637	11339	31	but	but	CC
18637	11339	32	was	be	VBD
18637	11339	33	added	add	VBN
18637	11339	34	without	without	IN
18637	11339	35	objection	objection	NN
18637	11339	36	.	.	.
18637	11340	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11340	2	564	564	CD
18637	11340	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11340	4	Undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	11340	5	the	the	DT
18637	11340	6	motivation	motivation	NN
18637	11340	7	for	for	IN
18637	11340	8	this	this	DT
18637	11340	9	extension	extension	NN
18637	11340	10	of	of	IN
18637	11340	11	the	the	DT
18637	11340	12	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11340	13	power	power	NN
18637	11340	14	was	be	VBD
18637	11340	15	the	the	DT
18637	11340	16	existence	existence	NN
18637	11340	17	of	of	IN
18637	11340	18	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	11340	19	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	11340	20	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	11340	21	ten	ten	CD
18637	11340	22	States	state	NNS
18637	11340	23	at	at	IN
18637	11340	24	the	the	DT
18637	11340	25	time	time	NN
18637	11340	26	the	the	DT
18637	11340	27	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	11340	28	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	11340	29	met	meet	VBD
18637	11340	30	.	.	.
18637	11341	1	With	with	IN
18637	11341	2	the	the	DT
18637	11341	3	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	11341	4	Ordinance	Ordinance	NNP
18637	11341	5	of	of	IN
18637	11341	6	1787	1787	CD
18637	11341	7	,	,	,
18637	11341	8	the	the	DT
18637	11341	9	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	11341	10	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	11341	11	of	of	IN
18637	11341	12	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	11341	13	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	11341	14	between	between	IN
18637	11341	15	States	States	NNP
18637	11341	16	,	,	,
18637	11341	17	and	and	CC
18637	11341	18	the	the	DT
18637	11341	19	passing	passing	NN
18637	11341	20	of	of	IN
18637	11341	21	land	land	NN
18637	11341	22	grants	grant	NNS
18637	11341	23	by	by	IN
18637	11341	24	States	States	NNP
18637	11341	25	,	,	,
18637	11341	26	this	this	DT
18637	11341	27	clause	clause	NN
18637	11341	28	,	,	,
18637	11341	29	never	never	RB
18637	11341	30	productive	productive	VB
18637	11341	31	of	of	IN
18637	11341	32	many	many	JJ
18637	11341	33	cases	case	NNS
18637	11341	34	,	,	,
18637	11341	35	has	have	VBZ
18637	11341	36	become	become	VBN
18637	11341	37	obsolete	obsolete	JJ
18637	11341	38	.	.	.
18637	11342	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11342	2	565	565	CD
18637	11342	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11342	4	Controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11342	5	Between	between	IN
18637	11342	6	a	a	DT
18637	11342	7	State	state	NN
18637	11342	8	,	,	,
18637	11342	9	or	or	CC
18637	11342	10	the	the	DT
18637	11342	11	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	11342	12	Thereof	thereof	RB
18637	11342	13	,	,	,
18637	11342	14	and	and	CC
18637	11342	15	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	11342	16	States	States	NNPS
18637	11342	17	,	,	,
18637	11342	18	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	11342	19	or	or	CC
18637	11342	20	Subjects	subject	NNS
18637	11342	21	The	the	DT
18637	11342	22	scope	scope	NN
18637	11342	23	of	of	IN
18637	11342	24	this	this	DT
18637	11342	25	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11342	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	11342	27	been	be	VBN
18637	11342	28	limited	limit	VBN
18637	11342	29	both	both	CC
18637	11342	30	by	by	IN
18637	11342	31	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11342	32	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11342	33	and	and	CC
18637	11342	34	the	the	DT
18637	11342	35	Eleventh	Eleventh	NNP
18637	11342	36	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	11342	37	.	.	.
18637	11343	1	By	by	IN
18637	11343	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11343	3	application	application	NN
18637	11343	4	of	of	IN
18637	11343	5	the	the	DT
18637	11343	6	Law	Law	NNP
18637	11343	7	of	of	IN
18637	11343	8	Nations	Nations	NNPS
18637	11343	9	a	a	DT
18637	11343	10	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11343	11	State	state	NN
18637	11343	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	11343	13	immune	immune	JJ
18637	11343	14	from	from	IN
18637	11343	15	suit	suit	NN
18637	11343	16	in	in	IN
18637	11343	17	the	the	DT
18637	11343	18	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11343	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	11343	20	without	without	IN
18637	11343	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11343	22	consent,[566	consent,[566	NN
18637	11343	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11343	24	an	an	DT
18637	11343	25	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	11343	26	which	which	WDT
18637	11343	27	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	11343	28	to	to	IN
18637	11343	29	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11343	30	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11343	31	by	by	IN
18637	11343	32	States	state	NNS
18637	11343	33	of	of	IN
18637	11343	34	the	the	DT
18637	11343	35	American	American	NNP
18637	11343	36	Union	Union	NNP
18637	11343	37	.	.	.
18637	11344	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11344	2	567	567	CD
18637	11344	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11344	4	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	11344	5	,	,	,
18637	11344	6	the	the	DT
18637	11344	7	Eleventh	Eleventh	NNP
18637	11344	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	11344	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	11344	10	been	be	VBN
18637	11344	11	construed	construe	VBN
18637	11344	12	to	to	IN
18637	11344	13	bar	bar	NN
18637	11344	14	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11344	15	by	by	IN
18637	11344	16	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11344	17	States	state	NNS
18637	11344	18	against	against	IN
18637	11344	19	a	a	DT
18637	11344	20	State	State	NNP
18637	11344	21	of	of	IN
18637	11344	22	the	the	DT
18637	11344	23	American	American	NNP
18637	11344	24	Union	Union	NNP
18637	11344	25	.	.	.
18637	11345	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11345	2	568	568	CD
18637	11345	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11345	4	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	11345	5	,	,	,
18637	11345	6	the	the	DT
18637	11345	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11345	8	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	11345	9	by	by	IN
18637	11345	10	this	this	DT
18637	11345	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	11345	12	comprehends	comprehend	VBZ
18637	11345	13	only	only	RB
18637	11345	14	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11345	15	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11345	16	by	by	IN
18637	11345	17	a	a	DT
18637	11345	18	State	state	NN
18637	11345	19	against	against	IN
18637	11345	20	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11345	21	or	or	CC
18637	11345	22	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	11345	23	of	of	IN
18637	11345	24	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11345	25	States	state	NNS
18637	11345	26	,	,	,
18637	11345	27	by	by	IN
18637	11345	28	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11345	29	States	state	NNS
18637	11345	30	against	against	IN
18637	11345	31	American	american	JJ
18637	11345	32	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11345	33	,	,	,
18637	11345	34	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11345	35	of	of	IN
18637	11345	36	a	a	DT
18637	11345	37	State	State	NNP
18637	11345	38	against	against	IN
18637	11345	39	the	the	DT
18637	11345	40	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11345	41	or	or	CC
18637	11345	42	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	11345	43	of	of	IN
18637	11345	44	a	a	DT
18637	11345	45	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11345	46	State	state	NN
18637	11345	47	,	,	,
18637	11345	48	and	and	CC
18637	11345	49	by	by	IN
18637	11345	50	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	11345	51	against	against	IN
18637	11345	52	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11345	53	of	of	IN
18637	11345	54	a	a	DT
18637	11345	55	State	state	NN
18637	11345	56	.	.	.
18637	11346	1	SUITS	SUITS	NNP
18637	11346	2	BY	by	IN
18637	11346	3	FOREIGN	foreign	JJ
18637	11346	4	STATES	state	NNS
18637	11346	5	The	the	DT
18637	11346	6	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	11346	7	of	of	IN
18637	11346	8	a	a	DT
18637	11346	9	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	11346	10	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11346	11	State	State	NNP
18637	11346	12	to	to	TO
18637	11346	13	sue	sue	VB
18637	11346	14	in	in	IN
18637	11346	15	the	the	DT
18637	11346	16	courts	court	NNS
18637	11346	17	of	of	IN
18637	11346	18	a	a	DT
18637	11346	19	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11346	20	State	state	NN
18637	11346	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	11346	22	the	the	DT
18637	11346	23	principle	principle	NN
18637	11346	24	of	of	IN
18637	11346	25	comity	comity	NN
18637	11346	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	11346	27	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	11346	28	by	by	IN
18637	11346	29	both	both	DT
18637	11346	30	International	International	NNP
18637	11346	31	Law	Law	NNP
18637	11346	32	and	and	CC
18637	11346	33	American	American	NNP
18637	11346	34	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	11346	35	Law	Law	NNP
18637	11346	36	.	.	.
18637	11347	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11347	2	569	569	CD
18637	11347	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11347	4	To	to	TO
18637	11347	5	deny	deny	VB
18637	11347	6	a	a	DT
18637	11347	7	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	11347	8	this	this	DT
18637	11347	9	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	11347	10	"	"	``
18637	11347	11	would	would	MD
18637	11347	12	manifest	manifest	VB
18637	11347	13	a	a	DT
18637	11347	14	want	want	NN
18637	11347	15	of	of	IN
18637	11347	16	comity	comity	NN
18637	11347	17	and	and	CC
18637	11347	18	friendly	friendly	JJ
18637	11347	19	feeling	feeling	NN
18637	11347	20	.	.	.
18637	11348	1	"	"	``
18637	11348	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11348	3	570	570	CD
18637	11348	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11348	5	Although	although	IN
18637	11348	6	national	national	JJ
18637	11348	7	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	11348	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	11348	9	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	11348	10	,	,	,
18637	11348	11	a	a	DT
18637	11348	12	suit	suit	NN
18637	11348	13	in	in	IN
18637	11348	14	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	11348	15	of	of	IN
18637	11348	16	a	a	DT
18637	11348	17	national	national	JJ
18637	11348	18	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	11348	19	can	can	MD
18637	11348	20	be	be	VB
18637	11348	21	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	11348	22	in	in	IN
18637	11348	23	the	the	DT
18637	11348	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	11348	25	of	of	IN
18637	11348	26	the	the	DT
18637	11348	27	United	United	NNP
18637	11348	28	States	States	NNP
18637	11348	29	only	only	RB
18637	11348	30	by	by	IN
18637	11348	31	a	a	DT
18637	11348	32	government	government	NN
18637	11348	33	which	which	WDT
18637	11348	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	11348	35	been	be	VBN
18637	11348	36	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	11348	37	by	by	IN
18637	11348	38	the	the	DT
18637	11348	39	political	political	JJ
18637	11348	40	branches	branch	NNS
18637	11348	41	of	of	IN
18637	11348	42	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11348	43	own	own	JJ
18637	11348	44	government	government	NN
18637	11348	45	as	as	IN
18637	11348	46	the	the	DT
18637	11348	47	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	11348	48	government	government	NN
18637	11348	49	of	of	IN
18637	11348	50	the	the	DT
18637	11348	51	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11348	52	State	State	NNP
18637	11348	53	.	.	.
18637	11349	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11349	2	571	571	CD
18637	11349	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11349	4	Once	once	IN
18637	11349	5	a	a	DT
18637	11349	6	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11349	7	government	government	NN
18637	11349	8	avails	avail	VBZ
18637	11349	9	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11349	10	of	of	IN
18637	11349	11	the	the	DT
18637	11349	12	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	11349	13	of	of	IN
18637	11349	14	suing	sue	VBG
18637	11349	15	in	in	IN
18637	11349	16	the	the	DT
18637	11349	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	11349	18	of	of	IN
18637	11349	19	the	the	DT
18637	11349	20	United	United	NNP
18637	11349	21	States	States	NNP
18637	11349	22	,	,	,
18637	11349	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11349	24	subjects	subject	VBZ
18637	11349	25	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11349	26	to	to	IN
18637	11349	27	the	the	DT
18637	11349	28	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	11349	29	and	and	CC
18637	11349	30	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11349	31	of	of	IN
18637	11349	32	decision	decision	NN
18637	11349	33	governing	govern	VBG
18637	11349	34	those	those	DT
18637	11349	35	courts	court	NNS
18637	11349	36	and	and	CC
18637	11349	37	accepts	accept	VBZ
18637	11349	38	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	11349	39	liabilities	liability	NNS
18637	11349	40	the	the	DT
18637	11349	41	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11349	42	may	may	MD
18637	11349	43	decide	decide	VB
18637	11349	44	to	to	TO
18637	11349	45	be	be	VB
18637	11349	46	a	a	DT
18637	11349	47	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	11349	48	incident	incident	NN
18637	11349	49	of	of	IN
18637	11349	50	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	11349	51	the	the	DT
18637	11349	52	suit	suit	NN
18637	11349	53	.	.	.
18637	11350	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11350	2	572	572	CD
18637	11350	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11350	4	Also	also	RB
18637	11350	5	,	,	,
18637	11350	6	certain	certain	JJ
18637	11350	7	of	of	IN
18637	11350	8	the	the	DT
18637	11350	9	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	11350	10	extending	extend	VBG
18637	11350	11	to	to	IN
18637	11350	12	the	the	DT
18637	11350	13	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	11350	14	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	11350	15	do	do	VBP
18637	11350	16	not	not	RB
18637	11350	17	extend	extend	VB
18637	11350	18	to	to	IN
18637	11350	19	a	a	DT
18637	11350	20	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11350	21	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	11350	22	suing	suing	NN
18637	11350	23	in	in	IN
18637	11350	24	the	the	DT
18637	11350	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	11350	26	of	of	IN
18637	11350	27	the	the	DT
18637	11350	28	United	United	NNP
18637	11350	29	States	States	NNP
18637	11350	30	.	.	.
18637	11351	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	11351	2	a	a	DT
18637	11351	3	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11351	4	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	11351	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	11351	6	not	not	RB
18637	11351	7	receive	receive	VB
18637	11351	8	the	the	DT
18637	11351	9	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	11351	10	of	of	IN
18637	11351	11	the	the	DT
18637	11351	12	rule	rule	NN
18637	11351	13	which	which	WDT
18637	11351	14	exempts	exempt	VBZ
18637	11351	15	the	the	DT
18637	11351	16	United	United	NNP
18637	11351	17	States	States	NNP
18637	11351	18	and	and	CC
18637	11351	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11351	20	member	member	NN
18637	11351	21	States	state	NNS
18637	11351	22	from	from	IN
18637	11351	23	the	the	DT
18637	11351	24	operation	operation	NN
18637	11351	25	of	of	IN
18637	11351	26	the	the	DT
18637	11351	27	statute	statute	NN
18637	11351	28	of	of	IN
18637	11351	29	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	11351	30	,	,	,
18637	11351	31	because	because	IN
18637	11351	32	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	11351	33	of	of	IN
18637	11351	34	public	public	JJ
18637	11351	35	policy	policy	NN
18637	11351	36	back	back	RB
18637	11351	37	of	of	IN
18637	11351	38	the	the	DT
18637	11351	39	rule	rule	NN
18637	11351	40	are	be	VBP
18637	11351	41	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	11351	42	as	as	IN
18637	11351	43	absent	absent	JJ
18637	11351	44	.	.	.
18637	11352	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11352	2	573	573	CD
18637	11352	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11352	4	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	11352	5	Tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	11352	6	Within	within	IN
18637	11352	7	the	the	DT
18637	11352	8	terms	term	NNS
18637	11352	9	of	of	IN
18637	11352	10	article	article	NN
18637	11352	11	III	iii	CD
18637	11352	12	,	,	,
18637	11352	13	an	an	DT
18637	11352	14	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	11352	15	tribe	tribe	NN
18637	11352	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	11352	17	not	not	RB
18637	11352	18	a	a	DT
18637	11352	19	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11352	20	State	state	NN
18637	11352	21	and	and	CC
18637	11352	22	hence	hence	RB
18637	11352	23	can	can	MD
18637	11352	24	not	not	RB
18637	11352	25	sue	sue	VB
18637	11352	26	in	in	IN
18637	11352	27	the	the	DT
18637	11352	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	11352	29	of	of	IN
18637	11352	30	the	the	DT
18637	11352	31	United	United	NNP
18637	11352	32	States	States	NNP
18637	11352	33	.	.	.
18637	11353	1	This	this	DT
18637	11353	2	rule	rule	NN
18637	11353	3	was	be	VBD
18637	11353	4	applied	apply	VBN
18637	11353	5	in	in	IN
18637	11353	6	the	the	DT
18637	11353	7	case	case	NN
18637	11353	8	of	of	IN
18637	11353	9	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	11353	10	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	11353	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11353	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	11353	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11353	14	Georgia,[574	Georgia,[574	NNP
18637	11353	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11353	16	where	where	WRB
18637	11353	17	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11353	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11353	19	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11353	20	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	11353	21	that	that	IN
18637	11353	22	the	the	DT
18637	11353	23	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	11353	24	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	11353	25	was	be	VBD
18637	11353	26	a	a	DT
18637	11353	27	State	state	NN
18637	11353	28	,	,	,
18637	11353	29	but	but	CC
18637	11353	30	not	not	RB
18637	11353	31	a	a	DT
18637	11353	32	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11353	33	State	state	NN
18637	11353	34	,	,	,
18637	11353	35	being	be	VBG
18637	11353	36	a	a	DT
18637	11353	37	part	part	NN
18637	11353	38	of	of	IN
18637	11353	39	the	the	DT
18637	11353	40	United	United	NNP
18637	11353	41	States	States	NNP
18637	11353	42	and	and	CC
18637	11353	43	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	11353	44	upon	upon	IN
18637	11353	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11353	46	.	.	.
18637	11354	1	Other	other	JJ
18637	11354	2	passages	passage	NNS
18637	11354	3	of	of	IN
18637	11354	4	the	the	DT
18637	11354	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11354	6	specify	specify	VBP
18637	11354	7	the	the	DT
18637	11354	8	elements	element	NNS
18637	11354	9	essential	essential	JJ
18637	11354	10	to	to	IN
18637	11354	11	a	a	DT
18637	11354	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11354	13	State	State	NNP
18637	11354	14	for	for	IN
18637	11354	15	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	11354	16	of	of	IN
18637	11354	17	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11354	18	,	,	,
18637	11354	19	such	such	JJ
18637	11354	20	as	as	IN
18637	11354	21	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	11354	22	and	and	CC
18637	11354	23	independence	independence	NN
18637	11354	24	.	.	.
18637	11355	1	NARROW	NARROW	NNP
18637	11355	2	CONSTRUCTION	construction	NN
18637	11355	3	OF	of	IN
18637	11355	4	THE	the	DT
18637	11355	5	JURISDICTION	JURISDICTION	NNP
18637	11355	6	As	as	IN
18637	11355	7	in	in	IN
18637	11355	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	11355	9	of	of	IN
18637	11355	10	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11355	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11355	12	,	,	,
18637	11355	13	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11355	14	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11355	15	to	to	IN
18637	11355	16	the	the	DT
18637	11355	17	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11355	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	11355	19	under	under	IN
18637	11355	20	this	this	DT
18637	11355	21	category	category	NN
18637	11355	22	must	must	MD
18637	11355	23	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	11355	24	state	state	VB
18637	11355	25	in	in	IN
18637	11355	26	the	the	DT
18637	11355	27	record	record	NN
18637	11355	28	the	the	DT
18637	11355	29	nature	nature	NN
18637	11355	30	of	of	IN
18637	11355	31	the	the	DT
18637	11355	32	parties	party	NNS
18637	11355	33	.	.	.
18637	11356	1	As	as	RB
18637	11356	2	early	early	RB
18637	11356	3	as	as	IN
18637	11356	4	1809	1809	CD
18637	11356	5	the	the	DT
18637	11356	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11356	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11356	8	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	11356	9	that	that	IN
18637	11356	10	a	a	DT
18637	11356	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11356	12	court	court	NN
18637	11356	13	could	could	MD
18637	11356	14	not	not	RB
18637	11356	15	take	take	VB
18637	11356	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11356	17	of	of	IN
18637	11356	18	a	a	DT
18637	11356	19	cause	cause	NN
18637	11356	20	where	where	WRB
18637	11356	21	the	the	DT
18637	11356	22	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	11356	23	were	be	VBD
18637	11356	24	described	describe	VBN
18637	11356	25	in	in	IN
18637	11356	26	the	the	DT
18637	11356	27	record	record	NN
18637	11356	28	as	as	IN
18637	11356	29	"	"	``
18637	11356	30	late	late	RB
18637	11356	31	of	of	IN
18637	11356	32	the	the	DT
18637	11356	33	district	district	NN
18637	11356	34	of	of	IN
18637	11356	35	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	11356	36	,	,	,
18637	11356	37	"	"	''
18637	11356	38	but	but	CC
18637	11356	39	were	be	VBD
18637	11356	40	not	not	RB
18637	11356	41	designated	designate	VBN
18637	11356	42	as	as	IN
18637	11356	43	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11356	44	of	of	IN
18637	11356	45	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	11356	46	,	,	,
18637	11356	47	and	and	CC
18637	11356	48	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
18637	11356	49	were	be	VBD
18637	11356	50	described	describe	VBN
18637	11356	51	as	as	IN
18637	11356	52	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	11356	53	and	and	CC
18637	11356	54	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	11356	55	of	of	IN
18637	11356	56	the	the	DT
18637	11356	57	United	United	NNP
18637	11356	58	Kingdom	Kingdom	NNP
18637	11356	59	.	.	.
18637	11357	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11357	2	575	575	CD
18637	11357	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11357	4	The	the	DT
18637	11357	5	meticulous	meticulous	JJ
18637	11357	6	care	care	NN
18637	11357	7	manifested	manifest	VBN
18637	11357	8	in	in	IN
18637	11357	9	this	this	DT
18637	11357	10	case	case	NN
18637	11357	11	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	11357	12	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	11357	13	years	year	NNS
18637	11357	14	later	later	RB
18637	11357	15	when	when	WRB
18637	11357	16	the	the	DT
18637	11357	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11357	18	narrowly	narrowly	RB
18637	11357	19	construed	construe	VBD
18637	11357	20	section	section	NN
18637	11357	21	11	11	CD
18637	11357	22	of	of	IN
18637	11357	23	the	the	DT
18637	11357	24	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11357	25	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11357	26	of	of	IN
18637	11357	27	1789	1789	CD
18637	11357	28	,	,	,
18637	11357	29	vesting	vest	VBG
18637	11357	30	the	the	DT
18637	11357	31	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11357	32	courts	court	NNS
18637	11357	33	with	with	IN
18637	11357	34	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11357	35	where	where	WRB
18637	11357	36	an	an	DT
18637	11357	37	alien	alien	NN
18637	11357	38	was	be	VBD
18637	11357	39	a	a	DT
18637	11357	40	party	party	NN
18637	11357	41	,	,	,
18637	11357	42	in	in	IN
18637	11357	43	order	order	NN
18637	11357	44	to	to	TO
18637	11357	45	keep	keep	VB
18637	11357	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11357	47	within	within	IN
18637	11357	48	the	the	DT
18637	11357	49	limits	limit	NNS
18637	11357	50	of	of	IN
18637	11357	51	this	this	DT
18637	11357	52	clause	clause	NN
18637	11357	53	.	.	.
18637	11358	1	The	the	DT
18637	11358	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11358	3	power	power	NN
18637	11358	4	was	be	VBD
18637	11358	5	further	further	RB
18637	11358	6	held	hold	VBN
18637	11358	7	not	not	RB
18637	11358	8	to	to	TO
18637	11358	9	extend	extend	VB
18637	11358	10	to	to	IN
18637	11358	11	private	private	JJ
18637	11358	12	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11358	13	in	in	IN
18637	11358	14	which	which	WDT
18637	11358	15	an	an	DT
18637	11358	16	alien	alien	NN
18637	11358	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	11358	18	a	a	DT
18637	11358	19	party	party	NN
18637	11358	20	,	,	,
18637	11358	21	unless	unless	IN
18637	11358	22	a	a	DT
18637	11358	23	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11358	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	11358	25	the	the	DT
18637	11358	26	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	11358	27	party	party	NN
18637	11358	28	.	.	.
18637	11359	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11359	2	576	576	CD
18637	11359	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11359	4	This	this	DT
18637	11359	5	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11359	6	was	be	VBD
18637	11359	7	extended	extend	VBN
18637	11359	8	in	in	IN
18637	11359	9	1870	1870	CD
18637	11359	10	by	by	IN
18637	11359	11	a	a	DT
18637	11359	12	holding	holding	NN
18637	11359	13	that	that	IN
18637	11359	14	if	if	IN
18637	11359	15	there	there	EX
18637	11359	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	11359	17	more	more	JJR
18637	11359	18	than	than	IN
18637	11359	19	one	one	CD
18637	11359	20	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11359	21	or	or	CC
18637	11359	22	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	11359	23	,	,	,
18637	11359	24	each	each	DT
18637	11359	25	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11359	26	or	or	CC
18637	11359	27	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	11359	28	must	must	MD
18637	11359	29	be	be	VB
18637	11359	30	competent	competent	JJ
18637	11359	31	to	to	TO
18637	11359	32	sue	sue	VB
18637	11359	33	or	or	CC
18637	11359	34	liable	liable	JJ
18637	11359	35	to	to	TO
18637	11359	36	suit	suit	VB
18637	11359	37	.	.	.
18637	11360	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11360	2	577	577	CD
18637	11360	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11360	4	These	these	DT
18637	11360	5	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11360	6	,	,	,
18637	11360	7	however	however	RB
18637	11360	8	,	,	,
18637	11360	9	do	do	VBP
18637	11360	10	not	not	RB
18637	11360	11	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	11360	12	a	a	DT
18637	11360	13	suit	suit	NN
18637	11360	14	between	between	IN
18637	11360	15	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11360	16	of	of	IN
18637	11360	17	the	the	DT
18637	11360	18	same	same	JJ
18637	11360	19	State	State	NNP
18637	11360	20	if	if	IN
18637	11360	21	the	the	DT
18637	11360	22	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
18637	11360	23	are	be	VBP
18637	11360	24	merely	merely	RB
18637	11360	25	nominal	nominal	JJ
18637	11360	26	parties	party	NNS
18637	11360	27	and	and	CC
18637	11360	28	are	be	VBP
18637	11360	29	suing	sue	VBG
18637	11360	30	on	on	IN
18637	11360	31	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	11360	32	of	of	IN
18637	11360	33	an	an	DT
18637	11360	34	alien	alien	NN
18637	11360	35	.	.	.
18637	11361	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11361	2	578	578	CD
18637	11361	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11361	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	11361	5	2	2	CD
18637	11361	6	.	.	.
18637	11362	1	In	in	IN
18637	11362	2	all	all	DT
18637	11362	3	Cases	case	NNS
18637	11362	4	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	11362	5	Ambassadors	Ambassadors	NNPS
18637	11362	6	,	,	,
18637	11362	7	other	other	JJ
18637	11362	8	public	public	JJ
18637	11362	9	Ministers	Ministers	NNPS
18637	11362	10	and	and	CC
18637	11362	11	Consuls	Consuls	NNP
18637	11362	12	,	,	,
18637	11362	13	and	and	CC
18637	11362	14	those	those	DT
18637	11362	15	in	in	IN
18637	11362	16	which	which	WDT
18637	11362	17	a	a	DT
18637	11362	18	State	state	NN
18637	11362	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	11362	20	be	be	VB
18637	11362	21	Party	Party	NNP
18637	11362	22	,	,	,
18637	11362	23	the	the	DT
18637	11362	24	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	11362	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11362	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	11362	27	have	have	VB
18637	11362	28	original	original	JJ
18637	11362	29	Jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11362	30	.	.	.
18637	11363	1	In	in	IN
18637	11363	2	all	all	PDT
18637	11363	3	the	the	DT
18637	11363	4	other	other	JJ
18637	11363	5	Cases	case	NNS
18637	11363	6	before	before	IN
18637	11363	7	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	11363	8	,	,	,
18637	11363	9	the	the	DT
18637	11363	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11363	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11363	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	11363	13	have	have	VB
18637	11363	14	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	11363	15	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	11363	16	,	,	,
18637	11363	17	both	both	CC
18637	11363	18	as	as	IN
18637	11363	19	to	to	IN
18637	11363	20	Law	Law	NNP
18637	11363	21	and	and	CC
18637	11363	22	Fact	Fact	NNP
18637	11363	23	,	,	,
18637	11363	24	with	with	IN
18637	11363	25	such	such	JJ
18637	11363	26	Exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	11363	27	,	,	,
18637	11363	28	and	and	CC
18637	11363	29	under	under	IN
18637	11363	30	such	such	JJ
18637	11363	31	Regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	11363	32	as	as	IN
18637	11363	33	the	the	DT
18637	11363	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11363	35	shall	shall	MD
18637	11363	36	make	make	VB
18637	11363	37	.	.	.
18637	11364	1	The	the	DT
18637	11364	2	Original	Original	NNP
18637	11364	3	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	11364	4	of	of	IN
18637	11364	5	the	the	DT
18637	11364	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11364	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11364	8	AN	AN	NNP
18637	11364	9	AUTONOMOUS	AUTONOMOUS	NNP
18637	11364	10	JURISDICTION	JURISDICTION	NNP
18637	11364	11	Acting	act	VBG
18637	11364	12	on	on	IN
18637	11364	13	the	the	DT
18637	11364	14	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	11364	15	that	that	IN
18637	11364	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11364	17	existence	existence	NN
18637	11364	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	11364	19	derived	derive	VBN
18637	11364	20	directly	directly	RB
18637	11364	21	from	from	IN
18637	11364	22	the	the	DT
18637	11364	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11364	24	,	,	,
18637	11364	25	the	the	DT
18637	11364	26	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11364	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11364	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	11364	29	held	hold	VBN
18637	11364	30	since	since	IN
18637	11364	31	1792	1792	CD
18637	11364	32	that	that	IN
18637	11364	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11364	34	original	original	JJ
18637	11364	35	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11364	36	flows	flow	VBZ
18637	11364	37	directly	directly	RB
18637	11364	38	from	from	IN
18637	11364	39	the	the	DT
18637	11364	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11364	41	and	and	CC
18637	11364	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	11364	43	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11364	44	self	self	NN
18637	11364	45	-	-	HYPH
18637	11364	46	executing	execute	VBG
18637	11364	47	without	without	IN
18637	11364	48	further	further	JJ
18637	11364	49	action	action	NN
18637	11364	50	by	by	IN
18637	11364	51	the	the	DT
18637	11364	52	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11364	53	.	.	.
18637	11365	1	In	in	IN
18637	11365	2	the	the	DT
18637	11365	3	famous	famous	JJ
18637	11365	4	case	case	NN
18637	11365	5	of	of	IN
18637	11365	6	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
18637	11365	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11365	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11365	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11365	10	Georgia[579	Georgia[579	NNP
18637	11365	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11365	12	the	the	DT
18637	11365	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11365	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11365	15	entertained	entertain	VBD
18637	11365	16	an	an	DT
18637	11365	17	action	action	NN
18637	11365	18	of	of	IN
18637	11365	19	assumpsit	assumpsit	NN
18637	11365	20	against	against	IN
18637	11365	21	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11365	22	by	by	IN
18637	11365	23	a	a	DT
18637	11365	24	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11365	25	of	of	IN
18637	11365	26	another	another	DT
18637	11365	27	State	State	NNP
18637	11365	28	.	.	.
18637	11366	1	Although	although	IN
18637	11366	2	the	the	DT
18637	11366	3	13th	13th	JJ
18637	11366	4	section	section	NN
18637	11366	5	of	of	IN
18637	11366	6	the	the	DT
18637	11366	7	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11366	8	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11366	9	of	of	IN
18637	11366	10	1789	1789	CD
18637	11366	11	invested	invest	VBD
18637	11366	12	the	the	DT
18637	11366	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11366	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11366	15	with	with	IN
18637	11366	16	original	original	JJ
18637	11366	17	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11366	18	in	in	IN
18637	11366	19	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11366	20	between	between	IN
18637	11366	21	a	a	DT
18637	11366	22	State	state	NN
18637	11366	23	and	and	CC
18637	11366	24	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11366	25	of	of	IN
18637	11366	26	another	another	DT
18637	11366	27	State	state	NN
18637	11366	28	,	,	,
18637	11366	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11366	30	did	do	VBD
18637	11366	31	not	not	RB
18637	11366	32	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	11366	33	actions	action	NNS
18637	11366	34	of	of	IN
18637	11366	35	assumpsit	assumpsit	NN
18637	11366	36	in	in	IN
18637	11366	37	such	such	JJ
18637	11366	38	cases	case	NNS
18637	11366	39	,	,	,
18637	11366	40	nor	nor	CC
18637	11366	41	did	do	VBD
18637	11366	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11366	43	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	11366	44	forms	form	NNS
18637	11366	45	of	of	IN
18637	11366	46	process	process	NN
18637	11366	47	for	for	IN
18637	11366	48	the	the	DT
18637	11366	49	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11366	50	in	in	IN
18637	11366	51	the	the	DT
18637	11366	52	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11366	53	of	of	IN
18637	11366	54	original	original	JJ
18637	11366	55	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11366	56	.	.	.
18637	11367	1	Over	over	IN
18637	11367	2	the	the	DT
18637	11367	3	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11367	4	of	of	IN
18637	11367	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11367	6	Iredell	Iredell	NNP
18637	11367	7	,	,	,
18637	11367	8	the	the	DT
18637	11367	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11367	10	in	in	IN
18637	11367	11	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	11367	12	by	by	IN
18637	11367	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11367	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11367	15	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	11367	16	and	and	CC
18637	11367	17	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	11367	18	Blair	Blair	NNP
18637	11367	19	,	,	,
18637	11367	20	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	11367	21	,	,	,
18637	11367	22	and	and	CC
18637	11367	23	Cushing	Cushing	NNP
18637	11367	24	,	,	,
18637	11367	25	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	11367	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11367	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11367	28	and	and	CC
18637	11367	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11367	30	power	power	NN
18637	11367	31	,	,	,
18637	11367	32	in	in	IN
18637	11367	33	the	the	DT
18637	11367	34	absence	absence	NN
18637	11367	35	of	of	IN
18637	11367	36	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	11367	37	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	11367	38	,	,	,
18637	11367	39	to	to	TO
18637	11367	40	provide	provide	VB
18637	11367	41	forms	form	NNS
18637	11367	42	of	of	IN
18637	11367	43	process	process	NN
18637	11367	44	and	and	CC
18637	11367	45	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11367	46	of	of	IN
18637	11367	47	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	11367	48	.	.	.
18637	11368	1	So	so	RB
18637	11368	2	strong	strong	JJ
18637	11368	3	were	be	VBD
18637	11368	4	the	the	DT
18637	11368	5	States	States	NNPS
18637	11368	6	'	'	POS
18637	11368	7	rights	right	NNS
18637	11368	8	sentiments	sentiment	NNS
18637	11368	9	of	of	IN
18637	11368	10	the	the	DT
18637	11368	11	times	time	NNS
18637	11368	12	that	that	IN
18637	11368	13	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11368	14	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	11368	15	to	to	TO
18637	11368	16	appear	appear	VB
18637	11368	17	as	as	IN
18637	11368	18	a	a	DT
18637	11368	19	party	party	NN
18637	11368	20	litigant	litigant	NN
18637	11368	21	,	,	,
18637	11368	22	and	and	CC
18637	11368	23	other	other	JJ
18637	11368	24	States	States	NNPS
18637	11368	25	were	be	VBD
18637	11368	26	so	so	RB
18637	11368	27	disturbed	disturb	VBN
18637	11368	28	that	that	IN
18637	11368	29	the	the	DT
18637	11368	30	Eleventh	Eleventh	NNP
18637	11368	31	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	11368	32	was	be	VBD
18637	11368	33	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	11368	34	forthwith	forthwith	NN
18637	11368	35	and	and	CC
18637	11368	36	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	11368	37	.	.	.
18637	11369	1	This	this	DT
18637	11369	2	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	11369	3	,	,	,
18637	11369	4	however	however	RB
18637	11369	5	,	,	,
18637	11369	6	did	do	VBD
18637	11369	7	not	not	RB
18637	11369	8	affect	affect	VB
18637	11369	9	the	the	DT
18637	11369	10	direct	direct	JJ
18637	11369	11	flow	flow	NN
18637	11369	12	of	of	IN
18637	11369	13	original	original	JJ
18637	11369	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11369	15	to	to	IN
18637	11369	16	the	the	DT
18637	11369	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11369	18	,	,	,
18637	11369	19	which	which	WDT
18637	11369	20	continued	continue	VBD
18637	11369	21	to	to	TO
18637	11369	22	take	take	VB
18637	11369	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11369	24	of	of	IN
18637	11369	25	cases	case	NNS
18637	11369	26	to	to	TO
18637	11369	27	which	which	WDT
18637	11369	28	a	a	DT
18637	11369	29	State	state	NN
18637	11369	30	was	be	VBD
18637	11369	31	party	party	NN
18637	11369	32	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11369	33	and	and	CC
18637	11369	34	of	of	IN
18637	11369	35	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11369	36	between	between	IN
18637	11369	37	States	state	NNS
18637	11369	38	without	without	IN
18637	11369	39	specific	specific	JJ
18637	11369	40	provision	provision	NN
18637	11369	41	by	by	IN
18637	11369	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11369	43	for	for	IN
18637	11369	44	forms	form	NNS
18637	11369	45	of	of	IN
18637	11369	46	process	process	NN
18637	11369	47	.	.	.
18637	11370	1	By	by	IN
18637	11370	2	1861	1861	CD
18637	11370	3	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11370	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11370	5	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	11370	6	could	could	MD
18637	11370	7	enunciate	enunciate	VB
18637	11370	8	with	with	IN
18637	11370	9	confidence	confidence	NN
18637	11370	10	,	,	,
18637	11370	11	after	after	IN
18637	11370	12	a	a	DT
18637	11370	13	review	review	NN
18637	11370	14	of	of	IN
18637	11370	15	the	the	DT
18637	11370	16	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	11370	17	,	,	,
18637	11370	18	that	that	IN
18637	11370	19	in	in	IN
18637	11370	20	all	all	DT
18637	11370	21	cases	case	NNS
18637	11370	22	where	where	WRB
18637	11370	23	original	original	JJ
18637	11370	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11370	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	11370	26	given	give	VBN
18637	11370	27	by	by	IN
18637	11370	28	the	the	DT
18637	11370	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11370	30	,	,	,
18637	11370	31	the	the	DT
18637	11370	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11370	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11370	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	11370	35	authority	authority	NN
18637	11370	36	"	"	``
18637	11370	37	to	to	TO
18637	11370	38	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	11370	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11370	40	without	without	IN
18637	11370	41	further	further	JJ
18637	11370	42	act	act	NN
18637	11370	43	of	of	IN
18637	11370	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11370	45	to	to	TO
18637	11370	46	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	11370	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11370	48	powers	power	NNS
18637	11370	49	or	or	CC
18637	11370	50	confer	confer	VB
18637	11370	51	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11370	52	,	,	,
18637	11370	53	and	and	CC
18637	11370	54	that	that	IN
18637	11370	55	the	the	DT
18637	11370	56	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11370	57	may	may	MD
18637	11370	58	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	11370	59	and	and	CC
18637	11370	60	mould	mould	VB
18637	11370	61	the	the	DT
18637	11370	62	process	process	NN
18637	11370	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11370	64	uses	use	VBZ
18637	11370	65	in	in	IN
18637	11370	66	such	such	JJ
18637	11370	67	manner	manner	NN
18637	11370	68	as	as	IN
18637	11370	69	in	in	IN
18637	11370	70	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11370	71	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11370	72	will	will	MD
18637	11370	73	best	best	RB
18637	11370	74	promote	promote	VB
18637	11370	75	the	the	DT
18637	11370	76	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	11370	77	of	of	IN
18637	11370	78	justice	justice	NN
18637	11370	79	.	.	.
18637	11371	1	"	"	``
18637	11371	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11371	3	580	580	CD
18637	11371	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11371	5	CANNOT	CANNOT	NNP
18637	11371	6	BE	BE	NNP
18637	11371	7	ENLARGED	enlarge	VBN
18637	11371	8	;	;	:
18637	11371	9	MARBURY	MARBURY	NNP
18637	11371	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11371	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	11371	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11371	13	MADISON	MADISON	NNP
18637	11371	14	Since	since	IN
18637	11371	15	the	the	DT
18637	11371	16	original	original	JJ
18637	11371	17	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11371	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	11371	19	derived	derive	VBN
18637	11371	20	directly	directly	RB
18637	11371	21	from	from	IN
18637	11371	22	the	the	DT
18637	11371	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11371	24	,	,	,
18637	11371	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11371	26	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	11371	27	logically	logically	RB
18637	11371	28	that	that	IN
18637	11371	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11371	30	can	can	MD
18637	11371	31	neither	neither	CC
18637	11371	32	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	11371	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11371	34	nor	nor	CC
18637	11371	35	,	,	,
18637	11371	36	as	as	IN
18637	11371	37	was	be	VBD
18637	11371	38	held	hold	VBN
18637	11371	39	in	in	IN
18637	11371	40	the	the	DT
18637	11371	41	great	great	JJ
18637	11371	42	case	case	NN
18637	11371	43	of	of	IN
18637	11371	44	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	11371	45	_	_	NNP
18637	11371	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	11371	47	_	_	NNP
18637	11371	48	Madison,[581	Madison,[581	NNP
18637	11371	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11371	50	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	11371	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11371	52	.	.	.
18637	11372	1	In	in	IN
18637	11372	2	holding	hold	VBG
18637	11372	3	void	void	JJ
18637	11372	4	the	the	DT
18637	11372	5	13th	13th	JJ
18637	11372	6	section	section	NN
18637	11372	7	of	of	IN
18637	11372	8	the	the	DT
18637	11372	9	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11372	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11372	11	of	of	IN
18637	11372	12	1789	1789	CD
18637	11372	13	,	,	,
18637	11372	14	which	which	WDT
18637	11372	15	was	be	VBD
18637	11372	16	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	11372	17	as	as	IN
18637	11372	18	giving	give	VBG
18637	11372	19	the	the	DT
18637	11372	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11372	21	power	power	NN
18637	11372	22	to	to	TO
18637	11372	23	issue	issue	VB
18637	11372	24	a	a	DT
18637	11372	25	writ	writ	NN
18637	11372	26	of	of	IN
18637	11372	27	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	11372	28	in	in	IN
18637	11372	29	an	an	DT
18637	11372	30	original	original	JJ
18637	11372	31	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	11372	32	,	,	,
18637	11372	33	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11372	34	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11372	35	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11372	36	declared	declare	VBD
18637	11372	37	that	that	IN
18637	11372	38	"	"	``
18637	11372	39	a	a	DT
18637	11372	40	negative	negative	JJ
18637	11372	41	or	or	CC
18637	11372	42	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11372	43	sense	sense	NN
18637	11372	44	"	"	''
18637	11372	45	had	have	VBD
18637	11372	46	to	to	TO
18637	11372	47	be	be	VB
18637	11372	48	given	give	VBN
18637	11372	49	to	to	IN
18637	11372	50	the	the	DT
18637	11372	51	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	11372	52	enunciation	enunciation	NN
18637	11372	53	of	of	IN
18637	11372	54	the	the	DT
18637	11372	55	cases	case	NNS
18637	11372	56	to	to	TO
18637	11372	57	which	which	WDT
18637	11372	58	original	original	JJ
18637	11372	59	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11372	60	extends	extend	NNS
18637	11372	61	.	.	.
18637	11373	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11373	2	582	582	CD
18637	11373	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11373	4	While	while	IN
18637	11373	5	the	the	DT
18637	11373	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	11373	7	that	that	IN
18637	11373	8	the	the	DT
18637	11373	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11373	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11373	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	11373	12	vested	vest	VBN
18637	11373	13	with	with	IN
18637	11373	14	original	original	JJ
18637	11373	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11373	16	by	by	IN
18637	11373	17	the	the	DT
18637	11373	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11373	19	and	and	CC
18637	11373	20	that	that	IN
18637	11373	21	this	this	DT
18637	11373	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11373	23	can	can	MD
18637	11373	24	not	not	RB
18637	11373	25	be	be	VB
18637	11373	26	extended	extend	VBN
18637	11373	27	or	or	CC
18637	11373	28	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	11373	29	deprives	deprive	NNS
18637	11373	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11373	31	of	of	IN
18637	11373	32	any	any	DT
18637	11373	33	power	power	NN
18637	11373	34	to	to	TO
18637	11373	35	define	define	VB
18637	11373	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11373	37	,	,	,
18637	11373	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11373	39	allows	allow	VBZ
18637	11373	40	a	a	DT
18637	11373	41	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	11373	42	latitude	latitude	NN
18637	11373	43	of	of	IN
18637	11373	44	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11373	45	to	to	IN
18637	11373	46	the	the	DT
18637	11373	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11373	48	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11373	49	.	.	.
18637	11374	1	In	in	IN
18637	11374	2	some	some	DT
18637	11374	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	11374	4	,	,	,
18637	11374	5	as	as	IN
18637	11374	6	in	in	IN
18637	11374	7	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	11374	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11374	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	11374	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11374	11	Holland,[583	Holland,[583	NNP
18637	11374	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11374	13	the	the	DT
18637	11374	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11374	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	11374	16	manifested	manifest	VBN
18637	11374	17	a	a	DT
18637	11374	18	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	11374	19	toward	toward	IN
18637	11374	20	a	a	DT
18637	11374	21	liberal	liberal	JJ
18637	11374	22	construction	construction	NN
18637	11374	23	of	of	IN
18637	11374	24	original	original	JJ
18637	11374	25	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11374	26	;	;	:
18637	11374	27	in	in	IN
18637	11374	28	others	other	NNS
18637	11374	29	,	,	,
18637	11374	30	as	as	IN
18637	11374	31	in	in	IN
18637	11374	32	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	11374	33	_	_	NNP
18637	11374	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	11374	35	_	_	NNP
18637	11374	36	Mellon,[584	Mellon,[584	NNP
18637	11374	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11374	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11374	39	has	have	VBZ
18637	11374	40	placed	place	VBN
18637	11374	41	a	a	DT
18637	11374	42	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	11374	43	construction	construction	NN
18637	11374	44	upon	upon	IN
18637	11374	45	the	the	DT
18637	11374	46	grant	grant	NN
18637	11374	47	through	through	IN
18637	11374	48	the	the	DT
18637	11374	49	device	device	NN
18637	11374	50	of	of	IN
18637	11374	51	a	a	DT
18637	11374	52	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	11374	53	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11374	54	of	of	IN
18637	11374	55	cases	case	NNS
18637	11374	56	and	and	CC
18637	11374	57	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11374	58	;	;	:
18637	11374	59	and	and	CC
18637	11374	60	in	in	IN
18637	11374	61	still	still	RB
18637	11374	62	other	other	JJ
18637	11374	63	cases	case	NNS
18637	11374	64	,	,	,
18637	11374	65	as	as	IN
18637	11374	66	in	in	IN
18637	11374	67	California	California	NNP
18637	11374	68	_	_	NNP
18637	11374	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	11374	70	_	_	NNP
18637	11374	71	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	11374	72	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	11374	73	Co	Co	NNP
18637	11374	74	.	.	.
18637	11374	75	,[585	,[585	NFP
18637	11374	76	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11374	77	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11374	78	has	have	VBZ
18637	11374	79	stated	state	VBN
18637	11374	80	that	that	IN
18637	11374	81	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11374	82	original	original	JJ
18637	11374	83	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11374	84	"	"	''
18637	11374	85	is	be	VBZ
18637	11374	86	limited	limited	JJ
18637	11374	87	and	and	CC
18637	11374	88	manifestly	manifestly	RB
18637	11374	89	to	to	TO
18637	11374	90	be	be	VB
18637	11374	91	sparingly	sparingly	RB
18637	11374	92	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	11374	93	,	,	,
18637	11374	94	and	and	CC
18637	11374	95	should	should	MD
18637	11374	96	not	not	RB
18637	11374	97	be	be	VB
18637	11374	98	expanded	expand	VBN
18637	11374	99	by	by	IN
18637	11374	100	construction	construction	NN
18637	11374	101	.	.	.
18637	11374	102	"	"	''
18637	11375	1	CONCURRENT	CONCURRENT	NNP
18637	11375	2	JURISDICTION	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11375	3	OF	of	IN
18637	11375	4	THE	the	DT
18637	11375	5	LOWER	lower	JJ
18637	11375	6	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	11375	7	COURTS	court	NNS
18637	11375	8	Although	although	IN
18637	11375	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11375	10	can	can	MD
18637	11375	11	neither	neither	CC
18637	11375	12	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	11375	13	nor	nor	CC
18637	11375	14	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	11375	15	the	the	DT
18637	11375	16	original	original	JJ
18637	11375	17	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11375	18	of	of	IN
18637	11375	19	the	the	DT
18637	11375	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11375	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11375	22	,	,	,
18637	11375	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11375	24	may	may	MD
18637	11375	25	vest	vest	VB
18637	11375	26	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	11375	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11375	28	in	in	IN
18637	11375	29	the	the	DT
18637	11375	30	lower	low	JJR
18637	11375	31	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11375	32	courts	court	NNS
18637	11375	33	in	in	IN
18637	11375	34	cases	case	NNS
18637	11375	35	over	over	IN
18637	11375	36	which	which	WDT
18637	11375	37	the	the	DT
18637	11375	38	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11375	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11375	40	has	have	VBZ
18637	11375	41	original	original	JJ
18637	11375	42	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11375	43	.	.	.
18637	11376	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11376	2	586	586	CD
18637	11376	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11376	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	11376	5	among	among	IN
18637	11376	6	the	the	DT
18637	11376	7	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	11376	8	given	give	VBN
18637	11376	9	for	for	IN
18637	11376	10	the	the	DT
18637	11376	11	decision	decision	NN
18637	11376	12	in	in	IN
18637	11376	13	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	11376	14	_	_	NNP
18637	11376	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	11376	16	_	_	NNP
18637	11376	17	Pelican	Pelican	NNP
18637	11376	18	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	11376	19	Co	Co	NNP
18637	11376	20	.	.	.
18637	11376	21	,[587	,[587	ADD
18637	11376	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11376	23	that	that	IN
18637	11376	24	the	the	DT
18637	11376	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11376	26	had	have	VBD
18637	11376	27	no	no	DT
18637	11376	28	original	original	JJ
18637	11376	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11376	30	of	of	IN
18637	11376	31	an	an	DT
18637	11376	32	action	action	NN
18637	11376	33	by	by	IN
18637	11376	34	a	a	DT
18637	11376	35	State	State	NNP
18637	11376	36	to	to	TO
18637	11376	37	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11376	38	a	a	DT
18637	11376	39	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11376	40	for	for	IN
18637	11376	41	a	a	DT
18637	11376	42	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
18637	11376	43	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	11376	44	awarded	award	VBN
18637	11376	45	by	by	IN
18637	11376	46	one	one	CD
18637	11376	47	of	of	IN
18637	11376	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11376	49	own	own	JJ
18637	11376	50	courts	court	NNS
18637	11376	51	,	,	,
18637	11376	52	was	be	VBD
18637	11376	53	the	the	DT
18637	11376	54	provision	provision	NN
18637	11376	55	of	of	IN
18637	11376	56	the	the	DT
18637	11376	57	13th	13th	JJ
18637	11376	58	section	section	NN
18637	11376	59	of	of	IN
18637	11376	60	the	the	DT
18637	11376	61	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11376	62	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11376	63	of	of	IN
18637	11376	64	1789[588	1789[588	CD
18637	11376	65	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11376	66	that	that	IN
18637	11376	67	"	"	``
18637	11376	68	the	the	DT
18637	11376	69	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11376	70	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11376	71	shall	shall	MD
18637	11376	72	have	have	VB
18637	11376	73	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11376	74	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11376	75	of	of	IN
18637	11376	76	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11376	77	of	of	IN
18637	11376	78	a	a	DT
18637	11376	79	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11376	80	nature	nature	NN
18637	11376	81	,	,	,
18637	11376	82	where	where	WRB
18637	11376	83	a	a	DT
18637	11376	84	State	state	NN
18637	11376	85	is	be	VBZ
18637	11376	86	a	a	DT
18637	11376	87	party	party	NN
18637	11376	88	,	,	,
18637	11376	89	except	except	IN
18637	11376	90	between	between	IN
18637	11376	91	a	a	DT
18637	11376	92	State	state	NN
18637	11376	93	and	and	CC
18637	11376	94	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11376	95	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11376	96	;	;	:
18637	11376	97	and	and	CC
18637	11376	98	except	except	IN
18637	11376	99	also	also	RB
18637	11376	100	between	between	IN
18637	11376	101	a	a	DT
18637	11376	102	State	state	NN
18637	11376	103	and	and	CC
18637	11376	104	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11376	105	of	of	IN
18637	11376	106	other	other	JJ
18637	11376	107	States	States	NNPS
18637	11376	108	,	,	,
18637	11376	109	or	or	CC
18637	11376	110	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	11376	111	,	,	,
18637	11376	112	in	in	IN
18637	11376	113	which	which	WDT
18637	11376	114	latter	latter	JJ
18637	11376	115	case	case	NN
18637	11376	116	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11376	117	shall	shall	MD
18637	11376	118	have	have	VB
18637	11376	119	original	original	JJ
18637	11376	120	but	but	CC
18637	11376	121	not	not	RB
18637	11376	122	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11376	123	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11376	124	.	.	.
18637	11376	125	"	"	''
18637	11377	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	11377	2	of	of	IN
18637	11377	3	that	that	DT
18637	11377	4	act	act	NN
18637	11377	5	with	with	IN
18637	11377	6	particular	particular	JJ
18637	11377	7	reference	reference	NN
18637	11377	8	to	to	IN
18637	11377	9	this	this	DT
18637	11377	10	section	section	NN
18637	11377	11	,	,	,
18637	11377	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11377	13	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	11377	14	declared	declare	VBD
18637	11377	15	that	that	IN
18637	11377	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11377	17	"	"	``
18637	11377	18	was	be	VBD
18637	11377	19	passed	pass	VBN
18637	11377	20	by	by	IN
18637	11377	21	the	the	DT
18637	11377	22	first	first	JJ
18637	11377	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11377	24	assembled	assemble	VBN
18637	11377	25	under	under	IN
18637	11377	26	the	the	DT
18637	11377	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11377	28	,	,	,
18637	11377	29	many	many	JJ
18637	11377	30	of	of	IN
18637	11377	31	whose	whose	WP$
18637	11377	32	members	member	NNS
18637	11377	33	had	have	VBD
18637	11377	34	taken	take	VBN
18637	11377	35	part	part	NN
18637	11377	36	in	in	IN
18637	11377	37	framing	frame	VBG
18637	11377	38	that	that	DT
18637	11377	39	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	11377	40	,	,	,
18637	11377	41	and	and	CC
18637	11377	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	11377	43	contemporaneous	contemporaneous	JJ
18637	11377	44	and	and	CC
18637	11377	45	weighty	weighty	JJ
18637	11377	46	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	11377	47	of	of	IN
18637	11377	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11377	49	true	true	JJ
18637	11377	50	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	11377	51	.	.	.
18637	11378	1	"	"	``
18637	11378	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11378	3	589	589	CD
18637	11378	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11378	5	In	in	IN
18637	11378	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	11378	7	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	11378	8	consuls	consul	NNS
18637	11378	9	,	,	,
18637	11378	10	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	11378	11	,	,	,
18637	11378	12	the	the	DT
18637	11378	13	original	original	JJ
18637	11378	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11378	15	of	of	IN
18637	11378	16	the	the	DT
18637	11378	17	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11378	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11378	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	11378	20	shared	share	VBN
18637	11378	21	concurrently	concurrently	RB
18637	11378	22	with	with	IN
18637	11378	23	State	State	NNP
18637	11378	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	11378	25	unless	unless	IN
18637	11378	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11378	27	by	by	IN
18637	11378	28	positive	positive	JJ
18637	11378	29	action	action	NN
18637	11378	30	makes	make	VBZ
18637	11378	31	such	such	JJ
18637	11378	32	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11378	33	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11378	34	.	.	.
18637	11379	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11379	2	590	590	CD
18637	11379	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11379	4	The	the	DT
18637	11379	5	Appellate	Appellate	NNP
18637	11379	6	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	11379	7	of	of	IN
18637	11379	8	the	the	DT
18637	11379	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11379	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11379	11	SUBJECT	SUBJECT	NNP
18637	11379	12	TO	to	IN
18637	11379	13	LIMITATION	limitation	NN
18637	11379	14	BY	by	IN
18637	11379	15	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	11379	16	Unlike	unlike	IN
18637	11379	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11379	18	original	original	JJ
18637	11379	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11379	20	,	,	,
18637	11379	21	the	the	DT
18637	11379	22	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	11379	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11379	24	of	of	IN
18637	11379	25	the	the	DT
18637	11379	26	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11379	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11379	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	11379	29	subject	subject	JJ
18637	11379	30	to	to	IN
18637	11379	31	control	control	NN
18637	11379	32	by	by	IN
18637	11379	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11379	34	in	in	IN
18637	11379	35	the	the	DT
18637	11379	36	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11379	37	of	of	IN
18637	11379	38	the	the	DT
18637	11379	39	broadest	broad	JJS
18637	11379	40	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	11379	41	.	.	.
18637	11380	1	Although	although	IN
18637	11380	2	the	the	DT
18637	11380	3	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	11380	4	of	of	IN
18637	11380	5	article	article	NN
18637	11380	6	III	iii	CD
18637	11380	7	seem	seem	VBP
18637	11380	8	,	,	,
18637	11380	9	superficially	superficially	RB
18637	11380	10	at	at	IN
18637	11380	11	least	least	JJS
18637	11380	12	,	,	,
18637	11380	13	to	to	TO
18637	11380	14	imply	imply	VB
18637	11380	15	that	that	IN
18637	11380	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11380	17	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	11380	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11380	19	would	would	MD
18637	11380	20	flow	flow	VB
18637	11380	21	directly	directly	RB
18637	11380	22	from	from	IN
18637	11380	23	the	the	DT
18637	11380	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11380	25	until	until	IN
18637	11380	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11380	27	should	should	MD
18637	11380	28	by	by	IN
18637	11380	29	positive	positive	JJ
18637	11380	30	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	11380	31	make	make	VB
18637	11380	32	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	11380	33	to	to	IN
18637	11380	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11380	35	,	,	,
18637	11380	36	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	11380	37	of	of	IN
18637	11380	38	the	the	DT
18637	11380	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11380	40	since	since	IN
18637	11380	41	1796	1796	CD
18637	11380	42	establish	establish	VB
18637	11380	43	the	the	DT
18637	11380	44	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	11380	45	rule	rule	NN
18637	11380	46	.	.	.
18637	11381	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	11381	2	,	,	,
18637	11381	3	before	before	IN
18637	11381	4	the	the	DT
18637	11381	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11381	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11381	7	can	can	MD
18637	11381	8	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	11381	9	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	11381	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11381	11	,	,	,
18637	11381	12	an	an	DT
18637	11381	13	act	act	NN
18637	11381	14	of	of	IN
18637	11381	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11381	16	must	must	MD
18637	11381	17	have	have	VB
18637	11381	18	bestowed	bestow	VBN
18637	11381	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11381	20	,	,	,
18637	11381	21	and	and	CC
18637	11381	22	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	11381	23	bestowals	bestowal	NNS
18637	11381	24	of	of	IN
18637	11381	25	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11381	26	are	be	VBP
18637	11381	27	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	11381	28	as	as	IN
18637	11381	29	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11381	30	in	in	IN
18637	11381	31	nature	nature	NN
18637	11381	32	so	so	IN
18637	11381	33	as	as	IN
18637	11381	34	to	to	TO
18637	11381	35	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	11381	36	an	an	DT
18637	11381	37	exception	exception	NN
18637	11381	38	to	to	IN
18637	11381	39	all	all	DT
18637	11381	40	other	other	JJ
18637	11381	41	cases	case	NNS
18637	11381	42	.	.	.
18637	11382	1	This	this	DT
18637	11382	2	rule	rule	NN
18637	11382	3	was	be	VBD
18637	11382	4	first	first	RB
18637	11382	5	applied	apply	VBN
18637	11382	6	in	in	IN
18637	11382	7	Wiscart	Wiscart	NNP
18637	11382	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11382	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	11382	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11382	11	Dauchy[591	Dauchy[591	NNP
18637	11382	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11382	13	where	where	WRB
18637	11382	14	the	the	DT
18637	11382	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11382	16	held	hold	VBD
18637	11382	17	that	that	IN
18637	11382	18	in	in	IN
18637	11382	19	the	the	DT
18637	11382	20	absence	absence	NN
18637	11382	21	of	of	IN
18637	11382	22	a	a	DT
18637	11382	23	statute	statute	NN
18637	11382	24	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	11382	25	a	a	DT
18637	11382	26	rule	rule	NN
18637	11382	27	for	for	IN
18637	11382	28	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	11382	29	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11382	30	,	,	,
18637	11382	31	the	the	DT
18637	11382	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11382	33	lacked	lack	VBD
18637	11382	34	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11382	35	.	.	.
18637	11383	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11383	2	was	be	VBD
18637	11383	3	further	further	RB
18637	11383	4	stated	state	VBN
18637	11383	5	that	that	IN
18637	11383	6	if	if	IN
18637	11383	7	a	a	DT
18637	11383	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	11383	9	were	be	VBD
18637	11383	10	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	11383	11	,	,	,
18637	11383	12	the	the	DT
18637	11383	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11383	14	could	could	MD
18637	11383	15	not	not	RB
18637	11383	16	depart	depart	VB
18637	11383	17	from	from	IN
18637	11383	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11383	19	.	.	.
18637	11384	1	Fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	11384	2	years	year	NNS
18637	11384	3	later	later	RB
18637	11384	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11384	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11384	6	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11384	7	observed	observe	VBD
18637	11384	8	for	for	IN
18637	11384	9	the	the	DT
18637	11384	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11384	11	that	that	WDT
18637	11384	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11384	13	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	11384	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11384	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	11384	16	derived	derive	VBN
18637	11384	17	from	from	IN
18637	11384	18	the	the	DT
18637	11384	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11384	20	,	,	,
18637	11384	21	but	but	CC
18637	11384	22	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	11384	23	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	11384	24	to	to	TO
18637	11384	25	hold	hold	VB
18637	11384	26	that	that	IN
18637	11384	27	an	an	DT
18637	11384	28	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	11384	29	bestowal	bestowal	NN
18637	11384	30	of	of	IN
18637	11384	31	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	11384	32	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11384	33	by	by	IN
18637	11384	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11384	35	,	,	,
18637	11384	36	which	which	WDT
18637	11384	37	made	make	VBD
18637	11384	38	no	no	DT
18637	11384	39	express	express	JJ
18637	11384	40	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	11384	41	to	to	IN
18637	11384	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11384	43	,	,	,
18637	11384	44	implied	imply	VBD
18637	11384	45	a	a	DT
18637	11384	46	denial	denial	NN
18637	11384	47	of	of	IN
18637	11384	48	all	all	DT
18637	11384	49	others	other	NNS
18637	11384	50	.	.	.
18637	11385	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11385	2	592	592	CD
18637	11385	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11385	4	The	the	DT
18637	11385	5	McCardle	McCardle	NNP
18637	11385	6	Case	case	NN
18637	11385	7	The	the	DT
18637	11385	8	power	power	NN
18637	11385	9	of	of	IN
18637	11385	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11385	11	to	to	TO
18637	11385	12	make	make	VB
18637	11385	13	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	11385	14	to	to	IN
18637	11385	15	the	the	DT
18637	11385	16	court	court	NN
18637	11385	17	's	's	POS
18637	11385	18	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	11385	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11385	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	11385	21	thus	thus	RB
18637	11385	22	become	become	VBN
18637	11385	23	,	,	,
18637	11385	24	in	in	IN
18637	11385	25	effect	effect	NN
18637	11385	26	,	,	,
18637	11385	27	a	a	DT
18637	11385	28	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	11385	29	power	power	NN
18637	11385	30	to	to	TO
18637	11385	31	bestow	bestow	VB
18637	11385	32	,	,	,
18637	11385	33	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	11385	34	,	,	,
18637	11385	35	and	and	CC
18637	11385	36	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	11385	37	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	11385	38	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11385	39	,	,	,
18637	11385	40	even	even	RB
18637	11385	41	to	to	IN
18637	11385	42	the	the	DT
18637	11385	43	point	point	NN
18637	11385	44	of	of	IN
18637	11385	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11385	46	abolition	abolition	NN
18637	11385	47	.	.	.
18637	11386	1	And	and	CC
18637	11386	2	this	this	DT
18637	11386	3	power	power	NN
18637	11386	4	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	11386	5	to	to	IN
18637	11386	6	the	the	DT
18637	11386	7	withdrawal	withdrawal	NN
18637	11386	8	of	of	IN
18637	11386	9	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	11386	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11386	11	even	even	RB
18637	11386	12	in	in	IN
18637	11386	13	pending	pende	VBG
18637	11386	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	11386	15	.	.	.
18637	11387	1	In	in	IN
18637	11387	2	the	the	DT
18637	11387	3	notable	notable	JJ
18637	11387	4	case	case	NN
18637	11387	5	of	of	IN
18637	11387	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11387	7	parte	parte	NNP
18637	11387	8	McCardle,[593	McCardle,[593	NNP
18637	11387	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11387	10	a	a	DT
18637	11387	11	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	11387	12	newspaper	newspaper	NN
18637	11387	13	editor	editor	NN
18637	11387	14	who	who	WP
18637	11387	15	was	be	VBD
18637	11387	16	being	be	VBG
18637	11387	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	11387	18	in	in	IN
18637	11387	19	custody	custody	NN
18637	11387	20	by	by	IN
18637	11387	21	the	the	DT
18637	11387	22	military	military	JJ
18637	11387	23	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	11387	24	acting	act	VBG
18637	11387	25	under	under	IN
18637	11387	26	the	the	DT
18637	11387	27	authority	authority	NN
18637	11387	28	of	of	IN
18637	11387	29	the	the	DT
18637	11387	30	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
18637	11387	31	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	11387	32	filed	file	VBD
18637	11387	33	a	a	DT
18637	11387	34	petition	petition	NN
18637	11387	35	for	for	IN
18637	11387	36	a	a	DT
18637	11387	37	writ	writ	NN
18637	11387	38	of	of	IN
18637	11387	39	_	_	NNP
18637	11387	40	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11387	41	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11387	42	_	_	NNP
18637	11387	43	in	in	IN
18637	11387	44	the	the	DT
18637	11387	45	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	11387	46	court	court	NN
18637	11387	47	for	for	IN
18637	11387	48	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	11387	49	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	11387	50	.	.	.
18637	11388	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11388	2	alleged	allege	VBD
18637	11388	3	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	11388	4	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	11388	5	and	and	CC
18637	11388	6	challenged	challenge	VBD
18637	11388	7	the	the	DT
18637	11388	8	validity	validity	NN
18637	11388	9	to	to	IN
18637	11388	10	the	the	DT
18637	11388	11	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
18637	11388	12	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	11388	13	.	.	.
18637	11389	1	The	the	DT
18637	11389	2	writ	writ	NNP
18637	11389	3	was	be	VBD
18637	11389	4	issued	issue	VBN
18637	11389	5	,	,	,
18637	11389	6	but	but	CC
18637	11389	7	after	after	IN
18637	11389	8	a	a	DT
18637	11389	9	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	11389	10	the	the	DT
18637	11389	11	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	11389	12	was	be	VBD
18637	11389	13	remanded	remand	VBN
18637	11389	14	to	to	IN
18637	11389	15	the	the	DT
18637	11389	16	custody	custody	NN
18637	11389	17	of	of	IN
18637	11389	18	the	the	DT
18637	11389	19	military	military	JJ
18637	11389	20	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	11389	21	.	.	.
18637	11390	1	McCardle	McCardle	NNP
18637	11390	2	then	then	RB
18637	11390	3	appealed	appeal	VBD
18637	11390	4	to	to	IN
18637	11390	5	the	the	DT
18637	11390	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11390	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11390	8	which	which	WDT
18637	11390	9	denied	deny	VBD
18637	11390	10	a	a	DT
18637	11390	11	motion	motion	NN
18637	11390	12	to	to	TO
18637	11390	13	dismiss	dismiss	VB
18637	11390	14	the	the	DT
18637	11390	15	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	11390	16	,	,	,
18637	11390	17	heard	hear	VBD
18637	11390	18	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	11390	19	on	on	IN
18637	11390	20	the	the	DT
18637	11390	21	merits	merit	NNS
18637	11390	22	of	of	IN
18637	11390	23	the	the	DT
18637	11390	24	case	case	NN
18637	11390	25	,	,	,
18637	11390	26	and	and	CC
18637	11390	27	took	take	VBD
18637	11390	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11390	29	under	under	IN
18637	11390	30	advisement	advisement	NN
18637	11390	31	.	.	.
18637	11391	1	Before	before	IN
18637	11391	2	a	a	DT
18637	11391	3	conference	conference	NN
18637	11391	4	could	could	MD
18637	11391	5	be	be	VB
18637	11391	6	held	hold	VBN
18637	11391	7	,	,	,
18637	11391	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11391	9	,	,	,
18637	11391	10	fearful	fearful	JJ
18637	11391	11	of	of	IN
18637	11391	12	a	a	DT
18637	11391	13	test	test	NN
18637	11391	14	of	of	IN
18637	11391	15	the	the	DT
18637	11391	16	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
18637	11391	17	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	11391	18	,	,	,
18637	11391	19	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	11391	20	a	a	DT
18637	11391	21	statute	statute	NN
18637	11391	22	withdrawing	withdraw	VBG
18637	11391	23	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	11391	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11391	25	from	from	IN
18637	11391	26	the	the	DT
18637	11391	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11391	28	in	in	IN
18637	11391	29	certain	certain	JJ
18637	11391	30	_	_	NNP
18637	11391	31	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11391	32	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11391	33	_	_	NNP
18637	11391	34	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11391	35	.	.	.
18637	11392	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11392	2	594	594	CD
18637	11392	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11392	4	The	the	DT
18637	11392	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11392	6	then	then	RB
18637	11392	7	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	11392	8	to	to	TO
18637	11392	9	dismiss	dismiss	VB
18637	11392	10	the	the	DT
18637	11392	11	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	11392	12	for	for	IN
18637	11392	13	want	want	NN
18637	11392	14	of	of	IN
18637	11392	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11392	16	.	.	.
18637	11393	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11393	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11393	3	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	11393	4	,	,	,
18637	11393	5	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	11393	6	for	for	IN
18637	11393	7	the	the	DT
18637	11393	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11393	9	said	say	VBD
18637	11393	10	:	:	:
18637	11393	11	"	"	``
18637	11393	12	Without	without	IN
18637	11393	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11393	14	the	the	DT
18637	11393	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11393	16	can	can	MD
18637	11393	17	not	not	RB
18637	11393	18	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	11393	19	at	at	RB
18637	11393	20	all	all	RB
18637	11393	21	in	in	IN
18637	11393	22	any	any	DT
18637	11393	23	cause	cause	NN
18637	11393	24	.	.	.
18637	11394	1	Jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11394	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	11394	3	the	the	DT
18637	11394	4	power	power	NN
18637	11394	5	to	to	TO
18637	11394	6	declare	declare	VB
18637	11394	7	the	the	DT
18637	11394	8	law	law	NN
18637	11394	9	and	and	CC
18637	11394	10	when	when	WRB
18637	11394	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11394	12	ceases	cease	VBZ
18637	11394	13	to	to	TO
18637	11394	14	exist	exist	VB
18637	11394	15	,	,	,
18637	11394	16	the	the	DT
18637	11394	17	only	only	JJ
18637	11394	18	function	function	NN
18637	11394	19	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	11394	20	to	to	IN
18637	11394	21	the	the	DT
18637	11394	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11394	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	11394	24	that	that	DT
18637	11394	25	of	of	IN
18637	11394	26	announcing	announce	VBG
18637	11394	27	the	the	DT
18637	11394	28	fact	fact	NN
18637	11394	29	and	and	CC
18637	11394	30	dismissing	dismiss	VBG
18637	11394	31	the	the	DT
18637	11394	32	cause	cause	NN
18637	11394	33	.	.	.
18637	11395	1	"	"	``
18637	11395	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11395	3	595	595	CD
18637	11395	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11395	5	Although	although	IN
18637	11395	6	the	the	DT
18637	11395	7	McCardle	McCardle	NNP
18637	11395	8	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11395	9	goes	go	VBZ
18637	11395	10	to	to	IN
18637	11395	11	the	the	DT
18637	11395	12	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	11395	13	in	in	IN
18637	11395	14	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	11395	15	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	11395	16	power	power	NN
18637	11395	17	over	over	IN
18637	11395	18	the	the	DT
18637	11395	19	court	court	NN
18637	11395	20	's	's	POS
18637	11395	21	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	11395	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11395	23	and	and	CC
18637	11395	24	although	although	IN
18637	11395	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11395	26	was	be	VBD
18637	11395	27	born	bear	VBN
18637	11395	28	of	of	IN
18637	11395	29	the	the	DT
18637	11395	30	stresses	stress	NNS
18637	11395	31	and	and	CC
18637	11395	32	tensions	tension	NNS
18637	11395	33	of	of	IN
18637	11395	34	the	the	DT
18637	11395	35	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
18637	11395	36	period	period	NN
18637	11395	37	,	,	,
18637	11395	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11395	39	has	have	VBZ
18637	11395	40	been	be	VBN
18637	11395	41	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	11395	42	reaffirmed	reaffirm	VBN
18637	11395	43	and	and	CC
18637	11395	44	approved	approve	VBN
18637	11395	45	.	.	.
18637	11396	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11396	2	596	596	CD
18637	11396	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11396	4	The	the	DT
18637	11396	5	result	result	NN
18637	11396	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	11396	7	to	to	TO
18637	11396	8	vest	vest	VB
18637	11396	9	an	an	DT
18637	11396	10	unrestrained	unrestrained	JJ
18637	11396	11	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	11396	12	in	in	IN
18637	11396	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11396	14	to	to	TO
18637	11396	15	curtail	curtail	VB
18637	11396	16	and	and	CC
18637	11396	17	even	even	RB
18637	11396	18	abolish	abolish	VB
18637	11396	19	the	the	DT
18637	11396	20	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	11396	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11396	22	of	of	IN
18637	11396	23	the	the	DT
18637	11396	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11396	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11396	26	,	,	,
18637	11396	27	and	and	CC
18637	11396	28	to	to	TO
18637	11396	29	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	11396	30	the	the	DT
18637	11396	31	manner	manner	NN
18637	11396	32	and	and	CC
18637	11396	33	forms	form	NNS
18637	11396	34	in	in	IN
18637	11396	35	which	which	WDT
18637	11396	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11396	37	may	may	MD
18637	11396	38	be	be	VB
18637	11396	39	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	11396	40	.	.	.
18637	11397	1	This	this	DT
18637	11397	2	principle	principle	NN
18637	11397	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	11397	4	well	well	RB
18637	11397	5	expressed	express	VBN
18637	11397	6	in	in	IN
18637	11397	7	The	the	DT
18637	11397	8	"	"	``
18637	11397	9	Francis	Francis	NNP
18637	11397	10	Wright"[597	Wright"[597	NNP
18637	11397	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11397	12	where	where	WRB
18637	11397	13	the	the	DT
18637	11397	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11397	15	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	11397	16	the	the	DT
18637	11397	17	validity	validity	NN
18637	11397	18	of	of	IN
18637	11397	19	an	an	DT
18637	11397	20	act	act	NN
18637	11397	21	of	of	IN
18637	11397	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11397	23	which	which	WDT
18637	11397	24	limited	limit	VBD
18637	11397	25	the	the	DT
18637	11397	26	court	court	NN
18637	11397	27	's	's	POS
18637	11397	28	review	review	NN
18637	11397	29	in	in	IN
18637	11397	30	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	11397	31	cases	case	NNS
18637	11397	32	to	to	IN
18637	11397	33	questions	question	NNS
18637	11397	34	of	of	IN
18637	11397	35	law	law	NN
18637	11397	36	appearing	appear	VBG
18637	11397	37	on	on	IN
18637	11397	38	the	the	DT
18637	11397	39	record	record	NN
18637	11397	40	.	.	.
18637	11398	1	A	a	DT
18637	11398	2	portion	portion	NN
18637	11398	3	of	of	IN
18637	11398	4	the	the	DT
18637	11398	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11398	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	11398	7	worthy	worthy	JJ
18637	11398	8	of	of	IN
18637	11398	9	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	11398	10	:	:	:
18637	11398	11	"	"	``
18637	11398	12	Authority	authority	NN
18637	11398	13	to	to	TO
18637	11398	14	limit	limit	VB
18637	11398	15	the	the	DT
18637	11398	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11398	17	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	11398	18	carries	carry	VBZ
18637	11398	19	with	with	IN
18637	11398	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11398	21	authority	authority	NN
18637	11398	22	to	to	TO
18637	11398	23	limit	limit	VB
18637	11398	24	the	the	DT
18637	11398	25	use	use	NN
18637	11398	26	of	of	IN
18637	11398	27	the	the	DT
18637	11398	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11398	29	.	.	.
18637	11399	1	Not	not	RB
18637	11399	2	only	only	RB
18637	11399	3	may	may	MD
18637	11399	4	whole	whole	VB
18637	11399	5	classes	class	NNS
18637	11399	6	of	of	IN
18637	11399	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	11399	8	be	be	VB
18637	11399	9	kept	keep	VBN
18637	11399	10	out	out	IN
18637	11399	11	of	of	IN
18637	11399	12	the	the	DT
18637	11399	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11399	14	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	11399	15	,	,	,
18637	11399	16	but	but	CC
18637	11399	17	particular	particular	JJ
18637	11399	18	classes	class	NNS
18637	11399	19	of	of	IN
18637	11399	20	questions	question	NNS
18637	11399	21	may	may	MD
18637	11399	22	be	be	VB
18637	11399	23	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	11399	24	to	to	IN
18637	11399	25	reexamination	reexamination	NN
18637	11399	26	and	and	CC
18637	11399	27	review	review	NN
18637	11399	28	,	,	,
18637	11399	29	while	while	IN
18637	11399	30	others	other	NNS
18637	11399	31	are	be	VBP
18637	11399	32	not	not	RB
18637	11399	33	.	.	.
18637	11400	1	To	to	IN
18637	11400	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11400	3	minds	mind	NNS
18637	11400	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11400	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	11400	6	no	no	DT
18637	11400	7	more	more	RBR
18637	11400	8	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	11400	9	to	to	TO
18637	11400	10	provide	provide	VB
18637	11400	11	that	that	IN
18637	11400	12	issues	issue	NNS
18637	11400	13	of	of	IN
18637	11400	14	fact	fact	NN
18637	11400	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	11400	16	not	not	RB
18637	11400	17	be	be	VB
18637	11400	18	retried	retry	VBN
18637	11400	19	in	in	IN
18637	11400	20	any	any	DT
18637	11400	21	case	case	NN
18637	11400	22	,	,	,
18637	11400	23	than	than	IN
18637	11400	24	that	that	IN
18637	11400	25	neither	neither	DT
18637	11400	26	issues	issue	NNS
18637	11400	27	of	of	IN
18637	11400	28	law	law	NN
18637	11400	29	nor	nor	CC
18637	11400	30	fact	fact	NN
18637	11400	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	11400	32	be	be	VB
18637	11400	33	retried	retry	VBN
18637	11400	34	in	in	IN
18637	11400	35	cases	case	NNS
18637	11400	36	where	where	WRB
18637	11400	37	the	the	DT
18637	11400	38	value	value	NN
18637	11400	39	of	of	IN
18637	11400	40	the	the	DT
18637	11400	41	matter	matter	NN
18637	11400	42	in	in	IN
18637	11400	43	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	11400	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	11400	45	less	less	JJR
18637	11400	46	than	than	IN
18637	11400	47	$	$	$
18637	11400	48	5,000	5,000	CD
18637	11400	49	.	.	.
18637	11401	1	The	the	DT
18637	11401	2	general	general	JJ
18637	11401	3	power	power	NN
18637	11401	4	to	to	TO
18637	11401	5	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	11401	6	implies	imply	VBZ
18637	11401	7	the	the	DT
18637	11401	8	power	power	NN
18637	11401	9	to	to	TO
18637	11401	10	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	11401	11	in	in	IN
18637	11401	12	all	all	DT
18637	11401	13	things	thing	NNS
18637	11401	14	.	.	.
18637	11402	1	The	the	DT
18637	11402	2	whole	whole	NN
18637	11402	3	of	of	IN
18637	11402	4	a	a	DT
18637	11402	5	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11402	6	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	11402	7	may	may	MD
18637	11402	8	be	be	VB
18637	11402	9	given	give	VBN
18637	11402	10	,	,	,
18637	11402	11	or	or	CC
18637	11402	12	a	a	DT
18637	11402	13	part	part	NN
18637	11402	14	.	.	.
18637	11403	1	The	the	DT
18637	11403	2	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11403	3	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	11403	4	are	be	VBP
18637	11403	5	all	all	DT
18637	11403	6	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	11403	7	if	if	IN
18637	11403	8	one	one	CD
18637	11403	9	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	11403	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	11403	11	had	have	VBN
18637	11403	12	for	for	IN
18637	11403	13	the	the	DT
18637	11403	14	trial	trial	NN
18637	11403	15	of	of	IN
18637	11403	16	all	all	DT
18637	11403	17	parts	part	NNS
18637	11403	18	of	of	IN
18637	11403	19	a	a	DT
18637	11403	20	case	case	NN
18637	11403	21	.	.	.
18637	11404	1	Everything	everything	NN
18637	11404	2	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	11404	3	that	that	DT
18637	11404	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	11404	5	a	a	DT
18637	11404	6	matter	matter	NN
18637	11404	7	of	of	IN
18637	11404	8	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	11404	9	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	11404	10	.	.	.
18637	11405	1	"	"	``
18637	11405	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11405	3	598	598	CD
18637	11405	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11405	5	The	the	DT
18637	11405	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	11405	7	of	of	IN
18637	11405	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11405	9	To	to	TO
18637	11405	10	Regulate	regulate	VB
18637	11405	11	the	the	DT
18637	11405	12	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	11405	13	of	of	IN
18637	11405	14	the	the	DT
18637	11405	15	Lower	Lower	NNP
18637	11405	16	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11405	17	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	11405	18	MARTIN	MARTIN	NNP
18637	11405	19	_	_	NNP
18637	11405	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	11405	21	_	_	NNP
18637	11405	22	HUNTER	HUNTER	NNP
18637	11405	23	'S	'S	NNP
18637	11405	24	LESSEE	LESSEE	NNP
18637	11405	25	The	the	DT
18637	11405	26	power	power	NN
18637	11405	27	of	of	IN
18637	11405	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11405	29	to	to	TO
18637	11405	30	vest	vest	NNP
18637	11405	31	,	,	,
18637	11405	32	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	11405	33	,	,	,
18637	11405	34	and	and	CC
18637	11405	35	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	11405	36	the	the	DT
18637	11405	37	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11405	38	of	of	IN
18637	11405	39	the	the	DT
18637	11405	40	lower	low	JJR
18637	11405	41	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11405	42	courts	court	NNS
18637	11405	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	11405	44	derived	derive	VBN
18637	11405	45	from	from	IN
18637	11405	46	the	the	DT
18637	11405	47	power	power	NN
18637	11405	48	to	to	TO
18637	11405	49	create	create	VB
18637	11405	50	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	11405	51	under	under	IN
18637	11405	52	article	article	NN
18637	11405	53	I	i	CD
18637	11405	54	,	,	,
18637	11405	55	the	the	DT
18637	11405	56	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11405	57	and	and	CC
18637	11405	58	proper	proper	JJ
18637	11405	59	clause	clause	NN
18637	11405	60	,	,	,
18637	11405	61	and	and	CC
18637	11405	62	the	the	DT
18637	11405	63	clause	clause	NN
18637	11405	64	in	in	IN
18637	11405	65	article	article	NN
18637	11405	66	III	iii	CD
18637	11405	67	,	,	,
18637	11405	68	vesting	vest	VBG
18637	11405	69	the	the	DT
18637	11405	70	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11405	71	power	power	NN
18637	11405	72	in	in	IN
18637	11405	73	the	the	DT
18637	11405	74	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11405	75	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11405	76	and	and	CC
18637	11405	77	such	such	JJ
18637	11405	78	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	11405	79	courts	court	NNS
18637	11405	80	as	as	IN
18637	11405	81	"	"	``
18637	11405	82	the	the	DT
18637	11405	83	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11405	84	may	may	MD
18637	11405	85	from	from	IN
18637	11405	86	time	time	NN
18637	11405	87	to	to	IN
18637	11405	88	time	time	NN
18637	11405	89	ordain	ordain	NN
18637	11405	90	and	and	CC
18637	11405	91	establish	establish	VB
18637	11405	92	.	.	.
18637	11405	93	"	"	''
18637	11406	1	Balancing	balance	VBG
18637	11406	2	these	these	DT
18637	11406	3	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	11406	4	,	,	,
18637	11406	5	however	however	RB
18637	11406	6	,	,	,
18637	11406	7	are	be	VBP
18637	11406	8	the	the	DT
18637	11406	9	phrases	phrase	NNS
18637	11406	10	in	in	IN
18637	11406	11	article	article	NN
18637	11406	12	III	iii	CD
18637	11406	13	to	to	IN
18637	11406	14	the	the	DT
18637	11406	15	effect	effect	NN
18637	11406	16	that	that	IN
18637	11406	17	the	the	DT
18637	11406	18	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11406	19	power	power	NN
18637	11406	20	"	"	''
18637	11406	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	11406	22	be	be	VB
18637	11406	23	vested	vest	VBN
18637	11406	24	"	"	''
18637	11406	25	in	in	IN
18637	11406	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	11406	27	and	and	CC
18637	11406	28	"	"	``
18637	11406	29	shall	shall	MD
18637	11406	30	extend	extend	VB
18637	11406	31	"	"	''
18637	11406	32	to	to	IN
18637	11406	33	nine	nine	CD
18637	11406	34	classes	class	NNS
18637	11406	35	of	of	IN
18637	11406	36	cases	case	NNS
18637	11406	37	and	and	CC
18637	11406	38	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11406	39	and	and	CC
18637	11406	40	the	the	DT
18637	11406	41	question	question	NN
18637	11406	42	of	of	IN
18637	11406	43	what	what	WP
18637	11406	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	11406	45	the	the	DT
18637	11406	46	force	force	NN
18637	11406	47	of	of	IN
18637	11406	48	the	the	DT
18637	11406	49	word	word	NN
18637	11406	50	"	"	``
18637	11406	51	shall	shall	MD
18637	11406	52	.	.	.
18637	11406	53	"	"	''
18637	11407	1	In	in	IN
18637	11407	2	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	11407	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11407	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	11407	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11407	6	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	11407	7	's	's	POS
18637	11407	8	Lessee,[599	lessee,[599	CD
18637	11407	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11407	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11407	11	Story	Story	NNP
18637	11407	12	declared	declare	VBD
18637	11407	13	obiter	obiter	NN
18637	11407	14	that	that	IN
18637	11407	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11407	16	was	be	VBD
18637	11407	17	imperative	imperative	JJ
18637	11407	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	11407	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11407	20	to	to	TO
18637	11407	21	create	create	VB
18637	11407	22	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	11407	23	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11407	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	11407	25	and	and	CC
18637	11407	26	vest	vest	NN
18637	11407	27	in	in	IN
18637	11407	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11407	29	all	all	PDT
18637	11407	30	the	the	DT
18637	11407	31	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11407	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11407	33	were	be	VBD
18637	11407	34	capable	capable	JJ
18637	11407	35	of	of	IN
18637	11407	36	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	11407	37	.	.	.
18637	11408	1	This	this	DT
18637	11408	2	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	11408	3	was	be	VBD
18637	11408	4	criticized	criticize	VBN
18637	11408	5	by	by	IN
18637	11408	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11408	7	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	11408	8	in	in	IN
18637	11408	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11408	10	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11408	11	,	,	,
18637	11408	12	in	in	IN
18637	11408	13	which	which	WDT
18637	11408	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11408	15	contended	contend	VBD
18637	11408	16	that	that	IN
18637	11408	17	the	the	DT
18637	11408	18	word	word	NN
18637	11408	19	"	"	``
18637	11408	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	11408	21	"	"	''
18637	11408	22	was	be	VBD
18637	11408	23	used	use	VBN
18637	11408	24	"	"	''
18637	11408	25	in	in	IN
18637	11408	26	the	the	DT
18637	11408	27	future	future	JJ
18637	11408	28	sense	sense	NN
18637	11408	29	,	,	,
18637	11408	30	"	"	''
18637	11408	31	and	and	CC
18637	11408	32	had	have	VBD
18637	11408	33	"	"	``
18637	11408	34	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	11408	35	imperative	imperative	JJ
18637	11408	36	in	in	IN
18637	11408	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11408	38	.	.	.
18637	11409	1	"	"	``
18637	11409	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11409	3	600	600	CD
18637	11409	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11409	5	And	and	CC
18637	11409	6	for	for	IN
18637	11409	7	that	that	DT
18637	11409	8	matter	matter	NN
18637	11409	9	in	in	IN
18637	11409	10	another	another	DT
18637	11409	11	portion	portion	NN
18637	11409	12	of	of	IN
18637	11409	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11409	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11409	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11409	16	Story	Story	NNP
18637	11409	17	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	11409	18	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	11409	19	that	that	IN
18637	11409	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11409	21	may	may	MD
18637	11409	22	create	create	VB
18637	11409	23	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	11409	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	11409	25	and	and	CC
18637	11409	26	"	"	``
18637	11409	27	parcel	parcel	VB
18637	11409	28	out	out	RP
18637	11409	29	such	such	JJ
18637	11409	30	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11409	31	among	among	IN
18637	11409	32	such	such	JJ
18637	11409	33	courts	court	NNS
18637	11409	34	,	,	,
18637	11409	35	from	from	IN
18637	11409	36	time	time	NN
18637	11409	37	to	to	IN
18637	11409	38	time	time	NN
18637	11409	39	at	at	IN
18637	11409	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11409	41	own	own	JJ
18637	11409	42	pleasure";[601	pleasure";[601	.
18637	11409	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11409	44	and	and	CC
18637	11409	45	in	in	IN
18637	11409	46	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11409	47	Commentaries	commentary	NNS
18637	11409	48	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11409	49	took	take	VBD
18637	11409	50	a	a	DT
18637	11409	51	broad	broad	JJ
18637	11409	52	view	view	NN
18637	11409	53	of	of	IN
18637	11409	54	the	the	DT
18637	11409	55	power	power	NN
18637	11409	56	of	of	IN
18637	11409	57	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11409	58	to	to	TO
18637	11409	59	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	11409	60	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11409	61	.	.	.
18637	11410	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11410	2	602	602	CD
18637	11410	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11410	4	PLENARY	PLENARY	NNP
18637	11410	5	POWER	power	NN
18637	11410	6	OF	of	IN
18637	11410	7	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	11410	8	OVER	over	IN
18637	11410	9	JURISDICTION	JURISDICTION	NNP
18637	11410	10	Neither	neither	CC
18637	11410	11	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	11410	12	construction	construction	NN
18637	11410	13	nor	nor	CC
18637	11410	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11410	15	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11410	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	11410	17	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	11410	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11410	19	Story	Story	NNP
18637	11410	20	's	's	POS
18637	11410	21	position	position	NN
18637	11410	22	in	in	IN
18637	11410	23	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	11410	24	_	_	NNP
18637	11410	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	11410	26	_	_	NNP
18637	11410	27	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	11410	28	's	's	POS
18637	11410	29	Lessee	Lessee	NNP
18637	11410	30	.	.	.
18637	11411	1	The	the	DT
18637	11411	2	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11411	3	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11411	4	of	of	IN
18637	11411	5	1789	1789	CD
18637	11411	6	,	,	,
18637	11411	7	which	which	WDT
18637	11411	8	was	be	VBD
18637	11411	9	a	a	DT
18637	11411	10	contemporaneous	contemporaneous	JJ
18637	11411	11	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11411	12	of	of	IN
18637	11411	13	the	the	DT
18637	11411	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11411	15	by	by	IN
18637	11411	16	the	the	DT
18637	11411	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11411	18	,	,	,
18637	11411	19	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	11411	20	on	on	IN
18637	11411	21	the	the	DT
18637	11411	22	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	11411	23	of	of	IN
18637	11411	24	a	a	DT
18637	11411	25	broad	broad	JJ
18637	11411	26	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	11411	27	on	on	IN
18637	11411	28	the	the	DT
18637	11411	29	part	part	NN
18637	11411	30	of	of	IN
18637	11411	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11411	32	to	to	TO
18637	11411	33	create	create	VB
18637	11411	34	courts	court	NNS
18637	11411	35	and	and	CC
18637	11411	36	to	to	TO
18637	11411	37	grant	grant	VB
18637	11411	38	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11411	39	to	to	IN
18637	11411	40	and	and	CC
18637	11411	41	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	11411	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11411	43	from	from	IN
18637	11411	44	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11411	45	.	.	.
18637	11412	1	This	this	DT
18637	11412	2	act	act	NN
18637	11412	3	conferred	confer	VBD
18637	11412	4	original	original	JJ
18637	11412	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11412	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	11412	7	the	the	DT
18637	11412	8	district	district	NN
18637	11412	9	and	and	CC
18637	11412	10	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	11412	11	courts	court	NNS
18637	11412	12	in	in	IN
18637	11412	13	certain	certain	JJ
18637	11412	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	11412	15	,	,	,
18637	11412	16	but	but	CC
18637	11412	17	by	by	IN
18637	11412	18	no	no	DT
18637	11412	19	means	means	NN
18637	11412	20	all	all	DT
18637	11412	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11412	22	were	be	VBD
18637	11412	23	capable	capable	JJ
18637	11412	24	of	of	IN
18637	11412	25	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	11412	26	.	.	.
18637	11413	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	11413	2	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11413	3	at	at	IN
18637	11413	4	the	the	DT
18637	11413	5	common	common	JJ
18637	11413	6	law	law	NN
18637	11413	7	to	to	TO
18637	11413	8	which	which	WDT
18637	11413	9	the	the	DT
18637	11413	10	United	United	NNP
18637	11413	11	States	States	NNP
18637	11413	12	was	be	VBD
18637	11413	13	a	a	DT
18637	11413	14	party	party	NN
18637	11413	15	were	be	VBD
18637	11413	16	limited	limit	VBN
18637	11413	17	by	by	IN
18637	11413	18	the	the	DT
18637	11413	19	amount	amount	NN
18637	11413	20	in	in	IN
18637	11413	21	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	11413	22	.	.	.
18637	11414	1	Except	except	IN
18637	11414	2	for	for	IN
18637	11414	3	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	11414	4	against	against	IN
18637	11414	5	the	the	DT
18637	11414	6	United	United	NNP
18637	11414	7	States	States	NNP
18637	11414	8	,	,	,
18637	11414	9	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	11414	10	and	and	CC
18637	11414	11	forfeitures	forfeiture	NNS
18637	11414	12	made	make	VBN
18637	11414	13	under	under	IN
18637	11414	14	the	the	DT
18637	11414	15	impost	impost	NN
18637	11414	16	,	,	,
18637	11414	17	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	11414	18	,	,	,
18637	11414	19	or	or	CC
18637	11414	20	trade	trade	NN
18637	11414	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	11414	22	of	of	IN
18637	11414	23	the	the	DT
18637	11414	24	United	United	NNP
18637	11414	25	States	States	NNP
18637	11414	26	,	,	,
18637	11414	27	and	and	CC
18637	11414	28	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11414	29	by	by	IN
18637	11414	30	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	11414	31	under	under	IN
18637	11414	32	International	International	NNP
18637	11414	33	Law	Law	NNP
18637	11414	34	or	or	CC
18637	11414	35	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	11414	36	,	,	,
18637	11414	37	that	that	DT
18637	11414	38	whole	whole	JJ
18637	11414	39	group	group	NN
18637	11414	40	of	of	IN
18637	11414	41	cases	case	NNS
18637	11414	42	involving	involve	VBG
18637	11414	43	the	the	DT
18637	11414	44	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11414	45	,	,	,
18637	11414	46	laws	law	NNS
18637	11414	47	,	,	,
18637	11414	48	and	and	CC
18637	11414	49	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	11414	50	of	of	IN
18637	11414	51	the	the	DT
18637	11414	52	United	United	NNP
18637	11414	53	States	States	NNP
18637	11414	54	was	be	VBD
18637	11414	55	withheld	withhold	VBN
18637	11414	56	from	from	IN
18637	11414	57	the	the	DT
18637	11414	58	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11414	59	of	of	IN
18637	11414	60	the	the	DT
18637	11414	61	district	district	NN
18637	11414	62	and	and	CC
18637	11414	63	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	11414	64	courts,[603	courts,[603	NNP
18637	11414	65	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11414	66	with	with	IN
18637	11414	67	the	the	DT
18637	11414	68	result	result	NN
18637	11414	69	that	that	IN
18637	11414	70	original	original	JJ
18637	11414	71	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11414	72	in	in	IN
18637	11414	73	these	these	DT
18637	11414	74	cases	case	NNS
18637	11414	75	was	be	VBD
18637	11414	76	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	11414	77	by	by	IN
18637	11414	78	the	the	DT
18637	11414	79	State	State	NNP
18637	11414	80	courts	court	NNS
18637	11414	81	subject	subject	JJ
18637	11414	82	to	to	IN
18637	11414	83	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	11414	84	to	to	IN
18637	11414	85	the	the	DT
18637	11414	86	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11414	87	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11414	88	under	under	IN
18637	11414	89	section	section	NN
18637	11414	90	25	25	CD
18637	11414	91	.	.	.
18637	11415	1	Jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11415	2	was	be	VBD
18637	11415	3	vested	vest	VBN
18637	11415	4	in	in	IN
18637	11415	5	the	the	DT
18637	11415	6	district	district	NN
18637	11415	7	courts	court	NNS
18637	11415	8	over	over	IN
18637	11415	9	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11415	10	and	and	CC
18637	11415	11	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11415	12	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11415	13	and	and	CC
18637	11415	14	in	in	IN
18637	11415	15	the	the	DT
18637	11415	16	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	11415	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	11415	18	over	over	IN
18637	11415	19	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11415	20	between	between	IN
18637	11415	21	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11415	22	of	of	IN
18637	11415	23	different	different	JJ
18637	11415	24	States	state	NNS
18637	11415	25	where	where	WRB
18637	11415	26	the	the	DT
18637	11415	27	amount	amount	NN
18637	11415	28	exceeded	exceed	VBD
18637	11415	29	$	$	$
18637	11415	30	500	500	CD
18637	11415	31	,	,	,
18637	11415	32	or	or	CC
18637	11415	33	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11415	34	to	to	TO
18637	11415	35	which	which	WDT
18637	11415	36	an	an	DT
18637	11415	37	alien	alien	NN
18637	11415	38	was	be	VBD
18637	11415	39	a	a	DT
18637	11415	40	party	party	NN
18637	11415	41	.	.	.
18637	11416	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11416	2	604	604	CD
18637	11416	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11416	4	The	the	DT
18637	11416	5	act	act	NN
18637	11416	6	of	of	IN
18637	11416	7	1789	1789	CD
18637	11416	8	empowered	empower	VBD
18637	11416	9	the	the	DT
18637	11416	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	11416	11	to	to	TO
18637	11416	12	issue	issue	VB
18637	11416	13	writs	writ	NNS
18637	11416	14	,	,	,
18637	11416	15	to	to	TO
18637	11416	16	require	require	VB
18637	11416	17	parties	party	NNS
18637	11416	18	to	to	TO
18637	11416	19	produce	produce	VB
18637	11416	20	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	11416	21	,	,	,
18637	11416	22	to	to	TO
18637	11416	23	punish	punish	VB
18637	11416	24	contempts	contempt	NNS
18637	11416	25	,	,	,
18637	11416	26	to	to	TO
18637	11416	27	make	make	VB
18637	11416	28	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11416	29	,	,	,
18637	11416	30	and	and	CC
18637	11416	31	to	to	TO
18637	11416	32	grant	grant	VB
18637	11416	33	stays	stay	NNS
18637	11416	34	of	of	IN
18637	11416	35	execution	execution	NN
18637	11416	36	.	.	.
18637	11417	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11417	2	605	605	CD
18637	11417	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11417	4	Finally	finally	RB
18637	11417	5	,	,	,
18637	11417	6	equity	equity	NN
18637	11417	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11417	8	was	be	VBD
18637	11417	9	limited	limit	VBN
18637	11417	10	to	to	IN
18637	11417	11	those	those	DT
18637	11417	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	11417	13	where	where	WRB
18637	11417	14	a	a	DT
18637	11417	15	"	"	``
18637	11417	16	plain	plain	JJ
18637	11417	17	,	,	,
18637	11417	18	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	11417	19	,	,	,
18637	11417	20	and	and	CC
18637	11417	21	complete	complete	JJ
18637	11417	22	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	11417	23	"	"	''
18637	11417	24	could	could	MD
18637	11417	25	not	not	RB
18637	11417	26	be	be	VB
18637	11417	27	had	have	VBN
18637	11417	28	at	at	IN
18637	11417	29	law	law	NN
18637	11417	30	.	.	.
18637	11418	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11418	2	606	606	CD
18637	11418	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11418	4	This	this	DT
18637	11418	5	care	care	NN
18637	11418	6	for	for	IN
18637	11418	7	detail	detail	NN
18637	11418	8	in	in	IN
18637	11418	9	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	11418	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11418	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	11418	12	the	the	DT
18637	11418	13	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	11418	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	11418	15	and	and	CC
18637	11418	16	vesting	vest	VBG
18637	11418	17	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11418	18	with	with	IN
18637	11418	19	ancillary	ancillary	JJ
18637	11418	20	powers	power	NNS
18637	11418	21	in	in	IN
18637	11418	22	order	order	NN
18637	11418	23	to	to	TO
18637	11418	24	render	render	VB
18637	11418	25	such	such	JJ
18637	11418	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11418	27	effective	effective	JJ
18637	11418	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	11418	29	of	of	IN
18637	11418	30	the	the	DT
18637	11418	31	utmost	utmost	JJ
18637	11418	32	significance	significance	NN
18637	11418	33	in	in	IN
18637	11418	34	the	the	DT
18637	11418	35	later	later	JJ
18637	11418	36	development	development	NN
18637	11418	37	of	of	IN
18637	11418	38	the	the	DT
18637	11418	39	law	law	NN
18637	11418	40	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	11418	41	to	to	IN
18637	11418	42	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	11418	43	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	11418	44	of	of	IN
18637	11418	45	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11418	46	,	,	,
18637	11418	47	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	11418	48	as	as	IN
18637	11418	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11418	50	demonstrates	demonstrate	VBZ
18637	11418	51	conclusively	conclusively	RB
18637	11418	52	that	that	IN
18637	11418	53	a	a	DT
18637	11418	54	majority	majority	NN
18637	11418	55	of	of	IN
18637	11418	56	the	the	DT
18637	11418	57	members	member	NNS
18637	11418	58	of	of	IN
18637	11418	59	the	the	DT
18637	11418	60	first	first	JJ
18637	11418	61	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11418	62	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	11418	63	positive	positive	JJ
18637	11418	64	action	action	NN
18637	11418	65	on	on	IN
18637	11418	66	the	the	DT
18637	11418	67	part	part	NN
18637	11418	68	of	of	IN
18637	11418	69	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11418	70	to	to	TO
18637	11418	71	be	be	VB
18637	11418	72	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11418	73	before	before	IN
18637	11418	74	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11418	75	and	and	CC
18637	11418	76	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11418	77	powers	power	NNS
18637	11418	78	could	could	MD
18637	11418	79	be	be	VB
18637	11418	80	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	11418	81	by	by	IN
18637	11418	82	courts	court	NNS
18637	11418	83	of	of	IN
18637	11418	84	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11418	85	own	own	JJ
18637	11418	86	creation	creation	NN
18637	11418	87	.	.	.
18637	11419	1	Ten	ten	CD
18637	11419	2	years	year	NNS
18637	11419	3	later	later	RB
18637	11419	4	this	this	DT
18637	11419	5	practical	practical	JJ
18637	11419	6	construction	construction	NN
18637	11419	7	of	of	IN
18637	11419	8	article	article	NN
18637	11419	9	III	iii	CD
18637	11419	10	was	be	VBD
18637	11419	11	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	11419	12	by	by	IN
18637	11419	13	the	the	DT
18637	11419	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11419	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11419	16	in	in	IN
18637	11419	17	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	11419	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11419	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	11419	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11419	21	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	11419	22	of	of	IN
18637	11419	23	North	North	NNP
18637	11419	24	America	America	NNP
18637	11419	25	.	.	.
18637	11420	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11420	2	607	607	CD
18637	11420	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11420	4	The	the	DT
18637	11420	5	case	case	NN
18637	11420	6	involved	involve	VBD
18637	11420	7	an	an	DT
18637	11420	8	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	11420	9	to	to	TO
18637	11420	10	recover	recover	VB
18637	11420	11	on	on	IN
18637	11420	12	a	a	DT
18637	11420	13	promissory	promissory	JJ
18637	11420	14	note	note	NN
18637	11420	15	in	in	IN
18637	11420	16	a	a	DT
18637	11420	17	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11420	18	case	case	NN
18637	11420	19	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	11420	20	to	to	IN
18637	11420	21	§	§	NNP
18637	11420	22	11	11	CD
18637	11420	23	of	of	IN
18637	11420	24	the	the	DT
18637	11420	25	act	act	NN
18637	11420	26	of	of	IN
18637	11420	27	1789	1789	CD
18637	11420	28	which	which	WDT
18637	11420	29	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	11420	30	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11420	31	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11420	32	involving	involve	VBG
18637	11420	33	assignments	assignment	NNS
18637	11420	34	unless	unless	IN
18637	11420	35	the	the	DT
18637	11420	36	suit	suit	NN
18637	11420	37	was	be	VBD
18637	11420	38	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11420	39	before	before	RB
18637	11420	40	the	the	DT
18637	11420	41	assignment	assignment	NN
18637	11420	42	was	be	VBD
18637	11420	43	made	make	VBN
18637	11420	44	.	.	.
18637	11421	1	Counsel	counsel	NN
18637	11421	2	for	for	IN
18637	11421	3	the	the	DT
18637	11421	4	bank	bank	NN
18637	11421	5	argued	argue	VBD
18637	11421	6	that	that	IN
18637	11421	7	the	the	DT
18637	11421	8	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	11421	9	courts	court	NNS
18637	11421	10	were	be	VBD
18637	11421	11	not	not	RB
18637	11421	12	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	11421	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	11421	14	and	and	CC
18637	11421	15	that	that	IN
18637	11421	16	the	the	DT
18637	11421	17	grant	grant	NN
18637	11421	18	of	of	IN
18637	11421	19	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11421	20	power	power	NN
18637	11421	21	by	by	IN
18637	11421	22	the	the	DT
18637	11421	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11421	24	was	be	VBD
18637	11421	25	a	a	DT
18637	11421	26	direct	direct	JJ
18637	11421	27	grant	grant	NN
18637	11421	28	of	of	IN
18637	11421	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11421	30	.	.	.
18637	11422	1	This	this	DT
18637	11422	2	argument	argument	NN
18637	11422	3	evoked	evoke	VBD
18637	11422	4	questions	question	NNS
18637	11422	5	from	from	IN
18637	11422	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11422	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11422	8	Ellsworth	Ellsworth	NNP
18637	11422	9	and	and	CC
18637	11422	10	the	the	DT
18637	11422	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	11422	12	statement	statement	NN
18637	11422	13	from	from	IN
18637	11422	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11422	15	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	11422	16	:	:	:
18637	11422	17	"	"	``
18637	11422	18	The	the	DT
18637	11422	19	notion	notion	NN
18637	11422	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	11422	21	been	be	VBN
18637	11422	22	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	11422	23	entertained	entertain	VBN
18637	11422	24	,	,	,
18637	11422	25	that	that	IN
18637	11422	26	the	the	DT
18637	11422	27	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11422	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	11422	29	derive	derive	VBP
18637	11422	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11422	31	power	power	NN
18637	11422	32	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	11422	33	from	from	IN
18637	11422	34	the	the	DT
18637	11422	35	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11422	36	;	;	:
18637	11422	37	but	but	CC
18637	11422	38	the	the	DT
18637	11422	39	political	political	JJ
18637	11422	40	truth	truth	NN
18637	11422	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	11422	42	,	,	,
18637	11422	43	that	that	IN
18637	11422	44	the	the	DT
18637	11422	45	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11422	46	power	power	NN
18637	11422	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11422	48	except	except	IN
18637	11422	49	in	in	IN
18637	11422	50	a	a	DT
18637	11422	51	few	few	JJ
18637	11422	52	specified	specified	JJ
18637	11422	53	instances	instance	NNS
18637	11422	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11422	55	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	11422	56	to	to	IN
18637	11422	57	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11422	58	.	.	.
18637	11423	1	If	if	IN
18637	11423	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11423	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	11423	4	given	give	VBN
18637	11423	5	the	the	DT
18637	11423	6	power	power	NN
18637	11423	7	to	to	IN
18637	11423	8	this	this	DT
18637	11423	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11423	10	,	,	,
18637	11423	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11423	12	possess	possess	VBP
18637	11423	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11423	14	,	,	,
18637	11423	15	not	not	RB
18637	11423	16	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	11423	17	;	;	:
18637	11423	18	and	and	CC
18637	11423	19	if	if	IN
18637	11423	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11423	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	11423	22	not	not	RB
18637	11423	23	given	give	VBN
18637	11423	24	the	the	DT
18637	11423	25	power	power	NN
18637	11423	26	to	to	IN
18637	11423	27	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11423	28	,	,	,
18637	11423	29	or	or	CC
18637	11423	30	to	to	IN
18637	11423	31	any	any	DT
18637	11423	32	other	other	JJ
18637	11423	33	court	court	NN
18637	11423	34	,	,	,
18637	11423	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11423	36	still	still	RB
18637	11423	37	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	11423	38	at	at	IN
18637	11423	39	the	the	DT
18637	11423	40	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	11423	41	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	11423	42	.	.	.
18637	11424	1	Besides	besides	RB
18637	11424	2	,	,	,
18637	11424	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11424	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	11424	5	not	not	RB
18637	11424	6	bound	bind	VBN
18637	11424	7	,	,	,
18637	11424	8	and	and	CC
18637	11424	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11424	10	would	would	MD
18637	11424	11	,	,	,
18637	11424	12	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	11424	13	,	,	,
18637	11424	14	be	be	VB
18637	11424	15	inexpedient	inexpedient	JJ
18637	11424	16	,	,	,
18637	11424	17	to	to	TO
18637	11424	18	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	11424	19	the	the	DT
18637	11424	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11424	21	of	of	IN
18637	11424	22	the	the	DT
18637	11424	23	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11424	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	11424	25	,	,	,
18637	11424	26	to	to	IN
18637	11424	27	every	every	DT
18637	11424	28	subject	subject	NN
18637	11424	29	,	,	,
18637	11424	30	in	in	IN
18637	11424	31	every	every	DT
18637	11424	32	form	form	NN
18637	11424	33	,	,	,
18637	11424	34	which	which	WDT
18637	11424	35	the	the	DT
18637	11424	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11424	37	might	may	MD
18637	11424	38	warrant	warrant	VB
18637	11424	39	.	.	.
18637	11425	1	"	"	``
18637	11425	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11425	3	608	608	CD
18637	11425	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11425	5	The	the	DT
18637	11425	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11425	7	applied	apply	VBD
18637	11425	8	§	â§	NN
18637	11425	9	11	11	CD
18637	11425	10	of	of	IN
18637	11425	11	the	the	DT
18637	11425	12	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11425	13	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11425	14	and	and	CC
18637	11425	15	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	11425	16	that	that	IN
18637	11425	17	the	the	DT
18637	11425	18	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	11425	19	court	court	NN
18637	11425	20	lacked	lack	VBD
18637	11425	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11425	22	.	.	.
18637	11426	1	Eight	eight	CD
18637	11426	2	years	year	NNS
18637	11426	3	later	later	RB
18637	11426	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11426	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11426	6	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11426	7	in	in	IN
18637	11426	8	distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
18637	11426	9	between	between	IN
18637	11426	10	common	common	JJ
18637	11426	11	law	law	NN
18637	11426	12	and	and	CC
18637	11426	13	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	11426	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	11426	15	declared	declare	VBD
18637	11426	16	that	that	IN
18637	11426	17	"	"	``
18637	11426	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	11426	19	which	which	WDT
18637	11426	20	are	be	VBP
18637	11426	21	created	create	VBN
18637	11426	22	by	by	IN
18637	11426	23	written	write	VBN
18637	11426	24	law	law	NN
18637	11426	25	,	,	,
18637	11426	26	and	and	CC
18637	11426	27	whose	whose	WP$
18637	11426	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11426	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	11426	30	defined	define	VBN
18637	11426	31	by	by	IN
18637	11426	32	written	write	VBN
18637	11426	33	law	law	NN
18637	11426	34	,	,	,
18637	11426	35	can	can	MD
18637	11426	36	not	not	RB
18637	11426	37	transcend	transcend	VB
18637	11426	38	that	that	DT
18637	11426	39	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11426	40	.	.	.
18637	11427	1	"	"	``
18637	11427	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11427	3	609	609	CD
18637	11427	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11427	5	This	this	DT
18637	11427	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	11427	7	was	be	VBD
18637	11427	8	reaffirmed	reaffirm	VBN
18637	11427	9	in	in	IN
18637	11427	10	the	the	DT
18637	11427	11	famous	famous	JJ
18637	11427	12	case	case	NN
18637	11427	13	of	of	IN
18637	11427	14	United	United	NNP
18637	11427	15	States	States	NNP
18637	11427	16	_	_	NNP
18637	11427	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	11427	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11427	19	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	11427	20	and	and	CC
18637	11427	21	Goodwin[610	Goodwin[610	NNP
18637	11427	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11427	23	on	on	IN
18637	11427	24	the	the	DT
18637	11427	25	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	11427	26	that	that	IN
18637	11427	27	the	the	DT
18637	11427	28	power	power	NN
18637	11427	29	of	of	IN
18637	11427	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11427	31	to	to	TO
18637	11427	32	create	create	VB
18637	11427	33	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	11427	34	courts	court	NNS
18637	11427	35	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	11427	36	implies	imply	VBZ
18637	11427	37	"	"	``
18637	11427	38	the	the	DT
18637	11427	39	power	power	NN
18637	11427	40	to	to	TO
18637	11427	41	limit	limit	VB
18637	11427	42	the	the	DT
18637	11427	43	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11427	44	of	of	IN
18637	11427	45	those	those	DT
18637	11427	46	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	11427	47	to	to	IN
18637	11427	48	particular	particular	JJ
18637	11427	49	objects	object	NNS
18637	11427	50	.	.	.
18637	11428	1	"	"	``
18637	11428	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11428	3	611	611	CD
18637	11428	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11428	5	After	after	IN
18637	11428	6	pointing	point	VBG
18637	11428	7	to	to	IN
18637	11428	8	the	the	DT
18637	11428	9	original	original	JJ
18637	11428	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11428	11	which	which	WDT
18637	11428	12	flows	flow	VBZ
18637	11428	13	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	11428	14	from	from	IN
18637	11428	15	the	the	DT
18637	11428	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11428	17	,	,	,
18637	11428	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11428	19	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	11428	20	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	11428	21	:	:	:
18637	11428	22	"	"	``
18637	11428	23	All	all	DT
18637	11428	24	other	other	JJ
18637	11428	25	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	11428	26	created	create	VBN
18637	11428	27	by	by	IN
18637	11428	28	the	the	DT
18637	11428	29	general	general	JJ
18637	11428	30	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11428	31	possess	possess	VBP
18637	11428	32	no	no	DT
18637	11428	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11428	34	but	but	CC
18637	11428	35	what	what	WP
18637	11428	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	11428	37	given	give	VBN
18637	11428	38	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11428	39	by	by	IN
18637	11428	40	the	the	DT
18637	11428	41	power	power	NN
18637	11428	42	that	that	WDT
18637	11428	43	creates	create	VBZ
18637	11428	44	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11428	45	,	,	,
18637	11428	46	and	and	CC
18637	11428	47	can	can	MD
18637	11428	48	be	be	VB
18637	11428	49	vested	vest	VBN
18637	11428	50	with	with	IN
18637	11428	51	none	none	NN
18637	11428	52	but	but	CC
18637	11428	53	what	what	WP
18637	11428	54	the	the	DT
18637	11428	55	power	power	NN
18637	11428	56	ceded	cede	VBD
18637	11428	57	to	to	IN
18637	11428	58	the	the	DT
18637	11428	59	general	general	JJ
18637	11428	60	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11428	61	will	will	MD
18637	11428	62	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	11428	63	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11428	64	to	to	TO
18637	11428	65	confer	confer	VB
18637	11428	66	.	.	.
18637	11429	1	"	"	``
18637	11429	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11429	3	612	612	CD
18637	11429	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11429	5	To	to	IN
18637	11429	6	the	the	DT
18637	11429	7	same	same	JJ
18637	11429	8	affect	affect	NN
18637	11429	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	11429	10	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	11429	11	Island	Island	NNP
18637	11429	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11429	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	11429	14	_	_	NNP
18637	11429	15	Massachusetts[613	Massachusetts[613	NNP
18637	11429	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11429	17	where	where	WRB
18637	11429	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11429	19	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	11429	20	declared	declare	VBD
18637	11429	21	that	that	IN
18637	11429	22	"	"	``
18637	11429	23	the	the	DT
18637	11429	24	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	11429	25	and	and	CC
18637	11429	26	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	11429	27	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11429	28	of	of	IN
18637	11429	29	the	the	DT
18637	11429	30	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11429	31	power	power	NN
18637	11429	32	must	must	MD
18637	11429	33	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11429	34	be	be	VB
18637	11429	35	made	make	VBN
18637	11429	36	by	by	IN
18637	11429	37	laws	law	NNS
18637	11429	38	passed	pass	VBN
18637	11429	39	by	by	IN
18637	11429	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11429	41	and	and	CC
18637	11429	42	can	can	MD
18637	11429	43	not	not	RB
18637	11429	44	be	be	VB
18637	11429	45	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	11429	46	by	by	IN
18637	11429	47	any	any	DT
18637	11429	48	other	other	JJ
18637	11429	49	department	department	NN
18637	11429	50	*	*	NFP
18637	11429	51	*	*	NFP
18637	11429	52	*	*	NFP
18637	11429	53	"	"	``
18637	11429	54	A	a	DT
18637	11429	55	more	more	RBR
18637	11429	56	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	11429	57	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	11429	58	of	of	IN
18637	11429	59	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	11429	60	power	power	NN
18637	11429	61	over	over	IN
18637	11429	62	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11429	63	was	be	VBD
18637	11429	64	made	make	VBN
18637	11429	65	by	by	IN
18637	11429	66	the	the	DT
18637	11429	67	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11429	68	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11429	69	in	in	IN
18637	11429	70	Cary	Cary	NNP
18637	11429	71	_	_	NNP
18637	11429	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	11429	73	_	_	NNP
18637	11429	74	Curtis,[614	Curtis,[614	NNP
18637	11429	75	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11429	76	which	which	WDT
18637	11429	77	bears	bear	VBZ
18637	11429	78	more	more	RBR
18637	11429	79	directly	directly	RB
18637	11429	80	upon	upon	IN
18637	11429	81	the	the	DT
18637	11429	82	issue	issue	NN
18637	11429	83	than	than	IN
18637	11429	84	some	some	DT
18637	11429	85	of	of	IN
18637	11429	86	the	the	DT
18637	11429	87	earlier	early	JJR
18637	11429	88	cases	case	NNS
18637	11429	89	.	.	.
18637	11430	1	Here	here	RB
18637	11430	2	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	11430	3	had	have	VBD
18637	11430	4	argued	argue	VBN
18637	11430	5	that	that	IN
18637	11430	6	a	a	DT
18637	11430	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	11430	8	which	which	WDT
18637	11430	9	made	make	VBD
18637	11430	10	final	final	JJ
18637	11430	11	the	the	DT
18637	11430	12	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11430	13	of	of	IN
18637	11430	14	the	the	DT
18637	11430	15	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	11430	16	of	of	IN
18637	11430	17	the	the	DT
18637	11430	18	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	11430	19	in	in	IN
18637	11430	20	tax	tax	NN
18637	11430	21	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	11430	22	was	be	VBD
18637	11430	23	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	11430	24	in	in	IN
18637	11430	25	that	that	IN
18637	11430	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11430	27	deprived	deprive	VBD
18637	11430	28	the	the	DT
18637	11430	29	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11430	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	11430	31	of	of	IN
18637	11430	32	the	the	DT
18637	11430	33	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11430	34	power	power	NN
18637	11430	35	vested	vest	VBN
18637	11430	36	in	in	IN
18637	11430	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11430	38	by	by	IN
18637	11430	39	the	the	DT
18637	11430	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11430	41	.	.	.
18637	11431	1	In	in	IN
18637	11431	2	reply	reply	NN
18637	11431	3	to	to	IN
18637	11431	4	this	this	DT
18637	11431	5	argument	argument	NN
18637	11431	6	the	the	DT
18637	11431	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11431	8	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	11431	9	through	through	IN
18637	11431	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11431	11	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	11431	12	declared	declare	VBD
18637	11431	13	:	:	:
18637	11431	14	"	"	``
18637	11431	15	The	the	DT
18637	11431	16	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11431	17	power	power	NN
18637	11431	18	of	of	IN
18637	11431	19	the	the	DT
18637	11431	20	United	United	NNP
18637	11431	21	States	States	NNP
18637	11431	22	*	*	NFP
18637	11431	23	*	*	NFP
18637	11431	24	*	*	NFP
18637	11431	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	11431	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11431	27	except	except	IN
18637	11431	28	in	in	IN
18637	11431	29	enumerated	enumerated	JJ
18637	11431	30	instances	instance	NNS
18637	11431	31	,	,	,
18637	11431	32	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	11431	33	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	11431	34	to	to	IN
18637	11431	35	this	this	DT
18637	11431	36	court	court	NN
18637	11431	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11431	38	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	11431	39	for	for	IN
18637	11431	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11431	41	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	11431	42	and	and	CC
18637	11431	43	organization	organization	NN
18637	11431	44	,	,	,
18637	11431	45	and	and	CC
18637	11431	46	for	for	IN
18637	11431	47	the	the	DT
18637	11431	48	modes	mode	NNS
18637	11431	49	of	of	IN
18637	11431	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11431	51	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11431	52	,	,	,
18637	11431	53	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	11431	54	upon	upon	IN
18637	11431	55	the	the	DT
18637	11431	56	action	action	NN
18637	11431	57	of	of	IN
18637	11431	58	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11431	59	,	,	,
18637	11431	60	who	who	WP
18637	11431	61	possess	possess	VBP
18637	11431	62	the	the	DT
18637	11431	63	sole	sole	JJ
18637	11431	64	power	power	NN
18637	11431	65	of	of	IN
18637	11431	66	creating	create	VBG
18637	11431	67	the	the	DT
18637	11431	68	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	11431	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11431	70	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	11431	71	to	to	IN
18637	11431	72	the	the	DT
18637	11431	73	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11431	74	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11431	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11431	76	*	*	NFP
18637	11431	77	*	*	NFP
18637	11431	78	*	*	NFP
18637	11431	79	and	and	CC
18637	11431	80	of	of	IN
18637	11431	81	investing	invest	VBG
18637	11431	82	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11431	83	with	with	IN
18637	11431	84	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11431	85	,	,	,
18637	11431	86	either	either	CC
18637	11431	87	limited	limited	JJ
18637	11431	88	,	,	,
18637	11431	89	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	11431	90	,	,	,
18637	11431	91	or	or	CC
18637	11431	92	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11431	93	,	,	,
18637	11431	94	and	and	CC
18637	11431	95	of	of	IN
18637	11431	96	withholding	withhold	VBG
18637	11431	97	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11431	98	from	from	IN
18637	11431	99	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11431	100	in	in	IN
18637	11431	101	the	the	DT
18637	11431	102	exact	exact	JJ
18637	11431	103	degrees	degree	NNS
18637	11431	104	and	and	CC
18637	11431	105	character	character	NN
18637	11431	106	which	which	WDT
18637	11431	107	to	to	IN
18637	11431	108	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11431	109	may	may	MD
18637	11431	110	seem	seem	VB
18637	11431	111	proper	proper	JJ
18637	11431	112	for	for	IN
18637	11431	113	the	the	DT
18637	11431	114	public	public	JJ
18637	11431	115	good	good	NN
18637	11431	116	.	.	.
18637	11431	117	"	"	''
18637	11432	1	Continuing	Continuing	NNP
18637	11432	2	,	,	,
18637	11432	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11432	4	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	11432	5	said	say	VBD
18637	11432	6	:	:	:
18637	11432	7	"	"	``
18637	11432	8	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11432	9	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	11432	10	then	then	RB
18637	11432	11	that	that	IN
18637	11432	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	11432	13	created	create	VBN
18637	11432	14	by	by	IN
18637	11432	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	11432	16	,	,	,
18637	11432	17	must	must	MD
18637	11432	18	look	look	VB
18637	11432	19	to	to	IN
18637	11432	20	the	the	DT
18637	11432	21	statute	statute	NN
18637	11432	22	as	as	IN
18637	11432	23	the	the	DT
18637	11432	24	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	11432	25	for	for	IN
18637	11432	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11432	27	authority	authority	NN
18637	11432	28	;	;	:
18637	11432	29	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	11432	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11432	31	can	can	MD
18637	11432	32	not	not	RB
18637	11432	33	go	go	VB
18637	11432	34	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	11432	35	the	the	DT
18637	11432	36	statute	statute	NN
18637	11432	37	,	,	,
18637	11432	38	and	and	CC
18637	11432	39	assert	assert	VB
18637	11432	40	an	an	DT
18637	11432	41	authority	authority	NN
18637	11432	42	with	with	IN
18637	11432	43	which	which	WDT
18637	11432	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11432	45	may	may	MD
18637	11432	46	not	not	RB
18637	11432	47	be	be	VB
18637	11432	48	invested	invest	VBN
18637	11432	49	by	by	IN
18637	11432	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11432	51	,	,	,
18637	11432	52	or	or	CC
18637	11432	53	which	which	WDT
18637	11432	54	may	may	MD
18637	11432	55	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	11432	56	be	be	VB
18637	11432	57	denied	deny	VBN
18637	11432	58	to	to	IN
18637	11432	59	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11432	60	.	.	.
18637	11433	1	"	"	``
18637	11433	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11433	3	615	615	CD
18637	11433	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11433	5	The	the	DT
18637	11433	6	principles	principle	NNS
18637	11433	7	of	of	IN
18637	11433	8	Cary	Cary	NNP
18637	11433	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11433	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	11433	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11433	12	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	11433	13	were	be	VBD
18637	11433	14	reiterated	reiterate	VBN
18637	11433	15	five	five	CD
18637	11433	16	years	year	NNS
18637	11433	17	later	later	RB
18637	11433	18	in	in	IN
18637	11433	19	Sheldon	Sheldon	NNP
18637	11433	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11433	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	11433	22	_	_	NNP
18637	11433	23	Sill[616	Sill[616	NNP
18637	11433	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11433	25	where	where	WRB
18637	11433	26	the	the	DT
18637	11433	27	validity	validity	NN
18637	11433	28	of	of	IN
18637	11433	29	§	§	NNP
18637	11433	30	11	11	CD
18637	11433	31	of	of	IN
18637	11433	32	the	the	DT
18637	11433	33	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11433	34	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11433	35	of	of	IN
18637	11433	36	1789	1789	CD
18637	11433	37	was	be	VBD
18637	11433	38	directly	directly	RB
18637	11433	39	questioned	question	VBN
18637	11433	40	.	.	.
18637	11434	1	The	the	DT
18637	11434	2	assignee	assignee	NN
18637	11434	3	of	of	IN
18637	11434	4	a	a	DT
18637	11434	5	negotiable	negotiable	JJ
18637	11434	6	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	11434	7	filed	file	VBD
18637	11434	8	a	a	DT
18637	11434	9	suit	suit	NN
18637	11434	10	in	in	IN
18637	11434	11	a	a	DT
18637	11434	12	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	11434	13	court	court	NN
18637	11434	14	even	even	RB
18637	11434	15	though	though	IN
18637	11434	16	no	no	DT
18637	11434	17	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	11434	18	of	of	IN
18637	11434	19	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11434	20	existed	exist	VBD
18637	11434	21	as	as	IN
18637	11434	22	between	between	IN
18637	11434	23	the	the	DT
18637	11434	24	original	original	JJ
18637	11434	25	parties	party	NNS
18637	11434	26	to	to	IN
18637	11434	27	the	the	DT
18637	11434	28	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	11434	29	.	.	.
18637	11435	1	The	the	DT
18637	11435	2	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	11435	3	court	court	NN
18637	11435	4	entertained	entertain	VBD
18637	11435	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11435	6	in	in	IN
18637	11435	7	spite	spite	NN
18637	11435	8	of	of	IN
18637	11435	9	the	the	DT
18637	11435	10	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	11435	11	against	against	IN
18637	11435	12	such	such	JJ
18637	11435	13	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11435	14	in	in	IN
18637	11435	15	§	§	NNP
18637	11435	16	11	11	CD
18637	11435	17	and	and	CC
18637	11435	18	ordered	order	VBD
18637	11435	19	a	a	DT
18637	11435	20	sale	sale	NN
18637	11435	21	of	of	IN
18637	11435	22	the	the	DT
18637	11435	23	property	property	NN
18637	11435	24	in	in	IN
18637	11435	25	question	question	NN
18637	11435	26	.	.	.
18637	11436	1	On	on	IN
18637	11436	2	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	11436	3	to	to	IN
18637	11436	4	the	the	DT
18637	11436	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11436	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11436	7	,	,	,
18637	11436	8	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	11436	9	for	for	IN
18637	11436	10	the	the	DT
18637	11436	11	assignee	assignee	NN
18637	11436	12	contended	contend	VBD
18637	11436	13	that	that	IN
18637	11436	14	§	§	NNP
18637	11436	15	11	11	CD
18637	11436	16	was	be	VBD
18637	11436	17	void	void	JJ
18637	11436	18	because	because	IN
18637	11436	19	the	the	DT
18637	11436	20	right	right	NN
18637	11436	21	of	of	IN
18637	11436	22	a	a	DT
18637	11436	23	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11436	24	of	of	IN
18637	11436	25	any	any	DT
18637	11436	26	State	State	NNP
18637	11436	27	to	to	TO
18637	11436	28	sue	sue	VB
18637	11436	29	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11436	30	of	of	IN
18637	11436	31	another	another	DT
18637	11436	32	in	in	IN
18637	11436	33	the	the	DT
18637	11436	34	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11436	35	courts	court	NNS
18637	11436	36	flowed	flow	VBD
18637	11436	37	directly	directly	RB
18637	11436	38	from	from	IN
18637	11436	39	article	article	NN
18637	11436	40	III	III	NNP
18637	11436	41	and	and	CC
18637	11436	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11436	43	could	could	MD
18637	11436	44	not	not	RB
18637	11436	45	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	11436	46	that	that	DT
18637	11436	47	right	right	JJ
18637	11436	48	.	.	.
18637	11437	1	The	the	DT
18637	11437	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11437	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11437	4	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	11437	5	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	11437	6	these	these	DT
18637	11437	7	contentions	contention	NNS
18637	11437	8	and	and	CC
18637	11437	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	11437	10	that	that	IN
18637	11437	11	since	since	IN
18637	11437	12	the	the	DT
18637	11437	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11437	14	had	have	VBD
18637	11437	15	not	not	RB
18637	11437	16	established	establish	VBN
18637	11437	17	the	the	DT
18637	11437	18	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	11437	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	11437	20	or	or	CC
18637	11437	21	distributed	distribute	VBN
18637	11437	22	to	to	IN
18637	11437	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11437	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11437	25	respective	respective	JJ
18637	11437	26	powers	power	NNS
18637	11437	27	,	,	,
18637	11437	28	and	and	CC
18637	11437	29	since	since	IN
18637	11437	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11437	31	had	have	VBD
18637	11437	32	the	the	DT
18637	11437	33	authority	authority	NN
18637	11437	34	to	to	TO
18637	11437	35	establish	establish	VB
18637	11437	36	such	such	JJ
18637	11437	37	courts	court	NNS
18637	11437	38	,	,	,
18637	11437	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11437	40	could	could	MD
18637	11437	41	define	define	VB
18637	11437	42	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11437	43	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11437	44	and	and	CC
18637	11437	45	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	11437	46	from	from	IN
18637	11437	47	any	any	DT
18637	11437	48	court	court	NN
18637	11437	49	of	of	IN
18637	11437	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11437	51	own	own	JJ
18637	11437	52	creation	creation	NN
18637	11437	53	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11437	54	of	of	IN
18637	11437	55	any	any	DT
18637	11437	56	of	of	IN
18637	11437	57	the	the	DT
18637	11437	58	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	11437	59	cases	case	NNS
18637	11437	60	and	and	CC
18637	11437	61	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11437	62	in	in	IN
18637	11437	63	article	article	NN
18637	11437	64	III	iii	CD
18637	11437	65	.	.	.
18637	11438	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11438	2	617	617	CD
18637	11438	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11438	4	Sheldon	Sheldon	NNP
18637	11438	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11438	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11438	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11438	8	Sill	Sill	NNP
18637	11438	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	11438	10	been	be	VBN
18637	11438	11	cited	cite	VBN
18637	11438	12	,	,	,
18637	11438	13	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	11438	14	,	,	,
18637	11438	15	and	and	CC
18637	11438	16	reaffirmed	reaffirm	VBD
18637	11438	17	many	many	JJ
18637	11438	18	times	time	NNS
18637	11438	19	.	.	.
18637	11439	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11439	2	618	618	LS
18637	11439	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11439	4	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11439	5	effect	effect	NN
18637	11439	6	and	and	CC
18637	11439	7	that	that	DT
18637	11439	8	of	of	IN
18637	11439	9	the	the	DT
18637	11439	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	11439	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	11439	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11439	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	11439	14	that	that	IN
18637	11439	15	as	as	IN
18637	11439	16	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	11439	17	the	the	DT
18637	11439	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11439	19	of	of	IN
18637	11439	20	the	the	DT
18637	11439	21	lower	low	JJR
18637	11439	22	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11439	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	11439	24	two	two	CD
18637	11439	25	elements	element	NNS
18637	11439	26	are	be	VBP
18637	11439	27	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11439	28	to	to	TO
18637	11439	29	confer	confer	VB
18637	11439	30	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11439	31	:	:	:
18637	11439	32	first	first	RB
18637	11439	33	,	,	,
18637	11439	34	the	the	DT
18637	11439	35	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11439	36	must	must	MD
18637	11439	37	have	have	VB
18637	11439	38	given	give	VBN
18637	11439	39	the	the	DT
18637	11439	40	courts	court	NNS
18637	11439	41	the	the	DT
18637	11439	42	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	11439	43	to	to	TO
18637	11439	44	receive	receive	VB
18637	11439	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11439	46	,	,	,
18637	11439	47	and	and	CC
18637	11439	48	second	second	RB
18637	11439	49	,	,	,
18637	11439	50	an	an	DT
18637	11439	51	act	act	NN
18637	11439	52	of	of	IN
18637	11439	53	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11439	54	must	must	MD
18637	11439	55	have	have	VB
18637	11439	56	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	11439	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11439	58	.	.	.
18637	11440	1	The	the	DT
18637	11440	2	manner	manner	NN
18637	11440	3	in	in	IN
18637	11440	4	which	which	WDT
18637	11440	5	the	the	DT
18637	11440	6	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	11440	7	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11440	8	courts	court	NNS
18637	11440	9	acquire	acquire	VBP
18637	11440	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11440	11	,	,	,
18637	11440	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11440	13	character	character	NN
18637	11440	14	,	,	,
18637	11440	15	the	the	DT
18637	11440	16	mode	mode	NN
18637	11440	17	of	of	IN
18637	11440	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11440	19	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11440	20	,	,	,
18637	11440	21	and	and	CC
18637	11440	22	the	the	DT
18637	11440	23	objects	object	NNS
18637	11440	24	of	of	IN
18637	11440	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11440	26	operation	operation	NN
18637	11440	27	are	be	VBP
18637	11440	28	remitted	remit	VBN
18637	11440	29	without	without	IN
18637	11440	30	check	check	NN
18637	11440	31	or	or	CC
18637	11440	32	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	11440	33	to	to	IN
18637	11440	34	the	the	DT
18637	11440	35	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	11440	36	of	of	IN
18637	11440	37	the	the	DT
18637	11440	38	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	11440	39	.	.	.
18637	11441	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11441	2	619	619	CD
18637	11441	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11441	4	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	11441	5	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	11441	6	UNDER	under	IN
18637	11441	7	THE	the	DT
18637	11441	8	EMERGENCY	EMERGENCY	NNP
18637	11441	9	PRICE	price	NN
18637	11441	10	CONTROL	control	NN
18637	11441	11	ACT	ACT	NNP
18637	11441	12	The	the	DT
18637	11441	13	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	11441	14	power	power	NN
18637	11441	15	of	of	IN
18637	11441	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11441	17	to	to	TO
18637	11441	18	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	11441	19	and	and	CC
18637	11441	20	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	11441	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11441	22	was	be	VBD
18637	11441	23	given	give	VBN
18637	11441	24	renewed	renew	VBN
18637	11441	25	vitality	vitality	NN
18637	11441	26	by	by	IN
18637	11441	27	the	the	DT
18637	11441	28	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	11441	29	Price	Price	NNP
18637	11441	30	Control	Control	NNP
18637	11441	31	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11441	32	of	of	IN
18637	11441	33	1942[620	1942[620	CD
18637	11441	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11441	35	and	and	CC
18637	11441	36	the	the	DT
18637	11441	37	cases	case	NNS
18637	11441	38	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11441	39	therefrom	therefrom	NN
18637	11441	40	.	.	.
18637	11442	1	Fearful	fearful	JJ
18637	11442	2	that	that	IN
18637	11442	3	the	the	DT
18637	11442	4	price	price	NN
18637	11442	5	control	control	NN
18637	11442	6	program	program	NN
18637	11442	7	might	may	MD
18637	11442	8	be	be	VB
18637	11442	9	effectively	effectively	RB
18637	11442	10	nullified	nullify	VBN
18637	11442	11	by	by	IN
18637	11442	12	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	11442	13	,	,	,
18637	11442	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11442	15	provided	provide	VBD
18637	11442	16	for	for	IN
18637	11442	17	a	a	DT
18637	11442	18	special	special	JJ
18637	11442	19	court	court	NN
18637	11442	20	and	and	CC
18637	11442	21	special	special	JJ
18637	11442	22	procedures	procedure	NNS
18637	11442	23	for	for	IN
18637	11442	24	contesting	contest	VBG
18637	11442	25	the	the	DT
18637	11442	26	validity	validity	NN
18637	11442	27	of	of	IN
18637	11442	28	price	price	NN
18637	11442	29	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	11442	30	.	.	.
18637	11443	1	In	in	IN
18637	11443	2	Lockerty	Lockerty	NNP
18637	11443	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11443	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	11443	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11443	6	Phillips[621	Phillips[621	NNP
18637	11443	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11443	8	the	the	DT
18637	11443	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11443	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11443	11	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	11443	12	the	the	DT
18637	11443	13	power	power	NN
18637	11443	14	of	of	IN
18637	11443	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11443	16	to	to	TO
18637	11443	17	confine	confine	VB
18637	11443	18	equity	equity	NN
18637	11443	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11443	20	,	,	,
18637	11443	21	to	to	TO
18637	11443	22	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	11443	23	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11443	24	of	of	IN
18637	11443	25	the	the	DT
18637	11443	26	act	act	NN
18637	11443	27	to	to	IN
18637	11443	28	the	the	DT
18637	11443	29	specially	specially	RB
18637	11443	30	created	create	VBN
18637	11443	31	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	11443	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11443	33	of	of	IN
18637	11443	34	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	11443	35	,	,	,
18637	11443	36	with	with	IN
18637	11443	37	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	11443	38	to	to	IN
18637	11443	39	the	the	DT
18637	11443	40	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11443	41	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11443	42	.	.	.
18637	11444	1	The	the	DT
18637	11444	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11444	3	went	go	VBD
18637	11444	4	much	much	RB
18637	11444	5	farther	farther	RB
18637	11444	6	than	than	IN
18637	11444	7	this	this	DT
18637	11444	8	in	in	IN
18637	11444	9	Yakus	Yakus	NNP
18637	11444	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11444	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	11444	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11444	13	United	United	NNP
18637	11444	14	States,[622	States,[622	NNP
18637	11444	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11444	16	and	and	CC
18637	11444	17	held	hold	VBD
18637	11444	18	that	that	IN
18637	11444	19	the	the	DT
18637	11444	20	provision	provision	NN
18637	11444	21	of	of	IN
18637	11444	22	the	the	DT
18637	11444	23	act	act	NN
18637	11444	24	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	11444	25	on	on	IN
18637	11444	26	the	the	DT
18637	11444	27	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	11444	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11444	29	of	of	IN
18637	11444	30	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	11444	31	and	and	CC
18637	11444	32	the	the	DT
18637	11444	33	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11444	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11444	35	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11444	36	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11444	37	to	to	TO
18637	11444	38	determine	determine	VB
18637	11444	39	the	the	DT
18637	11444	40	validity	validity	NN
18637	11444	41	of	of	IN
18637	11444	42	any	any	DT
18637	11444	43	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	11444	44	or	or	CC
18637	11444	45	order	order	NN
18637	11444	46	,	,	,
18637	11444	47	and	and	CC
18637	11444	48	providing	provide	VBG
18637	11444	49	that	that	IN
18637	11444	50	no	no	DT
18637	11444	51	court	court	NN
18637	11444	52	should	should	MD
18637	11444	53	have	have	VB
18637	11444	54	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11444	55	or	or	CC
18637	11444	56	power	power	NN
18637	11444	57	to	to	TO
18637	11444	58	consider	consider	VB
18637	11444	59	the	the	DT
18637	11444	60	validity	validity	NN
18637	11444	61	of	of	IN
18637	11444	62	any	any	DT
18637	11444	63	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	11444	64	,	,	,
18637	11444	65	precluded	preclude	VBD
18637	11444	66	the	the	DT
18637	11444	67	plea	plea	NN
18637	11444	68	of	of	IN
18637	11444	69	invalidity	invalidity	NN
18637	11444	70	of	of	IN
18637	11444	71	such	such	PDT
18637	11444	72	a	a	DT
18637	11444	73	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	11444	74	as	as	IN
18637	11444	75	a	a	DT
18637	11444	76	defense	defense	NN
18637	11444	77	to	to	IN
18637	11444	78	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11444	79	violation	violation	NN
18637	11444	80	in	in	IN
18637	11444	81	a	a	DT
18637	11444	82	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	11444	83	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	11444	84	in	in	IN
18637	11444	85	a	a	DT
18637	11444	86	district	district	NN
18637	11444	87	court	court	NN
18637	11444	88	.	.	.
18637	11445	1	Although	although	IN
18637	11445	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11445	3	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	11445	4	protested	protest	VBD
18637	11445	5	in	in	IN
18637	11445	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11445	7	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11445	8	that	that	IN
18637	11445	9	this	this	DT
18637	11445	10	provision	provision	NN
18637	11445	11	of	of	IN
18637	11445	12	the	the	DT
18637	11445	13	act	act	NN
18637	11445	14	conferred	confer	VBD
18637	11445	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11445	16	on	on	IN
18637	11445	17	the	the	DT
18637	11445	18	district	district	NN
18637	11445	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	11445	20	from	from	IN
18637	11445	21	which	which	WDT
18637	11445	22	essential	essential	JJ
18637	11445	23	elements	element	NNS
18637	11445	24	of	of	IN
18637	11445	25	the	the	DT
18637	11445	26	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11445	27	power	power	NN
18637	11445	28	had	have	VBD
18637	11445	29	been	be	VBN
18637	11445	30	abstracted,[623	abstracted,[623	NNP
18637	11445	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11445	32	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11445	33	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11445	34	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	11445	35	declared	declare	VBD
18637	11445	36	for	for	IN
18637	11445	37	the	the	DT
18637	11445	38	majority	majority	NN
18637	11445	39	that	that	WDT
18637	11445	40	the	the	DT
18637	11445	41	provision	provision	NN
18637	11445	42	presented	present	VBD
18637	11445	43	no	no	DT
18637	11445	44	novel	novel	JJ
18637	11445	45	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11445	46	issue	issue	NN
18637	11445	47	.	.	.
18637	11446	1	LEGISLATIVE	legislative	JJ
18637	11446	2	CONTROL	control	NN
18637	11446	3	OVER	over	IN
18637	11446	4	WRITS	writs	NN
18637	11446	5	The	the	DT
18637	11446	6	authority	authority	NN
18637	11446	7	of	of	IN
18637	11446	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11446	9	to	to	TO
18637	11446	10	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	11446	11	the	the	DT
18637	11446	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11446	13	of	of	IN
18637	11446	14	the	the	DT
18637	11446	15	lower	low	JJR
18637	11446	16	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11446	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	11446	18	includes	include	VBZ
18637	11446	19	that	that	DT
18637	11446	20	of	of	IN
18637	11446	21	controlling	control	VBG
18637	11446	22	the	the	DT
18637	11446	23	power	power	NN
18637	11446	24	of	of	IN
18637	11446	25	the	the	DT
18637	11446	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	11446	27	to	to	TO
18637	11446	28	issue	issue	VB
18637	11446	29	writs	writ	NNS
18637	11446	30	in	in	IN
18637	11446	31	cases	case	NNS
18637	11446	32	where	where	WRB
18637	11446	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11446	34	have	have	VBP
18637	11446	35	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11446	36	and	and	CC
18637	11446	37	to	to	TO
18637	11446	38	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	11446	39	other	other	JJ
18637	11446	40	ancillary	ancillary	JJ
18637	11446	41	powers	power	NNS
18637	11446	42	generally	generally	RB
18637	11446	43	.	.	.
18637	11447	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11447	2	624	624	CD
18637	11447	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11447	4	Among	among	IN
18637	11447	5	some	some	DT
18637	11447	6	of	of	IN
18637	11447	7	the	the	DT
18637	11447	8	more	more	RBR
18637	11447	9	notable	notable	JJ
18637	11447	10	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	11447	11	in	in	IN
18637	11447	12	this	this	DT
18637	11447	13	regard	regard	NN
18637	11447	14	are	be	VBP
18637	11447	15	the	the	DT
18637	11447	16	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	11447	17	on	on	IN
18637	11447	18	the	the	DT
18637	11447	19	power	power	NN
18637	11447	20	of	of	IN
18637	11447	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	11447	22	to	to	TO
18637	11447	23	issue	issue	VB
18637	11447	24	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	11447	25	,	,	,
18637	11447	26	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	11447	27	in	in	IN
18637	11447	28	the	the	DT
18637	11447	29	field	field	NN
18637	11447	30	of	of	IN
18637	11447	31	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	11447	32	and	and	CC
18637	11447	33	labor	labor	NN
18637	11447	34	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	11447	35	.	.	.
18637	11448	1	By	by	IN
18637	11448	2	the	the	DT
18637	11448	3	act	act	NN
18637	11448	4	of	of	IN
18637	11448	5	March	March	NNP
18637	11448	6	2	2	CD
18637	11448	7	,	,	,
18637	11448	8	1867,[625	1867,[625	LS
18637	11448	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11448	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11448	11	provided	provide	VBD
18637	11448	12	that	that	IN
18637	11448	13	"	"	``
18637	11448	14	no	no	DT
18637	11448	15	suit	suit	NN
18637	11448	16	for	for	IN
18637	11448	17	the	the	DT
18637	11448	18	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	11448	19	of	of	IN
18637	11448	20	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	11448	21	the	the	DT
18637	11448	22	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	11448	23	or	or	CC
18637	11448	24	collection	collection	NN
18637	11448	25	of	of	IN
18637	11448	26	any	any	DT
18637	11448	27	tax	tax	NN
18637	11448	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	11448	29	be	be	VB
18637	11448	30	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	11448	31	in	in	IN
18637	11448	32	any	any	DT
18637	11448	33	court	court	NN
18637	11448	34	.	.	.
18637	11448	35	"	"	''
18637	11449	1	There	there	EX
18637	11449	2	have	have	VBP
18637	11449	3	never	never	RB
18637	11449	4	been	be	VBN
18637	11449	5	any	any	DT
18637	11449	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11449	7	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	11449	8	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	11449	9	this	this	DT
18637	11449	10	provision	provision	NN
18637	11449	11	,	,	,
18637	11449	12	which	which	WDT
18637	11449	13	was	be	VBD
18637	11449	14	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	11449	15	applied	apply	VBN
18637	11449	16	for	for	IN
18637	11449	17	many	many	JJ
18637	11449	18	years[626	years[626	NNS
18637	11449	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11449	20	until	until	IN
18637	11449	21	1916	1916	CD
18637	11449	22	when	when	WRB
18637	11449	23	the	the	DT
18637	11449	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11449	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11449	26	began	begin	VBD
18637	11449	27	to	to	TO
18637	11449	28	make	make	VB
18637	11449	29	exceptions[627	exceptions[627	NNP
18637	11449	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11449	31	which	which	WDT
18637	11449	32	in	in	IN
18637	11449	33	the	the	DT
18637	11449	34	later	later	JJ
18637	11449	35	cases[628	cases[628	NN
18637	11449	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11449	37	made	make	VBD
18637	11449	38	the	the	DT
18637	11449	39	provision	provision	NN
18637	11449	40	so	so	RB
18637	11449	41	inefficacious	inefficacious	JJ
18637	11449	42	that	that	IN
18637	11449	43	by	by	IN
18637	11449	44	October	October	NNP
18637	11449	45	,	,	,
18637	11449	46	1935	1935	CD
18637	11449	47	,	,	,
18637	11449	48	more	more	JJR
18637	11449	49	than	than	IN
18637	11449	50	1600	1600	CD
18637	11449	51	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11449	52	had	have	VBD
18637	11449	53	been	be	VBN
18637	11449	54	filed	file	VBN
18637	11449	55	to	to	TO
18637	11449	56	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	11449	57	the	the	DT
18637	11449	58	collection	collection	NN
18637	11449	59	of	of	IN
18637	11449	60	processing	process	VBG
18637	11449	61	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	11449	62	under	under	IN
18637	11449	63	the	the	DT
18637	11449	64	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	11449	65	Adjustment	Adjustment	NNP
18637	11449	66	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11449	67	.	.	.
18637	11450	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11450	2	629	629	CD
18637	11450	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11450	4	None	none	NN
18637	11450	5	of	of	IN
18637	11450	6	these	these	DT
18637	11450	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	11450	8	,	,	,
18637	11450	9	however	however	RB
18637	11450	10	,	,	,
18637	11450	11	raises	raise	VBZ
18637	11450	12	any	any	DT
18637	11450	13	issue	issue	NN
18637	11450	14	other	other	JJ
18637	11450	15	than	than	IN
18637	11450	16	that	that	DT
18637	11450	17	of	of	IN
18637	11450	18	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	11450	19	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11450	20	,	,	,
18637	11450	21	and	and	CC
18637	11450	22	since	since	IN
18637	11450	23	1936	1936	CD
18637	11450	24	the	the	DT
18637	11450	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11450	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	11450	27	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	11450	28	the	the	DT
18637	11450	29	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	11450	30	to	to	IN
18637	11450	31	the	the	DT
18637	11450	32	statute	statute	NN
18637	11450	33	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	11450	34	more	more	RBR
18637	11450	35	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	11450	36	.	.	.
18637	11451	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11451	2	630	630	CD
18637	11451	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11451	4	Injunctions	Injunctions	NNPS
18637	11451	5	in	in	IN
18637	11451	6	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	11451	7	Disputes	Disputes	NNP
18637	11451	8	;	;	:
18637	11451	9	the	the	DT
18637	11451	10	Norris	Norris	NNP
18637	11451	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	11451	12	LaGuardia	LaGuardia	NNP
18637	11451	13	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11451	14	The	the	DT
18637	11451	15	Norris	Norris	NNP
18637	11451	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	11451	17	LaGuardia	LaGuardia	NNP
18637	11451	18	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11451	19	of	of	IN
18637	11451	20	1932[631	1932[631	CD
18637	11451	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11451	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	11451	23	significant	significant	JJ
18637	11451	24	for	for	IN
18637	11451	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11451	26	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	11451	27	on	on	IN
18637	11451	28	the	the	DT
18637	11451	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	11451	30	of	of	IN
18637	11451	31	the	the	DT
18637	11451	32	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11451	33	courts	court	NNS
18637	11451	34	to	to	TO
18637	11451	35	issue	issue	VB
18637	11451	36	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	11451	37	in	in	IN
18637	11451	38	labor	labor	NN
18637	11451	39	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	11451	40	in	in	IN
18637	11451	41	the	the	DT
18637	11451	42	form	form	NN
18637	11451	43	of	of	IN
18637	11451	44	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	11451	45	for	for	IN
18637	11451	46	hearings	hearing	NNS
18637	11451	47	followed	follow	VBN
18637	11451	48	by	by	IN
18637	11451	49	findings	finding	NNS
18637	11451	50	that	that	WDT
18637	11451	51	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	11451	52	acts	act	NNS
18637	11451	53	are	be	VBP
18637	11451	54	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	11451	55	and	and	CC
18637	11451	56	will	will	MD
18637	11451	57	be	be	VB
18637	11451	58	committed	commit	VBN
18637	11451	59	unless	unless	IN
18637	11451	60	restrained	restrain	VBN
18637	11451	61	,	,	,
18637	11451	62	or	or	CC
18637	11451	63	if	if	IN
18637	11451	64	already	already	RB
18637	11451	65	committed	committed	JJ
18637	11451	66	will	will	MD
18637	11451	67	be	be	VB
18637	11451	68	continued	continue	VBN
18637	11451	69	;	;	:
18637	11451	70	that	that	IN
18637	11451	71	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	11451	72	injury	injury	NN
18637	11451	73	to	to	IN
18637	11451	74	the	the	DT
18637	11451	75	property	property	NN
18637	11451	76	of	of	IN
18637	11451	77	complainants	complainant	NNS
18637	11451	78	will	will	MD
18637	11451	79	ensue	ensue	VB
18637	11451	80	;	;	:
18637	11451	81	that	that	IN
18637	11451	82	as	as	IN
18637	11451	83	to	to	IN
18637	11451	84	the	the	DT
18637	11451	85	relief	relief	NN
18637	11451	86	granted	grant	VBN
18637	11451	87	greater	great	JJR
18637	11451	88	injury	injury	NN
18637	11451	89	will	will	MD
18637	11451	90	be	be	VB
18637	11451	91	inflicted	inflict	VBN
18637	11451	92	upon	upon	IN
18637	11451	93	complainants	complainant	NNS
18637	11451	94	by	by	IN
18637	11451	95	denying	deny	VBG
18637	11451	96	relief	relief	NN
18637	11451	97	than	than	IN
18637	11451	98	will	will	MD
18637	11451	99	be	be	VB
18637	11451	100	inflicted	inflict	VBN
18637	11451	101	on	on	IN
18637	11451	102	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	11451	103	by	by	IN
18637	11451	104	granting	grant	VBG
18637	11451	105	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11451	106	;	;	:
18637	11451	107	that	that	IN
18637	11451	108	the	the	DT
18637	11451	109	complainants	complainant	NNS
18637	11451	110	have	have	VBP
18637	11451	111	no	no	DT
18637	11451	112	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	11451	113	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	11451	114	at	at	IN
18637	11451	115	law	law	NN
18637	11451	116	;	;	:
18637	11451	117	and	and	CC
18637	11451	118	,	,	,
18637	11451	119	finally	finally	RB
18637	11451	120	,	,	,
18637	11451	121	that	that	IN
18637	11451	122	the	the	DT
18637	11451	123	public	public	JJ
18637	11451	124	officials	official	NNS
18637	11451	125	charged	charge	VBN
18637	11451	126	with	with	IN
18637	11451	127	the	the	DT
18637	11451	128	protection	protection	NN
18637	11451	129	of	of	IN
18637	11451	130	complainants	complainant	NNS
18637	11451	131	'	'	POS
18637	11451	132	property	property	NN
18637	11451	133	are	be	VBP
18637	11451	134	either	either	CC
18637	11451	135	unable	unable	JJ
18637	11451	136	or	or	CC
18637	11451	137	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
18637	11451	138	to	to	TO
18637	11451	139	do	do	VB
18637	11451	140	so	so	RB
18637	11451	141	.	.	.
18637	11452	1	This	this	DT
18637	11452	2	act	act	NN
18637	11452	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	11452	4	been	be	VBN
18637	11452	5	scrupulously	scrupulously	RB
18637	11452	6	applied	apply	VBN
18637	11452	7	by	by	IN
18637	11452	8	the	the	DT
18637	11452	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11452	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11452	11	,	,	,
18637	11452	12	which	which	WDT
18637	11452	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	11452	14	implicitly	implicitly	RB
18637	11452	15	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	11452	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11452	17	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	11452	18	by	by	IN
18637	11452	19	construing	construe	VBG
18637	11452	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11452	21	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	11452	22	liberally[632	liberally[632	VB
18637	11452	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11452	24	in	in	IN
18637	11452	25	every	every	DT
18637	11452	26	case	case	NN
18637	11452	27	except	except	IN
18637	11452	28	United	United	NNP
18637	11452	29	States	States	NNP
18637	11452	30	_	_	NNP
18637	11452	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	11452	32	_	_	NNP
18637	11452	33	United	United	NNP
18637	11452	34	Mine	Mine	NNP
18637	11452	35	Workers,[633	Workers,[633	NNP
18637	11452	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11452	37	where	where	WRB
18637	11452	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11452	39	was	be	VBD
18637	11452	40	held	hold	VBN
18637	11452	41	that	that	IN
18637	11452	42	the	the	DT
18637	11452	43	statute	statute	NN
18637	11452	44	did	do	VBD
18637	11452	45	not	not	RB
18637	11452	46	apply	apply	VB
18637	11452	47	to	to	IN
18637	11452	48	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11452	49	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11452	50	by	by	IN
18637	11452	51	the	the	DT
18637	11452	52	United	United	NNP
18637	11452	53	States	States	NNP
18637	11452	54	to	to	TO
18637	11452	55	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	11452	56	a	a	DT
18637	11452	57	strike	strike	NN
18637	11452	58	in	in	IN
18637	11452	59	the	the	DT
18637	11452	60	coal	coal	NN
18637	11452	61	industry	industry	NN
18637	11452	62	while	while	IN
18637	11452	63	the	the	DT
18637	11452	64	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11452	65	technically	technically	RB
18637	11452	66	was	be	VBD
18637	11452	67	operating	operate	VBG
18637	11452	68	the	the	DT
18637	11452	69	mines	mine	NNS
18637	11452	70	.	.	.
18637	11453	1	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	11453	2	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	11453	3	EQUATED	equate	VBD
18637	11453	4	WITH	with	IN
18637	11453	5	DUE	DUE	NNP
18637	11453	6	PROCESS	PROCESS	NNP
18637	11453	7	OF	of	IN
18637	11453	8	LAW	law	NN
18637	11453	9	Although	although	IN
18637	11453	10	the	the	DT
18637	11453	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	11453	12	point	point	VBP
18637	11453	13	to	to	IN
18637	11453	14	a	a	DT
18637	11453	15	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	11453	16	power	power	NN
18637	11453	17	in	in	IN
18637	11453	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11453	19	to	to	TO
18637	11453	20	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	11453	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11453	22	from	from	IN
18637	11453	23	the	the	DT
18637	11453	24	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	11453	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	11453	26	and	and	CC
18637	11453	27	to	to	TO
18637	11453	28	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	11453	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11453	30	at	at	IN
18637	11453	31	any	any	DT
18637	11453	32	time	time	NN
18637	11453	33	after	after	IN
18637	11453	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11453	35	has	have	VBZ
18637	11453	36	been	be	VBN
18637	11453	37	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	11453	38	,	,	,
18637	11453	39	even	even	RB
18637	11453	40	as	as	IN
18637	11453	41	applied	apply	VBN
18637	11453	42	to	to	IN
18637	11453	43	pending	pende	VBG
18637	11453	44	cases	case	NNS
18637	11453	45	,	,	,
18637	11453	46	there	there	EX
18637	11453	47	are	be	VBP
18637	11453	48	a	a	DT
18637	11453	49	few	few	JJ
18637	11453	50	cases	case	NNS
18637	11453	51	in	in	IN
18637	11453	52	addition	addition	NN
18637	11453	53	to	to	IN
18637	11453	54	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	11453	55	_	_	NNP
18637	11453	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	11453	57	_	_	NNP
18637	11453	58	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	11453	59	's	's	POS
18637	11453	60	Lessee[634	Lessee[634	NNP
18637	11453	61	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11453	62	which	which	WDT
18637	11453	63	slightly	slightly	RB
18637	11453	64	qualify	qualify	VBP
18637	11453	65	the	the	DT
18637	11453	66	cumulative	cumulative	JJ
18637	11453	67	effect	effect	NN
18637	11453	68	of	of	IN
18637	11453	69	this	this	DT
18637	11453	70	impressive	impressive	JJ
18637	11453	71	array	array	NN
18637	11453	72	of	of	IN
18637	11453	73	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	11453	74	.	.	.
18637	11454	1	As	as	RB
18637	11454	2	early	early	RB
18637	11454	3	as	as	IN
18637	11454	4	1856	1856	CD
18637	11454	5	,	,	,
18637	11454	6	the	the	DT
18637	11454	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11454	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11454	9	in	in	IN
18637	11454	10	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	11454	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11454	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	11454	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11454	14	Hoboken	Hoboken	NNP
18637	11454	15	Land	Land	NNP
18637	11454	16	and	and	CC
18637	11454	17	Improvement	Improvement	NNP
18637	11454	18	Co.[635	Co.[635	NNP
18637	11454	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11454	20	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	11454	21	between	between	IN
18637	11454	22	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11454	23	of	of	IN
18637	11454	24	private	private	JJ
18637	11454	25	right	right	NN
18637	11454	26	which	which	WDT
18637	11454	27	from	from	IN
18637	11454	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11454	29	nature	nature	NN
18637	11454	30	were	be	VBD
18637	11454	31	the	the	DT
18637	11454	32	subject	subject	NN
18637	11454	33	of	of	IN
18637	11454	34	a	a	DT
18637	11454	35	suit	suit	NN
18637	11454	36	at	at	IN
18637	11454	37	the	the	DT
18637	11454	38	common	common	JJ
18637	11454	39	law	law	NN
18637	11454	40	,	,	,
18637	11454	41	equity	equity	NN
18637	11454	42	,	,	,
18637	11454	43	or	or	CC
18637	11454	44	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11454	45	and	and	CC
18637	11454	46	can	can	MD
18637	11454	47	not	not	RB
18637	11454	48	be	be	VB
18637	11454	49	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	11454	50	from	from	IN
18637	11454	51	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11454	52	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	11454	53	and	and	CC
18637	11454	54	those	those	DT
18637	11454	55	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11454	56	of	of	IN
18637	11454	57	public	public	JJ
18637	11454	58	right	right	NN
18637	11454	59	which	which	WDT
18637	11454	60	,	,	,
18637	11454	61	though	though	IN
18637	11454	62	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
18637	11454	63	of	of	IN
18637	11454	64	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11454	65	determination	determination	NN
18637	11454	66	,	,	,
18637	11454	67	did	do	VBD
18637	11454	68	not	not	RB
18637	11454	69	require	require	VB
18637	11454	70	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11454	71	and	and	CC
18637	11454	72	which	which	WDT
18637	11454	73	might	may	MD
18637	11454	74	or	or	CC
18637	11454	75	might	may	MD
18637	11454	76	not	not	RB
18637	11454	77	be	be	VB
18637	11454	78	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11454	79	within	within	IN
18637	11454	80	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11454	81	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	11454	82	.	.	.
18637	11455	1	Seventy	seventy	CD
18637	11455	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	11455	3	seven	seven	CD
18637	11455	4	years	year	NNS
18637	11455	5	later	later	RB
18637	11455	6	the	the	DT
18637	11455	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11455	8	elaborated	elaborate	VBD
18637	11455	9	this	this	DT
18637	11455	10	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	11455	11	in	in	IN
18637	11455	12	Crowell	Crowell	NNP
18637	11455	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11455	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	11455	15	_	_	NNP
18637	11455	16	Benson,[636	Benson,[636	NNP
18637	11455	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11455	18	which	which	WDT
18637	11455	19	involved	involve	VBD
18637	11455	20	the	the	DT
18637	11455	21	finality	finality	NN
18637	11455	22	to	to	TO
18637	11455	23	be	be	VB
18637	11455	24	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	11455	25	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	11455	26	findings	finding	NNS
18637	11455	27	of	of	IN
18637	11455	28	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	11455	29	facts	fact	NNS
18637	11455	30	in	in	IN
18637	11455	31	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	11455	32	cases	case	NNS
18637	11455	33	.	.	.
18637	11456	1	In	in	IN
18637	11456	2	holding	hold	VBG
18637	11456	3	that	that	IN
18637	11456	4	an	an	DT
18637	11456	5	employer	employer	NN
18637	11456	6	was	be	VBD
18637	11456	7	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	11456	8	to	to	IN
18637	11456	9	a	a	DT
18637	11456	10	trial	trial	NN
18637	11456	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11456	12	de	de	FW
18637	11456	13	novo	novo	NNP
18637	11456	14	_	_	NNP
18637	11456	15	of	of	IN
18637	11456	16	the	the	DT
18637	11456	17	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11456	18	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	11456	19	facts	fact	NNS
18637	11456	20	of	of	IN
18637	11456	21	the	the	DT
18637	11456	22	matter	matter	NN
18637	11456	23	of	of	IN
18637	11456	24	the	the	DT
18637	11456	25	employer	employer	NN
18637	11456	26	-	-	HYPH
18637	11456	27	employee	employee	NN
18637	11456	28	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	11456	29	and	and	CC
18637	11456	30	of	of	IN
18637	11456	31	the	the	DT
18637	11456	32	occurrence	occurrence	NN
18637	11456	33	of	of	IN
18637	11456	34	the	the	DT
18637	11456	35	injury	injury	NN
18637	11456	36	in	in	IN
18637	11456	37	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	11456	38	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	11456	39	,	,	,
18637	11456	40	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11456	41	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11456	42	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	11456	43	,	,	,
18637	11456	44	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	11456	45	for	for	IN
18637	11456	46	the	the	DT
18637	11456	47	majority	majority	NN
18637	11456	48	fused	fuse	VBD
18637	11456	49	the	the	DT
18637	11456	50	due	due	JJ
18637	11456	51	process	process	NN
18637	11456	52	clause	clause	NN
18637	11456	53	of	of	IN
18637	11456	54	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	11456	55	V	V	NNP
18637	11456	56	and	and	CC
18637	11456	57	article	article	NN
18637	11456	58	III	iii	CD
18637	11456	59	,	,	,
18637	11456	60	but	but	CC
18637	11456	61	emphasized	emphasize	VBD
18637	11456	62	that	that	IN
18637	11456	63	the	the	DT
18637	11456	64	issue	issue	NN
18637	11456	65	ultimately	ultimately	RB
18637	11456	66	was	be	VBD
18637	11456	67	"	"	``
18637	11456	68	rather	rather	RB
18637	11456	69	a	a	DT
18637	11456	70	question	question	NN
18637	11456	71	of	of	IN
18637	11456	72	the	the	DT
18637	11456	73	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	11456	74	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	11456	75	of	of	IN
18637	11456	76	the	the	DT
18637	11456	77	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11456	78	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11456	79	power	power	NN
18637	11456	80	,	,	,
18637	11456	81	"	"	''
18637	11456	82	and	and	CC
18637	11456	83	"	"	``
18637	11456	84	whether	whether	IN
18637	11456	85	the	the	DT
18637	11456	86	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11456	87	may	may	MD
18637	11456	88	substitute	substitute	VB
18637	11456	89	for	for	IN
18637	11456	90	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11456	91	courts	court	NNS
18637	11456	92	,	,	,
18637	11456	93	in	in	IN
18637	11456	94	which	which	WDT
18637	11456	95	the	the	DT
18637	11456	96	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11456	97	power	power	NN
18637	11456	98	of	of	IN
18637	11456	99	the	the	DT
18637	11456	100	United	United	NNP
18637	11456	101	States	States	NNP
18637	11456	102	is	be	VBZ
18637	11456	103	vested	vest	VBN
18637	11456	104	,	,	,
18637	11456	105	an	an	DT
18637	11456	106	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	11456	107	agency	agency	NN
18637	11456	108	*	*	NFP
18637	11456	109	*	*	NFP
18637	11456	110	*	*	NFP
18637	11456	111	for	for	IN
18637	11456	112	the	the	DT
18637	11456	113	final	final	JJ
18637	11456	114	determination	determination	NN
18637	11456	115	of	of	IN
18637	11456	116	the	the	DT
18637	11456	117	existence	existence	NN
18637	11456	118	of	of	IN
18637	11456	119	the	the	DT
18637	11456	120	facts	fact	NNS
18637	11456	121	upon	upon	IN
18637	11456	122	which	which	WDT
18637	11456	123	the	the	DT
18637	11456	124	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11456	125	of	of	IN
18637	11456	126	the	the	DT
18637	11456	127	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11456	128	rights	right	NNS
18637	11456	129	of	of	IN
18637	11456	130	the	the	DT
18637	11456	131	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11456	132	depend	depend	VBP
18637	11456	133	.	.	.
18637	11456	134	"	"	''
18637	11457	1	To	to	TO
18637	11457	2	do	do	VB
18637	11457	3	so	so	RB
18637	11457	4	,	,	,
18637	11457	5	contended	contend	VBD
18637	11457	6	the	the	DT
18637	11457	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11457	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11457	9	,	,	,
18637	11457	10	"	"	``
18637	11457	11	would	would	MD
18637	11457	12	be	be	VB
18637	11457	13	to	to	TO
18637	11457	14	sap	sap	VB
18637	11457	15	the	the	DT
18637	11457	16	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11457	17	power	power	NN
18637	11457	18	as	as	IN
18637	11457	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11457	20	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	11457	21	under	under	IN
18637	11457	22	the	the	DT
18637	11457	23	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11457	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11457	25	and	and	CC
18637	11457	26	to	to	TO
18637	11457	27	establish	establish	VB
18637	11457	28	a	a	DT
18637	11457	29	government	government	NN
18637	11457	30	of	of	IN
18637	11457	31	a	a	DT
18637	11457	32	bureaucratic	bureaucratic	JJ
18637	11457	33	character	character	NN
18637	11457	34	alien	alien	NN
18637	11457	35	to	to	IN
18637	11457	36	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11457	37	system	system	NN
18637	11457	38	,	,	,
18637	11457	39	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	11457	40	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11457	41	rights	right	NNS
18637	11457	42	depend	depend	VBP
18637	11457	43	,	,	,
18637	11457	44	as	as	IN
18637	11457	45	not	not	RB
18637	11457	46	infrequently	infrequently	RB
18637	11457	47	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11457	48	do	do	VBP
18637	11457	49	depend	depend	VB
18637	11457	50	,	,	,
18637	11457	51	upon	upon	IN
18637	11457	52	the	the	DT
18637	11457	53	facts	fact	NNS
18637	11457	54	,	,	,
18637	11457	55	and	and	CC
18637	11457	56	finality	finality	NN
18637	11457	57	as	as	IN
18637	11457	58	to	to	IN
18637	11457	59	facts	fact	NNS
18637	11457	60	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	11457	61	in	in	IN
18637	11457	62	effect	effect	NN
18637	11457	63	finality	finality	NN
18637	11457	64	in	in	IN
18637	11457	65	law	law	NN
18637	11457	66	.	.	.
18637	11458	1	"	"	``
18637	11458	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11458	3	637	637	CD
18637	11458	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11458	5	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	11458	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11458	7	VERSUS	VERSUS	NNP
18637	11458	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11458	9	NONJUDICIAL	NONJUDICIAL	NNP
18637	11458	10	FUNCTIONS	FUNCTIONS	NNP
18637	11458	11	The	the	DT
18637	11458	12	power	power	NN
18637	11458	13	of	of	IN
18637	11458	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11458	15	to	to	TO
18637	11458	16	confer	confer	VB
18637	11458	17	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11458	18	on	on	IN
18637	11458	19	the	the	DT
18637	11458	20	lower	low	JJR
18637	11458	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11458	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	11458	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	11458	24	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	11458	25	by	by	IN
18637	11458	26	the	the	DT
18637	11458	27	rule	rule	NN
18637	11458	28	that	that	IN
18637	11458	29	before	before	IN
18637	11458	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11458	31	can	can	MD
18637	11458	32	vest	vest	VB
18637	11458	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11458	34	in	in	IN
18637	11458	35	the	the	DT
18637	11458	36	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	11458	37	courts	court	NNS
18637	11458	38	,	,	,
18637	11458	39	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11458	40	must	must	MD
18637	11458	41	have	have	VB
18637	11458	42	the	the	DT
18637	11458	43	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	11458	44	to	to	TO
18637	11458	45	receive	receive	VB
18637	11458	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11458	47	.	.	.
18637	11459	1	The	the	DT
18637	11459	2	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	11459	3	of	of	IN
18637	11459	4	the	the	DT
18637	11459	5	lower	low	JJR
18637	11459	6	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	11459	7	to	to	TO
18637	11459	8	receive	receive	VB
18637	11459	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11459	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	11459	11	defined	define	VBN
18637	11459	12	in	in	IN
18637	11459	13	the	the	DT
18637	11459	14	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	11459	15	of	of	IN
18637	11459	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	11459	17	and	and	CC
18637	11459	18	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11459	19	in	in	IN
18637	11459	20	article	article	NN
18637	11459	21	III	iii	CD
18637	11459	22	.	.	.
18637	11460	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	11460	2	in	in	IN
18637	11460	3	vesting	vest	VBG
18637	11460	4	courts	court	NNS
18637	11460	5	with	with	IN
18637	11460	6	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11460	7	,	,	,
18637	11460	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11460	9	can	can	MD
18637	11460	10	not	not	RB
18637	11460	11	go	go	VB
18637	11460	12	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	11460	13	this	this	DT
18637	11460	14	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	11460	15	.	.	.
18637	11461	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11461	2	638	638	CD
18637	11461	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11461	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11461	5	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	11461	6	from	from	IN
18637	11461	7	the	the	DT
18637	11461	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	11461	9	that	that	IN
18637	11461	10	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11461	11	courts	court	NNS
18637	11461	12	can	can	MD
18637	11461	13	perform	perform	VB
18637	11461	14	only	only	RB
18637	11461	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11461	16	functions	function	NNS
18637	11461	17	that	that	WDT
18637	11461	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11461	19	,	,	,
18637	11461	20	in	in	IN
18637	11461	21	vesting	vest	VBG
18637	11461	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	11461	23	with	with	IN
18637	11461	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11461	25	,	,	,
18637	11461	26	can	can	MD
18637	11461	27	not	not	RB
18637	11461	28	impose	impose	VB
18637	11461	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	11461	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11461	31	nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	11461	32	duties	duty	NNS
18637	11461	33	such	such	JJ
18637	11461	34	as	as	IN
18637	11461	35	administering	administer	VBG
18637	11461	36	pensions,[639	pensions,[639	NN
18637	11461	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11461	38	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	11461	39	issues	issue	NNS
18637	11461	40	subject	subject	JJ
18637	11461	41	to	to	IN
18637	11461	42	later	later	JJ
18637	11461	43	executive	executive	JJ
18637	11461	44	or	or	CC
18637	11461	45	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	11461	46	action,[640	action,[640	NN
18637	11461	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11461	48	rendering	render	VBG
18637	11461	49	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	11461	50	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	11461	51	,	,	,
18637	11461	52	or	or	CC
18637	11461	53	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	11461	54	which	which	WDT
18637	11461	55	are	be	VBP
18637	11461	56	not	not	RB
18637	11461	57	final	final	JJ
18637	11461	58	and	and	CC
18637	11461	59	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	11461	60	upon	upon	IN
18637	11461	61	the	the	DT
18637	11461	62	parties,[641	parties,[641	NNS
18637	11461	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11461	64	or	or	CC
18637	11461	65	taking	take	VBG
18637	11461	66	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11461	67	of	of	IN
18637	11461	68	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11461	69	from	from	IN
18637	11461	70	which	which	WDT
18637	11461	71	any	any	DT
18637	11461	72	essential	essential	JJ
18637	11461	73	element	element	NN
18637	11461	74	of	of	IN
18637	11461	75	the	the	DT
18637	11461	76	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11461	77	power	power	NN
18637	11461	78	has	have	VBZ
18637	11461	79	been	be	VBN
18637	11461	80	abstracted	abstract	VBN
18637	11461	81	.	.	.
18637	11462	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11462	2	642	642	CD
18637	11462	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11462	4	To	to	TO
18637	11462	5	be	be	VB
18637	11462	6	sure	sure	JJ
18637	11462	7	,	,	,
18637	11462	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11462	9	may	may	MD
18637	11462	10	clothe	clothe	VB
18637	11462	11	some	some	DT
18637	11462	12	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11462	13	of	of	IN
18637	11462	14	an	an	DT
18637	11462	15	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	11462	16	nature	nature	NN
18637	11462	17	with	with	IN
18637	11462	18	the	the	DT
18637	11462	19	mantle	mantle	NN
18637	11462	20	of	of	IN
18637	11462	21	a	a	DT
18637	11462	22	case	case	NN
18637	11462	23	or	or	CC
18637	11462	24	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	11462	25	and	and	CC
18637	11462	26	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	11462	27	make	make	VB
18637	11462	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11462	29	a	a	DT
18637	11462	30	matter	matter	NN
18637	11462	31	of	of	IN
18637	11462	32	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11462	33	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	11462	34	,	,	,
18637	11462	35	as	as	IN
18637	11462	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11462	37	has	have	VBZ
18637	11462	38	done	do	VBN
18637	11462	39	with	with	IN
18637	11462	40	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	11462	41	proceedings,[643	proceedings,[643	NNP
18637	11462	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11462	43	the	the	DT
18637	11462	44	administration	administration	NN
18637	11462	45	of	of	IN
18637	11462	46	certain	certain	JJ
18637	11462	47	laws	law	NNS
18637	11462	48	relating	relate	VBG
18637	11462	49	to	to	IN
18637	11462	50	the	the	DT
18637	11462	51	expulsion	expulsion	NN
18637	11462	52	of	of	IN
18637	11462	53	aliens,[644	aliens,[644	NNP
18637	11462	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11462	55	the	the	DT
18637	11462	56	limited	limited	JJ
18637	11462	57	administration	administration	NN
18637	11462	58	of	of	IN
18637	11462	59	funds	fund	NNS
18637	11462	60	received	receive	VBN
18637	11462	61	from	from	IN
18637	11462	62	the	the	DT
18637	11462	63	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11462	64	of	of	IN
18637	11462	65	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	11462	66	to	to	TO
18637	11462	67	compensate	compensate	VB
18637	11462	68	American	american	JJ
18637	11462	69	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	11462	70	for	for	IN
18637	11462	71	claims	claim	NNS
18637	11462	72	against	against	IN
18637	11462	73	that	that	DT
18637	11462	74	government,[645	government,[645	NN
18637	11462	75	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11462	76	and	and	CC
18637	11462	77	,	,	,
18637	11462	78	of	of	IN
18637	11462	79	course	course	NN
18637	11462	80	,	,	,
18637	11462	81	the	the	DT
18637	11462	82	traditional	traditional	JJ
18637	11462	83	administration	administration	NN
18637	11462	84	of	of	IN
18637	11462	85	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
18637	11462	86	enterprises	enterprise	NNS
18637	11462	87	through	through	IN
18637	11462	88	the	the	DT
18637	11462	89	medium	medium	NN
18637	11462	90	of	of	IN
18637	11462	91	a	a	DT
18637	11462	92	receiver	receiver	NN
18637	11462	93	.	.	.
18637	11463	1	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11463	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	11463	3	State	State	NNP
18637	11463	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11463	5	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	11463	6	PROBLEMS	PROBLEMS	NNP
18637	11463	7	RAISED	raise	VBD
18637	11463	8	BY	by	RB
18637	11463	9	CONCURRENCY	concurrency	VBP
18637	11463	10	The	the	DT
18637	11463	11	American	American	NNP
18637	11463	12	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11463	13	System	System	NNP
18637	11463	14	with	with	IN
18637	11463	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11463	16	dual	dual	JJ
18637	11463	17	system	system	NN
18637	11463	18	of	of	IN
18637	11463	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	11463	20	,	,	,
18637	11463	21	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	11463	22	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	11463	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11463	24	in	in	IN
18637	11463	25	a	a	DT
18637	11463	26	number	number	NN
18637	11463	27	of	of	IN
18637	11463	28	classes	class	NNS
18637	11463	29	of	of	IN
18637	11463	30	cases	case	NNS
18637	11463	31	,	,	,
18637	11463	32	presents	present	VBZ
18637	11463	33	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	11463	34	possibilities	possibility	NNS
18637	11463	35	of	of	IN
18637	11463	36	inter	inter	JJ
18637	11463	37	-	-	JJ
18637	11463	38	court	court	JJ
18637	11463	39	conflicts	conflict	NNS
18637	11463	40	and	and	CC
18637	11463	41	interference	interference	NN
18637	11463	42	.	.	.
18637	11464	1	Subject	subject	JJ
18637	11464	2	to	to	IN
18637	11464	3	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	11464	4	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	11464	5	to	to	IN
18637	11464	6	the	the	DT
18637	11464	7	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	11464	8	,	,	,
18637	11464	9	the	the	DT
18637	11464	10	State	State	NNP
18637	11464	11	courts	court	NNS
18637	11464	12	have	have	VBP
18637	11464	13	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	11464	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11464	15	over	over	IN
18637	11464	16	all	all	PDT
18637	11464	17	the	the	DT
18637	11464	18	classes	class	NNS
18637	11464	19	of	of	IN
18637	11464	20	cases	case	NNS
18637	11464	21	and	and	CC
18637	11464	22	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11464	23	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	11464	24	in	in	IN
18637	11464	25	article	article	NN
18637	11464	26	III	iii	CD
18637	11464	27	except	except	IN
18637	11464	28	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11464	29	between	between	IN
18637	11464	30	States	States	NNP
18637	11464	31	,	,	,
18637	11464	32	those	those	DT
18637	11464	33	to	to	TO
18637	11464	34	which	which	WDT
18637	11464	35	the	the	DT
18637	11464	36	United	United	NNP
18637	11464	37	States	States	NNP
18637	11464	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	11464	39	a	a	DT
18637	11464	40	party	party	NN
18637	11464	41	,	,	,
18637	11464	42	those	those	DT
18637	11464	43	to	to	TO
18637	11464	44	which	which	WDT
18637	11464	45	a	a	DT
18637	11464	46	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11464	47	state	state	NN
18637	11464	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	11464	49	a	a	DT
18637	11464	50	party	party	NN
18637	11464	51	,	,	,
18637	11464	52	and	and	CC
18637	11464	53	cases	case	NNS
18637	11464	54	of	of	IN
18637	11464	55	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11464	56	and	and	CC
18637	11464	57	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11464	58	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11464	59	.	.	.
18637	11465	1	Even	even	RB
18637	11465	2	in	in	IN
18637	11465	3	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11465	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	11465	5	the	the	DT
18637	11465	6	State	State	NNP
18637	11465	7	courts	court	NNS
18637	11465	8	,	,	,
18637	11465	9	though	though	IN
18637	11465	10	unable	unable	JJ
18637	11465	11	to	to	TO
18637	11465	12	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	11465	13	any	any	DT
18637	11465	14	portion	portion	NN
18637	11465	15	of	of	IN
18637	11465	16	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	11465	17	or	or	CC
18637	11465	18	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	11465	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11465	20	by	by	IN
18637	11465	21	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	11465	22	or	or	CC
18637	11465	23	otherwise,[646	otherwise,[646	NN
18637	11465	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11465	25	may	may	MD
18637	11465	26	have	have	VB
18637	11465	27	a	a	DT
18637	11465	28	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	11465	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11465	30	when	when	WRB
18637	11465	31	the	the	DT
18637	11465	32	same	same	JJ
18637	11465	33	issues	issue	NNS
18637	11465	34	assume	assume	VBP
18637	11465	35	the	the	DT
18637	11465	36	form	form	NN
18637	11465	37	of	of	IN
18637	11465	38	a	a	DT
18637	11465	39	case	case	NN
18637	11465	40	at	at	IN
18637	11465	41	common	common	JJ
18637	11465	42	law	law	NN
18637	11465	43	.	.	.
18637	11466	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11466	2	647	647	CD
18637	11466	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11466	4	In	in	IN
18637	11466	5	addition	addition	NN
18637	11466	6	to	to	IN
18637	11466	7	conflicts	conflict	NNS
18637	11466	8	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11466	9	out	out	IN
18637	11466	10	of	of	IN
18637	11466	11	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	11466	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11466	13	,	,	,
18637	11466	14	relations	relation	NNS
18637	11466	15	between	between	IN
18637	11466	16	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11466	17	and	and	CC
18637	11466	18	State	State	NNP
18637	11466	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	11466	20	are	be	VBP
18637	11466	21	exposed	expose	VBN
18637	11466	22	to	to	IN
18637	11466	23	other	other	JJ
18637	11466	24	frictions	friction	NNS
18637	11466	25	,	,	,
18637	11466	26	such	such	JJ
18637	11466	27	as	as	IN
18637	11466	28	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	11466	29	in	in	IN
18637	11466	30	one	one	CD
18637	11466	31	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11466	32	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	11466	33	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11466	34	processes	process	NNS
18637	11466	35	in	in	IN
18637	11466	36	another	another	DT
18637	11466	37	,	,	,
18637	11466	38	the	the	DT
18637	11466	39	use	use	NN
18637	11466	40	of	of	IN
18637	11466	41	the	the	DT
18637	11466	42	writ	writ	NNP
18637	11466	43	of	of	IN
18637	11466	44	_	_	NNP
18637	11466	45	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11466	46	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11466	47	_	_	NNP
18637	11466	48	by	by	IN
18637	11466	49	a	a	DT
18637	11466	50	court	court	NN
18637	11466	51	of	of	IN
18637	11466	52	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	11466	53	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11466	54	to	to	TO
18637	11466	55	release	release	VB
18637	11466	56	persons	person	NNS
18637	11466	57	in	in	IN
18637	11466	58	custody	custody	NN
18637	11466	59	of	of	IN
18637	11466	60	another	another	DT
18637	11466	61	,	,	,
18637	11466	62	and	and	CC
18637	11466	63	the	the	DT
18637	11466	64	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	11466	65	by	by	IN
18637	11466	66	State	State	NNP
18637	11466	67	courts	court	NNS
18637	11466	68	to	to	TO
18637	11466	69	comply	comply	VB
18637	11466	70	with	with	IN
18637	11466	71	orders	order	NNS
18637	11466	72	of	of	IN
18637	11466	73	the	the	DT
18637	11466	74	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11466	75	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11466	76	.	.	.
18637	11467	1	The	the	DT
18637	11467	2	relations	relation	NNS
18637	11467	3	between	between	IN
18637	11467	4	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11467	5	and	and	CC
18637	11467	6	State	State	NNP
18637	11467	7	courts	court	NNS
18637	11467	8	are	be	VBP
18637	11467	9	governed	govern	VBN
18637	11467	10	in	in	IN
18637	11467	11	part	part	NN
18637	11467	12	by	by	IN
18637	11467	13	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	11467	14	Law	Law	NNP
18637	11467	15	with	with	IN
18637	11467	16	respect	respect	NN
18637	11467	17	to	to	IN
18637	11467	18	State	state	NN
18637	11467	19	court	court	NN
18637	11467	20	interference	interference	NN
18637	11467	21	with	with	IN
18637	11467	22	the	the	DT
18637	11467	23	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11467	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	11467	25	and	and	CC
18637	11467	26	State	State	NNP
18637	11467	27	court	court	NN
18637	11467	28	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	11467	29	to	to	TO
18637	11467	30	comply	comply	VB
18637	11467	31	with	with	IN
18637	11467	32	the	the	DT
18637	11467	33	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	11467	34	of	of	IN
18637	11467	35	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11467	36	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	11467	37	,	,	,
18637	11467	38	by	by	IN
18637	11467	39	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	11467	40	as	as	IN
18637	11467	41	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	11467	42	interference	interference	NN
18637	11467	43	by	by	IN
18637	11467	44	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11467	45	courts	court	NNS
18637	11467	46	with	with	IN
18637	11467	47	those	those	DT
18637	11467	48	of	of	IN
18637	11467	49	the	the	DT
18637	11467	50	States	States	NNPS
18637	11467	51	,	,	,
18637	11467	52	and	and	CC
18637	11467	53	by	by	IN
18637	11467	54	self	self	NN
18637	11467	55	-	-	HYPH
18637	11467	56	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	11467	57	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11467	58	of	of	IN
18637	11467	59	comity	comity	NN
18637	11467	60	applied	apply	VBN
18637	11467	61	for	for	IN
18637	11467	62	the	the	DT
18637	11467	63	avoidance	avoidance	NN
18637	11467	64	of	of	IN
18637	11467	65	unseemly	unseemly	JJ
18637	11467	66	conflicts	conflict	NNS
18637	11467	67	.	.	.
18637	11468	1	DISOBEDIENCE	disobedience	NN
18637	11468	2	OF	of	IN
18637	11468	3	SUPREME	SUPREME	NNP
18637	11468	4	COURT	COURT	NNP
18637	11468	5	ORDERS	order	NNS
18637	11468	6	BY	by	IN
18637	11468	7	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	11468	8	COURTS	court	VBD
18637	11468	9	The	the	DT
18637	11468	10	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	11468	11	of	of	IN
18637	11468	12	State	State	NNP
18637	11468	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	11468	14	to	to	TO
18637	11468	15	make	make	VB
18637	11468	16	returns	return	NNS
18637	11468	17	on	on	IN
18637	11468	18	writs	writ	NNS
18637	11468	19	of	of	IN
18637	11468	20	errors	error	NNS
18637	11468	21	issued	issue	VBN
18637	11468	22	by	by	IN
18637	11468	23	the	the	DT
18637	11468	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11468	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11468	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	11468	27	already	already	RB
18637	11468	28	been	be	VBN
18637	11468	29	noted	note	VBN
18637	11468	30	in	in	IN
18637	11468	31	connection	connection	NN
18637	11468	32	with	with	IN
18637	11468	33	the	the	DT
18637	11468	34	disobedience	disobedience	NN
18637	11468	35	of	of	IN
18637	11468	36	the	the	DT
18637	11468	37	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11468	38	courts	court	NNS
18637	11468	39	in	in	IN
18637	11468	40	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	11468	41	_	_	NNP
18637	11468	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	11468	43	_	_	NNP
18637	11468	44	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	11468	45	's	's	POS
18637	11468	46	Lessee[648	Lessee[648	NNP
18637	11468	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11468	48	and	and	CC
18637	11468	49	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	11468	50	_	_	NNP
18637	11468	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	11468	52	_	_	NNP
18637	11468	53	Virginia[649	Virginia[649	NNP
18637	11468	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11468	55	and	and	CC
18637	11468	56	in	in	IN
18637	11468	57	that	that	DT
18637	11468	58	of	of	IN
18637	11468	59	the	the	DT
18637	11468	60	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	11468	61	court	court	NN
18637	11468	62	in	in	IN
18637	11468	63	Ableman	Ableman	NNP
18637	11468	64	_	_	NNP
18637	11468	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	11468	66	_	_	NNP
18637	11468	67	Booth	Booth	NNP
18637	11468	68	.	.	.
18637	11469	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11469	2	650	650	CD
18637	11469	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11469	4	More	more	RBR
18637	11469	5	spectacular	spectacular	JJ
18637	11469	6	disobedience	disobedience	NN
18637	11469	7	to	to	IN
18637	11469	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11469	9	authority	authority	NN
18637	11469	10	arose	arise	VBD
18637	11469	11	out	out	IN
18637	11469	12	of	of	IN
18637	11469	13	the	the	DT
18637	11469	14	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	11469	15	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	11469	16	case	case	NN
18637	11469	17	involving	involve	VBG
18637	11469	18	actions	action	NNS
18637	11469	19	of	of	IN
18637	11469	20	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11469	21	and	and	CC
18637	11469	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11469	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	11469	24	.	.	.
18637	11470	1	In	in	IN
18637	11470	2	the	the	DT
18637	11470	3	first	first	JJ
18637	11470	4	of	of	IN
18637	11470	5	these	these	DT
18637	11470	6	the	the	DT
18637	11470	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11470	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11470	9	had	have	VBD
18637	11470	10	issued	issue	VBN
18637	11470	11	a	a	DT
18637	11470	12	writ	writ	NN
18637	11470	13	of	of	IN
18637	11470	14	error	error	NN
18637	11470	15	to	to	IN
18637	11470	16	the	the	DT
18637	11470	17	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11470	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11470	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11470	20	to	to	TO
18637	11470	21	review	review	VB
18637	11470	22	the	the	DT
18637	11470	23	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	11470	24	of	of	IN
18637	11470	25	Corn	Corn	NNP
18637	11470	26	Tassel	Tassel	NNP
18637	11470	27	for	for	IN
18637	11470	28	the	the	DT
18637	11470	29	murder	murder	NN
18637	11470	30	of	of	IN
18637	11470	31	another	another	DT
18637	11470	32	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	11470	33	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	11470	34	.	.	.
18637	11471	1	The	the	DT
18637	11471	2	writ	writ	NNP
18637	11471	3	was	be	VBD
18637	11471	4	served	serve	VBN
18637	11471	5	,	,	,
18637	11471	6	but	but	CC
18637	11471	7	before	before	IN
18637	11471	8	a	a	DT
18637	11471	9	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	11471	10	could	could	MD
18637	11471	11	be	be	VB
18637	11471	12	held	hold	VBN
18637	11471	13	Corn	Corn	NNP
18637	11471	14	Tassel	Tassel	NNP
18637	11471	15	was	be	VBD
18637	11471	16	executed	execute	VBN
18637	11471	17	on	on	IN
18637	11471	18	the	the	DT
18637	11471	19	day	day	NN
18637	11471	20	originally	originally	RB
18637	11471	21	set	set	VBN
18637	11471	22	for	for	IN
18637	11471	23	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	11471	24	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	11471	25	to	to	IN
18637	11471	26	the	the	DT
18637	11471	27	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11471	28	law	law	NN
18637	11471	29	that	that	WDT
18637	11471	30	a	a	DT
18637	11471	31	writ	writ	NN
18637	11471	32	of	of	IN
18637	11471	33	error	error	NN
18637	11471	34	superseded	superseded	JJ
18637	11471	35	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	11471	36	until	until	IN
18637	11471	37	the	the	DT
18637	11471	38	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	11471	39	was	be	VBD
18637	11471	40	decided	decide	VBN
18637	11471	41	.	.	.
18637	11472	1	This	this	DT
18637	11472	2	action	action	NN
18637	11472	3	ensued	ensue	VBD
18637	11472	4	as	as	IN
18637	11472	5	a	a	DT
18637	11472	6	result	result	NN
18637	11472	7	of	of	IN
18637	11472	8	the	the	DT
18637	11472	9	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	11472	10	's	's	POS
18637	11472	11	approval	approval	NN
18637	11472	12	of	of	IN
18637	11472	13	the	the	DT
18637	11472	14	governor	governor	NN
18637	11472	15	's	's	POS
18637	11472	16	policy	policy	NN
18637	11472	17	that	that	WDT
18637	11472	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11472	19	would	would	MD
18637	11472	20	permit	permit	VB
18637	11472	21	no	no	DT
18637	11472	22	interference	interference	NN
18637	11472	23	with	with	IN
18637	11472	24	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11472	25	's	's	POS
18637	11472	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	11472	27	by	by	IN
18637	11472	28	orders	order	NNS
18637	11472	29	of	of	IN
18637	11472	30	the	the	DT
18637	11472	31	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11472	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11472	33	and	and	CC
18637	11472	34	would	would	MD
18637	11472	35	resist	resist	VB
18637	11472	36	by	by	IN
18637	11472	37	force	force	NN
18637	11472	38	any	any	DT
18637	11472	39	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	11472	40	to	to	TO
18637	11472	41	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11472	42	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11472	43	with	with	IN
18637	11472	44	all	all	PDT
18637	11472	45	the	the	DT
18637	11472	46	forces	force	NNS
18637	11472	47	at	at	IN
18637	11472	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11472	49	command	command	NN
18637	11472	50	.	.	.
18637	11473	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11473	2	651	651	CD
18637	11473	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11473	4	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
18637	11473	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11473	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11473	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11473	8	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11473	9	Two	two	CD
18637	11473	10	years	year	NNS
18637	11473	11	later	later	RBR
18637	11473	12	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11473	13	renewed	renew	VBD
18637	11473	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11473	15	defiance	defiance	NN
18637	11473	16	of	of	IN
18637	11473	17	the	the	DT
18637	11473	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11473	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11473	20	in	in	IN
18637	11473	21	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
18637	11473	22	_	_	NNP
18637	11473	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	11473	24	_	_	NNP
18637	11473	25	Georgia[652	Georgia[652	NNP
18637	11473	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11473	27	which	which	WDT
18637	11473	28	involved	involve	VBD
18637	11473	29	the	the	DT
18637	11473	30	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	11473	31	of	of	IN
18637	11473	32	two	two	CD
18637	11473	33	missionaries	missionary	NNS
18637	11473	34	for	for	IN
18637	11473	35	residing	reside	VBG
18637	11473	36	among	among	IN
18637	11473	37	the	the	DT
18637	11473	38	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	11473	39	without	without	IN
18637	11473	40	a	a	DT
18637	11473	41	license	license	NN
18637	11473	42	.	.	.
18637	11474	1	The	the	DT
18637	11474	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11474	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11474	4	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	11474	5	the	the	DT
18637	11474	6	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	11474	7	on	on	IN
18637	11474	8	the	the	DT
18637	11474	9	ground	ground	NN
18637	11474	10	that	that	IN
18637	11474	11	the	the	DT
18637	11474	12	State	State	NNP
18637	11474	13	had	have	VBD
18637	11474	14	no	no	DT
18637	11474	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11474	16	over	over	IN
18637	11474	17	the	the	DT
18637	11474	18	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	11474	19	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	11474	20	and	and	CC
18637	11474	21	ordered	order	VBD
18637	11474	22	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
18637	11474	23	's	's	POS
18637	11474	24	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	11474	25	in	in	IN
18637	11474	26	a	a	DT
18637	11474	27	special	special	JJ
18637	11474	28	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	11474	29	to	to	IN
18637	11474	30	the	the	DT
18637	11474	31	superior	superior	JJ
18637	11474	32	court	court	NN
18637	11474	33	of	of	IN
18637	11474	34	Gwinnett	Gwinnett	NNP
18637	11474	35	County	County	NNP
18637	11474	36	.	.	.
18637	11475	1	The	the	DT
18637	11475	2	State	State	NNP
18637	11475	3	court	court	NN
18637	11475	4	ignored	ignore	VBD
18637	11475	5	the	the	DT
18637	11475	6	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	11475	7	and	and	CC
18637	11475	8	once	once	RB
18637	11475	9	again	again	RB
18637	11475	10	the	the	DT
18637	11475	11	governor	governor	NN
18637	11475	12	of	of	IN
18637	11475	13	the	the	DT
18637	11475	14	State	State	NNP
18637	11475	15	announced	announce	VBD
18637	11475	16	that	that	IN
18637	11475	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11475	18	would	would	MD
18637	11475	19	meet	meet	VB
18637	11475	20	such	such	JJ
18637	11475	21	usurpation	usurpation	NN
18637	11475	22	by	by	IN
18637	11475	23	the	the	DT
18637	11475	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11475	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11475	26	with	with	IN
18637	11475	27	determined	determine	VBN
18637	11475	28	resistance	resistance	NN
18637	11475	29	.	.	.
18637	11476	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	11476	2	,	,	,
18637	11476	3	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
18637	11476	4	and	and	CC
18637	11476	5	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	11476	6	remained	remain	VBD
18637	11476	7	in	in	IN
18637	11476	8	jail	jail	NN
18637	11476	9	until	until	IN
18637	11476	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11476	11	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	11476	12	to	to	TO
18637	11476	13	abandon	abandon	VB
18637	11476	14	further	further	JJ
18637	11476	15	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	11476	16	for	for	IN
18637	11476	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11476	18	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	11476	19	by	by	IN
18637	11476	20	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11476	21	authority	authority	NN
18637	11476	22	in	in	IN
18637	11476	23	the	the	DT
18637	11476	24	form	form	NN
18637	11476	25	of	of	IN
18637	11476	26	a	a	DT
18637	11476	27	writ	writ	NN
18637	11476	28	of	of	IN
18637	11476	29	error	error	NN
18637	11476	30	,	,	,
18637	11476	31	whereupon	whereupon	IN
18637	11476	32	the	the	DT
18637	11476	33	governor	governor	NN
18637	11476	34	pardoned	pardon	VBD
18637	11476	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11476	36	on	on	IN
18637	11476	37	the	the	DT
18637	11476	38	condition	condition	NN
18637	11476	39	that	that	IN
18637	11476	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11476	41	leave	leave	VBP
18637	11476	42	the	the	DT
18637	11476	43	State	State	NNP
18637	11476	44	.	.	.
18637	11477	1	CONFLICTS	CONFLICTS	NNP
18637	11477	2	OF	of	IN
18637	11477	3	JURISDICTION	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11477	4	:	:	:
18637	11477	5	COMITY	COMITY	NNP
18637	11477	6	Aside	aside	RB
18637	11477	7	from	from	IN
18637	11477	8	these	these	DT
18637	11477	9	more	more	RBR
18637	11477	10	dramatic	dramatic	JJ
18637	11477	11	assertions	assertion	NNS
18637	11477	12	of	of	IN
18637	11477	13	independence	independence	NN
18637	11477	14	of	of	IN
18637	11477	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11477	16	courts	court	NNS
18637	11477	17	,	,	,
18637	11477	18	State	state	NN
18637	11477	19	court	court	NN
18637	11477	20	interference	interference	NN
18637	11477	21	with	with	IN
18637	11477	22	the	the	DT
18637	11477	23	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11477	24	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	11477	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	11477	26	occurred	occur	VBN
18637	11477	27	for	for	IN
18637	11477	28	the	the	DT
18637	11477	29	most	most	JJS
18637	11477	30	part	part	NN
18637	11477	31	in	in	IN
18637	11477	32	conflicts	conflict	NNS
18637	11477	33	of	of	IN
18637	11477	34	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11477	35	which	which	WDT
18637	11477	36	affect	affect	VBP
18637	11477	37	only	only	RB
18637	11477	38	the	the	DT
18637	11477	39	lower	low	JJR
18637	11477	40	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11477	41	courts	court	NNS
18637	11477	42	as	as	IN
18637	11477	43	courts	court	NNS
18637	11477	44	of	of	IN
18637	11477	45	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	11477	46	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11477	47	and	and	CC
18637	11477	48	in	in	IN
18637	11477	49	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	11477	50	to	to	TO
18637	11477	51	release	release	VB
18637	11477	52	persons	person	NNS
18637	11477	53	in	in	IN
18637	11477	54	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11477	55	custody	custody	NN
18637	11477	56	.	.	.
18637	11478	1	To	to	IN
18637	11478	2	the	the	DT
18637	11478	3	extent	extent	NN
18637	11478	4	that	that	IN
18637	11478	5	this	this	DT
18637	11478	6	phase	phase	NN
18637	11478	7	of	of	IN
18637	11478	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11478	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	11478	10	state	state	NN
18637	11478	11	relations	relation	NNS
18637	11478	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	11478	13	not	not	RB
18637	11478	14	governed	govern	VBN
18637	11478	15	by	by	IN
18637	11478	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	11478	17	or	or	CC
18637	11478	18	the	the	DT
18637	11478	19	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	11478	20	clause	clause	NN
18637	11478	21	of	of	IN
18637	11478	22	article	article	NN
18637	11478	23	VI	VI	NNP
18637	11478	24	,	,	,
18637	11478	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11478	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	11478	27	governed	govern	VBN
18637	11478	28	by	by	IN
18637	11478	29	comity	comity	NN
18637	11478	30	,	,	,
18637	11478	31	a	a	DT
18637	11478	32	self	self	NN
18637	11478	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	11478	34	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	11478	35	rule	rule	NN
18637	11478	36	of	of	IN
18637	11478	37	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11478	38	morality	morality	NN
18637	11478	39	whereby	whereby	IN
18637	11478	40	independent	independent	JJ
18637	11478	41	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	11478	42	of	of	IN
18637	11478	43	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	11478	44	or	or	CC
18637	11478	45	coordinate	coordinate	VB
18637	11478	46	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11478	47	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11478	48	a	a	DT
18637	11478	49	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	11478	50	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	11478	51	in	in	IN
18637	11478	52	order	order	NN
18637	11478	53	to	to	TO
18637	11478	54	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	11478	55	interference	interference	NN
18637	11478	56	with	with	IN
18637	11478	57	each	each	DT
18637	11478	58	other	other	JJ
18637	11478	59	and	and	CC
18637	11478	60	to	to	TO
18637	11478	61	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	11478	62	collisions	collision	NNS
18637	11478	63	of	of	IN
18637	11478	64	authority	authority	NN
18637	11478	65	.	.	.
18637	11479	1	Although	although	IN
18637	11479	2	the	the	DT
18637	11479	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11479	4	on	on	IN
18637	11479	5	one	one	CD
18637	11479	6	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	11479	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	11479	8	stated	state	VBN
18637	11479	9	that	that	IN
18637	11479	10	the	the	DT
18637	11479	11	principle	principle	NN
18637	11479	12	of	of	IN
18637	11479	13	comity	comity	NN
18637	11479	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	11479	15	not	not	RB
18637	11479	16	a	a	DT
18637	11479	17	rule	rule	NN
18637	11479	18	of	of	IN
18637	11479	19	law	law	NN
18637	11479	20	but	but	CC
18637	11479	21	"	"	``
18637	11479	22	one	one	CD
18637	11479	23	of	of	IN
18637	11479	24	practice	practice	NN
18637	11479	25	,	,	,
18637	11479	26	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	11479	27	,	,	,
18637	11479	28	and	and	CC
18637	11479	29	expediency"[653	expediency"[653	NNP
18637	11479	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11479	31	which	which	WDT
18637	11479	32	persuades	persuade	NNS
18637	11479	33	,	,	,
18637	11479	34	but	but	CC
18637	11479	35	does	do	VBZ
18637	11479	36	not	not	RB
18637	11479	37	command	command	VB
18637	11479	38	,	,	,
18637	11479	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11479	40	has	have	VBZ
18637	11479	41	also	also	RB
18637	11479	42	declared	declare	VBN
18637	11479	43	that	that	IN
18637	11479	44	in	in	IN
18637	11479	45	the	the	DT
18637	11479	46	American	American	NNP
18637	11479	47	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11479	48	System	System	NNP
18637	11479	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11479	50	has	have	VBZ
18637	11479	51	come	come	VBN
18637	11479	52	to	to	TO
18637	11479	53	have	have	VB
18637	11479	54	"	"	``
18637	11479	55	a	a	DT
18637	11479	56	higher	high	JJR
18637	11479	57	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	11479	58	than	than	IN
18637	11479	59	the	the	DT
18637	11479	60	utility	utility	NN
18637	11479	61	which	which	WDT
18637	11479	62	comes	come	VBZ
18637	11479	63	from	from	IN
18637	11479	64	concord	concord	NN
18637	11479	65	"	"	''
18637	11479	66	and	and	CC
18637	11479	67	has	have	VBZ
18637	11479	68	been	be	VBN
18637	11479	69	converted	convert	VBN
18637	11479	70	into	into	IN
18637	11479	71	a	a	DT
18637	11479	72	principle	principle	NN
18637	11479	73	"	"	''
18637	11479	74	of	of	IN
18637	11479	75	right	right	NN
18637	11479	76	and	and	CC
18637	11479	77	of	of	IN
18637	11479	78	law	law	NN
18637	11479	79	,	,	,
18637	11479	80	and	and	CC
18637	11479	81	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11479	82	of	of	IN
18637	11479	83	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	11479	84	.	.	.
18637	11480	1	"	"	``
18637	11480	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11480	3	654	654	CD
18637	11480	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11480	5	As	as	IN
18637	11480	6	developed	develop	VBN
18637	11480	7	and	and	CC
18637	11480	8	applied	apply	VBN
18637	11480	9	by	by	IN
18637	11480	10	the	the	DT
18637	11480	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11480	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11480	13	the	the	DT
18637	11480	14	rule	rule	NN
18637	11480	15	of	of	IN
18637	11480	16	comity	comity	NN
18637	11480	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	11480	18	exemplified	exemplify	VBN
18637	11480	19	in	in	IN
18637	11480	20	three	three	CD
18637	11480	21	classes	class	NNS
18637	11480	22	of	of	IN
18637	11480	23	cases	case	NNS
18637	11480	24	:	:	:
18637	11480	25	First	first	RB
18637	11480	26	,	,	,
18637	11480	27	those	those	DT
18637	11480	28	in	in	IN
18637	11480	29	which	which	WDT
18637	11480	30	a	a	DT
18637	11480	31	court	court	NN
18637	11480	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	11480	33	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	11480	34	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11480	35	of	of	IN
18637	11480	36	the	the	DT
18637	11480	37	_	_	NNP
18637	11480	38	res	res	NNP
18637	11480	39	_	_	NNP
18637	11480	40	or	or	CC
18637	11480	41	the	the	DT
18637	11480	42	possession	possession	NN
18637	11480	43	of	of	IN
18637	11480	44	property	property	NN
18637	11480	45	and	and	CC
18637	11480	46	another	another	DT
18637	11480	47	court	court	NN
18637	11480	48	interferes	interfere	VBZ
18637	11480	49	with	with	IN
18637	11480	50	that	that	DT
18637	11480	51	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11480	52	or	or	CC
18637	11480	53	possession	possession	NN
18637	11480	54	;	;	:
18637	11480	55	second	second	LS
18637	11480	56	,	,	,
18637	11480	57	those	those	DT
18637	11480	58	in	in	IN
18637	11480	59	which	which	WDT
18637	11480	60	a	a	DT
18637	11480	61	court	court	NN
18637	11480	62	has	have	VBZ
18637	11480	63	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	11480	64	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11480	65	or	or	CC
18637	11480	66	custody	custody	NN
18637	11480	67	of	of	IN
18637	11480	68	the	the	DT
18637	11480	69	person	person	NN
18637	11480	70	and	and	CC
18637	11480	71	another	another	DT
18637	11480	72	interferes	interfere	VBZ
18637	11480	73	with	with	IN
18637	11480	74	such	such	JJ
18637	11480	75	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11480	76	or	or	CC
18637	11480	77	custody	custody	NN
18637	11480	78	,	,	,
18637	11480	79	most	most	RBS
18637	11480	80	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	11480	81	by	by	IN
18637	11480	82	discharges	discharge	NNS
18637	11480	83	from	from	IN
18637	11480	84	custody	custody	NN
18637	11480	85	in	in	IN
18637	11480	86	_	_	NNP
18637	11480	87	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11480	88	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11480	89	_	_	NNP
18637	11480	90	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11480	91	;	;	:
18637	11480	92	and	and	CC
18637	11480	93	,	,	,
18637	11480	94	third	third	JJ
18637	11480	95	,	,	,
18637	11480	96	those	those	DT
18637	11480	97	in	in	IN
18637	11480	98	which	which	WDT
18637	11480	99	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	11480	100	are	be	VBP
18637	11480	101	used	use	VBN
18637	11480	102	to	to	TO
18637	11480	103	stay	stay	VB
18637	11480	104	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11480	105	in	in	IN
18637	11480	106	another	another	DT
18637	11480	107	court	court	NN
18637	11480	108	or	or	CC
18637	11480	109	to	to	TO
18637	11480	110	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	11480	111	official	official	JJ
18637	11480	112	action	action	NN
18637	11480	113	before	before	IN
18637	11480	114	the	the	DT
18637	11480	115	courts	court	NNS
18637	11480	116	of	of	IN
18637	11480	117	proper	proper	JJ
18637	11480	118	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11480	119	have	have	VBP
18637	11480	120	had	have	VBN
18637	11480	121	an	an	DT
18637	11480	122	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	11480	123	to	to	TO
18637	11480	124	adjudicate	adjudicate	VB
18637	11480	125	the	the	DT
18637	11480	126	issue	issue	NN
18637	11480	127	.	.	.
18637	11481	1	JURISDICTION	JURISDICTION	NNP
18637	11481	2	OF	of	IN
18637	11481	3	THE	the	DT
18637	11481	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11481	5	RES	RES	NNP
18637	11481	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11481	7	As	as	IN
18637	11481	8	applied	apply	VBN
18637	11481	9	by	by	IN
18637	11481	10	the	the	DT
18637	11481	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11481	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11481	13	in	in	IN
18637	11481	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	11481	15	involving	involve	VBG
18637	11481	16	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	11481	17	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11481	18	the	the	DT
18637	11481	19	principle	principle	NN
18637	11481	20	of	of	IN
18637	11481	21	comity	comity	NN
18637	11481	22	means	mean	VBZ
18637	11481	23	that	that	IN
18637	11481	24	when	when	WRB
18637	11481	25	the	the	DT
18637	11481	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11481	27	of	of	IN
18637	11481	28	a	a	DT
18637	11481	29	court	court	NN
18637	11481	30	and	and	CC
18637	11481	31	the	the	DT
18637	11481	32	right	right	NN
18637	11481	33	of	of	IN
18637	11481	34	a	a	DT
18637	11481	35	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	11481	36	to	to	TO
18637	11481	37	prosecute	prosecute	VB
18637	11481	38	a	a	DT
18637	11481	39	suit	suit	NN
18637	11481	40	therein	therein	RB
18637	11481	41	have	have	VBP
18637	11481	42	attached	attach	VBN
18637	11481	43	and	and	CC
18637	11481	44	when	when	WRB
18637	11481	45	a	a	DT
18637	11481	46	court	court	NN
18637	11481	47	has	have	VBZ
18637	11481	48	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	11481	49	constructive	constructive	JJ
18637	11481	50	possession	possession	NN
18637	11481	51	of	of	IN
18637	11481	52	property	property	NN
18637	11481	53	,	,	,
18637	11481	54	such	such	JJ
18637	11481	55	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11481	56	can	can	MD
18637	11481	57	not	not	RB
18637	11481	58	be	be	VB
18637	11481	59	taken	take	VBN
18637	11481	60	away	away	RP
18637	11481	61	or	or	CC
18637	11481	62	obstructed	obstruct	VBN
18637	11481	63	by	by	IN
18637	11481	64	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11481	65	in	in	IN
18637	11481	66	another	another	DT
18637	11481	67	court	court	NN
18637	11481	68	,	,	,
18637	11481	69	nor	nor	CC
18637	11481	70	can	can	MD
18637	11481	71	the	the	DT
18637	11481	72	possession	possession	NN
18637	11481	73	of	of	IN
18637	11481	74	the	the	DT
18637	11481	75	property	property	NN
18637	11481	76	be	be	VB
18637	11481	77	disturbed	disturb	VBN
18637	11481	78	by	by	IN
18637	11481	79	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11481	80	in	in	IN
18637	11481	81	another	another	DT
18637	11481	82	court	court	NN
18637	11481	83	;	;	:
18637	11481	84	and	and	CC
18637	11481	85	the	the	DT
18637	11481	86	court	court	NN
18637	11481	87	which	which	WDT
18637	11481	88	has	have	VBZ
18637	11481	89	first	first	RB
18637	11481	90	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	11481	91	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11481	92	of	of	IN
18637	11481	93	the	the	DT
18637	11481	94	cause	cause	NN
18637	11481	95	or	or	CC
18637	11481	96	the	the	DT
18637	11481	97	possession	possession	NN
18637	11481	98	of	of	IN
18637	11481	99	the	the	DT
18637	11481	100	_	_	NNP
18637	11481	101	res	res	NNP
18637	11481	102	_	_	NNP
18637	11481	103	has	have	VBZ
18637	11481	104	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11481	105	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11481	106	to	to	TO
18637	11481	107	hear	hear	VB
18637	11481	108	and	and	CC
18637	11481	109	determine	determine	VB
18637	11481	110	the	the	DT
18637	11481	111	case	case	NN
18637	11481	112	and	and	CC
18637	11481	113	all	all	DT
18637	11481	114	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11481	115	relating	relate	VBG
18637	11481	116	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	11481	117	,	,	,
18637	11481	118	provided	provide	VBN
18637	11481	119	that	that	IN
18637	11481	120	the	the	DT
18637	11481	121	subject	subject	JJ
18637	11481	122	matter	matter	NN
18637	11481	123	of	of	IN
18637	11481	124	the	the	DT
18637	11481	125	suit	suit	NN
18637	11481	126	,	,	,
18637	11481	127	the	the	DT
18637	11481	128	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	11481	129	sought	seek	VBD
18637	11481	130	,	,	,
18637	11481	131	and	and	CC
18637	11481	132	the	the	DT
18637	11481	133	parties	party	NNS
18637	11481	134	to	to	IN
18637	11481	135	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11481	136	are	be	VBP
18637	11481	137	the	the	DT
18637	11481	138	same	same	JJ
18637	11481	139	,	,	,
18637	11481	140	and	and	CC
18637	11481	141	provided	provide	VBD
18637	11481	142	further	further	RB
18637	11481	143	that	that	IN
18637	11481	144	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11481	145	is	be	VBZ
18637	11481	146	not	not	RB
18637	11481	147	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11481	148	for	for	IN
18637	11481	149	the	the	DT
18637	11481	150	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11481	151	courts	court	NNS
18637	11481	152	to	to	TO
18637	11481	153	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	11481	154	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11481	155	in	in	IN
18637	11481	156	order	order	NN
18637	11481	157	to	to	TO
18637	11481	158	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11481	159	the	the	DT
18637	11481	160	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	11481	161	of	of	IN
18637	11481	162	the	the	DT
18637	11481	163	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11481	164	and	and	CC
18637	11481	165	laws	law	NNS
18637	11481	166	of	of	IN
18637	11481	167	the	the	DT
18637	11481	168	United	United	NNP
18637	11481	169	States	States	NNP
18637	11481	170	.	.	.
18637	11482	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11482	2	655	655	CD
18637	11482	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11482	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	11482	5	INTERFERENCE	interference	NN
18637	11482	6	BY	by	IN
18637	11482	7	INJUNCTION	injunction	NN
18637	11482	8	WITH	with	IN
18637	11482	9	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	11482	10	JURISDICTION	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11482	11	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11482	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	11482	13	long	long	RB
18637	11482	14	been	be	VBN
18637	11482	15	settled	settle	VBN
18637	11482	16	as	as	IN
18637	11482	17	a	a	DT
18637	11482	18	general	general	JJ
18637	11482	19	rule	rule	NN
18637	11482	20	that	that	IN
18637	11482	21	State	State	NNP
18637	11482	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	11482	23	have	have	VBP
18637	11482	24	no	no	DT
18637	11482	25	power	power	NN
18637	11482	26	to	to	TO
18637	11482	27	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	11482	28	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11482	29	or	or	CC
18637	11482	30	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	11482	31	of	of	IN
18637	11482	32	the	the	DT
18637	11482	33	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11482	34	courts	court	NNS
18637	11482	35	.	.	.
18637	11483	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11483	2	656	656	CD
18637	11483	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11483	4	In	in	IN
18637	11483	5	United	United	NNP
18637	11483	6	States	States	NNP
18637	11483	7	ex	ex	NNP
18637	11483	8	rel	rel	NN
18637	11483	9	.	.	.
18637	11484	1	Riggs	Riggs	NNP
18637	11484	2	_	_	NNP
18637	11484	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	11484	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11484	5	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	11484	6	County[657	County[657	NNP
18637	11484	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11484	8	this	this	DT
18637	11484	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	11484	10	was	be	VBD
18637	11484	11	attributed	attribute	VBN
18637	11484	12	to	to	IN
18637	11484	13	no	no	DT
18637	11484	14	paramount	paramount	JJ
18637	11484	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11484	16	of	of	IN
18637	11484	17	the	the	DT
18637	11484	18	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11484	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	11484	20	,	,	,
18637	11484	21	but	but	CC
18637	11484	22	rather	rather	RB
18637	11484	23	to	to	IN
18637	11484	24	the	the	DT
18637	11484	25	complete	complete	JJ
18637	11484	26	independence	independence	NN
18637	11484	27	of	of	IN
18637	11484	28	the	the	DT
18637	11484	29	State	State	NNP
18637	11484	30	and	and	CC
18637	11484	31	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11484	32	courts	court	NNS
18637	11484	33	in	in	IN
18637	11484	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11484	35	spheres	sphere	NNS
18637	11484	36	of	of	IN
18637	11484	37	action	action	NN
18637	11484	38	.	.	.
18637	11485	1	Like	like	IN
18637	11485	2	many	many	JJ
18637	11485	3	of	of	IN
18637	11485	4	the	the	DT
18637	11485	5	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11485	6	governing	govern	VBG
18637	11485	7	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11485	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	11485	9	state	state	NN
18637	11485	10	court	court	NN
18637	11485	11	relations	relation	NNS
18637	11485	12	,	,	,
18637	11485	13	this	this	DT
18637	11485	14	rule	rule	NN
18637	11485	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	11485	16	not	not	RB
18637	11485	17	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	11485	18	,	,	,
18637	11485	19	as	as	IN
18637	11485	20	shown	show	VBN
18637	11485	21	by	by	IN
18637	11485	22	a	a	DT
18637	11485	23	case	case	NN
18637	11485	24	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11485	25	in	in	IN
18637	11485	26	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	11485	27	.	.	.
18637	11486	1	Two	two	CD
18637	11486	2	surviving	survive	VBG
18637	11486	3	trustees	trustee	NNS
18637	11486	4	had	have	VBD
18637	11486	5	filed	file	VBN
18637	11486	6	an	an	DT
18637	11486	7	account	account	NN
18637	11486	8	for	for	IN
18637	11486	9	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11486	10	and	and	CC
18637	11486	11	a	a	DT
18637	11486	12	deceased	deceased	JJ
18637	11486	13	trustee	trustee	NN
18637	11486	14	in	in	IN
18637	11486	15	a	a	DT
18637	11486	16	court	court	NN
18637	11486	17	of	of	IN
18637	11486	18	common	common	JJ
18637	11486	19	pleas	plea	NNS
18637	11486	20	.	.	.
18637	11487	1	Thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	11487	2	,	,	,
18637	11487	3	two	two	CD
18637	11487	4	of	of	IN
18637	11487	5	the	the	DT
18637	11487	6	five	five	CD
18637	11487	7	beneficiaries	beneficiary	NNS
18637	11487	8	sued	sue	VBD
18637	11487	9	the	the	DT
18637	11487	10	two	two	CD
18637	11487	11	trustees	trustee	NNS
18637	11487	12	and	and	CC
18637	11487	13	the	the	DT
18637	11487	14	deceased	deceased	JJ
18637	11487	15	trustee	trustee	NN
18637	11487	16	in	in	IN
18637	11487	17	a	a	DT
18637	11487	18	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11487	19	district	district	NN
18637	11487	20	court	court	NN
18637	11487	21	,	,	,
18637	11487	22	charging	charge	VBG
18637	11487	23	mismanagement	mismanagement	NN
18637	11487	24	and	and	CC
18637	11487	25	praying	pray	VBG
18637	11487	26	for	for	IN
18637	11487	27	an	an	DT
18637	11487	28	accounting	accounting	NN
18637	11487	29	and	and	CC
18637	11487	30	restitution	restitution	NN
18637	11487	31	and	and	CC
18637	11487	32	removal	removal	NN
18637	11487	33	of	of	IN
18637	11487	34	the	the	DT
18637	11487	35	trustees	trustee	NNS
18637	11487	36	.	.	.
18637	11488	1	The	the	DT
18637	11488	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11488	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11488	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	11488	5	that	that	IN
18637	11488	6	the	the	DT
18637	11488	7	State	State	NNP
18637	11488	8	court	court	NN
18637	11488	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	11488	10	the	the	DT
18637	11488	11	filing	filing	NN
18637	11488	12	of	of	IN
18637	11488	13	the	the	DT
18637	11488	14	account	account	NN
18637	11488	15	acquired	acquire	VBD
18637	11488	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11488	17	over	over	IN
18637	11488	18	the	the	DT
18637	11488	19	trust	trust	NN
18637	11488	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11488	21	quasi	quasi	NNP
18637	11488	22	in	in	IN
18637	11488	23	rem	rem	NN
18637	11488	24	_	_	NNP
18637	11488	25	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	11488	26	and	and	CC
18637	11488	27	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11488	28	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	11488	29	the	the	DT
18637	11488	30	State	State	NNP
18637	11488	31	court	court	NN
18637	11488	32	's	's	POS
18637	11488	33	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	11488	34	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	11488	35	the	the	DT
18637	11488	36	parties	party	NNS
18637	11488	37	from	from	IN
18637	11488	38	further	further	RB
18637	11488	39	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	11488	40	in	in	IN
18637	11488	41	the	the	DT
18637	11488	42	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11488	43	court	court	NN
18637	11488	44	while	while	IN
18637	11488	45	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
18637	11488	46	holding	hold	VBG
18637	11488	47	that	that	IN
18637	11488	48	the	the	DT
18637	11488	49	district	district	NN
18637	11488	50	court	court	NN
18637	11488	51	could	could	MD
18637	11488	52	not	not	RB
18637	11488	53	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	11488	54	the	the	DT
18637	11488	55	parties	party	NNS
18637	11488	56	from	from	IN
18637	11488	57	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	11488	58	in	in	IN
18637	11488	59	the	the	DT
18637	11488	60	State	State	NNP
18637	11488	61	court	court	NN
18637	11488	62	.	.	.
18637	11489	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11489	2	658	658	CD
18637	11489	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11489	4	The	the	DT
18637	11489	5	power	power	NN
18637	11489	6	of	of	IN
18637	11489	7	a	a	DT
18637	11489	8	State	State	NNP
18637	11489	9	court	court	NN
18637	11489	10	to	to	TO
18637	11489	11	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	11489	12	parties	party	NNS
18637	11489	13	from	from	IN
18637	11489	14	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	11489	15	in	in	IN
18637	11489	16	a	a	DT
18637	11489	17	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11489	18	court	court	NN
18637	11489	19	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	11489	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	11489	21	not	not	RB
18637	11489	22	include	include	VB
18637	11489	23	that	that	DT
18637	11489	24	of	of	IN
18637	11489	25	enjoining	enjoin	VBG
18637	11489	26	a	a	DT
18637	11489	27	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11489	28	court	court	NN
18637	11489	29	.	.	.
18637	11490	1	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	11490	2	INTERFERENCE	interference	NN
18637	11490	3	BY	by	IN
18637	11490	4	INJUNCTION	injunction	NN
18637	11490	5	WITH	with	IN
18637	11490	6	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	11490	7	JURISDICTION	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11490	8	The	the	DT
18637	11490	9	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	11490	10	of	of	IN
18637	11490	11	the	the	DT
18637	11490	12	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11490	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	11490	14	to	to	TO
18637	11490	15	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	11490	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11490	17	in	in	IN
18637	11490	18	State	State	NNP
18637	11490	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	11490	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	11490	21	not	not	RB
18637	11490	22	been	be	VBN
18637	11490	23	left	leave	VBN
18637	11490	24	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	11490	25	to	to	IN
18637	11490	26	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	11490	27	of	of	IN
18637	11490	28	comity	comity	NN
18637	11490	29	,	,	,
18637	11490	30	for	for	IN
18637	11490	31	since	since	IN
18637	11490	32	1793	1793	CD
18637	11490	33	the	the	DT
18637	11490	34	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11490	35	courts	court	NNS
18637	11490	36	have	have	VBP
18637	11490	37	been	be	VBN
18637	11490	38	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	11490	39	by	by	IN
18637	11490	40	statute	statute	NN
18637	11490	41	from	from	IN
18637	11490	42	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	11490	43	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11490	44	in	in	IN
18637	11490	45	State	State	NNP
18637	11490	46	courts	court	NNS
18637	11490	47	.	.	.
18637	11491	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11491	2	659	659	CD
18637	11491	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11491	4	Initially	initially	RB
18637	11491	5	this	this	DT
18637	11491	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	11491	7	was	be	VBD
18637	11491	8	applied	apply	VBN
18637	11491	9	with	with	IN
18637	11491	10	strict	strict	JJ
18637	11491	11	literalness	literalness	NN
18637	11491	12	in	in	IN
18637	11491	13	condemning	condemn	VBG
18637	11491	14	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	11491	15	by	by	IN
18637	11491	16	the	the	DT
18637	11491	17	lower	low	JJR
18637	11491	18	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11491	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	11491	20	to	to	TO
18637	11491	21	enter	enter	VB
18637	11491	22	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	11491	23	to	to	IN
18637	11491	24	it,[660	it,[660	NN
18637	11491	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11491	26	but	but	CC
18637	11491	27	gradually	gradually	RB
18637	11491	28	the	the	DT
18637	11491	29	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11491	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11491	31	began	begin	VBD
18637	11491	32	to	to	TO
18637	11491	33	interpret	interpret	VB
18637	11491	34	the	the	DT
18637	11491	35	provision	provision	NN
18637	11491	36	as	as	IN
18637	11491	37	not	not	RB
18637	11491	38	prohibitive	prohibitive	JJ
18637	11491	39	of	of	IN
18637	11491	40	all	all	DT
18637	11491	41	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	11491	42	.	.	.
18637	11492	1	First	first	RB
18637	11492	2	,	,	,
18637	11492	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11492	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	11492	5	been	be	VBN
18637	11492	6	held	hold	VBN
18637	11492	7	that	that	IN
18637	11492	8	an	an	DT
18637	11492	9	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	11492	10	will	will	MD
18637	11492	11	lie	lie	VB
18637	11492	12	against	against	IN
18637	11492	13	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11492	14	in	in	IN
18637	11492	15	a	a	DT
18637	11492	16	State	State	NNP
18637	11492	17	court	court	NN
18637	11492	18	to	to	TO
18637	11492	19	protect	protect	VB
18637	11492	20	the	the	DT
18637	11492	21	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	11492	22	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	11492	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11492	24	of	of	IN
18637	11492	25	a	a	DT
18637	11492	26	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11492	27	court	court	NN
18637	11492	28	against	against	IN
18637	11492	29	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	11492	30	or	or	CC
18637	11492	31	defeat	defeat	NN
18637	11492	32	.	.	.
18637	11493	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11493	2	661	661	CD
18637	11493	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11493	4	This	this	DT
18637	11493	5	exception	exception	NN
18637	11493	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	11493	7	notably	notably	RB
18637	11493	8	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	11493	9	to	to	IN
18637	11493	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	11493	11	where	where	WRB
18637	11493	12	the	the	DT
18637	11493	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11493	14	court	court	NN
18637	11493	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	11493	16	taken	take	VBN
18637	11493	17	possession	possession	NN
18637	11493	18	of	of	IN
18637	11493	19	property	property	NN
18637	11493	20	which	which	WDT
18637	11493	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11493	22	may	may	MD
18637	11493	23	protect	protect	VB
18637	11493	24	by	by	IN
18637	11493	25	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	11493	26	from	from	IN
18637	11493	27	interference	interference	NN
18637	11493	28	by	by	IN
18637	11493	29	State	State	NNP
18637	11493	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	11493	31	.	.	.
18637	11494	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11494	2	662	662	CD
18637	11494	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11494	4	Second	second	RB
18637	11494	5	,	,	,
18637	11494	6	in	in	IN
18637	11494	7	order	order	NN
18637	11494	8	to	to	TO
18637	11494	9	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	11494	10	irreparable	irreparable	JJ
18637	11494	11	damages	damage	NNS
18637	11494	12	to	to	IN
18637	11494	13	persons	person	NNS
18637	11494	14	and	and	CC
18637	11494	15	property	property	VB
18637	11494	16	the	the	DT
18637	11494	17	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11494	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	11494	19	may	may	MD
18637	11494	20	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	11494	21	the	the	DT
18637	11494	22	legal	legal	JJ
18637	11494	23	officers	officer	NNS
18637	11494	24	of	of	IN
18637	11494	25	a	a	DT
18637	11494	26	State	State	NNP
18637	11494	27	from	from	IN
18637	11494	28	taking	take	VBG
18637	11494	29	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11494	30	in	in	IN
18637	11494	31	State	State	NNP
18637	11494	32	courts	court	NNS
18637	11494	33	to	to	TO
18637	11494	34	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11494	35	State	State	NNP
18637	11494	36	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	11494	37	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	11494	38	to	to	TO
18637	11494	39	be	be	VB
18637	11494	40	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	11494	41	.	.	.
18637	11495	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11495	2	663	663	CD
18637	11495	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11495	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	11495	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	11495	6	the	the	DT
18637	11495	7	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	11495	8	of	of	IN
18637	11495	9	§	§	NNP
18637	11495	10	265	265	CD
18637	11495	11	of	of	IN
18637	11495	12	the	the	DT
18637	11495	13	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	11495	14	Code	Code	NNP
18637	11495	15	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11495	16	28	28	CD
18637	11495	17	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	11496	1	§	§	NNP
18637	11496	2	2283	2283	CD
18637	11496	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11496	4	prevent	prevent	NN
18637	11496	5	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	11496	6	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	11496	7	the	the	DT
18637	11496	8	execution	execution	NN
18637	11496	9	of	of	IN
18637	11496	10	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	11496	11	in	in	IN
18637	11496	12	State	State	NNP
18637	11496	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	11496	14	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	11496	15	by	by	IN
18637	11496	16	fraud,[664	fraud,[664	NNP
18637	11496	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11496	18	the	the	DT
18637	11496	19	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	11496	20	of	of	IN
18637	11496	21	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11496	22	in	in	IN
18637	11496	23	State	State	NNP
18637	11496	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	11496	25	in	in	IN
18637	11496	26	cases	case	NNS
18637	11496	27	which	which	WDT
18637	11496	28	have	have	VBP
18637	11496	29	been	be	VBN
18637	11496	30	removed	remove	VBN
18637	11496	31	to	to	IN
18637	11496	32	the	the	DT
18637	11496	33	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11496	34	courts,[665	courts,[665	NNP
18637	11496	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11496	36	nor	nor	CC
18637	11496	37	,	,	,
18637	11496	38	until	until	IN
18637	11496	39	lately	lately	RB
18637	11496	40	,	,	,
18637	11496	41	to	to	IN
18637	11496	42	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11496	43	in	in	IN
18637	11496	44	State	State	NNP
18637	11496	45	courts	court	NNS
18637	11496	46	to	to	TO
18637	11496	47	relitigate	relitigate	VB
18637	11496	48	issues	issue	NNS
18637	11496	49	previously	previously	RB
18637	11496	50	adjudicated	adjudicate	VBN
18637	11496	51	and	and	CC
18637	11496	52	finally	finally	RB
18637	11496	53	settled	settle	VBN
18637	11496	54	by	by	IN
18637	11496	55	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	11496	56	of	of	IN
18637	11496	57	a	a	DT
18637	11496	58	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11496	59	court	court	NN
18637	11496	60	.	.	.
18637	11497	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11497	2	666	666	CD
18637	11497	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11497	4	In	in	IN
18637	11497	5	Toucey	Toucey	NNP
18637	11497	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11497	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	11497	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11497	9	New	New	NNP
18637	11497	10	York	York	NNP
18637	11497	11	Life	Life	NNP
18637	11497	12	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	11497	13	Co	Co	NNP
18637	11497	14	.	.	.
18637	11497	15	,[667	,[667	NFP
18637	11497	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11497	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11497	18	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11497	19	,	,	,
18637	11497	20	as	as	IN
18637	11497	21	spokesman	spokesman	NN
18637	11497	22	for	for	IN
18637	11497	23	the	the	DT
18637	11497	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11497	25	,	,	,
18637	11497	26	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	11497	27	earlier	early	JJR
18637	11497	28	cases	case	NNS
18637	11497	29	and	and	CC
18637	11497	30	in	in	IN
18637	11497	31	effect	effect	NN
18637	11497	32	overruled	overrule	VBD
18637	11497	33	the	the	DT
18637	11497	34	exception	exception	NN
18637	11497	35	of	of	IN
18637	11497	36	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11497	37	designed	design	VBN
18637	11497	38	to	to	TO
18637	11497	39	relitigate	relitigate	VB
18637	11497	40	issues	issue	NNS
18637	11497	41	previously	previously	RB
18637	11497	42	adjudicated	adjudicate	VBN
18637	11497	43	by	by	IN
18637	11497	44	a	a	DT
18637	11497	45	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11497	46	court	court	NN
18637	11497	47	,	,	,
18637	11497	48	and	and	CC
18637	11497	49	held	hold	VBD
18637	11497	50	that	that	IN
18637	11497	51	a	a	DT
18637	11497	52	suit	suit	NN
18637	11497	53	for	for	IN
18637	11497	54	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	11497	55	would	would	MD
18637	11497	56	not	not	RB
18637	11497	57	lie	lie	VB
18637	11497	58	to	to	TO
18637	11497	59	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	11497	60	a	a	DT
18637	11497	61	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	11497	62	in	in	IN
18637	11497	63	a	a	DT
18637	11497	64	State	State	NNP
18637	11497	65	court	court	NN
18637	11497	66	on	on	IN
18637	11497	67	the	the	DT
18637	11497	68	ground	ground	NN
18637	11497	69	that	that	IN
18637	11497	70	the	the	DT
18637	11497	71	claim	claim	NN
18637	11497	72	had	have	VBD
18637	11497	73	been	be	VBN
18637	11497	74	previously	previously	RB
18637	11497	75	adjudicated	adjudicate	VBN
18637	11497	76	.	.	.
18637	11498	1	In	in	IN
18637	11498	2	so	so	RB
18637	11498	3	doing	do	VBG
18637	11498	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11498	5	placed	place	VBD
18637	11498	6	this	this	DT
18637	11498	7	issue	issue	NN
18637	11498	8	in	in	IN
18637	11498	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11498	10	proper	proper	JJ
18637	11498	11	context	context	NN
18637	11498	12	of	of	IN
18637	11498	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11498	14	res	res	NNP
18637	11498	15	judicata	judicata	NNP
18637	11498	16	_	_	NNP
18637	11498	17	.	.	.
18637	11499	1	In	in	IN
18637	11499	2	addition	addition	NN
18637	11499	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11499	4	went	go	VBD
18637	11499	5	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	11499	6	the	the	DT
18637	11499	7	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	11499	8	of	of	IN
18637	11499	9	the	the	DT
18637	11499	10	case	case	NN
18637	11499	11	at	at	IN
18637	11499	12	bar	bar	NN
18637	11499	13	to	to	TO
18637	11499	14	cast	cast	VB
18637	11499	15	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	11499	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	11499	17	the	the	DT
18637	11499	18	exception	exception	NN
18637	11499	19	of	of	IN
18637	11499	20	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11499	21	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11499	22	to	to	TO
18637	11499	23	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	11499	24	the	the	DT
18637	11499	25	execution	execution	NN
18637	11499	26	of	of	IN
18637	11499	27	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	11499	28	of	of	IN
18637	11499	29	State	State	NNP
18637	11499	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	11499	31	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	11499	32	by	by	IN
18637	11499	33	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	11499	34	.	.	.
18637	11500	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	11500	2	,	,	,
18637	11500	3	by	by	IN
18637	11500	4	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	11500	5	the	the	DT
18637	11500	6	exception	exception	NN
18637	11500	7	of	of	IN
18637	11500	8	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11500	9	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	11500	10	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11500	11	in	in	IN
18637	11500	12	State	State	NNP
18637	11500	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	11500	14	in	in	IN
18637	11500	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	11500	16	which	which	WDT
18637	11500	17	had	have	VBD
18637	11500	18	been	be	VBN
18637	11500	19	removed	remove	VBN
18637	11500	20	to	to	IN
18637	11500	21	the	the	DT
18637	11500	22	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11500	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	11500	24	as	as	IN
18637	11500	25	emanating	emanate	VBG
18637	11500	26	from	from	IN
18637	11500	27	the	the	DT
18637	11500	28	removal	removal	NN
18637	11500	29	acts	act	VBZ
18637	11500	30	,	,	,
18637	11500	31	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11500	32	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11500	33	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	11500	34	that	that	IN
18637	11500	35	only	only	RB
18637	11500	36	one	one	CD
18637	11500	37	exception	exception	NN
18637	11500	38	had	have	VBD
18637	11500	39	been	be	VBN
18637	11500	40	made	make	VBN
18637	11500	41	by	by	IN
18637	11500	42	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11500	43	construction	construction	NN
18637	11500	44	to	to	IN
18637	11500	45	§	§	NNP
18637	11500	46	265	265	CD
18637	11500	47	,	,	,
18637	11500	48	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11500	49	28	28	CD
18637	11500	50	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	11501	1	§	§	NNP
18637	11501	2	2283	2283	CD
18637	11501	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11501	4	namely	namely	RB
18637	11501	5	,	,	,
18637	11501	6	that	that	IN
18637	11501	7	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	11501	8	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	11501	9	of	of	IN
18637	11501	10	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11501	11	in	in	IN
18637	11501	12	State	State	NNP
18637	11501	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	11501	14	to	to	TO
18637	11501	15	protect	protect	VB
18637	11501	16	the	the	DT
18637	11501	17	possession	possession	NN
18637	11501	18	of	of	IN
18637	11501	19	property	property	NN
18637	11501	20	previously	previously	RB
18637	11501	21	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	11501	22	.	.	.
18637	11502	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11502	2	668	668	CD
18637	11502	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11502	4	The	the	DT
18637	11502	5	rule	rule	NN
18637	11502	6	of	of	IN
18637	11502	7	this	this	DT
18637	11502	8	case	case	NN
18637	11502	9	was	be	VBD
18637	11502	10	extended	extend	VBN
18637	11502	11	on	on	IN
18637	11502	12	the	the	DT
18637	11502	13	same	same	JJ
18637	11502	14	day	day	NN
18637	11502	15	to	to	TO
18637	11502	16	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	11502	17	an	an	DT
18637	11502	18	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	11502	19	to	to	TO
18637	11502	20	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	11502	21	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11502	22	in	in	IN
18637	11502	23	a	a	DT
18637	11502	24	State	State	NNP
18637	11502	25	court	court	NN
18637	11502	26	in	in	IN
18637	11502	27	support	support	NN
18637	11502	28	of	of	IN
18637	11502	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11502	30	previously	previously	RB
18637	11502	31	begun	begin	VBN
18637	11502	32	earlier	early	RBR
18637	11502	33	and	and	CC
18637	11502	34	still	still	RB
18637	11502	35	pending	pende	VBG
18637	11502	36	in	in	IN
18637	11502	37	the	the	DT
18637	11502	38	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11502	39	court	court	NN
18637	11502	40	.	.	.
18637	11503	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11503	2	669	669	CD
18637	11503	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11503	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11503	5	Injunctions	Injunctions	NNPS
18637	11503	6	of	of	IN
18637	11503	7	State	State	NNP
18637	11503	8	Official	Official	NNP
18637	11503	9	Action	Action	NNP
18637	11503	10	Injunctions	Injunctions	NNPS
18637	11503	11	by	by	IN
18637	11503	12	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11503	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	11503	14	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	11503	15	State	State	NNP
18637	11503	16	officials	official	NNS
18637	11503	17	from	from	IN
18637	11503	18	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	11503	19	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	11503	20	State	State	NNP
18637	11503	21	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	11503	22	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	11503	23	an	an	DT
18637	11503	24	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	11503	25	interference	interference	NN
18637	11503	26	with	with	IN
18637	11503	27	State	State	NNP
18637	11503	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	11503	29	and	and	CC
18637	11503	30	a	a	DT
18637	11503	31	serious	serious	JJ
18637	11503	32	obstruction	obstruction	NN
18637	11503	33	to	to	IN
18637	11503	34	the	the	DT
18637	11503	35	administration	administration	NN
18637	11503	36	of	of	IN
18637	11503	37	public	public	JJ
18637	11503	38	policy	policy	NN
18637	11503	39	.	.	.
18637	11504	1	From	from	IN
18637	11504	2	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	11504	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11504	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	11504	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11504	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	11504	7	of	of	IN
18637	11504	8	the	the	DT
18637	11504	9	United	United	NNP
18637	11504	10	States,[670	States,[670	NNP
18637	11504	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11504	12	which	which	WDT
18637	11504	13	was	be	VBD
18637	11504	14	the	the	DT
18637	11504	15	first	first	JJ
18637	11504	16	case	case	NN
18637	11504	17	in	in	IN
18637	11504	18	which	which	WDT
18637	11504	19	an	an	DT
18637	11504	20	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	11504	21	was	be	VBD
18637	11504	22	used	use	VBN
18637	11504	23	to	to	TO
18637	11504	24	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	11504	25	State	State	NNP
18637	11504	26	action	action	NN
18637	11504	27	under	under	IN
18637	11504	28	an	an	DT
18637	11504	29	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	11504	30	statute	statute	NN
18637	11504	31	,	,	,
18637	11504	32	to	to	IN
18637	11504	33	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11504	34	parte	parte	NN
18637	11504	35	Young[671	Young[671	NNS
18637	11504	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11504	37	the	the	DT
18637	11504	38	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11504	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11504	40	established	establish	VBD
18637	11504	41	firmly	firmly	RB
18637	11504	42	the	the	DT
18637	11504	43	rule	rule	NN
18637	11504	44	that	that	IN
18637	11504	45	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11504	46	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	11504	47	in	in	IN
18637	11504	48	the	the	DT
18637	11504	49	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11504	50	courts	court	NNS
18637	11504	51	to	to	TO
18637	11504	52	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	11504	53	the	the	DT
18637	11504	54	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11504	55	of	of	IN
18637	11504	56	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	11504	57	State	State	NNP
18637	11504	58	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	11504	59	and	and	CC
18637	11504	60	to	to	TO
18637	11504	61	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	11504	62	State	State	NNP
18637	11504	63	officials	official	NNS
18637	11504	64	charged	charge	VBN
18637	11504	65	with	with	IN
18637	11504	66	the	the	DT
18637	11504	67	duty	duty	NN
18637	11504	68	of	of	IN
18637	11504	69	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	11504	70	State	state	NN
18637	11504	71	laws	law	NNS
18637	11504	72	from	from	IN
18637	11504	73	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	11504	74	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	11504	75	or	or	CC
18637	11504	76	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11504	77	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11504	78	to	to	TO
18637	11504	79	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11504	80	an	an	DT
18637	11504	81	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	11504	82	statute	statute	NN
18637	11504	83	.	.	.
18637	11505	1	Until	until	IN
18637	11505	2	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11505	3	parte	parte	NN
18637	11505	4	Young	Young	NNP
18637	11505	5	,	,	,
18637	11505	6	the	the	DT
18637	11505	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11505	8	had	have	VBD
18637	11505	9	been	be	VBN
18637	11505	10	careful	careful	JJ
18637	11505	11	to	to	TO
18637	11505	12	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	11505	13	the	the	DT
18637	11505	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11505	15	of	of	IN
18637	11505	16	the	the	DT
18637	11505	17	lower	low	JJR
18637	11505	18	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11505	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	11505	20	to	to	TO
18637	11505	21	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	11505	22	the	the	DT
18637	11505	23	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11505	24	of	of	IN
18637	11505	25	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	11505	26	State	State	NNP
18637	11505	27	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	11505	28	only	only	RB
18637	11505	29	after	after	IN
18637	11505	30	a	a	DT
18637	11505	31	finding	finding	NN
18637	11505	32	of	of	IN
18637	11505	33	unconstitutionality,[672	unconstitutionality,[672	NN
18637	11505	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11505	35	but	but	CC
18637	11505	36	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11505	37	parte	parte	NN
18637	11505	38	Young	Young	NNP
18637	11505	39	abandoned	abandon	VBD
18637	11505	40	this	this	DT
18637	11505	41	rule	rule	NN
18637	11505	42	by	by	IN
18637	11505	43	holding	hold	VBG
18637	11505	44	that	that	IN
18637	11505	45	the	the	DT
18637	11505	46	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11505	47	of	of	IN
18637	11505	48	a	a	DT
18637	11505	49	State	State	NNP
18637	11505	50	statute	statute	NN
18637	11505	51	by	by	IN
18637	11505	52	the	the	DT
18637	11505	53	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	11505	54	general	general	NN
18637	11505	55	of	of	IN
18637	11505	56	the	the	DT
18637	11505	57	State	State	NNP
18637	11505	58	through	through	IN
18637	11505	59	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11505	60	in	in	IN
18637	11505	61	State	state	NN
18637	11505	62	courts	court	NNS
18637	11505	63	could	could	MD
18637	11505	64	be	be	VB
18637	11505	65	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	11505	66	pending	pende	VBG
18637	11505	67	the	the	DT
18637	11505	68	determination	determination	NN
18637	11505	69	of	of	IN
18637	11505	70	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11505	71	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	11505	72	.	.	.
18637	11506	1	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11506	2	Parte	Parte	NNP
18637	11506	3	Young	Young	NNP
18637	11506	4	Although	although	IN
18637	11506	5	a	a	DT
18637	11506	6	suit	suit	NN
18637	11506	7	to	to	TO
18637	11506	8	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	11506	9	the	the	DT
18637	11506	10	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	11506	11	general	general	NN
18637	11506	12	of	of	IN
18637	11506	13	a	a	DT
18637	11506	14	State	State	NNP
18637	11506	15	from	from	IN
18637	11506	16	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	11506	17	in	in	IN
18637	11506	18	the	the	DT
18637	11506	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	11506	20	of	of	IN
18637	11506	21	the	the	DT
18637	11506	22	State	State	NNP
18637	11506	23	to	to	TO
18637	11506	24	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11506	25	a	a	DT
18637	11506	26	State	State	NNP
18637	11506	27	law	law	NN
18637	11506	28	not	not	RB
18637	11506	29	declared	declare	VBN
18637	11506	30	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	11506	31	would	would	MD
18637	11506	32	seem	seem	VB
18637	11506	33	effectively	effectively	RB
18637	11506	34	to	to	TO
18637	11506	35	stay	stay	VB
18637	11506	36	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11506	37	in	in	IN
18637	11506	38	a	a	DT
18637	11506	39	State	State	NNP
18637	11506	40	court	court	NN
18637	11506	41	,	,	,
18637	11506	42	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11506	43	Peckham	Peckham	NNP
18637	11506	44	drew	draw	VBD
18637	11506	45	a	a	DT
18637	11506	46	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	11506	47	between	between	IN
18637	11506	48	the	the	DT
18637	11506	49	power	power	NN
18637	11506	50	to	to	TO
18637	11506	51	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	11506	52	the	the	DT
18637	11506	53	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	11506	54	general	general	JJ
18637	11506	55	and	and	CC
18637	11506	56	other	other	JJ
18637	11506	57	law	law	NN
18637	11506	58	officers	officer	NNS
18637	11506	59	as	as	IN
18637	11506	60	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	11506	61	and	and	CC
18637	11506	62	a	a	DT
18637	11506	63	suit	suit	NN
18637	11506	64	against	against	IN
18637	11506	65	a	a	DT
18637	11506	66	State	State	NNP
18637	11506	67	court	court	NN
18637	11506	68	on	on	IN
18637	11506	69	the	the	DT
18637	11506	70	ground	ground	NN
18637	11506	71	that	that	IN
18637	11506	72	the	the	DT
18637	11506	73	former	former	JJ
18637	11506	74	does	do	VBZ
18637	11506	75	not	not	RB
18637	11506	76	include	include	VB
18637	11506	77	the	the	DT
18637	11506	78	"	"	``
18637	11506	79	power	power	NN
18637	11506	80	to	to	TO
18637	11506	81	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	11506	82	any	any	DT
18637	11506	83	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	11506	84	or	or	CC
18637	11506	85	action	action	NN
18637	11506	86	by	by	IN
18637	11506	87	a	a	DT
18637	11506	88	grand	grand	JJ
18637	11506	89	jury	jury	NN
18637	11506	90	.	.	.
18637	11507	1	The	the	DT
18637	11507	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	11507	3	body	body	NN
18637	11507	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	11507	5	part	part	NN
18637	11507	6	of	of	IN
18637	11507	7	the	the	DT
18637	11507	8	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	11507	9	of	of	IN
18637	11507	10	a	a	DT
18637	11507	11	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	11507	12	court	court	NN
18637	11507	13	,	,	,
18637	11507	14	and	and	CC
18637	11507	15	an	an	DT
18637	11507	16	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	11507	17	against	against	IN
18637	11507	18	a	a	DT
18637	11507	19	State	State	NNP
18637	11507	20	court	court	NN
18637	11507	21	would	would	MD
18637	11507	22	be	be	VB
18637	11507	23	a	a	DT
18637	11507	24	violation	violation	NN
18637	11507	25	of	of	IN
18637	11507	26	the	the	DT
18637	11507	27	whole	whole	JJ
18637	11507	28	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	11507	29	of	of	IN
18637	11507	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11507	31	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11507	32	.	.	.
18637	11508	1	"	"	``
18637	11508	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11508	3	673	673	CD
18637	11508	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11508	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11508	6	Harlan	Harlan	NNP
18637	11508	7	,	,	,
18637	11508	8	not	not	RB
18637	11508	9	convinced	convince	VBN
18637	11508	10	by	by	IN
18637	11508	11	this	this	DT
18637	11508	12	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	11508	13	,	,	,
18637	11508	14	characterized	characterize	VBD
18637	11508	15	the	the	DT
18637	11508	16	suit	suit	NN
18637	11508	17	as	as	IN
18637	11508	18	an	an	DT
18637	11508	19	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	11508	20	"	"	``
18637	11508	21	_	_	NNP
18637	11508	22	to	to	TO
18637	11508	23	tie	tie	VB
18637	11508	24	the	the	DT
18637	11508	25	hands	hand	NNS
18637	11508	26	_	_	NNP
18637	11508	27	of	of	IN
18637	11508	28	the	the	DT
18637	11508	29	_	_	NNP
18637	11508	30	State	State	NNP
18637	11508	31	_	_	NNP
18637	11508	32	so	so	IN
18637	11508	33	that	that	IN
18637	11508	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11508	35	could	could	MD
18637	11508	36	not	not	RB
18637	11508	37	in	in	IN
18637	11508	38	any	any	DT
18637	11508	39	manner	manner	NN
18637	11508	40	or	or	CC
18637	11508	41	by	by	IN
18637	11508	42	any	any	DT
18637	11508	43	mode	mode	NN
18637	11508	44	of	of	IN
18637	11508	45	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	11508	46	_	_	NNP
18637	11508	47	in	in	IN
18637	11508	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11508	49	own	own	JJ
18637	11508	50	courts	court	NNS
18637	11508	51	_	_	NNP
18637	11508	52	,	,	,
18637	11508	53	test	test	VB
18637	11508	54	the	the	DT
18637	11508	55	validity	validity	NN
18637	11508	56	of	of	IN
18637	11508	57	the	the	DT
18637	11508	58	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	11508	59	and	and	CC
18637	11508	60	orders	order	NNS
18637	11508	61	in	in	IN
18637	11508	62	question	question	NN
18637	11508	63	.	.	.
18637	11509	1	"	"	``
18637	11509	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11509	3	674	674	CD
18637	11509	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11509	5	Although	although	IN
18637	11509	6	the	the	DT
18637	11509	7	rigor	rigor	NN
18637	11509	8	of	of	IN
18637	11509	9	the	the	DT
18637	11509	10	rule	rule	NN
18637	11509	11	of	of	IN
18637	11509	12	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11509	13	parte	parte	NN
18637	11509	14	Young	Young	NNP
18637	11509	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	11509	16	been	be	VBN
18637	11509	17	mitigated	mitigate	VBN
18637	11509	18	by	by	IN
18637	11509	19	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	11509	20	decisions[675	decisions[675	NNP
18637	11509	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11509	22	and	and	CC
18637	11509	23	the	the	DT
18637	11509	24	mode	mode	NN
18637	11509	25	of	of	IN
18637	11509	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11509	27	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11509	28	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	11509	29	narrowed	narrow	VBN
18637	11509	30	by	by	IN
18637	11509	31	statute	statute	NN
18637	11509	32	,	,	,
18637	11509	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11509	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	11509	35	not	not	RB
18637	11509	36	been	be	VBN
18637	11509	37	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	11509	38	and	and	CC
18637	11509	39	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	11509	40	a	a	DT
18637	11509	41	source	source	NN
18637	11509	42	of	of	IN
18637	11509	43	friction	friction	NN
18637	11509	44	in	in	IN
18637	11509	45	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11509	46	-	-	HYPH
18637	11509	47	state	state	NN
18637	11509	48	relations	relation	NNS
18637	11509	49	.	.	.
18637	11510	1	Simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
18637	11510	2	,	,	,
18637	11510	3	however	however	RB
18637	11510	4	,	,	,
18637	11510	5	§	§	NNP
18637	11510	6	266	266	CD
18637	11510	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11510	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11510	9	see	see	VB
18637	11510	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11510	11	note	note	NN
18637	11510	12	2	2	CD
18637	11510	13	above[Transcriber	above[transcriber	NN
18637	11510	14	's	's	POS
18637	11510	15	Note	note	NN
18637	11510	16	:	:	:
18637	11510	17	Reference	reference	NN
18637	11510	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	11510	19	to	to	TO
18637	11510	20	footnote	footnote	VB
18637	11510	21	674	674	CD
18637	11510	22	of	of	IN
18637	11510	23	Article	Article	NNP
18637	11510	24	III	III	NNP
18637	11510	25	.	.	.
18637	11510	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11510	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11511	1	has	have	VBZ
18637	11511	2	been	be	VBN
18637	11511	3	construed	construe	VBN
18637	11511	4	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	11511	5	as	as	IN
18637	11511	6	designed	design	VBN
18637	11511	7	"	"	''
18637	11511	8	to	to	TO
18637	11511	9	secure	secure	VB
18637	11511	10	the	the	DT
18637	11511	11	public	public	JJ
18637	11511	12	interest	interest	NN
18637	11511	13	in	in	IN
18637	11511	14	'	'	''
18637	11511	15	a	a	DT
18637	11511	16	limited	limited	JJ
18637	11511	17	class	class	NN
18637	11511	18	of	of	IN
18637	11511	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	11511	20	of	of	IN
18637	11511	21	special	special	JJ
18637	11511	22	importance,'"[676	importance,'"[676	NN
18637	11511	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11511	24	and	and	CC
18637	11511	25	not	not	RB
18637	11511	26	"	"	``
18637	11511	27	a	a	DT
18637	11511	28	measure	measure	NN
18637	11511	29	of	of	IN
18637	11511	30	broad	broad	JJ
18637	11511	31	social	social	JJ
18637	11511	32	policy	policy	NN
18637	11511	33	to	to	TO
18637	11511	34	be	be	VB
18637	11511	35	construed	construe	VBN
18637	11511	36	with	with	IN
18637	11511	37	great	great	JJ
18637	11511	38	liberality	liberality	NN
18637	11511	39	,	,	,
18637	11511	40	but	but	CC
18637	11511	41	as	as	IN
18637	11511	42	an	an	DT
18637	11511	43	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	11511	44	technical	technical	NN
18637	11511	45	in	in	IN
18637	11511	46	the	the	DT
18637	11511	47	strict	strict	JJ
18637	11511	48	sense	sense	NN
18637	11511	49	of	of	IN
18637	11511	50	the	the	DT
18637	11511	51	term	term	NN
18637	11511	52	and	and	CC
18637	11511	53	to	to	TO
18637	11511	54	be	be	VB
18637	11511	55	applied	apply	VBN
18637	11511	56	as	as	IN
18637	11511	57	such	such	JJ
18637	11511	58	.	.	.
18637	11512	1	"	"	``
18637	11512	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11512	3	677	677	CD
18637	11512	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11512	5	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	11512	6	INTERFERENCE	INTERFERENCE	NNP
18637	11512	7	BY	by	IN
18637	11512	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11512	9	HABEAS	HABEAS	NNP
18637	11512	10	CORPUS	CORPUS	NNP
18637	11512	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11512	12	PROCEEDINGS	PROCEEDINGS	NNP
18637	11512	13	WITH	with	IN
18637	11512	14	FEDERAL	FEDERAL	NNP
18637	11512	15	JURISDICTION	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11512	16	The	the	DT
18637	11512	17	most	most	RBS
18637	11512	18	spectacular	spectacular	JJ
18637	11512	19	type	type	NN
18637	11512	20	of	of	IN
18637	11512	21	State	State	NNP
18637	11512	22	court	court	NN
18637	11512	23	interference	interference	NN
18637	11512	24	with	with	IN
18637	11512	25	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11512	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	11512	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	11512	28	been	be	VBN
18637	11512	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11512	30	use	use	NN
18637	11512	31	of	of	IN
18637	11512	32	the	the	DT
18637	11512	33	writ	writ	NNP
18637	11512	34	of	of	IN
18637	11512	35	_	_	NNP
18637	11512	36	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11512	37	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11512	38	_	_	NNP
18637	11512	39	to	to	TO
18637	11512	40	release	release	VB
18637	11512	41	persons	person	NNS
18637	11512	42	in	in	IN
18637	11512	43	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11512	44	custody	custody	NN
18637	11512	45	.	.	.
18637	11513	1	Between	between	IN
18637	11513	2	1815	1815	CD
18637	11513	3	and	and	CC
18637	11513	4	1861	1861	CD
18637	11513	5	,	,	,
18637	11513	6	judges	judge	NNS
18637	11513	7	in	in	IN
18637	11513	8	nine	nine	CD
18637	11513	9	State	State	NNP
18637	11513	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	11513	11	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	11513	12	the	the	DT
18637	11513	13	right	right	NN
18637	11513	14	to	to	TO
18637	11513	15	release	release	VB
18637	11513	16	persons	person	NNS
18637	11513	17	in	in	IN
18637	11513	18	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11513	19	custody,[678	custody,[678	NN
18637	11513	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11513	21	and	and	CC
18637	11513	22	the	the	DT
18637	11513	23	issue	issue	NN
18637	11513	24	was	be	VBD
18637	11513	25	not	not	RB
18637	11513	26	finally	finally	RB
18637	11513	27	settled	settle	VBN
18637	11513	28	until	until	IN
18637	11513	29	1859	1859	CD
18637	11513	30	,	,	,
18637	11513	31	when	when	WRB
18637	11513	32	Ableman	Ableman	NNP
18637	11513	33	_	_	NNP
18637	11513	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	11513	35	_	_	NNP
18637	11513	36	Booth[679	Booth[679	NNP
18637	11513	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11513	38	was	be	VBD
18637	11513	39	decided	decide	VBN
18637	11513	40	.	.	.
18637	11514	1	Here	here	RB
18637	11514	2	a	a	DT
18637	11514	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11514	4	of	of	IN
18637	11514	5	the	the	DT
18637	11514	6	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	11514	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11514	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11514	9	first	first	RB
18637	11514	10	released	release	VBD
18637	11514	11	a	a	DT
18637	11514	12	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	11514	13	held	hold	VBN
18637	11514	14	by	by	IN
18637	11514	15	a	a	DT
18637	11514	16	United	United	NNP
18637	11514	17	States	States	NNP
18637	11514	18	commissioner	commissioner	NN
18637	11514	19	on	on	IN
18637	11514	20	charges	charge	NNS
18637	11514	21	of	of	IN
18637	11514	22	violating	violate	VBG
18637	11514	23	the	the	DT
18637	11514	24	fugitive	fugitive	JJ
18637	11514	25	slave	slave	NN
18637	11514	26	law	law	NN
18637	11514	27	.	.	.
18637	11515	1	After	after	IN
18637	11515	2	the	the	DT
18637	11515	3	trial	trial	NN
18637	11515	4	,	,	,
18637	11515	5	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	11515	6	,	,	,
18637	11515	7	and	and	CC
18637	11515	8	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	11515	9	of	of	IN
18637	11515	10	the	the	DT
18637	11515	11	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	11515	12	,	,	,
18637	11515	13	the	the	DT
18637	11515	14	State	State	NNP
18637	11515	15	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	11515	16	court	court	NNP
18637	11515	17	issued	issue	VBD
18637	11515	18	a	a	DT
18637	11515	19	second	second	JJ
18637	11515	20	writ	writ	NN
18637	11515	21	of	of	IN
18637	11515	22	_	_	NNP
18637	11515	23	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11515	24	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11515	25	_	_	NNP
18637	11515	26	and	and	CC
18637	11515	27	after	after	IN
18637	11515	28	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	11515	29	ordered	order	VBD
18637	11515	30	the	the	DT
18637	11515	31	release	release	NN
18637	11515	32	of	of	IN
18637	11515	33	the	the	DT
18637	11515	34	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	11515	35	.	.	.
18637	11516	1	The	the	DT
18637	11516	2	national	national	JJ
18637	11516	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11516	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11516	5	then	then	RB
18637	11516	6	issued	issue	VBD
18637	11516	7	a	a	DT
18637	11516	8	writ	writ	NN
18637	11516	9	of	of	IN
18637	11516	10	error	error	NN
18637	11516	11	to	to	IN
18637	11516	12	the	the	DT
18637	11516	13	State	State	NNP
18637	11516	14	court	court	NN
18637	11516	15	which	which	WDT
18637	11516	16	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	11516	17	to	to	TO
18637	11516	18	make	make	VB
18637	11516	19	a	a	DT
18637	11516	20	return	return	NN
18637	11516	21	.	.	.
18637	11517	1	In	in	IN
18637	11517	2	an	an	DT
18637	11517	3	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11517	4	based	base	VBN
18637	11517	5	in	in	IN
18637	11517	6	part	part	NN
18637	11517	7	on	on	IN
18637	11517	8	national	national	JJ
18637	11517	9	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	11517	10	and	and	CC
18637	11517	11	in	in	IN
18637	11517	12	part	part	NN
18637	11517	13	on	on	IN
18637	11517	14	dual	dual	JJ
18637	11517	15	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	11517	16	,	,	,
18637	11517	17	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11517	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11517	19	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	11517	20	,	,	,
18637	11517	21	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	11517	22	for	for	IN
18637	11517	23	the	the	DT
18637	11517	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11517	25	,	,	,
18637	11517	26	laid	lay	VBD
18637	11517	27	down	down	RP
18637	11517	28	the	the	DT
18637	11517	29	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	11517	30	rule	rule	NN
18637	11517	31	that	that	IN
18637	11517	32	no	no	DT
18637	11517	33	State	State	NNP
18637	11517	34	court	court	NN
18637	11517	35	has	have	VBZ
18637	11517	36	the	the	DT
18637	11517	37	power	power	NN
18637	11517	38	to	to	TO
18637	11517	39	release	release	VB
18637	11517	40	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
18637	11517	41	held	hold	VBN
18637	11517	42	in	in	IN
18637	11517	43	custody	custody	NN
18637	11517	44	under	under	IN
18637	11517	45	the	the	DT
18637	11517	46	authority	authority	NN
18637	11517	47	of	of	IN
18637	11517	48	the	the	DT
18637	11517	49	United	United	NNP
18637	11517	50	States	States	NNP
18637	11517	51	.	.	.
18637	11518	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11518	2	680	680	CD
18637	11518	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11518	4	Notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	11518	5	the	the	DT
18637	11518	6	strong	strong	JJ
18637	11518	7	language	language	NN
18637	11518	8	of	of	IN
18637	11518	9	the	the	DT
18637	11518	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11518	11	in	in	IN
18637	11518	12	Ableman	Ableman	NNP
18637	11518	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11518	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	11518	15	_	_	NNP
18637	11518	16	Booth	Booth	NNP
18637	11518	17	,	,	,
18637	11518	18	the	the	DT
18637	11518	19	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	11518	20	courts	court	VBZ
18637	11518	21	thirteen	thirteen	CD
18637	11518	22	years	year	NNS
18637	11518	23	later	later	RB
18637	11518	24	again	again	RB
18637	11518	25	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	11518	26	the	the	DT
18637	11518	27	power	power	NN
18637	11518	28	to	to	TO
18637	11518	29	release	release	VB
18637	11518	30	persons	person	NNS
18637	11518	31	in	in	IN
18637	11518	32	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11518	33	custody	custody	NN
18637	11518	34	by	by	IN
18637	11518	35	directing	direct	VBG
18637	11518	36	the	the	DT
18637	11518	37	release	release	NN
18637	11518	38	of	of	IN
18637	11518	39	an	an	DT
18637	11518	40	enlisted	enlisted	JJ
18637	11518	41	soldier	soldier	NN
18637	11518	42	in	in	IN
18637	11518	43	the	the	DT
18637	11518	44	custody	custody	NN
18637	11518	45	of	of	IN
18637	11518	46	a	a	DT
18637	11518	47	recruiting	recruit	VBG
18637	11518	48	officer	officer	NN
18637	11518	49	of	of	IN
18637	11518	50	the	the	DT
18637	11518	51	United	United	NNP
18637	11518	52	States	States	NNP
18637	11518	53	Army	Army	NNP
18637	11518	54	.	.	.
18637	11519	1	Once	once	RB
18637	11519	2	again	again	RB
18637	11519	3	the	the	DT
18637	11519	4	Court	court	NN
18637	11519	5	held	hold	VBD
18637	11519	6	that	that	IN
18637	11519	7	a	a	DT
18637	11519	8	State	State	NNP
18637	11519	9	court	court	NN
18637	11519	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	11519	11	no	no	DT
18637	11519	12	authority	authority	NN
18637	11519	13	to	to	TO
18637	11519	14	issue	issue	VB
18637	11519	15	a	a	DT
18637	11519	16	writ	writ	NN
18637	11519	17	of	of	IN
18637	11519	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11519	19	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11519	20	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11519	21	_	_	NNP
18637	11519	22	for	for	IN
18637	11519	23	the	the	DT
18637	11519	24	release	release	NN
18637	11519	25	of	of	IN
18637	11519	26	persons	person	NNS
18637	11519	27	held	hold	VBN
18637	11519	28	under	under	IN
18637	11519	29	the	the	DT
18637	11519	30	authority	authority	NN
18637	11519	31	or	or	CC
18637	11519	32	claim	claim	NN
18637	11519	33	and	and	CC
18637	11519	34	color	color	NN
18637	11519	35	of	of	IN
18637	11519	36	authority	authority	NN
18637	11519	37	of	of	IN
18637	11519	38	the	the	DT
18637	11519	39	United	United	NNP
18637	11519	40	States	States	NNP
18637	11519	41	.	.	.
18637	11520	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11520	2	Field	Field	NNP
18637	11520	3	for	for	IN
18637	11520	4	the	the	DT
18637	11520	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11520	6	went	go	VBD
18637	11520	7	on	on	RP
18637	11520	8	to	to	TO
18637	11520	9	lay	lay	VB
18637	11520	10	down	down	RP
18637	11520	11	the	the	DT
18637	11520	12	generalization	generalization	NN
18637	11520	13	that	that	WDT
18637	11520	14	neither	neither	CC
18637	11520	15	government	government	NN
18637	11520	16	"	"	``
18637	11520	17	can	can	MD
18637	11520	18	intrude	intrude	VB
18637	11520	19	with	with	IN
18637	11520	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11520	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11520	22	process	process	NN
18637	11520	23	into	into	IN
18637	11520	24	the	the	DT
18637	11520	25	domain	domain	NN
18637	11520	26	of	of	IN
18637	11520	27	the	the	DT
18637	11520	28	other	other	JJ
18637	11520	29	,	,	,
18637	11520	30	except	except	IN
18637	11520	31	so	so	RB
18637	11520	32	far	far	RB
18637	11520	33	as	as	IN
18637	11520	34	such	such	JJ
18637	11520	35	intrusion	intrusion	NN
18637	11520	36	may	may	MD
18637	11520	37	be	be	VB
18637	11520	38	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11520	39	on	on	IN
18637	11520	40	the	the	DT
18637	11520	41	part	part	NN
18637	11520	42	of	of	IN
18637	11520	43	the	the	DT
18637	11520	44	National	National	NNP
18637	11520	45	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11520	46	to	to	TO
18637	11520	47	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	11520	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11520	49	rightful	rightful	JJ
18637	11520	50	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	11520	51	in	in	IN
18637	11520	52	cases	case	NNS
18637	11520	53	of	of	IN
18637	11520	54	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	11520	55	of	of	IN
18637	11520	56	authority	authority	NN
18637	11520	57	.	.	.
18637	11521	1	"	"	``
18637	11521	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11521	3	681	681	CD
18637	11521	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11521	5	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	11521	6	INTERFERENCE	interference	NN
18637	11521	7	BY	by	IN
18637	11521	8	REMOVAL	REMOVAL	NNP
18637	11521	9	AND	and	CC
18637	11521	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11521	11	HABEAS	HABEAS	NNP
18637	11521	12	CORPUS	CORPUS	NNP
18637	11521	13	_	_	IN
18637	11521	14	Another	another	DT
18637	11521	15	potential	potential	JJ
18637	11521	16	source	source	NN
18637	11521	17	of	of	IN
18637	11521	18	friction	friction	NN
18637	11521	19	between	between	IN
18637	11521	20	State	State	NNP
18637	11521	21	and	and	CC
18637	11521	22	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11521	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	11521	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	11521	25	the	the	DT
18637	11521	26	use	use	NN
18637	11521	27	of	of	IN
18637	11521	28	the	the	DT
18637	11521	29	writ	writ	NNP
18637	11521	30	of	of	IN
18637	11521	31	_	_	NNP
18637	11521	32	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11521	33	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11521	34	_	_	NNP
18637	11521	35	or	or	CC
18637	11521	36	of	of	IN
18637	11521	37	removal	removal	NN
18637	11521	38	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11521	39	in	in	IN
18637	11521	40	the	the	DT
18637	11521	41	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11521	42	courts	court	NNS
18637	11521	43	to	to	TO
18637	11521	44	release	release	VB
18637	11521	45	persons	person	NNS
18637	11521	46	from	from	IN
18637	11521	47	State	State	NNP
18637	11521	48	custody	custody	NN
18637	11521	49	.	.	.
18637	11522	1	As	as	IN
18637	11522	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	11522	3	already	already	RB
18637	11522	4	been	be	VBN
18637	11522	5	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	11522	6	the	the	DT
18637	11522	7	rule	rule	NN
18637	11522	8	of	of	IN
18637	11522	9	national	national	JJ
18637	11522	10	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	11522	11	deprives	deprive	VBZ
18637	11522	12	the	the	DT
18637	11522	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	11522	14	of	of	IN
18637	11522	15	the	the	DT
18637	11522	16	States	States	NNPS
18637	11522	17	of	of	IN
18637	11522	18	any	any	DT
18637	11522	19	power	power	NN
18637	11522	20	to	to	TO
18637	11522	21	release	release	VB
18637	11522	22	persons	person	NNS
18637	11522	23	held	hold	VBN
18637	11522	24	in	in	IN
18637	11522	25	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11522	26	custody	custody	NN
18637	11522	27	.	.	.
18637	11523	1	Recourse	recourse	JJ
18637	11523	2	to	to	IN
18637	11523	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11523	4	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11523	5	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11523	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11523	7	or	or	CC
18637	11523	8	removal	removal	NN
18637	11523	9	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11523	10	in	in	IN
18637	11523	11	the	the	DT
18637	11523	12	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11523	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	11523	14	to	to	TO
18637	11523	15	release	release	VB
18637	11523	16	persons	person	NNS
18637	11523	17	in	in	IN
18637	11523	18	the	the	DT
18637	11523	19	custody	custody	NN
18637	11523	20	of	of	IN
18637	11523	21	State	State	NNP
18637	11523	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	11523	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	11523	24	governed	govern	VBN
18637	11523	25	by	by	IN
18637	11523	26	statute	statute	NN
18637	11523	27	and	and	CC
18637	11523	28	comity	comity	NN
18637	11523	29	.	.	.
18637	11524	1	The	the	DT
18637	11524	2	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11524	3	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11524	4	of	of	IN
18637	11524	5	1789[682	1789[682	CD
18637	11524	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11524	7	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	11524	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11524	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	11524	10	the	the	DT
18637	11524	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11524	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	11524	13	to	to	TO
18637	11524	14	issue	issue	VB
18637	11524	15	writs	writ	NNS
18637	11524	16	of	of	IN
18637	11524	17	_	_	NNP
18637	11524	18	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11524	19	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11524	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11524	21	to	to	TO
18637	11524	22	release	release	VB
18637	11524	23	persons	person	NNS
18637	11524	24	in	in	IN
18637	11524	25	State	State	NNP
18637	11524	26	custody	custody	NN
18637	11524	27	only	only	RB
18637	11524	28	for	for	IN
18637	11524	29	the	the	DT
18637	11524	30	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	11524	31	of	of	IN
18637	11524	32	having	have	VBG
18637	11524	33	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11524	34	appear	appear	VB
18637	11524	35	as	as	IN
18637	11524	36	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	11524	37	in	in	IN
18637	11524	38	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11524	39	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11524	40	.	.	.
18637	11525	1	The	the	DT
18637	11525	2	same	same	JJ
18637	11525	3	act	act	NN
18637	11525	4	also	also	RB
18637	11525	5	provided	provide	VBD
18637	11525	6	for	for	IN
18637	11525	7	the	the	DT
18637	11525	8	removal	removal	NN
18637	11525	9	before	before	IN
18637	11525	10	trial	trial	NN
18637	11525	11	into	into	IN
18637	11525	12	a	a	DT
18637	11525	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11525	14	court	court	NN
18637	11525	15	of	of	IN
18637	11525	16	civil	civil	JJ
18637	11525	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	11525	18	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11525	19	under	under	IN
18637	11525	20	the	the	DT
18637	11525	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	11525	22	of	of	IN
18637	11525	23	the	the	DT
18637	11525	24	United	United	NNP
18637	11525	25	States	States	NNP
18637	11525	26	.	.	.
18637	11526	1	Both	both	DT
18637	11526	2	branches	branch	NNS
18637	11526	3	of	of	IN
18637	11526	4	this	this	DT
18637	11526	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11526	6	were	be	VBD
18637	11526	7	broadened	broaden	VBN
18637	11526	8	as	as	IN
18637	11526	9	a	a	DT
18637	11526	10	result	result	NN
18637	11526	11	of	of	IN
18637	11526	12	the	the	DT
18637	11526	13	nullification	nullification	NN
18637	11526	14	movement	movement	NN
18637	11526	15	in	in	IN
18637	11526	16	South	South	NNP
18637	11526	17	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	11526	18	so	so	IN
18637	11526	19	as	as	IN
18637	11526	20	to	to	TO
18637	11526	21	make	make	VB
18637	11526	22	either	either	CC
18637	11526	23	removal	removal	NN
18637	11526	24	or	or	CC
18637	11526	25	_	_	NNP
18637	11526	26	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11526	27	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11526	28	_	_	NNP
18637	11526	29	available	available	JJ
18637	11526	30	to	to	IN
18637	11526	31	persons	person	NNS
18637	11526	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	11526	33	in	in	IN
18637	11526	34	State	state	NN
18637	11526	35	custody	custody	NN
18637	11526	36	for	for	IN
18637	11526	37	any	any	DT
18637	11526	38	act	act	NN
18637	11526	39	done	do	VBN
18637	11526	40	or	or	CC
18637	11526	41	omitted	omit	VBN
18637	11526	42	in	in	IN
18637	11526	43	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	11526	44	of	of	IN
18637	11526	45	the	the	DT
18637	11526	46	laws	law	NNS
18637	11526	47	of	of	IN
18637	11526	48	the	the	DT
18637	11526	49	United	United	NNP
18637	11526	50	States	States	NNP
18637	11526	51	.	.	.
18637	11527	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11527	2	683	683	CD
18637	11527	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11527	4	These	these	DT
18637	11527	5	recourses	recourse	NNS
18637	11527	6	were	be	VBD
18637	11527	7	in	in	IN
18637	11527	8	1842	1842	CD
18637	11527	9	made	make	VBN
18637	11527	10	available	available	JJ
18637	11527	11	to	to	IN
18637	11527	12	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	11527	13	restrained	restrain	VBN
18637	11527	14	by	by	IN
18637	11527	15	State	State	NNP
18637	11527	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	11527	17	in	in	IN
18637	11527	18	violation	violation	NN
18637	11527	19	of	of	IN
18637	11527	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11527	21	international	international	JJ
18637	11527	22	rights,[684	rights,[684	NN
18637	11527	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11527	24	and	and	CC
18637	11527	25	in	in	IN
18637	11527	26	1867	1867	CD
18637	11527	27	to	to	IN
18637	11527	28	all	all	DT
18637	11527	29	persons	person	NNS
18637	11527	30	restrained	restrain	VBN
18637	11527	31	in	in	IN
18637	11527	32	violation	violation	NN
18637	11527	33	of	of	IN
18637	11527	34	the	the	DT
18637	11527	35	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11527	36	,	,	,
18637	11527	37	laws	law	NNS
18637	11527	38	,	,	,
18637	11527	39	or	or	CC
18637	11527	40	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	11527	41	of	of	IN
18637	11527	42	the	the	DT
18637	11527	43	United	United	NNP
18637	11527	44	States	States	NNP
18637	11527	45	.	.	.
18637	11528	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11528	2	685	685	CD
18637	11528	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11528	4	In	in	IN
18637	11528	5	substance	substance	NN
18637	11528	6	all	all	PDT
18637	11528	7	these	these	DT
18637	11528	8	acts	act	NNS
18637	11528	9	still	still	RB
18637	11528	10	remain	remain	VB
18637	11528	11	on	on	IN
18637	11528	12	the	the	DT
18637	11528	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	11528	14	book	book	NN
18637	11528	15	.	.	.
18637	11529	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11529	2	686	686	CD
18637	11529	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11529	4	Of	of	IN
18637	11529	5	these	these	DT
18637	11529	6	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	11529	7	the	the	DT
18637	11529	8	most	most	RBS
18637	11529	9	important	important	JJ
18637	11529	10	are	be	VBP
18637	11529	11	those	those	DT
18637	11529	12	governing	govern	VBG
18637	11529	13	the	the	DT
18637	11529	14	release	release	NN
18637	11529	15	of	of	IN
18637	11529	16	persons	person	NNS
18637	11529	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	11529	18	under	under	IN
18637	11529	19	State	State	NNP
18637	11529	20	authority	authority	NN
18637	11529	21	for	for	IN
18637	11529	22	an	an	DT
18637	11529	23	act	act	NN
18637	11529	24	done	do	VBN
18637	11529	25	or	or	CC
18637	11529	26	omitted	omit	VBN
18637	11529	27	under	under	IN
18637	11529	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11529	29	authority	authority	NNP
18637	11529	30	and	and	CC
18637	11529	31	persons	person	NNS
18637	11529	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	11529	33	in	in	IN
18637	11529	34	violation	violation	NN
18637	11529	35	of	of	IN
18637	11529	36	the	the	DT
18637	11529	37	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11529	38	,	,	,
18637	11529	39	laws	law	NNS
18637	11529	40	,	,	,
18637	11529	41	or	or	CC
18637	11529	42	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	11529	43	of	of	IN
18637	11529	44	the	the	DT
18637	11529	45	United	United	NNP
18637	11529	46	States	States	NNP
18637	11529	47	.	.	.
18637	11530	1	In	in	IN
18637	11530	2	the	the	DT
18637	11530	3	leading	leading	JJ
18637	11530	4	case	case	NN
18637	11530	5	of	of	IN
18637	11530	6	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	11530	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11530	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11530	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11530	10	Davis,[687	Davis,[687	NNP
18637	11530	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11530	12	decided	decide	VBD
18637	11530	13	in	in	IN
18637	11530	14	1880	1880	CD
18637	11530	15	,	,	,
18637	11530	16	the	the	DT
18637	11530	17	question	question	NN
18637	11530	18	was	be	VBD
18637	11530	19	faced	face	VBN
18637	11530	20	of	of	IN
18637	11530	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11530	22	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	11530	23	.	.	.
18637	11531	1	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	11531	2	was	be	VBD
18637	11531	3	a	a	DT
18637	11531	4	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11531	5	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	11531	6	officer	officer	NN
18637	11531	7	who	who	WP
18637	11531	8	,	,	,
18637	11531	9	in	in	IN
18637	11531	10	the	the	DT
18637	11531	11	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	11531	12	of	of	IN
18637	11531	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11531	14	duties	duty	NNS
18637	11531	15	,	,	,
18637	11531	16	killed	kill	VBD
18637	11531	17	a	a	DT
18637	11531	18	man	man	NN
18637	11531	19	,	,	,
18637	11531	20	and	and	CC
18637	11531	21	was	be	VBD
18637	11531	22	arraigned	arraign	VBN
18637	11531	23	by	by	IN
18637	11531	24	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	11531	25	for	for	IN
18637	11531	26	murder	murder	NN
18637	11531	27	.	.	.
18637	11532	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11532	2	thereupon	thereupon	RB
18637	11532	3	applied	apply	VBD
18637	11532	4	for	for	IN
18637	11532	5	removal	removal	NN
18637	11532	6	of	of	IN
18637	11532	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11532	8	case	case	NN
18637	11532	9	to	to	IN
18637	11532	10	a	a	DT
18637	11532	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11532	12	court	court	NN
18637	11532	13	under	under	IN
18637	11532	14	the	the	DT
18637	11532	15	act	act	NN
18637	11532	16	of	of	IN
18637	11532	17	1867	1867	CD
18637	11532	18	.	.	.
18637	11533	1	To	to	IN
18637	11533	2	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	11533	3	's	's	POS
18637	11533	4	evocation	evocation	NN
18637	11533	5	of	of	IN
18637	11533	6	the	the	DT
18637	11533	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	11533	8	of	of	IN
18637	11533	9	State	State	NNP
18637	11533	10	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	11533	11	,	,	,
18637	11533	12	the	the	DT
18637	11533	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11533	14	rejoined	rejoin	VBD
18637	11533	15	with	with	IN
18637	11533	16	a	a	DT
18637	11533	17	ringing	ring	VBG
18637	11533	18	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	11533	19	of	of	IN
18637	11533	20	the	the	DT
18637	11533	21	principle	principle	NN
18637	11533	22	of	of	IN
18637	11533	23	National	National	NNP
18637	11533	24	Supremacy	Supremacy	NNP
18637	11533	25	.	.	.
18637	11534	1	Subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	11534	2	,	,	,
18637	11534	3	the	the	DT
18637	11534	4	same	same	JJ
18637	11534	5	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	11534	6	have	have	VBP
18637	11534	7	been	be	VBN
18637	11534	8	construed	construe	VBN
18637	11534	9	to	to	TO
18637	11534	10	procure	procure	VB
18637	11534	11	the	the	DT
18637	11534	12	release	release	NN
18637	11534	13	of	of	IN
18637	11534	14	a	a	DT
18637	11534	15	deputy	deputy	NN
18637	11534	16	United	United	NNP
18637	11534	17	States	States	NNP
18637	11534	18	marshal	marshal	NN
18637	11534	19	from	from	IN
18637	11534	20	State	State	NNP
18637	11534	21	custody	custody	NN
18637	11534	22	for	for	IN
18637	11534	23	killing	kill	VBG
18637	11534	24	a	a	DT
18637	11534	25	man	man	NN
18637	11534	26	while	while	IN
18637	11534	27	protecting	protect	VBG
18637	11534	28	a	a	DT
18637	11534	29	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11534	30	of	of	IN
18637	11534	31	the	the	DT
18637	11534	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11534	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11534	34	under	under	IN
18637	11534	35	a	a	DT
18637	11534	36	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	11534	37	order	order	NN
18637	11534	38	which	which	WDT
18637	11534	39	was	be	VBD
18637	11534	40	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	11534	41	as	as	IN
18637	11534	42	a	a	DT
18637	11534	43	"	"	``
18637	11534	44	law	law	NN
18637	11534	45	"	"	''
18637	11534	46	of	of	IN
18637	11534	47	the	the	DT
18637	11534	48	United	United	NNP
18637	11534	49	States;[688	states;[688	NN
18637	11534	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11534	51	the	the	DT
18637	11534	52	release	release	NN
18637	11534	53	of	of	IN
18637	11534	54	an	an	DT
18637	11534	55	election	election	NN
18637	11534	56	official	official	NN
18637	11534	57	held	hold	VBN
18637	11534	58	under	under	IN
18637	11534	59	State	State	NNP
18637	11534	60	authority	authority	NN
18637	11534	61	for	for	IN
18637	11534	62	perjury	perjury	NN
18637	11534	63	on	on	IN
18637	11534	64	the	the	DT
18637	11534	65	ground	ground	NN
18637	11534	66	that	that	IN
18637	11534	67	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11534	68	to	to	TO
18637	11534	69	punish	punish	VB
18637	11534	70	a	a	DT
18637	11534	71	false	false	JJ
18637	11534	72	witness	witness	NN
18637	11534	73	belonged	belong	VBN
18637	11534	74	to	to	IN
18637	11534	75	the	the	DT
18637	11534	76	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11534	77	courts	court	NNS
18637	11534	78	in	in	IN
18637	11534	79	this	this	DT
18637	11534	80	instance;[689	instance;[689	NNS
18637	11534	81	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11534	82	and	and	CC
18637	11534	83	the	the	DT
18637	11534	84	release	release	NN
18637	11534	85	of	of	IN
18637	11534	86	a	a	DT
18637	11534	87	collector	collector	NN
18637	11534	88	of	of	IN
18637	11534	89	internal	internal	JJ
18637	11534	90	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	11534	91	held	hold	VBN
18637	11534	92	in	in	IN
18637	11534	93	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	11534	94	for	for	IN
18637	11534	95	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11534	96	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	11534	97	to	to	TO
18637	11534	98	file	file	VB
18637	11534	99	copies	copy	NNS
18637	11534	100	of	of	IN
18637	11534	101	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11534	102	official	official	JJ
18637	11534	103	papers	paper	NNS
18637	11534	104	with	with	IN
18637	11534	105	a	a	DT
18637	11534	106	State	State	NNP
18637	11534	107	court	court	NN
18637	11534	108	.	.	.
18637	11535	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11535	2	690	690	CD
18637	11535	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11535	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	11535	5	,	,	,
18637	11535	6	the	the	DT
18637	11535	7	governor	governor	NN
18637	11535	8	of	of	IN
18637	11535	9	a	a	DT
18637	11535	10	national	national	JJ
18637	11535	11	home	home	NN
18637	11535	12	for	for	IN
18637	11535	13	disabled	disabled	JJ
18637	11535	14	soldiers	soldier	NNS
18637	11535	15	was	be	VBD
18637	11535	16	released	release	VBN
18637	11535	17	from	from	IN
18637	11535	18	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	11535	19	custody	custody	NN
18637	11535	20	for	for	IN
18637	11535	21	serving	serve	VBG
18637	11535	22	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
18637	11535	23	in	in	IN
18637	11535	24	the	the	DT
18637	11535	25	home	home	NN
18637	11535	26	in	in	IN
18637	11535	27	violation	violation	NN
18637	11535	28	of	of	IN
18637	11535	29	an	an	DT
18637	11535	30	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	11535	31	statute	statute	NN
18637	11535	32	.	.	.
18637	11536	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11536	2	691	691	CD
18637	11536	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11536	4	A	a	DT
18637	11536	5	more	more	RBR
18637	11536	6	extreme	extreme	JJ
18637	11536	7	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11536	8	of	of	IN
18637	11536	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11536	10	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11536	11	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11536	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11536	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11536	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	11536	15	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
18637	11536	16	by	by	IN
18637	11536	17	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	11536	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11536	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	11536	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11536	21	Wood[692	Wood[692	NNP
18637	11536	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11536	23	where	where	WRB
18637	11536	24	a	a	DT
18637	11536	25	ticket	ticket	NN
18637	11536	26	agent	agent	NN
18637	11536	27	of	of	IN
18637	11536	28	a	a	DT
18637	11536	29	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	11536	30	held	hold	VBN
18637	11536	31	in	in	IN
18637	11536	32	State	State	NNP
18637	11536	33	custody	custody	NN
18637	11536	34	for	for	IN
18637	11536	35	an	an	DT
18637	11536	36	overcharge	overcharge	NN
18637	11536	37	on	on	IN
18637	11536	38	a	a	DT
18637	11536	39	ticket	ticket	NN
18637	11536	40	was	be	VBD
18637	11536	41	released	release	VBN
18637	11536	42	because	because	IN
18637	11536	43	prior	prior	RB
18637	11536	44	to	to	IN
18637	11536	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11536	46	trial	trial	NN
18637	11536	47	in	in	IN
18637	11536	48	the	the	DT
18637	11536	49	State	State	NNP
18637	11536	50	court	court	NN
18637	11536	51	,	,	,
18637	11536	52	a	a	DT
18637	11536	53	United	United	NNP
18637	11536	54	States	States	NNP
18637	11536	55	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	11536	56	court	court	NN
18637	11536	57	had	have	VBD
18637	11536	58	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	11536	59	the	the	DT
18637	11536	60	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11536	61	of	of	IN
18637	11536	62	the	the	DT
18637	11536	63	statute	statute	NN
18637	11536	64	.	.	.
18637	11537	1	The	the	DT
18637	11537	2	element	element	NN
18637	11537	3	common	common	JJ
18637	11537	4	to	to	IN
18637	11537	5	all	all	DT
18637	11537	6	of	of	IN
18637	11537	7	these	these	DT
18637	11537	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	11537	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	11537	10	the	the	DT
18637	11537	11	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	11537	12	of	of	IN
18637	11537	13	the	the	DT
18637	11537	14	National	National	NNP
18637	11537	15	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11537	16	and	and	CC
18637	11537	17	the	the	DT
18637	11537	18	inability	inability	NN
18637	11537	19	of	of	IN
18637	11537	20	the	the	DT
18637	11537	21	States	States	NNPS
18637	11537	22	through	through	IN
18637	11537	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11537	24	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11537	25	or	or	CC
18637	11537	26	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	11537	27	to	to	TO
18637	11537	28	obstruct	obstruct	VB
18637	11537	29	the	the	DT
18637	11537	30	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11537	31	of	of	IN
18637	11537	32	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11537	33	authority	authority	NN
18637	11537	34	.	.	.
18637	11538	1	The	the	DT
18637	11538	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	11538	3	of	of	IN
18637	11538	4	comity	comity	NN
18637	11538	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	11538	6	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	11538	7	in	in	IN
18637	11538	8	this	this	DT
18637	11538	9	category	category	NN
18637	11538	10	of	of	IN
18637	11538	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	11538	12	.	.	.
18637	11539	1	COMITY	COMITY	NNP
18637	11539	2	AS	as	IN
18637	11539	3	A	a	DT
18637	11539	4	PRINCIPLE	PRINCIPLE	NNP
18637	11539	5	OF	of	IN
18637	11539	6	STATUTORY	STATUTORY	NNP
18637	11539	7	CONSTRUCTION	CONSTRUCTION	NNP
18637	11539	8	On	on	IN
18637	11539	9	the	the	DT
18637	11539	10	other	other	JJ
18637	11539	11	hand	hand	NN
18637	11539	12	,	,	,
18637	11539	13	in	in	IN
18637	11539	14	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11539	15	parte	parte	NNP
18637	11539	16	Royall,[693	royall,[693	CD
18637	11539	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11539	18	decided	decide	VBN
18637	11539	19	in	in	IN
18637	11539	20	1886	1886	CD
18637	11539	21	,	,	,
18637	11539	22	the	the	DT
18637	11539	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11539	24	held	hold	VBD
18637	11539	25	that	that	IN
18637	11539	26	the	the	DT
18637	11539	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11539	28	of	of	IN
18637	11539	29	the	the	DT
18637	11539	30	lower	low	JJR
18637	11539	31	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11539	32	courts	court	NNS
18637	11539	33	in	in	IN
18637	11539	34	the	the	DT
18637	11539	35	above	above	JJ
18637	11539	36	category	category	NN
18637	11539	37	of	of	IN
18637	11539	38	cases	case	NNS
18637	11539	39	involved	involve	VBN
18637	11539	40	no	no	DT
18637	11539	41	duty	duty	NN
18637	11539	42	to	to	TO
18637	11539	43	release	release	VB
18637	11539	44	persons	person	NNS
18637	11539	45	from	from	IN
18637	11539	46	State	state	NN
18637	11539	47	custody	custody	NN
18637	11539	48	but	but	CC
18637	11539	49	only	only	RB
18637	11539	50	a	a	DT
18637	11539	51	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	11539	52	to	to	TO
18637	11539	53	do	do	VB
18637	11539	54	so	so	RB
18637	11539	55	.	.	.
18637	11540	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	11540	2	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	11540	3	,	,	,
18637	11540	4	the	the	DT
18637	11540	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11540	6	declared	declare	VBD
18637	11540	7	,	,	,
18637	11540	8	"	"	``
18637	11540	9	should	should	MD
18637	11540	10	be	be	VB
18637	11540	11	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	11540	12	in	in	IN
18637	11540	13	the	the	DT
18637	11540	14	light	light	NN
18637	11540	15	of	of	IN
18637	11540	16	the	the	DT
18637	11540	17	relations	relation	NNS
18637	11540	18	existing	exist	VBG
18637	11540	19	,	,	,
18637	11540	20	under	under	IN
18637	11540	21	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11540	22	system	system	NN
18637	11540	23	of	of	IN
18637	11540	24	government	government	NN
18637	11540	25	,	,	,
18637	11540	26	between	between	IN
18637	11540	27	the	the	DT
18637	11540	28	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11540	29	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	11540	30	of	of	IN
18637	11540	31	the	the	DT
18637	11540	32	Union	Union	NNP
18637	11540	33	and	and	CC
18637	11540	34	of	of	IN
18637	11540	35	the	the	DT
18637	11540	36	States	States	NNPS
18637	11540	37	,	,	,
18637	11540	38	and	and	CC
18637	11540	39	in	in	IN
18637	11540	40	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	11540	41	of	of	IN
18637	11540	42	the	the	DT
18637	11540	43	fact	fact	NN
18637	11540	44	that	that	IN
18637	11540	45	the	the	DT
18637	11540	46	public	public	JJ
18637	11540	47	good	good	JJ
18637	11540	48	requires	require	VBZ
18637	11540	49	that	that	IN
18637	11540	50	those	those	DT
18637	11540	51	relations	relation	NNS
18637	11540	52	be	be	VB
18637	11540	53	not	not	RB
18637	11540	54	disturbed	disturb	VBN
18637	11540	55	by	by	IN
18637	11540	56	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	11540	57	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	11540	58	between	between	IN
18637	11540	59	the	the	DT
18637	11540	60	courts	court	NNS
18637	11540	61	equally	equally	RB
18637	11540	62	bound	bind	VBN
18637	11540	63	to	to	TO
18637	11540	64	guard	guard	VB
18637	11540	65	and	and	CC
18637	11540	66	protect	protect	VB
18637	11540	67	rights	right	NNS
18637	11540	68	secured	secure	VBN
18637	11540	69	by	by	IN
18637	11540	70	the	the	DT
18637	11540	71	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11540	72	.	.	.
18637	11541	1	"	"	``
18637	11541	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11541	3	694	694	CD
18637	11541	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11541	5	In	in	IN
18637	11541	6	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	11541	7	of	of	IN
18637	11541	8	these	these	DT
18637	11541	9	principles	principle	NNS
18637	11541	10	the	the	DT
18637	11541	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11541	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	11541	13	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	11541	14	formulated	formulate	VBN
18637	11541	15	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11541	16	to	to	IN
18637	11541	17	the	the	DT
18637	11541	18	effect	effect	NN
18637	11541	19	that	that	IN
18637	11541	20	mere	mere	JJ
18637	11541	21	error	error	NN
18637	11541	22	in	in	IN
18637	11541	23	the	the	DT
18637	11541	24	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	11541	25	and	and	CC
18637	11541	26	trial	trial	NN
18637	11541	27	of	of	IN
18637	11541	28	a	a	DT
18637	11541	29	suit	suit	NN
18637	11541	30	can	can	MD
18637	11541	31	not	not	RB
18637	11541	32	confer	confer	VB
18637	11541	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11541	34	upon	upon	IN
18637	11541	35	a	a	DT
18637	11541	36	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11541	37	court	court	NN
18637	11541	38	to	to	TO
18637	11541	39	review	review	VB
18637	11541	40	the	the	DT
18637	11541	41	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11541	42	upon	upon	IN
18637	11541	43	a	a	DT
18637	11541	44	writ	writ	NN
18637	11541	45	of	of	IN
18637	11541	46	_	_	NNP
18637	11541	47	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11541	48	corpus_;[695	corpus_;[695	NNP
18637	11541	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11541	50	that	that	IN
18637	11541	51	the	the	DT
18637	11541	52	writ	writ	NNP
18637	11541	53	of	of	IN
18637	11541	54	_	_	NNP
18637	11541	55	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11541	56	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11541	57	_	_	NNP
18637	11541	58	can	can	MD
18637	11541	59	not	not	RB
18637	11541	60	be	be	VB
18637	11541	61	substituted	substitute	VBN
18637	11541	62	for	for	IN
18637	11541	63	the	the	DT
18637	11541	64	writ	writ	NN
18637	11541	65	of	of	IN
18637	11541	66	error	error	NN
18637	11541	67	,	,	,
18637	11541	68	however	however	RB
18637	11541	69	serious	serious	JJ
18637	11541	70	the	the	DT
18637	11541	71	errors	error	NNS
18637	11541	72	committed	commit	VBN
18637	11541	73	by	by	IN
18637	11541	74	the	the	DT
18637	11541	75	State	State	NNP
18637	11541	76	court;[696	court;[696	NNS
18637	11541	77	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11541	78	that	that	IN
18637	11541	79	except	except	IN
18637	11541	80	in	in	IN
18637	11541	81	extreme	extreme	JJ
18637	11541	82	and	and	CC
18637	11541	83	urgent	urgent	JJ
18637	11541	84	cases	case	NNS
18637	11541	85	the	the	DT
18637	11541	86	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11541	87	courts	court	NNS
18637	11541	88	will	will	MD
18637	11541	89	not	not	RB
18637	11541	90	discharge	discharge	VB
18637	11541	91	a	a	DT
18637	11541	92	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	11541	93	in	in	IN
18637	11541	94	State	State	NNP
18637	11541	95	custody	custody	NN
18637	11541	96	prior	prior	RB
18637	11541	97	to	to	IN
18637	11541	98	final	final	JJ
18637	11541	99	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	11541	100	of	of	IN
18637	11541	101	the	the	DT
18637	11541	102	case	case	NN
18637	11541	103	in	in	IN
18637	11541	104	the	the	DT
18637	11541	105	State	State	NNP
18637	11541	106	courts	court	NNS
18637	11541	107	,	,	,
18637	11541	108	where	where	WRB
18637	11541	109	the	the	DT
18637	11541	110	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	11541	111	must	must	MD
18637	11541	112	first	first	RB
18637	11541	113	exhaust	exhaust	VB
18637	11541	114	all	all	DT
18637	11541	115	State	state	NN
18637	11541	116	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	11541	117	;	;	:
18637	11541	118	and	and	CC
18637	11541	119	even	even	RB
18637	11541	120	after	after	IN
18637	11541	121	the	the	DT
18637	11541	122	State	State	NNP
18637	11541	123	courts	court	NNS
18637	11541	124	have	have	VBP
18637	11541	125	acted	act	VBN
18637	11541	126	,	,	,
18637	11541	127	the	the	DT
18637	11541	128	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11541	129	courts	court	NNS
18637	11541	130	will	will	MD
18637	11541	131	usually	usually	RB
18637	11541	132	leave	leave	VB
18637	11541	133	the	the	DT
18637	11541	134	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	11541	135	to	to	IN
18637	11541	136	the	the	DT
18637	11541	137	usual	usual	JJ
18637	11541	138	and	and	CC
18637	11541	139	orderly	orderly	JJ
18637	11541	140	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	11541	141	of	of	IN
18637	11541	142	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	11541	143	to	to	IN
18637	11541	144	the	the	DT
18637	11541	145	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11541	146	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11541	147	.	.	.
18637	11542	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	11542	2	,	,	,
18637	11542	3	the	the	DT
18637	11542	4	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11542	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11542	6	will	will	MD
18637	11542	7	,	,	,
18637	11542	8	in	in	IN
18637	11542	9	the	the	DT
18637	11542	10	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11542	11	of	of	IN
18637	11542	12	a	a	DT
18637	11542	13	sound	sound	JJ
18637	11542	14	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	11542	15	,	,	,
18637	11542	16	issue	issue	VB
18637	11542	17	a	a	DT
18637	11542	18	writ	writ	NNP
18637	11542	19	of	of	IN
18637	11542	20	mandamus	mandamus	NNP
18637	11542	21	to	to	TO
18637	11542	22	compel	compel	VB
18637	11542	23	a	a	DT
18637	11542	24	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11542	25	court	court	NN
18637	11542	26	to	to	TO
18637	11542	27	remand	remand	NNP
18637	11542	28	to	to	IN
18637	11542	29	a	a	DT
18637	11542	30	State	State	NNP
18637	11542	31	court	court	NN
18637	11542	32	a	a	DT
18637	11542	33	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	11542	34	of	of	IN
18637	11542	35	a	a	DT
18637	11542	36	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11542	37	officer	officer	NN
18637	11542	38	removed	remove	VBN
18637	11542	39	to	to	IN
18637	11542	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11542	41	,	,	,
18637	11542	42	when	when	WRB
18637	11542	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11542	44	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	11542	45	that	that	IN
18637	11542	46	the	the	DT
18637	11542	47	officer	officer	NN
18637	11542	48	in	in	IN
18637	11542	49	question	question	NN
18637	11542	50	,	,	,
18637	11542	51	in	in	IN
18637	11542	52	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	11542	53	removal	removal	NN
18637	11542	54	,	,	,
18637	11542	55	failed	fail	VBD
18637	11542	56	to	to	TO
18637	11542	57	make	make	VB
18637	11542	58	a	a	DT
18637	11542	59	candid	candid	JJ
18637	11542	60	,	,	,
18637	11542	61	specific	specific	JJ
18637	11542	62	,	,	,
18637	11542	63	and	and	CC
18637	11542	64	positive	positive	JJ
18637	11542	65	explanation	explanation	NN
18637	11542	66	of	of	IN
18637	11542	67	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11542	68	relation	relation	NN
18637	11542	69	to	to	IN
18637	11542	70	the	the	DT
18637	11542	71	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	11542	72	giving	give	VBG
18637	11542	73	rise	rise	NN
18637	11542	74	to	to	IN
18637	11542	75	the	the	DT
18637	11542	76	crime	crime	NN
18637	11542	77	for	for	IN
18637	11542	78	which	which	WDT
18637	11542	79	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11542	80	was	be	VBD
18637	11542	81	indicted	indict	VBN
18637	11542	82	.	.	.
18637	11543	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11543	2	697	697	CD
18637	11543	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11543	4	Because	because	IN
18637	11543	5	of	of	IN
18637	11543	6	the	the	DT
18637	11543	7	care	care	NN
18637	11543	8	with	with	IN
18637	11543	9	which	which	WDT
18637	11543	10	the	the	DT
18637	11543	11	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	11543	12	to	to	TO
18637	11543	13	issue	issue	VB
18637	11543	14	writs	writ	NNS
18637	11543	15	of	of	IN
18637	11543	16	_	_	NNP
18637	11543	17	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11543	18	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11543	19	_	_	NNP
18637	11543	20	and	and	CC
18637	11543	21	to	to	TO
18637	11543	22	grant	grant	VB
18637	11543	23	removals	removal	NNS
18637	11543	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	11543	25	been	be	VBN
18637	11543	26	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	11543	27	by	by	IN
18637	11543	28	the	the	DT
18637	11543	29	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11543	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	11543	31	to	to	TO
18637	11543	32	release	release	VB
18637	11543	33	persons	person	NNS
18637	11543	34	from	from	IN
18637	11543	35	State	State	NNP
18637	11543	36	custody	custody	NN
18637	11543	37	there	there	EX
18637	11543	38	has	have	VBZ
18637	11543	39	been	be	VBN
18637	11543	40	a	a	DT
18637	11543	41	minimum	minimum	NN
18637	11543	42	of	of	IN
18637	11543	43	friction	friction	NN
18637	11543	44	in	in	IN
18637	11543	45	this	this	DT
18637	11543	46	area	area	NN
18637	11543	47	of	of	IN
18637	11543	48	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11543	49	-	-	HYPH
18637	11543	50	state	state	NN
18637	11543	51	relations	relation	NNS
18637	11543	52	,	,	,
18637	11543	53	in	in	IN
18637	11543	54	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	11543	55	to	to	IN
18637	11543	56	that	that	DT
18637	11543	57	produced	produce	VBN
18637	11543	58	by	by	IN
18637	11543	59	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11543	60	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	11543	61	use	use	NN
18637	11543	62	of	of	IN
18637	11543	63	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	11543	64	to	to	TO
18637	11543	65	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	11543	66	the	the	DT
18637	11543	67	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11543	68	of	of	IN
18637	11543	69	State	state	NN
18637	11543	70	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	11543	71	.	.	.
18637	11544	1	In	in	IN
18637	11544	2	Wade	Wade	NNP
18637	11544	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11544	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	11544	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11544	6	Mayo,[698	Mayo,[698	NNP
18637	11544	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11544	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11544	9	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	11544	10	cited	cite	VBD
18637	11544	11	the	the	DT
18637	11544	12	statistics	statistic	NNS
18637	11544	13	of	of	IN
18637	11544	14	the	the	DT
18637	11544	15	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	11544	16	Office	Office	NNP
18637	11544	17	of	of	IN
18637	11544	18	the	the	DT
18637	11544	19	United	United	NNP
18637	11544	20	States	States	NNP
18637	11544	21	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	11544	22	which	which	WDT
18637	11544	23	revealed	reveal	VBD
18637	11544	24	that	that	IN
18637	11544	25	during	during	IN
18637	11544	26	the	the	DT
18637	11544	27	fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	11544	28	years	year	NNS
18637	11544	29	of	of	IN
18637	11544	30	1943	1943	CD
18637	11544	31	,	,	,
18637	11544	32	1944	1944	CD
18637	11544	33	,	,	,
18637	11544	34	and	and	CC
18637	11544	35	1945	1945	CD
18637	11544	36	,	,	,
18637	11544	37	there	there	EX
18637	11544	38	was	be	VBD
18637	11544	39	an	an	DT
18637	11544	40	average	average	NN
18637	11544	41	of	of	IN
18637	11544	42	451	451	CD
18637	11544	43	_	_	NNP
18637	11544	44	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11544	45	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11544	46	_	_	NNP
18637	11544	47	petitions	petition	NNS
18637	11544	48	filed	file	VBD
18637	11544	49	each	each	DT
18637	11544	50	year	year	NN
18637	11544	51	in	in	IN
18637	11544	52	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11544	53	district	district	NN
18637	11544	54	courts	court	NNS
18637	11544	55	by	by	IN
18637	11544	56	persons	person	NNS
18637	11544	57	in	in	IN
18637	11544	58	State	State	NNP
18637	11544	59	custody	custody	NN
18637	11544	60	,	,	,
18637	11544	61	and	and	CC
18637	11544	62	that	that	DT
18637	11544	63	of	of	IN
18637	11544	64	these	these	DT
18637	11544	65	petitions	petition	NNS
18637	11544	66	,	,	,
18637	11544	67	an	an	DT
18637	11544	68	average	average	NN
18637	11544	69	of	of	IN
18637	11544	70	only	only	RB
18637	11544	71	six	six	CD
18637	11544	72	per	per	IN
18637	11544	73	year	year	NN
18637	11544	74	resulted	result	VBD
18637	11544	75	in	in	IN
18637	11544	76	a	a	DT
18637	11544	77	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	11544	78	of	of	IN
18637	11544	79	the	the	DT
18637	11544	80	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	11544	81	and	and	CC
18637	11544	82	the	the	DT
18637	11544	83	release	release	NN
18637	11544	84	of	of	IN
18637	11544	85	the	the	DT
18637	11544	86	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	11544	87	.	.	.
18637	11545	1	COMITY	COMITY	NNP
18637	11545	2	AS	as	IN
18637	11545	3	COOPERATION	cooperation	NN
18637	11545	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	11545	5	,	,	,
18637	11545	6	cold	cold	JJ
18637	11545	7	comity	comity	NN
18637	11545	8	may	may	MD
18637	11545	9	become	become	VB
18637	11545	10	on	on	IN
18637	11545	11	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	11545	12	warm	warm	JJ
18637	11545	13	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	11545	14	between	between	IN
18637	11545	15	the	the	DT
18637	11545	16	two	two	CD
18637	11545	17	systems	system	NNS
18637	11545	18	of	of	IN
18637	11545	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	11545	20	.	.	.
18637	11546	1	In	in	IN
18637	11546	2	Ponzi	Ponzi	NNP
18637	11546	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11546	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	11546	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11546	6	Fessenden,[699	Fessenden,[699	NNP
18637	11546	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11546	8	the	the	DT
18637	11546	9	matter	matter	NN
18637	11546	10	at	at	IN
18637	11546	11	issue	issue	NN
18637	11546	12	was	be	VBD
18637	11546	13	the	the	DT
18637	11546	14	authority	authority	NN
18637	11546	15	of	of	IN
18637	11546	16	the	the	DT
18637	11546	17	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	11546	18	General	General	NNP
18637	11546	19	of	of	IN
18637	11546	20	the	the	DT
18637	11546	21	United	United	NNP
18637	11546	22	States	States	NNP
18637	11546	23	to	to	TO
18637	11546	24	consent	consent	VB
18637	11546	25	to	to	IN
18637	11546	26	the	the	DT
18637	11546	27	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	11546	28	on	on	IN
18637	11546	29	a	a	DT
18637	11546	30	writ	writ	NN
18637	11546	31	of	of	IN
18637	11546	32	_	_	NNP
18637	11546	33	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	11546	34	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	11546	35	_	_	NNP
18637	11546	36	of	of	IN
18637	11546	37	a	a	DT
18637	11546	38	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11546	39	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	11546	40	to	to	IN
18637	11546	41	a	a	DT
18637	11546	42	State	State	NNP
18637	11546	43	court	court	NN
18637	11546	44	to	to	TO
18637	11546	45	be	be	VB
18637	11546	46	there	there	RB
18637	11546	47	put	put	VBN
18637	11546	48	on	on	IN
18637	11546	49	trial	trial	NN
18637	11546	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	11546	51	indictments	indictment	NNS
18637	11546	52	there	there	RB
18637	11546	53	pending	pende	VBG
18637	11546	54	against	against	IN
18637	11546	55	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11546	56	.	.	.
18637	11547	1	The	the	DT
18637	11547	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11547	3	,	,	,
18637	11547	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	11547	5	by	by	IN
18637	11547	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11547	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11547	8	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	11547	9	,	,	,
18637	11547	10	while	while	IN
18637	11547	11	conceding	concede	VBG
18637	11547	12	that	that	IN
18637	11547	13	there	there	EX
18637	11547	14	was	be	VBD
18637	11547	15	no	no	DT
18637	11547	16	express	express	JJ
18637	11547	17	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	11547	18	authority	authority	NN
18637	11547	19	for	for	IN
18637	11547	20	such	such	JJ
18637	11547	21	action	action	NN
18637	11547	22	,	,	,
18637	11547	23	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	11547	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11547	25	.	.	.
18637	11548	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	11548	2	the	the	DT
18637	11548	3	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11548	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11548	5	:	:	:
18637	11548	6	"	"	``
18637	11548	7	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11548	8	live	live	VBP
18637	11548	9	in	in	IN
18637	11548	10	the	the	DT
18637	11548	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11548	12	of	of	IN
18637	11548	13	two	two	CD
18637	11548	14	sovereignties	sovereignty	NNS
18637	11548	15	,	,	,
18637	11548	16	each	each	DT
18637	11548	17	having	have	VBG
18637	11548	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11548	19	own	own	JJ
18637	11548	20	system	system	NN
18637	11548	21	of	of	IN
18637	11548	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	11548	23	to	to	TO
18637	11548	24	declare	declare	VB
18637	11548	25	and	and	CC
18637	11548	26	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11548	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11548	28	laws	law	NNS
18637	11548	29	in	in	IN
18637	11548	30	common	common	JJ
18637	11548	31	territory	territory	NN
18637	11548	32	.	.	.
18637	11549	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11549	2	would	would	MD
18637	11549	3	be	be	VB
18637	11549	4	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	11549	5	for	for	IN
18637	11549	6	such	such	JJ
18637	11549	7	courts	court	NNS
18637	11549	8	to	to	TO
18637	11549	9	fulfil	fulfil	VB
18637	11549	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11549	11	respective	respective	JJ
18637	11549	12	functions	function	NNS
18637	11549	13	without	without	IN
18637	11549	14	embarrassing	embarrass	VBG
18637	11549	15	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	11549	16	unless	unless	IN
18637	11549	17	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11549	18	were	be	VBD
18637	11549	19	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	11549	20	by	by	IN
18637	11549	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11549	22	to	to	TO
18637	11549	23	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	11549	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11549	25	.	.	.
18637	11550	1	The	the	DT
18637	11550	2	people	people	NNS
18637	11550	3	for	for	IN
18637	11550	4	whose	whose	WP$
18637	11550	5	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	11550	6	these	these	DT
18637	11550	7	two	two	CD
18637	11550	8	systems	system	NNS
18637	11550	9	are	be	VBP
18637	11550	10	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	11550	11	are	be	VBP
18637	11550	12	deeply	deeply	RB
18637	11550	13	interested	interested	JJ
18637	11550	14	that	that	IN
18637	11550	15	each	each	DT
18637	11550	16	system	system	NN
18637	11550	17	shall	shall	MD
18637	11550	18	be	be	VB
18637	11550	19	effective	effective	JJ
18637	11550	20	and	and	CC
18637	11550	21	unhindered	unhindered	JJ
18637	11550	22	in	in	IN
18637	11550	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11550	24	vindication	vindication	NN
18637	11550	25	of	of	IN
18637	11550	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11550	27	laws	law	NNS
18637	11550	28	.	.	.
18637	11551	1	The	the	DT
18637	11551	2	situation	situation	NN
18637	11551	3	requires	require	VBZ
18637	11551	4	,	,	,
18637	11551	5	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11551	6	,	,	,
18637	11551	7	not	not	RB
18637	11551	8	only	only	RB
18637	11551	9	definite	definite	JJ
18637	11551	10	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11551	11	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	11551	12	the	the	DT
18637	11551	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	11551	14	of	of	IN
18637	11551	15	the	the	DT
18637	11551	16	courts	court	NNS
18637	11551	17	in	in	IN
18637	11551	18	cases	case	NNS
18637	11551	19	of	of	IN
18637	11551	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11551	21	over	over	IN
18637	11551	22	the	the	DT
18637	11551	23	same	same	JJ
18637	11551	24	persons	person	NNS
18637	11551	25	and	and	CC
18637	11551	26	things	thing	NNS
18637	11551	27	in	in	IN
18637	11551	28	actual	actual	JJ
18637	11551	29	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	11551	30	,	,	,
18637	11551	31	but	but	CC
18637	11551	32	also	also	RB
18637	11551	33	a	a	DT
18637	11551	34	spirit	spirit	NN
18637	11551	35	of	of	IN
18637	11551	36	reciprocal	reciprocal	JJ
18637	11551	37	comity	comity	NN
18637	11551	38	and	and	CC
18637	11551	39	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	11551	40	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	11551	41	to	to	TO
18637	11551	42	promote	promote	VB
18637	11551	43	due	due	JJ
18637	11551	44	and	and	CC
18637	11551	45	orderly	orderly	JJ
18637	11551	46	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	11551	47	.	.	.
18637	11552	1	"	"	``
18637	11552	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11552	3	700	700	CD
18637	11552	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11552	5	EARLY	early	NN
18637	11552	6	USE	use	NN
18637	11552	7	OF	of	IN
18637	11552	8	STATE	state	NN
18637	11552	9	COURTS	court	VBN
18637	11552	10	IN	in	IN
18637	11552	11	ENFORCEMENT	enforcement	NN
18637	11552	12	OF	of	IN
18637	11552	13	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	11552	14	LAW	law	NN
18637	11552	15	The	the	DT
18637	11552	16	final	final	JJ
18637	11552	17	phase	phase	NN
18637	11552	18	of	of	IN
18637	11552	19	the	the	DT
18637	11552	20	relation	relation	NN
18637	11552	21	of	of	IN
18637	11552	22	State	state	NN
18637	11552	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	11552	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	11552	25	to	to	TO
18637	11552	26	do	do	VB
18637	11552	27	with	with	IN
18637	11552	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11552	29	administration	administration	NN
18637	11552	30	of	of	IN
18637	11552	31	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11552	32	law	law	NN
18637	11552	33	.	.	.
18637	11553	1	Although	although	IN
18637	11553	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11553	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	11553	4	the	the	DT
18637	11553	5	general	general	JJ
18637	11553	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	11553	7	that	that	IN
18637	11553	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11553	9	can	can	MD
18637	11553	10	not	not	RB
18637	11553	11	vest	vest	VB
18637	11553	12	the	the	DT
18637	11553	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11553	14	power	power	NN
18637	11553	15	of	of	IN
18637	11553	16	the	the	DT
18637	11553	17	United	United	NNP
18637	11553	18	States	States	NNP
18637	11553	19	in	in	IN
18637	11553	20	courts	court	NNS
18637	11553	21	other	other	JJ
18637	11553	22	than	than	IN
18637	11553	23	those	those	DT
18637	11553	24	created	create	VBN
18637	11553	25	in	in	IN
18637	11553	26	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	11553	27	of	of	IN
18637	11553	28	article	article	NN
18637	11553	29	III,[701	iii,[701	LS
18637	11553	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11553	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11553	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	11553	33	from	from	IN
18637	11553	34	the	the	DT
18637	11553	35	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	11553	36	of	of	IN
18637	11553	37	the	the	DT
18637	11553	38	National	National	NNP
18637	11553	39	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11553	40	left	leave	VBD
18637	11553	41	to	to	IN
18637	11553	42	the	the	DT
18637	11553	43	State	State	NNP
18637	11553	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	11553	45	wide	wide	JJ
18637	11553	46	areas	area	NNS
18637	11553	47	of	of	IN
18637	11553	48	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11553	49	which	which	WDT
18637	11553	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11553	51	might	may	MD
18637	11553	52	have	have	VB
18637	11553	53	vested	vest	VBN
18637	11553	54	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	11553	55	in	in	IN
18637	11553	56	the	the	DT
18637	11553	57	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11553	58	courts	court	NNS
18637	11553	59	,	,	,
18637	11553	60	section	section	NN
18637	11553	61	25	25	CD
18637	11553	62	of	of	IN
18637	11553	63	the	the	DT
18637	11553	64	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11553	65	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11553	66	of	of	IN
18637	11553	67	1789	1789	CD
18637	11553	68	offering	offer	VBG
18637	11553	69	the	the	DT
18637	11553	70	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	11553	71	illustration	illustration	NNP
18637	11553	72	.	.	.
18637	11554	1	But	but	CC
18637	11554	2	going	go	VBG
18637	11554	3	far	far	RB
18637	11554	4	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	11554	5	that	that	DT
18637	11554	6	,	,	,
18637	11554	7	in	in	IN
18637	11554	8	the	the	DT
18637	11554	9	latter	latter	JJ
18637	11554	10	years	year	NNS
18637	11554	11	of	of	IN
18637	11554	12	the	the	DT
18637	11554	13	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
18637	11554	14	century	century	NN
18637	11554	15	and	and	CC
18637	11554	16	the	the	DT
18637	11554	17	early	early	JJ
18637	11554	18	part	part	NN
18637	11554	19	of	of	IN
18637	11554	20	the	the	DT
18637	11554	21	nineteenth	nineteenth	NN
18637	11554	22	,	,	,
18637	11554	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11554	24	provided	provide	VBD
18637	11554	25	that	that	IN
18637	11554	26	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11554	27	by	by	IN
18637	11554	28	the	the	DT
18637	11554	29	National	National	NNP
18637	11554	30	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11554	31	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11554	32	for	for	IN
18637	11554	33	fines	fine	NNS
18637	11554	34	,	,	,
18637	11554	35	forfeitures	forfeiture	NNS
18637	11554	36	,	,	,
18637	11554	37	and	and	CC
18637	11554	38	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	11554	39	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	11554	40	by	by	IN
18637	11554	41	the	the	DT
18637	11554	42	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	11554	43	laws	law	NNS
18637	11554	44	might	may	MD
18637	11554	45	be	be	VB
18637	11554	46	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11554	47	in	in	IN
18637	11554	48	State	State	NNP
18637	11554	49	courts	court	NNS
18637	11554	50	of	of	IN
18637	11554	51	competent	competent	JJ
18637	11554	52	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11554	53	as	as	RB
18637	11554	54	well	well	RB
18637	11554	55	as	as	IN
18637	11554	56	in	in	IN
18637	11554	57	the	the	DT
18637	11554	58	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11554	59	courts	court	NNS
18637	11554	60	.	.	.
18637	11555	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11555	2	702	702	CD
18637	11555	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11555	4	The	the	DT
18637	11555	5	Fugitive	Fugitive	NNP
18637	11555	6	Slave	Slave	NNP
18637	11555	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11555	8	of	of	IN
18637	11555	9	1793,[703	1793,[703	NNP
18637	11555	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11555	11	the	the	DT
18637	11555	12	Naturalization	Naturalization	NNP
18637	11555	13	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11555	14	of	of	IN
18637	11555	15	1795,[704	1795,[704	CD
18637	11555	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11555	17	and	and	CC
18637	11555	18	the	the	DT
18637	11555	19	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	11555	20	Enemies	Enemies	NNPS
18637	11555	21	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11555	22	of	of	IN
18637	11555	23	1798,[705	1798,[705	NN
18637	11555	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11555	25	all	all	DT
18637	11555	26	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	11555	27	positive	positive	JJ
18637	11555	28	duties	duty	NNS
18637	11555	29	on	on	IN
18637	11555	30	State	State	NNP
18637	11555	31	courts	court	NNS
18637	11555	32	to	to	TO
18637	11555	33	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11555	34	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11555	35	law	law	NN
18637	11555	36	.	.	.
18637	11556	1	In	in	IN
18637	11556	2	1799	1799	CD
18637	11556	3	the	the	DT
18637	11556	4	State	State	NNP
18637	11556	5	courts	court	NNS
18637	11556	6	were	be	VBD
18637	11556	7	vested	vest	VBN
18637	11556	8	with	with	IN
18637	11556	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11556	10	to	to	TO
18637	11556	11	try	try	VB
18637	11556	12	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	11556	13	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	11556	14	against	against	IN
18637	11556	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11556	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	11556	17	.	.	.
18637	11557	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11557	2	706	706	CD
18637	11557	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11557	4	Extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	11557	5	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	11557	6	was	be	VBD
18637	11557	7	placed	place	VBN
18637	11557	8	on	on	IN
18637	11557	9	State	State	NNP
18637	11557	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	11557	11	for	for	IN
18637	11557	12	the	the	DT
18637	11557	13	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11557	14	of	of	IN
18637	11557	15	the	the	DT
18637	11557	16	Embargo	Embargo	NNP
18637	11557	17	Acts;[707	Acts;[707	NNP
18637	11557	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11557	19	and	and	CC
18637	11557	20	the	the	DT
18637	11557	21	act	act	NN
18637	11557	22	of	of	IN
18637	11557	23	March	March	NNP
18637	11557	24	3	3	CD
18637	11557	25	,	,	,
18637	11557	26	1815,[708	1815,[708	CD
18637	11557	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11557	28	vested	vest	VBN
18637	11557	29	in	in	IN
18637	11557	30	State	state	NN
18637	11557	31	or	or	CC
18637	11557	32	county	county	NN
18637	11557	33	courts	court	NNS
18637	11557	34	within	within	IN
18637	11557	35	or	or	CC
18637	11557	36	directly	directly	RB
18637	11557	37	adjoining	adjoin	VBG
18637	11557	38	a	a	DT
18637	11557	39	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11557	40	tax	tax	NN
18637	11557	41	-	-	HYPH
18637	11557	42	collection	collection	NN
18637	11557	43	district	district	NN
18637	11557	44	cognizant	cognizant	NN
18637	11557	45	"	"	''
18637	11557	46	of	of	IN
18637	11557	47	all	all	DT
18637	11557	48	complaints	complaint	NNS
18637	11557	49	,	,	,
18637	11557	50	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11557	51	and	and	CC
18637	11557	52	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	11557	53	for	for	IN
18637	11557	54	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	11557	55	,	,	,
18637	11557	56	duties	duty	NNS
18637	11557	57	,	,	,
18637	11557	58	fines	fine	NNS
18637	11557	59	,	,	,
18637	11557	60	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	11557	61	,	,	,
18637	11557	62	and	and	CC
18637	11557	63	forfeitures	forfeiture	NNS
18637	11557	64	.	.	.
18637	11557	65	"	"	''
18637	11558	1	Retreat	retreat	NN
18637	11558	2	From	from	IN
18637	11558	3	This	this	DT
18637	11558	4	Practice	practice	NN
18637	11558	5	The	the	DT
18637	11558	6	indifference	indifference	NN
18637	11558	7	,	,	,
18637	11558	8	however	however	RB
18637	11558	9	,	,	,
18637	11558	10	of	of	IN
18637	11558	11	the	the	DT
18637	11558	12	State	State	NNP
18637	11558	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	11558	14	in	in	IN
18637	11558	15	New	New	NNP
18637	11558	16	England	England	NNP
18637	11558	17	to	to	IN
18637	11558	18	the	the	DT
18637	11558	19	Embargo	Embargo	NNP
18637	11558	20	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	11558	21	,	,	,
18637	11558	22	the	the	DT
18637	11558	23	later	later	JJ
18637	11558	24	hostility	hostility	NN
18637	11558	25	of	of	IN
18637	11558	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	11558	27	in	in	IN
18637	11558	28	the	the	DT
18637	11558	29	northern	northern	JJ
18637	11558	30	States	state	NNS
18637	11558	31	to	to	IN
18637	11558	32	the	the	DT
18637	11558	33	Fugitive	Fugitive	NNP
18637	11558	34	Slave	Slave	NNP
18637	11558	35	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11558	36	,	,	,
18637	11558	37	and	and	CC
18637	11558	38	the	the	DT
18637	11558	39	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	11558	40	of	of	IN
18637	11558	41	courts	court	NNS
18637	11558	42	in	in	IN
18637	11558	43	other	other	JJ
18637	11558	44	States	States	NNPS
18637	11558	45	to	to	TO
18637	11558	46	administer	administer	VB
18637	11558	47	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11558	48	law	law	NN
18637	11558	49	on	on	IN
18637	11558	50	the	the	DT
18637	11558	51	general	general	JJ
18637	11558	52	principle	principle	NN
18637	11558	53	that	that	IN
18637	11558	54	the	the	DT
18637	11558	55	courts	court	NNS
18637	11558	56	of	of	IN
18637	11558	57	no	no	DT
18637	11558	58	nation	nation	NN
18637	11558	59	are	be	VBP
18637	11558	60	bound	bind	VBN
18637	11558	61	to	to	TO
18637	11558	62	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11558	63	the	the	DT
18637	11558	64	penal	penal	JJ
18637	11558	65	laws	law	NNS
18637	11558	66	of	of	IN
18637	11558	67	another,[709	another,[709	NNP
18637	11558	68	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11558	69	all	all	DT
18637	11558	70	combined	combine	VBN
18637	11558	71	to	to	TO
18637	11558	72	produce	produce	VB
18637	11558	73	strong	strong	JJ
18637	11558	74	sentiments	sentiment	NNS
18637	11558	75	against	against	IN
18637	11558	76	the	the	DT
18637	11558	77	use	use	NN
18637	11558	78	of	of	IN
18637	11558	79	State	State	NNP
18637	11558	80	courts	court	NNS
18637	11558	81	to	to	TO
18637	11558	82	administer	administer	VB
18637	11558	83	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11558	84	law	law	NN
18637	11558	85	.	.	.
18637	11559	1	These	these	DT
18637	11559	2	sentiments	sentiment	NNS
18637	11559	3	came	come	VBD
18637	11559	4	in	in	IN
18637	11559	5	time	time	NN
18637	11559	6	to	to	TO
18637	11559	7	be	be	VB
18637	11559	8	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	11559	9	in	in	IN
18637	11559	10	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	11559	11	opinions,[710	opinions,[710	NNP
18637	11559	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11559	13	and	and	CC
18637	11559	14	in	in	IN
18637	11559	15	1842	1842	CD
18637	11559	16	in	in	IN
18637	11559	17	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
18637	11559	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11559	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	11559	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11559	21	Pennsylvania[711	Pennsylvania[711	NNP
18637	11559	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11559	23	the	the	DT
18637	11559	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11559	25	definitely	definitely	RB
18637	11559	26	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	11559	27	that	that	IN
18637	11559	28	the	the	DT
18637	11559	29	States	States	NNPS
18637	11559	30	could	could	MD
18637	11559	31	not	not	RB
18637	11559	32	be	be	VB
18637	11559	33	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	11559	34	to	to	TO
18637	11559	35	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11559	36	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11559	37	law	law	NN
18637	11559	38	.	.	.
18637	11560	1	However	however	RB
18637	11560	2	,	,	,
18637	11560	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11560	4	was	be	VBD
18637	11560	5	later	later	RB
18637	11560	6	held	hold	VBN
18637	11560	7	that	that	IN
18637	11560	8	this	this	DT
18637	11560	9	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	11560	10	did	do	VBD
18637	11560	11	not	not	RB
18637	11560	12	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	11560	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11560	14	from	from	IN
18637	11560	15	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	11560	16	State	state	NN
18637	11560	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	11560	18	to	to	TO
18637	11560	19	administer	administer	VB
18637	11560	20	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11560	21	law	law	NN
18637	11560	22	or	or	CC
18637	11560	23	the	the	DT
18637	11560	24	action	action	NN
18637	11560	25	taken	take	VBN
18637	11560	26	by	by	IN
18637	11560	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11560	28	,	,	,
18637	11560	29	if	if	IN
18637	11560	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11560	31	choose	choose	VBP
18637	11560	32	to	to	TO
18637	11560	33	do	do	VB
18637	11560	34	so	so	RB
18637	11560	35	,	,	,
18637	11560	36	from	from	IN
18637	11560	37	being	be	VBG
18637	11560	38	valid	valid	JJ
18637	11560	39	.	.	.
18637	11561	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11561	2	712	712	CD
18637	11561	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11561	4	Resumption	resumption	NN
18637	11561	5	of	of	IN
18637	11561	6	the	the	DT
18637	11561	7	Practice	Practice	NNP
18637	11561	8	Near	near	IN
18637	11561	9	the	the	DT
18637	11561	10	end	end	NN
18637	11561	11	of	of	IN
18637	11561	12	the	the	DT
18637	11561	13	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
18637	11561	14	century	century	NN
18637	11561	15	and	and	CC
18637	11561	16	afterwards	afterwards	RB
18637	11561	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11561	18	resumed	resume	VBD
18637	11561	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11561	20	earlier	early	JJR
18637	11561	21	practice	practice	NN
18637	11561	22	of	of	IN
18637	11561	23	vesting	vest	VBG
18637	11561	24	concurrently	concurrently	RB
18637	11561	25	the	the	DT
18637	11561	26	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11561	27	of	of	IN
18637	11561	28	federally	federally	RB
18637	11561	29	created	create	VBN
18637	11561	30	rights	right	NNS
18637	11561	31	in	in	IN
18637	11561	32	the	the	DT
18637	11561	33	State	State	NNP
18637	11561	34	and	and	CC
18637	11561	35	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11561	36	courts	court	NNS
18637	11561	37	.	.	.
18637	11562	1	The	the	DT
18637	11562	2	administration	administration	NN
18637	11562	3	of	of	IN
18637	11562	4	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	11562	5	lands	land	NNS
18637	11562	6	and	and	CC
18637	11562	7	the	the	DT
18637	11562	8	determination	determination	NN
18637	11562	9	of	of	IN
18637	11562	10	rights	right	NNS
18637	11562	11	to	to	TO
18637	11562	12	inherit	inherit	VB
18637	11562	13	allotted	allot	VBN
18637	11562	14	lands[713	lands[713	.
18637	11562	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11562	16	marked	mark	VBD
18637	11562	17	the	the	DT
18637	11562	18	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	11562	19	of	of	IN
18637	11562	20	the	the	DT
18637	11562	21	restoration	restoration	NN
18637	11562	22	of	of	IN
18637	11562	23	the	the	DT
18637	11562	24	use	use	NN
18637	11562	25	of	of	IN
18637	11562	26	State	State	NNP
18637	11562	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	11562	28	to	to	TO
18637	11562	29	apply	apply	VB
18637	11562	30	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11562	31	law	law	NN
18637	11562	32	,	,	,
18637	11562	33	and	and	CC
18637	11562	34	the	the	DT
18637	11562	35	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11562	36	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	11562	37	'	'	POS
18637	11562	38	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	11562	39	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11562	40	of	of	IN
18637	11562	41	1908[714	1908[714	CD
18637	11562	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11562	43	carried	carry	VBD
18637	11562	44	the	the	DT
18637	11562	45	practice	practice	NN
18637	11562	46	further	far	RBR
18637	11562	47	,	,	,
18637	11562	48	not	not	RB
18637	11562	49	only	only	RB
18637	11562	50	by	by	IN
18637	11562	51	vesting	vest	VBG
18637	11562	52	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	11562	53	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11562	54	in	in	IN
18637	11562	55	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11562	56	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11562	57	under	under	IN
18637	11562	58	the	the	DT
18637	11562	59	act	act	NN
18637	11562	60	,	,	,
18637	11562	61	in	in	IN
18637	11562	62	State	State	NNP
18637	11562	63	courts	court	NNS
18637	11562	64	but	but	CC
18637	11562	65	also	also	RB
18637	11562	66	in	in	IN
18637	11562	67	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	11562	68	the	the	DT
18637	11562	69	removal	removal	NN
18637	11562	70	of	of	IN
18637	11562	71	cases	case	NNS
18637	11562	72	begun	begin	VBN
18637	11562	73	in	in	IN
18637	11562	74	State	State	NNP
18637	11562	75	courts	court	NNS
18637	11562	76	to	to	IN
18637	11562	77	the	the	DT
18637	11562	78	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11562	79	courts	court	NNS
18637	11562	80	.	.	.
18637	11563	1	Soon	soon	RB
18637	11563	2	afterwards	afterwards	RB
18637	11563	3	the	the	DT
18637	11563	4	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	11563	5	courts	court	NNS
18637	11563	6	in	in	IN
18637	11563	7	a	a	DT
18637	11563	8	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	11563	9	case	case	NN
18637	11563	10	applied	apply	VBD
18637	11563	11	the	the	DT
18637	11563	12	State	State	NNP
18637	11563	13	's	's	POS
18637	11563	14	common	common	JJ
18637	11563	15	law	law	NN
18637	11563	16	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11563	17	of	of	IN
18637	11563	18	liability	liability	NN
18637	11563	19	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	11563	20	to	to	IN
18637	11563	21	the	the	DT
18637	11563	22	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11563	23	act	act	NN
18637	11563	24	and	and	CC
18637	11563	25	held	hold	VBD
18637	11563	26	that	that	IN
18637	11563	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11563	28	could	could	MD
18637	11563	29	not	not	RB
18637	11563	30	require	require	VB
18637	11563	31	a	a	DT
18637	11563	32	State	State	NNP
18637	11563	33	court	court	NN
18637	11563	34	to	to	TO
18637	11563	35	grant	grant	VB
18637	11563	36	a	a	DT
18637	11563	37	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	11563	38	which	which	WDT
18637	11563	39	local	local	JJ
18637	11563	40	law	law	NN
18637	11563	41	did	do	VBD
18637	11563	42	not	not	RB
18637	11563	43	permit	permit	VB
18637	11563	44	.	.	.
18637	11564	1	The	the	DT
18637	11564	2	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	11564	3	courts	court	NNS
18637	11564	4	further	further	RB
18637	11564	5	held	hold	VBD
18637	11564	6	that	that	DT
18637	11564	7	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	11564	8	of	of	IN
18637	11564	9	the	the	DT
18637	11564	10	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11564	11	act	act	NN
18637	11564	12	was	be	VBD
18637	11564	13	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	11564	14	to	to	IN
18637	11564	15	the	the	DT
18637	11564	16	public	public	JJ
18637	11564	17	policy	policy	NN
18637	11564	18	of	of	IN
18637	11564	19	the	the	DT
18637	11564	20	State	State	NNP
18637	11564	21	.	.	.
18637	11565	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11565	2	715	715	CD
18637	11565	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11565	4	This	this	DT
18637	11565	5	decision	decision	NN
18637	11565	6	was	be	VBD
18637	11565	7	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	11565	8	in	in	IN
18637	11565	9	the	the	DT
18637	11565	10	Second	Second	NNP
18637	11565	11	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	11565	12	'	'	POS
18637	11565	13	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	11565	14	Cases,[716	cases,[716	NN
18637	11565	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11565	16	where	where	WRB
18637	11565	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11565	18	was	be	VBD
18637	11565	19	held	hold	VBN
18637	11565	20	on	on	IN
18637	11565	21	the	the	DT
18637	11565	22	basis	basis	NN
18637	11565	23	of	of	IN
18637	11565	24	national	national	JJ
18637	11565	25	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	11565	26	that	that	IN
18637	11565	27	rights	right	NNS
18637	11565	28	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11565	29	under	under	IN
18637	11565	30	the	the	DT
18637	11565	31	act	act	NN
18637	11565	32	can	can	MD
18637	11565	33	be	be	VB
18637	11565	34	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	11565	35	"	"	''
18637	11565	36	as	as	IN
18637	11565	37	of	of	IN
18637	11565	38	right	right	NN
18637	11565	39	,	,	,
18637	11565	40	in	in	IN
18637	11565	41	the	the	DT
18637	11565	42	courts	court	NNS
18637	11565	43	of	of	IN
18637	11565	44	the	the	DT
18637	11565	45	States	States	NNPS
18637	11565	46	when	when	WRB
18637	11565	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11565	48	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11565	49	,	,	,
18637	11565	50	as	as	IN
18637	11565	51	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	11565	52	by	by	IN
18637	11565	53	local	local	JJ
18637	11565	54	laws	law	NNS
18637	11565	55	,	,	,
18637	11565	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	11565	57	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	11565	58	to	to	IN
18637	11565	59	the	the	DT
18637	11565	60	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	11565	61	.	.	.
18637	11565	62	"	"	''
18637	11566	1	Subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	11566	2	,	,	,
18637	11566	3	the	the	DT
18637	11566	4	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11566	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11566	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	11566	7	held	hold	VBN
18637	11566	8	that	that	IN
18637	11566	9	the	the	DT
18637	11566	10	rights	right	NNS
18637	11566	11	created	create	VBN
18637	11566	12	under	under	IN
18637	11566	13	this	this	DT
18637	11566	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	11566	15	can	can	MD
18637	11566	16	not	not	RB
18637	11566	17	be	be	VB
18637	11566	18	defeated	defeat	VBN
18637	11566	19	by	by	IN
18637	11566	20	forms	form	NNS
18637	11566	21	of	of	IN
18637	11566	22	local	local	JJ
18637	11566	23	practice	practice	NN
18637	11566	24	and	and	CC
18637	11566	25	that	that	IN
18637	11566	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11566	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	11566	28	the	the	DT
18637	11566	29	duty	duty	NN
18637	11566	30	of	of	IN
18637	11566	31	the	the	DT
18637	11566	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11566	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11566	34	to	to	TO
18637	11566	35	construe	construe	VB
18637	11566	36	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	11566	37	in	in	IN
18637	11566	38	a	a	DT
18637	11566	39	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	11566	40	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	11566	41	a	a	DT
18637	11566	42	right	right	NN
18637	11566	43	under	under	IN
18637	11566	44	the	the	DT
18637	11566	45	liability	liability	NN
18637	11566	46	act	act	NN
18637	11566	47	in	in	IN
18637	11566	48	order	order	NN
18637	11566	49	to	to	TO
18637	11566	50	determine	determine	VB
18637	11566	51	whether	whether	IN
18637	11566	52	a	a	DT
18637	11566	53	State	State	NNP
18637	11566	54	court	court	NN
18637	11566	55	has	have	VBZ
18637	11566	56	denied	deny	VBN
18637	11566	57	a	a	DT
18637	11566	58	right	right	NN
18637	11566	59	of	of	IN
18637	11566	60	trial	trial	NN
18637	11566	61	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	11566	62	by	by	IN
18637	11566	63	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11566	64	.	.	.
18637	11567	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11567	2	717	717	CD
18637	11567	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11567	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	11567	5	OBLIGATION	obligation	NN
18637	11567	6	TO	to	IN
18637	11567	7	ENFORCE	ENFORCE	NNP
18637	11567	8	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	11567	9	LAW	law	NN
18637	11567	10	The	the	DT
18637	11567	11	issue	issue	NN
18637	11567	12	of	of	IN
18637	11567	13	State	state	NN
18637	11567	14	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	11567	15	to	to	TO
18637	11567	16	administer	administer	VB
18637	11567	17	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11567	18	law	law	NN
18637	11567	19	was	be	VBD
18637	11567	20	presented	present	VBN
18637	11567	21	most	most	RBS
18637	11567	22	recently	recently	RB
18637	11567	23	by	by	IN
18637	11567	24	Testa	Testa	NNP
18637	11567	25	_	_	NNP
18637	11567	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	11567	27	_	_	NNP
18637	11567	28	Katt	Katt	NNP
18637	11567	29	.	.	.
18637	11568	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11568	2	718	718	CD
18637	11568	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11568	4	This	this	DT
18637	11568	5	case	case	NN
18637	11568	6	arose	arise	VBD
18637	11568	7	out	out	IN
18637	11568	8	of	of	IN
18637	11568	9	the	the	DT
18637	11568	10	Emergency	Emergency	NNP
18637	11568	11	Price	Price	NNP
18637	11568	12	Control	Control	NNP
18637	11568	13	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11568	14	of	of	IN
18637	11568	15	1942,[719	1942,[719	NNP
18637	11568	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11568	17	which	which	WDT
18637	11568	18	provided	provide	VBD
18637	11568	19	that	that	IN
18637	11568	20	persons	person	NNS
18637	11568	21	who	who	WP
18637	11568	22	had	have	VBD
18637	11568	23	been	be	VBN
18637	11568	24	overcharged	overcharge	VBN
18637	11568	25	in	in	IN
18637	11568	26	violation	violation	NN
18637	11568	27	of	of	IN
18637	11568	28	the	the	DT
18637	11568	29	act	act	NN
18637	11568	30	or	or	CC
18637	11568	31	,	,	,
18637	11568	32	in	in	IN
18637	11568	33	the	the	DT
18637	11568	34	alternative	alternative	NN
18637	11568	35	,	,	,
18637	11568	36	the	the	DT
18637	11568	37	Price	Price	NNP
18637	11568	38	Administrator	Administrator	NNP
18637	11568	39	,	,	,
18637	11568	40	could	could	MD
18637	11568	41	sue	sue	VB
18637	11568	42	for	for	IN
18637	11568	43	treble	treble	JJ
18637	11568	44	damages	damage	NNS
18637	11568	45	in	in	IN
18637	11568	46	any	any	DT
18637	11568	47	court	court	NN
18637	11568	48	of	of	IN
18637	11568	49	competent	competent	JJ
18637	11568	50	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11568	51	.	.	.
18637	11569	1	On	on	IN
18637	11569	2	the	the	DT
18637	11569	3	ground	ground	NN
18637	11569	4	that	that	WDT
18637	11569	5	one	one	CD
18637	11569	6	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	11569	7	can	can	MD
18637	11569	8	not	not	RB
18637	11569	9	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11569	10	the	the	DT
18637	11569	11	penal	penal	JJ
18637	11569	12	laws	law	NNS
18637	11569	13	of	of	IN
18637	11569	14	another	another	DT
18637	11569	15	,	,	,
18637	11569	16	the	the	DT
18637	11569	17	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	11569	18	Island	Island	NNP
18637	11569	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11569	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11569	21	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	11569	22	that	that	IN
18637	11569	23	the	the	DT
18637	11569	24	State	State	NNP
18637	11569	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	11569	26	had	have	VBD
18637	11569	27	no	no	DT
18637	11569	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11569	29	of	of	IN
18637	11569	30	such	such	JJ
18637	11569	31	suits	suit	NNS
18637	11569	32	.	.	.
18637	11570	1	Assuming	assume	VBG
18637	11570	2	for	for	IN
18637	11570	3	the	the	DT
18637	11570	4	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	11570	5	of	of	IN
18637	11570	6	the	the	DT
18637	11570	7	case	case	NN
18637	11570	8	that	that	IN
18637	11570	9	the	the	DT
18637	11570	10	treble	treble	JJ
18637	11570	11	damage	damage	NN
18637	11570	12	provision	provision	NN
18637	11570	13	,	,	,
18637	11570	14	was	be	VBD
18637	11570	15	"	"	``
18637	11570	16	penal	penal	JJ
18637	11570	17	"	"	''
18637	11570	18	in	in	IN
18637	11570	19	nature	nature	NN
18637	11570	20	,	,	,
18637	11570	21	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11570	22	Black	Black	NNP
18637	11570	23	for	for	IN
18637	11570	24	a	a	DT
18637	11570	25	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	11570	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11570	27	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	11570	28	to	to	TO
18637	11570	29	lay	lay	VB
18637	11570	30	to	to	IN
18637	11570	31	rest	rest	NN
18637	11570	32	the	the	DT
18637	11570	33	principle	principle	NN
18637	11570	34	that	that	IN
18637	11570	35	a	a	DT
18637	11570	36	State	State	NNP
18637	11570	37	court	court	NN
18637	11570	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	11570	39	not	not	RB
18637	11570	40	bound	bind	VBN
18637	11570	41	to	to	TO
18637	11570	42	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11570	43	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11570	44	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	11570	45	law	law	NN
18637	11570	46	as	as	IN
18637	11570	47	an	an	DT
18637	11570	48	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	11570	49	flying	flying	NN
18637	11570	50	"	"	''
18637	11570	51	in	in	IN
18637	11570	52	the	the	DT
18637	11570	53	face	face	NN
18637	11570	54	of	of	IN
18637	11570	55	the	the	DT
18637	11570	56	fact	fact	NN
18637	11570	57	that	that	IN
18637	11570	58	the	the	DT
18637	11570	59	States	States	NNPS
18637	11570	60	of	of	IN
18637	11570	61	the	the	DT
18637	11570	62	Union	Union	NNP
18637	11570	63	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	11570	64	a	a	DT
18637	11570	65	nation	nation	NN
18637	11570	66	"	"	''
18637	11570	67	and	and	CC
18637	11570	68	one	one	CD
18637	11570	69	which	which	WDT
18637	11570	70	disregarded	disregard	VBD
18637	11570	71	the	the	DT
18637	11570	72	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	11570	73	clause	clause	NN
18637	11570	74	.	.	.
18637	11571	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11571	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	11571	3	also	also	RB
18637	11571	4	pointed	point	VBD
18637	11571	5	to	to	IN
18637	11571	6	early	early	JJ
18637	11571	7	acts	act	NNS
18637	11571	8	of	of	IN
18637	11571	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11571	10	and	and	CC
18637	11571	11	early	early	JJ
18637	11571	12	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11571	13	of	of	IN
18637	11571	14	the	the	DT
18637	11571	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11571	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11571	17	as	as	IN
18637	11571	18	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	11571	19	the	the	DT
18637	11571	20	rule	rule	NN
18637	11571	21	that	that	IN
18637	11571	22	"	"	``
18637	11571	23	State	state	NN
18637	11571	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	11571	25	do	do	VBP
18637	11571	26	not	not	RB
18637	11571	27	bear	bear	VB
18637	11571	28	the	the	DT
18637	11571	29	same	same	JJ
18637	11571	30	relation	relation	NN
18637	11571	31	to	to	IN
18637	11571	32	the	the	DT
18637	11571	33	United	United	NNP
18637	11571	34	States	States	NNP
18637	11571	35	as	as	IN
18637	11571	36	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11571	37	do	do	VBP
18637	11571	38	to	to	IN
18637	11571	39	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11571	40	countries	country	NNS
18637	11571	41	.	.	.
18637	11572	1	"	"	``
18637	11572	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11572	3	720	720	CD
18637	11572	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11572	5	The	the	DT
18637	11572	6	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
18637	11572	7	case	case	NN
18637	11572	8	,	,	,
18637	11572	9	though	though	IN
18637	11572	10	not	not	RB
18637	11572	11	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	11572	12	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	11572	13	,	,	,
18637	11572	14	was	be	VBD
18637	11572	15	ignored	ignore	VBN
18637	11572	16	save	save	NN
18637	11572	17	for	for	IN
18637	11572	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11572	19	citation	citation	NN
18637	11572	20	in	in	IN
18637	11572	21	a	a	DT
18637	11572	22	footnote	footnote	NN
18637	11572	23	.	.	.
18637	11573	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11573	2	721	721	CD
18637	11573	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11573	4	RIGHT	RIGHT	NNP
18637	11573	5	OF	of	IN
18637	11573	6	FOREIGN	foreign	JJ
18637	11573	7	CORPORATIONS	corporations	NN
18637	11573	8	TO	to	IN
18637	11573	9	RESORT	RESORT	NNS
18637	11573	10	TO	to	IN
18637	11573	11	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	11573	12	COURTS	court	NNS
18637	11573	13	In	in	IN
18637	11573	14	a	a	DT
18637	11573	15	series	series	NN
18637	11573	16	of	of	IN
18637	11573	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	11573	18	the	the	DT
18637	11573	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11573	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	11573	21	been	be	VBN
18637	11573	22	called	call	VBN
18637	11573	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	11573	24	to	to	TO
18637	11573	25	adjudicate	adjudicate	VB
18637	11573	26	between	between	IN
18637	11573	27	the	the	DT
18637	11573	28	power	power	NN
18637	11573	29	of	of	IN
18637	11573	30	a	a	DT
18637	11573	31	State	State	NNP
18637	11573	32	to	to	TO
18637	11573	33	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	11573	34	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11573	35	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	11573	36	from	from	IN
18637	11573	37	doing	do	VBG
18637	11573	38	a	a	DT
18637	11573	39	purely	purely	RB
18637	11573	40	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	11573	41	business	business	NN
18637	11573	42	within	within	IN
18637	11573	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11573	44	borders	border	NNS
18637	11573	45	and	and	CC
18637	11573	46	the	the	DT
18637	11573	47	right	right	NN
18637	11573	48	of	of	IN
18637	11573	49	such	such	JJ
18637	11573	50	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11573	51	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	11573	52	to	to	TO
18637	11573	53	resort	resort	VB
18637	11573	54	to	to	IN
18637	11573	55	the	the	DT
18637	11573	56	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11573	57	courts	court	NNS
18637	11573	58	.	.	.
18637	11574	1	After	after	IN
18637	11574	2	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	11574	3	first	first	RB
18637	11574	4	one	one	CD
18637	11574	5	way	way	NN
18637	11574	6	and	and	CC
18637	11574	7	then	then	RB
18637	11574	8	the	the	DT
18637	11574	9	other	other	JJ
18637	11574	10	,	,	,
18637	11574	11	on	on	IN
18637	11574	12	the	the	DT
18637	11574	13	basis	basis	NN
18637	11574	14	of	of	IN
18637	11574	15	some	some	DT
18637	11574	16	highly	highly	RB
18637	11574	17	refined	refined	JJ
18637	11574	18	distinctions,[722	distinctions,[722	NN
18637	11574	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11574	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11574	21	finally	finally	RB
18637	11574	22	,	,	,
18637	11574	23	in	in	IN
18637	11574	24	1922	1922	CD
18637	11574	25	,	,	,
18637	11574	26	came	come	VBD
18637	11574	27	out	out	RP
18637	11574	28	unqualifiedly	unqualifiedly	RB
18637	11574	29	for	for	IN
18637	11574	30	the	the	DT
18637	11574	31	latter	latter	JJ
18637	11574	32	right	right	NN
18637	11574	33	.	.	.
18637	11575	1	This	this	DT
18637	11575	2	was	be	VBD
18637	11575	3	in	in	IN
18637	11575	4	Terral	Terral	NNP
18637	11575	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11575	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11575	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11575	8	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	11575	9	Construction	Construction	NNP
18637	11575	10	Co	Co	NNP
18637	11575	11	.	.	.
18637	11575	12	,[723	,[723	,
18637	11575	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11575	14	in	in	IN
18637	11575	15	which	which	WDT
18637	11575	16	an	an	DT
18637	11575	17	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	11575	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	11575	19	requiring	require	VBG
18637	11575	20	the	the	DT
18637	11575	21	cancellation	cancellation	NN
18637	11575	22	of	of	IN
18637	11575	23	the	the	DT
18637	11575	24	license	license	NN
18637	11575	25	of	of	IN
18637	11575	26	a	a	DT
18637	11575	27	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11575	28	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11575	29	to	to	TO
18637	11575	30	do	do	VB
18637	11575	31	business	business	NN
18637	11575	32	in	in	IN
18637	11575	33	the	the	DT
18637	11575	34	State	State	NNP
18637	11575	35	,	,	,
18637	11575	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	11575	37	notice	notice	NN
18637	11575	38	that	that	IN
18637	11575	39	such	such	JJ
18637	11575	40	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11575	41	had	have	VBD
18637	11575	42	removed	remove	VBN
18637	11575	43	a	a	DT
18637	11575	44	case	case	NN
18637	11575	45	to	to	IN
18637	11575	46	a	a	DT
18637	11575	47	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11575	48	court	court	NN
18637	11575	49	,	,	,
18637	11575	50	was	be	VBD
18637	11575	51	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
18637	11575	52	void	void	JJ
18637	11575	53	.	.	.
18637	11576	1	At	at	IN
18637	11576	2	the	the	DT
18637	11576	3	same	same	JJ
18637	11576	4	time	time	NN
18637	11576	5	all	all	DT
18637	11576	6	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	11576	7	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11576	8	were	be	VBD
18637	11576	9	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	11576	10	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	11576	11	.	.	.
18637	11577	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	11577	2	3	3	CD
18637	11577	3	.	.	.
18637	11578	1	The	the	DT
18637	11578	2	Trial	trial	NN
18637	11578	3	of	of	IN
18637	11578	4	all	all	DT
18637	11578	5	Crimes	Crimes	NNPS
18637	11578	6	,	,	,
18637	11578	7	except	except	IN
18637	11578	8	in	in	IN
18637	11578	9	Cases	case	NNS
18637	11578	10	of	of	IN
18637	11578	11	Impeachment	Impeachment	NNP
18637	11578	12	,	,	,
18637	11578	13	shall	shall	MD
18637	11578	14	be	be	VB
18637	11578	15	by	by	IN
18637	11578	16	Jury	jury	NN
18637	11578	17	;	;	:
18637	11578	18	and	and	CC
18637	11578	19	such	such	JJ
18637	11578	20	Trial	trial	NN
18637	11578	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	11578	22	be	be	VB
18637	11578	23	held	hold	VBN
18637	11578	24	in	in	IN
18637	11578	25	the	the	DT
18637	11578	26	State	State	NNP
18637	11578	27	where	where	WRB
18637	11578	28	the	the	DT
18637	11578	29	said	say	VBN
18637	11578	30	Crimes	crime	NNS
18637	11578	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	11578	32	have	have	VB
18637	11578	33	been	be	VBN
18637	11578	34	committed	commit	VBN
18637	11578	35	;	;	:
18637	11578	36	but	but	CC
18637	11578	37	when	when	WRB
18637	11578	38	not	not	RB
18637	11578	39	committed	commit	VBN
18637	11578	40	within	within	IN
18637	11578	41	any	any	DT
18637	11578	42	State	State	NNP
18637	11578	43	,	,	,
18637	11578	44	the	the	DT
18637	11578	45	Trial	trial	NN
18637	11578	46	shall	shall	MD
18637	11578	47	be	be	VB
18637	11578	48	at	at	IN
18637	11578	49	such	such	JJ
18637	11578	50	Place	Place	NNP
18637	11578	51	or	or	CC
18637	11578	52	Places	Places	NNPS
18637	11578	53	as	as	IN
18637	11578	54	the	the	DT
18637	11578	55	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11578	56	may	may	MD
18637	11578	57	by	by	IN
18637	11578	58	Law	Law	NNP
18637	11578	59	have	have	VBP
18637	11578	60	directed	direct	VBN
18637	11578	61	.	.	.
18637	11579	1	_	_	NNP
18637	11579	2	See	See	NNP
18637	11579	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11579	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	11579	5	VI	VI	NNP
18637	11579	6	,	,	,
18637	11579	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	11579	8	.	.	.
18637	11580	1	878	878	CD
18637	11580	2	-	-	SYM
18637	11580	3	881	881	CD
18637	11580	4	.	.	.
18637	11581	1	Section	section	NN
18637	11581	2	3	3	CD
18637	11581	3	.	.	.
18637	11582	1	Treason	treason	NN
18637	11582	2	against	against	IN
18637	11582	3	the	the	DT
18637	11582	4	United	United	NNP
18637	11582	5	States	States	NNP
18637	11582	6	,	,	,
18637	11582	7	shall	shall	MD
18637	11582	8	consist	consist	VB
18637	11582	9	only	only	RB
18637	11582	10	in	in	IN
18637	11582	11	levying	levy	VBG
18637	11582	12	War	war	NN
18637	11582	13	against	against	IN
18637	11582	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11582	15	,	,	,
18637	11582	16	or	or	CC
18637	11582	17	in	in	IN
18637	11582	18	adhering	adhere	VBG
18637	11582	19	to	to	IN
18637	11582	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11582	21	Enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	11582	22	,	,	,
18637	11582	23	giving	give	VBG
18637	11582	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11582	25	Aid	Aid	NNP
18637	11582	26	and	and	CC
18637	11582	27	Comfort	Comfort	NNP
18637	11582	28	.	.	.
18637	11583	1	No	no	DT
18637	11583	2	Person	person	NN
18637	11583	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	11583	4	be	be	VB
18637	11583	5	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	11583	6	of	of	IN
18637	11583	7	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	11583	8	unless	unless	IN
18637	11583	9	on	on	IN
18637	11583	10	the	the	DT
18637	11583	11	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	11583	12	of	of	IN
18637	11583	13	two	two	CD
18637	11583	14	Witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	11583	15	to	to	IN
18637	11583	16	the	the	DT
18637	11583	17	same	same	JJ
18637	11583	18	overt	overt	JJ
18637	11583	19	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11583	20	,	,	,
18637	11583	21	or	or	CC
18637	11583	22	on	on	IN
18637	11583	23	Confession	Confession	NNP
18637	11583	24	in	in	IN
18637	11583	25	open	open	JJ
18637	11583	26	Court	court	NN
18637	11583	27	.	.	.
18637	11584	1	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	11584	2	The	the	DT
18637	11584	3	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	11584	4	and	and	CC
18637	11584	5	phraseology	phraseology	NN
18637	11584	6	of	of	IN
18637	11584	7	this	this	DT
18637	11584	8	section	section	NN
18637	11584	9	are	be	VBP
18637	11584	10	derived	derive	VBN
18637	11584	11	from	from	IN
18637	11584	12	the	the	DT
18637	11584	13	English	English	NNP
18637	11584	14	Statute	Statute	NNP
18637	11584	15	of	of	IN
18637	11584	16	Treasons	Treasons	NNPS
18637	11584	17	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	11584	18	in	in	IN
18637	11584	19	1351	1351	CD
18637	11584	20	,	,	,
18637	11584	21	in	in	IN
18637	11584	22	the	the	DT
18637	11584	23	reign	reign	NN
18637	11584	24	of	of	IN
18637	11584	25	Edward	Edward	NNP
18637	11584	26	III,[724	III,[724	NNP
18637	11584	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11584	28	as	as	IN
18637	11584	29	an	an	DT
18637	11584	30	expression	expression	NN
18637	11584	31	of	of	IN
18637	11584	32	grievance	grievance	NN
18637	11584	33	against	against	IN
18637	11584	34	the	the	DT
18637	11584	35	application	application	NN
18637	11584	36	of	of	IN
18637	11584	37	the	the	DT
18637	11584	38	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	11584	39	of	of	IN
18637	11584	40	constructive	constructive	JJ
18637	11584	41	treasons	treason	NNS
18637	11584	42	by	by	IN
18637	11584	43	the	the	DT
18637	11584	44	common	common	JJ
18637	11584	45	law	law	NN
18637	11584	46	courts	court	NNS
18637	11584	47	.	.	.
18637	11585	1	The	the	DT
18637	11585	2	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11585	3	definition	definition	NN
18637	11585	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	11585	5	,	,	,
18637	11585	6	of	of	IN
18637	11585	7	course	course	NN
18637	11585	8	,	,	,
18637	11585	9	much	much	RB
18637	11585	10	more	more	RBR
18637	11585	11	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	11585	12	than	than	IN
18637	11585	13	the	the	DT
18637	11585	14	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	11585	15	of	of	IN
18637	11585	16	treasons	treason	NNS
18637	11585	17	in	in	IN
18637	11585	18	the	the	DT
18637	11585	19	English	english	JJ
18637	11585	20	statute	statute	NN
18637	11585	21	,	,	,
18637	11585	22	but	but	CC
18637	11585	23	like	like	IN
18637	11585	24	that	that	DT
18637	11585	25	statute	statute	NN
18637	11585	26	,	,	,
18637	11585	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11585	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	11585	29	emphatically	emphatically	RB
18637	11585	30	a	a	DT
18637	11585	31	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	11585	32	on	on	IN
18637	11585	33	the	the	DT
18637	11585	34	power	power	NN
18637	11585	35	of	of	IN
18637	11585	36	government	government	NN
18637	11585	37	to	to	TO
18637	11585	38	define	define	VB
18637	11585	39	treason	treason	NN
18637	11585	40	and	and	CC
18637	11585	41	to	to	TO
18637	11585	42	prove	prove	VB
18637	11585	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11585	44	existence	existence	NN
18637	11585	45	.	.	.
18637	11586	1	The	the	DT
18637	11586	2	rigid	rigid	JJ
18637	11586	3	and	and	CC
18637	11586	4	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	11586	5	definition	definition	NN
18637	11586	6	of	of	IN
18637	11586	7	treason	treason	NN
18637	11586	8	takes	take	VBZ
18637	11586	9	from	from	IN
18637	11586	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11586	11	all	all	DT
18637	11586	12	power	power	NN
18637	11586	13	to	to	TO
18637	11586	14	define	define	VB
18637	11586	15	treason	treason	NN
18637	11586	16	and	and	CC
18637	11586	17	prescribes	prescribe	VBZ
18637	11586	18	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	11586	19	on	on	IN
18637	11586	20	the	the	DT
18637	11586	21	power	power	NN
18637	11586	22	to	to	TO
18637	11586	23	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	11586	24	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	11586	25	thereupon	thereupon	RB
18637	11586	26	.	.	.
18637	11587	1	LEVYING	LEVYING	NNP
18637	11587	2	WAR	WAR	NNP
18637	11587	3	Early	early	JJ
18637	11587	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11587	5	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	11587	6	of	of	IN
18637	11587	7	the	the	DT
18637	11587	8	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	11587	9	of	of	IN
18637	11587	10	treason	treason	NN
18637	11587	11	in	in	IN
18637	11587	12	terms	term	NNS
18637	11587	13	of	of	IN
18637	11587	14	levying	levy	VBG
18637	11587	15	war	war	NN
18637	11587	16	was	be	VBD
18637	11587	17	conditioned	condition	VBN
18637	11587	18	by	by	IN
18637	11587	19	the	the	DT
18637	11587	20	partisan	partisan	JJ
18637	11587	21	struggles	struggle	NNS
18637	11587	22	of	of	IN
18637	11587	23	the	the	DT
18637	11587	24	early	early	JJ
18637	11587	25	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
18637	11587	26	century	century	NN
18637	11587	27	,	,	,
18637	11587	28	in	in	IN
18637	11587	29	which	which	WDT
18637	11587	30	were	be	VBD
18637	11587	31	involved	involve	VBN
18637	11587	32	the	the	DT
18637	11587	33	treason	treason	NN
18637	11587	34	trials	trial	NNS
18637	11587	35	of	of	IN
18637	11587	36	Aaron	Aaron	NNP
18637	11587	37	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	11587	38	and	and	CC
18637	11587	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11587	40	associates	associate	NNS
18637	11587	41	.	.	.
18637	11588	1	In	in	IN
18637	11588	2	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11588	3	parte	parte	NN
18637	11588	4	Bollman,[725	Bollman,[725	NNP
18637	11588	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11588	6	which	which	WDT
18637	11588	7	involved	involve	VBD
18637	11588	8	two	two	CD
18637	11588	9	of	of	IN
18637	11588	10	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	11588	11	's	's	POS
18637	11588	12	confederates	confederate	NNS
18637	11588	13	,	,	,
18637	11588	14	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11588	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11588	16	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11588	17	,	,	,
18637	11588	18	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	11588	19	for	for	IN
18637	11588	20	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11588	21	and	and	CC
18637	11588	22	three	three	CD
18637	11588	23	other	other	JJ
18637	11588	24	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	11588	25	,	,	,
18637	11588	26	confined	confine	VBD
18637	11588	27	the	the	DT
18637	11588	28	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	11588	29	of	of	IN
18637	11588	30	levying	levying	NN
18637	11588	31	of	of	IN
18637	11588	32	war	war	NN
18637	11588	33	to	to	IN
18637	11588	34	the	the	DT
18637	11588	35	actual	actual	JJ
18637	11588	36	waging	waging	NN
18637	11588	37	of	of	IN
18637	11588	38	war	war	NN
18637	11588	39	.	.	.
18637	11589	1	"	"	``
18637	11589	2	However	however	RB
18637	11589	3	flagitious	flagitious	JJ
18637	11589	4	may	may	MD
18637	11589	5	be	be	VB
18637	11589	6	the	the	DT
18637	11589	7	crime	crime	NN
18637	11589	8	of	of	IN
18637	11589	9	conspiring	conspire	VBG
18637	11589	10	to	to	TO
18637	11589	11	subvert	subvert	VB
18637	11589	12	by	by	IN
18637	11589	13	force	force	NN
18637	11589	14	the	the	DT
18637	11589	15	government	government	NN
18637	11589	16	of	of	IN
18637	11589	17	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11589	18	country	country	NN
18637	11589	19	,	,	,
18637	11589	20	such	such	JJ
18637	11589	21	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	11589	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	11589	23	not	not	RB
18637	11589	24	treason	treason	NN
18637	11589	25	.	.	.
18637	11590	1	To	to	TO
18637	11590	2	conspire	conspire	VB
18637	11590	3	to	to	TO
18637	11590	4	levy	levy	VB
18637	11590	5	war	war	NN
18637	11590	6	and	and	CC
18637	11590	7	actually	actually	RB
18637	11590	8	to	to	TO
18637	11590	9	levy	levy	VB
18637	11590	10	war	war	NN
18637	11590	11	,	,	,
18637	11590	12	are	be	VBP
18637	11590	13	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	11590	14	offences	offence	NNS
18637	11590	15	.	.	.
18637	11591	1	The	the	DT
18637	11591	2	first	first	JJ
18637	11591	3	must	must	MD
18637	11591	4	be	be	VB
18637	11591	5	brought	bring	VBN
18637	11591	6	into	into	IN
18637	11591	7	open	open	JJ
18637	11591	8	action	action	NN
18637	11591	9	,	,	,
18637	11591	10	by	by	IN
18637	11591	11	the	the	DT
18637	11591	12	assemblage	assemblage	NN
18637	11591	13	of	of	IN
18637	11591	14	men	man	NNS
18637	11591	15	for	for	IN
18637	11591	16	a	a	DT
18637	11591	17	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	11591	18	treasonable	treasonable	JJ
18637	11591	19	in	in	IN
18637	11591	20	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11591	21	,	,	,
18637	11591	22	or	or	CC
18637	11591	23	the	the	DT
18637	11591	24	fact	fact	NN
18637	11591	25	of	of	IN
18637	11591	26	levying	levy	VBG
18637	11591	27	war	war	NN
18637	11591	28	can	can	MD
18637	11591	29	not	not	RB
18637	11591	30	have	have	VB
18637	11591	31	been	be	VBN
18637	11591	32	committed	commit	VBN
18637	11591	33	.	.	.
18637	11592	1	So	so	RB
18637	11592	2	far	far	RB
18637	11592	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	11592	4	this	this	DT
18637	11592	5	principle	principle	NN
18637	11592	6	been	be	VBN
18637	11592	7	carried	carry	VBN
18637	11592	8	,	,	,
18637	11592	9	that	that	IN
18637	11592	10	*	*	NFP
18637	11592	11	*	*	NFP
18637	11592	12	*	*	NFP
18637	11592	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11592	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	11592	15	been	be	VBN
18637	11592	16	determined	determine	VBN
18637	11592	17	that	that	IN
18637	11592	18	the	the	DT
18637	11592	19	actual	actual	JJ
18637	11592	20	enlistment	enlistment	NN
18637	11592	21	of	of	IN
18637	11592	22	men	man	NNS
18637	11592	23	,	,	,
18637	11592	24	to	to	TO
18637	11592	25	serve	serve	VB
18637	11592	26	against	against	IN
18637	11592	27	the	the	DT
18637	11592	28	government	government	NN
18637	11592	29	,	,	,
18637	11592	30	does	do	VBZ
18637	11592	31	not	not	RB
18637	11592	32	amount	amount	VB
18637	11592	33	to	to	IN
18637	11592	34	the	the	DT
18637	11592	35	levying	levying	NN
18637	11592	36	of	of	IN
18637	11592	37	war	war	NN
18637	11592	38	.	.	.
18637	11593	1	"	"	``
18637	11593	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11593	3	726	726	CD
18637	11593	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11593	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11593	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11593	7	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11593	8	was	be	VBD
18637	11593	9	careful	careful	JJ
18637	11593	10	,	,	,
18637	11593	11	however	however	RB
18637	11593	12	,	,	,
18637	11593	13	to	to	TO
18637	11593	14	state	state	VB
18637	11593	15	that	that	IN
18637	11593	16	the	the	DT
18637	11593	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11593	18	did	do	VBD
18637	11593	19	not	not	RB
18637	11593	20	mean	mean	VB
18637	11593	21	that	that	IN
18637	11593	22	no	no	DT
18637	11593	23	person	person	NN
18637	11593	24	could	could	MD
18637	11593	25	be	be	VB
18637	11593	26	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	11593	27	of	of	IN
18637	11593	28	this	this	DT
18637	11593	29	crime	crime	NN
18637	11593	30	who	who	WP
18637	11593	31	had	have	VBD
18637	11593	32	not	not	RB
18637	11593	33	appeared	appear	VBN
18637	11593	34	in	in	IN
18637	11593	35	arms	arm	NNS
18637	11593	36	against	against	IN
18637	11593	37	the	the	DT
18637	11593	38	country	country	NN
18637	11593	39	.	.	.
18637	11594	1	"	"	``
18637	11594	2	On	on	IN
18637	11594	3	the	the	DT
18637	11594	4	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	11594	5	,	,	,
18637	11594	6	if	if	IN
18637	11594	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11594	8	be	be	VB
18637	11594	9	actually	actually	RB
18637	11594	10	levied	levy	VBN
18637	11594	11	,	,	,
18637	11594	12	that	that	RB
18637	11594	13	is	is	RB
18637	11594	14	,	,	,
18637	11594	15	if	if	IN
18637	11594	16	a	a	DT
18637	11594	17	body	body	NN
18637	11594	18	of	of	IN
18637	11594	19	men	man	NNS
18637	11594	20	be	be	VB
18637	11594	21	actually	actually	RB
18637	11594	22	assembled	assemble	VBN
18637	11594	23	,	,	,
18637	11594	24	for	for	IN
18637	11594	25	the	the	DT
18637	11594	26	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	11594	27	of	of	IN
18637	11594	28	effecting	effect	VBG
18637	11594	29	by	by	IN
18637	11594	30	force	force	NN
18637	11594	31	a	a	DT
18637	11594	32	treasonable	treasonable	JJ
18637	11594	33	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	11594	34	,	,	,
18637	11594	35	all	all	PDT
18637	11594	36	those	those	DT
18637	11594	37	who	who	WP
18637	11594	38	perform	perform	VBP
18637	11594	39	any	any	DT
18637	11594	40	part	part	NN
18637	11594	41	,	,	,
18637	11594	42	however	however	RB
18637	11594	43	minute	minute	JJ
18637	11594	44	,	,	,
18637	11594	45	or	or	CC
18637	11594	46	however	however	RB
18637	11594	47	remote	remote	JJ
18637	11594	48	from	from	IN
18637	11594	49	the	the	DT
18637	11594	50	scene	scene	NN
18637	11594	51	of	of	IN
18637	11594	52	action	action	NN
18637	11594	53	,	,	,
18637	11594	54	and	and	CC
18637	11594	55	who	who	WP
18637	11594	56	are	be	VBP
18637	11594	57	actually	actually	RB
18637	11594	58	leagued	league	VBN
18637	11594	59	in	in	IN
18637	11594	60	the	the	DT
18637	11594	61	general	general	JJ
18637	11594	62	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	11594	63	,	,	,
18637	11594	64	are	be	VBP
18637	11594	65	to	to	TO
18637	11594	66	be	be	VB
18637	11594	67	considered	consider	VBN
18637	11594	68	as	as	IN
18637	11594	69	traitors	traitor	NNS
18637	11594	70	.	.	.
18637	11595	1	But	but	CC
18637	11595	2	there	there	EX
18637	11595	3	must	must	MD
18637	11595	4	be	be	VB
18637	11595	5	an	an	DT
18637	11595	6	actual	actual	JJ
18637	11595	7	assembling	assembling	NN
18637	11595	8	of	of	IN
18637	11595	9	men	man	NNS
18637	11595	10	,	,	,
18637	11595	11	for	for	IN
18637	11595	12	the	the	DT
18637	11595	13	treasonable	treasonable	JJ
18637	11595	14	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	11595	15	,	,	,
18637	11595	16	to	to	TO
18637	11595	17	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	11595	18	a	a	DT
18637	11595	19	levying	levying	NN
18637	11595	20	of	of	IN
18637	11595	21	war	war	NN
18637	11595	22	.	.	.
18637	11596	1	"	"	``
18637	11596	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11596	3	727	727	CD
18637	11596	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11596	5	On	on	IN
18637	11596	6	the	the	DT
18637	11596	7	basis	basis	NN
18637	11596	8	of	of	IN
18637	11596	9	these	these	DT
18637	11596	10	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	11596	11	and	and	CC
18637	11596	12	due	due	IN
18637	11596	13	to	to	IN
18637	11596	14	the	the	DT
18637	11596	15	fact	fact	NN
18637	11596	16	that	that	IN
18637	11596	17	no	no	DT
18637	11596	18	part	part	NN
18637	11596	19	of	of	IN
18637	11596	20	the	the	DT
18637	11596	21	crime	crime	NN
18637	11596	22	charged	charge	VBN
18637	11596	23	had	have	VBD
18637	11596	24	been	be	VBN
18637	11596	25	committed	commit	VBN
18637	11596	26	in	in	IN
18637	11596	27	the	the	DT
18637	11596	28	District	District	NNP
18637	11596	29	of	of	IN
18637	11596	30	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	11596	31	,	,	,
18637	11596	32	the	the	DT
18637	11596	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11596	34	held	hold	VBD
18637	11596	35	that	that	IN
18637	11596	36	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	11596	37	and	and	CC
18637	11596	38	Swartwout	Swartwout	NNP
18637	11596	39	could	could	MD
18637	11596	40	not	not	RB
18637	11596	41	be	be	VB
18637	11596	42	tried	try	VBN
18637	11596	43	in	in	IN
18637	11596	44	the	the	DT
18637	11596	45	District	District	NNP
18637	11596	46	and	and	CC
18637	11596	47	ordered	order	VBD
18637	11596	48	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11596	49	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	11596	50	.	.	.
18637	11597	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11597	2	continued	continue	VBD
18637	11597	3	by	by	IN
18637	11597	4	saying	say	VBG
18637	11597	5	that	that	IN
18637	11597	6	"	"	``
18637	11597	7	the	the	DT
18637	11597	8	crime	crime	NN
18637	11597	9	of	of	IN
18637	11597	10	treason	treason	NN
18637	11597	11	should	should	MD
18637	11597	12	not	not	RB
18637	11597	13	be	be	VB
18637	11597	14	extended	extend	VBN
18637	11597	15	by	by	IN
18637	11597	16	construction	construction	NN
18637	11597	17	to	to	IN
18637	11597	18	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
18637	11597	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	11597	20	"	"	''
18637	11597	21	and	and	CC
18637	11597	22	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	11597	23	that	that	IN
18637	11597	24	no	no	DT
18637	11597	25	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	11597	26	for	for	IN
18637	11597	27	overturning	overturn	VBG
18637	11597	28	the	the	DT
18637	11597	29	Government	Government	NNP
18637	11597	30	and	and	CC
18637	11597	31	"	"	``
18637	11597	32	no	no	DT
18637	11597	33	enlisting	enlist	VBG
18637	11597	34	of	of	IN
18637	11597	35	men	man	NNS
18637	11597	36	to	to	TO
18637	11597	37	effect	effect	VB
18637	11597	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11597	39	,	,	,
18637	11597	40	would	would	MD
18637	11597	41	be	be	VB
18637	11597	42	an	an	DT
18637	11597	43	actual	actual	JJ
18637	11597	44	levying	levying	NN
18637	11597	45	of	of	IN
18637	11597	46	war	war	NN
18637	11597	47	.	.	.
18637	11598	1	"	"	``
18637	11598	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11598	3	728	728	CD
18637	11598	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11598	5	The	the	DT
18637	11598	6	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	11598	7	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	11598	8	Not	not	RB
18637	11598	9	long	long	RB
18637	11598	10	afterward	afterward	RB
18637	11598	11	the	the	DT
18637	11598	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11598	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11598	14	went	go	VBD
18637	11598	15	to	to	IN
18637	11598	16	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	11598	17	to	to	TO
18637	11598	18	preside	preside	VB
18637	11598	19	over	over	IN
18637	11598	20	the	the	DT
18637	11598	21	trial	trial	NN
18637	11598	22	of	of	IN
18637	11598	23	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	11598	24	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11598	25	.	.	.
18637	11599	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11599	2	ruling[729	ruling[729	NN
18637	11599	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11599	4	denying	deny	VBG
18637	11599	5	a	a	DT
18637	11599	6	motion	motion	NN
18637	11599	7	to	to	TO
18637	11599	8	introduce	introduce	VB
18637	11599	9	certain	certain	JJ
18637	11599	10	collateral	collateral	JJ
18637	11599	11	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	11599	12	bearing	bear	VBG
18637	11599	13	on	on	IN
18637	11599	14	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	11599	15	's	's	POS
18637	11599	16	activities	activity	NNS
18637	11599	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	11599	18	significant	significant	JJ
18637	11599	19	both	both	CC
18637	11599	20	for	for	IN
18637	11599	21	rendering	render	VBG
18637	11599	22	the	the	DT
18637	11599	23	latter	latter	NN
18637	11599	24	's	's	POS
18637	11599	25	acquittal	acquittal	JJ
18637	11599	26	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
18637	11599	27	and	and	CC
18637	11599	28	for	for	IN
18637	11599	29	the	the	DT
18637	11599	30	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	11599	31	and	and	CC
18637	11599	32	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	11599	33	made	make	VBN
18637	11599	34	to	to	IN
18637	11599	35	the	the	DT
18637	11599	36	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	11599	37	decision	decision	NN
18637	11599	38	.	.	.
18637	11600	1	In	in	IN
18637	11600	2	brief	brief	NN
18637	11600	3	this	this	DT
18637	11600	4	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	11600	5	held	hold	VBD
18637	11600	6	that	that	IN
18637	11600	7	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	11600	8	,	,	,
18637	11600	9	who	who	WP
18637	11600	10	had	have	VBD
18637	11600	11	not	not	RB
18637	11600	12	been	be	VBN
18637	11600	13	present	present	JJ
18637	11600	14	at	at	IN
18637	11600	15	the	the	DT
18637	11600	16	assemblage	assemblage	NN
18637	11600	17	on	on	IN
18637	11600	18	Blennerhassett	Blennerhassett	NNP
18637	11600	19	's	's	POS
18637	11600	20	Island	Island	NNP
18637	11600	21	,	,	,
18637	11600	22	could	could	MD
18637	11600	23	be	be	VB
18637	11600	24	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	11600	25	of	of	IN
18637	11600	26	advising	advise	VBG
18637	11600	27	or	or	CC
18637	11600	28	procuring	procure	VBG
18637	11600	29	a	a	DT
18637	11600	30	levying	levying	NN
18637	11600	31	of	of	IN
18637	11600	32	war	war	NN
18637	11600	33	,	,	,
18637	11600	34	only	only	RB
18637	11600	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	11600	36	the	the	DT
18637	11600	37	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	11600	38	of	of	IN
18637	11600	39	two	two	CD
18637	11600	40	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	11600	41	to	to	IN
18637	11600	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11600	43	having	have	VBG
18637	11600	44	procured	procure	VBN
18637	11600	45	the	the	DT
18637	11600	46	assemblage	assemblage	NN
18637	11600	47	.	.	.
18637	11601	1	This	this	DT
18637	11601	2	operation	operation	NN
18637	11601	3	having	have	VBG
18637	11601	4	been	be	VBN
18637	11601	5	covert	covert	JJ
18637	11601	6	,	,	,
18637	11601	7	such	such	JJ
18637	11601	8	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	11601	9	was	be	VBD
18637	11601	10	naturally	naturally	RB
18637	11601	11	unobtainable	unobtainable	JJ
18637	11601	12	.	.	.
18637	11602	1	The	the	DT
18637	11602	2	net	net	JJ
18637	11602	3	effect	effect	NN
18637	11602	4	of	of	IN
18637	11602	5	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11602	6	's	's	POS
18637	11602	7	pronouncements	pronouncement	NNS
18637	11602	8	was	be	VBD
18637	11602	9	to	to	TO
18637	11602	10	make	make	VB
18637	11602	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11602	12	extremely	extremely	RB
18637	11602	13	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	11602	14	to	to	TO
18637	11602	15	convict	convict	VB
18637	11602	16	one	one	CD
18637	11602	17	of	of	IN
18637	11602	18	levying	levy	VBG
18637	11602	19	war	war	NN
18637	11602	20	against	against	IN
18637	11602	21	the	the	DT
18637	11602	22	United	United	NNP
18637	11602	23	States	States	NNP
18637	11602	24	short	short	JJ
18637	11602	25	of	of	IN
18637	11602	26	the	the	DT
18637	11602	27	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	11602	28	of	of	IN
18637	11602	29	or	or	CC
18637	11602	30	personal	personal	JJ
18637	11602	31	participation	participation	NN
18637	11602	32	in	in	IN
18637	11602	33	actual	actual	JJ
18637	11602	34	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	11602	35	.	.	.
18637	11603	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11603	2	730	730	CD
18637	11603	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11603	4	AID	aid	NN
18637	11603	5	AND	and	CC
18637	11603	6	COMFORT	COMFORT	VBZ
18637	11603	7	TO	to	IN
18637	11603	8	THE	the	DT
18637	11603	9	ENEMY	enemy	NN
18637	11603	10	;	;	:
18637	11603	11	THE	the	DT
18637	11603	12	CRAMER	CRAMER	NNP
18637	11603	13	CASE	case	NN
18637	11603	14	Since	since	IN
18637	11603	15	the	the	DT
18637	11603	16	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	11603	17	case	case	NN
18637	11603	18	only	only	RB
18637	11603	19	three	three	CD
18637	11603	20	treason	treason	NN
18637	11603	21	cases	case	NNS
18637	11603	22	have	have	VBP
18637	11603	23	ever	ever	RB
18637	11603	24	reached	reach	VBN
18637	11603	25	the	the	DT
18637	11603	26	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11603	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11603	28	,	,	,
18637	11603	29	all	all	DT
18637	11603	30	of	of	IN
18637	11603	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11603	32	outgrowths	outgrowth	NNS
18637	11603	33	of	of	IN
18637	11603	34	World	World	NNP
18637	11603	35	War	War	NNP
18637	11603	36	II	II	NNP
18637	11603	37	and	and	CC
18637	11603	38	all	all	DT
18637	11603	39	charging	charge	VBG
18637	11603	40	adherence	adherence	NN
18637	11603	41	to	to	IN
18637	11603	42	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	11603	43	of	of	IN
18637	11603	44	the	the	DT
18637	11603	45	United	United	NNP
18637	11603	46	States	States	NNP
18637	11603	47	and	and	CC
18637	11603	48	giving	give	VBG
18637	11603	49	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11603	50	aid	aid	NN
18637	11603	51	and	and	CC
18637	11603	52	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	11603	53	.	.	.
18637	11604	1	In	in	IN
18637	11604	2	the	the	DT
18637	11604	3	first	first	JJ
18637	11604	4	of	of	IN
18637	11604	5	these	these	DT
18637	11604	6	,	,	,
18637	11604	7	Cramer	Cramer	NNP
18637	11604	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11604	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	11604	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11604	11	United	United	NNP
18637	11604	12	States,[731	States,[731	NNP
18637	11604	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11604	14	the	the	DT
18637	11604	15	issue	issue	NN
18637	11604	16	was	be	VBD
18637	11604	17	whether	whether	IN
18637	11604	18	the	the	DT
18637	11604	19	"	"	``
18637	11604	20	overt	overt	JJ
18637	11604	21	act	act	NNP
18637	11604	22	"	"	''
18637	11604	23	had	have	VBD
18637	11604	24	to	to	TO
18637	11604	25	be	be	VB
18637	11604	26	"	"	``
18637	11604	27	openly	openly	RB
18637	11604	28	manifest	manifest	VB
18637	11604	29	treason	treason	NN
18637	11604	30	"	"	''
18637	11604	31	or	or	CC
18637	11604	32	if	if	IN
18637	11604	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11604	34	was	be	VBD
18637	11604	35	enough	enough	JJ
18637	11604	36	if	if	IN
18637	11604	37	,	,	,
18637	11604	38	when	when	WRB
18637	11604	39	supported	support	VBN
18637	11604	40	by	by	IN
18637	11604	41	other	other	JJ
18637	11604	42	proper	proper	JJ
18637	11604	43	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	11604	44	,	,	,
18637	11604	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11604	46	showed	show	VBD
18637	11604	47	the	the	DT
18637	11604	48	required	require	VBN
18637	11604	49	treasonable	treasonable	JJ
18637	11604	50	intention	intention	NN
18637	11604	51	.	.	.
18637	11605	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11605	2	732	732	CD
18637	11605	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11605	4	The	the	DT
18637	11605	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11605	6	in	in	IN
18637	11605	7	a	a	DT
18637	11605	8	five	five	CD
18637	11605	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	11605	10	to	to	IN
18637	11605	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	11605	12	four	four	CD
18637	11605	13	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11605	14	by	by	IN
18637	11605	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11605	16	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	11605	17	in	in	IN
18637	11605	18	effect	effect	NN
18637	11605	19	took	take	VBD
18637	11605	20	the	the	DT
18637	11605	21	former	former	JJ
18637	11605	22	view	view	NN
18637	11605	23	holding	hold	VBG
18637	11605	24	that	that	IN
18637	11605	25	"	"	``
18637	11605	26	the	the	DT
18637	11605	27	two	two	CD
18637	11605	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	11605	29	witness	witness	NN
18637	11605	30	principle	principle	NN
18637	11605	31	"	"	``
18637	11605	32	interdicted	interdict	VBN
18637	11605	33	"	"	''
18637	11605	34	imputation	imputation	NN
18637	11605	35	of	of	IN
18637	11605	36	_	_	NNP
18637	11605	37	incriminating	incriminate	VBG
18637	11605	38	acts	act	NNS
18637	11605	39	_	_	NNP
18637	11605	40	to	to	IN
18637	11605	41	the	the	DT
18637	11605	42	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	11605	43	by	by	IN
18637	11605	44	circumstantial	circumstantial	JJ
18637	11605	45	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	11605	46	or	or	CC
18637	11605	47	by	by	IN
18637	11605	48	the	the	DT
18637	11605	49	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	11605	50	of	of	IN
18637	11605	51	a	a	DT
18637	11605	52	single	single	JJ
18637	11605	53	witness,"[733	witness,"[733	NN
18637	11605	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11605	55	even	even	RB
18637	11605	56	though	though	IN
18637	11605	57	the	the	DT
18637	11605	58	single	single	JJ
18637	11605	59	witness	witness	NN
18637	11605	60	in	in	IN
18637	11605	61	question	question	NN
18637	11605	62	was	be	VBD
18637	11605	63	the	the	DT
18637	11605	64	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	11605	65	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11605	66	.	.	.
18637	11606	1	"	"	``
18637	11606	2	Every	every	DT
18637	11606	3	act	act	NN
18637	11606	4	,	,	,
18637	11606	5	movement	movement	NN
18637	11606	6	,	,	,
18637	11606	7	deed	deed	NN
18637	11606	8	,	,	,
18637	11606	9	and	and	CC
18637	11606	10	word	word	NN
18637	11606	11	of	of	IN
18637	11606	12	the	the	DT
18637	11606	13	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	11606	14	charged	charge	VBN
18637	11606	15	to	to	TO
18637	11606	16	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	11606	17	treason	treason	NN
18637	11606	18	must	must	MD
18637	11606	19	be	be	VB
18637	11606	20	supported	support	VBN
18637	11606	21	by	by	IN
18637	11606	22	the	the	DT
18637	11606	23	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	11606	24	of	of	IN
18637	11606	25	two	two	CD
18637	11606	26	witnesses,"[734	witnesses,"[734	NNS
18637	11606	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11606	28	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11606	29	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	11606	30	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	11606	31	.	.	.
18637	11607	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11607	2	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	11607	3	in	in	IN
18637	11607	4	a	a	DT
18637	11607	5	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11607	6	,	,	,
18637	11607	7	in	in	IN
18637	11607	8	which	which	WDT
18637	11607	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11607	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11607	11	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	11607	12	and	and	CC
18637	11607	13	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	11607	14	Black	Black	NNP
18637	11607	15	and	and	CC
18637	11607	16	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	11607	17	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	11607	18	,	,	,
18637	11607	19	contended	contend	VBD
18637	11607	20	that	that	IN
18637	11607	21	Cramer	Cramer	NNP
18637	11607	22	's	's	POS
18637	11607	23	treasonable	treasonable	JJ
18637	11607	24	intention	intention	NN
18637	11607	25	was	be	VBD
18637	11607	26	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	11607	27	shown	show	VBN
18637	11607	28	by	by	IN
18637	11607	29	overt	overt	JJ
18637	11607	30	acts	act	NNS
18637	11607	31	as	as	IN
18637	11607	32	attested	attest	VBN
18637	11607	33	to	to	IN
18637	11607	34	by	by	IN
18637	11607	35	two	two	CD
18637	11607	36	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	11607	37	each	each	DT
18637	11607	38	,	,	,
18637	11607	39	plus	plus	CC
18637	11607	40	statements	statement	NNS
18637	11607	41	made	make	VBN
18637	11607	42	by	by	IN
18637	11607	43	Cramer	Cramer	NNP
18637	11607	44	on	on	IN
18637	11607	45	the	the	DT
18637	11607	46	witness	witness	NN
18637	11607	47	stand	stand	NN
18637	11607	48	.	.	.
18637	11608	1	THE	the	DT
18637	11608	2	HAUPT	HAUPT	NNP
18637	11608	3	CASE	case	VBP
18637	11608	4	The	the	DT
18637	11608	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11608	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11608	7	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	11608	8	a	a	DT
18637	11608	9	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	11608	10	of	of	IN
18637	11608	11	treason	treason	NN
18637	11608	12	,	,	,
18637	11608	13	for	for	IN
18637	11608	14	the	the	DT
18637	11608	15	first	first	JJ
18637	11608	16	time	time	NN
18637	11608	17	in	in	IN
18637	11608	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11608	19	history	history	NN
18637	11608	20	in	in	IN
18637	11608	21	1947	1947	CD
18637	11608	22	in	in	IN
18637	11608	23	Haupt	Haupt	NNP
18637	11608	24	_	_	NNP
18637	11608	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	11608	26	_	_	NNP
18637	11608	27	United	United	NNP
18637	11608	28	States	States	NNP
18637	11608	29	.	.	.
18637	11609	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11609	2	735	735	CD
18637	11609	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11609	4	Here	here	RB
18637	11609	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11609	6	was	be	VBD
18637	11609	7	held	hold	VBN
18637	11609	8	that	that	IN
18637	11609	9	although	although	IN
18637	11609	10	the	the	DT
18637	11609	11	overt	overt	JJ
18637	11609	12	acts	act	NNS
18637	11609	13	relied	rely	VBN
18637	11609	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	11609	15	to	to	TO
18637	11609	16	support	support	VB
18637	11609	17	the	the	DT
18637	11609	18	charge	charge	NN
18637	11609	19	of	of	IN
18637	11609	20	treason	treason	NN
18637	11609	21	--	--	:
18637	11609	22	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	11609	23	's	's	POS
18637	11609	24	harboring	harboring	NN
18637	11609	25	and	and	CC
18637	11609	26	sheltering	shelter	VBG
18637	11609	27	in	in	IN
18637	11609	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11609	29	home	home	NN
18637	11609	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11609	31	son	son	NN
18637	11609	32	who	who	WP
18637	11609	33	was	be	VBD
18637	11609	34	an	an	DT
18637	11609	35	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	11609	36	spy	spy	NN
18637	11609	37	and	and	CC
18637	11609	38	saboteur	saboteur	NN
18637	11609	39	,	,	,
18637	11609	40	assisting	assist	VBG
18637	11609	41	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11609	42	in	in	IN
18637	11609	43	purchasing	purchase	VBG
18637	11609	44	an	an	DT
18637	11609	45	automobile	automobile	NN
18637	11609	46	,	,	,
18637	11609	47	and	and	CC
18637	11609	48	in	in	IN
18637	11609	49	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	11609	50	employment	employment	NN
18637	11609	51	in	in	IN
18637	11609	52	a	a	DT
18637	11609	53	defense	defense	NN
18637	11609	54	plant	plant	NN
18637	11609	55	--	--	:
18637	11609	56	were	be	VBD
18637	11609	57	all	all	DT
18637	11609	58	acts	act	NNS
18637	11609	59	which	which	WDT
18637	11609	60	a	a	DT
18637	11609	61	father	father	NN
18637	11609	62	would	would	MD
18637	11609	63	naturally	naturally	RB
18637	11609	64	perform	perform	VB
18637	11609	65	for	for	IN
18637	11609	66	a	a	DT
18637	11609	67	son	son	NN
18637	11609	68	,	,	,
18637	11609	69	this	this	DT
18637	11609	70	fact	fact	NN
18637	11609	71	did	do	VBD
18637	11609	72	not	not	RB
18637	11609	73	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	11609	74	relieve	relieve	VB
18637	11609	75	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11609	76	of	of	IN
18637	11609	77	the	the	DT
18637	11609	78	treasonable	treasonable	JJ
18637	11609	79	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	11609	80	of	of	IN
18637	11609	81	giving	give	VBG
18637	11609	82	aid	aid	NN
18637	11609	83	and	and	CC
18637	11609	84	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	11609	85	to	to	IN
18637	11609	86	the	the	DT
18637	11609	87	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	11609	88	.	.	.
18637	11610	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	11610	2	for	for	IN
18637	11610	3	the	the	DT
18637	11610	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11610	5	,	,	,
18637	11610	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11610	7	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	11610	8	said	say	VBD
18637	11610	9	:	:	:
18637	11610	10	"	"	``
18637	11610	11	No	no	RB
18637	11610	12	matter	matter	RB
18637	11610	13	whether	whether	IN
18637	11610	14	young	young	JJ
18637	11610	15	Haupt	Haupt	NNP
18637	11610	16	's	's	POS
18637	11610	17	mission	mission	NN
18637	11610	18	was	be	VBD
18637	11610	19	benign	benign	JJ
18637	11610	20	or	or	CC
18637	11610	21	traitorous	traitorous	JJ
18637	11610	22	,	,	,
18637	11610	23	known	known	JJ
18637	11610	24	or	or	CC
18637	11610	25	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	11610	26	to	to	IN
18637	11610	27	the	the	DT
18637	11610	28	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	11610	29	,	,	,
18637	11610	30	these	these	DT
18637	11610	31	acts	act	NNS
18637	11610	32	were	be	VBD
18637	11610	33	aid	aid	NN
18637	11610	34	and	and	CC
18637	11610	35	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	11610	36	to	to	IN
18637	11610	37	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11610	38	.	.	.
18637	11611	1	In	in	IN
18637	11611	2	the	the	DT
18637	11611	3	light	light	NN
18637	11611	4	of	of	IN
18637	11611	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11611	6	mission	mission	NN
18637	11611	7	and	and	CC
18637	11611	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11611	9	instructions	instruction	NNS
18637	11611	10	,	,	,
18637	11611	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11611	12	were	be	VBD
18637	11611	13	more	more	JJR
18637	11611	14	than	than	IN
18637	11611	15	casually	casually	RB
18637	11611	16	useful	useful	JJ
18637	11611	17	;	;	:
18637	11611	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11611	19	were	be	VBD
18637	11611	20	aid	aid	NN
18637	11611	21	in	in	IN
18637	11611	22	steps	step	NNS
18637	11611	23	essential	essential	JJ
18637	11611	24	to	to	IN
18637	11611	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11611	26	design	design	NN
18637	11611	27	for	for	IN
18637	11611	28	treason	treason	NN
18637	11611	29	.	.	.
18637	11612	1	If	if	IN
18637	11612	2	proof	proof	NN
18637	11612	3	be	be	VB
18637	11612	4	added	add	VBN
18637	11612	5	that	that	IN
18637	11612	6	the	the	DT
18637	11612	7	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	11612	8	knew	know	VBD
18637	11612	9	of	of	IN
18637	11612	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11612	11	son	son	NN
18637	11612	12	's	's	POS
18637	11612	13	instructions	instruction	NNS
18637	11612	14	,	,	,
18637	11612	15	preparation	preparation	NN
18637	11612	16	and	and	CC
18637	11612	17	plans	plan	NNS
18637	11612	18	,	,	,
18637	11612	19	the	the	DT
18637	11612	20	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	11612	21	to	to	TO
18637	11612	22	aid	aid	VB
18637	11612	23	and	and	CC
18637	11612	24	comfort	comfort	VB
18637	11612	25	the	the	DT
18637	11612	26	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	11612	27	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	11612	28	clear	clear	JJ
18637	11612	29	.	.	.
18637	11613	1	"	"	``
18637	11613	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11613	3	736	736	CD
18637	11613	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11613	5	The	the	DT
18637	11613	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11613	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	11613	8	that	that	IN
18637	11613	9	conversations	conversation	NNS
18637	11613	10	and	and	CC
18637	11613	11	occurrences	occurrence	NNS
18637	11613	12	long	long	RB
18637	11613	13	prior	prior	RB
18637	11613	14	to	to	IN
18637	11613	15	the	the	DT
18637	11613	16	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	11613	17	were	be	VBD
18637	11613	18	admissible	admissible	JJ
18637	11613	19	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	11613	20	on	on	IN
18637	11613	21	the	the	DT
18637	11613	22	question	question	NN
18637	11613	23	of	of	IN
18637	11613	24	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	11613	25	's	's	POS
18637	11613	26	intent	intent	NN
18637	11613	27	.	.	.
18637	11614	1	And	and	CC
18637	11614	2	more	more	RBR
18637	11614	3	important	important	JJ
18637	11614	4	,	,	,
18637	11614	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11614	6	held	hold	VBD
18637	11614	7	that	that	IN
18637	11614	8	the	the	DT
18637	11614	9	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11614	10	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	11614	11	of	of	IN
18637	11614	12	two	two	CD
18637	11614	13	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	11614	14	to	to	IN
18637	11614	15	the	the	DT
18637	11614	16	same	same	JJ
18637	11614	17	overt	overt	JJ
18637	11614	18	act	act	NN
18637	11614	19	or	or	CC
18637	11614	20	confession	confession	NN
18637	11614	21	in	in	IN
18637	11614	22	open	open	JJ
18637	11614	23	court	court	NN
18637	11614	24	does	do	VBZ
18637	11614	25	not	not	RB
18637	11614	26	operate	operate	VB
18637	11614	27	to	to	TO
18637	11614	28	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	11614	29	confessions	confession	NNS
18637	11614	30	or	or	CC
18637	11614	31	admissions	admission	NNS
18637	11614	32	made	make	VBN
18637	11614	33	out	out	IN
18637	11614	34	of	of	IN
18637	11614	35	court	court	NN
18637	11614	36	,	,	,
18637	11614	37	where	where	WRB
18637	11614	38	a	a	DT
18637	11614	39	legal	legal	JJ
18637	11614	40	basis	basis	NN
18637	11614	41	for	for	IN
18637	11614	42	the	the	DT
18637	11614	43	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	11614	44	has	have	VBZ
18637	11614	45	been	be	VBN
18637	11614	46	laid	lay	VBN
18637	11614	47	by	by	IN
18637	11614	48	the	the	DT
18637	11614	49	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	11614	50	of	of	IN
18637	11614	51	two	two	CD
18637	11614	52	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	11614	53	of	of	IN
18637	11614	54	which	which	WDT
18637	11614	55	such	such	JJ
18637	11614	56	confessions	confession	NNS
18637	11614	57	or	or	CC
18637	11614	58	admissions	admission	NNS
18637	11614	59	are	be	VBP
18637	11614	60	merely	merely	RB
18637	11614	61	corroborative	corroborative	JJ
18637	11614	62	.	.	.
18637	11615	1	This	this	DT
18637	11615	2	relaxation	relaxation	NN
18637	11615	3	of	of	IN
18637	11615	4	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	11615	5	surrounding	surround	VBG
18637	11615	6	the	the	DT
18637	11615	7	definition	definition	NN
18637	11615	8	of	of	IN
18637	11615	9	treason	treason	NN
18637	11615	10	evoked	evoke	VBD
18637	11615	11	obvious	obvious	JJ
18637	11615	12	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
18637	11615	13	from	from	IN
18637	11615	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11615	15	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	11615	16	who	who	WP
18637	11615	17	saw	see	VBD
18637	11615	18	in	in	IN
18637	11615	19	the	the	DT
18637	11615	20	Haupt	Haupt	NNP
18637	11615	21	decision	decision	NN
18637	11615	22	a	a	DT
18637	11615	23	vindication	vindication	NN
18637	11615	24	of	of	IN
18637	11615	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11615	26	position	position	NN
18637	11615	27	in	in	IN
18637	11615	28	the	the	DT
18637	11615	29	Cramer	Cramer	NNP
18637	11615	30	case	case	NN
18637	11615	31	.	.	.
18637	11616	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11616	2	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	11616	3	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11616	4	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	11616	5	what	what	WP
18637	11616	6	may	may	MD
18637	11616	7	be	be	VB
18637	11616	8	called	call	VBN
18637	11616	9	a	a	DT
18637	11616	10	restatement	restatement	NN
18637	11616	11	of	of	IN
18637	11616	12	the	the	DT
18637	11616	13	law	law	NN
18637	11616	14	of	of	IN
18637	11616	15	treason	treason	NN
18637	11616	16	and	and	CC
18637	11616	17	merits	merit	NNS
18637	11616	18	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	11616	19	at	at	IN
18637	11616	20	length	length	NN
18637	11616	21	;	;	:
18637	11616	22	"	"	``
18637	11616	23	As	as	IN
18637	11616	24	the	the	DT
18637	11616	25	_	_	NNP
18637	11616	26	Cramer	Cramer	NNP
18637	11616	27	_	_	NNP
18637	11616	28	case	case	NN
18637	11616	29	makes	make	VBZ
18637	11616	30	plain	plain	JJ
18637	11616	31	,	,	,
18637	11616	32	the	the	DT
18637	11616	33	overt	overt	JJ
18637	11616	34	act	act	NNP
18637	11616	35	and	and	CC
18637	11616	36	the	the	DT
18637	11616	37	intent	intent	NN
18637	11616	38	with	with	IN
18637	11616	39	which	which	WDT
18637	11616	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11616	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	11616	42	done	do	VBN
18637	11616	43	are	be	VBP
18637	11616	44	separate	separate	JJ
18637	11616	45	and	and	CC
18637	11616	46	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	11616	47	elements	element	NNS
18637	11616	48	of	of	IN
18637	11616	49	the	the	DT
18637	11616	50	crime	crime	NN
18637	11616	51	.	.	.
18637	11617	1	Intent	intent	NN
18637	11617	2	need	nee	MD
18637	11617	3	not	not	RB
18637	11617	4	be	be	VB
18637	11617	5	proved	prove	VBN
18637	11617	6	by	by	IN
18637	11617	7	two	two	CD
18637	11617	8	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	11617	9	but	but	CC
18637	11617	10	may	may	MD
18637	11617	11	be	be	VB
18637	11617	12	inferred	infer	VBN
18637	11617	13	from	from	IN
18637	11617	14	all	all	PDT
18637	11617	15	the	the	DT
18637	11617	16	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	11617	17	surrounding	surround	VBG
18637	11617	18	the	the	DT
18637	11617	19	overt	overt	JJ
18637	11617	20	act	act	NN
18637	11617	21	.	.	.
18637	11618	1	But	but	CC
18637	11618	2	if	if	IN
18637	11618	3	two	two	CD
18637	11618	4	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	11618	5	are	be	VBP
18637	11618	6	not	not	RB
18637	11618	7	required	require	VBN
18637	11618	8	to	to	TO
18637	11618	9	prove	prove	VB
18637	11618	10	treasonable	treasonable	JJ
18637	11618	11	intent	intent	NN
18637	11618	12	,	,	,
18637	11618	13	two	two	CD
18637	11618	14	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	11618	15	need	nee	MD
18637	11618	16	not	not	RB
18637	11618	17	be	be	VB
18637	11618	18	required	require	VBN
18637	11618	19	to	to	TO
18637	11618	20	show	show	VB
18637	11618	21	the	the	DT
18637	11618	22	treasonable	treasonable	JJ
18637	11618	23	character	character	NN
18637	11618	24	of	of	IN
18637	11618	25	the	the	DT
18637	11618	26	overt	overt	JJ
18637	11618	27	act	act	NNP
18637	11618	28	.	.	.
18637	11619	1	For	for	IN
18637	11619	2	proof	proof	NN
18637	11619	3	of	of	IN
18637	11619	4	treasonable	treasonable	JJ
18637	11619	5	intent	intent	NN
18637	11619	6	in	in	IN
18637	11619	7	the	the	DT
18637	11619	8	doing	doing	NN
18637	11619	9	of	of	IN
18637	11619	10	the	the	DT
18637	11619	11	overt	overt	JJ
18637	11619	12	act	act	NNP
18637	11619	13	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	11619	14	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	11619	15	proof	proof	NN
18637	11619	16	that	that	IN
18637	11619	17	the	the	DT
18637	11619	18	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	11619	19	committed	commit	VBD
18637	11619	20	the	the	DT
18637	11619	21	overt	overt	JJ
18637	11619	22	act	act	NN
18637	11619	23	with	with	IN
18637	11619	24	the	the	DT
18637	11619	25	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	11619	26	or	or	CC
18637	11619	27	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	11619	28	of	of	IN
18637	11619	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11619	30	treasonable	treasonable	JJ
18637	11619	31	character	character	NN
18637	11619	32	.	.	.
18637	11620	1	"	"	``
18637	11620	2	The	the	DT
18637	11620	3	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	11620	4	of	of	IN
18637	11620	5	an	an	DT
18637	11620	6	overt	overt	JJ
18637	11620	7	act	act	NN
18637	11620	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	11620	9	to	to	TO
18637	11620	10	make	make	VB
18637	11620	11	certain	certain	JJ
18637	11620	12	a	a	DT
18637	11620	13	treasonable	treasonable	JJ
18637	11620	14	project	project	NN
18637	11620	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	11620	16	moved	move	VBN
18637	11620	17	from	from	IN
18637	11620	18	the	the	DT
18637	11620	19	realm	realm	NN
18637	11620	20	of	of	IN
18637	11620	21	thought	thought	NN
18637	11620	22	into	into	IN
18637	11620	23	the	the	DT
18637	11620	24	realm	realm	NN
18637	11620	25	of	of	IN
18637	11620	26	action	action	NN
18637	11620	27	.	.	.
18637	11621	1	That	that	DT
18637	11621	2	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	11621	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	11621	4	undeniably	undeniably	RB
18637	11621	5	met	meet	VBN
18637	11621	6	in	in	IN
18637	11621	7	the	the	DT
18637	11621	8	present	present	JJ
18637	11621	9	case	case	NN
18637	11621	10	,	,	,
18637	11621	11	as	as	IN
18637	11621	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11621	13	was	be	VBD
18637	11621	14	in	in	IN
18637	11621	15	the	the	DT
18637	11621	16	case	case	NN
18637	11621	17	of	of	IN
18637	11621	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11621	19	Cramer	Cramer	NNP
18637	11621	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11621	21	.	.	.
18637	11622	1	"	"	``
18637	11622	2	The	the	DT
18637	11622	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11622	4	Cramer	Cramer	NNP
18637	11622	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11622	6	case	case	NN
18637	11622	7	departed	depart	VBD
18637	11622	8	from	from	IN
18637	11622	9	those	those	DT
18637	11622	10	rules	rule	NNS
18637	11622	11	when	when	WRB
18637	11622	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11622	13	held	hold	VBD
18637	11622	14	that	that	IN
18637	11622	15	'	'	''
18637	11622	16	The	the	DT
18637	11622	17	two	two	CD
18637	11622	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	11622	19	witness	witness	NN
18637	11622	20	principle	principle	NN
18637	11622	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	11622	22	to	to	TO
18637	11622	23	interdict	interdict	VB
18637	11622	24	imputation	imputation	NN
18637	11622	25	of	of	IN
18637	11622	26	_	_	NNP
18637	11622	27	incriminating	incriminate	VBG
18637	11622	28	acts	act	NNS
18637	11622	29	_	_	NNP
18637	11622	30	to	to	IN
18637	11622	31	the	the	DT
18637	11622	32	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	11622	33	by	by	IN
18637	11622	34	circumstantial	circumstantial	JJ
18637	11622	35	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	11622	36	or	or	CC
18637	11622	37	by	by	IN
18637	11622	38	the	the	DT
18637	11622	39	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	11622	40	of	of	IN
18637	11622	41	a	a	DT
18637	11622	42	single	single	JJ
18637	11622	43	witness	witness	NN
18637	11622	44	.	.	.
18637	11622	45	'	'	''
18637	11623	1	325	325	CD
18637	11623	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11623	3	p.	p.	NN
18637	11623	4	35	35	CD
18637	11623	5	.	.	.
18637	11624	1	The	the	DT
18637	11624	2	present	present	JJ
18637	11624	3	decision	decision	NN
18637	11624	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	11624	5	truer	true	JJR
18637	11624	6	to	to	IN
18637	11624	7	the	the	DT
18637	11624	8	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11624	9	definition	definition	NN
18637	11624	10	of	of	IN
18637	11624	11	treason	treason	NN
18637	11624	12	when	when	WRB
18637	11624	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11624	14	forsakes	forsake	VBZ
18637	11624	15	that	that	DT
18637	11624	16	test	test	NN
18637	11624	17	and	and	CC
18637	11624	18	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	11624	19	that	that	IN
18637	11624	20	an	an	DT
18637	11624	21	act	act	NN
18637	11624	22	,	,	,
18637	11624	23	quite	quite	RB
18637	11624	24	innocent	innocent	JJ
18637	11624	25	on	on	IN
18637	11624	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11624	27	face	face	NN
18637	11624	28	,	,	,
18637	11624	29	does	do	VBZ
18637	11624	30	not	not	RB
18637	11624	31	need	need	VB
18637	11624	32	two	two	CD
18637	11624	33	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	11624	34	to	to	TO
18637	11624	35	be	be	VB
18637	11624	36	transformed	transform	VBN
18637	11624	37	into	into	IN
18637	11624	38	an	an	DT
18637	11624	39	incriminating	incriminate	VBG
18637	11624	40	one	one	CD
18637	11624	41	.	.	.
18637	11625	1	"	"	``
18637	11625	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11625	3	737	737	CD
18637	11625	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11625	5	THE	the	DT
18637	11625	6	KAWAKITA	KAWAKITA	NNP
18637	11625	7	CASE	case	NN
18637	11625	8	The	the	DT
18637	11625	9	third	third	JJ
18637	11625	10	case	case	NN
18637	11625	11	referred	refer	VBD
18637	11625	12	to	to	IN
18637	11625	13	above	above	RB
18637	11625	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	11625	15	Kawakita	Kawakita	NNP
18637	11625	16	_	_	NNP
18637	11625	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	11625	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11625	19	United	United	NNP
18637	11625	20	States,[738	States,[738	NNP
18637	11625	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11625	22	which	which	WDT
18637	11625	23	was	be	VBD
18637	11625	24	decided	decide	VBN
18637	11625	25	on	on	IN
18637	11625	26	June	June	NNP
18637	11625	27	2	2	CD
18637	11625	28	,	,	,
18637	11625	29	1952	1952	CD
18637	11625	30	.	.	.
18637	11626	1	The	the	DT
18637	11626	2	facts	fact	NNS
18637	11626	3	are	be	VBP
18637	11626	4	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	11626	5	stated	state	VBN
18637	11626	6	in	in	IN
18637	11626	7	the	the	DT
18637	11626	8	following	following	JJ
18637	11626	9	headnote	headnote	NN
18637	11626	10	:	:	:
18637	11626	11	"	"	``
18637	11626	12	At	at	IN
18637	11626	13	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	11626	14	's	's	POS
18637	11626	15	trial	trial	NN
18637	11626	16	for	for	IN
18637	11626	17	treason	treason	NN
18637	11626	18	,	,	,
18637	11626	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11626	20	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	11626	21	that	that	IN
18637	11626	22	originally	originally	RB
18637	11626	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11626	24	was	be	VBD
18637	11626	25	a	a	DT
18637	11626	26	native	native	NN
18637	11626	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	11626	28	born	bear	VBN
18637	11626	29	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11626	30	of	of	IN
18637	11626	31	the	the	DT
18637	11626	32	United	United	NNP
18637	11626	33	States	States	NNP
18637	11626	34	and	and	CC
18637	11626	35	also	also	RB
18637	11626	36	a	a	DT
18637	11626	37	national	national	NN
18637	11626	38	of	of	IN
18637	11626	39	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	11626	40	by	by	IN
18637	11626	41	reason	reason	NN
18637	11626	42	of	of	IN
18637	11626	43	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	11626	44	parentage	parentage	NN
18637	11626	45	and	and	CC
18637	11626	46	law	law	NN
18637	11626	47	.	.	.
18637	11627	1	While	while	IN
18637	11627	2	a	a	DT
18637	11627	3	minor	minor	NN
18637	11627	4	,	,	,
18637	11627	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11627	6	took	take	VBD
18637	11627	7	the	the	DT
18637	11627	8	oath	oath	NN
18637	11627	9	of	of	IN
18637	11627	10	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	11627	11	to	to	IN
18637	11627	12	the	the	DT
18637	11627	13	United	United	NNP
18637	11627	14	States	States	NNP
18637	11627	15	;	;	:
18637	11627	16	went	go	VBD
18637	11627	17	to	to	IN
18637	11627	18	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	11627	19	for	for	IN
18637	11627	20	a	a	DT
18637	11627	21	visit	visit	NN
18637	11627	22	on	on	IN
18637	11627	23	an	an	DT
18637	11627	24	American	american	JJ
18637	11627	25	passport	passport	NN
18637	11627	26	;	;	:
18637	11627	27	and	and	CC
18637	11627	28	was	be	VBD
18637	11627	29	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	11627	30	by	by	IN
18637	11627	31	the	the	DT
18637	11627	32	outbreak	outbreak	NN
18637	11627	33	of	of	IN
18637	11627	34	war	war	NN
18637	11627	35	from	from	IN
18637	11627	36	returning	return	VBG
18637	11627	37	to	to	IN
18637	11627	38	this	this	DT
18637	11627	39	country	country	NN
18637	11627	40	.	.	.
18637	11628	1	During	during	IN
18637	11628	2	the	the	DT
18637	11628	3	war	war	NN
18637	11628	4	,	,	,
18637	11628	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11628	6	reached	reach	VBD
18637	11628	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11628	8	majority	majority	NN
18637	11628	9	in	in	IN
18637	11628	10	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	11628	11	;	;	:
18637	11628	12	changed	change	VBD
18637	11628	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11628	14	registration	registration	NN
18637	11628	15	from	from	IN
18637	11628	16	American	american	JJ
18637	11628	17	to	to	IN
18637	11628	18	Japanese	Japanese	NNP
18637	11628	19	;	;	:
18637	11628	20	showed	show	VBD
18637	11628	21	sympathy	sympathy	NN
18637	11628	22	with	with	IN
18637	11628	23	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	11628	24	and	and	CC
18637	11628	25	hostility	hostility	NN
18637	11628	26	to	to	IN
18637	11628	27	the	the	DT
18637	11628	28	United	United	NNP
18637	11628	29	States	States	NNP
18637	11628	30	;	;	,
18637	11628	31	served	serve	VBD
18637	11628	32	as	as	IN
18637	11628	33	a	a	DT
18637	11628	34	civilian	civilian	JJ
18637	11628	35	employee	employee	NN
18637	11628	36	of	of	IN
18637	11628	37	a	a	DT
18637	11628	38	private	private	JJ
18637	11628	39	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11628	40	producing	produce	VBG
18637	11628	41	war	war	NN
18637	11628	42	materials	material	NNS
18637	11628	43	for	for	IN
18637	11628	44	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	11628	45	;	;	:
18637	11628	46	and	and	CC
18637	11628	47	brutally	brutally	RB
18637	11628	48	abused	abused	JJ
18637	11628	49	American	american	JJ
18637	11628	50	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
18637	11628	51	of	of	IN
18637	11628	52	war	war	NN
18637	11628	53	who	who	WP
18637	11628	54	were	be	VBD
18637	11628	55	forced	force	VBN
18637	11628	56	to	to	TO
18637	11628	57	work	work	VB
18637	11628	58	there	there	RB
18637	11628	59	.	.	.
18637	11629	1	After	after	IN
18637	11629	2	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	11629	3	's	's	POS
18637	11629	4	surrender	surrender	NN
18637	11629	5	,	,	,
18637	11629	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11629	7	registered	register	VBD
18637	11629	8	as	as	IN
18637	11629	9	an	an	DT
18637	11629	10	American	american	JJ
18637	11629	11	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11629	12	;	;	:
18637	11629	13	swore	swear	VBD
18637	11629	14	that	that	IN
18637	11629	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11629	16	was	be	VBD
18637	11629	17	an	an	DT
18637	11629	18	American	american	JJ
18637	11629	19	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11629	20	and	and	CC
18637	11629	21	had	have	VBD
18637	11629	22	not	not	RB
18637	11629	23	done	do	VBN
18637	11629	24	various	various	JJ
18637	11629	25	acts	act	NNS
18637	11629	26	amounting	amount	VBG
18637	11629	27	to	to	IN
18637	11629	28	expatriation	expatriation	NN
18637	11629	29	;	;	,
18637	11629	30	and	and	CC
18637	11629	31	returned	return	VBD
18637	11629	32	to	to	IN
18637	11629	33	this	this	DT
18637	11629	34	country	country	NN
18637	11629	35	on	on	IN
18637	11629	36	an	an	DT
18637	11629	37	American	american	JJ
18637	11629	38	passport	passport	NN
18637	11629	39	.	.	.
18637	11629	40	"	"	''
18637	11630	1	The	the	DT
18637	11630	2	question	question	NN
18637	11630	3	whether	whether	IN
18637	11630	4	,	,	,
18637	11630	5	on	on	IN
18637	11630	6	this	this	DT
18637	11630	7	record	record	NN
18637	11630	8	Kawakita	Kawakita	NNP
18637	11630	9	had	have	VBD
18637	11630	10	intended	intend	VBN
18637	11630	11	to	to	TO
18637	11630	12	renounce	renounce	VB
18637	11630	13	American	american	JJ
18637	11630	14	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	11630	15	,	,	,
18637	11630	16	said	say	VBD
18637	11630	17	the	the	DT
18637	11630	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11630	19	,	,	,
18637	11630	20	in	in	IN
18637	11630	21	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	11630	22	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	11630	23	,	,	,
18637	11630	24	was	be	VBD
18637	11630	25	peculiarly	peculiarly	RB
18637	11630	26	one	one	CD
18637	11630	27	for	for	IN
18637	11630	28	the	the	DT
18637	11630	29	jury	jury	NN
18637	11630	30	and	and	CC
18637	11630	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11630	32	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	11630	33	that	that	IN
18637	11630	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11630	35	had	have	VBD
18637	11630	36	not	not	RB
18637	11630	37	so	so	RB
18637	11630	38	intended	intended	JJ
18637	11630	39	was	be	VBD
18637	11630	40	based	base	VBN
18637	11630	41	on	on	IN
18637	11630	42	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	11630	43	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	11630	44	.	.	.
18637	11631	1	An	an	DT
18637	11631	2	American	american	JJ
18637	11631	3	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	11631	4	,	,	,
18637	11631	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11631	6	continued	continue	VBD
18637	11631	7	,	,	,
18637	11631	8	owes	owe	VBZ
18637	11631	9	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	11631	10	to	to	IN
18637	11631	11	the	the	DT
18637	11631	12	United	United	NNP
18637	11631	13	States	States	NNP
18637	11631	14	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	11631	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11631	16	may	may	MD
18637	11631	17	reside	reside	VB
18637	11631	18	,	,	,
18637	11631	19	and	and	CC
18637	11631	20	dual	dual	JJ
18637	11631	21	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	11631	22	does	do	VBZ
18637	11631	23	not	not	RB
18637	11631	24	alter	alter	VB
18637	11631	25	the	the	DT
18637	11631	26	situation	situation	NN
18637	11631	27	.	.	.
18637	11632	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11632	2	739	739	CD
18637	11632	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11632	4	DOUBTFUL	DOUBTFUL	NNP
18637	11632	5	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	11632	6	OF	of	IN
18637	11632	7	THE	the	DT
18637	11632	8	LAW	law	NN
18637	11632	9	OF	of	IN
18637	11632	10	TREASON	treason	NN
18637	11632	11	TODAY	today	NN
18637	11632	12	The	the	DT
18637	11632	13	vacillation	vacillation	NN
18637	11632	14	of	of	IN
18637	11632	15	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11632	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11632	17	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11632	18	between	between	IN
18637	11632	19	the	the	DT
18637	11632	20	Bollman[740	Bollman[740	NNP
18637	11632	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11632	22	and	and	CC
18637	11632	23	Burr[741	Burr[741	NNS
18637	11632	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11632	25	cases	case	NNS
18637	11632	26	and	and	CC
18637	11632	27	the	the	DT
18637	11632	28	vacillation	vacillation	NN
18637	11632	29	of	of	IN
18637	11632	30	the	the	DT
18637	11632	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11632	32	in	in	IN
18637	11632	33	the	the	DT
18637	11632	34	Cramer[742	Cramer[742	NNP
18637	11632	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11632	36	and	and	CC
18637	11632	37	Haupt[743	Haupt[743	NNP
18637	11632	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11632	39	cases	case	NNS
18637	11632	40	leaves	leave	VBZ
18637	11632	41	the	the	DT
18637	11632	42	law	law	NN
18637	11632	43	of	of	IN
18637	11632	44	treason	treason	NN
18637	11632	45	in	in	IN
18637	11632	46	a	a	DT
18637	11632	47	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	11632	48	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
18637	11632	49	condition	condition	NN
18637	11632	50	.	.	.
18637	11633	1	The	the	DT
18637	11633	2	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	11633	3	created	create	VBN
18637	11633	4	by	by	IN
18637	11633	5	the	the	DT
18637	11633	6	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	11633	7	case	case	NN
18637	11633	8	have	have	VBP
18637	11633	9	been	be	VBN
18637	11633	10	obviated	obviate	VBN
18637	11633	11	to	to	IN
18637	11633	12	a	a	DT
18637	11633	13	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	11633	14	extent	extent	NN
18637	11633	15	through	through	IN
18637	11633	16	the	the	DT
18637	11633	17	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	11633	18	of	of	IN
18637	11633	19	acts	act	NNS
18637	11633	20	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	11633	21	treasonable	treasonable	JJ
18637	11633	22	in	in	IN
18637	11633	23	nature	nature	NN
18637	11633	24	under	under	IN
18637	11633	25	a	a	DT
18637	11633	26	different	different	JJ
18637	11633	27	label	label	NN
18637	11633	28	within	within	IN
18637	11633	29	a	a	DT
18637	11633	30	formula	formula	NN
18637	11633	31	provided	provide	VBN
18637	11633	32	by	by	IN
18637	11633	33	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11633	34	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11633	35	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	11633	36	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11633	37	in	in	IN
18637	11633	38	the	the	DT
18637	11633	39	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	11633	40	case	case	NN
18637	11633	41	.	.	.
18637	11634	1	The	the	DT
18637	11634	2	passage	passage	NN
18637	11634	3	reads	read	VBZ
18637	11634	4	:	:	:
18637	11634	5	"	"	``
18637	11634	6	Crimes	crime	NNS
18637	11634	7	so	so	RB
18637	11634	8	atrocious	atrocious	JJ
18637	11634	9	as	as	IN
18637	11634	10	those	those	DT
18637	11634	11	which	which	WDT
18637	11634	12	have	have	VBP
18637	11634	13	for	for	IN
18637	11634	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11634	15	object	object	NN
18637	11634	16	the	the	DT
18637	11634	17	subversion	subversion	NN
18637	11634	18	by	by	IN
18637	11634	19	violence	violence	NN
18637	11634	20	of	of	IN
18637	11634	21	those	those	DT
18637	11634	22	laws	law	NNS
18637	11634	23	and	and	CC
18637	11634	24	those	those	DT
18637	11634	25	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	11634	26	which	which	WDT
18637	11634	27	have	have	VBP
18637	11634	28	been	be	VBN
18637	11634	29	ordained	ordain	VBN
18637	11634	30	in	in	IN
18637	11634	31	order	order	NN
18637	11634	32	to	to	TO
18637	11634	33	secure	secure	VB
18637	11634	34	the	the	DT
18637	11634	35	peace	peace	NN
18637	11634	36	and	and	CC
18637	11634	37	happiness	happiness	NN
18637	11634	38	of	of	IN
18637	11634	39	society	society	NN
18637	11634	40	,	,	,
18637	11634	41	are	be	VBP
18637	11634	42	not	not	RB
18637	11634	43	to	to	TO
18637	11634	44	escape	escape	VB
18637	11634	45	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	11634	46	,	,	,
18637	11634	47	because	because	IN
18637	11634	48	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11634	49	have	have	VBP
18637	11634	50	not	not	RB
18637	11634	51	ripened	ripen	VBN
18637	11634	52	into	into	IN
18637	11634	53	treason	treason	NN
18637	11634	54	.	.	.
18637	11635	1	The	the	DT
18637	11635	2	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	11635	3	of	of	IN
18637	11635	4	the	the	DT
18637	11635	5	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	11635	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	11635	7	competent	competent	JJ
18637	11635	8	to	to	TO
18637	11635	9	provide	provide	VB
18637	11635	10	for	for	IN
18637	11635	11	the	the	DT
18637	11635	12	case	case	NN
18637	11635	13	;	;	,
18637	11635	14	and	and	CC
18637	11635	15	the	the	DT
18637	11635	16	framers	framer	NNS
18637	11635	17	of	of	IN
18637	11635	18	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11635	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11635	20	*	*	NFP
18637	11635	21	*	*	NFP
18637	11635	22	*	*	NFP
18637	11635	23	must	must	MD
18637	11635	24	have	have	VB
18637	11635	25	conceived	conceive	VBN
18637	11635	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11635	27	more	more	RBR
18637	11635	28	safe	safe	JJ
18637	11635	29	that	that	IN
18637	11635	30	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	11635	31	in	in	IN
18637	11635	32	such	such	JJ
18637	11635	33	cases	case	NNS
18637	11635	34	should	should	MD
18637	11635	35	be	be	VB
18637	11635	36	ordained	ordain	VBN
18637	11635	37	by	by	IN
18637	11635	38	general	general	JJ
18637	11635	39	laws	law	NNS
18637	11635	40	,	,	,
18637	11635	41	formed	form	VBN
18637	11635	42	upon	upon	IN
18637	11635	43	deliberation	deliberation	NN
18637	11635	44	,	,	,
18637	11635	45	under	under	IN
18637	11635	46	the	the	DT
18637	11635	47	influence	influence	NN
18637	11635	48	of	of	IN
18637	11635	49	no	no	DT
18637	11635	50	resentments	resentment	NNS
18637	11635	51	,	,	,
18637	11635	52	and	and	CC
18637	11635	53	without	without	IN
18637	11635	54	knowing	know	VBG
18637	11635	55	on	on	IN
18637	11635	56	whom	whom	WP
18637	11635	57	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11635	58	were	be	VBD
18637	11635	59	to	to	TO
18637	11635	60	operate	operate	VB
18637	11635	61	,	,	,
18637	11635	62	than	than	IN
18637	11635	63	that	that	IN
18637	11635	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11635	65	should	should	MD
18637	11635	66	be	be	VB
18637	11635	67	inflicted	inflict	VBN
18637	11635	68	under	under	IN
18637	11635	69	the	the	DT
18637	11635	70	influence	influence	NN
18637	11635	71	of	of	IN
18637	11635	72	those	those	DT
18637	11635	73	passions	passion	NNS
18637	11635	74	which	which	WDT
18637	11635	75	the	the	DT
18637	11635	76	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	11635	77	seldom	seldom	RB
18637	11635	78	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	11635	79	to	to	TO
18637	11635	80	excite	excite	VB
18637	11635	81	,	,	,
18637	11635	82	and	and	CC
18637	11635	83	which	which	WDT
18637	11635	84	a	a	DT
18637	11635	85	flexible	flexible	JJ
18637	11635	86	definition	definition	NN
18637	11635	87	of	of	IN
18637	11635	88	the	the	DT
18637	11635	89	crime	crime	NN
18637	11635	90	,	,	,
18637	11635	91	or	or	CC
18637	11635	92	a	a	DT
18637	11635	93	construction	construction	NN
18637	11635	94	which	which	WDT
18637	11635	95	would	would	MD
18637	11635	96	render	render	VB
18637	11635	97	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11635	98	flexible	flexible	JJ
18637	11635	99	,	,	,
18637	11635	100	might	may	MD
18637	11635	101	bring	bring	VB
18637	11635	102	into	into	IN
18637	11635	103	operation	operation	NN
18637	11635	104	.	.	.
18637	11636	1	"	"	``
18637	11636	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11636	3	744	744	CD
18637	11636	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11636	5	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	11636	6	2	2	CD
18637	11636	7	.	.	.
18637	11637	1	The	the	DT
18637	11637	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11637	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	11637	4	have	have	VB
18637	11637	5	Power	power	NN
18637	11637	6	to	to	TO
18637	11637	7	declare	declare	VB
18637	11637	8	the	the	DT
18637	11637	9	Punishment	Punishment	NNP
18637	11637	10	of	of	IN
18637	11637	11	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	11637	12	,	,	,
18637	11637	13	but	but	CC
18637	11637	14	no	no	DT
18637	11637	15	Attainder	Attainder	NNP
18637	11637	16	of	of	IN
18637	11637	17	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	11637	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	11637	19	work	work	VB
18637	11637	20	Corruption	Corruption	NNP
18637	11637	21	of	of	IN
18637	11637	22	Blood	Blood	NNP
18637	11637	23	,	,	,
18637	11637	24	or	or	CC
18637	11637	25	Forfeiture	Forfeiture	NNP
18637	11637	26	except	except	IN
18637	11637	27	during	during	IN
18637	11637	28	the	the	DT
18637	11637	29	Life	Life	NNP
18637	11637	30	of	of	IN
18637	11637	31	the	the	DT
18637	11637	32	Person	person	NN
18637	11637	33	attainted	attaint	VBN
18637	11637	34	.	.	.
18637	11638	1	CORRUPTION	corruption	NN
18637	11638	2	OF	of	IN
18637	11638	3	BLOOD	blood	NN
18637	11638	4	AND	and	CC
18637	11638	5	FORFEITURE	forfeiture	NN
18637	11638	6	The	the	DT
18637	11638	7	Confiscation	Confiscation	NNP
18637	11638	8	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11638	9	of	of	IN
18637	11638	10	1862[745	1862[745	CD
18637	11638	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11638	12	"	"	``
18637	11638	13	to	to	IN
18637	11638	14	Suppress	Suppress	NNP
18637	11638	15	Insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	11638	16	;	;	:
18637	11638	17	to	to	TO
18637	11638	18	Punish	punish	VB
18637	11638	19	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	11638	20	and	and	CC
18637	11638	21	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
18637	11638	22	;	;	:
18637	11638	23	to	to	TO
18637	11638	24	Seize	seize	VB
18637	11638	25	and	and	CC
18637	11638	26	Confiscate	confiscate	VB
18637	11638	27	the	the	DT
18637	11638	28	Property	Property	NNP
18637	11638	29	of	of	IN
18637	11638	30	Rebels	Rebels	NNPS
18637	11638	31	raised	raise	VBD
18637	11638	32	issues	issue	NNS
18637	11638	33	under	under	IN
18637	11638	34	article	article	NN
18637	11638	35	III	iii	CD
18637	11638	36	,	,	,
18637	11638	37	section	section	NN
18637	11638	38	3	3	CD
18637	11638	39	,	,	,
18637	11638	40	clause	clause	NN
18637	11638	41	2	2	CD
18637	11638	42	.	.	.
18637	11638	43	"	"	''
18637	11639	1	Because	because	IN
18637	11639	2	of	of	IN
18637	11639	3	the	the	DT
18637	11639	4	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11639	5	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	11639	6	of	of	IN
18637	11639	7	the	the	DT
18637	11639	8	President	President	NNP
18637	11639	9	the	the	DT
18637	11639	10	act	act	NN
18637	11639	11	was	be	VBD
18637	11639	12	accompanied	accompany	VBN
18637	11639	13	by	by	IN
18637	11639	14	an	an	DT
18637	11639	15	explanatory	explanatory	JJ
18637	11639	16	joint	joint	JJ
18637	11639	17	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	11639	18	which	which	WDT
18637	11639	19	stipulated	stipulate	VBD
18637	11639	20	that	that	IN
18637	11639	21	only	only	RB
18637	11639	22	a	a	DT
18637	11639	23	life	life	NN
18637	11639	24	estate	estate	NN
18637	11639	25	terminating	terminate	VBG
18637	11639	26	with	with	IN
18637	11639	27	the	the	DT
18637	11639	28	death	death	NN
18637	11639	29	of	of	IN
18637	11639	30	the	the	DT
18637	11639	31	offender	offender	NN
18637	11639	32	could	could	MD
18637	11639	33	be	be	VB
18637	11639	34	sold	sell	VBN
18637	11639	35	and	and	CC
18637	11639	36	that	that	IN
18637	11639	37	at	at	IN
18637	11639	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11639	39	death	death	NN
18637	11639	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11639	41	children	child	NNS
18637	11639	42	could	could	MD
18637	11639	43	take	take	VB
18637	11639	44	the	the	DT
18637	11639	45	fee	fee	NN
18637	11639	46	simple	simple	JJ
18637	11639	47	by	by	IN
18637	11639	48	descent	descent	NN
18637	11639	49	as	as	IN
18637	11639	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11639	51	heirs	heir	NNS
18637	11639	52	without	without	IN
18637	11639	53	deriving	derive	VBG
18637	11639	54	any	any	DT
18637	11639	55	title	title	NN
18637	11639	56	from	from	IN
18637	11639	57	the	the	DT
18637	11639	58	United	United	NNP
18637	11639	59	States	States	NNP
18637	11639	60	.	.	.
18637	11640	1	In	in	IN
18637	11640	2	applying	apply	VBG
18637	11640	3	this	this	DT
18637	11640	4	act	act	NN
18637	11640	5	,	,	,
18637	11640	6	passed	pass	VBN
18637	11640	7	in	in	IN
18637	11640	8	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	11640	9	of	of	IN
18637	11640	10	the	the	DT
18637	11640	11	war	war	NN
18637	11640	12	power	power	NN
18637	11640	13	and	and	CC
18637	11640	14	not	not	RB
18637	11640	15	the	the	DT
18637	11640	16	power	power	NN
18637	11640	17	to	to	TO
18637	11640	18	punish	punish	VB
18637	11640	19	treason,[746	treason,[746	NNP
18637	11640	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11640	21	the	the	DT
18637	11640	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11640	23	in	in	IN
18637	11640	24	one	one	CD
18637	11640	25	case[747	case[747	NN
18637	11640	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11640	27	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	11640	28	with	with	IN
18637	11640	29	approval	approval	NN
18637	11640	30	the	the	DT
18637	11640	31	English	english	JJ
18637	11640	32	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	11640	33	between	between	IN
18637	11640	34	a	a	DT
18637	11640	35	disability	disability	NN
18637	11640	36	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	11640	37	and	and	CC
18637	11640	38	perpetual	perpetual	JJ
18637	11640	39	and	and	CC
18637	11640	40	one	one	CD
18637	11640	41	personal	personal	JJ
18637	11640	42	or	or	CC
18637	11640	43	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	11640	44	.	.	.
18637	11641	1	Corruption	corruption	NN
18637	11641	2	of	of	IN
18637	11641	3	blood	blood	NN
18637	11641	4	as	as	IN
18637	11641	5	a	a	DT
18637	11641	6	result	result	NN
18637	11641	7	of	of	IN
18637	11641	8	attainder	attainder	NN
18637	11641	9	of	of	IN
18637	11641	10	treason	treason	NN
18637	11641	11	was	be	VBD
18637	11641	12	cited	cite	VBN
18637	11641	13	as	as	IN
18637	11641	14	an	an	DT
18637	11641	15	example	example	NN
18637	11641	16	of	of	IN
18637	11641	17	the	the	DT
18637	11641	18	former	former	JJ
18637	11641	19	and	and	CC
18637	11641	20	was	be	VBD
18637	11641	21	defined	define	VBN
18637	11641	22	as	as	IN
18637	11641	23	the	the	DT
18637	11641	24	disability	disability	NN
18637	11641	25	of	of	IN
18637	11641	26	any	any	DT
18637	11641	27	of	of	IN
18637	11641	28	the	the	DT
18637	11641	29	posterity	posterity	NN
18637	11641	30	of	of	IN
18637	11641	31	the	the	DT
18637	11641	32	attainted	attaint	VBN
18637	11641	33	person	person	NN
18637	11641	34	"	"	''
18637	11641	35	to	to	TO
18637	11641	36	claim	claim	VB
18637	11641	37	any	any	DT
18637	11641	38	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	11641	39	in	in	IN
18637	11641	40	fee	fee	NN
18637	11641	41	simple	simple	NN
18637	11641	42	,	,	,
18637	11641	43	either	either	RB
18637	11641	44	as	as	IN
18637	11641	45	heir	heir	NN
18637	11641	46	to	to	IN
18637	11641	47	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11641	48	,	,	,
18637	11641	49	or	or	CC
18637	11641	50	to	to	IN
18637	11641	51	any	any	DT
18637	11641	52	ancestor	ancestor	NN
18637	11641	53	above	above	IN
18637	11641	54	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11641	55	.	.	.
18637	11642	1	"	"	``
18637	11642	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11642	3	748	748	CD
18637	11642	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11642	5	Notes	note	NNS
18637	11642	6	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11642	7	1	1	CD
18637	11642	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11642	9	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	11642	10	,	,	,
18637	11642	11	On	on	IN
18637	11642	12	the	the	DT
18637	11642	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11642	14	,	,	,
18637	11642	15	314	314	CD
18637	11642	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11642	17	New	New	NNP
18637	11642	18	York	York	NNP
18637	11642	19	,	,	,
18637	11642	20	1891	1891	CD
18637	11642	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11642	22	.	.	.
18637	11643	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11643	2	2	2	CD
18637	11643	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11643	4	219	219	CD
18637	11643	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11643	6	346	346	CD
18637	11643	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11643	8	1911	1911	CD
18637	11643	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11643	10	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11643	11	3	3	CD
18637	11643	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11643	13	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11643	14	.	.	.
18637	11644	1	361	361	CD
18637	11644	2	.	.	.
18637	11645	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11645	2	4	4	CD
18637	11645	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11645	4	United	United	NNP
18637	11645	5	States	States	NNP
18637	11645	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11645	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	11645	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11645	9	Arredondo	Arredondo	NNP
18637	11645	10	,	,	,
18637	11645	11	6	6	CD
18637	11645	12	Pet	pet	NN
18637	11645	13	.	.	.
18637	11646	1	691	691	CD
18637	11646	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11646	3	1832	1832	CD
18637	11646	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11646	5	.	.	.
18637	11647	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11647	2	5	5	CD
18637	11647	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11647	4	General	General	NNP
18637	11647	5	Investment	Investment	NNP
18637	11647	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11647	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11647	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11647	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11647	10	New	New	NNP
18637	11647	11	York	York	NNP
18637	11647	12	Central	Central	NNP
18637	11647	13	R.	R.	NNP
18637	11647	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11647	15	,	,	,
18637	11647	16	271	271	CD
18637	11647	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11647	18	228	228	CD
18637	11647	19	,	,	,
18637	11647	20	230	230	CD
18637	11647	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11647	22	1926	1926	CD
18637	11647	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11647	24	.	.	.
18637	11648	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11648	2	6	6	CD
18637	11648	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11648	4	For	for	IN
18637	11648	5	distinctions	distinction	NNS
18637	11648	6	between	between	IN
18637	11648	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11648	8	power	power	NN
18637	11648	9	and	and	CC
18637	11648	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11648	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11648	12	see	see	NN
18637	11648	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11648	14	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	11648	15	_	_	NNP
18637	11648	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	11648	17	_	_	NNP
18637	11648	18	United	United	NNP
18637	11648	19	States	States	NNP
18637	11648	20	,	,	,
18637	11648	21	289	289	CD
18637	11648	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11648	23	553	553	CD
18637	11648	24	,	,	,
18637	11648	25	566	566	CD
18637	11648	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11648	27	1933	1933	CD
18637	11648	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11648	29	;	;	:
18637	11648	30	and	and	CC
18637	11648	31	the	the	DT
18637	11648	32	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11648	33	of	of	IN
18637	11648	34	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11648	35	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	11648	36	in	in	IN
18637	11648	37	Yakus	Yakus	NNP
18637	11648	38	_	_	NNP
18637	11648	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	11648	40	_	_	NNP
18637	11648	41	United	United	NNP
18637	11648	42	States	States	NNP
18637	11648	43	,	,	,
18637	11648	44	321	321	CD
18637	11648	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11648	46	414	414	CD
18637	11648	47	,	,	,
18637	11648	48	467	467	CD
18637	11648	49	-	-	SYM
18637	11648	50	468	468	CD
18637	11648	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11648	52	1944	1944	CD
18637	11648	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11648	54	.	.	.
18637	11649	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11649	2	7	7	CD
18637	11649	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11649	4	Michaelson	Michaelson	NNP
18637	11649	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11649	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11649	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11649	8	United	United	NNP
18637	11649	9	States	States	NNP
18637	11649	10	,	,	,
18637	11649	11	266	266	CD
18637	11649	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11649	13	42	42	CD
18637	11649	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11649	15	1924	1924	CD
18637	11649	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11649	17	.	.	.
18637	11650	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11650	2	8	8	CD
18637	11650	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11650	4	McIntire	McIntire	NNP
18637	11650	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11650	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11650	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11650	8	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	11650	9	,	,	,
18637	11650	10	7	7	CD
18637	11650	11	Cr	cr	NN
18637	11650	12	.	.	.
18637	11651	1	504	504	CD
18637	11651	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11651	3	1813	1813	CD
18637	11651	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11651	5	;	;	:
18637	11651	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11651	7	parte	parte	NN
18637	11651	8	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	11651	9	,	,	,
18637	11651	10	4	4	CD
18637	11651	11	Cr	cr	NN
18637	11651	12	.	.	.
18637	11652	1	75	75	CD
18637	11652	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11652	3	1807	1807	CD
18637	11652	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11652	5	.	.	.
18637	11653	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11653	2	9	9	CD
18637	11653	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11653	4	Wayman	Wayman	NNP
18637	11653	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11653	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11653	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11653	8	Southard	Southard	NNP
18637	11653	9	,	,	,
18637	11653	10	10	10	CD
18637	11653	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	11653	12	.	.	.
18637	11654	1	1	1	CD
18637	11654	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11654	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	11654	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11654	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11654	6	10	10	CD
18637	11654	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11654	8	Gumbel	Gumbel	NNP
18637	11654	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11654	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	11654	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11654	12	Pitkin	Pitkin	NNP
18637	11654	13	,	,	,
18637	11654	14	124	124	CD
18637	11654	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11654	16	131	131	CD
18637	11654	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11654	18	1888	1888	CD
18637	11654	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11654	20	.	.	.
18637	11655	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11655	2	11	11	CD
18637	11655	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11655	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11655	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	11655	6	Peterson	Peterson	NNP
18637	11655	7	,	,	,
18637	11655	8	253	253	CD
18637	11655	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11655	10	300	300	CD
18637	11655	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11655	12	1920	1920	CD
18637	11655	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11655	14	.	.	.
18637	11656	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11656	2	12	12	CD
18637	11656	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11656	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11656	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	11656	6	Garland	Garland	NNP
18637	11656	7	,	,	,
18637	11656	8	4	4	CD
18637	11656	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	11656	10	.	.	.
18637	11657	1	333	333	CD
18637	11657	2	,	,	,
18637	11657	3	378	378	CD
18637	11657	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11657	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	11657	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11657	7	.	.	.
18637	11658	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11658	2	13	13	CD
18637	11658	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11658	4	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
18637	11658	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11658	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11658	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11658	8	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	11658	9	,	,	,
18637	11658	10	2	2	CD
18637	11658	11	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	11658	12	.	.	.
18637	11659	1	419	419	CD
18637	11659	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11659	3	1793	1793	CD
18637	11659	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11659	5	;	;	:
18637	11659	6	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	11659	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11659	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11659	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11659	10	Dennison	Dennison	NNP
18637	11659	11	,	,	,
18637	11659	12	24	24	CD
18637	11659	13	How	how	WRB
18637	11659	14	.	.	.
18637	11660	1	66	66	CD
18637	11660	2	,	,	,
18637	11660	3	98	98	CD
18637	11660	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11660	5	1861	1861	CD
18637	11660	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11660	7	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	11660	8	a	a	DT
18637	11660	9	review	review	NN
18637	11660	10	of	of	IN
18637	11660	11	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	11660	12	on	on	IN
18637	11660	13	this	this	DT
18637	11660	14	point	point	NN
18637	11660	15	.	.	.
18637	11661	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11661	2	14	14	CD
18637	11661	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11661	4	Mayor	Mayor	NNP
18637	11661	5	of	of	IN
18637	11661	6	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	11661	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11661	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11661	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11661	10	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	11661	11	,	,	,
18637	11661	12	6	6	CD
18637	11661	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	11661	14	.	.	.
18637	11662	1	247	247	CD
18637	11662	2	,	,	,
18637	11662	3	252	252	CD
18637	11662	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11662	5	1868	1868	CD
18637	11662	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11662	7	;	;	:
18637	11662	8	Cary	Cary	NNP
18637	11662	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11662	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	11662	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11662	12	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	11662	13	,	,	,
18637	11662	14	3	3	CD
18637	11662	15	How	how	WRB
18637	11662	16	.	.	.
18637	11663	1	236	236	CD
18637	11663	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11663	3	1845	1845	CD
18637	11663	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11663	5	;	;	:
18637	11663	6	Shelden	Shelden	NNP
18637	11663	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11663	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11663	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11663	10	Sill	Sill	NNP
18637	11663	11	,	,	,
18637	11663	12	8	8	CD
18637	11663	13	How	how	WRB
18637	11663	14	.	.	.
18637	11664	1	441	441	CD
18637	11664	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11664	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	11664	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11664	5	;	;	:
18637	11664	6	Kline	Kline	NNP
18637	11664	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11664	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11664	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11664	10	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	11664	11	Construction	Construction	NNP
18637	11664	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11664	13	,	,	,
18637	11664	14	260	260	CD
18637	11664	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11664	16	226	226	CD
18637	11664	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11664	18	1922	1922	CD
18637	11664	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11664	20	.	.	.
18637	11665	1	_	_	NNP
18637	11665	2	See	See	NNP
18637	11665	3	also	also	RB
18637	11665	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11665	5	the	the	DT
18637	11665	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	11665	7	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	11665	8	under	under	IN
18637	11665	9	the	the	DT
18637	11665	10	heading	heading	NN
18637	11665	11	of	of	IN
18637	11665	12	the	the	DT
18637	11665	13	Power	Power	NNP
18637	11665	14	of	of	IN
18637	11665	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11665	16	to	to	TO
18637	11665	17	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	11665	18	the	the	DT
18637	11665	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11665	20	of	of	IN
18637	11665	21	the	the	DT
18637	11665	22	lower	low	JJR
18637	11665	23	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11665	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	11665	25	,	,	,
18637	11665	26	_	_	NNP
18637	11665	27	infra	infra	NNP
18637	11665	28	_	_	NNP
18637	11665	29	,	,	,
18637	11665	30	p.	p.	NN
18637	11665	31	616	616	CD
18637	11665	32	.	.	.
18637	11666	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11666	2	15	15	CD
18637	11666	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11666	4	2	2	CD
18637	11666	5	Dall	dall	NN
18637	11666	6	.	.	.
18637	11667	1	409	409	CD
18637	11667	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11667	3	1792	1792	CD
18637	11667	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11667	5	.	.	.
18637	11668	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11668	2	16	16	CD
18637	11668	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11668	4	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11668	5	initial	initial	JJ
18637	11668	6	effort	effort	NN
18637	11668	7	was	be	VBD
18637	11668	8	in	in	IN
18637	11668	9	United	United	NNP
18637	11668	10	States	States	NNP
18637	11668	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11668	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	11668	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11668	14	Ferreira	Ferreira	NNP
18637	11668	15	,	,	,
18637	11668	16	13	13	CD
18637	11668	17	How	how	WRB
18637	11668	18	.	.	.
18637	11669	1	40	40	CD
18637	11669	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11669	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	11669	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11669	5	.	.	.
18637	11670	1	This	this	DT
18637	11670	2	case	case	NN
18637	11670	3	involved	involve	VBD
18637	11670	4	the	the	DT
18637	11670	5	validity	validity	NN
18637	11670	6	of	of	IN
18637	11670	7	an	an	DT
18637	11670	8	act	act	NN
18637	11670	9	of	of	IN
18637	11670	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11670	11	directing	direct	VBG
18637	11670	12	the	the	DT
18637	11670	13	judge	judge	NN
18637	11670	14	of	of	IN
18637	11670	15	the	the	DT
18637	11670	16	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	11670	17	court	court	NN
18637	11670	18	of	of	IN
18637	11670	19	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	11670	20	to	to	TO
18637	11670	21	examine	examine	VB
18637	11670	22	and	and	CC
18637	11670	23	adjudge	adjudge	VB
18637	11670	24	claims	claim	NNS
18637	11670	25	of	of	IN
18637	11670	26	Spanish	spanish	JJ
18637	11670	27	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	11670	28	against	against	IN
18637	11670	29	the	the	DT
18637	11670	30	United	United	NNP
18637	11670	31	States	States	NNP
18637	11670	32	and	and	CC
18637	11670	33	to	to	TO
18637	11670	34	report	report	VB
18637	11670	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11670	36	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11670	37	with	with	IN
18637	11670	38	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	11670	39	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	11670	40	to	to	IN
18637	11670	41	the	the	DT
18637	11670	42	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	11670	43	of	of	IN
18637	11670	44	the	the	DT
18637	11670	45	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	11670	46	who	who	WP
18637	11670	47	in	in	IN
18637	11670	48	turn	turn	NN
18637	11670	49	was	be	VBD
18637	11670	50	to	to	TO
18637	11670	51	pay	pay	VB
18637	11670	52	the	the	DT
18637	11670	53	award	award	NN
18637	11670	54	to	to	IN
18637	11670	55	the	the	DT
18637	11670	56	claimant	claimant	NN
18637	11670	57	if	if	IN
18637	11670	58	satisfied	satisfy	VBD
18637	11670	59	that	that	IN
18637	11670	60	the	the	DT
18637	11670	61	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	11670	62	were	be	VBD
18637	11670	63	just	just	RB
18637	11670	64	and	and	CC
18637	11670	65	within	within	IN
18637	11670	66	the	the	DT
18637	11670	67	terms	term	NNS
18637	11670	68	of	of	IN
18637	11670	69	the	the	DT
18637	11670	70	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	11670	71	of	of	IN
18637	11670	72	cession	cession	NN
18637	11670	73	.	.	.
18637	11671	1	After	after	IN
18637	11671	2	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	11671	3	became	become	VBD
18637	11671	4	a	a	DT
18637	11671	5	State	state	NN
18637	11671	6	and	and	CC
18637	11671	7	the	the	DT
18637	11671	8	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	11671	9	court	court	NN
18637	11671	10	a	a	DT
18637	11671	11	district	district	NN
18637	11671	12	court	court	NN
18637	11671	13	of	of	IN
18637	11671	14	the	the	DT
18637	11671	15	United	United	NNP
18637	11671	16	States	States	NNP
18637	11671	17	,	,	,
18637	11671	18	the	the	DT
18637	11671	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11671	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11671	21	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	11671	22	to	to	TO
18637	11671	23	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	11671	24	an	an	DT
18637	11671	25	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	11671	26	under	under	IN
18637	11671	27	the	the	DT
18637	11671	28	statute	statute	NN
18637	11671	29	for	for	IN
18637	11671	30	want	want	NN
18637	11671	31	of	of	IN
18637	11671	32	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11671	33	to	to	TO
18637	11671	34	review	review	VB
18637	11671	35	nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	11671	36	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	11671	37	.	.	.
18637	11672	1	The	the	DT
18637	11672	2	duties	duty	NNS
18637	11672	3	required	require	VBN
18637	11672	4	by	by	IN
18637	11672	5	the	the	DT
18637	11672	6	act	act	NN
18637	11672	7	,	,	,
18637	11672	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11672	9	was	be	VBD
18637	11672	10	said	say	VBN
18637	11672	11	"	"	``
18637	11672	12	are	be	VBP
18637	11672	13	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	11672	14	alien	alien	JJ
18637	11672	15	to	to	IN
18637	11672	16	the	the	DT
18637	11672	17	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	11672	18	functions	function	NNS
18637	11672	19	of	of	IN
18637	11672	20	a	a	DT
18637	11672	21	judge	judge	NN
18637	11672	22	or	or	CC
18637	11672	23	court	court	NN
18637	11672	24	of	of	IN
18637	11672	25	justice	justice	NN
18637	11672	26	,	,	,
18637	11672	27	and	and	CC
18637	11672	28	have	have	VBP
18637	11672	29	no	no	DT
18637	11672	30	analogy	analogy	NN
18637	11672	31	to	to	IN
18637	11672	32	the	the	DT
18637	11672	33	general	general	JJ
18637	11672	34	or	or	CC
18637	11672	35	special	special	JJ
18637	11672	36	powers	power	NNS
18637	11672	37	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	11672	38	and	and	CC
18637	11672	39	legally	legally	RB
18637	11672	40	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	11672	41	on	on	IN
18637	11672	42	judges	judge	NNS
18637	11672	43	or	or	CC
18637	11672	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	11672	45	to	to	TO
18637	11672	46	secure	secure	VB
18637	11672	47	the	the	DT
18637	11672	48	due	due	JJ
18637	11672	49	administration	administration	NN
18637	11672	50	of	of	IN
18637	11672	51	the	the	DT
18637	11672	52	laws	law	NNS
18637	11672	53	.	.	.
18637	11672	54	"	"	''
18637	11673	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	11673	2	.	.	.
18637	11674	1	51	51	CD
18637	11674	2	.	.	.
18637	11675	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11675	2	17	17	CD
18637	11675	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11675	4	2	2	CD
18637	11675	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	11675	6	.	.	.
18637	11676	1	561	561	CD
18637	11676	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11676	3	1865	1865	CD
18637	11676	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11676	5	.	.	.
18637	11677	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11677	2	18	18	CD
18637	11677	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11677	4	117	117	CD
18637	11677	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11677	6	697	697	CD
18637	11677	7	Appx	Appx	NNP
18637	11677	8	.	.	.
18637	11678	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11678	2	1864	1864	CD
18637	11678	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11678	4	.	.	.
18637	11679	1	_	_	NNP
18637	11679	2	See	See	NNP
18637	11679	3	also	also	RB
18637	11679	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11679	5	De	De	NNP
18637	11679	6	Groot	Groot	NNP
18637	11679	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11679	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11679	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11679	10	United	United	NNP
18637	11679	11	States	States	NNP
18637	11679	12	,	,	,
18637	11679	13	5	5	CD
18637	11679	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	11679	15	.	.	.
18637	11680	1	419	419	CD
18637	11680	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11680	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	11680	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11680	5	and	and	CC
18637	11680	6	United	United	NNP
18637	11680	7	States	States	NNP
18637	11680	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11680	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	11680	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11680	11	Klein	Klein	NNP
18637	11680	12	,	,	,
18637	11680	13	13	13	CD
18637	11680	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	11680	15	.	.	.
18637	11681	1	128	128	CD
18637	11681	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11681	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	11681	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11681	5	,	,	,
18637	11681	6	which	which	WDT
18637	11681	7	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	11681	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11681	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11681	10	revision	revision	NN
18637	11681	11	after	after	IN
18637	11681	12	the	the	DT
18637	11681	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11681	14	of	of	IN
18637	11681	15	the	the	DT
18637	11681	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11681	17	of	of	IN
18637	11681	18	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	11681	19	had	have	VBD
18637	11681	20	been	be	VBN
18637	11681	21	made	make	VBN
18637	11681	22	final	final	JJ
18637	11681	23	.	.	.
18637	11682	1	The	the	DT
18637	11682	2	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	11682	3	decision	decision	NN
18637	11682	4	had	have	VBD
18637	11682	5	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	11682	6	that	that	IN
18637	11682	7	the	the	DT
18637	11682	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11682	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11682	10	could	could	MD
18637	11682	11	not	not	RB
18637	11682	12	review	review	VB
18637	11682	13	the	the	DT
18637	11682	14	decision	decision	NN
18637	11682	15	of	of	IN
18637	11682	16	any	any	DT
18637	11682	17	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	11682	18	court	court	NN
18637	11682	19	.	.	.
18637	11683	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11683	2	19	19	CD
18637	11683	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11683	4	117	117	CD
18637	11683	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11683	6	697	697	CD
18637	11683	7	,	,	,
18637	11683	8	703	703	CD
18637	11683	9	.	.	.
18637	11684	1	This	this	DT
18637	11684	2	last	last	JJ
18637	11684	3	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	11684	4	was	be	VBD
18637	11684	5	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	11684	6	to	to	IN
18637	11684	7	the	the	DT
18637	11684	8	extent	extent	NN
18637	11684	9	that	that	IN
18637	11684	10	for	for	IN
18637	11684	11	many	many	JJ
18637	11684	12	years	year	NNS
18637	11684	13	an	an	DT
18637	11684	14	award	award	NN
18637	11684	15	of	of	IN
18637	11684	16	execution	execution	NN
18637	11684	17	as	as	IN
18637	11684	18	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	11684	19	from	from	IN
18637	11684	20	finality	finality	NN
18637	11684	21	of	of	IN
18637	11684	22	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11684	23	came	come	VBD
18637	11684	24	to	to	TO
18637	11684	25	be	be	VB
18637	11684	26	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	11684	27	as	as	IN
18637	11684	28	an	an	DT
18637	11684	29	essential	essential	JJ
18637	11684	30	attribute	attribute	NN
18637	11684	31	of	of	IN
18637	11684	32	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11684	33	power	power	NN
18637	11684	34	.	.	.
18637	11685	1	_	_	NNP
18637	11685	2	See	See	NNP
18637	11685	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11685	4	In	In	NNP
18637	11685	5	re	re	NN
18637	11685	6	Sanborn	Sanborn	NNP
18637	11685	7	,	,	,
18637	11685	8	148	148	CD
18637	11685	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11685	10	222	222	CD
18637	11685	11	,	,	,
18637	11685	12	226	226	CD
18637	11685	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11685	14	1893	1893	CD
18637	11685	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11685	16	;	;	:
18637	11685	17	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	11685	18	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	11685	19	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	11685	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11685	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	11685	22	_	_	NNP
18637	11685	23	Brimson	Brimson	NNP
18637	11685	24	,	,	,
18637	11685	25	154	154	CD
18637	11685	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11685	27	447	447	CD
18637	11685	28	,	,	,
18637	11685	29	483	483	CD
18637	11685	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11685	31	1894	1894	CD
18637	11685	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11685	33	;	;	:
18637	11685	34	La	La	NNP
18637	11685	35	Abra	Abra	NNP
18637	11685	36	Silver	Silver	NNP
18637	11685	37	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	11685	38	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11685	39	_	_	NNP
18637	11685	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	11685	41	_	_	NNP
18637	11685	42	United	United	NNP
18637	11685	43	States	States	NNP
18637	11685	44	,	,	,
18637	11685	45	175	175	CD
18637	11685	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11685	47	423	423	CD
18637	11685	48	,	,	,
18637	11685	49	457	457	CD
18637	11685	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11685	51	1899	1899	CD
18637	11685	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11685	53	;	;	:
18637	11685	54	Frasch	Frasch	NNP
18637	11685	55	_	_	NNP
18637	11685	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	11685	57	_	_	NNP
18637	11685	58	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	11685	59	,	,	,
18637	11685	60	211	211	CD
18637	11685	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11685	62	1	1	CD
18637	11685	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11685	64	1908	1908	CD
18637	11685	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11685	66	;	;	:
18637	11685	67	Muskrat	Muskrat	NNP
18637	11685	68	_	_	NNP
18637	11685	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	11685	70	_	_	NNP
18637	11685	71	United	United	NNP
18637	11685	72	States	States	NNP
18637	11685	73	,	,	,
18637	11685	74	219	219	CD
18637	11685	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11685	76	346	346	CD
18637	11685	77	,	,	,
18637	11685	78	355	355	CD
18637	11685	79	,	,	,
18637	11685	80	361	361	CD
18637	11685	81	-	-	HYPH
18637	11685	82	362	362	CD
18637	11685	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11685	84	1911	1911	CD
18637	11685	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11685	86	,	,	,
18637	11685	87	and	and	CC
18637	11685	88	Postum	Postum	NNP
18637	11685	89	Cereal	Cereal	NNP
18637	11685	90	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11685	91	_	_	NNP
18637	11685	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	11685	93	_	_	NNP
18637	11685	94	California	California	NNP
18637	11685	95	Fig	Fig	NNP
18637	11685	96	Nut	Nut	NNP
18637	11685	97	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11685	98	,	,	,
18637	11685	99	272	272	CD
18637	11685	100	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11685	101	693	693	CD
18637	11685	102	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11685	103	1927	1927	CD
18637	11685	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11685	105	.	.	.
18637	11686	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11686	2	20	20	CD
18637	11686	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11686	4	273	273	CD
18637	11686	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11686	6	70	70	CD
18637	11686	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11686	8	1927	1927	CD
18637	11686	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11686	10	.	.	.
18637	11687	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11687	2	21	21	CD
18637	11687	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11687	4	276	276	CD
18637	11687	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11687	6	71	71	CD
18637	11687	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11687	8	1928	1928	CD
18637	11687	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11687	10	.	.	.
18637	11688	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11688	2	22	22	CD
18637	11688	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11688	4	274	274	CD
18637	11688	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11688	6	123	123	CD
18637	11688	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11688	8	1927	1927	CD
18637	11688	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11688	10	.	.	.
18637	11689	1	This	this	DT
18637	11689	2	case	case	NN
18637	11689	3	also	also	RB
18637	11689	4	clarified	clarify	VBD
18637	11689	5	any	any	DT
18637	11689	6	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	11689	7	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	11689	8	a	a	DT
18637	11689	9	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11689	10	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	11689	11	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11689	12	act	act	NN
18637	11689	13	which	which	WDT
18637	11689	14	was	be	VBD
18637	11689	15	passed	pass	VBN
18637	11689	16	in	in	IN
18637	11689	17	1934	1934	CD
18637	11689	18	and	and	CC
18637	11689	19	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	11689	20	in	in	IN
18637	11689	21	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	11689	22	Life	Life	NNP
18637	11689	23	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	11689	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11689	25	_	_	NNP
18637	11689	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	11689	27	_	_	NNP
18637	11689	28	Haworth	Haworth	NNP
18637	11689	29	,	,	,
18637	11689	30	300	300	CD
18637	11689	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11689	32	227	227	CD
18637	11689	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11689	34	1937	1937	CD
18637	11689	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11689	36	.	.	.
18637	11690	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11690	2	23	23	CD
18637	11690	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11690	4	288	288	CD
18637	11690	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11690	6	249	249	CD
18637	11690	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11690	8	1933	1933	CD
18637	11690	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11690	10	.	.	.
18637	11691	1	The	the	DT
18637	11691	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	11691	3	in	in	IN
18637	11691	4	the	the	DT
18637	11691	5	Swope	Swope	NNP
18637	11691	6	and	and	CC
18637	11691	7	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	11691	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	11691	9	removed	remove	VBD
18637	11691	10	all	all	DT
18637	11691	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11691	12	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	11691	13	which	which	WDT
18637	11691	14	had	have	VBD
18637	11691	15	previously	previously	RB
18637	11691	16	shrouded	shroud	VBN
18637	11691	17	a	a	DT
18637	11691	18	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	11691	19	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11691	20	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	11691	21	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	11691	22	act	act	NN
18637	11691	23	which	which	WDT
18637	11691	24	was	be	VBD
18637	11691	25	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	11691	26	in	in	IN
18637	11691	27	1934	1934	CD
18637	11691	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11691	29	48	48	CD
18637	11691	30	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11691	31	.	.	.
18637	11692	1	955	955	CD
18637	11692	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11692	3	and	and	CC
18637	11692	4	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	11692	5	in	in	IN
18637	11692	6	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	11692	7	Life	Life	NNP
18637	11692	8	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	11692	9	.	.	.
18637	11693	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11693	2	_	_	NNP
18637	11693	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	11693	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11693	5	Haworth	Haworth	NNP
18637	11693	6	,	,	,
18637	11693	7	300	300	CD
18637	11693	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11693	9	227	227	CD
18637	11693	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11693	11	1937	1937	CD
18637	11693	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11693	13	.	.	.
18637	11694	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11694	2	24	24	CD
18637	11694	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11694	4	John	John	NNP
18637	11694	5	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	11694	6	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	11694	7	,	,	,
18637	11694	8	The	the	DT
18637	11694	9	King	King	NNP
18637	11694	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11694	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	11694	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11694	13	Almon	Almon	NNP
18637	11694	14	,	,	,
18637	11694	15	24	24	CD
18637	11694	16	Law	Law	NNP
18637	11694	17	Quarterly	Quarterly	NNP
18637	11694	18	Review	Review	NNP
18637	11694	19	184	184	CD
18637	11694	20	,	,	,
18637	11694	21	194	194	CD
18637	11694	22	-	-	SYM
18637	11694	23	195	195	CD
18637	11694	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11694	25	1908	1908	CD
18637	11694	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11694	27	.	.	.
18637	11695	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11695	2	25	25	CD
18637	11695	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11695	4	John	John	NNP
18637	11695	5	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	11695	6	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	11695	7	,	,	,
18637	11695	8	The	the	DT
18637	11695	9	Summary	Summary	NNP
18637	11695	10	Power	Power	NNP
18637	11695	11	to	to	TO
18637	11695	12	Punish	Punish	NNP
18637	11695	13	Contempt	Contempt	NNP
18637	11695	14	,	,	,
18637	11695	15	25	25	CD
18637	11695	16	Law	Law	NNP
18637	11695	17	Quarterly	Quarterly	NNP
18637	11695	18	Review	Review	NNP
18637	11695	19	,	,	,
18637	11695	20	238	238	CD
18637	11695	21	,	,	,
18637	11695	22	252	252	CD
18637	11695	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11695	24	1909	1909	CD
18637	11695	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11695	26	.	.	.
18637	11696	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11696	2	26	26	CD
18637	11696	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11696	4	1	1	CD
18637	11696	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11696	6	.	.	.
18637	11697	1	73	73	CD
18637	11697	2	,	,	,
18637	11697	3	83	83	CD
18637	11697	4	.	.	.
18637	11698	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11698	2	27	27	CD
18637	11698	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11698	4	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11698	5	of	of	IN
18637	11698	6	March	March	NNP
18637	11698	7	2	2	CD
18637	11698	8	,	,	,
18637	11698	9	1831	1831	CD
18637	11698	10	,	,	,
18637	11698	11	4	4	CD
18637	11698	12	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11698	13	.	.	.
18637	11699	1	487	487	CD
18637	11699	2	,	,	,
18637	11699	3	now	now	RB
18637	11699	4	18	18	CD
18637	11699	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	11700	1	401	401	CD
18637	11700	2	.	.	.
18637	11701	1	For	for	IN
18637	11701	2	a	a	DT
18637	11701	3	summary	summary	NN
18637	11701	4	of	of	IN
18637	11701	5	the	the	DT
18637	11701	6	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	11701	7	Impeachment	Impeachment	NNP
18637	11701	8	and	and	CC
18637	11701	9	the	the	DT
18637	11701	10	background	background	NN
18637	11701	11	of	of	IN
18637	11701	12	the	the	DT
18637	11701	13	act	act	NN
18637	11701	14	of	of	IN
18637	11701	15	1831	1831	CD
18637	11701	16	,	,	,
18637	11701	17	_	_	NNP
18637	11701	18	see	see	VBP
18637	11701	19	_	_	NNP
18637	11701	20	Felix	Felix	NNP
18637	11701	21	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11701	22	and	and	CC
18637	11701	23	James	James	NNP
18637	11701	24	Landis	Landis	NNP
18637	11701	25	,	,	,
18637	11701	26	Power	Power	NNP
18637	11701	27	of	of	IN
18637	11701	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11701	29	Over	over	IN
18637	11701	30	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	11701	31	in	in	IN
18637	11701	32	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
18637	11701	33	Contempts	Contempts	NNP
18637	11701	34	in	in	IN
18637	11701	35	Inferior	Inferior	NNP
18637	11701	36	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11701	37	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	11701	38	--	--	:
18637	11701	39	A	a	DT
18637	11701	40	Study	Study	NNP
18637	11701	41	in	in	IN
18637	11701	42	Separation	Separation	NNP
18637	11701	43	of	of	IN
18637	11701	44	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	11701	45	,	,	,
18637	11701	46	37	37	CD
18637	11701	47	Harvard	Harvard	NNP
18637	11701	48	Law	Law	NNP
18637	11701	49	Review	Review	NNP
18637	11701	50	,	,	,
18637	11701	51	1010	1010	CD
18637	11701	52	,	,	,
18637	11701	53	1024	1024	CD
18637	11701	54	-	-	SYM
18637	11701	55	1028	1028	CD
18637	11701	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11701	57	1924	1924	CD
18637	11701	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11701	59	.	.	.
18637	11702	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11702	2	28	28	CD
18637	11702	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11702	4	19	19	CD
18637	11702	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	11702	6	.	.	.
18637	11703	1	505	505	CD
18637	11703	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11703	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	11703	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11703	5	.	.	.
18637	11704	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11704	2	29	29	CD
18637	11704	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11704	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11704	5	.	.	.
18637	11705	1	505	505	CD
18637	11705	2	,	,	,
18637	11705	3	510	510	CD
18637	11705	4	-	-	SYM
18637	11705	5	511	511	CD
18637	11705	6	.	.	.
18637	11706	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11706	2	30	30	CD
18637	11706	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11706	4	Gompers	Gompers	NNP
18637	11706	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11706	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11706	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11706	8	Bucks	Bucks	NNP
18637	11706	9	Stove	Stove	NNP
18637	11706	10	&	&	CC
18637	11706	11	Range	Range	NNP
18637	11706	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11706	13	,	,	,
18637	11706	14	221	221	CD
18637	11706	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11706	16	418	418	CD
18637	11706	17	,	,	,
18637	11706	18	450	450	CD
18637	11706	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11706	20	1911	1911	CD
18637	11706	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11706	22	.	.	.
18637	11707	1	_	_	NNP
18637	11707	2	See	See	NNP
18637	11707	3	also	also	RB
18637	11707	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11707	5	In	in	IN
18637	11707	6	re	re	NN
18637	11707	7	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	11707	8	,	,	,
18637	11707	9	158	158	CD
18637	11707	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11707	11	504	504	CD
18637	11707	12	,	,	,
18637	11707	13	595	595	CD
18637	11707	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11707	15	1895	1895	CD
18637	11707	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11707	17	.	.	.
18637	11708	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11708	2	31	31	CD
18637	11708	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11708	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11708	5	42	42	CD
18637	11708	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11708	7	1924	1924	CD
18637	11708	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11708	9	.	.	.
18637	11709	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11709	2	32	32	CD
18637	11709	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11709	4	38	38	CD
18637	11709	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11709	6	.	.	.
18637	11710	1	730	730	CD
18637	11710	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11710	3	1914	1914	CD
18637	11710	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11710	5	.	.	.
18637	11711	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11711	2	33	33	CD
18637	11711	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11711	4	266	266	CD
18637	11711	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11711	6	42	42	CD
18637	11711	7	,	,	,
18637	11711	8	65	65	CD
18637	11711	9	-	-	SYM
18637	11711	10	66	66	CD
18637	11711	11	.	.	.
18637	11712	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11712	2	34	34	CD
18637	11712	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11712	4	247	247	CD
18637	11712	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11712	6	402	402	CD
18637	11712	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11712	8	1918	1918	CD
18637	11712	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11712	10	.	.	.
18637	11713	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11713	2	35	35	CD
18637	11713	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11713	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11713	5	.	.	.
18637	11714	1	418	418	CD
18637	11714	2	-	-	SYM
18637	11714	3	421	421	CD
18637	11714	4	.	.	.
18637	11715	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11715	2	36	36	CD
18637	11715	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11715	4	263	263	CD
18637	11715	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11715	6	255	255	CD
18637	11715	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11715	8	1923	1923	CD
18637	11715	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11715	10	.	.	.
18637	11716	1	In	in	IN
18637	11716	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11716	3	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11716	4	in	in	IN
18637	11716	5	this	this	DT
18637	11716	6	case	case	NN
18637	11716	7	,	,	,
18637	11716	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11716	9	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	11716	10	stated	state	VBD
18637	11716	11	that	that	IN
18637	11716	12	unless	unless	IN
18637	11716	13	a	a	DT
18637	11716	14	judge	judge	NN
18637	11716	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	11716	16	power	power	NN
18637	11716	17	to	to	TO
18637	11716	18	"	"	``
18637	11716	19	lay	lay	VB
18637	11716	20	hold	hold	NN
18637	11716	21	of	of	IN
18637	11716	22	anyone	anyone	NN
18637	11716	23	who	who	WP
18637	11716	24	ventures	venture	VBZ
18637	11716	25	to	to	TO
18637	11716	26	publish	publish	VB
18637	11716	27	anything	anything	NN
18637	11716	28	that	that	WDT
18637	11716	29	tends	tend	VBZ
18637	11716	30	to	to	TO
18637	11716	31	make	make	VB
18637	11716	32	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11716	33	unpopular	unpopular	JJ
18637	11716	34	or	or	CC
18637	11716	35	to	to	TO
18637	11716	36	belittle	belittle	VB
18637	11716	37	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11716	38	*	*	NFP
18637	11716	39	*	*	NFP
18637	11716	40	*	*	NFP
18637	11716	41	.	.	.
18637	11717	1	A	a	DT
18637	11717	2	man	man	NN
18637	11717	3	can	can	MD
18637	11717	4	not	not	RB
18637	11717	5	be	be	VB
18637	11717	6	summarily	summarily	RB
18637	11717	7	laid	lay	VBN
18637	11717	8	by	by	IN
18637	11717	9	the	the	DT
18637	11717	10	heels	heel	NNS
18637	11717	11	because	because	IN
18637	11717	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11717	13	words	word	NNS
18637	11717	14	may	may	MD
18637	11717	15	make	make	VB
18637	11717	16	public	public	JJ
18637	11717	17	feeling	feeling	NN
18637	11717	18	more	more	RBR
18637	11717	19	unfavorable	unfavorable	JJ
18637	11717	20	in	in	IN
18637	11717	21	case	case	NN
18637	11717	22	the	the	DT
18637	11717	23	judge	judge	NN
18637	11717	24	should	should	MD
18637	11717	25	be	be	VB
18637	11717	26	asked	ask	VBN
18637	11717	27	to	to	TO
18637	11717	28	act	act	VB
18637	11717	29	at	at	IN
18637	11717	30	some	some	DT
18637	11717	31	later	later	JJ
18637	11717	32	date	date	NN
18637	11717	33	,	,	,
18637	11717	34	any	any	DT
18637	11717	35	more	more	RBR
18637	11717	36	than	than	IN
18637	11717	37	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11717	38	can	can	MD
18637	11717	39	for	for	IN
18637	11717	40	exciting	exciting	JJ
18637	11717	41	feeling	feeling	NN
18637	11717	42	against	against	IN
18637	11717	43	a	a	DT
18637	11717	44	judge	judge	NN
18637	11717	45	for	for	IN
18637	11717	46	what	what	WP
18637	11717	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11717	48	already	already	RB
18637	11717	49	has	have	VBZ
18637	11717	50	done	do	VBN
18637	11717	51	.	.	.
18637	11717	52	"	"	''
18637	11718	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	11718	2	.	.	.
18637	11719	1	281	281	CD
18637	11719	2	-	-	SYM
18637	11719	3	282	282	CD
18637	11719	4	.	.	.
18637	11720	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11720	2	37	37	CD
18637	11720	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11720	4	313	313	CD
18637	11720	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11720	6	33	33	CD
18637	11720	7	,	,	,
18637	11720	8	47	47	CD
18637	11720	9	-	-	SYM
18637	11720	10	53	53	CD
18637	11720	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11720	12	1941	1941	CD
18637	11720	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11720	14	.	.	.
18637	11721	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11721	2	38	38	CD
18637	11721	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11721	4	314	314	CD
18637	11721	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11721	6	252	252	CD
18637	11721	7	,	,	,
18637	11721	8	260	260	CD
18637	11721	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11721	10	1941	1941	CD
18637	11721	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11721	12	.	.	.
18637	11722	1	_	_	NNP
18637	11722	2	See	See	NNP
18637	11722	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11722	4	pp	pp	NNP
18637	11722	5	.	.	.
18637	11723	1	783	783	CD
18637	11723	2	-	-	SYM
18637	11723	3	784	784	CD
18637	11723	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11723	5	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	11723	6	I	I	NNP
18637	11723	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11723	8	.	.	.
18637	11724	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11724	2	39	39	CD
18637	11724	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11724	4	128	128	CD
18637	11724	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11724	6	289	289	CD
18637	11724	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11724	8	1888	1888	CD
18637	11724	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11724	10	.	.	.
18637	11725	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11725	2	40	40	CD
18637	11725	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11725	4	267	267	CD
18637	11725	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11725	6	517	517	CD
18637	11725	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11725	8	1925	1925	CD
18637	11725	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11725	10	.	.	.
18637	11726	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11726	2	41	41	CD
18637	11726	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11726	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11726	5	.	.	.
18637	11727	1	534	534	CD
18637	11727	2	,	,	,
18637	11727	3	535	535	CD
18637	11727	4	.	.	.
18637	11728	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11728	2	42	42	CD
18637	11728	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11728	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11728	5	.	.	.
18637	11729	1	539	539	CD
18637	11729	2	.	.	.
18637	11730	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11730	2	43	43	CD
18637	11730	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11730	4	Sacher	Sacher	NNP
18637	11730	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11730	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11730	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11730	8	United	United	NNP
18637	11730	9	States	States	NNP
18637	11730	10	,	,	,
18637	11730	11	343	343	CD
18637	11730	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11730	13	1	1	CD
18637	11730	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11730	15	1952	1952	CD
18637	11730	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11730	17	.	.	.
18637	11731	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11731	2	44	44	CD
18637	11731	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11731	4	Dennis	Dennis	NNP
18637	11731	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11731	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11731	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11731	8	United	United	NNP
18637	11731	9	States	States	NNP
18637	11731	10	,	,	,
18637	11731	11	341	341	CD
18637	11731	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11731	13	494	494	CD
18637	11731	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11731	15	1951	1951	CD
18637	11731	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11731	17	.	.	.
18637	11732	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11732	2	45	45	CD
18637	11732	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11732	4	343	343	CD
18637	11732	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11732	6	1	1	CD
18637	11732	7	,	,	,
18637	11732	8	11	11	CD
18637	11732	9	,	,	,
18637	11732	10	13	13	CD
18637	11732	11	-	-	SYM
18637	11732	12	14	14	CD
18637	11732	13	.	.	.
18637	11733	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11733	2	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	11733	3	did	do	VBD
18637	11733	4	not	not	RB
18637	11733	5	participate	participate	VB
18637	11733	6	.	.	.
18637	11734	1	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	11734	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	11734	3	,	,	,
18637	11734	4	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11734	5	,	,	,
18637	11734	6	and	and	CC
18637	11734	7	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	11734	8	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	11734	9	.	.	.
18637	11735	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11735	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11735	3	's	's	POS
18637	11735	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11735	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	11735	6	accompanied	accompany	VBN
18637	11735	7	by	by	IN
18637	11735	8	an	an	DT
18637	11735	9	elaborate	elaborate	JJ
18637	11735	10	review	review	NN
18637	11735	11	of	of	IN
18637	11735	12	exchanges	exchange	NNS
18637	11735	13	between	between	IN
18637	11735	14	the	the	DT
18637	11735	15	trial	trial	NN
18637	11735	16	judge	judge	NN
18637	11735	17	and	and	CC
18637	11735	18	defense	defense	NN
18637	11735	19	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	11735	20	,	,	,
18637	11735	21	excerpted	excerpt	VBN
18637	11735	22	from	from	IN
18637	11735	23	the	the	DT
18637	11735	24	record	record	NN
18637	11735	25	of	of	IN
18637	11735	26	the	the	DT
18637	11735	27	case	case	NN
18637	11735	28	.	.	.
18637	11736	1	On	on	IN
18637	11736	2	the	the	DT
18637	11736	3	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	11736	4	issue	issue	NN
18637	11736	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11736	6	said	say	VBD
18637	11736	7	:	:	:
18637	11736	8	"	"	``
18637	11736	9	Summary	summary	JJ
18637	11736	10	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	11736	11	of	of	IN
18637	11736	12	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	11736	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	11736	14	concededly	concededly	RB
18637	11736	15	an	an	DT
18637	11736	16	exception	exception	NN
18637	11736	17	to	to	IN
18637	11736	18	the	the	DT
18637	11736	19	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	11736	20	of	of	IN
18637	11736	21	Due	Due	NNP
18637	11736	22	Process	Process	NNP
18637	11736	23	.	.	.
18637	11737	1	Necessity	necessity	NN
18637	11737	2	dictates	dictate	VBZ
18637	11737	3	the	the	DT
18637	11737	4	departure	departure	NN
18637	11737	5	.	.	.
18637	11738	1	Necessity	necessity	NN
18637	11738	2	must	must	MD
18637	11738	3	bound	bound	VB
18637	11738	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11738	5	limits	limit	NNS
18637	11738	6	.	.	.
18637	11739	1	In	in	IN
18637	11739	2	this	this	DT
18637	11739	3	case	case	NN
18637	11739	4	the	the	DT
18637	11739	5	course	course	NN
18637	11739	6	of	of	IN
18637	11739	7	events	event	NNS
18637	11739	8	to	to	IN
18637	11739	9	the	the	DT
18637	11739	10	very	very	JJ
18637	11739	11	end	end	NN
18637	11739	12	of	of	IN
18637	11739	13	the	the	DT
18637	11739	14	trial	trial	NN
18637	11739	15	shows	show	VBZ
18637	11739	16	that	that	IN
18637	11739	17	summary	summary	NN
18637	11739	18	measures	measure	NNS
18637	11739	19	were	be	VBD
18637	11739	20	not	not	RB
18637	11739	21	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11739	22	to	to	TO
18637	11739	23	enable	enable	VB
18637	11739	24	the	the	DT
18637	11739	25	trial	trial	NN
18637	11739	26	to	to	TO
18637	11739	27	go	go	VB
18637	11739	28	on	on	RP
18637	11739	29	.	.	.
18637	11740	1	Departure	departure	NN
18637	11740	2	from	from	IN
18637	11740	3	established	establish	VBN
18637	11740	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11740	5	practice	practice	NN
18637	11740	6	,	,	,
18637	11740	7	which	which	WDT
18637	11740	8	makes	make	VBZ
18637	11740	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11740	10	unfitting	unfit	VBG
18637	11740	11	for	for	IN
18637	11740	12	a	a	DT
18637	11740	13	judge	judge	NN
18637	11740	14	who	who	WP
18637	11740	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	11740	16	personally	personally	RB
18637	11740	17	involved	involve	VBN
18637	11740	18	to	to	TO
18637	11740	19	sit	sit	VB
18637	11740	20	in	in	IN
18637	11740	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11740	22	own	own	JJ
18637	11740	23	case	case	NN
18637	11740	24	,	,	,
18637	11740	25	was	be	VBD
18637	11740	26	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11740	27	unwarranted	unwarranted	JJ
18637	11740	28	.	.	.
18637	11741	1	Neither	neither	DT
18637	11741	2	self	self	NN
18637	11741	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	11741	4	respect	respect	NN
18637	11741	5	nor	nor	CC
18637	11741	6	the	the	DT
18637	11741	7	good	good	JJ
18637	11741	8	name	name	NN
18637	11741	9	of	of	IN
18637	11741	10	the	the	DT
18637	11741	11	law	law	NN
18637	11741	12	required	require	VBD
18637	11741	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11741	14	.	.	.
18637	11742	1	Quite	quite	RB
18637	11742	2	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	11742	3	.	.	.
18637	11743	1	Despite	despite	IN
18637	11743	2	the	the	DT
18637	11743	3	many	many	JJ
18637	11743	4	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	11743	5	of	of	IN
18637	11743	6	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	11743	7	that	that	WDT
18637	11743	8	were	be	VBD
18637	11743	9	charged	charge	VBN
18637	11743	10	,	,	,
18637	11743	11	the	the	DT
18637	11743	12	trial	trial	NN
18637	11743	13	went	go	VBD
18637	11743	14	to	to	IN
18637	11743	15	completion	completion	NN
18637	11743	16	,	,	,
18637	11743	17	nine	nine	CD
18637	11743	18	months	month	NNS
18637	11743	19	after	after	IN
18637	11743	20	the	the	DT
18637	11743	21	first	first	JJ
18637	11743	22	incident	incident	NN
18637	11743	23	,	,	,
18637	11743	24	without	without	IN
18637	11743	25	a	a	DT
18637	11743	26	single	single	JJ
18637	11743	27	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	11743	28	making	make	VBG
18637	11743	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11743	30	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	11743	31	to	to	TO
18637	11743	32	lay	lay	VB
18637	11743	33	any	any	DT
18637	11743	34	one	one	CD
18637	11743	35	of	of	IN
18637	11743	36	the	the	DT
18637	11743	37	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
18637	11743	38	by	by	IN
18637	11743	39	the	the	DT
18637	11743	40	heel	heel	NN
18637	11743	41	in	in	IN
18637	11743	42	order	order	NN
18637	11743	43	to	to	TO
18637	11743	44	assure	assure	VB
18637	11743	45	that	that	IN
18637	11743	46	the	the	DT
18637	11743	47	trial	trial	NN
18637	11743	48	proceed	proceed	NN
18637	11743	49	.	.	.
18637	11744	1	The	the	DT
18637	11744	2	trial	trial	NN
18637	11744	3	judge	judge	NN
18637	11744	4	was	be	VBD
18637	11744	5	able	able	JJ
18637	11744	6	to	to	TO
18637	11744	7	keep	keep	VB
18637	11744	8	order	order	NN
18637	11744	9	and	and	CC
18637	11744	10	to	to	TO
18637	11744	11	continue	continue	VB
18637	11744	12	the	the	DT
18637	11744	13	court	court	NN
18637	11744	14	's	's	POS
18637	11744	15	business	business	NN
18637	11744	16	by	by	IN
18637	11744	17	occasional	occasional	JJ
18637	11744	18	brief	brief	JJ
18637	11744	19	recesses	recess	NNS
18637	11744	20	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	11744	21	to	to	IN
18637	11744	22	cool	cool	JJ
18637	11744	23	passions	passion	NNS
18637	11744	24	and	and	CC
18637	11744	25	restore	restore	NN
18637	11744	26	decorum	decorum	NN
18637	11744	27	,	,	,
18637	11744	28	by	by	IN
18637	11744	29	periodic	periodic	JJ
18637	11744	30	warnings	warning	NNS
18637	11744	31	to	to	IN
18637	11744	32	defense	defense	NN
18637	11744	33	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
18637	11744	34	,	,	,
18637	11744	35	and	and	CC
18637	11744	36	by	by	IN
18637	11744	37	shutting	shut	VBG
18637	11744	38	off	off	RP
18637	11744	39	obstructive	obstructive	JJ
18637	11744	40	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	11744	41	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	11744	42	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	11744	43	were	be	VBD
18637	11744	44	concisely	concisely	RB
18637	11744	45	stated	state	VBN
18637	11744	46	and	and	CC
18637	11744	47	firmly	firmly	RB
18637	11744	48	held	hold	VBN
18637	11744	49	to	to	IN
18637	11744	50	.	.	.
18637	11744	51	"	"	''
18637	11745	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	11745	2	.	.	.
18637	11746	1	36	36	CD
18637	11746	2	.	.	.
18637	11747	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11747	2	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	11747	3	summarized	summarize	VBD
18637	11747	4	the	the	DT
18637	11747	5	position	position	NN
18637	11747	6	of	of	IN
18637	11747	7	all	all	DT
18637	11747	8	three	three	CD
18637	11747	9	dissenters	dissenter	NNS
18637	11747	10	,	,	,
18637	11747	11	as	as	IN
18637	11747	12	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	11747	13	:	:	:
18637	11747	14	"	"	``
18637	11747	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11747	16	agree	agree	VBP
18637	11747	17	with	with	IN
18637	11747	18	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	11747	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11747	20	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11747	21	that	that	IN
18637	11747	22	one	one	NN
18637	11747	23	who	who	WP
18637	11747	24	reads	read	VBZ
18637	11747	25	this	this	DT
18637	11747	26	record	record	NN
18637	11747	27	will	will	MD
18637	11747	28	have	have	VB
18637	11747	29	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	11747	30	in	in	IN
18637	11747	31	determining	determine	VBG
18637	11747	32	whether	whether	IN
18637	11747	33	members	member	NNS
18637	11747	34	of	of	IN
18637	11747	35	the	the	DT
18637	11747	36	bar	bar	NN
18637	11747	37	conspired	conspire	VBD
18637	11747	38	to	to	TO
18637	11747	39	drive	drive	VB
18637	11747	40	a	a	DT
18637	11747	41	judge	judge	NN
18637	11747	42	from	from	IN
18637	11747	43	the	the	DT
18637	11747	44	bench	bench	NN
18637	11747	45	or	or	CC
18637	11747	46	whether	whether	IN
18637	11747	47	the	the	DT
18637	11747	48	judge	judge	NN
18637	11747	49	used	use	VBD
18637	11747	50	the	the	DT
18637	11747	51	authority	authority	NN
18637	11747	52	of	of	IN
18637	11747	53	the	the	DT
18637	11747	54	bench	bench	NN
18637	11747	55	to	to	TO
18637	11747	56	whipsaw	whipsaw	VB
18637	11747	57	the	the	DT
18637	11747	58	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
18637	11747	59	,	,	,
18637	11747	60	to	to	TO
18637	11747	61	taunt	taunt	VB
18637	11747	62	and	and	CC
18637	11747	63	tempt	tempt	VB
18637	11747	64	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11747	65	,	,	,
18637	11747	66	and	and	CC
18637	11747	67	to	to	TO
18637	11747	68	create	create	VB
18637	11747	69	for	for	IN
18637	11747	70	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11747	71	the	the	DT
18637	11747	72	role	role	NN
18637	11747	73	of	of	IN
18637	11747	74	the	the	DT
18637	11747	75	persecuted	persecute	VBN
18637	11747	76	.	.	.
18637	11748	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11748	2	have	have	VBP
18637	11748	3	reluctantly	reluctantly	RB
18637	11748	4	concluded	conclude	VBN
18637	11748	5	that	that	IN
18637	11748	6	neither	neither	DT
18637	11748	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	11748	8	blameless	blameless	JJ
18637	11748	9	,	,	,
18637	11748	10	that	that	IN
18637	11748	11	there	there	EX
18637	11748	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	11748	13	fault	fault	NN
18637	11748	14	on	on	IN
18637	11748	15	each	each	DT
18637	11748	16	side	side	NN
18637	11748	17	,	,	,
18637	11748	18	that	that	IN
18637	11748	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11748	20	have	have	VBP
18637	11748	21	here	here	RB
18637	11748	22	the	the	DT
18637	11748	23	spectacle	spectacle	NN
18637	11748	24	of	of	IN
18637	11748	25	the	the	DT
18637	11748	26	bench	bench	NN
18637	11748	27	and	and	CC
18637	11748	28	the	the	DT
18637	11748	29	bar	bar	NN
18637	11748	30	using	use	VBG
18637	11748	31	the	the	DT
18637	11748	32	courtroom	courtroom	NN
18637	11748	33	for	for	IN
18637	11748	34	an	an	DT
18637	11748	35	unseemly	unseemly	JJ
18637	11748	36	demonstration	demonstration	NN
18637	11748	37	of	of	IN
18637	11748	38	garrulous	garrulous	JJ
18637	11748	39	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	11748	40	and	and	CC
18637	11748	41	of	of	IN
18637	11748	42	ill	ill	JJ
18637	11748	43	will	will	NN
18637	11748	44	and	and	CC
18637	11748	45	hot	hot	JJ
18637	11748	46	tempers	temper	NNS
18637	11748	47	.	.	.
18637	11749	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11749	2	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	11749	3	agree	agree	VBP
18637	11749	4	with	with	IN
18637	11749	5	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	11749	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11749	7	Black	Black	NNP
18637	11749	8	and	and	CC
18637	11749	9	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	11749	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11749	11	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11749	12	that	that	IN
18637	11749	13	this	this	DT
18637	11749	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	11749	15	the	the	DT
18637	11749	16	classic	classic	JJ
18637	11749	17	case	case	NN
18637	11749	18	where	where	WRB
18637	11749	19	the	the	DT
18637	11749	20	trial	trial	NN
18637	11749	21	for	for	IN
18637	11749	22	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	11749	23	should	should	MD
18637	11749	24	be	be	VB
18637	11749	25	held	hold	VBN
18637	11749	26	before	before	IN
18637	11749	27	another	another	DT
18637	11749	28	judge	judge	NN
18637	11749	29	.	.	.
18637	11750	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11750	2	also	also	RB
18637	11750	3	agree	agree	VBP
18637	11750	4	with	with	IN
18637	11750	5	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	11750	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11750	7	Black	Black	NNP
18637	11750	8	that	that	IN
18637	11750	9	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	11750	10	were	be	VBD
18637	11750	11	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	11750	12	by	by	IN
18637	11750	13	the	the	DT
18637	11750	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11750	15	to	to	IN
18637	11750	16	a	a	DT
18637	11750	17	trial	trial	NN
18637	11750	18	by	by	IN
18637	11750	19	jury	jury	NN
18637	11750	20	.	.	.
18637	11750	21	"	"	''
18637	11751	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	11751	2	.	.	.
18637	11752	1	80	80	CD
18637	11752	2	.	.	.
18637	11753	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11753	2	46	46	CD
18637	11753	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11753	4	330	330	CD
18637	11753	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11753	6	258	258	CD
18637	11753	7	,	,	,
18637	11753	8	293	293	CD
18637	11753	9	-	-	SYM
18637	11753	10	307	307	CD
18637	11753	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11753	12	1947	1947	CD
18637	11753	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11753	14	.	.	.
18637	11754	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11754	2	47	47	CD
18637	11754	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11754	4	203	203	CD
18637	11754	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11754	6	563	563	CD
18637	11754	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11754	8	1906	1906	CD
18637	11754	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11754	10	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11754	11	48	48	CD
18637	11754	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11754	13	Gompers	Gompers	NNP
18637	11754	14	_	_	NNP
18637	11754	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	11754	16	_	_	NNP
18637	11754	17	Bucks	Bucks	NNP
18637	11754	18	Stove	Stove	NNP
18637	11754	19	&	&	CC
18637	11754	20	Range	Range	NNP
18637	11754	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11754	22	,	,	,
18637	11754	23	221	221	CD
18637	11754	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11754	25	418	418	CD
18637	11754	26	,	,	,
18637	11754	27	441	441	CD
18637	11754	28	-	-	SYM
18637	11754	29	443	443	CD
18637	11754	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11754	31	1911	1911	CD
18637	11754	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11754	33	;	;	:
18637	11754	34	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11754	35	parte	parte	NNP
18637	11754	36	Grossman	Grossman	NNP
18637	11754	37	,	,	,
18637	11754	38	267	267	CD
18637	11754	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11754	40	87	87	CD
18637	11754	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11754	42	1925	1925	CD
18637	11754	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11754	44	.	.	.
18637	11755	1	_	_	NNP
18637	11755	2	See	See	NNP
18637	11755	3	also	also	RB
18637	11755	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11755	5	Bessette	Bessette	NNP
18637	11755	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11755	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	11755	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11755	9	W.B.	W.B.	NNP
18637	11756	1	Conkey	Conkey	NNP
18637	11756	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11756	3	,	,	,
18637	11756	4	194	194	CD
18637	11756	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11756	6	324	324	CD
18637	11756	7	,	,	,
18637	11756	8	327	327	CD
18637	11756	9	-	-	SYM
18637	11756	10	328	328	CD
18637	11756	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11756	12	1904	1904	CD
18637	11756	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11756	14	.	.	.
18637	11757	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11757	2	49	49	CD
18637	11757	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11757	4	267	267	CD
18637	11757	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11757	6	87	87	CD
18637	11757	7	,	,	,
18637	11757	8	119	119	CD
18637	11757	9	-	-	SYM
18637	11757	10	120	120	CD
18637	11757	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11757	12	1925	1925	CD
18637	11757	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11757	14	.	.	.
18637	11758	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11758	2	50	50	CD
18637	11758	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11758	4	Michaelson	Michaelson	NNP
18637	11758	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11758	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11758	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11758	8	United	United	NNP
18637	11758	9	States	States	NNP
18637	11758	10	,	,	,
18637	11758	11	266	266	CD
18637	11758	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11758	13	42	42	CD
18637	11758	14	,	,	,
18637	11758	15	65	65	CD
18637	11758	16	-	-	SYM
18637	11758	17	66	66	CD
18637	11758	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11758	19	1924	1924	CD
18637	11758	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11758	21	.	.	.
18637	11759	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11759	2	51	51	CD
18637	11759	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11759	4	154	154	CD
18637	11759	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11759	6	447	447	CD
18637	11759	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11759	8	1894	1894	CD
18637	11759	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11759	10	.	.	.
18637	11760	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11760	2	52	52	CD
18637	11760	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11760	4	Penfield	Penfield	NNP
18637	11760	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11760	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11760	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	11760	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11760	9	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	11760	10	and	and	CC
18637	11760	11	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	11760	12	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	11760	13	,	,	,
18637	11760	14	330	330	CD
18637	11760	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11760	16	585	585	CD
18637	11760	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11760	18	1947	1947	CD
18637	11760	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11760	20	.	.	.
18637	11761	1	Note	note	VB
18637	11761	2	the	the	DT
18637	11761	3	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11761	4	of	of	IN
18637	11761	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11761	6	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11761	7	.	.	.
18637	11762	1	For	for	IN
18637	11762	2	delegations	delegation	NNS
18637	11762	3	of	of	IN
18637	11762	4	the	the	DT
18637	11762	5	subpoena	subpoena	NN
18637	11762	6	power	power	NN
18637	11762	7	to	to	IN
18637	11762	8	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	11762	9	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	11762	10	and	and	CC
18637	11762	11	the	the	DT
18637	11762	12	use	use	NN
18637	11762	13	of	of	IN
18637	11762	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11762	15	process	process	NN
18637	11762	16	to	to	TO
18637	11762	17	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	11762	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11762	19	_	_	NNP
18637	11762	20	see	see	VB
18637	11762	21	also	also	RB
18637	11762	22	_	_	NNP
18637	11762	23	McCrone	McCrone	NNP
18637	11762	24	_	_	NNP
18637	11762	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	11762	26	_	_	NNP
18637	11762	27	United	United	NNP
18637	11762	28	States	States	NNP
18637	11762	29	,	,	,
18637	11762	30	307	307	CD
18637	11762	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11762	32	61	61	CD
18637	11762	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11762	34	1939	1939	CD
18637	11762	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11762	36	;	;	:
18637	11762	37	Endicott	Endicott	NNP
18637	11762	38	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	11762	39	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	11762	40	_	_	NNP
18637	11762	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	11762	42	_	_	NNP
18637	11762	43	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
18637	11762	44	,	,	,
18637	11762	45	317	317	CD
18637	11762	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11762	47	501	501	CD
18637	11762	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11762	49	1943	1943	CD
18637	11762	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11762	51	;	;	:
18637	11762	52	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	11762	53	Press	Press	NNP
18637	11762	54	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	11762	55	.	.	.
18637	11763	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11763	2	_	_	NNP
18637	11763	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	11763	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11763	5	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	11763	6	,	,	,
18637	11763	7	327	327	CD
18637	11763	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11763	9	186	186	CD
18637	11763	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11763	11	1946	1946	CD
18637	11763	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11763	13	.	.	.
18637	11764	1	In	in	IN
18637	11764	2	the	the	DT
18637	11764	3	last	last	JJ
18637	11764	4	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	11764	5	case	case	NN
18637	11764	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11764	7	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	11764	8	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	11764	9	on	on	IN
18637	11764	10	the	the	DT
18637	11764	11	ground	ground	NN
18637	11764	12	that	that	IN
18637	11764	13	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	11764	14	of	of	IN
18637	11764	15	the	the	DT
18637	11764	16	subpoena	subpoena	NN
18637	11764	17	power	power	NN
18637	11764	18	to	to	IN
18637	11764	19	nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	11764	20	officers	officer	NNS
18637	11764	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	11764	22	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	11764	23	as	as	IN
18637	11764	24	"	"	``
18637	11764	25	a	a	DT
18637	11764	26	corrosion	corrosion	NN
18637	11764	27	of	of	IN
18637	11764	28	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	11764	29	.	.	.
18637	11764	30	"	"	''
18637	11765	1	In	in	IN
18637	11765	2	the	the	DT
18637	11765	3	Endicott	Endicott	NNP
18637	11765	4	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	11765	5	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11765	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11765	7	expressed	express	VBD
18637	11765	8	dissatisfaction	dissatisfaction	NN
18637	11765	9	with	with	IN
18637	11765	10	the	the	DT
18637	11765	11	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11765	12	of	of	IN
18637	11765	13	this	this	DT
18637	11765	14	power	power	NN
18637	11765	15	by	by	IN
18637	11765	16	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	11765	17	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	11765	18	but	but	CC
18637	11765	19	confined	confine	VBD
18637	11765	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11765	21	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11765	22	to	to	IN
18637	11765	23	emphasizing	emphasize	VBG
18637	11765	24	greater	great	JJR
18637	11765	25	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11765	26	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
18637	11765	27	in	in	IN
18637	11765	28	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	11765	29	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	11765	30	orders	order	NNS
18637	11765	31	to	to	TO
18637	11765	32	appear	appear	VB
18637	11765	33	and	and	CC
18637	11765	34	produce	produce	VB
18637	11765	35	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	11765	36	.	.	.
18637	11766	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11766	2	53	53	CD
18637	11766	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11766	4	1	1	CD
18637	11766	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11766	6	.	.	.
18637	11767	1	73	73	CD
18637	11767	2	,	,	,
18637	11767	3	81	81	CD
18637	11767	4	.	.	.
18637	11768	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11768	2	54	54	CD
18637	11768	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11768	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11768	5	.	.	.
18637	11769	1	81	81	CD
18637	11769	2	-	-	SYM
18637	11769	3	82	82	CD
18637	11769	4	.	.	.
18637	11770	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11770	2	55	55	CD
18637	11770	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11770	4	1	1	CD
18637	11770	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	11770	6	.	.	.
18637	11771	1	137	137	CD
18637	11771	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11771	3	1803	1803	CD
18637	11771	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11771	5	.	.	.
18637	11772	1	_	_	NNP
18637	11772	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	11772	3	.	.	.
18637	11772	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11772	5	Wiscart	Wiscart	NNP
18637	11772	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11772	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	11772	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11772	9	Dauchy	Dauchy	NNP
18637	11772	10	,	,	,
18637	11772	11	3	3	CD
18637	11772	12	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	11772	13	.	.	.
18637	11773	1	321	321	CD
18637	11773	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11773	3	1796	1796	CD
18637	11773	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11773	5	.	.	.
18637	11774	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11774	2	56	56	CD
18637	11774	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11774	4	McIntire	McIntire	NNP
18637	11774	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11774	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11774	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11774	8	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	11774	9	,	,	,
18637	11774	10	7	7	CD
18637	11774	11	Cr	cr	NN
18637	11774	12	.	.	.
18637	11775	1	504	504	CD
18637	11775	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11775	3	1813	1813	CD
18637	11775	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11775	5	;	;	:
18637	11775	6	and	and	CC
18637	11775	7	McClung	McClung	NNP
18637	11775	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11775	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	11775	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11775	11	Silliman	Silliman	NNP
18637	11775	12	,	,	,
18637	11775	13	6	6	CD
18637	11775	14	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	11775	15	.	.	.
18637	11776	1	598	598	CD
18637	11776	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11776	3	1821	1821	CD
18637	11776	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11776	5	.	.	.
18637	11777	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11777	2	57	57	CD
18637	11777	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11777	4	12	12	CD
18637	11777	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	11777	6	.	.	.
18637	11778	1	524	524	CD
18637	11778	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11778	3	1838	1838	CD
18637	11778	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11778	5	.	.	.
18637	11779	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11779	2	58	58	CD
18637	11779	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11779	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11779	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	11779	6	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	11779	7	,	,	,
18637	11779	8	4	4	CD
18637	11779	9	Cr	cr	NN
18637	11779	10	.	.	.
18637	11780	1	74	74	CD
18637	11780	2	,	,	,
18637	11780	3	93	93	CD
18637	11780	4	,	,	,
18637	11780	5	94	94	CD
18637	11780	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11780	7	1807	1807	CD
18637	11780	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11780	9	.	.	.
18637	11781	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11781	2	59	59	CD
18637	11781	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11781	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11781	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	11781	6	Yerger	Yerger	NNP
18637	11781	7	,	,	,
18637	11781	8	8	8	CD
18637	11781	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	11781	10	.	.	.
18637	11782	1	85	85	CD
18637	11782	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11782	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	11782	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11782	5	.	.	.
18637	11783	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11783	2	60	60	CD
18637	11783	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11783	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11783	5	See	See	NNP
18637	11783	6	also	also	RB
18637	11783	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11783	8	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11783	9	parte	parte	NN
18637	11783	10	McCardle	McCardle	NNP
18637	11783	11	,	,	,
18637	11783	12	7	7	CD
18637	11783	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	11783	14	.	.	.
18637	11784	1	506	506	CD
18637	11784	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11784	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	11784	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11784	5	.	.	.
18637	11785	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11785	2	61	61	CD
18637	11785	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11785	4	In	in	IN
18637	11785	5	United	United	NNP
18637	11785	6	States	States	NNP
18637	11785	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11785	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11785	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11785	10	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	11785	11	Timber	Timber	NNP
18637	11785	12	&	&	CC
18637	11785	13	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	11785	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11785	15	,	,	,
18637	11785	16	200	200	CD
18637	11785	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11785	18	321	321	CD
18637	11785	19	,	,	,
18637	11785	20	339	339	CD
18637	11785	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11785	22	1906	1906	CD
18637	11785	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11785	24	,	,	,
18637	11785	25	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11785	26	Brewer	Brewer	NNP
18637	11785	27	,	,	,
18637	11785	28	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	11785	29	for	for	IN
18637	11785	30	the	the	DT
18637	11785	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11785	32	,	,	,
18637	11785	33	approached	approach	VBD
18637	11785	34	a	a	DT
18637	11785	35	theory	theory	NN
18637	11785	36	of	of	IN
18637	11785	37	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	11785	38	equity	equity	NN
18637	11785	39	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11785	40	when	when	WRB
18637	11785	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11785	42	declared	declare	VBD
18637	11785	43	:	:	:
18637	11785	44	"	"	``
18637	11785	45	The	the	DT
18637	11785	46	principles	principle	NNS
18637	11785	47	of	of	IN
18637	11785	48	equity	equity	NN
18637	11785	49	exist	exist	VBP
18637	11785	50	independently	independently	RB
18637	11785	51	of	of	IN
18637	11785	52	and	and	CC
18637	11785	53	anterior	anterior	JJ
18637	11785	54	to	to	IN
18637	11785	55	all	all	DT
18637	11785	56	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	11785	57	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	11785	58	,	,	,
18637	11785	59	and	and	CC
18637	11785	60	the	the	DT
18637	11785	61	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	11785	62	are	be	VBP
18637	11785	63	either	either	CC
18637	11785	64	annunciations	annunciation	NNS
18637	11785	65	of	of	IN
18637	11785	66	those	those	DT
18637	11785	67	principles	principle	NNS
18637	11785	68	or	or	CC
18637	11785	69	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	11785	70	upon	upon	IN
18637	11785	71	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11785	72	application	application	NN
18637	11785	73	in	in	IN
18637	11785	74	particular	particular	JJ
18637	11785	75	cases	case	NNS
18637	11785	76	.	.	.
18637	11785	77	"	"	''
18637	11786	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11786	2	should	should	MD
18637	11786	3	be	be	VB
18637	11786	4	emphasized	emphasize	VBN
18637	11786	5	,	,	,
18637	11786	6	however	however	RB
18637	11786	7	,	,	,
18637	11786	8	that	that	IN
18637	11786	9	the	the	DT
18637	11786	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11786	11	made	make	VBD
18637	11786	12	no	no	DT
18637	11786	13	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	11786	14	that	that	IN
18637	11786	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11786	16	could	could	MD
18637	11786	17	apply	apply	VB
18637	11786	18	pre	pre	JJ
18637	11786	19	-	-	JJ
18637	11786	20	existing	existing	JJ
18637	11786	21	principles	principle	NNS
18637	11786	22	of	of	IN
18637	11786	23	equity	equity	NN
18637	11786	24	without	without	IN
18637	11786	25	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11786	26	over	over	IN
18637	11786	27	the	the	DT
18637	11786	28	subject	subject	JJ
18637	11786	29	matter	matter	NN
18637	11786	30	.	.	.
18637	11787	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	11787	2	,	,	,
18637	11787	3	the	the	DT
18637	11787	4	inference	inference	NN
18637	11787	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	11787	6	to	to	IN
18637	11787	7	the	the	DT
18637	11787	8	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	11787	9	.	.	.
18637	11788	1	In	in	IN
18637	11788	2	a	a	DT
18637	11788	3	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	11788	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	11788	5	in	in	IN
18637	11788	6	which	which	WDT
18637	11788	7	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	11788	8	McKenna	McKenna	NNP
18637	11788	9	and	and	CC
18637	11788	10	Van	Van	NNP
18637	11788	11	Devanter	Devanter	NNP
18637	11788	12	joined	join	VBD
18637	11788	13	,	,	,
18637	11788	14	in	in	IN
18637	11788	15	Paine	Paine	NNP
18637	11788	16	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	11788	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11788	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11788	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	11788	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11788	21	Neal	Neal	NNP
18637	11788	22	,	,	,
18637	11788	23	244	244	CD
18637	11788	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11788	25	459	459	CD
18637	11788	26	,	,	,
18637	11788	27	475	475	CD
18637	11788	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11788	29	1917	1917	CD
18637	11788	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11788	31	,	,	,
18637	11788	32	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11788	33	Pitney	Pitney	NNP
18637	11788	34	contended	contend	VBD
18637	11788	35	that	that	IN
18637	11788	36	article	article	NN
18637	11788	37	III	iii	CD
18637	11788	38	,	,	,
18637	11788	39	section	section	NN
18637	11788	40	2	2	CD
18637	11788	41	,	,	,
18637	11788	42	"	"	''
18637	11788	43	had	have	VBD
18637	11788	44	the	the	DT
18637	11788	45	effect	effect	NN
18637	11788	46	of	of	IN
18637	11788	47	adopting	adopt	VBG
18637	11788	48	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	11788	49	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	11788	50	in	in	IN
18637	11788	51	all	all	DT
18637	11788	52	cases	case	NNS
18637	11788	53	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11788	54	under	under	IN
18637	11788	55	the	the	DT
18637	11788	56	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11788	57	and	and	CC
18637	11788	58	laws	law	NNS
18637	11788	59	of	of	IN
18637	11788	60	the	the	DT
18637	11788	61	United	United	NNP
18637	11788	62	States	States	NNP
18637	11788	63	where	where	WRB
18637	11788	64	such	such	JJ
18637	11788	65	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	11788	66	are	be	VBP
18637	11788	67	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	11788	68	.	.	.
18637	11788	69	"	"	''
18637	11789	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11789	2	62	62	CD
18637	11789	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11789	4	Boyce	Boyce	NNP
18637	11789	5	's	's	POS
18637	11789	6	Executors	Executors	NNP
18637	11789	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11789	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11789	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11789	10	Grundy	Grundy	NNP
18637	11789	11	,	,	,
18637	11789	12	3	3	CD
18637	11789	13	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	11789	14	.	.	.
18637	11790	1	210	210	CD
18637	11790	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11790	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	11790	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11790	5	.	.	.
18637	11791	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11791	2	63	63	CD
18637	11791	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11791	4	1	1	CD
18637	11791	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11791	6	.	.	.
18637	11792	1	333	333	CD
18637	11792	2	;	;	:
18637	11792	3	28	28	CD
18637	11792	4	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	11793	1	1651	1651	CD
18637	11793	2	.	.	.
18637	11794	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11794	2	64	64	CD
18637	11794	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11794	4	14	14	CD
18637	11794	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	11794	6	.	.	.
18637	11795	1	475	475	CD
18637	11795	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11795	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	11795	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11795	5	;	;	:
18637	11795	6	26	26	CD
18637	11795	7	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	11796	1	3653	3653	CD
18637	11796	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11796	3	a	a	DT
18637	11796	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11796	5	.	.	.
18637	11797	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11797	2	65	65	CD
18637	11797	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11797	4	36	36	CD
18637	11797	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11797	6	.	.	.
18637	11798	1	557	557	CD
18637	11798	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11798	3	1910	1910	CD
18637	11798	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11798	5	;	;	:
18637	11798	6	28	28	CD
18637	11798	7	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	11799	1	2281	2281	CD
18637	11799	2	.	.	.
18637	11800	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11800	2	66	66	CD
18637	11800	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11800	4	50	50	CD
18637	11800	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11800	6	.	.	.
18637	11801	1	752	752	CD
18637	11801	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11801	3	1937	1937	CD
18637	11801	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11801	5	;	;	:
18637	11801	6	28	28	CD
18637	11801	7	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	11802	1	2282	2282	CD
18637	11802	2	.	.	.
18637	11803	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11803	2	67	67	CD
18637	11803	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11803	4	38	38	CD
18637	11803	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11803	6	.	.	.
18637	11804	1	220	220	CD
18637	11804	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11804	3	1913	1913	CD
18637	11804	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11804	5	;	;	:
18637	11804	6	28	28	CD
18637	11804	7	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	11805	1	2325	2325	CD
18637	11805	2	.	.	.
18637	11806	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11806	2	68	68	CD
18637	11806	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11806	4	48	48	CD
18637	11806	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11806	6	.	.	.
18637	11807	1	775	775	CD
18637	11807	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11807	3	1934	1934	CD
18637	11807	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11807	5	;	;	:
18637	11807	6	28	28	CD
18637	11807	7	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	11808	1	1342	1342	CD
18637	11808	2	.	.	.
18637	11809	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11809	2	69	69	CD
18637	11809	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11809	4	38	38	CD
18637	11809	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11809	6	.	.	.
18637	11810	1	730	730	CD
18637	11810	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11810	3	1914	1914	CD
18637	11810	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11810	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11810	6	Clayton	Clayton	NNP
18637	11810	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11810	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11810	9	;	;	:
18637	11810	10	29	29	CD
18637	11810	11	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	11811	1	52	52	CD
18637	11811	2	,	,	,
18637	11811	3	and	and	CC
18637	11811	4	47	47	CD
18637	11811	5	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	11811	6	.	.	.
18637	11812	1	70	70	CD
18637	11812	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11812	3	1932	1932	CD
18637	11812	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11812	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11812	6	Norris	Norris	NNP
18637	11812	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	11812	8	LaGuardia	LaGuardia	NNP
18637	11812	9	Act	Act	NNP
18637	11812	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11812	11	;	;	:
18637	11812	12	29	29	CD
18637	11812	13	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	11813	1	101	101	CD
18637	11813	2	-	-	SYM
18637	11813	3	115	115	CD
18637	11813	4	.	.	.
18637	11814	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11814	2	70	70	CD
18637	11814	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11814	4	56	56	CD
18637	11814	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11814	6	.	.	.
18637	11815	1	31	31	CD
18637	11815	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11815	3	1942	1942	CD
18637	11815	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11815	5	,	,	,
18637	11815	6	§	§	NNP
18637	11815	7	204	204	CD
18637	11815	8	;	;	:
18637	11815	9	50	50	CD
18637	11815	10	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	11816	1	924	924	CD
18637	11816	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11816	3	App	App	NNP
18637	11816	4	.	.	.
18637	11816	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11816	6	.	.	.
18637	11817	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11817	2	71	71	CD
18637	11817	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11817	4	Freeman	Freeman	NNP
18637	11817	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11817	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11817	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11817	8	Howe	Howe	NNP
18637	11817	9	,	,	,
18637	11817	10	24	24	CD
18637	11817	11	How	how	WRB
18637	11817	12	.	.	.
18637	11818	1	450	450	CD
18637	11818	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11818	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	11818	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11818	5	;	;	:
18637	11818	6	Gaines	Gaines	NNP
18637	11818	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11818	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11818	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11818	10	Fuentes	Fuentes	NNP
18637	11818	11	,	,	,
18637	11818	12	92	92	CD
18637	11818	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11818	14	10	10	CD
18637	11818	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11818	16	1876	1876	CD
18637	11818	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11818	18	;	;	:
18637	11818	19	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11818	20	parte	parte	NN
18637	11818	21	Young	Young	NNP
18637	11818	22	,	,	,
18637	11818	23	209	209	CD
18637	11818	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11818	25	123	123	CD
18637	11818	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11818	27	1908	1908	CD
18637	11818	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11818	29	.	.	.
18637	11819	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11819	2	72	72	CD
18637	11819	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11819	4	Langnes	Langnes	NNP
18637	11819	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11819	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11819	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11819	8	Green	Green	NNP
18637	11819	9	,	,	,
18637	11819	10	282	282	CD
18637	11819	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11819	12	531	531	CD
18637	11819	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11819	14	1931	1931	CD
18637	11819	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11819	16	;	;	:
18637	11819	17	Riehle	Riehle	NNP
18637	11819	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11819	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	11819	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11819	21	Margolies	Margolies	NNP
18637	11819	22	,	,	,
18637	11819	23	270	270	CD
18637	11819	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11819	25	218	218	CD
18637	11819	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11819	27	1929	1929	CD
18637	11819	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11819	29	,	,	,
18637	11819	30	and	and	CC
18637	11819	31	Essanay	Essanay	NNP
18637	11819	32	Film	Film	NNP
18637	11819	33	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	11819	34	.	.	.
18637	11820	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11820	2	_	_	NNP
18637	11820	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	11820	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11820	5	Kane	Kane	NNP
18637	11820	6	,	,	,
18637	11820	7	258	258	CD
18637	11820	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11820	9	358	358	CD
18637	11820	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11820	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	11820	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11820	13	.	.	.
18637	11821	1	_	_	NNP
18637	11821	2	See	See	NNP
18637	11821	3	also	also	RB
18637	11821	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11821	5	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	11821	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11821	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	11821	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11821	9	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	11821	10	,	,	,
18637	11821	11	296	296	CD
18637	11821	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11821	13	393	393	CD
18637	11821	14	,	,	,
18637	11821	15	403	403	CD
18637	11821	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11821	17	1935	1935	CD
18637	11821	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11821	19	;	;	:
18637	11821	20	Kohn	Kohn	NNP
18637	11821	21	_	_	NNP
18637	11821	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	11821	23	_	_	NNP
18637	11821	24	Central	Central	NNP
18637	11821	25	Distributing	Distributing	NNP
18637	11821	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11821	27	,	,	,
18637	11821	28	306	306	CD
18637	11821	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11821	30	531	531	CD
18637	11821	31	,	,	,
18637	11821	32	534	534	CD
18637	11821	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11821	34	1939	1939	CD
18637	11821	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11821	36	;	;	:
18637	11821	37	and	and	CC
18637	11821	38	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	11821	39	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	11821	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11821	41	_	_	NNP
18637	11821	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	11821	43	_	_	NNP
18637	11821	44	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	11821	45	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	11821	46	and	and	CC
18637	11821	47	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	11821	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11821	49	,	,	,
18637	11821	50	309	309	CD
18637	11821	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11821	52	4	4	CD
18637	11821	53	,	,	,
18637	11821	54	9	9	CD
18637	11821	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11821	56	1940	1940	CD
18637	11821	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11821	58	.	.	.
18637	11822	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11822	2	73	73	CD
18637	11822	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11822	4	254	254	CD
18637	11822	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11822	6	443	443	CD
18637	11822	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11822	8	1921	1921	CD
18637	11822	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11822	10	.	.	.
18637	11823	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11823	2	74	74	CD
18637	11823	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11823	4	Lauf	Lauf	NNP
18637	11823	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11823	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11823	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11823	8	E.G.	E.G.	NNP
18637	11824	1	Shinner	Shinner	NNP
18637	11824	2	&	&	CC
18637	11824	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11824	4	,	,	,
18637	11824	5	303	303	CD
18637	11824	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11824	7	323	323	CD
18637	11824	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11824	9	1938	1938	CD
18637	11824	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11824	11	;	;	:
18637	11824	12	New	New	NNP
18637	11824	13	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	11824	14	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	11824	15	_	_	NNP
18637	11824	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	11824	17	_	_	NNP
18637	11824	18	Sanitary	Sanitary	NNP
18637	11824	19	Grocery	Grocery	NNP
18637	11824	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11824	21	,	,	,
18637	11824	22	303	303	CD
18637	11824	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11824	24	552	552	CD
18637	11824	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11824	26	1938	1938	CD
18637	11824	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11824	28	.	.	.
18637	11825	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11825	2	75	75	CD
18637	11825	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11825	4	In	in	IN
18637	11825	5	addition	addition	NN
18637	11825	6	to	to	IN
18637	11825	7	the	the	DT
18637	11825	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	11825	9	cited	cite	VBN
18637	11825	10	in	in	IN
18637	11825	11	note	note	NN
18637	11825	12	2	2	CD
18637	11825	13	,	,	,
18637	11825	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11825	15	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	11825	16	's	's	POS
18637	11825	17	Note	note	NN
18637	11825	18	:	:	:
18637	11825	19	Reference	reference	NN
18637	11825	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	11825	21	to	to	IN
18637	11825	22	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	11825	23	74	74	CD
18637	11825	24	,	,	,
18637	11825	25	above	above	RB
18637	11825	26	.	.	.
18637	11825	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11826	1	_	_	NNP
18637	11826	2	see	see	VBP
18637	11826	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11826	4	Milk	Milk	NNP
18637	11826	5	Wagon	Wagon	NNP
18637	11826	6	Drivers	Drivers	NNPS
18637	11826	7	'	'	POS
18637	11826	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	11826	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11826	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	11826	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11826	12	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	11826	13	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	11826	14	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	11826	15	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	11826	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11826	17	,	,	,
18637	11826	18	311	311	CD
18637	11826	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11826	20	91	91	CD
18637	11826	21	,	,	,
18637	11826	22	100	100	CD
18637	11826	23	-	-	SYM
18637	11826	24	103	103	CD
18637	11826	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11826	26	1940	1940	CD
18637	11826	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11826	28	.	.	.
18637	11827	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11827	2	76	76	CD
18637	11827	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11827	4	319	319	CD
18637	11827	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11827	6	182	182	CD
18637	11827	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11827	8	1943	1943	CD
18637	11827	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11827	10	.	.	.
18637	11828	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11828	2	77	77	CD
18637	11828	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11828	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11828	5	.	.	.
18637	11829	1	187	187	CD
18637	11829	2	,	,	,
18637	11829	3	quoting	quote	VBG
18637	11829	4	Cary	Cary	NNP
18637	11829	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11829	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11829	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11829	8	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	11829	9	,	,	,
18637	11829	10	3	3	CD
18637	11829	11	How	how	WRB
18637	11829	12	.	.	.
18637	11830	1	236	236	CD
18637	11830	2	,	,	,
18637	11830	3	245	245	CD
18637	11830	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11830	5	1845	1845	CD
18637	11830	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11830	7	.	.	.
18637	11831	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11831	2	78	78	CD
18637	11831	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11831	4	321	321	CD
18637	11831	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11831	6	414	414	CD
18637	11831	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11831	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	11831	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11831	10	.	.	.
18637	11832	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11832	2	79	79	CD
18637	11832	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11832	4	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	11832	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	11832	6	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	11832	7	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	11832	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11832	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11832	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	11832	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11832	12	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	11832	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11832	14	,	,	,
18637	11832	15	263	263	CD
18637	11832	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11832	17	629	629	CD
18637	11832	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11832	19	1924	1924	CD
18637	11832	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11832	21	.	.	.
18637	11833	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11833	2	80	80	CD
18637	11833	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11833	4	10	10	CD
18637	11833	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	11833	6	.	.	.
18637	11834	1	1	1	CD
18637	11834	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11834	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	11834	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11834	5	.	.	.
18637	11835	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11835	2	81	81	CD
18637	11835	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11835	4	106	106	CD
18637	11835	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11835	6	272	272	CD
18637	11835	7	,	,	,
18637	11835	8	280	280	CD
18637	11835	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11835	10	1882	1882	CD
18637	11835	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11835	12	.	.	.
18637	11836	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11836	2	82	82	CD
18637	11836	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11836	4	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	11836	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	11836	6	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	11836	7	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	11836	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11836	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11836	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	11836	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11836	12	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	11836	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11836	14	,	,	,
18637	11836	15	263	263	CD
18637	11836	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11836	17	629	629	CD
18637	11836	18	,	,	,
18637	11836	19	635	635	CD
18637	11836	20	,	,	,
18637	11836	21	636	636	CD
18637	11836	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11836	23	1924	1924	CD
18637	11836	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11836	25	.	.	.
18637	11837	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11837	2	83	83	CD
18637	11837	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11837	4	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	11837	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11837	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11837	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11837	8	Pless	Pless	NNP
18637	11837	9	,	,	,
18637	11837	10	238	238	CD
18637	11837	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11837	12	264	264	CD
18637	11837	13	,	,	,
18637	11837	14	266	266	CD
18637	11837	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11837	16	1915	1915	CD
18637	11837	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11837	18	;	;	:
18637	11837	19	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	11837	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11837	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	11837	22	_	_	NNP
18637	11837	23	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	11837	24	,	,	,
18637	11837	25	2	2	CD
18637	11837	26	How	how	WRB
18637	11837	27	.	.	.
18637	11838	1	244	244	CD
18637	11838	2	,	,	,
18637	11838	3	257	257	CD
18637	11838	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11838	5	1844	1844	CD
18637	11838	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11838	7	.	.	.
18637	11839	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11839	2	84	84	CD
18637	11839	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11839	4	Gumbel	Gumbel	NNP
18637	11839	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11839	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11839	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11839	8	Pitkin	Pitkin	NNP
18637	11839	9	,	,	,
18637	11839	10	124	124	CD
18637	11839	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11839	12	131	131	CD
18637	11839	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11839	14	1888	1888	CD
18637	11839	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11839	16	;	;	:
18637	11839	17	Covell	Covell	NNP
18637	11839	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11839	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	11839	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11839	21	Heyman	Heyman	NNP
18637	11839	22	,	,	,
18637	11839	23	111	111	CD
18637	11839	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11839	25	176	176	CD
18637	11839	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11839	27	1884	1884	CD
18637	11839	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11839	29	,	,	,
18637	11839	30	and	and	CC
18637	11839	31	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	11839	32	_	_	NNP
18637	11839	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	11839	34	_	_	NNP
18637	11839	35	Colbath	Colbath	NNP
18637	11839	36	,	,	,
18637	11839	37	3	3	CD
18637	11839	38	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	11839	39	.	.	.
18637	11840	1	334	334	CD
18637	11840	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11840	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	11840	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11840	5	.	.	.
18637	11841	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11841	2	85	85	CD
18637	11841	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11841	4	Eberly	eberly	RB
18637	11841	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11841	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11841	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11841	8	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	11841	9	,	,	,
18637	11841	10	24	24	CD
18637	11841	11	How	how	WRB
18637	11841	12	.	.	.
18637	11842	1	147	147	CD
18637	11842	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11842	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	11842	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11842	5	;	;	:
18637	11842	6	Arkadelphia	Arkadelphia	NNP
18637	11842	7	Milling	Milling	NNP
18637	11842	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11842	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11842	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	11842	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11842	12	St.	St.	NNP
18637	11842	13	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	11842	14	S.W.R.	S.W.R.	NNP
18637	11843	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11843	2	,	,	,
18637	11843	3	249	249	CD
18637	11843	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11843	5	134	134	CD
18637	11843	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11843	7	1919	1919	CD
18637	11843	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11843	9	.	.	.
18637	11844	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11844	2	86	86	CD
18637	11844	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11844	4	Gagnon	Gagnon	NNP
18637	11844	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11844	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11844	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11844	8	United	United	NNP
18637	11844	9	States	States	NNP
18637	11844	10	,	,	,
18637	11844	11	193	193	CD
18637	11844	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11844	13	451	451	CD
18637	11844	14	,	,	,
18637	11844	15	458	458	CD
18637	11844	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11844	17	1904	1904	CD
18637	11844	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11844	19	.	.	.
18637	11845	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11845	2	87	87	CD
18637	11845	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11845	4	2	2	CD
18637	11845	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	11845	6	.	.	.
18637	11846	1	123	123	CD
18637	11846	2	,	,	,
18637	11846	3	128	128	CD
18637	11846	4	-	-	SYM
18637	11846	5	129	129	CD
18637	11846	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11846	7	1864	1864	CD
18637	11846	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11846	9	.	.	.
18637	11847	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11847	2	88	88	CD
18637	11847	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11847	4	253	253	CD
18637	11847	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11847	6	300	300	CD
18637	11847	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11847	8	1920	1920	CD
18637	11847	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11847	10	.	.	.
18637	11848	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11848	2	89	89	CD
18637	11848	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11848	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11848	5	.	.	.
18637	11849	1	312	312	CD
18637	11849	2	.	.	.
18637	11850	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11850	2	90	90	CD
18637	11850	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11850	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11850	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	11850	6	Secombe	Secombe	NNP
18637	11850	7	,	,	,
18637	11850	8	19	19	CD
18637	11850	9	How	how	WRB
18637	11850	10	.	.	.
18637	11851	1	9	9	CD
18637	11851	2	,	,	,
18637	11851	3	13	13	CD
18637	11851	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11851	5	1857	1857	CD
18637	11851	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11851	7	.	.	.
18637	11852	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11852	2	91	91	CD
18637	11852	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11852	4	4	4	CD
18637	11852	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	11852	6	.	.	.
18637	11853	1	333	333	CD
18637	11853	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11853	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	11853	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11853	5	.	.	.
18637	11854	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11854	2	92	92	CD
18637	11854	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11854	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11854	5	.	.	.
18637	11855	1	378	378	CD
18637	11855	2	-	-	SYM
18637	11855	3	380	380	CD
18637	11855	4	.	.	.
18637	11856	1	For	for	IN
18637	11856	2	an	an	DT
18637	11856	3	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	11856	4	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	11856	5	of	of	IN
18637	11856	6	disbarment	disbarment	NN
18637	11856	7	and	and	CC
18637	11856	8	American	american	JJ
18637	11856	9	and	and	CC
18637	11856	10	English	english	JJ
18637	11856	11	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	11856	12	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	11856	13	,	,	,
18637	11856	14	_	_	NNP
18637	11856	15	see	see	VBP
18637	11856	16	_	_	NNP
18637	11856	17	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11856	18	parte	parte	NN
18637	11856	19	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	11856	20	,	,	,
18637	11856	21	107	107	CD
18637	11856	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11856	23	265	265	CD
18637	11856	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11856	25	1883	1883	CD
18637	11856	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11856	27	.	.	.
18637	11857	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11857	2	93	93	CD
18637	11857	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11857	4	Reorganization	reorganization	NN
18637	11857	5	of	of	IN
18637	11857	6	the	the	DT
18637	11857	7	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	11857	8	,	,	,
18637	11857	9	Hearings	Hearings	NNP
18637	11857	10	on	on	IN
18637	11857	11	S.	S.	NNP
18637	11857	12	1392	1392	CD
18637	11857	13	;	;	:
18637	11857	14	75th	75th	JJ
18637	11857	15	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	11857	16	.	.	NNP
18637	11857	17	,	,	,
18637	11857	18	1st	1st	JJ
18637	11857	19	sess	sess	NN
18637	11857	20	.	.	.
18637	11857	21	,	,	,
18637	11857	22	1937	1937	CD
18637	11857	23	,	,	,
18637	11857	24	Pt	Pt	NNP
18637	11857	25	.	.	.
18637	11858	1	3	3	CD
18637	11858	2	,	,	,
18637	11858	3	p.	p.	NN
18637	11858	4	491	491	CD
18637	11858	5	.	.	.
18637	11859	1	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	11859	2	Van	Van	NNP
18637	11859	3	Devanter	Devanter	NNP
18637	11859	4	and	and	CC
18637	11859	5	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	11859	6	approved	approve	VBD
18637	11859	7	the	the	DT
18637	11859	8	letter	letter	NN
18637	11859	9	.	.	.
18637	11860	1	For	for	IN
18637	11860	2	earlier	early	JJR
18637	11860	3	proposals	proposal	NNS
18637	11860	4	to	to	TO
18637	11860	5	have	have	VB
18637	11860	6	the	the	DT
18637	11860	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11860	8	sit	sit	VB
18637	11860	9	in	in	IN
18637	11860	10	divisions	division	NNS
18637	11860	11	,	,	,
18637	11860	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11860	13	see	see	VBP
18637	11860	14	_	_	NNP
18637	11860	15	Felix	Felix	NNP
18637	11860	16	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11860	17	and	and	CC
18637	11860	18	James	James	NNP
18637	11860	19	M.	M.	NNP
18637	11860	20	Landis	Landis	NNP
18637	11860	21	,	,	,
18637	11860	22	The	the	DT
18637	11860	23	Business	Business	NNP
18637	11860	24	of	of	IN
18637	11860	25	the	the	DT
18637	11860	26	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11860	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11860	28	,	,	,
18637	11860	29	pp	pp	NNP
18637	11860	30	.	.	.
18637	11861	1	81	81	CD
18637	11861	2	-	-	SYM
18637	11861	3	83	83	CD
18637	11861	4	,	,	,
18637	11861	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11861	6	New	New	NNP
18637	11861	7	York	York	NNP
18637	11861	8	,	,	,
18637	11861	9	1928	1928	CD
18637	11861	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11861	11	.	.	.
18637	11862	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11862	2	94	94	CD
18637	11862	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11862	4	1	1	CD
18637	11862	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11862	6	.	.	.
18637	11863	1	73	73	CD
18637	11863	2	-	-	SYM
18637	11863	3	74	74	CD
18637	11863	4	,	,	,
18637	11863	5	§	§	NNP
18637	11863	6	2	2	CD
18637	11863	7	-	-	SYM
18637	11863	8	3	3	CD
18637	11863	9	.	.	.
18637	11864	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11864	2	95	95	CD
18637	11864	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11864	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11864	5	.	.	.
18637	11865	1	73	73	CD
18637	11865	2	,	,	,
18637	11865	3	74	74	CD
18637	11865	4	-	-	SYM
18637	11865	5	76	76	CD
18637	11865	6	;	;	:
18637	11865	7	§	§	NNP
18637	11865	8	4	4	CD
18637	11865	9	-	-	SYM
18637	11865	10	5	5	CD
18637	11865	11	.	.	.
18637	11866	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11866	2	96	96	CD
18637	11866	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11866	4	2	2	CD
18637	11866	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11866	6	.	.	.
18637	11867	1	89	89	CD
18637	11867	2	.	.	.
18637	11868	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11868	2	97	97	CD
18637	11868	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11868	4	2	2	CD
18637	11868	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11868	6	.	.	.
18637	11869	1	132	132	CD
18637	11869	2	.	.	.
18637	11870	1	For	for	IN
18637	11870	2	a	a	DT
18637	11870	3	general	general	JJ
18637	11870	4	account	account	NN
18637	11870	5	of	of	IN
18637	11870	6	the	the	DT
18637	11870	7	events	event	NNS
18637	11870	8	leading	lead	VBG
18637	11870	9	to	to	IN
18637	11870	10	the	the	DT
18637	11870	11	acts	act	NNS
18637	11870	12	of	of	IN
18637	11870	13	1801	1801	CD
18637	11870	14	and	and	CC
18637	11870	15	1802	1802	CD
18637	11870	16	,	,	,
18637	11870	17	_	_	NNP
18637	11870	18	see	see	VBP
18637	11870	19	_	_	NNP
18637	11870	20	Felix	Felix	NNP
18637	11870	21	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11870	22	and	and	CC
18637	11870	23	James	James	NNP
18637	11870	24	M.	M.	NNP
18637	11870	25	Landis	Landis	NNP
18637	11870	26	,	,	,
18637	11870	27	The	the	DT
18637	11870	28	Business	Business	NNP
18637	11870	29	of	of	IN
18637	11870	30	the	the	DT
18637	11870	31	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11870	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11870	33	;	;	:
18637	11870	34	a	a	DT
18637	11870	35	study	study	NN
18637	11870	36	in	in	IN
18637	11870	37	the	the	DT
18637	11870	38	federal	federal	JJ
18637	11870	39	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11870	40	system	system	NN
18637	11870	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11870	42	New	New	NNP
18637	11870	43	York	York	NNP
18637	11870	44	,	,	,
18637	11870	45	1928	1928	CD
18637	11870	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11870	47	,	,	,
18637	11870	48	pp	pp	NNP
18637	11870	49	.	.	.
18637	11871	1	25	25	CD
18637	11871	2	-	-	SYM
18637	11871	3	32	32	CD
18637	11871	4	.	.	.
18637	11872	1	This	this	DT
18637	11872	2	book	book	NN
18637	11872	3	also	also	RB
18637	11872	4	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	11872	5	an	an	DT
18637	11872	6	excellent	excellent	JJ
18637	11872	7	account	account	NN
18637	11872	8	of	of	IN
18637	11872	9	the	the	DT
18637	11872	10	organization	organization	NN
18637	11872	11	and	and	CC
18637	11872	12	reorganization	reorganization	NN
18637	11872	13	of	of	IN
18637	11872	14	the	the	DT
18637	11872	15	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	11872	16	by	by	IN
18637	11872	17	statute	statute	NN
18637	11872	18	from	from	IN
18637	11872	19	time	time	NN
18637	11872	20	to	to	IN
18637	11872	21	time	time	NN
18637	11872	22	.	.	.
18637	11873	1	For	for	IN
18637	11873	2	another	another	DT
18637	11873	3	account	account	NN
18637	11873	4	of	of	IN
18637	11873	5	the	the	DT
18637	11873	6	acts	act	NNS
18637	11873	7	of	of	IN
18637	11873	8	1801	1801	CD
18637	11873	9	and	and	CC
18637	11873	10	1802	1802	CD
18637	11873	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11873	12	see	see	VBP
18637	11873	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11873	14	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	11873	15	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	11873	16	,	,	,
18637	11873	17	The	the	DT
18637	11873	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11873	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11873	20	in	in	IN
18637	11873	21	United	United	NNP
18637	11873	22	States	States	NNP
18637	11873	23	History	History	NNP
18637	11873	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11873	25	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	11873	26	,	,	,
18637	11873	27	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	11874	1	ed	ed	NNP
18637	11874	2	.	.	NNP
18637	11874	3	,	,	,
18637	11874	4	1932	1932	CD
18637	11874	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11874	6	,	,	,
18637	11874	7	189	189	CD
18637	11874	8	-	-	SYM
18637	11874	9	215	215	CD
18637	11874	10	.	.	.
18637	11875	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11875	2	98	98	CD
18637	11875	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11875	4	1	1	CD
18637	11875	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	11875	6	.	.	.
18637	11876	1	299	299	CD
18637	11876	2	,	,	,
18637	11876	3	309	309	CD
18637	11876	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11876	5	1803	1803	CD
18637	11876	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11876	7	.	.	.
18637	11877	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11877	2	99	99	CD
18637	11877	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11877	4	38	38	CD
18637	11877	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11877	6	.	.	.
18637	11878	1	208	208	CD
18637	11878	2	,	,	,
18637	11878	3	219	219	CD
18637	11878	4	-	-	SYM
18637	11878	5	221	221	CD
18637	11878	6	.	.	.
18637	11879	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11879	2	100	100	CD
18637	11879	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11879	4	Prior	prior	RB
18637	11879	5	to	to	IN
18637	11879	6	the	the	DT
18637	11879	7	act	act	NN
18637	11879	8	of	of	IN
18637	11879	9	1913	1913	CD
18637	11879	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11879	11	had	have	VBD
18637	11879	12	voted	vote	VBN
18637	11879	13	to	to	TO
18637	11879	14	abolish	abolish	VB
18637	11879	15	the	the	DT
18637	11879	16	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	11879	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11879	18	,	,	,
18637	11879	19	but	but	CC
18637	11879	20	President	President	NNP
18637	11879	21	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	11879	22	vetoed	veto	VBD
18637	11879	23	the	the	DT
18637	11879	24	bill	bill	NN
18637	11879	25	which	which	WDT
18637	11879	26	converted	convert	VBD
18637	11879	27	the	the	DT
18637	11879	28	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	11879	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11879	30	judges	judge	NNS
18637	11879	31	into	into	IN
18637	11879	32	ambulatory	ambulatory	JJ
18637	11879	33	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	11879	34	judges	judge	NNS
18637	11879	35	.	.	.
18637	11880	1	For	for	IN
18637	11880	2	a	a	DT
18637	11880	3	general	general	JJ
18637	11880	4	account	account	NN
18637	11880	5	of	of	IN
18637	11880	6	the	the	DT
18637	11880	7	abolition	abolition	NN
18637	11880	8	of	of	IN
18637	11880	9	the	the	DT
18637	11880	10	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	11880	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11880	12	,	,	,
18637	11880	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11880	14	see	see	VBP
18637	11880	15	_	_	NNP
18637	11880	16	Felix	Felix	NNP
18637	11880	17	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11880	18	and	and	CC
18637	11880	19	James	James	NNP
18637	11880	20	M.	M.	NNP
18637	11880	21	Landis	Landis	NNP
18637	11880	22	,	,	,
18637	11880	23	The	the	DT
18637	11880	24	Business	Business	NNP
18637	11880	25	of	of	IN
18637	11880	26	the	the	DT
18637	11880	27	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11880	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11880	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11880	30	New	New	NNP
18637	11880	31	York	York	NNP
18637	11880	32	,	,	,
18637	11880	33	1928	1928	CD
18637	11880	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11880	35	,	,	,
18637	11880	36	pp	pp	NNP
18637	11880	37	.	.	.
18637	11881	1	166	166	CD
18637	11881	2	-	-	SYM
18637	11881	3	173	173	CD
18637	11881	4	.	.	.
18637	11882	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11882	2	101	101	CD
18637	11882	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11882	4	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	11882	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11882	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11882	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11882	8	Gore	Gore	NNP
18637	11882	9	,	,	,
18637	11882	10	253	253	CD
18637	11882	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11882	12	245	245	CD
18637	11882	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11882	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	11882	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11882	16	.	.	.
18637	11883	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11883	2	102	102	CD
18637	11883	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11883	4	268	268	CD
18637	11883	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11883	6	501	501	CD
18637	11883	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11883	8	1925	1925	CD
18637	11883	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11883	10	.	.	.
18637	11884	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11884	2	103	103	CD
18637	11884	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11884	4	307	307	CD
18637	11884	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11884	6	277	277	CD
18637	11884	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11884	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	11884	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11884	10	.	.	.
18637	11885	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11885	2	104	104	CD
18637	11885	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11885	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11885	5	.	.	.
18637	11886	1	278	278	CD
18637	11886	2	-	-	SYM
18637	11886	3	282	282	CD
18637	11886	4	.	.	.
18637	11887	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11887	2	105	105	CD
18637	11887	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11887	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11887	5	.	.	.
18637	11888	1	282	282	CD
18637	11888	2	.	.	.
18637	11889	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11889	2	106	106	CD
18637	11889	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11889	4	289	289	CD
18637	11889	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11889	6	516	516	CD
18637	11889	7	,	,	,
18637	11889	8	526	526	CD
18637	11889	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11889	10	1933	1933	CD
18637	11889	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11889	12	.	.	.
18637	11890	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11890	2	107	107	CD
18637	11890	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11890	4	289	289	CD
18637	11890	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11890	6	553	553	CD
18637	11890	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11890	8	1933	1933	CD
18637	11890	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11890	10	.	.	.
18637	11891	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11891	2	108	108	CD
18637	11891	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11891	4	36	36	CD
18637	11891	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11891	6	.	.	.
18637	11892	1	539	539	CD
18637	11892	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11892	3	1910	1910	CD
18637	11892	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11892	5	.	.	.
18637	11893	1	For	for	IN
18637	11893	2	the	the	DT
18637	11893	3	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	11893	4	history	history	NN
18637	11893	5	of	of	IN
18637	11893	6	the	the	DT
18637	11893	7	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	11893	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11893	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11893	10	see	see	VB
18637	11893	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11893	12	Felix	Felix	NNP
18637	11893	13	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	11893	14	and	and	CC
18637	11893	15	James	James	NNP
18637	11893	16	M.	M.	NNP
18637	11893	17	Landis	Landis	NNP
18637	11893	18	,	,	,
18637	11893	19	The	the	DT
18637	11893	20	Business	Business	NNP
18637	11893	21	of	of	IN
18637	11893	22	the	the	DT
18637	11893	23	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11893	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11893	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11893	26	New	New	NNP
18637	11893	27	York	York	NNP
18637	11893	28	,	,	,
18637	11893	29	1928	1928	CD
18637	11893	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11893	31	,	,	,
18637	11893	32	pp	pp	NNP
18637	11893	33	.	.	.
18637	11894	1	155	155	CD
18637	11894	2	-	-	SYM
18637	11894	3	164	164	CD
18637	11894	4	.	.	.
18637	11895	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11895	2	109	109	CD
18637	11895	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11895	4	56	56	CD
18637	11895	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	11895	6	.	.	.
18637	11896	1	23	23	CD
18637	11896	2	,	,	,
18637	11896	3	31	31	CD
18637	11896	4	-	-	SYM
18637	11896	5	33	33	CD
18637	11896	6	.	.	.
18637	11897	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11897	2	110	110	CD
18637	11897	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11897	4	In	in	IN
18637	11897	5	Lockerty	Lockerty	NNP
18637	11897	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11897	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	11897	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11897	9	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	11897	10	,	,	,
18637	11897	11	319	319	CD
18637	11897	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11897	13	182	182	CD
18637	11897	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11897	15	1943	1943	CD
18637	11897	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11897	17	,	,	,
18637	11897	18	the	the	DT
18637	11897	19	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	11897	20	on	on	IN
18637	11897	21	the	the	DT
18637	11897	22	use	use	NN
18637	11897	23	of	of	IN
18637	11897	24	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	11897	25	,	,	,
18637	11897	26	except	except	IN
18637	11897	27	the	the	DT
18637	11897	28	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	11897	29	against	against	IN
18637	11897	30	interlocutory	interlocutory	JJ
18637	11897	31	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	11897	32	,	,	,
18637	11897	33	was	be	VBD
18637	11897	34	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	11897	35	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	11897	36	.	.	.
18637	11898	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11898	2	111	111	CD
18637	11898	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11898	4	321	321	CD
18637	11898	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11898	6	414	414	CD
18637	11898	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11898	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	11898	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11898	10	.	.	.
18637	11899	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11899	2	112	112	CD
18637	11899	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11899	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11899	5	.	.	.
18637	11900	1	444	444	CD
18637	11900	2	.	.	.
18637	11901	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11901	2	113	113	CD
18637	11901	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11901	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11901	5	.	.	.
18637	11902	1	468	468	CD
18637	11902	2	.	.	.
18637	11903	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11903	2	114	114	CD
18637	11903	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11903	4	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	11903	5	.	.	.
18637	11904	1	511	511	CD
18637	11904	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11904	3	1928	1928	CD
18637	11904	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11904	5	.	.	.
18637	11905	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11905	2	115	115	CD
18637	11905	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11905	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11905	5	.	.	.
18637	11906	1	546	546	CD
18637	11906	2	.	.	.
18637	11907	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11907	2	116	116	CD
18637	11907	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11907	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11907	5	.	.	.
18637	11908	1	546	546	CD
18637	11908	2	.	.	.
18637	11909	1	Closely	closely	RB
18637	11909	2	analogous	analogous	JJ
18637	11909	3	to	to	IN
18637	11909	4	the	the	DT
18637	11909	5	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	11909	6	courts	court	NNS
18637	11909	7	are	be	VBP
18637	11909	8	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	JJ
18637	11909	9	and	and	CC
18637	11909	10	consular	consular	JJ
18637	11909	11	courts	court	NNS
18637	11909	12	created	create	VBN
18637	11909	13	in	in	IN
18637	11909	14	the	the	DT
18637	11909	15	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	11909	16	of	of	IN
18637	11909	17	the	the	DT
18637	11909	18	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	11909	19	relations	relation	NNS
18637	11909	20	power	power	NN
18637	11909	21	.	.	.
18637	11910	1	_	_	NNP
18637	11910	2	See	See	NNP
18637	11910	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11910	4	In	In	NNP
18637	11910	5	re	re	IN
18637	11910	6	Ross	Ross	NNP
18637	11910	7	,	,	,
18637	11910	8	140	140	CD
18637	11910	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11910	10	453	453	CD
18637	11910	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11910	12	1891	1891	CD
18637	11910	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11910	14	.	.	.
18637	11911	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11911	2	117	117	CD
18637	11911	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11911	4	279	279	CD
18637	11911	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11911	6	438	438	CD
18637	11911	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11911	8	1929	1929	CD
18637	11911	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11911	10	.	.	.
18637	11912	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11912	2	118	118	CD
18637	11912	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11912	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11912	5	.	.	.
18637	11913	1	451	451	CD
18637	11913	2	.	.	.
18637	11914	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11914	2	119	119	CD
18637	11914	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11914	4	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	11914	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11914	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11914	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11914	8	United	United	NNP
18637	11914	9	States	States	NNP
18637	11914	10	,	,	,
18637	11914	11	117	117	CD
18637	11914	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11914	13	697	697	CD
18637	11914	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11914	15	1886	1886	CD
18637	11914	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11914	17	;	;	:
18637	11914	18	McElrath	McElrath	NNP
18637	11914	19	_	_	NNP
18637	11914	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	11914	21	_	_	NNP
18637	11914	22	United	United	NNP
18637	11914	23	States	States	NNP
18637	11914	24	,	,	,
18637	11914	25	102	102	CD
18637	11914	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11914	27	426	426	CD
18637	11914	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11914	29	1880	1880	CD
18637	11914	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11914	31	;	;	:
18637	11914	32	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	11914	33	_	_	NNP
18637	11914	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	11914	35	_	_	NNP
18637	11914	36	United	United	NNP
18637	11914	37	States	States	NNP
18637	11914	38	,	,	,
18637	11914	39	289	289	CD
18637	11914	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11914	41	553	553	CD
18637	11914	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11914	43	1933	1933	CD
18637	11914	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11914	45	.	.	.
18637	11915	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11915	2	120	120	CD
18637	11915	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11915	4	United	United	NNP
18637	11915	5	States	States	NNP
18637	11915	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11915	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	11915	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11915	9	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	11915	10	,	,	,
18637	11915	11	155	155	CD
18637	11915	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11915	13	76	76	CD
18637	11915	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11915	15	1894	1894	CD
18637	11915	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11915	17	.	.	.
18637	11916	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11916	2	121	121	CD
18637	11916	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11916	4	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	11916	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11916	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11916	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11916	8	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	11916	9	,	,	,
18637	11916	10	204	204	CD
18637	11916	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11916	12	415	415	CD
18637	11916	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11916	14	1907	1907	CD
18637	11916	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11916	16	.	.	.
18637	11917	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11917	2	122	122	CD
18637	11917	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11917	4	Old	Old	NNP
18637	11917	5	Colony	Colony	NNP
18637	11917	6	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	11917	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11917	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11917	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	11917	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11917	11	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	11917	12	of	of	IN
18637	11917	13	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	11917	14	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	11917	15	,	,	,
18637	11917	16	279	279	CD
18637	11917	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11917	18	716	716	CD
18637	11917	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11917	20	1929	1929	CD
18637	11917	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11917	22	;	;	:
18637	11917	23	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	11917	24	parte	parte	VBZ
18637	11917	25	Bakelite	Bakelite	NNP
18637	11917	26	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	11917	27	,	,	,
18637	11917	28	279	279	CD
18637	11917	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11917	30	438	438	CD
18637	11917	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11917	32	1929	1929	CD
18637	11917	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11917	34	.	.	.
18637	11918	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11918	2	123	123	CD
18637	11918	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11918	4	The	the	DT
18637	11918	5	general	general	JJ
18637	11918	6	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	11918	7	in	in	IN
18637	11918	8	the	the	DT
18637	11918	9	evolution	evolution	NN
18637	11918	10	of	of	IN
18637	11918	11	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	11918	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	11918	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	11918	14	to	to	TO
18637	11918	15	provide	provide	VB
18637	11918	16	for	for	IN
18637	11918	17	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	11918	18	during	during	IN
18637	11918	19	good	good	JJ
18637	11918	20	behavior	behavior	NN
18637	11918	21	.	.	.
18637	11919	1	This	this	DT
18637	11919	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	11919	3	true	true	JJ
18637	11919	4	of	of	IN
18637	11919	5	the	the	DT
18637	11919	6	judges	judge	NNS
18637	11919	7	of	of	IN
18637	11919	8	the	the	DT
18637	11919	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11919	10	of	of	IN
18637	11919	11	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	11919	12	,	,	,
18637	11919	13	the	the	DT
18637	11919	14	Customs	Customs	NNP
18637	11919	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11919	16	,	,	,
18637	11919	17	the	the	DT
18637	11919	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11919	19	of	of	IN
18637	11919	20	Customs	Customs	NNP
18637	11919	21	and	and	CC
18637	11919	22	Patent	Patent	NNP
18637	11919	23	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	11919	24	.	.	.
18637	11920	1	The	the	DT
18637	11920	2	terms	term	NNS
18637	11920	3	of	of	IN
18637	11920	4	the	the	DT
18637	11920	5	judges	judge	NNS
18637	11920	6	of	of	IN
18637	11920	7	the	the	DT
18637	11920	8	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	11920	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11920	10	are	be	VBP
18637	11920	11	limited	limit	VBN
18637	11920	12	to	to	IN
18637	11920	13	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	11920	14	years	year	NNS
18637	11920	15	and	and	CC
18637	11920	16	the	the	DT
18637	11920	17	judges	judge	NNS
18637	11920	18	are	be	VBP
18637	11920	19	subject	subject	JJ
18637	11920	20	to	to	IN
18637	11920	21	removal	removal	NN
18637	11920	22	by	by	IN
18637	11920	23	the	the	DT
18637	11920	24	President	President	NNP
18637	11920	25	after	after	IN
18637	11920	26	notice	notice	NN
18637	11920	27	and	and	CC
18637	11920	28	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	11920	29	.	.	.
18637	11921	1	For	for	IN
18637	11921	2	the	the	DT
18637	11921	3	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	11921	4	of	of	IN
18637	11921	5	the	the	DT
18637	11921	6	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	11921	7	governing	govern	VBG
18637	11921	8	these	these	DT
18637	11921	9	matters	matter	NNS
18637	11921	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11921	11	see	see	VBP
18637	11921	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11921	13	28	28	CD
18637	11921	14	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
18637	11922	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	11922	2	241	241	CD
18637	11922	3	,	,	,
18637	11922	4	296	296	CD
18637	11922	5	,	,	,
18637	11922	6	301	301	CD
18637	11922	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	11922	8	301a	301a	NNS
18637	11922	9	;	;	:
18637	11922	10	26	26	CD
18637	11922	11	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	11923	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	11923	2	1102b	1102b	NNS
18637	11923	3	,	,	,
18637	11923	4	d	d	NNP
18637	11923	5	,	,	,
18637	11923	6	f.	f.	NNP
18637	11923	7	The	the	DT
18637	11923	8	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	11923	9	judges	judge	NNS
18637	11923	10	in	in	IN
18637	11923	11	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	11923	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11923	13	48	48	CD
18637	11923	14	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	11924	1	§	§	NNP
18637	11924	2	112	112	CD
18637	11924	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11924	4	have	have	VBP
18637	11924	5	four	four	CD
18637	11924	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	11924	7	year	year	NN
18637	11924	8	terms	term	NNS
18637	11924	9	subject	subject	JJ
18637	11924	10	to	to	IN
18637	11924	11	removal	removal	NN
18637	11924	12	by	by	IN
18637	11924	13	the	the	DT
18637	11924	14	President	President	NNP
18637	11924	15	;	;	:
18637	11924	16	in	in	IN
18637	11924	17	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	11924	18	six	six	CD
18637	11924	19	years	year	NNS
18637	11924	20	unless	unless	IN
18637	11924	21	removed	remove	VBN
18637	11924	22	by	by	IN
18637	11924	23	the	the	DT
18637	11924	24	President	President	NNP
18637	11924	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11924	26	48	48	CD
18637	11924	27	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	11925	1	§	§	NNP
18637	11925	2	643	643	CD
18637	11925	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11925	4	,	,	,
18637	11925	5	eight	eight	CD
18637	11925	6	years	year	NNS
18637	11925	7	in	in	IN
18637	11925	8	Puerto	Puerto	NNP
18637	11925	9	Rico	Rico	NNP
18637	11925	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11925	11	28	28	CD
18637	11925	12	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
18637	11926	1	§	§	NNP
18637	11926	2	803	803	CD
18637	11926	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11926	4	;	;	:
18637	11926	5	eight	eight	CD
18637	11926	6	years	year	NNS
18637	11926	7	in	in	IN
18637	11926	8	the	the	DT
18637	11926	9	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	11926	10	Zone	Zone	NNP
18637	11926	11	subject	subject	NN
18637	11926	12	to	to	IN
18637	11926	13	removal	removal	NN
18637	11926	14	by	by	IN
18637	11926	15	the	the	DT
18637	11926	16	President	President	NNP
18637	11926	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11926	18	48	48	CD
18637	11926	19	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	11927	1	§	§	NNP
18637	11927	2	1353	1353	CD
18637	11927	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11927	4	;	;	:
18637	11927	5	and	and	CC
18637	11927	6	four	four	CD
18637	11927	7	years	year	NNS
18637	11927	8	in	in	IN
18637	11927	9	the	the	DT
18637	11927	10	Virgin	Virgin	NNP
18637	11927	11	Islands	Islands	NNP
18637	11927	12	unless	unless	IN
18637	11927	13	sooner	soon	RBR
18637	11927	14	removed	remove	VBN
18637	11927	15	by	by	IN
18637	11927	16	the	the	DT
18637	11927	17	President	President	NNP
18637	11927	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11927	19	48	48	CD
18637	11927	20	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	11928	1	§	§	NNP
18637	11928	2	1405y	1405y	CD
18637	11928	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11928	4	.	.	.
18637	11929	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11929	2	124	124	CD
18637	11929	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11929	4	141	141	CD
18637	11929	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11929	6	174	174	CD
18637	11929	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11929	8	1891	1891	CD
18637	11929	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11929	10	.	.	.
18637	11930	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11930	2	125	125	CD
18637	11930	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11930	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11930	5	.	.	.
18637	11931	1	188	188	CD
18637	11931	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11931	3	126	126	CD
18637	11931	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11931	5	289	289	CD
18637	11931	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11931	7	553	553	CD
18637	11931	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11931	9	1933	1933	CD
18637	11931	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11931	11	.	.	.
18637	11932	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11932	2	127	127	CD
18637	11932	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11932	4	268	268	CD
18637	11932	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11932	6	501	501	CD
18637	11932	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11932	8	1925	1925	CD
18637	11932	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11932	10	.	.	.
18637	11933	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11933	2	128	128	CD
18637	11933	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11933	4	117	117	CD
18637	11933	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11933	6	697	697	CD
18637	11933	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11933	8	1886	1886	CD
18637	11933	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11933	10	.	.	.
18637	11934	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11934	2	129	129	CD
18637	11934	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11934	4	13	13	CD
18637	11934	5	How	how	WRB
18637	11934	6	.	.	.
18637	11935	1	40	40	CD
18637	11935	2	,	,	,
18637	11935	3	48	48	CD
18637	11935	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11935	5	1852	1852	CD
18637	11935	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11935	7	.	.	.
18637	11936	1	_	_	NNP
18637	11936	2	See	See	NNP
18637	11936	3	also	also	RB
18637	11936	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11936	5	Keller	Keller	NNP
18637	11936	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11936	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	11936	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11936	9	Potomac	Potomac	NNP
18637	11936	10	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	11936	11	Power	Power	NNP
18637	11936	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11936	13	,	,	,
18637	11936	14	261	261	CD
18637	11936	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11936	16	428	428	CD
18637	11936	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11936	18	1923	1923	CD
18637	11936	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11936	20	;	;	:
18637	11936	21	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11936	22	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	11936	23	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	11936	24	_	_	NNP
18637	11936	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	11936	26	_	_	NNP
18637	11936	27	General	General	NNP
18637	11936	28	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	11936	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11936	30	,	,	,
18637	11936	31	231	231	CD
18637	11936	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11936	33	464	464	CD
18637	11936	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11936	35	1930	1930	CD
18637	11936	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11936	37	.	.	.
18637	11937	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11937	2	130	130	CD
18637	11937	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11937	4	5	5	CD
18637	11937	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	11937	6	.	.	.
18637	11938	1	419	419	CD
18637	11938	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11938	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	11938	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11938	5	.	.	.
18637	11939	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11939	2	131	131	CD
18637	11939	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11939	4	Postum	Postum	NNP
18637	11939	5	Cereal	Cereal	NNP
18637	11939	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11939	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11939	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11939	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11939	10	California	California	NNP
18637	11939	11	Fig	Fig	NNP
18637	11939	12	Nut	Nut	NNP
18637	11939	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11939	14	,	,	,
18637	11939	15	272	272	CD
18637	11939	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11939	17	693	693	CD
18637	11939	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11939	19	1927	1927	CD
18637	11939	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11939	21	;	;	:
18637	11939	22	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11939	23	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	11939	24	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	11939	25	_	_	NNP
18637	11939	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	11939	27	_	_	NNP
18637	11939	28	General	General	NNP
18637	11939	29	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	11939	30	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11939	31	,	,	,
18637	11939	32	281	281	CD
18637	11939	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11939	34	464	464	CD
18637	11939	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11939	36	1930	1930	CD
18637	11939	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11939	38	;	;	:
18637	11939	39	Pope	Pope	NNP
18637	11939	40	_	_	NNP
18637	11939	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	11939	42	_	_	NNP
18637	11939	43	United	United	NNP
18637	11939	44	States	States	NNP
18637	11939	45	,	,	,
18637	11939	46	323	323	CD
18637	11939	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11939	48	1	1	CD
18637	11939	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11939	50	1944	1944	CD
18637	11939	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11939	52	.	.	.
18637	11940	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11940	2	132	132	CD
18637	11940	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11940	4	112	112	CD
18637	11940	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11940	6	50	50	CD
18637	11940	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11940	8	1884	1884	CD
18637	11940	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11940	10	.	.	.
18637	11941	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11941	2	133	133	CD
18637	11941	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11941	4	Keller	Keller	NNP
18637	11941	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11941	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11941	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11941	8	Potomac	Potomac	NNP
18637	11941	9	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	11941	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11941	11	,	,	,
18637	11941	12	261	261	CD
18637	11941	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11941	14	428	428	CD
18637	11941	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11941	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	11941	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11941	18	.	.	.
18637	11942	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11942	2	134	134	CD
18637	11942	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11942	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11942	5	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	11942	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	11942	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11942	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11942	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11942	10	General	General	NNP
18637	11942	11	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	11942	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11942	13	,	,	,
18637	11942	14	281	281	CD
18637	11942	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11942	16	464	464	CD
18637	11942	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11942	18	1930	1930	CD
18637	11942	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11942	20	.	.	.
18637	11943	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11943	2	135	135	CD
18637	11943	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11943	4	279	279	CD
18637	11943	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11943	6	438	438	CD
18637	11943	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11943	8	1929	1929	CD
18637	11943	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11943	10	.	.	.
18637	11944	1	All	all	DT
18637	11944	2	of	of	IN
18637	11944	3	these	these	DT
18637	11944	4	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	11944	5	with	with	IN
18637	11944	6	respect	respect	NN
18637	11944	7	to	to	IN
18637	11944	8	the	the	DT
18637	11944	9	vesting	vesting	NN
18637	11944	10	of	of	IN
18637	11944	11	revisory	revisory	JJ
18637	11944	12	powers	power	NNS
18637	11944	13	in	in	IN
18637	11944	14	the	the	DT
18637	11944	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	11944	16	of	of	IN
18637	11944	17	the	the	DT
18637	11944	18	District	District	NNP
18637	11944	19	carried	carry	VBD
18637	11944	20	the	the	DT
18637	11944	21	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	11944	22	that	that	IN
18637	11944	23	revisory	revisory	JJ
18637	11944	24	actions	action	NNS
18637	11944	25	and	and	CC
18637	11944	26	interlocutory	interlocutory	JJ
18637	11944	27	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	11944	28	,	,	,
18637	11944	29	as	as	IN
18637	11944	30	nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	11944	31	functions	function	NNS
18637	11944	32	,	,	,
18637	11944	33	were	be	VBD
18637	11944	34	not	not	RB
18637	11944	35	reviewable	reviewable	JJ
18637	11944	36	on	on	IN
18637	11944	37	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	11944	38	to	to	IN
18637	11944	39	the	the	DT
18637	11944	40	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	11944	41	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11944	42	of	of	IN
18637	11944	43	the	the	DT
18637	11944	44	United	United	NNP
18637	11944	45	States	States	NNP
18637	11944	46	.	.	.
18637	11945	1	Frasch	Frasch	NNP
18637	11945	2	_	_	NNP
18637	11945	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	11945	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11945	5	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	11945	6	,	,	,
18637	11945	7	211	211	CD
18637	11945	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11945	9	1	1	CD
18637	11945	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11945	11	1908	1908	CD
18637	11945	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11945	13	;	;	:
18637	11945	14	E.C.	E.C.	NNP
18637	11946	1	Atkins	Atkins	NNP
18637	11946	2	&	&	CC
18637	11946	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11946	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11946	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	11946	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11946	7	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	11946	8	,	,	,
18637	11946	9	212	212	CD
18637	11946	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11946	11	285	285	CD
18637	11946	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11946	13	1909	1909	CD
18637	11946	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11946	15	;	;	:
18637	11946	16	Keller	Keller	NNP
18637	11946	17	_	_	NNP
18637	11946	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	11946	19	_	_	NNP
18637	11946	20	Potomac	Potomac	NNP
18637	11946	21	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	11946	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11946	23	,	,	,
18637	11946	24	261	261	CD
18637	11946	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11946	26	428	428	CD
18637	11946	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11946	28	1923	1923	CD
18637	11946	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11946	30	;	;	:
18637	11946	31	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	11946	32	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	11946	33	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	11946	34	_	_	NNP
18637	11946	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	11946	36	_	_	NNP
18637	11946	37	General	General	NNP
18637	11946	38	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	11946	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11946	40	,	,	,
18637	11946	41	281	281	CD
18637	11946	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11946	43	464	464	CD
18637	11946	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11946	45	1930	1930	CD
18637	11946	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11946	47	.	.	.
18637	11947	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11947	2	136	136	CD
18637	11947	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11947	4	O'Donoghue	O'Donoghue	NNP
18637	11947	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11947	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11947	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11947	8	United	United	NNP
18637	11947	9	States	States	NNP
18637	11947	10	,	,	,
18637	11947	11	289	289	CD
18637	11947	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11947	13	516	516	CD
18637	11947	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11947	15	1933	1933	CD
18637	11947	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11947	17	.	.	.
18637	11948	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11948	2	137	137	CD
18637	11948	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11948	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11948	5	.	.	.
18637	11949	1	545	545	CD
18637	11949	2	-	-	SYM
18637	11949	3	546	546	CD
18637	11949	4	.	.	.
18637	11950	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11950	2	138	138	CD
18637	11950	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11950	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11950	5	.	.	.
18637	11951	1	545	545	CD
18637	11951	2	.	.	.
18637	11952	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11952	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11952	3	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	11952	4	in	in	IN
18637	11952	5	a	a	DT
18637	11952	6	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11952	7	joined	join	VBN
18637	11952	8	by	by	IN
18637	11952	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11952	10	Van	Van	NNP
18637	11952	11	Devanter	Devanter	NNP
18637	11952	12	and	and	CC
18637	11952	13	Cardozo	Cardozo	NNP
18637	11952	14	took	take	VBD
18637	11952	15	the	the	DT
18637	11952	16	position	position	NN
18637	11952	17	that	that	IN
18637	11952	18	the	the	DT
18637	11952	19	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	11952	20	power	power	NN
18637	11952	21	of	of	IN
18637	11952	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	11952	23	over	over	IN
18637	11952	24	the	the	DT
18637	11952	25	District	district	NN
18637	11952	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	11952	27	complete	complete	JJ
18637	11952	28	in	in	IN
18637	11952	29	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11952	30	and	and	CC
18637	11952	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	11952	32	power	power	NN
18637	11952	33	to	to	TO
18637	11952	34	create	create	VB
18637	11952	35	courts	court	NNS
18637	11952	36	in	in	IN
18637	11952	37	the	the	DT
18637	11952	38	District	District	NNP
18637	11952	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	11952	40	not	not	RB
18637	11952	41	derived	derive	VBN
18637	11952	42	from	from	IN
18637	11952	43	article	article	NN
18637	11952	44	III	iii	CD
18637	11952	45	.	.	.
18637	11953	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	11953	2	,	,	,
18637	11953	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11953	4	argued	argue	VBD
18637	11953	5	that	that	IN
18637	11953	6	the	the	DT
18637	11953	7	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	11953	8	of	of	IN
18637	11953	9	article	article	NN
18637	11953	10	III	iii	CD
18637	11953	11	do	do	VBP
18637	11953	12	not	not	RB
18637	11953	13	apply	apply	VB
18637	11953	14	to	to	IN
18637	11953	15	the	the	DT
18637	11953	16	organization	organization	NN
18637	11953	17	of	of	IN
18637	11953	18	such	such	JJ
18637	11953	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	11953	20	.	.	.
18637	11954	1	The	the	DT
18637	11954	2	O'Donoghue	O'Donoghue	NNP
18637	11954	3	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11954	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	11954	5	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	11954	6	in	in	IN
18637	11954	7	the	the	DT
18637	11954	8	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	11954	9	of	of	IN
18637	11954	10	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	11954	11	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	11954	12	and	and	CC
18637	11954	13	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	11954	14	and	and	CC
18637	11954	15	in	in	IN
18637	11954	16	the	the	DT
18637	11954	17	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	11954	18	of	of	IN
18637	11954	19	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	11954	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11954	21	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	11954	22	in	in	IN
18637	11954	23	National	National	NNP
18637	11954	24	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	11954	25	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	11954	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11954	27	_	_	NNP
18637	11954	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	11954	29	_	_	NNP
18637	11954	30	Tidewater	Tidewater	NNP
18637	11954	31	Transfer	Transfer	NNP
18637	11954	32	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11954	33	,	,	,
18637	11954	34	337	337	CD
18637	11954	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11954	36	582	582	CD
18637	11954	37	,	,	,
18637	11954	38	601	601	CD
18637	11954	39	-	-	SYM
18637	11954	40	602	602	CD
18637	11954	41	,	,	,
18637	11954	42	608	608	CD
18637	11954	43	-	-	SYM
18637	11954	44	611	611	CD
18637	11954	45	,	,	,
18637	11954	46	638	638	CD
18637	11954	47	-	-	SYM
18637	11954	48	640	640	CD
18637	11954	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11954	50	1949	1949	CD
18637	11954	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11954	52	.	.	.
18637	11955	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11955	2	139	139	CD
18637	11955	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11955	4	6	6	CD
18637	11955	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	11955	6	.	.	.
18637	11956	1	264	264	CD
18637	11956	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11956	3	1821	1821	CD
18637	11956	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11956	5	.	.	.
18637	11957	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11957	2	140	140	CD
18637	11957	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11957	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11957	5	.	.	.
18637	11958	1	378	378	CD
18637	11958	2	.	.	.
18637	11959	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11959	2	141	141	CD
18637	11959	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11959	4	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	11959	5	,	,	,
18637	11959	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	11959	7	,	,	,
18637	11959	8	314	314	CD
18637	11959	9	,	,	,
18637	11959	10	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	11959	11	in	in	IN
18637	11959	12	Muskrat	Muskrat	NNP
18637	11959	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11959	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	11959	15	_	_	NNP
18637	11959	16	United	United	NNP
18637	11959	17	States	States	NNP
18637	11959	18	,	,	,
18637	11959	19	219	219	CD
18637	11959	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11959	21	346	346	CD
18637	11959	22	,	,	,
18637	11959	23	356	356	CD
18637	11959	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11959	25	1911	1911	CD
18637	11959	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11959	27	.	.	.
18637	11960	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11960	2	142	142	CD
18637	11960	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11960	4	9	9	CD
18637	11960	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	11960	6	.	.	.
18637	11961	1	738	738	CD
18637	11961	2	,	,	,
18637	11961	3	819	819	CD
18637	11961	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11961	5	1824	1824	CD
18637	11961	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11961	7	.	.	.
18637	11962	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11962	2	143	143	CD
18637	11962	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11962	4	2	2	CD
18637	11962	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	11962	6	.	.	.
18637	11963	1	419	419	CD
18637	11963	2	,	,	,
18637	11963	3	431	431	CD
18637	11963	4	,	,	,
18637	11963	5	432	432	CD
18637	11963	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11963	7	1793	1793	CD
18637	11963	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11963	9	.	.	.
18637	11964	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11964	2	144	144	CD
18637	11964	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11964	4	In	in	IN
18637	11964	5	re	re	IN
18637	11964	6	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	11964	7	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	11964	8	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	11964	9	,	,	,
18637	11964	10	32	32	CD
18637	11964	11	F.	F.	NNP
18637	11964	12	241	241	CD
18637	11964	13	,	,	,
18637	11964	14	255	255	CD
18637	11964	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11964	16	1887	1887	CD
18637	11964	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11964	18	.	.	.
18637	11965	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11965	2	Field	Field	NNP
18637	11965	3	repeated	repeat	VBD
18637	11965	4	the	the	DT
18637	11965	5	substance	substance	NN
18637	11965	6	of	of	IN
18637	11965	7	this	this	DT
18637	11965	8	definition	definition	NN
18637	11965	9	in	in	IN
18637	11965	10	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	11965	11	_	_	NNP
18637	11965	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	11965	13	_	_	NNP
18637	11965	14	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	11965	15	,	,	,
18637	11965	16	130	130	CD
18637	11965	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11965	18	167	167	CD
18637	11965	19	,	,	,
18637	11965	20	173	173	CD
18637	11965	21	-	-	SYM
18637	11965	22	174	174	CD
18637	11965	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11965	24	1889	1889	CD
18637	11965	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11965	26	.	.	.
18637	11966	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11966	2	145	145	CD
18637	11966	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11966	4	219	219	CD
18637	11966	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11966	6	346	346	CD
18637	11966	7	,	,	,
18637	11966	8	357	357	CD
18637	11966	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11966	10	1911	1911	CD
18637	11966	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11966	12	.	.	.
18637	11967	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11967	2	146	146	CD
18637	11967	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11967	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11967	5	.	.	.
18637	11968	1	361	361	CD
18637	11968	2	-	-	SYM
18637	11968	3	362	362	CD
18637	11968	4	.	.	.
18637	11969	1	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	11969	2	power	power	NN
18637	11969	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	11969	4	here	here	RB
18637	11969	5	defined	define	VBN
18637	11969	6	by	by	IN
18637	11969	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	11969	8	Day	Day	NNP
18637	11969	9	as	as	IN
18637	11969	10	"	"	``
18637	11969	11	the	the	DT
18637	11969	12	right	right	NN
18637	11969	13	to	to	TO
18637	11969	14	determine	determine	VB
18637	11969	15	actual	actual	JJ
18637	11969	16	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	11969	17	arising	arise	VBG
18637	11969	18	between	between	IN
18637	11969	19	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	11969	20	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	11969	21	,	,	,
18637	11969	22	duly	duly	RB
18637	11969	23	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	11969	24	in	in	IN
18637	11969	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	11969	26	of	of	IN
18637	11969	27	proper	proper	JJ
18637	11969	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	11969	29	.	.	.
18637	11969	30	"	"	''
18637	11970	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	11970	2	.	.	.
18637	11971	1	361	361	CD
18637	11971	2	.	.	.
18637	11972	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11972	2	147	147	CD
18637	11972	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11972	4	Muskrat	Muskrat	NNP
18637	11972	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11972	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11972	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11972	8	United	United	NNP
18637	11972	9	States	States	NNP
18637	11972	10	,	,	,
18637	11972	11	219	219	CD
18637	11972	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11972	13	346	346	CD
18637	11972	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11972	15	1911	1911	CD
18637	11972	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11972	17	;	;	:
18637	11972	18	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	11972	19	&	&	CC
18637	11972	20	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	11972	21	Trunk	Trunk	NNP
18637	11972	22	R.	R.	NNP
18637	11972	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11972	24	_	_	NNP
18637	11972	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	11972	26	_	_	NNP
18637	11972	27	Wellman	Wellman	NNP
18637	11972	28	,	,	,
18637	11972	29	143	143	CD
18637	11972	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11972	31	339	339	CD
18637	11972	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11972	33	1892	1892	CD
18637	11972	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11972	35	;	;	:
18637	11972	36	Lampasas	Lampasas	NNP
18637	11972	37	_	_	NNP
18637	11972	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	11972	39	_	_	NNP
18637	11972	40	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	11972	41	,	,	,
18637	11972	42	180	180	CD
18637	11972	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11972	44	276	276	CD
18637	11972	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11972	46	1901	1901	CD
18637	11972	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11972	48	;	;	:
18637	11972	49	Braxton	Braxton	NNP
18637	11972	50	County	County	NNP
18637	11972	51	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11972	52	_	_	NNP
18637	11972	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	11972	54	_	_	NNP
18637	11972	55	West	West	NNP
18637	11972	56	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11972	57	,	,	,
18637	11972	58	208	208	CD
18637	11972	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11972	60	192	192	CD
18637	11972	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11972	62	1908	1908	CD
18637	11972	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11972	64	;	;	:
18637	11972	65	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	11972	66	_	_	NNP
18637	11972	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	11972	68	_	_	NNP
18637	11972	69	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	11972	70	,	,	,
18637	11972	71	191	191	CD
18637	11972	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11972	73	138	138	CD
18637	11972	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11972	75	1903	1903	CD
18637	11972	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11972	77	;	;	:
18637	11972	78	Tregea	Tregea	NNP
18637	11972	79	_	_	NNP
18637	11972	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	11972	81	_	_	NNP
18637	11972	82	Modesto	Modesto	NNP
18637	11972	83	Irrigation	Irrigation	NNP
18637	11972	84	District	District	NNP
18637	11972	85	,	,	,
18637	11972	86	164	164	CD
18637	11972	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11972	88	179	179	CD
18637	11972	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11972	90	1896	1896	CD
18637	11972	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11972	92	.	.	.
18637	11973	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11973	2	148	148	CD
18637	11973	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11973	4	143	143	CD
18637	11973	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11973	6	339	339	CD
18637	11973	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11973	8	1892	1892	CD
18637	11973	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11973	10	.	.	.
18637	11974	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11974	2	149	149	CD
18637	11974	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11974	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11974	5	.	.	.
18637	11975	1	345	345	CD
18637	11975	2	.	.	.
18637	11976	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11976	2	150	150	CD
18637	11976	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11976	4	Muskrat	Muskrat	NNP
18637	11976	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11976	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11976	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11976	8	United	United	NNP
18637	11976	9	States	States	NNP
18637	11976	10	,	,	,
18637	11976	11	219	219	CD
18637	11976	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11976	13	346	346	CD
18637	11976	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11976	15	1911	1911	CD
18637	11976	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11976	17	.	.	.
18637	11977	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11977	2	151	151	CD
18637	11977	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11977	4	Lampasas	Lampasas	NNP
18637	11977	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11977	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11977	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11977	8	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	11977	9	,	,	,
18637	11977	10	180	180	CD
18637	11977	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11977	12	276	276	CD
18637	11977	13	,	,	,
18637	11977	14	284	284	CD
18637	11977	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11977	16	1901	1901	CD
18637	11977	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11977	18	.	.	.
18637	11978	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11978	2	152	152	CD
18637	11978	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11978	4	Braxton	Braxton	NNP
18637	11978	5	County	County	NNP
18637	11978	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11978	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11978	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	11978	9	_	_	NNP
18637	11978	10	West	West	NNP
18637	11978	11	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	11978	12	,	,	,
18637	11978	13	208	208	CD
18637	11978	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11978	15	192	192	CD
18637	11978	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11978	17	1908	1908	CD
18637	11978	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11978	19	.	.	.
18637	11979	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11979	2	153	153	CD
18637	11979	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11979	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	11979	5	.	.	.
18637	11980	1	198	198	CD
18637	11980	2	.	.	.
18637	11981	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11981	2	154	154	CD
18637	11981	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11981	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	11981	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11981	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11981	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11981	8	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	11981	9	,	,	,
18637	11981	10	191	191	CD
18637	11981	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11981	12	138	138	CD
18637	11981	13	,	,	,
18637	11981	14	149	149	CD
18637	11981	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11981	16	1903	1903	CD
18637	11981	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11981	18	.	.	.
18637	11982	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11982	2	155	155	CD
18637	11982	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11982	4	Tregea	Tregea	NNP
18637	11982	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11982	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11982	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11982	8	Modesto	Modesto	NNP
18637	11982	9	Irrigation	Irrigation	NNP
18637	11982	10	District	District	NNP
18637	11982	11	,	,	,
18637	11982	12	164	164	CD
18637	11982	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11982	14	179	179	CD
18637	11982	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11982	16	1896	1896	CD
18637	11982	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11982	18	.	.	.
18637	11983	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11983	2	156	156	CD
18637	11983	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11983	4	Coffman	Coffman	NNP
18637	11983	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11983	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11983	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11983	8	Breeze	Breeze	NNP
18637	11983	9	Corporations	Corporations	NNP
18637	11983	10	,	,	,
18637	11983	11	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	11983	12	,	,	,
18637	11983	13	323	323	CD
18637	11983	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11983	15	316	316	CD
18637	11983	16	,	,	,
18637	11983	17	324	324	CD
18637	11983	18	-	-	SYM
18637	11983	19	325	325	CD
18637	11983	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11983	21	1945	1945	CD
18637	11983	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11983	23	,	,	,
18637	11983	24	citing	cite	VBG
18637	11983	25	Tyler	Tyler	NNP
18637	11983	26	_	_	NNP
18637	11983	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	11983	28	_	_	NNP
18637	11983	29	The	the	DT
18637	11983	30	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	11983	31	,	,	,
18637	11983	32	179	179	CD
18637	11983	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11983	34	405	405	CD
18637	11983	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11983	36	1900	1900	CD
18637	11983	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11983	38	;	;	:
18637	11983	39	Hendrick	Hendrick	NNP
18637	11983	40	_	_	NNP
18637	11983	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	11983	42	_	_	NNP
18637	11983	43	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	11983	44	,	,	,
18637	11983	45	235	235	CD
18637	11983	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11983	47	610	610	CD
18637	11983	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11983	49	1915	1915	CD
18637	11983	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11983	51	.	.	.
18637	11984	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11984	2	157	157	CD
18637	11984	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11984	4	Fleming	Fleming	NNP
18637	11984	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11984	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11984	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11984	8	Rhodes	Rhodes	NNP
18637	11984	9	,	,	,
18637	11984	10	331	331	CD
18637	11984	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11984	12	100	100	CD
18637	11984	13	,	,	,
18637	11984	14	104	104	CD
18637	11984	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11984	16	1947	1947	CD
18637	11984	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11984	18	.	.	.
18637	11985	1	_	_	NNP
18637	11985	2	See	See	NNP
18637	11985	3	also	also	RB
18637	11985	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11985	5	Blackmer	Blackmer	NNP
18637	11985	6	_	_	NNP
18637	11985	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	11985	8	_	_	NNP
18637	11985	9	United	United	NNP
18637	11985	10	States	States	NNP
18637	11985	11	,	,	,
18637	11985	12	284	284	CD
18637	11985	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11985	14	421	421	CD
18637	11985	15	,	,	,
18637	11985	16	442	442	CD
18637	11985	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11985	18	1932	1932	CD
18637	11985	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11985	20	;	;	:
18637	11985	21	Virginian	Virginian	NNP
18637	11985	22	R.	R.	NNP
18637	11985	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11985	24	_	_	NNP
18637	11985	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	11985	26	_	_	NNP
18637	11985	27	System	System	NNP
18637	11985	28	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	11985	29	,	,	,
18637	11985	30	300	300	CD
18637	11985	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11985	32	515	515	CD
18637	11985	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11985	34	1937	1937	CD
18637	11985	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11985	36	;	;	:
18637	11985	37	Carmichael	Carmichael	NNP
18637	11985	38	_	_	NNP
18637	11985	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	11985	40	_	_	NNP
18637	11985	41	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	11985	42	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	11985	43	&	&	CC
18637	11985	44	Coke	Coke	NNP
18637	11985	45	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11985	46	,	,	,
18637	11985	47	301	301	CD
18637	11985	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11985	49	495	495	CD
18637	11985	50	,	,	,
18637	11985	51	513	513	CD
18637	11985	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11985	53	1937	1937	CD
18637	11985	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11985	55	.	.	.
18637	11986	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11986	2	158	158	CD
18637	11986	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11986	4	157	157	CD
18637	11986	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11986	6	429	429	CD
18637	11986	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11986	8	1895	1895	CD
18637	11986	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11986	10	.	.	.
18637	11987	1	The	the	DT
18637	11987	2	first	first	JJ
18637	11987	3	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	11987	4	suit	suit	NN
18637	11987	5	by	by	IN
18637	11987	6	a	a	DT
18637	11987	7	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	11987	8	to	to	TO
18637	11987	9	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	11987	10	a	a	DT
18637	11987	11	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	11987	12	from	from	IN
18637	11987	13	paying	pay	VBG
18637	11987	14	the	the	DT
18637	11987	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	11987	16	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	11987	17	to	to	TO
18637	11987	18	be	be	VB
18637	11987	19	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	11987	20	_	_	NNP
18637	11987	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	11987	22	_	_	NNP
18637	11987	23	Woolsey	Woolsey	NNP
18637	11987	24	,	,	,
18637	11987	25	18	18	CD
18637	11987	26	How	how	WRB
18637	11987	27	.	.	.
18637	11988	1	331	331	CD
18637	11988	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11988	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	11988	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11988	5	which	which	WDT
18637	11988	6	involved	involve	VBD
18637	11988	7	the	the	DT
18637	11988	8	validity	validity	NN
18637	11988	9	of	of	IN
18637	11988	10	an	an	DT
18637	11988	11	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	11988	12	tax	tax	NN
18637	11988	13	.	.	.
18637	11989	1	The	the	DT
18637	11989	2	suit	suit	NN
18637	11989	3	was	be	VBD
18637	11989	4	entertained	entertain	VBN
18637	11989	5	on	on	IN
18637	11989	6	the	the	DT
18637	11989	7	basis	basis	NN
18637	11989	8	of	of	IN
18637	11989	9	English	english	JJ
18637	11989	10	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	11989	11	.	.	.
18637	11990	1	A	a	DT
18637	11990	2	case	case	NN
18637	11990	3	similar	similar	JJ
18637	11990	4	to	to	IN
18637	11990	5	the	the	DT
18637	11990	6	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	11990	7	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11990	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	11990	9	Brushaber	Brushaber	NNP
18637	11990	10	_	_	NNP
18637	11990	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	11990	12	_	_	NNP
18637	11990	13	Union	Union	NNP
18637	11990	14	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	11990	15	R.	R.	NNP
18637	11990	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11990	17	,	,	,
18637	11990	18	240	240	CD
18637	11990	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11990	20	1	1	CD
18637	11990	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11990	22	1916	1916	CD
18637	11990	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11990	24	.	.	.
18637	11991	1	Hawes	Hawes	NNP
18637	11991	2	_	_	NNP
18637	11991	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	11991	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11991	5	Oakland	Oakland	NNP
18637	11991	6	,	,	,
18637	11991	7	104	104	CD
18637	11991	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11991	9	450	450	CD
18637	11991	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11991	11	1881	1881	CD
18637	11991	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11991	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	11991	14	cited	cite	VBN
18637	11991	15	in	in	IN
18637	11991	16	the	the	DT
18637	11991	17	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	11991	18	Case	Case	NNP
18637	11991	19	,	,	,
18637	11991	20	although	although	IN
18637	11991	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	11991	22	in	in	IN
18637	11991	23	fact	fact	NN
18637	11991	24	threw	throw	VBD
18637	11991	25	out	out	RP
18637	11991	26	a	a	DT
18637	11991	27	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	11991	28	's	's	POS
18637	11991	29	suit	suit	NN
18637	11991	30	.	.	.
18637	11992	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11992	2	159	159	CD
18637	11992	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11992	4	_	_	NNP
18637	11992	5	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	11992	6	.	.	.
18637	11992	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11992	8	Cheatham	Cheatham	NNP
18637	11992	9	et	et	FW
18637	11992	10	al	al	NNP
18637	11992	11	.	.	.
18637	11993	1	_	_	NNP
18637	11993	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	11993	3	_	_	NNP
18637	11993	4	United	United	NNP
18637	11993	5	States	States	NNP
18637	11993	6	,	,	,
18637	11993	7	92	92	CD
18637	11993	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11993	9	85	85	CD
18637	11993	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11993	11	1875	1875	CD
18637	11993	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11993	13	;	;	:
18637	11993	14	and	and	CC
18637	11993	15	Snyder	Snyder	NNP
18637	11993	16	_	_	NNP
18637	11993	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	11993	18	_	_	NNP
18637	11993	19	Marks	Marks	NNP
18637	11993	20	,	,	,
18637	11993	21	109	109	CD
18637	11993	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11993	23	189	189	CD
18637	11993	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11993	25	1883	1883	CD
18637	11993	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11993	27	.	.	.
18637	11994	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11994	2	160	160	CD
18637	11994	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11994	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	11994	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11994	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11994	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11994	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	11994	9	City	City	NNP
18637	11994	10	Title	Title	NNP
18637	11994	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	11994	12	,	,	,
18637	11994	13	255	255	CD
18637	11994	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11994	15	180	180	CD
18637	11994	16	,	,	,
18637	11994	17	201	201	CD
18637	11994	18	,	,	,
18637	11994	19	202	202	CD
18637	11994	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11994	21	1921	1921	CD
18637	11994	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11994	23	.	.	.
18637	11995	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11995	2	161	161	CD
18637	11995	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11995	4	Ashwander	Ashwander	NNP
18637	11995	5	_	_	NNP
18637	11995	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	11995	7	_	_	NNP
18637	11995	8	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	11995	9	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	11995	10	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	11995	11	,	,	,
18637	11995	12	297	297	CD
18637	11995	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11995	14	288	288	CD
18637	11995	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11995	16	1936	1936	CD
18637	11995	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11995	18	.	.	.
18637	11996	1	Although	although	IN
18637	11996	2	the	the	DT
18637	11996	3	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	11996	4	of	of	IN
18637	11996	5	the	the	DT
18637	11996	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
18637	11996	7	amounted	amount	VBD
18637	11996	8	to	to	IN
18637	11996	9	only	only	RB
18637	11996	10	one	one	CD
18637	11996	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	11996	12	three	three	CD
18637	11996	13	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	11996	14	and	and	CC
18637	11996	15	fortieth	fortieth	JJ
18637	11996	16	of	of	IN
18637	11996	17	the	the	DT
18637	11996	18	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	11996	19	stock	stock	NN
18637	11996	20	,	,	,
18637	11996	21	the	the	DT
18637	11996	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	11996	23	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	11996	24	that	that	IN
18637	11996	25	the	the	DT
18637	11996	26	right	right	NN
18637	11996	27	to	to	TO
18637	11996	28	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	11996	29	the	the	DT
18637	11996	30	suit	suit	NN
18637	11996	31	was	be	VBD
18637	11996	32	not	not	RB
18637	11996	33	affected	affect	VBN
18637	11996	34	by	by	IN
18637	11996	35	the	the	DT
18637	11996	36	smallness	smallness	NN
18637	11996	37	of	of	IN
18637	11996	38	the	the	DT
18637	11996	39	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	11996	40	.	.	.
18637	11997	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11997	2	162	162	CD
18637	11997	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11997	4	298	298	CD
18637	11997	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	11997	6	238	238	CD
18637	11997	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	11997	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	11997	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	11997	10	.	.	.
18637	11998	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	11998	2	163	163	CD
18637	11998	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	11998	4	Robert	Robert	NNP
18637	11998	5	L.	L.	NNP
18637	11998	6	Stern	Stern	NNP
18637	11998	7	,	,	,
18637	11998	8	in	in	IN
18637	11998	9	The	the	DT
18637	11998	10	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	11998	11	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	11998	12	and	and	CC
18637	11998	13	the	the	DT
18637	11998	14	National	National	NNP
18637	11998	15	Economy	Economy	NNP
18637	11998	16	,	,	,
18637	11998	17	59	59	CD
18637	11998	18	Harv	Harv	NNP
18637	11998	19	.	.	.
18637	11999	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	11999	2	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	12000	1	645	645	CD
18637	12000	2	,	,	,
18637	12000	3	667	667	CD
18637	12000	4	-	-	SYM
18637	12000	5	668	668	CD
18637	12000	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12000	7	1948	1948	CD
18637	12000	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12000	9	,	,	,
18637	12000	10	gives	give	VBZ
18637	12000	11	the	the	DT
18637	12000	12	following	follow	VBG
18637	12000	13	account	account	NN
18637	12000	14	of	of	IN
18637	12000	15	the	the	DT
18637	12000	16	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	12000	17	in	in	IN
18637	12000	18	the	the	DT
18637	12000	19	first	first	JJ
18637	12000	20	bituminous	bituminous	JJ
18637	12000	21	coal	coal	NN
18637	12000	22	case	case	NN
18637	12000	23	:	:	:
18637	12000	24	On	on	IN
18637	12000	25	the	the	DT
18637	12000	26	same	same	JJ
18637	12000	27	day	day	NN
18637	12000	28	that	that	WDT
18637	12000	29	the	the	DT
18637	12000	30	Bituminous	Bituminous	NNP
18637	12000	31	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	12000	32	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12000	33	became	become	VBD
18637	12000	34	law	law	NN
18637	12000	35	,	,	,
18637	12000	36	the	the	DT
18637	12000	37	directors	director	NNS
18637	12000	38	of	of	IN
18637	12000	39	the	the	DT
18637	12000	40	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	12000	41	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	12000	42	Company	Company	NNP
18637	12000	43	met	meet	VBD
18637	12000	44	in	in	IN
18637	12000	45	New	New	NNP
18637	12000	46	York	York	NNP
18637	12000	47	.	.	.
18637	12001	1	James	James	NNP
18637	12001	2	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	12001	3	presented	present	VBD
18637	12001	4	a	a	DT
18637	12001	5	letter	letter	NN
18637	12001	6	saying	say	VBG
18637	12001	7	the	the	DT
18637	12001	8	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	12001	9	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12001	10	was	be	VBD
18637	12001	11	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	12001	12	and	and	CC
18637	12001	13	that	that	IN
18637	12001	14	the	the	DT
18637	12001	15	company	company	NN
18637	12001	16	should	should	MD
18637	12001	17	not	not	RB
18637	12001	18	join	join	VB
18637	12001	19	the	the	DT
18637	12001	20	Code	Code	NNP
18637	12001	21	.	.	.
18637	12002	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12002	2	father	father	NN
18637	12002	3	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	12002	4	that	that	IN
18637	12002	5	the	the	DT
18637	12002	6	act	act	NN
18637	12002	7	was	be	VBD
18637	12002	8	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	12002	9	,	,	,
18637	12002	10	but	but	CC
18637	12002	11	thought	think	VBD
18637	12002	12	the	the	DT
18637	12002	13	company	company	NN
18637	12002	14	should	should	MD
18637	12002	15	not	not	RB
18637	12002	16	take	take	VB
18637	12002	17	the	the	DT
18637	12002	18	risk	risk	NN
18637	12002	19	of	of	IN
18637	12002	20	paying	pay	VBG
18637	12002	21	the	the	DT
18637	12002	22	tax	tax	NN
18637	12002	23	required	require	VBN
18637	12002	24	of	of	IN
18637	12002	25	nonmembers	nonmember	NNS
18637	12002	26	in	in	IN
18637	12002	27	the	the	DT
18637	12002	28	event	event	NN
18637	12002	29	the	the	DT
18637	12002	30	act	act	NN
18637	12002	31	should	should	MD
18637	12002	32	be	be	VB
18637	12002	33	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	12002	34	.	.	.
18637	12003	1	The	the	DT
18637	12003	2	third	third	JJ
18637	12003	3	director	director	NN
18637	12003	4	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	12003	5	with	with	IN
18637	12003	6	the	the	DT
18637	12003	7	elder	eld	JJR
18637	12003	8	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	12003	9	,	,	,
18637	12003	10	and	and	CC
18637	12003	11	the	the	DT
18637	12003	12	board	board	NN
18637	12003	13	passed	pass	VBD
18637	12003	14	a	a	DT
18637	12003	15	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	12003	16	rejecting	reject	VBG
18637	12003	17	James	James	NNP
18637	12003	18	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	12003	19	's	's	POS
18637	12003	20	proposals	proposal	NNS
18637	12003	21	.	.	.
18637	12004	1	This	this	DT
18637	12004	2	action	action	NN
18637	12004	3	was	be	VBD
18637	12004	4	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	12004	5	approved	approve	VBN
18637	12004	6	by	by	IN
18637	12004	7	a	a	DT
18637	12004	8	majority	majority	NN
18637	12004	9	of	of	IN
18637	12004	10	the	the	DT
18637	12004	11	voting	voting	NN
18637	12004	12	stock	stock	NN
18637	12004	13	held	hold	VBN
18637	12004	14	by	by	IN
18637	12004	15	James	James	NNP
18637	12004	16	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	12004	17	's	's	POS
18637	12004	18	father	father	NN
18637	12004	19	and	and	CC
18637	12004	20	mother	mother	NN
18637	12004	21	who	who	WP
18637	12004	22	outvoted	outvote	VBD
18637	12004	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12004	24	and	and	CC
18637	12004	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12004	26	wife	wife	NN
18637	12004	27	.	.	.
18637	12005	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12005	2	164	164	CD
18637	12005	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12005	4	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	12005	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12005	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12005	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12005	8	Mellon	Mellon	NNP
18637	12005	9	,	,	,
18637	12005	10	262	262	CD
18637	12005	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12005	12	447	447	CD
18637	12005	13	,	,	,
18637	12005	14	487	487	CD
18637	12005	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12005	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	12005	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12005	18	.	.	.
18637	12006	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12006	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12006	3	also	also	RB
18637	12006	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12006	5	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	12006	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12006	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12006	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12006	9	Riley	Riley	NNP
18637	12006	10	,	,	,
18637	12006	11	280	280	CD
18637	12006	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12006	13	78	78	CD
18637	12006	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12006	15	1929	1929	CD
18637	12006	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12006	17	.	.	.
18637	12007	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12007	2	165	165	CD
18637	12007	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12007	4	Fairchild	Fairchild	NNP
18637	12007	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12007	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12007	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12007	8	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	12007	9	,	,	,
18637	12007	10	258	258	CD
18637	12007	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12007	12	126	126	CD
18637	12007	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12007	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	12007	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12007	16	.	.	.
18637	12008	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12008	2	166	166	CD
18637	12008	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12008	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	12008	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	12008	6	Levitt	Levitt	NNP
18637	12008	7	,	,	,
18637	12008	8	302	302	CD
18637	12008	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12008	10	633	633	CD
18637	12008	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12008	12	1937	1937	CD
18637	12008	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12008	14	.	.	.
18637	12009	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12009	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12009	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12009	4	,	,	,
18637	12009	5	however	however	RB
18637	12009	6	,	,	,
18637	12009	7	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	12009	8	State	State	NNP
18637	12009	9	Grange	Grange	NNP
18637	12009	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12009	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	12009	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12009	13	Benton	Benton	NNP
18637	12009	14	,	,	,
18637	12009	15	272	272	CD
18637	12009	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12009	17	525	525	CD
18637	12009	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12009	19	1926	1926	CD
18637	12009	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12009	21	,	,	,
18637	12009	22	where	where	WRB
18637	12009	23	the	the	DT
18637	12009	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12009	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12009	26	,	,	,
18637	12009	27	though	though	IN
18637	12009	28	affirming	affirm	VBG
18637	12009	29	the	the	DT
18637	12009	30	dismissal	dismissal	NN
18637	12009	31	of	of	IN
18637	12009	32	a	a	DT
18637	12009	33	suit	suit	NN
18637	12009	34	to	to	TO
18637	12009	35	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	12009	36	a	a	DT
18637	12009	37	day	day	NN
18637	12009	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	12009	39	light	light	NN
18637	12009	40	-	-	HYPH
18637	12009	41	saving	save	VBG
18637	12009	42	statute	statute	NN
18637	12009	43	,	,	,
18637	12009	44	nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
18637	12009	45	,	,	,
18637	12009	46	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	12009	47	the	the	DT
18637	12009	48	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12009	49	of	of	IN
18637	12009	50	the	the	DT
18637	12009	51	district	district	NN
18637	12009	52	court	court	NN
18637	12009	53	to	to	TO
18637	12009	54	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	12009	55	the	the	DT
18637	12009	56	suit	suit	NN
18637	12009	57	.	.	.
18637	12010	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12010	2	167	167	CD
18637	12010	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12010	4	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	12010	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	12010	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12010	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12010	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12010	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12010	10	Ickes	Ickes	NNP
18637	12010	11	,	,	,
18637	12010	12	302	302	CD
18637	12010	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12010	14	464	464	CD
18637	12010	15	,	,	,
18637	12010	16	480	480	CD
18637	12010	17	-	-	SYM
18637	12010	18	481	481	CD
18637	12010	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12010	20	1938	1938	CD
18637	12010	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12010	22	.	.	.
18637	12011	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12011	2	168	168	CD
18637	12011	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12011	4	333	333	CD
18637	12011	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12011	6	203	203	CD
18637	12011	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12011	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	12011	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12011	10	.	.	.
18637	12012	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12012	2	169	169	CD
18637	12012	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12012	4	342	342	CD
18637	12012	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12012	6	429	429	CD
18637	12012	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12012	8	1952	1952	CD
18637	12012	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12012	10	.	.	.
18637	12013	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12013	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12013	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12013	4	p.	p.	NN
18637	12013	5	763	763	CD
18637	12013	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12013	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	12013	8	I	I	NNP
18637	12013	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12013	10	.	.	.
18637	12014	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12014	2	170	170	CD
18637	12014	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12014	4	6	6	CD
18637	12014	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12014	6	.	.	.
18637	12015	1	50	50	CD
18637	12015	2	,	,	,
18637	12015	3	64	64	CD
18637	12015	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12015	5	1868	1868	CD
18637	12015	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12015	7	.	.	.
18637	12016	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12016	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12016	3	also	also	RB
18637	12016	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12016	5	State	State	NNP
18637	12016	6	of	of	IN
18637	12016	7	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	12016	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12016	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12016	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12016	11	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	12016	12	,	,	,
18637	12016	13	4	4	CD
18637	12016	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12016	15	.	.	.
18637	12017	1	475	475	CD
18637	12017	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12017	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	12017	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12017	5	.	.	.
18637	12018	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12018	2	171	171	CD
18637	12018	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12018	4	6	6	CD
18637	12018	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12018	6	.	.	.
18637	12019	1	at	at	IN
18637	12019	2	76	76	CD
18637	12019	3	.	.	.
18637	12020	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12020	2	172	172	CD
18637	12020	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12020	4	262	262	CD
18637	12020	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12020	6	447	447	CD
18637	12020	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12020	8	1923	1923	CD
18637	12020	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12020	10	.	.	.
18637	12021	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12021	2	173	173	CD
18637	12021	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12021	4	42	42	CD
18637	12021	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12021	6	.	.	.
18637	12022	1	224	224	CD
18637	12022	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12022	3	1921	1921	CD
18637	12022	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12022	5	.	.	.
18637	12023	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12023	2	174	174	CD
18637	12023	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12023	4	262	262	CD
18637	12023	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12023	6	447	447	CD
18637	12023	7	,	,	,
18637	12023	8	484	484	CD
18637	12023	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12023	10	485	485	CD
18637	12023	11	.	.	.
18637	12024	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12024	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12024	3	also	also	RB
18637	12024	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12024	5	New	New	NNP
18637	12024	6	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	12024	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12024	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12024	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12024	10	Sargent	Sargent	NNP
18637	12024	11	,	,	,
18637	12024	12	269	269	CD
18637	12024	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12024	14	328	328	CD
18637	12024	15	,	,	,
18637	12024	16	338	338	CD
18637	12024	17	-	-	SYM
18637	12024	18	340	340	CD
18637	12024	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12024	20	1926	1926	CD
18637	12024	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12024	22	,	,	,
18637	12024	23	where	where	WRB
18637	12024	24	the	the	DT
18637	12024	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12024	26	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	12024	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12024	28	of	of	IN
18637	12024	29	a	a	DT
18637	12024	30	suit	suit	NN
18637	12024	31	to	to	TO
18637	12024	32	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	12024	33	the	the	DT
18637	12024	34	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12024	35	water	water	NNP
18637	12024	36	power	power	NNP
18637	12024	37	act	act	NNP
18637	12024	38	because	because	IN
18637	12024	39	of	of	IN
18637	12024	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12024	41	effect	effect	NN
18637	12024	42	on	on	IN
18637	12024	43	the	the	DT
18637	12024	44	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	12024	45	of	of	IN
18637	12024	46	potable	potable	JJ
18637	12024	47	waters	water	NNS
18637	12024	48	in	in	IN
18637	12024	49	New	New	NNP
18637	12024	50	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	12024	51	.	.	.
18637	12025	1	A	a	DT
18637	12025	2	similar	similar	JJ
18637	12025	3	situation	situation	NN
18637	12025	4	arose	arise	VBD
18637	12025	5	in	in	IN
18637	12025	6	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	12025	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12025	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12025	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12025	10	California	California	NNP
18637	12025	11	,	,	,
18637	12025	12	283	283	CD
18637	12025	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12025	14	423	423	CD
18637	12025	15	,	,	,
18637	12025	16	450	450	CD
18637	12025	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12025	18	1931	1931	CD
18637	12025	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12025	20	,	,	,
18637	12025	21	where	where	WRB
18637	12025	22	the	the	DT
18637	12025	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12025	24	declined	decline	VBD
18637	12025	25	to	to	TO
18637	12025	26	take	take	VB
18637	12025	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12025	28	of	of	IN
18637	12025	29	an	an	DT
18637	12025	30	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	12025	31	suit	suit	NN
18637	12025	32	to	to	TO
18637	12025	33	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	12025	34	the	the	DT
18637	12025	35	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	12025	36	of	of	IN
18637	12025	37	the	the	DT
18637	12025	38	Interior	Interior	NNP
18637	12025	39	and	and	CC
18637	12025	40	the	the	DT
18637	12025	41	five	five	CD
18637	12025	42	States	state	NNS
18637	12025	43	of	of	IN
18637	12025	44	the	the	DT
18637	12025	45	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	12025	46	River	River	NNP
18637	12025	47	Compact	Compact	NNP
18637	12025	48	from	from	IN
18637	12025	49	constructing	construct	VBG
18637	12025	50	Boulder	Boulder	NNP
18637	12025	51	Dam	Dam	NNP
18637	12025	52	.	.	.
18637	12026	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12026	2	175	175	CD
18637	12026	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12026	4	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	12026	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12026	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12026	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12026	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	12026	9	R.	R.	NNP
18637	12026	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12026	11	,	,	,
18637	12026	12	324	324	CD
18637	12026	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12026	14	439	439	CD
18637	12026	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12026	16	1945	1945	CD
18637	12026	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12026	18	.	.	.
18637	12027	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12027	2	176	176	CD
18637	12027	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12027	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	12027	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12027	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12027	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12027	8	Holland	Holland	NNP
18637	12027	9	,	,	,
18637	12027	10	252	252	CD
18637	12027	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12027	12	416	416	CD
18637	12027	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12027	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	12027	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12027	16	.	.	.
18637	12028	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12028	2	177	177	CD
18637	12028	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12028	4	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	12028	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12028	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12028	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12028	8	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	12028	9	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	12028	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12028	11	,	,	,
18637	12028	12	206	206	CD
18637	12028	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12028	14	230	230	CD
18637	12028	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12028	16	1907	1907	CD
18637	12028	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12028	18	.	.	.
18637	12029	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12029	2	178	178	CD
18637	12029	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12029	4	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	12029	5	State	State	NNP
18637	12029	6	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	12029	7	of	of	IN
18637	12029	8	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	12029	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12029	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12029	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12029	12	McAdory	McAdory	NNP
18637	12029	13	,	,	,
18637	12029	14	325	325	CD
18637	12029	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12029	16	450	450	CD
18637	12029	17	,	,	,
18637	12029	18	461	461	CD
18637	12029	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12029	20	1945	1945	CD
18637	12029	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12029	22	.	.	.
18637	12030	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12030	2	179	179	CD
18637	12030	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12030	4	Giles	Giles	NNP
18637	12030	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12030	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12030	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12030	8	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	12030	9	,	,	,
18637	12030	10	189	189	CD
18637	12030	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12030	12	475	475	CD
18637	12030	13	,	,	,
18637	12030	14	486	486	CD
18637	12030	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12030	16	1903	1903	CD
18637	12030	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12030	18	.	.	.
18637	12031	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12031	2	180	180	CD
18637	12031	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12031	4	258	258	CD
18637	12031	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12031	6	158	158	CD
18637	12031	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12031	8	1922	1922	CD
18637	12031	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12031	10	.	.	.
18637	12032	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12032	2	181	181	CD
18637	12032	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12032	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12032	5	.	.	.
18637	12033	1	162	162	CD
18637	12033	2	.	.	.
18637	12034	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12034	2	182	182	CD
18637	12034	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12034	4	297	297	CD
18637	12034	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12034	6	288	288	CD
18637	12034	7	,	,	,
18637	12034	8	324	324	CD
18637	12034	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12034	10	1936	1936	CD
18637	12034	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12034	12	.	.	.
18637	12035	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12035	2	183	183	CD
18637	12035	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12035	4	274	274	CD
18637	12035	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12035	6	488	488	CD
18637	12035	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12035	8	1927	1927	CD
18637	12035	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12035	10	.	.	.
18637	12036	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12036	2	184	184	CD
18637	12036	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12036	4	Ashwander	Ashwander	NNP
18637	12036	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12036	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12036	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12036	8	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	12036	9	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	12036	10	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	12036	11	,	,	,
18637	12036	12	297	297	CD
18637	12036	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12036	14	288	288	CD
18637	12036	15	,	,	,
18637	12036	16	324	324	CD
18637	12036	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12036	18	1936	1936	CD
18637	12036	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12036	20	.	.	.
18637	12037	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12037	2	185	185	CD
18637	12037	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12037	4	283	283	CD
18637	12037	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12037	6	423	423	CD
18637	12037	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12037	8	1931	1931	CD
18637	12037	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12037	10	.	.	.
18637	12038	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12038	2	186	186	CD
18637	12038	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12038	4	330	330	CD
18637	12038	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12038	6	75	75	CD
18637	12038	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12038	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	12038	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12038	10	.	.	.
18637	12039	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12039	2	187	187	CD
18637	12039	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12039	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12039	5	.	.	.
18637	12040	1	89	89	CD
18637	12040	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12040	3	91	91	CD
18637	12040	4	.	.	.
18637	12041	1	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	12041	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	12041	3	and	and	CC
18637	12041	4	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	12041	5	wrote	write	VBD
18637	12041	6	separate	separate	JJ
18637	12041	7	dissents	dissent	NNS
18637	12041	8	,	,	,
18637	12041	9	but	but	CC
18637	12041	10	each	each	DT
18637	12041	11	contended	contend	VBD
18637	12041	12	that	that	IN
18637	12041	13	the	the	DT
18637	12041	14	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	12041	15	was	be	VBD
18637	12041	16	justiciable	justiciable	NN
18637	12041	17	.	.	.
18637	12042	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12042	2	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	12042	3	could	could	MD
18637	12042	4	not	not	RB
18637	12042	5	agree	agree	VB
18637	12042	6	that	that	IN
18637	12042	7	the	the	DT
18637	12042	8	men	man	NNS
18637	12042	9	should	should	MD
18637	12042	10	violate	violate	VB
18637	12042	11	the	the	DT
18637	12042	12	act	act	NN
18637	12042	13	and	and	CC
18637	12042	14	lose	lose	VB
18637	12042	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12042	16	jobs	job	NNS
18637	12042	17	in	in	IN
18637	12042	18	order	order	NN
18637	12042	19	to	to	TO
18637	12042	20	test	test	VB
18637	12042	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12042	22	rights	right	NNS
18637	12042	23	.	.	.
18637	12043	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12043	2	188	188	CD
18637	12043	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12043	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	12043	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	12043	6	Steele	Steele	NNP
18637	12043	7	,	,	,
18637	12043	8	162	162	CD
18637	12043	9	F.	F.	NNP
18637	12043	10	694	694	CD
18637	12043	11	,	,	,
18637	12043	12	701	701	CD
18637	12043	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12043	14	1908	1908	CD
18637	12043	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12043	16	.	.	.
18637	12044	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12044	2	189	189	CD
18637	12044	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12044	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	12044	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12044	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12044	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12044	8	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	12044	9	&	&	CC
18637	12044	10	Belmont	Belmont	NNP
18637	12044	11	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	12044	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12044	13	,	,	,
18637	12044	14	13	13	CD
18637	12044	15	How	how	WRB
18637	12044	16	.	.	.
18637	12045	1	518	518	CD
18637	12045	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12045	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	12045	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12045	5	;	;	:
18637	12045	6	United	United	NNP
18637	12045	7	States	States	NNP
18637	12045	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12045	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12045	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12045	11	Chambers	Chambers	NNPS
18637	12045	12	,	,	,
18637	12045	13	291	291	CD
18637	12045	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12045	15	217	217	CD
18637	12045	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12045	17	1934	1934	CD
18637	12045	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12045	19	;	;	:
18637	12045	20	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	12045	21	_	_	NNP
18637	12045	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	12045	23	_	_	NNP
18637	12045	24	Green	Green	NNP
18637	12045	25	,	,	,
18637	12045	26	159	159	CD
18637	12045	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12045	28	651	651	CD
18637	12045	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12045	30	1895	1895	CD
18637	12045	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12045	32	;	;	:
18637	12045	33	United	United	NNP
18637	12045	34	States	States	NNP
18637	12045	35	_	_	NNP
18637	12045	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	12045	37	_	_	NNP
18637	12045	38	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	12045	39	,	,	,
18637	12045	40	213	213	CD
18637	12045	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12045	42	297	297	CD
18637	12045	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12045	44	1909	1909	CD
18637	12045	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12045	46	.	.	.
18637	12046	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12046	2	190	190	CD
18637	12046	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12046	4	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	12046	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12046	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12046	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12046	8	Green	Green	NNP
18637	12046	9	,	,	,
18637	12046	10	159	159	CD
18637	12046	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12046	12	651	651	CD
18637	12046	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12046	14	1895	1895	CD
18637	12046	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12046	16	.	.	.
18637	12047	1	This	this	DT
18637	12047	2	case	case	NN
18637	12047	3	came	come	VBD
18637	12047	4	to	to	IN
18637	12047	5	the	the	DT
18637	12047	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12047	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12047	8	on	on	IN
18637	12047	9	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	12047	10	from	from	IN
18637	12047	11	a	a	DT
18637	12047	12	decree	decree	NN
18637	12047	13	of	of	IN
18637	12047	14	the	the	DT
18637	12047	15	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	12047	16	court	court	NN
18637	12047	17	of	of	IN
18637	12047	18	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	12047	19	dissolving	dissolve	VBG
18637	12047	20	an	an	DT
18637	12047	21	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	12047	22	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	12047	23	certain	certain	JJ
18637	12047	24	registration	registration	NN
18637	12047	25	officials	official	NNS
18637	12047	26	from	from	IN
18637	12047	27	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	12047	28	the	the	DT
18637	12047	29	appellant	appellant	NN
18637	12047	30	from	from	IN
18637	12047	31	the	the	DT
18637	12047	32	voting	voting	NN
18637	12047	33	list	list	NN
18637	12047	34	.	.	.
18637	12048	1	However	however	RB
18637	12048	2	,	,	,
18637	12048	3	the	the	DT
18637	12048	4	election	election	NN
18637	12048	5	in	in	IN
18637	12048	6	which	which	WDT
18637	12048	7	appellant	appellant	NN
18637	12048	8	desired	desire	VBD
18637	12048	9	to	to	TO
18637	12048	10	vote	vote	VB
18637	12048	11	was	be	VBD
18637	12048	12	held	hold	VBN
18637	12048	13	prior	prior	RB
18637	12048	14	to	to	IN
18637	12048	15	the	the	DT
18637	12048	16	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	12048	17	,	,	,
18637	12048	18	and	and	CC
18637	12048	19	the	the	DT
18637	12048	20	case	case	NN
18637	12048	21	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	12048	22	became	become	VBD
18637	12048	23	moot	moot	JJ
18637	12048	24	.	.	.
18637	12049	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12049	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12049	3	also	also	RB
18637	12049	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12049	5	St.	St.	NNP
18637	12049	6	Pierre	Pierre	NNP
18637	12049	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12049	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12049	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12049	10	United	United	NNP
18637	12049	11	States	States	NNP
18637	12049	12	,	,	,
18637	12049	13	319	319	CD
18637	12049	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12049	15	41	41	CD
18637	12049	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12049	17	1943	1943	CD
18637	12049	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12049	19	.	.	.
18637	12050	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12050	2	191	191	CD
18637	12050	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12050	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12050	5	.	.	.
18637	12051	1	653	653	CD
18637	12051	2	.	.	.
18637	12052	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12052	2	192	192	CD
18637	12052	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12052	4	Keim	Keim	NNP
18637	12052	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12052	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12052	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12052	8	United	United	NNP
18637	12052	9	States	States	NNP
18637	12052	10	,	,	,
18637	12052	11	177	177	CD
18637	12052	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12052	13	290	290	CD
18637	12052	14	,	,	,
18637	12052	15	293	293	CD
18637	12052	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12052	17	1900	1900	CD
18637	12052	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12052	19	;	;	:
18637	12052	20	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	12052	21	_	_	NNP
18637	12052	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	12052	23	_	_	NNP
18637	12052	24	Stanton	Stanton	NNP
18637	12052	25	,	,	,
18637	12052	26	6	6	CD
18637	12052	27	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12052	28	.	.	.
18637	12053	1	50	50	CD
18637	12053	2	,	,	,
18637	12053	3	71	71	CD
18637	12053	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12053	5	1868	1868	CD
18637	12053	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12053	7	.	.	.
18637	12054	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12054	2	193	193	CD
18637	12054	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12054	4	14	14	CD
18637	12054	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12054	6	.	.	.
18637	12055	1	497	497	CD
18637	12055	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12055	3	1840	1840	CD
18637	12055	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12055	5	.	.	.
18637	12056	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12056	2	194	194	CD
18637	12056	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12056	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12056	5	.	.	.
18637	12057	1	516	516	CD
18637	12057	2	.	.	.
18637	12058	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12058	2	195	195	CD
18637	12058	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12058	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12058	5	.	.	.
18637	12058	6	,	,	,
18637	12058	7	and	and	CC
18637	12058	8	Kendall	Kendall	NNP
18637	12058	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12058	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12058	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12058	12	United	United	NNP
18637	12058	13	States	States	NNP
18637	12058	14	ex	ex	NNP
18637	12058	15	rel	rel	NN
18637	12058	16	.	.	.
18637	12059	1	Stokes	stoke	NNS
18637	12059	2	,	,	,
18637	12059	3	12	12	CD
18637	12059	4	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12059	5	.	.	.
18637	12060	1	524	524	CD
18637	12060	2	,	,	,
18637	12060	3	621	621	CD
18637	12060	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12060	5	1838	1838	CD
18637	12060	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12060	7	;	;	:
18637	12060	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12060	9	see	see	VB
18637	12060	10	also	also	RB
18637	12060	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12060	12	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	12060	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12060	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	12060	15	_	_	NNP
18637	12060	16	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	12060	17	,	,	,
18637	12060	18	1	1	CD
18637	12060	19	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12060	20	.	.	.
18637	12061	1	137	137	CD
18637	12061	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12061	3	1803	1803	CD
18637	12061	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12061	5	.	.	.
18637	12062	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12062	2	196	196	CD
18637	12062	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12062	4	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	12062	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12062	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12062	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12062	8	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	12062	9	,	,	,
18637	12062	10	4	4	CD
18637	12062	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12062	12	.	.	.
18637	12063	1	475	475	CD
18637	12063	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12063	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	12063	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12063	5	.	.	.
18637	12064	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12064	2	197	197	CD
18637	12064	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12064	4	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	12064	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12064	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12064	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12064	8	Stanton	Stanton	NNP
18637	12064	9	,	,	,
18637	12064	10	6	6	CD
18637	12064	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12064	12	.	.	.
18637	12065	1	50	50	CD
18637	12065	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12065	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	12065	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12065	5	.	.	.
18637	12066	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12066	2	198	198	CD
18637	12066	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12066	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12066	5	.	.	.
18637	12067	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12067	2	199	199	CD
18637	12067	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12067	4	4	4	CD
18637	12067	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12067	6	.	.	.
18637	12068	1	475	475	CD
18637	12068	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12068	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	12068	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12068	5	.	.	.
18637	12069	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12069	2	200	200	CD
18637	12069	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12069	4	12	12	CD
18637	12069	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12069	6	.	.	.
18637	12070	1	524	524	CD
18637	12070	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12070	3	1838	1838	CD
18637	12070	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12070	5	.	.	.
18637	12071	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12071	2	201	201	CD
18637	12071	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12071	4	1	1	CD
18637	12071	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12071	6	.	.	.
18637	12072	1	137	137	CD
18637	12072	2	,	,	,
18637	12072	3	170	170	CD
18637	12072	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12072	5	1803	1803	CD
18637	12072	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12072	7	.	.	.
18637	12073	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12073	2	202	202	CD
18637	12073	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12073	4	7	7	CD
18637	12073	5	How	how	WRB
18637	12073	6	.	.	.
18637	12074	1	1	1	CD
18637	12074	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12074	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	12074	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12074	5	.	.	.
18637	12075	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12075	2	203	203	CD
18637	12075	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12075	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12075	5	.	.	.
18637	12076	1	41	41	CD
18637	12076	2	.	.	.
18637	12077	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12077	2	204	204	CD
18637	12077	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12077	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12077	5	.	.	.
18637	12078	1	42	42	CD
18637	12078	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12078	3	45	45	CD
18637	12078	4	.	.	.
18637	12079	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12079	2	205	205	CD
18637	12079	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12079	4	This	this	DT
18637	12079	5	classification	classification	NN
18637	12079	6	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	12079	7	in	in	IN
18637	12079	8	the	the	DT
18637	12079	9	main	main	JJ
18637	12079	10	that	that	DT
18637	12079	11	of	of	IN
18637	12079	12	Melville	Melville	NNP
18637	12079	13	Fuller	Fuller	NNP
18637	12079	14	Weston	Weston	NNP
18637	12079	15	,	,	,
18637	12079	16	Political	Political	NNP
18637	12079	17	Questions	Questions	NNPS
18637	12079	18	,	,	,
18637	12079	19	38	38	CD
18637	12079	20	Harv	Harv	NNP
18637	12079	21	.	.	.
18637	12080	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	12080	2	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	12081	1	296	296	CD
18637	12081	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12081	3	1925	1925	CD
18637	12081	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12081	5	.	.	.
18637	12082	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12082	2	206	206	CD
18637	12082	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12082	4	Field	Field	NNP
18637	12082	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12082	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12082	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12082	8	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	12082	9	,	,	,
18637	12082	10	143	143	CD
18637	12082	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12082	12	649	649	CD
18637	12082	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12082	14	1892	1892	CD
18637	12082	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12082	16	.	.	.
18637	12083	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12083	2	207	207	CD
18637	12083	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12083	4	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	12083	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12083	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12083	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12083	8	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	12083	9	,	,	,
18637	12083	10	307	307	CD
18637	12083	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12083	12	433	433	CD
18637	12083	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12083	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	12083	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12083	16	.	.	.
18637	12084	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12084	2	208	208	CD
18637	12084	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12084	4	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	12084	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12084	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12084	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12084	8	Neilson	Neilson	NNP
18637	12084	9	,	,	,
18637	12084	10	2	2	CD
18637	12084	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12084	12	.	.	.
18637	12085	1	253	253	CD
18637	12085	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12085	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	12085	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12085	5	.	.	.
18637	12086	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12086	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12086	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12086	4	p.	p.	NN
18637	12086	5	472	472	CD
18637	12086	6	,	,	,
18637	12086	7	supra	supra	NNP
18637	12086	8	.	.	.
18637	12087	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12087	2	209	209	CD
18637	12087	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12087	4	Commercial	Commercial	NNP
18637	12087	5	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	12087	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12087	7	of	of	IN
18637	12087	8	New	New	NNP
18637	12087	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	12087	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12087	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	12087	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12087	13	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	12087	14	,	,	,
18637	12087	15	262	262	CD
18637	12087	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12087	17	51	51	CD
18637	12087	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12087	19	1923	1923	CD
18637	12087	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12087	21	.	.	.
18637	12088	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12088	2	210	210	CD
18637	12088	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12088	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12088	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12088	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12088	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12088	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12088	9	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	12088	10	,	,	,
18637	12088	11	9	9	CD
18637	12088	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12088	13	.	.	.
18637	12089	1	56	56	CD
18637	12089	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12089	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	12089	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12089	5	.	.	.
18637	12090	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12090	2	211	211	CD
18637	12090	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12090	4	Luther	Luther	NNP
18637	12090	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12090	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12090	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12090	8	Borden	Borden	NNP
18637	12090	9	,	,	,
18637	12090	10	7	7	CD
18637	12090	11	How	how	WRB
18637	12090	12	.	.	.
18637	12091	1	1	1	CD
18637	12091	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12091	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	12091	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12091	5	;	;	:
18637	12091	6	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	12091	7	States	States	NNP
18637	12091	8	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	12091	9	&	&	CC
18637	12091	10	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	12091	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12091	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12091	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	12091	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12091	15	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	12091	16	,	,	,
18637	12091	17	223	223	CD
18637	12091	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12091	19	118	118	CD
18637	12091	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12091	21	1912	1912	CD
18637	12091	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12091	23	.	.	.
18637	12092	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12092	2	212	212	CD
18637	12092	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12092	4	Luther	Luther	NNP
18637	12092	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12092	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12092	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12092	8	Borden	Borden	NNP
18637	12092	9	,	,	,
18637	12092	10	7	7	CD
18637	12092	11	How	how	WRB
18637	12092	12	.	.	.
18637	12093	1	1	1	CD
18637	12093	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12093	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	12093	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12093	5	.	.	.
18637	12094	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12094	2	213	213	CD
18637	12094	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12094	4	McPherson	McPherson	NNP
18637	12094	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12094	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12094	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12094	8	Blacker	Blacker	NNP
18637	12094	9	,	,	,
18637	12094	10	146	146	CD
18637	12094	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12094	12	1	1	CD
18637	12094	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12094	14	1892	1892	CD
18637	12094	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12094	16	,	,	,
18637	12094	17	where	where	WRB
18637	12094	18	the	the	DT
18637	12094	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12094	20	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	12094	21	to	to	TO
18637	12094	22	pass	pass	VB
18637	12094	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	12094	24	the	the	DT
18637	12094	25	act	act	NN
18637	12094	26	of	of	IN
18637	12094	27	the	the	DT
18637	12094	28	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	12094	29	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	12094	30	in	in	IN
18637	12094	31	1892	1892	CD
18637	12094	32	providing	provide	VBG
18637	12094	33	for	for	IN
18637	12094	34	the	the	DT
18637	12094	35	election	election	NN
18637	12094	36	of	of	IN
18637	12094	37	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	12094	38	electors	elector	NNS
18637	12094	39	by	by	IN
18637	12094	40	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	12094	41	districts	district	NNS
18637	12094	42	.	.	.
18637	12095	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12095	2	214	214	CD
18637	12095	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12095	4	South	South	NNP
18637	12095	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12095	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12095	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12095	8	Peters	Peters	NNP
18637	12095	9	,	,	,
18637	12095	10	339	339	CD
18637	12095	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12095	12	276	276	CD
18637	12095	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12095	14	1950	1950	CD
18637	12095	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12095	16	.	.	.
18637	12096	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12096	2	215	215	CD
18637	12096	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12096	4	Colegrove	Colegrove	NNP
18637	12096	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12096	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12096	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12096	8	Green	Green	NNP
18637	12096	9	,	,	,
18637	12096	10	328	328	CD
18637	12096	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12096	12	549	549	CD
18637	12096	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12096	14	1946	1946	CD
18637	12096	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12096	16	.	.	.
18637	12097	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12097	2	216	216	CD
18637	12097	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12097	4	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	12097	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12097	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12097	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12097	8	Mellon	Mellon	NNP
18637	12097	9	,	,	,
18637	12097	10	262	262	CD
18637	12097	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12097	12	447	447	CD
18637	12097	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12097	14	1923	1923	CD
18637	12097	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12097	16	;	;	:
18637	12097	17	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	12097	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12097	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	12097	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12097	21	Stanton	Stanton	NNP
18637	12097	22	,	,	,
18637	12097	23	6	6	CD
18637	12097	24	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12097	25	.	.	.
18637	12098	1	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12098	2	50	50	CD
18637	12098	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12098	4	1868	1868	CD
18637	12098	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12098	6	;	;	:
18637	12098	7	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	12098	8	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	12098	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12098	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12098	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12098	12	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	12098	13	,	,	,
18637	12098	14	5	5	CD
18637	12098	15	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12098	16	.	.	.
18637	12099	1	1	1	CD
18637	12099	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12099	3	1831	1831	CD
18637	12099	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12099	5	.	.	.
18637	12100	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12100	2	217	217	CD
18637	12100	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12100	4	143	143	CD
18637	12100	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12100	6	649	649	CD
18637	12100	7	,	,	,
18637	12100	8	670	670	CD
18637	12100	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12100	10	672	672	CD
18637	12100	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12100	12	1892	1892	CD
18637	12100	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12100	14	.	.	.
18637	12101	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12101	2	218	218	CD
18637	12101	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12101	4	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	12101	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12101	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12101	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12101	8	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	12101	9	,	,	,
18637	12101	10	307	307	CD
18637	12101	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12101	12	433	433	CD
18637	12101	13	,	,	,
18637	12101	14	450	450	CD
18637	12101	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12101	16	1939	1939	CD
18637	12101	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12101	18	.	.	.
18637	12102	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12102	2	219	219	CD
18637	12102	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12102	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12102	5	.	.	.
18637	12103	1	452	452	CD
18637	12103	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12103	3	453	453	CD
18637	12103	4	.	.	.
18637	12104	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12104	2	220	220	CD
18637	12104	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12104	4	328	328	CD
18637	12104	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12104	6	549	549	CD
18637	12104	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12104	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	12104	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12104	10	.	.	.
18637	12105	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12105	2	221	221	CD
18637	12105	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12105	4	287	287	CD
18637	12105	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12105	6	1	1	CD
18637	12105	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12105	8	1932	1932	CD
18637	12105	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12105	10	.	.	.
18637	12106	1	This	this	DT
18637	12106	2	case	case	NN
18637	12106	3	involved	involve	VBD
18637	12106	4	an	an	DT
18637	12106	5	unsuccessful	unsuccessful	JJ
18637	12106	6	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	12106	7	to	to	TO
18637	12106	8	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	12106	9	an	an	DT
18637	12106	10	election	election	NN
18637	12106	11	of	of	IN
18637	12106	12	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	12106	13	in	in	IN
18637	12106	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12106	15	in	in	IN
18637	12106	16	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	12106	17	because	because	IN
18637	12106	18	the	the	DT
18637	12106	19	districts	district	NNS
18637	12106	20	formed	form	VBN
18637	12106	21	by	by	IN
18637	12106	22	the	the	DT
18637	12106	23	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	12106	24	for	for	IN
18637	12106	25	that	that	DT
18637	12106	26	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	12106	27	were	be	VBD
18637	12106	28	not	not	RB
18637	12106	29	a	a	DT
18637	12106	30	contiguous	contiguous	JJ
18637	12106	31	and	and	CC
18637	12106	32	compact	compact	JJ
18637	12106	33	territory	territory	NN
18637	12106	34	and	and	CC
18637	12106	35	of	of	IN
18637	12106	36	equal	equal	JJ
18637	12106	37	population	population	NN
18637	12106	38	and	and	CC
18637	12106	39	that	that	IN
18637	12106	40	the	the	DT
18637	12106	41	redistricting	redistricte	VBG
18637	12106	42	violated	violate	VBD
18637	12106	43	article	article	NN
18637	12106	44	I	i	NN
18637	12106	45	,	,	,
18637	12106	46	§	§	NNP
18637	12106	47	4	4	CD
18637	12106	48	and	and	CC
18637	12106	49	the	the	DT
18637	12106	50	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	12106	51	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	12106	52	.	.	.
18637	12107	1	The	the	DT
18637	12107	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12107	3	held	hold	VBD
18637	12107	4	that	that	IN
18637	12107	5	the	the	DT
18637	12107	6	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	12107	7	of	of	IN
18637	12107	8	the	the	DT
18637	12107	9	Reapportionment	Reapportionment	NNP
18637	12107	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12107	11	of	of	IN
18637	12107	12	1929	1929	CD
18637	12107	13	did	do	VBD
18637	12107	14	not	not	RB
18637	12107	15	reenact	reenact	VB
18637	12107	16	the	the	DT
18637	12107	17	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	12107	18	of	of	IN
18637	12107	19	the	the	DT
18637	12107	20	act	act	NN
18637	12107	21	of	of	IN
18637	12107	22	1911	1911	CD
18637	12107	23	and	and	CC
18637	12107	24	that	that	IN
18637	12107	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12107	26	was	be	VBD
18637	12107	27	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	12107	28	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	12107	29	to	to	TO
18637	12107	30	determine	determine	VB
18637	12107	31	whether	whether	IN
18637	12107	32	the	the	DT
18637	12107	33	questions	question	NNS
18637	12107	34	raised	raise	VBN
18637	12107	35	were	be	VBD
18637	12107	36	justiciable	justiciable	NN
18637	12107	37	.	.	.
18637	12108	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12108	2	222	222	CD
18637	12108	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12108	4	285	285	CD
18637	12108	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12108	6	355	355	CD
18637	12108	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12108	8	1932	1932	CD
18637	12108	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12108	10	.	.	.
18637	12109	1	Here	here	RB
18637	12109	2	the	the	DT
18637	12109	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12109	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	12109	5	that	that	IN
18637	12109	6	the	the	DT
18637	12109	7	act	act	NN
18637	12109	8	of	of	IN
18637	12109	9	the	the	DT
18637	12109	10	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	12109	11	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	12109	12	redistricting	redistricte	VBG
18637	12109	13	the	the	DT
18637	12109	14	State	state	NN
18637	12109	15	required	require	VBD
18637	12109	16	the	the	DT
18637	12109	17	governor	governor	NN
18637	12109	18	's	's	POS
18637	12109	19	signature	signature	NN
18637	12109	20	,	,	,
18637	12109	21	and	and	CC
18637	12109	22	that	that	IN
18637	12109	23	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	12109	24	should	should	MD
18637	12109	25	be	be	VB
18637	12109	26	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	12109	27	at	at	IN
18637	12109	28	large	large	JJ
18637	12109	29	until	until	IN
18637	12109	30	a	a	DT
18637	12109	31	redistricting	redistricting	NN
18637	12109	32	was	be	VBD
18637	12109	33	passed	pass	VBN
18637	12109	34	.	.	.
18637	12110	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12110	2	223	223	CD
18637	12110	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12110	4	328	328	CD
18637	12110	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12110	6	549	549	CD
18637	12110	7	,	,	,
18637	12110	8	565	565	CD
18637	12110	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12110	10	566	566	CD
18637	12110	11	.	.	.
18637	12111	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12111	2	224	224	CD
18637	12111	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12111	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12111	5	.	.	.
18637	12112	1	566	566	CD
18637	12112	2	ff	ff	NNS
18637	12112	3	.	.	.
18637	12113	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12113	2	225	225	CD
18637	12113	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12113	4	335	335	CD
18637	12113	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12113	6	281	281	CD
18637	12113	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12113	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	12113	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12113	10	.	.	.
18637	12114	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12114	2	226	226	CD
18637	12114	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12114	4	335	335	CD
18637	12114	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12114	6	160	160	CD
18637	12114	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12114	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	12114	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12114	10	.	.	.
18637	12115	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12115	2	227	227	CD
18637	12115	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12115	4	339	339	CD
18637	12115	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12115	6	276	276	CD
18637	12115	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12115	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	12115	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12115	10	.	.	.
18637	12116	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12116	2	228	228	CD
18637	12116	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12116	4	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	12116	5	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	12116	6	,	,	,
18637	12116	7	The	the	DT
18637	12116	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12116	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12116	10	in	in	IN
18637	12116	11	United	United	NNP
18637	12116	12	States	States	NNP
18637	12116	13	History	History	NNP
18637	12116	14	,	,	,
18637	12116	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12116	16	,	,	,
18637	12116	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12116	18	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	12116	19	,	,	,
18637	12116	20	1922	1922	CD
18637	12116	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12116	22	,	,	,
18637	12116	23	110	110	CD
18637	12116	24	-	-	SYM
18637	12116	25	111	111	CD
18637	12116	26	.	.	.
18637	12117	1	For	for	IN
18637	12117	2	the	the	DT
18637	12117	3	full	full	JJ
18637	12117	4	correspondence	correspondence	NN
18637	12117	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12117	6	see	see	NNP
18637	12117	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12117	8	3	3	CD
18637	12117	9	Correspondence	Correspondence	NNP
18637	12117	10	and	and	CC
18637	12117	11	Public	Public	NNP
18637	12117	12	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	12117	13	of	of	IN
18637	12117	14	John	John	NNP
18637	12117	15	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	12117	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12117	17	1890	1890	CD
18637	12117	18	-	-	SYM
18637	12117	19	1893	1893	CD
18637	12117	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12117	21	,	,	,
18637	12117	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12117	23	edited	edit	VBN
18637	12117	24	by	by	IN
18637	12117	25	Henry	Henry	NNP
18637	12117	26	Phelps	Phelps	NNP
18637	12117	27	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	12117	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12117	29	,	,	,
18637	12117	30	486	486	CD
18637	12117	31	.	.	.
18637	12118	1	According	accord	VBG
18637	12118	2	to	to	IN
18637	12118	3	E.F.	E.F.	NNP
18637	12118	4	Albertsworth	Albertsworth	NNP
18637	12118	5	,	,	,
18637	12118	6	Advisory	Advisory	NNP
18637	12118	7	Functions	Functions	NNPS
18637	12118	8	in	in	IN
18637	12118	9	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	12118	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12118	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12118	12	,	,	,
18637	12118	13	23	23	CD
18637	12118	14	Georgetown	Georgetown	NNP
18637	12118	15	L.J.	L.J.	NNP
18637	12118	16	,	,	,
18637	12118	17	643	643	CD
18637	12118	18	,	,	,
18637	12118	19	644	644	CD
18637	12118	20	-	-	SYM
18637	12118	21	647	647	CD
18637	12118	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12118	23	May	May	NNP
18637	12118	24	1935	1935	CD
18637	12118	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12118	26	,	,	,
18637	12118	27	the	the	DT
18637	12118	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12118	29	rendered	render	VBD
18637	12118	30	an	an	DT
18637	12118	31	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	12118	32	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	12118	33	to	to	IN
18637	12118	34	President	President	NNP
18637	12118	35	Monroe	Monroe	NNP
18637	12118	36	in	in	IN
18637	12118	37	response	response	NN
18637	12118	38	to	to	IN
18637	12118	39	a	a	DT
18637	12118	40	request	request	NN
18637	12118	41	for	for	IN
18637	12118	42	legal	legal	JJ
18637	12118	43	advice	advice	NN
18637	12118	44	on	on	IN
18637	12118	45	the	the	DT
18637	12118	46	power	power	NN
18637	12118	47	of	of	IN
18637	12118	48	the	the	DT
18637	12118	49	Government	Government	NNP
18637	12118	50	to	to	TO
18637	12118	51	appropriate	appropriate	VB
18637	12118	52	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12118	53	funds	fund	NNS
18637	12118	54	for	for	IN
18637	12118	55	public	public	JJ
18637	12118	56	improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	12118	57	by	by	IN
18637	12118	58	responding	respond	VBG
18637	12118	59	that	that	IN
18637	12118	60	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12118	61	might	may	MD
18637	12118	62	do	do	VB
18637	12118	63	so	so	RB
18637	12118	64	under	under	IN
18637	12118	65	the	the	DT
18637	12118	66	war	war	NN
18637	12118	67	and	and	CC
18637	12118	68	postal	postal	JJ
18637	12118	69	powers	power	NNS
18637	12118	70	.	.	.
18637	12119	1	The	the	DT
18637	12119	2	inhibitions	inhibition	NNS
18637	12119	3	of	of	IN
18637	12119	4	the	the	DT
18637	12119	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12119	6	against	against	IN
18637	12119	7	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	12119	8	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	12119	9	do	do	VBP
18637	12119	10	not	not	RB
18637	12119	11	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	12119	12	the	the	DT
18637	12119	13	individual	individual	JJ
18637	12119	14	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	12119	15	from	from	IN
18637	12119	16	giving	give	VBG
18637	12119	17	advice	advice	NN
18637	12119	18	or	or	CC
18637	12119	19	aiding	aid	VBG
18637	12119	20	the	the	DT
18637	12119	21	political	political	JJ
18637	12119	22	departments	department	NNS
18637	12119	23	in	in	IN
18637	12119	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12119	25	private	private	JJ
18637	12119	26	capacities	capacity	NNS
18637	12119	27	.	.	.
18637	12120	1	Ever	ever	RB
18637	12120	2	since	since	IN
18637	12120	3	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	12120	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12120	5	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	12120	6	went	go	VBD
18637	12120	7	on	on	IN
18637	12120	8	a	a	DT
18637	12120	9	mission	mission	NN
18637	12120	10	to	to	IN
18637	12120	11	England	England	NNP
18637	12120	12	to	to	TO
18637	12120	13	negotiate	negotiate	VB
18637	12120	14	a	a	DT
18637	12120	15	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	12120	16	the	the	DT
18637	12120	17	members	member	NNS
18637	12120	18	of	of	IN
18637	12120	19	the	the	DT
18637	12120	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12120	21	have	have	VBP
18637	12120	22	performed	perform	VBN
18637	12120	23	various	various	JJ
18637	12120	24	nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	12120	25	functions	function	NNS
18637	12120	26	.	.	.
18637	12121	1	John	John	NNP
18637	12121	2	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	12121	3	served	serve	VBD
18637	12121	4	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
18637	12121	5	as	as	IN
18637	12121	6	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	12121	7	of	of	IN
18637	12121	8	State	State	NNP
18637	12121	9	and	and	CC
18637	12121	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	12121	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12121	12	,	,	,
18637	12121	13	and	and	CC
18637	12121	14	later	later	RBR
18637	12121	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12121	16	Robert	Robert	NNP
18637	12121	17	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	12121	18	served	serve	VBD
18637	12121	19	as	as	IN
18637	12121	20	war	war	NN
18637	12121	21	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	12121	22	prosecutor	prosecutor	NN
18637	12121	23	.	.	.
18637	12122	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12122	2	229	229	CD
18637	12122	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12122	4	For	for	IN
18637	12122	5	example	example	NN
18637	12122	6	,	,	,
18637	12122	7	Muskrat	Muskrat	NNP
18637	12122	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12122	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12122	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12122	11	United	United	NNP
18637	12122	12	States	States	NNP
18637	12122	13	,	,	,
18637	12122	14	219	219	CD
18637	12122	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12122	16	346	346	CD
18637	12122	17	,	,	,
18637	12122	18	354	354	CD
18637	12122	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12122	20	1911	1911	CD
18637	12122	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12122	22	;	;	:
18637	12122	23	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	12122	24	&	&	CC
18637	12122	25	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	12122	26	Airlines	Airlines	NNPS
18637	12122	27	_	_	NNP
18637	12122	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	12122	29	_	_	NNP
18637	12122	30	Waterman	Waterman	NNP
18637	12122	31	Steamship	Steamship	NNP
18637	12122	32	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	12122	33	,	,	,
18637	12122	34	333	333	CD
18637	12122	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12122	36	103	103	CD
18637	12122	37	,	,	,
18637	12122	38	113	113	CD
18637	12122	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12122	40	1948	1948	CD
18637	12122	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12122	42	;	;	:
18637	12122	43	United	United	NNP
18637	12122	44	Public	Public	NNP
18637	12122	45	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	12122	46	of	of	IN
18637	12122	47	America	America	NNP
18637	12122	48	_	_	NNP
18637	12122	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	12122	50	_	_	NNP
18637	12122	51	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	12122	52	,	,	,
18637	12122	53	330	330	CD
18637	12122	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12122	55	75	75	CD
18637	12122	56	,	,	,
18637	12122	57	89	89	CD
18637	12122	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12122	59	1947	1947	CD
18637	12122	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12122	61	.	.	.
18637	12123	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12123	2	230	230	CD
18637	12123	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12123	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	12123	5	&	&	CC
18637	12123	6	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	12123	7	Airlines	Airlines	NNPS
18637	12123	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12123	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12123	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12123	11	Waterman	Waterman	NNP
18637	12123	12	Steamship	Steamship	NNP
18637	12123	13	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	12123	14	,	,	,
18637	12123	15	333	333	CD
18637	12123	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12123	17	103	103	CD
18637	12123	18	,	,	,
18637	12123	19	113	113	CD
18637	12123	20	-	-	SYM
18637	12123	21	114	114	CD
18637	12123	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12123	23	1948	1948	CD
18637	12123	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12123	25	,	,	,
18637	12123	26	citing	cite	VBG
18637	12123	27	Hayburn	Hayburn	NNP
18637	12123	28	's	's	POS
18637	12123	29	Case	Case	NNP
18637	12123	30	,	,	,
18637	12123	31	2	2	CD
18637	12123	32	Dall	dall	NN
18637	12123	33	.	.	.
18637	12124	1	409	409	CD
18637	12124	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12124	3	1792	1792	CD
18637	12124	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12124	5	;	;	:
18637	12124	6	United	United	NNP
18637	12124	7	States	States	NNP
18637	12124	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12124	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12124	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12124	11	Ferreira	Ferreira	NNP
18637	12124	12	,	,	,
18637	12124	13	13	13	CD
18637	12124	14	How	how	WRB
18637	12124	15	.	.	.
18637	12125	1	40	40	CD
18637	12125	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12125	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	12125	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12125	5	;	;	:
18637	12125	6	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	12125	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12125	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12125	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12125	10	United	United	NNP
18637	12125	11	States	States	NNP
18637	12125	12	,	,	,
18637	12125	13	117	117	CD
18637	12125	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12125	15	697	697	CD
18637	12125	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12125	17	1864	1864	CD
18637	12125	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12125	19	;	;	:
18637	12125	20	In	in	IN
18637	12125	21	re	re	NNP
18637	12125	22	Sanborn	Sanborn	NNP
18637	12125	23	,	,	,
18637	12125	24	148	148	CD
18637	12125	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12125	26	222	222	CD
18637	12125	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12125	28	1893	1893	CD
18637	12125	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12125	30	;	;	:
18637	12125	31	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	12125	32	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	12125	33	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	12125	34	_	_	NNP
18637	12125	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	12125	36	_	_	NNP
18637	12125	37	Brimson	Brimson	NNP
18637	12125	38	,	,	,
18637	12125	39	154	154	CD
18637	12125	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12125	41	447	447	CD
18637	12125	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12125	43	1894	1894	CD
18637	12125	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12125	45	;	;	:
18637	12125	46	La	La	NNP
18637	12125	47	Abra	Abra	NNP
18637	12125	48	Silver	Silver	NNP
18637	12125	49	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	12125	50	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12125	51	_	_	NNP
18637	12125	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	12125	53	_	_	NNP
18637	12125	54	United	United	NNP
18637	12125	55	States	States	NNP
18637	12125	56	,	,	,
18637	12125	57	175	175	CD
18637	12125	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12125	59	423	423	CD
18637	12125	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12125	61	1899	1899	CD
18637	12125	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12125	63	;	;	:
18637	12125	64	Muskrat	Muskrat	NNP
18637	12125	65	_	_	NNP
18637	12125	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	12125	67	_	_	NNP
18637	12125	68	United	United	NNP
18637	12125	69	States	States	NNP
18637	12125	70	,	,	,
18637	12125	71	219	219	CD
18637	12125	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12125	73	346	346	CD
18637	12125	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12125	75	1911	1911	CD
18637	12125	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12125	77	;	;	:
18637	12125	78	United	United	NNP
18637	12125	79	States	States	NNP
18637	12125	80	_	_	NNP
18637	12125	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	12125	82	_	_	NNP
18637	12125	83	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	12125	84	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	12125	85	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12125	86	,	,	,
18637	12125	87	291	291	CD
18637	12125	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12125	89	386	386	CD
18637	12125	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12125	91	1934	1934	CD
18637	12125	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12125	93	.	.	.
18637	12126	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12126	2	231	231	CD
18637	12126	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12126	4	Muskrat	Muskrat	NNP
18637	12126	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12126	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12126	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12126	8	United	United	NNP
18637	12126	9	States	States	NNP
18637	12126	10	,	,	,
18637	12126	11	219	219	CD
18637	12126	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12126	13	346	346	CD
18637	12126	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12126	15	1911	1911	CD
18637	12126	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12126	17	.	.	.
18637	12127	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12127	2	232	232	CD
18637	12127	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12127	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12127	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12127	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12127	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12127	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12127	9	Ferreira	Ferreira	NNP
18637	12127	10	,	,	,
18637	12127	11	13	13	CD
18637	12127	12	How	how	WRB
18637	12127	13	.	.	.
18637	12128	1	40	40	CD
18637	12128	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12128	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	12128	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12128	5	.	.	.
18637	12129	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12129	2	233	233	CD
18637	12129	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12129	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12129	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	12129	6	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	12129	7	of	of	IN
18637	12129	8	America	America	NNP
18637	12129	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12129	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12129	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12129	12	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	12129	13	,	,	,
18637	12129	14	330	330	CD
18637	12129	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12129	16	75	75	CD
18637	12129	17	,	,	,
18637	12129	18	89	89	CD
18637	12129	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12129	20	1947	1947	CD
18637	12129	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12129	22	.	.	.
18637	12130	1	Here	here	RB
18637	12130	2	,	,	,
18637	12130	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12130	4	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	12130	5	,	,	,
18637	12130	6	for	for	IN
18637	12130	7	the	the	DT
18637	12130	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12130	9	,	,	,
18637	12130	10	after	after	IN
18637	12130	11	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	12130	12	that	that	IN
18637	12130	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	12130	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	12130	15	do	do	VBP
18637	12130	16	not	not	RB
18637	12130	17	render	render	VB
18637	12130	18	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	12130	19	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	12130	20	,	,	,
18637	12130	21	declared	declare	VBD
18637	12130	22	that	that	IN
18637	12130	23	"	"	``
18637	12130	24	'	'	``
18637	12130	25	concrete	concrete	JJ
18637	12130	26	legal	legal	JJ
18637	12130	27	issues	issue	NNS
18637	12130	28	,	,	,
18637	12130	29	presented	present	VBN
18637	12130	30	in	in	IN
18637	12130	31	actual	actual	JJ
18637	12130	32	cases	case	NNS
18637	12130	33	,	,	,
18637	12130	34	not	not	RB
18637	12130	35	abstractions	abstraction	NNS
18637	12130	36	,	,	,
18637	12130	37	'	'	``
18637	12130	38	are	be	VBP
18637	12130	39	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	12130	40	"	"	''
18637	12130	41	for	for	IN
18637	12130	42	the	the	DT
18637	12130	43	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	12130	44	of	of	IN
18637	12130	45	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	12130	46	issues	issue	NNS
18637	12130	47	,	,	,
18637	12130	48	citing	cite	VBG
18637	12130	49	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	12130	50	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	12130	51	and	and	CC
18637	12130	52	Share	Share	NNP
18637	12130	53	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12130	54	_	_	NNP
18637	12130	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	12130	56	_	_	NNP
18637	12130	57	Securities	Securities	NNP
18637	12130	58	&	&	CC
18637	12130	59	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	12130	60	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	12130	61	,	,	,
18637	12130	62	303	303	CD
18637	12130	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12130	64	419	419	CD
18637	12130	65	,	,	,
18637	12130	66	443	443	CD
18637	12130	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12130	68	1938	1938	CD
18637	12130	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12130	70	;	;	:
18637	12130	71	United	United	NNP
18637	12130	72	States	States	NNP
18637	12130	73	_	_	NNP
18637	12130	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	12130	75	_	_	NNP
18637	12130	76	Appalachian	Appalachian	NNP
18637	12130	77	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	12130	78	Power	Power	NNP
18637	12130	79	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12130	80	,	,	,
18637	12130	81	311	311	CD
18637	12130	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12130	83	377	377	CD
18637	12130	84	,	,	,
18637	12130	85	423	423	CD
18637	12130	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12130	87	1940	1940	CD
18637	12130	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12130	89	;	;	:
18637	12130	90	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	12130	91	State	State	NNP
18637	12130	92	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	12130	93	of	of	IN
18637	12130	94	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	12130	95	_	_	NNP
18637	12130	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	12130	97	_	_	NNP
18637	12130	98	McAdory	McAdory	NNP
18637	12130	99	,	,	,
18637	12130	100	325	325	CD
18637	12130	101	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12130	102	450	450	CD
18637	12130	103	,	,	,
18637	12130	104	461	461	CD
18637	12130	105	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12130	106	1945	1945	CD
18637	12130	107	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12130	108	;	;	:
18637	12130	109	and	and	CC
18637	12130	110	Coffman	Coffman	NNP
18637	12130	111	_	_	NNP
18637	12130	112	v.	v.	IN
18637	12130	113	_	_	NNP
18637	12130	114	Breeze	Breeze	NNP
18637	12130	115	Corporations	Corporations	NNP
18637	12130	116	,	,	,
18637	12130	117	323	323	CD
18637	12130	118	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12130	119	316	316	CD
18637	12130	120	,	,	,
18637	12130	121	324	324	CD
18637	12130	122	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12130	123	1945	1945	CD
18637	12130	124	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12130	125	.	.	.
18637	12131	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12131	2	234	234	CD
18637	12131	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12131	4	13	13	CD
18637	12131	5	How	how	WRB
18637	12131	6	.	.	.
18637	12132	1	40	40	CD
18637	12132	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12132	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	12132	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12132	5	.	.	.
18637	12133	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12133	2	235	235	CD
18637	12133	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12133	4	117	117	CD
18637	12133	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12133	6	697	697	CD
18637	12133	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12133	8	1864	1864	CD
18637	12133	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12133	10	.	.	.
18637	12134	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12134	2	236	236	CD
18637	12134	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12134	4	273	273	CD
18637	12134	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12134	6	70	70	CD
18637	12134	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12134	8	1927	1927	CD
18637	12134	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12134	10	.	.	.
18637	12135	1	In	in	IN
18637	12135	2	Willing	Willing	NNP
18637	12135	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12135	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	12135	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12135	6	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	12135	7	Auditorium	Auditorium	NNP
18637	12135	8	Association	Association	NNP
18637	12135	9	,	,	,
18637	12135	10	277	277	CD
18637	12135	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12135	12	274	274	CD
18637	12135	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12135	14	1928	1928	CD
18637	12135	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12135	16	certain	certain	JJ
18637	12135	17	lessees	lessee	NNS
18637	12135	18	desired	desire	VBN
18637	12135	19	to	to	TO
18637	12135	20	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	12135	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12135	22	rights	right	NNS
18637	12135	23	under	under	IN
18637	12135	24	a	a	DT
18637	12135	25	lease	lease	NN
18637	12135	26	to	to	TO
18637	12135	27	demolish	demolish	VB
18637	12135	28	a	a	DT
18637	12135	29	building	building	NN
18637	12135	30	after	after	IN
18637	12135	31	the	the	DT
18637	12135	32	lessors	lessor	NNS
18637	12135	33	had	have	VBD
18637	12135	34	failed	fail	VBN
18637	12135	35	to	to	TO
18637	12135	36	admit	admit	VB
18637	12135	37	such	such	JJ
18637	12135	38	rights	right	NNS
18637	12135	39	on	on	IN
18637	12135	40	the	the	DT
18637	12135	41	allegation	allegation	NN
18637	12135	42	that	that	WDT
18637	12135	43	claims	claim	VBZ
18637	12135	44	,	,	,
18637	12135	45	fears	fear	NNS
18637	12135	46	,	,	,
18637	12135	47	and	and	CC
18637	12135	48	uncertainties	uncertainty	NNS
18637	12135	49	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	12135	50	the	the	DT
18637	12135	51	rights	right	NNS
18637	12135	52	of	of	IN
18637	12135	53	the	the	DT
18637	12135	54	parties	party	NNS
18637	12135	55	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	12135	56	impaired	impair	VBD
18637	12135	57	the	the	DT
18637	12135	58	value	value	NN
18637	12135	59	of	of	IN
18637	12135	60	the	the	DT
18637	12135	61	leasehold	leasehold	NN
18637	12135	62	.	.	.
18637	12136	1	Because	because	IN
18637	12136	2	there	there	EX
18637	12136	3	was	be	VBD
18637	12136	4	no	no	DT
18637	12136	5	showing	showing	NN
18637	12136	6	that	that	IN
18637	12136	7	the	the	DT
18637	12136	8	lessors	lessor	NNS
18637	12136	9	had	have	VBD
18637	12136	10	hampered	hamper	VBN
18637	12136	11	the	the	DT
18637	12136	12	full	full	JJ
18637	12136	13	use	use	NN
18637	12136	14	of	of	IN
18637	12136	15	the	the	DT
18637	12136	16	premises	premise	NNS
18637	12136	17	or	or	CC
18637	12136	18	had	have	VBD
18637	12136	19	committed	commit	VBN
18637	12136	20	or	or	CC
18637	12136	21	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	12136	22	a	a	DT
18637	12136	23	hostile	hostile	JJ
18637	12136	24	act	act	NN
18637	12136	25	,	,	,
18637	12136	26	the	the	DT
18637	12136	27	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12136	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12136	29	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	12136	30	the	the	DT
18637	12136	31	decree	decree	NN
18637	12136	32	of	of	IN
18637	12136	33	the	the	DT
18637	12136	34	lower	low	JJR
18637	12136	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12136	36	dismissing	dismiss	VBG
18637	12136	37	the	the	DT
18637	12136	38	bill	bill	NN
18637	12136	39	on	on	IN
18637	12136	40	the	the	DT
18637	12136	41	ground	ground	NN
18637	12136	42	that	that	IN
18637	12136	43	the	the	DT
18637	12136	44	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	12136	45	was	be	VBD
18637	12136	46	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	12136	47	a	a	DT
18637	12136	48	mere	mere	JJ
18637	12136	49	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	12136	50	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	12136	51	.	.	.
18637	12137	1	The	the	DT
18637	12137	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12137	3	admitted	admit	VBD
18637	12137	4	that	that	IN
18637	12137	5	the	the	DT
18637	12137	6	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	12137	7	was	be	VBD
18637	12137	8	not	not	RB
18637	12137	9	moot	moot	JJ
18637	12137	10	,	,	,
18637	12137	11	that	that	IN
18637	12137	12	there	there	EX
18637	12137	13	were	be	VBD
18637	12137	14	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	12137	15	parties	party	NNS
18637	12137	16	with	with	IN
18637	12137	17	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	12137	18	interests	interest	NNS
18637	12137	19	,	,	,
18637	12137	20	and	and	CC
18637	12137	21	that	that	IN
18637	12137	22	a	a	DT
18637	12137	23	final	final	JJ
18637	12137	24	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	12137	25	could	could	MD
18637	12137	26	have	have	VB
18637	12137	27	been	be	VBN
18637	12137	28	rendered	render	VBN
18637	12137	29	,	,	,
18637	12137	30	but	but	CC
18637	12137	31	held	hold	VBN
18637	12137	32	,	,	,
18637	12137	33	nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
18637	12137	34	,	,	,
18637	12137	35	that	that	IN
18637	12137	36	the	the	DT
18637	12137	37	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	12137	38	was	be	VBD
18637	12137	39	not	not	RB
18637	12137	40	a	a	DT
18637	12137	41	case	case	NN
18637	12137	42	or	or	CC
18637	12137	43	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	12137	44	merely	merely	RB
18637	12137	45	because	because	IN
18637	12137	46	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
18637	12137	47	were	be	VBD
18637	12137	48	thwarted	thwart	VBN
18637	12137	49	by	by	IN
18637	12137	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12137	51	own	own	JJ
18637	12137	52	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	12137	53	,	,	,
18637	12137	54	or	or	CC
18637	12137	55	by	by	IN
18637	12137	56	the	the	DT
18637	12137	57	fears	fear	NNS
18637	12137	58	of	of	IN
18637	12137	59	others	other	NNS
18637	12137	60	.	.	.
18637	12138	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	12138	2	.	.	.
18637	12139	1	289	289	CD
18637	12139	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12139	3	290	290	CD
18637	12139	4	.	.	.
18637	12140	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12140	2	237	237	CD
18637	12140	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12140	4	219	219	CD
18637	12140	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12140	6	346	346	CD
18637	12140	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12140	8	1911	1911	CD
18637	12140	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12140	10	.	.	.
18637	12141	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12141	2	238	238	CD
18637	12141	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12141	4	274	274	CD
18637	12141	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12141	6	123	123	CD
18637	12141	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12141	8	1927	1927	CD
18637	12141	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12141	10	.	.	.
18637	12142	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12142	2	239	239	CD
18637	12142	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12142	4	288	288	CD
18637	12142	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12142	6	249	249	CD
18637	12142	7	,	,	,
18637	12142	8	264	264	CD
18637	12142	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12142	10	1933	1933	CD
18637	12142	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12142	12	.	.	.
18637	12143	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12143	2	240	240	CD
18637	12143	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12143	4	300	300	CD
18637	12143	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12143	6	227	227	CD
18637	12143	7	,	,	,
18637	12143	8	240	240	CD
18637	12143	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12143	10	1937	1937	CD
18637	12143	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12143	12	.	.	.
18637	12144	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12144	2	241	241	CD
18637	12144	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12144	4	28	28	CD
18637	12144	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	12145	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	12145	2	2201	2201	CD
18637	12145	3	,	,	,
18637	12145	4	2202	2202	CD
18637	12145	5	;	;	:
18637	12145	6	48	48	CD
18637	12145	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	12145	8	.	.	.
18637	12146	1	955	955	CD
18637	12146	2	.	.	.
18637	12147	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12147	2	242	242	CD
18637	12147	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12147	4	300	300	CD
18637	12147	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12147	6	227	227	CD
18637	12147	7	,	,	,
18637	12147	8	240	240	CD
18637	12147	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	12147	10	241	241	CD
18637	12147	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12147	12	1937	1937	CD
18637	12147	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12147	14	.	.	.
18637	12148	1	The	the	DT
18637	12148	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12148	3	distinguished	distinguish	VBD
18637	12148	4	between	between	IN
18637	12148	5	a	a	DT
18637	12148	6	justiciable	justiciable	JJ
18637	12148	7	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	12148	8	and	and	CC
18637	12148	9	a	a	DT
18637	12148	10	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	12148	11	of	of	IN
18637	12148	12	an	an	DT
18637	12148	13	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	12148	14	character	character	NN
18637	12148	15	,	,	,
18637	12148	16	emphasized	emphasize	VBD
18637	12148	17	that	that	IN
18637	12148	18	the	the	DT
18637	12148	19	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	12148	20	must	must	MD
18637	12148	21	be	be	VB
18637	12148	22	definite	definite	JJ
18637	12148	23	and	and	CC
18637	12148	24	concrete	concrete	JJ
18637	12148	25	,	,	,
18637	12148	26	touching	touch	VBG
18637	12148	27	the	the	DT
18637	12148	28	legal	legal	JJ
18637	12148	29	relations	relation	NNS
18637	12148	30	of	of	IN
18637	12148	31	parties	party	NNS
18637	12148	32	having	have	VBG
18637	12148	33	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	12148	34	legal	legal	JJ
18637	12148	35	interests	interest	NNS
18637	12148	36	,	,	,
18637	12148	37	and	and	CC
18637	12148	38	reiterated	reiterate	VBD
18637	12148	39	the	the	DT
18637	12148	40	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	12148	41	of	of	IN
18637	12148	42	"	"	``
18637	12148	43	a	a	DT
18637	12148	44	real	real	JJ
18637	12148	45	and	and	CC
18637	12148	46	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	12148	47	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	12148	48	admitting	admit	VBG
18637	12148	49	of	of	IN
18637	12148	50	specific	specific	JJ
18637	12148	51	relief	relief	NN
18637	12148	52	through	through	IN
18637	12148	53	a	a	DT
18637	12148	54	decree	decree	NN
18637	12148	55	of	of	IN
18637	12148	56	a	a	DT
18637	12148	57	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	12148	58	character	character	NN
18637	12148	59	,	,	,
18637	12148	60	as	as	IN
18637	12148	61	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	12148	62	from	from	IN
18637	12148	63	an	an	DT
18637	12148	64	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	12148	65	advising	advise	VBG
18637	12148	66	what	what	WP
18637	12148	67	the	the	DT
18637	12148	68	law	law	NN
18637	12148	69	would	would	MD
18637	12148	70	be	be	VB
18637	12148	71	upon	upon	IN
18637	12148	72	a	a	DT
18637	12148	73	hypothetical	hypothetical	JJ
18637	12148	74	state	state	NN
18637	12148	75	of	of	IN
18637	12148	76	facts	fact	NNS
18637	12148	77	.	.	.
18637	12148	78	"	"	''
18637	12149	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12149	2	243	243	CD
18637	12149	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12149	4	Ashwander	Ashwander	NNP
18637	12149	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12149	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12149	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12149	8	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	12149	9	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	12149	10	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	12149	11	,	,	,
18637	12149	12	297	297	CD
18637	12149	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12149	14	288	288	CD
18637	12149	15	,	,	,
18637	12149	16	324	324	CD
18637	12149	17	-	-	SYM
18637	12149	18	325	325	CD
18637	12149	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12149	20	1936	1936	CD
18637	12149	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12149	22	.	.	.
18637	12150	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12150	2	244	244	CD
18637	12150	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12150	4	303	303	CD
18637	12150	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12150	6	419	419	CD
18637	12150	7	,	,	,
18637	12150	8	443	443	CD
18637	12150	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12150	10	1938	1938	CD
18637	12150	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12150	12	.	.	.
18637	12151	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12151	2	245	245	CD
18637	12151	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12151	4	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	12151	5	State	State	NNP
18637	12151	6	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	12151	7	of	of	IN
18637	12151	8	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	12151	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12151	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12151	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12151	12	McAdory	McAdory	NNP
18637	12151	13	,	,	,
18637	12151	14	325	325	CD
18637	12151	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12151	16	450	450	CD
18637	12151	17	,	,	,
18637	12151	18	461	461	CD
18637	12151	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12151	20	1945	1945	CD
18637	12151	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12151	22	,	,	,
18637	12151	23	citing	cite	VBG
18637	12151	24	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	12151	25	,	,	,
18637	12151	26	C.	C.	NNP
18637	12151	27	&	&	CC
18637	12151	28	St.	St.	NNP
18637	12151	29	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	12152	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12152	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12152	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12152	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12152	5	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	12152	6	,	,	,
18637	12152	7	288	288	CD
18637	12152	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12152	9	249	249	CD
18637	12152	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12152	11	1933	1933	CD
18637	12152	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12152	13	;	;	:
18637	12152	14	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	12152	15	Life	Life	NNP
18637	12152	16	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	12152	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12152	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12152	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	12152	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12152	21	Haworth	Haworth	NNP
18637	12152	22	,	,	,
18637	12152	23	300	300	CD
18637	12152	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12152	25	227	227	CD
18637	12152	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12152	27	1937	1937	CD
18637	12152	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12152	29	;	;	:
18637	12152	30	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	12152	31	Casualty	Casualty	NNP
18637	12152	32	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12152	33	_	_	NNP
18637	12152	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	12152	35	_	_	NNP
18637	12152	36	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	12152	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12152	38	,	,	,
18637	12152	39	312	312	CD
18637	12152	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12152	41	270	270	CD
18637	12152	42	,	,	,
18637	12152	43	273	273	CD
18637	12152	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12152	45	1941	1941	CD
18637	12152	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12152	47	;	;	:
18637	12152	48	Great	Great	NNP
18637	12152	49	Lakes	Lakes	NNPS
18637	12152	50	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12152	51	_	_	NNP
18637	12152	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	12152	53	_	_	NNP
18637	12152	54	Huffman	Huffman	NNP
18637	12152	55	,	,	,
18637	12152	56	319	319	CD
18637	12152	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12152	58	293	293	CD
18637	12152	59	,	,	,
18637	12152	60	299	299	CD
18637	12152	61	,	,	,
18637	12152	62	300	300	CD
18637	12152	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12152	64	1943	1943	CD
18637	12152	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12152	66	;	;	:
18637	12152	67	and	and	CC
18637	12152	68	Coffman	Coffman	NNP
18637	12152	69	_	_	NNP
18637	12152	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	12152	71	_	_	NNP
18637	12152	72	Breeze	Breeze	NNP
18637	12152	73	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	12152	74	,	,	,
18637	12152	75	323	323	CD
18637	12152	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12152	77	316	316	CD
18637	12152	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12152	79	1945	1945	CD
18637	12152	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12152	81	.	.	.
18637	12153	1	Here	here	RB
18637	12153	2	,	,	,
18637	12153	3	as	as	IN
18637	12153	4	in	in	IN
18637	12153	5	other	other	JJ
18637	12153	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	12153	7	,	,	,
18637	12153	8	the	the	DT
18637	12153	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12153	10	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	12153	11	to	to	TO
18637	12153	12	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	12153	13	hypothetical	hypothetical	JJ
18637	12153	14	,	,	,
18637	12153	15	or	or	CC
18637	12153	16	contingent	contingent	JJ
18637	12153	17	questions	question	NNS
18637	12153	18	,	,	,
18637	12153	19	and	and	CC
18637	12153	20	the	the	DT
18637	12153	21	decision	decision	NN
18637	12153	22	of	of	IN
18637	12153	23	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	12153	24	issues	issue	NNS
18637	12153	25	prematurely	prematurely	RB
18637	12153	26	.	.	.
18637	12154	1	For	for	IN
18637	12154	2	this	this	DT
18637	12154	3	same	same	JJ
18637	12154	4	rule	rule	NN
18637	12154	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12154	6	see	see	VB
18637	12154	7	also	also	RB
18637	12154	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12154	9	,	,	,
18637	12154	10	Altvater	Altvater	NNP
18637	12154	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12154	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	12154	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12154	14	Freeman	Freeman	NNP
18637	12154	15	,	,	,
18637	12154	16	319	319	CD
18637	12154	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12154	18	359	359	CD
18637	12154	19	,	,	,
18637	12154	20	363	363	CD
18637	12154	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12154	22	1943	1943	CD
18637	12154	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12154	24	.	.	.
18637	12155	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12155	2	246	246	CD
18637	12155	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12155	4	306	306	CD
18637	12155	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12155	6	1	1	CD
18637	12155	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12155	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	12155	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12155	10	.	.	.
18637	12156	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12156	2	247	247	CD
18637	12156	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12156	4	307	307	CD
18637	12156	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12156	6	325	325	CD
18637	12156	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12156	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	12156	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12156	10	.	.	.
18637	12157	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12157	2	248	248	CD
18637	12157	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12157	4	312	312	CD
18637	12157	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12157	6	270	270	CD
18637	12157	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12157	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	12157	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12157	10	.	.	.
18637	12158	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12158	2	249	249	CD
18637	12158	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12158	4	300	300	CD
18637	12158	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12158	6	227	227	CD
18637	12158	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12158	8	1937	1937	CD
18637	12158	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12158	10	.	.	.
18637	12159	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12159	2	250	250	CD
18637	12159	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12159	4	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	12159	5	Casualty	Casualty	NNP
18637	12159	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12159	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12159	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12159	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12159	10	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	12159	11	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	12159	12	&	&	CC
18637	12159	13	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	12159	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12159	15	,	,	,
18637	12159	16	312	312	CD
18637	12159	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12159	18	270	270	CD
18637	12159	19	,	,	,
18637	12159	20	273	273	CD
18637	12159	21	,	,	,
18637	12159	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12159	23	1941	1941	CD
18637	12159	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12159	25	.	.	.
18637	12160	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12160	2	251	251	CD
18637	12160	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12160	4	Brillhart	Brillhart	NNP
18637	12160	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12160	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12160	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12160	8	Excess	Excess	NNP
18637	12160	9	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	12160	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12160	11	,	,	,
18637	12160	12	316	316	CD
18637	12160	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12160	14	491	491	CD
18637	12160	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12160	16	1942	1942	CD
18637	12160	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12160	18	.	.	.
18637	12161	1	This	this	DT
18637	12161	2	was	be	VBD
18637	12161	3	a	a	DT
18637	12161	4	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	12161	5	of	of	IN
18637	12161	6	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	12161	7	case	case	NN
18637	12161	8	which	which	WDT
18637	12161	9	presented	present	VBD
18637	12161	10	only	only	RB
18637	12161	11	local	local	JJ
18637	12161	12	questions	question	NNS
18637	12161	13	.	.	.
18637	12162	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12162	2	252	252	CD
18637	12162	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12162	4	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	12162	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12162	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12162	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12162	8	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	12162	9	,	,	,
18637	12162	10	6	6	CD
18637	12162	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12162	12	.	.	.
18637	12163	1	264	264	CD
18637	12163	2	,	,	,
18637	12163	3	378	378	CD
18637	12163	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12163	5	1821	1821	CD
18637	12163	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12163	7	.	.	.
18637	12164	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12164	2	253	253	CD
18637	12164	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12164	4	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12164	5	.	.	.
18637	12165	1	73	73	CD
18637	12165	2	,	,	,
18637	12165	3	85	85	CD
18637	12165	4	-	-	SYM
18637	12165	5	86	86	CD
18637	12165	6	.	.	.
18637	12166	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12166	2	254	254	CD
18637	12166	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12166	4	1	1	CD
18637	12166	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12166	6	.	.	.
18637	12167	1	304	304	CD
18637	12167	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12167	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	12167	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12167	5	.	.	.
18637	12168	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12168	2	255	255	CD
18637	12168	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12168	4	6	6	CD
18637	12168	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12168	6	.	.	.
18637	12169	1	264	264	CD
18637	12169	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12169	3	1821	1821	CD
18637	12169	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12169	5	.	.	.
18637	12170	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12170	2	256	256	CD
18637	12170	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12170	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12170	5	.	.	.
18637	12171	1	379	379	CD
18637	12171	2	.	.	.
18637	12172	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12172	2	257	257	CD
18637	12172	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12172	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12172	5	.	.	.
18637	12173	1	422	422	CD
18637	12173	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12173	3	423	423	CD
18637	12173	4	.	.	.
18637	12174	1	In	in	IN
18637	12174	2	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	12174	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12174	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	12174	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12174	6	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	12174	7	's	's	POS
18637	12174	8	Lessee	Lessee	NNP
18637	12174	9	,	,	,
18637	12174	10	1	1	CD
18637	12174	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12174	12	.	.	.
18637	12175	1	304	304	CD
18637	12175	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12175	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	12175	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12175	5	,	,	,
18637	12175	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12175	7	Story	Story	NNP
18637	12175	8	had	have	VBD
18637	12175	9	traversed	traverse	VBN
18637	12175	10	some	some	DT
18637	12175	11	of	of	IN
18637	12175	12	these	these	DT
18637	12175	13	same	same	JJ
18637	12175	14	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	12175	15	.	.	.
18637	12176	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12176	2	,	,	,
18637	12176	3	too	too	RB
18637	12176	4	,	,	,
18637	12176	5	began	begin	VBD
18637	12176	6	with	with	IN
18637	12176	7	the	the	DT
18637	12176	8	general	general	JJ
18637	12176	9	assumptions	assumption	NNS
18637	12176	10	that	that	WDT
18637	12176	11	the	the	DT
18637	12176	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12176	13	was	be	VBD
18637	12176	14	established	establish	VBN
18637	12176	15	by	by	IN
18637	12176	16	the	the	DT
18637	12176	17	people	people	NNS
18637	12176	18	of	of	IN
18637	12176	19	the	the	DT
18637	12176	20	United	United	NNP
18637	12176	21	States	States	NNP
18637	12176	22	and	and	CC
18637	12176	23	not	not	RB
18637	12176	24	by	by	IN
18637	12176	25	the	the	DT
18637	12176	26	States	state	NNS
18637	12176	27	in	in	IN
18637	12176	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12176	29	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	12176	30	capacities	capacity	NNS
18637	12176	31	,	,	,
18637	12176	32	that	that	IN
18637	12176	33	the	the	DT
18637	12176	34	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12176	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	12176	36	to	to	TO
18637	12176	37	be	be	VB
18637	12176	38	construed	construe	VBN
18637	12176	39	liberally	liberally	RB
18637	12176	40	,	,	,
18637	12176	41	and	and	CC
18637	12176	42	that	that	IN
18637	12176	43	the	the	DT
18637	12176	44	National	National	NNP
18637	12176	45	Government	Government	NNP
18637	12176	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	12176	47	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	12176	48	in	in	IN
18637	12176	49	relation	relation	NN
18637	12176	50	to	to	IN
18637	12176	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12176	52	objects	object	NNS
18637	12176	53	;	;	:
18637	12176	54	and	and	CC
18637	12176	55	had	have	VBD
18637	12176	56	concluded	conclude	VBN
18637	12176	57	that	that	IN
18637	12176	58	the	the	DT
18637	12176	59	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12176	60	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12176	61	had	have	VBD
18637	12176	62	authority	authority	NN
18637	12176	63	to	to	TO
18637	12176	64	review	review	VB
18637	12176	65	State	State	NNP
18637	12176	66	court	court	NN
18637	12176	67	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	12176	68	under	under	IN
18637	12176	69	the	the	DT
18637	12176	70	express	express	JJ
18637	12176	71	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	12176	72	of	of	IN
18637	12176	73	articles	article	NNS
18637	12176	74	III	III	NNP
18637	12176	75	and	and	CC
18637	12176	76	VI	VI	NNP
18637	12176	77	,	,	,
18637	12176	78	and	and	CC
18637	12176	79	also	also	RB
18637	12176	80	from	from	IN
18637	12176	81	the	the	DT
18637	12176	82	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	12176	83	that	that	IN
18637	12176	84	final	final	JJ
18637	12176	85	decision	decision	NN
18637	12176	86	must	must	MD
18637	12176	87	rest	rest	VB
18637	12176	88	somewhere	somewhere	RB
18637	12176	89	and	and	CC
18637	12176	90	from	from	IN
18637	12176	91	the	the	DT
18637	12176	92	importance	importance	NN
18637	12176	93	and	and	CC
18637	12176	94	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	12176	95	of	of	IN
18637	12176	96	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	12176	97	of	of	IN
18637	12176	98	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	12176	99	interpreting	interpret	VBG
18637	12176	100	the	the	DT
18637	12176	101	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12176	102	.	.	.
18637	12177	1	Many	many	JJ
18637	12177	2	years	year	NNS
18637	12177	3	later	later	RB
18637	12177	4	in	in	IN
18637	12177	5	Ableman	Ableman	NNP
18637	12177	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12177	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12177	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12177	9	Booth	Booth	NNP
18637	12177	10	,	,	,
18637	12177	11	21	21	CD
18637	12177	12	How	how	WRB
18637	12177	13	.	.	.
18637	12178	1	506	506	CD
18637	12178	2	,	,	,
18637	12178	3	514	514	CD
18637	12178	4	-	-	SYM
18637	12178	5	523	523	CD
18637	12178	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12178	7	1859	1859	CD
18637	12178	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12178	9	,	,	,
18637	12178	10	where	where	WRB
18637	12178	11	the	the	DT
18637	12178	12	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	12178	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12178	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12178	15	,	,	,
18637	12178	16	like	like	IN
18637	12178	17	the	the	DT
18637	12178	18	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	12178	19	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	12178	20	earlier	early	RBR
18637	12178	21	,	,	,
18637	12178	22	had	have	VBD
18637	12178	23	declared	declare	VBN
18637	12178	24	an	an	DT
18637	12178	25	act	act	NN
18637	12178	26	of	of	IN
18637	12178	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12178	28	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	12178	29	and	and	CC
18637	12178	30	disregarded	disregard	VBD
18637	12178	31	a	a	DT
18637	12178	32	writ	writ	NN
18637	12178	33	of	of	IN
18637	12178	34	error	error	NN
18637	12178	35	from	from	IN
18637	12178	36	the	the	DT
18637	12178	37	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12178	38	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12178	39	,	,	,
18637	12178	40	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	12178	41	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12178	42	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	12178	43	on	on	IN
18637	12178	44	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	12178	45	both	both	DT
18637	12178	46	of	of	IN
18637	12178	47	dual	dual	JJ
18637	12178	48	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	12178	49	and	and	CC
18637	12178	50	national	national	JJ
18637	12178	51	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	12178	52	was	be	VBD
18637	12178	53	even	even	RB
18637	12178	54	more	more	RBR
18637	12178	55	emphatic	emphatic	JJ
18637	12178	56	in	in	IN
18637	12178	57	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12178	58	rebuke	rebuke	NN
18637	12178	59	of	of	IN
18637	12178	60	State	state	NN
18637	12178	61	pretensions	pretension	NNS
18637	12178	62	.	.	.
18637	12179	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12179	2	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	12179	3	on	on	IN
18637	12179	4	the	the	DT
18637	12179	5	indispensability	indispensability	NN
18637	12179	6	of	of	IN
18637	12179	7	the	the	DT
18637	12179	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12179	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12179	10	power	power	NN
18637	12179	11	to	to	TO
18637	12179	12	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	12179	13	national	national	JJ
18637	12179	14	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	12179	15	,	,	,
18637	12179	16	to	to	TO
18637	12179	17	protect	protect	VB
18637	12179	18	the	the	DT
18637	12179	19	States	States	NNPS
18637	12179	20	from	from	IN
18637	12179	21	national	national	JJ
18637	12179	22	encroachments	encroachment	NNS
18637	12179	23	,	,	,
18637	12179	24	and	and	CC
18637	12179	25	to	to	TO
18637	12179	26	make	make	VB
18637	12179	27	the	the	DT
18637	12179	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12179	29	and	and	CC
18637	12179	30	laws	law	NNS
18637	12179	31	of	of	IN
18637	12179	32	the	the	DT
18637	12179	33	United	United	NNP
18637	12179	34	States	States	NNP
18637	12179	35	uniform	uniform	VBP
18637	12179	36	all	all	DT
18637	12179	37	combine	combine	VBP
18637	12179	38	to	to	TO
18637	12179	39	enhance	enhance	VB
18637	12179	40	the	the	DT
18637	12179	41	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12179	42	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12179	43	power	power	NN
18637	12179	44	to	to	IN
18637	12179	45	a	a	DT
18637	12179	46	degree	degree	NN
18637	12179	47	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	12179	48	that	that	DT
18637	12179	49	envisaged	envisage	VBD
18637	12179	50	even	even	RB
18637	12179	51	by	by	IN
18637	12179	52	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	12179	53	and	and	CC
18637	12179	54	Story	Story	NNP
18637	12179	55	.	.	.
18637	12180	1	As	as	RB
18637	12180	2	late	late	RB
18637	12180	3	as	as	IN
18637	12180	4	1880	1880	CD
18637	12180	5	the	the	DT
18637	12180	6	questions	question	NNS
18637	12180	7	presented	present	VBN
18637	12180	8	in	in	IN
18637	12180	9	the	the	DT
18637	12180	10	foregoing	foregoing	JJ
18637	12180	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	12180	12	were	be	VBD
18637	12180	13	before	before	IN
18637	12180	14	the	the	DT
18637	12180	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12180	16	in	in	IN
18637	12180	17	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	12180	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12180	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	12180	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12180	21	Bruffy	Bruffy	NNP
18637	12180	22	,	,	,
18637	12180	23	102	102	CD
18637	12180	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12180	25	248	248	CD
18637	12180	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12180	27	1880	1880	CD
18637	12180	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12180	29	,	,	,
18637	12180	30	which	which	WDT
18637	12180	31	again	again	RB
18637	12180	32	involved	involve	VBD
18637	12180	33	the	the	DT
18637	12180	34	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	12180	35	of	of	IN
18637	12180	36	a	a	DT
18637	12180	37	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	12180	38	court	court	NN
18637	12180	39	to	to	TO
18637	12180	40	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	12180	41	a	a	DT
18637	12180	42	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	12180	43	of	of	IN
18637	12180	44	the	the	DT
18637	12180	45	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12180	46	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12180	47	.	.	.
18637	12181	1	By	by	IN
18637	12181	2	the	the	DT
18637	12181	3	act	act	NN
18637	12181	4	of	of	IN
18637	12181	5	December	December	NNP
18637	12181	6	23	23	CD
18637	12181	7	,	,	,
18637	12181	8	1914	1914	CD
18637	12181	9	,	,	,
18637	12181	10	38	38	CD
18637	12181	11	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	12181	12	.	.	.
18637	12182	1	790	790	CD
18637	12182	2	,	,	,
18637	12182	3	the	the	DT
18637	12182	4	25th	25th	JJ
18637	12182	5	section	section	NN
18637	12182	6	of	of	IN
18637	12182	7	the	the	DT
18637	12182	8	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	12182	9	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12182	10	of	of	IN
18637	12182	11	1789	1789	CD
18637	12182	12	which	which	WDT
18637	12182	13	was	be	VBD
18637	12182	14	carried	carry	VBN
18637	12182	15	over	over	RP
18637	12182	16	with	with	IN
18637	12182	17	modifications	modification	NNS
18637	12182	18	into	into	IN
18637	12182	19	the	the	DT
18637	12182	20	Revised	Revised	NNP
18637	12182	21	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	12182	22	,	,	,
18637	12182	23	§	§	NNP
18637	12182	24	690	690	CD
18637	12182	25	;	;	:
18637	12182	26	28	28	CD
18637	12182	27	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	12183	1	§	§	NNP
18637	12183	2	344	344	CD
18637	12183	3	was	be	VBD
18637	12183	4	amended	amend	VBN
18637	12183	5	so	so	IN
18637	12183	6	as	as	IN
18637	12183	7	to	to	TO
18637	12183	8	provide	provide	VB
18637	12183	9	for	for	IN
18637	12183	10	review	review	NN
18637	12183	11	of	of	IN
18637	12183	12	State	State	NNP
18637	12183	13	court	court	NN
18637	12183	14	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	12183	15	on	on	IN
18637	12183	16	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	12183	17	whether	whether	IN
18637	12183	18	the	the	DT
18637	12183	19	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12183	20	claim	claim	NN
18637	12183	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	12183	22	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	12183	23	or	or	CC
18637	12183	24	denied	deny	VBN
18637	12183	25	.	.	.
18637	12184	1	These	these	DT
18637	12184	2	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	12184	3	are	be	VBP
18637	12184	4	now	now	RB
18637	12184	5	contained	contain	VBN
18637	12184	6	in	in	IN
18637	12184	7	28	28	CD
18637	12184	8	U.S.C.A.	U.S.C.A.	NNP
18637	12185	1	1257	1257	CD
18637	12185	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12185	3	1948	1948	CD
18637	12185	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12185	5	.	.	.
18637	12186	1	The	the	DT
18637	12186	2	first	first	JJ
18637	12186	3	case	case	NN
18637	12186	4	involving	involve	VBG
18637	12186	5	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	12186	6	State	State	NNP
18637	12186	7	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	12186	8	arose	arise	VBD
18637	12186	9	under	under	IN
18637	12186	10	a	a	DT
18637	12186	11	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	12186	12	of	of	IN
18637	12186	13	the	the	DT
18637	12186	14	United	United	NNP
18637	12186	15	States	States	NNP
18637	12186	16	.	.	.
18637	12187	1	Ware	Ware	NNP
18637	12187	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12187	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12187	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12187	5	Hylton	Hylton	NNP
18637	12187	6	,	,	,
18637	12187	7	3	3	CD
18637	12187	8	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12187	9	.	.	.
18637	12188	1	199	199	CD
18637	12188	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12188	3	1797	1797	CD
18637	12188	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12188	5	.	.	.
18637	12189	1	In	in	IN
18637	12189	2	Calder	Calder	NNP
18637	12189	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12189	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	12189	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12189	6	Bull	Bull	NNP
18637	12189	7	,	,	,
18637	12189	8	3	3	CD
18637	12189	9	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12189	10	.	.	.
18637	12190	1	386	386	CD
18637	12190	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12190	3	1798	1798	CD
18637	12190	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12190	5	,	,	,
18637	12190	6	the	the	DT
18637	12190	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12190	8	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	12190	9	a	a	DT
18637	12190	10	State	State	NNP
18637	12190	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	12190	12	as	as	IN
18637	12190	13	not	not	RB
18637	12190	14	being	be	VBG
18637	12190	15	an	an	DT
18637	12190	16	_	_	NNP
18637	12190	17	ex	ex	FW
18637	12190	18	post	post	FW
18637	12190	19	facto	facto	FW
18637	12190	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12190	21	law	law	NN
18637	12190	22	.	.	.
18637	12191	1	The	the	DT
18637	12191	2	first	first	JJ
18637	12191	3	case	case	NN
18637	12191	4	in	in	IN
18637	12191	5	which	which	WDT
18637	12191	6	a	a	DT
18637	12191	7	State	State	NNP
18637	12191	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	12191	9	was	be	VBD
18637	12191	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	12191	11	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	12191	12	as	as	IN
18637	12191	13	a	a	DT
18637	12191	14	violation	violation	NN
18637	12191	15	of	of	IN
18637	12191	16	the	the	DT
18637	12191	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12191	18	was	be	VBD
18637	12191	19	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	12191	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12191	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	12191	22	_	_	NNP
18637	12191	23	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	12191	24	,	,	,
18637	12191	25	6	6	CD
18637	12191	26	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12191	27	.	.	.
18637	12192	1	87	87	CD
18637	12192	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12192	3	1810	1810	CD
18637	12192	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12192	5	,	,	,
18637	12192	6	which	which	WDT
18637	12192	7	came	come	VBD
18637	12192	8	to	to	IN
18637	12192	9	the	the	DT
18637	12192	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12192	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12192	12	by	by	IN
18637	12192	13	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	12192	14	from	from	IN
18637	12192	15	a	a	DT
18637	12192	16	United	United	NNP
18637	12192	17	States	States	NNP
18637	12192	18	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	12192	19	court	court	NN
18637	12192	20	and	and	CC
18637	12192	21	not	not	RB
18637	12192	22	by	by	IN
18637	12192	23	a	a	DT
18637	12192	24	writ	writ	NN
18637	12192	25	of	of	IN
18637	12192	26	error	error	NN
18637	12192	27	under	under	IN
18637	12192	28	section	section	NN
18637	12192	29	25	25	CD
18637	12192	30	.	.	.
18637	12193	1	Famous	famous	JJ
18637	12193	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	12193	3	coming	come	VBG
18637	12193	4	to	to	IN
18637	12193	5	the	the	DT
18637	12193	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12193	7	under	under	IN
18637	12193	8	section	section	NN
18637	12193	9	25	25	CD
18637	12193	10	were	be	VBD
18637	12193	11	Sturges	Sturges	NNP
18637	12193	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12193	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	12193	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12193	15	Crowninshield	Crowninshield	NNP
18637	12193	16	,	,	,
18637	12193	17	4	4	CD
18637	12193	18	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12193	19	.	.	.
18637	12194	1	122	122	CD
18637	12194	2	,	,	,
18637	12194	3	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	12194	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12194	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	12194	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12194	7	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	12194	8	,	,	,
18637	12194	9	4	4	CD
18637	12194	10	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12194	11	.	.	.
18637	12195	1	316	316	CD
18637	12195	2	,	,	,
18637	12195	3	and	and	CC
18637	12195	4	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	12195	5	College	College	NNP
18637	12195	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12195	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12195	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12195	9	Woodward	Woodward	NNP
18637	12195	10	,	,	,
18637	12195	11	4	4	CD
18637	12195	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12195	13	.	.	.
18637	12196	1	518	518	CD
18637	12196	2	.	.	.
18637	12197	1	All	all	DT
18637	12197	2	three	three	CD
18637	12197	3	were	be	VBD
18637	12197	4	decided	decide	VBN
18637	12197	5	in	in	IN
18637	12197	6	1819	1819	CD
18637	12197	7	and	and	CC
18637	12197	8	the	the	DT
18637	12197	9	State	State	NNP
18637	12197	10	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	12197	11	involved	involve	VBN
18637	12197	12	in	in	IN
18637	12197	13	each	each	DT
18637	12197	14	was	be	VBD
18637	12197	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	12197	16	void	void	JJ
18637	12197	17	.	.	.
18637	12198	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12198	2	258	258	CD
18637	12198	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12198	4	That	that	IN
18637	12198	5	the	the	DT
18637	12198	6	great	great	JJ
18637	12198	7	majority	majority	NN
18637	12198	8	of	of	IN
18637	12198	9	the	the	DT
18637	12198	10	most	most	RBS
18637	12198	11	influential	influential	JJ
18637	12198	12	members	member	NNS
18637	12198	13	of	of	IN
18637	12198	14	the	the	DT
18637	12198	15	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	12198	16	of	of	IN
18637	12198	17	1787	1787	CD
18637	12198	18	thought	think	VBD
18637	12198	19	the	the	DT
18637	12198	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12198	21	secured	secure	VBD
18637	12198	22	to	to	IN
18637	12198	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	12198	24	in	in	IN
18637	12198	25	the	the	DT
18637	12198	26	United	United	NNP
18637	12198	27	States	States	NNP
18637	12198	28	the	the	DT
18637	12198	29	right	right	NN
18637	12198	30	to	to	TO
18637	12198	31	pass	pass	VB
18637	12198	32	on	on	RP
18637	12198	33	the	the	DT
18637	12198	34	validity	validity	NN
18637	12198	35	of	of	IN
18637	12198	36	acts	act	NNS
18637	12198	37	of	of	IN
18637	12198	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12198	39	under	under	IN
18637	12198	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12198	41	can	can	MD
18637	12198	42	not	not	RB
18637	12198	43	be	be	VB
18637	12198	44	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	12198	45	doubted	doubt	VBN
18637	12198	46	.	.	.
18637	12199	1	Confining	confine	VBG
18637	12199	2	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12199	3	simply	simply	RB
18637	12199	4	to	to	IN
18637	12199	5	the	the	DT
18637	12199	6	available	available	JJ
18637	12199	7	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	12199	8	that	that	WDT
18637	12199	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	12199	10	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	12199	11	contemporaneous	contemporaneous	JJ
18637	12199	12	with	with	IN
18637	12199	13	the	the	DT
18637	12199	14	framing	framing	NN
18637	12199	15	and	and	CC
18637	12199	16	ratifying	ratifying	NN
18637	12199	17	of	of	IN
18637	12199	18	the	the	DT
18637	12199	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12199	20	,	,	,
18637	12199	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12199	22	find	find	VBP
18637	12199	23	the	the	DT
18637	12199	24	following	follow	VBG
18637	12199	25	members	member	NNS
18637	12199	26	of	of	IN
18637	12199	27	the	the	DT
18637	12199	28	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	12199	29	that	that	WDT
18637	12199	30	framed	frame	VBD
18637	12199	31	the	the	DT
18637	12199	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12199	33	definitely	definitely	RB
18637	12199	34	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	12199	35	that	that	IN
18637	12199	36	this	this	DT
18637	12199	37	would	would	MD
18637	12199	38	be	be	VB
18637	12199	39	the	the	DT
18637	12199	40	case	case	NN
18637	12199	41	:	:	:
18637	12199	42	Gerry	Gerry	NNP
18637	12199	43	and	and	CC
18637	12199	44	King	King	NNP
18637	12199	45	of	of	IN
18637	12199	46	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	12199	47	,	,	,
18637	12199	48	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	12199	49	and	and	CC
18637	12199	50	Gouverneur	Gouverneur	NNP
18637	12199	51	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	12199	52	of	of	IN
18637	12199	53	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	12199	54	,	,	,
18637	12199	55	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	12199	56	of	of	IN
18637	12199	57	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	12199	58	,	,	,
18637	12199	59	Randolph	Randolph	NNP
18637	12199	60	,	,	,
18637	12199	61	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	12199	62	,	,	,
18637	12199	63	and	and	CC
18637	12199	64	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	12199	65	of	of	IN
18637	12199	66	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	12199	67	,	,	,
18637	12199	68	Dickinson	Dickinson	NNP
18637	12199	69	of	of	IN
18637	12199	70	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	12199	71	,	,	,
18637	12199	72	Yates	Yates	NNP
18637	12199	73	and	and	CC
18637	12199	74	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	12199	75	of	of	IN
18637	12199	76	New	New	NNP
18637	12199	77	York	York	NNP
18637	12199	78	,	,	,
18637	12199	79	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	12199	80	and	and	CC
18637	12199	81	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	12199	82	Pinckney	Pinckney	NNP
18637	12199	83	of	of	IN
18637	12199	84	South	South	NNP
18637	12199	85	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	12199	86	,	,	,
18637	12199	87	Davie	Davie	NNP
18637	12199	88	and	and	CC
18637	12199	89	Williamson	Williamson	NNP
18637	12199	90	of	of	IN
18637	12199	91	North	North	NNP
18637	12199	92	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	12199	93	,	,	,
18637	12199	94	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	12199	95	and	and	CC
18637	12199	96	Ellsworth	Ellsworth	NNP
18637	12199	97	of	of	IN
18637	12199	98	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	12199	99	.	.	.
18637	12200	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12200	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12200	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12200	4	Max	Max	NNP
18637	12200	5	Farrand	Farrand	NNP
18637	12200	6	,	,	,
18637	12200	7	Records	Records	NNPS
18637	12200	8	of	of	IN
18637	12200	9	the	the	DT
18637	12200	10	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	12200	11	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	12200	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12200	13	Yale	Yale	NNP
18637	12200	14	Univ	Univ	NNP
18637	12200	15	.	.	.
18637	12201	1	Press	Press	NNP
18637	12201	2	,	,	,
18637	12201	3	1913	1913	CD
18637	12201	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12201	5	;	;	:
18637	12201	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12201	7	,	,	,
18637	12201	8	97	97	CD
18637	12201	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12201	10	Gerry	Gerry	NNP
18637	12201	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12201	12	,	,	,
18637	12201	13	109	109	CD
18637	12201	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12201	15	King	King	NNP
18637	12201	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12201	17	;	;	:
18637	12201	18	II	II	NNP
18637	12201	19	,	,	,
18637	12201	20	73	73	CD
18637	12201	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12201	22	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	12201	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12201	24	,	,	,
18637	12201	25	76	76	CD
18637	12201	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12201	27	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	12201	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12201	29	,	,	,
18637	12201	30	78	78	CD
18637	12201	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12201	32	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	12201	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12201	34	,	,	,
18637	12201	35	299	299	CD
18637	12201	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12201	37	Dickinson	Dickinson	NNP
18637	12201	38	and	and	CC
18637	12201	39	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	12201	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12201	41	,	,	,
18637	12201	42	428	428	CD
18637	12201	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12201	44	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	12201	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12201	46	,	,	,
18637	12201	47	248	248	CD
18637	12201	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12201	49	Pinckney	Pinckney	NNP
18637	12201	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12201	51	,	,	,
18637	12201	52	376	376	CD
18637	12201	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12201	54	Williamson	Williamson	NNP
18637	12201	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12201	56	,	,	,
18637	12201	57	28	28	CD
18637	12201	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12201	59	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	12201	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12201	61	,	,	,
18637	12201	62	93	93	CD
18637	12201	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12201	64	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	12201	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12201	66	;	;	:
18637	12201	67	III	iii	CD
18637	12201	68	,	,	,
18637	12201	69	220	220	CD
18637	12201	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12201	71	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	12201	72	,	,	,
18637	12201	73	in	in	IN
18637	12201	74	"	"	``
18637	12201	75	Genuine	Genuine	NNP
18637	12201	76	Information	information	NN
18637	12201	77	"	"	''
18637	12201	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12201	79	.	.	.
18637	12202	1	The	the	DT
18637	12202	2	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	12202	3	:	:	:
18637	12202	4	Nos	Nos	NNP
18637	12202	5	.	.	.
18637	12203	1	39	39	CD
18637	12203	2	and	and	CC
18637	12203	3	44	44	CD
18637	12203	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12203	5	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	12203	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12203	7	,	,	,
18637	12203	8	Nos	Nos	NNP
18637	12203	9	.	.	.
18637	12204	1	78	78	CD
18637	12204	2	and	and	CC
18637	12204	3	81	81	CD
18637	12204	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12204	5	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	12204	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12204	7	.	.	.
18637	12205	1	Elliot	Elliot	NNP
18637	12205	2	's	's	POS
18637	12205	3	Debates	debate	NNS
18637	12205	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12205	5	ed	ed	NN
18637	12205	6	.	.	.
18637	12206	1	of	of	IN
18637	12206	2	1836	1836	CD
18637	12206	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12206	4	,	,	,
18637	12206	5	II	II	NNP
18637	12206	6	,	,	,
18637	12206	7	1898	1898	CD
18637	12206	8	-	-	SYM
18637	12206	9	1899	1899	CD
18637	12206	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12206	11	Ellsworth	Ellsworth	NNP
18637	12206	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12206	13	,	,	,
18637	12206	14	417	417	CD
18637	12206	15	and	and	CC
18637	12206	16	454	454	CD
18637	12206	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12206	18	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	12206	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12206	20	,	,	,
18637	12206	21	336	336	CD
18637	12206	22	-	-	SYM
18637	12206	23	337	337	CD
18637	12206	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12206	25	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	12206	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12206	27	;	;	:
18637	12206	28	III	III	NNP
18637	12206	29	,	,	,
18637	12206	30	197	197	CD
18637	12206	31	,	,	,
18637	12206	32	208	208	CD
18637	12206	33	,	,	,
18637	12206	34	431	431	CD
18637	12206	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12206	36	Randolph	Randolph	NNP
18637	12206	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12206	38	,	,	,
18637	12206	39	441	441	CD
18637	12206	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12206	41	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	12206	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12206	43	,	,	,
18637	12206	44	484	484	CD
18637	12206	45	-	-	SYM
18637	12206	46	485	485	CD
18637	12206	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12206	48	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	12206	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12206	50	;	;	:
18637	12206	51	IV	IV	NNP
18637	12206	52	,	,	,
18637	12206	53	165	165	CD
18637	12206	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12206	55	Davie	Davie	NNP
18637	12206	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12206	57	.	.	.
18637	12207	1	P.L.	P.L.	NNP
18637	12208	1	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	12208	2	,	,	,
18637	12208	3	Pamphlets	Pamphlets	NNPS
18637	12208	4	on	on	IN
18637	12208	5	the	the	DT
18637	12208	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12208	7	,	,	,
18637	12208	8	184	184	CD
18637	12208	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12208	10	Dickinson	Dickinson	NNP
18637	12208	11	,	,	,
18637	12208	12	in	in	IN
18637	12208	13	"	"	``
18637	12208	14	Letters	Letters	NNPS
18637	12208	15	of	of	IN
18637	12208	16	Fabius	Fabius	NNP
18637	12208	17	"	"	''
18637	12208	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12208	19	.	.	.
18637	12209	1	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	12209	2	,	,	,
18637	12209	3	Essays	essay	NNS
18637	12209	4	on	on	IN
18637	12209	5	the	the	DT
18637	12209	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12209	7	,	,	,
18637	12209	8	295	295	CD
18637	12209	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12209	10	Robert	Robert	NNP
18637	12209	11	Yates	Yates	NNP
18637	12209	12	,	,	,
18637	12209	13	writing	write	VBG
18637	12209	14	as	as	IN
18637	12209	15	"	"	``
18637	12209	16	Brutus	Brutus	NNP
18637	12209	17	"	"	''
18637	12209	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12209	19	.	.	.
18637	12210	1	True	true	JJ
18637	12210	2	these	these	DT
18637	12210	3	are	be	VBP
18637	12210	4	only	only	RB
18637	12210	5	seventeen	seventeen	CD
18637	12210	6	names	name	NNS
18637	12210	7	out	out	IN
18637	12210	8	of	of	IN
18637	12210	9	a	a	DT
18637	12210	10	possible	possible	JJ
18637	12210	11	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	12210	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	12210	13	five	five	CD
18637	12210	14	,	,	,
18637	12210	15	but	but	CC
18637	12210	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12210	17	designate	designate	VBP
18637	12210	18	fully	fully	RB
18637	12210	19	three	three	CD
18637	12210	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	12210	21	fourths	fourth	NNS
18637	12210	22	of	of	IN
18637	12210	23	the	the	DT
18637	12210	24	leaders	leader	NNS
18637	12210	25	of	of	IN
18637	12210	26	the	the	DT
18637	12210	27	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	12210	28	,	,	,
18637	12210	29	four	four	CD
18637	12210	30	of	of	IN
18637	12210	31	the	the	DT
18637	12210	32	five	five	CD
18637	12210	33	members	member	NNS
18637	12210	34	of	of	IN
18637	12210	35	the	the	DT
18637	12210	36	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	12210	37	of	of	IN
18637	12210	38	Detail	Detail	NNP
18637	12210	39	which	which	WDT
18637	12210	40	drafted	draft	VBD
18637	12210	41	the	the	DT
18637	12210	42	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12210	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12210	44	Gorham	Gorham	NNP
18637	12210	45	,	,	,
18637	12210	46	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	12210	47	,	,	,
18637	12210	48	Randolph	Randolph	NNP
18637	12210	49	,	,	,
18637	12210	50	Ellsworth	Ellsworth	NNP
18637	12210	51	,	,	,
18637	12210	52	and	and	CC
18637	12210	53	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	12210	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12210	55	and	and	CC
18637	12210	56	four	four	CD
18637	12210	57	of	of	IN
18637	12210	58	the	the	DT
18637	12210	59	five	five	CD
18637	12210	60	members	member	NNS
18637	12210	61	of	of	IN
18637	12210	62	the	the	DT
18637	12210	63	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	12210	64	of	of	IN
18637	12210	65	Style	Style	NNP
18637	12210	66	which	which	WDT
18637	12210	67	gave	give	VBD
18637	12210	68	the	the	DT
18637	12210	69	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12210	70	final	final	JJ
18637	12210	71	form	form	NN
18637	12210	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12210	73	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	12210	74	,	,	,
18637	12210	75	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	12210	76	,	,	,
18637	12210	77	Gouverneur	Gouverneur	NNP
18637	12210	78	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	12210	79	,	,	,
18637	12210	80	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	12210	81	,	,	,
18637	12210	82	and	and	CC
18637	12210	83	King	King	NNP
18637	12210	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12210	85	.	.	.
18637	12211	1	Against	against	IN
18637	12211	2	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12211	3	are	be	VBP
18637	12211	4	to	to	TO
18637	12211	5	be	be	VB
18637	12211	6	pitted	pit	VBN
18637	12211	7	,	,	,
18637	12211	8	in	in	IN
18637	12211	9	reference	reference	NN
18637	12211	10	to	to	IN
18637	12211	11	the	the	DT
18637	12211	12	question	question	NN
18637	12211	13	under	under	IN
18637	12211	14	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	12211	15	,	,	,
18637	12211	16	only	only	RB
18637	12211	17	Mercer	Mercer	NNP
18637	12211	18	of	of	IN
18637	12211	19	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	12211	20	,	,	,
18637	12211	21	Bedford	Bedford	NNP
18637	12211	22	of	of	IN
18637	12211	23	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	12211	24	,	,	,
18637	12211	25	and	and	CC
18637	12211	26	Spaight	Spaight	NNP
18637	12211	27	of	of	IN
18637	12211	28	North	North	NNP
18637	12211	29	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	12211	30	,	,	,
18637	12211	31	the	the	DT
18637	12211	32	record	record	NN
18637	12211	33	in	in	IN
18637	12211	34	each	each	DT
18637	12211	35	of	of	IN
18637	12211	36	whose	whose	WP$
18637	12211	37	cases	case	NNS
18637	12211	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	12211	39	of	of	IN
18637	12211	40	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
18637	12211	41	implication	implication	NN
18637	12211	42	.	.	.
18637	12212	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12212	2	should	should	MD
18637	12212	3	be	be	VB
18637	12212	4	noted	note	VBN
18637	12212	5	,	,	,
18637	12212	6	however	however	RB
18637	12212	7	,	,	,
18637	12212	8	that	that	IN
18637	12212	9	there	there	EX
18637	12212	10	was	be	VBD
18637	12212	11	later	later	RB
18637	12212	12	some	some	DT
18637	12212	13	backsliding	backsliding	NN
18637	12212	14	.	.	.
18637	12213	1	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	12213	2	's	's	POS
18637	12213	3	record	record	NN
18637	12213	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	12213	5	characteristically	characteristically	RB
18637	12213	6	erratic	erratic	JJ
18637	12213	7	.	.	.
18637	12214	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12214	2	statement	statement	NN
18637	12214	3	in	in	IN
18637	12214	4	The	the	DT
18637	12214	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	12214	6	No	no	NN
18637	12214	7	.	.	.
18637	12215	1	39	39	CD
18637	12215	2	written	write	VBN
18637	12215	3	probably	probably	RB
18637	12215	4	early	early	RB
18637	12215	5	in	in	IN
18637	12215	6	1788	1788	CD
18637	12215	7	,	,	,
18637	12215	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	12215	9	very	very	RB
18637	12215	10	positive	positive	JJ
18637	12215	11	:	:	:
18637	12215	12	The	the	DT
18637	12215	13	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	12215	14	which	which	WDT
18637	12215	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	12215	16	to	to	TO
18637	12215	17	ultimately	ultimately	RB
18637	12215	18	decide	decide	VB
18637	12215	19	,	,	,
18637	12215	20	in	in	IN
18637	12215	21	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	12215	22	relating	relate	VBG
18637	12215	23	to	to	IN
18637	12215	24	the	the	DT
18637	12215	25	boundary	boundary	NN
18637	12215	26	between	between	IN
18637	12215	27	the	the	DT
18637	12215	28	two	two	CD
18637	12215	29	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NNS
18637	12215	30	,	,	,
18637	12215	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	12215	32	to	to	TO
18637	12215	33	be	be	VB
18637	12215	34	established	establish	VBN
18637	12215	35	under	under	IN
18637	12215	36	the	the	DT
18637	12215	37	general	general	JJ
18637	12215	38	government	government	NN
18637	12215	39	.	.	.
18637	12216	1	Yet	yet	RB
18637	12216	2	a	a	DT
18637	12216	3	few	few	JJ
18637	12216	4	months	month	NNS
18637	12216	5	later	later	RB
18637	12216	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12216	7	probably	probably	RB
18637	12216	8	October	October	NNP
18637	12216	9	,	,	,
18637	12216	10	1788	1788	CD
18637	12216	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12216	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12216	13	seemed	seem	VBD
18637	12216	14	to	to	TO
18637	12216	15	repudiate	repudiate	VB
18637	12216	16	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12216	17	review	review	NN
18637	12216	18	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	12216	19	,	,	,
18637	12216	20	writing	write	VBG
18637	12216	21	:	:	:
18637	12216	22	"	"	``
18637	12216	23	In	in	IN
18637	12216	24	the	the	DT
18637	12216	25	State	State	NNP
18637	12216	26	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
18637	12216	27	and	and	CC
18637	12216	28	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	12216	29	in	in	IN
18637	12216	30	the	the	DT
18637	12216	31	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	12216	32	one	one	NN
18637	12216	33	also	also	RB
18637	12216	34	,	,	,
18637	12216	35	no	no	DT
18637	12216	36	provision	provision	NN
18637	12216	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	12216	38	made	make	VBN
18637	12216	39	for	for	IN
18637	12216	40	the	the	DT
18637	12216	41	case	case	NN
18637	12216	42	of	of	IN
18637	12216	43	a	a	DT
18637	12216	44	disagreement	disagreement	NN
18637	12216	45	in	in	IN
18637	12216	46	expounding	expound	VBG
18637	12216	47	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12216	48	;	;	:
18637	12216	49	and	and	CC
18637	12216	50	as	as	IN
18637	12216	51	the	the	DT
18637	12216	52	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	12216	53	are	be	VBP
18637	12216	54	generally	generally	RB
18637	12216	55	the	the	DT
18637	12216	56	last	last	JJ
18637	12216	57	in	in	IN
18637	12216	58	making	make	VBG
18637	12216	59	the	the	DT
18637	12216	60	decision	decision	NN
18637	12216	61	,	,	,
18637	12216	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12216	63	results	result	VBZ
18637	12216	64	to	to	IN
18637	12216	65	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12216	66	by	by	IN
18637	12216	67	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	12216	68	or	or	CC
18637	12216	69	not	not	RB
18637	12216	70	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	12216	71	to	to	TO
18637	12216	72	execute	execute	VB
18637	12216	73	a	a	DT
18637	12216	74	law	law	NN
18637	12216	75	,	,	,
18637	12216	76	to	to	TO
18637	12216	77	stamp	stamp	VB
18637	12216	78	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12216	79	with	with	IN
18637	12216	80	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12216	81	final	final	JJ
18637	12216	82	character	character	NN
18637	12216	83	.	.	.
18637	12217	1	This	this	DT
18637	12217	2	makes	make	VBZ
18637	12217	3	the	the	DT
18637	12217	4	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	12217	5	Department	Department	NNP
18637	12217	6	paramount	paramount	NN
18637	12217	7	in	in	IN
18637	12217	8	fact	fact	NN
18637	12217	9	to	to	IN
18637	12217	10	the	the	DT
18637	12217	11	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	12217	12	,	,	,
18637	12217	13	which	which	WDT
18637	12217	14	was	be	VBD
18637	12217	15	never	never	RB
18637	12217	16	intended	intend	VBN
18637	12217	17	and	and	CC
18637	12217	18	can	can	MD
18637	12217	19	never	never	RB
18637	12217	20	be	be	VB
18637	12217	21	proper	proper	JJ
18637	12217	22	.	.	.
18637	12217	23	"	"	''
18637	12218	1	5	5	CD
18637	12218	2	Writings	Writings	NNP
18637	12218	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12218	4	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
18637	12218	5	ed	ed	NNP
18637	12218	6	.	.	.
18637	12219	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12219	2	,	,	,
18637	12219	3	294	294	CD
18637	12219	4	.	.	.
18637	12220	1	Yet	yet	CC
18637	12220	2	in	in	IN
18637	12220	3	June	June	NNP
18637	12220	4	,	,	,
18637	12220	5	1789	1789	CD
18637	12220	6	,	,	,
18637	12220	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12220	8	find	find	VBP
18637	12220	9	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12220	10	arguing	argue	VBG
18637	12220	11	as	as	IN
18637	12220	12	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	12220	13	in	in	IN
18637	12220	14	support	support	NN
18637	12220	15	of	of	IN
18637	12220	16	the	the	DT
18637	12220	17	proposals	proposal	NNS
18637	12220	18	to	to	TO
18637	12220	19	amend	amend	VB
18637	12220	20	the	the	DT
18637	12220	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12220	22	which	which	WDT
18637	12220	23	led	lead	VBD
18637	12220	24	to	to	IN
18637	12220	25	the	the	DT
18637	12220	26	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	12220	27	of	of	IN
18637	12220	28	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	12220	29	:	:	:
18637	12220	30	"	"	``
18637	12220	31	If	if	IN
18637	12220	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12220	33	are	be	VBP
18637	12220	34	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	12220	35	into	into	IN
18637	12220	36	the	the	DT
18637	12220	37	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12220	38	,	,	,
18637	12220	39	independent	independent	JJ
18637	12220	40	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	12220	41	of	of	IN
18637	12220	42	justice	justice	NN
18637	12220	43	will	will	MD
18637	12220	44	consider	consider	VB
18637	12220	45	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12220	46	in	in	IN
18637	12220	47	a	a	DT
18637	12220	48	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	12220	49	manner	manner	NN
18637	12220	50	the	the	DT
18637	12220	51	guardians	guardian	NNS
18637	12220	52	of	of	IN
18637	12220	53	those	those	DT
18637	12220	54	rights	right	NNS
18637	12220	55	;	;	:
18637	12220	56	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12220	57	will	will	MD
18637	12220	58	be	be	VB
18637	12220	59	an	an	DT
18637	12220	60	impenetrable	impenetrable	JJ
18637	12220	61	bulwark	bulwark	NN
18637	12220	62	against	against	IN
18637	12220	63	every	every	DT
18637	12220	64	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	12220	65	of	of	IN
18637	12220	66	power	power	NN
18637	12220	67	in	in	IN
18637	12220	68	the	the	DT
18637	12220	69	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	12220	70	or	or	CC
18637	12220	71	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	12220	72	;	;	:
18637	12220	73	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12220	74	will	will	MD
18637	12220	75	be	be	VB
18637	12220	76	naturally	naturally	RB
18637	12220	77	led	lead	VBN
18637	12220	78	to	to	TO
18637	12220	79	resist	resist	VB
18637	12220	80	every	every	DT
18637	12220	81	encroachment	encroachment	NN
18637	12220	82	upon	upon	IN
18637	12220	83	rights	right	NNS
18637	12220	84	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	12220	85	stipulated	stipulate	VBN
18637	12220	86	for	for	IN
18637	12220	87	in	in	IN
18637	12220	88	the	the	DT
18637	12220	89	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12220	90	by	by	IN
18637	12220	91	the	the	DT
18637	12220	92	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	12220	93	of	of	IN
18637	12220	94	rights	right	NNS
18637	12220	95	.	.	.
18637	12220	96	"	"	''
18637	12221	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	12221	2	.	.	.
18637	12222	1	385	385	CD
18637	12222	2	.	.	.
18637	12223	1	Nine	nine	CD
18637	12223	2	years	year	NNS
18637	12223	3	later	later	RB
18637	12223	4	as	as	IN
18637	12223	5	author	author	NN
18637	12223	6	of	of	IN
18637	12223	7	the	the	DT
18637	12223	8	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	12223	9	Resolutions	Resolutions	NNPS
18637	12223	10	of	of	IN
18637	12223	11	1798	1798	CD
18637	12223	12	,	,	,
18637	12223	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12223	14	committed	commit	VBD
18637	12223	15	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12223	16	to	to	IN
18637	12223	17	the	the	DT
18637	12223	18	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	12223	19	that	that	IN
18637	12223	20	the	the	DT
18637	12223	21	final	final	JJ
18637	12223	22	power	power	NN
18637	12223	23	in	in	IN
18637	12223	24	construing	construe	VBG
18637	12223	25	the	the	DT
18637	12223	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12223	27	rested	rest	VBD
18637	12223	28	with	with	IN
18637	12223	29	the	the	DT
18637	12223	30	respective	respective	JJ
18637	12223	31	State	State	NNP
18637	12223	32	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	12223	33	,	,	,
18637	12223	34	a	a	DT
18637	12223	35	position	position	NN
18637	12223	36	from	from	IN
18637	12223	37	the	the	DT
18637	12223	38	logical	logical	JJ
18637	12223	39	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	12223	40	of	of	IN
18637	12223	41	which	which	WDT
18637	12223	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12223	43	spent	spend	VBD
18637	12223	44	no	no	DT
18637	12223	45	little	little	JJ
18637	12223	46	effort	effort	NN
18637	12223	47	to	to	TO
18637	12223	48	disengage	disengage	VB
18637	12223	49	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12223	50	in	in	IN
18637	12223	51	the	the	DT
18637	12223	52	years	year	NNS
18637	12223	53	of	of	IN
18637	12223	54	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12223	55	retirement	retirement	NN
18637	12223	56	.	.	.
18637	12224	1	Another	another	DT
18637	12224	2	recidivist	recidivist	NN
18637	12224	3	was	be	VBD
18637	12224	4	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	12224	5	Pinckney	Pinckney	NNP
18637	12224	6	,	,	,
18637	12224	7	who	who	WP
18637	12224	8	in	in	IN
18637	12224	9	1799	1799	CD
18637	12224	10	denounced	denounce	VBD
18637	12224	11	the	the	DT
18637	12224	12	idea	idea	NN
18637	12224	13	of	of	IN
18637	12224	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12224	15	review	review	NN
18637	12224	16	as	as	IN
18637	12224	17	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	12224	18	:	:	:
18637	12224	19	"	"	``
18637	12224	20	On	on	IN
18637	12224	21	no	no	DT
18637	12224	22	subject	subject	NN
18637	12224	23	am	be	VBP
18637	12224	24	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12224	25	more	more	RBR
18637	12224	26	convinced	convinced	JJ
18637	12224	27	,	,	,
18637	12224	28	than	than	IN
18637	12224	29	that	that	IN
18637	12224	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12224	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	12224	32	an	an	DT
18637	12224	33	unsafe	unsafe	JJ
18637	12224	34	and	and	CC
18637	12224	35	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	12224	36	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	12224	37	in	in	IN
18637	12224	38	a	a	DT
18637	12224	39	republic	republic	NN
18637	12224	40	,	,	,
18637	12224	41	ever	ever	RB
18637	12224	42	to	to	TO
18637	12224	43	suppose	suppose	VB
18637	12224	44	that	that	IN
18637	12224	45	a	a	DT
18637	12224	46	judge	judge	NN
18637	12224	47	ought	ought	MD
18637	12224	48	to	to	TO
18637	12224	49	possess	possess	VB
18637	12224	50	the	the	DT
18637	12224	51	right	right	NN
18637	12224	52	of	of	IN
18637	12224	53	questioning	question	VBG
18637	12224	54	or	or	CC
18637	12224	55	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	12224	56	upon	upon	IN
18637	12224	57	the	the	DT
18637	12224	58	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	12224	59	of	of	IN
18637	12224	60	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	12224	61	,	,	,
18637	12224	62	laws	law	NNS
18637	12224	63	,	,	,
18637	12224	64	or	or	CC
18637	12224	65	any	any	DT
18637	12224	66	act	act	NN
18637	12224	67	of	of	IN
18637	12224	68	the	the	DT
18637	12224	69	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	12224	70	.	.	.
18637	12225	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12225	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	12225	3	placing	place	VBG
18637	12225	4	the	the	DT
18637	12225	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	12225	6	of	of	IN
18637	12225	7	an	an	DT
18637	12225	8	individual	individual	NN
18637	12225	9	,	,	,
18637	12225	10	or	or	CC
18637	12225	11	of	of	IN
18637	12225	12	two	two	CD
18637	12225	13	or	or	CC
18637	12225	14	three	three	CD
18637	12225	15	,	,	,
18637	12225	16	above	above	IN
18637	12225	17	that	that	DT
18637	12225	18	of	of	IN
18637	12225	19	both	both	DT
18637	12225	20	branches	branch	NNS
18637	12225	21	of	of	IN
18637	12225	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12225	23	,	,	,
18637	12225	24	a	a	DT
18637	12225	25	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	12225	26	which	which	WDT
18637	12225	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	12225	28	not	not	RB
18637	12225	29	warranted	warrant	VBN
18637	12225	30	by	by	IN
18637	12225	31	the	the	DT
18637	12225	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12225	33	,	,	,
18637	12225	34	and	and	CC
18637	12225	35	will	will	MD
18637	12225	36	not	not	RB
18637	12225	37	,	,	,
18637	12225	38	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12225	39	hope	hope	VBP
18637	12225	40	,	,	,
18637	12225	41	long	long	RB
18637	12225	42	have	have	VBP
18637	12225	43	many	many	JJ
18637	12225	44	advocates	advocate	NNS
18637	12225	45	in	in	IN
18637	12225	46	this	this	DT
18637	12225	47	country	country	NN
18637	12225	48	.	.	.
18637	12225	49	"	"	''
18637	12226	1	Wharton	Wharton	NNP
18637	12226	2	,	,	,
18637	12226	3	State	State	NNP
18637	12226	4	Trials	Trials	NNPS
18637	12226	5	,	,	,
18637	12226	6	412	412	CD
18637	12226	7	.	.	.
18637	12227	1	The	the	DT
18637	12227	2	great	great	JJ
18637	12227	3	debate	debate	NN
18637	12227	4	in	in	IN
18637	12227	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12227	6	in	in	IN
18637	12227	7	the	the	DT
18637	12227	8	first	first	JJ
18637	12227	9	session	session	NN
18637	12227	10	of	of	IN
18637	12227	11	the	the	DT
18637	12227	12	7th	7th	JJ
18637	12227	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12227	14	over	over	IN
18637	12227	15	the	the	DT
18637	12227	16	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	12227	17	of	of	IN
18637	12227	18	the	the	DT
18637	12227	19	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	12227	20	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12227	21	of	of	IN
18637	12227	22	1801	1801	CD
18637	12227	23	speedily	speedily	RB
18637	12227	24	developed	develop	VBD
18637	12227	25	into	into	IN
18637	12227	26	a	a	DT
18637	12227	27	debate	debate	NN
18637	12227	28	over	over	IN
18637	12227	29	whether	whether	IN
18637	12227	30	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12227	31	review	review	NN
18637	12227	32	of	of	IN
18637	12227	33	acts	act	NNS
18637	12227	34	of	of	IN
18637	12227	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12227	36	was	be	VBD
18637	12227	37	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
18637	12227	38	by	by	IN
18637	12227	39	the	the	DT
18637	12227	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12227	41	.	.	.
18637	12228	1	In	in	IN
18637	12228	2	the	the	DT
18637	12228	3	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	12228	4	Breckenridge	Breckenridge	NNP
18637	12228	5	of	of	IN
18637	12228	6	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	12228	7	,	,	,
18637	12228	8	author	author	NN
18637	12228	9	of	of	IN
18637	12228	10	the	the	DT
18637	12228	11	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	12228	12	Resolutions	Resolutions	NNPS
18637	12228	13	of	of	IN
18637	12228	14	1799	1799	CD
18637	12228	15	,	,	,
18637	12228	16	contended	contend	VBD
18637	12228	17	for	for	IN
18637	12228	18	the	the	DT
18637	12228	19	equal	equal	JJ
18637	12228	20	right	right	NN
18637	12228	21	of	of	IN
18637	12228	22	the	the	DT
18637	12228	23	three	three	CD
18637	12228	24	departments	department	NNS
18637	12228	25	to	to	TO
18637	12228	26	construe	construe	VB
18637	12228	27	the	the	DT
18637	12228	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12228	29	for	for	IN
18637	12228	30	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12228	31	within	within	IN
18637	12228	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12228	33	respective	respective	JJ
18637	12228	34	spheres	sphere	NNS
18637	12228	35	,	,	,
18637	12228	36	and	and	CC
18637	12228	37	from	from	IN
18637	12228	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12228	39	deduced	deduce	VBD
18637	12228	40	the	the	DT
18637	12228	41	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	12228	42	right	right	NN
18637	12228	43	of	of	IN
18637	12228	44	the	the	DT
18637	12228	45	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	12228	46	to	to	TO
18637	12228	47	interpret	interpret	VB
18637	12228	48	the	the	DT
18637	12228	49	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12228	50	in	in	IN
18637	12228	51	what	what	WP
18637	12228	52	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	12228	53	the	the	DT
18637	12228	54	lawmaking	lawmaking	NN
18637	12228	55	power	power	NN
18637	12228	56	and	and	CC
18637	12228	57	the	the	DT
18637	12228	58	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	12228	59	of	of	IN
18637	12228	60	the	the	DT
18637	12228	61	judges	judge	NNS
18637	12228	62	to	to	TO
18637	12228	63	execute	execute	VB
18637	12228	64	what	what	WDT
18637	12228	65	laws	law	NNS
18637	12228	66	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12228	67	make	make	VBP
18637	12228	68	.	.	.
18637	12229	1	But	but	CC
18637	12229	2	the	the	DT
18637	12229	3	feeble	feeble	JJ
18637	12229	4	disguise	disguise	NN
18637	12229	5	which	which	WDT
18637	12229	6	this	this	DT
18637	12229	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	12229	8	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	12229	9	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	12229	10	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	12229	11	made	make	VBD
18637	12229	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12229	13	little	little	JJ
18637	12229	14	attractive	attractive	JJ
18637	12229	15	even	even	RB
18637	12229	16	to	to	IN
18637	12229	17	Republicans	Republicans	NNPS
18637	12229	18	,	,	,
18637	12229	19	who	who	WP
18637	12229	20	for	for	IN
18637	12229	21	the	the	DT
18637	12229	22	most	most	JJS
18637	12229	23	part	part	NN
18637	12229	24	either	either	CC
18637	12229	25	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	12229	26	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	12229	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12229	28	adherence	adherence	NN
18637	12229	29	to	to	IN
18637	12229	30	the	the	DT
18637	12229	31	juristic	juristic	JJ
18637	12229	32	view	view	NN
18637	12229	33	of	of	IN
18637	12229	34	the	the	DT
18637	12229	35	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12229	36	,	,	,
18637	12229	37	or	or	CC
18637	12229	38	following	follow	VBG
18637	12229	39	a	a	DT
18637	12229	40	hint	hint	NN
18637	12229	41	by	by	IN
18637	12229	42	Giles	Giles	NNP
18637	12229	43	of	of	IN
18637	12229	44	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	12229	45	,	,	,
18637	12229	46	kept	keep	VBD
18637	12229	47	silent	silent	JJ
18637	12229	48	on	on	IN
18637	12229	49	the	the	DT
18637	12229	50	subject	subject	NN
18637	12229	51	.	.	.
18637	12230	1	The	the	DT
18637	12230	2	Federalists	Federalists	NNPS
18637	12230	3	on	on	IN
18637	12230	4	the	the	DT
18637	12230	5	other	other	JJ
18637	12230	6	hand	hand	NN
18637	12230	7	were	be	VBD
18637	12230	8	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	12230	9	on	on	IN
18637	12230	10	the	the	DT
18637	12230	11	main	main	JJ
18637	12230	12	question	question	NN
18637	12230	13	,	,	,
18637	12230	14	though	though	IN
18637	12230	15	of	of	IN
18637	12230	16	divergent	divergent	JJ
18637	12230	17	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	12230	18	as	as	IN
18637	12230	19	to	to	IN
18637	12230	20	the	the	DT
18637	12230	21	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	12230	22	on	on	IN
18637	12230	23	which	which	WDT
18637	12230	24	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12230	25	review	review	NN
18637	12230	26	was	be	VBD
18637	12230	27	to	to	TO
18637	12230	28	be	be	VB
18637	12230	29	legally	legally	RB
18637	12230	30	based	base	VBN
18637	12230	31	,	,	,
18637	12230	32	some	some	DT
18637	12230	33	grounding	ground	VBG
18637	12230	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12230	35	on	on	IN
18637	12230	36	the	the	DT
18637	12230	37	"	"	``
18637	12230	38	arising	arise	VBG
18637	12230	39	"	"	''
18637	12230	40	and	and	CC
18637	12230	41	"	"	``
18637	12230	42	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	12230	43	"	"	''
18637	12230	44	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	12230	45	,	,	,
18637	12230	46	some	some	DT
18637	12230	47	on	on	IN
18637	12230	48	the	the	DT
18637	12230	49	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	12230	50	of	of	IN
18637	12230	51	the	the	DT
18637	12230	52	Pension	Pension	NNP
18637	12230	53	and	and	CC
18637	12230	54	Carriage	Carriage	NNP
18637	12230	55	cases	case	NNS
18637	12230	56	,	,	,
18637	12230	57	some	some	DT
18637	12230	58	on	on	IN
18637	12230	59	the	the	DT
18637	12230	60	nature	nature	NN
18637	12230	61	of	of	IN
18637	12230	62	the	the	DT
18637	12230	63	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12230	64	and	and	CC
18637	12230	65	of	of	IN
18637	12230	66	the	the	DT
18637	12230	67	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12230	68	office	office	NN
18637	12230	69	,	,	,
18637	12230	70	some	some	DT
18637	12230	71	on	on	IN
18637	12230	72	the	the	DT
18637	12230	73	contemporary	contemporary	JJ
18637	12230	74	use	use	NN
18637	12230	75	of	of	IN
18637	12230	76	terms	term	NNS
18637	12230	77	and	and	CC
18637	12230	78	the	the	DT
18637	12230	79	undisputed	undisputed	JJ
18637	12230	80	practice	practice	NN
18637	12230	81	under	under	IN
18637	12230	82	the	the	DT
18637	12230	83	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12230	84	of	of	IN
18637	12230	85	all	all	DT
18637	12230	86	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	12230	87	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	12230	88	.	.	.
18637	12231	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	12231	2	,	,	,
18637	12231	3	said	say	VBD
18637	12231	4	The	the	DT
18637	12231	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	12231	6	orators	orator	NNS
18637	12231	7	,	,	,
18637	12231	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12231	9	review	review	NN
18637	12231	10	was	be	VBD
18637	12231	11	expedient	expedient	NN
18637	12231	12	,	,	,
18637	12231	13	since	since	IN
18637	12231	14	the	the	DT
18637	12231	15	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	12231	16	had	have	VBD
18637	12231	17	control	control	NN
18637	12231	18	of	of	IN
18637	12231	19	neither	neither	CC
18637	12231	20	the	the	DT
18637	12231	21	purse	purse	NN
18637	12231	22	nor	nor	CC
18637	12231	23	the	the	DT
18637	12231	24	sword	sword	NN
18637	12231	25	;	;	:
18637	12231	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12231	27	was	be	VBD
18637	12231	28	the	the	DT
18637	12231	29	substitute	substitute	NN
18637	12231	30	offered	offer	VBN
18637	12231	31	by	by	IN
18637	12231	32	political	political	JJ
18637	12231	33	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	12231	34	for	for	IN
18637	12231	35	the	the	DT
18637	12231	36	destructive	destructive	JJ
18637	12231	37	right	right	NN
18637	12231	38	of	of	IN
18637	12231	39	revolution	revolution	NN
18637	12231	40	;	;	:
18637	12231	41	to	to	TO
18637	12231	42	have	have	VB
18637	12231	43	established	establish	VBN
18637	12231	44	this	this	DT
18637	12231	45	principle	principle	NN
18637	12231	46	of	of	IN
18637	12231	47	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	12231	48	security	security	NN
18637	12231	49	,	,	,
18637	12231	50	a	a	DT
18637	12231	51	novelty	novelty	NN
18637	12231	52	in	in	IN
18637	12231	53	the	the	DT
18637	12231	54	history	history	NN
18637	12231	55	of	of	IN
18637	12231	56	nations	nation	NNS
18637	12231	57	,	,	,
18637	12231	58	was	be	VBD
18637	12231	59	the	the	DT
18637	12231	60	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	12231	61	glory	glory	NN
18637	12231	62	of	of	IN
18637	12231	63	the	the	DT
18637	12231	64	American	american	JJ
18637	12231	65	people	people	NNS
18637	12231	66	;	;	:
18637	12231	67	the	the	DT
18637	12231	68	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	12231	69	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	12231	70	was	be	VBD
18637	12231	71	monstrous	monstrous	JJ
18637	12231	72	and	and	CC
18637	12231	73	unheard	unheard	JJ
18637	12231	74	of	of	IN
18637	12231	75	.	.	.
18637	12232	1	The	the	DT
18637	12232	2	year	year	NN
18637	12232	3	following	follow	VBG
18637	12232	4	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	12232	5	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	12232	6	the	the	DT
18637	12232	7	debate	debate	NN
18637	12232	8	,	,	,
18637	12232	9	and	and	CC
18637	12232	10	rendered	render	VBN
18637	12232	11	decision	decision	NN
18637	12232	12	,	,	,
18637	12232	13	in	in	IN
18637	12232	14	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	12232	15	_	_	NNP
18637	12232	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	12232	17	_	_	NNP
18637	12232	18	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	12232	19	.	.	.
18637	12233	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12233	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12233	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12233	4	Edward	Edward	NNP
18637	12233	5	S.	S.	NNP
18637	12233	6	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	12233	7	,	,	,
18637	12233	8	The	the	DT
18637	12233	9	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	12233	10	of	of	IN
18637	12233	11	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	12233	12	Review	Review	NNP
18637	12233	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12233	14	Princeton	Princeton	NNP
18637	12233	15	University	University	NNP
18637	12233	16	Press	Press	NNP
18637	12233	17	.	.	.
18637	12234	1	1914	1914	CD
18637	12234	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12234	3	,	,	,
18637	12234	4	49	49	CD
18637	12234	5	-	-	SYM
18637	12234	6	59	59	CD
18637	12234	7	;	;	:
18637	12234	8	and	and	CC
18637	12234	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12234	10	Over	over	IN
18637	12234	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12234	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12234	13	1938	1938	CD
18637	12234	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12234	15	,	,	,
18637	12234	16	Chap	Chap	NNP
18637	12234	17	.	.	.
18637	12235	1	1	1	LS
18637	12235	2	.	.	.
18637	12236	1	"	"	``
18637	12236	2	The	the	DT
18637	12236	3	glory	glory	NN
18637	12236	4	and	and	CC
18637	12236	5	ornament	ornament	NN
18637	12236	6	of	of	IN
18637	12236	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12236	8	system	system	NN
18637	12236	9	which	which	WDT
18637	12236	10	distinguishes	distinguish	VBZ
18637	12236	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12236	12	from	from	IN
18637	12236	13	every	every	DT
18637	12236	14	other	other	JJ
18637	12236	15	government	government	NN
18637	12236	16	on	on	IN
18637	12236	17	the	the	DT
18637	12236	18	face	face	NN
18637	12236	19	of	of	IN
18637	12236	20	the	the	DT
18637	12236	21	earth	earth	NN
18637	12236	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	12236	23	that	that	IN
18637	12236	24	there	there	EX
18637	12236	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	12236	26	a	a	DT
18637	12236	27	great	great	JJ
18637	12236	28	and	and	CC
18637	12236	29	mighty	mighty	JJ
18637	12236	30	power	power	NN
18637	12236	31	hovering	hovering	NN
18637	12236	32	over	over	IN
18637	12236	33	the	the	DT
18637	12236	34	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12236	35	of	of	IN
18637	12236	36	the	the	DT
18637	12236	37	land	land	NN
18637	12236	38	to	to	TO
18637	12236	39	which	which	WDT
18637	12236	40	has	have	VBZ
18637	12236	41	been	be	VBN
18637	12236	42	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	12236	43	the	the	DT
18637	12236	44	awful	awful	JJ
18637	12236	45	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	12236	46	of	of	IN
18637	12236	47	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	12236	48	all	all	PDT
18637	12236	49	the	the	DT
18637	12236	50	coordinate	coordinate	JJ
18637	12236	51	departments	department	NNS
18637	12236	52	of	of	IN
18637	12236	53	government	government	NN
18637	12236	54	within	within	IN
18637	12236	55	the	the	DT
18637	12236	56	walls	wall	NNS
18637	12236	57	of	of	IN
18637	12236	58	the	the	DT
18637	12236	59	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	12236	60	fabric	fabric	NN
18637	12236	61	which	which	WDT
18637	12236	62	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12236	63	fathers	father	NNS
18637	12236	64	built	build	VBN
18637	12236	65	for	for	IN
18637	12236	66	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12236	67	protection	protection	NN
18637	12236	68	and	and	CC
18637	12236	69	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	12236	70	.	.	.
18637	12236	71	"	"	''
18637	12237	1	--Chief	--Chief	:
18637	12237	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12237	3	Edward	Edward	NNP
18637	12237	4	Douglass	Douglass	NNP
18637	12237	5	White	White	NNP
18637	12237	6	when	when	WRB
18637	12237	7	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	12237	8	from	from	IN
18637	12237	9	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	12237	10	.	.	.
18637	12238	1	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	12238	2	.	.	.
18637	12239	1	Record	record	NN
18637	12239	2	,	,	,
18637	12239	3	52d	52d	NNP
18637	12239	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	12239	5	.	.	NNP
18637	12239	6	,	,	,
18637	12239	7	2d	2d	NNP
18637	12239	8	sess	sess	NN
18637	12239	9	.	.	.
18637	12239	10	,	,	,
18637	12239	11	p.	p.	NN
18637	12239	12	6516	6516	CD
18637	12239	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12239	14	1894	1894	CD
18637	12239	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12239	16	.	.	.
18637	12240	1	"	"	``
18637	12240	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12240	3	do	do	VBP
18637	12240	4	not	not	RB
18637	12240	5	think	think	VB
18637	12240	6	the	the	DT
18637	12240	7	United	United	NNP
18637	12240	8	States	States	NNP
18637	12240	9	would	would	MD
18637	12240	10	come	come	VB
18637	12240	11	to	to	IN
18637	12240	12	an	an	DT
18637	12240	13	end	end	NN
18637	12240	14	if	if	IN
18637	12240	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12240	16	lost	lose	VBD
18637	12240	17	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12240	18	power	power	NN
18637	12240	19	to	to	TO
18637	12240	20	declare	declare	VB
18637	12240	21	an	an	DT
18637	12240	22	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12240	23	of	of	IN
18637	12240	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12240	25	void	void	NN
18637	12240	26	.	.	.
18637	12241	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12241	2	do	do	VBP
18637	12241	3	think	think	VB
18637	12241	4	the	the	DT
18637	12241	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	12241	6	would	would	MD
18637	12241	7	be	be	VB
18637	12241	8	imperiled	imperil	VBN
18637	12241	9	if	if	IN
18637	12241	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12241	11	could	could	MD
18637	12241	12	not	not	RB
18637	12241	13	make	make	VB
18637	12241	14	that	that	DT
18637	12241	15	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	12241	16	as	as	IN
18637	12241	17	to	to	IN
18637	12241	18	the	the	DT
18637	12241	19	laws	law	NNS
18637	12241	20	of	of	IN
18637	12241	21	the	the	DT
18637	12241	22	several	several	JJ
18637	12241	23	States	state	NNS
18637	12241	24	.	.	.
18637	12241	25	"	"	''
18637	12242	1	Oliver	Oliver	NNP
18637	12242	2	Wendell	Wendell	NNP
18637	12242	3	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	12242	4	,	,	,
18637	12242	5	Collected	Collected	NNP
18637	12242	6	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	12242	7	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	12242	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12242	9	New	New	NNP
18637	12242	10	York	York	NNP
18637	12242	11	,	,	,
18637	12242	12	1920	1920	CD
18637	12242	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12242	14	,	,	,
18637	12242	15	295	295	CD
18637	12242	16	-	-	SYM
18637	12242	17	296	296	CD
18637	12242	18	.	.	.
18637	12243	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12243	2	259	259	CD
18637	12243	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12243	4	The	the	DT
18637	12243	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	12243	6	No	no	NN
18637	12243	7	.	.	.
18637	12244	1	78	78	CD
18637	12244	2	.	.	.
18637	12245	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12245	2	260	260	CD
18637	12245	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12245	4	3	3	CD
18637	12245	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12245	6	.	.	.
18637	12246	1	386	386	CD
18637	12246	2	,	,	,
18637	12246	3	399	399	CD
18637	12246	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12246	5	1798	1798	CD
18637	12246	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12246	7	.	.	.
18637	12247	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12247	2	261	261	CD
18637	12247	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12247	4	2	2	CD
18637	12247	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12247	6	.	.	.
18637	12248	1	409	409	CD
18637	12248	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12248	3	1792	1792	CD
18637	12248	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12248	5	.	.	.
18637	12249	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12249	2	262	262	CD
18637	12249	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12249	4	1	1	CD
18637	12249	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12249	6	.	.	.
18637	12250	1	243	243	CD
18637	12250	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12250	3	1792	1792	CD
18637	12250	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12250	5	.	.	.
18637	12251	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12251	2	263	263	CD
18637	12251	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12251	4	3	3	CD
18637	12251	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12251	6	.	.	.
18637	12252	1	171	171	CD
18637	12252	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12252	3	1796	1796	CD
18637	12252	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12252	5	.	.	.
18637	12253	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12253	2	264	264	CD
18637	12253	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12253	4	1	1	CD
18637	12253	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12253	6	.	.	.
18637	12254	1	137	137	CD
18637	12254	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12254	3	1803	1803	CD
18637	12254	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12254	5	.	.	.
18637	12255	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12255	2	265	265	CD
18637	12255	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12255	4	1	1	CD
18637	12255	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12255	6	.	.	.
18637	12256	1	73	73	CD
18637	12256	2	,	,	,
18637	12256	3	81	81	CD
18637	12256	4	.	.	.
18637	12257	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12257	2	266	266	CD
18637	12257	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12257	4	Cr	Cr	NNP
18637	12257	5	.	.	.
18637	12258	1	137	137	CD
18637	12258	2	,	,	,
18637	12258	3	175	175	CD
18637	12258	4	-	-	SYM
18637	12258	5	180	180	CD
18637	12258	6	.	.	.
18637	12259	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12259	2	267	267	CD
18637	12259	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12259	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12259	5	.	.	.
18637	12260	1	180	180	CD
18637	12260	2	.	.	.
18637	12261	1	The	the	DT
18637	12261	2	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	12261	3	in	in	IN
18637	12261	4	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	12261	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12261	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12261	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12261	8	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	12261	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	12261	10	subject	subject	JJ
18637	12261	11	to	to	IN
18637	12261	12	two	two	CD
18637	12261	13	valid	valid	JJ
18637	12261	14	criticisms	criticism	NNS
18637	12261	15	.	.	.
18637	12262	1	In	in	IN
18637	12262	2	the	the	DT
18637	12262	3	first	first	JJ
18637	12262	4	place	place	NN
18637	12262	5	the	the	DT
18637	12262	6	construction	construction	NN
18637	12262	7	of	of	IN
18637	12262	8	the	the	DT
18637	12262	9	13th	13th	JJ
18637	12262	10	Section	Section	NNP
18637	12262	11	of	of	IN
18637	12262	12	the	the	DT
18637	12262	13	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	12262	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12262	15	,	,	,
18637	12262	16	if	if	IN
18637	12262	17	not	not	RB
18637	12262	18	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
18637	12262	19	,	,	,
18637	12262	20	was	be	VBD
18637	12262	21	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	12262	22	since	since	IN
18637	12262	23	the	the	DT
18637	12262	24	section	section	NN
18637	12262	25	could	could	MD
18637	12262	26	have	have	VB
18637	12262	27	been	be	VBN
18637	12262	28	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	12262	29	,	,	,
18637	12262	30	as	as	IN
18637	12262	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12262	32	afterward	afterward	RB
18637	12262	33	was	be	VBD
18637	12262	34	,	,	,
18637	12262	35	merely	merely	RB
18637	12262	36	to	to	TO
18637	12262	37	give	give	VB
18637	12262	38	the	the	DT
18637	12262	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12262	40	the	the	DT
18637	12262	41	power	power	NN
18637	12262	42	to	to	TO
18637	12262	43	issue	issue	VB
18637	12262	44	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	12262	45	and	and	CC
18637	12262	46	other	other	JJ
18637	12262	47	writs	writ	NNS
18637	12262	48	when	when	WRB
18637	12262	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12262	50	had	have	VBD
18637	12262	51	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12262	52	but	but	CC
18637	12262	53	not	not	RB
18637	12262	54	for	for	IN
18637	12262	55	the	the	DT
18637	12262	56	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	12262	57	of	of	IN
18637	12262	58	acquiring	acquire	VBG
18637	12262	59	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12262	60	.	.	.
18637	12263	1	The	the	DT
18637	12263	2	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	12263	3	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	12263	4	of	of	IN
18637	12263	5	the	the	DT
18637	12263	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12263	7	's	's	POS
18637	12263	8	original	original	JJ
18637	12263	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12263	10	,	,	,
18637	12263	11	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	12263	12	made	make	VBD
18637	12263	13	a	a	DT
18637	12263	14	subject	subject	NN
18637	12263	15	of	of	IN
18637	12263	16	criticism	criticism	NN
18637	12263	17	,	,	,
18637	12263	18	had	have	VBD
18637	12263	19	been	be	VBN
18637	12263	20	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	12263	21	by	by	IN
18637	12263	22	the	the	DT
18637	12263	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12263	24	in	in	IN
18637	12263	25	Wiscart	Wiscart	NNP
18637	12263	26	_	_	NNP
18637	12263	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	12263	28	_	_	NNP
18637	12263	29	Dauchy	Dauchy	NNP
18637	12263	30	,	,	,
18637	12263	31	3	3	CD
18637	12263	32	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12263	33	.	.	.
18637	12264	1	321	321	CD
18637	12264	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12264	3	1796	1796	CD
18637	12264	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12264	5	,	,	,
18637	12264	6	and	and	CC
18637	12264	7	while	while	IN
18637	12264	8	couched	couch	VBN
18637	12264	9	in	in	IN
18637	12264	10	terms	term	NNS
18637	12264	11	which	which	WDT
18637	12264	12	had	have	VBD
18637	12264	13	later	later	RB
18637	12264	14	to	to	TO
18637	12264	15	be	be	VB
18637	12264	16	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	12264	17	in	in	IN
18637	12264	18	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	12264	19	_	_	NNP
18637	12264	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	12264	21	_	_	NNP
18637	12264	22	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	12264	23	,	,	,
18637	12264	24	6	6	CD
18637	12264	25	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12264	26	.	.	.
18637	12265	1	264	264	CD
18637	12265	2	,	,	,
18637	12265	3	398	398	CD
18637	12265	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	12265	5	402	402	CD
18637	12265	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12265	7	1821	1821	CD
18637	12265	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12265	9	,	,	,
18637	12265	10	by	by	IN
18637	12265	11	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	12265	12	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12265	13	,	,	,
18637	12265	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	12265	15	remained	remain	VBN
18637	12265	16	the	the	DT
18637	12265	17	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	12265	18	of	of	IN
18637	12265	19	the	the	DT
18637	12265	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12265	21	.	.	.
18637	12266	1	Secondly	secondly	RB
18637	12266	2	,	,	,
18637	12266	3	there	there	EX
18637	12266	4	was	be	VBD
18637	12266	5	good	good	JJ
18637	12266	6	ground	ground	NN
18637	12266	7	for	for	IN
18637	12266	8	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	12266	9	's	's	POS
18637	12266	10	criticism	criticism	NN
18637	12266	11	,	,	,
18637	12266	12	which	which	WDT
18637	12266	13	did	do	VBD
18637	12266	14	not	not	RB
18637	12266	15	touch	touch	VB
18637	12266	16	the	the	DT
18637	12266	17	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	12266	18	features	feature	NNS
18637	12266	19	of	of	IN
18637	12266	20	the	the	DT
18637	12266	21	decision	decision	NN
18637	12266	22	,	,	,
18637	12266	23	but	but	CC
18637	12266	24	did	do	VBD
18637	12266	25	inveigh	inveigh	RB
18637	12266	26	against	against	IN
18637	12266	27	the	the	DT
18637	12266	28	temerity	temerity	NN
18637	12266	29	of	of	IN
18637	12266	30	the	the	DT
18637	12266	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12266	32	in	in	IN
18637	12266	33	passing	pass	VBG
18637	12266	34	on	on	IN
18637	12266	35	the	the	DT
18637	12266	36	merits	merit	NNS
18637	12266	37	of	of	IN
18637	12266	38	a	a	DT
18637	12266	39	case	case	NN
18637	12266	40	of	of	IN
18637	12266	41	which	which	WDT
18637	12266	42	,	,	,
18637	12266	43	by	by	IN
18637	12266	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12266	45	own	own	JJ
18637	12266	46	admission	admission	NN
18637	12266	47	,	,	,
18637	12266	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12266	49	had	have	VBD
18637	12266	50	no	no	DT
18637	12266	51	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12266	52	.	.	.
18637	12267	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12267	2	268	268	CD
18637	12267	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12267	4	In	in	IN
18637	12267	5	this	this	DT
18637	12267	6	connection	connection	NN
18637	12267	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12267	8	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	12267	9	's	's	POS
18637	12267	10	jury	jury	NN
18637	12267	11	charge	charge	NN
18637	12267	12	in	in	IN
18637	12267	13	Van	Van	NNP
18637	12267	14	Horne	Horne	NNP
18637	12267	15	's	's	POS
18637	12267	16	Lessee	Lessee	NNP
18637	12267	17	_	_	NNP
18637	12267	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	12267	19	_	_	NNP
18637	12267	20	Dorrance	Dorrance	NNP
18637	12267	21	,	,	,
18637	12267	22	2	2	CD
18637	12267	23	Dall	dall	NN
18637	12267	24	.	.	.
18637	12268	1	304	304	CD
18637	12268	2	,	,	,
18637	12268	3	308	308	CD
18637	12268	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12268	5	1795	1795	CD
18637	12268	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12268	7	,	,	,
18637	12268	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	12268	9	of	of	IN
18637	12268	10	significance	significance	NN
18637	12268	11	for	for	IN
18637	12268	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12268	13	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	12268	14	of	of	IN
18637	12268	15	the	the	DT
18637	12268	16	relation	relation	NN
18637	12268	17	of	of	IN
18637	12268	18	the	the	DT
18637	12268	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12268	20	,	,	,
18637	12268	21	the	the	DT
18637	12268	22	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	12268	23	and	and	CC
18637	12268	24	the	the	DT
18637	12268	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	12268	26	.	.	.
18637	12269	1	A	a	DT
18637	12269	2	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	12269	3	,	,	,
18637	12269	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12269	5	said	say	VBD
18637	12269	6	,	,	,
18637	12269	7	"	"	``
18637	12269	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	12269	9	the	the	DT
18637	12269	10	form	form	NN
18637	12269	11	of	of	IN
18637	12269	12	government	government	NN
18637	12269	13	,	,	,
18637	12269	14	delineated	delineate	VBN
18637	12269	15	by	by	IN
18637	12269	16	the	the	DT
18637	12269	17	mighty	mighty	JJ
18637	12269	18	hand	hand	NN
18637	12269	19	of	of	IN
18637	12269	20	the	the	DT
18637	12269	21	people	people	NNS
18637	12269	22	,	,	,
18637	12269	23	in	in	IN
18637	12269	24	which	which	WDT
18637	12269	25	certain	certain	JJ
18637	12269	26	first	first	JJ
18637	12269	27	principles	principle	NNS
18637	12269	28	of	of	IN
18637	12269	29	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	12269	30	laws	law	NNS
18637	12269	31	are	be	VBP
18637	12269	32	established	establish	VBN
18637	12269	33	.	.	.
18637	12270	1	The	the	DT
18637	12270	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12270	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	12270	4	certain	certain	JJ
18637	12270	5	and	and	CC
18637	12270	6	fixed	fixed	JJ
18637	12270	7	;	;	:
18637	12270	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12270	9	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	12270	10	the	the	DT
18637	12270	11	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	12270	12	will	will	NN
18637	12270	13	of	of	IN
18637	12270	14	the	the	DT
18637	12270	15	people	people	NNS
18637	12270	16	,	,	,
18637	12270	17	and	and	CC
18637	12270	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	12270	19	the	the	DT
18637	12270	20	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	12270	21	law	law	NNP
18637	12270	22	of	of	IN
18637	12270	23	the	the	DT
18637	12270	24	land	land	NN
18637	12270	25	;	;	:
18637	12270	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12270	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	12270	28	paramount	paramount	JJ
18637	12270	29	to	to	IN
18637	12270	30	the	the	DT
18637	12270	31	power	power	NN
18637	12270	32	of	of	IN
18637	12270	33	the	the	DT
18637	12270	34	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	12270	35	,	,	,
18637	12270	36	and	and	CC
18637	12270	37	can	can	MD
18637	12270	38	be	be	VB
18637	12270	39	revoked	revoke	VBN
18637	12270	40	or	or	CC
18637	12270	41	altered	alter	VBN
18637	12270	42	only	only	RB
18637	12270	43	by	by	IN
18637	12270	44	the	the	DT
18637	12270	45	authority	authority	NN
18637	12270	46	that	that	WDT
18637	12270	47	made	make	VBD
18637	12270	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12270	49	.	.	.
18637	12270	50	"	"	''
18637	12271	1	Legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	12271	2	are	be	VBP
18637	12271	3	the	the	DT
18637	12271	4	creatures	creature	NNS
18637	12271	5	of	of	IN
18637	12271	6	the	the	DT
18637	12271	7	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12271	8	to	to	TO
18637	12271	9	which	which	WDT
18637	12271	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12271	11	owe	owe	VBP
18637	12271	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12271	13	existence	existence	NN
18637	12271	14	and	and	CC
18637	12271	15	powers	power	NNS
18637	12271	16	,	,	,
18637	12271	17	and	and	CC
18637	12271	18	in	in	IN
18637	12271	19	case	case	NN
18637	12271	20	of	of	IN
18637	12271	21	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	12271	22	between	between	IN
18637	12271	23	a	a	DT
18637	12271	24	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	12271	25	act	act	NN
18637	12271	26	and	and	CC
18637	12271	27	the	the	DT
18637	12271	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12271	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12271	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	12271	31	the	the	DT
18637	12271	32	duty	duty	NN
18637	12271	33	of	of	IN
18637	12271	34	the	the	DT
18637	12271	35	courts	court	NNS
18637	12271	36	to	to	TO
18637	12271	37	hold	hold	VB
18637	12271	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12271	39	void	void	JJ
18637	12271	40	.	.	.
18637	12272	1	In	in	IN
18637	12272	2	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	12272	3	with	with	IN
18637	12272	4	these	these	DT
18637	12272	5	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	12272	6	fortified	fortify	VBN
18637	12272	7	by	by	IN
18637	12272	8	natural	natural	JJ
18637	12272	9	law	law	NN
18637	12272	10	concepts	concept	NNS
18637	12272	11	,	,	,
18637	12272	12	the	the	DT
18637	12272	13	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	12272	14	court	court	NN
18637	12272	15	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
18637	12272	16	a	a	DT
18637	12272	17	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	12272	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	12272	19	as	as	IN
18637	12272	20	being	be	VBG
18637	12272	21	in	in	IN
18637	12272	22	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	12272	23	with	with	IN
18637	12272	24	the	the	DT
18637	12272	25	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12272	26	and	and	CC
18637	12272	27	State	State	NNP
18637	12272	28	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
18637	12272	29	as	as	IN
18637	12272	30	a	a	DT
18637	12272	31	violation	violation	NN
18637	12272	32	of	of	IN
18637	12272	33	the	the	DT
18637	12272	34	inalienable	inalienable	JJ
18637	12272	35	rights	right	NNS
18637	12272	36	of	of	IN
18637	12272	37	property	property	NN
18637	12272	38	.	.	.
18637	12273	1	In	in	IN
18637	12273	2	1799	1799	CD
18637	12273	3	the	the	DT
18637	12273	4	federal	federal	NNP
18637	12273	5	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	12273	6	court	court	NN
18637	12273	7	in	in	IN
18637	12273	8	North	North	NNP
18637	12273	9	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	12273	10	,	,	,
18637	12273	11	over	over	IN
18637	12273	12	which	which	WDT
18637	12273	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	12273	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12273	15	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	12273	16	presided	preside	VBD
18637	12273	17	,	,	,
18637	12273	18	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
18637	12273	19	an	an	DT
18637	12273	20	act	act	NN
18637	12273	21	of	of	IN
18637	12273	22	North	North	NNP
18637	12273	23	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	12273	24	as	as	IN
18637	12273	25	a	a	DT
18637	12273	26	violation	violation	NN
18637	12273	27	of	of	IN
18637	12273	28	the	the	DT
18637	12273	29	contract	contract	NN
18637	12273	30	clause	clause	NN
18637	12273	31	and	and	CC
18637	12273	32	the	the	DT
18637	12273	33	separation	separation	NN
18637	12273	34	of	of	IN
18637	12273	35	powers	power	NNS
18637	12273	36	in	in	IN
18637	12273	37	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	12273	38	_	_	NNP
18637	12273	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	12273	40	_	_	NNP
18637	12273	41	Witherspoon	Witherspoon	NNP
18637	12273	42	,	,	,
18637	12273	43	18	18	CD
18637	12273	44	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	12273	45	.	.	.
18637	12274	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	12274	2	.	.	.
18637	12275	1	No	no	UH
18637	12275	2	.	.	.
18637	12276	1	10,461	10,461	CD
18637	12276	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12276	3	1802	1802	CD
18637	12276	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12276	5	.	.	.
18637	12277	1	The	the	DT
18637	12277	2	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	12277	3	on	on	IN
18637	12277	4	general	general	JJ
18637	12277	5	principles	principle	NNS
18637	12277	6	and	and	CC
18637	12277	7	natural	natural	JJ
18637	12277	8	rights	right	NNS
18637	12277	9	continued	continue	VBN
18637	12277	10	in	in	IN
18637	12277	11	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	12277	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12277	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	12277	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12277	15	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	12277	16	,	,	,
18637	12277	17	6	6	CD
18637	12277	18	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12277	19	.	.	.
18637	12278	1	87	87	CD
18637	12278	2	,	,	,
18637	12278	3	139	139	CD
18637	12278	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12278	5	1810	1810	CD
18637	12278	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12278	7	where	where	WRB
18637	12278	8	the	the	DT
18637	12278	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12278	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12278	11	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
18637	12278	12	an	an	DT
18637	12278	13	act	act	NN
18637	12278	14	of	of	IN
18637	12278	15	the	the	DT
18637	12278	16	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	12278	17	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	12278	18	revoking	revoke	VBG
18637	12278	19	an	an	DT
18637	12278	20	earlier	early	JJR
18637	12278	21	land	land	NN
18637	12278	22	grant	grant	NN
18637	12278	23	as	as	IN
18637	12278	24	a	a	DT
18637	12278	25	violation	violation	NN
18637	12278	26	either	either	DT
18637	12278	27	of	of	IN
18637	12278	28	the	the	DT
18637	12278	29	"	"	``
18637	12278	30	general	general	JJ
18637	12278	31	principles	principle	NNS
18637	12278	32	which	which	WDT
18637	12278	33	are	be	VBP
18637	12278	34	common	common	JJ
18637	12278	35	to	to	IN
18637	12278	36	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12278	37	free	free	JJ
18637	12278	38	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	12278	39	,	,	,
18637	12278	40	"	"	''
18637	12278	41	or	or	CC
18637	12278	42	of	of	IN
18637	12278	43	the	the	DT
18637	12278	44	contract	contract	NN
18637	12278	45	clause	clause	NN
18637	12278	46	.	.	.
18637	12279	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12279	2	269	269	CD
18637	12279	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12279	4	This	this	DT
18637	12279	5	phase	phase	NN
18637	12279	6	of	of	IN
18637	12279	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12279	8	review	review	NN
18637	12279	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	12279	10	described	describe	VBN
18637	12279	11	by	by	IN
18637	12279	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12279	13	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	12279	14	as	as	IN
18637	12279	15	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	12279	16	:	:	:
18637	12279	17	"	"	``
18637	12279	18	From	from	IN
18637	12279	19	the	the	DT
18637	12279	20	authority	authority	NN
18637	12279	21	to	to	TO
18637	12279	22	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	12279	23	and	and	CC
18637	12279	24	determine	determine	VB
18637	12279	25	the	the	DT
18637	12279	26	law	law	NN
18637	12279	27	in	in	IN
18637	12279	28	a	a	DT
18637	12279	29	given	give	VBN
18637	12279	30	case	case	NN
18637	12279	31	,	,	,
18637	12279	32	there	there	EX
18637	12279	33	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	12279	34	results	result	NNS
18637	12279	35	,	,	,
18637	12279	36	in	in	IN
18637	12279	37	case	case	NN
18637	12279	38	of	of	IN
18637	12279	39	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	12279	40	,	,	,
18637	12279	41	the	the	DT
18637	12279	42	duty	duty	NN
18637	12279	43	to	to	TO
18637	12279	44	declare	declare	VB
18637	12279	45	and	and	CC
18637	12279	46	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	12279	47	the	the	DT
18637	12279	48	rule	rule	NN
18637	12279	49	of	of	IN
18637	12279	50	the	the	DT
18637	12279	51	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	12279	52	law	law	NNP
18637	12279	53	and	and	CC
18637	12279	54	reject	reject	VBP
18637	12279	55	that	that	DT
18637	12279	56	of	of	IN
18637	12279	57	an	an	DT
18637	12279	58	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	12279	59	act	act	NN
18637	12279	60	of	of	IN
18637	12279	61	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	12279	62	which	which	WDT
18637	12279	63	,	,	,
18637	12279	64	transcending	transcend	VBG
18637	12279	65	the	the	DT
18637	12279	66	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12279	67	,	,	,
18637	12279	68	is	be	VBZ
18637	12279	69	of	of	IN
18637	12279	70	no	no	DT
18637	12279	71	effect	effect	NN
18637	12279	72	and	and	CC
18637	12279	73	binding	bind	VBG
18637	12279	74	on	on	IN
18637	12279	75	no	no	DT
18637	12279	76	one	one	NN
18637	12279	77	.	.	.
18637	12280	1	This	this	DT
18637	12280	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	12280	3	not	not	RB
18637	12280	4	the	the	DT
18637	12280	5	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	12280	6	of	of	IN
18637	12280	7	a	a	DT
18637	12280	8	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	12280	9	power	power	NN
18637	12280	10	to	to	TO
18637	12280	11	review	review	VB
18637	12280	12	and	and	CC
18637	12280	13	nullify	nullify	VB
18637	12280	14	acts	act	NNS
18637	12280	15	of	of	IN
18637	12280	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12280	17	,	,	,
18637	12280	18	for	for	IN
18637	12280	19	no	no	DT
18637	12280	20	such	such	JJ
18637	12280	21	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	12280	22	power	power	NN
18637	12280	23	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	12280	24	.	.	.
18637	12281	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12281	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	12281	3	simply	simply	RB
18637	12281	4	a	a	DT
18637	12281	5	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	12281	6	concomitant	concomitant	NN
18637	12281	7	of	of	IN
18637	12281	8	the	the	DT
18637	12281	9	power	power	NN
18637	12281	10	to	to	TO
18637	12281	11	hear	hear	VB
18637	12281	12	and	and	CC
18637	12281	13	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	12281	14	of	of	IN
18637	12281	15	a	a	DT
18637	12281	16	case	case	NN
18637	12281	17	or	or	CC
18637	12281	18	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	12281	19	properly	properly	RB
18637	12281	20	before	before	IN
18637	12281	21	the	the	DT
18637	12281	22	court	court	NN
18637	12281	23	,	,	,
18637	12281	24	to	to	IN
18637	12281	25	the	the	DT
18637	12281	26	determination	determination	NN
18637	12281	27	of	of	IN
18637	12281	28	which	which	WDT
18637	12281	29	must	must	MD
18637	12281	30	be	be	VB
18637	12281	31	brought	bring	VBN
18637	12281	32	the	the	DT
18637	12281	33	test	test	NN
18637	12281	34	and	and	CC
18637	12281	35	measure	measure	NN
18637	12281	36	of	of	IN
18637	12281	37	the	the	DT
18637	12281	38	law	law	NN
18637	12281	39	.	.	.
18637	12281	40	"	"	''
18637	12282	1	Adkins	Adkins	NNPS
18637	12282	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12282	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12282	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12282	5	Children	Children	NNP
18637	12282	6	's	's	POS
18637	12282	7	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	12282	8	,	,	,
18637	12282	9	261	261	CD
18637	12282	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12282	11	525	525	CD
18637	12282	12	,	,	,
18637	12282	13	544	544	CD
18637	12282	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12282	15	1923	1923	CD
18637	12282	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12282	17	.	.	.
18637	12283	1	In	in	IN
18637	12283	2	United	United	NNP
18637	12283	3	States	States	NNP
18637	12283	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12283	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	12283	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12283	7	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	12283	8	,	,	,
18637	12283	9	297	297	CD
18637	12283	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12283	11	1	1	CD
18637	12283	12	,	,	,
18637	12283	13	62	62	CD
18637	12283	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12283	15	1936	1936	CD
18637	12283	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12283	17	,	,	,
18637	12283	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12283	19	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	12283	20	for	for	IN
18637	12283	21	the	the	DT
18637	12283	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12283	23	reduced	reduce	VBD
18637	12283	24	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12283	25	review	review	NN
18637	12283	26	to	to	IN
18637	12283	27	very	very	RB
18637	12283	28	simple	simple	JJ
18637	12283	29	terms	term	NNS
18637	12283	30	when	when	WRB
18637	12283	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12283	32	declared	declare	VBD
18637	12283	33	that	that	IN
18637	12283	34	when	when	WRB
18637	12283	35	an	an	DT
18637	12283	36	act	act	NN
18637	12283	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	12283	38	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	12283	39	as	as	IN
18637	12283	40	being	be	VBG
18637	12283	41	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	12283	42	,	,	,
18637	12283	43	"	"	''
18637	12283	44	the	the	DT
18637	12283	45	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12283	46	branch	branch	NN
18637	12283	47	of	of	IN
18637	12283	48	the	the	DT
18637	12283	49	Government	Government	NNP
18637	12283	50	has	have	VBZ
18637	12283	51	only	only	RB
18637	12283	52	one	one	CD
18637	12283	53	duty,--to	duty,--to	NN
18637	12283	54	lay	lie	VBD
18637	12283	55	the	the	DT
18637	12283	56	article	article	NN
18637	12283	57	of	of	IN
18637	12283	58	the	the	DT
18637	12283	59	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12283	60	which	which	WDT
18637	12283	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	12283	62	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	12283	63	beside	beside	IN
18637	12283	64	the	the	DT
18637	12283	65	statute	statute	NN
18637	12283	66	which	which	WDT
18637	12283	67	is	be	VBZ
18637	12283	68	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	12283	69	and	and	CC
18637	12283	70	to	to	TO
18637	12283	71	decide	decide	VB
18637	12283	72	whether	whether	IN
18637	12283	73	the	the	DT
18637	12283	74	latter	latter	JJ
18637	12283	75	squares	square	NNS
18637	12283	76	with	with	IN
18637	12283	77	the	the	DT
18637	12283	78	former	former	JJ
18637	12283	79	.	.	.
18637	12283	80	"	"	''
18637	12284	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12284	2	270	270	CD
18637	12284	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12284	4	Note	note	VB
18637	12284	5	,	,	,
18637	12284	6	for	for	IN
18637	12284	7	example	example	NN
18637	12284	8	,	,	,
18637	12284	9	the	the	DT
18637	12284	10	following	follow	VBG
18637	12284	11	statement	statement	NN
18637	12284	12	of	of	IN
18637	12284	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	12284	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12284	15	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	12284	16	:	:	:
18637	12284	17	"	"	``
18637	12284	18	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12284	19	power	power	NN
18637	12284	20	,	,	,
18637	12284	21	as	as	IN
18637	12284	22	contradistinguished	contradistinguish	VBN
18637	12284	23	from	from	IN
18637	12284	24	the	the	DT
18637	12284	25	power	power	NN
18637	12284	26	of	of	IN
18637	12284	27	the	the	DT
18637	12284	28	laws	law	NNS
18637	12284	29	,	,	,
18637	12284	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	12284	31	no	no	DT
18637	12284	32	existence	existence	NN
18637	12284	33	.	.	.
18637	12285	1	Courts	court	NNS
18637	12285	2	are	be	VBP
18637	12285	3	the	the	DT
18637	12285	4	mere	mere	JJ
18637	12285	5	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	12285	6	of	of	IN
18637	12285	7	the	the	DT
18637	12285	8	law	law	NN
18637	12285	9	,	,	,
18637	12285	10	and	and	CC
18637	12285	11	can	can	MD
18637	12285	12	will	will	VB
18637	12285	13	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	12285	14	.	.	.
18637	12285	15	"	"	''
18637	12286	1	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	12286	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12286	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12286	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12286	5	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	12286	6	of	of	IN
18637	12286	7	United	United	NNP
18637	12286	8	States	States	NNP
18637	12286	9	,	,	,
18637	12286	10	9	9	CD
18637	12286	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12286	12	.	.	.
18637	12287	1	738	738	CD
18637	12287	2	,	,	,
18637	12287	3	866	866	CD
18637	12287	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12287	5	1824	1824	CD
18637	12287	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12287	7	.	.	.
18637	12288	1	Note	note	VB
18637	12288	2	also	also	RB
18637	12288	3	the	the	DT
18637	12288	4	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	12288	5	of	of	IN
18637	12288	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12288	7	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	12288	8	:	:	:
18637	12288	9	"	"	``
18637	12288	10	All	all	PDT
18637	12288	11	the	the	DT
18637	12288	12	court	court	NN
18637	12288	13	does	do	VBZ
18637	12288	14	,	,	,
18637	12288	15	can	can	MD
18637	12288	16	do	do	VB
18637	12288	17	,	,	,
18637	12288	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	12288	19	to	to	TO
18637	12288	20	announce	announce	VB
18637	12288	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12288	22	considered	consider	VBN
18637	12288	23	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	12288	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	12288	25	the	the	DT
18637	12288	26	question	question	NN
18637	12288	27	.	.	.
18637	12289	1	The	the	DT
18637	12289	2	only	only	JJ
18637	12289	3	power	power	NN
18637	12289	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12289	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	12289	6	,	,	,
18637	12289	7	if	if	IN
18637	12289	8	such	such	JJ
18637	12289	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12289	10	may	may	MD
18637	12289	11	be	be	VB
18637	12289	12	called	call	VBN
18637	12289	13	,	,	,
18637	12289	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	12289	15	the	the	DT
18637	12289	16	power	power	NN
18637	12289	17	of	of	IN
18637	12289	18	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	12289	19	.	.	.
18637	12290	1	This	this	DT
18637	12290	2	court	court	NN
18637	12290	3	neither	neither	CC
18637	12290	4	approves	approve	VBZ
18637	12290	5	nor	nor	CC
18637	12290	6	condemns	condemn	VBZ
18637	12290	7	any	any	DT
18637	12290	8	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	12290	9	policy	policy	NN
18637	12290	10	.	.	.
18637	12291	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12291	2	delicate	delicate	JJ
18637	12291	3	and	and	CC
18637	12291	4	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	12291	5	office	office	NN
18637	12291	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	12291	7	to	to	TO
18637	12291	8	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	12291	9	and	and	CC
18637	12291	10	declare	declare	VB
18637	12291	11	whether	whether	IN
18637	12291	12	the	the	DT
18637	12291	13	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	12291	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	12291	15	in	in	IN
18637	12291	16	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	12291	17	with	with	IN
18637	12291	18	,	,	,
18637	12291	19	or	or	CC
18637	12291	20	in	in	IN
18637	12291	21	contravention	contravention	NN
18637	12291	22	of	of	IN
18637	12291	23	,	,	,
18637	12291	24	the	the	DT
18637	12291	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12291	26	;	;	:
18637	12291	27	and	and	CC
18637	12291	28	,	,	,
18637	12291	29	having	have	VBG
18637	12291	30	done	do	VBN
18637	12291	31	that	that	DT
18637	12291	32	,	,	,
18637	12291	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12291	34	duty	duty	NN
18637	12291	35	ends	end	NNS
18637	12291	36	.	.	.
18637	12291	37	"	"	''
18637	12292	1	United	United	NNP
18637	12292	2	States	States	NNP
18637	12292	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12292	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	12292	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12292	6	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	12292	7	,	,	,
18637	12292	8	297	297	CD
18637	12292	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12292	10	1	1	CD
18637	12292	11	,	,	,
18637	12292	12	62	62	CD
18637	12292	13	-	-	SYM
18637	12292	14	63	63	CD
18637	12292	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12292	16	1936	1936	CD
18637	12292	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12292	18	.	.	.
18637	12293	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12293	2	271	271	CD
18637	12293	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12293	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	12293	5	&	&	CC
18637	12293	6	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	12293	7	Trunk	Trunk	NNP
18637	12293	8	R.	R.	NNP
18637	12293	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12293	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12293	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	12293	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12293	13	Wellman	Wellman	NNP
18637	12293	14	,	,	,
18637	12293	15	143	143	CD
18637	12293	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12293	17	339	339	CD
18637	12293	18	,	,	,
18637	12293	19	345	345	CD
18637	12293	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12293	21	1892	1892	CD
18637	12293	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12293	23	.	.	.
18637	12294	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12294	2	272	272	CD
18637	12294	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12294	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12294	5	.	.	.
18637	12295	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12295	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12295	3	also	also	RB
18637	12295	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12295	5	Muskrat	Muskrat	NNP
18637	12295	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12295	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12295	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12295	9	United	United	NNP
18637	12295	10	States	States	NNP
18637	12295	11	,	,	,
18637	12295	12	219	219	CD
18637	12295	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12295	14	346	346	CD
18637	12295	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12295	16	1911	1911	CD
18637	12295	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12295	18	;	;	:
18637	12295	19	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	12295	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12295	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	12295	22	_	_	NNP
18637	12295	23	Mellon	Mellon	NNP
18637	12295	24	,	,	,
18637	12295	25	262	262	CD
18637	12295	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12295	27	447	447	CD
18637	12295	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12295	29	1923	1923	CD
18637	12295	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12295	31	;	;	:
18637	12295	32	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	12295	33	State	State	NNP
18637	12295	34	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	12295	35	of	of	IN
18637	12295	36	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	12295	37	_	_	NNP
18637	12295	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	12295	39	_	_	NNP
18637	12295	40	McAdory	McAdory	NNP
18637	12295	41	,	,	,
18637	12295	42	325	325	CD
18637	12295	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12295	44	450	450	CD
18637	12295	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12295	46	1945	1945	CD
18637	12295	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12295	48	;	;	:
18637	12295	49	United	United	NNP
18637	12295	50	Public	Public	NNP
18637	12295	51	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	12295	52	of	of	IN
18637	12295	53	America	America	NNP
18637	12295	54	_	_	NNP
18637	12295	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	12295	56	_	_	NNP
18637	12295	57	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	12295	58	,	,	,
18637	12295	59	330	330	CD
18637	12295	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12295	61	75	75	CD
18637	12295	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12295	63	1947	1947	CD
18637	12295	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12295	65	;	;	:
18637	12295	66	Fleming	Fleming	NNP
18637	12295	67	_	_	NNP
18637	12295	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	12295	69	_	_	NNP
18637	12295	70	Rhodes	Rhodes	NNP
18637	12295	71	,	,	,
18637	12295	72	331	331	CD
18637	12295	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12295	74	100	100	CD
18637	12295	75	,	,	,
18637	12295	76	104	104	CD
18637	12295	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12295	78	1947	1947	CD
18637	12295	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12295	80	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12295	81	273	273	CD
18637	12295	82	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12295	83	Rescue	Rescue	NNP
18637	12295	84	Army	Army	NNP
18637	12295	85	_	_	NNP
18637	12295	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	12295	87	_	_	NNP
18637	12295	88	Municipal	Municipal	NNP
18637	12295	89	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12295	90	of	of	IN
18637	12295	91	Los	Los	NNP
18637	12295	92	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	12295	93	,	,	,
18637	12295	94	331	331	CD
18637	12295	95	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12295	96	549	549	CD
18637	12295	97	,	,	,
18637	12295	98	568	568	CD
18637	12295	99	-	-	SYM
18637	12295	100	575	575	CD
18637	12295	101	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12295	102	1947	1947	CD
18637	12295	103	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12295	104	.	.	.
18637	12296	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12296	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12296	3	also	also	RB
18637	12296	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12296	5	Alma	Alma	NNP
18637	12296	6	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	12296	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12296	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12296	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12296	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12296	11	Timken	Timken	NNP
18637	12296	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	12296	13	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	12296	14	Axle	Axle	NNP
18637	12296	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12296	16	,	,	,
18637	12296	17	329	329	CD
18637	12296	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12296	19	129	129	CD
18637	12296	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12296	21	1946	1946	CD
18637	12296	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12296	23	;	;	:
18637	12296	24	Spector	Spector	NNP
18637	12296	25	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	12296	26	Service	Service	NNP
18637	12296	27	_	_	NNP
18637	12296	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	12296	29	_	_	NNP
18637	12296	30	McLaughlin	McLaughlin	NNP
18637	12296	31	,	,	,
18637	12296	32	323	323	CD
18637	12296	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12296	34	101	101	CD
18637	12296	35	,	,	,
18637	12296	36	105	105	CD
18637	12296	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12296	38	1944	1944	CD
18637	12296	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12296	40	;	;	:
18637	12296	41	Coffman	Coffman	NNP
18637	12296	42	_	_	NNP
18637	12296	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	12296	44	_	_	NNP
18637	12296	45	Breeze	Breeze	NNP
18637	12296	46	Corporations	Corporations	NNP
18637	12296	47	,	,	,
18637	12296	48	323	323	CD
18637	12296	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12296	50	316	316	CD
18637	12296	51	,	,	,
18637	12296	52	324	324	CD
18637	12296	53	-	-	SYM
18637	12296	54	325	325	CD
18637	12296	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12296	56	1945	1945	CD
18637	12296	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12296	58	;	;	:
18637	12296	59	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	12296	60	_	_	NNP
18637	12296	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	12296	62	_	_	NNP
18637	12296	63	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	12296	64	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	12296	65	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12296	66	,	,	,
18637	12296	67	298	298	CD
18637	12296	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12296	69	238	238	CD
18637	12296	70	,	,	,
18637	12296	71	325	325	CD
18637	12296	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12296	73	1936	1936	CD
18637	12296	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12296	75	;	;	:
18637	12296	76	Siler	Siler	NNP
18637	12296	77	_	_	NNP
18637	12296	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	12296	79	_	_	NNP
18637	12296	80	L.	L.	NNP
18637	12296	81	&	&	CC
18637	12296	82	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	12297	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12297	2	,	,	,
18637	12297	3	213	213	CD
18637	12297	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12297	5	175	175	CD
18637	12297	6	,	,	,
18637	12297	7	191	191	CD
18637	12297	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12297	9	1909	1909	CD
18637	12297	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12297	11	;	;	:
18637	12297	12	Berea	Berea	NNP
18637	12297	13	College	College	NNP
18637	12297	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12297	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	12297	16	_	_	NNP
18637	12297	17	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	12297	18	,	,	,
18637	12297	19	211	211	CD
18637	12297	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12297	21	45	45	CD
18637	12297	22	,	,	,
18637	12297	23	53	53	CD
18637	12297	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12297	25	1908	1908	CD
18637	12297	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12297	27	;	;	:
18637	12297	28	and	and	CC
18637	12297	29	the	the	DT
18637	12297	30	cases	case	NNS
18637	12297	31	cited	cite	VBN
18637	12297	32	in	in	IN
18637	12297	33	the	the	DT
18637	12297	34	notes	note	NNS
18637	12297	35	to	to	IN
18637	12297	36	the	the	DT
18637	12297	37	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	12297	38	paragraph	paragraph	NN
18637	12297	39	.	.	.
18637	12298	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12298	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	12298	3	's	's	POS
18637	12298	4	Note	note	NN
18637	12298	5	:	:	:
18637	12298	6	Reference	reference	NN
18637	12298	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	12298	8	to	to	IN
18637	12298	9	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	12298	10	272	272	CD
18637	12298	11	,	,	,
18637	12298	12	above	above	RB
18637	12298	13	.	.	.
18637	12298	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12299	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12299	2	274	274	CD
18637	12299	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12299	4	331	331	CD
18637	12299	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12299	6	549	549	CD
18637	12299	7	,	,	,
18637	12299	8	571	571	CD
18637	12299	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12299	10	1947	1947	CD
18637	12299	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12299	12	.	.	.
18637	12300	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12300	2	275	275	CD
18637	12300	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12300	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12300	5	See	See	NNP
18637	12300	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12300	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	12300	8	.	.	.
18637	12301	1	546	546	CD
18637	12301	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12301	3	548	548	CD
18637	12301	4	.	.	.
18637	12302	1	For	for	IN
18637	12302	2	the	the	DT
18637	12302	3	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	12302	4	between	between	IN
18637	12302	5	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	12302	6	and	and	CC
18637	12302	7	precautionary	precautionary	JJ
18637	12302	8	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	12302	9	to	to	IN
18637	12302	10	the	the	DT
18637	12302	11	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	12302	12	of	of	IN
18637	12302	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12302	14	review	review	NN
18637	12302	15	and	and	CC
18637	12302	16	the	the	DT
18637	12302	17	operation	operation	NN
18637	12302	18	of	of	IN
18637	12302	19	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12302	20	review	review	NN
18637	12302	21	within	within	IN
18637	12302	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12302	23	,	,	,
18637	12302	24	_	_	NNP
18637	12302	25	see	see	VBP
18637	12302	26	_	_	NNP
18637	12302	27	Edward	Edward	NNP
18637	12302	28	S.	S.	NNP
18637	12302	29	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	12302	30	,	,	,
18637	12302	31	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	12302	32	Review	Review	NNP
18637	12302	33	in	in	IN
18637	12302	34	Action	Action	NNP
18637	12302	35	,	,	,
18637	12302	36	74	74	CD
18637	12302	37	Univ	Univ	NNS
18637	12302	38	.	.	.
18637	12303	1	of	of	IN
18637	12303	2	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	12303	3	L.	L.	NNP
18637	12303	4	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	12304	1	639	639	CD
18637	12304	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12304	3	1926	1926	CD
18637	12304	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12304	5	.	.	.
18637	12305	1	For	for	IN
18637	12305	2	the	the	DT
18637	12305	3	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	12305	4	generally	generally	RB
18637	12305	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12305	6	see	see	VBP
18637	12305	7	also	also	RB
18637	12305	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12305	9	the	the	DT
18637	12305	10	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	12305	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	12305	12	of	of	IN
18637	12305	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12305	14	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	12305	15	in	in	IN
18637	12305	16	Ashwander	Ashwander	NNP
18637	12305	17	_	_	NNP
18637	12305	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	12305	19	_	_	NNP
18637	12305	20	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	12305	21	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	12305	22	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	12305	23	,	,	,
18637	12305	24	297	297	CD
18637	12305	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12305	26	288	288	CD
18637	12305	27	,	,	,
18637	12305	28	346	346	CD
18637	12305	29	-	-	SYM
18637	12305	30	356	356	CD
18637	12305	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12305	32	1936	1936	CD
18637	12305	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12305	34	,	,	,
18637	12305	35	and	and	CC
18637	12305	36	the	the	DT
18637	12305	37	cases	case	NNS
18637	12305	38	cited	cite	VBN
18637	12305	39	therein	therein	RB
18637	12305	40	.	.	.
18637	12306	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12306	2	276	276	CD
18637	12306	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12306	4	One	one	CD
18637	12306	5	of	of	IN
18637	12306	6	the	the	DT
18637	12306	7	earliest	early	JJS
18637	12306	8	formulations	formulation	NNS
18637	12306	9	of	of	IN
18637	12306	10	this	this	DT
18637	12306	11	rule	rule	NN
18637	12306	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	12306	13	that	that	IN
18637	12306	14	by	by	IN
18637	12306	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12306	16	Iredell	Iredell	NNP
18637	12306	17	in	in	IN
18637	12306	18	Calder	Calder	NNP
18637	12306	19	_	_	NNP
18637	12306	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	12306	21	_	_	NNP
18637	12306	22	Bull	Bull	NNP
18637	12306	23	,	,	,
18637	12306	24	3	3	CD
18637	12306	25	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12306	26	.	.	.
18637	12307	1	386	386	CD
18637	12307	2	,	,	,
18637	12307	3	399	399	CD
18637	12307	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12307	5	1798	1798	CD
18637	12307	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12307	7	,	,	,
18637	12307	8	and	and	CC
18637	12307	9	by	by	IN
18637	12307	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12307	11	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	12307	12	in	in	IN
18637	12307	13	the	the	DT
18637	12307	14	same	same	JJ
18637	12307	15	case	case	NN
18637	12307	16	,	,	,
18637	12307	17	p.	p.	NN
18637	12307	18	394	394	CD
18637	12307	19	.	.	.
18637	12308	1	On	on	IN
18637	12308	2	the	the	DT
18637	12308	3	other	other	JJ
18637	12308	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	12308	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12308	6	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	12308	7	in	in	IN
18637	12308	8	this	this	DT
18637	12308	9	same	same	JJ
18637	12308	10	case	case	NN
18637	12308	11	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	12308	12	that	that	IN
18637	12308	13	there	there	EX
18637	12308	14	were	be	VBD
18637	12308	15	certain	certain	JJ
18637	12308	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	12308	17	which	which	WDT
18637	12308	18	"	"	``
18637	12308	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12308	20	can	can	MD
18637	12308	21	not	not	RB
18637	12308	22	be	be	VB
18637	12308	23	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	12308	24	"	"	``
18637	12308	25	have	have	VBP
18637	12308	26	been	be	VBN
18637	12308	27	entrusted	entrust	VBN
18637	12308	28	to	to	IN
18637	12308	29	the	the	DT
18637	12308	30	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	12308	31	.	.	.
18637	12309	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12309	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12309	3	also	also	RB
18637	12309	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12309	5	Sinking	Sinking	NNP
18637	12309	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	12309	7	Fund	Fund	NNP
18637	12309	8	Cases	case	NNS
18637	12309	9	,	,	,
18637	12309	10	99	99	CD
18637	12309	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12309	12	700	700	CD
18637	12309	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12309	14	1879	1879	CD
18637	12309	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12309	16	.	.	.
18637	12310	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12310	2	277	277	CD
18637	12310	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12310	4	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	12310	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12310	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12310	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12310	8	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
18637	12310	9	,	,	,
18637	12310	10	12	12	CD
18637	12310	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12310	12	.	.	.
18637	12311	1	213	213	CD
18637	12311	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12311	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	12311	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12311	5	;	;	:
18637	12311	6	Providence	Providence	NNP
18637	12311	7	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	12311	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12311	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12311	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12311	11	Billings	Billings	NNP
18637	12311	12	,	,	,
18637	12311	13	4	4	CD
18637	12311	14	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12311	15	.	.	.
18637	12312	1	514	514	CD
18637	12312	2	,	,	,
18637	12312	3	549	549	CD
18637	12312	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12312	5	1830	1830	CD
18637	12312	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12312	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12312	8	argument	argument	NN
18637	12312	9	of	of	IN
18637	12312	10	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	12312	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12312	12	;	;	:
18637	12312	13	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	12312	14	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	12312	15	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	12312	16	,	,	,
18637	12312	17	12	12	CD
18637	12312	18	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12312	19	.	.	.
18637	12313	1	457	457	CD
18637	12313	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12313	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	12313	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12313	5	;	;	:
18637	12313	6	Madden	Madden	NNP
18637	12313	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12313	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12313	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12313	10	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	12313	11	,	,	,
18637	12313	12	309	309	CD
18637	12313	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12313	14	83	83	CD
18637	12313	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12313	16	1940	1940	CD
18637	12313	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12313	18	;	;	:
18637	12313	19	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	12313	20	State	State	NNP
18637	12313	21	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	12313	22	of	of	IN
18637	12313	23	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	12313	24	_	_	NNP
18637	12313	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	12313	26	_	_	NNP
18637	12313	27	McAdory	McAdory	NNP
18637	12313	28	,	,	,
18637	12313	29	325	325	CD
18637	12313	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12313	31	450	450	CD
18637	12313	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12313	33	1945	1945	CD
18637	12313	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12313	35	.	.	.
18637	12314	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12314	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12314	3	also	also	RB
18637	12314	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12314	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12314	6	Moody	Moody	NNP
18637	12314	7	's	's	POS
18637	12314	8	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	12314	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	12314	10	in	in	IN
18637	12314	11	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	12314	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12314	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	12314	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12314	15	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	12314	16	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	12315	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12315	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12315	3	The	the	DT
18637	12315	4	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	12315	5	'	'	POS
18637	12315	6	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	12315	7	Cases	case	NNS
18637	12315	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12315	9	,	,	,
18637	12315	10	207	207	CD
18637	12315	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12315	12	463	463	CD
18637	12315	13	,	,	,
18637	12315	14	509	509	CD
18637	12315	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	12315	16	511	511	CD
18637	12315	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12315	18	1908	1908	CD
18637	12315	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12315	20	.	.	.
18637	12316	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12316	2	278	278	CD
18637	12316	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12316	4	Adkins	Adkins	NNPS
18637	12316	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12316	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12316	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12316	8	Children	Children	NNP
18637	12316	9	's	's	POS
18637	12316	10	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	12316	11	,	,	,
18637	12316	12	261	261	CD
18637	12316	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12316	14	525	525	CD
18637	12316	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12316	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	12316	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12316	18	.	.	.
18637	12317	1	"	"	``
18637	12317	2	But	but	CC
18637	12317	3	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	12317	4	of	of	IN
18637	12317	5	contract	contract	NN
18637	12317	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	12317	7	,	,	,
18637	12317	8	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	12317	9	,	,	,
18637	12317	10	the	the	DT
18637	12317	11	general	general	JJ
18637	12317	12	rule	rule	NN
18637	12317	13	and	and	CC
18637	12317	14	restraint	restraint	VB
18637	12317	15	the	the	DT
18637	12317	16	exception	exception	NN
18637	12317	17	;	;	,
18637	12317	18	and	and	CC
18637	12317	19	the	the	DT
18637	12317	20	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	12317	21	of	of	IN
18637	12317	22	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	12317	23	authority	authority	NN
18637	12317	24	to	to	TO
18637	12317	25	abridge	abridge	VB
18637	12317	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12317	27	can	can	MD
18637	12317	28	be	be	VB
18637	12317	29	justified	justify	VBN
18637	12317	30	only	only	RB
18637	12317	31	by	by	IN
18637	12317	32	the	the	DT
18637	12317	33	existence	existence	NN
18637	12317	34	of	of	IN
18637	12317	35	exceptional	exceptional	JJ
18637	12317	36	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	12317	37	.	.	.
18637	12317	38	"	"	''
18637	12318	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	12318	2	.	.	.
18637	12319	1	546	546	CD
18637	12319	2	.	.	.
18637	12320	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12320	2	279	279	CD
18637	12320	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12320	4	Kovacs	Kovacs	NNP
18637	12320	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12320	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12320	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12320	8	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	12320	9	,	,	,
18637	12320	10	336	336	CD
18637	12320	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12320	12	77	77	CD
18637	12320	13	,	,	,
18637	12320	14	88	88	CD
18637	12320	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12320	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	12320	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12320	18	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	12320	19	of	of	IN
18637	12320	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12320	21	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	12320	22	.	.	.
18637	12321	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12321	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12321	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12321	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12321	5	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	12321	6	's	's	POS
18637	12321	7	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	12321	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	12321	9	for	for	IN
18637	12321	10	a	a	DT
18637	12321	11	criticism	criticism	NN
18637	12321	12	of	of	IN
18637	12321	13	this	this	DT
18637	12321	14	rule	rule	NN
18637	12321	15	.	.	.
18637	12322	1	For	for	IN
18637	12322	2	other	other	JJ
18637	12322	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	12322	4	imputing	impute	VBG
18637	12322	5	to	to	IN
18637	12322	6	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	12322	7	of	of	IN
18637	12322	8	religion	religion	NN
18637	12322	9	and	and	CC
18637	12322	10	the	the	DT
18637	12322	11	press	press	NN
18637	12322	12	a	a	DT
18637	12322	13	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	12322	14	position	position	NN
18637	12322	15	so	so	IN
18637	12322	16	as	as	IN
18637	12322	17	to	to	TO
18637	12322	18	reverse	reverse	VB
18637	12322	19	the	the	DT
18637	12322	20	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	12322	21	of	of	IN
18637	12322	22	validity	validity	NN
18637	12322	23	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	24	see	see	UH
18637	12322	25	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	26	Herndon	Herndon	NNP
18637	12322	27	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	12322	29	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	30	Lowry	Lowry	NNP
18637	12322	31	,	,	,
18637	12322	32	301	301	CD
18637	12322	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12322	34	242	242	CD
18637	12322	35	,	,	,
18637	12322	36	258	258	CD
18637	12322	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12322	38	1937	1937	CD
18637	12322	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12322	40	;	;	:
18637	12322	41	United	United	NNP
18637	12322	42	States	States	NNP
18637	12322	43	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	12322	45	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	46	Carolene	Carolene	NNP
18637	12322	47	Products	Products	NNP
18637	12322	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12322	49	,	,	,
18637	12322	50	304	304	CD
18637	12322	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12322	52	144	144	CD
18637	12322	53	,	,	,
18637	12322	54	152	152	CD
18637	12322	55	,	,	,
18637	12322	56	n.	n.	NNP
18637	12322	57	4	4	CD
18637	12322	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12322	59	1938	1938	CD
18637	12322	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12322	61	;	;	:
18637	12322	62	Thornhill	Thornhill	NNP
18637	12322	63	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	12322	65	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	66	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	12322	67	,	,	,
18637	12322	68	310	310	CD
18637	12322	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12322	70	88	88	CD
18637	12322	71	,	,	,
18637	12322	72	95	95	CD
18637	12322	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12322	74	1940	1940	CD
18637	12322	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12322	76	;	;	:
18637	12322	77	Schneider	Schneider	NNP
18637	12322	78	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	12322	80	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	81	State	State	NNP
18637	12322	82	,	,	,
18637	12322	83	308	308	CD
18637	12322	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12322	85	147	147	CD
18637	12322	86	,	,	,
18637	12322	87	161	161	CD
18637	12322	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12322	89	1939	1939	CD
18637	12322	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12322	91	;	;	:
18637	12322	92	Bridges	Bridges	NNP
18637	12322	93	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	94	v.	v.	IN
18637	12322	95	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	96	California	California	NNP
18637	12322	97	,	,	,
18637	12322	98	314	314	CD
18637	12322	99	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12322	100	252	252	CD
18637	12322	101	,	,	,
18637	12322	102	262	262	CD
18637	12322	103	-	-	SYM
18637	12322	104	263	263	CD
18637	12322	105	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12322	106	1941	1941	CD
18637	12322	107	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12322	108	;	;	:
18637	12322	109	Murdock	Murdock	NNP
18637	12322	110	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	111	v.	v.	IN
18637	12322	112	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	113	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	12322	114	,	,	,
18637	12322	115	319	319	CD
18637	12322	116	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12322	117	105	105	CD
18637	12322	118	,	,	,
18637	12322	119	115	115	CD
18637	12322	120	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12322	121	1943	1943	CD
18637	12322	122	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12322	123	;	;	:
18637	12322	124	Prince	Prince	NNP
18637	12322	125	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	126	v.	v.	IN
18637	12322	127	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	128	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	12322	129	,	,	,
18637	12322	130	321	321	CD
18637	12322	131	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12322	132	158	158	CD
18637	12322	133	,	,	,
18637	12322	134	164	164	CD
18637	12322	135	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12322	136	1944	1944	CD
18637	12322	137	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12322	138	;	;	:
18637	12322	139	Follett	Follett	NNP
18637	12322	140	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	141	v.	v.	IN
18637	12322	142	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	143	McCormick	McCormick	NNP
18637	12322	144	,	,	,
18637	12322	145	321	321	CD
18637	12322	146	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12322	147	573	573	CD
18637	12322	148	,	,	,
18637	12322	149	575	575	CD
18637	12322	150	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12322	151	1944	1944	CD
18637	12322	152	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12322	153	;	;	:
18637	12322	154	Marsh	Marsh	NNP
18637	12322	155	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	156	v.	v.	IN
18637	12322	157	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	158	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	12322	159	,	,	,
18637	12322	160	326	326	CD
18637	12322	161	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12322	162	501	501	CD
18637	12322	163	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12322	164	1946	1946	CD
18637	12322	165	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12322	166	;	;	:
18637	12322	167	Board	Board	NNP
18637	12322	168	of	of	IN
18637	12322	169	Education	Education	NNP
18637	12322	170	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	171	v.	v.	IN
18637	12322	172	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	173	Barnette	Barnette	NNP
18637	12322	174	,	,	,
18637	12322	175	319	319	CD
18637	12322	176	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12322	177	624	624	CD
18637	12322	178	,	,	,
18637	12322	179	639	639	CD
18637	12322	180	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12322	181	1943	1943	CD
18637	12322	182	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12322	183	;	;	:
18637	12322	184	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	12322	185	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	186	v.	v.	IN
18637	12322	187	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	188	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	12322	189	,	,	,
18637	12322	190	323	323	CD
18637	12322	191	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12322	192	516	516	CD
18637	12322	193	,	,	,
18637	12322	194	530	530	CD
18637	12322	195	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12322	196	1945	1945	CD
18637	12322	197	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12322	198	;	;	:
18637	12322	199	Saia	Saia	NNP
18637	12322	200	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	201	v.	v.	IN
18637	12322	202	_	_	NNP
18637	12322	203	New	New	NNP
18637	12322	204	York	York	NNP
18637	12322	205	,	,	,
18637	12322	206	334	334	CD
18637	12322	207	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12322	208	558	558	CD
18637	12322	209	,	,	,
18637	12322	210	562	562	CD
18637	12322	211	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12322	212	1948	1948	CD
18637	12322	213	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12322	214	.	.	.
18637	12323	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12323	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	12323	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	12323	4	criticized	criticize	VBN
18637	12323	5	the	the	DT
18637	12323	6	concept	concept	NN
18637	12323	7	of	of	IN
18637	12323	8	"	"	``
18637	12323	9	the	the	DT
18637	12323	10	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	12323	11	position	position	NN
18637	12323	12	"	"	''
18637	12323	13	of	of	IN
18637	12323	14	these	these	DT
18637	12323	15	rights	right	NNS
18637	12323	16	as	as	IN
18637	12323	17	a	a	DT
18637	12323	18	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	12323	19	that	that	WDT
18637	12323	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	12323	21	"	"	``
18637	12323	22	uncritically	uncritically	RB
18637	12323	23	crept	creep	VBN
18637	12323	24	into	into	IN
18637	12323	25	some	some	DT
18637	12323	26	recent	recent	JJ
18637	12323	27	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	12323	28	"	"	''
18637	12323	29	of	of	IN
18637	12323	30	the	the	DT
18637	12323	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12323	32	,	,	,
18637	12323	33	Kovacs	Kovacs	NNP
18637	12323	34	_	_	NNP
18637	12323	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	12323	36	_	_	NNP
18637	12323	37	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	12323	38	,	,	,
18637	12323	39	336	336	CD
18637	12323	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12323	41	77	77	CD
18637	12323	42	,	,	,
18637	12323	43	90	90	CD
18637	12323	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12323	45	1949	1949	CD
18637	12323	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12323	47	;	;	:
18637	12323	48	and	and	CC
18637	12323	49	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12323	50	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	12323	51	in	in	IN
18637	12323	52	a	a	DT
18637	12323	53	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	12323	54	has	have	VBZ
18637	12323	55	also	also	RB
18637	12323	56	opposed	oppose	VBN
18637	12323	57	the	the	DT
18637	12323	58	idea	idea	NN
18637	12323	59	that	that	IN
18637	12323	60	some	some	DT
18637	12323	61	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	12323	62	rights	right	NNS
18637	12323	63	have	have	VBP
18637	12323	64	a	a	DT
18637	12323	65	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	12323	66	position	position	NN
18637	12323	67	.	.	.
18637	12324	1	Brinegar	Brinegar	NNP
18637	12324	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12324	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12324	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12324	5	United	United	NNP
18637	12324	6	States	States	NNP
18637	12324	7	,	,	,
18637	12324	8	338	338	CD
18637	12324	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12324	10	160	160	CD
18637	12324	11	,	,	,
18637	12324	12	180	180	CD
18637	12324	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12324	14	1949	1949	CD
18637	12324	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12324	16	.	.	.
18637	12325	1	"	"	``
18637	12325	2	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12325	3	can	can	MD
18637	12325	4	not	not	RB
18637	12325	5	,	,	,
18637	12325	6	"	"	''
18637	12325	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12325	8	said	say	VBD
18637	12325	9	,	,	,
18637	12325	10	"	"	``
18637	12325	11	give	give	VB
18637	12325	12	some	some	DT
18637	12325	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	12325	14	rights	right	NNS
18637	12325	15	a	a	DT
18637	12325	16	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	12325	17	position	position	NN
18637	12325	18	without	without	IN
18637	12325	19	relegating	relegate	VBG
18637	12325	20	others	other	NNS
18637	12325	21	to	to	IN
18637	12325	22	a	a	DT
18637	12325	23	deferred	deferred	JJ
18637	12325	24	position	position	NN
18637	12325	25	;	;	:
18637	12325	26	*	*	NFP
18637	12325	27	*	*	NFP
18637	12325	28	*	*	NFP
18637	12325	29	"	"	''
18637	12325	30	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12325	31	280	280	CD
18637	12325	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12325	33	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	12325	34	_	_	NNP
18637	12325	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	12325	36	_	_	NNP
18637	12325	37	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	12325	38	,	,	,
18637	12325	39	313	313	CD
18637	12325	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12325	41	387	387	CD
18637	12325	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12325	43	1941	1941	CD
18637	12325	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12325	45	;	;	:
18637	12325	46	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12325	47	Iredell	Iredell	NNP
18637	12325	48	's	's	POS
18637	12325	49	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	12325	50	in	in	IN
18637	12325	51	Calder	Calder	NNP
18637	12325	52	_	_	NNP
18637	12325	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	12325	54	_	_	NNP
18637	12325	55	Bull	Bull	NNP
18637	12325	56	,	,	,
18637	12325	57	3	3	CD
18637	12325	58	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12325	59	.	.	.
18637	12326	1	386	386	CD
18637	12326	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12326	3	1798	1798	CD
18637	12326	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12326	5	;	;	:
18637	12326	6	Jacobson	Jacobson	NNP
18637	12326	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12326	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12326	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12326	10	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	12326	11	,	,	,
18637	12326	12	197	197	CD
18637	12326	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12326	14	11	11	CD
18637	12326	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12326	16	1905	1905	CD
18637	12326	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12326	18	.	.	.
18637	12327	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12327	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12327	3	also	also	RB
18637	12327	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12327	5	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
18637	12327	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12327	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12327	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12327	9	Beneficial	Beneficial	NNP
18637	12327	10	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	12327	11	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	12327	12	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	12327	13	,	,	,
18637	12327	14	337	337	CD
18637	12327	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12327	16	541	541	CD
18637	12327	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12327	18	1949	1949	CD
18637	12327	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12327	20	;	;	:
18637	12327	21	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	12327	22	_	_	NNP
18637	12327	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	12327	24	_	_	NNP
18637	12327	25	Family	Family	NNP
18637	12327	26	Security	Security	NNP
18637	12327	27	Life	Life	NNP
18637	12327	28	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	12327	29	.	.	.
18637	12328	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12328	2	,	,	,
18637	12328	3	336	336	CD
18637	12328	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12328	5	220	220	CD
18637	12328	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12328	7	1949	1949	CD
18637	12328	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12328	9	;	;	:
18637	12328	10	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	12328	11	Express	Express	NNP
18637	12328	12	Agency	Agency	NNP
18637	12328	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12328	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	12328	15	_	_	NNP
18637	12328	16	New	New	NNP
18637	12328	17	York	York	NNP
18637	12328	18	,	,	,
18637	12328	19	336	336	CD
18637	12328	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12328	21	106	106	CD
18637	12328	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12328	23	1949	1949	CD
18637	12328	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12328	25	;	;	:
18637	12328	26	Wickard	Wickard	NNP
18637	12328	27	_	_	NNP
18637	12328	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	12328	29	_	_	NNP
18637	12328	30	Filburn	Filburn	NNP
18637	12328	31	,	,	,
18637	12328	32	317	317	CD
18637	12328	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12328	34	111	111	CD
18637	12328	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12328	36	1942	1942	CD
18637	12328	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12328	38	;	;	:
18637	12328	39	United	United	NNP
18637	12328	40	States	States	NNP
18637	12328	41	_	_	NNP
18637	12328	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	12328	43	_	_	NNP
18637	12328	44	Petrillo	Petrillo	NNP
18637	12328	45	,	,	,
18637	12328	46	332	332	CD
18637	12328	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12328	48	1	1	CD
18637	12328	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12328	50	1947	1947	CD
18637	12328	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12328	52	;	;	:
18637	12328	53	American	American	NNP
18637	12328	54	Power	Power	NNP
18637	12328	55	&	&	CC
18637	12328	56	Light	Light	NNP
18637	12328	57	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12328	58	_	_	NNP
18637	12328	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	12328	60	_	_	NNP
18637	12328	61	Securities	Securities	NNP
18637	12328	62	&	&	CC
18637	12328	63	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	12328	64	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	12328	65	,	,	,
18637	12328	66	329	329	CD
18637	12328	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12328	68	90	90	CD
18637	12328	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12328	70	1946	1946	CD
18637	12328	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12328	72	;	;	:
18637	12328	73	Sunshine	Sunshine	NNP
18637	12328	74	Anthracite	Anthracite	NNP
18637	12328	75	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	12328	76	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12328	77	_	_	NNP
18637	12328	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	12328	79	_	_	NNP
18637	12328	80	Adkins	Adkins	NNP
18637	12328	81	,	,	,
18637	12328	82	310	310	CD
18637	12328	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12328	84	381	381	CD
18637	12328	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12328	86	1940	1940	CD
18637	12328	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12328	88	.	.	.
18637	12329	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12329	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12329	3	also	also	RB
18637	12329	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12329	5	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	12329	6	Retirement	Retirement	NNP
18637	12329	7	Board	Board	NNP
18637	12329	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12329	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12329	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12329	11	Alton	Alton	NNP
18637	12329	12	R.	R.	NNP
18637	12329	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12329	14	,	,	,
18637	12329	15	295	295	CD
18637	12329	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12329	17	330	330	CD
18637	12329	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12329	19	1935	1935	CD
18637	12329	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12329	21	;	;	:
18637	12329	22	Home	Home	NNP
18637	12329	23	Bldg	Bldg	NNP
18637	12329	24	.	.	.
18637	12330	1	&	&	CC
18637	12330	2	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	12330	3	Assoc	Assoc	NNP
18637	12330	4	.	.	.
18637	12331	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12331	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	12331	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12331	4	Blaisdell	Blaisdell	NNP
18637	12331	5	,	,	,
18637	12331	6	290	290	CD
18637	12331	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12331	8	398	398	CD
18637	12331	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12331	10	1934	1934	CD
18637	12331	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12331	12	;	;	:
18637	12331	13	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	12331	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12331	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	12331	16	_	_	NNP
18637	12331	17	California	California	NNP
18637	12331	18	,	,	,
18637	12331	19	283	283	CD
18637	12331	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12331	21	423	423	CD
18637	12331	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12331	23	1931	1931	CD
18637	12331	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12331	25	;	;	:
18637	12331	26	McCray	McCray	NNP
18637	12331	27	_	_	NNP
18637	12331	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	12331	29	_	_	NNP
18637	12331	30	United	United	NNP
18637	12331	31	States	States	NNP
18637	12331	32	,	,	,
18637	12331	33	195	195	CD
18637	12331	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12331	35	27	27	CD
18637	12331	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12331	37	1904	1904	CD
18637	12331	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12331	39	;	;	:
18637	12331	40	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	12331	41	_	_	NNP
18637	12331	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	12331	43	_	_	NNP
18637	12331	44	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	12331	45	Distilleries	Distilleries	NNP
18637	12331	46	&	&	CC
18637	12331	47	W.	W.	NNP
18637	12331	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12331	49	,	,	,
18637	12331	50	251	251	CD
18637	12331	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12331	52	146	146	CD
18637	12331	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12331	54	1919	1919	CD
18637	12331	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12331	56	.	.	.
18637	12332	1	Compare	compare	VB
18637	12332	2	,	,	,
18637	12332	3	however	however	RB
18637	12332	4	,	,	,
18637	12332	5	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	12332	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12332	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12332	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12332	9	Drexel	Drexel	NNP
18637	12332	10	Furniture	Furniture	NNP
18637	12332	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12332	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12332	13	Child	Child	NNP
18637	12332	14	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	12332	15	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	12332	16	Case	Case	NNP
18637	12332	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12332	18	,	,	,
18637	12332	19	259	259	CD
18637	12332	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12332	21	20	20	CD
18637	12332	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12332	23	1922	1922	CD
18637	12332	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12332	25	,	,	,
18637	12332	26	where	where	WRB
18637	12332	27	the	the	DT
18637	12332	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12332	29	considered	consider	VBD
18637	12332	30	the	the	DT
18637	12332	31	motives	motive	NNS
18637	12332	32	of	of	IN
18637	12332	33	the	the	DT
18637	12332	34	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	12332	35	.	.	.
18637	12333	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12333	2	281	281	CD
18637	12333	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12333	4	198	198	CD
18637	12333	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12333	6	45	45	CD
18637	12333	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12333	8	1905	1905	CD
18637	12333	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12333	10	.	.	.
18637	12334	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12334	2	282	282	CD
18637	12334	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12334	4	297	297	CD
18637	12334	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12334	6	1	1	CD
18637	12334	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12334	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	12334	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12334	10	.	.	.
18637	12335	1	The	the	DT
18637	12335	2	majority	majority	NN
18637	12335	3	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	12335	4	evoked	evoke	VBD
18637	12335	5	a	a	DT
18637	12335	6	protest	protest	NN
18637	12335	7	from	from	IN
18637	12335	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12335	9	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	12335	10	who	who	WP
18637	12335	11	said	say	VBD
18637	12335	12	in	in	IN
18637	12335	13	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	12335	14	:	:	:
18637	12335	15	"	"	``
18637	12335	16	The	the	DT
18637	12335	17	power	power	NN
18637	12335	18	of	of	IN
18637	12335	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	12335	20	to	to	TO
18637	12335	21	declare	declare	VB
18637	12335	22	...	...	:
18637	12335	23	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12335	24	an	an	DT
18637	12335	25	act	act	NN
18637	12335	26	of	of	IN
18637	12335	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12335	28	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	12335	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12335	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	12335	31	subject	subject	JJ
18637	12335	32	to	to	IN
18637	12335	33	two	two	CD
18637	12335	34	guiding	guide	VBG
18637	12335	35	principles	principle	NNS
18637	12335	36	of	of	IN
18637	12335	37	decision	decision	NN
18637	12335	38	which	which	WDT
18637	12335	39	ought	ought	MD
18637	12335	40	never	never	RB
18637	12335	41	to	to	TO
18637	12335	42	be	be	VB
18637	12335	43	absent	absent	JJ
18637	12335	44	from	from	IN
18637	12335	45	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12335	46	consciousness	consciousness	NN
18637	12335	47	.	.	.
18637	12336	1	One	one	CD
18637	12336	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	12336	3	that	that	IN
18637	12336	4	courts	court	NNS
18637	12336	5	are	be	VBP
18637	12336	6	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	12336	7	only	only	RB
18637	12336	8	with	with	IN
18637	12336	9	the	the	DT
18637	12336	10	power	power	NN
18637	12336	11	to	to	TO
18637	12336	12	enact	enact	VB
18637	12336	13	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	12336	14	,	,	,
18637	12336	15	not	not	RB
18637	12336	16	with	with	IN
18637	12336	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12336	18	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	12336	19	.	.	.
18637	12337	1	The	the	DT
18637	12337	2	other	other	JJ
18637	12337	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	12337	4	that	that	IN
18637	12337	5	while	while	IN
18637	12337	6	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	12337	7	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	12337	8	of	of	IN
18637	12337	9	power	power	NN
18637	12337	10	by	by	IN
18637	12337	11	the	the	DT
18637	12337	12	executive	executive	JJ
18637	12337	13	and	and	CC
18637	12337	14	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	12337	15	branches	branch	NNS
18637	12337	16	of	of	IN
18637	12337	17	the	the	DT
18637	12337	18	government	government	NN
18637	12337	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	12337	20	subject	subject	JJ
18637	12337	21	to	to	IN
18637	12337	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12337	23	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	12337	24	,	,	,
18637	12337	25	the	the	DT
18637	12337	26	only	only	JJ
18637	12337	27	check	check	NN
18637	12337	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	12337	29	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12337	30	own	own	JJ
18637	12337	31	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	12337	32	of	of	IN
18637	12337	33	power	power	NN
18637	12337	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	12337	35	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12337	36	own	own	JJ
18637	12337	37	sense	sense	NN
18637	12337	38	of	of	IN
18637	12337	39	self	self	NN
18637	12337	40	-	-	HYPH
18637	12337	41	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	12337	42	.	.	.
18637	12338	1	For	for	IN
18637	12338	2	the	the	DT
18637	12338	3	removal	removal	NN
18637	12338	4	of	of	IN
18637	12338	5	unwise	unwise	JJ
18637	12338	6	laws	law	NNS
18637	12338	7	from	from	IN
18637	12338	8	the	the	DT
18637	12338	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	12338	10	books	book	NNS
18637	12338	11	appeal	appeal	VBP
18637	12338	12	lies	lie	VBZ
18637	12338	13	not	not	RB
18637	12338	14	to	to	IN
18637	12338	15	the	the	DT
18637	12338	16	courts	court	NNS
18637	12338	17	but	but	CC
18637	12338	18	to	to	IN
18637	12338	19	the	the	DT
18637	12338	20	ballot	ballot	NN
18637	12338	21	and	and	CC
18637	12338	22	to	to	IN
18637	12338	23	the	the	DT
18637	12338	24	processes	process	NNS
18637	12338	25	of	of	IN
18637	12338	26	democratic	democratic	JJ
18637	12338	27	government	government	NN
18637	12338	28	.	.	.
18637	12338	29	"	"	''
18637	12339	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	12339	2	.	.	.
18637	12340	1	78	78	CD
18637	12340	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12340	3	79	79	CD
18637	12340	4	.	.	.
18637	12341	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12341	2	283	283	CD
18637	12341	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12341	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12341	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12341	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12341	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12341	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12341	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12341	10	of	of	IN
18637	12341	11	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	12341	12	Organizations	Organizations	NNP
18637	12341	13	,	,	,
18637	12341	14	335	335	CD
18637	12341	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12341	16	106	106	CD
18637	12341	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12341	18	1948	1948	CD
18637	12341	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12341	20	;	;	:
18637	12341	21	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	12341	22	_	_	NNP
18637	12341	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	12341	24	_	_	NNP
18637	12341	25	United	United	NNP
18637	12341	26	States	States	NNP
18637	12341	27	,	,	,
18637	12341	28	11	11	CD
18637	12341	29	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12341	30	.	.	.
18637	12342	1	268	268	CD
18637	12342	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12342	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	12342	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12342	5	.	.	.
18637	12343	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12343	2	284	284	CD
18637	12343	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12343	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12343	5	See	See	NNP
18637	12343	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12343	7	,	,	,
18637	12343	8	for	for	IN
18637	12343	9	example	example	NN
18637	12343	10	,	,	,
18637	12343	11	Michaelson	Michaelson	NNP
18637	12343	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12343	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	12343	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12343	15	United	United	NNP
18637	12343	16	States	States	NNP
18637	12343	17	,	,	,
18637	12343	18	266	266	CD
18637	12343	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12343	20	42	42	CD
18637	12343	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12343	22	1924	1924	CD
18637	12343	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12343	24	,	,	,
18637	12343	25	where	where	WRB
18637	12343	26	the	the	DT
18637	12343	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12343	28	narrowly	narrowly	RB
18637	12343	29	construed	construe	VBD
18637	12343	30	those	those	DT
18637	12343	31	sections	section	NNS
18637	12343	32	of	of	IN
18637	12343	33	the	the	DT
18637	12343	34	Clayton	Clayton	NNP
18637	12343	35	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12343	36	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	12343	37	the	the	DT
18637	12343	38	power	power	NN
18637	12343	39	of	of	IN
18637	12343	40	courts	court	NNS
18637	12343	41	to	to	TO
18637	12343	42	punish	punish	VB
18637	12343	43	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	12343	44	in	in	IN
18637	12343	45	order	order	NN
18637	12343	46	to	to	TO
18637	12343	47	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	12343	48	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	12343	49	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	12343	50	.	.	.
18637	12344	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12344	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12344	3	also	also	RB
18637	12344	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12344	5	United	United	NNP
18637	12344	6	States	States	NNP
18637	12344	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12344	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12344	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12344	10	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	12344	11	&	&	CC
18637	12344	12	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	12345	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12345	2	,	,	,
18637	12345	3	213	213	CD
18637	12345	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12345	5	366	366	CD
18637	12345	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12345	7	1909	1909	CD
18637	12345	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12345	9	,	,	,
18637	12345	10	where	where	WRB
18637	12345	11	the	the	DT
18637	12345	12	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	12345	13	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12345	14	was	be	VBD
18637	12345	15	narrowly	narrowly	RB
18637	12345	16	construed	construe	VBN
18637	12345	17	.	.	.
18637	12346	1	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12346	2	disallowance	disallowance	NN
18637	12346	3	in	in	IN
18637	12346	4	the	the	DT
18637	12346	5	guise	guise	NN
18637	12346	6	of	of	IN
18637	12346	7	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	12346	8	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	12346	9	was	be	VBD
18637	12346	10	foreseen	foresee	VBN
18637	12346	11	by	by	IN
18637	12346	12	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	12346	13	,	,	,
18637	12346	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12346	15	see	see	VBP
18637	12346	16	_	_	NNP
18637	12346	17	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	12346	18	No	no	UH
18637	12346	19	.	.	.
18637	12347	1	81	81	CD
18637	12347	2	.	.	.
18637	12348	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12348	2	285	285	CD
18637	12348	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12348	4	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	12348	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12348	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12348	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12348	8	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	12348	9	'	'	POS
18637	12348	10	L.	L.	NNP
18637	12348	11	&	&	CC
18637	12348	12	T.	T.	NNP
18637	12348	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12348	14	,	,	,
18637	12348	15	158	158	CD
18637	12348	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12348	17	429	429	CD
18637	12348	18	,	,	,
18637	12348	19	601	601	CD
18637	12348	20	,	,	,
18637	12348	21	635	635	CD
18637	12348	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12348	23	1895	1895	CD
18637	12348	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12348	25	.	.	.
18637	12349	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12349	2	286	286	CD
18637	12349	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12349	4	In	in	IN
18637	12349	5	the	the	DT
18637	12349	6	first	first	JJ
18637	12349	7	Guffey	Guffey	NNP
18637	12349	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	12349	9	Snyder	Snyder	NNP
18637	12349	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12349	11	Bituminous	Bituminous	NNP
18637	12349	12	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	12349	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12349	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12349	15	of	of	IN
18637	12349	16	1935	1935	CD
18637	12349	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12349	18	49	49	CD
18637	12349	19	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12349	20	.	.	.
18637	12350	1	991	991	CD
18637	12350	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12350	3	,	,	,
18637	12350	4	there	there	EX
18637	12350	5	was	be	VBD
18637	12350	6	a	a	DT
18637	12350	7	section	section	NN
18637	12350	8	providing	provide	VBG
18637	12350	9	for	for	IN
18637	12350	10	separability	separability	NN
18637	12350	11	of	of	IN
18637	12350	12	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	12350	13	,	,	,
18637	12350	14	but	but	CC
18637	12350	15	the	the	DT
18637	12350	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12350	17	none	none	NN
18637	12350	18	the	the	DT
18637	12350	19	less	less	RBR
18637	12350	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	12350	21	the	the	DT
18637	12350	22	price	price	NN
18637	12350	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	12350	24	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	12350	25	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	12350	26	inseparable	inseparable	JJ
18637	12350	27	from	from	IN
18637	12350	28	the	the	DT
18637	12350	29	labor	labor	NN
18637	12350	30	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	12350	31	which	which	WDT
18637	12350	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12350	33	found	find	VBD
18637	12350	34	void	void	JJ
18637	12350	35	and	and	CC
18637	12350	36	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	12350	37	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
18637	12350	38	the	the	DT
18637	12350	39	whole	whole	JJ
18637	12350	40	statute	statute	NN
18637	12350	41	.	.	.
18637	12351	1	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	12351	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12351	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12351	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12351	5	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	12351	6	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	12351	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12351	8	,	,	,
18637	12351	9	298	298	CD
18637	12351	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12351	11	238	238	CD
18637	12351	12	,	,	,
18637	12351	13	312	312	CD
18637	12351	14	-	-	SYM
18637	12351	15	316	316	CD
18637	12351	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12351	17	1936	1936	CD
18637	12351	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12351	19	.	.	.
18637	12352	1	On	on	IN
18637	12352	2	this	this	DT
18637	12352	3	point	point	NN
18637	12352	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12352	5	see	see	NN
18637	12352	6	also	also	RB
18637	12352	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12352	8	the	the	DT
18637	12352	9	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	12352	10	of	of	IN
18637	12352	11	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	12352	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12352	13	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	12352	14	.	.	.
18637	12353	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	12353	2	.	.	.
18637	12354	1	321	321	CD
18637	12354	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12354	3	324	324	CD
18637	12354	4	.	.	.
18637	12355	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12355	2	287	287	CD
18637	12355	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12355	4	157	157	CD
18637	12355	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12355	6	429	429	CD
18637	12355	7	,	,	,
18637	12355	8	574	574	CD
18637	12355	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12355	10	579	579	CD
18637	12355	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12355	12	1895	1895	CD
18637	12355	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12355	14	.	.	.
18637	12356	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12356	2	288	288	CD
18637	12356	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12356	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12356	5	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	12356	6	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	12356	7	in	in	IN
18637	12356	8	Burnet	Burnet	NNP
18637	12356	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12356	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12356	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12356	12	Coronado	Coronado	NNP
18637	12356	13	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	12356	14	&	&	CC
18637	12356	15	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	12356	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12356	17	,	,	,
18637	12356	18	285	285	CD
18637	12356	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12356	20	393	393	CD
18637	12356	21	,	,	,
18637	12356	22	405	405	CD
18637	12356	23	-	-	CD
18637	12356	24	411	411	CD
18637	12356	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12356	26	1932	1932	CD
18637	12356	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12356	28	states	state	VBZ
18637	12356	29	the	the	DT
18637	12356	30	rules	rule	NNS
18637	12356	31	governing	govern	VBG
18637	12356	32	the	the	DT
18637	12356	33	binding	bind	VBG
18637	12356	34	force	force	NN
18637	12356	35	of	of	IN
18637	12356	36	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	12356	37	and	and	CC
18637	12356	38	collects	collect	VBZ
18637	12356	39	the	the	DT
18637	12356	40	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	12356	41	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	12356	42	earlier	early	JJR
18637	12356	43	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	12356	44	to	to	IN
18637	12356	45	1932	1932	CD
18637	12356	46	.	.	.
18637	12357	1	In	in	IN
18637	12357	2	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	12357	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12357	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	12357	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12357	6	Griffiths	Griffiths	NNP
18637	12357	7	,	,	,
18637	12357	8	318	318	CD
18637	12357	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12357	10	371	371	CD
18637	12357	11	,	,	,
18637	12357	12	401	401	CD
18637	12357	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12357	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	12357	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12357	16	,	,	,
18637	12357	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12357	18	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	12357	19	lists	list	VBZ
18637	12357	20	other	other	JJ
18637	12357	21	cases	case	NNS
18637	12357	22	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	12357	23	between	between	IN
18637	12357	24	1932	1932	CD
18637	12357	25	and	and	CC
18637	12357	26	1943	1943	CD
18637	12357	27	.	.	.
18637	12358	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12358	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	12358	3	.	.	.
18637	12358	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12358	5	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	12358	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12358	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12358	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12358	9	Allwright	Allwright	NNP
18637	12358	10	,	,	,
18637	12358	11	321	321	CD
18637	12358	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12358	13	649	649	CD
18637	12358	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12358	15	1944	1944	CD
18637	12358	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12358	17	for	for	IN
18637	12358	18	similar	similar	JJ
18637	12358	19	list	list	NN
18637	12358	20	.	.	.
18637	12359	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12359	2	289	289	CD
18637	12359	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12359	4	321	321	CD
18637	12359	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12359	6	649	649	CD
18637	12359	7	,	,	,
18637	12359	8	665	665	CD
18637	12359	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12359	10	1944	1944	CD
18637	12359	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12359	12	.	.	.
18637	12360	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12360	2	290	290	CD
18637	12360	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12360	4	295	295	CD
18637	12360	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12360	6	45	45	CD
18637	12360	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12360	8	1935	1935	CD
18637	12360	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12360	10	.	.	.
18637	12361	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12361	2	291	291	CD
18637	12361	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12361	4	321	321	CD
18637	12361	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12361	6	649	649	CD
18637	12361	7	,	,	,
18637	12361	8	669	669	CD
18637	12361	9	.	.	.
18637	12362	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12362	2	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	12362	3	in	in	IN
18637	12362	4	a	a	DT
18637	12362	5	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	12362	6	,	,	,
18637	12362	7	in	in	IN
18637	12362	8	which	which	WDT
18637	12362	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12362	10	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	12362	11	joined	join	VBD
18637	12362	12	,	,	,
18637	12362	13	also	also	RB
18637	12362	14	protested	protest	VBN
18637	12362	15	against	against	IN
18637	12362	16	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	12362	17	"	"	``
18637	12362	18	earlier	early	RBR
18637	12362	19	considered	consider	VBN
18637	12362	20	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	12362	21	"	"	''
18637	12362	22	in	in	IN
18637	12362	23	Mahnich	Mahnich	NNP
18637	12362	24	_	_	NNP
18637	12362	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	12362	26	_	_	NNP
18637	12362	27	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	12362	28	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	12362	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12362	30	,	,	,
18637	12362	31	321	321	CD
18637	12362	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12362	33	96	96	CD
18637	12362	34	,	,	,
18637	12362	35	112	112	CD
18637	12362	36	-	-	SYM
18637	12362	37	113	113	CD
18637	12362	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12362	39	1944	1944	CD
18637	12362	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12362	41	.	.	.
18637	12363	1	More	more	RBR
18637	12363	2	recently	recently	RB
18637	12363	3	in	in	IN
18637	12363	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12363	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12363	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12363	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12363	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12363	9	Rabinowitz	Rabinowitz	NNP
18637	12363	10	,	,	,
18637	12363	11	339	339	CD
18637	12363	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12363	13	56	56	CD
18637	12363	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12363	15	1950	1950	CD
18637	12363	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12363	17	,	,	,
18637	12363	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12363	19	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	12363	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	12363	21	protested	protest	VBN
18637	12363	22	in	in	IN
18637	12363	23	a	a	DT
18637	12363	24	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	12363	25	against	against	IN
18637	12363	26	reversals	reversal	NNS
18637	12363	27	of	of	IN
18637	12363	28	earlier	early	JJR
18637	12363	29	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	12363	30	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	12363	31	following	follow	VBG
18637	12363	32	changes	change	NNS
18637	12363	33	of	of	IN
18637	12363	34	the	the	DT
18637	12363	35	court	court	NN
18637	12363	36	's	's	POS
18637	12363	37	membership	membership	NN
18637	12363	38	.	.	.
18637	12364	1	"	"	``
18637	12364	2	Especially	especially	RB
18637	12364	3	ought	ought	MD
18637	12364	4	the	the	DT
18637	12364	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12364	6	not	not	RB
18637	12364	7	reenforce	reenforce	VB
18637	12364	8	needlessly	needlessly	RB
18637	12364	9	the	the	DT
18637	12364	10	instabilities	instability	NNS
18637	12364	11	of	of	IN
18637	12364	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12364	13	day	day	NN
18637	12364	14	by	by	IN
18637	12364	15	giving	give	VBG
18637	12364	16	fair	fair	JJ
18637	12364	17	ground	ground	NN
18637	12364	18	for	for	IN
18637	12364	19	the	the	DT
18637	12364	20	belief	belief	NN
18637	12364	21	that	that	IN
18637	12364	22	Law	Law	NNP
18637	12364	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	12364	24	the	the	DT
18637	12364	25	expression	expression	NN
18637	12364	26	of	of	IN
18637	12364	27	chance	chance	NN
18637	12364	28	--	--	:
18637	12364	29	for	for	IN
18637	12364	30	instance	instance	NN
18637	12364	31	,	,	,
18637	12364	32	of	of	IN
18637	12364	33	unexpected	unexpected	JJ
18637	12364	34	changes	change	NNS
18637	12364	35	in	in	IN
18637	12364	36	the	the	DT
18637	12364	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12364	38	's	's	POS
18637	12364	39	composition	composition	NN
18637	12364	40	and	and	CC
18637	12364	41	the	the	DT
18637	12364	42	contingencies	contingency	NNS
18637	12364	43	in	in	IN
18637	12364	44	the	the	DT
18637	12364	45	choice	choice	NN
18637	12364	46	of	of	IN
18637	12364	47	successors	successor	NNS
18637	12364	48	.	.	.
18637	12364	49	"	"	''
18637	12365	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	12365	2	.	.	.
18637	12366	1	80	80	CD
18637	12366	2	.	.	.
18637	12367	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12367	2	292	292	CD
18637	12367	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12367	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12367	5	See	See	NNP
18637	12367	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12367	7	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	12367	8	,	,	,
18637	12367	9	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	12367	10	Review	Review	NNP
18637	12367	11	in	in	IN
18637	12367	12	Action	Action	NNP
18637	12367	13	,	,	,
18637	12367	14	74	74	CD
18637	12367	15	University	University	NNP
18637	12367	16	of	of	IN
18637	12367	17	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	12367	18	Law	Law	NNP
18637	12367	19	Review	Review	NNP
18637	12367	20	639	639	CD
18637	12367	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12367	22	1926	1926	CD
18637	12367	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12367	24	.	.	.
18637	12368	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12368	2	293	293	CD
18637	12368	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12368	4	Levering	Levering	NNP
18637	12368	5	&	&	CC
18637	12368	6	Garrigues	Garrigues	NNP
18637	12368	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12368	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12368	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12368	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12368	11	Morrin	Morrin	NNP
18637	12368	12	,	,	,
18637	12368	13	289	289	CD
18637	12368	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12368	15	103	103	CD
18637	12368	16	,	,	,
18637	12368	17	105	105	CD
18637	12368	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12368	19	1933	1933	CD
18637	12368	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12368	21	,	,	,
18637	12368	22	citing	cite	VBG
18637	12368	23	Mosher	Mosher	NNP
18637	12368	24	_	_	NNP
18637	12368	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	12368	26	_	_	NNP
18637	12368	27	Phoenix	Phoenix	NNP
18637	12368	28	,	,	,
18637	12368	29	287	287	CD
18637	12368	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12368	31	29	29	CD
18637	12368	32	,	,	,
18637	12368	33	30	30	CD
18637	12368	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12368	35	1932	1932	CD
18637	12368	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12368	37	.	.	.
18637	12369	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12369	2	294	294	CD
18637	12369	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12369	4	Levering	Levering	NNP
18637	12369	5	&	&	CC
18637	12369	6	Garrigues	Garrigues	NNP
18637	12369	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12369	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12369	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12369	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12369	11	Morrin	Morrin	NNP
18637	12369	12	,	,	,
18637	12369	13	289	289	CD
18637	12369	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12369	15	103	103	CD
18637	12369	16	,	,	,
18637	12369	17	105	105	CD
18637	12369	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12369	19	1933	1933	CD
18637	12369	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12369	21	.	.	.
18637	12370	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12370	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12370	3	also	also	RB
18637	12370	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12370	5	Binderup	Binderup	NNP
18637	12370	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12370	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12370	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12370	9	Pathe	Pathe	NNP
18637	12370	10	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	12370	11	,	,	,
18637	12370	12	263	263	CD
18637	12370	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12370	14	291	291	CD
18637	12370	15	,	,	,
18637	12370	16	305	305	CD
18637	12370	17	-	-	SYM
18637	12370	18	308	308	CD
18637	12370	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12370	20	1923	1923	CD
18637	12370	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12370	22	;	;	:
18637	12370	23	South	South	NNP
18637	12370	24	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	12370	25	&	&	CC
18637	12370	26	C.	C.	NNP
18637	12370	27	St.	St.	NNP
18637	12370	28	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	12370	29	.	.	.
18637	12371	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12371	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12371	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12371	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12371	5	Newport	Newport	NNP
18637	12371	6	,	,	,
18637	12371	7	259	259	CD
18637	12371	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12371	9	97	97	CD
18637	12371	10	,	,	,
18637	12371	11	99	99	CD
18637	12371	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12371	13	1922	1922	CD
18637	12371	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12371	15	;	;	:
18637	12371	16	Hull	Hull	NNP
18637	12371	17	_	_	NNP
18637	12371	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	12371	19	_	_	NNP
18637	12371	20	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	12371	21	,	,	,
18637	12371	22	234	234	CD
18637	12371	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12371	24	712	712	CD
18637	12371	25	,	,	,
18637	12371	26	720	720	CD
18637	12371	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12371	28	1914	1914	CD
18637	12371	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12371	30	;	;	:
18637	12371	31	The	the	DT
18637	12371	32	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	12371	33	_	_	NNP
18637	12371	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	12371	35	_	_	NNP
18637	12371	36	Kohler	Kohler	NNP
18637	12371	37	Die	Die	NNP
18637	12371	38	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12371	39	,	,	,
18637	12371	40	228	228	CD
18637	12371	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12371	42	22	22	CD
18637	12371	43	,	,	,
18637	12371	44	25	25	CD
18637	12371	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12371	46	1913	1913	CD
18637	12371	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12371	48	;	;	:
18637	12371	49	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	12371	50	Catholic	Catholic	NNP
18637	12371	51	Missions	Missions	NNPS
18637	12371	52	_	_	NNP
18637	12371	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	12371	54	_	_	NNP
18637	12371	55	Missoula	Missoula	NNP
18637	12371	56	County	County	NNP
18637	12371	57	,	,	,
18637	12371	58	200	200	CD
18637	12371	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12371	60	118	118	CD
18637	12371	61	,	,	,
18637	12371	62	130	130	CD
18637	12371	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12371	64	1906	1906	CD
18637	12371	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12371	66	;	;	:
18637	12371	67	Western	Western	NNP
18637	12371	68	Union	Union	NNP
18637	12371	69	Tel	Tel	NNP
18637	12371	70	.	.	.
18637	12372	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12372	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12372	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12372	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12372	5	Ann	Ann	NNP
18637	12372	6	Arbor	Arbor	NNP
18637	12372	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	12372	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12372	9	,	,	,
18637	12372	10	178	178	CD
18637	12372	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12372	12	239	239	CD
18637	12372	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12372	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	12372	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12372	16	.	.	.
18637	12373	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12373	2	295	295	CD
18637	12373	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12373	4	Newburyport	Newburyport	NNP
18637	12373	5	Water	Water	NNP
18637	12373	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12373	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12373	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12373	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12373	10	Newburyport	Newburyport	NNP
18637	12373	11	,	,	,
18637	12373	12	193	193	CD
18637	12373	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12373	14	561	561	CD
18637	12373	15	,	,	,
18637	12373	16	576	576	CD
18637	12373	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12373	18	1904	1904	CD
18637	12373	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12373	20	.	.	.
18637	12374	1	For	for	IN
18637	12374	2	these	these	DT
18637	12374	3	issues	issue	NNS
18637	12374	4	,	,	,
18637	12374	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12374	6	see	see	VBP
18637	12374	7	also	also	RB
18637	12374	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12374	9	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	12374	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12374	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	12374	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12374	13	Hood	Hood	NNP
18637	12374	14	,	,	,
18637	12374	15	327	327	CD
18637	12374	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12374	17	678	678	CD
18637	12374	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12374	19	1946	1946	CD
18637	12374	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12374	21	.	.	.
18637	12375	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12375	2	296	296	CD
18637	12375	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12375	4	Levering	Levering	NNP
18637	12375	5	&	&	CC
18637	12375	6	Garrigues	Garrigues	NNP
18637	12375	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12375	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12375	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12375	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12375	11	Morrin	Morrin	NNP
18637	12375	12	,	,	,
18637	12375	13	289	289	CD
18637	12375	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12375	15	103	103	CD
18637	12375	16	,	,	,
18637	12375	17	105	105	CD
18637	12375	18	-	-	SYM
18637	12375	19	106	106	CD
18637	12375	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12375	21	1933	1933	CD
18637	12375	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12375	23	.	.	.
18637	12376	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12376	2	297	297	CD
18637	12376	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12376	4	299	299	CD
18637	12376	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12376	6	109	109	CD
18637	12376	7	,	,	,
18637	12376	8	112	112	CD
18637	12376	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12376	10	113	113	CD
18637	12376	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12376	12	1936	1936	CD
18637	12376	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12376	14	.	.	.
18637	12377	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12377	2	298	298	CD
18637	12377	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12377	4	Whether	whether	IN
18637	12377	5	the	the	DT
18637	12377	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	12377	7	that	that	IN
18637	12377	8	the	the	DT
18637	12377	9	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	12377	10	must	must	MD
18637	12377	11	allege	allege	VB
18637	12377	12	the	the	DT
18637	12377	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	12377	14	question	question	NN
18637	12377	15	to	to	TO
18637	12377	16	make	make	VB
18637	12377	17	the	the	DT
18637	12377	18	case	case	NN
18637	12377	19	one	one	CD
18637	12377	20	arising	arise	VBG
18637	12377	21	under	under	IN
18637	12377	22	the	the	DT
18637	12377	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12377	24	rests	rest	NNS
18637	12377	25	on	on	IN
18637	12377	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	12377	27	or	or	CC
18637	12377	28	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	12377	29	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	12377	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	12377	31	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
18637	12377	32	.	.	.
18637	12378	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12378	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12378	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12378	4	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	12378	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12378	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12378	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12378	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	12378	9	and	and	CC
18637	12378	10	Planters	Planters	NNPS
18637	12378	11	'	'	POS
18637	12378	12	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	12378	13	,	,	,
18637	12378	14	152	152	CD
18637	12378	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12378	16	454	454	CD
18637	12378	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12378	18	1894	1894	CD
18637	12378	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12378	20	;	;	:
18637	12378	21	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	12378	22	Short	Short	NNP
18637	12378	23	Line	Line	NNP
18637	12378	24	and	and	CC
18637	12378	25	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	12378	26	N.	N.	NNP
18637	12378	27	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	12378	28	.	.	.
18637	12379	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12379	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12379	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12379	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12379	5	Skottowe	Skottowe	NNP
18637	12379	6	,	,	,
18637	12379	7	162	162	CD
18637	12379	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12379	9	490	490	CD
18637	12379	10	,	,	,
18637	12379	11	492	492	CD
18637	12379	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12379	13	1896	1896	CD
18637	12379	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12379	15	;	;	:
18637	12379	16	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	12379	17	,	,	,
18637	12379	18	H.	H.	NNP
18637	12379	19	&	&	CC
18637	12379	20	S.A.	S.A.	NNP
18637	12379	21	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	12379	22	.	.	.
18637	12380	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12380	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12380	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12380	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12380	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	12380	6	,	,	,
18637	12380	7	170	170	CD
18637	12380	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12380	9	226	226	CD
18637	12380	10	,	,	,
18637	12380	11	236	236	CD
18637	12380	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12380	13	1898	1898	CD
18637	12380	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12380	15	;	;	:
18637	12380	16	Sawyer	Sawyer	NNP
18637	12380	17	_	_	NNP
18637	12380	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	12380	19	_	_	NNP
18637	12380	20	Kochersperger	Kochersperger	NNP
18637	12380	21	,	,	,
18637	12380	22	170	170	CD
18637	12380	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12380	24	303	303	CD
18637	12380	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12380	26	1898	1898	CD
18637	12380	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12380	28	;	;	:
18637	12380	29	Board	Board	NNP
18637	12380	30	of	of	IN
18637	12380	31	Councilmen	Councilmen	NNP
18637	12380	32	of	of	IN
18637	12380	33	Frankfort	Frankfort	NNP
18637	12380	34	_	_	NNP
18637	12380	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	12380	36	_	_	NNP
18637	12380	37	State	State	NNP
18637	12380	38	National	National	NNP
18637	12380	39	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	12380	40	,	,	,
18637	12380	41	184	184	CD
18637	12380	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12380	43	696	696	CD
18637	12380	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12380	45	1902	1902	CD
18637	12380	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12380	47	;	;	:
18637	12380	48	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	12380	49	and	and	CC
18637	12380	50	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	12380	51	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	12380	52	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	12380	53	&	&	CC
18637	12380	54	Silver	Silver	NNP
18637	12380	55	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	12380	56	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12380	57	_	_	NNP
18637	12380	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	12380	59	_	_	NNP
18637	12380	60	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	12380	61	Ore	Ore	NNP
18637	12380	62	Purchasing	Purchasing	NNP
18637	12380	63	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12380	64	,	,	,
18637	12380	65	188	188	CD
18637	12380	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12380	67	632	632	CD
18637	12380	68	,	,	,
18637	12380	69	639	639	CD
18637	12380	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12380	71	1903	1903	CD
18637	12380	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12380	73	.	.	.
18637	12381	1	Some	some	DT
18637	12381	2	of	of	IN
18637	12381	3	these	these	DT
18637	12381	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	12381	5	apply	apply	VBP
18637	12381	6	to	to	IN
18637	12381	7	the	the	DT
18637	12381	8	removal	removal	NN
18637	12381	9	of	of	IN
18637	12381	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	12381	11	from	from	IN
18637	12381	12	State	State	NNP
18637	12381	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	12381	14	where	where	WRB
18637	12381	15	the	the	DT
18637	12381	16	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	12381	17	does	do	VBZ
18637	12381	18	not	not	RB
18637	12381	19	aver	aver	VB
18637	12381	20	a	a	DT
18637	12381	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12381	22	question	question	NN
18637	12381	23	.	.	.
18637	12382	1	On	on	IN
18637	12382	2	this	this	DT
18637	12382	3	point	point	NN
18637	12382	4	note	note	VB
18637	12382	5	the	the	DT
18637	12382	6	following	follow	VBG
18637	12382	7	statement	statement	NN
18637	12382	8	of	of	IN
18637	12382	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	12382	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12382	11	Fuller	Fuller	NNP
18637	12382	12	in	in	IN
18637	12382	13	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	12382	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12382	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	12382	16	_	_	NNP
18637	12382	17	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	12382	18	&	&	CC
18637	12382	19	T.C.	T.C.	NNP
18637	12383	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12383	2	&	&	CC
18637	12383	3	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	12383	4	,	,	,
18637	12383	5	183	183	CD
18637	12383	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12383	7	185	185	CD
18637	12383	8	,	,	,
18637	12383	9	188	188	CD
18637	12383	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12383	11	1901	1901	CD
18637	12383	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12383	13	:	:	:
18637	12383	14	"	"	``
18637	12383	15	Hence	hence	RB
18637	12383	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12383	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	12383	18	been	be	VBN
18637	12383	19	settled	settle	VBN
18637	12383	20	that	that	IN
18637	12383	21	a	a	DT
18637	12383	22	case	case	NN
18637	12383	23	can	can	MD
18637	12383	24	not	not	RB
18637	12383	25	be	be	VB
18637	12383	26	removed	remove	VBN
18637	12383	27	from	from	IN
18637	12383	28	a	a	DT
18637	12383	29	State	State	NNP
18637	12383	30	court	court	NN
18637	12383	31	into	into	IN
18637	12383	32	the	the	DT
18637	12383	33	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
18637	12383	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12383	35	of	of	IN
18637	12383	36	the	the	DT
18637	12383	37	United	United	NNP
18637	12383	38	States	States	NNP
18637	12383	39	on	on	IN
18637	12383	40	the	the	DT
18637	12383	41	sole	sole	JJ
18637	12383	42	ground	ground	NN
18637	12383	43	that	that	IN
18637	12383	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12383	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	12383	46	one	one	CD
18637	12383	47	arising	arise	VBG
18637	12383	48	under	under	IN
18637	12383	49	the	the	DT
18637	12383	50	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12383	51	,	,	,
18637	12383	52	laws	law	NNS
18637	12383	53	or	or	CC
18637	12383	54	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	12383	55	of	of	IN
18637	12383	56	the	the	DT
18637	12383	57	United	United	NNP
18637	12383	58	States	States	NNP
18637	12383	59	,	,	,
18637	12383	60	unless	unless	IN
18637	12383	61	that	that	DT
18637	12383	62	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	12383	63	by	by	IN
18637	12383	64	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	12383	65	's	's	POS
18637	12383	66	statement	statement	NN
18637	12383	67	of	of	IN
18637	12383	68	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12383	69	own	own	JJ
18637	12383	70	claim	claim	NN
18637	12383	71	;	;	:
18637	12383	72	and	and	CC
18637	12383	73	if	if	IN
18637	12383	74	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12383	75	does	do	VBZ
18637	12383	76	not	not	RB
18637	12383	77	so	so	RB
18637	12383	78	appear	appear	VB
18637	12383	79	,	,	,
18637	12383	80	the	the	DT
18637	12383	81	want	want	NN
18637	12383	82	of	of	IN
18637	12383	83	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12383	84	can	can	MD
18637	12383	85	not	not	RB
18637	12383	86	be	be	VB
18637	12383	87	supplied	supply	VBN
18637	12383	88	by	by	IN
18637	12383	89	any	any	DT
18637	12383	90	statement	statement	NN
18637	12383	91	of	of	IN
18637	12383	92	the	the	DT
18637	12383	93	petition	petition	NN
18637	12383	94	for	for	IN
18637	12383	95	removal	removal	NN
18637	12383	96	or	or	CC
18637	12383	97	in	in	IN
18637	12383	98	the	the	DT
18637	12383	99	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	12383	100	pleadings	pleading	NNS
18637	12383	101	.	.	.
18637	12384	1	And	and	CC
18637	12384	2	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	12384	3	that	that	DT
18637	12384	4	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12384	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	12384	6	not	not	RB
18637	12384	7	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	12384	8	by	by	IN
18637	12384	9	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	12384	10	that	that	IN
18637	12384	11	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	12384	12	intends	intend	VBZ
18637	12384	13	to	to	TO
18637	12384	14	assert	assert	VB
18637	12384	15	a	a	DT
18637	12384	16	defence	defence	NN
18637	12384	17	based	base	VBN
18637	12384	18	on	on	IN
18637	12384	19	the	the	DT
18637	12384	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12384	21	or	or	CC
18637	12384	22	a	a	DT
18637	12384	23	law	law	NN
18637	12384	24	or	or	CC
18637	12384	25	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	12384	26	of	of	IN
18637	12384	27	the	the	DT
18637	12384	28	United	United	NNP
18637	12384	29	States	States	NNP
18637	12384	30	,	,	,
18637	12384	31	or	or	CC
18637	12384	32	under	under	IN
18637	12384	33	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	12384	34	of	of	IN
18637	12384	35	the	the	DT
18637	12384	36	United	United	NNP
18637	12384	37	States	States	NNP
18637	12384	38	,	,	,
18637	12384	39	or	or	CC
18637	12384	40	of	of	IN
18637	12384	41	a	a	DT
18637	12384	42	State	State	NNP
18637	12384	43	,	,	,
18637	12384	44	in	in	IN
18637	12384	45	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	12384	46	with	with	IN
18637	12384	47	the	the	DT
18637	12384	48	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12384	49	.	.	.
18637	12384	50	"	"	''
18637	12385	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12385	2	299	299	CD
18637	12385	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12385	4	5	5	CD
18637	12385	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12385	6	.	.	.
18637	12386	1	61	61	CD
18637	12386	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12386	3	1809	1809	CD
18637	12386	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12386	5	.	.	.
18637	12387	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12387	2	300	300	CD
18637	12387	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12387	4	9	9	CD
18637	12387	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12387	6	.	.	.
18637	12388	1	738	738	CD
18637	12388	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12388	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	12388	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12388	5	.	.	.
18637	12389	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12389	2	301	301	CD
18637	12389	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12389	4	115	115	CD
18637	12389	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12389	6	1	1	CD
18637	12389	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12389	8	1885	1885	CD
18637	12389	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12389	10	.	.	.
18637	12390	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12390	2	302	302	CD
18637	12390	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12390	4	22	22	CD
18637	12390	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	12390	6	.	.	.
18637	12391	1	162	162	CD
18637	12391	2	,	,	,
18637	12391	3	§	§	NNP
18637	12391	4	4	4	CD
18637	12391	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12391	6	1882	1882	CD
18637	12391	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12391	8	.	.	.
18637	12392	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12392	2	303	303	CD
18637	12392	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12392	4	38	38	CD
18637	12392	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12392	6	.	.	.
18637	12393	1	803	803	CD
18637	12393	2	,	,	,
18637	12393	3	§	§	NNP
18637	12393	4	5	5	CD
18637	12393	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12393	6	1915	1915	CD
18637	12393	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12393	8	.	.	.
18637	12394	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12394	2	304	304	CD
18637	12394	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12394	4	43	43	CD
18637	12394	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	12394	6	.	.	.
18637	12395	1	936	936	CD
18637	12395	2	,	,	,
18637	12395	3	941	941	CD
18637	12395	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12395	5	1925	1925	CD
18637	12395	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12395	7	;	;	:
18637	12395	8	28	28	CD
18637	12395	9	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	12396	1	§	§	NNP
18637	12396	2	1349	1349	CD
18637	12396	3	.	.	.
18637	12397	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12397	2	305	305	CD
18637	12397	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12397	4	3	3	CD
18637	12397	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12397	6	.	.	.
18637	12398	1	195	195	CD
18637	12398	2	,	,	,
18637	12398	3	198	198	CD
18637	12398	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12398	5	1815	1815	CD
18637	12398	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12398	7	.	.	.
18637	12399	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12399	2	306	306	CD
18637	12399	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12399	4	4	4	CD
18637	12399	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12399	6	.	.	.
18637	12400	1	632	632	CD
18637	12400	2	,	,	,
18637	12400	3	633	633	CD
18637	12400	4	,	,	,
18637	12400	5	§	§	NNP
18637	12400	6	3	3	CD
18637	12400	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12400	8	1833	1833	CD
18637	12400	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12400	10	.	.	.
18637	12401	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12401	2	307	307	CD
18637	12401	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12401	4	12	12	CD
18637	12401	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12401	6	.	.	.
18637	12402	1	755	755	CD
18637	12402	2	,	,	,
18637	12402	3	756	756	CD
18637	12402	4	,	,	,
18637	12402	5	§	§	NNP
18637	12402	6	5	5	CD
18637	12402	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12402	8	1863	1863	CD
18637	12402	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12402	10	.	.	.
18637	12403	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12403	2	308	308	CD
18637	12403	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12403	4	28	28	CD
18637	12403	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	12404	1	§	§	NNP
18637	12404	2	1442	1442	CD
18637	12404	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12404	4	a	a	LS
18637	12404	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12404	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12404	7	1	1	CD
18637	12404	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12404	9	.	.	.
18637	12405	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12405	2	309	309	CD
18637	12405	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12405	4	100	100	CD
18637	12405	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12405	6	257	257	CD
18637	12405	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12405	8	1880	1880	CD
18637	12405	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12405	10	.	.	.
18637	12406	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12406	2	310	310	CD
18637	12406	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12406	4	1	1	CD
18637	12406	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12406	6	.	.	.
18637	12407	1	304	304	CD
18637	12407	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12407	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	12407	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12407	5	.	.	.
18637	12408	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12408	2	311	311	CD
18637	12408	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12408	4	6	6	CD
18637	12408	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12408	6	.	.	.
18637	12409	1	264	264	CD
18637	12409	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12409	3	1821	1821	CD
18637	12409	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12409	5	.	.	.
18637	12410	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12410	2	312	312	CD
18637	12410	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12410	4	100	100	CD
18637	12410	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12410	6	257	257	CD
18637	12410	7	,	,	,
18637	12410	8	264	264	CD
18637	12410	9	.	.	.
18637	12411	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12411	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12411	3	also	also	RB
18637	12411	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12411	5	The	the	DT
18637	12411	6	Mayor	Mayor	NNP
18637	12411	7	of	of	IN
18637	12411	8	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	12411	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12411	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12411	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12411	12	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	12411	13	,	,	,
18637	12411	14	6	6	CD
18637	12411	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12411	16	.	.	.
18637	12412	1	247	247	CD
18637	12412	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12412	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	12412	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12412	5	.	.	.
18637	12413	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12413	2	313	313	CD
18637	12413	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12413	4	Lovell	Lovell	NNP
18637	12413	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12413	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12413	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12413	8	City	City	NNP
18637	12413	9	of	of	IN
18637	12413	10	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	12413	11	,	,	,
18637	12413	12	303	303	CD
18637	12413	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12413	14	444	444	CD
18637	12413	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12413	16	1938	1938	CD
18637	12413	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12413	18	.	.	.
18637	12414	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12414	2	314	314	CD
18637	12414	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12414	4	Stoll	Stoll	NNP
18637	12414	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12414	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12414	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12414	8	Gottlieb	Gottlieb	NNP
18637	12414	9	,	,	,
18637	12414	10	305	305	CD
18637	12414	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12414	12	165	165	CD
18637	12414	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12414	14	1938	1938	CD
18637	12414	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12414	16	.	.	.
18637	12415	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12415	2	315	315	CD
18637	12415	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12415	4	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	12415	5	ex	ex	FW
18637	12415	6	rel	rel	NNP
18637	12415	7	.	.	.
18637	12416	1	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	12416	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12416	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12416	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12416	5	Brand	Brand	NNP
18637	12416	6	,	,	,
18637	12416	7	303	303	CD
18637	12416	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12416	9	95	95	CD
18637	12416	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12416	11	1938	1938	CD
18637	12416	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12416	13	.	.	.
18637	12417	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12417	2	316	316	CD
18637	12417	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12417	4	Southwestern	Southwestern	NNP
18637	12417	5	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	12417	6	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	12417	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12417	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12417	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12417	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12417	11	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	12417	12	,	,	,
18637	12417	13	303	303	CD
18637	12417	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12417	15	206	206	CD
18637	12417	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12417	17	1938	1938	CD
18637	12417	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12417	19	.	.	.
18637	12418	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12418	2	317	317	CD
18637	12418	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12418	4	Adam	Adam	NNP
18637	12418	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12418	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12418	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12418	8	Saenger	Saenger	NNP
18637	12418	9	,	,	,
18637	12418	10	303	303	CD
18637	12418	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12418	12	59	59	CD
18637	12418	13	,	,	,
18637	12418	14	164	164	CD
18637	12418	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12418	16	1938	1938	CD
18637	12418	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12418	18	.	.	.
18637	12419	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12419	2	318	318	CD
18637	12419	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12419	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12419	5	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	12419	6	Public	Public	NNP
18637	12419	7	Service	Service	NNP
18637	12419	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12419	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12419	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12419	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12419	12	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	12419	13	,	,	,
18637	12419	14	303	303	CD
18637	12419	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12419	16	123	123	CD
18637	12419	17	,	,	,
18637	12419	18	143	143	CD
18637	12419	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12419	20	1938	1938	CD
18637	12419	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12419	22	.	.	.
18637	12420	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12420	2	319	319	CD
18637	12420	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12420	4	279	279	CD
18637	12420	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12420	6	159	159	CD
18637	12420	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12420	8	1929	1929	CD
18637	12420	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12420	10	.	.	.
18637	12421	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12421	2	320	320	CD
18637	12421	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12421	4	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	12421	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12421	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12421	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12421	8	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	12421	9	,	,	,
18637	12421	10	307	307	CD
18637	12421	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12421	12	268	268	CD
18637	12421	13	,	,	,
18637	12421	14	274	274	CD
18637	12421	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12421	16	1939	1939	CD
18637	12421	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12421	18	.	.	.
18637	12422	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12422	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	12422	3	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	12422	4	obvious	obvious	JJ
18637	12422	5	,	,	,
18637	12422	6	of	of	IN
18637	12422	7	course	course	NN
18637	12422	8	,	,	,
18637	12422	9	that	that	IN
18637	12422	10	whether	whether	IN
18637	12422	11	State	State	NNP
18637	12422	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	12422	13	have	have	VBP
18637	12422	14	exceeded	exceed	VBN
18637	12422	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12422	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	12422	17	under	under	IN
18637	12422	18	the	the	DT
18637	12422	19	State	State	NNP
18637	12422	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12422	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	12422	22	not	not	RB
18637	12422	23	a	a	DT
18637	12422	24	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12422	25	question	question	NN
18637	12422	26	.	.	.
18637	12423	1	This	this	DT
18637	12423	2	rule	rule	NN
18637	12423	3	was	be	VBD
18637	12423	4	applied	apply	VBN
18637	12423	5	in	in	IN
18637	12423	6	Schuylkill	Schuylkill	NNP
18637	12423	7	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	12423	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12423	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12423	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12423	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12423	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	12423	13	,	,	,
18637	12423	14	302	302	CD
18637	12423	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12423	16	506	506	CD
18637	12423	17	,	,	,
18637	12423	18	512	512	CD
18637	12423	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12423	20	1938	1938	CD
18637	12423	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12423	22	,	,	,
18637	12423	23	where	where	WRB
18637	12423	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12423	25	was	be	VBD
18637	12423	26	contended	contend	VBN
18637	12423	27	that	that	IN
18637	12423	28	instead	instead	RB
18637	12423	29	of	of	IN
18637	12423	30	construing	construe	VBG
18637	12423	31	a	a	DT
18637	12423	32	State	State	NNP
18637	12423	33	statute	statute	NN
18637	12423	34	,	,	,
18637	12423	35	the	the	DT
18637	12423	36	courts	court	NNS
18637	12423	37	had	have	VBD
18637	12423	38	actually	actually	RB
18637	12423	39	amended	amend	VBN
18637	12423	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12423	41	by	by	IN
18637	12423	42	a	a	DT
18637	12423	43	species	species	NN
18637	12423	44	of	of	IN
18637	12423	45	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12423	46	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	12423	47	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	12423	48	by	by	IN
18637	12423	49	the	the	DT
18637	12423	50	State	State	NNP
18637	12423	51	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	12423	52	.	.	.
18637	12424	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12424	2	321	321	CD
18637	12424	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12424	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12424	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12424	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12424	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12424	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12424	9	Ravara	Ravara	NNP
18637	12424	10	,	,	,
18637	12424	11	2	2	CD
18637	12424	12	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12424	13	.	.	.
18637	12425	1	297	297	CD
18637	12425	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12425	3	1793	1793	CD
18637	12425	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12425	5	.	.	.
18637	12426	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12426	2	322	322	CD
18637	12426	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12426	4	Börs	Börs	NNP
18637	12426	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12426	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12426	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12426	8	Preston	Preston	NNP
18637	12426	9	,	,	,
18637	12426	10	111	111	CD
18637	12426	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12426	12	252	252	CD
18637	12426	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12426	14	1884	1884	CD
18637	12426	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12426	16	.	.	.
18637	12427	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12427	2	323	323	NNP
18637	12427	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12427	4	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	12427	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12427	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12427	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12427	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	12427	9	ex	ex	NNP
18637	12427	10	rel	rel	NNP
18637	12427	11	.	.	.
18637	12428	1	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	12428	2	,	,	,
18637	12428	3	111	111	CD
18637	12428	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12428	5	449	449	CD
18637	12428	6	,	,	,
18637	12428	7	469	469	CD
18637	12428	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12428	9	1884	1884	CD
18637	12428	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12428	11	.	.	.
18637	12429	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12429	2	324	324	CD
18637	12429	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12429	4	280	280	CD
18637	12429	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12429	6	379	379	CD
18637	12429	7	,	,	,
18637	12429	8	383	383	CD
18637	12429	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12429	10	384	384	CD
18637	12429	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12429	12	1930	1930	CD
18637	12429	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12429	14	.	.	.
18637	12430	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12430	2	325	325	CD
18637	12430	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12430	4	11	11	CD
18637	12430	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12430	6	.	.	.
18637	12431	1	467	467	CD
18637	12431	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12431	3	1826	1826	CD
18637	12431	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12431	5	.	.	.
18637	12432	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12432	2	326	326	CD
18637	12432	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12432	4	135	135	CD
18637	12432	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12432	6	403	403	CD
18637	12432	7	,	,	,
18637	12432	8	432	432	CD
18637	12432	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12432	10	1890	1890	CD
18637	12432	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12432	12	.	.	.
18637	12433	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12433	2	327	327	CD
18637	12433	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12433	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	12433	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	12433	6	Gruber	Gruber	NNP
18637	12433	7	,	,	,
18637	12433	8	269	269	CD
18637	12433	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12433	10	302	302	CD
18637	12433	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12433	12	1925	1925	CD
18637	12433	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12433	14	.	.	.
18637	12434	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12434	2	328	328	CD
18637	12434	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12434	4	1	1	CD
18637	12434	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12434	6	.	.	.
18637	12435	1	73	73	CD
18637	12435	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12435	3	1789	1789	CD
18637	12435	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12435	5	.	.	.
18637	12436	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12436	2	329	329	CD
18637	12436	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12436	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12436	5	See	See	NNP
18637	12436	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12436	7	W.W.	W.W.	NNP
18637	12436	8	Willoughby	Willoughby	NNP
18637	12436	9	,	,	,
18637	12436	10	The	the	DT
18637	12436	11	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	12436	12	Law	Law	NNP
18637	12436	13	of	of	IN
18637	12436	14	the	the	DT
18637	12436	15	United	United	NNP
18637	12436	16	States	States	NNP
18637	12436	17	,	,	,
18637	12436	18	III	III	NNP
18637	12436	19	,	,	,
18637	12436	20	1339	1339	CD
18637	12436	21	,	,	,
18637	12436	22	1347	1347	CD
18637	12436	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12436	24	New	New	NNP
18637	12436	25	York	York	NNP
18637	12436	26	,	,	,
18637	12436	27	1929	1929	CD
18637	12436	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12436	29	.	.	.
18637	12437	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12437	2	330	330	CD
18637	12437	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12437	4	Willoughby	Willoughby	NNP
18637	12437	5	,	,	,
18637	12437	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12437	7	op	op	NN
18637	12437	8	.	.	.
18637	12438	1	cit	cit	NNP
18637	12438	2	.	.	.
18637	12438	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12438	4	,	,	,
18637	12438	5	III	III	NNP
18637	12438	6	,	,	,
18637	12438	7	1339	1339	CD
18637	12438	8	.	.	.
18637	12439	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12439	2	331	331	CD
18637	12439	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12439	4	1	1	CD
18637	12439	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12439	6	.	.	.
18637	12440	1	73	73	CD
18637	12440	2	,	,	,
18637	12440	3	§	§	NNP
18637	12440	4	9	9	CD
18637	12440	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12440	6	1789	1789	CD
18637	12440	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12440	8	.	.	.
18637	12441	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12441	2	332	332	CD
18637	12441	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12441	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12441	5	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	12441	6	in	in	IN
18637	12441	7	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	12441	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12441	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12441	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12441	11	Brig	Brig	NNP
18637	12441	12	Seneca	Seneca	NNP
18637	12441	13	,	,	,
18637	12441	14	21	21	CD
18637	12441	15	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	12441	16	.	.	.
18637	12442	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	12442	2	.	.	.
18637	12443	1	No	no	UH
18637	12443	2	.	.	.
18637	12444	1	12,670	12,670	CD
18637	12444	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12444	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	12444	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12444	5	.	.	.
18637	12445	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12445	2	333	333	CD
18637	12445	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12445	4	The	the	DT
18637	12445	5	"	"	``
18637	12445	6	Vengeance	vengeance	NN
18637	12445	7	,	,	,
18637	12445	8	"	"	''
18637	12445	9	3	3	CD
18637	12445	10	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12445	11	.	.	.
18637	12446	1	297	297	CD
18637	12446	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12446	3	1796	1796	CD
18637	12446	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12446	5	;	;	:
18637	12446	6	The	the	DT
18637	12446	7	"	"	``
18637	12446	8	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
18637	12446	9	Sally	Sally	NNP
18637	12446	10	,	,	,
18637	12446	11	"	"	''
18637	12446	12	2	2	CD
18637	12446	13	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12446	14	.	.	.
18637	12447	1	406	406	CD
18637	12447	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12447	3	1805	1805	CD
18637	12447	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12447	5	;	;	:
18637	12447	6	The	the	DT
18637	12447	7	"	"	``
18637	12447	8	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
18637	12447	9	Betsey	Betsey	NNP
18637	12447	10	,	,	,
18637	12447	11	"	"	``
18637	12447	12	4	4	CD
18637	12447	13	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12447	14	.	.	.
18637	12448	1	443	443	CD
18637	12448	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12448	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	12448	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12448	5	;	;	:
18637	12448	6	The	the	DT
18637	12448	7	"	"	``
18637	12448	8	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
18637	12448	9	,	,	,
18637	12448	10	"	"	''
18637	12448	11	1	1	CD
18637	12448	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12448	13	.	.	.
18637	12449	1	9	9	CD
18637	12449	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12449	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	12449	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12449	5	;	;	:
18637	12449	6	The	the	DT
18637	12449	7	"	"	``
18637	12449	8	Octavia	Octavia	NNP
18637	12449	9	,	,	,
18637	12449	10	"	"	''
18637	12449	11	1	1	CD
18637	12449	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12449	13	.	.	.
18637	12450	1	20	20	CD
18637	12450	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12450	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	12450	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12450	5	.	.	.
18637	12451	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12451	2	334	334	CD
18637	12451	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12451	4	New	New	NNP
18637	12451	5	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	12451	6	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	12451	7	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	12451	8	.	.	.
18637	12452	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12452	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12452	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12452	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12452	5	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	12452	6	'	'	POS
18637	12452	7	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	12452	8	,	,	,
18637	12452	9	6	6	CD
18637	12452	10	How	how	WRB
18637	12452	11	.	.	.
18637	12453	1	344	344	CD
18637	12453	2	,	,	,
18637	12453	3	386	386	CD
18637	12453	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12453	5	1848	1848	CD
18637	12453	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12453	7	.	.	.
18637	12454	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12454	2	335	335	CD
18637	12454	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12454	4	Waring	Waring	NNP
18637	12454	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12454	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12454	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12454	8	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	12454	9	,	,	,
18637	12454	10	5	5	CD
18637	12454	11	How	how	WRB
18637	12454	12	.	.	.
18637	12455	1	441	441	CD
18637	12455	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12455	3	1847	1847	CD
18637	12455	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12455	5	;	;	:
18637	12455	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	12455	7	parte	parte	NN
18637	12455	8	Easton	Easton	NNP
18637	12455	9	,	,	,
18637	12455	10	95	95	CD
18637	12455	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12455	12	68	68	CD
18637	12455	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12455	14	1877	1877	CD
18637	12455	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12455	16	;	;	:
18637	12455	17	North	North	NNP
18637	12455	18	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	12455	19	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	12455	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12455	21	_	_	NNP
18637	12455	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	12455	23	_	_	NNP
18637	12455	24	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	12455	25	Brothers	Brothers	NNP
18637	12455	26	M.R.	M.R.	NNP
18637	12456	1	&	&	CC
18637	12456	2	S.	S.	NNP
18637	12456	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12456	4	,	,	,
18637	12456	5	249	249	CD
18637	12456	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12456	7	119	119	CD
18637	12456	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12456	9	1919	1919	CD
18637	12456	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12456	11	;	;	:
18637	12456	12	Grant	Grant	NNP
18637	12456	13	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	12456	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	12456	15	Porter	Porter	NNP
18637	12456	16	Ship	Ship	NNP
18637	12456	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12456	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12456	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	12456	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12456	21	Rohde	Rohde	NNP
18637	12456	22	,	,	,
18637	12456	23	257	257	CD
18637	12456	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12456	25	469	469	CD
18637	12456	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12456	27	1922	1922	CD
18637	12456	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12456	29	.	.	.
18637	12457	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12457	2	336	336	CD
18637	12457	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12457	4	Sheppard	Sheppard	NNP
18637	12457	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12457	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12457	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12457	8	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	12457	9	,	,	,
18637	12457	10	5	5	CD
18637	12457	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12457	12	.	.	.
18637	12458	1	675	675	CD
18637	12458	2	,	,	,
18637	12458	3	710	710	CD
18637	12458	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12458	5	1831	1831	CD
18637	12458	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12458	7	.	.	.
18637	12459	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12459	2	337	337	CD
18637	12459	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12459	4	New	New	NNP
18637	12459	5	England	England	NNP
18637	12459	6	M.	M.	NNP
18637	12459	7	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	12459	8	.	.	.
18637	12460	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12460	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12460	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12460	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12460	5	Dunham	Dunham	NNP
18637	12460	6	,	,	,
18637	12460	7	11	11	CD
18637	12460	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12460	9	.	.	.
18637	12461	1	1	1	CD
18637	12461	2	,	,	,
18637	12461	3	31	31	CD
18637	12461	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12461	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	12461	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12461	7	.	.	.
18637	12462	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12462	2	338	338	CD
18637	12462	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12462	4	Knapp	knapp	UH
18637	12462	5	,	,	,
18637	12462	6	Stout	Stout	NNP
18637	12462	7	&	&	CC
18637	12462	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12462	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12462	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12462	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12462	12	McCaffrey	McCaffrey	NNP
18637	12462	13	,	,	,
18637	12462	14	177	177	CD
18637	12462	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12462	16	638	638	CD
18637	12462	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12462	18	1900	1900	CD
18637	12462	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12462	20	.	.	.
18637	12463	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12463	2	339	339	CD
18637	12463	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12463	4	Atlee	Atlee	NNP
18637	12463	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12463	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12463	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12463	8	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	12463	9	Union	Union	NNP
18637	12463	10	P.	P.	NNP
18637	12463	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12463	12	,	,	,
18637	12463	13	21	21	CD
18637	12463	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12463	15	.	.	.
18637	12464	1	389	389	CD
18637	12464	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12464	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	12464	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12464	5	;	;	:
18637	12464	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	12464	7	parte	parte	NNP
18637	12464	8	McNiel	McNiel	NNP
18637	12464	9	,	,	,
18637	12464	10	13	13	CD
18637	12464	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12464	12	.	.	.
18637	12465	1	236	236	CD
18637	12465	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12465	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	12465	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12465	5	.	.	.
18637	12466	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12466	2	340	340	CD
18637	12466	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12466	4	O'Brien	O'Brien	NNP
18637	12466	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12466	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12466	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12466	8	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	12466	9	,	,	,
18637	12466	10	168	168	CD
18637	12466	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12466	12	287	287	CD
18637	12466	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12466	14	1897	1897	CD
18637	12466	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12466	16	;	;	:
18637	12466	17	The	the	DT
18637	12466	18	"	"	``
18637	12466	19	Grapeshot	Grapeshot	NNP
18637	12466	20	"	"	''
18637	12466	21	_	_	NNP
18637	12466	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	12466	23	_	_	NNP
18637	12466	24	Wallerstein	Wallerstein	NNP
18637	12466	25	,	,	,
18637	12466	26	9	9	CD
18637	12466	27	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12466	28	.	.	.
18637	12467	1	129	129	CD
18637	12467	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12467	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	12467	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12467	5	.	.	.
18637	12468	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12468	2	341	341	CD
18637	12468	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12468	4	New	New	NNP
18637	12468	5	Bedford	Bedford	NNP
18637	12468	6	Dry	Dry	NNP
18637	12468	7	Dock	Dock	NNP
18637	12468	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12468	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12468	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12468	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12468	12	Purdy	Purdy	NNP
18637	12468	13	,	,	,
18637	12468	14	258	258	CD
18637	12468	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12468	16	95	95	CD
18637	12468	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12468	18	1922	1922	CD
18637	12468	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12468	20	;	;	:
18637	12468	21	North	North	NNP
18637	12468	22	Pac	Pac	NNP
18637	12468	23	.	.	.
18637	12469	1	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	12469	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12469	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12469	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	12469	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12469	6	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	12469	7	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	12469	8	M.R.	M.R.	NNP
18637	12470	1	&	&	CC
18637	12470	2	S.	S.	NNP
18637	12470	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12470	4	,	,	,
18637	12470	5	249	249	CD
18637	12470	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12470	7	119	119	CD
18637	12470	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12470	9	1919	1919	CD
18637	12470	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12470	11	;	;	:
18637	12470	12	The	the	DT
18637	12470	13	General	General	NNP
18637	12470	14	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	12470	15	,	,	,
18637	12470	16	4	4	CD
18637	12470	17	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12470	18	.	.	.
18637	12471	1	438	438	CD
18637	12471	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12471	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	12471	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12471	5	.	.	.
18637	12472	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12472	2	342	342	CD
18637	12472	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12472	4	New	New	NNP
18637	12472	5	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	12472	6	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	12472	7	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	12472	8	.	.	.
18637	12473	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12473	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12473	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12473	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12473	5	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	12473	6	'	'	POS
18637	12473	7	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	12473	8	,	,	,
18637	12473	9	6	6	CD
18637	12473	10	How	how	WRB
18637	12473	11	.	.	.
18637	12474	1	344	344	CD
18637	12474	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12474	3	1848	1848	CD
18637	12474	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12474	5	.	.	.
18637	12475	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12475	2	343	343	CD
18637	12475	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12475	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	12475	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	12475	6	Easton	Easton	NNP
18637	12475	7	,	,	,
18637	12475	8	95	95	CD
18637	12475	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12475	10	68	68	CD
18637	12475	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12475	12	1877	1877	CD
18637	12475	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12475	14	.	.	.
18637	12476	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12476	2	344	344	CD
18637	12476	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12476	4	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
18637	12476	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12476	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12476	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12476	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12476	9	,	,	,
18637	12476	10	3	3	CD
18637	12476	11	How	how	WRB
18637	12476	12	.	.	.
18637	12477	1	568	568	CD
18637	12477	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12477	3	1845	1845	CD
18637	12477	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12477	5	.	.	.
18637	12478	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12478	2	345	345	CD
18637	12478	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12478	4	Janney	Janney	NNP
18637	12478	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12478	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12478	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12478	8	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	12478	9	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	12478	10	.	.	.
18637	12479	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12479	2	,	,	,
18637	12479	3	10	10	CD
18637	12479	4	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12479	5	.	.	.
18637	12480	1	411	411	CD
18637	12480	2	,	,	,
18637	12480	3	412	412	CD
18637	12480	4	,	,	,
18637	12480	5	415	415	CD
18637	12480	6	,	,	,
18637	12480	7	418	418	CD
18637	12480	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12480	9	1825	1825	CD
18637	12480	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12480	11	,	,	,
18637	12480	12	cited	cite	VBN
18637	12480	13	by	by	IN
18637	12480	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12480	15	Story	Story	NNP
18637	12480	16	in	in	IN
18637	12480	17	The	the	DT
18637	12480	18	"	"	``
18637	12480	19	Tilton	Tilton	NNP
18637	12480	20	,	,	,
18637	12480	21	"	"	''
18637	12480	22	23	23	CD
18637	12480	23	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	12480	24	.	.	.
18637	12481	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	12481	2	.	.	.
18637	12482	1	No	no	UH
18637	12482	2	.	.	.
18637	12483	1	14,054	14,054	CD
18637	12483	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12483	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	12483	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12483	5	.	.	.
18637	12484	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12484	2	346	346	CD
18637	12484	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12484	4	95	95	CD
18637	12484	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12484	6	68	68	CD
18637	12484	7	,	,	,
18637	12484	8	72	72	CD
18637	12484	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12484	10	1877	1877	CD
18637	12484	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12484	12	.	.	.
18637	12485	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12485	2	347	347	CD
18637	12485	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12485	4	The	the	DT
18637	12485	5	"	"	``
18637	12485	6	Belfast	Belfast	NNP
18637	12485	7	"	"	''
18637	12485	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12485	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12485	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12485	11	Boon	Boon	NNP
18637	12485	12	,	,	,
18637	12485	13	7	7	CD
18637	12485	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12485	15	.	.	.
18637	12486	1	624	624	CD
18637	12486	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12486	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	12486	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12486	5	.	.	.
18637	12487	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12487	2	348	348	CD
18637	12487	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12487	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	12487	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	12487	6	Garnett	Garnett	NNP
18637	12487	7	,	,	,
18637	12487	8	141	141	CD
18637	12487	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12487	10	1	1	CD
18637	12487	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12487	12	1891	1891	CD
18637	12487	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12487	14	.	.	.
18637	12488	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12488	2	349	349	CD
18637	12488	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12488	4	The	the	DT
18637	12488	5	"	"	``
18637	12488	6	City	City	NNP
18637	12488	7	of	of	IN
18637	12488	8	Panama	Panama	NNP
18637	12488	9	,	,	,
18637	12488	10	"	"	''
18637	12488	11	101	101	CD
18637	12488	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12488	13	453	453	CD
18637	12488	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12488	15	1880	1880	CD
18637	12488	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12488	17	;	;	:
18637	12488	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12488	19	see	see	VB
18637	12488	20	also	also	RB
18637	12488	21	_	_	NNP
18637	12488	22	Kenward	Kenward	NNP
18637	12488	23	_	_	NNP
18637	12488	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	12488	25	_	_	NNP
18637	12488	26	"	"	``
18637	12488	27	Admiral	Admiral	NNP
18637	12488	28	Peoples	Peoples	NNPS
18637	12488	29	,	,	,
18637	12488	30	"	"	''
18637	12488	31	295	295	CD
18637	12488	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12488	33	649	649	CD
18637	12488	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12488	35	1935	1935	CD
18637	12488	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12488	37	;	;	:
18637	12488	38	The	the	DT
18637	12488	39	"	"	``
18637	12488	40	Harrisburg	Harrisburg	NNP
18637	12488	41	,	,	,
18637	12488	42	"	"	''
18637	12488	43	119	119	CD
18637	12488	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12488	45	199	199	CD
18637	12488	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12488	47	1886	1886	CD
18637	12488	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12488	49	.	.	.
18637	12489	1	Although	although	IN
18637	12489	2	a	a	DT
18637	12489	3	suit	suit	NN
18637	12489	4	for	for	IN
18637	12489	5	damages	damage	NNS
18637	12489	6	for	for	IN
18637	12489	7	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
18637	12489	8	death	death	NN
18637	12489	9	will	will	MD
18637	12489	10	not	not	RB
18637	12489	11	lie	lie	VB
18637	12489	12	in	in	IN
18637	12489	13	the	the	DT
18637	12489	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	12489	15	of	of	IN
18637	12489	16	the	the	DT
18637	12489	17	United	United	NNP
18637	12489	18	States	States	NNP
18637	12489	19	under	under	IN
18637	12489	20	the	the	DT
18637	12489	21	general	general	JJ
18637	12489	22	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	12489	23	law	law	NN
18637	12489	24	,	,	,
18637	12489	25	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	12489	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	12489	27	will	will	MD
18637	12489	28	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	12489	29	a	a	DT
18637	12489	30	State	State	NNP
18637	12489	31	law	law	NN
18637	12489	32	creating	create	VBG
18637	12489	33	liability	liability	NN
18637	12489	34	for	for	IN
18637	12489	35	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
18637	12489	36	death	death	NN
18637	12489	37	.	.	.
18637	12490	1	Just	just	RB
18637	12490	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12490	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12490	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12490	5	Chambers	Chambers	NNP
18637	12490	6	,	,	,
18637	12490	7	312	312	CD
18637	12490	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12490	9	383	383	CD
18637	12490	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12490	11	1941	1941	CD
18637	12490	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12490	13	.	.	.
18637	12491	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12491	2	350	350	CD
18637	12491	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12491	4	The	the	DT
18637	12491	5	"	"	``
18637	12491	6	Raithmoor	Raithmoor	NNP
18637	12491	7	,	,	,
18637	12491	8	"	"	''
18637	12491	9	241	241	CD
18637	12491	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12491	11	166	166	CD
18637	12491	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12491	13	1916	1916	CD
18637	12491	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12491	15	;	;	:
18637	12491	16	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	12491	17	R.	R.	NNP
18637	12491	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12491	19	_	_	NNP
18637	12491	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	12491	21	_	_	NNP
18637	12491	22	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	12491	23	&	&	CC
18637	12491	24	Western	Western	NNP
18637	12491	25	T.	T.	NNP
18637	12491	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12491	27	,	,	,
18637	12491	28	204	204	CD
18637	12491	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12491	30	220	220	CD
18637	12491	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12491	32	1907	1907	CD
18637	12491	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12491	34	.	.	.
18637	12492	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12492	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12492	3	also	also	RB
18637	12492	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12492	5	Canadian	Canadian	NNP
18637	12492	6	Aviator	Aviator	NNP
18637	12492	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12492	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12492	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12492	10	United	United	NNP
18637	12492	11	States	States	NNP
18637	12492	12	,	,	,
18637	12492	13	324	324	CD
18637	12492	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12492	15	215	215	CD
18637	12492	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12492	17	1945	1945	CD
18637	12492	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12492	19	.	.	.
18637	12493	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12493	2	351	351	CD
18637	12493	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12493	4	L'Invincible	L'Invincible	NNP
18637	12493	5	,	,	,
18637	12493	6	1	1	CD
18637	12493	7	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12493	8	.	.	.
18637	12494	1	238	238	CD
18637	12494	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12494	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	12494	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12494	5	.	.	.
18637	12495	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12495	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12495	3	also	also	RB
18637	12495	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12495	5	In	In	NNP
18637	12495	6	re	re	IN
18637	12495	7	Fassett	Fassett	NNP
18637	12495	8	,	,	,
18637	12495	9	142	142	CD
18637	12495	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12495	11	479	479	CD
18637	12495	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12495	13	1892	1892	CD
18637	12495	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12495	15	.	.	.
18637	12496	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12496	2	352	352	CD
18637	12496	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12496	4	Sherlock	Sherlock	NNP
18637	12496	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12496	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12496	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12496	8	Alling	Alling	NNP
18637	12496	9	,	,	,
18637	12496	10	93	93	CD
18637	12496	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12496	12	99	99	CD
18637	12496	13	,	,	,
18637	12496	14	104	104	CD
18637	12496	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12496	16	1876	1876	CD
18637	12496	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12496	18	.	.	.
18637	12497	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12497	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12497	3	also	also	RB
18637	12497	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12497	5	Old	Old	NNP
18637	12497	6	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	12497	7	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	12497	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12497	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12497	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12497	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12497	12	Gilmore	Gilmore	NNP
18637	12497	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12497	14	The	the	DT
18637	12497	15	"	"	``
18637	12497	16	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	12497	17	"	"	''
18637	12497	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12497	19	,	,	,
18637	12497	20	207	207	CD
18637	12497	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12497	22	398	398	CD
18637	12497	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12497	24	1907	1907	CD
18637	12497	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12497	26	.	.	.
18637	12498	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12498	2	353	353	CD
18637	12498	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12498	4	Jennings	Jennings	NNP
18637	12498	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12498	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12498	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12498	8	Carson	Carson	NNP
18637	12498	9	,	,	,
18637	12498	10	4	4	CD
18637	12498	11	Cr	Cr	NNP
18637	12498	12	.	.	.
18637	12499	1	2	2	CD
18637	12499	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12499	3	1807	1807	CD
18637	12499	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12499	5	;	;	:
18637	12499	6	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	12499	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12499	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12499	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12499	10	Carryl	Carryl	NNP
18637	12499	11	,	,	,
18637	12499	12	20	20	CD
18637	12499	13	How	how	WRB
18637	12499	14	.	.	.
18637	12500	1	583	583	CD
18637	12500	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12500	3	1857	1857	CD
18637	12500	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12500	5	.	.	.
18637	12501	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12501	2	354	354	CD
18637	12501	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12501	4	Thirty	Thirty	NNP
18637	12501	5	Hogsheads	Hogsheads	NNPS
18637	12501	6	of	of	IN
18637	12501	7	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	12501	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12501	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12501	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12501	11	Boyle	Boyle	NNP
18637	12501	12	,	,	,
18637	12501	13	9	9	CD
18637	12501	14	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12501	15	.	.	.
18637	12502	1	191	191	CD
18637	12502	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12502	3	1815	1815	CD
18637	12502	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12502	5	;	;	:
18637	12502	6	The	the	DT
18637	12502	7	Siren	Siren	NNP
18637	12502	8	,	,	,
18637	12502	9	13	13	CD
18637	12502	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12502	11	.	.	.
18637	12503	1	389	389	CD
18637	12503	2	,	,	,
18637	12503	3	393	393	CD
18637	12503	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12503	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	12503	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12503	7	.	.	.
18637	12504	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12504	2	355	355	LS
18637	12504	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12504	4	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	12504	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12504	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12504	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12504	8	Guestier	Guestier	NNP
18637	12504	9	,	,	,
18637	12504	10	4	4	CD
18637	12504	11	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12504	12	.	.	.
18637	12505	1	293	293	CD
18637	12505	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12505	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	12505	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12505	5	.	.	.
18637	12506	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12506	2	356	356	CD
18637	12506	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12506	4	La	La	NNP
18637	12506	5	Vengeance	Vengeance	NNP
18637	12506	6	,	,	,
18637	12506	7	3	3	CD
18637	12506	8	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12506	9	.	.	.
18637	12507	1	297	297	CD
18637	12507	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12507	3	1796	1796	CD
18637	12507	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12507	5	;	;	:
18637	12507	6	Church	Church	NNP
18637	12507	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12507	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12507	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12507	10	Hubbart	Hubbart	NNP
18637	12507	11	,	,	,
18637	12507	12	2	2	CD
18637	12507	13	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12507	14	.	.	.
18637	12508	1	187	187	CD
18637	12508	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12508	3	1804	1804	CD
18637	12508	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12508	5	;	;	:
18637	12508	6	The	the	DT
18637	12508	7	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
18637	12508	8	Sally	Sally	NNP
18637	12508	9	,	,	,
18637	12508	10	2	2	CD
18637	12508	11	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12508	12	.	.	.
18637	12509	1	406	406	CD
18637	12509	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12509	3	1805	1805	CD
18637	12509	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12509	5	.	.	.
18637	12510	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12510	2	357	357	CD
18637	12510	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12510	4	The	the	DT
18637	12510	5	Brig	Brig	NNP
18637	12510	6	.	.	.
18637	12511	1	Ann	Ann	NNP
18637	12511	2	,	,	,
18637	12511	3	9	9	CD
18637	12511	4	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12511	5	.	.	.
18637	12512	1	289	289	CD
18637	12512	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12512	3	1815	1815	CD
18637	12512	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12512	5	;	;	:
18637	12512	6	The	the	DT
18637	12512	7	Sarah	Sarah	NNP
18637	12512	8	,	,	,
18637	12512	9	8	8	CD
18637	12512	10	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12512	11	.	.	.
18637	12513	1	391	391	CD
18637	12513	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12513	3	1823	1823	CD
18637	12513	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12513	5	;	;	:
18637	12513	6	Maul	Maul	NNP
18637	12513	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12513	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12513	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12513	10	United	United	NNP
18637	12513	11	States	States	NNP
18637	12513	12	,	,	,
18637	12513	13	274	274	CD
18637	12513	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12513	15	501	501	CD
18637	12513	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12513	17	1927	1927	CD
18637	12513	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12513	19	.	.	.
18637	12514	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12514	2	358	358	CD
18637	12514	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12514	4	Section	section	NN
18637	12514	5	9	9	CD
18637	12514	6	of	of	IN
18637	12514	7	the	the	DT
18637	12514	8	original	original	JJ
18637	12514	9	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	12514	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12514	11	,	,	,
18637	12514	12	since	since	IN
18637	12514	13	carried	carry	VBN
18637	12514	14	over	over	RB
18637	12514	15	in	in	IN
18637	12514	16	28	28	CD
18637	12514	17	U.S.C.A.	U.S.C.A.	NNP
18637	12515	1	§	§	NNP
18637	12515	2	1333	1333	CD
18637	12515	3	,	,	,
18637	12515	4	saves	save	VBZ
18637	12515	5	to	to	IN
18637	12515	6	suitors	suitor	NNS
18637	12515	7	such	such	PDT
18637	12515	8	a	a	DT
18637	12515	9	common	common	JJ
18637	12515	10	law	law	NN
18637	12515	11	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	12515	12	.	.	.
18637	12516	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12516	2	359	359	CD
18637	12516	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12516	4	For	for	IN
18637	12516	5	example	example	NN
18637	12516	6	,	,	,
18637	12516	7	the	the	DT
18637	12516	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12516	9	stated	state	VBD
18637	12516	10	in	in	IN
18637	12516	11	The	the	DT
18637	12516	12	"	"	``
18637	12516	13	Moses	Moses	NNP
18637	12516	14	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	12516	15	"	"	``
18637	12516	16	_	_	NNP
18637	12516	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	12516	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12516	19	Hammons	Hammons	NNP
18637	12516	20	,	,	,
18637	12516	21	4	4	CD
18637	12516	22	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12516	23	.	.	.
18637	12517	1	411	411	CD
18637	12517	2	,	,	,
18637	12517	3	431	431	CD
18637	12517	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12517	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	12517	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12517	7	,	,	,
18637	12517	8	that	that	IN
18637	12517	9	a	a	DT
18637	12517	10	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	12517	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12517	12	in	in	IN
18637	12517	13	rem	rem	NN
18637	12517	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12517	15	as	as	IN
18637	12517	16	used	use	VBN
18637	12517	17	in	in	IN
18637	12517	18	the	the	DT
18637	12517	19	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	12517	20	courts	court	NNS
18637	12517	21	,	,	,
18637	12517	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	12517	23	not	not	RB
18637	12517	24	a	a	DT
18637	12517	25	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	12517	26	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	12517	27	by	by	IN
18637	12517	28	the	the	DT
18637	12517	29	common	common	JJ
18637	12517	30	law	law	NN
18637	12517	31	and	and	CC
18637	12517	32	that	that	IN
18637	12517	33	a	a	DT
18637	12517	34	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	12517	35	_	_	NNP
18637	12517	36	in	in	IN
18637	12517	37	rem	rem	NN
18637	12517	38	_	_	NNP
18637	12517	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	12517	40	essentially	essentially	RB
18637	12517	41	a	a	DT
18637	12517	42	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	12517	43	possible	possible	JJ
18637	12517	44	only	only	RB
18637	12517	45	in	in	IN
18637	12517	46	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	12517	47	.	.	.
18637	12518	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12518	2	360	360	CD
18637	12518	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12518	4	318	318	CD
18637	12518	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12518	6	133	133	CD
18637	12518	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12518	8	1943	1943	CD
18637	12518	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12518	10	.	.	.
18637	12519	1	In	in	IN
18637	12519	2	the	the	DT
18637	12519	3	course	course	NN
18637	12519	4	of	of	IN
18637	12519	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12519	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	12519	7	for	for	IN
18637	12519	8	the	the	DT
18637	12519	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12519	10	which	which	WDT
18637	12519	11	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	12519	12	a	a	DT
18637	12519	13	lengthy	lengthy	JJ
18637	12519	14	historical	historical	JJ
18637	12519	15	account	account	NN
18637	12519	16	of	of	IN
18637	12519	17	Admiralty	Admiralty	NNP
18637	12519	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12519	19	in	in	IN
18637	12519	20	this	this	DT
18637	12519	21	country	country	NN
18637	12519	22	,	,	,
18637	12519	23	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	12519	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12519	25	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	12519	26	cited	cite	VBD
18637	12519	27	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	12519	28	_	_	NNP
18637	12519	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	12519	30	_	_	NNP
18637	12519	31	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	12519	32	,	,	,
18637	12519	33	18	18	CD
18637	12519	34	How	how	WRB
18637	12519	35	.	.	.
18637	12520	1	71	71	CD
18637	12520	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12520	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	12520	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12520	5	,	,	,
18637	12520	6	where	where	WRB
18637	12520	7	the	the	DT
18637	12520	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12520	9	without	without	IN
18637	12520	10	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	12520	11	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	12520	12	the	the	DT
18637	12520	13	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	12520	14	and	and	CC
18637	12520	15	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	12520	16	of	of	IN
18637	12520	17	a	a	DT
18637	12520	18	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	12520	19	in	in	IN
18637	12520	20	a	a	DT
18637	12520	21	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	12520	22	_	_	NNP
18637	12520	23	in	in	IN
18637	12520	24	rem	rem	NNP
18637	12520	25	_	_	NNP
18637	12520	26	of	of	IN
18637	12520	27	a	a	DT
18637	12520	28	State	State	NNP
18637	12520	29	court	court	NN
18637	12520	30	for	for	IN
18637	12520	31	violation	violation	NN
18637	12520	32	of	of	IN
18637	12520	33	a	a	DT
18637	12520	34	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	12520	35	fishing	fishing	NN
18637	12520	36	law	law	NN
18637	12520	37	within	within	IN
18637	12520	38	the	the	DT
18637	12520	39	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	12520	40	waters	water	NNS
18637	12520	41	of	of	IN
18637	12520	42	the	the	DT
18637	12520	43	State	State	NNP
18637	12520	44	.	.	.
18637	12521	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12521	2	361	361	CD
18637	12521	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12521	4	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	12521	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12521	6	of	of	IN
18637	12521	7	1789	1789	CD
18637	12521	8	,	,	,
18637	12521	9	1	1	CD
18637	12521	10	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	12521	11	.	.	.
18637	12522	1	73	73	CD
18637	12522	2	,	,	,
18637	12522	3	§	§	NNP
18637	12522	4	9	9	CD
18637	12522	5	;	;	:
18637	12522	6	La	La	NNP
18637	12522	7	Vengeance	Vengeance	NNP
18637	12522	8	,	,	,
18637	12522	9	3	3	CD
18637	12522	10	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12522	11	.	.	.
18637	12523	1	297	297	CD
18637	12523	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12523	3	1796	1796	CD
18637	12523	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12523	5	;	;	:
18637	12523	6	United	United	NNP
18637	12523	7	States	States	NNP
18637	12523	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12523	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12523	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12523	11	The	the	DT
18637	12523	12	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
18637	12523	13	Sally	Sally	NNP
18637	12523	14	,	,	,
18637	12523	15	2	2	CD
18637	12523	16	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12523	17	.	.	.
18637	12524	1	406	406	CD
18637	12524	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12524	3	1805	1805	CD
18637	12524	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12524	5	;	;	:
18637	12524	6	United	United	NNP
18637	12524	7	States	States	NNP
18637	12524	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12524	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12524	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12524	11	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
18637	12524	12	Betsey	Betsey	NNP
18637	12524	13	and	and	CC
18637	12524	14	Charlotte	Charlotte	NNP
18637	12524	15	,	,	,
18637	12524	16	4	4	CD
18637	12524	17	Cr	Cr	NNP
18637	12524	18	.	.	.
18637	12525	1	443	443	CD
18637	12525	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12525	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	12525	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12525	5	;	;	:
18637	12525	6	Whelan	Whelan	NNP
18637	12525	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12525	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12525	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12525	10	United	United	NNP
18637	12525	11	States	States	NNP
18637	12525	12	,	,	,
18637	12525	13	7	7	CD
18637	12525	14	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12525	15	.	.	.
18637	12526	1	112	112	CD
18637	12526	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12526	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	12526	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12526	5	;	;	:
18637	12526	6	The	the	DT
18637	12526	7	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
18637	12526	8	,	,	,
18637	12526	9	1	1	CD
18637	12526	10	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12526	11	.	.	.
18637	12527	1	9	9	CD
18637	12527	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12527	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	12527	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12527	5	.	.	.
18637	12528	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12528	2	362	362	CD
18637	12528	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12528	4	Hendry	Hendry	NNP
18637	12528	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12528	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12528	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12528	8	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	12528	9	,	,	,
18637	12528	10	318	318	CD
18637	12528	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12528	12	133	133	CD
18637	12528	13	,	,	,
18637	12528	14	141	141	CD
18637	12528	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12528	16	1943	1943	CD
18637	12528	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12528	18	.	.	.
18637	12529	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12529	2	363	363	CD
18637	12529	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12529	4	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	12529	5	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	12529	6	,	,	,
18637	12529	7	The	the	DT
18637	12529	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12529	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12529	10	in	in	IN
18637	12529	11	United	United	NNP
18637	12529	12	States	States	NNP
18637	12529	13	History	History	NNP
18637	12529	14	,	,	,
18637	12529	15	II	II	NNP
18637	12529	16	,	,	,
18637	12529	17	93	93	CD
18637	12529	18	-	-	SYM
18637	12529	19	95	95	CD
18637	12529	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12529	21	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	12529	22	,	,	,
18637	12529	23	1922	1922	CD
18637	12529	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12529	25	.	.	.
18637	12530	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12530	2	364	364	CD
18637	12530	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12530	4	10	10	CD
18637	12530	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12530	6	.	.	.
18637	12531	1	428	428	CD
18637	12531	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12531	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	12531	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12531	5	.	.	.
18637	12532	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12532	2	365	365	CD
18637	12532	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12532	4	5	5	CD
18637	12532	5	How	how	WRB
18637	12532	6	.	.	.
18637	12533	1	441	441	CD
18637	12533	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12533	3	1847	1847	CD
18637	12533	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12533	5	.	.	.
18637	12534	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12534	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12534	3	also	also	RB
18637	12534	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12534	5	New	New	NNP
18637	12534	6	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	12534	7	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	12534	8	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	12534	9	.	.	.
18637	12535	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12535	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12535	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12535	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12535	5	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	12535	6	'	'	POS
18637	12535	7	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	12535	8	,	,	,
18637	12535	9	6	6	CD
18637	12535	10	How	how	WRB
18637	12535	11	.	.	.
18637	12536	1	344	344	CD
18637	12536	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12536	3	1848	1848	CD
18637	12536	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12536	5	.	.	.
18637	12537	1	Aside	aside	RB
18637	12537	2	from	from	IN
18637	12537	3	rejecting	reject	VBG
18637	12537	4	English	english	JJ
18637	12537	5	rules	rule	NNS
18637	12537	6	,	,	,
18637	12537	7	Waring	Waring	NNP
18637	12537	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12537	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12537	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12537	11	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	12537	12	did	do	VBD
18637	12537	13	not	not	RB
18637	12537	14	affect	affect	VB
18637	12537	15	the	the	DT
18637	12537	16	rule	rule	NN
18637	12537	17	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	12537	18	the	the	DT
18637	12537	19	ebb	ebb	NN
18637	12537	20	and	and	CC
18637	12537	21	flow	flow	NN
18637	12537	22	of	of	IN
18637	12537	23	the	the	DT
18637	12537	24	tide	tide	NN
18637	12537	25	,	,	,
18637	12537	26	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	12537	27	as	as	IN
18637	12537	28	the	the	DT
18637	12537	29	collision	collision	NN
18637	12537	30	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	12537	31	within	within	IN
18637	12537	32	the	the	DT
18637	12537	33	ebb	ebb	NN
18637	12537	34	and	and	CC
18637	12537	35	flow	flow	NN
18637	12537	36	of	of	IN
18637	12537	37	the	the	DT
18637	12537	38	tide	tide	NN
18637	12537	39	,	,	,
18637	12537	40	though	though	IN
18637	12537	41	within	within	IN
18637	12537	42	the	the	DT
18637	12537	43	body	body	NN
18637	12537	44	of	of	IN
18637	12537	45	a	a	DT
18637	12537	46	county	county	NN
18637	12537	47	.	.	.
18637	12538	1	Citing	cite	VBG
18637	12538	2	Peyroux	Peyroux	NNP
18637	12538	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12538	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	12538	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12538	6	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	12538	7	,	,	,
18637	12538	8	7	7	CD
18637	12538	9	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	12538	10	.	.	.
18637	12539	1	324	324	CD
18637	12539	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12539	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	12539	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12539	5	;	;	:
18637	12539	6	The	the	DT
18637	12539	7	"	"	``
18637	12539	8	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	12539	9	"	"	''
18637	12539	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12539	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	12539	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12539	13	Phoebus	Phoebus	NNP
18637	12539	14	,	,	,
18637	12539	15	11	11	CD
18637	12539	16	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12539	17	.	.	.
18637	12540	1	175	175	CD
18637	12540	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12540	3	1837	1837	CD
18637	12540	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12540	5	;	;	:
18637	12540	6	The	the	DT
18637	12540	7	"	"	``
18637	12540	8	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	12540	9	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	12540	10	,	,	,
18637	12540	11	"	"	''
18637	12540	12	10	10	CD
18637	12540	13	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12540	14	.	.	.
18637	12541	1	328	328	CD
18637	12541	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12541	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	12541	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12541	5	;	;	:
18637	12541	6	United	United	NNP
18637	12541	7	States	States	NNP
18637	12541	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12541	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12541	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12541	11	Coombs	Coombs	NNP
18637	12541	12	,	,	,
18637	12541	13	12	12	CD
18637	12541	14	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12541	15	.	.	.
18637	12542	1	72	72	CD
18637	12542	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12542	3	1838	1838	CD
18637	12542	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12542	5	.	.	.
18637	12543	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12543	2	366	366	CD
18637	12543	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12543	4	12	12	CD
18637	12543	5	How	how	WRB
18637	12543	6	.	.	.
18637	12544	1	443	443	CD
18637	12544	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12544	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	12544	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12544	5	.	.	.
18637	12545	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12545	2	367	367	CD
18637	12545	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12545	4	Soon	soon	RB
18637	12545	5	afterwards	afterwards	RB
18637	12545	6	in	in	IN
18637	12545	7	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	12545	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12545	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12545	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12545	11	Steamboat	Steamboat	NNP
18637	12545	12	Magnolia	Magnolia	NNP
18637	12545	13	,	,	,
18637	12545	14	20	20	CD
18637	12545	15	How	how	WRB
18637	12545	16	.	.	.
18637	12546	1	296	296	CD
18637	12546	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12546	3	1858	1858	CD
18637	12546	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12546	5	,	,	,
18637	12546	6	the	the	DT
18637	12546	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12546	8	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	12546	9	what	what	WP
18637	12546	10	was	be	VBD
18637	12546	11	left	leave	VBN
18637	12546	12	of	of	IN
18637	12546	13	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	12546	14	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	12546	15	of	of	IN
18637	12546	16	the	the	DT
18637	12546	17	extent	extent	NN
18637	12546	18	of	of	IN
18637	12546	19	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	12546	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12546	21	by	by	IN
18637	12546	22	holding	hold	VBG
18637	12546	23	that	that	IN
18637	12546	24	a	a	DT
18637	12546	25	collision	collision	NN
18637	12546	26	on	on	IN
18637	12546	27	the	the	DT
18637	12546	28	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	12546	29	river	river	NN
18637	12546	30	above	above	IN
18637	12546	31	tidal	tidal	JJ
18637	12546	32	flow	flow	NN
18637	12546	33	and	and	CC
18637	12546	34	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	12546	35	within	within	IN
18637	12546	36	the	the	DT
18637	12546	37	State	State	NNP
18637	12546	38	of	of	IN
18637	12546	39	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	12546	40	came	come	VBD
18637	12546	41	within	within	IN
18637	12546	42	the	the	DT
18637	12546	43	grant	grant	NN
18637	12546	44	of	of	IN
18637	12546	45	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	12546	46	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12546	47	in	in	IN
18637	12546	48	the	the	DT
18637	12546	49	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	12546	50	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12546	51	of	of	IN
18637	12546	52	1789	1789	CD
18637	12546	53	which	which	WDT
18637	12546	54	extended	extend	VBD
18637	12546	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12546	56	"	"	''
18637	12546	57	to	to	IN
18637	12546	58	rivers	river	NNS
18637	12546	59	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	12546	60	from	from	IN
18637	12546	61	the	the	DT
18637	12546	62	sea	sea	NN
18637	12546	63	*	*	NFP
18637	12546	64	*	*	NFP
18637	12546	65	*	*	NFP
18637	12546	66	as	as	RB
18637	12546	67	well	well	RB
18637	12546	68	as	as	IN
18637	12546	69	upon	upon	IN
18637	12546	70	the	the	DT
18637	12546	71	high	high	JJ
18637	12546	72	seas	sea	NNS
18637	12546	73	.	.	.
18637	12546	74	"	"	''
18637	12547	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12547	2	368	368	CD
18637	12547	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12547	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12547	5	See	See	NNP
18637	12547	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12547	7	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	12547	8	,	,	,
18637	12547	9	II	II	NNP
18637	12547	10	,	,	,
18637	12547	11	512	512	CD
18637	12547	12	-	-	SYM
18637	12547	13	513	513	CD
18637	12547	14	.	.	.
18637	12548	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12548	2	369	369	CD
18637	12548	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12548	4	109	109	CD
18637	12548	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12548	6	629	629	CD
18637	12548	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12548	8	1884	1884	CD
18637	12548	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12548	10	;	;	:
18637	12548	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12548	12	see	see	VB
18637	12548	13	also	also	RB
18637	12548	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12548	15	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	12548	16	_	_	NNP
18637	12548	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	12548	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12548	19	Haines	Haines	NNP
18637	12548	20	,	,	,
18637	12548	21	191	191	CD
18637	12548	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12548	23	17	17	CD
18637	12548	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12548	25	1903	1903	CD
18637	12548	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12548	27	where	where	WRB
18637	12548	28	the	the	DT
18637	12548	29	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	12548	30	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12548	31	was	be	VBD
18637	12548	32	extended	extend	VBN
18637	12548	33	to	to	TO
18637	12548	34	inland	inland	VB
18637	12548	35	canals	canal	NNS
18637	12548	36	.	.	.
18637	12549	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12549	2	370	370	CD
18637	12549	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12549	4	10	10	CD
18637	12549	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12549	6	.	.	.
18637	12550	1	557	557	CD
18637	12550	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12550	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	12550	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12550	5	.	.	.
18637	12551	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12551	2	371	371	CD
18637	12551	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12551	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12551	5	.	.	.
18637	12552	1	563	563	CD
18637	12552	2	.	.	.
18637	12553	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12553	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12553	3	also	also	RB
18637	12553	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12553	5	The	the	DT
18637	12553	6	Montello	Montello	NNP
18637	12553	7	,	,	,
18637	12553	8	20	20	CD
18637	12553	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12553	10	.	.	.
18637	12554	1	430	430	CD
18637	12554	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12554	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	12554	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12554	5	,	,	,
18637	12554	6	where	where	WRB
18637	12554	7	this	this	DT
18637	12554	8	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	12554	9	was	be	VBD
18637	12554	10	applied	apply	VBN
18637	12554	11	to	to	IN
18637	12554	12	the	the	DT
18637	12554	13	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	12554	14	River	River	NNP
18637	12554	15	in	in	IN
18637	12554	16	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	12554	17	after	after	IN
18637	12554	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12554	19	had	have	VBD
18637	12554	20	been	be	VBN
18637	12554	21	improved	improve	VBN
18637	12554	22	to	to	TO
18637	12554	23	become	become	VB
18637	12554	24	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	12554	25	.	.	.
18637	12555	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12555	2	372	372	CD
18637	12555	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12555	4	141	141	CD
18637	12555	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12555	6	1	1	CD
18637	12555	7	,	,	,
18637	12555	8	12	12	CD
18637	12555	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12555	10	15	15	CD
18637	12555	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12555	12	1891	1891	CD
18637	12555	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12555	14	.	.	.
18637	12556	1	This	this	DT
18637	12556	2	case	case	NN
18637	12556	3	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	12556	4	a	a	DT
18637	12556	5	good	good	JJ
18637	12556	6	review	review	NN
18637	12556	7	of	of	IN
18637	12556	8	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	12556	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	12556	10	to	to	IN
18637	12556	11	the	the	DT
18637	12556	12	time	time	NN
18637	12556	13	of	of	IN
18637	12556	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12556	15	decision	decision	NN
18637	12556	16	.	.	.
18637	12557	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12557	2	373	373	CD
18637	12557	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12557	4	311	311	CD
18637	12557	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12557	6	377	377	CD
18637	12557	7	,	,	,
18637	12557	8	407	407	CD
18637	12557	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12557	10	410	410	CD
18637	12557	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12557	12	1940	1940	CD
18637	12557	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12557	14	.	.	.
18637	12558	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12558	2	374	374	CD
18637	12558	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12558	4	316	316	CD
18637	12558	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12558	6	31	31	CD
18637	12558	7	,	,	,
18637	12558	8	41	41	CD
18637	12558	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12558	10	1942	1942	CD
18637	12558	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12558	12	.	.	.
18637	12559	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12559	2	375	375	CD
18637	12559	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12559	4	3	3	CD
18637	12559	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12559	6	.	.	.
18637	12560	1	336	336	CD
18637	12560	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12560	3	1818	1818	CD
18637	12560	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12560	5	.	.	.
18637	12561	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12561	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12561	3	also	also	RB
18637	12561	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12561	5	Manchester	Manchester	NNP
18637	12561	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12561	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12561	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12561	9	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	12561	10	,	,	,
18637	12561	11	139	139	CD
18637	12561	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12561	13	240	240	CD
18637	12561	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12561	15	1891	1891	CD
18637	12561	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12561	17	which	which	WDT
18637	12561	18	followed	follow	VBD
18637	12561	19	this	this	DT
18637	12561	20	rule	rule	NN
18637	12561	21	and	and	CC
18637	12561	22	which	which	WDT
18637	12561	23	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	12561	24	to	to	TO
18637	12561	25	contain	contain	VB
18637	12561	26	a	a	DT
18637	12561	27	rule	rule	NN
18637	12561	28	analogous	analogous	JJ
18637	12561	29	to	to	IN
18637	12561	30	the	the	DT
18637	12561	31	"	"	``
18637	12561	32	silence	silence	NN
18637	12561	33	of	of	IN
18637	12561	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12561	35	"	"	''
18637	12561	36	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	12561	37	applied	apply	VBD
18637	12561	38	in	in	IN
18637	12561	39	cases	case	NNS
18637	12561	40	involving	involve	VBG
18637	12561	41	State	State	NNP
18637	12561	42	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	12561	43	which	which	WDT
18637	12561	44	affect	affect	VBP
18637	12561	45	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	12561	46	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	12561	47	.	.	.
18637	12562	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12562	2	376	376	CD
18637	12562	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12562	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12562	5	.	.	.
18637	12563	1	389	389	CD
18637	12563	2	.	.	.
18637	12564	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12564	2	377	377	CD
18637	12564	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12564	4	The	the	DT
18637	12564	5	St.	St.	NNP
18637	12564	6	Lawrence	Lawrence	NNP
18637	12564	7	,	,	,
18637	12564	8	1	1	CD
18637	12564	9	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	12564	10	.	.	.
18637	12565	1	522	522	CD
18637	12565	2	,	,	,
18637	12565	3	527	527	CD
18637	12565	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12565	5	1862	1862	CD
18637	12565	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12565	7	.	.	.
18637	12566	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12566	2	378	378	CD
18637	12566	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12566	4	The	the	DT
18637	12566	5	"	"	``
18637	12566	6	Lottawanna	Lottawanna	NNP
18637	12566	7	,	,	,
18637	12566	8	"	"	''
18637	12566	9	21	21	CD
18637	12566	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12566	11	.	.	.
18637	12567	1	558	558	CD
18637	12567	2	,	,	,
18637	12567	3	576	576	CD
18637	12567	4	,	,	,
18637	12567	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12567	6	1875	1875	CD
18637	12567	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12567	8	;	;	:
18637	12567	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12567	10	see	see	VB
18637	12567	11	also	also	RB
18637	12567	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12567	13	Janney	Janney	NNP
18637	12567	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12567	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	12567	16	_	_	NNP
18637	12567	17	Columbian	Columbian	NNP
18637	12567	18	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	12567	19	.	.	.
18637	12568	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12568	2	,	,	,
18637	12568	3	10	10	CD
18637	12568	4	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12568	5	.	.	.
18637	12569	1	411	411	CD
18637	12569	2	,	,	,
18637	12569	3	418	418	CD
18637	12569	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12569	5	1825	1825	CD
18637	12569	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12569	7	,	,	,
18637	12569	8	where	where	WRB
18637	12569	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12569	10	was	be	VBD
18637	12569	11	held	hold	VBN
18637	12569	12	that	that	IN
18637	12569	13	the	the	DT
18637	12569	14	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	12569	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12569	16	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	12569	17	on	on	IN
18637	12569	18	the	the	DT
18637	12569	19	grant	grant	NN
18637	12569	20	in	in	IN
18637	12569	21	the	the	DT
18637	12569	22	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	12569	23	and	and	CC
18637	12569	24	can	can	MD
18637	12569	25	only	only	RB
18637	12569	26	be	be	VB
18637	12569	27	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	12569	28	under	under	IN
18637	12569	29	the	the	DT
18637	12569	30	laws	law	NNS
18637	12569	31	of	of	IN
18637	12569	32	the	the	DT
18637	12569	33	United	United	NNP
18637	12569	34	States	States	NNP
18637	12569	35	extending	extend	VBG
18637	12569	36	that	that	DT
18637	12569	37	grant	grant	NN
18637	12569	38	to	to	IN
18637	12569	39	the	the	DT
18637	12569	40	respective	respective	JJ
18637	12569	41	courts	court	NNS
18637	12569	42	of	of	IN
18637	12569	43	the	the	DT
18637	12569	44	United	United	NNP
18637	12569	45	States	States	NNP
18637	12569	46	.	.	.
18637	12570	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12570	2	379	379	CD
18637	12570	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12570	4	4	4	CD
18637	12570	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12570	6	.	.	.
18637	12571	1	411	411	CD
18637	12571	2	,	,	,
18637	12571	3	431	431	CD
18637	12571	4	,	,	,
18637	12571	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12571	6	1867	1867	CD
18637	12571	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12571	8	;	;	:
18637	12571	9	The	the	DT
18637	12571	10	Hine	Hine	NNP
18637	12571	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12571	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	12571	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12571	14	Trevor	Trevor	NNP
18637	12571	15	,	,	,
18637	12571	16	4	4	CD
18637	12571	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12571	18	.	.	.
18637	12572	1	555	555	CD
18637	12572	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12572	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	12572	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12572	5	.	.	.
18637	12573	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12573	2	380	380	CD
18637	12573	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12573	4	Knapp	knapp	UH
18637	12573	5	,	,	,
18637	12573	6	Stout	Stout	NNP
18637	12573	7	&	&	CC
18637	12573	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12573	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12573	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12573	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12573	12	McCaffrey	McCaffrey	NNP
18637	12573	13	,	,	,
18637	12573	14	177	177	CD
18637	12573	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12573	16	638	638	CD
18637	12573	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12573	18	1900	1900	CD
18637	12573	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12573	20	;	;	:
18637	12573	21	Red	Red	NNP
18637	12573	22	Cross	Cross	NNP
18637	12573	23	Line	Line	NNP
18637	12573	24	_	_	NNP
18637	12573	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	12573	26	_	_	NNP
18637	12573	27	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	12573	28	Fruit	Fruit	NNP
18637	12573	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12573	30	,	,	,
18637	12573	31	264	264	CD
18637	12573	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12573	33	109	109	CD
18637	12573	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12573	35	1924	1924	CD
18637	12573	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12573	37	.	.	.
18637	12574	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12574	2	381	381	CD
18637	12574	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12574	4	Chelentis	Chelentis	NNP
18637	12574	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12574	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12574	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12574	8	Luckenbach	Luckenbach	NNP
18637	12574	9	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	12574	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12574	11	,	,	,
18637	12574	12	247	247	CD
18637	12574	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12574	14	372	372	CD
18637	12574	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12574	16	1918	1918	CD
18637	12574	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12574	18	.	.	.
18637	12575	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12575	2	382	382	CD
18637	12575	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12575	4	Rodd	Rodd	NNP
18637	12575	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12575	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12575	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12575	8	Heartt	Heartt	NNP
18637	12575	9	,	,	,
18637	12575	10	21	21	CD
18637	12575	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12575	12	.	.	.
18637	12576	1	558	558	CD
18637	12576	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12576	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	12576	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12576	5	.	.	.
18637	12577	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12577	2	383	383	CD
18637	12577	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12577	4	Old	Old	NNP
18637	12577	5	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	12577	6	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	12577	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12577	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12577	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12577	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12577	11	Gilmore	Gilmore	NNP
18637	12577	12	,	,	,
18637	12577	13	207	207	CD
18637	12577	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12577	15	398	398	CD
18637	12577	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12577	17	1907	1907	CD
18637	12577	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12577	19	.	.	.
18637	12578	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12578	2	384	384	CD
18637	12578	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12578	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12578	5	.	.	.
18637	12579	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12579	2	385	385	CD
18637	12579	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12579	4	312	312	CD
18637	12579	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12579	6	383	383	CD
18637	12579	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12579	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	12579	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12579	10	.	.	.
18637	12580	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12580	2	386	386	CD
18637	12580	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12580	4	244	244	CD
18637	12580	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12580	6	205	205	CD
18637	12580	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12580	8	1917	1917	CD
18637	12580	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12580	10	.	.	.
18637	12581	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12581	2	387	387	CD
18637	12581	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12581	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12581	5	.	.	.
18637	12582	1	202	202	CD
18637	12582	2	,	,	,
18637	12582	3	215	215	CD
18637	12582	4	-	-	SYM
18637	12582	5	218	218	CD
18637	12582	6	.	.	.
18637	12583	1	This	this	DT
18637	12583	2	was	be	VBD
18637	12583	3	a	a	DT
18637	12583	4	five	five	CD
18637	12583	5	to	to	TO
18637	12583	6	four	four	CD
18637	12583	7	decision	decision	NN
18637	12583	8	with	with	IN
18637	12583	9	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	12583	10	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	12583	11	,	,	,
18637	12583	12	Pitney	Pitney	NNP
18637	12583	13	,	,	,
18637	12583	14	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	12583	15	,	,	,
18637	12583	16	and	and	CC
18637	12583	17	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	12583	18	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	12583	19	.	.	.
18637	12584	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12584	2	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	12584	3	'	'	POS
18637	12584	4	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	12584	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	12584	6	notable	notable	JJ
18637	12584	7	among	among	IN
18637	12584	8	other	other	JJ
18637	12584	9	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	12584	10	for	for	IN
18637	12584	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12584	12	epigrams	epigram	NNS
18637	12584	13	that	that	IN
18637	12584	14	"	"	``
18637	12584	15	Judges	judge	NNS
18637	12584	16	do	do	VBP
18637	12584	17	and	and	CC
18637	12584	18	must	must	MD
18637	12584	19	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	12584	20	,	,	,
18637	12584	21	but	but	CC
18637	12584	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12584	23	can	can	MD
18637	12584	24	do	do	VB
18637	12584	25	so	so	RB
18637	12584	26	only	only	RB
18637	12584	27	interstitially	interstitially	RB
18637	12584	28	;	;	:
18637	12584	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12584	30	are	be	VBP
18637	12584	31	confined	confine	VBN
18637	12584	32	from	from	IN
18637	12584	33	molar	molar	JJ
18637	12584	34	to	to	IN
18637	12584	35	molecular	molecular	JJ
18637	12584	36	motions	motion	NNS
18637	12584	37	,	,	,
18637	12584	38	"	"	''
18637	12584	39	ibid	ibid	NNP
18637	12584	40	.	.	.
18637	12585	1	221	221	CD
18637	12585	2	;	;	:
18637	12585	3	and	and	CC
18637	12585	4	that	that	IN
18637	12585	5	"	"	``
18637	12585	6	the	the	DT
18637	12585	7	common	common	JJ
18637	12585	8	law	law	NN
18637	12585	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	12585	10	not	not	RB
18637	12585	11	a	a	DT
18637	12585	12	brooding	brood	VBG
18637	12585	13	omnipresence	omnipresence	NN
18637	12585	14	in	in	IN
18637	12585	15	the	the	DT
18637	12585	16	sky	sky	NN
18637	12585	17	but	but	CC
18637	12585	18	the	the	DT
18637	12585	19	articulate	articulate	JJ
18637	12585	20	voice	voice	NN
18637	12585	21	of	of	IN
18637	12585	22	some	some	DT
18637	12585	23	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	12585	24	or	or	CC
18637	12585	25	some	some	DT
18637	12585	26	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	12585	27	-	-	JJ
18637	12585	28	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	12585	29	that	that	WDT
18637	12585	30	can	can	MD
18637	12585	31	be	be	VB
18637	12585	32	identified	identify	VBN
18637	12585	33	.	.	.
18637	12585	34	"	"	''
18637	12586	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	12586	2	.	.	.
18637	12587	1	222	222	CD
18637	12587	2	.	.	.
18637	12588	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12588	2	Pitney	Pitney	NNP
18637	12588	3	attacked	attack	VBD
18637	12588	4	the	the	DT
18637	12588	5	decision	decision	NN
18637	12588	6	as	as	IN
18637	12588	7	unsupported	unsupporte	VBN
18637	12588	8	by	by	IN
18637	12588	9	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	12588	10	and	and	CC
18637	12588	11	contended	contend	VBD
18637	12588	12	that	that	IN
18637	12588	13	article	article	NN
18637	12588	14	III	III	NNP
18637	12588	15	speaks	speak	VBZ
18637	12588	16	only	only	RB
18637	12588	17	of	of	IN
18637	12588	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12588	19	and	and	CC
18637	12588	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	12588	21	not	not	RB
18637	12588	22	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	12588	23	the	the	DT
18637	12588	24	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	12588	25	or	or	CC
18637	12588	26	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	12588	27	law	law	NN
18637	12588	28	by	by	IN
18637	12588	29	which	which	WDT
18637	12588	30	the	the	DT
18637	12588	31	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	12588	32	of	of	IN
18637	12588	33	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	12588	34	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12588	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	12588	36	to	to	TO
18637	12588	37	be	be	VB
18637	12588	38	governed	govern	VBN
18637	12588	39	.	.	.
18637	12589	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	12589	2	.	.	.
18637	12590	1	225	225	CD
18637	12590	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12590	3	229	229	CD
18637	12590	4	.	.	.
18637	12591	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12591	2	388	388	CD
18637	12591	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12591	4	40	40	CD
18637	12591	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12591	6	.	.	.
18637	12592	1	395	395	CD
18637	12592	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12592	3	1917	1917	CD
18637	12592	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12592	5	.	.	.
18637	12593	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12593	2	389	389	CD
18637	12593	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12593	4	253	253	CD
18637	12593	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12593	6	149	149	CD
18637	12593	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12593	8	1920	1920	CD
18637	12593	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12593	10	.	.	.
18637	12594	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12594	2	390	390	CD
18637	12594	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12594	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12594	5	.	.	.
18637	12595	1	160	160	CD
18637	12595	2	.	.	.
18637	12596	1	For	for	IN
18637	12596	2	the	the	DT
18637	12596	3	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	12596	4	of	of	IN
18637	12596	5	the	the	DT
18637	12596	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	12596	7	as	as	IN
18637	12596	8	an	an	DT
18637	12596	9	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	12596	10	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	12596	11	of	of	IN
18637	12596	12	power	power	NN
18637	12596	13	,	,	,
18637	12596	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12596	15	see	see	VBP
18637	12596	16	_	_	NNP
18637	12596	17	ibid	ibid	NNP
18637	12596	18	.	.	.
18637	12597	1	163	163	CD
18637	12597	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12597	3	166	166	CD
18637	12597	4	.	.	.
18637	12598	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12598	2	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	12598	3	wrote	write	VBD
18637	12598	4	a	a	DT
18637	12598	5	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	12598	6	in	in	IN
18637	12598	7	which	which	WDT
18637	12598	8	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	12598	9	Pitney	Pitney	NNP
18637	12598	10	,	,	,
18637	12598	11	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	12598	12	and	and	CC
18637	12598	13	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	12598	14	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	12598	15	.	.	.
18637	12599	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12599	2	391	391	CD
18637	12599	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12599	4	42	42	CD
18637	12599	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12599	6	.	.	.
18637	12600	1	634	634	CD
18637	12600	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12600	3	1922	1922	CD
18637	12600	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12600	5	;	;	,
18637	12600	6	overturned	overturn	VBN
18637	12600	7	in	in	IN
18637	12600	8	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	12600	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12600	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12600	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12600	12	W.C.	W.C.	NNP
18637	12600	13	Dawson	Dawson	NNP
18637	12600	14	&	&	CC
18637	12600	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12600	16	,	,	,
18637	12600	17	264	264	CD
18637	12600	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12600	19	219	219	CD
18637	12600	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12600	21	1924	1924	CD
18637	12600	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12600	23	.	.	.
18637	12601	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12601	2	392	392	CD
18637	12601	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12601	4	44	44	CD
18637	12601	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	12601	6	.	.	.
18637	12602	1	1424	1424	CD
18637	12602	2	.	.	.
18637	12603	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12603	2	393	393	CD
18637	12603	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12603	4	Nogueira	Nogueira	NNP
18637	12603	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12603	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12603	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12603	8	New	New	NNP
18637	12603	9	York	York	NNP
18637	12603	10	,	,	,
18637	12603	11	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	12603	12	&	&	CC
18637	12603	13	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	12604	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12604	2	,	,	,
18637	12604	3	281	281	CD
18637	12604	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12604	5	128	128	CD
18637	12604	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12604	7	1930	1930	CD
18637	12604	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12604	9	;	;	:
18637	12604	10	Vancouver	Vancouver	NNP
18637	12604	11	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	12604	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12604	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12604	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	12604	15	_	_	NNP
18637	12604	16	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	12604	17	,	,	,
18637	12604	18	288	288	CD
18637	12604	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12604	20	445	445	CD
18637	12604	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12604	22	1933	1933	CD
18637	12604	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12604	24	.	.	.
18637	12605	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12605	2	394	394	CD
18637	12605	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12605	4	244	244	CD
18637	12605	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12605	6	205	205	CD
18637	12605	7	,	,	,
18637	12605	8	216	216	CD
18637	12605	9	.	.	.
18637	12606	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12606	2	395	395	CD
18637	12606	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12606	4	317	317	CD
18637	12606	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12606	6	249	249	CD
18637	12606	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12606	8	1942	1942	CD
18637	12606	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12606	10	.	.	.
18637	12607	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12607	2	396	396	CD
18637	12607	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12607	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12607	5	.	.	.
18637	12608	1	252	252	CD
18637	12608	2	.	.	.
18637	12609	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12609	2	397	397	CD
18637	12609	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12609	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12609	5	.	.	.
18637	12610	1	253	253	CD
18637	12610	2	.	.	.
18637	12611	1	Citing	cite	VBG
18637	12611	2	Baizley	Baizley	NNP
18637	12611	3	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	12611	4	Works	Works	NNP
18637	12611	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12611	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12611	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12611	8	Span	Span	NNP
18637	12611	9	,	,	,
18637	12611	10	281	281	CD
18637	12611	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12611	12	222	222	CD
18637	12611	13	,	,	,
18637	12611	14	230	230	CD
18637	12611	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12611	16	1930	1930	CD
18637	12611	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12611	18	.	.	.
18637	12612	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12612	2	398	398	CD
18637	12612	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12612	4	317	317	CD
18637	12612	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12612	6	249	249	CD
18637	12612	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12612	8	1942	1942	CD
18637	12612	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12612	10	.	.	.
18637	12613	1	Cases	case	NNS
18637	12613	2	cited	cite	VBD
18637	12613	3	as	as	IN
18637	12613	4	strengthening	strengthen	VBG
18637	12613	5	the	the	DT
18637	12613	6	claim	claim	NN
18637	12613	7	were	be	VBD
18637	12613	8	Sultan	Sultan	NNP
18637	12613	9	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	12613	10	.	.	.
18637	12614	1	&	&	CC
18637	12614	2	Timber	Timber	NNP
18637	12614	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12614	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12614	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	12614	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12614	7	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	12614	8	.	.	.
18637	12615	1	of	of	IN
18637	12615	2	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	12615	3	,	,	,
18637	12615	4	277	277	CD
18637	12615	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12615	6	135	135	CD
18637	12615	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12615	8	1928	1928	CD
18637	12615	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12615	10	;	;	:
18637	12615	11	Grant	Grant	NNP
18637	12615	12	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	12615	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	12615	14	Porter	Porter	NNP
18637	12615	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12615	16	_	_	NNP
18637	12615	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	12615	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12615	19	Rohde	Rohde	NNP
18637	12615	20	,	,	,
18637	12615	21	257	257	CD
18637	12615	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12615	23	469	469	CD
18637	12615	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12615	25	1922	1922	CD
18637	12615	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12615	27	;	;	:
18637	12615	28	Millers	miller	NNS
18637	12615	29	'	'	POS
18637	12615	30	Underwriters	Underwriters	NNPS
18637	12615	31	_	_	NNP
18637	12615	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	12615	33	_	_	NNP
18637	12615	34	Braud	Braud	NNP
18637	12615	35	,	,	,
18637	12615	36	270	270	CD
18637	12615	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12615	38	59	59	CD
18637	12615	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12615	40	1926	1926	CD
18637	12615	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12615	42	;	;	:
18637	12615	43	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	12615	44	parte	parte	NNP
18637	12615	45	Rosengrant	Rosengrant	NNP
18637	12615	46	,	,	,
18637	12615	47	213	213	CD
18637	12615	48	Ala.	Alabama	NNP
18637	12615	49	202	202	CD
18637	12615	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12615	51	104	104	CD
18637	12615	52	So	so	RB
18637	12615	53	.	.	.
18637	12616	1	409	409	CD
18637	12616	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12616	3	,	,	,
18637	12616	4	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	12616	5	273	273	CD
18637	12616	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12616	7	664	664	CD
18637	12616	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12616	9	1927	1927	CD
18637	12616	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12616	11	;	;	:
18637	12616	12	State	State	NNP
18637	12616	13	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	12616	14	Board	Board	NNP
18637	12616	15	of	of	IN
18637	12616	16	New	New	NNP
18637	12616	17	York	York	NNP
18637	12616	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12616	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	12616	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12616	21	Terry	Terry	NNP
18637	12616	22	&	&	CC
18637	12616	23	Tench	Tench	NNP
18637	12616	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12616	25	,	,	,
18637	12616	26	273	273	CD
18637	12616	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12616	28	639	639	CD
18637	12616	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12616	30	1926	1926	CD
18637	12616	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12616	32	;	;	:
18637	12616	33	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	12616	34	Packers	Packers	NNP
18637	12616	35	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	12616	36	.	.	.
18637	12617	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12617	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	12617	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12617	4	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	12617	5	Accident	Accident	NNP
18637	12617	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	12617	7	,	,	,
18637	12617	8	276	276	CD
18637	12617	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12617	10	467	467	CD
18637	12617	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12617	12	1928	1928	CD
18637	12617	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12617	14	.	.	.
18637	12618	1	Cases	case	NNS
18637	12618	2	cited	cite	VBD
18637	12618	3	against	against	IN
18637	12618	4	the	the	DT
18637	12618	5	claim	claim	NN
18637	12618	6	were	be	VBD
18637	12618	7	Baizley	Baizley	NNP
18637	12618	8	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	12618	9	Works	Works	NNP
18637	12618	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12618	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	12618	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12618	13	Span	Span	NNP
18637	12618	14	,	,	,
18637	12618	15	281	281	CD
18637	12618	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12618	17	222	222	CD
18637	12618	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12618	19	1930	1930	CD
18637	12618	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12618	21	;	;	:
18637	12618	22	Gonsalves	Gonsalves	NNP
18637	12618	23	_	_	NNP
18637	12618	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	12618	25	_	_	NNP
18637	12618	26	Morse	Morse	NNP
18637	12618	27	Dry	Dry	NNP
18637	12618	28	Dock	Dock	NNP
18637	12618	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12618	30	,	,	,
18637	12618	31	266	266	CD
18637	12618	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12618	33	171	171	CD
18637	12618	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12618	35	1924	1924	CD
18637	12618	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12618	37	;	;	:
18637	12618	38	Nogueira	Nogueira	NNP
18637	12618	39	_	_	NNP
18637	12618	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	12618	41	_	_	NNP
18637	12618	42	N.Y.	New York	NNP
18637	12618	43	,	,	,
18637	12618	44	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	12618	45	&	&	CC
18637	12618	46	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	12619	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12619	2	,	,	,
18637	12619	3	281	281	CD
18637	12619	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12619	5	128	128	CD
18637	12619	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12619	7	1930	1930	CD
18637	12619	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12619	9	;	;	:
18637	12619	10	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	12619	11	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	12619	12	&	&	CC
18637	12619	13	Dock	Dock	NNP
18637	12619	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12619	15	_	_	NNP
18637	12619	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	12619	17	_	_	NNP
18637	12619	18	Strand	Strand	NNP
18637	12619	19	,	,	,
18637	12619	20	278	278	CD
18637	12619	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12619	22	142	142	CD
18637	12619	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12619	24	1928	1928	CD
18637	12619	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12619	26	;	;	:
18637	12619	27	Employers	Employers	NNP
18637	12619	28	'	'	POS
18637	12619	29	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	12619	30	Assurance	Assurance	NNP
18637	12619	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12619	32	_	_	NNP
18637	12619	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	12619	34	_	_	NNP
18637	12619	35	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	12619	36	,	,	,
18637	12619	37	281	281	CD
18637	12619	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12619	39	233	233	CD
18637	12619	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12619	41	1930	1930	CD
18637	12619	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12619	43	.	.	.
18637	12620	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12620	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	12620	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12620	4	also	also	RB
18637	12620	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12620	6	cites	cite	VBZ
18637	12620	7	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
18637	12620	8	Morrison	Morrison	NNP
18637	12620	9	,	,	,
18637	12620	10	Workmen	Workmen	NNP
18637	12620	11	's	's	POS
18637	12620	12	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	12620	13	and	and	CC
18637	12620	14	the	the	DT
18637	12620	15	Maritime	Maritime	NNP
18637	12620	16	Law	Law	NNP
18637	12620	17	,	,	,
18637	12620	18	38	38	CD
18637	12620	19	Yale	Yale	NNP
18637	12620	20	L.J.	L.J.	NNP
18637	12621	1	472	472	CD
18637	12621	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12621	3	1929	1929	CD
18637	12621	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12621	5	.	.	.
18637	12622	1	In	in	IN
18637	12622	2	the	the	DT
18637	12622	3	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	12622	4	case	case	NN
18637	12622	5	the	the	DT
18637	12622	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12622	7	was	be	VBD
18637	12622	8	not	not	RB
18637	12622	9	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	12622	10	of	of	IN
18637	12622	11	exaggeration	exaggeration	NN
18637	12622	12	when	when	WRB
18637	12622	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12622	14	declared	declare	VBD
18637	12622	15	that	that	IN
18637	12622	16	"	"	``
18637	12622	17	the	the	DT
18637	12622	18	very	very	JJ
18637	12622	19	closeness	closeness	NN
18637	12622	20	of	of	IN
18637	12622	21	the	the	DT
18637	12622	22	cases	case	NNS
18637	12622	23	cited	cite	VBN
18637	12622	24	*	*	NFP
18637	12622	25	*	*	NFP
18637	12622	26	*	*	NFP
18637	12622	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	12622	28	caused	cause	VBN
18637	12622	29	much	much	JJ
18637	12622	30	serious	serious	JJ
18637	12622	31	confusion	confusion	NN
18637	12622	32	,	,	,
18637	12622	33	"	"	''
18637	12622	34	and	and	CC
18637	12622	35	went	go	VBD
18637	12622	36	on	on	RP
18637	12622	37	to	to	IN
18637	12622	38	picture	picture	NN
18637	12622	39	rather	rather	RB
18637	12622	40	vividly	vividly	RB
18637	12622	41	the	the	DT
18637	12622	42	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	12622	43	dilemma	dilemma	NN
18637	12622	44	of	of	IN
18637	12622	45	an	an	DT
18637	12622	46	injured	injure	VBN
18637	12622	47	employee	employee	NN
18637	12622	48	who	who	WP
18637	12622	49	might	may	MD
18637	12622	50	suffer	suffer	VB
18637	12622	51	great	great	JJ
18637	12622	52	financial	financial	JJ
18637	12622	53	loss	loss	NN
18637	12622	54	as	as	IN
18637	12622	55	a	a	DT
18637	12622	56	result	result	NN
18637	12622	57	of	of	IN
18637	12622	58	the	the	DT
18637	12622	59	delay	delay	NN
18637	12622	60	and	and	CC
18637	12622	61	expense	expense	NN
18637	12622	62	if	if	IN
18637	12622	63	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12622	64	guessed	guess	VBD
18637	12622	65	wrong	wrong	NN
18637	12622	66	,	,	,
18637	12622	67	and	and	CC
18637	12622	68	might	may	MD
18637	12622	69	even	even	RB
18637	12622	70	discover	discover	VB
18637	12622	71	that	that	IN
18637	12622	72	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12622	73	claim	claim	NN
18637	12622	74	was	be	VBD
18637	12622	75	"	"	``
18637	12622	76	barred	bar	VBN
18637	12622	77	by	by	IN
18637	12622	78	the	the	DT
18637	12622	79	statute	statute	NN
18637	12622	80	of	of	IN
18637	12622	81	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	12622	82	in	in	IN
18637	12622	83	the	the	DT
18637	12622	84	proper	proper	JJ
18637	12622	85	forum	forum	NN
18637	12622	86	while	while	IN
18637	12622	87	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12622	88	was	be	VBD
18637	12622	89	erroneously	erroneously	RB
18637	12622	90	pursuing	pursue	VBG
18637	12622	91	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12622	92	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	12622	93	.	.	.
18637	12622	94	"	"	''
18637	12623	1	317	317	CD
18637	12623	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12623	3	249	249	CD
18637	12623	4	,	,	,
18637	12623	5	254	254	CD
18637	12623	6	.	.	.
18637	12624	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	12624	2	the	the	DT
18637	12624	3	dilemma	dilemma	NN
18637	12624	4	affected	affect	VBD
18637	12624	5	employers	employer	NNS
18637	12624	6	who	who	WP
18637	12624	7	might	may	MD
18637	12624	8	not	not	RB
18637	12624	9	be	be	VB
18637	12624	10	protected	protect	VBN
18637	12624	11	by	by	IN
18637	12624	12	contributions	contribution	NNS
18637	12624	13	to	to	IN
18637	12624	14	a	a	DT
18637	12624	15	State	State	NNP
18637	12624	16	fund	fund	NN
18637	12624	17	and	and	CC
18637	12624	18	at	at	IN
18637	12624	19	the	the	DT
18637	12624	20	same	same	JJ
18637	12624	21	time	time	NN
18637	12624	22	be	be	VB
18637	12624	23	liable	liable	JJ
18637	12624	24	for	for	IN
18637	12624	25	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	12624	26	additional	additional	JJ
18637	12624	27	payments	payment	NNS
18637	12624	28	.	.	.
18637	12625	1	The	the	DT
18637	12625	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12625	3	had	have	VBD
18637	12625	4	harsh	harsh	JJ
18637	12625	5	words	word	NNS
18637	12625	6	for	for	IN
18637	12625	7	the	the	DT
18637	12625	8	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	12625	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	12625	10	but	but	CC
18637	12625	11	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	12625	12	that	that	IN
18637	12625	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12625	14	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	12625	15	would	would	MD
18637	12625	16	not	not	RB
18637	12625	17	solve	solve	VB
18637	12625	18	the	the	DT
18637	12625	19	problem	problem	NN
18637	12625	20	.	.	.
18637	12626	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	12626	2	.	.	.
18637	12627	1	256	256	CD
18637	12627	2	.	.	.
18637	12628	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12628	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	12628	3	also	also	RB
18637	12628	4	pointed	point	VBD
18637	12628	5	to	to	IN
18637	12628	6	Parker	Parker	NNP
18637	12628	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12628	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12628	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12628	10	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	12628	11	Boat	Boat	NNP
18637	12628	12	Sales	Sales	NNP
18637	12628	13	,	,	,
18637	12628	14	314	314	CD
18637	12628	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12628	16	244	244	CD
18637	12628	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12628	18	1941	1941	CD
18637	12628	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12628	20	,	,	,
18637	12628	21	where	where	WRB
18637	12628	22	the	the	DT
18637	12628	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12628	24	,	,	,
18637	12628	25	after	after	IN
18637	12628	26	stating	state	VBG
18637	12628	27	that	that	IN
18637	12628	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12628	29	by	by	IN
18637	12628	30	the	the	DT
18637	12628	31	Longshoremen	Longshoremen	NNP
18637	12628	32	's	's	POS
18637	12628	33	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12628	34	accepted	accept	VBD
18637	12628	35	the	the	DT
18637	12628	36	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	12628	37	line	line	NN
18637	12628	38	of	of	IN
18637	12628	39	demarcation	demarcation	NN
18637	12628	40	between	between	IN
18637	12628	41	State	State	NNP
18637	12628	42	and	and	CC
18637	12628	43	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12628	44	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12628	45	,	,	,
18637	12628	46	had	have	VBD
18637	12628	47	proceeded	proceed	VBN
18637	12628	48	to	to	TO
18637	12628	49	hold	hold	VB
18637	12628	50	that	that	DT
18637	12628	51	,	,	,
18637	12628	52	in	in	IN
18637	12628	53	shadowy	shadowy	JJ
18637	12628	54	cases	case	NNS
18637	12628	55	where	where	WRB
18637	12628	56	the	the	DT
18637	12628	57	claimant	claimant	NN
18637	12628	58	was	be	VBD
18637	12628	59	in	in	IN
18637	12628	60	a	a	DT
18637	12628	61	twilight	twilight	NN
18637	12628	62	zone	zone	NN
18637	12628	63	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12628	64	was	be	VBD
18637	12628	65	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	12628	66	to	to	TO
18637	12628	67	recover	recover	VB
18637	12628	68	under	under	IN
18637	12628	69	the	the	DT
18637	12628	70	State	State	NNP
18637	12628	71	statute	statute	NN
18637	12628	72	in	in	IN
18637	12628	73	the	the	DT
18637	12628	74	absence	absence	NN
18637	12628	75	of	of	IN
18637	12628	76	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12628	77	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	12628	78	action	action	NN
18637	12628	79	under	under	IN
18637	12628	80	the	the	DT
18637	12628	81	Longshoremen	Longshoremen	NNP
18637	12628	82	's	's	POS
18637	12628	83	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12628	84	on	on	IN
18637	12628	85	the	the	DT
18637	12628	86	ground	ground	NN
18637	12628	87	of	of	IN
18637	12628	88	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12628	89	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	12628	90	.	.	.
18637	12629	1	In	in	IN
18637	12629	2	brief	brief	NN
18637	12629	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12629	4	would	would	MD
18637	12629	5	seem	seem	VB
18637	12629	6	that	that	IN
18637	12629	7	in	in	IN
18637	12629	8	shadowy	shadowy	JJ
18637	12629	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	12629	10	a	a	DT
18637	12629	11	claimant	claimant	NN
18637	12629	12	may	may	MD
18637	12629	13	elect	elect	VB
18637	12629	14	either	either	CC
18637	12629	15	a	a	DT
18637	12629	16	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12629	17	court	court	NN
18637	12629	18	applying	apply	VBG
18637	12629	19	the	the	DT
18637	12629	20	Longshoremen	Longshoremen	NNP
18637	12629	21	's	's	POS
18637	12629	22	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12629	23	or	or	CC
18637	12629	24	a	a	DT
18637	12629	25	State	State	NNP
18637	12629	26	forum	forum	NN
18637	12629	27	applying	apply	VBG
18637	12629	28	the	the	DT
18637	12629	29	State	State	NNP
18637	12629	30	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	12629	31	law	law	NN
18637	12629	32	.	.	.
18637	12630	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12630	2	399	399	CD
18637	12630	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12630	4	317	317	CD
18637	12630	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12630	6	219	219	CD
18637	12630	7	,	,	,
18637	12630	8	259	259	CD
18637	12630	9	.	.	.
18637	12631	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12631	2	400	400	CD
18637	12631	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12631	4	21	21	CD
18637	12631	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12631	6	.	.	.
18637	12632	1	558	558	CD
18637	12632	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12632	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	12632	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12632	5	.	.	.
18637	12633	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12633	2	401	401	CD
18637	12633	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12633	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12633	5	.	.	.
18637	12634	1	572	572	CD
18637	12634	2	.	.	.
18637	12635	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12635	2	402	402	CD
18637	12635	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12635	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12635	5	.	.	.
18637	12636	1	574	574	CD
18637	12636	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12636	3	575	575	CD
18637	12636	4	.	.	.
18637	12637	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12637	2	403	403	CD
18637	12637	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12637	4	The	the	DT
18637	12637	5	"	"	``
18637	12637	6	Lottawanna	Lottawanna	NNP
18637	12637	7	,	,	,
18637	12637	8	"	"	''
18637	12637	9	21	21	CD
18637	12637	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12637	11	.	.	.
18637	12638	1	558	558	CD
18637	12638	2	,	,	,
18637	12638	3	577	577	CD
18637	12638	4	.	.	.
18637	12639	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12639	2	404	404	CD
18637	12639	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12639	4	In	in	IN
18637	12639	5	re	re	NN
18637	12639	6	Garnett	Garnett	NNP
18637	12639	7	,	,	,
18637	12639	8	141	141	CD
18637	12639	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12639	10	1	1	CD
18637	12639	11	,	,	,
18637	12639	12	12	12	CD
18637	12639	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12639	14	1891	1891	CD
18637	12639	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12639	16	.	.	.
18637	12640	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12640	2	405	405	CD
18637	12640	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12640	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12640	5	.	.	.
18637	12641	1	14	14	CD
18637	12641	2	.	.	.
18637	12642	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12642	2	406	406	CD
18637	12642	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12642	4	244	244	CD
18637	12642	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12642	6	205	205	CD
18637	12642	7	,	,	,
18637	12642	8	215	215	CD
18637	12642	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12642	10	1917	1917	CD
18637	12642	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12642	12	,	,	,
18637	12642	13	citing	cite	VBG
18637	12642	14	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	12642	15	_	_	NNP
18637	12642	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	12642	17	_	_	NNP
18637	12642	18	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	12642	19	&	&	CC
18637	12642	20	Savannah	Savannah	NNP
18637	12642	21	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	12642	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12642	23	,	,	,
18637	12642	24	130	130	CD
18637	12642	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12642	26	527	527	CD
18637	12642	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12642	28	1889	1889	CD
18637	12642	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12642	30	,	,	,
18637	12642	31	and	and	CC
18637	12642	32	In	in	IN
18637	12642	33	re	re	IN
18637	12642	34	Garnett	Garnett	NNP
18637	12642	35	,	,	,
18637	12642	36	141	141	CD
18637	12642	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12642	38	1	1	CD
18637	12642	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12642	40	1891	1891	CD
18637	12642	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12642	42	.	.	.
18637	12643	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12643	2	407	407	CD
18637	12643	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12643	4	253	253	CD
18637	12643	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12643	6	149	149	CD
18637	12643	7	,	,	,
18637	12643	8	160	160	CD
18637	12643	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12643	10	1920	1920	CD
18637	12643	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12643	12	.	.	.
18637	12644	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12644	2	408	408	CD
18637	12644	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12644	4	328	328	CD
18637	12644	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12644	6	1	1	CD
18637	12644	7	,	,	,
18637	12644	8	5	5	CD
18637	12644	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12644	10	1946	1946	CD
18637	12644	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12644	12	,	,	,
18637	12644	13	citing	cite	VBG
18637	12644	14	O'Donnell	O'Donnell	NNP
18637	12644	15	_	_	NNP
18637	12644	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	12644	17	_	_	NNP
18637	12644	18	Great	Great	NNP
18637	12644	19	Lakes	Lakes	NNP
18637	12644	20	Dredge	Dredge	NNP
18637	12644	21	&	&	CC
18637	12644	22	Dock	Dock	NNP
18637	12644	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12644	24	,	,	,
18637	12644	25	318	318	CD
18637	12644	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12644	27	36	36	CD
18637	12644	28	,	,	,
18637	12644	29	40	40	CD
18637	12644	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12644	31	1943	1943	CD
18637	12644	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12644	33	,	,	,
18637	12644	34	and	and	CC
18637	12644	35	the	the	DT
18637	12644	36	cases	case	NNS
18637	12644	37	cited	cite	VBN
18637	12644	38	therein	therein	RB
18637	12644	39	.	.	.
18637	12645	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12645	2	409	409	CD
18637	12645	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12645	4	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	12645	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12645	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12645	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12645	8	Department	Department	NNP
18637	12645	9	of	of	IN
18637	12645	10	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	12645	11	,	,	,
18637	12645	12	317	317	CD
18637	12645	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12645	14	249	249	CD
18637	12645	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12645	16	1942	1942	CD
18637	12645	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12645	18	.	.	.
18637	12646	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12646	2	410	410	CD
18637	12646	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12646	4	2	2	CD
18637	12646	5	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	12646	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12646	7	2d	2d	NNP
18637	12646	8	ed	ed	NNP
18637	12646	9	.	.	NNP
18637	12646	10	,	,	,
18637	12646	11	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	12646	12	,	,	,
18637	12646	13	1851	1851	CD
18637	12646	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12646	15	,	,	,
18637	12646	16	§	§	NNP
18637	12646	17	1674	1674	CD
18637	12646	18	.	.	.
18637	12647	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12647	2	411	411	CD
18637	12647	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12647	4	Dugan	Dugan	NNP
18637	12647	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12647	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12647	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12647	8	United	United	NNP
18637	12647	9	States	States	NNP
18637	12647	10	,	,	,
18637	12647	11	3	3	CD
18637	12647	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12647	13	.	.	.
18637	12648	1	172	172	CD
18637	12648	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12648	3	1818	1818	CD
18637	12648	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12648	5	.	.	.
18637	12649	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12649	2	412	412	CD
18637	12649	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12649	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12649	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12649	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12649	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12649	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12649	9	San	San	NNP
18637	12649	10	Jacinto	Jacinto	NNP
18637	12649	11	Tin	Tin	NNP
18637	12649	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12649	13	,	,	,
18637	12649	14	125	125	CD
18637	12649	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12649	16	273	273	CD
18637	12649	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12649	18	1888	1888	CD
18637	12649	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12649	20	;	;	:
18637	12649	21	United	United	NNP
18637	12649	22	States	States	NNP
18637	12649	23	_	_	NNP
18637	12649	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	12649	25	_	_	NNP
18637	12649	26	Beebe	Beebe	NNP
18637	12649	27	,	,	,
18637	12649	28	127	127	CD
18637	12649	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12649	30	338	338	CD
18637	12649	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12649	32	1888	1888	CD
18637	12649	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12649	34	;	;	:
18637	12649	35	United	United	NNP
18637	12649	36	States	States	NNP
18637	12649	37	_	_	NNP
18637	12649	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	12649	39	_	_	NNP
18637	12649	40	American	American	NNP
18637	12649	41	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	12649	42	Tel	Tel	NNP
18637	12649	43	.	.	.
18637	12650	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12650	2	,	,	,
18637	12650	3	128	128	CD
18637	12650	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12650	5	315	315	CD
18637	12650	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12650	7	1888	1888	CD
18637	12650	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12650	9	.	.	.
18637	12651	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12651	2	413	413	CD
18637	12651	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12651	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12651	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12651	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12651	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12651	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12651	9	San	San	NNP
18637	12651	10	Jacinto	Jacinto	NNP
18637	12651	11	Tin	Tin	NNP
18637	12651	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12651	13	,	,	,
18637	12651	14	125	125	CD
18637	12651	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12651	16	273	273	CD
18637	12651	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12651	18	1888	1888	CD
18637	12651	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12651	20	.	.	.
18637	12652	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12652	2	414	414	CD
18637	12652	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12652	4	28	28	CD
18637	12652	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	12653	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	12653	2	1331	1331	CD
18637	12653	3	-	-	SYM
18637	12653	4	1332	1332	CD
18637	12653	5	.	.	.
18637	12654	1	The	the	DT
18637	12654	2	original	original	JJ
18637	12654	3	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12654	4	of	of	IN
18637	12654	5	the	the	DT
18637	12654	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12654	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12654	8	does	do	VBZ
18637	12654	9	not	not	RB
18637	12654	10	extend	extend	VB
18637	12654	11	to	to	IN
18637	12654	12	suits	suit	NNS
18637	12654	13	brought	bring	VBN
18637	12654	14	by	by	IN
18637	12654	15	the	the	DT
18637	12654	16	United	United	NNP
18637	12654	17	States	States	NNP
18637	12654	18	against	against	IN
18637	12654	19	persons	person	NNS
18637	12654	20	or	or	CC
18637	12654	21	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	12654	22	alone	alone	RB
18637	12654	23	.	.	.
18637	12655	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12655	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12655	3	also	also	RB
18637	12655	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12655	5	Revised	Revised	NNP
18637	12655	6	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	12655	7	,	,	,
18637	12655	8	§§	§§	NNP
18637	12655	9	565	565	CD
18637	12655	10	,	,	,
18637	12655	11	629	629	CD
18637	12655	12	.	.	.
18637	12656	1	United	United	NNP
18637	12656	2	States	States	NNP
18637	12656	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12656	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	12656	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12656	6	West	West	NNP
18637	12656	7	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	12656	8	,	,	,
18637	12656	9	295	295	CD
18637	12656	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12656	11	463	463	CD
18637	12656	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12656	13	1935	1935	CD
18637	12656	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12656	15	.	.	.
18637	12657	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12657	2	415	415	CD
18637	12657	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12657	4	136	136	CD
18637	12657	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12657	6	211	211	CD
18637	12657	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12657	8	1890	1890	CD
18637	12657	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12657	10	.	.	.
18637	12658	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12658	2	416	416	CD
18637	12658	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12658	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12658	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12658	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12658	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12658	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12658	9	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	12658	10	,	,	,
18637	12658	11	143	143	CD
18637	12658	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12658	13	621	621	CD
18637	12658	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12658	15	1892	1892	CD
18637	12658	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12658	17	.	.	.
18637	12659	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12659	2	417	417	CD
18637	12659	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12659	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12659	5	.	.	.
18637	12660	1	642	642	CD
18637	12660	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12660	3	646	646	CD
18637	12660	4	.	.	.
18637	12661	1	This	this	DT
18637	12661	2	suit	suit	NN
18637	12661	3	,	,	,
18637	12661	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12661	5	may	may	MD
18637	12661	6	be	be	VB
18637	12661	7	noted	note	VBN
18637	12661	8	,	,	,
18637	12661	9	was	be	VBD
18637	12661	10	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	12661	11	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	12661	12	by	by	IN
18637	12661	13	the	the	DT
18637	12661	14	act	act	NN
18637	12661	15	of	of	IN
18637	12661	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12661	17	of	of	IN
18637	12661	18	May	May	NNP
18637	12661	19	2	2	CD
18637	12661	20	,	,	,
18637	12661	21	1890	1890	CD
18637	12661	22	,	,	,
18637	12661	23	providing	provide	VBG
18637	12661	24	for	for	IN
18637	12661	25	a	a	DT
18637	12661	26	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	12661	27	government	government	NN
18637	12661	28	for	for	IN
18637	12661	29	the	the	DT
18637	12661	30	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	12661	31	territory	territory	NN
18637	12661	32	to	to	TO
18637	12661	33	determine	determine	VB
18637	12661	34	the	the	DT
18637	12661	35	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	12661	36	of	of	IN
18637	12661	37	Greer	Greer	NNP
18637	12661	38	County	County	NNP
18637	12661	39	.	.	.
18637	12662	1	26	26	CD
18637	12662	2	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	12662	3	.	.	.
18637	12663	1	81	81	CD
18637	12663	2	,	,	,
18637	12663	3	92	92	CD
18637	12663	4	,	,	,
18637	12663	5	§	§	NNP
18637	12663	6	25	25	CD
18637	12663	7	.	.	.
18637	12664	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12664	2	418	418	CD
18637	12664	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12664	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12664	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12664	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12664	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12664	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12664	9	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	12664	10	,	,	,
18637	12664	11	270	270	CD
18637	12664	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12664	13	181	181	CD
18637	12664	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12664	15	1926	1926	CD
18637	12664	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12664	17	.	.	.
18637	12665	1	For	for	IN
18637	12665	2	an	an	DT
18637	12665	3	earlier	early	JJR
18637	12665	4	suit	suit	NN
18637	12665	5	against	against	IN
18637	12665	6	a	a	DT
18637	12665	7	State	state	NN
18637	12665	8	by	by	IN
18637	12665	9	the	the	DT
18637	12665	10	United	United	NNP
18637	12665	11	States	States	NNP
18637	12665	12	,	,	,
18637	12665	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12665	14	see	see	VBP
18637	12665	15	_	_	NNP
18637	12665	16	United	United	NNP
18637	12665	17	States	States	NNP
18637	12665	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12665	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	12665	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12665	21	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	12665	22	,	,	,
18637	12665	23	190	190	CD
18637	12665	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12665	25	379	379	CD
18637	12665	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12665	27	1903	1903	CD
18637	12665	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12665	29	.	.	.
18637	12666	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12666	2	419	419	CD
18637	12666	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12666	4	295	295	CD
18637	12666	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12666	6	463	463	CD
18637	12666	7	,	,	,
18637	12666	8	471	471	CD
18637	12666	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12666	10	475	475	CD
18637	12666	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12666	12	1935	1935	CD
18637	12666	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12666	14	.	.	.
18637	12667	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12667	2	420	420	CD
18637	12667	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12667	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12667	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12667	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12667	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12667	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12667	9	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	12667	10	,	,	,
18637	12667	11	283	283	CD
18637	12667	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12667	13	64	64	CD
18637	12667	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12667	15	1931	1931	CD
18637	12667	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12667	17	.	.	.
18637	12668	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12668	2	421	421	CD
18637	12668	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12668	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12668	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12668	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12668	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12668	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12668	9	California	California	NNP
18637	12668	10	,	,	,
18637	12668	11	332	332	CD
18637	12668	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12668	13	19	19	CD
18637	12668	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12668	15	1947	1947	CD
18637	12668	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12668	17	.	.	.
18637	12669	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12669	2	422	422	CD
18637	12669	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12669	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12669	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12669	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12669	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12669	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12669	9	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	12669	10	,	,	,
18637	12669	11	339	339	CD
18637	12669	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12669	13	699	699	CD
18637	12669	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12669	15	1950	1950	CD
18637	12669	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12669	17	;	;	:
18637	12669	18	United	United	NNP
18637	12669	19	States	States	NNP
18637	12669	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12669	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	12669	22	_	_	NNP
18637	12669	23	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	12669	24	,	,	,
18637	12669	25	339	339	CD
18637	12669	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12669	27	707	707	CD
18637	12669	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12669	29	1950	1950	CD
18637	12669	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12669	31	.	.	.
18637	12670	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12670	2	423	423	CD
18637	12670	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12670	4	2	2	CD
18637	12670	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12670	6	.	.	.
18637	12671	1	419	419	CD
18637	12671	2	,	,	,
18637	12671	3	478	478	CD
18637	12671	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12671	5	1793	1793	CD
18637	12671	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12671	7	.	.	.
18637	12672	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12672	2	424	424	CD
18637	12672	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12672	4	6	6	CD
18637	12672	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12672	6	.	.	.
18637	12673	1	264	264	CD
18637	12673	2	,	,	,
18637	12673	3	412	412	CD
18637	12673	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12673	5	1821	1821	CD
18637	12673	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12673	7	.	.	.
18637	12674	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12674	2	425	425	CD
18637	12674	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12674	4	8	8	CD
18637	12674	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12674	6	.	.	.
18637	12675	1	436	436	CD
18637	12675	2	,	,	,
18637	12675	3	444	444	CD
18637	12675	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12675	5	1834	1834	CD
18637	12675	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12675	7	.	.	.
18637	12676	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12676	2	426	426	CD
18637	12676	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12676	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12676	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12676	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12676	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12676	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12676	9	McLemore	McLemore	NNP
18637	12676	10	,	,	,
18637	12676	11	4	4	CD
18637	12676	12	How	how	WRB
18637	12676	13	.	.	.
18637	12677	1	286	286	CD
18637	12677	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12677	3	1846	1846	CD
18637	12677	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12677	5	;	;	:
18637	12677	6	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	12677	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12677	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12677	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12677	10	United	United	NNP
18637	12677	11	States	States	NNP
18637	12677	12	,	,	,
18637	12677	13	9	9	CD
18637	12677	14	How	how	WRB
18637	12677	15	.	.	.
18637	12678	1	386	386	CD
18637	12678	2	,	,	,
18637	12678	3	389	389	CD
18637	12678	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12678	5	1850	1850	CD
18637	12678	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12678	7	;	;	:
18637	12678	8	DeGroot	DeGroot	NNP
18637	12678	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12678	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12678	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12678	12	United	United	NNP
18637	12678	13	States	States	NNP
18637	12678	14	,	,	,
18637	12678	15	5	5	CD
18637	12678	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12678	17	.	.	.
18637	12679	1	419	419	CD
18637	12679	2	,	,	,
18637	12679	3	431	431	CD
18637	12679	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12679	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	12679	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12679	7	;	;	:
18637	12679	8	United	United	NNP
18637	12679	9	States	States	NNP
18637	12679	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12679	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	12679	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12679	13	Eckford	Eckford	NNP
18637	12679	14	,	,	,
18637	12679	15	6	6	CD
18637	12679	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12679	17	.	.	.
18637	12680	1	484	484	CD
18637	12680	2	,	,	,
18637	12680	3	488	488	CD
18637	12680	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12680	5	1868	1868	CD
18637	12680	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12680	7	;	;	:
18637	12680	8	The	the	DT
18637	12680	9	Siren	Siren	NNP
18637	12680	10	,	,	,
18637	12680	11	7	7	CD
18637	12680	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12680	13	.	.	.
18637	12681	1	152	152	CD
18637	12681	2	,	,	,
18637	12681	3	154	154	CD
18637	12681	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12681	5	1869	1869	CD
18637	12681	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12681	7	;	;	:
18637	12681	8	Nichols	Nichols	NNP
18637	12681	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12681	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12681	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12681	12	United	United	NNP
18637	12681	13	States	States	NNP
18637	12681	14	,	,	,
18637	12681	15	7	7	CD
18637	12681	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12681	17	.	.	.
18637	12682	1	122	122	CD
18637	12682	2	,	,	,
18637	12682	3	126	126	CD
18637	12682	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12682	5	1869	1869	CD
18637	12682	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12682	7	;	;	:
18637	12682	8	The	the	DT
18637	12682	9	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	12682	10	,	,	,
18637	12682	11	10	10	CD
18637	12682	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12682	13	.	.	.
18637	12683	1	15	15	CD
18637	12683	2	,	,	,
18637	12683	3	20	20	CD
18637	12683	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12683	5	1870	1870	CD
18637	12683	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12683	7	;	;	:
18637	12683	8	Carr	Carr	NNP
18637	12683	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12683	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12683	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12683	12	United	United	NNP
18637	12683	13	States	States	NNP
18637	12683	14	,	,	,
18637	12683	15	98	98	CD
18637	12683	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12683	17	433	433	CD
18637	12683	18	,	,	,
18637	12683	19	437	437	CD
18637	12683	20	-	-	SYM
18637	12683	21	439	439	CD
18637	12683	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12683	23	1879	1879	CD
18637	12683	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12683	25	.	.	.
18637	12684	1	"	"	``
18637	12684	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12684	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	12684	4	also	also	RB
18637	12684	5	clear	clear	JJ
18637	12684	6	that	that	IN
18637	12684	7	the	the	DT
18637	12684	8	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	12684	9	Government	Government	NNP
18637	12684	10	,	,	,
18637	12684	11	in	in	IN
18637	12684	12	the	the	DT
18637	12684	13	absence	absence	NN
18637	12684	14	of	of	IN
18637	12684	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12684	16	consent	consent	NN
18637	12684	17	,	,	,
18637	12684	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	12684	19	not	not	RB
18637	12684	20	liable	liable	JJ
18637	12684	21	in	in	IN
18637	12684	22	tort	tort	NN
18637	12684	23	for	for	IN
18637	12684	24	the	the	DT
18637	12684	25	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	12684	26	of	of	IN
18637	12684	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12684	28	agents	agent	NNS
18637	12684	29	or	or	CC
18637	12684	30	employees	employee	NNS
18637	12684	31	.	.	.
18637	12685	1	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	12685	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12685	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12685	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12685	5	United	United	NNP
18637	12685	6	States	States	NNP
18637	12685	7	,	,	,
18637	12685	8	8	8	CD
18637	12685	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12685	10	.	.	.
18637	12686	1	269	269	CD
18637	12686	2	,	,	,
18637	12686	3	275	275	CD
18637	12686	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12686	5	1869	1869	CD
18637	12686	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12686	7	;	;	:
18637	12686	8	Peabody	Peabody	NNP
18637	12686	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12686	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12686	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12686	12	United	United	NNP
18637	12686	13	States	States	NNP
18637	12686	14	,	,	,
18637	12686	15	231	231	CD
18637	12686	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12686	17	530	530	CD
18637	12686	18	,	,	,
18637	12686	19	539	539	CD
18637	12686	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12686	21	1913	1913	CD
18637	12686	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12686	23	;	;	:
18637	12686	24	Keokuk	Keokuk	NNP
18637	12686	25	&	&	CC
18637	12686	26	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	12686	27	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	12686	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12686	29	_	_	NNP
18637	12686	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	12686	31	_	_	NNP
18637	12686	32	United	United	NNP
18637	12686	33	States	States	NNP
18637	12686	34	,	,	,
18637	12686	35	260	260	CD
18637	12686	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12686	37	125	125	CD
18637	12686	38	,	,	,
18637	12686	39	127	127	CD
18637	12686	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12686	41	1922	1922	CD
18637	12686	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12686	43	.	.	.
18637	12687	1	The	the	DT
18637	12687	2	reason	reason	NN
18637	12687	3	for	for	IN
18637	12687	4	such	such	JJ
18637	12687	5	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	12687	6	as	as	IN
18637	12687	7	stated	state	VBN
18637	12687	8	by	by	IN
18637	12687	9	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	12687	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12687	11	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	12687	12	in	in	IN
18637	12687	13	Kawananakoa	Kawananakoa	NNP
18637	12687	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12687	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	12687	16	_	_	NNP
18637	12687	17	Polyblank	Polyblank	NNP
18637	12687	18	,	,	,
18637	12687	19	205	205	CD
18637	12687	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12687	21	349	349	CD
18637	12687	22	,	,	,
18637	12687	23	353	353	CD
18637	12687	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12687	25	1907	1907	CD
18637	12687	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12687	27	,	,	,
18637	12687	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	12687	29	because	because	IN
18637	12687	30	'	'	``
18637	12687	31	there	there	EX
18637	12687	32	can	can	MD
18637	12687	33	be	be	VB
18637	12687	34	no	no	DT
18637	12687	35	legal	legal	JJ
18637	12687	36	right	right	NN
18637	12687	37	as	as	IN
18637	12687	38	against	against	IN
18637	12687	39	the	the	DT
18637	12687	40	authority	authority	NN
18637	12687	41	that	that	WDT
18637	12687	42	makes	make	VBZ
18637	12687	43	the	the	DT
18637	12687	44	law	law	NN
18637	12687	45	on	on	IN
18637	12687	46	which	which	WDT
18637	12687	47	the	the	DT
18637	12687	48	right	right	NN
18637	12687	49	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	12687	50	.	.	.
18637	12687	51	'	'	''
18637	12688	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12688	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12688	3	also	also	RB
18637	12688	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12688	5	The	the	DT
18637	12688	6	Western	Western	NNP
18637	12688	7	Maid	Maid	NNP
18637	12688	8	,	,	,
18637	12688	9	257	257	CD
18637	12688	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12688	11	419	419	CD
18637	12688	12	,	,	,
18637	12688	13	433	433	CD
18637	12688	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12688	15	1922	1922	CD
18637	12688	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12688	17	.	.	.
18637	12689	1	As	as	IN
18637	12689	2	the	the	DT
18637	12689	3	Housing	Housing	NNP
18637	12689	4	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12689	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	12689	6	not	not	RB
18637	12689	7	purport	purport	VB
18637	12689	8	to	to	TO
18637	12689	9	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	12689	10	suits	suit	NNS
18637	12689	11	against	against	IN
18637	12689	12	the	the	DT
18637	12689	13	United	United	NNP
18637	12689	14	States	States	NNP
18637	12689	15	as	as	IN
18637	12689	16	such	such	JJ
18637	12689	17	,	,	,
18637	12689	18	the	the	DT
18637	12689	19	question	question	NN
18637	12689	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	12689	21	whether	whether	IN
18637	12689	22	the	the	DT
18637	12689	23	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	12689	24	--	--	:
18637	12689	25	which	which	WDT
18637	12689	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	12689	27	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	12689	28	an	an	DT
18637	12689	29	agency	agency	NN
18637	12689	30	of	of	IN
18637	12689	31	the	the	DT
18637	12689	32	United	United	NNP
18637	12689	33	States	States	NNP
18637	12689	34	--	--	:
18637	12689	35	partakes	partake	NNS
18637	12689	36	of	of	IN
18637	12689	37	this	this	DT
18637	12689	38	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	12689	39	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	12689	40	.	.	.
18637	12690	1	The	the	DT
18637	12690	2	answer	answer	NN
18637	12690	3	must	must	MD
18637	12690	4	be	be	VB
18637	12690	5	sought	seek	VBN
18637	12690	6	in	in	IN
18637	12690	7	the	the	DT
18637	12690	8	intention	intention	NN
18637	12690	9	of	of	IN
18637	12690	10	the	the	DT
18637	12690	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12690	12	.	.	.
18637	12691	1	Sloan	Sloan	NNP
18637	12691	2	Shipyards	Shipyards	NNP
18637	12691	3	case	case	NN
18637	12691	4	,	,	,
18637	12691	5	258	258	CD
18637	12691	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12691	7	549	549	CD
18637	12691	8	,	,	,
18637	12691	9	570	570	CD
18637	12691	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12691	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	12691	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12691	13	;	;	:
18637	12691	14	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	12691	15	Land	Land	NNP
18637	12691	16	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	12691	17	_	_	NNP
18637	12691	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	12691	19	_	_	NNP
18637	12691	20	Priddy	Priddy	NNP
18637	12691	21	,	,	,
18637	12691	22	295	295	CD
18637	12691	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12691	24	229	229	CD
18637	12691	25	,	,	,
18637	12691	26	231	231	CD
18637	12691	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12691	28	1935	1935	CD
18637	12691	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12691	30	.	.	.
18637	12692	1	This	this	DT
18637	12692	2	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	12692	3	a	a	DT
18637	12692	4	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	12692	5	of	of	IN
18637	12692	6	the	the	DT
18637	12692	7	extent	extent	NN
18637	12692	8	to	to	TO
18637	12692	9	which	which	WDT
18637	12692	10	other	other	JJ
18637	12692	11	Government	government	NN
18637	12692	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	12692	13	owned	own	VBN
18637	12692	14	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	12692	15	have	have	VBP
18637	12692	16	been	be	VBN
18637	12692	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	12692	18	liable	liable	JJ
18637	12692	19	for	for	IN
18637	12692	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12692	21	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
18637	12692	22	acts	act	NNS
18637	12692	23	.	.	.
18637	12692	24	"	"	''
18637	12693	1	39	39	CD
18637	12693	2	Op	Op	NNP
18637	12693	3	.	.	.
18637	12694	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	12694	2	.	.	.
18637	12695	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	12695	2	559	559	CD
18637	12695	3	,	,	,
18637	12695	4	562	562	CD
18637	12695	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12695	6	1938	1938	CD
18637	12695	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12695	8	.	.	.
18637	12696	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12696	2	427	427	CD
18637	12696	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12696	4	106	106	CD
18637	12696	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12696	6	196	196	CD
18637	12696	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12696	8	1882	1882	CD
18637	12696	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12696	10	.	.	.
18637	12697	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12697	2	428	428	CD
18637	12697	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12697	4	Lonergan	Lonergan	NNP
18637	12697	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12697	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12697	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12697	8	United	United	NNP
18637	12697	9	States	States	NNP
18637	12697	10	,	,	,
18637	12697	11	303	303	CD
18637	12697	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12697	13	33	33	CD
18637	12697	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12697	15	1938	1938	CD
18637	12697	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12697	17	.	.	.
18637	12698	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12698	2	429	429	CD
18637	12698	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12698	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12698	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12698	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12698	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12698	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12698	9	N.Y.	New York	NNP
18637	12698	10	Rayon	Rayon	NNP
18637	12698	11	Importing	Importing	NNP
18637	12698	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12698	13	,	,	,
18637	12698	14	329	329	CD
18637	12698	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12698	16	654	654	CD
18637	12698	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12698	18	1947	1947	CD
18637	12698	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12698	20	.	.	.
18637	12699	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12699	2	430	430	CD
18637	12699	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12699	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12699	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12699	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12699	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12699	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12699	9	Shaw	Shaw	NNP
18637	12699	10	,	,	,
18637	12699	11	309	309	CD
18637	12699	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12699	13	495	495	CD
18637	12699	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12699	15	1940	1940	CD
18637	12699	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12699	17	.	.	.
18637	12700	1	Here	here	RB
18637	12700	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12700	3	was	be	VBD
18637	12700	4	said	say	VBN
18637	12700	5	that	that	IN
18637	12700	6	the	the	DT
18637	12700	7	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	12700	8	for	for	IN
18637	12700	9	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	12700	10	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	12700	11	"	"	``
18637	12700	12	partake	partake	VBP
18637	12700	13	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	12700	14	of	of	IN
18637	12700	15	dignity	dignity	NN
18637	12700	16	and	and	CC
18637	12700	17	decorum	decorum	NN
18637	12700	18	,	,	,
18637	12700	19	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	12700	20	of	of	IN
18637	12700	21	practical	practical	JJ
18637	12700	22	administration	administration	NN
18637	12700	23	,	,	,
18637	12700	24	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	12700	25	of	of	IN
18637	12700	26	the	the	DT
18637	12700	27	political	political	JJ
18637	12700	28	desirability	desirability	NN
18637	12700	29	of	of	IN
18637	12700	30	an	an	DT
18637	12700	31	impregnable	impregnable	JJ
18637	12700	32	legal	legal	JJ
18637	12700	33	citadel	citadel	NN
18637	12700	34	where	where	WRB
18637	12700	35	government	government	NN
18637	12700	36	,	,	,
18637	12700	37	as	as	IN
18637	12700	38	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	12700	39	from	from	IN
18637	12700	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12700	41	functionaries	functionary	NNS
18637	12700	42	may	may	MD
18637	12700	43	operate	operate	VB
18637	12700	44	undisturbed	undisturbed	JJ
18637	12700	45	by	by	IN
18637	12700	46	the	the	DT
18637	12700	47	demands	demand	NNS
18637	12700	48	of	of	IN
18637	12700	49	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	12700	50	,	,	,
18637	12700	51	"	"	''
18637	12700	52	ibid	ibid	NNP
18637	12700	53	.	.	.
18637	12701	1	500	500	CD
18637	12701	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12701	3	501	501	CD
18637	12701	4	.	.	.
18637	12702	1	The	the	DT
18637	12702	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12702	3	went	go	VBD
18637	12702	4	on	on	RP
18637	12702	5	to	to	TO
18637	12702	6	hold	hold	VB
18637	12702	7	that	that	IN
18637	12702	8	when	when	WRB
18637	12702	9	the	the	DT
18637	12702	10	United	United	NNP
18637	12702	11	States	States	NNP
18637	12702	12	took	take	VBD
18637	12702	13	possession	possession	NN
18637	12702	14	of	of	IN
18637	12702	15	the	the	DT
18637	12702	16	assets	asset	NNS
18637	12702	17	of	of	IN
18637	12702	18	Fleet	Fleet	NNP
18637	12702	19	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	12702	20	and	and	CC
18637	12702	21	assumed	assume	VBD
18637	12702	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12702	23	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	12702	24	,	,	,
18637	12702	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12702	26	did	do	VBD
18637	12702	27	not	not	RB
18637	12702	28	waive	waive	VB
18637	12702	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12702	30	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	12702	31	from	from	IN
18637	12702	32	suit	suit	NN
18637	12702	33	in	in	IN
18637	12702	34	a	a	DT
18637	12702	35	State	State	NNP
18637	12702	36	court	court	NN
18637	12702	37	on	on	IN
18637	12702	38	a	a	DT
18637	12702	39	counterclaim	counterclaim	NN
18637	12702	40	based	base	VBN
18637	12702	41	on	on	IN
18637	12702	42	the	the	DT
18637	12702	43	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	12702	44	's	's	POS
18637	12702	45	breach	breach	NN
18637	12702	46	of	of	IN
18637	12702	47	contract	contract	NN
18637	12702	48	,	,	,
18637	12702	49	ibid	ibid	NNP
18637	12702	50	.	.	.
18637	12703	1	505	505	CD
18637	12703	2	.	.	.
18637	12704	1	Any	any	DT
18637	12704	2	consent	consent	NN
18637	12704	3	to	to	TO
18637	12704	4	be	be	VB
18637	12704	5	sued	sue	VBN
18637	12704	6	will	will	MD
18637	12704	7	not	not	RB
18637	12704	8	be	be	VB
18637	12704	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	12704	10	to	to	TO
18637	12704	11	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	12704	12	action	action	NN
18637	12704	13	in	in	IN
18637	12704	14	the	the	DT
18637	12704	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12704	16	courts	court	NNS
18637	12704	17	unless	unless	IN
18637	12704	18	the	the	DT
18637	12704	19	language	language	NN
18637	12704	20	giving	give	VBG
18637	12704	21	consent	consent	NN
18637	12704	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	12704	23	clear	clear	JJ
18637	12704	24	.	.	.
18637	12705	1	Great	Great	NNP
18637	12705	2	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	12705	3	Life	Life	NNP
18637	12705	4	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	12705	5	.	.	.
18637	12706	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12706	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12706	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12706	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12706	5	Read	Read	NNP
18637	12706	6	,	,	,
18637	12706	7	322	322	CD
18637	12706	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12706	9	47	47	CD
18637	12706	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12706	11	1944	1944	CD
18637	12706	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12706	13	.	.	.
18637	12707	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12707	2	431	431	CD
18637	12707	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12707	4	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	12707	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12707	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12707	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12707	8	United	United	NNP
18637	12707	9	States	States	NNP
18637	12707	10	,	,	,
18637	12707	11	305	305	CD
18637	12707	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12707	13	382	382	CD
18637	12707	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12707	15	1939	1939	CD
18637	12707	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12707	17	.	.	.
18637	12708	1	The	the	DT
18637	12708	2	United	United	NNP
18637	12708	3	States	States	NNP
18637	12708	4	was	be	VBD
18637	12708	5	held	hold	VBN
18637	12708	6	here	here	RB
18637	12708	7	to	to	TO
18637	12708	8	be	be	VB
18637	12708	9	an	an	DT
18637	12708	10	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
18637	12708	11	party	party	NN
18637	12708	12	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	12708	13	in	in	IN
18637	12708	14	a	a	DT
18637	12708	15	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	12708	16	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	12708	17	brought	bring	VBN
18637	12708	18	by	by	IN
18637	12708	19	a	a	DT
18637	12708	20	State	State	NNP
18637	12708	21	to	to	TO
18637	12708	22	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	12708	23	a	a	DT
18637	12708	24	right	right	NN
18637	12708	25	of	of	IN
18637	12708	26	way	way	NN
18637	12708	27	over	over	IN
18637	12708	28	lands	land	NNS
18637	12708	29	owned	own	VBN
18637	12708	30	by	by	IN
18637	12708	31	the	the	DT
18637	12708	32	United	United	NNP
18637	12708	33	States	States	NNP
18637	12708	34	and	and	CC
18637	12708	35	held	hold	VBN
18637	12708	36	in	in	IN
18637	12708	37	trust	trust	NN
18637	12708	38	for	for	IN
18637	12708	39	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	12708	40	allottees	allottee	NNS
18637	12708	41	.	.	.
18637	12709	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12709	2	432	432	CD
18637	12709	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12709	4	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	12709	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12709	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12709	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12709	8	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	12709	9	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	12709	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12709	11	,	,	,
18637	12709	12	317	317	CD
18637	12709	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12709	14	575	575	CD
18637	12709	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12709	16	1943	1943	CD
18637	12709	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12709	18	.	.	.
18637	12710	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12710	2	433	433	CD
18637	12710	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12710	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12710	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12710	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12710	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12710	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12710	9	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	12710	10	,	,	,
18637	12710	11	106	106	CD
18637	12710	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12710	13	196	196	CD
18637	12710	14	,	,	,
18637	12710	15	207	207	CD
18637	12710	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	12710	17	208	208	CD
18637	12710	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12710	19	1882	1882	CD
18637	12710	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12710	21	.	.	.
18637	12711	1	The	the	DT
18637	12711	2	principle	principle	NN
18637	12711	3	of	of	IN
18637	12711	4	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	12711	5	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	12711	6	was	be	VBD
18637	12711	7	further	further	RB
18637	12711	8	disparaged	disparage	VBN
18637	12711	9	in	in	IN
18637	12711	10	a	a	DT
18637	12711	11	brief	brief	JJ
18637	12711	12	essay	essay	NN
18637	12711	13	by	by	IN
18637	12711	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12711	15	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	12711	16	on	on	IN
18637	12711	17	the	the	DT
18637	12711	18	subject	subject	NN
18637	12711	19	of	of	IN
18637	12711	20	the	the	DT
18637	12711	21	rule	rule	NN
18637	12711	22	of	of	IN
18637	12711	23	law	law	NN
18637	12711	24	,	,	,
18637	12711	25	as	as	IN
18637	12711	26	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	12711	27	:	:	:
18637	12711	28	"	"	``
18637	12711	29	Under	under	IN
18637	12711	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12711	31	system	system	NN
18637	12711	32	the	the	DT
18637	12711	33	_	_	NNP
18637	12711	34	people	people	NNS
18637	12711	35	_	_	NNP
18637	12711	36	*	*	NFP
18637	12711	37	*	*	NFP
18637	12711	38	*	*	NFP
18637	12711	39	are	be	VBP
18637	12711	40	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	12711	41	.	.	.
18637	12712	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12712	2	rights	right	NNS
18637	12712	3	,	,	,
18637	12712	4	whether	whether	IN
18637	12712	5	collective	collective	JJ
18637	12712	6	or	or	CC
18637	12712	7	individual	individual	JJ
18637	12712	8	,	,	,
18637	12712	9	are	be	VBP
18637	12712	10	not	not	RB
18637	12712	11	bound	bind	VBN
18637	12712	12	to	to	TO
18637	12712	13	give	give	VB
18637	12712	14	way	way	NN
18637	12712	15	to	to	IN
18637	12712	16	a	a	DT
18637	12712	17	sentiment	sentiment	NN
18637	12712	18	of	of	IN
18637	12712	19	loyalty	loyalty	NN
18637	12712	20	to	to	IN
18637	12712	21	the	the	DT
18637	12712	22	person	person	NN
18637	12712	23	of	of	IN
18637	12712	24	a	a	DT
18637	12712	25	monarch	monarch	NN
18637	12712	26	.	.	.
18637	12713	1	The	the	DT
18637	12713	2	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	12713	3	here	here	RB
18637	12713	4	knows	know	VBZ
18637	12713	5	no	no	DT
18637	12713	6	person	person	NN
18637	12713	7	,	,	,
18637	12713	8	however	however	RB
18637	12713	9	near	near	RB
18637	12713	10	to	to	IN
18637	12713	11	those	those	DT
18637	12713	12	in	in	IN
18637	12713	13	power	power	NN
18637	12713	14	,	,	,
18637	12713	15	or	or	CC
18637	12713	16	however	however	RB
18637	12713	17	powerful	powerful	JJ
18637	12713	18	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12713	19	,	,	,
18637	12713	20	to	to	TO
18637	12713	21	whom	whom	WP
18637	12713	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12713	23	need	nee	MD
18637	12713	24	yield	yield	VB
18637	12713	25	the	the	DT
18637	12713	26	rights	right	NNS
18637	12713	27	which	which	WDT
18637	12713	28	the	the	DT
18637	12713	29	law	law	NN
18637	12713	30	secures	secure	VBZ
18637	12713	31	to	to	IN
18637	12713	32	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12713	33	when	when	WRB
18637	12713	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12713	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	12713	36	well	well	RB
18637	12713	37	administered	administer	VBN
18637	12713	38	.	.	.
18637	12714	1	When	when	WRB
18637	12714	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12714	3	,	,	,
18637	12714	4	in	in	IN
18637	12714	5	one	one	CD
18637	12714	6	of	of	IN
18637	12714	7	the	the	DT
18637	12714	8	courts	court	NNS
18637	12714	9	of	of	IN
18637	12714	10	competent	competent	JJ
18637	12714	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12714	12	,	,	,
18637	12714	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	12714	14	established	establish	VBN
18637	12714	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12714	16	right	right	NN
18637	12714	17	to	to	IN
18637	12714	18	property	property	NN
18637	12714	19	,	,	,
18637	12714	20	there	there	EX
18637	12714	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	12714	22	no	no	DT
18637	12714	23	reason	reason	NN
18637	12714	24	why	why	WRB
18637	12714	25	deference	deference	NN
18637	12714	26	to	to	IN
18637	12714	27	any	any	DT
18637	12714	28	person	person	NN
18637	12714	29	,	,	,
18637	12714	30	natural	natural	JJ
18637	12714	31	or	or	CC
18637	12714	32	artificial	artificial	JJ
18637	12714	33	,	,	,
18637	12714	34	not	not	RB
18637	12714	35	even	even	RB
18637	12714	36	the	the	DT
18637	12714	37	United	United	NNP
18637	12714	38	States	States	NNP
18637	12714	39	,	,	,
18637	12714	40	should	should	MD
18637	12714	41	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	12714	42	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12714	43	from	from	IN
18637	12714	44	using	use	VBG
18637	12714	45	the	the	DT
18637	12714	46	means	mean	NNS
18637	12714	47	which	which	WDT
18637	12714	48	the	the	DT
18637	12714	49	law	law	NN
18637	12714	50	gives	give	VBZ
18637	12714	51	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12714	52	for	for	IN
18637	12714	53	the	the	DT
18637	12714	54	protection	protection	NN
18637	12714	55	and	and	CC
18637	12714	56	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	12714	57	of	of	IN
18637	12714	58	that	that	DT
18637	12714	59	right	right	NN
18637	12714	60	.	.	.
18637	12714	61	"	"	''
18637	12715	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	12715	2	.	.	.
18637	12716	1	208	208	CD
18637	12716	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12716	3	209	209	CD
18637	12716	4	.	.	.
18637	12717	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12717	2	434	434	CD
18637	12717	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12717	4	204	204	CD
18637	12717	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12717	6	331	331	CD
18637	12717	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12717	8	1907	1907	CD
18637	12717	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12717	10	.	.	.
18637	12718	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12718	2	435	435	CD
18637	12718	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12718	4	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	12718	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12718	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12718	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12718	8	McAdoo	McAdoo	NNP
18637	12718	9	,	,	,
18637	12718	10	234	234	CD
18637	12718	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12718	12	627	627	CD
18637	12718	13	,	,	,
18637	12718	14	628	628	CD
18637	12718	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12718	16	1914	1914	CD
18637	12718	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12718	18	.	.	.
18637	12719	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12719	2	436	436	CD
18637	12719	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12719	4	162	162	CD
18637	12719	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12719	6	255	255	CD
18637	12719	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12719	8	1896	1896	CD
18637	12719	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12719	10	.	.	.
18637	12720	1	At	at	IN
18637	12720	2	page	page	NN
18637	12720	3	271	271	CD
18637	12720	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12720	5	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	12720	6	endeavors	endeavor	NNS
18637	12720	7	to	to	TO
18637	12720	8	distinguish	distinguish	VB
18637	12720	9	between	between	IN
18637	12720	10	this	this	DT
18637	12720	11	and	and	CC
18637	12720	12	the	the	DT
18637	12720	13	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	12720	14	Case	Case	NNP
18637	12720	15	.	.	.
18637	12721	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12721	2	was	be	VBD
18637	12721	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12721	4	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	12721	5	who	who	WP
18637	12721	6	spoke	speak	VBD
18637	12721	7	for	for	IN
18637	12721	8	the	the	DT
18637	12721	9	dissenters	dissenter	NNS
18637	12721	10	in	in	IN
18637	12721	11	the	the	DT
18637	12721	12	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	12721	13	Case	Case	NNP
18637	12721	14	.	.	.
18637	12722	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12722	2	437	437	CD
18637	12722	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12722	4	Land	Land	NNP
18637	12722	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12722	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12722	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12722	8	Dollar	Dollar	NNP
18637	12722	9	,	,	,
18637	12722	10	330	330	CD
18637	12722	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12722	12	731	731	CD
18637	12722	13	,	,	,
18637	12722	14	737	737	CD
18637	12722	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12722	16	1947	1947	CD
18637	12722	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12722	18	.	.	.
18637	12723	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12723	2	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	12723	3	cites	cite	VBZ
18637	12723	4	for	for	IN
18637	12723	5	this	this	DT
18637	12723	6	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	12723	7	Cunningham	Cunningham	NNP
18637	12723	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12723	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12723	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12723	11	Macon	Macon	NNP
18637	12723	12	&	&	CC
18637	12723	13	B.R.	B.R.	NNP
18637	12724	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12724	2	,	,	,
18637	12724	3	109	109	CD
18637	12724	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12724	5	446	446	CD
18637	12724	6	,	,	,
18637	12724	7	452	452	CD
18637	12724	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12724	9	1883	1883	CD
18637	12724	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12724	11	;	;	:
18637	12724	12	Tindal	Tindal	NNP
18637	12724	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12724	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	12724	15	_	_	NNP
18637	12724	16	Wesley	Wesley	NNP
18637	12724	17	,	,	,
18637	12724	18	167	167	CD
18637	12724	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12724	20	204	204	CD
18637	12724	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12724	22	1897	1897	CD
18637	12724	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12724	24	;	;	:
18637	12724	25	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	12724	26	_	_	NNP
18637	12724	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	12724	28	_	_	NNP
18637	12724	29	Reeves	Reeves	NNP
18637	12724	30	,	,	,
18637	12724	31	178	178	CD
18637	12724	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12724	33	436	436	CD
18637	12724	34	,	,	,
18637	12724	35	439	439	CD
18637	12724	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12724	37	1900	1900	CD
18637	12724	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12724	39	;	;	:
18637	12724	40	Scranton	Scranton	NNP
18637	12724	41	_	_	NNP
18637	12724	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	12724	43	_	_	NNP
18637	12724	44	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	12724	45	,	,	,
18637	12724	46	179	179	CD
18637	12724	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12724	48	141	141	CD
18637	12724	49	,	,	,
18637	12724	50	152	152	CD
18637	12724	51	,	,	,
18637	12724	52	153	153	CD
18637	12724	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12724	54	1900	1900	CD
18637	12724	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12724	56	;	;	:
18637	12724	57	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	12724	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12724	59	_	_	NNP
18637	12724	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	12724	61	_	_	NNP
18637	12724	62	Stimson	Stimson	NNP
18637	12724	63	,	,	,
18637	12724	64	223	223	CD
18637	12724	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12724	66	605	605	CD
18637	12724	67	,	,	,
18637	12724	68	619	619	CD
18637	12724	69	,	,	,
18637	12724	70	620	620	CD
18637	12724	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12724	72	1912	1912	CD
18637	12724	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12724	74	;	;	:
18637	12724	75	Goltra	Goltra	NNP
18637	12724	76	_	_	NNP
18637	12724	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	12724	78	_	_	NNP
18637	12724	79	Weeks	Weeks	NNP
18637	12724	80	,	,	,
18637	12724	81	271	271	CD
18637	12724	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12724	83	536	536	CD
18637	12724	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12724	85	1926	1926	CD
18637	12724	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12724	87	.	.	.
18637	12725	1	This	this	DT
18637	12725	2	last	last	JJ
18637	12725	3	case	case	NN
18637	12725	4	actually	actually	RB
18637	12725	5	extended	extend	VBD
18637	12725	6	the	the	DT
18637	12725	7	rule	rule	NN
18637	12725	8	of	of	IN
18637	12725	9	the	the	DT
18637	12725	10	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	12725	11	Case	Case	NNP
18637	12725	12	and	and	CC
18637	12725	13	was	be	VBD
18637	12725	14	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	12725	15	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	12725	16	in	in	IN
18637	12725	17	Larson	Larson	NNP
18637	12725	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12725	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	12725	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12725	21	Domestic	Domestic	NNP
18637	12725	22	&	&	CC
18637	12725	23	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	12725	24	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	12725	25	,	,	,
18637	12725	26	337	337	CD
18637	12725	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12725	28	682	682	CD
18637	12725	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12725	30	1949	1949	CD
18637	12725	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12725	32	.	.	.
18637	12726	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12726	2	438	438	CD
18637	12726	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12726	4	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	12726	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12726	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12726	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12726	8	Hitchcock	Hitchcock	NNP
18637	12726	9	,	,	,
18637	12726	10	202	202	CD
18637	12726	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12726	12	60	60	CD
18637	12726	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12726	14	1906	1906	CD
18637	12726	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12726	16	;	;	:
18637	12726	17	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	12726	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12726	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	12726	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12726	21	Garfield	Garfield	NNP
18637	12726	22	,	,	,
18637	12726	23	211	211	CD
18637	12726	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12726	25	70	70	CD
18637	12726	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12726	27	1908	1908	CD
18637	12726	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12726	29	;	;	:
18637	12726	30	New	New	NNP
18637	12726	31	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	12726	32	_	_	NNP
18637	12726	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	12726	34	_	_	NNP
18637	12726	35	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	12726	36	,	,	,
18637	12726	37	243	243	CD
18637	12726	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12726	39	52	52	CD
18637	12726	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12726	41	1917	1917	CD
18637	12726	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12726	43	;	;	:
18637	12726	44	Wells	Wells	NNP
18637	12726	45	_	_	NNP
18637	12726	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	12726	47	_	_	NNP
18637	12726	48	Roper	Roper	NNP
18637	12726	49	,	,	,
18637	12726	50	246	246	CD
18637	12726	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12726	52	335	335	CD
18637	12726	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12726	54	1918	1918	CD
18637	12726	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12726	56	;	;	:
18637	12726	57	Morrison	Morrison	NNP
18637	12726	58	_	_	NNP
18637	12726	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	12726	60	_	_	NNP
18637	12726	61	Work	Work	NNP
18637	12726	62	,	,	,
18637	12726	63	266	266	CD
18637	12726	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12726	65	481	481	CD
18637	12726	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12726	67	1925	1925	CD
18637	12726	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12726	69	;	;	:
18637	12726	70	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	12726	71	_	_	NNP
18637	12726	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	12726	73	_	_	NNP
18637	12726	74	United	United	NNP
18637	12726	75	States	States	NNP
18637	12726	76	,	,	,
18637	12726	77	305	305	CD
18637	12726	78	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12726	79	382	382	CD
18637	12726	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12726	81	1939	1939	CD
18637	12726	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12726	83	;	;	:
18637	12726	84	Mine	Mine	NNP
18637	12726	85	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	12726	86	Appliances	Appliances	NNPS
18637	12726	87	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12726	88	_	_	NNP
18637	12726	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	12726	90	_	_	NNP
18637	12726	91	Forrestal	Forrestal	NNP
18637	12726	92	,	,	,
18637	12726	93	326	326	CD
18637	12726	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12726	95	371	371	CD
18637	12726	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12726	97	1945	1945	CD
18637	12726	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12726	99	.	.	.
18637	12727	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12727	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12727	3	also	also	RB
18637	12727	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12727	5	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	12727	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12727	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12727	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12727	9	Hitchcock	Hitchcock	NNP
18637	12727	10	,	,	,
18637	12727	11	185	185	CD
18637	12727	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12727	13	373	373	CD
18637	12727	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12727	15	1902	1902	CD
18637	12727	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12727	17	.	.	.
18637	12728	1	For	for	IN
18637	12728	2	a	a	DT
18637	12728	3	review	review	NN
18637	12728	4	of	of	IN
18637	12728	5	the	the	DT
18637	12728	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	12728	7	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	12728	8	with	with	IN
18637	12728	9	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	12728	10	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	12728	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12728	12	see	see	NN
18637	12728	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12728	14	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
18637	12728	15	D.	D.	NNP
18637	12728	16	Block	Block	NNP
18637	12728	17	,	,	,
18637	12728	18	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	12728	19	Against	against	IN
18637	12728	20	Government	Government	NNP
18637	12728	21	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	12728	22	and	and	CC
18637	12728	23	the	the	DT
18637	12728	24	Sovereign	Sovereign	NNP
18637	12728	25	Immunity	Immunity	NNP
18637	12728	26	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	12728	27	,	,	,
18637	12728	28	59	59	CD
18637	12728	29	Harv	Harv	NNP
18637	12728	30	.	.	.
18637	12729	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	12729	2	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	12730	1	1060	1060	CD
18637	12730	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12730	3	1946	1946	CD
18637	12730	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12730	5	.	.	.
18637	12731	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12731	2	439	439	CD
18637	12731	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12731	4	Cunningham	Cunningham	NNP
18637	12731	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12731	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12731	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12731	8	Macon	Macon	NNP
18637	12731	9	&	&	CC
18637	12731	10	B.R.	B.R.	NNP
18637	12732	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12732	2	,	,	,
18637	12732	3	109	109	CD
18637	12732	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12732	5	446	446	CD
18637	12732	6	,	,	,
18637	12732	7	451	451	CD
18637	12732	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12732	9	1883	1883	CD
18637	12732	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12732	11	,	,	,
18637	12732	12	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	12732	13	by	by	IN
18637	12732	14	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	12732	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12732	16	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	12732	17	in	in	IN
18637	12732	18	the	the	DT
18637	12732	19	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	12732	20	of	of	IN
18637	12732	21	the	the	DT
18637	12732	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12732	23	in	in	IN
18637	12732	24	Larson	Larson	NNP
18637	12732	25	_	_	NNP
18637	12732	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	12732	27	_	_	NNP
18637	12732	28	Domestic	Domestic	NNP
18637	12732	29	&	&	CC
18637	12732	30	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	12732	31	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	12732	32	,	,	,
18637	12732	33	337	337	CD
18637	12732	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12732	35	682	682	CD
18637	12732	36	,	,	,
18637	12732	37	698	698	CD
18637	12732	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12732	39	1949	1949	CD
18637	12732	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12732	41	.	.	.
18637	12733	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12733	2	440	440	CD
18637	12733	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12733	4	Larson	Larson	NNP
18637	12733	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12733	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12733	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12733	8	Domestic	Domestic	NNP
18637	12733	9	&	&	CC
18637	12733	10	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	12733	11	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	12733	12	,	,	,
18637	12733	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12733	14	supra	supra	NNP
18637	12733	15	_	_	NNP
18637	12733	16	,	,	,
18637	12733	17	708	708	CD
18637	12733	18	.	.	.
18637	12734	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12734	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	12734	3	's	's	POS
18637	12734	4	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	12734	5	also	also	RB
18637	12734	6	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	12734	7	a	a	DT
18637	12734	8	useful	useful	JJ
18637	12734	9	classification	classification	NN
18637	12734	10	of	of	IN
18637	12734	11	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	12734	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	12734	13	and	and	CC
18637	12734	14	an	an	DT
18637	12734	15	appendix	appendix	NNP
18637	12734	16	listing	list	VBG
18637	12734	17	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12734	18	.	.	.
18637	12735	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12735	2	441	441	CD
18637	12735	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12735	4	330	330	CD
18637	12735	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12735	6	731	731	CD
18637	12735	7	,	,	,
18637	12735	8	735	735	CD
18637	12735	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12735	10	1947	1947	CD
18637	12735	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12735	12	.	.	.
18637	12736	1	The	the	DT
18637	12736	2	italics	italic	NNS
18637	12736	3	are	be	VBP
18637	12736	4	added	add	VBN
18637	12736	5	.	.	.
18637	12737	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12737	2	442	442	CD
18637	12737	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12737	4	337	337	CD
18637	12737	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12737	6	682	682	CD
18637	12737	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12737	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	12737	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12737	10	.	.	.
18637	12738	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12738	2	443	443	CD
18637	12738	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12738	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12738	5	.	.	.
18637	12739	1	689	689	CD
18637	12739	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12739	3	697	697	CD
18637	12739	4	.	.	.
18637	12740	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12740	2	444	444	CD
18637	12740	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12740	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12740	5	.	.	.
18637	12741	1	701	701	CD
18637	12741	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12741	3	702	702	CD
18637	12741	4	.	.	.
18637	12742	1	This	this	DT
18637	12742	2	rule	rule	NN
18637	12742	3	was	be	VBD
18637	12742	4	applied	apply	VBN
18637	12742	5	in	in	IN
18637	12742	6	United	United	NNP
18637	12742	7	States	States	NNP
18637	12742	8	ex	ex	NNP
18637	12742	9	rel	rel	NN
18637	12742	10	.	.	.
18637	12743	1	Goldberg	Goldberg	NNP
18637	12743	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12743	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12743	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12743	5	Daniels	Daniels	NNP
18637	12743	6	,	,	,
18637	12743	7	231	231	CD
18637	12743	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12743	9	218	218	CD
18637	12743	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12743	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	12743	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12743	13	,	,	,
18637	12743	14	which	which	WDT
18637	12743	15	also	also	RB
18637	12743	16	involved	involve	VBD
18637	12743	17	a	a	DT
18637	12743	18	sale	sale	NN
18637	12743	19	of	of	IN
18637	12743	20	government	government	NN
18637	12743	21	surplus	surplus	NN
18637	12743	22	property	property	NN
18637	12743	23	.	.	.
18637	12744	1	After	after	IN
18637	12744	2	the	the	DT
18637	12744	3	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	12744	4	of	of	IN
18637	12744	5	the	the	DT
18637	12744	6	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	12744	7	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	12744	8	the	the	DT
18637	12744	9	highest	high	JJS
18637	12744	10	bid	bid	NN
18637	12744	11	,	,	,
18637	12744	12	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	12744	13	sought	seek	VBD
18637	12744	14	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	12744	15	to	to	TO
18637	12744	16	compel	compel	NN
18637	12744	17	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	12744	18	.	.	.
18637	12745	1	The	the	DT
18637	12745	2	suit	suit	NN
18637	12745	3	was	be	VBD
18637	12745	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	12745	5	to	to	TO
18637	12745	6	be	be	VB
18637	12745	7	against	against	IN
18637	12745	8	the	the	DT
18637	12745	9	United	United	NNP
18637	12745	10	States	States	NNP
18637	12745	11	.	.	.
18637	12746	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12746	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12746	3	also	also	RB
18637	12746	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12746	5	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
18637	12746	6	,	,	,
18637	12746	7	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	12746	8	of	of	IN
18637	12746	9	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	12746	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12746	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	12746	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12746	13	Lukens	Lukens	NNP
18637	12746	14	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	12746	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12746	16	,	,	,
18637	12746	17	310	310	CD
18637	12746	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12746	19	113	113	CD
18637	12746	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12746	21	1940	1940	CD
18637	12746	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12746	23	,	,	,
18637	12746	24	which	which	WDT
18637	12746	25	held	hold	VBD
18637	12746	26	that	that	IN
18637	12746	27	prospective	prospective	JJ
18637	12746	28	bidders	bidder	NNS
18637	12746	29	for	for	IN
18637	12746	30	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	12746	31	derive	derive	VBP
18637	12746	32	no	no	DT
18637	12746	33	enforceable	enforceable	JJ
18637	12746	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	12746	35	against	against	IN
18637	12746	36	a	a	DT
18637	12746	37	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12746	38	official	official	NN
18637	12746	39	for	for	IN
18637	12746	40	an	an	DT
18637	12746	41	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	12746	42	misinterpretation	misinterpretation	NN
18637	12746	43	of	of	IN
18637	12746	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12746	45	government	government	NN
18637	12746	46	's	's	POS
18637	12746	47	authority	authority	NN
18637	12746	48	on	on	IN
18637	12746	49	the	the	DT
18637	12746	50	ground	ground	NN
18637	12746	51	that	that	IN
18637	12746	52	an	an	DT
18637	12746	53	agent	agent	NN
18637	12746	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	12746	55	answerable	answerable	JJ
18637	12746	56	only	only	RB
18637	12746	57	to	to	IN
18637	12746	58	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12746	59	principal	principal	NN
18637	12746	60	for	for	IN
18637	12746	61	misconstruction	misconstruction	NN
18637	12746	62	of	of	IN
18637	12746	63	instructions	instruction	NNS
18637	12746	64	,	,	,
18637	12746	65	given	give	VBN
18637	12746	66	for	for	IN
18637	12746	67	the	the	DT
18637	12746	68	sole	sole	JJ
18637	12746	69	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	12746	70	of	of	IN
18637	12746	71	the	the	DT
18637	12746	72	principal	principal	NN
18637	12746	73	.	.	.
18637	12747	1	In	in	IN
18637	12747	2	the	the	DT
18637	12747	3	Larson	Larson	NNP
18637	12747	4	Case	Case	NNP
18637	12747	5	the	the	DT
18637	12747	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12747	7	not	not	RB
18637	12747	8	only	only	RB
18637	12747	9	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	12747	10	to	to	TO
18637	12747	11	follow	follow	VB
18637	12747	12	Goltra	Goltra	NNP
18637	12747	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12747	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	12747	15	_	_	NNP
18637	12747	16	Weeks	Weeks	NNP
18637	12747	17	,	,	,
18637	12747	18	271	271	CD
18637	12747	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12747	20	536	536	CD
18637	12747	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12747	22	1926	1926	CD
18637	12747	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12747	24	,	,	,
18637	12747	25	but	but	CC
18637	12747	26	in	in	IN
18637	12747	27	effect	effect	NN
18637	12747	28	overruled	overrule	VBD
18637	12747	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12747	30	.	.	.
18637	12748	1	The	the	DT
18637	12748	2	Goltra	Goltra	NNP
18637	12748	3	Case	Case	NNP
18637	12748	4	involved	involve	VBD
18637	12748	5	an	an	DT
18637	12748	6	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	12748	7	of	of	IN
18637	12748	8	the	the	DT
18637	12748	9	Government	Government	NNP
18637	12748	10	to	to	TO
18637	12748	11	repossess	repossess	VB
18637	12748	12	barges	barge	NNS
18637	12748	13	which	which	WDT
18637	12748	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12748	15	had	have	VBD
18637	12748	16	leased	lease	VBN
18637	12748	17	under	under	IN
18637	12748	18	a	a	DT
18637	12748	19	contract	contract	NN
18637	12748	20	reserving	reserve	VBG
18637	12748	21	the	the	DT
18637	12748	22	right	right	NN
18637	12748	23	to	to	TO
18637	12748	24	repossess	repossess	VB
18637	12748	25	in	in	IN
18637	12748	26	certain	certain	JJ
18637	12748	27	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	12748	28	.	.	.
18637	12749	1	A	a	DT
18637	12749	2	suit	suit	NN
18637	12749	3	to	to	TO
18637	12749	4	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	12749	5	repossession	repossession	NN
18637	12749	6	was	be	VBD
18637	12749	7	held	hold	VBN
18637	12749	8	not	not	RB
18637	12749	9	to	to	TO
18637	12749	10	be	be	VB
18637	12749	11	a	a	DT
18637	12749	12	suit	suit	NN
18637	12749	13	against	against	IN
18637	12749	14	the	the	DT
18637	12749	15	United	United	NNP
18637	12749	16	States	States	NNP
18637	12749	17	on	on	IN
18637	12749	18	the	the	DT
18637	12749	19	ground	ground	NN
18637	12749	20	that	that	IN
18637	12749	21	the	the	DT
18637	12749	22	actions	action	NNS
18637	12749	23	were	be	VBD
18637	12749	24	personal	personal	JJ
18637	12749	25	and	and	CC
18637	12749	26	in	in	IN
18637	12749	27	the	the	DT
18637	12749	28	nature	nature	NN
18637	12749	29	of	of	IN
18637	12749	30	a	a	DT
18637	12749	31	trespass	trespass	NN
18637	12749	32	.	.	.
18637	12750	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12750	2	445	445	CD
18637	12750	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12750	4	337	337	CD
18637	12750	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12750	6	682	682	CD
18637	12750	7	,	,	,
18637	12750	8	703	703	CD
18637	12750	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12750	10	704	704	CD
18637	12750	11	.	.	.
18637	12751	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12751	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	12751	3	,	,	,
18637	12751	4	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	12751	5	,	,	,
18637	12751	6	would	would	MD
18637	12751	7	have	have	VB
18637	12751	8	applied	apply	VBN
18637	12751	9	the	the	DT
18637	12751	10	rule	rule	NN
18637	12751	11	of	of	IN
18637	12751	12	the	the	DT
18637	12751	13	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	12751	14	Case	Case	NNP
18637	12751	15	.	.	.
18637	12752	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12752	2	446	446	CD
18637	12752	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12752	4	Larson	Larson	NNP
18637	12752	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12752	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12752	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12752	8	Domestic	Domestic	NNP
18637	12752	9	&	&	CC
18637	12752	10	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	12752	11	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	12752	12	,	,	,
18637	12752	13	337	337	CD
18637	12752	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12752	15	682	682	CD
18637	12752	16	,	,	,
18637	12752	17	709	709	CD
18637	12752	18	-	-	SYM
18637	12752	19	710	710	CD
18637	12752	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12752	21	1949	1949	CD
18637	12752	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12752	23	.	.	.
18637	12753	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12753	2	447	447	CD
18637	12753	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12753	4	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	12753	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12753	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12753	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12753	8	Hitchcock	Hitchcock	NNP
18637	12753	9	,	,	,
18637	12753	10	202	202	CD
18637	12753	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12753	12	60	60	CD
18637	12753	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12753	14	1906	1906	CD
18637	12753	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12753	16	;	;	:
18637	12753	17	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	12753	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12753	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	12753	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12753	21	McAdoo	McAdoo	NNP
18637	12753	22	,	,	,
18637	12753	23	224	224	CD
18637	12753	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12753	25	627	627	CD
18637	12753	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12753	27	1914	1914	CD
18637	12753	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12753	29	;	;	:
18637	12753	30	Wells	Wells	NNP
18637	12753	31	_	_	NNP
18637	12753	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	12753	33	_	_	NNP
18637	12753	34	Roper	Roper	NNP
18637	12753	35	,	,	,
18637	12753	36	246	246	CD
18637	12753	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12753	38	335	335	CD
18637	12753	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12753	40	1918	1918	CD
18637	12753	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12753	42	.	.	.
18637	12754	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12754	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12754	3	also	also	RB
18637	12754	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12754	5	Belknap	Belknap	NNP
18637	12754	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12754	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12754	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12754	9	Schild	Schild	NNP
18637	12754	10	,	,	,
18637	12754	11	161	161	CD
18637	12754	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12754	13	10	10	CD
18637	12754	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12754	15	1896	1896	CD
18637	12754	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12754	17	;	;	:
18637	12754	18	and	and	CC
18637	12754	19	International	International	NNP
18637	12754	20	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	12754	21	Supply	Supply	NNP
18637	12754	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12754	23	_	_	NNP
18637	12754	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	12754	25	_	_	NNP
18637	12754	26	Bruce	Bruce	NNP
18637	12754	27	,	,	,
18637	12754	28	194	194	CD
18637	12754	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12754	30	601	601	CD
18637	12754	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12754	32	1904	1904	CD
18637	12754	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12754	34	.	.	.
18637	12755	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12755	2	448	448	CD
18637	12755	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12755	4	Rickert	Rickert	NNP
18637	12755	5	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	12755	6	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	12755	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12755	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12755	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12755	10	Fontenot	Fontenot	NNP
18637	12755	11	,	,	,
18637	12755	12	297	297	CD
18637	12755	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12755	14	110	110	CD
18637	12755	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12755	16	1936	1936	CD
18637	12755	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12755	18	;	;	:
18637	12755	19	and	and	CC
18637	12755	20	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	12755	21	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	12755	22	Power	Power	NNP
18637	12755	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12755	24	_	_	NNP
18637	12755	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	12755	26	_	_	NNP
18637	12755	27	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	12755	28	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	12755	29	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	12755	30	,	,	,
18637	12755	31	306	306	CD
18637	12755	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12755	33	118	118	CD
18637	12755	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12755	35	1939	1939	CD
18637	12755	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12755	37	which	which	WDT
18637	12755	38	held	hold	VBD
18637	12755	39	that	that	IN
18637	12755	40	one	one	CD
18637	12755	41	threatened	threaten	VBD
18637	12755	42	with	with	IN
18637	12755	43	direct	direct	JJ
18637	12755	44	and	and	CC
18637	12755	45	special	special	JJ
18637	12755	46	injury	injury	NN
18637	12755	47	by	by	IN
18637	12755	48	the	the	DT
18637	12755	49	act	act	NN
18637	12755	50	of	of	IN
18637	12755	51	an	an	DT
18637	12755	52	agent	agent	NN
18637	12755	53	of	of	IN
18637	12755	54	the	the	DT
18637	12755	55	Government	Government	NNP
18637	12755	56	under	under	IN
18637	12755	57	a	a	DT
18637	12755	58	statute	statute	NN
18637	12755	59	may	may	MD
18637	12755	60	challenge	challenge	VB
18637	12755	61	the	the	DT
18637	12755	62	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	12755	63	of	of	IN
18637	12755	64	the	the	DT
18637	12755	65	statute	statute	NN
18637	12755	66	in	in	IN
18637	12755	67	a	a	DT
18637	12755	68	suit	suit	NN
18637	12755	69	against	against	IN
18637	12755	70	the	the	DT
18637	12755	71	agent	agent	NN
18637	12755	72	.	.	.
18637	12756	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12756	2	449	449	CD
18637	12756	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12756	4	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	12756	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12756	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12756	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12756	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12756	9	Stimson	Stimson	NNP
18637	12756	10	,	,	,
18637	12756	11	223	223	CD
18637	12756	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12756	13	605	605	CD
18637	12756	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12756	15	1912	1912	CD
18637	12756	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12756	17	;	;	:
18637	12756	18	Waite	Waite	NNP
18637	12756	19	_	_	NNP
18637	12756	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	12756	21	_	_	NNP
18637	12756	22	Macy	Macy	NNP
18637	12756	23	,	,	,
18637	12756	24	246	246	CD
18637	12756	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12756	26	606	606	CD
18637	12756	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12756	28	1918	1918	CD
18637	12756	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12756	30	.	.	.
18637	12757	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12757	2	450	450	CD
18637	12757	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12757	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12757	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12757	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12757	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12757	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12757	9	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	12757	10	,	,	,
18637	12757	11	106	106	CD
18637	12757	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12757	13	196	196	CD
18637	12757	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12757	15	1882	1882	CD
18637	12757	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12757	17	;	;	:
18637	12757	18	Goltra	Goltra	NNP
18637	12757	19	_	_	NNP
18637	12757	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	12757	21	_	_	NNP
18637	12757	22	Weeks	Weeks	NNP
18637	12757	23	,	,	,
18637	12757	24	271	271	CD
18637	12757	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12757	26	536	536	CD
18637	12757	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12757	28	1926	1926	CD
18637	12757	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12757	30	;	;	:
18637	12757	31	Ickes	Ickes	NNP
18637	12757	32	_	_	NNP
18637	12757	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	12757	34	_	_	NNP
18637	12757	35	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	12757	36	,	,	,
18637	12757	37	300	300	CD
18637	12757	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12757	39	82	82	CD
18637	12757	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12757	41	1937	1937	CD
18637	12757	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12757	43	;	;	:
18637	12757	44	Land	Land	NNP
18637	12757	45	_	_	NNP
18637	12757	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	12757	47	_	_	NNP
18637	12757	48	Dollar	Dollar	NNP
18637	12757	49	,	,	,
18637	12757	50	330	330	CD
18637	12757	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12757	52	731	731	CD
18637	12757	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12757	54	1947	1947	CD
18637	12757	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12757	56	.	.	.
18637	12758	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12758	2	451	451	CD
18637	12758	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12758	4	306	306	CD
18637	12758	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12758	6	381	381	CD
18637	12758	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12758	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	12758	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12758	10	.	.	.
18637	12759	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12759	2	452	452	CD
18637	12759	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12759	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	12759	5	Housing	Housing	NNP
18637	12759	6	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	12759	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12759	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12759	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12759	10	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	12759	11	,	,	,
18637	12759	12	309	309	CD
18637	12759	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12759	14	242	242	CD
18637	12759	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12759	16	1940	1940	CD
18637	12759	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12759	18	.	.	.
18637	12760	1	Nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
18637	12760	2	,	,	,
18637	12760	3	the	the	DT
18637	12760	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12760	5	held	hold	VBD
18637	12760	6	that	that	IN
18637	12760	7	a	a	DT
18637	12760	8	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	12760	9	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	12760	10	of	of	IN
18637	12760	11	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	12760	12	in	in	IN
18637	12760	13	the	the	DT
18637	12760	14	case	case	NN
18637	12760	15	of	of	IN
18637	12760	16	a	a	DT
18637	12760	17	government	government	NN
18637	12760	18	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	12760	19	did	do	VBD
18637	12760	20	not	not	RB
18637	12760	21	mean	mean	VB
18637	12760	22	that	that	IN
18637	12760	23	funds	fund	NNS
18637	12760	24	or	or	CC
18637	12760	25	property	property	NN
18637	12760	26	of	of	IN
18637	12760	27	the	the	DT
18637	12760	28	United	United	NNP
18637	12760	29	States	States	NNP
18637	12760	30	can	can	MD
18637	12760	31	be	be	VB
18637	12760	32	levied	levy	VBN
18637	12760	33	on	on	RP
18637	12760	34	to	to	TO
18637	12760	35	pay	pay	VB
18637	12760	36	a	a	DT
18637	12760	37	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	12760	38	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	12760	39	against	against	IN
18637	12760	40	such	such	PDT
18637	12760	41	a	a	DT
18637	12760	42	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	12760	43	as	as	IN
18637	12760	44	the	the	DT
18637	12760	45	result	result	NN
18637	12760	46	of	of	IN
18637	12760	47	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	12760	48	of	of	IN
18637	12760	49	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	12760	50	.	.	.
18637	12761	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12761	2	453	453	CD
18637	12761	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12761	4	United	United	NNP
18637	12761	5	States	States	NNP
18637	12761	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12761	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12761	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12761	9	United	United	NNP
18637	12761	10	States	States	NNP
18637	12761	11	Fidelity	Fidelity	NNP
18637	12761	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12761	13	,	,	,
18637	12761	14	309	309	CD
18637	12761	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12761	16	506	506	CD
18637	12761	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12761	18	1940	1940	CD
18637	12761	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12761	20	.	.	.
18637	12762	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12762	2	454	454	CD
18637	12762	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12762	4	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	12762	5	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	12762	6	,	,	,
18637	12762	7	The	the	DT
18637	12762	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12762	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12762	10	and	and	CC
18637	12762	11	Disputes	Disputes	NNPS
18637	12762	12	Between	between	IN
18637	12762	13	States	States	NNP
18637	12762	14	,	,	,
18637	12762	15	Bulletin	Bulletin	NNP
18637	12762	16	of	of	IN
18637	12762	17	the	the	DT
18637	12762	18	College	College	NNP
18637	12762	19	of	of	IN
18637	12762	20	William	William	NNP
18637	12762	21	and	and	CC
18637	12762	22	Mary	Mary	NNP
18637	12762	23	,	,	,
18637	12762	24	Vol	Vol	NNP
18637	12762	25	.	.	.
18637	12763	1	34	34	CD
18637	12763	2	,	,	,
18637	12763	3	No	no	UH
18637	12763	4	.	.	.
18637	12764	1	5	5	CD
18637	12764	2	,	,	,
18637	12764	3	pp	pp	NNP
18637	12764	4	.	.	.
18637	12765	1	7	7	CD
18637	12765	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12765	3	11	11	CD
18637	12765	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12765	5	1940	1940	CD
18637	12765	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12765	7	.	.	.
18637	12766	1	For	for	IN
18637	12766	2	a	a	DT
18637	12766	3	more	more	RBR
18637	12766	4	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	12766	5	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	12766	6	of	of	IN
18637	12766	7	backgrounds	background	NNS
18637	12766	8	as	as	RB
18637	12766	9	well	well	RB
18637	12766	10	as	as	IN
18637	12766	11	the	the	DT
18637	12766	12	general	general	JJ
18637	12766	13	subject	subject	NN
18637	12766	14	,	,	,
18637	12766	15	_	_	NNP
18637	12766	16	see	see	VBP
18637	12766	17	_	_	NNP
18637	12766	18	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	12766	19	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	12766	20	,	,	,
18637	12766	21	The	the	DT
18637	12766	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12766	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12766	24	and	and	CC
18637	12766	25	Sovereign	Sovereign	NNP
18637	12766	26	States	States	NNPS
18637	12766	27	,	,	,
18637	12766	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12766	29	Princeton	Princeton	NNP
18637	12766	30	,	,	,
18637	12766	31	1924	1924	CD
18637	12766	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12766	33	.	.	.
18637	12767	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12767	2	455	455	CD
18637	12767	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12767	4	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	12767	5	,	,	,
18637	12767	6	The	the	DT
18637	12767	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12767	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12767	9	and	and	CC
18637	12767	10	Disputes	Disputes	NNPS
18637	12767	11	Between	between	IN
18637	12767	12	States	States	NNP
18637	12767	13	,	,	,
18637	12767	14	p.	p.	NN
18637	12767	15	13	13	CD
18637	12767	16	.	.	.
18637	12768	1	However	however	RB
18637	12768	2	,	,	,
18637	12768	3	only	only	RB
18637	12768	4	three	three	CD
18637	12768	5	such	such	JJ
18637	12768	6	suits	suit	NNS
18637	12768	7	were	be	VBD
18637	12768	8	brought	bring	VBN
18637	12768	9	in	in	RP
18637	12768	10	this	this	DT
18637	12768	11	period	period	NN
18637	12768	12	,	,	,
18637	12768	13	1789	1789	CD
18637	12768	14	-	-	SYM
18637	12768	15	1849	1849	CD
18637	12768	16	.	.	.
18637	12769	1	During	during	IN
18637	12769	2	the	the	DT
18637	12769	3	next	next	JJ
18637	12769	4	90	90	CD
18637	12769	5	years	year	NNS
18637	12769	6	,	,	,
18637	12769	7	1849	1849	CD
18637	12769	8	-	-	SYM
18637	12769	9	1939	1939	CD
18637	12769	10	,	,	,
18637	12769	11	at	at	IN
18637	12769	12	least	least	JJS
18637	12769	13	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	12769	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	12769	15	nine	nine	CD
18637	12769	16	such	such	JJ
18637	12769	17	suits	suit	NNS
18637	12769	18	were	be	VBD
18637	12769	19	brought	bring	VBN
18637	12769	20	.	.	.
18637	12770	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	12770	2	.	.	.
18637	12771	1	13	13	CD
18637	12771	2	,	,	,
18637	12771	3	14	14	CD
18637	12771	4	.	.	.
18637	12772	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12772	2	456	456	CD
18637	12772	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12772	4	2	2	CD
18637	12772	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12772	6	.	.	.
18637	12773	1	419	419	CD
18637	12773	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12773	3	1793	1793	CD
18637	12773	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12773	5	.	.	.
18637	12774	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12774	2	457	457	CD
18637	12774	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12774	4	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	12774	5	Island	Island	NNP
18637	12774	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12774	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12774	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12774	9	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	12774	10	,	,	,
18637	12774	11	12	12	CD
18637	12774	12	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12774	13	.	.	.
18637	12775	1	657	657	CD
18637	12775	2	,	,	,
18637	12775	3	721	721	CD
18637	12775	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12775	5	1838	1838	CD
18637	12775	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12775	7	.	.	.
18637	12776	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12776	2	458	458	CD
18637	12776	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12776	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12776	5	.	.	.
18637	12777	1	736	736	CD
18637	12777	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12777	3	737	737	CD
18637	12777	4	.	.	.
18637	12778	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12778	2	459	459	CD
18637	12778	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12778	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12778	5	.	.	.
18637	12779	1	737	737	CD
18637	12779	2	.	.	.
18637	12780	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	12780	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12780	3	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	12780	4	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	12780	5	because	because	IN
18637	12780	6	of	of	IN
18637	12780	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12780	8	belief	belief	NN
18637	12780	9	that	that	IN
18637	12780	10	the	the	DT
18637	12780	11	issue	issue	NN
18637	12780	12	was	be	VBD
18637	12780	13	not	not	RB
18637	12780	14	one	one	CD
18637	12780	15	of	of	IN
18637	12780	16	property	property	NN
18637	12780	17	in	in	IN
18637	12780	18	the	the	DT
18637	12780	19	soil	soil	NN
18637	12780	20	,	,	,
18637	12780	21	but	but	CC
18637	12780	22	of	of	IN
18637	12780	23	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	12780	24	and	and	CC
18637	12780	25	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12780	26	,	,	,
18637	12780	27	and	and	CC
18637	12780	28	hence	hence	RB
18637	12780	29	political	political	JJ
18637	12780	30	.	.	.
18637	12781	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	12781	2	.	.	.
18637	12782	1	752	752	CD
18637	12782	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12782	3	753	753	CD
18637	12782	4	.	.	.
18637	12783	1	For	for	IN
18637	12783	2	different	different	JJ
18637	12783	3	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	12783	4	,	,	,
18637	12783	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12783	6	should	should	MD
18637	12783	7	be	be	VB
18637	12783	8	noted	note	VBN
18637	12783	9	,	,	,
18637	12783	10	a	a	DT
18637	12783	11	suit	suit	NN
18637	12783	12	between	between	IN
18637	12783	13	private	private	JJ
18637	12783	14	parties	party	NNS
18637	12783	15	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	12783	16	soil	soil	NN
18637	12783	17	or	or	CC
18637	12783	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12783	19	of	of	IN
18637	12783	20	two	two	CD
18637	12783	21	States	States	NNPS
18637	12783	22	,	,	,
18637	12783	23	to	to	TO
18637	12783	24	which	which	WDT
18637	12783	25	neither	neither	DT
18637	12783	26	State	State	NNP
18637	12783	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	12783	28	a	a	DT
18637	12783	29	party	party	NN
18637	12783	30	does	do	VBZ
18637	12783	31	not	not	RB
18637	12783	32	come	come	VB
18637	12783	33	within	within	IN
18637	12783	34	the	the	DT
18637	12783	35	original	original	JJ
18637	12783	36	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12783	37	of	of	IN
18637	12783	38	the	the	DT
18637	12783	39	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12783	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12783	41	.	.	.
18637	12784	1	Fowler	Fowler	NNP
18637	12784	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12784	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12784	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12784	5	Lindsay	Lindsay	NNP
18637	12784	6	,	,	,
18637	12784	7	3	3	CD
18637	12784	8	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12784	9	.	.	.
18637	12785	1	411	411	CD
18637	12785	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12785	3	1799	1799	CD
18637	12785	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12785	5	.	.	.
18637	12786	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12786	2	460	460	CD
18637	12786	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12786	4	180	180	CD
18637	12786	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12786	6	208	208	CD
18637	12786	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12786	8	1901	1901	CD
18637	12786	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12786	10	.	.	.
18637	12787	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12787	2	461	461	CD
18637	12787	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12787	4	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	12787	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12787	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12787	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12787	8	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	12787	9	,	,	,
18637	12787	10	206	206	CD
18637	12787	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12787	12	46	46	CD
18637	12787	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12787	14	1907	1907	CD
18637	12787	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12787	16	.	.	.
18637	12788	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12788	2	462	462	CD
18637	12788	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12788	4	283	283	CD
18637	12788	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12788	6	336	336	CD
18637	12788	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12788	8	1931	1931	CD
18637	12788	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12788	10	.	.	.
18637	12789	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12789	2	463	463	CD
18637	12789	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12789	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12789	5	.	.	.
18637	12790	1	342	342	CD
18637	12790	2	.	.	.
18637	12791	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12791	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12791	3	also	also	RB
18637	12791	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12791	5	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	12791	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12791	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12791	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12791	9	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	12791	10	,	,	,
18637	12791	11	325	325	CD
18637	12791	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12791	13	589	589	CD
18637	12791	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12791	15	1945	1945	CD
18637	12791	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12791	17	,	,	,
18637	12791	18	for	for	IN
18637	12791	19	the	the	DT
18637	12791	20	restatement	restatement	NN
18637	12791	21	of	of	IN
18637	12791	22	the	the	DT
18637	12791	23	familiar	familiar	JJ
18637	12791	24	principle	principle	NN
18637	12791	25	that	that	IN
18637	12791	26	the	the	DT
18637	12791	27	power	power	NN
18637	12791	28	of	of	IN
18637	12791	29	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	12791	30	among	among	IN
18637	12791	31	several	several	JJ
18637	12791	32	States	state	NNS
18637	12791	33	of	of	IN
18637	12791	34	waters	water	NNS
18637	12791	35	of	of	IN
18637	12791	36	an	an	DT
18637	12791	37	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	12791	38	river	river	NN
18637	12791	39	where	where	WRB
18637	12791	40	the	the	DT
18637	12791	41	demands	demand	NNS
18637	12791	42	of	of	IN
18637	12791	43	the	the	DT
18637	12791	44	users	user	NNS
18637	12791	45	exceeds	exceed	VBZ
18637	12791	46	the	the	DT
18637	12791	47	supply	supply	NN
18637	12791	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	12791	49	a	a	DT
18637	12791	50	matter	matter	NN
18637	12791	51	of	of	IN
18637	12791	52	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	12791	53	importance	importance	NN
18637	12791	54	and	and	CC
18637	12791	55	dignity	dignity	NN
18637	12791	56	as	as	IN
18637	12791	57	to	to	TO
18637	12791	58	be	be	VB
18637	12791	59	justiciable	justiciable	NN
18637	12791	60	in	in	IN
18637	12791	61	the	the	DT
18637	12791	62	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12791	63	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12791	64	.	.	.
18637	12792	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12792	2	464	464	CD
18637	12792	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12792	4	South	South	NNP
18637	12792	5	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	12792	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12792	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12792	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12792	9	North	North	NNP
18637	12792	10	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	12792	11	,	,	,
18637	12792	12	192	192	CD
18637	12792	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12792	14	286	286	CD
18637	12792	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12792	16	1904	1904	CD
18637	12792	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12792	18	.	.	.
18637	12793	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12793	2	465	465	CD
18637	12793	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12793	4	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	12793	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12793	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12793	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12793	8	West	West	NNP
18637	12793	9	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	12793	10	,	,	,
18637	12793	11	220	220	CD
18637	12793	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12793	13	1	1	CD
18637	12793	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12793	15	1911	1911	CD
18637	12793	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12793	17	.	.	.
18637	12794	1	This	this	DT
18637	12794	2	case	case	NN
18637	12794	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	12794	4	also	also	RB
18637	12794	5	significant	significant	JJ
18637	12794	6	for	for	IN
18637	12794	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12794	8	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	12794	9	'	'	POS
18637	12794	10	statement	statement	NN
18637	12794	11	that	that	IN
18637	12794	12	,	,	,
18637	12794	13	"	"	``
18637	12794	14	The	the	DT
18637	12794	15	case	case	NN
18637	12794	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	12794	17	to	to	TO
18637	12794	18	be	be	VB
18637	12794	19	considered	consider	VBN
18637	12794	20	in	in	IN
18637	12794	21	the	the	DT
18637	12794	22	untechnical	untechnical	JJ
18637	12794	23	spirit	spirit	NN
18637	12794	24	proper	proper	JJ
18637	12794	25	for	for	IN
18637	12794	26	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	12794	27	with	with	IN
18637	12794	28	a	a	DT
18637	12794	29	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	12794	30	-	-	JJ
18637	12794	31	international	international	JJ
18637	12794	32	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	12794	33	,	,	,
18637	12794	34	remembering	remember	VBG
18637	12794	35	that	that	IN
18637	12794	36	there	there	EX
18637	12794	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	12794	38	no	no	DT
18637	12794	39	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	12794	40	code	code	NN
18637	12794	41	governing	govern	VBG
18637	12794	42	the	the	DT
18637	12794	43	matter	matter	NN
18637	12794	44	,	,	,
18637	12794	45	and	and	CC
18637	12794	46	that	that	IN
18637	12794	47	this	this	DT
18637	12794	48	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12794	49	may	may	MD
18637	12794	50	be	be	VB
18637	12794	51	called	call	VBN
18637	12794	52	on	on	RP
18637	12794	53	to	to	TO
18637	12794	54	adjust	adjust	VB
18637	12794	55	differences	difference	NNS
18637	12794	56	that	that	WDT
18637	12794	57	can	can	MD
18637	12794	58	not	not	RB
18637	12794	59	be	be	VB
18637	12794	60	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	12794	61	with	with	IN
18637	12794	62	by	by	IN
18637	12794	63	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	12794	64	or	or	CC
18637	12794	65	disposed	dispose	VBN
18637	12794	66	of	of	IN
18637	12794	67	by	by	IN
18637	12794	68	the	the	DT
18637	12794	69	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	12794	70	of	of	IN
18637	12794	71	either	either	CC
18637	12794	72	State	state	NN
18637	12794	73	alone	alone	RB
18637	12794	74	.	.	.
18637	12794	75	"	"	''
18637	12795	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	12795	2	.	.	.
18637	12796	1	27	27	CD
18637	12796	2	.	.	.
18637	12797	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12797	2	466	466	CD
18637	12797	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12797	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	12797	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12797	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12797	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12797	8	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	12797	9	,	,	,
18637	12797	10	281	281	CD
18637	12797	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12797	12	163	163	CD
18637	12797	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12797	14	1930	1930	CD
18637	12797	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12797	16	.	.	.
18637	12798	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12798	2	467	467	CD
18637	12798	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12798	4	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	12798	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12798	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12798	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12798	8	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	12798	9	et	et	NNP
18637	12798	10	al	al	NNP
18637	12798	11	.	.	NNP
18637	12798	12	,	,	,
18637	12798	13	306	306	CD
18637	12798	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12798	15	398	398	CD
18637	12798	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12798	17	1939	1939	CD
18637	12798	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12798	19	.	.	.
18637	12799	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12799	2	468	468	CD
18637	12799	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12799	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	12799	5	and	and	CC
18637	12799	6	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	12799	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12799	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12799	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12799	10	West	West	NNP
18637	12799	11	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	12799	12	,	,	,
18637	12799	13	262	262	CD
18637	12799	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12799	15	553	553	CD
18637	12799	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12799	17	1923	1923	CD
18637	12799	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12799	19	.	.	.
18637	12800	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12800	2	469	469	CD
18637	12800	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12800	4	12	12	CD
18637	12800	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12800	6	.	.	.
18637	12801	1	657	657	CD
18637	12801	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12801	3	1838	1838	CD
18637	12801	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12801	5	.	.	.
18637	12802	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12802	2	470	470	CD
18637	12802	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12802	4	6	6	CD
18637	12802	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12802	6	.	.	.
18637	12803	1	264	264	CD
18637	12803	2	,	,	,
18637	12803	3	378	378	CD
18637	12803	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12803	5	1821	1821	CD
18637	12803	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12803	7	.	.	.
18637	12804	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12804	2	471	471	CD
18637	12804	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12804	4	291	291	CD
18637	12804	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12804	6	286	286	CD
18637	12804	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12804	8	1934	1934	CD
18637	12804	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12804	10	.	.	.
18637	12805	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12805	2	472	472	CD
18637	12805	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12805	4	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	12805	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12805	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12805	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12805	8	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	12805	9	,	,	,
18637	12805	10	308	308	CD
18637	12805	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12805	12	1	1	CD
18637	12805	13	,	,	,
18637	12805	14	15	15	CD
18637	12805	15	-	-	SYM
18637	12805	16	16	16	CD
18637	12805	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12805	18	1939	1939	CD
18637	12805	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12805	20	,	,	,
18637	12805	21	citing	cite	VBG
18637	12805	22	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	12805	23	_	_	NNP
18637	12805	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	12805	25	_	_	NNP
18637	12805	26	Mellon	Mellon	NNP
18637	12805	27	,	,	,
18637	12805	28	273	273	CD
18637	12805	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12805	30	12	12	CD
18637	12805	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12805	32	1927	1927	CD
18637	12805	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12805	34	.	.	.
18637	12806	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12806	2	473	473	CD
18637	12806	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12806	4	306	306	CD
18637	12806	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12806	6	398	398	CD
18637	12806	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12806	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	12806	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12806	10	.	.	.
18637	12807	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12807	2	474	474	CD
18637	12807	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12807	4	308	308	CD
18637	12807	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12807	6	1	1	CD
18637	12807	7	,	,	,
18637	12807	8	17	17	CD
18637	12807	9	,	,	,
18637	12807	10	citing	cite	VBG
18637	12807	11	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	12807	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12807	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	12807	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12807	15	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	12807	16	,	,	,
18637	12807	17	T.	T.	NNP
18637	12807	18	&	&	CC
18637	12807	19	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	12808	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12808	2	,	,	,
18637	12808	3	220	220	CD
18637	12808	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12808	5	277	277	CD
18637	12808	6	,	,	,
18637	12808	7	286	286	CD
18637	12808	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12808	9	1911	1911	CD
18637	12808	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12808	11	,	,	,
18637	12808	12	and	and	CC
18637	12808	13	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	12808	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12808	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	12808	16	_	_	NNP
18637	12808	17	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	12808	18	,	,	,
18637	12808	19	304	304	CD
18637	12808	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12808	21	387	387	CD
18637	12808	22	,	,	,
18637	12808	23	394	394	CD
18637	12808	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12808	25	1938	1938	CD
18637	12808	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12808	27	.	.	.
18637	12809	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12809	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12809	3	also	also	RB
18637	12809	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12809	5	New	New	NNP
18637	12809	6	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	12809	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12809	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12809	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12809	10	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	12809	11	,	,	,
18637	12809	12	108	108	CD
18637	12809	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12809	14	76	76	CD
18637	12809	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12809	16	1883	1883	CD
18637	12809	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12809	18	,	,	,
18637	12809	19	which	which	WDT
18637	12809	20	held	hold	VBD
18637	12809	21	that	that	IN
18637	12809	22	a	a	DT
18637	12809	23	State	state	NN
18637	12809	24	can	can	MD
18637	12809	25	not	not	RB
18637	12809	26	bring	bring	VB
18637	12809	27	a	a	DT
18637	12809	28	suit	suit	NN
18637	12809	29	on	on	IN
18637	12809	30	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	12809	31	of	of	IN
18637	12809	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12809	33	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	12809	34	to	to	TO
18637	12809	35	collect	collect	VB
18637	12809	36	on	on	IN
18637	12809	37	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	12809	38	issued	issue	VBN
18637	12809	39	by	by	IN
18637	12809	40	another	another	DT
18637	12809	41	State	State	NNP
18637	12809	42	,	,	,
18637	12809	43	and	and	CC
18637	12809	44	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	12809	45	_	_	NNP
18637	12809	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	12809	47	_	_	NNP
18637	12809	48	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	12809	49	,	,	,
18637	12809	50	176	176	CD
18637	12809	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12809	52	1	1	CD
18637	12809	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12809	54	1900	1900	CD
18637	12809	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12809	56	,	,	,
18637	12809	57	which	which	WDT
18637	12809	58	held	hold	VBD
18637	12809	59	that	that	IN
18637	12809	60	a	a	DT
18637	12809	61	State	state	NN
18637	12809	62	can	can	MD
18637	12809	63	not	not	RB
18637	12809	64	sue	sue	VB
18637	12809	65	another	another	DT
18637	12809	66	to	to	TO
18637	12809	67	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	12809	68	maladministration	maladministration	NN
18637	12809	69	of	of	IN
18637	12809	70	quarantine	quarantine	JJ
18637	12809	71	laws	law	NNS
18637	12809	72	.	.	.
18637	12810	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12810	2	475	475	CD
18637	12810	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12810	4	308	308	CD
18637	12810	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12810	6	1	1	CD
18637	12810	7	,	,	,
18637	12810	8	17	17	CD
18637	12810	9	.	.	.
18637	12811	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12811	2	476	476	CD
18637	12811	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12811	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12811	5	.	.	.
18637	12812	1	19	19	CD
18637	12812	2	.	.	.
18637	12813	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12813	2	477	477	CD
18637	12813	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12813	4	The	the	DT
18637	12813	5	various	various	JJ
18637	12813	6	litigations	litigation	NNS
18637	12813	7	of	of	IN
18637	12813	8	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	12813	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12813	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	12813	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12813	12	West	West	NNP
18637	12813	13	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	12813	14	are	be	VBP
18637	12813	15	to	to	TO
18637	12813	16	be	be	VB
18637	12813	17	found	find	VBN
18637	12813	18	in	in	IN
18637	12813	19	206	206	CD
18637	12813	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12813	21	290	290	CD
18637	12813	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12813	23	1907	1907	CD
18637	12813	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12813	25	;	;	:
18637	12813	26	209	209	CD
18637	12813	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12813	28	514	514	CD
18637	12813	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12813	30	1908	1908	CD
18637	12813	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12813	32	;	;	:
18637	12813	33	220	220	CD
18637	12813	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12813	35	1	1	CD
18637	12813	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12813	37	1911	1911	CD
18637	12813	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12813	39	;	;	:
18637	12813	40	222	222	CD
18637	12813	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12813	42	17	17	CD
18637	12813	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12813	44	1911	1911	CD
18637	12813	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12813	46	;	;	:
18637	12813	47	231	231	CD
18637	12813	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12813	49	89	89	CD
18637	12813	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12813	51	1913	1913	CD
18637	12813	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12813	53	;	;	:
18637	12813	54	234	234	CD
18637	12813	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12813	56	117	117	CD
18637	12813	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12813	58	1914	1914	CD
18637	12813	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12813	60	;	;	:
18637	12813	61	238	238	CD
18637	12813	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12813	63	202	202	CD
18637	12813	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12813	65	1915	1915	CD
18637	12813	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12813	67	;	;	:
18637	12813	68	241	241	CD
18637	12813	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12813	70	531	531	CD
18637	12813	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12813	72	1916	1916	CD
18637	12813	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12813	74	;	;	:
18637	12813	75	246	246	CD
18637	12813	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12813	77	565	565	CD
18637	12813	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12813	79	1918	1918	CD
18637	12813	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12813	81	.	.	.
18637	12814	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12814	2	478	478	CD
18637	12814	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12814	4	246	246	CD
18637	12814	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12814	6	565	565	CD
18637	12814	7	,	,	,
18637	12814	8	591	591	CD
18637	12814	9	.	.	.
18637	12815	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12815	2	479	479	CD
18637	12815	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12815	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12815	5	.	.	.
18637	12816	1	600	600	CD
18637	12816	2	.	.	.
18637	12817	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12817	2	480	480	CD
18637	12817	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12817	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12817	5	.	.	.
18637	12818	1	601	601	CD
18637	12818	2	.	.	.
18637	12819	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12819	2	481	481	CD
18637	12819	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12819	4	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	12819	5	,	,	,
18637	12819	6	The	the	DT
18637	12819	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12819	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12819	9	and	and	CC
18637	12819	10	Sovereign	Sovereign	NNP
18637	12819	11	States	States	NNPS
18637	12819	12	,	,	,
18637	12819	13	79	79	CD
18637	12819	14	.	.	.
18637	12820	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12820	2	482	482	CD
18637	12820	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12820	4	2	2	CD
18637	12820	5	Dall	dall	NN
18637	12820	6	.	.	.
18637	12821	1	419	419	CD
18637	12821	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12821	3	1793	1793	CD
18637	12821	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12821	5	.	.	.
18637	12822	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12822	2	483	483	CD
18637	12822	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12822	4	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	12822	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12822	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12822	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12822	8	Mellon	Mellon	NNP
18637	12822	9	,	,	,
18637	12822	10	262	262	CD
18637	12822	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12822	12	447	447	CD
18637	12822	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12822	14	1923	1923	CD
18637	12822	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12822	16	;	;	:
18637	12822	17	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	12822	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12822	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	12822	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12822	21	Mellon	Mellon	NNP
18637	12822	22	,	,	,
18637	12822	23	273	273	CD
18637	12822	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12822	25	12	12	CD
18637	12822	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12822	27	1927	1927	CD
18637	12822	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12822	29	;	;	:
18637	12822	30	New	New	NNP
18637	12822	31	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	12822	32	_	_	NNP
18637	12822	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	12822	34	_	_	NNP
18637	12822	35	Sargent	Sargent	NNP
18637	12822	36	,	,	,
18637	12822	37	269	269	CD
18637	12822	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12822	39	328	328	CD
18637	12822	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12822	41	1926	1926	CD
18637	12822	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12822	43	.	.	.
18637	12823	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12823	2	484	484	CD
18637	12823	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12823	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	12823	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12823	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12823	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12823	8	Quicksilver	Quicksilver	NNP
18637	12823	9	Min	Min	NNP
18637	12823	10	.	.	.
18637	12824	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12824	2	,	,	,
18637	12824	3	10	10	CD
18637	12824	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12824	5	.	.	.
18637	12825	1	553	553	CD
18637	12825	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12825	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	12825	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12825	5	;	;	:
18637	12825	6	California	California	NNP
18637	12825	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12825	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12825	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12825	10	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	12825	11	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	12825	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12825	13	,	,	,
18637	12825	14	157	157	CD
18637	12825	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12825	16	229	229	CD
18637	12825	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12825	18	1895	1895	CD
18637	12825	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12825	20	;	;	:
18637	12825	21	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	12825	22	_	_	NNP
18637	12825	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	12825	24	_	_	NNP
18637	12825	25	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	12825	26	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	12825	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12825	28	,	,	,
18637	12825	29	184	184	CD
18637	12825	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12825	31	199	199	CD
18637	12825	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12825	33	1902	1902	CD
18637	12825	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12825	35	.	.	.
18637	12826	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12826	2	485	485	CD
18637	12826	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12826	4	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	12826	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12826	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12826	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12826	8	Pelican	Pelican	NNP
18637	12826	9	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	12826	10	.	.	.
18637	12827	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12827	2	,	,	,
18637	12827	3	127	127	CD
18637	12827	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12827	5	265	265	CD
18637	12827	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12827	7	1888	1888	CD
18637	12827	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12827	9	.	.	.
18637	12828	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12828	2	486	486	CD
18637	12828	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12828	4	4	4	CD
18637	12828	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12828	6	.	.	.
18637	12829	1	475	475	CD
18637	12829	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12829	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	12829	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12829	5	.	.	.
18637	12830	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12830	2	487	487	CD
18637	12830	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12830	4	6	6	CD
18637	12830	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12830	6	.	.	.
18637	12831	1	50	50	CD
18637	12831	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12831	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	12831	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12831	5	.	.	.
18637	12832	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12832	2	488	488	CD
18637	12832	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12832	4	262	262	CD
18637	12832	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12832	6	447	447	CD
18637	12832	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12832	8	1923	1923	CD
18637	12832	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12832	10	.	.	.
18637	12833	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12833	2	489	489	CD
18637	12833	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12833	4	273	273	CD
18637	12833	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12833	6	12	12	CD
18637	12833	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12833	8	1927	1927	CD
18637	12833	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12833	10	.	.	.
18637	12834	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12834	2	490	490	CD
18637	12834	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12834	4	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	12834	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12834	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12834	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12834	8	.	.	.
18637	12835	1	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	12835	2	,	,	,
18637	12835	3	T.	T.	NNP
18637	12835	4	&	&	CC
18637	12835	5	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	12836	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12836	2	,	,	,
18637	12836	3	220	220	CD
18637	12836	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12836	5	277	277	CD
18637	12836	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12836	7	1911	1911	CD
18637	12836	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12836	9	;	;	:
18637	12836	10	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	12836	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12836	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	12836	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12836	14	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	12836	15	,	,	,
18637	12836	16	304	304	CD
18637	12836	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12836	18	387	387	CD
18637	12836	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12836	20	1938	1938	CD
18637	12836	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12836	22	.	.	.
18637	12837	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12837	2	491	491	CD
18637	12837	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12837	4	6	6	CD
18637	12837	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12837	6	.	.	.
18637	12838	1	264	264	CD
18637	12838	2	,	,	,
18637	12838	3	398	398	CD
18637	12838	4	-	-	SYM
18637	12838	5	399	399	CD
18637	12838	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12838	7	1821	1821	CD
18637	12838	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12838	9	.	.	.
18637	12839	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12839	2	492	492	CD
18637	12839	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12839	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	12839	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12839	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12839	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12839	8	Quicksilver	Quicksilver	NNP
18637	12839	9	Min	Min	NNP
18637	12839	10	.	.	.
18637	12840	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12840	2	,	,	,
18637	12840	3	10	10	CD
18637	12840	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12840	5	.	.	.
18637	12841	1	553	553	CD
18637	12841	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12841	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	12841	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12841	5	.	.	.
18637	12842	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12842	2	493	493	CD
18637	12842	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12842	4	California	California	NNP
18637	12842	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12842	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12842	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12842	8	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	12842	9	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	12842	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12842	11	,	,	,
18637	12842	12	157	157	CD
18637	12842	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12842	14	229	229	CD
18637	12842	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12842	16	1895	1895	CD
18637	12842	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12842	18	;	;	:
18637	12842	19	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	12842	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12842	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	12842	22	_	_	NNP
18637	12842	23	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	12842	24	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	12842	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12842	26	,	,	,
18637	12842	27	184	184	CD
18637	12842	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12842	29	199	199	CD
18637	12842	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12842	31	1902	1902	CD
18637	12842	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12842	33	.	.	.
18637	12843	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12843	2	494	494	CD
18637	12843	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12843	4	6	6	CD
18637	12843	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12843	6	.	.	.
18637	12844	1	264	264	CD
18637	12844	2	,	,	,
18637	12844	3	398	398	CD
18637	12844	4	-	-	SYM
18637	12844	5	399	399	CD
18637	12844	6	.	.	.
18637	12845	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12845	2	495	495	CD
18637	12845	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12845	4	127	127	CD
18637	12845	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12845	6	265	265	CD
18637	12845	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12845	8	1888	1888	CD
18637	12845	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12845	10	.	.	.
18637	12846	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12846	2	496	496	CD
18637	12846	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12846	4	2	2	CD
18637	12846	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12846	6	.	.	.
18637	12847	1	419	419	CD
18637	12847	2	,	,	,
18637	12847	3	431	431	CD
18637	12847	4	-	-	SYM
18637	12847	5	432	432	CD
18637	12847	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12847	7	1793	1793	CD
18637	12847	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12847	9	.	.	.
18637	12848	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12848	2	497	497	CD
18637	12848	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12848	4	127	127	CD
18637	12848	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12848	6	265	265	CD
18637	12848	7	,	,	,
18637	12848	8	289	289	CD
18637	12848	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12848	10	300	300	CD
18637	12848	11	.	.	.
18637	12849	1	This	this	DT
18637	12849	2	case	case	NN
18637	12849	3	also	also	RB
18637	12849	4	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	12849	5	the	the	DT
18637	12849	6	general	general	JJ
18637	12849	7	rule	rule	NN
18637	12849	8	that	that	IN
18637	12849	9	a	a	DT
18637	12849	10	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	12849	11	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	12849	12	by	by	IN
18637	12849	13	the	the	DT
18637	12849	14	laws	law	NNS
18637	12849	15	of	of	IN
18637	12849	16	a	a	DT
18637	12849	17	State	State	NNP
18637	12849	18	,	,	,
18637	12849	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	12849	20	a	a	DT
18637	12849	21	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	12849	22	of	of	IN
18637	12849	23	that	that	DT
18637	12849	24	State	State	NNP
18637	12849	25	for	for	IN
18637	12849	26	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	12849	27	of	of	IN
18637	12849	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12849	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12849	30	.	.	.
18637	12850	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12850	2	498	498	CD
18637	12850	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12850	4	304	304	CD
18637	12850	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12850	6	387	387	CD
18637	12850	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12850	8	1938	1938	CD
18637	12850	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12850	10	.	.	.
18637	12851	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12851	2	499	499	CD
18637	12851	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12851	4	220	220	CD
18637	12851	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12851	6	277	277	CD
18637	12851	7	,	,	,
18637	12851	8	286	286	CD
18637	12851	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12851	10	289	289	CD
18637	12851	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12851	12	1911	1911	CD
18637	12851	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12851	14	.	.	.
18637	12852	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12852	2	500	500	CD
18637	12852	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12852	4	316	316	CD
18637	12852	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12852	6	159	159	CD
18637	12852	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12852	8	1942	1942	CD
18637	12852	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12852	10	.	.	.
18637	12853	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12853	2	501	501	CD
18637	12853	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12853	4	220	220	CD
18637	12853	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12853	6	277	277	CD
18637	12853	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12853	8	1911	1911	CD
18637	12853	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12853	10	.	.	.
18637	12854	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12854	2	502	502	CD
18637	12854	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12854	4	324	324	CD
18637	12854	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12854	6	439	439	CD
18637	12854	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12854	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	12854	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12854	10	.	.	.
18637	12855	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12855	2	503	503	CD
18637	12855	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12855	4	206	206	CD
18637	12855	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12855	6	230	230	CD
18637	12855	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12855	8	1907	1907	CD
18637	12855	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12855	10	.	.	.
18637	12856	1	Here	here	RB
18637	12856	2	the	the	DT
18637	12856	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12856	4	entertained	entertain	VBD
18637	12856	5	a	a	DT
18637	12856	6	suit	suit	NN
18637	12856	7	by	by	IN
18637	12856	8	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	12856	9	and	and	CC
18637	12856	10	enjoined	enjoin	VBD
18637	12856	11	the	the	DT
18637	12856	12	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	12856	13	company	company	NN
18637	12856	14	from	from	IN
18637	12856	15	discharging	discharge	VBG
18637	12856	16	noxious	noxious	JJ
18637	12856	17	gases	gas	NNS
18637	12856	18	from	from	IN
18637	12856	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12856	20	works	work	NNS
18637	12856	21	in	in	IN
18637	12856	22	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	12856	23	over	over	IN
18637	12856	24	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	12856	25	's	's	POS
18637	12856	26	territory	territory	NN
18637	12856	27	.	.	.
18637	12857	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12857	2	504	504	CD
18637	12857	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12857	4	324	324	CD
18637	12857	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12857	6	439	439	CD
18637	12857	7	,	,	,
18637	12857	8	447	447	CD
18637	12857	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12857	10	448	448	CD
18637	12857	11	,	,	,
18637	12857	12	citing	cite	VBG
18637	12857	13	and	and	CC
18637	12857	14	quoting	quote	VBG
18637	12857	15	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	12857	16	_	_	NNP
18637	12857	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	12857	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12857	19	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	12857	20	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	12857	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12857	22	,	,	,
18637	12857	23	206	206	CD
18637	12857	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12857	25	230	230	CD
18637	12857	26	,	,	,
18637	12857	27	237	237	CD
18637	12857	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12857	29	1907	1907	CD
18637	12857	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12857	31	.	.	.
18637	12858	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12858	2	505	505	CD
18637	12858	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12858	4	324	324	CD
18637	12858	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12858	6	439	439	CD
18637	12858	7	,	,	,
18637	12858	8	450	450	CD
18637	12858	9	,	,	,
18637	12858	10	citing	cite	VBG
18637	12858	11	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	12858	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12858	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	12858	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12858	15	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	12858	16	,	,	,
18637	12858	17	180	180	CD
18637	12858	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12858	19	208	208	CD
18637	12858	20	,	,	,
18637	12858	21	219	219	CD
18637	12858	22	-	-	SYM
18637	12858	23	224	224	CD
18637	12858	24	,	,	,
18637	12858	25	241	241	CD
18637	12858	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12858	27	1901	1901	CD
18637	12858	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12858	29	;	;	:
18637	12858	30	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	12858	31	_	_	NNP
18637	12858	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	12858	33	_	_	NNP
18637	12858	34	West	West	NNP
18637	12858	35	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	12858	36	,	,	,
18637	12858	37	246	246	CD
18637	12858	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12858	39	565	565	CD
18637	12858	40	,	,	,
18637	12858	41	599	599	CD
18637	12858	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12858	43	1918	1918	CD
18637	12858	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12858	45	;	;	:
18637	12858	46	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	12858	47	_	_	NNP
18637	12858	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	12858	49	_	_	NNP
18637	12858	50	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	12858	51	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	12858	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12858	53	,	,	,
18637	12858	54	206	206	CD
18637	12858	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12858	56	230	230	CD
18637	12858	57	,	,	,
18637	12858	58	237	237	CD
18637	12858	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12858	60	1907	1907	CD
18637	12858	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12858	62	.	.	.
18637	12859	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12859	2	506	506	CD
18637	12859	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12859	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12859	5	.	.	.
18637	12860	1	451	451	CD
18637	12860	2	,	,	,
18637	12860	3	468	468	CD
18637	12860	4	.	.	.
18637	12861	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	12861	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12861	3	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	12861	4	,	,	,
18637	12861	5	joined	join	VBN
18637	12861	6	by	by	IN
18637	12861	7	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	12861	8	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	12861	9	,	,	,
18637	12861	10	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	12861	11	,	,	,
18637	12861	12	and	and	CC
18637	12861	13	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	12861	14	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	12861	15	on	on	IN
18637	12861	16	the	the	DT
18637	12861	17	ground	ground	NN
18637	12861	18	that	that	IN
18637	12861	19	the	the	DT
18637	12861	20	suit	suit	NN
18637	12861	21	actually	actually	RB
18637	12861	22	was	be	VBD
18637	12861	23	one	one	CD
18637	12861	24	for	for	IN
18637	12861	25	a	a	DT
18637	12861	26	district	district	NN
18637	12861	27	court	court	NN
18637	12861	28	,	,	,
18637	12861	29	that	that	IN
18637	12861	30	a	a	DT
18637	12861	31	State	state	NN
18637	12861	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	12861	33	without	without	IN
18637	12861	34	standing	stand	VBG
18637	12861	35	to	to	TO
18637	12861	36	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	12861	37	suit	suit	NN
18637	12861	38	for	for	IN
18637	12861	39	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	12861	40	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	12861	41	by	by	IN
18637	12861	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12861	43	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	12861	44	and	and	CC
18637	12861	45	residents	resident	NNS
18637	12861	46	for	for	IN
18637	12861	47	which	which	WDT
18637	12861	48	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12861	49	may	may	MD
18637	12861	50	sue	sue	VB
18637	12861	51	in	in	IN
18637	12861	52	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12861	53	own	own	JJ
18637	12861	54	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	12861	55	,	,	,
18637	12861	56	and	and	CC
18637	12861	57	that	that	IN
18637	12861	58	as	as	IN
18637	12861	59	presented	present	VBD
18637	12861	60	the	the	DT
18637	12861	61	suit	suit	NN
18637	12861	62	was	be	VBD
18637	12861	63	not	not	RB
18637	12861	64	one	one	CD
18637	12861	65	in	in	IN
18637	12861	66	which	which	WDT
18637	12861	67	a	a	DT
18637	12861	68	court	court	NN
18637	12861	69	of	of	IN
18637	12861	70	equity	equity	NN
18637	12861	71	could	could	MD
18637	12861	72	give	give	VB
18637	12861	73	effective	effective	JJ
18637	12861	74	relief	relief	NN
18637	12861	75	.	.	.
18637	12862	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12862	2	507	507	CD
18637	12862	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12862	4	2	2	CD
18637	12862	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12862	6	.	.	.
18637	12863	1	445	445	CD
18637	12863	2	,	,	,
18637	12863	3	452	452	CD
18637	12863	4	-	-	SYM
18637	12863	5	453	453	CD
18637	12863	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12863	7	1805	1805	CD
18637	12863	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12863	9	.	.	.
18637	12864	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12864	2	508	508	CD
18637	12864	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12864	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12864	5	.	.	.
18637	12865	1	453	453	CD
18637	12865	2	.	.	.
18637	12866	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12866	2	509	509	CD
18637	12866	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12866	4	New	New	NNP
18637	12866	5	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	12866	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12866	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	12866	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12866	9	Winter	Winter	NNP
18637	12866	10	et	et	NNP
18637	12866	11	al	al	NNP
18637	12866	12	.	.	NNP
18637	12866	13	,	,	,
18637	12866	14	1	1	CD
18637	12866	15	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	12866	16	.	.	.
18637	12867	1	91	91	CD
18637	12867	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12867	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	12867	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12867	5	.	.	.
18637	12868	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12868	2	510	510	CD
18637	12868	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12868	4	54	54	CD
18637	12868	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	12868	6	.	.	.
18637	12869	1	143	143	CD
18637	12869	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12869	3	1940	1940	CD
18637	12869	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12869	5	;	;	:
18637	12869	6	28	28	CD
18637	12869	7	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	12870	1	1332	1332	CD
18637	12870	2	.	.	.
18637	12871	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12871	2	511	511	CD
18637	12871	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12871	4	337	337	CD
18637	12871	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12871	6	582	582	CD
18637	12871	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12871	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	12871	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12871	10	.	.	.
18637	12872	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12872	2	512	512	CD
18637	12872	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12872	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12872	5	.	.	.
18637	12873	1	583	583	CD
18637	12873	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12873	3	604	604	CD
18637	12873	4	.	.	.
18637	12874	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12874	2	513	513	CD
18637	12874	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12874	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12874	5	.	.	.
18637	12875	1	604	604	CD
18637	12875	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12875	3	625	625	CD
18637	12875	4	.	.	.
18637	12876	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12876	2	514	514	LS
18637	12876	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12876	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12876	5	.	.	.
18637	12877	1	626	626	CD
18637	12877	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12877	3	646	646	CD
18637	12877	4	.	.	.
18637	12878	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12878	2	515	515	CD
18637	12878	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12878	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12878	5	.	.	.
18637	12879	1	646	646	CD
18637	12879	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12879	3	655	655	CD
18637	12879	4	.	.	.
18637	12880	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12880	2	516	516	CD
18637	12880	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12880	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12880	5	.	.	.
18637	12881	1	655	655	CD
18637	12881	2	.	.	.
18637	12882	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12882	2	517	517	CD
18637	12882	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12882	4	Knox	Knox	NNP
18637	12882	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12882	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12882	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12882	8	Greenleaf	Greenleaf	NNP
18637	12882	9	,	,	,
18637	12882	10	4	4	CD
18637	12882	11	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	12882	12	.	.	.
18637	12883	1	360	360	CD
18637	12883	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12883	3	1802	1802	CD
18637	12883	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12883	5	.	.	.
18637	12884	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12884	2	518	518	CD
18637	12884	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12884	4	Shelton	Shelton	NNP
18637	12884	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12884	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12884	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12884	8	Tiffin	Tiffin	NNP
18637	12884	9	,	,	,
18637	12884	10	6	6	CD
18637	12884	11	How	how	WRB
18637	12884	12	.	.	.
18637	12885	1	163	163	CD
18637	12885	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12885	3	1848	1848	CD
18637	12885	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12885	5	.	.	.
18637	12886	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12886	2	519	519	CD
18637	12886	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12886	4	Williamson	Williamson	NNP
18637	12886	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12886	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12886	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12886	8	Osenton	Osenton	NNP
18637	12886	9	,	,	,
18637	12886	10	232	232	CD
18637	12886	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12886	12	619	619	CD
18637	12886	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12886	14	1014	1014	CD
18637	12886	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12886	16	.	.	.
18637	12887	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12887	2	520	520	CD
18637	12887	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12887	4	Shelton	Shelton	NNP
18637	12887	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12887	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12887	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12887	8	Tiffin	Tiffin	NNP
18637	12887	9	,	,	,
18637	12887	10	6	6	CD
18637	12887	11	How	how	WRB
18637	12887	12	.	.	.
18637	12888	1	163	163	CD
18637	12888	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12888	3	1848	1848	CD
18637	12888	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12888	5	.	.	.
18637	12889	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12889	2	521	521	CD
18637	12889	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12889	4	Williamson	Williamson	NNP
18637	12889	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12889	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12889	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12889	8	Osenton	Osenton	NNP
18637	12889	9	,	,	,
18637	12889	10	232	232	CD
18637	12889	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12889	12	619	619	CD
18637	12889	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12889	14	1914	1914	CD
18637	12889	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12889	16	.	.	.
18637	12890	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12890	2	522	522	CD
18637	12890	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12890	4	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	12890	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12890	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12890	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12890	8	League	League	NNP
18637	12890	9	,	,	,
18637	12890	10	18	18	CD
18637	12890	11	How	how	WRB
18637	12890	12	.	.	.
18637	12891	1	76	76	CD
18637	12891	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12891	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	12891	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12891	5	.	.	.
18637	12892	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12892	2	523	523	CD
18637	12892	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12892	4	Shelton	Shelton	NNP
18637	12892	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12892	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12892	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12892	8	Tiffin	Tiffin	NNP
18637	12892	9	,	,	,
18637	12892	10	6	6	CD
18637	12892	11	How	how	WRB
18637	12892	12	.	.	.
18637	12893	1	163	163	CD
18637	12893	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12893	3	1848	1848	CD
18637	12893	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12893	5	.	.	.
18637	12894	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12894	2	524	524	CD
18637	12894	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12894	4	5	5	CD
18637	12894	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	12894	6	.	.	.
18637	12895	1	61	61	CD
18637	12895	2	,	,	,
18637	12895	3	86	86	CD
18637	12895	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12895	5	1809	1809	CD
18637	12895	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12895	7	.	.	.
18637	12896	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12896	2	525	525	CD
18637	12896	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12896	4	14	14	CD
18637	12896	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12896	6	.	.	.
18637	12897	1	60	60	CD
18637	12897	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12897	3	1840	1840	CD
18637	12897	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12897	5	.	.	.
18637	12898	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12898	2	526	526	CD
18637	12898	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12898	4	Strawbridge	Strawbridge	NNP
18637	12898	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12898	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12898	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12898	8	Curtiss	Curtiss	NNP
18637	12898	9	,	,	,
18637	12898	10	3	3	CD
18637	12898	11	Cr	Cr	NNP
18637	12898	12	.	.	.
18637	12899	1	267	267	CD
18637	12899	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12899	3	1806	1806	CD
18637	12899	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12899	5	.	.	.
18637	12900	1	The	the	DT
18637	12900	2	Slocomb	Slocomb	NNP
18637	12900	3	Case	Case	NNP
18637	12900	4	had	have	VBD
18637	12900	5	to	to	TO
18637	12900	6	be	be	VB
18637	12900	7	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
18637	12900	8	because	because	IN
18637	12900	9	two	two	CD
18637	12900	10	members	member	NNS
18637	12900	11	of	of	IN
18637	12900	12	the	the	DT
18637	12900	13	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	12900	14	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	12900	15	were	be	VBD
18637	12900	16	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	12900	17	of	of	IN
18637	12900	18	the	the	DT
18637	12900	19	same	same	JJ
18637	12900	20	State	State	NNP
18637	12900	21	as	as	IN
18637	12900	22	the	the	DT
18637	12900	23	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
18637	12900	24	.	.	.
18637	12901	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12901	2	527	527	CD
18637	12901	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12901	4	2	2	CD
18637	12901	5	How	how	WRB
18637	12901	6	.	.	.
18637	12902	1	497	497	CD
18637	12902	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12902	3	1844	1844	CD
18637	12902	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12902	5	.	.	.
18637	12903	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12903	2	528	528	CD
18637	12903	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12903	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12903	5	.	.	.
18637	12904	1	558	558	CD
18637	12904	2	.	.	.
18637	12905	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12905	2	529	529	CD
18637	12905	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12905	4	Muller	Muller	NNP
18637	12905	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12905	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12905	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12905	8	Dows	Dows	NNP
18637	12905	9	,	,	,
18637	12905	10	94	94	CD
18637	12905	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12905	12	444	444	CD
18637	12905	13	,	,	,
18637	12905	14	445	445	CD
18637	12905	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12905	16	1877	1877	CD
18637	12905	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12905	18	.	.	.
18637	12906	1	This	this	DT
18637	12906	2	fiction	fiction	NN
18637	12906	3	had	have	VBD
18637	12906	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12906	5	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	12906	6	in	in	IN
18637	12906	7	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	12906	8	_	_	NNP
18637	12906	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	12906	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12906	11	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	12906	12	&	&	CC
18637	12906	13	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	12906	14	R.	R.	NNP
18637	12906	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12906	16	,	,	,
18637	12906	17	16	16	CD
18637	12906	18	How	how	WRB
18637	12906	19	.	.	.
18637	12907	1	314	314	CD
18637	12907	2	,	,	,
18637	12907	3	329	329	CD
18637	12907	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12907	5	1854	1854	CD
18637	12907	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12907	7	and	and	CC
18637	12907	8	attained	attain	VBN
18637	12907	9	final	final	JJ
18637	12907	10	approval	approval	NN
18637	12907	11	in	in	IN
18637	12907	12	St.	St.	NNP
18637	12907	13	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	12907	14	&	&	CC
18637	12907	15	S.F.	S.F.	NNP
18637	12908	1	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	12908	2	.	.	.
18637	12909	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12909	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12909	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12909	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12909	5	James	James	NNP
18637	12909	6	,	,	,
18637	12909	7	161	161	CD
18637	12909	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12909	9	545	545	CD
18637	12909	10	,	,	,
18637	12909	11	554	554	CD
18637	12909	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12909	13	1896	1896	CD
18637	12909	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12909	15	.	.	.
18637	12910	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12910	2	530	530	CD
18637	12910	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12910	4	John	John	NNP
18637	12910	5	Chipman	Chipman	NNP
18637	12910	6	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	12910	7	,	,	,
18637	12910	8	The	the	DT
18637	12910	9	Nature	Nature	NNP
18637	12910	10	and	and	CC
18637	12910	11	Sources	Sources	NNPS
18637	12910	12	of	of	IN
18637	12910	13	the	the	DT
18637	12910	14	Law	Law	NNP
18637	12910	15	,	,	,
18637	12910	16	2d	2d	NNP
18637	12910	17	ed	ed	NNP
18637	12910	18	.	.	.
18637	12911	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12911	2	New	New	NNP
18637	12911	3	York	York	NNP
18637	12911	4	,	,	,
18637	12911	5	1927	1927	CD
18637	12911	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12911	7	,	,	,
18637	12911	8	34	34	CD
18637	12911	9	.	.	.
18637	12912	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12912	2	531	531	CD
18637	12912	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12912	4	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	12912	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12912	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12912	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12912	8	Woolsey	Woolsey	NNP
18637	12912	9	,	,	,
18637	12912	10	18	18	CD
18637	12912	11	How	how	WRB
18637	12912	12	.	.	.
18637	12913	1	331	331	CD
18637	12913	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12913	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	12913	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12913	5	;	;	:
18637	12913	6	Mechanics	Mechanics	NNP
18637	12913	7	'	'	POS
18637	12913	8	&	&	CC
18637	12913	9	Traders	Traders	NNPS
18637	12913	10	'	'	POS
18637	12913	11	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	12913	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12913	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	12913	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12913	15	Debolt	Debolt	NNP
18637	12913	16	,	,	,
18637	12913	17	18	18	CD
18637	12913	18	How	how	WRB
18637	12913	19	.	.	.
18637	12914	1	380	380	CD
18637	12914	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12914	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	12914	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12914	5	.	.	.
18637	12915	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12915	2	532	532	CD
18637	12915	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12915	4	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	12915	5	,	,	,
18637	12915	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12915	7	op	op	NN
18637	12915	8	.	.	.
18637	12916	1	cit	cit	NNP
18637	12916	2	.	.	.
18637	12916	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12916	4	,	,	,
18637	12916	5	185	185	CD
18637	12916	6	-	-	SYM
18637	12916	7	186	186	CD
18637	12916	8	.	.	.
18637	12917	1	Although	although	IN
18637	12917	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12917	3	Wayne	Wayne	NNP
18637	12917	4	criticized	criticize	VBD
18637	12917	5	the	the	DT
18637	12917	6	Strawbridge	Strawbridge	NNP
18637	12917	7	Case	Case	NNP
18637	12917	8	as	as	IN
18637	12917	9	going	go	VBG
18637	12917	10	too	too	RB
18637	12917	11	far	far	RB
18637	12917	12	,	,	,
18637	12917	13	later	later	RB
18637	12917	14	developments	development	NNS
18637	12917	15	in	in	IN
18637	12917	16	determining	determine	VBG
18637	12917	17	the	the	DT
18637	12917	18	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	12917	19	of	of	IN
18637	12917	20	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	12917	21	,	,	,
18637	12917	22	have	have	VBP
18637	12917	23	enabled	enable	VBN
18637	12917	24	the	the	DT
18637	12917	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12917	26	to	to	TO
18637	12917	27	restore	restore	VB
18637	12917	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12917	29	to	to	IN
18637	12917	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12917	31	original	original	JJ
18637	12917	32	status	status	NN
18637	12917	33	.	.	.
18637	12918	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	12918	2	the	the	DT
18637	12918	3	rule	rule	NN
18637	12918	4	still	still	RB
18637	12918	5	requires	require	VBZ
18637	12918	6	that	that	DT
18637	12918	7	to	to	TO
18637	12918	8	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	12918	9	a	a	DT
18637	12918	10	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	12918	11	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	12918	12	all	all	PDT
18637	12918	13	the	the	DT
18637	12918	14	parties	party	NNS
18637	12918	15	on	on	IN
18637	12918	16	one	one	CD
18637	12918	17	side	side	NN
18637	12918	18	must	must	MD
18637	12918	19	be	be	VB
18637	12918	20	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	12918	21	of	of	IN
18637	12918	22	different	different	JJ
18637	12918	23	States	state	NNS
18637	12918	24	from	from	IN
18637	12918	25	all	all	PDT
18637	12918	26	the	the	DT
18637	12918	27	parties	party	NNS
18637	12918	28	on	on	IN
18637	12918	29	the	the	DT
18637	12918	30	other	other	JJ
18637	12918	31	side	side	NN
18637	12918	32	.	.	.
18637	12919	1	Treinies	Treinies	NNP
18637	12919	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12919	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12919	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12919	5	Sunshine	Sunshine	NNP
18637	12919	6	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	12919	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12919	8	,	,	,
18637	12919	9	308	308	CD
18637	12919	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12919	11	66	66	CD
18637	12919	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12919	13	1939	1939	CD
18637	12919	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12919	15	;	;	:
18637	12919	16	City	City	NNP
18637	12919	17	of	of	IN
18637	12919	18	Indianapolis	Indianapolis	NNP
18637	12919	19	_	_	NNP
18637	12919	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	12919	21	_	_	NNP
18637	12919	22	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	12919	23	National	National	NNP
18637	12919	24	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	12919	25	,	,	,
18637	12919	26	314	314	CD
18637	12919	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12919	28	63	63	CD
18637	12919	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12919	30	1941	1941	CD
18637	12919	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12919	32	.	.	.
18637	12920	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12920	2	533	533	CD
18637	12920	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12920	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12920	5	See	See	NNP
18637	12920	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12920	7	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	12920	8	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	12920	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12920	10	_	_	NNP
18637	12920	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	12920	12	_	_	NNP
18637	12920	13	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	12920	14	,	,	,
18637	12920	15	211	211	CD
18637	12920	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12920	17	603	603	CD
18637	12920	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12920	19	1909	1909	CD
18637	12920	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12920	21	,	,	,
18637	12920	22	where	where	WRB
18637	12920	23	two	two	CD
18637	12920	24	Georgians	Georgians	NNPS
18637	12920	25	who	who	WP
18637	12920	26	conducted	conduct	VBD
18637	12920	27	all	all	DT
18637	12920	28	of	of	IN
18637	12920	29	that	that	DT
18637	12920	30	business	business	NN
18637	12920	31	in	in	IN
18637	12920	32	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	12920	33	created	create	VBD
18637	12920	34	a	a	DT
18637	12920	35	sham	sham	JJ
18637	12920	36	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	12920	37	in	in	IN
18637	12920	38	South	South	NNP
18637	12920	39	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	12920	40	for	for	IN
18637	12920	41	the	the	DT
18637	12920	42	sole	sole	JJ
18637	12920	43	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	12920	44	of	of	IN
18637	12920	45	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	12920	46	suits	suit	NNS
18637	12920	47	in	in	IN
18637	12920	48	the	the	DT
18637	12920	49	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12920	50	courts	court	NNS
18637	12920	51	which	which	WDT
18637	12920	52	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	12920	53	would	would	MD
18637	12920	54	have	have	VB
18637	12920	55	been	be	VBN
18637	12920	56	brought	bring	VBN
18637	12920	57	in	in	IN
18637	12920	58	the	the	DT
18637	12920	59	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	12920	60	courts	court	NNS
18637	12920	61	.	.	.
18637	12921	1	Diversity	diversity	NN
18637	12921	2	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	12921	3	was	be	VBD
18637	12921	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	12921	5	not	not	RB
18637	12921	6	to	to	TO
18637	12921	7	exist	exist	VB
18637	12921	8	because	because	IN
18637	12921	9	of	of	IN
18637	12921	10	collusion	collusion	NN
18637	12921	11	.	.	.
18637	12922	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12922	2	534	534	CD
18637	12922	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12922	4	Black	black	JJ
18637	12922	5	and	and	CC
18637	12922	6	White	White	NNP
18637	12922	7	Taxicab	Taxicab	NNP
18637	12922	8	&	&	CC
18637	12922	9	T.	T.	NNP
18637	12922	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12922	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12922	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	12922	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12922	14	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	12922	15	&	&	CC
18637	12922	16	Yellow	Yellow	NNP
18637	12922	17	Taxicab	Taxicab	NNP
18637	12922	18	&	&	CC
18637	12922	19	T.	T.	NNP
18637	12922	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12922	21	,	,	,
18637	12922	22	276	276	CD
18637	12922	23	_	_	NNP
18637	12922	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	12922	25	_	_	NNP
18637	12922	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12922	27	518	518	CD
18637	12922	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12922	29	1928	1928	CD
18637	12922	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12922	31	.	.	.
18637	12923	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12923	2	535	535	CD
18637	12923	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12923	4	16	16	CD
18637	12923	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12923	6	.	.	.
18637	12924	1	1	1	CD
18637	12924	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12924	3	1842	1842	CD
18637	12924	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12924	5	.	.	.
18637	12925	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12925	2	536	536	CD
18637	12925	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12925	4	16	16	CD
18637	12925	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12925	6	.	.	.
18637	12926	1	1	1	LS
18637	12926	2	.	.	.
18637	12927	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12927	2	537	537	CD
18637	12927	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12927	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12927	5	.	.	.
18637	12928	1	19	19	CD
18637	12928	2	.	.	.
18637	12929	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12929	2	Story	Story	NNP
18637	12929	3	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	12929	4	this	this	DT
18637	12929	5	portion	portion	NN
18637	12929	6	of	of	IN
18637	12929	7	the	the	DT
18637	12929	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	12929	9	as	as	IN
18637	12929	10	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	12929	11	:	:	:
18637	12929	12	"	"	``
18637	12929	13	The	the	DT
18637	12929	14	law	law	NN
18637	12929	15	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	12929	16	negotiable	negotiable	JJ
18637	12929	17	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	12929	18	may	may	MD
18637	12929	19	be	be	VB
18637	12929	20	truly	truly	RB
18637	12929	21	declared	declare	VBN
18637	12929	22	in	in	IN
18637	12929	23	the	the	DT
18637	12929	24	language	language	NN
18637	12929	25	of	of	IN
18637	12929	26	Cicero	Cicero	NNP
18637	12929	27	,	,	,
18637	12929	28	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	12929	29	by	by	IN
18637	12929	30	Lord	Lord	NNP
18637	12929	31	Mansfield	Mansfield	NNP
18637	12929	32	in	in	IN
18637	12929	33	Luke	Luke	NNP
18637	12929	34	_	_	NNP
18637	12929	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	12929	36	_	_	NNP
18637	12929	37	Lyde	Lyde	NNP
18637	12929	38	,	,	,
18637	12929	39	2	2	CD
18637	12929	40	Burr	Burr	NNS
18637	12929	41	.	.	.
18637	12930	1	883	883	CD
18637	12930	2	,	,	,
18637	12930	3	887	887	CD
18637	12930	4	,	,	,
18637	12930	5	to	to	TO
18637	12930	6	be	be	VB
18637	12930	7	in	in	IN
18637	12930	8	great	great	JJ
18637	12930	9	measure	measure	NN
18637	12930	10	,	,	,
18637	12930	11	not	not	RB
18637	12930	12	the	the	DT
18637	12930	13	law	law	NN
18637	12930	14	of	of	IN
18637	12930	15	a	a	DT
18637	12930	16	single	single	JJ
18637	12930	17	country	country	NN
18637	12930	18	only	only	RB
18637	12930	19	,	,	,
18637	12930	20	but	but	CC
18637	12930	21	of	of	IN
18637	12930	22	the	the	DT
18637	12930	23	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	12930	24	world	world	NN
18637	12930	25	.	.	.
18637	12931	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12931	2	Non	Non	NNP
18637	12931	3	erit	erit	JJ
18637	12931	4	alia	alia	NNS
18637	12931	5	lex	lex	NN
18637	12931	6	Romae	Romae	NNP
18637	12931	7	,	,	,
18637	12931	8	alia	alia	NNP
18637	12931	9	Athenis	Athenis	NNP
18637	12931	10	;	;	:
18637	12931	11	alia	alia	NNP
18637	12931	12	nunc	nunc	NNP
18637	12931	13	,	,	,
18637	12931	14	alia	alia	NNP
18637	12931	15	posthac	posthac	NNP
18637	12931	16	,	,	,
18637	12931	17	sed	sed	NNP
18637	12931	18	et	et	NNP
18637	12931	19	apud	apud	NN
18637	12931	20	omenes	omenes	NNP
18637	12931	21	gentes	gentes	NNP
18637	12931	22	,	,	,
18637	12931	23	et	et	NNP
18637	12931	24	omni	omni	NNP
18637	12931	25	tempore	tempore	VBD
18637	12931	26	una	una	NNP
18637	12931	27	eademque	eademque	NNP
18637	12931	28	lex	lex	NN
18637	12931	29	obtinebit	obtinebit	NN
18637	12931	30	.	.	.
18637	12931	31	_	_	NNP
18637	12931	32	"	"	``
18637	12931	33	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12931	34	.	.	.
18637	12932	1	9	9	CD
18637	12932	2	.	.	.
18637	12933	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12933	2	538	538	CD
18637	12933	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12933	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12933	5	See	See	NNP
18637	12933	6	_	_	NNP
18637	12933	7	Simeon	Simeon	NNP
18637	12933	8	E.	E.	NNP
18637	12933	9	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	12933	10	,	,	,
18637	12933	11	The	the	DT
18637	12933	12	American	American	NNP
18637	12933	13	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	12933	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12933	15	New	New	NNP
18637	12933	16	York	York	NNP
18637	12933	17	,	,	,
18637	12933	18	1920	1920	CD
18637	12933	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12933	20	,	,	,
18637	12933	21	169	169	CD
18637	12933	22	-	-	SYM
18637	12933	23	170	170	CD
18637	12933	24	.	.	.
18637	12934	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12934	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12934	3	also	also	RB
18637	12934	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12934	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12934	6	Catron	Catron	NNP
18637	12934	7	's	's	POS
18637	12934	8	statement	statement	NN
18637	12934	9	in	in	IN
18637	12934	10	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	12934	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12934	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	12934	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12934	14	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	12934	15	,	,	,
18637	12934	16	16	16	CD
18637	12934	17	Pet	pet	NN
18637	12934	18	.	.	.
18637	12935	1	1	1	CD
18637	12935	2	,	,	,
18637	12935	3	23	23	CD
18637	12935	4	.	.	.
18637	12936	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12936	2	539	539	CD
18637	12936	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12936	4	The	the	DT
18637	12936	5	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	12936	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	12936	7	was	be	VBD
18637	12936	8	extended	extend	VBN
18637	12936	9	to	to	IN
18637	12936	10	wills	will	NNS
18637	12936	11	in	in	IN
18637	12936	12	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	12936	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12936	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	12936	15	_	_	NNP
18637	12936	16	Vick	Vick	NNP
18637	12936	17	,	,	,
18637	12936	18	3	3	CD
18637	12936	19	How	how	WRB
18637	12936	20	.	.	.
18637	12937	1	464	464	CD
18637	12937	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12937	3	1845	1845	CD
18637	12937	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12937	5	;	;	:
18637	12937	6	to	to	IN
18637	12937	7	torts	tort	NNS
18637	12937	8	in	in	IN
18637	12937	9	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	12937	10	City	City	NNP
18637	12937	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12937	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	12937	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12937	14	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	12937	15	,	,	,
18637	12937	16	2	2	CD
18637	12937	17	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	12937	18	.	.	.
18637	12938	1	418	418	CD
18637	12938	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12938	3	1862	1862	CD
18637	12938	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12938	5	;	;	:
18637	12938	6	to	to	IN
18637	12938	7	real	real	JJ
18637	12938	8	estate	estate	NN
18637	12938	9	titles	title	NNS
18637	12938	10	and	and	CC
18637	12938	11	the	the	DT
18637	12938	12	rights	right	NNS
18637	12938	13	of	of	IN
18637	12938	14	riparian	riparian	JJ
18637	12938	15	owners	owner	NNS
18637	12938	16	in	in	IN
18637	12938	17	Yates	Yates	NNP
18637	12938	18	_	_	NNP
18637	12938	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	12938	20	_	_	NNP
18637	12938	21	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	12938	22	,	,	,
18637	12938	23	10	10	CD
18637	12938	24	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12938	25	.	.	.
18637	12939	1	497	497	CD
18637	12939	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12939	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	12939	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12939	5	;	;	:
18637	12939	6	to	to	TO
18637	12939	7	mineral	mineral	NN
18637	12939	8	conveyances	conveyance	NNS
18637	12939	9	in	in	IN
18637	12939	10	Kuhn	Kuhn	NNP
18637	12939	11	_	_	NNP
18637	12939	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	12939	13	_	_	NNP
18637	12939	14	Fairmont	Fairmont	NNP
18637	12939	15	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	12939	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12939	17	,	,	,
18637	12939	18	215	215	CD
18637	12939	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12939	20	349	349	CD
18637	12939	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12939	22	1910	1910	CD
18637	12939	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12939	24	;	;	:
18637	12939	25	to	to	IN
18637	12939	26	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	12939	27	in	in	IN
18637	12939	28	Rowan	Rowan	NNP
18637	12939	29	_	_	NNP
18637	12939	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	12939	31	_	_	NNP
18637	12939	32	Runnels	Runnels	NNP
18637	12939	33	,	,	,
18637	12939	34	5	5	CD
18637	12939	35	How	how	WRB
18637	12939	36	.	.	.
18637	12940	1	134	134	CD
18637	12940	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12940	3	1847	1847	CD
18637	12940	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12940	5	;	;	:
18637	12940	6	and	and	CC
18637	12940	7	to	to	IN
18637	12940	8	the	the	DT
18637	12940	9	right	right	NN
18637	12940	10	to	to	IN
18637	12940	11	exemplary	exemplary	JJ
18637	12940	12	or	or	CC
18637	12940	13	punitive	punitive	JJ
18637	12940	14	damages	damage	NNS
18637	12940	15	in	in	IN
18637	12940	16	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	12940	17	Shore	Shore	NNP
18637	12940	18	&	&	CC
18637	12940	19	M.S.R.	M.S.R.	NNP
18637	12941	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12941	2	_	_	NNP
18637	12941	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	12941	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12941	5	Prentice	Prentice	NNP
18637	12941	6	,	,	,
18637	12941	7	147	147	CD
18637	12941	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12941	9	101	101	CD
18637	12941	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12941	11	1893	1893	CD
18637	12941	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12941	13	.	.	.
18637	12942	1	By	by	IN
18637	12942	2	1888	1888	CD
18637	12942	3	there	there	EX
18637	12942	4	were	be	VBD
18637	12942	5	28	28	CD
18637	12942	6	kinds	kind	NNS
18637	12942	7	of	of	IN
18637	12942	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	12942	9	in	in	IN
18637	12942	10	which	which	WDT
18637	12942	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12942	12	and	and	CC
18637	12942	13	State	State	NNP
18637	12942	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	12942	15	applied	apply	VBD
18637	12942	16	different	different	JJ
18637	12942	17	rules	rule	NNS
18637	12942	18	of	of	IN
18637	12942	19	the	the	DT
18637	12942	20	common	common	JJ
18637	12942	21	law	law	NN
18637	12942	22	.	.	.
18637	12943	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12943	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12943	3	_	_	NNP
18637	12943	4	George	George	NNP
18637	12943	5	C.	C.	NNP
18637	12943	6	Holt	Holt	NNP
18637	12943	7	,	,	,
18637	12943	8	The	the	DT
18637	12943	9	Concurrent	Concurrent	NNP
18637	12943	10	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	12943	11	of	of	IN
18637	12943	12	the	the	DT
18637	12943	13	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	12943	14	and	and	CC
18637	12943	15	State	State	NNP
18637	12943	16	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	12943	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12943	18	New	New	NNP
18637	12943	19	York	York	NNP
18637	12943	20	,	,	,
18637	12943	21	1888	1888	CD
18637	12943	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12943	23	,	,	,
18637	12943	24	159	159	CD
18637	12943	25	-	-	SYM
18637	12943	26	188	188	CD
18637	12943	27	.	.	.
18637	12944	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12944	2	540	540	CD
18637	12944	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12944	4	Rowan	Rowan	NNP
18637	12944	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12944	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12944	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12944	8	Runnels	Runnels	NNP
18637	12944	9	,	,	,
18637	12944	10	5	5	CD
18637	12944	11	How	how	WRB
18637	12944	12	.	.	.
18637	12945	1	134	134	CD
18637	12945	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12945	3	1847	1847	CD
18637	12945	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12945	5	;	;	:
18637	12945	6	Gelpcke	Gelpcke	NNP
18637	12945	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12945	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12945	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12945	10	Dubuque	Dubuque	NNP
18637	12945	11	,	,	,
18637	12945	12	1	1	CD
18637	12945	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12945	14	.	.	.
18637	12946	1	175	175	CD
18637	12946	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12946	3	1864	1864	CD
18637	12946	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12946	5	.	.	.
18637	12947	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12947	2	541	541	CD
18637	12947	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12947	4	Williamson	Williamson	NNP
18637	12947	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12947	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12947	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12947	8	Berry	Berry	NNP
18637	12947	9	,	,	,
18637	12947	10	8	8	CD
18637	12947	11	How	how	WRB
18637	12947	12	.	.	.
18637	12948	1	495	495	CD
18637	12948	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12948	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	12948	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12948	5	;	;	:
18637	12948	6	Pease	Pease	NNP
18637	12948	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12948	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12948	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12948	10	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	12948	11	,	,	,
18637	12948	12	18	18	CD
18637	12948	13	How	how	WRB
18637	12948	14	.	.	.
18637	12949	1	595	595	CD
18637	12949	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12949	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	12949	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12949	5	;	;	:
18637	12949	6	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	12949	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12949	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12949	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12949	10	Tarpley	Tarpley	NNP
18637	12949	11	,	,	,
18637	12949	12	18	18	CD
18637	12949	13	How	how	WRB
18637	12949	14	.	.	.
18637	12950	1	517	517	CD
18637	12950	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12950	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	12950	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12950	5	.	.	.
18637	12951	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12951	2	542	542	CD
18637	12951	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12951	4	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	12951	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12951	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12951	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12951	8	Vick	Vick	NNP
18637	12951	9	,	,	,
18637	12951	10	3	3	CD
18637	12951	11	How	how	WRB
18637	12951	12	.	.	.
18637	12952	1	464	464	CD
18637	12952	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12952	3	1845	1845	CD
18637	12952	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12952	5	;	;	:
18637	12952	6	Williamson	Williamson	NNP
18637	12952	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12952	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12952	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12952	10	Berry	Berry	NNP
18637	12952	11	,	,	,
18637	12952	12	8	8	CD
18637	12952	13	How	how	WRB
18637	12952	14	.	.	.
18637	12953	1	495	495	CD
18637	12953	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12953	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	12953	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12953	5	;	;	:
18637	12953	6	Gelpcke	Gelpcke	NNP
18637	12953	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12953	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	12953	9	_	_	NNP
18637	12953	10	Dubuque	Dubuque	NNP
18637	12953	11	,	,	,
18637	12953	12	1	1	CD
18637	12953	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	12953	14	.	.	.
18637	12954	1	175	175	CD
18637	12954	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12954	3	1864	1864	CD
18637	12954	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12954	5	.	.	.
18637	12955	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12955	2	543	543	CD
18637	12955	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12955	4	149	149	CD
18637	12955	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12955	6	308	308	CD
18637	12955	7	,	,	,
18637	12955	8	401	401	CD
18637	12955	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12955	10	404	404	CD
18637	12955	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12955	12	1893	1893	CD
18637	12955	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12955	14	.	.	.
18637	12956	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12956	2	544	544	CD
18637	12956	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12956	4	215	215	CD
18637	12956	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12956	6	349	349	CD
18637	12956	7	,	,	,
18637	12956	8	370	370	CD
18637	12956	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12956	10	1910	1910	CD
18637	12956	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12956	12	.	.	.
18637	12957	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12957	2	545	545	CD
18637	12957	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12957	4	276	276	CD
18637	12957	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12957	6	518	518	CD
18637	12957	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12957	8	1928	1928	CD
18637	12957	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12957	10	.	.	.
18637	12958	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12958	2	546	546	CD
18637	12958	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12958	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12958	5	.	.	.
18637	12959	1	533	533	CD
18637	12959	2	.	.	.
18637	12960	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12960	2	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	12960	3	was	be	VBD
18637	12960	4	influenced	influence	VBN
18637	12960	5	in	in	IN
18637	12960	6	part	part	NN
18637	12960	7	by	by	IN
18637	12960	8	the	the	DT
18637	12960	9	article	article	NN
18637	12960	10	of	of	IN
18637	12960	11	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	12960	12	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	12960	13	,	,	,
18637	12960	14	New	New	NNP
18637	12960	15	Light	Light	NNP
18637	12960	16	On	on	IN
18637	12960	17	The	the	DT
18637	12960	18	History	history	NN
18637	12960	19	Of	of	IN
18637	12960	20	The	the	DT
18637	12960	21	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	12960	22	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	12960	23	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12960	24	of	of	IN
18637	12960	25	1789	1789	CD
18637	12960	26	,	,	,
18637	12960	27	37	37	CD
18637	12960	28	Harv	Harv	NNP
18637	12960	29	.	.	.
18637	12961	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	12961	2	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	12962	1	49	49	CD
18637	12962	2	,	,	,
18637	12962	3	81	81	CD
18637	12962	4	-	-	SYM
18637	12962	5	88	88	CD
18637	12962	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12962	7	1923	1923	CD
18637	12962	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12962	9	,	,	,
18637	12962	10	in	in	IN
18637	12962	11	which	which	WDT
18637	12962	12	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	12962	13	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	12962	14	produced	produce	VBD
18637	12962	15	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	12962	16	to	to	TO
18637	12962	17	show	show	VB
18637	12962	18	that	that	IN
18637	12962	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12962	20	Story	Story	NNP
18637	12962	21	's	's	POS
18637	12962	22	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	12962	23	in	in	IN
18637	12962	24	the	the	DT
18637	12962	25	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	12962	26	Case	Case	NNP
18637	12962	27	was	be	VBD
18637	12962	28	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	12962	29	to	to	IN
18637	12962	30	the	the	DT
18637	12962	31	intention	intention	NN
18637	12962	32	of	of	IN
18637	12962	33	the	the	DT
18637	12962	34	framers	framer	NNS
18637	12962	35	of	of	IN
18637	12962	36	the	the	DT
18637	12962	37	act	act	NN
18637	12962	38	.	.	.
18637	12963	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	12963	2	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	12963	3	did	do	VBD
18637	12963	4	not	not	RB
18637	12963	5	,	,	,
18637	12963	6	however	however	RB
18637	12963	7	,	,	,
18637	12963	8	contend	contend	VBP
18637	12963	9	that	that	IN
18637	12963	10	the	the	DT
18637	12963	11	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	12963	12	rule	rule	NN
18637	12963	13	was	be	VBD
18637	12963	14	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	12963	15	.	.	.
18637	12964	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12964	2	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	12964	3	was	be	VBD
18637	12964	4	joined	join	VBN
18637	12964	5	in	in	IN
18637	12964	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	12964	7	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	12964	8	by	by	IN
18637	12964	9	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	12964	10	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	12964	11	and	and	CC
18637	12964	12	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	12964	13	.	.	.
18637	12965	1	In	in	IN
18637	12965	2	addition	addition	NN
18637	12965	3	to	to	IN
18637	12965	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	12965	5	dissatisfaction	dissatisfaction	NN
18637	12965	6	with	with	IN
18637	12965	7	the	the	DT
18637	12965	8	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	12965	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	12965	10	as	as	IN
18637	12965	11	manifested	manifest	VBN
18637	12965	12	in	in	IN
18637	12965	13	dissents	dissent	NNS
18637	12965	14	,	,	,
18637	12965	15	disapproval	disapproval	NN
18637	12965	16	in	in	IN
18637	12965	17	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	12965	18	quarters	quarter	NNS
18637	12965	19	resulted	result	VBD
18637	12965	20	in	in	IN
18637	12965	21	bills	bill	NNS
18637	12965	22	by	by	IN
18637	12965	23	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	12965	24	Walsh	Walsh	NNP
18637	12965	25	and	and	CC
18637	12965	26	Norris	Norris	NNP
18637	12965	27	in	in	IN
18637	12965	28	the	the	DT
18637	12965	29	70th	70th	JJ
18637	12965	30	and	and	CC
18637	12965	31	71st	71st	NNP
18637	12965	32	Congresses	Congresses	NNPS
18637	12965	33	,	,	,
18637	12965	34	S.	S.	NNP
18637	12965	35	3151	3151	CD
18637	12965	36	,	,	,
18637	12965	37	70th	70th	NNP
18637	12965	38	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	12965	39	.	.	NNP
18637	12965	40	,	,	,
18637	12965	41	1st	1st	NNP
18637	12965	42	.	.	.
18637	12966	1	sess	sess	NN
18637	12966	2	.	.	.
18637	12966	3	,	,	,
18637	12966	4	S.	S.	NNP
18637	12966	5	Rept	Rept	NNP
18637	12966	6	.	.	.
18637	12967	1	626	626	CD
18637	12967	2	of	of	IN
18637	12967	3	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	12967	4	on	on	IN
18637	12967	5	the	the	DT
18637	12967	6	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	12967	7	,	,	,
18637	12967	8	March	March	NNP
18637	12967	9	27	27	CD
18637	12967	10	,	,	,
18637	12967	11	1928	1928	CD
18637	12967	12	;	;	:
18637	12967	13	S.	S.	NNP
18637	12967	14	4357	4357	CD
18637	12967	15	,	,	,
18637	12967	16	70th	70th	NNP
18637	12967	17	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	12967	18	.	.	NNP
18637	12967	19	,	,	,
18637	12967	20	2d	2d	CD
18637	12967	21	.	.	.
18637	12968	1	sess	sess	NN
18637	12968	2	.	.	.
18637	12968	3	,	,	,
18637	12968	4	S.	S.	NNP
18637	12968	5	Rept	Rept	NNP
18637	12968	6	.	.	.
18637	12969	1	691	691	CD
18637	12969	2	,	,	,
18637	12969	3	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	12969	4	on	on	IN
18637	12969	5	the	the	DT
18637	12969	6	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	12969	7	,	,	,
18637	12969	8	May	May	NNP
18637	12969	9	20	20	CD
18637	12969	10	,	,	,
18637	12969	11	1930	1930	CD
18637	12969	12	;	;	:
18637	12969	13	S.	S.	NNP
18637	12969	14	4333	4333	CD
18637	12969	15	,	,	,
18637	12969	16	70th	70th	NNP
18637	12969	17	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	12969	18	.	.	NNP
18637	12969	19	,	,	,
18637	12969	20	1st	1st	NNP
18637	12969	21	.	.	.
18637	12970	1	sess	sess	NN
18637	12970	2	.	.	.
18637	12971	1	;	;	:
18637	12971	2	S.	S.	NNP
18637	12971	3	96	96	CD
18637	12971	4	,	,	,
18637	12971	5	71st	71st	NNP
18637	12971	6	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	12971	7	.	.	.
18637	12971	8	,	,	,
18637	12971	9	1st	1st	NNP
18637	12971	10	.	.	.
18637	12972	1	sess	sess	NN
18637	12972	2	.	.	.
18637	12973	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12973	2	547	547	CD
18637	12973	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12973	4	293	293	CD
18637	12973	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12973	6	335	335	CD
18637	12973	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12973	8	1934	1934	CD
18637	12973	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12973	10	.	.	.
18637	12974	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12974	2	548	548	CD
18637	12974	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12974	4	This	this	DT
18637	12974	5	concept	concept	NN
18637	12974	6	was	be	VBD
18637	12974	7	first	first	RB
18637	12974	8	used	use	VBN
18637	12974	9	by	by	IN
18637	12974	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	12974	11	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	12974	12	in	in	IN
18637	12974	13	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
18637	12974	14	_	_	NNP
18637	12974	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	12974	16	_	_	NNP
18637	12974	17	Seligman	Seligman	NNP
18637	12974	18	,	,	,
18637	12974	19	107	107	CD
18637	12974	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12974	21	21	21	CD
18637	12974	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12974	23	1883	1883	CD
18637	12974	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12974	25	.	.	.
18637	12975	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12975	2	549	549	CD
18637	12975	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12975	4	293	293	CD
18637	12975	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12975	6	335	335	CD
18637	12975	7	,	,	,
18637	12975	8	339	339	CD
18637	12975	9	.	.	.
18637	12976	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12976	2	550	550	CD
18637	12976	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12976	4	304	304	CD
18637	12976	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12976	6	64	64	CD
18637	12976	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12976	8	1938	1938	CD
18637	12976	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12976	10	.	.	.
18637	12977	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12977	2	551	551	CD
18637	12977	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12977	4	304	304	CD
18637	12977	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12977	6	64	64	CD
18637	12977	7	,	,	,
18637	12977	8	69	69	CD
18637	12977	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12977	10	70	70	CD
18637	12977	11	,	,	,
18637	12977	12	77	77	CD
18637	12977	13	-	-	SYM
18637	12977	14	78	78	CD
18637	12977	15	.	.	.
18637	12978	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12978	2	552	552	CD
18637	12978	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12978	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12978	5	.	.	.
18637	12979	1	79	79	CD
18637	12979	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12979	3	80	80	CD
18637	12979	4	.	.	.
18637	12980	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12980	2	553	553	CD
18637	12980	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12980	4	304	304	CD
18637	12980	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12980	6	64	64	CD
18637	12980	7	,	,	,
18637	12980	8	80	80	CD
18637	12980	9	-	-	SYM
18637	12980	10	90	90	CD
18637	12980	11	.	.	.
18637	12981	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12981	2	554	554	CD
18637	12981	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12981	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	12981	5	.	.	.
18637	12982	1	90	90	CD
18637	12982	2	,	,	,
18637	12982	3	91	91	CD
18637	12982	4	-	-	SYM
18637	12982	5	92	92	CD
18637	12982	6	.	.	.
18637	12983	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12983	2	555	555	CD
18637	12983	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12983	4	311	311	CD
18637	12983	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12983	6	223	223	CD
18637	12983	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12983	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	12983	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12983	10	.	.	.
18637	12984	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12984	2	556	556	CD
18637	12984	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12984	4	311	311	CD
18637	12984	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12984	6	169	169	CD
18637	12984	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12984	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	12984	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12984	10	.	.	.
18637	12985	1	This	this	DT
18637	12985	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	12985	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	12985	4	been	be	VBN
18637	12985	5	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
18637	12985	6	criticized	criticize	VBN
18637	12985	7	by	by	IN
18637	12985	8	Arthur	Arthur	NNP
18637	12985	9	L.	L.	NNP
18637	12985	10	Corbin	Corbin	NNP
18637	12985	11	in	in	IN
18637	12985	12	The	the	DT
18637	12985	13	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	12985	14	of	of	IN
18637	12985	15	the	the	DT
18637	12985	16	Several	Several	NNP
18637	12985	17	States	States	NNPS
18637	12985	18	,	,	,
18637	12985	19	50	50	CD
18637	12985	20	Yale	Yale	NNP
18637	12985	21	L.J.	L.J.	NNP
18637	12986	1	762	762	CD
18637	12986	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12986	3	1941	1941	CD
18637	12986	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12986	5	.	.	.
18637	12987	1	_	_	NNP
18637	12987	2	See	See	NNP
18637	12987	3	also	also	RB
18637	12987	4	_	_	NNP
18637	12987	5	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	12987	6	Wendell	Wendell	NNP
18637	12987	7	,	,	,
18637	12987	8	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	12987	9	Between	between	IN
18637	12987	10	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	12987	11	and	and	CC
18637	12987	12	State	State	NNP
18637	12987	13	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	12987	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12987	15	New	New	NNP
18637	12987	16	York	York	NNP
18637	12987	17	,	,	,
18637	12987	18	1949	1949	CD
18637	12987	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12987	20	,	,	,
18637	12987	21	209	209	CD
18637	12987	22	-	-	SYM
18637	12987	23	223	223	CD
18637	12987	24	.	.	.
18637	12988	1	This	this	DT
18637	12988	2	book	book	NN
18637	12988	3	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	12988	4	a	a	DT
18637	12988	5	good	good	JJ
18637	12988	6	account	account	NN
18637	12988	7	of	of	IN
18637	12988	8	the	the	DT
18637	12988	9	operation	operation	NN
18637	12988	10	of	of	IN
18637	12988	11	the	the	DT
18637	12988	12	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	12988	13	and	and	CC
18637	12988	14	Tompkins	Tompkins	NNP
18637	12988	15	rules	rule	NNS
18637	12988	16	,	,	,
18637	12988	17	pp	pp	NNP
18637	12988	18	.	.	.
18637	12989	1	113	113	CD
18637	12989	2	-	-	SYM
18637	12989	3	247	247	CD
18637	12989	4	.	.	.
18637	12990	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12990	2	557	557	CD
18637	12990	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12990	4	333	333	CD
18637	12990	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12990	6	153	153	CD
18637	12990	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12990	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	12990	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12990	10	.	.	.
18637	12991	1	For	for	IN
18637	12991	2	other	other	JJ
18637	12991	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	12991	4	applying	apply	VBG
18637	12991	5	the	the	DT
18637	12991	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	12991	7	that	that	IN
18637	12991	8	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	12991	9	of	of	IN
18637	12991	10	State	State	NNP
18637	12991	11	intermediate	intermediate	JJ
18637	12991	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	12991	13	are	be	VBP
18637	12991	14	binding	bind	VBG
18637	12991	15	unless	unless	IN
18637	12991	16	there	there	EX
18637	12991	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	12991	18	convincing	convince	VBG
18637	12991	19	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	12991	20	that	that	IN
18637	12991	21	the	the	DT
18637	12991	22	State	State	NNP
18637	12991	23	law	law	NN
18637	12991	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	12991	25	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	12991	26	,	,	,
18637	12991	27	_	_	NNP
18637	12991	28	see	see	VBP
18637	12991	29	_	_	NNP
18637	12991	30	Six	Six	NNP
18637	12991	31	Companies	Companies	NNPS
18637	12991	32	of	of	IN
18637	12991	33	California	California	NNP
18637	12991	34	_	_	NNP
18637	12991	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	12991	36	_	_	NNP
18637	12991	37	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	12991	38	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	12991	39	.	.	NNP
18637	12991	40	,	,	,
18637	12991	41	311	311	CD
18637	12991	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12991	43	180	180	CD
18637	12991	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12991	45	1940	1940	CD
18637	12991	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12991	47	;	;	:
18637	12991	48	Stoner	Stoner	NNP
18637	12991	49	_	_	NNP
18637	12991	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	12991	51	_	_	NNP
18637	12991	52	New	New	NNP
18637	12991	53	York	York	NNP
18637	12991	54	Life	Life	NNP
18637	12991	55	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	12991	56	.	.	.
18637	12992	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12992	2	,	,	,
18637	12992	3	311	311	CD
18637	12992	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12992	5	464	464	CD
18637	12992	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12992	7	1940	1940	CD
18637	12992	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12992	9	.	.	.
18637	12993	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12993	2	558	558	CD
18637	12993	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12993	4	Vandenbark	Vandenbark	NNP
18637	12993	5	_	_	NNP
18637	12993	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	12993	7	_	_	NNP
18637	12993	8	Owens	Owens	NNP
18637	12993	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	12993	10	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	12993	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	12993	12	,	,	,
18637	12993	13	311	311	CD
18637	12993	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	12993	15	538	538	CD
18637	12993	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12993	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	12993	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12993	19	.	.	.
18637	12994	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	12994	2	559	559	CD
18637	12994	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	12994	4	28	28	CD
18637	12994	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	12995	1	§	§	NNP
18637	12995	2	1652	1652	CD
18637	12995	3	;	;	:
18637	12995	4	62	62	CD
18637	12995	5	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	12995	6	.	.	.
18637	12996	1	944	944	CD
18637	12996	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12996	3	1948	1948	CD
18637	12996	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12996	5	.	.	.
18637	12997	1	In	in	IN
18637	12997	2	1938	1938	CD
18637	12997	3	,	,	,
18637	12997	4	the	the	DT
18637	12997	5	year	year	NN
18637	12997	6	of	of	IN
18637	12997	7	the	the	DT
18637	12997	8	Tompkins	Tompkins	NNP
18637	12997	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	12997	10	,	,	,
18637	12997	11	the	the	DT
18637	12997	12	Conformity	Conformity	NNP
18637	12997	13	Act	Act	NNP
18637	12997	14	of	of	IN
18637	12997	15	1872	1872	CD
18637	12997	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	12997	17	17	17	CD
18637	12997	18	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12997	19	.	.	.
18637	12998	1	196	196	CD
18637	12998	2	§	â§	SYM
18637	12998	3	5	5	CD
18637	12998	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	12998	5	was	be	VBD
18637	12998	6	superseded	superseded	JJ
18637	12998	7	;	;	:
18637	12998	8	and	and	CC
18637	12998	9	from	from	IN
18637	12998	10	that	that	DT
18637	12998	11	time	time	NN
18637	12998	12	until	until	IN
18637	12998	13	the	the	DT
18637	12998	14	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	12998	15	of	of	IN
18637	12998	16	62	62	CD
18637	12998	17	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12998	18	.	.	.
18637	12999	1	944	944	CD
18637	12999	2	,	,	,
18637	12999	3	the	the	DT
18637	12999	4	federal	federal	JJ
18637	12999	5	courts	court	NNS
18637	12999	6	were	be	VBD
18637	12999	7	guided	guide	VBN
18637	12999	8	in	in	IN
18637	12999	9	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	12999	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	12999	11	by	by	IN
18637	12999	12	the	the	DT
18637	12999	13	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	12999	14	Rules	Rules	NNPS
18637	12999	15	of	of	IN
18637	12999	16	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	12999	17	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	12999	18	formulated	formulate	VBN
18637	12999	19	by	by	IN
18637	12999	20	the	the	DT
18637	12999	21	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	12999	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	12999	23	by	by	IN
18637	12999	24	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	12999	25	of	of	IN
18637	12999	26	the	the	DT
18637	12999	27	authority	authority	NN
18637	12999	28	delegated	delegate	VBD
18637	12999	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	12999	30	,	,	,
18637	12999	31	in	in	IN
18637	12999	32	1934	1934	CD
18637	12999	33	,	,	,
18637	12999	34	by	by	IN
18637	12999	35	48	48	CD
18637	12999	36	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	12999	37	.	.	.
18637	13000	1	1064	1064	CD
18637	13000	2	.	.	.
18637	13001	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13001	2	560	560	CD
18637	13001	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13001	4	Ruhlin	Ruhlin	NNP
18637	13001	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13001	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13001	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13001	8	New	New	NNP
18637	13001	9	York	York	NNP
18637	13001	10	Life	Life	NNP
18637	13001	11	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	13001	12	.	.	.
18637	13002	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13002	2	,	,	,
18637	13002	3	304	304	CD
18637	13002	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13002	5	202	202	CD
18637	13002	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13002	7	1938	1938	CD
18637	13002	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13002	9	.	.	.
18637	13003	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13003	2	561	561	CD
18637	13003	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13003	4	326	326	CD
18637	13003	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13003	6	99	99	CD
18637	13003	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13003	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	13003	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13003	10	.	.	.
18637	13004	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13004	2	562	562	CD
18637	13004	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13004	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13004	5	.	.	.
18637	13005	1	108	108	CD
18637	13005	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13005	3	109	109	CD
18637	13005	4	.	.	.
18637	13006	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13006	2	563	563	CD
18637	13006	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13006	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13006	5	.	.	.
18637	13007	1	109	109	CD
18637	13007	2	.	.	.
18637	13008	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13008	2	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	13008	3	wrote	write	VBD
18637	13008	4	a	a	DT
18637	13008	5	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	13008	6	in	in	IN
18637	13008	7	which	which	WDT
18637	13008	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13008	9	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	13008	10	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	13008	11	.	.	.
18637	13009	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13009	2	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	13009	3	objected	object	VBD
18637	13009	4	to	to	IN
18637	13009	5	the	the	DT
18637	13009	6	rigid	rigid	JJ
18637	13009	7	application	application	NN
18637	13009	8	of	of	IN
18637	13009	9	a	a	DT
18637	13009	10	statute	statute	NN
18637	13009	11	of	of	IN
18637	13009	12	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	13009	13	to	to	IN
18637	13009	14	suits	suit	NNS
18637	13009	15	in	in	IN
18637	13009	16	equity	equity	NN
18637	13009	17	and	and	CC
18637	13009	18	to	to	IN
18637	13009	19	the	the	DT
18637	13009	20	implication	implication	NN
18637	13009	21	that	that	IN
18637	13009	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13009	23	could	could	MD
18637	13009	24	not	not	RB
18637	13009	25	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	13009	26	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13009	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	13009	28	to	to	TO
18637	13009	29	administer	administer	VB
18637	13009	30	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	13009	31	relief	relief	NN
18637	13009	32	in	in	IN
18637	13009	33	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	13009	34	with	with	IN
18637	13009	35	the	the	DT
18637	13009	36	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	13009	37	rights	right	NNS
18637	13009	38	of	of	IN
18637	13009	39	the	the	DT
18637	13009	40	parties	party	NNS
18637	13009	41	,	,	,
18637	13009	42	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	13009	43	State	state	NN
18637	13009	44	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	13009	45	of	of	IN
18637	13009	46	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	13009	47	barring	bar	VBG
18637	13009	48	such	such	JJ
18637	13009	49	suits	suit	NNS
18637	13009	50	in	in	IN
18637	13009	51	State	State	NNP
18637	13009	52	courts	court	NNS
18637	13009	53	.	.	.
18637	13010	1	In	in	IN
18637	13010	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13010	3	view	view	NN
18637	13010	4	,	,	,
18637	13010	5	if	if	IN
18637	13010	6	any	any	DT
18637	13010	7	change	change	NN
18637	13010	8	were	be	VBD
18637	13010	9	to	to	TO
18637	13010	10	be	be	VB
18637	13010	11	made	make	VBN
18637	13010	12	,	,	,
18637	13010	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13010	14	was	be	VBD
18637	13010	15	for	for	IN
18637	13010	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13010	17	and	and	CC
18637	13010	18	not	not	RB
18637	13010	19	the	the	DT
18637	13010	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13010	21	to	to	TO
18637	13010	22	make	make	VB
18637	13010	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13010	24	.	.	.
18637	13011	1	In	in	IN
18637	13011	2	line	line	NN
18637	13011	3	with	with	IN
18637	13011	4	this	this	DT
18637	13011	5	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	13011	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13011	7	see	see	VBP
18637	13011	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13011	9	Ragan	Ragan	NNP
18637	13011	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13011	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	13011	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13011	13	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	13011	14	Transfer	Transfer	NNP
18637	13011	15	&	&	CC
18637	13011	16	W.	W.	NNP
18637	13011	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13011	18	,	,	,
18637	13011	19	337	337	CD
18637	13011	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13011	21	530	530	CD
18637	13011	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13011	23	1949	1949	CD
18637	13011	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13011	25	;	;	:
18637	13011	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13011	27	also	also	RB
18637	13011	28	_	_	NNP
18637	13011	29	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
18637	13011	30	_	_	NNP
18637	13011	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	13011	32	_	_	NNP
18637	13011	33	Beneficial	Beneficial	NNP
18637	13011	34	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	13011	35	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	13011	36	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	13011	37	,	,	,
18637	13011	38	337	337	CD
18637	13011	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13011	40	541	541	CD
18637	13011	41	,	,	,
18637	13011	42	555	555	CD
18637	13011	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13011	44	1949	1949	CD
18637	13011	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13011	46	.	.	.
18637	13012	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13012	2	564	564	CD
18637	13012	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13012	4	2	2	CD
18637	13012	5	Story	Story	NNP
18637	13012	6	,	,	,
18637	13012	7	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	13012	8	,	,	,
18637	13012	9	467	467	CD
18637	13012	10	§	â§	NN
18637	13012	11	1696	1696	CD
18637	13012	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13012	13	2d	2d	CD
18637	13012	14	.	.	.
18637	13013	1	ed	ed	NNP
18637	13013	2	.	.	NNP
18637	13013	3	,	,	,
18637	13013	4	1851	1851	CD
18637	13013	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13013	6	.	.	.
18637	13014	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13014	2	565	565	CD
18637	13014	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13014	4	An	an	DT
18637	13014	5	interesting	interesting	JJ
18637	13014	6	case	case	NN
18637	13014	7	which	which	WDT
18637	13014	8	reached	reach	VBD
18637	13014	9	the	the	DT
18637	13014	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13014	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13014	12	under	under	IN
18637	13014	13	this	this	DT
18637	13014	14	clause	clause	NN
18637	13014	15	was	be	VBD
18637	13014	16	Pawlet	Pawlet	NNP
18637	13014	17	_	_	NNP
18637	13014	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	13014	19	_	_	NNP
18637	13014	20	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	13014	21	,	,	,
18637	13014	22	9	9	CD
18637	13014	23	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13014	24	.	.	.
18637	13015	1	292	292	CD
18637	13015	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13015	3	1815	1815	CD
18637	13015	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13015	5	.	.	.
18637	13016	1	In	in	IN
18637	13016	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13016	3	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	13016	4	for	for	IN
18637	13016	5	the	the	DT
18637	13016	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13016	7	,	,	,
18637	13016	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13016	9	Story	Story	NNP
18637	13016	10	took	take	VBD
18637	13016	11	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	13016	12	to	to	TO
18637	13016	13	assert	assert	VB
18637	13016	14	that	that	IN
18637	13016	15	grants	grant	NNS
18637	13016	16	of	of	IN
18637	13016	17	land	land	NN
18637	13016	18	by	by	IN
18637	13016	19	a	a	DT
18637	13016	20	State	state	NN
18637	13016	21	to	to	IN
18637	13016	22	a	a	DT
18637	13016	23	town	town	NN
18637	13016	24	could	could	MD
18637	13016	25	not	not	RB
18637	13016	26	afterwards	afterwards	RB
18637	13016	27	be	be	VB
18637	13016	28	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	13016	29	so	so	IN
18637	13016	30	as	as	IN
18637	13016	31	to	to	TO
18637	13016	32	divest	divest	VB
18637	13016	33	the	the	DT
18637	13016	34	town	town	NN
18637	13016	35	of	of	IN
18637	13016	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13016	37	rights	right	NNS
18637	13016	38	under	under	IN
18637	13016	39	the	the	DT
18637	13016	40	grant	grant	NN
18637	13016	41	.	.	.
18637	13017	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	13017	2	.	.	.
18637	13018	1	326	326	LS
18637	13018	2	;	;	:
18637	13018	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13018	4	cf	cf	NNP
18637	13018	5	.	.	.
18637	13018	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13018	7	Trenton	Trenton	NNP
18637	13018	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13018	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	13018	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13018	11	New	New	NNP
18637	13018	12	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	13018	13	,	,	,
18637	13018	14	262	262	CD
18637	13018	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13018	16	182	182	CD
18637	13018	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13018	18	1923	1923	CD
18637	13018	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13018	20	.	.	.
18637	13019	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13019	2	566	566	CD
18637	13019	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13019	4	The	the	DT
18637	13019	5	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	13019	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13019	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13019	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13019	9	McFaddon	McFaddon	NNP
18637	13019	10	,	,	,
18637	13019	11	7	7	CD
18637	13019	12	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13019	13	.	.	.
18637	13020	1	116	116	CD
18637	13020	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13020	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	13020	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13020	5	;	;	:
18637	13020	6	Berizzi	Berizzi	NNP
18637	13020	7	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	13020	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13020	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13020	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	13020	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13020	12	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	13020	13	Pesaro	Pesaro	NNP
18637	13020	14	,	,	,
18637	13020	15	271	271	CD
18637	13020	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13020	17	562	562	CD
18637	13020	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13020	19	1926	1926	CD
18637	13020	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13020	21	;	;	:
18637	13020	22	Compania	Compania	NNP
18637	13020	23	Espanola	Espanola	NNP
18637	13020	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13020	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	13020	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13020	27	The	the	DT
18637	13020	28	Navemar	Navemar	NNP
18637	13020	29	,	,	,
18637	13020	30	303	303	CD
18637	13020	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13020	32	68	68	CD
18637	13020	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13020	34	1938	1938	CD
18637	13020	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13020	36	;	;	:
18637	13020	37	Guaranty	Guaranty	NNP
18637	13020	38	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	13020	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13020	40	_	_	NNP
18637	13020	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	13020	42	_	_	NNP
18637	13020	43	United	United	NNP
18637	13020	44	States	States	NNP
18637	13020	45	,	,	,
18637	13020	46	304	304	CD
18637	13020	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13020	48	126	126	CD
18637	13020	49	,	,	,
18637	13020	50	134	134	CD
18637	13020	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13020	52	1938	1938	CD
18637	13020	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13020	54	.	.	.
18637	13021	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13021	2	567	567	CD
18637	13021	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13021	4	Principality	Principality	NNP
18637	13021	5	of	of	IN
18637	13021	6	Monaco	Monaco	NNP
18637	13021	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13021	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13021	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13021	10	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	13021	11	,	,	,
18637	13021	12	292	292	CD
18637	13021	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13021	14	313	313	CD
18637	13021	15	,	,	,
18637	13021	16	330	330	CD
18637	13021	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13021	18	1934	1934	CD
18637	13021	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13021	20	.	.	.
18637	13022	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13022	2	568	568	CD
18637	13022	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13022	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13022	5	.	.	.
18637	13023	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13023	2	569	569	CD
18637	13023	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13023	4	The	the	DT
18637	13023	5	"	"	``
18637	13023	6	Sapphire	Sapphire	NNP
18637	13023	7	,	,	,
18637	13023	8	"	"	''
18637	13023	9	11	11	CD
18637	13023	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13023	11	.	.	.
18637	13024	1	164	164	CD
18637	13024	2	,	,	,
18637	13024	3	167	167	CD
18637	13024	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13024	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	13024	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13024	7	.	.	.
18637	13025	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13025	2	570	570	CD
18637	13025	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13025	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13025	5	.	.	.
18637	13026	1	167	167	CD
18637	13026	2	.	.	.
18637	13027	1	This	this	DT
18637	13027	2	case	case	NN
18637	13027	3	also	also	RB
18637	13027	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	13027	5	that	that	IN
18637	13027	6	a	a	DT
18637	13027	7	change	change	NN
18637	13027	8	in	in	IN
18637	13027	9	the	the	DT
18637	13027	10	person	person	NN
18637	13027	11	of	of	IN
18637	13027	12	the	the	DT
18637	13027	13	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	13027	14	does	do	VBZ
18637	13027	15	not	not	RB
18637	13027	16	affect	affect	VB
18637	13027	17	the	the	DT
18637	13027	18	continuity	continuity	NN
18637	13027	19	or	or	CC
18637	13027	20	rights	right	NNS
18637	13027	21	of	of	IN
18637	13027	22	national	national	JJ
18637	13027	23	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	13027	24	,	,	,
18637	13027	25	including	include	VBG
18637	13027	26	the	the	DT
18637	13027	27	right	right	NN
18637	13027	28	to	to	TO
18637	13027	29	bring	bring	VB
18637	13027	30	suit	suit	NN
18637	13027	31	,	,	,
18637	13027	32	or	or	CC
18637	13027	33	to	to	TO
18637	13027	34	continue	continue	VB
18637	13027	35	one	one	NN
18637	13027	36	that	that	WDT
18637	13027	37	has	have	VBZ
18637	13027	38	been	be	VBN
18637	13027	39	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13027	40	.	.	.
18637	13028	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13028	2	571	571	CD
18637	13028	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13028	4	Guaranty	Guaranty	NNP
18637	13028	5	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	13028	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13028	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13028	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13028	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13028	10	United	United	NNP
18637	13028	11	States	States	NNP
18637	13028	12	,	,	,
18637	13028	13	304	304	CD
18637	13028	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13028	15	126	126	CD
18637	13028	16	,	,	,
18637	13028	17	137	137	CD
18637	13028	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13028	19	1938	1938	CD
18637	13028	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13028	21	;	;	:
18637	13028	22	citing	cite	VBG
18637	13028	23	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	13028	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13028	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	13028	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13028	27	United	United	NNP
18637	13028	28	States	States	NNP
18637	13028	29	,	,	,
18637	13028	30	137	137	CD
18637	13028	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13028	32	202	202	CD
18637	13028	33	,	,	,
18637	13028	34	212	212	CD
18637	13028	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13028	36	1890	1890	CD
18637	13028	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13028	38	;	;	:
18637	13028	39	Matter	Matter	NNP
18637	13028	40	of	of	IN
18637	13028	41	Lehigh	Lehigh	NNP
18637	13028	42	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	13028	43	R.	R.	NNP
18637	13028	44	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13028	45	,	,	,
18637	13028	46	265	265	CD
18637	13028	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13028	48	573	573	CD
18637	13028	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13028	50	1924	1924	CD
18637	13028	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13028	52	.	.	.
18637	13029	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	13029	2	a	a	DT
18637	13029	3	government	government	NN
18637	13029	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	13029	5	to	to	TO
18637	13029	6	be	be	VB
18637	13029	7	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	13029	8	as	as	IN
18637	13029	9	the	the	DT
18637	13029	10	legal	legal	JJ
18637	13029	11	representative	representative	NN
18637	13029	12	of	of	IN
18637	13029	13	a	a	DT
18637	13029	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13029	15	State	state	NN
18637	13029	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	13029	17	,	,	,
18637	13029	18	of	of	IN
18637	13029	19	course	course	NN
18637	13029	20	,	,	,
18637	13029	21	a	a	DT
18637	13029	22	political	political	JJ
18637	13029	23	question	question	NN
18637	13029	24	.	.	.
18637	13030	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13030	2	572	572	CD
18637	13030	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13030	4	Guaranty	Guaranty	NNP
18637	13030	5	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	13030	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13030	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13030	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13030	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13030	10	United	United	NNP
18637	13030	11	States	States	NNP
18637	13030	12	,	,	,
18637	13030	13	304	304	CD
18637	13030	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13030	15	126	126	CD
18637	13030	16	,	,	,
18637	13030	17	134	134	CD
18637	13030	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13030	19	1938	1938	CD
18637	13030	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13030	21	;	;	:
18637	13030	22	citing	cite	VBG
18637	13030	23	United	United	NNP
18637	13030	24	States	States	NNP
18637	13030	25	_	_	NNP
18637	13030	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	13030	27	_	_	NNP
18637	13030	28	The	The	NNP
18637	13030	29	Thekla	Thekla	NNP
18637	13030	30	,	,	,
18637	13030	31	266	266	CD
18637	13030	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13030	33	328	328	CD
18637	13030	34	,	,	,
18637	13030	35	340	340	CD
18637	13030	36	,	,	,
18637	13030	37	341	341	CD
18637	13030	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13030	39	1924	1924	CD
18637	13030	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13030	41	;	;	:
18637	13030	42	United	United	NNP
18637	13030	43	States	States	NNP
18637	13030	44	_	_	NNP
18637	13030	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	13030	46	_	_	NNP
18637	13030	47	Stinson	Stinson	NNP
18637	13030	48	,	,	,
18637	13030	49	197	197	CD
18637	13030	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13030	51	200	200	CD
18637	13030	52	,	,	,
18637	13030	53	205	205	CD
18637	13030	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13030	55	1905	1905	CD
18637	13030	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13030	57	;	;	:
18637	13030	58	The	the	DT
18637	13030	59	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	13030	60	,	,	,
18637	13030	61	10	10	CD
18637	13030	62	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13030	63	.	.	.
18637	13031	1	15	15	CD
18637	13031	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13031	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	13031	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13031	5	;	;	:
18637	13031	6	The	the	DT
18637	13031	7	Siren	Siren	NNP
18637	13031	8	,	,	,
18637	13031	9	7	7	CD
18637	13031	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13031	11	.	.	.
18637	13032	1	152	152	CD
18637	13032	2	,	,	,
18637	13032	3	159	159	CD
18637	13032	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13032	5	1869	1869	CD
18637	13032	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13032	7	.	.	.
18637	13033	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13033	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13033	3	also	also	RB
18637	13033	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13033	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13033	6	parte	parte	NNP
18637	13033	7	Republic	Republic	NNP
18637	13033	8	of	of	IN
18637	13033	9	Colombia	Colombia	NNP
18637	13033	10	,	,	,
18637	13033	11	195	195	CD
18637	13033	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13033	13	604	604	CD
18637	13033	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13033	15	1904	1904	CD
18637	13033	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13033	17	.	.	.
18637	13034	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13034	2	573	573	CD
18637	13034	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13034	4	Guaranty	Guaranty	NNP
18637	13034	5	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	13034	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13034	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13034	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13034	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13034	10	United	United	NNP
18637	13034	11	States	States	NNP
18637	13034	12	,	,	,
18637	13034	13	304	304	CD
18637	13034	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13034	15	126	126	CD
18637	13034	16	,	,	,
18637	13034	17	137	137	CD
18637	13034	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13034	19	1938	1938	CD
18637	13034	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13034	21	.	.	.
18637	13035	1	Among	among	IN
18637	13035	2	other	other	JJ
18637	13035	3	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	13035	4	which	which	WDT
18637	13035	5	the	the	DT
18637	13035	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13035	7	cites	cite	VBZ
18637	13035	8	as	as	IN
18637	13035	9	not	not	RB
18637	13035	10	extending	extend	VBG
18637	13035	11	to	to	IN
18637	13035	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13035	13	States	States	NNP
18637	13035	14	as	as	IN
18637	13035	15	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	13035	16	include	include	VBP
18637	13035	17	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	13035	18	from	from	IN
18637	13035	19	costs	cost	NNS
18637	13035	20	and	and	CC
18637	13035	21	from	from	IN
18637	13035	22	giving	give	VBG
18637	13035	23	discovery	discovery	NN
18637	13035	24	.	.	.
18637	13036	1	Decisions	decision	NNS
18637	13036	2	are	be	VBP
18637	13036	3	also	also	RB
18637	13036	4	cited	cite	VBN
18637	13036	5	to	to	IN
18637	13036	6	the	the	DT
18637	13036	7	effect	effect	NN
18637	13036	8	that	that	IN
18637	13036	9	a	a	DT
18637	13036	10	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	13036	11	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	13036	12	"	"	''
18637	13036	13	should	should	MD
18637	13036	14	so	so	RB
18637	13036	15	far	far	RB
18637	13036	16	as	as	IN
18637	13036	17	the	the	DT
18637	13036	18	thing	thing	NN
18637	13036	19	can	can	MD
18637	13036	20	be	be	VB
18637	13036	21	done	do	VBN
18637	13036	22	,	,	,
18637	13036	23	be	be	VB
18637	13036	24	put	put	VBN
18637	13036	25	in	in	IN
18637	13036	26	the	the	DT
18637	13036	27	same	same	JJ
18637	13036	28	position	position	NN
18637	13036	29	as	as	IN
18637	13036	30	a	a	DT
18637	13036	31	body	body	NN
18637	13036	32	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	13036	33	.	.	.
18637	13036	34	"	"	''
18637	13037	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	13037	2	,	,	,
18637	13037	3	note	note	VB
18637	13037	4	2	2	CD
18637	13037	5	,	,	,
18637	13037	6	pp	pp	NNP
18637	13037	7	.	.	.
18637	13038	1	134	134	CD
18637	13038	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13038	3	135	135	CD
18637	13038	4	.	.	.
18637	13039	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13039	2	574	574	CD
18637	13039	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13039	4	5	5	CD
18637	13039	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	13039	6	.	.	.
18637	13040	1	1	1	CD
18637	13040	2	,	,	,
18637	13040	3	16	16	CD
18637	13040	4	-	-	SYM
18637	13040	5	20	20	CD
18637	13040	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13040	7	1831	1831	CD
18637	13040	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13040	9	.	.	.
18637	13041	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13041	2	575	575	CD
18637	13041	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13041	4	Hodgson	Hodgson	NNP
18637	13041	5	&	&	CC
18637	13041	6	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	13041	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13041	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13041	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13041	10	Bowerbank	Bowerbank	NNP
18637	13041	11	,	,	,
18637	13041	12	5	5	CD
18637	13041	13	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13041	14	.	.	.
18637	13042	1	303	303	CD
18637	13042	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13042	3	1809	1809	CD
18637	13042	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13042	5	.	.	.
18637	13043	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13043	2	576	576	CD
18637	13043	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13043	4	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	13043	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13043	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13043	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13043	8	Twentyman	Twentyman	NNP
18637	13043	9	,	,	,
18637	13043	10	2	2	CD
18637	13043	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	13043	12	.	.	.
18637	13044	1	136	136	CD
18637	13044	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13044	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	13044	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13044	5	.	.	.
18637	13045	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13045	2	577	577	CD
18637	13045	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13045	4	Susquehanna	Susquehanna	NNP
18637	13045	5	&	&	CC
18637	13045	6	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	13045	7	V.R.	V.R.	NNP
18637	13046	1	&	&	CC
18637	13046	2	C.	C.	NNP
18637	13046	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13046	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13046	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	13046	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13046	7	Blatchford	Blatchford	NNP
18637	13046	8	,	,	,
18637	13046	9	11	11	CD
18637	13046	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13046	11	.	.	.
18637	13047	1	172	172	CD
18637	13047	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13047	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	13047	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13047	5	.	.	.
18637	13048	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13048	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13048	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13048	4	,	,	,
18637	13048	5	however	however	RB
18637	13048	6	,	,	,
18637	13048	7	Lacassagne	Lacassagne	NNP
18637	13048	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13048	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	13048	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13048	11	Chapuis	Chapuis	NNP
18637	13048	12	,	,	,
18637	13048	13	144	144	CD
18637	13048	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13048	15	119	119	CD
18637	13048	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13048	17	1892	1892	CD
18637	13048	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13048	19	,	,	,
18637	13048	20	which	which	WDT
18637	13048	21	held	hold	VBD
18637	13048	22	that	that	IN
18637	13048	23	a	a	DT
18637	13048	24	lower	low	JJR
18637	13048	25	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13048	26	court	court	NN
18637	13048	27	had	have	VBD
18637	13048	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13048	29	over	over	IN
18637	13048	30	a	a	DT
18637	13048	31	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13048	32	to	to	TO
18637	13048	33	impeach	impeach	VB
18637	13048	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13048	35	former	former	JJ
18637	13048	36	decree	decree	NN
18637	13048	37	,	,	,
18637	13048	38	although	although	IN
18637	13048	39	the	the	DT
18637	13048	40	parties	party	NNS
18637	13048	41	were	be	VBD
18637	13048	42	new	new	JJ
18637	13048	43	and	and	CC
18637	13048	44	were	be	VBD
18637	13048	45	both	both	DT
18637	13048	46	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	13048	47	.	.	.
18637	13049	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13049	2	578	578	CD
18637	13049	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13049	4	Browne	Browne	NNP
18637	13049	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13049	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13049	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13049	8	Strode	Strode	NNP
18637	13049	9	,	,	,
18637	13049	10	5	5	CD
18637	13049	11	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13049	12	.	.	.
18637	13050	1	303	303	CD
18637	13050	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13050	3	1809	1809	CD
18637	13050	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13050	5	.	.	.
18637	13051	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13051	2	579	579	CD
18637	13051	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13051	4	2	2	CD
18637	13051	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	13051	6	.	.	.
18637	13052	1	419	419	CD
18637	13052	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13052	3	1793	1793	CD
18637	13052	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13052	5	.	.	.
18637	13053	1	For	for	IN
18637	13053	2	an	an	DT
18637	13053	3	earlier	early	JJR
18637	13053	4	case	case	NN
18637	13053	5	where	where	WRB
18637	13053	6	the	the	DT
18637	13053	7	point	point	NN
18637	13053	8	of	of	IN
18637	13053	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13053	10	was	be	VBD
18637	13053	11	not	not	RB
18637	13053	12	raised	raise	VBN
18637	13053	13	,	,	,
18637	13053	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13053	15	see	see	VBP
18637	13053	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13053	17	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	13053	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13053	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	13053	20	_	_	NNP
18637	13053	21	Brailsford	Brailsford	NNP
18637	13053	22	,	,	,
18637	13053	23	2	2	CD
18637	13053	24	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	13053	25	.	.	.
18637	13054	1	402	402	CD
18637	13054	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13054	3	1792	1792	CD
18637	13054	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13054	5	.	.	.
18637	13055	1	For	for	IN
18637	13055	2	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	13055	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	13055	4	prior	prior	RB
18637	13055	5	to	to	IN
18637	13055	6	1861	1861	CD
18637	13055	7	,	,	,
18637	13055	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13055	9	see	see	VBP
18637	13055	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13055	11	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	13055	12	Island	Island	NNP
18637	13055	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13055	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	13055	15	_	_	NNP
18637	13055	16	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13055	17	,	,	,
18637	13055	18	12	12	CD
18637	13055	19	Pet	pet	NN
18637	13055	20	.	.	.
18637	13056	1	657	657	CD
18637	13056	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13056	3	1838	1838	CD
18637	13056	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13056	5	;	;	:
18637	13056	6	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13056	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13056	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13056	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13056	10	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	13056	11	,	,	,
18637	13056	12	17	17	CD
18637	13056	13	How	how	WRB
18637	13056	14	.	.	.
18637	13057	1	478	478	CD
18637	13057	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13057	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	13057	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13057	5	.	.	.
18637	13058	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13058	2	580	580	CD
18637	13058	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13058	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	13058	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13058	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13058	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13058	8	Dennison	Dennison	NNP
18637	13058	9	,	,	,
18637	13058	10	24	24	CD
18637	13058	11	How	how	WRB
18637	13058	12	.	.	.
18637	13059	1	66	66	CD
18637	13059	2	,	,	,
18637	13059	3	98	98	CD
18637	13059	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13059	5	1861	1861	CD
18637	13059	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13059	7	.	.	.
18637	13060	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13060	2	581	581	CD
18637	13060	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13060	4	1	1	CD
18637	13060	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13060	6	.	.	.
18637	13061	1	137	137	CD
18637	13061	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13061	3	1803	1803	CD
18637	13061	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13061	5	.	.	.
18637	13062	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13062	2	582	582	CD
18637	13062	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13062	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13062	5	.	.	.
18637	13063	1	174	174	CD
18637	13063	2	.	.	.
18637	13064	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13064	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13064	3	also	also	RB
18637	13064	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13064	5	Wiscart	Wiscart	NNP
18637	13064	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13064	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13064	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13064	9	Dauchy	Dauchy	NNP
18637	13064	10	,	,	,
18637	13064	11	3	3	CD
18637	13064	12	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	13064	13	.	.	.
18637	13065	1	321	321	CD
18637	13065	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13065	3	1796	1796	CD
18637	13065	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13065	5	.	.	.
18637	13066	1	This	this	DT
18637	13066	2	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	13066	3	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	13066	4	of	of	IN
18637	13066	5	article	article	NN
18637	13066	6	III	iii	CD
18637	13066	7	posed	pose	VBD
18637	13066	8	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	13066	9	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	13066	10	for	for	IN
18637	13066	11	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	13066	12	in	in	IN
18637	13066	13	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	13066	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13066	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	13066	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13066	17	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	13066	18	,	,	,
18637	13066	19	6	6	CD
18637	13066	20	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	13066	21	.	.	.
18637	13067	1	264	264	CD
18637	13067	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13067	3	1821	1821	CD
18637	13067	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13067	5	,	,	,
18637	13067	6	where	where	WRB
18637	13067	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13067	8	gave	give	VBD
18637	13067	9	a	a	DT
18637	13067	10	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	13067	11	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	13067	12	to	to	IN
18637	13067	13	other	other	JJ
18637	13067	14	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	13067	15	of	of	IN
18637	13067	16	the	the	DT
18637	13067	17	Article	Article	NNP
18637	13067	18	.	.	.
18637	13068	1	The	the	DT
18637	13068	2	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	13068	3	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	13068	4	as	as	IN
18637	13068	5	applied	apply	VBN
18637	13068	6	to	to	IN
18637	13068	7	original	original	JJ
18637	13068	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13068	9	of	of	IN
18637	13068	10	the	the	DT
18637	13068	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13068	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13068	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	13068	14	been	be	VBN
18637	13068	15	followed	follow	VBN
18637	13068	16	in	in	IN
18637	13068	17	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13068	18	parte	parte	NN
18637	13068	19	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	13068	20	,	,	,
18637	13068	21	4	4	CD
18637	13068	22	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13068	23	.	.	.
18637	13069	1	75	75	CD
18637	13069	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13069	3	1807	1807	CD
18637	13069	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13069	5	;	;	:
18637	13069	6	New	New	NNP
18637	13069	7	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	13069	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13069	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	13069	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13069	11	New	New	NNP
18637	13069	12	York	York	NNP
18637	13069	13	,	,	,
18637	13069	14	5	5	CD
18637	13069	15	Pet	pet	NN
18637	13069	16	.	.	.
18637	13070	1	284	284	CD
18637	13070	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13070	3	1831	1831	CD
18637	13070	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13070	5	;	;	:
18637	13070	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13070	7	parte	parte	VBZ
18637	13070	8	Barry	Barry	NNP
18637	13070	9	,	,	,
18637	13070	10	2	2	CD
18637	13070	11	How	how	WRB
18637	13070	12	.	.	.
18637	13071	1	65	65	CD
18637	13071	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13071	3	1844	1844	CD
18637	13071	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13071	5	;	;	:
18637	13071	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13071	7	parte	parte	VBZ
18637	13071	8	Vallandigham	Vallandigham	NNP
18637	13071	9	,	,	,
18637	13071	10	1	1	CD
18637	13071	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13071	12	.	.	.
18637	13072	1	243	243	CD
18637	13072	2	,	,	,
18637	13072	3	252	252	CD
18637	13072	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13072	5	1864	1864	CD
18637	13072	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13072	7	;	;	:
18637	13072	8	and	and	CC
18637	13072	9	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13072	10	parte	parte	NNP
18637	13072	11	Yerger	Yerger	NNP
18637	13072	12	,	,	,
18637	13072	13	8	8	CD
18637	13072	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13072	15	.	.	.
18637	13073	1	85	85	CD
18637	13073	2	,	,	,
18637	13073	3	98	98	CD
18637	13073	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13073	5	1869	1869	CD
18637	13073	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13073	7	.	.	.
18637	13074	1	In	in	IN
18637	13074	2	the	the	DT
18637	13074	3	curious	curious	JJ
18637	13074	4	case	case	NN
18637	13074	5	of	of	IN
18637	13074	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13074	7	parte	parte	NN
18637	13074	8	Levitt	Levitt	NNP
18637	13074	9	,	,	,
18637	13074	10	Petitioner	Petitioner	NNP
18637	13074	11	,	,	,
18637	13074	12	302	302	CD
18637	13074	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13074	14	633	633	CD
18637	13074	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13074	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	13074	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13074	18	,	,	,
18637	13074	19	the	the	DT
18637	13074	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13074	21	was	be	VBD
18637	13074	22	asked	ask	VBN
18637	13074	23	to	to	TO
18637	13074	24	purge	purge	VB
18637	13074	25	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13074	26	of	of	IN
18637	13074	27	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13074	28	Black	Black	NNP
18637	13074	29	on	on	IN
18637	13074	30	the	the	DT
18637	13074	31	ground	ground	NN
18637	13074	32	that	that	IN
18637	13074	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13074	34	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	13074	35	to	to	IN
18637	13074	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13074	37	violated	violate	VBD
18637	13074	38	the	the	DT
18637	13074	39	second	second	JJ
18637	13074	40	clause	clause	NN
18637	13074	41	of	of	IN
18637	13074	42	section	section	NN
18637	13074	43	6	6	CD
18637	13074	44	of	of	IN
18637	13074	45	Article	article	NN
18637	13074	46	I.	i.	NN
18637	13075	1	Although	although	IN
18637	13075	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13075	3	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	13075	4	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	13075	5	's	's	POS
18637	13075	6	application	application	NN
18637	13075	7	,	,	,
18637	13075	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13075	9	refrained	refrain	VBD
18637	13075	10	from	from	IN
18637	13075	11	pointing	point	VBG
18637	13075	12	out	out	RP
18637	13075	13	that	that	IN
18637	13075	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13075	15	was	be	VBD
18637	13075	16	being	be	VBG
18637	13075	17	asked	ask	VBD
18637	13075	18	to	to	TO
18637	13075	19	assume	assume	VB
18637	13075	20	original	original	JJ
18637	13075	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13075	22	contrary	contrary	RB
18637	13075	23	to	to	IN
18637	13075	24	the	the	DT
18637	13075	25	holding	holding	NN
18637	13075	26	in	in	IN
18637	13075	27	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	13075	28	_	_	NNP
18637	13075	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	13075	30	_	_	NNP
18637	13075	31	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	13075	32	.	.	.
18637	13076	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13076	2	583	583	CD
18637	13076	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13076	4	252	252	CD
18637	13076	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13076	6	416	416	CD
18637	13076	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13076	8	1920	1920	CD
18637	13076	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13076	10	.	.	.
18637	13077	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13077	2	584	584	CD
18637	13077	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13077	4	262	262	CD
18637	13077	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13077	6	447	447	CD
18637	13077	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13077	8	1923	1923	CD
18637	13077	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13077	10	.	.	.
18637	13078	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13078	2	585	585	CD
18637	13078	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13078	4	157	157	CD
18637	13078	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13078	6	229	229	CD
18637	13078	7	,	,	,
18637	13078	8	261	261	CD
18637	13078	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13078	10	1895	1895	CD
18637	13078	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13078	12	.	.	.
18637	13079	1	Here	here	RB
18637	13079	2	the	the	DT
18637	13079	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13079	4	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	13079	5	to	to	TO
18637	13079	6	take	take	VB
18637	13079	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13079	8	on	on	IN
18637	13079	9	the	the	DT
18637	13079	10	ground	ground	NN
18637	13079	11	that	that	IN
18637	13079	12	the	the	DT
18637	13079	13	City	City	NNP
18637	13079	14	of	of	IN
18637	13079	15	Oakland	Oakland	NNP
18637	13079	16	and	and	CC
18637	13079	17	the	the	DT
18637	13079	18	Oakland	Oakland	NNP
18637	13079	19	Water	Water	NNP
18637	13079	20	Company	Company	NNP
18637	13079	21	,	,	,
18637	13079	22	a	a	DT
18637	13079	23	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	13079	24	of	of	IN
18637	13079	25	California	California	NNP
18637	13079	26	,	,	,
18637	13079	27	were	be	VBD
18637	13079	28	so	so	RB
18637	13079	29	situated	situated	JJ
18637	13079	30	that	that	IN
18637	13079	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13079	32	would	would	MD
18637	13079	33	have	have	VB
18637	13079	34	to	to	TO
18637	13079	35	be	be	VB
18637	13079	36	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13079	37	into	into	IN
18637	13079	38	the	the	DT
18637	13079	39	case	case	NN
18637	13079	40	,	,	,
18637	13079	41	which	which	WDT
18637	13079	42	would	would	MD
18637	13079	43	make	make	VB
18637	13079	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13079	45	then	then	RB
18637	13079	46	a	a	DT
18637	13079	47	suit	suit	NN
18637	13079	48	between	between	IN
18637	13079	49	a	a	DT
18637	13079	50	State	state	NN
18637	13079	51	and	and	CC
18637	13079	52	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13079	53	of	of	IN
18637	13079	54	another	another	DT
18637	13079	55	State	State	NNP
18637	13079	56	and	and	CC
18637	13079	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13079	58	own	own	JJ
18637	13079	59	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13079	60	.	.	.
18637	13080	1	The	the	DT
18637	13080	2	same	same	JJ
18637	13080	3	rule	rule	NN
18637	13080	4	was	be	VBD
18637	13080	5	followed	follow	VBN
18637	13080	6	in	in	IN
18637	13080	7	New	New	NNP
18637	13080	8	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	13080	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13080	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	13080	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13080	12	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	13080	13	,	,	,
18637	13080	14	243	243	CD
18637	13080	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13080	16	52	52	CD
18637	13080	17	,	,	,
18637	13080	18	58	58	CD
18637	13080	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13080	20	1917	1917	CD
18637	13080	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13080	22	;	;	:
18637	13080	23	and	and	CC
18637	13080	24	in	in	IN
18637	13080	25	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	13080	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13080	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	13080	28	_	_	NNP
18637	13080	29	Cummins	Cummins	NNP
18637	13080	30	,	,	,
18637	13080	31	314	314	CD
18637	13080	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13080	33	577	577	CD
18637	13080	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13080	35	1941	1941	CD
18637	13080	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13080	37	.	.	.
18637	13081	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13081	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13081	3	also	also	RB
18637	13081	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13081	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	13081	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13081	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13081	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13081	9	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	13081	10	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	13081	11	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	13081	12	,	,	,
18637	13081	13	258	258	CD
18637	13081	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13081	15	158	158	CD
18637	13081	16	,	,	,
18637	13081	17	163	163	CD
18637	13081	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13081	19	1922	1922	CD
18637	13081	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13081	21	.	.	.
18637	13082	1	For	for	IN
18637	13082	2	the	the	DT
18637	13082	3	original	original	JJ
18637	13082	4	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13082	5	of	of	IN
18637	13082	6	the	the	DT
18637	13082	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13082	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13082	9	in	in	IN
18637	13082	10	specific	specific	JJ
18637	13082	11	classes	class	NNS
18637	13082	12	of	of	IN
18637	13082	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	13082	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13082	15	see	see	VBP
18637	13082	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13082	17	the	the	DT
18637	13082	18	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	13082	19	of	of	IN
18637	13082	20	suits	suit	NNS
18637	13082	21	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	13082	22	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	13082	23	and	and	CC
18637	13082	24	suits	suit	NNS
18637	13082	25	between	between	IN
18637	13082	26	States	States	NNP
18637	13082	27	,	,	,
18637	13082	28	_	_	NNP
18637	13082	29	supra	supra	NNP
18637	13082	30	_	_	NNP
18637	13082	31	,	,	,
18637	13082	32	pp	pp	NNP
18637	13082	33	.	.	.
18637	13083	1	571	571	CD
18637	13083	2	,	,	,
18637	13083	3	591	591	CD
18637	13083	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	13083	5	593	593	CD
18637	13083	6	.	.	.
18637	13084	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13084	2	586	586	CD
18637	13084	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13084	4	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	13084	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13084	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13084	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13084	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	13084	9	ex	ex	NNP
18637	13084	10	rel	rel	NNP
18637	13084	11	.	.	.
18637	13085	1	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	13085	2	,	,	,
18637	13085	3	111	111	CD
18637	13085	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13085	5	449	449	CD
18637	13085	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13085	7	1884	1884	CD
18637	13085	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13085	9	.	.	.
18637	13086	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13086	2	587	587	CD
18637	13086	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13086	4	127	127	CD
18637	13086	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13086	6	265	265	CD
18637	13086	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13086	8	1888	1888	CD
18637	13086	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13086	10	.	.	.
18637	13087	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13087	2	588	588	CD
18637	13087	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13087	4	1	1	CD
18637	13087	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13087	6	.	.	.
18637	13088	1	73	73	CD
18637	13088	2	,	,	,
18637	13088	3	80	80	CD
18637	13088	4	.	.	.
18637	13089	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13089	2	589	589	CD
18637	13089	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13089	4	127	127	CD
18637	13089	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13089	6	265	265	CD
18637	13089	7	,	,	,
18637	13089	8	297	297	CD
18637	13089	9	.	.	.
18637	13090	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13090	2	Note	Note	NNP
18637	13090	3	also	also	RB
18637	13090	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13090	5	the	the	DT
18637	13090	6	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	13090	7	in	in	IN
18637	13090	8	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	13090	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13090	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	13090	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13090	12	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	13090	13	,	,	,
18637	13090	14	6	6	CD
18637	13090	15	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	13090	16	.	.	.
18637	13091	1	264	264	CD
18637	13091	2	,	,	,
18637	13091	3	398	398	CD
18637	13091	4	-	-	SYM
18637	13091	5	399	399	CD
18637	13091	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13091	7	1821	1821	CD
18637	13091	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13091	9	to	to	IN
18637	13091	10	the	the	DT
18637	13091	11	effect	effect	NN
18637	13091	12	that	that	IN
18637	13091	13	"	"	``
18637	13091	14	*	*	NFP
18637	13091	15	*	*	NFP
18637	13091	16	*	*	NFP
18637	13091	17	the	the	DT
18637	13091	18	original	original	JJ
18637	13091	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13091	20	of	of	IN
18637	13091	21	the	the	DT
18637	13091	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13091	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13091	24	,	,	,
18637	13091	25	in	in	IN
18637	13091	26	cases	case	NNS
18637	13091	27	where	where	WRB
18637	13091	28	a	a	DT
18637	13091	29	State	state	NN
18637	13091	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	13091	31	a	a	DT
18637	13091	32	party	party	NN
18637	13091	33	,	,	,
18637	13091	34	refers	refer	VBZ
18637	13091	35	to	to	IN
18637	13091	36	those	those	DT
18637	13091	37	cases	case	NNS
18637	13091	38	in	in	IN
18637	13091	39	which	which	WDT
18637	13091	40	,	,	,
18637	13091	41	according	accord	VBG
18637	13091	42	to	to	IN
18637	13091	43	the	the	DT
18637	13091	44	grant	grant	NN
18637	13091	45	of	of	IN
18637	13091	46	power	power	NN
18637	13091	47	made	make	VBN
18637	13091	48	in	in	IN
18637	13091	49	the	the	DT
18637	13091	50	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	13091	51	clause	clause	NN
18637	13091	52	,	,	,
18637	13091	53	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13091	54	might	may	MD
18637	13091	55	be	be	VB
18637	13091	56	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	13091	57	in	in	IN
18637	13091	58	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	13091	59	of	of	IN
18637	13091	60	the	the	DT
18637	13091	61	character	character	NN
18637	13091	62	of	of	IN
18637	13091	63	the	the	DT
18637	13091	64	party	party	NN
18637	13091	65	,	,	,
18637	13091	66	and	and	CC
18637	13091	67	an	an	DT
18637	13091	68	original	original	JJ
18637	13091	69	suit	suit	NN
18637	13091	70	might	may	MD
18637	13091	71	be	be	VB
18637	13091	72	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	13091	73	in	in	IN
18637	13091	74	any	any	DT
18637	13091	75	of	of	IN
18637	13091	76	the	the	DT
18637	13091	77	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13091	78	courts	court	NNS
18637	13091	79	;	;	:
18637	13091	80	not	not	RB
18637	13091	81	to	to	IN
18637	13091	82	those	those	DT
18637	13091	83	cases	case	NNS
18637	13091	84	in	in	IN
18637	13091	85	which	which	WDT
18637	13091	86	an	an	DT
18637	13091	87	original	original	JJ
18637	13091	88	suit	suit	NN
18637	13091	89	might	may	MD
18637	13091	90	not	not	RB
18637	13091	91	be	be	VB
18637	13091	92	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	13091	93	in	in	IN
18637	13091	94	a	a	DT
18637	13091	95	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13091	96	court	court	NN
18637	13091	97	.	.	.
18637	13092	1	Of	of	IN
18637	13092	2	the	the	DT
18637	13092	3	last	last	JJ
18637	13092	4	description	description	NN
18637	13092	5	,	,	,
18637	13092	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	13092	7	every	every	DT
18637	13092	8	case	case	NN
18637	13092	9	between	between	IN
18637	13092	10	a	a	DT
18637	13092	11	State	state	NN
18637	13092	12	and	and	CC
18637	13092	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13092	14	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13092	15	,	,	,
18637	13092	16	and	and	CC
18637	13092	17	,	,	,
18637	13092	18	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	13092	19	every	every	DT
18637	13092	20	case	case	NN
18637	13092	21	in	in	IN
18637	13092	22	which	which	WDT
18637	13092	23	a	a	DT
18637	13092	24	State	state	NN
18637	13092	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	13092	26	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	13092	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13092	28	penal	penal	JJ
18637	13092	29	laws	law	NNS
18637	13092	30	.	.	.
18637	13093	1	In	in	IN
18637	13093	2	such	such	JJ
18637	13093	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	13093	4	,	,	,
18637	13093	5	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	13093	6	,	,	,
18637	13093	7	the	the	DT
18637	13093	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13093	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13093	10	can	can	MD
18637	13093	11	not	not	RB
18637	13093	12	take	take	VB
18637	13093	13	original	original	JJ
18637	13093	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13093	15	.	.	.
18637	13093	16	"	"	''
18637	13094	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13094	2	590	590	CD
18637	13094	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13094	4	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	13094	5	ex	ex	JJ
18637	13094	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	13094	7	.	.	.
18637	13095	1	Popovici	Popovici	NNP
18637	13095	2	_	_	NNP
18637	13095	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	13095	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13095	5	Agler	Agler	NNP
18637	13095	6	,	,	,
18637	13095	7	280	280	CD
18637	13095	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13095	9	379	379	CD
18637	13095	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13095	11	1930	1930	CD
18637	13095	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13095	13	.	.	.
18637	13096	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13096	2	591	591	CD
18637	13096	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13096	4	3	3	CD
18637	13096	5	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	13096	6	.	.	.
18637	13097	1	321	321	CD
18637	13097	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13097	3	1796	1796	CD
18637	13097	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13097	5	.	.	.
18637	13098	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13098	2	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	13098	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	13098	4	from	from	IN
18637	13098	5	this	this	DT
18637	13098	6	holding	holding	NN
18637	13098	7	and	and	CC
18637	13098	8	contended	contend	VBD
18637	13098	9	that	that	IN
18637	13098	10	the	the	DT
18637	13098	11	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	13098	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13098	13	,	,	,
18637	13098	14	as	as	IN
18637	13098	15	being	be	VBG
18637	13098	16	derived	derive	VBN
18637	13098	17	from	from	IN
18637	13098	18	the	the	DT
18637	13098	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13098	20	,	,	,
18637	13098	21	could	could	MD
18637	13098	22	be	be	VB
18637	13098	23	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	13098	24	without	without	IN
18637	13098	25	an	an	DT
18637	13098	26	act	act	NN
18637	13098	27	of	of	IN
18637	13098	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13098	29	or	or	CC
18637	13098	30	until	until	IN
18637	13098	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13098	32	made	make	VBD
18637	13098	33	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	13098	34	to	to	IN
18637	13098	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13098	36	.	.	.
18637	13099	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13099	2	592	592	CD
18637	13099	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13099	4	Durousseau	Durousseau	NNP
18637	13099	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13099	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13099	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13099	8	United	United	NNP
18637	13099	9	States	States	NNP
18637	13099	10	,	,	,
18637	13099	11	6	6	CD
18637	13099	12	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13099	13	.	.	.
18637	13100	1	307	307	CD
18637	13100	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13100	3	1810	1810	CD
18637	13100	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13100	5	.	.	.
18637	13101	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13101	2	593	593	CD
18637	13101	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13101	4	6	6	CD
18637	13101	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13101	6	.	.	.
18637	13102	1	318	318	CD
18637	13102	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13102	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	13102	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13102	5	;	;	:
18637	13102	6	7	7	CD
18637	13102	7	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13102	8	.	.	.
18637	13103	1	506	506	CD
18637	13103	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13103	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	13103	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13103	5	.	.	.
18637	13104	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13104	2	594	594	CD
18637	13104	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13104	4	15	15	CD
18637	13104	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13104	6	.	.	.
18637	13105	1	44	44	CD
18637	13105	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13105	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	13105	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13105	5	.	.	.
18637	13106	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13106	2	595	595	CD
18637	13106	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13106	4	7	7	CD
18637	13106	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13106	6	.	.	.
18637	13107	1	506	506	CD
18637	13107	2	,	,	,
18637	13107	3	514	514	CD
18637	13107	4	.	.	.
18637	13108	1	The	the	DT
18637	13108	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13108	3	also	also	RB
18637	13108	4	took	take	VBD
18637	13108	5	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	13108	6	to	to	TO
18637	13108	7	reiterate	reiterate	VB
18637	13108	8	the	the	DT
18637	13108	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	13108	10	that	that	IN
18637	13108	11	an	an	DT
18637	13108	12	affirmation	affirmation	NN
18637	13108	13	of	of	IN
18637	13108	14	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	13108	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13108	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	13108	17	a	a	DT
18637	13108	18	negative	negative	NN
18637	13108	19	of	of	IN
18637	13108	20	all	all	DT
18637	13108	21	other	other	JJ
18637	13108	22	and	and	CC
18637	13108	23	stated	state	VBD
18637	13108	24	that	that	IN
18637	13108	25	as	as	IN
18637	13108	26	a	a	DT
18637	13108	27	result	result	NN
18637	13108	28	acts	act	NNS
18637	13108	29	of	of	IN
18637	13108	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13108	31	providing	provide	VBG
18637	13108	32	for	for	IN
18637	13108	33	the	the	DT
18637	13108	34	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	13108	35	of	of	IN
18637	13108	36	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13108	37	had	have	VBD
18637	13108	38	"	"	``
18637	13108	39	come	come	VBN
18637	13108	40	to	to	TO
18637	13108	41	be	be	VB
18637	13108	42	spoken	speak	VBN
18637	13108	43	of	of	IN
18637	13108	44	as	as	IN
18637	13108	45	acts	act	NNS
18637	13108	46	granting	grant	VBG
18637	13108	47	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13108	48	,	,	,
18637	13108	49	and	and	CC
18637	13108	50	not	not	RB
18637	13108	51	as	as	IN
18637	13108	52	acts	act	VBZ
18637	13108	53	making	make	VBG
18637	13108	54	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	13108	55	to	to	IN
18637	13108	56	*	*	NFP
18637	13108	57	*	*	NFP
18637	13108	58	*	*	NFP
18637	13108	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13108	60	.	.	.
18637	13108	61	"	"	''
18637	13109	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13109	2	continued	continue	VBD
18637	13109	3	grandly	grandly	RB
18637	13109	4	:	:	:
18637	13109	5	"	"	``
18637	13109	6	*	*	NFP
18637	13109	7	*	*	NFP
18637	13109	8	*	*	NFP
18637	13109	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13109	10	duty	duty	NN
18637	13109	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	13109	12	not	not	RB
18637	13109	13	less	less	RBR
18637	13109	14	fitly	fitly	RB
18637	13109	15	performed	perform	VBN
18637	13109	16	by	by	IN
18637	13109	17	declining	decline	VBG
18637	13109	18	ungranted	ungranted	JJ
18637	13109	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13109	20	than	than	IN
18637	13109	21	in	in	IN
18637	13109	22	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	13109	23	firmly	firmly	RB
18637	13109	24	that	that	WDT
18637	13109	25	which	which	WDT
18637	13109	26	the	the	DT
18637	13109	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13109	28	and	and	CC
18637	13109	29	the	the	DT
18637	13109	30	laws	law	NNS
18637	13109	31	confer	confer	VBP
18637	13109	32	.	.	.
18637	13109	33	"	"	''
18637	13110	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	13110	2	.	.	.
18637	13111	1	513	513	CD
18637	13111	2	,	,	,
18637	13111	3	515	515	CD
18637	13111	4	.	.	.
18637	13112	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13112	2	596	596	CD
18637	13112	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13112	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13112	5	See	See	NNP
18637	13112	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13112	7	especially	especially	RB
18637	13112	8	the	the	DT
18637	13112	9	parallel	parallel	JJ
18637	13112	10	case	case	NN
18637	13112	11	of	of	IN
18637	13112	12	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13112	13	parte	parte	NNP
18637	13112	14	Yerger	Yerger	NNP
18637	13112	15	,	,	,
18637	13112	16	8	8	CD
18637	13112	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13112	18	.	.	.
18637	13113	1	85	85	CD
18637	13113	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13113	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	13113	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13113	5	.	.	.
18637	13114	1	For	for	IN
18637	13114	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	13114	3	following	follow	VBG
18637	13114	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13114	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	13114	6	McCardle	McCardle	NNP
18637	13114	7	,	,	,
18637	13114	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13114	9	see	see	VBP
18637	13114	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13114	11	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	13114	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13114	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13114	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	13114	15	_	_	NNP
18637	13114	16	Grant	Grant	NNP
18637	13114	17	,	,	,
18637	13114	18	98	98	CD
18637	13114	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13114	20	398	398	CD
18637	13114	21	,	,	,
18637	13114	22	491	491	CD
18637	13114	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13114	24	1878	1878	CD
18637	13114	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13114	26	;	;	:
18637	13114	27	Kurtz	Kurtz	NNP
18637	13114	28	_	_	NNP
18637	13114	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	13114	30	_	_	NNP
18637	13114	31	Moffitt	Moffitt	NNP
18637	13114	32	,	,	,
18637	13114	33	115	115	CD
18637	13114	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13114	35	487	487	CD
18637	13114	36	,	,	,
18637	13114	37	497	497	CD
18637	13114	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13114	39	1885	1885	CD
18637	13114	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13114	41	;	;	:
18637	13114	42	Cross	Cross	NNP
18637	13114	43	_	_	NNP
18637	13114	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	13114	45	_	_	NNP
18637	13114	46	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	13114	47	,	,	,
18637	13114	48	146	146	CD
18637	13114	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13114	50	82	82	CD
18637	13114	51	,	,	,
18637	13114	52	86	86	CD
18637	13114	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13114	54	1892	1892	CD
18637	13114	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13114	56	;	;	:
18637	13114	57	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	13114	58	_	_	NNP
18637	13114	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	13114	60	_	_	NNP
18637	13114	61	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	13114	62	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	13114	63	R.	R.	NNP
18637	13114	64	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13114	65	,	,	,
18637	13114	66	292	292	CD
18637	13114	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13114	68	13	13	CD
18637	13114	69	,	,	,
18637	13114	70	15	15	CD
18637	13114	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13114	72	1934	1934	CD
18637	13114	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13114	74	;	;	:
18637	13114	75	Stephan	Stephan	NNP
18637	13114	76	_	_	NNP
18637	13114	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	13114	78	_	_	NNP
18637	13114	79	United	United	NNP
18637	13114	80	States	States	NNP
18637	13114	81	,	,	,
18637	13114	82	319	319	CD
18637	13114	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13114	84	423	423	CD
18637	13114	85	,	,	,
18637	13114	86	426	426	CD
18637	13114	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13114	88	1943	1943	CD
18637	13114	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13114	90	.	.	.
18637	13115	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13115	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13115	3	also	also	RB
18637	13115	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13115	5	United	United	NNP
18637	13115	6	States	States	NNP
18637	13115	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13115	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13115	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13115	10	Bitty	Bitty	NNP
18637	13115	11	,	,	,
18637	13115	12	208	208	CD
18637	13115	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13115	14	393	393	CD
18637	13115	15	,	,	,
18637	13115	16	399	399	CD
18637	13115	17	-	-	SYM
18637	13115	18	400	400	CD
18637	13115	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13115	20	1908	1908	CD
18637	13115	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13115	22	,	,	,
18637	13115	23	where	where	WRB
18637	13115	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13115	25	was	be	VBD
18637	13115	26	held	hold	VBN
18637	13115	27	that	that	IN
18637	13115	28	there	there	EX
18637	13115	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	13115	30	no	no	DT
18637	13115	31	right	right	NN
18637	13115	32	to	to	TO
18637	13115	33	appeal	appeal	VB
18637	13115	34	to	to	IN
18637	13115	35	the	the	DT
18637	13115	36	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13115	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13115	38	except	except	IN
18637	13115	39	as	as	IN
18637	13115	40	an	an	DT
18637	13115	41	act	act	NN
18637	13115	42	of	of	IN
18637	13115	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13115	44	confers	confer	VBZ
18637	13115	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13115	46	.	.	.
18637	13116	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13116	2	597	597	CD
18637	13116	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13116	4	105	105	CD
18637	13116	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13116	6	381	381	CD
18637	13116	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13116	8	1882	1882	CD
18637	13116	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13116	10	.	.	.
18637	13117	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13117	2	598	598	CD
18637	13117	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13117	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13117	5	.	.	.
18637	13118	1	386	386	CD
18637	13118	2	.	.	.
18637	13119	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13119	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13119	3	also	also	RB
18637	13119	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13119	5	Barry	Barry	NNP
18637	13119	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13119	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13119	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13119	9	Mercein	Mercein	NNP
18637	13119	10	,	,	,
18637	13119	11	5	5	CD
18637	13119	12	How	how	WRB
18637	13119	13	.	.	.
18637	13120	1	103	103	CD
18637	13120	2	,	,	,
18637	13120	3	119	119	CD
18637	13120	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13120	5	1847	1847	CD
18637	13120	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13120	7	;	;	:
18637	13120	8	National	National	NNP
18637	13120	9	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	13120	10	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	13120	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13120	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13120	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13120	14	Peters	Peters	NNP
18637	13120	15	,	,	,
18637	13120	16	144	144	CD
18637	13120	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13120	18	570	570	CD
18637	13120	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13120	20	1892	1892	CD
18637	13120	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13120	22	;	;	:
18637	13120	23	American	American	NNP
18637	13120	24	Construction	Construction	NNP
18637	13120	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13120	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13120	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	13120	28	_	_	NNP
18637	13120	29	Jacksonville	Jacksonville	NNP
18637	13120	30	T.	T.	NNP
18637	13120	31	&	&	CC
18637	13120	32	K.W.R.	K.W.R.	NNP
18637	13121	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13121	2	,	,	,
18637	13121	3	148	148	CD
18637	13121	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13121	5	372	372	CD
18637	13121	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13121	7	1893	1893	CD
18637	13121	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13121	9	;	;	:
18637	13121	10	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	13121	11	Central	Central	NNP
18637	13121	12	Consol	Consol	NNP
18637	13121	13	.	.	.
18637	13122	1	Min	Min	NNP
18637	13122	2	.	.	.
18637	13123	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13123	2	_	_	NNP
18637	13123	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	13123	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13123	5	Turck	Turck	NNP
18637	13123	6	,	,	,
18637	13123	7	150	150	CD
18637	13123	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13123	9	138	138	CD
18637	13123	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13123	11	1893	1893	CD
18637	13123	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13123	13	;	;	:
18637	13123	14	St.	St.	NNP
18637	13123	15	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	13123	16	,	,	,
18637	13123	17	I.M.	I.M.	NNP
18637	13124	1	&	&	CC
18637	13124	2	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	13125	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13125	2	_	_	NNP
18637	13125	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	13125	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13125	5	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	13125	6	,	,	,
18637	13125	7	210	210	CD
18637	13125	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13125	9	281	281	CD
18637	13125	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13125	11	1908	1908	CD
18637	13125	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13125	13	;	;	:
18637	13125	14	Luckenbach	Luckenbach	NNP
18637	13125	15	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	13125	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13125	17	_	_	NNP
18637	13125	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	13125	19	_	_	NNP
18637	13125	20	United	United	NNP
18637	13125	21	States	States	NNP
18637	13125	22	,	,	,
18637	13125	23	272	272	CD
18637	13125	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13125	25	533	533	CD
18637	13125	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13125	27	1926	1926	CD
18637	13125	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13125	29	.	.	.
18637	13126	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13126	2	599	599	CD
18637	13126	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13126	4	1	1	CD
18637	13126	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	13126	6	.	.	.
18637	13127	1	304	304	CD
18637	13127	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13127	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	13127	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13127	5	.	.	.
18637	13128	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13128	2	600	600	CD
18637	13128	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13128	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13128	5	.	.	.
18637	13129	1	374	374	CD
18637	13129	2	.	.	.
18637	13130	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13130	2	601	601	CD
18637	13130	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13130	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13130	5	.	.	.
18637	13131	1	331	331	CD
18637	13131	2	.	.	.
18637	13132	1	This	this	DT
18637	13132	2	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13132	3	,	,	,
18637	13132	4	however	however	RB
18637	13132	5	,	,	,
18637	13132	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	13132	7	followed	follow	VBN
18637	13132	8	by	by	IN
18637	13132	9	the	the	DT
18637	13132	10	statement	statement	NN
18637	13132	11	that	that	IN
18637	13132	12	"	"	``
18637	13132	13	the	the	DT
18637	13132	14	whole	whole	JJ
18637	13132	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13132	16	power	power	NN
18637	13132	17	of	of	IN
18637	13132	18	the	the	DT
18637	13132	19	United	United	NNP
18637	13132	20	States	States	NNP
18637	13132	21	should	should	MD
18637	13132	22	be	be	VB
18637	13132	23	at	at	IN
18637	13132	24	all	all	DT
18637	13132	25	times	time	NNS
18637	13132	26	,	,	,
18637	13132	27	vested	vest	VBN
18637	13132	28	either	either	CC
18637	13132	29	in	in	IN
18637	13132	30	an	an	DT
18637	13132	31	original	original	JJ
18637	13132	32	or	or	CC
18637	13132	33	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	13132	34	form	form	NN
18637	13132	35	,	,	,
18637	13132	36	in	in	IN
18637	13132	37	some	some	DT
18637	13132	38	courts	court	NNS
18637	13132	39	created	create	VBN
18637	13132	40	under	under	IN
18637	13132	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13132	42	authority	authority	NN
18637	13132	43	.	.	.
18637	13132	44	"	"	''
18637	13133	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13133	2	602	602	CD
18637	13133	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13133	4	2	2	CD
18637	13133	5	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	13133	6	,	,	,
18637	13133	7	§§	§§	-LRB-
18637	13133	8	1590	1590	CD
18637	13133	9	-	-	SYM
18637	13133	10	1595	1595	CD
18637	13133	11	.	.	.
18637	13134	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13134	2	603	603	CD
18637	13134	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13134	4	1	1	CD
18637	13134	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13134	6	.	.	.
18637	13135	1	73	73	CD
18637	13135	2	,	,	,
18637	13135	3	§§	§§	-LRB-
18637	13135	4	9	9	CD
18637	13135	5	-	-	SYM
18637	13135	6	11	11	CD
18637	13135	7	.	.	.
18637	13136	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13136	2	604	604	CD
18637	13136	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13136	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13136	5	.	.	.
18637	13137	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13137	2	605	605	CD
18637	13137	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13137	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13137	5	.	.	.
18637	13138	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	13138	2	14	14	CD
18637	13138	3	,	,	,
18637	13138	4	15	15	CD
18637	13138	5	,	,	,
18637	13138	6	17	17	CD
18637	13138	7	,	,	,
18637	13138	8	18	18	CD
18637	13138	9	.	.	.
18637	13139	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13139	2	606	606	CD
18637	13139	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13139	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13139	5	.	.	.
18637	13140	1	§	§	NNP
18637	13140	2	16	16	CD
18637	13140	3	.	.	.
18637	13141	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13141	2	607	607	CD
18637	13141	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13141	4	Dall	dall	NN
18637	13141	5	.	.	.
18637	13142	1	8	8	CD
18637	13142	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13142	3	1799	1799	CD
18637	13142	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13142	5	.	.	.
18637	13143	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13143	2	608	608	CD
18637	13143	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13143	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13143	5	.	.	.
18637	13144	1	9	9	CD
18637	13144	2	.	.	.
18637	13145	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13145	2	609	609	CD
18637	13145	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13145	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13145	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	13145	6	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	13145	7	,	,	,
18637	13145	8	4	4	CD
18637	13145	9	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13145	10	.	.	.
18637	13146	1	75	75	CD
18637	13146	2	,	,	,
18637	13146	3	93	93	CD
18637	13146	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13146	5	1807	1807	CD
18637	13146	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13146	7	.	.	.
18637	13147	1	Two	two	CD
18637	13147	2	years	year	NNS
18637	13147	3	later	later	RB
18637	13147	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	13147	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13147	6	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	13147	7	in	in	IN
18637	13147	8	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	13147	9	of	of	IN
18637	13147	10	United	United	NNP
18637	13147	11	States	States	NNP
18637	13147	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13147	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	13147	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13147	15	Deveaux	Deveaux	NNP
18637	13147	16	,	,	,
18637	13147	17	5	5	CD
18637	13147	18	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13147	19	.	.	.
18637	13148	1	61	61	CD
18637	13148	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13148	3	1809	1809	CD
18637	13148	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13148	5	,	,	,
18637	13148	6	held	hold	VBN
18637	13148	7	for	for	IN
18637	13148	8	the	the	DT
18637	13148	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13148	10	that	that	WDT
18637	13148	11	the	the	DT
18637	13148	12	right	right	NN
18637	13148	13	to	to	TO
18637	13148	14	sue	sue	VB
18637	13148	15	does	do	VBZ
18637	13148	16	not	not	RB
18637	13148	17	imply	imply	VB
18637	13148	18	a	a	DT
18637	13148	19	right	right	NN
18637	13148	20	to	to	TO
18637	13148	21	sue	sue	VB
18637	13148	22	in	in	IN
18637	13148	23	a	a	DT
18637	13148	24	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13148	25	court	court	NN
18637	13148	26	unless	unless	IN
18637	13148	27	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	13148	28	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	13148	29	by	by	IN
18637	13148	30	an	an	DT
18637	13148	31	act	act	NN
18637	13148	32	of	of	IN
18637	13148	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13148	34	.	.	.
18637	13149	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13149	2	610	610	CD
18637	13149	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13149	4	7	7	CD
18637	13149	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13149	6	.	.	.
18637	13150	1	32	32	CD
18637	13150	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13150	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	13150	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13150	5	.	.	.
18637	13151	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13151	2	611	611	CD
18637	13151	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13151	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13151	5	.	.	.
18637	13152	1	33	33	CD
18637	13152	2	.	.	.
18637	13153	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13153	2	612	612	CD
18637	13153	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13153	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13153	5	.	.	.
18637	13154	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13154	2	613	613	CD
18637	13154	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13154	4	12	12	CD
18637	13154	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	13154	6	.	.	.
18637	13155	1	657	657	CD
18637	13155	2	,	,	,
18637	13155	3	721	721	CD
18637	13155	4	-	-	SYM
18637	13155	5	722	722	CD
18637	13155	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13155	7	1838	1838	CD
18637	13155	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13155	9	.	.	.
18637	13156	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13156	2	614	614	CD
18637	13156	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13156	4	3	3	CD
18637	13156	5	How	how	WRB
18637	13156	6	.	.	.
18637	13157	1	236	236	CD
18637	13157	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13157	3	1845	1845	CD
18637	13157	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13157	5	.	.	.
18637	13158	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13158	2	615	615	CD
18637	13158	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13158	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13158	5	.	.	.
18637	13159	1	244	244	CD
18637	13159	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13159	3	245	245	CD
18637	13159	4	.	.	.
18637	13160	1	To	to	IN
18637	13160	2	these	these	DT
18637	13160	3	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	13160	4	assertions	assertion	NNS
18637	13160	5	of	of	IN
18637	13160	6	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	13160	7	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	13160	8	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	13160	9	Story	Story	NNP
18637	13160	10	and	and	CC
18637	13160	11	McLean	McLean	NNP
18637	13160	12	took	take	VBD
18637	13160	13	vigorous	vigorous	JJ
18637	13160	14	exception	exception	NN
18637	13160	15	.	.	.
18637	13161	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13161	2	denied	deny	VBD
18637	13161	3	the	the	DT
18637	13161	4	authority	authority	NN
18637	13161	5	of	of	IN
18637	13161	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13161	7	to	to	TO
18637	13161	8	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	13161	9	the	the	DT
18637	13161	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	13161	11	of	of	IN
18637	13161	12	power	power	NN
18637	13161	13	and	and	CC
18637	13161	14	vest	vest	VBD
18637	13161	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13161	16	in	in	IN
18637	13161	17	an	an	DT
18637	13161	18	executive	executive	JJ
18637	13161	19	official	official	NN
18637	13161	20	because	because	IN
18637	13161	21	"	"	``
18637	13161	22	the	the	DT
18637	13161	23	right	right	NN
18637	13161	24	to	to	TO
18637	13161	25	construe	construe	VB
18637	13161	26	the	the	DT
18637	13161	27	laws	law	NNS
18637	13161	28	in	in	IN
18637	13161	29	all	all	DT
18637	13161	30	matters	matter	NNS
18637	13161	31	of	of	IN
18637	13161	32	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	13161	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	13161	34	of	of	IN
18637	13161	35	the	the	DT
18637	13161	36	very	very	JJ
18637	13161	37	essence	essence	NN
18637	13161	38	of	of	IN
18637	13161	39	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13161	40	power	power	NN
18637	13161	41	.	.	.
18637	13161	42	"	"	''
18637	13162	1	In	in	IN
18637	13162	2	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13162	3	view	view	NN
18637	13162	4	the	the	DT
18637	13162	5	act	act	NN
18637	13162	6	as	as	IN
18637	13162	7	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	13162	8	violated	violate	VBD
18637	13162	9	the	the	DT
18637	13162	10	principle	principle	NN
18637	13162	11	of	of	IN
18637	13162	12	the	the	DT
18637	13162	13	separation	separation	NN
18637	13162	14	of	of	IN
18637	13162	15	powers	power	NNS
18637	13162	16	,	,	,
18637	13162	17	impaired	impair	VBD
18637	13162	18	the	the	DT
18637	13162	19	independence	independence	NN
18637	13162	20	of	of	IN
18637	13162	21	the	the	DT
18637	13162	22	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	13162	23	,	,	,
18637	13162	24	and	and	CC
18637	13162	25	merged	merge	VBD
18637	13162	26	the	the	DT
18637	13162	27	executive	executive	JJ
18637	13162	28	and	and	CC
18637	13162	29	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13162	30	department	department	NN
18637	13162	31	.	.	.
18637	13163	1	Dissent	Dissent	NNP
18637	13163	2	of	of	IN
18637	13163	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13163	4	McLean	McLean	NNP
18637	13163	5	,	,	,
18637	13163	6	pp	pp	NNP
18637	13163	7	.	.	.
18637	13164	1	264	264	CD
18637	13164	2	and	and	CC
18637	13164	3	following	follow	VBG
18637	13164	4	.	.	.
18637	13165	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13165	2	616	616	CD
18637	13165	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13165	4	8	8	CD
18637	13165	5	How	how	WRB
18637	13165	6	.	.	.
18637	13166	1	441	441	CD
18637	13166	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13166	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	13166	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13166	5	.	.	.
18637	13167	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13167	2	617	617	CD
18637	13167	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13167	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13167	5	.	.	.
18637	13168	1	449	449	CD
18637	13168	2	.	.	.
18637	13169	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13169	2	618	618	CD
18637	13169	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13169	4	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	13169	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13169	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13169	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13169	8	M.	M.	NNP
18637	13169	9	&	&	CC
18637	13169	10	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	13170	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13170	2	,	,	,
18637	13170	3	1	1	CD
18637	13170	4	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	13170	5	.	.	.
18637	13171	1	358	358	CD
18637	13171	2	,	,	,
18637	13171	3	374	374	CD
18637	13171	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13171	5	1862	1862	CD
18637	13171	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13171	7	;	;	:
18637	13171	8	Mayor	Mayor	NNP
18637	13171	9	of	of	IN
18637	13171	10	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	13171	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13171	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13171	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13171	14	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	13171	15	,	,	,
18637	13171	16	6	6	CD
18637	13171	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13171	18	.	.	.
18637	13172	1	247	247	CD
18637	13172	2	,	,	,
18637	13172	3	251	251	CD
18637	13172	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	13172	5	252	252	CD
18637	13172	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13172	7	1868	1868	CD
18637	13172	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13172	9	;	;	:
18637	13172	10	United	United	NNP
18637	13172	11	States	States	NNP
18637	13172	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13172	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	13172	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13172	15	Eckford	Eckford	NNP
18637	13172	16	,	,	,
18637	13172	17	6	6	CD
18637	13172	18	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13172	19	.	.	.
18637	13173	1	484	484	CD
18637	13173	2	,	,	,
18637	13173	3	488	488	CD
18637	13173	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13173	5	1868	1868	CD
18637	13173	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13173	7	;	;	:
18637	13173	8	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13173	9	parte	parte	NNP
18637	13173	10	Yerger	Yerger	NNP
18637	13173	11	,	,	,
18637	13173	12	8	8	CD
18637	13173	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13173	14	.	.	.
18637	13174	1	85	85	CD
18637	13174	2	,	,	,
18637	13174	3	104	104	CD
18637	13174	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13174	5	1868	1868	CD
18637	13174	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13174	7	;	;	:
18637	13174	8	case	case	NN
18637	13174	9	of	of	IN
18637	13174	10	the	the	DT
18637	13174	11	Sewing	Sewing	NNP
18637	13174	12	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	13174	13	Companies	Companies	NNPS
18637	13174	14	,	,	,
18637	13174	15	18	18	CD
18637	13174	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13174	17	.	.	.
18637	13175	1	553	553	CD
18637	13175	2	,	,	,
18637	13175	3	557	557	CD
18637	13175	4	-	-	SYM
18637	13175	5	558	558	CD
18637	13175	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13175	7	1874	1874	CD
18637	13175	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13175	9	;	;	:
18637	13175	10	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	13175	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13175	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13175	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13175	14	Gay	Gay	NNP
18637	13175	15	,	,	,
18637	13175	16	19	19	CD
18637	13175	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13175	18	.	.	.
18637	13176	1	81	81	CD
18637	13176	2	,	,	,
18637	13176	3	83	83	CD
18637	13176	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13176	5	1874	1874	CD
18637	13176	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13176	7	;	;	:
18637	13176	8	Gaines	Gaines	NNP
18637	13176	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	13176	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	12	Fuentes	Fuentes	NNP
18637	13176	13	,	,	,
18637	13176	14	92	92	CD
18637	13176	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13176	16	10	10	CD
18637	13176	17	,	,	,
18637	13176	18	18	18	CD
18637	13176	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13176	20	1876	1876	CD
18637	13176	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13176	22	;	;	:
18637	13176	23	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	13176	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	13176	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	27	United	United	NNP
18637	13176	28	States	States	NNP
18637	13176	29	,	,	,
18637	13176	30	137	137	CD
18637	13176	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13176	32	202	202	CD
18637	13176	33	,	,	,
18637	13176	34	211	211	CD
18637	13176	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13176	36	1890	1890	CD
18637	13176	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13176	38	;	;	:
18637	13176	39	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	13176	40	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	13176	42	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	43	Goldsmith	Goldsmith	NNP
18637	13176	44	,	,	,
18637	13176	45	147	147	CD
18637	13176	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13176	47	150	150	CD
18637	13176	48	,	,	,
18637	13176	49	158	158	CD
18637	13176	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13176	51	1893	1893	CD
18637	13176	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13176	53	;	;	:
18637	13176	54	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	13176	55	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	13176	56	Street	Street	NNP
18637	13176	57	Rail	Rail	NNP
18637	13176	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13176	59	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	13176	61	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	62	Wharton	Wharton	NNP
18637	13176	63	,	,	,
18637	13176	64	152	152	CD
18637	13176	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13176	66	252	252	CD
18637	13176	67	,	,	,
18637	13176	68	260	260	CD
18637	13176	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13176	70	1894	1894	CD
18637	13176	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13176	72	;	;	:
18637	13176	73	Plaquemines	Plaquemines	NNP
18637	13176	74	Tropical	Tropical	NNP
18637	13176	75	Fruit	Fruit	NNP
18637	13176	76	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13176	77	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	13176	79	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	80	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	13176	81	,	,	,
18637	13176	82	170	170	CD
18637	13176	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13176	84	511	511	CD
18637	13176	85	,	,	,
18637	13176	86	513	513	CD
18637	13176	87	-	-	SYM
18637	13176	88	521	521	CD
18637	13176	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13176	90	1898	1898	CD
18637	13176	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13176	92	;	;	:
18637	13176	93	Stevenson	Stevenson	NNP
18637	13176	94	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	13176	96	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	97	Fain	Fain	NNP
18637	13176	98	,	,	,
18637	13176	99	195	195	CD
18637	13176	100	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13176	101	165	165	CD
18637	13176	102	,	,	,
18637	13176	103	167	167	CD
18637	13176	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13176	105	1904	1904	CD
18637	13176	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13176	107	;	;	:
18637	13176	108	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	13176	109	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	110	v.	v.	IN
18637	13176	111	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	112	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	13176	113	,	,	,
18637	13176	114	201	201	CD
18637	13176	115	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13176	116	1	1	CD
18637	13176	117	,	,	,
18637	13176	118	24	24	CD
18637	13176	119	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13176	120	1906	1906	CD
18637	13176	121	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13176	122	;	;	:
18637	13176	123	Venner	Venner	NNP
18637	13176	124	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	125	v.	v.	IN
18637	13176	126	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	127	Great	Great	NNP
18637	13176	128	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	13176	129	R.	R.	NNP
18637	13176	130	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13176	131	,	,	,
18637	13176	132	209	209	CD
18637	13176	133	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13176	134	24	24	CD
18637	13176	135	,	,	,
18637	13176	136	35	35	CD
18637	13176	137	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13176	138	1908	1908	CD
18637	13176	139	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13176	140	;	;	:
18637	13176	141	Ladew	Ladew	NNP
18637	13176	142	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	143	v.	v.	IN
18637	13176	144	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	145	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	13176	146	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	13176	147	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13176	148	,	,	,
18637	13176	149	218	218	CD
18637	13176	150	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13176	151	357	357	CD
18637	13176	152	,	,	,
18637	13176	153	358	358	CD
18637	13176	154	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13176	155	1910	1910	CD
18637	13176	156	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13176	157	;	;	:
18637	13176	158	Kline	Kline	NNP
18637	13176	159	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	160	v.	v.	IN
18637	13176	161	_	_	NNP
18637	13176	162	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	13176	163	Construction	Construction	NNP
18637	13176	164	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13176	165	,	,	,
18637	13176	166	260	260	CD
18637	13176	167	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13176	168	226	226	CD
18637	13176	169	,	,	,
18637	13176	170	233	233	CD
18637	13176	171	,	,	,
18637	13176	172	234	234	CD
18637	13176	173	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13176	174	1922	1922	CD
18637	13176	175	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13176	176	.	.	.
18637	13177	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13177	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13177	3	also	also	RB
18637	13177	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13177	5	Lauf	Lauf	NNP
18637	13177	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13177	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13177	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13177	9	E.G.	E.G.	NNP
18637	13178	1	Shinner	Shinner	NNP
18637	13178	2	&	&	CC
18637	13178	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13178	4	,	,	,
18637	13178	5	303	303	CD
18637	13178	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13178	7	323	323	CD
18637	13178	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13178	9	1938	1938	CD
18637	13178	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13178	11	;	;	:
18637	13178	12	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	13178	13	Power	Power	NNP
18637	13178	14	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	13178	15	_	_	NNP
18637	13178	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	13178	17	_	_	NNP
18637	13178	18	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	13178	19	Power	Power	NNP
18637	13178	20	&	&	CC
18637	13178	21	Light	Light	NNP
18637	13178	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13178	23	,	,	,
18637	13178	24	307	307	CD
18637	13178	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13178	26	156	156	CD
18637	13178	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13178	28	1939	1939	CD
18637	13178	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13178	30	.	.	.
18637	13179	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13179	2	619	619	CD
18637	13179	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13179	4	Mayor	Mayor	NNP
18637	13179	5	of	of	IN
18637	13179	6	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	13179	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13179	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13179	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13179	10	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	13179	11	,	,	,
18637	13179	12	6	6	CD
18637	13179	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13179	14	.	.	.
18637	13180	1	247	247	CD
18637	13180	2	,	,	,
18637	13180	3	251	251	CD
18637	13180	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	13180	5	252	252	CD
18637	13180	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13180	7	1868	1868	CD
18637	13180	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13180	9	.	.	.
18637	13181	1	The	the	DT
18637	13181	2	rule	rule	NN
18637	13181	3	of	of	IN
18637	13181	4	Cary	Cary	NNP
18637	13181	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13181	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13181	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13181	8	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	13181	9	and	and	CC
18637	13181	10	Sheldon	Sheldon	NNP
18637	13181	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13181	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13181	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13181	14	Sill	Sill	NNP
18637	13181	15	was	be	VBD
18637	13181	16	restated	restate	VBN
18637	13181	17	with	with	IN
18637	13181	18	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	13181	19	many	many	JJ
18637	13181	20	years	year	NNS
18637	13181	21	later	later	RB
18637	13181	22	in	in	IN
18637	13181	23	Kline	Kline	NNP
18637	13181	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13181	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	13181	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13181	27	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	13181	28	Construction	Construction	NNP
18637	13181	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13181	30	,	,	,
18637	13181	31	260	260	CD
18637	13181	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13181	33	226	226	CD
18637	13181	34	,	,	,
18637	13181	35	233	233	CD
18637	13181	36	-	-	HYPH
18637	13181	37	234	234	CD
18637	13181	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13181	39	1922	1922	CD
18637	13181	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13181	41	,	,	,
18637	13181	42	where	where	WRB
18637	13181	43	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13181	44	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	13181	45	,	,	,
18637	13181	46	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	13181	47	for	for	IN
18637	13181	48	the	the	DT
18637	13181	49	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13181	50	,	,	,
18637	13181	51	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	13181	52	to	to	TO
18637	13181	53	say	say	VB
18637	13181	54	to	to	IN
18637	13181	55	article	article	NN
18637	13181	56	III	III	NNP
18637	13181	57	,	,	,
18637	13181	58	§§	§§	NNP
18637	13181	59	1	1	CD
18637	13181	60	and	and	CC
18637	13181	61	2	2	CD
18637	13181	62	:	:	:
18637	13181	63	"	"	``
18637	13181	64	The	the	DT
18637	13181	65	effect	effect	NN
18637	13181	66	of	of	IN
18637	13181	67	these	these	DT
18637	13181	68	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	13181	69	is	be	VBZ
18637	13181	70	not	not	RB
18637	13181	71	to	to	TO
18637	13181	72	vest	vest	VB
18637	13181	73	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13181	74	in	in	IN
18637	13181	75	the	the	DT
18637	13181	76	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	13181	77	courts	court	NNS
18637	13181	78	over	over	IN
18637	13181	79	the	the	DT
18637	13181	80	designated	designate	VBN
18637	13181	81	cases	case	NNS
18637	13181	82	and	and	CC
18637	13181	83	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	13181	84	but	but	CC
18637	13181	85	to	to	TO
18637	13181	86	delimit	delimit	VB
18637	13181	87	those	those	DT
18637	13181	88	in	in	IN
18637	13181	89	respect	respect	NN
18637	13181	90	of	of	IN
18637	13181	91	which	which	WDT
18637	13181	92	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13181	93	may	may	MD
18637	13181	94	confer	confer	VB
18637	13181	95	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13181	96	upon	upon	IN
18637	13181	97	such	such	JJ
18637	13181	98	courts	court	NNS
18637	13181	99	as	as	IN
18637	13181	100	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13181	101	creates	create	VBZ
18637	13181	102	.	.	.
18637	13182	1	Only	only	RB
18637	13182	2	the	the	DT
18637	13182	3	original	original	JJ
18637	13182	4	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13182	5	of	of	IN
18637	13182	6	the	the	DT
18637	13182	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13182	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13182	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	13182	10	derived	derive	VBN
18637	13182	11	directly	directly	RB
18637	13182	12	from	from	IN
18637	13182	13	the	the	DT
18637	13182	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13182	15	.	.	.
18637	13183	1	Every	every	DT
18637	13183	2	other	other	JJ
18637	13183	3	court	court	NN
18637	13183	4	created	create	VBN
18637	13183	5	by	by	IN
18637	13183	6	the	the	DT
18637	13183	7	general	general	JJ
18637	13183	8	government	government	NN
18637	13183	9	derives	derive	VBZ
18637	13183	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13183	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13183	12	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	13183	13	from	from	IN
18637	13183	14	the	the	DT
18637	13183	15	authority	authority	NN
18637	13183	16	of	of	IN
18637	13183	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13183	18	.	.	.
18637	13184	1	That	that	DT
18637	13184	2	body	body	NN
18637	13184	3	may	may	MD
18637	13184	4	give	give	VB
18637	13184	5	,	,	,
18637	13184	6	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	13184	7	or	or	CC
18637	13184	8	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	13184	9	such	such	JJ
18637	13184	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13184	11	at	at	IN
18637	13184	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13184	13	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	13184	14	,	,	,
18637	13184	15	provided	provide	VBN
18637	13184	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13184	17	be	be	VB
18637	13184	18	not	not	RB
18637	13184	19	extended	extend	VBN
18637	13184	20	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	13184	21	the	the	DT
18637	13184	22	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	13184	23	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	13184	24	by	by	IN
18637	13184	25	the	the	DT
18637	13184	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13184	27	.	.	.
18637	13185	1	*	*	NFP
18637	13185	2	*	*	NFP
18637	13185	3	*	*	NFP
18637	13185	4	The	the	DT
18637	13185	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13185	6	simply	simply	RB
18637	13185	7	gives	give	VBZ
18637	13185	8	to	to	IN
18637	13185	9	the	the	DT
18637	13185	10	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	13185	11	courts	court	NNS
18637	13185	12	the	the	DT
18637	13185	13	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	13185	14	to	to	TO
18637	13185	15	take	take	VB
18637	13185	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13185	17	in	in	IN
18637	13185	18	the	the	DT
18637	13185	19	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	13185	20	cases	case	NNS
18637	13185	21	,	,	,
18637	13185	22	but	but	CC
18637	13185	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13185	24	requires	require	VBZ
18637	13185	25	an	an	DT
18637	13185	26	act	act	NN
18637	13185	27	of	of	IN
18637	13185	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13185	29	to	to	TO
18637	13185	30	confer	confer	VB
18637	13185	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13185	32	.	.	.
18637	13186	1	*	*	NFP
18637	13186	2	*	*	NFP
18637	13186	3	*	*	NFP
18637	13186	4	And	and	CC
18637	13186	5	the	the	DT
18637	13186	6	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13186	7	having	have	VBG
18637	13186	8	been	be	VBN
18637	13186	9	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	13186	10	may	may	MD
18637	13186	11	,	,	,
18637	13186	12	at	at	IN
18637	13186	13	the	the	DT
18637	13186	14	will	will	NN
18637	13186	15	of	of	IN
18637	13186	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13186	17	,	,	,
18637	13186	18	be	be	VB
18637	13186	19	taken	take	VBN
18637	13186	20	away	away	RB
18637	13186	21	in	in	IN
18637	13186	22	whole	whole	NN
18637	13186	23	or	or	CC
18637	13186	24	in	in	IN
18637	13186	25	part	part	NN
18637	13186	26	;	;	:
18637	13186	27	and	and	CC
18637	13186	28	if	if	IN
18637	13186	29	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	13186	30	without	without	IN
18637	13186	31	a	a	DT
18637	13186	32	saving	save	VBG
18637	13186	33	clause	clause	NN
18637	13186	34	all	all	DT
18637	13186	35	pending	pende	VBG
18637	13186	36	cases	case	NNS
18637	13186	37	though	though	IN
18637	13186	38	cognizable	cognizable	JJ
18637	13186	39	when	when	WRB
18637	13186	40	commenced	commence	VBN
18637	13186	41	must	must	MD
18637	13186	42	fall	fall	VB
18637	13186	43	.	.	.
18637	13186	44	"	"	''
18637	13187	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13187	2	620	620	CD
18637	13187	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13187	4	56	56	CD
18637	13187	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13187	6	.	.	.
18637	13188	1	23	23	CD
18637	13188	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13188	3	1942	1942	CD
18637	13188	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13188	5	.	.	.
18637	13189	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13189	2	621	621	CD
18637	13189	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13189	4	319	319	CD
18637	13189	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13189	6	182	182	CD
18637	13189	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13189	8	1943	1943	CD
18637	13189	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13189	10	.	.	.
18637	13190	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13190	2	622	622	CD
18637	13190	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13190	4	321	321	CD
18637	13190	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13190	6	414	414	CD
18637	13190	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13190	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	13190	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13190	10	.	.	.
18637	13191	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13191	2	623	623	CD
18637	13191	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13191	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13191	5	.	.	.
18637	13192	1	468	468	CD
18637	13192	2	.	.	.
18637	13193	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13193	2	624	624	CD
18637	13193	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13193	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13193	5	See	See	NNP
18637	13193	6	infra	infra	NNP
18637	13193	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13193	8	,	,	,
18637	13193	9	pp	pp	NNP
18637	13193	10	.	.	.
18637	13194	1	515	515	CD
18637	13194	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13194	3	528	528	CD
18637	13194	4	.	.	.
18637	13195	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13195	2	625	625	CD
18637	13195	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13195	4	26	26	CD
18637	13195	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	13196	1	3653	3653	CD
18637	13196	2	.	.	.
18637	13197	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13197	2	626	626	CD
18637	13197	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13197	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13197	5	See	See	NNP
18637	13197	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13197	7	for	for	IN
18637	13197	8	example	example	NN
18637	13197	9	Snyder	Snyder	NNP
18637	13197	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13197	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	13197	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13197	13	Marks	Marks	NNP
18637	13197	14	,	,	,
18637	13197	15	109	109	CD
18637	13197	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13197	17	189	189	CD
18637	13197	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13197	19	1883	1883	CD
18637	13197	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13197	21	;	;	:
18637	13197	22	Cheatham	Cheatham	NNP
18637	13197	23	_	_	NNP
18637	13197	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	13197	25	_	_	NNP
18637	13197	26	United	United	NNP
18637	13197	27	States	States	NNP
18637	13197	28	,	,	,
18637	13197	29	92	92	CD
18637	13197	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13197	31	85	85	CD
18637	13197	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13197	33	1875	1875	CD
18637	13197	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13197	35	;	;	:
18637	13197	36	Shelton	Shelton	NNP
18637	13197	37	_	_	NNP
18637	13197	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	13197	39	_	_	NNP
18637	13197	40	Platt	Platt	NNP
18637	13197	41	,	,	,
18637	13197	42	139	139	CD
18637	13197	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13197	44	591	591	CD
18637	13197	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13197	46	1891	1891	CD
18637	13197	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13197	48	;	;	:
18637	13197	49	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	13197	50	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	13197	51	Whaling	Whaling	NNP
18637	13197	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13197	53	_	_	NNP
18637	13197	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	13197	55	_	_	NNP
18637	13197	56	United	United	NNP
18637	13197	57	States	States	NNP
18637	13197	58	,	,	,
18637	13197	59	187	187	CD
18637	13197	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13197	61	447	447	CD
18637	13197	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13197	63	1903	1903	CD
18637	13197	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13197	65	;	;	:
18637	13197	66	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	13197	67	_	_	NNP
18637	13197	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	13197	69	_	_	NNP
18637	13197	70	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	13197	71	,	,	,
18637	13197	72	240	240	CD
18637	13197	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13197	74	118	118	CD
18637	13197	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13197	76	1916	1916	CD
18637	13197	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13197	78	.	.	.
18637	13198	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13198	2	627	627	CD
18637	13198	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13198	4	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	13198	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13198	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13198	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13198	8	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	13198	9	,	,	,
18637	13198	10	240	240	CD
18637	13198	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13198	12	122	122	CD
18637	13198	13	,	,	,
18637	13198	14	126	126	CD
18637	13198	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13198	16	1916	1916	CD
18637	13198	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13198	18	.	.	.
18637	13199	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13199	2	628	628	CD
18637	13199	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13199	4	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	13199	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13199	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13199	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13199	8	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	13199	9	,	,	,
18637	13199	10	259	259	CD
18637	13199	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13199	12	44	44	CD
18637	13199	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13199	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	13199	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13199	16	;	;	:
18637	13199	17	Lipke	Lipke	NNP
18637	13199	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13199	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	13199	20	_	_	NNP
18637	13199	21	Lederer	Lederer	NNP
18637	13199	22	,	,	,
18637	13199	23	259	259	CD
18637	13199	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13199	25	557	557	CD
18637	13199	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13199	27	1922	1922	CD
18637	13199	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13199	29	;	;	:
18637	13199	30	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	13199	31	_	_	NNP
18637	13199	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	13199	33	_	_	NNP
18637	13199	34	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	13199	35	Nut	Nut	NNP
18637	13199	36	Margarine	Margarine	NNP
18637	13199	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13199	38	,	,	,
18637	13199	39	284	284	CD
18637	13199	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13199	41	498	498	CD
18637	13199	42	,	,	,
18637	13199	43	509	509	CD
18637	13199	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13199	45	1932	1932	CD
18637	13199	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13199	47	.	.	.
18637	13200	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13200	2	629	629	CD
18637	13200	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13200	4	Enjoining	enjoin	VBG
18637	13200	5	the	the	DT
18637	13200	6	Assessment	Assessment	NNP
18637	13200	7	and	and	CC
18637	13200	8	Collection	Collection	NNP
18637	13200	9	of	of	IN
18637	13200	10	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	13200	11	Taxes	Taxes	NNPS
18637	13200	12	Despite	despite	IN
18637	13200	13	Statutory	Statutory	NNP
18637	13200	14	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	13200	15	,	,	,
18637	13200	16	49	49	CD
18637	13200	17	Harv	Harv	NNP
18637	13200	18	.	.	.
18637	13201	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	13201	2	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	13202	1	109	109	CD
18637	13202	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13202	3	1935	1935	CD
18637	13202	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13202	5	.	.	.
18637	13203	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13203	2	630	630	CD
18637	13203	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13203	4	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	13203	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13203	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13203	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13203	8	Regents	Regents	NNPS
18637	13203	9	of	of	IN
18637	13203	10	University	University	NNP
18637	13203	11	System	System	NNP
18637	13203	12	of	of	IN
18637	13203	13	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	13203	14	,	,	,
18637	13203	15	304	304	CD
18637	13203	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13203	17	439	439	CD
18637	13203	18	,	,	,
18637	13203	19	445	445	CD
18637	13203	20	-	-	SYM
18637	13203	21	449	449	CD
18637	13203	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13203	23	1938	1938	CD
18637	13203	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13203	25	.	.	.
18637	13204	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13204	2	631	631	CD
18637	13204	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13204	4	47	47	CD
18637	13204	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13204	6	.	.	.
18637	13205	1	70	70	CD
18637	13205	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13205	3	1932	1932	CD
18637	13205	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13205	5	.	.	.
18637	13206	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13206	2	632	632	CD
18637	13206	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13206	4	Lauf	Lauf	NNP
18637	13206	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13206	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13206	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13206	8	E.G.	E.G.	NNP
18637	13207	1	Shinner	Shinner	NNP
18637	13207	2	&	&	CC
18637	13207	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13207	4	,	,	,
18637	13207	5	303	303	CD
18637	13207	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13207	7	323	323	CD
18637	13207	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13207	9	1938	1938	CD
18637	13207	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13207	11	;	;	:
18637	13207	12	New	New	NNP
18637	13207	13	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	13207	14	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	13207	15	_	_	NNP
18637	13207	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	13207	17	_	_	NNP
18637	13207	18	Sanitary	Sanitary	NNP
18637	13207	19	Grocery	Grocery	NNP
18637	13207	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13207	21	,	,	,
18637	13207	22	303	303	CD
18637	13207	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13207	24	552	552	CD
18637	13207	25	.	.	.
18637	13208	1	562	562	CD
18637	13208	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13208	3	563	563	CD
18637	13208	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13208	5	1838	1838	CD
18637	13208	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13208	7	;	;	:
18637	13208	8	Milk	Milk	NNP
18637	13208	9	Wagon	Wagon	NNP
18637	13208	10	Drivers	Drivers	NNPS
18637	13208	11	'	'	POS
18637	13208	12	Union	Union	NNP
18637	13208	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13208	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	13208	15	_	_	NNP
18637	13208	16	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	13208	17	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	13208	18	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	13208	19	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	13208	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13208	21	,	,	,
18637	13208	22	311	311	CD
18637	13208	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13208	24	91	91	CD
18637	13208	25	,	,	,
18637	13208	26	100	100	CD
18637	13208	27	-	-	SYM
18637	13208	28	103	103	CD
18637	13208	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13208	30	1940	1940	CD
18637	13208	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13208	32	.	.	.
18637	13209	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13209	2	633	633	CD
18637	13209	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13209	4	330	330	CD
18637	13209	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13209	6	258	258	CD
18637	13209	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13209	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	13209	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13209	10	.	.	.
18637	13210	1	Virginian	Virginian	NNP
18637	13210	2	R.	R.	NNP
18637	13210	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13210	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13210	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	13210	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13210	7	System	System	NNP
18637	13210	8	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	13210	9	No	No	NNP
18637	13210	10	.	.	.
18637	13211	1	40	40	CD
18637	13211	2	,	,	,
18637	13211	3	300	300	CD
18637	13211	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13211	5	515	515	CD
18637	13211	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13211	7	1937	1937	CD
18637	13211	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13211	9	,	,	,
18637	13211	10	in	in	IN
18637	13211	11	some	some	DT
18637	13211	12	ways	way	NNS
18637	13211	13	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	13211	14	an	an	DT
18637	13211	15	exception	exception	NN
18637	13211	16	to	to	IN
18637	13211	17	section	section	NN
18637	13211	18	9	9	CD
18637	13211	19	of	of	IN
18637	13211	20	the	the	DT
18637	13211	21	statute	statute	NN
18637	13211	22	by	by	IN
18637	13211	23	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	13211	24	a	a	DT
18637	13211	25	mandatory	mandatory	JJ
18637	13211	26	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	13211	27	issued	issue	VBN
18637	13211	28	against	against	IN
18637	13211	29	an	an	DT
18637	13211	30	employer	employer	NN
18637	13211	31	on	on	IN
18637	13211	32	the	the	DT
18637	13211	33	petition	petition	NN
18637	13211	34	of	of	IN
18637	13211	35	employees	employee	NNS
18637	13211	36	on	on	IN
18637	13211	37	the	the	DT
18637	13211	38	ground	ground	NN
18637	13211	39	that	that	IN
18637	13211	40	the	the	DT
18637	13211	41	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	13211	42	of	of	IN
18637	13211	43	section	section	NN
18637	13211	44	9	9	CD
18637	13211	45	does	do	VBZ
18637	13211	46	not	not	RB
18637	13211	47	include	include	VB
18637	13211	48	mandatory	mandatory	JJ
18637	13211	49	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	13211	50	,	,	,
18637	13211	51	but	but	CC
18637	13211	52	"	"	``
18637	13211	53	blanket	blanket	NN
18637	13211	54	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	13211	55	which	which	WDT
18637	13211	56	are	be	VBP
18637	13211	57	usually	usually	RB
18637	13211	58	prohibitory	prohibitory	JJ
18637	13211	59	in	in	IN
18637	13211	60	form	form	NN
18637	13211	61	.	.	.
18637	13211	62	"	"	''
18637	13212	1	For	for	IN
18637	13212	2	other	other	JJ
18637	13212	3	acts	act	NNS
18637	13212	4	of	of	IN
18637	13212	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13212	6	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	13212	7	the	the	DT
18637	13212	8	power	power	NN
18637	13212	9	of	of	IN
18637	13212	10	the	the	DT
18637	13212	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13212	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	13212	13	to	to	TO
18637	13212	14	issue	issue	VB
18637	13212	15	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	13212	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13212	17	see	see	VBP
18637	13212	18	infra	infra	NNP
18637	13212	19	_	_	NNP
18637	13212	20	,	,	,
18637	13212	21	pp	pp	NNP
18637	13212	22	.	.	.
18637	13213	1	523	523	CD
18637	13213	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13213	3	525	525	CD
18637	13213	4	.	.	.
18637	13214	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13214	2	634	634	CD
18637	13214	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13214	4	1	1	CD
18637	13214	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	13214	6	.	.	.
18637	13215	1	304	304	CD
18637	13215	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13215	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	13215	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13215	5	.	.	.
18637	13216	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13216	2	635	635	CD
18637	13216	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13216	4	18	18	CD
18637	13216	5	How	how	WRB
18637	13216	6	.	.	.
18637	13217	1	272	272	CD
18637	13217	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13217	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	13217	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13217	5	.	.	.
18637	13218	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13218	2	636	636	CD
18637	13218	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13218	4	285	285	CD
18637	13218	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13218	6	22	22	CD
18637	13218	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13218	8	1932	1932	CD
18637	13218	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13218	10	.	.	.
18637	13219	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13219	2	637	637	CD
18637	13219	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13219	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13219	5	56	56	CD
18637	13219	6	-	-	SYM
18637	13219	7	57	57	CD
18637	13219	8	.	.	.
18637	13220	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13220	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	13220	3	.	.	.
18637	13220	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13220	5	,	,	,
18637	13220	6	however	however	RB
18637	13220	7	,	,	,
18637	13220	8	Shields	Shields	NNP
18637	13220	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13220	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	13220	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13220	12	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	13220	13	,	,	,
18637	13220	14	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
18637	13220	15	R.	R.	NNP
18637	13220	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13220	17	,	,	,
18637	13220	18	305	305	CD
18637	13220	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13220	20	185	185	CD
18637	13220	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13220	22	1938	1938	CD
18637	13220	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13220	24	.	.	.
18637	13221	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13221	2	638	638	CD
18637	13221	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13221	4	Mayor	Mayor	NNP
18637	13221	5	of	of	IN
18637	13221	6	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	13221	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13221	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13221	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13221	10	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	13221	11	,	,	,
18637	13221	12	6	6	CD
18637	13221	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13221	14	.	.	.
18637	13222	1	247	247	CD
18637	13222	2	,	,	,
18637	13222	3	252	252	CD
18637	13222	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13222	5	1868	1868	CD
18637	13222	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13222	7	;	;	:
18637	13222	8	Kline	Kline	NNP
18637	13222	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13222	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	13222	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13222	12	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	13222	13	Construction	Construction	NNP
18637	13222	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13222	15	,	,	,
18637	13222	16	260	260	CD
18637	13222	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13222	18	226	226	CD
18637	13222	19	,	,	,
18637	13222	20	233	233	CD
18637	13222	21	,	,	,
18637	13222	22	234	234	CD
18637	13222	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13222	24	1922	1922	CD
18637	13222	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13222	26	.	.	.
18637	13223	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13223	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13223	3	also	also	RB
18637	13223	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13223	5	Hodgson	Hodgson	NNP
18637	13223	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13223	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13223	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13223	9	Bowerbank	Bowerbank	NNP
18637	13223	10	,	,	,
18637	13223	11	5	5	CD
18637	13223	12	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13223	13	.	.	.
18637	13224	1	303	303	CD
18637	13224	2	,	,	,
18637	13224	3	304	304	CD
18637	13224	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13224	5	1809	1809	CD
18637	13224	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13224	7	where	where	WRB
18637	13224	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	13224	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13224	10	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	13224	11	disposed	dispose	VBD
18637	13224	12	of	of	IN
18637	13224	13	the	the	DT
18637	13224	14	effort	effort	NN
18637	13224	15	of	of	IN
18637	13224	16	British	british	JJ
18637	13224	17	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	13224	18	to	to	TO
18637	13224	19	docket	docket	VB
18637	13224	20	a	a	DT
18637	13224	21	case	case	NN
18637	13224	22	in	in	IN
18637	13224	23	a	a	DT
18637	13224	24	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	13224	25	court	court	NN
18637	13224	26	,	,	,
18637	13224	27	saying	say	VBG
18637	13224	28	,	,	,
18637	13224	29	"	"	``
18637	13224	30	turn	turn	VB
18637	13224	31	to	to	IN
18637	13224	32	the	the	DT
18637	13224	33	article	article	NN
18637	13224	34	of	of	IN
18637	13224	35	the	the	DT
18637	13224	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13224	37	of	of	IN
18637	13224	38	the	the	DT
18637	13224	39	United	United	NNP
18637	13224	40	States	States	NNP
18637	13224	41	,	,	,
18637	13224	42	for	for	IN
18637	13224	43	the	the	DT
18637	13224	44	statute	statute	NN
18637	13224	45	can	can	MD
18637	13224	46	not	not	RB
18637	13224	47	extend	extend	VB
18637	13224	48	the	the	DT
18637	13224	49	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13224	50	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	13224	51	the	the	DT
18637	13224	52	limits	limit	NNS
18637	13224	53	of	of	IN
18637	13224	54	the	the	DT
18637	13224	55	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13224	56	.	.	.
18637	13224	57	"	"	''
18637	13225	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13225	2	639	639	CD
18637	13225	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13225	4	Hayburn	Hayburn	NNP
18637	13225	5	's	's	POS
18637	13225	6	Case	Case	NNP
18637	13225	7	,	,	,
18637	13225	8	2	2	CD
18637	13225	9	Dall	dall	NN
18637	13225	10	.	.	.
18637	13226	1	409	409	CD
18637	13226	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13226	3	1792	1792	CD
18637	13226	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13226	5	.	.	.
18637	13227	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13227	2	640	640	CD
18637	13227	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13227	4	United	United	NNP
18637	13227	5	States	States	NNP
18637	13227	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13227	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13227	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13227	9	Ferriera	Ferriera	NNP
18637	13227	10	,	,	,
18637	13227	11	13	13	CD
18637	13227	12	How	how	WRB
18637	13227	13	.	.	.
18637	13228	1	40	40	CD
18637	13228	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13228	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	13228	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13228	5	;	;	:
18637	13228	6	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	13228	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13228	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13228	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13228	10	United	United	NNP
18637	13228	11	States	States	NNP
18637	13228	12	,	,	,
18637	13228	13	117	117	CD
18637	13228	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13228	15	697	697	CD
18637	13228	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13228	17	1864	1864	CD
18637	13228	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13228	19	;	;	:
18637	13228	20	Muskrat	Muskrat	NNP
18637	13228	21	_	_	NNP
18637	13228	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	13228	23	_	_	NNP
18637	13228	24	United	United	NNP
18637	13228	25	States	States	NNP
18637	13228	26	,	,	,
18637	13228	27	219	219	CD
18637	13228	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13228	29	346	346	CD
18637	13228	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13228	31	1911	1911	CD
18637	13228	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13228	33	.	.	.
18637	13229	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13229	2	641	641	CD
18637	13229	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13229	4	In	in	IN
18637	13229	5	addition	addition	NN
18637	13229	6	to	to	IN
18637	13229	7	the	the	DT
18637	13229	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	13229	9	cited	cite	VBN
18637	13229	10	in	in	IN
18637	13229	11	note	note	NN
18637	13229	12	3[Transcriber	3[Transcriber	NNP
18637	13229	13	's	's	POS
18637	13229	14	Note	note	NN
18637	13229	15	:	:	:
18637	13229	16	Reference	reference	NN
18637	13229	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	13229	18	to	to	TO
18637	13229	19	footnote	footnote	VB
18637	13229	20	640	640	CD
18637	13229	21	above	above	RB
18637	13229	22	.	.	.
18637	13230	1	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13230	2	,	,	,
18637	13230	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13230	4	see	see	VBP
18637	13230	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13230	6	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	13230	7	&	&	CC
18637	13230	8	S.	S.	NNP
18637	13230	9	Air	Air	NNP
18637	13230	10	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	13230	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13230	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13230	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13230	14	Waterman	Waterman	NNP
18637	13230	15	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	13230	16	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	13230	17	,	,	,
18637	13230	18	333	333	CD
18637	13230	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13230	20	103	103	CD
18637	13230	21	,	,	,
18637	13230	22	113	113	CD
18637	13230	23	-	-	SYM
18637	13230	24	114	114	CD
18637	13230	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13230	26	1948	1948	CD
18637	13230	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13230	28	.	.	.
18637	13231	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13231	2	642	642	CD
18637	13231	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13231	4	In	in	IN
18637	13231	5	addition	addition	NN
18637	13231	6	to	to	IN
18637	13231	7	the	the	DT
18637	13231	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	13231	9	cited	cite	VBN
18637	13231	10	in	in	IN
18637	13231	11	notes	note	NNS
18637	13231	12	2	2	CD
18637	13231	13	,	,	,
18637	13231	14	3	3	CD
18637	13231	15	,	,	,
18637	13231	16	and	and	CC
18637	13231	17	4[Transcriber	4[Transcriber	NNP
18637	13231	18	's	's	POS
18637	13231	19	Note	note	NN
18637	13231	20	:	:	:
18637	13231	21	Reference	reference	NN
18637	13231	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	13231	23	to	to	IN
18637	13231	24	footnotes	footnote	VBZ
18637	13231	25	639	639	CD
18637	13231	26	,	,	,
18637	13231	27	640	640	CD
18637	13231	28	,	,	,
18637	13231	29	and	and	CC
18637	13231	30	641	641	CD
18637	13231	31	above	above	RB
18637	13231	32	.	.	.
18637	13231	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13232	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13232	2	see	see	VBP
18637	13232	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13232	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	13232	5	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	13232	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	13232	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13232	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13232	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13232	10	General	General	NNP
18637	13232	11	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	13232	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13232	13	,	,	,
18637	13232	14	281	281	CD
18637	13232	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13232	16	464	464	CD
18637	13232	17	,	,	,
18637	13232	18	469	469	CD
18637	13232	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13232	20	1930	1930	CD
18637	13232	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13232	22	;	;	:
18637	13232	23	Postum	Postum	NNP
18637	13232	24	Cereal	Cereal	NNP
18637	13232	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13232	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13232	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	13232	28	_	_	NNP
18637	13232	29	California	California	NNP
18637	13232	30	Fig	Fig	NNP
18637	13232	31	Nut	Nut	NNP
18637	13232	32	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13232	33	,	,	,
18637	13232	34	272	272	CD
18637	13232	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13232	36	693	693	CD
18637	13232	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13232	38	1927	1927	CD
18637	13232	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13232	40	;	;	:
18637	13232	41	Keller	Keller	NNP
18637	13232	42	_	_	NNP
18637	13232	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	13232	44	_	_	NNP
18637	13232	45	Potomac	Potomac	NNP
18637	13232	46	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	13232	47	Power	Power	NNP
18637	13232	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13232	49	,	,	,
18637	13232	50	261	261	CD
18637	13232	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13232	52	428	428	CD
18637	13232	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13232	54	1923	1923	CD
18637	13232	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13232	56	.	.	.
18637	13233	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13233	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13233	3	also	also	RB
18637	13233	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13233	5	the	the	DT
18637	13233	6	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	13233	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	13233	8	of	of	IN
18637	13233	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13233	10	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	13233	11	in	in	IN
18637	13233	12	Yakus	Yakus	NNP
18637	13233	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13233	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	13233	15	_	_	NNP
18637	13233	16	United	United	NNP
18637	13233	17	States	States	NNP
18637	13233	18	,	,	,
18637	13233	19	321	321	CD
18637	13233	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13233	21	414	414	CD
18637	13233	22	,	,	,
18637	13233	23	468	468	CD
18637	13233	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13233	25	1944	1944	CD
18637	13233	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13233	27	.	.	.
18637	13234	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13234	2	643	643	CD
18637	13234	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13234	4	Tutun	Tutun	NNP
18637	13234	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13234	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13234	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13234	8	United	United	NNP
18637	13234	9	States	States	NNP
18637	13234	10	,	,	,
18637	13234	11	270	270	CD
18637	13234	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13234	13	568	568	CD
18637	13234	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13234	15	1926	1926	CD
18637	13234	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13234	17	,	,	,
18637	13234	18	where	where	WRB
18637	13234	19	the	the	DT
18637	13234	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13234	21	held	hold	VBD
18637	13234	22	that	that	IN
18637	13234	23	the	the	DT
18637	13234	24	United	United	NNP
18637	13234	25	States	States	NNP
18637	13234	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	13234	27	always	always	RB
18637	13234	28	a	a	DT
18637	13234	29	possible	possible	JJ
18637	13234	30	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	13234	31	party	party	NN
18637	13234	32	to	to	IN
18637	13234	33	a	a	DT
18637	13234	34	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	13234	35	petition	petition	NN
18637	13234	36	.	.	.
18637	13235	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13235	2	644	644	CD
18637	13235	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13235	4	Fong	Fong	NNP
18637	13235	5	Yue	Yue	NNP
18637	13235	6	Ting	Ting	NNP
18637	13235	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13235	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13235	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13235	10	United	United	NNP
18637	13235	11	States	States	NNP
18637	13235	12	,	,	,
18637	13235	13	149	149	CD
18637	13235	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13235	15	698	698	CD
18637	13235	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13235	17	1893	1893	CD
18637	13235	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13235	19	,	,	,
18637	13235	20	where	where	WRB
18637	13235	21	the	the	DT
18637	13235	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13235	23	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	13235	24	an	an	DT
18637	13235	25	act	act	NN
18637	13235	26	of	of	IN
18637	13235	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13235	28	requiring	require	VBG
18637	13235	29	the	the	DT
18637	13235	30	registration	registration	NN
18637	13235	31	of	of	IN
18637	13235	32	Chinese	Chinese	NNP
18637	13235	33	and	and	CC
18637	13235	34	creating	create	VBG
18637	13235	35	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	13235	36	for	for	IN
18637	13235	37	the	the	DT
18637	13235	38	expulsion	expulsion	NN
18637	13235	39	of	of	IN
18637	13235	40	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	13235	41	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	13235	42	within	within	IN
18637	13235	43	the	the	DT
18637	13235	44	country	country	NN
18637	13235	45	and	and	CC
18637	13235	46	for	for	IN
18637	13235	47	the	the	DT
18637	13235	48	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	13235	49	of	of	IN
18637	13235	50	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	13235	51	to	to	IN
18637	13235	52	those	those	DT
18637	13235	53	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13235	54	to	to	TO
18637	13235	55	remain	remain	VB
18637	13235	56	.	.	.
18637	13236	1	The	the	DT
18637	13236	2	act	act	NN
18637	13236	3	provided	provide	VBN
18637	13236	4	for	for	IN
18637	13236	5	special	special	JJ
18637	13236	6	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13236	7	in	in	IN
18637	13236	8	such	such	JJ
18637	13236	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	13236	10	and	and	CC
18637	13236	11	prescribed	prescribe	VBD
18637	13236	12	the	the	DT
18637	13236	13	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	13236	14	the	the	DT
18637	13236	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	13236	16	were	be	VBD
18637	13236	17	to	to	TO
18637	13236	18	receive	receive	VB
18637	13236	19	and	and	CC
18637	13236	20	the	the	DT
18637	13236	21	weight	weight	NN
18637	13236	22	to	to	TO
18637	13236	23	be	be	VB
18637	13236	24	attached	attach	VBN
18637	13236	25	to	to	IN
18637	13236	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13236	27	.	.	.
18637	13237	1	The	the	DT
18637	13237	2	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	13237	3	was	be	VBD
18637	13237	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	13237	5	to	to	TO
18637	13237	6	contain	contain	VB
18637	13237	7	all	all	PDT
18637	13237	8	the	the	DT
18637	13237	9	elements	element	NNS
18637	13237	10	of	of	IN
18637	13237	11	a	a	DT
18637	13237	12	case--"a	case--"a	JJS
18637	13237	13	complainant	complainant	NN
18637	13237	14	,	,	,
18637	13237	15	a	a	DT
18637	13237	16	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13237	17	,	,	,
18637	13237	18	and	and	CC
18637	13237	19	a	a	DT
18637	13237	20	judge--_actor	judge--_actor	NNP
18637	13237	21	_	_	NNP
18637	13237	22	,	,	,
18637	13237	23	_	_	NNP
18637	13237	24	reus	reus	NNP
18637	13237	25	_	_	NNP
18637	13237	26	,	,	,
18637	13237	27	_	_	NNP
18637	13237	28	et	et	NNP
18637	13237	29	judex	judex	NNP
18637	13237	30	_	_	NNP
18637	13237	31	.	.	.
18637	13237	32	"	"	''
18637	13238	1	pp	pp	NNP
18637	13238	2	.	.	.
18637	13239	1	728	728	CD
18637	13239	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13239	3	729	729	CD
18637	13239	4	.	.	.
18637	13240	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13240	2	645	645	CD
18637	13240	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13240	4	La	La	NNP
18637	13240	5	Abra	Abra	NNP
18637	13240	6	Silver	Silver	NNP
18637	13240	7	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	13240	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13240	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13240	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	13240	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13240	12	United	United	NNP
18637	13240	13	States	States	NNP
18637	13240	14	,	,	,
18637	13240	15	175	175	CD
18637	13240	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13240	17	423	423	CD
18637	13240	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13240	19	1899	1899	CD
18637	13240	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13240	21	.	.	.
18637	13241	1	Here	here	RB
18637	13241	2	the	the	DT
18637	13241	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13241	4	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	13241	5	an	an	DT
18637	13241	6	act	act	NN
18637	13241	7	of	of	IN
18637	13241	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13241	9	which	which	WDT
18637	13241	10	directed	direct	VBD
18637	13241	11	the	the	DT
18637	13241	12	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	13241	13	General	General	NNP
18637	13241	14	to	to	TO
18637	13241	15	bring	bring	VB
18637	13241	16	a	a	DT
18637	13241	17	suit	suit	NN
18637	13241	18	on	on	IN
18637	13241	19	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	13241	20	of	of	IN
18637	13241	21	the	the	DT
18637	13241	22	United	United	NNP
18637	13241	23	States	States	NNP
18637	13241	24	against	against	IN
18637	13241	25	the	the	DT
18637	13241	26	appellants	appellant	NNS
18637	13241	27	to	to	TO
18637	13241	28	determine	determine	VB
18637	13241	29	whether	whether	IN
18637	13241	30	an	an	DT
18637	13241	31	award	award	NN
18637	13241	32	made	make	VBN
18637	13241	33	by	by	IN
18637	13241	34	an	an	DT
18637	13241	35	international	international	JJ
18637	13241	36	claims	claim	NNS
18637	13241	37	commission	commission	NN
18637	13241	38	was	be	VBD
18637	13241	39	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13241	40	by	by	IN
18637	13241	41	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	13241	42	.	.	.
18637	13242	1	The	the	DT
18637	13242	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13242	3	of	of	IN
18637	13242	4	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	13242	5	was	be	VBD
18637	13242	6	vested	vest	VBN
18637	13242	7	with	with	IN
18637	13242	8	full	full	JJ
18637	13242	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13242	10	with	with	IN
18637	13242	11	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	13242	12	to	to	IN
18637	13242	13	the	the	DT
18637	13242	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13242	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13242	16	to	to	TO
18637	13242	17	hear	hear	VB
18637	13242	18	the	the	DT
18637	13242	19	case	case	NN
18637	13242	20	,	,	,
18637	13242	21	decide	decide	VB
18637	13242	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13242	23	,	,	,
18637	13242	24	to	to	TO
18637	13242	25	issue	issue	VB
18637	13242	26	all	all	DT
18637	13242	27	proper	proper	JJ
18637	13242	28	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	13242	29	therein	therein	RB
18637	13242	30	,	,	,
18637	13242	31	and	and	CC
18637	13242	32	to	to	TO
18637	13242	33	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	13242	34	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13242	35	by	by	IN
18637	13242	36	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	13242	37	.	.	.
18637	13243	1	The	the	DT
18637	13243	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13243	3	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	13243	4	the	the	DT
18637	13243	5	money	money	NN
18637	13243	6	received	receive	VBN
18637	13243	7	by	by	IN
18637	13243	8	the	the	DT
18637	13243	9	United	United	NNP
18637	13243	10	States	States	NNP
18637	13243	11	from	from	IN
18637	13243	12	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	13243	13	as	as	IN
18637	13243	14	property	property	NN
18637	13243	15	of	of	IN
18637	13243	16	the	the	DT
18637	13243	17	United	United	NNP
18637	13243	18	States	States	NNP
18637	13243	19	.	.	.
18637	13244	1	This	this	DT
18637	13244	2	together	together	RB
18637	13244	3	with	with	IN
18637	13244	4	the	the	DT
18637	13244	5	interest	interest	NN
18637	13244	6	of	of	IN
18637	13244	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13244	8	in	in	IN
18637	13244	9	national	national	JJ
18637	13244	10	honor	honor	NN
18637	13244	11	in	in	IN
18637	13244	12	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	13244	13	with	with	IN
18637	13244	14	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	13244	15	was	be	VBD
18637	13244	16	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	13244	17	to	to	TO
18637	13244	18	enable	enable	VB
18637	13244	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13244	20	to	to	TO
18637	13244	21	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	13244	22	a	a	DT
18637	13244	23	suit	suit	NN
18637	13244	24	for	for	IN
18637	13244	25	the	the	DT
18637	13244	26	decision	decision	NN
18637	13244	27	of	of	IN
18637	13244	28	a	a	DT
18637	13244	29	question	question	NN
18637	13244	30	"	"	``
18637	13244	31	peculiarly	peculiarly	RB
18637	13244	32	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13244	33	in	in	IN
18637	13244	34	nature	nature	NN
18637	13244	35	.	.	.
18637	13244	36	"	"	''
18637	13245	1	pp	pp	NNP
18637	13245	2	.	.	.
18637	13246	1	458	458	CD
18637	13246	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13246	3	459	459	CD
18637	13246	4	.	.	.
18637	13247	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13247	2	646	646	CD
18637	13247	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13247	4	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	13247	5	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	13247	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13247	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13247	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13247	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13247	10	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	13247	11	,	,	,
18637	13247	12	244	244	CD
18637	13247	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13247	14	205	205	CD
18637	13247	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13247	16	1917	1917	CD
18637	13247	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13247	18	.	.	.
18637	13248	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13248	2	647	647	CD
18637	13248	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13248	4	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	13248	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13248	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13248	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13248	8	Carryl	Carryl	NNP
18637	13248	9	,	,	,
18637	13248	10	20	20	CD
18637	13248	11	How	how	WRB
18637	13248	12	.	.	.
18637	13249	1	583	583	CD
18637	13249	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13249	3	1858	1858	CD
18637	13249	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13249	5	.	.	.
18637	13250	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13250	2	648	648	CD
18637	13250	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13250	4	1	1	CD
18637	13250	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	13250	6	.	.	.
18637	13251	1	304	304	CD
18637	13251	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13251	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	13251	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13251	5	.	.	.
18637	13252	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13252	2	649	649	CD
18637	13252	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13252	4	6	6	CD
18637	13252	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	13252	6	.	.	.
18637	13253	1	264	264	CD
18637	13253	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13253	3	1821	1821	CD
18637	13253	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13253	5	.	.	.
18637	13254	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13254	2	650	650	CD
18637	13254	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13254	4	21	21	CD
18637	13254	5	How	how	WRB
18637	13254	6	.	.	.
18637	13255	1	506	506	CD
18637	13255	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13255	3	1859	1859	CD
18637	13255	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13255	5	.	.	.
18637	13256	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13256	2	651	651	CD
18637	13256	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13256	4	For	for	IN
18637	13256	5	a	a	DT
18637	13256	6	full	full	JJ
18637	13256	7	account	account	NN
18637	13256	8	of	of	IN
18637	13256	9	this	this	DT
18637	13256	10	episode	episode	NN
18637	13256	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13256	12	see	see	VB
18637	13256	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13256	14	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	13256	15	,	,	,
18637	13256	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13256	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13256	18	in	in	IN
18637	13256	19	United	United	NNP
18637	13256	20	States	States	NNP
18637	13256	21	History	History	NNP
18637	13256	22	,	,	,
18637	13256	23	II	II	NNP
18637	13256	24	,	,	,
18637	13256	25	193	193	CD
18637	13256	26	-	-	SYM
18637	13256	27	194	194	CD
18637	13256	28	.	.	.
18637	13257	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13257	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13257	3	also	also	RB
18637	13257	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13257	5	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	13257	6	,	,	,
18637	13257	7	The	the	DT
18637	13257	8	American	American	NNP
18637	13257	9	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	13257	10	,	,	,
18637	13257	11	163	163	CD
18637	13257	12	.	.	.
18637	13258	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13258	2	652	652	CD
18637	13258	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13258	4	6	6	CD
18637	13258	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	13258	6	.	.	.
18637	13259	1	515	515	CD
18637	13259	2	,	,	,
18637	13259	3	596	596	CD
18637	13259	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13259	5	1832	1832	CD
18637	13259	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13259	7	.	.	.
18637	13260	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13260	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13260	3	also	also	RB
18637	13260	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13260	5	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	13260	6	,	,	,
18637	13260	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13260	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13260	9	in	in	IN
18637	13260	10	United	United	NNP
18637	13260	11	States	States	NNP
18637	13260	12	History	History	NNP
18637	13260	13	,	,	,
18637	13260	14	II	II	NNP
18637	13260	15	,	,	,
18637	13260	16	213	213	CD
18637	13260	17	;	;	:
18637	13260	18	and	and	CC
18637	13260	19	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	13260	20	,	,	,
18637	13260	21	_	_	NNP
18637	13260	22	op	op	NN
18637	13260	23	.	.	.
18637	13261	1	cit	cit	NNP
18637	13261	2	.	.	.
18637	13261	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13261	4	,	,	,
18637	13261	5	164	164	CD
18637	13261	6	.	.	.
18637	13262	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13262	2	was	be	VBD
18637	13262	3	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
18637	13262	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13262	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	13262	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13262	7	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	13262	8	which	which	WDT
18637	13262	9	allegedly	allegedly	RB
18637	13262	10	provoked	provoke	VBD
18637	13262	11	the	the	DT
18637	13262	12	probably	probably	RB
18637	13262	13	apocryphal	apocryphal	NN
18637	13262	14	comment	comment	NN
18637	13262	15	attributed	attribute	VBN
18637	13262	16	to	to	IN
18637	13262	17	President	President	NNP
18637	13262	18	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	13262	19	,	,	,
18637	13262	20	"	"	``
18637	13262	21	'	'	``
18637	13262	22	Well	well	UH
18637	13262	23	,	,	,
18637	13262	24	John	John	NNP
18637	13262	25	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	13262	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	13262	27	made	make	VBN
18637	13262	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13262	29	decision	decision	NN
18637	13262	30	,	,	,
18637	13262	31	now	now	RB
18637	13262	32	let	let	VB
18637	13262	33	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13262	34	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	13262	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13262	36	.	.	.
18637	13262	37	'	'	''
18637	13262	38	"	"	''
18637	13263	1	2	2	CD
18637	13263	2	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	13263	3	,	,	,
18637	13263	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13263	5	.	.	.
18637	13264	1	219	219	CD
18637	13264	2	.	.	.
18637	13265	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13265	2	653	653	CD
18637	13265	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13265	4	Mast	Mast	NNP
18637	13265	5	,	,	,
18637	13265	6	Foos	Foos	NNP
18637	13265	7	&	&	CC
18637	13265	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13265	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13265	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	13265	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13265	12	Stover	Stover	NNP
18637	13265	13	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	13265	14	.	.	.
18637	13266	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13266	2	,	,	,
18637	13266	3	177	177	CD
18637	13266	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13266	5	485	485	CD
18637	13266	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13266	7	1900	1900	CD
18637	13266	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13266	9	.	.	.
18637	13267	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13267	2	654	654	CD
18637	13267	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13267	4	Covell	Covell	NNP
18637	13267	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13267	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13267	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13267	8	Heyman	Heyman	NNP
18637	13267	9	,	,	,
18637	13267	10	111	111	CD
18637	13267	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13267	12	176	176	CD
18637	13267	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13267	14	1884	1884	CD
18637	13267	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13267	16	.	.	.
18637	13268	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13268	2	655	655	CD
18637	13268	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13268	4	Riehle	Riehle	NNP
18637	13268	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13268	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	8	Margolies	Margolies	NNP
18637	13268	9	,	,	,
18637	13268	10	279	279	CD
18637	13268	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13268	12	218	218	CD
18637	13268	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13268	14	1929	1929	CD
18637	13268	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13268	16	;	;	:
18637	13268	17	Harkin	Harkin	NNP
18637	13268	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	13268	20	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	21	Brundage	Brundage	NNP
18637	13268	22	,	,	,
18637	13268	23	276	276	CD
18637	13268	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13268	25	36	36	CD
18637	13268	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13268	27	1928	1928	CD
18637	13268	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13268	29	;	;	:
18637	13268	30	Wabash	Wabash	NNP
18637	13268	31	R.	R.	NNP
18637	13268	32	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13268	33	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	13268	35	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	36	Adelbert	Adelbert	NNP
18637	13268	37	College	College	NNP
18637	13268	38	,	,	,
18637	13268	39	208	208	CD
18637	13268	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13268	41	38	38	CD
18637	13268	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13268	43	1908	1908	CD
18637	13268	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13268	45	;	;	:
18637	13268	46	Harkrader	Harkrader	NNP
18637	13268	47	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	13268	49	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	50	Wadley	Wadley	NNP
18637	13268	51	,	,	,
18637	13268	52	172	172	CD
18637	13268	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13268	54	148	148	CD
18637	13268	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13268	56	1898	1898	CD
18637	13268	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13268	58	;	;	:
18637	13268	59	Central	Central	NNP
18637	13268	60	National	National	NNP
18637	13268	61	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	13268	62	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	13268	64	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	65	Stevens	Stevens	NNP
18637	13268	66	,	,	,
18637	13268	67	169	169	CD
18637	13268	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13268	69	432	432	CD
18637	13268	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13268	71	1898	1898	CD
18637	13268	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13268	73	;	;	:
18637	13268	74	Shields	Shields	NNP
18637	13268	75	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	13268	77	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	78	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	13268	79	,	,	,
18637	13268	80	157	157	CD
18637	13268	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13268	82	168	168	CD
18637	13268	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13268	84	1895	1895	CD
18637	13268	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13268	86	;	;	:
18637	13268	87	Moran	Moran	NNP
18637	13268	88	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	13268	90	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	91	Sturges	Sturges	NNP
18637	13268	92	,	,	,
18637	13268	93	154	154	CD
18637	13268	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13268	95	256	256	CD
18637	13268	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13268	97	1894	1894	CD
18637	13268	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13268	99	;	;	:
18637	13268	100	Krippendorf	Krippendorf	NNP
18637	13268	101	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	102	v.	v.	IN
18637	13268	103	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	104	Hyde	Hyde	NNP
18637	13268	105	,	,	,
18637	13268	106	110	110	CD
18637	13268	107	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13268	108	276	276	CD
18637	13268	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13268	110	1884	1884	CD
18637	13268	111	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13268	112	;	;	:
18637	13268	113	Covell	Covell	NNP
18637	13268	114	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	115	v.	v.	IN
18637	13268	116	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	117	Heyman	Heyman	NNP
18637	13268	118	,	,	,
18637	13268	119	111	111	CD
18637	13268	120	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13268	121	176	176	CD
18637	13268	122	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13268	123	1884	1884	CD
18637	13268	124	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13268	125	;	;	:
18637	13268	126	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	13268	127	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	128	v.	v.	IN
18637	13268	129	_	_	NNP
18637	13268	130	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	13268	131	,	,	,
18637	13268	132	13	13	CD
18637	13268	133	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13268	134	.	.	.
18637	13269	1	679	679	CD
18637	13269	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13269	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	13269	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13269	5	;	;	:
18637	13269	6	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	13269	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13269	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13269	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13269	10	Colbath	Colbath	NNP
18637	13269	11	,	,	,
18637	13269	12	3	3	CD
18637	13269	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13269	14	.	.	.
18637	13270	1	334	334	CD
18637	13270	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13270	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	13270	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13270	5	;	;	:
18637	13270	6	Freeman	Freeman	NNP
18637	13270	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13270	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13270	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13270	10	Howe	Howe	NNP
18637	13270	11	,	,	,
18637	13270	12	24	24	CD
18637	13270	13	How	how	WRB
18637	13270	14	.	.	.
18637	13271	1	450	450	CD
18637	13271	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13271	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	13271	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13271	5	;	;	:
18637	13271	6	Orton	Orton	NNP
18637	13271	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13271	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13271	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13271	10	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	13271	11	,	,	,
18637	13271	12	18	18	CD
18637	13271	13	How	how	WRB
18637	13271	14	.	.	.
18637	13272	1	263	263	CD
18637	13272	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13272	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	13272	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13272	5	;	;	:
18637	13272	6	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	13272	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13272	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13272	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13272	10	Carryl	Carryl	NNP
18637	13272	11	,	,	,
18637	13272	12	20	20	CD
18637	13272	13	How	how	WRB
18637	13272	14	.	.	.
18637	13273	1	583	583	CD
18637	13273	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13273	3	1858	1858	CD
18637	13273	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13273	5	;	;	:
18637	13273	6	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	13273	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13273	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13273	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13273	10	Jenness	Jenness	NNP
18637	13273	11	,	,	,
18637	13273	12	7	7	CD
18637	13273	13	How	how	WRB
18637	13273	14	.	.	.
18637	13274	1	612	612	CD
18637	13274	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13274	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	13274	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13274	5	.	.	.
18637	13275	1	For	for	IN
18637	13275	2	later	later	JJ
18637	13275	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	13275	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13275	5	see	see	VBP
18637	13275	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13275	7	Toucey	Toucey	NNP
18637	13275	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13275	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	13275	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13275	11	New	New	NNP
18637	13275	12	York	York	NNP
18637	13275	13	Life	Life	NNP
18637	13275	14	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	13275	15	.	.	.
18637	13276	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13276	2	,	,	,
18637	13276	3	314	314	CD
18637	13276	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13276	5	118	118	CD
18637	13276	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13276	7	1941	1941	CD
18637	13276	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13276	9	.	.	.
18637	13277	1	Princess	Princess	NNP
18637	13277	2	Lida	Lida	NNP
18637	13277	3	of	of	IN
18637	13277	4	Thurn	Thurn	NNP
18637	13277	5	&	&	CC
18637	13277	6	Taxis	Taxis	NNP
18637	13277	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13277	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13277	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13277	10	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	13277	11	,	,	,
18637	13277	12	305	305	CD
18637	13277	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13277	14	456	456	CD
18637	13277	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13277	16	1939	1939	CD
18637	13277	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13277	18	;	;	:
18637	13277	19	Brillhart	Brillhart	NNP
18637	13277	20	_	_	NNP
18637	13277	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	13277	22	_	_	NNP
18637	13277	23	Excess	Excess	NNP
18637	13277	24	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	13277	25	.	.	.
18637	13278	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13278	2	,	,	,
18637	13278	3	316	316	CD
18637	13278	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13278	5	491	491	CD
18637	13278	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13278	7	1942	1942	CD
18637	13278	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13278	9	;	;	:
18637	13278	10	Mandeville	Mandeville	NNP
18637	13278	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13278	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13278	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13278	14	Canterbury	Canterbury	NNP
18637	13278	15	,	,	,
18637	13278	16	318	318	CD
18637	13278	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13278	18	47	47	CD
18637	13278	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13278	20	1943	1943	CD
18637	13278	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13278	22	;	;	:
18637	13278	23	Markham	Markham	NNP
18637	13278	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13278	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	13278	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13278	27	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	13278	28	,	,	,
18637	13278	29	326	326	CD
18637	13278	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13278	31	490	490	CD
18637	13278	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13278	33	1946	1946	CD
18637	13278	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13278	35	;	;	:
18637	13278	36	Propper	Propper	NNP
18637	13278	37	_	_	NNP
18637	13278	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	13278	39	_	_	NNP
18637	13278	40	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	13278	41	,	,	,
18637	13278	42	337	337	CD
18637	13278	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13278	44	472	472	CD
18637	13278	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13278	46	1949	1949	CD
18637	13278	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13278	48	.	.	.
18637	13279	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13279	2	656	656	CD
18637	13279	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13279	4	McKim	McKim	NNP
18637	13279	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13279	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13279	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13279	8	Voorhies	Voorhies	NNPS
18637	13279	9	,	,	,
18637	13279	10	7	7	CD
18637	13279	11	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13279	12	.	.	.
18637	13280	1	279	279	CD
18637	13280	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13280	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	13280	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13280	5	;	;	:
18637	13280	6	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	13280	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13280	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13280	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13280	10	Darst	Darst	NNP
18637	13280	11	,	,	,
18637	13280	12	1	1	CD
18637	13280	13	How	how	WRB
18637	13280	14	.	.	.
18637	13281	1	301	301	CD
18637	13281	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13281	3	1843	1843	CD
18637	13281	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13281	5	;	;	:
18637	13281	6	United	United	NNP
18637	13281	7	States	States	NNP
18637	13281	8	ex	ex	NNP
18637	13281	9	rel	rel	NN
18637	13281	10	.	.	.
18637	13282	1	Riggs	Riggs	NNP
18637	13282	2	_	_	NNP
18637	13282	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	13282	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13282	5	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	13282	6	County	County	NNP
18637	13282	7	,	,	,
18637	13282	8	6	6	CD
18637	13282	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13282	10	.	.	.
18637	13283	1	166	166	CD
18637	13283	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13283	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	13283	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13283	5	;	;	:
18637	13283	6	Moran	Moran	NNP
18637	13283	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13283	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13283	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13283	10	Sturges	Sturges	NNP
18637	13283	11	,	,	,
18637	13283	12	154	154	CD
18637	13283	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13283	14	256	256	CD
18637	13283	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13283	16	1894	1894	CD
18637	13283	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13283	18	;	;	:
18637	13283	19	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	13283	20	'	'	POS
18637	13283	21	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	13283	22	&	&	CC
18637	13283	23	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	13283	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13283	25	_	_	NNP
18637	13283	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	13283	27	_	_	NNP
18637	13283	28	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	13283	29	St.	St.	NNP
18637	13283	30	Elev	Elev	NNP
18637	13283	31	.	.	.
18637	13284	1	R.	R.	NNP
18637	13284	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13284	3	,	,	,
18637	13284	4	177	177	CD
18637	13284	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13284	6	51	51	CD
18637	13284	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13284	8	1900	1900	CD
18637	13284	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13284	10	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13284	11	657	657	CD
18637	13284	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13284	13	6	6	CD
18637	13284	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13284	15	.	.	.
18637	13285	1	166	166	CD
18637	13285	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13285	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	13285	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13285	5	.	.	.
18637	13286	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13286	2	658	658	CD
18637	13286	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13286	4	Princess	Princess	NNP
18637	13286	5	Lida	Lida	NNP
18637	13286	6	of	of	IN
18637	13286	7	Thurn	Thurn	NNP
18637	13286	8	&	&	CC
18637	13286	9	Taxis	Taxis	NNP
18637	13286	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13286	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	13286	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13286	13	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	13286	14	,	,	,
18637	13286	15	305	305	CD
18637	13286	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13286	17	456	456	CD
18637	13286	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13286	19	1939	1939	CD
18637	13286	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13286	21	.	.	.
18637	13287	1	This	this	DT
18637	13287	2	case	case	NN
18637	13287	3	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	13287	4	on	on	IN
18637	13287	5	the	the	DT
18637	13287	6	principle	principle	NN
18637	13287	7	of	of	IN
18637	13287	8	comity	comity	NN
18637	13287	9	that	that	IN
18637	13287	10	where	where	WRB
18637	13287	11	there	there	EX
18637	13287	12	are	be	VBP
18637	13287	13	two	two	CD
18637	13287	14	suits	suit	NNS
18637	13287	15	_	_	NNP
18637	13287	16	in	in	IN
18637	13287	17	rem	rem	NNP
18637	13287	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13287	19	or	or	CC
18637	13287	20	_	_	NNP
18637	13287	21	quasi	quasi	NNP
18637	13287	22	in	in	IN
18637	13287	23	rem	rem	NNP
18637	13287	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13287	25	,	,	,
18637	13287	26	as	as	IN
18637	13287	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13287	28	were	be	VBD
18637	13287	29	held	hold	VBN
18637	13287	30	to	to	TO
18637	13287	31	be	be	VB
18637	13287	32	here	here	RB
18637	13287	33	,	,	,
18637	13287	34	so	so	IN
18637	13287	35	that	that	IN
18637	13287	36	the	the	DT
18637	13287	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13287	38	has	have	VBZ
18637	13287	39	possession	possession	NN
18637	13287	40	of	of	IN
18637	13287	41	property	property	NN
18637	13287	42	which	which	WDT
18637	13287	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	13287	44	the	the	DT
18637	13287	45	subject	subject	NN
18637	13287	46	of	of	IN
18637	13287	47	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	13287	48	or	or	CC
18637	13287	49	must	must	MD
18637	13287	50	have	have	VB
18637	13287	51	control	control	NN
18637	13287	52	of	of	IN
18637	13287	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13287	54	in	in	IN
18637	13287	55	order	order	NN
18637	13287	56	to	to	TO
18637	13287	57	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	13287	58	with	with	IN
18637	13287	59	the	the	DT
18637	13287	60	cause	cause	NN
18637	13287	61	and	and	CC
18637	13287	62	grant	grant	VB
18637	13287	63	the	the	DT
18637	13287	64	relief	relief	NN
18637	13287	65	sought	seek	VBD
18637	13287	66	,	,	,
18637	13287	67	the	the	DT
18637	13287	68	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13287	69	of	of	IN
18637	13287	70	one	one	CD
18637	13287	71	court	court	NN
18637	13287	72	must	must	MD
18637	13287	73	yield	yield	VB
18637	13287	74	to	to	IN
18637	13287	75	that	that	DT
18637	13287	76	of	of	IN
18637	13287	77	the	the	DT
18637	13287	78	other	other	JJ
18637	13287	79	.	.	.
18637	13288	1	The	the	DT
18637	13288	2	principle	principle	NN
18637	13288	3	,	,	,
18637	13288	4	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	13288	5	to	to	IN
18637	13288	6	both	both	CC
18637	13288	7	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13288	8	and	and	CC
18637	13288	9	State	State	NNP
18637	13288	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	13288	11	,	,	,
18637	13288	12	that	that	IN
18637	13288	13	the	the	DT
18637	13288	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13288	15	first	first	RB
18637	13288	16	assuming	assume	VBG
18637	13288	17	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13288	18	over	over	IN
18637	13288	19	property	property	NN
18637	13288	20	may	may	MD
18637	13288	21	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	13288	22	and	and	CC
18637	13288	23	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	13288	24	that	that	DT
18637	13288	25	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13288	26	to	to	IN
18637	13288	27	the	the	DT
18637	13288	28	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	13288	29	of	of	IN
18637	13288	30	the	the	DT
18637	13288	31	other	other	JJ
18637	13288	32	,	,	,
18637	13288	33	was	be	VBD
18637	13288	34	held	hold	VBN
18637	13288	35	not	not	RB
18637	13288	36	to	to	TO
18637	13288	37	be	be	VB
18637	13288	38	confined	confine	VBN
18637	13288	39	to	to	IN
18637	13288	40	cases	case	NNS
18637	13288	41	where	where	WRB
18637	13288	42	the	the	DT
18637	13288	43	property	property	NN
18637	13288	44	has	have	VBZ
18637	13288	45	actually	actually	RB
18637	13288	46	been	be	VBN
18637	13288	47	seized	seize	VBN
18637	13288	48	under	under	IN
18637	13288	49	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13288	50	process	process	NN
18637	13288	51	,	,	,
18637	13288	52	but	but	CC
18637	13288	53	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	13288	54	as	as	RB
18637	13288	55	well	well	RB
18637	13288	56	to	to	IN
18637	13288	57	suits	suit	NNS
18637	13288	58	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13288	59	for	for	IN
18637	13288	60	marshalling	marshal	VBG
18637	13288	61	assets	asset	NNS
18637	13288	62	,	,	,
18637	13288	63	administering	administer	VBG
18637	13288	64	trusts	trust	NNS
18637	13288	65	,	,	,
18637	13288	66	or	or	CC
18637	13288	67	liquidating	liquidate	VBG
18637	13288	68	estates	estate	NNS
18637	13288	69	and	and	CC
18637	13288	70	to	to	IN
18637	13288	71	suits	suit	NNS
18637	13288	72	of	of	IN
18637	13288	73	a	a	DT
18637	13288	74	similar	similar	JJ
18637	13288	75	nature	nature	NN
18637	13288	76	,	,	,
18637	13288	77	where	where	WRB
18637	13288	78	to	to	TO
18637	13288	79	give	give	VB
18637	13288	80	effect	effect	NN
18637	13288	81	to	to	IN
18637	13288	82	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13288	83	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13288	84	the	the	DT
18637	13288	85	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13288	86	must	must	MD
18637	13288	87	control	control	VB
18637	13288	88	the	the	DT
18637	13288	89	property	property	NN
18637	13288	90	.	.	.
18637	13289	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13289	2	659	659	CD
18637	13289	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13289	4	1	1	CD
18637	13289	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13289	6	.	.	.
18637	13290	1	335	335	CD
18637	13290	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13290	3	1793	1793	CD
18637	13290	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13290	5	;	;	:
18637	13290	6	28	28	CD
18637	13290	7	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	13291	1	§	§	NNP
18637	13291	2	2283	2283	CD
18637	13291	3	.	.	.
18637	13292	1	In	in	IN
18637	13292	2	the	the	DT
18637	13292	3	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13292	4	code	code	NN
18637	13292	5	an	an	DT
18637	13292	6	exception	exception	NN
18637	13292	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	13292	8	made	make	VBN
18637	13292	9	to	to	IN
18637	13292	10	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13292	11	in	in	IN
18637	13292	12	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	13292	13	.	.	.
18637	13293	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13293	2	660	660	CD
18637	13293	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13293	4	Diggs	Diggs	NNP
18637	13293	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13293	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13293	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13293	8	Wolcott	Wolcott	NNP
18637	13293	9	,	,	,
18637	13293	10	4	4	CD
18637	13293	11	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13293	12	.	.	.
18637	13294	1	179	179	CD
18637	13294	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13294	3	1807	1807	CD
18637	13294	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13294	5	;	;	:
18637	13294	6	Orton	Orton	NNP
18637	13294	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13294	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13294	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13294	10	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	13294	11	,	,	,
18637	13294	12	18	18	CD
18637	13294	13	How	how	WRB
18637	13294	14	.	.	.
18637	13295	1	263	263	CD
18637	13295	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13295	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	13295	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13295	5	;	;	:
18637	13295	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13295	7	see	see	VB
18637	13295	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13295	9	especially	especially	RB
18637	13295	10	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	13295	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13295	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13295	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13295	14	Jenness	Jenness	NNP
18637	13295	15	,	,	,
18637	13295	16	7	7	CD
18637	13295	17	How	how	WRB
18637	13295	18	.	.	.
18637	13296	1	612	612	CD
18637	13296	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13296	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	13296	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13296	5	where	where	WRB
18637	13296	6	the	the	DT
18637	13296	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13296	8	held	hold	VBD
18637	13296	9	that	that	IN
18637	13296	10	the	the	DT
18637	13296	11	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	13296	12	of	of	IN
18637	13296	13	the	the	DT
18637	13296	14	act	act	NN
18637	13296	15	of	of	IN
18637	13296	16	1793	1793	CD
18637	13296	17	extended	extend	VBD
18637	13296	18	to	to	TO
18637	13296	19	injunction	injunction	VB
18637	13296	20	suits	suit	NNS
18637	13296	21	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13296	22	against	against	IN
18637	13296	23	the	the	DT
18637	13296	24	parties	party	NNS
18637	13296	25	to	to	IN
18637	13296	26	a	a	DT
18637	13296	27	State	State	NNP
18637	13296	28	court	court	NN
18637	13296	29	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13296	30	as	as	RB
18637	13296	31	well	well	RB
18637	13296	32	as	as	IN
18637	13296	33	to	to	IN
18637	13296	34	the	the	DT
18637	13296	35	State	State	NNP
18637	13296	36	court	court	NN
18637	13296	37	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13296	38	.	.	.
18637	13297	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13297	2	661	661	CD
18637	13297	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13297	4	Freeman	Freeman	NNP
18637	13297	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13297	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13297	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13297	8	Howe	Howe	NNP
18637	13297	9	,	,	,
18637	13297	10	24	24	CD
18637	13297	11	How	how	WRB
18637	13297	12	.	.	.
18637	13298	1	450	450	CD
18637	13298	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13298	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	13298	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13298	5	;	;	:
18637	13298	6	Julian	Julian	NNP
18637	13298	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13298	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13298	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13298	10	Central	Central	NNP
18637	13298	11	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	13298	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13298	13	,	,	,
18637	13298	14	193	193	CD
18637	13298	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13298	16	93	93	CD
18637	13298	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13298	18	1904	1904	CD
18637	13298	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13298	20	;	;	:
18637	13298	21	Riverdale	Riverdale	NNP
18637	13298	22	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	13298	23	Mills	Mills	NNPS
18637	13298	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13298	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	13298	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13298	27	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	13298	28	&	&	CC
18637	13298	29	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	13298	30	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	13298	31	.	.	.
18637	13299	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13299	2	,	,	,
18637	13299	3	198	198	CD
18637	13299	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13299	5	188	188	CD
18637	13299	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13299	7	1905	1905	CD
18637	13299	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13299	9	;	;	:
18637	13299	10	Looney	Looney	NNP
18637	13299	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13299	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13299	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13299	14	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	13299	15	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	13299	16	R.	R.	NNP
18637	13299	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13299	18	,	,	,
18637	13299	19	247	247	CD
18637	13299	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13299	21	214	214	CD
18637	13299	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13299	23	1918	1918	CD
18637	13299	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13299	25	.	.	.
18637	13300	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13300	2	662	662	CD
18637	13300	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13300	4	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	13300	5	'	'	POS
18637	13300	6	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	13300	7	&	&	CC
18637	13300	8	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	13300	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13300	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13300	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	13300	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13300	13	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	13300	14	St.	St.	NNP
18637	13300	15	Elev	Elev	NNP
18637	13300	16	.	.	.
18637	13301	1	R.	R.	NNP
18637	13301	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13301	3	,	,	,
18637	13301	4	177	177	CD
18637	13301	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13301	6	51	51	CD
18637	13301	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13301	8	1900	1900	CD
18637	13301	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13301	10	;	;	:
18637	13301	11	Riverdale	Riverdale	NNP
18637	13301	12	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	13301	13	Mills	Mills	NNPS
18637	13301	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13301	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	13301	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13301	17	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	13301	18	&	&	CC
18637	13301	19	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	13301	20	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	13301	21	.	.	.
18637	13302	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13302	2	,	,	,
18637	13302	3	198	198	CD
18637	13302	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13302	5	188	188	CD
18637	13302	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13302	7	1905	1905	CD
18637	13302	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13302	9	;	;	:
18637	13302	10	Julian	Julian	NNP
18637	13302	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13302	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13302	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13302	14	Central	Central	NNP
18637	13302	15	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	13302	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13302	17	,	,	,
18637	13302	18	193	193	CD
18637	13302	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13302	20	93	93	CD
18637	13302	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13302	22	1904	1904	CD
18637	13302	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13302	24	;	;	:
18637	13302	25	Kline	Kline	NNP
18637	13302	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13302	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	13302	28	_	_	NNP
18637	13302	29	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	13302	30	Construction	Construction	NNP
18637	13302	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13302	32	,	,	,
18637	13302	33	260	260	CD
18637	13302	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13302	35	226	226	CD
18637	13302	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13302	37	1922	1922	CD
18637	13302	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13302	39	.	.	.
18637	13303	1	For	for	IN
18637	13303	2	a	a	DT
18637	13303	3	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	13303	4	of	of	IN
18637	13303	5	this	this	DT
18637	13303	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	13303	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13303	8	see	see	VBP
18637	13303	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13303	10	Toucey	Toucey	NNP
18637	13303	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13303	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13303	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13303	14	New	New	NNP
18637	13303	15	York	York	NNP
18637	13303	16	Life	Life	NNP
18637	13303	17	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	13303	18	.	.	.
18637	13304	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13304	2	,	,	,
18637	13304	3	314	314	CD
18637	13304	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13304	5	118	118	CD
18637	13304	6	,	,	,
18637	13304	7	134	134	CD
18637	13304	8	-	-	SYM
18637	13304	9	136	136	CD
18637	13304	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13304	11	1941	1941	CD
18637	13304	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13304	13	.	.	.
18637	13305	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13305	2	663	663	CD
18637	13305	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13305	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13305	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	13305	6	Young	Young	NNP
18637	13305	7	,	,	,
18637	13305	8	209	209	CD
18637	13305	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13305	10	123	123	CD
18637	13305	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13305	12	1908	1908	CD
18637	13305	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13305	14	,	,	,
18637	13305	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	13305	16	the	the	DT
18637	13305	17	leading	leading	JJ
18637	13305	18	case	case	NN
18637	13305	19	.	.	.
18637	13306	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13306	2	664	664	CD
18637	13306	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13306	4	Arrowsmith	Arrowsmith	NNP
18637	13306	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13306	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13306	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13306	8	Gleason	Gleason	NNP
18637	13306	9	,	,	,
18637	13306	10	129	129	CD
18637	13306	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13306	12	86	86	CD
18637	13306	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13306	14	1889	1889	CD
18637	13306	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13306	16	;	;	:
18637	13306	17	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	13306	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13306	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	13306	20	_	_	NNP
18637	13306	21	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	13306	22	,	,	,
18637	13306	23	141	141	CD
18637	13306	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13306	25	589	589	CD
18637	13306	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13306	27	1891	1891	CD
18637	13306	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13306	29	;	;	:
18637	13306	30	Simon	Simon	NNP
18637	13306	31	_	_	NNP
18637	13306	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	13306	33	_	_	NNP
18637	13306	34	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	13306	35	R.	R.	NNP
18637	13306	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13306	37	,	,	,
18637	13306	38	236	236	CD
18637	13306	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13306	40	115	115	CD
18637	13306	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13306	42	1915	1915	CD
18637	13306	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13306	44	.	.	.
18637	13307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13307	2	665	665	CD
18637	13307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13307	4	French	French	NNP
18637	13307	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13307	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13307	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13307	8	Hay	Hay	NNP
18637	13307	9	,	,	,
18637	13307	10	22	22	CD
18637	13307	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13307	12	.	.	.
18637	13308	1	231	231	CD
18637	13308	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13308	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	13308	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13308	5	;	;	:
18637	13308	6	Dietzsch	Dietzsch	NNP
18637	13308	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13308	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13308	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13308	10	Huidekoper	Huidekoper	NNP
18637	13308	11	,	,	,
18637	13308	12	103	103	CD
18637	13308	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13308	14	494	494	CD
18637	13308	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13308	16	1881	1881	CD
18637	13308	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13308	18	;	;	:
18637	13308	19	Madisonville	Madisonville	NNP
18637	13308	20	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	13308	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13308	22	_	_	NNP
18637	13308	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	13308	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13308	25	St.	St.	NNP
18637	13308	26	Bernard	Bernard	NNP
18637	13308	27	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	13308	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13308	29	,	,	,
18637	13308	30	196	196	CD
18637	13308	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13308	32	239	239	CD
18637	13308	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13308	34	1905	1905	CD
18637	13308	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13308	36	.	.	.
18637	13309	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13309	2	666	666	CD
18637	13309	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13309	4	The	the	DT
18637	13309	5	earlier	early	JJR
18637	13309	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	13309	7	are	be	VBP
18637	13309	8	Root	Root	NNP
18637	13309	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13309	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	13309	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13309	12	Woolworth	Woolworth	NNP
18637	13309	13	,	,	,
18637	13309	14	150	150	CD
18637	13309	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13309	16	401	401	CD
18637	13309	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13309	18	1893	1893	CD
18637	13309	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13309	20	;	;	:
18637	13309	21	Prout	Prout	NNP
18637	13309	22	_	_	NNP
18637	13309	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	13309	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13309	25	Starr	Starr	NNP
18637	13309	26	,	,	,
18637	13309	27	188	188	CD
18637	13309	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13309	29	537	537	CD
18637	13309	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13309	31	1903	1903	CD
18637	13309	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13309	33	;	;	:
18637	13309	34	Juilian	Juilian	NNP
18637	13309	35	_	_	NNP
18637	13309	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	13309	37	_	_	NNP
18637	13309	38	Central	Central	NNP
18637	13309	39	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	13309	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13309	41	,	,	,
18637	13309	42	193	193	CD
18637	13309	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13309	44	93	93	CD
18637	13309	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13309	46	1904	1904	CD
18637	13309	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13309	48	.	.	.
18637	13310	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13310	2	667	667	CD
18637	13310	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13310	4	314	314	CD
18637	13310	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13310	6	118	118	CD
18637	13310	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13310	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	13310	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13310	10	.	.	.
18637	13311	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13311	2	668	668	CD
18637	13311	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13311	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13311	5	.	.	.
18637	13312	1	133	133	CD
18637	13312	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13312	3	141	141	CD
18637	13312	4	.	.	.
18637	13313	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13313	2	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	13313	3	,	,	,
18637	13313	4	in	in	IN
18637	13313	5	a	a	DT
18637	13313	6	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	13313	7	in	in	IN
18637	13313	8	which	which	WDT
18637	13313	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	13313	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13313	11	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	13313	12	and	and	CC
18637	13313	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13313	14	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	13313	15	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	13313	16	,	,	,
18637	13313	17	also	also	RB
18637	13313	18	reviewed	review	VBD
18637	13313	19	the	the	DT
18637	13313	20	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	13313	21	.	.	.
18637	13314	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13314	2	669	669	CD
18637	13314	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13314	4	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	13314	5	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	13314	6	.	.	.
18637	13315	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13315	2	_	_	NNP
18637	13315	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	13315	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13315	5	Painter	Painter	NNP
18637	13315	6	,	,	,
18637	13315	7	314	314	CD
18637	13315	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13315	9	155	155	CD
18637	13315	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13315	11	1941	1941	CD
18637	13315	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13315	13	.	.	.
18637	13316	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13316	2	670	670	CD
18637	13316	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13316	4	9	9	CD
18637	13316	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	13316	6	.	.	.
18637	13317	1	738	738	CD
18637	13317	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13317	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	13317	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13317	5	.	.	.
18637	13318	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13318	2	671	671	CD
18637	13318	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13318	4	209	209	CD
18637	13318	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13318	6	123	123	CD
18637	13318	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13318	8	1908	1908	CD
18637	13318	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13318	10	.	.	.
18637	13319	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13319	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13319	3	also	also	RB
18637	13319	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13319	5	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
18637	13319	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13319	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13319	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13319	9	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	13319	10	,	,	,
18637	13319	11	169	169	CD
18637	13319	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13319	13	466	466	CD
18637	13319	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13319	15	1898	1898	CD
18637	13319	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13319	17	;	;	:
18637	13319	18	Reagan	Reagan	NNP
18637	13319	19	_	_	NNP
18637	13319	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	13319	21	_	_	NNP
18637	13319	22	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	13319	23	'	'	POS
18637	13319	24	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	13319	25	&	&	CC
18637	13319	26	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	13319	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13319	28	,	,	,
18637	13319	29	154	154	CD
18637	13319	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13319	31	362	362	CD
18637	13319	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13319	33	1894	1894	CD
18637	13319	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13319	35	.	.	.
18637	13320	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13320	2	672	672	CD
18637	13320	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13320	4	Harkrader	Harkrader	NNP
18637	13320	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13320	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13320	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13320	8	Wadley	Wadley	NNP
18637	13320	9	,	,	,
18637	13320	10	172	172	CD
18637	13320	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13320	12	148	148	CD
18637	13320	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13320	14	1898	1898	CD
18637	13320	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13320	16	;	;	:
18637	13320	17	In	in	IN
18637	13320	18	re	re	IN
18637	13320	19	Sawyer	Sawyer	NNP
18637	13320	20	,	,	,
18637	13320	21	124	124	CD
18637	13320	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13320	23	200	200	CD
18637	13320	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13320	25	1888	1888	CD
18637	13320	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13320	27	.	.	.
18637	13321	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13321	2	673	673	CD
18637	13321	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13321	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13321	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	13321	6	Young	Young	NNP
18637	13321	7	,	,	,
18637	13321	8	209	209	CD
18637	13321	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13321	10	123	123	CD
18637	13321	11	,	,	,
18637	13321	12	163	163	CD
18637	13321	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13321	14	1908	1908	CD
18637	13321	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13321	16	.	.	.
18637	13322	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13322	2	674	674	CD
18637	13322	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13322	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13322	5	.	.	.
18637	13323	1	174	174	CD
18637	13323	2	.	.	.
18637	13324	1	The	the	DT
18637	13324	2	Young	Young	NNP
18637	13324	3	case	case	NN
18637	13324	4	evoked	evoke	VBD
18637	13324	5	sharp	sharp	JJ
18637	13324	6	criticism	criticism	NN
18637	13324	7	in	in	IN
18637	13324	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13324	9	and	and	CC
18637	13324	10	led	lead	VBD
18637	13324	11	to	to	IN
18637	13324	12	the	the	DT
18637	13324	13	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	13324	14	of	of	IN
18637	13324	15	§	§	NNP
18637	13324	16	266	266	CD
18637	13324	17	of	of	IN
18637	13324	18	the	the	DT
18637	13324	19	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	13324	20	Code	Code	NNP
18637	13324	21	,	,	,
18637	13324	22	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	13324	23	the	the	DT
18637	13324	24	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	13324	25	of	of	IN
18637	13324	26	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	13324	27	to	to	TO
18637	13324	28	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	13324	29	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	13324	30	of	of	IN
18637	13324	31	State	state	NN
18637	13324	32	laws	law	NNS
18637	13324	33	by	by	IN
18637	13324	34	a	a	DT
18637	13324	35	single	single	JJ
18637	13324	36	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13324	37	judge	judge	NN
18637	13324	38	,	,	,
18637	13324	39	providing	provide	VBG
18637	13324	40	for	for	IN
18637	13324	41	a	a	DT
18637	13324	42	three	three	CD
18637	13324	43	-	-	HYPH
18637	13324	44	judge	judge	NN
18637	13324	45	court	court	NN
18637	13324	46	in	in	IN
18637	13324	47	such	such	JJ
18637	13324	48	cases	case	NNS
18637	13324	49	,	,	,
18637	13324	50	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	13324	51	the	the	DT
18637	13324	52	effect	effect	NN
18637	13324	53	of	of	IN
18637	13324	54	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	13324	55	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	13324	56	,	,	,
18637	13324	57	and	and	CC
18637	13324	58	expediting	expedite	VBG
18637	13324	59	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	13324	60	in	in	IN
18637	13324	61	such	such	JJ
18637	13324	62	cases	case	NNS
18637	13324	63	to	to	IN
18637	13324	64	the	the	DT
18637	13324	65	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13324	66	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13324	67	.	.	.
18637	13325	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	13325	2	of	of	IN
18637	13325	3	June	June	NNP
18637	13325	4	18	18	CD
18637	13325	5	,	,	,
18637	13325	6	1910	1910	CD
18637	13325	7	,	,	,
18637	13325	8	36	36	CD
18637	13325	9	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	13325	10	.	.	.
18637	13326	1	539	539	CD
18637	13326	2	;	;	:
18637	13326	3	28	28	CD
18637	13326	4	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	13327	1	§	§	NNP
18637	13327	2	1253	1253	CD
18637	13327	3	,	,	,
18637	13327	4	2281	2281	CD
18637	13327	5	,	,	,
18637	13327	6	2284	2284	CD
18637	13327	7	.	.	.
18637	13328	1	A	a	DT
18637	13328	2	supplementary	supplementary	JJ
18637	13328	3	act	act	NN
18637	13328	4	in	in	IN
18637	13328	5	1913	1913	CD
18637	13328	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13328	7	37	37	CD
18637	13328	8	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13328	9	.	.	.
18637	13329	1	1013	1013	CD
18637	13329	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13329	3	amended	amend	VBD
18637	13329	4	§	§	NNP
18637	13329	5	266	266	CD
18637	13329	6	of	of	IN
18637	13329	7	the	the	DT
18637	13329	8	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	13329	9	Code	Code	NNP
18637	13329	10	providing	provide	VBG
18637	13329	11	for	for	IN
18637	13329	12	the	the	DT
18637	13329	13	stay	stay	NN
18637	13329	14	of	of	IN
18637	13329	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13329	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13329	17	to	to	TO
18637	13329	18	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	13329	19	State	State	NNP
18637	13329	20	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	13329	21	if	if	IN
18637	13329	22	a	a	DT
18637	13329	23	suit	suit	NN
18637	13329	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	13329	25	been	be	VBN
18637	13329	26	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13329	27	in	in	RP
18637	13329	28	a	a	DT
18637	13329	29	State	State	NNP
18637	13329	30	court	court	NN
18637	13329	31	to	to	TO
18637	13329	32	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	13329	33	the	the	DT
18637	13329	34	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	13329	35	until	until	IN
18637	13329	36	the	the	DT
18637	13329	37	State	State	NNP
18637	13329	38	court	court	NN
18637	13329	39	has	have	VBZ
18637	13329	40	determined	determine	VBN
18637	13329	41	the	the	DT
18637	13329	42	issues	issue	NNS
18637	13329	43	.	.	.
18637	13330	1	Section	section	NN
18637	13330	2	266	266	CD
18637	13330	3	was	be	VBD
18637	13330	4	amended	amend	VBN
18637	13330	5	again	again	RB
18637	13330	6	in	in	IN
18637	13330	7	1925	1925	CD
18637	13330	8	when	when	WRB
18637	13330	9	the	the	DT
18637	13330	10	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	13330	11	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	13330	12	interlocutory	interlocutory	JJ
18637	13330	13	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	13330	14	were	be	VBD
18637	13330	15	extended	extend	VBN
18637	13330	16	to	to	TO
18637	13330	17	include	include	VB
18637	13330	18	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	13330	19	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	13330	20	.	.	.
18637	13331	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	13331	2	of	of	IN
18637	13331	3	February	February	NNP
18637	13331	4	13	13	CD
18637	13331	5	,	,	,
18637	13331	6	1925	1925	CD
18637	13331	7	,	,	,
18637	13331	8	43	43	CD
18637	13331	9	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	13331	10	.	.	.
18637	13332	1	938	938	CD
18637	13332	2	.	.	.
18637	13333	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13333	2	675	675	CD
18637	13333	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13333	4	Prentis	Prentis	NNP
18637	13333	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13333	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13333	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13333	8	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	13333	9	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	13333	10	Line	Line	NNP
18637	13333	11	R.	R.	NNP
18637	13333	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13333	13	,	,	,
18637	13333	14	211	211	CD
18637	13333	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13333	16	210	210	CD
18637	13333	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13333	18	1908	1908	CD
18637	13333	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13333	20	;	;	:
18637	13333	21	Gilchrist	Gilchrist	NNP
18637	13333	22	_	_	NNP
18637	13333	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	13333	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13333	25	Interborough	Interborough	NNP
18637	13333	26	Rapid	Rapid	NNP
18637	13333	27	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	13333	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13333	29	,	,	,
18637	13333	30	279	279	CD
18637	13333	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13333	32	159	159	CD
18637	13333	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13333	34	1929	1929	CD
18637	13333	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13333	36	;	;	:
18637	13333	37	Grubb	Grubb	NNP
18637	13333	38	_	_	NNP
18637	13333	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	13333	40	_	_	NNP
18637	13333	41	Public	Public	NNP
18637	13333	42	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	13333	43	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	13333	44	,	,	,
18637	13333	45	281	281	CD
18637	13333	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13333	47	470	470	CD
18637	13333	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13333	49	1930	1930	CD
18637	13333	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13333	51	;	;	:
18637	13333	52	Beal	Beal	NNP
18637	13333	53	_	_	NNP
18637	13333	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	13333	55	_	_	NNP
18637	13333	56	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	13333	57	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	13333	58	R.	R.	NNP
18637	13333	59	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13333	60	,	,	,
18637	13333	61	312	312	CD
18637	13333	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13333	63	45	45	CD
18637	13333	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13333	65	1941	1941	CD
18637	13333	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13333	67	.	.	.
18637	13334	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13334	2	676	676	CD
18637	13334	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13334	4	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	13334	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13334	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13334	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13334	8	United	United	NNP
18637	13334	9	States	States	NNP
18637	13334	10	,	,	,
18637	13334	11	312	312	CD
18637	13334	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13334	13	246	246	CD
18637	13334	14	,	,	,
18637	13334	15	249	249	CD
18637	13334	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13334	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	13334	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13334	19	,	,	,
18637	13334	20	citing	cite	VBG
18637	13334	21	and	and	CC
18637	13334	22	quoting	quote	VBG
18637	13334	23	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13334	24	parte	parte	NN
18637	13334	25	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	13334	26	,	,	,
18637	13334	27	277	277	CD
18637	13334	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13334	29	565	565	CD
18637	13334	30	,	,	,
18637	13334	31	577	577	CD
18637	13334	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13334	33	1928	1928	CD
18637	13334	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13334	35	.	.	.
18637	13335	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13335	2	677	677	CD
18637	13335	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13335	4	312	312	CD
18637	13335	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13335	6	246	246	CD
18637	13335	7	,	,	,
18637	13335	8	251	251	CD
18637	13335	9	,	,	,
18637	13335	10	citing	cite	VBG
18637	13335	11	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	13335	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13335	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	13335	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13335	15	Fidelity	Fidelity	NNP
18637	13335	16	&	&	CC
18637	13335	17	Deposit	Deposit	NNP
18637	13335	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13335	19	,	,	,
18637	13335	20	272	272	CD
18637	13335	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13335	22	317	317	CD
18637	13335	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13335	24	1926	1926	CD
18637	13335	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13335	26	;	;	:
18637	13335	27	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	13335	28	_	_	NNP
18637	13335	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	13335	30	_	_	NNP
18637	13335	31	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	13335	32	,	,	,
18637	13335	33	273	273	CD
18637	13335	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13335	35	388	388	CD
18637	13335	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13335	37	1927	1927	CD
18637	13335	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13335	39	;	;	:
18637	13335	40	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	13335	41	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	13335	42	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13335	43	_	_	NNP
18637	13335	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	13335	45	_	_	NNP
18637	13335	46	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	13335	47	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13335	48	,	,	,
18637	13335	49	292	292	CD
18637	13335	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13335	51	386	386	CD
18637	13335	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13335	53	1934	1934	CD
18637	13335	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13335	55	;	;	:
18637	13335	56	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13335	57	parte	parte	VBZ
18637	13335	58	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	13335	59	,	,	,
18637	13335	60	277	277	CD
18637	13335	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13335	62	267	267	CD
18637	13335	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13335	64	1928	1928	CD
18637	13335	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13335	66	;	;	:
18637	13335	67	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13335	68	parte	parte	NN
18637	13335	69	Public	Public	NNP
18637	13335	70	National	National	NNP
18637	13335	71	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	13335	72	,	,	,
18637	13335	73	278	278	CD
18637	13335	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13335	75	101	101	CD
18637	13335	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13335	77	1928	1928	CD
18637	13335	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13335	79	;	;	:
18637	13335	80	Rorick	Rorick	NNP
18637	13335	81	_	_	NNP
18637	13335	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	13335	83	_	_	NNP
18637	13335	84	Commissioners	Commissioners	NNP
18637	13335	85	,	,	,
18637	13335	86	307	307	CD
18637	13335	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13335	88	208	208	CD
18637	13335	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13335	90	1939	1939	CD
18637	13335	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13335	92	;	;	:
18637	13335	93	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13335	94	parte	parte	NN
18637	13335	95	Bransford	Bransford	NNP
18637	13335	96	,	,	,
18637	13335	97	310	310	CD
18637	13335	98	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13335	99	354	354	CD
18637	13335	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13335	101	1940	1940	CD
18637	13335	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13335	103	.	.	.
18637	13336	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13336	2	678	678	CD
18637	13336	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13336	4	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	13336	5	,	,	,
18637	13336	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	13336	7	and	and	CC
18637	13336	8	State	State	NNP
18637	13336	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13336	10	Interference	Interference	NNP
18637	13336	11	,	,	,
18637	13336	12	43	43	CD
18637	13336	13	Harv	Harv	NNP
18637	13336	14	.	.	.
18637	13337	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	13337	2	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	13338	1	345	345	CD
18637	13338	2	,	,	,
18637	13338	3	354	354	CD
18637	13338	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13338	5	1930	1930	CD
18637	13338	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13338	7	.	.	.
18637	13339	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13339	2	679	679	CD
18637	13339	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13339	4	21	21	CD
18637	13339	5	How	how	WRB
18637	13339	6	.	.	.
18637	13340	1	506	506	CD
18637	13340	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13340	3	1859	1859	CD
18637	13340	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13340	5	.	.	.
18637	13341	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13341	2	680	680	CD
18637	13341	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13341	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13341	5	.	.	.
18637	13342	1	514	514	CD
18637	13342	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13342	3	516	516	CD
18637	13342	4	,	,	,
18637	13342	5	523	523	CD
18637	13342	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	13342	7	524	524	CD
18637	13342	8	,	,	,
18637	13342	9	526	526	CD
18637	13342	10	.	.	.
18637	13343	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13343	2	681	681	CD
18637	13343	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13343	4	United	United	NNP
18637	13343	5	States	States	NNP
18637	13343	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13343	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13343	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13343	9	Tarble	Tarble	NNP
18637	13343	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13343	11	Tarble	Tarble	NNP
18637	13343	12	's	's	POS
18637	13343	13	Case	Case	NNP
18637	13343	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13343	15	,	,	,
18637	13343	16	13	13	CD
18637	13343	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13343	18	.	.	.
18637	13344	1	397	397	CD
18637	13344	2	,	,	,
18637	13344	3	407	407	CD
18637	13344	4	-	-	SYM
18637	13344	5	408	408	CD
18637	13344	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13344	7	1872	1872	CD
18637	13344	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13344	9	.	.	.
18637	13345	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13345	2	682	682	CD
18637	13345	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13345	4	1	1	CD
18637	13345	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13345	6	.	.	.
18637	13346	1	81	81	CD
18637	13346	2	,	,	,
18637	13346	3	§	§	NNP
18637	13346	4	14	14	CD
18637	13346	5	.	.	.
18637	13347	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13347	2	683	683	CD
18637	13347	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13347	4	4	4	CD
18637	13347	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13347	6	.	.	.
18637	13348	1	634	634	CD
18637	13348	2	,	,	,
18637	13348	3	§	§	NNP
18637	13348	4	7	7	CD
18637	13348	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13348	6	1833	1833	CD
18637	13348	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13348	8	.	.	.
18637	13349	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13349	2	684	684	CD
18637	13349	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13349	4	5	5	CD
18637	13349	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13349	6	.	.	.
18637	13350	1	539	539	CD
18637	13350	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13350	3	1942	1942	CD
18637	13350	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13350	5	.	.	.
18637	13351	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13351	2	685	685	CD
18637	13351	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13351	4	14	14	CD
18637	13351	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13351	6	.	.	.
18637	13352	1	385	385	CD
18637	13352	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13352	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	13352	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13352	5	.	.	.
18637	13353	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13353	2	686	686	CD
18637	13353	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13353	4	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	13354	1	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13354	2	.	.	.
18637	13354	3	,	,	,
18637	13354	4	§	§	NNP
18637	13354	5	753	753	CD
18637	13354	6	;	;	:
18637	13354	7	28	28	CD
18637	13354	8	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	13355	1	§	§	NNP
18637	13355	2	2242	2242	CD
18637	13355	3	.	.	.
18637	13356	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13356	2	687	687	CD
18637	13356	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13356	4	100	100	CD
18637	13356	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13356	6	257	257	CD
18637	13356	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13356	8	1880	1880	CD
18637	13356	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13356	10	.	.	.
18637	13357	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13357	2	688	688	CD
18637	13357	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13357	4	In	in	IN
18637	13357	5	re	re	IN
18637	13357	6	Neagle	Neagle	NNP
18637	13357	7	,	,	,
18637	13357	8	135	135	CD
18637	13357	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13357	10	1	1	CD
18637	13357	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13357	12	1890	1890	CD
18637	13357	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13357	14	.	.	.
18637	13358	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13358	2	689	689	CD
18637	13358	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13358	4	In	in	IN
18637	13358	5	re	re	NN
18637	13358	6	Loney	Loney	NNP
18637	13358	7	,	,	,
18637	13358	8	134	134	CD
18637	13358	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13358	10	372	372	CD
18637	13358	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13358	12	1890	1890	CD
18637	13358	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13358	14	.	.	.
18637	13359	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13359	2	690	690	CD
18637	13359	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13359	4	Boske	Boske	NNP
18637	13359	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13359	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13359	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13359	8	Comingore	Comingore	NNP
18637	13359	9	,	,	,
18637	13359	10	177	177	CD
18637	13359	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13359	12	459	459	CD
18637	13359	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13359	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	13359	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13359	16	.	.	.
18637	13360	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13360	2	691	691	CD
18637	13360	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13360	4	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	13360	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13360	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13360	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13360	8	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	13360	9	,	,	,
18637	13360	10	173	173	CD
18637	13360	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13360	12	276	276	CD
18637	13360	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13360	14	1899	1899	CD
18637	13360	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13360	16	.	.	.
18637	13361	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13361	2	692	692	CD
18637	13361	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13361	4	209	209	CD
18637	13361	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13361	6	205	205	CD
18637	13361	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13361	8	1908	1908	CD
18637	13361	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13361	10	.	.	.
18637	13362	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13362	2	693	693	CD
18637	13362	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13362	4	117	117	CD
18637	13362	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13362	6	241	241	CD
18637	13362	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13362	8	1886	1886	CD
18637	13362	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13362	10	.	.	.
18637	13363	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13363	2	694	694	CD
18637	13363	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13363	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13363	5	.	.	.
18637	13364	1	251	251	CD
18637	13364	2	.	.	.
18637	13365	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13365	2	695	695	CD
18637	13365	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13365	4	Harkrader	Harkrader	NNP
18637	13365	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13365	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13365	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13365	8	Wadley	Wadley	NNP
18637	13365	9	,	,	,
18637	13365	10	172	172	CD
18637	13365	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13365	12	148	148	CD
18637	13365	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13365	14	1898	1898	CD
18637	13365	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13365	16	;	;	:
18637	13365	17	Whitten	Whitten	NNP
18637	13365	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13365	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	13365	20	_	_	NNP
18637	13365	21	Tomlinson	Tomlinson	NNP
18637	13365	22	,	,	,
18637	13365	23	160	160	CD
18637	13365	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13365	25	231	231	CD
18637	13365	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13365	27	1895	1895	CD
18637	13365	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13365	29	.	.	.
18637	13366	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13366	2	696	696	CD
18637	13366	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13366	4	Frank	Frank	NNP
18637	13366	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13366	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13366	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13366	8	Mangum	Mangum	NNP
18637	13366	9	,	,	,
18637	13366	10	237	237	CD
18637	13366	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13366	12	309	309	CD
18637	13366	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13366	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	13366	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13366	16	;	;	:
18637	13366	17	Tinsley	Tinsley	NNP
18637	13366	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13366	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	13366	20	_	_	NNP
18637	13366	21	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	13366	22	,	,	,
18637	13366	23	171	171	CD
18637	13366	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13366	25	101	101	CD
18637	13366	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13366	27	1898	1898	CD
18637	13366	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13366	29	.	.	.
18637	13367	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13367	2	697	697	CD
18637	13367	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13367	4	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	13367	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13367	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13367	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13367	8	Soper	Soper	NNP
18637	13367	9	,	,	,
18637	13367	10	270	270	CD
18637	13367	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13367	12	9	9	CD
18637	13367	13	,	,	,
18637	13367	14	36	36	CD
18637	13367	15	,	,	,
18637	13367	16	44	44	CD
18637	13367	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13367	18	1926	1926	CD
18637	13367	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13367	20	.	.	.
18637	13368	1	In	in	IN
18637	13368	2	addition	addition	NN
18637	13368	3	to	to	IN
18637	13368	4	the	the	DT
18637	13368	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	13368	6	cited	cite	VBN
18637	13368	7	above	above	IN
18637	13368	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13368	9	see	see	VBP
18637	13368	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13368	11	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13368	12	parte	parte	NN
18637	13368	13	Fonda	Fonda	NNP
18637	13368	14	,	,	,
18637	13368	15	117	117	CD
18637	13368	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13368	17	516	516	CD
18637	13368	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13368	19	1886	1886	CD
18637	13368	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13368	21	;	;	:
18637	13368	22	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	13368	23	_	_	NNP
18637	13368	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	13368	25	_	_	NNP
18637	13368	26	McCall	McCall	NNP
18637	13368	27	,	,	,
18637	13368	28	139	139	CD
18637	13368	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13368	30	449	449	CD
18637	13368	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13368	32	1891	1891	CD
18637	13368	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13368	34	;	;	:
18637	13368	35	New	New	NNP
18637	13368	36	York	York	NNP
18637	13368	37	_	_	NNP
18637	13368	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	13368	39	_	_	NNP
18637	13368	40	Eno	Eno	NNP
18637	13368	41	,	,	,
18637	13368	42	155	155	CD
18637	13368	43	.	.	.
18637	13369	1	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13369	2	89	89	CD
18637	13369	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13369	4	1894	1894	CD
18637	13369	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13369	6	;	;	:
18637	13369	7	Baker	Baker	NNP
18637	13369	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13369	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	13369	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13369	11	Grice	Grice	NNP
18637	13369	12	,	,	,
18637	13369	13	169	169	CD
18637	13369	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13369	15	284	284	CD
18637	13369	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13369	17	1898	1898	CD
18637	13369	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13369	19	;	;	:
18637	13369	20	Matter	Matter	NNP
18637	13369	21	of	of	IN
18637	13369	22	Moran	Moran	NNP
18637	13369	23	,	,	,
18637	13369	24	203	203	CD
18637	13369	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13369	26	96	96	CD
18637	13369	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13369	28	1906	1906	CD
18637	13369	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13369	30	;	;	:
18637	13369	31	Mooney	Mooney	NNP
18637	13369	32	_	_	NNP
18637	13369	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	13369	34	_	_	NNP
18637	13369	35	Holohan	Holohan	NNP
18637	13369	36	,	,	,
18637	13369	37	294	294	CD
18637	13369	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13369	39	103	103	CD
18637	13369	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13369	41	1935	1935	CD
18637	13369	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13369	43	;	;	:
18637	13369	44	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13369	45	parte	parte	NN
18637	13369	46	Hawk	Hawk	NNP
18637	13369	47	,	,	,
18637	13369	48	321	321	CD
18637	13369	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13369	50	114	114	CD
18637	13369	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13369	52	1944	1944	CD
18637	13369	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13369	54	.	.	.
18637	13370	1	Compare	compare	VB
18637	13370	2	,	,	,
18637	13370	3	however	however	RB
18637	13370	4	,	,	,
18637	13370	5	Wade	Wade	NNP
18637	13370	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13370	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13370	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13370	9	Mayo	Mayo	NNP
18637	13370	10	,	,	,
18637	13370	11	334	334	CD
18637	13370	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13370	13	672	672	CD
18637	13370	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13370	15	1948	1948	CD
18637	13370	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13370	17	,	,	,
18637	13370	18	where	where	WRB
18637	13370	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13370	20	was	be	VBD
18637	13370	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	13370	22	that	that	IN
18637	13370	23	failure	failure	NN
18637	13370	24	of	of	IN
18637	13370	25	the	the	DT
18637	13370	26	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	13370	27	to	to	TO
18637	13370	28	appeal	appeal	VB
18637	13370	29	to	to	IN
18637	13370	30	the	the	DT
18637	13370	31	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13370	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13370	33	from	from	IN
18637	13370	34	a	a	DT
18637	13370	35	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	13370	36	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	13370	37	by	by	IN
18637	13370	38	the	the	DT
18637	13370	39	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13370	40	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13370	41	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13370	42	did	do	VBD
18637	13370	43	not	not	RB
18637	13370	44	bar	bar	VB
18637	13370	45	relief	relief	NN
18637	13370	46	by	by	IN
18637	13370	47	_	_	NNP
18637	13370	48	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	13370	49	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	13370	50	_	_	NNP
18637	13370	51	because	because	IN
18637	13370	52	of	of	IN
18637	13370	53	denial	denial	NN
18637	13370	54	of	of	IN
18637	13370	55	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	13370	56	.	.	.
18637	13371	1	In	in	IN
18637	13371	2	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13371	3	parte	parte	NN
18637	13371	4	Hawk	Hawk	NNP
18637	13371	5	,	,	,
18637	13371	6	321	321	CD
18637	13371	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13371	8	114	114	CD
18637	13371	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13371	10	1944	1944	CD
18637	13371	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13371	12	,	,	,
18637	13371	13	the	the	DT
18637	13371	14	rule	rule	NN
18637	13371	15	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	13371	16	to	to	IN
18637	13371	17	the	the	DT
18637	13371	18	exhaustion	exhaustion	NN
18637	13371	19	of	of	IN
18637	13371	20	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	13371	21	was	be	VBD
18637	13371	22	applied	apply	VBN
18637	13371	23	so	so	IN
18637	13371	24	as	as	IN
18637	13371	25	to	to	TO
18637	13371	26	include	include	VB
18637	13371	27	a	a	DT
18637	13371	28	certiorari	certiorari	JJ
18637	13371	29	petition	petition	NN
18637	13371	30	in	in	IN
18637	13371	31	the	the	DT
18637	13371	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13371	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13371	34	.	.	.
18637	13372	1	In	in	IN
18637	13372	2	adopting	adopt	VBG
18637	13372	3	a	a	DT
18637	13372	4	new	new	JJ
18637	13372	5	United	United	NNP
18637	13372	6	States	States	NNP
18637	13372	7	Code	Code	NNP
18637	13372	8	in	in	IN
18637	13372	9	1948	1948	CD
18637	13372	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13372	11	62	62	CD
18637	13372	12	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13372	13	.	.	.
18637	13373	1	967	967	LS
18637	13373	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13373	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13373	4	added	add	VBD
18637	13373	5	a	a	DT
18637	13373	6	new	new	JJ
18637	13373	7	section	section	NN
18637	13373	8	to	to	IN
18637	13373	9	existing	exist	VBG
18637	13373	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13373	11	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	13373	12	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	13373	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13373	14	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	13373	15	which	which	WDT
18637	13373	16	stipulated	stipulate	VBD
18637	13373	17	that	that	IN
18637	13373	18	no	no	DT
18637	13373	19	application	application	NN
18637	13373	20	for	for	IN
18637	13373	21	a	a	DT
18637	13373	22	writ	writ	NN
18637	13373	23	of	of	IN
18637	13373	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13373	25	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	13373	26	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	13373	27	_	_	NNP
18637	13373	28	by	by	IN
18637	13373	29	a	a	DT
18637	13373	30	person	person	NN
18637	13373	31	in	in	IN
18637	13373	32	custody	custody	NN
18637	13373	33	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	13373	34	to	to	IN
18637	13373	35	a	a	DT
18637	13373	36	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13373	37	of	of	IN
18637	13373	38	a	a	DT
18637	13373	39	State	State	NNP
18637	13373	40	court	court	NN
18637	13373	41	shall	shall	MD
18637	13373	42	be	be	VB
18637	13373	43	granted	grant	VBN
18637	13373	44	until	until	IN
18637	13373	45	the	the	DT
18637	13373	46	applicant	applicant	NN
18637	13373	47	has	have	VBZ
18637	13373	48	exhausted	exhaust	VBN
18637	13373	49	the	the	DT
18637	13373	50	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	13373	51	available	available	JJ
18637	13373	52	in	in	IN
18637	13373	53	the	the	DT
18637	13373	54	courts	court	NNS
18637	13373	55	of	of	IN
18637	13373	56	the	the	DT
18637	13373	57	States	States	NNPS
18637	13373	58	and	and	CC
18637	13373	59	that	that	IN
18637	13373	60	an	an	DT
18637	13373	61	applicant	applicant	NN
18637	13373	62	shall	shall	MD
18637	13373	63	not	not	RB
18637	13373	64	be	be	VB
18637	13373	65	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	13373	66	to	to	TO
18637	13373	67	have	have	VB
18637	13373	68	exhausted	exhaust	VBN
18637	13373	69	State	state	NN
18637	13373	70	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	13373	71	if	if	IN
18637	13373	72	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13373	73	has	have	VBZ
18637	13373	74	the	the	DT
18637	13373	75	right	right	NN
18637	13373	76	under	under	IN
18637	13373	77	State	State	NNP
18637	13373	78	law	law	NN
18637	13373	79	to	to	TO
18637	13373	80	raise	raise	VB
18637	13373	81	,	,	,
18637	13373	82	by	by	IN
18637	13373	83	any	any	DT
18637	13373	84	available	available	JJ
18637	13373	85	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	13373	86	,	,	,
18637	13373	87	the	the	DT
18637	13373	88	question	question	NN
18637	13373	89	presented	present	VBD
18637	13373	90	,	,	,
18637	13373	91	28	28	CD
18637	13373	92	U.S.C.A.	U.S.C.A.	NNP
18637	13374	1	§	§	NNP
18637	13374	2	2254	2254	CD
18637	13374	3	.	.	.
18637	13375	1	This	this	DT
18637	13375	2	section	section	NN
18637	13375	3	codified	codify	VBD
18637	13375	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13375	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	13375	6	Hawk	Hawk	NNP
18637	13375	7	.	.	.
18637	13376	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13376	2	698	698	CD
18637	13376	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13376	4	334	334	CD
18637	13376	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13376	6	672	672	CD
18637	13376	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13376	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	13376	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13376	10	.	.	.
18637	13377	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13377	2	699	699	CD
18637	13377	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13377	4	258	258	CD
18637	13377	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13377	6	254	254	CD
18637	13377	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13377	8	1922	1922	CD
18637	13377	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13377	10	.	.	.
18637	13378	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13378	2	700	700	CD
18637	13378	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13378	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13378	5	.	.	.
18637	13379	1	259	259	CD
18637	13379	2	.	.	.
18637	13380	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13380	2	701	701	CD
18637	13380	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13380	4	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	13380	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13380	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13380	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13380	8	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	13380	9	,	,	,
18637	13380	10	5	5	CD
18637	13380	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	13380	12	.	.	.
18637	13381	1	1	1	CD
18637	13381	2	,	,	,
18637	13381	3	27	27	CD
18637	13381	4	-	-	SYM
18637	13381	5	28	28	CD
18637	13381	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13381	7	1820	1820	CD
18637	13381	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13381	9	.	.	.
18637	13382	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13382	2	702	702	CD
18637	13382	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13382	4	Carriage	Carriage	NNP
18637	13382	5	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	13382	6	Act	Act	NNP
18637	13382	7	,	,	,
18637	13382	8	1	1	CD
18637	13382	9	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	13382	10	.	.	.
18637	13383	1	373	373	CD
18637	13383	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13383	3	1794	1794	CD
18637	13383	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13383	5	;	;	:
18637	13383	6	License	License	NNP
18637	13383	7	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	13383	8	on	on	IN
18637	13383	9	Wine	Wine	NNP
18637	13383	10	and	and	CC
18637	13383	11	Spirits	Spirits	NNPS
18637	13383	12	Act	Act	NNP
18637	13383	13	,	,	,
18637	13383	14	1	1	CD
18637	13383	15	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	13383	16	.	.	.
18637	13384	1	376	376	CD
18637	13384	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13384	3	1794	1794	CD
18637	13384	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13384	5	.	.	.
18637	13385	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13385	2	703	703	CD
18637	13385	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13385	4	1	1	CD
18637	13385	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	13385	6	.	.	.
18637	13386	1	302	302	CD
18637	13386	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13386	3	1793	1793	CD
18637	13386	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13386	5	.	.	.
18637	13387	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13387	2	704	704	CD
18637	13387	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13387	4	1	1	CD
18637	13387	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13387	6	.	.	.
18637	13388	1	414	414	CD
18637	13388	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13388	3	1795	1795	CD
18637	13388	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13388	5	.	.	.
18637	13389	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13389	2	705	705	CD
18637	13389	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13389	4	1	1	CD
18637	13389	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13389	6	.	.	.
18637	13390	1	577	577	CD
18637	13390	2	.	.	.
18637	13391	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13391	2	706	706	CD
18637	13391	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13391	4	1	1	CD
18637	13391	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	13391	6	.	.	.
18637	13392	1	727	727	CD
18637	13392	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13392	3	1799	1799	CD
18637	13392	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13392	5	.	.	.
18637	13393	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13393	2	707	707	CD
18637	13393	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13393	4	2	2	CD
18637	13393	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13393	6	.	.	.
18637	13394	1	453	453	CD
18637	13394	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13394	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	13394	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13394	5	;	;	:
18637	13394	6	2	2	CD
18637	13394	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	13394	8	.	.	.
18637	13395	1	473	473	CD
18637	13395	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13395	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	13395	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13395	5	;	;	:
18637	13395	6	2	2	CD
18637	13395	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	13395	8	.	.	.
18637	13396	1	499	499	CD
18637	13396	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13396	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	13396	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13396	5	;	;	:
18637	13396	6	2	2	CD
18637	13396	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	13396	8	.	.	.
18637	13397	1	506	506	CD
18637	13397	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13397	3	1809	1809	CD
18637	13397	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13397	5	;	;	:
18637	13397	6	2	2	CD
18637	13397	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	13397	8	.	.	.
18637	13398	1	528	528	CD
18637	13398	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13398	3	1809	1809	CD
18637	13398	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13398	5	;	;	:
18637	13398	6	2	2	CD
18637	13398	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	13398	8	.	.	.
18637	13399	1	550	550	CD
18637	13399	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13399	3	1809	1809	CD
18637	13399	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13399	5	;	;	:
18637	13399	6	2	2	CD
18637	13399	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	13399	8	.	.	.
18637	13400	1	605	605	CD
18637	13400	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13400	3	1810	1810	CD
18637	13400	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13400	5	;	;	:
18637	13400	6	2	2	CD
18637	13400	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	13400	8	.	.	.
18637	13401	1	707	707	CD
18637	13401	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13401	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	13401	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13401	5	;	;	:
18637	13401	6	3	3	CD
18637	13401	7	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13401	8	.	.	.
18637	13402	1	88	88	CD
18637	13402	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13402	3	1813	1813	CD
18637	13402	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13402	5	.	.	.
18637	13403	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13403	2	708	708	CD
18637	13403	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13403	4	3	3	CD
18637	13403	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13403	6	.	.	.
18637	13404	1	244	244	CD
18637	13404	2	.	.	.
18637	13405	1	For	for	IN
18637	13405	2	the	the	DT
18637	13405	3	trial	trial	NN
18637	13405	4	of	of	IN
18637	13405	5	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13405	6	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	13405	7	in	in	IN
18637	13405	8	State	State	NNP
18637	13405	9	courts	court	NNS
18637	13405	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13405	11	see	see	VBP
18637	13405	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13405	13	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	13405	14	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	13405	15	,	,	,
18637	13405	16	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	13405	17	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
18637	13405	18	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	13405	19	and	and	CC
18637	13405	20	State	State	NNP
18637	13405	21	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	13405	22	,	,	,
18637	13405	23	38	38	CD
18637	13405	24	Harv	Harv	NNP
18637	13405	25	.	.	.
18637	13406	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	13406	2	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	13407	1	545	545	CD
18637	13407	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13407	3	1925	1925	CD
18637	13407	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13407	5	.	.	.
18637	13408	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13408	2	709	709	CD
18637	13408	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13408	4	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	13408	5	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	13408	6	,	,	,
18637	13408	7	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	13408	8	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
18637	13408	9	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	13408	10	and	and	CC
18637	13408	11	State	State	NNP
18637	13408	12	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	13408	13	,	,	,
18637	13408	14	38	38	CD
18637	13408	15	Harv	Harv	NNP
18637	13408	16	.	.	.
18637	13409	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	13409	2	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	13410	1	545	545	CD
18637	13410	2	,	,	,
18637	13410	3	577	577	CD
18637	13410	4	-	-	SYM
18637	13410	5	581	581	CD
18637	13410	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13410	7	1925	1925	CD
18637	13410	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13410	9	.	.	.
18637	13411	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13411	2	710	710	CD
18637	13411	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13411	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13411	5	Story	Story	NNP
18637	13411	6	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	13411	7	in	in	IN
18637	13411	8	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	13411	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13411	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	13411	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13411	12	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	13411	13	,	,	,
18637	13411	14	5	5	CD
18637	13411	15	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	13411	16	.	.	.
18637	13412	1	1	1	CD
18637	13412	2	,	,	,
18637	13412	3	69	69	CD
18637	13412	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13412	5	1820	1820	CD
18637	13412	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13412	7	;	;	:
18637	13412	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13412	9	McLean	McLean	NNP
18637	13412	10	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	13412	11	in	in	IN
18637	13412	12	United	United	NNP
18637	13412	13	States	States	NNP
18637	13412	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13412	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	13412	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13412	17	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	13412	18	,	,	,
18637	13412	19	9	9	CD
18637	13412	20	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	13412	21	.	.	.
18637	13413	1	238	238	CD
18637	13413	2	,	,	,
18637	13413	3	259	259	CD
18637	13413	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13413	5	1835	1835	CD
18637	13413	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13413	7	.	.	.
18637	13414	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13414	2	711	711	CD
18637	13414	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13414	4	16	16	CD
18637	13414	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	13414	6	.	.	.
18637	13415	1	539	539	CD
18637	13415	2	,	,	,
18637	13415	3	615	615	CD
18637	13415	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13415	5	1842	1842	CD
18637	13415	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13415	7	.	.	.
18637	13416	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13416	2	712	712	CD
18637	13416	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13416	4	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	13416	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13416	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13416	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13416	8	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	13416	9	,	,	,
18637	13416	10	165	165	CD
18637	13416	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13416	12	275	275	CD
18637	13416	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13416	14	1897	1897	CD
18637	13416	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13416	16	;	;	:
18637	13416	17	Dallemagne	Dallemagne	NNP
18637	13416	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13416	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	13416	20	_	_	NNP
18637	13416	21	Moisan	Moisan	NNP
18637	13416	22	,	,	,
18637	13416	23	197	197	CD
18637	13416	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13416	25	169	169	CD
18637	13416	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13416	27	1905	1905	CD
18637	13416	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13416	29	.	.	.
18637	13417	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13417	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13417	3	also	also	RB
18637	13417	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13417	5	Teal	Teal	NNP
18637	13417	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13417	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13417	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13417	9	Felton	Felton	NNP
18637	13417	10	,	,	,
18637	13417	11	12	12	CD
18637	13417	12	How	how	WRB
18637	13417	13	.	.	.
18637	13418	1	284	284	CD
18637	13418	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13418	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	13418	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13418	5	;	;	:
18637	13418	6	Claflin	Claflin	NNP
18637	13418	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13418	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13418	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13418	10	Houseman	Houseman	NNP
18637	13418	11	,	,	,
18637	13418	12	93	93	CD
18637	13418	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13418	14	130	130	CD
18637	13418	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13418	16	1876	1876	CD
18637	13418	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13418	18	.	.	.
18637	13419	1	This	this	DT
18637	13419	2	last	last	JJ
18637	13419	3	case	case	NN
18637	13419	4	proceeds	proceed	VBZ
18637	13419	5	on	on	IN
18637	13419	6	the	the	DT
18637	13419	7	express	express	JJ
18637	13419	8	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	13419	9	that	that	IN
18637	13419	10	the	the	DT
18637	13419	11	State	State	NNP
18637	13419	12	and	and	CC
18637	13419	13	National	National	NNP
18637	13419	14	Governments	Governments	NNPS
18637	13419	15	are	be	VBP
18637	13419	16	part	part	NN
18637	13419	17	of	of	IN
18637	13419	18	a	a	DT
18637	13419	19	single	single	JJ
18637	13419	20	nation	nation	NN
18637	13419	21	and	and	CC
18637	13419	22	implicity	implicity	NN
18637	13419	23	repudiates	repudiate	NNS
18637	13419	24	the	the	DT
18637	13419	25	idea	idea	NN
18637	13419	26	of	of	IN
18637	13419	27	separate	separate	JJ
18637	13419	28	sovereignties	sovereignty	NNS
18637	13419	29	,	,	,
18637	13419	30	as	as	IN
18637	13419	31	set	set	VBN
18637	13419	32	out	out	RP
18637	13419	33	in	in	IN
18637	13419	34	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
18637	13419	35	_	_	NNP
18637	13419	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	13419	37	_	_	NNP
18637	13419	38	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	13419	39	,	,	,
18637	13419	40	16	16	CD
18637	13419	41	Pet	pet	NN
18637	13419	42	.	.	.
18637	13420	1	539	539	CD
18637	13420	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13420	3	1842	1842	CD
18637	13420	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13420	5	.	.	.
18637	13421	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13421	2	713	713	CD
18637	13421	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13421	4	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	13421	5	Wendell	Wendell	NNP
18637	13421	6	,	,	,
18637	13421	7	Relations	relation	NNS
18637	13421	8	between	between	IN
18637	13421	9	the	the	DT
18637	13421	10	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	13421	11	and	and	CC
18637	13421	12	State	State	NNP
18637	13421	13	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	13421	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13421	15	New	New	NNP
18637	13421	16	York	York	NNP
18637	13421	17	,	,	,
18637	13421	18	1949	1949	CD
18637	13421	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13421	20	,	,	,
18637	13421	21	278	278	CD
18637	13421	22	.	.	.
18637	13422	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13422	2	714	714	CD
18637	13422	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13422	4	35	35	CD
18637	13422	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13422	6	.	.	.
18637	13423	1	65	65	CD
18637	13423	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13423	3	1908	1908	CD
18637	13423	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13423	5	.	.	.
18637	13424	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13424	2	715	715	CD
18637	13424	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13424	4	Hoxie	Hoxie	NNP
18637	13424	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13424	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13424	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13424	8	New	New	NNP
18637	13424	9	York	York	NNP
18637	13424	10	,	,	,
18637	13424	11	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	13424	12	&	&	CC
18637	13424	13	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	13425	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13425	2	,	,	,
18637	13425	3	82	82	CD
18637	13425	4	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
18637	13425	5	352	352	CD
18637	13425	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13425	7	1909	1909	CD
18637	13425	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13425	9	.	.	.
18637	13426	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13426	2	716	716	CD
18637	13426	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13426	4	223	223	CD
18637	13426	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13426	6	1	1	CD
18637	13426	7	,	,	,
18637	13426	8	59	59	CD
18637	13426	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13426	10	1912	1912	CD
18637	13426	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13426	12	.	.	.
18637	13427	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13427	2	717	717	CD
18637	13427	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13427	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	13427	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13427	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13427	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13427	8	Western	Western	NNP
18637	13427	9	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	13427	10	.	.	.
18637	13428	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13428	2	of	of	IN
18637	13428	3	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	13428	4	,	,	,
18637	13428	5	338	338	CD
18637	13428	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13428	7	294	294	CD
18637	13428	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13428	9	1949	1949	CD
18637	13428	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13428	11	.	.	.
18637	13429	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13429	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13429	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13429	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13429	5	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	13429	6	's	's	POS
18637	13429	7	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	13429	8	in	in	IN
18637	13429	9	this	this	DT
18637	13429	10	case	case	NN
18637	13429	11	for	for	IN
18637	13429	12	a	a	DT
18637	13429	13	summary	summary	NN
18637	13429	14	of	of	IN
18637	13429	15	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	13429	16	to	to	IN
18637	13429	17	the	the	DT
18637	13429	18	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	13429	19	.	.	.
18637	13430	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13430	2	718	718	CD
18637	13430	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13430	4	330	330	CD
18637	13430	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13430	6	386	386	CD
18637	13430	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13430	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	13430	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13430	10	.	.	.
18637	13431	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13431	2	719	719	CD
18637	13431	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13431	4	56	56	CD
18637	13431	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13431	6	.	.	.
18637	13432	1	23	23	CD
18637	13432	2	,	,	,
18637	13432	3	33	33	CD
18637	13432	4	-	-	SYM
18637	13432	5	34	34	CD
18637	13432	6	,	,	,
18637	13432	7	205	205	CD
18637	13432	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13432	9	c	c	NN
18637	13432	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13432	11	.	.	.
18637	13433	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13433	2	720	720	CD
18637	13433	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13433	4	330	330	CD
18637	13433	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13433	6	386	386	CD
18637	13433	7	,	,	,
18637	13433	8	389	389	CD
18637	13433	9	.	.	.
18637	13434	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13434	2	721	721	CD
18637	13434	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13434	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13434	5	.	.	.
18637	13435	1	390	390	CD
18637	13435	2	.	.	.
18637	13436	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13436	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	13436	3	refers	refer	VBZ
18637	13436	4	to	to	IN
18637	13436	5	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
18637	13436	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13436	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13436	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13436	9	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	13436	10	,	,	,
18637	13436	11	16	16	CD
18637	13436	12	Pet	pet	NN
18637	13436	13	.	.	.
18637	13437	1	539	539	CD
18637	13437	2	,	,	,
18637	13437	3	615	615	CD
18637	13437	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13437	5	1842	1842	CD
18637	13437	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13437	7	,	,	,
18637	13437	8	and	and	CC
18637	13437	9	other	other	JJ
18637	13437	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	13437	11	as	as	IN
18637	13437	12	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	13437	13	questioning	question	VBG
18637	13437	14	the	the	DT
18637	13437	15	power	power	NN
18637	13437	16	and	and	CC
18637	13437	17	duty	duty	NN
18637	13437	18	of	of	IN
18637	13437	19	State	State	NNP
18637	13437	20	courts	court	NNS
18637	13437	21	to	to	TO
18637	13437	22	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	13437	23	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13437	24	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	13437	25	law	law	NN
18637	13437	26	.	.	.
18637	13438	1	The	the	DT
18637	13438	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	13438	3	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	13438	4	relied	rely	VBN
18637	13438	5	upon	upon	IN
18637	13438	6	in	in	IN
18637	13438	7	the	the	DT
18637	13438	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	13438	9	are	be	VBP
18637	13438	10	Claflin	Claflin	NNP
18637	13438	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13438	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13438	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13438	14	Houseman	Houseman	NNP
18637	13438	15	,	,	,
18637	13438	16	93	93	CD
18637	13438	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13438	18	130	130	CD
18637	13438	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13438	20	1876	1876	CD
18637	13438	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13438	22	;	;	:
18637	13438	23	Mondou	Mondou	NNP
18637	13438	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13438	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	13438	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13438	27	New	New	NNP
18637	13438	28	York	York	NNP
18637	13438	29	,	,	,
18637	13438	30	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	13438	31	&	&	CC
18637	13438	32	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	13439	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13439	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13439	3	Second	Second	NNP
18637	13439	4	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	13439	5	'	'	POS
18637	13439	6	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	13439	7	Cases	case	NNS
18637	13439	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13439	9	,	,	,
18637	13439	10	223	223	CD
18637	13439	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13439	12	1	1	CD
18637	13439	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13439	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	13439	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13439	16	.	.	.
18637	13440	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13440	2	722	722	CD
18637	13440	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13440	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13440	5	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	13440	6	.	.	.
18637	13440	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13440	8	Doyle	Doyle	NNP
18637	13440	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13440	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	13440	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13440	12	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	13440	13	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	13440	14	.	.	.
18637	13441	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13441	2	,	,	,
18637	13441	3	94	94	CD
18637	13441	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13441	5	535	535	CD
18637	13441	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13441	7	1877	1877	CD
18637	13441	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13441	9	,	,	,
18637	13441	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13441	11	which	which	WDT
18637	13441	12	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	13441	13	a	a	DT
18637	13441	14	similar	similar	JJ
18637	13441	15	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	13441	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	13441	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13441	18	,	,	,
18637	13441	19	and	and	CC
18637	13441	20	Security	Security	NNP
18637	13441	21	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	13441	22	.	.	.
18637	13442	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	13442	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	13442	3	.	.	.
18637	13443	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13443	2	_	_	NNP
18637	13443	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	13443	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13443	5	Prewitt	Prewitt	NNP
18637	13443	6	,	,	,
18637	13443	7	202	202	CD
18637	13443	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13443	9	246	246	CD
18637	13443	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13443	11	1906	1906	CD
18637	13443	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13443	13	;	;	:
18637	13443	14	with	with	IN
18637	13443	15	Home	Home	NNP
18637	13443	16	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	13443	17	.	.	.
18637	13444	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13444	2	_	_	NNP
18637	13444	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	13444	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13444	5	Morse	Morse	NNP
18637	13444	6	,	,	,
18637	13444	7	20	20	CD
18637	13444	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13444	9	.	.	.
18637	13445	1	445	445	CD
18637	13445	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13445	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	13445	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13445	5	;	;	:
18637	13445	6	Barron	Barron	NNP
18637	13445	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13445	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13445	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13445	10	Burnside	Burnside	NNP
18637	13445	11	,	,	,
18637	13445	12	121	121	CD
18637	13445	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13445	14	186	186	CD
18637	13445	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13445	16	1887	1887	CD
18637	13445	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13445	18	;	;	:
18637	13445	19	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	13445	20	P.	P.	NNP
18637	13445	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13445	22	_	_	NNP
18637	13445	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	13445	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13445	25	Denton	Denton	NNP
18637	13445	26	,	,	,
18637	13445	27	146	146	CD
18637	13445	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13445	29	202	202	CD
18637	13445	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13445	31	1892	1892	CD
18637	13445	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13445	33	;	;	:
18637	13445	34	Gerling	Gerling	NNP
18637	13445	35	_	_	NNP
18637	13445	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	13445	37	_	_	NNP
18637	13445	38	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	13445	39	&	&	CC
18637	13445	40	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	13446	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13446	2	,	,	,
18637	13446	3	151	151	CD
18637	13446	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13446	5	673	673	CD
18637	13446	6	,	,	,
18637	13446	7	684	684	CD
18637	13446	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13446	9	1894	1894	CD
18637	13446	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13446	11	;	;	:
18637	13446	12	Barrow	Barrow	NNP
18637	13446	13	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	13446	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13446	15	_	_	NNP
18637	13446	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	13446	17	_	_	NNP
18637	13446	18	Kane	Kane	NNP
18637	13446	19	,	,	,
18637	13446	20	170	170	CD
18637	13446	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13446	22	100	100	CD
18637	13446	23	,	,	,
18637	13446	24	111	111	CD
18637	13446	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13446	26	1898	1898	CD
18637	13446	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13446	28	;	;	:
18637	13446	29	Herndon	Herndon	NNP
18637	13446	30	_	_	NNP
18637	13446	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	13446	32	_	_	NNP
18637	13446	33	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	13446	34	,	,	,
18637	13446	35	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	13446	36	&	&	CC
18637	13446	37	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	13447	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13447	2	,	,	,
18637	13447	3	218	218	CD
18637	13447	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13447	5	135	135	CD
18637	13447	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13447	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	13447	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13447	9	;	;	:
18637	13447	10	Harrison	Harrison	NNP
18637	13447	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13447	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13447	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13447	14	St.	St.	NNP
18637	13447	15	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	13447	16	&	&	CC
18637	13447	17	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	13448	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13448	2	,	,	,
18637	13448	3	232	232	CD
18637	13448	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13448	5	318	318	CD
18637	13448	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13448	7	1914	1914	CD
18637	13448	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13448	9	;	;	:
18637	13448	10	Donald	Donald	NNP
18637	13448	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13448	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13448	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13448	14	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	13448	15	&	&	CC
18637	13448	16	R.	R.	NNP
18637	13448	17	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	13448	18	&	&	CC
18637	13448	19	I.	I.	NNP
18637	13448	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13448	21	,	,	,
18637	13448	22	241	241	CD
18637	13448	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13448	24	329	329	CD
18637	13448	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13448	26	1916	1916	CD
18637	13448	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13448	28	.	.	.
18637	13449	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13449	2	723	723	CD
18637	13449	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13449	4	257	257	CD
18637	13449	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13449	6	529	529	CD
18637	13449	7	,	,	,
18637	13449	8	532	532	CD
18637	13449	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13449	10	1922	1922	CD
18637	13449	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13449	12	.	.	.
18637	13450	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13450	2	724	724	CD
18637	13450	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13450	4	25	25	CD
18637	13450	5	Edward	Edward	NNP
18637	13450	6	III	III	NNP
18637	13450	7	,	,	,
18637	13450	8	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13450	9	.	.	.
18637	13451	1	5	5	CD
18637	13451	2	,	,	,
18637	13451	3	Ch	Ch	NNP
18637	13451	4	.	.	.
18637	13452	1	2	2	LS
18637	13452	2	.	.	.
18637	13453	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13453	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13453	3	also	also	RB
18637	13453	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13453	5	Story	Story	NNP
18637	13453	6	's	's	POS
18637	13453	7	Commentaries	commentary	NNS
18637	13453	8	On	on	IN
18637	13453	9	The	the	DT
18637	13453	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13453	11	Of	of	IN
18637	13453	12	The	the	DT
18637	13453	13	United	United	NNP
18637	13453	14	States	States	NNP
18637	13453	15	,	,	,
18637	13453	16	Vol	Vol	NNP
18637	13453	17	.	.	.
18637	13454	1	2	2	CD
18637	13454	2	,	,	,
18637	13454	3	529	529	CD
18637	13454	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	13454	5	540	540	CD
18637	13454	6	,	,	,
18637	13454	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13454	8	5th	5th	JJ
18637	13454	9	ed	ed	NNP
18637	13454	10	.	.	.
18637	13454	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13454	12	.	.	.
18637	13455	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13455	2	725	725	CD
18637	13455	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13455	4	4	4	CD
18637	13455	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13455	6	.	.	.
18637	13456	1	75	75	CD
18637	13456	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13456	3	1807	1807	CD
18637	13456	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13456	5	.	.	.
18637	13457	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13457	2	726	726	CD
18637	13457	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13457	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13457	5	.	.	.
18637	13458	1	75	75	CD
18637	13458	2	,	,	,
18637	13458	3	126	126	CD
18637	13458	4	.	.	.
18637	13459	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13459	2	727	727	CD
18637	13459	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13459	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13459	5	.	.	.
18637	13460	1	126	126	CD
18637	13460	2	.	.	.
18637	13461	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13461	2	728	728	CD
18637	13461	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13461	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13461	5	.	.	.
18637	13462	1	127	127	CD
18637	13462	2	.	.	.
18637	13463	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13463	2	729	729	CD
18637	13463	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13463	4	United	United	NNP
18637	13463	5	States	States	NNP
18637	13463	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13463	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13463	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13463	9	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	13463	10	,	,	,
18637	13463	11	4	4	CD
18637	13463	12	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13463	13	.	.	.
18637	13464	1	470	470	LS
18637	13464	2	,	,	,
18637	13464	3	Appx	Appx	NNP
18637	13464	4	.	.	.
18637	13465	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13465	2	1807	1807	CD
18637	13465	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13465	4	.	.	.
18637	13466	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13466	2	730	730	CD
18637	13466	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13466	4	There	there	EX
18637	13466	5	have	have	VBP
18637	13466	6	been	be	VBN
18637	13466	7	a	a	DT
18637	13466	8	number	number	NN
18637	13466	9	of	of	IN
18637	13466	10	lower	low	JJR
18637	13466	11	court	court	NN
18637	13466	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	13466	13	in	in	IN
18637	13466	14	some	some	DT
18637	13466	15	of	of	IN
18637	13466	16	which	which	WDT
18637	13466	17	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	13466	18	were	be	VBD
18637	13466	19	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13466	20	.	.	.
18637	13467	1	As	as	IN
18637	13467	2	a	a	DT
18637	13467	3	result	result	NN
18637	13467	4	of	of	IN
18637	13467	5	the	the	DT
18637	13467	6	Whiskey	Whiskey	NNP
18637	13467	7	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
18637	13467	8	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	13467	9	of	of	IN
18637	13467	10	treason	treason	NN
18637	13467	11	were	be	VBD
18637	13467	12	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13467	13	on	on	IN
18637	13467	14	the	the	DT
18637	13467	15	basis	basis	NN
18637	13467	16	of	of	IN
18637	13467	17	the	the	DT
18637	13467	18	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	13467	19	that	that	IN
18637	13467	20	forcible	forcible	JJ
18637	13467	21	resistance	resistance	NN
18637	13467	22	to	to	IN
18637	13467	23	the	the	DT
18637	13467	24	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	13467	25	of	of	IN
18637	13467	26	the	the	DT
18637	13467	27	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	13467	28	laws	law	NNS
18637	13467	29	was	be	VBD
18637	13467	30	a	a	DT
18637	13467	31	constructive	constructive	JJ
18637	13467	32	levying	levying	NN
18637	13467	33	of	of	IN
18637	13467	34	war	war	NN
18637	13467	35	.	.	.
18637	13468	1	United	United	NNP
18637	13468	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13468	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13468	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13468	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13468	6	Vigol	Vigol	NNP
18637	13468	7	,	,	,
18637	13468	8	28	28	CD
18637	13468	9	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13468	10	.	.	.
18637	13469	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13469	2	.	.	.
18637	13470	1	No	no	UH
18637	13470	2	.	.	.
18637	13471	1	16,621	16,621	CD
18637	13471	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13471	3	1795	1795	CD
18637	13471	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13471	5	;	;	:
18637	13471	6	United	United	NNP
18637	13471	7	States	States	NNP
18637	13471	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13471	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	13471	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13471	11	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	13471	12	,	,	,
18637	13471	13	26	26	CD
18637	13471	14	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13471	15	.	.	.
18637	13472	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13472	2	.	.	.
18637	13473	1	No	no	UH
18637	13473	2	.	.	.
18637	13474	1	15,788	15,788	CD
18637	13474	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13474	3	1795	1795	CD
18637	13474	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13474	5	.	.	.
18637	13475	1	After	after	IN
18637	13475	2	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	13475	3	,	,	,
18637	13475	4	the	the	DT
18637	13475	5	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	13475	6	were	be	VBD
18637	13475	7	pardoned	pardon	VBN
18637	13475	8	.	.	.
18637	13476	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13476	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13476	3	also	also	RB
18637	13476	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13476	5	for	for	IN
18637	13476	6	the	the	DT
18637	13476	7	same	same	JJ
18637	13476	8	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	13476	9	in	in	IN
18637	13476	10	a	a	DT
18637	13476	11	different	different	JJ
18637	13476	12	situation	situation	NN
18637	13476	13	the	the	DT
18637	13476	14	Case	Case	NNP
18637	13476	15	of	of	IN
18637	13476	16	Fries	Fries	NNP
18637	13476	17	,	,	,
18637	13476	18	9	9	CD
18637	13476	19	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13476	20	.	.	.
18637	13477	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13477	2	.	.	.
18637	13478	1	Nos	nos	UH
18637	13478	2	.	.	.
18637	13479	1	5,126	5,126	CD
18637	13479	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13479	3	1799	1799	CD
18637	13479	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13479	5	;	;	:
18637	13479	6	5,127	5,127	CD
18637	13479	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13479	8	1800	1800	CD
18637	13479	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13479	10	.	.	.
18637	13480	1	The	the	DT
18637	13480	2	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13480	3	was	be	VBD
18637	13480	4	again	again	RB
18637	13480	5	pardoned	pardon	VBN
18637	13480	6	after	after	IN
18637	13480	7	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	13480	8	.	.	.
18637	13481	1	About	about	RB
18637	13481	2	a	a	DT
18637	13481	3	half	half	JJ
18637	13481	4	century	century	NN
18637	13481	5	later	later	JJ
18637	13481	6	participation	participation	NN
18637	13481	7	in	in	IN
18637	13481	8	forcible	forcible	JJ
18637	13481	9	resistance	resistance	NN
18637	13481	10	to	to	IN
18637	13481	11	the	the	DT
18637	13481	12	Fugitive	Fugitive	NNP
18637	13481	13	Slave	Slave	NNP
18637	13481	14	Law	Law	NNP
18637	13481	15	was	be	VBD
18637	13481	16	held	hold	VBN
18637	13481	17	not	not	RB
18637	13481	18	to	to	TO
18637	13481	19	be	be	VB
18637	13481	20	a	a	DT
18637	13481	21	constructive	constructive	JJ
18637	13481	22	levying	levying	NN
18637	13481	23	of	of	IN
18637	13481	24	war	war	NN
18637	13481	25	.	.	.
18637	13482	1	United	United	NNP
18637	13482	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13482	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13482	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13482	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13482	6	Hanway	Hanway	NNP
18637	13482	7	,	,	,
18637	13482	8	26	26	CD
18637	13482	9	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13482	10	.	.	.
18637	13483	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13483	2	.	.	.
18637	13484	1	No	no	UH
18637	13484	2	.	.	.
18637	13485	1	15,299	15,299	CD
18637	13485	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13485	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	13485	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13485	5	.	.	.
18637	13486	1	Although	although	IN
18637	13486	2	the	the	DT
18637	13486	3	United	United	NNP
18637	13486	4	States	States	NNP
18637	13486	5	Government	Government	NNP
18637	13486	6	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	13486	7	the	the	DT
18637	13486	8	activities	activity	NNS
18637	13486	9	of	of	IN
18637	13486	10	the	the	DT
18637	13486	11	Confederate	Confederate	NNP
18637	13486	12	States	States	NNP
18637	13486	13	as	as	IN
18637	13486	14	a	a	DT
18637	13486	15	levying	levying	NN
18637	13486	16	of	of	IN
18637	13486	17	war	war	NN
18637	13486	18	,	,	,
18637	13486	19	the	the	DT
18637	13486	20	President	President	NNP
18637	13486	21	by	by	IN
18637	13486	22	Amnesty	Amnesty	NNP
18637	13486	23	Proclamation	Proclamation	NNP
18637	13486	24	of	of	IN
18637	13486	25	December	December	NNP
18637	13486	26	25	25	CD
18637	13486	27	,	,	,
18637	13486	28	1868	1868	CD
18637	13486	29	,	,	,
18637	13486	30	pardoned	pardon	VBD
18637	13486	31	all	all	PDT
18637	13486	32	those	those	DT
18637	13486	33	who	who	WP
18637	13486	34	had	have	VBD
18637	13486	35	participated	participate	VBN
18637	13486	36	on	on	IN
18637	13486	37	the	the	DT
18637	13486	38	southern	southern	JJ
18637	13486	39	side	side	NN
18637	13486	40	in	in	IN
18637	13486	41	the	the	DT
18637	13486	42	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	13486	43	War	War	NNP
18637	13486	44	.	.	.
18637	13487	1	In	in	IN
18637	13487	2	applying	apply	VBG
18637	13487	3	the	the	DT
18637	13487	4	Captured	Captured	NNP
18637	13487	5	and	and	CC
18637	13487	6	Abandoned	Abandoned	NNP
18637	13487	7	Property	Property	NNP
18637	13487	8	Act	Act	NNP
18637	13487	9	of	of	IN
18637	13487	10	1863	1863	CD
18637	13487	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13487	12	12	12	CD
18637	13487	13	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	13487	14	.	.	.
18637	13488	1	820	820	CD
18637	13488	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13488	3	in	in	IN
18637	13488	4	a	a	DT
18637	13488	5	civil	civil	JJ
18637	13488	6	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13488	7	,	,	,
18637	13488	8	the	the	DT
18637	13488	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13488	10	declared	declare	VBD
18637	13488	11	that	that	IN
18637	13488	12	the	the	DT
18637	13488	13	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	13488	14	of	of	IN
18637	13488	15	the	the	DT
18637	13488	16	Confederacy	Confederacy	NNP
18637	13488	17	was	be	VBD
18637	13488	18	treason	treason	NN
18637	13488	19	against	against	IN
18637	13488	20	the	the	DT
18637	13488	21	United	United	NNP
18637	13488	22	States	States	NNP
18637	13488	23	.	.	.
18637	13489	1	Sprott	Sprott	NNP
18637	13489	2	_	_	NNP
18637	13489	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	13489	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13489	5	United	United	NNP
18637	13489	6	States	States	NNP
18637	13489	7	,	,	,
18637	13489	8	20	20	CD
18637	13489	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13489	10	.	.	.
18637	13490	1	459	459	CD
18637	13490	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13490	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	13490	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13490	5	.	.	.
18637	13491	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13491	2	See	See	NNP
18637	13491	3	also	also	RB
18637	13491	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13491	5	Hanauer	Hanauer	NNP
18637	13491	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13491	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13491	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13491	9	Doane	Doane	NNP
18637	13491	10	,	,	,
18637	13491	11	12	12	CD
18637	13491	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13491	13	.	.	.
18637	13492	1	342	342	CD
18637	13492	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13492	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	13492	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13492	5	;	;	:
18637	13492	6	Thorington	Thorington	NNP
18637	13492	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13492	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13492	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13492	10	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	13492	11	,	,	,
18637	13492	12	8	8	CD
18637	13492	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13492	14	.	.	.
18637	13493	1	1	1	CD
18637	13493	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13493	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	13493	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13493	5	;	;	:
18637	13493	6	Young	Young	NNP
18637	13493	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13493	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13493	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13493	10	United	United	NNP
18637	13493	11	States	States	NNP
18637	13493	12	,	,	,
18637	13493	13	97	97	CD
18637	13493	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13493	15	39	39	CD
18637	13493	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13493	17	1878	1878	CD
18637	13493	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13493	19	.	.	.
18637	13494	1	These	these	DT
18637	13494	2	four	four	CD
18637	13494	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	13494	4	bring	bring	VBP
18637	13494	5	in	in	RB
18637	13494	6	the	the	DT
18637	13494	7	concept	concept	NN
18637	13494	8	of	of	IN
18637	13494	9	adhering	adhere	VBG
18637	13494	10	to	to	IN
18637	13494	11	the	the	DT
18637	13494	12	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	13494	13	and	and	CC
18637	13494	14	giving	give	VBG
18637	13494	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13494	16	aid	aid	NN
18637	13494	17	and	and	CC
18637	13494	18	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	13494	19	,	,	,
18637	13494	20	but	but	CC
18637	13494	21	these	these	DT
18637	13494	22	are	be	VBP
18637	13494	23	not	not	RB
18637	13494	24	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	13494	25	cases	case	NNS
18637	13494	26	and	and	CC
18637	13494	27	deal	deal	VB
18637	13494	28	with	with	IN
18637	13494	29	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	13494	30	to	to	TO
18637	13494	31	recover	recover	VB
18637	13494	32	property	property	NN
18637	13494	33	under	under	IN
18637	13494	34	the	the	DT
18637	13494	35	Captured	Captured	NNP
18637	13494	36	and	and	CC
18637	13494	37	Abandoned	Abandoned	NNP
18637	13494	38	Property	Property	NNP
18637	13494	39	Act	Act	NNP
18637	13494	40	by	by	IN
18637	13494	41	persons	person	NNS
18637	13494	42	who	who	WP
18637	13494	43	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	13494	44	that	that	IN
18637	13494	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13494	46	had	have	VBD
18637	13494	47	given	give	VBN
18637	13494	48	no	no	DT
18637	13494	49	aid	aid	NN
18637	13494	50	or	or	CC
18637	13494	51	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	13494	52	to	to	IN
18637	13494	53	the	the	DT
18637	13494	54	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	13494	55	.	.	.
18637	13495	1	These	these	DT
18637	13495	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	13495	3	are	be	VBP
18637	13495	4	not	not	RB
18637	13495	5	,	,	,
18637	13495	6	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	13495	7	,	,	,
18637	13495	8	an	an	DT
18637	13495	9	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	13495	10	of	of	IN
18637	13495	11	the	the	DT
18637	13495	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13495	13	.	.	.
18637	13496	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13496	2	731	731	CD
18637	13496	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13496	4	325	325	CD
18637	13496	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13496	6	1	1	CD
18637	13496	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13496	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	13496	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13496	10	.	.	.
18637	13497	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13497	2	732	732	CD
18637	13497	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13497	4	89	89	CD
18637	13497	5	Law	Law	NNP
18637	13497	6	.	.	.
18637	13498	1	Ed	Ed	NNP
18637	13498	2	.	.	.
18637	13499	1	1443	1443	CD
18637	13499	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13499	3	1444	1444	CD
18637	13499	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13499	5	Argument	Argument	NNP
18637	13499	6	of	of	IN
18637	13499	7	Counsel	Counsel	NNP
18637	13499	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13499	9	.	.	.
18637	13500	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13500	2	733	733	CD
18637	13500	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13500	4	325	325	CD
18637	13500	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13500	6	35	35	CD
18637	13500	7	.	.	.
18637	13501	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13501	2	734	734	CD
18637	13501	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13501	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13501	5	.	.	.
18637	13502	1	34	34	CD
18637	13502	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13502	3	35	35	CD
18637	13502	4	.	.	.
18637	13503	1	Earlier	early	RBR
18637	13503	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13503	3	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	13503	4	had	have	VBD
18637	13503	5	declared	declare	VBN
18637	13503	6	that	that	IN
18637	13503	7	this	this	DT
18637	13503	8	phase	phase	NN
18637	13503	9	of	of	IN
18637	13503	10	treason	treason	NN
18637	13503	11	consists	consist	VBZ
18637	13503	12	of	of	IN
18637	13503	13	two	two	CD
18637	13503	14	elements	element	NNS
18637	13503	15	:	:	:
18637	13503	16	"	"	``
18637	13503	17	adherence	adherence	NN
18637	13503	18	to	to	IN
18637	13503	19	the	the	DT
18637	13503	20	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	13503	21	;	;	:
18637	13503	22	and	and	CC
18637	13503	23	rendering	render	VBG
18637	13503	24	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13503	25	aid	aid	NN
18637	13503	26	and	and	CC
18637	13503	27	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	13503	28	.	.	.
18637	13503	29	"	"	''
18637	13504	1	A	a	DT
18637	13504	2	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	13504	3	,	,	,
18637	13504	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13504	5	was	be	VBD
18637	13504	6	said	say	VBN
18637	13504	7	,	,	,
18637	13504	8	may	may	MD
18637	13504	9	take	take	VB
18637	13504	10	actions	action	NNS
18637	13504	11	"	"	``
18637	13504	12	which	which	WDT
18637	13504	13	do	do	VBP
18637	13504	14	aid	aid	NN
18637	13504	15	and	and	CC
18637	13504	16	comfort	comfort	VB
18637	13504	17	the	the	DT
18637	13504	18	enemy--	enemy--	NNP
18637	13504	19	*	*	NFP
18637	13504	20	*	*	NFP
18637	13504	21	*	*	NFP
18637	13504	22	--but	--but	:
18637	13504	23	if	if	IN
18637	13504	24	there	there	EX
18637	13504	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	13504	26	no	no	DT
18637	13504	27	adherence	adherence	NN
18637	13504	28	to	to	IN
18637	13504	29	the	the	DT
18637	13504	30	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	13504	31	in	in	IN
18637	13504	32	this	this	DT
18637	13504	33	,	,	,
18637	13504	34	if	if	IN
18637	13504	35	there	there	EX
18637	13504	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	13504	37	no	no	DT
18637	13504	38	intent	intent	NN
18637	13504	39	to	to	TO
18637	13504	40	betray	betray	VB
18637	13504	41	,	,	,
18637	13504	42	there	there	EX
18637	13504	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	13504	44	no	no	DT
18637	13504	45	treason	treason	NN
18637	13504	46	.	.	.
18637	13504	47	"	"	''
18637	13505	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	13505	2	.	.	.
18637	13506	1	29	29	CD
18637	13506	2	.	.	.
18637	13507	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13507	2	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	13507	3	states	state	VBZ
18637	13507	4	erroneously	erroneously	RB
18637	13507	5	that	that	IN
18637	13507	6	the	the	DT
18637	13507	7	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	13507	8	of	of	IN
18637	13507	9	two	two	CD
18637	13507	10	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	13507	11	to	to	IN
18637	13507	12	the	the	DT
18637	13507	13	same	same	JJ
18637	13507	14	overt	overt	JJ
18637	13507	15	act	act	NN
18637	13507	16	was	be	VBD
18637	13507	17	an	an	DT
18637	13507	18	original	original	JJ
18637	13507	19	invention	invention	NN
18637	13507	20	of	of	IN
18637	13507	21	the	the	DT
18637	13507	22	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	13507	23	of	of	IN
18637	13507	24	1787	1787	CD
18637	13507	25	.	.	.
18637	13508	1	Actually	actually	RB
18637	13508	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13508	3	comes	come	VBZ
18637	13508	4	from	from	IN
18637	13508	5	the	the	DT
18637	13508	6	British	british	JJ
18637	13508	7	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	13508	8	Trials	Trials	NNPS
18637	13508	9	Act	Act	NNP
18637	13508	10	of	of	IN
18637	13508	11	1696	1696	CD
18637	13508	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13508	13	7	7	CD
18637	13508	14	and	and	CC
18637	13508	15	8	8	CD
18637	13508	16	Wm	Wm	NNS
18637	13508	17	.	.	.
18637	13509	1	III	III	NNP
18637	13509	2	,	,	,
18637	13509	3	C.	C.	NNP
18637	13509	4	3	3	CD
18637	13509	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13509	6	.	.	.
18637	13510	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13510	2	735	735	CD
18637	13510	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13510	4	330	330	CD
18637	13510	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13510	6	631	631	CD
18637	13510	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13510	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	13510	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13510	10	.	.	.
18637	13511	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13511	2	736	736	CD
18637	13511	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13511	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13511	5	.	.	.
18637	13512	1	635	635	CD
18637	13512	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13512	3	636	636	CD
18637	13512	4	.	.	.
18637	13513	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13513	2	737	737	CD
18637	13513	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13513	4	330	330	CD
18637	13513	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13513	6	631	631	CD
18637	13513	7	,	,	,
18637	13513	8	645	645	CD
18637	13513	9	-	-	SYM
18637	13513	10	646	646	CD
18637	13513	11	.	.	.
18637	13514	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13514	2	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	13514	3	cites	cite	VBZ
18637	13514	4	no	no	DT
18637	13514	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	13514	6	for	for	IN
18637	13514	7	these	these	DT
18637	13514	8	propositions	proposition	NNS
18637	13514	9	.	.	.
18637	13515	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13515	2	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	13515	3	in	in	IN
18637	13515	4	a	a	DT
18637	13515	5	solitary	solitary	JJ
18637	13515	6	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	13515	7	stated	state	VBD
18637	13515	8	:	:	:
18637	13515	9	"	"	``
18637	13515	10	But	but	CC
18637	13515	11	the	the	DT
18637	13515	12	act	act	NN
18637	13515	13	of	of	IN
18637	13515	14	providing	provide	VBG
18637	13515	15	shelter	shelter	NN
18637	13515	16	was	be	VBD
18637	13515	17	of	of	IN
18637	13515	18	the	the	DT
18637	13515	19	type	type	NN
18637	13515	20	that	that	WDT
18637	13515	21	might	may	MD
18637	13515	22	naturally	naturally	RB
18637	13515	23	arise	arise	VB
18637	13515	24	out	out	IN
18637	13515	25	of	of	IN
18637	13515	26	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	13515	27	's	's	POS
18637	13515	28	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	13515	29	to	to	IN
18637	13515	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13515	31	son	son	NN
18637	13515	32	,	,	,
18637	13515	33	as	as	IN
18637	13515	34	the	the	DT
18637	13515	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13515	36	recognizes	recognize	VBZ
18637	13515	37	.	.	.
18637	13516	1	By	by	IN
18637	13516	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13516	3	very	very	JJ
18637	13516	4	nature	nature	NN
18637	13516	5	,	,	,
18637	13516	6	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	13516	7	,	,	,
18637	13516	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13516	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	13516	10	a	a	DT
18637	13516	11	non	non	JJ
18637	13516	12	-	-	JJ
18637	13516	13	treasonous	treasonous	JJ
18637	13516	14	act	act	NN
18637	13516	15	.	.	.
18637	13517	1	That	that	DT
18637	13517	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	13517	3	true	true	JJ
18637	13517	4	even	even	RB
18637	13517	5	when	when	WRB
18637	13517	6	the	the	DT
18637	13517	7	act	act	NN
18637	13517	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	13517	9	viewed	view	VBN
18637	13517	10	in	in	IN
18637	13517	11	light	light	NN
18637	13517	12	of	of	IN
18637	13517	13	all	all	PDT
18637	13517	14	the	the	DT
18637	13517	15	surrounding	surround	VBG
18637	13517	16	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	13517	17	.	.	.
18637	13518	1	All	all	DT
18637	13518	2	that	that	WDT
18637	13518	3	can	can	MD
18637	13518	4	be	be	VB
18637	13518	5	said	say	VBN
18637	13518	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	13518	7	that	that	IN
18637	13518	8	the	the	DT
18637	13518	9	problem	problem	NN
18637	13518	10	of	of	IN
18637	13518	11	whether	whether	IN
18637	13518	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13518	13	was	be	VBD
18637	13518	14	motivated	motivate	VBN
18637	13518	15	by	by	IN
18637	13518	16	treasonous	treasonous	JJ
18637	13518	17	or	or	CC
18637	13518	18	non	non	JJ
18637	13518	19	-	-	JJ
18637	13518	20	treasonous	treasonous	JJ
18637	13518	21	factors	factor	NNS
18637	13518	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	13518	23	left	leave	VBN
18637	13518	24	in	in	IN
18637	13518	25	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	13518	26	.	.	.
18637	13519	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13519	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	13519	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	13519	4	not	not	RB
18637	13519	5	an	an	DT
18637	13519	6	overt	overt	JJ
18637	13519	7	act	act	NN
18637	13519	8	of	of	IN
18637	13519	9	treason	treason	NN
18637	13519	10	,	,	,
18637	13519	11	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	13519	12	of	of	IN
18637	13519	13	how	how	WRB
18637	13519	14	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	13519	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13519	16	might	may	MD
18637	13519	17	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	13519	18	be	be	VB
18637	13519	19	.	.	.
18637	13519	20	"	"	''
18637	13520	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	13520	2	.	.	.
18637	13521	1	649	649	CD
18637	13521	2	.	.	.
18637	13522	1	The	the	DT
18637	13522	2	following	follow	VBG
18637	13522	3	summary	summary	NN
18637	13522	4	,	,	,
18637	13522	5	taken	take	VBN
18637	13522	6	from	from	IN
18637	13522	7	the	the	DT
18637	13522	8	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
18637	13522	9	to	to	IN
18637	13522	10	the	the	DT
18637	13522	11	Government	Government	NNP
18637	13522	12	's	's	POS
18637	13522	13	brief	brief	NN
18637	13522	14	in	in	IN
18637	13522	15	Cramer	Cramer	NNP
18637	13522	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13522	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	13522	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13522	19	United	United	NNP
18637	13522	20	States	States	NNP
18637	13522	21	,	,	,
18637	13522	22	325	325	CD
18637	13522	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13522	24	1	1	CD
18637	13522	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13522	26	1945	1945	CD
18637	13522	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13522	28	,	,	,
18637	13522	29	and	and	CC
18637	13522	30	incorporated	incorporate	VBD
18637	13522	31	as	as	IN
18637	13522	32	note	note	NN
18637	13522	33	38	38	CD
18637	13522	34	in	in	IN
18637	13522	35	the	the	DT
18637	13522	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13522	37	's	's	POS
18637	13522	38	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	13522	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13522	40	pp	pp	NNP
18637	13522	41	.	.	.
18637	13523	1	25	25	CD
18637	13523	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13523	3	26	26	CD
18637	13523	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13523	5	,	,	,
18637	13523	6	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	13523	7	all	all	PDT
18637	13523	8	the	the	DT
18637	13523	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	13523	10	in	in	IN
18637	13523	11	which	which	WDT
18637	13523	12	,	,	,
18637	13523	13	prior	prior	RB
18637	13523	14	to	to	IN
18637	13523	15	Kawakita	Kawakita	NNP
18637	13523	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13523	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	13523	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13523	19	United	United	NNP
18637	13523	20	States	States	NNP
18637	13523	21	,	,	,
18637	13523	22	which	which	WDT
18637	13523	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	13523	24	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	13523	25	with	with	IN
18637	13523	26	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	13523	27	below	below	IN
18637	13523	28	,	,	,
18637	13523	29	construction	construction	NN
18637	13523	30	of	of	IN
18637	13523	31	the	the	DT
18637	13523	32	treason	treason	NN
18637	13523	33	clause	clause	NN
18637	13523	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	13523	35	been	be	VBN
18637	13523	36	involved	involve	VBN
18637	13523	37	except	except	IN
18637	13523	38	grand	grand	JJ
18637	13523	39	jury	jury	NN
18637	13523	40	charges	charge	NNS
18637	13523	41	and	and	CC
18637	13523	42	cases	case	NNS
18637	13523	43	to	to	TO
18637	13523	44	which	which	WDT
18637	13523	45	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	13523	46	of	of	IN
18637	13523	47	the	the	DT
18637	13523	48	clause	clause	NN
18637	13523	49	was	be	VBD
18637	13523	50	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	13523	51	:	:	:
18637	13523	52	Whiskey	Whiskey	NNP
18637	13523	53	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
18637	13523	54	cases	case	NNS
18637	13523	55	:	:	:
18637	13523	56	United	United	NNP
18637	13523	57	States	States	NNP
18637	13523	58	_	_	NNP
18637	13523	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	13523	60	_	_	NNP
18637	13523	61	Vigol	Vigol	NNP
18637	13523	62	,	,	,
18637	13523	63	28	28	CD
18637	13523	64	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13523	65	.	.	.
18637	13524	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13524	2	.	.	.
18637	13525	1	No	no	UH
18637	13525	2	.	.	.
18637	13526	1	16,621	16,621	CD
18637	13526	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13526	3	1795	1795	CD
18637	13526	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13526	5	,	,	,
18637	13526	6	United	United	NNP
18637	13526	7	States	States	NNP
18637	13526	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13526	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	13526	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13526	11	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	13526	12	,	,	,
18637	13526	13	26	26	CD
18637	13526	14	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13526	15	.	.	.
18637	13527	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13527	2	.	.	.
18637	13528	1	No	no	UH
18637	13528	2	.	.	.
18637	13529	1	15,788	15,788	CD
18637	13529	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13529	3	1795	1795	CD
18637	13529	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13529	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13529	6	constructive	constructive	JJ
18637	13529	7	levying	levying	NN
18637	13529	8	of	of	IN
18637	13529	9	war	war	NN
18637	13529	10	,	,	,
18637	13529	11	based	base	VBN
18637	13529	12	on	on	IN
18637	13529	13	forcible	forcible	JJ
18637	13529	14	resistance	resistance	NN
18637	13529	15	to	to	IN
18637	13529	16	execution	execution	NN
18637	13529	17	of	of	IN
18637	13529	18	a	a	DT
18637	13529	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	13529	20	;	;	:
18637	13529	21	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	13529	22	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	13529	23	and	and	CC
18637	13529	24	later	later	RB
18637	13529	25	pardoned	pardon	VBN
18637	13529	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13529	27	.	.	.
18637	13530	1	House	House	NNP
18637	13530	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	13530	3	case	case	NN
18637	13530	4	:	:	:
18637	13530	5	Fries	Fries	NNP
18637	13530	6	's	's	POS
18637	13530	7	Case	Case	NNP
18637	13530	8	,	,	,
18637	13530	9	9	9	CD
18637	13530	10	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13530	11	.	.	.
18637	13531	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13531	2	.	.	.
18637	13532	1	Nos	nos	UH
18637	13532	2	.	.	.
18637	13533	1	5,126	5,126	CD
18637	13533	2	,	,	,
18637	13533	3	5,127	5,127	CD
18637	13533	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13533	5	1799	1799	CD
18637	13533	6	,	,	,
18637	13533	7	1800	1800	CD
18637	13533	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13533	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13533	10	constructive	constructive	JJ
18637	13533	11	levying	levying	NN
18637	13533	12	of	of	IN
18637	13533	13	war	war	NN
18637	13533	14	,	,	,
18637	13533	15	based	base	VBN
18637	13533	16	on	on	IN
18637	13533	17	forcible	forcible	JJ
18637	13533	18	resistance	resistance	NN
18637	13533	19	to	to	IN
18637	13533	20	execution	execution	NN
18637	13533	21	of	of	IN
18637	13533	22	a	a	DT
18637	13533	23	statute	statute	NN
18637	13533	24	;	;	:
18637	13533	25	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13533	26	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	13533	27	and	and	CC
18637	13533	28	later	later	RB
18637	13533	29	pardoned	pardon	VBN
18637	13533	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13533	31	.	.	.
18637	13534	1	The	the	DT
18637	13534	2	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	13534	3	Conspiracy	Conspiracy	NNP
18637	13534	4	:	:	:
18637	13534	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13534	6	parte	parte	NN
18637	13534	7	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	13534	8	,	,	,
18637	13534	9	4	4	CD
18637	13534	10	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13534	11	.	.	.
18637	13535	1	75	75	CD
18637	13535	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13535	3	1807	1807	CD
18637	13535	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13535	5	;	;	:
18637	13535	6	United	United	NNP
18637	13535	7	States	States	NNP
18637	13535	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13535	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	13535	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13535	11	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	13535	12	,	,	,
18637	13535	13	25	25	CD
18637	13535	14	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13535	15	.	.	.
18637	13536	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13536	2	.	.	.
18637	13537	1	Nos	nos	UH
18637	13537	2	.	.	.
18637	13538	1	14,692a	14,692a	CD
18637	13538	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13538	3	1806	1806	CD
18637	13538	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13538	5	;	;	:
18637	13538	6	14,693	14,693	CD
18637	13538	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13538	8	1807	1807	CD
18637	13538	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13538	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13538	11	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	13538	12	to	to	TO
18637	13538	13	levy	levy	VB
18637	13538	14	war	war	NN
18637	13538	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	13538	16	not	not	RB
18637	13538	17	an	an	DT
18637	13538	18	overt	overt	JJ
18637	13538	19	act	act	NN
18637	13538	20	of	of	IN
18637	13538	21	levying	levy	VBG
18637	13538	22	war	war	NN
18637	13538	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13538	24	.	.	.
18637	13539	1	United	United	NNP
18637	13539	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13539	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13539	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13539	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13539	6	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	13539	7	,	,	,
18637	13539	8	26	26	CD
18637	13539	9	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13539	10	.	.	.
18637	13540	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13540	2	.	.	.
18637	13541	1	No	no	UH
18637	13541	2	.	.	.
18637	13542	1	15,584	15,584	CD
18637	13542	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13542	3	1814	1814	CD
18637	13542	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13542	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13542	6	sale	sale	NN
18637	13542	7	of	of	IN
18637	13542	8	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	13542	9	a	a	DT
18637	13542	10	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	13542	11	overt	overt	JJ
18637	13542	12	act	act	NN
18637	13542	13	;	;	:
18637	13542	14	acquittal	acquittal	NNP
18637	13542	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13542	16	.	.	.
18637	13543	1	United	United	NNP
18637	13543	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13543	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13543	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13543	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13543	6	Hodges	Hodges	NNPS
18637	13543	7	,	,	,
18637	13543	8	26	26	CD
18637	13543	9	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13543	10	.	.	.
18637	13544	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13544	2	No	no	UH
18637	13544	3	.	.	.
18637	13545	1	15,374	15,374	CD
18637	13545	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13545	3	1815	1815	CD
18637	13545	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13545	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13545	6	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	13545	7	release	release	NN
18637	13545	8	of	of	IN
18637	13545	9	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
18637	13545	10	to	to	IN
18637	13545	11	the	the	DT
18637	13545	12	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	13545	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	13545	14	adhering	adhere	VBG
18637	13545	15	to	to	IN
18637	13545	16	the	the	DT
18637	13545	17	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	13545	18	,	,	,
18637	13545	19	the	the	DT
18637	13545	20	act	act	NN
18637	13545	21	showing	show	VBG
18637	13545	22	the	the	DT
18637	13545	23	intent	intent	NN
18637	13545	24	;	;	:
18637	13545	25	acquittal	acquittal	JJ
18637	13545	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13545	27	.	.	.
18637	13546	1	United	United	NNP
18637	13546	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13546	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13546	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13546	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13546	6	Hoxie	Hoxie	NNP
18637	13546	7	,	,	,
18637	13546	8	26	26	CD
18637	13546	9	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13546	10	.	.	.
18637	13547	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13547	2	.	.	.
18637	13548	1	No	no	UH
18637	13548	2	.	.	.
18637	13549	1	15,407	15,407	CD
18637	13549	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13549	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	13549	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13549	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13549	6	attack	attack	NN
18637	13549	7	of	of	IN
18637	13549	8	smugglers	smuggler	NNS
18637	13549	9	on	on	IN
18637	13549	10	troops	troop	NNS
18637	13549	11	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	13549	12	embargo	embargo	NN
18637	13549	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	13549	14	riot	riot	NN
18637	13549	15	and	and	CC
18637	13549	16	not	not	RB
18637	13549	17	levying	levy	VBG
18637	13549	18	of	of	IN
18637	13549	19	war	war	NN
18637	13549	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13549	21	.	.	.
18637	13550	1	United	United	NNP
18637	13550	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13550	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13550	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13550	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13550	6	Pryor	Pryor	NNP
18637	13550	7	,	,	,
18637	13550	8	27	27	CD
18637	13550	9	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13550	10	.	.	.
18637	13551	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13551	2	.	.	.
18637	13552	1	No	no	UH
18637	13552	2	.	.	.
18637	13553	1	16,096	16,096	CD
18637	13553	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13553	3	1814	1814	CD
18637	13553	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13553	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13553	6	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	13553	7	under	under	IN
18637	13553	8	flag	flag	NN
18637	13553	9	of	of	IN
18637	13553	10	truce	truce	NN
18637	13553	11	with	with	IN
18637	13553	12	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	13553	13	detachment	detachment	NN
18637	13553	14	to	to	TO
18637	13553	15	help	help	VB
18637	13553	16	buy	buy	VB
18637	13553	17	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	13553	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	13553	19	too	too	RB
18637	13553	20	remote	remote	JJ
18637	13553	21	an	an	DT
18637	13553	22	act	act	NN
18637	13553	23	to	to	TO
18637	13553	24	establish	establish	VB
18637	13553	25	adhering	adhere	VBG
18637	13553	26	to	to	IN
18637	13553	27	the	the	DT
18637	13553	28	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	13553	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13553	30	.	.	.
18637	13554	1	United	United	NNP
18637	13554	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13554	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13554	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13554	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13554	6	Hanway	Hanway	NNP
18637	13554	7	,	,	,
18637	13554	8	26	26	CD
18637	13554	9	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13554	10	.	.	.
18637	13555	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13555	2	.	.	.
18637	13556	1	No	no	UH
18637	13556	2	.	.	.
18637	13557	1	15,299	15,299	CD
18637	13557	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13557	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	13557	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13557	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13557	6	forcible	forcible	JJ
18637	13557	7	resistance	resistance	NN
18637	13557	8	to	to	IN
18637	13557	9	execution	execution	NN
18637	13557	10	of	of	IN
18637	13557	11	Fugitive	Fugitive	NNP
18637	13557	12	Slave	Slave	NNP
18637	13557	13	Law	Law	NNP
18637	13557	14	no	no	DT
18637	13557	15	levying	levying	NN
18637	13557	16	of	of	IN
18637	13557	17	war	war	NN
18637	13557	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13557	19	.	.	.
18637	13558	1	United	United	NNP
18637	13558	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13558	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13558	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13558	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13558	6	Greiner	Greiner	NNP
18637	13558	7	,	,	,
18637	13558	8	26	26	CD
18637	13558	9	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13558	10	.	.	.
18637	13559	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13559	2	.	.	.
18637	13560	1	No	no	UH
18637	13560	2	.	.	.
18637	13561	1	15,262	15,262	CD
18637	13561	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13561	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	13561	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13561	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13561	6	participation	participation	NN
18637	13561	7	as	as	IN
18637	13561	8	members	member	NNS
18637	13561	9	of	of	IN
18637	13561	10	state	state	NNP
18637	13561	11	militia	militia	NNP
18637	13561	12	company	company	NN
18637	13561	13	in	in	IN
18637	13561	14	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	13561	15	of	of	IN
18637	13561	16	a	a	DT
18637	13561	17	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13561	18	fort	fort	NN
18637	13561	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	13561	20	a	a	DT
18637	13561	21	levying	levying	NN
18637	13561	22	of	of	IN
18637	13561	23	war	war	NN
18637	13561	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13561	25	.	.	.
18637	13562	1	United	United	NNP
18637	13562	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13562	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13562	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13562	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13562	6	Greathouse	Greathouse	NNP
18637	13562	7	,	,	,
18637	13562	8	26	26	CD
18637	13562	9	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13562	10	.	.	.
18637	13563	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13563	2	.	.	.
18637	13564	1	No	no	UH
18637	13564	2	.	.	.
18637	13565	1	15,254	15,254	CD
18637	13565	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13565	3	1863	1863	CD
18637	13565	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13565	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13565	6	fitting	fit	VBG
18637	13565	7	out	out	RP
18637	13565	8	and	and	CC
18637	13565	9	sailing	sail	VBG
18637	13565	10	a	a	DT
18637	13565	11	privateer	privateer	NN
18637	13565	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	13565	13	a	a	DT
18637	13565	14	levying	levying	NN
18637	13565	15	of	of	IN
18637	13565	16	war	war	NN
18637	13565	17	;	;	:
18637	13565	18	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	13565	19	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	13565	20	,	,	,
18637	13565	21	later	later	RB
18637	13565	22	pardoned	pardon	VBN
18637	13565	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13565	24	.	.	.
18637	13566	1	Cases	case	NNS
18637	13566	2	of	of	IN
18637	13566	3	confiscation	confiscation	NN
18637	13566	4	of	of	IN
18637	13566	5	property	property	NN
18637	13566	6	or	or	CC
18637	13566	7	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	13566	8	to	to	TO
18637	13566	9	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	13566	10	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	13566	11	given	give	VBN
18637	13566	12	in	in	IN
18637	13566	13	connection	connection	NN
18637	13566	14	with	with	IN
18637	13566	15	sale	sale	NN
18637	13566	16	of	of	IN
18637	13566	17	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	13566	18	to	to	IN
18637	13566	19	the	the	DT
18637	13566	20	Confederacy	Confederacy	NNP
18637	13566	21	:	:	:
18637	13566	22	Hanauer	Hanauer	NNP
18637	13566	23	_	_	NNP
18637	13566	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	13566	25	_	_	NNP
18637	13566	26	Doane	Doane	NNP
18637	13566	27	,	,	,
18637	13566	28	12	12	CD
18637	13566	29	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13566	30	.	.	.
18637	13567	1	342	342	CD
18637	13567	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13567	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	13567	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13567	5	;	;	:
18637	13567	6	Carlisle	Carlisle	NNP
18637	13567	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13567	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13567	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13567	10	United	United	NNP
18637	13567	11	States	States	NNP
18637	13567	12	,	,	,
18637	13567	13	16	16	CD
18637	13567	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13567	15	.	.	.
18637	13568	1	147	147	CD
18637	13568	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13568	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	13568	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13568	5	;	;	:
18637	13568	6	Sprott	Sprott	NNP
18637	13568	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13568	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13568	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13568	10	United	United	NNP
18637	13568	11	States	States	NNP
18637	13568	12	,	,	,
18637	13568	13	20	20	CD
18637	13568	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13568	15	.	.	.
18637	13569	1	459	459	CD
18637	13569	2	,	,	,
18637	13569	3	371[Transcriber	371[transcriber	CD
18637	13569	4	's	's	POS
18637	13569	5	Note	note	NN
18637	13569	6	:	:	:
18637	13569	7	"	"	``
18637	13569	8	371	371	CD
18637	13569	9	"	"	''
18637	13569	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	13569	11	incorrect	incorrect	JJ
18637	13569	12	--	--	:
18637	13569	13	case	case	NN
18637	13569	14	occupies	occupy	VBZ
18637	13569	15	20	20	CD
18637	13569	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13569	17	.	.	.
18637	13570	1	459	459	CD
18637	13570	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13570	3	474	474	CD
18637	13570	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13570	5	1874	1874	CD
18637	13570	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13570	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13570	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13570	9	1874	1874	CD
18637	13570	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13570	11	;	;	:
18637	13570	12	United	United	NNP
18637	13570	13	States	States	NNP
18637	13570	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13570	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	13570	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13570	17	Athens	Athens	NNP
18637	13570	18	Armory	Armory	NNP
18637	13570	19	,	,	,
18637	13570	20	24	24	CD
18637	13570	21	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13570	22	.	.	.
18637	13571	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13571	2	.	.	.
18637	13572	1	No	no	UH
18637	13572	2	.	.	.
18637	13573	1	14,473	14,473	CD
18637	13573	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13573	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	13573	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13573	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13573	6	mixed	mix	VBN
18637	13573	7	motive	motive	NN
18637	13573	8	,	,	,
18637	13573	9	involving	involve	VBG
18637	13573	10	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	13573	11	profit	profit	NN
18637	13573	12	,	,	,
18637	13573	13	does	do	VBZ
18637	13573	14	not	not	RB
18637	13573	15	bar	bar	VB
18637	13573	16	finding	finding	NN
18637	13573	17	of	of	IN
18637	13573	18	giving	give	VBG
18637	13573	19	aid	aid	NN
18637	13573	20	and	and	CC
18637	13573	21	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	13573	22	to	to	IN
18637	13573	23	the	the	DT
18637	13573	24	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	13573	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13573	26	.	.	.
18637	13574	1	United	United	NNP
18637	13574	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13574	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13574	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13574	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13574	6	Cathcart	Cathcart	NNP
18637	13574	7	and	and	CC
18637	13574	8	United	United	NNP
18637	13574	9	States	States	NNP
18637	13574	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13574	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	13574	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13574	13	Parmenter	Parmenter	NNP
18637	13574	14	,	,	,
18637	13574	15	25	25	CD
18637	13574	16	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13574	17	.	.	.
18637	13575	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13575	2	.	.	.
18637	13576	1	No	no	UH
18637	13576	2	.	.	.
18637	13577	1	14,756	14,756	CD
18637	13577	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13577	3	1864	1864	CD
18637	13577	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13577	5	.	.	.
18637	13578	1	Chenoweth	Chenoweth	NNP
18637	13578	2	's	's	POS
18637	13578	3	Case	Case	NNP
18637	13578	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13578	5	unreported	unreported	JJ
18637	13578	6	:	:	:
18637	13578	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13578	8	see	see	VBP
18637	13578	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13578	10	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13578	11	parte	parte	VBZ
18637	13578	12	Vallandigham	Vallandigham	NNP
18637	13578	13	,	,	,
18637	13578	14	28	28	CD
18637	13578	15	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13578	16	.	.	.
18637	13579	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13579	2	.	.	.
18637	13580	1	No	no	UH
18637	13580	2	.	.	.
18637	13581	1	16,816	16,816	CD
18637	13581	2	,	,	,
18637	13581	3	at	at	IN
18637	13581	4	888	888	CD
18637	13581	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13581	6	1863	1863	CD
18637	13581	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13581	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13581	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13581	10	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	13581	11	bad	bad	JJ
18637	13581	12	for	for	IN
18637	13581	13	alleging	allege	VBG
18637	13581	14	aiding	aid	VBG
18637	13581	15	and	and	CC
18637	13581	16	abetting	abet	VBG
18637	13581	17	rebels	rebel	NNS
18637	13581	18	,	,	,
18637	13581	19	instead	instead	RB
18637	13581	20	of	of	IN
18637	13581	21	directly	directly	RB
18637	13581	22	charging	charge	VBG
18637	13581	23	levying	levying	NN
18637	13581	24	of	of	IN
18637	13581	25	war	war	NN
18637	13581	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13581	27	.	.	.
18637	13582	1	Case	case	NN
18637	13582	2	of	of	IN
18637	13582	3	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	13582	4	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	13582	5	,	,	,
18637	13582	6	7	7	CD
18637	13582	7	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	13582	8	.	.	.
18637	13583	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	13583	2	.	.	.
18637	13584	1	No	no	UH
18637	13584	2	.	.	.
18637	13585	1	3621a	3621a	CD
18637	13585	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13585	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	13585	4	-	-	SYM
18637	13585	5	71	71	CD
18637	13585	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13585	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13585	8	argument	argument	NN
18637	13585	9	that	that	IN
18637	13585	10	rebels	rebel	NNS
18637	13585	11	whose	whose	WP$
18637	13585	12	government	government	NN
18637	13585	13	achieved	achieve	VBD
18637	13585	14	status	status	NN
18637	13585	15	of	of	IN
18637	13585	16	a	a	DT
18637	13585	17	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	13585	18	belligerent	belligerent	NN
18637	13585	19	could	could	MD
18637	13585	20	not	not	RB
18637	13585	21	be	be	VB
18637	13585	22	held	hold	VBN
18637	13585	23	for	for	IN
18637	13585	24	treason	treason	NN
18637	13585	25	;	;	:
18637	13585	26	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	13585	27	was	be	VBD
18637	13585	28	not	not	RB
18637	13585	29	tried	try	VBN
18637	13585	30	on	on	IN
18637	13585	31	the	the	DT
18637	13585	32	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	13585	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13585	34	;	;	:
18637	13585	35	_	_	NNP
18637	13585	36	see	see	VBP
18637	13585	37	_	_	NNP
18637	13585	38	2	2	CD
18637	13585	39	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	13585	40	,	,	,
18637	13585	41	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13585	42	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13585	43	in	in	IN
18637	13585	44	United	United	NNP
18637	13585	45	States	States	NNP
18637	13585	46	History	History	NNP
18637	13585	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13585	48	1934	1934	CD
18637	13585	49	ed	ed	NNP
18637	13585	50	.	.	.
18637	13585	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13586	1	485	485	CD
18637	13586	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13586	3	487	487	CD
18637	13586	4	;	;	:
18637	13586	5	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	13586	6	,	,	,
18637	13586	7	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	13586	8	of	of	IN
18637	13586	9	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	13586	10	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	13586	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13586	12	1915	1915	CD
18637	13586	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13586	14	25	25	CD
18637	13586	15	Yale	Yale	NNP
18637	13586	16	L.J.	L.J.	NNP
18637	13587	1	669	669	CD
18637	13587	2	.	.	.
18637	13588	1	Philippine	philippine	JJ
18637	13588	2	insurrections	insurrection	NNS
18637	13588	3	:	:	:
18637	13588	4	United	United	NNP
18637	13588	5	States	States	NNP
18637	13588	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13588	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13588	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13588	9	Magtibay	Magtibay	NNP
18637	13588	10	,	,	,
18637	13588	11	2	2	CD
18637	13588	12	Phil	Phil	NNP
18637	13588	13	.	.	.
18637	13589	1	703	703	CD
18637	13589	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13589	3	1903	1903	CD
18637	13589	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13589	5	,	,	,
18637	13589	6	United	United	NNP
18637	13589	7	States	States	NNP
18637	13589	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13589	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	13589	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13589	11	De	De	NNP
18637	13589	12	Los	Los	NNP
18637	13589	13	Reyes	Reyes	NNP
18637	13589	14	,	,	,
18637	13589	15	3	3	CD
18637	13589	16	Phil	Phil	NNP
18637	13589	17	.	.	.
18637	13590	1	349	349	CD
18637	13590	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13590	3	1904	1904	CD
18637	13590	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13590	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13590	6	mere	mere	JJ
18637	13590	7	possession	possession	NN
18637	13590	8	of	of	IN
18637	13590	9	rebel	rebel	NN
18637	13590	10	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	13590	11	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	13590	12	overt	overt	JJ
18637	13590	13	acts	act	NNS
18637	13590	14	;	;	,
18637	13590	15	strict	strict	JJ
18637	13590	16	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	13590	17	of	of	IN
18637	13590	18	two	two	CD
18637	13590	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	13590	20	witness	witness	NN
18637	13590	21	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	13590	22	;	;	:
18637	13590	23	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	13590	24	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	13590	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13590	26	;	;	:
18637	13590	27	United	United	NNP
18637	13590	28	States	States	NNP
18637	13590	29	_	_	NNP
18637	13590	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	13590	31	_	_	NNP
18637	13590	32	Lagnason	Lagnason	NNP
18637	13590	33	,	,	,
18637	13590	34	3	3	CD
18637	13590	35	Phil	Phil	NNP
18637	13590	36	.	.	.
18637	13591	1	472	472	CD
18637	13591	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13591	3	1904	1904	CD
18637	13591	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13591	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13591	6	armed	armed	JJ
18637	13591	7	effort	effort	NN
18637	13591	8	to	to	TO
18637	13591	9	overthrow	overthrow	VB
18637	13591	10	the	the	DT
18637	13591	11	government	government	NN
18637	13591	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	13591	13	levying	levy	VBG
18637	13591	14	war	war	NN
18637	13591	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13591	16	.	.	.
18637	13592	1	United	United	NNP
18637	13592	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13592	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13592	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13592	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13592	6	Fricke	Fricke	NNP
18637	13592	7	,	,	,
18637	13592	8	259	259	CD
18637	13592	9	F.	F.	NNP
18637	13592	10	673	673	CD
18637	13592	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13592	12	1919	1919	CD
18637	13592	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13592	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13592	15	acts	act	NNS
18637	13592	16	"	"	``
18637	13592	17	indifferent	indifferent	JJ
18637	13592	18	"	"	''
18637	13592	19	on	on	IN
18637	13592	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13592	21	face	face	NN
18637	13592	22	held	hold	VBN
18637	13592	23	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	13592	24	overt	overt	JJ
18637	13592	25	acts	act	NNS
18637	13592	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13592	27	.	.	.
18637	13593	1	United	United	NNP
18637	13593	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13593	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13593	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13593	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13593	6	Robinson	Robinson	NNP
18637	13593	7	,	,	,
18637	13593	8	259	259	CD
18637	13593	9	F.	F.	NNP
18637	13593	10	685	685	CD
18637	13593	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13593	12	1919	1919	CD
18637	13593	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13593	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13593	15	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	13593	16	,	,	,
18637	13593	17	acts	act	VBZ
18637	13593	18	harmless	harmless	JJ
18637	13593	19	on	on	IN
18637	13593	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13593	21	face	face	NN
18637	13593	22	are	be	VBP
18637	13593	23	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	13593	24	overt	overt	JJ
18637	13593	25	acts	act	NNS
18637	13593	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13593	27	.	.	.
18637	13594	1	United	United	NNP
18637	13594	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13594	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13594	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13594	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13594	6	Werner	Werner	NNP
18637	13594	7	,	,	,
18637	13594	8	247	247	CD
18637	13594	9	F.	f.	NN
18637	13594	10	708	708	CD
18637	13594	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13594	12	1918	1918	CD
18637	13594	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13594	14	,	,	,
18637	13594	15	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	13594	16	in	in	IN
18637	13594	17	251	251	CD
18637	13594	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13594	19	466	466	CD
18637	13594	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13594	21	1920	1920	CD
18637	13594	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13594	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13594	24	act	act	VB
18637	13594	25	indifferent	indifferent	JJ
18637	13594	26	on	on	IN
18637	13594	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13594	28	face	face	NN
18637	13594	29	may	may	MD
18637	13594	30	be	be	VB
18637	13594	31	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	13594	32	overt	overt	JJ
18637	13594	33	act	act	NN
18637	13594	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13594	35	.	.	.
18637	13595	1	United	United	NNP
18637	13595	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13595	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13595	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13595	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13595	6	Haupt	Haupt	NNP
18637	13595	7	,	,	,
18637	13595	8	136	136	CD
18637	13595	9	F.	F.	NNP
18637	13595	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13595	11	2d	2d	CD
18637	13595	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13595	13	661	661	CD
18637	13595	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13595	15	1943	1943	CD
18637	13595	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13595	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13595	18	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	13595	19	of	of	IN
18637	13595	20	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	13595	21	on	on	IN
18637	13595	22	strict	strict	JJ
18637	13595	23	application	application	NN
18637	13595	24	of	of	IN
18637	13595	25	two	two	CD
18637	13595	26	-	-	HYPH
18637	13595	27	witness	witness	NN
18637	13595	28	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	13595	29	and	and	CC
18637	13595	30	other	other	JJ
18637	13595	31	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	13595	32	;	;	:
18637	13595	33	inferentially	inferentially	RB
18637	13595	34	approves	approve	VBZ
18637	13595	35	acts	act	VBZ
18637	13595	36	harmless	harmless	JJ
18637	13595	37	on	on	IN
18637	13595	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13595	39	face	face	NN
18637	13595	40	as	as	IN
18637	13595	41	overt	overt	JJ
18637	13595	42	acts	act	NNS
18637	13595	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13595	44	.	.	.
18637	13596	1	Stephan	Stephan	NNP
18637	13596	2	_	_	NNP
18637	13596	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	13596	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13596	5	United	United	NNP
18637	13596	6	States	States	NNP
18637	13596	7	,	,	,
18637	13596	8	133	133	CD
18637	13596	9	F.	F.	NNP
18637	13596	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13596	11	2d	2d	NNP
18637	13596	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13596	13	87	87	CD
18637	13596	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13596	15	1943	1943	CD
18637	13596	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13596	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13596	18	acts	act	VBZ
18637	13596	19	harmless	harmless	JJ
18637	13596	20	on	on	IN
18637	13596	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13596	22	face	face	NN
18637	13596	23	may	may	MD
18637	13596	24	be	be	VB
18637	13596	25	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	13596	26	overt	overt	JJ
18637	13596	27	acts	act	NNS
18637	13596	28	;	;	:
18637	13596	29	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	13596	30	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	13596	31	but	but	CC
18637	13596	32	sentence	sentence	NNP
18637	13596	33	commuted	commute	VBD
18637	13596	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13596	35	.	.	.
18637	13597	1	United	United	NNP
18637	13597	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13597	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13597	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13597	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13597	6	Cramer	Cramer	NNP
18637	13597	7	,	,	,
18637	13597	8	137	137	CD
18637	13597	9	F.	F.	NNP
18637	13597	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13597	11	2d	2d	NNP
18637	13597	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13597	13	888	888	CD
18637	13597	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13597	15	1943	1943	CD
18637	13597	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13597	17	.	.	.
18637	13598	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13598	2	738	738	CD
18637	13598	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13598	4	343	343	CD
18637	13598	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13598	6	717	717	CD
18637	13598	7	.	.	.
18637	13599	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13599	2	739	739	CD
18637	13599	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13599	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	13599	5	.	.	.
18637	13600	1	732	732	CD
18637	13600	2	.	.	.
18637	13601	1	For	for	IN
18637	13601	2	citations	citation	NNS
18637	13601	3	on	on	IN
18637	13601	4	the	the	DT
18637	13601	5	subject	subject	NN
18637	13601	6	of	of	IN
18637	13601	7	dual	dual	JJ
18637	13601	8	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	13601	9	,	,	,
18637	13601	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13601	11	see	see	VB
18637	13601	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13601	13	ibid	ibid	NNP
18637	13601	14	.	.	.
18637	13602	1	723	723	CD
18637	13602	2	note	note	NN
18637	13602	3	2	2	CD
18637	13602	4	.	.	.
18637	13603	1	Three	three	CD
18637	13603	2	dissenters	dissenter	NNS
18637	13603	3	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	13603	4	that	that	IN
18637	13603	5	Kawakita	Kawakita	NNP
18637	13603	6	's	's	POS
18637	13603	7	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	13603	8	in	in	IN
18637	13603	9	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	13603	10	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	13603	11	showed	show	VBD
18637	13603	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13603	13	was	be	VBD
18637	13603	14	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	13603	15	demonstrating	demonstrate	VBG
18637	13603	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13603	17	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	13603	18	to	to	IN
18637	13603	19	Japan	Japan	NNP
18637	13603	20	.	.	.
18637	13604	1	"	"	``
18637	13604	2	As	as	IN
18637	13604	3	a	a	DT
18637	13604	4	matter	matter	NN
18637	13604	5	of	of	IN
18637	13604	6	law	law	NN
18637	13604	7	,	,	,
18637	13604	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13604	9	expatriated	expatriate	VBD
18637	13604	10	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13604	11	as	as	RB
18637	13604	12	well	well	RB
18637	13604	13	as	as	IN
18637	13604	14	that	that	DT
18637	13604	15	can	can	MD
18637	13604	16	be	be	VB
18637	13604	17	done	do	VBN
18637	13604	18	.	.	.
18637	13604	19	"	"	''
18637	13605	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	13605	2	.	.	.
18637	13606	1	746	746	CD
18637	13606	2	.	.	.
18637	13607	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13607	2	740	740	CD
18637	13607	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13607	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13607	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	13607	6	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	13607	7	,	,	,
18637	13607	8	4	4	CD
18637	13607	9	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13607	10	.	.	.
18637	13608	1	75	75	CD
18637	13608	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13608	3	1807	1807	CD
18637	13608	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13608	5	.	.	.
18637	13609	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13609	2	741	741	CD
18637	13609	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13609	4	United	United	NNP
18637	13609	5	States	States	NNP
18637	13609	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13609	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13609	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13609	9	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	13609	10	,	,	,
18637	13609	11	4	4	CD
18637	13609	12	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13609	13	.	.	.
18637	13610	1	470	470	CD
18637	13610	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13610	3	1807	1807	CD
18637	13610	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13610	5	.	.	.
18637	13611	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13611	2	742	742	CD
18637	13611	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13611	4	Cramer	Cramer	NNP
18637	13611	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13611	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13611	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13611	8	United	United	NNP
18637	13611	9	States	States	NNP
18637	13611	10	,	,	,
18637	13611	11	325	325	CD
18637	13611	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13611	13	1	1	CD
18637	13611	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13611	15	1945	1945	CD
18637	13611	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13611	17	.	.	.
18637	13612	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13612	2	743	743	CD
18637	13612	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13612	4	Haupt	Haupt	NNP
18637	13612	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13612	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13612	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13612	8	United	United	NNP
18637	13612	9	States	States	NNP
18637	13612	10	,	,	,
18637	13612	11	330	330	CD
18637	13612	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13612	13	631	631	CD
18637	13612	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13612	15	1947	1947	CD
18637	13612	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13612	17	.	.	.
18637	13613	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13613	2	744	744	CD
18637	13613	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13613	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	13613	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	13613	6	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	13613	7	,	,	,
18637	13613	8	4	4	CD
18637	13613	9	Cr	cr	NN
18637	13613	10	.	.	.
18637	13614	1	75	75	CD
18637	13614	2	,	,	,
18637	13614	3	126	126	CD
18637	13614	4	,	,	,
18637	13614	5	127	127	CD
18637	13614	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13614	7	1807	1807	CD
18637	13614	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13614	9	.	.	.
18637	13615	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13615	2	745	745	CD
18637	13615	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13615	4	12	12	CD
18637	13615	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	13615	6	.	.	.
18637	13616	1	589	589	CD
18637	13616	2	.	.	.
18637	13617	1	This	this	DT
18637	13617	2	act	act	NN
18637	13617	3	incidentally	incidentally	RB
18637	13617	4	did	do	VBD
18637	13617	5	not	not	RB
18637	13617	6	designate	designate	VB
18637	13617	7	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	13617	8	as	as	IN
18637	13617	9	treason	treason	NN
18637	13617	10	.	.	.
18637	13618	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13618	2	746	746	CD
18637	13618	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13618	4	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	13618	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13618	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13618	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13618	8	United	United	NNP
18637	13618	9	States	States	NNP
18637	13618	10	,	,	,
18637	13618	11	11	11	CD
18637	13618	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13618	13	.	.	.
18637	13619	1	268	268	CD
18637	13619	2	,	,	,
18637	13619	3	305	305	CD
18637	13619	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13619	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	13619	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13619	7	.	.	.
18637	13620	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13620	2	747	747	CD
18637	13620	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13620	4	Wallach	Wallach	NNP
18637	13620	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13620	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13620	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13620	8	Van	Van	NNP
18637	13620	9	Riswick	Riswick	NNP
18637	13620	10	,	,	,
18637	13620	11	92	92	CD
18637	13620	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13620	13	202	202	CD
18637	13620	14	,	,	,
18637	13620	15	213	213	CD
18637	13620	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13620	17	1876	1876	CD
18637	13620	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13620	19	.	.	.
18637	13621	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13621	2	748	748	CD
18637	13621	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13621	4	Lord	Lord	NNP
18637	13621	5	de	de	NNP
18637	13621	6	la	la	NNP
18637	13621	7	Warre	Warre	NNP
18637	13621	8	's	's	POS
18637	13621	9	Case	Case	NNP
18637	13621	10	,	,	,
18637	13621	11	11	11	CD
18637	13621	12	Coke	Coke	NNP
18637	13621	13	,	,	,
18637	13621	14	1	1	CD
18637	13621	15	a.	a.	NN
18637	13622	1	A	a	DT
18637	13622	2	number	number	NN
18637	13622	3	of	of	IN
18637	13622	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	13622	5	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	13622	6	with	with	IN
18637	13622	7	the	the	DT
18637	13622	8	effect	effect	NN
18637	13622	9	of	of	IN
18637	13622	10	a	a	DT
18637	13622	11	full	full	JJ
18637	13622	12	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	13622	13	by	by	IN
18637	13622	14	the	the	DT
18637	13622	15	President	President	NNP
18637	13622	16	of	of	IN
18637	13622	17	owners	owner	NNS
18637	13622	18	of	of	IN
18637	13622	19	property	property	NN
18637	13622	20	confiscated	confiscate	VBN
18637	13622	21	under	under	IN
18637	13622	22	this	this	DT
18637	13622	23	act	act	NN
18637	13622	24	.	.	.
18637	13623	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13623	2	held	hold	VBD
18637	13623	3	that	that	IN
18637	13623	4	a	a	DT
18637	13623	5	full	full	JJ
18637	13623	6	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	13623	7	relieved	relieve	VBD
18637	13623	8	the	the	DT
18637	13623	9	owner	owner	NN
18637	13623	10	of	of	IN
18637	13623	11	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	13623	12	as	as	RB
18637	13623	13	far	far	RB
18637	13623	14	as	as	IN
18637	13623	15	the	the	DT
18637	13623	16	Government	Government	NNP
18637	13623	17	was	be	VBD
18637	13623	18	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	13623	19	,	,	,
18637	13623	20	but	but	CC
18637	13623	21	did	do	VBD
18637	13623	22	not	not	RB
18637	13623	23	divide	divide	VB
18637	13623	24	the	the	DT
18637	13623	25	interest	interest	NN
18637	13623	26	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	13623	27	by	by	IN
18637	13623	28	third	third	JJ
18637	13623	29	persons	person	NNS
18637	13623	30	from	from	IN
18637	13623	31	the	the	DT
18637	13623	32	Government	Government	NNP
18637	13623	33	during	during	IN
18637	13623	34	the	the	DT
18637	13623	35	lifetime	lifetime	NN
18637	13623	36	of	of	IN
18637	13623	37	the	the	DT
18637	13623	38	offender	offender	NN
18637	13623	39	.	.	.
18637	13624	1	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	13624	2	Central	Central	NNP
18637	13624	3	R.	R.	NNP
18637	13624	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13624	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13624	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13624	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13624	8	Bosworth	Bosworth	NNP
18637	13624	9	,	,	,
18637	13624	10	133	133	CD
18637	13624	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13624	12	92	92	CD
18637	13624	13	,	,	,
18637	13624	14	101	101	CD
18637	13624	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13624	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	13624	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13624	18	;	;	:
18637	13624	19	Knote	Knote	NNP
18637	13624	20	_	_	NNP
18637	13624	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	13624	22	_	_	NNP
18637	13624	23	United	United	NNP
18637	13624	24	States	States	NNP
18637	13624	25	,	,	,
18637	13624	26	95	95	CD
18637	13624	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13624	28	149	149	CD
18637	13624	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13624	30	1877	1877	CD
18637	13624	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13624	32	;	;	:
18637	13624	33	Wallach	Wallach	NNP
18637	13624	34	_	_	NNP
18637	13624	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	13624	36	_	_	NNP
18637	13624	37	Van	Van	NNP
18637	13624	38	Riswick	Riswick	NNP
18637	13624	39	,	,	,
18637	13624	40	92	92	CD
18637	13624	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13624	42	202	202	CD
18637	13624	43	,	,	,
18637	13624	44	213	213	CD
18637	13624	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13624	46	1876	1876	CD
18637	13624	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13624	48	;	;	:
18637	13624	49	Armstrong	Armstrong	NNP
18637	13624	50	's	's	POS
18637	13624	51	Foundry	Foundry	NNP
18637	13624	52	_	_	NNP
18637	13624	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	13624	54	_	_	NNP
18637	13624	55	United	United	NNP
18637	13624	56	States	States	NNP
18637	13624	57	,	,	,
18637	13624	58	6	6	CD
18637	13624	59	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13624	60	.	.	.
18637	13625	1	766	766	CD
18637	13625	2	,	,	,
18637	13625	3	769	769	CD
18637	13625	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13625	5	1868	1868	CD
18637	13625	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13625	7	.	.	.
18637	13626	1	There	there	EX
18637	13626	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	13626	3	no	no	DT
18637	13626	4	direct	direct	JJ
18637	13626	5	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	13626	6	on	on	IN
18637	13626	7	the	the	DT
18637	13626	8	question	question	NN
18637	13626	9	of	of	IN
18637	13626	10	whether	whether	IN
18637	13626	11	only	only	JJ
18637	13626	12	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13626	13	can	can	MD
18637	13626	14	commit	commit	VB
18637	13626	15	treason	treason	NN
18637	13626	16	.	.	.
18637	13627	1	In	in	IN
18637	13627	2	Carlisle	Carlisle	NNP
18637	13627	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13627	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13627	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13627	6	United	United	NNP
18637	13627	7	States	States	NNP
18637	13627	8	,	,	,
18637	13627	9	16	16	CD
18637	13627	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	13627	11	.	.	.
18637	13628	1	147	147	CD
18637	13628	2	,	,	,
18637	13628	3	154	154	CD
18637	13628	4	-	-	SYM
18637	13628	5	155	155	CD
18637	13628	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13628	7	1873	1873	CD
18637	13628	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13628	9	,	,	,
18637	13628	10	the	the	DT
18637	13628	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13628	12	declared	declare	VBD
18637	13628	13	that	that	IN
18637	13628	14	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	13628	15	while	while	IN
18637	13628	16	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	13628	17	in	in	IN
18637	13628	18	this	this	DT
18637	13628	19	country	country	NN
18637	13628	20	owe	owe	VBP
18637	13628	21	a	a	DT
18637	13628	22	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	13628	23	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	13628	24	to	to	IN
18637	13628	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13628	26	and	and	CC
18637	13628	27	may	may	MD
18637	13628	28	be	be	VB
18637	13628	29	punished	punish	VBN
18637	13628	30	for	for	IN
18637	13628	31	treason	treason	NN
18637	13628	32	equally	equally	RB
18637	13628	33	with	with	IN
18637	13628	34	a	a	DT
18637	13628	35	native	native	NN
18637	13628	36	-	-	HYPH
18637	13628	37	born	bear	VBN
18637	13628	38	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	13628	39	in	in	IN
18637	13628	40	the	the	DT
18637	13628	41	absence	absence	NN
18637	13628	42	of	of	IN
18637	13628	43	a	a	DT
18637	13628	44	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	13628	45	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	13628	46	to	to	IN
18637	13628	47	the	the	DT
18637	13628	48	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	13628	49	.	.	.
18637	13629	1	This	this	DT
18637	13629	2	case	case	NN
18637	13629	3	involved	involve	VBD
18637	13629	4	the	the	DT
18637	13629	5	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	13629	6	of	of	IN
18637	13629	7	certain	certain	JJ
18637	13629	8	British	british	JJ
18637	13629	9	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	13629	10	to	to	TO
18637	13629	11	recover	recover	VB
18637	13629	12	claims	claim	NNS
18637	13629	13	for	for	IN
18637	13629	14	property	property	NN
18637	13629	15	seized	seize	VBN
18637	13629	16	under	under	IN
18637	13629	17	the	the	DT
18637	13629	18	Captured	Captured	NNP
18637	13629	19	and	and	CC
18637	13629	20	Abandoned	Abandoned	NNP
18637	13629	21	Property	Property	NNP
18637	13629	22	Act	Act	NNP
18637	13629	23	,	,	,
18637	13629	24	12	12	CD
18637	13629	25	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	13629	26	.	.	.
18637	13630	1	820	820	CD
18637	13630	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13630	3	1863	1863	CD
18637	13630	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13630	5	which	which	WDT
18637	13630	6	provided	provide	VBD
18637	13630	7	for	for	IN
18637	13630	8	the	the	DT
18637	13630	9	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	13630	10	of	of	IN
18637	13630	11	property	property	NN
18637	13630	12	or	or	CC
18637	13630	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13630	14	value	value	NN
18637	13630	15	in	in	IN
18637	13630	16	suits	suit	NNS
18637	13630	17	in	in	IN
18637	13630	18	the	the	DT
18637	13630	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13630	20	of	of	IN
18637	13630	21	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	13630	22	by	by	IN
18637	13630	23	persons	person	NNS
18637	13630	24	who	who	WP
18637	13630	25	had	have	VBD
18637	13630	26	not	not	RB
18637	13630	27	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13630	28	aid	aid	NN
18637	13630	29	and	and	CC
18637	13630	30	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	13630	31	to	to	IN
18637	13630	32	the	the	DT
18637	13630	33	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	13630	34	.	.	.
18637	13631	1	Earlier	early	RBR
18637	13631	2	in	in	IN
18637	13631	3	United	United	NNP
18637	13631	4	States	States	NNP
18637	13631	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13631	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13631	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13631	8	Wiltberger	Wiltberger	NNP
18637	13631	9	,	,	,
18637	13631	10	5	5	CD
18637	13631	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	13631	12	.	.	.
18637	13632	1	76	76	CD
18637	13632	2	,	,	,
18637	13632	3	97	97	CD
18637	13632	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13632	5	1820	1820	CD
18637	13632	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13632	7	,	,	,
18637	13632	8	which	which	WDT
18637	13632	9	involved	involve	VBD
18637	13632	10	a	a	DT
18637	13632	11	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	13632	12	for	for	IN
18637	13632	13	manslaughter	manslaughter	NN
18637	13632	14	under	under	IN
18637	13632	15	an	an	DT
18637	13632	16	act	act	NN
18637	13632	17	punishing	punish	VBG
18637	13632	18	manslaughter	manslaughter	NN
18637	13632	19	and	and	CC
18637	13632	20	treason	treason	NN
18637	13632	21	on	on	IN
18637	13632	22	the	the	DT
18637	13632	23	high	high	JJ
18637	13632	24	seas	sea	NNS
18637	13632	25	,	,	,
18637	13632	26	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	13632	27	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13632	28	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	13632	29	going	go	VBG
18637	13632	30	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	13632	31	the	the	DT
18637	13632	32	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	13632	33	of	of	IN
18637	13632	34	the	the	DT
18637	13632	35	case	case	NN
18637	13632	36	stated	state	VBD
18637	13632	37	that	that	IN
18637	13632	38	treason	treason	NN
18637	13632	39	"	"	``
18637	13632	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	13632	41	a	a	DT
18637	13632	42	breach	breach	NN
18637	13632	43	of	of	IN
18637	13632	44	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	13632	45	,	,	,
18637	13632	46	and	and	CC
18637	13632	47	can	can	MD
18637	13632	48	be	be	VB
18637	13632	49	committed	commit	VBN
18637	13632	50	by	by	IN
18637	13632	51	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13632	52	only	only	RB
18637	13632	53	who	who	WP
18637	13632	54	owes	owe	VBZ
18637	13632	55	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	13632	56	either	either	CC
18637	13632	57	perpetual	perpetual	JJ
18637	13632	58	or	or	CC
18637	13632	59	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	13632	60	.	.	.
18637	13632	61	"	"	''
18637	13633	1	ARTICLE	ARTICLE	NNP
18637	13633	2	IV	IV	NNP
18637	13633	3	STATES	state	NNS
18637	13633	4	'	'	POS
18637	13633	5	RELATIONS	RELATIONS	NNP
18637	13633	6	Section	Section	NNP
18637	13633	7	1	1	CD
18637	13633	8	.	.	.
18637	13634	1	Full	full	JJ
18637	13634	2	faith	faith	NN
18637	13634	3	and	and	CC
18637	13634	4	credit	credit	NN
18637	13634	5	Page	Page	NNP
18637	13634	6	Sources	Sources	NNPS
18637	13634	7	and	and	CC
18637	13634	8	effect	effect	NN
18637	13634	9	of	of	IN
18637	13634	10	this	this	DT
18637	13634	11	provision	provision	NN
18637	13634	12	651	651	CD
18637	13634	13	Private	private	JJ
18637	13634	14	international	international	JJ
18637	13634	15	law	law	NN
18637	13634	16	651	651	CD
18637	13634	17	Importance	importance	NN
18637	13634	18	of	of	IN
18637	13634	19	the	the	DT
18637	13634	20	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	13634	21	provision	provision	NN
18637	13634	22	652	652	CD
18637	13634	23	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	13634	24	of	of	IN
18637	13634	25	1790	1790	CD
18637	13634	26	and	and	CC
18637	13634	27	1804	1804	CD
18637	13634	28	652	652	CD
18637	13634	29	Force	Force	NNP
18637	13634	30	and	and	CC
18637	13634	31	effect	effect	NN
18637	13634	32	of	of	IN
18637	13634	33	same	same	JJ
18637	13634	34	652	652	CD
18637	13634	35	Judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13634	36	:	:	:
18637	13634	37	Primary	primary	JJ
18637	13634	38	concern	concern	NN
18637	13634	39	of	of	IN
18637	13634	40	the	the	DT
18637	13634	41	provision	provision	NN
18637	13634	42	653	653	CD
18637	13634	43	Two	two	CD
18637	13634	44	principal	principal	JJ
18637	13634	45	classes	class	NNS
18637	13634	46	of	of	IN
18637	13634	47	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13634	48	653	653	CD
18637	13634	49	Effect	effect	NN
18637	13634	50	to	to	TO
18637	13634	51	be	be	VB
18637	13634	52	given	give	VBN
18637	13634	53	in	in	IN
18637	13634	54	forum	forum	NN
18637	13634	55	State	State	NNP
18637	13634	56	653	653	CD
18637	13634	57	Jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	13634	58	prerequisite	prerequisite	JJ
18637	13634	59	657	657	CD
18637	13634	60	Judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13634	61	in	in	IN
18637	13634	62	personam	personam	NN
18637	13634	63	658	658	CD
18637	13634	64	Jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	13634	65	question	question	NN
18637	13634	66	659	659	CD
18637	13634	67	Service	service	NN
18637	13634	68	on	on	IN
18637	13634	69	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13634	70	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	13634	71	660	660	CD
18637	13634	72	Service	service	NN
18637	13634	73	on	on	IN
18637	13634	74	out	out	RB
18637	13634	75	-	-	HYPH
18637	13634	76	of	of	IN
18637	13634	77	-	-	HYPH
18637	13634	78	State	state	NN
18637	13634	79	owners	owner	NNS
18637	13634	80	of	of	IN
18637	13634	81	motor	motor	NN
18637	13634	82	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	13634	83	660	660	CD
18637	13634	84	Judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13634	85	in	in	IN
18637	13634	86	rem	rem	NN
18637	13634	87	661	661	CD
18637	13634	88	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	13634	89	_	_	NNP
18637	13634	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	13634	91	_	_	NNP
18637	13634	92	Whitman	Whitman	NNP
18637	13634	93	661	661	CD
18637	13634	94	Divorce	Divorce	NNP
18637	13634	95	decrees	decree	VBZ
18637	13634	96	662	662	CD
18637	13634	97	Jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	13634	98	prerequisite	prerequisite	NN
18637	13634	99	:	:	:
18637	13634	100	Domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13634	101	662	662	CD
18637	13634	102	Haddock	Haddock	NNP
18637	13634	103	_	_	NNP
18637	13634	104	v.	v.	IN
18637	13634	105	_	_	NNP
18637	13634	106	Haddock	Haddock	NNP
18637	13634	107	662	662	CD
18637	13634	108	Emergence	Emergence	NNP
18637	13634	109	of	of	IN
18637	13634	110	the	the	DT
18637	13634	111	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13634	112	question	question	NN
18637	13634	113	663	663	CD
18637	13634	114	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	13634	115	I	I	NNP
18637	13634	116	and	and	CC
18637	13634	117	II	II	NNP
18637	13634	118	664	664	CD
18637	13634	119	Cases	case	NNS
18637	13634	120	involving	involve	VBG
18637	13634	121	claims	claim	NNS
18637	13634	122	for	for	IN
18637	13634	123	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	13634	124	or	or	CC
18637	13634	125	property	property	NN
18637	13634	126	arising	arise	VBG
18637	13634	127	in	in	IN
18637	13634	128	forum	forum	NN
18637	13634	129	State	State	NNP
18637	13634	130	666	666	CD
18637	13634	131	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	13634	132	cases	case	NNS
18637	13634	133	668	668	CD
18637	13634	134	State	state	NN
18637	13634	135	of	of	IN
18637	13634	136	the	the	DT
18637	13634	137	law	law	NN
18637	13634	138	today	today	NN
18637	13634	139	:	:	:
18637	13634	140	quaere	quaere	NNP
18637	13634	141	670	670	CD
18637	13634	142	Decrees	Decrees	NNPS
18637	13634	143	awarding	award	VBG
18637	13634	144	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	13634	145	,	,	,
18637	13634	146	custody	custody	NN
18637	13634	147	of	of	IN
18637	13634	148	children	child	NNS
18637	13634	149	670	670	CD
18637	13634	150	Collateral	collateral	JJ
18637	13634	151	attack	attack	NN
18637	13634	152	by	by	IN
18637	13634	153	child	child	NN
18637	13634	154	671	671	CD
18637	13634	155	Decrees	Decrees	NNPS
18637	13634	156	of	of	IN
18637	13634	157	other	other	JJ
18637	13634	158	types	type	NNS
18637	13634	159	672	672	CD
18637	13634	160	Probate	probate	NN
18637	13634	161	decrees	decree	VBZ
18637	13634	162	672	672	CD
18637	13634	163	Adoption	Adoption	NNP
18637	13634	164	decrees	decree	VBZ
18637	13634	165	673	673	CD
18637	13634	166	Garnishment	Garnishment	NNP
18637	13634	167	decrees	decree	VBZ
18637	13634	168	673	673	CD
18637	13634	169	Fraud	Fraud	NNP
18637	13634	170	as	as	IN
18637	13634	171	a	a	DT
18637	13634	172	defense	defense	NN
18637	13634	173	to	to	IN
18637	13634	174	suits	suit	NNS
18637	13634	175	on	on	IN
18637	13634	176	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13634	177	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13634	178	674	674	CD
18637	13634	179	Penal	Penal	NNP
18637	13634	180	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13634	181	:	:	:
18637	13634	182	types	type	NNS
18637	13634	183	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13634	184	to	to	TO
18637	13634	185	recognition	recognition	VB
18637	13634	186	674	674	CD
18637	13634	187	Recognition	Recognition	NNP
18637	13634	188	of	of	IN
18637	13634	189	rights	right	NNS
18637	13634	190	based	base	VBN
18637	13634	191	upon	upon	IN
18637	13634	192	Constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	13634	193	,	,	,
18637	13634	194	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	13634	195	,	,	,
18637	13634	196	common	common	JJ
18637	13634	197	law	law	NN
18637	13634	198	675	675	CD
18637	13634	199	The	the	DT
18637	13634	200	early	early	JJ
18637	13634	201	rule	rule	NN
18637	13634	202	675	675	CD
18637	13634	203	Development	development	NN
18637	13634	204	of	of	IN
18637	13634	205	the	the	DT
18637	13634	206	modern	modern	JJ
18637	13634	207	rule	rule	NN
18637	13634	208	675	675	CD
18637	13634	209	Transitory	transitory	JJ
18637	13634	210	actions	action	NNS
18637	13634	211	:	:	:
18637	13634	212	Death	death	NN
18637	13634	213	statutes	statute	VBZ
18637	13634	214	676	676	CD
18637	13634	215	Actions	action	NNS
18637	13634	216	upon	upon	IN
18637	13634	217	contract	contract	NN
18637	13634	218	:	:	:
18637	13634	219	When	when	WRB
18637	13634	220	governed	govern	VBN
18637	13634	221	by	by	IN
18637	13634	222	law	law	NN
18637	13634	223	of	of	IN
18637	13634	224	place	place	NN
18637	13634	225	of	of	IN
18637	13634	226	making	make	VBG
18637	13634	227	677	677	CD
18637	13634	228	Stockholder	Stockholder	NNP
18637	13634	229	-	-	HYPH
18637	13634	230	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13634	231	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	13634	232	677	677	CD
18637	13634	233	Fraternal	fraternal	JJ
18637	13634	234	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	13634	235	society	society	NN
18637	13634	236	--	--	:
18637	13634	237	member	member	NN
18637	13634	238	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	13634	239	678	678	CD
18637	13634	240	Insurance	insurance	NN
18637	13634	241	company	company	NN
18637	13634	242	,	,	,
18637	13634	243	building	building	NN
18637	13634	244	and	and	CC
18637	13634	245	loan	loan	NNP
18637	13634	246	association	association	NNP
18637	13634	247	--	--	:
18637	13634	248	contractual	contractual	JJ
18637	13634	249	relationships	relationship	NNS
18637	13634	250	679	679	CD
18637	13634	251	Workmen	Workmen	NNP
18637	13634	252	's	's	POS
18637	13634	253	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	13634	254	statutes	statute	VBZ
18637	13634	255	681	681	CD
18637	13634	256	Development	Development	NNP
18637	13634	257	of	of	IN
18637	13634	258	section	section	NN
18637	13634	259	to	to	IN
18637	13634	260	date	date	NN
18637	13634	261	and	and	CC
18637	13634	262	possibilities	possibility	NNS
18637	13634	263	682	682	CD
18637	13634	264	Evaluation	evaluation	NN
18637	13634	265	of	of	IN
18637	13634	266	results	result	NNS
18637	13634	267	682	682	CD
18637	13634	268	Scope	scope	NN
18637	13634	269	of	of	IN
18637	13634	270	powers	power	NNS
18637	13634	271	of	of	IN
18637	13634	272	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13634	273	under	under	IN
18637	13634	274	section	section	NN
18637	13634	275	683	683	CD
18637	13634	276	Full	full	JJ
18637	13634	277	faith	faith	NN
18637	13634	278	and	and	CC
18637	13634	279	credit	credit	NN
18637	13634	280	in	in	IN
18637	13634	281	the	the	DT
18637	13634	282	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13634	283	courts	court	NNS
18637	13634	284	684	684	CD
18637	13634	285	Judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13634	286	of	of	IN
18637	13634	287	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13634	288	States	States	NNP
18637	13634	289	685	685	NNP
18637	13634	290	Section	Section	NNP
18637	13634	291	2	2	CD
18637	13634	292	.	.	.
18637	13635	1	Interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	13635	2	comity	comity	NN
18637	13635	3	686	686	CD
18637	13635	4	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	13635	5	1	1	CD
18637	13635	6	.	.	.
18637	13636	1	The	the	DT
18637	13636	2	comity	comity	NN
18637	13636	3	clause	clause	NN
18637	13636	4	686	686	CD
18637	13636	5	Sources	source	NNS
18637	13636	6	686	686	CD
18637	13636	7	Theories	theory	NNS
18637	13636	8	as	as	IN
18637	13636	9	to	to	IN
18637	13636	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13636	11	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	13636	12	686	686	CD
18637	13636	13	How	how	WRB
18637	13636	14	implemented	implement	VBD
18637	13636	15	688	688	CD
18637	13636	16	"	"	``
18637	13636	17	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	13636	18	of	of	IN
18637	13636	19	each	each	DT
18637	13636	20	State	state	NN
18637	13636	21	"	"	''
18637	13636	22	688	688	CD
18637	13636	23	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	13636	24	688	688	CD
18637	13636	25	"	"	``
18637	13636	26	All	all	DT
18637	13636	27	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13636	28	and	and	CC
18637	13636	29	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	13636	30	of	of	IN
18637	13636	31	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13636	32	in	in	IN
18637	13636	33	the	the	DT
18637	13636	34	several	several	JJ
18637	13636	35	States	state	NNS
18637	13636	36	"	"	``
18637	13636	37	689	689	CD
18637	13636	38	Discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	13636	39	in	in	IN
18637	13636	40	private	private	JJ
18637	13636	41	rights	right	NNS
18637	13636	42	691	691	CD
18637	13636	43	Access	access	NN
18637	13636	44	to	to	IN
18637	13636	45	courts	court	NNS
18637	13636	46	691	691	CD
18637	13636	47	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	13636	48	692	692	CD
18637	13636	49	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	13636	50	2	2	CD
18637	13636	51	.	.	.
18637	13637	1	Fugitives	fugitive	NNS
18637	13637	2	from	from	IN
18637	13637	3	justice	justice	NN
18637	13637	4	693	693	CD
18637	13637	5	Duty	Duty	NNP
18637	13637	6	to	to	TO
18637	13637	7	surrender	surrender	VB
18637	13637	8	693	693	CD
18637	13637	9	"	"	``
18637	13637	10	Fugitive	Fugitive	NNP
18637	13637	11	from	from	IN
18637	13637	12	justice	justice	NN
18637	13637	13	"	"	''
18637	13637	14	694	694	CD
18637	13637	15	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	13637	16	of	of	IN
18637	13637	17	removal	removal	NN
18637	13637	18	695	695	CD
18637	13637	19	Trial	trial	NN
18637	13637	20	of	of	IN
18637	13637	21	fugitive	fugitive	NN
18637	13637	22	after	after	IN
18637	13637	23	removal	removal	NN
18637	13637	24	695	695	CD
18637	13637	25	Clause	clause	NN
18637	13637	26	3	3	CD
18637	13637	27	.	.	.
18637	13638	1	Fugitives	fugitive	NNS
18637	13638	2	from	from	IN
18637	13638	3	labor	labor	NN
18637	13638	4	696	696	CD
18637	13638	5	Section	Section	NNP
18637	13638	6	3	3	CD
18637	13638	7	.	.	.
18637	13639	1	New	New	NNP
18637	13639	2	States	States	NNP
18637	13639	3	and	and	CC
18637	13639	4	government	government	NN
18637	13639	5	of	of	IN
18637	13639	6	territory	territory	NN
18637	13639	7	,	,	,
18637	13639	8	etc	etc	FW
18637	13639	9	.	.	.
18637	13640	1	697	697	CD
18637	13640	2	Clause	clause	NN
18637	13640	3	1	1	CD
18637	13640	4	.	.	.
18637	13641	1	Admission	admission	NN
18637	13641	2	of	of	IN
18637	13641	3	States	States	NNP
18637	13641	4	697	697	CD
18637	13641	5	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	13641	6	of	of	IN
18637	13641	7	equality	equality	NN
18637	13641	8	of	of	IN
18637	13641	9	the	the	DT
18637	13641	10	States	States	NNPS
18637	13641	11	697	697	CD
18637	13641	12	Earlier	early	JJR
18637	13641	13	scope	scope	NN
18637	13641	14	of	of	IN
18637	13641	15	the	the	DT
18637	13641	16	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	13641	17	698	698	CD
18637	13641	18	Citizenship	Citizenship	NNP
18637	13641	19	of	of	IN
18637	13641	20	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	13641	21	699	699	CD
18637	13641	22	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13641	23	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13641	24	699	699	CD
18637	13641	25	Property	property	NN
18637	13641	26	rights	right	NNS
18637	13641	27	;	;	:
18637	13641	28	United	United	NNP
18637	13641	29	States	States	NNP
18637	13641	30	_	_	NNP
18637	13641	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	13641	32	_	_	NNP
18637	13641	33	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	13641	34	700	700	NNP
18637	13641	35	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	13641	36	conveyed	convey	VBN
18637	13641	37	to	to	IN
18637	13641	38	private	private	JJ
18637	13641	39	persons	person	NNS
18637	13641	40	before	before	IN
18637	13641	41	admission	admission	NN
18637	13641	42	of	of	IN
18637	13641	43	State	State	NNP
18637	13641	44	700	700	NNP
18637	13641	45	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	13641	46	2	2	CD
18637	13641	47	.	.	.
18637	13642	1	Property	property	NN
18637	13642	2	and	and	CC
18637	13642	3	territory	territory	NN
18637	13642	4	;	;	:
18637	13642	5	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	13642	6	powers	power	NNS
18637	13642	7	of	of	IN
18637	13642	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13642	9	701	701	CD
18637	13642	10	Property	Property	NNP
18637	13642	11	of	of	IN
18637	13642	12	the	the	DT
18637	13642	13	United	United	NNP
18637	13642	14	States	States	NNP
18637	13642	15	701	701	CD
18637	13642	16	Methods	Methods	NNPS
18637	13642	17	of	of	IN
18637	13642	18	disposing	dispose	VBG
18637	13642	19	701	701	CD
18637	13642	20	Public	public	JJ
18637	13642	21	lands	land	VBZ
18637	13642	22	701	701	CD
18637	13642	23	Power	power	NN
18637	13642	24	of	of	IN
18637	13642	25	the	the	DT
18637	13642	26	States	States	NNP
18637	13642	27	702	702	CD
18637	13642	28	Power	Power	NNP
18637	13642	29	of	of	IN
18637	13642	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13642	31	over	over	IN
18637	13642	32	territories	territory	NNS
18637	13642	33	703	703	CD
18637	13642	34	Section	section	NN
18637	13642	35	4	4	CD
18637	13642	36	.	.	.
18637	13643	1	Obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	13643	2	of	of	IN
18637	13643	3	United	United	NNP
18637	13643	4	States	States	NNP
18637	13643	5	to	to	IN
18637	13643	6	the	the	DT
18637	13643	7	States	state	NNS
18637	13643	8	704	704	CD
18637	13643	9	Republican	republican	JJ
18637	13643	10	form	form	NN
18637	13643	11	of	of	IN
18637	13643	12	government	government	NN
18637	13643	13	704	704	CD
18637	13643	14	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	13643	15	against	against	IN
18637	13643	16	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	13643	17	violence	violence	NN
18637	13643	18	704	704	CD
18637	13643	19	Decline	decline	NN
18637	13643	20	in	in	IN
18637	13643	21	importance	importance	NN
18637	13643	22	of	of	IN
18637	13643	23	this	this	DT
18637	13643	24	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	13643	25	704	704	CD
18637	13643	26	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	13643	27	'S	's	POS
18637	13643	28	RELATIONS	RELATIONS	NNP
18637	13643	29	Article	Article	NNP
18637	13643	30	IV	IV	NNP
18637	13643	31	Section	Section	NNP
18637	13643	32	1	1	CD
18637	13643	33	.	.	.
18637	13644	1	Full	full	JJ
18637	13644	2	Faith	Faith	NNP
18637	13644	3	and	and	CC
18637	13644	4	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	13644	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	13644	6	be	be	VB
18637	13644	7	given	give	VBN
18637	13644	8	in	in	IN
18637	13644	9	each	each	DT
18637	13644	10	State	state	NN
18637	13644	11	to	to	IN
18637	13644	12	the	the	DT
18637	13644	13	public	public	JJ
18637	13644	14	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	13644	15	,	,	,
18637	13644	16	Records	Records	NNPS
18637	13644	17	,	,	,
18637	13644	18	and	and	CC
18637	13644	19	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13644	20	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNPS
18637	13644	21	of	of	IN
18637	13644	22	every	every	DT
18637	13644	23	other	other	JJ
18637	13644	24	State	State	NNP
18637	13644	25	.	.	.
18637	13645	1	And	and	CC
18637	13645	2	the	the	DT
18637	13645	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13645	4	may	may	MD
18637	13645	5	by	by	IN
18637	13645	6	general	general	JJ
18637	13645	7	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	13645	8	prescribe	prescribe	VBP
18637	13645	9	the	the	DT
18637	13645	10	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	13645	11	in	in	IN
18637	13645	12	which	which	WDT
18637	13645	13	such	such	JJ
18637	13645	14	Acts	act	NNS
18637	13645	15	,	,	,
18637	13645	16	Records	Records	NNPS
18637	13645	17	and	and	CC
18637	13645	18	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNPS
18637	13645	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	13645	20	be	be	VB
18637	13645	21	proved	prove	VBN
18637	13645	22	,	,	,
18637	13645	23	and	and	CC
18637	13645	24	the	the	DT
18637	13645	25	Effect	Effect	NNP
18637	13645	26	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	13645	27	.	.	.
18637	13646	1	Sources	source	NNS
18637	13646	2	and	and	CC
18637	13646	3	Effect	Effect	NNP
18637	13646	4	of	of	IN
18637	13646	5	This	this	DT
18637	13646	6	Provision	Provision	NNP
18637	13646	7	PRIVATE	private	JJ
18637	13646	8	INTERNATIONAL	INTERNATIONAL	NNP
18637	13646	9	LAW	law	NN
18637	13646	10	The	the	DT
18637	13646	11	historical	historical	JJ
18637	13646	12	background	background	NN
18637	13646	13	of	of	IN
18637	13646	14	the	the	DT
18637	13646	15	above	above	JJ
18637	13646	16	section	section	NN
18637	13646	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	13646	18	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	13646	19	by	by	IN
18637	13646	20	that	that	DT
18637	13646	21	branch	branch	NN
18637	13646	22	of	of	IN
18637	13646	23	private	private	JJ
18637	13646	24	law	law	NN
18637	13646	25	which	which	WDT
18637	13646	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	13646	27	variously	variously	RB
18637	13646	28	termed	term	VBN
18637	13646	29	"	"	``
18637	13646	30	Private	Private	NNP
18637	13646	31	International	International	NNP
18637	13646	32	Law	Law	NNP
18637	13646	33	,	,	,
18637	13646	34	"	"	''
18637	13646	35	"	"	``
18637	13646	36	Conflict	Conflict	NNP
18637	13646	37	of	of	IN
18637	13646	38	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	13646	39	,	,	,
18637	13646	40	"	"	''
18637	13646	41	"	"	``
18637	13646	42	Comity	comity	NN
18637	13646	43	.	.	.
18637	13646	44	"	"	''
18637	13647	1	This	this	DT
18637	13647	2	comprises	comprise	VBZ
18637	13647	3	a	a	DT
18637	13647	4	body	body	NN
18637	13647	5	of	of	IN
18637	13647	6	rules	rule	NNS
18637	13647	7	,	,	,
18637	13647	8	based	base	VBN
18637	13647	9	largely	largely	RB
18637	13647	10	on	on	IN
18637	13647	11	the	the	DT
18637	13647	12	writings	writing	NNS
18637	13647	13	of	of	IN
18637	13647	14	jurists	jurist	NNS
18637	13647	15	and	and	CC
18637	13647	16	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13647	17	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	13647	18	,	,	,
18637	13647	19	in	in	IN
18637	13647	20	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	13647	21	with	with	IN
18637	13647	22	which	which	WDT
18637	13647	23	the	the	DT
18637	13647	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	13647	25	of	of	IN
18637	13647	26	one	one	CD
18637	13647	27	country	country	NN
18637	13647	28	or	or	CC
18637	13647	29	"	"	``
18637	13647	30	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13647	31	"	"	''
18637	13647	32	will	will	MD
18637	13647	33	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	13647	34	,	,	,
18637	13647	35	in	in	IN
18637	13647	36	the	the	DT
18637	13647	37	absence	absence	NN
18637	13647	38	of	of	IN
18637	13647	39	a	a	DT
18637	13647	40	local	local	JJ
18637	13647	41	policy	policy	NN
18637	13647	42	to	to	IN
18637	13647	43	the	the	DT
18637	13647	44	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	13647	45	,	,	,
18637	13647	46	extend	extend	VB
18637	13647	47	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13647	48	and	and	CC
18637	13647	49	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	13647	50	to	to	IN
18637	13647	51	rights	right	NNS
18637	13647	52	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	13647	53	by	by	IN
18637	13647	54	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	13647	55	by	by	IN
18637	13647	56	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	13647	57	of	of	IN
18637	13647	58	the	the	DT
18637	13647	59	laws	law	NNS
18637	13647	60	or	or	CC
18637	13647	61	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13647	62	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	13647	63	of	of	IN
18637	13647	64	another	another	DT
18637	13647	65	country	country	NN
18637	13647	66	or	or	CC
18637	13647	67	"	"	``
18637	13647	68	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13647	69	.	.	.
18637	13647	70	"	"	''
18637	13648	1	Most	most	RBS
18637	13648	2	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	13648	3	applied	apply	VBD
18637	13648	4	examples	example	NNS
18637	13648	5	of	of	IN
18637	13648	6	these	these	DT
18637	13648	7	rules	rule	NNS
18637	13648	8	include	include	VBP
18637	13648	9	the	the	DT
18637	13648	10	following	follow	VBG
18637	13648	11	:	:	:
18637	13648	12	the	the	DT
18637	13648	13	rule	rule	NN
18637	13648	14	that	that	IN
18637	13648	15	a	a	DT
18637	13648	16	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	13648	17	which	which	WDT
18637	13648	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	13648	19	good	good	JJ
18637	13648	20	in	in	IN
18637	13648	21	the	the	DT
18637	13648	22	country	country	NN
18637	13648	23	where	where	WRB
18637	13648	24	performed	perform	VBN
18637	13648	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13648	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13648	27	lex	lex	NN
18637	13648	28	loci	loci	NN
18637	13648	29	_	_	NNP
18637	13648	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13648	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	13648	32	good	good	JJ
18637	13648	33	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	13648	34	;	;	:
18637	13648	35	likewise	likewise	RB
18637	13648	36	the	the	DT
18637	13648	37	rule	rule	NN
18637	13648	38	that	that	IN
18637	13648	39	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	13648	40	are	be	VBP
18637	13648	41	to	to	TO
18637	13648	42	be	be	VB
18637	13648	43	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	13648	44	in	in	IN
18637	13648	45	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	13648	46	with	with	IN
18637	13648	47	the	the	DT
18637	13648	48	laws	law	NNS
18637	13648	49	of	of	IN
18637	13648	50	the	the	DT
18637	13648	51	country	country	NN
18637	13648	52	where	where	WRB
18637	13648	53	entered	enter	VBN
18637	13648	54	into	into	IN
18637	13648	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13648	56	_	_	NNP
18637	13648	57	lex	lex	NN
18637	13648	58	loci	loci	NN
18637	13648	59	contractus	contractus	NN
18637	13648	60	_	_	NNP
18637	13648	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13648	62	unless	unless	IN
18637	13648	63	the	the	DT
18637	13648	64	parties	party	NNS
18637	13648	65	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	13648	66	intended	intend	VBN
18637	13648	67	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	13648	68	;	;	:
18637	13648	69	also	also	RB
18637	13648	70	the	the	DT
18637	13648	71	rule	rule	NN
18637	13648	72	that	that	WDT
18637	13648	73	immovables	immovable	NNS
18637	13648	74	may	may	MD
18637	13648	75	be	be	VB
18637	13648	76	disposed	dispose	VBN
18637	13648	77	of	of	IN
18637	13648	78	only	only	RB
18637	13648	79	in	in	IN
18637	13648	80	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	13648	81	with	with	IN
18637	13648	82	the	the	DT
18637	13648	83	law	law	NN
18637	13648	84	of	of	IN
18637	13648	85	the	the	DT
18637	13648	86	country	country	NN
18637	13648	87	where	where	WRB
18637	13648	88	situated	situate	VBN
18637	13648	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13648	90	_	_	NNP
18637	13648	91	lex	lex	NNP
18637	13648	92	rei	rei	NN
18637	13648	93	sitae_);[1	sitae_);[1	NNS
18637	13648	94	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13648	95	also	also	RB
18637	13648	96	the	the	DT
18637	13648	97	converse	converse	NN
18637	13648	98	rule	rule	NN
18637	13648	99	that	that	IN
18637	13648	100	chattels	chattel	NNS
18637	13648	101	adhere	adhere	RB
18637	13648	102	to	to	IN
18637	13648	103	the	the	DT
18637	13648	104	person	person	NN
18637	13648	105	of	of	IN
18637	13648	106	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13648	107	owner	owner	NN
18637	13648	108	and	and	CC
18637	13648	109	hence	hence	RB
18637	13648	110	are	be	VBP
18637	13648	111	disposable	disposable	JJ
18637	13648	112	by	by	IN
18637	13648	113	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13648	114	,	,	,
18637	13648	115	even	even	RB
18637	13648	116	when	when	WRB
18637	13648	117	located	locate	VBN
18637	13648	118	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	13648	119	,	,	,
18637	13648	120	in	in	IN
18637	13648	121	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	13648	122	with	with	IN
18637	13648	123	the	the	DT
18637	13648	124	law	law	NN
18637	13648	125	of	of	IN
18637	13648	126	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13648	127	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13648	128	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13648	129	_	_	NNP
18637	13648	130	lex	lex	NN
18637	13648	131	domicilii	domicilii	NN
18637	13648	132	_	_	NNP
18637	13648	133	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13648	134	;	;	:
18637	13648	135	also	also	RB
18637	13648	136	the	the	DT
18637	13648	137	rule	rule	NN
18637	13648	138	that	that	IN
18637	13648	139	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	13648	140	of	of	IN
18637	13648	141	where	where	WRB
18637	13648	142	the	the	DT
18637	13648	143	cause	cause	NN
18637	13648	144	arose	arise	VBD
18637	13648	145	,	,	,
18637	13648	146	the	the	DT
18637	13648	147	courts	court	NNS
18637	13648	148	of	of	IN
18637	13648	149	any	any	DT
18637	13648	150	country	country	NN
18637	13648	151	where	where	WRB
18637	13648	152	personal	personal	JJ
18637	13648	153	service	service	NN
18637	13648	154	can	can	MD
18637	13648	155	be	be	VB
18637	13648	156	got	get	VBN
18637	13648	157	upon	upon	IN
18637	13648	158	the	the	DT
18637	13648	159	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13648	160	will	will	MD
18637	13648	161	take	take	VB
18637	13648	162	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13648	163	of	of	IN
18637	13648	164	certain	certain	JJ
18637	13648	165	types	type	NNS
18637	13648	166	of	of	IN
18637	13648	167	personal	personal	JJ
18637	13648	168	actions	action	NNS
18637	13648	169	,	,	,
18637	13648	170	hence	hence	RB
18637	13648	171	termed	term	VBD
18637	13648	172	"	"	``
18637	13648	173	transitory	transitory	NN
18637	13648	174	,	,	,
18637	13648	175	"	"	''
18637	13648	176	and	and	CC
18637	13648	177	accord	accord	VB
18637	13648	178	such	such	JJ
18637	13648	179	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	13648	180	as	as	IN
18637	13648	181	the	the	DT
18637	13648	182	_	_	NNP
18637	13648	183	lex	lex	NN
18637	13648	184	fori	fori	NN
18637	13648	185	_	_	NNP
18637	13648	186	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	13648	187	.	.	.
18637	13649	1	Still	still	RB
18637	13649	2	other	other	JJ
18637	13649	3	rules	rule	NNS
18637	13649	4	,	,	,
18637	13649	5	of	of	IN
18637	13649	6	first	first	JJ
18637	13649	7	importance	importance	NN
18637	13649	8	in	in	IN
18637	13649	9	the	the	DT
18637	13649	10	present	present	JJ
18637	13649	11	connection	connection	NN
18637	13649	12	,	,	,
18637	13649	13	determine	determine	VB
18637	13649	14	the	the	DT
18637	13649	15	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13649	16	which	which	WDT
18637	13649	17	the	the	DT
18637	13649	18	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13649	19	of	of	IN
18637	13649	20	the	the	DT
18637	13649	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	13649	22	of	of	IN
18637	13649	23	one	one	CD
18637	13649	24	country	country	NN
18637	13649	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	13649	26	receive	receive	VB
18637	13649	27	from	from	IN
18637	13649	28	those	those	DT
18637	13649	29	of	of	IN
18637	13649	30	another	another	DT
18637	13649	31	country	country	NN
18637	13649	32	.	.	.
18637	13650	1	IMPORTANCE	importance	NN
18637	13650	2	OF	of	IN
18637	13650	3	THE	the	DT
18637	13650	4	CONSTITUTIONAL	constitutional	JJ
18637	13650	5	PROVISION	provision	NN
18637	13650	6	So	so	RB
18637	13650	7	even	even	RB
18637	13650	8	had	have	VBD
18637	13650	9	the	the	DT
18637	13650	10	States	States	NNP
18637	13650	11	of	of	IN
18637	13650	12	the	the	DT
18637	13650	13	Union	Union	NNP
18637	13650	14	remained	remain	VBD
18637	13650	15	in	in	IN
18637	13650	16	a	a	DT
18637	13650	17	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	13650	18	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	13650	19	of	of	IN
18637	13650	20	entire	entire	JJ
18637	13650	21	independence	independence	NN
18637	13650	22	,	,	,
18637	13650	23	still	still	RB
18637	13650	24	private	private	JJ
18637	13650	25	claims	claim	NNS
18637	13650	26	originating	originate	VBG
18637	13650	27	in	in	IN
18637	13650	28	one	one	PRP
18637	13650	29	would	would	MD
18637	13650	30	often	often	RB
18637	13650	31	have	have	VB
18637	13650	32	been	be	VBN
18637	13650	33	assured	assure	VBN
18637	13650	34	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13650	35	and	and	CC
18637	13650	36	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	13650	37	in	in	IN
18637	13650	38	the	the	DT
18637	13650	39	others	other	NNS
18637	13650	40	.	.	.
18637	13651	1	The	the	DT
18637	13651	2	framers	framer	NNS
18637	13651	3	of	of	IN
18637	13651	4	the	the	DT
18637	13651	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13651	6	felt	feel	VBD
18637	13651	7	,	,	,
18637	13651	8	however	however	RB
18637	13651	9	,	,	,
18637	13651	10	that	that	IN
18637	13651	11	the	the	DT
18637	13651	12	rules	rule	NNS
18637	13651	13	of	of	IN
18637	13651	14	private	private	JJ
18637	13651	15	international	international	JJ
18637	13651	16	law	law	NN
18637	13651	17	should	should	MD
18637	13651	18	not	not	RB
18637	13651	19	be	be	VB
18637	13651	20	left	leave	VBN
18637	13651	21	as	as	IN
18637	13651	22	among	among	IN
18637	13651	23	the	the	DT
18637	13651	24	States	States	NNP
18637	13651	25	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	13651	26	on	on	IN
18637	13651	27	a	a	DT
18637	13651	28	basis	basis	NN
18637	13651	29	of	of	IN
18637	13651	30	comity	comity	NN
18637	13651	31	,	,	,
18637	13651	32	and	and	CC
18637	13651	33	hence	hence	RB
18637	13651	34	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13651	35	always	always	RB
18637	13651	36	to	to	IN
18637	13651	37	the	the	DT
18637	13651	38	overruling	overruling	JJ
18637	13651	39	local	local	JJ
18637	13651	40	policy	policy	NN
18637	13651	41	of	of	IN
18637	13651	42	the	the	DT
18637	13651	43	_	_	NNP
18637	13651	44	lex	lex	NN
18637	13651	45	fori	fori	NN
18637	13651	46	_	_	NNP
18637	13651	47	,	,	,
18637	13651	48	but	but	CC
18637	13651	49	ought	ought	MD
18637	13651	50	to	to	TO
18637	13651	51	be	be	VB
18637	13651	52	in	in	IN
18637	13651	53	some	some	DT
18637	13651	54	measure	measure	NN
18637	13651	55	at	at	RB
18637	13651	56	least	least	RBS
18637	13651	57	placed	place	VBN
18637	13651	58	on	on	IN
18637	13651	59	the	the	DT
18637	13651	60	higher	high	JJR
18637	13651	61	plane	plane	NN
18637	13651	62	of	of	IN
18637	13651	63	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	13651	64	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	13651	65	.	.	.
18637	13652	1	In	in	IN
18637	13652	2	fulfillment	fulfillment	NN
18637	13652	3	of	of	IN
18637	13652	4	this	this	DT
18637	13652	5	intent	intent	NN
18637	13652	6	the	the	DT
18637	13652	7	section	section	NN
18637	13652	8	now	now	RB
18637	13652	9	under	under	IN
18637	13652	10	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	13652	11	was	be	VBD
18637	13652	12	inserted	insert	VBN
18637	13652	13	,	,	,
18637	13652	14	and	and	CC
18637	13652	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13652	16	was	be	VBD
18637	13652	17	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	13652	18	to	to	TO
18637	13652	19	enact	enact	VB
18637	13652	20	supplementary	supplementary	JJ
18637	13652	21	and	and	CC
18637	13652	22	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	13652	23	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	13652	24	.	.	.
18637	13653	1	THE	the	DT
18637	13653	2	ACTS	ACTS	NNP
18637	13653	3	OF	of	IN
18637	13653	4	1790	1790	CD
18637	13653	5	AND	and	CC
18637	13653	6	1804	1804	CD
18637	13653	7	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	13653	8	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	13653	9	under	under	IN
18637	13653	10	the	the	DT
18637	13653	11	full	full	JJ
18637	13653	12	faith	faith	NN
18637	13653	13	and	and	CC
18637	13653	14	credit	credit	NN
18637	13653	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	13653	16	,	,	,
18637	13653	17	so	so	RB
18637	13653	18	far	far	RB
18637	13653	19	as	as	IN
18637	13653	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13653	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	13653	22	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	13653	23	to	to	IN
18637	13653	24	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	13653	25	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	13653	26	,	,	,
18637	13653	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	13653	28	today	today	NN
18637	13653	29	embraced	embrace	VBN
18637	13653	30	in	in	IN
18637	13653	31	section	section	NN
18637	13653	32	687	687	CD
18637	13653	33	of	of	IN
18637	13653	34	Title	Title	NNP
18637	13653	35	28	28	CD
18637	13653	36	of	of	IN
18637	13653	37	the	the	DT
18637	13653	38	United	United	NNP
18637	13653	39	States	States	NNP
18637	13653	40	Code	Code	NNP
18637	13653	41	,	,	,
18637	13653	42	which	which	WDT
18637	13653	43	consolidates	consolidate	VBZ
18637	13653	44	the	the	DT
18637	13653	45	acts	act	NNS
18637	13653	46	of	of	IN
18637	13653	47	May	May	NNP
18637	13653	48	26	26	CD
18637	13653	49	,	,	,
18637	13653	50	1790	1790	CD
18637	13653	51	and	and	CC
18637	13653	52	of	of	IN
18637	13653	53	March	March	NNP
18637	13653	54	27	27	CD
18637	13653	55	,	,	,
18637	13653	56	1804	1804	CD
18637	13653	57	.	.	.
18637	13654	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13654	2	2	2	CD
18637	13654	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13654	4	"	"	``
18637	13654	5	The	the	DT
18637	13654	6	acts	act	NNS
18637	13654	7	of	of	IN
18637	13654	8	the	the	DT
18637	13654	9	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	13654	10	of	of	IN
18637	13654	11	any	any	DT
18637	13654	12	State	State	NNP
18637	13654	13	or	or	CC
18637	13654	14	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	13654	15	,	,	,
18637	13654	16	or	or	CC
18637	13654	17	of	of	IN
18637	13654	18	any	any	DT
18637	13654	19	country	country	NN
18637	13654	20	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13654	21	to	to	IN
18637	13654	22	the	the	DT
18637	13654	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13654	24	of	of	IN
18637	13654	25	the	the	DT
18637	13654	26	United	United	NNP
18637	13654	27	States	States	NNP
18637	13654	28	,	,	,
18637	13654	29	shall	shall	MD
18637	13654	30	be	be	VB
18637	13654	31	authenticated	authenticate	VBN
18637	13654	32	by	by	IN
18637	13654	33	having	have	VBG
18637	13654	34	the	the	DT
18637	13654	35	seals	seal	NNS
18637	13654	36	of	of	IN
18637	13654	37	such	such	JJ
18637	13654	38	State	State	NNP
18637	13654	39	,	,	,
18637	13654	40	Territory	territory	NN
18637	13654	41	,	,	,
18637	13654	42	or	or	CC
18637	13654	43	country	country	NN
18637	13654	44	affixed	affix	VBN
18637	13654	45	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	13654	46	.	.	.
18637	13655	1	The	the	DT
18637	13655	2	records	record	NNS
18637	13655	3	and	and	CC
18637	13655	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13655	5	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13655	6	of	of	IN
18637	13655	7	the	the	DT
18637	13655	8	courts	court	NNS
18637	13655	9	of	of	IN
18637	13655	10	any	any	DT
18637	13655	11	State	State	NNP
18637	13655	12	or	or	CC
18637	13655	13	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	13655	14	,	,	,
18637	13655	15	or	or	CC
18637	13655	16	of	of	IN
18637	13655	17	any	any	DT
18637	13655	18	such	such	JJ
18637	13655	19	country	country	NN
18637	13655	20	,	,	,
18637	13655	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	13655	22	be	be	VB
18637	13655	23	proved	prove	VBN
18637	13655	24	or	or	CC
18637	13655	25	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	13655	26	in	in	IN
18637	13655	27	any	any	DT
18637	13655	28	other	other	JJ
18637	13655	29	court	court	NN
18637	13655	30	within	within	IN
18637	13655	31	the	the	DT
18637	13655	32	United	United	NNP
18637	13655	33	States	States	NNP
18637	13655	34	,	,	,
18637	13655	35	by	by	IN
18637	13655	36	the	the	DT
18637	13655	37	attestation	attestation	NN
18637	13655	38	of	of	IN
18637	13655	39	the	the	DT
18637	13655	40	clerk	clerk	NN
18637	13655	41	,	,	,
18637	13655	42	and	and	CC
18637	13655	43	the	the	DT
18637	13655	44	seal	seal	NN
18637	13655	45	of	of	IN
18637	13655	46	the	the	DT
18637	13655	47	court	court	NN
18637	13655	48	annexed	annex	VBD
18637	13655	49	,	,	,
18637	13655	50	if	if	IN
18637	13655	51	there	there	EX
18637	13655	52	be	be	VB
18637	13655	53	a	a	DT
18637	13655	54	seal	seal	NN
18637	13655	55	,	,	,
18637	13655	56	together	together	RB
18637	13655	57	with	with	IN
18637	13655	58	a	a	DT
18637	13655	59	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	13655	60	of	of	IN
18637	13655	61	the	the	DT
18637	13655	62	judge	judge	NN
18637	13655	63	,	,	,
18637	13655	64	chief	chief	JJ
18637	13655	65	justice	justice	NN
18637	13655	66	,	,	,
18637	13655	67	or	or	CC
18637	13655	68	presiding	preside	VBG
18637	13655	69	magistrate	magistrate	NN
18637	13655	70	,	,	,
18637	13655	71	that	that	IN
18637	13655	72	the	the	DT
18637	13655	73	said	said	JJ
18637	13655	74	attestation	attestation	NN
18637	13655	75	is	be	VBZ
18637	13655	76	in	in	IN
18637	13655	77	due	due	JJ
18637	13655	78	form	form	NN
18637	13655	79	.	.	.
18637	13656	1	And	and	CC
18637	13656	2	the	the	DT
18637	13656	3	said	say	VBN
18637	13656	4	records	record	NNS
18637	13656	5	and	and	CC
18637	13656	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13656	7	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13656	8	,	,	,
18637	13656	9	so	so	RB
18637	13656	10	authenticated	authenticated	JJ
18637	13656	11	,	,	,
18637	13656	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	13656	13	have	have	VB
18637	13656	14	such	such	JJ
18637	13656	15	faith	faith	NN
18637	13656	16	and	and	CC
18637	13656	17	credit	credit	NN
18637	13656	18	given	give	VBN
18637	13656	19	to	to	IN
18637	13656	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13656	21	in	in	IN
18637	13656	22	every	every	DT
18637	13656	23	court	court	NN
18637	13656	24	within	within	IN
18637	13656	25	the	the	DT
18637	13656	26	United	United	NNP
18637	13656	27	States	States	NNP
18637	13656	28	as	as	IN
18637	13656	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13656	30	have	have	VBP
18637	13656	31	by	by	IN
18637	13656	32	law	law	NN
18637	13656	33	or	or	CC
18637	13656	34	usage	usage	NN
18637	13656	35	in	in	IN
18637	13656	36	the	the	DT
18637	13656	37	courts	court	NNS
18637	13656	38	of	of	IN
18637	13656	39	the	the	DT
18637	13656	40	State	State	NNP
18637	13656	41	from	from	IN
18637	13656	42	which	which	WDT
18637	13656	43	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13656	44	are	be	VBP
18637	13656	45	taken	take	VBN
18637	13656	46	.	.	.
18637	13656	47	"	"	''
18637	13657	1	FORCE	FORCE	NNP
18637	13657	2	AND	and	CC
18637	13657	3	EFFECT	effect	NN
18637	13657	4	OF	of	IN
18637	13657	5	SAME	same	JJ
18637	13657	6	Several	several	JJ
18637	13657	7	points	point	NNS
18637	13657	8	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	13657	9	emerge	emerge	VBP
18637	13657	10	:	:	:
18637	13657	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13657	12	1	1	LS
18637	13657	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13657	14	the	the	DT
18637	13657	15	word	word	NN
18637	13657	16	"	"	``
18637	13657	17	effect	effect	NN
18637	13657	18	"	"	''
18637	13657	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	13657	20	construed	construe	VBN
18637	13657	21	as	as	IN
18637	13657	22	referring	refer	VBG
18637	13657	23	to	to	IN
18637	13657	24	the	the	DT
18637	13657	25	effect	effect	NN
18637	13657	26	of	of	IN
18637	13657	27	the	the	DT
18637	13657	28	records	record	NNS
18637	13657	29	when	when	WRB
18637	13657	30	authenticated	authenticate	VBN
18637	13657	31	,	,	,
18637	13657	32	not	not	RB
18637	13657	33	to	to	IN
18637	13657	34	the	the	DT
18637	13657	35	effect	effect	NN
18637	13657	36	of	of	IN
18637	13657	37	the	the	DT
18637	13657	38	authentication	authentication	NN
18637	13657	39	;	;	:
18637	13657	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13657	41	2	2	LS
18637	13657	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13657	43	the	the	DT
18637	13657	44	faith	faith	NN
18637	13657	45	and	and	CC
18637	13657	46	credit	credit	NN
18637	13657	47	which	which	WDT
18637	13657	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	13657	49	required	require	VBN
18637	13657	50	by	by	IN
18637	13657	51	the	the	DT
18637	13657	52	rules	rule	NNS
18637	13657	53	of	of	IN
18637	13657	54	private	private	JJ
18637	13657	55	international	international	JJ
18637	13657	56	law	law	NN
18637	13657	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	13657	58	superseded	superseded	JJ
18637	13657	59	as	as	IN
18637	13657	60	to	to	IN
18637	13657	61	"	"	``
18637	13657	62	the	the	DT
18637	13657	63	records	record	NNS
18637	13657	64	and	and	CC
18637	13657	65	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13657	66	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13657	67	"	"	''
18637	13657	68	of	of	IN
18637	13657	69	each	each	DT
18637	13657	70	State	State	NNP
18637	13657	71	by	by	IN
18637	13657	72	a	a	DT
18637	13657	73	rule	rule	NN
18637	13657	74	of	of	IN
18637	13657	75	complete	complete	JJ
18637	13657	76	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	13657	77	;	;	:
18637	13657	78	as	as	IN
18637	13657	79	to	to	IN
18637	13657	80	these	these	DT
18637	13657	81	the	the	DT
18637	13657	82	local	local	JJ
18637	13657	83	policy	policy	NN
18637	13657	84	of	of	IN
18637	13657	85	the	the	DT
18637	13657	86	forum	forum	NN
18637	13657	87	State	State	NNP
18637	13657	88	can	can	MD
18637	13657	89	validly	validly	RB
18637	13657	90	have	have	VB
18637	13657	91	no	no	DT
18637	13657	92	application	application	NN
18637	13657	93	.	.	.
18637	13658	1	On	on	IN
18637	13658	2	the	the	DT
18637	13658	3	other	other	JJ
18637	13658	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	13658	5	,	,	,
18637	13658	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13658	7	3	3	LS
18637	13658	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13658	9	while	while	IN
18637	13658	10	the	the	DT
18637	13658	11	act	act	NN
18637	13658	12	of	of	IN
18637	13658	13	1790	1790	CD
18637	13658	14	lays	lay	VBZ
18637	13658	15	down	down	RB
18637	13658	16	a	a	DT
18637	13658	17	rule	rule	NN
18637	13658	18	for	for	IN
18637	13658	19	the	the	DT
18637	13658	20	authentication	authentication	NN
18637	13658	21	of	of	IN
18637	13658	22	the	the	DT
18637	13658	23	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	13658	24	of	of	IN
18637	13658	25	the	the	DT
18637	13658	26	several	several	JJ
18637	13658	27	States	States	NNPS
18637	13658	28	,	,	,
18637	13658	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13658	30	says	say	VBZ
18637	13658	31	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	13658	32	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	13658	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13658	34	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	JJ
18637	13658	35	operation	operation	NN
18637	13658	36	;	;	,
18637	13658	37	and	and	CC
18637	13658	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13658	39	4	4	LS
18637	13658	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13658	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13658	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	13658	43	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	13658	44	silent	silent	JJ
18637	13658	45	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	13658	46	the	the	DT
18637	13658	47	common	common	JJ
18637	13658	48	law	law	NN
18637	13658	49	of	of	IN
18637	13658	50	the	the	DT
18637	13658	51	several	several	JJ
18637	13658	52	States	state	NNS
18637	13658	53	.	.	.
18637	13659	1	These	these	DT
18637	13659	2	silences	silence	NNS
18637	13659	3	,	,	,
18637	13659	4	however	however	RB
18637	13659	5	,	,	,
18637	13659	6	have	have	VBP
18637	13659	7	been	be	VBN
18637	13659	8	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	13659	9	,	,	,
18637	13659	10	in	in	IN
18637	13659	11	part	part	NN
18637	13659	12	,	,	,
18637	13659	13	by	by	IN
18637	13659	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13659	15	decision	decision	NN
18637	13659	16	.	.	.
18637	13660	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13660	2	_	_	NNP
18637	13660	3	See	See	NNP
18637	13660	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13660	5	pp	pp	NNP
18637	13660	6	.	.	.
18637	13661	1	675	675	CD
18637	13661	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13661	3	682	682	CD
18637	13661	4	.	.	.
18637	13661	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13662	1	Judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13662	2	:	:	:
18637	13662	3	The	the	DT
18637	13662	4	Primary	Primary	NNP
18637	13662	5	Concern	Concern	NNP
18637	13662	6	of	of	IN
18637	13662	7	the	the	DT
18637	13662	8	Provision	Provision	NNP
18637	13662	9	TWO	two	CD
18637	13662	10	PRINCIPAL	principal	NN
18637	13662	11	CLASSES	class	NNS
18637	13662	12	OF	of	IN
18637	13662	13	JUDGMENTS	JUDGMENTS	NNP
18637	13662	14	Article	Article	NNP
18637	13662	15	IV	IV	NNP
18637	13662	16	,	,	,
18637	13662	17	section	section	NN
18637	13662	18	1	1	CD
18637	13662	19	,	,	,
18637	13662	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	13662	21	had	have	VBN
18637	13662	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13662	23	principal	principal	JJ
18637	13662	24	operation	operation	NN
18637	13662	25	in	in	IN
18637	13662	26	relation	relation	NN
18637	13662	27	to	to	IN
18637	13662	28	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13662	29	.	.	.
18637	13663	1	The	the	DT
18637	13663	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	13663	3	fall	fall	VBP
18637	13663	4	into	into	IN
18637	13663	5	two	two	CD
18637	13663	6	groups	group	NNS
18637	13663	7	:	:	:
18637	13663	8	First	first	RB
18637	13663	9	,	,	,
18637	13663	10	those	those	DT
18637	13663	11	in	in	IN
18637	13663	12	which	which	WDT
18637	13663	13	the	the	DT
18637	13663	14	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13663	15	involved	involve	VBN
18637	13663	16	was	be	VBD
18637	13663	17	offered	offer	VBN
18637	13663	18	as	as	IN
18637	13663	19	a	a	DT
18637	13663	20	basis	basis	NN
18637	13663	21	of	of	IN
18637	13663	22	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13663	23	for	for	IN
18637	13663	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13663	25	own	own	JJ
18637	13663	26	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	13663	27	outside	outside	IN
18637	13663	28	the	the	DT
18637	13663	29	State	state	NN
18637	13663	30	where	where	WRB
18637	13663	31	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13663	32	,	,	,
18637	13663	33	as	as	IN
18637	13663	34	for	for	IN
18637	13663	35	example	example	NN
18637	13663	36	,	,	,
18637	13663	37	when	when	WRB
18637	13663	38	an	an	DT
18637	13663	39	action	action	NN
18637	13663	40	for	for	IN
18637	13663	41	debt	debt	NN
18637	13663	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	13663	43	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13663	44	in	in	RP
18637	13663	45	the	the	DT
18637	13663	46	courts	court	NNS
18637	13663	47	of	of	IN
18637	13663	48	State	State	NNP
18637	13663	49	B	B	NNP
18637	13663	50	on	on	IN
18637	13663	51	a	a	DT
18637	13663	52	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13663	53	for	for	IN
18637	13663	54	money	money	NN
18637	13663	55	damages	damage	NNS
18637	13663	56	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13663	57	in	in	IN
18637	13663	58	State	State	NNP
18637	13663	59	A	A	NNP
18637	13663	60	;	;	:
18637	13663	61	secondly	secondly	RB
18637	13663	62	,	,	,
18637	13663	63	those	those	DT
18637	13663	64	in	in	IN
18637	13663	65	which	which	WDT
18637	13663	66	the	the	DT
18637	13663	67	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13663	68	involved	involve	VBN
18637	13663	69	was	be	VBD
18637	13663	70	offered	offer	VBN
18637	13663	71	,	,	,
18637	13663	72	in	in	IN
18637	13663	73	conformance	conformance	NN
18637	13663	74	with	with	IN
18637	13663	75	the	the	DT
18637	13663	76	principle	principle	NN
18637	13663	77	of	of	IN
18637	13663	78	_	_	NNP
18637	13663	79	res	res	NNP
18637	13663	80	judicata	judicata	NNP
18637	13663	81	_	_	NNP
18637	13663	82	,	,	,
18637	13663	83	in	in	IN
18637	13663	84	defense	defense	NN
18637	13663	85	in	in	IN
18637	13663	86	a	a	DT
18637	13663	87	new	new	JJ
18637	13663	88	or	or	CC
18637	13663	89	"	"	``
18637	13663	90	collateral	collateral	NN
18637	13663	91	"	"	''
18637	13663	92	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13663	93	growing	grow	VBG
18637	13663	94	out	out	IN
18637	13663	95	of	of	IN
18637	13663	96	the	the	DT
18637	13663	97	same	same	JJ
18637	13663	98	facts	fact	NNS
18637	13663	99	as	as	IN
18637	13663	100	the	the	DT
18637	13663	101	original	original	JJ
18637	13663	102	suit	suit	NN
18637	13663	103	,	,	,
18637	13663	104	as	as	IN
18637	13663	105	for	for	IN
18637	13663	106	example	example	NN
18637	13663	107	,	,	,
18637	13663	108	when	when	WRB
18637	13663	109	a	a	DT
18637	13663	110	decree	decree	NN
18637	13663	111	of	of	IN
18637	13663	112	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13663	113	granted	grant	VBN
18637	13663	114	in	in	IN
18637	13663	115	State	State	NNP
18637	13663	116	A	A	NNP
18637	13663	117	is	be	VBZ
18637	13663	118	offered	offer	VBN
18637	13663	119	as	as	IN
18637	13663	120	barring	bar	VBG
18637	13663	121	a	a	DT
18637	13663	122	suit	suit	NN
18637	13663	123	for	for	IN
18637	13663	124	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13663	125	by	by	IN
18637	13663	126	the	the	DT
18637	13663	127	other	other	JJ
18637	13663	128	party	party	NN
18637	13663	129	to	to	IN
18637	13663	130	the	the	DT
18637	13663	131	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	13663	132	in	in	IN
18637	13663	133	the	the	DT
18637	13663	134	courts	court	NNS
18637	13663	135	of	of	IN
18637	13663	136	State	State	NNP
18637	13663	137	B.	B.	NNP
18637	13664	1	EFFECT	effect	NN
18637	13664	2	TO	to	TO
18637	13664	3	BE	be	VB
18637	13664	4	GIVEN	give	VBN
18637	13664	5	IN	in	IN
18637	13664	6	FORUM	forum	NN
18637	13664	7	STATE	state	NN
18637	13664	8	The	the	DT
18637	13664	9	English	english	JJ
18637	13664	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	13664	11	and	and	CC
18637	13664	12	the	the	DT
18637	13664	13	different	different	JJ
18637	13664	14	State	State	NNP
18637	13664	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	13664	16	in	in	IN
18637	13664	17	the	the	DT
18637	13664	18	United	United	NNP
18637	13664	19	States	States	NNP
18637	13664	20	,	,	,
18637	13664	21	while	while	IN
18637	13664	22	recognizing	recognize	VBG
18637	13664	23	"	"	``
18637	13664	24	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13664	25	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13664	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13664	27	in	in	IN
18637	13664	28	personam	personam	NNP
18637	13664	29	_	_	NNP
18637	13664	30	"	"	''
18637	13664	31	which	which	WDT
18637	13664	32	were	be	VBD
18637	13664	33	reducible	reducible	JJ
18637	13664	34	to	to	IN
18637	13664	35	money	money	NN
18637	13664	36	terms	term	NNS
18637	13664	37	as	as	IN
18637	13664	38	affording	afford	VBG
18637	13664	39	a	a	DT
18637	13664	40	basis	basis	NN
18637	13664	41	for	for	IN
18637	13664	42	actions	action	NNS
18637	13664	43	in	in	IN
18637	13664	44	debt	debt	NN
18637	13664	45	,	,	,
18637	13664	46	originally	originally	RB
18637	13664	47	accorded	accord	VBD
18637	13664	48	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13664	49	generally	generally	RB
18637	13664	50	only	only	RB
18637	13664	51	the	the	DT
18637	13664	52	status	status	NN
18637	13664	53	of	of	IN
18637	13664	54	_	_	NNP
18637	13664	55	prima	prima	NN
18637	13664	56	facie	facie	NNP
18637	13664	57	_	_	NNP
18637	13664	58	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	13664	59	in	in	IN
18637	13664	60	support	support	NN
18637	13664	61	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	13664	62	,	,	,
18637	13664	63	so	so	IN
18637	13664	64	that	that	IN
18637	13664	65	the	the	DT
18637	13664	66	merits	merit	NNS
18637	13664	67	of	of	IN
18637	13664	68	the	the	DT
18637	13664	69	original	original	JJ
18637	13664	70	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	13664	71	could	could	MD
18637	13664	72	always	always	RB
18637	13664	73	be	be	VB
18637	13664	74	opened	open	VBN
18637	13664	75	.	.	.
18637	13665	1	When	when	WRB
18637	13665	2	offered	offer	VBN
18637	13665	3	in	in	IN
18637	13665	4	defense	defense	NN
18637	13665	5	,	,	,
18637	13665	6	on	on	IN
18637	13665	7	the	the	DT
18637	13665	8	other	other	JJ
18637	13665	9	hand	hand	NN
18637	13665	10	,	,	,
18637	13665	11	"	"	``
18637	13665	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13665	13	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13665	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13665	15	in	in	IN
18637	13665	16	personam	personam	NNP
18637	13665	17	_	_	NNP
18637	13665	18	"	"	''
18637	13665	19	were	be	VBD
18637	13665	20	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	13665	21	treated	treat	VBN
18637	13665	22	as	as	IN
18637	13665	23	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	13665	24	,	,	,
18637	13665	25	as	as	IN
18637	13665	26	between	between	IN
18637	13665	27	parties	party	NNS
18637	13665	28	,	,	,
18637	13665	29	of	of	IN
18637	13665	30	the	the	DT
18637	13665	31	issues	issue	NNS
18637	13665	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13665	33	purported	purport	VBD
18637	13665	34	to	to	TO
18637	13665	35	determine	determine	VB
18637	13665	36	,	,	,
18637	13665	37	provided	provide	VBN
18637	13665	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13665	39	had	have	VBD
18637	13665	40	been	be	VBN
18637	13665	41	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13665	42	by	by	IN
18637	13665	43	a	a	DT
18637	13665	44	court	court	NN
18637	13665	45	of	of	IN
18637	13665	46	competent	competent	JJ
18637	13665	47	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13665	48	and	and	CC
18637	13665	49	were	be	VBD
18637	13665	50	not	not	RB
18637	13665	51	tainted	taint	VBN
18637	13665	52	with	with	IN
18637	13665	53	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	13665	54	.	.	.
18637	13666	1	And	and	CC
18637	13666	2	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13666	3	"	"	``
18637	13666	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13666	5	in	in	IN
18637	13666	6	rem	rem	NNP
18637	13666	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13666	8	"	"	``
18637	13666	9	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13666	10	under	under	IN
18637	13666	11	the	the	DT
18637	13666	12	same	same	JJ
18637	13666	13	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	13666	14	were	be	VBD
18637	13666	15	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	13666	16	as	as	IN
18637	13666	17	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	13666	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	13666	19	everybody	everybody	NN
18637	13666	20	on	on	IN
18637	13666	21	the	the	DT
18637	13666	22	theory	theory	NN
18637	13666	23	that	that	IN
18637	13666	24	,	,	,
18637	13666	25	as	as	IN
18637	13666	26	stated	state	VBN
18637	13666	27	by	by	IN
18637	13666	28	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	13666	29	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13666	30	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	13666	31	,	,	,
18637	13666	32	"	"	``
18637	13666	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13666	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	13666	35	a	a	DT
18637	13666	36	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13666	37	_	_	NNP
18637	13666	38	in	in	IN
18637	13666	39	rem	rem	NNP
18637	13666	40	_	_	NNP
18637	13666	41	,	,	,
18637	13666	42	to	to	TO
18637	13666	43	which	which	WDT
18637	13666	44	all	all	PDT
18637	13666	45	the	the	DT
18637	13666	46	world	world	NN
18637	13666	47	are	be	VBP
18637	13666	48	parties	party	NNS
18637	13666	49	.	.	.
18637	13667	1	"	"	``
18637	13667	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13667	3	3	3	LS
18637	13667	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13667	5	The	the	DT
18637	13667	6	pioneer	pioneer	NN
18637	13667	7	case	case	NN
18637	13667	8	was	be	VBD
18637	13667	9	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	13667	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13667	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	13667	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13667	13	Duryee,[4	Duryee,[4	NNP
18637	13667	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13667	15	decided	decide	VBD
18637	13667	16	in	in	IN
18637	13667	17	1813	1813	CD
18637	13667	18	.	.	.
18637	13668	1	In	in	IN
18637	13668	2	an	an	DT
18637	13668	3	action	action	NN
18637	13668	4	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13668	5	in	in	IN
18637	13668	6	the	the	DT
18637	13668	7	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	13668	8	court	court	NN
18637	13668	9	of	of	IN
18637	13668	10	the	the	DT
18637	13668	11	District	District	NNP
18637	13668	12	of	of	IN
18637	13668	13	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	13668	14	--	--	:
18637	13668	15	the	the	DT
18637	13668	16	equivalent	equivalent	NN
18637	13668	17	of	of	IN
18637	13668	18	a	a	DT
18637	13668	19	State	State	NNP
18637	13668	20	court	court	NN
18637	13668	21	for	for	IN
18637	13668	22	this	this	DT
18637	13668	23	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	13668	24	--	--	:
18637	13668	25	on	on	IN
18637	13668	26	a	a	DT
18637	13668	27	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13668	28	from	from	IN
18637	13668	29	a	a	DT
18637	13668	30	New	New	NNP
18637	13668	31	York	York	NNP
18637	13668	32	court	court	NN
18637	13668	33	,	,	,
18637	13668	34	the	the	DT
18637	13668	35	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13668	36	endeavored	endeavor	VBD
18637	13668	37	to	to	TO
18637	13668	38	reopen	reopen	VB
18637	13668	39	the	the	DT
18637	13668	40	whole	whole	JJ
18637	13668	41	question	question	NN
18637	13668	42	of	of	IN
18637	13668	43	the	the	DT
18637	13668	44	merits	merit	NNS
18637	13668	45	of	of	IN
18637	13668	46	the	the	DT
18637	13668	47	original	original	JJ
18637	13668	48	case	case	NN
18637	13668	49	by	by	IN
18637	13668	50	a	a	DT
18637	13668	51	plea	plea	NN
18637	13668	52	of	of	IN
18637	13668	53	"	"	``
18637	13668	54	_	_	NNP
18637	13668	55	nil	nil	NNP
18637	13668	56	debet	debet	NN
18637	13668	57	_	_	NNP
18637	13668	58	.	.	.
18637	13668	59	"	"	''
18637	13669	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13669	2	was	be	VBD
18637	13669	3	answered	answer	VBN
18637	13669	4	in	in	IN
18637	13669	5	the	the	DT
18637	13669	6	words	word	NNS
18637	13669	7	of	of	IN
18637	13669	8	the	the	DT
18637	13669	9	act	act	NN
18637	13669	10	of	of	IN
18637	13669	11	1790	1790	CD
18637	13669	12	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13669	13	,	,	,
18637	13669	14	that	that	IN
18637	13669	15	such	such	JJ
18637	13669	16	records	record	NNS
18637	13669	17	and	and	CC
18637	13669	18	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13669	19	were	be	VBD
18637	13669	20	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13669	21	in	in	IN
18637	13669	22	each	each	DT
18637	13669	23	State	state	NN
18637	13669	24	to	to	IN
18637	13669	25	the	the	DT
18637	13669	26	same	same	JJ
18637	13669	27	faith	faith	NN
18637	13669	28	and	and	CC
18637	13669	29	credit	credit	NN
18637	13669	30	as	as	IN
18637	13669	31	in	in	IN
18637	13669	32	the	the	DT
18637	13669	33	State	State	NNP
18637	13669	34	of	of	IN
18637	13669	35	origin	origin	NN
18637	13669	36	;	;	:
18637	13669	37	and	and	CC
18637	13669	38	that	that	DT
18637	13669	39	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	13669	40	as	as	IN
18637	13669	41	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13669	42	were	be	VBD
18637	13669	43	records	record	NNS
18637	13669	44	of	of	IN
18637	13669	45	a	a	DT
18637	13669	46	court	court	NN
18637	13669	47	in	in	IN
18637	13669	48	the	the	DT
18637	13669	49	State	State	NNP
18637	13669	50	of	of	IN
18637	13669	51	origin	origin	NN
18637	13669	52	,	,	,
18637	13669	53	and	and	CC
18637	13669	54	so	so	RB
18637	13669	55	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	13669	56	of	of	IN
18637	13669	57	the	the	DT
18637	13669	58	merits	merit	NNS
18637	13669	59	of	of	IN
18637	13669	60	the	the	DT
18637	13669	61	case	case	NN
18637	13669	62	there	there	RB
18637	13669	63	,	,	,
18637	13669	64	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13669	65	were	be	VBD
18637	13669	66	equally	equally	RB
18637	13669	67	so	so	RB
18637	13669	68	in	in	IN
18637	13669	69	the	the	DT
18637	13669	70	forum	forum	NN
18637	13669	71	State	state	NN
18637	13669	72	.	.	.
18637	13670	1	The	the	DT
18637	13670	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13670	3	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	13670	4	the	the	DT
18637	13670	5	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13670	6	view	view	NN
18637	13670	7	,	,	,
18637	13670	8	saying	say	VBG
18637	13670	9	that	that	IN
18637	13670	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13670	11	had	have	VBD
18637	13670	12	not	not	RB
18637	13670	13	been	be	VBN
18637	13670	14	the	the	DT
18637	13670	15	intention	intention	NN
18637	13670	16	of	of	IN
18637	13670	17	the	the	DT
18637	13670	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13670	19	merely	merely	RB
18637	13670	20	to	to	TO
18637	13670	21	reenact	reenact	VB
18637	13670	22	the	the	DT
18637	13670	23	common	common	JJ
18637	13670	24	law	law	NN
18637	13670	25	--	--	:
18637	13670	26	that	that	RB
18637	13670	27	is	is	RB
18637	13670	28	,	,	,
18637	13670	29	the	the	DT
18637	13670	30	principles	principle	NNS
18637	13670	31	of	of	IN
18637	13670	32	private	private	JJ
18637	13670	33	international	international	JJ
18637	13670	34	law	law	NN
18637	13670	35	--	--	:
18637	13670	36	as	as	IN
18637	13670	37	to	to	IN
18637	13670	38	the	the	DT
18637	13670	39	reception	reception	NN
18637	13670	40	of	of	IN
18637	13670	41	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13670	42	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13670	43	,	,	,
18637	13670	44	but	but	CC
18637	13670	45	to	to	TO
18637	13670	46	amplify	amplify	VB
18637	13670	47	and	and	CC
18637	13670	48	fortify	fortify	VB
18637	13670	49	these	these	DT
18637	13670	50	.	.	.
18637	13671	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13671	2	5	5	CD
18637	13671	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13671	4	And	and	CC
18637	13671	5	in	in	IN
18637	13671	6	Hampton	Hampton	NNP
18637	13671	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13671	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	13671	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13671	10	McConnell[6	McConnell[6	NNP
18637	13671	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13671	12	some	some	DT
18637	13671	13	years	year	NNS
18637	13671	14	later	later	RB
18637	13671	15	,	,	,
18637	13671	16	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	13671	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13671	18	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	13671	19	went	go	VBD
18637	13671	20	even	even	RB
18637	13671	21	further	further	RB
18637	13671	22	,	,	,
18637	13671	23	using	use	VBG
18637	13671	24	language	language	NN
18637	13671	25	which	which	WDT
18637	13671	26	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	13671	27	to	to	TO
18637	13671	28	show	show	VB
18637	13671	29	that	that	IN
18637	13671	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13671	31	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	13671	32	the	the	DT
18637	13671	33	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13671	34	of	of	IN
18637	13671	35	a	a	DT
18637	13671	36	State	State	NNP
18637	13671	37	court	court	NN
18637	13671	38	as	as	IN
18637	13671	39	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	13671	40	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13671	41	to	to	TO
18637	13671	42	be	be	VB
18637	13671	43	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	13671	44	in	in	IN
18637	13671	45	the	the	DT
18637	13671	46	courts	court	NNS
18637	13671	47	of	of	IN
18637	13671	48	sister	sister	NN
18637	13671	49	States	States	NNP
18637	13671	50	not	not	RB
18637	13671	51	simply	simply	RB
18637	13671	52	the	the	DT
18637	13671	53	faith	faith	NN
18637	13671	54	and	and	CC
18637	13671	55	credit	credit	NN
18637	13671	56	of	of	IN
18637	13671	57	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	13671	58	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	13671	59	,	,	,
18637	13671	60	but	but	CC
18637	13671	61	the	the	DT
18637	13671	62	validity	validity	NN
18637	13671	63	of	of	IN
18637	13671	64	a	a	DT
18637	13671	65	final	final	JJ
18637	13671	66	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13671	67	.	.	.
18637	13672	1	When	when	WRB
18637	13672	2	,	,	,
18637	13672	3	however	however	RB
18637	13672	4	,	,	,
18637	13672	5	the	the	DT
18637	13672	6	next	next	JJ
18637	13672	7	important	important	JJ
18637	13672	8	case	case	NN
18637	13672	9	arose	arise	VBD
18637	13672	10	,	,	,
18637	13672	11	the	the	DT
18637	13672	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13672	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	13672	14	come	come	VBN
18637	13672	15	under	under	IN
18637	13672	16	new	new	JJ
18637	13672	17	influences	influence	NNS
18637	13672	18	.	.	.
18637	13673	1	This	this	DT
18637	13673	2	was	be	VBD
18637	13673	3	McElmoyle	McElmoyle	NNP
18637	13673	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13673	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	13673	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13673	7	Cohen,[7	Cohen,[7	NNP
18637	13673	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13673	9	decided	decide	VBD
18637	13673	10	in	in	IN
18637	13673	11	1839	1839	CD
18637	13673	12	,	,	,
18637	13673	13	in	in	IN
18637	13673	14	which	which	WDT
18637	13673	15	the	the	DT
18637	13673	16	issue	issue	NN
18637	13673	17	was	be	VBD
18637	13673	18	whether	whether	IN
18637	13673	19	a	a	DT
18637	13673	20	statute	statute	NN
18637	13673	21	of	of	IN
18637	13673	22	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	13673	23	of	of	IN
18637	13673	24	the	the	DT
18637	13673	25	State	State	NNP
18637	13673	26	of	of	IN
18637	13673	27	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	13673	28	,	,	,
18637	13673	29	which	which	WDT
18637	13673	30	applied	apply	VBD
18637	13673	31	only	only	RB
18637	13673	32	to	to	IN
18637	13673	33	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13673	34	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13673	35	in	in	IN
18637	13673	36	courts	court	NNS
18637	13673	37	other	other	JJ
18637	13673	38	than	than	IN
18637	13673	39	those	those	DT
18637	13673	40	of	of	IN
18637	13673	41	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	13673	42	,	,	,
18637	13673	43	could	could	MD
18637	13673	44	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	13673	45	bar	bar	VB
18637	13673	46	an	an	DT
18637	13673	47	action	action	NN
18637	13673	48	in	in	IN
18637	13673	49	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	13673	50	on	on	IN
18637	13673	51	a	a	DT
18637	13673	52	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13673	53	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13673	54	by	by	IN
18637	13673	55	a	a	DT
18637	13673	56	court	court	NN
18637	13673	57	of	of	IN
18637	13673	58	record	record	NN
18637	13673	59	of	of	IN
18637	13673	60	South	South	NNP
18637	13673	61	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	13673	62	.	.	.
18637	13674	1	Declining	decline	VBG
18637	13674	2	to	to	TO
18637	13674	3	follow	follow	VB
18637	13674	4	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	13674	5	's	's	POS
18637	13674	6	lead	lead	NN
18637	13674	7	in	in	IN
18637	13674	8	Hampton	Hampton	NNP
18637	13674	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13674	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	13674	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13674	12	McConnell	McConnell	NNP
18637	13674	13	,	,	,
18637	13674	14	the	the	DT
18637	13674	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13674	16	held	hold	VBD
18637	13674	17	that	that	IN
18637	13674	18	the	the	DT
18637	13674	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13674	20	was	be	VBD
18637	13674	21	not	not	RB
18637	13674	22	intended	intend	VBN
18637	13674	23	"	"	''
18637	13674	24	materially	materially	RB
18637	13674	25	to	to	TO
18637	13674	26	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	13674	27	with	with	IN
18637	13674	28	the	the	DT
18637	13674	29	essential	essential	JJ
18637	13674	30	attributes	attribute	NNS
18637	13674	31	of	of	IN
18637	13674	32	the	the	DT
18637	13674	33	_	_	NNP
18637	13674	34	lex	lex	NN
18637	13674	35	fori	fori	NN
18637	13674	36	_	_	NNP
18637	13674	37	"	"	''
18637	13674	38	;	;	:
18637	13674	39	that	that	IN
18637	13674	40	the	the	DT
18637	13674	41	act	act	NN
18637	13674	42	of	of	IN
18637	13674	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13674	44	only	only	RB
18637	13674	45	established	establish	VBD
18637	13674	46	a	a	DT
18637	13674	47	rule	rule	NN
18637	13674	48	of	of	IN
18637	13674	49	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	13674	50	,	,	,
18637	13674	51	of	of	IN
18637	13674	52	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	13674	53	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	13674	54	to	to	TO
18637	13674	55	be	be	VB
18637	13674	56	sure	sure	JJ
18637	13674	57	,	,	,
18637	13674	58	but	but	CC
18637	13674	59	still	still	RB
18637	13674	60	of	of	IN
18637	13674	61	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	13674	62	only	only	RB
18637	13674	63	;	;	:
18637	13674	64	and	and	CC
18637	13674	65	that	that	IN
18637	13674	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13674	67	was	be	VBD
18637	13674	68	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	13674	69	,	,	,
18637	13674	70	in	in	IN
18637	13674	71	order	order	NN
18637	13674	72	to	to	TO
18637	13674	73	carry	carry	VB
18637	13674	74	into	into	IN
18637	13674	75	effect	effect	NN
18637	13674	76	in	in	IN
18637	13674	77	a	a	DT
18637	13674	78	State	state	NN
18637	13674	79	the	the	DT
18637	13674	80	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13674	81	of	of	IN
18637	13674	82	a	a	DT
18637	13674	83	court	court	NN
18637	13674	84	of	of	IN
18637	13674	85	a	a	DT
18637	13674	86	sister	sister	NN
18637	13674	87	State	State	NNP
18637	13674	88	,	,	,
18637	13674	89	to	to	TO
18637	13674	90	institute	institute	VB
18637	13674	91	a	a	DT
18637	13674	92	fresh	fresh	JJ
18637	13674	93	action	action	NN
18637	13674	94	in	in	IN
18637	13674	95	the	the	DT
18637	13674	96	court	court	NN
18637	13674	97	of	of	IN
18637	13674	98	the	the	DT
18637	13674	99	former	former	JJ
18637	13674	100	,	,	,
18637	13674	101	in	in	IN
18637	13674	102	strict	strict	JJ
18637	13674	103	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	13674	104	with	with	IN
18637	13674	105	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13674	106	laws	law	NNS
18637	13674	107	;	;	:
18637	13674	108	and	and	CC
18637	13674	109	that	that	IN
18637	13674	110	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	13674	111	,	,	,
18637	13674	112	when	when	WRB
18637	13674	113	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	13674	114	were	be	VBD
18637	13674	115	sought	seek	VBN
18637	13674	116	in	in	IN
18637	13674	117	support	support	NN
18637	13674	118	of	of	IN
18637	13674	119	the	the	DT
18637	13674	120	rights	right	NNS
18637	13674	121	accruing	accrue	VBG
18637	13674	122	in	in	IN
18637	13674	123	another	another	DT
18637	13674	124	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13674	125	,	,	,
18637	13674	126	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13674	127	were	be	VBD
18637	13674	128	governed	govern	VBN
18637	13674	129	by	by	IN
18637	13674	130	the	the	DT
18637	13674	131	_	_	NNP
18637	13674	132	lex	lex	NN
18637	13674	133	fori	fori	NN
18637	13674	134	_	_	NNP
18637	13674	135	.	.	.
18637	13675	1	In	in	IN
18637	13675	2	accord	accord	NN
18637	13675	3	with	with	IN
18637	13675	4	this	this	DT
18637	13675	5	holding	holding	NN
18637	13675	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13675	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	13675	8	been	be	VBN
18637	13675	9	further	far	RBR
18637	13675	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	13675	11	that	that	IN
18637	13675	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13675	13	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13675	14	enjoy	enjoy	VBP
18637	13675	15	,	,	,
18637	13675	16	not	not	RB
18637	13675	17	the	the	DT
18637	13675	18	right	right	NN
18637	13675	19	of	of	IN
18637	13675	20	priority	priority	NN
18637	13675	21	or	or	CC
18637	13675	22	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	13675	23	or	or	CC
18637	13675	24	lien	lien	NN
18637	13675	25	which	which	WDT
18637	13675	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13675	27	have	have	VBP
18637	13675	28	in	in	IN
18637	13675	29	the	the	DT
18637	13675	30	State	State	NNP
18637	13675	31	where	where	WRB
18637	13675	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13675	33	are	be	VBP
18637	13675	34	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
18637	13675	35	,	,	,
18637	13675	36	but	but	CC
18637	13675	37	only	only	RB
18637	13675	38	that	that	DT
18637	13675	39	which	which	WDT
18637	13675	40	the	the	DT
18637	13675	41	_	_	NNP
18637	13675	42	lex	lex	NN
18637	13675	43	fori	fori	NN
18637	13675	44	_	_	NNP
18637	13675	45	gives	give	VBZ
18637	13675	46	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13675	47	by	by	IN
18637	13675	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13675	49	own	own	JJ
18637	13675	50	laws	law	NNS
18637	13675	51	,	,	,
18637	13675	52	in	in	IN
18637	13675	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13675	54	character	character	NN
18637	13675	55	of	of	IN
18637	13675	56	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13675	57	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13675	58	.	.	.
18637	13676	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13676	2	8	8	LS
18637	13676	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13676	4	A	a	DT
18637	13676	5	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13676	6	of	of	IN
18637	13676	7	a	a	DT
18637	13676	8	State	State	NNP
18637	13676	9	court	court	NN
18637	13676	10	,	,	,
18637	13676	11	in	in	IN
18637	13676	12	a	a	DT
18637	13676	13	cause	cause	NN
18637	13676	14	within	within	IN
18637	13676	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13676	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13676	17	,	,	,
18637	13676	18	and	and	CC
18637	13676	19	against	against	IN
18637	13676	20	a	a	DT
18637	13676	21	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13676	22	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	13676	23	summoned	summon	VBN
18637	13676	24	,	,	,
18637	13676	25	or	or	CC
18637	13676	26	against	against	IN
18637	13676	27	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	13676	28	attached	attach	VBN
18637	13676	29	property	property	NN
18637	13676	30	of	of	IN
18637	13676	31	an	an	DT
18637	13676	32	absent	absent	JJ
18637	13676	33	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13676	34	,	,	,
18637	13676	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	13676	36	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13676	37	to	to	IN
18637	13676	38	as	as	RB
18637	13676	39	much	much	JJ
18637	13676	40	force	force	NN
18637	13676	41	and	and	CC
18637	13676	42	effect	effect	NN
18637	13676	43	against	against	IN
18637	13676	44	the	the	DT
18637	13676	45	person	person	NN
18637	13676	46	summoned	summon	VBN
18637	13676	47	or	or	CC
18637	13676	48	the	the	DT
18637	13676	49	property	property	NN
18637	13676	50	attached	attach	VBN
18637	13676	51	,	,	,
18637	13676	52	when	when	WRB
18637	13676	53	the	the	DT
18637	13676	54	question	question	NN
18637	13676	55	is	be	VBZ
18637	13676	56	presented	present	VBN
18637	13676	57	for	for	IN
18637	13676	58	decision	decision	NN
18637	13676	59	in	in	IN
18637	13676	60	a	a	DT
18637	13676	61	court	court	NN
18637	13676	62	in	in	IN
18637	13676	63	another	another	DT
18637	13676	64	State	State	NNP
18637	13676	65	,	,	,
18637	13676	66	as	as	IN
18637	13676	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13676	68	has	have	VBZ
18637	13676	69	in	in	IN
18637	13676	70	the	the	DT
18637	13676	71	State	State	NNP
18637	13676	72	in	in	IN
18637	13676	73	which	which	WDT
18637	13676	74	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13676	75	was	be	VBD
18637	13676	76	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13676	77	.	.	.
18637	13677	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13677	2	9	9	CD
18637	13677	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13677	4	A	a	DT
18637	13677	5	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13677	6	enforceable	enforceable	JJ
18637	13677	7	in	in	IN
18637	13677	8	the	the	DT
18637	13677	9	State	State	NNP
18637	13677	10	where	where	WRB
18637	13677	11	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13677	12	must	must	MD
18637	13677	13	be	be	VB
18637	13677	14	given	give	VBN
18637	13677	15	effect	effect	NN
18637	13677	16	in	in	IN
18637	13677	17	the	the	DT
18637	13677	18	other	other	JJ
18637	13677	19	State	State	NNP
18637	13677	20	,	,	,
18637	13677	21	although	although	IN
18637	13677	22	the	the	DT
18637	13677	23	modes	mode	NNS
18637	13677	24	of	of	IN
18637	13677	25	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	13677	26	to	to	TO
18637	13677	27	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	13677	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13677	29	collection	collection	NN
18637	13677	30	may	may	MD
18637	13677	31	not	not	RB
18637	13677	32	be	be	VB
18637	13677	33	the	the	DT
18637	13677	34	same	same	JJ
18637	13677	35	in	in	IN
18637	13677	36	both	both	DT
18637	13677	37	States	state	NNS
18637	13677	38	.	.	.
18637	13678	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13678	2	10	10	CD
18637	13678	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13678	4	If	if	IN
18637	13678	5	the	the	DT
18637	13678	6	court	court	NN
18637	13678	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	13678	8	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	13678	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13678	10	,	,	,
18637	13678	11	the	the	DT
18637	13678	12	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13678	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	13678	14	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13678	15	to	to	IN
18637	13678	16	full	full	JJ
18637	13678	17	faith	faith	NN
18637	13678	18	and	and	CC
18637	13678	19	credit	credit	NN
18637	13678	20	though	though	IN
18637	13678	21	the	the	DT
18637	13678	22	court	court	NN
18637	13678	23	may	may	MD
18637	13678	24	not	not	RB
18637	13678	25	be	be	VB
18637	13678	26	able	able	JJ
18637	13678	27	to	to	TO
18637	13678	28	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	13678	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13678	30	by	by	IN
18637	13678	31	execution	execution	NN
18637	13678	32	in	in	IN
18637	13678	33	the	the	DT
18637	13678	34	State	State	NNP
18637	13678	35	in	in	IN
18637	13678	36	which	which	WDT
18637	13678	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13678	38	was	be	VBD
18637	13678	39	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13678	40	,	,	,
18637	13678	41	as	as	IN
18637	13678	42	where	where	WRB
18637	13678	43	the	the	DT
18637	13678	44	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13678	45	left	leave	VBD
18637	13678	46	the	the	DT
18637	13678	47	State	State	NNP
18637	13678	48	after	after	IN
18637	13678	49	service	service	NN
18637	13678	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	13678	51	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13678	52	and	and	CC
18637	13678	53	took	take	VBD
18637	13678	54	all	all	PDT
18637	13678	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13678	56	property	property	NN
18637	13678	57	with	with	IN
18637	13678	58	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13678	59	.	.	.
18637	13679	1	While	while	IN
18637	13679	2	the	the	DT
18637	13679	3	want	want	NN
18637	13679	4	of	of	IN
18637	13679	5	power	power	NN
18637	13679	6	to	to	TO
18637	13679	7	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	13679	8	a	a	DT
18637	13679	9	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13679	10	or	or	CC
18637	13679	11	decree	decree	NN
18637	13679	12	may	may	MD
18637	13679	13	afford	afford	VB
18637	13679	14	a	a	DT
18637	13679	15	reason	reason	NN
18637	13679	16	against	against	IN
18637	13679	17	entertaining	entertaining	JJ
18637	13679	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13679	19	,	,	,
18637	13679	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13679	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	13679	22	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	13679	23	to	to	TO
18637	13679	24	do	do	VB
18637	13679	25	with	with	IN
18637	13679	26	the	the	DT
18637	13679	27	validity	validity	NN
18637	13679	28	of	of	IN
18637	13679	29	a	a	DT
18637	13679	30	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13679	31	or	or	CC
18637	13679	32	decree	decree	NN
18637	13679	33	when	when	WRB
18637	13679	34	made	make	VBN
18637	13679	35	.	.	.
18637	13680	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13680	2	11	11	CD
18637	13680	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13680	4	In	in	IN
18637	13680	5	the	the	DT
18637	13680	6	words	word	NNS
18637	13680	7	of	of	IN
18637	13680	8	the	the	DT
18637	13680	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13680	10	in	in	IN
18637	13680	11	a	a	DT
18637	13680	12	recent	recent	JJ
18637	13680	13	case	case	NN
18637	13680	14	:	:	:
18637	13680	15	"	"	``
18637	13680	16	A	a	DT
18637	13680	17	cause	cause	NN
18637	13680	18	of	of	IN
18637	13680	19	action	action	NN
18637	13680	20	on	on	IN
18637	13680	21	a	a	DT
18637	13680	22	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13680	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	13680	24	different	different	JJ
18637	13680	25	from	from	IN
18637	13680	26	that	that	DT
18637	13680	27	upon	upon	IN
18637	13680	28	which	which	WDT
18637	13680	29	the	the	DT
18637	13680	30	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13680	31	was	be	VBD
18637	13680	32	entered	enter	VBN
18637	13680	33	.	.	.
18637	13681	1	In	in	IN
18637	13681	2	a	a	DT
18637	13681	3	suit	suit	NN
18637	13681	4	upon	upon	IN
18637	13681	5	a	a	DT
18637	13681	6	money	money	NN
18637	13681	7	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13681	8	for	for	IN
18637	13681	9	a	a	DT
18637	13681	10	civil	civil	JJ
18637	13681	11	cause	cause	NN
18637	13681	12	of	of	IN
18637	13681	13	action	action	NN
18637	13681	14	,	,	,
18637	13681	15	the	the	DT
18637	13681	16	validity	validity	NN
18637	13681	17	of	of	IN
18637	13681	18	the	the	DT
18637	13681	19	claim	claim	NN
18637	13681	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	13681	21	which	which	WDT
18637	13681	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13681	23	was	be	VBD
18637	13681	24	founded	found	VBN
18637	13681	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	13681	26	not	not	RB
18637	13681	27	open	open	JJ
18637	13681	28	to	to	IN
18637	13681	29	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	13681	30	,	,	,
18637	13681	31	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	13681	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13681	33	genesis	genesis	NN
18637	13681	34	.	.	.
18637	13682	1	Regardless	regardless	RB
18637	13682	2	of	of	IN
18637	13682	3	the	the	DT
18637	13682	4	nature	nature	NN
18637	13682	5	of	of	IN
18637	13682	6	the	the	DT
18637	13682	7	right	right	NN
18637	13682	8	which	which	WDT
18637	13682	9	gave	give	VBD
18637	13682	10	rise	rise	NN
18637	13682	11	to	to	IN
18637	13682	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13682	13	,	,	,
18637	13682	14	the	the	DT
18637	13682	15	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13682	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	13682	17	an	an	DT
18637	13682	18	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	13682	19	to	to	TO
18637	13682	20	pay	pay	VB
18637	13682	21	money	money	NN
18637	13682	22	in	in	IN
18637	13682	23	the	the	DT
18637	13682	24	nature	nature	NN
18637	13682	25	of	of	IN
18637	13682	26	a	a	DT
18637	13682	27	debt	debt	NN
18637	13682	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	13682	29	a	a	DT
18637	13682	30	specialty	specialty	NN
18637	13682	31	.	.	.
18637	13683	1	Recovery	recovery	NN
18637	13683	2	upon	upon	IN
18637	13683	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13683	4	can	can	MD
18637	13683	5	be	be	VB
18637	13683	6	resisted	resist	VBN
18637	13683	7	only	only	RB
18637	13683	8	on	on	IN
18637	13683	9	the	the	DT
18637	13683	10	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	13683	11	that	that	IN
18637	13683	12	the	the	DT
18637	13683	13	court	court	NN
18637	13683	14	which	which	WDT
18637	13683	15	rendered	render	VBD
18637	13683	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13683	17	was	be	VBD
18637	13683	18	without	without	IN
18637	13683	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13683	20	,	,	,
18637	13683	21	*	*	NFP
18637	13683	22	*	*	NFP
18637	13683	23	*	*	NFP
18637	13683	24	or	or	CC
18637	13683	25	that	that	IN
18637	13683	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13683	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	13683	28	ceased	cease	VBN
18637	13683	29	to	to	TO
18637	13683	30	be	be	VB
18637	13683	31	obligatory	obligatory	JJ
18637	13683	32	because	because	IN
18637	13683	33	of	of	IN
18637	13683	34	payment	payment	NN
18637	13683	35	or	or	CC
18637	13683	36	other	other	JJ
18637	13683	37	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	13683	38	*	*	NFP
18637	13683	39	*	*	NFP
18637	13683	40	*	*	NFP
18637	13683	41	or	or	CC
18637	13683	42	that	that	IN
18637	13683	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13683	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	13683	45	a	a	DT
18637	13683	46	cause	cause	NN
18637	13683	47	of	of	IN
18637	13683	48	action	action	NN
18637	13683	49	for	for	IN
18637	13683	50	which	which	WDT
18637	13683	51	the	the	DT
18637	13683	52	State	State	NNP
18637	13683	53	of	of	IN
18637	13683	54	the	the	DT
18637	13683	55	forum	forum	NN
18637	13683	56	has	have	VBZ
18637	13683	57	not	not	RB
18637	13683	58	provided	provide	VBN
18637	13683	59	a	a	DT
18637	13683	60	court	court	NN
18637	13683	61	*	*	NFP
18637	13683	62	*	*	NFP
18637	13683	63	*	*	NFP
18637	13683	64	"	"	''
18637	13683	65	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13683	66	12	12	CD
18637	13683	67	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13683	68	On	on	IN
18637	13683	69	the	the	DT
18637	13683	70	other	other	JJ
18637	13683	71	hand	hand	NN
18637	13683	72	,	,	,
18637	13683	73	the	the	DT
18637	13683	74	clause	clause	NN
18637	13683	75	is	be	VBZ
18637	13683	76	not	not	RB
18637	13683	77	violated	violate	VBN
18637	13683	78	when	when	WRB
18637	13683	79	a	a	DT
18637	13683	80	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13683	81	is	be	VBZ
18637	13683	82	disregarded	disregard	VBN
18637	13683	83	because	because	IN
18637	13683	84	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13683	85	is	be	VBZ
18637	13683	86	not	not	RB
18637	13683	87	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	13683	88	of	of	IN
18637	13683	89	the	the	DT
18637	13683	90	issues	issue	NNS
18637	13683	91	before	before	IN
18637	13683	92	a	a	DT
18637	13683	93	court	court	NN
18637	13683	94	of	of	IN
18637	13683	95	the	the	DT
18637	13683	96	forum	forum	NN
18637	13683	97	.	.	.
18637	13684	1	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	13684	2	,	,	,
18637	13684	3	no	no	DT
18637	13684	4	greater	great	JJR
18637	13684	5	effect	effect	NN
18637	13684	6	can	can	MD
18637	13684	7	be	be	VB
18637	13684	8	given	give	VBN
18637	13684	9	than	than	IN
18637	13684	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	13684	11	given	give	VBN
18637	13684	12	in	in	IN
18637	13684	13	the	the	DT
18637	13684	14	State	State	NNP
18637	13684	15	where	where	WRB
18637	13684	16	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13684	17	.	.	.
18637	13685	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	13685	2	an	an	DT
18637	13685	3	interlocutory	interlocutory	JJ
18637	13685	4	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13685	5	may	may	MD
18637	13685	6	not	not	RB
18637	13685	7	be	be	VB
18637	13685	8	given	give	VBN
18637	13685	9	the	the	DT
18637	13685	10	effect	effect	NN
18637	13685	11	of	of	IN
18637	13685	12	a	a	DT
18637	13685	13	final	final	JJ
18637	13685	14	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13685	15	.	.	.
18637	13686	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13686	2	13	13	CD
18637	13686	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13686	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	13686	5	when	when	WRB
18637	13686	6	a	a	DT
18637	13686	7	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13686	8	court	court	NN
18637	13686	9	does	do	VBZ
18637	13686	10	not	not	RB
18637	13686	11	attempt	attempt	VB
18637	13686	12	to	to	TO
18637	13686	13	foreclose	foreclose	VB
18637	13686	14	the	the	DT
18637	13686	15	State	State	NNP
18637	13686	16	court	court	NN
18637	13686	17	from	from	IN
18637	13686	18	hearing	hear	VBG
18637	13686	19	all	all	DT
18637	13686	20	matters	matter	NNS
18637	13686	21	of	of	IN
18637	13686	22	personal	personal	JJ
18637	13686	23	defense	defense	NN
18637	13686	24	which	which	WDT
18637	13686	25	landowners	landowner	NNS
18637	13686	26	might	may	MD
18637	13686	27	plead	plead	VB
18637	13686	28	,	,	,
18637	13686	29	a	a	DT
18637	13686	30	State	State	NNP
18637	13686	31	court	court	NN
18637	13686	32	may	may	MD
18637	13686	33	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	13686	34	to	to	TO
18637	13686	35	accept	accept	VB
18637	13686	36	the	the	DT
18637	13686	37	former	former	JJ
18637	13686	38	's	's	POS
18637	13686	39	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13686	40	as	as	IN
18637	13686	41	determinative	determinative	JJ
18637	13686	42	of	of	IN
18637	13686	43	the	the	DT
18637	13686	44	landowners	landowner	NNS
18637	13686	45	'	'	POS
18637	13686	46	liabilities	liability	NNS
18637	13686	47	.	.	.
18637	13687	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13687	2	14	14	CD
18637	13687	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13687	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	13687	5	,	,	,
18637	13687	6	though	though	IN
18637	13687	7	a	a	DT
18637	13687	8	confession	confession	NN
18637	13687	9	of	of	IN
18637	13687	10	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13687	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	13687	12	a	a	DT
18637	13687	13	note	note	NN
18637	13687	14	,	,	,
18637	13687	15	with	with	IN
18637	13687	16	a	a	DT
18637	13687	17	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	13687	18	of	of	IN
18637	13687	19	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	13687	20	annexed	annexed	NNS
18637	13687	21	,	,	,
18637	13687	22	in	in	IN
18637	13687	23	favor	favor	NN
18637	13687	24	of	of	IN
18637	13687	25	the	the	DT
18637	13687	26	holder	holder	NN
18637	13687	27	,	,	,
18637	13687	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	13687	29	in	in	IN
18637	13687	30	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	13687	31	with	with	IN
18637	13687	32	a	a	DT
18637	13687	33	State	State	NNP
18637	13687	34	law	law	NN
18637	13687	35	and	and	CC
18637	13687	36	usage	usage	NN
18637	13687	37	as	as	IN
18637	13687	38	declared	declare	VBN
18637	13687	39	by	by	IN
18637	13687	40	the	the	DT
18637	13687	41	highest	high	JJS
18637	13687	42	court	court	NN
18637	13687	43	of	of	IN
18637	13687	44	the	the	DT
18637	13687	45	State	State	NNP
18637	13687	46	in	in	IN
18637	13687	47	which	which	WDT
18637	13687	48	the	the	DT
18637	13687	49	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13687	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	13687	51	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13687	52	,	,	,
18637	13687	53	the	the	DT
18637	13687	54	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13687	55	may	may	MD
18637	13687	56	be	be	VB
18637	13687	57	collaterally	collaterally	RB
18637	13687	58	impeached	impeach	VBN
18637	13687	59	upon	upon	IN
18637	13687	60	the	the	DT
18637	13687	61	ground	ground	NN
18637	13687	62	that	that	IN
18637	13687	63	the	the	DT
18637	13687	64	party	party	NN
18637	13687	65	in	in	IN
18637	13687	66	whose	whose	WP$
18637	13687	67	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	13687	68	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13687	69	was	be	VBD
18637	13687	70	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13687	71	was	be	VBD
18637	13687	72	not	not	RB
18637	13687	73	in	in	IN
18637	13687	74	fact	fact	NN
18637	13687	75	the	the	DT
18637	13687	76	holder	holder	NN
18637	13687	77	.	.	.
18637	13688	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13688	2	15	15	CD
18637	13688	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13688	4	But	but	CC
18637	13688	5	a	a	DT
18637	13688	6	consent	consent	NN
18637	13688	7	decree	decree	NN
18637	13688	8	,	,	,
18637	13688	9	which	which	WDT
18637	13688	10	under	under	IN
18637	13688	11	the	the	DT
18637	13688	12	law	law	NN
18637	13688	13	of	of	IN
18637	13688	14	the	the	DT
18637	13688	15	State	State	NNP
18637	13688	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	13688	17	the	the	DT
18637	13688	18	same	same	JJ
18637	13688	19	force	force	NN
18637	13688	20	and	and	CC
18637	13688	21	effect	effect	NN
18637	13688	22	as	as	IN
18637	13688	23	a	a	DT
18637	13688	24	decree	decree	NN
18637	13688	25	_	_	NNP
18637	13688	26	in	in	IN
18637	13688	27	invitum	invitum	NN
18637	13688	28	_	_	NNP
18637	13688	29	,	,	,
18637	13688	30	must	must	MD
18637	13688	31	be	be	VB
18637	13688	32	given	give	VBN
18637	13688	33	the	the	DT
18637	13688	34	same	same	JJ
18637	13688	35	effect	effect	NN
18637	13688	36	in	in	IN
18637	13688	37	the	the	DT
18637	13688	38	courts	court	NNS
18637	13688	39	of	of	IN
18637	13688	40	another	another	DT
18637	13688	41	State	state	NN
18637	13688	42	.	.	.
18637	13689	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13689	2	16	16	CD
18637	13689	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13689	4	One	one	CD
18637	13689	5	result	result	NN
18637	13689	6	produced	produce	VBN
18637	13689	7	by	by	IN
18637	13689	8	not	not	RB
18637	13689	9	following	follow	VBG
18637	13689	10	Hampton	Hampton	NNP
18637	13689	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13689	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13689	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13689	14	McConnell	McConnell	NNP
18637	13689	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	13689	16	that	that	IN
18637	13689	17	even	even	RB
18637	13689	18	nowadays	nowadays	RB
18637	13689	19	the	the	DT
18637	13689	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13689	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	13689	22	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	13689	23	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	13689	24	with	with	IN
18637	13689	25	the	the	DT
18637	13689	26	contention	contention	NN
18637	13689	27	that	that	IN
18637	13689	28	a	a	DT
18637	13689	29	State	state	NN
18637	13689	30	need	nee	MD
18637	13689	31	not	not	RB
18637	13689	32	provide	provide	VB
18637	13689	33	a	a	DT
18637	13689	34	forum	forum	NN
18637	13689	35	for	for	IN
18637	13689	36	some	some	DT
18637	13689	37	particular	particular	JJ
18637	13689	38	type	type	NN
18637	13689	39	of	of	IN
18637	13689	40	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13689	41	from	from	IN
18637	13689	42	a	a	DT
18637	13689	43	sister	sister	NN
18637	13689	44	State	State	NNP
18637	13689	45	,	,	,
18637	13689	46	a	a	DT
18637	13689	47	claim	claim	NN
18637	13689	48	which	which	WDT
18637	13689	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13689	50	has	have	VBZ
18637	13689	51	by	by	IN
18637	13689	52	no	no	DT
18637	13689	53	means	means	NN
18637	13689	54	met	meet	VBD
18637	13689	55	with	with	IN
18637	13689	56	clear	clear	RB
18637	13689	57	-	-	HYPH
18637	13689	58	cut	cut	VBN
18637	13689	59	principles	principle	NNS
18637	13689	60	.	.	.
18637	13690	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	13690	2	in	in	IN
18637	13690	3	one	one	CD
18637	13690	4	case	case	NN
18637	13690	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13690	6	held	hold	VBD
18637	13690	7	that	that	IN
18637	13690	8	a	a	DT
18637	13690	9	New	New	NNP
18637	13690	10	York	York	NNP
18637	13690	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	13690	12	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	13690	13	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13690	14	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	13690	15	doing	do	VBG
18637	13690	16	a	a	DT
18637	13690	17	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	13690	18	business	business	NN
18637	13690	19	to	to	TO
18637	13690	20	sue	sue	VB
18637	13690	21	on	on	IN
18637	13690	22	causes	cause	NNS
18637	13690	23	originating	originate	VBG
18637	13690	24	outside	outside	IN
18637	13690	25	the	the	DT
18637	13690	26	State	state	NN
18637	13690	27	was	be	VBD
18637	13690	28	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	13690	29	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	13690	30	to	to	TO
18637	13690	31	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	13690	32	such	such	PDT
18637	13690	33	a	a	DT
18637	13690	34	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13690	35	from	from	IN
18637	13690	36	suing	sue	VBG
18637	13690	37	on	on	IN
18637	13690	38	a	a	DT
18637	13690	39	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13690	40	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13690	41	in	in	IN
18637	13690	42	a	a	DT
18637	13690	43	sister	sister	NN
18637	13690	44	State	State	NNP
18637	13690	45	.	.	.
18637	13691	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13691	2	17	17	CD
18637	13691	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13691	4	But	but	CC
18637	13691	5	in	in	IN
18637	13691	6	a	a	DT
18637	13691	7	later	later	JJ
18637	13691	8	case	case	NN
18637	13691	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13691	10	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	13691	11	that	that	IN
18637	13691	12	a	a	DT
18637	13691	13	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	13691	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	13691	15	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	13691	16	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	13691	17	in	in	IN
18637	13691	18	cotton	cotton	NN
18637	13691	19	futures	future	NNS
18637	13691	20	could	could	MD
18637	13691	21	not	not	RB
18637	13691	22	validly	validly	RB
18637	13691	23	close	close	VB
18637	13691	24	the	the	DT
18637	13691	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	13691	26	of	of	IN
18637	13691	27	the	the	DT
18637	13691	28	State	State	NNP
18637	13691	29	to	to	IN
18637	13691	30	an	an	DT
18637	13691	31	action	action	NN
18637	13691	32	on	on	IN
18637	13691	33	a	a	DT
18637	13691	34	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13691	35	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13691	36	in	in	IN
18637	13691	37	a	a	DT
18637	13691	38	sister	sister	NN
18637	13691	39	State	State	NNP
18637	13691	40	on	on	IN
18637	13691	41	such	such	PDT
18637	13691	42	a	a	DT
18637	13691	43	contract	contract	NN
18637	13691	44	,	,	,
18637	13691	45	although	although	IN
18637	13691	46	the	the	DT
18637	13691	47	contract	contract	NN
18637	13691	48	in	in	IN
18637	13691	49	question	question	NN
18637	13691	50	had	have	VBD
18637	13691	51	been	be	VBN
18637	13691	52	entered	enter	VBN
18637	13691	53	into	into	IN
18637	13691	54	in	in	IN
18637	13691	55	the	the	DT
18637	13691	56	forum	forum	NN
18637	13691	57	State	state	NN
18637	13691	58	and	and	CC
18637	13691	59	between	between	IN
18637	13691	60	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13691	61	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13691	62	.	.	.
18637	13692	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13692	2	18	18	CD
18637	13692	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13692	4	Following	follow	VBG
18637	13692	5	the	the	DT
18637	13692	6	later	later	RB
18637	13692	7	rather	rather	RB
18637	13692	8	than	than	IN
18637	13692	9	the	the	DT
18637	13692	10	earlier	early	JJR
18637	13692	11	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	13692	12	,	,	,
18637	13692	13	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	13692	14	cases[19	cases[19	NNP
18637	13692	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13692	16	have	have	VBP
18637	13692	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	13692	18	:	:	:
18637	13692	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13692	20	1	1	LS
18637	13692	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13692	22	that	that	IN
18637	13692	23	a	a	DT
18637	13692	24	State	state	NN
18637	13692	25	may	may	MD
18637	13692	26	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	13692	27	such	such	JJ
18637	13692	28	system	system	NN
18637	13692	29	of	of	IN
18637	13692	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	13692	31	and	and	CC
18637	13692	32	form	form	NN
18637	13692	33	of	of	IN
18637	13692	34	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	13692	35	as	as	IN
18637	13692	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13692	37	sees	see	VBZ
18637	13692	38	fit	fit	JJ
18637	13692	39	,	,	,
18637	13692	40	but	but	CC
18637	13692	41	can	can	MD
18637	13692	42	not	not	RB
18637	13692	43	,	,	,
18637	13692	44	under	under	IN
18637	13692	45	the	the	DT
18637	13692	46	guise	guise	NN
18637	13692	47	of	of	IN
18637	13692	48	merely	merely	RB
18637	13692	49	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	13692	50	the	the	DT
18637	13692	51	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	13692	52	,	,	,
18637	13692	53	deny	deny	VB
18637	13692	54	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	13692	55	of	of	IN
18637	13692	56	claims	claim	NNS
18637	13692	57	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	13692	58	within	within	IN
18637	13692	59	the	the	DT
18637	13692	60	protection	protection	NN
18637	13692	61	of	of	IN
18637	13692	62	the	the	DT
18637	13692	63	full	full	JJ
18637	13692	64	faith	faith	NN
18637	13692	65	and	and	CC
18637	13692	66	credit	credit	NN
18637	13692	67	clause	clause	NN
18637	13692	68	when	when	WRB
18637	13692	69	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13692	70	courts	court	NNS
18637	13692	71	have	have	VBP
18637	13692	72	general	general	JJ
18637	13692	73	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13692	74	of	of	IN
18637	13692	75	the	the	DT
18637	13692	76	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13692	77	matter	matter	NN
18637	13692	78	and	and	CC
18637	13692	79	the	the	DT
18637	13692	80	parties;[20	parties;[20	NNPS
18637	13692	81	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13692	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13692	83	2	2	LS
18637	13692	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13692	85	that	that	IN
18637	13692	86	,	,	,
18637	13692	87	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	13692	88	,	,	,
18637	13692	89	a	a	DT
18637	13692	90	forum	forum	NN
18637	13692	91	State	State	NNP
18637	13692	92	,	,	,
18637	13692	93	which	which	WDT
18637	13692	94	has	have	VBZ
18637	13692	95	a	a	DT
18637	13692	96	shorter	short	JJR
18637	13692	97	period	period	NN
18637	13692	98	of	of	IN
18637	13692	99	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	13692	100	than	than	IN
18637	13692	101	the	the	DT
18637	13692	102	State	State	NNP
18637	13692	103	in	in	IN
18637	13692	104	which	which	WDT
18637	13692	105	a	a	DT
18637	13692	106	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13692	107	was	be	VBD
18637	13692	108	granted	grant	VBN
18637	13692	109	and	and	CC
18637	13692	110	later	later	RB
18637	13692	111	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	13692	112	,	,	,
18637	13692	113	erred	err	VBN
18637	13692	114	in	in	IN
18637	13692	115	concluding	conclude	VBG
18637	13692	116	that	that	IN
18637	13692	117	,	,	,
18637	13692	118	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	13692	119	the	the	DT
18637	13692	120	effect	effect	NN
18637	13692	121	of	of	IN
18637	13692	122	the	the	DT
18637	13692	123	revivor	revivor	NN
18637	13692	124	under	under	IN
18637	13692	125	the	the	DT
18637	13692	126	law	law	NN
18637	13692	127	of	of	IN
18637	13692	128	the	the	DT
18637	13692	129	State	State	NNP
18637	13692	130	of	of	IN
18637	13692	131	origin	origin	NN
18637	13692	132	,	,	,
18637	13692	133	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13692	134	could	could	MD
18637	13692	135	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	13692	136	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	13692	137	of	of	IN
18637	13692	138	the	the	DT
18637	13692	139	revived	revive	VBN
18637	13692	140	judgment;[21	judgment;[21	NNP
18637	13692	141	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13692	142	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13692	143	3	3	LS
18637	13692	144	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13692	145	that	that	IN
18637	13692	146	the	the	DT
18637	13692	147	courts	court	NNS
18637	13692	148	of	of	IN
18637	13692	149	one	one	CD
18637	13692	150	State	State	NNP
18637	13692	151	have	have	VBP
18637	13692	152	no	no	DT
18637	13692	153	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13692	154	to	to	TO
18637	13692	155	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	13692	156	the	the	DT
18637	13692	157	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	13692	158	of	of	IN
18637	13692	159	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13692	160	at	at	IN
18637	13692	161	law	law	NN
18637	13692	162	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13692	163	in	in	IN
18637	13692	164	another	another	DT
18637	13692	165	State	State	NNP
18637	13692	166	,	,	,
18637	13692	167	when	when	WRB
18637	13692	168	the	the	DT
18637	13692	169	same	same	JJ
18637	13692	170	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	13692	171	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	13692	172	for	for	IN
18637	13692	173	granting	grant	VBG
18637	13692	174	the	the	DT
18637	13692	175	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	13692	176	order	order	NN
18637	13692	177	were	be	VBD
18637	13692	178	passed	pass	VBN
18637	13692	179	upon	upon	RP
18637	13692	180	on	on	IN
18637	13692	181	a	a	DT
18637	13692	182	motion	motion	NN
18637	13692	183	for	for	IN
18637	13692	184	new	new	JJ
18637	13692	185	trial	trial	NN
18637	13692	186	in	in	IN
18637	13692	187	the	the	DT
18637	13692	188	action	action	NN
18637	13692	189	at	at	IN
18637	13692	190	law	law	NN
18637	13692	191	and	and	CC
18637	13692	192	the	the	DT
18637	13692	193	motion	motion	NN
18637	13692	194	denied;[22	denied;[22	NNP
18637	13692	195	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13692	196	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13692	197	4	4	LS
18637	13692	198	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13692	199	that	that	IN
18637	13692	200	the	the	DT
18637	13692	201	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	13692	202	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	13692	203	requires	require	VBZ
18637	13692	204	credit	credit	NN
18637	13692	205	to	to	TO
18637	13692	206	be	be	VB
18637	13692	207	given	give	VBN
18637	13692	208	to	to	IN
18637	13692	209	a	a	DT
18637	13692	210	money	money	NN
18637	13692	211	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13692	212	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13692	213	in	in	IN
18637	13692	214	a	a	DT
18637	13692	215	civil	civil	JJ
18637	13692	216	cause	cause	NN
18637	13692	217	of	of	IN
18637	13692	218	action	action	NN
18637	13692	219	in	in	IN
18637	13692	220	another	another	DT
18637	13692	221	State	State	NNP
18637	13692	222	,	,	,
18637	13692	223	even	even	RB
18637	13692	224	though	though	IN
18637	13692	225	the	the	DT
18637	13692	226	forum	forum	NN
18637	13692	227	State	State	NNP
18637	13692	228	would	would	MD
18637	13692	229	have	have	VB
18637	13692	230	been	be	VBN
18637	13692	231	under	under	IN
18637	13692	232	no	no	DT
18637	13692	233	duty	duty	NN
18637	13692	234	to	to	TO
18637	13692	235	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	13692	236	the	the	DT
18637	13692	237	suit	suit	NN
18637	13692	238	on	on	IN
18637	13692	239	which	which	WDT
18637	13692	240	the	the	DT
18637	13692	241	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13692	242	was	be	VBD
18637	13692	243	founded	found	VBN
18637	13692	244	,	,	,
18637	13692	245	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	13692	246	as	as	IN
18637	13692	247	a	a	DT
18637	13692	248	State	state	NN
18637	13692	249	can	can	MD
18637	13692	250	not	not	RB
18637	13692	251	,	,	,
18637	13692	252	by	by	IN
18637	13692	253	the	the	DT
18637	13692	254	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	13692	255	of	of	IN
18637	13692	256	a	a	DT
18637	13692	257	particular	particular	JJ
18637	13692	258	rule	rule	NN
18637	13692	259	of	of	IN
18637	13692	260	liability	liability	NN
18637	13692	261	or	or	CC
18637	13692	262	of	of	IN
18637	13692	263	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	13692	264	,	,	,
18637	13692	265	exclude	exclude	VBP
18637	13692	266	from	from	IN
18637	13692	267	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13692	268	courts	court	NNS
18637	13692	269	a	a	DT
18637	13692	270	suit	suit	NN
18637	13692	271	on	on	IN
18637	13692	272	a	a	DT
18637	13692	273	judgment;[23	judgment;[23	NNP
18637	13692	274	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13692	275	and	and	CC
18637	13692	276	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13692	277	5	5	LS
18637	13692	278	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13692	279	that	that	IN
18637	13692	280	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	13692	281	,	,	,
18637	13692	282	tort	tort	NN
18637	13692	283	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	13692	284	in	in	IN
18637	13692	285	State	State	NNP
18637	13692	286	A	A	NNP
18637	13692	287	,	,	,
18637	13692	288	who	who	WP
18637	13692	289	obtain	obtain	VBP
18637	13692	290	a	a	DT
18637	13692	291	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13692	292	against	against	IN
18637	13692	293	a	a	DT
18637	13692	294	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13692	295	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	13692	296	company	company	NN
18637	13692	297	,	,	,
18637	13692	298	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	13692	299	that	that	DT
18637	13692	300	,	,	,
18637	13692	301	prior	prior	RB
18637	13692	302	to	to	IN
18637	13692	303	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13692	304	,	,	,
18637	13692	305	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	13692	306	State	State	NNP
18637	13692	307	B	B	NNP
18637	13692	308	appointed	appoint	VBD
18637	13692	309	a	a	DT
18637	13692	310	liquidator	liquidator	NN
18637	13692	311	for	for	IN
18637	13692	312	the	the	DT
18637	13692	313	company	company	NN
18637	13692	314	,	,	,
18637	13692	315	vested	vest	VBN
18637	13692	316	company	company	NN
18637	13692	317	assets	asset	NNS
18637	13692	318	in	in	IN
18637	13692	319	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13692	320	,	,	,
18637	13692	321	and	and	CC
18637	13692	322	ordered	order	VBD
18637	13692	323	suits	suit	NNS
18637	13692	324	against	against	IN
18637	13692	325	the	the	DT
18637	13692	326	company	company	NN
18637	13692	327	stayed	stay	VBD
18637	13692	328	,	,	,
18637	13692	329	are	be	VBP
18637	13692	330	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13692	331	to	to	TO
18637	13692	332	have	have	VB
18637	13692	333	such	such	JJ
18637	13692	334	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13692	335	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	13692	336	in	in	IN
18637	13692	337	State	State	NNP
18637	13692	338	B	B	NNP
18637	13692	339	for	for	IN
18637	13692	340	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	13692	341	of	of	IN
18637	13692	342	determining	determine	VBG
18637	13692	343	the	the	DT
18637	13692	344	amount	amount	NN
18637	13692	345	of	of	IN
18637	13692	346	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13692	347	claim	claim	NN
18637	13692	348	,	,	,
18637	13692	349	although	although	IN
18637	13692	350	not	not	RB
18637	13692	351	for	for	IN
18637	13692	352	determination	determination	NN
18637	13692	353	of	of	IN
18637	13692	354	what	what	WDT
18637	13692	355	priority	priority	NN
18637	13692	356	,	,	,
18637	13692	357	if	if	IN
18637	13692	358	any	any	DT
18637	13692	359	,	,	,
18637	13692	360	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13692	361	claim	claim	NN
18637	13692	362	should	should	MD
18637	13692	363	have	have	VB
18637	13692	364	.	.	.
18637	13693	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13693	2	24	24	CD
18637	13693	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13693	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	13693	5	,	,	,
18637	13693	6	there	there	EX
18637	13693	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	13693	8	no	no	DT
18637	13693	9	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	13693	10	reason	reason	NN
18637	13693	11	why	why	WRB
18637	13693	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13693	13	,	,	,
18637	13693	14	acting	act	VBG
18637	13693	15	on	on	IN
18637	13693	16	the	the	DT
18637	13693	17	implications	implication	NNS
18637	13693	18	of	of	IN
18637	13693	19	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	13693	20	's	's	POS
18637	13693	21	words	word	NNS
18637	13693	22	in	in	IN
18637	13693	23	Hampton	Hampton	NNP
18637	13693	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13693	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	13693	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13693	27	McConnell	McConnell	NNP
18637	13693	28	,	,	,
18637	13693	29	should	should	MD
18637	13693	30	not	not	RB
18637	13693	31	clothe	clothe	VB
18637	13693	32	extrastate	extrastate	VB
18637	13693	33	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13693	34	of	of	IN
18637	13693	35	any	any	DT
18637	13693	36	particular	particular	JJ
18637	13693	37	type	type	NN
18637	13693	38	with	with	IN
18637	13693	39	the	the	DT
18637	13693	40	full	full	JJ
18637	13693	41	status	status	NN
18637	13693	42	of	of	IN
18637	13693	43	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	13693	44	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13693	45	of	of	IN
18637	13693	46	the	the	DT
18637	13693	47	same	same	JJ
18637	13693	48	type	type	NN
18637	13693	49	in	in	IN
18637	13693	50	the	the	DT
18637	13693	51	several	several	JJ
18637	13693	52	States	state	NNS
18637	13693	53	.	.	.
18637	13694	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13694	2	25	25	CD
18637	13694	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13694	4	The	the	DT
18637	13694	5	Jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	13694	6	Prerequisite	Prerequisite	NNP
18637	13694	7	The	the	DT
18637	13694	8	second	second	JJ
18637	13694	9	great	great	JJ
18637	13694	10	class	class	NN
18637	13694	11	of	of	IN
18637	13694	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	13694	13	to	to	TO
18637	13694	14	arise	arise	VB
18637	13694	15	under	under	IN
18637	13694	16	the	the	DT
18637	13694	17	full	full	JJ
18637	13694	18	faith	faith	NN
18637	13694	19	and	and	CC
18637	13694	20	credit	credit	NN
18637	13694	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	13694	22	comprises	comprise	VBZ
18637	13694	23	those	those	DT
18637	13694	24	raising	raise	VBG
18637	13694	25	the	the	DT
18637	13694	26	question	question	NN
18637	13694	27	whether	whether	IN
18637	13694	28	a	a	DT
18637	13694	29	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13694	30	for	for	IN
18637	13694	31	which	which	WDT
18637	13694	32	extrastate	extrastate	VBP
18637	13694	33	operation	operation	NN
18637	13694	34	was	be	VBD
18637	13694	35	being	be	VBG
18637	13694	36	sought	seek	VBN
18637	13694	37	,	,	,
18637	13694	38	either	either	CC
18637	13694	39	as	as	IN
18637	13694	40	a	a	DT
18637	13694	41	basis	basis	NN
18637	13694	42	of	of	IN
18637	13694	43	an	an	DT
18637	13694	44	action	action	NN
18637	13694	45	or	or	CC
18637	13694	46	as	as	IN
18637	13694	47	a	a	DT
18637	13694	48	defense	defense	NN
18637	13694	49	in	in	IN
18637	13694	50	one	one	CD
18637	13694	51	,	,	,
18637	13694	52	has	have	VBZ
18637	13694	53	been	be	VBN
18637	13694	54	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13694	55	with	with	IN
18637	13694	56	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13694	57	.	.	.
18637	13695	1	Records	record	NNS
18637	13695	2	and	and	CC
18637	13695	3	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13695	4	of	of	IN
18637	13695	5	courts	court	NNS
18637	13695	6	wanting	want	VBG
18637	13695	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13695	8	are	be	VBP
18637	13695	9	not	not	RB
18637	13695	10	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13695	11	to	to	IN
18637	13695	12	credit	credit	NN
18637	13695	13	.	.	.
18637	13696	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13696	2	26	26	CD
18637	13696	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13696	4	The	the	DT
18637	13696	5	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	13696	6	question	question	NN
18637	13696	7	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	13696	8	both	both	DT
18637	13696	9	in	in	IN
18637	13696	10	connection	connection	NN
18637	13696	11	with	with	IN
18637	13696	12	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13696	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13696	14	in	in	IN
18637	13696	15	personam	personam	NNP
18637	13696	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13696	17	against	against	IN
18637	13696	18	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	13696	19	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	13696	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	13696	21	whom	whom	WP
18637	13696	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13696	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	13696	24	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	13696	25	personal	personal	JJ
18637	13696	26	service	service	NN
18637	13696	27	was	be	VBD
18637	13696	28	not	not	RB
18637	13696	29	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13696	30	in	in	IN
18637	13696	31	the	the	DT
18637	13696	32	State	State	NNP
18637	13696	33	of	of	IN
18637	13696	34	origin	origin	NN
18637	13696	35	of	of	IN
18637	13696	36	the	the	DT
18637	13696	37	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13696	38	,	,	,
18637	13696	39	and	and	CC
18637	13696	40	in	in	IN
18637	13696	41	relation	relation	NN
18637	13696	42	to	to	IN
18637	13696	43	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13696	44	_	_	NNP
18637	13696	45	in	in	IN
18637	13696	46	rem	rem	NNP
18637	13696	47	_	_	NNP
18637	13696	48	against	against	IN
18637	13696	49	property	property	NN
18637	13696	50	or	or	CC
18637	13696	51	a	a	DT
18637	13696	52	status	status	NN
18637	13696	53	alleged	allege	VBD
18637	13696	54	not	not	RB
18637	13696	55	to	to	TO
18637	13696	56	have	have	VB
18637	13696	57	been	be	VBN
18637	13696	58	within	within	IN
18637	13696	59	the	the	DT
18637	13696	60	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13696	61	of	of	IN
18637	13696	62	the	the	DT
18637	13696	63	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13696	64	which	which	WDT
18637	13696	65	handed	hand	VBD
18637	13696	66	down	down	RP
18637	13696	67	the	the	DT
18637	13696	68	original	original	JJ
18637	13696	69	decree	decree	NN
18637	13696	70	.	.	.
18637	13697	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13697	2	27	27	CD
18637	13697	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13697	4	JUDGMENTS	JUDGMENTS	NNP
18637	13697	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13697	6	IN	in	IN
18637	13697	7	PERSONAM	PERSONAM	NNP
18637	13697	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13697	9	The	the	DT
18637	13697	10	pioneer	pioneer	NN
18637	13697	11	case	case	NN
18637	13697	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	13697	13	that	that	DT
18637	13697	14	of	of	IN
18637	13697	15	D'Arcy	D'Arcy	NNP
18637	13697	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13697	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	13697	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13697	19	Ketchum,[28	Ketchum,[28	NNP
18637	13697	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13697	21	decided	decide	VBD
18637	13697	22	in	in	IN
18637	13697	23	1850	1850	CD
18637	13697	24	.	.	.
18637	13698	1	The	the	DT
18637	13698	2	question	question	NN
18637	13698	3	presented	present	VBN
18637	13698	4	was	be	VBD
18637	13698	5	whether	whether	IN
18637	13698	6	a	a	DT
18637	13698	7	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13698	8	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13698	9	by	by	IN
18637	13698	10	a	a	DT
18637	13698	11	New	New	NNP
18637	13698	12	York	York	NNP
18637	13698	13	court	court	NN
18637	13698	14	under	under	IN
18637	13698	15	a	a	DT
18637	13698	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	13698	17	which	which	WDT
18637	13698	18	provided	provide	VBD
18637	13698	19	that	that	IN
18637	13698	20	,	,	,
18637	13698	21	when	when	WRB
18637	13698	22	joint	joint	JJ
18637	13698	23	debtors	debtor	NNS
18637	13698	24	were	be	VBD
18637	13698	25	sued	sue	VBN
18637	13698	26	and	and	CC
18637	13698	27	one	one	CD
18637	13698	28	of	of	IN
18637	13698	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13698	30	was	be	VBD
18637	13698	31	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13698	32	into	into	IN
18637	13698	33	court	court	NN
18637	13698	34	on	on	IN
18637	13698	35	a	a	DT
18637	13698	36	process	process	NN
18637	13698	37	,	,	,
18637	13698	38	a	a	DT
18637	13698	39	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13698	40	in	in	IN
18637	13698	41	favor	favor	NN
18637	13698	42	of	of	IN
18637	13698	43	the	the	DT
18637	13698	44	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	13698	45	would	would	MD
18637	13698	46	entitle	entitle	VB
18637	13698	47	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13698	48	to	to	TO
18637	13698	49	execute	execute	VB
18637	13698	50	against	against	IN
18637	13698	51	all	all	DT
18637	13698	52	,	,	,
18637	13698	53	and	and	CC
18637	13698	54	so	so	RB
18637	13698	55	must	must	MD
18637	13698	56	be	be	VB
18637	13698	57	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	13698	58	full	full	JJ
18637	13698	59	faith	faith	NN
18637	13698	60	and	and	CC
18637	13698	61	credit	credit	NN
18637	13698	62	in	in	IN
18637	13698	63	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	13698	64	when	when	WRB
18637	13698	65	offered	offer	VBD
18637	13698	66	as	as	IN
18637	13698	67	the	the	DT
18637	13698	68	basis	basis	NN
18637	13698	69	of	of	IN
18637	13698	70	an	an	DT
18637	13698	71	action	action	NN
18637	13698	72	in	in	IN
18637	13698	73	debt	debt	NN
18637	13698	74	against	against	IN
18637	13698	75	a	a	DT
18637	13698	76	resident	resident	NN
18637	13698	77	of	of	IN
18637	13698	78	that	that	DT
18637	13698	79	State	State	NNP
18637	13698	80	who	who	WP
18637	13698	81	had	have	VBD
18637	13698	82	not	not	RB
18637	13698	83	been	be	VBN
18637	13698	84	served	serve	VBN
18637	13698	85	by	by	IN
18637	13698	86	process	process	NN
18637	13698	87	in	in	IN
18637	13698	88	the	the	DT
18637	13698	89	New	New	NNP
18637	13698	90	York	York	NNP
18637	13698	91	action	action	NN
18637	13698	92	.	.	.
18637	13699	1	Pressed	press	VBN
18637	13699	2	with	with	IN
18637	13699	3	the	the	DT
18637	13699	4	argument	argument	NN
18637	13699	5	that	that	IN
18637	13699	6	by	by	IN
18637	13699	7	"	"	``
18637	13699	8	the	the	DT
18637	13699	9	immutable	immutable	JJ
18637	13699	10	principles	principle	NNS
18637	13699	11	of	of	IN
18637	13699	12	justice	justice	NN
18637	13699	13	"	"	``
18637	13699	14	no	no	DT
18637	13699	15	man	man	NN
18637	13699	16	's	's	POS
18637	13699	17	rights	right	NNS
18637	13699	18	should	should	MD
18637	13699	19	be	be	VB
18637	13699	20	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	13699	21	without	without	IN
18637	13699	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13699	23	being	be	VBG
18637	13699	24	given	give	VBN
18637	13699	25	an	an	DT
18637	13699	26	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	13699	27	to	to	TO
18637	13699	28	defend	defend	VB
18637	13699	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13699	30	,	,	,
18637	13699	31	the	the	DT
18637	13699	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13699	33	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	13699	34	that	that	IN
18637	13699	35	,	,	,
18637	13699	36	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	13699	37	in	in	IN
18637	13699	38	the	the	DT
18637	13699	39	light	light	NN
18637	13699	40	of	of	IN
18637	13699	41	the	the	DT
18637	13699	42	principles	principle	NNS
18637	13699	43	of	of	IN
18637	13699	44	"	"	``
18637	13699	45	international	international	JJ
18637	13699	46	law	law	NN
18637	13699	47	and	and	CC
18637	13699	48	comity	comity	NN
18637	13699	49	"	"	''
18637	13699	50	as	as	IN
18637	13699	51	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13699	52	existed	exist	VBD
18637	13699	53	in	in	IN
18637	13699	54	1790	1790	CD
18637	13699	55	,	,	,
18637	13699	56	the	the	DT
18637	13699	57	act	act	NN
18637	13699	58	of	of	IN
18637	13699	59	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13699	60	of	of	IN
18637	13699	61	that	that	DT
18637	13699	62	year	year	NN
18637	13699	63	did	do	VBD
18637	13699	64	not	not	RB
18637	13699	65	reach	reach	VB
18637	13699	66	the	the	DT
18637	13699	67	case	case	NN
18637	13699	68	.	.	.
18637	13700	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13700	2	29	29	CD
18637	13700	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13700	4	The	the	DT
18637	13700	5	truth	truth	NN
18637	13700	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	13700	7	that	that	IN
18637	13700	8	the	the	DT
18637	13700	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	13700	10	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	13700	11	amended	amend	VBD
18637	13700	12	the	the	DT
18637	13700	13	act	act	NN
18637	13700	14	,	,	,
18637	13700	15	for	for	IN
18637	13700	16	had	have	VBD
18637	13700	17	the	the	DT
18637	13700	18	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	13700	19	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13700	20	ventured	venture	VBD
18637	13700	21	to	to	IN
18637	13700	22	New	New	NNP
18637	13700	23	York	York	NNP
18637	13700	24	,	,	,
18637	13700	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13700	26	could	could	MD
18637	13700	27	,	,	,
18637	13700	28	as	as	IN
18637	13700	29	the	the	DT
18637	13700	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13700	31	of	of	IN
18637	13700	32	the	the	DT
18637	13700	33	United	United	NNP
18637	13700	34	States	States	NNP
18637	13700	35	then	then	RB
18637	13700	36	stood	stand	VBD
18637	13700	37	,	,	,
18637	13700	38	have	have	VBP
18637	13700	39	been	be	VBN
18637	13700	40	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	13700	41	to	to	IN
18637	13700	42	the	the	DT
18637	13700	43	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13700	44	of	of	IN
18637	13700	45	the	the	DT
18637	13700	46	same	same	JJ
18637	13700	47	extent	extent	NN
18637	13700	48	as	as	IN
18637	13700	49	the	the	DT
18637	13700	50	New	New	NNP
18637	13700	51	York	York	NNP
18637	13700	52	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13700	53	who	who	WP
18637	13700	54	had	have	VBD
18637	13700	55	been	be	VBN
18637	13700	56	personally	personally	RB
18637	13700	57	served	serve	VBN
18637	13700	58	.	.	.
18637	13701	1	Subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	13701	2	,	,	,
18637	13701	3	this	this	DT
18637	13701	4	disparity	disparity	NN
18637	13701	5	between	between	IN
18637	13701	6	the	the	DT
18637	13701	7	operation	operation	NN
18637	13701	8	of	of	IN
18637	13701	9	a	a	DT
18637	13701	10	personal	personal	JJ
18637	13701	11	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13701	12	in	in	IN
18637	13701	13	the	the	DT
18637	13701	14	home	home	NN
18637	13701	15	State	State	NNP
18637	13701	16	and	and	CC
18637	13701	17	a	a	DT
18637	13701	18	sister	sister	NN
18637	13701	19	State	State	NNP
18637	13701	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	13701	21	been	be	VBN
18637	13701	22	eliminated	eliminate	VBN
18637	13701	23	,	,	,
18637	13701	24	thanks	thank	NNS
18637	13701	25	to	to	IN
18637	13701	26	the	the	DT
18637	13701	27	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	13701	28	of	of	IN
18637	13701	29	the	the	DT
18637	13701	30	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	13701	31	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	13701	32	.	.	.
18637	13702	1	In	in	IN
18637	13702	2	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13702	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	13702	4	,	,	,
18637	13702	5	however	however	RB
18637	13702	6	,	,	,
18637	13702	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13702	8	still	still	RB
18637	13702	9	persists	persist	VBZ
18637	13702	10	in	in	IN
18637	13702	11	some	some	DT
18637	13702	12	measure	measure	NN
18637	13702	13	.	.	.
18637	13703	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13703	2	_	_	NNP
18637	13703	3	See	See	NNP
18637	13703	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13703	5	pp	pp	NNP
18637	13703	6	.	.	.
18637	13704	1	662	662	CD
18637	13704	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13704	3	670	670	CD
18637	13704	4	.	.	.
18637	13704	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13705	1	In	in	IN
18637	13705	2	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
18637	13705	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13705	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13705	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13705	6	Neff,[30	Neff,[30	NNP
18637	13705	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13705	8	decided	decide	VBD
18637	13705	9	in	in	IN
18637	13705	10	1878	1878	CD
18637	13705	11	,	,	,
18637	13705	12	and	and	CC
18637	13705	13	so	so	RB
18637	13705	14	under	under	IN
18637	13705	15	the	the	DT
18637	13705	16	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	13705	17	,	,	,
18637	13705	18	the	the	DT
18637	13705	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13705	20	held	hold	VBD
18637	13705	21	that	that	IN
18637	13705	22	a	a	DT
18637	13705	23	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13705	24	given	give	VBN
18637	13705	25	in	in	IN
18637	13705	26	a	a	DT
18637	13705	27	case	case	NN
18637	13705	28	in	in	IN
18637	13705	29	which	which	WDT
18637	13705	30	the	the	DT
18637	13705	31	State	State	NNP
18637	13705	32	court	court	NN
18637	13705	33	had	have	VBD
18637	13705	34	endeavored	endeavor	VBN
18637	13705	35	to	to	TO
18637	13705	36	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	13705	37	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13705	38	of	of	IN
18637	13705	39	a	a	DT
18637	13705	40	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	13705	41	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13705	42	by	by	IN
18637	13705	43	an	an	DT
18637	13705	44	attachment	attachment	NN
18637	13705	45	upon	upon	IN
18637	13705	46	property	property	NN
18637	13705	47	of	of	IN
18637	13705	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13705	49	within	within	IN
18637	13705	50	the	the	DT
18637	13705	51	State	State	NNP
18637	13705	52	and	and	CC
18637	13705	53	constructive	constructive	JJ
18637	13705	54	notice	notice	NN
18637	13705	55	to	to	IN
18637	13705	56	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13705	57	,	,	,
18637	13705	58	had	have	VBD
18637	13705	59	not	not	RB
18637	13705	60	been	be	VBN
18637	13705	61	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13705	62	with	with	IN
18637	13705	63	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13705	64	and	and	CC
18637	13705	65	hence	hence	RB
18637	13705	66	could	could	MD
18637	13705	67	not	not	RB
18637	13705	68	afford	afford	VB
18637	13705	69	the	the	DT
18637	13705	70	basis	basis	NN
18637	13705	71	of	of	IN
18637	13705	72	an	an	DT
18637	13705	73	action	action	NN
18637	13705	74	in	in	IN
18637	13705	75	the	the	DT
18637	13705	76	court	court	NN
18637	13705	77	of	of	IN
18637	13705	78	another	another	DT
18637	13705	79	State	State	NNP
18637	13705	80	against	against	IN
18637	13705	81	such	such	JJ
18637	13705	82	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13705	83	,	,	,
18637	13705	84	although	although	IN
18637	13705	85	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13705	86	bound	bind	VBD
18637	13705	87	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13705	88	so	so	RB
18637	13705	89	far	far	RB
18637	13705	90	as	as	IN
18637	13705	91	the	the	DT
18637	13705	92	property	property	NN
18637	13705	93	attached	attach	VBN
18637	13705	94	was	be	VBD
18637	13705	95	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	13705	96	,	,	,
18637	13705	97	on	on	IN
18637	13705	98	account	account	NN
18637	13705	99	of	of	IN
18637	13705	100	the	the	DT
18637	13705	101	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	13705	102	right	right	NN
18637	13705	103	of	of	IN
18637	13705	104	a	a	DT
18637	13705	105	State	State	NNP
18637	13705	106	to	to	TO
18637	13705	107	assist	assist	VB
18637	13705	108	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13705	109	own	own	JJ
18637	13705	110	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13705	111	in	in	IN
18637	13705	112	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	13705	113	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
18637	13705	114	of	of	IN
18637	13705	115	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13705	116	just	just	JJ
18637	13705	117	claims	claim	NNS
18637	13705	118	.	.	.
18637	13706	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	13706	2	would	would	MD
18637	13706	3	such	such	PDT
18637	13706	4	a	a	DT
18637	13706	5	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13706	6	,	,	,
18637	13706	7	the	the	DT
18637	13706	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13706	9	further	further	RB
18637	13706	10	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	13706	11	,	,	,
18637	13706	12	be	be	VB
18637	13706	13	due	due	JJ
18637	13706	14	process	process	NN
18637	13706	15	of	of	IN
18637	13706	16	law	law	NN
18637	13706	17	to	to	IN
18637	13706	18	any	any	DT
18637	13706	19	greater	great	JJR
18637	13706	20	extent	extent	NN
18637	13706	21	in	in	IN
18637	13706	22	the	the	DT
18637	13706	23	State	State	NNP
18637	13706	24	where	where	WRB
18637	13706	25	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13706	26	.	.	.
18637	13707	1	In	in	IN
18637	13707	2	the	the	DT
18637	13707	3	words	word	NNS
18637	13707	4	of	of	IN
18637	13707	5	a	a	DT
18637	13707	6	later	later	JJ
18637	13707	7	case	case	NN
18637	13707	8	,	,	,
18637	13707	9	"	"	''
18637	13707	10	an	an	DT
18637	13707	11	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	13707	12	personal	personal	JJ
18637	13707	13	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13707	14	for	for	IN
18637	13707	15	money	money	NN
18637	13707	16	,	,	,
18637	13707	17	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	13707	18	for	for	IN
18637	13707	19	want	want	NN
18637	13707	20	of	of	IN
18637	13707	21	service	service	NN
18637	13707	22	amounting	amount	VBG
18637	13707	23	to	to	IN
18637	13707	24	due	due	JJ
18637	13707	25	process	process	NN
18637	13707	26	of	of	IN
18637	13707	27	law	law	NN
18637	13707	28	,	,	,
18637	13707	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	13707	30	as	as	RB
18637	13707	31	ineffective	ineffective	JJ
18637	13707	32	in	in	IN
18637	13707	33	the	the	DT
18637	13707	34	State	State	NNP
18637	13707	35	as	as	IN
18637	13707	36	outside	outside	IN
18637	13707	37	of	of	IN
18637	13707	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13707	39	.	.	.
18637	13708	1	"	"	``
18637	13708	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13708	3	31	31	CD
18637	13708	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13708	5	THE	the	DT
18637	13708	6	JURISDICTIONAL	JURISDICTIONAL	NNP
18637	13708	7	QUESTION	QUESTION	VBD
18637	13708	8	In	in	IN
18637	13708	9	short	short	JJ
18637	13708	10	,	,	,
18637	13708	11	when	when	WRB
18637	13708	12	the	the	DT
18637	13708	13	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13708	14	matter	matter	NN
18637	13708	15	of	of	IN
18637	13708	16	a	a	DT
18637	13708	17	suit	suit	NN
18637	13708	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	13708	19	merely	merely	RB
18637	13708	20	the	the	DT
18637	13708	21	determination	determination	NN
18637	13708	22	of	of	IN
18637	13708	23	the	the	DT
18637	13708	24	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13708	25	's	's	POS
18637	13708	26	liability	liability	NN
18637	13708	27	,	,	,
18637	13708	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13708	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	13708	30	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	13708	31	that	that	IN
18637	13708	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13708	33	should	should	MD
18637	13708	34	appear	appear	VB
18637	13708	35	from	from	IN
18637	13708	36	the	the	DT
18637	13708	37	record	record	NN
18637	13708	38	that	that	IN
18637	13708	39	the	the	DT
18637	13708	40	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13708	41	had	have	VBD
18637	13708	42	been	be	VBN
18637	13708	43	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13708	44	within	within	IN
18637	13708	45	the	the	DT
18637	13708	46	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13708	47	of	of	IN
18637	13708	48	the	the	DT
18637	13708	49	court	court	NN
18637	13708	50	by	by	IN
18637	13708	51	personal	personal	JJ
18637	13708	52	service	service	NN
18637	13708	53	of	of	IN
18637	13708	54	process	process	NN
18637	13708	55	,	,	,
18637	13708	56	or	or	CC
18637	13708	57	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13708	58	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	13708	59	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	13708	60	,	,	,
18637	13708	61	or	or	CC
18637	13708	62	that	that	IN
18637	13708	63	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13708	64	had	have	VBD
18637	13708	65	in	in	IN
18637	13708	66	some	some	DT
18637	13708	67	manner	manner	NN
18637	13708	68	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	13708	69	the	the	DT
18637	13708	70	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13708	71	.	.	.
18637	13709	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13709	2	32	32	CD
18637	13709	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13709	4	The	the	DT
18637	13709	5	claim	claim	NN
18637	13709	6	that	that	IN
18637	13709	7	a	a	DT
18637	13709	8	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13709	9	was	be	VBD
18637	13709	10	"	"	``
18637	13709	11	not	not	RB
18637	13709	12	responsive	responsive	JJ
18637	13709	13	to	to	IN
18637	13709	14	the	the	DT
18637	13709	15	pleadings	pleading	NNS
18637	13709	16	"	"	``
18637	13709	17	raises	raise	VBZ
18637	13709	18	the	the	DT
18637	13709	19	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	13709	20	question;[33	question;[33	NN
18637	13709	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13709	22	but	but	CC
18637	13709	23	the	the	DT
18637	13709	24	fact	fact	NN
18637	13709	25	that	that	IN
18637	13709	26	a	a	DT
18637	13709	27	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	13709	28	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13709	29	was	be	VBD
18637	13709	30	only	only	RB
18637	13709	31	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	13709	32	in	in	IN
18637	13709	33	the	the	DT
18637	13709	34	State	State	NNP
18637	13709	35	when	when	WRB
18637	13709	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13709	37	was	be	VBD
18637	13709	38	served	serve	VBN
18637	13709	39	in	in	IN
18637	13709	40	the	the	DT
18637	13709	41	original	original	JJ
18637	13709	42	action	action	NN
18637	13709	43	does	do	VBZ
18637	13709	44	not	not	RB
18637	13709	45	vitiate	vitiate	VB
18637	13709	46	the	the	DT
18637	13709	47	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13709	48	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13709	49	as	as	IN
18637	13709	50	the	the	DT
18637	13709	51	basis	basis	NN
18637	13709	52	of	of	IN
18637	13709	53	an	an	DT
18637	13709	54	action	action	NN
18637	13709	55	in	in	IN
18637	13709	56	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13709	57	home	home	NN
18637	13709	58	State	State	NNP
18637	13709	59	.	.	.
18637	13710	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13710	2	34	34	CD
18637	13710	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13710	4	Also	also	RB
18637	13710	5	,	,	,
18637	13710	6	a	a	DT
18637	13710	7	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13710	8	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13710	9	in	in	IN
18637	13710	10	the	the	DT
18637	13710	11	State	State	NNP
18637	13710	12	of	of	IN
18637	13710	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13710	14	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13710	15	against	against	IN
18637	13710	16	a	a	DT
18637	13710	17	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13710	18	who	who	WP
18637	13710	19	,	,	,
18637	13710	20	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	13710	21	to	to	IN
18637	13710	22	the	the	DT
18637	13710	23	statute	statute	NN
18637	13710	24	thereof	thereof	IN
18637	13710	25	providing	provide	VBG
18637	13710	26	for	for	IN
18637	13710	27	the	the	DT
18637	13710	28	service	service	NN
18637	13710	29	of	of	IN
18637	13710	30	process	process	NN
18637	13710	31	on	on	IN
18637	13710	32	absent	absent	JJ
18637	13710	33	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	13710	34	,	,	,
18637	13710	35	was	be	VBD
18637	13710	36	personally	personally	RB
18637	13710	37	served	serve	VBN
18637	13710	38	in	in	IN
18637	13710	39	another	another	DT
18637	13710	40	State	State	NNP
18637	13710	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	13710	42	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13710	43	to	to	IN
18637	13710	44	full	full	JJ
18637	13710	45	faith	faith	NN
18637	13710	46	and	and	CC
18637	13710	47	credit	credit	NN
18637	13710	48	.	.	.
18637	13711	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13711	2	35	35	CD
18637	13711	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13711	4	Also	also	RB
18637	13711	5	,	,	,
18637	13711	6	when	when	WRB
18637	13711	7	the	the	DT
18637	13711	8	matter	matter	NN
18637	13711	9	of	of	IN
18637	13711	10	fact	fact	NN
18637	13711	11	or	or	CC
18637	13711	12	law	law	NN
18637	13711	13	on	on	IN
18637	13711	14	which	which	WDT
18637	13711	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13711	16	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	13711	17	was	be	VBD
18637	13711	18	not	not	RB
18637	13711	19	litigated	litigate	VBN
18637	13711	20	in	in	IN
18637	13711	21	the	the	DT
18637	13711	22	original	original	JJ
18637	13711	23	suit	suit	NN
18637	13711	24	,	,	,
18637	13711	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13711	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	13711	27	a	a	DT
18637	13711	28	matter	matter	NN
18637	13711	29	to	to	TO
18637	13711	30	be	be	VB
18637	13711	31	adjudicated	adjudicate	VBN
18637	13711	32	in	in	IN
18637	13711	33	the	the	DT
18637	13711	34	suit	suit	NN
18637	13711	35	founded	found	VBN
18637	13711	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	13711	37	the	the	DT
18637	13711	38	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13711	39	.	.	.
18637	13712	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13712	2	36	36	CD
18637	13712	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13712	4	Inasmuch	Inasmuch	NNP
18637	13712	5	as	as	IN
18637	13712	6	the	the	DT
18637	13712	7	principle	principle	NN
18637	13712	8	of	of	IN
18637	13712	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13712	10	res	res	NNP
18637	13712	11	judicata	judicata	NNP
18637	13712	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13712	13	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	13712	14	only	only	RB
18637	13712	15	to	to	IN
18637	13712	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13712	17	between	between	IN
18637	13712	18	the	the	DT
18637	13712	19	same	same	JJ
18637	13712	20	parties	party	NNS
18637	13712	21	and	and	CC
18637	13712	22	privies	privy	NNS
18637	13712	23	,	,	,
18637	13712	24	the	the	DT
18637	13712	25	plea	plea	NN
18637	13712	26	by	by	IN
18637	13712	27	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13712	28	in	in	IN
18637	13712	29	an	an	DT
18637	13712	30	action	action	NN
18637	13712	31	based	base	VBN
18637	13712	32	on	on	IN
18637	13712	33	a	a	DT
18637	13712	34	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13712	35	that	that	IN
18637	13712	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13712	37	was	be	VBD
18637	13712	38	no	no	DT
18637	13712	39	party	party	NN
18637	13712	40	or	or	CC
18637	13712	41	privy	privy	NN
18637	13712	42	to	to	IN
18637	13712	43	the	the	DT
18637	13712	44	original	original	JJ
18637	13712	45	action	action	NN
18637	13712	46	raises	raise	VBZ
18637	13712	47	the	the	DT
18637	13712	48	question	question	NN
18637	13712	49	of	of	IN
18637	13712	50	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13712	51	;	;	:
18637	13712	52	and	and	CC
18637	13712	53	while	while	IN
18637	13712	54	a	a	DT
18637	13712	55	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13712	56	against	against	IN
18637	13712	57	a	a	DT
18637	13712	58	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13712	59	in	in	IN
18637	13712	60	one	one	CD
18637	13712	61	State	State	NNP
18637	13712	62	may	may	MD
18637	13712	63	validly	validly	RB
18637	13712	64	bind	bind	VB
18637	13712	65	a	a	DT
18637	13712	66	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	13712	67	in	in	IN
18637	13712	68	another	another	DT
18637	13712	69	State	state	NN
18637	13712	70	to	to	IN
18637	13712	71	the	the	DT
18637	13712	72	extent	extent	NN
18637	13712	73	of	of	IN
18637	13712	74	the	the	DT
18637	13712	75	par	par	NN
18637	13712	76	value	value	NN
18637	13712	77	of	of	IN
18637	13712	78	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13712	79	holdings,[37	holdings,[37	CD
18637	13712	80	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13712	81	an	an	DT
18637	13712	82	administrator	administrator	NN
18637	13712	83	acting	act	VBG
18637	13712	84	under	under	IN
18637	13712	85	a	a	DT
18637	13712	86	grant	grant	NN
18637	13712	87	of	of	IN
18637	13712	88	administration	administration	NN
18637	13712	89	in	in	IN
18637	13712	90	one	one	CD
18637	13712	91	State	State	NNP
18637	13712	92	stands	stand	VBZ
18637	13712	93	in	in	IN
18637	13712	94	no	no	DT
18637	13712	95	sort	sort	NN
18637	13712	96	of	of	IN
18637	13712	97	relation	relation	NN
18637	13712	98	of	of	IN
18637	13712	99	priority	priority	NN
18637	13712	100	to	to	IN
18637	13712	101	an	an	DT
18637	13712	102	administrator	administrator	NN
18637	13712	103	of	of	IN
18637	13712	104	the	the	DT
18637	13712	105	same	same	JJ
18637	13712	106	estate	estate	NN
18637	13712	107	in	in	IN
18637	13712	108	another	another	DT
18637	13712	109	State	state	NN
18637	13712	110	.	.	.
18637	13713	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13713	2	38	38	CD
18637	13713	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13713	4	But	but	CC
18637	13713	5	where	where	WRB
18637	13713	6	a	a	DT
18637	13713	7	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13713	8	of	of	IN
18637	13713	9	dismissal	dismissal	NN
18637	13713	10	was	be	VBD
18637	13713	11	entered	enter	VBN
18637	13713	12	in	in	IN
18637	13713	13	a	a	DT
18637	13713	14	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13713	15	court	court	NN
18637	13713	16	in	in	IN
18637	13713	17	an	an	DT
18637	13713	18	action	action	NN
18637	13713	19	against	against	IN
18637	13713	20	one	one	CD
18637	13713	21	of	of	IN
18637	13713	22	two	two	CD
18637	13713	23	joint	joint	JJ
18637	13713	24	tortfeasors	tortfeasor	NNS
18637	13713	25	,	,	,
18637	13713	26	in	in	IN
18637	13713	27	a	a	DT
18637	13713	28	State	State	NNP
18637	13713	29	in	in	IN
18637	13713	30	which	which	WDT
18637	13713	31	such	such	PDT
18637	13713	32	a	a	DT
18637	13713	33	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13713	34	would	would	MD
18637	13713	35	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	13713	36	an	an	DT
18637	13713	37	estoppel	estoppel	NN
18637	13713	38	in	in	IN
18637	13713	39	another	another	DT
18637	13713	40	action	action	NN
18637	13713	41	in	in	IN
18637	13713	42	the	the	DT
18637	13713	43	same	same	JJ
18637	13713	44	State	State	NNP
18637	13713	45	against	against	IN
18637	13713	46	the	the	DT
18637	13713	47	other	other	JJ
18637	13713	48	tort	tort	NN
18637	13713	49	-	-	HYPH
18637	13713	50	feasor	feasor	NN
18637	13713	51	,	,	,
18637	13713	52	such	such	JJ
18637	13713	53	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13713	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	13713	55	not	not	RB
18637	13713	56	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13713	57	to	to	IN
18637	13713	58	full	full	JJ
18637	13713	59	faith	faith	NN
18637	13713	60	and	and	CC
18637	13713	61	credit	credit	NN
18637	13713	62	in	in	IN
18637	13713	63	an	an	DT
18637	13713	64	action	action	NN
18637	13713	65	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13713	66	against	against	IN
18637	13713	67	the	the	DT
18637	13713	68	other	other	JJ
18637	13713	69	tortfeasor	tortfeasor	NN
18637	13713	70	in	in	IN
18637	13713	71	another	another	DT
18637	13713	72	State	state	NN
18637	13713	73	.	.	.
18637	13714	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13714	2	39	39	CD
18637	13714	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13714	4	SERVICE	service	NN
18637	13714	5	ON	on	IN
18637	13714	6	FOREIGN	foreign	JJ
18637	13714	7	CORPORATIONS	corporations	NN
18637	13714	8	In	in	IN
18637	13714	9	1856	1856	CD
18637	13714	10	the	the	DT
18637	13714	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13714	12	decided	decide	VBD
18637	13714	13	Lafayette	Lafayette	NNP
18637	13714	14	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	13714	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13714	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13714	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	13714	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13714	19	French	French	NNP
18637	13714	20	et	et	FW
18637	13714	21	al	al	NNP
18637	13714	22	.	.	NNP
18637	13714	23	,[40	,[40	NNP
18637	13714	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13714	25	a	a	DT
18637	13714	26	pioneer	pioneer	NN
18637	13714	27	case	case	NN
18637	13714	28	in	in	IN
18637	13714	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13714	30	general	general	JJ
18637	13714	31	class	class	NN
18637	13714	32	.	.	.
18637	13715	1	Here	here	RB
18637	13715	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13715	3	was	be	VBD
18637	13715	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	13715	5	that	that	IN
18637	13715	6	"	"	``
18637	13715	7	where	where	WRB
18637	13715	8	a	a	DT
18637	13715	9	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13715	10	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	13715	11	by	by	IN
18637	13715	12	the	the	DT
18637	13715	13	State	State	NNP
18637	13715	14	of	of	IN
18637	13715	15	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	13715	16	was	be	VBD
18637	13715	17	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	13715	18	by	by	IN
18637	13715	19	a	a	DT
18637	13715	20	law	law	NN
18637	13715	21	of	of	IN
18637	13715	22	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	13715	23	to	to	TO
18637	13715	24	transact	transact	VB
18637	13715	25	business	business	NN
18637	13715	26	in	in	IN
18637	13715	27	the	the	DT
18637	13715	28	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13715	29	State	State	NNP
18637	13715	30	upon	upon	IN
18637	13715	31	the	the	DT
18637	13715	32	condition	condition	NN
18637	13715	33	that	that	IN
18637	13715	34	service	service	NN
18637	13715	35	of	of	IN
18637	13715	36	process	process	NN
18637	13715	37	upon	upon	IN
18637	13715	38	the	the	DT
18637	13715	39	agent	agent	NN
18637	13715	40	of	of	IN
18637	13715	41	the	the	DT
18637	13715	42	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13715	43	should	should	MD
18637	13715	44	be	be	VB
18637	13715	45	considered	consider	VBN
18637	13715	46	as	as	IN
18637	13715	47	service	service	NN
18637	13715	48	upon	upon	IN
18637	13715	49	the	the	DT
18637	13715	50	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13715	51	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13715	52	,	,	,
18637	13715	53	a	a	DT
18637	13715	54	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13715	55	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13715	56	against	against	IN
18637	13715	57	the	the	DT
18637	13715	58	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13715	59	by	by	IN
18637	13715	60	means	mean	NNS
18637	13715	61	of	of	IN
18637	13715	62	such	such	JJ
18637	13715	63	process	process	NN
18637	13715	64	"	"	''
18637	13715	65	ought	ought	MD
18637	13715	66	to	to	TO
18637	13715	67	receive	receive	VB
18637	13715	68	in	in	IN
18637	13715	69	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	13715	70	the	the	DT
18637	13715	71	same	same	JJ
18637	13715	72	faith	faith	NN
18637	13715	73	and	and	CC
18637	13715	74	credit	credit	NN
18637	13715	75	as	as	IN
18637	13715	76	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13715	77	was	be	VBD
18637	13715	78	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13715	79	to	to	IN
18637	13715	80	in	in	IN
18637	13715	81	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	13715	82	.	.	.
18637	13716	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13716	2	41	41	CD
18637	13716	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13716	4	Later	late	JJR
18637	13716	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	13716	6	establish	establish	VBP
18637	13716	7	under	under	IN
18637	13716	8	both	both	CC
18637	13716	9	the	the	DT
18637	13716	10	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	13716	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	13716	12	and	and	CC
18637	13716	13	article	article	NN
18637	13716	14	IV	IV	NNP
18637	13716	15	,	,	,
18637	13716	16	section	section	NN
18637	13716	17	1	1	CD
18637	13716	18	,	,	,
18637	13716	19	that	that	IN
18637	13716	20	the	the	DT
18637	13716	21	cause	cause	NN
18637	13716	22	of	of	IN
18637	13716	23	action	action	NN
18637	13716	24	must	must	MD
18637	13716	25	have	have	VB
18637	13716	26	arisen	arise	VBN
18637	13716	27	within	within	IN
18637	13716	28	the	the	DT
18637	13716	29	State	State	NNP
18637	13716	30	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	13716	31	service	service	NN
18637	13716	32	in	in	IN
18637	13716	33	this	this	DT
18637	13716	34	way,[42	way,[42	NN
18637	13716	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13716	36	that	that	DT
18637	13716	37	service	service	NN
18637	13716	38	on	on	IN
18637	13716	39	an	an	DT
18637	13716	40	officer	officer	NN
18637	13716	41	of	of	IN
18637	13716	42	a	a	DT
18637	13716	43	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13716	44	,	,	,
18637	13716	45	not	not	RB
18637	13716	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13716	47	resident	resident	JJ
18637	13716	48	agent	agent	NN
18637	13716	49	and	and	CC
18637	13716	50	not	not	RB
18637	13716	51	present	present	JJ
18637	13716	52	in	in	IN
18637	13716	53	the	the	DT
18637	13716	54	State	State	NNP
18637	13716	55	in	in	IN
18637	13716	56	an	an	DT
18637	13716	57	official	official	JJ
18637	13716	58	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	13716	59	,	,	,
18637	13716	60	will	will	MD
18637	13716	61	not	not	RB
18637	13716	62	confer	confer	VB
18637	13716	63	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13716	64	over	over	IN
18637	13716	65	the	the	DT
18637	13716	66	corporation;[43	corporation;[43	NNP
18637	13716	67	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13716	68	that	that	IN
18637	13716	69	the	the	DT
18637	13716	70	question	question	NN
18637	13716	71	whether	whether	IN
18637	13716	72	the	the	DT
18637	13716	73	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13716	74	was	be	VBD
18637	13716	75	actually	actually	RB
18637	13716	76	"	"	``
18637	13716	77	doing	do	VBG
18637	13716	78	business	business	NN
18637	13716	79	"	"	''
18637	13716	80	in	in	IN
18637	13716	81	the	the	DT
18637	13716	82	State	State	NNP
18637	13716	83	may	may	MD
18637	13716	84	be	be	VB
18637	13716	85	raised	raise	VBN
18637	13716	86	.	.	.
18637	13717	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13717	2	44	44	CD
18637	13717	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13717	4	On	on	IN
18637	13717	5	the	the	DT
18637	13717	6	other	other	JJ
18637	13717	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	13717	8	,	,	,
18637	13717	9	the	the	DT
18637	13717	10	fact	fact	NN
18637	13717	11	that	that	IN
18637	13717	12	the	the	DT
18637	13717	13	business	business	NN
18637	13717	14	was	be	VBD
18637	13717	15	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	13717	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	13717	17	no	no	DT
18637	13717	18	objection	objection	NN
18637	13717	19	.	.	.
18637	13718	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13718	2	45	45	CD
18637	13718	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13718	4	SERVICE	service	NN
18637	13718	5	ON	on	IN
18637	13718	6	OUT	out	IN
18637	13718	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	13718	8	OF	of	IN
18637	13718	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	13718	10	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	13718	11	OWNERS	OWNERS	NNP
18637	13718	12	OF	of	IN
18637	13718	13	MOTOR	MOTOR	NNP
18637	13718	14	VEHICLES	VEHICLES	NNP
18637	13718	15	By	by	IN
18637	13718	16	analogy	analogy	NN
18637	13718	17	to	to	IN
18637	13718	18	the	the	DT
18637	13718	19	above	above	JJ
18637	13718	20	cases	case	NNS
18637	13718	21	,	,	,
18637	13718	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13718	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	13718	24	been	be	VBN
18637	13718	25	held	hold	VBN
18637	13718	26	that	that	IN
18637	13718	27	a	a	DT
18637	13718	28	State	state	NN
18637	13718	29	may	may	MD
18637	13718	30	require	require	VB
18637	13718	31	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	13718	32	owners	owner	NNS
18637	13718	33	of	of	IN
18637	13718	34	motor	motor	NN
18637	13718	35	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	13718	36	to	to	TO
18637	13718	37	designate	designate	VB
18637	13718	38	an	an	DT
18637	13718	39	official	official	NN
18637	13718	40	within	within	IN
18637	13718	41	the	the	DT
18637	13718	42	State	State	NNP
18637	13718	43	as	as	IN
18637	13718	44	an	an	DT
18637	13718	45	agent	agent	NN
18637	13718	46	upon	upon	IN
18637	13718	47	whom	whom	WP
18637	13718	48	process	process	NN
18637	13718	49	may	may	MD
18637	13718	50	be	be	VB
18637	13718	51	served	serve	VBN
18637	13718	52	in	in	IN
18637	13718	53	any	any	DT
18637	13718	54	legal	legal	JJ
18637	13718	55	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13718	56	growing	grow	VBG
18637	13718	57	out	out	IN
18637	13718	58	of	of	IN
18637	13718	59	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13718	60	operation	operation	NN
18637	13718	61	of	of	IN
18637	13718	62	a	a	DT
18637	13718	63	motor	motor	NN
18637	13718	64	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	13718	65	within	within	IN
18637	13718	66	the	the	DT
18637	13718	67	State;[46	State;[46	NNP
18637	13718	68	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13718	69	and	and	CC
18637	13718	70	while	while	IN
18637	13718	71	these	these	DT
18637	13718	72	cases	case	NNS
18637	13718	73	arose	arise	VBD
18637	13718	74	under	under	IN
18637	13718	75	the	the	DT
18637	13718	76	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	13718	77	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	13718	78	alone	alone	RB
18637	13718	79	,	,	,
18637	13718	80	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
18637	13718	81	a	a	DT
18637	13718	82	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13718	83	validly	validly	RB
18637	13718	84	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13718	85	upon	upon	IN
18637	13718	86	this	this	DT
18637	13718	87	species	specie	NNS
18637	13718	88	of	of	IN
18637	13718	89	service	service	NN
18637	13718	90	could	could	MD
18637	13718	91	be	be	VB
18637	13718	92	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	13718	93	upon	upon	IN
18637	13718	94	the	the	DT
18637	13718	95	owner	owner	NN
18637	13718	96	of	of	IN
18637	13718	97	a	a	DT
18637	13718	98	car	car	NN
18637	13718	99	through	through	IN
18637	13718	100	the	the	DT
18637	13718	101	courts	court	NNS
18637	13718	102	of	of	IN
18637	13718	103	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13718	104	home	home	NN
18637	13718	105	State	State	NNP
18637	13718	106	.	.	.
18637	13719	1	JUDGMENTS	JUDGMENTS	NNP
18637	13719	2	_	_	NNP
18637	13719	3	IN	IN	NNP
18637	13719	4	REM	REM	NNP
18637	13719	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13719	6	In	in	IN
18637	13719	7	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	13719	8	the	the	DT
18637	13719	9	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	13719	10	to	to	IN
18637	13719	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13719	12	in	in	IN
18637	13719	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	13719	14	involving	involve	VBG
18637	13719	15	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13719	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13719	17	in	in	IN
18637	13719	18	personam	personam	NNP
18637	13719	19	_	_	NNP
18637	13719	20	,	,	,
18637	13719	21	the	the	DT
18637	13719	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13719	23	was	be	VBD
18637	13719	24	in	in	IN
18637	13719	25	the	the	DT
18637	13719	26	main	main	JJ
18637	13719	27	making	making	NN
18637	13719	28	only	only	RB
18637	13719	29	a	a	DT
18637	13719	30	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	13719	31	more	more	RBR
18637	13719	32	extended	extended	JJ
18637	13719	33	application	application	NN
18637	13719	34	of	of	IN
18637	13719	35	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	13719	36	principles	principle	NNS
18637	13719	37	.	.	.
18637	13720	1	In	in	IN
18637	13720	2	order	order	NN
18637	13720	3	to	to	TO
18637	13720	4	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	13720	5	the	the	DT
18637	13720	6	same	same	JJ
18637	13720	7	kind	kind	NN
18637	13720	8	of	of	IN
18637	13720	9	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	13720	10	in	in	IN
18637	13720	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	13720	12	involving	involve	VBG
18637	13720	13	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13720	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13720	15	in	in	IN
18637	13720	16	rem	rem	NNP
18637	13720	17	_	_	NNP
18637	13720	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13720	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	13720	20	had	have	VBN
18637	13720	21	to	to	TO
18637	13720	22	make	make	VB
18637	13720	23	law	law	NN
18637	13720	24	outright	outright	RB
18637	13720	25	.	.	.
18637	13721	1	The	the	DT
18637	13721	2	leading	leading	JJ
18637	13721	3	case	case	NN
18637	13721	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	13721	5	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	13721	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13721	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13721	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13721	9	Whitman,[47	Whitman,[47	NNP
18637	13721	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13721	11	decided	decide	VBN
18637	13721	12	in	in	IN
18637	13721	13	1874	1874	CD
18637	13721	14	.	.	.
18637	13722	1	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	13722	2	,	,	,
18637	13722	3	sheriff	sheriff	NN
18637	13722	4	of	of	IN
18637	13722	5	Monmouth	Monmouth	NNP
18637	13722	6	County	County	NNP
18637	13722	7	,	,	,
18637	13722	8	New	New	NNP
18637	13722	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	13722	10	,	,	,
18637	13722	11	acting	act	VBG
18637	13722	12	under	under	IN
18637	13722	13	a	a	DT
18637	13722	14	New	New	NNP
18637	13722	15	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	13722	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	13722	17	,	,	,
18637	13722	18	had	have	VBD
18637	13722	19	seized	seize	VBN
18637	13722	20	a	a	DT
18637	13722	21	sloop	sloop	NN
18637	13722	22	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	13722	23	to	to	IN
18637	13722	24	Whitman	Whitman	NNP
18637	13722	25	,	,	,
18637	13722	26	and	and	CC
18637	13722	27	by	by	IN
18637	13722	28	a	a	DT
18637	13722	29	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13722	30	_	_	NNP
18637	13722	31	in	in	IN
18637	13722	32	rem	rem	NN
18637	13722	33	_	_	NNP
18637	13722	34	had	have	VBD
18637	13722	35	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13722	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13722	37	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	13722	38	and	and	CC
18637	13722	39	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	13722	40	in	in	IN
18637	13722	41	a	a	DT
18637	13722	42	local	local	JJ
18637	13722	43	court	court	NN
18637	13722	44	.	.	.
18637	13723	1	Later	later	RB
18637	13723	2	,	,	,
18637	13723	3	Whitman	Whitman	NNP
18637	13723	4	,	,	,
18637	13723	5	a	a	DT
18637	13723	6	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	13723	7	of	of	IN
18637	13723	8	New	New	NNP
18637	13723	9	York	York	NNP
18637	13723	10	,	,	,
18637	13723	11	brought	bring	VBD
18637	13723	12	an	an	DT
18637	13723	13	action	action	NN
18637	13723	14	for	for	IN
18637	13723	15	trespass	trespass	NN
18637	13723	16	against	against	IN
18637	13723	17	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	13723	18	in	in	IN
18637	13723	19	the	the	DT
18637	13723	20	United	United	NNP
18637	13723	21	States	States	NNP
18637	13723	22	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
18637	13723	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13723	24	for	for	IN
18637	13723	25	the	the	DT
18637	13723	26	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	13723	27	District	District	NNP
18637	13723	28	of	of	IN
18637	13723	29	New	New	NNP
18637	13723	30	York	York	NNP
18637	13723	31	,	,	,
18637	13723	32	and	and	CC
18637	13723	33	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	13723	34	answered	answer	VBD
18637	13723	35	by	by	IN
18637	13723	36	producing	produce	VBG
18637	13723	37	a	a	DT
18637	13723	38	record	record	NN
18637	13723	39	of	of	IN
18637	13723	40	the	the	DT
18637	13723	41	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13723	42	before	before	IN
18637	13723	43	the	the	DT
18637	13723	44	New	New	NNP
18637	13723	45	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	13723	46	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	13723	47	.	.	.
18637	13724	1	Whitman	Whitman	NNP
18637	13724	2	thereupon	thereupon	RB
18637	13724	3	set	set	VBD
18637	13724	4	up	up	RP
18637	13724	5	the	the	DT
18637	13724	6	contention	contention	NN
18637	13724	7	that	that	IN
18637	13724	8	the	the	DT
18637	13724	9	New	New	NNP
18637	13724	10	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	13724	11	court	court	NN
18637	13724	12	had	have	VBD
18637	13724	13	acted	act	VBN
18637	13724	14	without	without	IN
18637	13724	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13724	16	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	13724	17	as	as	IN
18637	13724	18	the	the	DT
18637	13724	19	sloop	sloop	NN
18637	13724	20	which	which	WDT
18637	13724	21	was	be	VBD
18637	13724	22	the	the	DT
18637	13724	23	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13724	24	matter	matter	NN
18637	13724	25	of	of	IN
18637	13724	26	the	the	DT
18637	13724	27	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13724	28	had	have	VBD
18637	13724	29	been	be	VBN
18637	13724	30	seized	seize	VBN
18637	13724	31	outside	outside	IN
18637	13724	32	the	the	DT
18637	13724	33	county	county	NN
18637	13724	34	to	to	IN
18637	13724	35	which	which	WDT
18637	13724	36	,	,	,
18637	13724	37	by	by	IN
18637	13724	38	the	the	DT
18637	13724	39	statute	statute	NN
18637	13724	40	under	under	IN
18637	13724	41	which	which	WDT
18637	13724	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13724	43	had	have	VBD
18637	13724	44	acted	act	VBN
18637	13724	45	,	,	,
18637	13724	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13724	47	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13724	48	was	be	VBD
18637	13724	49	confined	confine	VBN
18637	13724	50	.	.	.
18637	13725	1	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	13725	2	_	_	NNP
18637	13725	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	13725	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13725	5	Whitman	Whitman	NNP
18637	13725	6	As	as	IN
18637	13725	7	previously	previously	RB
18637	13725	8	explained	explain	VBN
18637	13725	9	,	,	,
18637	13725	10	the	the	DT
18637	13725	11	plea	plea	NN
18637	13725	12	of	of	IN
18637	13725	13	lack	lack	NN
18637	13725	14	of	of	IN
18637	13725	15	privity	privity	NN
18637	13725	16	can	can	MD
18637	13725	17	not	not	RB
18637	13725	18	be	be	VB
18637	13725	19	set	set	VBN
18637	13725	20	up	up	RP
18637	13725	21	in	in	IN
18637	13725	22	defense	defense	NN
18637	13725	23	in	in	IN
18637	13725	24	a	a	DT
18637	13725	25	sister	sister	NN
18637	13725	26	State	State	NNP
18637	13725	27	against	against	IN
18637	13725	28	a	a	DT
18637	13725	29	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13725	30	_	_	NNP
18637	13725	31	in	in	IN
18637	13725	32	rem	rem	NNP
18637	13725	33	_	_	NNP
18637	13725	34	.	.	.
18637	13726	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13726	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	13726	3	,	,	,
18637	13726	4	on	on	IN
18637	13726	5	the	the	DT
18637	13726	6	other	other	JJ
18637	13726	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	13726	8	,	,	,
18637	13726	9	required	require	VBN
18637	13726	10	of	of	IN
18637	13726	11	a	a	DT
18637	13726	12	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13726	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13726	14	in	in	IN
18637	13726	15	rem	rem	NNP
18637	13726	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13726	17	that	that	IN
18637	13726	18	the	the	DT
18637	13726	19	_	_	NNP
18637	13726	20	res	res	NNP
18637	13726	21	_	_	NNP
18637	13726	22	be	be	VBP
18637	13726	23	within	within	IN
18637	13726	24	the	the	DT
18637	13726	25	court	court	NN
18637	13726	26	's	's	POS
18637	13726	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13726	28	,	,	,
18637	13726	29	and	and	CC
18637	13726	30	this	this	DT
18637	13726	31	,	,	,
18637	13726	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13726	33	was	be	VBD
18637	13726	34	urged	urge	VBN
18637	13726	35	,	,	,
18637	13726	36	had	have	VBD
18637	13726	37	not	not	RB
18637	13726	38	been	be	VBN
18637	13726	39	the	the	DT
18637	13726	40	case	case	NN
18637	13726	41	in	in	IN
18637	13726	42	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	13726	43	_	_	NNP
18637	13726	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	13726	45	_	_	NNP
18637	13726	46	Whitman	Whitman	NNP
18637	13726	47	.	.	.
18637	13727	1	Could	Could	MD
18637	13727	2	,	,	,
18637	13727	3	then	then	RB
18637	13727	4	,	,	,
18637	13727	5	the	the	DT
18637	13727	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13727	7	consider	consider	VBP
18637	13727	8	this	this	DT
18637	13727	9	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	13727	10	with	with	IN
18637	13727	11	respect	respect	NN
18637	13727	12	to	to	IN
18637	13727	13	a	a	DT
18637	13727	14	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13727	15	which	which	WDT
18637	13727	16	was	be	VBD
18637	13727	17	offered	offer	VBN
18637	13727	18	not	not	RB
18637	13727	19	as	as	IN
18637	13727	20	the	the	DT
18637	13727	21	basis	basis	NN
18637	13727	22	for	for	IN
18637	13727	23	an	an	DT
18637	13727	24	action	action	NN
18637	13727	25	for	for	IN
18637	13727	26	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	13727	27	through	through	IN
18637	13727	28	the	the	DT
18637	13727	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	13727	30	of	of	IN
18637	13727	31	a	a	DT
18637	13727	32	sister	sister	NN
18637	13727	33	State	State	NNP
18637	13727	34	,	,	,
18637	13727	35	but	but	CC
18637	13727	36	merely	merely	RB
18637	13727	37	as	as	IN
18637	13727	38	a	a	DT
18637	13727	39	defense	defense	NN
18637	13727	40	in	in	IN
18637	13727	41	a	a	DT
18637	13727	42	collateral	collateral	JJ
18637	13727	43	action	action	NN
18637	13727	44	?	?	.
18637	13728	1	As	as	IN
18637	13728	2	the	the	DT
18637	13728	3	law	law	NN
18637	13728	4	stood	stand	VBD
18637	13728	5	in	in	IN
18637	13728	6	1873	1873	CD
18637	13728	7	,	,	,
18637	13728	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13728	9	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	13728	10	could	could	MD
18637	13728	11	not	not	RB
18637	13728	12	.	.	.
18637	13729	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13729	2	48	48	CD
18637	13729	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13729	4	All	all	DT
18637	13729	5	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	13729	6	,	,	,
18637	13729	7	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	13729	8	,	,	,
18637	13729	9	to	to	IN
18637	13729	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13729	11	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	13729	12	of	of	IN
18637	13729	13	the	the	DT
18637	13729	14	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	13729	15	to	to	IN
18637	13729	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13729	17	in	in	IN
18637	13729	18	the	the	DT
18637	13729	19	case	case	NN
18637	13729	20	were	be	VBD
18637	13729	21	brushed	brush	VBN
18637	13729	22	aside	aside	RB
18637	13729	23	by	by	IN
18637	13729	24	the	the	DT
18637	13729	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13729	26	.	.	.
18637	13730	1	Whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	13730	2	,	,	,
18637	13730	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13730	4	said	say	VBD
18637	13730	5	,	,	,
18637	13730	6	the	the	DT
18637	13730	7	record	record	NN
18637	13730	8	of	of	IN
18637	13730	9	a	a	DT
18637	13730	10	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13730	11	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13730	12	in	in	IN
18637	13730	13	a	a	DT
18637	13730	14	State	State	NNP
18637	13730	15	court	court	NN
18637	13730	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	13730	17	offered	offer	VBN
18637	13730	18	"	"	''
18637	13730	19	in	in	IN
18637	13730	20	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	13730	21	"	"	''
18637	13730	22	by	by	IN
18637	13730	23	either	either	DT
18637	13730	24	of	of	IN
18637	13730	25	the	the	DT
18637	13730	26	parties	party	NNS
18637	13730	27	to	to	IN
18637	13730	28	an	an	DT
18637	13730	29	action	action	NN
18637	13730	30	in	in	IN
18637	13730	31	another	another	DT
18637	13730	32	State	state	NN
18637	13730	33	,	,	,
18637	13730	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13730	35	may	may	MD
18637	13730	36	be	be	VB
18637	13730	37	contradicted	contradict	VBN
18637	13730	38	as	as	IN
18637	13730	39	to	to	IN
18637	13730	40	the	the	DT
18637	13730	41	facts	fact	NNS
18637	13730	42	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	13730	43	to	to	TO
18637	13730	44	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	13730	45	the	the	DT
18637	13730	46	former	former	JJ
18637	13730	47	court	court	NN
18637	13730	48	's	's	POS
18637	13730	49	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13730	50	;	;	:
18637	13730	51	"	"	``
18637	13730	52	and	and	CC
18637	13730	53	if	if	IN
18637	13730	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13730	55	be	be	VB
18637	13730	56	shown	show	VBN
18637	13730	57	that	that	IN
18637	13730	58	such	such	JJ
18637	13730	59	facts	fact	NNS
18637	13730	60	did	do	VBD
18637	13730	61	not	not	RB
18637	13730	62	exist	exist	VB
18637	13730	63	,	,	,
18637	13730	64	the	the	DT
18637	13730	65	record	record	NN
18637	13730	66	will	will	MD
18637	13730	67	be	be	VB
18637	13730	68	a	a	DT
18637	13730	69	nullity	nullity	NN
18637	13730	70	,	,	,
18637	13730	71	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	13730	72	the	the	DT
18637	13730	73	claim	claim	NN
18637	13730	74	that	that	IN
18637	13730	75	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13730	76	did	do	VBD
18637	13730	77	exist	exist	VB
18637	13730	78	.	.	.
18637	13731	1	"	"	``
18637	13731	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13731	3	49	49	CD
18637	13731	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13731	5	Divorce	Divorce	NNP
18637	13731	6	Decrees	Decrees	NNP
18637	13731	7	THE	the	DT
18637	13731	8	JURISDICTIONAL	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	13731	9	PREREQUISITE	PREREQUISITE	NNS
18637	13731	10	:	:	:
18637	13731	11	DOMICILE	domicile	NN
18637	13731	12	This	this	DT
18637	13731	13	however	however	RB
18637	13731	14	,	,	,
18637	13731	15	was	be	VBD
18637	13731	16	only	only	RB
18637	13731	17	the	the	DT
18637	13731	18	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	13731	19	of	of	IN
18637	13731	20	the	the	DT
18637	13731	21	court	court	NN
18637	13731	22	's	's	POS
18637	13731	23	lawmaking	lawmaking	NN
18637	13731	24	in	in	IN
18637	13731	25	cases	case	NNS
18637	13731	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13731	27	in	in	IN
18637	13731	28	rem	rem	NNP
18637	13731	29	_	_	NNP
18637	13731	30	.	.	.
18637	13732	1	The	the	DT
18637	13732	2	most	most	RBS
18637	13732	3	important	important	JJ
18637	13732	4	class	class	NN
18637	13732	5	of	of	IN
18637	13732	6	such	such	JJ
18637	13732	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	13732	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	13732	9	that	that	IN
18637	13732	10	in	in	IN
18637	13732	11	which	which	WDT
18637	13732	12	the	the	DT
18637	13732	13	respondent	respondent	NN
18637	13732	14	to	to	IN
18637	13732	15	a	a	DT
18637	13732	16	suit	suit	NN
18637	13732	17	for	for	IN
18637	13732	18	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13732	19	offers	offer	VBZ
18637	13732	20	in	in	IN
18637	13732	21	defense	defense	NN
18637	13732	22	an	an	DT
18637	13732	23	earlier	early	JJR
18637	13732	24	decree	decree	NN
18637	13732	25	from	from	IN
18637	13732	26	the	the	DT
18637	13732	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	13732	28	of	of	IN
18637	13732	29	a	a	DT
18637	13732	30	sister	sister	NN
18637	13732	31	State	State	NNP
18637	13732	32	.	.	.
18637	13733	1	By	by	IN
18637	13733	2	the	the	DT
18637	13733	3	almost	almost	RB
18637	13733	4	universally	universally	RB
18637	13733	5	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	13733	6	view	view	NN
18637	13733	7	prior	prior	RB
18637	13733	8	to	to	IN
18637	13733	9	1906	1906	CD
18637	13733	10	a	a	DT
18637	13733	11	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13733	12	in	in	IN
18637	13733	13	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13733	14	was	be	VBD
18637	13733	15	one	one	CD
18637	13733	16	against	against	IN
18637	13733	17	the	the	DT
18637	13733	18	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	13733	19	status	status	NN
18637	13733	20	,	,	,
18637	13733	21	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	13733	22	,	,	,
18637	13733	23	_	_	NNP
18637	13733	24	in	in	IN
18637	13733	25	rem	rem	NNP
18637	13733	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13733	27	,	,	,
18637	13733	28	and	and	CC
18637	13733	29	hence	hence	RB
18637	13733	30	might	may	MD
18637	13733	31	be	be	VB
18637	13733	32	validly	validly	RB
18637	13733	33	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13733	34	by	by	RP
18637	13733	35	either	either	CC
18637	13733	36	party	party	NN
18637	13733	37	in	in	IN
18637	13733	38	any	any	DT
18637	13733	39	State	State	NNP
18637	13733	40	where	where	WRB
18637	13733	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13733	42	or	or	CC
18637	13733	43	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13733	44	was	be	VBD
18637	13733	45	_	_	NNP
18637	13733	46	bona	bona	NN
18637	13733	47	fide	fide	FW
18637	13733	48	_	_	NNP
18637	13733	49	domiciled;[50	domiciled;[50	NNP
18637	13733	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13733	51	and	and	CC
18637	13733	52	,	,	,
18637	13733	53	conversely	conversely	RB
18637	13733	54	,	,	,
18637	13733	55	when	when	WRB
18637	13733	56	the	the	DT
18637	13733	57	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	13733	58	did	do	VBD
18637	13733	59	not	not	RB
18637	13733	60	have	have	VB
18637	13733	61	a	a	DT
18637	13733	62	_	_	NNP
18637	13733	63	bona	bona	NN
18637	13733	64	fide	fide	FW
18637	13733	65	_	_	NNP
18637	13733	66	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13733	67	in	in	IN
18637	13733	68	the	the	DT
18637	13733	69	State	State	NNP
18637	13733	70	,	,	,
18637	13733	71	a	a	DT
18637	13733	72	court	court	NN
18637	13733	73	could	could	MD
18637	13733	74	not	not	RB
18637	13733	75	render	render	VB
18637	13733	76	a	a	DT
18637	13733	77	decree	decree	NN
18637	13733	78	binding	bind	VBG
18637	13733	79	in	in	IN
18637	13733	80	other	other	JJ
18637	13733	81	States	state	NNS
18637	13733	82	even	even	RB
18637	13733	83	if	if	IN
18637	13733	84	the	the	DT
18637	13733	85	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	13733	86	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13733	87	entered	enter	VBD
18637	13733	88	a	a	DT
18637	13733	89	personal	personal	JJ
18637	13733	90	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	13733	91	.	.	.
18637	13734	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13734	2	51	51	CD
18637	13734	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13734	4	But	but	CC
18637	13734	5	in	in	IN
18637	13734	6	1906	1906	CD
18637	13734	7	the	the	DT
18637	13734	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13734	9	discovered	discover	VBD
18637	13734	10	,	,	,
18637	13734	11	by	by	IN
18637	13734	12	a	a	DT
18637	13734	13	vote	vote	NN
18637	13734	14	of	of	IN
18637	13734	15	five	five	CD
18637	13734	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	13734	17	to	to	IN
18637	13734	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	13734	19	four	four	CD
18637	13734	20	,	,	,
18637	13734	21	a	a	DT
18637	13734	22	situation	situation	NN
18637	13734	23	in	in	IN
18637	13734	24	which	which	WDT
18637	13734	25	a	a	DT
18637	13734	26	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13734	27	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13734	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	13734	29	one	one	CD
18637	13734	30	_	_	NNP
18637	13734	31	in	in	IN
18637	13734	32	personam	personam	NNP
18637	13734	33	_	_	NNP
18637	13734	34	.	.	.
18637	13735	1	Haddock	Haddock	NNP
18637	13735	2	_	_	NNP
18637	13735	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	13735	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13735	5	Haddock	Haddock	NNP
18637	13735	6	The	the	DT
18637	13735	7	case	case	NN
18637	13735	8	referred	refer	VBD
18637	13735	9	to	to	IN
18637	13735	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	13735	11	Haddock	Haddock	NNP
18637	13735	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13735	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	13735	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13735	15	Haddock,[52	Haddock,[52	NNP
18637	13735	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13735	17	while	while	IN
18637	13735	18	the	the	DT
18637	13735	19	earlier	early	JJR
18637	13735	20	rule	rule	NN
18637	13735	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	13735	22	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
18637	13735	23	by	by	IN
18637	13735	24	Atherton	Atherton	NNP
18637	13735	25	_	_	NNP
18637	13735	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	13735	27	_	_	NNP
18637	13735	28	Atherton,[53	Atherton,[53	NNP
18637	13735	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13735	30	decided	decide	VBD
18637	13735	31	five	five	CD
18637	13735	32	years	year	NNS
18637	13735	33	previously	previously	RB
18637	13735	34	.	.	.
18637	13736	1	In	in	IN
18637	13736	2	the	the	DT
18637	13736	3	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13736	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13736	5	was	be	VBD
18637	13736	6	held	hold	VBN
18637	13736	7	,	,	,
18637	13736	8	in	in	IN
18637	13736	9	the	the	DT
18637	13736	10	former	former	JJ
18637	13736	11	denied	denied	NN
18637	13736	12	,	,	,
18637	13736	13	that	that	IN
18637	13736	14	a	a	DT
18637	13736	15	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13736	16	granted	grant	VBD
18637	13736	17	a	a	DT
18637	13736	18	husband	husband	NN
18637	13736	19	without	without	IN
18637	13736	20	personal	personal	JJ
18637	13736	21	service	service	NN
18637	13736	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	13736	23	the	the	DT
18637	13736	24	wife	wife	NN
18637	13736	25	,	,	,
18637	13736	26	who	who	WP
18637	13736	27	at	at	IN
18637	13736	28	the	the	DT
18637	13736	29	time	time	NN
18637	13736	30	was	be	VBD
18637	13736	31	residing	reside	VBG
18637	13736	32	in	in	IN
18637	13736	33	another	another	DT
18637	13736	34	State	State	NNP
18637	13736	35	,	,	,
18637	13736	36	was	be	VBD
18637	13736	37	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13736	38	to	to	IN
18637	13736	39	recognition	recognition	VB
18637	13736	40	under	under	IN
18637	13736	41	the	the	DT
18637	13736	42	full	full	JJ
18637	13736	43	faith	faith	NN
18637	13736	44	and	and	CC
18637	13736	45	credit	credit	NN
18637	13736	46	clause	clause	NN
18637	13736	47	and	and	CC
18637	13736	48	the	the	DT
18637	13736	49	acts	act	NNS
18637	13736	50	of	of	IN
18637	13736	51	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13736	52	;	;	:
18637	13736	53	the	the	DT
18637	13736	54	difference	difference	NN
18637	13736	55	between	between	IN
18637	13736	56	the	the	DT
18637	13736	57	cases	case	NNS
18637	13736	58	consisting	consist	VBG
18637	13736	59	solely	solely	RB
18637	13736	60	in	in	IN
18637	13736	61	the	the	DT
18637	13736	62	fact	fact	NN
18637	13736	63	that	that	IN
18637	13736	64	in	in	IN
18637	13736	65	the	the	DT
18637	13736	66	Atherton	Atherton	NNP
18637	13736	67	case	case	NN
18637	13736	68	the	the	DT
18637	13736	69	husband	husband	NN
18637	13736	70	had	have	VBD
18637	13736	71	driven	drive	VBN
18637	13736	72	the	the	DT
18637	13736	73	wife	wife	NN
18637	13736	74	from	from	IN
18637	13736	75	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13736	76	joint	joint	JJ
18637	13736	77	home	home	NN
18637	13736	78	by	by	IN
18637	13736	79	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13736	80	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	13736	81	,	,	,
18637	13736	82	while	while	IN
18637	13736	83	in	in	IN
18637	13736	84	the	the	DT
18637	13736	85	Haddock	Haddock	NNP
18637	13736	86	case	case	NN
18637	13736	87	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13736	88	had	have	VBD
18637	13736	89	deserted	desert	VBN
18637	13736	90	her	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13736	91	.	.	.
18637	13737	1	The	the	DT
18637	13737	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13737	3	which	which	WDT
18637	13737	4	granted	grant	VBD
18637	13737	5	the	the	DT
18637	13737	6	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13737	7	in	in	IN
18637	13737	8	Atherton	Atherton	NNP
18637	13737	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13737	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	13737	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13737	12	Atherton	Atherton	NNP
18637	13737	13	was	be	VBD
18637	13737	14	held	hold	VBN
18637	13737	15	to	to	TO
18637	13737	16	have	have	VB
18637	13737	17	had	have	VBN
18637	13737	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13737	19	of	of	IN
18637	13737	20	the	the	DT
18637	13737	21	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	13737	22	status	status	NN
18637	13737	23	,	,	,
18637	13737	24	with	with	IN
18637	13737	25	the	the	DT
18637	13737	26	result	result	NN
18637	13737	27	that	that	IN
18637	13737	28	the	the	DT
18637	13737	29	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13737	30	was	be	VBD
18637	13737	31	one	one	CD
18637	13737	32	_	_	NNP
18637	13737	33	in	in	IN
18637	13737	34	rem	rem	NNP
18637	13737	35	_	_	NNP
18637	13737	36	and	and	CC
18637	13737	37	hence	hence	RB
18637	13737	38	required	require	VBN
18637	13737	39	only	only	JJ
18637	13737	40	service	service	NN
18637	13737	41	by	by	IN
18637	13737	42	publication	publication	NN
18637	13737	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	13737	44	the	the	DT
18637	13737	45	respondent	respondent	NN
18637	13737	46	.	.	.
18637	13738	1	Haddock	Haddock	NNP
18637	13738	2	's	's	POS
18637	13738	3	suit	suit	NN
18637	13738	4	,	,	,
18637	13738	5	on	on	IN
18637	13738	6	the	the	DT
18637	13738	7	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	13738	8	,	,	,
18637	13738	9	was	be	VBD
18637	13738	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	13738	11	to	to	TO
18637	13738	12	be	be	VB
18637	13738	13	as	as	IN
18637	13738	14	to	to	IN
18637	13738	15	the	the	DT
18637	13738	16	wife	wife	NN
18637	13738	17	_	_	NNP
18637	13738	18	in	in	IN
18637	13738	19	personam	personam	NNP
18637	13738	20	_	_	NNP
18637	13738	21	,	,	,
18637	13738	22	and	and	CC
18637	13738	23	so	so	RB
18637	13738	24	to	to	TO
18637	13738	25	require	require	VB
18637	13738	26	personal	personal	JJ
18637	13738	27	service	service	NN
18637	13738	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	13738	29	her	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13738	30	,	,	,
18637	13738	31	or	or	CC
18637	13738	32	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13738	33	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	13738	34	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	13738	35	,	,	,
18637	13738	36	neither	neither	DT
18637	13738	37	of	of	IN
18637	13738	38	which	which	WDT
18637	13738	39	had	have	VBD
18637	13738	40	been	be	VBN
18637	13738	41	had	have	VBN
18637	13738	42	;	;	:
18637	13738	43	although	although	IN
18637	13738	44	,	,	,
18637	13738	45	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	13738	46	this	this	DT
18637	13738	47	,	,	,
18637	13738	48	the	the	DT
18637	13738	49	decree	decree	NN
18637	13738	50	in	in	IN
18637	13738	51	the	the	DT
18637	13738	52	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13738	53	case	case	NN
18637	13738	54	was	be	VBD
18637	13738	55	held	hold	VBN
18637	13738	56	to	to	TO
18637	13738	57	be	be	VB
18637	13738	58	valid	valid	JJ
18637	13738	59	as	as	IN
18637	13738	60	to	to	IN
18637	13738	61	the	the	DT
18637	13738	62	State	State	NNP
18637	13738	63	where	where	WRB
18637	13738	64	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13738	65	on	on	IN
18637	13738	66	account	account	NN
18637	13738	67	of	of	IN
18637	13738	68	the	the	DT
18637	13738	69	State	State	NNP
18637	13738	70	's	's	POS
18637	13738	71	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	13738	72	power	power	NN
18637	13738	73	to	to	TO
18637	13738	74	determine	determine	VB
18637	13738	75	the	the	DT
18637	13738	76	status	status	NN
18637	13738	77	of	of	IN
18637	13738	78	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13738	79	own	own	JJ
18637	13738	80	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13738	81	.	.	.
18637	13739	1	The	the	DT
18637	13739	2	upshot	upshot	NN
18637	13739	3	was	be	VBD
18637	13739	4	a	a	DT
18637	13739	5	situation	situation	NN
18637	13739	6	in	in	IN
18637	13739	7	which	which	WDT
18637	13739	8	a	a	DT
18637	13739	9	man	man	NN
18637	13739	10	and	and	CC
18637	13739	11	a	a	DT
18637	13739	12	woman	woman	NN
18637	13739	13	,	,	,
18637	13739	14	when	when	WRB
18637	13739	15	both	both	DT
18637	13739	16	were	be	VBD
18637	13739	17	in	in	IN
18637	13739	18	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	13739	19	,	,	,
18637	13739	20	were	be	VBD
18637	13739	21	divorced	divorce	VBN
18637	13739	22	;	;	:
18637	13739	23	when	when	WRB
18637	13739	24	both	both	DT
18637	13739	25	were	be	VBD
18637	13739	26	in	in	IN
18637	13739	27	New	New	NNP
18637	13739	28	York	York	NNP
18637	13739	29	,	,	,
18637	13739	30	were	be	VBD
18637	13739	31	married	marry	VBN
18637	13739	32	;	;	:
18637	13739	33	and	and	CC
18637	13739	34	when	when	WRB
18637	13739	35	the	the	DT
18637	13739	36	one	one	NN
18637	13739	37	was	be	VBD
18637	13739	38	in	in	IN
18637	13739	39	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	13739	40	and	and	CC
18637	13739	41	the	the	DT
18637	13739	42	other	other	JJ
18637	13739	43	in	in	IN
18637	13739	44	New	New	NNP
18637	13739	45	York	York	NNP
18637	13739	46	,	,	,
18637	13739	47	the	the	DT
18637	13739	48	former	former	JJ
18637	13739	49	was	be	VBD
18637	13739	50	divorced	divorce	VBN
18637	13739	51	and	and	CC
18637	13739	52	the	the	DT
18637	13739	53	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13739	54	married	marry	VBN
18637	13739	55	.	.	.
18637	13740	1	In	in	IN
18637	13740	2	Atherton	Atherton	NNP
18637	13740	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13740	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13740	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13740	6	Atherton	Atherton	NNP
18637	13740	7	the	the	DT
18637	13740	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13740	9	had	have	VBD
18637	13740	10	earlier	early	RBR
18637	13740	11	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	13740	12	that	that	IN
18637	13740	13	"	"	``
18637	13740	14	a	a	DT
18637	13740	15	husband	husband	NN
18637	13740	16	without	without	IN
18637	13740	17	a	a	DT
18637	13740	18	wife	wife	NN
18637	13740	19	,	,	,
18637	13740	20	or	or	CC
18637	13740	21	a	a	DT
18637	13740	22	wife	wife	NN
18637	13740	23	without	without	IN
18637	13740	24	a	a	DT
18637	13740	25	husband	husband	NN
18637	13740	26	,	,	,
18637	13740	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	13740	28	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	13740	29	to	to	IN
18637	13740	30	the	the	DT
18637	13740	31	law	law	NN
18637	13740	32	.	.	.
18637	13740	33	"	"	''
18637	13741	1	EMERGENCE	emergence	RB
18637	13741	2	OF	of	IN
18637	13741	3	THE	the	DT
18637	13741	4	DOMICILE	DOMICILE	NNP
18637	13741	5	QUESTION	question	NN
18637	13741	6	The	the	DT
18637	13741	7	practical	practical	JJ
18637	13741	8	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	13741	9	and	and	CC
18637	13741	10	distresses	distress	NNS
18637	13741	11	likely	likely	JJ
18637	13741	12	to	to	TO
18637	13741	13	result	result	VB
18637	13741	14	from	from	IN
18637	13741	15	such	such	JJ
18637	13741	16	anomalies	anomaly	NNS
18637	13741	17	were	be	VBD
18637	13741	18	pointed	point	VBN
18637	13741	19	out	out	RP
18637	13741	20	by	by	IN
18637	13741	21	critics	critic	NNS
18637	13741	22	of	of	IN
18637	13741	23	the	the	DT
18637	13741	24	decision	decision	NN
18637	13741	25	at	at	IN
18637	13741	26	the	the	DT
18637	13741	27	time	time	NN
18637	13741	28	.	.	.
18637	13742	1	In	in	IN
18637	13742	2	point	point	NN
18637	13742	3	of	of	IN
18637	13742	4	fact	fact	NN
18637	13742	5	,	,	,
18637	13742	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13742	7	have	have	VBP
18637	13742	8	been	be	VBN
18637	13742	9	largely	largely	RB
18637	13742	10	avoided	avoid	VBN
18637	13742	11	,	,	,
18637	13742	12	because	because	IN
18637	13742	13	most	most	JJS
18637	13742	14	of	of	IN
18637	13742	15	the	the	DT
18637	13742	16	State	State	NNP
18637	13742	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	13742	18	have	have	VBP
18637	13742	19	continued	continue	VBN
18637	13742	20	to	to	TO
18637	13742	21	give	give	VB
18637	13742	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13742	23	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13742	24	and	and	CC
18637	13742	25	full	full	JJ
18637	13742	26	faith	faith	NN
18637	13742	27	and	and	CC
18637	13742	28	credit	credit	NN
18637	13742	29	to	to	IN
18637	13742	30	one	one	CD
18637	13742	31	another	another	DT
18637	13742	32	's	's	POS
18637	13742	33	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13742	34	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13742	35	on	on	IN
18637	13742	36	the	the	DT
18637	13742	37	basis	basis	NN
18637	13742	38	of	of	IN
18637	13742	39	the	the	DT
18637	13742	40	older	old	JJR
18637	13742	41	idea	idea	NN
18637	13742	42	that	that	IN
18637	13742	43	a	a	DT
18637	13742	44	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13742	45	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13742	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	13742	47	one	one	CD
18637	13742	48	_	_	NNP
18637	13742	49	in	in	IN
18637	13742	50	rem	rem	NNP
18637	13742	51	_	_	NNP
18637	13742	52	,	,	,
18637	13742	53	and	and	CC
18637	13742	54	that	that	IN
18637	13742	55	if	if	IN
18637	13742	56	the	the	DT
18637	13742	57	applicant	applicant	NN
18637	13742	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	13742	59	_	_	NNP
18637	13742	60	bona	bona	NN
18637	13742	61	fide	fide	JJ
18637	13742	62	_	_	NNP
18637	13742	63	domiciled	domicile	VBD
18637	13742	64	in	in	IN
18637	13742	65	the	the	DT
18637	13742	66	State	State	NNP
18637	13742	67	the	the	DT
18637	13742	68	court	court	NN
18637	13742	69	has	have	VBZ
18637	13742	70	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13742	71	in	in	IN
18637	13742	72	this	this	DT
18637	13742	73	respect	respect	NN
18637	13742	74	.	.	.
18637	13743	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	13743	2	,	,	,
18637	13743	3	until	until	IN
18637	13743	4	the	the	DT
18637	13743	5	second	second	JJ
18637	13743	6	of	of	IN
18637	13743	7	the	the	DT
18637	13743	8	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	13743	9	_	_	NNP
18637	13743	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	13743	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13743	12	North	North	NNP
18637	13743	13	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	13743	14	cases[54	cases[54	NNP
18637	13743	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13743	16	was	be	VBD
18637	13743	17	decided	decide	VBN
18637	13743	18	in	in	IN
18637	13743	19	1945	1945	CD
18637	13743	20	,	,	,
18637	13743	21	there	there	EX
18637	13743	22	had	have	VBD
18637	13743	23	not	not	RB
18637	13743	24	been	be	VBN
18637	13743	25	manifested	manifest	VBN
18637	13743	26	the	the	DT
18637	13743	27	slightest	slight	JJS
18637	13743	28	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	13743	29	to	to	TO
18637	13743	30	challenge	challenge	VB
18637	13743	31	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	13743	32	the	the	DT
18637	13743	33	power	power	NN
18637	13743	34	of	of	IN
18637	13743	35	the	the	DT
18637	13743	36	States	States	NNPS
18637	13743	37	to	to	TO
18637	13743	38	determine	determine	VB
18637	13743	39	what	what	WP
18637	13743	40	shall	shall	MD
18637	13743	41	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	13743	42	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13743	43	for	for	IN
18637	13743	44	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13743	45	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	13743	46	.	.	.
18637	13744	1	Shortly	shortly	RB
18637	13744	2	prior	prior	RB
18637	13744	3	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	13744	4	,	,	,
18637	13744	5	in	in	IN
18637	13744	6	1938	1938	CD
18637	13744	7	,	,	,
18637	13744	8	the	the	DT
18637	13744	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13744	10	in	in	IN
18637	13744	11	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	13744	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13744	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	13744	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13744	15	Davis[55	Davis[55	NNP
18637	13744	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13744	17	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	13744	18	contentions	contention	NNS
18637	13744	19	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	13744	20	to	to	IN
18637	13744	21	the	the	DT
18637	13744	22	validity	validity	NN
18637	13744	23	of	of	IN
18637	13744	24	a	a	DT
18637	13744	25	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	13744	26	decree	decree	NN
18637	13744	27	of	of	IN
18637	13744	28	which	which	WDT
18637	13744	29	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	13744	30	was	be	VBD
18637	13744	31	sought	seek	VBN
18637	13744	32	in	in	IN
18637	13744	33	the	the	DT
18637	13744	34	District	District	NNP
18637	13744	35	of	of	IN
18637	13744	36	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	13744	37	.	.	.
18637	13745	1	In	in	IN
18637	13745	2	this	this	DT
18637	13745	3	case	case	NN
18637	13745	4	,	,	,
18637	13745	5	a	a	DT
18637	13745	6	husband	husband	NN
18637	13745	7	,	,	,
18637	13745	8	after	after	IN
18637	13745	9	having	have	VBG
18637	13745	10	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13745	11	in	in	IN
18637	13745	12	the	the	DT
18637	13745	13	District	District	NNP
18637	13745	14	a	a	DT
18637	13745	15	decree	decree	NN
18637	13745	16	of	of	IN
18637	13745	17	separation	separation	NN
18637	13745	18	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13745	19	to	to	IN
18637	13745	20	payment	payment	NN
18637	13745	21	of	of	IN
18637	13745	22	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	13745	23	,	,	,
18637	13745	24	established	establish	VBN
18637	13745	25	years	year	NNS
18637	13745	26	later	later	RB
18637	13745	27	a	a	DT
18637	13745	28	residence	residence	NN
18637	13745	29	in	in	IN
18637	13745	30	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	13745	31	,	,	,
18637	13745	32	and	and	CC
18637	13745	33	sued	sue	VBD
18637	13745	34	there	there	RB
18637	13745	35	for	for	IN
18637	13745	36	a	a	DT
18637	13745	37	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13745	38	.	.	.
18637	13746	1	Personally	personally	RB
18637	13746	2	served	serve	VBD
18637	13746	3	in	in	IN
18637	13746	4	the	the	DT
18637	13746	5	District	District	NNP
18637	13746	6	,	,	,
18637	13746	7	where	where	WRB
18637	13746	8	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13746	9	continued	continue	VBD
18637	13746	10	to	to	TO
18637	13746	11	reside	reside	VB
18637	13746	12	,	,	,
18637	13746	13	the	the	DT
18637	13746	14	wife	wife	NN
18637	13746	15	filed	file	VBD
18637	13746	16	a	a	DT
18637	13746	17	plea	plea	NN
18637	13746	18	denying	deny	VBG
18637	13746	19	that	that	IN
18637	13746	20	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13746	21	husband	husband	NN
18637	13746	22	was	be	VBD
18637	13746	23	a	a	DT
18637	13746	24	resident	resident	NN
18637	13746	25	of	of	IN
18637	13746	26	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	13746	27	and	and	CC
18637	13746	28	averred	aver	VBD
18637	13746	29	that	that	IN
18637	13746	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13746	31	was	be	VBD
18637	13746	32	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	13746	33	of	of	IN
18637	13746	34	a	a	DT
18637	13746	35	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	13746	36	on	on	IN
18637	13746	37	the	the	DT
18637	13746	38	court	court	NN
18637	13746	39	in	in	IN
18637	13746	40	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	13746	41	to	to	TO
18637	13746	42	establish	establish	VB
18637	13746	43	a	a	DT
18637	13746	44	residence	residence	NN
18637	13746	45	for	for	IN
18637	13746	46	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	13746	47	of	of	IN
18637	13746	48	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13746	49	.	.	.
18637	13747	1	In	in	IN
18637	13747	2	ruling	rule	VBG
18637	13747	3	that	that	IN
18637	13747	4	the	the	DT
18637	13747	5	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	13747	6	decree	decree	NN
18637	13747	7	,	,	,
18637	13747	8	granting	grant	VBG
18637	13747	9	to	to	IN
18637	13747	10	the	the	DT
18637	13747	11	husband	husband	NN
18637	13747	12	an	an	DT
18637	13747	13	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	13747	14	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13747	15	minus	minus	CC
18637	13747	16	any	any	DT
18637	13747	17	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	13747	18	payment	payment	NN
18637	13747	19	,	,	,
18637	13747	20	was	be	VBD
18637	13747	21	enforceable	enforceable	JJ
18637	13747	22	in	in	IN
18637	13747	23	the	the	DT
18637	13747	24	District	District	NNP
18637	13747	25	,	,	,
18637	13747	26	the	the	DT
18637	13747	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13747	28	stated	state	VBD
18637	13747	29	that	that	IN
18637	13747	30	in	in	IN
18637	13747	31	view	view	NN
18637	13747	32	of	of	IN
18637	13747	33	the	the	DT
18637	13747	34	wife	wife	NN
18637	13747	35	's	's	POS
18637	13747	36	failure	failure	NN
18637	13747	37	,	,	,
18637	13747	38	while	while	IN
18637	13747	39	in	in	IN
18637	13747	40	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	13747	41	litigating	litigate	VBG
18637	13747	42	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13747	43	husband	husband	NN
18637	13747	44	's	's	POS
18637	13747	45	status	status	NN
18637	13747	46	to	to	TO
18637	13747	47	sue	sue	VB
18637	13747	48	,	,	,
18637	13747	49	to	to	TO
18637	13747	50	answer	answer	VB
18637	13747	51	the	the	DT
18637	13747	52	husband	husband	NN
18637	13747	53	's	's	POS
18637	13747	54	charges	charge	NNS
18637	13747	55	of	of	IN
18637	13747	56	wilful	wilful	JJ
18637	13747	57	desertion	desertion	NN
18637	13747	58	,	,	,
18637	13747	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13747	60	would	would	MD
18637	13747	61	be	be	VB
18637	13747	62	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	13747	63	to	to	TO
18637	13747	64	hold	hold	VB
18637	13747	65	that	that	IN
18637	13747	66	the	the	DT
18637	13747	67	husband	husband	NN
18637	13747	68	's	's	POS
18637	13747	69	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13747	70	in	in	IN
18637	13747	71	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	13747	72	was	be	VBD
18637	13747	73	not	not	RB
18637	13747	74	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	13747	75	to	to	TO
18637	13747	76	entitle	entitle	VB
18637	13747	77	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13747	78	to	to	IN
18637	13747	79	a	a	DT
18637	13747	80	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13747	81	effective	effective	JJ
18637	13747	82	in	in	IN
18637	13747	83	the	the	DT
18637	13747	84	District	District	NNP
18637	13747	85	.	.	.
18637	13748	1	The	the	DT
18637	13748	2	finding	finding	NN
18637	13748	3	of	of	IN
18637	13748	4	the	the	DT
18637	13748	5	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	13748	6	court	court	NN
18637	13748	7	on	on	IN
18637	13748	8	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13748	9	and	and	CC
18637	13748	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13748	11	was	be	VBD
18637	13748	12	declared	declare	VBN
18637	13748	13	to	to	TO
18637	13748	14	bind	bind	VB
18637	13748	15	the	the	DT
18637	13748	16	wife	wife	NN
18637	13748	17	.	.	.
18637	13749	1	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	13749	2	_	_	NNP
18637	13749	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	13749	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13749	5	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	13749	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	13749	7	distinguishable	distinguishable	JJ
18637	13749	8	from	from	IN
18637	13749	9	the	the	DT
18637	13749	10	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	13749	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13749	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13749	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13749	14	North	North	NNP
18637	13749	15	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	13749	16	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	13749	17	in	in	IN
18637	13749	18	that	that	DT
18637	13749	19	in	in	IN
18637	13749	20	the	the	DT
18637	13749	21	former	former	JJ
18637	13749	22	,	,	,
18637	13749	23	determination	determination	NN
18637	13749	24	of	of	IN
18637	13749	25	the	the	DT
18637	13749	26	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	13749	27	prerequisite	prerequisite	NN
18637	13749	28	of	of	IN
18637	13749	29	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13749	30	was	be	VBD
18637	13749	31	made	make	VBN
18637	13749	32	in	in	IN
18637	13749	33	a	a	DT
18637	13749	34	contested	contest	VBN
18637	13749	35	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13749	36	,	,	,
18637	13749	37	while	while	IN
18637	13749	38	in	in	IN
18637	13749	39	the	the	DT
18637	13749	40	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	13749	41	cases	case	NNS
18637	13749	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13749	43	was	be	VBD
18637	13749	44	not	not	RB
18637	13749	45	.	.	.
18637	13750	1	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	13750	2	I	I	NNP
18637	13750	3	and	and	CC
18637	13750	4	II	II	NNP
18637	13750	5	In	in	IN
18637	13750	6	the	the	DT
18637	13750	7	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	13750	8	I	I	NNP
18637	13750	9	and	and	CC
18637	13750	10	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	13750	11	II	II	NNP
18637	13750	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	13750	13	,	,	,
18637	13750	14	the	the	DT
18637	13750	15	husband	husband	NN
18637	13750	16	of	of	IN
18637	13750	17	one	one	CD
18637	13750	18	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	13750	19	and	and	CC
18637	13750	20	the	the	DT
18637	13750	21	wife	wife	NN
18637	13750	22	of	of	IN
18637	13750	23	another	another	DT
18637	13750	24	left	leave	VBN
18637	13750	25	North	North	NNP
18637	13750	26	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	13750	27	,	,	,
18637	13750	28	obtained	obtain	VBD
18637	13750	29	six	six	CD
18637	13750	30	-	-	HYPH
18637	13750	31	week	week	NN
18637	13750	32	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13750	33	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	13750	34	in	in	IN
18637	13750	35	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13750	36	,	,	,
18637	13750	37	married	marry	VBD
18637	13750	38	there	there	RB
18637	13750	39	,	,	,
18637	13750	40	and	and	CC
18637	13750	41	resumed	resume	VBD
18637	13750	42	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13750	43	residence	residence	NN
18637	13750	44	in	in	IN
18637	13750	45	North	North	NNP
18637	13750	46	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	13750	47	where	where	WRB
18637	13750	48	both	both	DT
18637	13750	49	previously	previously	RB
18637	13750	50	had	have	VBD
18637	13750	51	been	be	VBN
18637	13750	52	married	marry	VBN
18637	13750	53	and	and	CC
18637	13750	54	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	13750	55	.	.	.
18637	13751	1	Prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
18637	13751	2	for	for	IN
18637	13751	3	bigamy	bigamy	NN
18637	13751	4	,	,	,
18637	13751	5	the	the	DT
18637	13751	6	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	13751	7	relied	rely	VBD
18637	13751	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	13751	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13751	10	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13751	11	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	13751	12	;	;	:
18637	13751	13	and	and	CC
18637	13751	14	won	win	VBD
18637	13751	15	the	the	DT
18637	13751	16	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	13751	17	round	round	NN
18637	13751	18	of	of	IN
18637	13751	19	this	this	DT
18637	13751	20	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	13751	21	;	;	:
18637	13751	22	that	that	RB
18637	13751	23	is	is	RB
18637	13751	24	,	,	,
18637	13751	25	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	13751	26	I,[56	I,[56	NNP
18637	13751	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13751	28	when	when	WRB
18637	13751	29	a	a	DT
18637	13751	30	majority	majority	NN
18637	13751	31	of	of	IN
18637	13751	32	the	the	DT
18637	13751	33	justices	justice	NNS
18637	13751	34	,	,	,
18637	13751	35	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	13751	36	Haddock	Haddock	NNP
18637	13751	37	_	_	NNP
18637	13751	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	13751	39	_	_	NNP
18637	13751	40	Haddock	Haddock	NNP
18637	13751	41	,	,	,
18637	13751	42	declared	declare	VBD
18637	13751	43	that	that	IN
18637	13751	44	in	in	IN
18637	13751	45	this	this	DT
18637	13751	46	case	case	NN
18637	13751	47	,	,	,
18637	13751	48	the	the	DT
18637	13751	49	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13751	50	must	must	MD
18637	13751	51	assume	assume	VB
18637	13751	52	that	that	IN
18637	13751	53	the	the	DT
18637	13751	54	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	13751	55	for	for	IN
18637	13751	56	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13751	57	had	have	VBD
18637	13751	58	a	a	DT
18637	13751	59	_	_	NNP
18637	13751	60	bona	bona	NN
18637	13751	61	fide	fide	FW
18637	13751	62	_	_	NNP
18637	13751	63	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13751	64	in	in	IN
18637	13751	65	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13751	66	,	,	,
18637	13751	67	and	and	CC
18637	13751	68	not	not	RB
18637	13751	69	that	that	IN
18637	13751	70	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13751	71	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13751	72	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13751	73	was	be	VBD
18637	13751	74	a	a	DT
18637	13751	75	sham	sham	NN
18637	13751	76	.	.	.
18637	13752	1	"	"	``
18637	13752	2	*	*	NFP
18637	13752	3	*	*	NFP
18637	13752	4	*	*	NFP
18637	13752	5	each	each	DT
18637	13752	6	State	state	NN
18637	13752	7	,	,	,
18637	13752	8	by	by	IN
18637	13752	9	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	13752	10	of	of	IN
18637	13752	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13752	12	command	command	NN
18637	13752	13	over	over	IN
18637	13752	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13752	15	domiciliaries	domiciliarie	NNS
18637	13752	16	and	and	CC
18637	13752	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13752	18	large	large	JJ
18637	13752	19	interest	interest	NN
18637	13752	20	in	in	IN
18637	13752	21	the	the	DT
18637	13752	22	institution	institution	NN
18637	13752	23	of	of	IN
18637	13752	24	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	13752	25	,	,	,
18637	13752	26	can	can	MD
18637	13752	27	alter	alter	VB
18637	13752	28	within	within	IN
18637	13752	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13752	30	own	own	JJ
18637	13752	31	borders	border	NNS
18637	13752	32	the	the	DT
18637	13752	33	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	13752	34	status	status	NN
18637	13752	35	of	of	IN
18637	13752	36	the	the	DT
18637	13752	37	spouse	spouse	NN
18637	13752	38	domiciled	domicile	VBD
18637	13752	39	there	there	RB
18637	13752	40	,	,	,
18637	13752	41	even	even	RB
18637	13752	42	though	though	IN
18637	13752	43	the	the	DT
18637	13752	44	other	other	JJ
18637	13752	45	spouse	spouse	NN
18637	13752	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	13752	47	absent	absent	JJ
18637	13752	48	.	.	.
18637	13753	1	There	there	EX
18637	13753	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	13753	3	no	no	DT
18637	13753	4	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	13753	5	barrier	barrier	NN
18637	13753	6	if	if	IN
18637	13753	7	the	the	DT
18637	13753	8	form	form	NN
18637	13753	9	and	and	CC
18637	13753	10	nature	nature	NN
18637	13753	11	of	of	IN
18637	13753	12	substituted	substituted	JJ
18637	13753	13	service	service	NN
18637	13753	14	meet	meet	VBP
18637	13753	15	the	the	DT
18637	13753	16	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	13753	17	of	of	IN
18637	13753	18	due	due	JJ
18637	13753	19	process	process	NN
18637	13753	20	.	.	.
18637	13753	21	"	"	''
18637	13754	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	13754	2	,	,	,
18637	13754	3	a	a	DT
18637	13754	4	decree	decree	NN
18637	13754	5	granted	grant	VBN
18637	13754	6	by	by	IN
18637	13754	7	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13754	8	to	to	IN
18637	13754	9	one	one	CD
18637	13754	10	,	,	,
18637	13754	11	who	who	WP
18637	13754	12	,	,	,
18637	13754	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13754	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	13754	15	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	13754	16	,	,	,
18637	13754	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	13754	18	at	at	IN
18637	13754	19	the	the	DT
18637	13754	20	time	time	NN
18637	13754	21	_	_	NNP
18637	13754	22	bona	bona	NN
18637	13754	23	fide	fide	FW
18637	13754	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13754	25	domiciled	domicile	VBD
18637	13754	26	therein	therein	RB
18637	13754	27	,	,	,
18637	13754	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	13754	29	binding	bind	VBG
18637	13754	30	upon	upon	IN
18637	13754	31	the	the	DT
18637	13754	32	courts	court	NNS
18637	13754	33	of	of	IN
18637	13754	34	other	other	JJ
18637	13754	35	States	States	NNP
18637	13754	36	,	,	,
18637	13754	37	including	include	VBG
18637	13754	38	North	North	NNP
18637	13754	39	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	13754	40	in	in	IN
18637	13754	41	which	which	WDT
18637	13754	42	the	the	DT
18637	13754	43	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	13754	44	was	be	VBD
18637	13754	45	performed	perform	VBN
18637	13754	46	and	and	CC
18637	13754	47	where	where	WRB
18637	13754	48	the	the	DT
18637	13754	49	other	other	JJ
18637	13754	50	party	party	NN
18637	13754	51	to	to	IN
18637	13754	52	the	the	DT
18637	13754	53	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	13754	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	13754	55	still	still	RB
18637	13754	56	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	13754	57	when	when	WRB
18637	13754	58	the	the	DT
18637	13754	59	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13754	60	was	be	VBD
18637	13754	61	decreed	decree	VBN
18637	13754	62	.	.	.
18637	13755	1	In	in	IN
18637	13755	2	view	view	NN
18637	13755	3	of	of	IN
18637	13755	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13755	5	assumptions	assumption	NNS
18637	13755	6	,	,	,
18637	13755	7	which	which	WDT
18637	13755	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13755	9	justified	justify	VBD
18637	13755	10	on	on	IN
18637	13755	11	the	the	DT
18637	13755	12	basis	basis	NN
18637	13755	13	of	of	IN
18637	13755	14	an	an	DT
18637	13755	15	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
18637	13755	16	record	record	NN
18637	13755	17	,	,	,
18637	13755	18	the	the	DT
18637	13755	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13755	20	did	do	VBD
18637	13755	21	not	not	RB
18637	13755	22	here	here	RB
18637	13755	23	pass	pass	VB
18637	13755	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	13755	25	the	the	DT
18637	13755	26	question	question	NN
18637	13755	27	whether	whether	IN
18637	13755	28	North	North	NNP
18637	13755	29	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	13755	30	had	have	VBD
18637	13755	31	the	the	DT
18637	13755	32	power	power	NN
18637	13755	33	to	to	TO
18637	13755	34	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	13755	35	full	full	JJ
18637	13755	36	faith	faith	NN
18637	13755	37	and	and	CC
18637	13755	38	credit	credit	NN
18637	13755	39	to	to	IN
18637	13755	40	a	a	DT
18637	13755	41	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13755	42	decree	decree	NN
18637	13755	43	because	because	IN
18637	13755	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13755	45	was	be	VBD
18637	13755	46	based	base	VBN
18637	13755	47	on	on	IN
18637	13755	48	residence	residence	NN
18637	13755	49	rather	rather	RB
18637	13755	50	than	than	IN
18637	13755	51	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13755	52	;	;	:
18637	13755	53	or	or	CC
18637	13755	54	because	because	IN
18637	13755	55	,	,	,
18637	13755	56	contrary	contrary	RB
18637	13755	57	to	to	IN
18637	13755	58	the	the	DT
18637	13755	59	findings	finding	NNS
18637	13755	60	of	of	IN
18637	13755	61	the	the	DT
18637	13755	62	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13755	63	court	court	NN
18637	13755	64	,	,	,
18637	13755	65	North	North	NNP
18637	13755	66	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	13755	67	found	find	VBD
18637	13755	68	that	that	IN
18637	13755	69	no	no	DT
18637	13755	70	_	_	NNP
18637	13755	71	bona	bona	FW
18637	13755	72	fide	fide	FW
18637	13755	73	_	_	NNP
18637	13755	74	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13755	75	had	have	VBD
18637	13755	76	been	be	VBN
18637	13755	77	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	13755	78	in	in	IN
18637	13755	79	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13755	80	.	.	.
18637	13756	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13756	2	57	57	CD
18637	13756	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13756	4	Presaging	presage	VBG
18637	13756	5	what	what	WP
18637	13756	6	ruling	rule	VBG
18637	13756	7	the	the	DT
18637	13756	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13756	9	would	would	MD
18637	13756	10	make	make	VB
18637	13756	11	when	when	WRB
18637	13756	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13756	13	did	do	VBD
18637	13756	14	get	get	VB
18637	13756	15	around	around	RB
18637	13756	16	to	to	IN
18637	13756	17	passing	pass	VBG
18637	13756	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	13756	19	the	the	DT
18637	13756	20	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13756	21	question	question	NN
18637	13756	22	,	,	,
18637	13756	23	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13756	24	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	13756	25	,	,	,
18637	13756	26	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	13756	27	in	in	IN
18637	13756	28	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	13756	29	I	I	NNP
18637	13756	30	,	,	,
18637	13756	31	protested	protest	VBD
18637	13756	32	that	that	IN
18637	13756	33	"	"	``
18637	13756	34	this	this	DT
18637	13756	35	decision	decision	NN
18637	13756	36	repeals	repeal	VBZ
18637	13756	37	the	the	DT
18637	13756	38	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13756	39	laws	law	NNS
18637	13756	40	of	of	IN
18637	13756	41	all	all	PDT
18637	13756	42	the	the	DT
18637	13756	43	States	States	NNPS
18637	13756	44	and	and	CC
18637	13756	45	substitutes	substitute	VBZ
18637	13756	46	the	the	DT
18637	13756	47	law	law	NN
18637	13756	48	of	of	IN
18637	13756	49	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13756	50	as	as	IN
18637	13756	51	to	to	IN
18637	13756	52	all	all	DT
18637	13756	53	marriages	marriage	NNS
18637	13756	54	one	one	CD
18637	13756	55	of	of	IN
18637	13756	56	the	the	DT
18637	13756	57	parties	party	NNS
18637	13756	58	to	to	TO
18637	13756	59	which	which	WDT
18637	13756	60	can	can	MD
18637	13756	61	afford	afford	VB
18637	13756	62	a	a	DT
18637	13756	63	short	short	JJ
18637	13756	64	trip	trip	NN
18637	13756	65	there	there	RB
18637	13756	66	.	.	.
18637	13757	1	*	*	NFP
18637	13757	2	*	*	NFP
18637	13757	3	*	*	NFP
18637	13757	4	While	while	IN
18637	13757	5	a	a	DT
18637	13757	6	State	state	NN
18637	13757	7	can	can	MD
18637	13757	8	no	no	RB
18637	13757	9	doubt	doubt	RB
18637	13757	10	set	set	VB
18637	13757	11	up	up	RP
18637	13757	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13757	13	own	own	JJ
18637	13757	14	standards	standard	NNS
18637	13757	15	of	of	IN
18637	13757	16	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13757	17	as	as	IN
18637	13757	18	to	to	IN
18637	13757	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13757	20	internal	internal	JJ
18637	13757	21	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	13757	22	,	,	,
18637	13757	23	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13757	24	do	do	VBP
18637	13757	25	not	not	RB
18637	13757	26	think	think	VB
18637	13757	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13757	28	can	can	MD
18637	13757	29	require	require	VB
18637	13757	30	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13757	31	to	to	TO
18637	13757	32	accept	accept	VB
18637	13757	33	and	and	CC
18637	13757	34	in	in	IN
18637	13757	35	the	the	DT
18637	13757	36	name	name	NN
18637	13757	37	of	of	IN
18637	13757	38	the	the	DT
18637	13757	39	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13757	40	impose	impose	VB
18637	13757	41	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13757	42	on	on	IN
18637	13757	43	other	other	JJ
18637	13757	44	States	state	NNS
18637	13757	45	.	.	.
18637	13758	1	*	*	NFP
18637	13758	2	*	*	NFP
18637	13758	3	*	*	NFP
18637	13758	4	The	the	DT
18637	13758	5	effect	effect	NN
18637	13758	6	of	of	IN
18637	13758	7	the	the	DT
18637	13758	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13758	9	's	's	POS
18637	13758	10	decision	decision	NN
18637	13758	11	today	today	NN
18637	13758	12	--	--	:
18637	13758	13	that	that	IN
18637	13758	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13758	15	must	must	MD
18637	13758	16	give	give	VB
18637	13758	17	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	JJ
18637	13758	18	effect	effect	NN
18637	13758	19	to	to	IN
18637	13758	20	any	any	DT
18637	13758	21	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13758	22	that	that	WDT
18637	13758	23	a	a	DT
18637	13758	24	state	state	NN
18637	13758	25	honors	honor	NNS
18637	13758	26	for	for	IN
18637	13758	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13758	28	own	own	JJ
18637	13758	29	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	13758	30	--	--	:
18637	13758	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	13758	32	to	to	TO
18637	13758	33	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	13758	34	this	this	DT
18637	13758	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13758	36	of	of	IN
18637	13758	37	control	control	NN
18637	13758	38	over	over	IN
18637	13758	39	the	the	DT
18637	13758	40	operation	operation	NN
18637	13758	41	of	of	IN
18637	13758	42	the	the	DT
18637	13758	43	full	full	JJ
18637	13758	44	faith	faith	NN
18637	13758	45	and	and	CC
18637	13758	46	credit	credit	NN
18637	13758	47	and	and	CC
18637	13758	48	the	the	DT
18637	13758	49	due	due	JJ
18637	13758	50	process	process	NN
18637	13758	51	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	13758	52	of	of	IN
18637	13758	53	the	the	DT
18637	13758	54	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	13758	55	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13758	56	in	in	IN
18637	13758	57	cases	case	NNS
18637	13758	58	of	of	IN
18637	13758	59	contested	contested	JJ
18637	13758	60	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13758	61	and	and	CC
18637	13758	62	to	to	TO
18637	13758	63	vest	vest	VB
18637	13758	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13758	65	in	in	IN
18637	13758	66	the	the	DT
18637	13758	67	first	first	JJ
18637	13758	68	State	State	NNP
18637	13758	69	to	to	TO
18637	13758	70	pass	pass	VB
18637	13758	71	on	on	RP
18637	13758	72	the	the	DT
18637	13758	73	facts	fact	NNS
18637	13758	74	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	13758	75	to	to	IN
18637	13758	76	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13758	77	.	.	.
18637	13759	1	"	"	``
18637	13759	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13759	3	58	58	CD
18637	13759	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13759	5	Notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	13759	6	that	that	IN
18637	13759	7	one	one	CD
18637	13759	8	of	of	IN
18637	13759	9	the	the	DT
18637	13759	10	deserted	desert	VBN
18637	13759	11	spouses	spouse	NNS
18637	13759	12	had	have	VBD
18637	13759	13	died	die	VBN
18637	13759	14	since	since	IN
18637	13759	15	the	the	DT
18637	13759	16	initial	initial	JJ
18637	13759	17	trial	trial	NN
18637	13759	18	and	and	CC
18637	13759	19	that	that	IN
18637	13759	20	another	another	DT
18637	13759	21	had	have	VBD
18637	13759	22	remarried	remarry	VBN
18637	13759	23	,	,	,
18637	13759	24	North	North	NNP
18637	13759	25	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	13759	26	,	,	,
18637	13759	27	without	without	IN
18637	13759	28	calling	call	VBG
18637	13759	29	into	into	IN
18637	13759	30	question	question	NN
18637	13759	31	the	the	DT
18637	13759	32	status	status	NN
18637	13759	33	of	of	IN
18637	13759	34	the	the	DT
18637	13759	35	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13759	36	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	13759	37	began	begin	VBD
18637	13759	38	a	a	DT
18637	13759	39	new	new	JJ
18637	13759	40	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	13759	41	for	for	IN
18637	13759	42	bigamy	bigamy	NN
18637	13759	43	;	;	:
18637	13759	44	and	and	CC
18637	13759	45	when	when	WRB
18637	13759	46	the	the	DT
18637	13759	47	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	13759	48	appealed	appeal	VBD
18637	13759	49	the	the	DT
18637	13759	50	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	13759	51	resulting	result	VBG
18637	13759	52	therefrom	therefrom	NN
18637	13759	53	,	,	,
18637	13759	54	the	the	DT
18637	13759	55	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13759	56	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13759	57	,	,	,
18637	13759	58	in	in	IN
18637	13759	59	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	13759	60	II,[59	II,[59	NNP
18637	13759	61	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13759	62	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	13759	63	the	the	DT
18637	13759	64	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	13759	65	of	of	IN
18637	13759	66	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	13759	67	as	as	IN
18637	13759	68	not	not	RB
18637	13759	69	denying	deny	VBG
18637	13759	70	full	full	JJ
18637	13759	71	faith	faith	NN
18637	13759	72	and	and	CC
18637	13759	73	credit	credit	NN
18637	13759	74	to	to	IN
18637	13759	75	the	the	DT
18637	13759	76	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13759	77	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13759	78	decree	decree	NN
18637	13759	79	.	.	.
18637	13760	1	Reiterating	reiterate	VBG
18637	13760	2	the	the	DT
18637	13760	3	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	13760	4	that	that	DT
18637	13760	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13760	6	to	to	TO
18637	13760	7	grant	grant	VB
18637	13760	8	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13760	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	13760	10	founded	found	VBN
18637	13760	11	on	on	IN
18637	13760	12	domicile,[60	domicile,[60	NNP
18637	13760	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13760	14	a	a	DT
18637	13760	15	majority	majority	NN
18637	13760	16	of	of	IN
18637	13760	17	the	the	DT
18637	13760	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13760	19	held	hold	VBD
18637	13760	20	that	that	IN
18637	13760	21	a	a	DT
18637	13760	22	decree	decree	NN
18637	13760	23	of	of	IN
18637	13760	24	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13760	25	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13760	26	in	in	IN
18637	13760	27	one	one	CD
18637	13760	28	State	state	NN
18637	13760	29	may	may	MD
18637	13760	30	be	be	VB
18637	13760	31	collaterally	collaterally	RB
18637	13760	32	impeached	impeach	VBN
18637	13760	33	in	in	IN
18637	13760	34	another	another	DT
18637	13760	35	by	by	IN
18637	13760	36	proof	proof	NN
18637	13760	37	that	that	IN
18637	13760	38	the	the	DT
18637	13760	39	court	court	NN
18637	13760	40	which	which	WDT
18637	13760	41	rendered	render	VBD
18637	13760	42	the	the	DT
18637	13760	43	decree	decree	NN
18637	13760	44	lacked	lack	VBN
18637	13760	45	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13760	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13760	47	the	the	DT
18637	13760	48	parties	party	NNS
18637	13760	49	not	not	RB
18637	13760	50	having	have	VBG
18637	13760	51	been	be	VBN
18637	13760	52	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	13760	53	therein	therein	RB
18637	13760	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13760	55	,	,	,
18637	13760	56	even	even	RB
18637	13760	57	though	though	IN
18637	13760	58	the	the	DT
18637	13760	59	record	record	NN
18637	13760	60	of	of	IN
18637	13760	61	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13760	62	in	in	IN
18637	13760	63	that	that	DT
18637	13760	64	court	court	NN
18637	13760	65	purports	purport	VBZ
18637	13760	66	to	to	TO
18637	13760	67	show	show	VB
18637	13760	68	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13760	69	.	.	.
18637	13761	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13761	2	61	61	CD
18637	13761	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13761	4	CASES	case	NNS
18637	13761	5	INVOLVING	involve	VBG
18637	13761	6	CLAIMS	claim	NNS
18637	13761	7	FOR	for	IN
18637	13761	8	ALIMONY	ALIMONY	NNP
18637	13761	9	OR	or	CC
18637	13761	10	PROPERTY	property	NN
18637	13761	11	ARISING	arise	VBG
18637	13761	12	IN	in	IN
18637	13761	13	FORUM	forum	NN
18637	13761	14	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	13761	15	In	in	IN
18637	13761	16	Esenwein	Esenwein	NNP
18637	13761	17	_	_	NNP
18637	13761	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	13761	19	_	_	NNP
18637	13761	20	Commonwealth,[62	Commonwealth,[62	NNP
18637	13761	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13761	22	decided	decide	VBD
18637	13761	23	on	on	IN
18637	13761	24	the	the	DT
18637	13761	25	same	same	JJ
18637	13761	26	day	day	NN
18637	13761	27	as	as	IN
18637	13761	28	the	the	DT
18637	13761	29	second	second	JJ
18637	13761	30	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	13761	31	Case	Case	NNP
18637	13761	32	,	,	,
18637	13761	33	the	the	DT
18637	13761	34	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13761	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13761	36	also	also	RB
18637	13761	37	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	13761	38	a	a	DT
18637	13761	39	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	13761	40	court	court	NN
18637	13761	41	in	in	IN
18637	13761	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13761	43	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	13761	44	to	to	TO
18637	13761	45	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	13761	46	an	an	DT
18637	13761	47	_	_	NNP
18637	13761	48	ex	ex	NN
18637	13761	49	parte	parte	NN
18637	13761	50	_	_	NNP
18637	13761	51	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13761	52	decree	decree	NN
18637	13761	53	on	on	IN
18637	13761	54	the	the	DT
18637	13761	55	ground	ground	NN
18637	13761	56	that	that	IN
18637	13761	57	the	the	DT
18637	13761	58	husband	husband	NN
18637	13761	59	who	who	WP
18637	13761	60	obtained	obtain	VBD
18637	13761	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13761	62	never	never	RB
18637	13761	63	acquired	acquire	VBD
18637	13761	64	a	a	DT
18637	13761	65	_	_	NNP
18637	13761	66	bona	bona	NN
18637	13761	67	fide	fide	FW
18637	13761	68	_	_	NNP
18637	13761	69	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13761	70	in	in	IN
18637	13761	71	the	the	DT
18637	13761	72	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13761	73	State	state	NN
18637	13761	74	.	.	.
18637	13762	1	In	in	IN
18637	13762	2	this	this	DT
18637	13762	3	instance	instance	NN
18637	13762	4	,	,	,
18637	13762	5	the	the	DT
18637	13762	6	husband	husband	NN
18637	13762	7	and	and	CC
18637	13762	8	wife	wife	NN
18637	13762	9	had	have	VBD
18637	13762	10	separated	separate	VBN
18637	13762	11	in	in	IN
18637	13762	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	13762	13	,	,	,
18637	13762	14	where	where	WRB
18637	13762	15	the	the	DT
18637	13762	16	wife	wife	NN
18637	13762	17	was	be	VBD
18637	13762	18	granted	grant	VBN
18637	13762	19	a	a	DT
18637	13762	20	support	support	NN
18637	13762	21	order	order	NN
18637	13762	22	;	;	:
18637	13762	23	and	and	CC
18637	13762	24	after	after	IN
18637	13762	25	two	two	CD
18637	13762	26	unsuccessful	unsuccessful	JJ
18637	13762	27	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	13762	28	to	to	TO
18637	13762	29	win	win	VB
18637	13762	30	a	a	DT
18637	13762	31	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13762	32	in	in	IN
18637	13762	33	that	that	DT
18637	13762	34	State	State	NNP
18637	13762	35	,	,	,
18637	13762	36	the	the	DT
18637	13762	37	husband	husband	NN
18637	13762	38	departed	depart	VBD
18637	13762	39	for	for	IN
18637	13762	40	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13762	41	.	.	.
18637	13763	1	Upon	upon	IN
18637	13763	2	the	the	DT
18637	13763	3	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	13763	4	of	of	IN
18637	13763	5	a	a	DT
18637	13763	6	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13763	7	decree	decree	NN
18637	13763	8	,	,	,
18637	13763	9	the	the	DT
18637	13763	10	husband	husband	NN
18637	13763	11	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	13763	12	established	establish	VBD
18637	13763	13	a	a	DT
18637	13763	14	residence	residence	NN
18637	13763	15	in	in	IN
18637	13763	16	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	13763	17	,	,	,
18637	13763	18	and	and	CC
18637	13763	19	filed	file	VBD
18637	13763	20	an	an	DT
18637	13763	21	action	action	NN
18637	13763	22	in	in	IN
18637	13763	23	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	13763	24	for	for	IN
18637	13763	25	total	total	JJ
18637	13763	26	relief	relief	NN
18637	13763	27	from	from	IN
18637	13763	28	the	the	DT
18637	13763	29	support	support	NN
18637	13763	30	order	order	NN
18637	13763	31	.	.	.
18637	13764	1	In	in	IN
18637	13764	2	a	a	DT
18637	13764	3	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	13764	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	13764	5	,	,	,
18637	13764	6	in	in	IN
18637	13764	7	which	which	WDT
18637	13764	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13764	9	was	be	VBD
18637	13764	10	joined	join	VBN
18637	13764	11	by	by	IN
18637	13764	12	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	13764	13	Black	Black	NNP
18637	13764	14	and	and	CC
18637	13764	15	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	13764	16	,	,	,
18637	13764	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13764	18	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	13764	19	stressed	stress	VBD
18637	13764	20	the	the	DT
18637	13764	21	"	"	``
18637	13764	22	basic	basic	JJ
18637	13764	23	difference	difference	NN
18637	13764	24	between	between	IN
18637	13764	25	the	the	DT
18637	13764	26	problem	problem	NN
18637	13764	27	of	of	IN
18637	13764	28	marital	marital	JJ
18637	13764	29	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	13764	30	and	and	CC
18637	13764	31	the	the	DT
18637	13764	32	problem	problem	NN
18637	13764	33	of	of	IN
18637	13764	34	support	support	NN
18637	13764	35	,	,	,
18637	13764	36	"	"	''
18637	13764	37	and	and	CC
18637	13764	38	stated	state	VBD
18637	13764	39	that	that	IN
18637	13764	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13764	41	was	be	VBD
18637	13764	42	"	"	``
18637	13764	43	not	not	RB
18637	13764	44	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	13764	45	that	that	IN
18637	13764	46	the	the	DT
18637	13764	47	spouse	spouse	NN
18637	13764	48	who	who	WP
18637	13764	49	obtained	obtain	VBD
18637	13764	50	the	the	DT
18637	13764	51	decree	decree	NN
18637	13764	52	can	can	MD
18637	13764	53	defeat	defeat	VB
18637	13764	54	an	an	DT
18637	13764	55	action	action	NN
18637	13764	56	for	for	IN
18637	13764	57	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	13764	58	or	or	CC
18637	13764	59	support	support	NN
18637	13764	60	in	in	IN
18637	13764	61	another	another	DT
18637	13764	62	State	State	NNP
18637	13764	63	by	by	IN
18637	13764	64	showing	show	VBG
18637	13764	65	that	that	IN
18637	13764	66	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13764	67	was	be	VBD
18637	13764	68	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	13764	69	in	in	IN
18637	13764	70	the	the	DT
18637	13764	71	State	State	NNP
18637	13764	72	which	which	WDT
18637	13764	73	awarded	award	VBD
18637	13764	74	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13764	75	the	the	DT
18637	13764	76	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13764	77	decree	decree	NN
18637	13764	78	,	,	,
18637	13764	79	"	"	''
18637	13764	80	unless	unless	IN
18637	13764	81	the	the	DT
18637	13764	82	other	other	JJ
18637	13764	83	spouse	spouse	NN
18637	13764	84	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	13764	85	or	or	CC
18637	13764	86	was	be	VBD
18637	13764	87	personally	personally	RB
18637	13764	88	served	serve	VBN
18637	13764	89	.	.	.
18637	13765	1	"	"	``
18637	13765	2	The	the	DT
18637	13765	3	State	state	NN
18637	13765	4	where	where	WRB
18637	13765	5	the	the	DT
18637	13765	6	deserted	desert	VBN
18637	13765	7	wife	wife	NN
18637	13765	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	13765	9	domiciled	domiciled	JJ
18637	13765	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	13765	11	a	a	DT
18637	13765	12	deep	deep	JJ
18637	13765	13	concern	concern	NN
18637	13765	14	in	in	IN
18637	13765	15	the	the	DT
18637	13765	16	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	13765	17	of	of	IN
18637	13765	18	the	the	DT
18637	13765	19	family	family	NN
18637	13765	20	deserted	desert	VBN
18637	13765	21	by	by	IN
18637	13765	22	the	the	DT
18637	13765	23	head	head	NN
18637	13765	24	of	of	IN
18637	13765	25	the	the	DT
18637	13765	26	household	household	NN
18637	13765	27	.	.	.
18637	13766	1	If	if	IN
18637	13766	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13766	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	13766	4	required	require	VBN
18637	13766	5	to	to	TO
18637	13766	6	support	support	VB
18637	13766	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13766	8	former	former	JJ
18637	13766	9	wife	wife	NN
18637	13766	10	,	,	,
18637	13766	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13766	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	13766	13	not	not	RB
18637	13766	14	made	make	VBN
18637	13766	15	a	a	DT
18637	13766	16	bigamist	bigamist	NN
18637	13766	17	and	and	CC
18637	13766	18	the	the	DT
18637	13766	19	offspring	offspring	NN
18637	13766	20	of	of	IN
18637	13766	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13766	22	second	second	JJ
18637	13766	23	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	13766	24	are	be	VBP
18637	13766	25	not	not	RB
18637	13766	26	bastardized	bastardize	VBN
18637	13766	27	.	.	.
18637	13766	28	"	"	''
18637	13767	1	Or	or	CC
18637	13767	2	as	as	RB
18637	13767	3	succinctly	succinctly	RB
18637	13767	4	stated	state	VBN
18637	13767	5	by	by	IN
18637	13767	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13767	7	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	13767	8	,	,	,
18637	13767	9	"	"	''
18637	13767	10	the	the	DT
18637	13767	11	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	13767	12	foundation	foundation	NNP
18637	13767	13	for	for	IN
18637	13767	14	a	a	DT
18637	13767	15	decree	decree	NN
18637	13767	16	in	in	IN
18637	13767	17	one	one	CD
18637	13767	18	State	state	NN
18637	13767	19	capable	capable	JJ
18637	13767	20	of	of	IN
18637	13767	21	foreclosing	foreclose	VBG
18637	13767	22	an	an	DT
18637	13767	23	action	action	NN
18637	13767	24	for	for	IN
18637	13767	25	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	13767	26	or	or	CC
18637	13767	27	support	support	NN
18637	13767	28	in	in	IN
18637	13767	29	another	another	DT
18637	13767	30	may	may	MD
18637	13767	31	be	be	VB
18637	13767	32	different	different	JJ
18637	13767	33	from	from	IN
18637	13767	34	that	that	DT
18637	13767	35	required	require	VBN
18637	13767	36	to	to	TO
18637	13767	37	alter	alter	VB
18637	13767	38	the	the	DT
18637	13767	39	marital	marital	JJ
18637	13767	40	status	status	NN
18637	13767	41	with	with	IN
18637	13767	42	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	JJ
18637	13767	43	effect	effect	NN
18637	13767	44	.	.	.
18637	13768	1	"	"	``
18637	13768	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13768	3	63	63	CD
18637	13768	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13768	5	Three	three	CD
18637	13768	6	years	year	NNS
18637	13768	7	later	later	RB
18637	13768	8	,	,	,
18637	13768	9	but	but	CC
18637	13768	10	on	on	IN
18637	13768	11	this	this	DT
18637	13768	12	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	13768	13	as	as	IN
18637	13768	14	spokesman	spokesman	NN
18637	13768	15	for	for	IN
18637	13768	16	a	a	DT
18637	13768	17	majority	majority	NN
18637	13768	18	of	of	IN
18637	13768	19	the	the	DT
18637	13768	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13768	21	,	,	,
18637	13768	22	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13768	23	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	13768	24	reiterated	reiterate	VBD
18637	13768	25	these	these	DT
18637	13768	26	views	view	NNS
18637	13768	27	in	in	IN
18637	13768	28	the	the	DT
18637	13768	29	case	case	NN
18637	13768	30	of	of	IN
18637	13768	31	Estin	Estin	NNP
18637	13768	32	_	_	NNP
18637	13768	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	13768	34	_	_	NNP
18637	13768	35	Estin	Estin	NNP
18637	13768	36	.	.	.
18637	13769	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13769	2	64	64	CD
18637	13769	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13769	4	Even	even	RB
18637	13769	5	though	though	IN
18637	13769	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13769	7	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBD
18637	13769	8	the	the	DT
18637	13769	9	validity	validity	NN
18637	13769	10	of	of	IN
18637	13769	11	an	an	DT
18637	13769	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13769	13	ex	ex	NN
18637	13769	14	parte	parte	NN
18637	13769	15	_	_	NNP
18637	13769	16	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13769	17	decree	decree	NN
18637	13769	18	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13769	19	by	by	IN
18637	13769	20	a	a	DT
18637	13769	21	husband	husband	NN
18637	13769	22	,	,	,
18637	13769	23	New	New	NNP
18637	13769	24	York	York	NNP
18637	13769	25	was	be	VBD
18637	13769	26	held	hold	VBN
18637	13769	27	not	not	RB
18637	13769	28	to	to	TO
18637	13769	29	have	have	VB
18637	13769	30	denied	deny	VBN
18637	13769	31	full	full	JJ
18637	13769	32	faith	faith	NN
18637	13769	33	and	and	CC
18637	13769	34	credit	credit	NN
18637	13769	35	to	to	IN
18637	13769	36	said	say	VBD
18637	13769	37	decree	decree	NN
18637	13769	38	when	when	WRB
18637	13769	39	,	,	,
18637	13769	40	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	13769	41	thereto	thereto	NNP
18637	13769	42	,	,	,
18637	13769	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13769	44	granted	grant	VBD
18637	13769	45	the	the	DT
18637	13769	46	wife	wife	NN
18637	13769	47	a	a	DT
18637	13769	48	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13769	49	for	for	IN
18637	13769	50	arrears	arrear	NNS
18637	13769	51	in	in	IN
18637	13769	52	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	13769	53	founded	found	VBN
18637	13769	54	upon	upon	IN
18637	13769	55	a	a	DT
18637	13769	56	decree	decree	NN
18637	13769	57	of	of	IN
18637	13769	58	separation	separation	NN
18637	13769	59	previously	previously	RB
18637	13769	60	awarded	award	VBD
18637	13769	61	to	to	IN
18637	13769	62	her	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13769	63	when	when	WRB
18637	13769	64	both	both	CC
18637	13769	65	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13769	66	and	and	CC
18637	13769	67	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13769	68	husband	husband	NN
18637	13769	69	were	be	VBD
18637	13769	70	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	13769	71	in	in	IN
18637	13769	72	New	New	NNP
18637	13769	73	York	York	NNP
18637	13769	74	.	.	.
18637	13770	1	The	the	DT
18637	13770	2	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13770	3	decree	decree	NN
18637	13770	4	,	,	,
18637	13770	5	issued	issue	VBN
18637	13770	6	to	to	IN
18637	13770	7	the	the	DT
18637	13770	8	husband	husband	NN
18637	13770	9	after	after	IN
18637	13770	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13770	11	had	have	VBD
18637	13770	12	resided	reside	VBN
18637	13770	13	there	there	RB
18637	13770	14	a	a	DT
18637	13770	15	year	year	NN
18637	13770	16	and	and	CC
18637	13770	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	13770	18	constructive	constructive	JJ
18637	13770	19	notice	notice	NN
18637	13770	20	to	to	IN
18637	13770	21	the	the	DT
18637	13770	22	wife	wife	NN
18637	13770	23	in	in	IN
18637	13770	24	New	New	NNP
18637	13770	25	York	York	NNP
18637	13770	26	who	who	WP
18637	13770	27	entered	enter	VBD
18637	13770	28	no	no	DT
18637	13770	29	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	13770	30	,	,	,
18637	13770	31	was	be	VBD
18637	13770	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	13770	33	to	to	TO
18637	13770	34	be	be	VB
18637	13770	35	effective	effective	JJ
18637	13770	36	only	only	RB
18637	13770	37	to	to	TO
18637	13770	38	change	change	VB
18637	13770	39	the	the	DT
18637	13770	40	marital	marital	JJ
18637	13770	41	status	status	NN
18637	13770	42	of	of	IN
18637	13770	43	both	both	DT
18637	13770	44	parties	party	NNS
18637	13770	45	in	in	IN
18637	13770	46	all	all	DT
18637	13770	47	States	state	NNS
18637	13770	48	of	of	IN
18637	13770	49	the	the	DT
18637	13770	50	Union	Union	NNP
18637	13770	51	but	but	CC
18637	13770	52	ineffective	ineffective	JJ
18637	13770	53	on	on	IN
18637	13770	54	the	the	DT
18637	13770	55	issue	issue	NN
18637	13770	56	of	of	IN
18637	13770	57	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	13770	58	.	.	.
18637	13771	1	Divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13771	2	,	,	,
18637	13771	3	in	in	IN
18637	13771	4	other	other	JJ
18637	13771	5	words	word	NNS
18637	13771	6	,	,	,
18637	13771	7	was	be	VBD
18637	13771	8	viewed	view	VBN
18637	13771	9	as	as	IN
18637	13771	10	being	be	VBG
18637	13771	11	divisible	divisible	JJ
18637	13771	12	;	;	:
18637	13771	13	and	and	CC
18637	13771	14	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13771	15	,	,	,
18637	13771	16	in	in	IN
18637	13771	17	the	the	DT
18637	13771	18	absence	absence	NN
18637	13771	19	of	of	IN
18637	13771	20	acquiring	acquire	VBG
18637	13771	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13771	22	over	over	IN
18637	13771	23	the	the	DT
18637	13771	24	wife	wife	NN
18637	13771	25	,	,	,
18637	13771	26	was	be	VBD
18637	13771	27	held	hold	VBN
18637	13771	28	incapable	incapable	JJ
18637	13771	29	of	of	IN
18637	13771	30	adjudicating	adjudicate	VBG
18637	13771	31	the	the	DT
18637	13771	32	rights	right	NNS
18637	13771	33	of	of	IN
18637	13771	34	the	the	DT
18637	13771	35	wife	wife	NN
18637	13771	36	in	in	IN
18637	13771	37	the	the	DT
18637	13771	38	prior	prior	JJ
18637	13771	39	New	New	NNP
18637	13771	40	York	York	NNP
18637	13771	41	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13771	42	awarding	award	VBG
18637	13771	43	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13771	44	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	13771	45	.	.	.
18637	13772	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	13772	2	,	,	,
18637	13772	3	the	the	DT
18637	13772	4	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13772	5	decree	decree	NN
18637	13772	6	could	could	MD
18637	13772	7	not	not	RB
18637	13772	8	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	13772	9	New	New	NNP
18637	13772	10	York	York	NNP
18637	13772	11	from	from	IN
18637	13772	12	applying	apply	VBG
18637	13772	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13772	14	own	own	JJ
18637	13772	15	rule	rule	NN
18637	13772	16	of	of	IN
18637	13772	17	law	law	NN
18637	13772	18	which	which	WDT
18637	13772	19	,	,	,
18637	13772	20	unlike	unlike	IN
18637	13772	21	that	that	DT
18637	13772	22	of	of	IN
18637	13772	23	Pennsylvania,[65	Pennsylvania,[65	NNP
18637	13772	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13772	25	does	do	VBZ
18637	13772	26	permit	permit	VB
18637	13772	27	a	a	DT
18637	13772	28	support	support	NN
18637	13772	29	order	order	NN
18637	13772	30	to	to	TO
18637	13772	31	survive	survive	VB
18637	13772	32	a	a	DT
18637	13772	33	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13772	34	decree	decree	NN
18637	13772	35	.	.	.
18637	13773	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13773	2	66	66	CD
18637	13773	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13773	4	Such	such	PDT
18637	13773	5	a	a	DT
18637	13773	6	result	result	NN
18637	13773	7	was	be	VBD
18637	13773	8	justified	justify	VBN
18637	13773	9	as	as	IN
18637	13773	10	accommodating	accommodate	VBG
18637	13773	11	the	the	DT
18637	13773	12	interests	interest	NNS
18637	13773	13	of	of	IN
18637	13773	14	both	both	DT
18637	13773	15	New	New	NNP
18637	13773	16	York	York	NNP
18637	13773	17	and	and	CC
18637	13773	18	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13773	19	in	in	IN
18637	13773	20	the	the	DT
18637	13773	21	broken	broken	JJ
18637	13773	22	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	13773	23	by	by	IN
18637	13773	24	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	13773	25	each	each	DT
18637	13773	26	State	state	NN
18637	13773	27	to	to	IN
18637	13773	28	matters	matter	NNS
18637	13773	29	of	of	IN
18637	13773	30	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13773	31	dominant	dominant	JJ
18637	13773	32	concern	concern	NN
18637	13773	33	,	,	,
18637	13773	34	the	the	DT
18637	13773	35	concern	concern	NN
18637	13773	36	of	of	IN
18637	13773	37	New	New	NNP
18637	13773	38	York	York	NNP
18637	13773	39	being	be	VBG
18637	13773	40	that	that	DT
18637	13773	41	of	of	IN
18637	13773	42	protecting	protect	VBG
18637	13773	43	the	the	DT
18637	13773	44	abandoned	abandon	VBN
18637	13773	45	wife	wife	NN
18637	13773	46	against	against	IN
18637	13773	47	impoverishment	impoverishment	NN
18637	13773	48	.	.	.
18637	13774	1	RECENT	recent	JJ
18637	13774	2	CASES	cases	NN
18637	13774	3	Fears	fear	NNS
18637	13774	4	registered	register	VBN
18637	13774	5	by	by	IN
18637	13774	6	the	the	DT
18637	13774	7	dissenters	dissenter	NNS
18637	13774	8	in	in	IN
18637	13774	9	the	the	DT
18637	13774	10	second	second	JJ
18637	13774	11	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	13774	12	Case	Case	NNP
18637	13774	13	that	that	IN
18637	13774	14	the	the	DT
18637	13774	15	stability	stability	NN
18637	13774	16	of	of	IN
18637	13774	17	all	all	DT
18637	13774	18	divorces	divorce	NNS
18637	13774	19	might	may	MD
18637	13774	20	be	be	VB
18637	13774	21	undermined	undermine	VBN
18637	13774	22	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	13774	23	and	and	CC
18637	13774	24	that	that	IN
18637	13774	25	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	13774	26	the	the	DT
18637	13774	27	court	court	NN
18637	13774	28	of	of	IN
18637	13774	29	each	each	DT
18637	13774	30	forum	forum	NN
18637	13774	31	State	State	NNP
18637	13774	32	,	,	,
18637	13774	33	by	by	IN
18637	13774	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13774	35	own	own	JJ
18637	13774	36	independent	independent	JJ
18637	13774	37	determination	determination	NN
18637	13774	38	of	of	IN
18637	13774	39	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13774	40	,	,	,
18637	13774	41	might	may	MD
18637	13774	42	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	13774	43	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13774	44	of	of	IN
18637	13774	45	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13774	46	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	13774	47	were	be	VBD
18637	13774	48	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	13774	49	set	set	VBN
18637	13774	50	at	at	IN
18637	13774	51	rest	rest	NN
18637	13774	52	by	by	IN
18637	13774	53	the	the	DT
18637	13774	54	holding	holding	NN
18637	13774	55	in	in	IN
18637	13774	56	Sherrer	Sherrer	NNP
18637	13774	57	_	_	NNP
18637	13774	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	13774	59	_	_	NNP
18637	13774	60	Sherrer,[67	sherrer,[67	XX
18637	13774	61	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13774	62	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	13774	63	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13774	64	,	,	,
18637	13774	65	a	a	DT
18637	13774	66	state	state	NN
18637	13774	67	of	of	IN
18637	13774	68	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	13774	69	origin	origin	NN
18637	13774	70	,	,	,
18637	13774	71	was	be	VBD
18637	13774	72	required	require	VBN
18637	13774	73	to	to	TO
18637	13774	74	accord	accord	VB
18637	13774	75	full	full	JJ
18637	13774	76	faith	faith	NN
18637	13774	77	and	and	CC
18637	13774	78	credit	credit	NN
18637	13774	79	to	to	IN
18637	13774	80	a	a	DT
18637	13774	81	90-day	90-day	CD
18637	13774	82	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13774	83	decree	decree	NN
18637	13774	84	which	which	WDT
18637	13774	85	had	have	VBD
18637	13774	86	been	be	VBN
18637	13774	87	contested	contest	VBN
18637	13774	88	by	by	IN
18637	13774	89	the	the	DT
18637	13774	90	husband	husband	NN
18637	13774	91	.	.	.
18637	13775	1	The	the	DT
18637	13775	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13775	3	,	,	,
18637	13775	4	upon	upon	IN
18637	13775	5	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	13775	6	notice	notice	NN
18637	13775	7	by	by	IN
18637	13775	8	mail	mail	NN
18637	13775	9	,	,	,
18637	13775	10	retained	retain	VBD
18637	13775	11	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13775	12	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	13775	13	who	who	WP
18637	13775	14	entered	enter	VBD
18637	13775	15	a	a	DT
18637	13775	16	general	general	JJ
18637	13775	17	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	13775	18	and	and	CC
18637	13775	19	denied	deny	VBD
18637	13775	20	all	all	DT
18637	13775	21	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	13775	22	in	in	IN
18637	13775	23	the	the	DT
18637	13775	24	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	13775	25	,	,	,
18637	13775	26	including	include	VBG
18637	13775	27	the	the	DT
18637	13775	28	wife	wife	NN
18637	13775	29	's	's	POS
18637	13775	30	residence	residence	NN
18637	13775	31	.	.	.
18637	13776	1	At	at	IN
18637	13776	2	the	the	DT
18637	13776	3	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	13776	4	the	the	DT
18637	13776	5	husband	husband	NN
18637	13776	6	,	,	,
18637	13776	7	though	though	IN
18637	13776	8	present	present	JJ
18637	13776	9	in	in	IN
18637	13776	10	person	person	NN
18637	13776	11	and	and	CC
18637	13776	12	by	by	IN
18637	13776	13	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	13776	14	,	,	,
18637	13776	15	did	do	VBD
18637	13776	16	not	not	RB
18637	13776	17	offer	offer	VB
18637	13776	18	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	13776	19	in	in	IN
18637	13776	20	rebuttal	rebuttal	NN
18637	13776	21	of	of	IN
18637	13776	22	the	the	DT
18637	13776	23	wife	wife	NN
18637	13776	24	's	's	POS
18637	13776	25	proof	proof	NN
18637	13776	26	of	of	IN
18637	13776	27	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13776	28	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13776	29	residence	residence	NN
18637	13776	30	;	;	:
18637	13776	31	and	and	CC
18637	13776	32	when	when	WRB
18637	13776	33	the	the	DT
18637	13776	34	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13776	35	court	court	NN
18637	13776	36	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	13776	37	that	that	IN
18637	13776	38	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13776	39	was	be	VBD
18637	13776	40	a	a	DT
18637	13776	41	_	_	NNP
18637	13776	42	bona	bona	NN
18637	13776	43	fide	fide	FW
18637	13776	44	_	_	NNP
18637	13776	45	resident	resident	NN
18637	13776	46	,	,	,
18637	13776	47	the	the	DT
18637	13776	48	husband	husband	NN
18637	13776	49	did	do	VBD
18637	13776	50	not	not	RB
18637	13776	51	appeal	appeal	VB
18637	13776	52	.	.	.
18637	13777	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	13777	2	as	as	IN
18637	13777	3	the	the	DT
18637	13777	4	findings	finding	NNS
18637	13777	5	of	of	IN
18637	13777	6	the	the	DT
18637	13777	7	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	13777	8	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	13777	9	facts	fact	NNS
18637	13777	10	,	,	,
18637	13777	11	unlike	unlike	IN
18637	13777	12	those	those	DT
18637	13777	13	in	in	IN
18637	13777	14	the	the	DT
18637	13777	15	Second	Second	NNP
18637	13777	16	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	13777	17	Case	Case	NNP
18637	13777	18	,	,	,
18637	13777	19	were	be	VBD
18637	13777	20	made	make	VBN
18637	13777	21	in	in	IN
18637	13777	22	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13777	23	in	in	IN
18637	13777	24	which	which	WDT
18637	13777	25	the	the	DT
18637	13777	26	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13777	27	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	13777	28	and	and	CC
18637	13777	29	participated	participate	VBD
18637	13777	30	,	,	,
18637	13777	31	the	the	DT
18637	13777	32	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	13777	33	of	of	IN
18637	13777	34	full	full	JJ
18637	13777	35	faith	faith	NN
18637	13777	36	and	and	CC
18637	13777	37	credit	credit	NN
18637	13777	38	were	be	VBD
18637	13777	39	held	hold	VBN
18637	13777	40	to	to	TO
18637	13777	41	bar	bar	VB
18637	13777	42	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13777	43	from	from	IN
18637	13777	44	collaterally	collaterally	RB
18637	13777	45	attacking	attack	VBG
18637	13777	46	such	such	JJ
18637	13777	47	findings	finding	NNS
18637	13777	48	in	in	IN
18637	13777	49	a	a	DT
18637	13777	50	suit	suit	NN
18637	13777	51	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	13777	52	by	by	IN
18637	13777	53	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13777	54	in	in	IN
18637	13777	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13777	56	home	home	NN
18637	13777	57	State	State	NNP
18637	13777	58	of	of	IN
18637	13777	59	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13777	60	,	,	,
18637	13777	61	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	13777	62	in	in	IN
18637	13777	63	the	the	DT
18637	13777	64	absence	absence	NN
18637	13777	65	of	of	IN
18637	13777	66	proof	proof	NN
18637	13777	67	that	that	IN
18637	13777	68	the	the	DT
18637	13777	69	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13777	70	decree	decree	NN
18637	13777	71	was	be	VBD
18637	13777	72	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13777	73	to	to	IN
18637	13777	74	such	such	JJ
18637	13777	75	collateral	collateral	JJ
18637	13777	76	attack	attack	NN
18637	13777	77	in	in	IN
18637	13777	78	a	a	DT
18637	13777	79	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13777	80	court	court	NN
18637	13777	81	.	.	.
18637	13778	1	Having	have	VBG
18637	13778	2	failed	fail	VBN
18637	13778	3	to	to	TO
18637	13778	4	take	take	VB
18637	13778	5	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	13778	6	of	of	IN
18637	13778	7	the	the	DT
18637	13778	8	opportunities	opportunity	NNS
18637	13778	9	afforded	afford	VBD
18637	13778	10	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13778	11	by	by	IN
18637	13778	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13778	13	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	13778	14	in	in	IN
18637	13778	15	the	the	DT
18637	13778	16	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13778	17	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13778	18	,	,	,
18637	13778	19	the	the	DT
18637	13778	20	husband	husband	NN
18637	13778	21	was	be	VBD
18637	13778	22	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	13778	23	precluded	preclude	VBN
18637	13778	24	from	from	IN
18637	13778	25	re	re	NN
18637	13778	26	-	-	NN
18637	13778	27	litigating	litigating	NN
18637	13778	28	in	in	IN
18637	13778	29	another	another	DT
18637	13778	30	State	State	NNP
18637	13778	31	the	the	DT
18637	13778	32	issue	issue	NN
18637	13778	33	of	of	IN
18637	13778	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13778	35	wife	wife	NN
18637	13778	36	's	's	POS
18637	13778	37	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13778	38	already	already	RB
18637	13778	39	passed	pass	VBN
18637	13778	40	upon	upon	IN
18637	13778	41	by	by	IN
18637	13778	42	the	the	DT
18637	13778	43	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13778	44	court	court	NN
18637	13778	45	.	.	.
18637	13779	1	In	in	IN
18637	13779	2	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	13779	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13779	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13779	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13779	6	Coe,[68	Coe,[68	NNP
18637	13779	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13779	8	embracing	embrace	VBG
18637	13779	9	a	a	DT
18637	13779	10	similar	similar	JJ
18637	13779	11	set	set	NN
18637	13779	12	of	of	IN
18637	13779	13	facts	fact	NNS
18637	13779	14	,	,	,
18637	13779	15	the	the	DT
18637	13779	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13779	17	applied	apply	VBD
18637	13779	18	like	like	IN
18637	13779	19	reasoning	reason	VBG
18637	13779	20	to	to	TO
18637	13779	21	reach	reach	VB
18637	13779	22	a	a	DT
18637	13779	23	similar	similar	JJ
18637	13779	24	result	result	NN
18637	13779	25	.	.	.
18637	13780	1	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13780	2	again	again	RB
18637	13780	3	was	be	VBD
18637	13780	4	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	13780	5	to	to	TO
18637	13780	6	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	13780	7	the	the	DT
18637	13780	8	validity	validity	NN
18637	13780	9	of	of	IN
18637	13780	10	a	a	DT
18637	13780	11	six	six	CD
18637	13780	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	13780	13	week	week	NN
18637	13780	14	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13780	15	decree	decree	NN
18637	13780	16	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13780	17	by	by	IN
18637	13780	18	a	a	DT
18637	13780	19	husband	husband	NN
18637	13780	20	who	who	WP
18637	13780	21	had	have	VBD
18637	13780	22	left	leave	VBN
18637	13780	23	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13780	24	after	after	IN
18637	13780	25	a	a	DT
18637	13780	26	court	court	NN
18637	13780	27	of	of	IN
18637	13780	28	that	that	DT
18637	13780	29	State	State	NNP
18637	13780	30	had	have	VBD
18637	13780	31	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	13780	32	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13780	33	a	a	DT
18637	13780	34	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13780	35	and	and	CC
18637	13780	36	had	have	VBD
18637	13780	37	granted	grant	VBN
18637	13780	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13780	39	wife	wife	NN
18637	13780	40	separate	separate	JJ
18637	13780	41	support	support	NN
18637	13780	42	.	.	.
18637	13781	1	In	in	IN
18637	13781	2	the	the	DT
18637	13781	3	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13781	4	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13781	5	,	,	,
18637	13781	6	the	the	DT
18637	13781	7	wife	wife	NN
18637	13781	8	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	13781	9	personally	personally	RB
18637	13781	10	and	and	CC
18637	13781	11	by	by	IN
18637	13781	12	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	13781	13	filed	file	VBD
18637	13781	14	a	a	DT
18637	13781	15	cross	cross	NN
18637	13781	16	-	-	NN
18637	13781	17	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	13781	18	for	for	IN
18637	13781	19	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13781	20	,	,	,
18637	13781	21	admitted	admit	VBD
18637	13781	22	the	the	DT
18637	13781	23	husband	husband	NN
18637	13781	24	's	's	POS
18637	13781	25	residence	residence	NN
18637	13781	26	,	,	,
18637	13781	27	and	and	CC
18637	13781	28	participated	participate	VBD
18637	13781	29	personally	personally	RB
18637	13781	30	in	in	IN
18637	13781	31	the	the	DT
18637	13781	32	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13781	33	.	.	.
18637	13782	1	After	after	IN
18637	13782	2	finding	find	VBG
18637	13782	3	that	that	IN
18637	13782	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13782	5	had	have	VBD
18637	13782	6	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13782	7	of	of	IN
18637	13782	8	the	the	DT
18637	13782	9	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	13782	10	,	,	,
18637	13782	11	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13782	12	,	,	,
18637	13782	13	and	and	CC
18637	13782	14	the	the	DT
18637	13782	15	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13782	16	matter	matter	NN
18637	13782	17	involved	involve	VBN
18637	13782	18	,	,	,
18637	13782	19	the	the	DT
18637	13782	20	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13782	21	court	court	NN
18637	13782	22	granted	grant	VBD
18637	13782	23	the	the	DT
18637	13782	24	wife	wife	NN
18637	13782	25	a	a	DT
18637	13782	26	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13782	27	,	,	,
18637	13782	28	which	which	WDT
18637	13782	29	was	be	VBD
18637	13782	30	valid	valid	JJ
18637	13782	31	,	,	,
18637	13782	32	final	final	JJ
18637	13782	33	,	,	,
18637	13782	34	and	and	CC
18637	13782	35	not	not	RB
18637	13782	36	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13782	37	to	to	IN
18637	13782	38	collateral	collateral	JJ
18637	13782	39	attack	attack	NN
18637	13782	40	under	under	IN
18637	13782	41	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13782	42	law	law	NN
18637	13782	43	.	.	.
18637	13783	1	The	the	DT
18637	13783	2	husband	husband	NN
18637	13783	3	married	marry	VBD
18637	13783	4	again	again	RB
18637	13783	5	,	,	,
18637	13783	6	and	and	CC
18637	13783	7	on	on	IN
18637	13783	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13783	9	return	return	NN
18637	13783	10	to	to	IN
18637	13783	11	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13783	12	,	,	,
18637	13783	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13783	14	ex	ex	NN
18637	13783	15	-	-	NN
18637	13783	16	wife	wife	NN
18637	13783	17	petitioned	petition	VBD
18637	13783	18	the	the	DT
18637	13783	19	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13783	20	court	court	NN
18637	13783	21	to	to	TO
18637	13783	22	adjudge	adjudge	VB
18637	13783	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13783	24	in	in	IN
18637	13783	25	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	13783	26	for	for	IN
18637	13783	27	failing	fail	VBG
18637	13783	28	to	to	TO
18637	13783	29	make	make	VB
18637	13783	30	payments	payment	NNS
18637	13783	31	for	for	IN
18637	13783	32	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13783	33	separate	separate	JJ
18637	13783	34	support	support	NN
18637	13783	35	under	under	IN
18637	13783	36	the	the	DT
18637	13783	37	earlier	early	JJR
18637	13783	38	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13783	39	decree	decree	NN
18637	13783	40	.	.	.
18637	13784	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	13784	2	as	as	IN
18637	13784	3	there	there	EX
18637	13784	4	was	be	VBD
18637	13784	5	no	no	DT
18637	13784	6	intimation	intimation	NN
18637	13784	7	that	that	IN
18637	13784	8	under	under	IN
18637	13784	9	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13784	10	law	law	NN
18637	13784	11	a	a	DT
18637	13784	12	decree	decree	NN
18637	13784	13	of	of	IN
18637	13784	14	separate	separate	JJ
18637	13784	15	support	support	NN
18637	13784	16	would	would	MD
18637	13784	17	survive	survive	VB
18637	13784	18	a	a	DT
18637	13784	19	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13784	20	,	,	,
18637	13784	21	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13784	22	of	of	IN
18637	13784	23	the	the	DT
18637	13784	24	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13784	25	decree	decree	NN
18637	13784	26	as	as	IN
18637	13784	27	valid	valid	JJ
18637	13784	28	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	13784	29	necessitated	necessitate	VBD
18637	13784	30	a	a	DT
18637	13784	31	rejection	rejection	NN
18637	13784	32	of	of	IN
18637	13784	33	the	the	DT
18637	13784	34	ex	ex	NN
18637	13784	35	-	-	NN
18637	13784	36	wife	wife	NN
18637	13784	37	's	's	POS
18637	13784	38	contention	contention	NN
18637	13784	39	.	.	.
18637	13785	1	Appearing	appear	VBG
18637	13785	2	to	to	TO
18637	13785	3	revive	revive	VB
18637	13785	4	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	13785	5	II	II	NNP
18637	13785	6	,	,	,
18637	13785	7	and	and	CC
18637	13785	8	significant	significant	JJ
18637	13785	9	for	for	IN
18637	13785	10	the	the	DT
18637	13785	11	social	social	JJ
18637	13785	12	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	13785	13	produced	produce	VBN
18637	13785	14	by	by	IN
18637	13785	15	the	the	DT
18637	13785	16	result	result	NN
18637	13785	17	decreed	decreed	NN
18637	13785	18	therein	therein	RB
18637	13785	19	,	,	,
18637	13785	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	13785	21	the	the	DT
18637	13785	22	recent	recent	JJ
18637	13785	23	case	case	NN
18637	13785	24	of	of	IN
18637	13785	25	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	13785	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13785	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	13785	28	_	_	NNP
18637	13785	29	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	13785	30	.	.	.
18637	13786	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13786	2	69	69	CD
18637	13786	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13786	4	To	to	TO
18637	13786	5	determine	determine	VB
18637	13786	6	the	the	DT
18637	13786	7	widowhood	widowhood	NNP
18637	13786	8	status	status	NN
18637	13786	9	of	of	IN
18637	13786	10	the	the	DT
18637	13786	11	party	party	NN
18637	13786	12	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	13786	13	in	in	IN
18637	13786	14	relation	relation	NN
18637	13786	15	to	to	IN
18637	13786	16	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	13786	17	of	of	IN
18637	13786	18	property	property	NN
18637	13786	19	of	of	IN
18637	13786	20	a	a	DT
18637	13786	21	husband	husband	NN
18637	13786	22	who	who	WP
18637	13786	23	had	have	VBD
18637	13786	24	deserted	desert	VBN
18637	13786	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13786	26	first	first	JJ
18637	13786	27	wife	wife	NN
18637	13786	28	in	in	IN
18637	13786	29	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	13786	30	,	,	,
18637	13786	31	had	have	VBD
18637	13786	32	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13786	33	an	an	DT
18637	13786	34	_	_	NNP
18637	13786	35	ex	ex	NNP
18637	13786	36	parte	parte	NNP
18637	13786	37	_	_	NNP
18637	13786	38	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13786	39	in	in	IN
18637	13786	40	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13786	41	,	,	,
18637	13786	42	and	and	CC
18637	13786	43	after	after	IN
18637	13786	44	remarriage	remarriage	NN
18637	13786	45	,	,	,
18637	13786	46	had	have	VBD
18637	13786	47	died	die	VBN
18637	13786	48	without	without	IN
18637	13786	49	ever	ever	RB
18637	13786	50	returning	return	VBG
18637	13786	51	to	to	IN
18637	13786	52	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	13786	53	,	,	,
18637	13786	54	the	the	DT
18637	13786	55	first	first	JJ
18637	13786	56	wife	wife	NN
18637	13786	57	,	,	,
18637	13786	58	joining	join	VBG
18637	13786	59	the	the	DT
18637	13786	60	second	second	JJ
18637	13786	61	wife	wife	NN
18637	13786	62	and	and	CC
18637	13786	63	the	the	DT
18637	13786	64	administrator	administrator	NN
18637	13786	65	of	of	IN
18637	13786	66	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13786	67	estate	estate	NN
18637	13786	68	as	as	IN
18637	13786	69	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	13786	70	,	,	,
18637	13786	71	petitioned	petition	VBD
18637	13786	72	a	a	DT
18637	13786	73	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	13786	74	court	court	NN
18637	13786	75	for	for	IN
18637	13786	76	a	a	DT
18637	13786	77	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	13786	78	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13786	79	.	.	.
18637	13787	1	After	after	IN
18637	13787	2	having	have	VBG
18637	13787	3	placed	place	VBN
18637	13787	4	upon	upon	IN
18637	13787	5	the	the	DT
18637	13787	6	first	first	JJ
18637	13787	7	wife	wife	NN
18637	13787	8	the	the	DT
18637	13787	9	burden	burden	NN
18637	13787	10	of	of	IN
18637	13787	11	proving	prove	VBG
18637	13787	12	that	that	IN
18637	13787	13	the	the	DT
18637	13787	14	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	13787	15	had	have	VBD
18637	13787	16	not	not	RB
18637	13787	17	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	13787	18	a	a	DT
18637	13787	19	_	_	NNP
18637	13787	20	bona	bona	NN
18637	13787	21	fide	fide	FW
18637	13787	22	_	_	NNP
18637	13787	23	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13787	24	in	in	IN
18637	13787	25	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13787	26	,	,	,
18637	13787	27	and	and	CC
18637	13787	28	after	after	IN
18637	13787	29	giving	give	VBG
18637	13787	30	proper	proper	JJ
18637	13787	31	weight	weight	NN
18637	13787	32	to	to	IN
18637	13787	33	the	the	DT
18637	13787	34	claims	claim	NNS
18637	13787	35	of	of	IN
18637	13787	36	power	power	NN
18637	13787	37	by	by	IN
18637	13787	38	the	the	DT
18637	13787	39	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13787	40	court	court	NN
18637	13787	41	,	,	,
18637	13787	42	the	the	DT
18637	13787	43	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	13787	44	court	court	NN
18637	13787	45	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	13787	46	that	that	IN
18637	13787	47	the	the	DT
18637	13787	48	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	13787	49	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	13787	50	the	the	DT
18637	13787	51	contentions	contention	NNS
18637	13787	52	of	of	IN
18637	13787	53	the	the	DT
18637	13787	54	first	first	JJ
18637	13787	55	wife	wife	NN
18637	13787	56	;	;	:
18637	13787	57	and	and	CC
18637	13787	58	in	in	IN
18637	13787	59	so	so	RB
18637	13787	60	doing	do	VBG
18637	13787	61	,	,	,
18637	13787	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13787	63	was	be	VBD
18637	13787	64	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	13787	65	by	by	IN
18637	13787	66	the	the	DT
18637	13787	67	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13787	68	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13787	69	.	.	.
18637	13788	1	The	the	DT
18637	13788	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	13788	3	of	of	IN
18637	13788	4	Sherrer	Sherrer	NNP
18637	13788	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13788	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13788	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13788	8	Sherrer	Sherrer	NNP
18637	13788	9	,	,	,
18637	13788	10	334	334	CD
18637	13788	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13788	12	343	343	CD
18637	13788	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13788	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	13788	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13788	16	and	and	CC
18637	13788	17	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	13788	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13788	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	13788	20	_	_	NNP
18637	13788	21	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	13788	22	,	,	,
18637	13788	23	334	334	CD
18637	13788	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13788	25	378	378	CD
18637	13788	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13788	27	1948	1948	CD
18637	13788	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13788	29	,	,	,
18637	13788	30	previously	previously	RB
18637	13788	31	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	13788	32	,	,	,
18637	13788	33	were	be	VBD
18637	13788	34	declared	declare	VBN
18637	13788	35	not	not	RB
18637	13788	36	to	to	TO
18637	13788	37	be	be	VB
18637	13788	38	in	in	IN
18637	13788	39	point	point	NN
18637	13788	40	;	;	:
18637	13788	41	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	13788	42	as	as	IN
18637	13788	43	no	no	DT
18637	13788	44	personal	personal	JJ
18637	13788	45	service	service	NN
18637	13788	46	was	be	VBD
18637	13788	47	made	make	VBN
18637	13788	48	upon	upon	IN
18637	13788	49	the	the	DT
18637	13788	50	first	first	JJ
18637	13788	51	wife	wife	NN
18637	13788	52	,	,	,
18637	13788	53	nor	nor	CC
18637	13788	54	did	do	VBD
18637	13788	55	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13788	56	in	in	IN
18637	13788	57	any	any	DT
18637	13788	58	way	way	NN
18637	13788	59	participate	participate	VB
18637	13788	60	in	in	IN
18637	13788	61	the	the	DT
18637	13788	62	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13788	63	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13788	64	.	.	.
18637	13789	1	She	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13789	2	was	be	VBD
18637	13789	3	not	not	RB
18637	13789	4	,	,	,
18637	13789	5	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	13789	6	,	,	,
18637	13789	7	precluded	preclude	VBD
18637	13789	8	from	from	IN
18637	13789	9	challenging	challenge	VBG
18637	13789	10	the	the	DT
18637	13789	11	finding	finding	NN
18637	13789	12	of	of	IN
18637	13789	13	the	the	DT
18637	13789	14	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	13789	15	court	court	NN
18637	13789	16	that	that	IN
18637	13789	17	the	the	DT
18637	13789	18	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	13789	19	was	be	VBD
18637	13789	20	,	,	,
18637	13789	21	at	at	IN
18637	13789	22	the	the	DT
18637	13789	23	time	time	NN
18637	13789	24	of	of	IN
18637	13789	25	the	the	DT
18637	13789	26	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13789	27	,	,	,
18637	13789	28	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	13789	29	in	in	IN
18637	13789	30	that	that	DT
18637	13789	31	State	State	NNP
18637	13789	32	.	.	.
18637	13790	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13790	2	70	70	CD
18637	13790	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13790	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	13790	5	OF	of	IN
18637	13790	6	THE	the	DT
18637	13790	7	LAW	law	NN
18637	13790	8	TODAY	today	NN
18637	13790	9	:	:	:
18637	13790	10	QUAERE	QUAERE	NNP
18637	13790	11	Upon	upon	IN
18637	13790	12	summation	summation	NN
18637	13790	13	one	one	PRP
18637	13790	14	may	may	MD
18637	13790	15	speculate	speculate	VB
18637	13790	16	as	as	IN
18637	13790	17	to	to	IN
18637	13790	18	whether	whether	IN
18637	13790	19	the	the	DT
18637	13790	20	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	13790	21	of	of	IN
18637	13790	22	divisible	divisible	JJ
18637	13790	23	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13790	24	,	,	,
18637	13790	25	as	as	IN
18637	13790	26	developed	develop	VBN
18637	13790	27	by	by	IN
18637	13790	28	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13790	29	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	13790	30	in	in	IN
18637	13790	31	Estin	Estin	NNP
18637	13790	32	_	_	NNP
18637	13790	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	13790	34	_	_	NNP
18637	13790	35	Estin	Estin	NNP
18637	13790	36	,	,	,
18637	13790	37	334	334	CD
18637	13790	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	13790	39	541	541	CD
18637	13790	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13790	41	1948	1948	CD
18637	13790	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13790	43	,	,	,
18637	13790	44	has	have	VBZ
18637	13790	45	not	not	RB
18637	13790	46	become	become	VBN
18637	13790	47	the	the	DT
18637	13790	48	prevailing	prevailing	JJ
18637	13790	49	standard	standard	NN
18637	13790	50	for	for	IN
18637	13790	51	determining	determine	VBG
18637	13790	52	the	the	DT
18637	13790	53	enforceability	enforceability	NN
18637	13790	54	of	of	IN
18637	13790	55	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13790	56	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13790	57	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	13790	58	.	.	.
18637	13791	1	If	if	IN
18637	13791	2	such	such	JJ
18637	13791	3	be	be	VB
18637	13791	4	the	the	DT
18637	13791	5	case	case	NN
18637	13791	6	,	,	,
18637	13791	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13791	8	may	may	MD
18637	13791	9	be	be	VB
18637	13791	10	tenable	tenable	JJ
18637	13791	11	to	to	TO
18637	13791	12	assert	assert	VB
18637	13791	13	that	that	IN
18637	13791	14	an	an	DT
18637	13791	15	_	_	NNP
18637	13791	16	ex	ex	NNP
18637	13791	17	parte	parte	NNP
18637	13791	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13791	19	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13791	20	,	,	,
18637	13791	21	founded	found	VBN
18637	13791	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	13791	23	acquisition	acquisition	NN
18637	13791	24	of	of	IN
18637	13791	25	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13791	26	by	by	IN
18637	13791	27	one	one	CD
18637	13791	28	spouse	spouse	NN
18637	13791	29	in	in	IN
18637	13791	30	the	the	DT
18637	13791	31	State	State	NNP
18637	13791	32	which	which	WDT
18637	13791	33	granted	grant	VBD
18637	13791	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13791	35	,	,	,
18637	13791	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	13791	37	effective	effective	JJ
18637	13791	38	to	to	TO
18637	13791	39	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	13791	40	the	the	DT
18637	13791	41	marital	marital	JJ
18637	13791	42	status	status	NN
18637	13791	43	of	of	IN
18637	13791	44	both	both	DT
18637	13791	45	parties	party	NNS
18637	13791	46	in	in	IN
18637	13791	47	the	the	DT
18637	13791	48	State	State	NNP
18637	13791	49	of	of	IN
18637	13791	50	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	13791	51	origin	origin	NN
18637	13791	52	and	and	CC
18637	13791	53	probably	probably	RB
18637	13791	54	in	in	IN
18637	13791	55	all	all	DT
18637	13791	56	other	other	JJ
18637	13791	57	States	States	NNPS
18637	13791	58	and	and	CC
18637	13791	59	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	13791	60	to	to	TO
18637	13791	61	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	13791	62	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	13791	63	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	13791	64	for	for	IN
18637	13791	65	bigamy	bigamy	NN
18637	13791	66	,	,	,
18637	13791	67	but	but	CC
18637	13791	68	not	not	RB
18637	13791	69	to	to	TO
18637	13791	70	alter	alter	VB
18637	13791	71	rights	right	NNS
18637	13791	72	as	as	IN
18637	13791	73	to	to	IN
18637	13791	74	property	property	NN
18637	13791	75	,	,	,
18637	13791	76	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	13791	77	,	,	,
18637	13791	78	or	or	CC
18637	13791	79	custody	custody	NN
18637	13791	80	of	of	IN
18637	13791	81	children	child	NNS
18637	13791	82	in	in	IN
18637	13791	83	the	the	DT
18637	13791	84	State	State	NNP
18637	13791	85	of	of	IN
18637	13791	86	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	13791	87	origin	origin	NN
18637	13791	88	of	of	IN
18637	13791	89	a	a	DT
18637	13791	90	spouse	spouse	NN
18637	13791	91	who	who	WP
18637	13791	92	was	be	VBD
18637	13791	93	neither	neither	CC
18637	13791	94	served	serve	VBN
18637	13791	95	nor	nor	CC
18637	13791	96	personally	personally	RB
18637	13791	97	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	13791	98	.	.	.
18637	13792	1	DECREES	DECREES	NNP
18637	13792	2	AWARDING	AWARDING	NNP
18637	13792	3	ALIMONY	ALIMONY	NNP
18637	13792	4	,	,	,
18637	13792	5	CUSTODY	custody	NN
18637	13792	6	OF	of	IN
18637	13792	7	CHILDREN	child	NNS
18637	13792	8	Resulting	result	VBG
18637	13792	9	as	as	IN
18637	13792	10	a	a	DT
18637	13792	11	by	by	IN
18637	13792	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	13792	13	product	product	NN
18637	13792	14	of	of	IN
18637	13792	15	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13792	16	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	13792	17	are	be	VBP
18637	13792	18	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	13792	19	for	for	IN
18637	13792	20	the	the	DT
18637	13792	21	payment	payment	NN
18637	13792	22	of	of	IN
18637	13792	23	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	13792	24	,	,	,
18637	13792	25	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13792	26	for	for	IN
18637	13792	27	accrued	accrued	JJ
18637	13792	28	and	and	CC
18637	13792	29	unpaid	unpaid	JJ
18637	13792	30	instalments	instalment	NNS
18637	13792	31	of	of	IN
18637	13792	32	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	13792	33	,	,	,
18637	13792	34	and	and	CC
18637	13792	35	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13792	36	awards	award	NNS
18637	13792	37	of	of	IN
18637	13792	38	the	the	DT
18637	13792	39	custody	custody	NN
18637	13792	40	of	of	IN
18637	13792	41	children	child	NNS
18637	13792	42	,	,	,
18637	13792	43	all	all	DT
18637	13792	44	of	of	IN
18637	13792	45	which	which	WDT
18637	13792	46	necessitate	necessitate	JJ
18637	13792	47	application	application	NN
18637	13792	48	of	of	IN
18637	13792	49	the	the	DT
18637	13792	50	full	full	JJ
18637	13792	51	faith	faith	NN
18637	13792	52	and	and	CC
18637	13792	53	credit	credit	NN
18637	13792	54	clause	clause	NN
18637	13792	55	when	when	WRB
18637	13792	56	extrastate	extrastate	VBP
18637	13792	57	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	13792	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	13792	59	sought	seek	VBN
18637	13792	60	for	for	IN
18637	13792	61	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13792	62	.	.	.
18637	13793	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	13793	2	a	a	DT
18637	13793	3	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13793	4	in	in	IN
18637	13793	5	State	State	NNP
18637	13793	6	A	A	NNP
18637	13793	7	for	for	IN
18637	13793	8	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	13793	9	in	in	IN
18637	13793	10	arrears	arrear	NNS
18637	13793	11	and	and	CC
18637	13793	12	payable	payable	JJ
18637	13793	13	under	under	IN
18637	13793	14	a	a	DT
18637	13793	15	prior	prior	JJ
18637	13793	16	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13793	17	of	of	IN
18637	13793	18	separation	separation	NN
18637	13793	19	which	which	WDT
18637	13793	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	13793	21	not	not	RB
18637	13793	22	by	by	IN
18637	13793	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13793	24	terms	term	NNS
18637	13793	25	conditional	conditional	JJ
18637	13793	26	,	,	,
18637	13793	27	nor	nor	CC
18637	13793	28	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13793	29	by	by	IN
18637	13793	30	the	the	DT
18637	13793	31	law	law	NN
18637	13793	32	of	of	IN
18637	13793	33	State	State	NNP
18637	13793	34	A	A	NNP
18637	13793	35	to	to	IN
18637	13793	36	modification	modification	NN
18637	13793	37	or	or	CC
18637	13793	38	recall	recall	VB
18637	13793	39	,	,	,
18637	13793	40	and	and	CC
18637	13793	41	on	on	IN
18637	13793	42	which	which	WDT
18637	13793	43	execution	execution	NN
18637	13793	44	was	be	VBD
18637	13793	45	directed	direct	VBN
18637	13793	46	to	to	TO
18637	13793	47	issue	issue	VB
18637	13793	48	,	,	,
18637	13793	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	13793	50	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13793	51	to	to	TO
18637	13793	52	recognition	recognition	VB
18637	13793	53	in	in	IN
18637	13793	54	the	the	DT
18637	13793	55	forum	forum	NN
18637	13793	56	State	state	NN
18637	13793	57	.	.	.
18637	13794	1	Although	although	IN
18637	13794	2	an	an	DT
18637	13794	3	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	13794	4	for	for	IN
18637	13794	5	accrued	accrue	VBN
18637	13794	6	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	13794	7	could	could	MD
18637	13794	8	have	have	VB
18637	13794	9	been	be	VBN
18637	13794	10	modified	modify	VBN
18637	13794	11	or	or	CC
18637	13794	12	set	set	VBN
18637	13794	13	aside	aside	RB
18637	13794	14	in	in	IN
18637	13794	15	State	State	NNP
18637	13794	16	A	A	NNP
18637	13794	17	prior	prior	RB
18637	13794	18	to	to	IN
18637	13794	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13794	20	merger	merger	NN
18637	13794	21	in	in	IN
18637	13794	22	the	the	DT
18637	13794	23	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13794	24	,	,	,
18637	13794	25	such	such	PDT
18637	13794	26	a	a	DT
18637	13794	27	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13794	28	,	,	,
18637	13794	29	by	by	IN
18637	13794	30	the	the	DT
18637	13794	31	law	law	NN
18637	13794	32	of	of	IN
18637	13794	33	State	State	NNP
18637	13794	34	A	A	NNP
18637	13794	35	,	,	,
18637	13794	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	13794	37	not	not	RB
18637	13794	38	lacking	lack	VBG
18637	13794	39	in	in	IN
18637	13794	40	finality	finality	NN
18637	13794	41	.	.	.
18637	13795	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13795	2	71	71	CD
18637	13795	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13795	4	As	as	IN
18637	13795	5	to	to	IN
18637	13795	6	the	the	DT
18637	13795	7	finality	finality	NN
18637	13795	8	of	of	IN
18637	13795	9	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	13795	10	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	13795	11	in	in	IN
18637	13795	12	general	general	JJ
18637	13795	13	,	,	,
18637	13795	14	the	the	DT
18637	13795	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13795	16	had	have	VBD
18637	13795	17	previously	previously	RB
18637	13795	18	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	13795	19	that	that	IN
18637	13795	20	where	where	WRB
18637	13795	21	such	such	PDT
18637	13795	22	a	a	DT
18637	13795	23	decree	decree	NN
18637	13795	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	13795	25	rendered	render	VBN
18637	13795	26	,	,	,
18637	13795	27	payable	payable	JJ
18637	13795	28	in	in	IN
18637	13795	29	future	future	JJ
18637	13795	30	instalments	instalment	NNS
18637	13795	31	,	,	,
18637	13795	32	the	the	DT
18637	13795	33	right	right	NN
18637	13795	34	to	to	IN
18637	13795	35	such	such	JJ
18637	13795	36	instalments	instalment	NNS
18637	13795	37	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	13795	38	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	13795	39	and	and	CC
18637	13795	40	vested	vest	VBN
18637	13795	41	on	on	RP
18637	13795	42	becoming	become	VBG
18637	13795	43	due	due	JJ
18637	13795	44	,	,	,
18637	13795	45	provided	provide	VBN
18637	13795	46	no	no	DT
18637	13795	47	modification	modification	NN
18637	13795	48	of	of	IN
18637	13795	49	the	the	DT
18637	13795	50	decree	decree	NN
18637	13795	51	has	have	VBZ
18637	13795	52	been	be	VBN
18637	13795	53	made	make	VBN
18637	13795	54	prior	prior	RB
18637	13795	55	to	to	IN
18637	13795	56	the	the	DT
18637	13795	57	maturity	maturity	NN
18637	13795	58	of	of	IN
18637	13795	59	the	the	DT
18637	13795	60	instalments	instalment	NNS
18637	13795	61	.	.	.
18637	13796	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13796	2	72	72	CD
18637	13796	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13796	4	However	however	RB
18637	13796	5	,	,	,
18637	13796	6	a	a	DT
18637	13796	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13796	8	order	order	NN
18637	13796	9	requiring	require	VBG
18637	13796	10	the	the	DT
18637	13796	11	payment	payment	NN
18637	13796	12	of	of	IN
18637	13796	13	arrearages	arrearage	NNS
18637	13796	14	in	in	IN
18637	13796	15	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	13796	16	,	,	,
18637	13796	17	which	which	WDT
18637	13796	18	exceeded	exceed	VBD
18637	13796	19	the	the	DT
18637	13796	20	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	13796	21	previously	previously	RB
18637	13796	22	decreed	decreed	VB
18637	13796	23	,	,	,
18637	13796	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	13796	25	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	13796	26	for	for	IN
18637	13796	27	want	want	NN
18637	13796	28	of	of	IN
18637	13796	29	due	due	JJ
18637	13796	30	process	process	NN
18637	13796	31	,	,	,
18637	13796	32	the	the	DT
18637	13796	33	respondent	respondent	NN
18637	13796	34	having	have	VBG
18637	13796	35	been	be	VBN
18637	13796	36	given	give	VBN
18637	13796	37	no	no	DT
18637	13796	38	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	13796	39	to	to	TO
18637	13796	40	contest	contest	VB
18637	13796	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13796	42	.	.	.
18637	13797	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13797	2	73	73	CD
18637	13797	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13797	4	"	"	``
18637	13797	5	A	a	DT
18637	13797	6	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13797	7	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	13797	8	in	in	IN
18637	13797	9	violation	violation	NN
18637	13797	10	of	of	IN
18637	13797	11	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	13797	12	due	due	JJ
18637	13797	13	process	process	NN
18637	13797	14	,	,	,
18637	13797	15	"	"	''
18637	13797	16	said	say	VBD
18637	13797	17	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	13797	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13797	19	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	13797	20	,	,	,
18637	13797	21	"	"	``
18637	13797	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	13797	23	not	not	RB
18637	13797	24	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13797	25	to	to	IN
18637	13797	26	full	full	JJ
18637	13797	27	faith	faith	NN
18637	13797	28	and	and	CC
18637	13797	29	credit	credit	NN
18637	13797	30	when	when	WRB
18637	13797	31	sued	sue	VBN
18637	13797	32	upon	upon	IN
18637	13797	33	in	in	IN
18637	13797	34	another	another	DT
18637	13797	35	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13797	36	.	.	.
18637	13798	1	"	"	``
18637	13798	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13798	3	74	74	CD
18637	13798	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13798	5	A	a	DT
18637	13798	6	recent	recent	JJ
18637	13798	7	example	example	NN
18637	13798	8	of	of	IN
18637	13798	9	a	a	DT
18637	13798	10	custody	custody	NN
18637	13798	11	case	case	NN
18637	13798	12	was	be	VBD
18637	13798	13	one	one	CD
18637	13798	14	involving	involve	VBG
18637	13798	15	a	a	DT
18637	13798	16	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13798	17	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13798	18	decree	decree	NN
18637	13798	19	which	which	WDT
18637	13798	20	was	be	VBD
18637	13798	21	granted	grant	VBN
18637	13798	22	_	_	NNP
18637	13798	23	ex	ex	NNP
18637	13798	24	parte	parte	NNP
18637	13798	25	_	_	NNP
18637	13798	26	to	to	IN
18637	13798	27	a	a	DT
18637	13798	28	wife	wife	NN
18637	13798	29	who	who	WP
18637	13798	30	had	have	VBD
18637	13798	31	left	leave	VBN
18637	13798	32	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13798	33	husband	husband	NN
18637	13798	34	in	in	IN
18637	13798	35	New	New	NNP
18637	13798	36	York	York	NNP
18637	13798	37	,	,	,
18637	13798	38	where	where	WRB
18637	13798	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13798	40	was	be	VBD
18637	13798	41	served	serve	VBN
18637	13798	42	by	by	IN
18637	13798	43	publication	publication	NN
18637	13798	44	.	.	.
18637	13799	1	The	the	DT
18637	13799	2	decree	decree	NN
18637	13799	3	carried	carry	VBD
18637	13799	4	with	with	IN
18637	13799	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13799	6	an	an	DT
18637	13799	7	award	award	NN
18637	13799	8	of	of	IN
18637	13799	9	the	the	DT
18637	13799	10	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	13799	11	custody	custody	NN
18637	13799	12	of	of	IN
18637	13799	13	the	the	DT
18637	13799	14	child	child	NN
18637	13799	15	,	,	,
18637	13799	16	whom	whom	WP
18637	13799	17	the	the	DT
18637	13799	18	day	day	NN
18637	13799	19	before	before	IN
18637	13799	20	the	the	DT
18637	13799	21	husband	husband	NN
18637	13799	22	had	have	VBD
18637	13799	23	secretly	secretly	RB
18637	13799	24	seized	seize	VBN
18637	13799	25	and	and	CC
18637	13799	26	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13799	27	back	back	RB
18637	13799	28	to	to	IN
18637	13799	29	New	New	NNP
18637	13799	30	York	York	NNP
18637	13799	31	.	.	.
18637	13800	1	The	the	DT
18637	13800	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13800	3	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	13800	4	that	that	IN
18637	13800	5	the	the	DT
18637	13800	6	decree	decree	NN
18637	13800	7	was	be	VBD
18637	13800	8	adequately	adequately	RB
18637	13800	9	honored	honor	VBN
18637	13800	10	by	by	IN
18637	13800	11	a	a	DT
18637	13800	12	New	New	NNP
18637	13800	13	York	York	NNP
18637	13800	14	court	court	NN
18637	13800	15	when	when	WRB
18637	13800	16	,	,	,
18637	13800	17	in	in	IN
18637	13800	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13800	19	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	13800	20	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	13800	21	_	_	NNP
18637	13800	22	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13800	23	,	,	,
18637	13800	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13800	25	gave	give	VBD
18637	13800	26	the	the	DT
18637	13800	27	father	father	NN
18637	13800	28	rights	right	NNS
18637	13800	29	of	of	IN
18637	13800	30	visitation	visitation	NN
18637	13800	31	and	and	CC
18637	13800	32	custody	custody	NN
18637	13800	33	of	of	IN
18637	13800	34	the	the	DT
18637	13800	35	child	child	NN
18637	13800	36	during	during	IN
18637	13800	37	stated	state	VBN
18637	13800	38	periods	period	NNS
18637	13800	39	,	,	,
18637	13800	40	and	and	CC
18637	13800	41	exacted	exact	VBD
18637	13800	42	a	a	DT
18637	13800	43	surety	surety	NN
18637	13800	44	bond	bond	NN
18637	13800	45	of	of	IN
18637	13800	46	the	the	DT
18637	13800	47	wife	wife	NN
18637	13800	48	conditioned	condition	VBD
18637	13800	49	on	on	IN
18637	13800	50	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13800	51	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	13800	52	of	of	IN
18637	13800	53	the	the	DT
18637	13800	54	child	child	NN
18637	13800	55	to	to	IN
18637	13800	56	the	the	DT
18637	13800	57	father	father	NN
18637	13800	58	at	at	IN
18637	13800	59	the	the	DT
18637	13800	60	proper	proper	JJ
18637	13800	61	times,[75	times,[75	NNP
18637	13800	62	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13800	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13800	64	having	have	VBG
18637	13800	65	not	not	RB
18637	13800	66	been	be	VBN
18637	13800	67	"	"	``
18637	13800	68	shown	show	VBN
18637	13800	69	that	that	IN
18637	13800	70	the	the	DT
18637	13800	71	New	New	NNP
18637	13800	72	York	York	NNP
18637	13800	73	court	court	NN
18637	13800	74	in	in	IN
18637	13800	75	modifying	modify	VBG
18637	13800	76	the	the	DT
18637	13800	77	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13800	78	decree	decree	NN
18637	13800	79	exceeded	exceed	VBD
18637	13800	80	the	the	DT
18637	13800	81	limits	limit	NNS
18637	13800	82	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	13800	83	under	under	IN
18637	13800	84	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13800	85	law	law	NN
18637	13800	86	.	.	.
18637	13801	1	There	there	EX
18637	13801	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	13801	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	13801	4	a	a	DT
18637	13801	5	failure	failure	NN
18637	13801	6	of	of	IN
18637	13801	7	proof	proof	NN
18637	13801	8	that	that	IN
18637	13801	9	the	the	DT
18637	13801	10	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13801	11	decree	decree	NN
18637	13801	12	received	receive	VBD
18637	13801	13	less	less	JJR
18637	13801	14	credit	credit	NN
18637	13801	15	in	in	IN
18637	13801	16	New	New	NNP
18637	13801	17	York	York	NNP
18637	13801	18	than	than	IN
18637	13801	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13801	20	had	have	VBD
18637	13801	21	in	in	IN
18637	13801	22	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13801	23	.	.	.
18637	13801	24	"	"	''
18637	13802	1	COLLATERAL	collateral	NN
18637	13802	2	ATTACK	ATTACK	NNS
18637	13802	3	BY	by	IN
18637	13802	4	CHILD	child	NN
18637	13802	5	A	a	DT
18637	13802	6	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13802	7	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13802	8	decree	decree	NN
18637	13802	9	was	be	VBD
18637	13802	10	also	also	RB
18637	13802	11	at	at	IN
18637	13802	12	the	the	DT
18637	13802	13	bottom	bottom	NN
18637	13802	14	of	of	IN
18637	13802	15	another	another	DT
18637	13802	16	recent	recent	JJ
18637	13802	17	case	case	NN
18637	13802	18	in	in	IN
18637	13802	19	which	which	WDT
18637	13802	20	the	the	DT
18637	13802	21	daughter	daughter	NN
18637	13802	22	of	of	IN
18637	13802	23	a	a	DT
18637	13802	24	divorced	divorce	VBN
18637	13802	25	man	man	NN
18637	13802	26	by	by	IN
18637	13802	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13802	28	first	first	JJ
18637	13802	29	wife	wife	NN
18637	13802	30	,	,	,
18637	13802	31	and	and	CC
18637	13802	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13802	33	legatee	legatee	NN
18637	13802	34	under	under	IN
18637	13802	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13802	36	will	will	NN
18637	13802	37	,	,	,
18637	13802	38	sought	seek	VBN
18637	13802	39	to	to	TO
18637	13802	40	attack	attack	VB
18637	13802	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13802	42	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13802	43	in	in	IN
18637	13802	44	the	the	DT
18637	13802	45	New	New	NNP
18637	13802	46	York	York	NNP
18637	13802	47	courts	court	NNS
18637	13802	48	,	,	,
18637	13802	49	and	and	CC
18637	13802	50	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	13802	51	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	13802	52	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13802	53	third	third	JJ
18637	13802	54	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	13802	55	.	.	.
18637	13803	1	The	the	DT
18637	13803	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13803	3	held	hold	VBD
18637	13803	4	that	that	DT
18637	13803	5	inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	13803	6	as	as	IN
18637	13803	7	the	the	DT
18637	13803	8	attack	attack	NN
18637	13803	9	would	would	MD
18637	13803	10	not	not	RB
18637	13803	11	have	have	VB
18637	13803	12	been	be	VBN
18637	13803	13	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	13803	14	in	in	IN
18637	13803	15	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	13803	16	under	under	IN
18637	13803	17	the	the	DT
18637	13803	18	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	13803	19	of	of	IN
18637	13803	20	_	_	NNP
18637	13803	21	res	res	NNP
18637	13803	22	judicata	judicata	NNP
18637	13803	23	_	_	NNP
18637	13803	24	,	,	,
18637	13803	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13803	26	was	be	VBD
18637	13803	27	not	not	RB
18637	13803	28	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	13803	29	under	under	IN
18637	13803	30	the	the	DT
18637	13803	31	full	full	JJ
18637	13803	32	faith	faith	NN
18637	13803	33	and	and	CC
18637	13803	34	credit	credit	NN
18637	13803	35	clause	clause	NN
18637	13803	36	in	in	IN
18637	13803	37	New	New	NNP
18637	13803	38	York	York	NNP
18637	13803	39	.	.	.
18637	13804	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13804	2	76	76	CD
18637	13804	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13804	4	On	on	IN
18637	13804	5	the	the	DT
18637	13804	6	whole	whole	NN
18637	13804	7	,	,	,
18637	13804	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13804	9	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	13804	10	that	that	IN
18637	13804	11	the	the	DT
18637	13804	12	principle	principle	NN
18637	13804	13	of	of	IN
18637	13804	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13804	15	res	res	NNP
18637	13804	16	judicata	judicata	NNP
18637	13804	17	_	_	NNP
18637	13804	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	13804	19	slowly	slowly	RB
18637	13804	20	winning	win	VBG
18637	13804	21	out	out	RP
18637	13804	22	against	against	IN
18637	13804	23	the	the	DT
18637	13804	24	principle	principle	NN
18637	13804	25	of	of	IN
18637	13804	26	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13804	27	.	.	.
18637	13805	1	Decrees	decree	NNS
18637	13805	2	of	of	IN
18637	13805	3	Other	other	JJ
18637	13805	4	Types	type	NNS
18637	13805	5	PROBATE	probate	NN
18637	13805	6	DECREES	decrees	VBP
18637	13805	7	Many	many	JJ
18637	13805	8	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13805	9	,	,	,
18637	13805	10	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	13805	11	of	of	IN
18637	13805	12	which	which	WDT
18637	13805	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	13805	14	given	give	VBN
18637	13805	15	rise	rise	NN
18637	13805	16	to	to	IN
18637	13805	17	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	13805	18	,	,	,
18637	13805	19	embrace	embrace	NN
18637	13805	20	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	13805	21	of	of	IN
18637	13805	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	13805	23	of	of	IN
18637	13805	24	probate	probate	NN
18637	13805	25	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	13805	26	the	the	DT
18637	13805	27	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	13805	28	of	of	IN
18637	13805	29	estates	estate	NNS
18637	13805	30	.	.	.
18637	13806	1	In	in	IN
18637	13806	2	order	order	NN
18637	13806	3	that	that	IN
18637	13806	4	a	a	DT
18637	13806	5	court	court	NN
18637	13806	6	have	have	VBP
18637	13806	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13806	8	of	of	IN
18637	13806	9	such	such	PDT
18637	13806	10	a	a	DT
18637	13806	11	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13806	12	,	,	,
18637	13806	13	the	the	DT
18637	13806	14	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	13806	15	must	must	MD
18637	13806	16	have	have	VB
18637	13806	17	been	be	VBN
18637	13806	18	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	13806	19	in	in	IN
18637	13806	20	the	the	DT
18637	13806	21	State	State	NNP
18637	13806	22	,	,	,
18637	13806	23	and	and	CC
18637	13806	24	the	the	DT
18637	13806	25	question	question	NN
18637	13806	26	whether	whether	IN
18637	13806	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13806	28	was	be	VBD
18637	13806	29	so	so	RB
18637	13806	30	domiciled	domiciled	JJ
18637	13806	31	at	at	IN
18637	13806	32	the	the	DT
18637	13806	33	time	time	NN
18637	13806	34	of	of	IN
18637	13806	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13806	36	death	death	NN
18637	13806	37	may	may	MD
18637	13806	38	be	be	VB
18637	13806	39	raised	raise	VBN
18637	13806	40	in	in	IN
18637	13806	41	the	the	DT
18637	13806	42	court	court	NN
18637	13806	43	of	of	IN
18637	13806	44	a	a	DT
18637	13806	45	sister	sister	NN
18637	13806	46	State	State	NNP
18637	13806	47	.	.	.
18637	13807	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13807	2	77	77	CD
18637	13807	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13807	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	13807	5	,	,	,
18637	13807	6	when	when	WRB
18637	13807	7	a	a	DT
18637	13807	8	court	court	NN
18637	13807	9	of	of	IN
18637	13807	10	State	State	NNP
18637	13807	11	A	A	NNP
18637	13807	12	,	,	,
18637	13807	13	in	in	IN
18637	13807	14	probating	probate	VBG
18637	13807	15	a	a	DT
18637	13807	16	will	will	NN
18637	13807	17	and	and	CC
18637	13807	18	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	13807	19	letters	letter	NNS
18637	13807	20	,	,	,
18637	13807	21	in	in	IN
18637	13807	22	a	a	DT
18637	13807	23	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13807	24	to	to	TO
18637	13807	25	which	which	WDT
18637	13807	26	all	all	DT
18637	13807	27	distributees	distributee	NNS
18637	13807	28	were	be	VBD
18637	13807	29	parties	party	NNS
18637	13807	30	,	,	,
18637	13807	31	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	13807	32	found	find	VBD
18637	13807	33	that	that	IN
18637	13807	34	the	the	DT
18637	13807	35	testator	testator	NN
18637	13807	36	's	's	POS
18637	13807	37	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13807	38	at	at	IN
18637	13807	39	the	the	DT
18637	13807	40	time	time	NN
18637	13807	41	of	of	IN
18637	13807	42	death	death	NN
18637	13807	43	was	be	VBD
18637	13807	44	in	in	IN
18637	13807	45	State	State	NNP
18637	13807	46	A	A	NNP
18637	13807	47	,	,	,
18637	13807	48	such	such	JJ
18637	13807	49	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	13807	50	of	of	IN
18637	13807	51	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13807	52	was	be	VBD
18637	13807	53	held	hold	VBN
18637	13807	54	not	not	RB
18637	13807	55	to	to	TO
18637	13807	56	bind	bind	VB
18637	13807	57	one	one	CD
18637	13807	58	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	13807	59	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	13807	60	as	as	IN
18637	13807	61	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	13807	62	administrator	administrator	NN
18637	13807	63	c.t.a	c.t.a	NNP
18637	13807	64	.	.	.
18637	13808	1	in	in	IN
18637	13808	2	State	State	NNP
18637	13808	3	B	B	NNP
18637	13808	4	,	,	,
18637	13808	5	in	in	IN
18637	13808	6	which	which	WDT
18637	13808	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13808	8	was	be	VBD
18637	13808	9	liable	liable	JJ
18637	13808	10	to	to	TO
18637	13808	11	be	be	VB
18637	13808	12	called	call	VBN
18637	13808	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	13808	14	to	to	TO
18637	13808	15	deal	deal	VB
18637	13808	16	with	with	IN
18637	13808	17	claims	claim	NNS
18637	13808	18	of	of	IN
18637	13808	19	local	local	JJ
18637	13808	20	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	13808	21	and	and	CC
18637	13808	22	that	that	DT
18637	13808	23	of	of	IN
18637	13808	24	the	the	DT
18637	13808	25	State	State	NNP
18637	13808	26	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13808	27	for	for	IN
18637	13808	28	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	13808	29	,	,	,
18637	13808	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13808	31	having	have	VBG
18637	13808	32	not	not	RB
18637	13808	33	been	be	VBN
18637	13808	34	a	a	DT
18637	13808	35	party	party	NN
18637	13808	36	to	to	IN
18637	13808	37	the	the	DT
18637	13808	38	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13808	39	in	in	IN
18637	13808	40	State	State	NNP
18637	13808	41	A.	a.	NN
18637	13809	1	In	in	IN
18637	13809	2	this	this	DT
18637	13809	3	situation	situation	NN
18637	13809	4	,	,	,
18637	13809	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13809	6	was	be	VBD
18637	13809	7	held	hold	VBN
18637	13809	8	,	,	,
18637	13809	9	a	a	DT
18637	13809	10	court	court	NN
18637	13809	11	of	of	IN
18637	13809	12	State	State	NNP
18637	13809	13	C	C	NNP
18637	13809	14	,	,	,
18637	13809	15	when	when	WRB
18637	13809	16	disposing	dispose	VBG
18637	13809	17	of	of	IN
18637	13809	18	local	local	JJ
18637	13809	19	assets	asset	NNS
18637	13809	20	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	13809	21	by	by	IN
18637	13809	22	both	both	DT
18637	13809	23	personal	personal	JJ
18637	13809	24	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	13809	25	,	,	,
18637	13809	26	was	be	VBD
18637	13809	27	free	free	JJ
18637	13809	28	to	to	TO
18637	13809	29	determine	determine	VB
18637	13809	30	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13809	31	in	in	IN
18637	13809	32	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	13809	33	with	with	IN
18637	13809	34	the	the	DT
18637	13809	35	law	law	NN
18637	13809	36	of	of	IN
18637	13809	37	State	State	NNP
18637	13809	38	C.[78	c.[78	FW
18637	13809	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13809	40	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	13809	41	,	,	,
18637	13809	42	there	there	EX
18637	13809	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	13809	44	no	no	DT
18637	13809	45	such	such	JJ
18637	13809	46	relation	relation	NN
18637	13809	47	of	of	IN
18637	13809	48	privity	privity	NN
18637	13809	49	between	between	IN
18637	13809	50	an	an	DT
18637	13809	51	executor	executor	NN
18637	13809	52	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	13809	53	in	in	IN
18637	13809	54	one	one	CD
18637	13809	55	State	State	NNP
18637	13809	56	and	and	CC
18637	13809	57	an	an	DT
18637	13809	58	administrator	administrator	NN
18637	13809	59	c.t.a	c.t.a	NN
18637	13809	60	.	.	.
18637	13810	1	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	13810	2	in	in	IN
18637	13810	3	another	another	DT
18637	13810	4	State	State	NNP
18637	13810	5	as	as	IN
18637	13810	6	will	will	MD
18637	13810	7	make	make	VB
18637	13810	8	a	a	DT
18637	13810	9	decree	decree	NN
18637	13810	10	against	against	IN
18637	13810	11	the	the	DT
18637	13810	12	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13810	13	binding	bind	VBG
18637	13810	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	13810	15	the	the	DT
18637	13810	16	former	former	JJ
18637	13810	17	.	.	.
18637	13811	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13811	2	79	79	CD
18637	13811	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13811	4	On	on	IN
18637	13811	5	the	the	DT
18637	13811	6	other	other	JJ
18637	13811	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	13811	8	,	,	,
18637	13811	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13811	10	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13811	11	in	in	IN
18637	13811	12	one	one	CD
18637	13811	13	State	State	NNP
18637	13811	14	,	,	,
18637	13811	15	under	under	IN
18637	13811	16	which	which	WDT
18637	13811	17	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	13811	18	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	13811	19	have	have	VBP
18637	13811	20	been	be	VBN
18637	13811	21	paid	pay	VBN
18637	13811	22	and	and	CC
18637	13811	23	the	the	DT
18637	13811	24	administration	administration	NN
18637	13811	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	13811	26	the	the	DT
18637	13811	27	estate	estate	NN
18637	13811	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	13811	29	been	be	VBN
18637	13811	30	closed	close	VBN
18637	13811	31	,	,	,
18637	13811	32	are	be	VBP
18637	13811	33	denied	deny	VBN
18637	13811	34	full	full	JJ
18637	13811	35	faith	faith	NN
18637	13811	36	and	and	CC
18637	13811	37	credit	credit	NN
18637	13811	38	by	by	IN
18637	13811	39	the	the	DT
18637	13811	40	action	action	NN
18637	13811	41	of	of	IN
18637	13811	42	a	a	DT
18637	13811	43	probate	probate	JJ
18637	13811	44	court	court	NN
18637	13811	45	in	in	IN
18637	13811	46	another	another	DT
18637	13811	47	State	State	NNP
18637	13811	48	in	in	IN
18637	13811	49	assuming	assume	VBG
18637	13811	50	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13811	51	and	and	CC
18637	13811	52	assessing	assess	VBG
18637	13811	53	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	13811	54	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	13811	55	against	against	IN
18637	13811	56	the	the	DT
18637	13811	57	beneficiaries	beneficiary	NNS
18637	13811	58	of	of	IN
18637	13811	59	the	the	DT
18637	13811	60	estate	estate	NN
18637	13811	61	,	,	,
18637	13811	62	when	when	WRB
18637	13811	63	under	under	IN
18637	13811	64	the	the	DT
18637	13811	65	law	law	NN
18637	13811	66	of	of	IN
18637	13811	67	the	the	DT
18637	13811	68	former	former	JJ
18637	13811	69	State	State	NNP
18637	13811	70	the	the	DT
18637	13811	71	order	order	NN
18637	13811	72	of	of	IN
18637	13811	73	the	the	DT
18637	13811	74	probate	probate	JJ
18637	13811	75	court	court	NN
18637	13811	76	barring	bar	VBG
18637	13811	77	all	all	DT
18637	13811	78	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	13811	79	who	who	WP
18637	13811	80	had	have	VBD
18637	13811	81	failed	fail	VBN
18637	13811	82	to	to	TO
18637	13811	83	bring	bring	VB
18637	13811	84	in	in	RP
18637	13811	85	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13811	86	demand	demand	NN
18637	13811	87	from	from	IN
18637	13811	88	any	any	DT
18637	13811	89	further	further	JJ
18637	13811	90	claim	claim	NN
18637	13811	91	against	against	IN
18637	13811	92	the	the	DT
18637	13811	93	executors	executor	NNS
18637	13811	94	was	be	VBD
18637	13811	95	binding	bind	VBG
18637	13811	96	upon	upon	IN
18637	13811	97	all	all	DT
18637	13811	98	.	.	.
18637	13812	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13812	2	80	80	CD
18637	13812	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13812	4	What	what	WP
18637	13812	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	13812	6	more	more	RBR
18637	13812	7	important	important	JJ
18637	13812	8	,	,	,
18637	13812	9	however	however	RB
18637	13812	10	,	,	,
18637	13812	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	13812	12	that	that	IN
18637	13812	13	the	the	DT
18637	13812	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13812	15	res	res	NNP
18637	13812	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13812	17	in	in	IN
18637	13812	18	such	such	PDT
18637	13812	19	a	a	DT
18637	13812	20	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13812	21	,	,	,
18637	13812	22	that	that	RB
18637	13812	23	is	is	RB
18637	13812	24	,	,	,
18637	13812	25	the	the	DT
18637	13812	26	estate	estate	NN
18637	13812	27	,	,	,
18637	13812	28	in	in	IN
18637	13812	29	order	order	NN
18637	13812	30	to	to	TO
18637	13812	31	entitle	entitle	VB
18637	13812	32	the	the	DT
18637	13812	33	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13812	34	to	to	TO
18637	13812	35	recognition	recognition	VB
18637	13812	36	under	under	IN
18637	13812	37	article	article	NN
18637	13812	38	IV	IV	NNP
18637	13812	39	,	,	,
18637	13812	40	section	section	NN
18637	13812	41	1	1	CD
18637	13812	42	,	,	,
18637	13812	43	must	must	MD
18637	13812	44	have	have	VB
18637	13812	45	been	be	VBN
18637	13812	46	located	locate	VBN
18637	13812	47	in	in	IN
18637	13812	48	the	the	DT
18637	13812	49	State	State	NNP
18637	13812	50	or	or	CC
18637	13812	51	legally	legally	RB
18637	13812	52	attached	attach	VBN
18637	13812	53	to	to	IN
18637	13812	54	the	the	DT
18637	13812	55	person	person	NN
18637	13812	56	of	of	IN
18637	13812	57	the	the	DT
18637	13812	58	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	13812	59	.	.	.
18637	13813	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	13813	2	a	a	DT
18637	13813	3	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13813	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	13813	5	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	13813	6	valid	valid	JJ
18637	13813	7	,	,	,
18637	13813	8	generally	generally	RB
18637	13813	9	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	13813	10	,	,	,
18637	13813	11	to	to	TO
18637	13813	12	distribute	distribute	VB
18637	13813	13	the	the	DT
18637	13813	14	intangible	intangible	JJ
18637	13813	15	property	property	NN
18637	13813	16	of	of	IN
18637	13813	17	the	the	DT
18637	13813	18	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	13813	19	,	,	,
18637	13813	20	though	though	IN
18637	13813	21	the	the	DT
18637	13813	22	evidences	evidence	NNS
18637	13813	23	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	13813	24	were	be	VBD
18637	13813	25	actually	actually	RB
18637	13813	26	located	locate	VBN
18637	13813	27	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	13813	28	.	.	.
18637	13814	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13814	2	81	81	CD
18637	13814	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13814	4	This	this	DT
18637	13814	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	13814	6	not	not	RB
18637	13814	7	so	so	RB
18637	13814	8	,	,	,
18637	13814	9	on	on	IN
18637	13814	10	the	the	DT
18637	13814	11	other	other	JJ
18637	13814	12	hand	hand	NN
18637	13814	13	,	,	,
18637	13814	14	as	as	IN
18637	13814	15	to	to	IN
18637	13814	16	tangibles	tangible	NNS
18637	13814	17	and	and	CC
18637	13814	18	realty	realty	VB
18637	13814	19	.	.	.
18637	13815	1	In	in	IN
18637	13815	2	order	order	NN
18637	13815	3	that	that	IN
18637	13815	4	the	the	DT
18637	13815	5	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13815	6	of	of	IN
18637	13815	7	a	a	DT
18637	13815	8	probate	probate	JJ
18637	13815	9	court	court	NN
18637	13815	10	distributing	distribute	VBG
18637	13815	11	these	these	DT
18637	13815	12	be	be	VB
18637	13815	13	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13815	14	to	to	IN
18637	13815	15	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13815	16	under	under	IN
18637	13815	17	the	the	DT
18637	13815	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13815	19	,	,	,
18637	13815	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13815	21	must	must	MD
18637	13815	22	have	have	VB
18637	13815	23	been	be	VBN
18637	13815	24	located	locate	VBN
18637	13815	25	in	in	IN
18637	13815	26	the	the	DT
18637	13815	27	State	State	NNP
18637	13815	28	;	;	:
18637	13815	29	as	as	IN
18637	13815	30	to	to	IN
18637	13815	31	tangibles	tangible	NNS
18637	13815	32	and	and	CC
18637	13815	33	realty	realty	VB
18637	13815	34	outside	outside	IN
18637	13815	35	the	the	DT
18637	13815	36	State	State	NNP
18637	13815	37	,	,	,
18637	13815	38	the	the	DT
18637	13815	39	decree	decree	NN
18637	13815	40	of	of	IN
18637	13815	41	the	the	DT
18637	13815	42	probate	probate	NN
18637	13815	43	court	court	NN
18637	13815	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	13815	45	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	13815	46	at	at	IN
18637	13815	47	the	the	DT
18637	13815	48	mercy	mercy	NN
18637	13815	49	of	of	IN
18637	13815	50	the	the	DT
18637	13815	51	_	_	NNP
18637	13815	52	lex	lex	NNP
18637	13815	53	rei	rei	NN
18637	13815	54	sitae	sitae	VBD
18637	13815	55	_	_	NNP
18637	13815	56	.	.	.
18637	13816	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13816	2	82	82	CD
18637	13816	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13816	4	So	so	CC
18637	13816	5	,	,	,
18637	13816	6	the	the	DT
18637	13816	7	probate	probate	NN
18637	13816	8	of	of	IN
18637	13816	9	a	a	DT
18637	13816	10	will	will	NN
18637	13816	11	in	in	IN
18637	13816	12	one	one	CD
18637	13816	13	State	state	NN
18637	13816	14	,	,	,
18637	13816	15	while	while	IN
18637	13816	16	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	13816	17	therein	therein	RB
18637	13816	18	,	,	,
18637	13816	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	13816	20	not	not	RB
18637	13816	21	displace	displace	VB
18637	13816	22	legal	legal	JJ
18637	13816	23	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	13816	24	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	13816	25	to	to	IN
18637	13816	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13816	27	validity	validity	NN
18637	13816	28	as	as	IN
18637	13816	29	a	a	DT
18637	13816	30	will	will	NN
18637	13816	31	of	of	IN
18637	13816	32	real	real	JJ
18637	13816	33	property	property	NN
18637	13816	34	in	in	IN
18637	13816	35	other	other	JJ
18637	13816	36	States	States	NNPS
18637	13816	37	.	.	.
18637	13817	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13817	2	83	83	CD
18637	13817	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13817	4	ADOPTION	ADOPTION	NNP
18637	13817	5	DECREES	decrees	VBP
18637	13817	6	That	that	IN
18637	13817	7	a	a	DT
18637	13817	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	13817	9	legitimizing	legitimize	VBG
18637	13817	10	children	child	NNS
18637	13817	11	born	bear	VBN
18637	13817	12	out	out	IN
18637	13817	13	of	of	IN
18637	13817	14	wedlock	wedlock	NN
18637	13817	15	does	do	VBZ
18637	13817	16	not	not	RB
18637	13817	17	entitle	entitle	VB
18637	13817	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13817	19	by	by	IN
18637	13817	20	the	the	DT
18637	13817	21	aid	aid	NN
18637	13817	22	of	of	IN
18637	13817	23	the	the	DT
18637	13817	24	full	full	JJ
18637	13817	25	faith	faith	NN
18637	13817	26	and	and	CC
18637	13817	27	credit	credit	NN
18637	13817	28	clause	clause	NN
18637	13817	29	to	to	TO
18637	13817	30	share	share	VB
18637	13817	31	in	in	IN
18637	13817	32	the	the	DT
18637	13817	33	property	property	NN
18637	13817	34	located	locate	VBN
18637	13817	35	in	in	IN
18637	13817	36	another	another	DT
18637	13817	37	State	state	NN
18637	13817	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	13817	39	not	not	RB
18637	13817	40	surprising	surprising	JJ
18637	13817	41	,	,	,
18637	13817	42	in	in	IN
18637	13817	43	view	view	NN
18637	13817	44	of	of	IN
18637	13817	45	the	the	DT
18637	13817	46	general	general	JJ
18637	13817	47	principle	principle	NN
18637	13817	48	--	--	:
18637	13817	49	to	to	TO
18637	13817	50	which	which	WDT
18637	13817	51	,	,	,
18637	13817	52	however	however	RB
18637	13817	53	,	,	,
18637	13817	54	there	there	EX
18637	13817	55	are	be	VBP
18637	13817	56	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	13817	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13817	58	_	_	NNP
18637	13817	59	see	see	VBP
18637	13817	60	_	_	NNP
18637	13817	61	pp	pp	NNP
18637	13817	62	.	.	.
18637	13818	1	675	675	CD
18637	13818	2	-	-	SYM
18637	13818	3	682)--that	682)--that	CD
18637	13818	4	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	13818	5	do	do	VBP
18637	13818	6	not	not	RB
18637	13818	7	have	have	VB
18637	13818	8	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	JJ
18637	13818	9	operation	operation	NN
18637	13818	10	.	.	.
18637	13819	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13819	2	84	84	CD
18637	13819	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13819	4	For	for	IN
18637	13819	5	the	the	DT
18637	13819	6	same	same	JJ
18637	13819	7	reason	reason	NN
18637	13819	8	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	13819	9	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13819	10	in	in	IN
18637	13819	11	one	one	CD
18637	13819	12	State	State	NNP
18637	13819	13	are	be	VBP
18637	13819	14	not	not	RB
18637	13819	15	denied	deny	VBN
18637	13819	16	full	full	JJ
18637	13819	17	faith	faith	NN
18637	13819	18	and	and	CC
18637	13819	19	credit	credit	NN
18637	13819	20	by	by	IN
18637	13819	21	the	the	DT
18637	13819	22	law	law	NN
18637	13819	23	of	of	IN
18637	13819	24	the	the	DT
18637	13819	25	sister	sister	NN
18637	13819	26	State	State	NNP
18637	13819	27	which	which	WDT
18637	13819	28	excludes	exclude	VBZ
18637	13819	29	children	child	NNS
18637	13819	30	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	13819	31	by	by	IN
18637	13819	32	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13819	33	in	in	IN
18637	13819	34	other	other	JJ
18637	13819	35	States	States	NNP
18637	13819	36	from	from	IN
18637	13819	37	the	the	DT
18637	13819	38	right	right	NN
18637	13819	39	to	to	TO
18637	13819	40	inherit	inherit	VB
18637	13819	41	land	land	NN
18637	13819	42	therein	therein	RB
18637	13819	43	.	.	.
18637	13820	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13820	2	85	85	CD
18637	13820	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13820	4	GARNISHMENT	GARNISHMENT	NNP
18637	13820	5	DECREES	DECREES	NNP
18637	13820	6	A	a	DT
18637	13820	7	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13820	8	which	which	WDT
18637	13820	9	combines	combine	VBZ
18637	13820	10	some	some	DT
18637	13820	11	of	of	IN
18637	13820	12	the	the	DT
18637	13820	13	elements	element	NNS
18637	13820	14	of	of	IN
18637	13820	15	both	both	CC
18637	13820	16	an	an	DT
18637	13820	17	_	_	NNP
18637	13820	18	in	in	IN
18637	13820	19	rem	rem	NNP
18637	13820	20	_	_	NNP
18637	13820	21	and	and	CC
18637	13820	22	an	an	DT
18637	13820	23	_	_	NNP
18637	13820	24	in	in	IN
18637	13820	25	personam	personam	NNP
18637	13820	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13820	27	action	action	NN
18637	13820	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	13820	29	the	the	DT
18637	13820	30	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	13820	31	in	in	IN
18637	13820	32	garnishment	garnishment	JJ
18637	13820	33	cases	case	NNS
18637	13820	34	.	.	.
18637	13821	1	Suppose	suppose	VB
18637	13821	2	that	that	IN
18637	13821	3	A	A	NNP
18637	13821	4	owes	owes	JJ
18637	13821	5	B	b	NN
18637	13821	6	and	and	CC
18637	13821	7	B	B	NNP
18637	13821	8	owes	owes	NNP
18637	13821	9	C	C	NNP
18637	13821	10	,	,	,
18637	13821	11	and	and	CC
18637	13821	12	that	that	IN
18637	13821	13	the	the	DT
18637	13821	14	two	two	CD
18637	13821	15	former	former	JJ
18637	13821	16	live	live	NN
18637	13821	17	in	in	IN
18637	13821	18	a	a	DT
18637	13821	19	different	different	JJ
18637	13821	20	State	State	NNP
18637	13821	21	than	than	IN
18637	13821	22	C.	C.	NNP
18637	13821	23	A	A	NNP
18637	13821	24	,	,	,
18637	13821	25	while	while	IN
18637	13821	26	on	on	IN
18637	13821	27	a	a	DT
18637	13821	28	brief	brief	JJ
18637	13821	29	visit	visit	NN
18637	13821	30	to	to	IN
18637	13821	31	C	C	NNP
18637	13821	32	's	's	POS
18637	13821	33	State	State	NNP
18637	13821	34	,	,	,
18637	13821	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	13821	36	presented	present	VBN
18637	13821	37	with	with	IN
18637	13821	38	a	a	DT
18637	13821	39	writ	writ	NN
18637	13821	40	attaching	attach	VBG
18637	13821	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13821	42	debt	debt	NN
18637	13821	43	to	to	IN
18637	13821	44	B	b	NN
18637	13821	45	and	and	CC
18637	13821	46	also	also	RB
18637	13821	47	a	a	DT
18637	13821	48	summons	summon	NNS
18637	13821	49	to	to	TO
18637	13821	50	appear	appear	VB
18637	13821	51	in	in	IN
18637	13821	52	court	court	NN
18637	13821	53	on	on	IN
18637	13821	54	a	a	DT
18637	13821	55	named	name	VBN
18637	13821	56	day	day	NN
18637	13821	57	.	.	.
18637	13822	1	The	the	DT
18637	13822	2	result	result	NN
18637	13822	3	of	of	IN
18637	13822	4	the	the	DT
18637	13822	5	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13822	6	thus	thus	RB
18637	13822	7	instituted	institute	VBD
18637	13822	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	13822	9	that	that	IN
18637	13822	10	a	a	DT
18637	13822	11	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13822	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	13822	13	entered	enter	VBN
18637	13822	14	in	in	IN
18637	13822	15	C	C	NNP
18637	13822	16	's	's	POS
18637	13822	17	favor	favor	NN
18637	13822	18	against	against	IN
18637	13822	19	A	a	NN
18637	13822	20	to	to	IN
18637	13822	21	the	the	DT
18637	13822	22	amount	amount	NN
18637	13822	23	of	of	IN
18637	13822	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13822	25	indebtedness	indebtedness	NN
18637	13822	26	to	to	IN
18637	13822	27	B.	B.	NNP
18637	13823	1	Subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	13823	2	A	A	NNP
18637	13823	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	13823	4	sued	sue	VBN
18637	13823	5	by	by	IN
18637	13823	6	B	b	NN
18637	13823	7	in	in	IN
18637	13823	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13823	9	home	home	NN
18637	13823	10	State	State	NNP
18637	13823	11	,	,	,
18637	13823	12	and	and	CC
18637	13823	13	offers	offer	VBZ
18637	13823	14	the	the	DT
18637	13823	15	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13823	16	,	,	,
18637	13823	17	which	which	WDT
18637	13823	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13823	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	13823	20	in	in	IN
18637	13823	21	the	the	DT
18637	13823	22	meantime	meantime	NN
18637	13823	23	paid	pay	VBN
18637	13823	24	,	,	,
18637	13823	25	in	in	IN
18637	13823	26	defense	defense	NN
18637	13823	27	.	.	.
18637	13824	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13824	2	was	be	VBD
18637	13824	3	argued	argue	VBN
18637	13824	4	in	in	IN
18637	13824	5	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	13824	6	of	of	IN
18637	13824	7	B	b	NN
18637	13824	8	that	that	IN
18637	13824	9	A	A	NNP
18637	13824	10	's	's	POS
18637	13824	11	debt	debt	NN
18637	13824	12	to	to	IN
18637	13824	13	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13824	14	had	have	VBD
18637	13824	15	a	a	DT
18637	13824	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13824	17	situs	situs	NN
18637	13824	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13824	19	in	in	IN
18637	13824	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13824	21	home	home	NN
18637	13824	22	State	State	NNP
18637	13824	23	,	,	,
18637	13824	24	and	and	CC
18637	13824	25	furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	13824	26	that	that	IN
18637	13824	27	C	C	NNP
18637	13824	28	could	could	MD
18637	13824	29	not	not	RB
18637	13824	30	have	have	VB
18637	13824	31	sued	sue	VBN
18637	13824	32	B	b	NN
18637	13824	33	in	in	IN
18637	13824	34	this	this	DT
18637	13824	35	same	same	JJ
18637	13824	36	State	state	NN
18637	13824	37	without	without	IN
18637	13824	38	formally	formally	RB
18637	13824	39	acquiring	acquire	VBG
18637	13824	40	a	a	DT
18637	13824	41	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13824	42	there	there	RB
18637	13824	43	.	.	.
18637	13825	1	Both	both	DT
18637	13825	2	propositions	proposition	NNS
18637	13825	3	were	be	VBD
18637	13825	4	,	,	,
18637	13825	5	however	however	RB
18637	13825	6	,	,	,
18637	13825	7	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	13825	8	by	by	IN
18637	13825	9	the	the	DT
18637	13825	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13825	11	,	,	,
18637	13825	12	which	which	WDT
18637	13825	13	held	hold	VBD
18637	13825	14	that	that	IN
18637	13825	15	the	the	DT
18637	13825	16	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13825	17	in	in	IN
18637	13825	18	the	the	DT
18637	13825	19	garnishment	garnishment	JJ
18637	13825	20	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13825	21	was	be	VBD
18637	13825	22	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13825	23	to	to	IN
18637	13825	24	full	full	JJ
18637	13825	25	faith	faith	NN
18637	13825	26	and	and	CC
18637	13825	27	credit	credit	NN
18637	13825	28	as	as	IN
18637	13825	29	against	against	IN
18637	13825	30	C	C	NNP
18637	13825	31	's	's	POS
18637	13825	32	action	action	NN
18637	13825	33	.	.	.
18637	13826	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13826	2	86	86	CD
18637	13826	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13826	4	FRAUD	FRAUD	NNP
18637	13826	5	AS	as	IN
18637	13826	6	A	a	NN
18637	13826	7	DEFENSE	defense	NN
18637	13826	8	TO	to	TO
18637	13826	9	SUITS	SUITS	NNP
18637	13826	10	ON	on	IN
18637	13826	11	FOREIGN	foreign	JJ
18637	13826	12	JUDGMENTS	judgment	NNS
18637	13826	13	As	as	IN
18637	13826	14	to	to	IN
18637	13826	15	whether	whether	IN
18637	13826	16	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13826	17	of	of	IN
18637	13826	18	a	a	DT
18637	13826	19	State	State	NNP
18637	13826	20	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13826	21	can	can	MD
18637	13826	22	be	be	VB
18637	13826	23	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	13826	24	by	by	IN
18637	13826	25	the	the	DT
18637	13826	26	forum	forum	NN
18637	13826	27	State	State	NNP
18637	13826	28	on	on	IN
18637	13826	29	other	other	JJ
18637	13826	30	than	than	IN
18637	13826	31	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	13826	32	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	13826	33	,	,	,
18637	13826	34	there	there	EX
18637	13826	35	are	be	VBP
18637	13826	36	_	_	NNP
18637	13826	37	dicta	dicta	NN
18637	13826	38	_	_	NNP
18637	13826	39	to	to	IN
18637	13826	40	the	the	DT
18637	13826	41	effect	effect	NN
18637	13826	42	that	that	WDT
18637	13826	43	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13826	44	,	,	,
18637	13826	45	for	for	IN
18637	13826	46	which	which	WDT
18637	13826	47	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	JJ
18637	13826	48	operation	operation	NN
18637	13826	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	13826	50	demanded	demand	VBN
18637	13826	51	under	under	IN
18637	13826	52	article	article	NN
18637	13826	53	IV	IV	NNP
18637	13826	54	,	,	,
18637	13826	55	section	section	NN
18637	13826	56	I	i	NN
18637	13826	57	and	and	CC
18637	13826	58	acts	act	NNS
18637	13826	59	of	of	IN
18637	13826	60	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13826	61	,	,	,
18637	13826	62	are	be	VBP
18637	13826	63	"	"	``
18637	13826	64	impeachable	impeachable	JJ
18637	13826	65	for	for	IN
18637	13826	66	manifest	manifest	NN
18637	13826	67	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	13826	68	.	.	.
18637	13826	69	"	"	''
18637	13827	1	But	but	CC
18637	13827	2	unless	unless	IN
18637	13827	3	the	the	DT
18637	13827	4	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	13827	5	affected	affect	VBD
18637	13827	6	the	the	DT
18637	13827	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13827	8	of	of	IN
18637	13827	9	the	the	DT
18637	13827	10	court	court	NN
18637	13827	11	,	,	,
18637	13827	12	the	the	DT
18637	13827	13	vast	vast	JJ
18637	13827	14	weight	weight	NN
18637	13827	15	of	of	IN
18637	13827	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	13827	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	13827	18	against	against	IN
18637	13827	19	the	the	DT
18637	13827	20	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	13827	21	.	.	.
18637	13828	1	Also	also	RB
18637	13828	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13828	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	13828	4	universally	universally	RB
18637	13828	5	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	13828	6	that	that	IN
18637	13828	7	a	a	DT
18637	13828	8	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13828	9	may	may	MD
18637	13828	10	not	not	RB
18637	13828	11	be	be	VB
18637	13828	12	impeached	impeach	VBN
18637	13828	13	for	for	IN
18637	13828	14	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	13828	15	error	error	NN
18637	13828	16	or	or	CC
18637	13828	17	irregularity,[87	irregularity,[87	CD
18637	13828	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13828	19	or	or	CC
18637	13828	20	as	as	RB
18637	13828	21	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	13828	22	to	to	IN
18637	13828	23	the	the	DT
18637	13828	24	public	public	JJ
18637	13828	25	policy	policy	NN
18637	13828	26	of	of	IN
18637	13828	27	the	the	DT
18637	13828	28	State	State	NNP
18637	13828	29	where	where	WRB
18637	13828	30	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13828	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	13828	32	sought	seek	VBN
18637	13828	33	for	for	IN
18637	13828	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13828	35	under	under	IN
18637	13828	36	the	the	DT
18637	13828	37	full	full	JJ
18637	13828	38	faith	faith	NN
18637	13828	39	and	and	CC
18637	13828	40	credit	credit	NN
18637	13828	41	clause	clause	NN
18637	13828	42	.	.	.
18637	13829	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13829	2	88	88	CD
18637	13829	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13829	4	Previously	previously	RB
18637	13829	5	listed	list	VBN
18637	13829	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	13829	7	indicate	indicate	VBP
18637	13829	8	,	,	,
18637	13829	9	however	however	RB
18637	13829	10	,	,	,
18637	13829	11	that	that	IN
18637	13829	12	the	the	DT
18637	13829	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13829	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	13829	15	in	in	IN
18637	13829	16	fact	fact	NN
18637	13829	17	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	13829	18	local	local	JJ
18637	13829	19	policy	policy	NN
18637	13829	20	to	to	TO
18637	13829	21	determine	determine	VB
18637	13829	22	the	the	DT
18637	13829	23	merits	merit	NNS
18637	13829	24	of	of	IN
18637	13829	25	a	a	DT
18637	13829	26	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13829	27	under	under	IN
18637	13829	28	the	the	DT
18637	13829	29	pretext	pretext	NN
18637	13829	30	of	of	IN
18637	13829	31	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	13829	32	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13829	33	.	.	.
18637	13830	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13830	2	89	89	CD
18637	13830	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13830	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	13830	5	in	in	IN
18637	13830	6	one	one	CD
18637	13830	7	case	case	NN
18637	13830	8	,	,	,
18637	13830	9	Cole	Cole	NNP
18637	13830	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13830	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	13830	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13830	13	Cunningham,[90	Cunningham,[90	NNP
18637	13830	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13830	15	the	the	DT
18637	13830	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13830	17	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	13830	18	a	a	DT
18637	13830	19	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13830	20	court	court	NN
18637	13830	21	in	in	IN
18637	13830	22	enjoining	enjoining	NN
18637	13830	23	,	,	,
18637	13830	24	in	in	IN
18637	13830	25	connection	connection	NN
18637	13830	26	with	with	IN
18637	13830	27	insolvency	insolvency	NN
18637	13830	28	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13830	29	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	13830	30	in	in	IN
18637	13830	31	that	that	DT
18637	13830	32	State	State	NNP
18637	13830	33	,	,	,
18637	13830	34	a	a	DT
18637	13830	35	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13830	36	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	13830	37	from	from	IN
18637	13830	38	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	13830	39	in	in	IN
18637	13830	40	New	New	NNP
18637	13830	41	York	York	NNP
18637	13830	42	courts	court	VBZ
18637	13830	43	an	an	DT
18637	13830	44	action	action	NN
18637	13830	45	which	which	WDT
18637	13830	46	had	have	VBD
18637	13830	47	been	be	VBN
18637	13830	48	commenced	commence	VBN
18637	13830	49	there	there	RB
18637	13830	50	before	before	IN
18637	13830	51	the	the	DT
18637	13830	52	insolvency	insolvency	NN
18637	13830	53	suit	suit	NN
18637	13830	54	was	be	VBD
18637	13830	55	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13830	56	.	.	.
18637	13831	1	This	this	DT
18637	13831	2	was	be	VBD
18637	13831	3	done	do	VBN
18637	13831	4	on	on	IN
18637	13831	5	the	the	DT
18637	13831	6	theory	theory	NN
18637	13831	7	that	that	IN
18637	13831	8	a	a	DT
18637	13831	9	party	party	NN
18637	13831	10	within	within	IN
18637	13831	11	the	the	DT
18637	13831	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13831	13	of	of	IN
18637	13831	14	a	a	DT
18637	13831	15	court	court	NN
18637	13831	16	may	may	MD
18637	13831	17	be	be	VB
18637	13831	18	restrained	restrain	VBN
18637	13831	19	from	from	IN
18637	13831	20	doing	do	VBG
18637	13831	21	something	something	NN
18637	13831	22	in	in	IN
18637	13831	23	another	another	DT
18637	13831	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13831	25	opposed	oppose	VBN
18637	13831	26	to	to	IN
18637	13831	27	principles	principle	NNS
18637	13831	28	of	of	IN
18637	13831	29	equity	equity	NN
18637	13831	30	,	,	,
18637	13831	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13831	32	having	have	VBG
18637	13831	33	been	be	VBN
18637	13831	34	shown	show	VBN
18637	13831	35	that	that	IN
18637	13831	36	the	the	DT
18637	13831	37	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	13831	38	was	be	VBD
18637	13831	39	aware	aware	JJ
18637	13831	40	of	of	IN
18637	13831	41	the	the	DT
18637	13831	42	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	13831	43	's	's	POS
18637	13831	44	embarrassed	embarrassed	JJ
18637	13831	45	condition	condition	NN
18637	13831	46	when	when	WRB
18637	13831	47	the	the	DT
18637	13831	48	New	New	NNP
18637	13831	49	York	York	NNP
18637	13831	50	action	action	NN
18637	13831	51	was	be	VBD
18637	13831	52	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	13831	53	.	.	.
18637	13832	1	The	the	DT
18637	13832	2	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	13832	3	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
18637	13832	4	denied	deny	VBD
18637	13832	5	full	full	JJ
18637	13832	6	faith	faith	NN
18637	13832	7	and	and	CC
18637	13832	8	credit	credit	NN
18637	13832	9	and	and	CC
18637	13832	10	commanded	command	VBD
18637	13832	11	the	the	DT
18637	13832	12	assent	assent	NN
18637	13832	13	of	of	IN
18637	13832	14	only	only	RB
18637	13832	15	five	five	CD
18637	13832	16	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	13832	17	.	.	.
18637	13833	1	PENAL	PENAL	NNP
18637	13833	2	JUDGMENTS	judgment	NNS
18637	13833	3	:	:	:
18637	13833	4	TYPES	types	NN
18637	13833	5	ENTITLED	entitled	NN
18637	13833	6	TO	to	IN
18637	13833	7	RECOGNITION	RECOGNITION	NNP
18637	13833	8	Finally	finally	RB
18637	13833	9	,	,	,
18637	13833	10	the	the	DT
18637	13833	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	13833	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	13833	13	been	be	VBN
18637	13833	14	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	13833	15	in	in	IN
18637	13833	16	the	the	DT
18637	13833	17	light	light	NN
18637	13833	18	of	of	IN
18637	13833	19	the	the	DT
18637	13833	20	"	"	``
18637	13833	21	incontrovertible	incontrovertible	JJ
18637	13833	22	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	13833	23	"	"	''
18637	13833	24	that	that	IN
18637	13833	25	"	"	``
18637	13833	26	the	the	DT
18637	13833	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	13833	28	of	of	IN
18637	13833	29	no	no	DT
18637	13833	30	country	country	NN
18637	13833	31	execute	execute	VB
18637	13833	32	the	the	DT
18637	13833	33	penal	penal	JJ
18637	13833	34	laws	law	NNS
18637	13833	35	of	of	IN
18637	13833	36	another	another	DT
18637	13833	37	.	.	.
18637	13834	1	"	"	``
18637	13834	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13834	3	91	91	CD
18637	13834	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13834	5	In	in	IN
18637	13834	6	the	the	DT
18637	13834	7	leading	leading	JJ
18637	13834	8	case	case	NN
18637	13834	9	of	of	IN
18637	13834	10	Huntington	Huntington	NNP
18637	13834	11	_	_	NNP
18637	13834	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	13834	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13834	14	Attrill,[92	Attrill,[92	NNP
18637	13834	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13834	16	however	however	RB
18637	13834	17	,	,	,
18637	13834	18	the	the	DT
18637	13834	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13834	20	so	so	RB
18637	13834	21	narrowly	narrowly	RB
18637	13834	22	defined	define	VBD
18637	13834	23	"	"	``
18637	13834	24	penal	penal	JJ
18637	13834	25	"	"	''
18637	13834	26	in	in	IN
18637	13834	27	this	this	DT
18637	13834	28	connection	connection	NN
18637	13834	29	as	as	IN
18637	13834	30	to	to	TO
18637	13834	31	make	make	VB
18637	13834	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13834	33	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	13834	34	synonymous	synonymous	JJ
18637	13834	35	with	with	IN
18637	13834	36	"	"	``
18637	13834	37	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	13834	38	,	,	,
18637	13834	39	"	"	''
18637	13834	40	and	and	CC
18637	13834	41	on	on	IN
18637	13834	42	this	this	DT
18637	13834	43	basis	basis	NN
18637	13834	44	held	hold	VBD
18637	13834	45	a	a	DT
18637	13834	46	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13834	47	which	which	WDT
18637	13834	48	had	have	VBD
18637	13834	49	been	be	VBN
18637	13834	50	recovered	recover	VBN
18637	13834	51	under	under	IN
18637	13834	52	a	a	DT
18637	13834	53	State	State	NNP
18637	13834	54	statute	statute	NN
18637	13834	55	making	make	VBG
18637	13834	56	the	the	DT
18637	13834	57	officers	officer	NNS
18637	13834	58	of	of	IN
18637	13834	59	a	a	DT
18637	13834	60	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13834	61	who	who	WP
18637	13834	62	signed	sign	VBD
18637	13834	63	and	and	CC
18637	13834	64	recorded	record	VBD
18637	13834	65	a	a	DT
18637	13834	66	false	false	JJ
18637	13834	67	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	13834	68	of	of	IN
18637	13834	69	the	the	DT
18637	13834	70	amount	amount	NN
18637	13834	71	of	of	IN
18637	13834	72	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13834	73	capital	capital	NN
18637	13834	74	stock	stock	NN
18637	13834	75	liable	liable	JJ
18637	13834	76	for	for	IN
18637	13834	77	all	all	DT
18637	13834	78	of	of	IN
18637	13834	79	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13834	80	debts	debt	NNS
18637	13834	81	,	,	,
18637	13834	82	to	to	TO
18637	13834	83	be	be	VB
18637	13834	84	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13834	85	under	under	IN
18637	13834	86	article	article	NN
18637	13834	87	IV	IV	NNP
18637	13834	88	,	,	,
18637	13834	89	section	section	NN
18637	13834	90	1	1	CD
18637	13834	91	,	,	,
18637	13834	92	to	to	TO
18637	13834	93	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13834	94	and	and	CC
18637	13834	95	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	13834	96	in	in	IN
18637	13834	97	the	the	DT
18637	13834	98	courts	court	NNS
18637	13834	99	of	of	IN
18637	13834	100	sister	sister	NN
18637	13834	101	States	States	NNP
18637	13834	102	.	.	.
18637	13835	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	13835	2	,	,	,
18637	13835	3	in	in	IN
18637	13835	4	general	general	JJ
18637	13835	5	,	,	,
18637	13835	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	13835	7	a	a	DT
18637	13835	8	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13835	9	for	for	IN
18637	13835	10	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	13835	11	to	to	TO
18637	13835	12	be	be	VB
18637	13835	13	denied	deny	VBN
18637	13835	14	full	full	JJ
18637	13835	15	faith	faith	NN
18637	13835	16	and	and	CC
18637	13835	17	credit	credit	NN
18637	13835	18	in	in	IN
18637	13835	19	State	State	NNP
18637	13835	20	and	and	CC
18637	13835	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13835	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	13835	23	merely	merely	RB
18637	13835	24	because	because	IN
18637	13835	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13835	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	13835	27	for	for	IN
18637	13835	28	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	13835	29	.	.	.
18637	13836	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13836	2	93	93	CD
18637	13836	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13836	4	Recognition	Recognition	NNP
18637	13836	5	of	of	IN
18637	13836	6	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	13836	7	Based	base	VBN
18637	13836	8	Upon	upon	IN
18637	13836	9	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
18637	13836	10	,	,	,
18637	13836	11	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	13836	12	,	,	,
18637	13836	13	Common	Common	NNP
18637	13836	14	Law	Law	NNP
18637	13836	15	THE	the	DT
18637	13836	16	EARLY	early	NN
18637	13836	17	RULE	rule	NN
18637	13836	18	As	as	IN
18637	13836	19	to	to	IN
18637	13836	20	the	the	DT
18637	13836	21	extrastate	extrastate	JJ
18637	13836	22	protection	protection	NN
18637	13836	23	of	of	IN
18637	13836	24	rights	right	NNS
18637	13836	25	which	which	WDT
18637	13836	26	have	have	VBP
18637	13836	27	not	not	RB
18637	13836	28	matured	mature	VBN
18637	13836	29	into	into	IN
18637	13836	30	final	final	JJ
18637	13836	31	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13836	32	,	,	,
18637	13836	33	the	the	DT
18637	13836	34	full	full	JJ
18637	13836	35	faith	faith	NN
18637	13836	36	and	and	CC
18637	13836	37	credit	credit	NN
18637	13836	38	clause	clause	NN
18637	13836	39	has	have	VBZ
18637	13836	40	never	never	RB
18637	13836	41	abolished	abolish	VBN
18637	13836	42	the	the	DT
18637	13836	43	general	general	JJ
18637	13836	44	principle	principle	NN
18637	13836	45	of	of	IN
18637	13836	46	the	the	DT
18637	13836	47	dominance	dominance	NN
18637	13836	48	of	of	IN
18637	13836	49	local	local	JJ
18637	13836	50	policy	policy	NN
18637	13836	51	over	over	IN
18637	13836	52	the	the	DT
18637	13836	53	rules	rule	NNS
18637	13836	54	of	of	IN
18637	13836	55	comity	comity	NN
18637	13836	56	.	.	.
18637	13837	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13837	2	94	94	CD
18637	13837	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13837	4	This	this	DT
18637	13837	5	was	be	VBD
18637	13837	6	stated	state	VBN
18637	13837	7	by	by	IN
18637	13837	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13837	9	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	13837	10	in	in	IN
18637	13837	11	the	the	DT
18637	13837	12	Dred	Dred	NNP
18637	13837	13	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	13837	14	case	case	NN
18637	13837	15	,	,	,
18637	13837	16	as	as	IN
18637	13837	17	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	13837	18	:	:	:
18637	13837	19	"	"	``
18637	13837	20	No	no	DT
18637	13837	21	State	State	NNP
18637	13837	22	,	,	,
18637	13837	23	*	*	NFP
18637	13837	24	*	*	NFP
18637	13837	25	*	*	NFP
18637	13837	26	,	,	,
18637	13837	27	can	can	MD
18637	13837	28	enact	enact	VB
18637	13837	29	laws	law	NNS
18637	13837	30	to	to	TO
18637	13837	31	operate	operate	VB
18637	13837	32	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	13837	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13837	34	own	own	JJ
18637	13837	35	dominions	dominion	NNS
18637	13837	36	,	,	,
18637	13837	37	*	*	NFP
18637	13837	38	*	*	NFP
18637	13837	39	*	*	NFP
18637	13837	40	Nations	nation	NNS
18637	13837	41	,	,	,
18637	13837	42	from	from	IN
18637	13837	43	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	13837	44	and	and	CC
18637	13837	45	comity	comity	NN
18637	13837	46	,	,	,
18637	13837	47	*	*	NFP
18637	13837	48	*	*	NFP
18637	13837	49	*	*	NFP
18637	13837	50	,	,	,
18637	13837	51	recognizes	recognize	VBZ
18637	13837	52	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13837	53	sic	sic	NN
18637	13837	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13837	55	and	and	CC
18637	13837	56	administer	administer	VB
18637	13837	57	the	the	DT
18637	13837	58	laws	law	NNS
18637	13837	59	of	of	IN
18637	13837	60	other	other	JJ
18637	13837	61	countries	country	NNS
18637	13837	62	.	.	.
18637	13838	1	But	but	CC
18637	13838	2	,	,	,
18637	13838	3	of	of	IN
18637	13838	4	the	the	DT
18637	13838	5	nature	nature	NN
18637	13838	6	,	,	,
18637	13838	7	extent	extent	NN
18637	13838	8	,	,	,
18637	13838	9	and	and	CC
18637	13838	10	utility	utility	NN
18637	13838	11	,	,	,
18637	13838	12	of	of	IN
18637	13838	13	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13838	14	,	,	,
18637	13838	15	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	13838	16	property	property	NN
18637	13838	17	,	,	,
18637	13838	18	or	or	CC
18637	13838	19	the	the	DT
18637	13838	20	state	state	NN
18637	13838	21	and	and	CC
18637	13838	22	condition	condition	NN
18637	13838	23	of	of	IN
18637	13838	24	persons	person	NNS
18637	13838	25	within	within	IN
18637	13838	26	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13838	27	territories	territory	NNS
18637	13838	28	,	,	,
18637	13838	29	each	each	DT
18637	13838	30	nation	nation	NN
18637	13838	31	judges	judge	VBZ
18637	13838	32	for	for	IN
18637	13838	33	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13838	34	;	;	:
18637	13838	35	*	*	NFP
18637	13838	36	*	*	NFP
18637	13838	37	*	*	NFP
18637	13838	38	"	"	''
18637	13838	39	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13838	40	added	add	VBD
18637	13838	41	that	that	IN
18637	13838	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13838	43	was	be	VBD
18637	13838	44	the	the	DT
18637	13838	45	same	same	JJ
18637	13838	46	with	with	IN
18637	13838	47	the	the	DT
18637	13838	48	States	States	NNP
18637	13838	49	of	of	IN
18637	13838	50	the	the	DT
18637	13838	51	Union	Union	NNP
18637	13838	52	in	in	IN
18637	13838	53	relation	relation	NN
18637	13838	54	to	to	IN
18637	13838	55	another	another	DT
18637	13838	56	.	.	.
18637	13839	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13839	2	followed	follow	VBD
18637	13839	3	that	that	IN
18637	13839	4	even	even	RB
18637	13839	5	though	though	IN
18637	13839	6	Dred	Dred	NNP
18637	13839	7	had	have	VBD
18637	13839	8	become	become	VBN
18637	13839	9	a	a	DT
18637	13839	10	free	free	JJ
18637	13839	11	man	man	NN
18637	13839	12	in	in	IN
18637	13839	13	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	13839	14	of	of	IN
18637	13839	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13839	16	having	have	VBG
18637	13839	17	resided	reside	VBN
18637	13839	18	in	in	IN
18637	13839	19	the	the	DT
18637	13839	20	"	"	``
18637	13839	21	free	free	JJ
18637	13839	22	"	"	''
18637	13839	23	State	State	NNP
18637	13839	24	of	of	IN
18637	13839	25	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	13839	26	,	,	,
18637	13839	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13839	28	had	have	VBD
18637	13839	29	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	13839	30	upon	upon	IN
18637	13839	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13839	32	return	return	NN
18637	13839	33	to	to	IN
18637	13839	34	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	13839	35	,	,	,
18637	13839	36	which	which	WDT
18637	13839	37	had	have	VBD
18637	13839	38	the	the	DT
18637	13839	39	same	same	JJ
18637	13839	40	power	power	NN
18637	13839	41	as	as	IN
18637	13839	42	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	13839	43	to	to	TO
18637	13839	44	determine	determine	VB
18637	13839	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13839	46	local	local	JJ
18637	13839	47	policy	policy	NN
18637	13839	48	respecting	respecting	NN
18637	13839	49	rights	right	NNS
18637	13839	50	acquired	acquire	VBD
18637	13839	51	extraterritorially	extraterritorially	RB
18637	13839	52	,	,	,
18637	13839	53	reverted	revert	VBN
18637	13839	54	to	to	TO
18637	13839	55	servitude	servitude	VB
18637	13839	56	under	under	IN
18637	13839	57	the	the	DT
18637	13839	58	laws	law	NNS
18637	13839	59	and	and	CC
18637	13839	60	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13839	61	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	13839	62	of	of	IN
18637	13839	63	that	that	DT
18637	13839	64	State	State	NNP
18637	13839	65	.	.	.
18637	13840	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13840	2	95	95	CD
18637	13840	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13840	4	DEVELOPMENT	development	NN
18637	13840	5	OF	of	IN
18637	13840	6	THE	the	DT
18637	13840	7	MODERN	MODERN	NNP
18637	13840	8	RULE	rule	NN
18637	13840	9	In	in	IN
18637	13840	10	a	a	DT
18637	13840	11	case	case	NN
18637	13840	12	decided	decide	VBN
18637	13840	13	in	in	IN
18637	13840	14	1887	1887	CD
18637	13840	15	,	,	,
18637	13840	16	however	however	RB
18637	13840	17	,	,	,
18637	13840	18	the	the	DT
18637	13840	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13840	20	remarked	remark	VBD
18637	13840	21	:	:	:
18637	13840	22	"	"	``
18637	13840	23	Without	without	IN
18637	13840	24	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	13840	25	the	the	DT
18637	13840	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	13840	27	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	13840	28	,	,	,
18637	13840	29	Art	art	NN
18637	13840	30	.	.	.
18637	13841	1	IV	IV	NNP
18637	13841	2	,	,	,
18637	13841	3	§	§	NNP
18637	13841	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13841	5	,	,	,
18637	13841	6	that	that	IN
18637	13841	7	'	'	``
18637	13841	8	full	full	JJ
18637	13841	9	faith	faith	NN
18637	13841	10	and	and	CC
18637	13841	11	credit	credit	NN
18637	13841	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	13841	13	be	be	VB
18637	13841	14	given	give	VBN
18637	13841	15	in	in	IN
18637	13841	16	each	each	DT
18637	13841	17	State	state	NN
18637	13841	18	to	to	IN
18637	13841	19	the	the	DT
18637	13841	20	public	public	JJ
18637	13841	21	acts	act	NNS
18637	13841	22	,	,	,
18637	13841	23	records	record	NNS
18637	13841	24	,	,	,
18637	13841	25	and	and	CC
18637	13841	26	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13841	27	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13841	28	of	of	IN
18637	13841	29	every	every	DT
18637	13841	30	other	other	JJ
18637	13841	31	State	State	NNP
18637	13841	32	,	,	,
18637	13841	33	'	'	''
18637	13841	34	implies	imply	VBZ
18637	13841	35	that	that	IN
18637	13841	36	the	the	DT
18637	13841	37	public	public	JJ
18637	13841	38	acts	act	NNS
18637	13841	39	of	of	IN
18637	13841	40	every	every	DT
18637	13841	41	State	state	NN
18637	13841	42	shall	shall	MD
18637	13841	43	be	be	VB
18637	13841	44	given	give	VBN
18637	13841	45	the	the	DT
18637	13841	46	same	same	JJ
18637	13841	47	effect	effect	NN
18637	13841	48	by	by	IN
18637	13841	49	the	the	DT
18637	13841	50	courts	court	NNS
18637	13841	51	of	of	IN
18637	13841	52	another	another	DT
18637	13841	53	State	State	NNP
18637	13841	54	that	that	WDT
18637	13841	55	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13841	56	have	have	VBP
18637	13841	57	by	by	IN
18637	13841	58	law	law	NN
18637	13841	59	and	and	CC
18637	13841	60	usage	usage	NN
18637	13841	61	at	at	IN
18637	13841	62	home	home	NN
18637	13841	63	.	.	.
18637	13842	1	"	"	``
18637	13842	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13842	3	96	96	CD
18637	13842	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13842	5	And	and	CC
18637	13842	6	this	this	DT
18637	13842	7	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	13842	8	was	be	VBD
18637	13842	9	later	later	RB
18637	13842	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	13842	11	to	to	TO
18637	13842	12	extend	extend	VB
18637	13842	13	to	to	IN
18637	13842	14	State	state	NN
18637	13842	15	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	13842	16	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	13842	17	.	.	.
18637	13843	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13843	2	97	97	CD
18637	13843	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13843	4	More	more	RBR
18637	13843	5	recently	recently	RB
18637	13843	6	this	this	DT
18637	13843	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	13843	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	13843	9	been	be	VBN
18637	13843	10	stated	state	VBN
18637	13843	11	in	in	IN
18637	13843	12	a	a	DT
18637	13843	13	very	very	RB
18637	13843	14	mitigated	mitigate	VBN
18637	13843	15	form	form	NN
18637	13843	16	,	,	,
18637	13843	17	the	the	DT
18637	13843	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13843	19	saying	say	VBG
18637	13843	20	that	that	IN
18637	13843	21	where	where	WRB
18637	13843	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	13843	23	or	or	CC
18637	13843	24	policy	policy	NN
18637	13843	25	of	of	IN
18637	13843	26	the	the	DT
18637	13843	27	forum	forum	NN
18637	13843	28	State	State	NNP
18637	13843	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	13843	30	set	set	VBN
18637	13843	31	up	up	RP
18637	13843	32	as	as	IN
18637	13843	33	a	a	DT
18637	13843	34	defense	defense	NN
18637	13843	35	to	to	IN
18637	13843	36	a	a	DT
18637	13843	37	suit	suit	NN
18637	13843	38	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13843	39	under	under	IN
18637	13843	40	the	the	DT
18637	13843	41	statute	statute	NN
18637	13843	42	of	of	IN
18637	13843	43	another	another	DT
18637	13843	44	State	State	NNP
18637	13843	45	or	or	CC
18637	13843	46	territory	territory	NN
18637	13843	47	,	,	,
18637	13843	48	or	or	CC
18637	13843	49	where	where	WRB
18637	13843	50	a	a	DT
18637	13843	51	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13843	52	statute	statute	NN
18637	13843	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	13843	54	set	set	VBN
18637	13843	55	up	up	RP
18637	13843	56	as	as	IN
18637	13843	57	a	a	DT
18637	13843	58	defense	defense	NN
18637	13843	59	to	to	IN
18637	13843	60	a	a	DT
18637	13843	61	suit	suit	NN
18637	13843	62	or	or	CC
18637	13843	63	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13843	64	under	under	IN
18637	13843	65	a	a	DT
18637	13843	66	local	local	JJ
18637	13843	67	statute	statute	NN
18637	13843	68	,	,	,
18637	13843	69	the	the	DT
18637	13843	70	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	13843	71	is	be	VBZ
18637	13843	72	to	to	TO
18637	13843	73	be	be	VB
18637	13843	74	resolved	resolve	VBN
18637	13843	75	,	,	,
18637	13843	76	not	not	RB
18637	13843	77	by	by	IN
18637	13843	78	giving	give	VBG
18637	13843	79	automatic	automatic	JJ
18637	13843	80	effect	effect	NN
18637	13843	81	to	to	IN
18637	13843	82	the	the	DT
18637	13843	83	full	full	JJ
18637	13843	84	faith	faith	NN
18637	13843	85	and	and	CC
18637	13843	86	credit	credit	NN
18637	13843	87	clause	clause	NN
18637	13843	88	and	and	CC
18637	13843	89	thus	thus	RB
18637	13843	90	compelling	compelling	JJ
18637	13843	91	courts	court	NNS
18637	13843	92	of	of	IN
18637	13843	93	each	each	DT
18637	13843	94	State	state	NN
18637	13843	95	to	to	TO
18637	13843	96	subordinate	subordinate	VB
18637	13843	97	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13843	98	own	own	JJ
18637	13843	99	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	13843	100	to	to	IN
18637	13843	101	those	those	DT
18637	13843	102	of	of	IN
18637	13843	103	others	other	NNS
18637	13843	104	,	,	,
18637	13843	105	but	but	CC
18637	13843	106	by	by	IN
18637	13843	107	appraising	appraise	VBG
18637	13843	108	the	the	DT
18637	13843	109	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	13843	110	interest	interest	NN
18637	13843	111	of	of	IN
18637	13843	112	each	each	DT
18637	13843	113	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13843	114	and	and	CC
18637	13843	115	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	13843	116	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	13843	117	.	.	.
18637	13844	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13844	2	98	98	CD
18637	13844	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13844	4	Obviously	obviously	RB
18637	13844	5	this	this	DT
18637	13844	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	13844	7	endows	endow	VBZ
18637	13844	8	the	the	DT
18637	13844	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13844	10	with	with	IN
18637	13844	11	something	something	NN
18637	13844	12	akin	akin	JJ
18637	13844	13	to	to	IN
18637	13844	14	an	an	DT
18637	13844	15	arbitral	arbitral	JJ
18637	13844	16	function	function	NN
18637	13844	17	in	in	IN
18637	13844	18	the	the	DT
18637	13844	19	decision	decision	NN
18637	13844	20	of	of	IN
18637	13844	21	cases	case	NNS
18637	13844	22	to	to	TO
18637	13844	23	which	which	WDT
18637	13844	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13844	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	13844	26	applied	apply	VBN
18637	13844	27	.	.	.
18637	13845	1	TRANSITORY	TRANSITORY	NNP
18637	13845	2	ACTIONS	action	NNS
18637	13845	3	:	:	:
18637	13845	4	DEATH	death	NN
18637	13845	5	STATUTES	statute	NNS
18637	13845	6	The	the	DT
18637	13845	7	initial	initial	JJ
18637	13845	8	effort	effort	NN
18637	13845	9	in	in	IN
18637	13845	10	this	this	DT
18637	13845	11	direction	direction	NN
18637	13845	12	was	be	VBD
18637	13845	13	made	make	VBN
18637	13845	14	in	in	IN
18637	13845	15	connection	connection	NN
18637	13845	16	with	with	IN
18637	13845	17	transitory	transitory	JJ
18637	13845	18	actions	action	NNS
18637	13845	19	based	base	VBN
18637	13845	20	on	on	IN
18637	13845	21	statute	statute	NN
18637	13845	22	.	.	.
18637	13846	1	Earlier	early	RBR
18637	13846	2	,	,	,
18637	13846	3	such	such	JJ
18637	13846	4	actions	action	NNS
18637	13846	5	had	have	VBD
18637	13846	6	rested	rest	VBN
18637	13846	7	upon	upon	IN
18637	13846	8	the	the	DT
18637	13846	9	common	common	JJ
18637	13846	10	law	law	NN
18637	13846	11	,	,	,
18637	13846	12	which	which	WDT
18637	13846	13	was	be	VBD
18637	13846	14	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	13846	15	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	13846	16	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	13846	17	the	the	DT
18637	13846	18	States	States	NNPS
18637	13846	19	,	,	,
18637	13846	20	so	so	IN
18637	13846	21	that	that	IN
18637	13846	22	there	there	EX
18637	13846	23	was	be	VBD
18637	13846	24	usually	usually	RB
18637	13846	25	little	little	JJ
18637	13846	26	discrepancy	discrepancy	NN
18637	13846	27	between	between	IN
18637	13846	28	the	the	DT
18637	13846	29	law	law	NN
18637	13846	30	under	under	IN
18637	13846	31	which	which	WDT
18637	13846	32	the	the	DT
18637	13846	33	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	13846	34	from	from	IN
18637	13846	35	another	another	DT
18637	13846	36	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13846	37	brought	bring	VBD
18637	13846	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13846	39	action	action	NN
18637	13846	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13846	41	_	_	NNP
18637	13846	42	lex	lex	NN
18637	13846	43	loci	loci	NN
18637	13846	44	_	_	NNP
18637	13846	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13846	46	and	and	CC
18637	13846	47	the	the	DT
18637	13846	48	law	law	NN
18637	13846	49	under	under	IN
18637	13846	50	which	which	WDT
18637	13846	51	the	the	DT
18637	13846	52	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13846	53	responded	respond	VBD
18637	13846	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13846	55	_	_	NNP
18637	13846	56	lex	lex	NNP
18637	13846	57	fori	fori	NN
18637	13846	58	_	_	NNP
18637	13846	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13846	60	.	.	.
18637	13847	1	In	in	IN
18637	13847	2	the	the	DT
18637	13847	3	late	late	JJ
18637	13847	4	seventies	seventy	NNS
18637	13847	5	,	,	,
18637	13847	6	however	however	RB
18637	13847	7	,	,	,
18637	13847	8	the	the	DT
18637	13847	9	States	States	NNP
18637	13847	10	,	,	,
18637	13847	11	abandoning	abandon	VBG
18637	13847	12	the	the	DT
18637	13847	13	common	common	JJ
18637	13847	14	law	law	NN
18637	13847	15	rule	rule	NN
18637	13847	16	on	on	IN
18637	13847	17	the	the	DT
18637	13847	18	subject	subject	NN
18637	13847	19	,	,	,
18637	13847	20	began	begin	VBD
18637	13847	21	passing	pass	VBG
18637	13847	22	laws	law	NNS
18637	13847	23	which	which	WDT
18637	13847	24	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	13847	25	the	the	DT
18637	13847	26	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	13847	27	of	of	IN
18637	13847	28	a	a	DT
18637	13847	29	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	13847	30	whose	whose	WP$
18637	13847	31	death	death	NN
18637	13847	32	had	have	VBD
18637	13847	33	resulted	result	VBN
18637	13847	34	from	from	IN
18637	13847	35	injury	injury	NN
18637	13847	36	to	to	TO
18637	13847	37	bring	bring	VB
18637	13847	38	an	an	DT
18637	13847	39	action	action	NN
18637	13847	40	for	for	IN
18637	13847	41	damages	damage	NNS
18637	13847	42	.	.	.
18637	13848	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13848	2	99	99	CD
18637	13848	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13848	4	The	the	DT
18637	13848	5	question	question	NN
18637	13848	6	at	at	IN
18637	13848	7	once	once	RB
18637	13848	8	presented	present	VBD
18637	13848	9	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13848	10	whether	whether	IN
18637	13848	11	,	,	,
18637	13848	12	if	if	IN
18637	13848	13	such	such	PDT
18637	13848	14	an	an	DT
18637	13848	15	action	action	NN
18637	13848	16	was	be	VBD
18637	13848	17	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13848	18	in	in	RP
18637	13848	19	a	a	DT
18637	13848	20	State	state	NN
18637	13848	21	other	other	JJ
18637	13848	22	than	than	IN
18637	13848	23	that	that	DT
18637	13848	24	in	in	IN
18637	13848	25	which	which	WDT
18637	13848	26	the	the	DT
18637	13848	27	injury	injury	NN
18637	13848	28	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	13848	29	,	,	,
18637	13848	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13848	31	was	be	VBD
18637	13848	32	governed	govern	VBN
18637	13848	33	by	by	IN
18637	13848	34	the	the	DT
18637	13848	35	statute	statute	NN
18637	13848	36	under	under	IN
18637	13848	37	which	which	WDT
18637	13848	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13848	39	arose	arise	VBD
18637	13848	40	or	or	CC
18637	13848	41	by	by	IN
18637	13848	42	the	the	DT
18637	13848	43	law	law	NN
18637	13848	44	of	of	IN
18637	13848	45	the	the	DT
18637	13848	46	forum	forum	NN
18637	13848	47	State	State	NNP
18637	13848	48	,	,	,
18637	13848	49	which	which	WDT
18637	13848	50	might	may	MD
18637	13848	51	be	be	VB
18637	13848	52	less	less	RBR
18637	13848	53	favorable	favorable	JJ
18637	13848	54	to	to	IN
18637	13848	55	the	the	DT
18637	13848	56	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13848	57	.	.	.
18637	13849	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	13849	2	was	be	VBD
18637	13849	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13849	4	long	long	JJ
18637	13849	5	before	before	IN
18637	13849	6	the	the	DT
18637	13849	7	same	same	JJ
18637	13849	8	question	question	NN
18637	13849	9	presented	present	VBD
18637	13849	10	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13849	11	with	with	IN
18637	13849	12	respect	respect	NN
18637	13849	13	to	to	IN
18637	13849	14	transitory	transitory	JJ
18637	13849	15	action	action	NN
18637	13849	16	_	_	NNP
18637	13849	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	13849	18	contractu	contractu	NN
18637	13849	19	_	_	NNP
18637	13849	20	,	,	,
18637	13849	21	where	where	WRB
18637	13849	22	the	the	DT
18637	13849	23	contract	contract	NN
18637	13849	24	involved	involve	VBN
18637	13849	25	had	have	VBD
18637	13849	26	been	be	VBN
18637	13849	27	made	make	VBN
18637	13849	28	under	under	IN
18637	13849	29	laws	law	NNS
18637	13849	30	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	13849	31	to	to	IN
18637	13849	32	the	the	DT
18637	13849	33	State	State	NNP
18637	13849	34	where	where	WRB
18637	13849	35	made	make	VBN
18637	13849	36	,	,	,
18637	13849	37	and	and	CC
18637	13849	38	with	with	IN
18637	13849	39	those	those	DT
18637	13849	40	laws	law	NNS
18637	13849	41	in	in	IN
18637	13849	42	view	view	NN
18637	13849	43	.	.	.
18637	13850	1	ACTIONS	actions	JJ
18637	13850	2	UPON	upon	NN
18637	13850	3	CONTRACT	contract	NN
18637	13850	4	:	:	:
18637	13850	5	WHEN	when	WRB
18637	13850	6	GOVERNED	governed	NN
18637	13850	7	BY	by	IN
18637	13850	8	LAW	law	NN
18637	13850	9	OF	of	IN
18637	13850	10	PLACE	PLACE	NNP
18637	13850	11	OF	of	IN
18637	13850	12	MAKING	make	VBG
18637	13850	13	In	in	IN
18637	13850	14	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	13850	15	and	and	CC
18637	13850	16	Alton	Alton	NNP
18637	13850	17	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	13851	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13851	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	13851	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13851	4	Wiggins,[100	Wiggins,[100	NNP
18637	13851	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13851	6	referred	refer	VBD
18637	13851	7	to	to	IN
18637	13851	8	above	above	RB
18637	13851	9	,	,	,
18637	13851	10	the	the	DT
18637	13851	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13851	12	,	,	,
18637	13851	13	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	13851	14	with	with	IN
18637	13851	15	the	the	DT
18637	13851	16	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13851	17	form	form	NN
18637	13851	18	of	of	IN
18637	13851	19	the	the	DT
18637	13851	20	question	question	NN
18637	13851	21	,	,	,
18637	13851	22	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	13851	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13851	24	clear	clear	JJ
18637	13851	25	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	13851	26	that	that	IN
18637	13851	27	in	in	IN
18637	13851	28	such	such	JJ
18637	13851	29	situations	situation	NNS
18637	13851	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13851	31	was	be	VBD
18637	13851	32	the	the	DT
18637	13851	33	law	law	NN
18637	13851	34	under	under	IN
18637	13851	35	which	which	WDT
18637	13851	36	the	the	DT
18637	13851	37	contract	contract	NN
18637	13851	38	was	be	VBD
18637	13851	39	made	make	VBN
18637	13851	40	,	,	,
18637	13851	41	not	not	RB
18637	13851	42	the	the	DT
18637	13851	43	law	law	NN
18637	13851	44	of	of	IN
18637	13851	45	the	the	DT
18637	13851	46	forum	forum	NN
18637	13851	47	State	State	NNP
18637	13851	48	,	,	,
18637	13851	49	which	which	WDT
18637	13851	50	should	should	MD
18637	13851	51	govern	govern	VB
18637	13851	52	.	.	.
18637	13852	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13852	2	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	13852	3	on	on	IN
18637	13852	4	the	the	DT
18637	13852	5	point	point	NN
18637	13852	6	was	be	VBD
18637	13852	7	,	,	,
18637	13852	8	however	however	RB
18637	13852	9	,	,	,
18637	13852	10	not	not	RB
18637	13852	11	merely	merely	RB
18637	13852	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13852	13	obiter	obiter	NN
18637	13852	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13852	15	;	;	:
18637	13852	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13852	17	was	be	VBD
18637	13852	18	based	base	VBN
18637	13852	19	on	on	IN
18637	13852	20	an	an	DT
18637	13852	21	error	error	NN
18637	13852	22	,	,	,
18637	13852	23	namely	namely	RB
18637	13852	24	,	,	,
18637	13852	25	the	the	DT
18637	13852	26	false	false	JJ
18637	13852	27	supposition	supposition	NN
18637	13852	28	that	that	IN
18637	13852	29	the	the	DT
18637	13852	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13852	31	gives	give	VBZ
18637	13852	32	"	"	``
18637	13852	33	acts	act	NNS
18637	13852	34	"	"	''
18637	13852	35	the	the	DT
18637	13852	36	same	same	JJ
18637	13852	37	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	JJ
18637	13852	38	operation	operation	NN
18637	13852	39	as	as	IN
18637	13852	40	the	the	DT
18637	13852	41	act	act	NN
18637	13852	42	of	of	IN
18637	13852	43	1790	1790	CD
18637	13852	44	does	do	VBZ
18637	13852	45	"	"	``
18637	13852	46	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13852	47	records	record	NNS
18637	13852	48	and	and	CC
18637	13852	49	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13852	50	.	.	.
18637	13852	51	"	"	''
18637	13853	1	Notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	13853	2	which	which	WDT
18637	13853	3	,	,	,
18637	13853	4	this	this	DT
18637	13853	5	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	13853	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	13853	7	today	today	NN
18637	13853	8	the	the	DT
18637	13853	9	basis	basis	NN
18637	13853	10	of	of	IN
18637	13853	11	"	"	``
18637	13853	12	the	the	DT
18637	13853	13	settled	settle	VBN
18637	13853	14	rule	rule	NN
18637	13853	15	"	"	''
18637	13853	16	that	that	IN
18637	13853	17	the	the	DT
18637	13853	18	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13853	19	in	in	IN
18637	13853	20	a	a	DT
18637	13853	21	transitory	transitory	JJ
18637	13853	22	action	action	NN
18637	13853	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	13853	24	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13853	25	to	to	IN
18637	13853	26	all	all	PDT
18637	13853	27	the	the	DT
18637	13853	28	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	13853	29	resulting	result	VBG
18637	13853	30	from	from	IN
18637	13853	31	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	13853	32	material	material	NN
18637	13853	33	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	13853	34	the	the	DT
18637	13853	35	statute	statute	NN
18637	13853	36	under	under	IN
18637	13853	37	which	which	WDT
18637	13853	38	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	13853	39	's	's	POS
18637	13853	40	right	right	NN
18637	13853	41	of	of	IN
18637	13853	42	action	action	NN
18637	13853	43	originated	originate	VBD
18637	13853	44	sets	set	NNS
18637	13853	45	thereto	thereto	NNP
18637	13853	46	,	,	,
18637	13853	47	except	except	IN
18637	13853	48	that	that	IN
18637	13853	49	courts	court	NNS
18637	13853	50	of	of	IN
18637	13853	51	sister	sister	NN
18637	13853	52	States	States	NNP
18637	13853	53	can	can	MD
18637	13853	54	not	not	RB
18637	13853	55	be	be	VB
18637	13853	56	thus	thus	RB
18637	13853	57	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	13853	58	from	from	IN
18637	13853	59	taking	take	VBG
18637	13853	60	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13853	61	in	in	IN
18637	13853	62	such	such	JJ
18637	13853	63	cases	case	NNS
18637	13853	64	.	.	.
18637	13854	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13854	2	101	101	CD
18637	13854	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13854	4	However	however	RB
18637	13854	5	,	,	,
18637	13854	6	a	a	DT
18637	13854	7	State	State	NNP
18637	13854	8	court	court	NN
18637	13854	9	does	do	VBZ
18637	13854	10	not	not	RB
18637	13854	11	violate	violate	VB
18637	13854	12	the	the	DT
18637	13854	13	full	full	JJ
18637	13854	14	faith	faith	NN
18637	13854	15	and	and	CC
18637	13854	16	credit	credit	NN
18637	13854	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	13854	18	by	by	IN
18637	13854	19	mere	mere	JJ
18637	13854	20	error	error	NN
18637	13854	21	in	in	IN
18637	13854	22	construing	construe	VBG
18637	13854	23	the	the	DT
18637	13854	24	law	law	NN
18637	13854	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	13854	26	which	which	WDT
18637	13854	27	a	a	DT
18637	13854	28	transitory	transitory	JJ
18637	13854	29	action	action	NN
18637	13854	30	from	from	IN
18637	13854	31	another	another	DT
18637	13854	32	state	state	NN
18637	13854	33	depends;[102	depends;[102	ADD
18637	13854	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13854	35	nor	nor	CC
18637	13854	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	13854	37	a	a	DT
18637	13854	38	court	court	NN
18637	13854	39	of	of	IN
18637	13854	40	the	the	DT
18637	13854	41	forum	forum	NN
18637	13854	42	State	State	NNP
18637	13854	43	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	13854	44	of	of	IN
18637	13854	45	a	a	DT
18637	13854	46	disregard	disregard	NN
18637	13854	47	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	13854	48	when	when	WRB
18637	13854	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13854	50	entertains	entertain	VBZ
18637	13854	51	a	a	DT
18637	13854	52	suit	suit	NN
18637	13854	53	based	base	VBN
18637	13854	54	on	on	IN
18637	13854	55	a	a	DT
18637	13854	56	statute	statute	NN
18637	13854	57	of	of	IN
18637	13854	58	another	another	DT
18637	13854	59	State	State	NNP
18637	13854	60	,	,	,
18637	13854	61	albeit	albeit	IN
18637	13854	62	the	the	DT
18637	13854	63	statute	statute	NN
18637	13854	64	in	in	IN
18637	13854	65	terms	term	NNS
18637	13854	66	limits	limit	VBZ
18637	13854	67	actions	action	NNS
18637	13854	68	thereunder	thereunder	VBP
18637	13854	69	to	to	IN
18637	13854	70	courts	court	NNS
18637	13854	71	of	of	IN
18637	13854	72	the	the	DT
18637	13854	73	enacting	enact	VBG
18637	13854	74	State	State	NNP
18637	13854	75	.	.	.
18637	13855	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13855	2	103	103	CD
18637	13855	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13855	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	13855	5	,	,	,
18637	13855	6	in	in	IN
18637	13855	7	actions	action	NNS
18637	13855	8	on	on	IN
18637	13855	9	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	13855	10	made	make	VBN
18637	13855	11	in	in	IN
18637	13855	12	other	other	JJ
18637	13855	13	States	States	NNP
18637	13855	14	,	,	,
18637	13855	15	a	a	DT
18637	13855	16	State	state	NN
18637	13855	17	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	13855	18	may	may	MD
18637	13855	19	decline	decline	VB
18637	13855	20	to	to	TO
18637	13855	21	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	13855	22	in	in	IN
18637	13855	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13855	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	13855	25	,	,	,
18637	13855	26	as	as	RB
18637	13855	27	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	13855	28	to	to	IN
18637	13855	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13855	30	own	own	JJ
18637	13855	31	policy	policy	NN
18637	13855	32	,	,	,
18637	13855	33	the	the	DT
18637	13855	34	laws	law	NNS
18637	13855	35	of	of	IN
18637	13855	36	such	such	JJ
18637	13855	37	States	state	NNS
18637	13855	38	relating	relate	VBG
18637	13855	39	to	to	IN
18637	13855	40	the	the	DT
18637	13855	41	right	right	NN
18637	13855	42	to	to	TO
18637	13855	43	add	add	VB
18637	13855	44	interest	interest	NN
18637	13855	45	to	to	IN
18637	13855	46	the	the	DT
18637	13855	47	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	13855	48	as	as	IN
18637	13855	49	an	an	DT
18637	13855	50	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	13855	51	item	item	NN
18637	13855	52	of	of	IN
18637	13855	53	damages	damage	NNS
18637	13855	54	.	.	.
18637	13856	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13856	2	104	104	CD
18637	13856	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13856	4	STOCKHOLDER	STOCKHOLDER	NNP
18637	13856	5	--	--	:
18637	13856	6	CORPORATION	corporation	NN
18637	13856	7	RELATIONSHIP	RELATIONSHIP	NNS
18637	13856	8	Nor	nor	CC
18637	13856	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	13856	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13856	11	alone	alone	JJ
18637	13856	12	to	to	IN
18637	13856	13	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	13856	14	in	in	IN
18637	13856	15	transitory	transitory	JJ
18637	13856	16	actions	action	NNS
18637	13856	17	that	that	WDT
18637	13856	18	the	the	DT
18637	13856	19	full	full	JJ
18637	13856	20	faith	faith	NN
18637	13856	21	and	and	CC
18637	13856	22	credit	credit	NN
18637	13856	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	13856	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	13856	25	today	today	NN
18637	13856	26	a	a	DT
18637	13856	27	shield	shield	NN
18637	13856	28	and	and	CC
18637	13856	29	a	a	DT
18637	13856	30	buckler	buckler	NN
18637	13856	31	.	.	.
18637	13857	1	Some	some	DT
18637	13857	2	legal	legal	JJ
18637	13857	3	relationships	relationship	NNS
18637	13857	4	are	be	VBP
18637	13857	5	so	so	RB
18637	13857	6	complex	complex	JJ
18637	13857	7	,	,	,
18637	13857	8	the	the	DT
18637	13857	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13857	10	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	13857	11	,	,	,
18637	13857	12	that	that	IN
18637	13857	13	the	the	DT
18637	13857	14	law	law	NN
18637	13857	15	under	under	IN
18637	13857	16	which	which	WDT
18637	13857	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13857	18	were	be	VBD
18637	13857	19	formed	form	VBN
18637	13857	20	ought	ought	MD
18637	13857	21	always	always	RB
18637	13857	22	to	to	TO
18637	13857	23	govern	govern	VB
18637	13857	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13857	25	as	as	RB
18637	13857	26	long	long	RB
18637	13857	27	as	as	IN
18637	13857	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13857	29	persist	persist	VBP
18637	13857	30	.	.	.
18637	13858	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13858	2	105	105	CD
18637	13858	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13858	4	One	one	CD
18637	13858	5	such	such	JJ
18637	13858	6	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	13858	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	13858	8	that	that	DT
18637	13858	9	of	of	IN
18637	13858	10	a	a	DT
18637	13858	11	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	13858	12	and	and	CC
18637	13858	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13858	14	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13858	15	.	.	.
18637	13859	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	13859	2	,	,	,
18637	13859	3	if	if	IN
18637	13859	4	a	a	DT
18637	13859	5	question	question	NN
18637	13859	6	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	13859	7	as	as	IN
18637	13859	8	to	to	IN
18637	13859	9	the	the	DT
18637	13859	10	liability	liability	NN
18637	13859	11	of	of	IN
18637	13859	12	the	the	DT
18637	13859	13	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	13859	14	of	of	IN
18637	13859	15	a	a	DT
18637	13859	16	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13859	17	,	,	,
18637	13859	18	the	the	DT
18637	13859	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	13859	20	of	of	IN
18637	13859	21	the	the	DT
18637	13859	22	forum	forum	NN
18637	13859	23	State	State	NNP
18637	13859	24	are	be	VBP
18637	13859	25	required	require	VBN
18637	13859	26	by	by	IN
18637	13859	27	the	the	DT
18637	13859	28	full	full	JJ
18637	13859	29	faith	faith	NN
18637	13859	30	and	and	CC
18637	13859	31	credit	credit	NN
18637	13859	32	clause	clause	NN
18637	13859	33	to	to	TO
18637	13859	34	determine	determine	VB
18637	13859	35	the	the	DT
18637	13859	36	question	question	NN
18637	13859	37	in	in	IN
18637	13859	38	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	13859	39	with	with	IN
18637	13859	40	the	the	DT
18637	13859	41	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13859	42	,	,	,
18637	13859	43	laws	law	NNS
18637	13859	44	and	and	CC
18637	13859	45	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13859	46	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	13859	47	of	of	IN
18637	13859	48	the	the	DT
18637	13859	49	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13859	50	's	's	POS
18637	13859	51	home	home	NN
18637	13859	52	State	State	NNP
18637	13859	53	.	.	.
18637	13860	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13860	2	106	106	CD
18637	13860	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13860	4	Illustrative	illustrative	JJ
18637	13860	5	applications	application	NNS
18637	13860	6	of	of	IN
18637	13860	7	the	the	DT
18637	13860	8	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13860	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	13860	10	are	be	VBP
18637	13860	11	to	to	TO
18637	13860	12	be	be	VB
18637	13860	13	found	find	VBN
18637	13860	14	in	in	IN
18637	13860	15	the	the	DT
18637	13860	16	following	follow	VBG
18637	13860	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	13860	18	.	.	.
18637	13861	1	A	a	DT
18637	13861	2	New	New	NNP
18637	13861	3	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	13861	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	13861	5	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	13861	6	an	an	DT
18637	13861	7	action	action	NN
18637	13861	8	at	at	IN
18637	13861	9	law	law	NN
18637	13861	10	to	to	TO
18637	13861	11	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	13861	12	a	a	DT
18637	13861	13	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	13861	14	's	's	POS
18637	13861	15	liability	liability	NN
18637	13861	16	arising	arise	VBG
18637	13861	17	under	under	IN
18637	13861	18	the	the	DT
18637	13861	19	laws	law	NNS
18637	13861	20	of	of	IN
18637	13861	21	another	another	DT
18637	13861	22	State	state	NN
18637	13861	23	,	,	,
18637	13861	24	and	and	CC
18637	13861	25	providing	provide	VBG
18637	13861	26	that	that	DT
18637	13861	27	such	such	JJ
18637	13861	28	liability	liability	NN
18637	13861	29	may	may	MD
18637	13861	30	be	be	VB
18637	13861	31	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	13861	32	only	only	RB
18637	13861	33	in	in	IN
18637	13861	34	equity	equity	NN
18637	13861	35	,	,	,
18637	13861	36	and	and	CC
18637	13861	37	that	that	IN
18637	13861	38	in	in	IN
18637	13861	39	such	such	PDT
18637	13861	40	a	a	DT
18637	13861	41	case	case	NN
18637	13861	42	the	the	DT
18637	13861	43	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13861	44	,	,	,
18637	13861	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13861	46	legal	legal	JJ
18637	13861	47	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	13861	48	,	,	,
18637	13861	49	all	all	DT
18637	13861	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13861	51	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	13861	52	,	,	,
18637	13861	53	and	and	CC
18637	13861	54	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	13861	55	,	,	,
18637	13861	56	should	should	MD
18637	13861	57	be	be	VB
18637	13861	58	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	13861	59	parties	party	NNS
18637	13861	60	,	,	,
18637	13861	61	was	be	VBD
18637	13861	62	held	hold	VBN
18637	13861	63	not	not	RB
18637	13861	64	to	to	TO
18637	13861	65	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	13861	66	an	an	DT
18637	13861	67	action	action	NN
18637	13861	68	at	at	IN
18637	13861	69	law	law	NN
18637	13861	70	in	in	IN
18637	13861	71	New	New	NNP
18637	13861	72	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	13861	73	by	by	IN
18637	13861	74	the	the	DT
18637	13861	75	New	New	NNP
18637	13861	76	York	York	NNP
18637	13861	77	State	State	NNP
18637	13861	78	superintendent	superintendent	NN
18637	13861	79	of	of	IN
18637	13861	80	banks	bank	NNS
18637	13861	81	against	against	IN
18637	13861	82	557	557	CD
18637	13861	83	New	New	NNP
18637	13861	84	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	13861	85	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	13861	86	in	in	IN
18637	13861	87	an	an	DT
18637	13861	88	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
18637	13861	89	New	New	NNP
18637	13861	90	York	York	NNP
18637	13861	91	bank	bank	NN
18637	13861	92	to	to	TO
18637	13861	93	recover	recover	VB
18637	13861	94	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	13861	95	made	make	VBN
18637	13861	96	under	under	IN
18637	13861	97	the	the	DT
18637	13861	98	laws	law	NNS
18637	13861	99	of	of	IN
18637	13861	100	New	New	NNP
18637	13861	101	York	York	NNP
18637	13861	102	.	.	.
18637	13862	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13862	2	107	107	CD
18637	13862	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13862	4	Also	also	RB
18637	13862	5	,	,	,
18637	13862	6	in	in	IN
18637	13862	7	a	a	DT
18637	13862	8	suit	suit	NN
18637	13862	9	to	to	TO
18637	13862	10	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	13862	11	double	double	JJ
18637	13862	12	liability	liability	NN
18637	13862	13	,	,	,
18637	13862	14	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13862	15	in	in	IN
18637	13862	16	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	13862	17	Island	Island	NNP
18637	13862	18	against	against	IN
18637	13862	19	a	a	DT
18637	13862	20	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	13862	21	in	in	IN
18637	13862	22	a	a	DT
18637	13862	23	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	13862	24	trust	trust	NN
18637	13862	25	company	company	NN
18637	13862	26	,	,	,
18637	13862	27	the	the	DT
18637	13862	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	13862	29	of	of	IN
18637	13862	30	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	13862	31	Island	Island	NNP
18637	13862	32	were	be	VBD
18637	13862	33	held	hold	VBN
18637	13862	34	to	to	TO
18637	13862	35	be	be	VB
18637	13862	36	obligated	obligate	VBN
18637	13862	37	to	to	TO
18637	13862	38	extend	extend	VB
18637	13862	39	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13862	40	to	to	IN
18637	13862	41	the	the	DT
18637	13862	42	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	13862	43	and	and	CC
18637	13862	44	court	court	NN
18637	13862	45	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	13862	46	of	of	IN
18637	13862	47	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	13862	48	whereunder	whereunder	NN
18637	13862	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13862	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	13862	51	established	establish	VBN
18637	13862	52	that	that	IN
18637	13862	53	a	a	DT
18637	13862	54	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	13862	55	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13862	56	recovered	recover	VBN
18637	13862	57	by	by	IN
18637	13862	58	a	a	DT
18637	13862	59	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	13862	60	against	against	IN
18637	13862	61	the	the	DT
18637	13862	62	trust	trust	NN
18637	13862	63	company	company	NN
18637	13862	64	is	be	VBZ
18637	13862	65	not	not	RB
18637	13862	66	only	only	RB
18637	13862	67	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	13862	68	as	as	IN
18637	13862	69	to	to	IN
18637	13862	70	the	the	DT
18637	13862	71	liability	liability	NN
18637	13862	72	of	of	IN
18637	13862	73	the	the	DT
18637	13862	74	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13862	75	but	but	CC
18637	13862	76	also	also	RB
18637	13862	77	an	an	DT
18637	13862	78	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	13862	79	binding	bind	VBG
18637	13862	80	each	each	DT
18637	13862	81	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	13862	82	therein	therein	RB
18637	13862	83	.	.	.
18637	13863	1	The	the	DT
18637	13863	2	only	only	JJ
18637	13863	3	defenses	defense	NNS
18637	13863	4	available	available	JJ
18637	13863	5	to	to	IN
18637	13863	6	the	the	DT
18637	13863	7	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	13863	8	are	be	VBP
18637	13863	9	those	those	DT
18637	13863	10	which	which	WDT
18637	13863	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13863	12	could	could	MD
18637	13863	13	make	make	VB
18637	13863	14	in	in	IN
18637	13863	15	a	a	DT
18637	13863	16	suit	suit	NN
18637	13863	17	in	in	IN
18637	13863	18	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	13863	19	.	.	.
18637	13864	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13864	2	108	108	CD
18637	13864	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13864	4	FRATERNAL	FRATERNAL	NNP
18637	13864	5	BENEFIT	benefit	NN
18637	13864	6	SOCIETY	SOCIETY	NNS
18637	13864	7	--	--	:
18637	13864	8	MEMBER	member	NN
18637	13864	9	RELATIONSHIP	RELATIONSHIP	NNS
18637	13864	10	And	and	CC
18637	13864	11	the	the	DT
18637	13864	12	same	same	JJ
18637	13864	13	principle	principle	NN
18637	13864	14	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	13864	15	to	to	IN
18637	13864	16	the	the	DT
18637	13864	17	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	13864	18	which	which	WDT
18637	13864	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	13864	20	formed	form	VBN
18637	13864	21	when	when	WRB
18637	13864	22	one	one	PRP
18637	13864	23	takes	take	VBZ
18637	13864	24	out	out	RP
18637	13864	25	a	a	DT
18637	13864	26	policy	policy	NN
18637	13864	27	in	in	IN
18637	13864	28	a	a	DT
18637	13864	29	"	"	``
18637	13864	30	fraternal	fraternal	JJ
18637	13864	31	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	13864	32	society	society	NN
18637	13864	33	.	.	.
18637	13864	34	"	"	''
18637	13865	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	13865	2	in	in	IN
18637	13865	3	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	13865	4	Arcanum	Arcanum	NNP
18637	13865	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	13865	6	Green,[109	Green,[109	NNP
18637	13865	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13865	8	in	in	IN
18637	13865	9	which	which	WDT
18637	13865	10	a	a	DT
18637	13865	11	fraternal	fraternal	JJ
18637	13865	12	insurance	insurance	NNP
18637	13865	13	association	association	NN
18637	13865	14	chartered	charter	VBD
18637	13865	15	under	under	IN
18637	13865	16	the	the	DT
18637	13865	17	laws	law	NNS
18637	13865	18	of	of	IN
18637	13865	19	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13865	20	was	be	VBD
18637	13865	21	being	be	VBG
18637	13865	22	sued	sue	VBN
18637	13865	23	in	in	IN
18637	13865	24	the	the	DT
18637	13865	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	13865	26	of	of	IN
18637	13865	27	New	New	NNP
18637	13865	28	York	York	NNP
18637	13865	29	by	by	IN
18637	13865	30	a	a	DT
18637	13865	31	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	13865	32	of	of	IN
18637	13865	33	the	the	DT
18637	13865	34	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13865	35	State	State	NNP
18637	13865	36	on	on	IN
18637	13865	37	a	a	DT
18637	13865	38	contract	contract	NN
18637	13865	39	of	of	IN
18637	13865	40	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	13865	41	made	make	VBN
18637	13865	42	in	in	IN
18637	13865	43	that	that	DT
18637	13865	44	State	State	NNP
18637	13865	45	,	,	,
18637	13865	46	the	the	DT
18637	13865	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13865	48	held	hold	VBD
18637	13865	49	that	that	IN
18637	13865	50	the	the	DT
18637	13865	51	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13865	52	company	company	NN
18637	13865	53	was	be	VBD
18637	13865	54	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13865	55	under	under	IN
18637	13865	56	the	the	DT
18637	13865	57	full	full	JJ
18637	13865	58	faith	faith	NN
18637	13865	59	and	and	CC
18637	13865	60	credit	credit	NN
18637	13865	61	clause	clause	NN
18637	13865	62	to	to	TO
18637	13865	63	have	have	VB
18637	13865	64	the	the	DT
18637	13865	65	case	case	NN
18637	13865	66	determined	determine	VBN
18637	13865	67	in	in	IN
18637	13865	68	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	13865	69	with	with	IN
18637	13865	70	the	the	DT
18637	13865	71	laws	law	NNS
18637	13865	72	of	of	IN
18637	13865	73	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13865	74	and	and	CC
18637	13865	75	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13865	76	own	own	JJ
18637	13865	77	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	13865	78	and	and	CC
18637	13865	79	by	by	NNS
18637	13865	80	-	-	HYPH
18637	13865	81	laws	law	NNS
18637	13865	82	as	as	IN
18637	13865	83	these	these	DT
18637	13865	84	had	have	VBD
18637	13865	85	been	be	VBN
18637	13865	86	construed	construe	VBN
18637	13865	87	by	by	IN
18637	13865	88	the	the	DT
18637	13865	89	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13865	90	courts	court	NNS
18637	13865	91	.	.	.
18637	13866	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	13866	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	13866	3	the	the	DT
18637	13866	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13866	5	manifested	manifest	VBN
18637	13866	6	lately	lately	RB
18637	13866	7	any	any	DT
18637	13866	8	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	13866	9	to	to	TO
18637	13866	10	depart	depart	VB
18637	13866	11	from	from	IN
18637	13866	12	this	this	DT
18637	13866	13	rule	rule	NN
18637	13866	14	.	.	.
18637	13867	1	In	in	IN
18637	13867	2	Sovereign	Sovereign	NNP
18637	13867	3	Camp	Camp	NNP
18637	13867	4	_	_	NNP
18637	13867	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	13867	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13867	7	Bolin[110	Bolin[110	NNPS
18637	13867	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13867	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13867	10	declared	declare	VBD
18637	13867	11	that	that	IN
18637	13867	12	a	a	DT
18637	13867	13	State	state	NN
18637	13867	14	in	in	IN
18637	13867	15	which	which	WDT
18637	13867	16	a	a	DT
18637	13867	17	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	13867	18	of	of	IN
18637	13867	19	life	life	NN
18637	13867	20	membership	membership	NN
18637	13867	21	of	of	IN
18637	13867	22	a	a	DT
18637	13867	23	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13867	24	fraternal	fraternal	JJ
18637	13867	25	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	13867	26	association	association	NNP
18637	13867	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	13867	28	issued	issue	VBN
18637	13867	29	,	,	,
18637	13867	30	which	which	WDT
18637	13867	31	construes	construe	NNS
18637	13867	32	and	and	CC
18637	13867	33	enforces	enforce	NNS
18637	13867	34	said	say	VBD
18637	13867	35	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	13867	36	according	accord	VBG
18637	13867	37	to	to	IN
18637	13867	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13867	39	own	own	JJ
18637	13867	40	law	law	NN
18637	13867	41	rather	rather	RB
18637	13867	42	than	than	IN
18637	13867	43	according	accord	VBG
18637	13867	44	to	to	IN
18637	13867	45	the	the	DT
18637	13867	46	law	law	NN
18637	13867	47	of	of	IN
18637	13867	48	the	the	DT
18637	13867	49	State	State	NNP
18637	13867	50	in	in	IN
18637	13867	51	which	which	WDT
18637	13867	52	the	the	DT
18637	13867	53	association	association	NN
18637	13867	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	13867	55	domiciled	domiciled	JJ
18637	13867	56	denies	deny	VBZ
18637	13867	57	full	full	JJ
18637	13867	58	faith	faith	NN
18637	13867	59	and	and	CC
18637	13867	60	credit	credit	NN
18637	13867	61	to	to	IN
18637	13867	62	the	the	DT
18637	13867	63	association	association	NN
18637	13867	64	's	's	POS
18637	13867	65	charter	charter	NN
18637	13867	66	embodied	embody	VBN
18637	13867	67	in	in	IN
18637	13867	68	the	the	DT
18637	13867	69	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	13867	70	of	of	IN
18637	13867	71	the	the	DT
18637	13867	72	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	13867	73	State	State	NNP
18637	13867	74	as	as	IN
18637	13867	75	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	13867	76	by	by	IN
18637	13867	77	the	the	DT
18637	13867	78	latter	latter	NN
18637	13867	79	's	's	POS
18637	13867	80	court	court	NN
18637	13867	81	.	.	.
18637	13868	1	"	"	``
18637	13868	2	The	the	DT
18637	13868	3	beneficiary	beneficiary	NN
18637	13868	4	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	13868	5	was	be	VBD
18637	13868	6	not	not	RB
18637	13868	7	a	a	DT
18637	13868	8	mere	mere	JJ
18637	13868	9	contract	contract	NN
18637	13868	10	to	to	TO
18637	13868	11	be	be	VB
18637	13868	12	construed	construe	VBN
18637	13868	13	and	and	CC
18637	13868	14	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	13868	15	according	accord	VBG
18637	13868	16	to	to	IN
18637	13868	17	the	the	DT
18637	13868	18	laws	law	NNS
18637	13868	19	of	of	IN
18637	13868	20	the	the	DT
18637	13868	21	State	State	NNP
18637	13868	22	where	where	WRB
18637	13868	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13868	24	was	be	VBD
18637	13868	25	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	13868	26	.	.	.
18637	13869	1	Entry	entry	NN
18637	13869	2	into	into	IN
18637	13869	3	membership	membership	NN
18637	13869	4	of	of	IN
18637	13869	5	an	an	DT
18637	13869	6	incorporated	incorporated	JJ
18637	13869	7	beneficiary	beneficiary	NN
18637	13869	8	society	society	NN
18637	13869	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	13869	10	more	more	JJR
18637	13869	11	than	than	IN
18637	13869	12	a	a	DT
18637	13869	13	contract	contract	NN
18637	13869	14	;	;	:
18637	13869	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13869	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	13869	17	entering	enter	VBG
18637	13869	18	into	into	IN
18637	13869	19	a	a	DT
18637	13869	20	complex	complex	JJ
18637	13869	21	and	and	CC
18637	13869	22	abiding	abide	VBG
18637	13869	23	relation	relation	NN
18637	13869	24	and	and	CC
18637	13869	25	the	the	DT
18637	13869	26	rights	right	NNS
18637	13869	27	of	of	IN
18637	13869	28	membership	membership	NN
18637	13869	29	are	be	VBP
18637	13869	30	governed	govern	VBN
18637	13869	31	by	by	IN
18637	13869	32	the	the	DT
18637	13869	33	law	law	NN
18637	13869	34	of	of	IN
18637	13869	35	the	the	DT
18637	13869	36	State	State	NNP
18637	13869	37	of	of	IN
18637	13869	38	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	13869	39	.	.	.
18637	13870	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13870	2	Hence	hence	RB
18637	13870	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13870	4	another	another	DT
18637	13870	5	State	state	NN
18637	13870	6	,	,	,
18637	13870	7	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	13870	8	the	the	DT
18637	13870	9	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	13870	10	of	of	IN
18637	13870	11	membership	membership	NN
18637	13870	12	was	be	VBD
18637	13870	13	issued	issue	VBN
18637	13870	14	,	,	,
18637	13870	15	can	can	MD
18637	13870	16	not	not	RB
18637	13870	17	attach	attach	VB
18637	13870	18	to	to	IN
18637	13870	19	membership	membership	NN
18637	13870	20	rights	right	NNS
18637	13870	21	against	against	IN
18637	13870	22	the	the	DT
18637	13870	23	society	society	NN
18637	13870	24	which	which	WDT
18637	13870	25	are	be	VBP
18637	13870	26	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	13870	27	by	by	IN
18637	13870	28	the	the	DT
18637	13870	29	law	law	NN
18637	13870	30	of	of	IN
18637	13870	31	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13870	32	.	.	.
18637	13870	33	"	"	''
18637	13871	1	Consistently	consistently	RB
18637	13871	2	therewith	therewith	NNP
18637	13871	3	,	,	,
18637	13871	4	the	the	DT
18637	13871	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13871	6	also	also	RB
18637	13871	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	13871	8	,	,	,
18637	13871	9	in	in	IN
18637	13871	10	Order	order	NN
18637	13871	11	of	of	IN
18637	13871	12	Travelers	Travelers	NNPS
18637	13871	13	_	_	NNP
18637	13871	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	13871	15	_	_	NNP
18637	13871	16	Wolfe,[111	Wolfe,[111	NNP
18637	13871	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13871	18	that	that	IN
18637	13871	19	South	South	NNP
18637	13871	20	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	13871	21	,	,	,
18637	13871	22	in	in	IN
18637	13871	23	a	a	DT
18637	13871	24	suit	suit	NN
18637	13871	25	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13871	26	therein	therein	RB
18637	13871	27	by	by	IN
18637	13871	28	an	an	DT
18637	13871	29	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	13871	30	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	13871	31	against	against	IN
18637	13871	32	an	an	DT
18637	13871	33	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	13871	34	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	13871	35	society	society	NN
18637	13871	36	,	,	,
18637	13871	37	must	must	MD
18637	13871	38	give	give	VB
18637	13871	39	effect	effect	NN
18637	13871	40	to	to	IN
18637	13871	41	a	a	DT
18637	13871	42	provision	provision	NN
18637	13871	43	of	of	IN
18637	13871	44	the	the	DT
18637	13871	45	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	13871	46	of	of	IN
18637	13871	47	the	the	DT
18637	13871	48	society	society	NN
18637	13871	49	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	13871	50	the	the	DT
18637	13871	51	bringing	bringing	NN
18637	13871	52	of	of	IN
18637	13871	53	an	an	DT
18637	13871	54	action	action	NN
18637	13871	55	on	on	IN
18637	13871	56	a	a	DT
18637	13871	57	claim	claim	NN
18637	13871	58	more	more	JJR
18637	13871	59	than	than	IN
18637	13871	60	six	six	CD
18637	13871	61	months	month	NNS
18637	13871	62	after	after	IN
18637	13871	63	disallowance	disallowance	NN
18637	13871	64	by	by	IN
18637	13871	65	the	the	DT
18637	13871	66	society	society	NN
18637	13871	67	,	,	,
18637	13871	68	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	13871	69	that	that	IN
18637	13871	70	South	South	NNP
18637	13871	71	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	13871	72	's	's	POS
18637	13871	73	period	period	NN
18637	13871	74	of	of	IN
18637	13871	75	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	13871	76	was	be	VBD
18637	13871	77	six	six	CD
18637	13871	78	years	year	NNS
18637	13871	79	and	and	CC
18637	13871	80	that	that	IN
18637	13871	81	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13871	82	own	own	JJ
18637	13871	83	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	13871	84	voided	void	VBD
18637	13871	85	contract	contract	NN
18637	13871	86	stipulations	stipulation	NNS
18637	13871	87	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	13871	88	the	the	DT
18637	13871	89	time	time	NN
18637	13871	90	within	within	IN
18637	13871	91	which	which	WDT
18637	13871	92	rights	right	NNS
18637	13871	93	may	may	MD
18637	13871	94	be	be	VB
18637	13871	95	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	13871	96	.	.	.
18637	13872	1	Objecting	object	VBG
18637	13872	2	to	to	IN
18637	13872	3	these	these	DT
18637	13872	4	results	result	NNS
18637	13872	5	,	,	,
18637	13872	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13872	7	Black	Black	NNP
18637	13872	8	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	13872	9	on	on	IN
18637	13872	10	the	the	DT
18637	13872	11	ground	ground	NN
18637	13872	12	that	that	IN
18637	13872	13	fraternal	fraternal	JJ
18637	13872	14	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	13872	15	companies	company	NNS
18637	13872	16	are	be	VBP
18637	13872	17	not	not	RB
18637	13872	18	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13872	19	,	,	,
18637	13872	20	either	either	CC
18637	13872	21	by	by	IN
18637	13872	22	the	the	DT
18637	13872	23	language	language	NN
18637	13872	24	of	of	IN
18637	13872	25	the	the	DT
18637	13872	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13872	27	,	,	,
18637	13872	28	or	or	CC
18637	13872	29	by	by	IN
18637	13872	30	the	the	DT
18637	13872	31	nature	nature	NN
18637	13872	32	of	of	IN
18637	13872	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13872	34	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	13872	35	,	,	,
18637	13872	36	to	to	IN
18637	13872	37	such	such	JJ
18637	13872	38	unique	unique	JJ
18637	13872	39	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	13872	40	protection	protection	NN
18637	13872	41	.	.	.
18637	13873	1	INSURANCE	INSURANCE	NNP
18637	13873	2	COMPANY	COMPANY	NNP
18637	13873	3	,	,	,
18637	13873	4	BUILDING	BUILDING	NNP
18637	13873	5	AND	and	CC
18637	13873	6	LOAN	LOAN	NNP
18637	13873	7	ASSOCIATION	ASSOCIATION	NNP
18637	13873	8	--	--	:
18637	13873	9	CONTRACTUAL	CONTRACTUAL	NNP
18637	13873	10	RELATIONSHIPS	RELATIONSHIPS	NNP
18637	13873	11	Whether	whether	IN
18637	13873	12	or	or	CC
18637	13873	13	not	not	RB
18637	13873	14	distinguishable	distinguishable	JJ
18637	13873	15	by	by	IN
18637	13873	16	nature	nature	NN
18637	13873	17	of	of	IN
18637	13873	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13873	19	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	13873	20	,	,	,
18637	13873	21	stock	stock	NN
18637	13873	22	and	and	CC
18637	13873	23	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	13873	24	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	13873	25	companies	company	NNS
18637	13873	26	and	and	CC
18637	13873	27	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	13873	28	building	building	NN
18637	13873	29	and	and	CC
18637	13873	30	loan	loan	NN
18637	13873	31	associations	association	NNS
18637	13873	32	,	,	,
18637	13873	33	unlike	unlike	IN
18637	13873	34	fraternal	fraternal	JJ
18637	13873	35	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	13873	36	societies	society	NNS
18637	13873	37	,	,	,
18637	13873	38	have	have	VBP
18637	13873	39	not	not	RB
18637	13873	40	been	be	VBN
18637	13873	41	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	13873	42	the	the	DT
18637	13873	43	same	same	JJ
18637	13873	44	unique	unique	JJ
18637	13873	45	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	13873	46	protection	protection	NN
18637	13873	47	;	;	,
18637	13873	48	and	and	CC
18637	13873	49	,	,	,
18637	13873	50	with	with	IN
18637	13873	51	few	few	JJ
18637	13873	52	exceptions,[112	exceptions,[112	NNP
18637	13873	53	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13873	54	have	have	VBP
18637	13873	55	had	have	VBN
18637	13873	56	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	13873	57	arising	arise	VBG
18637	13873	58	out	out	IN
18637	13873	59	of	of	IN
18637	13873	60	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13873	61	business	business	NN
18637	13873	62	relationships	relationship	NNS
18637	13873	63	settled	settle	VBN
18637	13873	64	by	by	IN
18637	13873	65	application	application	NN
18637	13873	66	of	of	IN
18637	13873	67	the	the	DT
18637	13873	68	law	law	NN
18637	13873	69	of	of	IN
18637	13873	70	the	the	DT
18637	13873	71	forum	forum	NN
18637	13873	72	State	State	NNP
18637	13873	73	.	.	.
18637	13874	1	In	in	IN
18637	13874	2	National	National	NNP
18637	13874	3	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	13874	4	B.	B.	NNP
18637	13875	1	&	&	CC
18637	13875	2	L.	L.	NNP
18637	13875	3	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	13875	4	.	.	.
18637	13876	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13876	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	13876	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13876	4	Brahan,[113	Brahan,[113	NNP
18637	13876	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13876	6	the	the	DT
18637	13876	7	principle	principle	NN
18637	13876	8	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	13876	9	to	to	IN
18637	13876	10	these	these	DT
18637	13876	11	three	three	CD
18637	13876	12	forms	form	NNS
18637	13876	13	of	of	IN
18637	13876	14	business	business	NN
18637	13876	15	organization	organization	NN
18637	13876	16	was	be	VBD
18637	13876	17	stated	state	VBN
18637	13876	18	as	as	IN
18637	13876	19	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	13876	20	:	:	:
18637	13876	21	Where	where	WRB
18637	13876	22	a	a	DT
18637	13876	23	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13876	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	13876	25	become	become	VBN
18637	13876	26	localized	localize	VBN
18637	13876	27	in	in	IN
18637	13876	28	a	a	DT
18637	13876	29	State	state	NN
18637	13876	30	and	and	CC
18637	13876	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	13876	32	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	13876	33	the	the	DT
18637	13876	34	laws	law	NNS
18637	13876	35	of	of	IN
18637	13876	36	the	the	DT
18637	13876	37	State	State	NNP
18637	13876	38	as	as	IN
18637	13876	39	a	a	DT
18637	13876	40	condition	condition	NN
18637	13876	41	of	of	IN
18637	13876	42	doing	do	VBG
18637	13876	43	business	business	NN
18637	13876	44	there	there	RB
18637	13876	45	,	,	,
18637	13876	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13876	47	can	can	MD
18637	13876	48	not	not	RB
18637	13876	49	abrogate	abrogate	VB
18637	13876	50	those	those	DT
18637	13876	51	laws	law	NNS
18637	13876	52	by	by	IN
18637	13876	53	attempting	attempt	VBG
18637	13876	54	to	to	TO
18637	13876	55	make	make	VB
18637	13876	56	contract	contract	NN
18637	13876	57	stipulations	stipulation	NNS
18637	13876	58	,	,	,
18637	13876	59	and	and	CC
18637	13876	60	there	there	EX
18637	13876	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	13876	62	no	no	DT
18637	13876	63	violation	violation	NN
18637	13876	64	of	of	IN
18637	13876	65	the	the	DT
18637	13876	66	full	full	JJ
18637	13876	67	faith	faith	NN
18637	13876	68	and	and	CC
18637	13876	69	credit	credit	NN
18637	13876	70	clause	clause	NN
18637	13876	71	in	in	IN
18637	13876	72	instructing	instruct	VBG
18637	13876	73	a	a	DT
18637	13876	74	jury	jury	NN
18637	13876	75	to	to	TO
18637	13876	76	find	find	VB
18637	13876	77	according	accord	VBG
18637	13876	78	to	to	IN
18637	13876	79	local	local	JJ
18637	13876	80	law	law	NN
18637	13876	81	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	13876	82	a	a	DT
18637	13876	83	clause	clause	NN
18637	13876	84	in	in	IN
18637	13876	85	a	a	DT
18637	13876	86	contract	contract	NN
18637	13876	87	that	that	IN
18637	13876	88	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13876	89	should	should	MD
18637	13876	90	be	be	VB
18637	13876	91	construed	construe	VBN
18637	13876	92	according	accord	VBG
18637	13876	93	to	to	IN
18637	13876	94	the	the	DT
18637	13876	95	laws	law	NNS
18637	13876	96	of	of	IN
18637	13876	97	another	another	DT
18637	13876	98	State	state	NN
18637	13876	99	.	.	.
18637	13877	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	13877	2	,	,	,
18637	13877	3	when	when	WRB
18637	13877	4	a	a	DT
18637	13877	5	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	13877	6	borrower	borrower	NN
18637	13877	7	,	,	,
18637	13877	8	having	have	VBG
18637	13877	9	repaid	repay	VBN
18637	13877	10	a	a	DT
18637	13877	11	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	13877	12	loan	loan	NN
18637	13877	13	to	to	IN
18637	13877	14	a	a	DT
18637	13877	15	New	New	NNP
18637	13877	16	York	York	NNP
18637	13877	17	building	building	NN
18637	13877	18	and	and	CC
18637	13877	19	loan	loan	NNP
18637	13877	20	association	association	NNP
18637	13877	21	,	,	,
18637	13877	22	sued	sue	VBN
18637	13877	23	in	in	IN
18637	13877	24	a	a	DT
18637	13877	25	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	13877	26	court	court	NN
18637	13877	27	to	to	TO
18637	13877	28	recover	recover	VB
18637	13877	29	,	,	,
18637	13877	30	as	as	IN
18637	13877	31	usurious	usurious	JJ
18637	13877	32	,	,	,
18637	13877	33	certain	certain	JJ
18637	13877	34	charges	charge	NNS
18637	13877	35	collected	collect	VBN
18637	13877	36	by	by	IN
18637	13877	37	the	the	DT
18637	13877	38	association	association	NN
18637	13877	39	,	,	,
18637	13877	40	the	the	DT
18637	13877	41	usury	usury	JJ
18637	13877	42	law	law	NN
18637	13877	43	of	of	IN
18637	13877	44	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	13877	45	rather	rather	RB
18637	13877	46	than	than	IN
18637	13877	47	that	that	DT
18637	13877	48	of	of	IN
18637	13877	49	New	New	NNP
18637	13877	50	York	York	NNP
18637	13877	51	was	be	VBD
18637	13877	52	held	hold	VBN
18637	13877	53	to	to	TO
18637	13877	54	control	control	VB
18637	13877	55	.	.	.
18637	13878	1	In	in	IN
18637	13878	2	this	this	DT
18637	13878	3	case	case	NN
18637	13878	4	,	,	,
18637	13878	5	the	the	DT
18637	13878	6	loan	loan	NN
18637	13878	7	contract	contract	NN
18637	13878	8	,	,	,
18637	13878	9	which	which	WDT
18637	13878	10	was	be	VBD
18637	13878	11	negotiated	negotiate	VBN
18637	13878	12	in	in	IN
18637	13878	13	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	13878	14	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13878	15	to	to	IN
18637	13878	16	approval	approval	NN
18637	13878	17	by	by	IN
18637	13878	18	the	the	DT
18637	13878	19	New	New	NNP
18637	13878	20	York	York	NNP
18637	13878	21	office	office	NN
18637	13878	22	,	,	,
18637	13878	23	did	do	VBD
18637	13878	24	not	not	RB
18637	13878	25	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	13878	26	state	state	VB
18637	13878	27	that	that	IN
18637	13878	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13878	29	was	be	VBD
18637	13878	30	governed	govern	VBN
18637	13878	31	by	by	IN
18637	13878	32	New	New	NNP
18637	13878	33	York	York	NNP
18637	13878	34	law	law	NN
18637	13878	35	.	.	.
18637	13879	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13879	2	114	114	CD
18637	13879	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13879	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	13879	5	,	,	,
18637	13879	6	when	when	WRB
18637	13879	7	the	the	DT
18637	13879	8	New	New	NNP
18637	13879	9	York	York	NNP
18637	13879	10	Life	Life	NNP
18637	13879	11	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	13879	12	Company	Company	NNP
18637	13879	13	,	,	,
18637	13879	14	which	which	WDT
18637	13879	15	had	have	VBD
18637	13879	16	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	13879	17	stated	state	VBN
18637	13879	18	in	in	IN
18637	13879	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13879	20	application	application	NN
18637	13879	21	and	and	CC
18637	13879	22	policy	policy	NN
18637	13879	23	forms	form	NNS
18637	13879	24	that	that	IN
18637	13879	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13879	26	would	would	MD
18637	13879	27	be	be	VB
18637	13879	28	controlled	control	VBN
18637	13879	29	by	by	IN
18637	13879	30	New	New	NNP
18637	13879	31	York	York	NNP
18637	13879	32	law	law	NN
18637	13879	33	,	,	,
18637	13879	34	was	be	VBD
18637	13879	35	sued	sue	VBN
18637	13879	36	in	in	IN
18637	13879	37	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	13879	38	on	on	IN
18637	13879	39	a	a	DT
18637	13879	40	policy	policy	NN
18637	13879	41	sold	sell	VBN
18637	13879	42	to	to	IN
18637	13879	43	a	a	DT
18637	13879	44	resident	resident	NN
18637	13879	45	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	13879	46	,	,	,
18637	13879	47	the	the	DT
18637	13879	48	court	court	NN
18637	13879	49	of	of	IN
18637	13879	50	that	that	DT
18637	13879	51	State	State	NNP
18637	13879	52	was	be	VBD
18637	13879	53	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	13879	54	in	in	IN
18637	13879	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13879	56	application	application	NN
18637	13879	57	of	of	IN
18637	13879	58	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	13879	59	rather	rather	RB
18637	13879	60	than	than	IN
18637	13879	61	New	New	NNP
18637	13879	62	York	York	NNP
18637	13879	63	law	law	NN
18637	13879	64	.	.	.
18637	13880	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13880	2	115	115	CD
18637	13880	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13880	4	Also	also	RB
18637	13880	5	,	,	,
18637	13880	6	in	in	IN
18637	13880	7	an	an	DT
18637	13880	8	action	action	NN
18637	13880	9	in	in	IN
18637	13880	10	a	a	DT
18637	13880	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13880	12	court	court	NN
18637	13880	13	in	in	IN
18637	13880	14	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	13880	15	to	to	TO
18637	13880	16	collect	collect	VB
18637	13880	17	the	the	DT
18637	13880	18	amount	amount	NN
18637	13880	19	of	of	IN
18637	13880	20	a	a	DT
18637	13880	21	life	life	NN
18637	13880	22	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	13880	23	policy	policy	NN
18637	13880	24	which	which	WDT
18637	13880	25	had	have	VBD
18637	13880	26	been	be	VBN
18637	13880	27	made	make	VBN
18637	13880	28	in	in	IN
18637	13880	29	New	New	NNP
18637	13880	30	York	York	NNP
18637	13880	31	and	and	CC
18637	13880	32	later	later	RB
18637	13880	33	changed	change	VBN
18637	13880	34	by	by	IN
18637	13880	35	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	13880	36	assigning	assign	VBG
18637	13880	37	beneficial	beneficial	JJ
18637	13880	38	interest	interest	NN
18637	13880	39	,	,	,
18637	13880	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13880	41	was	be	VBD
18637	13880	42	held	hold	VBN
18637	13880	43	that	that	IN
18637	13880	44	questions	question	NNS
18637	13880	45	:	:	:
18637	13880	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13880	47	1	1	LS
18637	13880	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13880	49	whether	whether	IN
18637	13880	50	the	the	DT
18637	13880	51	contract	contract	NN
18637	13880	52	remained	remain	VBD
18637	13880	53	one	one	CD
18637	13880	54	governed	govern	VBN
18637	13880	55	by	by	IN
18637	13880	56	the	the	DT
18637	13880	57	law	law	NN
18637	13880	58	of	of	IN
18637	13880	59	New	New	NNP
18637	13880	60	York	York	NNP
18637	13880	61	with	with	IN
18637	13880	62	respect	respect	NN
18637	13880	63	to	to	IN
18637	13880	64	rights	right	NNS
18637	13880	65	of	of	IN
18637	13880	66	assignees	assignee	NNS
18637	13880	67	,	,	,
18637	13880	68	rather	rather	RB
18637	13880	69	than	than	IN
18637	13880	70	by	by	IN
18637	13880	71	the	the	DT
18637	13880	72	law	law	NN
18637	13880	73	of	of	IN
18637	13880	74	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	13880	75	,	,	,
18637	13880	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13880	77	2	2	LS
18637	13880	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13880	79	whether	whether	IN
18637	13880	80	the	the	DT
18637	13880	81	public	public	JJ
18637	13880	82	policy	policy	NN
18637	13880	83	of	of	IN
18637	13880	84	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	13880	85	permits	permit	VBZ
18637	13880	86	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	13880	87	by	by	IN
18637	13880	88	one	one	CD
18637	13880	89	named	name	VBN
18637	13880	90	beneficiary	beneficiary	NN
18637	13880	91	who	who	WP
18637	13880	92	has	have	VBZ
18637	13880	93	no	no	DT
18637	13880	94	beneficial	beneficial	JJ
18637	13880	95	interest	interest	NN
18637	13880	96	in	in	IN
18637	13880	97	the	the	DT
18637	13880	98	life	life	NN
18637	13880	99	of	of	IN
18637	13880	100	the	the	DT
18637	13880	101	insured	insure	VBN
18637	13880	102	,	,	,
18637	13880	103	and	and	CC
18637	13880	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	13880	105	3	3	LS
18637	13880	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	13880	107	whether	whether	IN
18637	13880	108	lack	lack	NN
18637	13880	109	of	of	IN
18637	13880	110	insurable	insurable	JJ
18637	13880	111	interest	interest	NN
18637	13880	112	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	13880	113	material	material	NN
18637	13880	114	when	when	WRB
18637	13880	115	the	the	DT
18637	13880	116	insurer	insurer	NN
18637	13880	117	acknowledges	acknowledge	VBZ
18637	13880	118	liability	liability	NN
18637	13880	119	and	and	CC
18637	13880	120	pays	pay	VBZ
18637	13880	121	the	the	DT
18637	13880	122	money	money	NN
18637	13880	123	into	into	IN
18637	13880	124	court	court	NN
18637	13880	125	,	,	,
18637	13880	126	were	be	VBD
18637	13880	127	questions	question	NNS
18637	13880	128	of	of	IN
18637	13880	129	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	13880	130	law	law	NN
18637	13880	131	,	,	,
18637	13880	132	to	to	TO
18637	13880	133	be	be	VB
18637	13880	134	decided	decide	VBN
18637	13880	135	according	accord	VBG
18637	13880	136	to	to	IN
18637	13880	137	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	13880	138	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	13880	139	.	.	.
18637	13881	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13881	2	116	116	CD
18637	13881	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13881	4	Consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	13881	5	with	with	IN
18637	13881	6	the	the	DT
18637	13881	7	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13881	8	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	13881	9	are	be	VBP
18637	13881	10	the	the	DT
18637	13881	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	13881	12	two	two	CD
18637	13881	13	involving	involve	VBG
18637	13881	14	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	13881	15	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	13881	16	companies	company	NNS
18637	13881	17	.	.	.
18637	13882	1	In	in	IN
18637	13882	2	Pink	Pink	NNP
18637	13882	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13882	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13882	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13882	6	A.A.A.	A.A.A.	NNP
18637	13883	1	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	13883	2	Express,[117	express,[117	CD
18637	13883	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13883	4	the	the	DT
18637	13883	5	New	New	NNP
18637	13883	6	York	York	NNP
18637	13883	7	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	13883	8	commissioner	commissioner	NN
18637	13883	9	,	,	,
18637	13883	10	as	as	IN
18637	13883	11	a	a	DT
18637	13883	12	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	13883	13	liquidator	liquidator	NN
18637	13883	14	of	of	IN
18637	13883	15	an	an	DT
18637	13883	16	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
18637	13883	17	auto	auto	NN
18637	13883	18	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	13883	19	company	company	NN
18637	13883	20	organized	organize	VBN
18637	13883	21	in	in	IN
18637	13883	22	New	New	NNP
18637	13883	23	York	York	NNP
18637	13883	24	sued	sue	VBD
18637	13883	25	resident	resident	JJ
18637	13883	26	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	13883	27	policyholders	policyholder	NNS
18637	13883	28	in	in	IN
18637	13883	29	a	a	DT
18637	13883	30	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	13883	31	court	court	NN
18637	13883	32	to	to	TO
18637	13883	33	recover	recover	VB
18637	13883	34	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	13883	35	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	13883	36	to	to	TO
18637	13883	37	be	be	VB
18637	13883	38	due	due	JJ
18637	13883	39	by	by	IN
18637	13883	40	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	13883	41	of	of	IN
18637	13883	42	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13883	43	membership	membership	NN
18637	13883	44	in	in	IN
18637	13883	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13883	46	.	.	.
18637	13884	1	The	the	DT
18637	13884	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13884	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13884	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	13884	5	that	that	IN
18637	13884	6	,	,	,
18637	13884	7	although	although	IN
18637	13884	8	by	by	IN
18637	13884	9	the	the	DT
18637	13884	10	law	law	NN
18637	13884	11	of	of	IN
18637	13884	12	the	the	DT
18637	13884	13	State	State	NNP
18637	13884	14	of	of	IN
18637	13884	15	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	13884	16	,	,	,
18637	13884	17	policyholders	policyholder	NNS
18637	13884	18	of	of	IN
18637	13884	19	a	a	DT
18637	13884	20	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	13884	21	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	13884	22	company	company	NN
18637	13884	23	become	become	VBP
18637	13884	24	members	member	NNS
18637	13884	25	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	13884	26	and	and	CC
18637	13884	27	as	as	IN
18637	13884	28	such	such	JJ
18637	13884	29	liable	liable	JJ
18637	13884	30	to	to	TO
18637	13884	31	pay	pay	VB
18637	13884	32	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	13884	33	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
18637	13884	34	to	to	TO
18637	13884	35	be	be	VB
18637	13884	36	required	require	VBN
18637	13884	37	in	in	IN
18637	13884	38	liquidation	liquidation	NN
18637	13884	39	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13884	40	in	in	IN
18637	13884	41	that	that	DT
18637	13884	42	State	State	NNP
18637	13884	43	,	,	,
18637	13884	44	the	the	DT
18637	13884	45	courts	court	NNS
18637	13884	46	of	of	IN
18637	13884	47	another	another	DT
18637	13884	48	State	state	NN
18637	13884	49	are	be	VBP
18637	13884	50	not	not	RB
18637	13884	51	required	require	VBN
18637	13884	52	to	to	TO
18637	13884	53	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	13884	54	such	such	JJ
18637	13884	55	liability	liability	NN
18637	13884	56	against	against	IN
18637	13884	57	local	local	JJ
18637	13884	58	resident	resident	JJ
18637	13884	59	policyholders	policyholder	NNS
18637	13884	60	who	who	WP
18637	13884	61	did	do	VBD
18637	13884	62	not	not	RB
18637	13884	63	appear	appear	VB
18637	13884	64	and	and	CC
18637	13884	65	were	be	VBD
18637	13884	66	not	not	RB
18637	13884	67	personally	personally	RB
18637	13884	68	served	serve	VBN
18637	13884	69	in	in	IN
18637	13884	70	the	the	DT
18637	13884	71	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13884	72	liquidation	liquidation	NN
18637	13884	73	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13884	74	;	;	:
18637	13884	75	but	but	CC
18637	13884	76	are	be	VBP
18637	13884	77	free	free	JJ
18637	13884	78	to	to	TO
18637	13884	79	decide	decide	VB
18637	13884	80	according	accord	VBG
18637	13884	81	to	to	IN
18637	13884	82	local	local	JJ
18637	13884	83	law	law	NN
18637	13884	84	the	the	DT
18637	13884	85	question	question	NN
18637	13884	86	whether	whether	IN
18637	13884	87	,	,	,
18637	13884	88	by	by	IN
18637	13884	89	entering	enter	VBG
18637	13884	90	into	into	IN
18637	13884	91	the	the	DT
18637	13884	92	policies	policy	NNS
18637	13884	93	,	,	,
18637	13884	94	residents	resident	NNS
18637	13884	95	became	become	VBD
18637	13884	96	members	member	NNS
18637	13884	97	of	of	IN
18637	13884	98	the	the	DT
18637	13884	99	company	company	NN
18637	13884	100	.	.	.
18637	13885	1	Again	again	RB
18637	13885	2	,	,	,
18637	13885	3	in	in	IN
18637	13885	4	State	State	NNP
18637	13885	5	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	13885	6	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	13885	7	.	.	.
18637	13886	1	_	_	NNP
18637	13886	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	13886	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13886	4	Duel,[118	Duel,[118	NNP
18637	13886	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13886	6	the	the	DT
18637	13886	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13886	8	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	13886	9	that	that	IN
18637	13886	10	an	an	DT
18637	13886	11	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	13886	12	company	company	NN
18637	13886	13	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	13886	14	in	in	IN
18637	13886	15	State	State	NNP
18637	13886	16	A	A	NNP
18637	13886	17	,	,	,
18637	13886	18	which	which	WDT
18637	13886	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	13886	20	not	not	RB
18637	13886	21	treat	treat	VB
18637	13886	22	membership	membership	NN
18637	13886	23	fees	fee	NNS
18637	13886	24	as	as	IN
18637	13886	25	part	part	NN
18637	13886	26	of	of	IN
18637	13886	27	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	13886	28	,	,	,
18637	13886	29	can	can	MD
18637	13886	30	not	not	RB
18637	13886	31	plead	plead	VB
18637	13886	32	denial	denial	NN
18637	13886	33	of	of	IN
18637	13886	34	full	full	JJ
18637	13886	35	faith	faith	NN
18637	13886	36	and	and	CC
18637	13886	37	credit	credit	NN
18637	13886	38	when	when	WRB
18637	13886	39	State	State	NNP
18637	13886	40	B	B	NNP
18637	13886	41	,	,	,
18637	13886	42	as	as	IN
18637	13886	43	a	a	DT
18637	13886	44	condition	condition	NN
18637	13886	45	of	of	IN
18637	13886	46	entry	entry	NN
18637	13886	47	,	,	,
18637	13886	48	requires	require	VBZ
18637	13886	49	the	the	DT
18637	13886	50	company	company	NN
18637	13886	51	to	to	TO
18637	13886	52	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	13886	53	a	a	DT
18637	13886	54	reserve	reserve	NN
18637	13886	55	computed	compute	VBN
18637	13886	56	by	by	IN
18637	13886	57	including	include	VBG
18637	13886	58	membership	membership	NN
18637	13886	59	fees	fee	NNS
18637	13886	60	as	as	RB
18637	13886	61	well	well	RB
18637	13886	62	as	as	IN
18637	13886	63	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	13886	64	received	receive	VBN
18637	13886	65	in	in	IN
18637	13886	66	all	all	DT
18637	13886	67	States	state	NNS
18637	13886	68	.	.	.
18637	13887	1	Were	be	VBD
18637	13887	2	the	the	DT
18637	13887	3	company	company	NN
18637	13887	4	's	's	POS
18637	13887	5	contention	contention	NN
18637	13887	6	accepted	accept	VBD
18637	13887	7	,	,	,
18637	13887	8	"	"	``
18637	13887	9	no	no	DT
18637	13887	10	State	state	NN
18637	13887	11	,	,	,
18637	13887	12	"	"	''
18637	13887	13	the	the	DT
18637	13887	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13887	15	observed	observe	VBD
18637	13887	16	,	,	,
18637	13887	17	"	"	``
18637	13887	18	could	could	MD
18637	13887	19	impose	impose	VB
18637	13887	20	stricter	strict	JJR
18637	13887	21	financial	financial	JJ
18637	13887	22	standards	standard	NNS
18637	13887	23	for	for	IN
18637	13887	24	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13887	25	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	13887	26	doing	do	VBG
18637	13887	27	business	business	NN
18637	13887	28	within	within	IN
18637	13887	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13887	30	borders	border	NNS
18637	13887	31	than	than	IN
18637	13887	32	were	be	VBD
18637	13887	33	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	13887	34	by	by	IN
18637	13887	35	the	the	DT
18637	13887	36	State	State	NNP
18637	13887	37	of	of	IN
18637	13887	38	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	13887	39	.	.	.
18637	13887	40	"	"	''
18637	13888	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13888	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	13888	3	not	not	RB
18637	13888	4	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	13888	5	,	,	,
18637	13888	6	the	the	DT
18637	13888	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13888	8	added	add	VBD
18637	13888	9	,	,	,
18637	13888	10	that	that	IN
18637	13888	11	State	State	NNP
18637	13888	12	A	A	NNP
18637	13888	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	13888	14	an	an	DT
18637	13888	15	interest	interest	NN
18637	13888	16	superior	superior	JJ
18637	13888	17	to	to	IN
18637	13888	18	that	that	DT
18637	13888	19	of	of	IN
18637	13888	20	State	State	NNP
18637	13888	21	B	B	NNP
18637	13888	22	in	in	IN
18637	13888	23	the	the	DT
18637	13888	24	financial	financial	JJ
18637	13888	25	soundness	soundness	NN
18637	13888	26	and	and	CC
18637	13888	27	stability	stability	NN
18637	13888	28	of	of	IN
18637	13888	29	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	13888	30	companies	company	NNS
18637	13888	31	doing	do	VBG
18637	13888	32	business	business	NN
18637	13888	33	in	in	IN
18637	13888	34	State	State	NNP
18637	13888	35	B,--which	B,--which	NNP
18637	13888	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	13888	37	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	13888	38	more	more	JJR
18637	13888	39	the	the	DT
18637	13888	40	language	language	NN
18637	13888	41	of	of	IN
18637	13888	42	arbitration	arbitration	NN
18637	13888	43	than	than	IN
18637	13888	44	of	of	IN
18637	13888	45	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	13888	46	,	,	,
18637	13888	47	as	as	IN
18637	13888	48	conventionally	conventionally	RB
18637	13888	49	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	13888	50	.	.	.
18637	13889	1	WORKMEN	WORKMEN	NNP
18637	13889	2	'S	's	POS
18637	13889	3	COMPENSATION	compensation	NN
18637	13889	4	STATUTES	statute	NNS
18637	13889	5	Finally	finally	RB
18637	13889	6	,	,	,
18637	13889	7	the	the	DT
18637	13889	8	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	13889	9	of	of	IN
18637	13889	10	employer	employer	NN
18637	13889	11	and	and	CC
18637	13889	12	employee	employee	NN
18637	13889	13	,	,	,
18637	13889	14	so	so	RB
18637	13889	15	far	far	RB
18637	13889	16	as	as	IN
18637	13889	17	the	the	DT
18637	13889	18	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	13889	19	of	of	IN
18637	13889	20	the	the	DT
18637	13889	21	one	one	NN
18637	13889	22	and	and	CC
18637	13889	23	the	the	DT
18637	13889	24	rights	right	NNS
18637	13889	25	of	of	IN
18637	13889	26	the	the	DT
18637	13889	27	other	other	JJ
18637	13889	28	under	under	IN
18637	13889	29	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	13889	30	's	's	POS
18637	13889	31	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	13889	32	acts	act	NNS
18637	13889	33	are	be	VBP
18637	13889	34	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	13889	35	,	,	,
18637	13889	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	13889	37	been	be	VBN
18637	13889	38	the	the	DT
18637	13889	39	subject	subject	NN
18637	13889	40	of	of	IN
18637	13889	41	similar	similar	JJ
18637	13889	42	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	13889	43	.	.	.
18637	13890	1	In	in	IN
18637	13890	2	an	an	DT
18637	13890	3	earlier	early	JJR
18637	13890	4	case,[119	case,[119	NN
18637	13890	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13890	6	the	the	DT
18637	13890	7	cause	cause	NN
18637	13890	8	of	of	IN
18637	13890	9	action	action	NN
18637	13890	10	was	be	VBD
18637	13890	11	an	an	DT
18637	13890	12	injury	injury	NN
18637	13890	13	in	in	IN
18637	13890	14	New	New	NNP
18637	13890	15	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	13890	16	,	,	,
18637	13890	17	resulting	result	VBG
18637	13890	18	in	in	IN
18637	13890	19	death	death	NN
18637	13890	20	to	to	IN
18637	13890	21	a	a	DT
18637	13890	22	workman	workman	NN
18637	13890	23	who	who	WP
18637	13890	24	had	have	VBD
18637	13890	25	entered	enter	VBN
18637	13890	26	the	the	DT
18637	13890	27	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13890	28	company	company	NN
18637	13890	29	's	's	POS
18637	13890	30	employment	employment	NN
18637	13890	31	in	in	IN
18637	13890	32	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	13890	33	,	,	,
18637	13890	34	the	the	DT
18637	13890	35	home	home	NN
18637	13890	36	State	State	NNP
18637	13890	37	of	of	IN
18637	13890	38	both	both	DT
18637	13890	39	parties	party	NNS
18637	13890	40	.	.	.
18637	13891	1	The	the	DT
18637	13891	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13891	3	held	hold	VBD
18637	13891	4	that	that	IN
18637	13891	5	the	the	DT
18637	13891	6	case	case	NN
18637	13891	7	was	be	VBD
18637	13891	8	governed	govern	VBN
18637	13891	9	under	under	IN
18637	13891	10	the	the	DT
18637	13891	11	full	full	JJ
18637	13891	12	faith	faith	NN
18637	13891	13	and	and	CC
18637	13891	14	credit	credit	NN
18637	13891	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	13891	16	by	by	IN
18637	13891	17	the	the	DT
18637	13891	18	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	13891	19	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	13891	20	's	's	POS
18637	13891	21	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	13891	22	act	act	NN
18637	13891	23	,	,	,
18637	13891	24	not	not	RB
18637	13891	25	that	that	DT
18637	13891	26	of	of	IN
18637	13891	27	New	New	NNP
18637	13891	28	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	13891	29	.	.	.
18637	13892	1	The	the	DT
18637	13892	2	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	13892	3	,	,	,
18637	13892	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13892	5	said	say	VBD
18637	13892	6	,	,	,
18637	13892	7	"	"	``
18637	13892	8	was	be	VBD
18637	13892	9	created	create	VBN
18637	13892	10	by	by	IN
18637	13892	11	the	the	DT
18637	13892	12	law	law	NN
18637	13892	13	of	of	IN
18637	13892	14	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	13892	15	,	,	,
18637	13892	16	and	and	CC
18637	13892	17	so	so	RB
18637	13892	18	long	long	RB
18637	13892	19	as	as	IN
18637	13892	20	that	that	DT
18637	13892	21	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	13892	22	persisted	persist	VBD
18637	13892	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13892	24	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	13892	25	were	be	VBD
18637	13892	26	properly	properly	RB
18637	13892	27	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13892	28	to	to	IN
18637	13892	29	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	13892	30	there	there	RB
18637	13892	31	.	.	.
18637	13893	1	"	"	``
18637	13893	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13893	3	120	120	CD
18637	13893	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13893	5	However	however	RB
18637	13893	6	,	,	,
18637	13893	7	in	in	IN
18637	13893	8	an	an	DT
18637	13893	9	unacknowledged	unacknowledged	JJ
18637	13893	10	departure	departure	NN
18637	13893	11	from	from	IN
18637	13893	12	this	this	DT
18637	13893	13	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	13893	14	the	the	DT
18637	13893	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13893	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	13893	17	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	13893	18	held	hold	VBN
18637	13893	19	that	that	IN
18637	13893	20	the	the	DT
18637	13893	21	full	full	JJ
18637	13893	22	faith	faith	NN
18637	13893	23	and	and	CC
18637	13893	24	credit	credit	NN
18637	13893	25	clause	clause	NN
18637	13893	26	did	do	VBD
18637	13893	27	not	not	RB
18637	13893	28	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	13893	29	California	California	NNP
18637	13893	30	from	from	IN
18637	13893	31	disregarding	disregard	VBG
18637	13893	32	a	a	DT
18637	13893	33	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13893	34	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	13893	35	's	's	POS
18637	13893	36	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	13893	37	statute	statute	NN
18637	13893	38	and	and	CC
18637	13893	39	applying	apply	VBG
18637	13893	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13893	41	own	own	JJ
18637	13893	42	conflicting	conflicting	JJ
18637	13893	43	act	act	NN
18637	13893	44	in	in	IN
18637	13893	45	the	the	DT
18637	13893	46	case	case	NN
18637	13893	47	of	of	IN
18637	13893	48	an	an	DT
18637	13893	49	injury	injury	NN
18637	13893	50	suffered	suffer	VBN
18637	13893	51	by	by	IN
18637	13893	52	a	a	DT
18637	13893	53	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13893	54	employee	employee	NN
18637	13893	55	of	of	IN
18637	13893	56	a	a	DT
18637	13893	57	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13893	58	employer	employer	NN
18637	13893	59	while	while	IN
18637	13893	60	in	in	IN
18637	13893	61	California	California	NNP
18637	13893	62	in	in	IN
18637	13893	63	the	the	DT
18637	13893	64	course	course	NN
18637	13893	65	of	of	IN
18637	13893	66	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13893	67	employment	employment	NN
18637	13893	68	.	.	.
18637	13894	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13894	2	121	121	CD
18637	13894	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13894	4	The	the	DT
18637	13894	5	earlier	early	JJR
18637	13894	6	case	case	NN
18637	13894	7	was	be	VBD
18637	13894	8	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	13894	9	as	as	IN
18637	13894	10	not	not	RB
18637	13894	11	having	have	VBG
18637	13894	12	decided	decide	VBN
18637	13894	13	more	more	JJR
18637	13894	14	than	than	IN
18637	13894	15	that	that	IN
18637	13894	16	a	a	DT
18637	13894	17	State	state	NN
18637	13894	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	13894	19	,	,	,
18637	13894	20	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	13894	21	to	to	TO
18637	13894	22	employer	employer	NN
18637	13894	23	and	and	CC
18637	13894	24	employee	employee	NN
18637	13894	25	within	within	IN
18637	13894	26	the	the	DT
18637	13894	27	State	State	NNP
18637	13894	28	,	,	,
18637	13894	29	which	which	WDT
18637	13894	30	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	13894	31	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	13894	32	if	if	IN
18637	13894	33	the	the	DT
18637	13894	34	employee	employee	NN
18637	13894	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	13894	36	injured	injure	VBN
18637	13894	37	while	while	IN
18637	13894	38	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	13894	39	in	in	IN
18637	13894	40	another	another	DT
18637	13894	41	State	state	NN
18637	13894	42	,	,	,
18637	13894	43	will	will	MD
18637	13894	44	be	be	VB
18637	13894	45	given	give	VBN
18637	13894	46	full	full	JJ
18637	13894	47	faith	faith	NN
18637	13894	48	and	and	CC
18637	13894	49	credit	credit	NN
18637	13894	50	in	in	IN
18637	13894	51	the	the	DT
18637	13894	52	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13894	53	when	when	WRB
18637	13894	54	not	not	RB
18637	13894	55	obnoxious	obnoxious	JJ
18637	13894	56	to	to	IN
18637	13894	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13894	58	policy	policy	NN
18637	13894	59	.	.	.
18637	13895	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	13895	2	as	as	IN
18637	13895	3	the	the	DT
18637	13895	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13895	5	in	in	IN
18637	13895	6	the	the	DT
18637	13895	7	older	old	JJR
18637	13895	8	decision	decision	NN
18637	13895	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	13895	10	reputed	repute	VBN
18637	13895	11	to	to	TO
18637	13895	12	have	have	VB
18637	13895	13	observed	observe	VBN
18637	13895	14	that	that	DT
18637	13895	15	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	13895	16	on	on	IN
18637	13895	17	the	the	DT
18637	13895	18	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	13895	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	13895	20	,	,	,
18637	13895	21	as	as	IN
18637	13895	22	a	a	DT
18637	13895	23	defense	defense	NN
18637	13895	24	to	to	IN
18637	13895	25	the	the	DT
18637	13895	26	New	New	NNP
18637	13895	27	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	13895	28	suit	suit	NN
18637	13895	29	,	,	,
18637	13895	30	was	be	VBD
18637	13895	31	not	not	RB
18637	13895	32	obnoxious	obnoxious	JJ
18637	13895	33	to	to	IN
18637	13895	34	the	the	DT
18637	13895	35	policy	policy	NN
18637	13895	36	of	of	IN
18637	13895	37	New	New	NNP
18637	13895	38	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	13895	39	,	,	,
18637	13895	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13895	41	may	may	MD
18637	13895	42	be	be	VB
18637	13895	43	possible	possible	JJ
18637	13895	44	to	to	TO
18637	13895	45	reconcile	reconcile	VB
18637	13895	46	these	these	DT
18637	13895	47	two	two	CD
18637	13895	48	cases	case	NNS
18637	13895	49	by	by	IN
18637	13895	50	stating	state	VBG
18637	13895	51	that	that	IN
18637	13895	52	a	a	DT
18637	13895	53	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13895	54	workmen	workmen	NN
18637	13895	55	's	's	POS
18637	13895	56	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	13895	57	statute	statute	NN
18637	13895	58	will	will	MD
18637	13895	59	be	be	VB
18637	13895	60	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	13895	61	when	when	WRB
18637	13895	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13895	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	13895	64	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	13895	65	as	as	IN
18637	13895	66	a	a	DT
18637	13895	67	defense	defense	NN
18637	13895	68	but	but	CC
18637	13895	69	need	nee	MD
18637	13895	70	not	not	RB
18637	13895	71	be	be	VB
18637	13895	72	applied	apply	VBN
18637	13895	73	when	when	WRB
18637	13895	74	the	the	DT
18637	13895	75	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	13895	76	endeavors	endeavor	NNS
18637	13895	77	to	to	TO
18637	13895	78	found	find	VBD
18637	13895	79	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13895	80	suit	suit	NN
18637	13895	81	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	13895	82	.	.	.
18637	13896	1	Later	later	JJ
18637	13896	2	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	13896	3	involving	involve	VBG
18637	13896	4	the	the	DT
18637	13896	5	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13896	6	of	of	IN
18637	13896	7	a	a	DT
18637	13896	8	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13896	9	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	13896	10	's	's	POS
18637	13896	11	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	13896	12	act	act	NN
18637	13896	13	include	include	VBP
18637	13896	14	the	the	DT
18637	13896	15	following	following	NN
18637	13896	16	.	.	.
18637	13897	1	In	in	IN
18637	13897	2	Magnolia	Magnolia	NNP
18637	13897	3	Petroleum	Petroleum	NNP
18637	13897	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13897	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13897	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13897	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13897	8	Hunt[122	Hunt[122	NNP
18637	13897	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13897	10	the	the	DT
18637	13897	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13897	12	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	13897	13	that	that	IN
18637	13897	14	a	a	DT
18637	13897	15	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	13897	16	employee	employee	NN
18637	13897	17	of	of	IN
18637	13897	18	a	a	DT
18637	13897	19	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	13897	20	employer	employer	NN
18637	13897	21	,	,	,
18637	13897	22	who	who	WP
18637	13897	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	13897	24	injured	injure	VBN
18637	13897	25	on	on	IN
18637	13897	26	the	the	DT
18637	13897	27	job	job	NN
18637	13897	28	in	in	IN
18637	13897	29	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	13897	30	and	and	CC
18637	13897	31	who	who	WP
18637	13897	32	receives	receive	VBZ
18637	13897	33	an	an	DT
18637	13897	34	award	award	NN
18637	13897	35	under	under	IN
18637	13897	36	the	the	DT
18637	13897	37	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	13897	38	Act	Act	NNP
18637	13897	39	,	,	,
18637	13897	40	which	which	WDT
18637	13897	41	does	do	VBZ
18637	13897	42	not	not	RB
18637	13897	43	grant	grant	VB
18637	13897	44	further	further	JJ
18637	13897	45	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	13897	46	to	to	IN
18637	13897	47	an	an	DT
18637	13897	48	employee	employee	NN
18637	13897	49	who	who	WP
18637	13897	50	receives	receive	VBZ
18637	13897	51	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	13897	52	under	under	IN
18637	13897	53	the	the	DT
18637	13897	54	laws	law	NNS
18637	13897	55	of	of	IN
18637	13897	56	another	another	DT
18637	13897	57	State	state	NN
18637	13897	58	,	,	,
18637	13897	59	can	can	MD
18637	13897	60	not	not	RB
18637	13897	61	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	13897	62	additional	additional	JJ
18637	13897	63	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	13897	64	under	under	IN
18637	13897	65	the	the	DT
18637	13897	66	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	13897	67	Act	Act	NNP
18637	13897	68	.	.	.
18637	13898	1	However	however	RB
18637	13898	2	,	,	,
18637	13898	3	a	a	DT
18637	13898	4	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	13898	5	award	award	NN
18637	13898	6	by	by	IN
18637	13898	7	State	State	NNP
18637	13898	8	A	A	NNP
18637	13898	9	to	to	IN
18637	13898	10	a	a	DT
18637	13898	11	resident	resident	JJ
18637	13898	12	employee	employee	NN
18637	13898	13	of	of	IN
18637	13898	14	a	a	DT
18637	13898	15	resident	resident	JJ
18637	13898	16	employer	employer	NN
18637	13898	17	injured	injure	VBN
18637	13898	18	on	on	IN
18637	13898	19	the	the	DT
18637	13898	20	job	job	NN
18637	13898	21	in	in	IN
18637	13898	22	State	State	NNP
18637	13898	23	B	B	NNP
18637	13898	24	will	will	MD
18637	13898	25	not	not	RB
18637	13898	26	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	13898	27	State	State	NNP
18637	13898	28	B	B	NNP
18637	13898	29	from	from	IN
18637	13898	30	awarding	award	VBG
18637	13898	31	added	add	VBN
18637	13898	32	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	13898	33	under	under	IN
18637	13898	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13898	35	own	own	JJ
18637	13898	36	laws	law	NNS
18637	13898	37	,	,	,
18637	13898	38	when	when	WRB
18637	13898	39	the	the	DT
18637	13898	40	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	13898	41	statute	statute	NN
18637	13898	42	of	of	IN
18637	13898	43	State	State	NNP
18637	13898	44	A	A	NNP
18637	13898	45	does	do	VBZ
18637	13898	46	not	not	RB
18637	13898	47	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	13898	48	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	13898	49	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	13898	50	under	under	IN
18637	13898	51	a	a	DT
18637	13898	52	law	law	NN
18637	13898	53	of	of	IN
18637	13898	54	the	the	DT
18637	13898	55	State	State	NNP
18637	13898	56	in	in	IN
18637	13898	57	which	which	WDT
18637	13898	58	the	the	DT
18637	13898	59	injury	injury	NN
18637	13898	60	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	13898	61	and	and	CC
18637	13898	62	when	when	WRB
18637	13898	63	the	the	DT
18637	13898	64	State	State	NNP
18637	13898	65	A	A	NNP
18637	13898	66	award	award	NN
18637	13898	67	incorporated	incorporate	VBD
18637	13898	68	a	a	DT
18637	13898	69	private	private	JJ
18637	13898	70	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	13898	71	contract	contract	NN
18637	13898	72	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	13898	73	the	the	DT
18637	13898	74	employee	employee	NN
18637	13898	75	reserved	reserve	VBD
18637	13898	76	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13898	77	rights	right	NNS
18637	13898	78	in	in	IN
18637	13898	79	State	State	NNP
18637	13898	80	B.	B.	NNP
18637	13899	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13899	2	123	123	CD
18637	13899	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13899	4	Also	also	RB
18637	13899	5	,	,	,
18637	13899	6	the	the	DT
18637	13899	7	District	District	NNP
18637	13899	8	of	of	IN
18637	13899	9	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	13899	10	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	13899	11	's	's	POS
18637	13899	12	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	13899	13	act	act	NNP
18637	13899	14	,	,	,
18637	13899	15	which	which	WDT
18637	13899	16	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	13899	17	covers	cover	VBZ
18637	13899	18	an	an	DT
18637	13899	19	employee	employee	NN
18637	13899	20	of	of	IN
18637	13899	21	the	the	DT
18637	13899	22	District	District	NNP
18637	13899	23	employer	employer	NN
18637	13899	24	,	,	,
18637	13899	25	"	"	``
18637	13899	26	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	13899	27	of	of	IN
18637	13899	28	the	the	DT
18637	13899	29	place	place	NN
18637	13899	30	where	where	WRB
18637	13899	31	the	the	DT
18637	13899	32	injury	injury	NN
18637	13899	33	occurs	occur	VBZ
18637	13899	34	,	,	,
18637	13899	35	"	"	``
18637	13899	36	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	13899	37	may	may	MD
18637	13899	38	be	be	VB
18637	13899	39	applied	apply	VBN
18637	13899	40	,	,	,
18637	13899	41	in	in	IN
18637	13899	42	the	the	DT
18637	13899	43	case	case	NN
18637	13899	44	of	of	IN
18637	13899	45	injury	injury	NN
18637	13899	46	resulting	result	VBG
18637	13899	47	in	in	IN
18637	13899	48	death	death	NN
18637	13899	49	,	,	,
18637	13899	50	to	to	IN
18637	13899	51	a	a	DT
18637	13899	52	District	District	NNP
18637	13899	53	resident	resident	NN
18637	13899	54	,	,	,
18637	13899	55	employed	employ	VBN
18637	13899	56	by	by	IN
18637	13899	57	a	a	DT
18637	13899	58	District	District	NNP
18637	13899	59	employer	employer	NN
18637	13899	60	,	,	,
18637	13899	61	who	who	WP
18637	13899	62	was	be	VBD
18637	13899	63	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	13899	64	to	to	IN
18637	13899	65	a	a	DT
18637	13899	66	job	job	NN
18637	13899	67	at	at	IN
18637	13899	68	Quantico	Quantico	NNP
18637	13899	69	,	,	,
18637	13899	70	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	13899	71	,	,	,
18637	13899	72	and	and	CC
18637	13899	73	who	who	WP
18637	13899	74	,	,	,
18637	13899	75	for	for	IN
18637	13899	76	three	three	CD
18637	13899	77	years	year	NNS
18637	13899	78	prior	prior	RB
18637	13899	79	to	to	IN
18637	13899	80	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13899	81	death	death	NN
18637	13899	82	in	in	IN
18637	13899	83	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	13899	84	,	,	,
18637	13899	85	has	have	VBZ
18637	13899	86	commuted	commute	VBN
18637	13899	87	to	to	IN
18637	13899	88	the	the	DT
18637	13899	89	job	job	NN
18637	13899	90	site	site	NN
18637	13899	91	from	from	IN
18637	13899	92	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13899	93	house	house	NN
18637	13899	94	in	in	IN
18637	13899	95	the	the	DT
18637	13899	96	District	District	NNP
18637	13899	97	.	.	.
18637	13900	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13900	2	124	124	CD
18637	13900	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13900	4	Development	Development	NNP
18637	13900	5	of	of	IN
18637	13900	6	Section	Section	NNP
18637	13900	7	to	to	IN
18637	13900	8	Date	Date	NNP
18637	13900	9	and	and	CC
18637	13900	10	Possibilities	possibility	NNS
18637	13900	11	EVALUATION	EVALUATION	NNS
18637	13900	12	OF	of	IN
18637	13900	13	RESULTS	results	NN
18637	13900	14	Thus	thus	RB
18637	13900	15	the	the	DT
18637	13900	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13900	17	,	,	,
18637	13900	18	from	from	IN
18637	13900	19	according	accord	VBG
18637	13900	20	an	an	DT
18637	13900	21	extrastate	extrastate	NN
18637	13900	22	operation	operation	NN
18637	13900	23	to	to	IN
18637	13900	24	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	13900	25	and	and	CC
18637	13900	26	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13900	27	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	13900	28	in	in	IN
18637	13900	29	favor	favor	NN
18637	13900	30	of	of	IN
18637	13900	31	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	13900	32	in	in	IN
18637	13900	33	transitory	transitory	JJ
18637	13900	34	actions	action	NNS
18637	13900	35	,	,	,
18637	13900	36	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	13900	37	next	next	RB
18637	13900	38	to	to	TO
18637	13900	39	confer	confer	VB
18637	13900	40	the	the	DT
18637	13900	41	same	same	JJ
18637	13900	42	protection	protection	NN
18637	13900	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	13900	44	certain	certain	JJ
18637	13900	45	classes	class	NNS
18637	13900	46	of	of	IN
18637	13900	47	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	13900	48	in	in	IN
18637	13900	49	local	local	JJ
18637	13900	50	actions	action	NNS
18637	13900	51	in	in	IN
18637	13900	52	which	which	WDT
18637	13900	53	the	the	DT
18637	13900	54	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	13900	55	's	's	POS
18637	13900	56	claim	claim	NN
18637	13900	57	was	be	VBD
18637	13900	58	the	the	DT
18637	13900	59	outgrowth	outgrowth	NN
18637	13900	60	of	of	IN
18637	13900	61	a	a	DT
18637	13900	62	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	13900	63	formed	form	VBN
18637	13900	64	extraterritorially	extraterritorially	RB
18637	13900	65	.	.	.
18637	13901	1	But	but	CC
18637	13901	2	can	can	MD
18637	13901	3	the	the	DT
18637	13901	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13901	5	stop	stop	VB
18637	13901	6	at	at	IN
18637	13901	7	this	this	DT
18637	13901	8	point	point	NN
18637	13901	9	?	?	.
18637	13902	1	If	if	IN
18637	13902	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13902	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	13902	4	true	true	JJ
18637	13902	5	,	,	,
18637	13902	6	as	as	IN
18637	13902	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	13902	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13902	9	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	13902	10	once	once	RB
18637	13902	11	remarked	remark	VBD
18637	13902	12	,	,	,
18637	13902	13	that	that	IN
18637	13902	14	"	"	``
18637	13902	15	the	the	DT
18637	13902	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13902	17	was	be	VBD
18637	13902	18	not	not	RB
18637	13902	19	made	make	VBN
18637	13902	20	for	for	IN
18637	13902	21	the	the	DT
18637	13902	22	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	13902	23	of	of	IN
18637	13902	24	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
18637	13902	25	alone	alone	RB
18637	13902	26	,	,	,
18637	13902	27	"	"	''
18637	13902	28	so	so	RB
18637	13902	29	also	also	RB
18637	13902	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13902	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	13902	32	true	true	JJ
18637	13902	33	that	that	IN
18637	13902	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13902	35	was	be	VBD
18637	13902	36	not	not	RB
18637	13902	37	made	make	VBN
18637	13902	38	for	for	IN
18637	13902	39	the	the	DT
18637	13902	40	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	13902	41	of	of	IN
18637	13902	42	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	13902	43	alone	alone	RB
18637	13902	44	.	.	.
18637	13903	1	The	the	DT
18637	13903	2	day	day	NN
18637	13903	3	may	may	MD
18637	13903	4	come	come	VB
18637	13903	5	when	when	WRB
18637	13903	6	the	the	DT
18637	13903	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13903	8	will	will	MD
18637	13903	9	approach	approach	VB
18637	13903	10	the	the	DT
18637	13903	11	question	question	NN
18637	13903	12	of	of	IN
18637	13903	13	the	the	DT
18637	13903	14	relation	relation	NN
18637	13903	15	of	of	IN
18637	13903	16	the	the	DT
18637	13903	17	full	full	JJ
18637	13903	18	faith	faith	NN
18637	13903	19	and	and	CC
18637	13903	20	credit	credit	NN
18637	13903	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	13903	22	to	to	IN
18637	13903	23	the	the	DT
18637	13903	24	extrastate	extrastate	JJ
18637	13903	25	operation	operation	NN
18637	13903	26	of	of	IN
18637	13903	27	laws	law	NNS
18637	13903	28	from	from	IN
18637	13903	29	the	the	DT
18637	13903	30	same	same	JJ
18637	13903	31	angle	angle	NN
18637	13903	32	as	as	IN
18637	13903	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13903	34	today	today	NN
18637	13903	35	views	view	VBZ
18637	13903	36	the	the	DT
18637	13903	37	broader	broad	JJR
18637	13903	38	question	question	NN
18637	13903	39	of	of	IN
18637	13903	40	the	the	DT
18637	13903	41	scope	scope	NN
18637	13903	42	of	of	IN
18637	13903	43	State	State	NNP
18637	13903	44	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	13903	45	power	power	NN
18637	13903	46	.	.	.
18637	13904	1	When	when	WRB
18637	13904	2	and	and	CC
18637	13904	3	if	if	IN
18637	13904	4	this	this	DT
18637	13904	5	day	day	NN
18637	13904	6	arrives	arrive	VBZ
18637	13904	7	,	,	,
18637	13904	8	State	state	NN
18637	13904	9	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	13904	10	and	and	CC
18637	13904	11	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13904	12	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	13904	13	will	will	MD
18637	13904	14	be	be	VB
18637	13904	15	given	give	VBN
18637	13904	16	such	such	JJ
18637	13904	17	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	JJ
18637	13904	18	operation	operation	NN
18637	13904	19	as	as	IN
18637	13904	20	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	13904	21	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	13904	22	to	to	IN
18637	13904	23	the	the	DT
18637	13904	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13904	25	to	to	TO
18637	13904	26	give	give	VB
18637	13904	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13904	28	.	.	.
18637	13905	1	In	in	IN
18637	13905	2	short	short	JJ
18637	13905	3	,	,	,
18637	13905	4	the	the	DT
18637	13905	5	rule	rule	NN
18637	13905	6	of	of	IN
18637	13905	7	the	the	DT
18637	13905	8	dominance	dominance	NN
18637	13905	9	of	of	IN
18637	13905	10	local	local	JJ
18637	13905	11	policy	policy	NN
18637	13905	12	of	of	IN
18637	13905	13	the	the	DT
18637	13905	14	forum	forum	NN
18637	13905	15	State	State	NNP
18637	13905	16	will	will	MD
18637	13905	17	be	be	VB
18637	13905	18	superseded	supersede	VBN
18637	13905	19	by	by	IN
18637	13905	20	that	that	DT
18637	13905	21	of	of	IN
18637	13905	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13905	23	review	review	NN
18637	13905	24	.	.	.
18637	13906	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13906	2	125	125	CD
18637	13906	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13906	4	The	the	DT
18637	13906	5	question	question	NN
18637	13906	6	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	13906	7	whether	whether	IN
18637	13906	8	the	the	DT
18637	13906	9	application	application	NN
18637	13906	10	to	to	IN
18637	13906	11	date	date	NN
18637	13906	12	,	,	,
18637	13906	13	not	not	RB
18637	13906	14	by	by	IN
18637	13906	15	the	the	DT
18637	13906	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13906	17	alone	alone	RB
18637	13906	18	but	but	CC
18637	13906	19	by	by	IN
18637	13906	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13906	21	and	and	CC
18637	13906	22	the	the	DT
18637	13906	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13906	24	,	,	,
18637	13906	25	of	of	IN
18637	13906	26	article	article	NN
18637	13906	27	IV	IV	NNP
18637	13906	28	,	,	,
18637	13906	29	section	section	NN
18637	13906	30	1	1	CD
18637	13906	31	,	,	,
18637	13906	32	can	can	MD
18637	13906	33	be	be	VB
18637	13906	34	said	say	VBN
18637	13906	35	to	to	TO
18637	13906	36	have	have	VB
18637	13906	37	met	meet	VBN
18637	13906	38	the	the	DT
18637	13906	39	expectations	expectation	NNS
18637	13906	40	of	of	IN
18637	13906	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13906	42	framers	framer	NNS
18637	13906	43	.	.	.
18637	13907	1	In	in	IN
18637	13907	2	the	the	DT
18637	13907	3	light	light	NN
18637	13907	4	of	of	IN
18637	13907	5	some	some	DT
18637	13907	6	things	thing	NNS
18637	13907	7	said	say	VBD
18637	13907	8	at	at	IN
18637	13907	9	the	the	DT
18637	13907	10	time	time	NN
18637	13907	11	of	of	IN
18637	13907	12	the	the	DT
18637	13907	13	framing	framing	NN
18637	13907	14	of	of	IN
18637	13907	15	the	the	DT
18637	13907	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	13907	17	this	this	DT
18637	13907	18	may	may	MD
18637	13907	19	be	be	VB
18637	13907	20	doubted	doubt	VBN
18637	13907	21	.	.	.
18637	13908	1	The	the	DT
18637	13908	2	protest	protest	NN
18637	13908	3	was	be	VBD
18637	13908	4	raised	raise	VBN
18637	13908	5	against	against	IN
18637	13908	6	the	the	DT
18637	13908	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	13908	8	that	that	WDT
18637	13908	9	in	in	IN
18637	13908	10	vesting	vest	VBG
18637	13908	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13908	12	with	with	IN
18637	13908	13	power	power	NN
18637	13908	14	to	to	TO
18637	13908	15	declare	declare	VB
18637	13908	16	the	the	DT
18637	13908	17	effect	effect	NN
18637	13908	18	State	State	NNP
18637	13908	19	laws	law	NNS
18637	13908	20	should	should	MD
18637	13908	21	have	have	VB
18637	13908	22	outside	outside	IN
18637	13908	23	the	the	DT
18637	13908	24	enacting	enact	VBG
18637	13908	25	State	State	NNP
18637	13908	26	,	,	,
18637	13908	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13908	28	enabled	enable	VBD
18637	13908	29	the	the	DT
18637	13908	30	new	new	JJ
18637	13908	31	government	government	NN
18637	13908	32	to	to	TO
18637	13908	33	usurp	usurp	VB
18637	13908	34	the	the	DT
18637	13908	35	powers	power	NNS
18637	13908	36	of	of	IN
18637	13908	37	the	the	DT
18637	13908	38	States	States	NNPS
18637	13908	39	;	;	:
18637	13908	40	but	but	CC
18637	13908	41	the	the	DT
18637	13908	42	objection	objection	NN
18637	13908	43	went	go	VBD
18637	13908	44	unheeded	unheeded	JJ
18637	13908	45	.	.	.
18637	13909	1	The	the	DT
18637	13909	2	main	main	JJ
18637	13909	3	concern	concern	NN
18637	13909	4	of	of	IN
18637	13909	5	the	the	DT
18637	13909	6	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	13909	7	,	,	,
18637	13909	8	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	13909	9	,	,	,
18637	13909	10	was	be	VBD
18637	13909	11	to	to	TO
18637	13909	12	render	render	VB
18637	13909	13	the	the	DT
18637	13909	14	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13909	15	of	of	IN
18637	13909	16	the	the	DT
18637	13909	17	State	State	NNP
18637	13909	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	13909	19	in	in	IN
18637	13909	20	civil	civil	JJ
18637	13909	21	cases	case	NNS
18637	13909	22	effective	effective	JJ
18637	13909	23	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	13909	24	the	the	DT
18637	13909	25	Union	Union	NNP
18637	13909	26	.	.	.
18637	13910	1	Yet	yet	CC
18637	13910	2	even	even	RB
18637	13910	3	this	this	DT
18637	13910	4	object	object	NN
18637	13910	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	13910	6	been	be	VBN
18637	13910	7	by	by	IN
18637	13910	8	no	no	DT
18637	13910	9	means	means	NN
18637	13910	10	completely	completely	RB
18637	13910	11	realized	realize	VBN
18637	13910	12	,	,	,
18637	13910	13	owing	owe	VBG
18637	13910	14	to	to	IN
18637	13910	15	the	the	DT
18637	13910	16	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	13910	17	of	of	IN
18637	13910	18	the	the	DT
18637	13910	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13910	20	that	that	IN
18637	13910	21	before	before	IN
18637	13910	22	a	a	DT
18637	13910	23	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13910	24	of	of	IN
18637	13910	25	a	a	DT
18637	13910	26	State	State	NNP
18637	13910	27	court	court	NN
18637	13910	28	can	can	MD
18637	13910	29	be	be	VB
18637	13910	30	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	13910	31	in	in	IN
18637	13910	32	a	a	DT
18637	13910	33	sister	sister	NN
18637	13910	34	State	State	NNP
18637	13910	35	,	,	,
18637	13910	36	a	a	DT
18637	13910	37	new	new	JJ
18637	13910	38	suit	suit	NN
18637	13910	39	must	must	MD
18637	13910	40	be	be	VB
18637	13910	41	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13910	42	on	on	IN
18637	13910	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13910	44	in	in	IN
18637	13910	45	the	the	DT
18637	13910	46	courts	court	NNS
18637	13910	47	of	of	IN
18637	13910	48	the	the	DT
18637	13910	49	latter	latter	JJ
18637	13910	50	;	;	:
18637	13910	51	and	and	CC
18637	13910	52	the	the	DT
18637	13910	53	further	further	JJ
18637	13910	54	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	13910	55	that	that	IN
18637	13910	56	with	with	IN
18637	13910	57	respect	respect	NN
18637	13910	58	to	to	IN
18637	13910	59	such	such	PDT
18637	13910	60	a	a	DT
18637	13910	61	suit	suit	NN
18637	13910	62	,	,	,
18637	13910	63	the	the	DT
18637	13910	64	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13910	65	sued	sue	VBN
18637	13910	66	on	on	IN
18637	13910	67	is	be	VBZ
18637	13910	68	only	only	RB
18637	13910	69	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	13910	70	;	;	:
18637	13910	71	the	the	DT
18637	13910	72	logical	logical	JJ
18637	13910	73	deduction	deduction	NN
18637	13910	74	from	from	IN
18637	13910	75	which	which	WDT
18637	13910	76	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	13910	77	is	be	VBZ
18637	13910	78	that	that	IN
18637	13910	79	the	the	DT
18637	13910	80	sister	sister	NN
18637	13910	81	State	State	NNP
18637	13910	82	is	be	VBZ
18637	13910	83	under	under	IN
18637	13910	84	no	no	DT
18637	13910	85	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	13910	86	compulsion	compulsion	NN
18637	13910	87	to	to	TO
18637	13910	88	give	give	VB
18637	13910	89	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13910	90	a	a	DT
18637	13910	91	forum	forum	NN
18637	13910	92	.	.	.
18637	13911	1	These	these	DT
18637	13911	2	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	13911	3	were	be	VBD
18637	13911	4	first	first	RB
18637	13911	5	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	13911	6	stated	state	VBN
18637	13911	7	in	in	IN
18637	13911	8	the	the	DT
18637	13911	9	McElmoyle	McElmoyle	NNP
18637	13911	10	Case	Case	NNP
18637	13911	11	and	and	CC
18637	13911	12	flowed	flow	VBD
18637	13911	13	directly	directly	RB
18637	13911	14	from	from	IN
18637	13911	15	the	the	DT
18637	13911	16	new	new	JJ
18637	13911	17	States	States	NNPS
18637	13911	18	'	'	POS
18637	13911	19	rights	right	NNS
18637	13911	20	premises	premise	NNS
18637	13911	21	of	of	IN
18637	13911	22	the	the	DT
18637	13911	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13911	24	;	;	:
18637	13911	25	but	but	CC
18637	13911	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13911	27	are	be	VBP
18637	13911	28	no	no	RB
18637	13911	29	longer	long	RBR
18637	13911	30	in	in	IN
18637	13911	31	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	13911	32	with	with	IN
18637	13911	33	the	the	DT
18637	13911	34	prevailing	prevail	VBG
18637	13911	35	spirit	spirit	NN
18637	13911	36	of	of	IN
18637	13911	37	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	13911	38	construction	construction	NN
18637	13911	39	nor	nor	CC
18637	13911	40	with	with	IN
18637	13911	41	the	the	DT
18637	13911	42	needs	need	NNS
18637	13911	43	of	of	IN
18637	13911	44	the	the	DT
18637	13911	45	times	time	NNS
18637	13911	46	.	.	.
18637	13912	1	Also	also	RB
18637	13912	2	,	,	,
18637	13912	3	the	the	DT
18637	13912	4	clause	clause	NN
18637	13912	5	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	13912	6	always	always	RB
18637	13912	7	to	to	TO
18637	13912	8	have	have	VB
18637	13912	9	been	be	VBN
18637	13912	10	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	13912	11	on	on	IN
18637	13912	12	the	the	DT
18637	13912	13	basis	basis	NN
18637	13912	14	of	of	IN
18637	13912	15	the	the	DT
18637	13912	16	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	13912	17	that	that	IN
18637	13912	18	the	the	DT
18637	13912	19	term	term	NN
18637	13912	20	"	"	``
18637	13912	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13912	22	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13912	23	"	"	''
18637	13912	24	refers	refer	VBZ
18637	13912	25	only	only	RB
18637	13912	26	to	to	IN
18637	13912	27	final	final	JJ
18637	13912	28	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13912	29	and	and	CC
18637	13912	30	does	do	VBZ
18637	13912	31	not	not	RB
18637	13912	32	include	include	VB
18637	13912	33	intermediate	intermediate	JJ
18637	13912	34	processes	process	NNS
18637	13912	35	and	and	CC
18637	13912	36	writs	writ	NNS
18637	13912	37	;	;	:
18637	13912	38	but	but	CC
18637	13912	39	the	the	DT
18637	13912	40	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	13912	41	would	would	MD
18637	13912	42	seem	seem	VB
18637	13912	43	to	to	TO
18637	13912	44	be	be	VB
18637	13912	45	groundless	groundless	JJ
18637	13912	46	,	,	,
18637	13912	47	and	and	CC
18637	13912	48	if	if	IN
18637	13912	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13912	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	13912	51	,	,	,
18637	13912	52	then	then	RB
18637	13912	53	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13912	54	has	have	VBZ
18637	13912	55	the	the	DT
18637	13912	56	power	power	NN
18637	13912	57	under	under	IN
18637	13912	58	the	the	DT
18637	13912	59	clause	clause	NN
18637	13912	60	to	to	TO
18637	13912	61	provide	provide	VB
18637	13912	62	for	for	IN
18637	13912	63	the	the	DT
18637	13912	64	service	service	NN
18637	13912	65	and	and	CC
18637	13912	66	execution	execution	NN
18637	13912	67	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	13912	68	the	the	DT
18637	13912	69	United	United	NNP
18637	13912	70	States	States	NNP
18637	13912	71	of	of	IN
18637	13912	72	the	the	DT
18637	13912	73	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13912	74	processes	process	NNS
18637	13912	75	of	of	IN
18637	13912	76	the	the	DT
18637	13912	77	several	several	JJ
18637	13912	78	States	state	NNS
18637	13912	79	.	.	.
18637	13913	1	SCOPE	scope	NN
18637	13913	2	OF	of	IN
18637	13913	3	POWERS	power	NNS
18637	13913	4	OF	of	IN
18637	13913	5	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	13913	6	UNDER	under	IN
18637	13913	7	SECTION	section	NN
18637	13913	8	Under	under	IN
18637	13913	9	the	the	DT
18637	13913	10	present	present	JJ
18637	13913	11	system	system	NN
18637	13913	12	,	,	,
18637	13913	13	suit	suit	NN
18637	13913	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	13913	15	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	13913	16	to	to	TO
18637	13913	17	be	be	VB
18637	13913	18	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13913	19	where	where	WRB
18637	13913	20	the	the	DT
18637	13913	21	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13913	22	,	,	,
18637	13913	23	the	the	DT
18637	13913	24	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	13913	25	wrongdoer	wrongdoer	NN
18637	13913	26	,	,	,
18637	13913	27	resides	reside	NNS
18637	13913	28	,	,	,
18637	13913	29	which	which	WDT
18637	13913	30	means	mean	VBZ
18637	13913	31	generally	generally	RB
18637	13913	32	where	where	WRB
18637	13913	33	no	no	DT
18637	13913	34	part	part	NN
18637	13913	35	of	of	IN
18637	13913	36	the	the	DT
18637	13913	37	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	13913	38	giving	give	VBG
18637	13913	39	rise	rise	NN
18637	13913	40	to	to	IN
18637	13913	41	the	the	DT
18637	13913	42	action	action	NN
18637	13913	43	took	take	VBD
18637	13913	44	place	place	NN
18637	13913	45	.	.	.
18637	13914	1	What	what	WP
18637	13914	2	could	could	MD
18637	13914	3	be	be	VB
18637	13914	4	more	more	RBR
18637	13914	5	irrational	irrational	JJ
18637	13914	6	?	?	.
18637	13915	1	"	"	``
18637	13915	2	Granted	grant	VBN
18637	13915	3	that	that	IN
18637	13915	4	no	no	DT
18637	13915	5	state	state	NN
18637	13915	6	can	can	MD
18637	13915	7	of	of	IN
18637	13915	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13915	9	own	own	JJ
18637	13915	10	volition	volition	NN
18637	13915	11	make	make	VBP
18637	13915	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13915	13	process	process	NN
18637	13915	14	run	run	VB
18637	13915	15	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	13915	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13915	17	borders	border	NNS
18637	13915	18	*	*	NFP
18637	13915	19	*	*	NFP
18637	13915	20	*	*	NFP
18637	13915	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	13915	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13915	23	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	13915	24	that	that	IN
18637	13915	25	the	the	DT
18637	13915	26	United	United	NNP
18637	13915	27	States	States	NNP
18637	13915	28	should	should	MD
18637	13915	29	by	by	IN
18637	13915	30	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13915	31	action	action	NN
18637	13915	32	be	be	VB
18637	13915	33	made	make	VBN
18637	13915	34	a	a	DT
18637	13915	35	unit	unit	NN
18637	13915	36	in	in	IN
18637	13915	37	the	the	DT
18637	13915	38	manner	manner	NN
18637	13915	39	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	13915	40	?	?	.
18637	13916	1	"	"	``
18637	13916	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13916	3	126	126	CD
18637	13916	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13916	5	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	13916	6	,	,	,
18637	13916	7	there	there	EX
18637	13916	8	are	be	VBP
18637	13916	9	few	few	JJ
18637	13916	10	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	13916	11	of	of	IN
18637	13916	12	the	the	DT
18637	13916	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13916	14	,	,	,
18637	13916	15	the	the	DT
18637	13916	16	merely	merely	RB
18637	13916	17	literal	literal	JJ
18637	13916	18	possibilities	possibility	NNS
18637	13916	19	of	of	IN
18637	13916	20	which	which	WDT
18637	13916	21	have	have	VBP
18637	13916	22	been	be	VBN
18637	13916	23	so	so	RB
18637	13916	24	little	little	RB
18637	13916	25	developed	develop	VBN
18637	13916	26	as	as	IN
18637	13916	27	the	the	DT
18637	13916	28	full	full	JJ
18637	13916	29	faith	faith	NN
18637	13916	30	and	and	CC
18637	13916	31	credit	credit	NN
18637	13916	32	clause	clause	NN
18637	13916	33	.	.	.
18637	13917	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13917	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	13917	3	the	the	DT
18637	13917	4	power	power	NN
18637	13917	5	under	under	IN
18637	13917	6	the	the	DT
18637	13917	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	13917	8	to	to	TO
18637	13917	9	decree	decree	VB
18637	13917	10	the	the	DT
18637	13917	11	effect	effect	NN
18637	13917	12	that	that	WDT
18637	13917	13	the	the	DT
18637	13917	14	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	13917	15	of	of	IN
18637	13917	16	one	one	CD
18637	13917	17	State	state	NN
18637	13917	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	13917	19	have	have	VB
18637	13917	20	in	in	IN
18637	13917	21	other	other	JJ
18637	13917	22	States	state	NNS
18637	13917	23	.	.	.
18637	13918	1	This	this	DT
18637	13918	2	being	be	VBG
18637	13918	3	so	so	RB
18637	13918	4	,	,	,
18637	13918	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13918	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	13918	7	not	not	RB
18637	13918	8	seem	seem	VB
18637	13918	9	extravagant	extravagant	JJ
18637	13918	10	to	to	TO
18637	13918	11	argue	argue	VB
18637	13918	12	that	that	IN
18637	13918	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13918	14	may	may	MD
18637	13918	15	under	under	IN
18637	13918	16	the	the	DT
18637	13918	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	13918	18	describe	describe	VBP
18637	13918	19	a	a	DT
18637	13918	20	certain	certain	JJ
18637	13918	21	type	type	NN
18637	13918	22	of	of	IN
18637	13918	23	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	13918	24	and	and	CC
18637	13918	25	say	say	VB
18637	13918	26	that	that	IN
18637	13918	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13918	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	13918	29	be	be	VB
18637	13918	30	granted	grant	VBN
18637	13918	31	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13918	32	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	13918	33	the	the	DT
18637	13918	34	Union	Union	NNP
18637	13918	35	,	,	,
18637	13918	36	and	and	CC
18637	13918	37	that	that	IN
18637	13918	38	no	no	DT
18637	13918	39	other	other	JJ
18637	13918	40	kind	kind	NN
18637	13918	41	shall	shall	MD
18637	13918	42	.	.	.
18637	13919	1	Or	or	CC
18637	13919	2	to	to	TO
18637	13919	3	speak	speak	VB
18637	13919	4	in	in	IN
18637	13919	5	more	more	JJR
18637	13919	6	general	general	JJ
18637	13919	7	terms	term	NNS
18637	13919	8	,	,	,
18637	13919	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13919	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	13919	11	under	under	IN
18637	13919	12	the	the	DT
18637	13919	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	13919	14	power	power	NN
18637	13919	15	to	to	TO
18637	13919	16	enact	enact	VB
18637	13919	17	standards	standard	NNS
18637	13919	18	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	13919	19	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	13919	20	of	of	IN
18637	13919	21	State	State	NNP
18637	13919	22	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	13919	23	may	may	MD
18637	13919	24	be	be	VB
18637	13919	25	secured	secure	VBN
18637	13919	26	as	as	IN
18637	13919	27	to	to	IN
18637	13919	28	almost	almost	RB
18637	13919	29	any	any	DT
18637	13919	30	matter	matter	NN
18637	13919	31	in	in	IN
18637	13919	32	connection	connection	NN
18637	13919	33	with	with	IN
18637	13919	34	which	which	WDT
18637	13919	35	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	13919	36	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13919	37	of	of	IN
18637	13919	38	private	private	JJ
18637	13919	39	rights	right	NNS
18637	13919	40	would	would	MD
18637	13919	41	be	be	VB
18637	13919	42	useful	useful	JJ
18637	13919	43	and	and	CC
18637	13919	44	valuable	valuable	JJ
18637	13919	45	.	.	.
18637	13920	1	FULL	FULL	NNP
18637	13920	2	FAITH	FAITH	NNP
18637	13920	3	AND	and	CC
18637	13920	4	CREDIT	credit	NN
18637	13920	5	IN	in	IN
18637	13920	6	THE	the	DT
18637	13920	7	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	13920	8	COURTS	court	NNS
18637	13920	9	As	as	IN
18637	13920	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13920	11	saw	see	VBD
18637	13920	12	earlier	early	RBR
18637	13920	13	,	,	,
18637	13920	14	the	the	DT
18637	13920	15	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	13920	16	of	of	IN
18637	13920	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13920	18	comprised	comprise	VBD
18637	13920	19	in	in	IN
18637	13920	20	section	section	NN
18637	13920	21	905	905	CD
18637	13920	22	of	of	IN
18637	13920	23	the	the	DT
18637	13920	24	Revised	Revised	NNP
18637	13920	25	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	13920	26	lays	lay	VBZ
18637	13920	27	down	down	RB
18637	13920	28	a	a	DT
18637	13920	29	rule	rule	NN
18637	13920	30	not	not	RB
18637	13920	31	merely	merely	RB
18637	13920	32	for	for	IN
18637	13920	33	the	the	DT
18637	13920	34	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13920	35	of	of	IN
18637	13920	36	the	the	DT
18637	13920	37	records	record	NNS
18637	13920	38	and	and	CC
18637	13920	39	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13920	40	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13920	41	of	of	IN
18637	13920	42	State	State	NNP
18637	13920	43	courts	court	NNS
18637	13920	44	in	in	IN
18637	13920	45	the	the	DT
18637	13920	46	courts	court	NNS
18637	13920	47	of	of	IN
18637	13920	48	sister	sister	NN
18637	13920	49	States	States	NNP
18637	13920	50	,	,	,
18637	13920	51	but	but	CC
18637	13920	52	for	for	IN
18637	13920	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13920	54	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13920	55	in	in	IN
18637	13920	56	"	"	``
18637	13920	57	every	every	DT
18637	13920	58	court	court	NN
18637	13920	59	of	of	IN
18637	13920	60	the	the	DT
18637	13920	61	United	United	NNP
18637	13920	62	States	States	NNP
18637	13920	63	,	,	,
18637	13920	64	"	"	''
18637	13920	65	and	and	CC
18637	13920	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13920	67	further	further	RB
18637	13920	68	lays	lay	VBZ
18637	13920	69	down	down	RB
18637	13920	70	a	a	DT
18637	13920	71	like	like	JJ
18637	13920	72	rule	rule	NN
18637	13920	73	for	for	IN
18637	13920	74	the	the	DT
18637	13920	75	records	record	NNS
18637	13920	76	and	and	CC
18637	13920	77	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13920	78	of	of	IN
18637	13920	79	the	the	DT
18637	13920	80	courts	court	NNS
18637	13920	81	"	"	''
18637	13920	82	of	of	IN
18637	13920	83	any	any	DT
18637	13920	84	territory	territory	NN
18637	13920	85	or	or	CC
18637	13920	86	any	any	DT
18637	13920	87	country	country	NN
18637	13920	88	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13920	89	to	to	IN
18637	13920	90	the	the	DT
18637	13920	91	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13920	92	of	of	IN
18637	13920	93	the	the	DT
18637	13920	94	United	United	NNP
18637	13920	95	States	States	NNP
18637	13920	96	.	.	.
18637	13920	97	"	"	''
18637	13921	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	13921	2	the	the	DT
18637	13921	3	courts	court	NNS
18637	13921	4	of	of	IN
18637	13921	5	the	the	DT
18637	13921	6	United	United	NNP
18637	13921	7	States	States	NNP
18637	13921	8	are	be	VBP
18637	13921	9	bound	bind	VBN
18637	13921	10	to	to	TO
18637	13921	11	give	give	VB
18637	13921	12	to	to	IN
18637	13921	13	the	the	DT
18637	13921	14	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13921	15	of	of	IN
18637	13921	16	the	the	DT
18637	13921	17	State	State	NNP
18637	13921	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	13921	19	the	the	DT
18637	13921	20	same	same	JJ
18637	13921	21	faith	faith	NN
18637	13921	22	and	and	CC
18637	13921	23	credit	credit	NN
18637	13921	24	that	that	WDT
18637	13921	25	the	the	DT
18637	13921	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	13921	27	of	of	IN
18637	13921	28	one	one	CD
18637	13921	29	State	State	NNP
18637	13921	30	are	be	VBP
18637	13921	31	bound	bind	VBN
18637	13921	32	to	to	TO
18637	13921	33	give	give	VB
18637	13921	34	to	to	IN
18637	13921	35	the	the	DT
18637	13921	36	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13921	37	of	of	IN
18637	13921	38	the	the	DT
18637	13921	39	courts	court	NNS
18637	13921	40	of	of	IN
18637	13921	41	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13921	42	sister	sister	NN
18637	13921	43	States	States	NNP
18637	13921	44	.	.	.
18637	13922	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13922	2	127	127	CD
18637	13922	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13922	4	So	so	CC
18637	13922	5	,	,	,
18637	13922	6	where	where	WRB
18637	13922	7	suits	suit	NNS
18637	13922	8	to	to	TO
18637	13922	9	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	13922	10	the	the	DT
18637	13922	11	laws	law	NNS
18637	13922	12	of	of	IN
18637	13922	13	one	one	CD
18637	13922	14	State	State	NNP
18637	13922	15	are	be	VBP
18637	13922	16	entertained	entertain	VBN
18637	13922	17	in	in	IN
18637	13922	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	13922	19	of	of	IN
18637	13922	20	another	another	DT
18637	13922	21	on	on	IN
18637	13922	22	principles	principle	NNS
18637	13922	23	of	of	IN
18637	13922	24	comity	comity	NN
18637	13922	25	,	,	,
18637	13922	26	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13922	27	district	district	NN
18637	13922	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	13922	29	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	13922	30	in	in	IN
18637	13922	31	that	that	DT
18637	13922	32	State	State	NNP
18637	13922	33	may	may	MD
18637	13922	34	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	13922	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13922	36	,	,	,
18637	13922	37	and	and	CC
18637	13922	38	should	should	MD
18637	13922	39	,	,	,
18637	13922	40	if	if	IN
18637	13922	41	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13922	42	do	do	VBP
18637	13922	43	not	not	RB
18637	13922	44	infringe	infringe	VB
18637	13922	45	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13922	46	law	law	NN
18637	13922	47	or	or	CC
18637	13922	48	policy	policy	NN
18637	13922	49	.	.	.
18637	13923	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13923	2	128	128	CD
18637	13923	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13923	4	However	however	RB
18637	13923	5	,	,	,
18637	13923	6	the	the	DT
18637	13923	7	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	13923	8	of	of	IN
18637	13923	9	a	a	DT
18637	13923	10	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	13923	11	court	court	NN
18637	13923	12	in	in	IN
18637	13923	13	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	13923	14	,	,	,
18637	13923	15	having	have	VBG
18637	13923	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13923	17	of	of	IN
18637	13923	18	the	the	DT
18637	13923	19	action	action	NN
18637	13923	20	,	,	,
18637	13923	21	which	which	WDT
18637	13923	22	was	be	VBD
18637	13923	23	on	on	IN
18637	13923	24	a	a	DT
18637	13923	25	policy	policy	NN
18637	13923	26	issued	issue	VBN
18637	13923	27	by	by	IN
18637	13923	28	a	a	DT
18637	13923	29	New	New	NNP
18637	13923	30	York	York	NNP
18637	13923	31	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	13923	32	company	company	NN
18637	13923	33	,	,	,
18637	13923	34	to	to	TO
18637	13923	35	admit	admit	VB
18637	13923	36	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	13923	37	that	that	IN
18637	13923	38	an	an	DT
18637	13923	39	administrator	administrator	NN
18637	13923	40	had	have	VBD
18637	13923	41	been	be	VBN
18637	13923	42	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	13923	43	and	and	CC
18637	13923	44	a	a	DT
18637	13923	45	suit	suit	NN
18637	13923	46	brought	bring	VBN
18637	13923	47	by	by	IN
18637	13923	48	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13923	49	on	on	IN
18637	13923	50	a	a	DT
18637	13923	51	bond	bond	NN
18637	13923	52	in	in	IN
18637	13923	53	the	the	DT
18637	13923	54	federal	federal	JJ
18637	13923	55	court	court	NN
18637	13923	56	in	in	IN
18637	13923	57	New	New	NNP
18637	13923	58	York	York	NNP
18637	13923	59	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	13923	60	no	no	DT
18637	13923	61	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13923	62	had	have	VBD
18637	13923	63	been	be	VBN
18637	13923	64	entered	enter	VBN
18637	13923	65	,	,	,
18637	13923	66	did	do	VBD
18637	13923	67	not	not	RB
18637	13923	68	violate	violate	VB
18637	13923	69	this	this	DT
18637	13923	70	clause	clause	NN
18637	13923	71	.	.	.
18637	13924	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13924	2	129	129	CD
18637	13924	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13924	4	The	the	DT
18637	13924	5	power	power	NN
18637	13924	6	to	to	TO
18637	13924	7	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	13924	8	what	what	WDT
18637	13924	9	effect	effect	NN
18637	13924	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	13924	11	be	be	VB
18637	13924	12	given	give	VBN
18637	13924	13	to	to	IN
18637	13924	14	the	the	DT
18637	13924	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13924	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	13924	17	of	of	IN
18637	13924	18	the	the	DT
18637	13924	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	13924	20	of	of	IN
18637	13924	21	the	the	DT
18637	13924	22	United	United	NNP
18637	13924	23	States	States	NNP
18637	13924	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	13924	25	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	13924	26	by	by	IN
18637	13924	27	other	other	JJ
18637	13924	28	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	13924	29	of	of	IN
18637	13924	30	the	the	DT
18637	13924	31	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13924	32	,	,	,
18637	13924	33	such	such	JJ
18637	13924	34	as	as	IN
18637	13924	35	those	those	DT
18637	13924	36	which	which	WDT
18637	13924	37	declare	declare	VBP
18637	13924	38	the	the	DT
18637	13924	39	extent	extent	NN
18637	13924	40	of	of	IN
18637	13924	41	the	the	DT
18637	13924	42	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13924	43	power	power	NN
18637	13924	44	of	of	IN
18637	13924	45	the	the	DT
18637	13924	46	United	United	NNP
18637	13924	47	States	States	NNP
18637	13924	48	,	,	,
18637	13924	49	which	which	WDT
18637	13924	50	authorize	authorize	VBP
18637	13924	51	all	all	DT
18637	13924	52	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	13924	53	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	13924	54	and	and	CC
18637	13924	55	proper	proper	JJ
18637	13924	56	for	for	IN
18637	13924	57	executing	execute	VBG
18637	13924	58	the	the	DT
18637	13924	59	powers	power	NNS
18637	13924	60	vested	vest	VBN
18637	13924	61	by	by	IN
18637	13924	62	the	the	DT
18637	13924	63	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13924	64	in	in	IN
18637	13924	65	the	the	DT
18637	13924	66	Government	Government	NNP
18637	13924	67	of	of	IN
18637	13924	68	the	the	DT
18637	13924	69	United	United	NNP
18637	13924	70	States	States	NNP
18637	13924	71	,	,	,
18637	13924	72	and	and	CC
18637	13924	73	which	which	WDT
18637	13924	74	declare	declare	VBP
18637	13924	75	the	the	DT
18637	13924	76	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	13924	77	of	of	IN
18637	13924	78	the	the	DT
18637	13924	79	authority	authority	NN
18637	13924	80	of	of	IN
18637	13924	81	the	the	DT
18637	13924	82	National	National	NNP
18637	13924	83	Government	Government	NNP
18637	13924	84	within	within	IN
18637	13924	85	the	the	DT
18637	13924	86	limits	limit	NNS
18637	13924	87	of	of	IN
18637	13924	88	the	the	DT
18637	13924	89	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13924	90	.	.	.
18637	13925	1	As	as	IN
18637	13925	2	part	part	NN
18637	13925	3	of	of	IN
18637	13925	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13925	5	general	general	JJ
18637	13925	6	authority	authority	NNP
18637	13925	7	,	,	,
18637	13925	8	the	the	DT
18637	13925	9	power	power	NN
18637	13925	10	to	to	TO
18637	13925	11	give	give	VB
18637	13925	12	effect	effect	NN
18637	13925	13	to	to	IN
18637	13925	14	the	the	DT
18637	13925	15	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13925	16	of	of	IN
18637	13925	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13925	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	13925	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	13925	20	coextensive	coextensive	JJ
18637	13925	21	with	with	IN
18637	13925	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13925	23	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	13925	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13925	25	.	.	.
18637	13926	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13926	2	130	130	CD
18637	13926	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13926	4	JUDGMENTS	judgments	NN
18637	13926	5	OF	of	IN
18637	13926	6	FOREIGN	foreign	JJ
18637	13926	7	STATES	state	NNS
18637	13926	8	Doubtless	Doubtless	NNP
18637	13926	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13926	10	might	may	MD
18637	13926	11	also	also	RB
18637	13926	12	by	by	IN
18637	13926	13	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	13926	14	of	of	IN
18637	13926	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13926	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	13926	17	in	in	IN
18637	13926	18	the	the	DT
18637	13926	19	field	field	NN
18637	13926	20	of	of	IN
18637	13926	21	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13926	22	relations	relation	NNS
18637	13926	23	lay	lie	VBD
18637	13926	24	down	down	RP
18637	13926	25	a	a	DT
18637	13926	26	mandatory	mandatory	JJ
18637	13926	27	rule	rule	NN
18637	13926	28	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	13926	29	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13926	30	of	of	IN
18637	13926	31	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13926	32	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13926	33	in	in	IN
18637	13926	34	every	every	DT
18637	13926	35	court	court	NN
18637	13926	36	of	of	IN
18637	13926	37	the	the	DT
18637	13926	38	United	United	NNP
18637	13926	39	States	States	NNP
18637	13926	40	.	.	.
18637	13927	1	At	at	IN
18637	13927	2	present	present	JJ
18637	13927	3	the	the	DT
18637	13927	4	duty	duty	NN
18637	13927	5	to	to	TO
18637	13927	6	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	13927	7	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	13927	8	even	even	RB
18637	13927	9	in	in	IN
18637	13927	10	national	national	JJ
18637	13927	11	courts	court	NNS
18637	13927	12	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	13927	13	only	only	RB
18637	13927	14	on	on	IN
18637	13927	15	comity	comity	NN
18637	13927	16	and	and	CC
18637	13927	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	13927	18	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	13927	19	,	,	,
18637	13927	20	in	in	IN
18637	13927	21	the	the	DT
18637	13927	22	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	13927	23	of	of	IN
18637	13927	24	the	the	DT
18637	13927	25	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13927	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13927	27	,	,	,
18637	13927	28	by	by	IN
18637	13927	29	a	a	DT
18637	13927	30	strict	strict	JJ
18637	13927	31	rule	rule	NN
18637	13927	32	of	of	IN
18637	13927	33	parity	parity	NN
18637	13927	34	.	.	.
18637	13928	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13928	2	131	131	CD
18637	13928	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13928	4	Section	section	NN
18637	13928	5	2	2	CD
18637	13928	6	.	.	.
18637	13929	1	The	the	DT
18637	13929	2	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	13929	3	of	of	IN
18637	13929	4	each	each	DT
18637	13929	5	State	state	NN
18637	13929	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	13929	7	be	be	VB
18637	13929	8	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13929	9	to	to	IN
18637	13929	10	all	all	DT
18637	13929	11	Privileges	Privileges	NNPS
18637	13929	12	and	and	CC
18637	13929	13	Immunities	Immunities	NNPS
18637	13929	14	of	of	IN
18637	13929	15	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	13929	16	in	in	IN
18637	13929	17	the	the	DT
18637	13929	18	several	several	JJ
18637	13929	19	States	state	NNS
18637	13929	20	.	.	.
18637	13930	1	The	the	DT
18637	13930	2	Comity	Comity	NNP
18637	13930	3	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	13930	4	SOURCES	source	VBZ
18637	13930	5	The	the	DT
18637	13930	6	community	community	NN
18637	13930	7	of	of	IN
18637	13930	8	rights	right	NNS
18637	13930	9	among	among	IN
18637	13930	10	the	the	DT
18637	13930	11	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13930	12	of	of	IN
18637	13930	13	the	the	DT
18637	13930	14	several	several	JJ
18637	13930	15	States	state	NNS
18637	13930	16	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	13930	17	by	by	IN
18637	13930	18	this	this	DT
18637	13930	19	article	article	NN
18637	13930	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	13930	21	traceable	traceable	JJ
18637	13930	22	to	to	IN
18637	13930	23	colonial	colonial	JJ
18637	13930	24	days	day	NNS
18637	13930	25	.	.	.
18637	13931	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13931	2	had	have	VBD
18637	13931	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13931	4	origin	origin	NN
18637	13931	5	in	in	IN
18637	13931	6	the	the	DT
18637	13931	7	fact	fact	NN
18637	13931	8	that	that	IN
18637	13931	9	the	the	DT
18637	13931	10	colonists	colonist	NNS
18637	13931	11	were	be	VBD
18637	13931	12	all	all	DT
18637	13931	13	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	13931	14	of	of	IN
18637	13931	15	the	the	DT
18637	13931	16	same	same	JJ
18637	13931	17	monarch	monarch	NN
18637	13931	18	.	.	.
18637	13932	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13932	2	132	132	CD
18637	13932	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13932	4	After	after	IN
18637	13932	5	the	the	DT
18637	13932	6	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
18637	13932	7	of	of	IN
18637	13932	8	Independence	Independence	NNP
18637	13932	9	was	be	VBD
18637	13932	10	signed	sign	VBN
18637	13932	11	,	,	,
18637	13932	12	the	the	DT
18637	13932	13	question	question	NN
18637	13932	14	arose	arise	VBD
18637	13932	15	as	as	IN
18637	13932	16	to	to	IN
18637	13932	17	how	how	WRB
18637	13932	18	to	to	TO
18637	13932	19	reconcile	reconcile	VB
18637	13932	20	the	the	DT
18637	13932	21	advantages	advantage	NNS
18637	13932	22	of	of	IN
18637	13932	23	a	a	DT
18637	13932	24	common	common	JJ
18637	13932	25	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	13932	26	with	with	IN
18637	13932	27	a	a	DT
18637	13932	28	dispersed	disperse	VBN
18637	13932	29	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	13932	30	.	.	.
18637	13933	1	One	one	CD
18637	13933	2	element	element	NN
18637	13933	3	of	of	IN
18637	13933	4	the	the	DT
18637	13933	5	solution	solution	NN
18637	13933	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	13933	7	to	to	TO
18637	13933	8	be	be	VB
18637	13933	9	seen	see	VBN
18637	13933	10	in	in	IN
18637	13933	11	the	the	DT
18637	13933	12	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	13933	13	of	of	IN
18637	13933	14	the	the	DT
18637	13933	15	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	13933	16	of	of	IN
18637	13933	17	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	13933	18	,	,	,
18637	13933	19	which	which	WDT
18637	13933	20	read	read	VBD
18637	13933	21	as	as	IN
18637	13933	22	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	13933	23	:	:	:
18637	13933	24	"	"	``
18637	13933	25	The	the	DT
18637	13933	26	better	well	JJR
18637	13933	27	to	to	TO
18637	13933	28	secure	secure	VB
18637	13933	29	and	and	CC
18637	13933	30	perpetuate	perpetuate	VB
18637	13933	31	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	13933	32	friendship	friendship	NN
18637	13933	33	and	and	CC
18637	13933	34	intercourse	intercourse	VB
18637	13933	35	among	among	IN
18637	13933	36	the	the	DT
18637	13933	37	people	people	NNS
18637	13933	38	of	of	IN
18637	13933	39	the	the	DT
18637	13933	40	different	different	JJ
18637	13933	41	States	state	NNS
18637	13933	42	in	in	IN
18637	13933	43	this	this	DT
18637	13933	44	Union	Union	NNP
18637	13933	45	,	,	,
18637	13933	46	the	the	DT
18637	13933	47	free	free	JJ
18637	13933	48	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	13933	49	of	of	IN
18637	13933	50	each	each	DT
18637	13933	51	of	of	IN
18637	13933	52	these	these	DT
18637	13933	53	States	state	NNS
18637	13933	54	,	,	,
18637	13933	55	paupers	pauper	NNS
18637	13933	56	,	,	,
18637	13933	57	vagabonds	vagabond	NNS
18637	13933	58	and	and	CC
18637	13933	59	fugitives	fugitive	NNS
18637	13933	60	from	from	IN
18637	13933	61	justice	justice	NN
18637	13933	62	excepted	except	VBN
18637	13933	63	,	,	,
18637	13933	64	shall	shall	MD
18637	13933	65	be	be	VB
18637	13933	66	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13933	67	to	to	IN
18637	13933	68	all	all	DT
18637	13933	69	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13933	70	and	and	CC
18637	13933	71	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	13933	72	of	of	IN
18637	13933	73	free	free	JJ
18637	13933	74	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13933	75	in	in	IN
18637	13933	76	the	the	DT
18637	13933	77	several	several	JJ
18637	13933	78	States	state	NNS
18637	13933	79	;	;	:
18637	13933	80	and	and	CC
18637	13933	81	the	the	DT
18637	13933	82	people	people	NNS
18637	13933	83	of	of	IN
18637	13933	84	each	each	DT
18637	13933	85	State	state	NN
18637	13933	86	shall	shall	MD
18637	13933	87	have	have	VB
18637	13933	88	free	free	JJ
18637	13933	89	ingress	ingress	NN
18637	13933	90	and	and	CC
18637	13933	91	regress	regress	NN
18637	13933	92	to	to	IN
18637	13933	93	and	and	CC
18637	13933	94	from	from	IN
18637	13933	95	any	any	DT
18637	13933	96	other	other	JJ
18637	13933	97	State	State	NNP
18637	13933	98	,	,	,
18637	13933	99	and	and	CC
18637	13933	100	shall	shall	MD
18637	13933	101	enjoy	enjoy	VB
18637	13933	102	therein	therein	RB
18637	13933	103	all	all	PDT
18637	13933	104	the	the	DT
18637	13933	105	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13933	106	of	of	IN
18637	13933	107	trade	trade	NN
18637	13933	108	and	and	CC
18637	13933	109	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	13933	110	,	,	,
18637	13933	111	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13933	112	to	to	IN
18637	13933	113	the	the	DT
18637	13933	114	same	same	JJ
18637	13933	115	duties	duty	NNS
18637	13933	116	,	,	,
18637	13933	117	impositions	imposition	NNS
18637	13933	118	and	and	CC
18637	13933	119	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	13933	120	as	as	IN
18637	13933	121	the	the	DT
18637	13933	122	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	13933	123	thereof	thereof	VBP
18637	13933	124	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	13933	125	*	*	NFP
18637	13933	126	*	*	NFP
18637	13933	127	*	*	NFP
18637	13933	128	"	"	``
18637	13933	129	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	13933	130	,	,	,
18637	13933	131	writing	write	VBG
18637	13933	132	in	in	IN
18637	13933	133	_	_	NNP
18637	13933	134	The	the	DT
18637	13933	135	Federalist_,[133	Federalist_,[133	NNP
18637	13933	136	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13933	137	adverted	advert	VBD
18637	13933	138	to	to	IN
18637	13933	139	the	the	DT
18637	13933	140	confusion	confusion	NN
18637	13933	141	engendered	engender	VBN
18637	13933	142	by	by	IN
18637	13933	143	use	use	NN
18637	13933	144	of	of	IN
18637	13933	145	the	the	DT
18637	13933	146	different	different	JJ
18637	13933	147	terms	term	NNS
18637	13933	148	"	"	``
18637	13933	149	free	free	JJ
18637	13933	150	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	13933	151	,	,	,
18637	13933	152	free	free	JJ
18637	13933	153	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13933	154	,	,	,
18637	13933	155	"	"	''
18637	13933	156	and	and	CC
18637	13933	157	"	"	``
18637	13933	158	people	people	NNS
18637	13933	159	"	"	''
18637	13933	160	and	and	CC
18637	13933	161	by	by	IN
18637	13933	162	"	"	``
18637	13933	163	superadding	superadde	VBG
18637	13933	164	to	to	IN
18637	13933	165	'	'	''
18637	13933	166	all	all	DT
18637	13933	167	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13933	168	and	and	CC
18637	13933	169	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	13933	170	of	of	IN
18637	13933	171	free	free	JJ
18637	13933	172	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13933	173	--	--	:
18637	13933	174	all	all	PDT
18637	13933	175	the	the	DT
18637	13933	176	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13933	177	of	of	IN
18637	13933	178	trade	trade	NN
18637	13933	179	and	and	CC
18637	13933	180	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	13933	181	,	,	,
18637	13933	182	'	'	''
18637	13933	183	*	*	NFP
18637	13933	184	*	*	NFP
18637	13933	185	*	*	NFP
18637	13933	186	"	"	``
18637	13933	187	The	the	DT
18637	13933	188	more	more	RBR
18637	13933	189	concise	concise	JJ
18637	13933	190	phraseology	phraseology	NN
18637	13933	191	of	of	IN
18637	13933	192	article	article	NN
18637	13933	193	IV	IV	NNP
18637	13933	194	,	,	,
18637	13933	195	however	however	RB
18637	13933	196	,	,	,
18637	13933	197	did	do	VBD
18637	13933	198	little	little	JJ
18637	13933	199	to	to	TO
18637	13933	200	dispel	dispel	VB
18637	13933	201	the	the	DT
18637	13933	202	uncertainty	uncertainty	NN
18637	13933	203	.	.	.
18637	13934	1	In	in	IN
18637	13934	2	the	the	DT
18637	13934	3	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	13934	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	13934	5	House	House	NNP
18637	13934	6	Cases,[134	Cases,[134	NNP
18637	13934	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13934	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13934	9	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	13934	10	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	13934	11	that	that	IN
18637	13934	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13934	13	was	be	VBD
18637	13934	14	to	to	TO
18637	13934	15	be	be	VB
18637	13934	16	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	13934	17	as	as	IN
18637	13934	18	the	the	DT
18637	13934	19	compendious	compendious	JJ
18637	13934	20	equivalent	equivalent	NN
18637	13934	21	of	of	IN
18637	13934	22	the	the	DT
18637	13934	23	earlier	early	JJR
18637	13934	24	version	version	NN
18637	13934	25	:	:	:
18637	13934	26	"	"	``
18637	13934	27	There	there	EX
18637	13934	28	can	can	MD
18637	13934	29	be	be	VB
18637	13934	30	but	but	CC
18637	13934	31	little	little	JJ
18637	13934	32	question	question	NN
18637	13934	33	that	that	IN
18637	13934	34	the	the	DT
18637	13934	35	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	13934	36	of	of	IN
18637	13934	37	both	both	PDT
18637	13934	38	these	these	DT
18637	13934	39	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	13934	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	13934	41	the	the	DT
18637	13934	42	same	same	JJ
18637	13934	43	,	,	,
18637	13934	44	and	and	CC
18637	13934	45	that	that	IN
18637	13934	46	the	the	DT
18637	13934	47	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13934	48	and	and	CC
18637	13934	49	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	13934	50	intended	intend	VBN
18637	13934	51	are	be	VBP
18637	13934	52	the	the	DT
18637	13934	53	same	same	JJ
18637	13934	54	in	in	IN
18637	13934	55	each	each	DT
18637	13934	56	.	.	.
18637	13935	1	In	in	IN
18637	13935	2	the	the	DT
18637	13935	3	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	13935	4	of	of	IN
18637	13935	5	the	the	DT
18637	13935	6	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	13935	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13935	8	have	have	VBP
18637	13935	9	some	some	DT
18637	13935	10	of	of	IN
18637	13935	11	these	these	DT
18637	13935	12	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	13935	13	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	13935	14	,	,	,
18637	13935	15	and	and	CC
18637	13935	16	enough	enough	JJ
18637	13935	17	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	13935	18	to	to	TO
18637	13935	19	give	give	VB
18637	13935	20	some	some	DT
18637	13935	21	general	general	JJ
18637	13935	22	ideal	ideal	NN
18637	13935	23	of	of	IN
18637	13935	24	the	the	DT
18637	13935	25	class	class	NN
18637	13935	26	of	of	IN
18637	13935	27	civil	civil	JJ
18637	13935	28	rights	right	NNS
18637	13935	29	meant	mean	VBN
18637	13935	30	by	by	IN
18637	13935	31	the	the	DT
18637	13935	32	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	13935	33	.	.	.
18637	13936	1	"	"	``
18637	13936	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13936	3	135	135	CD
18637	13936	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13936	5	THEORIES	theory	NNS
18637	13936	6	AS	as	IN
18637	13936	7	TO	to	IN
18637	13936	8	ITS	its	PRP$
18637	13936	9	PURPOSE	purpose	NN
18637	13936	10	First	first	RB
18637	13936	11	and	and	CC
18637	13936	12	last	last	JJ
18637	13936	13	,	,	,
18637	13936	14	at	at	IN
18637	13936	15	least	least	JJS
18637	13936	16	four	four	CD
18637	13936	17	theories	theory	NNS
18637	13936	18	have	have	VBP
18637	13936	19	been	be	VBN
18637	13936	20	proffered	proffer	VBN
18637	13936	21	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	13936	22	the	the	DT
18637	13936	23	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	13936	24	of	of	IN
18637	13936	25	this	this	DT
18637	13936	26	clause	clause	NN
18637	13936	27	.	.	.
18637	13937	1	The	the	DT
18637	13937	2	first	first	JJ
18637	13937	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	13937	4	that	that	IN
18637	13937	5	the	the	DT
18637	13937	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	13937	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	13937	8	a	a	DT
18637	13937	9	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	13937	10	to	to	IN
18637	13937	11	the	the	DT
18637	13937	12	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13937	13	of	of	IN
18637	13937	14	the	the	DT
18637	13937	15	different	different	JJ
18637	13937	16	States	state	NNS
18637	13937	17	of	of	IN
18637	13937	18	equal	equal	JJ
18637	13937	19	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	13937	20	by	by	IN
18637	13937	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13937	22	--	--	:
18637	13937	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	13937	24	,	,	,
18637	13937	25	in	in	IN
18637	13937	26	other	other	JJ
18637	13937	27	words	word	NNS
18637	13937	28	,	,	,
18637	13937	29	a	a	DT
18637	13937	30	species	species	NN
18637	13937	31	of	of	IN
18637	13937	32	equal	equal	JJ
18637	13937	33	protection	protection	NN
18637	13937	34	clause	clause	NN
18637	13937	35	binding	bind	VBG
18637	13937	36	on	on	IN
18637	13937	37	the	the	DT
18637	13937	38	National	National	NNP
18637	13937	39	Government	Government	NNP
18637	13937	40	.	.	.
18637	13938	1	The	the	DT
18637	13938	2	second	second	JJ
18637	13938	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	13938	4	that	that	IN
18637	13938	5	the	the	DT
18637	13938	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	13938	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	13938	8	a	a	DT
18637	13938	9	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	13938	10	to	to	IN
18637	13938	11	the	the	DT
18637	13938	12	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13938	13	of	of	IN
18637	13938	14	each	each	DT
18637	13938	15	State	State	NNP
18637	13938	16	of	of	IN
18637	13938	17	all	all	PDT
18637	13938	18	the	the	DT
18637	13938	19	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13938	20	and	and	CC
18637	13938	21	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	13938	22	of	of	IN
18637	13938	23	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	13938	24	that	that	WDT
18637	13938	25	are	be	VBP
18637	13938	26	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
18637	13938	27	in	in	IN
18637	13938	28	any	any	DT
18637	13938	29	State	State	NNP
18637	13938	30	by	by	IN
18637	13938	31	the	the	DT
18637	13938	32	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13938	33	thereof,--a	thereof,--a	NNP
18637	13938	34	view	view	NN
18637	13938	35	which	which	WDT
18637	13938	36	,	,	,
18637	13938	37	if	if	IN
18637	13938	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13938	39	had	have	VBD
18637	13938	40	been	be	VBN
18637	13938	41	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	13938	42	at	at	IN
18637	13938	43	the	the	DT
18637	13938	44	outset	outset	NN
18637	13938	45	,	,	,
18637	13938	46	might	may	MD
18637	13938	47	well	well	RB
18637	13938	48	have	have	VB
18637	13938	49	endowed	endow	VBN
18637	13938	50	the	the	DT
18637	13938	51	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13938	52	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13938	53	with	with	IN
18637	13938	54	a	a	DT
18637	13938	55	reviewing	review	VBG
18637	13938	56	power	power	NN
18637	13938	57	over	over	IN
18637	13938	58	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	13938	59	State	State	NNP
18637	13938	60	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	13938	61	as	as	RB
18637	13938	62	broad	broad	JJ
18637	13938	63	as	as	IN
18637	13938	64	that	that	DT
18637	13938	65	which	which	WDT
18637	13938	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13938	67	later	later	RB
18637	13938	68	came	come	VBD
18637	13938	69	to	to	TO
18637	13938	70	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	13938	71	under	under	IN
18637	13938	72	the	the	DT
18637	13938	73	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	13938	74	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	13938	75	.	.	.
18637	13939	1	The	the	DT
18637	13939	2	third	third	JJ
18637	13939	3	theory	theory	NN
18637	13939	4	of	of	IN
18637	13939	5	the	the	DT
18637	13939	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	13939	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	13939	8	that	that	IN
18637	13939	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13939	10	guarantees	guarantee	VBZ
18637	13939	11	to	to	IN
18637	13939	12	the	the	DT
18637	13939	13	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	13939	14	of	of	IN
18637	13939	15	any	any	DT
18637	13939	16	State	State	NNP
18637	13939	17	the	the	DT
18637	13939	18	rights	right	NNS
18637	13939	19	which	which	WDT
18637	13939	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13939	21	enjoys	enjoy	VBZ
18637	13939	22	as	as	RB
18637	13939	23	such	such	JJ
18637	13939	24	even	even	RB
18637	13939	25	when	when	WRB
18637	13939	26	sojourning	sojourn	VBG
18637	13939	27	in	in	IN
18637	13939	28	another	another	DT
18637	13939	29	State	State	NNP
18637	13939	30	,	,	,
18637	13939	31	that	that	DT
18637	13939	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	13939	33	to	to	TO
18637	13939	34	say	say	VB
18637	13939	35	,	,	,
18637	13939	36	enables	enable	VBZ
18637	13939	37	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13939	38	to	to	TO
18637	13939	39	carry	carry	VB
18637	13939	40	with	with	IN
18637	13939	41	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13939	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13939	43	rights	right	NNS
18637	13939	44	of	of	IN
18637	13939	45	State	State	NNP
18637	13939	46	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	13939	47	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	13939	48	the	the	DT
18637	13939	49	Union	Union	NNP
18637	13939	50	,	,	,
18637	13939	51	without	without	IN
18637	13939	52	embarrassment	embarrassment	NN
18637	13939	53	by	by	IN
18637	13939	54	State	state	NN
18637	13939	55	lines	line	NNS
18637	13939	56	.	.	.
18637	13940	1	Finally	finally	RB
18637	13940	2	,	,	,
18637	13940	3	the	the	DT
18637	13940	4	clause	clause	NN
18637	13940	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	13940	6	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	13940	7	as	as	IN
18637	13940	8	merely	merely	RB
18637	13940	9	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	13940	10	any	any	DT
18637	13940	11	State	State	NNP
18637	13940	12	to	to	TO
18637	13940	13	discriminate	discriminate	VB
18637	13940	14	against	against	IN
18637	13940	15	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13940	16	of	of	IN
18637	13940	17	other	other	JJ
18637	13940	18	States	States	NNPS
18637	13940	19	in	in	IN
18637	13940	20	favor	favor	NN
18637	13940	21	of	of	IN
18637	13940	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13940	23	own	own	JJ
18637	13940	24	.	.	.
18637	13941	1	Though	though	IN
18637	13941	2	the	the	DT
18637	13941	3	first	first	JJ
18637	13941	4	theory	theory	NN
18637	13941	5	received	receive	VBD
18637	13941	6	some	some	DT
18637	13941	7	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13941	8	in	in	IN
18637	13941	9	the	the	DT
18637	13941	10	Dred	Dred	NNP
18637	13941	11	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	13941	12	Case,[136	Case,[136	NNP
18637	13941	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13941	14	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	13941	15	in	in	IN
18637	13941	16	the	the	DT
18637	13941	17	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	13941	18	of	of	IN
18637	13941	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13941	20	Catron,[137	Catron,[137	.
18637	13941	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13941	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13941	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	13941	24	today	today	NN
18637	13941	25	obsolete	obsolete	JJ
18637	13941	26	.	.	.
18637	13942	1	The	the	DT
18637	13942	2	second	second	JJ
18637	13942	3	was	be	VBD
18637	13942	4	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	13942	5	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	13942	6	in	in	IN
18637	13942	7	McKane	McKane	NNP
18637	13942	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13942	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	13942	10	_	_	NNP
18637	13942	11	Durston;[138	durston;[138	NN
18637	13942	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13942	13	the	the	DT
18637	13942	14	third	third	JJ
18637	13942	15	,	,	,
18637	13942	16	in	in	IN
18637	13942	17	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	13942	18	_	_	NNP
18637	13942	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	13942	20	_	_	NNP
18637	13942	21	Osborne	Osborne	NNP
18637	13942	22	.	.	.
18637	13943	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13943	2	139	139	CD
18637	13943	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13943	4	The	the	DT
18637	13943	5	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	13943	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	13943	7	become	become	VBN
18637	13943	8	a	a	DT
18637	13943	9	settled	settle	VBN
18637	13943	10	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	13943	11	of	of	IN
18637	13943	12	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	13943	13	Law	Law	NNP
18637	13943	14	.	.	.
18637	13944	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13944	2	140	140	CD
18637	13944	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13944	4	In	in	IN
18637	13944	5	the	the	DT
18637	13944	6	words	word	NNS
18637	13944	7	of	of	IN
18637	13944	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13944	9	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	13944	10	in	in	IN
18637	13944	11	the	the	DT
18637	13944	12	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	13944	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	13944	14	House	House	NNP
18637	13944	15	Cases,[141	Cases,[141	.
18637	13944	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13944	17	the	the	DT
18637	13944	18	sole	sole	JJ
18637	13944	19	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	13944	20	of	of	IN
18637	13944	21	the	the	DT
18637	13944	22	comity	comity	NN
18637	13944	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	13944	24	was	be	VBD
18637	13944	25	"	"	``
18637	13944	26	to	to	TO
18637	13944	27	declare	declare	VB
18637	13944	28	to	to	IN
18637	13944	29	the	the	DT
18637	13944	30	several	several	JJ
18637	13944	31	States	States	NNPS
18637	13944	32	,	,	,
18637	13944	33	that	that	IN
18637	13944	34	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	13944	35	these	these	DT
18637	13944	36	rights	right	NNS
18637	13944	37	,	,	,
18637	13944	38	as	as	IN
18637	13944	39	you	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13944	40	grant	grant	VBP
18637	13944	41	or	or	CC
18637	13944	42	establish	establish	VB
18637	13944	43	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13944	44	to	to	IN
18637	13944	45	your	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13944	46	own	own	JJ
18637	13944	47	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13944	48	,	,	,
18637	13944	49	or	or	CC
18637	13944	50	as	as	IN
18637	13944	51	you	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13944	52	limit	limit	VBP
18637	13944	53	or	or	CC
18637	13944	54	qualify	qualify	VB
18637	13944	55	,	,	,
18637	13944	56	or	or	CC
18637	13944	57	impose	impose	VB
18637	13944	58	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	13944	59	on	on	IN
18637	13944	60	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13944	61	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	13944	62	,	,	,
18637	13944	63	the	the	DT
18637	13944	64	same	same	JJ
18637	13944	65	,	,	,
18637	13944	66	neither	neither	CC
18637	13944	67	more	more	RBR
18637	13944	68	nor	nor	CC
18637	13944	69	less	less	RBR
18637	13944	70	,	,	,
18637	13944	71	shall	shall	MD
18637	13944	72	be	be	VB
18637	13944	73	the	the	DT
18637	13944	74	measure	measure	NN
18637	13944	75	of	of	IN
18637	13944	76	the	the	DT
18637	13944	77	rights	right	NNS
18637	13944	78	of	of	IN
18637	13944	79	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13944	80	of	of	IN
18637	13944	81	other	other	JJ
18637	13944	82	States	States	NNPS
18637	13944	83	within	within	IN
18637	13944	84	your	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13944	85	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13944	86	.	.	.
18637	13945	1	"	"	``
18637	13945	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13945	3	142	142	CD
18637	13945	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13945	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13945	6	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	13945	7	that	that	IN
18637	13945	8	this	this	DT
18637	13945	9	section	section	NN
18637	13945	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	13945	11	no	no	DT
18637	13945	12	application	application	NN
18637	13945	13	in	in	IN
18637	13945	14	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	13945	15	between	between	IN
18637	13945	16	a	a	DT
18637	13945	17	State	state	NN
18637	13945	18	and	and	CC
18637	13945	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13945	20	own	own	JJ
18637	13945	21	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13945	22	.	.	.
18637	13946	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13946	2	143	143	CD
18637	13946	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13946	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13946	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	13946	6	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	13946	7	to	to	TO
18637	13946	8	be	be	VB
18637	13946	9	infringed	infringe	VBN
18637	13946	10	by	by	IN
18637	13946	11	a	a	DT
18637	13946	12	hostile	hostile	JJ
18637	13946	13	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	13946	14	against	against	IN
18637	13946	15	all	all	DT
18637	13946	16	nonresidents[144	nonresidents[144	RB
18637	13946	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13946	18	but	but	CC
18637	13946	19	not	not	RB
18637	13946	20	by	by	IN
18637	13946	21	such	such	JJ
18637	13946	22	differences	difference	NNS
18637	13946	23	of	of	IN
18637	13946	24	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	13946	25	between	between	IN
18637	13946	26	residents	resident	NNS
18637	13946	27	and	and	CC
18637	13946	28	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	13946	29	as	as	IN
18637	13946	30	the	the	DT
18637	13946	31	nature	nature	NN
18637	13946	32	of	of	IN
18637	13946	33	the	the	DT
18637	13946	34	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13946	35	matter	matter	NN
18637	13946	36	makes	make	VBZ
18637	13946	37	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	13946	38	.	.	.
18637	13947	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13947	2	145	145	CD
18637	13947	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13947	4	HOW	how	WRB
18637	13947	5	IMPLEMENTED	implement	VBN
18637	13947	6	This	this	DT
18637	13947	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	13947	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	13947	9	self	self	NN
18637	13947	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	13947	11	executory	executory	NN
18637	13947	12	,	,	,
18637	13947	13	that	that	DT
18637	13947	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	13947	15	to	to	TO
18637	13947	16	say	say	VB
18637	13947	17	,	,	,
18637	13947	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13947	19	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	13947	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	13947	21	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	13947	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	13947	23	the	the	DT
18637	13947	24	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13947	25	process	process	NN
18637	13947	26	.	.	.
18637	13948	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13948	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	13948	3	not	not	RB
18637	13948	4	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	13948	5	penal	penal	JJ
18637	13948	6	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	13948	7	by	by	IN
18637	13948	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13948	9	.	.	.
18637	13949	1	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	13949	2	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	13949	3	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	13949	4	conspiracies	conspiracy	NNS
18637	13949	5	to	to	TO
18637	13949	6	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	13949	7	any	any	DT
18637	13949	8	person	person	NN
18637	13949	9	of	of	IN
18637	13949	10	rights	right	NNS
18637	13949	11	or	or	CC
18637	13949	12	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13949	13	secured	secure	VBN
18637	13949	14	by	by	IN
18637	13949	15	State	State	NNP
18637	13949	16	laws,[146	laws,[146	NNP
18637	13949	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13949	18	or	or	CC
18637	13949	19	punishing	punish	VBG
18637	13949	20	infractions	infraction	NNS
18637	13949	21	by	by	IN
18637	13949	22	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	13949	23	of	of	IN
18637	13949	24	the	the	DT
18637	13949	25	right	right	NN
18637	13949	26	of	of	IN
18637	13949	27	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13949	28	to	to	TO
18637	13949	29	reside	reside	VB
18637	13949	30	peacefully	peacefully	RB
18637	13949	31	in	in	IN
18637	13949	32	the	the	DT
18637	13949	33	several	several	JJ
18637	13949	34	States	States	NNPS
18637	13949	35	,	,	,
18637	13949	36	and	and	CC
18637	13949	37	to	to	TO
18637	13949	38	have	have	VB
18637	13949	39	free	free	JJ
18637	13949	40	ingress	ingress	NN
18637	13949	41	into	into	IN
18637	13949	42	and	and	CC
18637	13949	43	egress	egress	NN
18637	13949	44	from	from	IN
18637	13949	45	such	such	JJ
18637	13949	46	States,[147	States,[147	NNP
18637	13949	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13949	48	have	have	VBP
18637	13949	49	been	be	VBN
18637	13949	50	held	hold	VBN
18637	13949	51	void	void	JJ
18637	13949	52	.	.	.
18637	13950	1	CITIZENS	citizen	NNS
18637	13950	2	OF	of	IN
18637	13950	3	EACH	each	NN
18637	13950	4	STATE	state	NN
18637	13950	5	A	a	DT
18637	13950	6	question	question	NN
18637	13950	7	much	much	RB
18637	13950	8	mooted	moot	VBN
18637	13950	9	before	before	IN
18637	13950	10	the	the	DT
18637	13950	11	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	13950	12	War	War	NNP
18637	13950	13	was	be	VBD
18637	13950	14	whether	whether	IN
18637	13950	15	the	the	DT
18637	13950	16	term	term	NN
18637	13950	17	could	could	MD
18637	13950	18	be	be	VB
18637	13950	19	held	hold	VBN
18637	13950	20	to	to	TO
18637	13950	21	include	include	VB
18637	13950	22	free	free	JJ
18637	13950	23	Negroes	Negroes	NNPS
18637	13950	24	.	.	.
18637	13951	1	In	in	IN
18637	13951	2	the	the	DT
18637	13951	3	Dred	Dred	NNP
18637	13951	4	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	13951	5	Case,[148	Case,[148	NNP
18637	13951	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13951	7	the	the	DT
18637	13951	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13951	9	answered	answer	VBD
18637	13951	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13951	11	in	in	IN
18637	13951	12	the	the	DT
18637	13951	13	negative	negative	NN
18637	13951	14	.	.	.
18637	13952	1	"	"	``
18637	13952	2	Citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13952	3	of	of	IN
18637	13952	4	each	each	DT
18637	13952	5	State	state	NN
18637	13952	6	,	,	,
18637	13952	7	"	"	''
18637	13952	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	13952	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13952	10	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	13952	11	argued	argue	VBD
18637	13952	12	,	,	,
18637	13952	13	meant	mean	VBN
18637	13952	14	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13952	15	of	of	IN
18637	13952	16	the	the	DT
18637	13952	17	United	United	NNP
18637	13952	18	States	States	NNP
18637	13952	19	as	as	IN
18637	13952	20	understood	understand	VBD
18637	13952	21	at	at	IN
18637	13952	22	the	the	DT
18637	13952	23	time	time	NN
18637	13952	24	the	the	DT
18637	13952	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13952	26	was	be	VBD
18637	13952	27	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	13952	28	,	,	,
18637	13952	29	and	and	CC
18637	13952	30	Negroes	Negroes	NNPS
18637	13952	31	were	be	VBD
18637	13952	32	not	not	RB
18637	13952	33	then	then	RB
18637	13952	34	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	13952	35	as	as	RB
18637	13952	36	capable	capable	JJ
18637	13952	37	of	of	IN
18637	13952	38	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	13952	39	.	.	.
18637	13953	1	The	the	DT
18637	13953	2	only	only	JJ
18637	13953	3	category	category	NN
18637	13953	4	of	of	IN
18637	13953	5	national	national	JJ
18637	13953	6	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	13953	7	added	add	VBN
18637	13953	8	under	under	IN
18637	13953	9	the	the	DT
18637	13953	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13953	11	comprised	comprise	VBD
18637	13953	12	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	13953	13	,	,	,
18637	13953	14	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	13953	15	in	in	IN
18637	13953	16	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	13953	17	with	with	IN
18637	13953	18	acts	act	NNS
18637	13953	19	of	of	IN
18637	13953	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13953	21	.	.	.
18637	13954	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13954	2	149	149	CD
18637	13954	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13954	4	In	in	IN
18637	13954	5	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	13954	6	,	,	,
18637	13954	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13954	8	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	13954	9	not	not	RB
18637	13954	10	only	only	RB
18637	13954	11	denied	deny	VBD
18637	13954	12	the	the	DT
18637	13954	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	13954	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13954	15	's	's	POS
18637	13954	16	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	13954	17	that	that	IN
18637	13954	18	there	there	EX
18637	13954	19	were	be	VBD
18637	13954	20	no	no	DT
18637	13954	21	Negro	negro	JJ
18637	13954	22	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13954	23	of	of	IN
18637	13954	24	States	state	NNS
18637	13954	25	in	in	IN
18637	13954	26	1789	1789	CD
18637	13954	27	,	,	,
18637	13954	28	but	but	CC
18637	13954	29	further	further	RB
18637	13954	30	argued	argue	VBD
18637	13954	31	that	that	IN
18637	13954	32	while	while	IN
18637	13954	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13954	34	alone	alone	RB
18637	13954	35	could	could	MD
18637	13954	36	determine	determine	VB
18637	13954	37	what	what	WDT
18637	13954	38	classes	class	NNS
18637	13954	39	of	of	IN
18637	13954	40	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	13954	41	should	should	MD
18637	13954	42	be	be	VB
18637	13954	43	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	13954	44	,	,	,
18637	13954	45	the	the	DT
18637	13954	46	several	several	JJ
18637	13954	47	States	States	NNPS
18637	13954	48	retained	retain	VBD
18637	13954	49	the	the	DT
18637	13954	50	right	right	NN
18637	13954	51	to	to	TO
18637	13954	52	extend	extend	VB
18637	13954	53	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	13954	54	to	to	IN
18637	13954	55	classes	class	NNS
18637	13954	56	of	of	IN
18637	13954	57	persons	person	NNS
18637	13954	58	born	bear	VBN
18637	13954	59	within	within	IN
18637	13954	60	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13954	61	borders	border	NNS
18637	13954	62	who	who	WP
18637	13954	63	had	have	VBD
18637	13954	64	not	not	RB
18637	13954	65	previously	previously	RB
18637	13954	66	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
18637	13954	67	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	13954	68	,	,	,
18637	13954	69	and	and	CC
18637	13954	70	that	that	IN
18637	13954	71	one	one	CD
18637	13954	72	upon	upon	IN
18637	13954	73	whom	whom	WP
18637	13954	74	State	State	NNP
18637	13954	75	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	13954	76	was	be	VBD
18637	13954	77	thus	thus	RB
18637	13954	78	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	13954	79	became	become	VBD
18637	13954	80	a	a	DT
18637	13954	81	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	13954	82	of	of	IN
18637	13954	83	the	the	DT
18637	13954	84	State	State	NNP
18637	13954	85	in	in	IN
18637	13954	86	the	the	DT
18637	13954	87	full	full	JJ
18637	13954	88	sense	sense	NN
18637	13954	89	of	of	IN
18637	13954	90	the	the	DT
18637	13954	91	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13954	92	.	.	.
18637	13955	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13955	2	150	150	CD
18637	13955	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13955	4	So	so	RB
18637	13955	5	far	far	RB
18637	13955	6	as	as	IN
18637	13955	7	persons	person	NNS
18637	13955	8	born	bear	VBN
18637	13955	9	in	in	IN
18637	13955	10	the	the	DT
18637	13955	11	United	United	NNP
18637	13955	12	States	States	NNP
18637	13955	13	,	,	,
18637	13955	14	and	and	CC
18637	13955	15	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13955	16	to	to	IN
18637	13955	17	the	the	DT
18637	13955	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	13955	19	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	13955	20	are	be	VBP
18637	13955	21	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	13955	22	,	,	,
18637	13955	23	the	the	DT
18637	13955	24	question	question	NN
18637	13955	25	was	be	VBD
18637	13955	26	put	put	VBN
18637	13955	27	at	at	IN
18637	13955	28	rest	rest	NN
18637	13955	29	by	by	IN
18637	13955	30	the	the	DT
18637	13955	31	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	13955	32	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	13955	33	.	.	.
18637	13956	1	CORPORATIONS	corporations	NN
18637	13956	2	At	at	IN
18637	13956	3	a	a	DT
18637	13956	4	comparatively	comparatively	RB
18637	13956	5	early	early	JJ
18637	13956	6	date	date	NN
18637	13956	7	the	the	DT
18637	13956	8	claim	claim	NN
18637	13956	9	was	be	VBD
18637	13956	10	made	make	VBN
18637	13956	11	that	that	IN
18637	13956	12	a	a	DT
18637	13956	13	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13956	14	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	13956	15	by	by	IN
18637	13956	16	a	a	DT
18637	13956	17	State	state	NN
18637	13956	18	and	and	CC
18637	13956	19	consisting	consist	VBG
18637	13956	20	of	of	IN
18637	13956	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13956	22	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13956	23	was	be	VBD
18637	13956	24	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	13956	25	to	to	IN
18637	13956	26	the	the	DT
18637	13956	27	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	13956	28	of	of	IN
18637	13956	29	the	the	DT
18637	13956	30	comity	comity	NN
18637	13956	31	clause	clause	NN
18637	13956	32	in	in	IN
18637	13956	33	the	the	DT
18637	13956	34	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	13956	35	of	of	IN
18637	13956	36	business	business	NN
18637	13956	37	in	in	IN
18637	13956	38	other	other	JJ
18637	13956	39	States	States	NNPS
18637	13956	40	.	.	.
18637	13957	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13957	2	was	be	VBD
18637	13957	3	argued	argue	VBN
18637	13957	4	that	that	IN
18637	13957	5	the	the	DT
18637	13957	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13957	7	was	be	VBD
18637	13957	8	bound	bind	VBN
18637	13957	9	to	to	TO
18637	13957	10	look	look	VB
18637	13957	11	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	13957	12	the	the	DT
18637	13957	13	act	act	NN
18637	13957	14	of	of	IN
18637	13957	15	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	13957	16	and	and	CC
18637	13957	17	see	see	VB
18637	13957	18	who	who	WP
18637	13957	19	were	be	VBD
18637	13957	20	the	the	DT
18637	13957	21	incorporators	incorporator	NNS
18637	13957	22	.	.	.
18637	13958	1	If	if	IN
18637	13958	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13958	3	found	find	VBD
18637	13958	4	these	these	DT
18637	13958	5	to	to	TO
18637	13958	6	consist	consist	VB
18637	13958	7	solely	solely	RB
18637	13958	8	of	of	IN
18637	13958	9	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13958	10	of	of	IN
18637	13958	11	the	the	DT
18637	13958	12	incorporating	incorporate	VBG
18637	13958	13	State	State	NNP
18637	13958	14	,	,	,
18637	13958	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13958	16	was	be	VBD
18637	13958	17	bound	bind	VBN
18637	13958	18	to	to	TO
18637	13958	19	permit	permit	VB
18637	13958	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13958	21	through	through	IN
18637	13958	22	the	the	DT
18637	13958	23	agency	agency	NN
18637	13958	24	of	of	IN
18637	13958	25	the	the	DT
18637	13958	26	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13958	27	,	,	,
18637	13958	28	to	to	TO
18637	13958	29	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	13958	30	in	in	IN
18637	13958	31	other	other	JJ
18637	13958	32	States	state	NNS
18637	13958	33	such	such	JJ
18637	13958	34	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13958	35	and	and	CC
18637	13958	36	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	13958	37	as	as	IN
18637	13958	38	the	the	DT
18637	13958	39	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13958	40	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	13958	41	enjoyed	enjoy	VBD
18637	13958	42	.	.	.
18637	13959	1	In	in	IN
18637	13959	2	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	13959	3	of	of	IN
18637	13959	4	Augusta	Augusta	NNP
18637	13959	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13959	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	13959	7	_	_	NNP
18637	13959	8	Earle[151	Earle[151	NNP
18637	13959	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13959	10	this	this	DT
18637	13959	11	view	view	NN
18637	13959	12	was	be	VBD
18637	13959	13	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	13959	14	.	.	.
18637	13960	1	The	the	DT
18637	13960	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13960	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13960	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	13960	5	that	that	IN
18637	13960	6	the	the	DT
18637	13960	7	comity	comity	NN
18637	13960	8	clause	clause	NN
18637	13960	9	was	be	VBD
18637	13960	10	never	never	RB
18637	13960	11	intended	intend	VBN
18637	13960	12	"	"	''
18637	13960	13	to	to	TO
18637	13960	14	give	give	VB
18637	13960	15	to	to	IN
18637	13960	16	the	the	DT
18637	13960	17	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13960	18	of	of	IN
18637	13960	19	each	each	DT
18637	13960	20	State	State	NNP
18637	13960	21	the	the	DT
18637	13960	22	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13960	23	of	of	IN
18637	13960	24	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13960	25	in	in	IN
18637	13960	26	the	the	DT
18637	13960	27	several	several	JJ
18637	13960	28	States	States	NNPS
18637	13960	29	,	,	,
18637	13960	30	and	and	CC
18637	13960	31	at	at	IN
18637	13960	32	the	the	DT
18637	13960	33	same	same	JJ
18637	13960	34	time	time	NN
18637	13960	35	to	to	TO
18637	13960	36	exempt	exempt	VB
18637	13960	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13960	38	from	from	IN
18637	13960	39	the	the	DT
18637	13960	40	liabilities	liability	NNS
18637	13960	41	which	which	WDT
18637	13960	42	the	the	DT
18637	13960	43	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	13960	44	of	of	IN
18637	13960	45	such	such	JJ
18637	13960	46	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13960	47	would	would	MD
18637	13960	48	bring	bring	VB
18637	13960	49	upon	upon	IN
18637	13960	50	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	13960	51	who	who	WP
18637	13960	52	were	be	VBD
18637	13960	53	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13960	54	of	of	IN
18637	13960	55	the	the	DT
18637	13960	56	State	State	NNP
18637	13960	57	.	.	.
18637	13961	1	This	this	DT
18637	13961	2	would	would	MD
18637	13961	3	be	be	VB
18637	13961	4	to	to	TO
18637	13961	5	give	give	VB
18637	13961	6	the	the	DT
18637	13961	7	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13961	8	of	of	IN
18637	13961	9	other	other	JJ
18637	13961	10	States	States	NNPS
18637	13961	11	far	far	RB
18637	13961	12	higher	high	JJR
18637	13961	13	and	and	CC
18637	13961	14	greater	great	JJR
18637	13961	15	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13961	16	than	than	IN
18637	13961	17	are	be	VBP
18637	13961	18	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
18637	13961	19	by	by	IN
18637	13961	20	the	the	DT
18637	13961	21	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13961	22	of	of	IN
18637	13961	23	the	the	DT
18637	13961	24	State	State	NNP
18637	13961	25	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13961	26	.	.	.
18637	13962	1	"	"	``
18637	13962	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13962	3	152	152	CD
18637	13962	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13962	5	A	a	DT
18637	13962	6	similar	similar	JJ
18637	13962	7	result	result	NN
18637	13962	8	was	be	VBD
18637	13962	9	reached	reach	VBN
18637	13962	10	in	in	IN
18637	13962	11	Paul	Paul	NNP
18637	13962	12	_	_	NNP
18637	13962	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	13962	14	_	_	NNP
18637	13962	15	Virginia,[153	Virginia,[153	NNP
18637	13962	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13962	17	but	but	CC
18637	13962	18	by	by	IN
18637	13962	19	a	a	DT
18637	13962	20	different	different	JJ
18637	13962	21	course	course	NN
18637	13962	22	of	of	IN
18637	13962	23	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	13962	24	.	.	.
18637	13963	1	The	the	DT
18637	13963	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13963	3	there	there	RB
18637	13963	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	13963	5	that	that	IN
18637	13963	6	a	a	DT
18637	13963	7	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13963	8	--	--	:
18637	13963	9	in	in	IN
18637	13963	10	this	this	DT
18637	13963	11	instance	instance	NN
18637	13963	12	,	,	,
18637	13963	13	an	an	DT
18637	13963	14	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	13963	15	company	company	NN
18637	13963	16	--	--	:
18637	13963	17	was	be	VBD
18637	13963	18	"	"	``
18637	13963	19	the	the	DT
18637	13963	20	mere	mere	JJ
18637	13963	21	creation	creation	NN
18637	13963	22	of	of	IN
18637	13963	23	local	local	JJ
18637	13963	24	law	law	NN
18637	13963	25	"	"	''
18637	13963	26	and	and	CC
18637	13963	27	could	could	MD
18637	13963	28	"	"	``
18637	13963	29	have	have	VB
18637	13963	30	no	no	DT
18637	13963	31	legal	legal	JJ
18637	13963	32	existence	existence	NN
18637	13963	33	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	13963	34	the	the	DT
18637	13963	35	limits	limit	NNS
18637	13963	36	of	of	IN
18637	13963	37	the	the	DT
18637	13963	38	sovereignty"[154	sovereignty"[154	NN
18637	13963	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13963	40	which	which	WDT
18637	13963	41	created	create	VBD
18637	13963	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13963	43	;	;	:
18637	13963	44	even	even	RB
18637	13963	45	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	13963	46	of	of	IN
18637	13963	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13963	48	existence	existence	NN
18637	13963	49	by	by	IN
18637	13963	50	other	other	JJ
18637	13963	51	States	States	NNPS
18637	13963	52	rested	rest	VBD
18637	13963	53	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	13963	54	in	in	IN
18637	13963	55	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13963	56	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	13963	57	.	.	.
18637	13964	1	More	more	RBR
18637	13964	2	recent	recent	JJ
18637	13964	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	13964	4	have	have	VBP
18637	13964	5	held	hold	VBN
18637	13964	6	that	that	IN
18637	13964	7	this	this	DT
18637	13964	8	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	13964	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	13964	10	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	13964	11	by	by	IN
18637	13964	12	other	other	JJ
18637	13964	13	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	13964	14	of	of	IN
18637	13964	15	the	the	DT
18637	13964	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13964	17	,	,	,
18637	13964	18	notably	notably	RB
18637	13964	19	the	the	DT
18637	13964	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	13964	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	13964	22	and	and	CC
18637	13964	23	the	the	DT
18637	13964	24	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	13964	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	13964	26	.	.	.
18637	13965	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13965	2	155	155	CD
18637	13965	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13965	4	By	by	IN
18637	13965	5	reason	reason	NN
18637	13965	6	of	of	IN
18637	13965	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13965	8	similarity	similarity	NN
18637	13965	9	to	to	IN
18637	13965	10	the	the	DT
18637	13965	11	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	13965	12	form	form	NN
18637	13965	13	of	of	IN
18637	13965	14	organization	organization	NN
18637	13965	15	,	,	,
18637	13965	16	a	a	DT
18637	13965	17	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	13965	18	trust	trust	NN
18637	13965	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	13965	20	been	be	VBN
18637	13965	21	denied	deny	VBN
18637	13965	22	the	the	DT
18637	13965	23	protection	protection	NN
18637	13965	24	of	of	IN
18637	13965	25	this	this	DT
18637	13965	26	clause	clause	NN
18637	13965	27	.	.	.
18637	13966	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13966	2	156	156	CD
18637	13966	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13966	4	ALL	all	DT
18637	13966	5	PRIVILEGES	privilege	NNS
18637	13966	6	AND	and	CC
18637	13966	7	IMMUNITIES	immunity	NNS
18637	13966	8	OF	of	IN
18637	13966	9	CITIZENS	citizen	NNS
18637	13966	10	IN	in	IN
18637	13966	11	THE	the	DT
18637	13966	12	SEVERAL	several	JJ
18637	13966	13	STATES	state	NNS
18637	13966	14	The	the	DT
18637	13966	15	classical	classical	JJ
18637	13966	16	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13966	17	exposition	exposition	NN
18637	13966	18	of	of	IN
18637	13966	19	the	the	DT
18637	13966	20	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	13966	21	of	of	IN
18637	13966	22	this	this	DT
18637	13966	23	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	13966	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	13966	25	that	that	DT
18637	13966	26	of	of	IN
18637	13966	27	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13966	28	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	13966	29	in	in	IN
18637	13966	30	Corfield	Corfield	NNP
18637	13966	31	_	_	NNP
18637	13966	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	13966	33	_	_	NNP
18637	13966	34	Coryell,[157	Coryell,[157	NNP
18637	13966	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13966	36	which	which	WDT
18637	13966	37	was	be	VBD
18637	13966	38	decided	decide	VBN
18637	13966	39	by	by	IN
18637	13966	40	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13966	41	on	on	IN
18637	13966	42	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	13966	43	in	in	IN
18637	13966	44	1823	1823	CD
18637	13966	45	.	.	.
18637	13967	1	The	the	DT
18637	13967	2	question	question	NN
18637	13967	3	at	at	IN
18637	13967	4	issue	issue	NN
18637	13967	5	was	be	VBD
18637	13967	6	the	the	DT
18637	13967	7	validity	validity	NN
18637	13967	8	of	of	IN
18637	13967	9	a	a	DT
18637	13967	10	New	New	NNP
18637	13967	11	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	13967	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	13967	13	which	which	WDT
18637	13967	14	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	13967	15	"	"	``
18637	13967	16	any	any	DT
18637	13967	17	person	person	NN
18637	13967	18	who	who	WP
18637	13967	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	13967	20	not	not	RB
18637	13967	21	,	,	,
18637	13967	22	at	at	IN
18637	13967	23	the	the	DT
18637	13967	24	time	time	NN
18637	13967	25	,	,	,
18637	13967	26	an	an	DT
18637	13967	27	actual	actual	JJ
18637	13967	28	inhabitant	inhabitant	NN
18637	13967	29	and	and	CC
18637	13967	30	resident	resident	NN
18637	13967	31	in	in	IN
18637	13967	32	this	this	DT
18637	13967	33	State	State	NNP
18637	13967	34	"	"	''
18637	13967	35	from	from	IN
18637	13967	36	raking	raking	NN
18637	13967	37	or	or	CC
18637	13967	38	gathering	gather	VBG
18637	13967	39	"	"	``
18637	13967	40	clams	clam	NNS
18637	13967	41	,	,	,
18637	13967	42	oysters	oyster	NNS
18637	13967	43	or	or	CC
18637	13967	44	shells	shell	NNS
18637	13967	45	"	"	''
18637	13967	46	in	in	IN
18637	13967	47	any	any	DT
18637	13967	48	of	of	IN
18637	13967	49	the	the	DT
18637	13967	50	waters	water	NNS
18637	13967	51	of	of	IN
18637	13967	52	the	the	DT
18637	13967	53	State	State	NNP
18637	13967	54	,	,	,
18637	13967	55	on	on	IN
18637	13967	56	board	board	NN
18637	13967	57	any	any	DT
18637	13967	58	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	13967	59	"	"	``
18637	13967	60	not	not	RB
18637	13967	61	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	13967	62	owned	own	VBN
18637	13967	63	by	by	IN
18637	13967	64	some	some	DT
18637	13967	65	person	person	NN
18637	13967	66	,	,	,
18637	13967	67	inhabitant	inhabitant	NN
18637	13967	68	of	of	IN
18637	13967	69	and	and	CC
18637	13967	70	actually	actually	RB
18637	13967	71	residing	reside	VBG
18637	13967	72	in	in	IN
18637	13967	73	this	this	DT
18637	13967	74	State	State	NNP
18637	13967	75	.	.	.
18637	13968	1	*	*	NFP
18637	13968	2	*	*	NFP
18637	13968	3	*	*	NFP
18637	13968	4	The	the	DT
18637	13968	5	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	13968	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	13968	7	,	,	,
18637	13968	8	"	"	``
18637	13968	9	wrote	write	VBD
18637	13968	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13968	11	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	13968	12	,	,	,
18637	13968	13	"	"	''
18637	13968	14	what	what	WP
18637	13968	15	are	be	VBP
18637	13968	16	the	the	DT
18637	13968	17	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13968	18	and	and	CC
18637	13968	19	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	13968	20	of	of	IN
18637	13968	21	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13968	22	in	in	IN
18637	13968	23	the	the	DT
18637	13968	24	several	several	JJ
18637	13968	25	States	state	NNS
18637	13968	26	?	?	.
18637	13969	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13969	2	feel	feel	VBP
18637	13969	3	no	no	DT
18637	13969	4	hesitation	hesitation	NN
18637	13969	5	in	in	IN
18637	13969	6	confining	confine	VBG
18637	13969	7	these	these	DT
18637	13969	8	expressions	expression	NNS
18637	13969	9	to	to	IN
18637	13969	10	those	those	DT
18637	13969	11	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13969	12	and	and	CC
18637	13969	13	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	13969	14	which	which	WDT
18637	13969	15	are	be	VBP
18637	13969	16	,	,	,
18637	13969	17	in	in	IN
18637	13969	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13969	19	nature	nature	NN
18637	13969	20	,	,	,
18637	13969	21	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	13969	22	;	;	:
18637	13969	23	which	which	WDT
18637	13969	24	belong	belong	VBP
18637	13969	25	,	,	,
18637	13969	26	of	of	IN
18637	13969	27	right	right	NN
18637	13969	28	,	,	,
18637	13969	29	to	to	IN
18637	13969	30	the	the	DT
18637	13969	31	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13969	32	of	of	IN
18637	13969	33	all	all	DT
18637	13969	34	free	free	JJ
18637	13969	35	governments	government	NNS
18637	13969	36	;	;	:
18637	13969	37	and	and	CC
18637	13969	38	which	which	WDT
18637	13969	39	have	have	VBP
18637	13969	40	,	,	,
18637	13969	41	at	at	IN
18637	13969	42	all	all	DT
18637	13969	43	times	time	NNS
18637	13969	44	,	,	,
18637	13969	45	been	be	VBN
18637	13969	46	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
18637	13969	47	by	by	IN
18637	13969	48	the	the	DT
18637	13969	49	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13969	50	of	of	IN
18637	13969	51	the	the	DT
18637	13969	52	several	several	JJ
18637	13969	53	States	state	NNS
18637	13969	54	which	which	WDT
18637	13969	55	compose	compose	VBD
18637	13969	56	this	this	DT
18637	13969	57	Union	Union	NNP
18637	13969	58	,	,	,
18637	13969	59	*	*	NFP
18637	13969	60	*	*	NFP
18637	13969	61	*	*	NFP
18637	13969	62	"	"	''
18637	13969	63	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13969	64	158	158	CD
18637	13969	65	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13969	66	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13969	67	specified	specify	VBD
18637	13969	68	the	the	DT
18637	13969	69	following	follow	VBG
18637	13969	70	rights	right	NNS
18637	13969	71	as	as	IN
18637	13969	72	answering	answer	VBG
18637	13969	73	this	this	DT
18637	13969	74	description	description	NN
18637	13969	75	:	:	:
18637	13969	76	"	"	``
18637	13969	77	Protection	protection	NN
18637	13969	78	by	by	IN
18637	13969	79	the	the	DT
18637	13969	80	Government	Government	NNP
18637	13969	81	;	;	:
18637	13969	82	the	the	DT
18637	13969	83	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	13969	84	of	of	IN
18637	13969	85	life	life	NN
18637	13969	86	and	and	CC
18637	13969	87	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	13969	88	,	,	,
18637	13969	89	with	with	IN
18637	13969	90	the	the	DT
18637	13969	91	right	right	NN
18637	13969	92	to	to	TO
18637	13969	93	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	13969	94	and	and	CC
18637	13969	95	possess	possess	VB
18637	13969	96	property	property	NN
18637	13969	97	of	of	IN
18637	13969	98	every	every	DT
18637	13969	99	kind	kind	NN
18637	13969	100	,	,	,
18637	13969	101	and	and	CC
18637	13969	102	to	to	TO
18637	13969	103	pursue	pursue	VB
18637	13969	104	and	and	CC
18637	13969	105	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	13969	106	happiness	happiness	NN
18637	13969	107	and	and	CC
18637	13969	108	safety	safety	NN
18637	13969	109	;	;	:
18637	13969	110	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13969	111	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	13969	112	to	to	IN
18637	13969	113	such	such	JJ
18637	13969	114	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	13969	115	as	as	IN
18637	13969	116	the	the	DT
18637	13969	117	Government	Government	NNP
18637	13969	118	may	may	MD
18637	13969	119	justly	justly	RB
18637	13969	120	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	13969	121	for	for	IN
18637	13969	122	the	the	DT
18637	13969	123	general	general	JJ
18637	13969	124	good	good	NN
18637	13969	125	of	of	IN
18637	13969	126	the	the	DT
18637	13969	127	whole	whole	NN
18637	13969	128	.	.	.
18637	13970	1	The	the	DT
18637	13970	2	right	right	NN
18637	13970	3	of	of	IN
18637	13970	4	a	a	DT
18637	13970	5	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	13970	6	of	of	IN
18637	13970	7	one	one	CD
18637	13970	8	State	State	NNP
18637	13970	9	to	to	TO
18637	13970	10	pass	pass	VB
18637	13970	11	through	through	RP
18637	13970	12	,	,	,
18637	13970	13	or	or	CC
18637	13970	14	to	to	TO
18637	13970	15	reside	reside	VB
18637	13970	16	in	in	IN
18637	13970	17	any	any	DT
18637	13970	18	other	other	JJ
18637	13970	19	State	State	NNP
18637	13970	20	,	,	,
18637	13970	21	for	for	IN
18637	13970	22	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	13970	23	of	of	IN
18637	13970	24	trade	trade	NN
18637	13970	25	,	,	,
18637	13970	26	agriculture	agriculture	NN
18637	13970	27	,	,	,
18637	13970	28	professional	professional	JJ
18637	13970	29	pursuits	pursuit	NNS
18637	13970	30	,	,	,
18637	13970	31	or	or	CC
18637	13970	32	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	13970	33	;	;	:
18637	13970	34	to	to	TO
18637	13970	35	claim	claim	VB
18637	13970	36	the	the	DT
18637	13970	37	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	13970	38	of	of	IN
18637	13970	39	the	the	DT
18637	13970	40	writ	writ	NNP
18637	13970	41	of	of	IN
18637	13970	42	_	_	NNP
18637	13970	43	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	13970	44	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	13970	45	_	_	NNP
18637	13970	46	;	;	:
18637	13970	47	to	to	TO
18637	13970	48	institute	institute	VB
18637	13970	49	and	and	CC
18637	13970	50	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	13970	51	actions	action	NNS
18637	13970	52	of	of	IN
18637	13970	53	any	any	DT
18637	13970	54	kind	kind	NN
18637	13970	55	in	in	IN
18637	13970	56	the	the	DT
18637	13970	57	courts	court	NNS
18637	13970	58	of	of	IN
18637	13970	59	the	the	DT
18637	13970	60	State	State	NNP
18637	13970	61	;	;	:
18637	13970	62	to	to	TO
18637	13970	63	take	take	VB
18637	13970	64	,	,	,
18637	13970	65	hold	hold	VB
18637	13970	66	and	and	CC
18637	13970	67	dispose	dispose	VBP
18637	13970	68	of	of	IN
18637	13970	69	property	property	NN
18637	13970	70	,	,	,
18637	13970	71	either	either	CC
18637	13970	72	real	real	JJ
18637	13970	73	or	or	CC
18637	13970	74	personal	personal	JJ
18637	13970	75	;	;	:
18637	13970	76	and	and	CC
18637	13970	77	an	an	DT
18637	13970	78	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	13970	79	from	from	IN
18637	13970	80	higher	high	JJR
18637	13970	81	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	13970	82	or	or	CC
18637	13970	83	impositions	imposition	NNS
18637	13970	84	than	than	IN
18637	13970	85	are	be	VBP
18637	13970	86	paid	pay	VBN
18637	13970	87	by	by	IN
18637	13970	88	the	the	DT
18637	13970	89	other	other	JJ
18637	13970	90	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13970	91	of	of	IN
18637	13970	92	the	the	DT
18637	13970	93	State	state	NN
18637	13970	94	;	;	:
18637	13970	95	*	*	NFP
18637	13970	96	*	*	NFP
18637	13970	97	*	*	NFP
18637	13970	98	"	"	''
18637	13970	99	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13970	100	159	159	CD
18637	13970	101	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13970	102	After	after	IN
18637	13970	103	thus	thus	RB
18637	13970	104	defining	define	VBG
18637	13970	105	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	13970	106	the	the	DT
18637	13970	107	private	private	JJ
18637	13970	108	and	and	CC
18637	13970	109	personal	personal	JJ
18637	13970	110	rights	right	NNS
18637	13970	111	which	which	WDT
18637	13970	112	were	be	VBD
18637	13970	113	protected	protect	VBN
18637	13970	114	,	,	,
18637	13970	115	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13970	116	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	13970	117	went	go	VBD
18637	13970	118	on	on	RP
18637	13970	119	to	to	TO
18637	13970	120	distinguish	distinguish	VB
18637	13970	121	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13970	122	from	from	IN
18637	13970	123	the	the	DT
18637	13970	124	right	right	NN
18637	13970	125	to	to	IN
18637	13970	126	a	a	DT
18637	13970	127	share	share	NN
18637	13970	128	in	in	IN
18637	13970	129	the	the	DT
18637	13970	130	public	public	JJ
18637	13970	131	patrimony	patrimony	NN
18637	13970	132	of	of	IN
18637	13970	133	the	the	DT
18637	13970	134	State	State	NNP
18637	13970	135	.	.	.
18637	13971	1	"	"	``
18637	13971	2	*	*	NFP
18637	13971	3	*	*	NFP
18637	13971	4	*	*	NFP
18637	13971	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13971	6	can	can	MD
18637	13971	7	not	not	RB
18637	13971	8	accede	accede	VB
18637	13971	9	"	"	``
18637	13971	10	the	the	DT
18637	13971	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	13971	12	proceeds	proceed	VBZ
18637	13971	13	,	,	,
18637	13971	14	"	"	``
18637	13971	15	to	to	IN
18637	13971	16	the	the	DT
18637	13971	17	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	13971	18	*	*	NFP
18637	13971	19	*	*	NFP
18637	13971	20	*	*	NFP
18637	13971	21	that	that	IN
18637	13971	22	,	,	,
18637	13971	23	under	under	IN
18637	13971	24	this	this	DT
18637	13971	25	provision	provision	NN
18637	13971	26	of	of	IN
18637	13971	27	the	the	DT
18637	13971	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13971	29	,	,	,
18637	13971	30	the	the	DT
18637	13971	31	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13971	32	of	of	IN
18637	13971	33	the	the	DT
18637	13971	34	several	several	JJ
18637	13971	35	States	state	NNS
18637	13971	36	are	be	VBP
18637	13971	37	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	13971	38	to	to	TO
18637	13971	39	participate	participate	VB
18637	13971	40	in	in	IN
18637	13971	41	all	all	PDT
18637	13971	42	the	the	DT
18637	13971	43	rights	right	NNS
18637	13971	44	which	which	WDT
18637	13971	45	belong	belong	VBP
18637	13971	46	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	13971	47	to	to	IN
18637	13971	48	the	the	DT
18637	13971	49	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13971	50	of	of	IN
18637	13971	51	any	any	DT
18637	13971	52	particular	particular	JJ
18637	13971	53	State	State	NNP
18637	13971	54	,	,	,
18637	13971	55	merely	merely	RB
18637	13971	56	upon	upon	IN
18637	13971	57	the	the	DT
18637	13971	58	ground	ground	NN
18637	13971	59	that	that	IN
18637	13971	60	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13971	61	are	be	VBP
18637	13971	62	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
18637	13971	63	by	by	IN
18637	13971	64	those	those	DT
18637	13971	65	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13971	66	;	;	:
18637	13971	67	much	much	RB
18637	13971	68	less	less	RBR
18637	13971	69	,	,	,
18637	13971	70	that	that	IN
18637	13971	71	in	in	IN
18637	13971	72	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	13971	73	the	the	DT
18637	13971	74	use	use	NN
18637	13971	75	of	of	IN
18637	13971	76	the	the	DT
18637	13971	77	common	common	JJ
18637	13971	78	property	property	NN
18637	13971	79	of	of	IN
18637	13971	80	the	the	DT
18637	13971	81	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13971	82	of	of	IN
18637	13971	83	such	such	JJ
18637	13971	84	State	State	NNP
18637	13971	85	,	,	,
18637	13971	86	the	the	DT
18637	13971	87	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	13971	88	is	be	VBZ
18637	13971	89	bound	bind	VBN
18637	13971	90	to	to	TO
18637	13971	91	extend	extend	VB
18637	13971	92	to	to	IN
18637	13971	93	the	the	DT
18637	13971	94	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13971	95	of	of	IN
18637	13971	96	all	all	DT
18637	13971	97	other	other	JJ
18637	13971	98	States	state	NNS
18637	13971	99	the	the	DT
18637	13971	100	same	same	JJ
18637	13971	101	advantages	advantage	NNS
18637	13971	102	as	as	IN
18637	13971	103	are	be	VBP
18637	13971	104	secured	secure	VBN
18637	13971	105	to	to	IN
18637	13971	106	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13971	107	own	own	JJ
18637	13971	108	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13971	109	.	.	.
18637	13972	1	"	"	``
18637	13972	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13972	3	160	160	CD
18637	13972	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13972	5	The	the	DT
18637	13972	6	right	right	NN
18637	13972	7	of	of	IN
18637	13972	8	a	a	DT
18637	13972	9	State	state	NN
18637	13972	10	to	to	IN
18637	13972	11	the	the	DT
18637	13972	12	fisheries	fishery	NNS
18637	13972	13	within	within	IN
18637	13972	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13972	15	borders	border	NNS
18637	13972	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13972	17	then	then	RB
18637	13972	18	held	hold	VBD
18637	13972	19	to	to	TO
18637	13972	20	be	be	VB
18637	13972	21	in	in	IN
18637	13972	22	the	the	DT
18637	13972	23	nature	nature	NN
18637	13972	24	of	of	IN
18637	13972	25	a	a	DT
18637	13972	26	property	property	NN
18637	13972	27	right	right	NN
18637	13972	28	,	,	,
18637	13972	29	held	hold	VBN
18637	13972	30	by	by	IN
18637	13972	31	the	the	DT
18637	13972	32	State	State	NNP
18637	13972	33	"	"	''
18637	13972	34	for	for	IN
18637	13972	35	the	the	DT
18637	13972	36	use	use	NN
18637	13972	37	of	of	IN
18637	13972	38	the	the	DT
18637	13972	39	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13972	40	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	13972	41	;	;	:
18637	13972	42	"	"	``
18637	13972	43	the	the	DT
18637	13972	44	State	state	NN
18637	13972	45	was	be	VBD
18637	13972	46	under	under	IN
18637	13972	47	no	no	DT
18637	13972	48	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	13972	49	to	to	TO
18637	13972	50	grant	grant	VB
18637	13972	51	"	"	``
18637	13972	52	co	co	NN
18637	13972	53	-	-	NN
18637	13972	54	tenancy	tenancy	NN
18637	13972	55	in	in	IN
18637	13972	56	the	the	DT
18637	13972	57	common	common	JJ
18637	13972	58	property	property	NN
18637	13972	59	of	of	IN
18637	13972	60	the	the	DT
18637	13972	61	State	State	NNP
18637	13972	62	,	,	,
18637	13972	63	to	to	IN
18637	13972	64	the	the	DT
18637	13972	65	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13972	66	of	of	IN
18637	13972	67	all	all	PDT
18637	13972	68	the	the	DT
18637	13972	69	other	other	JJ
18637	13972	70	States	States	NNPS
18637	13972	71	.	.	.
18637	13973	1	"	"	``
18637	13973	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13973	3	161	161	CD
18637	13973	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13973	5	The	the	DT
18637	13973	6	precise	precise	JJ
18637	13973	7	holding	holding	NN
18637	13973	8	of	of	IN
18637	13973	9	this	this	DT
18637	13973	10	case	case	NN
18637	13973	11	was	be	VBD
18637	13973	12	confirmed	confirm	VBN
18637	13973	13	in	in	IN
18637	13973	14	McCready	McCready	NNP
18637	13973	15	_	_	NNP
18637	13973	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	13973	17	_	_	NNP
18637	13973	18	Virginia;[162	Virginia;[162	NNP
18637	13973	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13973	20	the	the	DT
18637	13973	21	logic	logic	NN
18637	13973	22	of	of	IN
18637	13973	23	Geer	Geer	NNP
18637	13973	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13973	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	13973	26	_	_	NNP
18637	13973	27	Connecticut[163	Connecticut[163	NNP
18637	13973	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13973	29	extended	extend	VBD
18637	13973	30	the	the	DT
18637	13973	31	same	same	JJ
18637	13973	32	rule	rule	NN
18637	13973	33	to	to	IN
18637	13973	34	wild	wild	JJ
18637	13973	35	game	game	NN
18637	13973	36	,	,	,
18637	13973	37	and	and	CC
18637	13973	38	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	13973	39	County	County	NNP
18637	13973	40	Water	Water	NNP
18637	13973	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	13973	42	_	_	NNP
18637	13973	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	13973	44	_	_	NNP
18637	13973	45	McCarter[164	McCarter[164	NNP
18637	13973	46	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13973	47	applied	apply	VBD
18637	13973	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13973	49	to	to	IN
18637	13973	50	the	the	DT
18637	13973	51	running	running	NN
18637	13973	52	water	water	NN
18637	13973	53	of	of	IN
18637	13973	54	a	a	DT
18637	13973	55	State	state	NN
18637	13973	56	.	.	.
18637	13974	1	In	in	IN
18637	13974	2	Toomer	Toomer	NNP
18637	13974	3	_	_	NNP
18637	13974	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	13974	5	_	_	NNP
18637	13974	6	Witsell,[165	Witsell,[165	NNP
18637	13974	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13974	8	however	however	RB
18637	13974	9	,	,	,
18637	13974	10	the	the	DT
18637	13974	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13974	12	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	13974	13	to	to	TO
18637	13974	14	apply	apply	VB
18637	13974	15	this	this	DT
18637	13974	16	rule	rule	NN
18637	13974	17	to	to	IN
18637	13974	18	free	free	JJ
18637	13974	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	13974	20	swimming	swim	VBG
18637	13974	21	fish	fish	NN
18637	13974	22	caught	catch	VBN
18637	13974	23	in	in	IN
18637	13974	24	the	the	DT
18637	13974	25	three	three	CD
18637	13974	26	-	-	HYPH
18637	13974	27	mile	mile	NN
18637	13974	28	belt	belt	NN
18637	13974	29	off	off	IN
18637	13974	30	the	the	DT
18637	13974	31	coast	coast	NN
18637	13974	32	of	of	IN
18637	13974	33	South	South	NNP
18637	13974	34	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	13974	35	.	.	.
18637	13975	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13975	2	held	hold	VBD
18637	13975	3	instead	instead	RB
18637	13975	4	that	that	IN
18637	13975	5	"	"	``
18637	13975	6	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	13975	7	shrimping	shrimping	NN
18637	13975	8	in	in	IN
18637	13975	9	the	the	DT
18637	13975	10	marginal	marginal	JJ
18637	13975	11	sea	sea	NN
18637	13975	12	,	,	,
18637	13975	13	like	like	IN
18637	13975	14	other	other	JJ
18637	13975	15	common	common	JJ
18637	13975	16	callings	calling	NNS
18637	13975	17	,	,	,
18637	13975	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	13975	19	within	within	IN
18637	13975	20	the	the	DT
18637	13975	21	purview	purview	NN
18637	13975	22	of	of	IN
18637	13975	23	the	the	DT
18637	13975	24	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13975	25	and	and	CC
18637	13975	26	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	13975	27	clause	clause	NN
18637	13975	28	"	"	''
18637	13975	29	and	and	CC
18637	13975	30	that	that	IN
18637	13975	31	a	a	DT
18637	13975	32	heavily	heavily	RB
18637	13975	33	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	13975	34	license	license	NN
18637	13975	35	fee	fee	NN
18637	13975	36	exacted	exact	VBN
18637	13975	37	from	from	IN
18637	13975	38	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	13975	39	was	be	VBD
18637	13975	40	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	13975	41	.	.	.
18637	13976	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13976	2	166	166	CD
18637	13976	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13976	4	Universal	universal	JJ
18637	13976	5	practice	practice	NN
18637	13976	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	13976	7	also	also	RB
18637	13976	8	established	establish	VBN
18637	13976	9	another	another	DT
18637	13976	10	exception	exception	NN
18637	13976	11	to	to	TO
18637	13976	12	which	which	WDT
18637	13976	13	the	the	DT
18637	13976	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13976	15	gave	give	VBD
18637	13976	16	approval	approval	NN
18637	13976	17	by	by	IN
18637	13976	18	a	a	DT
18637	13976	19	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	13976	20	in	in	IN
18637	13976	21	Blake	Blake	NNP
18637	13976	22	_	_	NNP
18637	13976	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	13976	24	_	_	NNP
18637	13976	25	McClung:[167	McClung:[167	NNP
18637	13976	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13976	27	"	"	``
18637	13976	28	A	A	NNP
18637	13976	29	State	state	NN
18637	13976	30	may	may	MD
18637	13976	31	,	,	,
18637	13976	32	by	by	IN
18637	13976	33	rule	rule	NN
18637	13976	34	uniform	uniform	NN
18637	13976	35	in	in	IN
18637	13976	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13976	37	operation	operation	NN
18637	13976	38	as	as	IN
18637	13976	39	to	to	IN
18637	13976	40	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13976	41	of	of	IN
18637	13976	42	the	the	DT
18637	13976	43	several	several	JJ
18637	13976	44	States	state	NNS
18637	13976	45	,	,	,
18637	13976	46	require	require	VBP
18637	13976	47	residence	residence	NN
18637	13976	48	within	within	IN
18637	13976	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13976	50	limits	limit	NNS
18637	13976	51	for	for	IN
18637	13976	52	a	a	DT
18637	13976	53	given	give	VBN
18637	13976	54	time	time	NN
18637	13976	55	before	before	IN
18637	13976	56	a	a	DT
18637	13976	57	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	13976	58	of	of	IN
18637	13976	59	another	another	DT
18637	13976	60	State	state	NN
18637	13976	61	who	who	WP
18637	13976	62	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	13976	63	a	a	DT
18637	13976	64	resident	resident	NN
18637	13976	65	thereof	thereof	NN
18637	13976	66	shall	shall	MD
18637	13976	67	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	13976	68	the	the	DT
18637	13976	69	right	right	NN
18637	13976	70	of	of	IN
18637	13976	71	suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	13976	72	or	or	CC
18637	13976	73	become	become	VBN
18637	13976	74	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	13976	75	to	to	IN
18637	13976	76	office	office	NN
18637	13976	77	.	.	.
18637	13977	1	"	"	``
18637	13977	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13977	3	168	168	CD
18637	13977	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13977	5	DISCRIMINATION	DISCRIMINATION	VBN
18637	13977	6	IN	in	IN
18637	13977	7	PRIVATE	private	JJ
18637	13977	8	RIGHTS	right	NNS
18637	13977	9	Not	not	RB
18637	13977	10	only	only	RB
18637	13977	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	13977	12	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	13977	13	construction	construction	NN
18637	13977	14	of	of	IN
18637	13977	15	the	the	DT
18637	13977	16	comity	comity	NN
18637	13977	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	13977	18	excluded	exclude	VBD
18637	13977	19	some	some	DT
18637	13977	20	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13977	21	of	of	IN
18637	13977	22	a	a	DT
18637	13977	23	public	public	JJ
18637	13977	24	nature	nature	NN
18637	13977	25	from	from	IN
18637	13977	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13977	27	protection	protection	NN
18637	13977	28	;	;	:
18637	13977	29	the	the	DT
18637	13977	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	13977	31	have	have	VBP
18637	13977	32	also	also	RB
18637	13977	33	established	establish	VBN
18637	13977	34	the	the	DT
18637	13977	35	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	13977	36	that	that	IN
18637	13977	37	the	the	DT
18637	13977	38	purely	purely	RB
18637	13977	39	private	private	JJ
18637	13977	40	and	and	CC
18637	13977	41	personal	personal	JJ
18637	13977	42	rights	right	NNS
18637	13977	43	to	to	TO
18637	13977	44	which	which	WDT
18637	13977	45	the	the	DT
18637	13977	46	clause	clause	NN
18637	13977	47	admittedly	admittedly	RB
18637	13977	48	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	13977	49	are	be	VBP
18637	13977	50	not	not	RB
18637	13977	51	in	in	IN
18637	13977	52	all	all	DT
18637	13977	53	cases	case	NNS
18637	13977	54	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	13977	55	the	the	DT
18637	13977	56	reach	reach	NN
18637	13977	57	of	of	IN
18637	13977	58	State	State	NNP
18637	13977	59	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	13977	60	which	which	WDT
18637	13977	61	differentiates	differentiate	VBZ
18637	13977	62	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13977	63	and	and	CC
18637	13977	64	noncitizens	noncitizen	NNS
18637	13977	65	.	.	.
18637	13978	1	Broadly	broadly	RB
18637	13978	2	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	13978	3	,	,	,
18637	13978	4	these	these	DT
18637	13978	5	rights	right	NNS
18637	13978	6	are	be	VBP
18637	13978	7	held	hold	VBN
18637	13978	8	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13978	9	to	to	IN
18637	13978	10	the	the	DT
18637	13978	11	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	13978	12	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	13978	13	by	by	IN
18637	13978	14	a	a	DT
18637	13978	15	State	state	NN
18637	13978	16	of	of	IN
18637	13978	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13978	18	police	police	NN
18637	13978	19	power	power	NN
18637	13978	20	,	,	,
18637	13978	21	and	and	CC
18637	13978	22	the	the	DT
18637	13978	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13978	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	13978	25	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	13978	26	that	that	IN
18637	13978	27	there	there	EX
18637	13978	28	are	be	VBP
18637	13978	29	cases	case	NNS
18637	13978	30	in	in	IN
18637	13978	31	which	which	WDT
18637	13978	32	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	13978	33	against	against	IN
18637	13978	34	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	13978	35	may	may	MD
18637	13978	36	be	be	VB
18637	13978	37	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	13978	38	resorted	resort	VBN
18637	13978	39	to	to	IN
18637	13978	40	by	by	IN
18637	13978	41	a	a	DT
18637	13978	42	State	state	NN
18637	13978	43	in	in	IN
18637	13978	44	aid	aid	NN
18637	13978	45	of	of	IN
18637	13978	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13978	47	own	own	JJ
18637	13978	48	public	public	JJ
18637	13978	49	health	health	NN
18637	13978	50	,	,	,
18637	13978	51	safety	safety	NN
18637	13978	52	and	and	CC
18637	13978	53	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	13978	54	.	.	.
18637	13979	1	To	to	IN
18637	13979	2	that	that	DT
18637	13979	3	end	end	NN
18637	13979	4	a	a	DT
18637	13979	5	State	state	NN
18637	13979	6	may	may	MD
18637	13979	7	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	13979	8	the	the	DT
18637	13979	9	right	right	NN
18637	13979	10	to	to	TO
18637	13979	11	sell	sell	VB
18637	13979	12	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	13979	13	to	to	IN
18637	13979	14	persons	person	NNS
18637	13979	15	who	who	WP
18637	13979	16	have	have	VBP
18637	13979	17	resided	reside	VBN
18637	13979	18	within	within	IN
18637	13979	19	the	the	DT
18637	13979	20	State	State	NNP
18637	13979	21	for	for	IN
18637	13979	22	a	a	DT
18637	13979	23	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	13979	24	period	period	NN
18637	13979	25	of	of	IN
18637	13979	26	time	time	NN
18637	13979	27	.	.	.
18637	13980	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13980	2	169	169	CD
18637	13980	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13980	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13980	5	may	may	MD
18637	13980	6	require	require	VB
18637	13980	7	a	a	DT
18637	13980	8	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	13980	9	who	who	WP
18637	13980	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	13980	11	business	business	NN
18637	13980	12	within	within	IN
18637	13980	13	the	the	DT
18637	13980	14	State[170	State[170	NNS
18637	13980	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13980	16	or	or	CC
18637	13980	17	who	who	WP
18637	13980	18	uses	use	VBZ
18637	13980	19	the	the	DT
18637	13980	20	highways	highway	NNS
18637	13980	21	of	of	IN
18637	13980	22	the	the	DT
18637	13980	23	State[171	State[171	NNP
18637	13980	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13980	25	to	to	TO
18637	13980	26	consent	consent	VB
18637	13980	27	,	,	,
18637	13980	28	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	13980	29	or	or	CC
18637	13980	30	by	by	IN
18637	13980	31	implication	implication	NN
18637	13980	32	,	,	,
18637	13980	33	to	to	IN
18637	13980	34	service	service	NN
18637	13980	35	of	of	IN
18637	13980	36	process	process	NN
18637	13980	37	on	on	IN
18637	13980	38	an	an	DT
18637	13980	39	agent	agent	NN
18637	13980	40	within	within	IN
18637	13980	41	the	the	DT
18637	13980	42	State	State	NNP
18637	13980	43	.	.	.
18637	13981	1	Without	without	IN
18637	13981	2	violating	violate	VBG
18637	13981	3	this	this	DT
18637	13981	4	section	section	NN
18637	13981	5	,	,	,
18637	13981	6	a	a	DT
18637	13981	7	State	state	NN
18637	13981	8	may	may	MD
18637	13981	9	limit	limit	VB
18637	13981	10	the	the	DT
18637	13981	11	dower	dower	NN
18637	13981	12	rights	right	NNS
18637	13981	13	of	of	IN
18637	13981	14	a	a	DT
18637	13981	15	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	13981	16	to	to	IN
18637	13981	17	lands	land	NNS
18637	13981	18	of	of	IN
18637	13981	19	which	which	WDT
18637	13981	20	the	the	DT
18637	13981	21	husband	husband	NN
18637	13981	22	died	die	VBD
18637	13981	23	seized	seize	VBD
18637	13981	24	while	while	IN
18637	13981	25	giving	give	VBG
18637	13981	26	a	a	DT
18637	13981	27	resident	resident	JJ
18637	13981	28	dower	dower	NN
18637	13981	29	in	in	IN
18637	13981	30	all	all	DT
18637	13981	31	lands	land	NNS
18637	13981	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	13981	33	during	during	IN
18637	13981	34	the	the	DT
18637	13981	35	marriage,[172	marriage,[172	NN
18637	13981	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13981	37	or	or	CC
18637	13981	38	may	may	MD
18637	13981	39	leave	leave	VB
18637	13981	40	the	the	DT
18637	13981	41	rights	right	NNS
18637	13981	42	of	of	IN
18637	13981	43	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	13981	44	married	married	JJ
18637	13981	45	persons	person	NNS
18637	13981	46	in	in	IN
18637	13981	47	respect	respect	NN
18637	13981	48	of	of	IN
18637	13981	49	property	property	NN
18637	13981	50	within	within	IN
18637	13981	51	the	the	DT
18637	13981	52	State	State	NNP
18637	13981	53	to	to	TO
18637	13981	54	be	be	VB
18637	13981	55	governed	govern	VBN
18637	13981	56	by	by	IN
18637	13981	57	the	the	DT
18637	13981	58	laws	law	NNS
18637	13981	59	of	of	IN
18637	13981	60	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13981	61	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	13981	62	,	,	,
18637	13981	63	rather	rather	RB
18637	13981	64	than	than	IN
18637	13981	65	by	by	IN
18637	13981	66	the	the	DT
18637	13981	67	laws	law	NNS
18637	13981	68	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13981	69	promulgates	promulgate	VBZ
18637	13981	70	for	for	IN
18637	13981	71	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13981	72	own	own	JJ
18637	13981	73	residents	resident	NNS
18637	13981	74	.	.	.
18637	13982	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13982	2	173	173	CD
18637	13982	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13982	4	But	but	CC
18637	13982	5	a	a	DT
18637	13982	6	State	state	NN
18637	13982	7	may	may	MD
18637	13982	8	not	not	RB
18637	13982	9	give	give	VB
18637	13982	10	a	a	DT
18637	13982	11	preference	preference	NN
18637	13982	12	to	to	IN
18637	13982	13	resident	resident	JJ
18637	13982	14	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	13982	15	in	in	IN
18637	13982	16	the	the	DT
18637	13982	17	administration	administration	NN
18637	13982	18	of	of	IN
18637	13982	19	the	the	DT
18637	13982	20	property	property	NN
18637	13982	21	of	of	IN
18637	13982	22	an	an	DT
18637	13982	23	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
18637	13982	24	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13982	25	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13982	26	.	.	.
18637	13983	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13983	2	174	174	CD
18637	13983	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13983	4	An	an	DT
18637	13983	5	act	act	NN
18637	13983	6	of	of	IN
18637	13983	7	the	the	DT
18637	13983	8	Confederate	Confederate	NNP
18637	13983	9	Government	Government	NNP
18637	13983	10	,	,	,
18637	13983	11	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	13983	12	by	by	IN
18637	13983	13	a	a	DT
18637	13983	14	State	state	NN
18637	13983	15	,	,	,
18637	13983	16	to	to	TO
18637	13983	17	sequester	sequester	VB
18637	13983	18	a	a	DT
18637	13983	19	debt	debt	NN
18637	13983	20	owed	owe	VBN
18637	13983	21	by	by	IN
18637	13983	22	one	one	CD
18637	13983	23	of	of	IN
18637	13983	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13983	25	residents	resident	NNS
18637	13983	26	to	to	IN
18637	13983	27	a	a	DT
18637	13983	28	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	13983	29	of	of	IN
18637	13983	30	another	another	DT
18637	13983	31	State	state	NN
18637	13983	32	was	be	VBD
18637	13983	33	held	hold	VBN
18637	13983	34	to	to	TO
18637	13983	35	be	be	VB
18637	13983	36	a	a	DT
18637	13983	37	flagrant	flagrant	JJ
18637	13983	38	violation	violation	NN
18637	13983	39	of	of	IN
18637	13983	40	this	this	DT
18637	13983	41	clause	clause	NN
18637	13983	42	.	.	.
18637	13984	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13984	2	175	175	CD
18637	13984	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13984	4	ACCESS	ACCESS	NNP
18637	13984	5	TO	to	IN
18637	13984	6	COURTS	courts	NN
18637	13984	7	The	the	DT
18637	13984	8	right	right	NN
18637	13984	9	to	to	TO
18637	13984	10	sue	sue	VB
18637	13984	11	and	and	CC
18637	13984	12	defend	defend	VB
18637	13984	13	in	in	IN
18637	13984	14	the	the	DT
18637	13984	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	13984	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	13984	17	one	one	CD
18637	13984	18	of	of	IN
18637	13984	19	the	the	DT
18637	13984	20	highest	high	JJS
18637	13984	21	and	and	CC
18637	13984	22	most	most	RBS
18637	13984	23	essential	essential	JJ
18637	13984	24	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	13984	25	of	of	IN
18637	13984	26	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	13984	27	,	,	,
18637	13984	28	and	and	CC
18637	13984	29	must	must	MD
18637	13984	30	be	be	VB
18637	13984	31	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	13984	32	by	by	IN
18637	13984	33	each	each	DT
18637	13984	34	State	state	NN
18637	13984	35	to	to	IN
18637	13984	36	the	the	DT
18637	13984	37	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13984	38	of	of	IN
18637	13984	39	all	all	DT
18637	13984	40	other	other	JJ
18637	13984	41	States	state	NNS
18637	13984	42	to	to	IN
18637	13984	43	the	the	DT
18637	13984	44	same	same	JJ
18637	13984	45	extent	extent	NN
18637	13984	46	that	that	IN
18637	13984	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13984	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	13984	49	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	13984	50	to	to	IN
18637	13984	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13984	52	own	own	JJ
18637	13984	53	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13984	54	.	.	.
18637	13985	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13985	2	176	176	CD
18637	13985	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13985	4	The	the	DT
18637	13985	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	13985	6	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	13985	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	13985	8	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	13985	9	if	if	IN
18637	13985	10	the	the	DT
18637	13985	11	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	13985	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	13985	13	given	give	VBN
18637	13985	14	access	access	NN
18637	13985	15	to	to	IN
18637	13985	16	the	the	DT
18637	13985	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	13985	18	of	of	IN
18637	13985	19	the	the	DT
18637	13985	20	State	State	NNP
18637	13985	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	13985	22	terms	term	NNS
18637	13985	23	which	which	WDT
18637	13985	24	,	,	,
18637	13985	25	in	in	IN
18637	13985	26	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13985	27	,	,	,
18637	13985	28	are	be	VBP
18637	13985	29	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	13985	30	and	and	CC
18637	13985	31	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	13985	32	for	for	IN
18637	13985	33	the	the	DT
18637	13985	34	enforcing	enforcing	NN
18637	13985	35	of	of	IN
18637	13985	36	any	any	DT
18637	13985	37	rights	right	NNS
18637	13985	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13985	39	may	may	MD
18637	13985	40	have	have	VB
18637	13985	41	,	,	,
18637	13985	42	even	even	RB
18637	13985	43	though	though	IN
18637	13985	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13985	45	may	may	MD
18637	13985	46	not	not	RB
18637	13985	47	be	be	VB
18637	13985	48	technically	technically	RB
18637	13985	49	the	the	DT
18637	13985	50	same	same	JJ
18637	13985	51	as	as	IN
18637	13985	52	those	those	DT
18637	13985	53	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	13985	54	to	to	IN
18637	13985	55	resident	resident	JJ
18637	13985	56	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13985	57	.	.	.
18637	13986	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13986	2	177	177	CD
18637	13986	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13986	4	The	the	DT
18637	13986	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	13986	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13986	7	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	13986	8	a	a	DT
18637	13986	9	State	State	NNP
18637	13986	10	statute	statute	NN
18637	13986	11	of	of	IN
18637	13986	12	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	13986	13	which	which	WDT
18637	13986	14	prevented	prevent	VBD
18637	13986	15	a	a	DT
18637	13986	16	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	13986	17	from	from	IN
18637	13986	18	suing	sue	VBG
18637	13986	19	in	in	IN
18637	13986	20	the	the	DT
18637	13986	21	State	State	NNP
18637	13986	22	's	's	POS
18637	13986	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	13986	24	after	after	IN
18637	13986	25	expiration	expiration	NN
18637	13986	26	of	of	IN
18637	13986	27	the	the	DT
18637	13986	28	time	time	NN
18637	13986	29	for	for	IN
18637	13986	30	suit	suit	NN
18637	13986	31	in	in	IN
18637	13986	32	the	the	DT
18637	13986	33	place	place	NN
18637	13986	34	where	where	WRB
18637	13986	35	the	the	DT
18637	13986	36	cause	cause	NN
18637	13986	37	of	of	IN
18637	13986	38	action	action	NN
18637	13986	39	arose,[178	arose,[178	NNP
18637	13986	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13986	41	and	and	CC
18637	13986	42	another	another	DT
18637	13986	43	such	such	JJ
18637	13986	44	statute	statute	NN
18637	13986	45	which	which	WDT
18637	13986	46	suspended	suspend	VBD
18637	13986	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13986	48	operation	operation	NN
18637	13986	49	as	as	IN
18637	13986	50	to	to	IN
18637	13986	51	resident	resident	NN
18637	13986	52	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	13986	53	,	,	,
18637	13986	54	but	but	CC
18637	13986	55	not	not	RB
18637	13986	56	as	as	IN
18637	13986	57	to	to	IN
18637	13986	58	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	13986	59	,	,	,
18637	13986	60	during	during	IN
18637	13986	61	the	the	DT
18637	13986	62	period	period	NN
18637	13986	63	of	of	IN
18637	13986	64	the	the	DT
18637	13986	65	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	13986	66	's	's	POS
18637	13986	67	absence	absence	NN
18637	13986	68	from	from	IN
18637	13986	69	the	the	DT
18637	13986	70	State	State	NNP
18637	13986	71	.	.	.
18637	13987	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13987	2	179	179	CD
18637	13987	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13987	4	A	a	DT
18637	13987	5	State	State	NNP
18637	13987	6	law	law	NN
18637	13987	7	making	make	VBG
18637	13987	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13987	9	discretionary	discretionary	JJ
18637	13987	10	with	with	IN
18637	13987	11	the	the	DT
18637	13987	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	13987	13	to	to	TO
18637	13987	14	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	13987	15	an	an	DT
18637	13987	16	action	action	NN
18637	13987	17	by	by	IN
18637	13987	18	a	a	DT
18637	13987	19	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	13987	20	of	of	IN
18637	13987	21	the	the	DT
18637	13987	22	State	State	NNP
18637	13987	23	against	against	IN
18637	13987	24	a	a	DT
18637	13987	25	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	13987	26	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13987	27	doing	do	VBG
18637	13987	28	business	business	NN
18637	13987	29	in	in	IN
18637	13987	30	the	the	DT
18637	13987	31	State	State	NNP
18637	13987	32	,	,	,
18637	13987	33	was	be	VBD
18637	13987	34	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	13987	35	since	since	IN
18637	13987	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13987	37	was	be	VBD
18637	13987	38	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	13987	39	alike	alike	RB
18637	13987	40	to	to	IN
18637	13987	41	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13987	42	and	and	CC
18637	13987	43	noncitizens	noncitizen	NNS
18637	13987	44	residing	reside	VBG
18637	13987	45	out	out	IN
18637	13987	46	of	of	IN
18637	13987	47	the	the	DT
18637	13987	48	State	State	NNP
18637	13987	49	.	.	.
18637	13988	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13988	2	180	180	CD
18637	13988	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13988	4	A	a	DT
18637	13988	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	13988	6	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	13988	7	a	a	DT
18637	13988	8	suit	suit	NN
18637	13988	9	in	in	IN
18637	13988	10	the	the	DT
18637	13988	11	courts	court	NNS
18637	13988	12	of	of	IN
18637	13988	13	the	the	DT
18637	13988	14	State	State	NNP
18637	13988	15	for	for	IN
18637	13988	16	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
18637	13988	17	death	death	NN
18637	13988	18	occurring	occur	VBG
18637	13988	19	outside	outside	IN
18637	13988	20	the	the	DT
18637	13988	21	State	State	NNP
18637	13988	22	,	,	,
18637	13988	23	only	only	RB
18637	13988	24	if	if	IN
18637	13988	25	the	the	DT
18637	13988	26	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	13988	27	was	be	VBD
18637	13988	28	a	a	DT
18637	13988	29	resident	resident	NN
18637	13988	30	of	of	IN
18637	13988	31	the	the	DT
18637	13988	32	State	State	NNP
18637	13988	33	,	,	,
18637	13988	34	was	be	VBD
18637	13988	35	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	13988	36	,	,	,
18637	13988	37	because	because	IN
18637	13988	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13988	39	operated	operate	VBD
18637	13988	40	equally	equally	RB
18637	13988	41	upon	upon	IN
18637	13988	42	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	13988	43	of	of	IN
18637	13988	44	the	the	DT
18637	13988	45	deceased	deceased	JJ
18637	13988	46	whether	whether	IN
18637	13988	47	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13988	48	or	or	CC
18637	13988	49	noncitizens	noncitizen	NNS
18637	13988	50	.	.	.
18637	13989	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13989	2	181	181	CD
18637	13989	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13989	4	TAXATION	TAXATION	NNP
18637	13989	5	A	A	NNP
18637	13989	6	State	state	NN
18637	13989	7	may	may	MD
18637	13989	8	not	not	RB
18637	13989	9	,	,	,
18637	13989	10	in	in	IN
18637	13989	11	the	the	DT
18637	13989	12	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	13989	13	of	of	IN
18637	13989	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13989	15	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	13989	16	power	power	NN
18637	13989	17	,	,	,
18637	13989	18	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	13989	19	discriminate	discriminate	VB
18637	13989	20	between	between	IN
18637	13989	21	residents	resident	NNS
18637	13989	22	and	and	CC
18637	13989	23	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	13989	24	.	.	.
18637	13990	1	A	a	DT
18637	13990	2	leading	leading	JJ
18637	13990	3	case	case	NN
18637	13990	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	13990	5	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	13990	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13990	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13990	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13990	9	Maryland,[182	Maryland,[182	NNP
18637	13990	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13990	11	in	in	IN
18637	13990	12	which	which	WDT
18637	13990	13	the	the	DT
18637	13990	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13990	15	set	set	VBD
18637	13990	16	aside	aside	RP
18637	13990	17	a	a	DT
18637	13990	18	State	State	NNP
18637	13990	19	law	law	NN
18637	13990	20	which	which	WDT
18637	13990	21	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	13990	22	special	special	JJ
18637	13990	23	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	13990	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	13990	25	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	13990	26	for	for	IN
18637	13990	27	the	the	DT
18637	13990	28	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	13990	29	of	of	IN
18637	13990	30	selling	selling	NN
18637	13990	31	within	within	IN
18637	13990	32	the	the	DT
18637	13990	33	State	State	NNP
18637	13990	34	goods	good	NNS
18637	13990	35	which	which	WDT
18637	13990	36	were	be	VBD
18637	13990	37	produced	produce	VBN
18637	13990	38	outside	outside	IN
18637	13990	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13990	40	.	.	.
18637	13991	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	13991	2	,	,	,
18637	13991	3	a	a	DT
18637	13991	4	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	13991	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	13991	6	which	which	WDT
18637	13991	7	made	make	VBD
18637	13991	8	the	the	DT
18637	13991	9	amount	amount	NN
18637	13991	10	of	of	IN
18637	13991	11	the	the	DT
18637	13991	12	annual	annual	JJ
18637	13991	13	license	license	NN
18637	13991	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	13991	15	exacted	exact	VBN
18637	13991	16	for	for	IN
18637	13991	17	the	the	DT
18637	13991	18	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	13991	19	of	of	IN
18637	13991	20	doing	do	VBG
18637	13991	21	railway	railway	NN
18637	13991	22	construction	construction	NN
18637	13991	23	work	work	NN
18637	13991	24	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	13991	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	13991	26	whether	whether	IN
18637	13991	27	the	the	DT
18637	13991	28	person	person	NN
18637	13991	29	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	13991	30	had	have	VBD
18637	13991	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13991	32	chief	chief	JJ
18637	13991	33	office	office	NN
18637	13991	34	within	within	IN
18637	13991	35	or	or	CC
18637	13991	36	without	without	IN
18637	13991	37	the	the	DT
18637	13991	38	State	State	NNP
18637	13991	39	,	,	,
18637	13991	40	was	be	VBD
18637	13991	41	found	find	VBN
18637	13991	42	to	to	TO
18637	13991	43	be	be	VB
18637	13991	44	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
18637	13991	45	with	with	IN
18637	13991	46	the	the	DT
18637	13991	47	comity	comity	NN
18637	13991	48	clause	clause	NN
18637	13991	49	.	.	.
18637	13992	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13992	2	183	183	CD
18637	13992	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13992	4	In	in	IN
18637	13992	5	Travis	Travis	NNP
18637	13992	6	_	_	NNP
18637	13992	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	13992	8	_	_	NNP
18637	13992	9	Yale	Yale	NNP
18637	13992	10	and	and	CC
18637	13992	11	Towne	Towne	NNP
18637	13992	12	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	13992	13	.	.	.
18637	13993	1	Co	Co	NNS
18637	13993	2	.	.	.
18637	13993	3	,[184	,[184	NFP
18637	13993	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13993	5	the	the	DT
18637	13993	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13993	7	,	,	,
18637	13993	8	while	while	IN
18637	13993	9	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	13993	10	the	the	DT
18637	13993	11	right	right	NN
18637	13993	12	of	of	IN
18637	13993	13	a	a	DT
18637	13993	14	State	State	NNP
18637	13993	15	to	to	TO
18637	13993	16	tax	tax	VB
18637	13993	17	income	income	NN
18637	13993	18	accruing	accrue	VBG
18637	13993	19	within	within	IN
18637	13993	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13993	21	borders	border	NNS
18637	13993	22	to	to	TO
18637	13993	23	nonresidents,[185	nonresidents,[185	NNP
18637	13993	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13993	25	held	hold	VBD
18637	13993	26	the	the	DT
18637	13993	27	particular	particular	JJ
18637	13993	28	tax	tax	NN
18637	13993	29	void	void	NN
18637	13993	30	because	because	IN
18637	13993	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13993	32	denied	deny	VBD
18637	13993	33	to	to	IN
18637	13993	34	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	13993	35	exemptions	exemption	NNS
18637	13993	36	which	which	WDT
18637	13993	37	were	be	VBD
18637	13993	38	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	13993	39	to	to	IN
18637	13993	40	residents	resident	NNS
18637	13993	41	.	.	.
18637	13994	1	The	the	DT
18637	13994	2	"	"	``
18637	13994	3	terms	term	NNS
18637	13994	4	'	'	POS
18637	13994	5	resident	resident	NN
18637	13994	6	'	'	''
18637	13994	7	and	and	CC
18637	13994	8	'	'	``
18637	13994	9	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	13994	10	'	'	''
18637	13994	11	are	be	VBP
18637	13994	12	not	not	RB
18637	13994	13	synonymous	synonymous	JJ
18637	13994	14	,	,	,
18637	13994	15	"	"	''
18637	13994	16	wrote	write	VBD
18637	13994	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	13994	18	Pitney	Pitney	NNP
18637	13994	19	,	,	,
18637	13994	20	"	"	``
18637	13994	21	*	*	NFP
18637	13994	22	*	*	NFP
18637	13994	23	*	*	NFP
18637	13994	24	but	but	CC
18637	13994	25	a	a	DT
18637	13994	26	general	general	JJ
18637	13994	27	taxing	taxing	NN
18637	13994	28	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	13994	29	*	*	NFP
18637	13994	30	*	*	NFP
18637	13994	31	*	*	NFP
18637	13994	32	if	if	IN
18637	13994	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	13994	34	discriminates	discriminate	VBZ
18637	13994	35	against	against	IN
18637	13994	36	all	all	DT
18637	13994	37	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	13994	38	,	,	,
18637	13994	39	has	have	VBZ
18637	13994	40	the	the	DT
18637	13994	41	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	13994	42	effect	effect	NN
18637	13994	43	of	of	IN
18637	13994	44	including	include	VBG
18637	13994	45	in	in	IN
18637	13994	46	the	the	DT
18637	13994	47	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	13994	48	those	those	DT
18637	13994	49	who	who	WP
18637	13994	50	are	be	VBP
18637	13994	51	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13994	52	of	of	IN
18637	13994	53	other	other	JJ
18637	13994	54	States	state	NNS
18637	13994	55	;	;	:
18637	13994	56	*	*	NFP
18637	13994	57	*	*	NFP
18637	13994	58	*	*	NFP
18637	13994	59	"	"	''
18637	13994	60	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13994	61	186	186	CD
18637	13994	62	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13994	63	Where	where	WRB
18637	13994	64	there	there	EX
18637	13994	65	was	be	VBD
18637	13994	66	no	no	DT
18637	13994	67	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	13994	68	between	between	IN
18637	13994	69	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13994	70	and	and	CC
18637	13994	71	noncitizens	noncitizen	NNS
18637	13994	72	,	,	,
18637	13994	73	a	a	DT
18637	13994	74	State	State	NNP
18637	13994	75	statute	statute	NN
18637	13994	76	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	13994	77	the	the	DT
18637	13994	78	business	business	NN
18637	13994	79	of	of	IN
18637	13994	80	hiring	hire	VBG
18637	13994	81	persons	person	NNS
18637	13994	82	within	within	IN
18637	13994	83	the	the	DT
18637	13994	84	State	State	NNP
18637	13994	85	for	for	IN
18637	13994	86	labor	labor	NN
18637	13994	87	outside	outside	IN
18637	13994	88	the	the	DT
18637	13994	89	State	State	NNP
18637	13994	90	,	,	,
18637	13994	91	was	be	VBD
18637	13994	92	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	13994	93	.	.	.
18637	13995	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13995	2	187	187	CD
18637	13995	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13995	4	This	this	DT
18637	13995	5	section	section	NN
18637	13995	6	of	of	IN
18637	13995	7	the	the	DT
18637	13995	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	13995	9	does	do	VBZ
18637	13995	10	not	not	RB
18637	13995	11	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	13995	12	a	a	DT
18637	13995	13	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	13995	14	government	government	NN
18637	13995	15	,	,	,
18637	13995	16	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	13995	17	powers	power	NNS
18637	13995	18	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	13995	19	by	by	IN
18637	13995	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	13995	21	,	,	,
18637	13995	22	from	from	IN
18637	13995	23	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	13995	24	a	a	DT
18637	13995	25	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	13995	26	license	license	NN
18637	13995	27	tax	tax	NN
18637	13995	28	on	on	IN
18637	13995	29	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	13995	30	fishermen	fisherman	NNS
18637	13995	31	operating	operate	VBG
18637	13995	32	within	within	IN
18637	13995	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13995	34	waters	water	NNS
18637	13995	35	.	.	.
18637	13996	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13996	2	188	188	CD
18637	13996	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13996	4	However	however	RB
18637	13996	5	,	,	,
18637	13996	6	what	what	WP
18637	13996	7	at	at	IN
18637	13996	8	first	first	JJ
18637	13996	9	glance	glance	NN
18637	13996	10	may	may	MD
18637	13996	11	appear	appear	VB
18637	13996	12	to	to	TO
18637	13996	13	be	be	VB
18637	13996	14	a	a	DT
18637	13996	15	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	13996	16	may	may	MD
18637	13996	17	turn	turn	VB
18637	13996	18	out	out	RP
18637	13996	19	not	not	RB
18637	13996	20	to	to	TO
18637	13996	21	be	be	VB
18637	13996	22	when	when	WRB
18637	13996	23	the	the	DT
18637	13996	24	entire	entire	JJ
18637	13996	25	system	system	NN
18637	13996	26	of	of	IN
18637	13996	27	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	13996	28	prevailing	prevail	VBG
18637	13996	29	in	in	IN
18637	13996	30	the	the	DT
18637	13996	31	enacting	enact	VBG
18637	13996	32	State	State	NNP
18637	13996	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	13996	34	considered	consider	VBN
18637	13996	35	.	.	.
18637	13997	1	On	on	IN
18637	13997	2	the	the	DT
18637	13997	3	basis	basis	NN
18637	13997	4	of	of	IN
18637	13997	5	over	over	IN
18637	13997	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	13997	7	all	all	DT
18637	13997	8	fairness	fairness	NN
18637	13997	9	,	,	,
18637	13997	10	the	the	DT
18637	13997	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13997	12	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	13997	13	a	a	DT
18637	13997	14	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	13997	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	13997	16	which	which	WDT
18637	13997	17	required	require	VBD
18637	13997	18	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	13997	19	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	13997	20	to	to	TO
18637	13997	21	pay	pay	VB
18637	13997	22	a	a	DT
18637	13997	23	State	state	NN
18637	13997	24	tax	tax	NN
18637	13997	25	measured	measure	VBN
18637	13997	26	by	by	IN
18637	13997	27	the	the	DT
18637	13997	28	full	full	JJ
18637	13997	29	market	market	NN
18637	13997	30	value	value	NN
18637	13997	31	of	of	IN
18637	13997	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13997	33	stock	stock	NN
18637	13997	34	,	,	,
18637	13997	35	while	while	IN
18637	13997	36	resident	resident	NN
18637	13997	37	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	13997	38	were	be	VBD
18637	13997	39	subject	subject	JJ
18637	13997	40	to	to	IN
18637	13997	41	local	local	JJ
18637	13997	42	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	13997	43	on	on	IN
18637	13997	44	the	the	DT
18637	13997	45	market	market	NN
18637	13997	46	value	value	NN
18637	13997	47	of	of	IN
18637	13997	48	that	that	DT
18637	13997	49	stock	stock	NN
18637	13997	50	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	13997	51	by	by	IN
18637	13997	52	the	the	DT
18637	13997	53	value	value	NN
18637	13997	54	of	of	IN
18637	13997	55	the	the	DT
18637	13997	56	real	real	JJ
18637	13997	57	estate	estate	NN
18637	13997	58	owned	own	VBN
18637	13997	59	by	by	IN
18637	13997	60	the	the	DT
18637	13997	61	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	13997	62	.	.	.
18637	13998	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13998	2	189	189	CD
18637	13998	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13998	4	Occasional	occasional	JJ
18637	13998	5	or	or	CC
18637	13998	6	accidental	accidental	JJ
18637	13998	7	inequality	inequality	NN
18637	13998	8	to	to	IN
18637	13998	9	a	a	DT
18637	13998	10	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	13998	11	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	13998	12	are	be	VBP
18637	13998	13	not	not	RB
18637	13998	14	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	13998	15	to	to	TO
18637	13998	16	defeat	defeat	VB
18637	13998	17	a	a	DT
18637	13998	18	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	13998	19	of	of	IN
18637	13998	20	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	13998	21	whose	whose	WP$
18637	13998	22	operation	operation	NN
18637	13998	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	13998	24	generally	generally	RB
18637	13998	25	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	13998	26	.	.	.
18637	13999	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	13999	2	190	190	CD
18637	13999	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	13999	4	In	in	IN
18637	13999	5	an	an	DT
18637	13999	6	early	early	JJ
18637	13999	7	case	case	NN
18637	13999	8	the	the	DT
18637	13999	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	13999	10	brushed	brush	VBD
18637	13999	11	aside	aside	RB
18637	13999	12	as	as	RB
18637	13999	13	frivolous	frivolous	JJ
18637	13999	14	the	the	DT
18637	13999	15	contention	contention	NN
18637	13999	16	that	that	IN
18637	13999	17	a	a	DT
18637	13999	18	State	state	NN
18637	13999	19	violated	violate	VBD
18637	13999	20	this	this	DT
18637	13999	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	13999	22	by	by	IN
18637	13999	23	subjecting	subject	VBG
18637	13999	24	one	one	CD
18637	13999	25	of	of	IN
18637	13999	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	13999	27	own	own	JJ
18637	13999	28	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	13999	29	to	to	IN
18637	13999	30	a	a	DT
18637	13999	31	property	property	NN
18637	13999	32	tax	tax	NN
18637	13999	33	on	on	IN
18637	13999	34	a	a	DT
18637	13999	35	debt	debt	NN
18637	13999	36	due	due	JJ
18637	13999	37	from	from	IN
18637	13999	38	a	a	DT
18637	13999	39	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	13999	40	secured	secure	VBN
18637	13999	41	by	by	IN
18637	13999	42	real	real	JJ
18637	13999	43	estate	estate	NN
18637	13999	44	situated	situate	VBN
18637	13999	45	where	where	WRB
18637	13999	46	the	the	DT
18637	13999	47	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	13999	48	resided	reside	VBD
18637	13999	49	.	.	.
18637	14000	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14000	2	191	191	CD
18637	14000	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14000	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	14000	5	2	2	CD
18637	14000	6	.	.	.
18637	14001	1	A	a	DT
18637	14001	2	person	person	NN
18637	14001	3	charged	charge	VBN
18637	14001	4	in	in	IN
18637	14001	5	any	any	DT
18637	14001	6	State	State	NNP
18637	14001	7	With	with	IN
18637	14001	8	Treason	Treason	NNP
18637	14001	9	,	,	,
18637	14001	10	Felony	Felony	NNP
18637	14001	11	,	,	,
18637	14001	12	or	or	CC
18637	14001	13	other	other	JJ
18637	14001	14	Crime	Crime	NNP
18637	14001	15	,	,	,
18637	14001	16	who	who	WP
18637	14001	17	shall	shall	MD
18637	14001	18	flee	flee	VB
18637	14001	19	from	from	IN
18637	14001	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14001	21	,	,	,
18637	14001	22	and	and	CC
18637	14001	23	be	be	VB
18637	14001	24	found	find	VBN
18637	14001	25	in	in	IN
18637	14001	26	another	another	DT
18637	14001	27	State	State	NNP
18637	14001	28	,	,	,
18637	14001	29	shall	shall	MD
18637	14001	30	on	on	IN
18637	14001	31	Demand	demand	NN
18637	14001	32	of	of	IN
18637	14001	33	the	the	DT
18637	14001	34	executive	executive	NN
18637	14001	35	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	14001	36	of	of	IN
18637	14001	37	the	the	DT
18637	14001	38	State	State	NNP
18637	14001	39	from	from	IN
18637	14001	40	which	which	WDT
18637	14001	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14001	42	fled	flee	VBD
18637	14001	43	,	,	,
18637	14001	44	be	be	VB
18637	14001	45	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	14001	46	up	up	RP
18637	14001	47	,	,	,
18637	14001	48	to	to	TO
18637	14001	49	be	be	VB
18637	14001	50	removed	remove	VBN
18637	14001	51	to	to	IN
18637	14001	52	the	the	DT
18637	14001	53	State	state	NN
18637	14001	54	having	have	VBG
18637	14001	55	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	14001	56	of	of	IN
18637	14001	57	the	the	DT
18637	14001	58	Crime	Crime	NNP
18637	14001	59	.	.	.
18637	14002	1	Fugitives	fugitive	NNS
18637	14002	2	From	from	IN
18637	14002	3	Justice	justice	NN
18637	14002	4	DUTY	DUTY	NNP
18637	14002	5	TO	to	IN
18637	14002	6	SURRENDER	SURRENDER	NNP
18637	14002	7	Although	although	IN
18637	14002	8	this	this	DT
18637	14002	9	provision	provision	NN
18637	14002	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	14002	11	not	not	RB
18637	14002	12	in	in	IN
18637	14002	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14002	14	nature	nature	NN
18637	14002	15	self	self	NN
18637	14002	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	14002	17	executing	execute	VBG
18637	14002	18	,	,	,
18637	14002	19	and	and	CC
18637	14002	20	there	there	EX
18637	14002	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	14002	22	no	no	DT
18637	14002	23	express	express	JJ
18637	14002	24	grant	grant	NN
18637	14002	25	to	to	IN
18637	14002	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14002	27	of	of	IN
18637	14002	28	power	power	NN
18637	14002	29	to	to	TO
18637	14002	30	carry	carry	VB
18637	14002	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14002	32	into	into	IN
18637	14002	33	effect	effect	NN
18637	14002	34	,	,	,
18637	14002	35	that	that	DT
18637	14002	36	body	body	NN
18637	14002	37	passed	pass	VBD
18637	14002	38	a	a	DT
18637	14002	39	law	law	NN
18637	14002	40	shortly	shortly	RB
18637	14002	41	after	after	IN
18637	14002	42	the	the	DT
18637	14002	43	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14002	44	was	be	VBD
18637	14002	45	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	14002	46	,	,	,
18637	14002	47	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	14002	48	upon	upon	IN
18637	14002	49	the	the	DT
18637	14002	50	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	14002	51	of	of	IN
18637	14002	52	each	each	DT
18637	14002	53	State	state	NN
18637	14002	54	the	the	DT
18637	14002	55	duty	duty	NN
18637	14002	56	to	to	TO
18637	14002	57	deliver	deliver	VB
18637	14002	58	up	up	RP
18637	14002	59	fugitives	fugitive	NNS
18637	14002	60	from	from	IN
18637	14002	61	justice	justice	NN
18637	14002	62	found	find	VBN
18637	14002	63	in	in	IN
18637	14002	64	such	such	JJ
18637	14002	65	State	State	NNP
18637	14002	66	.	.	.
18637	14003	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14003	2	192	192	CD
18637	14003	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14003	4	The	the	DT
18637	14003	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14003	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14003	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	14003	8	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	14003	9	this	this	DT
18637	14003	10	contemporaneous	contemporaneous	JJ
18637	14003	11	construction	construction	NN
18637	14003	12	as	as	IN
18637	14003	13	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	14003	14	the	the	DT
18637	14003	15	validity	validity	NN
18637	14003	16	of	of	IN
18637	14003	17	this	this	DT
18637	14003	18	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	14003	19	.	.	.
18637	14004	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14004	2	193	193	CD
18637	14004	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14004	4	The	the	DT
18637	14004	5	duty	duty	NN
18637	14004	6	to	to	TO
18637	14004	7	surrender	surrender	VB
18637	14004	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	14004	9	not	not	RB
18637	14004	10	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	14004	11	and	and	CC
18637	14004	12	unqualified	unqualified	JJ
18637	14004	13	;	;	:
18637	14004	14	if	if	IN
18637	14004	15	the	the	DT
18637	14004	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	14004	17	of	of	IN
18637	14004	18	the	the	DT
18637	14004	19	State	State	NNP
18637	14004	20	to	to	TO
18637	14004	21	which	which	WDT
18637	14004	22	the	the	DT
18637	14004	23	fugitive	fugitive	NN
18637	14004	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	14004	25	fled	flee	VBN
18637	14004	26	have	have	VBP
18637	14004	27	been	be	VBN
18637	14004	28	put	put	VBN
18637	14004	29	in	in	IN
18637	14004	30	force	force	NN
18637	14004	31	against	against	IN
18637	14004	32	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14004	33	,	,	,
18637	14004	34	and	and	CC
18637	14004	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14004	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	14004	37	imprisoned	imprison	VBN
18637	14004	38	there	there	RB
18637	14004	39	,	,	,
18637	14004	40	the	the	DT
18637	14004	41	demands	demand	NNS
18637	14004	42	of	of	IN
18637	14004	43	those	those	DT
18637	14004	44	laws	law	NNS
18637	14004	45	may	may	MD
18637	14004	46	be	be	VB
18637	14004	47	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	14004	48	before	before	IN
18637	14004	49	the	the	DT
18637	14004	50	duty	duty	NN
18637	14004	51	of	of	IN
18637	14004	52	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	14004	53	to	to	IN
18637	14004	54	the	the	DT
18637	14004	55	requisition	requisition	NN
18637	14004	56	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	14004	57	.	.	.
18637	14005	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14005	2	194	194	CD
18637	14005	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14005	4	In	in	IN
18637	14005	5	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	14005	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14005	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14005	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14005	9	Dennison[195	Dennison[195	NNP
18637	14005	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14005	11	the	the	DT
18637	14005	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14005	13	held	hold	VBD
18637	14005	14	,	,	,
18637	14005	15	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	14005	16	,	,	,
18637	14005	17	that	that	IN
18637	14005	18	this	this	DT
18637	14005	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	14005	20	was	be	VBD
18637	14005	21	merely	merely	RB
18637	14005	22	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	14005	23	of	of	IN
18637	14005	24	a	a	DT
18637	14005	25	moral	moral	JJ
18637	14005	26	duty	duty	NN
18637	14005	27	;	;	:
18637	14005	28	that	that	IN
18637	14005	29	the	the	DT
18637	14005	30	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	14005	31	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14005	32	"	"	''
18637	14005	33	has	have	VBZ
18637	14005	34	no	no	DT
18637	14005	35	power	power	NN
18637	14005	36	to	to	TO
18637	14005	37	impose	impose	VB
18637	14005	38	on	on	IN
18637	14005	39	a	a	DT
18637	14005	40	State	state	NN
18637	14005	41	officer	officer	NN
18637	14005	42	,	,	,
18637	14005	43	as	as	IN
18637	14005	44	such	such	JJ
18637	14005	45	,	,	,
18637	14005	46	any	any	DT
18637	14005	47	duty	duty	NN
18637	14005	48	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	14005	49	,	,	,
18637	14005	50	and	and	CC
18637	14005	51	compel	compel	VB
18637	14005	52	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14005	53	to	to	TO
18637	14005	54	perform	perform	VB
18637	14005	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14005	56	;	;	:
18637	14005	57	*	*	NFP
18637	14005	58	*	*	NFP
18637	14005	59	*	*	NFP
18637	14005	60	"	"	''
18637	14005	61	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14005	62	196	196	CD
18637	14005	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14005	64	and	and	CC
18637	14005	65	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	14005	66	that	that	IN
18637	14005	67	a	a	DT
18637	14005	68	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14005	69	court	court	NN
18637	14005	70	could	could	MD
18637	14005	71	not	not	RB
18637	14005	72	issue	issue	VB
18637	14005	73	a	a	DT
18637	14005	74	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	14005	75	to	to	TO
18637	14005	76	compel	compel	VB
18637	14005	77	the	the	DT
18637	14005	78	governor	governor	NN
18637	14005	79	of	of	IN
18637	14005	80	one	one	CD
18637	14005	81	State	State	NNP
18637	14005	82	to	to	TO
18637	14005	83	surrender	surrender	VB
18637	14005	84	a	a	DT
18637	14005	85	fugitive	fugitive	NN
18637	14005	86	to	to	IN
18637	14005	87	another	another	DT
18637	14005	88	.	.	.
18637	14006	1	In	in	IN
18637	14006	2	1934	1934	CD
18637	14006	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14006	4	plugged	plug	VBD
18637	14006	5	the	the	DT
18637	14006	6	loophole	loophole	NN
18637	14006	7	exposed	expose	VBN
18637	14006	8	by	by	IN
18637	14006	9	this	this	DT
18637	14006	10	decision	decision	NN
18637	14006	11	by	by	IN
18637	14006	12	making	make	VBG
18637	14006	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14006	14	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	14006	15	for	for	IN
18637	14006	16	any	any	DT
18637	14006	17	person	person	NN
18637	14006	18	to	to	TO
18637	14006	19	flee	flee	VB
18637	14006	20	from	from	IN
18637	14006	21	one	one	CD
18637	14006	22	State	state	NN
18637	14006	23	to	to	IN
18637	14006	24	another	another	DT
18637	14006	25	for	for	IN
18637	14006	26	the	the	DT
18637	14006	27	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	14006	28	of	of	IN
18637	14006	29	avoiding	avoid	VBG
18637	14006	30	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	14006	31	in	in	IN
18637	14006	32	certain	certain	JJ
18637	14006	33	cases	case	NNS
18637	14006	34	.	.	.
18637	14007	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14007	2	197	197	CD
18637	14007	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14007	4	FUGITIVE	FUGITIVE	VBD
18637	14007	5	FROM	from	IN
18637	14007	6	JUSTICE	justice	NN
18637	14007	7	To	to	TO
18637	14007	8	be	be	VB
18637	14007	9	a	a	DT
18637	14007	10	fugitive	fugitive	NN
18637	14007	11	from	from	IN
18637	14007	12	justice	justice	NN
18637	14007	13	within	within	IN
18637	14007	14	the	the	DT
18637	14007	15	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	14007	16	of	of	IN
18637	14007	17	this	this	DT
18637	14007	18	clause	clause	NN
18637	14007	19	,	,	,
18637	14007	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14007	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	14007	22	not	not	RB
18637	14007	23	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	14007	24	that	that	IN
18637	14007	25	the	the	DT
18637	14007	26	party	party	NN
18637	14007	27	charged	charge	VBD
18637	14007	28	should	should	MD
18637	14007	29	have	have	VB
18637	14007	30	left	leave	VBN
18637	14007	31	the	the	DT
18637	14007	32	State	State	NNP
18637	14007	33	after	after	IN
18637	14007	34	an	an	DT
18637	14007	35	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	14007	36	found	find	VBD
18637	14007	37	,	,	,
18637	14007	38	or	or	CC
18637	14007	39	for	for	IN
18637	14007	40	the	the	DT
18637	14007	41	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	14007	42	of	of	IN
18637	14007	43	avoiding	avoid	VBG
18637	14007	44	a	a	DT
18637	14007	45	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	14007	46	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
18637	14007	47	or	or	CC
18637	14007	48	begun	begin	VBN
18637	14007	49	.	.	.
18637	14008	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14008	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	14008	3	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	14008	4	that	that	IN
18637	14008	5	the	the	DT
18637	14008	6	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	14008	7	,	,	,
18637	14008	8	having	have	VBG
18637	14008	9	committed	commit	VBN
18637	14008	10	a	a	DT
18637	14008	11	crime	crime	NN
18637	14008	12	within	within	IN
18637	14008	13	one	one	CD
18637	14008	14	State	state	NN
18637	14008	15	and	and	CC
18637	14008	16	having	have	VBG
18637	14008	17	left	leave	VBN
18637	14008	18	the	the	DT
18637	14008	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14008	20	before	before	IN
18637	14008	21	being	be	VBG
18637	14008	22	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	14008	23	to	to	IN
18637	14008	24	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	14008	25	process	process	NN
18637	14008	26	,	,	,
18637	14008	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	14008	28	found	find	VBN
18637	14008	29	within	within	IN
18637	14008	30	another	another	DT
18637	14008	31	State	state	NN
18637	14008	32	.	.	.
18637	14009	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14009	2	198	198	CD
18637	14009	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14009	4	The	the	DT
18637	14009	5	motive	motive	NN
18637	14009	6	which	which	WDT
18637	14009	7	induced	induce	VBD
18637	14009	8	the	the	DT
18637	14009	9	departure	departure	NN
18637	14009	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	14009	11	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
18637	14009	12	.	.	.
18637	14010	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14010	2	199	199	CD
18637	14010	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14010	4	Even	even	RB
18637	14010	5	if	if	IN
18637	14010	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14010	7	were	be	VBD
18637	14010	8	brought	bring	VBN
18637	14010	9	involuntarily	involuntarily	RB
18637	14010	10	into	into	IN
18637	14010	11	the	the	DT
18637	14010	12	State	State	NNP
18637	14010	13	where	where	WRB
18637	14010	14	found	find	VBN
18637	14010	15	by	by	IN
18637	14010	16	requisition	requisition	NN
18637	14010	17	from	from	IN
18637	14010	18	another	another	DT
18637	14010	19	State	state	NN
18637	14010	20	,	,	,
18637	14010	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14010	22	may	may	MD
18637	14010	23	be	be	VB
18637	14010	24	surrendered	surrender	VBN
18637	14010	25	to	to	IN
18637	14010	26	a	a	DT
18637	14010	27	third	third	JJ
18637	14010	28	State	State	NNP
18637	14010	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	14010	30	an	an	DT
18637	14010	31	extradition	extradition	NN
18637	14010	32	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	14010	33	.	.	.
18637	14011	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14011	2	200	200	CD
18637	14011	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14011	4	A	a	DT
18637	14011	5	person	person	NN
18637	14011	6	indicted	indict	VBD
18637	14011	7	a	a	DT
18637	14011	8	second	second	JJ
18637	14011	9	time	time	NN
18637	14011	10	for	for	IN
18637	14011	11	the	the	DT
18637	14011	12	same	same	JJ
18637	14011	13	offense	offense	NN
18637	14011	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	14011	15	nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
18637	14011	16	a	a	DT
18637	14011	17	fugitive	fugitive	NN
18637	14011	18	from	from	IN
18637	14011	19	justice	justice	NN
18637	14011	20	by	by	IN
18637	14011	21	reason	reason	NN
18637	14011	22	of	of	IN
18637	14011	23	the	the	DT
18637	14011	24	fact	fact	NN
18637	14011	25	that	that	IN
18637	14011	26	after	after	IN
18637	14011	27	dismissal	dismissal	NN
18637	14011	28	of	of	IN
18637	14011	29	the	the	DT
18637	14011	30	first	first	JJ
18637	14011	31	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	14011	32	,	,	,
18637	14011	33	on	on	IN
18637	14011	34	which	which	WDT
18637	14011	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14011	36	was	be	VBD
18637	14011	37	originally	originally	RB
18637	14011	38	indicted	indict	VBN
18637	14011	39	,	,	,
18637	14011	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14011	41	left	leave	VBD
18637	14011	42	the	the	DT
18637	14011	43	State	State	NNP
18637	14011	44	with	with	IN
18637	14011	45	the	the	DT
18637	14011	46	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	14011	47	of	of	IN
18637	14011	48	,	,	,
18637	14011	49	or	or	CC
18637	14011	50	without	without	IN
18637	14011	51	objection	objection	NN
18637	14011	52	by	by	IN
18637	14011	53	,	,	,
18637	14011	54	State	State	NNP
18637	14011	55	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	14011	56	.	.	.
18637	14012	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14012	2	201	201	CD
18637	14012	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14012	4	But	but	CC
18637	14012	5	a	a	DT
18637	14012	6	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	14012	7	can	can	MD
18637	14012	8	not	not	RB
18637	14012	9	be	be	VB
18637	14012	10	extradited	extradite	VBN
18637	14012	11	if	if	IN
18637	14012	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14012	13	was	be	VBD
18637	14012	14	only	only	RB
18637	14012	15	constructively	constructively	RB
18637	14012	16	present	present	JJ
18637	14012	17	in	in	IN
18637	14012	18	the	the	DT
18637	14012	19	demanding	demand	VBG
18637	14012	20	State	state	NN
18637	14012	21	at	at	IN
18637	14012	22	the	the	DT
18637	14012	23	time	time	NN
18637	14012	24	of	of	IN
18637	14012	25	the	the	DT
18637	14012	26	commission	commission	NN
18637	14012	27	of	of	IN
18637	14012	28	the	the	DT
18637	14012	29	crime	crime	NN
18637	14012	30	charged	charge	VBN
18637	14012	31	.	.	.
18637	14013	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14013	2	202	202	CD
18637	14013	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14013	4	For	for	IN
18637	14013	5	the	the	DT
18637	14013	6	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	14013	7	of	of	IN
18637	14013	8	determining	determine	VBG
18637	14013	9	who	who	WP
18637	14013	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	14013	11	a	a	DT
18637	14013	12	fugitive	fugitive	NN
18637	14013	13	from	from	IN
18637	14013	14	justice	justice	NN
18637	14013	15	,	,	,
18637	14013	16	the	the	DT
18637	14013	17	words	word	NNS
18637	14013	18	"	"	``
18637	14013	19	treason	treason	NN
18637	14013	20	,	,	,
18637	14013	21	felony	felony	NN
18637	14013	22	or	or	CC
18637	14013	23	other	other	JJ
18637	14013	24	crime	crime	NN
18637	14013	25	"	"	''
18637	14013	26	embrace	embrace	VBP
18637	14013	27	every	every	DT
18637	14013	28	act	act	NN
18637	14013	29	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	14013	30	and	and	CC
18637	14013	31	made	make	VBN
18637	14013	32	punishable	punishable	JJ
18637	14013	33	by	by	IN
18637	14013	34	a	a	DT
18637	14013	35	law	law	NN
18637	14013	36	of	of	IN
18637	14013	37	a	a	DT
18637	14013	38	State,[203	state,[203	NN
18637	14013	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14013	40	including	include	VBG
18637	14013	41	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
18637	14013	42	.	.	.
18637	14014	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14014	2	204	204	CD
18637	14014	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14014	4	PROCEDURE	PROCEDURE	NNP
18637	14014	5	FOR	for	IN
18637	14014	6	REMOVAL	REMOVAL	NNP
18637	14014	7	Only	only	RB
18637	14014	8	after	after	IN
18637	14014	9	a	a	DT
18637	14014	10	person	person	NN
18637	14014	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	14014	12	been	be	VBN
18637	14014	13	charged	charge	VBN
18637	14014	14	with	with	IN
18637	14014	15	crime	crime	NN
18637	14014	16	in	in	IN
18637	14014	17	the	the	DT
18637	14014	18	regular	regular	JJ
18637	14014	19	course	course	NN
18637	14014	20	of	of	IN
18637	14014	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	14014	22	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	14014	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	14014	24	the	the	DT
18637	14014	25	governor	governor	NN
18637	14014	26	of	of	IN
18637	14014	27	a	a	DT
18637	14014	28	State	state	NN
18637	14014	29	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	14014	30	to	to	TO
18637	14014	31	make	make	VB
18637	14014	32	demand	demand	NN
18637	14014	33	for	for	IN
18637	14014	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14014	35	return	return	NN
18637	14014	36	from	from	IN
18637	14014	37	another	another	DT
18637	14014	38	State	state	NN
18637	14014	39	.	.	.
18637	14015	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14015	2	205	205	CD
18637	14015	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14015	4	The	the	DT
18637	14015	5	person	person	NN
18637	14015	6	demanded	demand	VBD
18637	14015	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	14015	8	no	no	DT
18637	14015	9	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	14015	10	right	right	NN
18637	14015	11	to	to	TO
18637	14015	12	be	be	VB
18637	14015	13	heard	hear	VBN
18637	14015	14	before	before	IN
18637	14015	15	the	the	DT
18637	14015	16	governor	governor	NN
18637	14015	17	of	of	IN
18637	14015	18	the	the	DT
18637	14015	19	State	State	NNP
18637	14015	20	in	in	IN
18637	14015	21	which	which	WDT
18637	14015	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14015	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	14015	24	found	find	VBN
18637	14015	25	on	on	IN
18637	14015	26	the	the	DT
18637	14015	27	question	question	NN
18637	14015	28	whether	whether	IN
18637	14015	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14015	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	14015	31	been	be	VBN
18637	14015	32	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	14015	33	charged	charge	VBN
18637	14015	34	with	with	IN
18637	14015	35	crime	crime	NN
18637	14015	36	and	and	CC
18637	14015	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	14015	38	a	a	DT
18637	14015	39	fugitive	fugitive	NN
18637	14015	40	from	from	IN
18637	14015	41	justice	justice	NN
18637	14015	42	.	.	.
18637	14016	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14016	2	206	206	CD
18637	14016	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14016	4	The	the	DT
18637	14016	5	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	14016	6	required	require	VBN
18637	14016	7	surrender	surrender	NN
18637	14016	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	14016	9	not	not	RB
18637	14016	10	to	to	TO
18637	14016	11	be	be	VB
18637	14016	12	interfered	interfere	VBN
18637	14016	13	with	with	IN
18637	14016	14	by	by	IN
18637	14016	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14016	16	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	14016	17	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	14016	18	_	_	NNP
18637	14016	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	14016	20	speculations	speculation	NNS
18637	14016	21	as	as	IN
18637	14016	22	to	to	IN
18637	14016	23	what	what	WP
18637	14016	24	ought	ought	MD
18637	14016	25	to	to	TO
18637	14016	26	be	be	VB
18637	14016	27	the	the	DT
18637	14016	28	result	result	NN
18637	14016	29	of	of	IN
18637	14016	30	a	a	DT
18637	14016	31	trial	trial	NN
18637	14016	32	.	.	.
18637	14017	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14017	2	207	207	CD
18637	14017	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14017	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	14017	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	14017	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14017	7	proper	proper	JJ
18637	14017	8	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	14017	9	to	to	TO
18637	14017	10	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	14017	11	into	into	IN
18637	14017	12	the	the	DT
18637	14017	13	motives	motive	NNS
18637	14017	14	controlling	control	VBG
18637	14017	15	the	the	DT
18637	14017	16	actions	action	NNS
18637	14017	17	of	of	IN
18637	14017	18	the	the	DT
18637	14017	19	governors	governor	NNS
18637	14017	20	of	of	IN
18637	14017	21	the	the	DT
18637	14017	22	demanding	demand	VBG
18637	14017	23	and	and	CC
18637	14017	24	surrendering	surrendering	JJ
18637	14017	25	States	state	NNS
18637	14017	26	.	.	.
18637	14018	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14018	2	208	208	CD
18637	14018	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14018	4	Matters	matter	NNS
18637	14018	5	of	of	IN
18637	14018	6	defense	defense	NN
18637	14018	7	,	,	,
18637	14018	8	such	such	JJ
18637	14018	9	as	as	IN
18637	14018	10	the	the	DT
18637	14018	11	running	running	NN
18637	14018	12	of	of	IN
18637	14018	13	the	the	DT
18637	14018	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	14018	15	of	of	IN
18637	14018	16	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	14018	17	,	,	,
18637	14018	18	can	can	MD
18637	14018	19	not	not	RB
18637	14018	20	be	be	VB
18637	14018	21	heard	hear	VBN
18637	14018	22	on	on	IN
18637	14018	23	_	_	NNP
18637	14018	24	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	14018	25	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	14018	26	_	_	NNP
18637	14018	27	,	,	,
18637	14018	28	but	but	CC
18637	14018	29	must	must	MD
18637	14018	30	be	be	VB
18637	14018	31	determined	determine	VBN
18637	14018	32	at	at	IN
18637	14018	33	the	the	DT
18637	14018	34	trial	trial	NN
18637	14018	35	.	.	.
18637	14019	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14019	2	209	209	CD
18637	14019	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14019	4	A	a	DT
18637	14019	5	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	14019	6	will	will	MD
18637	14019	7	,	,	,
18637	14019	8	however	however	RB
18637	14019	9	,	,	,
18637	14019	10	be	be	VB
18637	14019	11	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	14019	12	on	on	IN
18637	14019	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14019	14	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	14019	15	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	14019	16	_	_	NNP
18637	14019	17	if	if	IN
18637	14019	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14019	19	shows	show	VBZ
18637	14019	20	by	by	IN
18637	14019	21	clear	clear	JJ
18637	14019	22	and	and	CC
18637	14019	23	satisfactory	satisfactory	JJ
18637	14019	24	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	14019	25	that	that	IN
18637	14019	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14019	27	was	be	VBD
18637	14019	28	outside	outside	IN
18637	14019	29	the	the	DT
18637	14019	30	demanding	demand	VBG
18637	14019	31	State	State	NNP
18637	14019	32	at	at	IN
18637	14019	33	the	the	DT
18637	14019	34	time	time	NN
18637	14019	35	of	of	IN
18637	14019	36	the	the	DT
18637	14019	37	crime	crime	NN
18637	14019	38	.	.	.
18637	14020	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14020	2	210	210	CD
18637	14020	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14020	4	If	if	IN
18637	14020	5	,	,	,
18637	14020	6	however	however	RB
18637	14020	7	,	,	,
18637	14020	8	the	the	DT
18637	14020	9	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	14020	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	14020	11	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	14020	12	,	,	,
18637	14020	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14020	14	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	14020	15	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	14020	16	_	_	NNP
18637	14020	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	14020	18	not	not	RB
18637	14020	19	a	a	DT
18637	14020	20	proper	proper	JJ
18637	14020	21	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	14020	22	to	to	TO
18637	14020	23	try	try	VB
18637	14020	24	the	the	DT
18637	14020	25	question	question	NN
18637	14020	26	of	of	IN
18637	14020	27	alibi	alibi	NN
18637	14020	28	.	.	.
18637	14021	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14021	2	211	211	CD
18637	14021	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14021	4	TRIAL	trial	NN
18637	14021	5	OF	of	IN
18637	14021	6	FUGITIVE	fugitive	NN
18637	14021	7	AFTER	after	IN
18637	14021	8	REMOVAL	REMOVAL	NNP
18637	14021	9	There	there	EX
18637	14021	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	14021	11	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	14021	12	in	in	IN
18637	14021	13	the	the	DT
18637	14021	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14021	15	or	or	CC
18637	14021	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	14021	17	of	of	IN
18637	14021	18	the	the	DT
18637	14021	19	United	United	NNP
18637	14021	20	States	States	NNP
18637	14021	21	which	which	WDT
18637	14021	22	exempts	exempt	VBZ
18637	14021	23	an	an	DT
18637	14021	24	offender	offender	NN
18637	14021	25	,	,	,
18637	14021	26	brought	bring	VBN
18637	14021	27	before	before	RB
18637	14021	28	the	the	DT
18637	14021	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	14021	30	of	of	IN
18637	14021	31	a	a	DT
18637	14021	32	State	State	NNP
18637	14021	33	for	for	IN
18637	14021	34	an	an	DT
18637	14021	35	offense	offense	NN
18637	14021	36	against	against	IN
18637	14021	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14021	38	laws	law	NNS
18637	14021	39	,	,	,
18637	14021	40	from	from	IN
18637	14021	41	trial	trial	NN
18637	14021	42	and	and	CC
18637	14021	43	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	14021	44	,	,	,
18637	14021	45	even	even	RB
18637	14021	46	though	though	IN
18637	14021	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14021	48	was	be	VBD
18637	14021	49	brought	bring	VBN
18637	14021	50	from	from	IN
18637	14021	51	another	another	DT
18637	14021	52	State	state	NN
18637	14021	53	by	by	IN
18637	14021	54	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	14021	55	violence,[212	violence,[212	NN
18637	14021	56	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14021	57	or	or	CC
18637	14021	58	by	by	IN
18637	14021	59	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	14021	60	of	of	IN
18637	14021	61	legal	legal	JJ
18637	14021	62	process,[213	process,[213	NNP
18637	14021	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14021	64	and	and	CC
18637	14021	65	a	a	DT
18637	14021	66	fugitive	fugitive	JJ
18637	14021	67	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	14021	68	extradited	extradite	VBN
18637	14021	69	from	from	IN
18637	14021	70	another	another	DT
18637	14021	71	State	state	NN
18637	14021	72	may	may	MD
18637	14021	73	be	be	VB
18637	14021	74	tried	try	VBN
18637	14021	75	for	for	IN
18637	14021	76	an	an	DT
18637	14021	77	offense	offense	NN
18637	14021	78	other	other	JJ
18637	14021	79	than	than	IN
18637	14021	80	that	that	DT
18637	14021	81	for	for	IN
18637	14021	82	which	which	WDT
18637	14021	83	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14021	84	was	be	VBD
18637	14021	85	surrendered	surrender	VBN
18637	14021	86	.	.	.
18637	14022	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14022	2	214	214	CD
18637	14022	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14022	4	The	the	DT
18637	14022	5	rule	rule	NN
18637	14022	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	14022	7	different	different	JJ
18637	14022	8	,	,	,
18637	14022	9	however	however	RB
18637	14022	10	,	,	,
18637	14022	11	with	with	IN
18637	14022	12	respect	respect	NN
18637	14022	13	to	to	IN
18637	14022	14	fugitives	fugitive	NNS
18637	14022	15	surrendered	surrender	VBN
18637	14022	16	by	by	IN
18637	14022	17	a	a	DT
18637	14022	18	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	14022	19	government	government	NN
18637	14022	20	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	14022	21	to	to	IN
18637	14022	22	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	14022	23	.	.	.
18637	14023	1	In	in	IN
18637	14023	2	that	that	DT
18637	14023	3	case	case	NN
18637	14023	4	the	the	DT
18637	14023	5	offender	offender	NN
18637	14023	6	may	may	MD
18637	14023	7	be	be	VB
18637	14023	8	tried	try	VBN
18637	14023	9	only	only	RB
18637	14023	10	"	"	''
18637	14023	11	for	for	IN
18637	14023	12	the	the	DT
18637	14023	13	offence	offence	NN
18637	14023	14	with	with	IN
18637	14023	15	which	which	WDT
18637	14023	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14023	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	14023	18	charged	charge	VBN
18637	14023	19	in	in	IN
18637	14023	20	the	the	DT
18637	14023	21	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	14023	22	for	for	IN
18637	14023	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14023	24	extradition	extradition	NN
18637	14023	25	,	,	,
18637	14023	26	until	until	IN
18637	14023	27	a	a	DT
18637	14023	28	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	14023	29	time	time	NN
18637	14023	30	and	and	CC
18637	14023	31	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	14023	32	have	have	VBP
18637	14023	33	been	be	VBN
18637	14023	34	given	give	VBN
18637	14023	35	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14023	36	,	,	,
18637	14023	37	after	after	IN
18637	14023	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14023	39	release	release	NN
18637	14023	40	or	or	CC
18637	14023	41	trial	trial	NN
18637	14023	42	upon	upon	IN
18637	14023	43	such	such	JJ
18637	14023	44	charge	charge	NN
18637	14023	45	,	,	,
18637	14023	46	to	to	TO
18637	14023	47	return	return	VB
18637	14023	48	to	to	IN
18637	14023	49	the	the	DT
18637	14023	50	country	country	NN
18637	14023	51	from	from	IN
18637	14023	52	whose	whose	WP$
18637	14023	53	asylum	asylum	NN
18637	14023	54	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14023	55	had	have	VBD
18637	14023	56	been	be	VBN
18637	14023	57	forcibly	forcibly	RB
18637	14023	58	taken	take	VBN
18637	14023	59	under	under	IN
18637	14023	60	those	those	DT
18637	14023	61	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	14023	62	.	.	.
18637	14024	1	"	"	``
18637	14024	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14024	3	215	215	CD
18637	14024	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14024	5	Clause	clause	NN
18637	14024	6	3	3	CD
18637	14024	7	.	.	.
18637	14025	1	No	no	DT
18637	14025	2	Person	person	NN
18637	14025	3	held	hold	VBN
18637	14025	4	to	to	IN
18637	14025	5	Service	Service	NNP
18637	14025	6	or	or	CC
18637	14025	7	Labour	Labour	NNP
18637	14025	8	in	in	IN
18637	14025	9	one	one	CD
18637	14025	10	State	state	NN
18637	14025	11	,	,	,
18637	14025	12	under	under	IN
18637	14025	13	the	the	DT
18637	14025	14	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	14025	15	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	14025	16	,	,	,
18637	14025	17	escaping	escape	VBG
18637	14025	18	into	into	IN
18637	14025	19	another	another	DT
18637	14025	20	,	,	,
18637	14025	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	14025	22	,	,	,
18637	14025	23	in	in	IN
18637	14025	24	Consequence	Consequence	NNP
18637	14025	25	of	of	IN
18637	14025	26	any	any	DT
18637	14025	27	Law	Law	NNP
18637	14025	28	or	or	CC
18637	14025	29	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	14025	30	therein	therein	RB
18637	14025	31	,	,	,
18637	14025	32	be	be	VB
18637	14025	33	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	14025	34	from	from	IN
18637	14025	35	such	such	JJ
18637	14025	36	Service	Service	NNP
18637	14025	37	or	or	CC
18637	14025	38	Labour	Labour	NNP
18637	14025	39	,	,	,
18637	14025	40	but	but	CC
18637	14025	41	shall	shall	MD
18637	14025	42	be	be	VB
18637	14025	43	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	14025	44	up	up	RP
18637	14025	45	on	on	IN
18637	14025	46	Claim	Claim	NNP
18637	14025	47	of	of	IN
18637	14025	48	the	the	DT
18637	14025	49	Party	Party	NNP
18637	14025	50	to	to	TO
18637	14025	51	whom	whom	WP
18637	14025	52	such	such	JJ
18637	14025	53	Service	Service	NNP
18637	14025	54	or	or	CC
18637	14025	55	Labour	Labour	NNP
18637	14025	56	may	may	MD
18637	14025	57	be	be	VB
18637	14025	58	due	due	JJ
18637	14025	59	.	.	.
18637	14026	1	This	this	DT
18637	14026	2	clause	clause	NN
18637	14026	3	contemplated	contemplate	VBD
18637	14026	4	the	the	DT
18637	14026	5	existence	existence	NN
18637	14026	6	of	of	IN
18637	14026	7	a	a	DT
18637	14026	8	positive	positive	JJ
18637	14026	9	unqualified	unqualified	JJ
18637	14026	10	right	right	NN
18637	14026	11	on	on	IN
18637	14026	12	the	the	DT
18637	14026	13	part	part	NN
18637	14026	14	of	of	IN
18637	14026	15	the	the	DT
18637	14026	16	owner	owner	NN
18637	14026	17	of	of	IN
18637	14026	18	a	a	DT
18637	14026	19	slave	slave	NN
18637	14026	20	which	which	WDT
18637	14026	21	no	no	DT
18637	14026	22	State	State	NNP
18637	14026	23	law	law	NN
18637	14026	24	could	could	MD
18637	14026	25	in	in	IN
18637	14026	26	any	any	DT
18637	14026	27	way	way	NN
18637	14026	28	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	14026	29	,	,	,
18637	14026	30	control	control	NN
18637	14026	31	or	or	CC
18637	14026	32	restrain	restrain	NN
18637	14026	33	.	.	.
18637	14027	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	14027	2	the	the	DT
18637	14027	3	owner	owner	NN
18637	14027	4	of	of	IN
18637	14027	5	a	a	DT
18637	14027	6	slave	slave	NN
18637	14027	7	had	have	VBD
18637	14027	8	the	the	DT
18637	14027	9	same	same	JJ
18637	14027	10	right	right	NN
18637	14027	11	to	to	TO
18637	14027	12	seize	seize	VB
18637	14027	13	and	and	CC
18637	14027	14	repossess	repossess	VB
18637	14027	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14027	16	in	in	IN
18637	14027	17	another	another	DT
18637	14027	18	State	State	NNP
18637	14027	19	,	,	,
18637	14027	20	as	as	IN
18637	14027	21	the	the	DT
18637	14027	22	local	local	JJ
18637	14027	23	laws	law	NNS
18637	14027	24	of	of	IN
18637	14027	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14027	26	own	own	JJ
18637	14027	27	State	state	NN
18637	14027	28	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	14027	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	14027	30	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14027	31	,	,	,
18637	14027	32	and	and	CC
18637	14027	33	a	a	DT
18637	14027	34	State	State	NNP
18637	14027	35	law	law	NN
18637	14027	36	which	which	WDT
18637	14027	37	penalized	penalize	VBD
18637	14027	38	such	such	JJ
18637	14027	39	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	14027	40	was	be	VBD
18637	14027	41	held	hold	VBN
18637	14027	42	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	14027	43	.	.	.
18637	14028	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14028	2	216	216	CD
18637	14028	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14028	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14028	5	had	have	VBD
18637	14028	6	the	the	DT
18637	14028	7	power	power	NN
18637	14028	8	and	and	CC
18637	14028	9	the	the	DT
18637	14028	10	duty	duty	NN
18637	14028	11	,	,	,
18637	14028	12	which	which	WDT
18637	14028	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14028	14	exercised	exercise	VBD
18637	14028	15	by	by	IN
18637	14028	16	the	the	DT
18637	14028	17	act	act	NN
18637	14028	18	of	of	IN
18637	14028	19	February	February	NNP
18637	14028	20	12	12	CD
18637	14028	21	,	,	,
18637	14028	22	1793,[217	1793,[217	CD
18637	14028	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14028	24	to	to	TO
18637	14028	25	carry	carry	VB
18637	14028	26	into	into	IN
18637	14028	27	effect	effect	NN
18637	14028	28	the	the	DT
18637	14028	29	rights	right	NNS
18637	14028	30	given	give	VBN
18637	14028	31	by	by	IN
18637	14028	32	this	this	DT
18637	14028	33	Section,[218	section,[218	CD
18637	14028	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14028	35	and	and	CC
18637	14028	36	the	the	DT
18637	14028	37	States	States	NNPS
18637	14028	38	had	have	VBD
18637	14028	39	no	no	DT
18637	14028	40	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	14028	41	power	power	NN
18637	14028	42	to	to	TO
18637	14028	43	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	14028	44	on	on	IN
18637	14028	45	the	the	DT
18637	14028	46	subject	subject	NN
18637	14028	47	.	.	.
18637	14029	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14029	2	219	219	CD
18637	14029	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14029	4	However	however	RB
18637	14029	5	,	,	,
18637	14029	6	a	a	DT
18637	14029	7	State	state	NN
18637	14029	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	14029	9	providing	provide	VBG
18637	14029	10	a	a	DT
18637	14029	11	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	14029	12	for	for	IN
18637	14029	13	harboring	harbor	VBG
18637	14029	14	a	a	DT
18637	14029	15	fugitive	fugitive	JJ
18637	14029	16	slave	slave	NN
18637	14029	17	was	be	VBD
18637	14029	18	held	hold	VBN
18637	14029	19	not	not	RB
18637	14029	20	to	to	TO
18637	14029	21	conflict	conflict	VB
18637	14029	22	with	with	IN
18637	14029	23	this	this	DT
18637	14029	24	clause	clause	NN
18637	14029	25	since	since	IN
18637	14029	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14029	27	did	do	VBD
18637	14029	28	not	not	RB
18637	14029	29	affect	affect	VB
18637	14029	30	the	the	DT
18637	14029	31	right	right	NN
18637	14029	32	or	or	CC
18637	14029	33	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	14029	34	either	either	CC
18637	14029	35	of	of	IN
18637	14029	36	the	the	DT
18637	14029	37	master	master	NN
18637	14029	38	or	or	CC
18637	14029	39	the	the	DT
18637	14029	40	slave	slave	NN
18637	14029	41	;	;	:
18637	14029	42	by	by	IN
18637	14029	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14029	44	the	the	DT
18637	14029	45	State	State	NNP
18637	14029	46	simply	simply	RB
18637	14029	47	prescribed	prescribe	VBD
18637	14029	48	a	a	DT
18637	14029	49	rule	rule	NN
18637	14029	50	of	of	IN
18637	14029	51	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	14029	52	for	for	IN
18637	14029	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14029	54	own	own	JJ
18637	14029	55	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	14029	56	in	in	IN
18637	14029	57	the	the	DT
18637	14029	58	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	14029	59	of	of	IN
18637	14029	60	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14029	61	police	police	NN
18637	14029	62	power	power	NN
18637	14029	63	.	.	.
18637	14030	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14030	2	220	220	CD
18637	14030	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14030	4	Section	section	NN
18637	14030	5	3	3	CD
18637	14030	6	.	.	.
18637	14031	1	New	New	NNP
18637	14031	2	States	States	NNP
18637	14031	3	may	may	MD
18637	14031	4	be	be	VB
18637	14031	5	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	14031	6	by	by	IN
18637	14031	7	the	the	DT
18637	14031	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14031	9	into	into	IN
18637	14031	10	this	this	DT
18637	14031	11	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14031	12	;	;	:
18637	14031	13	but	but	CC
18637	14031	14	no	no	DT
18637	14031	15	new	new	JJ
18637	14031	16	State	State	NNP
18637	14031	17	shall	shall	MD
18637	14031	18	be	be	VB
18637	14031	19	formed	form	VBN
18637	14031	20	or	or	CC
18637	14031	21	erected	erect	VBN
18637	14031	22	within	within	IN
18637	14031	23	the	the	DT
18637	14031	24	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	14031	25	of	of	IN
18637	14031	26	any	any	DT
18637	14031	27	other	other	JJ
18637	14031	28	State	state	NN
18637	14031	29	;	;	:
18637	14031	30	nor	nor	CC
18637	14031	31	any	any	DT
18637	14031	32	State	state	NN
18637	14031	33	be	be	VB
18637	14031	34	formed	form	VBN
18637	14031	35	by	by	IN
18637	14031	36	the	the	DT
18637	14031	37	Junction	Junction	NNP
18637	14031	38	of	of	IN
18637	14031	39	two	two	CD
18637	14031	40	or	or	CC
18637	14031	41	more	more	JJR
18637	14031	42	States	States	NNPS
18637	14031	43	,	,	,
18637	14031	44	or	or	CC
18637	14031	45	Parts	Parts	NNPS
18637	14031	46	of	of	IN
18637	14031	47	States	States	NNP
18637	14031	48	,	,	,
18637	14031	49	without	without	IN
18637	14031	50	the	the	DT
18637	14031	51	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	14031	52	of	of	IN
18637	14031	53	the	the	DT
18637	14031	54	Legislatures	Legislatures	NNPS
18637	14031	55	of	of	IN
18637	14031	56	the	the	DT
18637	14031	57	States	States	NNP
18637	14031	58	concerned	concern	VBD
18637	14031	59	as	as	RB
18637	14031	60	well	well	RB
18637	14031	61	as	as	IN
18637	14031	62	of	of	IN
18637	14031	63	the	the	DT
18637	14031	64	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14031	65	.	.	.
18637	14032	1	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	14032	2	of	of	IN
18637	14032	3	the	the	DT
18637	14032	4	Equality	Equality	NNP
18637	14032	5	of	of	IN
18637	14032	6	the	the	DT
18637	14032	7	States	States	NNPS
18637	14032	8	"	"	''
18637	14032	9	Equality	Equality	NNP
18637	14032	10	of	of	IN
18637	14032	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	14032	12	right	right	NN
18637	14032	13	and	and	CC
18637	14032	14	power	power	NN
18637	14032	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	14032	16	the	the	DT
18637	14032	17	condition	condition	NN
18637	14032	18	of	of	IN
18637	14032	19	all	all	PDT
18637	14032	20	the	the	DT
18637	14032	21	States	States	NNPS
18637	14032	22	of	of	IN
18637	14032	23	the	the	DT
18637	14032	24	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14032	25	,	,	,
18637	14032	26	old	old	JJ
18637	14032	27	and	and	CC
18637	14032	28	new	new	JJ
18637	14032	29	.	.	.
18637	14033	1	"	"	``
18637	14033	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14033	3	221	221	CD
18637	14033	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14033	5	This	this	DT
18637	14033	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	14033	7	,	,	,
18637	14033	8	now	now	RB
18637	14033	9	a	a	DT
18637	14033	10	truism	truism	NN
18637	14033	11	of	of	IN
18637	14033	12	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	14033	13	Law	Law	NNP
18637	14033	14	,	,	,
18637	14033	15	did	do	VBD
18637	14033	16	not	not	RB
18637	14033	17	find	find	VB
18637	14033	18	favor	favor	NN
18637	14033	19	in	in	IN
18637	14033	20	the	the	DT
18637	14033	21	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	14033	22	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	14033	23	.	.	.
18637	14034	1	That	that	DT
18637	14034	2	body	body	NN
18637	14034	3	struck	strike	VBD
18637	14034	4	out	out	RP
18637	14034	5	from	from	IN
18637	14034	6	this	this	DT
18637	14034	7	section	section	NN
18637	14034	8	,	,	,
18637	14034	9	as	as	IN
18637	14034	10	reported	report	VBN
18637	14034	11	by	by	IN
18637	14034	12	the	the	DT
18637	14034	13	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	14034	14	on	on	IN
18637	14034	15	Detail	Detail	NNP
18637	14034	16	,	,	,
18637	14034	17	two	two	CD
18637	14034	18	sections	section	NNS
18637	14034	19	to	to	IN
18637	14034	20	the	the	DT
18637	14034	21	effect	effect	NN
18637	14034	22	that	that	IN
18637	14034	23	"	"	``
18637	14034	24	...	...	NFP
18637	14034	25	new	new	JJ
18637	14034	26	States	state	NNS
18637	14034	27	shall	shall	MD
18637	14034	28	be	be	VB
18637	14034	29	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	14034	30	on	on	IN
18637	14034	31	the	the	DT
18637	14034	32	same	same	JJ
18637	14034	33	terms	term	NNS
18637	14034	34	with	with	IN
18637	14034	35	the	the	DT
18637	14034	36	original	original	JJ
18637	14034	37	States	state	NNS
18637	14034	38	.	.	.
18637	14035	1	But	but	CC
18637	14035	2	the	the	DT
18637	14035	3	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	14035	4	may	may	MD
18637	14035	5	make	make	VB
18637	14035	6	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	14035	7	with	with	IN
18637	14035	8	the	the	DT
18637	14035	9	new	new	JJ
18637	14035	10	States	States	NNPS
18637	14035	11	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	14035	12	the	the	DT
18637	14035	13	public	public	JJ
18637	14035	14	debt	debt	NN
18637	14035	15	which	which	WDT
18637	14035	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	14035	17	be	be	VB
18637	14035	18	subsisting	subsist	VBG
18637	14035	19	.	.	.
18637	14036	1	"	"	``
18637	14036	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14036	3	222	222	CD
18637	14036	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14036	5	Opposing	oppose	VBG
18637	14036	6	this	this	DT
18637	14036	7	action	action	NN
18637	14036	8	,	,	,
18637	14036	9	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	14036	10	insisted	insist	VBD
18637	14036	11	that	that	IN
18637	14036	12	"	"	``
18637	14036	13	the	the	DT
18637	14036	14	Western	Western	NNP
18637	14036	15	States	States	NNPS
18637	14036	16	neither	neither	CC
18637	14036	17	would	would	MD
18637	14036	18	nor	nor	CC
18637	14036	19	ought	ought	MD
18637	14036	20	to	to	TO
18637	14036	21	submit	submit	VB
18637	14036	22	to	to	IN
18637	14036	23	a	a	DT
18637	14036	24	union	union	NN
18637	14036	25	which	which	WDT
18637	14036	26	degraded	degrade	VBD
18637	14036	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14036	28	from	from	IN
18637	14036	29	an	an	DT
18637	14036	30	equal	equal	JJ
18637	14036	31	rank	rank	NN
18637	14036	32	with	with	IN
18637	14036	33	the	the	DT
18637	14036	34	other	other	JJ
18637	14036	35	States	States	NNPS
18637	14036	36	.	.	.
18637	14037	1	"	"	``
18637	14037	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14037	3	223	223	CD
18637	14037	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14037	5	Nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
18637	14037	6	,	,	,
18637	14037	7	after	after	IN
18637	14037	8	further	further	JJ
18637	14037	9	expressions	expression	NNS
18637	14037	10	of	of	IN
18637	14037	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	14037	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14037	13	pro	pro	JJ
18637	14037	14	_	_	NNP
18637	14037	15	and	and	CC
18637	14037	16	_	_	NNP
18637	14037	17	con	con	XX
18637	14037	18	_	_	NNP
18637	14037	19	,	,	,
18637	14037	20	the	the	DT
18637	14037	21	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	14037	22	voted	vote	VBD
18637	14037	23	nine	nine	CD
18637	14037	24	States	States	NNPS
18637	14037	25	to	to	IN
18637	14037	26	two	two	CD
18637	14037	27	to	to	TO
18637	14037	28	delete	delete	VB
18637	14037	29	the	the	DT
18637	14037	30	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	14037	31	of	of	IN
18637	14037	32	equality	equality	NN
18637	14037	33	.	.	.
18637	14038	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14038	2	224	224	CD
18637	14038	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14038	4	Prior	prior	RB
18637	14038	5	to	to	IN
18637	14038	6	this	this	DT
18637	14038	7	time	time	NN
18637	14038	8	,	,	,
18637	14038	9	however	however	RB
18637	14038	10	,	,	,
18637	14038	11	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	14038	12	and	and	CC
18637	14038	13	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	14038	14	had	have	VBD
18637	14038	15	ceded	cede	VBN
18637	14038	16	to	to	IN
18637	14038	17	the	the	DT
18637	14038	18	United	United	NNP
18637	14038	19	States	States	NNP
18637	14038	20	large	large	JJ
18637	14038	21	territories	territory	NNS
18637	14038	22	held	hold	VBN
18637	14038	23	by	by	IN
18637	14038	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14038	25	,	,	,
18637	14038	26	upon	upon	IN
18637	14038	27	condition	condition	NN
18637	14038	28	that	that	IN
18637	14038	29	new	new	JJ
18637	14038	30	States	state	NNS
18637	14038	31	should	should	MD
18637	14038	32	be	be	VB
18637	14038	33	formed	form	VBN
18637	14038	34	therefrom	therefrom	JJ
18637	14038	35	,	,	,
18637	14038	36	and	and	CC
18637	14038	37	admitted	admit	VBD
18637	14038	38	to	to	IN
18637	14038	39	the	the	DT
18637	14038	40	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14038	41	on	on	IN
18637	14038	42	an	an	DT
18637	14038	43	equal	equal	JJ
18637	14038	44	footing	footing	NN
18637	14038	45	with	with	IN
18637	14038	46	the	the	DT
18637	14038	47	original	original	JJ
18637	14038	48	States	state	NNS
18637	14038	49	.	.	.
18637	14039	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14039	2	225	225	CD
18637	14039	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14039	4	With	with	IN
18637	14039	5	the	the	DT
18637	14039	6	admission	admission	NN
18637	14039	7	of	of	IN
18637	14039	8	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	14039	9	in	in	IN
18637	14039	10	1812	1812	CD
18637	14039	11	,	,	,
18637	14039	12	the	the	DT
18637	14039	13	principle	principle	NN
18637	14039	14	of	of	IN
18637	14039	15	equality	equality	NN
18637	14039	16	was	be	VBD
18637	14039	17	extended	extend	VBN
18637	14039	18	to	to	IN
18637	14039	19	States	States	NNP
18637	14039	20	created	create	VBD
18637	14039	21	out	out	IN
18637	14039	22	of	of	IN
18637	14039	23	territory	territory	NN
18637	14039	24	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	14039	25	from	from	IN
18637	14039	26	a	a	DT
18637	14039	27	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	14039	28	power	power	NN
18637	14039	29	.	.	.
18637	14040	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14040	2	226	226	CD
18637	14040	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14040	4	By	by	IN
18637	14040	5	the	the	DT
18637	14040	6	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	14040	7	Resolution	Resolution	NNP
18637	14040	8	of	of	IN
18637	14040	9	December	December	NNP
18637	14040	10	29	29	CD
18637	14040	11	,	,	,
18637	14040	12	1845	1845	CD
18637	14040	13	,	,	,
18637	14040	14	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	14040	15	"	"	''
18637	14040	16	was	be	VBD
18637	14040	17	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	14040	18	into	into	IN
18637	14040	19	the	the	DT
18637	14040	20	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14040	21	on	on	IN
18637	14040	22	an	an	DT
18637	14040	23	equal	equal	JJ
18637	14040	24	footing	footing	NN
18637	14040	25	with	with	IN
18637	14040	26	the	the	DT
18637	14040	27	original	original	JJ
18637	14040	28	States	state	NNS
18637	14040	29	in	in	IN
18637	14040	30	all	all	DT
18637	14040	31	respects	respect	NNS
18637	14040	32	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	14040	33	.	.	.
18637	14041	1	"	"	``
18637	14041	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14041	3	227	227	CD
18637	14041	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14041	5	Again	again	RB
18637	14041	6	and	and	CC
18637	14041	7	again	again	RB
18637	14041	8	,	,	,
18637	14041	9	in	in	IN
18637	14041	10	adjudicating	adjudicate	VBG
18637	14041	11	the	the	DT
18637	14041	12	rights	right	NNS
18637	14041	13	and	and	CC
18637	14041	14	duties	duty	NNS
18637	14041	15	of	of	IN
18637	14041	16	States	States	NNP
18637	14041	17	admitted	admit	VBD
18637	14041	18	after	after	IN
18637	14041	19	1789	1789	CD
18637	14041	20	,	,	,
18637	14041	21	the	the	DT
18637	14041	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14041	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14041	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	14041	25	referred	refer	VBN
18637	14041	26	to	to	IN
18637	14041	27	the	the	DT
18637	14041	28	condition	condition	NN
18637	14041	29	of	of	IN
18637	14041	30	equality	equality	NN
18637	14041	31	as	as	IN
18637	14041	32	if	if	IN
18637	14041	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14041	34	were	be	VBD
18637	14041	35	an	an	DT
18637	14041	36	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	14041	37	attribute	attribute	NN
18637	14041	38	of	of	IN
18637	14041	39	the	the	DT
18637	14041	40	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	14041	41	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14041	42	.	.	.
18637	14042	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14042	2	228	228	CD
18637	14042	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14042	4	Finally	finally	RB
18637	14042	5	,	,	,
18637	14042	6	in	in	IN
18637	14042	7	1911	1911	CD
18637	14042	8	,	,	,
18637	14042	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14042	10	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
18637	14042	11	a	a	DT
18637	14042	12	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	14042	13	on	on	IN
18637	14042	14	the	the	DT
18637	14042	15	change	change	NN
18637	14042	16	of	of	IN
18637	14042	17	location	location	NN
18637	14042	18	of	of	IN
18637	14042	19	the	the	DT
18637	14042	20	State	State	NNP
18637	14042	21	capital	capital	NN
18637	14042	22	,	,	,
18637	14042	23	which	which	WDT
18637	14042	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14042	25	had	have	VBD
18637	14042	26	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	14042	27	as	as	IN
18637	14042	28	a	a	DT
18637	14042	29	condition	condition	NN
18637	14042	30	for	for	IN
18637	14042	31	the	the	DT
18637	14042	32	admission	admission	NN
18637	14042	33	of	of	IN
18637	14042	34	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	14042	35	,	,	,
18637	14042	36	on	on	IN
18637	14042	37	the	the	DT
18637	14042	38	ground	ground	NN
18637	14042	39	that	that	IN
18637	14042	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14042	41	may	may	MD
18637	14042	42	not	not	RB
18637	14042	43	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	14042	44	in	in	IN
18637	14042	45	an	an	DT
18637	14042	46	enabling	enable	VBG
18637	14042	47	act	act	NN
18637	14042	48	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	14042	49	relating	relate	VBG
18637	14042	50	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	14042	51	to	to	IN
18637	14042	52	matters	matter	NNS
18637	14042	53	under	under	IN
18637	14042	54	State	State	NNP
18637	14042	55	control	control	NN
18637	14042	56	.	.	.
18637	14043	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14043	2	229	229	CD
18637	14043	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14043	4	In	in	IN
18637	14043	5	an	an	DT
18637	14043	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	14043	7	,	,	,
18637	14043	8	from	from	IN
18637	14043	9	which	which	WDT
18637	14043	10	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	14043	11	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	14043	12	and	and	CC
18637	14043	13	McKenna	McKenna	NNP
18637	14043	14	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	14043	15	,	,	,
18637	14043	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14043	17	Lurton	Lurton	NNP
18637	14043	18	argued	argue	VBD
18637	14043	19	:	:	:
18637	14043	20	"	"	``
18637	14043	21	The	the	DT
18637	14043	22	power	power	NN
18637	14043	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	14043	24	to	to	TO
18637	14043	25	admit	admit	VB
18637	14043	26	'	'	``
18637	14043	27	new	new	JJ
18637	14043	28	States	States	NNPS
18637	14043	29	into	into	IN
18637	14043	30	_	_	NNP
18637	14043	31	this	this	DT
18637	14043	32	_	_	NNP
18637	14043	33	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14043	34	.	.	.
18637	14043	35	'	'	''
18637	14044	1	'	'	``
18637	14044	2	This	this	DT
18637	14044	3	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14044	4	'	'	''
18637	14044	5	was	be	VBD
18637	14044	6	and	and	CC
18637	14044	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	14044	8	a	a	DT
18637	14044	9	union	union	NN
18637	14044	10	of	of	IN
18637	14044	11	States	States	NNP
18637	14044	12	,	,	,
18637	14044	13	equal	equal	JJ
18637	14044	14	in	in	IN
18637	14044	15	power	power	NN
18637	14044	16	,	,	,
18637	14044	17	dignity	dignity	NN
18637	14044	18	and	and	CC
18637	14044	19	authority	authority	NN
18637	14044	20	,	,	,
18637	14044	21	each	each	DT
18637	14044	22	competent	competent	JJ
18637	14044	23	to	to	TO
18637	14044	24	exert	exert	VB
18637	14044	25	that	that	DT
18637	14044	26	residuum	residuum	NN
18637	14044	27	of	of	IN
18637	14044	28	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	14044	29	not	not	RB
18637	14044	30	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	14044	31	to	to	IN
18637	14044	32	the	the	DT
18637	14044	33	United	United	NNP
18637	14044	34	States	States	NNP
18637	14044	35	by	by	IN
18637	14044	36	the	the	DT
18637	14044	37	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14044	38	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14044	39	.	.	.
18637	14045	1	To	to	TO
18637	14045	2	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	14045	3	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	14045	4	would	would	MD
18637	14045	5	be	be	VB
18637	14045	6	to	to	TO
18637	14045	7	say	say	VB
18637	14045	8	that	that	IN
18637	14045	9	the	the	DT
18637	14045	10	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14045	11	,	,	,
18637	14045	12	through	through	IN
18637	14045	13	the	the	DT
18637	14045	14	power	power	NN
18637	14045	15	of	of	IN
18637	14045	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14045	17	to	to	TO
18637	14045	18	admit	admit	VB
18637	14045	19	new	new	JJ
18637	14045	20	States	state	NNS
18637	14045	21	,	,	,
18637	14045	22	might	may	MD
18637	14045	23	come	come	VB
18637	14045	24	to	to	TO
18637	14045	25	be	be	VB
18637	14045	26	a	a	DT
18637	14045	27	union	union	NN
18637	14045	28	of	of	IN
18637	14045	29	States	States	NNP
18637	14045	30	unequal	unequal	JJ
18637	14045	31	in	in	IN
18637	14045	32	power	power	NN
18637	14045	33	,	,	,
18637	14045	34	as	as	IN
18637	14045	35	including	include	VBG
18637	14045	36	States	States	NNPS
18637	14045	37	whose	whose	WP$
18637	14045	38	powers	power	NNS
18637	14045	39	were	be	VBD
18637	14045	40	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	14045	41	only	only	RB
18637	14045	42	by	by	IN
18637	14045	43	the	the	DT
18637	14045	44	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14045	45	,	,	,
18637	14045	46	with	with	IN
18637	14045	47	others	other	NNS
18637	14045	48	whose	whose	WP$
18637	14045	49	powers	power	NNS
18637	14045	50	had	have	VBD
18637	14045	51	been	be	VBN
18637	14045	52	further	further	RB
18637	14045	53	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	14045	54	by	by	IN
18637	14045	55	an	an	DT
18637	14045	56	act	act	NN
18637	14045	57	of	of	IN
18637	14045	58	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14045	59	accepted	accept	VBD
18637	14045	60	as	as	IN
18637	14045	61	a	a	DT
18637	14045	62	condition	condition	NN
18637	14045	63	of	of	IN
18637	14045	64	admission	admission	NN
18637	14045	65	.	.	.
18637	14046	1	"	"	``
18637	14046	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14046	3	230	230	CD
18637	14046	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14046	5	EARLIER	earlier	JJ
18637	14046	6	SCOPE	scope	NN
18637	14046	7	OF	of	IN
18637	14046	8	THE	the	DT
18637	14046	9	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNP
18637	14046	10	Until	until	IN
18637	14046	11	recently	recently	RB
18637	14046	12	,	,	,
18637	14046	13	however	however	RB
18637	14046	14	,	,	,
18637	14046	15	the	the	DT
18637	14046	16	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	14046	17	of	of	IN
18637	14046	18	equality	equality	NN
18637	14046	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	14046	20	applied	apply	VBN
18637	14046	21	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	14046	22	to	to	IN
18637	14046	23	political	political	JJ
18637	14046	24	standing	standing	NN
18637	14046	25	and	and	CC
18637	14046	26	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	14046	27	rather	rather	RB
18637	14046	28	than	than	IN
18637	14046	29	to	to	IN
18637	14046	30	economic	economic	JJ
18637	14046	31	or	or	CC
18637	14046	32	property	property	NN
18637	14046	33	rights	right	NNS
18637	14046	34	.	.	.
18637	14047	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14047	2	231	231	CD
18637	14047	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14047	4	Broadly	broadly	RB
18637	14047	5	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	14047	6	,	,	,
18637	14047	7	every	every	DT
18637	14047	8	new	new	JJ
18637	14047	9	State	State	NNP
18637	14047	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	14047	11	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	14047	12	to	to	TO
18637	14047	13	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	14047	14	all	all	PDT
18637	14047	15	the	the	DT
18637	14047	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	14047	17	of	of	IN
18637	14047	18	government	government	NN
18637	14047	19	which	which	WDT
18637	14047	20	belong	belong	VBP
18637	14047	21	to	to	IN
18637	14047	22	the	the	DT
18637	14047	23	original	original	JJ
18637	14047	24	States	States	NNP
18637	14047	25	of	of	IN
18637	14047	26	the	the	DT
18637	14047	27	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14047	28	.	.	.
18637	14048	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14048	2	232	232	CD
18637	14048	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14048	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14048	5	acquires	acquire	VBZ
18637	14048	6	general	general	JJ
18637	14048	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14048	8	,	,	,
18637	14048	9	civil	civil	JJ
18637	14048	10	and	and	CC
18637	14048	11	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	14048	12	,	,	,
18637	14048	13	for	for	IN
18637	14048	14	the	the	DT
18637	14048	15	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	14048	16	of	of	IN
18637	14048	17	public	public	JJ
18637	14048	18	order	order	NN
18637	14048	19	,	,	,
18637	14048	20	and	and	CC
18637	14048	21	the	the	DT
18637	14048	22	protection	protection	NN
18637	14048	23	of	of	IN
18637	14048	24	persons	person	NNS
18637	14048	25	and	and	CC
18637	14048	26	property	property	NN
18637	14048	27	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	14048	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14048	29	limits	limit	NNS
18637	14048	30	except	except	IN
18637	14048	31	where	where	WRB
18637	14048	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14048	33	has	have	VBZ
18637	14048	34	ceded	cede	VBN
18637	14048	35	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	14048	36	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14048	37	to	to	IN
18637	14048	38	the	the	DT
18637	14048	39	United	United	NNP
18637	14048	40	States	States	NNP
18637	14048	41	.	.	.
18637	14049	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14049	2	233	233	CD
18637	14049	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14049	4	The	the	DT
18637	14049	5	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	14049	6	authority	authority	NN
18637	14049	7	of	of	IN
18637	14049	8	a	a	DT
18637	14049	9	newly	newly	RB
18637	14049	10	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	14049	11	State	state	NN
18637	14049	12	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	14049	13	over	over	IN
18637	14049	14	federally	federally	RB
18637	14049	15	owned	own	VBN
18637	14049	16	land	land	NN
18637	14049	17	within	within	IN
18637	14049	18	the	the	DT
18637	14049	19	State	State	NNP
18637	14049	20	,	,	,
18637	14049	21	to	to	IN
18637	14049	22	the	the	DT
18637	14049	23	same	same	JJ
18637	14049	24	extent	extent	NN
18637	14049	25	as	as	IN
18637	14049	26	over	over	IN
18637	14049	27	similar	similar	JJ
18637	14049	28	property	property	NN
18637	14049	29	held	hold	VBN
18637	14049	30	by	by	IN
18637	14049	31	private	private	JJ
18637	14049	32	owners	owner	NNS
18637	14049	33	,	,	,
18637	14049	34	save	save	VB
18637	14049	35	that	that	IN
18637	14049	36	the	the	DT
18637	14049	37	State	State	NNP
18637	14049	38	can	can	MD
18637	14049	39	enact	enact	VB
18637	14049	40	no	no	DT
18637	14049	41	law	law	NN
18637	14049	42	which	which	WDT
18637	14049	43	would	would	MD
18637	14049	44	conflict	conflict	VB
18637	14049	45	with	with	IN
18637	14049	46	the	the	DT
18637	14049	47	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	14049	48	powers	power	NNS
18637	14049	49	of	of	IN
18637	14049	50	the	the	DT
18637	14049	51	United	United	NNP
18637	14049	52	States	States	NNP
18637	14049	53	.	.	.
18637	14050	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	14050	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14050	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	14050	4	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14050	5	to	to	TO
18637	14050	6	tax	tax	VB
18637	14050	7	private	private	JJ
18637	14050	8	activities	activity	NNS
18637	14050	9	carried	carry	VBN
18637	14050	10	on	on	RP
18637	14050	11	within	within	IN
18637	14050	12	the	the	DT
18637	14050	13	public	public	JJ
18637	14050	14	domain	domain	NN
18637	14050	15	,	,	,
18637	14050	16	if	if	IN
18637	14050	17	the	the	DT
18637	14050	18	tax	tax	NN
18637	14050	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	14050	20	not	not	RB
18637	14050	21	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	14050	22	an	an	DT
18637	14050	23	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	14050	24	burden	burden	NN
18637	14050	25	on	on	IN
18637	14050	26	the	the	DT
18637	14050	27	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	14050	28	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14050	29	.	.	.
18637	14051	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14051	2	234	234	CD
18637	14051	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14051	4	Statutes	statute	NNS
18637	14051	5	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	14051	6	to	to	IN
18637	14051	7	territories	territory	NNS
18637	14051	8	,	,	,
18637	14051	9	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	14051	10	,	,	,
18637	14051	11	the	the	DT
18637	14051	12	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	14051	13	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	14051	14	Ordinance	Ordinance	NNP
18637	14051	15	of	of	IN
18637	14051	16	1787	1787	CD
18637	14051	17	,	,	,
18637	14051	18	cease	cease	VB
18637	14051	19	to	to	TO
18637	14051	20	have	have	VB
18637	14051	21	any	any	DT
18637	14051	22	operative	operative	JJ
18637	14051	23	force	force	NN
18637	14051	24	when	when	WRB
18637	14051	25	the	the	DT
18637	14051	26	territory	territory	NN
18637	14051	27	,	,	,
18637	14051	28	or	or	CC
18637	14051	29	any	any	DT
18637	14051	30	part	part	NN
18637	14051	31	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	14051	32	,	,	,
18637	14051	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	14051	34	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	14051	35	to	to	IN
18637	14051	36	the	the	DT
18637	14051	37	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14051	38	,	,	,
18637	14051	39	except	except	IN
18637	14051	40	as	as	IN
18637	14051	41	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	14051	42	by	by	IN
18637	14051	43	State	State	NNP
18637	14051	44	law	law	NN
18637	14051	45	.	.	.
18637	14052	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14052	2	235	235	CD
18637	14052	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14052	4	When	when	WRB
18637	14052	5	the	the	DT
18637	14052	6	enabling	enable	VBG
18637	14052	7	act	act	NN
18637	14052	8	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	14052	9	no	no	DT
18637	14052	10	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	14052	11	of	of	IN
18637	14052	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14052	13	as	as	IN
18637	14052	14	to	to	IN
18637	14052	15	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	14052	16	committed	commit	VBN
18637	14052	17	on	on	IN
18637	14052	18	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	14052	19	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	14052	20	by	by	IN
18637	14052	21	persons	person	NNS
18637	14052	22	other	other	JJ
18637	14052	23	than	than	IN
18637	14052	24	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	14052	25	,	,	,
18637	14052	26	State	state	NN
18637	14052	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	14052	28	are	be	VBP
18637	14052	29	vested	vest	VBN
18637	14052	30	with	with	IN
18637	14052	31	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14052	32	.	.	.
18637	14053	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14053	2	236	236	CD
18637	14053	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14053	4	But	but	CC
18637	14053	5	the	the	DT
18637	14053	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	14053	7	authority	authority	NN
18637	14053	8	of	of	IN
18637	14053	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14053	10	to	to	TO
18637	14053	11	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	14053	12	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	14053	13	with	with	IN
18637	14053	14	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	14053	15	tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	14053	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	14053	17	not	not	RB
18637	14053	18	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	14053	19	with	with	IN
18637	14053	20	the	the	DT
18637	14053	21	equality	equality	NN
18637	14053	22	of	of	IN
18637	14053	23	new	new	NNP
18637	14053	24	States,[237	States,[237	NNP
18637	14053	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14053	26	and	and	CC
18637	14053	27	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	14053	28	inserted	insert	VBN
18637	14053	29	in	in	IN
18637	14053	30	the	the	DT
18637	14053	31	New	New	NNP
18637	14053	32	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	14053	33	Enabling	Enabling	NNP
18637	14053	34	Act	Act	NNP
18637	14053	35	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	14053	36	the	the	DT
18637	14053	37	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	14053	38	of	of	IN
18637	14053	39	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	14053	40	into	into	IN
18637	14053	41	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	14053	42	territory	territory	NN
18637	14053	43	were	be	VBD
18637	14053	44	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	14053	45	valid	valid	JJ
18637	14053	46	.	.	.
18637	14054	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14054	2	238	238	CD
18637	14054	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14054	4	CITIZENSHIP	citizenship	VB
18637	14054	5	OF	of	IN
18637	14054	6	INHABITANTS	INHABITANTS	NNP
18637	14054	7	Admission	admission	NN
18637	14054	8	of	of	IN
18637	14054	9	a	a	DT
18637	14054	10	State	state	NN
18637	14054	11	on	on	IN
18637	14054	12	an	an	DT
18637	14054	13	equal	equal	JJ
18637	14054	14	footing	footing	NN
18637	14054	15	with	with	IN
18637	14054	16	the	the	DT
18637	14054	17	original	original	JJ
18637	14054	18	States	States	NNP
18637	14054	19	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	14054	20	the	the	DT
18637	14054	21	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	14054	22	as	as	IN
18637	14054	23	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	14054	24	of	of	IN
18637	14054	25	the	the	DT
18637	14054	26	United	United	NNP
18637	14054	27	States	States	NNP
18637	14054	28	of	of	IN
18637	14054	29	those	those	DT
18637	14054	30	whom	whom	WP
18637	14054	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14054	32	makes	make	VBZ
18637	14054	33	members	member	NNS
18637	14054	34	of	of	IN
18637	14054	35	the	the	DT
18637	14054	36	political	political	JJ
18637	14054	37	community	community	NN
18637	14054	38	,	,	,
18637	14054	39	and	and	CC
18637	14054	40	who	who	WP
18637	14054	41	are	be	VBP
18637	14054	42	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	14054	43	as	as	IN
18637	14054	44	such	such	JJ
18637	14054	45	in	in	IN
18637	14054	46	the	the	DT
18637	14054	47	formation	formation	NN
18637	14054	48	of	of	IN
18637	14054	49	the	the	DT
18637	14054	50	new	new	JJ
18637	14054	51	State	State	NNP
18637	14054	52	.	.	.
18637	14055	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14055	2	239	239	CD
18637	14055	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14055	4	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	14055	5	PROCEEDINGS	proceeding	NNS
18637	14055	6	Whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	14055	7	a	a	DT
18637	14055	8	territory	territory	NN
18637	14055	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	14055	10	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	14055	11	into	into	IN
18637	14055	12	the	the	DT
18637	14055	13	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14055	14	,	,	,
18637	14055	15	the	the	DT
18637	14055	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	14055	17	pending	pende	VBG
18637	14055	18	in	in	IN
18637	14055	19	the	the	DT
18637	14055	20	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	14055	21	court	court	NN
18637	14055	22	which	which	WDT
18637	14055	23	are	be	VBP
18637	14055	24	of	of	IN
18637	14055	25	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	14055	26	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14055	27	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	14055	28	are	be	VBP
18637	14055	29	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	14055	30	to	to	IN
18637	14055	31	the	the	DT
18637	14055	32	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14055	33	court	court	NN
18637	14055	34	having	have	VBG
18637	14055	35	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14055	36	over	over	IN
18637	14055	37	the	the	DT
18637	14055	38	area	area	NN
18637	14055	39	;	;	:
18637	14055	40	cases	case	NNS
18637	14055	41	not	not	RB
18637	14055	42	cognizable	cognizable	JJ
18637	14055	43	in	in	IN
18637	14055	44	the	the	DT
18637	14055	45	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14055	46	courts	court	NNS
18637	14055	47	are	be	VBP
18637	14055	48	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	14055	49	to	to	IN
18637	14055	50	the	the	DT
18637	14055	51	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	14055	52	of	of	IN
18637	14055	53	the	the	DT
18637	14055	54	new	new	JJ
18637	14055	55	State	State	NNP
18637	14055	56	,	,	,
18637	14055	57	and	and	CC
18637	14055	58	those	those	DT
18637	14055	59	over	over	IN
18637	14055	60	which	which	WDT
18637	14055	61	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14055	62	and	and	CC
18637	14055	63	State	State	NNP
18637	14055	64	courts	court	NNS
18637	14055	65	have	have	VBP
18637	14055	66	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	14055	67	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14055	68	may	may	MD
18637	14055	69	be	be	VB
18637	14055	70	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	14055	71	either	either	RB
18637	14055	72	to	to	IN
18637	14055	73	the	the	DT
18637	14055	74	State	State	NNP
18637	14055	75	or	or	CC
18637	14055	76	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14055	77	courts	court	NNS
18637	14055	78	by	by	IN
18637	14055	79	the	the	DT
18637	14055	80	party	party	NN
18637	14055	81	possessing	possess	VBG
18637	14055	82	that	that	DT
18637	14055	83	option	option	NN
18637	14055	84	under	under	IN
18637	14055	85	existing	exist	VBG
18637	14055	86	law	law	NN
18637	14055	87	.	.	.
18637	14056	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14056	2	240	240	CD
18637	14056	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14056	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	14056	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14056	6	neglected	neglect	VBD
18637	14056	7	to	to	TO
18637	14056	8	make	make	VB
18637	14056	9	provision	provision	NN
18637	14056	10	for	for	IN
18637	14056	11	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	14056	12	of	of	IN
18637	14056	13	certain	certain	JJ
18637	14056	14	pending	pende	VBG
18637	14056	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	14056	16	in	in	IN
18637	14056	17	an	an	DT
18637	14056	18	Enabling	Enabling	NNP
18637	14056	19	Act	Act	NNP
18637	14056	20	for	for	IN
18637	14056	21	the	the	DT
18637	14056	22	admission	admission	NN
18637	14056	23	of	of	IN
18637	14056	24	a	a	DT
18637	14056	25	State	State	NNP
18637	14056	26	to	to	IN
18637	14056	27	the	the	DT
18637	14056	28	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14056	29	,	,	,
18637	14056	30	a	a	DT
18637	14056	31	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	14056	32	act	act	NN
18637	14056	33	supplying	supply	VBG
18637	14056	34	the	the	DT
18637	14056	35	omission	omission	NN
18637	14056	36	was	be	VBD
18637	14056	37	held	hold	VBN
18637	14056	38	valid	valid	JJ
18637	14056	39	.	.	.
18637	14057	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14057	2	241	241	CD
18637	14057	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14057	4	After	after	IN
18637	14057	5	a	a	DT
18637	14057	6	case	case	NN
18637	14057	7	,	,	,
18637	14057	8	begun	begin	VBN
18637	14057	9	in	in	IN
18637	14057	10	a	a	DT
18637	14057	11	United	United	NNP
18637	14057	12	States	States	NNP
18637	14057	13	court	court	NN
18637	14057	14	of	of	IN
18637	14057	15	a	a	DT
18637	14057	16	territory	territory	NN
18637	14057	17	,	,	,
18637	14057	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	14057	19	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	14057	20	to	to	IN
18637	14057	21	a	a	DT
18637	14057	22	State	State	NNP
18637	14057	23	court	court	NN
18637	14057	24	under	under	IN
18637	14057	25	the	the	DT
18637	14057	26	operation	operation	NN
18637	14057	27	of	of	IN
18637	14057	28	the	the	DT
18637	14057	29	enabling	enable	VBG
18637	14057	30	act	act	NN
18637	14057	31	and	and	CC
18637	14057	32	the	the	DT
18637	14057	33	State	State	NNP
18637	14057	34	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	14057	35	,	,	,
18637	14057	36	the	the	DT
18637	14057	37	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	14057	38	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	14057	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	14057	40	governed	govern	VBN
18637	14057	41	by	by	IN
18637	14057	42	the	the	DT
18637	14057	43	State	State	NNP
18637	14057	44	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	14057	45	and	and	CC
18637	14057	46	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	14057	47	.	.	.
18637	14058	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14058	2	242	242	CD
18637	14058	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14058	4	The	the	DT
18637	14058	5	new	new	JJ
18637	14058	6	State	State	NNP
18637	14058	7	can	can	MD
18637	14058	8	not	not	RB
18637	14058	9	,	,	,
18637	14058	10	without	without	IN
18637	14058	11	the	the	DT
18637	14058	12	express	express	JJ
18637	14058	13	or	or	CC
18637	14058	14	implied	imply	VBN
18637	14058	15	assent	assent	NN
18637	14058	16	of	of	IN
18637	14058	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14058	18	,	,	,
18637	14058	19	enact	enact	VB
18637	14058	20	that	that	IN
18637	14058	21	the	the	DT
18637	14058	22	records	record	NNS
18637	14058	23	of	of	IN
18637	14058	24	the	the	DT
18637	14058	25	former	former	JJ
18637	14058	26	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	14058	27	court	court	NN
18637	14058	28	of	of	IN
18637	14058	29	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	14058	30	should	should	MD
18637	14058	31	become	become	VB
18637	14058	32	records	record	NNS
18637	14058	33	of	of	IN
18637	14058	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14058	35	own	own	JJ
18637	14058	36	courts	court	NNS
18637	14058	37	,	,	,
18637	14058	38	or	or	CC
18637	14058	39	provide	provide	VB
18637	14058	40	by	by	IN
18637	14058	41	law	law	NN
18637	14058	42	for	for	IN
18637	14058	43	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	14058	44	based	base	VBN
18637	14058	45	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	14058	46	.	.	.
18637	14059	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14059	2	243	243	CD
18637	14059	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14059	4	PROPERTY	property	NN
18637	14059	5	RIGHTS	right	NNS
18637	14059	6	:	:	:
18637	14059	7	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	14059	8	STATES	STATES	NNP
18637	14059	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14059	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14059	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14059	12	TEXAS	TEXAS	NNP
18637	14059	13	Holding	Holding	NNP
18637	14059	14	that	that	IN
18637	14059	15	a	a	DT
18637	14059	16	"	"	``
18637	14059	17	mere	mere	JJ
18637	14059	18	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	14059	19	in	in	IN
18637	14059	20	reference	reference	NN
18637	14059	21	to	to	IN
18637	14059	22	property	property	NN
18637	14059	23	"	"	``
18637	14059	24	involved	involve	VBN
18637	14059	25	"	"	''
18637	14059	26	no	no	DT
18637	14059	27	question	question	NN
18637	14059	28	of	of	IN
18637	14059	29	equality	equality	NN
18637	14059	30	of	of	IN
18637	14059	31	status	status	NN
18637	14059	32	,	,	,
18637	14059	33	"	"	''
18637	14059	34	the	the	DT
18637	14059	35	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14059	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14059	37	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	14059	38	,	,	,
18637	14059	39	in	in	IN
18637	14059	40	Stearns	Stearns	NNP
18637	14059	41	_	_	NNP
18637	14059	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	14059	43	_	_	NNP
18637	14059	44	Minnesota,[244	Minnesota,[244	NNP
18637	14059	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14059	46	a	a	DT
18637	14059	47	promise	promise	NN
18637	14059	48	exacted	exact	VBD
18637	14059	49	from	from	IN
18637	14059	50	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	14059	51	upon	upon	IN
18637	14059	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14059	53	admission	admission	NN
18637	14059	54	to	to	IN
18637	14059	55	the	the	DT
18637	14059	56	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14059	57	which	which	WDT
18637	14059	58	was	be	VBD
18637	14059	59	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	14059	60	to	to	TO
18637	14059	61	limit	limit	VB
18637	14059	62	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14059	63	right	right	NN
18637	14059	64	to	to	IN
18637	14059	65	tax	tax	NN
18637	14059	66	lands	land	NNS
18637	14059	67	held	hold	VBN
18637	14059	68	by	by	IN
18637	14059	69	the	the	DT
18637	14059	70	United	United	NNP
18637	14059	71	States	States	NNP
18637	14059	72	at	at	IN
18637	14059	73	the	the	DT
18637	14059	74	time	time	NN
18637	14059	75	of	of	IN
18637	14059	76	admission	admission	NN
18637	14059	77	and	and	CC
18637	14059	78	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	14059	79	granted	grant	VBD
18637	14059	80	to	to	IN
18637	14059	81	a	a	DT
18637	14059	82	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	14059	83	.	.	.
18637	14060	1	The	the	DT
18637	14060	2	"	"	``
18637	14060	3	equal	equal	JJ
18637	14060	4	footing	footing	NN
18637	14060	5	"	"	''
18637	14060	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	14060	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	14060	8	had	have	VBN
18637	14060	9	an	an	DT
18637	14060	10	important	important	JJ
18637	14060	11	effect	effect	NN
18637	14060	12	,	,	,
18637	14060	13	however	however	RB
18637	14060	14	,	,	,
18637	14060	15	on	on	IN
18637	14060	16	the	the	DT
18637	14060	17	property	property	NN
18637	14060	18	rights	right	NNS
18637	14060	19	of	of	IN
18637	14060	20	new	new	JJ
18637	14060	21	States	States	NNPS
18637	14060	22	to	to	TO
18637	14060	23	soil	soil	VB
18637	14060	24	under	under	IN
18637	14060	25	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	14060	26	waters	water	NNS
18637	14060	27	.	.	.
18637	14061	1	In	in	IN
18637	14061	2	Pollard	Pollard	NNP
18637	14061	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14061	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	14061	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14061	6	Hagan,[245	Hagan,[245	NNP
18637	14061	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14061	8	the	the	DT
18637	14061	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14061	10	held	hold	VBD
18637	14061	11	that	that	IN
18637	14061	12	the	the	DT
18637	14061	13	original	original	JJ
18637	14061	14	States	States	NNPS
18637	14061	15	had	have	VBD
18637	14061	16	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	14061	17	to	to	IN
18637	14061	18	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14061	19	the	the	DT
18637	14061	20	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	14061	21	of	of	IN
18637	14061	22	the	the	DT
18637	14061	23	shores	shore	NNS
18637	14061	24	of	of	IN
18637	14061	25	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	14061	26	waters	water	NNS
18637	14061	27	and	and	CC
18637	14061	28	the	the	DT
18637	14061	29	soils	soil	NNS
18637	14061	30	under	under	IN
18637	14061	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14061	32	,	,	,
18637	14061	33	and	and	CC
18637	14061	34	that	that	IN
18637	14061	35	under	under	IN
18637	14061	36	the	the	DT
18637	14061	37	principle	principle	NN
18637	14061	38	of	of	IN
18637	14061	39	equality	equality	NN
18637	14061	40	the	the	DT
18637	14061	41	title	title	NN
18637	14061	42	to	to	IN
18637	14061	43	the	the	DT
18637	14061	44	soils	soil	NNS
18637	14061	45	of	of	IN
18637	14061	46	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	14061	47	waters	water	NNS
18637	14061	48	passes	pass	VBZ
18637	14061	49	to	to	IN
18637	14061	50	a	a	DT
18637	14061	51	new	new	JJ
18637	14061	52	State	state	NN
18637	14061	53	upon	upon	IN
18637	14061	54	admission	admission	NN
18637	14061	55	.	.	.
18637	14062	1	After	after	IN
18637	14062	2	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	14062	3	to	to	TO
18637	14062	4	extend	extend	VB
18637	14062	5	the	the	DT
18637	14062	6	inland	inland	JJ
18637	14062	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	14062	8	water	water	NN
18637	14062	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	14062	10	of	of	IN
18637	14062	11	this	this	DT
18637	14062	12	case	case	NN
18637	14062	13	to	to	IN
18637	14062	14	the	the	DT
18637	14062	15	three	three	CD
18637	14062	16	mile	mile	NN
18637	14062	17	marginal	marginal	JJ
18637	14062	18	belt	belt	NN
18637	14062	19	under	under	IN
18637	14062	20	the	the	DT
18637	14062	21	ocean	ocean	NN
18637	14062	22	along	along	IN
18637	14062	23	the	the	DT
18637	14062	24	coast,[246	coast,[246	NNP
18637	14062	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14062	26	the	the	DT
18637	14062	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14062	28	applied	apply	VBD
18637	14062	29	the	the	DT
18637	14062	30	principle	principle	NN
18637	14062	31	of	of	IN
18637	14062	32	the	the	DT
18637	14062	33	Pollard	Pollard	NNP
18637	14062	34	Case	Case	NNP
18637	14062	35	in	in	IN
18637	14062	36	reverse	reverse	NN
18637	14062	37	in	in	IN
18637	14062	38	United	United	NNP
18637	14062	39	States	States	NNP
18637	14062	40	_	_	NNP
18637	14062	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	14062	42	_	_	NNP
18637	14062	43	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	14062	44	.	.	.
18637	14063	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14063	2	247	247	CD
18637	14063	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14063	4	Since	since	IN
18637	14063	5	the	the	DT
18637	14063	6	original	original	JJ
18637	14063	7	States	States	NNPS
18637	14063	8	had	have	VBD
18637	14063	9	been	be	VBN
18637	14063	10	found	find	VBN
18637	14063	11	not	not	RB
18637	14063	12	to	to	TO
18637	14063	13	own	own	VB
18637	14063	14	the	the	DT
18637	14063	15	soil	soil	NN
18637	14063	16	under	under	IN
18637	14063	17	the	the	DT
18637	14063	18	three	three	CD
18637	14063	19	mile	mile	NN
18637	14063	20	belt	belt	NN
18637	14063	21	,	,	,
18637	14063	22	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	14063	23	,	,	,
18637	14063	24	which	which	WDT
18637	14063	25	concededly	concededly	RB
18637	14063	26	did	do	VBD
18637	14063	27	own	own	VB
18637	14063	28	this	this	DT
18637	14063	29	soil	soil	NN
18637	14063	30	before	before	IN
18637	14063	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14063	32	annexation	annexation	NN
18637	14063	33	to	to	IN
18637	14063	34	the	the	DT
18637	14063	35	United	United	NNP
18637	14063	36	States	States	NNP
18637	14063	37	,	,	,
18637	14063	38	was	be	VBD
18637	14063	39	held	hold	VBN
18637	14063	40	to	to	TO
18637	14063	41	have	have	VB
18637	14063	42	surrendered	surrender	VBN
18637	14063	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14063	44	dominion	dominion	NN
18637	14063	45	and	and	CC
18637	14063	46	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	14063	47	over	over	IN
18637	14063	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14063	49	,	,	,
18637	14063	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	14063	51	entering	enter	VBG
18637	14063	52	the	the	DT
18637	14063	53	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14063	54	on	on	IN
18637	14063	55	terms	term	NNS
18637	14063	56	of	of	IN
18637	14063	57	equality	equality	NN
18637	14063	58	with	with	IN
18637	14063	59	the	the	DT
18637	14063	60	existing	exist	VBG
18637	14063	61	States	States	NNP
18637	14063	62	.	.	.
18637	14064	1	To	to	IN
18637	14064	2	this	this	DT
18637	14064	3	extent	extent	NN
18637	14064	4	,	,	,
18637	14064	5	the	the	DT
18637	14064	6	earlier	early	JJR
18637	14064	7	rule	rule	NN
18637	14064	8	that	that	IN
18637	14064	9	unless	unless	IN
18637	14064	10	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	14064	11	declared	declare	VBN
18637	14064	12	by	by	IN
18637	14064	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14064	14	the	the	DT
18637	14064	15	title	title	NN
18637	14064	16	to	to	IN
18637	14064	17	every	every	DT
18637	14064	18	species	species	NN
18637	14064	19	of	of	IN
18637	14064	20	property	property	NN
18637	14064	21	owned	own	VBN
18637	14064	22	by	by	IN
18637	14064	23	a	a	DT
18637	14064	24	territory	territory	NN
18637	14064	25	passes	pass	VBZ
18637	14064	26	to	to	IN
18637	14064	27	the	the	DT
18637	14064	28	State	State	NNP
18637	14064	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	14064	30	admission[248	admission[248	NNP
18637	14064	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14064	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	14064	33	been	be	VBN
18637	14064	34	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	14064	35	.	.	.
18637	14065	1	RIGHTS	right	NNS
18637	14065	2	CONVEYED	CONVEYED	NNS
18637	14065	3	TO	to	IN
18637	14065	4	PRIVATE	private	JJ
18637	14065	5	PERSONS	person	NNS
18637	14065	6	BEFORE	before	IN
18637	14065	7	ADMISSION	ADMISSION	VBN
18637	14065	8	OF	of	IN
18637	14065	9	A	a	DT
18637	14065	10	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	14065	11	While	while	IN
18637	14065	12	the	the	DT
18637	14065	13	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	14065	14	status	status	NN
18637	14065	15	continues	continue	VBZ
18637	14065	16	,	,	,
18637	14065	17	the	the	DT
18637	14065	18	United	United	NNP
18637	14065	19	States	States	NNP
18637	14065	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	14065	21	power	power	NN
18637	14065	22	to	to	TO
18637	14065	23	convey	convey	VB
18637	14065	24	property	property	NN
18637	14065	25	rights	right	NNS
18637	14065	26	,	,	,
18637	14065	27	such	such	JJ
18637	14065	28	as	as	IN
18637	14065	29	rights	right	NNS
18637	14065	30	in	in	IN
18637	14065	31	soil	soil	NN
18637	14065	32	below	below	IN
18637	14065	33	high	high	JJ
18637	14065	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	14065	35	water	water	NN
18637	14065	36	mark	mark	NN
18637	14065	37	along	along	IN
18637	14065	38	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	14065	39	waters,[249	waters,[249	NN
18637	14065	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14065	41	or	or	CC
18637	14065	42	the	the	DT
18637	14065	43	right	right	NN
18637	14065	44	to	to	TO
18637	14065	45	fish	fish	VB
18637	14065	46	in	in	IN
18637	14065	47	designated	designate	VBN
18637	14065	48	waters,[250	waters,[250	NNP
18637	14065	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14065	50	which	which	WDT
18637	14065	51	will	will	MD
18637	14065	52	be	be	VB
18637	14065	53	binding	bind	VBG
18637	14065	54	on	on	IN
18637	14065	55	the	the	DT
18637	14065	56	State	State	NNP
18637	14065	57	.	.	.
18637	14066	1	But	but	CC
18637	14066	2	a	a	DT
18637	14066	3	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	14066	4	with	with	IN
18637	14066	5	an	an	DT
18637	14066	6	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	14066	7	tribe	tribe	NN
18637	14066	8	which	which	WDT
18637	14066	9	gave	give	VBD
18637	14066	10	hunting	hunt	VBG
18637	14066	11	rights	right	NNS
18637	14066	12	on	on	IN
18637	14066	13	unoccupied	unoccupied	JJ
18637	14066	14	lands	land	NNS
18637	14066	15	of	of	IN
18637	14066	16	the	the	DT
18637	14066	17	United	United	NNP
18637	14066	18	States	States	NNP
18637	14066	19	,	,	,
18637	14066	20	which	which	WDT
18637	14066	21	rights	right	NNS
18637	14066	22	should	should	MD
18637	14066	23	cease	cease	VB
18637	14066	24	when	when	WRB
18637	14066	25	the	the	DT
18637	14066	26	United	United	NNP
18637	14066	27	States	States	NNP
18637	14066	28	parted	part	VBD
18637	14066	29	with	with	IN
18637	14066	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14066	31	title	title	NN
18637	14066	32	to	to	IN
18637	14066	33	any	any	DT
18637	14066	34	of	of	IN
18637	14066	35	the	the	DT
18637	14066	36	land	land	NN
18637	14066	37	,	,	,
18637	14066	38	was	be	VBD
18637	14066	39	held	hold	VBN
18637	14066	40	to	to	TO
18637	14066	41	be	be	VB
18637	14066	42	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	14066	43	by	by	IN
18637	14066	44	the	the	DT
18637	14066	45	admission	admission	NN
18637	14066	46	to	to	IN
18637	14066	47	the	the	DT
18637	14066	48	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14066	49	of	of	IN
18637	14066	50	the	the	DT
18637	14066	51	territory	territory	NN
18637	14066	52	in	in	IN
18637	14066	53	which	which	WDT
18637	14066	54	the	the	DT
18637	14066	55	hunting	hunting	NN
18637	14066	56	lands	land	NNS
18637	14066	57	were	be	VBD
18637	14066	58	situated	situate	VBN
18637	14066	59	.	.	.
18637	14067	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14067	2	251	251	CD
18637	14067	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14067	4	Clause	clause	NN
18637	14067	5	2	2	CD
18637	14067	6	.	.	.
18637	14068	1	The	the	DT
18637	14068	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14068	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	14068	4	have	have	VB
18637	14068	5	Power	power	NN
18637	14068	6	to	to	TO
18637	14068	7	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	14068	8	of	of	IN
18637	14068	9	and	and	CC
18637	14068	10	make	make	VB
18637	14068	11	all	all	DT
18637	14068	12	needful	needful	JJ
18637	14068	13	Rules	Rules	NNPS
18637	14068	14	and	and	CC
18637	14068	15	Regulations	Regulations	NNPS
18637	14068	16	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	14068	17	the	the	DT
18637	14068	18	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	14068	19	or	or	CC
18637	14068	20	other	other	JJ
18637	14068	21	Property	Property	NNP
18637	14068	22	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	14068	23	to	to	IN
18637	14068	24	the	the	DT
18637	14068	25	United	United	NNP
18637	14068	26	States	States	NNP
18637	14068	27	;	;	:
18637	14068	28	and	and	CC
18637	14068	29	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	14068	30	in	in	IN
18637	14068	31	this	this	DT
18637	14068	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14068	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	14068	34	be	be	VB
18637	14068	35	so	so	RB
18637	14068	36	construed	construe	VBN
18637	14068	37	as	as	IN
18637	14068	38	to	to	IN
18637	14068	39	Prejudice	Prejudice	NNP
18637	14068	40	any	any	DT
18637	14068	41	Claims	claim	NNS
18637	14068	42	of	of	IN
18637	14068	43	the	the	DT
18637	14068	44	United	United	NNP
18637	14068	45	States	States	NNP
18637	14068	46	,	,	,
18637	14068	47	or	or	CC
18637	14068	48	of	of	IN
18637	14068	49	any	any	DT
18637	14068	50	particular	particular	JJ
18637	14068	51	State	state	NN
18637	14068	52	.	.	.
18637	14069	1	Property	property	NN
18637	14069	2	of	of	IN
18637	14069	3	the	the	DT
18637	14069	4	United	United	NNP
18637	14069	5	States	States	NNP
18637	14069	6	METHODS	METHODS	NNP
18637	14069	7	OF	of	IN
18637	14069	8	DISPOSING	dispose	VBG
18637	14069	9	THEREOF	THEREOF	NNP
18637	14069	10	The	the	DT
18637	14069	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14069	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	14069	13	silent	silent	JJ
18637	14069	14	as	as	IN
18637	14069	15	to	to	IN
18637	14069	16	the	the	DT
18637	14069	17	methods	method	NNS
18637	14069	18	of	of	IN
18637	14069	19	disposing	dispose	VBG
18637	14069	20	of	of	IN
18637	14069	21	property	property	NN
18637	14069	22	of	of	IN
18637	14069	23	the	the	DT
18637	14069	24	United	United	NNP
18637	14069	25	States	States	NNP
18637	14069	26	.	.	.
18637	14070	1	In	in	IN
18637	14070	2	United	United	NNP
18637	14070	3	States	States	NNP
18637	14070	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14070	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	14070	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14070	7	Gratiot,[252	Gratiot,[252	NNP
18637	14070	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14070	9	in	in	IN
18637	14070	10	which	which	WDT
18637	14070	11	the	the	DT
18637	14070	12	validity	validity	NN
18637	14070	13	of	of	IN
18637	14070	14	a	a	DT
18637	14070	15	lease	lease	NN
18637	14070	16	of	of	IN
18637	14070	17	lead	lead	JJ
18637	14070	18	mines	mine	NNS
18637	14070	19	on	on	IN
18637	14070	20	government	government	NN
18637	14070	21	lands	land	NNS
18637	14070	22	was	be	VBD
18637	14070	23	put	put	VBN
18637	14070	24	in	in	IN
18637	14070	25	issue	issue	NN
18637	14070	26	,	,	,
18637	14070	27	the	the	DT
18637	14070	28	contention	contention	NN
18637	14070	29	was	be	VBD
18637	14070	30	advanced	advance	VBN
18637	14070	31	that	that	IN
18637	14070	32	"	"	``
18637	14070	33	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	14070	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	14070	35	not	not	RB
18637	14070	36	letting	let	VBG
18637	14070	37	or	or	CC
18637	14070	38	leasing	lease	VBG
18637	14070	39	,	,	,
18637	14070	40	"	"	''
18637	14070	41	and	and	CC
18637	14070	42	that	that	IN
18637	14070	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14070	44	has	have	VBZ
18637	14070	45	no	no	DT
18637	14070	46	power	power	NN
18637	14070	47	"	"	''
18637	14070	48	to	to	TO
18637	14070	49	give	give	VB
18637	14070	50	or	or	CC
18637	14070	51	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	14070	52	leases	lease	NNS
18637	14070	53	.	.	.
18637	14070	54	"	"	''
18637	14071	1	The	the	DT
18637	14071	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14071	3	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	14071	4	the	the	DT
18637	14071	5	leases	lease	NNS
18637	14071	6	,	,	,
18637	14071	7	saying	say	VBG
18637	14071	8	"	"	``
18637	14071	9	the	the	DT
18637	14071	10	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	14071	11	must	must	MD
18637	14071	12	be	be	VB
18637	14071	13	left	leave	VBN
18637	14071	14	to	to	IN
18637	14071	15	the	the	DT
18637	14071	16	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	14071	17	of	of	IN
18637	14071	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14071	19	.	.	.
18637	14072	1	"	"	``
18637	14072	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14072	3	253	253	CD
18637	14072	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14072	5	Nearly	nearly	RB
18637	14072	6	a	a	DT
18637	14072	7	century	century	NN
18637	14072	8	later	later	RB
18637	14072	9	this	this	DT
18637	14072	10	power	power	NN
18637	14072	11	to	to	TO
18637	14072	12	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	14072	13	of	of	IN
18637	14072	14	public	public	JJ
18637	14072	15	property	property	NN
18637	14072	16	was	be	VBD
18637	14072	17	relied	rely	VBN
18637	14072	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	14072	19	to	to	TO
18637	14072	20	uphold	uphold	VB
18637	14072	21	the	the	DT
18637	14072	22	generation	generation	NN
18637	14072	23	and	and	CC
18637	14072	24	sale	sale	NN
18637	14072	25	of	of	IN
18637	14072	26	electricity	electricity	NN
18637	14072	27	by	by	IN
18637	14072	28	the	the	DT
18637	14072	29	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	14072	30	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	14072	31	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	14072	32	.	.	.
18637	14073	1	The	the	DT
18637	14073	2	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	14073	3	of	of	IN
18637	14073	4	the	the	DT
18637	14073	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14073	6	ran	run	VBD
18637	14073	7	thus	thus	RB
18637	14073	8	:	:	:
18637	14073	9	the	the	DT
18637	14073	10	potential	potential	JJ
18637	14073	11	electrical	electrical	JJ
18637	14073	12	energy	energy	NN
18637	14073	13	made	make	VBN
18637	14073	14	available	available	JJ
18637	14073	15	by	by	IN
18637	14073	16	the	the	DT
18637	14073	17	construction	construction	NN
18637	14073	18	of	of	IN
18637	14073	19	a	a	DT
18637	14073	20	dam	dam	NN
18637	14073	21	in	in	IN
18637	14073	22	the	the	DT
18637	14073	23	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	14073	24	of	of	IN
18637	14073	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14073	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	14073	27	powers	power	NNS
18637	14073	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	14073	29	property	property	NN
18637	14073	30	which	which	WDT
18637	14073	31	the	the	DT
18637	14073	32	United	United	NNP
18637	14073	33	States	States	NNP
18637	14073	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	14073	35	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	14073	36	to	to	TO
18637	14073	37	reduce	reduce	VB
18637	14073	38	to	to	IN
18637	14073	39	possession	possession	NN
18637	14073	40	;	;	:
18637	14073	41	to	to	IN
18637	14073	42	that	that	DT
18637	14073	43	end	end	NN
18637	14073	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14073	45	may	may	MD
18637	14073	46	install	install	VB
18637	14073	47	the	the	DT
18637	14073	48	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	14073	49	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	14073	50	to	to	TO
18637	14073	51	generate	generate	VB
18637	14073	52	such	such	JJ
18637	14073	53	energy	energy	NN
18637	14073	54	.	.	.
18637	14074	1	In	in	IN
18637	14074	2	order	order	NN
18637	14074	3	to	to	TO
18637	14074	4	widen	widen	VB
18637	14074	5	the	the	DT
18637	14074	6	market	market	NN
18637	14074	7	and	and	CC
18637	14074	8	make	make	VB
18637	14074	9	a	a	DT
18637	14074	10	more	more	RBR
18637	14074	11	advantageous	advantageous	JJ
18637	14074	12	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	14074	13	of	of	IN
18637	14074	14	the	the	DT
18637	14074	15	product	product	NN
18637	14074	16	,	,	,
18637	14074	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14074	18	may	may	MD
18637	14074	19	construct	construct	VB
18637	14074	20	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	14074	21	lines	line	NNS
18637	14074	22	,	,	,
18637	14074	23	and	and	CC
18637	14074	24	may	may	MD
18637	14074	25	enter	enter	VB
18637	14074	26	into	into	IN
18637	14074	27	a	a	DT
18637	14074	28	contract	contract	NN
18637	14074	29	with	with	IN
18637	14074	30	a	a	DT
18637	14074	31	private	private	JJ
18637	14074	32	company	company	NN
18637	14074	33	for	for	IN
18637	14074	34	the	the	DT
18637	14074	35	interchange	interchange	NN
18637	14074	36	of	of	IN
18637	14074	37	electric	electric	JJ
18637	14074	38	energy	energy	NN
18637	14074	39	.	.	.
18637	14075	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14075	2	254	254	CD
18637	14075	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14075	4	PUBLIC	public	NN
18637	14075	5	LANDS	land	NNS
18637	14075	6	No	no	DT
18637	14075	7	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	14075	8	of	of	IN
18637	14075	9	public	public	JJ
18637	14075	10	lands	land	NNS
18637	14075	11	may	may	MD
18637	14075	12	be	be	VB
18637	14075	13	made	make	VBN
18637	14075	14	for	for	IN
18637	14075	15	any	any	DT
18637	14075	16	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	14075	17	except	except	IN
18637	14075	18	by	by	IN
18637	14075	19	authority	authority	NN
18637	14075	20	of	of	IN
18637	14075	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14075	22	.	.	.
18637	14076	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14076	2	255	255	CD
18637	14076	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14076	4	However	however	RB
18637	14076	5	,	,	,
18637	14076	6	the	the	DT
18637	14076	7	long	long	RB
18637	14076	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	14076	9	continued	continue	VBN
18637	14076	10	practice	practice	NN
18637	14076	11	of	of	IN
18637	14076	12	withdrawing	withdraw	VBG
18637	14076	13	land	land	NN
18637	14076	14	from	from	IN
18637	14076	15	the	the	DT
18637	14076	16	public	public	JJ
18637	14076	17	domain	domain	NN
18637	14076	18	by	by	IN
18637	14076	19	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	14076	20	Orders	Orders	NNP
18637	14076	21	for	for	IN
18637	14076	22	the	the	DT
18637	14076	23	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	14076	24	of	of	IN
18637	14076	25	creating	create	VBG
18637	14076	26	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	14076	27	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	14076	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	14076	29	raised	raise	VBN
18637	14076	30	an	an	DT
18637	14076	31	implied	imply	VBN
18637	14076	32	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	14076	33	of	of	IN
18637	14076	34	authority	authority	NN
18637	14076	35	from	from	IN
18637	14076	36	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14076	37	to	to	TO
18637	14076	38	take	take	VB
18637	14076	39	such	such	JJ
18637	14076	40	action	action	NN
18637	14076	41	.	.	.
18637	14077	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14077	2	256	256	CD
18637	14077	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14077	4	The	the	DT
18637	14077	5	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	14077	6	authority	authority	NN
18637	14077	7	of	of	IN
18637	14077	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14077	9	over	over	IN
18637	14077	10	public	public	JJ
18637	14077	11	lands	land	NNS
18637	14077	12	includes	include	VBZ
18637	14077	13	the	the	DT
18637	14077	14	power	power	NN
18637	14077	15	to	to	TO
18637	14077	16	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	14077	17	the	the	DT
18637	14077	18	times	time	NNS
18637	14077	19	,	,	,
18637	14077	20	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	14077	21	and	and	CC
18637	14077	22	mode	mode	NN
18637	14077	23	of	of	IN
18637	14077	24	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	14077	25	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	14077	26	,	,	,
18637	14077	27	and	and	CC
18637	14077	28	to	to	TO
18637	14077	29	designate	designate	VB
18637	14077	30	the	the	DT
18637	14077	31	persons	person	NNS
18637	14077	32	to	to	TO
18637	14077	33	whom	whom	WP
18637	14077	34	the	the	DT
18637	14077	35	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	14077	36	shall	shall	MD
18637	14077	37	be	be	VB
18637	14077	38	made;[257	made;[257	LS
18637	14077	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14077	40	to	to	TO
18637	14077	41	declare	declare	VB
18637	14077	42	the	the	DT
18637	14077	43	dignity	dignity	NN
18637	14077	44	and	and	CC
18637	14077	45	effect	effect	NN
18637	14077	46	of	of	IN
18637	14077	47	titles	title	NNS
18637	14077	48	emanating	emanate	VBG
18637	14077	49	from	from	IN
18637	14077	50	the	the	DT
18637	14077	51	United	United	NNP
18637	14077	52	States;[258	States;[258	,
18637	14077	53	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14077	54	to	to	TO
18637	14077	55	determine	determine	VB
18637	14077	56	the	the	DT
18637	14077	57	validity	validity	NN
18637	14077	58	of	of	IN
18637	14077	59	grants	grant	NNS
18637	14077	60	which	which	WDT
18637	14077	61	antedate	antedate	VBP
18637	14077	62	the	the	DT
18637	14077	63	government	government	NN
18637	14077	64	's	's	POS
18637	14077	65	acquisition	acquisition	NN
18637	14077	66	of	of	IN
18637	14077	67	the	the	DT
18637	14077	68	property;[259	property;[259	CD
18637	14077	69	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14077	70	to	to	TO
18637	14077	71	exempt	exempt	VB
18637	14077	72	lands	land	NNS
18637	14077	73	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	14077	74	under	under	IN
18637	14077	75	the	the	DT
18637	14077	76	homestead	homestead	NN
18637	14077	77	laws	law	NNS
18637	14077	78	from	from	IN
18637	14077	79	previously	previously	RB
18637	14077	80	contracted	contract	VBN
18637	14077	81	debts;[260	debts;[260	NNS
18637	14077	82	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14077	83	to	to	TO
18637	14077	84	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	14077	85	land	land	NN
18637	14077	86	from	from	IN
18637	14077	87	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	14077	88	and	and	CC
18637	14077	89	to	to	TO
18637	14077	90	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	14077	91	grazing	graze	VBG
18637	14077	92	thereon;[261	thereon;[261	NNP
18637	14077	93	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14077	94	to	to	TO
18637	14077	95	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	14077	96	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	14077	97	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	14077	98	of	of	IN
18637	14077	99	public	public	JJ
18637	14077	100	property	property	NN
18637	14077	101	and	and	CC
18637	14077	102	to	to	TO
18637	14077	103	declare	declare	VB
18637	14077	104	what	what	WP
18637	14077	105	are	be	VBP
18637	14077	106	nuisances	nuisance	NNS
18637	14077	107	,	,	,
18637	14077	108	as	as	IN
18637	14077	109	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	14077	110	such	such	JJ
18637	14077	111	property	property	NN
18637	14077	112	,	,	,
18637	14077	113	and	and	CC
18637	14077	114	provide	provide	VB
18637	14077	115	for	for	IN
18637	14077	116	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14077	117	abatement;[262	abatement;[262	NNS
18637	14077	118	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14077	119	and	and	CC
18637	14077	120	to	to	TO
18637	14077	121	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	14077	122	the	the	DT
18637	14077	123	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	14077	124	of	of	IN
18637	14077	125	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	14077	126	on	on	IN
18637	14077	127	lands	land	NNS
18637	14077	128	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	14077	129	and	and	CC
18637	14077	130	used	use	VBN
18637	14077	131	for	for	IN
18637	14077	132	an	an	DT
18637	14077	133	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	14077	134	colony	colony	NN
18637	14077	135	.	.	.
18637	14078	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14078	2	263	263	CD
18637	14078	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14078	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14078	5	may	may	MD
18637	14078	6	limit	limit	VB
18637	14078	7	the	the	DT
18637	14078	8	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	14078	9	of	of	IN
18637	14078	10	the	the	DT
18637	14078	11	public	public	JJ
18637	14078	12	domain	domain	NN
18637	14078	13	to	to	IN
18637	14078	14	a	a	DT
18637	14078	15	manner	manner	NN
18637	14078	16	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	14078	17	with	with	IN
18637	14078	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14078	19	views	view	NNS
18637	14078	20	of	of	IN
18637	14078	21	public	public	JJ
18637	14078	22	policy	policy	NN
18637	14078	23	.	.	.
18637	14079	1	A	a	DT
18637	14079	2	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	14079	3	inserted	insert	VBN
18637	14079	4	in	in	IN
18637	14079	5	a	a	DT
18637	14079	6	grant	grant	NN
18637	14079	7	of	of	IN
18637	14079	8	public	public	JJ
18637	14079	9	lands	land	NNS
18637	14079	10	to	to	IN
18637	14079	11	a	a	DT
18637	14079	12	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	14079	13	which	which	WDT
18637	14079	14	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	14079	15	the	the	DT
18637	14079	16	grantee	grantee	NN
18637	14079	17	from	from	IN
18637	14079	18	selling	sell	VBG
18637	14079	19	or	or	CC
18637	14079	20	leasing	lease	VBG
18637	14079	21	to	to	IN
18637	14079	22	a	a	DT
18637	14079	23	private	private	JJ
18637	14079	24	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	14079	25	the	the	DT
18637	14079	26	right	right	NN
18637	14079	27	to	to	TO
18637	14079	28	sell	sell	VB
18637	14079	29	or	or	CC
18637	14079	30	sublet	sublet	VB
18637	14079	31	water	water	NN
18637	14079	32	or	or	CC
18637	14079	33	electric	electric	JJ
18637	14079	34	energy	energy	NN
18637	14079	35	supplied	supply	VBN
18637	14079	36	by	by	IN
18637	14079	37	the	the	DT
18637	14079	38	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	14079	39	constructed	construct	VBN
18637	14079	40	on	on	IN
18637	14079	41	such	such	JJ
18637	14079	42	land	land	NN
18637	14079	43	was	be	VBD
18637	14079	44	held	hold	VBN
18637	14079	45	valid	valid	JJ
18637	14079	46	.	.	.
18637	14080	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14080	2	264	264	CD
18637	14080	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14080	4	THE	the	DT
18637	14080	5	POWER	power	NN
18637	14080	6	OF	of	IN
18637	14080	7	THE	the	DT
18637	14080	8	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	14080	9	No	no	DT
18637	14080	10	State	State	NNP
18637	14080	11	can	can	MD
18637	14080	12	tax	tax	VB
18637	14080	13	public	public	JJ
18637	14080	14	lands	land	NNS
18637	14080	15	of	of	IN
18637	14080	16	the	the	DT
18637	14080	17	United	United	NNP
18637	14080	18	States	States	NNP
18637	14080	19	within	within	IN
18637	14080	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14080	21	borders;[265	borders;[265	NNS
18637	14080	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14080	23	nor	nor	CC
18637	14080	24	can	can	MD
18637	14080	25	State	State	NNP
18637	14080	26	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	14080	27	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	14080	28	with	with	IN
18637	14080	29	the	the	DT
18637	14080	30	power	power	NN
18637	14080	31	of	of	IN
18637	14080	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14080	33	under	under	IN
18637	14080	34	this	this	DT
18637	14080	35	clause	clause	NN
18637	14080	36	or	or	CC
18637	14080	37	embarrass	embarrass	VB
18637	14080	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14080	39	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	14080	40	.	.	.
18637	14081	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14081	2	266	266	CD
18637	14081	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14081	4	The	the	DT
18637	14081	5	question	question	NN
18637	14081	6	whether	whether	IN
18637	14081	7	title	title	NN
18637	14081	8	to	to	TO
18637	14081	9	land	land	NN
18637	14081	10	which	which	WDT
18637	14081	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	14081	12	once	once	RB
18637	14081	13	been	be	VBN
18637	14081	14	the	the	DT
18637	14081	15	property	property	NN
18637	14081	16	of	of	IN
18637	14081	17	the	the	DT
18637	14081	18	United	United	NNP
18637	14081	19	States	States	NNP
18637	14081	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	14081	21	passed	pass	VBN
18637	14081	22	from	from	IN
18637	14081	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14081	24	must	must	MD
18637	14081	25	be	be	VB
18637	14081	26	resolved	resolve	VBN
18637	14081	27	by	by	IN
18637	14081	28	the	the	DT
18637	14081	29	laws	law	NNS
18637	14081	30	of	of	IN
18637	14081	31	the	the	DT
18637	14081	32	United	United	NNP
18637	14081	33	States	States	NNP
18637	14081	34	;	;	:
18637	14081	35	after	after	IN
18637	14081	36	title	title	NN
18637	14081	37	has	have	VBZ
18637	14081	38	passed	pass	VBN
18637	14081	39	,	,	,
18637	14081	40	"	"	''
18637	14081	41	that	that	DT
18637	14081	42	property	property	NN
18637	14081	43	,	,	,
18637	14081	44	like	like	IN
18637	14081	45	all	all	DT
18637	14081	46	other	other	JJ
18637	14081	47	property	property	NN
18637	14081	48	in	in	IN
18637	14081	49	the	the	DT
18637	14081	50	State	State	NNP
18637	14081	51	,	,	,
18637	14081	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	14081	53	subject	subject	JJ
18637	14081	54	to	to	IN
18637	14081	55	State	State	NNP
18637	14081	56	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	14081	57	;	;	:
18637	14081	58	so	so	RB
18637	14081	59	far	far	RB
18637	14081	60	as	as	IN
18637	14081	61	that	that	DT
18637	14081	62	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	14081	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	14081	64	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	14081	65	with	with	IN
18637	14081	66	the	the	DT
18637	14081	67	admission	admission	NN
18637	14081	68	that	that	IN
18637	14081	69	the	the	DT
18637	14081	70	title	title	NN
18637	14081	71	passed	pass	VBD
18637	14081	72	and	and	CC
18637	14081	73	vested	vest	VBN
18637	14081	74	according	accord	VBG
18637	14081	75	to	to	IN
18637	14081	76	the	the	DT
18637	14081	77	laws	law	NNS
18637	14081	78	of	of	IN
18637	14081	79	the	the	DT
18637	14081	80	United	United	NNP
18637	14081	81	States	States	NNP
18637	14081	82	.	.	.
18637	14082	1	"	"	``
18637	14082	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14082	3	267	267	CD
18637	14082	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14082	5	In	in	IN
18637	14082	6	construing	construe	VBG
18637	14082	7	a	a	DT
18637	14082	8	conveyance	conveyance	NN
18637	14082	9	by	by	IN
18637	14082	10	the	the	DT
18637	14082	11	United	United	NNP
18637	14082	12	States	States	NNP
18637	14082	13	of	of	IN
18637	14082	14	land	land	NN
18637	14082	15	within	within	IN
18637	14082	16	a	a	DT
18637	14082	17	State	State	NNP
18637	14082	18	,	,	,
18637	14082	19	the	the	DT
18637	14082	20	settled	settled	JJ
18637	14082	21	and	and	CC
18637	14082	22	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	14082	23	rule	rule	NN
18637	14082	24	of	of	IN
18637	14082	25	construction	construction	NN
18637	14082	26	of	of	IN
18637	14082	27	the	the	DT
18637	14082	28	State	State	NNP
18637	14082	29	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	14082	30	a	a	DT
18637	14082	31	guide	guide	NN
18637	14082	32	in	in	IN
18637	14082	33	determining	determine	VBG
18637	14082	34	what	what	WP
18637	14082	35	impliedly	impliedly	RB
18637	14082	36	passes	pass	VBZ
18637	14082	37	to	to	IN
18637	14082	38	the	the	DT
18637	14082	39	grantee	grantee	NN
18637	14082	40	as	as	IN
18637	14082	41	an	an	DT
18637	14082	42	incident	incident	NN
18637	14082	43	to	to	TO
18637	14082	44	land	land	NN
18637	14082	45	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	14082	46	granted	grant	VBN
18637	14082	47	.	.	.
18637	14083	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14083	2	268	268	CD
18637	14083	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14083	4	But	but	CC
18637	14083	5	a	a	DT
18637	14083	6	State	State	NNP
18637	14083	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	14083	8	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	14083	9	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	14083	10	to	to	IN
18637	14083	11	a	a	DT
18637	14083	12	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14083	13	grant	grant	NN
18637	14083	14	can	can	MD
18637	14083	15	not	not	RB
18637	14083	16	be	be	VB
18637	14083	17	given	give	VBN
18637	14083	18	effect	effect	NN
18637	14083	19	to	to	IN
18637	14083	20	vest	vest	VB
18637	14083	21	in	in	IN
18637	14083	22	the	the	DT
18637	14083	23	State	State	NNP
18637	14083	24	rights	right	NNS
18637	14083	25	which	which	WDT
18637	14083	26	either	either	CC
18637	14083	27	remained	remain	VBD
18637	14083	28	in	in	IN
18637	14083	29	the	the	DT
18637	14083	30	United	United	NNP
18637	14083	31	States	States	NNP
18637	14083	32	or	or	CC
18637	14083	33	passed	pass	VBD
18637	14083	34	to	to	IN
18637	14083	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14083	36	grantee	grantee	NN
18637	14083	37	.	.	.
18637	14084	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14084	2	269	269	CD
18637	14084	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14084	4	POWER	power	NN
18637	14084	5	OF	of	IN
18637	14084	6	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	14084	7	OVER	over	IN
18637	14084	8	THE	the	DT
18637	14084	9	TERRITORIES	territory	NNS
18637	14084	10	In	in	IN
18637	14084	11	the	the	DT
18637	14084	12	territories	territory	NNS
18637	14084	13	,	,	,
18637	14084	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14084	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	14084	16	the	the	DT
18637	14084	17	entire	entire	JJ
18637	14084	18	dominion	dominion	NN
18637	14084	19	and	and	CC
18637	14084	20	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	14084	21	,	,	,
18637	14084	22	national	national	JJ
18637	14084	23	and	and	CC
18637	14084	24	local	local	JJ
18637	14084	25	,	,	,
18637	14084	26	and	and	CC
18637	14084	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	14084	28	full	full	JJ
18637	14084	29	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	14084	30	power	power	NN
18637	14084	31	over	over	IN
18637	14084	32	all	all	DT
18637	14084	33	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	14084	34	upon	upon	IN
18637	14084	35	which	which	WDT
18637	14084	36	a	a	DT
18637	14084	37	State	state	NN
18637	14084	38	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	14084	39	might	may	MD
18637	14084	40	act	act	VB
18637	14084	41	.	.	.
18637	14085	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14085	2	270	270	CD
18637	14085	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14085	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14085	5	may	may	MD
18637	14085	6	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	14085	7	directly	directly	RB
18637	14085	8	with	with	IN
18637	14085	9	respect	respect	NN
18637	14085	10	to	to	IN
18637	14085	11	the	the	DT
18637	14085	12	local	local	JJ
18637	14085	13	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	14085	14	of	of	IN
18637	14085	15	a	a	DT
18637	14085	16	territory	territory	NN
18637	14085	17	or	or	CC
18637	14085	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14085	19	may	may	MD
18637	14085	20	transfer	transfer	VB
18637	14085	21	that	that	DT
18637	14085	22	function	function	NN
18637	14085	23	to	to	IN
18637	14085	24	a	a	DT
18637	14085	25	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	14085	26	elected	elect	VBN
18637	14085	27	by	by	IN
18637	14085	28	the	the	DT
18637	14085	29	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	14085	30	thereof,[271	thereof,[271	NN
18637	14085	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14085	32	which	which	WDT
18637	14085	33	will	will	MD
18637	14085	34	then	then	RB
18637	14085	35	be	be	VB
18637	14085	36	invested	invest	VBN
18637	14085	37	with	with	IN
18637	14085	38	all	all	DT
18637	14085	39	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	14085	40	power	power	NN
18637	14085	41	except	except	IN
18637	14085	42	as	as	RB
18637	14085	43	limited	limit	VBN
18637	14085	44	by	by	IN
18637	14085	45	the	the	DT
18637	14085	46	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14085	47	of	of	IN
18637	14085	48	the	the	DT
18637	14085	49	United	United	NNP
18637	14085	50	States	States	NNP
18637	14085	51	and	and	CC
18637	14085	52	acts	act	NNS
18637	14085	53	of	of	IN
18637	14085	54	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14085	55	.	.	.
18637	14086	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14086	2	272	272	CD
18637	14086	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14086	4	In	in	IN
18637	14086	5	1886	1886	CD
18637	14086	6	,	,	,
18637	14086	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14086	8	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	14086	9	the	the	DT
18637	14086	10	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	14086	11	by	by	IN
18637	14086	12	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	14086	13	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	14086	14	of	of	IN
18637	14086	15	local	local	JJ
18637	14086	16	or	or	CC
18637	14086	17	special	special	JJ
18637	14086	18	laws	law	NNS
18637	14086	19	on	on	IN
18637	14086	20	enumerated	enumerated	JJ
18637	14086	21	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	14086	22	.	.	.
18637	14087	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14087	2	273	273	CD
18637	14087	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14087	4	The	the	DT
18637	14087	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	14087	6	guarantees	guarantee	NNS
18637	14087	7	of	of	IN
18637	14087	8	private	private	JJ
18637	14087	9	rights	right	NNS
18637	14087	10	are	be	VBP
18637	14087	11	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	14087	12	in	in	IN
18637	14087	13	territories	territory	NNS
18637	14087	14	which	which	WDT
18637	14087	15	have	have	VBP
18637	14087	16	been	be	VBN
18637	14087	17	made	make	VBN
18637	14087	18	a	a	DT
18637	14087	19	part	part	NN
18637	14087	20	of	of	IN
18637	14087	21	the	the	DT
18637	14087	22	United	United	NNP
18637	14087	23	States	States	NNP
18637	14087	24	by	by	IN
18637	14087	25	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	14087	26	action,[274	action,[274	NN
18637	14087	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14087	28	but	but	CC
18637	14087	29	not	not	RB
18637	14087	30	to	to	IN
18637	14087	31	unincorporated	unincorporated	JJ
18637	14087	32	territories	territory	NNS
18637	14087	33	.	.	.
18637	14088	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14088	2	275	275	CD
18637	14088	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14088	4	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	14088	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	14088	6	of	of	IN
18637	14088	7	the	the	DT
18637	14088	8	former	former	JJ
18637	14088	9	description,[276	description,[276	NN
18637	14088	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14088	11	while	while	IN
18637	14088	12	the	the	DT
18637	14088	13	status	status	NN
18637	14088	14	of	of	IN
18637	14088	15	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	14088	16	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	14088	17	to	to	TO
18637	14088	18	be	be	VB
18637	14088	19	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
18637	14088	20	.	.	.
18637	14089	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14089	2	277	277	CD
18637	14089	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14089	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14089	5	may	may	MD
18637	14089	6	establish	establish	VB
18637	14089	7	,	,	,
18637	14089	8	or	or	CC
18637	14089	9	may	may	MD
18637	14089	10	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	14089	11	the	the	DT
18637	14089	12	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	14089	13	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	14089	14	to	to	TO
18637	14089	15	create	create	VB
18637	14089	16	,	,	,
18637	14089	17	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	14089	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	14089	19	whose	whose	WP$
18637	14089	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14089	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	14089	22	derived	derive	VBN
18637	14089	23	from	from	IN
18637	14089	24	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	14089	25	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	14089	26	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	14089	27	to	to	IN
18637	14089	28	this	this	DT
18637	14089	29	section	section	NN
18637	14089	30	rather	rather	RB
18637	14089	31	than	than	IN
18637	14089	32	from	from	IN
18637	14089	33	article	article	NN
18637	14089	34	IV	IV	NNP
18637	14089	35	.	.	.
18637	14090	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14090	2	278	278	CD
18637	14090	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14090	4	Such	such	JJ
18637	14090	5	courts	court	NNS
18637	14090	6	may	may	MD
18637	14090	7	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	14090	8	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
18637	14090	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14090	10	despite	despite	IN
18637	14090	11	the	the	DT
18637	14090	12	fact	fact	NN
18637	14090	13	that	that	IN
18637	14090	14	such	such	JJ
18637	14090	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14090	16	may	may	MD
18637	14090	17	be	be	VB
18637	14090	18	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	14090	19	in	in	IN
18637	14090	20	the	the	DT
18637	14090	21	States	state	NNS
18637	14090	22	only	only	RB
18637	14090	23	by	by	IN
18637	14090	24	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	14090	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	14090	26	.	.	.
18637	14091	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14091	2	279	279	CD
18637	14091	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14091	4	Section	section	NN
18637	14091	5	4	4	CD
18637	14091	6	.	.	.
18637	14092	1	The	the	DT
18637	14092	2	United	United	NNP
18637	14092	3	States	States	NNP
18637	14092	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	14092	5	guarantee	guarantee	VB
18637	14092	6	to	to	IN
18637	14092	7	every	every	DT
18637	14092	8	State	State	NNP
18637	14092	9	in	in	IN
18637	14092	10	this	this	DT
18637	14092	11	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14092	12	a	a	DT
18637	14092	13	Republican	Republican	NNP
18637	14092	14	Form	Form	NNP
18637	14092	15	of	of	IN
18637	14092	16	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14092	17	,	,	,
18637	14092	18	and	and	CC
18637	14092	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	14092	20	protect	protect	VB
18637	14092	21	each	each	DT
18637	14092	22	of	of	IN
18637	14092	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14092	24	against	against	IN
18637	14092	25	Invasion	Invasion	NNP
18637	14092	26	;	;	:
18637	14092	27	and	and	CC
18637	14092	28	on	on	IN
18637	14092	29	Application	application	NN
18637	14092	30	of	of	IN
18637	14092	31	the	the	DT
18637	14092	32	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	14092	33	,	,	,
18637	14092	34	or	or	CC
18637	14092	35	of	of	IN
18637	14092	36	the	the	DT
18637	14092	37	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	14092	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14092	39	when	when	WRB
18637	14092	40	the	the	DT
18637	14092	41	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	14092	42	can	can	MD
18637	14092	43	not	not	RB
18637	14092	44	be	be	VB
18637	14092	45	convened	convene	VBN
18637	14092	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14092	47	against	against	IN
18637	14092	48	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	14092	49	Violence	violence	NN
18637	14092	50	.	.	.
18637	14093	1	A	a	DT
18637	14093	2	Republican	republican	JJ
18637	14093	3	Form	Form	NNP
18637	14093	4	of	of	IN
18637	14093	5	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14093	6	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14093	7	was	be	VBD
18637	14093	8	established	establish	VBN
18637	14093	9	in	in	IN
18637	14093	10	the	the	DT
18637	14093	11	pioneer	pioneer	NN
18637	14093	12	case	case	NN
18637	14093	13	of	of	IN
18637	14093	14	Luther	Luther	NNP
18637	14093	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14093	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	14093	17	_	_	NNP
18637	14093	18	Borden,[280	Borden,[280	NNP
18637	14093	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14093	20	that	that	IN
18637	14093	21	questions	question	NNS
18637	14093	22	arising	arise	VBG
18637	14093	23	under	under	IN
18637	14093	24	this	this	DT
18637	14093	25	section	section	NN
18637	14093	26	are	be	VBP
18637	14093	27	political	political	JJ
18637	14093	28	,	,	,
18637	14093	29	not	not	RB
18637	14093	30	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	14093	31	,	,	,
18637	14093	32	in	in	IN
18637	14093	33	character	character	NN
18637	14093	34	,	,	,
18637	14093	35	and	and	CC
18637	14093	36	that	that	IN
18637	14093	37	"	"	``
18637	14093	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14093	39	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	14093	40	with	with	IN
18637	14093	41	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14093	42	to	to	TO
18637	14093	43	decide	decide	VB
18637	14093	44	what	what	WP
18637	14093	45	government	government	NN
18637	14093	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	14093	47	the	the	DT
18637	14093	48	established	establish	VBN
18637	14093	49	one	one	CD
18637	14093	50	in	in	IN
18637	14093	51	a	a	DT
18637	14093	52	State	state	NN
18637	14093	53	*	*	NFP
18637	14093	54	*	*	NFP
18637	14093	55	*	*	NFP
18637	14093	56	as	as	RB
18637	14093	57	well	well	RB
18637	14093	58	as	as	IN
18637	14093	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14093	60	republican	republican	JJ
18637	14093	61	character	character	NN
18637	14093	62	.	.	.
18637	14094	1	"	"	``
18637	14094	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14094	3	281	281	CD
18637	14094	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14094	5	Upon	upon	IN
18637	14094	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14094	7	also	also	RB
18637	14094	8	rested	rest	VBD
18637	14094	9	the	the	DT
18637	14094	10	duty	duty	NN
18637	14094	11	to	to	TO
18637	14094	12	restore	restore	VB
18637	14094	13	republican	republican	JJ
18637	14094	14	governments	government	NNS
18637	14094	15	to	to	IN
18637	14094	16	the	the	DT
18637	14094	17	States	States	NNP
18637	14094	18	which	which	WDT
18637	14094	19	seceded	secede	VBD
18637	14094	20	from	from	IN
18637	14094	21	the	the	DT
18637	14094	22	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14094	23	at	at	IN
18637	14094	24	the	the	DT
18637	14094	25	time	time	NN
18637	14094	26	of	of	IN
18637	14094	27	the	the	DT
18637	14094	28	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	14094	29	War	War	NNP
18637	14094	30	.	.	.
18637	14095	1	In	in	IN
18637	14095	2	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	14095	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14095	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	14095	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14095	6	White[282	White[282	NNP
18637	14095	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14095	8	the	the	DT
18637	14095	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14095	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14095	11	declared	declare	VBD
18637	14095	12	that	that	IN
18637	14095	13	the	the	DT
18637	14095	14	action	action	NN
18637	14095	15	of	of	IN
18637	14095	16	the	the	DT
18637	14095	17	President	President	NNP
18637	14095	18	in	in	IN
18637	14095	19	setting	set	VBG
18637	14095	20	up	up	RP
18637	14095	21	provisional	provisional	JJ
18637	14095	22	governments	government	NNS
18637	14095	23	at	at	IN
18637	14095	24	the	the	DT
18637	14095	25	end	end	NN
18637	14095	26	of	of	IN
18637	14095	27	the	the	DT
18637	14095	28	war	war	NN
18637	14095	29	was	be	VBD
18637	14095	30	justified	justify	VBN
18637	14095	31	,	,	,
18637	14095	32	if	if	IN
18637	14095	33	at	at	RB
18637	14095	34	all	all	RB
18637	14095	35	,	,	,
18637	14095	36	only	only	RB
18637	14095	37	as	as	IN
18637	14095	38	an	an	DT
18637	14095	39	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	14095	40	of	of	IN
18637	14095	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14095	42	powers	power	NNS
18637	14095	43	as	as	IN
18637	14095	44	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	14095	45	in	in	IN
18637	14095	46	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	14095	47	and	and	CC
18637	14095	48	that	that	IN
18637	14095	49	such	such	JJ
18637	14095	50	governments	government	NNS
18637	14095	51	were	be	VBD
18637	14095	52	to	to	TO
18637	14095	53	be	be	VB
18637	14095	54	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	14095	55	merely	merely	RB
18637	14095	56	as	as	IN
18637	14095	57	provisional	provisional	JJ
18637	14095	58	regimes	regime	NNS
18637	14095	59	to	to	TO
18637	14095	60	perform	perform	VB
18637	14095	61	the	the	DT
18637	14095	62	functions	function	NNS
18637	14095	63	of	of	IN
18637	14095	64	government	government	NN
18637	14095	65	pending	pende	VBG
18637	14095	66	action	action	NN
18637	14095	67	by	by	IN
18637	14095	68	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14095	69	.	.	.
18637	14096	1	On	on	IN
18637	14096	2	the	the	DT
18637	14096	3	ground	ground	NN
18637	14096	4	that	that	IN
18637	14096	5	the	the	DT
18637	14096	6	questions	question	NNS
18637	14096	7	were	be	VBD
18637	14096	8	not	not	RB
18637	14096	9	justiciable	justiciable	JJ
18637	14096	10	in	in	IN
18637	14096	11	character	character	NN
18637	14096	12	,	,	,
18637	14096	13	the	the	DT
18637	14096	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14096	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14096	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	14096	17	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	14096	18	to	to	TO
18637	14096	19	consider	consider	VB
18637	14096	20	whether	whether	IN
18637	14096	21	the	the	DT
18637	14096	22	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	14096	23	of	of	IN
18637	14096	24	the	the	DT
18637	14096	25	initiative	initiative	NN
18637	14096	26	and	and	CC
18637	14096	27	referendum,[283	referendum,[283	NN
18637	14096	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14096	29	or	or	CC
18637	14096	30	the	the	DT
18637	14096	31	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	14096	32	of	of	IN
18637	14096	33	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	14096	34	power	power	NN
18637	14096	35	to	to	IN
18637	14096	36	other	other	JJ
18637	14096	37	departments	department	NNS
18637	14096	38	of	of	IN
18637	14096	39	government[284	government[284	NNP
18637	14096	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14096	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	14096	42	compatible	compatible	JJ
18637	14096	43	with	with	IN
18637	14096	44	a	a	DT
18637	14096	45	republican	republican	JJ
18637	14096	46	form	form	NN
18637	14096	47	of	of	IN
18637	14096	48	government	government	NN
18637	14096	49	.	.	.
18637	14097	1	This	this	DT
18637	14097	2	guarantee	guarantee	NN
18637	14097	3	does	do	VBZ
18637	14097	4	not	not	RB
18637	14097	5	give	give	VB
18637	14097	6	the	the	DT
18637	14097	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14097	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14097	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14097	10	to	to	TO
18637	14097	11	review	review	VB
18637	14097	12	a	a	DT
18637	14097	13	decision	decision	NN
18637	14097	14	of	of	IN
18637	14097	15	a	a	DT
18637	14097	16	State	State	NNP
18637	14097	17	court	court	NN
18637	14097	18	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	14097	19	a	a	DT
18637	14097	20	determination	determination	NN
18637	14097	21	of	of	IN
18637	14097	22	an	an	DT
18637	14097	23	election	election	NN
18637	14097	24	contest	contest	NN
18637	14097	25	for	for	IN
18637	14097	26	the	the	DT
18637	14097	27	office	office	NN
18637	14097	28	of	of	IN
18637	14097	29	governor	governor	NN
18637	14097	30	made	make	VBN
18637	14097	31	by	by	IN
18637	14097	32	a	a	DT
18637	14097	33	State	State	NNP
18637	14097	34	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	14097	35	under	under	IN
18637	14097	36	the	the	DT
18637	14097	37	authority	authority	NN
18637	14097	38	of	of	IN
18637	14097	39	a	a	DT
18637	14097	40	State	State	NNP
18637	14097	41	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	14097	42	.	.	.
18637	14098	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14098	2	285	285	CD
18637	14098	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14098	4	Inasmuch	Inasmuch	NNP
18637	14098	5	as	as	IN
18637	14098	6	women	woman	NNS
18637	14098	7	were	be	VBD
18637	14098	8	denied	deny	VBN
18637	14098	9	the	the	DT
18637	14098	10	right	right	NN
18637	14098	11	to	to	TO
18637	14098	12	vote	vote	VB
18637	14098	13	in	in	IN
18637	14098	14	most	most	RBS
18637	14098	15	,	,	,
18637	14098	16	if	if	IN
18637	14098	17	not	not	RB
18637	14098	18	all	all	DT
18637	14098	19	,	,	,
18637	14098	20	of	of	IN
18637	14098	21	the	the	DT
18637	14098	22	original	original	JJ
18637	14098	23	thirteen	thirteen	CD
18637	14098	24	States	States	NNPS
18637	14098	25	,	,	,
18637	14098	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14098	27	was	be	VBD
18637	14098	28	held	hold	VBN
18637	14098	29	,	,	,
18637	14098	30	prior	prior	RB
18637	14098	31	to	to	IN
18637	14098	32	the	the	DT
18637	14098	33	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	14098	34	of	of	IN
18637	14098	35	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	14098	36	XIX	XIX	NNP
18637	14098	37	,	,	,
18637	14098	38	that	that	IN
18637	14098	39	a	a	DT
18637	14098	40	State	State	NNP
18637	14098	41	government	government	NN
18637	14098	42	could	could	MD
18637	14098	43	be	be	VB
18637	14098	44	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	14098	45	under	under	IN
18637	14098	46	this	this	DT
18637	14098	47	clause	clause	NN
18637	14098	48	by	by	IN
18637	14098	49	reason	reason	NN
18637	14098	50	of	of	IN
18637	14098	51	the	the	DT
18637	14098	52	fact	fact	NN
18637	14098	53	that	that	IN
18637	14098	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14098	55	did	do	VBD
18637	14098	56	not	not	RB
18637	14098	57	permit	permit	VB
18637	14098	58	women	woman	NNS
18637	14098	59	to	to	TO
18637	14098	60	vote	vote	VB
18637	14098	61	.	.	.
18637	14099	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14099	2	286	286	CD
18637	14099	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14099	4	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	14099	5	Against	against	IN
18637	14099	6	Domestic	Domestic	NNP
18637	14099	7	Violence	Violence	NNP
18637	14099	8	The	the	DT
18637	14099	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14099	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14099	11	also	also	RB
18637	14099	12	held	hold	VBD
18637	14099	13	in	in	IN
18637	14099	14	Luther	Luther	NNP
18637	14099	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14099	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	14099	17	_	_	NNP
18637	14099	18	Borden[287	Borden[287	NNP
18637	14099	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14099	20	that	that	IN
18637	14099	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14099	22	rested	rest	VBD
18637	14099	23	with	with	IN
18637	14099	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14099	25	to	to	TO
18637	14099	26	determine	determine	VB
18637	14099	27	upon	upon	IN
18637	14099	28	the	the	DT
18637	14099	29	means	mean	NNS
18637	14099	30	proper	proper	JJ
18637	14099	31	to	to	TO
18637	14099	32	fulfill	fulfill	VB
18637	14099	33	the	the	DT
18637	14099	34	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	14099	35	guarantee	guarantee	NN
18637	14099	36	of	of	IN
18637	14099	37	protection	protection	NN
18637	14099	38	to	to	IN
18637	14099	39	the	the	DT
18637	14099	40	States	state	NNS
18637	14099	41	against	against	IN
18637	14099	42	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	14099	43	violence	violence	NN
18637	14099	44	.	.	.
18637	14100	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	14100	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14100	3	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	14100	4	declared	declare	VBD
18637	14100	5	that	that	IN
18637	14100	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14100	7	might	may	MD
18637	14100	8	have	have	VB
18637	14100	9	placed	place	VBN
18637	14100	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14100	11	in	in	IN
18637	14100	12	the	the	DT
18637	14100	13	power	power	NN
18637	14100	14	of	of	IN
18637	14100	15	a	a	DT
18637	14100	16	court	court	NN
18637	14100	17	to	to	TO
18637	14100	18	decide	decide	VB
18637	14100	19	when	when	WRB
18637	14100	20	the	the	DT
18637	14100	21	contingency	contingency	NN
18637	14100	22	had	have	VBD
18637	14100	23	happened	happen	VBN
18637	14100	24	which	which	WDT
18637	14100	25	required	require	VBD
18637	14100	26	the	the	DT
18637	14100	27	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	14100	28	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14100	29	to	to	TO
18637	14100	30	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	14100	31	.	.	.
18637	14101	1	Instead	instead	RB
18637	14101	2	,	,	,
18637	14101	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14101	4	had	have	VBD
18637	14101	5	,	,	,
18637	14101	6	by	by	IN
18637	14101	7	the	the	DT
18637	14101	8	act	act	NN
18637	14101	9	of	of	IN
18637	14101	10	February	February	NNP
18637	14101	11	28	28	CD
18637	14101	12	,	,	,
18637	14101	13	1795,[288	1795,[288	CD
18637	14101	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14101	15	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	14101	16	the	the	DT
18637	14101	17	President	President	NNP
18637	14101	18	to	to	TO
18637	14101	19	call	call	VB
18637	14101	20	out	out	RP
18637	14101	21	the	the	DT
18637	14101	22	militia	militia	NN
18637	14101	23	in	in	IN
18637	14101	24	case	case	NN
18637	14101	25	of	of	IN
18637	14101	26	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	14101	27	against	against	IN
18637	14101	28	the	the	DT
18637	14101	29	government	government	NN
18637	14101	30	of	of	IN
18637	14101	31	any	any	DT
18637	14101	32	State	State	NNP
18637	14101	33	.	.	.
18637	14102	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14102	2	followed	follow	VBD
18637	14102	3	,	,	,
18637	14102	4	said	say	VBD
18637	14102	5	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	14102	6	,	,	,
18637	14102	7	that	that	IN
18637	14102	8	the	the	DT
18637	14102	9	President	President	NNP
18637	14102	10	"	"	''
18637	14102	11	must	must	MD
18637	14102	12	,	,	,
18637	14102	13	of	of	IN
18637	14102	14	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	14102	15	,	,	,
18637	14102	16	decide	decide	VB
18637	14102	17	which	which	WDT
18637	14102	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	14102	19	the	the	DT
18637	14102	20	government	government	NN
18637	14102	21	,	,	,
18637	14102	22	and	and	CC
18637	14102	23	which	which	WDT
18637	14102	24	party	party	NN
18637	14102	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	14102	26	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	14102	27	arrayed	array	VBN
18637	14102	28	against	against	IN
18637	14102	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14102	30	,	,	,
18637	14102	31	before	before	IN
18637	14102	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14102	33	can	can	MD
18637	14102	34	perform	perform	VB
18637	14102	35	the	the	DT
18637	14102	36	duty	duty	NN
18637	14102	37	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	14102	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	14102	39	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14102	40	by	by	IN
18637	14102	41	the	the	DT
18637	14102	42	act	act	NN
18637	14102	43	of	of	IN
18637	14102	44	Congress"[289	Congress"[289	NNP
18637	14102	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14102	46	and	and	CC
18637	14102	47	that	that	IN
18637	14102	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14102	49	determination	determination	NN
18637	14102	50	was	be	VBD
18637	14102	51	not	not	RB
18637	14102	52	subject	subject	JJ
18637	14102	53	to	to	IN
18637	14102	54	review	review	NN
18637	14102	55	by	by	IN
18637	14102	56	the	the	DT
18637	14102	57	courts	court	NNS
18637	14102	58	.	.	.
18637	14103	1	DECLINE	DECLINE	NNP
18637	14103	2	IN	in	IN
18637	14103	3	IMPORTANCE	importance	NN
18637	14103	4	OF	of	IN
18637	14103	5	THIS	this	DT
18637	14103	6	GUARANTY	GUARANTY	VBN
18637	14103	7	With	with	IN
18637	14103	8	the	the	DT
18637	14103	9	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	14103	10	in	in	IN
18637	14103	11	the	the	DT
18637	14103	12	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	14103	13	Case[290	case[290	NN
18637	14103	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14103	15	of	of	IN
18637	14103	16	the	the	DT
18637	14103	17	power	power	NN
18637	14103	18	and	and	CC
18637	14103	19	duty	duty	NN
18637	14103	20	of	of	IN
18637	14103	21	the	the	DT
18637	14103	22	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	14103	23	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14103	24	to	to	TO
18637	14103	25	use	use	VB
18637	14103	26	"	"	``
18637	14103	27	the	the	DT
18637	14103	28	entire	entire	JJ
18637	14103	29	strength	strength	NN
18637	14103	30	of	of	IN
18637	14103	31	the	the	DT
18637	14103	32	Nation	nation	NN
18637	14103	33	*	*	NFP
18637	14103	34	*	*	NFP
18637	14103	35	*	*	NFP
18637	14103	36	to	to	TO
18637	14103	37	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	14103	38	in	in	IN
18637	14103	39	any	any	DT
18637	14103	40	part	part	NN
18637	14103	41	of	of	IN
18637	14103	42	the	the	DT
18637	14103	43	land	land	NN
18637	14103	44	the	the	DT
18637	14103	45	full	full	JJ
18637	14103	46	and	and	CC
18637	14103	47	free	free	JJ
18637	14103	48	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	14103	49	of	of	IN
18637	14103	50	all	all	DT
18637	14103	51	national	national	JJ
18637	14103	52	powers	power	NNS
18637	14103	53	and	and	CC
18637	14103	54	the	the	DT
18637	14103	55	security	security	NN
18637	14103	56	of	of	IN
18637	14103	57	all	all	DT
18637	14103	58	rights	right	NNS
18637	14103	59	entrusted	entrust	VBN
18637	14103	60	by	by	IN
18637	14103	61	the	the	DT
18637	14103	62	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14103	63	to	to	IN
18637	14103	64	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14103	65	care,"[291	care,"[291	NN
18637	14103	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14103	67	this	this	DT
18637	14103	68	clause	clause	NN
18637	14103	69	has	have	VBZ
18637	14103	70	declined	decline	VBN
18637	14103	71	in	in	IN
18637	14103	72	importance	importance	NN
18637	14103	73	.	.	.
18637	14104	1	When	when	WRB
18637	14104	2	that	that	IN
18637	14104	3	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14104	4	finds	find	VBZ
18637	14104	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14104	6	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	14104	7	or	or	CC
18637	14104	8	desirable	desirable	JJ
18637	14104	9	to	to	TO
18637	14104	10	use	use	VB
18637	14104	11	force	force	NN
18637	14104	12	to	to	TO
18637	14104	13	quell	quell	VB
18637	14104	14	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	14104	15	violence	violence	NN
18637	14104	16	,	,	,
18637	14104	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14104	18	power	power	NN
18637	14104	19	to	to	TO
18637	14104	20	protect	protect	VB
18637	14104	21	the	the	DT
18637	14104	22	property	property	NN
18637	14104	23	of	of	IN
18637	14104	24	the	the	DT
18637	14104	25	United	United	NNP
18637	14104	26	States	States	NNP
18637	14104	27	,	,	,
18637	14104	28	to	to	TO
18637	14104	29	remove	remove	VB
18637	14104	30	obstructions	obstruction	NNS
18637	14104	31	to	to	IN
18637	14104	32	the	the	DT
18637	14104	33	United	United	NNP
18637	14104	34	States	States	NNP
18637	14104	35	mails	mail	VBZ
18637	14104	36	,	,	,
18637	14104	37	or	or	CC
18637	14104	38	to	to	TO
18637	14104	39	protect	protect	VB
18637	14104	40	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	14104	41	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	14104	42	from	from	IN
18637	14104	43	interruption	interruption	NN
18637	14104	44	by	by	IN
18637	14104	45	labor	labor	NN
18637	14104	46	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	14104	47	or	or	CC
18637	14104	48	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	14104	49	,	,	,
18637	14104	50	usually	usually	RB
18637	14104	51	will	will	MD
18637	14104	52	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	14104	53	legal	legal	JJ
18637	14104	54	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	14104	55	for	for	IN
18637	14104	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14104	57	action	action	NN
18637	14104	58	,	,	,
18637	14104	59	without	without	IN
18637	14104	60	reference	reference	NN
18637	14104	61	to	to	IN
18637	14104	62	this	this	DT
18637	14104	63	provision	provision	NN
18637	14104	64	.	.	.
18637	14105	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14105	2	292	292	CD
18637	14105	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14105	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	14105	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14105	6	1	1	CD
18637	14105	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14105	8	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	14105	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14105	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14105	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14105	12	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	14105	13	,	,	,
18637	14105	14	6	6	CD
18637	14105	15	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	14105	16	.	.	.
18637	14106	1	577	577	CD
18637	14106	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14106	3	1821	1821	CD
18637	14106	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14106	5	,	,	,
18637	14106	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	14106	7	an	an	DT
18637	14106	8	early	early	JJ
18637	14106	9	case	case	NN
18637	14106	10	in	in	IN
18637	14106	11	which	which	WDT
18637	14106	12	the	the	DT
18637	14106	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14106	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14106	15	enforced	enforce	VBD
18637	14106	16	this	this	DT
18637	14106	17	rule	rule	NN
18637	14106	18	.	.	.
18637	14107	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14107	2	2	2	LS
18637	14107	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14107	4	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	14107	5	.	.	.
18637	14108	1	122	122	CD
18637	14108	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14108	3	1790	1790	CD
18637	14108	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14108	5	;	;	:
18637	14108	6	2	2	CD
18637	14108	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	14108	8	.	.	.
18637	14109	1	299	299	CD
18637	14109	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14109	3	1804	1804	CD
18637	14109	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14109	5	,	,	,
18637	14109	6	R.S.	R.S.	NNP
18637	14110	1	§	§	NNP
18637	14110	2	905	905	CD
18637	14110	3	28	28	CD
18637	14110	4	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
18637	14111	1	§	§	NNP
18637	14111	2	687	687	CD
18637	14111	3	.	.	.
18637	14112	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14112	2	3	3	LS
18637	14112	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14112	4	Mankin	Mankin	NNP
18637	14112	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14112	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14112	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14112	8	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	14112	9	&	&	CC
18637	14112	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14112	11	,	,	,
18637	14112	12	2	2	CD
18637	14112	13	Brock	Brock	NNP
18637	14112	14	.	.	.
18637	14113	1	125	125	CD
18637	14113	2	,	,	,
18637	14113	3	127	127	CD
18637	14113	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14113	5	1823	1823	CD
18637	14113	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14113	7	.	.	.
18637	14114	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14114	2	4	4	CD
18637	14114	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14114	4	7	7	CD
18637	14114	5	Cr	cr	NN
18637	14114	6	.	.	.
18637	14115	1	481	481	CD
18637	14115	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14115	3	1813	1813	CD
18637	14115	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14115	5	.	.	.
18637	14116	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14116	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14116	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14116	4	also	also	RB
18637	14116	5	Everett	Everett	NNP
18637	14116	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14116	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14116	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14116	9	Everett	Everett	NNP
18637	14116	10	,	,	,
18637	14116	11	215	215	CD
18637	14116	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14116	13	203	203	CD
18637	14116	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14116	15	1909	1909	CD
18637	14116	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14116	17	;	;	:
18637	14116	18	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	14116	19	L.	L.	NNP
18637	14116	20	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14116	21	.	.	.
18637	14117	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14117	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14117	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14117	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14117	5	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	14117	6	,	,	,
18637	14117	7	97	97	CD
18637	14117	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14117	9	331	331	CD
18637	14117	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14117	11	1878	1878	CD
18637	14117	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14117	13	.	.	.
18637	14118	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14118	2	5	5	CD
18637	14118	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14118	4	On	on	IN
18637	14118	5	the	the	DT
18637	14118	6	same	same	JJ
18637	14118	7	basis	basis	NN
18637	14118	8	,	,	,
18637	14118	9	a	a	DT
18637	14118	10	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14118	11	can	can	MD
18637	14118	12	not	not	RB
18637	14118	13	be	be	VB
18637	14118	14	impeached	impeach	VBN
18637	14118	15	either	either	CC
18637	14118	16	in	in	IN
18637	14118	17	or	or	CC
18637	14118	18	out	out	IN
18637	14118	19	of	of	IN
18637	14118	20	the	the	DT
18637	14118	21	State	State	NNP
18637	14118	22	by	by	IN
18637	14118	23	showing	show	VBG
18637	14118	24	that	that	IN
18637	14118	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14118	26	was	be	VBD
18637	14118	27	based	base	VBN
18637	14118	28	on	on	IN
18637	14118	29	a	a	DT
18637	14118	30	mistake	mistake	NN
18637	14118	31	of	of	IN
18637	14118	32	law	law	NN
18637	14118	33	.	.	.
18637	14119	1	American	American	NNP
18637	14119	2	Exp	Exp	NNP
18637	14119	3	.	.	.
18637	14120	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14120	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14120	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14120	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14120	5	Mullins	Mullins	NNP
18637	14120	6	,	,	,
18637	14120	7	212	212	CD
18637	14120	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14120	9	311	311	CD
18637	14120	10	,	,	,
18637	14120	11	312	312	CD
18637	14120	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14120	13	1909	1909	CD
18637	14120	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14120	15	;	;	:
18637	14120	16	Fauntleroy	Fauntleroy	NNP
18637	14120	17	_	_	NNP
18637	14120	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	14120	19	_	_	NNP
18637	14120	20	Lum	Lum	NNP
18637	14120	21	,	,	,
18637	14120	22	210	210	CD
18637	14120	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14120	24	230	230	CD
18637	14120	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14120	26	1908	1908	CD
18637	14120	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14120	28	;	;	:
18637	14120	29	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	14120	30	L.	L.	NNP
18637	14120	31	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14120	32	.	.	.
18637	14121	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14121	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14121	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14121	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14121	5	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	14121	6	,	,	,
18637	14121	7	245	245	CD
18637	14121	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14121	9	146	146	CD
18637	14121	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14121	11	1917	1917	CD
18637	14121	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14121	13	;	;	:
18637	14121	14	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	14121	15	L.	L.	NNP
18637	14121	16	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14121	17	.	.	.
18637	14122	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14122	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14122	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14122	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14122	5	Ibs	Ibs	NNP
18637	14122	6	,	,	,
18637	14122	7	237	237	CD
18637	14122	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14122	9	662	662	CD
18637	14122	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14122	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	14122	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14122	13	.	.	.
18637	14123	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14123	2	6	6	CD
18637	14123	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14123	4	3	3	CD
18637	14123	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	14123	6	.	.	.
18637	14124	1	234	234	CD
18637	14124	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14124	3	1818	1818	CD
18637	14124	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14124	5	.	.	.
18637	14125	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14125	2	7	7	CD
18637	14125	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14125	4	13	13	CD
18637	14125	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	14125	6	.	.	.
18637	14126	1	312	312	CD
18637	14126	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14126	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	14126	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14126	5	.	.	.
18637	14127	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14127	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14127	3	also	also	RB
18637	14127	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14127	5	Bacon	Bacon	NNP
18637	14127	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14127	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14127	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14127	9	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	14127	10	,	,	,
18637	14127	11	20	20	CD
18637	14127	12	How	how	WRB
18637	14127	13	.	.	.
18637	14128	1	22	22	CD
18637	14128	2	,	,	,
18637	14128	3	25	25	CD
18637	14128	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14128	5	1858	1858	CD
18637	14128	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14128	7	;	;	:
18637	14128	8	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	14128	9	of	of	IN
18637	14128	10	Ala.	Alabama	NNP
18637	14128	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14128	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	14128	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14128	14	Dalton	Dalton	NNP
18637	14128	15	,	,	,
18637	14128	16	9	9	CD
18637	14128	17	How	how	WRB
18637	14128	18	.	.	.
18637	14129	1	522	522	CD
18637	14129	2	,	,	,
18637	14129	3	528	528	CD
18637	14129	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14129	5	1850	1850	CD
18637	14129	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14129	7	;	;	:
18637	14129	8	Great	Great	NNP
18637	14129	9	Western	Western	NNP
18637	14129	10	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	14129	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14129	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14129	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	14129	14	_	_	NNP
18637	14129	15	Purdy	Purdy	NNP
18637	14129	16	,	,	,
18637	14129	17	162	162	CD
18637	14129	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14129	19	329	329	CD
18637	14129	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14129	21	1896	1896	CD
18637	14129	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14129	23	;	;	:
18637	14129	24	Christmas	Christmas	NNP
18637	14129	25	_	_	NNP
18637	14129	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	14129	27	_	_	NNP
18637	14129	28	Russell	Russell	NNP
18637	14129	29	,	,	,
18637	14129	30	5	5	CD
18637	14129	31	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14129	32	.	.	.
18637	14130	1	290	290	CD
18637	14130	2	,	,	,
18637	14130	3	301	301	CD
18637	14130	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14130	5	1866	1866	CD
18637	14130	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14130	7	;	;	:
18637	14130	8	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	14130	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14130	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14130	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14130	12	Pelican	Pelican	NNP
18637	14130	13	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	14130	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14130	15	,	,	,
18637	14130	16	127	127	CD
18637	14130	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14130	18	265	265	CD
18637	14130	19	,	,	,
18637	14130	20	292	292	CD
18637	14130	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14130	22	1888	1888	CD
18637	14130	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14130	24	.	.	.
18637	14131	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14131	2	8	8	CD
18637	14131	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14131	4	Cole	Cole	NNP
18637	14131	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14131	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14131	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14131	8	Cunningham	Cunningham	NNP
18637	14131	9	,	,	,
18637	14131	10	133	133	CD
18637	14131	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14131	12	107	107	CD
18637	14131	13	,	,	,
18637	14131	14	112	112	CD
18637	14131	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14131	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	14131	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14131	18	.	.	.
18637	14132	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14132	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14132	3	also	also	RB
18637	14132	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14132	5	Stacy	Stacy	NNP
18637	14132	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14132	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14132	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14132	9	Thrasher	Thrasher	NNP
18637	14132	10	,	,	,
18637	14132	11	use	use	NN
18637	14132	12	of	of	IN
18637	14132	13	Sellers	seller	NNS
18637	14132	14	,	,	,
18637	14132	15	6	6	CD
18637	14132	16	How	how	WRB
18637	14132	17	.	.	.
18637	14133	1	44	44	CD
18637	14133	2	,	,	,
18637	14133	3	61	61	CD
18637	14133	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14133	5	1848	1848	CD
18637	14133	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14133	7	;	;	:
18637	14133	8	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	14133	9	County	County	NNP
18637	14133	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14133	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	14133	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14133	13	White	White	NNP
18637	14133	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14133	15	M.E.	M.E.	NNP
18637	14133	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14134	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14134	2	,	,	,
18637	14134	3	296	296	CD
18637	14134	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14134	5	268	268	CD
18637	14134	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14134	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	14134	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14134	9	.	.	.
18637	14135	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14135	2	9	9	CD
18637	14135	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14135	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	14135	5	&	&	CC
18637	14135	6	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	14136	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14136	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14136	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14136	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14136	5	Wiggins	Wiggins	NNP
18637	14136	6	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	14136	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14136	8	,	,	,
18637	14136	9	119	119	CD
18637	14136	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14136	11	615	615	CD
18637	14136	12	,	,	,
18637	14136	13	622	622	CD
18637	14136	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14136	15	1887	1887	CD
18637	14136	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14136	17	;	;	:
18637	14136	18	Hanley	Hanley	NNP
18637	14136	19	_	_	NNP
18637	14136	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	14136	21	_	_	NNP
18637	14136	22	Donoghue	Donoghue	NNP
18637	14136	23	,	,	,
18637	14136	24	116	116	CD
18637	14136	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14136	26	1	1	CD
18637	14136	27	,	,	,
18637	14136	28	3	3	CD
18637	14136	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14136	30	1885	1885	CD
18637	14136	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14136	32	.	.	.
18637	14137	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14137	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14137	3	also	also	RB
18637	14137	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14137	5	Bigelow	Bigelow	NNP
18637	14137	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14137	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14137	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14137	9	Old	Old	NNP
18637	14137	10	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	14137	11	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	14137	12	Min	Min	NNP
18637	14137	13	.	.	.
18637	14138	1	&	&	CC
18637	14138	2	S.	S.	NNP
18637	14138	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14138	4	,	,	,
18637	14138	5	225	225	CD
18637	14138	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14138	7	111	111	CD
18637	14138	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14138	9	1912	1912	CD
18637	14138	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14138	11	;	;	:
18637	14138	12	Green	Green	NNP
18637	14138	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14138	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	14138	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14138	16	Van	Van	NNP
18637	14138	17	Buskirk	Buskirk	NNP
18637	14138	18	,	,	,
18637	14138	19	7	7	CD
18637	14138	20	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14138	21	.	.	.
18637	14139	1	139	139	CD
18637	14139	2	,	,	,
18637	14139	3	140	140	CD
18637	14139	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14139	5	1869	1869	CD
18637	14139	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14139	7	;	;	:
18637	14139	8	Roche	Roche	NNP
18637	14139	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14139	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14139	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14139	12	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	14139	13	,	,	,
18637	14139	14	275	275	CD
18637	14139	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14139	16	449	449	CD
18637	14139	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14139	18	1928	1928	CD
18637	14139	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14139	20	;	;	:
18637	14139	21	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	14139	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14139	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	14139	24	_	_	NNP
18637	14139	25	Chattanooga	Chattanooga	NNP
18637	14139	26	Boiler	Boiler	NNP
18637	14139	27	&	&	CC
18637	14139	28	Tank	Tank	NNP
18637	14139	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14139	30	,	,	,
18637	14139	31	289	289	CD
18637	14139	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14139	33	439	439	CD
18637	14139	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14139	35	1933	1933	CD
18637	14139	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14139	37	.	.	.
18637	14140	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14140	2	10	10	CD
18637	14140	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14140	4	Sistare	Sistare	NNP
18637	14140	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14140	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14140	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14140	8	Sistare	Sistare	NNP
18637	14140	9	,	,	,
18637	14140	10	218	218	CD
18637	14140	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14140	12	1	1	CD
18637	14140	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14140	14	1910	1910	CD
18637	14140	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14140	16	.	.	.
18637	14141	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14141	2	11	11	CD
18637	14141	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14141	4	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	14141	5	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	14141	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14141	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14141	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14141	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14141	10	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	14141	11	,	,	,
18637	14141	12	228	228	CD
18637	14141	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14141	14	346	346	CD
18637	14141	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14141	16	1913	1913	CD
18637	14141	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14141	18	.	.	.
18637	14142	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14142	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14142	3	also	also	RB
18637	14142	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14142	5	Fall	Fall	NNP
18637	14142	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14142	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14142	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14142	9	Eastin	Eastin	NNP
18637	14142	10	,	,	,
18637	14142	11	215	215	CD
18637	14142	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14142	13	1	1	CD
18637	14142	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14142	15	1909	1909	CD
18637	14142	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14142	17	.	.	.
18637	14143	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14143	2	12	12	CD
18637	14143	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14143	4	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	14143	5	County	County	NNP
18637	14143	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14143	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14143	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14143	9	White	White	NNP
18637	14143	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14143	11	M.E.	M.E.	NNP
18637	14143	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14144	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14144	2	,	,	,
18637	14144	3	296	296	CD
18637	14144	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14144	5	268	268	CD
18637	14144	6	,	,	,
18637	14144	7	275	275	CD
18637	14144	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	14144	9	276	276	CD
18637	14144	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14144	11	1935	1935	CD
18637	14144	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14144	13	.	.	.
18637	14145	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14145	2	13	13	CD
18637	14145	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14145	4	Board	Board	NNP
18637	14145	5	of	of	IN
18637	14145	6	Public	Public	NNP
18637	14145	7	Works	Works	NNP
18637	14145	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14145	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	14145	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14145	11	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	14145	12	College	College	NNP
18637	14145	13	,	,	,
18637	14145	14	17	17	CD
18637	14145	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14145	16	.	.	.
18637	14146	1	521	521	CD
18637	14146	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14146	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	14146	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14146	5	;	;	:
18637	14146	6	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	14146	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14146	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14146	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14146	10	Pickrell	Pickrell	NNP
18637	14146	11	,	,	,
18637	14146	12	109	109	CD
18637	14146	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14146	14	608	608	CD
18637	14146	15	,	,	,
18637	14146	16	610	610	CD
18637	14146	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14146	18	1883	1883	CD
18637	14146	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14146	20	.	.	.
18637	14147	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14147	2	14	14	CD
18637	14147	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14147	4	Kersh	Kersh	NNP
18637	14147	5	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	14147	6	Drainage	Drainage	NNP
18637	14147	7	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	14147	8	.	.	.
18637	14148	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14148	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	14148	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14148	4	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	14148	5	,	,	,
18637	14148	6	309	309	CD
18637	14148	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14148	8	485	485	CD
18637	14148	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14148	10	1940	1940	CD
18637	14148	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14148	12	.	.	.
18637	14149	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14149	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14149	3	also	also	RB
18637	14149	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14149	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	14149	6	&	&	CC
18637	14149	7	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	14150	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14150	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14150	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14150	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14150	5	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	14150	6	P.	P.	NNP
18637	14150	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14150	8	,	,	,
18637	14150	9	137	137	CD
18637	14150	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14150	11	48	48	CD
18637	14150	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14150	13	1890	1890	CD
18637	14150	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14150	15	.	.	.
18637	14151	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14151	2	15	15	CD
18637	14151	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14151	4	National	National	NNP
18637	14151	5	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	14151	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	14151	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14151	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14151	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14151	10	Wiley	Wiley	NNP
18637	14151	11	,	,	,
18637	14151	12	195	195	CD
18637	14151	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14151	14	257	257	CD
18637	14151	15	,	,	,
18637	14151	16	265	265	CD
18637	14151	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14151	18	1904	1904	CD
18637	14151	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14151	20	.	.	.
18637	14152	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14152	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14152	3	also	also	RB
18637	14152	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14152	5	Grover	Grover	NNP
18637	14152	6	&	&	CC
18637	14152	7	B.	B.	NNP
18637	14152	8	Sewing	Sewing	NNP
18637	14152	9	-	-	:
18637	14152	10	Mach	Mach	NNP
18637	14152	11	.	.	.
18637	14153	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14153	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14153	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14153	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14153	5	Radcliffe	Radcliffe	NNP
18637	14153	6	,	,	,
18637	14153	7	137	137	CD
18637	14153	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14153	9	287	287	CD
18637	14153	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14153	11	1890	1890	CD
18637	14153	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14153	13	.	.	.
18637	14154	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14154	2	16	16	CD
18637	14154	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14154	4	Harding	Harding	NNP
18637	14154	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14154	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14154	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14154	8	Harding	Harding	NNP
18637	14154	9	,	,	,
18637	14154	10	198	198	CD
18637	14154	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14154	12	317	317	CD
18637	14154	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14154	14	1905	1905	CD
18637	14154	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14154	16	.	.	.
18637	14155	1	The	the	DT
18637	14155	2	following	follow	VBG
18637	14155	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	14155	4	further	further	RB
18637	14155	5	illustrate	illustrate	VBP
18637	14155	6	the	the	DT
18637	14155	7	application	application	NN
18637	14155	8	of	of	IN
18637	14155	9	the	the	DT
18637	14155	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	14155	11	when	when	WRB
18637	14155	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14155	13	protection	protection	NN
18637	14155	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	14155	15	sought	seek	VBN
18637	14155	16	by	by	IN
18637	14155	17	a	a	DT
18637	14155	18	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	14155	19	.	.	.
18637	14156	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	14156	2	claim	claim	NN
18637	14156	3	must	must	MD
18637	14156	4	be	be	VB
18637	14156	5	specific	specific	JJ
18637	14156	6	,	,	,
18637	14156	7	Wabash	Wabash	NNP
18637	14156	8	R.	R.	NNP
18637	14156	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14156	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14156	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	14156	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14156	13	Flannigan	Flannigan	NNP
18637	14156	14	,	,	,
18637	14156	15	192	192	CD
18637	14156	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14156	17	29	29	CD
18637	14156	18	,	,	,
18637	14156	19	37	37	CD
18637	14156	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14156	21	1904	1904	CD
18637	14156	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14156	23	.	.	.
18637	14157	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14157	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14157	3	also	also	RB
18637	14157	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14157	5	American	American	NNP
18637	14157	6	Exp	Exp	NNP
18637	14157	7	.	.	.
18637	14158	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14158	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14158	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14158	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14158	5	Mullins	Mullins	NNP
18637	14158	6	,	,	,
18637	14158	7	212	212	CD
18637	14158	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14158	9	311	311	CD
18637	14158	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14158	11	1909	1909	CD
18637	14158	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14158	13	.	.	.
18637	14159	1	The	the	DT
18637	14159	2	burden	burden	NN
18637	14159	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	14159	4	upon	upon	IN
18637	14159	5	the	the	DT
18637	14159	6	party	party	NN
18637	14159	7	making	make	VBG
18637	14159	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14159	9	to	to	TO
18637	14159	10	establish	establish	VB
18637	14159	11	the	the	DT
18637	14159	12	failure	failure	NN
18637	14159	13	of	of	IN
18637	14159	14	a	a	DT
18637	14159	15	court	court	NN
18637	14159	16	to	to	TO
18637	14159	17	give	give	VB
18637	14159	18	to	to	IN
18637	14159	19	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	14159	20	of	of	IN
18637	14159	21	a	a	DT
18637	14159	22	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14159	23	court	court	NN
18637	14159	24	and	and	CC
18637	14159	25	the	the	DT
18637	14159	26	court	court	NN
18637	14159	27	of	of	IN
18637	14159	28	another	another	DT
18637	14159	29	State	State	NNP
18637	14159	30	the	the	DT
18637	14159	31	due	due	JJ
18637	14159	32	effect	effect	NN
18637	14159	33	to	to	TO
18637	14159	34	which	which	WDT
18637	14159	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14159	36	are	be	VBP
18637	14159	37	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	14159	38	.	.	.
18637	14160	1	Commercial	Commercial	NNP
18637	14160	2	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	14160	3	.	.	.
18637	14161	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14161	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14161	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14161	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14161	5	Beckwith	Beckwith	NNP
18637	14161	6	,	,	,
18637	14161	7	188	188	CD
18637	14161	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14161	9	567	567	CD
18637	14161	10	,	,	,
18637	14161	11	573	573	CD
18637	14161	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14161	13	1903	1903	CD
18637	14161	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14161	15	.	.	.
18637	14162	1	However	however	RB
18637	14162	2	,	,	,
18637	14162	3	by	by	IN
18637	14162	4	defending	defend	VBG
18637	14162	5	on	on	IN
18637	14162	6	the	the	DT
18637	14162	7	merits	merit	NNS
18637	14162	8	,	,	,
18637	14162	9	after	after	IN
18637	14162	10	pleading	plead	VBG
18637	14162	11	and	and	CC
18637	14162	12	relying	rely	VBG
18637	14162	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	14162	14	a	a	DT
18637	14162	15	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	14162	16	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14162	17	,	,	,
18637	14162	18	a	a	DT
18637	14162	19	party	party	NN
18637	14162	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	14162	21	not	not	RB
18637	14162	22	waive	waive	VB
18637	14162	23	the	the	DT
18637	14162	24	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	14162	25	of	of	IN
18637	14162	26	an	an	DT
18637	14162	27	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	14162	28	estoppel	estoppel	NN
18637	14162	29	arising	arise	VBG
18637	14162	30	from	from	IN
18637	14162	31	the	the	DT
18637	14162	32	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	14162	33	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14162	34	.	.	.
18637	14163	1	Harding	Harding	NNP
18637	14163	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14163	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14163	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14163	5	Harding	Harding	NNP
18637	14163	6	,	,	,
18637	14163	7	198	198	CD
18637	14163	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14163	9	317	317	CD
18637	14163	10	,	,	,
18637	14163	11	330	330	CD
18637	14163	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14163	13	1905	1905	CD
18637	14163	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14163	15	.	.	.
18637	14164	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	14164	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	14164	3	a	a	DT
18637	14164	4	decree	decree	NN
18637	14164	5	of	of	IN
18637	14164	6	dismissal	dismissal	NN
18637	14164	7	,	,	,
18637	14164	8	not	not	RB
18637	14164	9	on	on	IN
18637	14164	10	the	the	DT
18637	14164	11	merits	merit	NNS
18637	14164	12	,	,	,
18637	14164	13	a	a	DT
18637	14164	14	bar	bar	NN
18637	14164	15	to	to	TO
18637	14164	16	suit	suit	VB
18637	14164	17	in	in	IN
18637	14164	18	another	another	DT
18637	14164	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14164	20	.	.	.
18637	14165	1	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	14165	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14165	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14165	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14165	5	McPherson	McPherson	NNP
18637	14165	6	,	,	,
18637	14165	7	232	232	CD
18637	14165	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14165	9	51	51	CD
18637	14165	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14165	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	14165	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14165	13	.	.	.
18637	14166	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	14166	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	14166	3	an	an	DT
18637	14166	4	entry	entry	NN
18637	14166	5	of	of	IN
18637	14166	6	discontinuance	discontinuance	NN
18637	14166	7	.	.	.
18637	14167	1	In	in	IN
18637	14167	2	allowing	allow	VBG
18637	14167	3	the	the	DT
18637	14167	4	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	14167	5	to	to	TO
18637	14167	6	show	show	VB
18637	14167	7	that	that	IN
18637	14167	8	such	such	JJ
18637	14167	9	entry	entry	NN
18637	14167	10	of	of	IN
18637	14167	11	discontinuance	discontinuance	NN
18637	14167	12	was	be	VBD
18637	14167	13	not	not	RB
18637	14167	14	intended	intend	VBN
18637	14167	15	by	by	IN
18637	14167	16	the	the	DT
18637	14167	17	parties	party	NNS
18637	14167	18	as	as	IN
18637	14167	19	a	a	DT
18637	14167	20	release	release	NN
18637	14167	21	and	and	CC
18637	14167	22	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
18637	14167	23	of	of	IN
18637	14167	24	the	the	DT
18637	14167	25	cause	cause	NN
18637	14167	26	of	of	IN
18637	14167	27	action	action	NN
18637	14167	28	,	,	,
18637	14167	29	but	but	CC
18637	14167	30	was	be	VBD
18637	14167	31	the	the	DT
18637	14167	32	result	result	NN
18637	14167	33	of	of	IN
18637	14167	34	a	a	DT
18637	14167	35	promissory	promissory	JJ
18637	14167	36	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	14167	37	by	by	IN
18637	14167	38	the	the	DT
18637	14167	39	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	14167	40	which	which	WDT
18637	14167	41	was	be	VBD
18637	14167	42	never	never	RB
18637	14167	43	complied	comply	VBN
18637	14167	44	with	with	IN
18637	14167	45	,	,	,
18637	14167	46	the	the	DT
18637	14167	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14167	48	in	in	IN
18637	14167	49	the	the	DT
18637	14167	50	forum	forum	NN
18637	14167	51	State	State	NNP
18637	14167	52	was	be	VBD
18637	14167	53	not	not	RB
18637	14167	54	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	14167	55	full	full	JJ
18637	14167	56	faith	faith	NN
18637	14167	57	and	and	CC
18637	14167	58	credit	credit	NN
18637	14167	59	to	to	IN
18637	14167	60	the	the	DT
18637	14167	61	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14167	62	.	.	.
18637	14168	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	14168	2	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	14168	3	was	be	VBD
18637	14168	4	properly	properly	RB
18637	14168	5	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	14168	6	,	,	,
18637	14168	7	not	not	RB
18637	14168	8	to	to	TO
18637	14168	9	contradict	contradict	VB
18637	14168	10	the	the	DT
18637	14168	11	legal	legal	JJ
18637	14168	12	import	import	NN
18637	14168	13	of	of	IN
18637	14168	14	said	say	VBN
18637	14168	15	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14168	16	,	,	,
18637	14168	17	but	but	CC
18637	14168	18	to	to	TO
18637	14168	19	show	show	VB
18637	14168	20	the	the	DT
18637	14168	21	true	true	JJ
18637	14168	22	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	14168	23	of	of	IN
18637	14168	24	the	the	DT
18637	14168	25	parties	party	NNS
18637	14168	26	to	to	IN
18637	14168	27	the	the	DT
18637	14168	28	suit	suit	NN
18637	14168	29	in	in	IN
18637	14168	30	agreeing	agree	VBG
18637	14168	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	14168	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14168	33	discontinuance	discontinuance	NN
18637	14168	34	.	.	.
18637	14169	1	Jacobs	Jacobs	NNP
18637	14169	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14169	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14169	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14169	5	Marks	Marks	NNP
18637	14169	6	,	,	,
18637	14169	7	182	182	CD
18637	14169	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14169	9	583	583	CD
18637	14169	10	,	,	,
18637	14169	11	593	593	CD
18637	14169	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14169	13	1901	1901	CD
18637	14169	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14169	15	.	.	.
18637	14170	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14170	2	17	17	CD
18637	14170	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14170	4	Anglo	anglo	JJ
18637	14170	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	14170	6	American	American	NNP
18637	14170	7	Provision	Provision	NNP
18637	14170	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14170	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14170	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14170	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14170	12	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	14170	13	Provision	Provision	NNP
18637	14170	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14170	15	,	,	,
18637	14170	16	191	191	CD
18637	14170	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14170	18	373	373	CD
18637	14170	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14170	20	1903	1903	CD
18637	14170	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14170	22	.	.	.
18637	14171	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14171	2	18	18	CD
18637	14171	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14171	4	Fauntleroy	Fauntleroy	NNP
18637	14171	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14171	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14171	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14171	8	Lum	Lum	NNP
18637	14171	9	,	,	,
18637	14171	10	210	210	CD
18637	14171	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14171	12	230	230	CD
18637	14171	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14171	14	1908	1908	CD
18637	14171	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14171	16	.	.	.
18637	14172	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14172	2	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	14172	3	,	,	,
18637	14172	4	who	who	WP
18637	14172	5	spoke	speak	VBD
18637	14172	6	for	for	IN
18637	14172	7	the	the	DT
18637	14172	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14172	9	in	in	IN
18637	14172	10	both	both	DT
18637	14172	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	14172	12	,	,	,
18637	14172	13	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	14172	14	in	in	IN
18637	14172	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14172	16	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	14172	17	in	in	IN
18637	14172	18	the	the	DT
18637	14172	19	latter	latter	JJ
18637	14172	20	that	that	IN
18637	14172	21	the	the	DT
18637	14172	22	New	New	NNP
18637	14172	23	York	York	NNP
18637	14172	24	statute	statute	NN
18637	14172	25	was	be	VBD
18637	14172	26	"	"	``
18637	14172	27	directed	direct	VBN
18637	14172	28	to	to	IN
18637	14172	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14172	30	,	,	,
18637	14172	31	"	"	''
18637	14172	32	the	the	DT
18637	14172	33	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	14172	34	statute	statute	NN
18637	14172	35	to	to	IN
18637	14172	36	"	"	``
18637	14172	37	merits	merit	NNS
18637	14172	38	,	,	,
18637	14172	39	"	"	''
18637	14172	40	but	but	CC
18637	14172	41	four	four	CD
18637	14172	42	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	14172	43	could	could	MD
18637	14172	44	not	not	RB
18637	14172	45	grasp	grasp	VB
18637	14172	46	the	the	DT
18637	14172	47	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	14172	48	.	.	.
18637	14173	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14173	2	19	19	CD
18637	14173	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14173	4	Kenney	Kenney	NNP
18637	14173	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14173	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14173	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14173	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14173	9	Lodge	Lodge	NNP
18637	14173	10	,	,	,
18637	14173	11	252	252	CD
18637	14173	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14173	13	411	411	CD
18637	14173	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14173	15	1920	1920	CD
18637	14173	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14173	17	,	,	,
18637	14173	18	and	and	CC
18637	14173	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	14173	20	there	there	RB
18637	14173	21	cited	cite	VBD
18637	14173	22	.	.	.
18637	14174	1	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	14174	2	again	again	RB
18637	14174	3	spoke	speak	VBD
18637	14174	4	for	for	IN
18637	14174	5	the	the	DT
18637	14174	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14174	7	.	.	.
18637	14175	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14175	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14175	3	also	also	RB
18637	14175	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14175	5	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	14175	6	,	,	,
18637	14175	7	The	the	DT
18637	14175	8	Powers	power	NNS
18637	14175	9	of	of	IN
18637	14175	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14175	11	Under	under	IN
18637	14175	12	the	the	DT
18637	14175	13	Full	Full	NNP
18637	14175	14	Faith	Faith	NNP
18637	14175	15	and	and	CC
18637	14175	16	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	14175	17	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	14175	18	,	,	,
18637	14175	19	28	28	CD
18637	14175	20	Yale	Yale	NNP
18637	14175	21	L.J.	L.J.	NNP
18637	14176	1	421	421	CD
18637	14176	2	,	,	,
18637	14176	3	434	434	CD
18637	14176	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14176	5	1919	1919	CD
18637	14176	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14176	7	.	.	.
18637	14177	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14177	2	20	20	CD
18637	14177	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14177	4	Broderick	Broderick	NNP
18637	14177	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14177	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14177	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14177	8	Rosner	Rosner	NNP
18637	14177	9	,	,	,
18637	14177	10	294	294	CD
18637	14177	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14177	12	629	629	CD
18637	14177	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14177	14	1935	1935	CD
18637	14177	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14177	16	,	,	,
18637	14177	17	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	14177	18	in	in	IN
18637	14177	19	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	14177	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14177	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	14177	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14177	23	Fetter	Fetter	NNP
18637	14177	24	,	,	,
18637	14177	25	341	341	CD
18637	14177	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14177	27	609	609	CD
18637	14177	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14177	29	1951	1951	CD
18637	14177	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14177	31	.	.	.
18637	14178	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14178	2	21	21	CD
18637	14178	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14178	4	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14178	5	National	National	NNP
18637	14178	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	14178	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14178	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14178	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14178	10	Lamb	Lamb	NNP
18637	14178	11	,	,	,
18637	14178	12	337	337	CD
18637	14178	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14178	14	38	38	CD
18637	14178	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14178	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	14178	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14178	18	;	;	:
18637	14178	19	_	_	NNP
18637	14178	20	see	see	VB
18637	14178	21	also	also	RB
18637	14178	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14178	23	Roche	Roche	NNP
18637	14178	24	_	_	NNP
18637	14178	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	14178	26	_	_	NNP
18637	14178	27	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	14178	28	,	,	,
18637	14178	29	275	275	CD
18637	14178	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14178	31	449	449	CD
18637	14178	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14178	33	1928	1928	CD
18637	14178	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14178	35	.	.	.
18637	14179	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14179	2	22	22	CD
18637	14179	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14179	4	Embry	Embry	NNP
18637	14179	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14179	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14179	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14179	8	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	14179	9	,	,	,
18637	14179	10	107	107	CD
18637	14179	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14179	12	3	3	CD
18637	14179	13	,	,	,
18637	14179	14	13	13	CD
18637	14179	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14179	16	1883	1883	CD
18637	14179	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14179	18	.	.	.
18637	14180	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14180	2	23	23	CD
18637	14180	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14180	4	Titus	Titus	NNP
18637	14180	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14180	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14180	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14180	8	Wallick	Wallick	NNP
18637	14180	9	,	,	,
18637	14180	10	306	306	CD
18637	14180	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14180	12	282	282	CD
18637	14180	13	,	,	,
18637	14180	14	291	291	CD
18637	14180	15	-	-	SYM
18637	14180	16	292	292	CD
18637	14180	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14180	18	1939	1939	CD
18637	14180	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14180	20	.	.	.
18637	14181	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14181	2	24	24	CD
18637	14181	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14181	4	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	14181	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14181	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14181	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14181	8	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	14181	9	,	,	,
18637	14181	10	329	329	CD
18637	14181	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14181	12	545	545	CD
18637	14181	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14181	14	1947	1947	CD
18637	14181	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14181	16	.	.	.
18637	14182	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14182	2	25	25	CD
18637	14182	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14182	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	14182	5	why	why	WRB
18637	14182	6	should	should	MD
18637	14182	7	not	not	RB
18637	14182	8	a	a	DT
18637	14182	9	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14182	10	for	for	IN
18637	14182	11	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	14182	12	be	be	VB
18637	14182	13	made	make	VBN
18637	14182	14	directly	directly	RB
18637	14182	15	enforceable	enforceable	JJ
18637	14182	16	in	in	IN
18637	14182	17	sister	sister	NN
18637	14182	18	States	States	NNP
18637	14182	19	instead	instead	RB
18637	14182	20	of	of	IN
18637	14182	21	merely	merely	RB
18637	14182	22	furnishing	furnish	VBG
18637	14182	23	the	the	DT
18637	14182	24	basis	basis	NN
18637	14182	25	of	of	IN
18637	14182	26	an	an	DT
18637	14182	27	action	action	NN
18637	14182	28	in	in	IN
18637	14182	29	debt	debt	NN
18637	14182	30	?	?	.
18637	14183	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14183	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14183	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14183	4	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	14183	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14183	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14183	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14183	8	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	14183	9	,	,	,
18637	14183	10	226	226	CD
18637	14183	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14183	12	551	551	CD
18637	14183	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14183	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	14183	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14183	16	.	.	.
18637	14184	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14184	2	26	26	CD
18637	14184	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14184	4	Board	Board	NNP
18637	14184	5	of	of	IN
18637	14184	6	Public	Public	NNP
18637	14184	7	Works	Works	NNP
18637	14184	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14184	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	14184	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14184	11	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	14184	12	College	College	NNP
18637	14184	13	,	,	,
18637	14184	14	17	17	CD
18637	14184	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14184	16	.	.	.
18637	14185	1	521	521	CD
18637	14185	2	,	,	,
18637	14185	3	528	528	CD
18637	14185	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14185	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	14185	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14185	7	.	.	.
18637	14186	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14186	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14186	3	also	also	RB
18637	14186	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14186	5	Spokane	Spokane	NNP
18637	14186	6	&	&	CC
18637	14186	7	I.E.R.	I.E.R.	NNP
18637	14187	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14187	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14187	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14187	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14187	5	Whitley	Whitley	NNP
18637	14187	6	,	,	,
18637	14187	7	237	237	CD
18637	14187	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14187	9	487	487	CD
18637	14187	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14187	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	14187	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14187	13	;	;	:
18637	14187	14	Bigelow	Bigelow	NNP
18637	14187	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14187	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	14187	17	_	_	NNP
18637	14187	18	Old	Old	NNP
18637	14187	19	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	14187	20	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	14187	21	Min	Min	NNP
18637	14187	22	.	.	.
18637	14188	1	&	&	CC
18637	14188	2	S.	S.	NNP
18637	14188	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14188	4	,	,	,
18637	14188	5	225	225	CD
18637	14188	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14188	7	111	111	CD
18637	14188	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14188	9	1912	1912	CD
18637	14188	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14188	11	;	;	:
18637	14188	12	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	14188	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14188	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	14188	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14188	16	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	14188	17	,	,	,
18637	14188	18	210	210	CD
18637	14188	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14188	20	82	82	CD
18637	14188	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14188	22	1908	1908	CD
18637	14188	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14188	24	;	;	:
18637	14188	25	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	14188	26	_	_	NNP
18637	14188	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	14188	28	_	_	NNP
18637	14188	29	Pelican	Pelican	NNP
18637	14188	30	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14188	31	.	.	.
18637	14189	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14189	2	,	,	,
18637	14189	3	127	127	CD
18637	14189	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14189	5	265	265	CD
18637	14189	6	,	,	,
18637	14189	7	291	291	CD
18637	14189	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14189	9	1888	1888	CD
18637	14189	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14189	11	;	;	:
18637	14189	12	Huntington	Huntington	NNP
18637	14189	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14189	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	14189	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14189	16	Attrill	Attrill	NNP
18637	14189	17	,	,	,
18637	14189	18	146	146	CD
18637	14189	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14189	20	657	657	CD
18637	14189	21	,	,	,
18637	14189	22	685	685	CD
18637	14189	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14189	24	1892	1892	CD
18637	14189	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14189	26	.	.	.
18637	14190	1	However	however	RB
18637	14190	2	a	a	DT
18637	14190	3	denial	denial	NN
18637	14190	4	of	of	IN
18637	14190	5	credit	credit	NN
18637	14190	6	,	,	,
18637	14190	7	founded	found	VBN
18637	14190	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	14190	9	a	a	DT
18637	14190	10	mere	mere	JJ
18637	14190	11	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	14190	12	of	of	IN
18637	14190	13	want	want	NN
18637	14190	14	of	of	IN
18637	14190	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14190	16	and	and	CC
18637	14190	17	unsupported	unsupporte	VBN
18637	14190	18	by	by	IN
18637	14190	19	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	14190	20	,	,	,
18637	14190	21	violates	violate	VBZ
18637	14190	22	the	the	DT
18637	14190	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	14190	24	.	.	.
18637	14191	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14191	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14191	3	also	also	RB
18637	14191	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14191	5	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	14191	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14191	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14191	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14191	9	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	14191	10	,	,	,
18637	14191	11	192	192	CD
18637	14191	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14191	13	226	226	CD
18637	14191	14	,	,	,
18637	14191	15	231	231	CD
18637	14191	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14191	17	1904	1904	CD
18637	14191	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14191	19	;	;	:
18637	14191	20	Wells	Wells	NNP
18637	14191	21	Fargo	Fargo	NNP
18637	14191	22	&	&	CC
18637	14191	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14191	24	_	_	NNP
18637	14191	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	14191	26	_	_	NNP
18637	14191	27	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	14191	28	,	,	,
18637	14191	29	238	238	CD
18637	14191	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14191	31	503	503	CD
18637	14191	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14191	33	1915	1915	CD
18637	14191	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14191	35	.	.	.
18637	14192	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14192	2	27	27	CD
18637	14192	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14192	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14192	5	See	See	NNP
18637	14192	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14192	7	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	14192	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14192	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	14192	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14192	11	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	14192	12	,	,	,
18637	14192	13	10	10	CD
18637	14192	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14192	15	.	.	.
18637	14193	1	308	308	CD
18637	14193	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14193	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	14193	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14193	5	.	.	.
18637	14194	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14194	2	28	28	CD
18637	14194	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14194	4	11	11	CD
18637	14194	5	How	how	WRB
18637	14194	6	.	.	.
18637	14195	1	165	165	CD
18637	14195	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14195	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	14195	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14195	5	.	.	.
18637	14196	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14196	2	29	29	CD
18637	14196	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14196	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14196	5	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	14196	6	,	,	,
18637	14196	7	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	14196	8	in	in	IN
18637	14196	9	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	14196	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14196	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	14196	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14196	13	Duryee	Duryee	NNP
18637	14196	14	,	,	,
18637	14196	15	7	7	CD
18637	14196	16	Cr	cr	NN
18637	14196	17	.	.	.
18637	14197	1	481	481	CD
18637	14197	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14197	3	1813	1813	CD
18637	14197	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14197	5	,	,	,
18637	14197	6	had	have	VBD
18637	14197	7	said	say	VBD
18637	14197	8	:	:	:
18637	14197	9	"	"	``
18637	14197	10	There	there	EX
18637	14197	11	are	be	VBP
18637	14197	12	certain	certain	JJ
18637	14197	13	eternal	eternal	JJ
18637	14197	14	principles	principle	NNS
18637	14197	15	of	of	IN
18637	14197	16	justice	justice	NN
18637	14197	17	which	which	WDT
18637	14197	18	never	never	RB
18637	14197	19	ought	ought	MD
18637	14197	20	to	to	TO
18637	14197	21	be	be	VB
18637	14197	22	dispensed	dispense	VBN
18637	14197	23	with	with	IN
18637	14197	24	,	,	,
18637	14197	25	and	and	CC
18637	14197	26	which	which	WDT
18637	14197	27	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	14197	28	of	of	IN
18637	14197	29	justice	justice	NN
18637	14197	30	never	never	RB
18637	14197	31	can	can	MD
18637	14197	32	dispense	dispense	VB
18637	14197	33	with	with	IN
18637	14197	34	but	but	CC
18637	14197	35	when	when	WRB
18637	14197	36	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	14197	37	by	by	IN
18637	14197	38	positive	positive	JJ
18637	14197	39	statute	statute	NN
18637	14197	40	.	.	.
18637	14198	1	One	one	CD
18637	14198	2	of	of	IN
18637	14198	3	those	those	DT
18637	14198	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	14198	5	,	,	,
18637	14198	6	that	that	DT
18637	14198	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14198	8	can	can	MD
18637	14198	9	not	not	RB
18637	14198	10	be	be	VB
18637	14198	11	justly	justly	RB
18637	14198	12	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	14198	13	by	by	IN
18637	14198	14	a	a	DT
18637	14198	15	State	State	NNP
18637	14198	16	over	over	IN
18637	14198	17	property	property	NN
18637	14198	18	not	not	RB
18637	14198	19	within	within	IN
18637	14198	20	the	the	DT
18637	14198	21	reach	reach	NN
18637	14198	22	of	of	IN
18637	14198	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14198	24	process	process	NN
18637	14198	25	,	,	,
18637	14198	26	or	or	CC
18637	14198	27	over	over	IN
18637	14198	28	persons	person	NNS
18637	14198	29	not	not	RB
18637	14198	30	owing	owe	VBG
18637	14198	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14198	32	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	14198	33	or	or	CC
18637	14198	34	not	not	RB
18637	14198	35	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	14198	36	to	to	IN
18637	14198	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14198	38	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14198	39	,	,	,
18637	14198	40	by	by	IN
18637	14198	41	being	be	VBG
18637	14198	42	found	find	VBN
18637	14198	43	within	within	IN
18637	14198	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14198	45	limits	limit	NNS
18637	14198	46	.	.	.
18637	14198	47	"	"	''
18637	14199	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	14199	2	.	.	.
18637	14200	1	486	486	CD
18637	14200	2	.	.	.
18637	14201	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14201	2	30	30	CD
18637	14201	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14201	4	95	95	CD
18637	14201	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14201	6	714	714	CD
18637	14201	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14201	8	1878	1878	CD
18637	14201	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14201	10	.	.	.
18637	14202	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14202	2	31	31	CD
18637	14202	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14202	4	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	14202	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14202	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14202	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14202	8	Mabee	Mabee	NNP
18637	14202	9	,	,	,
18637	14202	10	243	243	CD
18637	14202	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14202	12	90	90	CD
18637	14202	13	,	,	,
18637	14202	14	92	92	CD
18637	14202	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14202	16	1917	1917	CD
18637	14202	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14202	18	.	.	.
18637	14203	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14203	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14203	3	also	also	RB
18637	14203	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14203	5	Wetmore	Wetmore	NNP
18637	14203	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14203	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14203	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14203	9	Karrick	Karrick	NNP
18637	14203	10	,	,	,
18637	14203	11	205	205	CD
18637	14203	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14203	13	141	141	CD
18637	14203	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14203	15	1907	1907	CD
18637	14203	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14203	17	.	.	.
18637	14204	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14204	2	32	32	CD
18637	14204	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14204	4	Grover	Grover	NNP
18637	14204	5	&	&	CC
18637	14204	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	14204	7	Sewing	Sewing	NNP
18637	14204	8	-	-	:
18637	14204	9	Mach	Mach	NNP
18637	14204	10	.	.	.
18637	14205	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14205	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14205	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14205	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14205	5	Radcliffe	Radcliffe	NNP
18637	14205	6	,	,	,
18637	14205	7	137	137	CD
18637	14205	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14205	9	287	287	CD
18637	14205	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14205	11	1890	1890	CD
18637	14205	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14205	13	.	.	.
18637	14206	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14206	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14206	3	also	also	RB
18637	14206	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14206	5	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	14206	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14206	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14206	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14206	9	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	14206	10	,	,	,
18637	14206	11	210	210	CD
18637	14206	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14206	13	82	82	CD
18637	14206	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14206	15	1908	1908	CD
18637	14206	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14206	17	;	;	:
18637	14206	18	Galpin	Galpin	NNP
18637	14206	19	_	_	NNP
18637	14206	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	14206	21	_	_	NNP
18637	14206	22	Page	Page	NNP
18637	14206	23	,	,	,
18637	14206	24	18	18	CD
18637	14206	25	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14206	26	.	.	.
18637	14207	1	350	350	CD
18637	14207	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14207	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	14207	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14207	5	;	;	:
18637	14207	6	Old	Old	NNP
18637	14207	7	Wayne	Wayne	NNP
18637	14207	8	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	14207	9	Life	Life	NNP
18637	14207	10	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	14207	11	.	.	.
18637	14208	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14208	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14208	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14208	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14208	5	McDonough	McDonough	NNP
18637	14208	6	,	,	,
18637	14208	7	204	204	CD
18637	14208	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14208	9	8	8	CD
18637	14208	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14208	11	1907	1907	CD
18637	14208	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14208	13	.	.	.
18637	14209	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14209	2	33	33	CD
18637	14209	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14209	4	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	14209	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14209	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14209	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14209	8	Stockton	Stockton	NNP
18637	14209	9	,	,	,
18637	14209	10	140	140	CD
18637	14209	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14209	12	254	254	CD
18637	14209	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14209	14	1891	1891	CD
18637	14209	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14209	16	.	.	.
18637	14210	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14210	2	34	34	CD
18637	14210	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14210	4	Renaud	Renaud	NNP
18637	14210	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14210	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14210	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14210	8	Abbott	Abbott	NNP
18637	14210	9	,	,	,
18637	14210	10	116	116	CD
18637	14210	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14210	12	277	277	CD
18637	14210	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14210	14	1886	1886	CD
18637	14210	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14210	16	;	;	:
18637	14210	17	Jaster	Jaster	NNP
18637	14210	18	_	_	NNP
18637	14210	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	14210	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14210	21	Currie	Currie	NNP
18637	14210	22	,	,	,
18637	14210	23	198	198	CD
18637	14210	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14210	25	144	144	CD
18637	14210	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14210	27	1905	1905	CD
18637	14210	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14210	29	.	.	.
18637	14211	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14211	2	35	35	CD
18637	14211	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14211	4	Milliken	Milliken	NNP
18637	14211	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14211	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14211	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14211	8	Meyer	Meyer	NNP
18637	14211	9	,	,	,
18637	14211	10	311	311	CD
18637	14211	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14211	12	457	457	CD
18637	14211	13	,	,	,
18637	14211	14	463	463	CD
18637	14211	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14211	16	1940	1940	CD
18637	14211	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14211	18	.	.	.
18637	14212	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14212	2	36	36	CD
18637	14212	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14212	4	Adam	Adam	NNP
18637	14212	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14212	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14212	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14212	8	Saenger	Saenger	NNP
18637	14212	9	,	,	,
18637	14212	10	303	303	CD
18637	14212	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14212	12	59	59	CD
18637	14212	13	,	,	,
18637	14212	14	62	62	CD
18637	14212	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14212	16	1938	1938	CD
18637	14212	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14212	18	.	.	.
18637	14213	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14213	2	37	37	CD
18637	14213	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14213	4	Hancock	Hancock	NNP
18637	14213	5	National	National	NNP
18637	14213	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	14213	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14213	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14213	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14213	10	Farnum	Farnum	NNP
18637	14213	11	,	,	,
18637	14213	12	176	176	CD
18637	14213	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14213	14	640	640	CD
18637	14213	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14213	16	1900	1900	CD
18637	14213	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14213	18	.	.	.
18637	14214	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14214	2	38	38	CD
18637	14214	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14214	4	Stacy	Stacy	NNP
18637	14214	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14214	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14214	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14214	8	Thrasher	Thrasher	NNP
18637	14214	9	,	,	,
18637	14214	10	use	use	NN
18637	14214	11	of	of	IN
18637	14214	12	Sellers	seller	NNS
18637	14214	13	,	,	,
18637	14214	14	6	6	CD
18637	14214	15	How	how	WRB
18637	14214	16	.	.	.
18637	14215	1	44	44	CD
18637	14215	2	,	,	,
18637	14215	3	58	58	CD
18637	14215	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14215	5	1848	1848	CD
18637	14215	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14215	7	.	.	.
18637	14216	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14216	2	39	39	CD
18637	14216	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14216	4	Bigelow	Bigelow	NNP
18637	14216	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14216	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14216	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14216	8	Old	Old	NNP
18637	14216	9	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	14216	10	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	14216	11	Min	Min	NNP
18637	14216	12	.	.	.
18637	14217	1	&	&	CC
18637	14217	2	S.	S.	NNP
18637	14217	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14217	4	,	,	,
18637	14217	5	225	225	CD
18637	14217	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14217	7	111	111	CD
18637	14217	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14217	9	1912	1912	CD
18637	14217	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14217	11	.	.	.
18637	14218	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14218	2	40	40	CD
18637	14218	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14218	4	18	18	CD
18637	14218	5	How	how	WRB
18637	14218	6	.	.	.
18637	14219	1	404	404	CD
18637	14219	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14219	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	14219	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14219	5	.	.	.
18637	14220	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14220	2	41	41	CD
18637	14220	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14220	4	To	to	IN
18637	14220	5	the	the	DT
18637	14220	6	same	same	JJ
18637	14220	7	effect	effect	NN
18637	14220	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	14220	9	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	14220	10	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	14220	11	.	.	.
18637	14221	1	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14221	2	.	.	.
18637	14222	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14222	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14222	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14222	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14222	5	Spratley	Spratley	NNP
18637	14222	6	,	,	,
18637	14222	7	172	172	CD
18637	14222	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14222	9	602	602	CD
18637	14222	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14222	11	1899	1899	CD
18637	14222	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14222	13	.	.	.
18637	14223	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14223	2	42	42	CD
18637	14223	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14223	4	Simon	Simon	NNP
18637	14223	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14223	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14223	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14223	8	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	14223	9	Ky.	Kentucky	NNP
18637	14223	10	,	,	,
18637	14223	11	236	236	CD
18637	14223	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14223	13	115	115	CD
18637	14223	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14223	15	1915	1915	CD
18637	14223	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14223	17	.	.	.
18637	14224	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14224	2	43	43	CD
18637	14224	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14224	4	Goldey	Goldey	NNP
18637	14224	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14224	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14224	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14224	8	Morning	Morning	NNP
18637	14224	9	News	News	NNP
18637	14224	10	,	,	,
18637	14224	11	156	156	CD
18637	14224	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14224	13	518	518	CD
18637	14224	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14224	15	1895	1895	CD
18637	14224	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14224	17	;	;	:
18637	14224	18	Riverside	Riverside	NNP
18637	14224	19	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	14224	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14224	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	14224	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14224	23	Menefee	Menefee	NNP
18637	14224	24	,	,	,
18637	14224	25	237	237	CD
18637	14224	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14224	27	189	189	CD
18637	14224	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14224	29	1915	1915	CD
18637	14224	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14224	31	.	.	.
18637	14225	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14225	2	44	44	CD
18637	14225	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14225	4	International	International	NNP
18637	14225	5	Harvester	Harvester	NNP
18637	14225	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14225	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14225	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14225	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14225	10	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	14225	11	,	,	,
18637	14225	12	234	234	CD
18637	14225	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14225	14	579	579	CD
18637	14225	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14225	16	1914	1914	CD
18637	14225	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14225	18	;	;	:
18637	14225	19	Riverside	Riverside	NNP
18637	14225	20	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	14225	21	_	_	NNP
18637	14225	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	14225	23	_	_	NNP
18637	14225	24	Menefee	Menefee	NNP
18637	14225	25	,	,	,
18637	14225	26	237	237	CD
18637	14225	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14225	28	189	189	CD
18637	14225	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14225	30	1915	1915	CD
18637	14225	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14225	32	.	.	.
18637	14226	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14226	2	45	45	CD
18637	14226	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14226	4	International	International	NNP
18637	14226	5	Harvester	Harvester	NNP
18637	14226	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14226	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14226	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14226	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14226	10	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	14226	11	,	,	,
18637	14226	12	234	234	CD
18637	14226	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14226	14	579	579	CD
18637	14226	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14226	16	1914	1914	CD
18637	14226	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14226	18	.	.	.
18637	14227	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14227	2	46	46	CD
18637	14227	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14227	4	Kane	Kane	NNP
18637	14227	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14227	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14227	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14227	8	New	New	NNP
18637	14227	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	14227	10	,	,	,
18637	14227	11	242	242	CD
18637	14227	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14227	13	160	160	CD
18637	14227	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14227	15	1916	1916	CD
18637	14227	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14227	17	;	;	:
18637	14227	18	Hess	Hess	NNP
18637	14227	19	_	_	NNP
18637	14227	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	14227	21	_	_	NNP
18637	14227	22	Pawloski	Pawloski	NNP
18637	14227	23	,	,	,
18637	14227	24	274	274	CD
18637	14227	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14227	26	352	352	CD
18637	14227	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14227	28	1927	1927	CD
18637	14227	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14227	30	.	.	.
18637	14228	1	Limited	limited	JJ
18637	14228	2	in	in	IN
18637	14228	3	Wuchter	Wuchter	NNP
18637	14228	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14228	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	14228	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14228	7	Pizzutti	Pizzutti	NNP
18637	14228	8	,	,	,
18637	14228	9	276	276	CD
18637	14228	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14228	11	13	13	CD
18637	14228	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14228	13	1928	1928	CD
18637	14228	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14228	15	.	.	.
18637	14229	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14229	2	47	47	CD
18637	14229	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14229	4	18	18	CD
18637	14229	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14229	6	.	.	.
18637	14230	1	457	457	CD
18637	14230	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14230	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	14230	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14230	5	.	.	.
18637	14231	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14231	2	48	48	CD
18637	14231	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14231	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14231	5	See	See	NNP
18637	14231	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14231	7	1	1	CD
18637	14231	8	Black	Black	NNP
18637	14231	9	,	,	,
18637	14231	10	Judgments	Judgments	NNP
18637	14231	11	§	§	NNP
18637	14231	12	246	246	CD
18637	14231	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14231	14	1891	1891	CD
18637	14231	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14231	16	.	.	.
18637	14232	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14232	2	49	49	CD
18637	14232	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14232	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14232	5	See	See	NNP
18637	14232	6	also	also	RB
18637	14232	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14232	8	Simmons	Simmons	NNP
18637	14232	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14232	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14232	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14232	12	Saul	Saul	NNP
18637	14232	13	,	,	,
18637	14232	14	138	138	CD
18637	14232	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14232	16	439	439	CD
18637	14232	17	,	,	,
18637	14232	18	448	448	CD
18637	14232	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14232	20	1891	1891	CD
18637	14232	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14232	22	.	.	.
18637	14233	1	In	in	IN
18637	14233	2	other	other	JJ
18637	14233	3	words	word	NNS
18637	14233	4	,	,	,
18637	14233	5	the	the	DT
18637	14233	6	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	14233	7	to	to	IN
18637	14233	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14233	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	14233	10	treated	treat	VBN
18637	14233	11	as	as	IN
18637	14233	12	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
18637	14233	13	to	to	IN
18637	14233	14	the	the	DT
18637	14233	15	plea	plea	NN
18637	14233	16	_	_	NNP
18637	14233	17	nul	nul	NNP
18637	14233	18	tiel	tiel	NNP
18637	14233	19	record	record	NNP
18637	14233	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14233	21	,	,	,
18637	14233	22	a	a	DT
18637	14233	23	plea	plea	NN
18637	14233	24	which	which	WDT
18637	14233	25	was	be	VBD
18637	14233	26	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	14233	27	even	even	RB
18637	14233	28	in	in	IN
18637	14233	29	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	14233	30	_	_	NNP
18637	14233	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	14233	32	_	_	NNP
18637	14233	33	Duryee	Duryee	NNP
18637	14233	34	as	as	IN
18637	14233	35	always	always	RB
18637	14233	36	available	available	JJ
18637	14233	37	against	against	IN
18637	14233	38	an	an	DT
18637	14233	39	attempted	attempt	VBN
18637	14233	40	invocation	invocation	NN
18637	14233	41	of	of	IN
18637	14233	42	the	the	DT
18637	14233	43	full	full	JJ
18637	14233	44	faith	faith	NN
18637	14233	45	and	and	CC
18637	14233	46	credit	credit	NN
18637	14233	47	clause	clause	NN
18637	14233	48	.	.	.
18637	14234	1	What	what	WP
18637	14234	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	14234	3	not	not	RB
18637	14234	4	pointed	point	VBN
18637	14234	5	out	out	RP
18637	14234	6	by	by	IN
18637	14234	7	the	the	DT
18637	14234	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14234	9	,	,	,
18637	14234	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	14234	11	that	that	IN
18637	14234	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14234	13	was	be	VBD
18637	14234	14	also	also	RB
18637	14234	15	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	14234	16	in	in	IN
18637	14234	17	the	the	DT
18637	14234	18	earlier	early	JJR
18637	14234	19	case	case	NN
18637	14234	20	that	that	IN
18637	14234	21	such	such	PDT
18637	14234	22	a	a	DT
18637	14234	23	plea	plea	NN
18637	14234	24	could	could	MD
18637	14234	25	always	always	RB
18637	14234	26	be	be	VB
18637	14234	27	rebutted	rebut	VBN
18637	14234	28	by	by	IN
18637	14234	29	producing	produce	VBG
18637	14234	30	a	a	DT
18637	14234	31	transcript	transcript	NN
18637	14234	32	,	,	,
18637	14234	33	properly	properly	RB
18637	14234	34	authenticated	authenticate	VBN
18637	14234	35	in	in	IN
18637	14234	36	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	14234	37	with	with	IN
18637	14234	38	the	the	DT
18637	14234	39	act	act	NN
18637	14234	40	of	of	IN
18637	14234	41	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14234	42	,	,	,
18637	14234	43	of	of	IN
18637	14234	44	the	the	DT
18637	14234	45	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14234	46	in	in	IN
18637	14234	47	the	the	DT
18637	14234	48	original	original	JJ
18637	14234	49	case	case	NN
18637	14234	50	.	.	.
18637	14235	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14235	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14235	3	also	also	RB
18637	14235	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14235	5	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	14235	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14235	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14235	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14235	9	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	14235	10	,	,	,
18637	14235	11	210	210	CD
18637	14235	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14235	13	82	82	CD
18637	14235	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14235	15	1908	1908	CD
18637	14235	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14235	17	;	;	:
18637	14235	18	German	German	NNP
18637	14235	19	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	14235	20	Society	Society	NNP
18637	14235	21	_	_	NNP
18637	14235	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	14235	23	_	_	NNP
18637	14235	24	Dormitzer	Dormitzer	NNP
18637	14235	25	,	,	,
18637	14235	26	192	192	CD
18637	14235	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14235	28	125	125	CD
18637	14235	29	,	,	,
18637	14235	30	128	128	CD
18637	14235	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14235	32	1904	1904	CD
18637	14235	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14235	34	;	;	:
18637	14235	35	Grover	Grover	NNP
18637	14235	36	&	&	CC
18637	14235	37	Sewing	Sewing	NNP
18637	14235	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	14235	39	Mach	Mach	NNP
18637	14235	40	.	.	.
18637	14236	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14236	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14236	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14236	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14236	5	Radcliffe	Radcliffe	NNP
18637	14236	6	,	,	,
18637	14236	7	137	137	CD
18637	14236	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14236	9	287	287	CD
18637	14236	10	,	,	,
18637	14236	11	294	294	CD
18637	14236	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14236	13	1890	1890	CD
18637	14236	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14236	15	.	.	.
18637	14237	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14237	2	50	50	CD
18637	14237	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14237	4	Cheever	Cheever	NNP
18637	14237	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14237	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14237	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14237	8	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	14237	9	,	,	,
18637	14237	10	9	9	CD
18637	14237	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14237	12	.	.	.
18637	14238	1	108	108	CD
18637	14238	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14238	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	14238	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14238	5	.	.	.
18637	14239	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14239	2	51	51	CD
18637	14239	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14239	4	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
18637	14239	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14239	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14239	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14239	8	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
18637	14239	9	,	,	,
18637	14239	10	188	188	CD
18637	14239	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14239	12	14	14	CD
18637	14239	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14239	14	1903	1903	CD
18637	14239	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14239	16	.	.	.
18637	14240	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14240	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14240	3	also	also	RB
18637	14240	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14240	5	German	German	NNP
18637	14240	6	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	14240	7	Society	Society	NNP
18637	14240	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14240	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	14240	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14240	11	Dormitzer	Dormitzer	NNP
18637	14240	12	,	,	,
18637	14240	13	192	192	CD
18637	14240	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14240	15	125	125	CD
18637	14240	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14240	17	1904	1904	CD
18637	14240	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14240	19	.	.	.
18637	14241	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14241	2	52	52	CD
18637	14241	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14241	4	201	201	CD
18637	14241	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14241	6	562	562	CD
18637	14241	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14241	8	1906	1906	CD
18637	14241	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14241	10	.	.	.
18637	14242	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14242	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14242	3	also	also	RB
18637	14242	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14242	5	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	14242	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14242	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14242	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14242	9	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	14242	10	,	,	,
18637	14242	11	226	226	CD
18637	14242	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14242	13	551	551	CD
18637	14242	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14242	15	1913	1913	CD
18637	14242	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14242	17	.	.	.
18637	14243	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14243	2	53	53	CD
18637	14243	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14243	4	181	181	CD
18637	14243	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14243	6	155	155	CD
18637	14243	7	,	,	,
18637	14243	8	162	162	CD
18637	14243	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14243	10	1901	1901	CD
18637	14243	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14243	12	.	.	.
18637	14244	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14244	2	54	54	CD
18637	14244	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14244	4	317	317	CD
18637	14244	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14244	6	287	287	CD
18637	14244	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14244	8	1942	1942	CD
18637	14244	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14244	10	;	;	:
18637	14244	11	325	325	CD
18637	14244	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14244	13	226	226	CD
18637	14244	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14244	15	1945	1945	CD
18637	14244	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14244	17	.	.	.
18637	14245	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14245	2	55	55	CD
18637	14245	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14245	4	305	305	CD
18637	14245	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14245	6	32	32	CD
18637	14245	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14245	8	1938	1938	CD
18637	14245	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14245	10	.	.	.
18637	14246	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14246	2	56	56	CD
18637	14246	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14246	4	317	317	CD
18637	14246	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14246	6	287	287	CD
18637	14246	7	,	,	,
18637	14246	8	298	298	CD
18637	14246	9	-	-	SYM
18637	14246	10	299	299	CD
18637	14246	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14246	12	1942	1942	CD
18637	14246	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14246	14	.	.	.
18637	14247	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14247	2	57	57	CD
18637	14247	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14247	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14247	5	.	.	.
18637	14248	1	at	at	IN
18637	14248	2	p.	p.	NN
18637	14248	3	302	302	CD
18637	14248	4	.	.	.
18637	14249	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14249	2	58	58	CD
18637	14249	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14249	4	317	317	CD
18637	14249	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14249	6	287	287	CD
18637	14249	7	,	,	,
18637	14249	8	312	312	CD
18637	14249	9	,	,	,
18637	14249	10	315	315	CD
18637	14249	11	,	,	,
18637	14249	12	321	321	CD
18637	14249	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14249	14	1942	1942	CD
18637	14249	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14249	16	.	.	.
18637	14250	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14250	2	59	59	CD
18637	14250	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14250	4	325	325	CD
18637	14250	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14250	6	226	226	CD
18637	14250	7	,	,	,
18637	14250	8	229	229	CD
18637	14250	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14250	10	1945	1945	CD
18637	14250	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14250	12	.	.	.
18637	14251	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14251	2	60	60	CD
18637	14251	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14251	4	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	14251	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14251	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14251	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14251	8	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	14251	9	,	,	,
18637	14251	10	181	181	CD
18637	14251	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14251	12	175	175	CD
18637	14251	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14251	14	1901	1901	CD
18637	14251	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14251	16	;	;	:
18637	14251	17	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
18637	14251	18	_	_	NNP
18637	14251	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	14251	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14251	21	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
18637	14251	22	,	,	,
18637	14251	23	188	188	CD
18637	14251	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14251	25	14	14	CD
18637	14251	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14251	27	1903	1903	CD
18637	14251	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14251	29	.	.	.
18637	14252	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14252	2	61	61	CD
18637	14252	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14252	4	Strong	strong	JJ
18637	14252	5	dissents	dissent	NNS
18637	14252	6	were	be	VBD
18637	14252	7	filed	file	VBN
18637	14252	8	which	which	WDT
18637	14252	9	have	have	VBP
18637	14252	10	influenced	influence	VBN
18637	14252	11	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	14252	12	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	14252	13	.	.	.
18637	14253	1	Among	among	IN
18637	14253	2	these	these	DT
18637	14253	3	was	be	VBD
18637	14253	4	that	that	DT
18637	14253	5	of	of	IN
18637	14253	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14253	7	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	14253	8	which	which	WDT
18637	14253	9	attacked	attack	VBD
18637	14253	10	both	both	CC
18637	14253	11	the	the	DT
18637	14253	12	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	14253	13	of	of	IN
18637	14253	14	the	the	DT
18637	14253	15	decision	decision	NN
18637	14253	16	as	as	RB
18637	14253	17	well	well	RB
18637	14253	18	as	as	IN
18637	14253	19	the	the	DT
18637	14253	20	concept	concept	NN
18637	14253	21	of	of	IN
18637	14253	22	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	14253	23	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	14253	24	on	on	IN
18637	14253	25	which	which	WDT
18637	14253	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14253	27	was	be	VBD
18637	14253	28	founded	found	VBN
18637	14253	29	.	.	.
18637	14254	1	"	"	``
18637	14254	2	Unless	unless	IN
18637	14254	3	'	'	''
18637	14254	4	matrimonial	matrimonial	JJ
18637	14254	5	domicil	domicil	NN
18637	14254	6	,	,	,
18637	14254	7	'	'	''
18637	14254	8	banished	banish	VBN
18637	14254	9	in	in	IN
18637	14254	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14254	11	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	14254	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14254	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14254	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14254	15	by	by	IN
18637	14254	16	the	the	DT
18637	14254	17	overruling	overruling	NN
18637	14254	18	of	of	IN
18637	14254	19	Haddock	Haddock	NNP
18637	14254	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14254	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	14254	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14254	23	Haddock	Haddock	NNP
18637	14254	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14254	25	,	,	,
18637	14254	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	14254	27	returned	return	VBN
18637	14254	28	renamed	renamed	NNP
18637	14254	29	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14254	30	'	'	POS
18637	14254	31	domicil	domicil	NN
18637	14254	32	of	of	IN
18637	14254	33	origin	origin	NN
18637	14254	34	'	'	''
18637	14254	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14254	36	in	in	IN
18637	14254	37	_	_	NNP
18637	14254	38	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	14254	39	_	_	NNP
18637	14254	40	II	II	NNP
18637	14254	41	,	,	,
18637	14254	42	every	every	DT
18637	14254	43	decree	decree	NN
18637	14254	44	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	14254	45	vulnerable	vulnerable	JJ
18637	14254	46	in	in	IN
18637	14254	47	every	every	DT
18637	14254	48	State	state	NN
18637	14254	49	.	.	.
18637	14255	1	Every	every	DT
18637	14255	2	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	14255	3	,	,	,
18637	14255	4	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	14255	5	granted	grant	VBN
18637	14255	6	,	,	,
18637	14255	7	*	*	NFP
18637	14255	8	*	*	NFP
18637	14255	9	*	*	NFP
18637	14255	10	,	,	,
18637	14255	11	may	may	MD
18637	14255	12	now	now	RB
18637	14255	13	be	be	VB
18637	14255	14	reexamined	reexamine	VBN
18637	14255	15	by	by	IN
18637	14255	16	every	every	DT
18637	14255	17	other	other	JJ
18637	14255	18	State	State	NNP
18637	14255	19	,	,	,
18637	14255	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	14255	21	the	the	DT
18637	14255	22	same	same	JJ
18637	14255	23	or	or	CC
18637	14255	24	different	different	JJ
18637	14255	25	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	14255	26	,	,	,
18637	14255	27	to	to	TO
18637	14255	28	redetermine	redetermine	VB
18637	14255	29	the	the	DT
18637	14255	30	'	'	``
18637	14255	31	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	14255	32	fact	fact	NN
18637	14255	33	,	,	,
18637	14255	34	'	'	''
18637	14255	35	always	always	RB
18637	14255	36	the	the	DT
18637	14255	37	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	14255	38	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	14255	39	of	of	IN
18637	14255	40	'	'	``
18637	14255	41	domicil	domicil	NN
18637	14255	42	.	.	.
18637	14255	43	'	'	''
18637	14256	1	*	*	NFP
18637	14256	2	*	*	NFP
18637	14256	3	*	*	NFP
18637	14256	4	"	"	``
18637	14256	5	The	the	DT
18637	14256	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14256	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	14256	8	not	not	RB
18637	14256	9	mention	mention	VB
18637	14256	10	domicil	domicil	NN
18637	14256	11	.	.	.
18637	14257	1	Nowhere	nowhere	RB
18637	14257	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	14257	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14257	4	posit	posit	VB
18637	14257	5	the	the	DT
18637	14257	6	powers	power	NNS
18637	14257	7	of	of	IN
18637	14257	8	the	the	DT
18637	14257	9	states	state	NNS
18637	14257	10	or	or	CC
18637	14257	11	the	the	DT
18637	14257	12	nation	nation	NN
18637	14257	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	14257	14	that	that	DT
18637	14257	15	amorphous	amorphous	JJ
18637	14257	16	,	,	,
18637	14257	17	highly	highly	RB
18637	14257	18	variable	variable	JJ
18637	14257	19	common	common	JJ
18637	14257	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	14257	21	law	law	NN
18637	14257	22	conception	conception	NN
18637	14257	23	.	.	.
18637	14258	1	*	*	NFP
18637	14258	2	*	*	NFP
18637	14258	3	*	*	NFP
18637	14258	4	No	no	DT
18637	14258	5	legal	legal	JJ
18637	14258	6	conception	conception	NN
18637	14258	7	,	,	,
18637	14258	8	save	save	VB
18637	14258	9	possibly	possibly	RB
18637	14258	10	'	'	``
18637	14258	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14258	12	,	,	,
18637	14258	13	'	'	''
18637	14258	14	*	*	NFP
18637	14258	15	*	*	NFP
18637	14258	16	*	*	NFP
18637	14258	17	,	,	,
18637	14258	18	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	14258	19	such	such	JJ
18637	14258	20	possibilities	possibility	NNS
18637	14258	21	for	for	IN
18637	14258	22	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
18637	14258	23	application	application	NN
18637	14258	24	.	.	.
18637	14259	1	*	*	NFP
18637	14259	2	*	*	NFP
18637	14259	3	*	*	NFP
18637	14259	4	Apart	apart	RB
18637	14259	5	from	from	IN
18637	14259	6	the	the	DT
18637	14259	7	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	14259	8	for	for	IN
18637	14259	9	travel	travel	NN
18637	14259	10	,	,	,
18637	14259	11	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14259	12	to	to	TO
18637	14259	13	effect	effect	VB
18637	14259	14	a	a	DT
18637	14259	15	change	change	NN
18637	14259	16	of	of	IN
18637	14259	17	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	14259	18	,	,	,
18637	14259	19	the	the	DT
18637	14259	20	latter	latter	JJ
18637	14259	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14259	22	,	,	,
18637	14259	23	criterion	criterion	NN
18637	14259	24	comes	come	VBZ
18637	14259	25	down	down	RP
18637	14259	26	to	to	IN
18637	14259	27	a	a	DT
18637	14259	28	purely	purely	RB
18637	14259	29	subjective	subjective	JJ
18637	14259	30	mental	mental	JJ
18637	14259	31	state	state	NN
18637	14259	32	,	,	,
18637	14259	33	related	related	JJ
18637	14259	34	to	to	IN
18637	14259	35	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	14259	36	for	for	IN
18637	14259	37	a	a	DT
18637	14259	38	length	length	NN
18637	14259	39	of	of	IN
18637	14259	40	time	time	NN
18637	14259	41	never	never	RB
18637	14259	42	yet	yet	RB
18637	14259	43	defined	define	VBN
18637	14259	44	with	with	IN
18637	14259	45	clarity	clarity	NN
18637	14259	46	.	.	.
18637	14260	1	*	*	NFP
18637	14260	2	*	*	NFP
18637	14260	3	*	*	NFP
18637	14260	4	When	when	WRB
18637	14260	5	what	what	WP
18637	14260	6	must	must	MD
18637	14260	7	be	be	VB
18637	14260	8	proved	prove	VBN
18637	14260	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	14260	10	a	a	DT
18637	14260	11	variable	variable	NN
18637	14260	12	,	,	,
18637	14260	13	the	the	DT
18637	14260	14	proof	proof	NN
18637	14260	15	and	and	CC
18637	14260	16	the	the	DT
18637	14260	17	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	14260	18	which	which	WDT
18637	14260	19	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	14260	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	14260	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14260	22	inevitably	inevitably	RB
18637	14260	23	take	take	VBP
18637	14260	24	on	on	RP
18637	14260	25	that	that	DT
18637	14260	26	character	character	NN
18637	14260	27	.	.	.
18637	14261	1	*	*	NFP
18637	14261	2	*	*	NFP
18637	14261	3	*	*	NFP
18637	14261	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14261	5	The	the	DT
18637	14261	6	majority	majority	NN
18637	14261	7	have	have	VBP
18637	14261	8	not	not	RB
18637	14261	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	14261	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14261	11	that	that	DT
18637	14261	12	denial	denial	NN
18637	14261	13	of	of	IN
18637	14261	14	credit	credit	NN
18637	14261	15	will	will	MD
18637	14261	16	be	be	VB
18637	14261	17	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	14261	18	,	,	,
18637	14261	19	only	only	RB
18637	14261	20	if	if	IN
18637	14261	21	the	the	DT
18637	14261	22	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	14261	23	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14261	24	as	as	IN
18637	14261	25	to	to	IN
18637	14261	26	the	the	DT
18637	14261	27	place	place	NN
18637	14261	28	of	of	IN
18637	14261	29	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	14261	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14261	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	14261	32	different	different	JJ
18637	14261	33	or	or	CC
18637	14261	34	depending	depend	VBG
18637	14261	35	in	in	IN
18637	14261	36	any	any	DT
18637	14261	37	way	way	NN
18637	14261	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	14261	39	the	the	DT
18637	14261	40	character	character	NN
18637	14261	41	or	or	CC
18637	14261	42	the	the	DT
18637	14261	43	weight	weight	NN
18637	14261	44	of	of	IN
18637	14261	45	the	the	DT
18637	14261	46	difference	difference	NN
18637	14261	47	.	.	.
18637	14262	1	The	the	DT
18637	14262	2	test	test	NN
18637	14262	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	14262	4	not	not	RB
18637	14262	5	different	different	JJ
18637	14262	6	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	14262	7	.	.	.
18637	14263	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14263	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	14263	3	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	14263	4	,	,	,
18637	14263	5	whether	whether	IN
18637	14263	6	the	the	DT
18637	14263	7	same	same	JJ
18637	14263	8	or	or	CC
18637	14263	9	different	different	JJ
18637	14263	10	and	and	CC
18637	14263	11	,	,	,
18637	14263	12	if	if	IN
18637	14263	13	different	different	JJ
18637	14263	14	,	,	,
18637	14263	15	without	without	IN
18637	14263	16	regard	regard	NN
18637	14263	17	to	to	IN
18637	14263	18	the	the	DT
18637	14263	19	quality	quality	NN
18637	14263	20	of	of	IN
18637	14263	21	the	the	DT
18637	14263	22	difference	difference	NN
18637	14263	23	,	,	,
18637	14263	24	from	from	IN
18637	14263	25	which	which	WDT
18637	14263	26	an	an	DT
18637	14263	27	opposing	oppose	VBG
18637	14263	28	set	set	NN
18637	14263	29	of	of	IN
18637	14263	30	inferences	inference	NNS
18637	14263	31	can	can	MD
18637	14263	32	be	be	VB
18637	14263	33	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	14263	34	by	by	IN
18637	14263	35	the	the	DT
18637	14263	36	trier	trier	NN
18637	14263	37	of	of	IN
18637	14263	38	fact	fact	NN
18637	14263	39	'	'	``
18637	14263	40	not	not	RB
18637	14263	41	unreasonably	unreasonably	RB
18637	14263	42	.	.	.
18637	14263	43	'	'	''
18637	14264	1	*	*	NFP
18637	14264	2	*	*	NFP
18637	14264	3	*	*	NFP
18637	14264	4	But	but	CC
18637	14264	5	*	*	NFP
18637	14264	6	*	*	NFP
18637	14264	7	*	*	NFP
18637	14264	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14264	9	the	the	DT
18637	14264	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14264	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14264	12	does	do	VBZ
18637	14264	13	not	not	RB
18637	14264	14	define	define	VB
18637	14264	15	'	'	''
18637	14264	16	not	not	RB
18637	14264	17	unreasonably	unreasonably	RB
18637	14264	18	.	.	.
18637	14264	19	'	'	''
18637	14265	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14265	2	vaguely	vaguely	RB
18637	14265	3	suggests	suggest	VBZ
18637	14265	4	a	a	DT
18637	14265	5	supervisory	supervisory	JJ
18637	14265	6	function	function	NN
18637	14265	7	,	,	,
18637	14265	8	to	to	TO
18637	14265	9	be	be	VB
18637	14265	10	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	14265	11	when	when	WRB
18637	14265	12	the	the	DT
18637	14265	13	denial	denial	NN
18637	14265	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14265	15	of	of	IN
18637	14265	16	credit	credit	NN
18637	14265	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14265	18	strikes	strike	VBZ
18637	14265	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14265	20	sensibilities	sensibility	NNS
18637	14265	21	as	as	IN
18637	14265	22	wrong	wrong	JJ
18637	14265	23	,	,	,
18637	14265	24	by	by	IN
18637	14265	25	some	some	DT
18637	14265	26	not	not	RB
18637	14265	27	stated	state	VBN
18637	14265	28	standard	standard	NN
18637	14265	29	.	.	.
18637	14266	1	*	*	NFP
18637	14266	2	*	*	NFP
18637	14266	3	*	*	NFP
18637	14266	4	There	there	EX
18637	14266	5	will	will	MD
18637	14266	6	be	be	VB
18637	14266	7	no	no	DT
18637	14266	8	'	'	``
18637	14266	9	weighing	weigh	VBG
18637	14266	10	'	'	''
18637	14266	11	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14266	12	of	of	IN
18637	14266	13	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	14266	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14266	15	,	,	,
18637	14266	16	*	*	NFP
18637	14266	17	*	*	NFP
18637	14266	18	*	*	NFP
18637	14266	19	only	only	RB
18637	14266	20	examination	examination	NN
18637	14266	21	for	for	IN
18637	14266	22	sufficiency	sufficiency	NN
18637	14266	23	.	.	.
18637	14266	24	"	"	''
18637	14267	1	--(325	--(325	:
18637	14267	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14267	3	226	226	CD
18637	14267	4	,	,	,
18637	14267	5	248	248	CD
18637	14267	6	,	,	,
18637	14267	7	251	251	CD
18637	14267	8	,	,	,
18637	14267	9	255	255	CD
18637	14267	10	,	,	,
18637	14267	11	258	258	CD
18637	14267	12	-	-	SYM
18637	14267	13	259	259	CD
18637	14267	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14267	15	1945	1945	CD
18637	14267	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14267	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14267	18	.	.	.
18637	14268	1	No	no	DT
18637	14268	2	less	less	RBR
18637	14268	3	disposed	disposed	JJ
18637	14268	4	to	to	TO
18637	14268	5	prophesy	prophesy	VB
18637	14268	6	undesirable	undesirable	JJ
18637	14268	7	results	result	NNS
18637	14268	8	from	from	IN
18637	14268	9	this	this	DT
18637	14268	10	decision	decision	NN
18637	14268	11	was	be	VBD
18637	14268	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14268	13	Black	Black	NNP
18637	14268	14	in	in	IN
18637	14268	15	whose	whose	WP$
18637	14268	16	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	14268	17	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	14268	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14268	19	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	14268	20	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	14268	21	.	.	.
18637	14269	1	"	"	``
18637	14269	2	The	the	DT
18637	14269	3	full	full	JJ
18637	14269	4	faith	faith	NN
18637	14269	5	and	and	CC
18637	14269	6	credit	credit	NN
18637	14269	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	14269	8	,	,	,
18637	14269	9	as	as	IN
18637	14269	10	now	now	RB
18637	14269	11	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	14269	12	,	,	,
18637	14269	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	14269	14	become	become	VBN
18637	14269	15	a	a	DT
18637	14269	16	disrupting	disrupting	JJ
18637	14269	17	influence	influence	NN
18637	14269	18	.	.	.
18637	14270	1	The	the	DT
18637	14270	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14270	3	in	in	IN
18637	14270	4	effect	effect	NN
18637	14270	5	states	state	VBZ
18637	14270	6	that	that	IN
18637	14270	7	the	the	DT
18637	14270	8	clause	clause	NN
18637	14270	9	does	do	VBZ
18637	14270	10	not	not	RB
18637	14270	11	apply	apply	VB
18637	14270	12	to	to	IN
18637	14270	13	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	14270	14	actions	action	NNS
18637	14270	15	,	,	,
18637	14270	16	and	and	CC
18637	14270	17	that	that	IN
18637	14270	18	States	state	NNS
18637	14270	19	alone	alone	RB
18637	14270	20	have	have	VBP
18637	14270	21	the	the	DT
18637	14270	22	right	right	NN
18637	14270	23	to	to	TO
18637	14270	24	determine	determine	VB
18637	14270	25	what	what	WDT
18637	14270	26	effect	effect	NN
18637	14270	27	shall	shall	MD
18637	14270	28	be	be	VB
18637	14270	29	given	give	VBN
18637	14270	30	to	to	IN
18637	14270	31	the	the	DT
18637	14270	32	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	14270	33	of	of	IN
18637	14270	34	other	other	JJ
18637	14270	35	States	States	NNPS
18637	14270	36	.	.	.
18637	14271	1	If	if	IN
18637	14271	2	the	the	DT
18637	14271	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14271	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	14271	5	abandoning	abandon	VBG
18637	14271	6	the	the	DT
18637	14271	7	principle	principle	NN
18637	14271	8	that	that	IN
18637	14271	9	a	a	DT
18637	14271	10	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	14271	11	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14271	12	valid	valid	JJ
18637	14271	13	where	where	WRB
18637	14271	14	made	make	VBN
18637	14271	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	14271	16	valid	valid	JJ
18637	14271	17	everywhere	everywhere	RB
18637	14271	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14271	19	,	,	,
18637	14271	20	a	a	DT
18637	14271	21	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	14271	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	14271	23	to	to	TO
18637	14271	24	subject	subject	VB
18637	14271	25	people	people	NNS
18637	14271	26	to	to	IN
18637	14271	27	bigamy	bigamy	NN
18637	14271	28	or	or	CC
18637	14271	29	adultery	adultery	NN
18637	14271	30	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	14271	31	because	because	IN
18637	14271	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14271	33	exercise	exercise	VBP
18637	14271	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14271	35	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	14271	36	right	right	NN
18637	14271	37	to	to	TO
18637	14271	38	pass	pass	VB
18637	14271	39	from	from	IN
18637	14271	40	a	a	DT
18637	14271	41	State	state	NN
18637	14271	42	in	in	IN
18637	14271	43	which	which	WDT
18637	14271	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14271	45	were	be	VBD
18637	14271	46	validly	validly	RB
18637	14271	47	married	married	JJ
18637	14271	48	on	on	IN
18637	14271	49	to	to	IN
18637	14271	50	another	another	DT
18637	14271	51	which	which	WDT
18637	14271	52	refuses	refuse	VBZ
18637	14271	53	to	to	TO
18637	14271	54	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	14271	55	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14271	56	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	14271	57	.	.	.
18637	14272	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	14272	2	a	a	DT
18637	14272	3	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	14272	4	violates	violate	VBZ
18637	14272	5	basic	basic	JJ
18637	14272	6	guarantees	guarantee	NNS
18637	14272	7	.	.	.
18637	14272	8	"	"	''
18637	14273	1	North	North	NNP
18637	14273	2	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	14273	3	's	's	POS
18637	14273	4	interest	interest	NN
18637	14273	5	was	be	VBD
18637	14273	6	to	to	TO
18637	14273	7	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	14273	8	a	a	DT
18637	14273	9	bare	bare	JJ
18637	14273	10	marital	marital	JJ
18637	14273	11	status	status	NN
18637	14273	12	as	as	IN
18637	14273	13	to	to	IN
18637	14273	14	two	two	CD
18637	14273	15	persons	person	NNS
18637	14273	16	who	who	WP
18637	14273	17	sought	seek	VBD
18637	14273	18	a	a	DT
18637	14273	19	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	14273	20	and	and	CC
18637	14273	21	two	two	CD
18637	14273	22	others	other	NNS
18637	14273	23	who	who	WP
18637	14273	24	had	have	VBD
18637	14273	25	not	not	RB
18637	14273	26	objected	object	VBN
18637	14273	27	to	to	IN
18637	14273	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14273	29	.	.	.
18637	14274	1	"	"	``
18637	14274	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14274	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	14274	4	an	an	DT
18637	14274	5	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	14274	6	thing	thing	NN
18637	14274	7	for	for	IN
18637	14274	8	a	a	DT
18637	14274	9	State	state	NN
18637	14274	10	to	to	TO
18637	14274	11	procure	procure	VB
18637	14274	12	a	a	DT
18637	14274	13	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	14274	14	invalidation	invalidation	NN
18637	14274	15	of	of	IN
18637	14274	16	a	a	DT
18637	14274	17	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	14274	18	decree	decree	NN
18637	14274	19	,	,	,
18637	14274	20	and	and	CC
18637	14274	21	then	then	RB
18637	14274	22	punish	punish	VB
18637	14274	23	one	one	CD
18637	14274	24	of	of	IN
18637	14274	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14274	26	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	14274	27	for	for	IN
18637	14274	28	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	14274	29	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	14274	30	by	by	IN
18637	14274	31	that	that	DT
18637	14274	32	decree	decree	NN
18637	14274	33	,	,	,
18637	14274	34	when	when	WRB
18637	14274	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14274	36	had	have	VBD
18637	14274	37	never	never	RB
18637	14274	38	been	be	VBN
18637	14274	39	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	14274	40	by	by	IN
18637	14274	41	either	either	DT
18637	14274	42	of	of	IN
18637	14274	43	the	the	DT
18637	14274	44	people	people	NNS
18637	14274	45	most	most	RBS
18637	14274	46	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	14274	47	interested	interested	JJ
18637	14274	48	in	in	IN
18637	14274	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14274	50	.	.	.
18637	14274	51	"	"	''
18637	14275	1	The	the	DT
18637	14275	2	State	State	NNP
18637	14275	3	here	here	RB
18637	14275	4	did	do	VBD
18637	14275	5	not	not	RB
18637	14275	6	sue	sue	VB
18637	14275	7	to	to	TO
18637	14275	8	protect	protect	VB
18637	14275	9	any	any	DT
18637	14275	10	North	North	NNP
18637	14275	11	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	14275	12	property	property	NN
18637	14275	13	rights	right	NNS
18637	14275	14	nor	nor	CC
18637	14275	15	to	to	TO
18637	14275	16	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	14275	17	support	support	NN
18637	14275	18	for	for	IN
18637	14275	19	deserted	deserted	JJ
18637	14275	20	families	family	NNS
18637	14275	21	.	.	.
18637	14276	1	"	"	``
18637	14276	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14276	3	would	would	MD
18637	14276	4	not	not	RB
18637	14276	5	permit	permit	VB
18637	14276	6	such	such	PDT
18637	14276	7	an	an	DT
18637	14276	8	attenuated	attenuate	VBN
18637	14276	9	state	state	NN
18637	14276	10	interest	interest	NN
18637	14276	11	to	to	TO
18637	14276	12	override	override	VB
18637	14276	13	the	the	DT
18637	14276	14	Full	Full	NNP
18637	14276	15	Faith	Faith	NNP
18637	14276	16	and	and	CC
18637	14276	17	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	14276	18	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	14276	19	*	*	NFP
18637	14276	20	*	*	NFP
18637	14276	21	*	*	NFP
18637	14276	22	"	"	''
18637	14276	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14276	24	325	325	CD
18637	14276	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14276	26	226	226	CD
18637	14276	27	,	,	,
18637	14276	28	262	262	CD
18637	14276	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	14276	30	267	267	CD
18637	14276	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14276	32	1945	1945	CD
18637	14276	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14276	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14276	35	.	.	.
18637	14277	1	The	the	DT
18637	14277	2	unsettling	unsettling	JJ
18637	14277	3	effect	effect	NN
18637	14277	4	of	of	IN
18637	14277	5	this	this	DT
18637	14277	6	decision	decision	NN
18637	14277	7	was	be	VBD
18637	14277	8	expressed	express	VBN
18637	14277	9	statistically	statistically	RB
18637	14277	10	by	by	IN
18637	14277	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14277	12	Black	Black	NNP
18637	14277	13	as	as	IN
18637	14277	14	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	14277	15	:	:	:
18637	14277	16	"	"	``
18637	14277	17	Statistics	statistic	NNS
18637	14277	18	indicate	indicate	VBP
18637	14277	19	that	that	IN
18637	14277	20	approximately	approximately	RB
18637	14277	21	five	five	CD
18637	14277	22	million	million	CD
18637	14277	23	divorced	divorced	JJ
18637	14277	24	persons	person	NNS
18637	14277	25	are	be	VBP
18637	14277	26	scattered	scatter	VBN
18637	14277	27	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	14277	28	the	the	DT
18637	14277	29	forty	forty	CD
18637	14277	30	-	-	HYPH
18637	14277	31	eight	eight	CD
18637	14277	32	States	state	NNS
18637	14277	33	.	.	.
18637	14278	1	More	More	JJR
18637	14278	2	than	than	IN
18637	14278	3	85	85	CD
18637	14278	4	%	%	NN
18637	14278	5	of	of	IN
18637	14278	6	these	these	DT
18637	14278	7	divorces	divorce	NNS
18637	14278	8	were	be	VBD
18637	14278	9	granted	grant	VBN
18637	14278	10	in	in	IN
18637	14278	11	uncontested	uncontested	JJ
18637	14278	12	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	14278	13	.	.	.
18637	14279	1	Not	not	RB
18637	14279	2	one	one	CD
18637	14279	3	of	of	IN
18637	14279	4	this	this	DT
18637	14279	5	latter	latter	JJ
18637	14279	6	group	group	NN
18637	14279	7	can	can	MD
18637	14279	8	now	now	RB
18637	14279	9	retain	retain	VB
18637	14279	10	any	any	DT
18637	14279	11	feeling	feeling	NN
18637	14279	12	of	of	IN
18637	14279	13	security	security	NN
18637	14279	14	in	in	IN
18637	14279	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14279	16	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	14279	17	decree	decree	NN
18637	14279	18	.	.	.
18637	14280	1	Ever	ever	RB
18637	14280	2	present	present	JJ
18637	14280	3	will	will	MD
18637	14280	4	be	be	VB
18637	14280	5	the	the	DT
18637	14280	6	danger	danger	NN
18637	14280	7	of	of	IN
18637	14280	8	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	14280	9	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	14280	10	and	and	CC
18637	14280	11	harassment	harassment	NN
18637	14280	12	.	.	.
18637	14280	13	"	"	''
18637	14281	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	14281	2	.	.	.
18637	14282	1	262	262	CD
18637	14282	2	-	-	SYM
18637	14282	3	263	263	CD
18637	14282	4	.	.	.
18637	14283	1	As	as	IN
18637	14283	2	to	to	IN
18637	14283	3	the	the	DT
18637	14283	4	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	14283	5	that	that	IN
18637	14283	6	the	the	DT
18637	14283	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14283	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14283	9	as	as	RB
18637	14283	10	well	well	RB
18637	14283	11	as	as	IN
18637	14283	12	the	the	DT
18637	14283	13	State	State	NNP
18637	14283	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	14283	15	should	should	MD
18637	14283	16	reach	reach	VB
18637	14283	17	in	in	IN
18637	14283	18	like	like	JJ
18637	14283	19	situations	situation	NNS
18637	14283	20	,	,	,
18637	14283	21	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14283	22	Black	Black	NNP
18637	14283	23	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	14283	24	that	that	IN
18637	14283	25	"	"	``
18637	14283	26	until	until	IN
18637	14283	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14283	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	14283	29	commanded	command	VBN
18637	14283	30	a	a	DT
18637	14283	31	different	different	JJ
18637	14283	32	'	'	``
18637	14283	33	effect	effect	NN
18637	14283	34	'	'	''
18637	14283	35	for	for	IN
18637	14283	36	divorces	divorce	NNS
18637	14283	37	granted	grant	VBN
18637	14283	38	on	on	IN
18637	14283	39	a	a	DT
18637	14283	40	short	short	JJ
18637	14283	41	sojourn	sojourn	NN
18637	14283	42	within	within	IN
18637	14283	43	a	a	DT
18637	14283	44	State	state	NN
18637	14283	45	,	,	,
18637	14283	46	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14283	47	should	should	MD
18637	14283	48	stay	stay	VB
18637	14283	49	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14283	50	hands	hand	NNS
18637	14283	51	.	.	.
18637	14284	1	*	*	NFP
18637	14284	2	*	*	NFP
18637	14284	3	*	*	NFP
18637	14284	4	If	if	IN
18637	14284	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14284	6	follow	follow	VBP
18637	14284	7	that	that	DT
18637	14284	8	course	course	NN
18637	14284	9	,	,	,
18637	14284	10	North	North	NNP
18637	14284	11	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	14284	12	can	can	MD
18637	14284	13	not	not	RB
18637	14284	14	be	be	VB
18637	14284	15	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	14284	16	to	to	TO
18637	14284	17	disregard	disregard	VB
18637	14284	18	the	the	DT
18637	14284	19	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	14284	20	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	14284	21	without	without	IN
18637	14284	22	passing	pass	VBG
18637	14284	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	14284	24	the	the	DT
18637	14284	25	'	'	``
18637	14284	26	faith	faith	NN
18637	14284	27	and	and	CC
18637	14284	28	credit	credit	NN
18637	14284	29	'	'	''
18637	14284	30	which	which	WDT
18637	14284	31	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	14284	32	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14284	33	would	would	MD
18637	14284	34	give	give	VB
18637	14284	35	to	to	IN
18637	14284	36	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14284	37	under	under	IN
18637	14284	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14284	39	own	own	JJ
18637	14284	40	'	'	``
18637	14284	41	law	law	NN
18637	14284	42	or	or	CC
18637	14284	43	usage	usage	NN
18637	14284	44	.	.	.
18637	14284	45	'	'	''
18637	14285	1	*	*	NFP
18637	14285	2	*	*	NFP
18637	14285	3	*	*	NFP
18637	14285	4	For	for	IN
18637	14285	5	in	in	IN
18637	14285	6	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	14285	7	,	,	,
18637	14285	8	even	even	RB
18637	14285	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14285	10	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	14285	11	General	General	NNP
18637	14285	12	could	could	MD
18637	14285	13	not	not	RB
18637	14285	14	have	have	VB
18637	14285	15	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	14285	16	a	a	DT
18637	14285	17	cancellation	cancellation	NN
18637	14285	18	of	of	IN
18637	14285	19	the	the	DT
18637	14285	20	decree	decree	NN
18637	14285	21	*	*	NFP
18637	14285	22	*	*	NFP
18637	14285	23	*	*	NFP
18637	14285	24	.	.	.
18637	14285	25	"	"	''
18637	14286	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	14286	2	.	.	.
18637	14287	1	267	267	CD
18637	14287	2	,	,	,
18637	14287	3	268	268	CD
18637	14287	4	.	.	.
18637	14288	1	The	the	DT
18637	14288	2	reader	reader	NN
18637	14288	3	should	should	MD
18637	14288	4	take	take	VB
18637	14288	5	note	note	NN
18637	14288	6	of	of	IN
18637	14288	7	the	the	DT
18637	14288	8	effect	effect	NN
18637	14288	9	in	in	IN
18637	14288	10	some	some	DT
18637	14288	11	of	of	IN
18637	14288	12	the	the	DT
18637	14288	13	above	above	JJ
18637	14288	14	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	14288	15	to	to	TO
18637	14288	16	weigh	weigh	VB
18637	14288	17	competing	compete	VBG
18637	14288	18	interests	interest	NNS
18637	14288	19	against	against	IN
18637	14288	20	one	one	CD
18637	14288	21	another	another	DT
18637	14288	22	and	and	CC
18637	14288	23	the	the	DT
18637	14288	24	implication	implication	NN
18637	14288	25	that	that	IN
18637	14288	26	the	the	DT
18637	14288	27	court	court	NN
18637	14288	28	's	's	POS
18637	14288	29	relation	relation	NN
18637	14288	30	to	to	IN
18637	14288	31	the	the	DT
18637	14288	32	full	full	JJ
18637	14288	33	faith	faith	NN
18637	14288	34	and	and	CC
18637	14288	35	credit	credit	NN
18637	14288	36	clause	clause	NN
18637	14288	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	14288	38	that	that	DT
18637	14288	39	of	of	IN
18637	14288	40	an	an	DT
18637	14288	41	arbitral	arbitral	JJ
18637	14288	42	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	14288	43	rather	rather	RB
18637	14288	44	than	than	IN
18637	14288	45	of	of	IN
18637	14288	46	a	a	DT
18637	14288	47	court	court	NN
18637	14288	48	in	in	IN
18637	14288	49	the	the	DT
18637	14288	50	conventional	conventional	JJ
18637	14288	51	sense	sense	NN
18637	14288	52	of	of	IN
18637	14288	53	a	a	DT
18637	14288	54	body	body	NN
18637	14288	55	whose	whose	WP$
18637	14288	56	duty	duty	NN
18637	14288	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	14288	58	to	to	TO
18637	14288	59	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	14288	60	an	an	DT
18637	14288	61	established	established	JJ
18637	14288	62	rule	rule	NN
18637	14288	63	of	of	IN
18637	14288	64	law	law	NN
18637	14288	65	.	.	.
18637	14289	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14289	2	62	62	CD
18637	14289	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14289	4	325	325	CD
18637	14289	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14289	6	279	279	CD
18637	14289	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14289	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	14289	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14289	10	.	.	.
18637	14290	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14290	2	63	63	CD
18637	14290	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14290	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14290	5	.	.	.
18637	14291	1	281	281	CD
18637	14291	2	-	-	SYM
18637	14291	3	283	283	CD
18637	14291	4	.	.	.
18637	14292	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14292	2	64	64	CD
18637	14292	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14292	4	334	334	CD
18637	14292	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14292	6	541	541	CD
18637	14292	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14292	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	14292	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14292	10	.	.	.
18637	14293	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14293	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14293	3	also	also	RB
18637	14293	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14293	5	the	the	DT
18637	14293	6	companion	companion	NN
18637	14293	7	case	case	NN
18637	14293	8	of	of	IN
18637	14293	9	Kreiger	Kreiger	NNP
18637	14293	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14293	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	14293	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14293	13	Kreiger	Kreiger	NNP
18637	14293	14	,	,	,
18637	14293	15	334	334	CD
18637	14293	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14293	17	555	555	CD
18637	14293	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14293	19	1948	1948	CD
18637	14293	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14293	21	.	.	.
18637	14294	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14294	2	65	65	CD
18637	14294	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14294	4	Esenwein	Esenwein	NNP
18637	14294	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14294	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14294	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14294	8	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
18637	14294	9	,	,	,
18637	14294	10	325	325	CD
18637	14294	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14294	12	279	279	CD
18637	14294	13	,	,	,
18637	14294	14	280	280	CD
18637	14294	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14294	16	1945	1945	CD
18637	14294	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14294	18	.	.	.
18637	14295	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14295	2	66	66	CD
18637	14295	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14295	4	Because	because	IN
18637	14295	5	the	the	DT
18637	14295	6	record	record	NN
18637	14295	7	,	,	,
18637	14295	8	in	in	IN
18637	14295	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14295	10	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	14295	11	,	,	,
18637	14295	12	did	do	VBD
18637	14295	13	not	not	RB
18637	14295	14	make	make	VB
18637	14295	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14295	16	clear	clear	JJ
18637	14295	17	whether	whether	IN
18637	14295	18	New	New	NNP
18637	14295	19	York	York	NNP
18637	14295	20	"	"	''
18637	14295	21	law	law	NN
18637	14295	22	"	"	''
18637	14295	23	held	hold	VBD
18637	14295	24	that	that	IN
18637	14295	25	no	no	UH
18637	14295	26	"	"	``
18637	14295	27	_	_	NNP
18637	14295	28	ex	ex	NNP
18637	14295	29	parte	parte	NNP
18637	14295	30	_	_	NNP
18637	14295	31	"	"	``
18637	14295	32	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	14295	33	decree	decree	NN
18637	14295	34	could	could	MD
18637	14295	35	terminate	terminate	VB
18637	14295	36	a	a	DT
18637	14295	37	prior	prior	JJ
18637	14295	38	New	New	NNP
18637	14295	39	York	York	NNP
18637	14295	40	separate	separate	JJ
18637	14295	41	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	14295	42	decree	decree	NN
18637	14295	43	,	,	,
18637	14295	44	or	or	CC
18637	14295	45	merely	merely	RB
18637	14295	46	that	that	IN
18637	14295	47	no	no	DT
18637	14295	48	"	"	``
18637	14295	49	_	_	NNP
18637	14295	50	ex	ex	NNP
18637	14295	51	parte	parte	NNP
18637	14295	52	_	_	NNP
18637	14295	53	"	"	``
18637	14295	54	decree	decree	NN
18637	14295	55	of	of	IN
18637	14295	56	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	14295	57	of	of	IN
18637	14295	58	_	_	NNP
18637	14295	59	another	another	DT
18637	14295	60	State	State	NNP
18637	14295	61	_	_	NNP
18637	14295	62	could	could	MD
18637	14295	63	,	,	,
18637	14295	64	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14295	65	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	14295	66	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	14295	67	and	and	CC
18637	14295	68	recommended	recommend	VBD
18637	14295	69	that	that	IN
18637	14295	70	the	the	DT
18637	14295	71	case	case	NN
18637	14295	72	be	be	VB
18637	14295	73	remanded	remand	VBN
18637	14295	74	for	for	IN
18637	14295	75	clarification	clarification	NN
18637	14295	76	.	.	.
18637	14296	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14296	2	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	14296	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	14296	4	on	on	IN
18637	14296	5	the	the	DT
18637	14296	6	ground	ground	NN
18637	14296	7	that	that	IN
18637	14296	8	under	under	IN
18637	14296	9	New	New	NNP
18637	14296	10	York	York	NNP
18637	14296	11	law	law	NN
18637	14296	12	,	,	,
18637	14296	13	a	a	DT
18637	14296	14	New	New	NNP
18637	14296	15	York	York	NNP
18637	14296	16	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	14296	17	would	would	MD
18637	14296	18	terminate	terminate	VB
18637	14296	19	the	the	DT
18637	14296	20	wife	wife	NN
18637	14296	21	's	's	POS
18637	14296	22	right	right	NN
18637	14296	23	to	to	IN
18637	14296	24	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	14296	25	;	;	:
18637	14296	26	and	and	CC
18637	14296	27	if	if	IN
18637	14296	28	the	the	DT
18637	14296	29	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	14296	30	decree	decree	NN
18637	14296	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	14296	32	good	good	JJ
18637	14296	33	,	,	,
18637	14296	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14296	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	14296	36	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	14296	37	to	to	IN
18637	14296	38	no	no	DT
18637	14296	39	less	less	JJR
18637	14296	40	effect	effect	NN
18637	14296	41	in	in	IN
18637	14296	42	New	New	NNP
18637	14296	43	York	York	NNP
18637	14296	44	than	than	IN
18637	14296	45	a	a	DT
18637	14296	46	local	local	JJ
18637	14296	47	decree	decree	NN
18637	14296	48	.	.	.
18637	14297	1	However	however	RB
18637	14297	2	,	,	,
18637	14297	3	for	for	IN
18637	14297	4	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	14297	5	stated	state	VBN
18637	14297	6	in	in	IN
18637	14297	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14297	8	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	14297	9	in	in	IN
18637	14297	10	the	the	DT
18637	14297	11	First	First	NNP
18637	14297	12	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	14297	13	Case	Case	NNP
18637	14297	14	,	,	,
18637	14297	15	317	317	CD
18637	14297	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14297	17	287	287	CD
18637	14297	18	,	,	,
18637	14297	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14297	20	would	would	MD
18637	14297	21	prefer	prefer	VB
18637	14297	22	not	not	RB
18637	14297	23	to	to	TO
18637	14297	24	give	give	VB
18637	14297	25	standing	stand	VBG
18637	14297	26	to	to	IN
18637	14297	27	constructive	constructive	JJ
18637	14297	28	service	service	NN
18637	14297	29	divorces	divorce	NNS
18637	14297	30	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	14297	31	on	on	IN
18637	14297	32	short	short	JJ
18637	14297	33	residence	residence	NN
18637	14297	34	.	.	.
18637	14298	1	334	334	CD
18637	14298	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14298	3	541	541	CD
18637	14298	4	,	,	,
18637	14298	5	549	549	CD
18637	14298	6	-	-	SYM
18637	14298	7	554	554	CD
18637	14298	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14298	9	1948	1948	CD
18637	14298	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14298	11	.	.	.
18637	14299	1	These	these	DT
18637	14299	2	two	two	CD
18637	14299	3	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	14299	4	filed	file	VBD
18637	14299	5	similar	similar	JJ
18637	14299	6	dissents	dissent	NNS
18637	14299	7	in	in	IN
18637	14299	8	the	the	DT
18637	14299	9	companion	companion	NN
18637	14299	10	case	case	NN
18637	14299	11	of	of	IN
18637	14299	12	Kreiger	Kreiger	NNP
18637	14299	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14299	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	14299	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14299	16	Kreiger	Kreiger	NNP
18637	14299	17	,	,	,
18637	14299	18	334	334	CD
18637	14299	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14299	20	555	555	CD
18637	14299	21	,	,	,
18637	14299	22	557	557	CD
18637	14299	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14299	24	1948	1948	CD
18637	14299	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14299	26	.	.	.
18637	14300	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14300	2	67	67	CD
18637	14300	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14300	4	334	334	CD
18637	14300	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14300	6	343	343	CD
18637	14300	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14300	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	14300	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14300	10	.	.	.
18637	14301	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14301	2	68	68	CD
18637	14301	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14301	4	334	334	CD
18637	14301	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14301	6	378	378	CD
18637	14301	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14301	8	1948).--In	1948).--in	CD
18637	14301	9	a	a	DT
18637	14301	10	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	14301	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	14301	12	filed	file	VBN
18637	14301	13	in	in	IN
18637	14301	14	the	the	DT
18637	14301	15	case	case	NN
18637	14301	16	of	of	IN
18637	14301	17	Sherrer	Sherrer	NNP
18637	14301	18	_	_	NNP
18637	14301	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	14301	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14301	21	Sherrer	Sherrer	NNP
18637	14301	22	,	,	,
18637	14301	23	but	but	CC
18637	14301	24	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	14301	25	also	also	RB
18637	14301	26	to	to	IN
18637	14301	27	the	the	DT
18637	14301	28	case	case	NN
18637	14301	29	of	of	IN
18637	14301	30	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	14301	31	_	_	NNP
18637	14301	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	14301	33	_	_	NNP
18637	14301	34	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	14301	35	,	,	,
18637	14301	36	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14301	37	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	14301	38	,	,	,
18637	14301	39	with	with	IN
18637	14301	40	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14301	41	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	14301	42	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	14301	43	,	,	,
18637	14301	44	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	14301	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14301	46	inability	inability	NN
18637	14301	47	to	to	TO
18637	14301	48	accept	accept	VB
18637	14301	49	the	the	DT
18637	14301	50	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	14301	51	advanced	advance	VBN
18637	14301	52	by	by	IN
18637	14301	53	the	the	DT
18637	14301	54	majority	majority	NN
18637	14301	55	that	that	IN
18637	14301	56	"	"	``
18637	14301	57	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	14301	58	of	of	IN
18637	14301	59	how	how	WRB
18637	14301	60	overwhelming	overwhelming	JJ
18637	14301	61	the	the	DT
18637	14301	62	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	14301	63	may	may	MD
18637	14301	64	have	have	VB
18637	14301	65	been	be	VBN
18637	14301	66	that	that	IN
18637	14301	67	the	the	DT
18637	14301	68	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	14301	69	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	14301	70	in	in	IN
18637	14301	71	the	the	DT
18637	14301	72	State	State	NNP
18637	14301	73	offering	offer	VBG
18637	14301	74	bargain	bargain	NN
18637	14301	75	-	-	HYPH
18637	14301	76	counter	counter	NN
18637	14301	77	divorces	divorce	NNS
18637	14301	78	was	be	VBD
18637	14301	79	a	a	DT
18637	14301	80	sham	sham	NN
18637	14301	81	,	,	,
18637	14301	82	the	the	DT
18637	14301	83	home	home	NN
18637	14301	84	State	State	NNP
18637	14301	85	of	of	IN
18637	14301	86	the	the	DT
18637	14301	87	parties	party	NNS
18637	14301	88	is	be	VBZ
18637	14301	89	not	not	RB
18637	14301	90	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	14301	91	to	to	TO
18637	14301	92	question	question	VB
18637	14301	93	the	the	DT
18637	14301	94	matter	matter	NN
18637	14301	95	if	if	IN
18637	14301	96	the	the	DT
18637	14301	97	form	form	NN
18637	14301	98	of	of	IN
18637	14301	99	a	a	DT
18637	14301	100	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	14301	101	had	have	VBD
18637	14301	102	been	be	VBN
18637	14301	103	gone	go	VBN
18637	14301	104	through	through	RB
18637	14301	105	.	.	.
18637	14301	106	"	"	''
18637	14302	1	--334	--334	:
18637	14302	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14302	3	343	343	CD
18637	14302	4	,	,	,
18637	14302	5	377	377	CD
18637	14302	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14302	7	1948	1948	CD
18637	14302	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14302	9	.	.	.
18637	14303	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14303	2	69	69	CD
18637	14303	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14303	4	336	336	CD
18637	14303	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14303	6	674	674	CD
18637	14303	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14303	8	1949).--Of	1949).--of	CD
18637	14303	9	four	four	CD
18637	14303	10	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	14303	11	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	14303	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14303	13	Black	Black	NNP
18637	14303	14	,	,	,
18637	14303	15	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	14303	16	,	,	,
18637	14303	17	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	14303	18	,	,	,
18637	14303	19	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	14303	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14303	21	,	,	,
18637	14303	22	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14303	23	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	14303	24	alone	alone	RB
18637	14303	25	filed	file	VBD
18637	14303	26	a	a	DT
18637	14303	27	written	write	VBN
18637	14303	28	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	14303	29	.	.	.
18637	14304	1	To	to	IN
18637	14304	2	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14304	3	the	the	DT
18637	14304	4	decision	decision	NN
18637	14304	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	14304	6	"	"	``
18637	14304	7	an	an	DT
18637	14304	8	example	example	NN
18637	14304	9	of	of	IN
18637	14304	10	the	the	DT
18637	14304	11	manner	manner	NN
18637	14304	12	in	in	IN
18637	14304	13	which	which	WDT
18637	14304	14	,	,	,
18637	14304	15	in	in	IN
18637	14304	16	the	the	DT
18637	14304	17	law	law	NN
18637	14304	18	of	of	IN
18637	14304	19	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	14304	20	relations	relation	NNS
18637	14304	21	,	,	,
18637	14304	22	'	'	''
18637	14304	23	confusion	confusion	NN
18637	14304	24	now	now	RB
18637	14304	25	hath	hath	NNP
18637	14304	26	made	make	VBD
18637	14304	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14304	28	masterpiece	masterpiece	NN
18637	14304	29	,	,	,
18637	14304	30	'	'	''
18637	14304	31	"	"	''
18637	14304	32	but	but	CC
18637	14304	33	for	for	IN
18637	14304	34	the	the	DT
18637	14304	35	first	first	JJ
18637	14304	36	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	14304	37	case	case	NN
18637	14304	38	and	and	CC
18637	14304	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14304	40	progeny	progeny	NN
18637	14304	41	,	,	,
18637	14304	42	the	the	DT
18637	14304	43	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14304	44	of	of	IN
18637	14304	45	the	the	DT
18637	14304	46	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	14304	47	court	court	NN
18637	14304	48	might	may	MD
18637	14304	49	properly	properly	RB
18637	14304	50	have	have	VB
18637	14304	51	held	hold	VBN
18637	14304	52	that	that	IN
18637	14304	53	the	the	DT
18637	14304	54	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	14304	55	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	14304	56	decree	decree	NN
18637	14304	57	was	be	VBD
18637	14304	58	void	void	JJ
18637	14304	59	for	for	IN
18637	14304	60	every	every	DT
18637	14304	61	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	14304	62	because	because	IN
18637	14304	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14304	64	was	be	VBD
18637	14304	65	rendered	render	VBN
18637	14304	66	by	by	IN
18637	14304	67	a	a	DT
18637	14304	68	State	State	NNP
18637	14304	69	court	court	NN
18637	14304	70	which	which	WDT
18637	14304	71	never	never	RB
18637	14304	72	obtained	obtain	VBD
18637	14304	73	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14304	74	of	of	IN
18637	14304	75	the	the	DT
18637	14304	76	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	14304	77	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	14304	78	.	.	.
18637	14305	1	"	"	``
18637	14305	2	But	but	CC
18637	14305	3	if	if	IN
18637	14305	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14305	5	adhere	adhere	VBP
18637	14305	6	to	to	IN
18637	14305	7	the	the	DT
18637	14305	8	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	14305	9	that	that	WDT
18637	14305	10	the	the	DT
18637	14305	11	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	14305	12	court	court	NN
18637	14305	13	had	have	VBD
18637	14305	14	power	power	NN
18637	14305	15	over	over	IN
18637	14305	16	her	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14305	17	for	for	IN
18637	14305	18	the	the	DT
18637	14305	19	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	14305	20	of	of	IN
18637	14305	21	blasting	blast	VBG
18637	14305	22	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14305	23	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	14305	24	and	and	CC
18637	14305	25	opening	open	VBG
18637	14305	26	the	the	DT
18637	14305	27	way	way	NN
18637	14305	28	to	to	IN
18637	14305	29	a	a	DT
18637	14305	30	successor	successor	NN
18637	14305	31	,	,	,
18637	14305	32	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14305	33	do	do	VBP
18637	14305	34	not	not	RB
18637	14305	35	see	see	VB
18637	14305	36	the	the	DT
18637	14305	37	justice	justice	NN
18637	14305	38	of	of	IN
18637	14305	39	inventing	invent	VBG
18637	14305	40	a	a	DT
18637	14305	41	compensating	compensating	JJ
18637	14305	42	confusion	confusion	NN
18637	14305	43	in	in	IN
18637	14305	44	the	the	DT
18637	14305	45	device	device	NN
18637	14305	46	of	of	IN
18637	14305	47	divisible	divisible	JJ
18637	14305	48	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	14305	49	by	by	IN
18637	14305	50	which	which	WDT
18637	14305	51	the	the	DT
18637	14305	52	parties	party	NNS
18637	14305	53	are	be	VBP
18637	14305	54	half	half	RB
18637	14305	55	-	-	HYPH
18637	14305	56	bound	bind	VBN
18637	14305	57	and	and	CC
18637	14305	58	half	half	RB
18637	14305	59	-	-	HYPH
18637	14305	60	free	free	JJ
18637	14305	61	and	and	CC
18637	14305	62	which	which	WDT
18637	14305	63	permits	permit	VBZ
18637	14305	64	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	14305	65	to	to	TO
18637	14305	66	have	have	VB
18637	14305	67	a	a	DT
18637	14305	68	wife	wife	NN
18637	14305	69	who	who	WP
18637	14305	70	can	can	MD
18637	14305	71	not	not	RB
18637	14305	72	become	become	VB
18637	14305	73	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14305	74	widow	widow	NN
18637	14305	75	and	and	CC
18637	14305	76	to	to	TO
18637	14305	77	leave	leave	VB
18637	14305	78	a	a	DT
18637	14305	79	widow	widow	NN
18637	14305	80	who	who	WP
18637	14305	81	was	be	VBD
18637	14305	82	no	no	RB
18637	14305	83	longer	long	RBR
18637	14305	84	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14305	85	wife	wife	NN
18637	14305	86	.	.	.
18637	14305	87	"	"	''
18637	14306	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	14306	2	.	.	.
18637	14307	1	676	676	CD
18637	14307	2	,	,	,
18637	14307	3	679	679	CD
18637	14307	4	,	,	,
18637	14307	5	680	680	CD
18637	14307	6	.	.	.
18637	14308	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14308	2	70	70	CD
18637	14308	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14308	4	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	14308	5	violated	violate	VBD
18637	14308	6	the	the	DT
18637	14308	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	14308	8	in	in	IN
18637	14308	9	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	14308	10	a	a	DT
18637	14308	11	collateral	collateral	JJ
18637	14308	12	attack	attack	NN
18637	14308	13	on	on	IN
18637	14308	14	a	a	DT
18637	14308	15	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	14308	16	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	14308	17	decree	decree	NN
18637	14308	18	,	,	,
18637	14308	19	the	the	DT
18637	14308	20	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	14308	21	of	of	IN
18637	14308	22	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	14308	23	's	's	POS
18637	14308	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14308	25	over	over	IN
18637	14308	26	the	the	DT
18637	14308	27	cause	cause	NN
18637	14308	28	and	and	CC
18637	14308	29	the	the	DT
18637	14308	30	parties	party	NNS
18637	14308	31	not	not	RB
18637	14308	32	having	have	VBG
18637	14308	33	been	be	VBN
18637	14308	34	overcome	overcome	VBN
18637	14308	35	by	by	IN
18637	14308	36	extrinsic	extrinsic	JJ
18637	14308	37	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	14308	38	or	or	CC
18637	14308	39	the	the	DT
18637	14308	40	record	record	NN
18637	14308	41	of	of	IN
18637	14308	42	the	the	DT
18637	14308	43	case	case	NN
18637	14308	44	.	.	.
18637	14309	1	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	14309	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14309	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14309	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14309	5	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	14309	6	,	,	,
18637	14309	7	342	342	CD
18637	14309	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14309	9	126	126	CD
18637	14309	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14309	11	1951	1951	CD
18637	14309	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14309	13	.	.	.
18637	14310	1	The	the	DT
18637	14310	2	Sherrer	Sherrer	NNP
18637	14310	3	and	and	CC
18637	14310	4	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	14310	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	14310	6	were	be	VBD
18637	14310	7	relied	rely	VBN
18637	14310	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	14310	9	.	.	.
18637	14311	1	There	there	EX
18637	14311	2	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	14311	3	,	,	,
18637	14311	4	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	14311	5	,	,	,
18637	14311	6	to	to	TO
18637	14311	7	be	be	VB
18637	14311	8	no	no	DT
18637	14311	9	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	14311	10	of	of	IN
18637	14311	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14311	12	continued	continue	VBN
18637	14311	13	vitality	vitality	NN
18637	14311	14	.	.	.
18637	14312	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14312	2	71	71	CD
18637	14312	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14312	4	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	14312	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14312	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14312	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14312	8	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	14312	9	,	,	,
18637	14312	10	323	323	CD
18637	14312	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14312	12	77	77	CD
18637	14312	13	,	,	,
18637	14312	14	84	84	CD
18637	14312	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14312	16	1944	1944	CD
18637	14312	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14312	18	.	.	.
18637	14313	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14313	2	72	72	CD
18637	14313	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14313	4	Sistare	Sistare	NNP
18637	14313	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14313	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14313	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14313	8	Sistare	Sistare	NNP
18637	14313	9	,	,	,
18637	14313	10	218	218	CD
18637	14313	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14313	12	1	1	CD
18637	14313	13	,	,	,
18637	14313	14	11	11	CD
18637	14313	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14313	16	1910	1910	CD
18637	14313	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14313	18	.	.	.
18637	14314	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14314	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14314	3	also	also	RB
18637	14314	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14314	5	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	14314	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14314	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14314	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14314	9	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	14314	10	,	,	,
18637	14314	11	21	21	CD
18637	14314	12	How	how	WRB
18637	14314	13	.	.	.
18637	14315	1	582	582	CD
18637	14315	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14315	3	1859	1859	CD
18637	14315	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14315	5	;	;	:
18637	14315	6	Lynde	Lynde	NNP
18637	14315	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14315	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14315	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14315	10	Lynde	Lynde	NNP
18637	14315	11	,	,	,
18637	14315	12	181	181	CD
18637	14315	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14315	14	183	183	CD
18637	14315	15	,	,	,
18637	14315	16	186	186	CD
18637	14315	17	-	-	SYM
18637	14315	18	187	187	CD
18637	14315	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14315	20	1901	1901	CD
18637	14315	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14315	22	;	;	:
18637	14315	23	Bates	Bates	NNP
18637	14315	24	_	_	NNP
18637	14315	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	14315	26	_	_	NNP
18637	14315	27	Bodie	Bodie	NNP
18637	14315	28	,	,	,
18637	14315	29	245	245	CD
18637	14315	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14315	31	520	520	CD
18637	14315	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14315	33	1918	1918	CD
18637	14315	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14315	35	;	;	:
18637	14315	36	Audubon	Audubon	NNP
18637	14315	37	_	_	NNP
18637	14315	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	14315	39	_	_	NNP
18637	14315	40	Shufeldt	Shufeldt	NNP
18637	14315	41	,	,	,
18637	14315	42	181	181	CD
18637	14315	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14315	44	575	575	CD
18637	14315	45	,	,	,
18637	14315	46	577	577	CD
18637	14315	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14315	48	1901	1901	CD
18637	14315	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14315	50	;	;	:
18637	14315	51	Yarbrough	Yarbrough	NNP
18637	14315	52	_	_	NNP
18637	14315	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	14315	54	_	_	NNP
18637	14315	55	Yarbrough	Yarbrough	NNP
18637	14315	56	,	,	,
18637	14315	57	290	290	CD
18637	14315	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14315	59	202	202	CD
18637	14315	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14315	61	1933	1933	CD
18637	14315	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14315	63	;	;	:
18637	14315	64	Loughran	Loughran	NNP
18637	14315	65	_	_	NNP
18637	14315	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	14315	67	_	_	NNP
18637	14315	68	Loughran	Loughran	NNP
18637	14315	69	,	,	,
18637	14315	70	292	292	CD
18637	14315	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14315	72	216	216	CD
18637	14315	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14315	74	1934	1934	CD
18637	14315	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14315	76	.	.	.
18637	14316	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14316	2	73	73	CD
18637	14316	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14316	4	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	14316	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14316	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14316	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14316	8	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	14316	9	,	,	,
18637	14316	10	327	327	CD
18637	14316	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14316	12	220	220	CD
18637	14316	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14316	14	1946	1946	CD
18637	14316	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14316	16	.	.	.
18637	14317	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14317	2	74	74	CD
18637	14317	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14317	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14317	5	.	.	.
18637	14318	1	228	228	CD
18637	14318	2	.	.	.
18637	14319	1	An	an	DT
18637	14319	2	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	14319	3	case	case	NN
18637	14319	4	of	of	IN
18637	14319	5	a	a	DT
18637	14319	6	quite	quite	RB
18637	14319	7	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	14319	8	pattern	pattern	NN
18637	14319	9	was	be	VBD
18637	14319	10	that	that	DT
18637	14319	11	of	of	IN
18637	14319	12	Sutton	Sutton	NNP
18637	14319	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14319	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	14319	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14319	16	Leib	Leib	NNP
18637	14319	17	.	.	.
18637	14320	1	On	on	IN
18637	14320	2	account	account	NN
18637	14320	3	of	of	IN
18637	14320	4	the	the	DT
18637	14320	5	diverse	diverse	JJ
18637	14320	6	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	14320	7	of	of	IN
18637	14320	8	the	the	DT
18637	14320	9	parties	party	NNS
18637	14320	10	,	,	,
18637	14320	11	who	who	WP
18637	14320	12	had	have	VBD
18637	14320	13	once	once	RB
18637	14320	14	been	be	VBN
18637	14320	15	husband	husband	NN
18637	14320	16	and	and	CC
18637	14320	17	wife	wife	NN
18637	14320	18	,	,	,
18637	14320	19	the	the	DT
18637	14320	20	case	case	NN
18637	14320	21	was	be	VBD
18637	14320	22	brought	bring	VBN
18637	14320	23	by	by	IN
18637	14320	24	the	the	DT
18637	14320	25	latter	latter	NN
18637	14320	26	in	in	IN
18637	14320	27	a	a	DT
18637	14320	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14320	29	court	court	NN
18637	14320	30	in	in	IN
18637	14320	31	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	14320	32	.	.	.
18637	14321	1	Her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14321	2	suit	suit	NN
18637	14321	3	was	be	VBD
18637	14321	4	to	to	TO
18637	14321	5	recover	recover	VB
18637	14321	6	unpaid	unpaid	JJ
18637	14321	7	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	14321	8	which	which	WDT
18637	14321	9	was	be	VBD
18637	14321	10	to	to	TO
18637	14321	11	continue	continue	VB
18637	14321	12	until	until	IN
18637	14321	13	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14321	14	remarriage	remarriage	NN
18637	14321	15	.	.	.
18637	14322	1	To	to	TO
18637	14322	2	be	be	VB
18637	14322	3	sure	sure	JJ
18637	14322	4	,	,	,
18637	14322	5	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14322	6	had	have	VBD
18637	14322	7	,	,	,
18637	14322	8	as	as	IN
18637	14322	9	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14322	10	confessed	confess	VBD
18637	14322	11	,	,	,
18637	14322	12	remarried	remarry	VBN
18637	14322	13	in	in	IN
18637	14322	14	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	14322	15	,	,	,
18637	14322	16	but	but	CC
18637	14322	17	the	the	DT
18637	14322	18	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	14322	19	had	have	VBD
18637	14322	20	been	be	VBN
18637	14322	21	annulled	annul	VBN
18637	14322	22	in	in	IN
18637	14322	23	New	New	NNP
18637	14322	24	York	York	NNP
18637	14322	25	on	on	IN
18637	14322	26	the	the	DT
18637	14322	27	ground	ground	NN
18637	14322	28	that	that	IN
18637	14322	29	the	the	DT
18637	14322	30	man	man	NN
18637	14322	31	was	be	VBD
18637	14322	32	already	already	RB
18637	14322	33	married	marry	VBN
18637	14322	34	,	,	,
18637	14322	35	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	14322	36	as	as	IN
18637	14322	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14322	38	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	14322	39	from	from	IN
18637	14322	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14322	41	previous	previous	JJ
18637	14322	42	wife	wife	NN
18637	14322	43	was	be	VBD
18637	14322	44	null	null	JJ
18637	14322	45	and	and	CC
18637	14322	46	void	void	JJ
18637	14322	47	,	,	,
18637	14322	48	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14322	49	having	have	VBG
18637	14322	50	neither	neither	CC
18637	14322	51	entered	enter	VBN
18637	14322	52	a	a	DT
18637	14322	53	personal	personal	JJ
18637	14322	54	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	14322	55	nor	nor	CC
18637	14322	56	been	be	VBN
18637	14322	57	personally	personally	RB
18637	14322	58	served	serve	VBN
18637	14322	59	.	.	.
18637	14323	1	The	the	DT
18637	14323	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14323	3	,	,	,
18637	14323	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	14323	5	by	by	IN
18637	14323	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14323	7	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	14323	8	,	,	,
18637	14323	9	held	hold	VBD
18637	14323	10	that	that	IN
18637	14323	11	the	the	DT
18637	14323	12	New	New	NNP
18637	14323	13	York	York	NNP
18637	14323	14	annulment	annulment	NN
18637	14323	15	of	of	IN
18637	14323	16	the	the	DT
18637	14323	17	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	14323	18	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	14323	19	must	must	MD
18637	14323	20	be	be	VB
18637	14323	21	given	give	VBN
18637	14323	22	full	full	JJ
18637	14323	23	faith	faith	NN
18637	14323	24	and	and	CC
18637	14323	25	credit	credit	NN
18637	14323	26	in	in	IN
18637	14323	27	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	14323	28	,	,	,
18637	14323	29	but	but	CC
18637	14323	30	left	leave	VBD
18637	14323	31	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	14323	32	to	to	TO
18637	14323	33	decide	decide	VB
18637	14323	34	for	for	IN
18637	14323	35	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14323	36	the	the	DT
18637	14323	37	effect	effect	NN
18637	14323	38	of	of	IN
18637	14323	39	the	the	DT
18637	14323	40	annulment	annulment	NN
18637	14323	41	upon	upon	IN
18637	14323	42	the	the	DT
18637	14323	43	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	14323	44	of	of	IN
18637	14323	45	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	14323	46	's	's	POS
18637	14323	47	first	first	JJ
18637	14323	48	husband	husband	NN
18637	14323	49	.	.	.
18637	14324	1	Sutton	Sutton	NNP
18637	14324	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14324	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14324	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14324	5	Leib	Leib	NNP
18637	14324	6	,	,	,
18637	14324	7	342	342	CD
18637	14324	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14324	9	402	402	CD
18637	14324	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14324	11	1952	1952	CD
18637	14324	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14324	13	.	.	.
18637	14325	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14325	2	75	75	CD
18637	14325	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14325	4	Halvey	Halvey	NNP
18637	14325	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14325	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14325	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14325	8	Halvey	Halvey	NNP
18637	14325	9	,	,	,
18637	14325	10	330	330	CD
18637	14325	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14325	12	610	610	CD
18637	14325	13	,	,	,
18637	14325	14	615	615	CD
18637	14325	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14325	16	1947	1947	CD
18637	14325	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14325	18	.	.	.
18637	14326	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14326	2	76	76	CD
18637	14326	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14326	4	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	14326	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14326	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14326	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14326	8	Muelberger	Muelberger	NNP
18637	14326	9	,	,	,
18637	14326	10	341	341	CD
18637	14326	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14326	12	581	581	CD
18637	14326	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14326	14	1951	1951	CD
18637	14326	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14326	16	.	.	.
18637	14327	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14327	2	77	77	CD
18637	14327	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14327	4	Tilt	Tilt	NNP
18637	14327	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14327	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14327	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14327	8	Kelsey	Kelsey	NNP
18637	14327	9	,	,	,
18637	14327	10	207	207	CD
18637	14327	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14327	12	43	43	CD
18637	14327	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14327	14	1907	1907	CD
18637	14327	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14327	16	;	;	:
18637	14327	17	Burbank	Burbank	NNP
18637	14327	18	_	_	NNP
18637	14327	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	14327	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14327	21	Ernst	Ernst	NNP
18637	14327	22	,	,	,
18637	14327	23	232	232	CD
18637	14327	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14327	25	162	162	CD
18637	14327	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14327	27	1914	1914	CD
18637	14327	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14327	29	.	.	.
18637	14328	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14328	2	78	78	CD
18637	14328	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14328	4	Riley	Riley	NNP
18637	14328	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14328	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14328	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14328	8	New	New	NNP
18637	14328	9	York	York	NNP
18637	14328	10	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	14328	11	Company	Company	NNP
18637	14328	12	,	,	,
18637	14328	13	315	315	CD
18637	14328	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14328	15	343	343	CD
18637	14328	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14328	17	1942	1942	CD
18637	14328	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14328	19	.	.	.
18637	14329	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14329	2	79	79	CD
18637	14329	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14329	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	14329	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14329	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14329	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14329	8	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	14329	9	,	,	,
18637	14329	10	210	210	CD
18637	14329	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14329	12	82	82	CD
18637	14329	13	,	,	,
18637	14329	14	90	90	CD
18637	14329	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14329	16	1908	1908	CD
18637	14329	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14329	18	.	.	.
18637	14330	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14330	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14330	3	also	also	RB
18637	14330	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14330	5	Stacy	Stacy	NNP
18637	14330	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14330	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14330	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14330	9	Thrasher	Thrasher	NNP
18637	14330	10	,	,	,
18637	14330	11	Use	Use	NNP
18637	14330	12	of	of	IN
18637	14330	13	Sellers	Sellers	NNP
18637	14330	14	,	,	,
18637	14330	15	6	6	CD
18637	14330	16	How	how	WRB
18637	14330	17	.	.	.
18637	14331	1	44	44	CD
18637	14331	2	,	,	,
18637	14331	3	58	58	CD
18637	14331	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14331	5	1848	1848	CD
18637	14331	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14331	7	;	;	:
18637	14331	8	McLean	McLean	NNP
18637	14331	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14331	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14331	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14331	12	Meek	Meek	NNP
18637	14331	13	,	,	,
18637	14331	14	18	18	CD
18637	14331	15	How	how	WRB
18637	14331	16	.	.	.
18637	14332	1	16	16	CD
18637	14332	2	,	,	,
18637	14332	3	18	18	CD
18637	14332	4	,	,	,
18637	14332	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14332	6	1856	1856	CD
18637	14332	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14332	8	.	.	.
18637	14333	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14333	2	80	80	CD
18637	14333	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14333	4	Tilt	Tilt	NNP
18637	14333	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14333	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14333	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14333	8	Kelsey	Kelsey	NNP
18637	14333	9	,	,	,
18637	14333	10	207	207	CD
18637	14333	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14333	12	43	43	CD
18637	14333	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14333	14	1907	1907	CD
18637	14333	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14333	16	.	.	.
18637	14334	1	In	in	IN
18637	14334	2	the	the	DT
18637	14334	3	case	case	NN
18637	14334	4	of	of	IN
18637	14334	5	Borer	Borer	NNP
18637	14334	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14334	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14334	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14334	9	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	14334	10	,	,	,
18637	14334	11	119	119	CD
18637	14334	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14334	13	587	587	CD
18637	14334	14	,	,	,
18637	14334	15	599	599	CD
18637	14334	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14334	17	1887	1887	CD
18637	14334	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14334	19	involving	involve	VBG
18637	14334	20	a	a	DT
18637	14334	21	complicated	complicated	JJ
18637	14334	22	set	set	NN
18637	14334	23	of	of	IN
18637	14334	24	facts	fact	NNS
18637	14334	25	,	,	,
18637	14334	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14334	27	was	be	VBD
18637	14334	28	held	hold	VBN
18637	14334	29	,	,	,
18637	14334	30	in	in	IN
18637	14334	31	1887	1887	CD
18637	14334	32	,	,	,
18637	14334	33	that	that	IN
18637	14334	34	a	a	DT
18637	14334	35	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14334	36	in	in	IN
18637	14334	37	a	a	DT
18637	14334	38	probate	probate	NN
18637	14334	39	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	14334	40	,	,	,
18637	14334	41	which	which	WDT
18637	14334	42	was	be	VBD
18637	14334	43	merely	merely	RB
18637	14334	44	ancillary	ancillary	JJ
18637	14334	45	to	to	IN
18637	14334	46	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	14334	47	in	in	IN
18637	14334	48	another	another	DT
18637	14334	49	State	State	NNP
18637	14334	50	and	and	CC
18637	14334	51	which	which	WDT
18637	14334	52	ordered	order	VBD
18637	14334	53	the	the	DT
18637	14334	54	residue	residue	NN
18637	14334	55	of	of	IN
18637	14334	56	the	the	DT
18637	14334	57	estate	estate	NN
18637	14334	58	to	to	TO
18637	14334	59	be	be	VB
18637	14334	60	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	14334	61	to	to	IN
18637	14334	62	the	the	DT
18637	14334	63	legatee	legatee	NN
18637	14334	64	and	and	CC
18637	14334	65	discharged	discharge	VBD
18637	14334	66	the	the	DT
18637	14334	67	executor	executor	NN
18637	14334	68	from	from	IN
18637	14334	69	further	further	JJ
18637	14334	70	liability	liability	NN
18637	14334	71	,	,	,
18637	14334	72	did	do	VBD
18637	14334	73	not	not	RB
18637	14334	74	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	14334	75	a	a	DT
18637	14334	76	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	14334	77	,	,	,
18637	14334	78	who	who	WP
18637	14334	79	was	be	VBD
18637	14334	80	not	not	RB
18637	14334	81	a	a	DT
18637	14334	82	resident	resident	NN
18637	14334	83	of	of	IN
18637	14334	84	the	the	DT
18637	14334	85	State	State	NNP
18637	14334	86	in	in	IN
18637	14334	87	which	which	WDT
18637	14334	88	the	the	DT
18637	14334	89	ancillary	ancillary	JJ
18637	14334	90	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14334	91	was	be	VBD
18637	14334	92	rendered	render	VBN
18637	14334	93	,	,	,
18637	14334	94	from	from	IN
18637	14334	95	setting	set	VBG
18637	14334	96	up	up	RP
18637	14334	97	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14334	98	claim	claim	NN
18637	14334	99	in	in	IN
18637	14334	100	the	the	DT
18637	14334	101	State	State	NNP
18637	14334	102	probate	probate	NN
18637	14334	103	court	court	NN
18637	14334	104	which	which	WDT
18637	14334	105	had	have	VBD
18637	14334	106	the	the	DT
18637	14334	107	primary	primary	JJ
18637	14334	108	administration	administration	NN
18637	14334	109	of	of	IN
18637	14334	110	the	the	DT
18637	14334	111	estate	estate	NN
18637	14334	112	.	.	.
18637	14335	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14335	2	81	81	CD
18637	14335	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14335	4	Blodgett	Blodgett	NNP
18637	14335	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14335	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14335	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14335	8	Silberman	Silberman	NNP
18637	14335	9	,	,	,
18637	14335	10	277	277	CD
18637	14335	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14335	12	1	1	CD
18637	14335	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14335	14	1928	1928	CD
18637	14335	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14335	16	.	.	.
18637	14336	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14336	2	82	82	CD
18637	14336	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14336	4	Kerr	Kerr	NNP
18637	14336	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14336	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14336	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14336	8	Devisees	Devisees	NNPS
18637	14336	9	of	of	IN
18637	14336	10	Moon	Moon	NNP
18637	14336	11	,	,	,
18637	14336	12	9	9	CD
18637	14336	13	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	14336	14	.	.	.
18637	14337	1	565	565	CD
18637	14337	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14337	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	14337	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14337	5	;	;	:
18637	14337	6	McCormick	McCormick	NNP
18637	14337	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14337	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14337	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14337	10	Sullivant	Sullivant	NNP
18637	14337	11	,	,	,
18637	14337	12	10	10	CD
18637	14337	13	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	14337	14	.	.	.
18637	14338	1	192	192	CD
18637	14338	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14338	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	14338	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14338	5	;	;	:
18637	14338	6	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	14338	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14338	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14338	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14338	10	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	14338	11	,	,	,
18637	14338	12	178	178	CD
18637	14338	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14338	14	186	186	CD
18637	14338	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14338	16	1900	1900	CD
18637	14338	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14338	18	.	.	.
18637	14339	1	The	the	DT
18637	14339	2	controlling	control	VBG
18637	14339	3	principle	principle	NN
18637	14339	4	of	of	IN
18637	14339	5	these	these	DT
18637	14339	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	14339	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	14339	8	not	not	RB
18637	14339	9	confined	confine	VBN
18637	14339	10	to	to	IN
18637	14339	11	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	14339	12	in	in	IN
18637	14339	13	probate	probate	NN
18637	14339	14	.	.	.
18637	14340	1	A	a	DT
18637	14340	2	court	court	NN
18637	14340	3	of	of	IN
18637	14340	4	equity	equity	NN
18637	14340	5	"	"	``
18637	14340	6	not	not	RB
18637	14340	7	having	have	VBG
18637	14340	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14340	9	of	of	IN
18637	14340	10	the	the	DT
18637	14340	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14340	12	res	res	NNP
18637	14340	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14340	14	can	can	MD
18637	14340	15	not	not	RB
18637	14340	16	affect	affect	VB
18637	14340	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14340	18	by	by	IN
18637	14340	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14340	20	decree	decree	NN
18637	14340	21	nor	nor	CC
18637	14340	22	by	by	IN
18637	14340	23	a	a	DT
18637	14340	24	deed	deed	NN
18637	14340	25	made	make	VBN
18637	14340	26	by	by	IN
18637	14340	27	a	a	DT
18637	14340	28	master	master	NN
18637	14340	29	in	in	IN
18637	14340	30	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	14340	31	with	with	IN
18637	14340	32	the	the	DT
18637	14340	33	decree	decree	NN
18637	14340	34	.	.	.
18637	14340	35	"	"	''
18637	14341	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14341	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14341	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14341	4	Fall	Fall	NNP
18637	14341	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14341	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14341	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14341	8	Eastin	Eastin	NNP
18637	14341	9	,	,	,
18637	14341	10	215	215	CD
18637	14341	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14341	12	1	1	CD
18637	14341	13	,	,	,
18637	14341	14	11	11	CD
18637	14341	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14341	16	1909	1909	CD
18637	14341	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14341	18	.	.	.
18637	14342	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14342	2	83	83	CD
18637	14342	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14342	4	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	14342	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14342	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14342	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14342	8	Pickrell	Pickrell	NNP
18637	14342	9	,	,	,
18637	14342	10	109	109	CD
18637	14342	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14342	12	608	608	CD
18637	14342	13	,	,	,
18637	14342	14	611	611	CD
18637	14342	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14342	16	1883	1883	CD
18637	14342	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14342	18	.	.	.
18637	14343	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14343	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14343	3	also	also	RB
18637	14343	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14343	5	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	14343	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14343	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14343	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14343	9	Mayer	Mayer	NNP
18637	14343	10	,	,	,
18637	14343	11	10	10	CD
18637	14343	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	14343	13	.	.	.
18637	14344	1	465	465	CD
18637	14344	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14344	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	14344	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14344	5	;	;	:
18637	14344	6	Gasquet	Gasquet	NNP
18637	14344	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14344	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14344	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14344	10	Fenner	Fenner	NNP
18637	14344	11	,	,	,
18637	14344	12	247	247	CD
18637	14344	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14344	14	16	16	CD
18637	14344	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14344	16	1918	1918	CD
18637	14344	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14344	18	.	.	.
18637	14345	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14345	2	84	84	CD
18637	14345	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14345	4	Olmsted	Olmsted	NNP
18637	14345	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14345	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14345	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14345	8	Olmsted	Olmsted	NNP
18637	14345	9	,	,	,
18637	14345	10	216	216	CD
18637	14345	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14345	12	386	386	CD
18637	14345	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14345	14	1910	1910	CD
18637	14345	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14345	16	.	.	.
18637	14346	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14346	2	85	85	CD
18637	14346	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14346	4	Hood	Hood	NNP
18637	14346	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14346	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14346	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14346	8	McGehee	McGehee	NNP
18637	14346	9	,	,	,
18637	14346	10	237	237	CD
18637	14346	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14346	12	611	611	CD
18637	14346	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14346	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	14346	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14346	16	.	.	.
18637	14347	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14347	2	86	86	CD
18637	14347	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14347	4	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	14347	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14347	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14347	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14347	8	Balk	Balk	NNP
18637	14347	9	,	,	,
18637	14347	10	198	198	CD
18637	14347	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14347	12	215	215	CD
18637	14347	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14347	14	1905	1905	CD
18637	14347	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14347	16	.	.	.
18637	14348	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14348	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14348	3	also	also	RB
18637	14348	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14348	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	14348	6	,	,	,
18637	14348	7	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	14348	8	&	&	CC
18637	14348	9	Pac	Pac	NNP
18637	14348	10	.	.	.
18637	14349	1	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	14349	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14349	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14349	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14349	5	Sturm	Sturm	NNP
18637	14349	6	,	,	,
18637	14349	7	174	174	CD
18637	14349	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14349	9	710	710	CD
18637	14349	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14349	11	1899	1899	CD
18637	14349	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14349	13	;	;	:
18637	14349	14	King	King	NNP
18637	14349	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14349	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	14349	17	_	_	NNP
18637	14349	18	Cross	Cross	NNP
18637	14349	19	,	,	,
18637	14349	20	175	175	CD
18637	14349	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14349	22	396	396	CD
18637	14349	23	,	,	,
18637	14349	24	399	399	CD
18637	14349	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14349	26	1899	1899	CD
18637	14349	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14349	28	;	;	:
18637	14349	29	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	14349	30	&	&	CC
18637	14349	31	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	14350	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14350	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14350	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14350	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14350	5	Deer	Deer	NNP
18637	14350	6	,	,	,
18637	14350	7	200	200	CD
18637	14350	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14350	9	176	176	CD
18637	14350	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14350	11	1906	1906	CD
18637	14350	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14350	13	;	;	:
18637	14350	14	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	14350	15	&	&	CC
18637	14350	16	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	14351	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14351	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14351	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14351	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14351	5	Hostetter	Hostetter	NNP
18637	14351	6	,	,	,
18637	14351	7	240	240	CD
18637	14351	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14351	9	620	620	CD
18637	14351	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14351	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	14351	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14351	13	.	.	.
18637	14352	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14352	2	87	87	CD
18637	14352	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14352	4	Christmas	Christmas	NNP
18637	14352	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14352	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14352	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14352	8	Russell	Russell	NNP
18637	14352	9	,	,	,
18637	14352	10	5	5	CD
18637	14352	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14352	12	.	.	.
18637	14353	1	290	290	CD
18637	14353	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14353	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	14353	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14353	5	;	;	:
18637	14353	6	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	14353	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14353	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14353	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14353	10	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	14353	11	,	,	,
18637	14353	12	21	21	CD
18637	14353	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14353	14	.	.	.
18637	14354	1	71	71	CD
18637	14354	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14354	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	14354	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14354	5	;	;	:
18637	14354	6	Hanley	Hanley	NNP
18637	14354	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14354	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14354	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14354	10	Donoghue	Donoghue	NNP
18637	14354	11	,	,	,
18637	14354	12	116	116	CD
18637	14354	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14354	14	1	1	CD
18637	14354	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14354	16	1885	1885	CD
18637	14354	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14354	18	;	;	:
18637	14354	19	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	14354	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14354	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	14354	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14354	23	Pelican	Pelican	NNP
18637	14354	24	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14354	25	.	.	.
18637	14355	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14355	2	,	,	,
18637	14355	3	127	127	CD
18637	14355	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14355	5	265	265	CD
18637	14355	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14355	7	1888	1888	CD
18637	14355	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14355	9	;	;	:
18637	14355	10	Simmons	Simmons	NNP
18637	14355	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14355	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	14355	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14355	14	Saul	Saul	NNP
18637	14355	15	,	,	,
18637	14355	16	138	138	CD
18637	14355	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14355	18	439	439	CD
18637	14355	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14355	20	1891	1891	CD
18637	14355	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14355	22	;	;	:
18637	14355	23	American	American	NNP
18637	14355	24	Express	Express	NNP
18637	14355	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14355	26	_	_	NNP
18637	14355	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	14355	28	_	_	NNP
18637	14355	29	Mullins	Mullins	NNP
18637	14355	30	,	,	,
18637	14355	31	212	212	CD
18637	14355	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14355	33	311	311	CD
18637	14355	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14355	35	1909	1909	CD
18637	14355	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14355	37	.	.	.
18637	14356	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14356	2	88	88	CD
18637	14356	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14356	4	Fauntleroy	Fauntleroy	NNP
18637	14356	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14356	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14356	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14356	8	Lum	Lum	NNP
18637	14356	9	,	,	,
18637	14356	10	210	210	CD
18637	14356	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14356	12	230	230	CD
18637	14356	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14356	14	1908	1908	CD
18637	14356	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14356	16	.	.	.
18637	14357	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14357	2	89	89	CD
18637	14357	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14357	4	Anglo	anglo	JJ
18637	14357	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	14357	6	American	American	NNP
18637	14357	7	Provision	Provision	NNP
18637	14357	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14357	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14357	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14357	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14357	12	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	14357	13	Provision	Provision	NNP
18637	14357	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14357	15	,	,	,
18637	14357	16	191	191	CD
18637	14357	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14357	18	373	373	CD
18637	14357	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14357	20	1903	1903	CD
18637	14357	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14357	22	.	.	.
18637	14358	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14358	2	90	90	CD
18637	14358	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14358	4	133	133	CD
18637	14358	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14358	6	107	107	CD
18637	14358	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14358	8	1890	1890	CD
18637	14358	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14358	10	.	.	.
18637	14359	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14359	2	91	91	CD
18637	14359	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14359	4	The	the	DT
18637	14359	5	Antelope	Antelope	NNP
18637	14359	6	,	,	,
18637	14359	7	10	10	CD
18637	14359	8	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	14359	9	.	.	.
18637	14360	1	66	66	CD
18637	14360	2	,	,	,
18637	14360	3	123	123	CD
18637	14360	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14360	5	1825	1825	CD
18637	14360	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14360	7	.	.	.
18637	14361	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14361	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14361	3	also	also	RB
18637	14361	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14361	5	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	14361	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14361	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14361	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14361	9	Pelican	Pelican	NNP
18637	14361	10	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14361	11	.	.	.
18637	14362	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14362	2	,	,	,
18637	14362	3	127	127	CD
18637	14362	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14362	5	265	265	CD
18637	14362	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14362	7	1888	1888	CD
18637	14362	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14362	9	.	.	.
18637	14363	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14363	2	92	92	CD
18637	14363	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14363	4	146	146	CD
18637	14363	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14363	6	657	657	CD
18637	14363	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14363	8	1892	1892	CD
18637	14363	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14363	10	.	.	.
18637	14364	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14364	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14364	3	also	also	RB
18637	14364	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14364	5	Dennick	Dennick	NNP
18637	14364	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14364	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14364	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14364	9	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	14365	1	103	103	CD
18637	14365	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14365	3	11	11	CD
18637	14365	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14365	5	1881	1881	CD
18637	14365	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14365	7	.	.	.
18637	14366	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14366	2	93	93	CD
18637	14366	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14366	4	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	14366	5	County	County	NNP
18637	14366	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14366	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14366	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14366	9	White	White	NNP
18637	14366	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14366	11	N.E.	N.E.	NNP
18637	14366	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14367	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14367	2	,	,	,
18637	14367	3	296	296	CD
18637	14367	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14367	5	268	268	CD
18637	14367	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14367	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	14367	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14367	9	.	.	.
18637	14368	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14368	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14368	3	also	also	RB
18637	14368	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14368	5	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	14368	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14368	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14368	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14368	9	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	14368	10	,	,	,
18637	14368	11	281	281	CD
18637	14368	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14368	13	18	18	CD
18637	14368	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14368	15	1930	1930	CD
18637	14368	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14368	17	.	.	.
18637	14369	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14369	2	94	94	CD
18637	14369	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14369	4	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	14369	5	of	of	IN
18637	14369	6	Augusta	Augusta	NNP
18637	14369	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14369	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14369	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14369	10	Earle	Earle	NNP
18637	14369	11	,	,	,
18637	14369	12	13	13	CD
18637	14369	13	Pet	pet	NN
18637	14369	14	.	.	.
18637	14370	1	519	519	CD
18637	14370	2	,	,	,
18637	14370	3	589	589	CD
18637	14370	4	-	-	SYM
18637	14370	5	596	596	CD
18637	14370	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14370	7	1839	1839	CD
18637	14370	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14370	9	.	.	.
18637	14371	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14371	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14371	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14371	4	Kryger	Kryger	NNP
18637	14371	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14371	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14371	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14371	8	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	14371	9	,	,	,
18637	14371	10	242	242	CD
18637	14371	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14371	12	171	171	CD
18637	14371	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14371	14	1916	1916	CD
18637	14371	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14371	16	;	;	:
18637	14371	17	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	14371	18	_	_	NNP
18637	14371	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	14371	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14371	21	Hume	Hume	NNP
18637	14371	22	,	,	,
18637	14371	23	243	243	CD
18637	14371	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14371	25	15	15	CD
18637	14371	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14371	27	1917	1917	CD
18637	14371	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14371	29	.	.	.
18637	14372	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14372	2	95	95	CD
18637	14372	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14372	4	19	19	CD
18637	14372	5	How	how	WRB
18637	14372	6	.	.	.
18637	14373	1	393	393	CD
18637	14373	2	,	,	,
18637	14373	3	460	460	CD
18637	14373	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14373	5	1857	1857	CD
18637	14373	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14373	7	;	;	:
18637	14373	8	Bonaparte	Bonaparte	NNP
18637	14373	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14373	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14373	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14373	12	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	14373	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14373	14	,	,	,
18637	14373	15	104	104	CD
18637	14373	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14373	17	592	592	CD
18637	14373	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14373	19	1882	1882	CD
18637	14373	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14373	21	,	,	,
18637	14373	22	where	where	WRB
18637	14373	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14373	24	was	be	VBD
18637	14373	25	held	hold	VBN
18637	14373	26	that	that	IN
18637	14373	27	a	a	DT
18637	14373	28	law	law	NN
18637	14373	29	exempting	exempt	VBG
18637	14373	30	from	from	IN
18637	14373	31	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	14373	32	certain	certain	JJ
18637	14373	33	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	14373	34	of	of	IN
18637	14373	35	the	the	DT
18637	14373	36	enacting	enact	VBG
18637	14373	37	State	State	NNP
18637	14373	38	did	do	VBD
18637	14373	39	not	not	RB
18637	14373	40	operate	operate	VB
18637	14373	41	extraterritorially	extraterritorially	RB
18637	14373	42	by	by	IN
18637	14373	43	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	14373	44	of	of	IN
18637	14373	45	the	the	DT
18637	14373	46	full	full	JJ
18637	14373	47	faith	faith	NN
18637	14373	48	and	and	CC
18637	14373	49	credit	credit	NN
18637	14373	50	clause	clause	NN
18637	14373	51	.	.	.
18637	14374	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14374	2	96	96	CD
18637	14374	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14374	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	14374	5	&	&	CC
18637	14374	6	Alton	Alton	NNP
18637	14374	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	14374	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14374	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14374	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14374	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14374	12	Wiggins	Wiggins	NNP
18637	14374	13	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	14374	14	,	,	,
18637	14374	15	119	119	CD
18637	14374	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14374	17	615	615	CD
18637	14374	18	,	,	,
18637	14374	19	622	622	CD
18637	14374	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14374	21	1887	1887	CD
18637	14374	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14374	23	.	.	.
18637	14375	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14375	2	97	97	CD
18637	14375	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14375	4	Smithsonian	Smithsonian	NNP
18637	14375	5	Institution	Institution	NNP
18637	14375	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14375	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14375	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14375	9	St.	St.	NNP
18637	14375	10	John	John	NNP
18637	14375	11	,	,	,
18637	14375	12	214	214	CD
18637	14375	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14375	14	19	19	CD
18637	14375	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14375	16	1909	1909	CD
18637	14375	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14375	18	.	.	.
18637	14376	1	When	when	WRB
18637	14376	2	,	,	,
18637	14376	3	in	in	IN
18637	14376	4	a	a	DT
18637	14376	5	State	State	NNP
18637	14376	6	court	court	NN
18637	14376	7	,	,	,
18637	14376	8	the	the	DT
18637	14376	9	validity	validity	NN
18637	14376	10	of	of	IN
18637	14376	11	an	an	DT
18637	14376	12	act	act	NN
18637	14376	13	of	of	IN
18637	14376	14	the	the	DT
18637	14376	15	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	14376	16	of	of	IN
18637	14376	17	another	another	DT
18637	14376	18	State	State	NNP
18637	14376	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	14376	20	not	not	RB
18637	14376	21	in	in	IN
18637	14376	22	question	question	NN
18637	14376	23	,	,	,
18637	14376	24	and	and	CC
18637	14376	25	the	the	DT
18637	14376	26	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	14376	27	turns	turn	VBZ
18637	14376	28	merely	merely	RB
18637	14376	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	14376	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14376	31	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	14376	32	or	or	CC
18637	14376	33	construction	construction	NN
18637	14376	34	,	,	,
18637	14376	35	no	no	DT
18637	14376	36	question	question	NN
18637	14376	37	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	14376	38	under	under	IN
18637	14376	39	the	the	DT
18637	14376	40	full	full	JJ
18637	14376	41	faith	faith	NN
18637	14376	42	and	and	CC
18637	14376	43	credit	credit	NN
18637	14376	44	clause	clause	NN
18637	14376	45	.	.	.
18637	14377	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14377	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14377	3	also	also	RB
18637	14377	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14377	5	Western	Western	NNP
18637	14377	6	Life	Life	NNP
18637	14377	7	Indemnity	Indemnity	NNP
18637	14377	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14377	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14377	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14377	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14377	12	Rupp	Rupp	NNP
18637	14377	13	,	,	,
18637	14377	14	235	235	CD
18637	14377	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14377	16	261	261	CD
18637	14377	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14377	18	1914	1914	CD
18637	14377	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14377	20	,	,	,
18637	14377	21	citing	cite	VBG
18637	14377	22	Glenn	Glenn	NNP
18637	14377	23	_	_	NNP
18637	14377	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	14377	25	_	_	NNP
18637	14377	26	Garth	Garth	NNP
18637	14377	27	,	,	,
18637	14377	28	147	147	CD
18637	14377	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14377	30	360	360	CD
18637	14377	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14377	32	1893	1893	CD
18637	14377	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14377	34	;	;	:
18637	14377	35	Lloyd	Lloyd	NNP
18637	14377	36	_	_	NNP
18637	14377	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	14377	38	_	_	NNP
18637	14377	39	Matthews	Matthews	NNP
18637	14377	40	,	,	,
18637	14377	41	155	155	CD
18637	14377	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14377	43	222	222	CD
18637	14377	44	,	,	,
18637	14377	45	227	227	CD
18637	14377	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14377	47	1894	1894	CD
18637	14377	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14377	49	;	;	:
18637	14377	50	Banholzer	Banholzer	NNP
18637	14377	51	_	_	NNP
18637	14377	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	14377	53	_	_	NNP
18637	14377	54	New	New	NNP
18637	14377	55	York	York	NNP
18637	14377	56	L.	L.	NNP
18637	14377	57	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14377	58	.	.	.
18637	14378	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14378	2	,	,	,
18637	14378	3	178	178	CD
18637	14378	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14378	5	402	402	CD
18637	14378	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14378	7	1900	1900	CD
18637	14378	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14378	9	;	;	:
18637	14378	10	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	14378	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14378	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	14378	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14378	14	Alleghany	Alleghany	NNP
18637	14378	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14378	16	,	,	,
18637	14378	17	196	196	CD
18637	14378	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14378	19	458	458	CD
18637	14378	20	,	,	,
18637	14378	21	465	465	CD
18637	14378	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14378	23	1905	1905	CD
18637	14378	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14378	25	;	;	:
18637	14378	26	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	14378	27	&	&	CC
18637	14378	28	N.O.R.	N.O.R.	NNP
18637	14379	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14379	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14379	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14379	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14379	5	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	14379	6	,	,	,
18637	14379	7	221	221	CD
18637	14379	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14379	9	408	408	CD
18637	14379	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14379	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	14379	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14379	13	.	.	.
18637	14380	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14380	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14380	3	also	also	RB
18637	14380	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14380	5	National	National	NNP
18637	14380	6	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	14380	7	.	.	.
18637	14381	1	Bldg	bldg	UH
18637	14381	2	.	.	.
18637	14382	1	&	&	CC
18637	14382	2	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	14382	3	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	14382	4	.	.	.
18637	14383	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14383	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	14383	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14383	4	Brahan	Brahan	NNP
18637	14383	5	,	,	,
18637	14383	6	193	193	CD
18637	14383	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14383	8	635	635	CD
18637	14383	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14383	10	1904	1904	CD
18637	14383	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14383	12	;	;	:
18637	14383	13	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	14383	14	_	_	NNP
18637	14383	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	14383	16	_	_	NNP
18637	14383	17	New	New	NNP
18637	14383	18	York	York	NNP
18637	14383	19	Life	Life	NNP
18637	14383	20	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14383	21	.	.	.
18637	14384	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14384	2	,	,	,
18637	14384	3	187	187	CD
18637	14384	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14384	5	491	491	CD
18637	14384	6	,	,	,
18637	14384	7	495	495	CD
18637	14384	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14384	9	1903	1903	CD
18637	14384	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14384	11	;	;	:
18637	14384	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	14384	13	F.	F.	NNP
18637	14384	14	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14384	15	.	.	.
18637	14385	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14385	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14385	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14385	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14385	5	Gold	Gold	NNP
18637	14385	6	Issue	Issue	NNP
18637	14385	7	Min	Min	NNP
18637	14385	8	.	.	.
18637	14386	1	&	&	CC
18637	14386	2	Mill	Mill	NNP
18637	14386	3	.	.	.
18637	14387	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14387	2	,	,	,
18637	14387	3	243	243	CD
18637	14387	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14387	5	93	93	CD
18637	14387	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14387	7	1917	1917	CD
18637	14387	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14387	9	.	.	.
18637	14388	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14388	2	98	98	CD
18637	14388	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14388	4	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	14388	5	Packers	Packers	NNP
18637	14388	6	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	14388	7	.	.	.
18637	14389	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14389	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	14389	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14389	4	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	14389	5	Acci	Acci	NNP
18637	14389	6	.	.	.
18637	14390	1	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	14390	2	,	,	,
18637	14390	3	294	294	CD
18637	14390	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14390	5	532	532	CD
18637	14390	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14390	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	14390	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14390	9	;	;	:
18637	14390	10	Bradford	Bradford	NNP
18637	14390	11	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	14390	12	Light	Light	NNP
18637	14390	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14390	14	_	_	NNP
18637	14390	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	14390	16	_	_	NNP
18637	14390	17	Clapper	Clapper	NNP
18637	14390	18	,	,	,
18637	14390	19	286	286	CD
18637	14390	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14390	21	145	145	CD
18637	14390	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14390	23	1932	1932	CD
18637	14390	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14390	25	.	.	.
18637	14391	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14391	2	99	99	CD
18637	14391	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14391	4	Dennick	Dennick	NNP
18637	14391	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14391	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14391	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14391	8	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	14391	9	,	,	,
18637	14391	10	103	103	CD
18637	14391	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14391	12	11	11	CD
18637	14391	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14391	14	1881	1881	CD
18637	14391	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14391	16	was	be	VBD
18637	14391	17	the	the	DT
18637	14391	18	first	first	JJ
18637	14391	19	of	of	IN
18637	14391	20	the	the	DT
18637	14391	21	so	so	RB
18637	14391	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	14391	23	called	call	VBN
18637	14391	24	"	"	``
18637	14391	25	Death	Death	NNP
18637	14391	26	Act	Act	NNP
18637	14391	27	"	"	''
18637	14391	28	cases	case	NNS
18637	14391	29	to	to	TO
18637	14391	30	reach	reach	VB
18637	14391	31	the	the	DT
18637	14391	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14391	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14391	34	.	.	.
18637	14392	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14392	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14392	3	also	also	RB
18637	14392	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14392	5	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	14392	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14392	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14392	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14392	9	B.	B.	NNP
18637	14392	10	&	&	CC
18637	14392	11	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	14393	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14393	2	,	,	,
18637	14393	3	168	168	CD
18637	14393	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14393	5	445	445	CD
18637	14393	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14393	7	1897	1897	CD
18637	14393	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14393	9	.	.	.
18637	14394	1	Even	even	RB
18637	14394	2	today	today	NN
18637	14394	3	the	the	DT
18637	14394	4	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	14394	5	of	of	IN
18637	14394	6	a	a	DT
18637	14394	7	State	State	NNP
18637	14394	8	to	to	TO
18637	14394	9	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	14394	10	a	a	DT
18637	14394	11	forum	forum	NN
18637	14394	12	for	for	IN
18637	14394	13	the	the	DT
18637	14394	14	determination	determination	NN
18637	14394	15	of	of	IN
18637	14394	16	death	death	NN
18637	14394	17	claims	claim	NNS
18637	14394	18	arising	arise	VBG
18637	14394	19	in	in	IN
18637	14394	20	another	another	DT
18637	14394	21	State	state	NN
18637	14394	22	under	under	IN
18637	14394	23	the	the	DT
18637	14394	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	14394	25	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	14394	26	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	14394	27	to	to	TO
18637	14394	28	rest	rest	VB
18637	14394	29	on	on	IN
18637	14394	30	a	a	DT
18637	14394	31	rather	rather	RB
18637	14394	32	precarious	precarious	JJ
18637	14394	33	basis	basis	NN
18637	14394	34	.	.	.
18637	14395	1	In	in	IN
18637	14395	2	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	14395	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14395	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	14395	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14395	6	Fetter	Fetter	NNP
18637	14395	7	,	,	,
18637	14395	8	341	341	CD
18637	14395	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14395	10	609	609	CD
18637	14395	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14395	12	1951	1951	CD
18637	14395	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14395	14	,	,	,
18637	14395	15	the	the	DT
18637	14395	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14395	17	,	,	,
18637	14395	18	by	by	IN
18637	14395	19	a	a	DT
18637	14395	20	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	14395	21	majority	majority	NN
18637	14395	22	,	,	,
18637	14395	23	held	hold	VBD
18637	14395	24	invalid	invalid	NNP
18637	14395	25	under	under	IN
18637	14395	26	the	the	DT
18637	14395	27	full	full	JJ
18637	14395	28	faith	faith	NN
18637	14395	29	and	and	CC
18637	14395	30	credit	credit	NN
18637	14395	31	clause	clause	NN
18637	14395	32	a	a	DT
18637	14395	33	statute	statute	NN
18637	14395	34	of	of	IN
18637	14395	35	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	14395	36	which	which	WDT
18637	14395	37	,	,	,
18637	14395	38	as	as	IN
18637	14395	39	locally	locally	RB
18637	14395	40	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	14395	41	,	,	,
18637	14395	42	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	14395	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14395	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	14395	45	to	to	TO
18637	14395	46	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	14395	47	suits	suit	NNS
18637	14395	48	of	of	IN
18637	14395	49	this	this	DT
18637	14395	50	nature	nature	NN
18637	14395	51	;	;	:
18637	14395	52	and	and	CC
18637	14395	53	in	in	IN
18637	14395	54	First	First	NNP
18637	14395	55	National	National	NNP
18637	14395	56	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	14395	57	_	_	NNP
18637	14395	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	14395	59	_	_	NNP
18637	14395	60	United	United	NNP
18637	14395	61	Air	Air	NNP
18637	14395	62	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	14395	63	,	,	,
18637	14395	64	342	342	CD
18637	14395	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14395	66	396	396	CD
18637	14395	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14395	68	1952	1952	CD
18637	14395	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14395	70	,	,	,
18637	14395	71	a	a	DT
18637	14395	72	like	like	JJ
18637	14395	73	result	result	NN
18637	14395	74	was	be	VBD
18637	14395	75	reached	reach	VBN
18637	14395	76	as	as	IN
18637	14395	77	to	to	IN
18637	14395	78	an	an	DT
18637	14395	79	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	14395	80	statute	statute	NN
18637	14395	81	.	.	.
18637	14396	1	In	in	IN
18637	14396	2	both	both	DT
18637	14396	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	14396	4	the	the	DT
18637	14396	5	same	same	JJ
18637	14396	6	four	four	CD
18637	14396	7	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	14396	8	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	14396	9	.	.	.
18637	14397	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14397	2	100	100	CD
18637	14397	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14397	4	119	119	CD
18637	14397	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14397	6	615	615	CD
18637	14397	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14397	8	1887	1887	CD
18637	14397	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14397	10	.	.	.
18637	14398	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14398	2	101	101	CD
18637	14398	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14398	4	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	14398	5	Pac	Pac	NNP
18637	14398	6	.	.	.
18637	14399	1	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	14400	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14400	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	14400	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14400	4	Babcock	Babcock	NNP
18637	14400	5	,	,	,
18637	14400	6	154	154	CD
18637	14400	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14400	8	190	190	CD
18637	14400	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14400	10	1894	1894	CD
18637	14400	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14400	12	;	;	:
18637	14400	13	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	14400	14	,	,	,
18637	14400	15	T.	T.	NNP
18637	14400	16	&	&	CC
18637	14400	17	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	14401	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14401	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14401	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14401	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14401	5	Sowers	Sowers	NNP
18637	14401	6	,	,	,
18637	14401	7	213	213	CD
18637	14401	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14401	9	55	55	CD
18637	14401	10	,	,	,
18637	14401	11	67	67	CD
18637	14401	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14401	13	1909	1909	CD
18637	14401	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14401	15	.	.	.
18637	14402	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14402	2	102	102	CD
18637	14402	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14402	4	Glenn	Glenn	NNP
18637	14402	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14402	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14402	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14402	8	Garth	Garth	NNP
18637	14402	9	,	,	,
18637	14402	10	147	147	CD
18637	14402	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14402	12	360	360	CD
18637	14402	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14402	14	1893	1893	CD
18637	14402	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14402	16	.	.	.
18637	14403	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14403	2	103	103	CD
18637	14403	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14403	4	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	14403	5	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	14403	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14403	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14403	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14403	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14403	10	George	George	NNP
18637	14403	11	,	,	,
18637	14403	12	233	233	CD
18637	14403	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14403	14	354	354	CD
18637	14403	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14403	16	1914	1914	CD
18637	14403	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14403	18	.	.	.
18637	14404	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14404	2	104	104	CD
18637	14404	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14404	4	Klaxon	Klaxon	NNP
18637	14404	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14404	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14404	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14404	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14404	9	Stentor	Stentor	NNP
18637	14404	10	,	,	,
18637	14404	11	313	313	CD
18637	14404	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14404	13	487	487	CD
18637	14404	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14404	15	1941	1941	CD
18637	14404	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14404	17	;	;	:
18637	14404	18	John	John	NNP
18637	14404	19	Hancock	Hancock	NNP
18637	14404	20	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	14404	21	.	.	.
18637	14405	1	Life	Life	NNP
18637	14405	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14405	3	.	.	.
18637	14406	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14406	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14406	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14406	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14406	5	Yates	Yates	NNP
18637	14406	6	,	,	,
18637	14406	7	299	299	CD
18637	14406	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14406	9	178	178	CD
18637	14406	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14406	11	1936	1936	CD
18637	14406	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14406	13	distinguished	distinguish	VBD
18637	14406	14	.	.	.
18637	14407	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14407	2	105	105	CD
18637	14407	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14407	4	Modern	modern	JJ
18637	14407	5	Woodmen	Woodmen	NNP
18637	14407	6	of	of	IN
18637	14407	7	Am	Am	NNP
18637	14407	8	.	.	.
18637	14408	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14408	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	14408	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14408	4	Mixer	Mixer	NNP
18637	14408	5	,	,	,
18637	14408	6	267	267	CD
18637	14408	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14408	8	544	544	CD
18637	14408	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14408	10	1925	1925	CD
18637	14408	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14408	12	.	.	.
18637	14409	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14409	2	106	106	CD
18637	14409	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14409	4	Converse	Converse	NNP
18637	14409	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14409	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14409	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14409	8	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	14409	9	,	,	,
18637	14409	10	224	224	CD
18637	14409	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14409	12	243	243	CD
18637	14409	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14409	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	14409	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14409	16	;	;	:
18637	14409	17	Selig	Selig	NNP
18637	14409	18	_	_	NNP
18637	14409	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	14409	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14409	21	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	14409	22	,	,	,
18637	14409	23	234	234	CD
18637	14409	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14409	25	652	652	CD
18637	14409	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14409	27	1914	1914	CD
18637	14409	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14409	29	;	;	:
18637	14409	30	Marin	Marin	NNP
18637	14409	31	_	_	NNP
18637	14409	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	14409	33	_	_	NNP
18637	14409	34	Augedahl	Augedahl	NNP
18637	14409	35	,	,	,
18637	14409	36	247	247	CD
18637	14409	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14409	38	142	142	CD
18637	14409	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14409	40	1918	1918	CD
18637	14409	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14409	42	.	.	.
18637	14410	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14410	2	107	107	CD
18637	14410	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14410	4	Broderick	Broderick	NNP
18637	14410	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14410	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14410	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14410	8	Rosner	Rosner	NNP
18637	14410	9	,	,	,
18637	14410	10	294	294	CD
18637	14410	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14410	12	629	629	CD
18637	14410	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14410	14	1935	1935	CD
18637	14410	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14410	16	.	.	.
18637	14411	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14411	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14411	3	also	also	RB
18637	14411	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14411	5	Thormann	Thormann	NNP
18637	14411	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14411	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14411	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14411	9	Frame	Frame	NNP
18637	14411	10	,	,	,
18637	14411	11	176	176	CD
18637	14411	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14411	13	350	350	CD
18637	14411	14	,	,	,
18637	14411	15	356	356	CD
18637	14411	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14411	17	1900	1900	CD
18637	14411	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14411	19	;	;	:
18637	14411	20	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	14411	21	_	_	NNP
18637	14411	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	14411	23	_	_	NNP
18637	14411	24	Stockton	Stockton	NNP
18637	14411	25	,	,	,
18637	14411	26	140	140	CD
18637	14411	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14411	28	254	254	CD
18637	14411	29	,	,	,
18637	14411	30	264	264	CD
18637	14411	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14411	32	1891	1891	CD
18637	14411	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14411	34	.	.	.
18637	14412	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14412	2	108	108	CD
18637	14412	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14412	4	Hancock	Hancock	NNP
18637	14412	5	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	14412	6	.	.	.
18637	14413	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	14413	2	.	.	.
18637	14414	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14414	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	14414	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14414	4	Farnum	Farnum	NNP
18637	14414	5	,	,	,
18637	14414	6	176	176	CD
18637	14414	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14414	8	640	640	CD
18637	14414	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14414	10	1900	1900	CD
18637	14414	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14414	12	.	.	.
18637	14415	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14415	2	109	109	CD
18637	14415	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14415	4	237	237	CD
18637	14415	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14415	6	531	531	CD
18637	14415	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14415	8	1916	1916	CD
18637	14415	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14415	10	;	;	:
18637	14415	11	followed	follow	VBN
18637	14415	12	in	in	IN
18637	14415	13	Modern	Modern	NNP
18637	14415	14	Woodmen	Woodmen	NNP
18637	14415	15	of	of	IN
18637	14415	16	Am	Am	NNP
18637	14415	17	.	.	.
18637	14416	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14416	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	14416	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14416	4	Mixer	Mixer	NNP
18637	14416	5	,	,	,
18637	14416	6	267	267	CD
18637	14416	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14416	8	544	544	CD
18637	14416	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14416	10	1925	1925	CD
18637	14416	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14416	12	.	.	.
18637	14417	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14417	2	110	110	CD
18637	14417	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14417	4	305	305	CD
18637	14417	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14417	6	66	66	CD
18637	14417	7	,	,	,
18637	14417	8	75	75	CD
18637	14417	9	,	,	,
18637	14417	10	79	79	CD
18637	14417	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14417	12	1938	1938	CD
18637	14417	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14417	14	.	.	.
18637	14418	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14418	2	111	111	CD
18637	14418	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14418	4	331	331	CD
18637	14418	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14418	6	586	586	CD
18637	14418	7	,	,	,
18637	14418	8	588	588	CD
18637	14418	9	-	-	SYM
18637	14418	10	589	589	CD
18637	14418	11	,	,	,
18637	14418	12	637	637	CD
18637	14418	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14418	14	1947	1947	CD
18637	14418	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14418	16	.	.	.
18637	14419	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14419	2	112	112	CD
18637	14419	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14419	4	New	New	NNP
18637	14419	5	York	York	NNP
18637	14419	6	Life	Life	NNP
18637	14419	7	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14419	8	.	.	.
18637	14420	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14420	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14420	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14420	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14420	5	Head	Head	NNP
18637	14420	6	,	,	,
18637	14420	7	234	234	CD
18637	14420	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14420	9	149	149	CD
18637	14420	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14420	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	14420	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14420	13	;	;	:
18637	14420	14	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	14420	15	Life	Life	NNP
18637	14420	16	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14420	17	.	.	.
18637	14421	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14421	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14421	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14421	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14421	5	Dunken	Dunken	NNP
18637	14421	6	,	,	,
18637	14421	7	266	266	CD
18637	14421	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14421	9	389	389	CD
18637	14421	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14421	11	1924	1924	CD
18637	14421	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14421	13	.	.	.
18637	14422	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14422	2	113	113	CD
18637	14422	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14422	4	193	193	CD
18637	14422	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14422	6	635	635	CD
18637	14422	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14422	8	1904	1904	CD
18637	14422	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14422	10	.	.	.
18637	14423	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14423	2	114	114	CD
18637	14423	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14423	4	National	National	NNP
18637	14423	5	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	14423	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	14424	1	&	&	CC
18637	14424	2	L.	L.	NNP
18637	14424	3	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	14424	4	.	.	.
18637	14425	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14425	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	14425	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14425	4	Brahan	Brahan	NNP
18637	14425	5	,	,	,
18637	14425	6	193	193	CD
18637	14425	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14425	8	635	635	CD
18637	14425	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14425	10	1904	1904	CD
18637	14425	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14425	12	.	.	.
18637	14426	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14426	2	115	115	CD
18637	14426	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14426	4	New	New	NNP
18637	14426	5	York	York	NNP
18637	14426	6	Life	Life	NNP
18637	14426	7	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14426	8	.	.	.
18637	14427	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14427	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14427	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14427	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14427	5	Cravens	Cravens	NNP
18637	14427	6	,	,	,
18637	14427	7	178	178	CD
18637	14427	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14427	9	389	389	CD
18637	14427	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14427	11	1900	1900	CD
18637	14427	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14427	13	.	.	.
18637	14428	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14428	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14428	3	also	also	RB
18637	14428	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14428	5	American	American	NNP
18637	14428	6	Fire	Fire	NNP
18637	14428	7	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14428	8	.	.	.
18637	14429	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14429	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14429	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14429	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14429	5	King	King	NNP
18637	14429	6	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	14429	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14429	8	,	,	,
18637	14429	9	250	250	CD
18637	14429	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14429	11	2	2	CD
18637	14429	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14429	13	1919	1919	CD
18637	14429	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14429	15	.	.	.
18637	14430	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14430	2	116	116	CD
18637	14430	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14430	4	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	14430	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14430	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14430	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14430	8	McCoach	McCoach	NNP
18637	14430	9	,	,	,
18637	14430	10	313	313	CD
18637	14430	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14430	12	498	498	CD
18637	14430	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14430	14	1941	1941	CD
18637	14430	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14430	16	.	.	.
18637	14431	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14431	2	117	117	CD
18637	14431	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14431	4	314	314	CD
18637	14431	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14431	6	201	201	CD
18637	14431	7	,	,	,
18637	14431	8	206	206	CD
18637	14431	9	-	-	SYM
18637	14431	10	208	208	CD
18637	14431	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14431	12	1941	1941	CD
18637	14431	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14431	14	.	.	.
18637	14432	1	However	however	RB
18637	14432	2	,	,	,
18637	14432	3	a	a	DT
18637	14432	4	decree	decree	NN
18637	14432	5	of	of	IN
18637	14432	6	a	a	DT
18637	14432	7	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	14432	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14432	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14432	10	,	,	,
18637	14432	11	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	14432	12	as	as	IN
18637	14432	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14432	14	permitted	permit	VBD
18637	14432	15	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14432	16	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	14432	17	of	of	IN
18637	14432	18	a	a	DT
18637	14432	19	dissolved	dissolve	VBN
18637	14432	20	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	14432	21	surety	surety	NN
18637	14432	22	company	company	NN
18637	14432	23	to	to	TO
18637	14432	24	levy	levy	VB
18637	14432	25	execution	execution	NN
18637	14432	26	against	against	IN
18637	14432	27	local	local	JJ
18637	14432	28	assets	asset	NNS
18637	14432	29	to	to	TO
18637	14432	30	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	14432	31	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14432	32	,	,	,
18637	14432	33	as	as	IN
18637	14432	34	against	against	IN
18637	14432	35	title	title	NN
18637	14432	36	to	to	IN
18637	14432	37	such	such	JJ
18637	14432	38	assets	asset	NNS
18637	14432	39	of	of	IN
18637	14432	40	the	the	DT
18637	14432	41	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	14432	42	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	14432	43	commissioner	commissioner	NN
18637	14432	44	as	as	IN
18637	14432	45	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	14432	46	liquidator	liquidator	NN
18637	14432	47	and	and	CC
18637	14432	48	successor	successor	NN
18637	14432	49	to	to	IN
18637	14432	50	the	the	DT
18637	14432	51	dissolved	dissolve	VBN
18637	14432	52	company	company	NN
18637	14432	53	,	,	,
18637	14432	54	was	be	VBD
18637	14432	55	held	hold	VBN
18637	14432	56	to	to	TO
18637	14432	57	deny	deny	VB
18637	14432	58	full	full	JJ
18637	14432	59	faith	faith	NN
18637	14432	60	and	and	CC
18637	14432	61	credit	credit	NN
18637	14432	62	to	to	IN
18637	14432	63	the	the	DT
18637	14432	64	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	14432	65	of	of	IN
18637	14432	66	Iowa.--Clark	Iowa.--Clark	NNP
18637	14432	67	_	_	NNP
18637	14432	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	14432	69	_	_	NNP
18637	14432	70	Willard	Willard	NNP
18637	14432	71	,	,	,
18637	14432	72	292	292	CD
18637	14432	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14432	74	112	112	CD
18637	14432	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14432	76	1934	1934	CD
18637	14432	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14432	78	.	.	.
18637	14433	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14433	2	118	118	CD
18637	14433	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14433	4	324	324	CD
18637	14433	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14433	6	154	154	CD
18637	14433	7	,	,	,
18637	14433	8	159	159	CD
18637	14433	9	-	-	SYM
18637	14433	10	160	160	CD
18637	14433	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14433	12	1945	1945	CD
18637	14433	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14433	14	.	.	.
18637	14434	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14434	2	119	119	CD
18637	14434	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14434	4	Bradford	Bradford	NNP
18637	14434	5	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	14434	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14434	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14434	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14434	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14434	10	Clapper	Clapper	NNP
18637	14434	11	,	,	,
18637	14434	12	286	286	CD
18637	14434	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14434	14	145	145	CD
18637	14434	15	,	,	,
18637	14434	16	158	158	CD
18637	14434	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14434	18	1932	1932	CD
18637	14434	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14434	20	.	.	.
18637	14435	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14435	2	120	120	CD
18637	14435	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14435	4	The	the	DT
18637	14435	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14435	6	had	have	VBD
18637	14435	7	earlier	early	RBR
18637	14435	8	remarked	remark	VBN
18637	14435	9	that	that	IN
18637	14435	10	"	"	``
18637	14435	11	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	14435	12	's	's	POS
18637	14435	13	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	14435	14	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	14435	15	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	14435	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	14435	17	the	the	DT
18637	14435	18	idea	idea	NN
18637	14435	19	of	of	IN
18637	14435	20	status	status	NN
18637	14435	21	,	,	,
18637	14435	22	not	not	RB
18637	14435	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	14435	24	that	that	DT
18637	14435	25	of	of	IN
18637	14435	26	implied	imply	VBN
18637	14435	27	contract	contract	NN
18637	14435	28	.	.	.
18637	14435	29	"	"	''
18637	14436	1	Cudahy	Cudahy	NNP
18637	14436	2	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	14436	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14436	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14436	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	14436	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14436	7	Parramore	Parramore	NNP
18637	14436	8	,	,	,
18637	14436	9	263	263	CD
18637	14436	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14436	11	418	418	CD
18637	14436	12	,	,	,
18637	14436	13	423	423	CD
18637	14436	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14436	15	1923	1923	CD
18637	14436	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14436	17	.	.	.
18637	14437	1	In	in	IN
18637	14437	2	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	14437	3	to	to	IN
18637	14437	4	the	the	DT
18637	14437	5	above	above	JJ
18637	14437	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	14437	7	,	,	,
18637	14437	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14437	9	see	see	VBP
18637	14437	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14437	11	Kryger	Kryger	NNP
18637	14437	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14437	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	14437	14	_	_	NNP
18637	14437	15	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	14437	16	,	,	,
18637	14437	17	242	242	CD
18637	14437	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14437	19	171	171	CD
18637	14437	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14437	21	1916	1916	CD
18637	14437	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14437	23	,	,	,
18637	14437	24	where	where	WRB
18637	14437	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14437	26	was	be	VBD
18637	14437	27	held	hold	VBN
18637	14437	28	that	that	IN
18637	14437	29	the	the	DT
18637	14437	30	question	question	NN
18637	14437	31	whether	whether	IN
18637	14437	32	the	the	DT
18637	14437	33	cancellation	cancellation	NN
18637	14437	34	of	of	IN
18637	14437	35	a	a	DT
18637	14437	36	land	land	NN
18637	14437	37	contract	contract	NN
18637	14437	38	was	be	VBD
18637	14437	39	governed	govern	VBN
18637	14437	40	by	by	IN
18637	14437	41	the	the	DT
18637	14437	42	_	_	NNP
18637	14437	43	lex	lex	NNP
18637	14437	44	rei	rei	NN
18637	14437	45	sitae	sitae	VBD
18637	14437	46	_	_	NNP
18637	14437	47	or	or	CC
18637	14437	48	the	the	DT
18637	14437	49	_	_	NNP
18637	14437	50	lex	lex	NN
18637	14437	51	loci	loci	NN
18637	14437	52	contractus	contractus	NN
18637	14437	53	_	_	NNP
18637	14437	54	was	be	VBD
18637	14437	55	purely	purely	RB
18637	14437	56	a	a	DT
18637	14437	57	question	question	NN
18637	14437	58	of	of	IN
18637	14437	59	local	local	JJ
18637	14437	60	common	common	JJ
18637	14437	61	law	law	NN
18637	14437	62	;	;	:
18637	14437	63	_	_	NNP
18637	14437	64	also	also	RB
18637	14437	65	_	_	NNP
18637	14437	66	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	14437	67	_	_	NNP
18637	14437	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	14437	69	_	_	NNP
18637	14437	70	Hume	Hume	NNP
18637	14437	71	,	,	,
18637	14437	72	243	243	CD
18637	14437	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14437	74	15	15	CD
18637	14437	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14437	76	1917	1917	CD
18637	14437	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14437	78	.	.	.
18637	14438	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14438	2	121	121	CD
18637	14438	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14438	4	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	14438	5	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14438	6	.	.	.
18637	14439	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14439	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14439	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14439	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14439	5	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	14439	6	.	.	NNP
18637	14439	7	,	,	,
18637	14439	8	306	306	CD
18637	14439	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14439	10	493	493	CD
18637	14439	11	,	,	,
18637	14439	12	497	497	CD
18637	14439	13	,	,	,
18637	14439	14	503	503	CD
18637	14439	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	14439	16	504	504	CD
18637	14439	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14439	18	1939	1939	CD
18637	14439	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14439	20	.	.	.
18637	14440	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14440	2	122	122	CD
18637	14440	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14440	4	320	320	CD
18637	14440	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14440	6	430	430	CD
18637	14440	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14440	8	1943	1943	CD
18637	14440	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14440	10	.	.	.
18637	14441	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14441	2	123	123	CD
18637	14441	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14441	4	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	14441	5	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	14441	6	.	.	.
18637	14442	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14442	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	14442	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14442	4	McCartin	McCartin	NNP
18637	14442	5	,	,	,
18637	14442	6	330	330	CD
18637	14442	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14442	8	622	622	CD
18637	14442	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14442	10	1947	1947	CD
18637	14442	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14442	12	.	.	.
18637	14443	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14443	2	124	124	CD
18637	14443	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14443	4	Cardillo	Cardillo	NNP
18637	14443	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14443	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14443	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14443	8	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	14443	9	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	14443	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14443	11	,	,	,
18637	14443	12	330	330	CD
18637	14443	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14443	14	469	469	CD
18637	14443	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14443	16	1947	1947	CD
18637	14443	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14443	18	.	.	.
18637	14444	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14444	2	125	125	CD
18637	14444	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14444	4	Reviewing	review	VBG
18637	14444	5	some	some	DT
18637	14444	6	of	of	IN
18637	14444	7	the	the	DT
18637	14444	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	14444	9	treated	treat	VBN
18637	14444	10	in	in	IN
18637	14444	11	this	this	DT
18637	14444	12	section	section	NN
18637	14444	13	,	,	,
18637	14444	14	a	a	DT
18637	14444	15	writer	writer	NN
18637	14444	16	in	in	IN
18637	14444	17	1925	1925	CD
18637	14444	18	said	say	VBD
18637	14444	19	:	:	:
18637	14444	20	"	"	``
18637	14444	21	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14444	22	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	14444	23	,	,	,
18637	14444	24	then	then	RB
18637	14444	25	,	,	,
18637	14444	26	that	that	IN
18637	14444	27	the	the	DT
18637	14444	28	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14444	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14444	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	14444	31	quite	quite	RB
18637	14444	32	definitely	definitely	RB
18637	14444	33	committed	commit	VBN
18637	14444	34	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14444	35	to	to	IN
18637	14444	36	a	a	DT
18637	14444	37	program	program	NN
18637	14444	38	of	of	IN
18637	14444	39	making	make	VBG
18637	14444	40	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14444	41	,	,	,
18637	14444	42	to	to	IN
18637	14444	43	some	some	DT
18637	14444	44	extent	extent	NN
18637	14444	45	,	,	,
18637	14444	46	a	a	DT
18637	14444	47	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	14444	48	for	for	IN
18637	14444	49	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	14444	50	about	about	RP
18637	14444	51	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	14444	52	in	in	IN
18637	14444	53	the	the	DT
18637	14444	54	field	field	NN
18637	14444	55	of	of	IN
18637	14444	56	conflicts	conflict	NNS
18637	14444	57	*	*	NFP
18637	14444	58	*	*	NFP
18637	14444	59	*	*	NFP
18637	14444	60	although	although	IN
18637	14444	61	the	the	DT
18637	14444	62	precise	precise	JJ
18637	14444	63	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	14444	64	under	under	IN
18637	14444	65	which	which	WDT
18637	14444	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14444	67	will	will	MD
18637	14444	68	regard	regard	VB
18637	14444	69	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14444	70	as	as	IN
18637	14444	71	having	have	VBG
18637	14444	72	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14444	73	for	for	IN
18637	14444	74	this	this	DT
18637	14444	75	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	14444	76	are	be	VBP
18637	14444	77	far	far	RB
18637	14444	78	from	from	IN
18637	14444	79	clear	clear	JJ
18637	14444	80	.	.	.
18637	14444	81	"	"	''
18637	14445	1	E.M.	E.M.	NNP
18637	14445	2	Dodd	Dodd	NNP
18637	14445	3	,	,	,
18637	14445	4	The	the	DT
18637	14445	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	14445	6	of	of	IN
18637	14445	7	the	the	DT
18637	14445	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14445	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14445	10	to	to	IN
18637	14445	11	Review	Review	NNP
18637	14445	12	State	State	NNP
18637	14445	13	Decisions	Decisions	NNPS
18637	14445	14	in	in	IN
18637	14445	15	the	the	DT
18637	14445	16	Field	field	NN
18637	14445	17	of	of	IN
18637	14445	18	Conflict	Conflict	NNP
18637	14445	19	of	of	IN
18637	14445	20	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	14445	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14445	22	1926	1926	CD
18637	14445	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14445	24	,	,	,
18637	14445	25	39	39	CD
18637	14445	26	Harv	Harv	NNP
18637	14445	27	.	.	.
18637	14446	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	14446	2	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	14447	1	533	533	CD
18637	14447	2	-	-	SYM
18637	14447	3	562	562	CD
18637	14447	4	.	.	.
18637	14448	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14448	2	can	can	MD
18637	14448	3	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	14448	4	be	be	VB
18637	14448	5	said	say	VBN
18637	14448	6	that	that	IN
18637	14448	7	the	the	DT
18637	14448	8	law	law	NN
18637	14448	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	14448	10	been	be	VBN
18637	14448	11	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	14448	12	clarified	clarify	VBN
18637	14448	13	on	on	IN
18637	14448	14	this	this	DT
18637	14448	15	point	point	NN
18637	14448	16	.	.	.
18637	14449	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14449	2	126	126	CD
18637	14449	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14449	4	Walter	Walter	NNP
18637	14449	5	W.	W.	NNP
18637	14449	6	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	14449	7	,	,	,
18637	14449	8	The	the	DT
18637	14449	9	Power	Power	NNP
18637	14449	10	of	of	IN
18637	14449	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14449	12	Under	under	IN
18637	14449	13	the	the	DT
18637	14449	14	Full	Full	NNP
18637	14449	15	Faith	Faith	NNP
18637	14449	16	and	and	CC
18637	14449	17	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	14449	18	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	14449	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14449	20	1919	1919	CD
18637	14449	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14449	22	,	,	,
18637	14449	23	28	28	CD
18637	14449	24	Yale	Yale	NNP
18637	14449	25	L.J.	L.J.	NNP
18637	14450	1	430	430	CD
18637	14450	2	.	.	.
18637	14451	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14451	2	127	127	CD
18637	14451	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14451	4	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	14451	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14451	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14451	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14451	8	Newell	Newell	NNP
18637	14451	9	,	,	,
18637	14451	10	173	173	CD
18637	14451	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14451	12	555	555	CD
18637	14451	13	,	,	,
18637	14451	14	567	567	CD
18637	14451	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14451	16	1899	1899	CD
18637	14451	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14451	18	.	.	.
18637	14452	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14452	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14452	3	also	also	RB
18637	14452	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14452	5	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	14452	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14452	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14452	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14452	9	Pelican	Pelican	NNP
18637	14452	10	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14452	11	.	.	.
18637	14453	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14453	2	,	,	,
18637	14453	3	127	127	CD
18637	14453	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14453	5	265	265	CD
18637	14453	6	,	,	,
18637	14453	7	291	291	CD
18637	14453	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14453	9	1888	1888	CD
18637	14453	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14453	11	;	;	:
18637	14453	12	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	14453	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14453	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	14453	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14453	16	McPherson	McPherson	NNP
18637	14453	17	,	,	,
18637	14453	18	232	232	CD
18637	14453	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14453	20	51	51	CD
18637	14453	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14453	22	1914	1914	CD
18637	14453	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14453	24	;	;	:
18637	14453	25	Pennington	Pennington	NNP
18637	14453	26	_	_	NNP
18637	14453	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	14453	28	_	_	NNP
18637	14453	29	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	14453	30	,	,	,
18637	14453	31	16	16	CD
18637	14453	32	How	how	WRB
18637	14453	33	.	.	.
18637	14454	1	65	65	CD
18637	14454	2	,	,	,
18637	14454	3	81	81	CD
18637	14454	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14454	5	1854	1854	CD
18637	14454	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14454	7	;	;	:
18637	14454	8	Cheever	Cheever	NNP
18637	14454	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14454	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14454	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14454	12	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	14454	13	,	,	,
18637	14454	14	9	9	CD
18637	14454	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14454	16	.	.	.
18637	14455	1	108	108	CD
18637	14455	2	,	,	,
18637	14455	3	123	123	CD
18637	14455	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14455	5	1870	1870	CD
18637	14455	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14455	7	;	;	:
18637	14455	8	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	14455	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14455	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14455	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14455	12	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	14455	13	State	State	NNP
18637	14455	14	Traveling	Traveling	NNP
18637	14455	15	Men	Men	NNPS
18637	14455	16	's	's	POS
18637	14455	17	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	14455	18	.	.	.
18637	14455	19	,	,	,
18637	14455	20	283	283	CD
18637	14455	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14455	22	522	522	CD
18637	14455	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14455	24	1931	1931	CD
18637	14455	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14455	26	;	;	:
18637	14455	27	American	American	NNP
18637	14455	28	Surety	Surety	NNP
18637	14455	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14455	30	_	_	NNP
18637	14455	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	14455	32	_	_	NNP
18637	14455	33	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	14455	34	,	,	,
18637	14455	35	287	287	CD
18637	14455	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14455	37	156	156	CD
18637	14455	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14455	39	1932	1932	CD
18637	14455	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14455	41	;	;	:
18637	14455	42	Sanders	Sanders	NNP
18637	14455	43	_	_	NNP
18637	14455	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	14455	45	_	_	NNP
18637	14455	46	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	14455	47	Fertilizer	Fertilizer	NNP
18637	14455	48	Works	Works	NNP
18637	14455	49	,	,	,
18637	14455	50	292	292	CD
18637	14455	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14455	52	190	190	CD
18637	14455	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14455	54	1934	1934	CD
18637	14455	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14455	56	.	.	.
18637	14456	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14456	2	128	128	CD
18637	14456	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14456	4	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	14456	5	County	County	NNP
18637	14456	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14456	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14456	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14456	9	White	White	NNP
18637	14456	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14456	11	M.E.	M.E.	NNP
18637	14456	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14457	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14457	2	,	,	,
18637	14457	3	296	296	CD
18637	14457	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14457	5	268	268	CD
18637	14457	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14457	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	14457	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14457	9	.	.	.
18637	14458	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14458	2	129	129	CD
18637	14458	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14458	4	Equitable	Equitable	NNP
18637	14458	5	L.	L.	NNP
18637	14458	6	Assur	Assur	NNP
18637	14458	7	.	.	.
18637	14459	1	Soc	Soc	NNP
18637	14459	2	.	.	.
18637	14460	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14460	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	14460	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14460	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	14460	5	,	,	,
18637	14460	6	187	187	CD
18637	14460	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14460	8	308	308	CD
18637	14460	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14460	10	1902	1902	CD
18637	14460	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14460	12	.	.	.
18637	14461	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14461	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14461	3	also	also	RB
18637	14461	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14461	5	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	14461	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14461	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14461	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14461	9	Lyon	Lyon	NNP
18637	14461	10	,	,	,
18637	14461	11	115	115	CD
18637	14461	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14461	13	439	439	CD
18637	14461	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14461	15	1885	1885	CD
18637	14461	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14461	17	.	.	.
18637	14462	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14462	2	130	130	CD
18637	14462	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14462	4	Embry	Embry	NNP
18637	14462	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14462	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14462	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14462	8	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	14462	9	,	,	,
18637	14462	10	107	107	CD
18637	14462	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14462	12	3	3	CD
18637	14462	13	,	,	,
18637	14462	14	9	9	CD
18637	14462	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14462	16	1883	1883	CD
18637	14462	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14462	18	.	.	.
18637	14463	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14463	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14463	3	also	also	RB
18637	14463	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14463	5	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	14463	6	Assur	Assur	NNP
18637	14463	7	.	.	.
18637	14464	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14464	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14464	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14464	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14464	5	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	14464	6	View	View	NNP
18637	14464	7	Bldg	Bldg	NNP
18637	14464	8	.	.	.
18637	14465	1	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	14465	2	.	.	.
18637	14465	3	,	,	,
18637	14465	4	203	203	CD
18637	14465	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14465	6	106	106	CD
18637	14465	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14465	8	1906	1906	CD
18637	14465	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14465	10	;	;	:
18637	14465	11	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	14465	12	,	,	,
18637	14465	13	T.	T.	NNP
18637	14465	14	&	&	CC
18637	14465	15	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	14466	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14466	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14466	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14466	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14466	5	Sowers	Sowers	NNP
18637	14466	6	,	,	,
18637	14466	7	213	213	CD
18637	14466	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14466	9	55	55	CD
18637	14466	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14466	11	1909	1909	CD
18637	14466	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14466	13	;	;	:
18637	14466	14	Knights	Knights	NNPS
18637	14466	15	of	of	IN
18637	14466	16	Pythias	Pythias	NNP
18637	14466	17	_	_	NNP
18637	14466	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	14466	19	_	_	NNP
18637	14466	20	Meyer	Meyer	NNP
18637	14466	21	,	,	,
18637	14466	22	265	265	CD
18637	14466	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14466	24	30	30	CD
18637	14466	25	,	,	,
18637	14466	26	33	33	CD
18637	14466	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14466	28	1924	1924	CD
18637	14466	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14466	30	;	;	:
18637	14466	31	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	14466	32	&	&	CC
18637	14466	33	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	14467	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14467	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14467	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14467	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14467	5	Central	Central	NNP
18637	14467	6	Stockyards	Stockyards	NNPS
18637	14467	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14467	8	,	,	,
18637	14467	9	212	212	CD
18637	14467	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14467	11	132	132	CD
18637	14467	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14467	13	1909	1909	CD
18637	14467	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14467	15	;	;	:
18637	14467	16	West	West	NNP
18637	14467	17	Side	Side	NNP
18637	14467	18	Belt	Belt	NNP
18637	14467	19	R.	R.	NNP
18637	14467	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14467	21	_	_	NNP
18637	14467	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	14467	23	_	_	NNP
18637	14467	24	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	14467	25	Constr	Constr	NNP
18637	14467	26	.	.	.
18637	14468	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14468	2	,	,	,
18637	14468	3	219	219	CD
18637	14468	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14468	5	92	92	CD
18637	14468	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14468	7	1911	1911	CD
18637	14468	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14468	9	.	.	.
18637	14469	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14469	2	131	131	CD
18637	14469	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14469	4	No	no	UH
18637	14469	5	right	right	UH
18637	14469	6	,	,	,
18637	14469	7	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	14469	8	,	,	,
18637	14469	9	or	or	CC
18637	14469	10	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	14469	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	14469	12	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	14469	13	by	by	IN
18637	14469	14	the	the	DT
18637	14469	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14469	16	in	in	IN
18637	14469	17	respect	respect	NN
18637	14469	18	to	to	IN
18637	14469	19	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	14469	20	of	of	IN
18637	14469	21	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	14469	22	states	state	NNS
18637	14469	23	and	and	CC
18637	14469	24	nations.--Aetna	nations.--Aetna	NNP
18637	14469	25	Life	Life	NNP
18637	14469	26	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14469	27	.	.	.
18637	14470	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14470	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14470	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14470	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14470	5	Tremblay	Tremblay	NNP
18637	14470	6	,	,	,
18637	14470	7	223	223	CD
18637	14470	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14470	9	185	185	CD
18637	14470	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14470	11	1912	1912	CD
18637	14470	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14470	13	.	.	.
18637	14471	1	In	in	IN
18637	14471	2	Hilton	Hilton	NNP
18637	14471	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14471	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	14471	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14471	6	Guyot	Guyot	NNP
18637	14471	7	,	,	,
18637	14471	8	159	159	CD
18637	14471	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14471	10	113	113	CD
18637	14471	11	,	,	,
18637	14471	12	234	234	CD
18637	14471	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14471	14	1895	1895	CD
18637	14471	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14471	16	where	where	WRB
18637	14471	17	a	a	DT
18637	14471	18	French	french	JJ
18637	14471	19	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14471	20	offered	offer	VBN
18637	14471	21	in	in	IN
18637	14471	22	defense	defense	NN
18637	14471	23	was	be	VBD
18637	14471	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	14471	25	not	not	RB
18637	14471	26	a	a	DT
18637	14471	27	bar	bar	NN
18637	14471	28	to	to	IN
18637	14471	29	the	the	DT
18637	14471	30	suit	suit	NN
18637	14471	31	.	.	.
18637	14472	1	Four	four	CD
18637	14472	2	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	14472	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	14472	4	on	on	IN
18637	14472	5	the	the	DT
18637	14472	6	ground	ground	NN
18637	14472	7	that	that	IN
18637	14472	8	"	"	``
18637	14472	9	the	the	DT
18637	14472	10	application	application	NN
18637	14472	11	of	of	IN
18637	14472	12	the	the	DT
18637	14472	13	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	14472	14	of	of	IN
18637	14472	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14472	16	res	res	NNP
18637	14472	17	judicata	judicata	NNP
18637	14472	18	_	_	NNP
18637	14472	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	14472	20	not	not	RB
18637	14472	21	rest	rest	VB
18637	14472	22	in	in	IN
18637	14472	23	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	14472	24	;	;	:
18637	14472	25	and	and	CC
18637	14472	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14472	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	14472	28	for	for	IN
18637	14472	29	the	the	DT
18637	14472	30	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14472	31	,	,	,
18637	14472	32	and	and	CC
18637	14472	33	not	not	RB
18637	14472	34	for	for	IN
18637	14472	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14472	36	courts	court	NNS
18637	14472	37	,	,	,
18637	14472	38	to	to	TO
18637	14472	39	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	14472	40	the	the	DT
18637	14472	41	principle	principle	NN
18637	14472	42	of	of	IN
18637	14472	43	retorsion	retorsion	NN
18637	14472	44	,	,	,
18637	14472	45	if	if	IN
18637	14472	46	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	14472	47	under	under	IN
18637	14472	48	any	any	DT
18637	14472	49	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	14472	50	desirable	desirable	JJ
18637	14472	51	or	or	CC
18637	14472	52	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	14472	53	.	.	.
18637	14472	54	"	"	''
18637	14473	1	At	at	IN
18637	14473	2	the	the	DT
18637	14473	3	same	same	JJ
18637	14473	4	sitting	sitting	NN
18637	14473	5	of	of	IN
18637	14473	6	the	the	DT
18637	14473	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14473	8	,	,	,
18637	14473	9	an	an	DT
18637	14473	10	action	action	NN
18637	14473	11	in	in	IN
18637	14473	12	a	a	DT
18637	14473	13	United	United	NNP
18637	14473	14	States	States	NNP
18637	14473	15	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	14473	16	court	court	NN
18637	14473	17	on	on	IN
18637	14473	18	a	a	DT
18637	14473	19	Canadian	canadian	JJ
18637	14473	20	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14473	21	was	be	VBD
18637	14473	22	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	14473	23	on	on	IN
18637	14473	24	the	the	DT
18637	14473	25	same	same	JJ
18637	14473	26	ground	ground	NN
18637	14473	27	of	of	IN
18637	14473	28	reciprocity	reciprocity	NN
18637	14473	29	.	.	.
18637	14474	1	Ritchie	Ritchie	NNP
18637	14474	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14474	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14474	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14474	5	McMullen	McMullen	NNP
18637	14474	6	,	,	,
18637	14474	7	159	159	CD
18637	14474	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14474	9	235	235	CD
18637	14474	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14474	11	1895	1895	CD
18637	14474	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14474	13	.	.	.
18637	14475	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14475	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14475	3	also	also	RB
18637	14475	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14475	5	Ingenohl	Ingenohl	NNP
18637	14475	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14475	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14475	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14475	9	Olsen	Olsen	NNP
18637	14475	10	,	,	,
18637	14475	11	273	273	CD
18637	14475	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14475	13	541	541	CD
18637	14475	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14475	15	1927	1927	CD
18637	14475	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14475	17	,	,	,
18637	14475	18	where	where	WRB
18637	14475	19	a	a	DT
18637	14475	20	decision	decision	NN
18637	14475	21	of	of	IN
18637	14475	22	the	the	DT
18637	14475	23	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14475	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14475	25	of	of	IN
18637	14475	26	the	the	DT
18637	14475	27	Philippine	Philippine	NNP
18637	14475	28	Islands	Islands	NNPS
18637	14475	29	was	be	VBD
18637	14475	30	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	14475	31	for	for	IN
18637	14475	32	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	14475	33	to	to	TO
18637	14475	34	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	14475	35	a	a	DT
18637	14475	36	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14475	37	of	of	IN
18637	14475	38	the	the	DT
18637	14475	39	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14475	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14475	41	of	of	IN
18637	14475	42	the	the	DT
18637	14475	43	British	british	JJ
18637	14475	44	colony	colony	NN
18637	14475	45	of	of	IN
18637	14475	46	Hongkong	Hongkong	NNP
18637	14475	47	,	,	,
18637	14475	48	which	which	WDT
18637	14475	49	was	be	VBD
18637	14475	50	rendered	render	VBN
18637	14475	51	"	"	``
18637	14475	52	after	after	IN
18637	14475	53	a	a	DT
18637	14475	54	fair	fair	JJ
18637	14475	55	trial	trial	NN
18637	14475	56	by	by	IN
18637	14475	57	a	a	DT
18637	14475	58	court	court	NN
18637	14475	59	having	have	VBG
18637	14475	60	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14475	61	of	of	IN
18637	14475	62	the	the	DT
18637	14475	63	parties	party	NNS
18637	14475	64	.	.	.
18637	14475	65	"	"	''
18637	14476	1	In	in	IN
18637	14476	2	1897	1897	CD
18637	14476	3	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	14476	4	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	14476	5	of	of	IN
18637	14476	6	the	the	DT
18637	14476	7	United	United	NNP
18637	14476	8	States	States	NNP
18637	14476	9	7	7	CD
18637	14476	10	-	-	SYM
18637	14476	11	8	8	CD
18637	14476	12	,	,	,
18637	14476	13	will	will	MD
18637	14476	14	be	be	VB
18637	14476	15	found	find	VBN
18637	14476	16	a	a	DT
18637	14476	17	three	three	CD
18637	14476	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	14476	19	cornered	cornered	JJ
18637	14476	20	correspondence	correspondence	NN
18637	14476	21	between	between	IN
18637	14476	22	the	the	DT
18637	14476	23	State	State	NNP
18637	14476	24	Department	Department	NNP
18637	14476	25	,	,	,
18637	14476	26	the	the	DT
18637	14476	27	Austro	Austro	NNP
18637	14476	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	14476	29	Hungarian	Hungarian	NNP
18637	14476	30	Legation	Legation	NNP
18637	14476	31	,	,	,
18637	14476	32	and	and	CC
18637	14476	33	the	the	DT
18637	14476	34	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	14476	35	of	of	IN
18637	14476	36	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	14476	37	,	,	,
18637	14476	38	in	in	IN
18637	14476	39	which	which	WDT
18637	14476	40	the	the	DT
18637	14476	41	last	last	JJ
18637	14476	42	named	name	VBN
18637	14476	43	asserts	assert	VBZ
18637	14476	44	that	that	IN
18637	14476	45	"	"	``
18637	14476	46	under	under	IN
18637	14476	47	the	the	DT
18637	14476	48	laws	law	NNS
18637	14476	49	of	of	IN
18637	14476	50	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	14476	51	the	the	DT
18637	14476	52	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14476	53	of	of	IN
18637	14476	54	a	a	DT
18637	14476	55	court	court	NN
18637	14476	56	of	of	IN
18637	14476	57	competent	competent	JJ
18637	14476	58	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14476	59	in	in	IN
18637	14476	60	Croatia	Croatia	NNP
18637	14476	61	would	would	MD
18637	14476	62	be	be	VB
18637	14476	63	respected	respect	VBN
18637	14476	64	to	to	IN
18637	14476	65	the	the	DT
18637	14476	66	extent	extent	NN
18637	14476	67	of	of	IN
18637	14476	68	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	14476	69	such	such	JJ
18637	14476	70	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14476	71	to	to	TO
18637	14476	72	be	be	VB
18637	14476	73	sued	sue	VBN
18637	14476	74	upon	upon	IN
18637	14476	75	in	in	IN
18637	14476	76	the	the	DT
18637	14476	77	courts	court	NNS
18637	14476	78	of	of	IN
18637	14476	79	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	14476	80	.	.	.
18637	14476	81	"	"	''
18637	14477	1	Stowell	Stowell	NNP
18637	14477	2	,	,	,
18637	14477	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14477	4	op	op	NN
18637	14477	5	.	.	.
18637	14478	1	cit	cit	NNP
18637	14478	2	.	.	.
18637	14479	1	supra	supra	NNP
18637	14479	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14479	3	note	note	NN
18637	14479	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14479	5	,	,	,
18637	14479	6	at	at	IN
18637	14479	7	254	254	CD
18637	14479	8	-	-	SYM
18637	14479	9	255	255	CD
18637	14479	10	.	.	.
18637	14480	1	Another	another	DT
18637	14480	2	instance	instance	NN
18637	14480	3	of	of	IN
18637	14480	4	international	international	JJ
18637	14480	5	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	14480	6	in	in	IN
18637	14480	7	the	the	DT
18637	14480	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	14480	9	field	field	NN
18637	14480	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	14480	11	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	14480	12	by	by	IN
18637	14480	13	letters	letter	NNS
18637	14480	14	rogatory	rogatory	NN
18637	14480	15	.	.	.
18637	14481	1	"	"	``
18637	14481	2	When	when	WRB
18637	14481	3	letters	letter	NNS
18637	14481	4	rogatory	rogatory	NN
18637	14481	5	are	be	VBP
18637	14481	6	addressed	address	VBN
18637	14481	7	from	from	IN
18637	14481	8	any	any	DT
18637	14481	9	court	court	NN
18637	14481	10	of	of	IN
18637	14481	11	a	a	DT
18637	14481	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	14481	13	country	country	NN
18637	14481	14	to	to	IN
18637	14481	15	any	any	DT
18637	14481	16	district	district	NN
18637	14481	17	court	court	NN
18637	14481	18	of	of	IN
18637	14481	19	the	the	DT
18637	14481	20	United	United	NNP
18637	14481	21	States	States	NNP
18637	14481	22	,	,	,
18637	14481	23	a	a	DT
18637	14481	24	commissioner	commissioner	NN
18637	14481	25	of	of	IN
18637	14481	26	such	such	JJ
18637	14481	27	district	district	NN
18637	14481	28	court	court	NN
18637	14481	29	designated	designate	VBN
18637	14481	30	by	by	IN
18637	14481	31	said	say	VBD
18637	14481	32	court	court	NN
18637	14481	33	to	to	TO
18637	14481	34	make	make	VB
18637	14481	35	the	the	DT
18637	14481	36	examination	examination	NN
18637	14481	37	of	of	IN
18637	14481	38	the	the	DT
18637	14481	39	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	14481	40	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	14481	41	in	in	IN
18637	14481	42	said	say	VBN
18637	14481	43	letters	letter	NNS
18637	14481	44	,	,	,
18637	14481	45	shall	shall	MD
18637	14481	46	have	have	VB
18637	14481	47	power	power	NN
18637	14481	48	to	to	TO
18637	14481	49	compel	compel	VB
18637	14481	50	the	the	DT
18637	14481	51	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	14481	52	to	to	TO
18637	14481	53	appear	appear	VB
18637	14481	54	and	and	CC
18637	14481	55	depose	depose	VB
18637	14481	56	in	in	IN
18637	14481	57	the	the	DT
18637	14481	58	same	same	JJ
18637	14481	59	manner	manner	NN
18637	14481	60	as	as	IN
18637	14481	61	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	14481	62	may	may	MD
18637	14481	63	be	be	VB
18637	14481	64	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	14481	65	to	to	TO
18637	14481	66	appear	appear	VB
18637	14481	67	and	and	CC
18637	14481	68	testify	testify	VB
18637	14481	69	in	in	IN
18637	14481	70	courts	court	NNS
18637	14481	71	,	,	,
18637	14481	72	"	"	''
18637	14481	73	28	28	CD
18637	14481	74	U.S.C.A.	U.S.C.A.	NNP
18637	14481	75	,	,	,
18637	14481	76	_	_	NNP
18637	14481	77	supra	supra	NNP
18637	14481	78	_	_	NNP
18637	14481	79	note	note	NN
18637	14481	80	II	II	NNP
18637	14481	81	,	,	,
18637	14481	82	§	§	NNP
18637	14481	83	653	653	CD
18637	14481	84	.	.	.
18637	14482	1	Some	some	DT
18637	14482	2	of	of	IN
18637	14482	3	the	the	DT
18637	14482	4	States	States	NNPS
18637	14482	5	have	have	VBP
18637	14482	6	similar	similar	JJ
18637	14482	7	laws	law	NNS
18637	14482	8	.	.	.
18637	14483	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14483	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14483	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14483	4	2	2	CD
18637	14483	5	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	14483	6	,	,	,
18637	14483	7	Digest	Digest	NNP
18637	14483	8	of	of	IN
18637	14483	9	International	International	NNP
18637	14483	10	Law	Law	NNP
18637	14483	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14483	12	1906	1906	CD
18637	14483	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14483	14	108	108	CD
18637	14483	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	14483	16	109	109	CD
18637	14483	17	.	.	.
18637	14484	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14484	2	132	132	CD
18637	14484	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14484	4	David	David	NNP
18637	14484	5	K.	K.	NNP
18637	14484	6	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	14484	7	,	,	,
18637	14484	8	The	the	DT
18637	14484	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14484	10	of	of	IN
18637	14484	11	the	the	DT
18637	14484	12	United	United	NNP
18637	14484	13	States	States	NNP
18637	14484	14	,	,	,
18637	14484	15	vol	vol	NNP
18637	14484	16	.	.	.
18637	14485	1	II	II	NNP
18637	14485	2	,	,	,
18637	14485	3	1206	1206	CD
18637	14485	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14485	5	1910	1910	CD
18637	14485	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14485	7	.	.	.
18637	14486	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14486	2	133	133	CD
18637	14486	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14486	4	The	the	DT
18637	14486	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	14486	6	No	no	NN
18637	14486	7	.	.	.
18637	14487	1	42	42	CD
18637	14487	2	.	.	.
18637	14488	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14488	2	134	134	CD
18637	14488	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14488	4	16	16	CD
18637	14488	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14488	6	.	.	.
18637	14489	1	36	36	CD
18637	14489	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14489	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	14489	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14489	5	.	.	.
18637	14490	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14490	2	135	135	CD
18637	14490	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14490	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14490	5	.	.	.
18637	14491	1	75	75	CD
18637	14491	2	.	.	.
18637	14492	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14492	2	136	136	CD
18637	14492	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14492	4	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	14492	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14492	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14492	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14492	8	Sandford	Sandford	NNP
18637	14492	9	,	,	,
18637	14492	10	19	19	CD
18637	14492	11	How	how	WRB
18637	14492	12	.	.	.
18637	14493	1	393	393	CD
18637	14493	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14493	3	1857	1857	CD
18637	14493	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14493	5	.	.	.
18637	14494	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14494	2	137	137	CD
18637	14494	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14494	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14494	5	.	.	.
18637	14495	1	518	518	CD
18637	14495	2	,	,	,
18637	14495	3	527	527	CD
18637	14495	4	-	-	SYM
18637	14495	5	529	529	CD
18637	14495	6	.	.	.
18637	14496	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14496	2	138	138	CD
18637	14496	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14496	4	153	153	CD
18637	14496	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14496	6	684	684	CD
18637	14496	7	,	,	,
18637	14496	8	687	687	CD
18637	14496	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14496	10	1894	1894	CD
18637	14496	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14496	12	.	.	.
18637	14497	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14497	2	139	139	CD
18637	14497	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14497	4	135	135	CD
18637	14497	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14497	6	492	492	CD
18637	14497	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14497	8	1890	1890	CD
18637	14497	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14497	10	.	.	.
18637	14498	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14498	2	140	140	CD
18637	14498	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14498	4	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	14498	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	14498	6	House	House	NNP
18637	14498	7	Case	Case	NNP
18637	14498	8	,	,	,
18637	14498	9	15	15	CD
18637	14498	10	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	14498	11	.	.	.
18637	14499	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	14499	2	.	.	.
18637	14500	1	No	no	UH
18637	14500	2	.	.	.
18637	14501	1	8408	8408	CD
18637	14501	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14501	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	14501	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14501	5	;	;	:
18637	14501	6	Chambers	Chambers	NNP
18637	14501	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14501	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14501	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14501	10	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	14501	11	&	&	CC
18637	14501	12	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	14502	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14502	2	,	,	,
18637	14502	3	207	207	CD
18637	14502	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14502	5	142	142	CD
18637	14502	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14502	7	1907	1907	CD
18637	14502	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14502	9	;	;	:
18637	14502	10	Whitfield	Whitfield	NNP
18637	14502	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14502	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	14502	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14502	14	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	14502	15	,	,	,
18637	14502	16	297	297	CD
18637	14502	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14502	18	431	431	CD
18637	14502	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14502	20	1936	1936	CD
18637	14502	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14502	22	.	.	.
18637	14503	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14503	2	141	141	CD
18637	14503	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14503	4	16	16	CD
18637	14503	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14503	6	.	.	.
18637	14504	1	36	36	CD
18637	14504	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14504	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	14504	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14504	5	.	.	.
18637	14505	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14505	2	142	142	CD
18637	14505	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14505	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14505	5	.	.	.
18637	14506	1	77	77	CD
18637	14506	2	.	.	.
18637	14507	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14507	2	143	143	CD
18637	14507	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14507	4	Bradwell	Bradwell	NNP
18637	14507	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14507	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14507	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14507	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	14507	9	,	,	,
18637	14507	10	16	16	CD
18637	14507	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14507	12	.	.	.
18637	14508	1	130	130	CD
18637	14508	2	,	,	,
18637	14508	3	138	138	CD
18637	14508	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14508	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	14508	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14508	7	.	.	.
18637	14509	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14509	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14509	3	also	also	RB
18637	14509	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14509	5	Cole	Cole	NNP
18637	14509	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14509	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14509	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14509	9	Cunningham	Cunningham	NNP
18637	14509	10	,	,	,
18637	14509	11	133	133	CD
18637	14509	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14509	13	107	107	CD
18637	14509	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14509	15	1890	1890	CD
18637	14509	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14509	17	.	.	.
18637	14510	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14510	2	144	144	CD
18637	14510	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14510	4	Blake	Blake	NNP
18637	14510	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14510	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14510	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14510	8	McClung	McClung	NNP
18637	14510	9	,	,	,
18637	14510	10	172	172	CD
18637	14510	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14510	12	239	239	CD
18637	14510	13	,	,	,
18637	14510	14	246	246	CD
18637	14510	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14510	16	1898	1898	CD
18637	14510	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14510	18	;	;	:
18637	14510	19	Travis	Travis	NNP
18637	14510	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14510	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	14510	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14510	23	Yale	Yale	NNP
18637	14510	24	&	&	CC
18637	14510	25	Towne	Towne	NNP
18637	14510	26	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	14510	27	.	.	.
18637	14511	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14511	2	,	,	,
18637	14511	3	252	252	CD
18637	14511	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14511	5	60	60	CD
18637	14511	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14511	7	1920	1920	CD
18637	14511	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14511	9	.	.	.
18637	14512	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14512	2	145	145	CD
18637	14512	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14512	4	La	La	NNP
18637	14512	5	Tourette	Tourette	NNP
18637	14512	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14512	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14512	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14512	9	McMaster	McMaster	NNP
18637	14512	10	,	,	,
18637	14512	11	248	248	CD
18637	14512	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14512	13	465	465	CD
18637	14512	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14512	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	14512	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14512	17	;	;	:
18637	14512	18	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	14512	19	_	_	NNP
18637	14512	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	14512	21	_	_	NNP
18637	14512	22	New	New	NNP
18637	14512	23	York	York	NNP
18637	14512	24	,	,	,
18637	14512	25	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	14512	26	&	&	CC
18637	14512	27	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	14513	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14513	2	,	,	,
18637	14513	3	279	279	CD
18637	14513	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14513	5	377	377	CD
18637	14513	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14513	7	1929	1929	CD
18637	14513	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14513	9	;	;	:
18637	14513	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14513	11	cf	cf	NNP
18637	14513	12	.	.	.
18637	14513	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14513	14	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	14513	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14513	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	14513	17	_	_	NNP
18637	14513	18	Bugbee	Bugbee	NNP
18637	14513	19	,	,	,
18637	14513	20	250	250	CD
18637	14513	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14513	22	525	525	CD
18637	14513	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14513	24	1919	1919	CD
18637	14513	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14513	26	.	.	.
18637	14514	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14514	2	146	146	CD
18637	14514	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14514	4	United	United	NNP
18637	14514	5	States	States	NNP
18637	14514	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14514	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14514	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14514	9	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	14514	10	,	,	,
18637	14514	11	106	106	CD
18637	14514	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14514	13	629	629	CD
18637	14514	14	,	,	,
18637	14514	15	643	643	CD
18637	14514	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14514	17	1883	1883	CD
18637	14514	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14514	19	.	.	.
18637	14515	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14515	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14515	3	also	also	RB
18637	14515	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14515	5	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	14515	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14515	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14515	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14515	9	Franks	Franks	NNP
18637	14515	10	,	,	,
18637	14515	11	120	120	CD
18637	14515	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14515	13	678	678	CD
18637	14515	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14515	15	1887	1887	CD
18637	14515	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14515	17	.	.	.
18637	14516	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14516	2	147	147	CD
18637	14516	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14516	4	United	United	NNP
18637	14516	5	States	States	NNP
18637	14516	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14516	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14516	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14516	9	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	14516	10	,	,	,
18637	14516	11	254	254	CD
18637	14516	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14516	13	281	281	CD
18637	14516	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14516	15	1920	1920	CD
18637	14516	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14516	17	.	.	.
18637	14517	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14517	2	148	148	CD
18637	14517	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14517	4	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	14517	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14517	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14517	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14517	8	Sandford	Sandford	NNP
18637	14517	9	,	,	,
18637	14517	10	19	19	CD
18637	14517	11	How	how	WRB
18637	14517	12	.	.	.
18637	14518	1	393	393	CD
18637	14518	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14518	3	1857	1857	CD
18637	14518	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14518	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14518	6	149	149	CD
18637	14518	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14518	8	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14518	9	.	.	.
18637	14519	1	403	403	CD
18637	14519	2	-	-	SYM
18637	14519	3	411	411	CD
18637	14519	4	.	.	.
18637	14520	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14520	2	150	150	CD
18637	14520	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14520	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14520	5	.	.	.
18637	14521	1	572	572	CD
18637	14521	2	-	-	SYM
18637	14521	3	590	590	CD
18637	14521	4	.	.	.
18637	14522	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14522	2	151	151	CD
18637	14522	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14522	4	13	13	CD
18637	14522	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	14522	6	.	.	.
18637	14523	1	519	519	CD
18637	14523	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14523	3	1939	1939	CD
18637	14523	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14523	5	.	.	.
18637	14524	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14524	2	152	152	CD
18637	14524	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14524	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14524	5	.	.	.
18637	14525	1	586	586	CD
18637	14525	2	.	.	.
18637	14526	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14526	2	153	153	CD
18637	14526	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14526	4	8	8	CD
18637	14526	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14526	6	.	.	.
18637	14527	1	168	168	CD
18637	14527	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14527	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	14527	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14527	5	.	.	.
18637	14528	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14528	2	154	154	CD
18637	14528	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14528	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14528	5	.	.	.
18637	14529	1	181	181	CD
18637	14529	2	.	.	.
18637	14530	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14530	2	155	155	CD
18637	14530	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14530	4	Crutcher	Crutcher	NNP
18637	14530	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14530	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14530	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14530	8	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	14530	9	,	,	,
18637	14530	10	141	141	CD
18637	14530	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14530	12	47	47	CD
18637	14530	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14530	14	1891	1891	CD
18637	14530	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14530	16	.	.	.
18637	14531	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14531	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14531	3	also	also	RB
18637	14531	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14531	5	pp	pp	NNP
18637	14531	6	.	.	.
18637	14532	1	193	193	CD
18637	14532	2	-	-	SYM
18637	14532	3	198	198	CD
18637	14532	4	,	,	,
18637	14532	5	1049	1049	CD
18637	14532	6	-	-	SYM
18637	14532	7	1056	1056	CD
18637	14532	8	.	.	.
18637	14533	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14533	2	156	156	CD
18637	14533	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14533	4	Hemphill	Hemphill	NNP
18637	14533	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14533	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14533	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14533	8	Orloff	Orloff	NNP
18637	14533	9	,	,	,
18637	14533	10	277	277	CD
18637	14533	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14533	12	537	537	CD
18637	14533	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14533	14	1928	1928	CD
18637	14533	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14533	16	.	.	.
18637	14534	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14534	2	157	157	CD
18637	14534	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14534	4	6	6	CD
18637	14534	5	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	14534	6	.	.	.
18637	14535	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	14535	2	.	.	.
18637	14536	1	No	no	UH
18637	14536	2	.	.	.
18637	14537	1	3,230	3,230	CD
18637	14537	2	,	,	,
18637	14537	3	546	546	CD
18637	14537	4	,	,	,
18637	14537	5	550	550	CD
18637	14537	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14537	7	1823	1823	CD
18637	14537	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14537	9	.	.	.
18637	14538	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14538	2	158	158	CD
18637	14538	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14538	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14538	5	.	.	.
18637	14539	1	551	551	CD
18637	14539	2	-	-	SYM
18637	14539	3	522	522	CD
18637	14539	4	.	.	.
18637	14540	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14540	2	159	159	CD
18637	14540	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14540	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14540	5	.	.	.
18637	14541	1	552	552	CD
18637	14541	2	.	.	.
18637	14542	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14542	2	160	160	CD
18637	14542	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14542	4	Corfield	Corfield	NNP
18637	14542	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14542	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14542	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14542	8	Coryell	Coryell	NNP
18637	14542	9	,	,	,
18637	14542	10	6	6	CD
18637	14542	11	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	14542	12	.	.	.
18637	14543	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	14543	2	.	.	.
18637	14544	1	No	no	UH
18637	14544	2	.	.	.
18637	14545	1	3230	3230	CD
18637	14545	2	,	,	,
18637	14545	3	546	546	CD
18637	14545	4	,	,	,
18637	14545	5	552	552	CD
18637	14545	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14545	7	1823	1823	CD
18637	14545	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14545	9	.	.	.
18637	14546	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14546	2	161	161	CD
18637	14546	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14546	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14546	5	.	.	.
18637	14547	1	552	552	CD
18637	14547	2	.	.	.
18637	14548	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14548	2	162	162	CD
18637	14548	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14548	4	94	94	CD
18637	14548	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14548	6	391	391	CD
18637	14548	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14548	8	1877	1877	CD
18637	14548	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14548	10	.	.	.
18637	14549	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14549	2	163	163	CD
18637	14549	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14549	4	161	161	CD
18637	14549	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14549	6	519	519	CD
18637	14549	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14549	8	1896	1896	CD
18637	14549	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14549	10	.	.	.
18637	14550	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14550	2	164	164	CD
18637	14550	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14550	4	209	209	CD
18637	14550	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14550	6	349	349	CD
18637	14550	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14550	8	1908	1908	CD
18637	14550	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14550	10	.	.	.
18637	14551	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14551	2	165	165	CD
18637	14551	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14551	4	334	334	CD
18637	14551	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14551	6	385	385	CD
18637	14551	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14551	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	14551	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14551	10	.	.	.
18637	14552	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14552	2	166	166	CD
18637	14552	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14552	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14552	5	.	.	.
18637	14553	1	403	403	CD
18637	14553	2	.	.	.
18637	14554	1	In	in	IN
18637	14554	2	Mullaney	Mullaney	NNP
18637	14554	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14554	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	14554	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14554	6	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	14554	7	,	,	,
18637	14554	8	342	342	CD
18637	14554	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14554	10	415	415	CD
18637	14554	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14554	12	1952	1952	CD
18637	14554	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14554	14	an	an	DT
18637	14554	15	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	14554	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	14554	17	providing	provide	VBG
18637	14554	18	for	for	IN
18637	14554	19	the	the	DT
18637	14554	20	licensing	licensing	NN
18637	14554	21	of	of	IN
18637	14554	22	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	14554	23	fishermen	fisherman	NNS
18637	14554	24	in	in	IN
18637	14554	25	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	14554	26	waters	water	NNS
18637	14554	27	and	and	CC
18637	14554	28	levying	levy	VBG
18637	14554	29	a	a	DT
18637	14554	30	license	license	NN
18637	14554	31	fee	fee	NN
18637	14554	32	of	of	IN
18637	14554	33	$	$	$
18637	14554	34	50.00	50.00	CD
18637	14554	35	on	on	IN
18637	14554	36	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	14554	37	and	and	CC
18637	14554	38	only	only	RB
18637	14554	39	$	$	$
18637	14554	40	5.00	5.00	CD
18637	14554	41	on	on	IN
18637	14554	42	resident	resident	JJ
18637	14554	43	fishermen	fisherman	NNS
18637	14554	44	was	be	VBD
18637	14554	45	held	hold	VBN
18637	14554	46	void	void	JJ
18637	14554	47	under	under	IN
18637	14554	48	Art	art	NN
18637	14554	49	.	.	.
18637	14555	1	IV	IV	NNP
18637	14555	2	,	,	,
18637	14555	3	§	§	NNP
18637	14555	4	2	2	CD
18637	14555	5	on	on	IN
18637	14555	6	the	the	DT
18637	14555	7	authority	authority	NN
18637	14555	8	of	of	IN
18637	14555	9	Toomer	Toomer	NNP
18637	14555	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14555	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	14555	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14555	13	Witsell	Witsell	NNP
18637	14555	14	,	,	,
18637	14555	15	cited	cite	VBD
18637	14555	16	above	above	RB
18637	14555	17	.	.	.
18637	14556	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14556	2	167	167	CD
18637	14556	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14556	4	172	172	CD
18637	14556	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14556	6	239	239	CD
18637	14556	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14556	8	1898	1898	CD
18637	14556	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14556	10	.	.	.
18637	14557	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14557	2	168	168	CD
18637	14557	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14557	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14557	5	.	.	.
18637	14558	1	256	256	CD
18637	14558	2	.	.	.
18637	14559	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14559	2	169	169	CD
18637	14559	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14559	4	La	La	NNP
18637	14559	5	Tourette	Tourette	NNP
18637	14559	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14559	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14559	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14559	9	McMaster	McMaster	NNP
18637	14559	10	,	,	,
18637	14559	11	248	248	CD
18637	14559	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14559	13	465	465	CD
18637	14559	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14559	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	14559	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14559	17	.	.	.
18637	14560	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14560	2	170	170	CD
18637	14560	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14560	4	Doherty	Doherty	NNP
18637	14560	5	and	and	CC
18637	14560	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14560	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14560	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14560	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14560	10	Goodman	Goodman	NNP
18637	14560	11	,	,	,
18637	14560	12	294	294	CD
18637	14560	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14560	14	623	623	CD
18637	14560	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14560	16	1935	1935	CD
18637	14560	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14560	18	.	.	.
18637	14561	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14561	2	171	171	CD
18637	14561	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14561	4	Hess	Hess	NNP
18637	14561	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14561	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14561	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14561	8	Pawloski	Pawloski	NNP
18637	14561	9	,	,	,
18637	14561	10	274	274	CD
18637	14561	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14561	12	352	352	CD
18637	14561	13	,	,	,
18637	14561	14	356	356	CD
18637	14561	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14561	16	1927	1927	CD
18637	14561	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14561	18	.	.	.
18637	14562	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14562	2	172	172	CD
18637	14562	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14562	4	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	14562	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14562	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14562	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14562	8	Spokane	Spokane	NNP
18637	14562	9	P.	P.	NNP
18637	14562	10	&	&	CC
18637	14562	11	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	14563	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14563	2	,	,	,
18637	14563	3	258	258	CD
18637	14563	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14563	5	314	314	CD
18637	14563	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14563	7	1922	1922	CD
18637	14563	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14563	9	,	,	,
18637	14563	10	followed	follow	VBN
18637	14563	11	in	in	IN
18637	14563	12	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	14563	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14563	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	14563	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14563	16	Corbett	Corbett	NNP
18637	14563	17	,	,	,
18637	14563	18	258	258	CD
18637	14563	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14563	20	609	609	CD
18637	14563	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14563	22	1922	1922	CD
18637	14563	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14563	24	.	.	.
18637	14564	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14564	2	173	173	CD
18637	14564	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14564	4	Conner	Conner	NNP
18637	14564	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14564	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14564	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14564	8	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	14564	9	,	,	,
18637	14564	10	18	18	CD
18637	14564	11	How	how	WRB
18637	14564	12	.	.	.
18637	14565	1	591	591	CD
18637	14565	2	,	,	,
18637	14565	3	593	593	CD
18637	14565	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14565	5	1856	1856	CD
18637	14565	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14565	7	.	.	.
18637	14566	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14566	2	174	174	CD
18637	14566	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14566	4	Blake	Blake	NNP
18637	14566	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14566	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14566	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14566	8	McClung	McClung	NNP
18637	14566	9	,	,	,
18637	14566	10	172	172	CD
18637	14566	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14566	12	230	230	CD
18637	14566	13	,	,	,
18637	14566	14	248	248	CD
18637	14566	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14566	16	1898	1898	CD
18637	14566	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14566	18	.	.	.
18637	14567	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14567	2	175	175	CD
18637	14567	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14567	4	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	14567	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14567	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14567	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14567	8	Bruffy	Bruffy	NNP
18637	14567	9	,	,	,
18637	14567	10	96	96	CD
18637	14567	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14567	12	176	176	CD
18637	14567	13	,	,	,
18637	14567	14	184	184	CD
18637	14567	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14567	16	1878	1878	CD
18637	14567	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14567	18	.	.	.
18637	14568	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14568	2	176	176	CD
18637	14568	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14568	4	Chambers	Chambers	NNP
18637	14568	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14568	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14568	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14568	8	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	14568	9	&	&	CC
18637	14568	10	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	14569	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14569	2	,	,	,
18637	14569	3	207	207	CD
18637	14569	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14569	5	142	142	CD
18637	14569	6	,	,	,
18637	14569	7	148	148	CD
18637	14569	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14569	9	1907	1907	CD
18637	14569	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14569	11	;	;	:
18637	14569	12	McKnett	McKnett	NNP
18637	14569	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14569	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	14569	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14569	16	St.	St.	NNP
18637	14569	17	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	14569	18	&	&	CC
18637	14569	19	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	14570	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14570	2	,	,	,
18637	14570	3	292	292	CD
18637	14570	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14570	5	230	230	CD
18637	14570	6	,	,	,
18637	14570	7	233	233	CD
18637	14570	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14570	9	1934	1934	CD
18637	14570	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14570	11	;	;	:
18637	14570	12	Miles	Miles	NNP
18637	14570	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14570	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	14570	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14570	16	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	14570	17	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	14571	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14571	2	,	,	,
18637	14571	3	315	315	CD
18637	14571	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14571	5	698	698	CD
18637	14571	6	,	,	,
18637	14571	7	704	704	CD
18637	14571	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14571	9	1942	1942	CD
18637	14571	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14571	11	.	.	.
18637	14572	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14572	2	177	177	CD
18637	14572	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14572	4	Canadian	canadian	JJ
18637	14572	5	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	14573	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14573	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14573	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14573	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14573	5	Eggen	Eggen	NNP
18637	14573	6	,	,	,
18637	14573	7	252	252	CD
18637	14573	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14573	9	553	553	CD
18637	14573	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14573	11	1920	1920	CD
18637	14573	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14573	13	.	.	.
18637	14574	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14574	2	178	178	CD
18637	14574	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14574	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14574	5	.	.	.
18637	14575	1	563	563	CD
18637	14575	2	.	.	.
18637	14576	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14576	2	179	179	CD
18637	14576	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14576	4	Chemung	Chemung	NNP
18637	14576	5	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	14576	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	14576	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14576	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14576	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14576	10	Lowery	Lowery	NNP
18637	14576	11	,	,	,
18637	14576	12	93	93	CD
18637	14576	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14576	14	72	72	CD
18637	14576	15	,	,	,
18637	14576	16	76	76	CD
18637	14576	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14576	18	1876	1876	CD
18637	14576	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14576	20	.	.	.
18637	14577	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14577	2	180	180	CD
18637	14577	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14577	4	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	14577	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14577	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14577	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14577	8	New	New	NNP
18637	14577	9	York	York	NNP
18637	14577	10	,	,	,
18637	14577	11	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	14577	12	&	&	CC
18637	14577	13	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	14578	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14578	2	,	,	,
18637	14578	3	279	279	CD
18637	14578	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14578	5	377	377	CD
18637	14578	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14578	7	1929	1929	CD
18637	14578	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14578	9	.	.	.
18637	14579	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14579	2	181	181	CD
18637	14579	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14579	4	Chambers	Chambers	NNP
18637	14579	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14579	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14579	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14579	8	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	14579	9	&	&	CC
18637	14579	10	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	14580	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14580	2	,	,	,
18637	14580	3	207	207	CD
18637	14580	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14580	5	142	142	CD
18637	14580	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14580	7	1907	1907	CD
18637	14580	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14580	9	.	.	.
18637	14581	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14581	2	182	182	CD
18637	14581	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14581	4	12	12	CD
18637	14581	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14581	6	.	.	.
18637	14582	1	418	418	CD
18637	14582	2	,	,	,
18637	14582	3	424	424	CD
18637	14582	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14582	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	14582	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14582	7	.	.	.
18637	14583	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14583	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14583	3	also	also	RB
18637	14583	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14583	5	Downham	Downham	NNP
18637	14583	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14583	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14583	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14583	9	Alexandria	Alexandria	NNP
18637	14583	10	,	,	,
18637	14583	11	10	10	CD
18637	14583	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14583	13	.	.	.
18637	14584	1	173	173	CD
18637	14584	2	,	,	,
18637	14584	3	175	175	CD
18637	14584	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14584	5	1870	1870	CD
18637	14584	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14584	7	.	.	.
18637	14585	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14585	2	183	183	CD
18637	14585	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14585	4	Chalker	Chalker	NNP
18637	14585	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14585	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14585	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14585	8	Birmingham	Birmingham	NNP
18637	14585	9	&	&	CC
18637	14585	10	M.W.R.	M.W.R.	NNP
18637	14586	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14586	2	,	,	,
18637	14586	3	249	249	CD
18637	14586	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14586	5	522	522	CD
18637	14586	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14586	7	1919	1919	CD
18637	14586	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14586	9	.	.	.
18637	14587	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14587	2	184	184	CD
18637	14587	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14587	4	252	252	CD
18637	14587	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14587	6	60	60	CD
18637	14587	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14587	8	1920	1920	CD
18637	14587	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14587	10	.	.	.
18637	14588	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14588	2	185	185	CD
18637	14588	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14588	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14588	5	.	.	.
18637	14589	1	62	62	CD
18637	14589	2	-	-	SYM
18637	14589	3	64	64	CD
18637	14589	4	.	.	.
18637	14590	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14590	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14590	3	also	also	RB
18637	14590	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14590	5	Shaffer	Shaffer	NNP
18637	14590	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14590	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14590	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14590	9	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	14590	10	,	,	,
18637	14590	11	252	252	CD
18637	14590	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14590	13	37	37	CD
18637	14590	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14590	15	1920	1920	CD
18637	14590	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14590	17	.	.	.
18637	14591	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14591	2	186	186	CD
18637	14591	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14591	4	252	252	CD
18637	14591	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14591	6	60	60	CD
18637	14591	7	,	,	,
18637	14591	8	79	79	CD
18637	14591	9	-	-	SYM
18637	14591	10	80	80	CD
18637	14591	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14591	12	1920	1920	CD
18637	14591	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14591	14	.	.	.
18637	14592	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14592	2	187	187	CD
18637	14592	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14592	4	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	14592	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14592	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14592	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14592	8	Fears	Fears	NNP
18637	14592	9	,	,	,
18637	14592	10	179	179	CD
18637	14592	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14592	12	270	270	CD
18637	14592	13	,	,	,
18637	14592	14	274	274	CD
18637	14592	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14592	16	1900	1900	CD
18637	14592	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14592	18	.	.	.
18637	14593	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14593	2	188	188	CD
18637	14593	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14593	4	Haavik	Haavik	NNP
18637	14593	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14593	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14593	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14593	8	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	14593	9	Packers	Packers	NNP
18637	14593	10	'	'	POS
18637	14593	11	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	14593	12	.	.	.
18637	14593	13	,	,	,
18637	14593	14	263	263	CD
18637	14593	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14593	16	510	510	CD
18637	14593	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14593	18	1924	1924	CD
18637	14593	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14593	20	.	.	.
18637	14594	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14594	2	189	189	CD
18637	14594	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14594	4	Travelers	Travelers	NNPS
18637	14594	5	'	'	POS
18637	14594	6	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14594	7	.	.	.
18637	14595	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14595	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14595	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14595	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14595	5	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	14595	6	,	,	,
18637	14595	7	185	185	CD
18637	14595	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14595	9	364	364	CD
18637	14595	10	,	,	,
18637	14595	11	371	371	CD
18637	14595	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14595	13	1902	1902	CD
18637	14595	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14595	15	.	.	.
18637	14596	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14596	2	190	190	CD
18637	14596	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14596	4	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	14596	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14596	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14596	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14596	8	Bugbee	Bugbee	NNP
18637	14596	9	,	,	,
18637	14596	10	250	250	CD
18637	14596	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14596	12	525	525	CD
18637	14596	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14596	14	1919	1919	CD
18637	14596	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14596	16	.	.	.
18637	14597	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14597	2	191	191	CD
18637	14597	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14597	4	Kirtland	Kirtland	NNP
18637	14597	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14597	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14597	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14597	8	Hotchkiss	Hotchkiss	NNP
18637	14597	9	,	,	,
18637	14597	10	100	100	CD
18637	14597	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14597	12	491	491	CD
18637	14597	13	,	,	,
18637	14597	14	499	499	CD
18637	14597	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14597	16	1879	1879	CD
18637	14597	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14597	18	.	.	.
18637	14598	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14598	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	14598	3	.	.	.
18637	14598	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14598	5	Colgate	Colgate	NNP
18637	14598	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14598	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14598	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14598	9	Harvey	Harvey	NNP
18637	14598	10	,	,	,
18637	14598	11	296	296	CD
18637	14598	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14598	13	404	404	CD
18637	14598	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14598	15	1935	1935	CD
18637	14598	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14598	17	in	in	IN
18637	14598	18	which	which	WDT
18637	14598	19	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	14598	20	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	14598	21	of	of	IN
18637	14598	22	bank	bank	NN
18637	14598	23	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	14598	24	outside	outside	IN
18637	14598	25	the	the	DT
18637	14598	26	State	state	NN
18637	14598	27	owned	own	VBN
18637	14598	28	by	by	IN
18637	14598	29	a	a	DT
18637	14598	30	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	14598	31	of	of	IN
18637	14598	32	the	the	DT
18637	14598	33	State	State	NNP
18637	14598	34	was	be	VBD
18637	14598	35	held	hold	VBN
18637	14598	36	to	to	TO
18637	14598	37	infringe	infringe	VB
18637	14598	38	a	a	DT
18637	14598	39	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	14598	40	of	of	IN
18637	14598	41	national	national	JJ
18637	14598	42	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	14598	43	,	,	,
18637	14598	44	in	in	IN
18637	14598	45	contravention	contravention	NN
18637	14598	46	of	of	IN
18637	14598	47	the	the	DT
18637	14598	48	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	14598	49	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	14598	50	.	.	.
18637	14599	1	The	the	DT
18637	14599	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	14599	3	in	in	IN
18637	14599	4	Colgate	Colgate	NNP
18637	14599	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14599	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14599	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14599	8	Harvey	Harvey	NNP
18637	14599	9	was	be	VBD
18637	14599	10	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	14599	11	in	in	IN
18637	14599	12	Madden	Madden	NNP
18637	14599	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14599	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	14599	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14599	16	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	14599	17	,	,	,
18637	14599	18	309	309	CD
18637	14599	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14599	20	83	83	CD
18637	14599	21	,	,	,
18637	14599	22	93	93	CD
18637	14599	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14599	24	1940	1940	CD
18637	14599	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14599	26	.	.	.
18637	14600	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14600	2	192	192	CD
18637	14600	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14600	4	1	1	CD
18637	14600	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	14600	6	.	.	.
18637	14601	1	302	302	CD
18637	14601	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14601	3	1793	1793	CD
18637	14601	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14601	5	.	.	.
18637	14602	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14602	2	193	193	CD
18637	14602	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14602	4	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	14602	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14602	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14602	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14602	8	Reilly	Reilly	NNP
18637	14602	9	,	,	,
18637	14602	10	116	116	CD
18637	14602	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14602	12	80	80	CD
18637	14602	13	,	,	,
18637	14602	14	94	94	CD
18637	14602	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14602	16	1885	1885	CD
18637	14602	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14602	18	.	.	.
18637	14603	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14603	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14603	3	also	also	RB
18637	14603	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14603	5	Innes	Innes	NNP
18637	14603	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14603	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14603	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14603	9	Tobin	Tobin	NNP
18637	14603	10	,	,	,
18637	14603	11	240	240	CD
18637	14603	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14603	13	127	127	CD
18637	14603	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14603	15	1916	1916	CD
18637	14603	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14603	17	.	.	.
18637	14604	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	14604	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14604	3	Story	Story	NNP
18637	14604	4	:	:	:
18637	14604	5	"	"	``
18637	14604	6	...	...	NFP
18637	14604	7	the	the	DT
18637	14604	8	natural	natural	JJ
18637	14604	9	,	,	,
18637	14604	10	if	if	IN
18637	14604	11	not	not	RB
18637	14604	12	the	the	DT
18637	14604	13	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	14604	14	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	14604	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	14604	16	,	,	,
18637	14604	17	that	that	IN
18637	14604	18	the	the	DT
18637	14604	19	national	national	JJ
18637	14604	20	government	government	NN
18637	14604	21	,	,	,
18637	14604	22	in	in	IN
18637	14604	23	the	the	DT
18637	14604	24	absence	absence	NN
18637	14604	25	of	of	IN
18637	14604	26	all	all	DT
18637	14604	27	positive	positive	JJ
18637	14604	28	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	14604	29	to	to	IN
18637	14604	30	the	the	DT
18637	14604	31	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	14604	32	,	,	,
18637	14604	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	14604	34	bound	bind	VBN
18637	14604	35	,	,	,
18637	14604	36	through	through	IN
18637	14604	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14604	38	own	own	JJ
18637	14604	39	proper	proper	JJ
18637	14604	40	departments	department	NNS
18637	14604	41	,	,	,
18637	14604	42	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	14604	43	,	,	,
18637	14604	44	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	14604	45	,	,	,
18637	14604	46	or	or	CC
18637	14604	47	executive	executive	JJ
18637	14604	48	,	,	,
18637	14604	49	as	as	IN
18637	14604	50	the	the	DT
18637	14604	51	case	case	NN
18637	14604	52	may	may	MD
18637	14604	53	require	require	VB
18637	14604	54	,	,	,
18637	14604	55	to	to	TO
18637	14604	56	carry	carry	VB
18637	14604	57	into	into	IN
18637	14604	58	effect	effect	NN
18637	14604	59	all	all	PDT
18637	14604	60	the	the	DT
18637	14604	61	rights	right	NNS
18637	14604	62	and	and	CC
18637	14604	63	duties	duty	NNS
18637	14604	64	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	14604	65	upon	upon	IN
18637	14604	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14604	67	by	by	IN
18637	14604	68	the	the	DT
18637	14604	69	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14604	70	"	"	''
18637	14604	71	;	;	,
18637	14604	72	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14604	73	and	and	CC
18637	14604	74	again	again	RB
18637	14604	75	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14604	76	"	"	``
18637	14604	77	...	...	NFP
18637	14604	78	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14604	79	has	have	VBZ
18637	14604	80	,	,	,
18637	14604	81	on	on	IN
18637	14604	82	various	various	JJ
18637	14604	83	occasions	occasion	NNS
18637	14604	84	,	,	,
18637	14604	85	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	14604	86	powers	power	NNS
18637	14604	87	which	which	WDT
18637	14604	88	were	be	VBD
18637	14604	89	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	14604	90	and	and	CC
18637	14604	91	proper	proper	JJ
18637	14604	92	as	as	IN
18637	14604	93	means	mean	VBZ
18637	14604	94	to	to	TO
18637	14604	95	carry	carry	VB
18637	14604	96	into	into	IN
18637	14604	97	effect	effect	NN
18637	14604	98	rights	right	NNS
18637	14604	99	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	14604	100	given	give	VBN
18637	14604	101	,	,	,
18637	14604	102	and	and	CC
18637	14604	103	duties	duty	NNS
18637	14604	104	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	14604	105	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	14604	106	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	14604	107	.	.	.
18637	14604	108	"	"	''
18637	14605	1	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
18637	14605	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14605	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14605	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14605	5	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	14605	6	,	,	,
18637	14605	7	16	16	CD
18637	14605	8	Pet	pet	NN
18637	14605	9	.	.	.
18637	14606	1	539	539	CD
18637	14606	2	,	,	,
18637	14606	3	616	616	CD
18637	14606	4	,	,	,
18637	14606	5	618	618	CD
18637	14606	6	-	-	SYM
18637	14606	7	619	619	CD
18637	14606	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14606	9	1842	1842	CD
18637	14606	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14606	11	.	.	.
18637	14607	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14607	2	194	194	CD
18637	14607	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14607	4	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	14607	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14607	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14607	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14607	8	Taintor	Taintor	NNP
18637	14607	9	,	,	,
18637	14607	10	16	16	CD
18637	14607	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14607	12	.	.	.
18637	14608	1	366	366	CD
18637	14608	2	,	,	,
18637	14608	3	371	371	CD
18637	14608	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14608	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	14608	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14608	7	.	.	.
18637	14609	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14609	2	195	195	CD
18637	14609	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14609	4	24	24	CD
18637	14609	5	How	how	WRB
18637	14609	6	.	.	.
18637	14610	1	66	66	CD
18637	14610	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14610	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	14610	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14610	5	;	;	:
18637	14610	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14610	7	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	14610	8	.	.	.
18637	14610	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14610	10	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
18637	14610	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14610	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	14610	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14610	14	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	14610	15	,	,	,
18637	14610	16	16	16	CD
18637	14610	17	Pet	pet	NN
18637	14610	18	.	.	.
18637	14611	1	539	539	CD
18637	14611	2	,	,	,
18637	14611	3	612	612	CD
18637	14611	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14611	5	1842	1842	CD
18637	14611	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14611	7	.	.	.
18637	14612	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14612	2	196	196	CD
18637	14612	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14612	4	24	24	CD
18637	14612	5	How	how	WRB
18637	14612	6	.	.	.
18637	14613	1	66	66	CD
18637	14613	2	,	,	,
18637	14613	3	107	107	CD
18637	14613	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14613	5	1861	1861	CD
18637	14613	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14613	7	.	.	.
18637	14614	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14614	2	197	197	CD
18637	14614	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14614	4	48	48	CD
18637	14614	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	14614	6	.	.	.
18637	14615	1	782	782	CD
18637	14615	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14615	3	1934	1934	CD
18637	14615	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14615	5	.	.	.
18637	14616	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14616	2	198	198	CD
18637	14616	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14616	4	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	14616	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14616	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14616	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14616	8	Reilly	Reilly	NNP
18637	14616	9	,	,	,
18637	14616	10	116	116	CD
18637	14616	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14616	12	80	80	CD
18637	14616	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14616	14	1885	1885	CD
18637	14616	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14616	16	.	.	.
18637	14617	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14617	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14617	3	also	also	RB
18637	14617	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14617	5	Strassheim	Strassheim	NNP
18637	14617	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14617	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14617	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14617	9	Daily	Daily	NNP
18637	14617	10	,	,	,
18637	14617	11	221	221	CD
18637	14617	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14617	13	280	280	CD
18637	14617	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14617	15	1911	1911	CD
18637	14617	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14617	17	;	;	:
18637	14617	18	Appleyard	Appleyard	NNP
18637	14617	19	_	_	NNP
18637	14617	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	14617	21	_	_	NNP
18637	14617	22	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	14617	23	,	,	,
18637	14617	24	203	203	CD
18637	14617	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14617	26	222	222	CD
18637	14617	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14617	28	1906	1906	CD
18637	14617	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14617	30	;	;	:
18637	14617	31	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	14617	32	parte	parte	VBZ
18637	14617	33	Reggel	Reggel	NNP
18637	14617	34	,	,	,
18637	14617	35	114	114	CD
18637	14617	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14617	37	642	642	CD
18637	14617	38	,	,	,
18637	14617	39	650	650	CD
18637	14617	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14617	41	1885	1885	CD
18637	14617	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14617	43	.	.	.
18637	14618	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14618	2	199	199	CD
18637	14618	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14618	4	Drew	Drew	NNP
18637	14618	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14618	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14618	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14618	8	Thaw	Thaw	NNP
18637	14618	9	,	,	,
18637	14618	10	235	235	CD
18637	14618	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14618	12	432	432	CD
18637	14618	13	,	,	,
18637	14618	14	439	439	CD
18637	14618	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14618	16	1914	1914	CD
18637	14618	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14618	18	.	.	.
18637	14619	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14619	2	200	200	CD
18637	14619	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14619	4	Innes	Innes	NNP
18637	14619	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14619	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14619	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14619	8	Tobin	Tobin	NNP
18637	14619	9	,	,	,
18637	14619	10	240	240	CD
18637	14619	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14619	12	127	127	CD
18637	14619	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14619	14	1916	1916	CD
18637	14619	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14619	16	.	.	.
18637	14620	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14620	2	201	201	CD
18637	14620	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14620	4	Bassing	Bassing	NNP
18637	14620	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14620	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14620	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14620	8	Cady	Cady	NNP
18637	14620	9	,	,	,
18637	14620	10	208	208	CD
18637	14620	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14620	12	386	386	CD
18637	14620	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14620	14	1908	1908	CD
18637	14620	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14620	16	.	.	.
18637	14621	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14621	2	202	202	CD
18637	14621	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14621	4	Hyatt	Hyatt	NNP
18637	14621	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14621	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14621	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14621	8	New	New	NNP
18637	14621	9	York	York	NNP
18637	14621	10	ex	ex	NNP
18637	14621	11	rel	rel	NN
18637	14621	12	.	.	.
18637	14622	1	Corkran	Corkran	NNP
18637	14622	2	,	,	,
18637	14622	3	188	188	CD
18637	14622	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14622	5	691	691	CD
18637	14622	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14622	7	1903	1903	CD
18637	14622	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14622	9	.	.	.
18637	14623	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14623	2	203	203	CD
18637	14623	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14623	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	14623	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14623	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14623	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14623	8	Dennison	Dennison	NNP
18637	14623	9	,	,	,
18637	14623	10	24	24	CD
18637	14623	11	How	how	WRB
18637	14623	12	.	.	.
18637	14624	1	66	66	CD
18637	14624	2	,	,	,
18637	14624	3	103	103	CD
18637	14624	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14624	5	1861	1861	CD
18637	14624	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14624	7	.	.	.
18637	14625	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14625	2	204	204	CD
18637	14625	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14625	4	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	14625	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14625	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14625	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14625	8	Taintor	Taintor	NNP
18637	14625	9	,	,	,
18637	14625	10	16	16	CD
18637	14625	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14625	12	.	.	.
18637	14626	1	366	366	CD
18637	14626	2	,	,	,
18637	14626	3	375	375	CD
18637	14626	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14626	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	14626	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14626	7	.	.	.
18637	14627	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14627	2	205	205	CD
18637	14627	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14627	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	14627	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14627	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14627	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14627	8	Dennison	Dennison	NNP
18637	14627	9	,	,	,
18637	14627	10	24	24	CD
18637	14627	11	How	how	WRB
18637	14627	12	.	.	.
18637	14628	1	66	66	CD
18637	14628	2	,	,	,
18637	14628	3	104	104	CD
18637	14628	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14628	5	1861	1861	CD
18637	14628	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14628	7	;	;	:
18637	14628	8	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	14628	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14628	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14628	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14628	12	Creecy	Creecy	NNP
18637	14628	13	,	,	,
18637	14628	14	210	210	CD
18637	14628	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14628	16	387	387	CD
18637	14628	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14628	18	1908	1908	CD
18637	14628	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14628	20	.	.	.
18637	14629	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14629	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14629	3	also	also	RB
18637	14629	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14629	5	Marbles	Marbles	NNP
18637	14629	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14629	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14629	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14629	9	Creecy	Creecy	NNP
18637	14629	10	,	,	,
18637	14629	11	215	215	CD
18637	14629	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14629	13	63	63	CD
18637	14629	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14629	15	1909	1909	CD
18637	14629	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14629	17	;	;	:
18637	14629	18	Strassheim	Strassheim	NNP
18637	14629	19	_	_	NNP
18637	14629	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	14629	21	_	_	NNP
18637	14629	22	Daily	Daily	NNP
18637	14629	23	,	,	,
18637	14629	24	221	221	CD
18637	14629	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14629	26	280	280	CD
18637	14629	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14629	28	1911	1911	CD
18637	14629	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14629	30	;	;	:
18637	14629	31	Re	Re	NNP
18637	14629	32	Strauss	Strauss	NNP
18637	14629	33	,	,	,
18637	14629	34	197	197	CD
18637	14629	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14629	36	324	324	CD
18637	14629	37	,	,	,
18637	14629	38	325	325	CD
18637	14629	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14629	40	1905	1905	CD
18637	14629	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14629	42	.	.	.
18637	14630	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14630	2	206	206	CD
18637	14630	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14630	4	Munsey	Munsey	NNP
18637	14630	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14630	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14630	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14630	8	Clough	Clough	NNP
18637	14630	9	,	,	,
18637	14630	10	196	196	CD
18637	14630	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14630	12	364	364	CD
18637	14630	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14630	14	1905	1905	CD
18637	14630	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14630	16	;	;	:
18637	14630	17	Pettibone	Pettibone	NNP
18637	14630	18	_	_	NNP
18637	14630	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	14630	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14630	21	Nichols	Nichols	NNP
18637	14630	22	,	,	,
18637	14630	23	203	203	CD
18637	14630	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14630	25	192	192	CD
18637	14630	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14630	27	1906	1906	CD
18637	14630	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14630	29	.	.	.
18637	14631	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14631	2	207	207	CD
18637	14631	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14631	4	Drew	Drew	NNP
18637	14631	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14631	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14631	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14631	8	Thaw	Thaw	NNP
18637	14631	9	,	,	,
18637	14631	10	235	235	CD
18637	14631	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14631	12	432	432	CD
18637	14631	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14631	14	1914	1914	CD
18637	14631	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14631	16	.	.	.
18637	14632	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14632	2	208	208	CD
18637	14632	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14632	4	Pettibone	Pettibone	NNP
18637	14632	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14632	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14632	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14632	8	Nichols	Nichols	NNP
18637	14632	9	,	,	,
18637	14632	10	203	203	CD
18637	14632	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14632	12	192	192	CD
18637	14632	13	,	,	,
18637	14632	14	216	216	CD
18637	14632	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14632	16	1906	1906	CD
18637	14632	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14632	18	.	.	.
18637	14633	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14633	2	209	209	CD
18637	14633	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14633	4	Biddinger	Biddinger	NNP
18637	14633	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14633	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14633	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14633	8	Police	Police	NNP
18637	14633	9	Comr	Comr	NNP
18637	14633	10	.	.	.
18637	14633	11	,	,	,
18637	14633	12	245	245	CD
18637	14633	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14633	14	128	128	CD
18637	14633	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14633	16	1917	1917	CD
18637	14633	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14633	18	.	.	.
18637	14634	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14634	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14634	3	also	also	RB
18637	14634	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14634	5	Rodman	Rodman	NNP
18637	14634	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14634	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14634	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14634	9	Pothier	Pothier	NNP
18637	14634	10	,	,	,
18637	14634	11	264	264	CD
18637	14634	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14634	13	399	399	CD
18637	14634	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14634	15	1924	1924	CD
18637	14634	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14634	17	.	.	.
18637	14635	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14635	2	210	210	CD
18637	14635	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14635	4	Hyatt	Hyatt	NNP
18637	14635	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14635	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14635	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14635	8	New	New	NNP
18637	14635	9	York	York	NNP
18637	14635	10	ex	ex	NNP
18637	14635	11	rel	rel	NN
18637	14635	12	.	.	.
18637	14636	1	Corkran	Corkran	NNP
18637	14636	2	,	,	,
18637	14636	3	188	188	CD
18637	14636	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14636	5	691	691	CD
18637	14636	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14636	7	1903	1903	CD
18637	14636	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14636	9	.	.	.
18637	14637	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14637	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14637	3	also	also	RB
18637	14637	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14637	5	South	South	NNP
18637	14637	6	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	14637	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14637	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14637	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14637	10	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	14637	11	,	,	,
18637	14637	12	289	289	CD
18637	14637	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14637	14	412	412	CD
18637	14637	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14637	16	1933	1933	CD
18637	14637	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14637	18	.	.	.
18637	14638	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14638	2	211	211	CD
18637	14638	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14638	4	Munsey	Munsey	NNP
18637	14638	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14638	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14638	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14638	8	Clough	Clough	NNP
18637	14638	9	,	,	,
18637	14638	10	196	196	CD
18637	14638	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14638	12	364	364	CD
18637	14638	13	,	,	,
18637	14638	14	375	375	CD
18637	14638	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14638	16	1905	1905	CD
18637	14638	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14638	18	.	.	.
18637	14639	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14639	2	212	212	CD
18637	14639	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14639	4	Ker	Ker	NNP
18637	14639	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14639	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14639	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14639	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	14639	9	,	,	,
18637	14639	10	119	119	CD
18637	14639	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14639	12	436	436	CD
18637	14639	13	,	,	,
18637	14639	14	444	444	CD
18637	14639	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14639	16	1886	1886	CD
18637	14639	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14639	18	;	;	:
18637	14639	19	Mahon	Mahon	NNP
18637	14639	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14639	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	14639	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14639	23	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14639	24	,	,	,
18637	14639	25	127	127	CD
18637	14639	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14639	27	700	700	CD
18637	14639	28	,	,	,
18637	14639	29	707	707	CD
18637	14639	30	,	,	,
18637	14639	31	712	712	CD
18637	14639	32	,	,	,
18637	14639	33	714	714	CD
18637	14639	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14639	35	1888	1888	CD
18637	14639	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14639	37	.	.	.
18637	14640	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14640	2	213	213	CD
18637	14640	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14640	4	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	14640	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14640	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14640	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14640	8	Hart	Hart	NNP
18637	14640	9	,	,	,
18637	14640	10	146	146	CD
18637	14640	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14640	12	183	183	CD
18637	14640	13	,	,	,
18637	14640	14	193	193	CD
18637	14640	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14640	16	1892	1892	CD
18637	14640	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14640	18	;	;	:
18637	14640	19	Pettibone	Pettibone	NNP
18637	14640	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14640	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	14640	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14640	23	Nichols	Nichols	NNP
18637	14640	24	,	,	,
18637	14640	25	203	203	CD
18637	14640	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14640	27	192	192	CD
18637	14640	28	,	,	,
18637	14640	29	215	215	CD
18637	14640	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14640	31	1906	1906	CD
18637	14640	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14640	33	.	.	.
18637	14641	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14641	2	214	214	CD
18637	14641	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14641	4	Lascelles	Lascelles	NNP
18637	14641	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14641	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14641	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14641	8	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	14641	9	,	,	,
18637	14641	10	148	148	CD
18637	14641	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14641	12	537	537	CD
18637	14641	13	,	,	,
18637	14641	14	543	543	CD
18637	14641	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14641	16	1893	1893	CD
18637	14641	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14641	18	.	.	.
18637	14642	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14642	2	215	215	CD
18637	14642	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14642	4	United	United	NNP
18637	14642	5	States	States	NNP
18637	14642	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14642	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14642	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14642	9	Rauscher	Rauscher	NNP
18637	14642	10	,	,	,
18637	14642	11	119	119	CD
18637	14642	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14642	13	407	407	CD
18637	14642	14	,	,	,
18637	14642	15	430	430	CD
18637	14642	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14642	17	1886	1886	CD
18637	14642	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14642	19	.	.	.
18637	14643	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14643	2	216	216	CD
18637	14643	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14643	4	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
18637	14643	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14643	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14643	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14643	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	14643	9	,	,	,
18637	14643	10	16	16	CD
18637	14643	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	14643	12	.	.	.
18637	14644	1	539	539	CD
18637	14644	2	,	,	,
18637	14644	3	612	612	CD
18637	14644	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14644	5	1842	1842	CD
18637	14644	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14644	7	.	.	.
18637	14645	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14645	2	217	217	CD
18637	14645	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14645	4	1	1	CD
18637	14645	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	14645	6	.	.	.
18637	14646	1	302	302	CD
18637	14646	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14646	3	1793	1793	CD
18637	14646	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14646	5	.	.	.
18637	14647	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14647	2	218	218	CD
18637	14647	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14647	4	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	14647	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14647	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14647	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14647	8	Van	Van	NNP
18637	14647	9	Zandt	Zandt	NNP
18637	14647	10	,	,	,
18637	14647	11	5	5	CD
18637	14647	12	How	how	WRB
18637	14647	13	.	.	.
18637	14648	1	215	215	CD
18637	14648	2	,	,	,
18637	14648	3	229	229	CD
18637	14648	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14648	5	1847	1847	CD
18637	14648	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14648	7	;	;	:
18637	14648	8	Ableman	Ableman	NNP
18637	14648	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14648	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14648	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14648	12	Booth	Booth	NNP
18637	14648	13	,	,	,
18637	14648	14	21	21	CD
18637	14648	15	How	how	WRB
18637	14648	16	.	.	.
18637	14649	1	506	506	CD
18637	14649	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14649	3	1859	1859	CD
18637	14649	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14649	5	.	.	.
18637	14650	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14650	2	219	219	CD
18637	14650	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14650	4	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
18637	14650	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14650	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14650	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14650	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	14650	9	,	,	,
18637	14650	10	16	16	CD
18637	14650	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	14650	12	.	.	.
18637	14651	1	539	539	CD
18637	14651	2	,	,	,
18637	14651	3	625	625	CD
18637	14651	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14651	5	1842	1842	CD
18637	14651	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14651	7	.	.	.
18637	14652	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14652	2	220	220	CD
18637	14652	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14652	4	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	14652	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14652	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14652	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14652	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	14652	9	,	,	,
18637	14652	10	14	14	CD
18637	14652	11	How	how	WRB
18637	14652	12	.	.	.
18637	14653	1	13	13	CD
18637	14653	2	,	,	,
18637	14653	3	17	17	CD
18637	14653	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14653	5	1853	1853	CD
18637	14653	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14653	7	.	.	.
18637	14654	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14654	2	221	221	CD
18637	14654	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14654	4	Escanaba	Escanaba	NNP
18637	14654	5	&	&	CC
18637	14654	6	L.M.	L.M.	NNP
18637	14655	1	Transp	Transp	NNP
18637	14655	2	.	.	.
18637	14656	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14656	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14656	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14656	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14656	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	14656	6	,	,	,
18637	14656	7	107	107	CD
18637	14656	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14656	9	678	678	CD
18637	14656	10	,	,	,
18637	14656	11	689	689	CD
18637	14656	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14656	13	1883	1883	CD
18637	14656	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14656	15	.	.	.
18637	14657	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14657	2	222	222	CD
18637	14657	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14657	4	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	14657	5	,	,	,
18637	14657	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	14657	7	of	of	IN
18637	14657	8	the	the	DT
18637	14657	9	Debates	Debates	NNPS
18637	14657	10	in	in	IN
18637	14657	11	the	the	DT
18637	14657	12	Convention	convention	NN
18637	14657	13	which	which	WDT
18637	14657	14	Framed	frame	VBD
18637	14657	15	the	the	DT
18637	14657	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14657	17	,	,	,
18637	14657	18	89	89	CD
18637	14657	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14657	20	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
18637	14657	21	's	's	POS
18637	14657	22	ed	ed	NNP
18637	14657	23	.	.	NNP
18637	14657	24	,	,	,
18637	14657	25	1908	1908	CD
18637	14657	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14657	27	.	.	.
18637	14658	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14658	2	223	223	CD
18637	14658	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14658	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14658	5	.	.	.
18637	14659	1	274	274	CD
18637	14659	2	.	.	.
18637	14660	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14660	2	224	224	CD
18637	14660	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14660	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14660	5	.	.	.
18637	14661	1	275	275	CD
18637	14661	2	.	.	.
18637	14662	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14662	2	225	225	CD
18637	14662	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14662	4	Pollard	Pollard	NNP
18637	14662	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14662	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14662	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14662	8	Hagan	Hagan	NNP
18637	14662	9	,	,	,
18637	14662	10	3	3	CD
18637	14662	11	How	how	WRB
18637	14662	12	.	.	.
18637	14663	1	212	212	CD
18637	14663	2	,	,	,
18637	14663	3	221	221	CD
18637	14663	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14663	5	1845	1845	CD
18637	14663	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14663	7	.	.	.
18637	14664	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14664	2	226	226	CD
18637	14664	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14664	4	2	2	CD
18637	14664	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	14664	6	.	.	.
18637	14665	1	701	701	CD
18637	14665	2	,	,	,
18637	14665	3	703	703	CD
18637	14665	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14665	5	1812	1812	CD
18637	14665	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14665	7	.	.	.
18637	14666	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14666	2	227	227	CD
18637	14666	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14666	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14666	5	Harlan	Harlan	NNP
18637	14666	6	,	,	,
18637	14666	7	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	14666	8	for	for	IN
18637	14666	9	the	the	DT
18637	14666	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14666	11	in	in	IN
18637	14666	12	United	United	NNP
18637	14666	13	States	States	NNP
18637	14666	14	_	_	NNP
18637	14666	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	14666	16	_	_	NNP
18637	14666	17	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	14666	18	,	,	,
18637	14666	19	143	143	CD
18637	14666	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14666	21	621	621	CD
18637	14666	22	,	,	,
18637	14666	23	634	634	CD
18637	14666	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14666	25	1892	1892	CD
18637	14666	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14666	27	;	;	:
18637	14666	28	9	9	CD
18637	14666	29	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	14666	30	.	.	.
18637	14667	1	108	108	CD
18637	14667	2	.	.	.
18637	14668	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14668	2	228	228	CD
18637	14668	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14668	4	Permoli	Permoli	NNP
18637	14668	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14668	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14668	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14668	8	New	New	NNP
18637	14668	9	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	14668	10	,	,	,
18637	14668	11	3	3	CD
18637	14668	12	How	how	WRB
18637	14668	13	.	.	.
18637	14669	1	589	589	CD
18637	14669	2	,	,	,
18637	14669	3	609	609	CD
18637	14669	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14669	5	1845	1845	CD
18637	14669	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14669	7	;	;	:
18637	14669	8	McCabe	McCabe	NNP
18637	14669	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14669	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14669	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14669	12	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	14669	13	,	,	,
18637	14669	14	T.	T.	NNP
18637	14669	15	&	&	CC
18637	14669	16	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	14670	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14670	2	,	,	,
18637	14670	3	235	235	CD
18637	14670	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14670	5	151	151	CD
18637	14670	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14670	7	1914	1914	CD
18637	14670	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14670	9	;	;	:
18637	14670	10	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	14670	11	Central	Central	NNP
18637	14670	12	R.	R.	NNP
18637	14670	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14670	14	_	_	NNP
18637	14670	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	14670	16	_	_	NNP
18637	14670	17	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	14670	18	,	,	,
18637	14670	19	146	146	CD
18637	14670	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14670	21	387	387	CD
18637	14670	22	,	,	,
18637	14670	23	434	434	CD
18637	14670	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14670	25	1892	1892	CD
18637	14670	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14670	27	;	;	:
18637	14670	28	Knight	Knight	NNP
18637	14670	29	_	_	NNP
18637	14670	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	14670	31	_	_	NNP
18637	14670	32	United	United	NNP
18637	14670	33	Land	Land	NNP
18637	14670	34	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	14670	35	.	.	.
18637	14670	36	,	,	,
18637	14670	37	142	142	CD
18637	14670	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14670	39	161	161	CD
18637	14670	40	,	,	,
18637	14670	41	183	183	CD
18637	14670	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14670	43	1891	1891	CD
18637	14670	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14670	45	;	;	:
18637	14670	46	Weber	Weber	NNP
18637	14670	47	_	_	NNP
18637	14670	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	14670	49	_	_	NNP
18637	14670	50	State	State	NNP
18637	14670	51	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	14670	52	Comrs	Comrs	NNP
18637	14670	53	.	.	.
18637	14670	54	,	,	,
18637	14670	55	18	18	CD
18637	14670	56	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14670	57	.	.	.
18637	14671	1	57	57	CD
18637	14671	2	,	,	,
18637	14671	3	65	65	CD
18637	14671	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14671	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	14671	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14671	7	.	.	.
18637	14672	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14672	2	229	229	CD
18637	14672	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14672	4	Coyle	Coyle	NNP
18637	14672	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14672	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14672	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14672	8	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	14672	9	,	,	,
18637	14672	10	221	221	CD
18637	14672	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14672	12	559	559	CD
18637	14672	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14672	14	1911	1911	CD
18637	14672	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14672	16	.	.	.
18637	14673	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14673	2	230	230	CD
18637	14673	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14673	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14673	5	.	.	.
18637	14674	1	567	567	CD
18637	14674	2	.	.	.
18637	14675	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14675	2	231	231	CD
18637	14675	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14675	4	United	United	NNP
18637	14675	5	States	States	NNP
18637	14675	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14675	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14675	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14675	9	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	14675	10	,	,	,
18637	14675	11	339	339	CD
18637	14675	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14675	13	707	707	CD
18637	14675	14	,	,	,
18637	14675	15	716	716	CD
18637	14675	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14675	17	1950	1950	CD
18637	14675	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14675	19	;	;	:
18637	14675	20	Stearns	Stearns	NNP
18637	14675	21	_	_	NNP
18637	14675	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	14675	23	_	_	NNP
18637	14675	24	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	14675	25	,	,	,
18637	14675	26	179	179	CD
18637	14675	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14675	28	223	223	CD
18637	14675	29	,	,	,
18637	14675	30	245	245	CD
18637	14675	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14675	32	1900	1900	CD
18637	14675	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14675	34	.	.	.
18637	14676	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14676	2	232	232	CD
18637	14676	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14676	4	Pollard	Pollard	NNP
18637	14676	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14676	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14676	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14676	8	Hagan	Hagan	NNP
18637	14676	9	,	,	,
18637	14676	10	3	3	CD
18637	14676	11	How	how	WRB
18637	14676	12	.	.	.
18637	14677	1	212	212	CD
18637	14677	2	,	,	,
18637	14677	3	223	223	CD
18637	14677	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14677	5	1845	1845	CD
18637	14677	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14677	7	;	;	:
18637	14677	8	McCabe	McCabe	NNP
18637	14677	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14677	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14677	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14677	12	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	14677	13	,	,	,
18637	14677	14	T.	T.	NNP
18637	14677	15	&	&	CC
18637	14677	16	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	14678	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14678	2	,	,	,
18637	14678	3	235	235	CD
18637	14678	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14678	5	151	151	CD
18637	14678	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14678	7	1914	1914	CD
18637	14678	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14678	9	.	.	.
18637	14679	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14679	2	233	233	CD
18637	14679	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14679	4	Van	Van	NNP
18637	14679	5	Brocklin	Brocklin	NNP
18637	14679	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14679	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14679	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14679	9	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	14679	10	,	,	,
18637	14679	11	117	117	CD
18637	14679	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14679	13	151	151	CD
18637	14679	14	,	,	,
18637	14679	15	167	167	CD
18637	14679	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14679	17	1886	1886	CD
18637	14679	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14679	19	.	.	.
18637	14680	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14680	2	234	234	CD
18637	14680	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14680	4	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	14680	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14680	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14680	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14680	8	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	14680	9	,	,	,
18637	14680	10	327	327	CD
18637	14680	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14680	12	474	474	CD
18637	14680	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14680	14	1946	1946	CD
18637	14680	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14680	16	.	.	.
18637	14681	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14681	2	235	235	CD
18637	14681	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14681	4	Permoli	Permoli	NNP
18637	14681	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14681	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14681	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14681	8	New	New	NNP
18637	14681	9	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	14681	10	,	,	,
18637	14681	11	3	3	CD
18637	14681	12	How	how	WRB
18637	14681	13	.	.	.
18637	14682	1	589	589	CD
18637	14682	2	,	,	,
18637	14682	3	609	609	CD
18637	14682	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14682	5	1845	1845	CD
18637	14682	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14682	7	;	;	:
18637	14682	8	Sands	Sands	NNPS
18637	14682	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14682	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14682	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14682	12	Manistee	Manistee	NNP
18637	14682	13	River	River	NNP
18637	14682	14	Imp	Imp	NNP
18637	14682	15	.	.	.
18637	14683	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14683	2	,	,	,
18637	14683	3	123	123	CD
18637	14683	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14683	5	288	288	CD
18637	14683	6	,	,	,
18637	14683	7	296	296	CD
18637	14683	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14683	9	1887	1887	CD
18637	14683	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14683	11	;	;	:
18637	14683	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14683	13	see	see	VB
18637	14683	14	also	also	RB
18637	14683	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14683	16	Withers	Withers	NNP
18637	14683	17	_	_	NNP
18637	14683	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	14683	19	_	_	NNP
18637	14683	20	Buckley	Buckley	NNP
18637	14683	21	,	,	,
18637	14683	22	20	20	CD
18637	14683	23	How	how	WRB
18637	14683	24	.	.	.
18637	14684	1	84	84	CD
18637	14684	2	,	,	,
18637	14684	3	92	92	CD
18637	14684	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14684	5	1858	1858	CD
18637	14684	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14684	7	;	;	:
18637	14684	8	Willamette	Willamette	NNP
18637	14684	9	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	14684	10	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	14684	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14684	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14684	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	14684	14	_	_	NNP
18637	14684	15	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	14684	16	,	,	,
18637	14684	17	125	125	CD
18637	14684	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14684	19	1	1	CD
18637	14684	20	,	,	,
18637	14684	21	9	9	CD
18637	14684	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14684	23	1888	1888	CD
18637	14684	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14684	25	;	;	:
18637	14684	26	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	14684	27	_	_	NNP
18637	14684	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	14684	29	_	_	NNP
18637	14684	30	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	14684	31	&	&	CC
18637	14684	32	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	14685	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14685	2	,	,	,
18637	14685	3	223	223	CD
18637	14685	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14685	5	390	390	CD
18637	14685	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14685	7	1912	1912	CD
18637	14685	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14685	9	;	;	:
18637	14685	10	Huse	Huse	NNP
18637	14685	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14685	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	14685	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14685	14	Glover	Glover	NNP
18637	14685	15	,	,	,
18637	14685	16	119	119	CD
18637	14685	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14685	18	543,(1886	543,(1886	CD
18637	14685	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14685	20	.	.	.
18637	14686	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14686	2	236	236	CD
18637	14686	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14686	4	Draper	Draper	NNP
18637	14686	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14686	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14686	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14686	8	United	United	NNP
18637	14686	9	States	States	NNP
18637	14686	10	,	,	,
18637	14686	11	164	164	CD
18637	14686	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14686	13	240	240	CD
18637	14686	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14686	15	1896	1896	CD
18637	14686	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14686	17	following	follow	VBG
18637	14686	18	United	United	NNP
18637	14686	19	States	States	NNP
18637	14686	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14686	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	14686	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14686	23	McBratney	McBratney	NNP
18637	14686	24	,	,	,
18637	14686	25	104	104	CD
18637	14686	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14686	27	621	621	CD
18637	14686	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14686	29	1882	1882	CD
18637	14686	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14686	31	.	.	.
18637	14687	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14687	2	237	237	CD
18637	14687	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14687	4	Dick	Dick	NNP
18637	14687	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14687	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14687	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14687	8	United	United	NNP
18637	14687	9	States	States	NNP
18637	14687	10	,	,	,
18637	14687	11	208	208	CD
18637	14687	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14687	13	340	340	CD
18637	14687	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14687	15	1908	1908	CD
18637	14687	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14687	17	;	;	:
18637	14687	18	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	14687	19	parte	parte	NN
18637	14687	20	Webb	Webb	NNP
18637	14687	21	,	,	,
18637	14687	22	225	225	CD
18637	14687	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14687	24	663	663	CD
18637	14687	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14687	26	1912	1912	CD
18637	14687	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14687	28	.	.	.
18637	14688	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14688	2	238	238	CD
18637	14688	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14688	4	United	United	NNP
18637	14688	5	States	States	NNP
18637	14688	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14688	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14688	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14688	9	Sandoval	Sandoval	NNP
18637	14688	10	,	,	,
18637	14688	11	231	231	CD
18637	14688	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14688	13	28	28	CD
18637	14688	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14688	15	1914	1914	CD
18637	14688	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14688	17	.	.	.
18637	14689	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14689	2	239	239	CD
18637	14689	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14689	4	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
18637	14689	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14689	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14689	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14689	8	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	14689	9	,	,	,
18637	14689	10	143	143	CD
18637	14689	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14689	12	135	135	CD
18637	14689	13	,	,	,
18637	14689	14	170	170	CD
18637	14689	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14689	16	1892	1892	CD
18637	14689	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14689	18	.	.	.
18637	14690	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14690	2	240	240	CD
18637	14690	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14690	4	Baker	Baker	NNP
18637	14690	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14690	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14690	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14690	8	Morton	Morton	NNP
18637	14690	9	,	,	,
18637	14690	10	12	12	CD
18637	14690	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14690	12	.	.	.
18637	14691	1	150	150	CD
18637	14691	2	,	,	,
18637	14691	3	153	153	CD
18637	14691	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14691	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	14691	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14691	7	.	.	.
18637	14692	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14692	2	241	241	CD
18637	14692	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14692	4	Freeborn	Freeborn	NNP
18637	14692	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14692	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14692	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14692	8	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	14692	9	,	,	,
18637	14692	10	2	2	CD
18637	14692	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14692	12	.	.	.
18637	14693	1	160	160	CD
18637	14693	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14693	3	1865	1865	CD
18637	14693	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14693	5	.	.	.
18637	14694	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14694	2	242	242	CD
18637	14694	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14694	4	John	John	NNP
18637	14694	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14694	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14694	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14694	8	Paullin	Paullin	NNP
18637	14694	9	,	,	,
18637	14694	10	231	231	CD
18637	14694	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14694	12	583	583	CD
18637	14694	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14694	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	14694	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14694	16	.	.	.
18637	14695	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14695	2	243	243	CD
18637	14695	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14695	4	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
18637	14695	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14695	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14695	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14695	8	Palao	Palao	NNP
18637	14695	9	,	,	,
18637	14695	10	4	4	CD
18637	14695	11	How	how	WRB
18637	14695	12	.	.	.
18637	14696	1	589	589	CD
18637	14696	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14696	3	1846	1846	CD
18637	14696	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14696	5	.	.	.
18637	14697	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14697	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	14697	3	.	.	.
18637	14697	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14697	5	Benner	Benner	NNP
18637	14697	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14697	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14697	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14697	9	Porter	Porter	NNP
18637	14697	10	,	,	,
18637	14697	11	9	9	CD
18637	14697	12	How	how	WRB
18637	14697	13	.	.	.
18637	14698	1	235	235	CD
18637	14698	2	,	,	,
18637	14698	3	246	246	CD
18637	14698	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14698	5	1850	1850	CD
18637	14698	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14698	7	.	.	.
18637	14699	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14699	2	244	244	CD
18637	14699	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14699	4	179	179	CD
18637	14699	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14699	6	223	223	CD
18637	14699	7	,	,	,
18637	14699	8	245	245	CD
18637	14699	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14699	10	1900	1900	CD
18637	14699	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14699	12	.	.	.
18637	14700	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14700	2	245	245	CD
18637	14700	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14700	4	How	how	WRB
18637	14700	5	.	.	.
18637	14701	1	212	212	CD
18637	14701	2	,	,	,
18637	14701	3	223	223	CD
18637	14701	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14701	5	1845	1845	CD
18637	14701	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14701	7	.	.	.
18637	14702	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14702	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14702	3	also	also	RB
18637	14702	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14702	5	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	14702	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14702	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14702	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14702	9	Waddell	Waddell	NNP
18637	14702	10	,	,	,
18637	14702	11	16	16	CD
18637	14702	12	Pet	pet	NN
18637	14702	13	.	.	.
18637	14703	1	367	367	CD
18637	14703	2	,	,	,
18637	14703	3	410	410	CD
18637	14703	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14703	5	1842	1842	CD
18637	14703	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14703	7	.	.	.
18637	14704	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14704	2	246	246	CD
18637	14704	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14704	4	United	United	NNP
18637	14704	5	States	States	NNP
18637	14704	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14704	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14704	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14704	9	California	California	NNP
18637	14704	10	,	,	,
18637	14704	11	332	332	CD
18637	14704	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14704	13	19	19	CD
18637	14704	14	,	,	,
18637	14704	15	38	38	CD
18637	14704	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14704	17	1947	1947	CD
18637	14704	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14704	19	;	;	:
18637	14704	20	United	United	NNP
18637	14704	21	States	States	NNP
18637	14704	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14704	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	14704	24	_	_	NNP
18637	14704	25	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	14704	26	,	,	,
18637	14704	27	339	339	CD
18637	14704	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14704	29	699	699	CD
18637	14704	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14704	31	1950	1950	CD
18637	14704	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14704	33	.	.	.
18637	14705	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14705	2	247	247	CD
18637	14705	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14705	4	339	339	CD
18637	14705	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14705	6	707	707	CD
18637	14705	7	,	,	,
18637	14705	8	716	716	CD
18637	14705	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14705	10	1950	1950	CD
18637	14705	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14705	12	.	.	.
18637	14706	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14706	2	248	248	CD
18637	14706	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14706	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	14706	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14706	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14706	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14706	8	Grant	Grant	NNP
18637	14706	9	,	,	,
18637	14706	10	116	116	CD
18637	14706	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14706	12	207	207	CD
18637	14706	13	,	,	,
18637	14706	14	212	212	CD
18637	14706	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14706	16	1886	1886	CD
18637	14706	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14706	18	.	.	.
18637	14707	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14707	2	249	249	CD
18637	14707	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14707	4	Shively	shively	RB
18637	14707	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14707	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14707	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14707	8	Bowlby	Bowlby	NNP
18637	14707	9	,	,	,
18637	14707	10	152	152	CD
18637	14707	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14707	12	1	1	CD
18637	14707	13	,	,	,
18637	14707	14	47	47	CD
18637	14707	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14707	16	1894	1894	CD
18637	14707	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14707	18	.	.	.
18637	14708	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14708	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14708	3	also	also	RB
18637	14708	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14708	5	Joy	Joy	NNP
18637	14708	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14708	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14708	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14708	9	St.	St.	NNP
18637	14708	10	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	14708	11	,	,	,
18637	14708	12	201	201	CD
18637	14708	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14708	14	332	332	CD
18637	14708	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14708	16	1906	1906	CD
18637	14708	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14708	18	.	.	.
18637	14709	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14709	2	250	250	CD
18637	14709	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14709	4	United	United	NNP
18637	14709	5	States	States	NNP
18637	14709	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14709	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14709	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14709	9	Winans	Winans	NNP
18637	14709	10	,	,	,
18637	14709	11	198	198	CD
18637	14709	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14709	13	371	371	CD
18637	14709	14	,	,	,
18637	14709	15	378	378	CD
18637	14709	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14709	17	1905	1905	CD
18637	14709	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14709	19	;	;	:
18637	14709	20	Seufert	Seufert	NNP
18637	14709	21	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	14709	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14709	23	_	_	NNP
18637	14709	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	14709	25	_	_	NNP
18637	14709	26	United	United	NNP
18637	14709	27	States	States	NNP
18637	14709	28	,	,	,
18637	14709	29	249	249	CD
18637	14709	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14709	31	194	194	CD
18637	14709	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14709	33	1919	1919	CD
18637	14709	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14709	35	.	.	.
18637	14710	1	A	a	DT
18637	14710	2	fishing	fishing	NN
18637	14710	3	right	right	NN
18637	14710	4	granted	grant	VBN
18637	14710	5	by	by	IN
18637	14710	6	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	14710	7	to	to	IN
18637	14710	8	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	14710	9	does	do	VBZ
18637	14710	10	not	not	RB
18637	14710	11	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	14710	12	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	14710	13	the	the	DT
18637	14710	14	application	application	NN
18637	14710	15	to	to	IN
18637	14710	16	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	14710	17	of	of	IN
18637	14710	18	State	State	NNP
18637	14710	19	game	game	NN
18637	14710	20	laws	law	NNS
18637	14710	21	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	14710	22	the	the	DT
18637	14710	23	time	time	NN
18637	14710	24	and	and	CC
18637	14710	25	manner	manner	NN
18637	14710	26	of	of	IN
18637	14710	27	taking	take	VBG
18637	14710	28	fish	fish	NN
18637	14710	29	.	.	.
18637	14711	1	Kennedy	Kennedy	NNP
18637	14711	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14711	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14711	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14711	5	Becker	Becker	NNP
18637	14711	6	,	,	,
18637	14711	7	241	241	CD
18637	14711	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14711	9	556	556	CD
18637	14711	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14711	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	14711	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14711	13	.	.	.
18637	14712	1	But	but	CC
18637	14712	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14712	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	14712	4	been	be	VBN
18637	14712	5	held	hold	VBN
18637	14712	6	to	to	TO
18637	14712	7	be	be	VB
18637	14712	8	violated	violate	VBN
18637	14712	9	by	by	IN
18637	14712	10	the	the	DT
18637	14712	11	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	14712	12	of	of	IN
18637	14712	13	a	a	DT
18637	14712	14	license	license	NN
18637	14712	15	fee	fee	NN
18637	14712	16	which	which	WDT
18637	14712	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	14712	18	both	both	CC
18637	14712	19	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	14712	20	and	and	CC
18637	14712	21	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	14712	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	14712	23	producing	produce	VBG
18637	14712	24	.	.	.
18637	14713	1	Tulee	Tulee	NNP
18637	14713	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14713	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14713	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14713	5	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	14713	6	,	,	,
18637	14713	7	315	315	CD
18637	14713	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14713	9	681	681	CD
18637	14713	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14713	11	1942	1942	CD
18637	14713	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14713	13	.	.	.
18637	14714	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14714	2	251	251	CD
18637	14714	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14714	4	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	14714	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14714	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14714	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14714	8	Race	Race	NNP
18637	14714	9	Horse	Horse	NNP
18637	14714	10	,	,	,
18637	14714	11	163	163	CD
18637	14714	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14714	13	504	504	CD
18637	14714	14	,	,	,
18637	14714	15	510	510	CD
18637	14714	16	,	,	,
18637	14714	17	514	514	CD
18637	14714	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14714	19	1896	1896	CD
18637	14714	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14714	21	.	.	.
18637	14715	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14715	2	252	252	CD
18637	14715	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14715	4	14	14	CD
18637	14715	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	14715	6	.	.	.
18637	14716	1	526	526	CD
18637	14716	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14716	3	1840	1840	CD
18637	14716	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14716	5	.	.	.
18637	14717	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14717	2	253	253	CD
18637	14717	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14717	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14717	5	.	.	.
18637	14718	1	533	533	CD
18637	14718	2	,	,	,
18637	14718	3	538	538	CD
18637	14718	4	.	.	.
18637	14719	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14719	2	254	254	CD
18637	14719	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14719	4	Ashwander	Ashwander	NNP
18637	14719	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14719	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14719	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14719	8	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	14719	9	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	14719	10	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	14719	11	,	,	,
18637	14719	12	297	297	CD
18637	14719	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14719	14	288	288	CD
18637	14719	15	,	,	,
18637	14719	16	335	335	CD
18637	14719	17	-	-	SYM
18637	14719	18	340	340	CD
18637	14719	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14719	20	1936	1936	CD
18637	14719	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14719	22	.	.	.
18637	14720	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14720	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14720	3	also	also	RB
18637	14720	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14720	5	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	14720	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	14720	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14720	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14720	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	14720	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14720	11	Ickes	Ickes	NNP
18637	14720	12	,	,	,
18637	14720	13	302	302	CD
18637	14720	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14720	15	464	464	CD
18637	14720	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14720	17	1938	1938	CD
18637	14720	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14720	19	.	.	.
18637	14721	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14721	2	255	255	CD
18637	14721	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14721	4	United	United	NNP
18637	14721	5	States	States	NNP
18637	14721	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14721	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14721	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14721	9	Fitzgerald	Fitzgerald	NNP
18637	14721	10	,	,	,
18637	14721	11	15	15	CD
18637	14721	12	Pet	pet	NN
18637	14721	13	.	.	.
18637	14722	1	407	407	CD
18637	14722	2	,	,	,
18637	14722	3	521	521	CD
18637	14722	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14722	5	1841	1841	CD
18637	14722	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14722	7	.	.	.
18637	14723	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14723	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14723	3	also	also	RB
18637	14723	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14723	5	California	California	NNP
18637	14723	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14723	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14723	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14723	9	Deseret	Deseret	NNP
18637	14723	10	Water	Water	NNP
18637	14723	11	,	,	,
18637	14723	12	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	14723	13	&	&	CC
18637	14723	14	Irrig	Irrig	NNP
18637	14723	15	.	.	.
18637	14724	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14724	2	,	,	,
18637	14724	3	243	243	CD
18637	14724	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14724	5	415	415	CD
18637	14724	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14724	7	1917	1917	CD
18637	14724	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14724	9	;	;	:
18637	14724	10	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	14724	11	Power	Power	NNP
18637	14724	12	&	&	CC
18637	14724	13	Light	Light	NNP
18637	14724	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14724	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14724	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	14724	17	_	_	NNP
18637	14724	18	United	United	NNP
18637	14724	19	States	States	NNP
18637	14724	20	,	,	,
18637	14724	21	243	243	CD
18637	14724	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14724	23	389	389	CD
18637	14724	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14724	25	1917	1917	CD
18637	14724	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14724	27	.	.	.
18637	14725	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14725	2	256	256	CD
18637	14725	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14725	4	Sioux	Sioux	NNP
18637	14725	5	Tribe	Tribe	NNP
18637	14725	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14725	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14725	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14725	9	United	United	NNP
18637	14725	10	States	States	NNP
18637	14725	11	,	,	,
18637	14725	12	316	316	CD
18637	14725	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14725	14	317	317	CD
18637	14725	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14725	16	1942	1942	CD
18637	14725	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14725	18	;	;	:
18637	14725	19	United	United	NNP
18637	14725	20	States	States	NNP
18637	14725	21	_	_	NNP
18637	14725	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	14725	23	_	_	NNP
18637	14725	24	Midwest	Midwest	NNP
18637	14725	25	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	14725	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14725	27	,	,	,
18637	14725	28	236	236	CD
18637	14725	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14725	30	459	459	CD
18637	14725	31	,	,	,
18637	14725	32	469	469	CD
18637	14725	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14725	34	1915	1915	CD
18637	14725	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14725	36	.	.	.
18637	14726	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14726	2	257	257	CD
18637	14726	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14726	4	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	14726	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14726	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14726	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14726	8	Chouteau	Chouteau	NNP
18637	14726	9	,	,	,
18637	14726	10	13	13	CD
18637	14726	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14726	12	.	.	.
18637	14727	1	92	92	CD
18637	14727	2	,	,	,
18637	14727	3	99	99	CD
18637	14727	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14727	5	1872	1872	CD
18637	14727	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14727	7	;	;	:
18637	14727	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14727	9	see	see	VB
18637	14727	10	also	also	RB
18637	14727	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14727	12	Irvine	Irvine	NNP
18637	14727	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14727	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	14727	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14727	16	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	14727	17	,	,	,
18637	14727	18	20	20	CD
18637	14727	19	How	how	WRB
18637	14727	20	.	.	.
18637	14728	1	558	558	CD
18637	14728	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14728	3	1858	1858	CD
18637	14728	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14728	5	;	;	:
18637	14728	6	Emblem	Emblem	NNP
18637	14728	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14728	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14728	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14728	10	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	14728	11	Land	Land	NNP
18637	14728	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14728	13	,	,	,
18637	14728	14	184	184	CD
18637	14728	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14728	16	660	660	CD
18637	14728	17	,	,	,
18637	14728	18	664	664	CD
18637	14728	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14728	20	1902	1902	CD
18637	14728	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14728	22	.	.	.
18637	14729	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14729	2	258	258	CD
18637	14729	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14729	4	Bagnell	Bagnell	NNP
18637	14729	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14729	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14729	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14729	8	Broderick	Broderick	NNP
18637	14729	9	,	,	,
18637	14729	10	13	13	CD
18637	14729	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	14729	12	.	.	.
18637	14730	1	436	436	CD
18637	14730	2	,	,	,
18637	14730	3	450	450	CD
18637	14730	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14730	5	1839	1839	CD
18637	14730	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14730	7	.	.	.
18637	14731	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14731	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14731	3	also	also	RB
18637	14731	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14731	5	Field	Field	NNP
18637	14731	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14731	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14731	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14731	9	Seabury	Seabury	NNP
18637	14731	10	,	,	,
18637	14731	11	19	19	CD
18637	14731	12	How	how	WRB
18637	14731	13	.	.	.
18637	14732	1	323	323	CD
18637	14732	2	,	,	,
18637	14732	3	332	332	CD
18637	14732	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14732	5	1857	1857	CD
18637	14732	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14732	7	.	.	.
18637	14733	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14733	2	259	259	CD
18637	14733	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14733	4	Tameling	Tameling	NNP
18637	14733	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14733	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14733	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14733	8	United	United	NNP
18637	14733	9	States	States	NNP
18637	14733	10	Freehold	Freehold	NNP
18637	14733	11	&	&	CC
18637	14733	12	Emigration	Emigration	NNP
18637	14733	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14733	14	,	,	,
18637	14733	15	93	93	CD
18637	14733	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14733	17	644	644	CD
18637	14733	18	,	,	,
18637	14733	19	663	663	CD
18637	14733	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14733	21	1877	1877	CD
18637	14733	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14733	23	.	.	.
18637	14734	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14734	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14734	3	also	also	RB
18637	14734	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14734	5	United	United	NNP
18637	14734	6	States	States	NNP
18637	14734	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14734	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14734	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14734	10	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	14734	11	Land	Land	NNP
18637	14734	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	14734	13	Grant	Grant	NNP
18637	14734	14	and	and	CC
18637	14734	15	R.	R.	NNP
18637	14734	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14734	17	,	,	,
18637	14734	18	121	121	CD
18637	14734	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14734	20	325	325	CD
18637	14734	21	,	,	,
18637	14734	22	366	366	CD
18637	14734	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14734	24	1887	1887	CD
18637	14734	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14734	26	.	.	.
18637	14735	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14735	2	260	260	CD
18637	14735	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14735	4	Ruddy	Ruddy	NNP
18637	14735	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14735	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14735	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14735	8	Rossi	Rossi	NNP
18637	14735	9	,	,	,
18637	14735	10	248	248	CD
18637	14735	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14735	12	104	104	CD
18637	14735	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14735	14	1918	1918	CD
18637	14735	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14735	16	.	.	.
18637	14736	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14736	2	261	261	CD
18637	14736	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14736	4	Light	Light	NNP
18637	14736	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14736	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14736	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14736	8	United	United	NNP
18637	14736	9	States	States	NNP
18637	14736	10	,	,	,
18637	14736	11	220	220	CD
18637	14736	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14736	13	523	523	CD
18637	14736	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14736	15	1911	1911	CD
18637	14736	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14736	17	.	.	.
18637	14737	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14737	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14737	3	also	also	RB
18637	14737	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14737	5	Hutchings	Hutchings	NNP
18637	14737	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14737	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14737	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14737	9	Low	Low	NNP
18637	14737	10	,	,	,
18637	14737	11	15	15	CD
18637	14737	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14737	13	.	.	.
18637	14738	1	77	77	CD
18637	14738	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14738	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	14738	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14738	5	.	.	.
18637	14739	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14739	2	262	262	CD
18637	14739	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14739	4	Camfield	Camfield	NNP
18637	14739	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14739	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14739	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14739	8	United	United	NNP
18637	14739	9	States	States	NNP
18637	14739	10	,	,	,
18637	14739	11	167	167	CD
18637	14739	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14739	13	518	518	CD
18637	14739	14	,	,	,
18637	14739	15	525	525	CD
18637	14739	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14739	17	1897	1897	CD
18637	14739	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14739	19	.	.	.
18637	14740	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14740	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14740	3	also	also	RB
18637	14740	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14740	5	Jourdan	Jourdan	NNP
18637	14740	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14740	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14740	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14740	9	Barrett	Barrett	NNP
18637	14740	10	,	,	,
18637	14740	11	4	4	CD
18637	14740	12	How	how	WRB
18637	14740	13	.	.	.
18637	14741	1	169	169	CD
18637	14741	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14741	3	1846	1846	CD
18637	14741	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14741	5	;	;	:
18637	14741	6	United	United	NNP
18637	14741	7	States	States	NNP
18637	14741	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14741	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	14741	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14741	11	Waddell	Waddell	NNP
18637	14741	12	,	,	,
18637	14741	13	112	112	CD
18637	14741	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14741	15	76	76	CD
18637	14741	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14741	17	1884	1884	CD
18637	14741	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14741	19	.	.	.
18637	14742	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14742	2	263	263	CD
18637	14742	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14742	4	United	United	NNP
18637	14742	5	States	States	NNP
18637	14742	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14742	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14742	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14742	9	McGowan	McGowan	NNP
18637	14742	10	,	,	,
18637	14742	11	302	302	CD
18637	14742	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14742	13	535	535	CD
18637	14742	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14742	15	1938	1938	CD
18637	14742	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14742	17	.	.	.
18637	14743	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14743	2	264	264	CD
18637	14743	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14743	4	United	United	NNP
18637	14743	5	States	States	NNP
18637	14743	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14743	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14743	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14743	9	San	San	NNP
18637	14743	10	Francisco	Francisco	NNP
18637	14743	11	,	,	,
18637	14743	12	310	310	CD
18637	14743	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14743	14	16	16	CD
18637	14743	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14743	16	1940	1940	CD
18637	14743	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14743	18	.	.	.
18637	14744	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14744	2	265	265	CD
18637	14744	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14744	4	Van	Van	NNP
18637	14744	5	Brocklin	Brocklin	NNP
18637	14744	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14744	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14744	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14744	9	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	14744	10	,	,	,
18637	14744	11	117	117	CD
18637	14744	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14744	13	151	151	CD
18637	14744	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14744	15	1886	1886	CD
18637	14744	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14744	17	;	;	:
18637	14744	18	_	_	NNP
18637	14744	19	cf	cf	NNP
18637	14744	20	.	.	.
18637	14744	21	_	_	NNP
18637	14744	22	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	14744	23	_	_	NNP
18637	14744	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	14744	25	_	_	NNP
18637	14744	26	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	14744	27	,	,	,
18637	14744	28	327	327	CD
18637	14744	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14744	30	474	474	CD
18637	14744	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14744	32	1946	1946	CD
18637	14744	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14744	34	.	.	.
18637	14745	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14745	2	266	266	CD
18637	14745	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14745	4	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	14745	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14745	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14745	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14745	8	Chouteau	Chouteau	NNP
18637	14745	9	,	,	,
18637	14745	10	13	13	CD
18637	14745	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14745	12	92	92	CD
18637	14745	13	,	,	,
18637	14745	14	99	99	CD
18637	14745	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14745	16	1872	1872	CD
18637	14745	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14745	18	.	.	.
18637	14746	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14746	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14746	3	also	also	RB
18637	14746	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14746	5	Irvine	Irvine	NNP
18637	14746	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14746	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14746	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14746	9	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	14746	10	,	,	,
18637	14746	11	20	20	CD
18637	14746	12	How	how	WRB
18637	14746	13	.	.	.
18637	14747	1	558	558	CD
18637	14747	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14747	3	1858	1858	CD
18637	14747	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14747	5	;	;	:
18637	14747	6	Emblem	Emblem	NNP
18637	14747	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14747	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14747	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14747	10	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	14747	11	Land	Land	NNP
18637	14747	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14747	13	,	,	,
18637	14747	14	184	184	CD
18637	14747	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14747	16	660	660	CD
18637	14747	17	,	,	,
18637	14747	18	664	664	CD
18637	14747	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14747	20	1902	1902	CD
18637	14747	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14747	22	.	.	.
18637	14748	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14748	2	267	267	CD
18637	14748	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14748	4	Wilcox	Wilcox	NNP
18637	14748	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14748	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14748	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14748	8	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	14748	9	ex	ex	NNP
18637	14748	10	dem	dem	NNP
18637	14748	11	.	.	.
18637	14749	1	M'Connel	M'Connel	NNP
18637	14749	2	,	,	,
18637	14749	3	13	13	CD
18637	14749	4	Pet	pet	NN
18637	14749	5	.	.	.
18637	14750	1	498	498	CD
18637	14750	2	,	,	,
18637	14750	3	517	517	CD
18637	14750	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14750	5	1839	1839	CD
18637	14750	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14750	7	.	.	.
18637	14751	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14751	2	268	268	CD
18637	14751	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14751	4	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	14751	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14751	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14751	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14751	8	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	14751	9	,	,	,
18637	14751	10	258	258	CD
18637	14751	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14751	12	574	574	CD
18637	14751	13	,	,	,
18637	14751	14	595	595	CD
18637	14751	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14751	16	1922	1922	CD
18637	14751	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14751	18	.	.	.
18637	14752	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14752	2	269	269	CD
18637	14752	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14752	4	United	United	NNP
18637	14752	5	States	States	NNP
18637	14752	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14752	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14752	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14752	9	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	14752	10	,	,	,
18637	14752	11	295	295	CD
18637	14752	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14752	13	1	1	CD
18637	14752	14	,	,	,
18637	14752	15	28	28	CD
18637	14752	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14752	17	1935	1935	CD
18637	14752	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14752	19	.	.	.
18637	14753	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14753	2	270	270	CD
18637	14753	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14753	4	Simms	Simms	NNP
18637	14753	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14753	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14753	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14753	8	Simms	Simms	NNP
18637	14753	9	,	,	,
18637	14753	10	175	175	CD
18637	14753	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14753	12	162	162	CD
18637	14753	13	,	,	,
18637	14753	14	168	168	CD
18637	14753	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14753	16	1899	1899	CD
18637	14753	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14753	18	.	.	.
18637	14754	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14754	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14754	3	also	also	RB
18637	14754	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14754	5	United	United	NNP
18637	14754	6	States	States	NNP
18637	14754	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14754	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14754	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14754	10	McMillan	McMillan	NNP
18637	14754	11	,	,	,
18637	14754	12	165	165	CD
18637	14754	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14754	14	504	504	CD
18637	14754	15	,	,	,
18637	14754	16	510	510	CD
18637	14754	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14754	18	1897	1897	CD
18637	14754	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14754	20	;	;	:
18637	14754	21	El	El	NNP
18637	14754	22	Paso	Paso	NNP
18637	14754	23	&	&	CC
18637	14754	24	N.E.R.	N.E.R.	NNP
18637	14755	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14755	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14755	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14755	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14755	5	Gutierrez	Gutierrez	NNP
18637	14755	6	,	,	,
18637	14755	7	215	215	CD
18637	14755	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14755	9	87	87	CD
18637	14755	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14755	11	1909	1909	CD
18637	14755	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14755	13	;	;	:
18637	14755	14	First	First	NNP
18637	14755	15	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	14755	16	.	.	.
18637	14756	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	14756	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14756	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14756	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14756	5	Yankton	Yankton	NNP
18637	14756	6	County	County	NNP
18637	14756	7	,	,	,
18637	14756	8	101	101	CD
18637	14756	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14756	10	129	129	CD
18637	14756	11	,	,	,
18637	14756	12	133	133	CD
18637	14756	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14756	14	1880	1880	CD
18637	14756	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14756	16	.	.	.
18637	14757	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14757	2	271	271	CD
18637	14757	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14757	4	Binns	Binns	NNP
18637	14757	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14757	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14757	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14757	8	United	United	NNP
18637	14757	9	States	States	NNP
18637	14757	10	,	,	,
18637	14757	11	194	194	CD
18637	14757	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14757	13	486	486	CD
18637	14757	14	,	,	,
18637	14757	15	491	491	CD
18637	14757	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14757	17	1904	1904	CD
18637	14757	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14757	19	.	.	.
18637	14758	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14758	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14758	3	also	also	RB
18637	14758	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14758	5	Serè	Serè	NNP
18637	14758	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14758	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14758	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14758	9	Pitot	Pitot	NNP
18637	14758	10	,	,	,
18637	14758	11	6	6	CD
18637	14758	12	Cr	cr	NN
18637	14758	13	.	.	.
18637	14759	1	332	332	CD
18637	14759	2	,	,	,
18637	14759	3	336	336	CD
18637	14759	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14759	5	1810	1810	CD
18637	14759	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14759	7	;	;	:
18637	14759	8	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	14759	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14759	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14759	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14759	12	Ramsey	Ramsey	NNP
18637	14759	13	,	,	,
18637	14759	14	114	114	CD
18637	14759	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14759	16	15	15	CD
18637	14759	17	,	,	,
18637	14759	18	44	44	CD
18637	14759	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14759	20	1885	1885	CD
18637	14759	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14759	22	.	.	.
18637	14760	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14760	2	272	272	CD
18637	14760	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14760	4	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	14760	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14760	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14760	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14760	8	New	New	NNP
18637	14760	9	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	14760	10	&	&	CC
18637	14760	11	S.P.R.	S.P.R.	NNP
18637	14761	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14761	2	,	,	,
18637	14761	3	165	165	CD
18637	14761	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14761	5	593	593	CD
18637	14761	6	,	,	,
18637	14761	7	604	604	CD
18637	14761	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14761	9	1897	1897	CD
18637	14761	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14761	11	;	;	:
18637	14761	12	Simms	Simms	NNP
18637	14761	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14761	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	14761	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14761	16	Simms	Simms	NNP
18637	14761	17	,	,	,
18637	14761	18	175	175	CD
18637	14761	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14761	20	162	162	CD
18637	14761	21	,	,	,
18637	14761	22	163	163	CD
18637	14761	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14761	24	1899	1899	CD
18637	14761	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14761	26	;	;	:
18637	14761	27	Wagoner	Wagoner	NNP
18637	14761	28	_	_	NNP
18637	14761	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	14761	30	_	_	NNP
18637	14761	31	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	14761	32	,	,	,
18637	14761	33	170	170	CD
18637	14761	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14761	35	588	588	CD
18637	14761	36	,	,	,
18637	14761	37	591	591	CD
18637	14761	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14761	39	1898	1898	CD
18637	14761	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14761	41	.	.	.
18637	14762	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14762	2	273	273	CD
18637	14762	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14762	4	24	24	CD
18637	14762	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	14762	6	.	.	.
18637	14763	1	170	170	CD
18637	14763	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14763	3	1886	1886	CD
18637	14763	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14763	5	.	.	.
18637	14764	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14764	2	274	274	CD
18637	14764	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14764	4	Downes	Downes	NNPS
18637	14764	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14764	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14764	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14764	8	Bidwell	Bidwell	NNP
18637	14764	9	,	,	,
18637	14764	10	182	182	CD
18637	14764	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14764	12	244	244	CD
18637	14764	13	,	,	,
18637	14764	14	271	271	CD
18637	14764	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14764	16	1901	1901	CD
18637	14764	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14764	18	.	.	.
18637	14765	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14765	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14765	3	also	also	RB
18637	14765	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14765	5	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	14765	6	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	14765	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	14765	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14765	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	14765	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14765	11	United	United	NNP
18637	14765	12	States	States	NNP
18637	14765	13	ex	ex	NNP
18637	14765	14	rel	rel	NN
18637	14765	15	.	.	.
18637	14766	1	Humboldt	Humboldt	NNP
18637	14766	2	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	14766	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14766	4	,	,	,
18637	14766	5	224	224	CD
18637	14766	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14766	7	474	474	CD
18637	14766	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14766	9	1912	1912	CD
18637	14766	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14766	11	;	;	:
18637	14766	12	Church	Church	NNP
18637	14766	13	of	of	IN
18637	14766	14	Jesus	Jesus	NNP
18637	14766	15	Christ	Christ	NNP
18637	14766	16	of	of	IN
18637	14766	17	L.D.S.	L.D.S.	NNP
18637	14767	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14767	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	14767	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14767	4	United	United	NNP
18637	14767	5	States	States	NNP
18637	14767	6	,	,	,
18637	14767	7	136	136	CD
18637	14767	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14767	9	1	1	CD
18637	14767	10	,	,	,
18637	14767	11	44	44	CD
18637	14767	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14767	13	1890	1890	CD
18637	14767	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14767	15	.	.	.
18637	14768	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14768	2	275	275	CD
18637	14768	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14768	4	Dorr	Dorr	NNP
18637	14768	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14768	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14768	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14768	8	United	United	NNP
18637	14768	9	States	States	NNP
18637	14768	10	,	,	,
18637	14768	11	195	195	CD
18637	14768	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14768	13	138	138	CD
18637	14768	14	,	,	,
18637	14768	15	149	149	CD
18637	14768	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14768	17	1904	1904	CD
18637	14768	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14768	19	.	.	.
18637	14769	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14769	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14769	3	also	also	RB
18637	14769	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14769	5	Balzac	Balzac	NNP
18637	14769	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14769	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14769	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14769	9	Porto	Porto	NNP
18637	14769	10	Rico	Rico	NNP
18637	14769	11	,	,	,
18637	14769	12	258	258	CD
18637	14769	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14769	14	298	298	CD
18637	14769	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14769	16	1922	1922	CD
18637	14769	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14769	18	.	.	.
18637	14770	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14770	2	276	276	CD
18637	14770	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14770	4	Rassmussen	Rassmussen	NNP
18637	14770	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14770	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14770	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14770	8	United	United	NNP
18637	14770	9	States	States	NNP
18637	14770	10	,	,	,
18637	14770	11	197	197	CD
18637	14770	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14770	13	516	516	CD
18637	14770	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14770	15	1905	1905	CD
18637	14770	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14770	17	.	.	.
18637	14771	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14771	2	277	277	CD
18637	14771	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14771	4	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	14771	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14771	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14771	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14771	8	Mankichi	Mankichi	NNP
18637	14771	9	,	,	,
18637	14771	10	190	190	CD
18637	14771	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14771	12	197	197	CD
18637	14771	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14771	14	1903	1903	CD
18637	14771	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14771	16	;	;	:
18637	14771	17	R.M.C.	R.M.C.	NNP
18637	14772	1	Littler	Littler	NNP
18637	14772	2	,	,	,
18637	14772	3	The	the	DT
18637	14772	4	Governance	Governance	NNP
18637	14772	5	of	of	IN
18637	14772	6	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	14772	7	,	,	,
18637	14772	8	Chap	Chap	NNP
18637	14772	9	.	.	.
18637	14773	1	III	III	NNP
18637	14773	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14773	3	1929	1929	CD
18637	14773	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14773	5	.	.	.
18637	14774	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14774	2	278	278	CD
18637	14774	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14774	4	American	American	NNP
18637	14774	5	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14774	6	.	.	.
18637	14775	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14775	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14775	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14775	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14775	5	Canter	Canter	NNP
18637	14775	6	,	,	,
18637	14775	7	1	1	CD
18637	14775	8	Pet	pet	NN
18637	14775	9	.	.	.
18637	14776	1	511	511	CD
18637	14776	2	,	,	,
18637	14776	3	546	546	CD
18637	14776	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14776	5	1828	1828	CD
18637	14776	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14776	7	.	.	.
18637	14777	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14777	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14777	3	also	also	RB
18637	14777	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14777	5	Romeu	Romeu	NNP
18637	14777	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14777	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14777	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14777	9	Todd	Todd	NNP
18637	14777	10	,	,	,
18637	14777	11	206	206	CD
18637	14777	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14777	13	358	358	CD
18637	14777	14	,	,	,
18637	14777	15	368	368	CD
18637	14777	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14777	17	1907	1907	CD
18637	14777	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14777	19	;	;	:
18637	14777	20	United	United	NNP
18637	14777	21	States	States	NNP
18637	14777	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14777	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	14777	24	_	_	NNP
18637	14777	25	McMillan	McMillan	NNP
18637	14777	26	,	,	,
18637	14777	27	165	165	CD
18637	14777	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14777	29	504	504	CD
18637	14777	30	,	,	,
18637	14777	31	510	510	CD
18637	14777	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14777	33	1897	1897	CD
18637	14777	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14777	35	;	;	:
18637	14777	36	McAllister	McAllister	NNP
18637	14777	37	_	_	NNP
18637	14777	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	14777	39	_	_	NNP
18637	14777	40	United	United	NNP
18637	14777	41	States	States	NNP
18637	14777	42	,	,	,
18637	14777	43	141	141	CD
18637	14777	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14777	45	174	174	CD
18637	14777	46	,	,	,
18637	14777	47	180	180	CD
18637	14777	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14777	49	1891	1891	CD
18637	14777	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14777	51	;	;	:
18637	14777	52	The	the	DT
18637	14777	53	"	"	``
18637	14777	54	City	City	NNP
18637	14777	55	of	of	IN
18637	14777	56	Panama	Panama	NNP
18637	14777	57	"	"	''
18637	14777	58	_	_	NNP
18637	14777	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	14777	60	_	_	NNP
18637	14777	61	Phelps	Phelps	NNP
18637	14777	62	,	,	,
18637	14777	63	101	101	CD
18637	14777	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14777	65	453	453	CD
18637	14777	66	,	,	,
18637	14777	67	460	460	CD
18637	14777	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14777	69	1880	1880	CD
18637	14777	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14777	71	;	;	:
18637	14777	72	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	14777	73	_	_	NNP
18637	14777	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	14777	75	_	_	NNP
18637	14777	76	United	United	NNP
18637	14777	77	States	States	NNP
18637	14777	78	,	,	,
18637	14777	79	98	98	CD
18637	14777	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14777	81	145	145	CD
18637	14777	82	,	,	,
18637	14777	83	154	154	CD
18637	14777	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14777	85	1879	1879	CD
18637	14777	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14777	87	;	;	:
18637	14777	88	Hornbuckle	Hornbuckle	NNP
18637	14777	89	_	_	NNP
18637	14777	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	14777	91	_	_	NNP
18637	14777	92	Toombs	Toombs	NNP
18637	14777	93	,	,	,
18637	14777	94	18	18	CD
18637	14777	95	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14777	96	.	.	.
18637	14778	1	648	648	CD
18637	14778	2	,	,	,
18637	14778	3	655	655	CD
18637	14778	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14778	5	1874	1874	CD
18637	14778	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14778	7	;	;	:
18637	14778	8	Clinton	Clinton	NNP
18637	14778	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14778	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	14778	11	_	_	NNP
18637	14778	12	Englebrecht	Englebrecht	NNP
18637	14778	13	,	,	,
18637	14778	14	13	13	CD
18637	14778	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14778	16	.	.	.
18637	14779	1	434	434	CD
18637	14779	2	,	,	,
18637	14779	3	447	447	CD
18637	14779	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14779	5	1872	1872	CD
18637	14779	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14779	7	.	.	.
18637	14780	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14780	2	279	279	CD
18637	14780	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14780	4	American	American	NNP
18637	14780	5	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	14780	6	.	.	.
18637	14781	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14781	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14781	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14781	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14781	5	Canter	Canter	NNP
18637	14781	6	,	,	,
18637	14781	7	1	1	CD
18637	14781	8	Pet	pet	NN
18637	14781	9	.	.	.
18637	14782	1	511	511	CD
18637	14782	2	,	,	,
18637	14782	3	545	545	CD
18637	14782	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14782	5	1828	1828	CD
18637	14782	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14782	7	.	.	.
18637	14783	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14783	2	280	280	CD
18637	14783	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14783	4	7	7	CD
18637	14783	5	How	how	WRB
18637	14783	6	.	.	.
18637	14784	1	1	1	CD
18637	14784	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14784	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	14784	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14784	5	.	.	.
18637	14785	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14785	2	281	281	CD
18637	14785	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14785	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14785	5	.	.	.
18637	14786	1	42	42	CD
18637	14786	2	.	.	.
18637	14787	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14787	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14787	3	also	also	RB
18637	14787	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14787	5	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	14787	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	14787	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	14787	8	.	.	.
18637	14788	1	Bryant	Bryant	NNP
18637	14788	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14788	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14788	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14788	5	Akron	Akron	NNP
18637	14788	6	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
18637	14788	7	Park	Park	NNP
18637	14788	8	District	District	NNP
18637	14788	9	,	,	,
18637	14788	10	281	281	CD
18637	14788	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14788	12	74	74	CD
18637	14788	13	,	,	,
18637	14788	14	80	80	CD
18637	14788	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14788	16	1930	1930	CD
18637	14788	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14788	18	;	;	:
18637	14788	19	Mountain	Mountain	NNP
18637	14788	20	Timber	Timber	NNP
18637	14788	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14788	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14788	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	14788	24	_	_	NNP
18637	14788	25	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	14788	26	,	,	,
18637	14788	27	243	243	CD
18637	14788	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14788	29	219	219	CD
18637	14788	30	,	,	,
18637	14788	31	234	234	CD
18637	14788	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14788	33	1917	1917	CD
18637	14788	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14788	35	.	.	.
18637	14789	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14789	2	282	282	CD
18637	14789	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14789	4	7	7	CD
18637	14789	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14789	6	.	.	.
18637	14790	1	700	700	CD
18637	14790	2	,	,	,
18637	14790	3	729	729	CD
18637	14790	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14790	5	1869	1869	CD
18637	14790	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14790	7	.	.	.
18637	14791	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14791	2	283	283	CD
18637	14791	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14791	4	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	14791	5	States	States	NNP
18637	14791	6	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	14791	7	.	.	.
18637	14792	1	&	&	CC
18637	14792	2	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	14792	3	.	.	.
18637	14793	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	14793	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14793	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14793	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14793	5	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	14793	6	,	,	,
18637	14793	7	223	223	CD
18637	14793	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14793	9	118	118	CD
18637	14793	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14793	11	1912	1912	CD
18637	14793	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14793	13	;	;	:
18637	14793	14	Kiernan	Kiernan	NNP
18637	14793	15	_	_	NNP
18637	14793	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	14793	17	_	_	NNP
18637	14793	18	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	14793	19	,	,	,
18637	14793	20	223	223	CD
18637	14793	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14793	22	151	151	CD
18637	14793	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14793	24	1912	1912	CD
18637	14793	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14793	26	;	;	:
18637	14793	27	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	14793	28	ex	ex	NNP
18637	14793	29	rel	rel	NN
18637	14793	30	.	.	.
18637	14794	1	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	14794	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14794	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14794	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14794	5	Hildebrant	Hildebrant	NNP
18637	14794	6	,	,	,
18637	14794	7	241	241	CD
18637	14794	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14794	9	565	565	CD
18637	14794	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14794	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	14794	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14794	13	.	.	.
18637	14795	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14795	2	284	284	CD
18637	14795	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14795	4	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	14795	5	ex	ex	NNP
18637	14795	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	14795	7	.	.	.
18637	14796	1	Bryant	Bryant	NNP
18637	14796	2	_	_	NNP
18637	14796	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	14796	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14796	5	Akron	Akron	NNP
18637	14796	6	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
18637	14796	7	Park	Park	NNP
18637	14796	8	District	District	NNP
18637	14796	9	,	,	,
18637	14796	10	281	281	CD
18637	14796	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14796	12	74	74	CD
18637	14796	13	,	,	,
18637	14796	14	80	80	CD
18637	14796	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14796	16	1930	1930	CD
18637	14796	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14796	18	;	;	:
18637	14796	19	O'Neill	O'Neill	NNP
18637	14796	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14796	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	14796	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14796	23	Leamer	Leamer	NNP
18637	14796	24	,	,	,
18637	14796	25	239	239	CD
18637	14796	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14796	27	244	244	CD
18637	14796	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14796	29	1915	1915	CD
18637	14796	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14796	31	;	;	:
18637	14796	32	Highland	Highland	NNP
18637	14796	33	Farms	Farms	NNP
18637	14796	34	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
18637	14796	35	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	14796	36	_	_	NNP
18637	14796	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	14796	38	_	_	NNP
18637	14796	39	Agnew	Agnew	NNP
18637	14796	40	,	,	,
18637	14796	41	300	300	CD
18637	14796	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14796	43	608	608	CD
18637	14796	44	,	,	,
18637	14796	45	612	612	CD
18637	14796	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14796	47	1937	1937	CD
18637	14796	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14796	49	;	;	:
18637	14796	50	Forsyth	Forsyth	NNP
18637	14796	51	_	_	NNP
18637	14796	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	14796	53	_	_	NNP
18637	14796	54	Hammond	Hammond	NNP
18637	14796	55	,	,	,
18637	14796	56	166	166	CD
18637	14796	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14796	58	506	506	CD
18637	14796	59	,	,	,
18637	14796	60	519	519	CD
18637	14796	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14796	62	1897	1897	CD
18637	14796	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14796	64	.	.	.
18637	14797	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14797	2	285	285	CD
18637	14797	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14797	4	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	14797	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14797	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14797	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14797	8	Beckham	Beckham	NNP
18637	14797	9	,	,	,
18637	14797	10	178	178	CD
18637	14797	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14797	12	548	548	CD
18637	14797	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14797	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	14797	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14797	16	.	.	.
18637	14798	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14798	2	See	See	NNP
18637	14798	3	also	also	RB
18637	14798	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14798	5	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	14798	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14798	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14798	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14798	9	Dye	Dye	NNP
18637	14798	10	,	,	,
18637	14798	11	231	231	CD
18637	14798	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14798	13	250	250	CD
18637	14798	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14798	15	1914	1914	CD
18637	14798	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14798	17	.	.	.
18637	14799	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14799	2	286	286	CD
18637	14799	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14799	4	Minor	Minor	NNP
18637	14799	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14799	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14799	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14799	8	Happersett	Happersett	NNP
18637	14799	9	,	,	,
18637	14799	10	21	21	CD
18637	14799	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	14799	12	.	.	.
18637	14800	1	162	162	CD
18637	14800	2	,	,	,
18637	14800	3	175	175	CD
18637	14800	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14800	5	1875	1875	CD
18637	14800	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14800	7	.	.	.
18637	14801	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14801	2	287	287	CD
18637	14801	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14801	4	7	7	CD
18637	14801	5	How	how	WRB
18637	14801	6	.	.	.
18637	14802	1	1	1	CD
18637	14802	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14802	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	14802	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14802	5	.	.	.
18637	14803	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14803	2	288	288	CD
18637	14803	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14803	4	1	1	CD
18637	14803	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	14803	6	.	.	.
18637	14804	1	424	424	CD
18637	14804	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14804	3	1795	1795	CD
18637	14804	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14804	5	.	.	.
18637	14805	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14805	2	289	289	CD
18637	14805	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14805	4	7	7	CD
18637	14805	5	How	how	WRB
18637	14805	6	.	.	.
18637	14806	1	1	1	CD
18637	14806	2	,	,	,
18637	14806	3	43	43	CD
18637	14806	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14806	5	1849	1849	CD
18637	14806	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14806	7	.	.	.
18637	14807	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14807	2	290	290	CD
18637	14807	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14807	4	158	158	CD
18637	14807	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14807	6	564	564	CD
18637	14807	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14807	8	1895	1895	CD
18637	14807	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14807	10	.	.	.
18637	14808	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14808	2	291	291	CD
18637	14808	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14808	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14808	5	.	.	.
18637	14809	1	582	582	CD
18637	14809	2	.	.	.
18637	14810	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14810	2	292	292	CD
18637	14810	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14810	4	On	on	IN
18637	14810	5	the	the	DT
18637	14810	6	decline	decline	NN
18637	14810	7	in	in	IN
18637	14810	8	observance	observance	NN
18637	14810	9	of	of	IN
18637	14810	10	the	the	DT
18637	14810	11	formalities	formality	NNS
18637	14810	12	required	require	VBN
18637	14810	13	by	by	IN
18637	14810	14	the	the	DT
18637	14810	15	provision	provision	NN
18637	14810	16	both	both	CC
18637	14810	17	before	before	IN
18637	14810	18	and	and	CC
18637	14810	19	during	during	IN
18637	14810	20	World	World	NNP
18637	14810	21	War	War	NNP
18637	14810	22	I	I	NNP
18637	14810	23	,	,	,
18637	14810	24	_	_	NNP
18637	14810	25	see	see	VBP
18637	14810	26	_	_	NNP
18637	14810	27	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	14810	28	,	,	,
18637	14810	29	The	the	DT
18637	14810	30	President	President	NNP
18637	14810	31	,	,	,
18637	14810	32	Office	Office	NNP
18637	14810	33	and	and	CC
18637	14810	34	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	14810	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14810	36	3d	3d	NNP
18637	14810	37	ed	ed	NNP
18637	14810	38	.	.	NNP
18637	14810	39	,	,	,
18637	14810	40	1948	1948	CD
18637	14810	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14810	42	,	,	,
18637	14810	43	164	164	CD
18637	14810	44	-	-	SYM
18637	14810	45	166	166	CD
18637	14810	46	.	.	.
18637	14811	1	ARTICLE	article	NN
18637	14811	2	V	v	NN
18637	14811	3	MODE	mode	NN
18637	14811	4	OF	of	IN
18637	14811	5	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	14811	6	Page	Page	NNP
18637	14811	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	14811	8	of	of	IN
18637	14811	9	the	the	DT
18637	14811	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14811	11	711	711	CD
18637	14811	12	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	14811	13	of	of	IN
18637	14811	14	the	the	DT
18637	14811	15	amending	amend	VBG
18637	14811	16	power	power	NN
18637	14811	17	711	711	CD
18637	14811	18	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	14811	19	of	of	IN
18637	14811	20	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	14811	21	712	712	CD
18637	14811	22	Submission	Submission	NNP
18637	14811	23	of	of	IN
18637	14811	24	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14811	25	712	712	CD
18637	14811	26	Ratification	Ratification	NNP
18637	14811	27	712	712	NNP
18637	14811	28	Authentication	Authentication	NNP
18637	14811	29	and	and	CC
18637	14811	30	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	14811	31	713	713	CD
18637	14811	32	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	14811	33	review	review	NN
18637	14811	34	under	under	IN
18637	14811	35	article	article	NN
18637	14811	36	V	V	NNP
18637	14811	37	714	714	CD
18637	14811	38	MODE	MODE	NNP
18637	14811	39	OF	of	IN
18637	14811	40	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	14811	41	Article	Article	NNP
18637	14811	42	V	v	NN
18637	14811	43	The	the	DT
18637	14811	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14811	45	,	,	,
18637	14811	46	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	14811	47	two	two	CD
18637	14811	48	thirds	third	NNS
18637	14811	49	of	of	IN
18637	14811	50	both	both	DT
18637	14811	51	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	14811	52	shall	shall	MD
18637	14811	53	deem	deem	VB
18637	14811	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14811	55	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	14811	56	,	,	,
18637	14811	57	shall	shall	MD
18637	14811	58	propose	propose	VB
18637	14811	59	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	14811	60	to	to	IN
18637	14811	61	this	this	DT
18637	14811	62	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14811	63	,	,	,
18637	14811	64	or	or	CC
18637	14811	65	,	,	,
18637	14811	66	on	on	IN
18637	14811	67	the	the	DT
18637	14811	68	Application	Application	NNP
18637	14811	69	of	of	IN
18637	14811	70	the	the	DT
18637	14811	71	Legislatures	Legislatures	NNPS
18637	14811	72	of	of	IN
18637	14811	73	two	two	CD
18637	14811	74	thirds	third	NNS
18637	14811	75	of	of	IN
18637	14811	76	the	the	DT
18637	14811	77	several	several	JJ
18637	14811	78	States	States	NNPS
18637	14811	79	,	,	,
18637	14811	80	shall	shall	MD
18637	14811	81	call	call	VB
18637	14811	82	a	a	DT
18637	14811	83	Convention	convention	NN
18637	14811	84	for	for	IN
18637	14811	85	proposing	propose	VBG
18637	14811	86	Amendments	Amendments	NNP
18637	14811	87	,	,	,
18637	14811	88	which	which	WDT
18637	14811	89	,	,	,
18637	14811	90	in	in	IN
18637	14811	91	either	either	DT
18637	14811	92	Case	Case	NNP
18637	14811	93	,	,	,
18637	14811	94	shall	shall	MD
18637	14811	95	be	be	VB
18637	14811	96	valid	valid	JJ
18637	14811	97	to	to	IN
18637	14811	98	all	all	DT
18637	14811	99	Intents	Intents	NNPS
18637	14811	100	and	and	CC
18637	14811	101	Purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	14811	102	,	,	,
18637	14811	103	as	as	IN
18637	14811	104	Part	part	NN
18637	14811	105	of	of	IN
18637	14811	106	this	this	DT
18637	14811	107	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14811	108	,	,	,
18637	14811	109	when	when	WRB
18637	14811	110	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	14811	111	by	by	IN
18637	14811	112	the	the	DT
18637	14811	113	Legislatures	Legislatures	NNPS
18637	14811	114	of	of	IN
18637	14811	115	three	three	CD
18637	14811	116	fourths	fourth	NNS
18637	14811	117	of	of	IN
18637	14811	118	the	the	DT
18637	14811	119	several	several	JJ
18637	14811	120	States	States	NNPS
18637	14811	121	,	,	,
18637	14811	122	or	or	CC
18637	14811	123	by	by	IN
18637	14811	124	Conventions	convention	NNS
18637	14811	125	in	in	IN
18637	14811	126	three	three	CD
18637	14811	127	fourths	fourth	NNS
18637	14811	128	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	14811	129	,	,	,
18637	14811	130	as	as	IN
18637	14811	131	the	the	DT
18637	14811	132	one	one	CD
18637	14811	133	or	or	CC
18637	14811	134	the	the	DT
18637	14811	135	other	other	JJ
18637	14811	136	Mode	Mode	NNP
18637	14811	137	of	of	IN
18637	14811	138	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	14811	139	may	may	MD
18637	14811	140	be	be	VB
18637	14811	141	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	14811	142	by	by	IN
18637	14811	143	the	the	DT
18637	14811	144	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14811	145	;	;	:
18637	14811	146	Provided	provide	VBN
18637	14811	147	that	that	IN
18637	14811	148	no	no	DT
18637	14811	149	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	14811	150	which	which	WDT
18637	14811	151	may	may	MD
18637	14811	152	be	be	VB
18637	14811	153	made	make	VBN
18637	14811	154	prior	prior	RB
18637	14811	155	to	to	IN
18637	14811	156	the	the	DT
18637	14811	157	Year	Year	NNP
18637	14811	158	One	one	CD
18637	14811	159	thousand	thousand	CD
18637	14811	160	eight	eight	CD
18637	14811	161	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	14811	162	and	and	CC
18637	14811	163	eight	eight	CD
18637	14811	164	shall	shall	NN
18637	14811	165	in	in	IN
18637	14811	166	any	any	DT
18637	14811	167	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	14811	168	affect	affect	VB
18637	14811	169	the	the	DT
18637	14811	170	first	first	JJ
18637	14811	171	and	and	CC
18637	14811	172	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	14811	173	Clauses	clause	NNS
18637	14811	174	in	in	IN
18637	14811	175	the	the	DT
18637	14811	176	Ninth	Ninth	NNP
18637	14811	177	Section	Section	NNP
18637	14811	178	of	of	IN
18637	14811	179	the	the	DT
18637	14811	180	first	first	JJ
18637	14811	181	Article	article	NN
18637	14811	182	;	;	:
18637	14811	183	and	and	CC
18637	14811	184	that	that	IN
18637	14811	185	no	no	DT
18637	14811	186	State	State	NNP
18637	14811	187	,	,	,
18637	14811	188	without	without	IN
18637	14811	189	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14811	190	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	14811	191	,	,	,
18637	14811	192	shall	shall	MD
18637	14811	193	be	be	VB
18637	14811	194	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	14811	195	of	of	IN
18637	14811	196	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14811	197	equal	equal	JJ
18637	14811	198	Suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	14811	199	in	in	IN
18637	14811	200	the	the	DT
18637	14811	201	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	14811	202	.	.	.
18637	14812	1	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14812	2	of	of	IN
18637	14812	3	the	the	DT
18637	14812	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14812	5	SCOPE	SCOPE	NNP
18637	14812	6	OF	of	IN
18637	14812	7	AMENDING	amending	JJ
18637	14812	8	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	14812	9	When	when	WRB
18637	14812	10	this	this	DT
18637	14812	11	Article	article	NN
18637	14812	12	was	be	VBD
18637	14812	13	before	before	IN
18637	14812	14	the	the	DT
18637	14812	15	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	14812	16	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	14812	17	,	,	,
18637	14812	18	a	a	DT
18637	14812	19	motion	motion	NN
18637	14812	20	to	to	TO
18637	14812	21	insert	insert	VB
18637	14812	22	a	a	DT
18637	14812	23	provision	provision	NN
18637	14812	24	that	that	IN
18637	14812	25	"	"	``
18637	14812	26	no	no	DT
18637	14812	27	State	state	NN
18637	14812	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	14812	29	without	without	IN
18637	14812	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14812	31	consent	consent	NN
18637	14812	32	be	be	VB
18637	14812	33	affected	affect	VBN
18637	14812	34	in	in	IN
18637	14812	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14812	36	internal	internal	JJ
18637	14812	37	policy	policy	NN
18637	14812	38	"	"	''
18637	14812	39	was	be	VBD
18637	14812	40	made	make	VBN
18637	14812	41	and	and	CC
18637	14812	42	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	14812	43	.	.	.
18637	14813	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14813	2	1	1	LS
18637	14813	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14813	4	A	a	DT
18637	14813	5	further	further	JJ
18637	14813	6	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	14813	7	to	to	TO
18637	14813	8	impose	impose	VB
18637	14813	9	a	a	DT
18637	14813	10	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	14813	11	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	14813	12	on	on	IN
18637	14813	13	the	the	DT
18637	14813	14	amending	amend	VBG
18637	14813	15	power	power	NN
18637	14813	16	was	be	VBD
18637	14813	17	made	make	VBN
18637	14813	18	in	in	IN
18637	14813	19	1861	1861	CD
18637	14813	20	,	,	,
18637	14813	21	when	when	WRB
18637	14813	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14813	23	submitted	submit	VBD
18637	14813	24	to	to	IN
18637	14813	25	the	the	DT
18637	14813	26	States	States	NNP
18637	14813	27	a	a	DT
18637	14813	28	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	14813	29	to	to	TO
18637	14813	30	bar	bar	VB
18637	14813	31	any	any	DT
18637	14813	32	future	future	JJ
18637	14813	33	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	14813	34	which	which	WDT
18637	14813	35	would	would	MD
18637	14813	36	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	14813	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14813	38	to	to	TO
18637	14813	39	"	"	``
18637	14813	40	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	14813	41	,	,	,
18637	14813	42	within	within	IN
18637	14813	43	any	any	DT
18637	14813	44	State	State	NNP
18637	14813	45	,	,	,
18637	14813	46	with	with	IN
18637	14813	47	the	the	DT
18637	14813	48	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	14813	49	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	14813	50	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	14813	51	,	,	,
18637	14813	52	*	*	NFP
18637	14813	53	*	*	NFP
18637	14813	54	*	*	NFP
18637	14813	55	.	.	.
18637	14814	1	"	"	``
18637	14814	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14814	3	2	2	CD
18637	14814	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14814	5	Three	Three	NNP
18637	14814	6	States	States	NNPS
18637	14814	7	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	14814	8	this	this	DT
18637	14814	9	article	article	NN
18637	14814	10	before	before	IN
18637	14814	11	the	the	DT
18637	14814	12	outbreak	outbreak	NN
18637	14814	13	of	of	IN
18637	14814	14	the	the	DT
18637	14814	15	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	14814	16	War	War	NNP
18637	14814	17	made	make	VBD
18637	14814	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14814	19	academic	academic	JJ
18637	14814	20	.	.	.
18637	14815	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14815	2	3	3	LS
18637	14815	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14815	4	Many	many	JJ
18637	14815	5	years	year	NNS
18637	14815	6	later	later	RB
18637	14815	7	the	the	DT
18637	14815	8	validity	validity	NN
18637	14815	9	of	of	IN
18637	14815	10	both	both	CC
18637	14815	11	the	the	DT
18637	14815	12	Eighteenth	Eighteenth	NNP
18637	14815	13	and	and	CC
18637	14815	14	Nineteenth	Nineteenth	NNP
18637	14815	15	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	14815	16	was	be	VBD
18637	14815	17	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	14815	18	because	because	IN
18637	14815	19	of	of	IN
18637	14815	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14815	21	content	content	NN
18637	14815	22	.	.	.
18637	14816	1	The	the	DT
18637	14816	2	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	14816	3	against	against	IN
18637	14816	4	the	the	DT
18637	14816	5	former	former	JJ
18637	14816	6	took	take	VBD
18637	14816	7	a	a	DT
18637	14816	8	wide	wide	JJ
18637	14816	9	range	range	NN
18637	14816	10	.	.	.
18637	14817	1	Counsel	counsel	NN
18637	14817	2	urged	urge	VBD
18637	14817	3	that	that	IN
18637	14817	4	the	the	DT
18637	14817	5	power	power	NN
18637	14817	6	of	of	IN
18637	14817	7	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14817	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	14817	9	limited	limit	VBN
18637	14817	10	to	to	IN
18637	14817	11	the	the	DT
18637	14817	12	correction	correction	NN
18637	14817	13	of	of	IN
18637	14817	14	errors	error	NNS
18637	14817	15	in	in	IN
18637	14817	16	the	the	DT
18637	14817	17	framing	framing	NN
18637	14817	18	of	of	IN
18637	14817	19	the	the	DT
18637	14817	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14817	21	;	;	:
18637	14817	22	that	that	IN
18637	14817	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14817	24	does	do	VBZ
18637	14817	25	not	not	RB
18637	14817	26	comprehend	comprehend	VB
18637	14817	27	the	the	DT
18637	14817	28	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	14817	29	of	of	IN
18637	14817	30	additional	additional	JJ
18637	14817	31	or	or	CC
18637	14817	32	supplementary	supplementary	JJ
18637	14817	33	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	14817	34	.	.	.
18637	14818	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14818	2	contended	contend	VBD
18637	14818	3	further	further	RB
18637	14818	4	that	that	DT
18637	14818	5	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	14818	6	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	14818	7	can	can	MD
18637	14818	8	not	not	RB
18637	14818	9	be	be	VB
18637	14818	10	embodied	embody	VBN
18637	14818	11	in	in	IN
18637	14818	12	a	a	DT
18637	14818	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	14818	14	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14818	15	and	and	CC
18637	14818	16	that	that	IN
18637	14818	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14818	18	can	can	MD
18637	14818	19	not	not	RB
18637	14818	20	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	14818	21	propose	propose	VB
18637	14818	22	any	any	DT
18637	14818	23	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14818	24	which	which	WDT
18637	14818	25	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	14818	26	the	the	DT
18637	14818	27	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	14818	28	or	or	CC
18637	14818	29	relinquishment	relinquishment	NN
18637	14818	30	of	of	IN
18637	14818	31	the	the	DT
18637	14818	32	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	14818	33	powers	power	NNS
18637	14818	34	of	of	IN
18637	14818	35	a	a	DT
18637	14818	36	State	state	NN
18637	14818	37	.	.	.
18637	14819	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14819	2	4	4	LS
18637	14819	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14819	4	The	the	DT
18637	14819	5	Nineteenth	Nineteenth	NNP
18637	14819	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	14819	7	was	be	VBD
18637	14819	8	attacked	attack	VBN
18637	14819	9	on	on	IN
18637	14819	10	the	the	DT
18637	14819	11	narrower	narrow	JJR
18637	14819	12	ground	ground	NN
18637	14819	13	that	that	IN
18637	14819	14	a	a	DT
18637	14819	15	State	state	NN
18637	14819	16	which	which	WDT
18637	14819	17	had	have	VBD
18637	14819	18	not	not	RB
18637	14819	19	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	14819	20	the	the	DT
18637	14819	21	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14819	22	would	would	MD
18637	14819	23	be	be	VB
18637	14819	24	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	14819	25	of	of	IN
18637	14819	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14819	27	equal	equal	JJ
18637	14819	28	suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	14819	29	in	in	IN
18637	14819	30	the	the	DT
18637	14819	31	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	14819	32	because	because	IN
18637	14819	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14819	34	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	14819	35	in	in	IN
18637	14819	36	that	that	DT
18637	14819	37	body	body	NN
18637	14819	38	would	would	MD
18637	14819	39	be	be	VB
18637	14819	40	persons	person	NNS
18637	14819	41	not	not	RB
18637	14819	42	of	of	IN
18637	14819	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14819	44	choosing	choosing	NN
18637	14819	45	,	,	,
18637	14819	46	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	14819	47	,	,	,
18637	14819	48	persons	person	NNS
18637	14819	49	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	14819	50	by	by	IN
18637	14819	51	voters	voter	NNS
18637	14819	52	whom	whom	WP
18637	14819	53	the	the	DT
18637	14819	54	State	State	NNP
18637	14819	55	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14819	56	had	have	VBD
18637	14819	57	not	not	RB
18637	14819	58	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	14819	59	to	to	TO
18637	14819	60	vote	vote	VB
18637	14819	61	for	for	IN
18637	14819	62	Senators	senator	NNS
18637	14819	63	.	.	.
18637	14820	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14820	2	5	5	LS
18637	14820	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14820	4	Brushing	brush	VBG
18637	14820	5	aside	aside	RB
18637	14820	6	these	these	DT
18637	14820	7	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	14820	8	as	as	IN
18637	14820	9	unworthy	unworthy	JJ
18637	14820	10	of	of	IN
18637	14820	11	serious	serious	JJ
18637	14820	12	attention	attention	NN
18637	14820	13	,	,	,
18637	14820	14	the	the	DT
18637	14820	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14820	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14820	17	held	hold	VBD
18637	14820	18	both	both	DT
18637	14820	19	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	14820	20	valid	valid	JJ
18637	14820	21	.	.	.
18637	14821	1	PROCEDURE	PROCEDURE	NNP
18637	14821	2	OF	of	IN
18637	14821	3	ADOPTION	ADOPTION	NNP
18637	14821	4	Submission	Submission	NNP
18637	14821	5	of	of	IN
18637	14821	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	14821	7	When	when	WRB
18637	14821	8	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	14821	9	submitted	submit	VBD
18637	14821	10	to	to	IN
18637	14821	11	the	the	DT
18637	14821	12	House	House	NNP
18637	14821	13	of	of	IN
18637	14821	14	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	14821	15	the	the	DT
18637	14821	16	proposals	proposal	NNS
18637	14821	17	from	from	IN
18637	14821	18	which	which	WDT
18637	14821	19	the	the	DT
18637	14821	20	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	14821	21	of	of	IN
18637	14821	22	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	14821	23	evolved	evolve	VBD
18637	14821	24	,	,	,
18637	14821	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14821	26	contemplated	contemplate	VBD
18637	14821	27	that	that	IN
18637	14821	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14821	29	should	should	MD
18637	14821	30	be	be	VB
18637	14821	31	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	14821	32	in	in	IN
18637	14821	33	the	the	DT
18637	14821	34	text	text	NN
18637	14821	35	of	of	IN
18637	14821	36	the	the	DT
18637	14821	37	original	original	JJ
18637	14821	38	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	14821	39	.	.	.
18637	14822	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14822	2	6	6	CD
18637	14822	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14822	4	Instead	instead	RB
18637	14822	5	the	the	DT
18637	14822	6	House	House	NNP
18637	14822	7	decided	decide	VBD
18637	14822	8	to	to	TO
18637	14822	9	propose	propose	VB
18637	14822	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14822	11	as	as	IN
18637	14822	12	supplementary	supplementary	JJ
18637	14822	13	.	.	.
18637	14823	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14823	2	7	7	CD
18637	14823	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14823	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14823	5	ignored	ignore	VBD
18637	14823	6	a	a	DT
18637	14823	7	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	14823	8	that	that	IN
18637	14823	9	the	the	DT
18637	14823	10	two	two	CD
18637	14823	11	Houses	house	NNS
18637	14823	12	should	should	MD
18637	14823	13	first	first	RB
18637	14823	14	resolve	resolve	VB
18637	14823	15	that	that	IN
18637	14823	16	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	14823	17	are	be	VBP
18637	14823	18	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	14823	19	before	before	IN
18637	14823	20	considering	consider	VBG
18637	14823	21	specific	specific	JJ
18637	14823	22	proposals	proposal	NNS
18637	14823	23	.	.	.
18637	14824	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14824	2	8	8	CD
18637	14824	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14824	4	In	in	IN
18637	14824	5	the	the	DT
18637	14824	6	National	National	NNP
18637	14824	7	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	14824	8	Cases[9	Cases[9	NNP
18637	14824	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14824	10	the	the	DT
18637	14824	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14824	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14824	13	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	14824	14	that	that	IN
18637	14824	15	in	in	IN
18637	14824	16	proposing	propose	VBG
18637	14824	17	an	an	DT
18637	14824	18	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14824	19	the	the	DT
18637	14824	20	two	two	CD
18637	14824	21	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	14824	22	of	of	IN
18637	14824	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14824	24	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	14824	25	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	14824	26	that	that	IN
18637	14824	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14824	28	deemed	deem	VBD
18637	14824	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14824	30	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	14824	31	.	.	.
18637	14825	1	That	that	DT
18637	14825	2	same	same	JJ
18637	14825	3	case	case	NN
18637	14825	4	also	also	RB
18637	14825	5	established	establish	VBD
18637	14825	6	the	the	DT
18637	14825	7	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	14825	8	that	that	IN
18637	14825	9	the	the	DT
18637	14825	10	vote	vote	NN
18637	14825	11	required	require	VBN
18637	14825	12	to	to	TO
18637	14825	13	propose	propose	VB
18637	14825	14	an	an	DT
18637	14825	15	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14825	16	was	be	VBD
18637	14825	17	a	a	DT
18637	14825	18	vote	vote	NN
18637	14825	19	of	of	IN
18637	14825	20	two	two	CD
18637	14825	21	thirds	third	NNS
18637	14825	22	of	of	IN
18637	14825	23	the	the	DT
18637	14825	24	members	member	NNS
18637	14825	25	present	present	JJ
18637	14825	26	--	--	:
18637	14825	27	assuming	assume	VBG
18637	14825	28	the	the	DT
18637	14825	29	presence	presence	NN
18637	14825	30	of	of	IN
18637	14825	31	a	a	DT
18637	14825	32	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	14825	33	--	--	:
18637	14825	34	and	and	CC
18637	14825	35	not	not	RB
18637	14825	36	a	a	DT
18637	14825	37	vote	vote	NN
18637	14825	38	of	of	IN
18637	14825	39	two	two	CD
18637	14825	40	thirds	third	NNS
18637	14825	41	of	of	IN
18637	14825	42	the	the	DT
18637	14825	43	entire	entire	JJ
18637	14825	44	membership	membership	NN
18637	14825	45	present	present	NN
18637	14825	46	and	and	CC
18637	14825	47	absent	absent	JJ
18637	14825	48	.	.	.
18637	14826	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14826	2	10	10	CD
18637	14826	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14826	4	The	the	DT
18637	14826	5	approval	approval	NN
18637	14826	6	of	of	IN
18637	14826	7	the	the	DT
18637	14826	8	President	President	NNP
18637	14826	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	14826	10	not	not	RB
18637	14826	11	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	14826	12	for	for	IN
18637	14826	13	a	a	DT
18637	14826	14	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	14826	15	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14826	16	.	.	.
18637	14827	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14827	2	11	11	CD
18637	14827	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14827	4	Ratification	Ratification	NNP
18637	14827	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14827	6	may	may	MD
18637	14827	7	,	,	,
18637	14827	8	in	in	IN
18637	14827	9	proposing	propose	VBG
18637	14827	10	an	an	DT
18637	14827	11	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14827	12	,	,	,
18637	14827	13	set	set	VB
18637	14827	14	a	a	DT
18637	14827	15	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	14827	16	time	time	NN
18637	14827	17	limit	limit	NN
18637	14827	18	for	for	IN
18637	14827	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14827	20	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	14827	21	.	.	.
18637	14828	1	Two	two	CD
18637	14828	2	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	14828	3	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	14828	4	in	in	IN
18637	14828	5	1789	1789	CD
18637	14828	6	,	,	,
18637	14828	7	one	one	CD
18637	14828	8	submitted	submit	VBD
18637	14828	9	in	in	IN
18637	14828	10	1810	1810	CD
18637	14828	11	and	and	CC
18637	14828	12	one	one	CD
18637	14828	13	in	in	IN
18637	14828	14	1861	1861	CD
18637	14828	15	,	,	,
18637	14828	16	were	be	VBD
18637	14828	17	never	never	RB
18637	14828	18	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	14828	19	.	.	.
18637	14829	1	In	in	IN
18637	14829	2	Dillon	Dillon	NNP
18637	14829	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14829	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	14829	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14829	6	Gloss[12	Gloss[12	NNP
18637	14829	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14829	8	the	the	DT
18637	14829	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14829	10	intimated	intimate	VBD
18637	14829	11	that	that	IN
18637	14829	12	proposals	proposal	NNS
18637	14829	13	which	which	WDT
18637	14829	14	were	be	VBD
18637	14829	15	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	14829	16	out	out	IN
18637	14829	17	of	of	IN
18637	14829	18	date	date	NN
18637	14829	19	were	be	VBD
18637	14829	20	no	no	RB
18637	14829	21	longer	long	RBR
18637	14829	22	open	open	JJ
18637	14829	23	for	for	IN
18637	14829	24	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	14829	25	.	.	.
18637	14830	1	However	however	RB
18637	14830	2	,	,	,
18637	14830	3	in	in	IN
18637	14830	4	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	14830	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14830	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14830	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14830	8	Miller,[13	Miller,[13	NNP
18637	14830	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14830	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14830	11	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	14830	12	to	to	TO
18637	14830	13	pass	pass	VB
18637	14830	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	14830	15	the	the	DT
18637	14830	16	question	question	NN
18637	14830	17	whether	whether	IN
18637	14830	18	the	the	DT
18637	14830	19	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	14830	20	child	child	NN
18637	14830	21	labor	labor	NN
18637	14830	22	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14830	23	,	,	,
18637	14830	24	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	14830	25	to	to	IN
18637	14830	26	the	the	DT
18637	14830	27	States	States	NNP
18637	14830	28	in	in	IN
18637	14830	29	1924	1924	CD
18637	14830	30	,	,	,
18637	14830	31	was	be	VBD
18637	14830	32	open	open	JJ
18637	14830	33	to	to	IN
18637	14830	34	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	14830	35	thirteen	thirteen	CD
18637	14830	36	years	year	NNS
18637	14830	37	later	later	RB
18637	14830	38	.	.	.
18637	14831	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14831	2	held	hold	VBD
18637	14831	3	this	this	DT
18637	14831	4	to	to	TO
18637	14831	5	be	be	VB
18637	14831	6	a	a	DT
18637	14831	7	political	political	JJ
18637	14831	8	question	question	NN
18637	14831	9	which	which	WDT
18637	14831	10	would	would	MD
18637	14831	11	have	have	VB
18637	14831	12	to	to	TO
18637	14831	13	be	be	VB
18637	14831	14	resolved	resolve	VBN
18637	14831	15	by	by	IN
18637	14831	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14831	17	in	in	IN
18637	14831	18	the	the	DT
18637	14831	19	event	event	NN
18637	14831	20	three	three	CD
18637	14831	21	fourths	fourth	NNS
18637	14831	22	of	of	IN
18637	14831	23	the	the	DT
18637	14831	24	States	States	NNP
18637	14831	25	ever	ever	RB
18637	14831	26	gave	give	VBD
18637	14831	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14831	28	assent	assent	NN
18637	14831	29	to	to	IN
18637	14831	30	the	the	DT
18637	14831	31	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	14831	32	.	.	.
18637	14832	1	With	with	IN
18637	14832	2	respect	respect	NN
18637	14832	3	to	to	IN
18637	14832	4	the	the	DT
18637	14832	5	Eighteenth	Eighteenth	NNP
18637	14832	6	,	,	,
18637	14832	7	Twentieth	Twentieth	NNP
18637	14832	8	,	,	,
18637	14832	9	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	14832	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	14832	11	first	first	JJ
18637	14832	12	and	and	CC
18637	14832	13	Twenty	twenty	CD
18637	14832	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	14832	15	second	second	NN
18637	14832	16	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	14832	17	,	,	,
18637	14832	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14832	19	included	include	VBD
18637	14832	20	in	in	IN
18637	14832	21	the	the	DT
18637	14832	22	text	text	NN
18637	14832	23	of	of	IN
18637	14832	24	these	these	DT
18637	14832	25	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	14832	26	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	14832	27	a	a	DT
18637	14832	28	section	section	NN
18637	14832	29	stating	state	VBG
18637	14832	30	that	that	IN
18637	14832	31	the	the	DT
18637	14832	32	article	article	NN
18637	14832	33	should	should	MD
18637	14832	34	be	be	VB
18637	14832	35	inoperative	inoperative	JJ
18637	14832	36	unless	unless	IN
18637	14832	37	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	14832	38	within	within	IN
18637	14832	39	seven	seven	CD
18637	14832	40	years	year	NNS
18637	14832	41	.	.	.
18637	14833	1	In	in	IN
18637	14833	2	Dillon	Dillon	NNP
18637	14833	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14833	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	14833	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14833	6	Gloss	Gloss	NNP
18637	14833	7	the	the	DT
18637	14833	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14833	9	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	14833	10	this	this	DT
18637	14833	11	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	14833	12	on	on	IN
18637	14833	13	the	the	DT
18637	14833	14	ground	ground	NN
18637	14833	15	that	that	IN
18637	14833	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14833	17	gave	give	VBD
18637	14833	18	effect	effect	NN
18637	14833	19	to	to	IN
18637	14833	20	the	the	DT
18637	14833	21	implication	implication	NN
18637	14833	22	of	of	IN
18637	14833	23	article	article	NN
18637	14833	24	V	v	NN
18637	14833	25	that	that	DT
18637	14833	26	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	14833	27	"	"	''
18637	14833	28	must	must	MD
18637	14833	29	be	be	VB
18637	14833	30	within	within	IN
18637	14833	31	some	some	DT
18637	14833	32	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	14833	33	time	time	NN
18637	14833	34	after	after	IN
18637	14833	35	the	the	DT
18637	14833	36	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	14833	37	.	.	.
18637	14834	1	"	"	``
18637	14834	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14834	3	14	14	CD
18637	14834	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14834	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14834	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	14834	7	complete	complete	JJ
18637	14834	8	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	14834	9	of	of	IN
18637	14834	10	choice	choice	NN
18637	14834	11	between	between	IN
18637	14834	12	the	the	DT
18637	14834	13	two	two	CD
18637	14834	14	methods	method	NNS
18637	14834	15	of	of	IN
18637	14834	16	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	14834	17	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	14834	18	by	by	IN
18637	14834	19	article	article	NN
18637	14834	20	V	v	NN
18637	14834	21	--	--	:
18637	14834	22	by	by	IN
18637	14834	23	the	the	DT
18637	14834	24	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	14834	25	of	of	IN
18637	14834	26	the	the	DT
18637	14834	27	States	States	NNPS
18637	14834	28	,	,	,
18637	14834	29	or	or	CC
18637	14834	30	conventions	convention	NNS
18637	14834	31	in	in	IN
18637	14834	32	the	the	DT
18637	14834	33	States	States	NNP
18637	14834	34	.	.	.
18637	14835	1	In	in	IN
18637	14835	2	United	United	NNP
18637	14835	3	States	States	NNP
18637	14835	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14835	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	14835	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14835	7	Sprague[15	Sprague[15	NNP
18637	14835	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14835	9	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	14835	10	advanced	advance	VBD
18637	14835	11	the	the	DT
18637	14835	12	contention	contention	NN
18637	14835	13	that	that	IN
18637	14835	14	the	the	DT
18637	14835	15	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	14835	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	14835	17	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	14835	18	a	a	DT
18637	14835	19	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	14835	20	between	between	IN
18637	14835	21	powers	power	NNS
18637	14835	22	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	14835	23	to	to	IN
18637	14835	24	the	the	DT
18637	14835	25	States	States	NNPS
18637	14835	26	and	and	CC
18637	14835	27	powers	power	NNS
18637	14835	28	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	14835	29	to	to	IN
18637	14835	30	the	the	DT
18637	14835	31	people	people	NNS
18637	14835	32	,	,	,
18637	14835	33	and	and	CC
18637	14835	34	that	that	IN
18637	14835	35	State	State	NNP
18637	14835	36	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	14835	37	were	be	VBD
18637	14835	38	competent	competent	JJ
18637	14835	39	to	to	TO
18637	14835	40	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	14835	41	only	only	RB
18637	14835	42	the	the	DT
18637	14835	43	former	former	JJ
18637	14835	44	to	to	IN
18637	14835	45	the	the	DT
18637	14835	46	National	National	NNP
18637	14835	47	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14835	48	;	;	:
18637	14835	49	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	14835	50	of	of	IN
18637	14835	51	the	the	DT
18637	14835	52	latter	latter	JJ
18637	14835	53	required	require	VBN
18637	14835	54	action	action	NN
18637	14835	55	of	of	IN
18637	14835	56	the	the	DT
18637	14835	57	people	people	NNS
18637	14835	58	through	through	IN
18637	14835	59	conventions	convention	NNS
18637	14835	60	in	in	IN
18637	14835	61	the	the	DT
18637	14835	62	several	several	JJ
18637	14835	63	States	state	NNS
18637	14835	64	.	.	.
18637	14836	1	The	the	DT
18637	14836	2	Eighteenth	Eighteenth	NNP
18637	14836	3	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	14836	4	being	be	VBG
18637	14836	5	of	of	IN
18637	14836	6	the	the	DT
18637	14836	7	latter	latter	JJ
18637	14836	8	character	character	NN
18637	14836	9	,	,	,
18637	14836	10	the	the	DT
18637	14836	11	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	14836	12	by	by	IN
18637	14836	13	State	state	NN
18637	14836	14	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	14836	15	,	,	,
18637	14836	16	so	so	CC
18637	14836	17	the	the	DT
18637	14836	18	argument	argument	NN
18637	14836	19	ran	run	VBD
18637	14836	20	,	,	,
18637	14836	21	was	be	VBD
18637	14836	22	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	14836	23	.	.	.
18637	14837	1	The	the	DT
18637	14837	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14837	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14837	4	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	14837	5	the	the	DT
18637	14837	6	argument	argument	NN
18637	14837	7	.	.	.
18637	14838	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14838	2	found	find	VBD
18637	14838	3	the	the	DT
18637	14838	4	language	language	NN
18637	14838	5	of	of	IN
18637	14838	6	article	article	NN
18637	14838	7	V	v	NN
18637	14838	8	too	too	RB
18637	14838	9	clear	clear	JJ
18637	14838	10	to	to	TO
18637	14838	11	admit	admit	VB
18637	14838	12	of	of	IN
18637	14838	13	reading	read	VBG
18637	14838	14	any	any	DT
18637	14838	15	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	14838	16	into	into	IN
18637	14838	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14838	18	by	by	IN
18637	14838	19	implication	implication	NN
18637	14838	20	.	.	.
18637	14839	1	The	the	DT
18637	14839	2	term	term	NN
18637	14839	3	"	"	``
18637	14839	4	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	14839	5	"	"	''
18637	14839	6	as	as	IN
18637	14839	7	used	use	VBN
18637	14839	8	in	in	IN
18637	14839	9	article	article	NN
18637	14839	10	V	v	NN
18637	14839	11	means	mean	VBZ
18637	14839	12	deliberative	deliberative	JJ
18637	14839	13	,	,	,
18637	14839	14	representative	representative	JJ
18637	14839	15	bodies	body	NNS
18637	14839	16	of	of	IN
18637	14839	17	the	the	DT
18637	14839	18	type	type	NN
18637	14839	19	which	which	WDT
18637	14839	20	in	in	IN
18637	14839	21	1789	1789	CD
18637	14839	22	exercised	exercise	VBD
18637	14839	23	the	the	DT
18637	14839	24	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	14839	25	power	power	NN
18637	14839	26	in	in	IN
18637	14839	27	the	the	DT
18637	14839	28	several	several	JJ
18637	14839	29	States	state	NNS
18637	14839	30	.	.	.
18637	14840	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14840	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	14840	3	not	not	RB
18637	14840	4	comprehend	comprehend	VB
18637	14840	5	the	the	DT
18637	14840	6	popular	popular	JJ
18637	14840	7	referendum	referendum	NN
18637	14840	8	which	which	WDT
18637	14840	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	14840	10	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	14840	11	become	become	VBN
18637	14840	12	a	a	DT
18637	14840	13	part	part	NN
18637	14840	14	of	of	IN
18637	14840	15	the	the	DT
18637	14840	16	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	14840	17	process	process	NN
18637	14840	18	in	in	IN
18637	14840	19	many	many	JJ
18637	14840	20	of	of	IN
18637	14840	21	the	the	DT
18637	14840	22	States	States	NNPS
18637	14840	23	,	,	,
18637	14840	24	nor	nor	CC
18637	14840	25	may	may	MD
18637	14840	26	a	a	DT
18637	14840	27	State	state	NN
18637	14840	28	validly	validly	JJ
18637	14840	29	condition	condition	NN
18637	14840	30	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	14840	31	of	of	IN
18637	14840	32	a	a	DT
18637	14840	33	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	14840	34	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	14840	35	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14840	36	on	on	IN
18637	14840	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14840	38	approval	approval	NN
18637	14840	39	by	by	IN
18637	14840	40	such	such	PDT
18637	14840	41	a	a	DT
18637	14840	42	referendum	referendum	NN
18637	14840	43	.	.	.
18637	14841	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14841	2	16	16	CD
18637	14841	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14841	4	In	in	IN
18637	14841	5	the	the	DT
18637	14841	6	words	word	NNS
18637	14841	7	of	of	IN
18637	14841	8	the	the	DT
18637	14841	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14841	10	:	:	:
18637	14841	11	"	"	``
18637	14841	12	*	*	NFP
18637	14841	13	*	*	NFP
18637	14841	14	*	*	NFP
18637	14841	15	the	the	DT
18637	14841	16	function	function	NN
18637	14841	17	of	of	IN
18637	14841	18	a	a	DT
18637	14841	19	State	State	NNP
18637	14841	20	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	14841	21	in	in	IN
18637	14841	22	ratifying	ratify	VBG
18637	14841	23	a	a	DT
18637	14841	24	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	14841	25	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14841	26	to	to	IN
18637	14841	27	the	the	DT
18637	14841	28	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	14841	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14841	30	,	,	,
18637	14841	31	like	like	IN
18637	14841	32	the	the	DT
18637	14841	33	function	function	NN
18637	14841	34	of	of	IN
18637	14841	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14841	36	in	in	IN
18637	14841	37	proposing	propose	VBG
18637	14841	38	the	the	DT
18637	14841	39	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14841	40	,	,	,
18637	14841	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	14841	42	a	a	DT
18637	14841	43	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14841	44	function	function	NN
18637	14841	45	derived	derive	VBN
18637	14841	46	from	from	IN
18637	14841	47	the	the	DT
18637	14841	48	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	14841	49	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14841	50	;	;	:
18637	14841	51	and	and	CC
18637	14841	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14841	53	transcends	transcend	VBZ
18637	14841	54	any	any	DT
18637	14841	55	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	14841	56	sought	seek	VBN
18637	14841	57	to	to	TO
18637	14841	58	be	be	VB
18637	14841	59	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	14841	60	by	by	IN
18637	14841	61	the	the	DT
18637	14841	62	people	people	NNS
18637	14841	63	of	of	IN
18637	14841	64	a	a	DT
18637	14841	65	State	state	NN
18637	14841	66	.	.	.
18637	14842	1	"	"	``
18637	14842	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14842	3	17	17	CD
18637	14842	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14842	5	Authentication	Authentication	NNP
18637	14842	6	and	and	CC
18637	14842	7	Proclamation	Proclamation	NNP
18637	14842	8	Formerly	formerly	RB
18637	14842	9	official	official	JJ
18637	14842	10	notice	notice	NN
18637	14842	11	from	from	IN
18637	14842	12	a	a	DT
18637	14842	13	State	State	NNP
18637	14842	14	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	14842	15	,	,	,
18637	14842	16	duly	duly	RB
18637	14842	17	authenticated	authenticate	VBN
18637	14842	18	,	,	,
18637	14842	19	that	that	IN
18637	14842	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14842	21	had	have	VBD
18637	14842	22	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	14842	23	a	a	DT
18637	14842	24	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	14842	25	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14842	26	went	go	VBD
18637	14842	27	to	to	IN
18637	14842	28	the	the	DT
18637	14842	29	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	14842	30	of	of	IN
18637	14842	31	State	State	NNP
18637	14842	32	,	,	,
18637	14842	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	14842	34	whom	whom	WP
18637	14842	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14842	36	was	be	VBD
18637	14842	37	binding	bind	VBG
18637	14842	38	,	,	,
18637	14842	39	"	"	''
18637	14842	40	being	be	VBG
18637	14842	41	certified	certify	VBN
18637	14842	42	by	by	IN
18637	14842	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14842	44	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	14842	45	,	,	,
18637	14842	46	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14842	47	was	be	VBD
18637	14842	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14842	49	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	14842	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	14842	51	the	the	DT
18637	14842	52	courts	court	NNS
18637	14842	53	"	"	''
18637	14842	54	as	as	IN
18637	14842	55	against	against	IN
18637	14842	56	any	any	DT
18637	14842	57	objection	objection	NN
18637	14842	58	which	which	WDT
18637	14842	59	might	may	MD
18637	14842	60	be	be	VB
18637	14842	61	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	14842	62	raised	raise	VBN
18637	14842	63	as	as	IN
18637	14842	64	to	to	IN
18637	14842	65	the	the	DT
18637	14842	66	regularity	regularity	NN
18637	14842	67	of	of	IN
18637	14842	68	the	the	DT
18637	14842	69	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	14842	70	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	14842	71	by	by	IN
18637	14842	72	which	which	WDT
18637	14842	73	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	14842	74	was	be	VBD
18637	14842	75	brought	bring	VBN
18637	14842	76	about	about	RP
18637	14842	77	.	.	.
18637	14843	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14843	2	18	18	CD
18637	14843	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14843	4	This	this	DT
18637	14843	5	function	function	NN
18637	14843	6	of	of	IN
18637	14843	7	the	the	DT
18637	14843	8	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	14843	9	,	,	,
18637	14843	10	purely	purely	RB
18637	14843	11	ministerial	ministerial	JJ
18637	14843	12	in	in	IN
18637	14843	13	character	character	NN
18637	14843	14	,	,	,
18637	14843	15	was	be	VBD
18637	14843	16	,	,	,
18637	14843	17	however	however	RB
18637	14843	18	,	,	,
18637	14843	19	derived	derive	VBN
18637	14843	20	from	from	IN
18637	14843	21	an	an	DT
18637	14843	22	act	act	NN
18637	14843	23	of	of	IN
18637	14843	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14843	25	,	,	,
18637	14843	26	and	and	CC
18637	14843	27	was	be	VBD
18637	14843	28	recently	recently	RB
18637	14843	29	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	14843	30	to	to	IN
18637	14843	31	a	a	DT
18637	14843	32	functionary	functionary	NN
18637	14843	33	called	call	VBN
18637	14843	34	Administrator	Administrator	NNP
18637	14843	35	of	of	IN
18637	14843	36	General	General	NNP
18637	14843	37	Services	Services	NNP
18637	14843	38	.	.	.
18637	14844	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14844	2	19	19	CD
18637	14844	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14844	4	In	in	IN
18637	14844	5	Dillon	Dillon	NNP
18637	14844	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14844	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14844	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14844	9	Gloss,[20	Gloss,[20	NNP
18637	14844	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14844	11	the	the	DT
18637	14844	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14844	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14844	14	held	hold	VBD
18637	14844	15	that	that	IN
18637	14844	16	the	the	DT
18637	14844	17	Eighteenth	Eighteenth	NNP
18637	14844	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	14844	19	became	become	VBD
18637	14844	20	operative	operative	JJ
18637	14844	21	on	on	IN
18637	14844	22	the	the	DT
18637	14844	23	date	date	NN
18637	14844	24	of	of	IN
18637	14844	25	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	14844	26	by	by	IN
18637	14844	27	the	the	DT
18637	14844	28	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	14844	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	14844	30	sixth	sixth	JJ
18637	14844	31	State	state	NN
18637	14844	32	,	,	,
18637	14844	33	rather	rather	RB
18637	14844	34	than	than	IN
18637	14844	35	on	on	IN
18637	14844	36	the	the	DT
18637	14844	37	later	later	JJ
18637	14844	38	date	date	NN
18637	14844	39	of	of	IN
18637	14844	40	the	the	DT
18637	14844	41	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	14844	42	issued	issue	VBN
18637	14844	43	by	by	IN
18637	14844	44	the	the	DT
18637	14844	45	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	14844	46	of	of	IN
18637	14844	47	State	State	NNP
18637	14844	48	,	,	,
18637	14844	49	and	and	CC
18637	14844	50	doubtless	doubtless	RB
18637	14844	51	the	the	DT
18637	14844	52	same	same	JJ
18637	14844	53	rule	rule	NN
18637	14844	54	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	14844	55	as	as	IN
18637	14844	56	to	to	IN
18637	14844	57	a	a	DT
18637	14844	58	similar	similar	JJ
18637	14844	59	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	14844	60	by	by	IN
18637	14844	61	the	the	DT
18637	14844	62	Administrator	Administrator	NNP
18637	14844	63	.	.	.
18637	14845	1	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	14845	2	REVIEW	REVIEW	NNP
18637	14845	3	UNDER	under	IN
18637	14845	4	ARTICLE	article	NN
18637	14845	5	V	v	NN
18637	14845	6	Prior	prior	RB
18637	14845	7	to	to	IN
18637	14845	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	14845	9	,	,	,
18637	14845	10	the	the	DT
18637	14845	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14845	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14845	13	had	have	VBD
18637	14845	14	taken	take	VBN
18637	14845	15	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	14845	16	of	of	IN
18637	14845	17	a	a	DT
18637	14845	18	number	number	NN
18637	14845	19	of	of	IN
18637	14845	20	diverse	diverse	JJ
18637	14845	21	objections	objection	NNS
18637	14845	22	to	to	IN
18637	14845	23	the	the	DT
18637	14845	24	validity	validity	NN
18637	14845	25	of	of	IN
18637	14845	26	specific	specific	JJ
18637	14845	27	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	14845	28	.	.	.
18637	14846	1	Apart	apart	RB
18637	14846	2	from	from	IN
18637	14846	3	holding	hold	VBG
18637	14846	4	that	that	DT
18637	14846	5	official	official	JJ
18637	14846	6	notice	notice	NN
18637	14846	7	of	of	IN
18637	14846	8	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	14846	9	by	by	IN
18637	14846	10	the	the	DT
18637	14846	11	several	several	JJ
18637	14846	12	States	state	NNS
18637	14846	13	was	be	VBD
18637	14846	14	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	14846	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	14846	16	the	the	DT
18637	14846	17	courts,[21	courts,[21	CD
18637	14846	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14846	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14846	20	had	have	VBD
18637	14846	21	treated	treat	VBN
18637	14846	22	these	these	DT
18637	14846	23	questions	question	NNS
18637	14846	24	as	as	IN
18637	14846	25	justiciable	justiciable	NN
18637	14846	26	,	,	,
18637	14846	27	although	although	IN
18637	14846	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14846	29	had	have	VBD
18637	14846	30	uniformly	uniformly	RB
18637	14846	31	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	14846	32	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14846	33	on	on	IN
18637	14846	34	the	the	DT
18637	14846	35	merits	merit	NNS
18637	14846	36	.	.	.
18637	14847	1	In	in	IN
18637	14847	2	that	that	DT
18637	14847	3	year	year	NN
18637	14847	4	,	,	,
18637	14847	5	however	however	RB
18637	14847	6	,	,	,
18637	14847	7	the	the	DT
18637	14847	8	whole	whole	JJ
18637	14847	9	subject	subject	NN
18637	14847	10	was	be	VBD
18637	14847	11	thrown	throw	VBN
18637	14847	12	into	into	IN
18637	14847	13	confusion	confusion	NN
18637	14847	14	by	by	IN
18637	14847	15	the	the	DT
18637	14847	16	inconclusive	inconclusive	JJ
18637	14847	17	decision	decision	NN
18637	14847	18	in	in	IN
18637	14847	19	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	14847	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14847	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	14847	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14847	23	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	14847	24	.	.	.
18637	14848	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14848	2	22	22	CD
18637	14848	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14848	4	This	this	DT
18637	14848	5	case	case	NN
18637	14848	6	came	come	VBD
18637	14848	7	up	up	RP
18637	14848	8	on	on	IN
18637	14848	9	a	a	DT
18637	14848	10	writ	writ	NN
18637	14848	11	of	of	IN
18637	14848	12	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	14848	13	to	to	IN
18637	14848	14	the	the	DT
18637	14848	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14848	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14848	17	of	of	IN
18637	14848	18	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	14848	19	to	to	TO
18637	14848	20	review	review	VB
18637	14848	21	the	the	DT
18637	14848	22	denial	denial	NN
18637	14848	23	of	of	IN
18637	14848	24	a	a	DT
18637	14848	25	writ	writ	NNP
18637	14848	26	of	of	IN
18637	14848	27	mandamus	mandamus	NNP
18637	14848	28	to	to	TO
18637	14848	29	compel	compel	VB
18637	14848	30	the	the	DT
18637	14848	31	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	14848	32	of	of	IN
18637	14848	33	the	the	DT
18637	14848	34	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	14848	35	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	14848	36	to	to	TO
18637	14848	37	erase	erase	VB
18637	14848	38	an	an	DT
18637	14848	39	endorsement	endorsement	NN
18637	14848	40	on	on	IN
18637	14848	41	a	a	DT
18637	14848	42	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	14848	43	ratifying	ratify	VBG
18637	14848	44	the	the	DT
18637	14848	45	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	14848	46	child	child	NN
18637	14848	47	labor	labor	NN
18637	14848	48	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14848	49	to	to	IN
18637	14848	50	the	the	DT
18637	14848	51	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14848	52	to	to	IN
18637	14848	53	the	the	DT
18637	14848	54	effect	effect	NN
18637	14848	55	that	that	WDT
18637	14848	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14848	57	had	have	VBD
18637	14848	58	been	be	VBN
18637	14848	59	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	14848	60	by	by	IN
18637	14848	61	the	the	DT
18637	14848	62	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	14848	63	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	14848	64	.	.	.
18637	14849	1	The	the	DT
18637	14849	2	attempted	attempted	JJ
18637	14849	3	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	14849	4	was	be	VBD
18637	14849	5	assailed	assail	VBN
18637	14849	6	on	on	IN
18637	14849	7	three	three	CD
18637	14849	8	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	14849	9	:	:	:
18637	14849	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14849	11	1	1	LS
18637	14849	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14849	13	that	that	IN
18637	14849	14	the	the	DT
18637	14849	15	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14849	16	had	have	VBD
18637	14849	17	been	be	VBN
18637	14849	18	previously	previously	RB
18637	14849	19	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	14849	20	by	by	IN
18637	14849	21	the	the	DT
18637	14849	22	State	State	NNP
18637	14849	23	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	14849	24	;	;	:
18637	14849	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14849	26	2	2	LS
18637	14849	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14849	28	that	that	IN
18637	14849	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14849	30	was	be	VBD
18637	14849	31	no	no	RB
18637	14849	32	longer	longer	RB
18637	14849	33	open	open	JJ
18637	14849	34	to	to	IN
18637	14849	35	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	14849	36	because	because	IN
18637	14849	37	an	an	DT
18637	14849	38	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	14849	39	period	period	NN
18637	14849	40	of	of	IN
18637	14849	41	time	time	NN
18637	14849	42	,	,	,
18637	14849	43	thirteen	thirteen	CD
18637	14849	44	years	year	NNS
18637	14849	45	,	,	,
18637	14849	46	had	have	VBD
18637	14849	47	elapsed	elapse	VBN
18637	14849	48	since	since	IN
18637	14849	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14849	50	submission	submission	NN
18637	14849	51	to	to	IN
18637	14849	52	the	the	DT
18637	14849	53	States	States	NNP
18637	14849	54	,	,	,
18637	14849	55	and	and	CC
18637	14849	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14849	57	3	3	LS
18637	14849	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14849	59	that	that	IN
18637	14849	60	the	the	DT
18637	14849	61	lieutenant	lieutenant	NN
18637	14849	62	governor	governor	NN
18637	14849	63	had	have	VBD
18637	14849	64	no	no	DT
18637	14849	65	right	right	NN
18637	14849	66	to	to	TO
18637	14849	67	cast	cast	VB
18637	14849	68	the	the	DT
18637	14849	69	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	14849	70	vote	vote	NN
18637	14849	71	in	in	IN
18637	14849	72	the	the	DT
18637	14849	73	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	14849	74	in	in	IN
18637	14849	75	favor	favor	NN
18637	14849	76	of	of	IN
18637	14849	77	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	14849	78	.	.	.
18637	14850	1	Four	four	CD
18637	14850	2	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	14850	3	were	be	VBD
18637	14850	4	written	write	VBN
18637	14850	5	in	in	IN
18637	14850	6	the	the	DT
18637	14850	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14850	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14850	9	,	,	,
18637	14850	10	no	no	DT
18637	14850	11	one	one	NN
18637	14850	12	of	of	IN
18637	14850	13	which	which	WDT
18637	14850	14	commanded	command	VBD
18637	14850	15	the	the	DT
18637	14850	16	support	support	NN
18637	14850	17	of	of	IN
18637	14850	18	more	more	JJR
18637	14850	19	than	than	IN
18637	14850	20	four	four	CD
18637	14850	21	members	member	NNS
18637	14850	22	of	of	IN
18637	14850	23	the	the	DT
18637	14850	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14850	25	.	.	.
18637	14851	1	The	the	DT
18637	14851	2	majority	majority	NN
18637	14851	3	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	14851	4	that	that	IN
18637	14851	5	the	the	DT
18637	14851	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
18637	14851	7	,	,	,
18637	14851	8	members	member	NNS
18637	14851	9	of	of	IN
18637	14851	10	the	the	DT
18637	14851	11	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	14851	12	State	State	NNP
18637	14851	13	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	14851	14	,	,	,
18637	14851	15	had	have	VBD
18637	14851	16	a	a	DT
18637	14851	17	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	14851	18	interest	interest	NN
18637	14851	19	in	in	IN
18637	14851	20	the	the	DT
18637	14851	21	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	14851	22	to	to	TO
18637	14851	23	give	give	VB
18637	14851	24	the	the	DT
18637	14851	25	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14851	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	14851	27	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14851	28	to	to	TO
18637	14851	29	review	review	VB
18637	14851	30	the	the	DT
18637	14851	31	case	case	NN
18637	14851	32	.	.	.
18637	14852	1	Without	without	IN
18637	14852	2	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	14852	3	as	as	IN
18637	14852	4	to	to	IN
18637	14852	5	the	the	DT
18637	14852	6	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	14852	7	for	for	IN
18637	14852	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14852	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	14852	10	,	,	,
18637	14852	11	a	a	DT
18637	14852	12	different	different	JJ
18637	14852	13	majority	majority	NN
18637	14852	14	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	14852	15	the	the	DT
18637	14852	16	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14852	17	of	of	IN
18637	14852	18	the	the	DT
18637	14852	19	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	14852	20	court	court	NN
18637	14852	21	denying	deny	VBG
18637	14852	22	the	the	DT
18637	14852	23	relief	relief	NN
18637	14852	24	sought	seek	VBN
18637	14852	25	.	.	.
18637	14853	1	Four	four	CD
18637	14853	2	members	member	NNS
18637	14853	3	who	who	WP
18637	14853	4	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	14853	5	in	in	IN
18637	14853	6	the	the	DT
18637	14853	7	result	result	NN
18637	14853	8	had	have	VBD
18637	14853	9	voted	vote	VBN
18637	14853	10	to	to	TO
18637	14853	11	dismiss	dismiss	VB
18637	14853	12	the	the	DT
18637	14853	13	writ	writ	NNP
18637	14853	14	on	on	IN
18637	14853	15	the	the	DT
18637	14853	16	ground	ground	NN
18637	14853	17	that	that	IN
18637	14853	18	the	the	DT
18637	14853	19	amending	amending	JJ
18637	14853	20	process	process	NN
18637	14853	21	"	"	``
18637	14853	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	14853	23	'	'	``
18637	14853	24	political	political	JJ
18637	14853	25	'	'	''
18637	14853	26	in	in	IN
18637	14853	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14853	28	entirety	entirety	NN
18637	14853	29	,	,	,
18637	14853	30	from	from	IN
18637	14853	31	submission	submission	NN
18637	14853	32	until	until	IN
18637	14853	33	an	an	DT
18637	14853	34	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14853	35	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	14853	36	part	part	NN
18637	14853	37	of	of	IN
18637	14853	38	the	the	DT
18637	14853	39	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14853	40	,	,	,
18637	14853	41	and	and	CC
18637	14853	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	14853	43	not	not	RB
18637	14853	44	subject	subject	JJ
18637	14853	45	to	to	IN
18637	14853	46	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	14853	47	guidance	guidance	NN
18637	14853	48	,	,	,
18637	14853	49	control	control	NN
18637	14853	50	or	or	CC
18637	14853	51	interference	interference	NN
18637	14853	52	at	at	IN
18637	14853	53	any	any	DT
18637	14853	54	point	point	NN
18637	14853	55	.	.	.
18637	14854	1	"	"	``
18637	14854	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14854	3	23	23	CD
18637	14854	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14854	5	Whether	whether	IN
18637	14854	6	the	the	DT
18637	14854	7	contention	contention	NN
18637	14854	8	that	that	IN
18637	14854	9	the	the	DT
18637	14854	10	lieutenant	lieutenant	NN
18637	14854	11	governor	governor	NN
18637	14854	12	should	should	MD
18637	14854	13	have	have	VB
18637	14854	14	been	be	VBN
18637	14854	15	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	14854	16	to	to	TO
18637	14854	17	cast	cast	VB
18637	14854	18	the	the	DT
18637	14854	19	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	14854	20	vote	vote	NN
18637	14854	21	in	in	IN
18637	14854	22	favor	favor	NN
18637	14854	23	of	of	IN
18637	14854	24	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	14854	25	presented	present	VBD
18637	14854	26	a	a	DT
18637	14854	27	justiciable	justiciable	NN
18637	14854	28	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	14854	29	was	be	VBD
18637	14854	30	left	leave	VBN
18637	14854	31	undecided	undecided	JJ
18637	14854	32	,	,	,
18637	14854	33	the	the	DT
18637	14854	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14854	35	being	be	VBG
18637	14854	36	equally	equally	RB
18637	14854	37	divided	divide	VBN
18637	14854	38	on	on	IN
18637	14854	39	the	the	DT
18637	14854	40	point	point	NN
18637	14854	41	.	.	.
18637	14855	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14855	2	24	24	CD
18637	14855	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14855	4	In	in	IN
18637	14855	5	an	an	DT
18637	14855	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	14855	7	reported	report	VBN
18637	14855	8	as	as	IN
18637	14855	9	"	"	``
18637	14855	10	the	the	DT
18637	14855	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	14855	12	of	of	IN
18637	14855	13	the	the	DT
18637	14855	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14855	15	,	,	,
18637	14855	16	"	"	''
18637	14855	17	but	but	CC
18637	14855	18	in	in	IN
18637	14855	19	which	which	WDT
18637	14855	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14855	21	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	14855	22	that	that	IN
18637	14855	23	only	only	RB
18637	14855	24	three	three	CD
18637	14855	25	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	14855	26	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	14855	27	,	,	,
18637	14855	28	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	14855	29	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14855	30	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	14855	31	declared	declare	VBD
18637	14855	32	that	that	IN
18637	14855	33	the	the	DT
18637	14855	34	writ	writ	NNP
18637	14855	35	of	of	IN
18637	14855	36	mandamus	mandamus	NNP
18637	14855	37	was	be	VBD
18637	14855	38	properly	properly	RB
18637	14855	39	denied	deny	VBN
18637	14855	40	because	because	IN
18637	14855	41	the	the	DT
18637	14855	42	question	question	NN
18637	14855	43	as	as	IN
18637	14855	44	to	to	IN
18637	14855	45	the	the	DT
18637	14855	46	effect	effect	NN
18637	14855	47	of	of	IN
18637	14855	48	the	the	DT
18637	14855	49	previous	previous	JJ
18637	14855	50	rejection	rejection	NN
18637	14855	51	of	of	IN
18637	14855	52	the	the	DT
18637	14855	53	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14855	54	and	and	CC
18637	14855	55	the	the	DT
18637	14855	56	lapse	lapse	NN
18637	14855	57	of	of	IN
18637	14855	58	time	time	NN
18637	14855	59	since	since	IN
18637	14855	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14855	61	was	be	VBD
18637	14855	62	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	14855	63	to	to	IN
18637	14855	64	the	the	DT
18637	14855	65	States	States	NNPS
18637	14855	66	were	be	VBD
18637	14855	67	political	political	JJ
18637	14855	68	questions	question	NNS
18637	14855	69	which	which	WDT
18637	14855	70	should	should	MD
18637	14855	71	be	be	VB
18637	14855	72	left	leave	VBN
18637	14855	73	to	to	IN
18637	14855	74	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14855	75	.	.	.
18637	14856	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14856	2	25	25	CD
18637	14856	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14856	4	On	on	IN
18637	14856	5	the	the	DT
18637	14856	6	same	same	JJ
18637	14856	7	day	day	NN
18637	14856	8	,	,	,
18637	14856	9	the	the	DT
18637	14856	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14856	11	dismissed	dismiss	VBD
18637	14856	12	a	a	DT
18637	14856	13	writ	writ	NN
18637	14856	14	of	of	IN
18637	14856	15	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	14856	16	to	to	TO
18637	14856	17	review	review	VB
18637	14856	18	a	a	DT
18637	14856	19	decision	decision	NN
18637	14856	20	of	of	IN
18637	14856	21	the	the	DT
18637	14856	22	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	14856	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14856	24	of	of	IN
18637	14856	25	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	14856	26	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	14856	27	the	the	DT
18637	14856	28	action	action	NN
18637	14856	29	of	of	IN
18637	14856	30	the	the	DT
18637	14856	31	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	14856	32	General	General	NNP
18637	14856	33	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
18637	14856	34	purporting	purport	VBG
18637	14856	35	to	to	TO
18637	14856	36	ratify	ratify	VB
18637	14856	37	the	the	DT
18637	14856	38	child	child	NN
18637	14856	39	labor	labor	NN
18637	14856	40	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14856	41	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	14856	42	and	and	CC
18637	14856	43	void	void	JJ
18637	14856	44	.	.	.
18637	14857	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	14857	2	as	as	IN
18637	14857	3	the	the	DT
18637	14857	4	governor	governor	NN
18637	14857	5	had	have	VBD
18637	14857	6	forwarded	forward	VBN
18637	14857	7	the	the	DT
18637	14857	8	certified	certify	VBN
18637	14857	9	copy	copy	NN
18637	14857	10	of	of	IN
18637	14857	11	the	the	DT
18637	14857	12	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	14857	13	to	to	IN
18637	14857	14	the	the	DT
18637	14857	15	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	14857	16	of	of	IN
18637	14857	17	State	State	NNP
18637	14857	18	before	before	IN
18637	14857	19	being	be	VBG
18637	14857	20	served	serve	VBN
18637	14857	21	with	with	IN
18637	14857	22	a	a	DT
18637	14857	23	copy	copy	NN
18637	14857	24	of	of	IN
18637	14857	25	the	the	DT
18637	14857	26	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	14857	27	order	order	NN
18637	14857	28	issued	issue	VBN
18637	14857	29	by	by	IN
18637	14857	30	the	the	DT
18637	14857	31	State	State	NNP
18637	14857	32	court	court	NN
18637	14857	33	,	,	,
18637	14857	34	the	the	DT
18637	14857	35	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14857	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14857	37	found	find	VBD
18637	14857	38	that	that	IN
18637	14857	39	there	there	EX
18637	14857	40	was	be	VBD
18637	14857	41	no	no	RB
18637	14857	42	longer	long	RBR
18637	14857	43	a	a	DT
18637	14857	44	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	14857	45	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
18637	14857	46	of	of	IN
18637	14857	47	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	14857	48	determination	determination	NN
18637	14857	49	.	.	.
18637	14858	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14858	2	26	26	CD
18637	14858	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14858	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	14858	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14858	6	1	1	CD
18637	14858	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14858	8	II	II	NNP
18637	14858	9	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	14858	10	,	,	,
18637	14858	11	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	14858	12	of	of	IN
18637	14858	13	Debates	Debates	NNPS
18637	14858	14	in	in	IN
18637	14858	15	the	the	DT
18637	14858	16	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	14858	17	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	14858	18	,	,	,
18637	14858	19	385	385	CD
18637	14858	20	-	-	SYM
18637	14858	21	386	386	CD
18637	14858	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14858	23	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
18637	14858	24	's	's	POS
18637	14858	25	ed	ed	NNP
18637	14858	26	.	.	NNP
18637	14858	27	,	,	,
18637	14858	28	1908	1908	CD
18637	14858	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14858	30	.	.	.
18637	14859	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14859	2	2	2	LS
18637	14859	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14859	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	14859	5	.	.	.
18637	14860	1	Globe	Globe	NNP
18637	14860	2	,	,	,
18637	14860	3	1263	1263	CD
18637	14860	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14860	5	1861	1861	CD
18637	14860	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14860	7	.	.	.
18637	14861	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14861	2	3	3	LS
18637	14861	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14861	4	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	14861	5	,	,	,
18637	14861	6	Herman	Herman	NNP
18637	14861	7	V.	V.	NNP
18637	14861	8	,	,	,
18637	14861	9	Proposed	propose	VBN
18637	14861	10	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	14861	11	to	to	IN
18637	14861	12	the	the	DT
18637	14861	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14861	14	,	,	,
18637	14861	15	363	363	CD
18637	14861	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14861	17	1896	1896	CD
18637	14861	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14861	19	.	.	.
18637	14862	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14862	2	4	4	LS
18637	14862	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14862	4	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	14862	5	Island	Island	NNP
18637	14862	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14862	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14862	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14862	9	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	14862	10	,	,	,
18637	14862	11	253	253	CD
18637	14862	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14862	13	350	350	CD
18637	14862	14	,	,	,
18637	14862	15	386	386	CD
18637	14862	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14862	17	1920	1920	CD
18637	14862	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14862	19	.	.	.
18637	14863	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14863	2	5	5	CD
18637	14863	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14863	4	Leser	Leser	NNP
18637	14863	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14863	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14863	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14863	8	Garnett	Garnett	NNP
18637	14863	9	,	,	,
18637	14863	10	258	258	CD
18637	14863	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14863	12	130	130	CD
18637	14863	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14863	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	14863	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14863	16	.	.	.
18637	14864	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14864	2	6	6	CD
18637	14864	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14864	4	Annals	Annals	NNPS
18637	14864	5	of	of	IN
18637	14864	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14864	7	433	433	CD
18637	14864	8	-	-	SYM
18637	14864	9	436	436	CD
18637	14864	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14864	11	1789	1789	CD
18637	14864	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14864	13	.	.	.
18637	14865	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14865	2	7	7	CD
18637	14865	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14865	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14865	5	.	.	.
18637	14866	1	717	717	CD
18637	14866	2	.	.	.
18637	14867	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14867	2	8	8	CD
18637	14867	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14867	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14867	5	.	.	.
18637	14868	1	430	430	CD
18637	14868	2	.	.	.
18637	14869	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14869	2	9	9	CD
18637	14869	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14869	4	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	14869	5	Island	Island	NNP
18637	14869	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14869	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14869	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14869	9	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	14869	10	,	,	,
18637	14869	11	253	253	CD
18637	14869	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14869	13	350	350	CD
18637	14869	14	,	,	,
18637	14869	15	386	386	CD
18637	14869	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14869	17	1920	1920	CD
18637	14869	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14869	19	.	.	.
18637	14870	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14870	2	10	10	CD
18637	14870	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14870	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14870	5	.	.	.
18637	14871	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14871	2	11	11	CD
18637	14871	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14871	4	Hollingsworth	Hollingsworth	NNP
18637	14871	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14871	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14871	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14871	8	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	14871	9	,	,	,
18637	14871	10	3	3	CD
18637	14871	11	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	14871	12	.	.	.
18637	14872	1	378	378	CD
18637	14872	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14872	3	1798	1798	CD
18637	14872	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14872	5	.	.	.
18637	14873	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14873	2	12	12	CD
18637	14873	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14873	4	256	256	CD
18637	14873	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14873	6	368	368	CD
18637	14873	7	,	,	,
18637	14873	8	375	375	CD
18637	14873	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14873	10	1921	1921	CD
18637	14873	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14873	12	.	.	.
18637	14874	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14874	2	13	13	CD
18637	14874	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14874	4	307	307	CD
18637	14874	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14874	6	433	433	CD
18637	14874	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14874	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	14874	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14874	10	.	.	.
18637	14875	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14875	2	14	14	CD
18637	14875	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14875	4	256	256	CD
18637	14875	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14875	6	368	368	CD
18637	14875	7	,	,	,
18637	14875	8	375	375	CD
18637	14875	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14875	10	1921	1921	CD
18637	14875	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14875	12	.	.	.
18637	14876	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14876	2	15	15	CD
18637	14876	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14876	4	282	282	CD
18637	14876	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14876	6	716	716	CD
18637	14876	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14876	8	1931	1931	CD
18637	14876	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14876	10	.	.	.
18637	14877	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14877	2	16	16	CD
18637	14877	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14877	4	Hawke	Hawke	NNP
18637	14877	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14877	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14877	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14877	8	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	14877	9	,	,	,
18637	14877	10	253	253	CD
18637	14877	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14877	12	221	221	CD
18637	14877	13	,	,	,
18637	14877	14	231	231	CD
18637	14877	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14877	16	1920	1920	CD
18637	14877	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14877	18	.	.	.
18637	14878	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14878	2	17	17	CD
18637	14878	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14878	4	Leser	Leser	NNP
18637	14878	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14878	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14878	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14878	8	Garnett	Garnett	NNP
18637	14878	9	,	,	,
18637	14878	10	258	258	CD
18637	14878	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14878	12	130	130	CD
18637	14878	13	,	,	,
18637	14878	14	137	137	CD
18637	14878	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14878	16	1922	1922	CD
18637	14878	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14878	18	.	.	.
18637	14879	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14879	2	18	18	CD
18637	14879	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14879	4	Leser	Leser	NNP
18637	14879	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14879	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14879	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14879	8	Garnett	Garnett	NNP
18637	14879	9	,	,	,
18637	14879	10	258	258	CD
18637	14879	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14879	12	130	130	CD
18637	14879	13	,	,	,
18637	14879	14	137	137	CD
18637	14879	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14879	16	1922	1922	CD
18637	14879	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14879	18	.	.	.
18637	14880	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14880	2	19	19	CD
18637	14880	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14880	4	64	64	CD
18637	14880	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	14880	6	.	.	.
18637	14881	1	979	979	CD
18637	14881	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14881	3	1950	1950	CD
18637	14881	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14881	5	.	.	.
18637	14882	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14882	2	20	20	CD
18637	14882	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14882	4	256	256	CD
18637	14882	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14882	6	368	368	CD
18637	14882	7	,	,	,
18637	14882	8	376	376	CD
18637	14882	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14882	10	1921	1921	CD
18637	14882	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14882	12	.	.	.
18637	14883	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14883	2	21	21	CD
18637	14883	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14883	4	Leser	Leser	NNP
18637	14883	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14883	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14883	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14883	8	Garnett	Garnett	NNP
18637	14883	9	,	,	,
18637	14883	10	258	258	CD
18637	14883	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14883	12	130	130	CD
18637	14883	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14883	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	14883	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14883	16	.	.	.
18637	14884	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14884	2	22	22	CD
18637	14884	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14884	4	307	307	CD
18637	14884	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14884	6	433	433	CD
18637	14884	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14884	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	14884	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14884	10	.	.	.
18637	14885	1	_	_	NNP
18637	14885	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	14885	3	.	.	.
18637	14885	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14885	5	Fairchild	Fairchild	NNP
18637	14885	6	_	_	NNP
18637	14885	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	14885	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14885	9	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	14885	10	,	,	,
18637	14885	11	258	258	CD
18637	14885	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14885	13	126	126	CD
18637	14885	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14885	15	1922	1922	CD
18637	14885	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14885	17	,	,	,
18637	14885	18	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	14885	19	the	the	DT
18637	14885	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14885	21	held	hold	VBD
18637	14885	22	that	that	IN
18637	14885	23	a	a	DT
18637	14885	24	private	private	JJ
18637	14885	25	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	14885	26	could	could	MD
18637	14885	27	not	not	RB
18637	14885	28	sue	sue	VB
18637	14885	29	in	in	IN
18637	14885	30	the	the	DT
18637	14885	31	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14885	32	courts	court	NNS
18637	14885	33	to	to	TO
18637	14885	34	secure	secure	VB
18637	14885	35	an	an	DT
18637	14885	36	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	14885	37	determination	determination	NN
18637	14885	38	of	of	IN
18637	14885	39	the	the	DT
18637	14885	40	validity	validity	NN
18637	14885	41	of	of	IN
18637	14885	42	a	a	DT
18637	14885	43	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	14885	44	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	14885	45	about	about	IN
18637	14885	46	to	to	TO
18637	14885	47	be	be	VB
18637	14885	48	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	14885	49	.	.	.
18637	14886	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14886	2	23	23	CD
18637	14886	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14886	4	307	307	CD
18637	14886	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14886	6	433	433	CD
18637	14886	7	,	,	,
18637	14886	8	459	459	CD
18637	14886	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14886	10	1939	1939	CD
18637	14886	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14886	12	.	.	.
18637	14887	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14887	2	24	24	CD
18637	14887	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14887	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14887	5	.	.	.
18637	14888	1	446	446	CD
18637	14888	2	,	,	,
18637	14888	3	447	447	CD
18637	14888	4	.	.	.
18637	14889	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14889	2	25	25	CD
18637	14889	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14889	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	14889	5	.	.	.
18637	14890	1	450	450	CD
18637	14890	2	,	,	,
18637	14890	3	456	456	CD
18637	14890	4	.	.	.
18637	14891	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14891	2	26	26	CD
18637	14891	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14891	4	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	14891	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14891	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	14891	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14891	8	Wise	Wise	NNP
18637	14891	9	,	,	,
18637	14891	10	307	307	CD
18637	14891	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	14891	12	474	474	CD
18637	14891	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	14891	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	14891	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	14891	16	.	.	.
18637	14892	1	ARTICLE	article	NN
18637	14892	2	VI	vi	NN
18637	14892	3	MISCELLANEOUS	MISCELLANEOUS	NNP
18637	14892	4	PROVISIONS	PROVISIONS	NNP
18637	14892	5	Page	Page	NNP
18637	14892	6	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	14892	7	1	1	CD
18637	14892	8	.	.	.
18637	14893	1	Validity	Validity	NNP
18637	14893	2	of	of	IN
18637	14893	3	debts	debt	NNS
18637	14893	4	and	and	CC
18637	14893	5	engagements	engagement	VBZ
18637	14893	6	721	721	CD
18637	14893	7	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	14893	8	2	2	CD
18637	14893	9	.	.	.
18637	14894	1	Supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	14894	2	of	of	IN
18637	14894	3	the	the	DT
18637	14894	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14894	5	,	,	,
18637	14894	6	etc	etc	FW
18637	14894	7	.	.	.
18637	14895	1	721	721	CD
18637	14895	2	National	national	JJ
18637	14895	3	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	14895	4	721	721	CD
18637	14895	5	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	14895	6	's	's	POS
18637	14895	7	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	14895	8	of	of	IN
18637	14895	9	the	the	DT
18637	14895	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	14895	11	721	721	CD
18637	14895	12	Supremacy	Supremacy	NNP
18637	14895	13	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	14895	14	versus	versus	IN
18637	14895	15	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	14895	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	14895	17	722	722	CD
18637	14895	18	Status	Status	NNP
18637	14895	19	of	of	IN
18637	14895	20	the	the	DT
18637	14895	21	issue	issue	NN
18637	14895	22	today	today	NN
18637	14895	23	723	723	CD
18637	14895	24	Task	Task	NNP
18637	14895	25	of	of	IN
18637	14895	26	the	the	DT
18637	14895	27	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14895	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14895	29	under	under	IN
18637	14895	30	the	the	DT
18637	14895	31	clause	clause	NN
18637	14895	32	724	724	CD
18637	14895	33	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	14895	34	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	14895	35	and	and	CC
18637	14895	36	the	the	DT
18637	14895	37	State	State	NNP
18637	14895	38	police	police	NN
18637	14895	39	power	power	NN
18637	14895	40	725	725	CD
18637	14895	41	Obligation	Obligation	NNP
18637	14895	42	of	of	IN
18637	14895	43	State	State	NNP
18637	14895	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	14895	45	under	under	IN
18637	14895	46	the	the	DT
18637	14895	47	Supremacy	Supremacy	NNP
18637	14895	48	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	14895	49	726	726	CD
18637	14895	50	Immunity	immunity	NN
18637	14895	51	of	of	IN
18637	14895	52	the	the	DT
18637	14895	53	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14895	54	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	14895	55	process	process	NN
18637	14895	56	727	727	CD
18637	14895	57	Effect	effect	NN
18637	14895	58	of	of	IN
18637	14895	59	laws	law	NNS
18637	14895	60	passed	pass	VBN
18637	14895	61	by	by	IN
18637	14895	62	States	state	NNS
18637	14895	63	in	in	IN
18637	14895	64	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	14895	65	728	728	CD
18637	14895	66	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	14895	67	of	of	IN
18637	14895	68	tax	tax	NN
18637	14895	69	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	14895	70	728	728	CD
18637	14895	71	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	14895	72	_	_	NNP
18637	14895	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	14895	74	_	_	NNP
18637	14895	75	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	14895	76	728	728	CD
18637	14895	77	Applicability	Applicability	NNP
18637	14895	78	of	of	IN
18637	14895	79	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	14895	80	in	in	IN
18637	14895	81	re	re	IN
18637	14895	82	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14895	83	securities	security	NNS
18637	14895	84	,	,	,
18637	14895	85	etc	etc	FW
18637	14895	86	.	.	.
18637	14896	1	729	729	CD
18637	14896	2	Taxability	taxability	NN
18637	14896	3	of	of	IN
18637	14896	4	government	government	NN
18637	14896	5	contractors	contractor	VBZ
18637	14896	6	730	730	CD
18637	14896	7	Status	status	NN
18637	14896	8	of	of	IN
18637	14896	9	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	14896	10	today	today	NN
18637	14896	11	731	731	CD
18637	14896	12	Ad	ad	NN
18637	14896	13	valorem	valorem	NN
18637	14896	14	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	14896	15	under	under	IN
18637	14896	16	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	14896	17	732	732	CD
18637	14896	18	Public	public	JJ
18637	14896	19	property	property	NN
18637	14896	20	and	and	CC
18637	14896	21	functions	function	NNS
18637	14896	22	732	732	CD
18637	14896	23	Fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	14896	24	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	14896	25	;	;	,
18637	14896	26	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	14896	27	exemptions	exemption	NNS
18637	14896	28	733	733	CD
18637	14896	29	Atomic	Atomic	NNP
18637	14896	30	Energy	Energy	NNP
18637	14896	31	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	14896	32	734	734	CD
18637	14896	33	Royalties	Royalties	NNPS
18637	14896	34	;	;	:
18637	14896	35	a	a	DT
18637	14896	36	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	14896	37	anticlimax	anticlimax	NN
18637	14896	38	734	734	CD
18637	14896	39	Immunity	immunity	NN
18637	14896	40	of	of	IN
18637	14896	41	lessees	lessee	NNS
18637	14896	42	of	of	IN
18637	14896	43	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	14896	44	lands	land	NNS
18637	14896	45	735	735	CD
18637	14896	46	Summation	summation	NN
18637	14896	47	and	and	CC
18637	14896	48	evaluation	evaluation	NN
18637	14896	49	735	735	CD
18637	14896	50	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	14896	51	3	3	CD
18637	14896	52	.	.	.
18637	14897	1	Oath	Oath	NNP
18637	14897	2	of	of	IN
18637	14897	3	office	office	NN
18637	14897	4	736	736	CD
18637	14897	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	14897	6	of	of	IN
18637	14897	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14897	8	in	in	IN
18637	14897	9	respect	respect	NN
18637	14897	10	to	to	IN
18637	14897	11	oaths	oaths	NNP
18637	14897	12	736	736	CD
18637	14897	13	National	national	JJ
18637	14897	14	duties	duty	NNS
18637	14897	15	of	of	IN
18637	14897	16	State	state	NN
18637	14897	17	officers	officer	NNS
18637	14897	18	736	736	CD
18637	14897	19	MISCELLANEOUS	miscellaneous	JJ
18637	14897	20	PROVISIONS	PROVISIONS	NNP
18637	14897	21	Article	Article	NNP
18637	14897	22	VI	VI	NNP
18637	14897	23	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	14897	24	1	1	CD
18637	14897	25	.	.	.
18637	14898	1	All	all	DT
18637	14898	2	Debts	debt	NNS
18637	14898	3	contracted	contract	VBD
18637	14898	4	and	and	CC
18637	14898	5	Engagements	Engagements	NNPS
18637	14898	6	entered	enter	VBD
18637	14898	7	into	into	IN
18637	14898	8	,	,	,
18637	14898	9	before	before	IN
18637	14898	10	the	the	DT
18637	14898	11	Adoption	Adoption	NNP
18637	14898	12	of	of	IN
18637	14898	13	this	this	DT
18637	14898	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14898	15	,	,	,
18637	14898	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	14898	17	be	be	VB
18637	14898	18	as	as	RB
18637	14898	19	valid	valid	JJ
18637	14898	20	against	against	IN
18637	14898	21	the	the	DT
18637	14898	22	United	United	NNP
18637	14898	23	States	States	NNP
18637	14898	24	under	under	IN
18637	14898	25	this	this	DT
18637	14898	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14898	27	,	,	,
18637	14898	28	as	as	IN
18637	14898	29	under	under	IN
18637	14898	30	the	the	DT
18637	14898	31	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	14898	32	.	.	.
18637	14899	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	14899	2	2	2	CD
18637	14899	3	.	.	.
18637	14900	1	This	this	DT
18637	14900	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14900	3	,	,	,
18637	14900	4	and	and	CC
18637	14900	5	the	the	DT
18637	14900	6	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	14900	7	of	of	IN
18637	14900	8	the	the	DT
18637	14900	9	United	United	NNP
18637	14900	10	States	States	NNP
18637	14900	11	which	which	WDT
18637	14900	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	14900	13	be	be	VB
18637	14900	14	made	make	VBN
18637	14900	15	in	in	IN
18637	14900	16	Pursuance	Pursuance	NNP
18637	14900	17	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	14900	18	;	;	:
18637	14900	19	and	and	CC
18637	14900	20	all	all	DT
18637	14900	21	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	14900	22	made	make	VBD
18637	14900	23	,	,	,
18637	14900	24	or	or	CC
18637	14900	25	which	which	WDT
18637	14900	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	14900	27	be	be	VB
18637	14900	28	made	make	VBN
18637	14900	29	,	,	,
18637	14900	30	under	under	IN
18637	14900	31	the	the	DT
18637	14900	32	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	14900	33	of	of	IN
18637	14900	34	the	the	DT
18637	14900	35	United	United	NNP
18637	14900	36	States	States	NNP
18637	14900	37	,	,	,
18637	14900	38	shall	shall	MD
18637	14900	39	be	be	VB
18637	14900	40	the	the	DT
18637	14900	41	supreme	supreme	JJ
18637	14900	42	Law	Law	NNP
18637	14900	43	of	of	IN
18637	14900	44	the	the	DT
18637	14900	45	Land	Land	NNP
18637	14900	46	;	;	:
18637	14900	47	and	and	CC
18637	14900	48	the	the	DT
18637	14900	49	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	14900	50	in	in	IN
18637	14900	51	every	every	DT
18637	14900	52	State	state	NN
18637	14900	53	shall	shall	MD
18637	14900	54	be	be	VB
18637	14900	55	bound	bind	VBN
18637	14900	56	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	14900	57	,	,	,
18637	14900	58	any	any	DT
18637	14900	59	Thing	thing	NN
18637	14900	60	in	in	IN
18637	14900	61	the	the	DT
18637	14900	62	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14900	63	or	or	CC
18637	14900	64	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	14900	65	of	of	IN
18637	14900	66	any	any	DT
18637	14900	67	State	State	NNP
18637	14900	68	to	to	IN
18637	14900	69	the	the	DT
18637	14900	70	Contrary	Contrary	NNP
18637	14900	71	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	14900	72	.	.	.
18637	14901	1	National	National	NNP
18637	14901	2	Supremacy	Supremacy	NNP
18637	14901	3	MARSHALL	MARSHALL	NNP
18637	14901	4	'S	's	POS
18637	14901	5	INTERPRETATION	interpretation	NN
18637	14901	6	OF	of	IN
18637	14901	7	THE	the	DT
18637	14901	8	CLAUSE	CLAUSE	NNP
18637	14901	9	Although	although	IN
18637	14901	10	the	the	DT
18637	14901	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14901	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14901	13	had	have	VBD
18637	14901	14	held	hold	VBN
18637	14901	15	prior	prior	RB
18637	14901	16	to	to	IN
18637	14901	17	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	14901	18	's	's	POS
18637	14901	19	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	14901	20	to	to	IN
18637	14901	21	the	the	DT
18637	14901	22	Bench	Bench	NNP
18637	14901	23	,	,	,
18637	14901	24	that	that	IN
18637	14901	25	the	the	DT
18637	14901	26	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	14901	27	clause	clause	NN
18637	14901	28	rendered	render	VBD
18637	14901	29	null	null	JJ
18637	14901	30	and	and	CC
18637	14901	31	void	void	JJ
18637	14901	32	a	a	DT
18637	14901	33	State	state	NN
18637	14901	34	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	14901	35	or	or	CC
18637	14901	36	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	14901	37	provision	provision	NN
18637	14901	38	which	which	WDT
18637	14901	39	was	be	VBD
18637	14901	40	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	14901	41	with	with	IN
18637	14901	42	a	a	DT
18637	14901	43	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	14901	44	executed	execute	VBN
18637	14901	45	by	by	IN
18637	14901	46	the	the	DT
18637	14901	47	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	14901	48	Government,[1	Government,[1	NNP
18637	14901	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14901	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14901	51	was	be	VBD
18637	14901	52	left	leave	VBN
18637	14901	53	for	for	IN
18637	14901	54	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14901	55	to	to	TO
18637	14901	56	develop	develop	VB
18637	14901	57	the	the	DT
18637	14901	58	full	full	JJ
18637	14901	59	significance	significance	NN
18637	14901	60	of	of	IN
18637	14901	61	the	the	DT
18637	14901	62	clause	clause	NN
18637	14901	63	as	as	IN
18637	14901	64	applied	apply	VBN
18637	14901	65	to	to	IN
18637	14901	66	acts	act	NNS
18637	14901	67	of	of	IN
18637	14901	68	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14901	69	.	.	.
18637	14902	1	By	by	IN
18637	14902	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14902	3	vigorous	vigorous	JJ
18637	14902	4	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	14902	5	in	in	IN
18637	14902	6	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	14902	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14902	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14902	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14902	10	Maryland[2	Maryland[2	NNP
18637	14902	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14902	12	and	and	CC
18637	14902	13	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNPS
18637	14902	14	_	_	NNP
18637	14902	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	14902	16	_	_	NNP
18637	14902	17	Ogden[3	Ogden[3	NNP
18637	14902	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14902	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14902	20	gave	give	VBD
18637	14902	21	the	the	DT
18637	14902	22	principle	principle	NN
18637	14902	23	a	a	DT
18637	14902	24	vitality	vitality	NN
18637	14902	25	which	which	WDT
18637	14902	26	survived	survive	VBD
18637	14902	27	a	a	DT
18637	14902	28	century	century	NN
18637	14902	29	of	of	IN
18637	14902	30	vacillation	vacillation	NN
18637	14902	31	under	under	IN
18637	14902	32	the	the	DT
18637	14902	33	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	14902	34	of	of	IN
18637	14902	35	dual	dual	JJ
18637	14902	36	federalism	federalism	NN
18637	14902	37	.	.	.
18637	14903	1	In	in	IN
18637	14903	2	the	the	DT
18637	14903	3	former	former	JJ
18637	14903	4	case	case	NN
18637	14903	5	,	,	,
18637	14903	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14903	7	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	14903	8	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	14903	9	that	that	IN
18637	14903	10	"	"	``
18637	14903	11	the	the	DT
18637	14903	12	States	state	NNS
18637	14903	13	have	have	VBP
18637	14903	14	no	no	DT
18637	14903	15	power	power	NN
18637	14903	16	,	,	,
18637	14903	17	by	by	IN
18637	14903	18	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	14903	19	or	or	CC
18637	14903	20	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	14903	21	,	,	,
18637	14903	22	to	to	TO
18637	14903	23	retard	retard	VB
18637	14903	24	,	,	,
18637	14903	25	impede	impede	NNP
18637	14903	26	,	,	,
18637	14903	27	burden	burden	NN
18637	14903	28	,	,	,
18637	14903	29	or	or	CC
18637	14903	30	in	in	IN
18637	14903	31	any	any	DT
18637	14903	32	manner	manner	NN
18637	14903	33	control	control	NN
18637	14903	34	,	,	,
18637	14903	35	the	the	DT
18637	14903	36	operations	operation	NNS
18637	14903	37	of	of	IN
18637	14903	38	the	the	DT
18637	14903	39	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	14903	40	laws	law	NNS
18637	14903	41	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	14903	42	by	by	IN
18637	14903	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14903	44	to	to	TO
18637	14903	45	carry	carry	VB
18637	14903	46	into	into	IN
18637	14903	47	execution	execution	NN
18637	14903	48	the	the	DT
18637	14903	49	powers	power	NNS
18637	14903	50	vested	vest	VBN
18637	14903	51	in	in	IN
18637	14903	52	the	the	DT
18637	14903	53	general	general	JJ
18637	14903	54	government	government	NN
18637	14903	55	.	.	.
18637	14904	1	This	this	DT
18637	14904	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	14904	3	,	,	,
18637	14904	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14904	5	think	think	VBP
18637	14904	6	,	,	,
18637	14904	7	the	the	DT
18637	14904	8	unavoidable	unavoidable	JJ
18637	14904	9	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	14904	10	of	of	IN
18637	14904	11	that	that	DT
18637	14904	12	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	14904	13	which	which	WDT
18637	14904	14	the	the	DT
18637	14904	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14904	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	14904	17	declared	declare	VBN
18637	14904	18	.	.	.
18637	14905	1	"	"	``
18637	14905	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14905	3	4	4	CD
18637	14905	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14905	5	From	from	IN
18637	14905	6	this	this	DT
18637	14905	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14905	8	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	14905	9	that	that	IN
18637	14905	10	a	a	DT
18637	14905	11	State	State	NNP
18637	14905	12	tax	tax	NN
18637	14905	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	14905	14	notes	note	NNS
18637	14905	15	issued	issue	VBN
18637	14905	16	by	by	IN
18637	14905	17	a	a	DT
18637	14905	18	branch	branch	NN
18637	14905	19	of	of	IN
18637	14905	20	the	the	DT
18637	14905	21	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	14905	22	of	of	IN
18637	14905	23	the	the	DT
18637	14905	24	United	United	NNP
18637	14905	25	States	States	NNP
18637	14905	26	was	be	VBD
18637	14905	27	void	void	JJ
18637	14905	28	.	.	.
18637	14906	1	In	in	IN
18637	14906	2	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	14906	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14906	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	14906	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14906	6	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	14906	7	,	,	,
18637	14906	8	the	the	DT
18637	14906	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14906	10	held	hold	VBD
18637	14906	11	that	that	IN
18637	14906	12	certain	certain	JJ
18637	14906	13	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	14906	14	of	of	IN
18637	14906	15	New	New	NNP
18637	14906	16	York	York	NNP
18637	14906	17	granting	grant	VBG
18637	14906	18	an	an	DT
18637	14906	19	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	14906	20	right	right	NN
18637	14906	21	to	to	TO
18637	14906	22	use	use	VB
18637	14906	23	steam	steam	NN
18637	14906	24	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	14906	25	on	on	IN
18637	14906	26	the	the	DT
18637	14906	27	waters	water	NNS
18637	14906	28	of	of	IN
18637	14906	29	the	the	DT
18637	14906	30	State	State	NNP
18637	14906	31	were	be	VBD
18637	14906	32	null	null	JJ
18637	14906	33	and	and	CC
18637	14906	34	void	void	JJ
18637	14906	35	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	14906	36	as	as	IN
18637	14906	37	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14906	38	applied	apply	VBD
18637	14906	39	to	to	IN
18637	14906	40	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	14906	41	licensed	license	VBN
18637	14906	42	by	by	IN
18637	14906	43	the	the	DT
18637	14906	44	United	United	NNP
18637	14906	45	States	States	NNP
18637	14906	46	to	to	TO
18637	14906	47	engage	engage	VB
18637	14906	48	in	in	IN
18637	14906	49	coastwise	coastwise	JJ
18637	14906	50	trade	trade	NN
18637	14906	51	.	.	.
18637	14907	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	14907	2	the	the	DT
18637	14907	3	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	14907	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14907	5	:	:	:
18637	14907	6	"	"	``
18637	14907	7	In	in	IN
18637	14907	8	argument	argument	NN
18637	14907	9	,	,	,
18637	14907	10	however	however	RB
18637	14907	11	,	,	,
18637	14907	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14907	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	14907	14	been	be	VBN
18637	14907	15	contended	contend	VBN
18637	14907	16	,	,	,
18637	14907	17	that	that	IN
18637	14907	18	if	if	IN
18637	14907	19	a	a	DT
18637	14907	20	law	law	NN
18637	14907	21	passed	pass	VBN
18637	14907	22	by	by	IN
18637	14907	23	a	a	DT
18637	14907	24	State	State	NNP
18637	14907	25	,	,	,
18637	14907	26	in	in	IN
18637	14907	27	the	the	DT
18637	14907	28	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	14907	29	of	of	IN
18637	14907	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14907	31	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	14907	32	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	14907	33	,	,	,
18637	14907	34	comes	come	VBZ
18637	14907	35	into	into	IN
18637	14907	36	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	14907	37	with	with	IN
18637	14907	38	a	a	DT
18637	14907	39	law	law	NN
18637	14907	40	passed	pass	VBN
18637	14907	41	by	by	IN
18637	14907	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14907	43	in	in	IN
18637	14907	44	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	14907	45	of	of	IN
18637	14907	46	the	the	DT
18637	14907	47	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14907	48	,	,	,
18637	14907	49	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14907	50	affect	affect	VBP
18637	14907	51	the	the	DT
18637	14907	52	subject	subject	NN
18637	14907	53	,	,	,
18637	14907	54	and	and	CC
18637	14907	55	each	each	DT
18637	14907	56	other	other	JJ
18637	14907	57	,	,	,
18637	14907	58	like	like	IN
18637	14907	59	equal	equal	JJ
18637	14907	60	opposing	opposing	NN
18637	14907	61	powers	power	NNS
18637	14907	62	.	.	.
18637	14908	1	But	but	CC
18637	14908	2	the	the	DT
18637	14908	3	framers	framer	NNS
18637	14908	4	of	of	IN
18637	14908	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14908	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14908	7	foresaw	foresaw	NN
18637	14908	8	this	this	DT
18637	14908	9	state	state	NN
18637	14908	10	of	of	IN
18637	14908	11	things	thing	NNS
18637	14908	12	,	,	,
18637	14908	13	and	and	CC
18637	14908	14	provided	provide	VBN
18637	14908	15	for	for	IN
18637	14908	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14908	17	,	,	,
18637	14908	18	by	by	IN
18637	14908	19	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	14908	20	the	the	DT
18637	14908	21	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	14908	22	not	not	RB
18637	14908	23	only	only	RB
18637	14908	24	of	of	IN
18637	14908	25	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14908	26	,	,	,
18637	14908	27	but	but	CC
18637	14908	28	of	of	IN
18637	14908	29	the	the	DT
18637	14908	30	laws	law	NNS
18637	14908	31	made	make	VBN
18637	14908	32	in	in	IN
18637	14908	33	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	14908	34	of	of	IN
18637	14908	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14908	36	.	.	.
18637	14909	1	The	the	DT
18637	14909	2	nullity	nullity	NN
18637	14909	3	of	of	IN
18637	14909	4	an	an	DT
18637	14909	5	act	act	NN
18637	14909	6	,	,	,
18637	14909	7	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	14909	8	with	with	IN
18637	14909	9	the	the	DT
18637	14909	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14909	11	,	,	,
18637	14909	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	14909	13	produced	produce	VBN
18637	14909	14	by	by	IN
18637	14909	15	the	the	DT
18637	14909	16	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	14909	17	,	,	,
18637	14909	18	that	that	IN
18637	14909	19	the	the	DT
18637	14909	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14909	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	14909	22	the	the	DT
18637	14909	23	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	14909	24	law	law	NNP
18637	14909	25	.	.	.
18637	14910	1	The	the	DT
18637	14910	2	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	14910	3	application	application	NN
18637	14910	4	of	of	IN
18637	14910	5	that	that	DT
18637	14910	6	part	part	NN
18637	14910	7	of	of	IN
18637	14910	8	the	the	DT
18637	14910	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	14910	10	which	which	WDT
18637	14910	11	confers	confer	VBZ
18637	14910	12	the	the	DT
18637	14910	13	same	same	JJ
18637	14910	14	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	14910	15	on	on	IN
18637	14910	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	14910	17	and	and	CC
18637	14910	18	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	14910	19	,	,	,
18637	14910	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	14910	21	to	to	IN
18637	14910	22	such	such	JJ
18637	14910	23	acts	act	NNS
18637	14910	24	of	of	IN
18637	14910	25	the	the	DT
18637	14910	26	State	State	NNP
18637	14910	27	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	14910	28	as	as	IN
18637	14910	29	do	do	VBP
18637	14910	30	not	not	RB
18637	14910	31	transcend	transcend	VB
18637	14910	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14910	33	powers	power	NNS
18637	14910	34	,	,	,
18637	14910	35	but	but	CC
18637	14910	36	though	though	IN
18637	14910	37	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	14910	38	in	in	IN
18637	14910	39	the	the	DT
18637	14910	40	execution	execution	NN
18637	14910	41	of	of	IN
18637	14910	42	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	14910	43	State	State	NNP
18637	14910	44	powers	power	NNS
18637	14910	45	,	,	,
18637	14910	46	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	14910	47	with	with	IN
18637	14910	48	,	,	,
18637	14910	49	or	or	CC
18637	14910	50	are	be	VBP
18637	14910	51	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	14910	52	to	to	IN
18637	14910	53	the	the	DT
18637	14910	54	laws	law	NNS
18637	14910	55	of	of	IN
18637	14910	56	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14910	57	,	,	,
18637	14910	58	made	make	VBN
18637	14910	59	in	in	IN
18637	14910	60	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	14910	61	of	of	IN
18637	14910	62	the	the	DT
18637	14910	63	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14910	64	,	,	,
18637	14910	65	or	or	CC
18637	14910	66	some	some	DT
18637	14910	67	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	14910	68	made	make	VBN
18637	14910	69	under	under	IN
18637	14910	70	the	the	DT
18637	14910	71	authority	authority	NN
18637	14910	72	of	of	IN
18637	14910	73	the	the	DT
18637	14910	74	United	United	NNP
18637	14910	75	States	States	NNP
18637	14910	76	.	.	.
18637	14911	1	In	in	IN
18637	14911	2	every	every	DT
18637	14911	3	such	such	JJ
18637	14911	4	case	case	NN
18637	14911	5	,	,	,
18637	14911	6	the	the	DT
18637	14911	7	act	act	NN
18637	14911	8	of	of	IN
18637	14911	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14911	10	,	,	,
18637	14911	11	or	or	CC
18637	14911	12	the	the	DT
18637	14911	13	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	14911	14	,	,	,
18637	14911	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	14911	16	supreme	supreme	JJ
18637	14911	17	;	;	:
18637	14911	18	and	and	CC
18637	14911	19	the	the	DT
18637	14911	20	law	law	NN
18637	14911	21	of	of	IN
18637	14911	22	the	the	DT
18637	14911	23	State	State	NNP
18637	14911	24	,	,	,
18637	14911	25	though	though	IN
18637	14911	26	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	14911	27	in	in	IN
18637	14911	28	the	the	DT
18637	14911	29	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	14911	30	of	of	IN
18637	14911	31	powers	power	NNS
18637	14911	32	not	not	RB
18637	14911	33	controverted	controvert	VBN
18637	14911	34	,	,	,
18637	14911	35	must	must	MD
18637	14911	36	yield	yield	VB
18637	14911	37	to	to	IN
18637	14911	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14911	39	.	.	.
18637	14912	1	"	"	``
18637	14912	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14912	3	5	5	CD
18637	14912	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14912	5	SUPREMACY	SUPREMACY	NNP
18637	14912	6	CLAUSE	clause	NN
18637	14912	7	VERSUS	versu	NNS
18637	14912	8	TENTH	TENTH	NNP
18637	14912	9	AMENDMENT	amendment	NN
18637	14912	10	The	the	DT
18637	14912	11	logic	logic	NN
18637	14912	12	of	of	IN
18637	14912	13	the	the	DT
18637	14912	14	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	14912	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	14912	16	would	would	MD
18637	14912	17	seem	seem	VB
18637	14912	18	to	to	TO
18637	14912	19	require	require	VB
18637	14912	20	that	that	IN
18637	14912	21	the	the	DT
18637	14912	22	powers	power	NNS
18637	14912	23	of	of	IN
18637	14912	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14912	25	be	be	VB
18637	14912	26	determined	determine	VBN
18637	14912	27	by	by	IN
18637	14912	28	the	the	DT
18637	14912	29	fair	fair	JJ
18637	14912	30	reading	reading	NN
18637	14912	31	of	of	IN
18637	14912	32	the	the	DT
18637	14912	33	express	express	JJ
18637	14912	34	and	and	CC
18637	14912	35	implied	implied	JJ
18637	14912	36	grants	grant	NNS
18637	14912	37	contained	contain	VBN
18637	14912	38	in	in	IN
18637	14912	39	the	the	DT
18637	14912	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14912	41	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14912	42	,	,	,
18637	14912	43	without	without	IN
18637	14912	44	reference	reference	NN
18637	14912	45	to	to	IN
18637	14912	46	the	the	DT
18637	14912	47	powers	power	NNS
18637	14912	48	of	of	IN
18637	14912	49	the	the	DT
18637	14912	50	States	States	NNP
18637	14912	51	.	.	.
18637	14913	1	For	for	IN
18637	14913	2	a	a	DT
18637	14913	3	century	century	NN
18637	14913	4	after	after	IN
18637	14913	5	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	14913	6	's	's	POS
18637	14913	7	death	death	NN
18637	14913	8	,	,	,
18637	14913	9	however	however	RB
18637	14913	10	,	,	,
18637	14913	11	the	the	DT
18637	14913	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14913	13	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	14913	14	on	on	IN
18637	14913	15	the	the	DT
18637	14913	16	theory	theory	NN
18637	14913	17	that	that	IN
18637	14913	18	the	the	DT
18637	14913	19	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	14913	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	14913	21	had	have	VBD
18637	14913	22	the	the	DT
18637	14913	23	effect	effect	NN
18637	14913	24	of	of	IN
18637	14913	25	withdrawing	withdraw	VBG
18637	14913	26	various	various	JJ
18637	14913	27	matters	matter	NNS
18637	14913	28	of	of	IN
18637	14913	29	internal	internal	JJ
18637	14913	30	police	police	NNS
18637	14913	31	from	from	IN
18637	14913	32	the	the	DT
18637	14913	33	reach	reach	NN
18637	14913	34	of	of	IN
18637	14913	35	power	power	NN
18637	14913	36	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	14913	37	committed	commit	VBN
18637	14913	38	to	to	IN
18637	14913	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14913	40	.	.	.
18637	14914	1	This	this	DT
18637	14914	2	point	point	NN
18637	14914	3	of	of	IN
18637	14914	4	view	view	NN
18637	14914	5	was	be	VBD
18637	14914	6	originally	originally	RB
18637	14914	7	put	put	VBN
18637	14914	8	forward	forward	RB
18637	14914	9	in	in	IN
18637	14914	10	New	New	NNP
18637	14914	11	York	York	NNP
18637	14914	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14914	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	14914	14	_	_	NNP
18637	14914	15	Miln,[6	Miln,[6	NNP
18637	14914	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14914	17	which	which	WDT
18637	14914	18	was	be	VBD
18637	14914	19	first	first	RB
18637	14914	20	argued	argue	VBN
18637	14914	21	,	,	,
18637	14914	22	but	but	CC
18637	14914	23	not	not	RB
18637	14914	24	decided	decide	VBN
18637	14914	25	,	,	,
18637	14914	26	before	before	IN
18637	14914	27	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	14914	28	's	's	POS
18637	14914	29	death	death	NN
18637	14914	30	.	.	.
18637	14915	1	The	the	DT
18637	14915	2	Miln	Miln	NNP
18637	14915	3	Case	Case	NNP
18637	14915	4	involved	involve	VBD
18637	14915	5	a	a	DT
18637	14915	6	New	New	NNP
18637	14915	7	York	York	NNP
18637	14915	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	14915	9	which	which	WDT
18637	14915	10	required	require	VBD
18637	14915	11	the	the	DT
18637	14915	12	captains	captain	NNS
18637	14915	13	of	of	IN
18637	14915	14	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	14915	15	entering	enter	VBG
18637	14915	16	New	New	NNP
18637	14915	17	York	York	NNP
18637	14915	18	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	14915	19	with	with	IN
18637	14915	20	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	14915	21	aboard	aboard	RB
18637	14915	22	to	to	TO
18637	14915	23	make	make	VB
18637	14915	24	a	a	DT
18637	14915	25	report	report	NN
18637	14915	26	in	in	IN
18637	14915	27	writing	writing	NN
18637	14915	28	to	to	IN
18637	14915	29	the	the	DT
18637	14915	30	Mayor	Mayor	NNP
18637	14915	31	of	of	IN
18637	14915	32	the	the	DT
18637	14915	33	City	City	NNP
18637	14915	34	,	,	,
18637	14915	35	giving	give	VBG
18637	14915	36	certain	certain	JJ
18637	14915	37	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	14915	38	information	information	NN
18637	14915	39	.	.	.
18637	14916	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14916	2	might	may	MD
18637	14916	3	have	have	VB
18637	14916	4	been	be	VBN
18637	14916	5	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	14916	6	from	from	IN
18637	14916	7	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	14916	8	_	_	NNP
18637	14916	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	14916	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14916	11	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	14916	12	on	on	IN
18637	14916	13	the	the	DT
18637	14916	14	ground	ground	NN
18637	14916	15	that	that	IN
18637	14916	16	the	the	DT
18637	14916	17	statute	statute	NN
18637	14916	18	involved	involve	VBN
18637	14916	19	in	in	IN
18637	14916	20	the	the	DT
18637	14916	21	earlier	early	JJR
18637	14916	22	case	case	NN
18637	14916	23	conflicted	conflict	VBN
18637	14916	24	with	with	IN
18637	14916	25	an	an	DT
18637	14916	26	act	act	NN
18637	14916	27	of	of	IN
18637	14916	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14916	29	,	,	,
18637	14916	30	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	14916	31	the	the	DT
18637	14916	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14916	33	found	find	VBD
18637	14916	34	that	that	IN
18637	14916	35	no	no	DT
18637	14916	36	such	such	JJ
18637	14916	37	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	14916	38	existed	exist	VBD
18637	14916	39	in	in	IN
18637	14916	40	this	this	DT
18637	14916	41	case	case	NN
18637	14916	42	.	.	.
18637	14917	1	But	but	CC
18637	14917	2	the	the	DT
18637	14917	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14917	4	was	be	VBD
18637	14917	5	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
18637	14917	6	to	to	TO
18637	14917	7	rest	rest	VB
18637	14917	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14917	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	14917	10	on	on	IN
18637	14917	11	that	that	DT
18637	14917	12	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	14917	13	.	.	.
18637	14918	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	14918	2	for	for	IN
18637	14918	3	the	the	DT
18637	14918	4	majority	majority	NN
18637	14918	5	,	,	,
18637	14918	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14918	7	Barbour	Barbour	NNP
18637	14918	8	seized	seize	VBD
18637	14918	9	the	the	DT
18637	14918	10	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	14918	11	to	to	TO
18637	14918	12	proclaim	proclaim	VB
18637	14918	13	a	a	DT
18637	14918	14	new	new	JJ
18637	14918	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	14918	16	.	.	.
18637	14919	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14919	2	wrote	write	VBD
18637	14919	3	:	:	:
18637	14919	4	"	"	``
18637	14919	5	But	but	CC
18637	14919	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14919	7	do	do	VBP
18637	14919	8	not	not	RB
18637	14919	9	place	place	VB
18637	14919	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14919	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	14919	12	on	on	IN
18637	14919	13	this	this	DT
18637	14919	14	ground	ground	NN
18637	14919	15	.	.	.
18637	14920	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14920	2	choose	choose	VBP
18637	14920	3	rather	rather	RB
18637	14920	4	to	to	TO
18637	14920	5	plant	plant	VB
18637	14920	6	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14920	7	on	on	IN
18637	14920	8	what	what	WP
18637	14920	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14920	10	consider	consider	VBP
18637	14920	11	impregnable	impregnable	JJ
18637	14920	12	positions	position	NNS
18637	14920	13	.	.	.
18637	14921	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14921	2	are	be	VBP
18637	14921	3	these	these	DT
18637	14921	4	:	:	:
18637	14921	5	That	that	IN
18637	14921	6	a	a	DT
18637	14921	7	State	state	NN
18637	14921	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	14921	9	the	the	DT
18637	14921	10	same	same	JJ
18637	14921	11	undeniable	undeniable	JJ
18637	14921	12	and	and	CC
18637	14921	13	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	14921	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14921	15	over	over	IN
18637	14921	16	all	all	DT
18637	14921	17	persons	person	NNS
18637	14921	18	and	and	CC
18637	14921	19	things	thing	NNS
18637	14921	20	,	,	,
18637	14921	21	within	within	IN
18637	14921	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14921	23	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	14921	24	limits	limit	NNS
18637	14921	25	,	,	,
18637	14921	26	as	as	IN
18637	14921	27	any	any	DT
18637	14921	28	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	14921	29	nation	nation	NN
18637	14921	30	,	,	,
18637	14921	31	where	where	WRB
18637	14921	32	that	that	DT
18637	14921	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14921	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	14921	35	not	not	RB
18637	14921	36	surrendered	surrender	VBN
18637	14921	37	or	or	CC
18637	14921	38	restrained	restrain	VBN
18637	14921	39	by	by	IN
18637	14921	40	the	the	DT
18637	14921	41	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14921	42	of	of	IN
18637	14921	43	the	the	DT
18637	14921	44	United	United	NNP
18637	14921	45	States	States	NNP
18637	14921	46	.	.	.
18637	14922	1	That	that	IN
18637	14922	2	,	,	,
18637	14922	3	by	by	IN
18637	14922	4	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	14922	5	of	of	IN
18637	14922	6	this	this	DT
18637	14922	7	,	,	,
18637	14922	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14922	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	14922	10	not	not	RB
18637	14922	11	only	only	RB
18637	14922	12	the	the	DT
18637	14922	13	right	right	NN
18637	14922	14	,	,	,
18637	14922	15	but	but	CC
18637	14922	16	the	the	DT
18637	14922	17	bounden	bounden	JJ
18637	14922	18	and	and	CC
18637	14922	19	solemn	solemn	JJ
18637	14922	20	duty	duty	NN
18637	14922	21	of	of	IN
18637	14922	22	a	a	DT
18637	14922	23	State	state	NN
18637	14922	24	,	,	,
18637	14922	25	to	to	TO
18637	14922	26	advance	advance	VB
18637	14922	27	the	the	DT
18637	14922	28	safety	safety	NN
18637	14922	29	,	,	,
18637	14922	30	happiness	happiness	NN
18637	14922	31	and	and	CC
18637	14922	32	prosperity	prosperity	NN
18637	14922	33	of	of	IN
18637	14922	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14922	35	people	people	NNS
18637	14922	36	,	,	,
18637	14922	37	and	and	CC
18637	14922	38	to	to	TO
18637	14922	39	provide	provide	VB
18637	14922	40	for	for	IN
18637	14922	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14922	42	general	general	JJ
18637	14922	43	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	14922	44	,	,	,
18637	14922	45	by	by	IN
18637	14922	46	any	any	DT
18637	14922	47	and	and	CC
18637	14922	48	every	every	DT
18637	14922	49	act	act	NN
18637	14922	50	of	of	IN
18637	14922	51	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	14922	52	,	,	,
18637	14922	53	which	which	WDT
18637	14922	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14922	55	may	may	MD
18637	14922	56	deem	deem	VB
18637	14922	57	to	to	TO
18637	14922	58	be	be	VB
18637	14922	59	conducive	conducive	JJ
18637	14922	60	to	to	IN
18637	14922	61	these	these	DT
18637	14922	62	ends	end	NNS
18637	14922	63	;	;	:
18637	14922	64	where	where	WRB
18637	14922	65	the	the	DT
18637	14922	66	power	power	NN
18637	14922	67	over	over	IN
18637	14922	68	the	the	DT
18637	14922	69	particular	particular	JJ
18637	14922	70	subject	subject	NN
18637	14922	71	,	,	,
18637	14922	72	or	or	CC
18637	14922	73	the	the	DT
18637	14922	74	manner	manner	NN
18637	14922	75	of	of	IN
18637	14922	76	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14922	77	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	14922	78	is	be	VBZ
18637	14922	79	not	not	RB
18637	14922	80	surrendered	surrender	VBN
18637	14922	81	or	or	CC
18637	14922	82	restrained	restrain	VBN
18637	14922	83	,	,	,
18637	14922	84	in	in	IN
18637	14922	85	the	the	DT
18637	14922	86	manner	manner	NN
18637	14922	87	just	just	RB
18637	14922	88	stated	state	VBD
18637	14922	89	.	.	.
18637	14923	1	That	that	IN
18637	14923	2	all	all	PDT
18637	14923	3	those	those	DT
18637	14923	4	powers	power	NNS
18637	14923	5	which	which	WDT
18637	14923	6	relate	relate	VBP
18637	14923	7	to	to	IN
18637	14923	8	merely	merely	RB
18637	14923	9	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	14923	10	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	14923	11	,	,	,
18637	14923	12	or	or	CC
18637	14923	13	what	what	WP
18637	14923	14	may	may	MD
18637	14923	15	,	,	,
18637	14923	16	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	14923	17	,	,	,
18637	14923	18	more	more	RBR
18637	14923	19	properly	properly	RB
18637	14923	20	be	be	VB
18637	14923	21	called	call	VBN
18637	14923	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14923	23	internal	internal	JJ
18637	14923	24	police	police	NNS
18637	14923	25	_	_	NNP
18637	14923	26	,	,	,
18637	14923	27	are	be	VBP
18637	14923	28	not	not	RB
18637	14923	29	thus	thus	RB
18637	14923	30	surrendered	surrender	VBN
18637	14923	31	or	or	CC
18637	14923	32	restrained	restrain	VBD
18637	14923	33	;	;	:
18637	14923	34	and	and	CC
18637	14923	35	that	that	IN
18637	14923	36	,	,	,
18637	14923	37	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	14923	38	,	,	,
18637	14923	39	in	in	IN
18637	14923	40	relation	relation	NN
18637	14923	41	to	to	IN
18637	14923	42	these	these	DT
18637	14923	43	,	,	,
18637	14923	44	the	the	DT
18637	14923	45	authority	authority	NN
18637	14923	46	of	of	IN
18637	14923	47	a	a	DT
18637	14923	48	State	State	NNP
18637	14923	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	14923	50	complete	complete	JJ
18637	14923	51	,	,	,
18637	14923	52	unqualified	unqualified	JJ
18637	14923	53	,	,	,
18637	14923	54	and	and	CC
18637	14923	55	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	14923	56	.	.	.
18637	14924	1	"	"	``
18637	14924	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14924	3	7	7	CD
18637	14924	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14924	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14924	6	Story	Story	NNP
18637	14924	7	,	,	,
18637	14924	8	in	in	IN
18637	14924	9	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	14924	10	,	,	,
18637	14924	11	stated	state	VBD
18637	14924	12	that	that	IN
18637	14924	13	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	14924	14	had	have	VBD
18637	14924	15	heard	hear	VBN
18637	14924	16	the	the	DT
18637	14924	17	previous	previous	JJ
18637	14924	18	argument	argument	NN
18637	14924	19	and	and	CC
18637	14924	20	reached	reach	VBD
18637	14924	21	the	the	DT
18637	14924	22	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	14924	23	that	that	IN
18637	14924	24	the	the	DT
18637	14924	25	New	New	NNP
18637	14924	26	York	York	NNP
18637	14924	27	statute	statute	NN
18637	14924	28	was	be	VBD
18637	14924	29	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	14924	30	.	.	.
18637	14925	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14925	2	8	8	CD
18637	14925	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14925	4	Status	status	NN
18637	14925	5	of	of	IN
18637	14925	6	the	the	DT
18637	14925	7	Issue	issue	NN
18637	14925	8	Today	today	NN
18637	14925	9	The	the	DT
18637	14925	10	conception	conception	NN
18637	14925	11	of	of	IN
18637	14925	12	a	a	DT
18637	14925	13	"	"	``
18637	14925	14	complete	complete	JJ
18637	14925	15	,	,	,
18637	14925	16	unqualified	unqualified	JJ
18637	14925	17	and	and	CC
18637	14925	18	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	14925	19	"	"	''
18637	14925	20	police	police	NN
18637	14925	21	power	power	NN
18637	14925	22	residing	reside	VBG
18637	14925	23	in	in	IN
18637	14925	24	the	the	DT
18637	14925	25	States	States	NNP
18637	14925	26	and	and	CC
18637	14925	27	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	14925	28	the	the	DT
18637	14925	29	powers	power	NNS
18637	14925	30	of	of	IN
18637	14925	31	the	the	DT
18637	14925	32	National	National	NNP
18637	14925	33	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14925	34	was	be	VBD
18637	14925	35	endorsed	endorse	VBN
18637	14925	36	by	by	IN
18637	14925	37	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	14925	38	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14925	39	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	14925	40	ten	ten	CD
18637	14925	41	years	year	NNS
18637	14925	42	later	later	RB
18637	14925	43	in	in	IN
18637	14925	44	the	the	DT
18637	14925	45	License	License	NNP
18637	14925	46	Cases	case	NNS
18637	14925	47	.	.	.
18637	14926	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14926	2	9	9	CD
18637	14926	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14926	4	In	in	IN
18637	14926	5	upholding	uphold	VBG
18637	14926	6	State	State	NNP
18637	14926	7	laws	law	NNS
18637	14926	8	requiring	require	VBG
18637	14926	9	licenses	license	NNS
18637	14926	10	for	for	IN
18637	14926	11	the	the	DT
18637	14926	12	sale	sale	NN
18637	14926	13	of	of	IN
18637	14926	14	alcoholic	alcoholic	JJ
18637	14926	15	beverages	beverage	NNS
18637	14926	16	,	,	,
18637	14926	17	including	include	VBG
18637	14926	18	those	those	DT
18637	14926	19	imported	import	VBN
18637	14926	20	from	from	IN
18637	14926	21	other	other	JJ
18637	14926	22	States	state	NNS
18637	14926	23	or	or	CC
18637	14926	24	from	from	IN
18637	14926	25	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	14926	26	countries	country	NNS
18637	14926	27	,	,	,
18637	14926	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14926	29	set	set	VBD
18637	14926	30	up	up	RP
18637	14926	31	the	the	DT
18637	14926	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14926	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14926	34	as	as	IN
18637	14926	35	the	the	DT
18637	14926	36	final	final	JJ
18637	14926	37	arbiter	arbiter	NN
18637	14926	38	in	in	IN
18637	14926	39	drawing	draw	VBG
18637	14926	40	the	the	DT
18637	14926	41	line	line	NN
18637	14926	42	between	between	IN
18637	14926	43	the	the	DT
18637	14926	44	mutually	mutually	RB
18637	14926	45	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	14926	46	,	,	,
18637	14926	47	reciprocally	reciprocally	RB
18637	14926	48	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	14926	49	fields	field	NNS
18637	14926	50	of	of	IN
18637	14926	51	power	power	NN
18637	14926	52	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	14926	53	by	by	IN
18637	14926	54	the	the	DT
18637	14926	55	National	National	NNP
18637	14926	56	and	and	CC
18637	14926	57	State	State	NNP
18637	14926	58	Governments	Governments	NNPS
18637	14926	59	.	.	.
18637	14927	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14927	2	10	10	CD
18637	14927	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14927	4	This	this	DT
18637	14927	5	view	view	NN
18637	14927	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	14927	7	,	,	,
18637	14927	8	in	in	IN
18637	14927	9	effect	effect	NN
18637	14927	10	,	,	,
18637	14927	11	and	and	CC
18637	14927	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14927	13	would	would	MD
18637	14927	14	seem	seem	VB
18637	14927	15	in	in	IN
18637	14927	16	theory	theory	NN
18637	14927	17	also	also	RB
18637	14927	18	,	,	,
18637	14927	19	been	be	VBN
18637	14927	20	repudiated	repudiate	VBN
18637	14927	21	in	in	IN
18637	14927	22	recent	recent	JJ
18637	14927	23	cases	case	NNS
18637	14927	24	upholding	uphold	VBG
18637	14927	25	labor	labor	NN
18637	14927	26	relations,[11	relations,[11	CD
18637	14927	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14927	28	social	social	JJ
18637	14927	29	security,[12	security,[12	NNPS
18637	14927	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14927	31	and	and	CC
18637	14927	32	fair	fair	JJ
18637	14927	33	labor	labor	NN
18637	14927	34	standards	standard	NNS
18637	14927	35	acts[13	acts[13	NN
18637	14927	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14927	37	passed	pass	VBN
18637	14927	38	by	by	IN
18637	14927	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14927	40	.	.	.
18637	14928	1	TASK	TASK	NNS
18637	14928	2	OF	of	IN
18637	14928	3	THE	the	DT
18637	14928	4	SUPREME	SUPREME	NNP
18637	14928	5	COURT	COURT	NNP
18637	14928	6	UNDER	under	IN
18637	14928	7	THE	the	DT
18637	14928	8	CLAUSE	CLAUSE	NNP
18637	14928	9	In	in	IN
18637	14928	10	applying	apply	VBG
18637	14928	11	the	the	DT
18637	14928	12	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	14928	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	14928	14	to	to	IN
18637	14928	15	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	14928	16	which	which	WDT
18637	14928	17	have	have	VBP
18637	14928	18	been	be	VBN
18637	14928	19	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	14928	20	by	by	IN
18637	14928	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14928	22	,	,	,
18637	14928	23	the	the	DT
18637	14928	24	primary	primary	JJ
18637	14928	25	task	task	NN
18637	14928	26	of	of	IN
18637	14928	27	the	the	DT
18637	14928	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14928	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	14928	30	to	to	TO
18637	14928	31	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	14928	32	whether	whether	IN
18637	14928	33	a	a	DT
18637	14928	34	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	14928	35	State	State	NNP
18637	14928	36	law	law	NN
18637	14928	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	14928	38	compatible	compatible	JJ
18637	14928	39	with	with	IN
18637	14928	40	the	the	DT
18637	14928	41	policy	policy	NN
18637	14928	42	expressed	express	VBN
18637	14928	43	in	in	IN
18637	14928	44	the	the	DT
18637	14928	45	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14928	46	statute	statute	NN
18637	14928	47	.	.	.
18637	14929	1	When	when	WRB
18637	14929	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14929	3	condemns	condemn	VBZ
18637	14929	4	an	an	DT
18637	14929	5	act	act	NN
18637	14929	6	as	as	IN
18637	14929	7	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	14929	8	,	,	,
18637	14929	9	the	the	DT
18637	14929	10	extent	extent	NN
18637	14929	11	and	and	CC
18637	14929	12	nature	nature	NN
18637	14929	13	of	of	IN
18637	14929	14	the	the	DT
18637	14929	15	legal	legal	JJ
18637	14929	16	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	14929	17	of	of	IN
18637	14929	18	the	the	DT
18637	14929	19	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	14929	20	are	be	VBP
18637	14929	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14929	22	questions	question	NNS
18637	14929	23	,	,	,
18637	14929	24	the	the	DT
18637	14929	25	answers	answer	NNS
18637	14929	26	to	to	TO
18637	14929	27	which	which	WDT
18637	14929	28	are	be	VBP
18637	14929	29	to	to	TO
18637	14929	30	be	be	VB
18637	14929	31	derived	derive	VBN
18637	14929	32	from	from	IN
18637	14929	33	the	the	DT
18637	14929	34	statute	statute	NN
18637	14929	35	and	and	CC
18637	14929	36	the	the	DT
18637	14929	37	policy	policy	NN
18637	14929	38	which	which	WDT
18637	14929	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14929	40	has	have	VBZ
18637	14929	41	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	14929	42	.	.	.
18637	14930	1	To	to	IN
18637	14930	2	the	the	DT
18637	14930	3	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14930	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	14930	5	and	and	CC
18637	14930	6	policy	policy	NN
18637	14930	7	,	,	,
18637	14930	8	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	14930	9	State	state	NN
18637	14930	10	law	law	NN
18637	14930	11	and	and	CC
18637	14930	12	policy	policy	NN
18637	14930	13	must	must	MD
18637	14930	14	yield	yield	VB
18637	14930	15	.	.	.
18637	14931	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14931	2	14	14	CD
18637	14931	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14931	4	But	but	CC
18637	14931	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14931	6	in	in	IN
18637	14931	7	enacting	enact	VBG
18637	14931	8	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	14931	9	within	within	IN
18637	14931	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14931	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	14931	12	authority	authority	NN
18637	14931	13	will	will	MD
18637	14931	14	not	not	RB
18637	14931	15	be	be	VB
18637	14931	16	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	14931	17	to	to	TO
18637	14931	18	have	have	VB
18637	14931	19	intended	intend	VBN
18637	14931	20	to	to	TO
18637	14931	21	strike	strike	VB
18637	14931	22	down	down	RP
18637	14931	23	a	a	DT
18637	14931	24	State	State	NNP
18637	14931	25	statute	statute	NN
18637	14931	26	to	to	TO
18637	14931	27	protect	protect	VB
18637	14931	28	the	the	DT
18637	14931	29	health	health	NN
18637	14931	30	and	and	CC
18637	14931	31	safety	safety	NN
18637	14931	32	of	of	IN
18637	14931	33	the	the	DT
18637	14931	34	public	public	NN
18637	14931	35	unless	unless	IN
18637	14931	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14931	37	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	14931	38	to	to	TO
18637	14931	39	do	do	VB
18637	14931	40	so	so	RB
18637	14931	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	14931	42	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	14931	43	manifested	manifest	VBN
18637	14931	44	.	.	.
18637	14932	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14932	2	15	15	CD
18637	14932	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14932	4	When	when	WRB
18637	14932	5	the	the	DT
18637	14932	6	United	United	NNP
18637	14932	7	States	States	NNP
18637	14932	8	performs	perform	VBZ
18637	14932	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14932	10	functions	function	NNS
18637	14932	11	directly	directly	RB
18637	14932	12	,	,	,
18637	14932	13	through	through	IN
18637	14932	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14932	15	own	own	JJ
18637	14932	16	officers	officer	NNS
18637	14932	17	and	and	CC
18637	14932	18	employees	employee	NNS
18637	14932	19	,	,	,
18637	14932	20	State	state	NN
18637	14932	21	police	police	NN
18637	14932	22	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	14932	23	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	14932	24	are	be	VBP
18637	14932	25	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	14932	26	.	.	.
18637	14933	1	In	in	IN
18637	14933	2	reversing	reverse	VBG
18637	14933	3	the	the	DT
18637	14933	4	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	14933	5	of	of	IN
18637	14933	6	the	the	DT
18637	14933	7	governor	governor	NN
18637	14933	8	of	of	IN
18637	14933	9	a	a	DT
18637	14933	10	national	national	JJ
18637	14933	11	soldiers	soldier	NNS
18637	14933	12	'	'	POS
18637	14933	13	home	home	NN
18637	14933	14	for	for	IN
18637	14933	15	serving	serve	VBG
18637	14933	16	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
18637	14933	17	in	in	IN
18637	14933	18	disregard	disregard	NN
18637	14933	19	of	of	IN
18637	14933	20	State	State	NNP
18637	14933	21	law	law	NN
18637	14933	22	,	,	,
18637	14933	23	the	the	DT
18637	14933	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14933	25	said	say	VBD
18637	14933	26	that	that	IN
18637	14933	27	the	the	DT
18637	14933	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14933	29	officer	officer	NN
18637	14933	30	was	be	VBD
18637	14933	31	not	not	RB
18637	14933	32	"	"	``
18637	14933	33	subject	subject	JJ
18637	14933	34	to	to	IN
18637	14933	35	the	the	DT
18637	14933	36	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14933	37	of	of	IN
18637	14933	38	the	the	DT
18637	14933	39	State	State	NNP
18637	14933	40	in	in	IN
18637	14933	41	regard	regard	NN
18637	14933	42	to	to	IN
18637	14933	43	those	those	DT
18637	14933	44	very	very	JJ
18637	14933	45	matters	matter	NNS
18637	14933	46	of	of	IN
18637	14933	47	administration	administration	NN
18637	14933	48	which	which	WDT
18637	14933	49	are	be	VBP
18637	14933	50	thus	thus	RB
18637	14933	51	approved	approve	VBN
18637	14933	52	by	by	IN
18637	14933	53	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	14933	54	authority	authority	NN
18637	14933	55	.	.	.
18637	14934	1	"	"	``
18637	14934	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14934	3	16	16	CD
18637	14934	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14934	5	An	an	DT
18637	14934	6	employee	employee	NN
18637	14934	7	of	of	IN
18637	14934	8	the	the	DT
18637	14934	9	Post	Post	NNP
18637	14934	10	Office	Office	NNP
18637	14934	11	Department	Department	NNP
18637	14934	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	14934	13	not	not	RB
18637	14934	14	required	require	VBN
18637	14934	15	to	to	TO
18637	14934	16	submit	submit	VB
18637	14934	17	to	to	IN
18637	14934	18	examination	examination	NN
18637	14934	19	by	by	IN
18637	14934	20	State	State	NNP
18637	14934	21	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	14934	22	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	14934	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14934	24	competence	competence	NN
18637	14934	25	and	and	CC
18637	14934	26	to	to	TO
18637	14934	27	pay	pay	VB
18637	14934	28	a	a	DT
18637	14934	29	license	license	NN
18637	14934	30	fee	fee	NN
18637	14934	31	before	before	IN
18637	14934	32	performing	perform	VBG
18637	14934	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14934	34	official	official	JJ
18637	14934	35	duty	duty	NN
18637	14934	36	in	in	IN
18637	14934	37	driving	drive	VBG
18637	14934	38	a	a	DT
18637	14934	39	motor	motor	NN
18637	14934	40	truck	truck	NN
18637	14934	41	for	for	IN
18637	14934	42	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	14934	43	the	the	DT
18637	14934	44	mail	mail	NN
18637	14934	45	.	.	.
18637	14935	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14935	2	17	17	CD
18637	14935	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14935	4	To	to	IN
18637	14935	5	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	14935	6	's	's	POS
18637	14935	7	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	14935	8	,	,	,
18637	14935	9	in	in	IN
18637	14935	10	a	a	DT
18637	14935	11	suit	suit	NN
18637	14935	12	to	to	TO
18637	14935	13	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	14935	14	the	the	DT
18637	14935	15	construction	construction	NN
18637	14935	16	of	of	IN
18637	14935	17	Boulder	Boulder	NNP
18637	14935	18	Dam	Dam	NNP
18637	14935	19	,	,	,
18637	14935	20	that	that	IN
18637	14935	21	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14935	22	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	14935	23	-	-	NN
18637	14935	24	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	14935	25	would	would	MD
18637	14935	26	be	be	VB
18637	14935	27	invaded	invade	VBN
18637	14935	28	by	by	IN
18637	14935	29	the	the	DT
18637	14935	30	building	building	NN
18637	14935	31	of	of	IN
18637	14935	32	the	the	DT
18637	14935	33	dam	dam	NN
18637	14935	34	without	without	IN
18637	14935	35	first	first	RB
18637	14935	36	securing	secure	VBG
18637	14935	37	approval	approval	NN
18637	14935	38	of	of	IN
18637	14935	39	the	the	DT
18637	14935	40	State	State	NNP
18637	14935	41	engineer	engineer	NN
18637	14935	42	as	as	IN
18637	14935	43	required	require	VBN
18637	14935	44	by	by	IN
18637	14935	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14935	46	laws	law	NNS
18637	14935	47	,	,	,
18637	14935	48	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14935	49	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	14935	50	replied	reply	VBD
18637	14935	51	that	that	IN
18637	14935	52	,	,	,
18637	14935	53	"	"	``
18637	14935	54	if	if	IN
18637	14935	55	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14935	56	has	have	VBZ
18637	14935	57	power	power	NN
18637	14935	58	to	to	TO
18637	14935	59	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	14935	60	the	the	DT
18637	14935	61	construction	construction	NN
18637	14935	62	of	of	IN
18637	14935	63	the	the	DT
18637	14935	64	dam	dam	NN
18637	14935	65	and	and	CC
18637	14935	66	reservoir	reservoir	NN
18637	14935	67	,	,	,
18637	14935	68	Wilbur	Wilbur	NNP
18637	14935	69	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14935	70	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	14935	71	of	of	IN
18637	14935	72	the	the	DT
18637	14935	73	Interior	Interior	NNP
18637	14935	74	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14935	75	is	be	VBZ
18637	14935	76	under	under	IN
18637	14935	77	no	no	DT
18637	14935	78	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	14935	79	to	to	TO
18637	14935	80	submit	submit	VB
18637	14935	81	the	the	DT
18637	14935	82	plans	plan	NNS
18637	14935	83	and	and	CC
18637	14935	84	specifications	specification	NNS
18637	14935	85	to	to	IN
18637	14935	86	the	the	DT
18637	14935	87	State	State	NNP
18637	14935	88	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
18637	14935	89	for	for	IN
18637	14935	90	approval	approval	NN
18637	14935	91	.	.	.
18637	14936	1	"	"	``
18637	14936	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14936	3	18	18	CD
18637	14936	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14936	5	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	14936	6	INSTRUMENTALITIES	instrumentality	NNS
18637	14936	7	AND	and	CC
18637	14936	8	THE	the	DT
18637	14936	9	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	14936	10	POLICE	police	NN
18637	14936	11	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	14936	12	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	14936	13	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	14936	14	and	and	CC
18637	14936	15	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	14936	16	have	have	VBP
18637	14936	17	never	never	RB
18637	14936	18	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
18637	14936	19	the	the	DT
18637	14936	20	same	same	JJ
18637	14936	21	degree	degree	NN
18637	14936	22	of	of	IN
18637	14936	23	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	14936	24	from	from	IN
18637	14936	25	State	state	NN
18637	14936	26	police	police	NN
18637	14936	27	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	14936	28	as	as	IN
18637	14936	29	from	from	IN
18637	14936	30	State	state	NN
18637	14936	31	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	14936	32	.	.	.
18637	14937	1	The	the	DT
18637	14937	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14937	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	14937	4	looked	look	VBN
18637	14937	5	to	to	IN
18637	14937	6	the	the	DT
18637	14937	7	nature	nature	NN
18637	14937	8	of	of	IN
18637	14937	9	each	each	DT
18637	14937	10	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	14937	11	to	to	TO
18637	14937	12	determine	determine	VB
18637	14937	13	whether	whether	IN
18637	14937	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14937	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	14937	16	compatible	compatible	JJ
18637	14937	17	with	with	IN
18637	14937	18	the	the	DT
18637	14937	19	functions	function	NNS
18637	14937	20	committed	commit	VBN
18637	14937	21	by	by	IN
18637	14937	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14937	23	to	to	IN
18637	14937	24	the	the	DT
18637	14937	25	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14937	26	agency	agency	NN
18637	14937	27	.	.	.
18637	14938	1	This	this	DT
18637	14938	2	problem	problem	NN
18637	14938	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	14938	4	arisen	arise	VBN
18637	14938	5	most	most	RBS
18637	14938	6	often	often	RB
18637	14938	7	with	with	IN
18637	14938	8	reference	reference	NN
18637	14938	9	to	to	IN
18637	14938	10	the	the	DT
18637	14938	11	applicability	applicability	NN
18637	14938	12	of	of	IN
18637	14938	13	State	State	NNP
18637	14938	14	laws	law	NNS
18637	14938	15	to	to	IN
18637	14938	16	the	the	DT
18637	14938	17	operation	operation	NN
18637	14938	18	of	of	IN
18637	14938	19	national	national	JJ
18637	14938	20	banks	bank	NNS
18637	14938	21	.	.	.
18637	14939	1	Two	two	CD
18637	14939	2	correlative	correlative	JJ
18637	14939	3	propositions	proposition	NNS
18637	14939	4	have	have	VBP
18637	14939	5	governed	govern	VBN
18637	14939	6	the	the	DT
18637	14939	7	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	14939	8	in	in	IN
18637	14939	9	these	these	DT
18637	14939	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	14939	11	.	.	.
18637	14940	1	The	the	DT
18637	14940	2	first	first	JJ
18637	14940	3	was	be	VBD
18637	14940	4	stated	state	VBN
18637	14940	5	by	by	IN
18637	14940	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14940	7	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	14940	8	in	in	IN
18637	14940	9	First	First	NNP
18637	14940	10	National	National	NNP
18637	14940	11	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	14940	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14940	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	14940	14	_	_	NNP
18637	14940	15	Kentucky:[19	Kentucky:[19	NNP
18637	14940	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14940	17	"	"	``
18637	14940	18	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14940	19	National	national	JJ
18637	14940	20	banks	bank	NNS
18637	14940	21	are	be	VBP
18637	14940	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14940	23	subject	subject	JJ
18637	14940	24	to	to	IN
18637	14940	25	the	the	DT
18637	14940	26	laws	law	NNS
18637	14940	27	of	of	IN
18637	14940	28	the	the	DT
18637	14940	29	State	State	NNP
18637	14940	30	,	,	,
18637	14940	31	and	and	CC
18637	14940	32	are	be	VBP
18637	14940	33	governed	govern	VBN
18637	14940	34	in	in	IN
18637	14940	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14940	36	daily	daily	JJ
18637	14940	37	course	course	NN
18637	14940	38	of	of	IN
18637	14940	39	business	business	NN
18637	14940	40	far	far	RB
18637	14940	41	more	more	RBR
18637	14940	42	by	by	IN
18637	14940	43	the	the	DT
18637	14940	44	laws	law	NNS
18637	14940	45	of	of	IN
18637	14940	46	the	the	DT
18637	14940	47	State	State	NNP
18637	14940	48	than	than	IN
18637	14940	49	of	of	IN
18637	14940	50	the	the	DT
18637	14940	51	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	14940	52	.	.	.
18637	14941	1	All	all	DT
18637	14941	2	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14941	3	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	14941	4	are	be	VBP
18637	14941	5	governed	govern	VBN
18637	14941	6	and	and	CC
18637	14941	7	construed	construe	VBN
18637	14941	8	by	by	IN
18637	14941	9	State	state	NN
18637	14941	10	laws	law	NNS
18637	14941	11	.	.	.
18637	14942	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14942	2	acquisition	acquisition	NN
18637	14942	3	and	and	CC
18637	14942	4	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	14942	5	of	of	IN
18637	14942	6	property	property	NN
18637	14942	7	,	,	,
18637	14942	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14942	9	right	right	NN
18637	14942	10	to	to	TO
18637	14942	11	collect	collect	VB
18637	14942	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14942	13	debts	debt	NNS
18637	14942	14	,	,	,
18637	14942	15	and	and	CC
18637	14942	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14942	17	liability	liability	NN
18637	14942	18	to	to	TO
18637	14942	19	be	be	VB
18637	14942	20	sued	sue	VBN
18637	14942	21	for	for	IN
18637	14942	22	debts	debt	NNS
18637	14942	23	,	,	,
18637	14942	24	are	be	VBP
18637	14942	25	all	all	DT
18637	14942	26	based	base	VBN
18637	14942	27	on	on	IN
18637	14942	28	State	State	NNP
18637	14942	29	law	law	NN
18637	14942	30	.	.	.
18637	14943	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14943	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	14943	3	only	only	RB
18637	14943	4	when	when	WRB
18637	14943	5	the	the	DT
18637	14943	6	State	State	NNP
18637	14943	7	law	law	NN
18637	14943	8	incapacitates	incapacitate	VBZ
18637	14943	9	the	the	DT
18637	14943	10	banks	bank	NNS
18637	14943	11	from	from	IN
18637	14943	12	discharging	discharge	VBG
18637	14943	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14943	14	duties	duty	NNS
18637	14943	15	to	to	IN
18637	14943	16	the	the	DT
18637	14943	17	government	government	NN
18637	14943	18	that	that	IN
18637	14943	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14943	20	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	14943	21	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	14943	22	.	.	.
18637	14944	1	"	"	``
18637	14944	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14944	3	20	20	CD
18637	14944	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14944	5	In	in	IN
18637	14944	6	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	14944	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14944	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	14944	9	_	_	NNP
18637	14944	10	Elmira	Elmira	NNP
18637	14944	11	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	14944	12	Bank,[21	Bank,[21	NNP
18637	14944	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14944	14	the	the	DT
18637	14944	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14944	16	stated	state	VBD
18637	14944	17	the	the	DT
18637	14944	18	second	second	JJ
18637	14944	19	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	14944	20	thus	thus	RB
18637	14944	21	:	:	:
18637	14944	22	"	"	``
18637	14944	23	National	national	JJ
18637	14944	24	banks	bank	NNS
18637	14944	25	are	be	VBP
18637	14944	26	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	14944	27	of	of	IN
18637	14944	28	the	the	DT
18637	14944	29	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	14944	30	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14944	31	,	,	,
18637	14944	32	created	create	VBN
18637	14944	33	for	for	IN
18637	14944	34	a	a	DT
18637	14944	35	public	public	JJ
18637	14944	36	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	14944	37	,	,	,
18637	14944	38	and	and	CC
18637	14944	39	as	as	IN
18637	14944	40	such	such	JJ
18637	14944	41	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	14944	42	subject	subject	JJ
18637	14944	43	to	to	IN
18637	14944	44	the	the	DT
18637	14944	45	paramount	paramount	NNP
18637	14944	46	authority	authority	NNP
18637	14944	47	of	of	IN
18637	14944	48	the	the	DT
18637	14944	49	United	United	NNP
18637	14944	50	States	States	NNP
18637	14944	51	.	.	.
18637	14945	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14945	2	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	14945	3	that	that	IN
18637	14945	4	an	an	DT
18637	14945	5	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	14945	6	,	,	,
18637	14945	7	by	by	IN
18637	14945	8	a	a	DT
18637	14945	9	State	state	NN
18637	14945	10	,	,	,
18637	14945	11	to	to	TO
18637	14945	12	define	define	VB
18637	14945	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14945	14	duties	duty	NNS
18637	14945	15	or	or	CC
18637	14945	16	control	control	VB
18637	14945	17	the	the	DT
18637	14945	18	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	14945	19	of	of	IN
18637	14945	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14945	21	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	14945	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	14945	23	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	14945	24	void	void	JJ
18637	14945	25	,	,	,
18637	14945	26	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	14945	27	such	such	JJ
18637	14945	28	attempted	attempt	VBN
18637	14945	29	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	14945	30	of	of	IN
18637	14945	31	authority	authority	NN
18637	14945	32	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	14945	33	conflicts	conflict	VBZ
18637	14945	34	with	with	IN
18637	14945	35	the	the	DT
18637	14945	36	laws	law	NNS
18637	14945	37	of	of	IN
18637	14945	38	the	the	DT
18637	14945	39	United	United	NNP
18637	14945	40	States	States	NNP
18637	14945	41	,	,	,
18637	14945	42	and	and	CC
18637	14945	43	either	either	DT
18637	14945	44	frustrates	frustrate	VBZ
18637	14945	45	the	the	DT
18637	14945	46	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	14945	47	of	of	IN
18637	14945	48	the	the	DT
18637	14945	49	national	national	JJ
18637	14945	50	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	14945	51	or	or	CC
18637	14945	52	impairs	impairs	VB
18637	14945	53	the	the	DT
18637	14945	54	efficiency	efficiency	NN
18637	14945	55	of	of	IN
18637	14945	56	these	these	DT
18637	14945	57	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	14945	58	of	of	IN
18637	14945	59	the	the	DT
18637	14945	60	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	14945	61	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14945	62	to	to	TO
18637	14945	63	discharge	discharge	VB
18637	14945	64	the	the	DT
18637	14945	65	duties	duty	NNS
18637	14945	66	,	,	,
18637	14945	67	for	for	IN
18637	14945	68	the	the	DT
18637	14945	69	performance	performance	NN
18637	14945	70	of	of	IN
18637	14945	71	which	which	WDT
18637	14945	72	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14945	73	were	be	VBD
18637	14945	74	created	create	VBN
18637	14945	75	.	.	.
18637	14946	1	"	"	``
18637	14946	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14946	3	22	22	CD
18637	14946	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14946	5	Instructive	Instructive	NNP
18637	14946	6	,	,	,
18637	14946	7	too	too	RB
18637	14946	8	,	,	,
18637	14946	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	14946	10	a	a	DT
18637	14946	11	comparison	comparison	NN
18637	14946	12	of	of	IN
18637	14946	13	two	two	CD
18637	14946	14	other	other	JJ
18637	14946	15	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	14946	16	.	.	.
18637	14947	1	In	in	IN
18637	14947	2	the	the	DT
18637	14947	3	first,[23	first,[23	CD
18637	14947	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14947	5	the	the	DT
18637	14947	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14947	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	14947	8	that	that	IN
18637	14947	9	the	the	DT
18637	14947	10	fact	fact	NN
18637	14947	11	that	that	IN
18637	14947	12	the	the	DT
18637	14947	13	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	14947	14	and	and	CC
18637	14947	15	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	14947	16	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	14947	17	Company	Company	NNP
18637	14947	18	was	be	VBD
18637	14947	19	a	a	DT
18637	14947	20	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	14947	21	organized	organize	VBN
18637	14947	22	under	under	IN
18637	14947	23	a	a	DT
18637	14947	24	statute	statute	NN
18637	14947	25	of	of	IN
18637	14947	26	the	the	DT
18637	14947	27	United	United	NNP
18637	14947	28	States	States	NNP
18637	14947	29	did	do	VBD
18637	14947	30	not	not	RB
18637	14947	31	remove	remove	VB
18637	14947	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14947	33	from	from	IN
18637	14947	34	the	the	DT
18637	14947	35	control	control	NN
18637	14947	36	of	of	IN
18637	14947	37	the	the	DT
18637	14947	38	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	14947	39	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	14947	40	commission	commission	NNP
18637	14947	41	as	as	IN
18637	14947	42	to	to	IN
18637	14947	43	business	business	NN
18637	14947	44	done	do	VBN
18637	14947	45	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	14947	46	within	within	IN
18637	14947	47	the	the	DT
18637	14947	48	State	State	NNP
18637	14947	49	.	.	.
18637	14948	1	In	in	IN
18637	14948	2	the	the	DT
18637	14948	3	second,[24	second,[24	CD
18637	14948	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14948	5	the	the	DT
18637	14948	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14948	7	vetoed	veto	VBD
18637	14948	8	the	the	DT
18637	14948	9	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	14948	10	of	of	IN
18637	14948	11	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	14948	12	to	to	TO
18637	14948	13	require	require	VB
18637	14948	14	a	a	DT
18637	14948	15	post	post	NN
18637	14948	16	office	office	NN
18637	14948	17	employee	employee	NN
18637	14948	18	to	to	TO
18637	14948	19	cease	cease	VB
18637	14948	20	driving	drive	VBG
18637	14948	21	a	a	DT
18637	14948	22	United	United	NNP
18637	14948	23	States	States	NNP
18637	14948	24	motor	motor	NN
18637	14948	25	truck	truck	NN
18637	14948	26	in	in	IN
18637	14948	27	the	the	DT
18637	14948	28	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	14948	29	of	of	IN
18637	14948	30	mail	mail	NN
18637	14948	31	over	over	IN
18637	14948	32	a	a	DT
18637	14948	33	post	post	NN
18637	14948	34	road	road	NN
18637	14948	35	until	until	IN
18637	14948	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14948	37	should	should	MD
18637	14948	38	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	14948	39	a	a	DT
18637	14948	40	license	license	NN
18637	14948	41	by	by	IN
18637	14948	42	submitting	submit	VBG
18637	14948	43	to	to	IN
18637	14948	44	examination	examination	NN
18637	14948	45	before	before	IN
18637	14948	46	a	a	DT
18637	14948	47	State	State	NNP
18637	14948	48	official	official	NN
18637	14948	49	and	and	CC
18637	14948	50	paying	pay	VBG
18637	14948	51	a	a	DT
18637	14948	52	fee	fee	NN
18637	14948	53	.	.	.
18637	14949	1	"	"	``
18637	14949	2	Of	of	RB
18637	14949	3	course	course	RB
18637	14949	4	,	,	,
18637	14949	5	"	"	''
18637	14949	6	said	say	VBD
18637	14949	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14949	8	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	14949	9	,	,	,
18637	14949	10	"	"	''
18637	14949	11	an	an	DT
18637	14949	12	employee	employee	NN
18637	14949	13	of	of	IN
18637	14949	14	the	the	DT
18637	14949	15	United	United	NNP
18637	14949	16	States	States	NNP
18637	14949	17	does	do	VBZ
18637	14949	18	not	not	RB
18637	14949	19	secure	secure	VB
18637	14949	20	a	a	DT
18637	14949	21	general	general	JJ
18637	14949	22	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	14949	23	from	from	IN
18637	14949	24	State	State	NNP
18637	14949	25	law	law	NN
18637	14949	26	while	while	IN
18637	14949	27	acting	act	VBG
18637	14949	28	in	in	IN
18637	14949	29	the	the	DT
18637	14949	30	course	course	NN
18637	14949	31	of	of	IN
18637	14949	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14949	33	employment	employment	NN
18637	14949	34	"	"	''
18637	14949	35	;	;	:
18637	14949	36	but	but	CC
18637	14949	37	this	this	DT
18637	14949	38	time	time	NN
18637	14949	39	the	the	DT
18637	14949	40	State	state	NN
18637	14949	41	went	go	VBD
18637	14949	42	too	too	RB
18637	14949	43	far	far	RB
18637	14949	44	.	.	.
18637	14950	1	The	the	DT
18637	14950	2	extent	extent	NN
18637	14950	3	to	to	TO
18637	14950	4	which	which	WDT
18637	14950	5	States	States	NNP
18637	14950	6	may	may	MD
18637	14950	7	go	go	VB
18637	14950	8	in	in	IN
18637	14950	9	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	14950	10	contractors	contractor	NNS
18637	14950	11	who	who	WP
18637	14950	12	furnish	furnish	VBP
18637	14950	13	goods	good	NNS
18637	14950	14	or	or	CC
18637	14950	15	services	service	NNS
18637	14950	16	to	to	IN
18637	14950	17	the	the	DT
18637	14950	18	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	14950	19	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14950	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	14950	21	not	not	RB
18637	14950	22	as	as	RB
18637	14950	23	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	14950	24	established	establish	VBN
18637	14950	25	as	as	IN
18637	14950	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	14950	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14950	28	right	right	NN
18637	14950	29	to	to	TO
18637	14950	30	tax	tax	VB
18637	14950	31	such	such	JJ
18637	14950	32	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	14950	33	.	.	.
18637	14951	1	In	in	IN
18637	14951	2	1943	1943	CD
18637	14951	3	,	,	,
18637	14951	4	a	a	DT
18637	14951	5	closely	closely	RB
18637	14951	6	divided	divide	VBN
18637	14951	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14951	8	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	14951	9	the	the	DT
18637	14951	10	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	14951	11	of	of	IN
18637	14951	12	the	the	DT
18637	14951	13	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	14951	14	Milk	Milk	NNP
18637	14951	15	Control	Control	NNP
18637	14951	16	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	14951	17	to	to	TO
18637	14951	18	renew	renew	VB
18637	14951	19	the	the	DT
18637	14951	20	license	license	NN
18637	14951	21	of	of	IN
18637	14951	22	a	a	DT
18637	14951	23	milk	milk	NN
18637	14951	24	dealer	dealer	NN
18637	14951	25	who	who	WP
18637	14951	26	,	,	,
18637	14951	27	in	in	IN
18637	14951	28	violation	violation	NN
18637	14951	29	of	of	IN
18637	14951	30	State	State	NNP
18637	14951	31	law	law	NN
18637	14951	32	,	,	,
18637	14951	33	had	have	VBD
18637	14951	34	sold	sell	VBN
18637	14951	35	milk	milk	NN
18637	14951	36	to	to	IN
18637	14951	37	the	the	DT
18637	14951	38	United	United	NNP
18637	14951	39	States	States	NNP
18637	14951	40	for	for	IN
18637	14951	41	consumption	consumption	NN
18637	14951	42	by	by	IN
18637	14951	43	troops	troop	NNS
18637	14951	44	at	at	IN
18637	14951	45	an	an	DT
18637	14951	46	army	army	NN
18637	14951	47	camp	camp	NN
18637	14951	48	located	locate	VBN
18637	14951	49	on	on	IN
18637	14951	50	land	land	NN
18637	14951	51	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	14951	52	to	to	IN
18637	14951	53	the	the	DT
18637	14951	54	State	State	NNP
18637	14951	55	,	,	,
18637	14951	56	at	at	IN
18637	14951	57	prices	price	NNS
18637	14951	58	below	below	IN
18637	14951	59	the	the	DT
18637	14951	60	minima	minima	NN
18637	14951	61	established	establish	VBN
18637	14951	62	by	by	IN
18637	14951	63	the	the	DT
18637	14951	64	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	14951	65	.	.	.
18637	14952	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14952	2	25	25	CD
18637	14952	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14952	4	The	the	DT
18637	14952	5	majority	majority	NN
18637	14952	6	was	be	VBD
18637	14952	7	unable	unable	JJ
18637	14952	8	to	to	TO
18637	14952	9	find	find	VB
18637	14952	10	in	in	IN
18637	14952	11	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	14952	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	14952	13	,	,	,
18637	14952	14	or	or	CC
18637	14952	15	in	in	IN
18637	14952	16	the	the	DT
18637	14952	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14952	18	,	,	,
18637	14952	19	unaided	unaide	VBN
18637	14952	20	by	by	IN
18637	14952	21	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	14952	22	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	14952	23	,	,	,
18637	14952	24	any	any	DT
18637	14952	25	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	14952	26	from	from	IN
18637	14952	27	such	such	JJ
18637	14952	28	price	price	NN
18637	14952	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	14952	30	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	14952	31	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	14952	32	.	.	.
18637	14953	1	On	on	IN
18637	14953	2	the	the	DT
18637	14953	3	same	same	JJ
18637	14953	4	day	day	NN
18637	14953	5	,	,	,
18637	14953	6	a	a	DT
18637	14953	7	different	different	JJ
18637	14953	8	majority	majority	NN
18637	14953	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	14953	10	that	that	IN
18637	14953	11	California	California	NNP
18637	14953	12	could	could	MD
18637	14953	13	not	not	RB
18637	14953	14	penalize	penalize	VB
18637	14953	15	a	a	DT
18637	14953	16	milk	milk	NN
18637	14953	17	dealer	dealer	NN
18637	14953	18	for	for	IN
18637	14953	19	selling	sell	VBG
18637	14953	20	milk	milk	NN
18637	14953	21	to	to	IN
18637	14953	22	the	the	DT
18637	14953	23	War	War	NNP
18637	14953	24	Department	Department	NNP
18637	14953	25	at	at	IN
18637	14953	26	less	less	JJR
18637	14953	27	than	than	IN
18637	14953	28	the	the	DT
18637	14953	29	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	14953	30	price	price	NN
18637	14953	31	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	14953	32	by	by	IN
18637	14953	33	State	State	NNP
18637	14953	34	law	law	NN
18637	14953	35	where	where	WRB
18637	14953	36	the	the	DT
18637	14953	37	sales	sale	NNS
18637	14953	38	and	and	CC
18637	14953	39	deliveries	delivery	NNS
18637	14953	40	were	be	VBD
18637	14953	41	made	make	VBN
18637	14953	42	in	in	IN
18637	14953	43	a	a	DT
18637	14953	44	territory	territory	NN
18637	14953	45	which	which	WDT
18637	14953	46	had	have	VBD
18637	14953	47	been	be	VBN
18637	14953	48	ceded	cede	VBN
18637	14953	49	to	to	IN
18637	14953	50	the	the	DT
18637	14953	51	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	14953	52	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14953	53	by	by	IN
18637	14953	54	the	the	DT
18637	14953	55	State	state	NN
18637	14953	56	and	and	CC
18637	14953	57	were	be	VBD
18637	14953	58	subject	subject	JJ
18637	14953	59	to	to	IN
18637	14953	60	the	the	DT
18637	14953	61	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	14953	62	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14953	63	of	of	IN
18637	14953	64	the	the	DT
18637	14953	65	former	former	JJ
18637	14953	66	.	.	.
18637	14954	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14954	2	26	26	CD
18637	14954	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14954	4	OBLIGATION	obligation	NN
18637	14954	5	OF	of	IN
18637	14954	6	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	14954	7	COURTS	court	VBN
18637	14954	8	UNDER	under	IN
18637	14954	9	THE	the	DT
18637	14954	10	SUPREMACY	SUPREMACY	NNP
18637	14954	11	CLAUSE	CLAUSE	NNP
18637	14954	12	The	the	DT
18637	14954	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14954	14	,	,	,
18637	14954	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	14954	16	and	and	CC
18637	14954	17	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	14954	18	of	of	IN
18637	14954	19	the	the	DT
18637	14954	20	United	United	NNP
18637	14954	21	States	States	NNP
18637	14954	22	are	be	VBP
18637	14954	23	as	as	RB
18637	14954	24	much	much	JJ
18637	14954	25	a	a	DT
18637	14954	26	part	part	NN
18637	14954	27	of	of	IN
18637	14954	28	the	the	DT
18637	14954	29	law	law	NN
18637	14954	30	of	of	IN
18637	14954	31	every	every	DT
18637	14954	32	State	State	NNP
18637	14954	33	as	as	IN
18637	14954	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14954	35	own	own	JJ
18637	14954	36	local	local	JJ
18637	14954	37	laws	law	NNS
18637	14954	38	and	and	CC
18637	14954	39	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14954	40	.	.	.
18637	14955	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14955	2	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	14955	3	"	"	``
18637	14955	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	14955	5	imperative	imperative	JJ
18637	14955	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	14955	7	the	the	DT
18637	14955	8	State	State	NNP
18637	14955	9	judges	judge	NNS
18637	14955	10	,	,	,
18637	14955	11	in	in	IN
18637	14955	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14955	13	official	official	NN
18637	14955	14	and	and	CC
18637	14955	15	not	not	RB
18637	14955	16	merely	merely	RB
18637	14955	17	in	in	IN
18637	14955	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14955	19	private	private	JJ
18637	14955	20	capacities	capacity	NNS
18637	14955	21	.	.	.
18637	14956	1	From	from	IN
18637	14956	2	the	the	DT
18637	14956	3	very	very	JJ
18637	14956	4	nature	nature	NN
18637	14956	5	of	of	IN
18637	14956	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14956	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	14956	8	duties	duty	NNS
18637	14956	9	,	,	,
18637	14956	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14956	11	would	would	MD
18637	14956	12	be	be	VB
18637	14956	13	called	call	VBN
18637	14956	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	14956	15	to	to	TO
18637	14956	16	pronounce	pronounce	VB
18637	14956	17	the	the	DT
18637	14956	18	law	law	NN
18637	14956	19	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	14956	20	to	to	IN
18637	14956	21	the	the	DT
18637	14956	22	case	case	NN
18637	14956	23	in	in	IN
18637	14956	24	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	14956	25	.	.	.
18637	14957	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14957	2	were	be	VBD
18637	14957	3	not	not	RB
18637	14957	4	to	to	TO
18637	14957	5	decide	decide	VB
18637	14957	6	merely	merely	RB
18637	14957	7	according	accord	VBG
18637	14957	8	to	to	IN
18637	14957	9	the	the	DT
18637	14957	10	laws	law	NNS
18637	14957	11	or	or	CC
18637	14957	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14957	13	of	of	IN
18637	14957	14	the	the	DT
18637	14957	15	State	State	NNP
18637	14957	16	,	,	,
18637	14957	17	but	but	CC
18637	14957	18	according	accord	VBG
18637	14957	19	to	to	IN
18637	14957	20	the	the	DT
18637	14957	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	14957	22	and	and	CC
18637	14957	23	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	14957	24	of	of	IN
18637	14957	25	the	the	DT
18637	14957	26	United	United	NNP
18637	14957	27	States--'the	states--'the	SYM
18637	14957	28	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	14957	29	law	law	NN
18637	14957	30	of	of	IN
18637	14957	31	the	the	DT
18637	14957	32	land	land	NN
18637	14957	33	.	.	.
18637	14958	1	'	'	``
18637	14958	2	"	"	``
18637	14958	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14958	4	27	27	CD
18637	14958	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14958	6	State	state	NN
18637	14958	7	courts	court	NNS
18637	14958	8	have	have	VBP
18637	14958	9	both	both	CC
18637	14958	10	the	the	DT
18637	14958	11	power	power	NN
18637	14958	12	and	and	CC
18637	14958	13	the	the	DT
18637	14958	14	duty	duty	NN
18637	14958	15	to	to	TO
18637	14958	16	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	14958	17	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	14958	18	arising	arise	VBG
18637	14958	19	under	under	IN
18637	14958	20	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14958	21	law	law	NN
18637	14958	22	,	,	,
18637	14958	23	unless	unless	IN
18637	14958	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14958	25	gives	give	VBZ
18637	14958	26	the	the	DT
18637	14958	27	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14958	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	14958	29	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	14958	30	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14958	31	.	.	.
18637	14959	1	The	the	DT
18637	14959	2	power	power	NN
18637	14959	3	of	of	IN
18637	14959	4	State	State	NNP
18637	14959	5	courts	court	NNS
18637	14959	6	to	to	TO
18637	14959	7	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	14959	8	such	such	JJ
18637	14959	9	suits	suit	NNS
18637	14959	10	was	be	VBD
18637	14959	11	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	14959	12	in	in	IN
18637	14959	13	Claflin	Claflin	NNP
18637	14959	14	_	_	NNP
18637	14959	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	14959	16	_	_	NNP
18637	14959	17	Houseman[28	Houseman[28	NNP
18637	14959	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14959	19	in	in	IN
18637	14959	20	1876	1876	CD
18637	14959	21	,	,	,
18637	14959	22	thus	thus	RB
18637	14959	23	setting	set	VBG
18637	14959	24	at	at	IN
18637	14959	25	rest	rest	NN
18637	14959	26	the	the	DT
18637	14959	27	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	14959	28	which	which	WDT
18637	14959	29	had	have	VBD
18637	14959	30	been	be	VBN
18637	14959	31	raised	raise	VBN
18637	14959	32	by	by	IN
18637	14959	33	an	an	DT
18637	14959	34	early	early	JJ
18637	14959	35	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	14959	36	of	of	IN
18637	14959	37	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14959	38	Story	Story	NNP
18637	14959	39	.	.	.
18637	14960	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14960	2	29	29	CD
18637	14960	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14960	4	In	in	IN
18637	14960	5	the	the	DT
18637	14960	6	Claflin	Claflin	NNP
18637	14960	7	case	case	NN
18637	14960	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14960	9	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	14960	10	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	14960	11	on	on	IN
18637	14960	12	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	14960	13	of	of	IN
18637	14960	14	a	a	DT
18637	14960	15	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	14960	16	court	court	NN
18637	14960	17	that	that	WDT
18637	14960	18	:	:	:
18637	14960	19	"	"	``
18637	14960	20	If	if	IN
18637	14960	21	an	an	DT
18637	14960	22	Act	Act	NNP
18637	14960	23	of	of	IN
18637	14960	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14960	25	gives	give	VBZ
18637	14960	26	a	a	DT
18637	14960	27	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	14960	28	to	to	IN
18637	14960	29	a	a	DT
18637	14960	30	party	party	NN
18637	14960	31	aggrieved	aggrieve	VBN
18637	14960	32	,	,	,
18637	14960	33	without	without	IN
18637	14960	34	specifying	specify	VBG
18637	14960	35	a	a	DT
18637	14960	36	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	14960	37	for	for	IN
18637	14960	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14960	39	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	14960	40	,	,	,
18637	14960	41	there	there	EX
18637	14960	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	14960	43	no	no	DT
18637	14960	44	reason	reason	NN
18637	14960	45	why	why	WRB
18637	14960	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14960	47	should	should	MD
18637	14960	48	not	not	RB
18637	14960	49	be	be	VB
18637	14960	50	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	14960	51	,	,	,
18637	14960	52	if	if	IN
18637	14960	53	not	not	RB
18637	14960	54	provided	provide	VBN
18637	14960	55	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	14960	56	by	by	IN
18637	14960	57	some	some	DT
18637	14960	58	act	act	NN
18637	14960	59	of	of	IN
18637	14960	60	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14960	61	,	,	,
18637	14960	62	by	by	IN
18637	14960	63	a	a	DT
18637	14960	64	proper	proper	JJ
18637	14960	65	action	action	NN
18637	14960	66	in	in	IN
18637	14960	67	a	a	DT
18637	14960	68	State	State	NNP
18637	14960	69	court	court	NN
18637	14960	70	.	.	.
18637	14961	1	The	the	DT
18637	14961	2	fact	fact	NN
18637	14961	3	that	that	IN
18637	14961	4	a	a	DT
18637	14961	5	State	State	NNP
18637	14961	6	court	court	NN
18637	14961	7	derives	derive	VBZ
18637	14961	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14961	9	existence	existence	NN
18637	14961	10	and	and	CC
18637	14961	11	functions	function	NNS
18637	14961	12	from	from	IN
18637	14961	13	the	the	DT
18637	14961	14	State	State	NNP
18637	14961	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	14961	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	14961	17	no	no	DT
18637	14961	18	reason	reason	NN
18637	14961	19	why	why	WRB
18637	14961	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14961	21	should	should	MD
18637	14961	22	not	not	RB
18637	14961	23	afford	afford	VB
18637	14961	24	relief	relief	NN
18637	14961	25	,	,	,
18637	14961	26	because	because	IN
18637	14961	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14961	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	14961	29	subject	subject	JJ
18637	14961	30	also	also	RB
18637	14961	31	to	to	IN
18637	14961	32	the	the	DT
18637	14961	33	laws	law	NNS
18637	14961	34	of	of	IN
18637	14961	35	the	the	DT
18637	14961	36	United	United	NNP
18637	14961	37	States	States	NNP
18637	14961	38	,	,	,
18637	14961	39	and	and	CC
18637	14961	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	14961	41	just	just	RB
18637	14961	42	as	as	RB
18637	14961	43	much	much	JJ
18637	14961	44	bound	bind	VBN
18637	14961	45	to	to	TO
18637	14961	46	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	14961	47	these	these	DT
18637	14961	48	as	as	IN
18637	14961	49	operative	operative	JJ
18637	14961	50	within	within	IN
18637	14961	51	the	the	DT
18637	14961	52	State	State	NNP
18637	14961	53	as	as	IN
18637	14961	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14961	55	is	be	VBZ
18637	14961	56	to	to	TO
18637	14961	57	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	14961	58	the	the	DT
18637	14961	59	State	State	NNP
18637	14961	60	laws	law	NNS
18637	14961	61	.	.	.
18637	14962	1	"	"	``
18637	14962	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14962	3	30	30	CD
18637	14962	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14962	5	When	when	WRB
18637	14962	6	the	the	DT
18637	14962	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14962	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14962	9	of	of	IN
18637	14962	10	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	14962	11	held	hold	VBD
18637	14962	12	that	that	IN
18637	14962	13	rights	right	NNS
18637	14962	14	created	create	VBN
18637	14962	15	by	by	IN
18637	14962	16	the	the	DT
18637	14962	17	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	14962	18	Employer	Employer	NNP
18637	14962	19	's	's	POS
18637	14962	20	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	14962	21	Acts	act	NNS
18637	14962	22	could	could	MD
18637	14962	23	not	not	RB
18637	14962	24	be	be	VB
18637	14962	25	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	14962	26	in	in	IN
18637	14962	27	the	the	DT
18637	14962	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	14962	29	of	of	IN
18637	14962	30	that	that	DT
18637	14962	31	State	State	NNP
18637	14962	32	because	because	IN
18637	14962	33	the	the	DT
18637	14962	34	act	act	NN
18637	14962	35	was	be	VBD
18637	14962	36	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	14962	37	to	to	IN
18637	14962	38	State	state	NN
18637	14962	39	policy	policy	NN
18637	14962	40	,	,	,
18637	14962	41	the	the	DT
18637	14962	42	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14962	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14962	44	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	14962	45	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	14962	46	that	that	DT
18637	14962	47	decision	decision	NN
18637	14962	48	.	.	.
18637	14963	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	14963	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14963	3	Van	Van	NNP
18637	14963	4	Devanter	Devanter	NNP
18637	14963	5	:	:	:
18637	14963	6	"	"	``
18637	14963	7	The	the	DT
18637	14963	8	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	14963	9	that	that	IN
18637	14963	10	the	the	DT
18637	14963	11	act	act	NN
18637	14963	12	of	of	IN
18637	14963	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14963	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	14963	15	not	not	RB
18637	14963	16	in	in	IN
18637	14963	17	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	14963	18	with	with	IN
18637	14963	19	the	the	DT
18637	14963	20	policy	policy	NN
18637	14963	21	of	of	IN
18637	14963	22	the	the	DT
18637	14963	23	State	State	NNP
18637	14963	24	,	,	,
18637	14963	25	and	and	CC
18637	14963	26	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	14963	27	that	that	IN
18637	14963	28	the	the	DT
18637	14963	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	14963	30	of	of	IN
18637	14963	31	the	the	DT
18637	14963	32	State	State	NNP
18637	14963	33	are	be	VBP
18637	14963	34	free	free	JJ
18637	14963	35	to	to	TO
18637	14963	36	decline	decline	VB
18637	14963	37	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14963	38	,	,	,
18637	14963	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	14963	40	quite	quite	RB
18637	14963	41	inadmissible	inadmissible	JJ
18637	14963	42	,	,	,
18637	14963	43	because	because	IN
18637	14963	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14963	45	presupposes	presuppose	VBZ
18637	14963	46	what	what	WP
18637	14963	47	in	in	IN
18637	14963	48	legal	legal	JJ
18637	14963	49	contemplation	contemplation	NN
18637	14963	50	does	do	VBZ
18637	14963	51	not	not	RB
18637	14963	52	exist	exist	VB
18637	14963	53	.	.	.
18637	14964	1	When	when	WRB
18637	14964	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14964	3	,	,	,
18637	14964	4	in	in	IN
18637	14964	5	the	the	DT
18637	14964	6	exertion	exertion	NN
18637	14964	7	of	of	IN
18637	14964	8	the	the	DT
18637	14964	9	power	power	NN
18637	14964	10	confided	confide	VBD
18637	14964	11	to	to	IN
18637	14964	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14964	13	by	by	IN
18637	14964	14	the	the	DT
18637	14964	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	14964	16	,	,	,
18637	14964	17	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	14964	18	that	that	DT
18637	14964	19	act	act	NN
18637	14964	20	,	,	,
18637	14964	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14964	22	spoke	speak	VBD
18637	14964	23	for	for	IN
18637	14964	24	all	all	PDT
18637	14964	25	the	the	DT
18637	14964	26	people	people	NNS
18637	14964	27	and	and	CC
18637	14964	28	all	all	PDT
18637	14964	29	the	the	DT
18637	14964	30	States	States	NNPS
18637	14964	31	,	,	,
18637	14964	32	and	and	CC
18637	14964	33	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	14964	34	established	establish	VBD
18637	14964	35	a	a	DT
18637	14964	36	policy	policy	NN
18637	14964	37	for	for	IN
18637	14964	38	all	all	DT
18637	14964	39	.	.	.
18637	14965	1	That	that	DT
18637	14965	2	policy	policy	NN
18637	14965	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	14965	4	as	as	RB
18637	14965	5	much	much	JJ
18637	14965	6	the	the	DT
18637	14965	7	policy	policy	NN
18637	14965	8	of	of	IN
18637	14965	9	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	14965	10	as	as	IN
18637	14965	11	if	if	IN
18637	14965	12	the	the	DT
18637	14965	13	act	act	NN
18637	14965	14	had	have	VBD
18637	14965	15	emanated	emanate	VBN
18637	14965	16	from	from	IN
18637	14965	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14965	18	own	own	JJ
18637	14965	19	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	14965	20	,	,	,
18637	14965	21	and	and	CC
18637	14965	22	should	should	MD
18637	14965	23	be	be	VB
18637	14965	24	respected	respect	VBN
18637	14965	25	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	14965	26	in	in	IN
18637	14965	27	the	the	DT
18637	14965	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	14965	29	of	of	IN
18637	14965	30	the	the	DT
18637	14965	31	State	State	NNP
18637	14965	32	.	.	.
18637	14966	1	"	"	``
18637	14966	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14966	3	31	31	CD
18637	14966	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14966	5	Even	even	RB
18637	14966	6	if	if	IN
18637	14966	7	a	a	DT
18637	14966	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14966	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	14966	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	14966	11	penal	penal	JJ
18637	14966	12	in	in	IN
18637	14966	13	character	character	NN
18637	14966	14	,	,	,
18637	14966	15	a	a	DT
18637	14966	16	State	state	NN
18637	14966	17	may	may	MD
18637	14966	18	not	not	RB
18637	14966	19	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	14966	20	to	to	TO
18637	14966	21	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	14966	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14966	23	if	if	IN
18637	14966	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14966	25	allows	allow	VBZ
18637	14966	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14966	27	to	to	TO
18637	14966	28	take	take	VB
18637	14966	29	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	14966	30	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14966	31	.	.	.
18637	14967	1	In	in	IN
18637	14967	2	Testa	Testa	NNP
18637	14967	3	_	_	NNP
18637	14967	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	14967	5	_	_	NNP
18637	14967	6	Katt,[32	Katt,[32	NNP
18637	14967	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14967	8	the	the	DT
18637	14967	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14967	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14967	11	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	14967	12	a	a	DT
18637	14967	13	holding	holding	NN
18637	14967	14	of	of	IN
18637	14967	15	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	14967	16	Island	Island	NNP
18637	14967	17	's	's	POS
18637	14967	18	highest	high	JJS
18637	14967	19	court	court	NN
18637	14967	20	that	that	WDT
18637	14967	21	,	,	,
18637	14967	22	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	14967	23	as	as	IN
18637	14967	24	a	a	DT
18637	14967	25	State	state	NN
18637	14967	26	need	nee	MD
18637	14967	27	not	not	RB
18637	14967	28	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	14967	29	the	the	DT
18637	14967	30	penal	penal	JJ
18637	14967	31	laws	law	NNS
18637	14967	32	of	of	IN
18637	14967	33	another	another	DT
18637	14967	34	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	14967	35	,	,	,
18637	14967	36	a	a	DT
18637	14967	37	suit	suit	NN
18637	14967	38	for	for	IN
18637	14967	39	treble	treble	JJ
18637	14967	40	damages	damage	NNS
18637	14967	41	for	for	IN
18637	14967	42	violation	violation	NN
18637	14967	43	of	of	IN
18637	14967	44	OPA	opa	NN
18637	14967	45	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	14967	46	could	could	MD
18637	14967	47	not	not	RB
18637	14967	48	be	be	VB
18637	14967	49	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	14967	50	in	in	IN
18637	14967	51	the	the	DT
18637	14967	52	courts	court	NNS
18637	14967	53	of	of	IN
18637	14967	54	the	the	DT
18637	14967	55	State	State	NNP
18637	14967	56	.	.	.
18637	14968	1	Without	without	IN
18637	14968	2	determining	determine	VBG
18637	14968	3	the	the	DT
18637	14968	4	nature	nature	NN
18637	14968	5	of	of	IN
18637	14968	6	the	the	DT
18637	14968	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	14968	8	,	,	,
18637	14968	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14968	10	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	14968	11	once	once	RB
18637	14968	12	more	more	RBR
18637	14968	13	without	without	IN
18637	14968	14	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	14968	15	that	that	IN
18637	14968	16	"	"	``
18637	14968	17	the	the	DT
18637	14968	18	policy	policy	NN
18637	14968	19	of	of	IN
18637	14968	20	the	the	DT
18637	14968	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14968	22	Act	Act	NNP
18637	14968	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	14968	24	the	the	DT
18637	14968	25	prevailing	prevail	VBG
18637	14968	26	policy	policy	NN
18637	14968	27	in	in	IN
18637	14968	28	every	every	DT
18637	14968	29	state	state	NN
18637	14968	30	.	.	.
18637	14969	1	"	"	``
18637	14969	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14969	3	33	33	CD
18637	14969	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14969	5	IMMUNITY	immunity	NN
18637	14969	6	OF	of	IN
18637	14969	7	THE	the	DT
18637	14969	8	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	14969	9	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	14969	10	PROCESS	PROCESS	NNP
18637	14969	11	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14969	12	would	would	MD
18637	14969	13	seem	seem	VB
18637	14969	14	self	self	NN
18637	14969	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	14969	16	evident	evident	JJ
18637	14969	17	that	that	IN
18637	14969	18	a	a	DT
18637	14969	19	State	State	NNP
18637	14969	20	court	court	NN
18637	14969	21	can	can	MD
18637	14969	22	not	not	RB
18637	14969	23	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	14969	24	with	with	IN
18637	14969	25	the	the	DT
18637	14969	26	functioning	functioning	NN
18637	14969	27	of	of	IN
18637	14969	28	a	a	DT
18637	14969	29	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14969	30	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	14969	31	.	.	.
18637	14970	1	But	but	CC
18637	14970	2	this	this	DT
18637	14970	3	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	14970	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	14970	5	not	not	RB
18637	14970	6	always	always	RB
18637	14970	7	gone	go	VBN
18637	14970	8	unchallenged	unchallenged	JJ
18637	14970	9	.	.	.
18637	14971	1	Shortly	shortly	RB
18637	14971	2	before	before	IN
18637	14971	3	the	the	DT
18637	14971	4	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	14971	5	War	War	NNP
18637	14971	6	,	,	,
18637	14971	7	the	the	DT
18637	14971	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14971	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14971	10	of	of	IN
18637	14971	11	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	14971	12	,	,	,
18637	14971	13	holding	hold	VBG
18637	14971	14	the	the	DT
18637	14971	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14971	16	fugitive	fugitive	JJ
18637	14971	17	slave	slave	NN
18637	14971	18	law	law	NNP
18637	14971	19	invalid	invalid	NNP
18637	14971	20	,	,	,
18637	14971	21	ordered	order	VBD
18637	14971	22	a	a	DT
18637	14971	23	United	United	NNP
18637	14971	24	States	States	NNP
18637	14971	25	marshal	marshal	NN
18637	14971	26	to	to	TO
18637	14971	27	release	release	VB
18637	14971	28	a	a	DT
18637	14971	29	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	14971	30	who	who	WP
18637	14971	31	had	have	VBD
18637	14971	32	been	be	VBN
18637	14971	33	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	14971	34	of	of	IN
18637	14971	35	aiding	aid	VBG
18637	14971	36	and	and	CC
18637	14971	37	abetting	abet	VBG
18637	14971	38	the	the	DT
18637	14971	39	escape	escape	NN
18637	14971	40	of	of	IN
18637	14971	41	a	a	DT
18637	14971	42	fugitive	fugitive	JJ
18637	14971	43	slave	slave	NN
18637	14971	44	.	.	.
18637	14972	1	In	in	IN
18637	14972	2	a	a	DT
18637	14972	3	further	further	JJ
18637	14972	4	act	act	NN
18637	14972	5	of	of	IN
18637	14972	6	defiance	defiance	NN
18637	14972	7	,	,	,
18637	14972	8	the	the	DT
18637	14972	9	State	State	NNP
18637	14972	10	court	court	NN
18637	14972	11	instructed	instruct	VBD
18637	14972	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14972	13	clerk	clerk	NN
18637	14972	14	to	to	TO
18637	14972	15	disregard	disregard	VB
18637	14972	16	and	and	CC
18637	14972	17	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	14972	18	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	14972	19	to	to	IN
18637	14972	20	the	the	DT
18637	14972	21	writ	writ	NN
18637	14972	22	of	of	IN
18637	14972	23	error	error	NN
18637	14972	24	issued	issue	VBN
18637	14972	25	by	by	IN
18637	14972	26	the	the	DT
18637	14972	27	United	United	NNP
18637	14972	28	States	States	NNP
18637	14972	29	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14972	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14972	31	.	.	.
18637	14973	1	Strongly	strongly	RB
18637	14973	2	denouncing	denounce	VBG
18637	14973	3	this	this	DT
18637	14973	4	interference	interference	NN
18637	14973	5	with	with	IN
18637	14973	6	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14973	7	authority	authority	NN
18637	14973	8	,	,	,
18637	14973	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	14973	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14973	11	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	14973	12	held	hold	VBD
18637	14973	13	that	that	IN
18637	14973	14	when	when	WRB
18637	14973	15	a	a	DT
18637	14973	16	State	State	NNP
18637	14973	17	court	court	NN
18637	14973	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	14973	19	advised	advise	VBN
18637	14973	20	,	,	,
18637	14973	21	on	on	IN
18637	14973	22	the	the	DT
18637	14973	23	return	return	NN
18637	14973	24	of	of	IN
18637	14973	25	a	a	DT
18637	14973	26	writ	writ	NN
18637	14973	27	of	of	IN
18637	14973	28	_	_	NNP
18637	14973	29	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	14973	30	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	14973	31	_	_	NNP
18637	14973	32	,	,	,
18637	14973	33	that	that	IN
18637	14973	34	the	the	DT
18637	14973	35	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	14973	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	14973	37	in	in	IN
18637	14973	38	custody	custody	NN
18637	14973	39	on	on	IN
18637	14973	40	authority	authority	NN
18637	14973	41	of	of	IN
18637	14973	42	the	the	DT
18637	14973	43	United	United	NNP
18637	14973	44	States	States	NNP
18637	14973	45	,	,	,
18637	14973	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14973	47	can	can	MD
18637	14973	48	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	14973	49	no	no	RB
18637	14973	50	further	further	RB
18637	14973	51	.	.	.
18637	14974	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14974	2	34	34	CD
18637	14974	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14974	4	To	to	TO
18637	14974	5	protect	protect	VB
18637	14974	6	the	the	DT
18637	14974	7	performance	performance	NN
18637	14974	8	of	of	IN
18637	14974	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14974	10	functions	function	NNS
18637	14974	11	against	against	IN
18637	14974	12	interference	interference	NN
18637	14974	13	by	by	IN
18637	14974	14	State	state	NN
18637	14974	15	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	14974	16	,	,	,
18637	14974	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14974	18	may	may	MD
18637	14974	19	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	14974	20	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	14974	21	the	the	DT
18637	14974	22	removal	removal	NN
18637	14974	23	to	to	IN
18637	14974	24	a	a	DT
18637	14974	25	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14974	26	court	court	NN
18637	14974	27	of	of	IN
18637	14974	28	a	a	DT
18637	14974	29	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	14974	30	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	14974	31	commenced	commence	VBN
18637	14974	32	in	in	IN
18637	14974	33	a	a	DT
18637	14974	34	State	State	NNP
18637	14974	35	court	court	NN
18637	14974	36	against	against	IN
18637	14974	37	a	a	DT
18637	14974	38	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	14974	39	officer	officer	NN
18637	14974	40	of	of	IN
18637	14974	41	the	the	DT
18637	14974	42	United	United	NNP
18637	14974	43	States	States	NNP
18637	14974	44	on	on	IN
18637	14974	45	account	account	NN
18637	14974	46	of	of	IN
18637	14974	47	any	any	DT
18637	14974	48	act	act	NN
18637	14974	49	done	do	VBN
18637	14974	50	under	under	IN
18637	14974	51	color	color	NN
18637	14974	52	of	of	IN
18637	14974	53	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14974	54	office	office	NN
18637	14974	55	.	.	.
18637	14975	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14975	2	35	35	CD
18637	14975	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14975	4	In	in	IN
18637	14975	5	the	the	DT
18637	14975	6	celebrated	celebrated	JJ
18637	14975	7	case	case	NN
18637	14975	8	of	of	IN
18637	14975	9	Cunningham	Cunningham	NNP
18637	14975	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14975	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	14975	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14975	13	Neagle,[36	Neagle,[36	NNP
18637	14975	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14975	15	a	a	DT
18637	14975	16	United	United	NNP
18637	14975	17	States	States	NNP
18637	14975	18	marshal	marshal	NN
18637	14975	19	who	who	WP
18637	14975	20	,	,	,
18637	14975	21	while	while	IN
18637	14975	22	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	14975	23	to	to	TO
18637	14975	24	protect	protect	VB
18637	14975	25	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14975	26	Field	Field	NNP
18637	14975	27	,	,	,
18637	14975	28	killed	kill	VBD
18637	14975	29	the	the	DT
18637	14975	30	man	man	NN
18637	14975	31	who	who	WP
18637	14975	32	had	have	VBD
18637	14975	33	been	be	VBN
18637	14975	34	threatening	threaten	VBG
18637	14975	35	the	the	DT
18637	14975	36	life	life	NN
18637	14975	37	of	of	IN
18637	14975	38	the	the	DT
18637	14975	39	latter	latter	JJ
18637	14975	40	,	,	,
18637	14975	41	was	be	VBD
18637	14975	42	charged	charge	VBN
18637	14975	43	with	with	IN
18637	14975	44	murder	murder	NN
18637	14975	45	by	by	IN
18637	14975	46	the	the	DT
18637	14975	47	State	State	NNP
18637	14975	48	of	of	IN
18637	14975	49	California	California	NNP
18637	14975	50	.	.	.
18637	14976	1	Invoking	invoke	VBG
18637	14976	2	the	the	DT
18637	14976	3	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	14976	4	clause	clause	NN
18637	14976	5	,	,	,
18637	14976	6	the	the	DT
18637	14976	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	14976	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14976	9	held	hold	VBD
18637	14976	10	that	that	IN
18637	14976	11	a	a	DT
18637	14976	12	person	person	NN
18637	14976	13	could	could	MD
18637	14976	14	not	not	RB
18637	14976	15	be	be	VB
18637	14976	16	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	14976	17	of	of	IN
18637	14976	18	a	a	DT
18637	14976	19	crime	crime	NN
18637	14976	20	under	under	IN
18637	14976	21	State	State	NNP
18637	14976	22	law	law	NN
18637	14976	23	for	for	IN
18637	14976	24	doing	do	VBG
18637	14976	25	what	what	WP
18637	14976	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14976	27	was	be	VBD
18637	14976	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	14976	29	duty	duty	NN
18637	14976	30	to	to	TO
18637	14976	31	do	do	VB
18637	14976	32	as	as	IN
18637	14976	33	an	an	DT
18637	14976	34	officer	officer	NN
18637	14976	35	of	of	IN
18637	14976	36	the	the	DT
18637	14976	37	United	United	NNP
18637	14976	38	States	States	NNP
18637	14976	39	.	.	.
18637	14977	1	EFFECT	effect	NN
18637	14977	2	OF	of	IN
18637	14977	3	LAWS	LAWS	NNP
18637	14977	4	PASSED	pass	VBN
18637	14977	5	BY	by	IN
18637	14977	6	STATES	state	NNS
18637	14977	7	IN	in	IN
18637	14977	8	INSURRECTION	insurrection	NN
18637	14977	9	Since	since	IN
18637	14977	10	the	the	DT
18637	14977	11	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	14977	12	of	of	IN
18637	14977	13	States	States	NNPS
18637	14977	14	to	to	TO
18637	14977	15	depart	depart	VB
18637	14977	16	from	from	IN
18637	14977	17	the	the	DT
18637	14977	18	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14977	19	,	,	,
18637	14977	20	if	if	IN
18637	14977	21	successful	successful	JJ
18637	14977	22	,	,	,
18637	14977	23	would	would	MD
18637	14977	24	have	have	VB
18637	14977	25	been	be	VBN
18637	14977	26	_	_	NNP
18637	14977	27	pro	pro	JJ
18637	14977	28	tanto	tanto	IN
18637	14977	29	_	_	NNP
18637	14977	30	a	a	DT
18637	14977	31	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	14977	32	of	of	IN
18637	14977	33	the	the	DT
18637	14977	34	Constitution,[37	constitution,[37	NN
18637	14977	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14977	36	the	the	DT
18637	14977	37	ordinances	ordinance	NNS
18637	14977	38	of	of	IN
18637	14977	39	secession	secession	NN
18637	14977	40	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	14977	41	by	by	IN
18637	14977	42	the	the	DT
18637	14977	43	Confederate	Confederate	NNP
18637	14977	44	States,[38	states,[38	NN
18637	14977	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14977	46	and	and	CC
18637	14977	47	all	all	DT
18637	14977	48	acts	act	NNS
18637	14977	49	of	of	IN
18637	14977	50	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	14977	51	intended	intend	VBN
18637	14977	52	to	to	TO
18637	14977	53	give	give	VB
18637	14977	54	effect	effect	NN
18637	14977	55	to	to	IN
18637	14977	56	such	such	JJ
18637	14977	57	ordinances,[39	ordinances,[39	CD
18637	14977	58	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14977	59	were	be	VBD
18637	14977	60	treated	treat	VBN
18637	14977	61	as	as	IN
18637	14977	62	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	14977	63	nullities	nullity	NNS
18637	14977	64	.	.	.
18637	14978	1	The	the	DT
18637	14978	2	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	14978	3	of	of	IN
18637	14978	4	every	every	DT
18637	14978	5	State	State	NNP
18637	14978	6	,	,	,
18637	14978	7	as	as	IN
18637	14978	8	a	a	DT
18637	14978	9	member	member	NN
18637	14978	10	of	of	IN
18637	14978	11	the	the	DT
18637	14978	12	Union	Union	NNP
18637	14978	13	,	,	,
18637	14978	14	and	and	CC
18637	14978	15	the	the	DT
18637	14978	16	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	14978	17	of	of	IN
18637	14978	18	every	every	DT
18637	14978	19	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	14978	20	of	of	IN
18637	14978	21	the	the	DT
18637	14978	22	State	State	NNP
18637	14978	23	,	,	,
18637	14978	24	as	as	IN
18637	14978	25	a	a	DT
18637	14978	26	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	14978	27	of	of	IN
18637	14978	28	the	the	DT
18637	14978	29	United	United	NNP
18637	14978	30	States	States	NNP
18637	14978	31	,	,	,
18637	14978	32	remained	remain	VBD
18637	14978	33	perfect	perfect	JJ
18637	14978	34	and	and	CC
18637	14978	35	unimpaired	unimpaired	JJ
18637	14978	36	.	.	.
18637	14979	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14979	2	40	40	CD
18637	14979	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14979	4	But	but	CC
18637	14979	5	acts	act	VBZ
18637	14979	6	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	14979	7	to	to	IN
18637	14979	8	peace	peace	NN
18637	14979	9	and	and	CC
18637	14979	10	good	good	JJ
18637	14979	11	order	order	NN
18637	14979	12	among	among	IN
18637	14979	13	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	14979	14	,	,	,
18637	14979	15	such	such	JJ
18637	14979	16	,	,	,
18637	14979	17	for	for	IN
18637	14979	18	example	example	NN
18637	14979	19	,	,	,
18637	14979	20	as	as	IN
18637	14979	21	acts	act	NNS
18637	14979	22	sanctioning	sanction	VBG
18637	14979	23	and	and	CC
18637	14979	24	protecting	protect	VBG
18637	14979	25	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	14979	26	and	and	CC
18637	14979	27	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	14979	28	relations	relation	NNS
18637	14979	29	,	,	,
18637	14979	30	governing	govern	VBG
18637	14979	31	the	the	DT
18637	14979	32	course	course	NN
18637	14979	33	of	of	IN
18637	14979	34	descents	descent	NNS
18637	14979	35	,	,	,
18637	14979	36	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	14979	37	the	the	DT
18637	14979	38	conveyance	conveyance	NN
18637	14979	39	of	of	IN
18637	14979	40	property	property	NN
18637	14979	41	,	,	,
18637	14979	42	real	real	JJ
18637	14979	43	and	and	CC
18637	14979	44	personal	personal	JJ
18637	14979	45	,	,	,
18637	14979	46	and	and	CC
18637	14979	47	providing	provide	VBG
18637	14979	48	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	14979	49	for	for	IN
18637	14979	50	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	14979	51	to	to	IN
18637	14979	52	person	person	NN
18637	14979	53	and	and	CC
18637	14979	54	estate	estate	NN
18637	14979	55	,	,	,
18637	14979	56	and	and	CC
18637	14979	57	other	other	JJ
18637	14979	58	similar	similar	JJ
18637	14979	59	acts	act	NNS
18637	14979	60	,	,	,
18637	14979	61	which	which	WDT
18637	14979	62	would	would	MD
18637	14979	63	be	be	VB
18637	14979	64	valid	valid	JJ
18637	14979	65	if	if	IN
18637	14979	66	emanating	emanate	VBG
18637	14979	67	from	from	IN
18637	14979	68	a	a	DT
18637	14979	69	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	14979	70	government	government	NN
18637	14979	71	,	,	,
18637	14979	72	were	be	VBD
18637	14979	73	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	14979	74	in	in	IN
18637	14979	75	general	general	JJ
18637	14979	76	as	as	IN
18637	14979	77	valid	valid	JJ
18637	14979	78	when	when	WRB
18637	14979	79	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	14979	80	from	from	IN
18637	14979	81	an	an	DT
18637	14979	82	actual	actual	JJ
18637	14979	83	,	,	,
18637	14979	84	though	though	IN
18637	14979	85	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	14979	86	government	government	NN
18637	14979	87	.	.	.
18637	14980	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14980	2	41	41	CD
18637	14980	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14980	4	The	the	DT
18637	14980	5	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	14980	6	of	of	IN
18637	14980	7	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	14980	8	Exemption	Exemption	NNP
18637	14980	9	McCULLOCH	McCULLOCH	NNP
18637	14980	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14980	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	14980	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14980	13	MARYLAND	MARYLAND	NNP
18637	14980	14	Five	five	CD
18637	14980	15	years	year	NNS
18637	14980	16	after	after	IN
18637	14980	17	the	the	DT
18637	14980	18	decision	decision	NN
18637	14980	19	in	in	IN
18637	14980	20	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	14980	21	_	_	NNP
18637	14980	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	14980	23	_	_	NNP
18637	14980	24	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	14980	25	that	that	IN
18637	14980	26	a	a	DT
18637	14980	27	State	state	NN
18637	14980	28	may	may	MD
18637	14980	29	not	not	RB
18637	14980	30	tax	tax	VB
18637	14980	31	an	an	DT
18637	14980	32	instrumentality	instrumentality	NN
18637	14980	33	of	of	IN
18637	14980	34	the	the	DT
18637	14980	35	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	14980	36	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14980	37	,	,	,
18637	14980	38	the	the	DT
18637	14980	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14980	40	was	be	VBD
18637	14980	41	asked	ask	VBN
18637	14980	42	to	to	TO
18637	14980	43	and	and	CC
18637	14980	44	did	do	VBD
18637	14980	45	reexamine	reexamine	VB
18637	14980	46	the	the	DT
18637	14980	47	entire	entire	JJ
18637	14980	48	question	question	NN
18637	14980	49	in	in	IN
18637	14980	50	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	14980	51	_	_	NNP
18637	14980	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	14980	53	_	_	NNP
18637	14980	54	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	14980	55	of	of	IN
18637	14980	56	the	the	DT
18637	14980	57	United	United	NNP
18637	14980	58	States	States	NNP
18637	14980	59	.	.	.
18637	14981	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14981	2	42	42	CD
18637	14981	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14981	4	In	in	IN
18637	14981	5	that	that	DT
18637	14981	6	case	case	NN
18637	14981	7	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	14981	8	for	for	IN
18637	14981	9	the	the	DT
18637	14981	10	State	State	NNP
18637	14981	11	of	of	IN
18637	14981	12	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	14981	13	,	,	,
18637	14981	14	whose	whose	WP$
18637	14981	15	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	14981	16	to	to	TO
18637	14981	17	tax	tax	VB
18637	14981	18	the	the	DT
18637	14981	19	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	14981	20	was	be	VBD
18637	14981	21	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	14981	22	,	,	,
18637	14981	23	put	put	VBN
18637	14981	24	forward	forward	RB
18637	14981	25	two	two	CD
18637	14981	26	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	14981	27	of	of	IN
18637	14981	28	great	great	JJ
18637	14981	29	importance	importance	NN
18637	14981	30	.	.	.
18637	14982	1	In	in	IN
18637	14982	2	the	the	DT
18637	14982	3	first	first	JJ
18637	14982	4	place	place	NN
18637	14982	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14982	6	was	be	VBD
18637	14982	7	"	"	``
18637	14982	8	contended	contend	VBN
18637	14982	9	,	,	,
18637	14982	10	that	that	IN
18637	14982	11	,	,	,
18637	14982	12	admitting	admit	VBG
18637	14982	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14982	14	to	to	TO
18637	14982	15	possess	possess	VB
18637	14982	16	the	the	DT
18637	14982	17	power	power	NN
18637	14982	18	,	,	,
18637	14982	19	this	this	DT
18637	14982	20	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	14982	21	ought	ought	MD
18637	14982	22	to	to	TO
18637	14982	23	have	have	VB
18637	14982	24	been	be	VBN
18637	14982	25	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	14982	26	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	14982	27	in	in	IN
18637	14982	28	the	the	DT
18637	14982	29	act	act	NN
18637	14982	30	of	of	IN
18637	14982	31	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	14982	32	;	;	,
18637	14982	33	and	and	CC
18637	14982	34	,	,	,
18637	14982	35	not	not	RB
18637	14982	36	being	be	VBG
18637	14982	37	expressed	express	VBN
18637	14982	38	,	,	,
18637	14982	39	ought	ought	MD
18637	14982	40	not	not	RB
18637	14982	41	to	to	TO
18637	14982	42	be	be	VB
18637	14982	43	implied	imply	VBN
18637	14982	44	by	by	IN
18637	14982	45	the	the	DT
18637	14982	46	Court	Court	NNP
18637	14982	47	.	.	.
18637	14983	1	"	"	``
18637	14983	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14983	3	43	43	CD
18637	14983	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14983	5	To	to	TO
18637	14983	6	which	which	WDT
18637	14983	7	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	14983	8	replied	reply	VBD
18637	14983	9	that	that	IN
18637	14983	10	:	:	:
18637	14983	11	"	"	``
18637	14983	12	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14983	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	14983	14	no	no	DT
18637	14983	15	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	14983	16	thing	thing	NN
18637	14983	17	for	for	IN
18637	14983	18	an	an	DT
18637	14983	19	act	act	NN
18637	14983	20	of	of	IN
18637	14983	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14983	22	to	to	TO
18637	14983	23	imply	imply	VB
18637	14983	24	,	,	,
18637	14983	25	without	without	IN
18637	14983	26	expressing	express	VBG
18637	14983	27	,	,	,
18637	14983	28	this	this	DT
18637	14983	29	very	very	JJ
18637	14983	30	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	14983	31	from	from	IN
18637	14983	32	state	state	NN
18637	14983	33	control	control	NN
18637	14983	34	,	,	,
18637	14983	35	which	which	WDT
18637	14983	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	14983	37	said	say	VBN
18637	14983	38	to	to	TO
18637	14983	39	be	be	VB
18637	14983	40	so	so	RB
18637	14983	41	objectionable	objectionable	JJ
18637	14983	42	in	in	IN
18637	14983	43	this	this	DT
18637	14983	44	instance	instance	NN
18637	14983	45	.	.	.
18637	14984	1	"	"	``
18637	14984	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14984	3	44	44	CD
18637	14984	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14984	5	Secondly	secondly	RB
18637	14984	6	the	the	DT
18637	14984	7	appellants	appellant	NNS
18637	14984	8	relied	rely	VBD
18637	14984	9	"	"	``
18637	14984	10	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	14984	11	on	on	IN
18637	14984	12	the	the	DT
18637	14984	13	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	14984	14	between	between	IN
18637	14984	15	the	the	DT
18637	14984	16	bank	bank	NN
18637	14984	17	and	and	CC
18637	14984	18	the	the	DT
18637	14984	19	public	public	JJ
18637	14984	20	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	14984	21	,	,	,
18637	14984	22	such	such	JJ
18637	14984	23	as	as	IN
18637	14984	24	the	the	DT
18637	14984	25	mint	mint	NN
18637	14984	26	or	or	CC
18637	14984	27	the	the	DT
18637	14984	28	post	post	JJ
18637	14984	29	-	-	JJ
18637	14984	30	office	office	NN
18637	14984	31	.	.	.
18637	14985	1	The	the	DT
18637	14985	2	agents	agent	NNS
18637	14985	3	in	in	IN
18637	14985	4	those	those	DT
18637	14985	5	offices	office	NNS
18637	14985	6	are	be	VBP
18637	14985	7	,	,	,
18637	14985	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14985	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	14985	10	said	say	VBN
18637	14985	11	,	,	,
18637	14985	12	officers	officer	NNS
18637	14985	13	of	of	IN
18637	14985	14	government	government	NN
18637	14985	15	,	,	,
18637	14985	16	*	*	NFP
18637	14985	17	*	*	NFP
18637	14985	18	*	*	NFP
18637	14985	19	Not	not	RB
18637	14985	20	so	so	IN
18637	14985	21	the	the	DT
18637	14985	22	directors	director	NNS
18637	14985	23	of	of	IN
18637	14985	24	the	the	DT
18637	14985	25	bank	bank	NN
18637	14985	26	.	.	.
18637	14986	1	The	the	DT
18637	14986	2	connection	connection	NN
18637	14986	3	of	of	IN
18637	14986	4	the	the	DT
18637	14986	5	government	government	NN
18637	14986	6	with	with	IN
18637	14986	7	the	the	DT
18637	14986	8	bank	bank	NN
18637	14986	9	,	,	,
18637	14986	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	14986	11	likened	liken	VBN
18637	14986	12	to	to	IN
18637	14986	13	that	that	DT
18637	14986	14	with	with	IN
18637	14986	15	contractors	contractor	NNS
18637	14986	16	.	.	.
18637	14987	1	"	"	``
18637	14987	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14987	3	45	45	CD
18637	14987	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14987	5	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	14987	6	accepted	accept	VBD
18637	14987	7	this	this	DT
18637	14987	8	analogy	analogy	NN
18637	14987	9	,	,	,
18637	14987	10	but	but	CC
18637	14987	11	not	not	RB
18637	14987	12	to	to	IN
18637	14987	13	the	the	DT
18637	14987	14	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	14987	15	of	of	IN
18637	14987	16	the	the	DT
18637	14987	17	appellants	appellant	NNS
18637	14987	18	.	.	.
18637	14988	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14988	2	simply	simply	RB
18637	14988	3	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	14988	4	that	that	IN
18637	14988	5	all	all	DT
18637	14988	6	contractors	contractor	NNS
18637	14988	7	who	who	WP
18637	14988	8	dealt	deal	VBD
18637	14988	9	with	with	IN
18637	14988	10	the	the	DT
18637	14988	11	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14988	12	were	be	VBD
18637	14988	13	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	14988	14	to	to	IN
18637	14988	15	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	14988	16	from	from	IN
18637	14988	17	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	14988	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	14988	19	such	such	JJ
18637	14988	20	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	14988	21	.	.	.
18637	14989	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14989	2	46	46	CD
18637	14989	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14989	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	14989	5	not	not	RB
18637	14989	6	only	only	RB
18637	14989	7	was	be	VBD
18637	14989	8	the	the	DT
18637	14989	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	14989	10	of	of	IN
18637	14989	11	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	14989	12	_	_	NNP
18637	14989	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	14989	14	_	_	NNP
18637	14989	15	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	14989	16	reaffirmed	reaffirm	VBD
18637	14989	17	but	but	CC
18637	14989	18	the	the	DT
18637	14989	19	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	14989	20	was	be	VBD
18637	14989	21	laid	lay	VBN
18637	14989	22	for	for	IN
18637	14989	23	the	the	DT
18637	14989	24	vast	vast	JJ
18637	14989	25	expansion	expansion	NN
18637	14989	26	of	of	IN
18637	14989	27	the	the	DT
18637	14989	28	principle	principle	NN
18637	14989	29	of	of	IN
18637	14989	30	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	14989	31	that	that	WDT
18637	14989	32	was	be	VBD
18637	14989	33	to	to	TO
18637	14989	34	follow	follow	VB
18637	14989	35	in	in	IN
18637	14989	36	the	the	DT
18637	14989	37	succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	14989	38	decades	decade	NNS
18637	14989	39	.	.	.
18637	14990	1	APPLICABILITY	applicability	JJ
18637	14990	2	OF	of	IN
18637	14990	3	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNP
18637	14990	4	_	_	NNP
18637	14990	5	IN	IN	NNP
18637	14990	6	RE	RE	NNP
18637	14990	7	_	_	NNP
18637	14990	8	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	14990	9	SECURITIES	security	NNS
18637	14990	10	,	,	,
18637	14990	11	ETC	ETC	NNP
18637	14990	12	.	.	.
18637	14991	1	The	the	DT
18637	14991	2	first	first	JJ
18637	14991	3	significant	significant	JJ
18637	14991	4	extension	extension	NN
18637	14991	5	of	of	IN
18637	14991	6	the	the	DT
18637	14991	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	14991	8	of	of	IN
18637	14991	9	the	the	DT
18637	14991	10	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	14991	11	of	of	IN
18637	14991	12	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14991	13	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	14991	14	from	from	IN
18637	14991	15	State	State	NNP
18637	14991	16	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	14991	17	came	come	VBD
18637	14991	18	in	in	IN
18637	14991	19	Weston	Weston	NNP
18637	14991	20	_	_	NNP
18637	14991	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	14991	22	_	_	NNP
18637	14991	23	Charleston,[47	Charleston,[47	NNP
18637	14991	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14991	25	where	where	WRB
18637	14991	26	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	14991	27	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	14991	28	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	14991	29	also	also	RB
18637	14991	30	found	find	VBD
18637	14991	31	in	in	IN
18637	14991	32	the	the	DT
18637	14991	33	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	14991	34	clause	clause	NN
18637	14991	35	a	a	DT
18637	14991	36	bar	bar	NN
18637	14991	37	to	to	IN
18637	14991	38	State	state	NN
18637	14991	39	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	14991	40	of	of	IN
18637	14991	41	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	14991	42	of	of	IN
18637	14991	43	the	the	DT
18637	14991	44	United	United	NNP
18637	14991	45	States	States	NNP
18637	14991	46	.	.	.
18637	14992	1	During	during	IN
18637	14992	2	the	the	DT
18637	14992	3	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	14992	4	War	War	NNP
18637	14992	5	,	,	,
18637	14992	6	when	when	WRB
18637	14992	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14992	8	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	14992	9	the	the	DT
18637	14992	10	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	14992	11	of	of	IN
18637	14992	12	legal	legal	JJ
18637	14992	13	tender	tender	NN
18637	14992	14	notes	note	NNS
18637	14992	15	,	,	,
18637	14992	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14992	17	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	14992	18	declared	declare	VBD
18637	14992	19	that	that	IN
18637	14992	20	such	such	JJ
18637	14992	21	notes	note	NNS
18637	14992	22	,	,	,
18637	14992	23	as	as	RB
18637	14992	24	well	well	RB
18637	14992	25	as	as	IN
18637	14992	26	United	United	NNP
18637	14992	27	States	States	NNP
18637	14992	28	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	14992	29	and	and	CC
18637	14992	30	other	other	JJ
18637	14992	31	securities	security	NNS
18637	14992	32	,	,	,
18637	14992	33	should	should	MD
18637	14992	34	be	be	VB
18637	14992	35	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	14992	36	from	from	IN
18637	14992	37	State	state	NN
18637	14992	38	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	14992	39	.	.	.
18637	14993	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14993	2	48	48	CD
18637	14993	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14993	4	A	a	DT
18637	14993	5	modified	modify	VBN
18637	14993	6	version	version	NN
18637	14993	7	of	of	IN
18637	14993	8	this	this	DT
18637	14993	9	section	section	NN
18637	14993	10	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	14993	11	on	on	IN
18637	14993	12	the	the	DT
18637	14993	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	14993	14	books	book	NNS
18637	14993	15	today	today	NN
18637	14993	16	.	.	.
18637	14994	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14994	2	49	49	CD
18637	14994	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14994	4	The	the	DT
18637	14994	5	right	right	NN
18637	14994	6	of	of	IN
18637	14994	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	14994	8	to	to	TO
18637	14994	9	exempt	exempt	VB
18637	14994	10	legal	legal	JJ
18637	14994	11	tender	tender	NN
18637	14994	12	notes	note	NNS
18637	14994	13	to	to	IN
18637	14994	14	the	the	DT
18637	14994	15	same	same	JJ
18637	14994	16	extent	extent	NN
18637	14994	17	as	as	IN
18637	14994	18	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	14994	19	was	be	VBD
18637	14994	20	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	14994	21	in	in	IN
18637	14994	22	People	People	NNP
18637	14994	23	_	_	NNP
18637	14994	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	14994	25	_	_	NNP
18637	14994	26	Board	Board	NNP
18637	14994	27	of	of	IN
18637	14994	28	Supervisors[50	Supervisors[50	NNP
18637	14994	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14994	30	over	over	IN
18637	14994	31	the	the	DT
18637	14994	32	objection	objection	NN
18637	14994	33	that	that	IN
18637	14994	34	such	such	JJ
18637	14994	35	notes	note	NNS
18637	14994	36	circulated	circulate	VBD
18637	14994	37	as	as	IN
18637	14994	38	money	money	NN
18637	14994	39	and	and	CC
18637	14994	40	should	should	MD
18637	14994	41	be	be	VB
18637	14994	42	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	14994	43	in	in	IN
18637	14994	44	the	the	DT
18637	14994	45	same	same	JJ
18637	14994	46	way	way	NN
18637	14994	47	as	as	IN
18637	14994	48	coin	coin	NN
18637	14994	49	.	.	.
18637	14995	1	But	but	CC
18637	14995	2	a	a	DT
18637	14995	3	State	state	NN
18637	14995	4	tax	tax	NN
18637	14995	5	on	on	IN
18637	14995	6	checks	check	NNS
18637	14995	7	issued	issue	VBN
18637	14995	8	by	by	IN
18637	14995	9	the	the	DT
18637	14995	10	Treasurer	Treasurer	NNP
18637	14995	11	of	of	IN
18637	14995	12	the	the	DT
18637	14995	13	United	United	NNP
18637	14995	14	States	States	NNP
18637	14995	15	for	for	IN
18637	14995	16	interest	interest	NN
18637	14995	17	accrued	accrue	VBN
18637	14995	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	14995	19	government	government	NN
18637	14995	20	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	14995	21	was	be	VBD
18637	14995	22	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	14995	23	since	since	IN
18637	14995	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	14995	25	did	do	VBD
18637	14995	26	not	not	RB
18637	14995	27	in	in	IN
18637	14995	28	any	any	DT
18637	14995	29	wise	wise	JJ
18637	14995	30	affect	affect	NN
18637	14995	31	the	the	DT
18637	14995	32	credit	credit	NN
18637	14995	33	of	of	IN
18637	14995	34	the	the	DT
18637	14995	35	National	National	NNP
18637	14995	36	Government	Government	NNP
18637	14995	37	.	.	.
18637	14996	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14996	2	51	51	CD
18637	14996	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14996	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	14996	5	,	,	,
18637	14996	6	the	the	DT
18637	14996	7	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	14996	8	for	for	IN
18637	14996	9	an	an	DT
18637	14996	10	_	_	NNP
18637	14996	11	ad	ad	NN
18637	14996	12	valorem	valorem	NN
18637	14996	13	_	_	NNP
18637	14996	14	property	property	NN
18637	14996	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	14996	16	of	of	IN
18637	14996	17	an	an	DT
18637	14996	18	open	open	JJ
18637	14996	19	account	account	NN
18637	14996	20	for	for	IN
18637	14996	21	money	money	NN
18637	14996	22	due	due	JJ
18637	14996	23	under	under	IN
18637	14996	24	a	a	DT
18637	14996	25	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14996	26	contract,[52	contract,[52	CD
18637	14996	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14996	28	and	and	CC
18637	14996	29	the	the	DT
18637	14996	30	inclusion	inclusion	NN
18637	14996	31	of	of	IN
18637	14996	32	the	the	DT
18637	14996	33	value	value	NN
18637	14996	34	of	of	IN
18637	14996	35	United	United	NNP
18637	14996	36	States	States	NNP
18637	14996	37	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	14996	38	owned	own	VBN
18637	14996	39	by	by	IN
18637	14996	40	a	a	DT
18637	14996	41	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	14996	42	,	,	,
18637	14996	43	in	in	IN
18637	14996	44	measuring	measure	VBG
18637	14996	45	an	an	DT
18637	14996	46	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	14996	47	tax,[53	tax,[53	CD
18637	14996	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14996	49	were	be	VBD
18637	14996	50	held	hold	VBN
18637	14996	51	valid	valid	JJ
18637	14996	52	,	,	,
18637	14996	53	since	since	IN
18637	14996	54	neither	neither	DT
18637	14996	55	tax	tax	NN
18637	14996	56	would	would	MD
18637	14996	57	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	14996	58	embarrass	embarrass	VB
18637	14996	59	the	the	DT
18637	14996	60	power	power	NN
18637	14996	61	of	of	IN
18637	14996	62	the	the	DT
18637	14996	63	United	United	NNP
18637	14996	64	States	States	NNP
18637	14996	65	to	to	TO
18637	14996	66	secure	secure	VB
18637	14996	67	credit	credit	NN
18637	14996	68	.	.	.
18637	14997	1	Income	income	NN
18637	14997	2	from	from	IN
18637	14997	3	federal	federal	JJ
18637	14997	4	securities	security	NNS
18637	14997	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	14997	6	also	also	RB
18637	14997	7	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	14997	8	the	the	DT
18637	14997	9	reach	reach	NN
18637	14997	10	of	of	IN
18637	14997	11	the	the	DT
18637	14997	12	State	State	NNP
18637	14997	13	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	14997	14	power	power	NN
18637	14997	15	as	as	IN
18637	14997	16	the	the	DT
18637	14997	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	14997	18	now	now	RB
18637	14997	19	stand	stand	VBP
18637	14997	20	.	.	.
18637	14998	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14998	2	54	54	CD
18637	14998	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14998	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	14998	5	can	can	MD
18637	14998	6	such	such	PDT
18637	14998	7	a	a	DT
18637	14998	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	14998	9	be	be	VB
18637	14998	10	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	14998	11	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	14998	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	14998	13	the	the	DT
18637	14998	14	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	14998	15	on	on	IN
18637	14998	16	such	such	JJ
18637	14998	17	part	part	NN
18637	14998	18	of	of	IN
18637	14998	19	the	the	DT
18637	14998	20	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	14998	21	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	14998	22	as	as	IN
18637	14998	23	corresponds	correspond	NNS
18637	14998	24	to	to	IN
18637	14998	25	the	the	DT
18637	14998	26	part	part	NN
18637	14998	27	of	of	IN
18637	14998	28	the	the	DT
18637	14998	29	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	14998	30	's	's	POS
18637	14998	31	income	income	NN
18637	14998	32	which	which	WDT
18637	14998	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	14998	34	not	not	RB
18637	14998	35	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	14998	36	,	,	,
18637	14998	37	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	14998	38	,	,	,
18637	14998	39	income	income	NN
18637	14998	40	from	from	IN
18637	14998	41	tax	tax	NN
18637	14998	42	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	14998	43	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	14998	44	.	.	.
18637	14999	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	14999	2	55	55	CD
18637	14999	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	14999	4	A	a	DT
18637	14999	5	State	state	NN
18637	14999	6	may	may	MD
18637	14999	7	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	14999	8	levy	levy	VB
18637	14999	9	an	an	DT
18637	14999	10	excise	excise	NN
18637	14999	11	tax	tax	NN
18637	14999	12	on	on	IN
18637	14999	13	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	14999	14	for	for	IN
18637	14999	15	the	the	DT
18637	14999	16	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	14999	17	of	of	IN
18637	14999	18	doing	do	VBG
18637	14999	19	business	business	NN
18637	14999	20	,	,	,
18637	14999	21	and	and	CC
18637	14999	22	measure	measure	VB
18637	14999	23	the	the	DT
18637	14999	24	tax	tax	NN
18637	14999	25	by	by	IN
18637	14999	26	the	the	DT
18637	14999	27	property	property	NN
18637	14999	28	or	or	CC
18637	14999	29	net	net	JJ
18637	14999	30	income	income	NN
18637	14999	31	of	of	IN
18637	14999	32	the	the	DT
18637	14999	33	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	14999	34	,	,	,
18637	14999	35	including	include	VBG
18637	14999	36	tax	tax	NN
18637	14999	37	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	14999	38	United	United	NNP
18637	14999	39	States	States	NNP
18637	14999	40	securities	security	NNS
18637	14999	41	or	or	CC
18637	14999	42	the	the	DT
18637	14999	43	income	income	NN
18637	14999	44	derived	derive	VBD
18637	14999	45	therefrom	therefrom	NN
18637	14999	46	.	.	.
18637	15000	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15000	2	56	56	LS
18637	15000	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15000	4	The	the	DT
18637	15000	5	designation	designation	NN
18637	15000	6	of	of	IN
18637	15000	7	a	a	DT
18637	15000	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	15000	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	15000	10	not	not	RB
18637	15000	11	controlling	control	VBG
18637	15000	12	.	.	.
18637	15001	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15001	2	57	57	CD
18637	15001	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15001	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	15001	5	a	a	DT
18637	15001	6	so	so	RB
18637	15001	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	15001	8	called	call	VBN
18637	15001	9	"	"	``
18637	15001	10	license	license	NN
18637	15001	11	tax	tax	NN
18637	15001	12	"	"	''
18637	15001	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	15001	14	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	15001	15	companies	company	NNS
18637	15001	16	,	,	,
18637	15001	17	measured	measure	VBN
18637	15001	18	by	by	IN
18637	15001	19	gross	gross	JJ
18637	15001	20	income	income	NN
18637	15001	21	,	,	,
18637	15001	22	including	include	VBG
18637	15001	23	interest	interest	NN
18637	15001	24	on	on	IN
18637	15001	25	government	government	NN
18637	15001	26	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	15001	27	,	,	,
18637	15001	28	was	be	VBD
18637	15001	29	,	,	,
18637	15001	30	in	in	IN
18637	15001	31	effect	effect	NN
18637	15001	32	,	,	,
18637	15001	33	a	a	DT
18637	15001	34	commutation	commutation	NN
18637	15001	35	tax	tax	NN
18637	15001	36	levied	levy	VBN
18637	15001	37	in	in	IN
18637	15001	38	lieu	lieu	NN
18637	15001	39	of	of	IN
18637	15001	40	other	other	JJ
18637	15001	41	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	15001	42	upon	upon	IN
18637	15001	43	the	the	DT
18637	15001	44	personal	personal	JJ
18637	15001	45	property	property	NN
18637	15001	46	of	of	IN
18637	15001	47	the	the	DT
18637	15001	48	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	15001	49	,	,	,
18637	15001	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15001	51	was	be	VBD
18637	15001	52	still	still	RB
18637	15001	53	held	hold	VBN
18637	15001	54	to	to	TO
18637	15001	55	amount	amount	VB
18637	15001	56	to	to	IN
18637	15001	57	an	an	DT
18637	15001	58	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	15001	59	tax	tax	NN
18637	15001	60	on	on	IN
18637	15001	61	the	the	DT
18637	15001	62	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	15001	63	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15001	64	.	.	.
18637	15002	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15002	2	58	58	CD
18637	15002	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15002	4	TAXATION	taxation	NN
18637	15002	5	OF	of	IN
18637	15002	6	GOVERNMENT	GOVERNMENT	NNP
18637	15002	7	CONTRACTORS	CONTRACTORS	NNP
18637	15002	8	In	in	IN
18637	15002	9	the	the	DT
18637	15002	10	course	course	NN
18637	15002	11	of	of	IN
18637	15002	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15002	13	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15002	14	in	in	IN
18637	15002	15	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	15002	16	_	_	NNP
18637	15002	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	15002	18	_	_	NNP
18637	15002	19	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	15002	20	of	of	IN
18637	15002	21	the	the	DT
18637	15002	22	United	United	NNP
18637	15002	23	States,[59	States,[59	NNP
18637	15002	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15002	25	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15002	26	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15002	27	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	15002	28	posed	pose	VBD
18637	15002	29	the	the	DT
18637	15002	30	question	question	NN
18637	15002	31	:	:	:
18637	15002	32	"	"	``
18637	15002	33	Can	Can	MD
18637	15002	34	a	a	DT
18637	15002	35	contractor	contractor	NN
18637	15002	36	for	for	IN
18637	15002	37	supplying	supply	VBG
18637	15002	38	a	a	DT
18637	15002	39	military	military	JJ
18637	15002	40	post	post	NN
18637	15002	41	with	with	IN
18637	15002	42	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	15002	43	,	,	,
18637	15002	44	be	be	VB
18637	15002	45	restrained	restrain	VBN
18637	15002	46	from	from	IN
18637	15002	47	making	make	VBG
18637	15002	48	purchases	purchase	NNS
18637	15002	49	within	within	IN
18637	15002	50	any	any	DT
18637	15002	51	state	state	NN
18637	15002	52	,	,	,
18637	15002	53	or	or	CC
18637	15002	54	from	from	IN
18637	15002	55	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	15002	56	the	the	DT
18637	15002	57	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	15002	58	to	to	IN
18637	15002	59	the	the	DT
18637	15002	60	place	place	NN
18637	15002	61	at	at	IN
18637	15002	62	which	which	WDT
18637	15002	63	the	the	DT
18637	15002	64	troops	troop	NNS
18637	15002	65	were	be	VBD
18637	15002	66	stationed	station	VBN
18637	15002	67	?	?	.
18637	15003	1	or	or	CC
18637	15003	2	could	could	MD
18637	15003	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15003	4	be	be	VB
18637	15003	5	fined	fine	VBN
18637	15003	6	or	or	CC
18637	15003	7	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	15003	8	for	for	IN
18637	15003	9	doing	do	VBG
18637	15003	10	so	so	RB
18637	15003	11	?	?	.
18637	15004	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15004	2	have	have	VBP
18637	15004	3	not	not	RB
18637	15004	4	yet	yet	RB
18637	15004	5	heard	hear	VBN
18637	15004	6	these	these	DT
18637	15004	7	questions	question	NNS
18637	15004	8	answered	answer	VBN
18637	15004	9	in	in	IN
18637	15004	10	the	the	DT
18637	15004	11	affirmative	affirmative	NN
18637	15004	12	.	.	.
18637	15005	1	"	"	``
18637	15005	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15005	3	60	60	CD
18637	15005	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15005	5	One	one	CD
18637	15005	6	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	15005	7	and	and	CC
18637	15005	8	thirteen	thirteen	CD
18637	15005	9	years	year	NNS
18637	15005	10	later	later	RB
18637	15005	11	,	,	,
18637	15005	12	the	the	DT
18637	15005	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15005	14	did	do	VBD
18637	15005	15	answer	answer	VB
18637	15005	16	the	the	DT
18637	15005	17	last	last	JJ
18637	15005	18	part	part	NN
18637	15005	19	of	of	IN
18637	15005	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15005	21	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	15005	22	in	in	IN
18637	15005	23	the	the	DT
18637	15005	24	affirmative	affirmative	NN
18637	15005	25	.	.	.
18637	15006	1	In	in	IN
18637	15006	2	James	James	NNP
18637	15006	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15006	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	15006	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15006	6	Dravo	Dravo	NNP
18637	15006	7	Contracting	Contracting	NNP
18637	15006	8	Company[61	Company[61	VBN
18637	15006	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15006	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15006	11	held	hold	VBD
18637	15006	12	that	that	IN
18637	15006	13	a	a	DT
18637	15006	14	State	state	NN
18637	15006	15	may	may	MD
18637	15006	16	impose	impose	VB
18637	15006	17	an	an	DT
18637	15006	18	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	15006	19	tax	tax	NN
18637	15006	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	15006	21	an	an	DT
18637	15006	22	independent	independent	JJ
18637	15006	23	contractor	contractor	NN
18637	15006	24	,	,	,
18637	15006	25	measured	measure	VBN
18637	15006	26	by	by	IN
18637	15006	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15006	28	gross	gross	JJ
18637	15006	29	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	15006	30	under	under	IN
18637	15006	31	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	15006	32	with	with	IN
18637	15006	33	the	the	DT
18637	15006	34	United	United	NNP
18637	15006	35	States	States	NNP
18637	15006	36	.	.	.
18637	15007	1	Previously	previously	RB
18637	15007	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15007	3	had	have	VBD
18637	15007	4	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	15007	5	a	a	DT
18637	15007	6	gross	gross	JJ
18637	15007	7	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	15007	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	15007	9	levied	levy	VBN
18637	15007	10	in	in	IN
18637	15007	11	lieu	lieu	NN
18637	15007	12	of	of	IN
18637	15007	13	a	a	DT
18637	15007	14	property	property	NN
18637	15007	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	15007	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	15007	17	the	the	DT
18637	15007	18	operator	operator	NN
18637	15007	19	of	of	IN
18637	15007	20	an	an	DT
18637	15007	21	automobile	automobile	NN
18637	15007	22	stage	stage	NN
18637	15007	23	line	line	NN
18637	15007	24	,	,	,
18637	15007	25	who	who	WP
18637	15007	26	was	be	VBD
18637	15007	27	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	15007	28	in	in	IN
18637	15007	29	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	15007	30	the	the	DT
18637	15007	31	mails	mail	NNS
18637	15007	32	as	as	IN
18637	15007	33	an	an	DT
18637	15007	34	independent	independent	JJ
18637	15007	35	contractor,[62	contractor,[62	NN
18637	15007	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15007	37	and	and	CC
18637	15007	38	an	an	DT
18637	15007	39	excise	excise	NN
18637	15007	40	tax	tax	NN
18637	15007	41	on	on	IN
18637	15007	42	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	15007	43	sold	sell	VBN
18637	15007	44	to	to	IN
18637	15007	45	a	a	DT
18637	15007	46	contractor	contractor	NN
18637	15007	47	with	with	IN
18637	15007	48	the	the	DT
18637	15007	49	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	15007	50	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15007	51	and	and	CC
18637	15007	52	used	use	VBD
18637	15007	53	to	to	TO
18637	15007	54	operate	operate	VB
18637	15007	55	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	15007	56	in	in	IN
18637	15007	57	the	the	DT
18637	15007	58	construction	construction	NN
18637	15007	59	of	of	IN
18637	15007	60	levees	levee	NNS
18637	15007	61	in	in	IN
18637	15007	62	the	the	DT
18637	15007	63	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	15007	64	River	River	NNP
18637	15007	65	.	.	.
18637	15008	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15008	2	63	63	CD
18637	15008	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15008	4	Subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	15008	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15008	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	15008	7	approved	approve	VBN
18637	15008	8	State	state	NN
18637	15008	9	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	15008	10	on	on	IN
18637	15008	11	the	the	DT
18637	15008	12	net	net	JJ
18637	15008	13	income	income	NN
18637	15008	14	of	of	IN
18637	15008	15	a	a	DT
18637	15008	16	government	government	NN
18637	15008	17	contractor,[64	contractor,[64	NN
18637	15008	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15008	19	income[65	income[65	NN
18637	15008	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15008	21	and	and	CC
18637	15008	22	social	social	NNP
18637	15008	23	security[66	security[66	NNP
18637	15008	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15008	25	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	15008	26	on	on	IN
18637	15008	27	the	the	DT
18637	15008	28	operators	operator	NNS
18637	15008	29	of	of	IN
18637	15008	30	bath	bath	NN
18637	15008	31	houses	house	NNS
18637	15008	32	maintained	maintain	VBD
18637	15008	33	in	in	IN
18637	15008	34	a	a	DT
18637	15008	35	National	National	NNP
18637	15008	36	Park	Park	NNP
18637	15008	37	under	under	IN
18637	15008	38	a	a	DT
18637	15008	39	lease	lease	NN
18637	15008	40	from	from	IN
18637	15008	41	the	the	DT
18637	15008	42	United	United	NNP
18637	15008	43	States	States	NNP
18637	15008	44	;	;	:
18637	15008	45	sales	sale	NNS
18637	15008	46	and	and	CC
18637	15008	47	use	use	VBP
18637	15008	48	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	15008	49	on	on	IN
18637	15008	50	sales	sale	NNS
18637	15008	51	of	of	IN
18637	15008	52	beverages	beverage	NNS
18637	15008	53	by	by	IN
18637	15008	54	a	a	DT
18637	15008	55	concessionaire	concessionaire	NN
18637	15008	56	in	in	IN
18637	15008	57	a	a	DT
18637	15008	58	National	National	NNP
18637	15008	59	Park,[67	Park,[67	NNPS
18637	15008	60	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15008	61	and	and	CC
18637	15008	62	on	on	IN
18637	15008	63	purchases	purchase	NNS
18637	15008	64	of	of	IN
18637	15008	65	materials	material	NNS
18637	15008	66	used	use	VBN
18637	15008	67	by	by	IN
18637	15008	68	a	a	DT
18637	15008	69	contractor	contractor	NN
18637	15008	70	in	in	IN
18637	15008	71	the	the	DT
18637	15008	72	performance	performance	NN
18637	15008	73	of	of	IN
18637	15008	74	a	a	DT
18637	15008	75	cost	cost	NN
18637	15008	76	-	-	HYPH
18637	15008	77	plus	plus	NN
18637	15008	78	contract	contract	NN
18637	15008	79	with	with	IN
18637	15008	80	the	the	DT
18637	15008	81	United	United	NNP
18637	15008	82	States,[68	States,[68	NNP
18637	15008	83	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15008	84	and	and	CC
18637	15008	85	a	a	DT
18637	15008	86	severance	severance	NN
18637	15008	87	tax	tax	NN
18637	15008	88	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	15008	89	on	on	IN
18637	15008	90	a	a	DT
18637	15008	91	contractor	contractor	NN
18637	15008	92	who	who	WP
18637	15008	93	severed	sever	VBD
18637	15008	94	and	and	CC
18637	15008	95	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	15008	96	timber	timber	NN
18637	15008	97	from	from	IN
18637	15008	98	lands	land	NNS
18637	15008	99	owned	own	VBN
18637	15008	100	by	by	IN
18637	15008	101	the	the	DT
18637	15008	102	United	United	NNP
18637	15008	103	States	States	NNP
18637	15008	104	.	.	.
18637	15009	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15009	2	69	69	CD
18637	15009	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15009	4	STATUS	STATUS	NNP
18637	15009	5	OF	of	IN
18637	15009	6	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNP
18637	15009	7	TODAY	TODAY	NNP
18637	15009	8	Of	of	IN
18637	15009	9	a	a	DT
18637	15009	10	piece	piece	NN
18637	15009	11	with	with	IN
18637	15009	12	James	James	NNP
18637	15009	13	_	_	NNP
18637	15009	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	15009	15	_	_	NNP
18637	15009	16	Dravo	Dravo	NNP
18637	15009	17	Contracting	Contracting	NNP
18637	15009	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15009	19	was	be	VBD
18637	15009	20	the	the	DT
18637	15009	21	decision	decision	NN
18637	15009	22	in	in	IN
18637	15009	23	Graves	Graves	NNP
18637	15009	24	_	_	NNP
18637	15009	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	15009	26	_	_	NNP
18637	15009	27	O'Keefe,[70	O'Keefe,[70	NNP
18637	15009	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15009	29	handed	hand	VBN
18637	15009	30	down	down	RP
18637	15009	31	two	two	CD
18637	15009	32	years	year	NNS
18637	15009	33	later	later	RB
18637	15009	34	.	.	.
18637	15010	1	Repudiating	repudiate	VBG
18637	15010	2	the	the	DT
18637	15010	3	theory	theory	NN
18637	15010	4	"	"	''
18637	15010	5	that	that	IN
18637	15010	6	a	a	DT
18637	15010	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	15010	8	on	on	IN
18637	15010	9	income	income	NN
18637	15010	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	15010	11	legally	legally	RB
18637	15010	12	or	or	CC
18637	15010	13	economically	economically	RB
18637	15010	14	a	a	DT
18637	15010	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	15010	16	on	on	IN
18637	15010	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15010	18	source	source	NN
18637	15010	19	,	,	,
18637	15010	20	"	"	''
18637	15010	21	the	the	DT
18637	15010	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15010	23	held	hold	VBD
18637	15010	24	that	that	IN
18637	15010	25	a	a	DT
18637	15010	26	State	state	NN
18637	15010	27	could	could	MD
18637	15010	28	levy	levy	VB
18637	15010	29	a	a	DT
18637	15010	30	nondiscriminatory	nondiscriminatory	JJ
18637	15010	31	income	income	NN
18637	15010	32	tax	tax	NN
18637	15010	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	15010	34	the	the	DT
18637	15010	35	salary	salary	NN
18637	15010	36	of	of	IN
18637	15010	37	an	an	DT
18637	15010	38	employee	employee	NN
18637	15010	39	of	of	IN
18637	15010	40	a	a	DT
18637	15010	41	government	government	NN
18637	15010	42	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	15010	43	.	.	.
18637	15011	1	In	in	IN
18637	15011	2	the	the	DT
18637	15011	3	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15011	4	of	of	IN
18637	15011	5	the	the	DT
18637	15011	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15011	7	,	,	,
18637	15011	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15011	9	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	15011	10	intimated	intimate	VBD
18637	15011	11	that	that	IN
18637	15011	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15011	13	could	could	MD
18637	15011	14	not	not	RB
18637	15011	15	validly	validly	RB
18637	15011	16	confer	confer	VB
18637	15011	17	such	such	PDT
18637	15011	18	an	an	DT
18637	15011	19	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	15011	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	15011	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15011	22	employees	employee	NNS
18637	15011	23	.	.	.
18637	15012	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15012	2	wrote	write	VBD
18637	15012	3	:	:	:
18637	15012	4	"	"	``
18637	15012	5	The	the	DT
18637	15012	6	burden	burden	NN
18637	15012	7	,	,	,
18637	15012	8	so	so	RB
18637	15012	9	far	far	RB
18637	15012	10	as	as	IN
18637	15012	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15012	12	can	can	MD
18637	15012	13	be	be	VB
18637	15012	14	said	say	VBN
18637	15012	15	to	to	TO
18637	15012	16	exist	exist	VB
18637	15012	17	or	or	CC
18637	15012	18	to	to	TO
18637	15012	19	affect	affect	VB
18637	15012	20	the	the	DT
18637	15012	21	government	government	NN
18637	15012	22	in	in	IN
18637	15012	23	any	any	DT
18637	15012	24	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	15012	25	or	or	CC
18637	15012	26	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	15012	27	way	way	NN
18637	15012	28	,	,	,
18637	15012	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	15012	30	one	one	CD
18637	15012	31	which	which	WDT
18637	15012	32	the	the	DT
18637	15012	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15012	34	presupposes	presuppose	VBZ
18637	15012	35	;	;	:
18637	15012	36	and	and	CC
18637	15012	37	hence	hence	RB
18637	15012	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15012	39	can	can	MD
18637	15012	40	not	not	RB
18637	15012	41	rightly	rightly	RB
18637	15012	42	be	be	VB
18637	15012	43	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	15012	44	to	to	TO
18637	15012	45	be	be	VB
18637	15012	46	within	within	IN
18637	15012	47	an	an	DT
18637	15012	48	implied	imply	VBN
18637	15012	49	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	15012	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	15012	51	the	the	DT
18637	15012	52	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	15012	53	power	power	NN
18637	15012	54	of	of	IN
18637	15012	55	the	the	DT
18637	15012	56	national	national	JJ
18637	15012	57	and	and	CC
18637	15012	58	state	state	NN
18637	15012	59	governments	government	NNS
18637	15012	60	which	which	WDT
18637	15012	61	the	the	DT
18637	15012	62	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15012	63	has	have	VBZ
18637	15012	64	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	15012	65	granted	grant	VBN
18637	15012	66	to	to	IN
18637	15012	67	one	one	CD
18637	15012	68	and	and	CC
18637	15012	69	has	have	VBZ
18637	15012	70	confirmed	confirm	VBN
18637	15012	71	to	to	IN
18637	15012	72	the	the	DT
18637	15012	73	other	other	JJ
18637	15012	74	.	.	.
18637	15013	1	The	the	DT
18637	15013	2	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	15013	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	15013	4	not	not	RB
18637	15013	5	one	one	CD
18637	15013	6	to	to	TO
18637	15013	7	be	be	VB
18637	15013	8	implied	imply	VBN
18637	15013	9	from	from	IN
18637	15013	10	the	the	DT
18637	15013	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15013	12	,	,	,
18637	15013	13	because	because	IN
18637	15013	14	if	if	IN
18637	15013	15	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	15013	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15013	17	would	would	MD
18637	15013	18	impose	impose	VB
18637	15013	19	to	to	IN
18637	15013	20	an	an	DT
18637	15013	21	inadmissible	inadmissible	JJ
18637	15013	22	extent	extent	NN
18637	15013	23	a	a	DT
18637	15013	24	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	15013	25	on	on	IN
18637	15013	26	the	the	DT
18637	15013	27	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	15013	28	power	power	NN
18637	15013	29	which	which	WDT
18637	15013	30	the	the	DT
18637	15013	31	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15013	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	15013	33	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	15013	34	to	to	IN
18637	15013	35	the	the	DT
18637	15013	36	state	state	NN
18637	15013	37	governments	government	NNS
18637	15013	38	.	.	.
18637	15014	1	"	"	``
18637	15014	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15014	3	71	71	CD
18637	15014	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15014	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15014	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15014	7	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	15014	8	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	15014	9	in	in	IN
18637	15014	10	the	the	DT
18637	15014	11	result	result	NN
18637	15014	12	without	without	IN
18637	15014	13	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15014	14	.	.	.
18637	15015	1	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15015	2	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	15015	3	and	and	CC
18637	15015	4	McReynolds	McReynolds	NNP
18637	15015	5	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	15015	6	and	and	CC
18637	15015	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15015	8	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	15015	9	wrote	write	VBD
18637	15015	10	a	a	DT
18637	15015	11	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	15015	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15015	13	in	in	IN
18637	15015	14	which	which	WDT
18637	15015	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15015	16	reserved	reserve	VBD
18637	15015	17	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	15015	18	as	as	IN
18637	15015	19	to	to	IN
18637	15015	20	"	"	``
18637	15015	21	whether	whether	IN
18637	15015	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15015	23	may	may	MD
18637	15015	24	,	,	,
18637	15015	25	by	by	IN
18637	15015	26	express	express	NNP
18637	15015	27	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15015	28	,	,	,
18637	15015	29	relieve	relieve	VB
18637	15015	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15015	31	functionaries	functionary	NNS
18637	15015	32	from	from	IN
18637	15015	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15015	34	civic	civic	JJ
18637	15015	35	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	15015	36	to	to	TO
18637	15015	37	pay	pay	VB
18637	15015	38	for	for	IN
18637	15015	39	the	the	DT
18637	15015	40	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	15015	41	of	of	IN
18637	15015	42	the	the	DT
18637	15015	43	State	State	NNP
18637	15015	44	governments	government	NNS
18637	15015	45	under	under	IN
18637	15015	46	which	which	WDT
18637	15015	47	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15015	48	live	live	VBP
18637	15015	49	....	....	NFP
18637	15015	50	"[72	"[72	NFP
18637	15015	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15015	52	_	_	NNP
18637	15015	53	AD	ad	NN
18637	15015	54	VALOREM	valorem	NN
18637	15015	55	_	_	NNP
18637	15015	56	TAXES	taxis	NNS
18637	15015	57	UNDER	under	IN
18637	15015	58	THE	the	DT
18637	15015	59	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNP
18637	15015	60	Property	Property	NNP
18637	15015	61	owned	own	VBN
18637	15015	62	by	by	IN
18637	15015	63	a	a	DT
18637	15015	64	federally	federally	RB
18637	15015	65	chartered	chartered	JJ
18637	15015	66	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	15015	67	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	15015	68	in	in	IN
18637	15015	69	private	private	JJ
18637	15015	70	business	business	NN
18637	15015	71	is	be	VBZ
18637	15015	72	subject	subject	JJ
18637	15015	73	to	to	IN
18637	15015	74	State	state	NN
18637	15015	75	and	and	CC
18637	15015	76	local	local	JJ
18637	15015	77	_	_	NNP
18637	15015	78	ad	ad	NN
18637	15015	79	valorem	valorem	NN
18637	15015	80	_	_	NNP
18637	15015	81	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	15015	82	.	.	.
18637	15016	1	This	this	DT
18637	15016	2	was	be	VBD
18637	15016	3	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	15016	4	in	in	IN
18637	15016	5	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	15016	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15016	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15016	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15016	9	Maryland,[73	Maryland,[73	NNP
18637	15016	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15016	11	and	and	CC
18637	15016	12	confirmed	confirm	VBD
18637	15016	13	a	a	DT
18637	15016	14	half	half	JJ
18637	15016	15	century	century	NN
18637	15016	16	later	later	RB
18637	15016	17	with	with	IN
18637	15016	18	respect	respect	NN
18637	15016	19	to	to	IN
18637	15016	20	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	15016	21	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	15016	22	by	by	IN
18637	15016	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15016	24	.	.	.
18637	15017	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15017	2	74	74	CD
18637	15017	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15017	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	15017	5	,	,	,
18637	15017	6	a	a	DT
18637	15017	7	property	property	NN
18637	15017	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	15017	9	may	may	MD
18637	15017	10	be	be	VB
18637	15017	11	levied	levy	VBN
18637	15017	12	against	against	IN
18637	15017	13	the	the	DT
18637	15017	14	lands	land	NNS
18637	15017	15	under	under	IN
18637	15017	16	water	water	NN
18637	15017	17	which	which	WDT
18637	15017	18	are	be	VBP
18637	15017	19	owned	own	VBN
18637	15017	20	by	by	IN
18637	15017	21	a	a	DT
18637	15017	22	person	person	NN
18637	15017	23	holding	hold	VBG
18637	15017	24	a	a	DT
18637	15017	25	license	license	NN
18637	15017	26	under	under	IN
18637	15017	27	the	the	DT
18637	15017	28	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	15017	29	Water	Water	NNP
18637	15017	30	Power	Power	NNP
18637	15017	31	Act	Act	NNP
18637	15017	32	.	.	.
18637	15018	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15018	2	75	75	CD
18637	15018	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15018	4	Land	land	NN
18637	15018	5	conveyed	convey	VBN
18637	15018	6	by	by	IN
18637	15018	7	the	the	DT
18637	15018	8	United	United	NNP
18637	15018	9	States	States	NNP
18637	15018	10	to	to	IN
18637	15018	11	a	a	DT
18637	15018	12	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	15018	13	for	for	IN
18637	15018	14	dry	dry	JJ
18637	15018	15	dock	dock	NN
18637	15018	16	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	15018	17	was	be	VBD
18637	15018	18	subject	subject	JJ
18637	15018	19	to	to	IN
18637	15018	20	a	a	DT
18637	15018	21	general	general	JJ
18637	15018	22	property	property	NN
18637	15018	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	15018	24	,	,	,
18637	15018	25	despite	despite	IN
18637	15018	26	a	a	DT
18637	15018	27	reservation	reservation	NN
18637	15018	28	in	in	IN
18637	15018	29	the	the	DT
18637	15018	30	conveyance	conveyance	NN
18637	15018	31	of	of	IN
18637	15018	32	a	a	DT
18637	15018	33	right	right	NN
18637	15018	34	to	to	TO
18637	15018	35	free	free	VB
18637	15018	36	use	use	NN
18637	15018	37	of	of	IN
18637	15018	38	the	the	DT
18637	15018	39	dry	dry	JJ
18637	15018	40	dock	dock	NN
18637	15018	41	and	and	CC
18637	15018	42	a	a	DT
18637	15018	43	provision	provision	NN
18637	15018	44	for	for	IN
18637	15018	45	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	15018	46	in	in	IN
18637	15018	47	case	case	NN
18637	15018	48	of	of	IN
18637	15018	49	the	the	DT
18637	15018	50	continued	continue	VBN
18637	15018	51	unfitness	unfitness	NN
18637	15018	52	of	of	IN
18637	15018	53	the	the	DT
18637	15018	54	dry	dry	JJ
18637	15018	55	dock	dock	NN
18637	15018	56	for	for	IN
18637	15018	57	use	use	NN
18637	15018	58	,	,	,
18637	15018	59	or	or	CC
18637	15018	60	the	the	DT
18637	15018	61	use	use	NN
18637	15018	62	of	of	IN
18637	15018	63	the	the	DT
18637	15018	64	land	land	NN
18637	15018	65	for	for	IN
18637	15018	66	other	other	JJ
18637	15018	67	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	15018	68	.	.	.
18637	15019	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15019	2	76	76	CD
18637	15019	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15019	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	15019	5	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	15019	6	title	title	NN
18637	15019	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	15019	8	passed	pass	VBN
18637	15019	9	to	to	IN
18637	15019	10	the	the	DT
18637	15019	11	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	15019	12	of	of	IN
18637	15019	13	land	land	NN
18637	15019	14	from	from	IN
18637	15019	15	the	the	DT
18637	15019	16	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15019	17	,	,	,
18637	15019	18	a	a	DT
18637	15019	19	State	state	NN
18637	15019	20	may	may	MD
18637	15019	21	tax	tax	VB
18637	15019	22	the	the	DT
18637	15019	23	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	15019	24	owner	owner	NN
18637	15019	25	on	on	IN
18637	15019	26	the	the	DT
18637	15019	27	full	full	JJ
18637	15019	28	value	value	NN
18637	15019	29	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	15019	30	,	,	,
18637	15019	31	despite	despite	IN
18637	15019	32	the	the	DT
18637	15019	33	retention	retention	NN
18637	15019	34	of	of	IN
18637	15019	35	legal	legal	JJ
18637	15019	36	title	title	NN
18637	15019	37	by	by	IN
18637	15019	38	the	the	DT
18637	15019	39	Government,[77	Government,[77	NNP
18637	15019	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15019	41	but	but	CC
18637	15019	42	the	the	DT
18637	15019	43	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	15019	44	title	title	NN
18637	15019	45	passes	pass	VBZ
18637	15019	46	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	15019	47	.	.	.
18637	15020	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15020	2	78	78	CD
18637	15020	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15020	4	Recently	recently	RB
18637	15020	5	a	a	DT
18637	15020	6	divided	divide	VBN
18637	15020	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15020	8	held	hold	VBD
18637	15020	9	that	that	IN
18637	15020	10	where	where	WRB
18637	15020	11	the	the	DT
18637	15020	12	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15020	13	purchased	purchase	VBD
18637	15020	14	movable	movable	JJ
18637	15020	15	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	15020	16	and	and	CC
18637	15020	17	leased	lease	VBD
18637	15020	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15020	19	to	to	IN
18637	15020	20	a	a	DT
18637	15020	21	private	private	JJ
18637	15020	22	contractor	contractor	NN
18637	15020	23	,	,	,
18637	15020	24	the	the	DT
18637	15020	25	lessee	lessee	NN
18637	15020	26	could	could	MD
18637	15020	27	not	not	RB
18637	15020	28	be	be	VB
18637	15020	29	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	15020	30	on	on	IN
18637	15020	31	the	the	DT
18637	15020	32	full	full	JJ
18637	15020	33	value	value	NN
18637	15020	34	of	of	IN
18637	15020	35	the	the	DT
18637	15020	36	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	15020	37	.	.	.
18637	15021	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15021	2	79	79	CD
18637	15021	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15021	4	In	in	IN
18637	15021	5	the	the	DT
18637	15021	6	pioneer	pioneer	NN
18637	15021	7	case	case	NN
18637	15021	8	of	of	IN
18637	15021	9	Van	Van	NNP
18637	15021	10	Brocklin	Brocklin	NNP
18637	15021	11	_	_	NNP
18637	15021	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	15021	13	_	_	NNP
18637	15021	14	Tennessee,[80	Tennessee,[80	NNP
18637	15021	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15021	16	the	the	DT
18637	15021	17	State	state	NN
18637	15021	18	was	be	VBD
18637	15021	19	denied	deny	VBN
18637	15021	20	the	the	DT
18637	15021	21	right	right	NN
18637	15021	22	to	to	TO
18637	15021	23	sell	sell	VB
18637	15021	24	for	for	IN
18637	15021	25	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	15021	26	lands	land	NNS
18637	15021	27	which	which	WDT
18637	15021	28	the	the	DT
18637	15021	29	United	United	NNP
18637	15021	30	States	States	NNP
18637	15021	31	owned	own	VBD
18637	15021	32	at	at	IN
18637	15021	33	the	the	DT
18637	15021	34	time	time	NN
18637	15021	35	the	the	DT
18637	15021	36	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	15021	37	were	be	VBD
18637	15021	38	levied	levy	VBN
18637	15021	39	,	,	,
18637	15021	40	but	but	CC
18637	15021	41	in	in	IN
18637	15021	42	which	which	WDT
18637	15021	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15021	44	had	have	VBD
18637	15021	45	ceased	cease	VBN
18637	15021	46	to	to	TO
18637	15021	47	have	have	VB
18637	15021	48	any	any	DT
18637	15021	49	interest	interest	NN
18637	15021	50	at	at	IN
18637	15021	51	the	the	DT
18637	15021	52	time	time	NN
18637	15021	53	of	of	IN
18637	15021	54	sale	sale	NN
18637	15021	55	.	.	.
18637	15022	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	15022	2	can	can	MD
18637	15022	3	a	a	DT
18637	15022	4	State	state	NN
18637	15022	5	assess	assess	VB
18637	15022	6	land	land	NN
18637	15022	7	in	in	IN
18637	15022	8	the	the	DT
18637	15022	9	hands	hand	NNS
18637	15022	10	of	of	IN
18637	15022	11	private	private	JJ
18637	15022	12	owners	owner	NNS
18637	15022	13	for	for	IN
18637	15022	14	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	15022	15	from	from	IN
18637	15022	16	a	a	DT
18637	15022	17	road	road	NN
18637	15022	18	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	15022	19	completed	complete	VBN
18637	15022	20	while	while	IN
18637	15022	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15022	22	was	be	VBD
18637	15022	23	owned	own	VBN
18637	15022	24	by	by	IN
18637	15022	25	the	the	DT
18637	15022	26	United	United	NNP
18637	15022	27	States	States	NNP
18637	15022	28	.	.	.
18637	15023	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15023	2	81	81	CD
18637	15023	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15023	4	PUBLIC	PUBLIC	NNP
18637	15023	5	PROPERTY	property	NN
18637	15023	6	AND	and	CC
18637	15023	7	FUNCTIONS	FUNCTIONS	NNP
18637	15023	8	Property	Property	NNP
18637	15023	9	owned	own	VBN
18637	15023	10	by	by	IN
18637	15023	11	the	the	DT
18637	15023	12	United	United	NNP
18637	15023	13	States	States	NNP
18637	15023	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	15023	15	,	,	,
18637	15023	16	of	of	IN
18637	15023	17	course	course	NN
18637	15023	18	,	,	,
18637	15023	19	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	15023	20	immune	immune	JJ
18637	15023	21	to	to	IN
18637	15023	22	State	state	NN
18637	15023	23	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	15023	24	.	.	.
18637	15024	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15024	2	82	82	CD
18637	15024	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15024	4	No	no	DT
18637	15024	5	State	state	NN
18637	15024	6	can	can	MD
18637	15024	7	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	15024	8	,	,	,
18637	15024	9	by	by	IN
18637	15024	10	the	the	DT
18637	15024	11	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	15024	12	of	of	IN
18637	15024	13	an	an	DT
18637	15024	14	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	15024	15	fee	fee	NN
18637	15024	16	,	,	,
18637	15024	17	any	any	DT
18637	15024	18	activity	activity	NN
18637	15024	19	carried	carry	VBN
18637	15024	20	on	on	RP
18637	15024	21	by	by	IN
18637	15024	22	the	the	DT
18637	15024	23	United	United	NNP
18637	15024	24	States	States	NNP
18637	15024	25	directly	directly	RB
18637	15024	26	through	through	IN
18637	15024	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15024	28	own	own	JJ
18637	15024	29	agents	agent	NNS
18637	15024	30	and	and	CC
18637	15024	31	employees	employee	NNS
18637	15024	32	.	.	.
18637	15025	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15025	2	83	83	CD
18637	15025	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15025	4	An	an	DT
18637	15025	5	early	early	JJ
18637	15025	6	case	case	NN
18637	15025	7	whose	whose	WP$
18637	15025	8	authority	authority	NN
18637	15025	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	15025	10	now	now	RB
18637	15025	11	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
18637	15025	12	held	hold	VBN
18637	15025	13	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	15025	14	a	a	DT
18637	15025	15	flat	flat	JJ
18637	15025	16	rate	rate	NN
18637	15025	17	tax	tax	NN
18637	15025	18	on	on	IN
18637	15025	19	telegraphic	telegraphic	JJ
18637	15025	20	messages	message	NNS
18637	15025	21	,	,	,
18637	15025	22	as	as	IN
18637	15025	23	applied	apply	VBN
18637	15025	24	to	to	IN
18637	15025	25	messages	message	NNS
18637	15025	26	sent	send	VBN
18637	15025	27	by	by	IN
18637	15025	28	public	public	JJ
18637	15025	29	officers	officer	NNS
18637	15025	30	on	on	IN
18637	15025	31	official	official	JJ
18637	15025	32	business	business	NN
18637	15025	33	.	.	.
18637	15026	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15026	2	84	84	CD
18637	15026	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15026	4	FISCAL	fiscal	JJ
18637	15026	5	INSTITUTIONS	institution	NNS
18637	15026	6	;	;	:
18637	15026	7	LEGISLATIVE	legislative	JJ
18637	15026	8	EXEMPTIONS	exemptions	NN
18637	15026	9	Fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	15026	10	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	15026	11	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	15026	12	by	by	IN
18637	15026	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15026	14	,	,	,
18637	15026	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15026	16	shares	share	NNS
18637	15026	17	and	and	CC
18637	15026	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15026	19	property	property	NN
18637	15026	20	,	,	,
18637	15026	21	are	be	VBP
18637	15026	22	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	15026	23	only	only	RB
18637	15026	24	with	with	IN
18637	15026	25	the	the	DT
18637	15026	26	consent	consent	NN
18637	15026	27	of	of	IN
18637	15026	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15026	29	and	and	CC
18637	15026	30	only	only	RB
18637	15026	31	in	in	IN
18637	15026	32	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	15026	33	with	with	IN
18637	15026	34	the	the	DT
18637	15026	35	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	15026	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15026	37	has	have	VBZ
18637	15026	38	attached	attach	VBN
18637	15026	39	to	to	IN
18637	15026	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15026	41	consent	consent	NN
18637	15026	42	.	.	.
18637	15027	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15027	2	85	85	CD
18637	15027	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15027	4	Immediately	immediately	RB
18637	15027	5	after	after	IN
18637	15027	6	the	the	DT
18637	15027	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15027	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15027	9	construed	construe	VBD
18637	15027	10	the	the	DT
18637	15027	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	15027	12	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	15027	13	the	the	DT
18637	15027	14	States	States	NNPS
18637	15027	15	to	to	TO
18637	15027	16	tax	tax	VB
18637	15027	17	national	national	JJ
18637	15027	18	bank	bank	NN
18637	15027	19	shares	share	NNS
18637	15027	20	as	as	IN
18637	15027	21	allowing	allow	VBG
18637	15027	22	a	a	DT
18637	15027	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	15027	24	on	on	IN
18637	15027	25	the	the	DT
18637	15027	26	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	15027	27	shares	share	NNS
18637	15027	28	of	of	IN
18637	15027	29	such	such	PDT
18637	15027	30	a	a	DT
18637	15027	31	bank	bank	NN
18637	15027	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	15027	33	by	by	IN
18637	15027	34	the	the	DT
18637	15027	35	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
18637	15027	36	Finance	Finance	NNP
18637	15027	37	Corporation,[86	Corporation,[86	.
18637	15027	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15027	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15027	40	passed	pass	VBD
18637	15027	41	a	a	DT
18637	15027	42	law	law	NN
18637	15027	43	exempting	exempt	VBG
18637	15027	44	such	such	JJ
18637	15027	45	shares	share	NNS
18637	15027	46	from	from	IN
18637	15027	47	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	15027	48	.	.	.
18637	15028	1	The	the	DT
18637	15028	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15028	3	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	15028	4	this	this	DT
18637	15028	5	measure	measure	NN
18637	15028	6	saying	say	VBG
18637	15028	7	,	,	,
18637	15028	8	"	"	``
18637	15028	9	when	when	WRB
18637	15028	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15028	11	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	15028	12	the	the	DT
18637	15028	13	States	States	NNPS
18637	15028	14	to	to	TO
18637	15028	15	impose	impose	VB
18637	15028	16	such	such	JJ
18637	15028	17	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	15028	18	,	,	,
18637	15028	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15028	20	did	do	VBD
18637	15028	21	no	no	RB
18637	15028	22	more	more	RBR
18637	15028	23	than	than	IN
18637	15028	24	gratuitously	gratuitously	RB
18637	15028	25	grant	grant	VB
18637	15028	26	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15028	27	political	political	JJ
18637	15028	28	power	power	NN
18637	15028	29	which	which	WDT
18637	15028	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15028	31	theretofore	theretofore	VBP
18637	15028	32	lacked	lack	VBD
18637	15028	33	.	.	.
18637	15029	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15029	2	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	15029	3	power	power	NN
18637	15029	4	to	to	TO
18637	15029	5	revoke	revoke	VB
18637	15029	6	the	the	DT
18637	15029	7	grant	grant	NN
18637	15029	8	remained	remain	VBD
18637	15029	9	unimpaired	unimpaired	JJ
18637	15029	10	,	,	,
18637	15029	11	the	the	DT
18637	15029	12	grant	grant	NN
18637	15029	13	of	of	IN
18637	15029	14	the	the	DT
18637	15029	15	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	15029	16	being	be	VBG
18637	15029	17	only	only	RB
18637	15029	18	a	a	DT
18637	15029	19	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	15029	20	of	of	IN
18637	15029	21	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	15029	22	policy	policy	NN
18637	15029	23	changeable	changeable	JJ
18637	15029	24	at	at	IN
18637	15029	25	will	will	NN
18637	15029	26	.	.	.
18637	15030	1	"	"	``
18637	15030	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15030	3	87	87	CD
18637	15030	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15030	5	In	in	IN
18637	15030	6	Pittman	Pittman	NNP
18637	15030	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15030	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15030	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15030	10	Home	Home	NNP
18637	15030	11	Owners	Owners	NNP
18637	15030	12	'	'	POS
18637	15030	13	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	15030	14	Corporation[88	Corporation[88	''
18637	15030	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15030	16	the	the	DT
18637	15030	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15030	18	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15030	19	the	the	DT
18637	15030	20	power	power	NN
18637	15030	21	of	of	IN
18637	15030	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15030	23	under	under	IN
18637	15030	24	the	the	DT
18637	15030	25	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	15030	26	and	and	CC
18637	15030	27	proper	proper	JJ
18637	15030	28	clause	clause	NN
18637	15030	29	to	to	TO
18637	15030	30	immunize	immunize	VB
18637	15030	31	the	the	DT
18637	15030	32	activities	activity	NNS
18637	15030	33	of	of	IN
18637	15030	34	the	the	DT
18637	15030	35	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	15030	36	from	from	IN
18637	15030	37	state	state	NN
18637	15030	38	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	15030	39	;	;	,
18637	15030	40	and	and	CC
18637	15030	41	in	in	IN
18637	15030	42	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	15030	43	Land	Land	NNP
18637	15030	44	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	15030	45	_	_	NNP
18637	15030	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	15030	47	_	_	NNP
18637	15030	48	Bismarck	Bismarck	NNP
18637	15030	49	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	15030	50	Co	Co	NNP
18637	15030	51	.	.	NNP
18637	15030	52	,[89	,[89	NNP
18637	15030	53	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15030	54	the	the	DT
18637	15030	55	like	like	JJ
18637	15030	56	result	result	NN
18637	15030	57	was	be	VBD
18637	15030	58	reached	reach	VBN
18637	15030	59	with	with	IN
18637	15030	60	respect	respect	NN
18637	15030	61	to	to	IN
18637	15030	62	an	an	DT
18637	15030	63	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	15030	64	by	by	IN
18637	15030	65	the	the	DT
18637	15030	66	State	State	NNP
18637	15030	67	to	to	TO
18637	15030	68	impose	impose	VB
18637	15030	69	a	a	DT
18637	15030	70	retail	retail	JJ
18637	15030	71	sales	sale	NNS
18637	15030	72	tax	tax	NN
18637	15030	73	on	on	IN
18637	15030	74	a	a	DT
18637	15030	75	sale	sale	NN
18637	15030	76	of	of	IN
18637	15030	77	lumber	lumber	NN
18637	15030	78	and	and	CC
18637	15030	79	other	other	JJ
18637	15030	80	building	building	NN
18637	15030	81	materials	material	NNS
18637	15030	82	to	to	IN
18637	15030	83	the	the	DT
18637	15030	84	bank	bank	NN
18637	15030	85	for	for	IN
18637	15030	86	use	use	NN
18637	15030	87	in	in	IN
18637	15030	88	repairing	repair	VBG
18637	15030	89	and	and	CC
18637	15030	90	improving	improve	VBG
18637	15030	91	property	property	NN
18637	15030	92	that	that	WDT
18637	15030	93	had	have	VBD
18637	15030	94	been	be	VBN
18637	15030	95	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	15030	96	by	by	IN
18637	15030	97	foreclosure	foreclosure	NN
18637	15030	98	of	of	IN
18637	15030	99	mortgages	mortgage	NNS
18637	15030	100	.	.	.
18637	15031	1	The	the	DT
18637	15031	2	State	State	NNP
18637	15031	3	's	's	POS
18637	15031	4	principal	principal	JJ
18637	15031	5	argument	argument	NN
18637	15031	6	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	15031	7	thus	thus	RB
18637	15031	8	:	:	:
18637	15031	9	"	"	``
18637	15031	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15031	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	15031	12	authority	authority	NN
18637	15031	13	to	to	TO
18637	15031	14	extend	extend	VB
18637	15031	15	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	15031	16	only	only	RB
18637	15031	17	to	to	IN
18637	15031	18	the	the	DT
18637	15031	19	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	15031	20	functions	function	NNS
18637	15031	21	of	of	IN
18637	15031	22	the	the	DT
18637	15031	23	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15031	24	land	land	NN
18637	15031	25	banks	bank	NNS
18637	15031	26	;	;	:
18637	15031	27	the	the	DT
18637	15031	28	only	only	JJ
18637	15031	29	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	15031	30	functions	function	NNS
18637	15031	31	of	of	IN
18637	15031	32	the	the	DT
18637	15031	33	land	land	NN
18637	15031	34	banks	bank	NNS
18637	15031	35	are	be	VBP
18637	15031	36	those	those	DT
18637	15031	37	performed	perform	VBN
18637	15031	38	by	by	IN
18637	15031	39	acting	act	VBG
18637	15031	40	as	as	IN
18637	15031	41	depositaries	depositary	NNS
18637	15031	42	and	and	CC
18637	15031	43	fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	15031	44	agents	agent	NNS
18637	15031	45	for	for	IN
18637	15031	46	the	the	DT
18637	15031	47	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15031	48	government	government	NN
18637	15031	49	and	and	CC
18637	15031	50	providing	provide	VBG
18637	15031	51	a	a	DT
18637	15031	52	market	market	NN
18637	15031	53	for	for	IN
18637	15031	54	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	15031	55	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	15031	56	;	;	:
18637	15031	57	all	all	DT
18637	15031	58	other	other	JJ
18637	15031	59	functions	function	NNS
18637	15031	60	of	of	IN
18637	15031	61	the	the	DT
18637	15031	62	land	land	NN
18637	15031	63	banks	bank	NNS
18637	15031	64	are	be	VBP
18637	15031	65	private	private	JJ
18637	15031	66	;	;	:
18637	15031	67	petitioner	petitioner	NNP
18637	15031	68	here	here	RB
18637	15031	69	was	be	VBD
18637	15031	70	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	15031	71	in	in	IN
18637	15031	72	an	an	DT
18637	15031	73	activity	activity	NN
18637	15031	74	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	15031	75	to	to	IN
18637	15031	76	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15031	77	business	business	NN
18637	15031	78	of	of	IN
18637	15031	79	lending	lend	VBG
18637	15031	80	money	money	NN
18637	15031	81	,	,	,
18637	15031	82	an	an	DT
18637	15031	83	essentially	essentially	RB
18637	15031	84	private	private	JJ
18637	15031	85	function	function	NN
18637	15031	86	;	;	:
18637	15031	87	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	15031	88	§	§	NNP
18637	15031	89	26	26	CD
18637	15031	90	can	can	MD
18637	15031	91	not	not	RB
18637	15031	92	operate	operate	VB
18637	15031	93	to	to	TO
18637	15031	94	strike	strike	VB
18637	15031	95	down	down	RP
18637	15031	96	a	a	DT
18637	15031	97	sales	sale	NNS
18637	15031	98	tax	tax	NN
18637	15031	99	upon	upon	IN
18637	15031	100	purchases	purchase	NNS
18637	15031	101	made	make	VBN
18637	15031	102	in	in	IN
18637	15031	103	furtherance	furtherance	NN
18637	15031	104	of	of	IN
18637	15031	105	petitioner	petitioner	NNP
18637	15031	106	's	's	POS
18637	15031	107	lending	lending	NN
18637	15031	108	functions	function	NNS
18637	15031	109	.	.	.
18637	15032	1	"	"	``
18637	15032	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15032	3	90	90	CD
18637	15032	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15032	5	The	the	DT
18637	15032	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15032	7	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	15032	8	this	this	DT
18637	15032	9	argument	argument	NN
18637	15032	10	and	and	CC
18637	15032	11	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
18637	15032	12	the	the	DT
18637	15032	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	15032	14	saying	saying	NN
18637	15032	15	:	:	:
18637	15032	16	"	"	``
18637	15032	17	The	the	DT
18637	15032	18	argument	argument	NN
18637	15032	19	that	that	IN
18637	15032	20	the	the	DT
18637	15032	21	lending	lending	NN
18637	15032	22	functions	function	NNS
18637	15032	23	of	of	IN
18637	15032	24	the	the	DT
18637	15032	25	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15032	26	land	land	NN
18637	15032	27	banks	bank	NNS
18637	15032	28	are	be	VBP
18637	15032	29	proprietary	proprietary	JJ
18637	15032	30	rather	rather	RB
18637	15032	31	than	than	IN
18637	15032	32	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	15032	33	misconceives	misconceive	NNS
18637	15032	34	the	the	DT
18637	15032	35	nature	nature	NN
18637	15032	36	of	of	IN
18637	15032	37	the	the	DT
18637	15032	38	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15032	39	government	government	NN
18637	15032	40	with	with	IN
18637	15032	41	respect	respect	NN
18637	15032	42	to	to	IN
18637	15032	43	every	every	DT
18637	15032	44	function	function	NN
18637	15032	45	which	which	WDT
18637	15032	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15032	47	performs	perform	VBZ
18637	15032	48	.	.	.
18637	15033	1	The	the	DT
18637	15033	2	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15033	3	government	government	NN
18637	15033	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	15033	5	one	one	CD
18637	15033	6	of	of	IN
18637	15033	7	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	15033	8	powers	power	NNS
18637	15033	9	,	,	,
18637	15033	10	and	and	CC
18637	15033	11	from	from	IN
18637	15033	12	that	that	DT
18637	15033	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15033	14	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	15033	15	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	15033	16	that	that	IN
18637	15033	17	any	any	DT
18637	15033	18	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15033	19	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15033	20	of	of	IN
18637	15033	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15033	22	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	15033	23	powers	power	NNS
18637	15033	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	15033	25	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	15033	26	.	.	.
18637	15034	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15034	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15034	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15034	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15034	5	also	also	RB
18637	15034	6	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	15034	7	that	that	IN
18637	15034	8	,	,	,
18637	15034	9	when	when	WRB
18637	15034	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15034	11	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	15034	12	creates	create	VBZ
18637	15034	13	a	a	DT
18637	15034	14	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	15034	15	through	through	IN
18637	15034	16	which	which	WDT
18637	15034	17	the	the	DT
18637	15034	18	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15034	19	government	government	NN
18637	15034	20	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	15034	21	acts	act	VBZ
18637	15034	22	,	,	,
18637	15034	23	the	the	DT
18637	15034	24	activities	activity	NNS
18637	15034	25	of	of	IN
18637	15034	26	such	such	JJ
18637	15034	27	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	15034	28	are	be	VBP
18637	15034	29	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	15034	30	.	.	.
18637	15035	1	"	"	``
18637	15035	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15035	3	91	91	CD
18637	15035	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15035	5	However	however	RB
18637	15035	6	,	,	,
18637	15035	7	in	in	IN
18637	15035	8	the	the	DT
18637	15035	9	absence	absence	NN
18637	15035	10	of	of	IN
18637	15035	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15035	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15035	13	,	,	,
18637	15035	14	a	a	DT
18637	15035	15	state	state	NN
18637	15035	16	law	law	NN
18637	15035	17	laying	lay	VBG
18637	15035	18	a	a	DT
18637	15035	19	percentage	percentage	NN
18637	15035	20	tax	tax	NN
18637	15035	21	on	on	IN
18637	15035	22	the	the	DT
18637	15035	23	users	user	NNS
18637	15035	24	of	of	IN
18637	15035	25	safety	safety	NN
18637	15035	26	deposit	deposit	NN
18637	15035	27	services	service	NNS
18637	15035	28	,	,	,
18637	15035	29	measured	measure	VBN
18637	15035	30	by	by	IN
18637	15035	31	the	the	DT
18637	15035	32	banks	bank	NNS
18637	15035	33	'	'	POS
18637	15035	34	charges	charge	NNS
18637	15035	35	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	15035	36	,	,	,
18637	15035	37	was	be	VBD
18637	15035	38	held	hold	VBN
18637	15035	39	valid	valid	JJ
18637	15035	40	as	as	IN
18637	15035	41	applied	apply	VBN
18637	15035	42	to	to	IN
18637	15035	43	national	national	JJ
18637	15035	44	banks	bank	NNS
18637	15035	45	.	.	.
18637	15036	1	The	the	DT
18637	15036	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	15036	3	,	,	,
18637	15036	4	being	be	VBG
18637	15036	5	on	on	IN
18637	15036	6	the	the	DT
18637	15036	7	user	user	NN
18637	15036	8	,	,	,
18637	15036	9	did	do	VBD
18637	15036	10	not	not	RB
18637	15036	11	,	,	,
18637	15036	12	the	the	DT
18637	15036	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15036	14	held	hold	VBD
18637	15036	15	,	,	,
18637	15036	16	impose	impose	VB
18637	15036	17	an	an	DT
18637	15036	18	intrinsically	intrinsically	RB
18637	15036	19	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	15036	20	burden	burden	NN
18637	15036	21	on	on	IN
18637	15036	22	a	a	DT
18637	15036	23	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15036	24	instrumentality	instrumentality	NN
18637	15036	25	.	.	.
18637	15037	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15037	2	92	92	CD
18637	15037	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15037	4	THE	the	DT
18637	15037	5	ATOMIC	ATOMIC	NNP
18637	15037	6	ENERGY	ENERGY	NNP
18637	15037	7	COMMISSION	COMMISSION	NNP
18637	15037	8	;	;	:
18637	15037	9	"	"	``
18637	15037	10	ACTIVITIES	activity	NNS
18637	15037	11	"	"	''
18637	15037	12	OF	of	IN
18637	15037	13	In	in	IN
18637	15037	14	the	the	DT
18637	15037	15	recent	recent	JJ
18637	15037	16	case	case	NN
18637	15037	17	of	of	IN
18637	15037	18	Carson	Carson	NNP
18637	15037	19	_	_	NNP
18637	15037	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	15037	21	_	_	NNP
18637	15037	22	Roane	Roane	NNP
18637	15037	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	15037	24	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	15037	25	Co	Co	NNP
18637	15037	26	.	.	NNP
18637	15037	27	,[93	,[93	NNP
18637	15037	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15037	29	the	the	DT
18637	15037	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15037	31	was	be	VBD
18637	15037	32	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	15037	33	with	with	IN
18637	15037	34	an	an	DT
18637	15037	35	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	15037	36	on	on	IN
18637	15037	37	the	the	DT
18637	15037	38	part	part	NN
18637	15037	39	of	of	IN
18637	15037	40	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	15037	41	to	to	TO
18637	15037	42	apply	apply	VB
18637	15037	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15037	44	tax	tax	NN
18637	15037	45	on	on	IN
18637	15037	46	the	the	DT
18637	15037	47	use	use	NN
18637	15037	48	within	within	IN
18637	15037	49	the	the	DT
18637	15037	50	State	State	NNP
18637	15037	51	of	of	IN
18637	15037	52	goods	good	NNS
18637	15037	53	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	15037	54	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	15037	55	to	to	IN
18637	15037	56	a	a	DT
18637	15037	57	private	private	JJ
18637	15037	58	contractor	contractor	NN
18637	15037	59	for	for	IN
18637	15037	60	the	the	DT
18637	15037	61	Atomic	Atomic	NNP
18637	15037	62	Energy	Energy	NNP
18637	15037	63	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	15037	64	and	and	CC
18637	15037	65	to	to	IN
18637	15037	66	vendors	vendor	NNS
18637	15037	67	of	of	IN
18637	15037	68	such	such	JJ
18637	15037	69	contractors	contractor	NNS
18637	15037	70	.	.	.
18637	15038	1	This	this	DT
18637	15038	2	,	,	,
18637	15038	3	the	the	DT
18637	15038	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15038	5	held	hold	VBD
18637	15038	6	,	,	,
18637	15038	7	could	could	MD
18637	15038	8	not	not	RB
18637	15038	9	be	be	VB
18637	15038	10	done	do	VBN
18637	15038	11	under	under	IN
18637	15038	12	Section	section	NN
18637	15038	13	9	9	CD
18637	15038	14	b	b	NN
18637	15038	15	of	of	IN
18637	15038	16	the	the	DT
18637	15038	17	Atomic	Atomic	NNP
18637	15038	18	Energy	Energy	NNP
18637	15038	19	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	15038	20	Act	Act	NNP
18637	15038	21	,	,	,
18637	15038	22	which	which	WDT
18637	15038	23	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	15038	24	in	in	IN
18637	15038	25	part	part	NN
18637	15038	26	that	that	WDT
18637	15038	27	:	:	:
18637	15038	28	"	"	``
18637	15038	29	The	the	DT
18637	15038	30	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	15038	31	,	,	,
18637	15038	32	and	and	CC
18637	15038	33	the	the	DT
18637	15038	34	property	property	NN
18637	15038	35	,	,	,
18637	15038	36	activities	activity	NNS
18637	15038	37	,	,	,
18637	15038	38	and	and	CC
18637	15038	39	income	income	NN
18637	15038	40	of	of	IN
18637	15038	41	the	the	DT
18637	15038	42	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	15038	43	,	,	,
18637	15038	44	are	be	VBP
18637	15038	45	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	15038	46	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	15038	47	exempted	exempt	VBN
18637	15038	48	from	from	IN
18637	15038	49	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	15038	50	in	in	IN
18637	15038	51	any	any	DT
18637	15038	52	manner	manner	NN
18637	15038	53	or	or	CC
18637	15038	54	form	form	NN
18637	15038	55	by	by	IN
18637	15038	56	any	any	DT
18637	15038	57	State	State	NNP
18637	15038	58	,	,	,
18637	15038	59	county	county	NN
18637	15038	60	,	,	,
18637	15038	61	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	15038	62	,	,	,
18637	15038	63	or	or	CC
18637	15038	64	any	any	DT
18637	15038	65	subdivision	subdivision	NN
18637	15038	66	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	15038	67	.	.	.
18637	15039	1	"	"	``
18637	15039	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15039	3	94	94	CD
18637	15039	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15039	5	The	the	DT
18637	15039	6	power	power	NN
18637	15039	7	of	of	IN
18637	15039	8	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	15039	9	,	,	,
18637	15039	10	said	say	VBD
18637	15039	11	the	the	DT
18637	15039	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15039	13	,	,	,
18637	15039	14	"	"	''
18637	15039	15	stems	stem	VBZ
18637	15039	16	from	from	IN
18637	15039	17	the	the	DT
18637	15039	18	power	power	NN
18637	15039	19	to	to	TO
18637	15039	20	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	15039	21	and	and	CC
18637	15039	22	protect	protect	VB
18637	15039	23	functions	function	NNS
18637	15039	24	validly	validly	RB
18637	15039	25	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	15039	26	--	--	:
18637	15039	27	the	the	DT
18637	15039	28	power	power	NN
18637	15039	29	to	to	TO
18637	15039	30	make	make	VB
18637	15039	31	all	all	DT
18637	15039	32	laws	law	NNS
18637	15039	33	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	15039	34	and	and	CC
18637	15039	35	proper	proper	JJ
18637	15039	36	for	for	IN
18637	15039	37	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	15039	38	into	into	IN
18637	15039	39	execution	execution	NN
18637	15039	40	the	the	DT
18637	15039	41	powers	power	NNS
18637	15039	42	vested	vest	VBN
18637	15039	43	in	in	IN
18637	15039	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15039	45	.	.	.
18637	15040	1	"	"	``
18637	15040	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15040	3	95	95	CD
18637	15040	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15040	5	The	the	DT
18637	15040	6	term	term	NN
18637	15040	7	,	,	,
18637	15040	8	"	"	``
18637	15040	9	activities	activity	NNS
18637	15040	10	,	,	,
18637	15040	11	"	"	''
18637	15040	12	as	as	IN
18637	15040	13	used	use	VBN
18637	15040	14	in	in	IN
18637	15040	15	the	the	DT
18637	15040	16	Act	Act	NNP
18637	15040	17	described	describe	VBN
18637	15040	18	,	,	,
18637	15040	19	was	be	VBD
18637	15040	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	15040	21	to	to	TO
18637	15040	22	be	be	VB
18637	15040	23	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	15040	24	less	less	JJR
18637	15040	25	"	"	''
18637	15040	26	than	than	IN
18637	15040	27	all	all	DT
18637	15040	28	of	of	IN
18637	15040	29	the	the	DT
18637	15040	30	functions	function	NNS
18637	15040	31	of	of	IN
18637	15040	32	the	the	DT
18637	15040	33	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	15040	34	.	.	.
18637	15041	1	"	"	``
18637	15041	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15041	3	96	96	CD
18637	15041	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15041	5	ROYALTIES	royalty	NNS
18637	15041	6	;	;	:
18637	15041	7	A	a	DT
18637	15041	8	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	15041	9	ANTICLIMAX	ANTICLIMAX	NNS
18637	15041	10	In	in	IN
18637	15041	11	1928	1928	CD
18637	15041	12	the	the	DT
18637	15041	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15041	14	went	go	VBD
18637	15041	15	so	so	RB
18637	15041	16	far	far	RB
18637	15041	17	as	as	IN
18637	15041	18	to	to	TO
18637	15041	19	hold	hold	VB
18637	15041	20	that	that	IN
18637	15041	21	a	a	DT
18637	15041	22	State	state	NN
18637	15041	23	could	could	MD
18637	15041	24	not	not	RB
18637	15041	25	tax	tax	VB
18637	15041	26	as	as	IN
18637	15041	27	income	income	NN
18637	15041	28	royalties	royalty	NNS
18637	15041	29	for	for	IN
18637	15041	30	the	the	DT
18637	15041	31	use	use	NN
18637	15041	32	of	of	IN
18637	15041	33	a	a	DT
18637	15041	34	patent	patent	NN
18637	15041	35	issued	issue	VBN
18637	15041	36	by	by	IN
18637	15041	37	the	the	DT
18637	15041	38	United	United	NNP
18637	15041	39	States	States	NNP
18637	15041	40	.	.	.
18637	15042	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15042	2	97	97	CD
18637	15042	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15042	4	This	this	DT
18637	15042	5	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	15042	6	was	be	VBD
18637	15042	7	soon	soon	RB
18637	15042	8	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	15042	9	in	in	IN
18637	15042	10	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	15042	11	Film	Film	NNP
18637	15042	12	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	15042	13	_	_	NNP
18637	15042	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	15042	15	_	_	NNP
18637	15042	16	Doyal,[98	Doyal,[98	NNP
18637	15042	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15042	18	where	where	WRB
18637	15042	19	a	a	DT
18637	15042	20	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	15042	21	tax	tax	NN
18637	15042	22	based	base	VBN
18637	15042	23	on	on	IN
18637	15042	24	gross	gross	JJ
18637	15042	25	income	income	NN
18637	15042	26	and	and	CC
18637	15042	27	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	15042	28	to	to	IN
18637	15042	29	royalties	royalty	NNS
18637	15042	30	from	from	IN
18637	15042	31	copyrights	copyright	NNS
18637	15042	32	was	be	VBD
18637	15042	33	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	15042	34	.	.	.
18637	15043	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	15043	2	a	a	DT
18637	15043	3	State	state	NN
18637	15043	4	may	may	MD
18637	15043	5	lay	lay	VB
18637	15043	6	a	a	DT
18637	15043	7	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	15043	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	15043	9	on	on	IN
18637	15043	10	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	15043	11	,	,	,
18637	15043	12	measured	measure	VBN
18637	15043	13	by	by	IN
18637	15043	14	the	the	DT
18637	15043	15	net	net	JJ
18637	15043	16	income	income	NN
18637	15043	17	from	from	IN
18637	15043	18	all	all	DT
18637	15043	19	sources	source	NNS
18637	15043	20	,	,	,
18637	15043	21	and	and	CC
18637	15043	22	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	15043	23	to	to	TO
18637	15043	24	income	income	VB
18637	15043	25	from	from	IN
18637	15043	26	copyright	copyright	NN
18637	15043	27	royalties	royalty	NNS
18637	15043	28	.	.	.
18637	15044	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15044	2	99	99	CD
18637	15044	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15044	4	IMMUNITY	immunity	NN
18637	15044	5	OF	of	IN
18637	15044	6	LESSEES	LESSEES	NNP
18637	15044	7	OF	of	IN
18637	15044	8	INDIAN	INDIAN	NNP
18637	15044	9	LANDS	LANDS	NNP
18637	15044	10	Another	another	DT
18637	15044	11	line	line	NN
18637	15044	12	of	of	IN
18637	15044	13	anomalous	anomalous	JJ
18637	15044	14	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	15044	15	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	15044	16	tax	tax	NN
18637	15044	17	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	15044	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	15044	19	lessees	lessee	NNS
18637	15044	20	of	of	IN
18637	15044	21	restricted	restricted	JJ
18637	15044	22	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	15044	23	lands	land	NNS
18637	15044	24	was	be	VBD
18637	15044	25	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	15044	26	in	in	IN
18637	15044	27	1949	1949	CD
18637	15044	28	.	.	.
18637	15045	1	The	the	DT
18637	15045	2	first	first	JJ
18637	15045	3	of	of	IN
18637	15045	4	these	these	DT
18637	15045	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	15045	6	,	,	,
18637	15045	7	Choctaw	Choctaw	NNP
18637	15045	8	O.	O.	NNP
18637	15046	1	&	&	CC
18637	15046	2	G.R.	G.R.	NNP
18637	15047	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15047	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15047	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15047	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15047	5	Harrison,[100	Harrison,[100	NNP
18637	15047	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15047	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	15047	8	that	that	IN
18637	15047	9	a	a	DT
18637	15047	10	gross	gross	JJ
18637	15047	11	production	production	NN
18637	15047	12	tax	tax	NN
18637	15047	13	on	on	IN
18637	15047	14	oil	oil	NN
18637	15047	15	,	,	,
18637	15047	16	gas	gas	NN
18637	15047	17	and	and	CC
18637	15047	18	other	other	JJ
18637	15047	19	minerals	mineral	NNS
18637	15047	20	was	be	VBD
18637	15047	21	an	an	DT
18637	15047	22	occupational	occupational	JJ
18637	15047	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	15047	24	,	,	,
18637	15047	25	and	and	CC
18637	15047	26	,	,	,
18637	15047	27	as	as	IN
18637	15047	28	applied	apply	VBN
18637	15047	29	to	to	IN
18637	15047	30	a	a	DT
18637	15047	31	lessee	lessee	NN
18637	15047	32	of	of	IN
18637	15047	33	restricted	restricted	JJ
18637	15047	34	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	15047	35	lands	land	NNS
18637	15047	36	,	,	,
18637	15047	37	was	be	VBD
18637	15047	38	an	an	DT
18637	15047	39	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	15047	40	burden	burden	NN
18637	15047	41	on	on	IN
18637	15047	42	such	such	JJ
18637	15047	43	lessee	lessee	NN
18637	15047	44	,	,	,
18637	15047	45	who	who	WP
18637	15047	46	was	be	VBD
18637	15047	47	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	15047	48	to	to	TO
18637	15047	49	be	be	VB
18637	15047	50	an	an	DT
18637	15047	51	instrumentality	instrumentality	NN
18637	15047	52	of	of	IN
18637	15047	53	the	the	DT
18637	15047	54	United	United	NNP
18637	15047	55	States	States	NNP
18637	15047	56	.	.	.
18637	15048	1	Next	next	RB
18637	15048	2	the	the	DT
18637	15048	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15048	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	15048	5	the	the	DT
18637	15048	6	lease	lease	NN
18637	15048	7	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15048	8	a	a	DT
18637	15048	9	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15048	10	instrumentality	instrumentality	NN
18637	15048	11	immune	immune	JJ
18637	15048	12	from	from	IN
18637	15048	13	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	15048	14	.	.	.
18637	15049	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15049	2	101	101	CD
18637	15049	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15049	4	A	a	DT
18637	15049	5	modified	modify	VBN
18637	15049	6	gross	gross	JJ
18637	15049	7	production	production	NN
18637	15049	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	15049	9	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	15049	10	in	in	IN
18637	15049	11	lieu	lieu	NN
18637	15049	12	of	of	IN
18637	15049	13	all	all	DT
18637	15049	14	_	_	NNP
18637	15049	15	ad	ad	NN
18637	15049	16	valorem	valorem	NN
18637	15049	17	_	_	NNP
18637	15049	18	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	15049	19	was	be	VBD
18637	15049	20	invalidated	invalidate	VBN
18637	15049	21	in	in	IN
18637	15049	22	two	two	CD
18637	15049	23	_	_	NNP
18637	15049	24	per	per	IN
18637	15049	25	curiam	curiam	NNP
18637	15049	26	_	_	NNP
18637	15049	27	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	15049	28	.	.	.
18637	15050	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15050	2	102	102	CD
18637	15050	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15050	4	In	in	IN
18637	15050	5	Gillespie	Gillespie	NNP
18637	15050	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15050	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15050	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15050	9	Oklahoma[103	Oklahoma[103	NNP
18637	15050	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15050	11	a	a	DT
18637	15050	12	tax	tax	NN
18637	15050	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	15050	14	the	the	DT
18637	15050	15	net	net	JJ
18637	15050	16	income	income	NN
18637	15050	17	of	of	IN
18637	15050	18	the	the	DT
18637	15050	19	lessee	lessee	NN
18637	15050	20	derived	derive	VBN
18637	15050	21	from	from	IN
18637	15050	22	sales	sale	NNS
18637	15050	23	of	of	IN
18637	15050	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15050	25	share	share	NN
18637	15050	26	of	of	IN
18637	15050	27	oil	oil	NN
18637	15050	28	produced	produce	VBN
18637	15050	29	from	from	IN
18637	15050	30	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	15050	31	lands	land	NNS
18637	15050	32	also	also	RB
18637	15050	33	was	be	VBD
18637	15050	34	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	15050	35	.	.	.
18637	15051	1	Finally	finally	RB
18637	15051	2	a	a	DT
18637	15051	3	petroleum	petroleum	NN
18637	15051	4	excise	excise	NN
18637	15051	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	15051	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	15051	7	every	every	DT
18637	15051	8	barrel	barrel	NN
18637	15051	9	of	of	IN
18637	15051	10	oil	oil	NN
18637	15051	11	produced	produce	VBN
18637	15051	12	in	in	IN
18637	15051	13	the	the	DT
18637	15051	14	State	state	NN
18637	15051	15	was	be	VBD
18637	15051	16	held	hold	VBN
18637	15051	17	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	15051	18	to	to	IN
18637	15051	19	oil	oil	NN
18637	15051	20	produced	produce	VBN
18637	15051	21	on	on	IN
18637	15051	22	restricted	restricted	JJ
18637	15051	23	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	15051	24	lands	land	NNS
18637	15051	25	.	.	.
18637	15052	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15052	2	104	104	CD
18637	15052	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15052	4	In	in	IN
18637	15052	5	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	15052	6	with	with	IN
18637	15052	7	the	the	DT
18637	15052	8	trend	trend	NN
18637	15052	9	to	to	IN
18637	15052	10	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	15052	11	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	15052	12	implied	imply	VBN
18637	15052	13	from	from	IN
18637	15052	14	the	the	DT
18637	15052	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15052	16	to	to	IN
18637	15052	17	activities	activity	NNS
18637	15052	18	of	of	IN
18637	15052	19	the	the	DT
18637	15052	20	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15052	21	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15052	22	,	,	,
18637	15052	23	the	the	DT
18637	15052	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15052	25	overruled	overrule	VBD
18637	15052	26	all	all	PDT
18637	15052	27	these	these	DT
18637	15052	28	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	15052	29	in	in	IN
18637	15052	30	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	15052	31	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	15052	32	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	15052	33	_	_	NNP
18637	15052	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	15052	35	_	_	NNP
18637	15052	36	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	15052	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15052	38	and	and	CC
18637	15052	39	held	hold	VBD
18637	15052	40	that	that	IN
18637	15052	41	a	a	DT
18637	15052	42	lessee	lessee	NN
18637	15052	43	of	of	IN
18637	15052	44	mineral	mineral	NN
18637	15052	45	rights	right	NNS
18637	15052	46	in	in	IN
18637	15052	47	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	15052	48	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	15052	49	lands	land	NNS
18637	15052	50	was	be	VBD
18637	15052	51	subject	subject	JJ
18637	15052	52	to	to	IN
18637	15052	53	nondiscriminatory	nondiscriminatory	JJ
18637	15052	54	gross	gross	JJ
18637	15052	55	production	production	NN
18637	15052	56	and	and	CC
18637	15052	57	excise	excise	VB
18637	15052	58	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	15052	59	,	,	,
18637	15052	60	so	so	RB
18637	15052	61	long	long	RB
18637	15052	62	as	as	IN
18637	15052	63	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15052	64	did	do	VBD
18637	15052	65	not	not	RB
18637	15052	66	affirmatively	affirmatively	RB
18637	15052	67	grant	grant	VB
18637	15052	68	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15052	69	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	15052	70	.	.	.
18637	15053	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15053	2	105	105	CD
18637	15053	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15053	4	SUMMATION	summation	NN
18637	15053	5	AND	and	CC
18637	15053	6	EVALUATION	evaluation	NN
18637	15053	7	Although	although	IN
18637	15053	8	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	15053	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15053	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	15053	11	_	_	NNP
18637	15053	12	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	15053	13	and	and	CC
18637	15053	14	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	15053	15	_	_	NNP
18637	15053	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	15053	17	_	_	NNP
18637	15053	18	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	15053	19	were	be	VBD
18637	15053	20	expressions	expression	NNS
18637	15053	21	of	of	IN
18637	15053	22	a	a	DT
18637	15053	23	single	single	JJ
18637	15053	24	thesis	thesis	NN
18637	15053	25	--	--	:
18637	15053	26	the	the	DT
18637	15053	27	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	15053	28	of	of	IN
18637	15053	29	the	the	DT
18637	15053	30	National	National	NNP
18637	15053	31	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15053	32	--	--	:
18637	15053	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15053	34	development	development	NN
18637	15053	35	after	after	IN
18637	15053	36	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	15053	37	's	's	POS
18637	15053	38	death	death	NN
18637	15053	39	has	have	VBZ
18637	15053	40	been	be	VBN
18637	15053	41	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	15053	42	divergent	divergent	JJ
18637	15053	43	.	.	.
18637	15054	1	During	during	IN
18637	15054	2	the	the	DT
18637	15054	3	period	period	NN
18637	15054	4	when	when	WRB
18637	15054	5	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
18637	15054	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15054	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15054	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15054	9	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	15054	10	was	be	VBD
18637	15054	11	eclipsed	eclipse	VBN
18637	15054	12	by	by	IN
18637	15054	13	the	the	DT
18637	15054	14	theory	theory	NN
18637	15054	15	of	of	IN
18637	15054	16	dual	dual	JJ
18637	15054	17	federalism	federalism	NN
18637	15054	18	,	,	,
18637	15054	19	the	the	DT
18637	15054	20	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15054	21	of	of	IN
18637	15054	22	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	15054	23	_	_	NNP
18637	15054	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	15054	25	_	_	NNP
18637	15054	26	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	15054	27	was	be	VBD
18637	15054	28	not	not	RB
18637	15054	29	merely	merely	RB
18637	15054	30	followed	follow	VBN
18637	15054	31	but	but	CC
18637	15054	32	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	15054	33	extended	extend	VBN
18637	15054	34	as	as	IN
18637	15054	35	a	a	DT
18637	15054	36	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	15054	37	on	on	IN
18637	15054	38	State	state	NN
18637	15054	39	interference	interference	NN
18637	15054	40	with	with	IN
18637	15054	41	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15054	42	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	15054	43	.	.	.
18637	15055	1	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	15055	2	,	,	,
18637	15055	3	the	the	DT
18637	15055	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15055	5	's	's	POS
18637	15055	6	recent	recent	JJ
18637	15055	7	return	return	NN
18637	15055	8	to	to	IN
18637	15055	9	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	15055	10	's	's	POS
18637	15055	11	conception	conception	NN
18637	15055	12	of	of	IN
18637	15055	13	the	the	DT
18637	15055	14	powers	power	NNS
18637	15055	15	of	of	IN
18637	15055	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15055	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	15055	18	coincided	coincide	VBN
18637	15055	19	with	with	IN
18637	15055	20	a	a	DT
18637	15055	21	retreat	retreat	NN
18637	15055	22	from	from	IN
18637	15055	23	the	the	DT
18637	15055	24	more	more	RBR
18637	15055	25	extreme	extreme	JJ
18637	15055	26	positions	position	NNS
18637	15055	27	taken	take	VBN
18637	15055	28	in	in	IN
18637	15055	29	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	15055	30	upon	upon	IN
18637	15055	31	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	15055	32	_	_	NNP
18637	15055	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	15055	34	_	_	NNP
18637	15055	35	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	15055	36	.	.	.
18637	15056	1	Today	today	NN
18637	15056	2	the	the	DT
18637	15056	3	application	application	NN
18637	15056	4	of	of	IN
18637	15056	5	the	the	DT
18637	15056	6	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	15056	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	15056	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	15056	9	becoming	become	VBG
18637	15056	10	,	,	,
18637	15056	11	to	to	IN
18637	15056	12	an	an	DT
18637	15056	13	ever	ever	RB
18637	15056	14	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	15056	15	degree	degree	NN
18637	15056	16	,	,	,
18637	15056	17	a	a	DT
18637	15056	18	matter	matter	NN
18637	15056	19	of	of	IN
18637	15056	20	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	15056	21	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	15056	22	--	--	:
18637	15056	23	a	a	DT
18637	15056	24	determination	determination	NN
18637	15056	25	of	of	IN
18637	15056	26	whether	whether	IN
18637	15056	27	State	State	NNP
18637	15056	28	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	15056	29	can	can	MD
18637	15056	30	be	be	VB
18637	15056	31	reconciled	reconcile	VBN
18637	15056	32	with	with	IN
18637	15056	33	the	the	DT
18637	15056	34	language	language	NN
18637	15056	35	and	and	CC
18637	15056	36	policy	policy	NN
18637	15056	37	of	of	IN
18637	15056	38	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15056	39	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	15056	40	.	.	.
18637	15057	1	In	in	IN
18637	15057	2	the	the	DT
18637	15057	3	field	field	NN
18637	15057	4	of	of	IN
18637	15057	5	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	15057	6	,	,	,
18637	15057	7	the	the	DT
18637	15057	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15057	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	15057	10	all	all	DT
18637	15057	11	but	but	RB
18637	15057	12	wiped	wipe	VBD
18637	15057	13	out	out	RP
18637	15057	14	the	the	DT
18637	15057	15	private	private	JJ
18637	15057	16	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	15057	17	previously	previously	RB
18637	15057	18	implied	imply	VBN
18637	15057	19	from	from	IN
18637	15057	20	the	the	DT
18637	15057	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15057	22	without	without	IN
18637	15057	23	explicit	explicit	JJ
18637	15057	24	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	15057	25	command	command	NN
18637	15057	26	.	.	.
18637	15058	1	Broadly	broadly	RB
18637	15058	2	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15058	3	,	,	,
18637	15058	4	the	the	DT
18637	15058	5	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	15058	6	which	which	WDT
18637	15058	7	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	15058	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	15058	9	limited	limit	VBN
18637	15058	10	to	to	IN
18637	15058	11	activities	activity	NNS
18637	15058	12	of	of	IN
18637	15058	13	the	the	DT
18637	15058	14	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15058	15	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15058	16	,	,	,
18637	15058	17	and	and	CC
18637	15058	18	to	to	IN
18637	15058	19	that	that	DT
18637	15058	20	which	which	WDT
18637	15058	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	15058	22	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	15058	23	created	create	VBN
18637	15058	24	by	by	IN
18637	15058	25	statute	statute	NN
18637	15058	26	,	,	,
18637	15058	27	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	15058	28	,	,	,
18637	15058	29	that	that	DT
18637	15058	30	granted	grant	VBN
18637	15058	31	to	to	IN
18637	15058	32	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15058	33	securities	security	NNS
18637	15058	34	and	and	CC
18637	15058	35	to	to	IN
18637	15058	36	fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	15058	37	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	15058	38	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	15058	39	by	by	IN
18637	15058	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15058	41	.	.	.
18637	15059	1	But	but	CC
18637	15059	2	the	the	DT
18637	15059	3	term	term	NN
18637	15059	4	,	,	,
18637	15059	5	activities	activity	NNS
18637	15059	6	,	,	,
18637	15059	7	will	will	MD
18637	15059	8	be	be	VB
18637	15059	9	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	15059	10	construed	construe	VBN
18637	15059	11	.	.	.
18637	15060	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	15060	2	3	3	CD
18637	15060	3	.	.	.
18637	15061	1	The	the	DT
18637	15061	2	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	15061	3	and	and	CC
18637	15061	4	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	15061	5	before	before	IN
18637	15061	6	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	15061	7	,	,	,
18637	15061	8	and	and	CC
18637	15061	9	the	the	DT
18637	15061	10	Members	member	NNS
18637	15061	11	of	of	IN
18637	15061	12	the	the	DT
18637	15061	13	several	several	JJ
18637	15061	14	State	State	NNP
18637	15061	15	Legislatures	Legislatures	NNPS
18637	15061	16	,	,	,
18637	15061	17	and	and	CC
18637	15061	18	all	all	DT
18637	15061	19	executive	executive	JJ
18637	15061	20	and	and	CC
18637	15061	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15061	22	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	15061	23	,	,	,
18637	15061	24	both	both	DT
18637	15061	25	of	of	IN
18637	15061	26	the	the	DT
18637	15061	27	United	United	NNP
18637	15061	28	States	States	NNP
18637	15061	29	and	and	CC
18637	15061	30	of	of	IN
18637	15061	31	the	the	DT
18637	15061	32	several	several	JJ
18637	15061	33	States	state	NNS
18637	15061	34	,	,	,
18637	15061	35	shall	shall	MD
18637	15061	36	be	be	VB
18637	15061	37	bound	bind	VBN
18637	15061	38	by	by	IN
18637	15061	39	Oath	Oath	NNP
18637	15061	40	or	or	CC
18637	15061	41	Affirmation	Affirmation	NNP
18637	15061	42	,	,	,
18637	15061	43	to	to	TO
18637	15061	44	support	support	VB
18637	15061	45	this	this	DT
18637	15061	46	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15061	47	;	;	:
18637	15061	48	but	but	CC
18637	15061	49	no	no	DT
18637	15061	50	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15061	51	Test	test	NN
18637	15061	52	shall	shall	MD
18637	15061	53	ever	ever	RB
18637	15061	54	be	be	VB
18637	15061	55	required	require	VBN
18637	15061	56	as	as	IN
18637	15061	57	a	a	DT
18637	15061	58	Qualification	qualification	NN
18637	15061	59	to	to	IN
18637	15061	60	any	any	DT
18637	15061	61	Office	Office	NNP
18637	15061	62	or	or	CC
18637	15061	63	public	public	NNP
18637	15061	64	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	15061	65	under	under	IN
18637	15061	66	the	the	DT
18637	15061	67	United	United	NNP
18637	15061	68	States	States	NNP
18637	15061	69	.	.	.
18637	15062	1	Oath	Oath	NNP
18637	15062	2	of	of	IN
18637	15062	3	Office	Office	NNP
18637	15062	4	POWER	POWER	NNP
18637	15062	5	OF	of	IN
18637	15062	6	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	15062	7	IN	in	IN
18637	15062	8	RESPECT	RESPECT	NNP
18637	15062	9	TO	to	IN
18637	15062	10	OATHS	OATHS	NNP
18637	15062	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15062	12	may	may	MD
18637	15062	13	require	require	VB
18637	15062	14	no	no	DT
18637	15062	15	other	other	JJ
18637	15062	16	oath	oath	NN
18637	15062	17	of	of	IN
18637	15062	18	fidelity	fidelity	NN
18637	15062	19	to	to	IN
18637	15062	20	the	the	DT
18637	15062	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15062	22	,	,	,
18637	15062	23	but	but	CC
18637	15062	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15062	25	may	may	MD
18637	15062	26	superadd	superadd	VB
18637	15062	27	to	to	IN
18637	15062	28	this	this	DT
18637	15062	29	oath	oath	NN
18637	15062	30	such	such	JJ
18637	15062	31	other	other	JJ
18637	15062	32	oath	oath	NN
18637	15062	33	of	of	IN
18637	15062	34	office	office	NN
18637	15062	35	as	as	IN
18637	15062	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15062	37	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	15062	38	may	may	MD
18637	15062	39	require	require	VB
18637	15062	40	.	.	.
18637	15063	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15063	2	106	106	CD
18637	15063	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15063	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15063	5	may	may	MD
18637	15063	6	not	not	RB
18637	15063	7	,	,	,
18637	15063	8	however	however	RB
18637	15063	9	,	,	,
18637	15063	10	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	15063	11	a	a	DT
18637	15063	12	test	test	NN
18637	15063	13	oath	oath	NN
18637	15063	14	as	as	IN
18637	15063	15	a	a	DT
18637	15063	16	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	15063	17	for	for	IN
18637	15063	18	holding	hold	VBG
18637	15063	19	office	office	NN
18637	15063	20	,	,	,
18637	15063	21	such	such	PDT
18637	15063	22	an	an	DT
18637	15063	23	act	act	NN
18637	15063	24	being	be	VBG
18637	15063	25	in	in	IN
18637	15063	26	effect	effect	NN
18637	15063	27	an	an	DT
18637	15063	28	_	_	NNP
18637	15063	29	ex	ex	FW
18637	15063	30	post	post	FW
18637	15063	31	facto	facto	FW
18637	15063	32	_	_	NNP
18637	15063	33	law;[107	law;[107	NNP
18637	15063	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15063	35	and	and	CC
18637	15063	36	the	the	DT
18637	15063	37	same	same	JJ
18637	15063	38	rule	rule	NN
18637	15063	39	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	15063	40	in	in	IN
18637	15063	41	the	the	DT
18637	15063	42	case	case	NN
18637	15063	43	of	of	IN
18637	15063	44	the	the	DT
18637	15063	45	States	States	NNP
18637	15063	46	.	.	.
18637	15064	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15064	2	108	108	CD
18637	15064	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15064	4	NATIONAL	NATIONAL	NNP
18637	15064	5	DUTIES	duty	NNS
18637	15064	6	OF	of	IN
18637	15064	7	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	15064	8	OFFICERS	officer	NNS
18637	15064	9	Commenting	comment	VBG
18637	15064	10	in	in	IN
18637	15064	11	The	the	DT
18637	15064	12	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	15064	13	No	no	NN
18637	15064	14	.	.	.
18637	15065	1	27	27	CD
18637	15065	2	on	on	IN
18637	15065	3	the	the	DT
18637	15065	4	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	15065	5	that	that	IN
18637	15065	6	State	State	NNP
18637	15065	7	officers	officer	NNS
18637	15065	8	,	,	,
18637	15065	9	as	as	RB
18637	15065	10	well	well	RB
18637	15065	11	as	as	IN
18637	15065	12	members	member	NNS
18637	15065	13	of	of	IN
18637	15065	14	the	the	DT
18637	15065	15	State	State	NNP
18637	15065	16	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	15065	17	,	,	,
18637	15065	18	shall	shall	MD
18637	15065	19	be	be	VB
18637	15065	20	bound	bind	VBN
18637	15065	21	by	by	IN
18637	15065	22	oath	oath	NN
18637	15065	23	or	or	CC
18637	15065	24	affirmation	affirmation	NN
18637	15065	25	to	to	TO
18637	15065	26	support	support	VB
18637	15065	27	this	this	DT
18637	15065	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15065	29	,	,	,
18637	15065	30	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	15065	31	wrote	write	VBD
18637	15065	32	:	:	:
18637	15065	33	"	"	``
18637	15065	34	Thus	thus	RB
18637	15065	35	the	the	DT
18637	15065	36	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	15065	37	,	,	,
18637	15065	38	courts	court	NNS
18637	15065	39	,	,	,
18637	15065	40	and	and	CC
18637	15065	41	magistrates	magistrate	NNS
18637	15065	42	,	,	,
18637	15065	43	of	of	IN
18637	15065	44	the	the	DT
18637	15065	45	respective	respective	JJ
18637	15065	46	members	member	NNS
18637	15065	47	,	,	,
18637	15065	48	will	will	MD
18637	15065	49	be	be	VB
18637	15065	50	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	15065	51	into	into	IN
18637	15065	52	the	the	DT
18637	15065	53	operations	operation	NNS
18637	15065	54	of	of	IN
18637	15065	55	the	the	DT
18637	15065	56	national	national	JJ
18637	15065	57	government	government	NN
18637	15065	58	_	_	NNP
18637	15065	59	as	as	RB
18637	15065	60	far	far	RB
18637	15065	61	as	as	IN
18637	15065	62	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15065	63	just	just	JJ
18637	15065	64	and	and	CC
18637	15065	65	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15065	66	authority	authority	NN
18637	15065	67	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	15065	68	_	_	NNP
18637	15065	69	;	;	:
18637	15065	70	and	and	CC
18637	15065	71	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15065	72	will	will	MD
18637	15065	73	be	be	VB
18637	15065	74	rendered	render	VBN
18637	15065	75	auxiliary	auxiliary	JJ
18637	15065	76	to	to	IN
18637	15065	77	the	the	DT
18637	15065	78	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	15065	79	of	of	IN
18637	15065	80	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15065	81	laws	law	NNS
18637	15065	82	.	.	.
18637	15065	83	"	"	''
18637	15066	1	The	the	DT
18637	15066	2	younger	young	JJR
18637	15066	3	Pinckney	Pinckney	NNP
18637	15066	4	had	have	VBD
18637	15066	5	expressed	express	VBN
18637	15066	6	the	the	DT
18637	15066	7	same	same	JJ
18637	15066	8	idea	idea	NN
18637	15066	9	on	on	IN
18637	15066	10	the	the	DT
18637	15066	11	floor	floor	NN
18637	15066	12	of	of	IN
18637	15066	13	the	the	DT
18637	15066	14	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	15066	15	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	15066	16	:	:	:
18637	15066	17	"	"	``
18637	15066	18	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15066	19	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15066	20	the	the	DT
18637	15066	21	States	States	NNP
18637	15066	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15066	23	are	be	VBP
18637	15066	24	the	the	DT
18637	15066	25	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	15066	26	upon	upon	IN
18637	15066	27	which	which	WDT
18637	15066	28	the	the	DT
18637	15066	29	Union	Union	NNP
18637	15066	30	must	must	MD
18637	15066	31	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	15066	32	depend	depend	VB
18637	15066	33	for	for	IN
18637	15066	34	the	the	DT
18637	15066	35	support	support	NN
18637	15066	36	and	and	CC
18637	15066	37	execution	execution	NN
18637	15066	38	of	of	IN
18637	15066	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15066	40	powers	power	NNS
18637	15066	41	,	,	,
18637	15066	42	*	*	NFP
18637	15066	43	*	*	NFP
18637	15066	44	*	*	NFP
18637	15066	45	"	"	''
18637	15066	46	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15066	47	109	109	CD
18637	15066	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15066	49	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	15066	50	,	,	,
18637	15066	51	the	the	DT
18637	15066	52	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15066	53	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15066	54	lays	lay	VBZ
18637	15066	55	many	many	JJ
18637	15066	56	duties	duty	NNS
18637	15066	57	,	,	,
18637	15066	58	both	both	CC
18637	15066	59	positive	positive	JJ
18637	15066	60	and	and	CC
18637	15066	61	negative	negative	JJ
18637	15066	62	,	,	,
18637	15066	63	upon	upon	IN
18637	15066	64	the	the	DT
18637	15066	65	different	different	JJ
18637	15066	66	organs	organ	NNS
18637	15066	67	of	of	IN
18637	15066	68	State	State	NNP
18637	15066	69	government,[110	government,[110	NNP
18637	15066	70	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15066	71	and	and	CC
18637	15066	72	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15066	73	may	may	MD
18637	15066	74	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	15066	75	add	add	VB
18637	15066	76	others	other	NNS
18637	15066	77	,	,	,
18637	15066	78	provided	provide	VBN
18637	15066	79	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15066	80	does	do	VBZ
18637	15066	81	not	not	RB
18637	15066	82	require	require	VB
18637	15066	83	the	the	DT
18637	15066	84	State	State	NNP
18637	15066	85	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	15066	86	to	to	TO
18637	15066	87	act	act	VB
18637	15066	88	outside	outside	IN
18637	15066	89	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15066	90	normal	normal	JJ
18637	15066	91	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	15066	92	.	.	.
18637	15067	1	Early	early	JJ
18637	15067	2	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	15067	3	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15067	4	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	15067	5	many	many	JJ
18637	15067	6	illustrations	illustration	NNS
18637	15067	7	of	of	IN
18637	15067	8	such	such	JJ
18637	15067	9	action	action	NN
18637	15067	10	by	by	IN
18637	15067	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15067	12	.	.	.
18637	15068	1	The	the	DT
18637	15068	2	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	15068	3	Act	Act	NNP
18637	15068	4	of	of	IN
18637	15068	5	1789[111	1789[111	CD
18637	15068	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15068	7	left	leave	VBD
18637	15068	8	the	the	DT
18637	15068	9	State	State	NNP
18637	15068	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	15068	11	in	in	IN
18637	15068	12	sole	sole	JJ
18637	15068	13	possession	possession	NN
18637	15068	14	of	of	IN
18637	15068	15	a	a	DT
18637	15068	16	large	large	JJ
18637	15068	17	part	part	NN
18637	15068	18	of	of	IN
18637	15068	19	the	the	DT
18637	15068	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	15068	21	over	over	IN
18637	15068	22	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	15068	23	between	between	IN
18637	15068	24	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	15068	25	of	of	IN
18637	15068	26	different	different	JJ
18637	15068	27	States	state	NNS
18637	15068	28	and	and	CC
18637	15068	29	in	in	IN
18637	15068	30	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	15068	31	possession	possession	NN
18637	15068	32	of	of	IN
18637	15068	33	the	the	DT
18637	15068	34	rest	rest	NN
18637	15068	35	.	.	.
18637	15069	1	By	by	IN
18637	15069	2	other	other	JJ
18637	15069	3	sections	section	NNS
18637	15069	4	of	of	IN
18637	15069	5	the	the	DT
18637	15069	6	same	same	JJ
18637	15069	7	act	act	NN
18637	15069	8	State	State	NNP
18637	15069	9	courts	court	NNS
18637	15069	10	were	be	VBD
18637	15069	11	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	15069	12	to	to	TO
18637	15069	13	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	15069	14	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	15069	15	by	by	IN
18637	15069	16	the	the	DT
18637	15069	17	United	United	NNP
18637	15069	18	States	States	NNP
18637	15069	19	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15069	20	to	to	TO
18637	15069	21	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	15069	22	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	15069	23	and	and	CC
18637	15069	24	forfeitures	forfeiture	NNS
18637	15069	25	under	under	IN
18637	15069	26	the	the	DT
18637	15069	27	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	15069	28	laws	law	NNS
18637	15069	29	,	,	,
18637	15069	30	while	while	IN
18637	15069	31	any	any	DT
18637	15069	32	justice	justice	NN
18637	15069	33	of	of	IN
18637	15069	34	the	the	DT
18637	15069	35	peace	peace	NN
18637	15069	36	or	or	CC
18637	15069	37	other	other	JJ
18637	15069	38	magistrate	magistrate	NN
18637	15069	39	of	of	IN
18637	15069	40	any	any	DT
18637	15069	41	of	of	IN
18637	15069	42	the	the	DT
18637	15069	43	States	States	NNPS
18637	15069	44	was	be	VBD
18637	15069	45	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	15069	46	to	to	TO
18637	15069	47	cause	cause	VB
18637	15069	48	any	any	DT
18637	15069	49	offender	offender	NN
18637	15069	50	against	against	IN
18637	15069	51	the	the	DT
18637	15069	52	United	United	NNP
18637	15069	53	States	States	NNP
18637	15069	54	to	to	TO
18637	15069	55	be	be	VB
18637	15069	56	arrested	arrest	VBN
18637	15069	57	and	and	CC
18637	15069	58	imprisoned	imprison	VBN
18637	15069	59	or	or	CC
18637	15069	60	bailed	bail	VBN
18637	15069	61	under	under	IN
18637	15069	62	the	the	DT
18637	15069	63	usual	usual	JJ
18637	15069	64	mode	mode	NN
18637	15069	65	of	of	IN
18637	15069	66	process	process	NN
18637	15069	67	.	.	.
18637	15070	1	Even	even	RB
18637	15070	2	as	as	RB
18637	15070	3	late	late	JJ
18637	15070	4	as	as	IN
18637	15070	5	1839	1839	CD
18637	15070	6	,	,	,
18637	15070	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15070	8	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	15070	9	all	all	DT
18637	15070	10	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
18637	15070	11	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	15070	12	and	and	CC
18637	15070	13	forfeitures	forfeiture	NNS
18637	15070	14	under	under	IN
18637	15070	15	the	the	DT
18637	15070	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	15070	17	of	of	IN
18637	15070	18	the	the	DT
18637	15070	19	United	United	NNP
18637	15070	20	States	States	NNP
18637	15070	21	to	to	TO
18637	15070	22	be	be	VB
18637	15070	23	sued	sue	VBN
18637	15070	24	for	for	IN
18637	15070	25	before	before	IN
18637	15070	26	any	any	DT
18637	15070	27	court	court	NN
18637	15070	28	of	of	IN
18637	15070	29	competent	competent	JJ
18637	15070	30	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	15070	31	in	in	IN
18637	15070	32	the	the	DT
18637	15070	33	State	State	NNP
18637	15070	34	where	where	WRB
18637	15070	35	the	the	DT
18637	15070	36	cause	cause	NN
18637	15070	37	of	of	IN
18637	15070	38	action	action	NN
18637	15070	39	arose	arise	VBD
18637	15070	40	or	or	CC
18637	15070	41	where	where	WRB
18637	15070	42	the	the	DT
18637	15070	43	offender	offender	NN
18637	15070	44	might	may	MD
18637	15070	45	be	be	VB
18637	15070	46	found	find	VBN
18637	15070	47	.	.	.
18637	15071	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15071	2	112	112	CD
18637	15071	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15071	4	Pursuant	Pursuant	NNP
18637	15071	5	also	also	RB
18637	15071	6	of	of	IN
18637	15071	7	the	the	DT
18637	15071	8	same	same	JJ
18637	15071	9	idea	idea	NN
18637	15071	10	of	of	IN
18637	15071	11	treating	treat	VBG
18637	15071	12	State	State	NNP
18637	15071	13	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	15071	14	organs	organ	NNS
18637	15071	15	as	as	IN
18637	15071	16	available	available	JJ
18637	15071	17	to	to	IN
18637	15071	18	the	the	DT
18637	15071	19	National	National	NNP
18637	15071	20	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15071	21	for	for	IN
18637	15071	22	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	15071	23	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	15071	24	,	,	,
18637	15071	25	the	the	DT
18637	15071	26	act	act	NN
18637	15071	27	of	of	IN
18637	15071	28	1793	1793	CD
18637	15071	29	entrusted	entrust	VBD
18637	15071	30	the	the	DT
18637	15071	31	rendition	rendition	NN
18637	15071	32	of	of	IN
18637	15071	33	fugitive	fugitive	JJ
18637	15071	34	slaves	slave	NNS
18637	15071	35	in	in	IN
18637	15071	36	part	part	NN
18637	15071	37	to	to	IN
18637	15071	38	national	national	JJ
18637	15071	39	officials	official	NNS
18637	15071	40	and	and	CC
18637	15071	41	in	in	IN
18637	15071	42	part	part	NN
18637	15071	43	of	of	IN
18637	15071	44	State	State	NNP
18637	15071	45	officials	official	NNS
18637	15071	46	and	and	CC
18637	15071	47	the	the	DT
18637	15071	48	rendition	rendition	NN
18637	15071	49	of	of	IN
18637	15071	50	fugitives	fugitive	NNS
18637	15071	51	from	from	IN
18637	15071	52	justice	justice	NN
18637	15071	53	from	from	IN
18637	15071	54	one	one	CD
18637	15071	55	State	state	NN
18637	15071	56	to	to	IN
18637	15071	57	another	another	DT
18637	15071	58	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	15071	59	to	to	IN
18637	15071	60	the	the	DT
18637	15071	61	State	State	NNP
18637	15071	62	executives	executive	NNS
18637	15071	63	.	.	.
18637	15072	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15072	2	113	113	CD
18637	15072	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15072	4	Certain	certain	JJ
18637	15072	5	later	later	JJ
18637	15072	6	acts	act	VBZ
18637	15072	7	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	15072	8	State	state	NN
18637	15072	9	courts	court	NNS
18637	15072	10	to	to	TO
18637	15072	11	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	15072	12	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15072	13	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	15072	14	for	for	IN
18637	15072	15	forging	forge	VBG
18637	15072	16	paper	paper	NN
18637	15072	17	of	of	IN
18637	15072	18	the	the	DT
18637	15072	19	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	15072	20	of	of	IN
18637	15072	21	the	the	DT
18637	15072	22	United	United	NNP
18637	15072	23	States	States	NNP
18637	15072	24	and	and	CC
18637	15072	25	for	for	IN
18637	15072	26	counterfeiting	counterfeit	VBG
18637	15072	27	coin	coin	NN
18637	15072	28	of	of	IN
18637	15072	29	the	the	DT
18637	15072	30	United	United	NNP
18637	15072	31	States,[114	States,[114	NNP
18637	15072	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15072	33	while	while	IN
18637	15072	34	still	still	RB
18637	15072	35	others	other	NNS
18637	15072	36	conferred	confer	VBD
18637	15072	37	on	on	IN
18637	15072	38	State	State	NNP
18637	15072	39	judges	judge	NNS
18637	15072	40	authority	authority	NN
18637	15072	41	to	to	TO
18637	15072	42	admit	admit	VB
18637	15072	43	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	15072	44	to	to	IN
18637	15072	45	national	national	JJ
18637	15072	46	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	15072	47	and	and	CC
18637	15072	48	provided	provide	VBN
18637	15072	49	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	15072	50	in	in	IN
18637	15072	51	case	case	NN
18637	15072	52	such	such	JJ
18637	15072	53	judges	judge	NNS
18637	15072	54	should	should	MD
18637	15072	55	utter	utter	VB
18637	15072	56	false	false	JJ
18637	15072	57	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	15072	58	of	of	IN
18637	15072	59	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	15072	60	--	--	:
18637	15072	61	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	15072	62	which	which	WDT
18637	15072	63	are	be	VBP
18637	15072	64	still	still	RB
18637	15072	65	on	on	IN
18637	15072	66	the	the	DT
18637	15072	67	statute	statute	NN
18637	15072	68	books	book	NNS
18637	15072	69	.	.	.
18637	15073	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15073	2	115	115	CD
18637	15073	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15073	4	With	with	IN
18637	15073	5	the	the	DT
18637	15073	6	rise	rise	NN
18637	15073	7	of	of	IN
18637	15073	8	the	the	DT
18637	15073	9	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15073	10	of	of	IN
18637	15073	11	States	States	NNP
18637	15073	12	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	15073	13	and	and	CC
18637	15073	14	of	of	IN
18637	15073	15	the	the	DT
18637	15073	16	equal	equal	JJ
18637	15073	17	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	15073	18	of	of	IN
18637	15073	19	the	the	DT
18637	15073	20	States	States	NNPS
18637	15073	21	with	with	IN
18637	15073	22	the	the	DT
18637	15073	23	National	National	NNP
18637	15073	24	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15073	25	,	,	,
18637	15073	26	the	the	DT
18637	15073	27	availability	availability	NN
18637	15073	28	of	of	IN
18637	15073	29	the	the	DT
18637	15073	30	former	former	JJ
18637	15073	31	as	as	IN
18637	15073	32	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	15073	33	of	of	IN
18637	15073	34	the	the	DT
18637	15073	35	latter	latter	JJ
18637	15073	36	in	in	IN
18637	15073	37	the	the	DT
18637	15073	38	execution	execution	NN
18637	15073	39	of	of	IN
18637	15073	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15073	41	power	power	NN
18637	15073	42	,	,	,
18637	15073	43	came	come	VBD
18637	15073	44	to	to	TO
18637	15073	45	be	be	VB
18637	15073	46	questioned	question	VBN
18637	15073	47	.	.	.
18637	15074	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15074	2	116	116	CD
18637	15074	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15074	4	In	in	IN
18637	15074	5	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
18637	15074	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15074	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15074	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15074	9	Pennsylvania,[117	Pennsylvania,[117	NNP
18637	15074	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15074	11	decided	decide	VBD
18637	15074	12	in	in	IN
18637	15074	13	1842	1842	CD
18637	15074	14	,	,	,
18637	15074	15	the	the	DT
18637	15074	16	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	15074	17	of	of	IN
18637	15074	18	the	the	DT
18637	15074	19	provision	provision	NN
18637	15074	20	of	of	IN
18637	15074	21	the	the	DT
18637	15074	22	act	act	NN
18637	15074	23	of	of	IN
18637	15074	24	1793	1793	CD
18637	15074	25	making	make	VBG
18637	15074	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15074	27	the	the	DT
18637	15074	28	duty	duty	NN
18637	15074	29	of	of	IN
18637	15074	30	State	state	NN
18637	15074	31	magistrates	magistrate	NNS
18637	15074	32	to	to	TO
18637	15074	33	act	act	VB
18637	15074	34	in	in	IN
18637	15074	35	the	the	DT
18637	15074	36	return	return	NN
18637	15074	37	of	of	IN
18637	15074	38	fugitive	fugitive	JJ
18637	15074	39	slaves	slave	NNS
18637	15074	40	was	be	VBD
18637	15074	41	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	15074	42	;	;	:
18637	15074	43	and	and	CC
18637	15074	44	in	in	IN
18637	15074	45	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	15074	46	_	_	NNP
18637	15074	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	15074	48	_	_	NNP
18637	15074	49	Dennison,[118	Dennison,[118	NNP
18637	15074	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15074	51	decided	decide	VBN
18637	15074	52	on	on	IN
18637	15074	53	the	the	DT
18637	15074	54	eve	eve	NN
18637	15074	55	of	of	IN
18637	15074	56	the	the	DT
18637	15074	57	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	15074	58	War	War	NNP
18637	15074	59	,	,	,
18637	15074	60	similar	similar	JJ
18637	15074	61	objection	objection	NN
18637	15074	62	was	be	VBD
18637	15074	63	leveled	level	VBN
18637	15074	64	against	against	IN
18637	15074	65	the	the	DT
18637	15074	66	provision	provision	NN
18637	15074	67	of	of	IN
18637	15074	68	the	the	DT
18637	15074	69	same	same	JJ
18637	15074	70	act	act	NN
18637	15074	71	which	which	WDT
18637	15074	72	made	make	VBD
18637	15074	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15074	74	"	"	``
18637	15074	75	the	the	DT
18637	15074	76	duty	duty	NN
18637	15074	77	"	"	''
18637	15074	78	of	of	IN
18637	15074	79	the	the	DT
18637	15074	80	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15074	81	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	15074	82	of	of	IN
18637	15074	83	a	a	DT
18637	15074	84	State	State	NNP
18637	15074	85	to	to	TO
18637	15074	86	render	render	VB
18637	15074	87	up	up	RP
18637	15074	88	a	a	DT
18637	15074	89	fugitive	fugitive	NN
18637	15074	90	from	from	IN
18637	15074	91	justice	justice	NN
18637	15074	92	upon	upon	IN
18637	15074	93	the	the	DT
18637	15074	94	demand	demand	NN
18637	15074	95	of	of	IN
18637	15074	96	the	the	DT
18637	15074	97	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15074	98	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	15074	99	of	of	IN
18637	15074	100	the	the	DT
18637	15074	101	State	State	NNP
18637	15074	102	from	from	IN
18637	15074	103	which	which	WDT
18637	15074	104	the	the	DT
18637	15074	105	fugitive	fugitive	NN
18637	15074	106	had	have	VBD
18637	15074	107	fled	flee	VBN
18637	15074	108	.	.	.
18637	15075	1	The	the	DT
18637	15075	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15075	3	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15075	4	both	both	DT
18637	15075	5	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	15075	6	,	,	,
18637	15075	7	but	but	CC
18637	15075	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	15075	9	the	the	DT
18637	15075	10	theory	theory	NN
18637	15075	11	that	that	IN
18637	15075	12	the	the	DT
18637	15075	13	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	15075	14	of	of	IN
18637	15075	15	the	the	DT
18637	15075	16	State	State	NNP
18637	15075	17	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	15075	18	was	be	VBD
18637	15075	19	purely	purely	RB
18637	15075	20	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	15075	21	.	.	.
18637	15076	1	In	in	IN
18637	15076	2	the	the	DT
18637	15076	3	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
18637	15076	4	Case	Case	NNP
18637	15076	5	the	the	DT
18637	15076	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15076	7	,	,	,
18637	15076	8	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15076	9	by	by	IN
18637	15076	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15076	11	Story	Story	NNP
18637	15076	12	,	,	,
18637	15076	13	said	say	VBD
18637	15076	14	:	:	:
18637	15076	15	"	"	``
18637	15076	16	*	*	NFP
18637	15076	17	*	*	NFP
18637	15076	18	*	*	NFP
18637	15076	19	state	state	NN
18637	15076	20	magistrates	magistrate	NNS
18637	15076	21	may	may	MD
18637	15076	22	,	,	,
18637	15076	23	if	if	IN
18637	15076	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15076	25	choose	choose	VBP
18637	15076	26	,	,	,
18637	15076	27	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	15076	28	the	the	DT
18637	15076	29	authority	authority	NN
18637	15076	30	,	,	,
18637	15076	31	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15076	32	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	15076	33	by	by	IN
18637	15076	34	the	the	DT
18637	15076	35	act	act	NN
18637	15076	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15076	37	unless	unless	IN
18637	15076	38	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	15076	39	by	by	IN
18637	15076	40	state	state	NN
18637	15076	41	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15076	42	.	.	.
18637	15077	1	"	"	``
18637	15077	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15077	3	119	119	CD
18637	15077	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15077	5	In	in	IN
18637	15077	6	the	the	DT
18637	15077	7	Dennison	Dennison	NNP
18637	15077	8	Case	Case	NNP
18637	15077	9	,	,	,
18637	15077	10	"	"	``
18637	15077	11	the	the	DT
18637	15077	12	duty	duty	NN
18637	15077	13	"	"	''
18637	15077	14	of	of	IN
18637	15077	15	State	State	NNP
18637	15077	16	executives	executive	NNS
18637	15077	17	in	in	IN
18637	15077	18	the	the	DT
18637	15077	19	rendition	rendition	NN
18637	15077	20	of	of	IN
18637	15077	21	fugitives	fugitive	NNS
18637	15077	22	from	from	IN
18637	15077	23	justice	justice	NN
18637	15077	24	was	be	VBD
18637	15077	25	construed	construe	VBN
18637	15077	26	to	to	TO
18637	15077	27	be	be	VB
18637	15077	28	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	15077	29	of	of	IN
18637	15077	30	a	a	DT
18637	15077	31	"	"	``
18637	15077	32	moral	moral	JJ
18637	15077	33	duty	duty	NN
18637	15077	34	.	.	.
18637	15077	35	"	"	''
18637	15078	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	15078	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15078	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15078	4	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	15078	5	for	for	IN
18637	15078	6	the	the	DT
18637	15078	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15078	8	:	:	:
18637	15078	9	"	"	``
18637	15078	10	The	the	DT
18637	15078	11	act	act	NN
18637	15078	12	does	do	VBZ
18637	15078	13	not	not	RB
18637	15078	14	provide	provide	VB
18637	15078	15	any	any	DT
18637	15078	16	means	mean	NNS
18637	15078	17	to	to	TO
18637	15078	18	compel	compel	VB
18637	15078	19	the	the	DT
18637	15078	20	execution	execution	NN
18637	15078	21	of	of	IN
18637	15078	22	this	this	DT
18637	15078	23	duty	duty	NN
18637	15078	24	,	,	,
18637	15078	25	nor	nor	CC
18637	15078	26	inflict	inflict	VB
18637	15078	27	any	any	DT
18637	15078	28	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15078	29	for	for	IN
18637	15078	30	neglect	neglect	NN
18637	15078	31	or	or	CC
18637	15078	32	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	15078	33	on	on	IN
18637	15078	34	the	the	DT
18637	15078	35	part	part	NN
18637	15078	36	of	of	IN
18637	15078	37	the	the	DT
18637	15078	38	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	15078	39	of	of	IN
18637	15078	40	the	the	DT
18637	15078	41	State	State	NNP
18637	15078	42	;	;	:
18637	15078	43	nor	nor	CC
18637	15078	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	15078	45	there	there	EX
18637	15078	46	any	any	DT
18637	15078	47	clause	clause	NN
18637	15078	48	or	or	CC
18637	15078	49	provision	provision	NN
18637	15078	50	in	in	IN
18637	15078	51	the	the	DT
18637	15078	52	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15078	53	which	which	WDT
18637	15078	54	arms	arm	VBZ
18637	15078	55	the	the	DT
18637	15078	56	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15078	57	of	of	IN
18637	15078	58	the	the	DT
18637	15078	59	United	United	NNP
18637	15078	60	States	States	NNP
18637	15078	61	with	with	IN
18637	15078	62	this	this	DT
18637	15078	63	power	power	NN
18637	15078	64	.	.	.
18637	15079	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	15079	2	,	,	,
18637	15079	3	such	such	PDT
18637	15079	4	a	a	DT
18637	15079	5	power	power	NN
18637	15079	6	would	would	MD
18637	15079	7	place	place	VB
18637	15079	8	every	every	DT
18637	15079	9	State	state	NN
18637	15079	10	under	under	IN
18637	15079	11	the	the	DT
18637	15079	12	control	control	NN
18637	15079	13	and	and	CC
18637	15079	14	dominion	dominion	NN
18637	15079	15	of	of	IN
18637	15079	16	the	the	DT
18637	15079	17	General	General	NNP
18637	15079	18	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15079	19	,	,	,
18637	15079	20	even	even	RB
18637	15079	21	in	in	IN
18637	15079	22	the	the	DT
18637	15079	23	administration	administration	NN
18637	15079	24	of	of	IN
18637	15079	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15079	26	internal	internal	JJ
18637	15079	27	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	15079	28	and	and	CC
18637	15079	29	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	15079	30	rights	right	NNS
18637	15079	31	.	.	.
18637	15080	1	And	and	CC
18637	15080	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15080	3	think	think	VBP
18637	15080	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15080	5	clear	clear	RB
18637	15080	6	,	,	,
18637	15080	7	that	that	IN
18637	15080	8	the	the	DT
18637	15080	9	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	15080	10	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15080	11	,	,	,
18637	15080	12	under	under	IN
18637	15080	13	the	the	DT
18637	15080	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15080	15	,	,	,
18637	15080	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	15080	17	no	no	DT
18637	15080	18	power	power	NN
18637	15080	19	to	to	TO
18637	15080	20	impose	impose	VB
18637	15080	21	on	on	IN
18637	15080	22	a	a	DT
18637	15080	23	State	state	NN
18637	15080	24	officer	officer	NN
18637	15080	25	,	,	,
18637	15080	26	as	as	IN
18637	15080	27	such	such	JJ
18637	15080	28	,	,	,
18637	15080	29	any	any	DT
18637	15080	30	duty	duty	NN
18637	15080	31	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	15080	32	,	,	,
18637	15080	33	and	and	CC
18637	15080	34	compel	compel	VB
18637	15080	35	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15080	36	to	to	TO
18637	15080	37	perform	perform	VB
18637	15080	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15080	39	;	;	:
18637	15080	40	for	for	CC
18637	15080	41	if	if	IN
18637	15080	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15080	43	possessed	possess	VBD
18637	15080	44	this	this	DT
18637	15080	45	power	power	NN
18637	15080	46	,	,	,
18637	15080	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15080	48	might	may	MD
18637	15080	49	overload	overload	VB
18637	15080	50	the	the	DT
18637	15080	51	officer	officer	NN
18637	15080	52	with	with	IN
18637	15080	53	duties	duty	NNS
18637	15080	54	which	which	WDT
18637	15080	55	would	would	MD
18637	15080	56	fill	fill	VB
18637	15080	57	up	up	RP
18637	15080	58	all	all	PDT
18637	15080	59	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15080	60	time	time	NN
18637	15080	61	,	,	,
18637	15080	62	and	and	CC
18637	15080	63	disable	disable	VB
18637	15080	64	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15080	65	from	from	IN
18637	15080	66	performing	perform	VBG
18637	15080	67	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15080	68	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	15080	69	to	to	IN
18637	15080	70	the	the	DT
18637	15080	71	State	State	NNP
18637	15080	72	,	,	,
18637	15080	73	and	and	CC
18637	15080	74	might	may	MD
18637	15080	75	impose	impose	VB
18637	15080	76	on	on	IN
18637	15080	77	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15080	78	duties	duty	NNS
18637	15080	79	of	of	IN
18637	15080	80	a	a	DT
18637	15080	81	character	character	NN
18637	15080	82	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
18637	15080	83	with	with	IN
18637	15080	84	the	the	DT
18637	15080	85	rank	rank	NN
18637	15080	86	and	and	CC
18637	15080	87	dignity	dignity	NN
18637	15080	88	to	to	TO
18637	15080	89	which	which	WDT
18637	15080	90	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15080	91	was	be	VBD
18637	15080	92	elevated	elevate	VBN
18637	15080	93	by	by	IN
18637	15080	94	the	the	DT
18637	15080	95	State	State	NNP
18637	15080	96	.	.	.
18637	15081	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15081	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15081	3	true	true	JJ
18637	15081	4	,	,	,
18637	15081	5	"	"	''
18637	15081	6	the	the	DT
18637	15081	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15081	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15081	9	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	15081	10	,	,	,
18637	15081	11	"	"	``
18637	15081	12	that	that	IN
18637	15081	13	in	in	IN
18637	15081	14	the	the	DT
18637	15081	15	early	early	JJ
18637	15081	16	days	day	NNS
18637	15081	17	of	of	IN
18637	15081	18	the	the	DT
18637	15081	19	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15081	20	,	,	,
18637	15081	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15081	22	relied	rely	VBD
18637	15081	23	with	with	IN
18637	15081	24	confidence	confidence	NN
18637	15081	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	15081	26	the	the	DT
18637	15081	27	co	co	NN
18637	15081	28	-	-	NN
18637	15081	29	operation	operation	NN
18637	15081	30	and	and	CC
18637	15081	31	support	support	NN
18637	15081	32	of	of	IN
18637	15081	33	the	the	DT
18637	15081	34	States	States	NNPS
18637	15081	35	,	,	,
18637	15081	36	when	when	WRB
18637	15081	37	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	15081	38	the	the	DT
18637	15081	39	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	15081	40	powers	power	NNS
18637	15081	41	of	of	IN
18637	15081	42	the	the	DT
18637	15081	43	General	General	NNP
18637	15081	44	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15081	45	,	,	,
18637	15081	46	and	and	CC
18637	15081	47	were	be	VBD
18637	15081	48	accustomed	accustom	VBN
18637	15081	49	to	to	TO
18637	15081	50	receive	receive	VB
18637	15081	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15081	52	,	,	,
18637	15081	53	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15081	54	but	but	CC
18637	15081	55	this	this	DT
18637	15081	56	,	,	,
18637	15081	57	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15081	58	explained	explain	VBD
18637	15081	59	,	,	,
18637	15081	60	was	be	VBD
18637	15081	61	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15081	62	upon	upon	IN
18637	15081	63	principles	principle	NNS
18637	15081	64	of	of	IN
18637	15081	65	comity	comity	NN
18637	15081	66	,	,	,
18637	15081	67	and	and	CC
18637	15081	68	from	from	IN
18637	15081	69	a	a	DT
18637	15081	70	sense	sense	NN
18637	15081	71	of	of	IN
18637	15081	72	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	15081	73	and	and	CC
18637	15081	74	common	common	JJ
18637	15081	75	interest	interest	NN
18637	15081	76	,	,	,
18637	15081	77	where	where	WRB
18637	15081	78	no	no	DT
18637	15081	79	such	such	JJ
18637	15081	80	duty	duty	NN
18637	15081	81	was	be	VBD
18637	15081	82	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	15081	83	by	by	IN
18637	15081	84	the	the	DT
18637	15081	85	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15081	86	.	.	.
18637	15082	1	"	"	``
18637	15082	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15082	3	120	120	CD
18637	15082	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15082	5	Eighteen	eighteen	CD
18637	15082	6	years	year	NNS
18637	15082	7	later	later	RB
18637	15082	8	,	,	,
18637	15082	9	in	in	IN
18637	15082	10	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	15082	11	parte	parte	NNP
18637	15082	12	Siebold[121	Siebold[121	NNP
18637	15082	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15082	14	the	the	DT
18637	15082	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15082	16	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15082	17	the	the	DT
18637	15082	18	right	right	NN
18637	15082	19	of	of	IN
18637	15082	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15082	21	,	,	,
18637	15082	22	under	under	IN
18637	15082	23	article	article	NN
18637	15082	24	I	i	NN
18637	15082	25	,	,	,
18637	15082	26	section	section	NN
18637	15082	27	4	4	CD
18637	15082	28	,	,	,
18637	15082	29	paragraph	paragraph	NN
18637	15082	30	1	1	CD
18637	15082	31	of	of	IN
18637	15082	32	the	the	DT
18637	15082	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15082	34	,	,	,
18637	15082	35	to	to	TO
18637	15082	36	impose	impose	VB
18637	15082	37	duties	duty	NNS
18637	15082	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	15082	39	State	State	NNP
18637	15082	40	election	election	NN
18637	15082	41	officials	official	NNS
18637	15082	42	in	in	IN
18637	15082	43	connection	connection	NN
18637	15082	44	with	with	IN
18637	15082	45	a	a	DT
18637	15082	46	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	15082	47	election	election	NN
18637	15082	48	and	and	CC
18637	15082	49	to	to	TO
18637	15082	50	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	15082	51	additional	additional	JJ
18637	15082	52	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	15082	53	for	for	IN
18637	15082	54	the	the	DT
18637	15082	55	violation	violation	NN
18637	15082	56	by	by	IN
18637	15082	57	such	such	JJ
18637	15082	58	officials	official	NNS
18637	15082	59	of	of	IN
18637	15082	60	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15082	61	duties	duty	NNS
18637	15082	62	under	under	IN
18637	15082	63	State	State	NNP
18637	15082	64	law	law	NN
18637	15082	65	.	.	.
18637	15083	1	While	while	IN
18637	15083	2	the	the	DT
18637	15083	3	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15083	4	of	of	IN
18637	15083	5	the	the	DT
18637	15083	6	holding	holding	NN
18637	15083	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	15083	8	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	15083	9	confined	confine	VBN
18637	15083	10	to	to	IN
18637	15083	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	15083	12	in	in	IN
18637	15083	13	which	which	WDT
18637	15083	14	the	the	DT
18637	15083	15	National	National	NNP
18637	15083	16	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15083	17	and	and	CC
18637	15083	18	the	the	DT
18637	15083	19	States	state	NNS
18637	15083	20	enjoy	enjoy	VBP
18637	15083	21	"	"	``
18637	15083	22	a	a	DT
18637	15083	23	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	15083	24	power	power	NN
18637	15083	25	over	over	IN
18637	15083	26	the	the	DT
18637	15083	27	same	same	JJ
18637	15083	28	subject	subject	JJ
18637	15083	29	matter	matter	NN
18637	15083	30	,	,	,
18637	15083	31	"	"	''
18637	15083	32	no	no	DT
18637	15083	33	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	15083	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	15083	35	made	make	VBN
18637	15083	36	to	to	TO
18637	15083	37	catalogue	catalogue	VB
18637	15083	38	such	such	JJ
18637	15083	39	cases	case	NNS
18637	15083	40	.	.	.
18637	15084	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	15084	2	,	,	,
18637	15084	3	the	the	DT
18637	15084	4	outlook	outlook	NN
18637	15084	5	of	of	IN
18637	15084	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15084	7	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	15084	8	's	's	POS
18637	15084	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15084	10	for	for	IN
18637	15084	11	the	the	DT
18637	15084	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15084	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	15084	14	decidedly	decidedly	RB
18637	15084	15	nationalistic	nationalistic	JJ
18637	15084	16	rather	rather	RB
18637	15084	17	than	than	IN
18637	15084	18	dualistic	dualistic	JJ
18637	15084	19	,	,	,
18637	15084	20	as	as	IN
18637	15084	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	15084	22	shown	show	VBN
18637	15084	23	by	by	IN
18637	15084	24	the	the	DT
18637	15084	25	answer	answer	NN
18637	15084	26	made	make	VBN
18637	15084	27	to	to	IN
18637	15084	28	the	the	DT
18637	15084	29	contention	contention	NN
18637	15084	30	of	of	IN
18637	15084	31	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	15084	32	"	"	''
18637	15084	33	that	that	IN
18637	15084	34	the	the	DT
18637	15084	35	nature	nature	NN
18637	15084	36	of	of	IN
18637	15084	37	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	15084	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	15084	39	such	such	JJ
18637	15084	40	as	as	IN
18637	15084	41	to	to	TO
18637	15084	42	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	15084	43	the	the	DT
18637	15084	44	joint	joint	JJ
18637	15084	45	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	15084	46	of	of	IN
18637	15084	47	two	two	CD
18637	15084	48	sovereigns	sovereign	NNS
18637	15084	49	,	,	,
18637	15084	50	even	even	RB
18637	15084	51	in	in	IN
18637	15084	52	a	a	DT
18637	15084	53	matter	matter	NN
18637	15084	54	in	in	IN
18637	15084	55	which	which	WDT
18637	15084	56	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15084	57	are	be	VBP
18637	15084	58	mutually	mutually	RB
18637	15084	59	concerned	concerned	JJ
18637	15084	60	.	.	.
18637	15084	61	"	"	''
18637	15085	1	To	to	IN
18637	15085	2	this	this	DT
18637	15085	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15085	4	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	15085	5	replied	reply	VBD
18637	15085	6	:	:	:
18637	15085	7	"	"	``
18637	15085	8	As	as	IN
18637	15085	9	a	a	DT
18637	15085	10	general	general	JJ
18637	15085	11	rule	rule	NN
18637	15085	12	,	,	,
18637	15085	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15085	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	15085	15	no	no	DT
18637	15085	16	doubt	doubt	RB
18637	15085	17	expedient	expedient	JJ
18637	15085	18	and	and	CC
18637	15085	19	wise	wise	JJ
18637	15085	20	that	that	IN
18637	15085	21	the	the	DT
18637	15085	22	operations	operation	NNS
18637	15085	23	of	of	IN
18637	15085	24	the	the	DT
18637	15085	25	State	State	NNP
18637	15085	26	and	and	CC
18637	15085	27	national	national	JJ
18637	15085	28	governments	government	NNS
18637	15085	29	should	should	MD
18637	15085	30	,	,	,
18637	15085	31	as	as	RB
18637	15085	32	far	far	RB
18637	15085	33	as	as	IN
18637	15085	34	practicable	practicable	JJ
18637	15085	35	,	,	,
18637	15085	36	be	be	VB
18637	15085	37	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	15085	38	separately	separately	RB
18637	15085	39	,	,	,
18637	15085	40	in	in	IN
18637	15085	41	order	order	NN
18637	15085	42	to	to	TO
18637	15085	43	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	15085	44	undue	undue	JJ
18637	15085	45	jealousies	jealousy	NNS
18637	15085	46	and	and	CC
18637	15085	47	jars	jar	NNS
18637	15085	48	and	and	CC
18637	15085	49	conflicts	conflict	NNS
18637	15085	50	of	of	IN
18637	15085	51	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	15085	52	and	and	CC
18637	15085	53	power	power	NN
18637	15085	54	.	.	.
18637	15086	1	But	but	CC
18637	15086	2	there	there	EX
18637	15086	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	15086	4	no	no	DT
18637	15086	5	reason	reason	NN
18637	15086	6	for	for	IN
18637	15086	7	laying	lay	VBG
18637	15086	8	this	this	DT
18637	15086	9	down	down	RP
18637	15086	10	as	as	IN
18637	15086	11	a	a	DT
18637	15086	12	rule	rule	NN
18637	15086	13	of	of	IN
18637	15086	14	universal	universal	JJ
18637	15086	15	application	application	NN
18637	15086	16	.	.	.
18637	15087	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15087	2	should	should	MD
18637	15087	3	never	never	RB
18637	15087	4	be	be	VB
18637	15087	5	made	make	VBN
18637	15087	6	to	to	TO
18637	15087	7	override	override	VB
18637	15087	8	the	the	DT
18637	15087	9	plain	plain	JJ
18637	15087	10	and	and	CC
18637	15087	11	manifest	manif	JJS
18637	15087	12	dictates	dictate	NNS
18637	15087	13	of	of	IN
18637	15087	14	the	the	DT
18637	15087	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15087	16	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15087	17	.	.	.
18637	15088	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15088	2	can	can	MD
18637	15088	3	not	not	RB
18637	15088	4	yield	yield	VB
18637	15088	5	to	to	IN
18637	15088	6	such	such	PDT
18637	15088	7	a	a	DT
18637	15088	8	transcendental	transcendental	JJ
18637	15088	9	view	view	NN
18637	15088	10	of	of	IN
18637	15088	11	state	state	NN
18637	15088	12	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	15088	13	.	.	.
18637	15089	1	The	the	DT
18637	15089	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15089	3	and	and	CC
18637	15089	4	laws	law	NNS
18637	15089	5	of	of	IN
18637	15089	6	the	the	DT
18637	15089	7	United	United	NNP
18637	15089	8	States	States	NNP
18637	15089	9	are	be	VBP
18637	15089	10	the	the	DT
18637	15089	11	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	15089	12	law	law	NNP
18637	15089	13	of	of	IN
18637	15089	14	the	the	DT
18637	15089	15	land	land	NN
18637	15089	16	,	,	,
18637	15089	17	and	and	CC
18637	15089	18	to	to	IN
18637	15089	19	these	these	DT
18637	15089	20	every	every	DT
18637	15089	21	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	15089	22	of	of	IN
18637	15089	23	every	every	DT
18637	15089	24	State	State	NNP
18637	15089	25	owes	owe	VBZ
18637	15089	26	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	15089	27	,	,	,
18637	15089	28	whether	whether	IN
18637	15089	29	in	in	IN
18637	15089	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15089	31	individual	individual	JJ
18637	15089	32	or	or	CC
18637	15089	33	official	official	JJ
18637	15089	34	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	15089	35	.	.	.
18637	15090	1	"	"	``
18637	15090	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15090	3	122	122	CD
18637	15090	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15090	5	Three	three	CD
18637	15090	6	years	year	NNS
18637	15090	7	earlier	early	RBR
18637	15090	8	the	the	DT
18637	15090	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15090	10	,	,	,
18637	15090	11	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15090	12	also	also	RB
18637	15090	13	by	by	IN
18637	15090	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15090	15	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	15090	16	,	,	,
18637	15090	17	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15090	18	a	a	DT
18637	15090	19	provision	provision	NN
18637	15090	20	of	of	IN
18637	15090	21	the	the	DT
18637	15090	22	Bankruptcy	Bankruptcy	NNP
18637	15090	23	Act	Act	NNP
18637	15090	24	of	of	IN
18637	15090	25	1867	1867	CD
18637	15090	26	giving	give	VBG
18637	15090	27	assignees	assignee	VBZ
18637	15090	28	a	a	DT
18637	15090	29	right	right	NN
18637	15090	30	to	to	TO
18637	15090	31	sue	sue	VB
18637	15090	32	in	in	IN
18637	15090	33	State	State	NNP
18637	15090	34	courts	court	NNS
18637	15090	35	to	to	TO
18637	15090	36	recover	recover	VB
18637	15090	37	the	the	DT
18637	15090	38	assets	asset	NNS
18637	15090	39	of	of	IN
18637	15090	40	a	a	DT
18637	15090	41	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
18637	15090	42	.	.	.
18637	15091	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	15091	2	the	the	DT
18637	15091	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15091	4	:	:	:
18637	15091	5	The	the	DT
18637	15091	6	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	15091	7	of	of	IN
18637	15091	8	the	the	DT
18637	15091	9	United	United	NNP
18637	15091	10	States	States	NNP
18637	15091	11	are	be	VBP
18637	15091	12	as	as	RB
18637	15091	13	much	much	JJ
18637	15091	14	the	the	DT
18637	15091	15	law	law	NN
18637	15091	16	of	of	IN
18637	15091	17	the	the	DT
18637	15091	18	land	land	NN
18637	15091	19	in	in	IN
18637	15091	20	any	any	DT
18637	15091	21	State	State	NNP
18637	15091	22	as	as	IN
18637	15091	23	are	be	VBP
18637	15091	24	those	those	DT
18637	15091	25	of	of	IN
18637	15091	26	the	the	DT
18637	15091	27	State	State	NNP
18637	15091	28	;	;	:
18637	15091	29	and	and	CC
18637	15091	30	although	although	IN
18637	15091	31	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	15091	32	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	15091	33	for	for	IN
18637	15091	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15091	35	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	15091	36	may	may	MD
18637	15091	37	be	be	VB
18637	15091	38	given	give	VBN
18637	15091	39	to	to	IN
18637	15091	40	the	the	DT
18637	15091	41	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15091	42	courts	court	NNS
18637	15091	43	,	,	,
18637	15091	44	yet	yet	CC
18637	15091	45	where	where	WRB
18637	15091	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15091	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	15091	48	not	not	RB
18637	15091	49	given	give	VBN
18637	15091	50	,	,	,
18637	15091	51	either	either	CC
18637	15091	52	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	15091	53	or	or	CC
18637	15091	54	by	by	IN
18637	15091	55	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	15091	56	implication	implication	NN
18637	15091	57	,	,	,
18637	15091	58	the	the	DT
18637	15091	59	State	State	NNP
18637	15091	60	courts	court	NNS
18637	15091	61	having	have	VBG
18637	15091	62	competent	competent	JJ
18637	15091	63	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	15091	64	in	in	IN
18637	15091	65	other	other	JJ
18637	15091	66	respects	respect	NNS
18637	15091	67	,	,	,
18637	15091	68	may	may	MD
18637	15091	69	be	be	VB
18637	15091	70	resorted	resort	VBN
18637	15091	71	to	to	IN
18637	15091	72	.	.	.
18637	15092	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15092	2	123	123	CD
18637	15092	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15092	4	The	the	DT
18637	15092	5	Selective	Selective	NNP
18637	15092	6	Service	Service	NNP
18637	15092	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	15092	8	of	of	IN
18637	15092	9	1917[124	1917[124	CD
18637	15092	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15092	11	was	be	VBD
18637	15092	12	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	15092	13	to	to	IN
18637	15092	14	a	a	DT
18637	15092	15	great	great	JJ
18637	15092	16	extent	extent	NN
18637	15092	17	through	through	IN
18637	15092	18	State	state	NN
18637	15092	19	"	"	''
18637	15092	20	employees	employee	NNS
18637	15092	21	who	who	WP
18637	15092	22	functioned	function	VBD
18637	15092	23	under	under	IN
18637	15092	24	State	State	NNP
18637	15092	25	supervision";[125	supervision";[125	NNP
18637	15092	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15092	27	and	and	CC
18637	15092	28	State	State	NNP
18637	15092	29	officials	official	NNS
18637	15092	30	were	be	VBD
18637	15092	31	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	15092	32	employed	employ	VBN
18637	15092	33	by	by	IN
18637	15092	34	the	the	DT
18637	15092	35	National	National	NNP
18637	15092	36	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15092	37	in	in	IN
18637	15092	38	the	the	DT
18637	15092	39	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	15092	40	of	of	IN
18637	15092	41	National	National	NNP
18637	15092	42	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	15092	43	.	.	.
18637	15093	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15093	2	126	126	CD
18637	15093	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15093	4	Nowadays	nowadays	RB
18637	15093	5	,	,	,
18637	15093	6	there	there	EX
18637	15093	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	15093	8	constant	constant	JJ
18637	15093	9	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	15093	10	,	,	,
18637	15093	11	both	both	CC
18637	15093	12	in	in	IN
18637	15093	13	peacetime	peacetime	NN
18637	15093	14	and	and	CC
18637	15093	15	in	in	IN
18637	15093	16	wartime	wartime	NN
18637	15093	17	,	,	,
18637	15093	18	in	in	IN
18637	15093	19	many	many	JJ
18637	15093	20	fields	field	NNS
18637	15093	21	between	between	IN
18637	15093	22	National	National	NNP
18637	15093	23	and	and	CC
18637	15093	24	State	State	NNP
18637	15093	25	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	15093	26	and	and	CC
18637	15093	27	official	official	JJ
18637	15093	28	bodies	body	NNS
18637	15093	29	.	.	.
18637	15094	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15094	2	127	127	CD
18637	15094	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15094	4	This	this	DT
18637	15094	5	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	15094	6	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	15094	7	calls	call	VBZ
18637	15094	8	for	for	IN
18637	15094	9	the	the	DT
18637	15094	10	active	active	JJ
18637	15094	11	fidelity	fidelity	NN
18637	15094	12	of	of	IN
18637	15094	13	both	both	DT
18637	15094	14	categories	category	NNS
18637	15094	15	of	of	IN
18637	15094	16	officialdom	officialdom	NN
18637	15094	17	to	to	IN
18637	15094	18	the	the	DT
18637	15094	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15094	20	.	.	.
18637	15095	1	Notes	note	NNS
18637	15095	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15095	3	1	1	CD
18637	15095	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15095	5	On	on	IN
18637	15095	6	the	the	DT
18637	15095	7	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	15095	8	of	of	IN
18637	15095	9	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	15095	10	over	over	IN
18637	15095	11	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	15095	12	State	State	NNP
18637	15095	13	law	law	NN
18637	15095	14	,	,	,
18637	15095	15	_	_	NNP
18637	15095	16	see	see	VBP
18637	15095	17	_	_	NNP
18637	15095	18	pp	pp	NNP
18637	15095	19	.	.	.
18637	15096	1	414	414	CD
18637	15096	2	-	-	SYM
18637	15096	3	418	418	CD
18637	15096	4	.	.	.
18637	15097	1	The	the	DT
18637	15097	2	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	15097	3	due	due	JJ
18637	15097	4	to	to	IN
18637	15097	5	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	15097	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	15097	7	,	,	,
18637	15097	8	within	within	IN
18637	15097	9	recent	recent	JJ
18637	15097	10	years	year	NNS
18637	15097	11	,	,	,
18637	15097	12	been	be	VBN
18637	15097	13	extended	extend	VBN
18637	15097	14	to	to	IN
18637	15097	15	certain	certain	JJ
18637	15097	16	executive	executive	JJ
18637	15097	17	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	15097	18	.	.	.
18637	15098	1	_	_	NNP
18637	15098	2	See	See	NNP
18637	15098	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15098	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15098	5	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	15098	6	in	in	IN
18637	15098	7	United	United	NNP
18637	15098	8	States	States	NNP
18637	15098	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15098	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	15098	11	_	_	NNP
18637	15098	12	Pink	Pink	NNP
18637	15098	13	,	,	,
18637	15098	14	315	315	CD
18637	15098	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15098	16	203	203	CD
18637	15098	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15098	18	1942	1942	CD
18637	15098	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15098	20	.	.	.
18637	15099	1	As	as	IN
18637	15099	2	to	to	IN
18637	15099	3	the	the	DT
18637	15099	4	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	15099	5	of	of	IN
18637	15099	6	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	15099	7	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15099	8	implementing	implement	VBG
18637	15099	9	the	the	DT
18637	15099	10	national	national	JJ
18637	15099	11	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15099	12	power	power	NN
18637	15099	13	,	,	,
18637	15099	14	_	_	NNP
18637	15099	15	see	see	VBP
18637	15099	16	_	_	NNP
18637	15099	17	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	15099	18	_	_	NNP
18637	15099	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	15099	20	_	_	NNP
18637	15099	21	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	15099	22	,	,	,
18637	15099	23	100	100	CD
18637	15099	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15099	25	257	257	CD
18637	15099	26	,	,	,
18637	15099	27	266	266	CD
18637	15099	28	-	-	SYM
18637	15099	29	267	267	CD
18637	15099	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15099	31	1880	1880	CD
18637	15099	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15099	33	;	;	:
18637	15099	34	and	and	CC
18637	15099	35	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	15099	36	parte	parte	NN
18637	15099	37	Siebold	Siebold	NNP
18637	15099	38	,	,	,
18637	15099	39	100	100	CD
18637	15099	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15099	41	404	404	CD
18637	15099	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15099	43	1880	1880	CD
18637	15099	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15099	45	.	.	.
18637	15100	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15100	2	2	2	CD
18637	15100	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15100	4	4	4	CD
18637	15100	5	.	.	.
18637	15101	1	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	15101	2	.	.	.
18637	15102	1	316	316	CD
18637	15102	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15102	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	15102	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15102	5	.	.	.
18637	15103	1	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	15103	2	had	have	VBD
18637	15103	3	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
18637	15103	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15103	5	argument	argument	NN
18637	15103	6	in	in	IN
18637	15103	7	this	this	DT
18637	15103	8	case	case	NN
18637	15103	9	in	in	IN
18637	15103	10	1805	1805	CD
18637	15103	11	,	,	,
18637	15103	12	in	in	IN
18637	15103	13	United	United	NNP
18637	15103	14	States	States	NNP
18637	15103	15	_	_	NNP
18637	15103	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	15103	17	_	_	NNP
18637	15103	18	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	15103	19	,	,	,
18637	15103	20	2	2	CD
18637	15103	21	Cr	cr	NN
18637	15103	22	.	.	.
18637	15104	1	358	358	CD
18637	15104	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15104	3	1805	1805	CD
18637	15104	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15104	5	,	,	,
18637	15104	6	in	in	IN
18637	15104	7	which	which	WDT
18637	15104	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15104	9	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	15104	10	the	the	DT
18637	15104	11	act	act	NN
18637	15104	12	of	of	IN
18637	15104	13	1797	1797	CD
18637	15104	14	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	15104	15	for	for	IN
18637	15104	16	the	the	DT
18637	15104	17	United	United	NNP
18637	15104	18	States	States	NNP
18637	15104	19	a	a	DT
18637	15104	20	priority	priority	NN
18637	15104	21	of	of	IN
18637	15104	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15104	23	claims	claim	NNS
18637	15104	24	over	over	IN
18637	15104	25	those	those	DT
18637	15104	26	of	of	IN
18637	15104	27	the	the	DT
18637	15104	28	States	States	NNPS
18637	15104	29	.	.	.
18637	15105	1	_	_	NNP
18637	15105	2	See	See	NNP
18637	15105	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15105	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15105	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15105	6	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	15105	7	's	's	POS
18637	15105	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15105	9	in	in	IN
18637	15105	10	Spokane	Spokane	NNP
18637	15105	11	County	County	NNP
18637	15105	12	_	_	NNP
18637	15105	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	15105	14	_	_	NNP
18637	15105	15	United	United	NNP
18637	15105	16	States	States	NNP
18637	15105	17	,	,	,
18637	15105	18	279	279	CD
18637	15105	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15105	20	80	80	CD
18637	15105	21	,	,	,
18637	15105	22	87	87	CD
18637	15105	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15105	24	1929	1929	CD
18637	15105	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15105	26	,	,	,
18637	15105	27	where	where	WRB
18637	15105	28	United	United	NNP
18637	15105	29	States	States	NNP
18637	15105	30	_	_	NNP
18637	15105	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	15105	32	_	_	NNP
18637	15105	33	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	15105	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	15105	35	followed	follow	VBN
18637	15105	36	;	;	:
18637	15105	37	_	_	NNP
18637	15105	38	also	also	RB
18637	15105	39	_	_	NNP
18637	15105	40	1	1	CD
18637	15105	41	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	15105	42	,	,	,
18637	15105	43	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15105	44	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15105	45	in	in	IN
18637	15105	46	United	United	NNP
18637	15105	47	States	States	NNP
18637	15105	48	History	History	NNP
18637	15105	49	,	,	,
18637	15105	50	372	372	CD
18637	15105	51	,	,	,
18637	15105	52	538	538	CD
18637	15105	53	ff	ff	NNS
18637	15105	54	.	.	.
18637	15106	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15106	2	3	3	CD
18637	15106	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15106	4	9	9	CD
18637	15106	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	15106	6	.	.	.
18637	15107	1	1	1	CD
18637	15107	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15107	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	15107	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15107	5	.	.	.
18637	15108	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15108	2	4	4	CD
18637	15108	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15108	4	4	4	CD
18637	15108	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	15108	6	.	.	.
18637	15109	1	316	316	CD
18637	15109	2	,	,	,
18637	15109	3	436	436	CD
18637	15109	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15109	5	1819	1819	CD
18637	15109	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15109	7	.	.	.
18637	15110	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15110	2	5	5	CD
18637	15110	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15110	4	9	9	CD
18637	15110	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	15110	6	.	.	.
18637	15111	1	1	1	CD
18637	15111	2	,	,	,
18637	15111	3	210	210	CD
18637	15111	4	-	-	SYM
18637	15111	5	211	211	CD
18637	15111	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15111	7	1824	1824	CD
18637	15111	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15111	9	.	.	.
18637	15112	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15112	2	6	6	CD
18637	15112	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15112	4	11	11	CD
18637	15112	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	15112	6	.	.	.
18637	15113	1	102	102	CD
18637	15113	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15113	3	1837	1837	CD
18637	15113	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15113	5	.	.	.
18637	15114	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15114	2	7	7	CD
18637	15114	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15114	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15114	5	.	.	.
18637	15115	1	139	139	CD
18637	15115	2	.	.	.
18637	15116	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15116	2	8	8	CD
18637	15116	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15116	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15116	5	.	.	.
18637	15117	1	161	161	CD
18637	15117	2	.	.	.
18637	15118	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15118	2	9	9	CD
18637	15118	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15118	4	5	5	CD
18637	15118	5	How	how	WRB
18637	15118	6	.	.	.
18637	15119	1	504	504	CD
18637	15119	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15119	3	1847	1847	CD
18637	15119	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15119	5	.	.	.
18637	15120	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15120	2	10	10	CD
18637	15120	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15120	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15120	5	.	.	.
18637	15121	1	573	573	CD
18637	15121	2	-	-	SYM
18637	15121	3	574	574	CD
18637	15121	4	.	.	.
18637	15122	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15122	2	11	11	CD
18637	15122	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15122	4	National	National	NNP
18637	15122	5	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	15122	6	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	15122	7	Board	Board	NNP
18637	15122	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15122	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	15122	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15122	11	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	15122	12	&	&	CC
18637	15122	13	Laughlin	Laughlin	NNP
18637	15122	14	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	15122	15	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	15122	16	,	,	,
18637	15122	17	301	301	CD
18637	15122	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15122	19	1	1	CD
18637	15122	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15122	21	1937	1937	CD
18637	15122	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15122	23	.	.	.
18637	15123	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15123	2	12	12	CD
18637	15123	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15123	4	Steward	Steward	NNP
18637	15123	5	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	15123	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15123	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15123	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15123	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15123	10	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	15123	11	,	,	,
18637	15123	12	301	301	CD
18637	15123	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15123	14	548	548	CD
18637	15123	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15123	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	15123	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15123	18	;	;	:
18637	15123	19	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	15123	20	_	_	NNP
18637	15123	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	15123	22	_	_	NNP
18637	15123	23	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	15123	24	,	,	,
18637	15123	25	301	301	CD
18637	15123	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15123	27	619	619	CD
18637	15123	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15123	29	1937	1937	CD
18637	15123	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15123	31	.	.	.
18637	15124	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15124	2	13	13	CD
18637	15124	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15124	4	United	United	NNP
18637	15124	5	States	States	NNP
18637	15124	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15124	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15124	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15124	9	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	15124	10	,	,	,
18637	15124	11	312	312	CD
18637	15124	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15124	13	100	100	CD
18637	15124	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15124	15	1941	1941	CD
18637	15124	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15124	17	;	;	:
18637	15124	18	_	_	NNP
18637	15124	19	see	see	VB
18637	15124	20	_	_	NNP
18637	15124	21	especially	especially	RB
18637	15124	22	ibid	ibid	RB
18637	15124	23	.	.	.
18637	15125	1	113	113	CD
18637	15125	2	-	-	SYM
18637	15125	3	124	124	CD
18637	15125	4	.	.	.
18637	15126	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15126	2	14	14	CD
18637	15126	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15126	4	Sola	Sola	NNP
18637	15126	5	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	15126	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15126	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15126	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15126	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15126	10	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	15126	11	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	15126	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15126	13	,	,	,
18637	15126	14	317	317	CD
18637	15126	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15126	16	173	173	CD
18637	15126	17	,	,	,
18637	15126	18	170	170	CD
18637	15126	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15126	20	1942	1942	CD
18637	15126	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15126	22	;	;	:
18637	15126	23	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	15126	24	_	_	NNP
18637	15126	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	15126	26	_	_	NNP
18637	15126	27	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	15126	28	,	,	,
18637	15126	29	325	325	CD
18637	15126	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15126	31	538	538	CD
18637	15126	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15126	33	1945	1945	CD
18637	15126	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15126	35	;	;	:
18637	15126	36	_	_	NNP
18637	15126	37	see	see	VB
18637	15126	38	also	also	RB
18637	15126	39	_	_	NNP
18637	15126	40	Testa	Testa	NNP
18637	15126	41	_	_	NNP
18637	15126	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	15126	43	_	_	NNP
18637	15126	44	Katt	Katt	NNP
18637	15126	45	,	,	,
18637	15126	46	330	330	CD
18637	15126	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15126	48	380	380	CD
18637	15126	49	,	,	,
18637	15126	50	391	391	CD
18637	15126	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15126	52	1947	1947	CD
18637	15126	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15126	54	;	;	:
18637	15126	55	Francis	Francis	NNP
18637	15126	56	_	_	NNP
18637	15126	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	15126	58	_	_	NNP
18637	15126	59	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	15126	60	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	15126	61	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15126	62	333	333	CD
18637	15126	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15126	64	445	445	CD
18637	15126	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15126	66	1918	1918	CD
18637	15126	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15126	68	;	;	:
18637	15126	69	and	and	CC
18637	15126	70	Bus	Bus	NNP
18637	15126	71	Employers	Employers	NNP
18637	15126	72	_	_	NNP
18637	15126	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	15126	74	_	_	NNP
18637	15126	75	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	15126	76	Board	Board	NNP
18637	15126	77	,	,	,
18637	15126	78	340	340	CD
18637	15126	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15126	80	383	383	CD
18637	15126	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15126	82	1951	1951	CD
18637	15126	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15126	84	.	.	.
18637	15127	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15127	2	15	15	CD
18637	15127	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15127	4	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	15127	5	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	15127	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15127	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15127	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15127	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15127	10	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	15127	11	,	,	,
18637	15127	12	825	825	CD
18637	15127	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15127	14	761	761	CD
18637	15127	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15127	16	1945	1945	CD
18637	15127	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15127	18	;	;	:
18637	15127	19	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	15127	20	_	_	NNP
18637	15127	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	15127	22	_	_	NNP
18637	15127	23	Santa	Santa	NNP
18637	15127	24	Fe	Fe	NNP
18637	15127	25	Elevator	Elevator	NNP
18637	15127	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15127	27	,	,	,
18637	15127	28	331	331	CD
18637	15127	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15127	30	218	218	CD
18637	15127	31	,	,	,
18637	15127	32	230	230	CD
18637	15127	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15127	34	1947	1947	CD
18637	15127	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15127	36	;	;	:
18637	15127	37	Auto	Auto	NNP
18637	15127	38	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	15127	39	_	_	NNP
18637	15127	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	15127	41	_	_	NNP
18637	15127	42	Wis.	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	15127	43	Board	Board	NNP
18637	15127	44	,	,	,
18637	15127	45	336	336	CD
18637	15127	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15127	47	245	245	CD
18637	15127	48	,	,	,
18637	15127	49	253	253	CD
18637	15127	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15127	51	1949	1949	CD
18637	15127	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15127	53	;	;	:
18637	15127	54	United	United	NNP
18637	15127	55	States	States	NNP
18637	15127	56	_	_	NNP
18637	15127	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	15127	58	_	_	NNP
18637	15127	59	Burnison	Burnison	NNP
18637	15127	60	,	,	,
18637	15127	61	339	339	CD
18637	15127	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15127	63	87	87	CD
18637	15127	64	,	,	,
18637	15127	65	91	91	CD
18637	15127	66	-	-	HYPH
18637	15127	67	92	92	CD
18637	15127	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15127	69	1950	1950	CD
18637	15127	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15127	71	.	.	.
18637	15128	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15128	2	16	16	CD
18637	15128	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15128	4	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	15128	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15128	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15128	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15128	8	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	15128	9	,	,	,
18637	15128	10	173	173	CD
18637	15128	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15128	12	276	276	CD
18637	15128	13	,	,	,
18637	15128	14	283	283	CD
18637	15128	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15128	16	1899	1899	CD
18637	15128	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15128	18	.	.	.
18637	15129	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15129	2	17	17	CD
18637	15129	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15129	4	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	15129	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15129	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15129	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15129	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	15129	9	,	,	,
18637	15129	10	254	254	CD
18637	15129	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15129	12	51	51	CD
18637	15129	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15129	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	15129	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15129	16	.	.	.
18637	15130	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15130	2	18	18	CD
18637	15130	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15130	4	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	15130	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15130	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15130	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15130	8	California	California	NNP
18637	15130	9	,	,	,
18637	15130	10	283	283	CD
18637	15130	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15130	12	423	423	CD
18637	15130	13	,	,	,
18637	15130	14	451	451	CD
18637	15130	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15130	16	1931	1931	CD
18637	15130	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15130	18	.	.	.
18637	15131	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15131	2	19	19	CD
18637	15131	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15131	4	9	9	CD
18637	15131	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15131	6	.	.	.
18637	15132	1	353	353	CD
18637	15132	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15132	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	15132	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15132	5	.	.	.
18637	15133	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15133	2	20	20	CD
18637	15133	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15133	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15133	5	.	.	.
18637	15134	1	362	362	CD
18637	15134	2	.	.	.
18637	15135	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15135	2	21	21	CD
18637	15135	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15135	4	161	161	CD
18637	15135	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15135	6	275	275	CD
18637	15135	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15135	8	1896	1896	CD
18637	15135	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15135	10	.	.	.
18637	15136	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15136	2	22	22	CD
18637	15136	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15136	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15136	5	.	.	.
18637	15137	1	283	283	CD
18637	15137	2	.	.	.
18637	15138	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15138	2	23	23	CD
18637	15138	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15138	4	Reagan	Reagan	NNP
18637	15138	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15138	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15138	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15138	8	Mercantile	Mercantile	NNP
18637	15138	9	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	15138	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15138	11	,	,	,
18637	15138	12	154	154	CD
18637	15138	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15138	14	413	413	CD
18637	15138	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15138	16	1894	1894	CD
18637	15138	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15138	18	.	.	.
18637	15139	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15139	2	24	24	CD
18637	15139	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15139	4	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	15139	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15139	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15139	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15139	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	15139	9	,	,	,
18637	15139	10	254	254	CD
18637	15139	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15139	12	51	51	CD
18637	15139	13	,	,	,
18637	15139	14	56	56	CD
18637	15139	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15139	16	1920	1920	CD
18637	15139	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15139	18	.	.	.
18637	15140	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15140	2	25	25	CD
18637	15140	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15140	4	Penn	Penn	NNP
18637	15140	5	Dairies	Dairies	NNP
18637	15140	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15140	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15140	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15140	9	Milk	Milk	NNP
18637	15140	10	Control	Control	NNP
18637	15140	11	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	15140	12	.	.	.
18637	15140	13	,	,	,
18637	15140	14	318	318	CD
18637	15140	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15140	16	261	261	CD
18637	15140	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15140	18	1943	1943	CD
18637	15140	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15140	20	.	.	.
18637	15141	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15141	2	26	26	CD
18637	15141	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15141	4	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	15141	5	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	15141	6	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
18637	15141	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15141	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15141	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15141	10	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	15141	11	.	.	.
18637	15142	1	of	of	IN
18637	15142	2	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	15142	3	,	,	,
18637	15142	4	318	318	CD
18637	15142	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15142	6	285	285	CD
18637	15142	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15142	8	1943	1943	CD
18637	15142	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15142	10	.	.	.
18637	15143	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15143	2	27	27	CD
18637	15143	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15143	4	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	15143	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15143	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15143	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15143	8	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	15143	9	's	's	POS
18637	15143	10	Lessee	Lessee	NNP
18637	15143	11	,	,	,
18637	15143	12	1	1	CD
18637	15143	13	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	15143	14	.	.	.
18637	15144	1	304	304	CD
18637	15144	2	,	,	,
18637	15144	3	335	335	CD
18637	15144	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15144	5	1816	1816	CD
18637	15144	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15144	7	.	.	.
18637	15145	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15145	2	28	28	CD
18637	15145	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15145	4	93	93	CD
18637	15145	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15145	6	130	130	CD
18637	15145	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15145	8	1876	1876	CD
18637	15145	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15145	10	.	.	.
18637	15146	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15146	2	29	29	CD
18637	15146	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15146	4	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	15146	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15146	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15146	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15146	8	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	15146	9	's	's	POS
18637	15146	10	Lessee	Lessee	NNP
18637	15146	11	,	,	,
18637	15146	12	1	1	CD
18637	15146	13	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	15146	14	.	.	.
18637	15147	1	304	304	CD
18637	15147	2	,	,	,
18637	15147	3	335	335	CD
18637	15147	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15147	5	1816	1816	CD
18637	15147	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15147	7	.	.	.
18637	15148	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15148	2	30	30	CD
18637	15148	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15148	4	93	93	CD
18637	15148	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15148	6	130	130	CD
18637	15148	7	,	,	,
18637	15148	8	137	137	CD
18637	15148	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15148	10	1876	1876	CD
18637	15148	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15148	12	.	.	.
18637	15149	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15149	2	31	31	CD
18637	15149	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15149	4	Mondou	Mondou	NNP
18637	15149	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15149	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15149	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15149	8	New	New	NNP
18637	15149	9	York	York	NNP
18637	15149	10	,	,	,
18637	15149	11	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	15149	12	&	&	CC
18637	15149	13	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	15150	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15150	2	,	,	,
18637	15150	3	223	223	CD
18637	15150	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15150	5	1	1	CD
18637	15150	6	,	,	,
18637	15150	7	57	57	CD
18637	15150	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15150	9	1912	1912	CD
18637	15150	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15150	11	.	.	.
18637	15151	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15151	2	32	32	CD
18637	15151	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15151	4	330	330	CD
18637	15151	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15151	6	386	386	CD
18637	15151	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15151	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	15151	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15151	10	.	.	.
18637	15152	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15152	2	33	33	CD
18637	15152	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15152	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15152	5	.	.	.
18637	15153	1	393	393	CD
18637	15153	2	.	.	.
18637	15154	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15154	2	34	34	CD
18637	15154	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15154	4	Ableman	Ableman	NNP
18637	15154	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15154	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15154	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15154	8	Booth	Booth	NNP
18637	15154	9	,	,	,
18637	15154	10	21	21	CD
18637	15154	11	How	how	WRB
18637	15154	12	.	.	.
18637	15155	1	506	506	CD
18637	15155	2	,	,	,
18637	15155	3	523	523	CD
18637	15155	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15155	5	1859	1859	CD
18637	15155	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15155	7	,	,	,
18637	15155	8	followed	follow	VBN
18637	15155	9	in	in	IN
18637	15155	10	United	United	NNP
18637	15155	11	States	States	NNP
18637	15155	12	_	_	NNP
18637	15155	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	15155	14	_	_	NNP
18637	15155	15	Tarble	Tarble	NNP
18637	15155	16	,	,	,
18637	15155	17	13	13	CD
18637	15155	18	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15155	19	.	.	.
18637	15156	1	397	397	CD
18637	15156	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15156	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	15156	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15156	5	.	.	.
18637	15157	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15157	2	35	35	CD
18637	15157	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15157	4	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	15157	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15157	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15157	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15157	8	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	15157	9	,	,	,
18637	15157	10	100	100	CD
18637	15157	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15157	12	257	257	CD
18637	15157	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15157	14	1880	1880	CD
18637	15157	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15157	16	;	;	:
18637	15157	17	_	_	NNP
18637	15157	18	see	see	VB
18637	15157	19	also	also	RB
18637	15157	20	_	_	NNP
18637	15157	21	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	15157	22	_	_	NNP
18637	15157	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	15157	24	_	_	NNP
18637	15157	25	Soper	Soper	NNP
18637	15157	26	,	,	,
18637	15157	27	270	270	CD
18637	15157	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15157	29	36	36	CD
18637	15157	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15157	31	1926	1926	CD
18637	15157	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15157	33	.	.	.
18637	15158	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15158	2	36	36	CD
18637	15158	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15158	4	135	135	CD
18637	15158	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15158	6	1	1	CD
18637	15158	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15158	8	1890	1890	CD
18637	15158	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15158	10	.	.	.
18637	15159	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15159	2	37	37	CD
18637	15159	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15159	4	Keith	Keith	NNP
18637	15159	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15159	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15159	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15159	8	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	15159	9	,	,	,
18637	15159	10	97	97	CD
18637	15159	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15159	12	454	454	CD
18637	15159	13	,	,	,
18637	15159	14	461	461	CD
18637	15159	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15159	16	1878	1878	CD
18637	15159	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15159	18	.	.	.
18637	15160	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15160	2	38	38	CD
18637	15160	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15160	4	White	White	NNP
18637	15160	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15160	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15160	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15160	8	Cannon	Cannon	NNP
18637	15160	9	,	,	,
18637	15160	10	6	6	CD
18637	15160	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15160	12	.	.	.
18637	15161	1	443	443	CD
18637	15161	2	,	,	,
18637	15161	3	450	450	CD
18637	15161	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15161	5	1868	1868	CD
18637	15161	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15161	7	.	.	.
18637	15162	1	_	_	NNP
18637	15162	2	See	See	NNP
18637	15162	3	also	also	RB
18637	15162	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15162	5	Hickman	Hickman	NNP
18637	15162	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15162	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15162	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15162	9	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	15162	10	,	,	,
18637	15162	11	9	9	CD
18637	15162	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15162	13	.	.	.
18637	15163	1	197	197	CD
18637	15163	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15163	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	15163	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15163	5	;	;	:
18637	15163	6	Dewing	Dewing	NNP
18637	15163	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15163	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15163	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15163	10	Perdicaries	Perdicaries	NNP
18637	15163	11	,	,	,
18637	15163	12	96	96	CD
18637	15163	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15163	14	193	193	CD
18637	15163	15	,	,	,
18637	15163	16	195	195	CD
18637	15163	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15163	18	1878	1878	CD
18637	15163	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15163	20	.	.	.
18637	15164	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15164	2	39	39	CD
18637	15164	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15164	4	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	15164	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15164	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15164	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15164	8	Surget	Surget	NNP
18637	15164	9	,	,	,
18637	15164	10	97	97	CD
18637	15164	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15164	12	594	594	CD
18637	15164	13	,	,	,
18637	15164	14	604	604	CD
18637	15164	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15164	16	1878	1878	CD
18637	15164	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15164	18	;	;	:
18637	15164	19	United	United	NNP
18637	15164	20	States	States	NNP
18637	15164	21	_	_	NNP
18637	15164	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	15164	23	_	_	NNP
18637	15164	24	Keehler	Keehler	NNP
18637	15164	25	,	,	,
18637	15164	26	9	9	CD
18637	15164	27	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15164	28	.	.	.
18637	15165	1	83	83	CD
18637	15165	2	,	,	,
18637	15165	3	86	86	CD
18637	15165	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15165	5	1870	1870	CD
18637	15165	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15165	7	.	.	.
18637	15166	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15166	2	40	40	CD
18637	15166	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15166	4	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	15166	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15166	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15166	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15166	8	White	White	NNP
18637	15166	9	,	,	,
18637	15166	10	7	7	CD
18637	15166	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15166	12	.	.	.
18637	15167	1	700	700	CD
18637	15167	2	,	,	,
18637	15167	3	726	726	CD
18637	15167	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15167	5	1869	1869	CD
18637	15167	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15167	7	.	.	.
18637	15168	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15168	2	41	41	CD
18637	15168	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15168	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15168	5	.	.	.
18637	15169	1	733	733	CD
18637	15169	2	.	.	.
18637	15170	1	_	_	NNP
18637	15170	2	See	See	NNP
18637	15170	3	also	also	RB
18637	15170	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15170	5	Horn	Horn	NNP
18637	15170	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15170	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15170	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15170	9	Lockhart	Lockhart	NNP
18637	15170	10	,	,	,
18637	15170	11	17	17	CD
18637	15170	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15170	13	.	.	.
18637	15171	1	570	570	CD
18637	15171	2	,	,	,
18637	15171	3	580	580	CD
18637	15171	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15171	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	15171	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15171	7	;	;	:
18637	15171	8	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	15171	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15171	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	15171	11	_	_	NNP
18637	15171	12	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	15171	13	,	,	,
18637	15171	14	12	12	CD
18637	15171	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15171	16	.	.	.
18637	15172	1	349	349	CD
18637	15172	2	,	,	,
18637	15172	3	357	357	CD
18637	15172	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15172	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	15172	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15172	7	;	;	:
18637	15172	8	White	White	NNP
18637	15172	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15172	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	15172	11	_	_	NNP
18637	15172	12	Hart	Hart	NNP
18637	15172	13	,	,	,
18637	15172	14	13	13	CD
18637	15172	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15172	16	.	.	.
18637	15173	1	646	646	CD
18637	15173	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15173	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	15173	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15173	5	;	;	:
18637	15173	6	United	United	NNP
18637	15173	7	States	States	NNP
18637	15173	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15173	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	15173	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15173	11	Home	Home	NNP
18637	15173	12	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	15173	13	.	.	.
18637	15174	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15174	2	,	,	,
18637	15174	3	22	22	CD
18637	15174	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15174	5	.	.	.
18637	15175	1	99	99	CD
18637	15175	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15175	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	15175	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15175	5	;	;	:
18637	15175	6	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	15175	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15175	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15175	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15175	10	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	15175	11	,	,	,
18637	15175	12	22	22	CD
18637	15175	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15175	14	.	.	.
18637	15176	1	479	479	CD
18637	15176	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15176	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	15176	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15176	5	;	;	:
18637	15176	6	and	and	CC
18637	15176	7	Huntington	Huntington	NNP
18637	15176	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15176	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	15176	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15176	11	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	15176	12	,	,	,
18637	15176	13	16	16	CD
18637	15176	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15176	15	.	.	.
18637	15177	1	402	402	CD
18637	15177	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15177	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	15177	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15177	5	.	.	.
18637	15178	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15178	2	42	42	CD
18637	15178	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15178	4	9	9	CD
18637	15178	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	15178	6	.	.	.
18637	15179	1	788	788	CD
18637	15179	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15179	3	1924	1924	CD
18637	15179	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15179	5	.	.	.
18637	15180	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15180	2	43	43	CD
18637	15180	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15180	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15180	5	.	.	.
18637	15181	1	865	865	CD
18637	15181	2	.	.	.
18637	15182	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15182	2	44	44	CD
18637	15182	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15182	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15182	5	.	.	.
18637	15183	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15183	2	45	45	CD
18637	15183	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15183	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15183	5	.	.	.
18637	15184	1	866	866	CD
18637	15184	2	.	.	.
18637	15185	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15185	2	46	46	CD
18637	15185	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15185	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15185	5	.	.	.
18637	15186	1	867	867	CD
18637	15186	2	.	.	.
18637	15187	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15187	2	47	47	CD
18637	15187	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15187	4	2	2	CD
18637	15187	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	15187	6	.	.	.
18637	15188	1	449	449	CD
18637	15188	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15188	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	15188	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15188	5	,	,	,
18637	15188	6	followed	follow	VBN
18637	15188	7	in	in	IN
18637	15188	8	New	New	NNP
18637	15188	9	York	York	NNP
18637	15188	10	ex	ex	NNP
18637	15188	11	rel	rel	NN
18637	15188	12	.	.	.
18637	15189	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	15189	2	of	of	IN
18637	15189	3	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	15189	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15189	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	15189	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15189	7	Comrs	Comrs	NNP
18637	15189	8	.	.	.
18637	15190	1	of	of	IN
18637	15190	2	Taxes	Taxes	NNPS
18637	15190	3	and	and	CC
18637	15190	4	Assessments	Assessments	NNPS
18637	15190	5	,	,	,
18637	15190	6	2	2	CD
18637	15190	7	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	15190	8	.	.	.
18637	15191	1	620	620	CD
18637	15191	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15191	3	1863	1863	CD
18637	15191	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15191	5	.	.	.
18637	15192	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15192	2	48	48	CD
18637	15192	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15192	4	12	12	CD
18637	15192	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	15192	6	.	.	.
18637	15193	1	710	710	CD
18637	15193	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15193	3	1863	1863	CD
18637	15193	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15193	5	.	.	.
18637	15194	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15194	2	49	49	CD
18637	15194	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15194	4	31	31	CD
18637	15194	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
18637	15195	1	§	§	NNP
18637	15195	2	742	742	CD
18637	15195	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15195	4	1946	1946	CD
18637	15195	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15195	6	.	.	.
18637	15196	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15196	2	50	50	CD
18637	15196	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15196	4	7	7	CD
18637	15196	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15196	6	.	.	.
18637	15197	1	26	26	CD
18637	15197	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15197	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	15197	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15197	5	.	.	.
18637	15198	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15198	2	51	51	CD
18637	15198	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15198	4	Hibernia	Hibernia	NNP
18637	15198	5	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	15198	6	.	.	.
18637	15199	1	&	&	CC
18637	15199	2	L.	L.	NNP
18637	15199	3	Soc	Soc	NNP
18637	15199	4	.	.	.
18637	15200	1	_	_	NNP
18637	15200	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	15200	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15200	4	San	San	NNP
18637	15200	5	Francisco	Francisco	NNP
18637	15200	6	,	,	,
18637	15200	7	200	200	CD
18637	15200	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15200	9	310	310	CD
18637	15200	10	,	,	,
18637	15200	11	315	315	CD
18637	15200	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15200	13	1906	1906	CD
18637	15200	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15200	15	.	.	.
18637	15201	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15201	2	52	52	CD
18637	15201	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15201	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	15201	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15201	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15201	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15201	8	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	15201	9	,	,	,
18637	15201	10	323	323	CD
18637	15201	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15201	12	111	111	CD
18637	15201	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15201	14	1944	1944	CD
18637	15201	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15201	16	.	.	.
18637	15202	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15202	2	53	53	CD
18637	15202	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15202	4	Plummer	Plummer	NNP
18637	15202	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15202	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15202	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15202	8	Coler	Coler	NNP
18637	15202	9	,	,	,
18637	15202	10	178	178	CD
18637	15202	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15202	12	115	115	CD
18637	15202	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15202	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	15202	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15202	16	;	;	:
18637	15202	17	Blodgett	Blodgett	NNP
18637	15202	18	_	_	NNP
18637	15202	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	15202	20	_	_	NNP
18637	15202	21	Silberman	Silberman	NNP
18637	15202	22	,	,	,
18637	15202	23	277	277	CD
18637	15202	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15202	25	1	1	CD
18637	15202	26	,	,	,
18637	15202	27	12	12	CD
18637	15202	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15202	29	1928	1928	CD
18637	15202	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15202	31	.	.	.
18637	15203	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15203	2	54	54	CD
18637	15203	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15203	4	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	15203	5	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	15203	6	L.	L.	NNP
18637	15203	7	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	15203	8	.	.	.
18637	15204	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15204	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15204	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15204	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15204	5	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	15204	6	,	,	,
18637	15204	7	275	275	CD
18637	15204	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15204	9	136	136	CD
18637	15204	10	,	,	,
18637	15204	11	140	140	CD
18637	15204	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15204	13	1927	1927	CD
18637	15204	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15204	15	.	.	.
18637	15205	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15205	2	55	55	CD
18637	15205	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15205	4	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	15205	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15205	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15205	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15205	8	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	15205	9	,	,	,
18637	15205	10	272	272	CD
18637	15205	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15205	12	713	713	CD
18637	15205	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15205	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	15205	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15205	16	.	.	.
18637	15206	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15206	2	56	56	CD
18637	15206	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15206	4	Provident	Provident	NNP
18637	15206	5	Inst	Inst	NNP
18637	15206	6	.	.	.
18637	15207	1	for	for	IN
18637	15207	2	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	15207	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15207	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	15207	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15207	6	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	15207	7	,	,	,
18637	15207	8	6	6	CD
18637	15207	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15207	10	.	.	.
18637	15208	1	611	611	CD
18637	15208	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15208	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	15208	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15208	5	;	;	:
18637	15208	6	Society	Society	NNP
18637	15208	7	for	for	IN
18637	15208	8	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	15208	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15208	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	15208	11	_	_	NNP
18637	15208	12	Coite	Coite	NNP
18637	15208	13	,	,	,
18637	15208	14	6	6	CD
18637	15208	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15208	16	.	.	.
18637	15209	1	594	594	CD
18637	15209	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15209	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	15209	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15209	5	;	;	:
18637	15209	6	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	15209	7	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	15209	8	.	.	.
18637	15210	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15210	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15210	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15210	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15210	5	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	15210	6	,	,	,
18637	15210	7	6	6	CD
18637	15210	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15210	9	.	.	.
18637	15211	1	632	632	CD
18637	15211	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15211	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	15211	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15211	5	;	;	:
18637	15211	6	Home	Home	NNP
18637	15211	7	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	15211	8	.	.	.
18637	15212	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15212	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15212	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15212	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15212	5	New	New	NNP
18637	15212	6	York	York	NNP
18637	15212	7	,	,	,
18637	15212	8	134	134	CD
18637	15212	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15212	10	594	594	CD
18637	15212	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15212	12	1890	1890	CD
18637	15212	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15212	14	.	.	.
18637	15213	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15213	2	57	57	CD
18637	15213	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15213	4	Macallen	Macallen	NNP
18637	15213	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15213	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15213	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15213	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	15213	9	,	,	,
18637	15213	10	279	279	CD
18637	15213	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15213	12	620	620	CD
18637	15213	13	,	,	,
18637	15213	14	625	625	CD
18637	15213	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15213	16	1929	1929	CD
18637	15213	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15213	18	.	.	.
18637	15214	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15214	2	58	58	CD
18637	15214	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15214	4	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	15214	5	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	15214	6	L.	L.	NNP
18637	15214	7	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	15214	8	.	.	.
18637	15215	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15215	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15215	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15215	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15215	5	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	15215	6	,	,	,
18637	15215	7	275	275	CD
18637	15215	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15215	9	136	136	CD
18637	15215	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15215	11	1927	1927	CD
18637	15215	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15215	13	.	.	.
18637	15216	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15216	2	59	59	CD
18637	15216	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15216	4	9	9	CD
18637	15216	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	15216	6	.	.	.
18637	15217	1	738	738	CD
18637	15217	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15217	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	15217	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15217	5	.	.	.
18637	15218	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15218	2	60	60	CD
18637	15218	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15218	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15218	5	.	.	.
18637	15219	1	867	867	CD
18637	15219	2	.	.	.
18637	15220	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15220	2	61	61	CD
18637	15220	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15220	4	302	302	CD
18637	15220	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15220	6	134	134	CD
18637	15220	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15220	8	1937	1937	CD
18637	15220	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15220	10	.	.	.
18637	15221	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15221	2	62	62	CD
18637	15221	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15221	4	Alward	Alward	NNP
18637	15221	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15221	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15221	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15221	8	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	15221	9	,	,	,
18637	15221	10	282	282	CD
18637	15221	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15221	12	509	509	CD
18637	15221	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15221	14	1931	1931	CD
18637	15221	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15221	16	.	.	.
18637	15222	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15222	2	63	63	CD
18637	15222	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15222	4	Trinityfarm	Trinityfarm	NNP
18637	15222	5	Const	Const	NNP
18637	15222	6	.	.	.
18637	15223	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15223	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15223	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15223	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15223	5	Grosjean	Grosjean	NNP
18637	15223	6	,	,	,
18637	15223	7	291	291	CD
18637	15223	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15223	9	466	466	CD
18637	15223	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15223	11	1934	1934	CD
18637	15223	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15223	13	.	.	.
18637	15224	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15224	2	64	64	CD
18637	15224	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15224	4	Atkinson	Atkinson	NNP
18637	15224	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15224	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15224	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15224	8	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	15224	9	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	15224	10	,	,	,
18637	15224	11	303	303	CD
18637	15224	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15224	13	20	20	CD
18637	15224	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15224	15	1938	1938	CD
18637	15224	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15224	17	.	.	.
18637	15225	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15225	2	65	65	CD
18637	15225	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15225	4	Superior	Superior	NNP
18637	15225	5	Bath	Bath	NNP
18637	15225	6	House	House	NNP
18637	15225	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15225	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15225	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	15225	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15225	11	McCarroll	McCarroll	NNP
18637	15225	12	,	,	,
18637	15225	13	312	312	CD
18637	15225	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15225	15	176	176	CD
18637	15225	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15225	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	15225	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15225	19	.	.	.
18637	15226	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15226	2	66	66	CD
18637	15226	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15226	4	Buckstaff	Buckstaff	NNP
18637	15226	5	Bath	Bath	NNP
18637	15226	6	House	House	NNP
18637	15226	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15226	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15226	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15226	10	McKinley	McKinley	NNP
18637	15226	11	,	,	,
18637	15226	12	308	308	CD
18637	15226	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15226	14	358	358	CD
18637	15226	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15226	16	1939	1939	CD
18637	15226	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15226	18	.	.	.
18637	15227	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15227	2	67	67	CD
18637	15227	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15227	4	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	15227	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15227	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15227	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15227	8	Yosemite	Yosemite	NNP
18637	15227	9	Park	Park	NNP
18637	15227	10	&	&	CC
18637	15227	11	Curry	Curry	NNP
18637	15227	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15227	13	,	,	,
18637	15227	14	304	304	CD
18637	15227	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15227	16	518	518	CD
18637	15227	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15227	18	1938	1938	CD
18637	15227	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15227	20	.	.	.
18637	15228	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15228	2	68	68	CD
18637	15228	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15228	4	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	15228	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15228	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15228	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15228	8	King	King	NNP
18637	15228	9	&	&	CC
18637	15228	10	Boozer	Boozer	NNP
18637	15228	11	,	,	,
18637	15228	12	314	314	CD
18637	15228	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15228	14	1	1	CD
18637	15228	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15228	16	1941	1941	CD
18637	15228	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15228	18	,	,	,
18637	15228	19	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	15228	20	Panhandle	Panhandle	NNP
18637	15228	21	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	15228	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15228	23	_	_	NNP
18637	15228	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	15228	25	_	_	NNP
18637	15228	26	Knox	Knox	NNP
18637	15228	27	,	,	,
18637	15228	28	277	277	CD
18637	15228	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15228	30	218	218	CD
18637	15228	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15228	32	1928	1928	CD
18637	15228	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15228	34	and	and	CC
18637	15228	35	Graves	Graves	NNPS
18637	15228	36	_	_	NNP
18637	15228	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	15228	38	_	_	NNP
18637	15228	39	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	15228	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15228	41	,	,	,
18637	15228	42	298	298	CD
18637	15228	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15228	44	393	393	CD
18637	15228	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15228	46	1936	1936	CD
18637	15228	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15228	48	.	.	.
18637	15229	1	_	_	NNP
18637	15229	2	See	See	NNP
18637	15229	3	also	also	RB
18637	15229	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15229	5	Curry	Curry	NNP
18637	15229	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15229	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15229	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15229	9	United	United	NNP
18637	15229	10	States	States	NNP
18637	15229	11	,	,	,
18637	15229	12	314	314	CD
18637	15229	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15229	14	14	14	CD
18637	15229	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15229	16	1941	1941	CD
18637	15229	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15229	18	.	.	.
18637	15230	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15230	2	69	69	CD
18637	15230	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15230	4	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	15230	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15230	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15230	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15230	8	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	15230	9	,	,	,
18637	15230	10	327	327	CD
18637	15230	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15230	12	474	474	CD
18637	15230	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15230	14	1946	1946	CD
18637	15230	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15230	16	.	.	.
18637	15231	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15231	2	70	70	CD
18637	15231	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15231	4	306	306	CD
18637	15231	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15231	6	466	466	CD
18637	15231	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15231	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	15231	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15231	10	,	,	,
18637	15231	11	followed	follow	VBN
18637	15231	12	in	in	IN
18637	15231	13	State	State	NNP
18637	15231	14	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	15231	15	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
18637	15231	16	.	.	.
18637	15232	1	_	_	NNP
18637	15232	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	15232	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15232	4	Van	Van	NNP
18637	15232	5	Cott	Cott	NNP
18637	15232	6	,	,	,
18637	15232	7	306	306	CD
18637	15232	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15232	9	511	511	CD
18637	15232	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15232	11	1939	1939	CD
18637	15232	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15232	13	.	.	.
18637	15233	1	This	this	DT
18637	15233	2	case	case	NN
18637	15233	3	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	15233	4	by	by	IN
18637	15233	5	implication	implication	NN
18637	15233	6	Dobbins	Dobbins	NNP
18637	15233	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15233	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15233	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15233	10	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	15233	11	County	County	NNP
18637	15233	12	,	,	,
18637	15233	13	16	16	CD
18637	15233	14	Pet	pet	NN
18637	15233	15	.	.	.
18637	15234	1	435	435	CD
18637	15234	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15234	3	1842	1842	CD
18637	15234	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15234	5	and	and	CC
18637	15234	6	New	New	NNP
18637	15234	7	York	York	NNP
18637	15234	8	ex	ex	NNP
18637	15234	9	rel	rel	NN
18637	15234	10	.	.	.
18637	15235	1	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	15235	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15235	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15235	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15235	5	Graves	Graves	NNP
18637	15235	6	,	,	,
18637	15235	7	299	299	CD
18637	15235	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15235	9	401	401	CD
18637	15235	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15235	11	1937	1937	CD
18637	15235	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15235	13	,	,	,
18637	15235	14	which	which	WDT
18637	15235	15	held	hold	VBD
18637	15235	16	the	the	DT
18637	15235	17	income	income	NN
18637	15235	18	of	of	IN
18637	15235	19	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15235	20	employees	employee	NNS
18637	15235	21	to	to	TO
18637	15235	22	be	be	VB
18637	15235	23	immune	immune	JJ
18637	15235	24	from	from	IN
18637	15235	25	State	state	NN
18637	15235	26	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	15235	27	.	.	.
18637	15236	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15236	2	71	71	CD
18637	15236	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15236	4	306	306	CD
18637	15236	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15236	6	466	466	CD
18637	15236	7	,	,	,
18637	15236	8	487	487	CD
18637	15236	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15236	10	1939	1939	CD
18637	15236	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15236	12	.	.	.
18637	15237	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15237	2	72	72	CD
18637	15237	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15237	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15237	5	.	.	.
18637	15238	1	492	492	CD
18637	15238	2	.	.	.
18637	15239	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15239	2	73	73	CD
18637	15239	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15239	4	4	4	CD
18637	15239	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	15239	6	.	.	.
18637	15240	1	316	316	CD
18637	15240	2	,	,	,
18637	15240	3	426	426	CD
18637	15240	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15240	5	1819	1819	CD
18637	15240	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15240	7	.	.	.
18637	15241	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15241	2	74	74	CD
18637	15241	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15241	4	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	15241	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15241	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15241	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15241	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	15241	9	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	15242	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15242	2	,	,	,
18637	15242	3	9	9	CD
18637	15242	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15242	5	.	.	.
18637	15243	1	579	579	CD
18637	15243	2	,	,	,
18637	15243	3	588	588	CD
18637	15243	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15243	5	1870	1870	CD
18637	15243	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15243	7	;	;	:
18637	15243	8	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	15243	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15243	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15243	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	15243	12	_	_	NNP
18637	15243	13	Peniston	Peniston	NNP
18637	15243	14	,	,	,
18637	15243	15	18	18	CD
18637	15243	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15243	17	.	.	.
18637	15244	1	5	5	CD
18637	15244	2	,	,	,
18637	15244	3	31	31	CD
18637	15244	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15244	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	15244	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15244	7	.	.	.
18637	15245	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15245	2	75	75	CD
18637	15245	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15245	4	Susquehanna	Susquehanna	NNP
18637	15245	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	15245	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15245	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15245	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15245	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15245	10	State	State	NNP
18637	15245	11	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	15245	12	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	15245	13	.	.	.
18637	15245	14	,	,	,
18637	15245	15	283	283	CD
18637	15245	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15245	17	291	291	CD
18637	15245	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15245	19	1931	1931	CD
18637	15245	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15245	21	.	.	.
18637	15246	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15246	2	76	76	CD
18637	15246	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15246	4	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	15246	5	Shipbuilding	Shipbuilding	NNP
18637	15246	6	&	&	CC
18637	15246	7	Dry	Dry	NNP
18637	15246	8	Dock	Dock	NNP
18637	15246	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15246	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15246	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	15246	12	_	_	NNP
18637	15246	13	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	15246	14	,	,	,
18637	15246	15	195	195	CD
18637	15246	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15246	17	375	375	CD
18637	15246	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15246	19	1904	1904	CD
18637	15246	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15246	21	.	.	.
18637	15247	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15247	2	77	77	CD
18637	15247	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15247	4	Northern	northern	JJ
18637	15247	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	15248	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15248	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15248	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15248	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15248	5	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	15248	6	,	,	,
18637	15248	7	172	172	CD
18637	15248	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15248	9	589	589	CD
18637	15248	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15248	11	1899	1899	CD
18637	15248	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15248	13	;	;	:
18637	15248	14	New	New	NNP
18637	15248	15	Brunswick	Brunswick	NNP
18637	15248	16	_	_	NNP
18637	15248	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	15248	18	_	_	NNP
18637	15248	19	United	United	NNP
18637	15248	20	States	States	NNP
18637	15248	21	,	,	,
18637	15248	22	276	276	CD
18637	15248	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15248	24	547	547	CD
18637	15248	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15248	26	1928	1928	CD
18637	15248	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15248	28	.	.	.
18637	15249	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15249	2	78	78	CD
18637	15249	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15249	4	Irwin	Irwin	NNP
18637	15249	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15249	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15249	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15249	8	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	15249	9	,	,	,
18637	15249	10	258	258	CD
18637	15249	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15249	12	219	219	CD
18637	15249	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15249	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	15249	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15249	16	.	.	.
18637	15250	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15250	2	79	79	CD
18637	15250	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15250	4	United	United	NNP
18637	15250	5	States	States	NNP
18637	15250	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15250	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15250	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15250	9	Allegheny	Allegheny	NNP
18637	15250	10	County	County	NNP
18637	15250	11	,	,	,
18637	15250	12	322	322	CD
18637	15250	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15250	14	174	174	CD
18637	15250	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15250	16	1944	1944	CD
18637	15250	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15250	18	.	.	.
18637	15251	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15251	2	80	80	CD
18637	15251	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15251	4	117	117	CD
18637	15251	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15251	6	151	151	CD
18637	15251	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15251	8	1886	1886	CD
18637	15251	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15251	10	.	.	.
18637	15252	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15252	2	81	81	CD
18637	15252	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15252	4	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	15252	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15252	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15252	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15252	8	Osceola	Osceola	NNP
18637	15252	9	&	&	CC
18637	15252	10	L.	L.	NNP
18637	15252	11	River	River	NNP
18637	15252	12	Road	Road	NNP
18637	15252	13	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	15252	14	.	.	.
18637	15253	1	Dist	dist	NN
18637	15253	2	,	,	,
18637	15253	3	268	268	CD
18637	15253	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15253	5	643	643	CD
18637	15253	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15253	7	1925	1925	CD
18637	15253	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15253	9	.	.	.
18637	15254	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15254	2	82	82	CD
18637	15254	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15254	4	Clallam	Clallam	NNP
18637	15254	5	County	County	NNP
18637	15254	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15254	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15254	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15254	9	United	United	NNP
18637	15254	10	States	States	NNP
18637	15254	11	,	,	,
18637	15254	12	263	263	CD
18637	15254	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15254	14	341	341	CD
18637	15254	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15254	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	15254	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15254	18	.	.	.
18637	15255	1	_	_	NNP
18637	15255	2	See	See	NNP
18637	15255	3	also	also	RB
18637	15255	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15255	5	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
18637	15255	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15255	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15255	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15255	9	United	United	NNP
18637	15255	10	States	States	NNP
18637	15255	11	,	,	,
18637	15255	12	323	323	CD
18637	15255	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15255	14	329	329	CD
18637	15255	15	,	,	,
18637	15255	16	333	333	CD
18637	15255	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15255	18	1945	1945	CD
18637	15255	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15255	20	.	.	.
18637	15256	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15256	2	83	83	CD
18637	15256	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15256	4	Mayo	Mayo	NNP
18637	15256	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15256	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15256	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15256	8	United	United	NNP
18637	15256	9	States	States	NNP
18637	15256	10	,	,	,
18637	15256	11	319	319	CD
18637	15256	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15256	13	441	441	CD
18637	15256	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15256	15	1943	1943	CD
18637	15256	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15256	17	.	.	.
18637	15257	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15257	2	84	84	CD
18637	15257	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15257	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	15257	5	U.	U.	NNP
18637	15257	6	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	15257	7	.	.	.
18637	15258	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15258	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15258	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15258	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15258	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	15258	6	,	,	,
18637	15258	7	105	105	CD
18637	15258	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15258	9	460	460	CD
18637	15258	10	,	,	,
18637	15258	11	464	464	CD
18637	15258	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15258	13	1882	1882	CD
18637	15258	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15258	15	.	.	.
18637	15259	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15259	2	85	85	CD
18637	15259	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15259	4	Des	Des	NNP
18637	15259	5	Moines	Moines	NNP
18637	15259	6	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	15259	7	.	.	.
18637	15260	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	15260	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15260	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15260	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15260	5	Fairweather	Fairweather	NNP
18637	15260	6	,	,	,
18637	15260	7	263	263	CD
18637	15260	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15260	9	103	103	CD
18637	15260	10	,	,	,
18637	15260	11	106	106	CD
18637	15260	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15260	13	1923	1923	CD
18637	15260	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15260	15	;	;	:
18637	15260	16	Owensboro	Owensboro	NNP
18637	15260	17	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	15260	18	.	.	.
18637	15261	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	15261	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15261	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15261	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15261	5	Owensboro	Owensboro	NNP
18637	15261	6	,	,	,
18637	15261	7	173	173	CD
18637	15261	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15261	9	664	664	CD
18637	15261	10	,	,	,
18637	15261	11	669	669	CD
18637	15261	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15261	13	1899	1899	CD
18637	15261	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15261	15	;	;	:
18637	15261	16	First	First	NNP
18637	15261	17	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	15261	18	.	.	.
18637	15262	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	15262	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15262	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15262	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15262	5	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	15262	6	,	,	,
18637	15262	7	258	258	CD
18637	15262	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15262	9	362	362	CD
18637	15262	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15262	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	15262	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15262	13	.	.	.
18637	15263	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15263	2	86	86	CD
18637	15263	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15263	4	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	15263	5	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	15263	6	.	.	.
18637	15264	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	15264	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15264	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15264	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15264	5	State	State	NNP
18637	15264	6	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	15264	7	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	15264	8	.	.	.
18637	15264	9	,	,	,
18637	15264	10	297	297	CD
18637	15264	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15264	12	209	209	CD
18637	15264	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15264	14	1936	1936	CD
18637	15264	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15264	16	.	.	.
18637	15265	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15265	2	87	87	CD
18637	15265	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15265	4	Maricopa	Maricopa	NNP
18637	15265	5	County	County	NNP
18637	15265	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15265	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15265	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15265	9	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	15265	10	National	National	NNP
18637	15265	11	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	15265	12	,	,	,
18637	15265	13	318	318	CD
18637	15265	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15265	15	357	357	CD
18637	15265	16	,	,	,
18637	15265	17	362	362	CD
18637	15265	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15265	19	1943	1943	CD
18637	15265	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15265	21	.	.	.
18637	15266	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15266	2	88	88	CD
18637	15266	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15266	4	308	308	CD
18637	15266	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15266	6	21	21	CD
18637	15266	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15266	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	15266	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15266	10	.	.	.
18637	15267	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15267	2	89	89	CD
18637	15267	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15267	4	314	314	CD
18637	15267	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15267	6	95	95	CD
18637	15267	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15267	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	15267	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15267	10	.	.	.
18637	15268	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15268	2	90	90	CD
18637	15268	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15268	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15268	5	.	.	.
18637	15269	1	101	101	CD
18637	15269	2	.	.	.
18637	15270	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15270	2	91	91	CD
18637	15270	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15270	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15270	5	.	.	.
18637	15271	1	102	102	CD
18637	15271	2	;	;	:
18637	15271	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15271	4	cf	cf	NNP
18637	15271	5	.	.	.
18637	15271	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15271	7	9	9	CD
18637	15271	8	Wheat	Wheat	NNP
18637	15271	9	.	.	.
18637	15272	1	738	738	CD
18637	15272	2	,	,	,
18637	15272	3	864	864	CD
18637	15272	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	15272	5	865	865	CD
18637	15272	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15272	7	1824	1824	CD
18637	15272	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15272	9	.	.	.
18637	15273	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15273	2	92	92	CD
18637	15273	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15273	4	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	15273	5	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	15273	6	.	.	.
18637	15274	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	15274	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15274	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15274	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15274	5	Bedford	Bedford	NNP
18637	15274	6	,	,	,
18637	15274	7	310	310	CD
18637	15274	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15274	9	41	41	CD
18637	15274	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15274	11	1940	1940	CD
18637	15274	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15274	13	.	.	.
18637	15275	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15275	2	93	93	CD
18637	15275	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15275	4	342	342	CD
18637	15275	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15275	6	232	232	CD
18637	15275	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15275	8	1952	1952	CD
18637	15275	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15275	10	.	.	.
18637	15276	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15276	2	94	94	CD
18637	15276	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15276	4	60	60	CD
18637	15276	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	15276	6	.	.	.
18637	15277	1	765	765	CD
18637	15277	2	;	;	:
18637	15277	3	42	42	CD
18637	15277	4	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	15278	1	§	§	NNP
18637	15278	2	1809	1809	CD
18637	15278	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15278	4	b	b	NN
18637	15278	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15278	6	.	.	.
18637	15279	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15279	2	95	95	CD
18637	15279	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15279	4	342	342	CD
18637	15279	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15279	6	232	232	CD
18637	15279	7	,	,	,
18637	15279	8	234	234	CD
18637	15279	9	.	.	.
18637	15280	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15280	2	96	96	CD
18637	15280	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15280	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15280	5	.	.	.
18637	15281	1	236	236	CD
18637	15281	2	.	.	.
18637	15282	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15282	2	97	97	CD
18637	15282	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15282	4	Long	Long	NNP
18637	15282	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15282	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15282	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15282	8	Rockwood	Rockwood	NNP
18637	15282	9	,	,	,
18637	15282	10	277	277	CD
18637	15282	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15282	12	142	142	CD
18637	15282	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15282	14	1928	1928	CD
18637	15282	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15282	16	.	.	.
18637	15283	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15283	2	98	98	CD
18637	15283	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15283	4	286	286	CD
18637	15283	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15283	6	123	123	CD
18637	15283	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15283	8	1932	1932	CD
18637	15283	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15283	10	.	.	.
18637	15284	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15284	2	99	99	CD
18637	15284	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15284	4	Educational	Educational	NNP
18637	15284	5	Films	Films	NNPS
18637	15284	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	15284	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15284	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15284	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15284	10	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	15284	11	,	,	,
18637	15284	12	282	282	CD
18637	15284	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15284	14	379	379	CD
18637	15284	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15284	16	1931	1931	CD
18637	15284	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15284	18	.	.	.
18637	15285	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15285	2	100	100	CD
18637	15285	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15285	4	235	235	CD
18637	15285	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15285	6	292	292	CD
18637	15285	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15285	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	15285	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15285	10	.	.	.
18637	15286	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15286	2	101	101	CD
18637	15286	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15286	4	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	15286	5	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	15286	6	Illuminating	Illuminating	NNP
18637	15286	7	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	15286	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15286	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15286	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	15286	11	_	_	NNP
18637	15286	12	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	15286	13	,	,	,
18637	15286	14	240	240	CD
18637	15286	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15286	16	522	522	CD
18637	15286	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15286	18	1916	1916	CD
18637	15286	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15286	20	.	.	.
18637	15287	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15287	2	102	102	CD
18637	15287	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15287	4	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	15287	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15287	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15287	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15287	8	Gipsy	Gipsy	NNP
18637	15287	9	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	15287	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15287	11	,	,	,
18637	15287	12	247	247	CD
18637	15287	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15287	14	503	503	CD
18637	15287	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15287	16	1918	1918	CD
18637	15287	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15287	18	;	;	:
18637	15287	19	Large	Large	NNP
18637	15287	20	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	15287	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15287	22	_	_	NNP
18637	15287	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	15287	24	_	_	NNP
18637	15287	25	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	15287	26	,	,	,
18637	15287	27	248	248	CD
18637	15287	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15287	29	549	549	CD
18637	15287	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15287	31	1919	1919	CD
18637	15287	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15287	33	.	.	.
18637	15288	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15288	2	103	103	CD
18637	15288	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15288	4	257	257	CD
18637	15288	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15288	6	501	501	CD
18637	15288	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15288	8	1922	1922	CD
18637	15288	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15288	10	.	.	.
18637	15289	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15289	2	104	104	CD
18637	15289	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15289	4	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	15289	5	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	15289	6	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	15289	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15289	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15289	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15289	10	Barnsdall	Barnsdall	NNP
18637	15289	11	Refiners	Refiners	NNPS
18637	15289	12	,	,	,
18637	15289	13	296	296	CD
18637	15289	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15289	15	521	521	CD
18637	15289	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15289	17	1936	1936	CD
18637	15289	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15289	19	.	.	.
18637	15290	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15290	2	105	105	CD
18637	15290	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15290	4	330	330	CD
18637	15290	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15290	6	342	342	CD
18637	15290	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15290	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	15290	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15290	10	.	.	.
18637	15291	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15291	2	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	15291	3	,	,	,
18637	15291	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15291	5	for	for	IN
18637	15291	6	the	the	DT
18637	15291	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15291	8	,	,	,
18637	15291	9	sketched	sketch	VBD
18637	15291	10	the	the	DT
18637	15291	11	history	history	NN
18637	15291	12	of	of	IN
18637	15291	13	the	the	DT
18637	15291	14	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	15291	15	of	of	IN
18637	15291	16	lessees	lessee	NNS
18637	15291	17	of	of	IN
18637	15291	18	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	15291	19	lands	land	NNS
18637	15291	20	from	from	IN
18637	15291	21	State	state	NN
18637	15291	22	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	15291	23	,	,	,
18637	15291	24	which	which	WDT
18637	15291	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15291	26	found	find	VBD
18637	15291	27	to	to	TO
18637	15291	28	stem	stem	VB
18637	15291	29	from	from	IN
18637	15291	30	early	early	JJ
18637	15291	31	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	15291	32	that	that	WDT
18637	15291	33	tribal	tribal	JJ
18637	15291	34	lands	land	NNS
18637	15291	35	are	be	VBP
18637	15291	36	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15291	37	immune	immune	JJ
18637	15291	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15291	39	The	the	DT
18637	15291	40	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	15291	41	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	15291	42	,	,	,
18637	15291	43	5	5	CD
18637	15291	44	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15291	45	.	.	.
18637	15292	1	737	737	CD
18637	15292	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15292	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	15292	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15292	5	;	;	:
18637	15292	6	The	the	DT
18637	15292	7	New	New	NNP
18637	15292	8	York	York	NNP
18637	15292	9	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	15292	10	,	,	,
18637	15292	11	5	5	CD
18637	15292	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15292	13	.	.	.
18637	15293	1	761	761	CD
18637	15293	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15293	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	15293	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15293	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15293	6	.	.	.
18637	15294	1	One	one	CD
18637	15294	2	of	of	IN
18637	15294	3	the	the	DT
18637	15294	4	first	first	JJ
18637	15294	5	steps	step	NNS
18637	15294	6	taken	take	VBN
18637	15294	7	to	to	TO
18637	15294	8	curtail	curtail	VB
18637	15294	9	the	the	DT
18637	15294	10	scope	scope	NN
18637	15294	11	of	of	IN
18637	15294	12	the	the	DT
18637	15294	13	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	15294	14	was	be	VBD
18637	15294	15	Shaw	Shaw	NNP
18637	15294	16	_	_	NNP
18637	15294	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	15294	18	_	_	NNP
18637	15294	19	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	15294	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	15294	21	Zahniser	Zahniser	NNP
18637	15294	22	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	15294	23	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	15294	24	,	,	,
18637	15294	25	276	276	CD
18637	15294	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15294	27	575	575	CD
18637	15294	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15294	29	1928	1928	CD
18637	15294	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15294	31	,	,	,
18637	15294	32	which	which	WDT
18637	15294	33	held	hold	VBD
18637	15294	34	that	that	IN
18637	15294	35	lands	land	NNS
18637	15294	36	outside	outside	IN
18637	15294	37	a	a	DT
18637	15294	38	reservation	reservation	NN
18637	15294	39	,	,	,
18637	15294	40	though	though	IN
18637	15294	41	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	15294	42	with	with	IN
18637	15294	43	restricted	restricted	JJ
18637	15294	44	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	15294	45	funds	fund	NNS
18637	15294	46	,	,	,
18637	15294	47	were	be	VBD
18637	15294	48	subject	subject	JJ
18637	15294	49	to	to	IN
18637	15294	50	State	state	NN
18637	15294	51	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	15294	52	.	.	.
18637	15295	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15295	2	soon	soon	RB
18637	15295	3	upset	upset	VBD
18637	15295	4	the	the	DT
18637	15295	5	decision	decision	NN
18637	15295	6	,	,	,
18637	15295	7	however	however	RB
18637	15295	8	,	,	,
18637	15295	9	and	and	CC
18637	15295	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15295	11	act	act	NN
18637	15295	12	was	be	VBD
18637	15295	13	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	15295	14	in	in	IN
18637	15295	15	Board	Board	NNP
18637	15295	16	of	of	IN
18637	15295	17	County	County	NNP
18637	15295	18	Comm'rs	Comm'rs	NNP
18637	15295	19	_	_	NNP
18637	15295	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	15295	21	_	_	NNP
18637	15295	22	Seber	Seber	NNP
18637	15295	23	,	,	,
18637	15295	24	318	318	CD
18637	15295	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15295	26	705	705	CD
18637	15295	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15295	28	1943	1943	CD
18637	15295	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15295	30	.	.	.
18637	15296	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15296	2	106	106	CD
18637	15296	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15296	4	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	15296	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15296	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15296	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15296	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	15296	9	,	,	,
18637	15296	10	4	4	CD
18637	15296	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	15296	12	.	.	.
18637	15297	1	316	316	CD
18637	15297	2	,	,	,
18637	15297	3	416	416	CD
18637	15297	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15297	5	1819	1819	CD
18637	15297	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15297	7	.	.	.
18637	15298	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15298	2	107	107	CD
18637	15298	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15298	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	15298	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	15298	6	Garland	Garland	NNP
18637	15298	7	,	,	,
18637	15298	8	4	4	CD
18637	15298	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15298	10	.	.	.
18637	15299	1	333	333	CD
18637	15299	2	,	,	,
18637	15299	3	337	337	CD
18637	15299	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15299	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	15299	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15299	7	.	.	.
18637	15300	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15300	2	108	108	CD
18637	15300	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15300	4	Cummings	Cummings	NNP
18637	15300	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15300	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15300	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15300	8	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	15300	9	,	,	,
18637	15300	10	4	4	CD
18637	15300	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15300	12	.	.	.
18637	15301	1	277	277	CD
18637	15301	2	,	,	,
18637	15301	3	323	323	CD
18637	15301	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15301	5	1867	1867	CD
18637	15301	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15301	7	.	.	.
18637	15302	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15302	2	109	109	CD
18637	15302	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15302	4	The	the	DT
18637	15302	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	15302	6	No	no	NN
18637	15302	7	.	.	.
18637	15303	1	27	27	CD
18637	15303	2	,	,	,
18637	15303	3	p.	p.	NN
18637	15303	4	123	123	CD
18637	15303	5	;	;	:
18637	15303	6	I	I	NNP
18637	15303	7	Farrand	Farrand	NNP
18637	15303	8	Records	Records	NNPS
18637	15303	9	,	,	,
18637	15303	10	404	404	CD
18637	15303	11	.	.	.
18637	15304	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15304	2	110	110	CD
18637	15304	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15304	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15304	5	See	See	NNP
18637	15304	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15304	7	Article	Article	NNP
18637	15304	8	I	I	NNP
18637	15304	9	,	,	,
18637	15304	10	Section	Section	NNP
18637	15304	11	III	III	NNP
18637	15304	12	,	,	,
18637	15304	13	Paragraph	Paragraph	NNP
18637	15304	14	1	1	CD
18637	15304	15	;	;	:
18637	15304	16	Section	Section	NNP
18637	15304	17	IV	IV	NNP
18637	15304	18	,	,	,
18637	15304	19	Paragraph	Paragraph	NNP
18637	15304	20	1	1	CD
18637	15304	21	;	;	:
18637	15304	22	Section	section	NN
18637	15304	23	X	X	NNS
18637	15304	24	;	;	:
18637	15304	25	Article	Article	NNP
18637	15304	26	II	ii	CD
18637	15304	27	,	,	,
18637	15304	28	Section	Section	NNP
18637	15304	29	I	I	NNP
18637	15304	30	,	,	,
18637	15304	31	Paragraph	Paragraph	NNP
18637	15304	32	2	2	CD
18637	15304	33	;	;	:
18637	15304	34	Article	article	NN
18637	15304	35	III	iii	CD
18637	15304	36	,	,	,
18637	15304	37	Section	Section	NNP
18637	15304	38	II	II	NNP
18637	15304	39	,	,	,
18637	15304	40	Paragraph	Paragraph	NNP
18637	15304	41	2	2	CD
18637	15304	42	;	;	:
18637	15304	43	Article	Article	NNP
18637	15304	44	IV	IV	NNP
18637	15304	45	,	,	,
18637	15304	46	Sections	Sections	NNP
18637	15304	47	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15304	48	and	and	CC
18637	15304	49	II	ii	CD
18637	15304	50	;	;	:
18637	15304	51	Article	article	NN
18637	15304	52	V	v	NN
18637	15304	53	;	;	:
18637	15304	54	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	15304	55	XIII	XIII	NNP
18637	15304	56	,	,	,
18637	15304	57	XIV	xiv	NN
18637	15304	58	,	,	,
18637	15304	59	XV	XV	NNP
18637	15304	60	,	,	,
18637	15304	61	XVII	XVII	NNP
18637	15304	62	,	,	,
18637	15304	63	and	and	CC
18637	15304	64	XIX	XIX	NNP
18637	15304	65	.	.	.
18637	15305	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15305	2	111	111	CD
18637	15305	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15305	4	1	1	CD
18637	15305	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	15305	6	.	.	.
18637	15306	1	73	73	CD
18637	15306	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15306	3	1789	1789	CD
18637	15306	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15306	5	.	.	.
18637	15307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15307	2	112	112	CD
18637	15307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15307	4	5	5	CD
18637	15307	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	15307	6	.	.	.
18637	15308	1	322	322	CD
18637	15308	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15308	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	15308	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15308	5	.	.	.
18637	15309	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15309	2	113	113	CD
18637	15309	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15309	4	1	1	CD
18637	15309	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	15309	6	.	.	.
18637	15310	1	302	302	CD
18637	15310	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15310	3	1793	1793	CD
18637	15310	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15310	5	.	.	.
18637	15311	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15311	2	114	114	CD
18637	15311	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15311	4	2	2	CD
18637	15311	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	15311	6	.	.	.
18637	15312	1	404	404	CD
18637	15312	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15312	3	1806	1806	CD
18637	15312	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15312	5	.	.	.
18637	15313	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15313	2	115	115	CD
18637	15313	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15313	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15313	5	See	See	NNP
18637	15313	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15313	7	2	2	CD
18637	15313	8	Kent	Kent	NNP
18637	15313	9	's	's	POS
18637	15313	10	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	15313	11	,	,	,
18637	15313	12	64	64	CD
18637	15313	13	-	-	SYM
18637	15313	14	65	65	CD
18637	15313	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15313	16	1826	1826	CD
18637	15313	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15313	18	;	;	:
18637	15313	19	34	34	CD
18637	15313	20	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	15313	21	.	.	.
18637	15314	1	590	590	CD
18637	15314	2	,	,	,
18637	15314	3	602	602	CD
18637	15314	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15314	5	1906	1906	CD
18637	15314	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15314	7	;	;	:
18637	15314	8	8	8	CD
18637	15314	9	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	15315	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	15315	2	357	357	CD
18637	15315	3	,	,	,
18637	15315	4	379	379	CD
18637	15315	5	;	;	SYM
18637	15315	6	18	18	CD
18637	15315	7	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	15315	8	.	.	.
18637	15316	1	§	§	NNP
18637	15316	2	135	135	CD
18637	15316	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15316	4	1934	1934	CD
18637	15316	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15316	6	;	;	:
18637	15316	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15316	8	also	also	RB
18637	15316	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15316	10	Holmgren	Holmgren	NNP
18637	15316	11	_	_	NNP
18637	15316	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	15316	13	_	_	NNP
18637	15316	14	United	United	NNP
18637	15316	15	States	States	NNP
18637	15316	16	,	,	,
18637	15316	17	217	217	CD
18637	15316	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15316	19	509	509	CD
18637	15316	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15316	21	1910	1910	CD
18637	15316	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15316	23	.	.	.
18637	15317	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15317	2	116	116	CD
18637	15317	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15317	4	For	for	IN
18637	15317	5	the	the	DT
18637	15317	6	development	development	NN
18637	15317	7	of	of	IN
18637	15317	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15317	9	especially	especially	RB
18637	15317	10	on	on	IN
18637	15317	11	the	the	DT
18637	15317	12	part	part	NN
18637	15317	13	of	of	IN
18637	15317	14	State	State	NNP
18637	15317	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	15317	16	,	,	,
18637	15317	17	adverse	adverse	RB
18637	15317	18	to	to	IN
18637	15317	19	the	the	DT
18637	15317	20	validity	validity	NN
18637	15317	21	of	of	IN
18637	15317	22	the	the	DT
18637	15317	23	above	above	RB
18637	15317	24	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	15317	25	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15317	26	,	,	,
18637	15317	27	_	_	NNP
18637	15317	28	see	see	VBP
18637	15317	29	_	_	NNP
18637	15317	30	1	1	CD
18637	15317	31	Kent	Kent	NNP
18637	15317	32	's	's	POS
18637	15317	33	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	15317	34	,	,	,
18637	15317	35	396	396	CD
18637	15317	36	-	-	SYM
18637	15317	37	404	404	CD
18637	15317	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15317	39	1826	1826	CD
18637	15317	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15317	41	.	.	.
18637	15318	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15318	2	117	117	CD
18637	15318	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15318	4	16	16	CD
18637	15318	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	15318	6	.	.	.
18637	15319	1	539	539	CD
18637	15319	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15319	3	1842	1842	CD
18637	15319	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15319	5	.	.	.
18637	15320	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15320	2	118	118	CD
18637	15320	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15320	4	24	24	CD
18637	15320	5	How	how	WRB
18637	15320	6	.	.	.
18637	15321	1	66	66	CD
18637	15321	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15321	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	15321	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15321	5	.	.	.
18637	15322	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15322	2	119	119	CD
18637	15322	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15322	4	16	16	CD
18637	15322	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	15322	6	.	.	.
18637	15323	1	at	at	IN
18637	15323	2	622	622	CD
18637	15323	3	.	.	.
18637	15324	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15324	2	120	120	CD
18637	15324	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15324	4	24	24	CD
18637	15324	5	How	how	WRB
18637	15324	6	.	.	.
18637	15325	1	at	at	IN
18637	15325	2	107	107	CD
18637	15325	3	-	-	SYM
18637	15325	4	108	108	CD
18637	15325	5	.	.	.
18637	15326	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15326	2	121	121	CD
18637	15326	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15326	4	100	100	CD
18637	15326	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15326	6	371	371	CD
18637	15326	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15326	8	1880	1880	CD
18637	15326	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15326	10	.	.	.
18637	15327	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15327	2	122	122	CD
18637	15327	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15327	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15327	5	.	.	.
18637	15328	1	392	392	CD
18637	15328	2	.	.	.
18637	15329	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15329	2	123	123	CD
18637	15329	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15329	4	Claflin	Claflin	NNP
18637	15329	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15329	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15329	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15329	8	Houseman	Houseman	NNP
18637	15329	9	,	,	,
18637	15329	10	93	93	CD
18637	15329	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15329	12	130	130	CD
18637	15329	13	,	,	,
18637	15329	14	136	136	CD
18637	15329	15	,	,	,
18637	15329	16	137	137	CD
18637	15329	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15329	18	1876	1876	CD
18637	15329	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15329	20	;	;	:
18637	15329	21	followed	follow	VBN
18637	15329	22	in	in	IN
18637	15329	23	Second	Second	NNP
18637	15329	24	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	15329	25	'	'	POS
18637	15329	26	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	15329	27	Cases	case	NNS
18637	15329	28	,	,	,
18637	15329	29	223	223	CD
18637	15329	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15329	31	1	1	CD
18637	15329	32	,	,	,
18637	15329	33	55	55	CD
18637	15329	34	-	-	SYM
18637	15329	35	59	59	CD
18637	15329	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15329	37	1912	1912	CD
18637	15329	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15329	39	.	.	.
18637	15330	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15330	2	124	124	CD
18637	15330	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15330	4	40	40	CD
18637	15330	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	15330	6	.	.	.
18637	15331	1	76	76	CD
18637	15331	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15331	3	1917	1917	CD
18637	15331	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15331	5	.	.	.
18637	15332	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15332	2	125	125	CD
18637	15332	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15332	4	Jane	Jane	NNP
18637	15332	5	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	15332	6	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	15332	7	,	,	,
18637	15332	8	The	the	DT
18637	15332	9	Rise	rise	NN
18637	15332	10	of	of	IN
18637	15332	11	a	a	DT
18637	15332	12	New	New	NNP
18637	15332	13	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	15332	14	,	,	,
18637	15332	15	91	91	CD
18637	15332	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15332	17	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	15332	18	University	University	NNP
18637	15332	19	Press	Press	NNP
18637	15332	20	,	,	,
18637	15332	21	1938	1938	CD
18637	15332	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15332	23	.	.	.
18637	15333	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15333	2	126	126	CD
18637	15333	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15333	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15333	5	See	See	NNP
18637	15333	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15333	7	James	James	NNP
18637	15333	8	Hart	Hart	NNP
18637	15333	9	in	in	IN
18637	15333	10	13	13	CD
18637	15333	11	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	15333	12	Law	Law	NNP
18637	15333	13	Review	Review	NNP
18637	15333	14	,	,	,
18637	15333	15	86	86	CD
18637	15333	16	-	-	SYM
18637	15333	17	107	107	CD
18637	15333	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15333	19	1926	1926	CD
18637	15333	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15333	21	discussing	discuss	VBG
18637	15333	22	President	President	NNP
18637	15333	23	Coolidge	Coolidge	NNP
18637	15333	24	's	's	POS
18637	15333	25	order	order	NN
18637	15333	26	of	of	IN
18637	15333	27	May	May	NNP
18637	15333	28	8	8	CD
18637	15333	29	,	,	,
18637	15333	30	1926	1926	CD
18637	15333	31	,	,	,
18637	15333	32	for	for	IN
18637	15333	33	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	15333	34	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	15333	35	.	.	.
18637	15334	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15334	2	127	127	CD
18637	15334	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15334	4	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	15334	5	,	,	,
18637	15334	6	New	New	NNP
18637	15334	7	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	15334	8	,	,	,
18637	15334	9	cited	cite	VBD
18637	15334	10	in	in	IN
18637	15334	11	note	note	NN
18637	15334	12	2	2	CD
18637	15334	13	above	above	RB
18637	15334	14	;	;	:
18637	15334	15	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15334	16	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	15334	17	's	's	POS
18637	15334	18	Note	note	NN
18637	15334	19	:	:	:
18637	15334	20	Reference	reference	NN
18637	15334	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	15334	22	to	to	IN
18637	15334	23	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	15334	24	125	125	CD
18637	15334	25	,	,	,
18637	15334	26	above	above	RB
18637	15334	27	.	.	.
18637	15334	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15335	1	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	15335	2	,	,	,
18637	15335	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15335	4	Over	over	IN
18637	15335	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15335	6	,	,	,
18637	15335	7	148	148	CD
18637	15335	8	-	-	SYM
18637	15335	9	168	168	CD
18637	15335	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15335	11	Princeton	Princeton	NNP
18637	15335	12	University	University	NNP
18637	15335	13	Press	Press	NNP
18637	15335	14	,	,	,
18637	15335	15	1938	1938	CD
18637	15335	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15335	17	.	.	.
18637	15336	1	ARTICLE	article	NN
18637	15336	2	VII	vii	NN
18637	15336	3	RATIFICATION	ratification	NN
18637	15336	4	Article	article	NN
18637	15336	5	VII	vii	NN
18637	15336	6	The	the	DT
18637	15336	7	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	15336	8	of	of	IN
18637	15336	9	the	the	DT
18637	15336	10	Conventions	Conventions	NNPS
18637	15336	11	of	of	IN
18637	15336	12	nine	nine	CD
18637	15336	13	States	States	NNPS
18637	15336	14	,	,	,
18637	15336	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	15336	16	be	be	VB
18637	15336	17	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	15336	18	for	for	IN
18637	15336	19	the	the	DT
18637	15336	20	Establishment	Establishment	NNP
18637	15336	21	of	of	IN
18637	15336	22	this	this	DT
18637	15336	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15336	24	between	between	IN
18637	15336	25	the	the	DT
18637	15336	26	States	States	NNP
18637	15336	27	so	so	RB
18637	15336	28	ratifying	ratify	VBG
18637	15336	29	the	the	DT
18637	15336	30	Same	same	JJ
18637	15336	31	.	.	.
18637	15337	1	IN	in	IN
18637	15337	2	GENERAL	GENERAL	NNP
18637	15337	3	In	in	IN
18637	15337	4	Owings	Owings	NNP
18637	15337	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15337	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15337	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15337	8	Speed,[1	Speed,[1	NNP
18637	15337	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15337	10	the	the	DT
18637	15337	11	question	question	NN
18637	15337	12	at	at	IN
18637	15337	13	issue	issue	NN
18637	15337	14	was	be	VBD
18637	15337	15	whether	whether	IN
18637	15337	16	the	the	DT
18637	15337	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15337	18	of	of	IN
18637	15337	19	the	the	DT
18637	15337	20	United	United	NNP
18637	15337	21	States	States	NNP
18637	15337	22	operated	operate	VBD
18637	15337	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	15337	24	an	an	DT
18637	15337	25	act	act	NN
18637	15337	26	of	of	IN
18637	15337	27	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	15337	28	passed	pass	VBD
18637	15337	29	in	in	IN
18637	15337	30	1788	1788	CD
18637	15337	31	.	.	.
18637	15338	1	The	the	DT
18637	15338	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15338	3	held	hold	VBD
18637	15338	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15338	5	did	do	VBD
18637	15338	6	not	not	RB
18637	15338	7	,	,	,
18637	15338	8	stating	state	VBG
18637	15338	9	in	in	IN
18637	15338	10	part	part	NN
18637	15338	11	:	:	:
18637	15338	12	"	"	``
18637	15338	13	The	the	DT
18637	15338	14	Conventions	Conventions	NNPS
18637	15338	15	of	of	IN
18637	15338	16	nine	nine	CD
18637	15338	17	States	States	NNPS
18637	15338	18	having	have	VBG
18637	15338	19	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	15338	20	the	the	DT
18637	15338	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15338	22	,	,	,
18637	15338	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15338	24	,	,	,
18637	15338	25	in	in	IN
18637	15338	26	September	September	NNP
18637	15338	27	or	or	CC
18637	15338	28	October	October	NNP
18637	15338	29	,	,	,
18637	15338	30	1788	1788	CD
18637	15338	31	,	,	,
18637	15338	32	passed	pass	VBD
18637	15338	33	a	a	DT
18637	15338	34	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	15338	35	in	in	IN
18637	15338	36	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	15338	37	with	with	IN
18637	15338	38	the	the	DT
18637	15338	39	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	15338	40	expressed	express	VBN
18637	15338	41	by	by	IN
18637	15338	42	the	the	DT
18637	15338	43	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	15338	44	,	,	,
18637	15338	45	and	and	CC
18637	15338	46	appointed	appoint	VBD
18637	15338	47	the	the	DT
18637	15338	48	first	first	JJ
18637	15338	49	Wednesday	Wednesday	NNP
18637	15338	50	in	in	IN
18637	15338	51	March	March	NNP
18637	15338	52	of	of	IN
18637	15338	53	the	the	DT
18637	15338	54	ensuing	ensue	VBG
18637	15338	55	year	year	NN
18637	15338	56	as	as	IN
18637	15338	57	the	the	DT
18637	15338	58	day	day	NN
18637	15338	59	,	,	,
18637	15338	60	and	and	CC
18637	15338	61	the	the	DT
18637	15338	62	then	then	RB
18637	15338	63	seat	seat	NN
18637	15338	64	of	of	IN
18637	15338	65	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15338	66	as	as	IN
18637	15338	67	the	the	DT
18637	15338	68	place	place	NN
18637	15338	69	,	,	,
18637	15338	70	'	'	''
18637	15338	71	for	for	IN
18637	15338	72	commencing	commence	VBG
18637	15338	73	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	15338	74	under	under	IN
18637	15338	75	the	the	DT
18637	15338	76	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15338	77	.	.	.
18637	15338	78	'	'	''
18637	15339	1	"	"	``
18637	15339	2	Both	both	DT
18637	15339	3	Governments	government	NNS
18637	15339	4	could	could	MD
18637	15339	5	not	not	RB
18637	15339	6	be	be	VB
18637	15339	7	understood	understand	VBN
18637	15339	8	to	to	TO
18637	15339	9	exist	exist	VB
18637	15339	10	at	at	IN
18637	15339	11	the	the	DT
18637	15339	12	same	same	JJ
18637	15339	13	time	time	NN
18637	15339	14	.	.	.
18637	15340	1	The	the	DT
18637	15340	2	new	new	JJ
18637	15340	3	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15340	4	did	do	VBD
18637	15340	5	not	not	RB
18637	15340	6	commence	commence	VB
18637	15340	7	until	until	IN
18637	15340	8	the	the	DT
18637	15340	9	old	old	JJ
18637	15340	10	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15340	11	expired	expire	VBD
18637	15340	12	.	.	.
18637	15341	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15341	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15341	3	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	15341	4	that	that	IN
18637	15341	5	the	the	DT
18637	15341	6	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15341	7	did	do	VBD
18637	15341	8	not	not	RB
18637	15341	9	commence	commence	VB
18637	15341	10	on	on	IN
18637	15341	11	the	the	DT
18637	15341	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15341	13	being	be	VBG
18637	15341	14	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	15341	15	by	by	IN
18637	15341	16	the	the	DT
18637	15341	17	ninth	ninth	JJ
18637	15341	18	State	State	NNP
18637	15341	19	;	;	:
18637	15341	20	for	for	IN
18637	15341	21	these	these	DT
18637	15341	22	ratifications	ratification	NNS
18637	15341	23	were	be	VBD
18637	15341	24	to	to	TO
18637	15341	25	be	be	VB
18637	15341	26	reported	report	VBN
18637	15341	27	to	to	IN
18637	15341	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15341	29	,	,	,
18637	15341	30	whose	whose	WP$
18637	15341	31	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	15341	32	existence	existence	NN
18637	15341	33	was	be	VBD
18637	15341	34	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	15341	35	by	by	IN
18637	15341	36	the	the	DT
18637	15341	37	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	15341	38	,	,	,
18637	15341	39	and	and	CC
18637	15341	40	who	who	WP
18637	15341	41	were	be	VBD
18637	15341	42	requested	request	VBN
18637	15341	43	to	to	TO
18637	15341	44	continue	continue	VB
18637	15341	45	to	to	TO
18637	15341	46	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	15341	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15341	48	powers	power	NNS
18637	15341	49	for	for	IN
18637	15341	50	the	the	DT
18637	15341	51	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15341	52	of	of	IN
18637	15341	53	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	15341	54	the	the	DT
18637	15341	55	new	new	JJ
18637	15341	56	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15341	57	into	into	IN
18637	15341	58	operation	operation	NN
18637	15341	59	.	.	.
18637	15342	1	In	in	IN
18637	15342	2	fact	fact	NN
18637	15342	3	,	,	,
18637	15342	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15342	5	did	do	VBD
18637	15342	6	continue	continue	VB
18637	15342	7	to	to	TO
18637	15342	8	act	act	VB
18637	15342	9	as	as	IN
18637	15342	10	a	a	DT
18637	15342	11	Government	government	NN
18637	15342	12	until	until	IN
18637	15342	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15342	14	dissolved	dissolve	VBD
18637	15342	15	on	on	IN
18637	15342	16	the	the	DT
18637	15342	17	1st	1st	NN
18637	15342	18	of	of	IN
18637	15342	19	November	November	NNP
18637	15342	20	,	,	,
18637	15342	21	by	by	IN
18637	15342	22	the	the	DT
18637	15342	23	successive	successive	JJ
18637	15342	24	disappearance	disappearance	NN
18637	15342	25	of	of	IN
18637	15342	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15342	27	Members	member	NNS
18637	15342	28	.	.	.
18637	15343	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15343	2	existed	exist	VBD
18637	15343	3	potentially	potentially	RB
18637	15343	4	until	until	IN
18637	15343	5	the	the	DT
18637	15343	6	2d	2d	CD
18637	15343	7	of	of	IN
18637	15343	8	March	March	NNP
18637	15343	9	,	,	,
18637	15343	10	the	the	DT
18637	15343	11	day	day	NN
18637	15343	12	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	15343	13	that	that	DT
18637	15343	14	on	on	IN
18637	15343	15	which	which	WDT
18637	15343	16	the	the	DT
18637	15343	17	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	15343	18	of	of	IN
18637	15343	19	the	the	DT
18637	15343	20	new	new	JJ
18637	15343	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15343	22	were	be	VBD
18637	15343	23	directed	direct	VBN
18637	15343	24	to	to	TO
18637	15343	25	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	15343	26	.	.	.
18637	15344	1	"	"	``
18637	15344	2	The	the	DT
18637	15344	3	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	15344	4	of	of	IN
18637	15344	5	the	the	DT
18637	15344	6	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	15344	7	might	may	MD
18637	15344	8	originally	originally	RB
18637	15344	9	have	have	VB
18637	15344	10	suggested	suggest	VBN
18637	15344	11	a	a	DT
18637	15344	12	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	15344	13	,	,	,
18637	15344	14	whether	whether	IN
18637	15344	15	the	the	DT
18637	15344	16	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15344	17	could	could	MD
18637	15344	18	be	be	VB
18637	15344	19	in	in	IN
18637	15344	20	operation	operation	NN
18637	15344	21	for	for	IN
18637	15344	22	every	every	DT
18637	15344	23	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15344	24	before	before	IN
18637	15344	25	the	the	DT
18637	15344	26	choice	choice	NN
18637	15344	27	of	of	IN
18637	15344	28	a	a	DT
18637	15344	29	President	President	NNP
18637	15344	30	;	;	:
18637	15344	31	but	but	CC
18637	15344	32	this	this	DT
18637	15344	33	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	15344	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	15344	35	been	be	VBN
18637	15344	36	long	long	RB
18637	15344	37	solved	solve	VBN
18637	15344	38	,	,	,
18637	15344	39	and	and	CC
18637	15344	40	were	be	VBD
18637	15344	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15344	42	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	15344	43	,	,	,
18637	15344	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15344	45	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	15344	46	would	would	MD
18637	15344	47	be	be	VB
18637	15344	48	useless	useless	JJ
18637	15344	49	,	,	,
18637	15344	50	since	since	IN
18637	15344	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15344	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	15344	53	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	15344	54	that	that	IN
18637	15344	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15344	56	operation	operation	NN
18637	15344	57	did	do	VBD
18637	15344	58	not	not	RB
18637	15344	59	commence	commence	VB
18637	15344	60	before	before	IN
18637	15344	61	the	the	DT
18637	15344	62	first	first	JJ
18637	15344	63	Wednesday	Wednesday	NNP
18637	15344	64	in	in	IN
18637	15344	65	March	March	NNP
18637	15344	66	1789	1789	CD
18637	15344	67	*	*	NFP
18637	15344	68	*	*	NFP
18637	15344	69	*	*	NFP
18637	15344	70	"	"	``
18637	15344	71	Notes	note	NNS
18637	15344	72	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15344	73	1	1	CD
18637	15344	74	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15344	75	5	5	CD
18637	15344	76	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	15344	77	.	.	.
18637	15345	1	420	420	CD
18637	15345	2	,	,	,
18637	15345	3	422	422	CD
18637	15345	4	-	-	SYM
18637	15345	5	423	423	CD
18637	15345	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15345	7	1820	1820	CD
18637	15345	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15345	9	.	.	.
18637	15346	1	AMENDMENTS	amendment	NNS
18637	15346	2	TO	to	IN
18637	15346	3	THE	the	DT
18637	15346	4	CONSTITUTION	CONSTITUTION	NNP
18637	15346	5	AMENDMENTS	AMENDMENTS	NNP
18637	15346	6	NOS	NOS	NNP
18637	15346	7	.	.	.
18637	15347	1	1	1	CD
18637	15347	2	-	-	SYM
18637	15347	3	10	10	CD
18637	15347	4	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	15347	5	of	of	IN
18637	15347	6	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	15347	7	Page	Page	NNP
18637	15347	8	History	history	NN
18637	15347	9	749	749	CD
18637	15347	10	Ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	15347	11	of	of	IN
18637	15347	12	1787	1787	CD
18637	15347	13	749	749	CD
18637	15347	14	Formulation	Formulation	NNP
18637	15347	15	and	and	CC
18637	15347	16	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	15347	17	of	of	IN
18637	15347	18	the	the	DT
18637	15347	19	bill	bill	NN
18637	15347	20	of	of	IN
18637	15347	21	rights	right	NNS
18637	15347	22	750	750	CD
18637	15347	23	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	15347	24	of	of	IN
18637	15347	25	rights	right	NNS
18637	15347	26	and	and	CC
18637	15347	27	the	the	DT
18637	15347	28	States	States	NNPS
18637	15347	29	:	:	:
18637	15347	30	Barron	Barron	NNP
18637	15347	31	_	_	NNP
18637	15347	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	15347	33	_	_	NNP
18637	15347	34	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	15347	35	750	750	CD
18637	15347	36	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	15347	37	of	of	IN
18637	15347	38	rights	right	NNS
18637	15347	39	and	and	CC
18637	15347	40	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15347	41	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	15347	42	750	750	CD
18637	15347	43	AMENDMENTS	amendment	NNS
18637	15347	44	TO	to	IN
18637	15347	45	THE	the	DT
18637	15347	46	CONSTITUTION	CONSTITUTION	NNP
18637	15347	47	AMENDMENTS	AMENDMENTS	NNP
18637	15347	48	NOS	NOS	NNP
18637	15347	49	.	.	.
18637	15348	1	1	1	CD
18637	15348	2	-	-	SYM
18637	15348	3	10	10	CD
18637	15348	4	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	15348	5	of	of	IN
18637	15348	6	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	15348	7	HISTORY	HISTORY	NNP
18637	15348	8	:	:	:
18637	15348	9	THE	the	DT
18637	15348	10	ORDINANCE	ordinance	NN
18637	15348	11	OF	of	IN
18637	15348	12	1787	1787	CD
18637	15348	13	While	while	IN
18637	15348	14	the	the	DT
18637	15348	15	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	15348	16	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	15348	17	was	be	VBD
18637	15348	18	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	15348	19	in	in	IN
18637	15348	20	drafting	draft	VBG
18637	15348	21	the	the	DT
18637	15348	22	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15348	23	,	,	,
18637	15348	24	the	the	DT
18637	15348	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15348	26	of	of	IN
18637	15348	27	the	the	DT
18637	15348	28	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	15348	29	included	include	VBD
18637	15348	30	in	in	IN
18637	15348	31	the	the	DT
18637	15348	32	Ordinance	Ordinance	NNP
18637	15348	33	for	for	IN
18637	15348	34	the	the	DT
18637	15348	35	government	government	NN
18637	15348	36	of	of	IN
18637	15348	37	the	the	DT
18637	15348	38	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	15348	39	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	15348	40	,	,	,
18637	15348	41	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	15348	42	July	July	NNP
18637	15348	43	13	13	CD
18637	15348	44	,	,	,
18637	15348	45	1787	1787	CD
18637	15348	46	,	,	,
18637	15348	47	the	the	DT
18637	15348	48	following	follow	VBG
18637	15348	49	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	15348	50	:	:	:
18637	15348	51	"	"	``
18637	15348	52	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15348	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	15348	54	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	15348	55	ordained	ordain	VBN
18637	15348	56	and	and	CC
18637	15348	57	declared	declare	VBN
18637	15348	58	by	by	IN
18637	15348	59	the	the	DT
18637	15348	60	authority	authority	NN
18637	15348	61	aforesaid	aforesaid	VBD
18637	15348	62	,	,	,
18637	15348	63	that	that	IN
18637	15348	64	the	the	DT
18637	15348	65	following	follow	VBG
18637	15348	66	articles	article	NNS
18637	15348	67	shall	shall	MD
18637	15348	68	be	be	VB
18637	15348	69	considered	consider	VBN
18637	15348	70	as	as	IN
18637	15348	71	articles	article	NNS
18637	15348	72	of	of	IN
18637	15348	73	compact	compact	JJ
18637	15348	74	between	between	IN
18637	15348	75	the	the	DT
18637	15348	76	original	original	JJ
18637	15348	77	States	States	NNPS
18637	15348	78	and	and	CC
18637	15348	79	the	the	DT
18637	15348	80	people	people	NNS
18637	15348	81	and	and	CC
18637	15348	82	States	States	NNPS
18637	15348	83	in	in	IN
18637	15348	84	the	the	DT
18637	15348	85	said	say	VBN
18637	15348	86	territory	territory	NN
18637	15348	87	and	and	CC
18637	15348	88	forever	forever	RB
18637	15348	89	remain	remain	VBP
18637	15348	90	unalterable	unalterable	JJ
18637	15348	91	,	,	,
18637	15348	92	unless	unless	IN
18637	15348	93	by	by	IN
18637	15348	94	common	common	JJ
18637	15348	95	consent	consent	NN
18637	15348	96	,	,	,
18637	15348	97	to	to	IN
18637	15348	98	wit	wit	NN
18637	15348	99	:	:	:
18637	15348	100	"	"	``
18637	15348	101	Art	art	NN
18637	15348	102	.	.	.
18637	15349	1	1	1	LS
18637	15349	2	.	.	.
18637	15350	1	No	no	DT
18637	15350	2	person	person	NN
18637	15350	3	,	,	,
18637	15350	4	demeaning	demean	VBG
18637	15350	5	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15350	6	in	in	IN
18637	15350	7	a	a	DT
18637	15350	8	peaceable	peaceable	JJ
18637	15350	9	and	and	CC
18637	15350	10	orderly	orderly	JJ
18637	15350	11	manner	manner	NN
18637	15350	12	,	,	,
18637	15350	13	shall	shall	MD
18637	15350	14	ever	ever	RB
18637	15350	15	be	be	VB
18637	15350	16	molested	molest	VBN
18637	15350	17	on	on	IN
18637	15350	18	account	account	NN
18637	15350	19	of	of	IN
18637	15350	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15350	21	mode	mode	NN
18637	15350	22	of	of	IN
18637	15350	23	worship	worship	NN
18637	15350	24	or	or	CC
18637	15350	25	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15350	26	sentiments	sentiment	NNS
18637	15350	27	,	,	,
18637	15350	28	in	in	IN
18637	15350	29	the	the	DT
18637	15350	30	said	say	VBN
18637	15350	31	territory	territory	NN
18637	15350	32	.	.	.
18637	15351	1	"	"	``
18637	15351	2	Art	art	NN
18637	15351	3	.	.	.
18637	15352	1	2	2	LS
18637	15352	2	.	.	.
18637	15353	1	The	the	DT
18637	15353	2	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	15353	3	of	of	IN
18637	15353	4	the	the	DT
18637	15353	5	said	say	VBN
18637	15353	6	territory	territory	NN
18637	15353	7	shall	shall	MD
18637	15353	8	always	always	RB
18637	15353	9	be	be	VB
18637	15353	10	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	15353	11	to	to	IN
18637	15353	12	the	the	DT
18637	15353	13	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	15353	14	of	of	IN
18637	15353	15	the	the	DT
18637	15353	16	writ	writ	NNP
18637	15353	17	of	of	IN
18637	15353	18	_	_	NNP
18637	15353	19	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	15353	20	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	15353	21	_	_	NNP
18637	15353	22	,	,	,
18637	15353	23	and	and	CC
18637	15353	24	of	of	IN
18637	15353	25	the	the	DT
18637	15353	26	trial	trial	NN
18637	15353	27	by	by	IN
18637	15353	28	jury	jury	NN
18637	15353	29	;	;	:
18637	15353	30	of	of	IN
18637	15353	31	a	a	DT
18637	15353	32	proportionate	proportionate	NN
18637	15353	33	representation	representation	NN
18637	15353	34	of	of	IN
18637	15353	35	the	the	DT
18637	15353	36	people	people	NNS
18637	15353	37	in	in	IN
18637	15353	38	the	the	DT
18637	15353	39	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	15353	40	;	;	:
18637	15353	41	and	and	CC
18637	15353	42	of	of	IN
18637	15353	43	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15353	44	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	15353	45	according	accord	VBG
18637	15353	46	to	to	IN
18637	15353	47	the	the	DT
18637	15353	48	course	course	NN
18637	15353	49	of	of	IN
18637	15353	50	the	the	DT
18637	15353	51	common	common	JJ
18637	15353	52	law	law	NN
18637	15353	53	.	.	.
18637	15354	1	All	all	DT
18637	15354	2	persons	person	NNS
18637	15354	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	15354	4	be	be	VB
18637	15354	5	bailable	bailable	JJ
18637	15354	6	,	,	,
18637	15354	7	unless	unless	IN
18637	15354	8	for	for	IN
18637	15354	9	capital	capital	NN
18637	15354	10	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	15354	11	,	,	,
18637	15354	12	where	where	WRB
18637	15354	13	the	the	DT
18637	15354	14	proof	proof	NN
18637	15354	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	15354	16	be	be	VB
18637	15354	17	evident	evident	JJ
18637	15354	18	or	or	CC
18637	15354	19	the	the	DT
18637	15354	20	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	15354	21	great	great	JJ
18637	15354	22	.	.	.
18637	15355	1	All	all	DT
18637	15355	2	fines	fine	NNS
18637	15355	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	15355	4	be	be	VB
18637	15355	5	moderate	moderate	JJ
18637	15355	6	;	;	:
18637	15355	7	and	and	CC
18637	15355	8	no	no	DT
18637	15355	9	cruel	cruel	JJ
18637	15355	10	or	or	CC
18637	15355	11	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	15355	12	punishments	punishment	NNS
18637	15355	13	shall	shall	MD
18637	15355	14	be	be	VB
18637	15355	15	inflicted	inflict	VBN
18637	15355	16	.	.	.
18637	15356	1	No	no	DT
18637	15356	2	man	man	NN
18637	15356	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	15356	4	be	be	VB
18637	15356	5	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	15356	6	of	of	IN
18637	15356	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15356	8	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15356	9	or	or	CC
18637	15356	10	property	property	NN
18637	15356	11	,	,	,
18637	15356	12	but	but	CC
18637	15356	13	by	by	IN
18637	15356	14	the	the	DT
18637	15356	15	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	15356	16	of	of	IN
18637	15356	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15356	18	peers	peer	NNS
18637	15356	19	or	or	CC
18637	15356	20	the	the	DT
18637	15356	21	law	law	NN
18637	15356	22	of	of	IN
18637	15356	23	the	the	DT
18637	15356	24	land	land	NN
18637	15356	25	;	;	,
18637	15356	26	and	and	CC
18637	15356	27	,	,	,
18637	15356	28	should	should	MD
18637	15356	29	the	the	DT
18637	15356	30	public	public	JJ
18637	15356	31	exigencies	exigency	NNS
18637	15356	32	make	make	VBP
18637	15356	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15356	34	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	15356	35	,	,	,
18637	15356	36	for	for	IN
18637	15356	37	the	the	DT
18637	15356	38	common	common	JJ
18637	15356	39	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	15356	40	,	,	,
18637	15356	41	to	to	TO
18637	15356	42	take	take	VB
18637	15356	43	any	any	DT
18637	15356	44	person	person	NN
18637	15356	45	's	's	POS
18637	15356	46	property	property	NN
18637	15356	47	,	,	,
18637	15356	48	or	or	CC
18637	15356	49	to	to	TO
18637	15356	50	demand	demand	VB
18637	15356	51	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15356	52	particular	particular	JJ
18637	15356	53	services	service	NNS
18637	15356	54	,	,	,
18637	15356	55	full	full	JJ
18637	15356	56	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	15356	57	shall	shall	MD
18637	15356	58	be	be	VB
18637	15356	59	made	make	VBN
18637	15356	60	for	for	IN
18637	15356	61	the	the	DT
18637	15356	62	same	same	JJ
18637	15356	63	.	.	.
18637	15357	1	And	and	CC
18637	15357	2	,	,	,
18637	15357	3	in	in	IN
18637	15357	4	the	the	DT
18637	15357	5	just	just	JJ
18637	15357	6	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	15357	7	of	of	IN
18637	15357	8	rights	right	NNS
18637	15357	9	and	and	CC
18637	15357	10	property	property	NN
18637	15357	11	,	,	,
18637	15357	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15357	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	15357	14	understood	understand	VBN
18637	15357	15	and	and	CC
18637	15357	16	declared	declare	VBD
18637	15357	17	,	,	,
18637	15357	18	that	that	IN
18637	15357	19	no	no	DT
18637	15357	20	law	law	NN
18637	15357	21	ought	ought	MD
18637	15357	22	ever	ever	RB
18637	15357	23	to	to	TO
18637	15357	24	be	be	VB
18637	15357	25	made	make	VBN
18637	15357	26	,	,	,
18637	15357	27	or	or	CC
18637	15357	28	have	have	VB
18637	15357	29	force	force	NN
18637	15357	30	in	in	IN
18637	15357	31	the	the	DT
18637	15357	32	said	say	VBN
18637	15357	33	territory	territory	NN
18637	15357	34	,	,	,
18637	15357	35	that	that	DT
18637	15357	36	shall	shall	MD
18637	15357	37	,	,	,
18637	15357	38	in	in	IN
18637	15357	39	any	any	DT
18637	15357	40	manner	manner	NN
18637	15357	41	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	15357	42	,	,	,
18637	15357	43	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	15357	44	with	with	IN
18637	15357	45	or	or	CC
18637	15357	46	affect	affect	VB
18637	15357	47	private	private	JJ
18637	15357	48	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	15357	49	or	or	CC
18637	15357	50	engagements	engagement	NNS
18637	15357	51	,	,	,
18637	15357	52	_	_	NNP
18637	15357	53	bona	bona	NN
18637	15357	54	fide	fide	JJ
18637	15357	55	_	_	NNP
18637	15357	56	,	,	,
18637	15357	57	and	and	CC
18637	15357	58	without	without	IN
18637	15357	59	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	15357	60	,	,	,
18637	15357	61	previously	previously	RB
18637	15357	62	formed	form	VBN
18637	15357	63	.	.	.
18637	15358	1	"	"	``
18637	15358	2	Art	art	NN
18637	15358	3	.	.	.
18637	15359	1	3	3	LS
18637	15359	2	.	.	.
18637	15360	1	Religion	religion	NN
18637	15360	2	,	,	,
18637	15360	3	morality	morality	NN
18637	15360	4	,	,	,
18637	15360	5	and	and	CC
18637	15360	6	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	15360	7	,	,	,
18637	15360	8	being	be	VBG
18637	15360	9	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	15360	10	to	to	IN
18637	15360	11	good	good	JJ
18637	15360	12	government	government	NN
18637	15360	13	and	and	CC
18637	15360	14	the	the	DT
18637	15360	15	happiness	happiness	NN
18637	15360	16	of	of	IN
18637	15360	17	mankind	mankind	NN
18637	15360	18	,	,	,
18637	15360	19	schools	school	NNS
18637	15360	20	and	and	CC
18637	15360	21	the	the	DT
18637	15360	22	means	mean	NNS
18637	15360	23	of	of	IN
18637	15360	24	education	education	NN
18637	15360	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	15360	26	forever	forever	RB
18637	15360	27	be	be	VB
18637	15360	28	encouraged	encourage	VBN
18637	15360	29	.	.	.
18637	15361	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15361	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15361	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15361	4	*	*	NFP
18637	15361	5	*	*	NFP
18637	15361	6	"	"	``
18637	15361	7	Art	art	NN
18637	15361	8	.	.	.
18637	15362	1	6	6	CD
18637	15362	2	.	.	.
18637	15363	1	There	there	EX
18637	15363	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	15363	3	be	be	VB
18637	15363	4	neither	neither	CC
18637	15363	5	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	15363	6	nor	nor	CC
18637	15363	7	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	15363	8	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	15363	9	in	in	IN
18637	15363	10	the	the	DT
18637	15363	11	said	say	VBN
18637	15363	12	territory	territory	NN
18637	15363	13	,	,	,
18637	15363	14	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	15363	15	than	than	IN
18637	15363	16	in	in	IN
18637	15363	17	the	the	DT
18637	15363	18	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15363	19	of	of	IN
18637	15363	20	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	15363	21	whereof	whereof	IN
18637	15363	22	the	the	DT
18637	15363	23	party	party	NN
18637	15363	24	shall	shall	MD
18637	15363	25	have	have	VB
18637	15363	26	been	be	VBN
18637	15363	27	duly	duly	RB
18637	15363	28	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	15363	29	:	:	:
18637	15363	30	*	*	NFP
18637	15363	31	*	*	NFP
18637	15363	32	*	*	NFP
18637	15363	33	"	"	''
18637	15363	34	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15363	35	1	1	CD
18637	15363	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15363	37	FORMULATION	formulation	NN
18637	15363	38	AND	and	CC
18637	15363	39	ADOPTION	adoption	NN
18637	15363	40	OF	of	IN
18637	15363	41	THE	the	DT
18637	15363	42	BILL	BILL	NNP
18637	15363	43	OF	of	IN
18637	15363	44	RIGHTS	RIGHTS	NNP
18637	15363	45	Two	two	CD
18637	15363	46	months	month	NNS
18637	15363	47	later	later	RB
18637	15363	48	,	,	,
18637	15363	49	at	at	IN
18637	15363	50	the	the	DT
18637	15363	51	very	very	JJ
18637	15363	52	end	end	NN
18637	15363	53	of	of	IN
18637	15363	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15363	55	labors	labor	NNS
18637	15363	56	,	,	,
18637	15363	57	the	the	DT
18637	15363	58	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	15363	59	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	15363	60	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	15363	61	,	,	,
18637	15363	62	with	with	IN
18637	15363	63	scant	scant	JJ
18637	15363	64	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	15363	65	,	,	,
18637	15363	66	a	a	DT
18637	15363	67	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	15363	68	by	by	IN
18637	15363	69	Gerry	Gerry	NNP
18637	15363	70	and	and	CC
18637	15363	71	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	15363	72	,	,	,
18637	15363	73	to	to	TO
18637	15363	74	prepare	prepare	VB
18637	15363	75	a	a	DT
18637	15363	76	bill	bill	NN
18637	15363	77	of	of	IN
18637	15363	78	rights	right	NNS
18637	15363	79	.	.	.
18637	15364	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15364	2	2	2	LS
18637	15364	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15364	4	This	this	DT
18637	15364	5	omission	omission	NN
18637	15364	6	furnished	furnish	VBD
18637	15364	7	the	the	DT
18637	15364	8	principal	principal	JJ
18637	15364	9	argument	argument	NN
18637	15364	10	urged	urge	VBD
18637	15364	11	against	against	IN
18637	15364	12	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	15364	13	of	of	IN
18637	15364	14	the	the	DT
18637	15364	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15364	16	.	.	.
18637	15365	1	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	15365	2	replied	reply	VBD
18637	15365	3	with	with	IN
18637	15365	4	the	the	DT
18637	15365	5	following	follow	VBG
18637	15365	6	ingenious	ingenious	JJ
18637	15365	7	argument	argument	NN
18637	15365	8	:	:	:
18637	15365	9	"	"	``
18637	15365	10	*	*	NFP
18637	15365	11	*	*	NFP
18637	15365	12	*	*	NFP
18637	15365	13	bills	bill	NNS
18637	15365	14	of	of	IN
18637	15365	15	rights	right	NNS
18637	15365	16	are	be	VBP
18637	15365	17	in	in	IN
18637	15365	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15365	19	origin	origin	NN
18637	15365	20	,	,	,
18637	15365	21	stipulations	stipulation	NNS
18637	15365	22	between	between	IN
18637	15365	23	kings	king	NNS
18637	15365	24	and	and	CC
18637	15365	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15365	26	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	15365	27	,	,	,
18637	15365	28	abridgments	abridgment	NNS
18637	15365	29	of	of	IN
18637	15365	30	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	15365	31	in	in	IN
18637	15365	32	favor	favor	NN
18637	15365	33	of	of	IN
18637	15365	34	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	15365	35	,	,	,
18637	15365	36	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	15365	37	of	of	IN
18637	15365	38	rights	right	NNS
18637	15365	39	not	not	RB
18637	15365	40	surrendered	surrender	VBN
18637	15365	41	to	to	IN
18637	15365	42	the	the	DT
18637	15365	43	prince	prince	NN
18637	15365	44	.	.	.
18637	15366	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15366	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15366	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15366	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15366	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	15366	6	evident	evident	JJ
18637	15366	7	,	,	,
18637	15366	8	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	15366	9	,	,	,
18637	15366	10	that	that	IN
18637	15366	11	according	accord	VBG
18637	15366	12	to	to	IN
18637	15366	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15366	14	primitive	primitive	JJ
18637	15366	15	signification	signification	NN
18637	15366	16	,	,	,
18637	15366	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15366	18	have	have	VBP
18637	15366	19	no	no	DT
18637	15366	20	application	application	NN
18637	15366	21	to	to	IN
18637	15366	22	the	the	DT
18637	15366	23	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	15366	24	professedly	professedly	RB
18637	15366	25	founded	found	VBN
18637	15366	26	upon	upon	IN
18637	15366	27	the	the	DT
18637	15366	28	power	power	NN
18637	15366	29	of	of	IN
18637	15366	30	the	the	DT
18637	15366	31	people	people	NNS
18637	15366	32	,	,	,
18637	15366	33	and	and	CC
18637	15366	34	executed	execute	VBN
18637	15366	35	by	by	IN
18637	15366	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15366	37	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	15366	38	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	15366	39	and	and	CC
18637	15366	40	servants	servant	NNS
18637	15366	41	.	.	.
18637	15367	1	Here	here	RB
18637	15367	2	,	,	,
18637	15367	3	in	in	IN
18637	15367	4	strictness	strictness	NN
18637	15367	5	,	,	,
18637	15367	6	the	the	DT
18637	15367	7	people	people	NNS
18637	15367	8	surrender	surrender	VBP
18637	15367	9	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	15367	10	;	;	:
18637	15367	11	and	and	CC
18637	15367	12	as	as	IN
18637	15367	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15367	14	retain	retain	VBP
18637	15367	15	everything	everything	NN
18637	15367	16	,	,	,
18637	15367	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15367	18	have	have	VBP
18637	15367	19	no	no	DT
18637	15367	20	need	need	NN
18637	15367	21	of	of	IN
18637	15367	22	particular	particular	JJ
18637	15367	23	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	15367	24	.	.	.
18637	15368	1	"	"	``
18637	15368	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15368	3	3	3	LS
18637	15368	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15368	5	The	the	DT
18637	15368	6	people	people	NNS
18637	15368	7	did	do	VBD
18637	15368	8	not	not	RB
18637	15368	9	find	find	VB
18637	15368	10	this	this	DT
18637	15368	11	line	line	NN
18637	15368	12	of	of	IN
18637	15368	13	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	15368	14	persuasive	persuasive	JJ
18637	15368	15	.	.	.
18637	15369	1	Several	several	JJ
18637	15369	2	States	state	NNS
18637	15369	3	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	15369	4	only	only	RB
18637	15369	5	after	after	IN
18637	15369	6	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	15369	7	put	put	VBD
18637	15369	8	forward	forward	RP
18637	15369	9	the	the	DT
18637	15369	10	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	15369	11	that	that	IN
18637	15369	12	the	the	DT
18637	15369	13	desired	desire	VBN
18637	15369	14	guarantees	guarantee	NNS
18637	15369	15	could	could	MD
18637	15369	16	be	be	VB
18637	15369	17	added	add	VBN
18637	15369	18	by	by	IN
18637	15369	19	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	15369	20	.	.	.
18637	15370	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15370	2	4	4	LS
18637	15370	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15370	4	No	no	RB
18637	15370	5	less	less	JJR
18637	15370	6	than	than	IN
18637	15370	7	124	124	CD
18637	15370	8	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	15370	9	were	be	VBD
18637	15370	10	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	15370	11	by	by	IN
18637	15370	12	the	the	DT
18637	15370	13	States	States	NNP
18637	15370	14	.	.	.
18637	15371	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15371	2	5	5	CD
18637	15371	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15371	4	Shortly	shortly	RB
18637	15371	5	after	after	IN
18637	15371	6	the	the	DT
18637	15371	7	First	First	NNP
18637	15371	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15371	9	convened	convene	VBD
18637	15371	10	,	,	,
18637	15371	11	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	15371	12	introduced	introduce	VBD
18637	15371	13	a	a	DT
18637	15371	14	series	series	NN
18637	15371	15	of	of	IN
18637	15371	16	amendments,[6	amendments,[6	NNP
18637	15371	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15371	18	designed	design	VBN
18637	15371	19	"	"	''
18637	15371	20	to	to	TO
18637	15371	21	quiet	quiet	VB
18637	15371	22	the	the	DT
18637	15371	23	apprehension	apprehension	NN
18637	15371	24	of	of	IN
18637	15371	25	many	many	JJ
18637	15371	26	,	,	,
18637	15371	27	that	that	IN
18637	15371	28	without	without	IN
18637	15371	29	some	some	DT
18637	15371	30	such	such	JJ
18637	15371	31	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	15371	32	of	of	IN
18637	15371	33	rights	right	NNS
18637	15371	34	the	the	DT
18637	15371	35	government	government	NN
18637	15371	36	would	would	MD
18637	15371	37	assume	assume	VB
18637	15371	38	,	,	,
18637	15371	39	and	and	CC
18637	15371	40	might	may	MD
18637	15371	41	be	be	VB
18637	15371	42	held	hold	VBN
18637	15371	43	to	to	TO
18637	15371	44	possess	possess	VB
18637	15371	45	,	,	,
18637	15371	46	the	the	DT
18637	15371	47	power	power	NN
18637	15371	48	to	to	TO
18637	15371	49	trespass	trespass	VB
18637	15371	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	15371	51	those	those	DT
18637	15371	52	rights	right	NNS
18637	15371	53	of	of	IN
18637	15371	54	persons	person	NNS
18637	15371	55	and	and	CC
18637	15371	56	property	property	NN
18637	15371	57	which	which	WDT
18637	15371	58	by	by	IN
18637	15371	59	the	the	DT
18637	15371	60	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
18637	15371	61	of	of	IN
18637	15371	62	Independence	Independence	NNP
18637	15371	63	were	be	VBD
18637	15371	64	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	15371	65	to	to	TO
18637	15371	66	be	be	VB
18637	15371	67	unalienable	unalienable	JJ
18637	15371	68	*	*	NFP
18637	15371	69	*	*	NFP
18637	15371	70	*	*	NFP
18637	15371	71	"	"	''
18637	15371	72	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15371	73	7	7	CD
18637	15371	74	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15371	75	After	after	IN
18637	15371	76	prolonged	prolonged	JJ
18637	15371	77	debate	debate	NN
18637	15371	78	seventeen	seventeen	CD
18637	15371	79	proposals	proposal	NNS
18637	15371	80	were	be	VBD
18637	15371	81	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	15371	82	by	by	IN
18637	15371	83	the	the	DT
18637	15371	84	House	House	NNP
18637	15371	85	two	two	CD
18637	15371	86	of	of	IN
18637	15371	87	which	which	WDT
18637	15371	88	were	be	VBD
18637	15371	89	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	15371	90	by	by	IN
18637	15371	91	the	the	DT
18637	15371	92	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	15371	93	.	.	.
18637	15372	1	The	the	DT
18637	15372	2	remainder	remainder	NN
18637	15372	3	were	be	VBD
18637	15372	4	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	15372	5	to	to	IN
18637	15372	6	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	15372	7	in	in	IN
18637	15372	8	number	number	NN
18637	15372	9	,	,	,
18637	15372	10	all	all	DT
18637	15372	11	but	but	IN
18637	15372	12	two	two	CD
18637	15372	13	of	of	IN
18637	15372	14	which	which	WDT
18637	15372	15	were	be	VBD
18637	15372	16	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	15372	17	by	by	IN
18637	15372	18	the	the	DT
18637	15372	19	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	15372	20	number	number	NN
18637	15372	21	of	of	IN
18637	15372	22	States	States	NNP
18637	15372	23	.	.	.
18637	15373	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15373	2	8	8	LS
18637	15373	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15373	4	THE	the	DT
18637	15373	5	BILL	BILL	NNP
18637	15373	6	OF	of	IN
18637	15373	7	RIGHTS	RIGHTS	NNP
18637	15373	8	AND	and	CC
18637	15373	9	THE	the	DT
18637	15373	10	STATES	state	NNS
18637	15373	11	:	:	:
18637	15373	12	BARRON	BARRON	NNP
18637	15373	13	_	_	NNP
18637	15373	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	15373	15	_	_	NNP
18637	15373	16	BALTIMORE	BALTIMORE	NNP
18637	15373	17	One	one	CD
18637	15373	18	of	of	IN
18637	15373	19	the	the	DT
18637	15373	20	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	15373	21	which	which	WDT
18637	15373	22	the	the	DT
18637	15373	23	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	15373	24	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	15373	25	to	to	TO
18637	15373	26	accept	accept	VB
18637	15373	27	--	--	:
18637	15373	28	the	the	DT
18637	15373	29	one	one	NN
18637	15373	30	which	which	WDT
18637	15373	31	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	15373	32	declared	declare	VBD
18637	15373	33	to	to	TO
18637	15373	34	be	be	VB
18637	15373	35	"	"	``
18637	15373	36	the	the	DT
18637	15373	37	most	most	RBS
18637	15373	38	valuable	valuable	JJ
18637	15373	39	of	of	IN
18637	15373	40	the	the	DT
18637	15373	41	whole	whole	JJ
18637	15373	42	list"[9]--read	list"[9]--read	NN
18637	15373	43	as	as	IN
18637	15373	44	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	15373	45	:	:	:
18637	15373	46	"	"	``
18637	15373	47	The	the	DT
18637	15373	48	equal	equal	JJ
18637	15373	49	rights	right	NNS
18637	15373	50	of	of	IN
18637	15373	51	conscience	conscience	NN
18637	15373	52	,	,	,
18637	15373	53	the	the	DT
18637	15373	54	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15373	55	of	of	IN
18637	15373	56	speech	speech	NN
18637	15373	57	or	or	CC
18637	15373	58	of	of	IN
18637	15373	59	the	the	DT
18637	15373	60	press	press	NN
18637	15373	61	,	,	,
18637	15373	62	and	and	CC
18637	15373	63	the	the	DT
18637	15373	64	right	right	NN
18637	15373	65	of	of	IN
18637	15373	66	trial	trial	NN
18637	15373	67	by	by	IN
18637	15373	68	jury	jury	NN
18637	15373	69	in	in	IN
18637	15373	70	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15373	71	cases	case	NNS
18637	15373	72	,	,	,
18637	15373	73	shall	shall	MD
18637	15373	74	not	not	RB
18637	15373	75	be	be	VB
18637	15373	76	infringed	infringe	VBN
18637	15373	77	by	by	IN
18637	15373	78	any	any	DT
18637	15373	79	State	State	NNP
18637	15373	80	.	.	.
18637	15374	1	"	"	``
18637	15374	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15374	3	10	10	CD
18637	15374	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15374	5	The	the	DT
18637	15374	6	demand	demand	NN
18637	15374	7	for	for	IN
18637	15374	8	assurance	assurance	NN
18637	15374	9	of	of	IN
18637	15374	10	these	these	DT
18637	15374	11	rights	right	NNS
18637	15374	12	against	against	IN
18637	15374	13	encroachment	encroachment	NN
18637	15374	14	by	by	IN
18637	15374	15	the	the	DT
18637	15374	16	States	States	NNPS
18637	15374	17	would	would	MD
18637	15374	18	not	not	RB
18637	15374	19	die	die	VB
18637	15374	20	.	.	.
18637	15375	1	In	in	IN
18637	15375	2	spite	spite	NN
18637	15375	3	of	of	IN
18637	15375	4	the	the	DT
18637	15375	5	deliberate	deliberate	JJ
18637	15375	6	rejection	rejection	NN
18637	15375	7	of	of	IN
18637	15375	8	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	15375	9	's	's	POS
18637	15375	10	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	15375	11	the	the	DT
18637	15375	12	contention	contention	NN
18637	15375	13	that	that	IN
18637	15375	14	the	the	DT
18637	15375	15	first	first	JJ
18637	15375	16	Ten	ten	CD
18637	15375	17	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	15375	18	were	be	VBD
18637	15375	19	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	15375	20	to	to	IN
18637	15375	21	the	the	DT
18637	15375	22	States	States	NNP
18637	15375	23	was	be	VBD
18637	15375	24	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	15375	25	pressed	press	VBN
18637	15375	26	upon	upon	IN
18637	15375	27	the	the	DT
18637	15375	28	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15375	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15375	30	.	.	.
18637	15376	1	By	by	IN
18637	15376	2	a	a	DT
18637	15376	3	long	long	JJ
18637	15376	4	series	series	NN
18637	15376	5	of	of	IN
18637	15376	6	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	15376	7	,	,	,
18637	15376	8	beginning	begin	VBG
18637	15376	9	with	with	IN
18637	15376	10	the	the	DT
18637	15376	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15376	12	of	of	IN
18637	15376	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15376	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15376	15	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	15376	16	in	in	IN
18637	15376	17	Barron	Barron	NNP
18637	15376	18	_	_	NNP
18637	15376	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	15376	20	_	_	NNP
18637	15376	21	Baltimore[11	Baltimore[11	NNP
18637	15376	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15376	23	in	in	IN
18637	15376	24	1833	1833	CD
18637	15376	25	,	,	,
18637	15376	26	the	the	DT
18637	15376	27	argument	argument	NN
18637	15376	28	was	be	VBD
18637	15376	29	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	15376	30	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	15376	31	.	.	.
18637	15377	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	15377	2	the	the	DT
18637	15377	3	enduring	endure	VBG
18637	15377	4	vitality	vitality	NN
18637	15377	5	of	of	IN
18637	15377	6	natural	natural	JJ
18637	15377	7	law	law	NN
18637	15377	8	concepts	concept	NNS
18637	15377	9	encouraged	encourage	VBD
18637	15377	10	renewed	renew	VBN
18637	15377	11	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	15377	12	for	for	IN
18637	15377	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15377	14	protection	protection	NN
18637	15377	15	.	.	.
18637	15378	1	Expression	expression	NN
18637	15378	2	such	such	JJ
18637	15378	3	as	as	IN
18637	15378	4	the	the	DT
18637	15378	5	statement	statement	NN
18637	15378	6	of	of	IN
18637	15378	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15378	8	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	15378	9	in	in	IN
18637	15378	10	Citizens	Citizens	NNP
18637	15378	11	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	15378	12	and	and	CC
18637	15378	13	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	15378	14	Association	Association	NNP
18637	15378	15	_	_	NNP
18637	15378	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	15378	17	_	_	NNP
18637	15378	18	Topeka	Topeka	NNP
18637	15378	19	that	that	IN
18637	15378	20	:	:	:
18637	15378	21	"	"	``
18637	15378	22	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15378	23	must	must	MD
18637	15378	24	be	be	VB
18637	15378	25	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	15378	26	that	that	IN
18637	15378	27	there	there	EX
18637	15378	28	are	be	VBP
18637	15378	29	*	*	NFP
18637	15378	30	*	*	NFP
18637	15378	31	*	*	NFP
18637	15378	32	rights	right	NNS
18637	15378	33	in	in	IN
18637	15378	34	every	every	DT
18637	15378	35	free	free	JJ
18637	15378	36	government	government	NN
18637	15378	37	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	15378	38	the	the	DT
18637	15378	39	control	control	NN
18637	15378	40	of	of	IN
18637	15378	41	the	the	DT
18637	15378	42	States"[12	States"[12	NNPS
18637	15378	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15378	44	probably	probably	RB
18637	15378	45	account	account	VBP
18637	15378	46	for	for	IN
18637	15378	47	the	the	DT
18637	15378	48	fact	fact	NN
18637	15378	49	,	,	,
18637	15378	50	reported	report	VBN
18637	15378	51	by	by	IN
18637	15378	52	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	15378	53	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	15378	54	that	that	IN
18637	15378	55	:	:	:
18637	15378	56	"	"	``
18637	15378	57	In	in	IN
18637	15378	58	at	at	RB
18637	15378	59	least	least	RBS
18637	15378	60	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	15378	61	cases	case	NNS
18637	15378	62	between	between	IN
18637	15378	63	1877	1877	CD
18637	15378	64	and	and	CC
18637	15378	65	1907	1907	CD
18637	15378	66	,	,	,
18637	15378	67	the	the	DT
18637	15378	68	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15378	69	was	be	VBD
18637	15378	70	required	require	VBN
18637	15378	71	to	to	TO
18637	15378	72	rule	rule	VB
18637	15378	73	upon	upon	IN
18637	15378	74	this	this	DT
18637	15378	75	point	point	NN
18637	15378	76	and	and	CC
18637	15378	77	to	to	TO
18637	15378	78	reaffirm	reaffirm	VB
18637	15378	79	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	15378	80	's	's	POS
18637	15378	81	decision	decision	NN
18637	15378	82	of	of	IN
18637	15378	83	1833	1833	CD
18637	15378	84	,	,	,
18637	15378	85	*	*	NFP
18637	15378	86	*	*	NFP
18637	15378	87	*	*	NFP
18637	15378	88	"	"	''
18637	15378	89	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15378	90	13	13	CD
18637	15378	91	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15378	92	THE	the	DT
18637	15378	93	BILL	BILL	NNP
18637	15378	94	OF	of	IN
18637	15378	95	RIGHTS	RIGHTS	NNP
18637	15378	96	AND	and	CC
18637	15378	97	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	15378	98	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	15378	99	After	after	IN
18637	15378	100	the	the	DT
18637	15378	101	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	15378	102	of	of	IN
18637	15378	103	the	the	DT
18637	15378	104	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15378	105	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15378	106	,	,	,
18637	15378	107	a	a	DT
18637	15378	108	fresh	fresh	JJ
18637	15378	109	attack	attack	NN
18637	15378	110	was	be	VBD
18637	15378	111	launched	launch	VBN
18637	15378	112	on	on	IN
18637	15378	113	that	that	DT
18637	15378	114	front	front	NN
18637	15378	115	.	.	.
18637	15379	1	The	the	DT
18637	15379	2	rights	right	NNS
18637	15379	3	assured	assure	VBD
18637	15379	4	against	against	IN
18637	15379	5	encroachment	encroachment	NN
18637	15379	6	by	by	IN
18637	15379	7	the	the	DT
18637	15379	8	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	15379	9	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15379	10	were	be	VBD
18637	15379	11	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	15379	12	as	as	IN
18637	15379	13	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	15379	14	and	and	CC
18637	15379	15	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	15379	16	which	which	WDT
18637	15379	17	no	no	DT
18637	15379	18	State	State	NNP
18637	15379	19	may	may	MD
18637	15379	20	deny	deny	VB
18637	15379	21	to	to	IN
18637	15379	22	any	any	DT
18637	15379	23	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	15379	24	.	.	.
18637	15380	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15380	2	14	14	CD
18637	15380	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15380	4	As	as	RB
18637	15380	5	early	early	RB
18637	15380	6	as	as	IN
18637	15380	7	1884	1884	CD
18637	15380	8	the	the	DT
18637	15380	9	further	further	JJ
18637	15380	10	contention	contention	NN
18637	15380	11	was	be	VBD
18637	15380	12	made	make	VBN
18637	15380	13	that	that	IN
18637	15380	14	the	the	DT
18637	15380	15	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	15380	16	safeguards	safeguard	NNS
18637	15380	17	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	15380	18	by	by	IN
18637	15380	19	these	these	DT
18637	15380	20	articles	article	NNS
18637	15380	21	are	be	VBP
18637	15380	22	essential	essential	JJ
18637	15380	23	ingredients	ingredient	NNS
18637	15380	24	of	of	IN
18637	15380	25	due	due	JJ
18637	15380	26	process	process	NN
18637	15380	27	of	of	IN
18637	15380	28	law	law	NN
18637	15380	29	.	.	.
18637	15381	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15381	2	15	15	CD
18637	15381	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15381	4	For	for	IN
18637	15381	5	many	many	JJ
18637	15381	6	years	year	NNS
18637	15381	7	,	,	,
18637	15381	8	the	the	DT
18637	15381	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15381	10	continued	continue	VBD
18637	15381	11	to	to	TO
18637	15381	12	reject	reject	VB
18637	15381	13	these	these	DT
18637	15381	14	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	15381	15	also	also	RB
18637	15381	16	,	,	,
18637	15381	17	over	over	IN
18637	15381	18	the	the	DT
18637	15381	19	vigorous	vigorous	JJ
18637	15381	20	and	and	CC
18637	15381	21	prophetic	prophetic	JJ
18637	15381	22	dissents	dissent	NNS
18637	15381	23	of	of	IN
18637	15381	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15381	25	Harlan	Harlan	NNP
18637	15381	26	.	.	.
18637	15382	1	With	with	IN
18637	15382	2	respect	respect	NN
18637	15382	3	to	to	IN
18637	15382	4	the	the	DT
18637	15382	5	due	due	JJ
18637	15382	6	process	process	NN
18637	15382	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	15382	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15382	9	held	hold	VBD
18637	15382	10	that	that	IN
18637	15382	11	these	these	DT
18637	15382	12	words	word	NNS
18637	15382	13	have	have	VBP
18637	15382	14	the	the	DT
18637	15382	15	same	same	JJ
18637	15382	16	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	15382	17	in	in	IN
18637	15382	18	the	the	DT
18637	15382	19	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15382	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15382	21	as	as	IN
18637	15382	22	in	in	IN
18637	15382	23	the	the	DT
18637	15382	24	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	15382	25	,	,	,
18637	15382	26	and	and	CC
18637	15382	27	hence	hence	RB
18637	15382	28	do	do	VBP
18637	15382	29	not	not	RB
18637	15382	30	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	15382	31	the	the	DT
18637	15382	32	other	other	JJ
18637	15382	33	rights	right	NNS
18637	15382	34	more	more	RBR
18637	15382	35	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	15382	36	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	15382	37	in	in	IN
18637	15382	38	the	the	DT
18637	15382	39	latter	latter	JJ
18637	15382	40	,	,	,
18637	15382	41	there	there	EX
18637	15382	42	being	be	VBG
18637	15382	43	no	no	DT
18637	15382	44	superfluous	superfluous	JJ
18637	15382	45	language	language	NN
18637	15382	46	in	in	IN
18637	15382	47	the	the	DT
18637	15382	48	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15382	49	.	.	.
18637	15383	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15383	2	16	16	CD
18637	15383	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15383	4	In	in	IN
18637	15383	5	1897	1897	CD
18637	15383	6	,	,	,
18637	15383	7	however	however	RB
18637	15383	8	,	,	,
18637	15383	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15383	10	retreated	retreat	VBD
18637	15383	11	from	from	IN
18637	15383	12	this	this	DT
18637	15383	13	position	position	NN
18637	15383	14	to	to	IN
18637	15383	15	the	the	DT
18637	15383	16	extent	extent	NN
18637	15383	17	of	of	IN
18637	15383	18	holding	hold	VBG
18637	15383	19	that	that	IN
18637	15383	20	the	the	DT
18637	15383	21	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	15383	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15383	23	's	's	POS
18637	15383	24	explicit	explicit	JJ
18637	15383	25	guarantee	guarantee	NN
18637	15383	26	against	against	IN
18637	15383	27	the	the	DT
18637	15383	28	taking	taking	NN
18637	15383	29	of	of	IN
18637	15383	30	private	private	JJ
18637	15383	31	property	property	NN
18637	15383	32	without	without	IN
18637	15383	33	just	just	RB
18637	15383	34	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	15383	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	15383	36	included	include	VBN
18637	15383	37	in	in	IN
18637	15383	38	the	the	DT
18637	15383	39	due	due	JJ
18637	15383	40	process	process	NN
18637	15383	41	clause	clause	NN
18637	15383	42	of	of	IN
18637	15383	43	the	the	DT
18637	15383	44	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15383	45	.	.	.
18637	15384	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15384	2	17	17	CD
18637	15384	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15384	4	Later	late	JJR
18637	15384	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	15384	6	have	have	VBP
18637	15384	7	established	establish	VBN
18637	15384	8	that	that	IN
18637	15384	9	the	the	DT
18637	15384	10	terms	term	NNS
18637	15384	11	,	,	,
18637	15384	12	"	"	``
18637	15384	13	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15384	14	"	"	''
18637	15384	15	and	and	CC
18637	15384	16	"	"	``
18637	15384	17	due	due	JJ
18637	15384	18	process	process	NN
18637	15384	19	of	of	IN
18637	15384	20	law	law	NN
18637	15384	21	"	"	''
18637	15384	22	as	as	IN
18637	15384	23	used	use	VBN
18637	15384	24	in	in	IN
18637	15384	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15384	26	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	15384	27	,	,	,
18637	15384	28	render	render	NN
18637	15384	29	available	available	JJ
18637	15384	30	against	against	IN
18637	15384	31	the	the	DT
18637	15384	32	States	States	NNP
18637	15384	33	certain	certain	JJ
18637	15384	34	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	15384	35	rights	right	NNS
18637	15384	36	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	15384	37	accused	accuse	VBD
18637	15384	38	persons	person	NNS
18637	15384	39	in	in	IN
18637	15384	40	the	the	DT
18637	15384	41	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	15384	42	of	of	IN
18637	15384	43	Rights[18	Rights[18	,
18637	15384	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15384	45	and	and	CC
18637	15384	46	the	the	DT
18637	15384	47	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15384	48	rights	right	NNS
18637	15384	49	which	which	WDT
18637	15384	50	are	be	VBP
18637	15384	51	protected	protect	VBN
18637	15384	52	against	against	IN
18637	15384	53	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15384	54	by	by	IN
18637	15384	55	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15384	56	I.	I.	NNP
18637	15385	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15385	2	19	19	CD
18637	15385	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15385	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	15385	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15385	6	1	1	CD
18637	15385	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15385	8	1	1	CD
18637	15385	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	15385	10	.	.	.
18637	15386	1	51	51	CD
18637	15386	2	n.	n.	NN
18637	15386	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15386	4	2	2	CD
18637	15386	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15386	6	Elliot	Elliot	NNP
18637	15386	7	,	,	,
18637	15386	8	The	the	DT
18637	15386	9	Debates	Debates	NNPS
18637	15386	10	in	in	IN
18637	15386	11	the	the	DT
18637	15386	12	Several	Several	NNP
18637	15386	13	State	State	NNP
18637	15386	14	Conventions	Conventions	NNPS
18637	15386	15	on	on	IN
18637	15386	16	the	the	DT
18637	15386	17	Adoption	Adoption	NNP
18637	15386	18	of	of	IN
18637	15386	19	the	the	DT
18637	15386	20	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	15386	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15386	22	,	,	,
18637	15386	23	V	V	NNP
18637	15386	24	,	,	,
18637	15386	25	538	538	CD
18637	15386	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15386	27	1836	1836	CD
18637	15386	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15386	29	.	.	.
18637	15387	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15387	2	3	3	LS
18637	15387	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15387	4	The	the	DT
18637	15387	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	15387	6	No	no	NN
18637	15387	7	.	.	.
18637	15388	1	84	84	CD
18637	15388	2	.	.	.
18637	15389	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15389	2	4	4	CD
18637	15389	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15389	4	McLaughlin	McLaughlin	NNP
18637	15389	5	,	,	,
18637	15389	6	A	a	DT
18637	15389	7	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15389	8	History	history	NN
18637	15389	9	of	of	IN
18637	15389	10	the	the	DT
18637	15389	11	United	United	NNP
18637	15389	12	States	States	NNP
18637	15389	13	,	,	,
18637	15389	14	203	203	CD
18637	15389	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15389	16	1936	1936	CD
18637	15389	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15389	18	.	.	.
18637	15390	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15390	2	5	5	CD
18637	15390	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15390	4	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	15390	5	,	,	,
18637	15390	6	The	the	DT
18637	15390	7	Proposed	propose	VBN
18637	15390	8	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	15390	9	to	to	IN
18637	15390	10	the	the	DT
18637	15390	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15390	12	,	,	,
18637	15390	13	19	19	CD
18637	15390	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15390	15	1896	1896	CD
18637	15390	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15390	17	.	.	.
18637	15391	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15391	2	6	6	CD
18637	15391	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15391	4	Annals	Annals	NNPS
18637	15391	5	of	of	IN
18637	15391	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15391	7	,	,	,
18637	15391	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15391	9	,	,	,
18637	15391	10	424	424	CD
18637	15391	11	,	,	,
18637	15391	12	433	433	CD
18637	15391	13	.	.	.
18637	15392	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15392	2	7	7	CD
18637	15392	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15392	4	Monongahela	Monongahela	NNP
18637	15392	5	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	15392	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15392	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15392	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15392	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15392	10	United	United	NNP
18637	15392	11	States	States	NNP
18637	15392	12	,	,	,
18637	15392	13	148	148	CD
18637	15392	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15392	15	312	312	CD
18637	15392	16	,	,	,
18637	15392	17	324	324	CD
18637	15392	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15392	19	1893	1893	CD
18637	15392	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15392	21	.	.	.
18637	15393	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15393	2	8	8	CD
18637	15393	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15393	4	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	15393	5	,	,	,
18637	15393	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15393	7	op	op	NN
18637	15393	8	.	.	.
18637	15394	1	cit	cit	NNP
18637	15394	2	.	.	.
18637	15394	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15394	4	,	,	,
18637	15394	5	184	184	CD
18637	15394	6	,	,	,
18637	15394	7	185	185	CD
18637	15394	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15394	9	1896	1896	CD
18637	15394	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15394	11	.	.	.
18637	15395	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15395	2	9	9	CD
18637	15395	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15395	4	Annals	Annals	NNPS
18637	15395	5	of	of	IN
18637	15395	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15395	7	,	,	,
18637	15395	8	1	1	CD
18637	15395	9	,	,	,
18637	15395	10	755	755	CD
18637	15395	11	.	.	.
18637	15396	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15396	2	10	10	CD
18637	15396	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15396	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15396	5	.	.	.
18637	15397	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15397	2	11	11	CD
18637	15397	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15397	4	7	7	CD
18637	15397	5	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	15397	6	.	.	.
18637	15398	1	243	243	CD
18637	15398	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15398	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	15398	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15398	5	;	;	:
18637	15398	6	Lessee	Lessee	NNP
18637	15398	7	of	of	IN
18637	15398	8	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
18637	15398	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15398	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	15398	11	_	_	NNP
18637	15398	12	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	15398	13	,	,	,
18637	15398	14	7	7	CD
18637	15398	15	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	15398	16	.	.	.
18637	15399	1	469	469	CD
18637	15399	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15399	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	15399	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15399	5	;	;	:
18637	15399	6	Permoli	Permoli	NNP
18637	15399	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15399	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15399	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15399	10	New	New	NNP
18637	15399	11	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	15399	12	,	,	,
18637	15399	13	3	3	CD
18637	15399	14	How	how	WRB
18637	15399	15	.	.	.
18637	15400	1	589	589	CD
18637	15400	2	,	,	,
18637	15400	3	609	609	CD
18637	15400	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15400	5	1845	1845	CD
18637	15400	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15400	7	;	;	:
18637	15400	8	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	15400	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15400	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	15400	11	_	_	NNP
18637	15400	12	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	15400	13	,	,	,
18637	15400	14	5	5	CD
18637	15400	15	How	how	WRB
18637	15400	16	.	.	.
18637	15401	1	410	410	CD
18637	15401	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15401	3	1847	1847	CD
18637	15401	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15401	5	;	;	:
18637	15401	6	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	15401	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15401	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15401	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15401	10	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	15401	11	,	,	,
18637	15401	12	18	18	CD
18637	15401	13	How	how	WRB
18637	15401	14	.	.	.
18637	15402	1	71	71	CD
18637	15402	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15402	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	15402	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15402	5	;	;	:
18637	15402	6	Withers	Withers	NNP
18637	15402	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15402	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15402	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15402	10	Buckley	Buckley	NNP
18637	15402	11	,	,	,
18637	15402	12	20	20	CD
18637	15402	13	How	how	WRB
18637	15402	14	.	.	.
18637	15403	1	84	84	CD
18637	15403	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15403	3	1858	1858	CD
18637	15403	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15403	5	;	;	:
18637	15403	6	Pervear	Pervear	NNP
18637	15403	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15403	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15403	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15403	10	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	15403	11	,	,	,
18637	15403	12	5	5	CD
18637	15403	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15403	14	.	.	.
18637	15404	1	475	475	CD
18637	15404	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15404	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	15404	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15404	5	;	;	:
18637	15404	6	Twitchell	Twitchell	NNP
18637	15404	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15404	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15404	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15404	10	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	15404	11	,	,	,
18637	15404	12	7	7	CD
18637	15404	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15404	14	.	.	.
18637	15405	1	321	321	CD
18637	15405	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15405	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	15405	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15405	5	.	.	.
18637	15406	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15406	2	12	12	CD
18637	15406	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15406	4	20	20	CD
18637	15406	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15406	6	.	.	.
18637	15407	1	655	655	CD
18637	15407	2	,	,	,
18637	15407	3	669	669	CD
18637	15407	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15407	5	1875	1875	CD
18637	15407	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15407	7	.	.	.
18637	15408	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15408	2	13	13	CD
18637	15408	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15408	4	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	15408	5	,	,	,
18637	15408	6	The	the	DT
18637	15408	7	New	New	NNP
18637	15408	8	"	"	``
18637	15408	9	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	15408	10	"	"	''
18637	15408	11	Under	under	IN
18637	15408	12	the	the	DT
18637	15408	13	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15408	14	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15408	15	,	,	,
18637	15408	16	39	39	CD
18637	15408	17	Harv	Harv	NNP
18637	15408	18	.	.	.
18637	15409	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	15410	1	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	15410	2	,	,	,
18637	15410	3	431	431	CD
18637	15410	4	,	,	,
18637	15410	5	436	436	CD
18637	15410	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15410	7	1926	1926	CD
18637	15410	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15410	9	.	.	.
18637	15411	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15411	2	14	14	CD
18637	15411	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15411	4	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	15411	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	15411	6	House	House	NNP
18637	15411	7	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	15411	8	,	,	,
18637	15411	9	16	16	CD
18637	15411	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15411	11	.	.	.
18637	15412	1	36	36	CD
18637	15412	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15412	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	15412	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15412	5	;	;	:
18637	15412	6	Spies	Spies	NNP
18637	15412	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15412	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15412	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15412	10	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	15412	11	,	,	,
18637	15412	12	123	123	CD
18637	15412	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15412	14	131	131	CD
18637	15412	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15412	16	1887	1887	CD
18637	15412	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15412	18	;	;	:
18637	15412	19	O'Neil	O'Neil	NNP
18637	15412	20	_	_	NNP
18637	15412	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	15412	22	_	_	NNP
18637	15412	23	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	15412	24	,	,	,
18637	15412	25	144	144	CD
18637	15412	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15412	27	323	323	CD
18637	15412	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15412	29	1892	1892	CD
18637	15412	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15412	31	;	;	:
18637	15412	32	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	15412	33	_	_	NNP
18637	15412	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	15412	35	_	_	NNP
18637	15412	36	Dow	Dow	NNP
18637	15412	37	,	,	,
18637	15412	38	176	176	CD
18637	15412	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15412	40	581	581	CD
18637	15412	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15412	42	1900	1900	CD
18637	15412	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15412	44	;	;	:
18637	15412	45	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	15412	46	_	_	NNP
18637	15412	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	15412	48	_	_	NNP
18637	15412	49	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	15412	50	,	,	,
18637	15412	51	205	205	CD
18637	15412	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15412	53	454	454	CD
18637	15412	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15412	55	1907	1907	CD
18637	15412	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15412	57	;	;	:
18637	15412	58	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	15412	59	_	_	NNP
18637	15412	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	15412	61	_	_	NNP
18637	15412	62	New	New	NNP
18637	15412	63	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	15412	64	,	,	,
18637	15412	65	211	211	CD
18637	15412	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15412	67	78	78	CD
18637	15412	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15412	69	1908	1908	CD
18637	15412	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15412	71	.	.	.
18637	15413	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15413	2	15	15	CD
18637	15413	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15413	4	Hurtado	Hurtado	NNP
18637	15413	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15413	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15413	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15413	8	California	California	NNP
18637	15413	9	,	,	,
18637	15413	10	110	110	CD
18637	15413	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15413	12	516	516	CD
18637	15413	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15413	14	1884	1884	CD
18637	15413	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15413	16	.	.	.
18637	15414	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15414	2	16	16	CD
18637	15414	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15414	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	15414	5	.	.	.
18637	15415	1	534	534	CD
18637	15415	2	,	,	,
18637	15415	3	535	535	CD
18637	15415	4	.	.	.
18637	15416	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15416	2	17	17	CD
18637	15416	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15416	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	15416	5	,	,	,
18637	15416	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	15417	1	&	&	CC
18637	15417	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	15418	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	15418	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15418	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15418	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15418	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	15418	6	,	,	,
18637	15418	7	166	166	CD
18637	15418	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15418	9	226	226	CD
18637	15418	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15418	11	1897	1897	CD
18637	15418	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15418	13	.	.	.
18637	15419	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15419	2	18	18	CD
18637	15419	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15419	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15419	5	See	See	NNP
18637	15419	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15419	7	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	15419	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15419	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	15419	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15419	11	New	New	NNP
18637	15419	12	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	15419	13	,	,	,
18637	15419	14	211	211	CD
18637	15419	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15419	16	78	78	CD
18637	15419	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15419	18	1908	1908	CD
18637	15419	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15419	20	;	;	:
18637	15419	21	Adamson	Adamson	NNP
18637	15419	22	_	_	NNP
18637	15419	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	15419	24	_	_	NNP
18637	15419	25	California	California	NNP
18637	15419	26	,	,	,
18637	15419	27	332	332	CD
18637	15419	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15419	29	46	46	CD
18637	15419	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15419	31	1947	1947	CD
18637	15419	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15419	33	.	.	.
18637	15420	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15420	2	19	19	CD
18637	15420	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15420	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15420	5	See	See	NNP
18637	15420	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15420	7	Gitlow	Gitlow	NNP
18637	15420	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15420	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	15420	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15420	11	New	New	NNP
18637	15420	12	York	York	NNP
18637	15420	13	,	,	,
18637	15420	14	268	268	CD
18637	15420	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15420	16	652	652	CD
18637	15420	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15420	18	1925	1925	CD
18637	15420	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15420	20	;	;	:
18637	15420	21	Beauharnais	Beauharnais	NNP
18637	15420	22	_	_	NNP
18637	15420	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	15420	24	_	_	NNP
18637	15420	25	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	15420	26	,	,	,
18637	15420	27	343	343	CD
18637	15420	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15420	29	250	250	CD
18637	15420	30	,	,	,
18637	15420	31	288	288	CD
18637	15420	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15420	33	1952	1952	CD
18637	15420	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15420	35	.	.	.
18637	15421	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	15421	2	1	1	CD
18637	15421	3	RELIGION	religion	NN
18637	15421	4	,	,	,
18637	15421	5	FREE	free	JJ
18637	15421	6	SPEECH	SPEECH	NNP
18637	15421	7	,	,	,
18637	15421	8	ETC	ETC	NNP
18637	15421	9	.	.	.
18637	15422	1	Page	Page	NNP
18637	15422	2	Absorption	Absorption	NNP
18637	15422	3	of	of	IN
18637	15422	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15422	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15422	6	into	into	IN
18637	15422	7	the	the	DT
18637	15422	8	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15422	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15422	10	757	757	CD
18637	15422	11	"	"	``
18637	15422	12	An	an	DT
18637	15422	13	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	15422	14	of	of	IN
18637	15422	15	religion	religion	NN
18637	15422	16	"	"	``
18637	15422	17	758	758	CD
18637	15422	18	"	"	``
18637	15422	19	No	no	DT
18637	15422	20	preference	preference	NN
18637	15422	21	"	"	''
18637	15422	22	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15422	23	758	758	CD
18637	15422	24	"	"	``
18637	15422	25	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	15422	26	of	of	IN
18637	15422	27	separation	separation	NN
18637	15422	28	"	"	''
18637	15422	29	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15422	30	759	759	CD
18637	15422	31	Zorach	Zorach	NNP
18637	15422	32	Case	Case	NNP
18637	15422	33	762	762	CD
18637	15422	34	Permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	15422	35	monetary	monetary	JJ
18637	15422	36	aids	aid	NNS
18637	15422	37	to	to	TO
18637	15422	38	religion	religion	VB
18637	15422	39	763	763	CD
18637	15422	40	Free	free	JJ
18637	15422	41	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15422	42	of	of	IN
18637	15422	43	religion	religion	NN
18637	15422	44	;	;	:
18637	15422	45	dimensions	dimension	NNS
18637	15422	46	764	764	CD
18637	15422	47	Parochial	parochial	JJ
18637	15422	48	schools	school	NNS
18637	15422	49	765	765	CD
18637	15422	50	Free	free	JJ
18637	15422	51	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15422	52	of	of	IN
18637	15422	53	religion	religion	NN
18637	15422	54	;	;	,
18637	15422	55	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15422	56	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	15422	57	765	765	CD
18637	15422	58	Free	free	JJ
18637	15422	59	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15422	60	of	of	IN
18637	15422	61	religion	religion	NN
18637	15422	62	;	;	:
18637	15422	63	State	state	NN
18637	15422	64	and	and	CC
18637	15422	65	local	local	JJ
18637	15422	66	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	15422	67	766	766	CD
18637	15422	68	Free	free	JJ
18637	15422	69	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15422	70	of	of	IN
18637	15422	71	religion	religion	NN
18637	15422	72	;	;	:
18637	15422	73	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	15422	74	of	of	IN
18637	15422	75	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	15422	76	768	768	CD
18637	15422	77	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	15422	78	of	of	IN
18637	15422	79	speech	speech	NN
18637	15422	80	and	and	CC
18637	15422	81	press	press	NN
18637	15422	82	769	769	CD
18637	15422	83	Blackstonian	blackstonian	JJ
18637	15422	84	background	background	NN
18637	15422	85	769	769	CD
18637	15422	86	Effect	Effect	NNP
18637	15422	87	of	of	IN
18637	15422	88	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15422	89	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15422	90	on	on	IN
18637	15422	91	the	the	DT
18637	15422	92	common	common	JJ
18637	15422	93	law	law	NN
18637	15422	94	769	769	CD
18637	15422	95	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15422	96	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	15422	97	and	and	CC
18637	15422	98	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
18637	15422	99	771	771	CD
18637	15422	100	Clear	Clear	NNP
18637	15422	101	and	and	CC
18637	15422	102	present	present	JJ
18637	15422	103	danger	danger	NN
18637	15422	104	rule	rule	NN
18637	15422	105	,	,	,
18637	15422	106	meaning	mean	VBG
18637	15422	107	772	772	CD
18637	15422	108	Contrasting	contrast	VBG
18637	15422	109	operation	operation	NN
18637	15422	110	of	of	IN
18637	15422	111	the	the	DT
18637	15422	112	common	common	JJ
18637	15422	113	law	law	NN
18637	15422	114	rule	rule	NN
18637	15422	115	772	772	CD
18637	15422	116	Emergence	emergence	NN
18637	15422	117	of	of	IN
18637	15422	118	the	the	DT
18637	15422	119	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15422	120	and	and	CC
18637	15422	121	present	present	JJ
18637	15422	122	test	test	NN
18637	15422	123	773	773	CD
18637	15422	124	Gitlow	Gitlow	NNP
18637	15422	125	and	and	CC
18637	15422	126	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	15422	127	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	15422	128	775	775	CD
18637	15422	129	Acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	15422	130	of	of	IN
18637	15422	131	the	the	DT
18637	15422	132	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15422	133	and	and	CC
18637	15422	134	present	present	JJ
18637	15422	135	danger	danger	NN
18637	15422	136	test	test	NN
18637	15422	137	777	777	CD
18637	15422	138	Police	police	NN
18637	15422	139	power	power	NN
18637	15422	140	and	and	CC
18637	15422	141	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15422	142	and	and	CC
18637	15422	143	present	present	JJ
18637	15422	144	danger	danger	NN
18637	15422	145	777	777	CD
18637	15422	146	Public	public	JJ
18637	15422	147	order	order	NN
18637	15422	148	777	777	CD
18637	15422	149	Public	public	JJ
18637	15422	150	morals	moral	NNS
18637	15422	151	779	779	CD
18637	15422	152	Picketing	picket	VBG
18637	15422	153	and	and	CC
18637	15422	154	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15422	155	and	and	CC
18637	15422	156	present	present	JJ
18637	15422	157	danger	danger	NN
18637	15422	158	781	781	CD
18637	15422	159	Contempt	contempt	NN
18637	15422	160	of	of	IN
18637	15422	161	court	court	NN
18637	15422	162	and	and	CC
18637	15422	163	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15422	164	and	and	CC
18637	15422	165	present	present	JJ
18637	15422	166	danger	danger	NN
18637	15422	167	783	783	CD
18637	15422	168	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	15422	169	of	of	IN
18637	15422	170	speech	speech	NN
18637	15422	171	and	and	CC
18637	15422	172	press	press	NN
18637	15422	173	in	in	IN
18637	15422	174	public	public	JJ
18637	15422	175	parks	park	NNS
18637	15422	176	and	and	CC
18637	15422	177	streets	street	NNS
18637	15422	178	784	784	CD
18637	15422	179	Censorship	censorship	NN
18637	15422	180	786	786	CD
18637	15422	181	Clear	clear	JJ
18637	15422	182	and	and	CC
18637	15422	183	present	present	JJ
18637	15422	184	danger	danger	NN
18637	15422	185	test	test	NN
18637	15422	186	:	:	:
18637	15422	187	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15422	188	diversities	diversity	NNS
18637	15422	189	788	788	CD
18637	15422	190	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	15422	191	792	792	CD
18637	15422	192	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	15422	193	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	15422	194	on	on	IN
18637	15422	195	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15422	196	of	of	IN
18637	15422	197	speech	speech	NN
18637	15422	198	and	and	CC
18637	15422	199	press	press	NN
18637	15422	200	792	792	CD
18637	15422	201	Regulations	Regulations	NNPS
18637	15422	202	of	of	IN
18637	15422	203	Business	Business	NNP
18637	15422	204	and	and	CC
18637	15422	205	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	15422	206	Activities	Activities	NNP
18637	15422	207	792	792	CD
18637	15422	208	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	15422	209	of	of	IN
18637	15422	210	political	political	JJ
18637	15422	211	activities	activity	NNS
18637	15422	212	of	of	IN
18637	15422	213	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15422	214	employees	employee	NNS
18637	15422	215	793	793	CD
18637	15422	216	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	15422	217	protection	protection	NN
18637	15422	218	of	of	IN
18637	15422	219	the	the	DT
18637	15422	220	armed	armed	JJ
18637	15422	221	forces	force	NNS
18637	15422	222	and	and	CC
18637	15422	223	the	the	DT
18637	15422	224	war	war	NN
18637	15422	225	power	power	NN
18637	15422	226	794	794	CD
18637	15422	227	Loyalty	Loyalty	NNP
18637	15422	228	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	15422	229	:	:	:
18637	15422	230	The	the	DT
18637	15422	231	Douds	Douds	NNPS
18637	15422	232	Case	case	NN
18637	15422	233	794	794	CD
18637	15422	234	The	the	DT
18637	15422	235	Case	case	NN
18637	15422	236	of	of	IN
18637	15422	237	the	the	DT
18637	15422	238	Eleven	Eleven	NNP
18637	15422	239	Communists	Communists	NNPS
18637	15422	240	795	795	CD
18637	15422	241	Subversive	subversive	JJ
18637	15422	242	organizations	organization	NNS
18637	15422	243	801	801	CD
18637	15422	244	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	15422	245	state	state	NN
18637	15422	246	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15422	247	801	801	CD
18637	15422	248	Loyalty	Loyalty	NNP
18637	15422	249	tests	test	VBZ
18637	15422	250	801	801	CD
18637	15422	251	Group	Group	NNP
18637	15422	252	libel	libel	NN
18637	15422	253	802	802	CD
18637	15422	254	Censorship	Censorship	NNP
18637	15422	255	of	of	IN
18637	15422	256	the	the	DT
18637	15422	257	mails	mail	NNS
18637	15422	258	804	804	CD
18637	15422	259	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	15422	260	of	of	IN
18637	15422	261	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	15422	262	and	and	CC
18637	15422	263	petition	petition	NN
18637	15422	264	805	805	CD
18637	15422	265	Restraints	Restraints	NNPS
18637	15422	266	on	on	IN
18637	15422	267	the	the	DT
18637	15422	268	right	right	NN
18637	15422	269	of	of	IN
18637	15422	270	petition	petition	NN
18637	15422	271	806	806	CD
18637	15422	272	The	the	DT
18637	15422	273	Cruikshank	Cruikshank	NNP
18637	15422	274	Case	Case	NNP
18637	15422	275	807	807	CD
18637	15422	276	Hague	Hague	NNP
18637	15422	277	_	_	NNP
18637	15422	278	v.	v.	IN
18637	15422	279	_	_	NNP
18637	15422	280	C.I.O.	C.I.O.	NNP
18637	15423	1	808	808	CD
18637	15423	2	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	15423	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	15423	4	809	809	CD
18637	15423	5	Lobbying	lobby	VBG
18637	15423	6	and	and	CC
18637	15423	7	the	the	DT
18637	15423	8	right	right	NN
18637	15423	9	of	of	IN
18637	15423	10	petition	petition	NN
18637	15423	11	810	810	CD
18637	15423	12	RELIGION	religion	NN
18637	15423	13	,	,	,
18637	15423	14	FREE	free	JJ
18637	15423	15	SPEECH	SPEECH	NNP
18637	15423	16	,	,	,
18637	15423	17	ETC	ETC	NNP
18637	15423	18	.	.	.
18637	15424	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15424	2	1	1	CD
18637	15424	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15424	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	15424	5	make	make	VB
18637	15424	6	no	no	DT
18637	15424	7	law	law	NN
18637	15424	8	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	15424	9	an	an	DT
18637	15424	10	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	15424	11	of	of	IN
18637	15424	12	religion	religion	NN
18637	15424	13	,	,	,
18637	15424	14	or	or	CC
18637	15424	15	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	15424	16	the	the	DT
18637	15424	17	free	free	JJ
18637	15424	18	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15424	19	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	15424	20	;	;	:
18637	15424	21	or	or	CC
18637	15424	22	abridging	abridge	VBG
18637	15424	23	the	the	DT
18637	15424	24	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15424	25	of	of	IN
18637	15424	26	speech	speech	NN
18637	15424	27	,	,	,
18637	15424	28	or	or	CC
18637	15424	29	of	of	IN
18637	15424	30	the	the	DT
18637	15424	31	press	press	NN
18637	15424	32	;	;	:
18637	15424	33	or	or	CC
18637	15424	34	the	the	DT
18637	15424	35	right	right	NN
18637	15424	36	of	of	IN
18637	15424	37	the	the	DT
18637	15424	38	people	people	NNS
18637	15424	39	peaceably	peaceably	RB
18637	15424	40	to	to	TO
18637	15424	41	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	15424	42	,	,	,
18637	15424	43	and	and	CC
18637	15424	44	to	to	TO
18637	15424	45	petition	petition	VB
18637	15424	46	the	the	DT
18637	15424	47	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15424	48	for	for	IN
18637	15424	49	a	a	DT
18637	15424	50	redress	redress	NN
18637	15424	51	of	of	IN
18637	15424	52	grievances	grievance	NNS
18637	15424	53	.	.	.
18637	15425	1	Absorption	Absorption	NNP
18637	15425	2	of	of	IN
18637	15425	3	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15425	4	I	I	NNP
18637	15425	5	Into	into	IN
18637	15425	6	the	the	DT
18637	15425	7	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15425	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15425	9	Eventually	eventually	RB
18637	15425	10	the	the	DT
18637	15425	11	long	long	JJ
18637	15425	12	sought	seek	VBN
18637	15425	13	protection	protection	NN
18637	15425	14	for	for	IN
18637	15425	15	certain	certain	JJ
18637	15425	16	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15425	17	personal	personal	JJ
18637	15425	18	rights	right	NNS
18637	15425	19	was	be	VBD
18637	15425	20	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	15425	21	by	by	IN
18637	15425	22	identifying	identify	VBG
18637	15425	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15425	24	with	with	IN
18637	15425	25	the	the	DT
18637	15425	26	"	"	``
18637	15425	27	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15425	28	"	"	''
18637	15425	29	which	which	WDT
18637	15425	30	States	States	NNP
18637	15425	31	can	can	MD
18637	15425	32	not	not	RB
18637	15425	33	take	take	VB
18637	15425	34	away	away	RB
18637	15425	35	without	without	IN
18637	15425	36	due	due	JJ
18637	15425	37	process	process	NN
18637	15425	38	of	of	IN
18637	15425	39	law	law	NN
18637	15425	40	.	.	.
18637	15426	1	The	the	DT
18637	15426	2	shift	shift	NN
18637	15426	3	in	in	IN
18637	15426	4	the	the	DT
18637	15426	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15426	6	's	's	POS
18637	15426	7	point	point	NN
18637	15426	8	of	of	IN
18637	15426	9	view	view	NN
18637	15426	10	was	be	VBD
18637	15426	11	made	make	VBN
18637	15426	12	known	known	JJ
18637	15426	13	quite	quite	RB
18637	15426	14	casually	casually	RB
18637	15426	15	in	in	IN
18637	15426	16	Gitlow	Gitlow	NNP
18637	15426	17	_	_	NNP
18637	15426	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	15426	19	_	_	NNP
18637	15426	20	New	New	NNP
18637	15426	21	York,[1	York,[1	NNP
18637	15426	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15426	23	where	where	WRB
18637	15426	24	,	,	,
18637	15426	25	although	although	IN
18637	15426	26	affirming	affirm	VBG
18637	15426	27	a	a	DT
18637	15426	28	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15426	29	for	for	IN
18637	15426	30	violation	violation	NN
18637	15426	31	of	of	IN
18637	15426	32	a	a	DT
18637	15426	33	State	State	NNP
18637	15426	34	statute	statute	NN
18637	15426	35	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	15426	36	the	the	DT
18637	15426	37	advocacy	advocacy	NN
18637	15426	38	of	of	IN
18637	15426	39	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15426	40	anarchy	anarchy	NN
18637	15426	41	,	,	,
18637	15426	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15426	43	declared	declare	VBD
18637	15426	44	that	that	DT
18637	15426	45	:	:	:
18637	15426	46	"	"	``
18637	15426	47	For	for	IN
18637	15426	48	present	present	JJ
18637	15426	49	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	15426	50	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15426	51	may	may	MD
18637	15426	52	and	and	CC
18637	15426	53	do	do	VBP
18637	15426	54	assume	assume	VB
18637	15426	55	that	that	IN
18637	15426	56	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15426	57	of	of	IN
18637	15426	58	speech	speech	NN
18637	15426	59	and	and	CC
18637	15426	60	of	of	IN
18637	15426	61	the	the	DT
18637	15426	62	press	press	NN
18637	15426	63	--	--	:
18637	15426	64	which	which	WDT
18637	15426	65	are	be	VBP
18637	15426	66	protected	protect	VBN
18637	15426	67	by	by	IN
18637	15426	68	the	the	DT
18637	15426	69	First	First	NNP
18637	15426	70	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15426	71	from	from	IN
18637	15426	72	abridgment	abridgment	NN
18637	15426	73	by	by	IN
18637	15426	74	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15426	75	--	--	:
18637	15426	76	are	be	VBP
18637	15426	77	among	among	IN
18637	15426	78	the	the	DT
18637	15426	79	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	15426	80	personal	personal	JJ
18637	15426	81	rights	right	NNS
18637	15426	82	and	and	CC
18637	15426	83	'	'	``
18637	15426	84	liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	15426	85	'	'	''
18637	15426	86	protected	protect	VBN
18637	15426	87	by	by	IN
18637	15426	88	the	the	DT
18637	15426	89	due	due	JJ
18637	15426	90	process	process	NN
18637	15426	91	clause	clause	NN
18637	15426	92	of	of	IN
18637	15426	93	the	the	DT
18637	15426	94	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15426	95	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15426	96	from	from	IN
18637	15426	97	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	15426	98	by	by	IN
18637	15426	99	the	the	DT
18637	15426	100	States	States	NNP
18637	15426	101	.	.	.
18637	15427	1	"	"	``
18637	15427	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15427	3	2	2	LS
18637	15427	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15427	5	This	this	DT
18637	15427	6	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	15427	7	became	become	VBD
18637	15427	8	,	,	,
18637	15427	9	two	two	CD
18637	15427	10	years	year	NNS
18637	15427	11	later	later	RB
18637	15427	12	,	,	,
18637	15427	13	accepted	accepted	JJ
18637	15427	14	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15427	15	when	when	WRB
18637	15427	16	the	the	DT
18637	15427	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15427	18	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
18637	15427	19	a	a	DT
18637	15427	20	State	State	NNP
18637	15427	21	law	law	NN
18637	15427	22	on	on	IN
18637	15427	23	the	the	DT
18637	15427	24	ground	ground	NN
18637	15427	25	that	that	IN
18637	15427	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15427	27	abridged	abridge	VBD
18637	15427	28	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15427	29	of	of	IN
18637	15427	30	speech	speech	NN
18637	15427	31	contrary	contrary	RB
18637	15427	32	to	to	IN
18637	15427	33	the	the	DT
18637	15427	34	due	due	JJ
18637	15427	35	process	process	NN
18637	15427	36	clause	clause	NN
18637	15427	37	of	of	IN
18637	15427	38	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15427	39	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	15427	40	.	.	.
18637	15428	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15428	2	3	3	LS
18637	15428	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15428	4	Subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	15428	5	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	15428	6	have	have	VBP
18637	15428	7	brought	bring	VBN
18637	15428	8	the	the	DT
18637	15428	9	other	other	JJ
18637	15428	10	rights	right	NNS
18637	15428	11	safeguarded	safeguard	VBN
18637	15428	12	by	by	IN
18637	15428	13	the	the	DT
18637	15428	14	First	First	NNP
18637	15428	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15428	16	,	,	,
18637	15428	17	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15428	18	of	of	IN
18637	15428	19	religion,[4	religion,[4	NNP
18637	15428	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15428	21	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15428	22	of	of	IN
18637	15428	23	the	the	DT
18637	15428	24	press,[5	press,[5	NN
18637	15428	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15428	26	and	and	CC
18637	15428	27	the	the	DT
18637	15428	28	right	right	NN
18637	15428	29	of	of	IN
18637	15428	30	peaceable	peaceable	JJ
18637	15428	31	assembly,[6	assembly,[6	NN
18637	15428	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15428	33	within	within	IN
18637	15428	34	the	the	DT
18637	15428	35	protection	protection	NN
18637	15428	36	of	of	IN
18637	15428	37	the	the	DT
18637	15428	38	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15428	39	.	.	.
18637	15429	1	In	in	IN
18637	15429	2	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	15429	3	of	of	IN
18637	15429	4	this	this	DT
18637	15429	5	development	development	NN
18637	15429	6	the	the	DT
18637	15429	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	15429	8	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	15429	9	with	with	IN
18637	15429	10	the	the	DT
18637	15429	11	safeguarding	safeguarding	NN
18637	15429	12	of	of	IN
18637	15429	13	these	these	DT
18637	15429	14	rights	right	NNS
18637	15429	15	against	against	IN
18637	15429	16	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	15429	17	by	by	IN
18637	15429	18	the	the	DT
18637	15429	19	States	state	NNS
18637	15429	20	are	be	VBP
18637	15429	21	included	include	VBN
18637	15429	22	in	in	IN
18637	15429	23	the	the	DT
18637	15429	24	ensuing	ensue	VBG
18637	15429	25	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	15429	26	of	of	IN
18637	15429	27	the	the	DT
18637	15429	28	First	First	NNP
18637	15429	29	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15429	30	.	.	.
18637	15430	1	An	an	DT
18637	15430	2	Establishment	establishment	NN
18637	15430	3	of	of	IN
18637	15430	4	Religion	Religion	NNP
18637	15430	5	THE	the	DT
18637	15430	6	"	"	``
18637	15430	7	NO	no	DT
18637	15430	8	PREFERENCE	preference	NN
18637	15430	9	"	"	''
18637	15430	10	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNP
18637	15430	11	The	the	DT
18637	15430	12	original	original	JJ
18637	15430	13	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	15430	14	leading	lead	VBG
18637	15430	15	to	to	IN
18637	15430	16	the	the	DT
18637	15430	17	First	First	NNP
18637	15430	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15430	19	was	be	VBD
18637	15430	20	introduced	introduce	VBN
18637	15430	21	into	into	IN
18637	15430	22	the	the	DT
18637	15430	23	House	House	NNP
18637	15430	24	of	of	IN
18637	15430	25	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	15430	26	by	by	IN
18637	15430	27	James	James	NNP
18637	15430	28	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	15430	29	,	,	,
18637	15430	30	and	and	CC
18637	15430	31	read	read	VB
18637	15430	32	as	as	IN
18637	15430	33	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	15430	34	:	:	:
18637	15430	35	"	"	``
18637	15430	36	The	the	DT
18637	15430	37	civil	civil	JJ
18637	15430	38	rights	right	NNS
18637	15430	39	of	of	IN
18637	15430	40	none	none	NN
18637	15430	41	shall	shall	MD
18637	15430	42	be	be	VB
18637	15430	43	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	15430	44	on	on	IN
18637	15430	45	account	account	NN
18637	15430	46	of	of	IN
18637	15430	47	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15430	48	belief	belief	NN
18637	15430	49	or	or	CC
18637	15430	50	worship	worship	NN
18637	15430	51	,	,	,
18637	15430	52	nor	nor	CC
18637	15430	53	shall	shall	MD
18637	15430	54	any	any	DT
18637	15430	55	national	national	JJ
18637	15430	56	religion	religion	NN
18637	15430	57	be	be	VB
18637	15430	58	established	establish	VBN
18637	15430	59	,	,	,
18637	15430	60	nor	nor	CC
18637	15430	61	shall	shall	MD
18637	15430	62	the	the	DT
18637	15430	63	full	full	JJ
18637	15430	64	and	and	CC
18637	15430	65	equal	equal	JJ
18637	15430	66	rights	right	NNS
18637	15430	67	of	of	IN
18637	15430	68	conscience	conscience	NN
18637	15430	69	be	be	VBP
18637	15430	70	in	in	IN
18637	15430	71	any	any	DT
18637	15430	72	manner	manner	NN
18637	15430	73	,	,	,
18637	15430	74	or	or	CC
18637	15430	75	on	on	IN
18637	15430	76	any	any	DT
18637	15430	77	pretence	pretence	NN
18637	15430	78	,	,	,
18637	15430	79	infringed	infringe	VBD
18637	15430	80	.	.	.
18637	15431	1	"	"	``
18637	15431	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15431	3	7	7	CD
18637	15431	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15431	5	This	this	DT
18637	15431	6	was	be	VBD
18637	15431	7	altered	alter	VBN
18637	15431	8	in	in	IN
18637	15431	9	the	the	DT
18637	15431	10	House	House	NNP
18637	15431	11	to	to	TO
18637	15431	12	read	read	VB
18637	15431	13	:	:	:
18637	15431	14	"	"	``
18637	15431	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15431	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	15431	17	make	make	VB
18637	15431	18	no	no	DT
18637	15431	19	law	law	NN
18637	15431	20	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	15431	21	religion	religion	NN
18637	15431	22	,	,	,
18637	15431	23	or	or	CC
18637	15431	24	to	to	TO
18637	15431	25	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	15431	26	the	the	DT
18637	15431	27	free	free	JJ
18637	15431	28	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15431	29	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	15431	30	,	,	,
18637	15431	31	or	or	CC
18637	15431	32	to	to	TO
18637	15431	33	infringe	infringe	VB
18637	15431	34	the	the	DT
18637	15431	35	rights	right	NNS
18637	15431	36	of	of	IN
18637	15431	37	conscience	conscience	NN
18637	15431	38	.	.	.
18637	15432	1	"	"	``
18637	15432	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15432	3	8	8	CD
18637	15432	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15432	5	In	in	IN
18637	15432	6	the	the	DT
18637	15432	7	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	15432	8	the	the	DT
18637	15432	9	above	above	JJ
18637	15432	10	formula	formula	NN
18637	15432	11	was	be	VBD
18637	15432	12	replaced	replace	VBN
18637	15432	13	by	by	IN
18637	15432	14	the	the	DT
18637	15432	15	following	following	NN
18637	15432	16	;	;	:
18637	15432	17	"	"	``
18637	15432	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15432	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	15432	20	make	make	VB
18637	15432	21	no	no	DT
18637	15432	22	law	law	NN
18637	15432	23	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	15432	24	articles	article	NNS
18637	15432	25	of	of	IN
18637	15432	26	religion	religion	NN
18637	15432	27	.	.	.
18637	15433	1	"	"	``
18637	15433	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15433	3	9	9	CD
18637	15433	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15433	5	The	the	DT
18637	15433	6	conference	conference	NN
18637	15433	7	committee	committee	NN
18637	15433	8	of	of	IN
18637	15433	9	the	the	DT
18637	15433	10	two	two	CD
18637	15433	11	houses	house	NNS
18637	15433	12	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	15433	13	the	the	DT
18637	15433	14	House	House	NNP
18637	15433	15	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	15433	16	,	,	,
18637	15433	17	but	but	CC
18637	15433	18	with	with	IN
18637	15433	19	the	the	DT
18637	15433	20	neutral	neutral	JJ
18637	15433	21	term	term	NN
18637	15433	22	"	"	``
18637	15433	23	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	15433	24	an	an	DT
18637	15433	25	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	15433	26	,	,	,
18637	15433	27	"	"	''
18637	15433	28	etc	etc	FW
18637	15433	29	.	.	.
18637	15433	30	,	,	,
18637	15433	31	taking	take	VBG
18637	15433	32	the	the	DT
18637	15433	33	place	place	NN
18637	15433	34	of	of	IN
18637	15433	35	the	the	DT
18637	15433	36	original	original	JJ
18637	15433	37	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	15433	38	ban	ban	NN
18637	15433	39	against	against	IN
18637	15433	40	any	any	DT
18637	15433	41	law	law	NN
18637	15433	42	"	"	``
18637	15433	43	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	15433	44	religion	religion	NN
18637	15433	45	.	.	.
18637	15434	1	"	"	``
18637	15434	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15434	3	10	10	CD
18637	15434	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15434	5	Explaining	explain	VBG
18637	15434	6	this	this	DT
18637	15434	7	phraseology	phraseology	NN
18637	15434	8	,	,	,
18637	15434	9	in	in	IN
18637	15434	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15434	11	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	15434	12	,	,	,
18637	15434	13	Story	Story	NNP
18637	15434	14	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	15434	15	that	that	IN
18637	15434	16	the	the	DT
18637	15434	17	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15434	18	of	of	IN
18637	15434	19	the	the	DT
18637	15434	20	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	15434	21	was	be	VBD
18637	15434	22	not	not	RB
18637	15434	23	to	to	TO
18637	15434	24	discredit	discredit	VB
18637	15434	25	the	the	DT
18637	15434	26	then	then	RB
18637	15434	27	existing	exist	VBG
18637	15434	28	State	state	NN
18637	15434	29	establishments	establishment	NNS
18637	15434	30	of	of	IN
18637	15434	31	religion	religion	NN
18637	15434	32	,	,	,
18637	15434	33	but	but	CC
18637	15434	34	rather	rather	RB
18637	15434	35	"	"	``
18637	15434	36	to	to	TO
18637	15434	37	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	15434	38	from	from	IN
18637	15434	39	the	the	DT
18637	15434	40	National	National	NNP
18637	15434	41	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15434	42	all	all	DT
18637	15434	43	power	power	NN
18637	15434	44	to	to	TO
18637	15434	45	act	act	VB
18637	15434	46	on	on	IN
18637	15434	47	the	the	DT
18637	15434	48	subject	subject	NN
18637	15434	49	.	.	.
18637	15434	50	"	"	''
18637	15435	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15435	2	wrote	write	VBD
18637	15435	3	:	:	:
18637	15435	4	"	"	``
18637	15435	5	The	the	DT
18637	15435	6	situation	situation	NN
18637	15435	7	,	,	,
18637	15435	8	*	*	NFP
18637	15435	9	*	*	NFP
18637	15435	10	*	*	NFP
18637	15435	11	,	,	,
18637	15435	12	of	of	IN
18637	15435	13	the	the	DT
18637	15435	14	different	different	JJ
18637	15435	15	States	States	NNP
18637	15435	16	equally	equally	RB
18637	15435	17	proclaimed	proclaim	VBD
18637	15435	18	the	the	DT
18637	15435	19	policy	policy	NN
18637	15435	20	as	as	RB
18637	15435	21	well	well	RB
18637	15435	22	as	as	IN
18637	15435	23	the	the	DT
18637	15435	24	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	15435	25	of	of	IN
18637	15435	26	such	such	PDT
18637	15435	27	an	an	DT
18637	15435	28	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	15435	29	.	.	.
18637	15436	1	In	in	IN
18637	15436	2	some	some	DT
18637	15436	3	of	of	IN
18637	15436	4	the	the	DT
18637	15436	5	States	States	NNPS
18637	15436	6	,	,	,
18637	15436	7	episcopalians	episcopalian	NNS
18637	15436	8	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	15436	9	the	the	DT
18637	15436	10	predominant	predominant	JJ
18637	15436	11	sect	sect	NN
18637	15436	12	;	;	:
18637	15436	13	in	in	IN
18637	15436	14	others	other	NNS
18637	15436	15	,	,	,
18637	15436	16	presbyterians	presbyterians	NNPS
18637	15436	17	;	;	:
18637	15436	18	in	in	IN
18637	15436	19	others	other	NNS
18637	15436	20	,	,	,
18637	15436	21	congregationalists	congregationalist	NNS
18637	15436	22	;	;	:
18637	15436	23	in	in	IN
18637	15436	24	others	other	NNS
18637	15436	25	,	,	,
18637	15436	26	quakers	quaker	NNS
18637	15436	27	;	;	:
18637	15436	28	and	and	CC
18637	15436	29	in	in	IN
18637	15436	30	others	other	NNS
18637	15436	31	again	again	RB
18637	15436	32	,	,	,
18637	15436	33	there	there	EX
18637	15436	34	was	be	VBD
18637	15436	35	a	a	DT
18637	15436	36	close	close	JJ
18637	15436	37	numerical	numerical	JJ
18637	15436	38	rivalry	rivalry	NN
18637	15436	39	among	among	IN
18637	15436	40	contending	contend	VBG
18637	15436	41	sects	sect	NNS
18637	15436	42	.	.	.
18637	15437	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15437	2	was	be	VBD
18637	15437	3	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	15437	4	that	that	IN
18637	15437	5	there	there	EX
18637	15437	6	should	should	MD
18637	15437	7	not	not	RB
18637	15437	8	arise	arise	VB
18637	15437	9	perpetual	perpetual	JJ
18637	15437	10	strife	strife	NN
18637	15437	11	and	and	CC
18637	15437	12	perpetual	perpetual	JJ
18637	15437	13	jealousy	jealousy	NN
18637	15437	14	on	on	IN
18637	15437	15	the	the	DT
18637	15437	16	subject	subject	NN
18637	15437	17	of	of	IN
18637	15437	18	ecclesiastical	ecclesiastical	JJ
18637	15437	19	ascendency	ascendency	NN
18637	15437	20	,	,	,
18637	15437	21	if	if	IN
18637	15437	22	the	the	DT
18637	15437	23	national	national	JJ
18637	15437	24	government	government	NN
18637	15437	25	were	be	VBD
18637	15437	26	left	leave	VBN
18637	15437	27	free	free	JJ
18637	15437	28	to	to	TO
18637	15437	29	create	create	VB
18637	15437	30	a	a	DT
18637	15437	31	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15437	32	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	15437	33	.	.	.
18637	15438	1	The	the	DT
18637	15438	2	only	only	JJ
18637	15438	3	security	security	NN
18637	15438	4	was	be	VBD
18637	15438	5	in	in	IN
18637	15438	6	extirpating	extirpate	VBG
18637	15438	7	the	the	DT
18637	15438	8	power	power	NN
18637	15438	9	.	.	.
18637	15439	1	But	but	CC
18637	15439	2	this	this	DT
18637	15439	3	alone	alone	RB
18637	15439	4	would	would	MD
18637	15439	5	have	have	VB
18637	15439	6	been	be	VBN
18637	15439	7	an	an	DT
18637	15439	8	imperfect	imperfect	JJ
18637	15439	9	security	security	NN
18637	15439	10	,	,	,
18637	15439	11	if	if	IN
18637	15439	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15439	13	had	have	VBD
18637	15439	14	not	not	RB
18637	15439	15	been	be	VBN
18637	15439	16	followed	follow	VBN
18637	15439	17	up	up	RP
18637	15439	18	by	by	IN
18637	15439	19	a	a	DT
18637	15439	20	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	15439	21	of	of	IN
18637	15439	22	the	the	DT
18637	15439	23	right	right	NN
18637	15439	24	of	of	IN
18637	15439	25	the	the	DT
18637	15439	26	free	free	JJ
18637	15439	27	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15439	28	of	of	IN
18637	15439	29	religion	religion	NN
18637	15439	30	,	,	,
18637	15439	31	and	and	CC
18637	15439	32	a	a	DT
18637	15439	33	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	15439	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15439	35	as	as	IN
18637	15439	36	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15439	37	have	have	VBP
18637	15439	38	seen	see	VBN
18637	15439	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15439	40	of	of	IN
18637	15439	41	all	all	DT
18637	15439	42	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15439	43	tests	test	NNS
18637	15439	44	.	.	.
18637	15440	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	15440	2	,	,	,
18637	15440	3	the	the	DT
18637	15440	4	whole	whole	JJ
18637	15440	5	power	power	NN
18637	15440	6	over	over	IN
18637	15440	7	the	the	DT
18637	15440	8	subject	subject	NN
18637	15440	9	of	of	IN
18637	15440	10	religion	religion	NN
18637	15440	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	15440	12	left	leave	VBN
18637	15440	13	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	15440	14	to	to	IN
18637	15440	15	the	the	DT
18637	15440	16	State	state	NN
18637	15440	17	governments	government	NNS
18637	15440	18	,	,	,
18637	15440	19	to	to	TO
18637	15440	20	be	be	VB
18637	15440	21	acted	act	VBN
18637	15440	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	15440	23	according	accord	VBG
18637	15440	24	to	to	IN
18637	15440	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15440	26	own	own	JJ
18637	15440	27	sense	sense	NN
18637	15440	28	of	of	IN
18637	15440	29	justice	justice	NN
18637	15440	30	and	and	CC
18637	15440	31	the	the	DT
18637	15440	32	State	State	NNP
18637	15440	33	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	15440	34	;	;	:
18637	15440	35	and	and	CC
18637	15440	36	the	the	DT
18637	15440	37	Catholic	Catholic	NNP
18637	15440	38	and	and	CC
18637	15440	39	the	the	DT
18637	15440	40	Protestant	Protestant	NNP
18637	15440	41	,	,	,
18637	15440	42	the	the	DT
18637	15440	43	Calvinist	Calvinist	NNP
18637	15440	44	and	and	CC
18637	15440	45	the	the	DT
18637	15440	46	Arminian	Arminian	NNP
18637	15440	47	,	,	,
18637	15440	48	the	the	DT
18637	15440	49	Jew	Jew	NNP
18637	15440	50	and	and	CC
18637	15440	51	the	the	DT
18637	15440	52	Infidel	Infidel	NNP
18637	15440	53	,	,	,
18637	15440	54	may	may	MD
18637	15440	55	sit	sit	VB
18637	15440	56	down	down	RP
18637	15440	57	at	at	IN
18637	15440	58	the	the	DT
18637	15440	59	common	common	JJ
18637	15440	60	table	table	NN
18637	15440	61	of	of	IN
18637	15440	62	the	the	DT
18637	15440	63	national	national	JJ
18637	15440	64	councils	council	NNS
18637	15440	65	without	without	IN
18637	15440	66	any	any	DT
18637	15440	67	inquisition	inquisition	NN
18637	15440	68	into	into	IN
18637	15440	69	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15440	70	faith	faith	NN
18637	15440	71	or	or	CC
18637	15440	72	mode	mode	NN
18637	15440	73	of	of	IN
18637	15440	74	worship	worship	NN
18637	15440	75	.	.	.
18637	15441	1	"	"	``
18637	15441	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15441	3	11	11	CD
18637	15441	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15441	5	For	for	IN
18637	15441	6	the	the	DT
18637	15441	7	rest	rest	NN
18637	15441	8	,	,	,
18637	15441	9	Story	Story	NNP
18637	15441	10	contended	contend	VBD
18637	15441	11	,	,	,
18637	15441	12	the	the	DT
18637	15441	13	no	no	DT
18637	15441	14	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	15441	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	15441	16	,	,	,
18637	15441	17	while	while	IN
18637	15441	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15441	19	inhibited	inhibit	VBD
18637	15441	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15441	21	from	from	IN
18637	15441	22	giving	give	VBG
18637	15441	23	preference	preference	NN
18637	15441	24	to	to	IN
18637	15441	25	any	any	DT
18637	15441	26	denomination	denomination	NN
18637	15441	27	of	of	IN
18637	15441	28	the	the	DT
18637	15441	29	Christian	christian	JJ
18637	15441	30	faith	faith	NN
18637	15441	31	,	,	,
18637	15441	32	was	be	VBD
18637	15441	33	not	not	RB
18637	15441	34	intended	intend	VBN
18637	15441	35	to	to	TO
18637	15441	36	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	15441	37	the	the	DT
18637	15441	38	Christian	christian	JJ
18637	15441	39	religion	religion	NN
18637	15441	40	as	as	IN
18637	15441	41	a	a	DT
18637	15441	42	whole	whole	NN
18637	15441	43	from	from	IN
18637	15441	44	the	the	DT
18637	15441	45	protection	protection	NN
18637	15441	46	of	of	IN
18637	15441	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15441	48	.	.	.
18637	15442	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15442	2	said	say	VBD
18637	15442	3	:	:	:
18637	15442	4	"	"	``
18637	15442	5	Probably	probably	RB
18637	15442	6	at	at	IN
18637	15442	7	the	the	DT
18637	15442	8	time	time	NN
18637	15442	9	of	of	IN
18637	15442	10	the	the	DT
18637	15442	11	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	15442	12	of	of	IN
18637	15442	13	the	the	DT
18637	15442	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15442	15	,	,	,
18637	15442	16	and	and	CC
18637	15442	17	of	of	IN
18637	15442	18	the	the	DT
18637	15442	19	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	15442	20	to	to	IN
18637	15442	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15442	22	now	now	RB
18637	15442	23	under	under	IN
18637	15442	24	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	15442	25	,	,	,
18637	15442	26	the	the	DT
18637	15442	27	general	general	JJ
18637	15442	28	if	if	IN
18637	15442	29	not	not	RB
18637	15442	30	the	the	DT
18637	15442	31	universal	universal	JJ
18637	15442	32	sentiment	sentiment	NN
18637	15442	33	in	in	IN
18637	15442	34	America	America	NNP
18637	15442	35	was	be	VBD
18637	15442	36	,	,	,
18637	15442	37	that	that	IN
18637	15442	38	Christianity	Christianity	NNP
18637	15442	39	ought	ought	MD
18637	15442	40	to	to	TO
18637	15442	41	receive	receive	VB
18637	15442	42	encouragement	encouragement	NN
18637	15442	43	from	from	IN
18637	15442	44	the	the	DT
18637	15442	45	state	state	NN
18637	15442	46	so	so	RB
18637	15442	47	far	far	RB
18637	15442	48	as	as	IN
18637	15442	49	was	be	VBD
18637	15442	50	not	not	RB
18637	15442	51	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
18637	15442	52	with	with	IN
18637	15442	53	the	the	DT
18637	15442	54	private	private	JJ
18637	15442	55	rights	right	NNS
18637	15442	56	of	of	IN
18637	15442	57	conscience	conscience	NN
18637	15442	58	and	and	CC
18637	15442	59	the	the	DT
18637	15442	60	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15442	61	of	of	IN
18637	15442	62	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15442	63	worship	worship	NN
18637	15442	64	.	.	.
18637	15443	1	An	an	DT
18637	15443	2	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	15443	3	to	to	TO
18637	15443	4	level	level	VB
18637	15443	5	all	all	DT
18637	15443	6	religions	religion	NNS
18637	15443	7	,	,	,
18637	15443	8	and	and	CC
18637	15443	9	to	to	TO
18637	15443	10	make	make	VB
18637	15443	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15443	12	a	a	DT
18637	15443	13	matter	matter	NN
18637	15443	14	of	of	IN
18637	15443	15	state	state	NN
18637	15443	16	policy	policy	NN
18637	15443	17	to	to	TO
18637	15443	18	hold	hold	VB
18637	15443	19	all	all	DT
18637	15443	20	in	in	IN
18637	15443	21	utter	utter	JJ
18637	15443	22	indifference	indifference	NN
18637	15443	23	,	,	,
18637	15443	24	would	would	MD
18637	15443	25	have	have	VB
18637	15443	26	created	create	VBN
18637	15443	27	universal	universal	JJ
18637	15443	28	disapprobation	disapprobation	NN
18637	15443	29	,	,	,
18637	15443	30	if	if	IN
18637	15443	31	not	not	RB
18637	15443	32	universal	universal	JJ
18637	15443	33	indignation	indignation	NN
18637	15443	34	.	.	.
18637	15444	1	"	"	``
18637	15444	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15444	3	12	12	CD
18637	15444	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15444	5	As	as	RB
18637	15444	6	late	late	RB
18637	15444	7	as	as	IN
18637	15444	8	1898	1898	CD
18637	15444	9	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	15444	10	expounded	expound	VBD
18637	15444	11	the	the	DT
18637	15444	12	no	no	DT
18637	15444	13	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	15444	14	clause	clause	NN
18637	15444	15	as	as	IN
18637	15444	16	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	15444	17	:	:	:
18637	15444	18	"	"	``
18637	15444	19	By	by	IN
18637	15444	20	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	15444	21	of	of	IN
18637	15444	22	religion	religion	NN
18637	15444	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	15444	24	meant	mean	VBN
18637	15444	25	the	the	DT
18637	15444	26	setting	setting	NN
18637	15444	27	up	up	RP
18637	15444	28	or	or	CC
18637	15444	29	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	15444	30	of	of	IN
18637	15444	31	a	a	DT
18637	15444	32	state	state	NN
18637	15444	33	church	church	NN
18637	15444	34	,	,	,
18637	15444	35	or	or	CC
18637	15444	36	at	at	IN
18637	15444	37	least	least	JJS
18637	15444	38	the	the	DT
18637	15444	39	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	15444	40	upon	upon	IN
18637	15444	41	one	one	CD
18637	15444	42	church	church	NN
18637	15444	43	of	of	IN
18637	15444	44	special	special	JJ
18637	15444	45	favors	favor	NNS
18637	15444	46	and	and	CC
18637	15444	47	advantages	advantage	NNS
18637	15444	48	which	which	WDT
18637	15444	49	are	be	VBP
18637	15444	50	denied	deny	VBN
18637	15444	51	to	to	IN
18637	15444	52	others	other	NNS
18637	15444	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15444	54	citing	cite	VBG
18637	15444	55	1	1	CD
18637	15444	56	Tuck	Tuck	NNP
18637	15444	57	.	.	.
18637	15445	1	Bl	bl	UH
18637	15445	2	.	.	.
18637	15446	1	Com	com	NN
18637	15446	2	.	.	.
18637	15447	1	App	App	NNP
18637	15447	2	.	.	.
18637	15448	1	296	296	CD
18637	15448	2	;	;	:
18637	15448	3	2	2	CD
18637	15448	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15448	5	i	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15448	6	d	d	NN
18637	15448	7	.	.	.
18637	15448	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15448	9	,	,	,
18637	15448	10	App	App	NNP
18637	15448	11	.	.	.
18637	15449	1	Note	note	VB
18637	15449	2	G.	G.	NNP
18637	15449	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15449	4	.	.	.
18637	15450	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15450	2	was	be	VBD
18637	15450	3	never	never	RB
18637	15450	4	intended	intend	VBN
18637	15450	5	by	by	IN
18637	15450	6	the	the	DT
18637	15450	7	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15450	8	that	that	IN
18637	15450	9	the	the	DT
18637	15450	10	government	government	NN
18637	15450	11	should	should	MD
18637	15450	12	be	be	VB
18637	15450	13	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	15450	14	from	from	IN
18637	15450	15	recognizing	recognize	VBG
18637	15450	16	religion	religion	NN
18637	15450	17	,	,	,
18637	15450	18	*	*	NFP
18637	15450	19	*	*	NFP
18637	15450	20	*	*	NFP
18637	15450	21	where	where	WRB
18637	15450	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15450	23	might	may	MD
18637	15450	24	be	be	VB
18637	15450	25	done	do	VBN
18637	15450	26	without	without	IN
18637	15450	27	drawing	draw	VBG
18637	15450	28	any	any	DT
18637	15450	29	invidious	invidious	JJ
18637	15450	30	distinctions	distinction	NNS
18637	15450	31	between	between	IN
18637	15450	32	different	different	JJ
18637	15450	33	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15450	34	beliefs	belief	NNS
18637	15450	35	,	,	,
18637	15450	36	organizations	organization	NNS
18637	15450	37	,	,	,
18637	15450	38	or	or	CC
18637	15450	39	sects	sect	NNS
18637	15450	40	.	.	.
18637	15451	1	"	"	``
18637	15451	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15451	3	13	13	CD
18637	15451	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15451	5	THE	the	DT
18637	15451	6	"	"	``
18637	15451	7	WALL	WALL	NNP
18637	15451	8	OF	of	IN
18637	15451	9	SEPARATION	separation	NN
18637	15451	10	"	"	''
18637	15451	11	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNP
18637	15451	12	In	in	IN
18637	15451	13	1802	1802	CD
18637	15451	14	President	President	NNP
18637	15451	15	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	15451	16	wrote	write	VBD
18637	15451	17	a	a	DT
18637	15451	18	letter	letter	NN
18637	15451	19	to	to	IN
18637	15451	20	a	a	DT
18637	15451	21	group	group	NN
18637	15451	22	of	of	IN
18637	15451	23	Baptists	Baptists	NNPS
18637	15451	24	in	in	IN
18637	15451	25	Danbury	Danbury	NNP
18637	15451	26	,	,	,
18637	15451	27	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	15451	28	in	in	IN
18637	15451	29	which	which	WDT
18637	15451	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15451	31	declared	declare	VBD
18637	15451	32	that	that	IN
18637	15451	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15451	34	was	be	VBD
18637	15451	35	the	the	DT
18637	15451	36	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15451	37	of	of	IN
18637	15451	38	the	the	DT
18637	15451	39	First	First	NNP
18637	15451	40	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15451	41	to	to	TO
18637	15451	42	build	build	VB
18637	15451	43	"	"	``
18637	15451	44	a	a	DT
18637	15451	45	wall	wall	NN
18637	15451	46	of	of	IN
18637	15451	47	separation	separation	NN
18637	15451	48	between	between	IN
18637	15451	49	Church	Church	NNP
18637	15451	50	and	and	CC
18637	15451	51	State,"[14	State,"[14	NNP
18637	15451	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15451	53	and	and	CC
18637	15451	54	in	in	IN
18637	15451	55	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	15451	56	_	_	NNP
18637	15451	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	15451	58	_	_	NNP
18637	15451	59	United	United	NNP
18637	15451	60	States,[15	States,[15	NNP
18637	15451	61	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15451	62	the	the	DT
18637	15451	63	first	first	JJ
18637	15451	64	Anti	Anti	NNP
18637	15451	65	-	-	NNP
18637	15451	66	Mormon	Mormon	NNP
18637	15451	67	Case	Case	NNP
18637	15451	68	,	,	,
18637	15451	69	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15451	70	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15451	71	Waite	Waite	NNP
18637	15451	72	,	,	,
18637	15451	73	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15451	74	for	for	IN
18637	15451	75	the	the	DT
18637	15451	76	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	15451	77	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15451	78	,	,	,
18637	15451	79	characterized	characterize	VBD
18637	15451	80	this	this	DT
18637	15451	81	as	as	IN
18637	15451	82	"	"	``
18637	15451	83	almost	almost	RB
18637	15451	84	an	an	DT
18637	15451	85	authoritative	authoritative	JJ
18637	15451	86	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	15451	87	of	of	IN
18637	15451	88	the	the	DT
18637	15451	89	scope	scope	NN
18637	15451	90	and	and	CC
18637	15451	91	effect	effect	NN
18637	15451	92	of	of	IN
18637	15451	93	the	the	DT
18637	15451	94	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	15451	95	,	,	,
18637	15451	96	"	"	''
18637	15451	97	one	one	CD
18637	15451	98	which	which	WDT
18637	15451	99	left	leave	VBD
18637	15451	100	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15451	101	"	"	``
18637	15451	102	free	free	JJ
18637	15451	103	to	to	TO
18637	15451	104	reach	reach	VB
18637	15451	105	actions	action	NNS
18637	15451	106	which	which	WDT
18637	15451	107	were	be	VBD
18637	15451	108	in	in	IN
18637	15451	109	violation	violation	NN
18637	15451	110	of	of	IN
18637	15451	111	social	social	JJ
18637	15451	112	duties	duty	NNS
18637	15451	113	or	or	CC
18637	15451	114	subversive	subversive	NN
18637	15451	115	of	of	IN
18637	15451	116	good	good	JJ
18637	15451	117	order	order	NN
18637	15451	118	.	.	.
18637	15452	1	"	"	``
18637	15452	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15452	3	16	16	CD
18637	15452	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15452	5	Recently	recently	RB
18637	15452	6	the	the	DT
18637	15452	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15452	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	15452	9	given	give	VBN
18637	15452	10	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	15452	11	's	's	POS
18637	15452	12	"	"	``
18637	15452	13	almost	almost	RB
18637	15452	14	authoritative	authoritative	JJ
18637	15452	15	"	"	''
18637	15452	16	pronouncement	pronouncement	NN
18637	15452	17	a	a	DT
18637	15452	18	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	15452	19	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
18637	15452	20	application	application	NN
18637	15452	21	.	.	.
18637	15453	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15453	2	by	by	IN
18637	15453	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15453	4	Black	Black	NNP
18637	15453	5	,	,	,
18637	15453	6	a	a	DT
18637	15453	7	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	15453	8	divided	divide	VBN
18637	15453	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15453	10	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15453	11	in	in	IN
18637	15453	12	1947	1947	CD
18637	15453	13	the	the	DT
18637	15453	14	right	right	NN
18637	15453	15	of	of	IN
18637	15453	16	local	local	JJ
18637	15453	17	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	15453	18	in	in	IN
18637	15453	19	New	New	NNP
18637	15453	20	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	15453	21	to	to	TO
18637	15453	22	provide	provide	VB
18637	15453	23	free	free	JJ
18637	15453	24	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	15453	25	for	for	IN
18637	15453	26	children	child	NNS
18637	15453	27	attending	attend	VBG
18637	15453	28	parochial	parochial	JJ
18637	15453	29	schools,[17	schools,[17	CD
18637	15453	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15453	31	but	but	CC
18637	15453	32	accompanied	accompany	VBD
18637	15453	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15453	34	holding	holding	NN
18637	15453	35	with	with	IN
18637	15453	36	these	these	DT
18637	15453	37	warning	warning	NN
18637	15453	38	words	word	NNS
18637	15453	39	,	,	,
18637	15453	40	which	which	WDT
18637	15453	41	appear	appear	VBP
18637	15453	42	to	to	TO
18637	15453	43	have	have	VB
18637	15453	44	had	have	VBN
18637	15453	45	the	the	DT
18637	15453	46	approval	approval	NN
18637	15453	47	of	of	IN
18637	15453	48	most	most	JJS
18637	15453	49	of	of	IN
18637	15453	50	the	the	DT
18637	15453	51	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15453	52	:	:	:
18637	15453	53	"	"	``
18637	15453	54	The	the	DT
18637	15453	55	'	'	''
18637	15453	56	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	15453	57	of	of	IN
18637	15453	58	religion	religion	NN
18637	15453	59	'	'	''
18637	15453	60	clause	clause	NN
18637	15453	61	of	of	IN
18637	15453	62	the	the	DT
18637	15453	63	First	First	NNP
18637	15453	64	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15453	65	means	mean	VBZ
18637	15453	66	at	at	IN
18637	15453	67	least	least	JJS
18637	15453	68	this	this	DT
18637	15453	69	:	:	:
18637	15453	70	Neither	neither	CC
18637	15453	71	a	a	DT
18637	15453	72	state	state	NN
18637	15453	73	nor	nor	CC
18637	15453	74	the	the	DT
18637	15453	75	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	15453	76	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15453	77	can	can	MD
18637	15453	78	set	set	VB
18637	15453	79	up	up	RP
18637	15453	80	a	a	DT
18637	15453	81	church	church	NN
18637	15453	82	.	.	.
18637	15454	1	Neither	neither	DT
18637	15454	2	can	can	MD
18637	15454	3	pass	pass	VB
18637	15454	4	laws	law	NNS
18637	15454	5	which	which	WDT
18637	15454	6	aid	aid	VBP
18637	15454	7	one	one	CD
18637	15454	8	religion	religion	NN
18637	15454	9	,	,	,
18637	15454	10	aid	aid	VB
18637	15454	11	all	all	DT
18637	15454	12	religions	religion	NNS
18637	15454	13	,	,	,
18637	15454	14	or	or	CC
18637	15454	15	prefer	prefer	VB
18637	15454	16	one	one	CD
18637	15454	17	religion	religion	NN
18637	15454	18	over	over	IN
18637	15454	19	another	another	DT
18637	15454	20	.	.	.
18637	15455	1	Neither	neither	DT
18637	15455	2	can	can	MD
18637	15455	3	force	force	VB
18637	15455	4	nor	nor	CC
18637	15455	5	influence	influence	VB
18637	15455	6	a	a	DT
18637	15455	7	person	person	NN
18637	15455	8	to	to	TO
18637	15455	9	go	go	VB
18637	15455	10	to	to	IN
18637	15455	11	or	or	CC
18637	15455	12	to	to	TO
18637	15455	13	remain	remain	VB
18637	15455	14	away	away	RB
18637	15455	15	from	from	IN
18637	15455	16	church	church	NN
18637	15455	17	against	against	IN
18637	15455	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15455	19	will	will	NN
18637	15455	20	or	or	CC
18637	15455	21	force	force	VB
18637	15455	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15455	23	to	to	TO
18637	15455	24	profess	profess	VB
18637	15455	25	a	a	DT
18637	15455	26	belief	belief	NN
18637	15455	27	or	or	CC
18637	15455	28	disbelief	disbelief	NN
18637	15455	29	in	in	IN
18637	15455	30	any	any	DT
18637	15455	31	religion	religion	NN
18637	15455	32	.	.	.
18637	15456	1	No	no	DT
18637	15456	2	person	person	NN
18637	15456	3	can	can	MD
18637	15456	4	be	be	VB
18637	15456	5	punished	punish	VBN
18637	15456	6	for	for	IN
18637	15456	7	entertaining	entertain	VBG
18637	15456	8	or	or	CC
18637	15456	9	professing	profess	VBG
18637	15456	10	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15456	11	beliefs	belief	NNS
18637	15456	12	or	or	CC
18637	15456	13	disbeliefs	disbelief	NNS
18637	15456	14	,	,	,
18637	15456	15	for	for	IN
18637	15456	16	church	church	NN
18637	15456	17	attendance	attendance	NN
18637	15456	18	or	or	CC
18637	15456	19	non	non	NN
18637	15456	20	-	-	NN
18637	15456	21	attendance	attendance	NN
18637	15456	22	.	.	.
18637	15457	1	No	no	DT
18637	15457	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	15457	3	in	in	IN
18637	15457	4	any	any	DT
18637	15457	5	amount	amount	NN
18637	15457	6	,	,	,
18637	15457	7	large	large	JJ
18637	15457	8	or	or	CC
18637	15457	9	small	small	JJ
18637	15457	10	,	,	,
18637	15457	11	can	can	MD
18637	15457	12	be	be	VB
18637	15457	13	levied	levy	VBN
18637	15457	14	to	to	TO
18637	15457	15	support	support	VB
18637	15457	16	any	any	DT
18637	15457	17	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15457	18	activities	activity	NNS
18637	15457	19	or	or	CC
18637	15457	20	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	15457	21	,	,	,
18637	15457	22	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	15457	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15457	24	may	may	MD
18637	15457	25	be	be	VB
18637	15457	26	called	call	VBN
18637	15457	27	,	,	,
18637	15457	28	or	or	CC
18637	15457	29	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	15457	30	form	form	NN
18637	15457	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15457	32	may	may	MD
18637	15457	33	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	15457	34	to	to	TO
18637	15457	35	teach	teach	VB
18637	15457	36	or	or	CC
18637	15457	37	practice	practice	VB
18637	15457	38	religion	religion	NN
18637	15457	39	.	.	.
18637	15458	1	Neither	neither	CC
18637	15458	2	a	a	DT
18637	15458	3	state	state	NN
18637	15458	4	nor	nor	CC
18637	15458	5	the	the	DT
18637	15458	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	15458	7	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15458	8	can	can	MD
18637	15458	9	,	,	,
18637	15458	10	openly	openly	RB
18637	15458	11	or	or	CC
18637	15458	12	secretly	secretly	RB
18637	15458	13	,	,	,
18637	15458	14	participate	participate	VB
18637	15458	15	in	in	IN
18637	15458	16	the	the	DT
18637	15458	17	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	15458	18	of	of	IN
18637	15458	19	any	any	DT
18637	15458	20	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15458	21	organizations	organization	NNS
18637	15458	22	of	of	IN
18637	15458	23	groups	group	NNS
18637	15458	24	and	and	CC
18637	15458	25	_	_	NNP
18637	15458	26	vice	vice	NN
18637	15458	27	versa	versa	NNP
18637	15458	28	_	_	NNP
18637	15458	29	.	.	.
18637	15459	1	"	"	``
18637	15459	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15459	3	18	18	CD
18637	15459	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15459	5	And	and	CC
18637	15459	6	a	a	DT
18637	15459	7	year	year	NN
18637	15459	8	later	later	RB
18637	15459	9	a	a	DT
18637	15459	10	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	15459	11	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	15459	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15459	13	overturned	overturn	VBD
18637	15459	14	on	on	IN
18637	15459	15	the	the	DT
18637	15459	16	above	above	JJ
18637	15459	17	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	15459	18	a	a	DT
18637	15459	19	"	"	``
18637	15459	20	released	release	VBN
18637	15459	21	time	time	NN
18637	15459	22	"	"	''
18637	15459	23	arrangement	arrangement	NN
18637	15459	24	under	under	IN
18637	15459	25	which	which	WDT
18637	15459	26	the	the	DT
18637	15459	27	Champaign	Champaign	NNP
18637	15459	28	,	,	,
18637	15459	29	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	15459	30	Board	Board	NNP
18637	15459	31	of	of	IN
18637	15459	32	Education	Education	NNP
18637	15459	33	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	15459	34	that	that	IN
18637	15459	35	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15459	36	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	15459	37	should	should	MD
18637	15459	38	be	be	VB
18637	15459	39	given	give	VBN
18637	15459	40	in	in	IN
18637	15459	41	the	the	DT
18637	15459	42	local	local	JJ
18637	15459	43	schools	school	NNS
18637	15459	44	to	to	IN
18637	15459	45	pupils	pupil	NNS
18637	15459	46	whose	whose	WP$
18637	15459	47	parents	parent	NNS
18637	15459	48	signed	sign	VBD
18637	15459	49	"	"	``
18637	15459	50	request	request	NN
18637	15459	51	cards	card	NNS
18637	15459	52	.	.	.
18637	15459	53	"	"	''
18637	15460	1	The	the	DT
18637	15460	2	classes	class	NNS
18637	15460	3	were	be	VBD
18637	15460	4	to	to	TO
18637	15460	5	be	be	VB
18637	15460	6	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	15460	7	during	during	IN
18637	15460	8	regular	regular	JJ
18637	15460	9	school	school	NN
18637	15460	10	hours	hour	NNS
18637	15460	11	in	in	IN
18637	15460	12	the	the	DT
18637	15460	13	school	school	NN
18637	15460	14	building	building	NN
18637	15460	15	by	by	IN
18637	15460	16	outside	outside	JJ
18637	15460	17	teachers	teacher	NNS
18637	15460	18	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	15460	19	by	by	IN
18637	15460	20	a	a	DT
18637	15460	21	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15460	22	council	council	NN
18637	15460	23	representing	represent	VBG
18637	15460	24	the	the	DT
18637	15460	25	various	various	JJ
18637	15460	26	faiths	faith	NNS
18637	15460	27	,	,	,
18637	15460	28	subject	subject	JJ
18637	15460	29	to	to	IN
18637	15460	30	the	the	DT
18637	15460	31	approval	approval	NN
18637	15460	32	or	or	CC
18637	15460	33	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	15460	34	of	of	IN
18637	15460	35	the	the	DT
18637	15460	36	superintendent	superintendent	NN
18637	15460	37	of	of	IN
18637	15460	38	schools	school	NNS
18637	15460	39	.	.	.
18637	15461	1	Attendance	attendance	NN
18637	15461	2	records	record	NNS
18637	15461	3	were	be	VBD
18637	15461	4	kept	keep	VBN
18637	15461	5	and	and	CC
18637	15461	6	reported	report	VBN
18637	15461	7	to	to	IN
18637	15461	8	the	the	DT
18637	15461	9	school	school	NN
18637	15461	10	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	15461	11	in	in	IN
18637	15461	12	the	the	DT
18637	15461	13	same	same	JJ
18637	15461	14	way	way	NN
18637	15461	15	as	as	IN
18637	15461	16	for	for	IN
18637	15461	17	other	other	JJ
18637	15461	18	classes	class	NNS
18637	15461	19	;	;	,
18637	15461	20	and	and	CC
18637	15461	21	pupils	pupil	VBZ
18637	15461	22	not	not	RB
18637	15461	23	attending	attend	VBG
18637	15461	24	the	the	DT
18637	15461	25	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15461	26	-	-	HYPH
18637	15461	27	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	15461	28	classes	class	NNS
18637	15461	29	were	be	VBD
18637	15461	30	required	require	VBN
18637	15461	31	to	to	TO
18637	15461	32	continue	continue	VB
18637	15461	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15461	34	regular	regular	JJ
18637	15461	35	secular	secular	JJ
18637	15461	36	studies	study	NNS
18637	15461	37	.	.	.
18637	15462	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15462	2	19	19	CD
18637	15462	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15462	4	Said	Said	NNP
18637	15462	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15462	6	Black	Black	NNP
18637	15462	7	,	,	,
18637	15462	8	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15462	9	for	for	IN
18637	15462	10	the	the	DT
18637	15462	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15462	12	:	:	:
18637	15462	13	"	"	``
18637	15462	14	Here	here	RB
18637	15462	15	not	not	RB
18637	15462	16	only	only	RB
18637	15462	17	are	be	VBP
18637	15462	18	the	the	DT
18637	15462	19	State	State	NNP
18637	15462	20	's	's	POS
18637	15462	21	tax	tax	NN
18637	15462	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	15462	23	supported	support	VBN
18637	15462	24	public	public	JJ
18637	15462	25	school	school	NN
18637	15462	26	buildings	building	NNS
18637	15462	27	used	use	VBN
18637	15462	28	for	for	IN
18637	15462	29	the	the	DT
18637	15462	30	dissemination	dissemination	NN
18637	15462	31	of	of	IN
18637	15462	32	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15462	33	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	15462	34	.	.	.
18637	15463	1	The	the	DT
18637	15463	2	State	State	NNP
18637	15463	3	also	also	RB
18637	15463	4	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	15463	5	sectarian	sectarian	JJ
18637	15463	6	groups	group	NNS
18637	15463	7	an	an	DT
18637	15463	8	invaluable	invaluable	JJ
18637	15463	9	aid	aid	NN
18637	15463	10	in	in	IN
18637	15463	11	that	that	IN
18637	15463	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15463	13	helps	help	VBZ
18637	15463	14	to	to	TO
18637	15463	15	provide	provide	VB
18637	15463	16	pupils	pupil	NNS
18637	15463	17	for	for	IN
18637	15463	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15463	19	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15463	20	classes	class	NNS
18637	15463	21	through	through	IN
18637	15463	22	use	use	NN
18637	15463	23	of	of	IN
18637	15463	24	the	the	DT
18637	15463	25	State	State	NNP
18637	15463	26	's	's	POS
18637	15463	27	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	15463	28	public	public	JJ
18637	15463	29	school	school	NN
18637	15463	30	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	15463	31	.	.	.
18637	15464	1	This	this	DT
18637	15464	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15464	3	not	not	RB
18637	15464	4	separation	separation	NN
18637	15464	5	of	of	IN
18637	15464	6	Church	Church	NNP
18637	15464	7	and	and	CC
18637	15464	8	State	State	NNP
18637	15464	9	.	.	.
18637	15465	1	"	"	``
18637	15465	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15465	3	20	20	CD
18637	15465	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15465	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15465	6	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	15465	7	presented	present	VBD
18637	15465	8	a	a	DT
18637	15465	9	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	15465	10	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15465	11	for	for	IN
18637	15465	12	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15465	13	and	and	CC
18637	15465	14	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15465	15	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	15465	16	,	,	,
18637	15465	17	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	15465	18	and	and	CC
18637	15465	19	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	15465	20	.	.	.
18637	15466	1	"	"	``
18637	15466	2	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15466	3	are	be	VBP
18637	15466	4	all	all	RB
18637	15466	5	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	15466	6	,	,	,
18637	15466	7	"	"	''
18637	15466	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15466	9	begins	begin	VBZ
18637	15466	10	,	,	,
18637	15466	11	"	"	``
18637	15466	12	that	that	IN
18637	15466	13	the	the	DT
18637	15466	14	First	first	JJ
18637	15466	15	and	and	CC
18637	15466	16	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15466	17	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	15466	18	have	have	VBP
18637	15466	19	a	a	DT
18637	15466	20	secular	secular	JJ
18637	15466	21	reach	reach	NN
18637	15466	22	far	far	RB
18637	15466	23	more	more	JJR
18637	15466	24	penetrating	penetrating	NN
18637	15466	25	in	in	IN
18637	15466	26	the	the	DT
18637	15466	27	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	15466	28	of	of	IN
18637	15466	29	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15466	30	than	than	IN
18637	15466	31	merely	merely	RB
18637	15466	32	to	to	TO
18637	15466	33	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	15466	34	an	an	DT
18637	15466	35	'	'	``
18637	15466	36	established	establish	VBN
18637	15466	37	church	church	NN
18637	15466	38	.	.	.
18637	15467	1	'	'	``
18637	15467	2	"	"	``
18637	15467	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15467	4	21	21	CD
18637	15467	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15467	6	What	what	WP
18637	15467	7	ensues	ensue	VBZ
18637	15467	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	15467	9	a	a	DT
18637	15467	10	well	well	RB
18637	15467	11	documented	document	VBN
18637	15467	12	account	account	NN
18637	15467	13	of	of	IN
18637	15467	14	the	the	DT
18637	15467	15	elimination	elimination	NN
18637	15467	16	of	of	IN
18637	15467	17	sectarianism	sectarianism	NN
18637	15467	18	from	from	IN
18637	15467	19	the	the	DT
18637	15467	20	American	american	JJ
18637	15467	21	school	school	NN
18637	15467	22	system	system	NN
18637	15467	23	which	which	WDT
18637	15467	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	15467	25	reinterpreted	reinterpret	VBN
18637	15467	26	as	as	IN
18637	15467	27	a	a	DT
18637	15467	28	fight	fight	NN
18637	15467	29	for	for	IN
18637	15467	30	the	the	DT
18637	15467	31	secularization	secularization	NN
18637	15467	32	of	of	IN
18637	15467	33	public	public	NNP
18637	15467	34	supported	support	VBN
18637	15467	35	education	education	NN
18637	15467	36	.	.	.
18637	15468	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15468	2	22	22	CD
18637	15468	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15468	4	Facing	face	VBG
18637	15468	5	then	then	RB
18637	15468	6	the	the	DT
18637	15468	7	emergence	emergence	NN
18637	15468	8	of	of	IN
18637	15468	9	the	the	DT
18637	15468	10	"	"	``
18637	15468	11	released	release	VBN
18637	15468	12	time	time	NN
18637	15468	13	"	"	''
18637	15468	14	expedient,[23	expedient,[23	CD
18637	15468	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15468	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15468	17	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	15468	18	characterizes	characterize	VBZ
18637	15468	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15468	20	as	as	IN
18637	15468	21	a	a	DT
18637	15468	22	"	"	``
18637	15468	23	conscientious	conscientious	JJ
18637	15468	24	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	15468	25	to	to	TO
18637	15468	26	accommodate	accommodate	VB
18637	15468	27	the	the	DT
18637	15468	28	allowable	allowable	JJ
18637	15468	29	functions	function	NNS
18637	15468	30	of	of	IN
18637	15468	31	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15468	32	and	and	CC
18637	15468	33	the	the	DT
18637	15468	34	special	special	JJ
18637	15468	35	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	15468	36	of	of	IN
18637	15468	37	the	the	DT
18637	15468	38	Church	Church	NNP
18637	15468	39	within	within	IN
18637	15468	40	the	the	DT
18637	15468	41	framework	framework	NN
18637	15468	42	of	of	IN
18637	15468	43	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15468	44	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15468	45	.	.	.
18637	15469	1	"	"	``
18637	15469	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15469	3	24	24	CD
18637	15469	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15469	5	Elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	15469	6	in	in	IN
18637	15469	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15469	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15469	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15469	10	states	state	VBZ
18637	15469	11	:	:	:
18637	15469	12	"	"	``
18637	15469	13	Of	of	RB
18637	15469	14	course	course	RB
18637	15469	15	,	,	,
18637	15469	16	'	'	''
18637	15469	17	released	release	VBN
18637	15469	18	time	time	NN
18637	15469	19	'	'	''
18637	15469	20	as	as	IN
18637	15469	21	a	a	DT
18637	15469	22	generalized	generalize	VBN
18637	15469	23	conception	conception	NN
18637	15469	24	,	,	,
18637	15469	25	undefined	undefined	JJ
18637	15469	26	by	by	IN
18637	15469	27	differentiating	differentiate	VBG
18637	15469	28	particularities	particularity	NNS
18637	15469	29	,	,	,
18637	15469	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	15469	31	not	not	RB
18637	15469	32	an	an	DT
18637	15469	33	issue	issue	NN
18637	15469	34	for	for	IN
18637	15469	35	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15469	36	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	15469	37	.	.	.
18637	15470	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15470	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15470	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15470	4	The	the	DT
18637	15470	5	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	15470	6	differences	difference	NNS
18637	15470	7	among	among	IN
18637	15470	8	arrangements	arrangement	NNS
18637	15470	9	lumped	lump	VBN
18637	15470	10	together	together	RB
18637	15470	11	as	as	IN
18637	15470	12	'	'	``
18637	15470	13	released	release	VBN
18637	15470	14	time	time	NN
18637	15470	15	'	'	''
18637	15470	16	emphasize	emphasize	VB
18637	15470	17	the	the	DT
18637	15470	18	importance	importance	NN
18637	15470	19	of	of	IN
18637	15470	20	detailed	detailed	JJ
18637	15470	21	analysis	analysis	NN
18637	15470	22	of	of	IN
18637	15470	23	the	the	DT
18637	15470	24	facts	fact	NNS
18637	15470	25	to	to	TO
18637	15470	26	which	which	WDT
18637	15470	27	the	the	DT
18637	15470	28	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15470	29	test	test	NN
18637	15470	30	of	of	IN
18637	15470	31	Separation	separation	NN
18637	15470	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	15470	33	to	to	TO
18637	15470	34	be	be	VB
18637	15470	35	applied	apply	VBN
18637	15470	36	.	.	.
18637	15471	1	How	how	WRB
18637	15471	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	15471	3	'	'	``
18637	15471	4	released	release	VBN
18637	15471	5	time	time	NN
18637	15471	6	'	'	''
18637	15471	7	operate	operate	NN
18637	15471	8	in	in	IN
18637	15471	9	Champaign	Champaign	NNP
18637	15471	10	?	?	.
18637	15472	1	"	"	``
18637	15472	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15472	3	25	25	CD
18637	15472	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15472	5	And	and	CC
18637	15472	6	again	again	RB
18637	15472	7	:	:	:
18637	15472	8	"	"	``
18637	15472	9	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15472	10	do	do	VBP
18637	15472	11	not	not	RB
18637	15472	12	consider	consider	VB
18637	15472	13	,	,	,
18637	15472	14	as	as	RB
18637	15472	15	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	15472	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15472	17	could	could	MD
18637	15472	18	not	not	RB
18637	15472	19	,	,	,
18637	15472	20	school	school	NN
18637	15472	21	programs	program	NNS
18637	15472	22	not	not	RB
18637	15472	23	before	before	IN
18637	15472	24	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15472	25	which	which	WDT
18637	15472	26	,	,	,
18637	15472	27	though	though	IN
18637	15472	28	colloquially	colloquially	RB
18637	15472	29	characterized	characterize	VBN
18637	15472	30	as	as	IN
18637	15472	31	'	'	``
18637	15472	32	released	release	VBN
18637	15472	33	time	time	NN
18637	15472	34	,	,	,
18637	15472	35	'	'	''
18637	15472	36	present	present	JJ
18637	15472	37	situations	situation	NNS
18637	15472	38	differing	differ	VBG
18637	15472	39	in	in	IN
18637	15472	40	aspects	aspect	NNS
18637	15472	41	that	that	WDT
18637	15472	42	may	may	MD
18637	15472	43	well	well	RB
18637	15472	44	be	be	VB
18637	15472	45	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	15472	46	crucial	crucial	JJ
18637	15472	47	.	.	.
18637	15473	1	Different	different	JJ
18637	15473	2	forms	form	NNS
18637	15473	3	which	which	WDT
18637	15473	4	'	'	``
18637	15473	5	released	release	VBN
18637	15473	6	time	time	NN
18637	15473	7	'	'	''
18637	15473	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	15473	9	taken	take	VBN
18637	15473	10	during	during	IN
18637	15473	11	more	more	JJR
18637	15473	12	than	than	IN
18637	15473	13	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	15473	14	years	year	NNS
18637	15473	15	of	of	IN
18637	15473	16	growth	growth	NN
18637	15473	17	include	include	VBP
18637	15473	18	programs	program	NNS
18637	15473	19	which	which	WDT
18637	15473	20	,	,	,
18637	15473	21	like	like	IN
18637	15473	22	that	that	DT
18637	15473	23	before	before	IN
18637	15473	24	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15473	25	,	,	,
18637	15473	26	could	could	MD
18637	15473	27	not	not	RB
18637	15473	28	withstand	withstand	VB
18637	15473	29	the	the	DT
18637	15473	30	test	test	NN
18637	15473	31	of	of	IN
18637	15473	32	the	the	DT
18637	15473	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15473	34	;	;	:
18637	15473	35	others	other	NNS
18637	15473	36	may	may	MD
18637	15473	37	be	be	VB
18637	15473	38	found	find	VBN
18637	15473	39	unexceptionable	unexceptionable	JJ
18637	15473	40	.	.	.
18637	15474	1	"	"	``
18637	15474	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15474	3	26	26	CD
18637	15474	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15474	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15474	6	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	15474	7	added	add	VBD
18637	15474	8	further	further	JJ
18637	15474	9	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	15474	10	of	of	IN
18637	15474	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15474	12	own	own	JJ
18637	15474	13	as	as	IN
18637	15474	14	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	15474	15	:	:	:
18637	15474	16	"	"	``
18637	15474	17	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15474	18	should	should	MD
18637	15474	19	place	place	VB
18637	15474	20	some	some	DT
18637	15474	21	bounds	bound	NNS
18637	15474	22	on	on	IN
18637	15474	23	the	the	DT
18637	15474	24	demands	demand	NNS
18637	15474	25	for	for	IN
18637	15474	26	interference	interference	NN
18637	15474	27	with	with	IN
18637	15474	28	local	local	JJ
18637	15474	29	schools	school	NNS
18637	15474	30	that	that	WDT
18637	15474	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15474	32	are	be	VBP
18637	15474	33	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	15474	34	or	or	CC
18637	15474	35	willing	willing	JJ
18637	15474	36	to	to	TO
18637	15474	37	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	15474	38	.	.	.
18637	15475	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15475	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15475	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15475	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15475	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	15475	6	important	important	JJ
18637	15475	7	that	that	IN
18637	15475	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15475	9	circumscribe	circumscribe	VBP
18637	15475	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15475	11	decision	decision	NN
18637	15475	12	with	with	IN
18637	15475	13	some	some	DT
18637	15475	14	care	care	NN
18637	15475	15	.	.	.
18637	15476	1	"	"	``
18637	15476	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15476	3	27	27	CD
18637	15476	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15476	5	In	in	IN
18637	15476	6	a	a	DT
18637	15476	7	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	15476	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15476	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15476	10	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	15476	11	took	take	VBD
18637	15476	12	exception	exception	NN
18637	15476	13	to	to	IN
18637	15476	14	the	the	DT
18637	15476	15	extended	extended	JJ
18637	15476	16	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	15476	17	given	give	VBN
18637	15476	18	to	to	IN
18637	15476	19	the	the	DT
18637	15476	20	words	word	NNS
18637	15476	21	"	"	``
18637	15476	22	an	an	DT
18637	15476	23	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	15476	24	of	of	IN
18637	15476	25	religion	religion	NN
18637	15476	26	.	.	.
18637	15476	27	"	"	''
18637	15477	1	"	"	``
18637	15477	2	The	the	DT
18637	15477	3	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	15477	4	'	'	''
18637	15477	5	an	an	DT
18637	15477	6	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	15477	7	of	of	IN
18637	15477	8	religion	religion	NN
18637	15477	9	,	,	,
18637	15477	10	'	'	''
18637	15477	11	"	"	''
18637	15477	12	said	say	VBD
18637	15477	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15477	14	,	,	,
18637	15477	15	"	"	``
18637	15477	16	may	may	MD
18637	15477	17	have	have	VB
18637	15477	18	been	be	VBN
18637	15477	19	intended	intend	VBN
18637	15477	20	by	by	IN
18637	15477	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15477	22	to	to	TO
18637	15477	23	be	be	VB
18637	15477	24	aimed	aim	VBN
18637	15477	25	only	only	RB
18637	15477	26	at	at	IN
18637	15477	27	a	a	DT
18637	15477	28	state	state	NN
18637	15477	29	church	church	NN
18637	15477	30	.	.	.
18637	15478	1	When	when	WRB
18637	15478	2	the	the	DT
18637	15478	3	First	First	NNP
18637	15478	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15478	5	was	be	VBD
18637	15478	6	pending	pende	VBG
18637	15478	7	in	in	IN
18637	15478	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15478	9	in	in	IN
18637	15478	10	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	15478	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15478	12	present	present	JJ
18637	15478	13	form	form	NN
18637	15478	14	,	,	,
18637	15478	15	'	'	''
18637	15478	16	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	15479	1	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	15479	2	said	say	VBD
18637	15479	3	,	,	,
18637	15479	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15479	5	apprehended	apprehend	VBD
18637	15479	6	the	the	DT
18637	15479	7	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	15479	8	of	of	IN
18637	15479	9	the	the	DT
18637	15479	10	words	word	NNS
18637	15479	11	to	to	TO
18637	15479	12	be	be	VB
18637	15479	13	,	,	,
18637	15479	14	that	that	IN
18637	15479	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15479	16	should	should	MD
18637	15479	17	not	not	RB
18637	15479	18	establish	establish	VB
18637	15479	19	a	a	DT
18637	15479	20	religion	religion	NN
18637	15479	21	,	,	,
18637	15479	22	and	and	CC
18637	15479	23	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	15479	24	the	the	DT
18637	15479	25	legal	legal	JJ
18637	15479	26	observation	observation	NN
18637	15479	27	of	of	IN
18637	15479	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15479	29	by	by	IN
18637	15479	30	law	law	NN
18637	15479	31	,	,	,
18637	15479	32	nor	nor	CC
18637	15479	33	compel	compel	NN
18637	15479	34	men	man	NNS
18637	15479	35	to	to	TO
18637	15479	36	worship	worship	VB
18637	15479	37	God	God	NNP
18637	15479	38	in	in	IN
18637	15479	39	any	any	DT
18637	15479	40	manner	manner	NN
18637	15479	41	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	15479	42	to	to	IN
18637	15479	43	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15479	44	conscience	conscience	NN
18637	15479	45	.	.	.
18637	15479	46	'	'	''
18637	15480	1	Passing	pass	VBG
18637	15480	2	years	year	NNS
18637	15480	3	,	,	,
18637	15480	4	however	however	RB
18637	15480	5	,	,	,
18637	15480	6	have	have	VBP
18637	15480	7	brought	bring	VBN
18637	15480	8	about	about	RP
18637	15480	9	the	the	DT
18637	15480	10	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	15480	11	of	of	IN
18637	15480	12	a	a	DT
18637	15480	13	broader	broad	JJR
18637	15480	14	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	15480	15	,	,	,
18637	15480	16	although	although	IN
18637	15480	17	never	never	RB
18637	15480	18	until	until	IN
18637	15480	19	today	today	NN
18637	15480	20	,	,	,
18637	15480	21	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15480	22	believe	believe	VBP
18637	15480	23	,	,	,
18637	15480	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	15480	25	this	this	DT
18637	15480	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15480	27	widened	widen	VBD
18637	15480	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15480	29	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	15480	30	to	to	IN
18637	15480	31	any	any	DT
18637	15480	32	such	such	JJ
18637	15480	33	degree	degree	NN
18637	15480	34	as	as	IN
18637	15480	35	holding	hold	VBG
18637	15480	36	that	that	DT
18637	15480	37	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	15480	38	of	of	IN
18637	15480	39	the	the	DT
18637	15480	40	interest	interest	NN
18637	15480	41	of	of	IN
18637	15480	42	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15480	43	nation	nation	NN
18637	15480	44	in	in	IN
18637	15480	45	religion	religion	NN
18637	15480	46	,	,	,
18637	15480	47	through	through	IN
18637	15480	48	the	the	DT
18637	15480	49	granting	granting	NN
18637	15480	50	,	,	,
18637	15480	51	to	to	IN
18637	15480	52	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	15480	53	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	15480	54	of	of	IN
18637	15480	55	the	the	DT
18637	15480	56	principal	principal	JJ
18637	15480	57	faiths	faith	NNS
18637	15480	58	,	,	,
18637	15480	59	of	of	IN
18637	15480	60	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	15480	61	to	to	TO
18637	15480	62	present	present	VB
18637	15480	63	religion	religion	NN
18637	15480	64	as	as	IN
18637	15480	65	an	an	DT
18637	15480	66	optional	optional	JJ
18637	15480	67	,	,	,
18637	15480	68	extracurricular	extracurricular	JJ
18637	15480	69	subject	subject	NN
18637	15480	70	during	during	IN
18637	15480	71	released	release	VBN
18637	15480	72	school	school	NN
18637	15480	73	time	time	NN
18637	15480	74	in	in	IN
18637	15480	75	public	public	JJ
18637	15480	76	school	school	NN
18637	15480	77	buildings	building	NNS
18637	15480	78	,	,	,
18637	15480	79	was	be	VBD
18637	15480	80	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
18637	15480	81	to	to	IN
18637	15480	82	an	an	DT
18637	15480	83	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	15480	84	of	of	IN
18637	15480	85	religion	religion	NN
18637	15480	86	.	.	.
18637	15481	1	"	"	``
18637	15481	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15481	3	28	28	CD
18637	15481	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15481	5	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15481	6	further	further	RB
18637	15481	7	pointed	point	VBD
18637	15481	8	out	out	RP
18637	15481	9	that	that	IN
18637	15481	10	"	"	``
18637	15481	11	the	the	DT
18637	15481	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15481	13	of	of	IN
18637	15481	14	the	the	DT
18637	15481	15	United	United	NNP
18637	15481	16	States	States	NNP
18637	15481	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	15481	18	a	a	DT
18637	15481	19	chaplain	chaplain	NN
18637	15481	20	for	for	IN
18637	15481	21	each	each	DT
18637	15481	22	House	House	NNP
18637	15481	23	who	who	WP
18637	15481	24	daily	daily	RB
18637	15481	25	invokes	invoke	VBZ
18637	15481	26	divine	divine	JJ
18637	15481	27	blessings	blessing	NNS
18637	15481	28	and	and	CC
18637	15481	29	guidance	guidance	NN
18637	15481	30	for	for	IN
18637	15481	31	the	the	DT
18637	15481	32	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	15481	33	.	.	.
18637	15482	1	The	the	DT
18637	15482	2	armed	armed	JJ
18637	15482	3	forces	force	NNS
18637	15482	4	have	have	VBP
18637	15482	5	commissioned	commission	VBN
18637	15482	6	chaplains	chaplain	NNS
18637	15482	7	from	from	IN
18637	15482	8	early	early	JJ
18637	15482	9	days	day	NNS
18637	15482	10	.	.	.
18637	15483	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15483	2	conduct	conduct	VBP
18637	15483	3	the	the	DT
18637	15483	4	public	public	JJ
18637	15483	5	services	service	NNS
18637	15483	6	in	in	IN
18637	15483	7	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	15483	8	with	with	IN
18637	15483	9	the	the	DT
18637	15483	10	liturgical	liturgical	JJ
18637	15483	11	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	15483	12	of	of	IN
18637	15483	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15483	14	respective	respective	JJ
18637	15483	15	faiths	faith	NNS
18637	15483	16	,	,	,
18637	15483	17	ashore	ashore	RB
18637	15483	18	and	and	CC
18637	15483	19	afloat	afloat	RB
18637	15483	20	,	,	,
18637	15483	21	employing	employ	VBG
18637	15483	22	for	for	IN
18637	15483	23	the	the	DT
18637	15483	24	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15483	25	property	property	NN
18637	15483	26	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	15483	27	to	to	IN
18637	15483	28	the	the	DT
18637	15483	29	United	United	NNP
18637	15483	30	States	States	NNP
18637	15483	31	and	and	CC
18637	15483	32	dedicated	dedicate	VBN
18637	15483	33	to	to	IN
18637	15483	34	the	the	DT
18637	15483	35	services	service	NNS
18637	15483	36	of	of	IN
18637	15483	37	religion	religion	NN
18637	15483	38	.	.	.
18637	15484	1	Under	under	IN
18637	15484	2	the	the	DT
18637	15484	3	Servicemen	Servicemen	NNP
18637	15484	4	's	's	POS
18637	15484	5	Readjustment	Readjustment	NNP
18637	15484	6	Act	Act	NNP
18637	15484	7	of	of	IN
18637	15484	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	15484	9	,	,	,
18637	15484	10	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	15484	11	veterans	veteran	NNS
18637	15484	12	may	may	MD
18637	15484	13	receive	receive	VB
18637	15484	14	training	training	NN
18637	15484	15	at	at	IN
18637	15484	16	government	government	NN
18637	15484	17	expense	expense	NN
18637	15484	18	for	for	IN
18637	15484	19	the	the	DT
18637	15484	20	ministry	ministry	NN
18637	15484	21	in	in	IN
18637	15484	22	denominational	denominational	JJ
18637	15484	23	schools	school	NNS
18637	15484	24	.	.	.
18637	15485	1	The	the	DT
18637	15485	2	schools	school	NNS
18637	15485	3	of	of	IN
18637	15485	4	the	the	DT
18637	15485	5	District	District	NNP
18637	15485	6	of	of	IN
18637	15485	7	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	15485	8	have	have	VBP
18637	15485	9	opening	open	VBG
18637	15485	10	exercises	exercise	NNS
18637	15485	11	which	which	WDT
18637	15485	12	'	'	``
18637	15485	13	include	include	VBP
18637	15485	14	a	a	DT
18637	15485	15	reading	reading	NN
18637	15485	16	from	from	IN
18637	15485	17	the	the	DT
18637	15485	18	Bible	Bible	NNP
18637	15485	19	without	without	IN
18637	15485	20	note	note	NN
18637	15485	21	or	or	CC
18637	15485	22	comment	comment	NN
18637	15485	23	,	,	,
18637	15485	24	and	and	CC
18637	15485	25	the	the	DT
18637	15485	26	Lord	Lord	NNP
18637	15485	27	's	's	POS
18637	15485	28	Prayer	prayer	NN
18637	15485	29	.	.	.
18637	15486	1	'	'	``
18637	15486	2	"	"	``
18637	15486	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15486	4	29	29	CD
18637	15486	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15486	6	THE	the	DT
18637	15486	7	ZORACH	ZORACH	NNP
18637	15486	8	CASE	case	NN
18637	15486	9	;	;	:
18637	15486	10	THE	the	DT
18637	15486	11	McCOLLUM	McCOLLUM	NNP
18637	15486	12	CASE	case	NN
18637	15486	13	LIMITED	limited	JJ
18637	15486	14	In	in	IN
18637	15486	15	a	a	DT
18637	15486	16	decision	decision	NN
18637	15486	17	handed	hand	VBN
18637	15486	18	down	down	RP
18637	15486	19	July	July	NNP
18637	15486	20	11	11	CD
18637	15486	21	,	,	,
18637	15486	22	1951	1951	CD
18637	15486	23	the	the	DT
18637	15486	24	New	New	NNP
18637	15486	25	York	York	NNP
18637	15486	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15486	27	of	of	IN
18637	15486	28	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	15486	29	,	,	,
18637	15486	30	one	one	CD
18637	15486	31	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	15486	32	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	15486	33	,	,	,
18637	15486	34	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15486	35	the	the	DT
18637	15486	36	"	"	``
18637	15486	37	released	release	VBN
18637	15486	38	time	time	NN
18637	15486	39	"	"	''
18637	15486	40	program	program	NN
18637	15486	41	of	of	IN
18637	15486	42	that	that	DT
18637	15486	43	State	State	NNP
18637	15486	44	,	,	,
18637	15486	45	distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
18637	15486	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15486	47	from	from	IN
18637	15486	48	the	the	DT
18637	15486	49	one	one	CD
18637	15486	50	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	15486	51	in	in	IN
18637	15486	52	the	the	DT
18637	15486	53	McCollum	McCollum	NNP
18637	15486	54	Case	Case	NNP
18637	15486	55	as	as	IN
18637	15486	56	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	15486	57	:	:	:
18637	15486	58	"	"	``
18637	15486	59	In	in	IN
18637	15486	60	the	the	DT
18637	15486	61	New	New	NNP
18637	15486	62	York	York	NNP
18637	15486	63	City	City	NNP
18637	15486	64	program	program	NN
18637	15486	65	there	there	EX
18637	15486	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	15486	67	neither	neither	CC
18637	15486	68	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	15486	69	nor	nor	CC
18637	15486	70	approval	approval	NN
18637	15486	71	of	of	IN
18637	15486	72	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15486	73	teachers	teacher	NNS
18637	15486	74	and	and	CC
18637	15486	75	no	no	DT
18637	15486	76	solicitation	solicitation	NN
18637	15486	77	of	of	IN
18637	15486	78	pupils	pupil	NNS
18637	15486	79	or	or	CC
18637	15486	80	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	15486	81	of	of	IN
18637	15486	82	cards	card	NNS
18637	15486	83	.	.	.
18637	15487	1	The	the	DT
18637	15487	2	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15487	3	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	15487	4	must	must	MD
18637	15487	5	be	be	VB
18637	15487	6	outside	outside	IN
18637	15487	7	the	the	DT
18637	15487	8	school	school	NN
18637	15487	9	building	building	NN
18637	15487	10	and	and	CC
18637	15487	11	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	15487	12	.	.	.
18637	15488	1	There	there	EX
18637	15488	2	must	must	MD
18637	15488	3	be	be	VB
18637	15488	4	no	no	DT
18637	15488	5	announcement	announcement	NN
18637	15488	6	of	of	IN
18637	15488	7	any	any	DT
18637	15488	8	kind	kind	NN
18637	15488	9	in	in	IN
18637	15488	10	the	the	DT
18637	15488	11	public	public	JJ
18637	15488	12	schools	school	NNS
18637	15488	13	relative	relative	JJ
18637	15488	14	to	to	IN
18637	15488	15	the	the	DT
18637	15488	16	program	program	NN
18637	15488	17	and	and	CC
18637	15488	18	no	no	DT
18637	15488	19	comment	comment	NN
18637	15488	20	by	by	IN
18637	15488	21	any	any	DT
18637	15488	22	principal	principal	NN
18637	15488	23	or	or	CC
18637	15488	24	teacher	teacher	NN
18637	15488	25	on	on	IN
18637	15488	26	the	the	DT
18637	15488	27	attendance	attendance	NN
18637	15488	28	or	or	CC
18637	15488	29	non	non	NN
18637	15488	30	-	-	NN
18637	15488	31	attendance	attendance	NN
18637	15488	32	of	of	IN
18637	15488	33	any	any	DT
18637	15488	34	pupil	pupil	NN
18637	15488	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	15488	36	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15488	37	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	15488	38	.	.	.
18637	15489	1	All	all	DT
18637	15489	2	that	that	WDT
18637	15489	3	the	the	DT
18637	15489	4	school	school	NN
18637	15489	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	15489	6	besides	besides	IN
18637	15489	7	excusing	excuse	VBG
18637	15489	8	the	the	DT
18637	15489	9	pupil	pupil	NN
18637	15489	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	15489	11	to	to	TO
18637	15489	12	keep	keep	VB
18637	15489	13	a	a	DT
18637	15489	14	record	record	NN
18637	15489	15	--	--	:
18637	15489	16	which	which	WDT
18637	15489	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	15489	18	not	not	RB
18637	15489	19	available	available	JJ
18637	15489	20	for	for	IN
18637	15489	21	any	any	DT
18637	15489	22	other	other	JJ
18637	15489	23	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15489	24	--	--	:
18637	15489	25	in	in	IN
18637	15489	26	order	order	NN
18637	15489	27	to	to	TO
18637	15489	28	see	see	VB
18637	15489	29	that	that	IN
18637	15489	30	the	the	DT
18637	15489	31	excuses	excuse	NNS
18637	15489	32	are	be	VBP
18637	15489	33	not	not	RB
18637	15489	34	taken	take	VBN
18637	15489	35	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	15489	36	of	of	IN
18637	15489	37	and	and	CC
18637	15489	38	the	the	DT
18637	15489	39	school	school	NN
18637	15489	40	deceived	deceive	VBN
18637	15489	41	,	,	,
18637	15489	42	which	which	WDT
18637	15489	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	15489	44	,	,	,
18637	15489	45	of	of	IN
18637	15489	46	course	course	NN
18637	15489	47	,	,	,
18637	15489	48	the	the	DT
18637	15489	49	same	same	JJ
18637	15489	50	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	15489	51	the	the	DT
18637	15489	52	school	school	NN
18637	15489	53	would	would	MD
18637	15489	54	take	take	VB
18637	15489	55	in	in	RP
18637	15489	56	respect	respect	NN
18637	15489	57	of	of	IN
18637	15489	58	absence	absence	NN
18637	15489	59	for	for	IN
18637	15489	60	any	any	DT
18637	15489	61	other	other	JJ
18637	15489	62	reason	reason	NN
18637	15489	63	.	.	.
18637	15490	1	"	"	``
18637	15490	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15490	3	30	30	CD
18637	15490	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15490	5	On	on	IN
18637	15490	6	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	15490	7	this	this	DT
18637	15490	8	decision	decision	NN
18637	15490	9	was	be	VBD
18637	15490	10	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	15490	11	by	by	IN
18637	15490	12	the	the	DT
18637	15490	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15490	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15490	15	,	,	,
18637	15490	16	six	six	CD
18637	15490	17	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	15490	18	to	to	IN
18637	15490	19	three	three	CD
18637	15490	20	.	.	.
18637	15491	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15491	2	31	31	CD
18637	15491	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15491	4	Said	Said	NNP
18637	15491	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15491	6	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	15491	7	,	,	,
18637	15491	8	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15491	9	for	for	IN
18637	15491	10	the	the	DT
18637	15491	11	majority	majority	NN
18637	15491	12	:	:	:
18637	15491	13	"	"	``
18637	15491	14	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15491	15	are	be	VBP
18637	15491	16	a	a	DT
18637	15491	17	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15491	18	people	people	NNS
18637	15491	19	whose	whose	WP$
18637	15491	20	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	15491	21	presuppose	presuppose	VBP
18637	15491	22	a	a	DT
18637	15491	23	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15491	24	Being	Being	NNP
18637	15491	25	.	.	.
18637	15492	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15492	2	guarantee	guarantee	VBP
18637	15492	3	the	the	DT
18637	15492	4	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15492	5	to	to	TO
18637	15492	6	worship	worship	VB
18637	15492	7	as	as	IN
18637	15492	8	one	one	CD
18637	15492	9	chooses	choose	VBZ
18637	15492	10	.	.	.
18637	15493	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15493	2	make	make	VBP
18637	15493	3	room	room	NN
18637	15493	4	for	for	IN
18637	15493	5	as	as	RB
18637	15493	6	wide	wide	JJ
18637	15493	7	a	a	DT
18637	15493	8	variety	variety	NN
18637	15493	9	of	of	IN
18637	15493	10	beliefs	belief	NNS
18637	15493	11	and	and	CC
18637	15493	12	creeds	creed	NNS
18637	15493	13	as	as	IN
18637	15493	14	the	the	DT
18637	15493	15	spiritual	spiritual	JJ
18637	15493	16	needs	need	NNS
18637	15493	17	of	of	IN
18637	15493	18	man	man	NN
18637	15493	19	deem	deem	NN
18637	15493	20	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	15493	21	.	.	.
18637	15494	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15494	2	sponsor	sponsor	VBP
18637	15494	3	an	an	DT
18637	15494	4	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	15494	5	on	on	IN
18637	15494	6	the	the	DT
18637	15494	7	part	part	NN
18637	15494	8	of	of	IN
18637	15494	9	government	government	NN
18637	15494	10	that	that	WDT
18637	15494	11	shows	show	VBZ
18637	15494	12	no	no	DT
18637	15494	13	partiality	partiality	NN
18637	15494	14	to	to	IN
18637	15494	15	any	any	DT
18637	15494	16	one	one	CD
18637	15494	17	group	group	NN
18637	15494	18	and	and	CC
18637	15494	19	that	that	WDT
18637	15494	20	lets	let	VBZ
18637	15494	21	each	each	DT
18637	15494	22	flourish	flourish	NN
18637	15494	23	according	accord	VBG
18637	15494	24	to	to	IN
18637	15494	25	the	the	DT
18637	15494	26	zeal	zeal	NN
18637	15494	27	of	of	IN
18637	15494	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15494	29	adherents	adherent	NNS
18637	15494	30	and	and	CC
18637	15494	31	the	the	DT
18637	15494	32	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	15494	33	of	of	IN
18637	15494	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15494	35	dogma	dogma	NN
18637	15494	36	.	.	.
18637	15495	1	When	when	WRB
18637	15495	2	the	the	DT
18637	15495	3	state	state	NN
18637	15495	4	encourages	encourage	VBZ
18637	15495	5	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15495	6	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	15495	7	or	or	CC
18637	15495	8	cooperates	cooperate	NNS
18637	15495	9	with	with	IN
18637	15495	10	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15495	11	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	15495	12	by	by	IN
18637	15495	13	adjusting	adjust	VBG
18637	15495	14	the	the	DT
18637	15495	15	schedule	schedule	NN
18637	15495	16	of	of	IN
18637	15495	17	public	public	JJ
18637	15495	18	events	event	NNS
18637	15495	19	to	to	IN
18637	15495	20	sectarian	sectarian	JJ
18637	15495	21	needs	need	NNS
18637	15495	22	,	,	,
18637	15495	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15495	24	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	15495	25	the	the	DT
18637	15495	26	best	good	JJS
18637	15495	27	of	of	IN
18637	15495	28	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15495	29	traditions	tradition	NNS
18637	15495	30	.	.	.
18637	15496	1	For	for	IN
18637	15496	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15496	3	then	then	RB
18637	15496	4	respects	respect	VBZ
18637	15496	5	the	the	DT
18637	15496	6	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15496	7	nature	nature	NN
18637	15496	8	of	of	IN
18637	15496	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15496	10	people	people	NNS
18637	15496	11	and	and	CC
18637	15496	12	accommodates	accommodate	VBZ
18637	15496	13	the	the	DT
18637	15496	14	public	public	JJ
18637	15496	15	service	service	NN
18637	15496	16	to	to	IN
18637	15496	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15496	18	spiritual	spiritual	JJ
18637	15496	19	needs	need	NNS
18637	15496	20	.	.	.
18637	15497	1	To	to	TO
18637	15497	2	hold	hold	VB
18637	15497	3	that	that	IN
18637	15497	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15497	5	may	may	MD
18637	15497	6	not	not	RB
18637	15497	7	would	would	MD
18637	15497	8	be	be	VB
18637	15497	9	to	to	TO
18637	15497	10	find	find	VB
18637	15497	11	in	in	IN
18637	15497	12	the	the	DT
18637	15497	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15497	14	a	a	DT
18637	15497	15	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	15497	16	that	that	IN
18637	15497	17	the	the	DT
18637	15497	18	government	government	NN
18637	15497	19	show	show	VBP
18637	15497	20	a	a	DT
18637	15497	21	callous	callous	JJ
18637	15497	22	indifference	indifference	NN
18637	15497	23	to	to	IN
18637	15497	24	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15497	25	groups	group	NNS
18637	15497	26	.	.	.
18637	15498	1	That	that	DT
18637	15498	2	would	would	MD
18637	15498	3	be	be	VB
18637	15498	4	preferring	prefer	VBG
18637	15498	5	those	those	DT
18637	15498	6	who	who	WP
18637	15498	7	believe	believe	VBP
18637	15498	8	in	in	IN
18637	15498	9	no	no	DT
18637	15498	10	religion	religion	NN
18637	15498	11	over	over	IN
18637	15498	12	those	those	DT
18637	15498	13	who	who	WP
18637	15498	14	do	do	VBP
18637	15498	15	believe	believe	VB
18637	15498	16	.	.	.
18637	15499	1	Government	government	NN
18637	15499	2	may	may	MD
18637	15499	3	not	not	RB
18637	15499	4	finance	finance	VB
18637	15499	5	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15499	6	groups	group	NNS
18637	15499	7	nor	nor	CC
18637	15499	8	undertake	undertake	VB
18637	15499	9	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15499	10	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	15499	11	nor	nor	CC
18637	15499	12	blend	blend	NN
18637	15499	13	secular	secular	JJ
18637	15499	14	and	and	CC
18637	15499	15	sectarian	sectarian	JJ
18637	15499	16	education	education	NN
18637	15499	17	nor	nor	CC
18637	15499	18	use	use	VB
18637	15499	19	secular	secular	JJ
18637	15499	20	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	15499	21	to	to	TO
18637	15499	22	force	force	VB
18637	15499	23	one	one	CD
18637	15499	24	or	or	CC
18637	15499	25	some	some	DT
18637	15499	26	religion	religion	NN
18637	15499	27	on	on	IN
18637	15499	28	any	any	DT
18637	15499	29	person	person	NN
18637	15499	30	.	.	.
18637	15500	1	But	but	CC
18637	15500	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15500	3	find	find	VBP
18637	15500	4	no	no	DT
18637	15500	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15500	6	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	15500	7	which	which	WDT
18637	15500	8	makes	make	VBZ
18637	15500	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15500	10	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	15500	11	for	for	IN
18637	15500	12	government	government	NN
18637	15500	13	to	to	TO
18637	15500	14	be	be	VB
18637	15500	15	hostile	hostile	JJ
18637	15500	16	to	to	IN
18637	15500	17	religion	religion	NN
18637	15500	18	and	and	CC
18637	15500	19	to	to	TO
18637	15500	20	throw	throw	VB
18637	15500	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15500	22	weight	weight	NN
18637	15500	23	against	against	IN
18637	15500	24	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	15500	25	to	to	TO
18637	15500	26	widen	widen	VB
18637	15500	27	the	the	DT
18637	15500	28	effective	effective	JJ
18637	15500	29	scope	scope	NN
18637	15500	30	of	of	IN
18637	15500	31	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15500	32	influence	influence	NN
18637	15500	33	.	.	.
18637	15501	1	The	the	DT
18637	15501	2	government	government	NN
18637	15501	3	must	must	MD
18637	15501	4	be	be	VB
18637	15501	5	neutral	neutral	JJ
18637	15501	6	when	when	WRB
18637	15501	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15501	8	comes	come	VBZ
18637	15501	9	to	to	IN
18637	15501	10	competition	competition	NN
18637	15501	11	between	between	IN
18637	15501	12	sects	sect	NNS
18637	15501	13	.	.	.
18637	15502	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15502	2	may	may	MD
18637	15502	3	not	not	RB
18637	15502	4	thrust	thrust	VB
18637	15502	5	any	any	DT
18637	15502	6	sect	sect	NN
18637	15502	7	on	on	IN
18637	15502	8	any	any	DT
18637	15502	9	person	person	NN
18637	15502	10	.	.	.
18637	15503	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15503	2	may	may	MD
18637	15503	3	not	not	RB
18637	15503	4	make	make	VB
18637	15503	5	a	a	DT
18637	15503	6	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15503	7	observance	observance	NN
18637	15503	8	compulsory	compulsory	NN
18637	15503	9	.	.	.
18637	15504	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15504	2	may	may	MD
18637	15504	3	not	not	RB
18637	15504	4	coerce	coerce	VB
18637	15504	5	anyone	anyone	NN
18637	15504	6	to	to	TO
18637	15504	7	attend	attend	VB
18637	15504	8	church	church	NN
18637	15504	9	,	,	,
18637	15504	10	to	to	TO
18637	15504	11	observe	observe	VB
18637	15504	12	a	a	DT
18637	15504	13	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15504	14	holiday	holiday	NN
18637	15504	15	,	,	,
18637	15504	16	or	or	CC
18637	15504	17	to	to	TO
18637	15504	18	take	take	VB
18637	15504	19	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15504	20	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	15504	21	.	.	.
18637	15505	1	But	but	CC
18637	15505	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15505	3	can	can	MD
18637	15505	4	close	close	VB
18637	15505	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15505	6	doors	door	NNS
18637	15505	7	or	or	CC
18637	15505	8	suspend	suspend	VB
18637	15505	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15505	10	operations	operation	NNS
18637	15505	11	as	as	IN
18637	15505	12	to	to	IN
18637	15505	13	those	those	DT
18637	15505	14	who	who	WP
18637	15505	15	want	want	VBP
18637	15505	16	to	to	TO
18637	15505	17	repair	repair	VB
18637	15505	18	to	to	IN
18637	15505	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15505	20	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15505	21	sanctuary	sanctuary	NN
18637	15505	22	for	for	IN
18637	15505	23	worship	worship	NN
18637	15505	24	or	or	CC
18637	15505	25	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	15505	26	.	.	.
18637	15506	1	No	no	DT
18637	15506	2	more	more	JJR
18637	15506	3	than	than	IN
18637	15506	4	that	that	DT
18637	15506	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	15506	6	undertaken	undertake	VBN
18637	15506	7	here	here	RB
18637	15506	8	.	.	.
18637	15507	1	"	"	``
18637	15507	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15507	3	32	32	CD
18637	15507	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15507	5	A	a	DT
18637	15507	6	few	few	JJ
18637	15507	7	weeks	week	NNS
18637	15507	8	earlier	early	RBR
18637	15507	9	,	,	,
18637	15507	10	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	15507	11	,	,	,
18637	15507	12	the	the	DT
18637	15507	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15507	14	had	have	VBD
18637	15507	15	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	15507	16	an	an	DT
18637	15507	17	intention	intention	NN
18637	15507	18	to	to	TO
18637	15507	19	scrutinize	scrutinize	VB
18637	15507	20	more	more	RBR
18637	15507	21	closely	closely	RB
18637	15507	22	the	the	DT
18637	15507	23	basis	basis	NN
18637	15507	24	of	of	IN
18637	15507	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15507	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	15507	27	in	in	IN
18637	15507	28	this	this	DT
18637	15507	29	class	class	NN
18637	15507	30	of	of	IN
18637	15507	31	cases	case	NNS
18637	15507	32	.	.	.
18637	15508	1	This	this	DT
18637	15508	2	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	15508	3	in	in	IN
18637	15508	4	a	a	DT
18637	15508	5	case	case	NN
18637	15508	6	in	in	IN
18637	15508	7	which	which	WDT
18637	15508	8	the	the	DT
18637	15508	9	question	question	NN
18637	15508	10	involved	involve	VBN
18637	15508	11	was	be	VBD
18637	15508	12	the	the	DT
18637	15508	13	validity	validity	NN
18637	15508	14	of	of	IN
18637	15508	15	a	a	DT
18637	15508	16	New	New	NNP
18637	15508	17	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	15508	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	15508	19	which	which	WDT
18637	15508	20	requires	require	VBZ
18637	15508	21	the	the	DT
18637	15508	22	reading	reading	NN
18637	15508	23	at	at	IN
18637	15508	24	the	the	DT
18637	15508	25	opening	opening	NN
18637	15508	26	of	of	IN
18637	15508	27	each	each	DT
18637	15508	28	public	public	JJ
18637	15508	29	school	school	NN
18637	15508	30	day	day	NN
18637	15508	31	of	of	IN
18637	15508	32	five	five	CD
18637	15508	33	verses	verse	NNS
18637	15508	34	of	of	IN
18637	15508	35	the	the	DT
18637	15508	36	Old	Old	NNP
18637	15508	37	Testament	Testament	NNP
18637	15508	38	.	.	.
18637	15509	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15509	2	33	33	CD
18637	15509	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15509	4	The	the	DT
18637	15509	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15509	6	held	hold	VBD
18637	15509	7	that	that	IN
18637	15509	8	appellant	appellant	NN
18637	15509	9	's	's	POS
18637	15509	10	interest	interest	NN
18637	15509	11	as	as	IN
18637	15509	12	taxpayers	taxpayer	NNS
18637	15509	13	was	be	VBD
18637	15509	14	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	15509	15	to	to	TO
18637	15509	16	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	15509	17	a	a	DT
18637	15509	18	justiciable	justiciable	JJ
18637	15509	19	case	case	NN
18637	15509	20	or	or	CC
18637	15509	21	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	15509	22	,	,	,
18637	15509	23	while	while	IN
18637	15509	24	as	as	IN
18637	15509	25	to	to	IN
18637	15509	26	the	the	DT
18637	15509	27	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	15509	28	rights	right	NNS
18637	15509	29	of	of	IN
18637	15509	30	the	the	DT
18637	15509	31	child	child	NN
18637	15509	32	involved	involve	VBD
18637	15509	33	the	the	DT
18637	15509	34	case	case	NN
18637	15509	35	had	have	VBD
18637	15509	36	become	become	VBN
18637	15509	37	moot	moot	JJ
18637	15509	38	with	with	IN
18637	15509	39	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15509	40	graduation	graduation	NN
18637	15509	41	from	from	IN
18637	15509	42	school	school	NN
18637	15509	43	.	.	.
18637	15510	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15510	2	34	34	CD
18637	15510	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15510	4	PERMISSIBLE	permissible	NN
18637	15510	5	MONETARY	MONETARY	NNP
18637	15510	6	AIDS	aids	NN
18637	15510	7	TO	to	TO
18637	15510	8	RELIGION	religion	VB
18637	15510	9	In	in	IN
18637	15510	10	1899	1899	CD
18637	15510	11	the	the	DT
18637	15510	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15510	13	held	hold	VBD
18637	15510	14	that	that	IN
18637	15510	15	an	an	DT
18637	15510	16	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	15510	17	between	between	IN
18637	15510	18	the	the	DT
18637	15510	19	District	District	NNP
18637	15510	20	of	of	IN
18637	15510	21	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	15510	22	and	and	CC
18637	15510	23	the	the	DT
18637	15510	24	directors	director	NNS
18637	15510	25	of	of	IN
18637	15510	26	a	a	DT
18637	15510	27	hospital	hospital	NN
18637	15510	28	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	15510	29	by	by	IN
18637	15510	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15510	31	for	for	IN
18637	15510	32	erection	erection	NN
18637	15510	33	of	of	IN
18637	15510	34	a	a	DT
18637	15510	35	building	building	NN
18637	15510	36	and	and	CC
18637	15510	37	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	15510	38	of	of	IN
18637	15510	39	poor	poor	JJ
18637	15510	40	patients	patient	NNS
18637	15510	41	at	at	IN
18637	15510	42	the	the	DT
18637	15510	43	expense	expense	NN
18637	15510	44	of	of	IN
18637	15510	45	the	the	DT
18637	15510	46	District	District	NNP
18637	15510	47	was	be	VBD
18637	15510	48	valid	valid	JJ
18637	15510	49	despite	despite	IN
18637	15510	50	the	the	DT
18637	15510	51	fact	fact	NN
18637	15510	52	that	that	IN
18637	15510	53	the	the	DT
18637	15510	54	members	member	NNS
18637	15510	55	of	of	IN
18637	15510	56	the	the	DT
18637	15510	57	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	15510	58	belonged	belong	VBD
18637	15510	59	to	to	IN
18637	15510	60	a	a	DT
18637	15510	61	monastic	monastic	JJ
18637	15510	62	order	order	NN
18637	15510	63	or	or	CC
18637	15510	64	sisterhood	sisterhood	NN
18637	15510	65	of	of	IN
18637	15510	66	a	a	DT
18637	15510	67	particular	particular	JJ
18637	15510	68	church	church	NN
18637	15510	69	.	.	.
18637	15511	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15511	2	35	35	CD
18637	15511	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15511	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15511	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	15511	6	also	also	RB
18637	15511	7	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	15511	8	a	a	DT
18637	15511	9	contract	contract	NN
18637	15511	10	made	make	VBN
18637	15511	11	at	at	IN
18637	15511	12	the	the	DT
18637	15511	13	request	request	NN
18637	15511	14	of	of	IN
18637	15511	15	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	15511	16	to	to	TO
18637	15511	17	whom	whom	WP
18637	15511	18	money	money	NN
18637	15511	19	was	be	VBD
18637	15511	20	due	due	JJ
18637	15511	21	as	as	IN
18637	15511	22	a	a	DT
18637	15511	23	matter	matter	NN
18637	15511	24	of	of	IN
18637	15511	25	right	right	JJ
18637	15511	26	,	,	,
18637	15511	27	under	under	IN
18637	15511	28	a	a	DT
18637	15511	29	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	15511	30	,	,	,
18637	15511	31	for	for	IN
18637	15511	32	the	the	DT
18637	15511	33	payment	payment	NN
18637	15511	34	of	of	IN
18637	15511	35	such	such	JJ
18637	15511	36	money	money	NN
18637	15511	37	by	by	IN
18637	15511	38	the	the	DT
18637	15511	39	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	15511	40	of	of	IN
18637	15511	41	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	15511	42	Affairs	Affairs	NNPS
18637	15511	43	for	for	IN
18637	15511	44	the	the	DT
18637	15511	45	support	support	NN
18637	15511	46	of	of	IN
18637	15511	47	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	15511	48	Catholic	Catholic	NNP
18637	15511	49	schools	school	NNS
18637	15511	50	.	.	.
18637	15512	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15512	2	36	36	CD
18637	15512	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15512	4	In	in	IN
18637	15512	5	1930	1930	CD
18637	15512	6	the	the	DT
18637	15512	7	use	use	NN
18637	15512	8	of	of	IN
18637	15512	9	public	public	JJ
18637	15512	10	funds	fund	NNS
18637	15512	11	to	to	TO
18637	15512	12	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	15512	13	nonsectarian	nonsectarian	JJ
18637	15512	14	textbooks	textbook	NNS
18637	15512	15	to	to	IN
18637	15512	16	pupils	pupil	NNS
18637	15512	17	in	in	IN
18637	15512	18	parochial	parochial	JJ
18637	15512	19	schools	school	NNS
18637	15512	20	of	of	IN
18637	15512	21	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	15512	22	was	be	VBD
18637	15512	23	sustained,[37	sustained,[37	CD
18637	15512	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15512	25	and	and	CC
18637	15512	26	in	in	IN
18637	15512	27	1947	1947	CD
18637	15512	28	,	,	,
18637	15512	29	as	as	IN
18637	15512	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15512	31	have	have	VBP
18637	15512	32	seen	see	VBN
18637	15512	33	,	,	,
18637	15512	34	the	the	DT
18637	15512	35	case	case	NN
18637	15512	36	of	of	IN
18637	15512	37	public	public	JJ
18637	15512	38	funds	fund	NNS
18637	15512	39	for	for	IN
18637	15512	40	the	the	DT
18637	15512	41	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	15512	42	of	of	IN
18637	15512	43	pupils	pupil	NNS
18637	15512	44	attending	attend	VBG
18637	15512	45	such	such	JJ
18637	15512	46	schools	school	NNS
18637	15512	47	in	in	IN
18637	15512	48	New	New	NNP
18637	15512	49	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	15512	50	.	.	.
18637	15513	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15513	2	38	38	CD
18637	15513	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15513	4	In	in	IN
18637	15513	5	the	the	DT
18637	15513	6	former	former	NN
18637	15513	7	of	of	IN
18637	15513	8	these	these	DT
18637	15513	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	15513	10	the	the	DT
18637	15513	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15513	12	cited	cite	VBD
18637	15513	13	the	the	DT
18637	15513	14	State	state	NN
18637	15513	15	's	's	POS
18637	15513	16	interest	interest	NN
18637	15513	17	in	in	IN
18637	15513	18	secular	secular	JJ
18637	15513	19	education	education	NN
18637	15513	20	even	even	RB
18637	15513	21	when	when	WRB
18637	15513	22	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	15513	23	in	in	IN
18637	15513	24	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15513	25	schools	school	NNS
18637	15513	26	;	;	:
18637	15513	27	in	in	IN
18637	15513	28	the	the	DT
18637	15513	29	latter	latter	JJ
18637	15513	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15513	31	concern	concern	NN
18637	15513	32	for	for	IN
18637	15513	33	the	the	DT
18637	15513	34	safety	safety	NN
18637	15513	35	of	of	IN
18637	15513	36	school	school	NN
18637	15513	37	children	child	NNS
18637	15513	38	on	on	IN
18637	15513	39	the	the	DT
18637	15513	40	highways	highway	NNS
18637	15513	41	;	;	:
18637	15513	42	and	and	CC
18637	15513	43	the	the	DT
18637	15513	44	National	National	NNP
18637	15513	45	School	School	NNP
18637	15513	46	Lunch	Lunch	NNP
18637	15513	47	Act,[39	Act,[39	NNP
18637	15513	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15513	49	which	which	WDT
18637	15513	50	aids	aid	VBZ
18637	15513	51	all	all	DT
18637	15513	52	school	school	NN
18637	15513	53	children	child	NNS
18637	15513	54	attending	attend	VBG
18637	15513	55	tax	tax	NN
18637	15513	56	-	-	HYPH
18637	15513	57	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	15513	58	schools	school	NNS
18637	15513	59	can	can	MD
18637	15513	60	be	be	VB
18637	15513	61	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	15513	62	justified	justify	VBN
18637	15513	63	.	.	.
18637	15514	1	The	the	DT
18637	15514	2	most	most	RBS
18637	15514	3	notable	notable	JJ
18637	15514	4	financial	financial	JJ
18637	15514	5	concession	concession	NN
18637	15514	6	to	to	IN
18637	15514	7	religion	religion	NN
18637	15514	8	,	,	,
18637	15514	9	however	however	RB
18637	15514	10	,	,	,
18637	15514	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	15514	12	not	not	RB
18637	15514	13	to	to	TO
18637	15514	14	be	be	VB
18637	15514	15	explained	explain	VBN
18637	15514	16	in	in	IN
18637	15514	17	this	this	DT
18637	15514	18	way	way	NN
18637	15514	19	,	,	,
18637	15514	20	the	the	DT
18637	15514	21	universal	universal	JJ
18637	15514	22	practice	practice	NN
18637	15514	23	of	of	IN
18637	15514	24	exempting	exempt	VBG
18637	15514	25	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15514	26	property	property	NN
18637	15514	27	from	from	IN
18637	15514	28	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	15514	29	.	.	.
18637	15515	1	This	this	DT
18637	15515	2	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
18637	15515	3	traces	trace	VBZ
18637	15515	4	back	back	RB
18637	15515	5	to	to	IN
18637	15515	6	the	the	DT
18637	15515	7	idea	idea	NN
18637	15515	8	expressed	express	VBN
18637	15515	9	in	in	IN
18637	15515	10	the	the	DT
18637	15515	11	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	15515	12	Ordnance	Ordnance	NNP
18637	15515	13	that	that	WDT
18637	15515	14	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15515	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	15515	16	an	an	DT
18637	15515	17	interest	interest	NN
18637	15515	18	in	in	IN
18637	15515	19	religion	religion	NN
18637	15515	20	as	as	IN
18637	15515	21	such	such	JJ
18637	15515	22	.	.	.
18637	15516	1	FREE	free	JJ
18637	15516	2	EXERCISE	exercise	NN
18637	15516	3	OF	of	IN
18637	15516	4	RELIGION	religion	NN
18637	15516	5	:	:	:
18637	15516	6	DIMENSIONS	dimensions	VB
18637	15516	7	The	the	DT
18637	15516	8	First	First	NNP
18637	15516	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15516	10	"	"	''
18637	15516	11	was	be	VBD
18637	15516	12	intended	intend	VBN
18637	15516	13	to	to	TO
18637	15516	14	allow	allow	VB
18637	15516	15	every	every	DT
18637	15516	16	one	one	NN
18637	15516	17	under	under	IN
18637	15516	18	the	the	DT
18637	15516	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	15516	20	of	of	IN
18637	15516	21	the	the	DT
18637	15516	22	United	United	NNP
18637	15516	23	States	States	NNP
18637	15516	24	to	to	TO
18637	15516	25	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	15516	26	such	such	JJ
18637	15516	27	notions	notion	NNS
18637	15516	28	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	15516	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15516	30	relations	relation	NNS
18637	15516	31	to	to	IN
18637	15516	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15516	33	Maker	maker	NN
18637	15516	34	and	and	CC
18637	15516	35	the	the	DT
18637	15516	36	duties	duty	NNS
18637	15516	37	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15516	38	impose	impose	VBP
18637	15516	39	as	as	IN
18637	15516	40	may	may	MD
18637	15516	41	be	be	VB
18637	15516	42	approved	approve	VBN
18637	15516	43	by	by	IN
18637	15516	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15516	45	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	15516	46	and	and	CC
18637	15516	47	conscience	conscience	NN
18637	15516	48	,	,	,
18637	15516	49	and	and	CC
18637	15516	50	to	to	TO
18637	15516	51	exhibit	exhibit	VB
18637	15516	52	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15516	53	sentiments	sentiment	NNS
18637	15516	54	in	in	IN
18637	15516	55	such	such	JJ
18637	15516	56	form	form	NN
18637	15516	57	of	of	IN
18637	15516	58	worship	worship	NN
18637	15516	59	as	as	IN
18637	15516	60	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15516	61	may	may	MD
18637	15516	62	think	think	VB
18637	15516	63	proper	proper	JJ
18637	15516	64	,	,	,
18637	15516	65	not	not	RB
18637	15516	66	injurious	injurious	JJ
18637	15516	67	to	to	IN
18637	15516	68	the	the	DT
18637	15516	69	equal	equal	JJ
18637	15516	70	rights	right	NNS
18637	15516	71	of	of	IN
18637	15516	72	others	other	NNS
18637	15516	73	,	,	,
18637	15516	74	and	and	CC
18637	15516	75	to	to	TO
18637	15516	76	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	15516	77	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15516	78	for	for	IN
18637	15516	79	the	the	DT
18637	15516	80	support	support	NN
18637	15516	81	of	of	IN
18637	15516	82	any	any	DT
18637	15516	83	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15516	84	tenets	tenet	NNS
18637	15516	85	,	,	,
18637	15516	86	or	or	CC
18637	15516	87	the	the	DT
18637	15516	88	modes	mode	NNS
18637	15516	89	of	of	IN
18637	15516	90	worship	worship	NN
18637	15516	91	of	of	IN
18637	15516	92	any	any	DT
18637	15516	93	sect	sect	NN
18637	15516	94	.	.	.
18637	15517	1	The	the	DT
18637	15517	2	oppressive	oppressive	JJ
18637	15517	3	measures	measure	NNS
18637	15517	4	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	15517	5	,	,	,
18637	15517	6	and	and	CC
18637	15517	7	the	the	DT
18637	15517	8	cruelties	cruelty	NNS
18637	15517	9	and	and	CC
18637	15517	10	punishments	punishment	NNS
18637	15517	11	inflicted	inflict	VBN
18637	15517	12	,	,	,
18637	15517	13	by	by	IN
18637	15517	14	the	the	DT
18637	15517	15	governments	government	NNS
18637	15517	16	of	of	IN
18637	15517	17	Europe	Europe	NNP
18637	15517	18	for	for	IN
18637	15517	19	many	many	JJ
18637	15517	20	ages	age	NNS
18637	15517	21	,	,	,
18637	15517	22	to	to	TO
18637	15517	23	compel	compel	VB
18637	15517	24	parties	party	NNS
18637	15517	25	to	to	TO
18637	15517	26	conform	conform	VB
18637	15517	27	,	,	,
18637	15517	28	in	in	IN
18637	15517	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15517	30	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15517	31	beliefs	belief	NNS
18637	15517	32	and	and	CC
18637	15517	33	modes	mode	NNS
18637	15517	34	of	of	IN
18637	15517	35	worship	worship	NN
18637	15517	36	,	,	,
18637	15517	37	to	to	IN
18637	15517	38	the	the	DT
18637	15517	39	views	view	NNS
18637	15517	40	of	of	IN
18637	15517	41	the	the	DT
18637	15517	42	most	most	RBS
18637	15517	43	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	15517	44	sect	sect	NN
18637	15517	45	,	,	,
18637	15517	46	and	and	CC
18637	15517	47	the	the	DT
18637	15517	48	folly	folly	NN
18637	15517	49	of	of	IN
18637	15517	50	attempting	attempt	VBG
18637	15517	51	in	in	IN
18637	15517	52	that	that	DT
18637	15517	53	way	way	NN
18637	15517	54	to	to	TO
18637	15517	55	control	control	VB
18637	15517	56	the	the	DT
18637	15517	57	mental	mental	JJ
18637	15517	58	operations	operation	NNS
18637	15517	59	of	of	IN
18637	15517	60	persons	person	NNS
18637	15517	61	,	,	,
18637	15517	62	and	and	CC
18637	15517	63	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	15517	64	an	an	DT
18637	15517	65	outward	outward	JJ
18637	15517	66	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	15517	67	to	to	IN
18637	15517	68	a	a	DT
18637	15517	69	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	15517	70	standard	standard	NN
18637	15517	71	,	,	,
18637	15517	72	led	lead	VBD
18637	15517	73	to	to	IN
18637	15517	74	the	the	DT
18637	15517	75	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	15517	76	of	of	IN
18637	15517	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15517	78	this	this	DT
18637	15517	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15517	80	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	15517	81	.	.	.
18637	15518	1	"	"	``
18637	15518	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15518	3	40	40	CD
18637	15518	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15518	5	"	"	``
18637	15518	6	The	the	DT
18637	15518	7	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15518	8	inhibition	inhibition	NN
18637	15518	9	of	of	IN
18637	15518	10	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15518	11	on	on	IN
18637	15518	12	the	the	DT
18637	15518	13	subject	subject	NN
18637	15518	14	of	of	IN
18637	15518	15	religion	religion	NN
18637	15518	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	15518	17	a	a	DT
18637	15518	18	double	double	JJ
18637	15518	19	aspect	aspect	NN
18637	15518	20	.	.	.
18637	15519	1	On	on	IN
18637	15519	2	the	the	DT
18637	15519	3	one	one	CD
18637	15519	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	15519	5	,	,	,
18637	15519	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15519	7	forestalls	forestall	VBZ
18637	15519	8	compulsion	compulsion	NN
18637	15519	9	by	by	IN
18637	15519	10	law	law	NN
18637	15519	11	of	of	IN
18637	15519	12	the	the	DT
18637	15519	13	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	15519	14	of	of	IN
18637	15519	15	any	any	DT
18637	15519	16	creed	creed	NN
18637	15519	17	or	or	CC
18637	15519	18	the	the	DT
18637	15519	19	practice	practice	NN
18637	15519	20	of	of	IN
18637	15519	21	any	any	DT
18637	15519	22	form	form	NN
18637	15519	23	of	of	IN
18637	15519	24	worship	worship	NN
18637	15519	25	.	.	.
18637	15520	1	Freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15520	2	of	of	IN
18637	15520	3	conscience	conscience	NN
18637	15520	4	and	and	CC
18637	15520	5	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15520	6	to	to	TO
18637	15520	7	adhere	adhere	VB
18637	15520	8	to	to	IN
18637	15520	9	such	such	JJ
18637	15520	10	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15520	11	organization	organization	NN
18637	15520	12	or	or	CC
18637	15520	13	form	form	NN
18637	15520	14	of	of	IN
18637	15520	15	worship	worship	NN
18637	15520	16	as	as	IN
18637	15520	17	the	the	DT
18637	15520	18	individual	individual	NN
18637	15520	19	may	may	MD
18637	15520	20	choose	choose	VB
18637	15520	21	can	can	MD
18637	15520	22	not	not	RB
18637	15520	23	be	be	VB
18637	15520	24	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	15520	25	by	by	IN
18637	15520	26	law	law	NN
18637	15520	27	.	.	.
18637	15521	1	On	on	IN
18637	15521	2	the	the	DT
18637	15521	3	other	other	JJ
18637	15521	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	15521	5	,	,	,
18637	15521	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15521	7	safeguards	safeguard	VBZ
18637	15521	8	the	the	DT
18637	15521	9	free	free	JJ
18637	15521	10	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15521	11	of	of	IN
18637	15521	12	the	the	DT
18637	15521	13	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	15521	14	form	form	NN
18637	15521	15	of	of	IN
18637	15521	16	religion	religion	NN
18637	15521	17	.	.	.
18637	15522	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	15522	2	the	the	DT
18637	15522	3	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15522	4	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	15522	5	two	two	CD
18637	15522	6	concepts,--freedom	concepts,--freedom	VBG
18637	15522	7	to	to	TO
18637	15522	8	believe	believe	VB
18637	15522	9	and	and	CC
18637	15522	10	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15522	11	to	to	TO
18637	15522	12	act	act	VB
18637	15522	13	.	.	.
18637	15523	1	The	the	DT
18637	15523	2	first	first	JJ
18637	15523	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	15523	4	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	15523	5	,	,	,
18637	15523	6	but	but	CC
18637	15523	7	in	in	IN
18637	15523	8	the	the	DT
18637	15523	9	nature	nature	NN
18637	15523	10	of	of	IN
18637	15523	11	things	thing	NNS
18637	15523	12	,	,	,
18637	15523	13	the	the	DT
18637	15523	14	second	second	JJ
18637	15523	15	can	can	MD
18637	15523	16	not	not	RB
18637	15523	17	be	be	VB
18637	15523	18	.	.	.
18637	15524	1	"	"	``
18637	15524	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15524	3	41	41	CD
18637	15524	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15524	5	PAROCHIAL	PAROCHIAL	NNP
18637	15524	6	SCHOOLS	SCHOOLS	NNP
18637	15524	7	The	the	DT
18637	15524	8	Society	Society	NNP
18637	15524	9	of	of	IN
18637	15524	10	Sisters	Sisters	NNPS
18637	15524	11	,	,	,
18637	15524	12	an	an	DT
18637	15524	13	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	15524	14	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	15524	15	,	,	,
18637	15524	16	was	be	VBD
18637	15524	17	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	15524	18	by	by	IN
18637	15524	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15524	20	charter	charter	NN
18637	15524	21	to	to	TO
18637	15524	22	care	care	VB
18637	15524	23	for	for	IN
18637	15524	24	orphans	orphan	NNS
18637	15524	25	and	and	CC
18637	15524	26	to	to	TO
18637	15524	27	establish	establish	VB
18637	15524	28	and	and	CC
18637	15524	29	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	15524	30	schools	school	NNS
18637	15524	31	and	and	CC
18637	15524	32	academies	academy	NNS
18637	15524	33	for	for	IN
18637	15524	34	the	the	DT
18637	15524	35	education	education	NN
18637	15524	36	of	of	IN
18637	15524	37	the	the	DT
18637	15524	38	youth	youth	NN
18637	15524	39	.	.	.
18637	15525	1	Systematic	systematic	JJ
18637	15525	2	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	15525	3	and	and	CC
18637	15525	4	moral	moral	JJ
18637	15525	5	training	training	NN
18637	15525	6	according	accord	VBG
18637	15525	7	to	to	IN
18637	15525	8	the	the	DT
18637	15525	9	tenets	tenet	NNS
18637	15525	10	of	of	IN
18637	15525	11	the	the	DT
18637	15525	12	Roman	Roman	NNP
18637	15525	13	Catholic	Catholic	NNP
18637	15525	14	Church	Church	NNP
18637	15525	15	was	be	VBD
18637	15525	16	given	give	VBN
18637	15525	17	in	in	IN
18637	15525	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15525	19	establishments	establishment	NNS
18637	15525	20	along	along	IN
18637	15525	21	with	with	IN
18637	15525	22	education	education	NN
18637	15525	23	in	in	IN
18637	15525	24	the	the	DT
18637	15525	25	secular	secular	JJ
18637	15525	26	branches	branch	NNS
18637	15525	27	.	.	.
18637	15526	1	By	by	IN
18637	15526	2	an	an	DT
18637	15526	3	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	15526	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	15526	5	,	,	,
18637	15526	6	effective	effective	JJ
18637	15526	7	September	September	NNP
18637	15526	8	1	1	CD
18637	15526	9	,	,	,
18637	15526	10	1926	1926	CD
18637	15526	11	,	,	,
18637	15526	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15526	13	was	be	VBD
18637	15526	14	required	require	VBN
18637	15526	15	that	that	IN
18637	15526	16	every	every	DT
18637	15526	17	parent	parent	NN
18637	15526	18	,	,	,
18637	15526	19	or	or	CC
18637	15526	20	other	other	JJ
18637	15526	21	person	person	NN
18637	15526	22	having	have	VBG
18637	15526	23	control	control	NN
18637	15526	24	or	or	CC
18637	15526	25	charge	charge	NN
18637	15526	26	or	or	CC
18637	15526	27	custody	custody	NN
18637	15526	28	of	of	IN
18637	15526	29	a	a	DT
18637	15526	30	child	child	NN
18637	15526	31	between	between	IN
18637	15526	32	eight	eight	CD
18637	15526	33	and	and	CC
18637	15526	34	sixteen	sixteen	CD
18637	15526	35	years	year	NNS
18637	15526	36	send	send	VBP
18637	15526	37	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15526	38	"	"	``
18637	15526	39	to	to	IN
18637	15526	40	a	a	DT
18637	15526	41	public	public	JJ
18637	15526	42	school	school	NN
18637	15526	43	for	for	IN
18637	15526	44	the	the	DT
18637	15526	45	period	period	NN
18637	15526	46	of	of	IN
18637	15526	47	time	time	NN
18637	15526	48	a	a	DT
18637	15526	49	public	public	JJ
18637	15526	50	school	school	NN
18637	15526	51	shall	shall	MD
18637	15526	52	be	be	VB
18637	15526	53	held	hold	VBN
18637	15526	54	during	during	IN
18637	15526	55	the	the	DT
18637	15526	56	current	current	JJ
18637	15526	57	year	year	NN
18637	15526	58	"	"	''
18637	15526	59	in	in	IN
18637	15526	60	the	the	DT
18637	15526	61	district	district	NN
18637	15526	62	where	where	WRB
18637	15526	63	the	the	DT
18637	15526	64	child	child	NN
18637	15526	65	resides	reside	VBZ
18637	15526	66	;	;	:
18637	15526	67	and	and	CC
18637	15526	68	failure	failure	NN
18637	15526	69	so	so	RB
18637	15526	70	to	to	TO
18637	15526	71	do	do	VB
18637	15526	72	was	be	VBD
18637	15526	73	declared	declare	VBN
18637	15526	74	a	a	DT
18637	15526	75	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
18637	15526	76	.	.	.
18637	15527	1	The	the	DT
18637	15527	2	District	District	NNP
18637	15527	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15527	4	of	of	IN
18637	15527	5	The	the	DT
18637	15527	6	United	United	NNP
18637	15527	7	States	States	NNP
18637	15527	8	for	for	IN
18637	15527	9	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	15527	10	enjoined	enjoin	VBD
18637	15527	11	the	the	DT
18637	15527	12	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	15527	13	of	of	IN
18637	15527	14	the	the	DT
18637	15527	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	15527	16	and	and	CC
18637	15527	17	the	the	DT
18637	15527	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15527	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15527	20	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	15527	21	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15527	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15527	23	action,[42	action,[42	CD
18637	15527	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15527	25	holding	hold	VBG
18637	15527	26	that	that	IN
18637	15527	27	the	the	DT
18637	15527	28	measure	measure	NN
18637	15527	29	unreasonably	unreasonably	RB
18637	15527	30	interfered	interfere	VBD
18637	15527	31	with	with	IN
18637	15527	32	the	the	DT
18637	15527	33	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15527	34	of	of	IN
18637	15527	35	parents	parent	NNS
18637	15527	36	and	and	CC
18637	15527	37	guardians	guardian	NNS
18637	15527	38	to	to	TO
18637	15527	39	direct	direct	VB
18637	15527	40	the	the	DT
18637	15527	41	upbringing	upbringing	NN
18637	15527	42	and	and	CC
18637	15527	43	education	education	NN
18637	15527	44	of	of	IN
18637	15527	45	children	child	NNS
18637	15527	46	under	under	IN
18637	15527	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15527	48	control	control	NN
18637	15527	49	--	--	:
18637	15527	50	a	a	DT
18637	15527	51	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15527	52	protected	protect	VBN
18637	15527	53	by	by	IN
18637	15527	54	the	the	DT
18637	15527	55	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15527	56	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15527	57	.	.	.
18637	15528	1	While	while	IN
18637	15528	2	the	the	DT
18637	15528	3	First	First	NNP
18637	15528	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15528	5	was	be	VBD
18637	15528	6	not	not	RB
18637	15528	7	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	15528	8	in	in	IN
18637	15528	9	the	the	DT
18637	15528	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15528	11	's	's	POS
18637	15528	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15528	13	,	,	,
18637	15528	14	the	the	DT
18637	15528	15	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	15528	16	absorption	absorption	NN
18637	15528	17	of	of	IN
18637	15528	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15528	19	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15528	20	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	15528	21	into	into	IN
18637	15528	22	the	the	DT
18637	15528	23	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15528	24	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15528	25	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	15528	26	to	to	TO
18637	15528	27	make	make	VB
18637	15528	28	the	the	DT
18637	15528	29	case	case	NN
18637	15528	30	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	15528	31	to	to	IN
18637	15528	32	the	the	DT
18637	15528	33	question	question	NN
18637	15528	34	of	of	IN
18637	15528	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15528	36	proper	proper	JJ
18637	15528	37	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	15528	38	.	.	.
18637	15529	1	FREE	free	JJ
18637	15529	2	EXERCISE	exercise	NN
18637	15529	3	OF	of	IN
18637	15529	4	RELIGION	religion	NN
18637	15529	5	:	:	:
18637	15529	6	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	15529	7	RESTRAINTS	restraint	NNS
18637	15529	8	Religious	religious	JJ
18637	15529	9	belief	belief	NN
18637	15529	10	can	can	MD
18637	15529	11	not	not	RB
18637	15529	12	be	be	VB
18637	15529	13	pleaded	plead	VBN
18637	15529	14	as	as	IN
18637	15529	15	a	a	DT
18637	15529	16	justification	justification	NN
18637	15529	17	for	for	IN
18637	15529	18	an	an	DT
18637	15529	19	overt	overt	JJ
18637	15529	20	act	act	NN
18637	15529	21	made	make	VBN
18637	15529	22	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15529	23	by	by	IN
18637	15529	24	the	the	DT
18637	15529	25	law	law	NN
18637	15529	26	of	of	IN
18637	15529	27	the	the	DT
18637	15529	28	land	land	NN
18637	15529	29	.	.	.
18637	15530	1	"	"	``
18637	15530	2	Laws	law	NNS
18637	15530	3	are	be	VBP
18637	15530	4	made	make	VBN
18637	15530	5	for	for	IN
18637	15530	6	the	the	DT
18637	15530	7	government	government	NN
18637	15530	8	of	of	IN
18637	15530	9	action	action	NN
18637	15530	10	,	,	,
18637	15530	11	and	and	CC
18637	15530	12	while	while	IN
18637	15530	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15530	14	can	can	MD
18637	15530	15	not	not	RB
18637	15530	16	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	15530	17	with	with	IN
18637	15530	18	mere	mere	JJ
18637	15530	19	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15530	20	belief	belief	NN
18637	15530	21	and	and	CC
18637	15530	22	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	15530	23	,	,	,
18637	15530	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15530	25	may	may	MD
18637	15530	26	with	with	IN
18637	15530	27	practices	practice	NNS
18637	15530	28	.	.	.
18637	15531	1	"	"	``
18637	15531	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15531	3	43	43	CD
18637	15531	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15531	5	To	to	TO
18637	15531	6	permit	permit	VB
18637	15531	7	a	a	DT
18637	15531	8	man	man	NN
18637	15531	9	to	to	TO
18637	15531	10	excuse	excuse	VB
18637	15531	11	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	15531	12	in	in	IN
18637	15531	13	violation	violation	NN
18637	15531	14	of	of	IN
18637	15531	15	law	law	NN
18637	15531	16	on	on	IN
18637	15531	17	the	the	DT
18637	15531	18	ground	ground	NN
18637	15531	19	of	of	IN
18637	15531	20	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15531	21	belief	belief	NN
18637	15531	22	"	"	''
18637	15531	23	would	would	MD
18637	15531	24	be	be	VB
18637	15531	25	to	to	TO
18637	15531	26	make	make	VB
18637	15531	27	the	the	DT
18637	15531	28	professed	profess	VBN
18637	15531	29	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	15531	30	of	of	IN
18637	15531	31	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15531	32	belief	belief	NN
18637	15531	33	superior	superior	JJ
18637	15531	34	to	to	IN
18637	15531	35	the	the	DT
18637	15531	36	law	law	NN
18637	15531	37	of	of	IN
18637	15531	38	the	the	DT
18637	15531	39	land	land	NN
18637	15531	40	,	,	,
18637	15531	41	and	and	CC
18637	15531	42	in	in	IN
18637	15531	43	effect	effect	NN
18637	15531	44	to	to	TO
18637	15531	45	permit	permit	VB
18637	15531	46	every	every	DT
18637	15531	47	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	15531	48	to	to	TO
18637	15531	49	become	become	VB
18637	15531	50	a	a	DT
18637	15531	51	law	law	NN
18637	15531	52	unto	unto	IN
18637	15531	53	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15531	54	.	.	.
18637	15532	1	"	"	``
18637	15532	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15532	3	44	44	CD
18637	15532	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15532	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15532	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	15532	7	not	not	RB
18637	15532	8	follow	follow	VB
18637	15532	9	that	that	IN
18637	15532	10	"	"	``
18637	15532	11	because	because	IN
18637	15532	12	no	no	DT
18637	15532	13	mode	mode	NN
18637	15532	14	of	of	IN
18637	15532	15	worship	worship	NN
18637	15532	16	can	can	MD
18637	15532	17	be	be	VB
18637	15532	18	established	establish	VBN
18637	15532	19	or	or	CC
18637	15532	20	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15532	21	tenets	tenet	NNS
18637	15532	22	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	15532	23	in	in	IN
18637	15532	24	this	this	DT
18637	15532	25	country	country	NN
18637	15532	26	,	,	,
18637	15532	27	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	15532	28	any	any	DT
18637	15532	29	tenets	tenet	NNS
18637	15532	30	,	,	,
18637	15532	31	however	however	RB
18637	15532	32	destructive	destructive	JJ
18637	15532	33	of	of	IN
18637	15532	34	society	society	NN
18637	15532	35	,	,	,
18637	15532	36	may	may	MD
18637	15532	37	be	be	VB
18637	15532	38	held	hold	VBN
18637	15532	39	and	and	CC
18637	15532	40	advocated	advocate	VBN
18637	15532	41	,	,	,
18637	15532	42	if	if	IN
18637	15532	43	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	15532	44	,	,	,
18637	15532	45	to	to	TO
18637	15532	46	be	be	VB
18637	15532	47	a	a	DT
18637	15532	48	part	part	NN
18637	15532	49	of	of	IN
18637	15532	50	the	the	DT
18637	15532	51	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15532	52	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15532	53	of	of	IN
18637	15532	54	those	those	DT
18637	15532	55	advocating	advocate	VBG
18637	15532	56	and	and	CC
18637	15532	57	practicing	practice	VBG
18637	15532	58	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15532	59	*	*	NFP
18637	15532	60	*	*	NFP
18637	15532	61	*	*	NFP
18637	15532	62	Whilst	whilst	IN
18637	15532	63	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15532	64	for	for	IN
18637	15532	65	the	the	DT
18637	15532	66	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	15532	67	of	of	IN
18637	15532	68	a	a	DT
18637	15532	69	religion	religion	NN
18637	15532	70	is	be	VBZ
18637	15532	71	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	15532	72	,	,	,
18637	15532	73	and	and	CC
18637	15532	74	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15532	75	free	free	JJ
18637	15532	76	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15532	77	permitted	permit	VBD
18637	15532	78	,	,	,
18637	15532	79	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15532	80	does	do	VBZ
18637	15532	81	not	not	RB
18637	15532	82	follow	follow	VB
18637	15532	83	that	that	IN
18637	15532	84	everything	everything	NN
18637	15532	85	which	which	WDT
18637	15532	86	may	may	MD
18637	15532	87	be	be	VB
18637	15532	88	so	so	RB
18637	15532	89	-	-	HYPH
18637	15532	90	called	call	VBN
18637	15532	91	can	can	MD
18637	15532	92	be	be	VB
18637	15532	93	tolerated	tolerate	VBN
18637	15532	94	.	.	.
18637	15533	1	Crime	crime	NN
18637	15533	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15533	3	not	not	RB
18637	15533	4	the	the	DT
18637	15533	5	less	less	RBR
18637	15533	6	odious	odious	JJ
18637	15533	7	because	because	IN
18637	15533	8	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
18637	15533	9	by	by	IN
18637	15533	10	what	what	WP
18637	15533	11	any	any	DT
18637	15533	12	particular	particular	JJ
18637	15533	13	sect	sect	NN
18637	15533	14	may	may	MD
18637	15533	15	designate	designate	VB
18637	15533	16	as	as	IN
18637	15533	17	religion	religion	NN
18637	15533	18	.	.	.
18637	15534	1	"	"	``
18637	15534	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15534	3	45	45	CD
18637	15534	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15534	5	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	15534	6	acts	act	NNS
18637	15534	7	of	of	IN
18637	15534	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15534	9	directed	direct	VBD
18637	15534	10	against	against	IN
18637	15534	11	either	either	CC
18637	15534	12	the	the	DT
18637	15534	13	practice	practice	NN
18637	15534	14	of	of	IN
18637	15534	15	the	the	DT
18637	15534	16	advocacy	advocacy	NN
18637	15534	17	of	of	IN
18637	15534	18	polygamy	polygamy	NN
18637	15534	19	by	by	IN
18637	15534	20	members	member	NNS
18637	15534	21	of	of	IN
18637	15534	22	a	a	DT
18637	15534	23	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15534	24	sect	sect	NN
18637	15534	25	which	which	WDT
18637	15534	26	sanctioned	sanction	VBD
18637	15534	27	the	the	DT
18637	15534	28	practice	practice	NN
18637	15534	29	,	,	,
18637	15534	30	were	be	VBD
18637	15534	31	held	hold	VBN
18637	15534	32	valid	valid	JJ
18637	15534	33	.	.	.
18637	15535	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15535	2	46	46	CD
18637	15535	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15535	4	But	but	CC
18637	15535	5	when	when	WRB
18637	15535	6	,	,	,
18637	15535	7	in	in	IN
18637	15535	8	the	the	DT
18637	15535	9	Ballard	Ballard	NNP
18637	15535	10	Case,[47	Case,[47	NNP
18637	15535	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15535	12	decided	decide	VBD
18637	15535	13	in	in	IN
18637	15535	14	1944	1944	CD
18637	15535	15	,	,	,
18637	15535	16	the	the	DT
18637	15535	17	promoters	promoter	NNS
18637	15535	18	of	of	IN
18637	15535	19	a	a	DT
18637	15535	20	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15535	21	sect	sect	NN
18637	15535	22	,	,	,
18637	15535	23	whose	whose	WP$
18637	15535	24	founder	founder	NN
18637	15535	25	had	have	VBD
18637	15535	26	at	at	IN
18637	15535	27	different	different	JJ
18637	15535	28	times	time	NNS
18637	15535	29	identified	identify	VBD
18637	15535	30	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15535	31	as	as	IN
18637	15535	32	Saint	Saint	NNP
18637	15535	33	Germain	Germain	NNP
18637	15535	34	,	,	,
18637	15535	35	Jesus	Jesus	NNP
18637	15535	36	,	,	,
18637	15535	37	George	George	NNP
18637	15535	38	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	15535	39	,	,	,
18637	15535	40	and	and	CC
18637	15535	41	Godfre	Godfre	NNP
18637	15535	42	Ray	Ray	NNP
18637	15535	43	King	King	NNP
18637	15535	44	,	,	,
18637	15535	45	were	be	VBD
18637	15535	46	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	15535	47	of	of	IN
18637	15535	48	using	use	VBG
18637	15535	49	the	the	DT
18637	15535	50	mails	mail	NNS
18637	15535	51	to	to	TO
18637	15535	52	defraud	defraud	VB
18637	15535	53	by	by	IN
18637	15535	54	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	15535	55	money	money	NN
18637	15535	56	on	on	IN
18637	15535	57	the	the	DT
18637	15535	58	strength	strength	NN
18637	15535	59	of	of	IN
18637	15535	60	having	have	VBG
18637	15535	61	supernaturally	supernaturally	RB
18637	15535	62	healed	heal	VBN
18637	15535	63	hundreds	hundred	NNS
18637	15535	64	of	of	IN
18637	15535	65	persons	person	NNS
18637	15535	66	,	,	,
18637	15535	67	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15535	68	found	find	VBD
18637	15535	69	the	the	DT
18637	15535	70	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15535	71	in	in	IN
18637	15535	72	a	a	DT
18637	15535	73	softened	soften	VBN
18637	15535	74	frame	frame	NN
18637	15535	75	of	of	IN
18637	15535	76	mind	mind	NN
18637	15535	77	.	.	.
18637	15536	1	Although	although	IN
18637	15536	2	the	the	DT
18637	15536	3	trial	trial	NN
18637	15536	4	judge	judge	NN
18637	15536	5	,	,	,
18637	15536	6	carefully	carefully	RB
18637	15536	7	discriminating	discriminate	VBG
18637	15536	8	between	between	IN
18637	15536	9	the	the	DT
18637	15536	10	question	question	NN
18637	15536	11	of	of	IN
18637	15536	12	the	the	DT
18637	15536	13	truth	truth	NN
18637	15536	14	of	of	IN
18637	15536	15	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	15536	16	'	'	POS
18637	15536	17	pretensions	pretension	NNS
18637	15536	18	and	and	CC
18637	15536	19	that	that	DT
18637	15536	20	of	of	IN
18637	15536	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15536	22	good	good	JJ
18637	15536	23	faith	faith	NN
18637	15536	24	in	in	IN
18637	15536	25	advancing	advance	VBG
18637	15536	26	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15536	27	,	,	,
18637	15536	28	had	have	VBD
18637	15536	29	charged	charge	VBN
18637	15536	30	the	the	DT
18637	15536	31	jury	jury	NN
18637	15536	32	that	that	IN
18637	15536	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15536	34	could	could	MD
18637	15536	35	pass	pass	VB
18637	15536	36	on	on	RP
18637	15536	37	the	the	DT
18637	15536	38	latter	latter	JJ
18637	15536	39	but	but	CC
18637	15536	40	not	not	RB
18637	15536	41	the	the	DT
18637	15536	42	former	former	JJ
18637	15536	43	,	,	,
18637	15536	44	this	this	DT
18637	15536	45	caution	caution	NN
18637	15536	46	did	do	VBD
18637	15536	47	not	not	RB
18637	15536	48	avail	avail	VB
18637	15536	49	with	with	IN
18637	15536	50	the	the	DT
18637	15536	51	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15536	52	,	,	,
18637	15536	53	which	which	WDT
18637	15536	54	contrived	contrive	VBD
18637	15536	55	on	on	IN
18637	15536	56	another	another	DT
18637	15536	57	ground	ground	NN
18637	15536	58	ultimately	ultimately	RB
18637	15536	59	to	to	TO
18637	15536	60	upset	upset	VB
18637	15536	61	the	the	DT
18637	15536	62	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	15536	63	of	of	IN
18637	15536	64	"	"	``
18637	15536	65	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	15536	66	.	.	.
18637	15536	67	"	"	''
18637	15537	1	The	the	DT
18637	15537	2	late	late	JJ
18637	15537	3	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15537	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15537	5	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	15537	6	,	,	,
18637	15537	7	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15537	8	for	for	IN
18637	15537	9	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15537	10	and	and	CC
18637	15537	11	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15537	12	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	15537	13	and	and	CC
18637	15537	14	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	15537	15	,	,	,
18637	15537	16	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	15537	17	:	:	:
18637	15537	18	"	"	``
18637	15537	19	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15537	20	can	can	MD
18637	15537	21	not	not	RB
18637	15537	22	say	say	VB
18637	15537	23	that	that	DT
18637	15537	24	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15537	25	of	of	IN
18637	15537	26	thought	thought	NN
18637	15537	27	and	and	CC
18637	15537	28	worship	worship	NN
18637	15537	29	includes	include	VBZ
18637	15537	30	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15537	31	to	to	TO
18637	15537	32	procure	procure	VB
18637	15537	33	money	money	NN
18637	15537	34	by	by	IN
18637	15537	35	making	make	VBG
18637	15537	36	knowingly	knowingly	RB
18637	15537	37	false	false	JJ
18637	15537	38	statements	statement	NNS
18637	15537	39	about	about	IN
18637	15537	40	one	one	PRP
18637	15537	41	's	's	POS
18637	15537	42	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15537	43	experiences	experience	NNS
18637	15537	44	.	.	.
18637	15538	1	"	"	``
18637	15538	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15538	3	48	48	CD
18637	15538	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15538	5	FREE	free	JJ
18637	15538	6	EXERCISE	exercise	NN
18637	15538	7	OF	of	IN
18637	15538	8	RELIGION	religion	NN
18637	15538	9	:	:	:
18637	15538	10	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	15538	11	AND	and	CC
18637	15538	12	LOCAL	local	NN
18637	15538	13	RESTRAINTS	restraint	NNS
18637	15538	14	The	the	DT
18637	15538	15	Mormon	Mormon	NNP
18637	15538	16	Church	Church	NNP
18637	15538	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	15538	18	were	be	VBD
18637	15538	19	decided	decide	VBN
18637	15538	20	prior	prior	RB
18637	15538	21	to	to	IN
18637	15538	22	the	the	DT
18637	15538	23	emergence	emergence	NN
18637	15538	24	of	of	IN
18637	15538	25	the	the	DT
18637	15538	26	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15538	27	and	and	CC
18637	15538	28	present	present	JJ
18637	15538	29	danger	danger	NN
18637	15538	30	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15538	31	dealt	deal	VBD
18637	15538	32	with	with	IN
18637	15538	33	below	below	RB
18637	15538	34	.	.	.
18637	15539	1	In	in	IN
18637	15539	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15539	3	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	15539	4	of	of	IN
18637	15539	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	15539	6	stemming	stem	VBG
18637	15539	7	from	from	IN
18637	15539	8	State	State	NNP
18637	15539	9	and	and	CC
18637	15539	10	local	local	JJ
18637	15539	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15539	12	the	the	DT
18637	15539	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15539	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	15539	15	endeavored	endeavor	VBN
18637	15539	16	at	at	IN
18637	15539	17	times	time	NNS
18637	15539	18	to	to	TO
18637	15539	19	take	take	VB
18637	15539	20	account	account	NN
18637	15539	21	of	of	IN
18637	15539	22	this	this	DT
18637	15539	23	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15539	24	,	,	,
18637	15539	25	with	with	IN
18637	15539	26	the	the	DT
18637	15539	27	result	result	NN
18637	15539	28	that	that	IN
18637	15539	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15539	30	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	15539	31	have	have	VBP
18637	15539	32	followed	follow	VBN
18637	15539	33	a	a	DT
18637	15539	34	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	15539	35	erratic	erratic	JJ
18637	15539	36	course	course	NN
18637	15539	37	.	.	.
18637	15540	1	The	the	DT
18637	15540	2	leading	leading	JJ
18637	15540	3	case	case	NN
18637	15540	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	15540	5	Cantwell	Cantwell	NNP
18637	15540	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15540	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15540	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15540	9	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	15540	10	.	.	.
18637	15541	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15541	2	49	49	CD
18637	15541	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15541	4	Here	here	RB
18637	15541	5	three	three	CD
18637	15541	6	members	member	NNS
18637	15541	7	of	of	IN
18637	15541	8	the	the	DT
18637	15541	9	sect	sect	NN
18637	15541	10	calling	call	VBG
18637	15541	11	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15541	12	Jehovah	Jehovah	NNP
18637	15541	13	's	's	POS
18637	15541	14	Witnesses	Witnesses	NNPS
18637	15541	15	were	be	VBD
18637	15541	16	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	15541	17	under	under	IN
18637	15541	18	a	a	DT
18637	15541	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	15541	20	which	which	WDT
18637	15541	21	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	15541	22	the	the	DT
18637	15541	23	unlicensed	unlicensed	JJ
18637	15541	24	soliciting	soliciting	NN
18637	15541	25	of	of	IN
18637	15541	26	funds	fund	NNS
18637	15541	27	on	on	IN
18637	15541	28	the	the	DT
18637	15541	29	representation	representation	NN
18637	15541	30	that	that	IN
18637	15541	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15541	32	were	be	VBD
18637	15541	33	for	for	IN
18637	15541	34	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15541	35	or	or	CC
18637	15541	36	charitable	charitable	JJ
18637	15541	37	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	15541	38	,	,	,
18637	15541	39	and	and	CC
18637	15541	40	also	also	RB
18637	15541	41	on	on	IN
18637	15541	42	a	a	DT
18637	15541	43	general	general	JJ
18637	15541	44	charge	charge	NN
18637	15541	45	of	of	IN
18637	15541	46	breach	breach	NN
18637	15541	47	of	of	IN
18637	15541	48	the	the	DT
18637	15541	49	peace	peace	NN
18637	15541	50	by	by	IN
18637	15541	51	accosting	accost	VBG
18637	15541	52	in	in	IN
18637	15541	53	a	a	DT
18637	15541	54	strongly	strongly	RB
18637	15541	55	Catholic	catholic	JJ
18637	15541	56	neighborhood	neighborhood	NN
18637	15541	57	two	two	CD
18637	15541	58	communicants	communicant	NNS
18637	15541	59	of	of	IN
18637	15541	60	that	that	DT
18637	15541	61	faith	faith	NN
18637	15541	62	and	and	CC
18637	15541	63	playing	play	VBG
18637	15541	64	to	to	IN
18637	15541	65	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15541	66	a	a	DT
18637	15541	67	phonograph	phonograph	NN
18637	15541	68	record	record	NN
18637	15541	69	which	which	WDT
18637	15541	70	grossly	grossly	RB
18637	15541	71	insulted	insult	VBD
18637	15541	72	the	the	DT
18637	15541	73	Christian	christian	JJ
18637	15541	74	religion	religion	NN
18637	15541	75	in	in	IN
18637	15541	76	general	general	JJ
18637	15541	77	and	and	CC
18637	15541	78	the	the	DT
18637	15541	79	Catholic	Catholic	NNP
18637	15541	80	church	church	NN
18637	15541	81	in	in	IN
18637	15541	82	particular	particular	JJ
18637	15541	83	.	.	.
18637	15542	1	Both	both	DT
18637	15542	2	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	15542	3	were	be	VBD
18637	15542	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	15542	5	to	to	TO
18637	15542	6	violate	violate	VB
18637	15542	7	the	the	DT
18637	15542	8	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15542	9	guarantees	guarantee	NNS
18637	15542	10	of	of	IN
18637	15542	11	speech	speech	NN
18637	15542	12	and	and	CC
18637	15542	13	religion	religion	NN
18637	15542	14	,	,	,
18637	15542	15	the	the	DT
18637	15542	16	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15542	17	and	and	CC
18637	15542	18	present	present	JJ
18637	15542	19	danger	danger	NN
18637	15542	20	rule	rule	NN
18637	15542	21	being	be	VBG
18637	15542	22	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	15542	23	in	in	IN
18637	15542	24	partial	partial	JJ
18637	15542	25	justification	justification	NN
18637	15542	26	of	of	IN
18637	15542	27	the	the	DT
18637	15542	28	holding	holding	NN
18637	15542	29	,	,	,
18637	15542	30	although	although	IN
18637	15542	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15542	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	15542	33	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	15542	34	inferable	inferable	JJ
18637	15542	35	from	from	IN
18637	15542	36	the	the	DT
18637	15542	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15542	38	's	's	POS
18637	15542	39	own	own	JJ
18637	15542	40	recital	recital	NN
18637	15542	41	of	of	IN
18637	15542	42	the	the	DT
18637	15542	43	facts	fact	NNS
18637	15542	44	that	that	WDT
18637	15542	45	the	the	DT
18637	15542	46	listeners	listener	NNS
18637	15542	47	to	to	IN
18637	15542	48	the	the	DT
18637	15542	49	phonograph	phonograph	NN
18637	15542	50	record	record	NN
18637	15542	51	exhibited	exhibit	VBD
18637	15542	52	a	a	DT
18637	15542	53	degree	degree	NN
18637	15542	54	of	of	IN
18637	15542	55	self	self	NN
18637	15542	56	-	-	HYPH
18637	15542	57	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	15542	58	rather	rather	RB
18637	15542	59	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	15542	60	under	under	IN
18637	15542	61	the	the	DT
18637	15542	62	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	15542	63	.	.	.
18637	15543	1	Two	two	CD
18637	15543	2	weeks	week	NNS
18637	15543	3	later	later	RB
18637	15543	4	the	the	DT
18637	15543	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15543	6	,	,	,
18637	15543	7	as	as	IN
18637	15543	8	if	if	IN
18637	15543	9	to	to	TO
18637	15543	10	"	"	``
18637	15543	11	compensate	compensate	VB
18637	15543	12	"	"	''
18637	15543	13	for	for	IN
18637	15543	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15543	15	zeal	zeal	NN
18637	15543	16	in	in	IN
18637	15543	17	the	the	DT
18637	15543	18	Cantwell	Cantwell	NNP
18637	15543	19	Case	Case	NNP
18637	15543	20	,	,	,
18637	15543	21	went	go	VBD
18637	15543	22	to	to	IN
18637	15543	23	the	the	DT
18637	15543	24	other	other	JJ
18637	15543	25	extreme	extreme	NN
18637	15543	26	,	,	,
18637	15543	27	and	and	CC
18637	15543	28	urging	urge	VBG
18637	15543	29	the	the	DT
18637	15543	30	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	15543	31	that	that	IN
18637	15543	32	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	15543	33	acts	act	NNS
18637	15543	34	must	must	MD
18637	15543	35	be	be	VB
18637	15543	36	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	15543	37	to	to	TO
18637	15543	38	be	be	VB
18637	15543	39	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15543	40	,	,	,
18637	15543	41	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15543	42	the	the	DT
18637	15543	43	State	State	NNP
18637	15543	44	of	of	IN
18637	15543	45	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	15543	46	in	in	IN
18637	15543	47	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	15543	48	from	from	IN
18637	15543	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15543	50	schools	school	NNS
18637	15543	51	children	child	NNS
18637	15543	52	of	of	IN
18637	15543	53	the	the	DT
18637	15543	54	Jehovah	Jehovah	NNP
18637	15543	55	's	's	POS
18637	15543	56	Witnesses	Witnesses	NNPS
18637	15543	57	,	,	,
18637	15543	58	who	who	WP
18637	15543	59	in	in	IN
18637	15543	60	the	the	DT
18637	15543	61	name	name	NN
18637	15543	62	of	of	IN
18637	15543	63	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15543	64	beliefs	belief	NNS
18637	15543	65	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	15543	66	to	to	TO
18637	15543	67	salute	salute	VB
18637	15543	68	the	the	DT
18637	15543	69	flag	flag	NN
18637	15543	70	.	.	.
18637	15544	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15544	2	50	50	CD
18637	15544	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15544	4	The	the	DT
18637	15544	5	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	15544	6	record	record	NN
18637	15544	7	of	of	IN
18637	15544	8	the	the	DT
18637	15544	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15544	10	's	's	POS
18637	15544	11	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	15544	12	in	in	IN
18637	15544	13	this	this	DT
18637	15544	14	field	field	NN
18637	15544	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	15544	16	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	15544	17	variable	variable	JJ
18637	15544	18	.	.	.
18637	15545	1	A	a	DT
18637	15545	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	15545	3	in	in	IN
18637	15545	4	June	June	NNP
18637	15545	5	,	,	,
18637	15545	6	1942	1942	CD
18637	15545	7	,	,	,
18637	15545	8	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	15545	9	the	the	DT
18637	15545	10	application	application	NN
18637	15545	11	to	to	IN
18637	15545	12	vendors	vendor	NNS
18637	15545	13	of	of	IN
18637	15545	14	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15545	15	books	book	NNS
18637	15545	16	and	and	CC
18637	15545	17	pamphlets	pamphlet	NNS
18637	15545	18	of	of	IN
18637	15545	19	a	a	DT
18637	15545	20	nondiscriminatory	nondiscriminatory	JJ
18637	15545	21	license	license	NN
18637	15545	22	fee[51	fee[51	NNP
18637	15545	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15545	24	was	be	VBD
18637	15545	25	eleven	eleven	CD
18637	15545	26	months	month	NNS
18637	15545	27	later	later	RB
18637	15545	28	vacated	vacate	VBD
18637	15545	29	and	and	CC
18637	15545	30	formally	formally	RB
18637	15545	31	reversed;[52	reversed;[52	NNP
18637	15545	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15545	33	shortly	shortly	RB
18637	15545	34	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	15545	35	a	a	DT
18637	15545	36	like	like	JJ
18637	15545	37	fate	fate	NN
18637	15545	38	overtook	overtake	VBD
18637	15545	39	the	the	DT
18637	15545	40	decision	decision	NN
18637	15545	41	in	in	IN
18637	15545	42	the	the	DT
18637	15545	43	"	"	``
18637	15545	44	Flag	Flag	NNP
18637	15545	45	Salute	Salute	NNP
18637	15545	46	"	"	''
18637	15545	47	Case	Case	NNP
18637	15545	48	.	.	.
18637	15546	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15546	2	53	53	CD
18637	15546	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15546	4	In	in	IN
18637	15546	5	May	May	NNP
18637	15546	6	,	,	,
18637	15546	7	1943	1943	CD
18637	15546	8	,	,	,
18637	15546	9	the	the	DT
18637	15546	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15546	11	found	find	VBD
18637	15546	12	that	that	IN
18637	15546	13	an	an	DT
18637	15546	14	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	15546	15	of	of	IN
18637	15546	16	the	the	DT
18637	15546	17	city	city	NN
18637	15546	18	of	of	IN
18637	15546	19	Struthers	Struthers	NNP
18637	15546	20	,	,	,
18637	15546	21	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	15546	22	,	,	,
18637	15546	23	which	which	WDT
18637	15546	24	made	make	VBD
18637	15546	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15546	26	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	15546	27	for	for	IN
18637	15546	28	anyone	anyone	NN
18637	15546	29	distributing	distribute	VBG
18637	15546	30	literature	literature	NN
18637	15546	31	to	to	TO
18637	15546	32	ring	ring	VB
18637	15546	33	a	a	DT
18637	15546	34	doorbell	doorbell	NN
18637	15546	35	or	or	CC
18637	15546	36	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	15546	37	summon	summon	NNP
18637	15546	38	the	the	DT
18637	15546	39	dwellers	dweller	NNS
18637	15546	40	of	of	IN
18637	15546	41	a	a	DT
18637	15546	42	residence	residence	NN
18637	15546	43	to	to	IN
18637	15546	44	the	the	DT
18637	15546	45	door	door	NN
18637	15546	46	to	to	TO
18637	15546	47	receive	receive	VB
18637	15546	48	such	such	JJ
18637	15546	49	literature	literature	NN
18637	15546	50	,	,	,
18637	15546	51	was	be	VBD
18637	15546	52	violative	violative	JJ
18637	15546	53	of	of	IN
18637	15546	54	the	the	DT
18637	15546	55	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15546	56	when	when	WRB
18637	15546	57	applied	apply	VBN
18637	15546	58	to	to	IN
18637	15546	59	distributors	distributor	NNS
18637	15546	60	of	of	IN
18637	15546	61	leaflets	leaflet	NNS
18637	15546	62	advertising	advertise	VBG
18637	15546	63	a	a	DT
18637	15546	64	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15546	65	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	15546	66	.	.	.
18637	15547	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15547	2	54	54	CD
18637	15547	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15547	4	But	but	CC
18637	15547	5	eight	eight	CD
18637	15547	6	months	month	NNS
18637	15547	7	later	later	RB
18637	15547	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15547	9	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15547	10	the	the	DT
18637	15547	11	application	application	NN
18637	15547	12	of	of	IN
18637	15547	13	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	15547	14	'	'	POS
18637	15547	15	child	child	NN
18637	15547	16	labor	labor	NN
18637	15547	17	laws	law	NNS
18637	15547	18	in	in	IN
18637	15547	19	the	the	DT
18637	15547	20	case	case	NN
18637	15547	21	of	of	IN
18637	15547	22	a	a	DT
18637	15547	23	nine	nine	CD
18637	15547	24	year	year	NN
18637	15547	25	old	old	JJ
18637	15547	26	girl	girl	NN
18637	15547	27	who	who	WP
18637	15547	28	was	be	VBD
18637	15547	29	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	15547	30	by	by	IN
18637	15547	31	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15547	32	legal	legal	JJ
18637	15547	33	custodian	custodian	NN
18637	15547	34	to	to	TO
18637	15547	35	engage	engage	VB
18637	15547	36	in	in	IN
18637	15547	37	"	"	``
18637	15547	38	preaching	preach	VBG
18637	15547	39	work	work	NN
18637	15547	40	"	"	''
18637	15547	41	and	and	CC
18637	15547	42	the	the	DT
18637	15547	43	sale	sale	NN
18637	15547	44	of	of	IN
18637	15547	45	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15547	46	publications	publication	NNS
18637	15547	47	after	after	IN
18637	15547	48	hours	hour	NNS
18637	15547	49	.	.	.
18637	15548	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15548	2	55	55	CD
18637	15548	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15548	4	However	however	RB
18637	15548	5	,	,	,
18637	15548	6	in	in	IN
18637	15548	7	Saia	Saia	NNP
18637	15548	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15548	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	15548	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15548	11	New	New	NNP
18637	15548	12	York[56	York[56	NNP
18637	15548	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15548	14	decided	decide	VBD
18637	15548	15	in	in	IN
18637	15548	16	1948	1948	CD
18637	15548	17	,	,	,
18637	15548	18	the	the	DT
18637	15548	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15548	20	held	hold	VBD
18637	15548	21	,	,	,
18637	15548	22	by	by	IN
18637	15548	23	a	a	DT
18637	15548	24	vote	vote	NN
18637	15548	25	of	of	IN
18637	15548	26	five	five	CD
18637	15548	27	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	15548	28	to	to	IN
18637	15548	29	four	four	CD
18637	15548	30	,	,	,
18637	15548	31	that	that	IN
18637	15548	32	an	an	DT
18637	15548	33	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	15548	34	of	of	IN
18637	15548	35	the	the	DT
18637	15548	36	city	city	NN
18637	15548	37	of	of	IN
18637	15548	38	Lockport	Lockport	NNP
18637	15548	39	,	,	,
18637	15548	40	New	New	NNP
18637	15548	41	York	York	NNP
18637	15548	42	,	,	,
18637	15548	43	which	which	WDT
18637	15548	44	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	15548	45	the	the	DT
18637	15548	46	use	use	NN
18637	15548	47	of	of	IN
18637	15548	48	sound	sound	JJ
18637	15548	49	amplification	amplification	NN
18637	15548	50	devices	device	NNS
18637	15548	51	except	except	IN
18637	15548	52	with	with	IN
18637	15548	53	the	the	DT
18637	15548	54	permission	permission	NN
18637	15548	55	of	of	IN
18637	15548	56	the	the	DT
18637	15548	57	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15548	58	of	of	IN
18637	15548	59	Police	Police	NNPS
18637	15548	60	was	be	VBD
18637	15548	61	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	15548	62	as	as	IN
18637	15548	63	applied	apply	VBN
18637	15548	64	in	in	IN
18637	15548	65	the	the	DT
18637	15548	66	case	case	NN
18637	15548	67	of	of	IN
18637	15548	68	a	a	DT
18637	15548	69	Jehovah	Jehovah	NNP
18637	15548	70	's	's	POS
18637	15548	71	Witness	Witness	NNP
18637	15548	72	who	who	WP
18637	15548	73	used	use	VBD
18637	15548	74	sound	sound	JJ
18637	15548	75	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	15548	76	to	to	TO
18637	15548	77	amplify	amplify	VB
18637	15548	78	lectures	lecture	NNS
18637	15548	79	in	in	IN
18637	15548	80	a	a	DT
18637	15548	81	public	public	JJ
18637	15548	82	park	park	NN
18637	15548	83	on	on	IN
18637	15548	84	Sunday	Sunday	NNP
18637	15548	85	,	,	,
18637	15548	86	on	on	IN
18637	15548	87	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15548	88	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	15548	89	.	.	.
18637	15549	1	But	but	CC
18637	15549	2	a	a	DT
18637	15549	3	few	few	JJ
18637	15549	4	months	month	NNS
18637	15549	5	later	later	RB
18637	15549	6	the	the	DT
18637	15549	7	same	same	JJ
18637	15549	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15549	9	,	,	,
18637	15549	10	again	again	RB
18637	15549	11	dividing	divide	VBG
18637	15549	12	five	five	CD
18637	15549	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	15549	14	to	to	IN
18637	15549	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	15549	16	four	four	CD
18637	15549	17	,	,	,
18637	15549	18	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15549	19	a	a	DT
18637	15549	20	Trenton	Trenton	NNP
18637	15549	21	,	,	,
18637	15549	22	New	New	NNP
18637	15549	23	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	15549	24	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	15549	25	which	which	WDT
18637	15549	26	banned	ban	VBD
18637	15549	27	from	from	IN
18637	15549	28	that	that	DT
18637	15549	29	city	city	NN
18637	15549	30	's	's	POS
18637	15549	31	streets	street	NNS
18637	15549	32	all	all	DT
18637	15549	33	loud	loud	JJ
18637	15549	34	speakers	speaker	NNS
18637	15549	35	and	and	CC
18637	15549	36	other	other	JJ
18637	15549	37	devices	device	NNS
18637	15549	38	which	which	WDT
18637	15549	39	emit	emit	VBP
18637	15549	40	"	"	``
18637	15549	41	loud	loud	JJ
18637	15549	42	and	and	CC
18637	15549	43	raucous	raucous	JJ
18637	15549	44	noises	noise	NNS
18637	15549	45	.	.	.
18637	15550	1	"	"	``
18637	15550	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15550	3	57	57	CD
18637	15550	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15550	5	The	the	DT
18637	15550	6	latest	late	JJS
18637	15550	7	state	state	NN
18637	15550	8	of	of	IN
18637	15550	9	the	the	DT
18637	15550	10	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15550	11	on	on	IN
18637	15550	12	this	this	DT
18637	15550	13	particular	particular	JJ
18637	15550	14	topic	topic	NN
18637	15550	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	15550	16	represented	represent	VBN
18637	15550	17	by	by	IN
18637	15550	18	three	three	CD
18637	15550	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	15550	20	,	,	,
18637	15550	21	all	all	DT
18637	15550	22	decided	decide	VBD
18637	15550	23	the	the	DT
18637	15550	24	same	same	JJ
18637	15550	25	day	day	NN
18637	15550	26	.	.	.
18637	15551	1	In	in	IN
18637	15551	2	one	one	CD
18637	15551	3	the	the	DT
18637	15551	4	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15551	5	of	of	IN
18637	15551	6	a	a	DT
18637	15551	7	Baptist	Baptist	NNP
18637	15551	8	minister	minister	NN
18637	15551	9	for	for	IN
18637	15551	10	conducting	conduct	VBG
18637	15551	11	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15551	12	services	service	NNS
18637	15551	13	in	in	IN
18637	15551	14	the	the	DT
18637	15551	15	streets	street	NNS
18637	15551	16	of	of	IN
18637	15551	17	New	New	NNP
18637	15551	18	York	York	NNP
18637	15551	19	City	City	NNP
18637	15551	20	without	without	IN
18637	15551	21	first	first	RB
18637	15551	22	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	15551	23	a	a	DT
18637	15551	24	permit	permit	NN
18637	15551	25	from	from	IN
18637	15551	26	the	the	DT
18637	15551	27	city	city	NN
18637	15551	28	police	police	NNS
18637	15551	29	commissioner	commissioner	NN
18637	15551	30	was	be	VBD
18637	15551	31	overturned,[58	overturned,[58	CD
18637	15551	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15551	33	a	a	DT
18637	15551	34	permit	permit	NN
18637	15551	35	having	have	VBG
18637	15551	36	been	be	VBN
18637	15551	37	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	15551	38	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15551	39	on	on	IN
18637	15551	40	the	the	DT
18637	15551	41	ground	ground	NN
18637	15551	42	that	that	IN
18637	15551	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15551	44	had	have	VBD
18637	15551	45	in	in	IN
18637	15551	46	the	the	DT
18637	15551	47	past	past	NN
18637	15551	48	ridiculed	ridicule	VBN
18637	15551	49	other	other	JJ
18637	15551	50	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15551	51	beliefs	belief	NNS
18637	15551	52	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	15551	53	stirring	stir	VBG
18637	15551	54	strife	strife	NN
18637	15551	55	and	and	CC
18637	15551	56	threatening	threaten	VBG
18637	15551	57	violence	violence	NN
18637	15551	58	.	.	.
18637	15552	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15552	2	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	15552	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	15552	4	,	,	,
18637	15552	5	quoting	quote	VBG
18637	15552	6	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	15552	7	Bertrand	Bertrand	NNP
18637	15552	8	Russell	Russell	NNP
18637	15552	9	to	to	TO
18637	15552	10	prove	prove	VB
18637	15552	11	that	that	IN
18637	15552	12	"	"	``
18637	15552	13	too	too	RB
18637	15552	14	little	little	JJ
18637	15552	15	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15552	16	brings	bring	VBZ
18637	15552	17	stagnation	stagnation	NN
18637	15552	18	,	,	,
18637	15552	19	and	and	CC
18637	15552	20	too	too	RB
18637	15552	21	much	much	JJ
18637	15552	22	brings	bring	VBZ
18637	15552	23	chaos	chaos	NN
18637	15552	24	.	.	.
18637	15553	1	The	the	DT
18637	15553	2	fever	fever	NN
18637	15553	3	of	of	IN
18637	15553	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15553	5	times	time	NNS
18637	15553	6	,	,	,
18637	15553	7	"	"	''
18637	15553	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15553	9	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	15553	10	,	,	,
18637	15553	11	"	"	''
18637	15553	12	inclines	incline	VBZ
18637	15553	13	the	the	DT
18637	15553	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15553	15	today	today	NN
18637	15553	16	to	to	TO
18637	15553	17	favor	favor	VB
18637	15553	18	chaos	chaos	NN
18637	15553	19	.	.	.
18637	15554	1	"	"	``
18637	15554	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15554	3	59	59	CD
18637	15554	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15554	5	In	in	IN
18637	15554	6	the	the	DT
18637	15554	7	second	second	JJ
18637	15554	8	,	,	,
18637	15554	9	the	the	DT
18637	15554	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15554	11	upset	upset	VBD
18637	15554	12	the	the	DT
18637	15554	13	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15554	14	of	of	IN
18637	15554	15	a	a	DT
18637	15554	16	group	group	NN
18637	15554	17	of	of	IN
18637	15554	18	Jehovah	Jehovah	NNP
18637	15554	19	's	's	POS
18637	15554	20	Witnesses	Witnesses	NNPS
18637	15554	21	in	in	IN
18637	15554	22	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	15554	23	for	for	IN
18637	15554	24	using	use	VBG
18637	15554	25	a	a	DT
18637	15554	26	public	public	JJ
18637	15554	27	park	park	NN
18637	15554	28	without	without	IN
18637	15554	29	first	first	RB
18637	15554	30	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	15554	31	a	a	DT
18637	15554	32	permit	permit	NN
18637	15554	33	.	.	.
18637	15555	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15555	2	60	60	CD
18637	15555	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15555	4	The	the	DT
18637	15555	5	third	third	JJ
18637	15555	6	case,[61	case,[61	NN
18637	15555	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15555	8	which	which	WDT
18637	15555	9	had	have	VBD
18637	15555	10	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	15555	11	to	to	TO
18637	15555	12	do	do	VB
18637	15555	13	with	with	IN
18637	15555	14	religion	religion	NN
18637	15555	15	,	,	,
18637	15555	16	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	15555	17	an	an	DT
18637	15555	18	interesting	interesting	JJ
18637	15555	19	foil	foil	NN
18637	15555	20	to	to	IN
18637	15555	21	the	the	DT
18637	15555	22	other	other	JJ
18637	15555	23	two	two	CD
18637	15555	24	.	.	.
18637	15556	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15556	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15556	3	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	15556	4	with	with	IN
18637	15556	5	in	in	IN
18637	15556	6	another	another	DT
18637	15556	7	connection	connection	NN
18637	15556	8	.	.	.
18637	15557	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15557	2	62	62	CD
18637	15557	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15557	4	FREE	free	JJ
18637	15557	5	EXERCISE	exercise	NN
18637	15557	6	OF	of	IN
18637	15557	7	RELIGION	religion	NN
18637	15557	8	:	:	:
18637	15557	9	OBLIGATIONS	obligations	RB
18637	15557	10	OF	of	IN
18637	15557	11	CITIZENSHIP	citizenship	NN
18637	15557	12	In	in	IN
18637	15557	13	1918	1918	CD
18637	15557	14	the	the	DT
18637	15557	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15557	16	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	15557	17	as	as	RB
18637	15557	18	too	too	RB
18637	15557	19	unsound	unsound	JJ
18637	15557	20	to	to	TO
18637	15557	21	require	require	VB
18637	15557	22	more	more	JJR
18637	15557	23	than	than	IN
18637	15557	24	a	a	DT
18637	15557	25	mere	mere	JJ
18637	15557	26	statement	statement	NN
18637	15557	27	the	the	DT
18637	15557	28	argument	argument	NN
18637	15557	29	that	that	IN
18637	15557	30	the	the	DT
18637	15557	31	Selective	Selective	NNP
18637	15557	32	Service	Service	NNP
18637	15557	33	Act	Act	NNP
18637	15557	34	was	be	VBD
18637	15557	35	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	15557	36	to	to	IN
18637	15557	37	the	the	DT
18637	15557	38	First	First	NNP
18637	15557	39	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15557	40	as	as	IN
18637	15557	41	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	15557	42	or	or	CC
18637	15557	43	interfering	interfere	VBG
18637	15557	44	with	with	IN
18637	15557	45	religion	religion	NN
18637	15557	46	,	,	,
18637	15557	47	by	by	IN
18637	15557	48	reason	reason	NN
18637	15557	49	of	of	IN
18637	15557	50	the	the	DT
18637	15557	51	exemptions	exemption	NNS
18637	15557	52	granted	grant	VBD
18637	15557	53	ministers	minister	NNS
18637	15557	54	of	of	IN
18637	15557	55	religion	religion	NN
18637	15557	56	,	,	,
18637	15557	57	theological	theological	JJ
18637	15557	58	students	student	NNS
18637	15557	59	and	and	CC
18637	15557	60	members	member	NNS
18637	15557	61	of	of	IN
18637	15557	62	sects	sect	NNS
18637	15557	63	whose	whose	WP$
18637	15557	64	tenets	tenet	NNS
18637	15557	65	exclude	exclude	VBP
18637	15557	66	the	the	DT
18637	15557	67	moral	moral	JJ
18637	15557	68	right	right	NN
18637	15557	69	to	to	TO
18637	15557	70	engage	engage	VB
18637	15557	71	in	in	IN
18637	15557	72	war	war	NN
18637	15557	73	.	.	.
18637	15558	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15558	2	63	63	CD
18637	15558	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15558	4	The	the	DT
18637	15558	5	opposite	opposite	JJ
18637	15558	6	aspect	aspect	NN
18637	15558	7	of	of	IN
18637	15558	8	this	this	DT
18637	15558	9	problem	problem	NN
18637	15558	10	was	be	VBD
18637	15558	11	presented	present	VBN
18637	15558	12	in	in	IN
18637	15558	13	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	15558	14	_	_	NNP
18637	15558	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	15558	16	_	_	NNP
18637	15558	17	Regents	Regents	NNP
18637	15558	18	.	.	.
18637	15559	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15559	2	64	64	CD
18637	15559	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15559	4	There	there	RB
18637	15559	5	a	a	DT
18637	15559	6	California	California	NNP
18637	15559	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	15559	8	requiring	require	VBG
18637	15559	9	all	all	DT
18637	15559	10	male	male	JJ
18637	15559	11	students	student	NNS
18637	15559	12	at	at	IN
18637	15559	13	the	the	DT
18637	15559	14	State	State	NNP
18637	15559	15	university	university	NN
18637	15559	16	to	to	TO
18637	15559	17	take	take	VB
18637	15559	18	a	a	DT
18637	15559	19	course	course	NN
18637	15559	20	in	in	IN
18637	15559	21	military	military	JJ
18637	15559	22	science	science	NN
18637	15559	23	and	and	CC
18637	15559	24	tactics	tactic	NNS
18637	15559	25	was	be	VBD
18637	15559	26	assailed	assail	VBN
18637	15559	27	by	by	IN
18637	15559	28	students	student	NNS
18637	15559	29	who	who	WP
18637	15559	30	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	15559	31	that	that	IN
18637	15559	32	military	military	JJ
18637	15559	33	training	training	NN
18637	15559	34	was	be	VBD
18637	15559	35	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	15559	36	to	to	IN
18637	15559	37	the	the	DT
18637	15559	38	precepts	precept	NNS
18637	15559	39	of	of	IN
18637	15559	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15559	41	religion	religion	NN
18637	15559	42	.	.	.
18637	15560	1	This	this	DT
18637	15560	2	act	act	NN
18637	15560	3	did	do	VBD
18637	15560	4	not	not	RB
18637	15560	5	require	require	VB
18637	15560	6	military	military	JJ
18637	15560	7	service	service	NN
18637	15560	8	,	,	,
18637	15560	9	nor	nor	CC
18637	15560	10	did	do	VBD
18637	15560	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15560	12	peremptorily	peremptorily	RB
18637	15560	13	command	command	VB
18637	15560	14	submission	submission	NN
18637	15560	15	to	to	IN
18637	15560	16	military	military	JJ
18637	15560	17	training	training	NN
18637	15560	18	.	.	.
18637	15561	1	The	the	DT
18637	15561	2	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	15561	3	to	to	TO
18637	15561	4	take	take	VB
18637	15561	5	such	such	JJ
18637	15561	6	training	training	NN
18637	15561	7	was	be	VBD
18637	15561	8	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	15561	9	only	only	RB
18637	15561	10	as	as	IN
18637	15561	11	a	a	DT
18637	15561	12	condition	condition	NN
18637	15561	13	of	of	IN
18637	15561	14	attendance	attendance	NN
18637	15561	15	at	at	IN
18637	15561	16	the	the	DT
18637	15561	17	university	university	NN
18637	15561	18	.	.	.
18637	15562	1	In	in	IN
18637	15562	2	these	these	DT
18637	15562	3	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	15562	4	,	,	,
18637	15562	5	all	all	DT
18637	15562	6	members	member	NNS
18637	15562	7	of	of	IN
18637	15562	8	the	the	DT
18637	15562	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15562	10	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	15562	11	in	in	IN
18637	15562	12	the	the	DT
18637	15562	13	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	15562	14	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	15562	15	the	the	DT
18637	15562	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	15562	17	.	.	.
18637	15563	1	No	no	DT
18637	15563	2	such	such	JJ
18637	15563	3	unanimity	unanimity	NN
18637	15563	4	of	of	IN
18637	15563	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15563	6	prevailed	prevail	VBD
18637	15563	7	in	in	IN
18637	15563	8	In	in	IN
18637	15563	9	re	re	IN
18637	15563	10	Summers,[65	summers,[65	NN
18637	15563	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15563	12	where	where	WRB
18637	15563	13	the	the	DT
18637	15563	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15563	15	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	15563	16	the	the	DT
18637	15563	17	action	action	NN
18637	15563	18	of	of	IN
18637	15563	19	a	a	DT
18637	15563	20	State	State	NNP
18637	15563	21	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15563	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15563	23	in	in	IN
18637	15563	24	denying	deny	VBG
18637	15563	25	a	a	DT
18637	15563	26	license	license	NN
18637	15563	27	to	to	TO
18637	15563	28	practice	practice	VB
18637	15563	29	law	law	NN
18637	15563	30	to	to	IN
18637	15563	31	an	an	DT
18637	15563	32	applicant	applicant	NN
18637	15563	33	who	who	WP
18637	15563	34	entertained	entertain	VBD
18637	15563	35	conscientious	conscientious	JJ
18637	15563	36	scruples	scruple	NNS
18637	15563	37	against	against	IN
18637	15563	38	participation	participation	NN
18637	15563	39	in	in	IN
18637	15563	40	war	war	NN
18637	15563	41	.	.	.
18637	15564	1	The	the	DT
18637	15564	2	license	license	NN
18637	15564	3	was	be	VBD
18637	15564	4	withheld	withhold	VBN
18637	15564	5	on	on	IN
18637	15564	6	the	the	DT
18637	15564	7	premise	premise	NN
18637	15564	8	that	that	IN
18637	15564	9	a	a	DT
18637	15564	10	conscientious	conscientious	JJ
18637	15564	11	belief	belief	NN
18637	15564	12	in	in	IN
18637	15564	13	nonviolence	nonviolence	NN
18637	15564	14	to	to	IN
18637	15564	15	the	the	DT
18637	15564	16	extent	extent	NN
18637	15564	17	that	that	IN
18637	15564	18	the	the	DT
18637	15564	19	believer	believer	NN
18637	15564	20	would	would	MD
18637	15564	21	not	not	RB
18637	15564	22	use	use	VB
18637	15564	23	force	force	NN
18637	15564	24	to	to	TO
18637	15564	25	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	15564	26	wrong	wrong	NN
18637	15564	27	,	,	,
18637	15564	28	no	no	RB
18637	15564	29	matter	matter	RB
18637	15564	30	how	how	WRB
18637	15564	31	aggravated	aggravate	VBN
18637	15564	32	,	,	,
18637	15564	33	made	make	VBD
18637	15564	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15564	35	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	15564	36	for	for	IN
18637	15564	37	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15564	38	to	to	TO
18637	15564	39	swear	swear	VB
18637	15564	40	in	in	IN
18637	15564	41	good	good	JJ
18637	15564	42	faith	faith	NN
18637	15564	43	to	to	TO
18637	15564	44	support	support	VB
18637	15564	45	the	the	DT
18637	15564	46	State	State	NNP
18637	15564	47	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15564	48	.	.	.
18637	15565	1	The	the	DT
18637	15565	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15565	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15565	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	15565	5	that	that	IN
18637	15565	6	the	the	DT
18637	15565	7	State	State	NNP
18637	15565	8	's	's	POS
18637	15565	9	insistence	insistence	NN
18637	15565	10	that	that	IN
18637	15565	11	an	an	DT
18637	15565	12	officer	officer	NN
18637	15565	13	charged	charge	VBN
18637	15565	14	with	with	IN
18637	15565	15	the	the	DT
18637	15565	16	administration	administration	NN
18637	15565	17	of	of	IN
18637	15565	18	justice	justice	NN
18637	15565	19	take	take	VBP
18637	15565	20	such	such	PDT
18637	15565	21	an	an	DT
18637	15565	22	oath	oath	NN
18637	15565	23	and	and	CC
18637	15565	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15565	25	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	15565	26	of	of	IN
18637	15565	27	that	that	DT
18637	15565	28	oath	oath	NN
18637	15565	29	to	to	TO
18637	15565	30	require	require	VB
18637	15565	31	a	a	DT
18637	15565	32	willingness	willingness	NN
18637	15565	33	to	to	TO
18637	15565	34	perform	perform	VB
18637	15565	35	military	military	JJ
18637	15565	36	service	service	NN
18637	15565	37	,	,	,
18637	15565	38	did	do	VBD
18637	15565	39	not	not	RB
18637	15565	40	abridge	abridge	VB
18637	15565	41	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15565	42	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15565	43	.	.	.
18637	15566	1	In	in	IN
18637	15566	2	a	a	DT
18637	15566	3	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	15566	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15566	5	in	in	IN
18637	15566	6	which	which	WDT
18637	15566	7	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15566	8	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	15566	9	,	,	,
18637	15566	10	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	15566	11	and	and	CC
18637	15566	12	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	15566	13	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	15566	14	,	,	,
18637	15566	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15566	16	Black	Black	NNP
18637	15566	17	said	say	VBD
18637	15566	18	,	,	,
18637	15566	19	"	"	``
18637	15566	20	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15566	21	can	can	MD
18637	15566	22	not	not	RB
18637	15566	23	agree	agree	VB
18637	15566	24	that	that	IN
18637	15566	25	a	a	DT
18637	15566	26	State	state	NN
18637	15566	27	can	can	MD
18637	15566	28	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	15566	29	bar	bar	VB
18637	15566	30	from	from	IN
18637	15566	31	a	a	DT
18637	15566	32	semipublic	semipublic	JJ
18637	15566	33	position	position	NN
18637	15566	34	a	a	DT
18637	15566	35	well	well	RB
18637	15566	36	-	-	HYPH
18637	15566	37	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	15566	38	man	man	NN
18637	15566	39	of	of	IN
18637	15566	40	good	good	JJ
18637	15566	41	character	character	NN
18637	15566	42	solely	solely	RB
18637	15566	43	because	because	IN
18637	15566	44	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15566	45	entertains	entertain	VBZ
18637	15566	46	a	a	DT
18637	15566	47	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15566	48	belief	belief	NN
18637	15566	49	which	which	WDT
18637	15566	50	might	may	MD
18637	15566	51	prompt	prompt	VB
18637	15566	52	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15566	53	at	at	IN
18637	15566	54	some	some	DT
18637	15566	55	time	time	NN
18637	15566	56	in	in	IN
18637	15566	57	the	the	DT
18637	15566	58	future	future	NN
18637	15566	59	to	to	TO
18637	15566	60	violate	violate	VB
18637	15566	61	a	a	DT
18637	15566	62	law	law	NN
18637	15566	63	which	which	WDT
18637	15566	64	has	have	VBZ
18637	15566	65	not	not	RB
18637	15566	66	yet	yet	RB
18637	15566	67	been	be	VBN
18637	15566	68	and	and	CC
18637	15566	69	may	may	MD
18637	15566	70	never	never	RB
18637	15566	71	be	be	VB
18637	15566	72	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	15566	73	.	.	.
18637	15567	1	"	"	``
18637	15567	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15567	3	66	66	CD
18637	15567	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15567	5	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	15567	6	of	of	IN
18637	15567	7	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	15567	8	and	and	CC
18637	15567	9	Press	Press	NNP
18637	15567	10	THE	the	DT
18637	15567	11	BLACKSTONIAN	blackstonian	NN
18637	15567	12	BACKGROUND	background	NN
18637	15567	13	"	"	''
18637	15567	14	The	the	DT
18637	15567	15	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15567	16	of	of	IN
18637	15567	17	the	the	DT
18637	15567	18	press	press	NN
18637	15567	19	,	,	,
18637	15567	20	"	"	''
18637	15567	21	says	say	VBZ
18637	15567	22	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
18637	15567	23	,	,	,
18637	15567	24	"	"	``
18637	15567	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	15567	26	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	15567	27	essential	essential	JJ
18637	15567	28	to	to	IN
18637	15567	29	the	the	DT
18637	15567	30	nature	nature	NN
18637	15567	31	of	of	IN
18637	15567	32	a	a	DT
18637	15567	33	free	free	JJ
18637	15567	34	state	state	NN
18637	15567	35	:	:	:
18637	15567	36	but	but	CC
18637	15567	37	this	this	DT
18637	15567	38	consists	consist	VBZ
18637	15567	39	in	in	IN
18637	15567	40	laying	lay	VBG
18637	15567	41	no	no	DT
18637	15567	42	previous	previous	JJ
18637	15567	43	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	15567	44	upon	upon	IN
18637	15567	45	publications	publication	NNS
18637	15567	46	,	,	,
18637	15567	47	and	and	CC
18637	15567	48	not	not	RB
18637	15567	49	in	in	IN
18637	15567	50	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15567	51	from	from	IN
18637	15567	52	censure	censure	NN
18637	15567	53	from	from	IN
18637	15567	54	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15567	55	matter	matter	NN
18637	15567	56	when	when	WRB
18637	15567	57	published	publish	VBN
18637	15567	58	.	.	.
18637	15568	1	Every	every	DT
18637	15568	2	freeman	freeman	NN
18637	15568	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	15568	4	an	an	DT
18637	15568	5	undoubted	undoubted	JJ
18637	15568	6	right	right	NN
18637	15568	7	to	to	TO
18637	15568	8	lay	lay	VB
18637	15568	9	what	what	WDT
18637	15568	10	sentiments	sentiment	NNS
18637	15568	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15568	12	pleases	please	VBZ
18637	15568	13	before	before	IN
18637	15568	14	the	the	DT
18637	15568	15	public	public	NN
18637	15568	16	:	:	:
18637	15568	17	to	to	TO
18637	15568	18	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	15568	19	this	this	DT
18637	15568	20	,	,	,
18637	15568	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	15568	22	to	to	TO
18637	15568	23	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	15568	24	the	the	DT
18637	15568	25	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15568	26	of	of	IN
18637	15568	27	the	the	DT
18637	15568	28	press	press	NN
18637	15568	29	:	:	:
18637	15568	30	but	but	CC
18637	15568	31	if	if	IN
18637	15568	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15568	33	publishes	publish	VBZ
18637	15568	34	what	what	WP
18637	15568	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	15568	36	improper	improper	JJ
18637	15568	37	,	,	,
18637	15568	38	mischievous	mischievous	JJ
18637	15568	39	,	,	,
18637	15568	40	or	or	CC
18637	15568	41	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	15568	42	,	,	,
18637	15568	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15568	44	must	must	MD
18637	15568	45	take	take	VB
18637	15568	46	the	the	DT
18637	15568	47	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	15568	48	of	of	IN
18637	15568	49	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15568	50	own	own	JJ
18637	15568	51	temerity	temerity	NN
18637	15568	52	.	.	.
18637	15569	1	To	to	TO
18637	15569	2	subject	subject	VB
18637	15569	3	the	the	DT
18637	15569	4	press	press	NN
18637	15569	5	to	to	IN
18637	15569	6	the	the	DT
18637	15569	7	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	15569	8	power	power	NN
18637	15569	9	of	of	IN
18637	15569	10	a	a	DT
18637	15569	11	licenser	licenser	NN
18637	15569	12	,	,	,
18637	15569	13	as	as	IN
18637	15569	14	was	be	VBD
18637	15569	15	formerly	formerly	RB
18637	15569	16	done	do	VBN
18637	15569	17	,	,	,
18637	15569	18	both	both	CC
18637	15569	19	before	before	IN
18637	15569	20	and	and	CC
18637	15569	21	since	since	IN
18637	15569	22	the	the	DT
18637	15569	23	revolution	revolution	NN
18637	15569	24	,	,	,
18637	15569	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	15569	26	to	to	TO
18637	15569	27	subject	subject	VB
18637	15569	28	all	all	DT
18637	15569	29	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15569	30	of	of	IN
18637	15569	31	sentiment	sentiment	NN
18637	15569	32	to	to	IN
18637	15569	33	the	the	DT
18637	15569	34	prejudices	prejudice	NNS
18637	15569	35	of	of	IN
18637	15569	36	one	one	CD
18637	15569	37	man	man	NN
18637	15569	38	,	,	,
18637	15569	39	and	and	CC
18637	15569	40	make	make	VB
18637	15569	41	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15569	42	the	the	DT
18637	15569	43	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	15569	44	and	and	CC
18637	15569	45	infallible	infallible	JJ
18637	15569	46	judge	judge	NN
18637	15569	47	of	of	IN
18637	15569	48	all	all	DT
18637	15569	49	controverted	controvert	VBN
18637	15569	50	points	point	NNS
18637	15569	51	in	in	IN
18637	15569	52	learning	learning	NN
18637	15569	53	,	,	,
18637	15569	54	religion	religion	NN
18637	15569	55	and	and	CC
18637	15569	56	government	government	NN
18637	15569	57	.	.	.
18637	15570	1	But	but	CC
18637	15570	2	to	to	TO
18637	15570	3	punish	punish	VB
18637	15570	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15570	5	as	as	IN
18637	15570	6	the	the	DT
18637	15570	7	law	law	NN
18637	15570	8	does	do	VBZ
18637	15570	9	at	at	IN
18637	15570	10	present	present	JJ
18637	15570	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15570	12	any	any	DT
18637	15570	13	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	15570	14	or	or	CC
18637	15570	15	offensive	offensive	JJ
18637	15570	16	writings	writing	NNS
18637	15570	17	,	,	,
18637	15570	18	which	which	WDT
18637	15570	19	,	,	,
18637	15570	20	when	when	WRB
18637	15570	21	published	publish	VBN
18637	15570	22	,	,	,
18637	15570	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	15570	24	on	on	IN
18637	15570	25	a	a	DT
18637	15570	26	fair	fair	JJ
18637	15570	27	and	and	CC
18637	15570	28	impartial	impartial	JJ
18637	15570	29	trial	trial	NN
18637	15570	30	be	be	VB
18637	15570	31	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
18637	15570	32	of	of	IN
18637	15570	33	a	a	DT
18637	15570	34	pernicious	pernicious	JJ
18637	15570	35	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	15570	36	,	,	,
18637	15570	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	15570	38	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	15570	39	for	for	IN
18637	15570	40	the	the	DT
18637	15570	41	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	15570	42	of	of	IN
18637	15570	43	peace	peace	NN
18637	15570	44	and	and	CC
18637	15570	45	good	good	JJ
18637	15570	46	order	order	NN
18637	15570	47	,	,	,
18637	15570	48	of	of	IN
18637	15570	49	government	government	NN
18637	15570	50	and	and	CC
18637	15570	51	religion	religion	NN
18637	15570	52	,	,	,
18637	15570	53	the	the	DT
18637	15570	54	only	only	JJ
18637	15570	55	solid	solid	JJ
18637	15570	56	foundations	foundation	NNS
18637	15570	57	of	of	IN
18637	15570	58	civil	civil	JJ
18637	15570	59	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15570	60	.	.	.
18637	15571	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	15571	2	,	,	,
18637	15571	3	the	the	DT
18637	15571	4	will	will	NN
18637	15571	5	of	of	IN
18637	15571	6	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	15571	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	15571	8	still	still	RB
18637	15571	9	left	leave	VBN
18637	15571	10	free	free	JJ
18637	15571	11	:	:	:
18637	15571	12	the	the	DT
18637	15571	13	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	15571	14	only	only	RB
18637	15571	15	of	of	IN
18637	15571	16	that	that	DT
18637	15571	17	free	free	JJ
18637	15571	18	will	will	NN
18637	15571	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	15571	20	the	the	DT
18637	15571	21	object	object	NN
18637	15571	22	of	of	IN
18637	15571	23	legal	legal	JJ
18637	15571	24	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15571	25	.	.	.
18637	15572	1	Neither	neither	DT
18637	15572	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15572	3	any	any	DT
18637	15572	4	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	15572	5	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	15572	6	laid	lay	VBN
18637	15572	7	upon	upon	IN
18637	15572	8	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15572	9	of	of	IN
18637	15572	10	thought	thought	NN
18637	15572	11	or	or	CC
18637	15572	12	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	15572	13	:	:	:
18637	15572	14	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15572	15	of	of	IN
18637	15572	16	private	private	JJ
18637	15572	17	sentiment	sentiment	NN
18637	15572	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	15572	19	still	still	RB
18637	15572	20	left	leave	VBN
18637	15572	21	;	;	:
18637	15572	22	the	the	DT
18637	15572	23	disseminating	disseminating	NN
18637	15572	24	,	,	,
18637	15572	25	or	or	CC
18637	15572	26	making	make	VBG
18637	15572	27	public	public	NN
18637	15572	28	,	,	,
18637	15572	29	of	of	IN
18637	15572	30	bad	bad	JJ
18637	15572	31	sentiments	sentiment	NNS
18637	15572	32	,	,	,
18637	15572	33	destructive	destructive	JJ
18637	15572	34	to	to	IN
18637	15572	35	the	the	DT
18637	15572	36	ends	end	NNS
18637	15572	37	of	of	IN
18637	15572	38	society	society	NN
18637	15572	39	,	,	,
18637	15572	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	15572	41	the	the	DT
18637	15572	42	crime	crime	NN
18637	15572	43	which	which	WDT
18637	15572	44	society	society	NN
18637	15572	45	corrects	correct	VBZ
18637	15572	46	.	.	.
18637	15573	1	"	"	``
18637	15573	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15573	3	67	67	CD
18637	15573	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15573	5	EFFECT	EFFECT	NNP
18637	15573	6	OF	of	IN
18637	15573	7	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	15573	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15573	9	ON	on	VBP
18637	15573	10	THE	the	DT
18637	15573	11	COMMON	common	JJ
18637	15573	12	LAW	law	NN
18637	15573	13	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
18637	15573	14	was	be	VBD
18637	15573	15	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	15573	16	the	the	DT
18637	15573	17	Common	Common	NNP
18637	15573	18	Law	Law	NNP
18637	15573	19	of	of	IN
18637	15573	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15573	21	day	day	NN
18637	15573	22	,	,	,
18637	15573	23	and	and	CC
18637	15573	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15573	25	was	be	VBD
18637	15573	26	no	no	DT
18637	15573	27	intention	intention	NN
18637	15573	28	of	of	IN
18637	15573	29	the	the	DT
18637	15573	30	framers	framer	NNS
18637	15573	31	of	of	IN
18637	15573	32	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15573	33	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15573	34	to	to	TO
18637	15573	35	change	change	VB
18637	15573	36	that	that	DT
18637	15573	37	law	law	NN
18637	15573	38	.	.	.
18637	15574	1	"	"	``
18637	15574	2	The	the	DT
18637	15574	3	historic	historic	JJ
18637	15574	4	antecedents	antecedent	NNS
18637	15574	5	of	of	IN
18637	15574	6	the	the	DT
18637	15574	7	First	First	NNP
18637	15574	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15574	9	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	15574	10	the	the	DT
18637	15574	11	notion	notion	NN
18637	15574	12	that	that	IN
18637	15574	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15574	14	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15574	15	was	be	VBD
18637	15574	16	to	to	TO
18637	15574	17	give	give	VB
18637	15574	18	unqualified	unqualified	JJ
18637	15574	19	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	15574	20	to	to	IN
18637	15574	21	every	every	DT
18637	15574	22	expression	expression	NN
18637	15574	23	that	that	WDT
18637	15574	24	touched	touch	VBD
18637	15574	25	on	on	IN
18637	15574	26	matters	matter	NNS
18637	15574	27	within	within	IN
18637	15574	28	the	the	DT
18637	15574	29	range	range	NN
18637	15574	30	of	of	IN
18637	15574	31	political	political	JJ
18637	15574	32	interest	interest	NN
18637	15574	33	.	.	.
18637	15575	1	The	the	DT
18637	15575	2	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	15575	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15575	4	of	of	IN
18637	15575	5	1780	1780	CD
18637	15575	6	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	15575	7	free	free	JJ
18637	15575	8	speech	speech	NN
18637	15575	9	;	;	:
18637	15575	10	yet	yet	CC
18637	15575	11	there	there	EX
18637	15575	12	are	be	VBP
18637	15575	13	records	record	NNS
18637	15575	14	of	of	IN
18637	15575	15	at	at	RB
18637	15575	16	least	least	RBS
18637	15575	17	three	three	CD
18637	15575	18	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	15575	19	for	for	IN
18637	15575	20	political	political	JJ
18637	15575	21	libels	libel	NNS
18637	15575	22	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	15575	23	between	between	IN
18637	15575	24	1799	1799	CD
18637	15575	25	and	and	CC
18637	15575	26	1803	1803	CD
18637	15575	27	.	.	.
18637	15576	1	The	the	DT
18637	15576	2	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	15576	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15576	4	of	of	IN
18637	15576	5	1790	1790	CD
18637	15576	6	and	and	CC
18637	15576	7	the	the	DT
18637	15576	8	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	15576	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15576	10	of	of	IN
18637	15576	11	1792	1792	CD
18637	15576	12	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	15576	13	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	15576	14	liability	liability	NN
18637	15576	15	for	for	IN
18637	15576	16	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	15576	17	of	of	IN
18637	15576	18	the	the	DT
18637	15576	19	right	right	NN
18637	15576	20	of	of	IN
18637	15576	21	free	free	JJ
18637	15576	22	speech	speech	NN
18637	15576	23	.	.	.
18637	15577	1	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	15577	2	's	's	POS
18637	15577	3	own	own	JJ
18637	15577	4	State	state	NN
18637	15577	5	put	put	VBD
18637	15577	6	on	on	IN
18637	15577	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15577	8	books	book	NNS
18637	15577	9	in	in	IN
18637	15577	10	1792	1792	CD
18637	15577	11	a	a	DT
18637	15577	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	15577	13	confining	confine	VBG
18637	15577	14	the	the	DT
18637	15577	15	abusive	abusive	JJ
18637	15577	16	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15577	17	of	of	IN
18637	15577	18	the	the	DT
18637	15577	19	right	right	NN
18637	15577	20	of	of	IN
18637	15577	21	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	15577	22	.	.	.
18637	15578	1	And	and	CC
18637	15578	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15578	3	deserves	deserve	VBZ
18637	15578	4	to	to	TO
18637	15578	5	be	be	VB
18637	15578	6	noted	note	VBN
18637	15578	7	that	that	IN
18637	15578	8	in	in	IN
18637	15578	9	writing	writing	NN
18637	15578	10	to	to	IN
18637	15578	11	John	John	NNP
18637	15578	12	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	15578	13	'	'	POS
18637	15578	14	wife	wife	NN
18637	15578	15	,	,	,
18637	15578	16	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	15578	17	did	do	VBD
18637	15578	18	not	not	RB
18637	15578	19	rest	rest	VB
18637	15578	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15578	21	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	15578	22	of	of	IN
18637	15578	23	the	the	DT
18637	15578	24	Sedition	Sedition	NNP
18637	15578	25	Act	Act	NNP
18637	15578	26	of	of	IN
18637	15578	27	1798	1798	CD
18637	15578	28	on	on	IN
18637	15578	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15578	30	belief	belief	NN
18637	15578	31	in	in	IN
18637	15578	32	unrestrained	unrestrained	JJ
18637	15578	33	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	15578	34	as	as	IN
18637	15578	35	to	to	IN
18637	15578	36	political	political	JJ
18637	15578	37	matter	matter	NN
18637	15578	38	.	.	.
18637	15579	1	The	the	DT
18637	15579	2	First	First	NNP
18637	15579	3	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15579	4	,	,	,
18637	15579	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15579	6	argued	argue	VBD
18637	15579	7	,	,	,
18637	15579	8	reflected	reflect	VBD
18637	15579	9	a	a	DT
18637	15579	10	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	15579	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	15579	12	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	15579	13	power	power	NN
18637	15579	14	,	,	,
18637	15579	15	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	15579	16	the	the	DT
18637	15579	17	right	right	NN
18637	15579	18	to	to	TO
18637	15579	19	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	15579	20	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	15579	21	on	on	IN
18637	15579	22	speech	speech	NN
18637	15579	23	to	to	IN
18637	15579	24	the	the	DT
18637	15579	25	States	States	NNP
18637	15579	26	.	.	.
18637	15580	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15580	2	68	68	CD
18637	15580	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15580	4	*	*	NFP
18637	15580	5	*	*	NFP
18637	15580	6	*	*	NFP
18637	15580	7	'	'	''
18637	15580	8	The	the	DT
18637	15580	9	law	law	NN
18637	15580	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	15580	11	perfectly	perfectly	RB
18637	15580	12	well	well	RB
18637	15580	13	settled	settled	JJ
18637	15580	14	,	,	,
18637	15580	15	'	'	''
18637	15580	16	this	this	DT
18637	15580	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15580	18	said	say	VBD
18637	15580	19	over	over	IN
18637	15580	20	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	15580	21	years	year	NNS
18637	15580	22	ago	ago	RB
18637	15580	23	,	,	,
18637	15580	24	'	'	''
18637	15580	25	that	that	IN
18637	15580	26	the	the	DT
18637	15580	27	first	first	JJ
18637	15580	28	ten	ten	CD
18637	15580	29	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	15580	30	to	to	IN
18637	15580	31	the	the	DT
18637	15580	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15580	33	,	,	,
18637	15580	34	commonly	commonly	RB
18637	15580	35	known	know	VBN
18637	15580	36	as	as	IN
18637	15580	37	the	the	DT
18637	15580	38	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	15580	39	of	of	IN
18637	15580	40	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	15580	41	,	,	,
18637	15580	42	were	be	VBD
18637	15580	43	not	not	RB
18637	15580	44	intended	intend	VBN
18637	15580	45	to	to	TO
18637	15580	46	lay	lay	VB
18637	15580	47	down	down	RP
18637	15580	48	any	any	DT
18637	15580	49	novel	novel	JJ
18637	15580	50	principles	principle	NNS
18637	15580	51	of	of	IN
18637	15580	52	government	government	NN
18637	15580	53	,	,	,
18637	15580	54	but	but	CC
18637	15580	55	simply	simply	RB
18637	15580	56	to	to	TO
18637	15580	57	embody	embody	VB
18637	15580	58	certain	certain	JJ
18637	15580	59	guaranties	guaranty	NNS
18637	15580	60	and	and	CC
18637	15580	61	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	15580	62	which	which	WDT
18637	15580	63	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15580	64	had	have	VBD
18637	15580	65	inherited	inherit	VBN
18637	15580	66	from	from	IN
18637	15580	67	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15580	68	English	english	JJ
18637	15580	69	ancestors	ancestor	NNS
18637	15580	70	,	,	,
18637	15580	71	and	and	CC
18637	15580	72	which	which	WDT
18637	15580	73	had	have	VBD
18637	15580	74	from	from	IN
18637	15580	75	time	time	NN
18637	15580	76	immemorial	immemorial	JJ
18637	15580	77	been	be	VBN
18637	15580	78	subject	subject	JJ
18637	15580	79	to	to	IN
18637	15580	80	certain	certain	JJ
18637	15580	81	well	well	RB
18637	15580	82	-	-	HYPH
18637	15580	83	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	15580	84	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	15580	85	arising	arise	VBG
18637	15580	86	from	from	IN
18637	15580	87	the	the	DT
18637	15580	88	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	15580	89	of	of	IN
18637	15580	90	the	the	DT
18637	15580	91	case	case	NN
18637	15580	92	.	.	.
18637	15581	1	In	in	IN
18637	15581	2	incorporating	incorporate	VBG
18637	15581	3	these	these	DT
18637	15581	4	principles	principle	NNS
18637	15581	5	into	into	IN
18637	15581	6	the	the	DT
18637	15581	7	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	15581	8	law	law	NN
18637	15581	9	there	there	EX
18637	15581	10	was	be	VBD
18637	15581	11	no	no	DT
18637	15581	12	intention	intention	NN
18637	15581	13	of	of	IN
18637	15581	14	disregarding	disregard	VBG
18637	15581	15	the	the	DT
18637	15581	16	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	15581	17	,	,	,
18637	15581	18	which	which	WDT
18637	15581	19	continued	continue	VBD
18637	15581	20	to	to	TO
18637	15581	21	be	be	VB
18637	15581	22	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	15581	23	as	as	IN
18637	15581	24	if	if	IN
18637	15581	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15581	26	had	have	VBD
18637	15581	27	been	be	VBN
18637	15581	28	formally	formally	RB
18637	15581	29	expressed	express	VBN
18637	15581	30	.	.	.
18637	15582	1	'	'	``
18637	15582	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15582	3	69	69	CD
18637	15582	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15582	5	That	that	IN
18637	15582	6	this	this	DT
18637	15582	7	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	15582	8	the	the	DT
18637	15582	9	authentic	authentic	JJ
18637	15582	10	view	view	NN
18637	15582	11	of	of	IN
18637	15582	12	the	the	DT
18637	15582	13	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	15582	14	of	of	IN
18637	15582	15	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	15582	16	and	and	CC
18637	15582	17	the	the	DT
18637	15582	18	spirit	spirit	NN
18637	15582	19	in	in	IN
18637	15582	20	which	which	WDT
18637	15582	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15582	22	must	must	MD
18637	15582	23	be	be	VB
18637	15582	24	construed	construe	VBN
18637	15582	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	15582	26	been	be	VBN
18637	15582	27	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	15582	28	again	again	RB
18637	15582	29	and	and	CC
18637	15582	30	again	again	RB
18637	15582	31	in	in	IN
18637	15582	32	cases	case	NNS
18637	15582	33	that	that	WDT
18637	15582	34	have	have	VBP
18637	15582	35	come	come	VBN
18637	15582	36	here	here	RB
18637	15582	37	within	within	IN
18637	15582	38	the	the	DT
18637	15582	39	last	last	JJ
18637	15582	40	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	15582	41	years	year	NNS
18637	15582	42	.	.	.
18637	15583	1	"	"	``
18637	15583	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15583	3	70	70	CD
18637	15583	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15583	5	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	15583	6	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	15583	7	AND	and	CC
18637	15583	8	BLACKSTONE	BLACKSTONE	NNP
18637	15583	9	Nor	nor	CC
18637	15583	10	was	be	VBD
18637	15583	11	the	the	DT
18637	15583	12	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	15583	13	of	of	IN
18637	15583	14	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15583	15	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	15583	16	thought	think	VBD
18637	15583	17	to	to	TO
18637	15583	18	alter	alter	VB
18637	15583	19	the	the	DT
18637	15583	20	above	above	RB
18637	15583	21	described	describe	VBN
18637	15583	22	situation	situation	NN
18637	15583	23	until	until	IN
18637	15583	24	a	a	DT
18637	15583	25	comparatively	comparatively	RB
18637	15583	26	recent	recent	JJ
18637	15583	27	date	date	NN
18637	15583	28	.	.	.
18637	15584	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	15584	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15584	3	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	15584	4	,	,	,
18637	15584	5	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15584	6	for	for	IN
18637	15584	7	the	the	DT
18637	15584	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15584	9	in	in	IN
18637	15584	10	1907	1907	CD
18637	15584	11	:	:	:
18637	15584	12	"	"	``
18637	15584	13	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15584	14	leave	leave	VBP
18637	15584	15	undecided	undecide	VBN
18637	15584	16	the	the	DT
18637	15584	17	question	question	NN
18637	15584	18	whether	whether	IN
18637	15584	19	there	there	EX
18637	15584	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	15584	21	to	to	TO
18637	15584	22	be	be	VB
18637	15584	23	found	find	VBN
18637	15584	24	in	in	IN
18637	15584	25	the	the	DT
18637	15584	26	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15584	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15584	28	a	a	DT
18637	15584	29	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	15584	30	similar	similar	JJ
18637	15584	31	to	to	IN
18637	15584	32	that	that	DT
18637	15584	33	in	in	IN
18637	15584	34	the	the	DT
18637	15584	35	First	first	JJ
18637	15584	36	.	.	.
18637	15585	1	But	but	CC
18637	15585	2	even	even	RB
18637	15585	3	if	if	IN
18637	15585	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15585	5	were	be	VBD
18637	15585	6	to	to	TO
18637	15585	7	assume	assume	VB
18637	15585	8	that	that	IN
18637	15585	9	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15585	10	of	of	IN
18637	15585	11	speech	speech	NN
18637	15585	12	and	and	CC
18637	15585	13	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15585	14	of	of	IN
18637	15585	15	the	the	DT
18637	15585	16	press	press	NN
18637	15585	17	were	be	VBD
18637	15585	18	protected	protect	VBN
18637	15585	19	from	from	IN
18637	15585	20	abridgment	abridgment	NN
18637	15585	21	on	on	IN
18637	15585	22	the	the	DT
18637	15585	23	part	part	NN
18637	15585	24	not	not	RB
18637	15585	25	only	only	RB
18637	15585	26	of	of	IN
18637	15585	27	the	the	DT
18637	15585	28	United	United	NNP
18637	15585	29	States	States	NNP
18637	15585	30	but	but	CC
18637	15585	31	also	also	RB
18637	15585	32	of	of	IN
18637	15585	33	the	the	DT
18637	15585	34	States	States	NNPS
18637	15585	35	,	,	,
18637	15585	36	still	still	RB
18637	15585	37	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15585	38	should	should	MD
18637	15585	39	be	be	VB
18637	15585	40	far	far	RB
18637	15585	41	from	from	IN
18637	15585	42	the	the	DT
18637	15585	43	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	15585	44	that	that	IN
18637	15585	45	the	the	DT
18637	15585	46	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	15585	47	in	in	IN
18637	15585	48	error	error	NN
18637	15585	49	would	would	MD
18637	15585	50	have	have	VB
18637	15585	51	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15585	52	reach	reach	VB
18637	15585	53	.	.	.
18637	15586	1	In	in	IN
18637	15586	2	the	the	DT
18637	15586	3	first	first	JJ
18637	15586	4	place	place	NN
18637	15586	5	,	,	,
18637	15586	6	the	the	DT
18637	15586	7	main	main	JJ
18637	15586	8	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15586	9	of	of	IN
18637	15586	10	such	such	JJ
18637	15586	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15586	12	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	15586	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	15586	14	'	'	''
18637	15586	15	to	to	TO
18637	15586	16	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	15586	17	all	all	DT
18637	15586	18	such	such	JJ
18637	15586	19	_	_	NNP
18637	15586	20	previous	previous	JJ
18637	15586	21	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	15586	22	_	_	NNP
18637	15586	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	15586	24	publications	publication	NNS
18637	15586	25	as	as	IN
18637	15586	26	had	have	VBD
18637	15586	27	been	be	VBN
18637	15586	28	practiced	practice	VBN
18637	15586	29	by	by	IN
18637	15586	30	other	other	JJ
18637	15586	31	governments	government	NNS
18637	15586	32	,	,	,
18637	15586	33	'	'	''
18637	15586	34	and	and	CC
18637	15586	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15586	36	do	do	VBP
18637	15586	37	not	not	RB
18637	15586	38	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	15586	39	the	the	DT
18637	15586	40	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	15586	41	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15586	42	of	of	IN
18637	15586	43	such	such	JJ
18637	15586	44	as	as	IN
18637	15586	45	may	may	MD
18637	15586	46	be	be	VB
18637	15586	47	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	15586	48	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	15586	49	to	to	IN
18637	15586	50	the	the	DT
18637	15586	51	public	public	JJ
18637	15586	52	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	15586	53	.	.	.
18637	15587	1	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
18637	15587	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15587	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15587	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15587	5	Blanding	Blanding	NNP
18637	15587	6	,	,	,
18637	15587	7	3	3	CD
18637	15587	8	Pick	Pick	NNP
18637	15587	9	.	.	.
18637	15588	1	304	304	CD
18637	15588	2	,	,	,
18637	15588	3	313	313	CD
18637	15588	4	,	,	,
18637	15588	5	314	314	CD
18637	15588	6	;	;	:
18637	15588	7	Respublica	Respublica	NNP
18637	15588	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15588	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	15588	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15588	11	Oswald	Oswald	NNP
18637	15588	12	,	,	,
18637	15588	13	1	1	CD
18637	15588	14	Dallas	Dallas	NNP
18637	15588	15	319	319	CD
18637	15588	16	,	,	,
18637	15588	17	325	325	CD
18637	15588	18	.	.	.
18637	15589	1	The	the	DT
18637	15589	2	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	15589	3	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15589	4	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	15589	5	as	as	RB
18637	15589	6	well	well	RB
18637	15589	7	to	to	IN
18637	15589	8	the	the	DT
18637	15589	9	false	false	JJ
18637	15589	10	as	as	IN
18637	15589	11	to	to	IN
18637	15589	12	the	the	DT
18637	15589	13	true	true	JJ
18637	15589	14	;	;	:
18637	15589	15	the	the	DT
18637	15589	16	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	15589	17	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15589	18	may	may	MD
18637	15589	19	extend	extend	VB
18637	15589	20	as	as	RB
18637	15589	21	well	well	RB
18637	15589	22	to	to	IN
18637	15589	23	the	the	DT
18637	15589	24	true	true	JJ
18637	15589	25	as	as	IN
18637	15589	26	to	to	IN
18637	15589	27	the	the	DT
18637	15589	28	false	false	JJ
18637	15589	29	.	.	.
18637	15590	1	This	this	DT
18637	15590	2	was	be	VBD
18637	15590	3	the	the	DT
18637	15590	4	law	law	NN
18637	15590	5	of	of	IN
18637	15590	6	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15590	7	libel	libel	NN
18637	15590	8	apart	apart	RB
18637	15590	9	from	from	IN
18637	15590	10	statute	statute	NN
18637	15590	11	in	in	IN
18637	15590	12	most	most	JJS
18637	15590	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	15590	14	,	,	,
18637	15590	15	if	if	IN
18637	15590	16	not	not	RB
18637	15590	17	in	in	IN
18637	15590	18	all	all	DT
18637	15590	19	.	.	.
18637	15591	1	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
18637	15591	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15591	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15591	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15591	5	Blanding	Blanding	NNP
18637	15591	6	,	,	,
18637	15591	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15591	8	ubi	ubi	NNP
18637	15591	9	sup	sup	NNP
18637	15591	10	.	.	.
18637	15591	11	_	_	NNP
18637	15591	12	;	;	:
18637	15591	13	4	4	CD
18637	15591	14	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	15591	15	.	.	.
18637	15592	1	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	15592	2	.	.	.
18637	15593	1	150	150	CD
18637	15593	2	.	.	.
18637	15594	1	"	"	``
18637	15594	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15594	3	71	71	CD
18637	15594	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15594	5	This	this	DT
18637	15594	6	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	15594	7	to	to	TO
18637	15594	8	be	be	VB
18637	15594	9	an	an	DT
18637	15594	10	unqualified	unqualified	JJ
18637	15594	11	endorsement	endorsement	NN
18637	15594	12	of	of	IN
18637	15594	13	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
18637	15594	14	.	.	.
18637	15595	1	But	but	CC
18637	15595	2	,	,	,
18637	15595	3	as	as	IN
18637	15595	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15595	5	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	15595	6	remarks	remark	VBZ
18637	15595	7	in	in	IN
18637	15595	8	the	the	DT
18637	15595	9	same	same	JJ
18637	15595	10	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15595	11	,	,	,
18637	15595	12	"	"	``
18637	15595	13	There	there	EX
18637	15595	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	15595	15	no	no	DT
18637	15595	16	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15595	17	right	right	NN
18637	15595	18	to	to	TO
18637	15595	19	have	have	VB
18637	15595	20	all	all	DT
18637	15595	21	general	general	JJ
18637	15595	22	propositions	proposition	NNS
18637	15595	23	of	of	IN
18637	15595	24	law	law	NN
18637	15595	25	once	once	RB
18637	15595	26	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	15595	27	remain	remain	VBP
18637	15595	28	unchanged	unchanged	JJ
18637	15595	29	.	.	.
18637	15596	1	"	"	``
18637	15596	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15596	3	72	72	CD
18637	15596	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15596	5	As	as	RB
18637	15596	6	late	late	RB
18637	15596	7	as	as	IN
18637	15596	8	1922	1922	CD
18637	15596	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15596	10	Pitney	Pitney	NNP
18637	15596	11	,	,	,
18637	15596	12	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15596	13	for	for	IN
18637	15596	14	the	the	DT
18637	15596	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15596	16	,	,	,
18637	15596	17	said	say	VBD
18637	15596	18	:	:	:
18637	15596	19	"	"	``
18637	15596	20	Neither	neither	CC
18637	15596	21	the	the	DT
18637	15596	22	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15596	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15596	24	nor	nor	CC
18637	15596	25	any	any	DT
18637	15596	26	other	other	JJ
18637	15596	27	provision	provision	NN
18637	15596	28	of	of	IN
18637	15596	29	the	the	DT
18637	15596	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15596	31	of	of	IN
18637	15596	32	the	the	DT
18637	15596	33	United	United	NNP
18637	15596	34	States	States	NNP
18637	15596	35	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	15596	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	15596	37	the	the	DT
18637	15596	38	States	States	NNP
18637	15596	39	any	any	DT
18637	15596	40	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	15596	41	about	about	IN
18637	15596	42	'	'	``
18637	15596	43	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15596	44	of	of	IN
18637	15596	45	speech	speech	NN
18637	15596	46	'	'	''
18637	15596	47	or	or	CC
18637	15596	48	the	the	DT
18637	15596	49	'	'	``
18637	15596	50	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15596	51	of	of	IN
18637	15596	52	silence	silence	NN
18637	15596	53	'	'	''
18637	15596	54	*	*	NFP
18637	15596	55	*	*	NFP
18637	15596	56	*	*	NFP
18637	15596	57	"	"	''
18637	15596	58	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15596	59	73	73	CD
18637	15596	60	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15596	61	THE	the	DT
18637	15596	62	CLEAR	CLEAR	NNP
18637	15596	63	AND	and	CC
18637	15596	64	PRESENT	PRESENT	NNP
18637	15596	65	DANGER	DANGER	NNP
18637	15596	66	RULE	rule	NN
18637	15596	67	,	,	,
18637	15596	68	MEANING	MEANING	NNP
18637	15596	69	The	the	DT
18637	15596	70	rule	rule	NN
18637	15596	71	requires	require	VBZ
18637	15596	72	that	that	IN
18637	15596	73	before	before	IN
18637	15596	74	an	an	DT
18637	15596	75	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	15596	76	can	can	MD
18637	15596	77	be	be	VB
18637	15596	78	penalized	penalize	VBN
18637	15596	79	by	by	IN
18637	15596	80	government	government	NN
18637	15596	81	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15596	82	must	must	MD
18637	15596	83	,	,	,
18637	15596	84	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	15596	85	,	,	,
18637	15596	86	have	have	VBP
18637	15596	87	occurred	occur	VBN
18637	15596	88	"	"	''
18637	15596	89	in	in	IN
18637	15596	90	such	such	JJ
18637	15596	91	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	15596	92	or	or	CC
18637	15596	93	have	have	VBP
18637	15596	94	been	be	VBN
18637	15596	95	of	of	IN
18637	15596	96	such	such	PDT
18637	15596	97	a	a	DT
18637	15596	98	nature	nature	NN
18637	15596	99	as	as	IN
18637	15596	100	to	to	TO
18637	15596	101	create	create	VB
18637	15596	102	a	a	DT
18637	15596	103	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15596	104	and	and	CC
18637	15596	105	present	present	JJ
18637	15596	106	danger	danger	NN
18637	15596	107	"	"	''
18637	15596	108	that	that	IN
18637	15596	109	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15596	110	would	would	MD
18637	15596	111	bring	bring	VB
18637	15596	112	about	about	RP
18637	15596	113	"	"	``
18637	15596	114	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15596	115	evils	evil	NNS
18637	15596	116	"	"	''
18637	15596	117	within	within	IN
18637	15596	118	the	the	DT
18637	15596	119	power	power	NN
18637	15596	120	of	of	IN
18637	15596	121	government	government	NN
18637	15596	122	to	to	TO
18637	15596	123	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	15596	124	.	.	.
18637	15597	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15597	2	74	74	CD
18637	15597	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15597	4	The	the	DT
18637	15597	5	question	question	NN
18637	15597	6	whether	whether	IN
18637	15597	7	these	these	DT
18637	15597	8	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	15597	9	exist	exist	VBP
18637	15597	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	15597	11	one	one	CD
18637	15597	12	of	of	IN
18637	15597	13	law	law	NN
18637	15597	14	for	for	IN
18637	15597	15	the	the	DT
18637	15597	16	courts	court	NNS
18637	15597	17	,	,	,
18637	15597	18	and	and	CC
18637	15597	19	ultimately	ultimately	RB
18637	15597	20	for	for	IN
18637	15597	21	the	the	DT
18637	15597	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15597	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15597	24	,	,	,
18637	15597	25	in	in	IN
18637	15597	26	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	15597	27	of	of	IN
18637	15597	28	the	the	DT
18637	15597	29	First	first	JJ
18637	15597	30	and/or	and/or	CC
18637	15597	31	the	the	DT
18637	15597	32	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15597	33	Amendment;[75	Amendment;[75	NNP
18637	15597	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15597	35	and	and	CC
18637	15597	36	in	in	IN
18637	15597	37	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15597	38	of	of	IN
18637	15597	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15597	40	power	power	NN
18637	15597	41	of	of	IN
18637	15597	42	review	review	NN
18637	15597	43	in	in	IN
18637	15597	44	these	these	DT
18637	15597	45	premises	premise	NNS
18637	15597	46	the	the	DT
18637	15597	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15597	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	15597	49	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	15597	50	to	to	TO
18637	15597	51	review	review	VB
18637	15597	52	broadly	broadly	RB
18637	15597	53	findings	finding	NNS
18637	15597	54	of	of	IN
18637	15597	55	facts	fact	NNS
18637	15597	56	of	of	IN
18637	15597	57	lower	low	JJR
18637	15597	58	courts	court	NNS
18637	15597	59	,	,	,
18637	15597	60	whether	whether	IN
18637	15597	61	State	State	NNP
18637	15597	62	or	or	CC
18637	15597	63	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15597	64	.	.	.
18637	15598	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15598	2	76	76	CD
18637	15598	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15598	4	CONTRASTING	contrast	VBG
18637	15598	5	OPERATION	operation	NN
18637	15598	6	OF	of	IN
18637	15598	7	THE	the	DT
18637	15598	8	COMMON	common	JJ
18637	15598	9	LAW	law	NN
18637	15598	10	RULE	rule	NN
18637	15598	11	In	in	IN
18637	15598	12	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	15598	13	_	_	NNP
18637	15598	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	15598	15	_	_	NNP
18637	15598	16	Beason,[77	Beason,[77	NNP
18637	15598	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15598	18	decided	decide	VBD
18637	15598	19	in	in	IN
18637	15598	20	1890	1890	CD
18637	15598	21	,	,	,
18637	15598	22	the	the	DT
18637	15598	23	question	question	NN
18637	15598	24	at	at	IN
18637	15598	25	issue	issue	NN
18637	15598	26	was	be	VBD
18637	15598	27	the	the	DT
18637	15598	28	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	15598	29	of	of	IN
18637	15598	30	a	a	DT
18637	15598	31	statute	statute	NN
18637	15598	32	of	of	IN
18637	15598	33	the	the	DT
18637	15598	34	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	15598	35	of	of	IN
18637	15598	36	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
18637	15598	37	,	,	,
18637	15598	38	providing	provide	VBG
18637	15598	39	that	that	IN
18637	15598	40	"	"	``
18637	15598	41	no	no	DT
18637	15598	42	person	person	NN
18637	15598	43	who	who	WP
18637	15598	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	15598	45	a	a	DT
18637	15598	46	bigamist	bigamist	JJ
18637	15598	47	or	or	CC
18637	15598	48	polygamist	polygamist	JJ
18637	15598	49	,	,	,
18637	15598	50	or	or	CC
18637	15598	51	who	who	WP
18637	15598	52	teaches	teach	VBZ
18637	15598	53	,	,	,
18637	15598	54	advices	advice	NNS
18637	15598	55	,	,	,
18637	15598	56	counsels	counsel	NNS
18637	15598	57	or	or	CC
18637	15598	58	encourages	encourage	VBZ
18637	15598	59	any	any	DT
18637	15598	60	person	person	NN
18637	15598	61	or	or	CC
18637	15598	62	persons	person	NNS
18637	15598	63	to	to	TO
18637	15598	64	become	become	VB
18637	15598	65	bigamists	bigamist	NNS
18637	15598	66	or	or	CC
18637	15598	67	polygamists	polygamist	NNS
18637	15598	68	or	or	CC
18637	15598	69	to	to	TO
18637	15598	70	commit	commit	VB
18637	15598	71	any	any	DT
18637	15598	72	other	other	JJ
18637	15598	73	crime	crime	NN
18637	15598	74	defined	define	VBN
18637	15598	75	by	by	IN
18637	15598	76	law	law	NN
18637	15598	77	,	,	,
18637	15598	78	or	or	CC
18637	15598	79	to	to	TO
18637	15598	80	enter	enter	VB
18637	15598	81	into	into	IN
18637	15598	82	what	what	WP
18637	15598	83	is	be	VBZ
18637	15598	84	known	know	VBN
18637	15598	85	as	as	IN
18637	15598	86	plural	plural	JJ
18637	15598	87	or	or	CC
18637	15598	88	celestial	celestial	JJ
18637	15598	89	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	15598	90	,	,	,
18637	15598	91	or	or	CC
18637	15598	92	who	who	WP
18637	15598	93	is	be	VBZ
18637	15598	94	a	a	DT
18637	15598	95	member	member	NN
18637	15598	96	of	of	IN
18637	15598	97	any	any	DT
18637	15598	98	order	order	NN
18637	15598	99	,	,	,
18637	15598	100	organization	organization	NN
18637	15598	101	or	or	CC
18637	15598	102	association	association	NN
18637	15598	103	which	which	WDT
18637	15598	104	teaches	teach	VBZ
18637	15598	105	,	,	,
18637	15598	106	advises	advise	NNS
18637	15598	107	,	,	,
18637	15598	108	counsels	counsel	NNS
18637	15598	109	or	or	CC
18637	15598	110	encourages	encourage	VBZ
18637	15598	111	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15598	112	members	member	NNS
18637	15598	113	or	or	CC
18637	15598	114	devotees	devotee	NNS
18637	15598	115	or	or	CC
18637	15598	116	any	any	DT
18637	15598	117	other	other	JJ
18637	15598	118	persons	person	NNS
18637	15598	119	to	to	TO
18637	15598	120	commit	commit	VB
18637	15598	121	the	the	DT
18637	15598	122	crime	crime	NN
18637	15598	123	of	of	IN
18637	15598	124	bigamy	bigamy	NN
18637	15598	125	or	or	CC
18637	15598	126	polygamy	polygamy	NN
18637	15598	127	,	,	,
18637	15598	128	or	or	CC
18637	15598	129	any	any	DT
18637	15598	130	other	other	JJ
18637	15598	131	crime	crime	NN
18637	15598	132	defined	define	VBN
18637	15598	133	by	by	IN
18637	15598	134	law	law	NN
18637	15598	135	,	,	,
18637	15598	136	either	either	CC
18637	15598	137	as	as	IN
18637	15598	138	a	a	DT
18637	15598	139	rite	rite	NN
18637	15598	140	or	or	CC
18637	15598	141	ceremony	ceremony	NN
18637	15598	142	of	of	IN
18637	15598	143	such	such	JJ
18637	15598	144	order	order	NN
18637	15598	145	,	,	,
18637	15598	146	organization	organization	NN
18637	15598	147	or	or	CC
18637	15598	148	association	association	NN
18637	15598	149	,	,	,
18637	15598	150	or	or	CC
18637	15598	151	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	15598	152	,	,	,
18637	15598	153	is	be	VBZ
18637	15598	154	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	15598	155	to	to	TO
18637	15598	156	vote	vote	VB
18637	15598	157	at	at	IN
18637	15598	158	any	any	DT
18637	15598	159	election	election	NN
18637	15598	160	,	,	,
18637	15598	161	or	or	CC
18637	15598	162	to	to	TO
18637	15598	163	hold	hold	VB
18637	15598	164	any	any	DT
18637	15598	165	position	position	NN
18637	15598	166	or	or	CC
18637	15598	167	office	office	NN
18637	15598	168	of	of	IN
18637	15598	169	honor	honor	NN
18637	15598	170	,	,	,
18637	15598	171	trust	trust	NN
18637	15598	172	or	or	CC
18637	15598	173	profit	profit	NN
18637	15598	174	within	within	IN
18637	15598	175	this	this	DT
18637	15598	176	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	15598	177	.	.	.
18637	15598	178	"	"	''
18637	15599	1	A	a	DT
18637	15599	2	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	15599	3	court	court	NN
18637	15599	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	15599	5	this	this	DT
18637	15599	6	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	15599	7	to	to	TO
18637	15599	8	be	be	VB
18637	15599	9	within	within	IN
18637	15599	10	the	the	DT
18637	15599	11	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	15599	12	powers	power	NNS
18637	15599	13	which	which	WDT
18637	15599	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15599	15	had	have	VBD
18637	15599	16	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	15599	17	on	on	IN
18637	15599	18	the	the	DT
18637	15599	19	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	15599	20	and	and	CC
18637	15599	21	not	not	RB
18637	15599	22	to	to	TO
18637	15599	23	be	be	VB
18637	15599	24	open	open	JJ
18637	15599	25	to	to	IN
18637	15599	26	any	any	DT
18637	15599	27	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15599	28	objection	objection	NN
18637	15599	29	.	.	.
18637	15600	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	15600	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15600	3	Field	Field	NNP
18637	15600	4	for	for	IN
18637	15600	5	the	the	DT
18637	15600	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15600	7	:	:	:
18637	15600	8	"	"	``
18637	15600	9	Bigamy	Bigamy	NNP
18637	15600	10	and	and	CC
18637	15600	11	polygamy	polygamy	NN
18637	15600	12	are	be	VBP
18637	15600	13	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	15600	14	by	by	IN
18637	15600	15	the	the	DT
18637	15600	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	15600	17	of	of	IN
18637	15600	18	all	all	DT
18637	15600	19	civilized	civilized	JJ
18637	15600	20	and	and	CC
18637	15600	21	Christian	christian	JJ
18637	15600	22	countries	country	NNS
18637	15600	23	.	.	.
18637	15601	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15601	2	are	be	VBP
18637	15601	3	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	15601	4	by	by	IN
18637	15601	5	the	the	DT
18637	15601	6	laws	law	NNS
18637	15601	7	of	of	IN
18637	15601	8	the	the	DT
18637	15601	9	United	United	NNP
18637	15601	10	States	States	NNP
18637	15601	11	,	,	,
18637	15601	12	and	and	CC
18637	15601	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15601	14	are	be	VBP
18637	15601	15	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	15601	16	by	by	IN
18637	15601	17	the	the	DT
18637	15601	18	laws	law	NNS
18637	15601	19	of	of	IN
18637	15601	20	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
18637	15601	21	.	.	.
18637	15602	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15602	2	tend	tend	VBP
18637	15602	3	to	to	TO
18637	15602	4	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	15602	5	the	the	DT
18637	15602	6	purity	purity	NN
18637	15602	7	of	of	IN
18637	15602	8	the	the	DT
18637	15602	9	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	15602	10	relation	relation	NN
18637	15602	11	,	,	,
18637	15602	12	to	to	TO
18637	15602	13	disturb	disturb	VB
18637	15602	14	the	the	DT
18637	15602	15	peace	peace	NN
18637	15602	16	of	of	IN
18637	15602	17	families	family	NNS
18637	15602	18	,	,	,
18637	15602	19	to	to	TO
18637	15602	20	degrade	degrade	VB
18637	15602	21	woman	woman	NN
18637	15602	22	and	and	CC
18637	15602	23	to	to	TO
18637	15602	24	debase	debase	VB
18637	15602	25	man	man	NN
18637	15602	26	.	.	.
18637	15603	1	Few	few	JJ
18637	15603	2	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	15603	3	are	be	VBP
18637	15603	4	more	more	RBR
18637	15603	5	pernicious	pernicious	JJ
18637	15603	6	to	to	IN
18637	15603	7	the	the	DT
18637	15603	8	best	good	JJS
18637	15603	9	interests	interest	NNS
18637	15603	10	of	of	IN
18637	15603	11	society	society	NN
18637	15603	12	and	and	CC
18637	15603	13	receive	receive	VB
18637	15603	14	more	more	RBR
18637	15603	15	general	general	JJ
18637	15603	16	or	or	CC
18637	15603	17	more	more	JJR
18637	15603	18	deserved	deserved	JJ
18637	15603	19	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15603	20	.	.	.
18637	15604	1	To	to	TO
18637	15604	2	extend	extend	VB
18637	15604	3	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	15604	4	from	from	IN
18637	15604	5	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15604	6	for	for	IN
18637	15604	7	such	such	JJ
18637	15604	8	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	15604	9	would	would	MD
18637	15604	10	be	be	VB
18637	15604	11	to	to	TO
18637	15604	12	shock	shock	VB
18637	15604	13	the	the	DT
18637	15604	14	moral	moral	JJ
18637	15604	15	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	15604	16	of	of	IN
18637	15604	17	the	the	DT
18637	15604	18	community	community	NN
18637	15604	19	.	.	.
18637	15605	1	To	to	TO
18637	15605	2	call	call	VB
18637	15605	3	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15605	4	advocacy	advocacy	NN
18637	15605	5	a	a	DT
18637	15605	6	tenet	tenet	NN
18637	15605	7	of	of	IN
18637	15605	8	religion	religion	NN
18637	15605	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	15605	10	to	to	TO
18637	15605	11	offend	offend	VB
18637	15605	12	the	the	DT
18637	15605	13	common	common	JJ
18637	15605	14	sense	sense	NN
18637	15605	15	of	of	IN
18637	15605	16	mankind	mankind	NN
18637	15605	17	.	.	.
18637	15606	1	If	if	IN
18637	15606	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15606	3	are	be	VBP
18637	15606	4	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	15606	5	,	,	,
18637	15606	6	then	then	RB
18637	15606	7	to	to	TO
18637	15606	8	teach	teach	VB
18637	15606	9	,	,	,
18637	15606	10	advise	advise	VB
18637	15606	11	,	,	,
18637	15606	12	and	and	CC
18637	15606	13	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	15606	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15606	15	practice	practice	NN
18637	15606	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	15606	17	to	to	TO
18637	15606	18	aid	aid	VB
18637	15606	19	in	in	IN
18637	15606	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15606	21	commission	commission	NN
18637	15606	22	,	,	,
18637	15606	23	and	and	CC
18637	15606	24	such	such	JJ
18637	15606	25	teaching	teaching	NN
18637	15606	26	and	and	CC
18637	15606	27	counselling	counselling	NN
18637	15606	28	are	be	VBP
18637	15606	29	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15606	30	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15606	31	and	and	CC
18637	15606	32	proper	proper	JJ
18637	15606	33	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	15606	34	of	of	IN
18637	15606	35	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15606	36	,	,	,
18637	15606	37	as	as	IN
18637	15606	38	aiding	aid	VBG
18637	15606	39	and	and	CC
18637	15606	40	abetting	abet	VBG
18637	15606	41	crime	crime	NN
18637	15606	42	are	be	VBP
18637	15606	43	in	in	IN
18637	15606	44	all	all	DT
18637	15606	45	other	other	JJ
18637	15606	46	cases	case	NNS
18637	15606	47	.	.	.
18637	15607	1	"	"	``
18637	15607	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15607	3	78	78	CD
18637	15607	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15607	5	No	no	DT
18637	15607	6	talk	talk	NN
18637	15607	7	here	here	RB
18637	15607	8	about	about	IN
18637	15607	9	the	the	DT
18637	15607	10	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	15607	11	for	for	IN
18637	15607	12	showing	show	VBG
18637	15607	13	that	that	IN
18637	15607	14	the	the	DT
18637	15607	15	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	15607	16	teaching	teaching	NN
18637	15607	17	,	,	,
18637	15607	18	counselling	counselling	NN
18637	15607	19	,	,	,
18637	15607	20	advising	advising	NN
18637	15607	21	,	,	,
18637	15607	22	etc	etc	FW
18637	15607	23	.	.	.
18637	15607	24	,	,	,
18637	15607	25	must	must	MD
18637	15607	26	be	be	VB
18637	15607	27	shown	show	VBN
18637	15607	28	to	to	TO
18637	15607	29	have	have	VB
18637	15607	30	occurred	occur	VBN
18637	15607	31	in	in	IN
18637	15607	32	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	15607	33	creating	create	VBG
18637	15607	34	a	a	DT
18637	15607	35	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15607	36	and	and	CC
18637	15607	37	present	present	JJ
18637	15607	38	danger	danger	NN
18637	15607	39	of	of	IN
18637	15607	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15607	41	being	be	VBG
18637	15607	42	followed	follow	VBN
18637	15607	43	.	.	.
18637	15608	1	In	in	IN
18637	15608	2	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	15608	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15608	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	15608	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15608	6	Washington,[79	Washington,[79	NNP
18637	15608	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15608	8	decided	decide	VBD
18637	15608	9	in	in	IN
18637	15608	10	1915	1915	CD
18637	15608	11	,	,	,
18637	15608	12	the	the	DT
18637	15608	13	question	question	NN
18637	15608	14	at	at	IN
18637	15608	15	issue	issue	NN
18637	15608	16	was	be	VBD
18637	15608	17	the	the	DT
18637	15608	18	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	15608	19	of	of	IN
18637	15608	20	a	a	DT
18637	15608	21	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	15608	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	15608	23	denouncing	denounce	VBG
18637	15608	24	"	"	``
18637	15608	25	the	the	DT
18637	15608	26	wilful	wilful	JJ
18637	15608	27	printing	printing	NN
18637	15608	28	,	,	,
18637	15608	29	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	15608	30	,	,	,
18637	15608	31	etc	etc	FW
18637	15608	32	.	.	.
18637	15608	33	,	,	,
18637	15608	34	of	of	IN
18637	15608	35	matter	matter	NN
18637	15608	36	advocating	advocate	VBG
18637	15608	37	or	or	CC
18637	15608	38	encouraging	encourage	VBG
18637	15608	39	the	the	DT
18637	15608	40	commission	commission	NN
18637	15608	41	of	of	IN
18637	15608	42	any	any	DT
18637	15608	43	crime	crime	NN
18637	15608	44	or	or	CC
18637	15608	45	breach	breach	NN
18637	15608	46	of	of	IN
18637	15608	47	the	the	DT
18637	15608	48	peace	peace	NN
18637	15608	49	or	or	CC
18637	15608	50	which	which	WDT
18637	15608	51	shall	shall	MD
18637	15608	52	tend	tend	VB
18637	15608	53	to	to	TO
18637	15608	54	encourage	encourage	VB
18637	15608	55	or	or	CC
18637	15608	56	advocate	advocate	VB
18637	15608	57	disrespect	disrespect	NN
18637	15608	58	for	for	IN
18637	15608	59	law	law	NN
18637	15608	60	or	or	CC
18637	15608	61	any	any	DT
18637	15608	62	court	court	NN
18637	15608	63	or	or	CC
18637	15608	64	courts	court	NNS
18637	15608	65	of	of	IN
18637	15608	66	justice	justice	NN
18637	15608	67	.	.	.
18637	15608	68	"	"	''
18637	15609	1	The	the	DT
18637	15609	2	State	State	NNP
18637	15609	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15609	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15609	5	had	have	VBD
18637	15609	6	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	15609	7	that	that	IN
18637	15609	8	the	the	DT
18637	15609	9	case	case	NN
18637	15609	10	was	be	VBD
18637	15609	11	governed	govern	VBN
18637	15609	12	by	by	IN
18637	15609	13	the	the	DT
18637	15609	14	guarantees	guarantee	NNS
18637	15609	15	of	of	IN
18637	15609	16	the	the	DT
18637	15609	17	United	United	NNP
18637	15609	18	States	States	NNP
18637	15609	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15609	20	of	of	IN
18637	15609	21	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15609	22	of	of	IN
18637	15609	23	speech	speech	NN
18637	15609	24	,	,	,
18637	15609	25	and	and	CC
18637	15609	26	especially	especially	RB
18637	15609	27	by	by	IN
18637	15609	28	the	the	DT
18637	15609	29	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15609	30	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15609	31	,	,	,
18637	15609	32	and	and	CC
18637	15609	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15609	34	decision	decision	NN
18637	15609	35	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	15609	36	the	the	DT
18637	15609	37	statute	statute	NN
18637	15609	38	was	be	VBD
18637	15609	39	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	15609	40	by	by	IN
18637	15609	41	the	the	DT
18637	15609	42	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15609	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15609	44	on	on	IN
18637	15609	45	the	the	DT
18637	15609	46	same	same	JJ
18637	15609	47	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	15609	48	,	,	,
18637	15609	49	in	in	IN
18637	15609	50	the	the	DT
18637	15609	51	case	case	NN
18637	15609	52	of	of	IN
18637	15609	53	a	a	DT
18637	15609	54	person	person	NN
18637	15609	55	indicted	indict	VBN
18637	15609	56	for	for	IN
18637	15609	57	publishing	publish	VBG
18637	15609	58	an	an	DT
18637	15609	59	article	article	NN
18637	15609	60	encouraging	encourage	VBG
18637	15609	61	and	and	CC
18637	15609	62	inciting	incite	VBG
18637	15609	63	what	what	WP
18637	15609	64	the	the	DT
18637	15609	65	jury	jury	NN
18637	15609	66	had	have	VBD
18637	15609	67	found	find	VBN
18637	15609	68	to	to	TO
18637	15609	69	be	be	VB
18637	15609	70	a	a	DT
18637	15609	71	breach	breach	NN
18637	15609	72	of	of	IN
18637	15609	73	State	state	NN
18637	15609	74	laws	law	NNS
18637	15609	75	against	against	IN
18637	15609	76	indecent	indecent	JJ
18637	15609	77	exposure	exposure	NN
18637	15609	78	.	.	.
18637	15610	1	Again	again	RB
18637	15610	2	,	,	,
18637	15610	3	one	one	PRP
18637	15610	4	notes	note	VBZ
18637	15610	5	the	the	DT
18637	15610	6	total	total	JJ
18637	15610	7	absence	absence	NN
18637	15610	8	of	of	IN
18637	15610	9	any	any	DT
18637	15610	10	reference	reference	NN
18637	15610	11	to	to	IN
18637	15610	12	the	the	DT
18637	15610	13	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15610	14	and	and	CC
18637	15610	15	present	present	JJ
18637	15610	16	danger	danger	NN
18637	15610	17	rule	rule	NN
18637	15610	18	.	.	.
18637	15611	1	But	but	CC
18637	15611	2	not	not	RB
18637	15611	3	all	all	DT
18637	15611	4	State	state	NN
18637	15611	5	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	15611	6	survived	survive	VBD
18637	15611	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15611	8	review	review	NN
18637	15611	9	prior	prior	RB
18637	15611	10	to	to	IN
18637	15611	11	the	the	DT
18637	15611	12	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	15611	13	of	of	IN
18637	15611	14	the	the	DT
18637	15611	15	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15611	16	and	and	CC
18637	15611	17	present	present	JJ
18637	15611	18	danger	danger	NN
18637	15611	19	test	test	NN
18637	15611	20	.	.	.
18637	15612	1	In	in	IN
18637	15612	2	1927	1927	CD
18637	15612	3	the	the	DT
18637	15612	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15612	5	disallowed	disallow	VBD
18637	15612	6	a	a	DT
18637	15612	7	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	15612	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	15612	9	which	which	WDT
18637	15612	10	,	,	,
18637	15612	11	as	as	IN
18637	15612	12	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	15612	13	by	by	IN
18637	15612	14	the	the	DT
18637	15612	15	highest	high	JJS
18637	15612	16	State	State	NNP
18637	15612	17	court	court	NN
18637	15612	18	,	,	,
18637	15612	19	made	make	VBD
18637	15612	20	punishable	punishable	JJ
18637	15612	21	the	the	DT
18637	15612	22	joining	joining	NN
18637	15612	23	of	of	IN
18637	15612	24	an	an	DT
18637	15612	25	organization	organization	NN
18637	15612	26	teaching	teach	VBG
18637	15612	27	the	the	DT
18637	15612	28	inevitability	inevitability	NN
18637	15612	29	of	of	IN
18637	15612	30	"	"	``
18637	15612	31	the	the	DT
18637	15612	32	class	class	NN
18637	15612	33	struggle";[80	struggle";[80	NN
18637	15612	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15612	35	three	three	CD
18637	15612	36	years	year	NNS
18637	15612	37	later	later	RB
18637	15612	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15612	39	upset	upset	VBD
18637	15612	40	a	a	DT
18637	15612	41	California	California	NNP
18637	15612	42	statute	statute	NN
18637	15612	43	which	which	WDT
18637	15612	44	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	15612	45	in	in	IN
18637	15612	46	all	all	DT
18637	15612	47	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	15612	48	the	the	DT
18637	15612	49	carrying	carrying	NN
18637	15612	50	of	of	IN
18637	15612	51	a	a	DT
18637	15612	52	red	red	JJ
18637	15612	53	flag	flag	NN
18637	15612	54	as	as	IN
18637	15612	55	a	a	DT
18637	15612	56	symbol	symbol	NN
18637	15612	57	of	of	IN
18637	15612	58	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	15612	59	to	to	IN
18637	15612	60	government;[81	government;[81	NNP
18637	15612	61	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15612	62	and	and	CC
18637	15612	63	6	6	CD
18637	15612	64	years	year	NNS
18637	15612	65	after	after	IN
18637	15612	66	that	that	IN
18637	15612	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15612	68	upset	upset	VBD
18637	15612	69	a	a	DT
18637	15612	70	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15612	71	under	under	IN
18637	15612	72	an	an	DT
18637	15612	73	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	15612	74	statute	statute	NN
18637	15612	75	for	for	IN
18637	15612	76	participating	participate	VBG
18637	15612	77	in	in	IN
18637	15612	78	a	a	DT
18637	15612	79	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	15612	80	held	hold	VBN
18637	15612	81	under	under	IN
18637	15612	82	the	the	DT
18637	15612	83	auspices	auspex	NNS
18637	15612	84	of	of	IN
18637	15612	85	an	an	DT
18637	15612	86	organization	organization	NN
18637	15612	87	which	which	WDT
18637	15612	88	was	be	VBD
18637	15612	89	charged	charge	VBN
18637	15612	90	with	with	IN
18637	15612	91	advocating	advocate	VBG
18637	15612	92	violence	violence	NN
18637	15612	93	as	as	IN
18637	15612	94	a	a	DT
18637	15612	95	political	political	JJ
18637	15612	96	method	method	NN
18637	15612	97	,	,	,
18637	15612	98	although	although	IN
18637	15612	99	the	the	DT
18637	15612	100	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	15612	101	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15612	102	was	be	VBD
18637	15612	103	orderly	orderly	JJ
18637	15612	104	and	and	CC
18637	15612	105	did	do	VBD
18637	15612	106	not	not	RB
18637	15612	107	advocate	advocate	VB
18637	15612	108	violence	violence	NN
18637	15612	109	.	.	.
18637	15613	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15613	2	82	82	CD
18637	15613	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15613	4	In	in	IN
18637	15613	5	none	none	NN
18637	15613	6	of	of	IN
18637	15613	7	these	these	DT
18637	15613	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	15613	9	was	be	VBD
18637	15613	10	the	the	DT
18637	15613	11	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15613	12	and	and	CC
18637	15613	13	present	present	JJ
18637	15613	14	danger	danger	NN
18637	15613	15	test	test	NN
18637	15613	16	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	15613	17	.	.	.
18637	15614	1	EMERGENCE	emergence	RB
18637	15614	2	OF	of	IN
18637	15614	3	THE	the	DT
18637	15614	4	CLEAR	CLEAR	NNP
18637	15614	5	AND	and	CC
18637	15614	6	PRESENT	present	JJ
18637	15614	7	TEST	test	NN
18637	15614	8	In	in	IN
18637	15614	9	Schenck	Schenck	NNP
18637	15614	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15614	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	15614	12	_	_	NNP
18637	15614	13	United	United	NNP
18637	15614	14	States[83	States[83	NNP
18637	15614	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15614	16	appellants	appellant	NNS
18637	15614	17	had	have	VBD
18637	15614	18	been	be	VBN
18637	15614	19	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	15614	20	of	of	IN
18637	15614	21	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15614	22	to	to	TO
18637	15614	23	violate	violate	VB
18637	15614	24	the	the	DT
18637	15614	25	Espionage	Espionage	NNP
18637	15614	26	Act	Act	NNP
18637	15614	27	of	of	IN
18637	15614	28	June	June	NNP
18637	15614	29	15	15	CD
18637	15614	30	,	,	,
18637	15614	31	1917[84	1917[84	CD
18637	15614	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15614	33	"	"	``
18637	15614	34	by	by	IN
18637	15614	35	causing	cause	VBG
18637	15614	36	and	and	CC
18637	15614	37	attempting	attempt	VBG
18637	15614	38	to	to	TO
18637	15614	39	cause	cause	VB
18637	15614	40	insubordination	insubordination	NN
18637	15614	41	,	,	,
18637	15614	42	etc	etc	FW
18637	15614	43	.	.	FW
18637	15614	44	,	,	,
18637	15614	45	in	in	IN
18637	15614	46	the	the	DT
18637	15614	47	military	military	JJ
18637	15614	48	and	and	CC
18637	15614	49	naval	naval	JJ
18637	15614	50	forces	force	NNS
18637	15614	51	of	of	IN
18637	15614	52	the	the	DT
18637	15614	53	United	United	NNP
18637	15614	54	States	States	NNP
18637	15614	55	,	,	,
18637	15614	56	and	and	CC
18637	15614	57	to	to	TO
18637	15614	58	obstruct	obstruct	VB
18637	15614	59	the	the	DT
18637	15614	60	recruiting	recruiting	NN
18637	15614	61	and	and	CC
18637	15614	62	enlistment	enlistment	NN
18637	15614	63	service	service	NN
18637	15614	64	of	of	IN
18637	15614	65	the	the	DT
18637	15614	66	United	United	NNP
18637	15614	67	States	States	NNP
18637	15614	68	,	,	,
18637	15614	69	when	when	WRB
18637	15614	70	the	the	DT
18637	15614	71	United	United	NNP
18637	15614	72	States	States	NNP
18637	15614	73	was	be	VBD
18637	15614	74	at	at	IN
18637	15614	75	war	war	NN
18637	15614	76	with	with	IN
18637	15614	77	the	the	DT
18637	15614	78	German	German	NNP
18637	15614	79	Empire	Empire	NNP
18637	15614	80	,	,	,
18637	15614	81	to	to	IN
18637	15614	82	-	-	HYPH
18637	15614	83	wit	wit	NN
18637	15614	84	,	,	,
18637	15614	85	that	that	IN
18637	15614	86	the	the	DT
18637	15614	87	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	15614	88	willfully	willfully	RB
18637	15614	89	conspired	conspire	VBD
18637	15614	90	to	to	TO
18637	15614	91	have	have	VB
18637	15614	92	printed	print	VBN
18637	15614	93	and	and	CC
18637	15614	94	circulated	circulate	VBN
18637	15614	95	to	to	IN
18637	15614	96	men	man	NNS
18637	15614	97	who	who	WP
18637	15614	98	had	have	VBD
18637	15614	99	been	be	VBN
18637	15614	100	called	call	VBN
18637	15614	101	and	and	CC
18637	15614	102	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	15614	103	for	for	IN
18637	15614	104	military	military	JJ
18637	15614	105	service	service	NN
18637	15614	106	under	under	IN
18637	15614	107	the	the	DT
18637	15614	108	Act	Act	NNP
18637	15614	109	of	of	IN
18637	15614	110	May	May	NNP
18637	15614	111	18	18	CD
18637	15614	112	,	,	,
18637	15614	113	1917	1917	CD
18637	15614	114	,	,	,
18637	15614	115	a	a	DT
18637	15614	116	document	document	NN
18637	15614	117	set	set	VBN
18637	15614	118	forth	forth	RP
18637	15614	119	and	and	CC
18637	15614	120	alleged	allege	VBD
18637	15614	121	to	to	TO
18637	15614	122	be	be	VB
18637	15614	123	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	15614	124	to	to	TO
18637	15614	125	cause	cause	VB
18637	15614	126	such	such	JJ
18637	15614	127	insubordination	insubordination	NN
18637	15614	128	and	and	CC
18637	15614	129	obstruction	obstruction	NN
18637	15614	130	.	.	.
18637	15614	131	"	"	''
18637	15615	1	Affirming	affirm	VBG
18637	15615	2	the	the	DT
18637	15615	3	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15615	4	,	,	,
18637	15615	5	the	the	DT
18637	15615	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15615	7	,	,	,
18637	15615	8	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15615	9	by	by	IN
18637	15615	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15615	11	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	15615	12	said	say	VBD
18637	15615	13	:	:	:
18637	15615	14	"	"	``
18637	15615	15	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15615	16	well	well	RB
18637	15615	17	may	may	MD
18637	15615	18	be	be	VB
18637	15615	19	that	that	IN
18637	15615	20	the	the	DT
18637	15615	21	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	15615	22	of	of	IN
18637	15615	23	laws	law	NNS
18637	15615	24	abridging	abridge	VBG
18637	15615	25	the	the	DT
18637	15615	26	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15615	27	of	of	IN
18637	15615	28	speech	speech	NN
18637	15615	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	15615	30	not	not	RB
18637	15615	31	confined	confine	VBN
18637	15615	32	to	to	IN
18637	15615	33	previous	previous	JJ
18637	15615	34	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	15615	35	,	,	,
18637	15615	36	although	although	IN
18637	15615	37	to	to	TO
18637	15615	38	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	15615	39	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15615	40	may	may	MD
18637	15615	41	have	have	VB
18637	15615	42	been	be	VBN
18637	15615	43	the	the	DT
18637	15615	44	main	main	JJ
18637	15615	45	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15615	46	,	,	,
18637	15615	47	as	as	IN
18637	15615	48	intimated	intimate	VBN
18637	15615	49	in	in	IN
18637	15615	50	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	15615	51	_	_	NNP
18637	15615	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	15615	53	_	_	NNP
18637	15615	54	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	15615	55	.	.	.
18637	15616	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15616	2	85	85	CD
18637	15616	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15616	4	*	*	NFP
18637	15616	5	*	*	NFP
18637	15616	6	*	*	NFP
18637	15616	7	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15616	8	admit	admit	VBP
18637	15616	9	that	that	IN
18637	15616	10	in	in	IN
18637	15616	11	many	many	JJ
18637	15616	12	places	place	NNS
18637	15616	13	and	and	CC
18637	15616	14	in	in	IN
18637	15616	15	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	15616	16	times	time	NNS
18637	15616	17	the	the	DT
18637	15616	18	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	15616	19	in	in	IN
18637	15616	20	saying	say	VBG
18637	15616	21	all	all	DT
18637	15616	22	that	that	WDT
18637	15616	23	was	be	VBD
18637	15616	24	said	say	VBN
18637	15616	25	in	in	IN
18637	15616	26	the	the	DT
18637	15616	27	circular	circular	JJ
18637	15616	28	would	would	MD
18637	15616	29	have	have	VB
18637	15616	30	been	be	VBN
18637	15616	31	within	within	IN
18637	15616	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15616	33	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15616	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	15616	35	.	.	.
18637	15617	1	But	but	CC
18637	15617	2	the	the	DT
18637	15617	3	character	character	NN
18637	15617	4	of	of	IN
18637	15617	5	every	every	DT
18637	15617	6	act	act	NN
18637	15617	7	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	15617	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	15617	9	the	the	DT
18637	15617	10	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	15617	11	in	in	IN
18637	15617	12	which	which	WDT
18637	15617	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15617	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	15617	15	done	do	VBN
18637	15617	16	.	.	.
18637	15618	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15618	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15618	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15618	4	The	the	DT
18637	15618	5	most	most	RBS
18637	15618	6	stringent	stringent	JJ
18637	15618	7	protection	protection	NN
18637	15618	8	of	of	IN
18637	15618	9	free	free	JJ
18637	15618	10	speech	speech	NN
18637	15618	11	would	would	MD
18637	15618	12	not	not	RB
18637	15618	13	protect	protect	VB
18637	15618	14	a	a	DT
18637	15618	15	man	man	NN
18637	15618	16	in	in	IN
18637	15618	17	falsely	falsely	RB
18637	15618	18	shouting	shout	VBG
18637	15618	19	fire	fire	NN
18637	15618	20	in	in	IN
18637	15618	21	a	a	DT
18637	15618	22	theatre	theatre	NN
18637	15618	23	and	and	CC
18637	15618	24	causing	cause	VBG
18637	15618	25	a	a	DT
18637	15618	26	panic	panic	NN
18637	15618	27	.	.	.
18637	15619	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15619	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	15619	3	not	not	RB
18637	15619	4	even	even	RB
18637	15619	5	protect	protect	VB
18637	15619	6	a	a	DT
18637	15619	7	man	man	NN
18637	15619	8	from	from	IN
18637	15619	9	an	an	DT
18637	15619	10	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	15619	11	against	against	IN
18637	15619	12	uttering	utter	VBG
18637	15619	13	words	word	NNS
18637	15619	14	that	that	WDT
18637	15619	15	have	have	VBP
18637	15619	16	all	all	PDT
18637	15619	17	the	the	DT
18637	15619	18	effect	effect	NN
18637	15619	19	of	of	IN
18637	15619	20	force	force	NN
18637	15619	21	.	.	.
18637	15620	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15620	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15620	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15620	4	The	the	DT
18637	15620	5	question	question	NN
18637	15620	6	in	in	IN
18637	15620	7	every	every	DT
18637	15620	8	case	case	NN
18637	15620	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	15620	10	whether	whether	IN
18637	15620	11	the	the	DT
18637	15620	12	words	word	NNS
18637	15620	13	used	use	VBN
18637	15620	14	are	be	VBP
18637	15620	15	used	use	VBN
18637	15620	16	in	in	IN
18637	15620	17	such	such	JJ
18637	15620	18	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	15620	19	and	and	CC
18637	15620	20	are	be	VBP
18637	15620	21	of	of	IN
18637	15620	22	such	such	PDT
18637	15620	23	a	a	DT
18637	15620	24	nature	nature	NN
18637	15620	25	as	as	IN
18637	15620	26	to	to	TO
18637	15620	27	create	create	VB
18637	15620	28	a	a	DT
18637	15620	29	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15620	30	and	and	CC
18637	15620	31	present	present	JJ
18637	15620	32	danger	danger	NN
18637	15620	33	that	that	IN
18637	15620	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15620	35	will	will	MD
18637	15620	36	bring	bring	VB
18637	15620	37	about	about	RP
18637	15620	38	the	the	DT
18637	15620	39	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15620	40	evils	evil	NNS
18637	15620	41	that	that	WDT
18637	15620	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15620	43	has	have	VBZ
18637	15620	44	a	a	DT
18637	15620	45	right	right	NN
18637	15620	46	to	to	TO
18637	15620	47	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	15620	48	.	.	.
18637	15621	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15621	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15621	3	a	a	DT
18637	15621	4	question	question	NN
18637	15621	5	of	of	IN
18637	15621	6	proximity	proximity	NN
18637	15621	7	and	and	CC
18637	15621	8	degree	degree	NN
18637	15621	9	.	.	.
18637	15622	1	"	"	``
18637	15622	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15622	3	86	86	CD
18637	15622	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15622	5	One	one	CD
18637	15622	6	week	week	NN
18637	15622	7	later	later	RB
18637	15622	8	two	two	CD
18637	15622	9	other	other	JJ
18637	15622	10	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	15622	11	under	under	IN
18637	15622	12	the	the	DT
18637	15622	13	same	same	JJ
18637	15622	14	act	act	NN
18637	15622	15	were	be	VBD
18637	15622	16	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	15622	17	,	,	,
18637	15622	18	with	with	IN
18637	15622	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15622	20	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	15622	21	again	again	RB
18637	15622	22	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15622	23	for	for	IN
18637	15622	24	the	the	DT
18637	15622	25	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	15622	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15622	27	.	.	.
18637	15623	1	In	in	IN
18637	15623	2	Frohwerk	Frohwerk	NNP
18637	15623	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15623	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	15623	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15623	6	United	United	NNP
18637	15623	7	States[87	States[87	NNP
18637	15623	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15623	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15623	10	said	say	VBD
18637	15623	11	:	:	:
18637	15623	12	"	"	``
18637	15623	13	With	with	IN
18637	15623	14	regard	regard	NN
18637	15623	15	to	to	IN
18637	15623	16	the	the	DT
18637	15623	17	argument	argument	NN
18637	15623	18	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15623	19	on	on	IN
18637	15623	20	the	the	DT
18637	15623	21	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15623	22	question	question	NN
18637	15623	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15623	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15623	25	think	think	VBP
18637	15623	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15623	27	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	15623	28	to	to	TO
18637	15623	29	add	add	VB
18637	15623	30	to	to	IN
18637	15623	31	what	what	WP
18637	15623	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	15623	33	been	be	VBN
18637	15623	34	said	say	VBN
18637	15623	35	in	in	IN
18637	15623	36	Schenck	Schenck	NNP
18637	15623	37	_	_	NNP
18637	15623	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	15623	39	_	_	NNP
18637	15623	40	United	United	NNP
18637	15623	41	States	States	NNP
18637	15623	42	,	,	,
18637	15623	43	*	*	NFP
18637	15623	44	*	*	NFP
18637	15623	45	*	*	NFP
18637	15623	46	,	,	,
18637	15623	47	only	only	RB
18637	15623	48	that	that	IN
18637	15623	49	the	the	DT
18637	15623	50	First	First	NNP
18637	15623	51	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15623	52	while	while	IN
18637	15623	53	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	15623	54	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15623	55	against	against	IN
18637	15623	56	free	free	JJ
18637	15623	57	speech	speech	NN
18637	15623	58	as	as	IN
18637	15623	59	such	such	JJ
18637	15623	60	can	can	MD
18637	15623	61	not	not	RB
18637	15623	62	have	have	VB
18637	15623	63	been	be	VBN
18637	15623	64	,	,	,
18637	15623	65	and	and	CC
18637	15623	66	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	15623	67	was	be	VBD
18637	15623	68	not	not	RB
18637	15623	69	,	,	,
18637	15623	70	intended	intend	VBN
18637	15623	71	to	to	TO
18637	15623	72	give	give	VB
18637	15623	73	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	15623	74	for	for	IN
18637	15623	75	every	every	DT
18637	15623	76	possible	possible	JJ
18637	15623	77	use	use	NN
18637	15623	78	of	of	IN
18637	15623	79	language	language	NN
18637	15623	80	.	.	.
18637	15624	1	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	15624	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15624	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15624	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15624	5	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	15624	6	,	,	,
18637	15624	7	165	165	CD
18637	15624	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15624	9	275	275	CD
18637	15624	10	,	,	,
18637	15624	11	281	281	CD
18637	15624	12	.	.	.
18637	15625	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15625	2	venture	venture	VBP
18637	15625	3	to	to	TO
18637	15625	4	believe	believe	VB
18637	15625	5	that	that	IN
18637	15625	6	neither	neither	DT
18637	15625	7	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	15625	8	nor	nor	CC
18637	15625	9	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	15625	10	,	,	,
18637	15625	11	nor	nor	CC
18637	15625	12	any	any	DT
18637	15625	13	other	other	JJ
18637	15625	14	competent	competent	JJ
18637	15625	15	person	person	NN
18637	15625	16	then	then	RB
18637	15625	17	or	or	CC
18637	15625	18	later	later	RBR
18637	15625	19	,	,	,
18637	15625	20	ever	ever	RB
18637	15625	21	supposed	suppose	VBN
18637	15625	22	that	that	DT
18637	15625	23	to	to	TO
18637	15625	24	make	make	VB
18637	15625	25	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15625	26	the	the	DT
18637	15625	27	counselling	counselling	NN
18637	15625	28	of	of	IN
18637	15625	29	a	a	DT
18637	15625	30	murder	murder	NN
18637	15625	31	within	within	IN
18637	15625	32	the	the	DT
18637	15625	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	15625	34	of	of	IN
18637	15625	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15625	36	would	would	MD
18637	15625	37	be	be	VB
18637	15625	38	an	an	DT
18637	15625	39	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	15625	40	interference	interference	NN
18637	15625	41	with	with	IN
18637	15625	42	free	free	JJ
18637	15625	43	speech	speech	NN
18637	15625	44	.	.	.
18637	15626	1	"	"	``
18637	15626	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15626	3	88	88	CD
18637	15626	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15626	5	In	in	IN
18637	15626	6	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	15626	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15626	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15626	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15626	10	United	United	NNP
18637	15626	11	States[89	States[89	NNP
18637	15626	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15626	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15626	14	referred	refer	VBD
18637	15626	15	to	to	IN
18637	15626	16	"	"	``
18637	15626	17	the	the	DT
18637	15626	18	natural	natural	JJ
18637	15626	19	and	and	CC
18637	15626	20	intended	intended	JJ
18637	15626	21	effect	effect	NN
18637	15626	22	"	"	''
18637	15626	23	and	and	CC
18637	15626	24	"	"	``
18637	15626	25	probable	probable	JJ
18637	15626	26	effect"[90	effect"[90	NN
18637	15626	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15626	28	of	of	IN
18637	15626	29	the	the	DT
18637	15626	30	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	15626	31	speech	speech	NN
18637	15626	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15626	33	straight	straight	JJ
18637	15626	34	common	common	JJ
18637	15626	35	law	law	NN
18637	15626	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15626	37	.	.	.
18637	15627	1	When	when	WRB
18637	15627	2	,	,	,
18637	15627	3	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	15627	4	,	,	,
18637	15627	5	a	a	DT
18637	15627	6	case	case	NN
18637	15627	7	arose	arise	VBD
18637	15627	8	in	in	IN
18637	15627	9	which	which	WDT
18637	15627	10	the	the	DT
18637	15627	11	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	15627	12	in	in	IN
18637	15627	13	the	the	DT
18637	15627	14	Schenck	Schenck	NNP
18637	15627	15	case	case	NN
18637	15627	16	might	may	MD
18637	15627	17	have	have	VB
18637	15627	18	influenced	influence	VBN
18637	15627	19	the	the	DT
18637	15627	20	result	result	NN
18637	15627	21	,	,	,
18637	15627	22	the	the	DT
18637	15627	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15627	24	,	,	,
18637	15627	25	seven	seven	CD
18637	15627	26	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	15627	27	to	to	IN
18637	15627	28	two	two	CD
18637	15627	29	,	,	,
18637	15627	30	declined	decline	VBD
18637	15627	31	to	to	TO
18637	15627	32	follow	follow	VB
18637	15627	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15627	34	.	.	.
18637	15628	1	This	this	DT
18637	15628	2	was	be	VBD
18637	15628	3	in	in	IN
18637	15628	4	Abrams	Abrams	NNP
18637	15628	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15628	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15628	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15628	8	United	United	NNP
18637	15628	9	States,[91	States,[91	NNP
18637	15628	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15628	11	in	in	IN
18637	15628	12	which	which	WDT
18637	15628	13	the	the	DT
18637	15628	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15628	15	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	15628	16	a	a	DT
18637	15628	17	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15628	18	for	for	IN
18637	15628	19	spreading	spread	VBG
18637	15628	20	propaganda	propaganda	NN
18637	15628	21	"	"	``
18637	15628	22	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	15628	23	intended	intend	VBN
18637	15628	24	to	to	TO
18637	15628	25	provoke	provoke	VB
18637	15628	26	and	and	CC
18637	15628	27	to	to	TO
18637	15628	28	encourage	encourage	VB
18637	15628	29	resistance	resistance	NN
18637	15628	30	to	to	IN
18637	15628	31	the	the	DT
18637	15628	32	United	United	NNP
18637	15628	33	States	States	NNP
18637	15628	34	in	in	IN
18637	15628	35	the	the	DT
18637	15628	36	war	war	NN
18637	15628	37	.	.	.
18637	15628	38	"	"	''
18637	15629	1	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15629	2	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	15629	3	and	and	CC
18637	15629	4	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	15629	5	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	15629	6	on	on	IN
18637	15629	7	the	the	DT
18637	15629	8	ground	ground	NN
18637	15629	9	that	that	IN
18637	15629	10	the	the	DT
18637	15629	11	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	15629	12	did	do	VBD
18637	15629	13	not	not	RB
18637	15629	14	create	create	VB
18637	15629	15	a	a	DT
18637	15629	16	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15629	17	and	and	CC
18637	15629	18	imminent	imminent	JJ
18637	15629	19	danger[92	danger[92	NN
18637	15629	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15629	21	of	of	IN
18637	15629	22	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15629	23	evils	evil	NNS
18637	15629	24	.	.	.
18637	15630	1	And	and	CC
18637	15630	2	the	the	DT
18637	15630	3	same	same	JJ
18637	15630	4	result	result	NN
18637	15630	5	was	be	VBD
18637	15630	6	reached	reach	VBN
18637	15630	7	in	in	IN
18637	15630	8	Schaefer	Schaefer	NNP
18637	15630	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15630	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	15630	11	_	_	NNP
18637	15630	12	United	United	NNP
18637	15630	13	States,[93	States,[93	NNP
18637	15630	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15630	15	again	again	RB
18637	15630	16	over	over	IN
18637	15630	17	the	the	DT
18637	15630	18	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	15630	19	of	of	IN
18637	15630	20	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15630	21	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	15630	22	and	and	CC
18637	15630	23	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	15630	24	,	,	,
18637	15630	25	the	the	DT
18637	15630	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15630	27	saying	say	VBG
18637	15630	28	that	that	IN
18637	15630	29	:	:	:
18637	15630	30	"	"	``
18637	15630	31	The	the	DT
18637	15630	32	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	15630	33	of	of	IN
18637	15630	34	the	the	DT
18637	15630	35	articles	article	NNS
18637	15630	36	and	and	CC
18637	15630	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15630	38	efficacy	efficacy	NN
18637	15630	39	were	be	VBD
18637	15630	40	enough	enough	JJ
18637	15630	41	for	for	IN
18637	15630	42	the	the	DT
18637	15630	43	offense	offense	NN
18637	15630	44	*	*	NFP
18637	15630	45	*	*	NFP
18637	15630	46	*	*	NFP
18637	15630	47	.	.	.
18637	15631	1	"	"	``
18637	15631	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15631	3	94	94	CD
18637	15631	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15631	5	THE	the	DT
18637	15631	6	GITLOW	GITLOW	NNP
18637	15631	7	AND	and	CC
18637	15631	8	WHITNEY	WHITNEY	NNP
18637	15631	9	CASES	CASES	NNP
18637	15631	10	Gitlow	Gitlow	NNP
18637	15631	11	was	be	VBD
18637	15631	12	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	15631	13	under	under	IN
18637	15631	14	a	a	DT
18637	15631	15	New	New	NNP
18637	15631	16	York	York	NNP
18637	15631	17	statute	statute	NN
18637	15631	18	making	make	VBG
18637	15631	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15631	20	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15631	21	to	to	TO
18637	15631	22	advocate	advocate	VB
18637	15631	23	,	,	,
18637	15631	24	advise	advise	VB
18637	15631	25	or	or	CC
18637	15631	26	teach	teach	VB
18637	15631	27	the	the	DT
18637	15631	28	duty	duty	NN
18637	15631	29	,	,	,
18637	15631	30	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	15631	31	or	or	CC
18637	15631	32	propriety	propriety	NN
18637	15631	33	of	of	IN
18637	15631	34	overturning	overturn	VBG
18637	15631	35	organized	organize	VBN
18637	15631	36	government	government	NN
18637	15631	37	by	by	IN
18637	15631	38	force	force	NN
18637	15631	39	or	or	CC
18637	15631	40	violence	violence	NN
18637	15631	41	.	.	.
18637	15632	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15632	2	95	95	CD
18637	15632	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15632	4	Since	since	IN
18637	15632	5	there	there	EX
18637	15632	6	was	be	VBD
18637	15632	7	no	no	DT
18637	15632	8	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	15632	9	as	as	IN
18637	15632	10	to	to	IN
18637	15632	11	the	the	DT
18637	15632	12	effect	effect	NN
18637	15632	13	resulting	result	VBG
18637	15632	14	from	from	IN
18637	15632	15	the	the	DT
18637	15632	16	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	15632	17	of	of	IN
18637	15632	18	the	the	DT
18637	15632	19	manifesto	manifesto	NN
18637	15632	20	for	for	IN
18637	15632	21	which	which	WDT
18637	15632	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15632	23	was	be	VBD
18637	15632	24	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	15632	25	and	and	CC
18637	15632	26	no	no	DT
18637	15632	27	contention	contention	NN
18637	15632	28	that	that	IN
18637	15632	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15632	30	created	create	VBD
18637	15632	31	any	any	DT
18637	15632	32	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	15632	33	threat	threat	NN
18637	15632	34	to	to	IN
18637	15632	35	the	the	DT
18637	15632	36	security	security	NN
18637	15632	37	of	of	IN
18637	15632	38	the	the	DT
18637	15632	39	State	State	NNP
18637	15632	40	,	,	,
18637	15632	41	the	the	DT
18637	15632	42	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15632	43	was	be	VBD
18637	15632	44	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	15632	45	to	to	TO
18637	15632	46	reach	reach	VB
18637	15632	47	a	a	DT
18637	15632	48	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15632	49	cut	cut	NN
18637	15632	50	choice	choice	NN
18637	15632	51	between	between	IN
18637	15632	52	the	the	DT
18637	15632	53	common	common	JJ
18637	15632	54	law	law	NN
18637	15632	55	test	test	NN
18637	15632	56	of	of	IN
18637	15632	57	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	15632	58	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	15632	59	and	and	CC
18637	15632	60	the	the	DT
18637	15632	61	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15632	62	and	and	CC
18637	15632	63	present	present	JJ
18637	15632	64	danger	danger	NN
18637	15632	65	test	test	NN
18637	15632	66	.	.	.
18637	15633	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15633	2	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	15633	3	the	the	DT
18637	15633	4	former	former	JJ
18637	15633	5	and	and	CC
18637	15633	6	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15633	7	the	the	DT
18637	15633	8	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15633	9	,	,	,
18637	15633	10	saying	say	VBG
18637	15633	11	"	"	``
18637	15633	12	By	by	IN
18637	15633	13	enacting	enact	VBG
18637	15633	14	the	the	DT
18637	15633	15	present	present	JJ
18637	15633	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	15633	17	the	the	DT
18637	15633	18	state	state	NN
18637	15633	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	15633	20	determined	determine	VBN
18637	15633	21	,	,	,
18637	15633	22	through	through	IN
18637	15633	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15633	24	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	15633	25	body	body	NN
18637	15633	26	,	,	,
18637	15633	27	that	that	WDT
18637	15633	28	utterances	utterance	VBZ
18637	15633	29	advocating	advocate	VBG
18637	15633	30	the	the	DT
18637	15633	31	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	15633	32	of	of	IN
18637	15633	33	organized	organize	VBN
18637	15633	34	government	government	NN
18637	15633	35	by	by	IN
18637	15633	36	force	force	NN
18637	15633	37	,	,	,
18637	15633	38	violence	violence	NN
18637	15633	39	,	,	,
18637	15633	40	and	and	CC
18637	15633	41	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	15633	42	means	mean	NNS
18637	15633	43	,	,	,
18637	15633	44	are	be	VBP
18637	15633	45	so	so	RB
18637	15633	46	inimical	inimical	JJ
18637	15633	47	to	to	IN
18637	15633	48	the	the	DT
18637	15633	49	general	general	JJ
18637	15633	50	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	15633	51	,	,	,
18637	15633	52	and	and	CC
18637	15633	53	involve	involve	VBP
18637	15633	54	such	such	JJ
18637	15633	55	danger	danger	NN
18637	15633	56	of	of	IN
18637	15633	57	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15633	58	evil	evil	NN
18637	15633	59	,	,	,
18637	15633	60	that	that	IN
18637	15633	61	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15633	62	may	may	MD
18637	15633	63	be	be	VB
18637	15633	64	penalized	penalize	VBN
18637	15633	65	in	in	IN
18637	15633	66	the	the	DT
18637	15633	67	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15633	68	of	of	IN
18637	15633	69	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15633	70	police	police	NN
18637	15633	71	power	power	NN
18637	15633	72	.	.	.
18637	15634	1	That	that	DT
18637	15634	2	determination	determination	NN
18637	15634	3	must	must	MD
18637	15634	4	be	be	VB
18637	15634	5	given	give	VBN
18637	15634	6	great	great	JJ
18637	15634	7	weight	weight	NN
18637	15634	8	*	*	NFP
18637	15634	9	*	*	NFP
18637	15634	10	*	*	NFP
18637	15634	11	That	that	IN
18637	15634	12	utterances	utterance	VBZ
18637	15634	13	inciting	incite	VBG
18637	15634	14	to	to	IN
18637	15634	15	the	the	DT
18637	15634	16	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	15634	17	of	of	IN
18637	15634	18	organized	organize	VBN
18637	15634	19	government	government	NN
18637	15634	20	by	by	IN
18637	15634	21	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	15634	22	means	mean	NNS
18637	15634	23	present	present	VB
18637	15634	24	a	a	DT
18637	15634	25	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	15634	26	danger	danger	NN
18637	15634	27	of	of	IN
18637	15634	28	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15634	29	evil	evil	NN
18637	15634	30	to	to	TO
18637	15634	31	bring	bring	VB
18637	15634	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15634	33	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15634	34	within	within	IN
18637	15634	35	the	the	DT
18637	15634	36	range	range	NN
18637	15634	37	of	of	IN
18637	15634	38	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	15634	39	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	15634	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	15634	41	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15634	42	.	.	.
18637	15635	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	15635	2	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	15635	3	,	,	,
18637	15635	4	by	by	IN
18637	15635	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15635	6	very	very	JJ
18637	15635	7	nature	nature	NN
18637	15635	8	,	,	,
18637	15635	9	involve	involve	VBP
18637	15635	10	danger	danger	NN
18637	15635	11	to	to	IN
18637	15635	12	the	the	DT
18637	15635	13	public	public	JJ
18637	15635	14	peace	peace	NN
18637	15635	15	and	and	CC
18637	15635	16	to	to	IN
18637	15635	17	the	the	DT
18637	15635	18	security	security	NN
18637	15635	19	of	of	IN
18637	15635	20	the	the	DT
18637	15635	21	state	state	NN
18637	15635	22	.	.	.
18637	15636	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15636	2	threaten	threaten	VBP
18637	15636	3	breaches	breach	NNS
18637	15636	4	of	of	IN
18637	15636	5	the	the	DT
18637	15636	6	peace	peace	NN
18637	15636	7	and	and	CC
18637	15636	8	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	15636	9	revolution	revolution	NN
18637	15636	10	.	.	.
18637	15637	1	And	and	CC
18637	15637	2	the	the	DT
18637	15637	3	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	15637	4	danger	danger	NN
18637	15637	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	15637	6	none	none	NN
18637	15637	7	the	the	DT
18637	15637	8	less	less	JJR
18637	15637	9	and	and	CC
18637	15637	10	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	15637	11	because	because	IN
18637	15637	12	the	the	DT
18637	15637	13	effect	effect	NN
18637	15637	14	of	of	IN
18637	15637	15	a	a	DT
18637	15637	16	given	give	VBN
18637	15637	17	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	15637	18	can	can	MD
18637	15637	19	not	not	RB
18637	15637	20	be	be	VB
18637	15637	21	accurately	accurately	RB
18637	15637	22	foreseen	foresee	VBN
18637	15637	23	.	.	.
18637	15638	1	The	the	DT
18637	15638	2	state	state	NN
18637	15638	3	can	can	MD
18637	15638	4	not	not	RB
18637	15638	5	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	15638	6	be	be	VB
18637	15638	7	required	require	VBN
18637	15638	8	to	to	TO
18637	15638	9	measure	measure	VB
18637	15638	10	the	the	DT
18637	15638	11	danger	danger	NN
18637	15638	12	from	from	IN
18637	15638	13	every	every	DT
18637	15638	14	such	such	JJ
18637	15638	15	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	15638	16	in	in	IN
18637	15638	17	the	the	DT
18637	15638	18	nice	nice	JJ
18637	15638	19	balance	balance	NN
18637	15638	20	of	of	IN
18637	15638	21	a	a	DT
18637	15638	22	jeweler	jeweler	NN
18637	15638	23	's	's	POS
18637	15638	24	scale	scale	NN
18637	15638	25	.	.	.
18637	15639	1	"	"	``
18637	15639	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15639	3	96	96	CD
18637	15639	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15639	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15639	6	Sanford	Sanford	NNP
18637	15639	7	distinguished	distinguish	VBD
18637	15639	8	the	the	DT
18637	15639	9	Schenck	Schenck	NNP
18637	15639	10	Case	Case	NNP
18637	15639	11	by	by	IN
18637	15639	12	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	15639	13	that	that	IN
18637	15639	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15639	15	"	"	``
18637	15639	16	general	general	JJ
18637	15639	17	statement	statement	NN
18637	15639	18	"	"	''
18637	15639	19	was	be	VBD
18637	15639	20	intended	intend	VBN
18637	15639	21	to	to	TO
18637	15639	22	apply	apply	VB
18637	15639	23	only	only	RB
18637	15639	24	to	to	IN
18637	15639	25	cases	case	NNS
18637	15639	26	where	where	WRB
18637	15639	27	the	the	DT
18637	15639	28	statute	statute	NN
18637	15639	29	"	"	``
18637	15639	30	merely	merely	RB
18637	15639	31	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	15639	32	certain	certain	JJ
18637	15639	33	acts	act	NNS
18637	15639	34	involving	involve	VBG
18637	15639	35	the	the	DT
18637	15639	36	danger	danger	NN
18637	15639	37	of	of	IN
18637	15639	38	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15639	39	evil	evil	NN
18637	15639	40	without	without	IN
18637	15639	41	any	any	DT
18637	15639	42	reference	reference	NN
18637	15639	43	to	to	TO
18637	15639	44	language	language	VB
18637	15639	45	itself,"[97	itself,"[97	CD
18637	15639	46	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15639	47	and	and	CC
18637	15639	48	has	have	VBZ
18637	15639	49	no	no	DT
18637	15639	50	application	application	NN
18637	15639	51	"	"	''
18637	15639	52	where	where	WRB
18637	15639	53	the	the	DT
18637	15639	54	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	15639	55	body	body	NN
18637	15639	56	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15639	57	has	have	VBZ
18637	15639	58	previously	previously	RB
18637	15639	59	determined	determine	VBN
18637	15639	60	the	the	DT
18637	15639	61	danger	danger	NN
18637	15639	62	of	of	IN
18637	15639	63	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15639	64	evil	evil	NN
18637	15639	65	arising	arise	VBG
18637	15639	66	from	from	IN
18637	15639	67	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	15639	68	of	of	IN
18637	15639	69	a	a	DT
18637	15639	70	specified	specified	JJ
18637	15639	71	character	character	NN
18637	15639	72	.	.	.
18637	15640	1	"	"	``
18637	15640	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15640	3	98	98	CD
18637	15640	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15640	5	Two	two	CD
18637	15640	6	years	year	NNS
18637	15640	7	later	later	RB
18637	15640	8	,	,	,
18637	15640	9	in	in	IN
18637	15640	10	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	15640	11	_	_	NNP
18637	15640	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	15640	13	_	_	NNP
18637	15640	14	California,[99	California,[99	NNP
18637	15640	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15640	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	15640	17	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	15640	18	which	which	WDT
18637	15640	19	tended	tend	VBD
18637	15640	20	to	to	TO
18637	15640	21	establish	establish	VB
18637	15640	22	the	the	DT
18637	15640	23	existence	existence	NN
18637	15640	24	of	of	IN
18637	15640	25	a	a	DT
18637	15640	26	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15640	27	to	to	TO
18637	15640	28	commit	commit	VB
18637	15640	29	certain	certain	JJ
18637	15640	30	serious	serious	JJ
18637	15640	31	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	15640	32	,	,	,
18637	15640	33	the	the	DT
18637	15640	34	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15640	35	was	be	VBD
18637	15640	36	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	15640	37	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	15640	38	.	.	.
18637	15641	1	In	in	IN
18637	15641	2	a	a	DT
18637	15641	3	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	15641	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15641	5	in	in	IN
18637	15641	6	which	which	WDT
18637	15641	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15641	8	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	15641	9	joined	join	VBD
18637	15641	10	,	,	,
18637	15641	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15641	12	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	15641	13	restated	restate	VBD
18637	15641	14	the	the	DT
18637	15641	15	test	test	NN
18637	15641	16	of	of	IN
18637	15641	17	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15641	18	and	and	CC
18637	15641	19	present	present	JJ
18637	15641	20	danger	danger	NN
18637	15641	21	to	to	TO
18637	15641	22	include	include	VB
18637	15641	23	the	the	DT
18637	15641	24	intent	intent	NN
18637	15641	25	to	to	TO
18637	15641	26	create	create	VB
18637	15641	27	such	such	JJ
18637	15641	28	danger	danger	NN
18637	15641	29	:	:	:
18637	15641	30	"	"	``
18637	15641	31	But	but	CC
18637	15641	32	,	,	,
18637	15641	33	although	although	IN
18637	15641	34	the	the	DT
18637	15641	35	rights	right	NNS
18637	15641	36	of	of	IN
18637	15641	37	free	free	JJ
18637	15641	38	speech	speech	NN
18637	15641	39	and	and	CC
18637	15641	40	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	15641	41	are	be	VBP
18637	15641	42	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	15641	43	,	,	,
18637	15641	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15641	45	are	be	VBP
18637	15641	46	not	not	RB
18637	15641	47	in	in	IN
18637	15641	48	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15641	49	nature	nature	NN
18637	15641	50	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	15641	51	.	.	.
18637	15642	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15642	2	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15642	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	15642	4	subject	subject	JJ
18637	15642	5	to	to	IN
18637	15642	6	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	15642	7	,	,	,
18637	15642	8	if	if	IN
18637	15642	9	the	the	DT
18637	15642	10	particular	particular	JJ
18637	15642	11	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	15642	12	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	15642	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	15642	14	required	require	VBN
18637	15642	15	in	in	IN
18637	15642	16	order	order	NN
18637	15642	17	to	to	TO
18637	15642	18	protect	protect	VB
18637	15642	19	the	the	DT
18637	15642	20	state	state	NN
18637	15642	21	from	from	IN
18637	15642	22	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	15642	23	or	or	CC
18637	15642	24	from	from	IN
18637	15642	25	serious	serious	JJ
18637	15642	26	injury	injury	NN
18637	15642	27	,	,	,
18637	15642	28	political	political	JJ
18637	15642	29	,	,	,
18637	15642	30	economic	economic	JJ
18637	15642	31	or	or	CC
18637	15642	32	moral	moral	JJ
18637	15642	33	.	.	.
18637	15643	1	That	that	IN
18637	15643	2	the	the	DT
18637	15643	3	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	15643	4	which	which	WDT
18637	15643	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	15643	6	essential	essential	JJ
18637	15643	7	to	to	IN
18637	15643	8	a	a	DT
18637	15643	9	valid	valid	JJ
18637	15643	10	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	15643	11	does	do	VBZ
18637	15643	12	not	not	RB
18637	15643	13	exist	exist	VB
18637	15643	14	unless	unless	IN
18637	15643	15	speech	speech	NN
18637	15643	16	would	would	MD
18637	15643	17	produce	produce	VB
18637	15643	18	,	,	,
18637	15643	19	or	or	CC
18637	15643	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	15643	21	intended	intend	VBN
18637	15643	22	to	to	TO
18637	15643	23	produce	produce	VB
18637	15643	24	,	,	,
18637	15643	25	a	a	DT
18637	15643	26	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15643	27	and	and	CC
18637	15643	28	imminent	imminent	JJ
18637	15643	29	danger	danger	NN
18637	15643	30	of	of	IN
18637	15643	31	some	some	DT
18637	15643	32	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15643	33	evil	evil	NN
18637	15643	34	which	which	WDT
18637	15643	35	the	the	DT
18637	15643	36	State	State	NNP
18637	15643	37	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	15643	38	may	may	MD
18637	15643	39	seek	seek	VB
18637	15643	40	to	to	TO
18637	15643	41	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	15643	42	has	have	VBZ
18637	15643	43	been	be	VBN
18637	15643	44	settled	settle	VBN
18637	15643	45	.	.	.
18637	15644	1	_	_	NNP
18637	15644	2	See	See	NNP
18637	15644	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15644	4	Schenck	Schenck	NNP
18637	15644	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15644	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	15644	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15644	8	United	United	NNP
18637	15644	9	States	States	NNP
18637	15644	10	,	,	,
18637	15644	11	249	249	CD
18637	15644	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	15644	13	47	47	CD
18637	15644	14	,	,	,
18637	15644	15	52	52	CD
18637	15644	16	.	.	.
18637	15645	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15645	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15645	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15645	4	,	,	,
18637	15645	5	no	no	DT
18637	15645	6	danger	danger	NN
18637	15645	7	flowing	flow	VBG
18637	15645	8	from	from	IN
18637	15645	9	speech	speech	NN
18637	15645	10	can	can	MD
18637	15645	11	be	be	VB
18637	15645	12	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	15645	13	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15645	14	and	and	CC
18637	15645	15	present	present	JJ
18637	15645	16	,	,	,
18637	15645	17	unless	unless	IN
18637	15645	18	the	the	DT
18637	15645	19	incidence	incidence	NN
18637	15645	20	of	of	IN
18637	15645	21	the	the	DT
18637	15645	22	evil	evil	NN
18637	15645	23	apprehended	apprehend	VBN
18637	15645	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	15645	25	so	so	RB
18637	15645	26	imminent	imminent	JJ
18637	15645	27	that	that	IN
18637	15645	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15645	29	may	may	MD
18637	15645	30	befall	befall	VB
18637	15645	31	before	before	IN
18637	15645	32	there	there	EX
18637	15645	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	15645	34	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	15645	35	for	for	IN
18637	15645	36	full	full	JJ
18637	15645	37	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	15645	38	.	.	.
18637	15646	1	If	if	IN
18637	15646	2	there	there	EX
18637	15646	3	be	be	VBP
18637	15646	4	time	time	NN
18637	15646	5	to	to	TO
18637	15646	6	expose	expose	VB
18637	15646	7	through	through	IN
18637	15646	8	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	15646	9	the	the	DT
18637	15646	10	falsehood	falsehood	NN
18637	15646	11	and	and	CC
18637	15646	12	fallacies	fallacy	NNS
18637	15646	13	,	,	,
18637	15646	14	to	to	TO
18637	15646	15	avert	avert	VB
18637	15646	16	the	the	DT
18637	15646	17	evil	evil	NN
18637	15646	18	by	by	IN
18637	15646	19	the	the	DT
18637	15646	20	processes	process	NNS
18637	15646	21	of	of	IN
18637	15646	22	education	education	NN
18637	15646	23	,	,	,
18637	15646	24	the	the	DT
18637	15646	25	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	15646	26	to	to	TO
18637	15646	27	be	be	VB
18637	15646	28	applied	apply	VBN
18637	15646	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	15646	30	more	more	JJR
18637	15646	31	speech	speech	NN
18637	15646	32	,	,	,
18637	15646	33	not	not	RB
18637	15646	34	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	15646	35	silence	silence	NN
18637	15646	36	.	.	.
18637	15647	1	"	"	``
18637	15647	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15647	3	100	100	CD
18637	15647	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15647	5	ACCEPTANCE	ACCEPTANCE	NNP
18637	15647	6	OF	of	IN
18637	15647	7	THE	the	DT
18637	15647	8	CLEAR	CLEAR	NNP
18637	15647	9	AND	and	CC
18637	15647	10	PRESENT	PRESENT	NNP
18637	15647	11	DANGER	danger	NN
18637	15647	12	TEST	test	NN
18637	15647	13	Ten	ten	CD
18637	15647	14	years	year	NNS
18637	15647	15	later	later	RB
18637	15647	16	,	,	,
18637	15647	17	in	in	IN
18637	15647	18	Herndon	Herndon	NNP
18637	15647	19	_	_	NNP
18637	15647	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	15647	21	_	_	NNP
18637	15647	22	Lowry,[101	Lowry,[101	NNP
18637	15647	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15647	24	a	a	DT
18637	15647	25	narrowly	narrowly	RB
18637	15647	26	divided	divide	VBN
18637	15647	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15647	28	drew	draw	VBD
18637	15647	29	a	a	DT
18637	15647	30	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	15647	31	between	between	IN
18637	15647	32	the	the	DT
18637	15647	33	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	15647	34	by	by	IN
18637	15647	35	law	law	NN
18637	15647	36	of	of	IN
18637	15647	37	specific	specific	JJ
18637	15647	38	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	15647	39	which	which	WDT
18637	15647	40	the	the	DT
18637	15647	41	legislators	legislator	NNS
18637	15647	42	have	have	VBP
18637	15647	43	determined	determine	VBN
18637	15647	44	have	have	VBP
18637	15647	45	a	a	DT
18637	15647	46	"	"	``
18637	15647	47	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	15647	48	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	15647	49	"	"	''
18637	15647	50	to	to	TO
18637	15647	51	produce	produce	VB
18637	15647	52	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15647	53	evil	evil	NN
18637	15647	54	and	and	CC
18637	15647	55	the	the	DT
18637	15647	56	finding	finding	NN
18637	15647	57	by	by	IN
18637	15647	58	a	a	DT
18637	15647	59	jury	jury	NN
18637	15647	60	to	to	IN
18637	15647	61	that	that	DT
18637	15647	62	effect	effect	NN
18637	15647	63	,	,	,
18637	15647	64	and	and	CC
18637	15647	65	on	on	IN
18637	15647	66	this	this	DT
18637	15647	67	basis	basis	NN
18637	15647	68	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	15647	69	the	the	DT
18637	15647	70	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15647	71	of	of	IN
18637	15647	72	a	a	DT
18637	15647	73	communist	communist	JJ
18637	15647	74	organizer	organizer	NN
18637	15647	75	under	under	IN
18637	15647	76	a	a	DT
18637	15647	77	State	State	NNP
18637	15647	78	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15647	79	syndicalism	syndicalism	NN
18637	15647	80	statute	statute	NN
18637	15647	81	,	,	,
18637	15647	82	with	with	IN
18637	15647	83	the	the	DT
18637	15647	84	intimation	intimation	NN
18637	15647	85	that	that	IN
18637	15647	86	where	where	WRB
18637	15647	87	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15647	88	is	be	VBZ
18637	15647	89	left	leave	VBN
18637	15647	90	to	to	IN
18637	15647	91	a	a	DT
18637	15647	92	jury	jury	NN
18637	15647	93	to	to	TO
18637	15647	94	determine	determine	VB
18637	15647	95	whether	whether	IN
18637	15647	96	particular	particular	JJ
18637	15647	97	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	15647	98	are	be	VBP
18637	15647	99	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	15647	100	,	,	,
18637	15647	101	the	the	DT
18637	15647	102	test	test	NN
18637	15647	103	of	of	IN
18637	15647	104	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15647	105	and	and	CC
18637	15647	106	present	present	JJ
18637	15647	107	danger	danger	NN
18637	15647	108	must	must	MD
18637	15647	109	be	be	VB
18637	15647	110	applied	apply	VBN
18637	15647	111	.	.	.
18637	15648	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15648	2	102	102	CD
18637	15648	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15648	4	Finally	finally	RB
18637	15648	5	,	,	,
18637	15648	6	in	in	IN
18637	15648	7	Thornhill	Thornhill	NNP
18637	15648	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15648	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	15648	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15648	11	Alabama,[103	Alabama,[103	NNP
18637	15648	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15648	13	the	the	DT
18637	15648	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15648	15	went	go	VBD
18637	15648	16	the	the	DT
18637	15648	17	full	full	JJ
18637	15648	18	length	length	NN
18637	15648	19	in	in	IN
18637	15648	20	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
18637	15648	21	a	a	DT
18637	15648	22	State	State	NNP
18637	15648	23	law	law	NN
18637	15648	24	against	against	IN
18637	15648	25	picketing	picket	VBG
18637	15648	26	because[104	because[104	NN
18637	15648	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15648	28	"	"	``
18637	15648	29	*	*	NFP
18637	15648	30	*	*	NFP
18637	15648	31	*	*	NFP
18637	15648	32	no	no	UH
18637	15648	33	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15648	34	and	and	CC
18637	15648	35	present	present	JJ
18637	15648	36	danger	danger	NN
18637	15648	37	of	of	IN
18637	15648	38	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	15648	39	of	of	IN
18637	15648	40	life	life	NN
18637	15648	41	or	or	CC
18637	15648	42	property	property	NN
18637	15648	43	,	,	,
18637	15648	44	or	or	CC
18637	15648	45	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	15648	46	of	of	IN
18637	15648	47	the	the	DT
18637	15648	48	right	right	NN
18637	15648	49	of	of	IN
18637	15648	50	privacy	privacy	NN
18637	15648	51	,	,	,
18637	15648	52	or	or	CC
18637	15648	53	breach	breach	NN
18637	15648	54	of	of	IN
18637	15648	55	the	the	DT
18637	15648	56	peace	peace	NN
18637	15648	57	can	can	MD
18637	15648	58	be	be	VB
18637	15648	59	thought	think	VBN
18637	15648	60	to	to	TO
18637	15648	61	be	be	VB
18637	15648	62	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	15648	63	in	in	IN
18637	15648	64	the	the	DT
18637	15648	65	activities	activity	NNS
18637	15648	66	of	of	IN
18637	15648	67	every	every	DT
18637	15648	68	person	person	NN
18637	15648	69	who	who	WP
18637	15648	70	approaches	approach	VBZ
18637	15648	71	the	the	DT
18637	15648	72	premises	premise	NNS
18637	15648	73	of	of	IN
18637	15648	74	an	an	DT
18637	15648	75	employer	employer	NN
18637	15648	76	and	and	CC
18637	15648	77	publicizes	publicize	VBZ
18637	15648	78	the	the	DT
18637	15648	79	facts	fact	NNS
18637	15648	80	of	of	IN
18637	15648	81	a	a	DT
18637	15648	82	labor	labor	NN
18637	15648	83	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	15648	84	involving	involve	VBG
18637	15648	85	the	the	DT
18637	15648	86	latter	latter	JJ
18637	15648	87	.	.	.
18637	15648	88	"	"	''
18637	15649	1	The	the	DT
18637	15649	2	same	same	JJ
18637	15649	3	term	term	NN
18637	15649	4	,	,	,
18637	15649	5	again	again	RB
18637	15649	6	invoking	invoke	VBG
18637	15649	7	the	the	DT
18637	15649	8	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15649	9	and	and	CC
18637	15649	10	present	present	JJ
18637	15649	11	danger	danger	NN
18637	15649	12	formula	formula	NN
18637	15649	13	,	,	,
18637	15649	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15649	15	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	15649	16	a	a	DT
18637	15649	17	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15649	18	for	for	IN
18637	15649	19	the	the	DT
18637	15649	20	common	common	JJ
18637	15649	21	law	law	NN
18637	15649	22	offense	offense	NN
18637	15649	23	of	of	IN
18637	15649	24	inciting	incite	VBG
18637	15649	25	a	a	DT
18637	15649	26	breach	breach	NN
18637	15649	27	of	of	IN
18637	15649	28	the	the	DT
18637	15649	29	peace	peace	NN
18637	15649	30	by	by	IN
18637	15649	31	playing	play	VBG
18637	15649	32	,	,	,
18637	15649	33	on	on	IN
18637	15649	34	a	a	DT
18637	15649	35	public	public	JJ
18637	15649	36	street	street	NN
18637	15649	37	,	,	,
18637	15649	38	a	a	DT
18637	15649	39	phonograph	phonograph	NN
18637	15649	40	record	record	NN
18637	15649	41	attacking	attack	VBG
18637	15649	42	a	a	DT
18637	15649	43	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15649	44	sect	sect	NN
18637	15649	45	.	.	.
18637	15650	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15650	2	105	105	CD
18637	15650	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15650	4	THE	THE	NNP
18637	15650	5	POLICE	police	NN
18637	15650	6	POWER	POWER	NNS
18637	15650	7	AND	and	CC
18637	15650	8	CLEAR	CLEAR	NNP
18637	15650	9	AND	and	CC
18637	15650	10	PRESENT	PRESENT	NNP
18637	15650	11	DANGER	danger	NN
18637	15650	12	Public	public	NN
18637	15650	13	Order	order	NN
18637	15650	14	Prior	prior	RB
18637	15650	15	to	to	IN
18637	15650	16	the	the	DT
18637	15650	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15650	18	's	's	POS
18637	15650	19	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	15650	20	of	of	IN
18637	15650	21	the	the	DT
18637	15650	22	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15650	23	and	and	CC
18637	15650	24	present	present	JJ
18637	15650	25	danger	danger	NN
18637	15650	26	test	test	NN
18637	15650	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15650	28	had	have	VBD
18637	15650	29	held	hold	VBN
18637	15650	30	that	that	IN
18637	15650	31	while	while	IN
18637	15650	32	on	on	IN
18637	15650	33	the	the	DT
18637	15650	34	one	one	CD
18637	15650	35	hand	hand	NN
18637	15650	36	,	,	,
18637	15650	37	peaceful	peaceful	JJ
18637	15650	38	and	and	CC
18637	15650	39	orderly	orderly	JJ
18637	15650	40	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	15650	41	to	to	IN
18637	15650	42	government	government	NN
18637	15650	43	by	by	IN
18637	15650	44	legal	legal	JJ
18637	15650	45	means	mean	NNS
18637	15650	46	may	may	MD
18637	15650	47	not	not	RB
18637	15650	48	be	be	VB
18637	15650	49	inhibited	inhibit	VBN
18637	15650	50	,	,	,
18637	15650	51	and	and	CC
18637	15650	52	that	that	IN
18637	15650	53	the	the	DT
18637	15650	54	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15650	55	insures	insure	VBZ
18637	15650	56	the	the	DT
18637	15650	57	"	"	``
18637	15650	58	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	15650	59	of	of	IN
18637	15650	60	the	the	DT
18637	15650	61	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	15650	62	for	for	IN
18637	15650	63	free	free	JJ
18637	15650	64	political	political	JJ
18637	15650	65	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	15650	66	to	to	IN
18637	15650	67	the	the	DT
18637	15650	68	end	end	NN
18637	15650	69	that	that	WDT
18637	15650	70	government	government	NN
18637	15650	71	may	may	MD
18637	15650	72	be	be	VB
18637	15650	73	responsive	responsive	JJ
18637	15650	74	to	to	IN
18637	15650	75	the	the	DT
18637	15650	76	will	will	NN
18637	15650	77	of	of	IN
18637	15650	78	the	the	DT
18637	15650	79	people	people	NNS
18637	15650	80	and	and	CC
18637	15650	81	that	that	IN
18637	15650	82	changes	change	NNS
18637	15650	83	may	may	MD
18637	15650	84	be	be	VB
18637	15650	85	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	15650	86	by	by	IN
18637	15650	87	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	15650	88	means,"[106	means,"[106	NN
18637	15650	89	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15650	90	yet	yet	CC
18637	15650	91	on	on	IN
18637	15650	92	the	the	DT
18637	15650	93	other	other	JJ
18637	15650	94	hand	hand	NN
18637	15650	95	,	,	,
18637	15650	96	the	the	DT
18637	15650	97	State	State	NNP
18637	15650	98	may	may	MD
18637	15650	99	punish	punish	VB
18637	15650	100	those	those	DT
18637	15650	101	who	who	WP
18637	15650	102	abuse	abuse	VBP
18637	15650	103	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15650	104	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15650	105	of	of	IN
18637	15650	106	speech	speech	NN
18637	15650	107	by	by	IN
18637	15650	108	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	15650	109	tending	tend	VBG
18637	15650	110	to	to	TO
18637	15650	111	incite	incite	VB
18637	15650	112	to	to	IN
18637	15650	113	crime,[107	crime,[107	NNP
18637	15650	114	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15650	115	or	or	CC
18637	15650	116	to	to	TO
18637	15650	117	endanger	endanger	VB
18637	15650	118	the	the	DT
18637	15650	119	foundations	foundation	NNS
18637	15650	120	of	of	IN
18637	15650	121	organized	organize	VBN
18637	15650	122	government	government	NN
18637	15650	123	or	or	CC
18637	15650	124	to	to	TO
18637	15650	125	threaten	threaten	VB
18637	15650	126	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15650	127	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	15650	128	by	by	IN
18637	15650	129	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	15650	130	means	mean	NNS
18637	15650	131	.	.	.
18637	15651	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15651	2	108	108	CD
18637	15651	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15651	4	The	the	DT
18637	15651	5	impact	impact	NN
18637	15651	6	of	of	IN
18637	15651	7	the	the	DT
18637	15651	8	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15651	9	and	and	CC
18637	15651	10	present	present	JJ
18637	15651	11	danger	danger	NN
18637	15651	12	test	test	NN
18637	15651	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	15651	14	these	these	DT
18637	15651	15	principles	principle	NNS
18637	15651	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	15651	17	well	well	RB
18637	15651	18	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
18637	15651	19	by	by	IN
18637	15651	20	a	a	DT
18637	15651	21	holding	holding	NN
18637	15651	22	in	in	IN
18637	15651	23	1949	1949	CD
18637	15651	24	by	by	IN
18637	15651	25	a	a	DT
18637	15651	26	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	15651	27	divided	divide	VBN
18637	15651	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15651	29	,	,	,
18637	15651	30	that	that	IN
18637	15651	31	a	a	DT
18637	15651	32	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	15651	33	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	15651	34	which	which	WDT
18637	15651	35	,	,	,
18637	15651	36	as	as	IN
18637	15651	37	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	15651	38	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	15651	39	,	,	,
18637	15651	40	was	be	VBD
18637	15651	41	held	hold	VBN
18637	15651	42	to	to	TO
18637	15651	43	permit	permit	VB
18637	15651	44	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15651	45	for	for	IN
18637	15651	46	breach	breach	NN
18637	15651	47	of	of	IN
18637	15651	48	the	the	DT
18637	15651	49	peace	peace	NN
18637	15651	50	for	for	IN
18637	15651	51	speech	speech	NN
18637	15651	52	which	which	WDT
18637	15651	53	"	"	``
18637	15651	54	stirs	stir	VBZ
18637	15651	55	the	the	DT
18637	15651	56	public	public	NN
18637	15651	57	to	to	IN
18637	15651	58	anger	anger	NN
18637	15651	59	,	,	,
18637	15651	60	invites	invite	VBZ
18637	15651	61	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	15651	62	,	,	,
18637	15651	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15651	64	or	or	CC
18637	15651	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15651	66	brings	bring	VBZ
18637	15651	67	about	about	RP
18637	15651	68	a	a	DT
18637	15651	69	condition	condition	NN
18637	15651	70	of	of	IN
18637	15651	71	unrest	unrest	NN
18637	15651	72	"	"	''
18637	15651	73	was	be	VBD
18637	15651	74	an	an	DT
18637	15651	75	undue	undue	JJ
18637	15651	76	and	and	CC
18637	15651	77	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	15651	78	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	15651	79	on	on	IN
18637	15651	80	the	the	DT
18637	15651	81	right	right	NN
18637	15651	82	of	of	IN
18637	15651	83	free	free	JJ
18637	15651	84	speech	speech	NN
18637	15651	85	.	.	.
18637	15652	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15652	2	109	109	CD
18637	15652	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15652	4	Reversing	reverse	VBG
18637	15652	5	a	a	DT
18637	15652	6	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15652	7	under	under	IN
18637	15652	8	the	the	DT
18637	15652	9	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	15652	10	,	,	,
18637	15652	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15652	12	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	15652	13	wrote	write	VBD
18637	15652	14	:	:	:
18637	15652	15	"	"	``
18637	15652	16	A	a	DT
18637	15652	17	function	function	NN
18637	15652	18	of	of	IN
18637	15652	19	free	free	JJ
18637	15652	20	speech	speech	NN
18637	15652	21	under	under	IN
18637	15652	22	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15652	23	system	system	NN
18637	15652	24	of	of	IN
18637	15652	25	government	government	NN
18637	15652	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	15652	27	to	to	TO
18637	15652	28	invite	invite	VB
18637	15652	29	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	15652	30	.	.	.
18637	15653	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15653	2	may	may	MD
18637	15653	3	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	15653	4	best	well	RBS
18637	15653	5	serve	serve	VB
18637	15653	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15653	7	high	high	JJ
18637	15653	8	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15653	9	when	when	WRB
18637	15653	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15653	11	induces	induce	VBZ
18637	15653	12	a	a	DT
18637	15653	13	condition	condition	NN
18637	15653	14	of	of	IN
18637	15653	15	unrest	unrest	NN
18637	15653	16	,	,	,
18637	15653	17	creates	create	VBZ
18637	15653	18	dissatisfaction	dissatisfaction	NN
18637	15653	19	with	with	IN
18637	15653	20	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	15653	21	as	as	IN
18637	15653	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15653	23	are	be	VBP
18637	15653	24	,	,	,
18637	15653	25	or	or	CC
18637	15653	26	even	even	RB
18637	15653	27	stirs	stir	VBZ
18637	15653	28	people	people	NNS
18637	15653	29	to	to	IN
18637	15653	30	anger	anger	NN
18637	15653	31	.	.	.
18637	15654	1	Speech	speech	NN
18637	15654	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15654	3	often	often	RB
18637	15654	4	provocative	provocative	JJ
18637	15654	5	and	and	CC
18637	15654	6	challenging	challenging	JJ
18637	15654	7	.	.	.
18637	15655	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15655	2	may	may	MD
18637	15655	3	strike	strike	VB
18637	15655	4	at	at	IN
18637	15655	5	prejudices	prejudice	NNS
18637	15655	6	and	and	CC
18637	15655	7	preconceptions	preconception	NNS
18637	15655	8	and	and	CC
18637	15655	9	have	have	VBP
18637	15655	10	profound	profound	VBN
18637	15655	11	unsettling	unsettling	JJ
18637	15655	12	effects	effect	NNS
18637	15655	13	as	as	IN
18637	15655	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15655	15	presses	press	VBZ
18637	15655	16	for	for	IN
18637	15655	17	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	15655	18	of	of	IN
18637	15655	19	an	an	DT
18637	15655	20	idea	idea	NN
18637	15655	21	.	.	.
18637	15656	1	That	that	DT
18637	15656	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15656	3	why	why	WRB
18637	15656	4	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15656	5	of	of	IN
18637	15656	6	speech	speech	NN
18637	15656	7	,	,	,
18637	15656	8	though	though	IN
18637	15656	9	not	not	RB
18637	15656	10	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	15656	11	*	*	NFP
18637	15656	12	*	*	NFP
18637	15656	13	*	*	NFP
18637	15656	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	15656	15	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	15656	16	protected	protect	VBN
18637	15656	17	against	against	IN
18637	15656	18	censorship	censorship	NN
18637	15656	19	or	or	CC
18637	15656	20	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15656	21	,	,	,
18637	15656	22	unless	unless	IN
18637	15656	23	shown	show	VBN
18637	15656	24	likely	likely	RB
18637	15656	25	to	to	TO
18637	15656	26	produce	produce	VB
18637	15656	27	a	a	DT
18637	15656	28	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15656	29	and	and	CC
18637	15656	30	present	present	JJ
18637	15656	31	danger	danger	NN
18637	15656	32	of	of	IN
18637	15656	33	a	a	DT
18637	15656	34	serious	serious	JJ
18637	15656	35	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15656	36	evil	evil	NN
18637	15656	37	that	that	WDT
18637	15656	38	rises	rise	VBZ
18637	15656	39	far	far	RB
18637	15656	40	above	above	IN
18637	15656	41	public	public	JJ
18637	15656	42	inconvenience	inconvenience	NN
18637	15656	43	,	,	,
18637	15656	44	annoyance	annoyance	NN
18637	15656	45	,	,	,
18637	15656	46	or	or	CC
18637	15656	47	unrest	unrest	NN
18637	15656	48	.	.	.
18637	15657	1	"	"	``
18637	15657	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15657	3	110	110	CD
18637	15657	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15657	5	Finding	find	VBG
18637	15657	6	that	that	IN
18637	15657	7	the	the	DT
18637	15657	8	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	15657	9	as	as	IN
18637	15657	10	thus	thus	RB
18637	15657	11	construed	construe	VBN
18637	15657	12	was	be	VBD
18637	15657	13	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	15657	14	,	,	,
18637	15657	15	the	the	DT
18637	15657	16	majority	majority	NN
18637	15657	17	did	do	VBD
18637	15657	18	not	not	RB
18637	15657	19	enter	enter	VB
18637	15657	20	into	into	IN
18637	15657	21	a	a	DT
18637	15657	22	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	15657	23	of	of	IN
18637	15657	24	the	the	DT
18637	15657	25	facts	fact	NNS
18637	15657	26	of	of	IN
18637	15657	27	the	the	DT
18637	15657	28	particular	particular	JJ
18637	15657	29	case	case	NN
18637	15657	30	.	.	.
18637	15658	1	Dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	15658	2	,	,	,
18637	15658	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15658	4	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	15658	5	dwelt	dwell	VBD
18637	15658	6	at	at	IN
18637	15658	7	length	length	NN
18637	15658	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	15658	9	the	the	DT
18637	15658	10	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	15658	11	which	which	WDT
18637	15658	12	showed	show	VBD
18637	15658	13	that	that	IN
18637	15658	14	a	a	DT
18637	15658	15	riot	riot	NN
18637	15658	16	had	have	VBD
18637	15658	17	actually	actually	RB
18637	15658	18	occurred	occur	VBN
18637	15658	19	and	and	CC
18637	15658	20	that	that	IN
18637	15658	21	the	the	DT
18637	15658	22	speech	speech	NN
18637	15658	23	in	in	IN
18637	15658	24	question	question	NN
18637	15658	25	had	have	VBD
18637	15658	26	in	in	IN
18637	15658	27	fact	fact	NN
18637	15658	28	provoked	provoke	VBD
18637	15658	29	a	a	DT
18637	15658	30	hostile	hostile	JJ
18637	15658	31	mob	mob	NN
18637	15658	32	,	,	,
18637	15658	33	incited	incite	VBD
18637	15658	34	a	a	DT
18637	15658	35	friendly	friendly	JJ
18637	15658	36	one	one	NN
18637	15658	37	,	,	,
18637	15658	38	and	and	CC
18637	15658	39	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	15658	40	violence	violence	NN
18637	15658	41	between	between	IN
18637	15658	42	the	the	DT
18637	15658	43	two	two	CD
18637	15658	44	.	.	.
18637	15659	1	Conceding	concede	VBG
18637	15659	2	the	the	DT
18637	15659	3	premises	premise	NNS
18637	15659	4	of	of	IN
18637	15659	5	the	the	DT
18637	15659	6	majority	majority	NN
18637	15659	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15659	8	,	,	,
18637	15659	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15659	10	argued	argue	VBD
18637	15659	11	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	15659	12	that	that	DT
18637	15659	13	:	:	:
18637	15659	14	"	"	``
18637	15659	15	Because	because	IN
18637	15659	16	a	a	DT
18637	15659	17	subject	subject	NN
18637	15659	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	15659	19	legally	legally	RB
18637	15659	20	arguable	arguable	JJ
18637	15659	21	,	,	,
18637	15659	22	however	however	RB
18637	15659	23	,	,	,
18637	15659	24	does	do	VBZ
18637	15659	25	not	not	RB
18637	15659	26	mean	mean	VB
18637	15659	27	that	that	IN
18637	15659	28	public	public	JJ
18637	15659	29	sentiment	sentiment	NN
18637	15659	30	will	will	MD
18637	15659	31	be	be	VB
18637	15659	32	patient	patient	JJ
18637	15659	33	of	of	IN
18637	15659	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15659	35	advocacy	advocacy	NN
18637	15659	36	at	at	IN
18637	15659	37	all	all	DT
18637	15659	38	times	time	NNS
18637	15659	39	and	and	CC
18637	15659	40	in	in	IN
18637	15659	41	all	all	DT
18637	15659	42	manners	manner	NNS
18637	15659	43	.	.	.
18637	15660	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15660	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15660	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15660	4	A	a	DT
18637	15660	5	great	great	JJ
18637	15660	6	number	number	NN
18637	15660	7	of	of	IN
18637	15660	8	people	people	NNS
18637	15660	9	do	do	VBP
18637	15660	10	not	not	RB
18637	15660	11	agree	agree	VB
18637	15660	12	that	that	IN
18637	15660	13	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	15660	14	to	to	IN
18637	15660	15	America	America	NNP
18637	15660	16	of	of	IN
18637	15660	17	communism	communism	NN
18637	15660	18	or	or	CC
18637	15660	19	fascism	fascism	NN
18637	15660	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	15660	21	even	even	RB
18637	15660	22	debatable	debatable	JJ
18637	15660	23	.	.	.
18637	15661	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	15661	2	many	many	JJ
18637	15661	3	speeches	speech	NNS
18637	15661	4	,	,	,
18637	15661	5	such	such	JJ
18637	15661	6	as	as	IN
18637	15661	7	that	that	DT
18637	15661	8	of	of	IN
18637	15661	9	Terminiello	Terminiello	NNP
18637	15661	10	,	,	,
18637	15661	11	may	may	MD
18637	15661	12	be	be	VB
18637	15661	13	legally	legally	RB
18637	15661	14	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	15661	15	but	but	CC
18637	15661	16	may	may	MD
18637	15661	17	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	15661	18	in	in	IN
18637	15661	19	some	some	DT
18637	15661	20	surroundings	surrounding	NNS
18637	15661	21	be	be	VB
18637	15661	22	a	a	DT
18637	15661	23	menace	menace	NN
18637	15661	24	to	to	IN
18637	15661	25	peace	peace	NN
18637	15661	26	and	and	CC
18637	15661	27	order	order	NN
18637	15661	28	.	.	.
18637	15662	1	When	when	WRB
18637	15662	2	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	15662	3	show	show	VBP
18637	15662	4	the	the	DT
18637	15662	5	speaker	speaker	NN
18637	15662	6	that	that	IN
18637	15662	7	this	this	DT
18637	15662	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	15662	9	the	the	DT
18637	15662	10	case	case	NN
18637	15662	11	,	,	,
18637	15662	12	as	as	IN
18637	15662	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15662	14	did	do	VBD
18637	15662	15	here	here	RB
18637	15662	16	,	,	,
18637	15662	17	there	there	EX
18637	15662	18	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	15662	19	comes	come	VBZ
18637	15662	20	a	a	DT
18637	15662	21	point	point	NN
18637	15662	22	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	15662	23	which	which	WDT
18637	15662	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15662	25	can	can	MD
18637	15662	26	not	not	RB
18637	15662	27	indulge	indulge	VB
18637	15662	28	in	in	IN
18637	15662	29	provocations	provocation	NNS
18637	15662	30	to	to	IN
18637	15662	31	violence	violence	NN
18637	15662	32	without	without	IN
18637	15662	33	being	be	VBG
18637	15662	34	answerable	answerable	JJ
18637	15662	35	to	to	IN
18637	15662	36	society	society	NN
18637	15662	37	.	.	.
18637	15663	1	"	"	``
18637	15663	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15663	3	111	111	CD
18637	15663	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15663	5	Early	early	RB
18637	15663	6	in	in	IN
18637	15663	7	1951	1951	CD
18637	15663	8	the	the	DT
18637	15663	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15663	10	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15663	11	endorsed	endorse	VBD
18637	15663	12	this	this	DT
18637	15663	13	position	position	NN
18637	15663	14	in	in	IN
18637	15663	15	Feiner	Feiner	NNP
18637	15663	16	_	_	NNP
18637	15663	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	15663	18	_	_	NNP
18637	15663	19	New	New	NNP
18637	15663	20	York	York	NNP
18637	15663	21	.	.	.
18637	15664	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15664	2	112	112	CD
18637	15664	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15664	4	Here	here	RB
18637	15664	5	was	be	VBD
18637	15664	6	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	15664	7	the	the	DT
18637	15664	8	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15664	9	of	of	IN
18637	15664	10	a	a	DT
18637	15664	11	speaker	speaker	NN
18637	15664	12	who	who	WP
18637	15664	13	in	in	IN
18637	15664	14	addressing	address	VBG
18637	15664	15	a	a	DT
18637	15664	16	crowd	crowd	NN
18637	15664	17	including	include	VBG
18637	15664	18	a	a	DT
18637	15664	19	number	number	NN
18637	15664	20	of	of	IN
18637	15664	21	Negroes	Negroes	NNP
18637	15664	22	,	,	,
18637	15664	23	through	through	IN
18637	15664	24	a	a	DT
18637	15664	25	public	public	JJ
18637	15664	26	address	address	NN
18637	15664	27	system	system	NN
18637	15664	28	set	set	VBN
18637	15664	29	up	up	RP
18637	15664	30	on	on	IN
18637	15664	31	the	the	DT
18637	15664	32	sidewalk	sidewalk	NN
18637	15664	33	,	,	,
18637	15664	34	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	15664	35	that	that	IN
18637	15664	36	the	the	DT
18637	15664	37	Negroes	Negroes	NNPS
18637	15664	38	"	"	``
18637	15664	39	should	should	MD
18637	15664	40	rise	rise	VB
18637	15664	41	up	up	RP
18637	15664	42	in	in	IN
18637	15664	43	arms	arm	NNS
18637	15664	44	and	and	CC
18637	15664	45	fight	fight	VB
18637	15664	46	for	for	IN
18637	15664	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15664	48	rights	right	NNS
18637	15664	49	,	,	,
18637	15664	50	"	"	''
18637	15664	51	called	call	VBD
18637	15664	52	a	a	DT
18637	15664	53	number	number	NN
18637	15664	54	of	of	IN
18637	15664	55	public	public	JJ
18637	15664	56	officials	official	NNS
18637	15664	57	,	,	,
18637	15664	58	including	include	VBG
18637	15664	59	the	the	DT
18637	15664	60	President	President	NNP
18637	15664	61	,	,	,
18637	15664	62	"	"	``
18637	15664	63	bums	bum	NNS
18637	15664	64	,	,	,
18637	15664	65	"	"	''
18637	15664	66	and	and	CC
18637	15664	67	ignored	ignore	VBD
18637	15664	68	two	two	CD
18637	15664	69	police	police	NN
18637	15664	70	requests	request	NNS
18637	15664	71	to	to	TO
18637	15664	72	stop	stop	VB
18637	15664	73	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15664	74	.	.	.
18637	15665	1	The	the	DT
18637	15665	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15665	3	took	take	VBD
18637	15665	4	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	15665	5	of	of	IN
18637	15665	6	the	the	DT
18637	15665	7	findings	finding	NNS
18637	15665	8	by	by	IN
18637	15665	9	the	the	DT
18637	15665	10	trial	trial	NN
18637	15665	11	court	court	NN
18637	15665	12	and	and	CC
18637	15665	13	two	two	CD
18637	15665	14	reviewing	review	VBG
18637	15665	15	State	State	NNP
18637	15665	16	courts	court	NNS
18637	15665	17	that	that	WDT
18637	15665	18	danger	danger	NN
18637	15665	19	to	to	IN
18637	15665	20	public	public	JJ
18637	15665	21	order	order	NN
18637	15665	22	was	be	VBD
18637	15665	23	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	15665	24	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	15665	25	.	.	.
18637	15666	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15666	2	113	113	CD
18637	15666	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15666	4	Public	Public	NNP
18637	15666	5	Morals	Morals	NNPS
18637	15666	6	But	but	CC
18637	15666	7	the	the	DT
18637	15666	8	police	police	NN
18637	15666	9	power	power	NN
18637	15666	10	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	15666	11	also	also	RB
18637	15666	12	to	to	IN
18637	15666	13	the	the	DT
18637	15666	14	public	public	JJ
18637	15666	15	morals	moral	NNS
18637	15666	16	.	.	.
18637	15667	1	In	in	IN
18637	15667	2	Winters	Winters	NNP
18637	15667	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15667	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	15667	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15667	6	New	New	NNP
18637	15667	7	York[114	York[114	NNP
18637	15667	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15667	9	the	the	DT
18637	15667	10	question	question	NN
18637	15667	11	at	at	IN
18637	15667	12	issue	issue	NN
18637	15667	13	was	be	VBD
18637	15667	14	the	the	DT
18637	15667	15	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	15667	16	of	of	IN
18637	15667	17	a	a	DT
18637	15667	18	State	State	NNP
18637	15667	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	15667	20	making	make	VBG
18637	15667	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15667	22	an	an	DT
18637	15667	23	offense	offense	NN
18637	15667	24	"	"	''
18637	15667	25	to	to	TO
18637	15667	26	print	print	VB
18637	15667	27	,	,	,
18637	15667	28	publish	publish	VB
18637	15667	29	,	,	,
18637	15667	30	or	or	CC
18637	15667	31	distribute	distribute	VB
18637	15667	32	,	,	,
18637	15667	33	or	or	CC
18637	15667	34	to	to	TO
18637	15667	35	possess	possess	VB
18637	15667	36	with	with	IN
18637	15667	37	intent	intent	NN
18637	15667	38	to	to	TO
18637	15667	39	distribute	distribute	VB
18637	15667	40	,	,	,
18637	15667	41	any	any	DT
18637	15667	42	printed	print	VBN
18637	15667	43	matter	matter	NN
18637	15667	44	principally	principally	RB
18637	15667	45	made	make	VBN
18637	15667	46	up	up	RP
18637	15667	47	of	of	IN
18637	15667	48	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15667	49	views	view	NNS
18637	15667	50	,	,	,
18637	15667	51	police	police	NN
18637	15667	52	reports	report	NNS
18637	15667	53	,	,	,
18637	15667	54	or	or	CC
18637	15667	55	accounts	account	NNS
18637	15667	56	of	of	IN
18637	15667	57	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15667	58	deeds	deed	NNS
18637	15667	59	,	,	,
18637	15667	60	or	or	CC
18637	15667	61	pictures	picture	NNS
18637	15667	62	,	,	,
18637	15667	63	or	or	CC
18637	15667	64	stories	story	NNS
18637	15667	65	of	of	IN
18637	15667	66	deeds	deed	NNS
18637	15667	67	of	of	IN
18637	15667	68	bloodshed	bloodshed	NN
18637	15667	69	,	,	,
18637	15667	70	lust	lust	NN
18637	15667	71	or	or	CC
18637	15667	72	crime	crime	NN
18637	15667	73	,	,	,
18637	15667	74	"	"	''
18637	15667	75	and	and	CC
18637	15667	76	construed	construe	VBN
18637	15667	77	by	by	IN
18637	15667	78	the	the	DT
18637	15667	79	State	State	NNP
18637	15667	80	courts	court	NNS
18637	15667	81	"	"	''
18637	15667	82	as	as	IN
18637	15667	83	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	15667	84	such	such	JJ
18637	15667	85	massing	massing	NN
18637	15667	86	of	of	IN
18637	15667	87	accounts	account	NNS
18637	15667	88	of	of	IN
18637	15667	89	deeds	deed	NNS
18637	15667	90	of	of	IN
18637	15667	91	bloodshed	bloodshed	NN
18637	15667	92	and	and	CC
18637	15667	93	lust	lust	VB
18637	15667	94	as	as	IN
18637	15667	95	to	to	TO
18637	15667	96	incite	incite	VB
18637	15667	97	to	to	IN
18637	15667	98	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	15667	99	against	against	IN
18637	15667	100	the	the	DT
18637	15667	101	person	person	NN
18637	15667	102	.	.	.
18637	15667	103	"	"	''
18637	15668	1	A	a	DT
18637	15668	2	divided	divide	VBN
18637	15668	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15668	4	,	,	,
18637	15668	5	6	6	CD
18637	15668	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15668	7	to	to	IN
18637	15668	8	3	3	CD
18637	15668	9	,	,	,
18637	15668	10	following	follow	VBG
18637	15668	11	the	the	DT
18637	15668	12	third	third	JJ
18637	15668	13	argument	argument	NN
18637	15668	14	of	of	IN
18637	15668	15	the	the	DT
18637	15668	16	case	case	NN
18637	15668	17	before	before	IN
18637	15668	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15668	19	,	,	,
18637	15668	20	set	set	VBD
18637	15668	21	the	the	DT
18637	15668	22	act	act	NN
18637	15668	23	aside	aside	RB
18637	15668	24	on	on	IN
18637	15668	25	the	the	DT
18637	15668	26	ground	ground	NN
18637	15668	27	that	that	IN
18637	15668	28	,	,	,
18637	15668	29	as	as	IN
18637	15668	30	construed	construe	VBN
18637	15668	31	,	,	,
18637	15668	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15668	33	did	do	VBD
18637	15668	34	not	not	RB
18637	15668	35	define	define	VB
18637	15668	36	the	the	DT
18637	15668	37	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	15668	38	acts	act	NNS
18637	15668	39	in	in	IN
18637	15668	40	such	such	PDT
18637	15668	41	a	a	DT
18637	15668	42	way	way	NN
18637	15668	43	as	as	IN
18637	15668	44	to	to	TO
18637	15668	45	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	15668	46	those	those	DT
18637	15668	47	which	which	WDT
18637	15668	48	are	be	VBP
18637	15668	49	a	a	DT
18637	15668	50	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	15668	51	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15668	52	of	of	IN
18637	15668	53	the	the	DT
18637	15668	54	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15668	55	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15668	56	of	of	IN
18637	15668	57	the	the	DT
18637	15668	58	press	press	NN
18637	15668	59	;	;	:
18637	15668	60	and	and	CC
18637	15668	61	further	far	RBR
18637	15668	62	,	,	,
18637	15668	63	that	that	IN
18637	15668	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15668	65	failed	fail	VBD
18637	15668	66	to	to	TO
18637	15668	67	set	set	VB
18637	15668	68	up	up	RP
18637	15668	69	an	an	DT
18637	15668	70	ascertainable	ascertainable	JJ
18637	15668	71	standard	standard	NN
18637	15668	72	of	of	IN
18637	15668	73	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	15668	74	.	.	.
18637	15669	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15669	2	115	115	CD
18637	15669	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15669	4	A	a	DT
18637	15669	5	few	few	JJ
18637	15669	6	weeks	week	NNS
18637	15669	7	earlier	early	RBR
18637	15669	8	the	the	DT
18637	15669	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15669	10	had	have	VBD
18637	15669	11	vacated	vacate	VBN
18637	15669	12	a	a	DT
18637	15669	13	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	15669	14	of	of	IN
18637	15669	15	the	the	DT
18637	15669	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15669	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15669	18	of	of	IN
18637	15669	19	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	15669	20	affirming	affirming	NN
18637	15669	21	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	15669	22	on	on	IN
18637	15669	23	a	a	DT
18637	15669	24	charge	charge	NN
18637	15669	25	of	of	IN
18637	15669	26	conspiring	conspire	VBG
18637	15669	27	to	to	TO
18637	15669	28	"	"	``
18637	15669	29	commit	commit	VB
18637	15669	30	acts	act	VBZ
18637	15669	31	injurious	injurious	JJ
18637	15669	32	to	to	IN
18637	15669	33	public	public	JJ
18637	15669	34	morals	moral	NNS
18637	15669	35	"	"	''
18637	15669	36	by	by	IN
18637	15669	37	counseling	counseling	NN
18637	15669	38	,	,	,
18637	15669	39	advising	advise	VBG
18637	15669	40	and	and	CC
18637	15669	41	practicing	practice	VBG
18637	15669	42	plural	plural	JJ
18637	15669	43	marriage	marriage	NN
18637	15669	44	.	.	.
18637	15670	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15670	2	116	116	CD
18637	15670	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15670	4	Four	four	CD
18637	15670	5	members	member	NNS
18637	15670	6	of	of	IN
18637	15670	7	the	the	DT
18637	15670	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15670	9	thought	think	VBD
18637	15670	10	that	that	IN
18637	15670	11	the	the	DT
18637	15670	12	cause	cause	NN
18637	15670	13	should	should	MD
18637	15670	14	be	be	VB
18637	15670	15	remanded	remand	VBN
18637	15670	16	in	in	IN
18637	15670	17	order	order	NN
18637	15670	18	to	to	TO
18637	15670	19	give	give	VB
18637	15670	20	the	the	DT
18637	15670	21	State	State	NNP
18637	15670	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15670	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15670	24	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	15670	25	to	to	TO
18637	15670	26	construe	construe	VB
18637	15670	27	that	that	DT
18637	15670	28	statute	statute	NN
18637	15670	29	and	and	CC
18637	15670	30	a	a	DT
18637	15670	31	fifth	fifth	NN
18637	15670	32	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	15670	33	with	with	IN
18637	15670	34	this	this	DT
18637	15670	35	result	result	NN
18637	15670	36	without	without	IN
18637	15670	37	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15670	38	.	.	.
18637	15671	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15671	2	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	15671	3	,	,	,
18637	15671	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15671	5	for	for	IN
18637	15671	6	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15671	7	and	and	CC
18637	15671	8	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15671	9	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	15671	10	and	and	CC
18637	15671	11	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	15671	12	,	,	,
18637	15671	13	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	15671	14	on	on	IN
18637	15671	15	the	the	DT
18637	15671	16	ground	ground	NN
18637	15671	17	that	that	IN
18637	15671	18	the	the	DT
18637	15671	19	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	15671	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15671	21	had	have	VBD
18637	15671	22	already	already	RB
18637	15671	23	construed	construe	VBN
18637	15671	24	the	the	DT
18637	15671	25	statute	statute	NN
18637	15671	26	to	to	TO
18637	15671	27	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	15671	28	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15671	29	for	for	IN
18637	15671	30	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	15671	31	the	the	DT
18637	15671	32	right	right	NN
18637	15671	33	of	of	IN
18637	15671	34	free	free	JJ
18637	15671	35	speech	speech	NN
18637	15671	36	.	.	.
18637	15672	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15672	2	said	say	VBD
18637	15672	3	:	:	:
18637	15672	4	"	"	``
18637	15672	5	The	the	DT
18637	15672	6	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	15672	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	15672	8	was	be	VBD
18637	15672	9	construed	construe	VBN
18637	15672	10	to	to	TO
18637	15672	11	proscribe	proscribe	VB
18637	15672	12	any	any	DT
18637	15672	13	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	15672	14	to	to	TO
18637	15672	15	advocate	advocate	VB
18637	15672	16	the	the	DT
18637	15672	17	practice	practice	NN
18637	15672	18	of	of	IN
18637	15672	19	polygamy	polygamy	NN
18637	15672	20	.	.	.
18637	15673	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	15673	2	the	the	DT
18637	15673	3	line	line	NN
18637	15673	4	was	be	VBD
18637	15673	5	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	15673	6	between	between	IN
18637	15673	7	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	15673	8	and	and	CC
18637	15673	9	advocacy	advocacy	NN
18637	15673	10	.	.	.
18637	15674	1	The	the	DT
18637	15674	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15674	3	requires	require	VBZ
18637	15674	4	that	that	IN
18637	15674	5	the	the	DT
18637	15674	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	15674	7	be	be	VB
18637	15674	8	limited	limit	VBN
18637	15674	9	more	more	RBR
18637	15674	10	narrowly	narrowly	RB
18637	15674	11	.	.	.
18637	15675	1	At	at	IN
18637	15675	2	the	the	DT
18637	15675	3	very	very	RB
18637	15675	4	least	least	JJS
18637	15675	5	the	the	DT
18637	15675	6	line	line	NN
18637	15675	7	must	must	MD
18637	15675	8	be	be	VB
18637	15675	9	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	15675	10	between	between	IN
18637	15675	11	advocacy	advocacy	NN
18637	15675	12	and	and	CC
18637	15675	13	incitement	incitement	NN
18637	15675	14	,	,	,
18637	15675	15	and	and	CC
18637	15675	16	even	even	RB
18637	15675	17	the	the	DT
18637	15675	18	state	state	NN
18637	15675	19	's	's	POS
18637	15675	20	power	power	NN
18637	15675	21	to	to	TO
18637	15675	22	punish	punish	VB
18637	15675	23	incitement	incitement	NN
18637	15675	24	may	may	MD
18637	15675	25	vary	vary	VB
18637	15675	26	with	with	IN
18637	15675	27	the	the	DT
18637	15675	28	nature	nature	NN
18637	15675	29	of	of	IN
18637	15675	30	the	the	DT
18637	15675	31	speech	speech	NN
18637	15675	32	,	,	,
18637	15675	33	whether	whether	IN
18637	15675	34	persuasive	persuasive	JJ
18637	15675	35	or	or	CC
18637	15675	36	coercive	coercive	VB
18637	15675	37	,	,	,
18637	15675	38	the	the	DT
18637	15675	39	nature	nature	NN
18637	15675	40	of	of	IN
18637	15675	41	the	the	DT
18637	15675	42	wrong	wrong	NN
18637	15675	43	induced	induce	VBN
18637	15675	44	,	,	,
18637	15675	45	whether	whether	IN
18637	15675	46	violent	violent	JJ
18637	15675	47	or	or	CC
18637	15675	48	merely	merely	RB
18637	15675	49	offensive	offensive	JJ
18637	15675	50	to	to	IN
18637	15675	51	the	the	DT
18637	15675	52	mores	more	NNS
18637	15675	53	,	,	,
18637	15675	54	and	and	CC
18637	15675	55	the	the	DT
18637	15675	56	degree	degree	NN
18637	15675	57	of	of	IN
18637	15675	58	probability	probability	NN
18637	15675	59	that	that	IN
18637	15675	60	the	the	DT
18637	15675	61	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15675	62	evil	evil	NN
18637	15675	63	actually	actually	RB
18637	15675	64	will	will	MD
18637	15675	65	result	result	VB
18637	15675	66	.	.	.
18637	15676	1	"	"	``
18637	15676	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15676	3	117	117	CD
18637	15676	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15676	5	PICKETING	picketing	NN
18637	15676	6	AND	and	CC
18637	15676	7	CLEAR	CLEAR	NNP
18637	15676	8	AND	and	CC
18637	15676	9	PRESENT	PRESENT	NNP
18637	15676	10	DANGER	DANGER	NNP
18637	15676	11	Closely	closely	RB
18637	15676	12	allied	ally	VBD
18637	15676	13	to	to	IN
18637	15676	14	the	the	DT
18637	15676	15	problem	problem	NN
18637	15676	16	of	of	IN
18637	15676	17	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	15676	18	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	15676	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	15676	20	the	the	DT
18637	15676	21	resort	resort	NN
18637	15676	22	to	to	IN
18637	15676	23	picketing	picket	VBG
18637	15676	24	as	as	IN
18637	15676	25	a	a	DT
18637	15676	26	means	means	NN
18637	15676	27	of	of	IN
18637	15676	28	communication	communication	NN
18637	15676	29	and	and	CC
18637	15676	30	persuasion	persuasion	NN
18637	15676	31	in	in	IN
18637	15676	32	labor	labor	NN
18637	15676	33	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	15676	34	.	.	.
18637	15677	1	In	in	IN
18637	15677	2	such	such	JJ
18637	15677	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	15677	4	,	,	,
18637	15677	5	the	the	DT
18637	15677	6	evils	evil	NNS
18637	15677	7	feared	fear	VBN
18637	15677	8	by	by	IN
18637	15677	9	the	the	DT
18637	15677	10	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	15677	11	usually	usually	RB
18637	15677	12	arise	arise	VBP
18637	15677	13	,	,	,
18637	15677	14	not	not	RB
18637	15677	15	out	out	IN
18637	15677	16	of	of	IN
18637	15677	17	the	the	DT
18637	15677	18	substance	substance	NN
18637	15677	19	of	of	IN
18637	15677	20	the	the	DT
18637	15677	21	communications	communication	NNS
18637	15677	22	,	,	,
18637	15677	23	but	but	CC
18637	15677	24	from	from	IN
18637	15677	25	the	the	DT
18637	15677	26	manner	manner	NN
18637	15677	27	in	in	IN
18637	15677	28	which	which	WDT
18637	15677	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15677	30	are	be	VBP
18637	15677	31	made	make	VBN
18637	15677	32	.	.	.
18637	15678	1	Applying	apply	VBG
18637	15678	2	the	the	DT
18637	15678	3	test	test	NN
18637	15678	4	of	of	IN
18637	15678	5	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15678	6	and	and	CC
18637	15678	7	present	present	JJ
18637	15678	8	danger	danger	NN
18637	15678	9	in	in	IN
18637	15678	10	Thornhill	Thornhill	NNP
18637	15678	11	_	_	NNP
18637	15678	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	15678	13	_	_	NNP
18637	15678	14	Alabama[118	Alabama[118	NNP
18637	15678	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15678	16	and	and	CC
18637	15678	17	Carlson	Carlson	NNP
18637	15678	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	15678	19	California,[119	California,[119	NNP
18637	15678	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15678	21	the	the	DT
18637	15678	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15678	23	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
18637	15678	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	15678	25	against	against	IN
18637	15678	26	peaceful	peaceful	JJ
18637	15678	27	picketing	picketing	NN
18637	15678	28	,	,	,
18637	15678	29	including	include	VBG
18637	15678	30	the	the	DT
18637	15678	31	carrying	carrying	NN
18637	15678	32	of	of	IN
18637	15678	33	signs	sign	NNS
18637	15678	34	and	and	CC
18637	15678	35	banners	banner	NNS
18637	15678	36	.	.	.
18637	15679	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15679	2	held	hold	VBD
18637	15679	3	that	that	DT
18637	15679	4	:	:	:
18637	15679	5	"	"	``
18637	15679	6	the	the	DT
18637	15679	7	dissemination	dissemination	NN
18637	15679	8	of	of	IN
18637	15679	9	information	information	NN
18637	15679	10	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	15679	11	the	the	DT
18637	15679	12	facts	fact	NNS
18637	15679	13	of	of	IN
18637	15679	14	a	a	DT
18637	15679	15	labor	labor	NN
18637	15679	16	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	15679	17	must	must	MD
18637	15679	18	be	be	VB
18637	15679	19	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	15679	20	as	as	IN
18637	15679	21	within	within	IN
18637	15679	22	that	that	DT
18637	15679	23	area	area	NN
18637	15679	24	of	of	IN
18637	15679	25	free	free	JJ
18637	15679	26	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	15679	27	that	that	WDT
18637	15679	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	15679	29	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	15679	30	by	by	IN
18637	15679	31	the	the	DT
18637	15679	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15679	33	"	"	''
18637	15679	34	and	and	CC
18637	15679	35	may	may	MD
18637	15679	36	be	be	VB
18637	15679	37	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	15679	38	only	only	RB
18637	15679	39	where	where	WRB
18637	15679	40	"	"	``
18637	15679	41	the	the	DT
18637	15679	42	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15679	43	danger	danger	NN
18637	15679	44	of	of	IN
18637	15679	45	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15679	46	evils	evil	NNS
18637	15679	47	arises	arise	VBZ
18637	15679	48	under	under	IN
18637	15679	49	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	15679	50	affording	afford	VBG
18637	15679	51	no	no	DT
18637	15679	52	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	15679	53	to	to	TO
18637	15679	54	test	test	VB
18637	15679	55	the	the	DT
18637	15679	56	merits	merit	NNS
18637	15679	57	of	of	IN
18637	15679	58	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	15679	59	by	by	IN
18637	15679	60	competition	competition	NN
18637	15679	61	for	for	IN
18637	15679	62	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	15679	63	in	in	IN
18637	15679	64	the	the	DT
18637	15679	65	market	market	NN
18637	15679	66	of	of	IN
18637	15679	67	public	public	JJ
18637	15679	68	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15679	69	.	.	.
18637	15680	1	"	"	``
18637	15680	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15680	3	120	120	CD
18637	15680	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15680	5	Shortly	shortly	RB
18637	15680	6	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	15680	7	a	a	DT
18637	15680	8	divided	divide	VBN
18637	15680	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15680	10	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	15680	11	that	that	IN
18637	15680	12	peaceful	peaceful	JJ
18637	15680	13	picketing	picketing	NN
18637	15680	14	may	may	MD
18637	15680	15	be	be	VB
18637	15680	16	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	15680	17	where	where	WRB
18637	15680	18	the	the	DT
18637	15680	19	labor	labor	NN
18637	15680	20	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	15680	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	15680	22	been	be	VBN
18637	15680	23	attended	attend	VBN
18637	15680	24	by	by	IN
18637	15680	25	violence	violence	NN
18637	15680	26	on	on	IN
18637	15680	27	a	a	DT
18637	15680	28	serious	serious	JJ
18637	15680	29	scale	scale	NN
18637	15680	30	.	.	.
18637	15681	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15681	2	121	121	CD
18637	15681	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15681	4	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15681	5	for	for	IN
18637	15681	6	the	the	DT
18637	15681	7	majority	majority	NN
18637	15681	8	on	on	IN
18637	15681	9	this	this	DT
18637	15681	10	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	15681	11	,	,	,
18637	15681	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15681	13	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	15681	14	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	15681	15	that	that	IN
18637	15681	16	"	"	``
18637	15681	17	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	15681	18	in	in	IN
18637	15681	19	a	a	DT
18637	15681	20	context	context	NN
18637	15681	21	of	of	IN
18637	15681	22	violence	violence	NN
18637	15681	23	can	can	MD
18637	15681	24	lose	lose	VB
18637	15681	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15681	26	significance	significance	NN
18637	15681	27	as	as	IN
18637	15681	28	an	an	DT
18637	15681	29	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	15681	30	to	to	IN
18637	15681	31	reason	reason	NN
18637	15681	32	and	and	CC
18637	15681	33	become	become	VB
18637	15681	34	part	part	NN
18637	15681	35	of	of	IN
18637	15681	36	an	an	DT
18637	15681	37	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	15681	38	of	of	IN
18637	15681	39	force	force	NN
18637	15681	40	*	*	NFP
18637	15681	41	*	*	NFP
18637	15681	42	*	*	NFP
18637	15681	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15681	44	and	and	CC
18637	15681	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15681	46	was	be	VBD
18637	15681	47	not	not	RB
18637	15681	48	meant	mean	VBN
18637	15681	49	to	to	TO
18637	15681	50	be	be	VB
18637	15681	51	sheltered	shelter	VBN
18637	15681	52	by	by	IN
18637	15681	53	the	the	DT
18637	15681	54	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15681	55	.	.	.
18637	15682	1	"	"	``
18637	15682	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15682	3	122	122	CD
18637	15682	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15682	5	For	for	IN
18637	15682	6	a	a	DT
18637	15682	7	brief	brief	JJ
18637	15682	8	period	period	NN
18637	15682	9	strangers	stranger	NNS
18637	15682	10	to	to	IN
18637	15682	11	the	the	DT
18637	15682	12	employer	employer	NN
18637	15682	13	were	be	VBD
18637	15682	14	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	15682	15	an	an	DT
18637	15682	16	almost	almost	RB
18637	15682	17	equal	equal	JJ
18637	15682	18	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15682	19	of	of	IN
18637	15682	20	communication	communication	NN
18637	15682	21	by	by	IN
18637	15682	22	means	mean	NNS
18637	15682	23	of	of	IN
18637	15682	24	picketing	picket	VBG
18637	15682	25	.	.	.
18637	15683	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15683	2	123	123	CD
18637	15683	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15683	4	Subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	15683	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	15683	6	,	,	,
18637	15683	7	however	however	RB
18637	15683	8	,	,	,
18637	15683	9	have	have	VBP
18637	15683	10	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	15683	11	that	that	IN
18637	15683	12	"	"	``
18637	15683	13	while	while	IN
18637	15683	14	picketing	picket	VBG
18637	15683	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	15683	16	an	an	DT
18637	15683	17	ingredient	ingredient	NN
18637	15683	18	of	of	IN
18637	15683	19	communication	communication	NN
18637	15683	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15683	21	can	can	MD
18637	15683	22	not	not	RB
18637	15683	23	dogmatically	dogmatically	RB
18637	15683	24	be	be	VB
18637	15683	25	equated	equate	VBN
18637	15683	26	with	with	IN
18637	15683	27	the	the	DT
18637	15683	28	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	15683	29	protected	protect	VBN
18637	15683	30	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15683	31	of	of	IN
18637	15683	32	speech	speech	NN
18637	15683	33	.	.	.
18637	15684	1	"	"	``
18637	15684	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15684	3	124	124	CD
18637	15684	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15684	5	Without	without	IN
18637	15684	6	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	15684	7	the	the	DT
18637	15684	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15684	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	15684	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	15684	11	that	that	IN
18637	15684	12	a	a	DT
18637	15684	13	State	state	NN
18637	15684	14	may	may	MD
18637	15684	15	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	15684	16	picketing	picket	VBG
18637	15684	17	designed	design	VBN
18637	15684	18	to	to	TO
18637	15684	19	coerce	coerce	VB
18637	15684	20	the	the	DT
18637	15684	21	employer	employer	NN
18637	15684	22	to	to	TO
18637	15684	23	violate	violate	VB
18637	15684	24	State	State	NNP
18637	15684	25	law	law	NN
18637	15684	26	by	by	IN
18637	15684	27	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	15684	28	to	to	TO
18637	15684	29	sell	sell	VB
18637	15684	30	ice	ice	NN
18637	15684	31	to	to	IN
18637	15684	32	nonunion	nonunion	NNP
18637	15684	33	peddlers,[125	peddlers,[125	NNP
18637	15684	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15684	35	by	by	IN
18637	15684	36	interfering	interfere	VBG
18637	15684	37	with	with	IN
18637	15684	38	the	the	DT
18637	15684	39	right	right	NN
18637	15684	40	of	of	IN
18637	15684	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15684	42	employees	employee	NNS
18637	15684	43	to	to	TO
18637	15684	44	decide	decide	VB
18637	15684	45	whether	whether	IN
18637	15684	46	or	or	CC
18637	15684	47	not	not	RB
18637	15684	48	to	to	TO
18637	15684	49	join	join	VB
18637	15684	50	a	a	DT
18637	15684	51	union,[126	union,[126	NN
18637	15684	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15684	53	or	or	CC
18637	15684	54	by	by	IN
18637	15684	55	choosing	choose	VBG
18637	15684	56	a	a	DT
18637	15684	57	specified	specified	JJ
18637	15684	58	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	15684	59	of	of	IN
18637	15684	60	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15684	61	employees	employee	NNS
18637	15684	62	from	from	IN
18637	15684	63	one	one	CD
18637	15684	64	race	race	NN
18637	15684	65	,	,	,
18637	15684	66	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	15684	67	of	of	IN
18637	15684	68	merit	merit	NN
18637	15684	69	.	.	.
18637	15685	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15685	2	127	127	CD
18637	15685	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15685	4	By	by	IN
18637	15685	5	close	close	JJ
18637	15685	6	divisions	division	NNS
18637	15685	7	,	,	,
18637	15685	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15685	9	also	also	RB
18637	15685	10	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15685	11	the	the	DT
18637	15685	12	right	right	NN
18637	15685	13	of	of	IN
18637	15685	14	a	a	DT
18637	15685	15	State	State	NNP
18637	15685	16	to	to	TO
18637	15685	17	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	15685	18	the	the	DT
18637	15685	19	"	"	``
18637	15685	20	conscription	conscription	NN
18637	15685	21	of	of	IN
18637	15685	22	neutrals	neutral	NNS
18637	15685	23	"	"	''
18637	15685	24	by	by	IN
18637	15685	25	the	the	DT
18637	15685	26	picketing	picketing	NN
18637	15685	27	of	of	IN
18637	15685	28	a	a	DT
18637	15685	29	restaurant	restaurant	NN
18637	15685	30	solely	solely	RB
18637	15685	31	because	because	IN
18637	15685	32	the	the	DT
18637	15685	33	owner	owner	NN
18637	15685	34	had	have	VBD
18637	15685	35	contracted	contract	VBN
18637	15685	36	for	for	IN
18637	15685	37	the	the	DT
18637	15685	38	erection	erection	NN
18637	15685	39	of	of	IN
18637	15685	40	a	a	DT
18637	15685	41	building	building	NN
18637	15685	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15685	43	not	not	RB
18637	15685	44	connected	connect	VBN
18637	15685	45	with	with	IN
18637	15685	46	the	the	DT
18637	15685	47	restaurant	restaurant	NN
18637	15685	48	and	and	CC
18637	15685	49	located	locate	VBN
18637	15685	50	some	some	DT
18637	15685	51	distance	distance	NN
18637	15685	52	away	away	RB
18637	15685	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15685	54	by	by	IN
18637	15685	55	a	a	DT
18637	15685	56	contractor	contractor	NN
18637	15685	57	who	who	WP
18637	15685	58	employed	employ	VBD
18637	15685	59	nonunion	nonunion	NN
18637	15685	60	men;[128	men;[128	NNP
18637	15685	61	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15685	62	or	or	CC
18637	15685	63	the	the	DT
18637	15685	64	picketing	picketing	NN
18637	15685	65	of	of	IN
18637	15685	66	a	a	DT
18637	15685	67	shop	shop	NN
18637	15685	68	operated	operate	VBN
18637	15685	69	by	by	IN
18637	15685	70	the	the	DT
18637	15685	71	owner	owner	NN
18637	15685	72	without	without	IN
18637	15685	73	employees	employee	NNS
18637	15685	74	to	to	TO
18637	15685	75	induce	induce	VB
18637	15685	76	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15685	77	to	to	TO
18637	15685	78	observe	observe	VB
18637	15685	79	certain	certain	JJ
18637	15685	80	closing	closing	NN
18637	15685	81	hours	hour	NNS
18637	15685	82	.	.	.
18637	15686	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15686	2	129	129	CD
18637	15686	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15686	4	In	in	IN
18637	15686	5	this	this	DT
18637	15686	6	last	last	JJ
18637	15686	7	case	case	NN
18637	15686	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15686	9	Black	Black	NNP
18637	15686	10	distinguished	distinguish	VBD
18637	15686	11	Thornhill	Thornhill	NNP
18637	15686	12	_	_	NNP
18637	15686	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	15686	14	_	_	NNP
18637	15686	15	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	15686	16	and	and	CC
18637	15686	17	other	other	JJ
18637	15686	18	prior	prior	JJ
18637	15686	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	15686	20	by	by	IN
18637	15686	21	saying	say	VBG
18637	15686	22	,	,	,
18637	15686	23	"	"	``
18637	15686	24	No	no	DT
18637	15686	25	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	15686	26	relied	rely	VBN
18637	15686	27	on	on	RP
18637	15686	28	by	by	IN
18637	15686	29	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	15686	30	assert	assert	VBP
18637	15686	31	a	a	DT
18637	15686	32	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15686	33	right	right	NN
18637	15686	34	in	in	IN
18637	15686	35	picketers	picketer	NNS
18637	15686	36	to	to	TO
18637	15686	37	take	take	VB
18637	15686	38	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	15686	39	of	of	IN
18637	15686	40	speech	speech	NN
18637	15686	41	or	or	CC
18637	15686	42	press	press	NN
18637	15686	43	to	to	TO
18637	15686	44	violate	violate	VB
18637	15686	45	valid	valid	JJ
18637	15686	46	laws	law	NNS
18637	15686	47	designed	design	VBN
18637	15686	48	to	to	TO
18637	15686	49	protect	protect	VB
18637	15686	50	important	important	JJ
18637	15686	51	interests	interest	NNS
18637	15686	52	of	of	IN
18637	15686	53	society	society	NN
18637	15686	54	*	*	NFP
18637	15686	55	*	*	NFP
18637	15686	56	*	*	NFP
18637	15686	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15686	58	has	have	VBZ
18637	15686	59	never	never	RB
18637	15686	60	been	be	VBN
18637	15686	61	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	15686	62	an	an	DT
18637	15686	63	abridgment	abridgment	NN
18637	15686	64	of	of	IN
18637	15686	65	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15686	66	of	of	IN
18637	15686	67	speech	speech	NN
18637	15686	68	or	or	CC
18637	15686	69	press	press	NN
18637	15686	70	to	to	TO
18637	15686	71	make	make	VB
18637	15686	72	a	a	DT
18637	15686	73	course	course	NN
18637	15686	74	of	of	IN
18637	15686	75	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	15686	76	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	15686	77	merely	merely	RB
18637	15686	78	because	because	IN
18637	15686	79	the	the	DT
18637	15686	80	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	15686	81	was	be	VBD
18637	15686	82	in	in	IN
18637	15686	83	part	part	NN
18637	15686	84	initiated	initiate	VBN
18637	15686	85	,	,	,
18637	15686	86	evidenced	evidence	VBN
18637	15686	87	,	,	,
18637	15686	88	or	or	CC
18637	15686	89	carried	carry	VBN
18637	15686	90	out	out	RP
18637	15686	91	by	by	IN
18637	15686	92	means	mean	NNS
18637	15686	93	of	of	IN
18637	15686	94	language	language	NN
18637	15686	95	,	,	,
18637	15686	96	either	either	CC
18637	15686	97	spoken	speak	VBN
18637	15686	98	,	,	,
18637	15686	99	written	write	VBN
18637	15686	100	,	,	,
18637	15686	101	or	or	CC
18637	15686	102	printed	print	VBN
18637	15686	103	.	.	.
18637	15687	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15687	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15687	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15687	4	Such	such	PDT
18637	15687	5	an	an	DT
18637	15687	6	expansive	expansive	JJ
18637	15687	7	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	15687	8	of	of	IN
18637	15687	9	the	the	DT
18637	15687	10	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15687	11	guaranties	guaranty	NNS
18637	15687	12	of	of	IN
18637	15687	13	speech	speech	NN
18637	15687	14	and	and	CC
18637	15687	15	press	press	NN
18637	15687	16	would	would	MD
18637	15687	17	make	make	VB
18637	15687	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15687	19	practically	practically	RB
18637	15687	20	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	15687	21	ever	ever	RB
18637	15687	22	to	to	TO
18637	15687	23	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	15687	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	15687	25	against	against	IN
18637	15687	26	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	15687	27	in	in	IN
18637	15687	28	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	15687	29	of	of	IN
18637	15687	30	trade	trade	NN
18637	15687	31	as	as	RB
18637	15687	32	well	well	RB
18637	15687	33	as	as	IN
18637	15687	34	many	many	JJ
18637	15687	35	other	other	JJ
18637	15687	36	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	15687	37	and	and	CC
18637	15687	38	conspiracies	conspiracy	NNS
18637	15687	39	deemed	deem	VBD
18637	15687	40	injurious	injurious	JJ
18637	15687	41	to	to	IN
18637	15687	42	society	society	NN
18637	15687	43	.	.	.
18637	15688	1	"	"	``
18637	15688	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15688	3	130	130	CD
18637	15688	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15688	5	By	by	IN
18637	15688	6	the	the	DT
18637	15688	7	same	same	JJ
18637	15688	8	token	token	NN
18637	15688	9	,	,	,
18637	15688	10	a	a	DT
18637	15688	11	State	state	NN
18637	15688	12	anti	anti	JJ
18637	15688	13	-	-	JJ
18637	15688	14	closed	closed	JJ
18637	15688	15	shop	shop	NN
18637	15688	16	law	law	NN
18637	15688	17	does	do	VBZ
18637	15688	18	not	not	RB
18637	15688	19	infringe	infringe	VB
18637	15688	20	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15688	21	of	of	IN
18637	15688	22	speech	speech	NN
18637	15688	23	,	,	,
18637	15688	24	of	of	IN
18637	15688	25	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	15688	26	or	or	CC
18637	15688	27	of	of	IN
18637	15688	28	petition;[131	petition;[131	NNPS
18637	15688	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15688	30	neither	neither	CC
18637	15688	31	does	do	VBZ
18637	15688	32	a	a	DT
18637	15688	33	"	"	``
18637	15688	34	cease	cease	VB
18637	15688	35	and	and	CC
18637	15688	36	desist	desist	VB
18637	15688	37	"	"	''
18637	15688	38	order	order	NN
18637	15688	39	of	of	IN
18637	15688	40	a	a	DT
18637	15688	41	State	State	NNP
18637	15688	42	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	15688	43	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	15688	44	Board	Board	NNP
18637	15688	45	directed	direct	VBD
18637	15688	46	against	against	IN
18637	15688	47	work	work	NN
18637	15688	48	stoppages	stoppage	NNS
18637	15688	49	caused	cause	VBN
18637	15688	50	by	by	IN
18637	15688	51	the	the	DT
18637	15688	52	calling	calling	NN
18637	15688	53	of	of	IN
18637	15688	54	special	special	JJ
18637	15688	55	union	union	NN
18637	15688	56	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	15688	57	during	during	IN
18637	15688	58	working	working	NN
18637	15688	59	hours	hour	NNS
18637	15688	60	.	.	.
18637	15689	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15689	2	132	132	CD
18637	15689	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15689	4	But	but	CC
18637	15689	5	,	,	,
18637	15689	6	by	by	IN
18637	15689	7	a	a	DT
18637	15689	8	vote	vote	NN
18637	15689	9	of	of	IN
18637	15689	10	five	five	CD
18637	15689	11	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	15689	12	to	to	IN
18637	15689	13	four	four	CD
18637	15689	14	--	--	:
18637	15689	15	the	the	DT
18637	15689	16	five	five	CD
18637	15689	17	,	,	,
18637	15689	18	however	however	RB
18637	15689	19	,	,	,
18637	15689	20	being	be	VBG
18637	15689	21	unable	unable	JJ
18637	15689	22	to	to	TO
18637	15689	23	agree	agree	VB
18637	15689	24	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	15689	25	among	among	IN
18637	15689	26	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15689	27	--	--	:
18637	15689	28	a	a	DT
18637	15689	29	State	state	NN
18637	15689	30	may	may	MD
18637	15689	31	not	not	RB
18637	15689	32	require	require	VB
18637	15689	33	labor	labor	NN
18637	15689	34	organizers	organizer	NNS
18637	15689	35	to	to	IN
18637	15689	36	register,[133	register,[133	NNP
18637	15689	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15689	38	although	although	IN
18637	15689	39	,	,	,
18637	15689	40	as	as	IN
18637	15689	41	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15689	42	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	15689	43	pointed	point	VBD
18637	15689	44	out	out	RP
18637	15689	45	for	for	IN
18637	15689	46	the	the	DT
18637	15689	47	dissenters	dissenter	NNS
18637	15689	48	,	,	,
18637	15689	49	"	"	''
18637	15689	50	other	other	JJ
18637	15689	51	paid	pay	VBN
18637	15689	52	organizers	organizer	NNS
18637	15689	53	,	,	,
18637	15689	54	whether	whether	IN
18637	15689	55	for	for	IN
18637	15689	56	business	business	NN
18637	15689	57	or	or	CC
18637	15689	58	for	for	IN
18637	15689	59	charity	charity	NN
18637	15689	60	could	could	MD
18637	15689	61	be	be	VB
18637	15689	62	required	require	VBN
18637	15689	63	thus	thus	RB
18637	15689	64	to	to	TO
18637	15689	65	identify	identify	VB
18637	15689	66	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15689	67	.	.	.
18637	15690	1	"	"	``
18637	15690	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15690	3	134	134	CD
18637	15690	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15690	5	CONTEMPT	CONTEMPT	NNP
18637	15690	6	OF	of	IN
18637	15690	7	COURT	COURT	NNP
18637	15690	8	AND	and	CC
18637	15690	9	CLEAR	CLEAR	NNP
18637	15690	10	AND	and	CC
18637	15690	11	PRESENT	PRESENT	NNP
18637	15690	12	DANGER	DANGER	NNP
18637	15690	13	One	one	CD
18637	15690	14	area	area	NN
18637	15690	15	in	in	IN
18637	15690	16	which	which	WDT
18637	15690	17	the	the	DT
18637	15690	18	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15690	19	and	and	CC
18637	15690	20	present	present	JJ
18637	15690	21	danger	danger	NN
18637	15690	22	rule	rule	NN
18637	15690	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	15690	24	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	15690	25	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
18637	15690	26	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15690	27	of	of	IN
18637	15690	28	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	15690	29	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	15690	30	common	common	JJ
18637	15690	31	law	law	NN
18637	15690	32	limits	limit	NNS
18637	15690	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	15690	34	that	that	DT
18637	15690	35	of	of	IN
18637	15690	36	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	15690	37	of	of	IN
18637	15690	38	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15690	39	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	15690	40	.	.	.
18637	15691	1	In	in	IN
18637	15691	2	1907	1907	CD
18637	15691	3	the	the	DT
18637	15691	4	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15691	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15691	6	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15691	7	by	by	IN
18637	15691	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15691	9	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	15691	10	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	15691	11	to	to	TO
18637	15691	12	review	review	VB
18637	15691	13	the	the	DT
18637	15691	14	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15691	15	of	of	IN
18637	15691	16	an	an	DT
18637	15691	17	editor	editor	NN
18637	15691	18	for	for	IN
18637	15691	19	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	15691	20	of	of	IN
18637	15691	21	court	court	NN
18637	15691	22	in	in	IN
18637	15691	23	publishing	publish	VBG
18637	15691	24	articles	article	NNS
18637	15691	25	and	and	CC
18637	15691	26	cartoons	cartoon	NNS
18637	15691	27	criticizing	criticize	VBG
18637	15691	28	the	the	DT
18637	15691	29	action	action	NN
18637	15691	30	of	of	IN
18637	15691	31	the	the	DT
18637	15691	32	court	court	NN
18637	15691	33	in	in	IN
18637	15691	34	a	a	DT
18637	15691	35	pending	pending	JJ
18637	15691	36	case	case	NN
18637	15691	37	.	.	.
18637	15692	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15692	2	135	135	CD
18637	15692	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15692	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15692	5	took	take	VBD
18637	15692	6	the	the	DT
18637	15692	7	position	position	NN
18637	15692	8	that	that	IN
18637	15692	9	even	even	RB
18637	15692	10	if	if	IN
18637	15692	11	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15692	12	of	of	IN
18637	15692	13	the	the	DT
18637	15692	14	press	press	NN
18637	15692	15	was	be	VBD
18637	15692	16	protected	protect	VBN
18637	15692	17	against	against	IN
18637	15692	18	abridgment	abridgment	NN
18637	15692	19	by	by	IN
18637	15692	20	the	the	DT
18637	15692	21	State	State	NNP
18637	15692	22	,	,	,
18637	15692	23	a	a	DT
18637	15692	24	publication	publication	NN
18637	15692	25	tending	tend	VBG
18637	15692	26	to	to	TO
18637	15692	27	obstruct	obstruct	VB
18637	15692	28	the	the	DT
18637	15692	29	administration	administration	NN
18637	15692	30	of	of	IN
18637	15692	31	justice	justice	NN
18637	15692	32	was	be	VBD
18637	15692	33	punishable	punishable	JJ
18637	15692	34	,	,	,
18637	15692	35	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	15692	36	of	of	IN
18637	15692	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15692	38	truth	truth	NN
18637	15692	39	.	.	.
18637	15693	1	In	in	IN
18637	15693	2	recent	recent	JJ
18637	15693	3	years	year	NNS
18637	15693	4	the	the	DT
18637	15693	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15693	6	not	not	RB
18637	15693	7	only	only	RB
18637	15693	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	15693	9	taken	take	VBN
18637	15693	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	15693	11	of	of	IN
18637	15693	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	15693	13	of	of	IN
18637	15693	14	this	this	DT
18637	15693	15	order	order	NN
18637	15693	16	but	but	CC
18637	15693	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	15693	18	scrutinized	scrutinize	VBN
18637	15693	19	the	the	DT
18637	15693	20	facts	fact	NNS
18637	15693	21	with	with	IN
18637	15693	22	great	great	JJ
18637	15693	23	care	care	NN
18637	15693	24	and	and	CC
18637	15693	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	15693	26	not	not	RB
18637	15693	27	hesitated	hesitate	VBN
18637	15693	28	to	to	TO
18637	15693	29	reverse	reverse	VB
18637	15693	30	the	the	DT
18637	15693	31	action	action	NN
18637	15693	32	of	of	IN
18637	15693	33	State	State	NNP
18637	15693	34	courts	court	NNS
18637	15693	35	.	.	.
18637	15694	1	Bridges	Bridges	NNPS
18637	15694	2	_	_	NNP
18637	15694	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	15694	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15694	5	California[136	California[136	NNP
18637	15694	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15694	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	15694	8	the	the	DT
18637	15694	9	leading	leading	JJ
18637	15694	10	case	case	NN
18637	15694	11	.	.	.
18637	15695	1	Enlarging	enlarge	VBG
18637	15695	2	upon	upon	IN
18637	15695	3	the	the	DT
18637	15695	4	idea	idea	NN
18637	15695	5	that	that	WDT
18637	15695	6	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15695	7	and	and	CC
18637	15695	8	present	present	JJ
18637	15695	9	danger	danger	NN
18637	15695	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	15695	11	an	an	DT
18637	15695	12	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	15695	13	guide	guide	NN
18637	15695	14	in	in	IN
18637	15695	15	determining	determine	VBG
18637	15695	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	15695	17	comment	comment	NN
18637	15695	18	on	on	IN
18637	15695	19	pending	pende	VBG
18637	15695	20	cases	case	NNS
18637	15695	21	can	can	MD
18637	15695	22	be	be	VB
18637	15695	23	punished	punish	VBN
18637	15695	24	,	,	,
18637	15695	25	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15695	26	Black	Black	NNP
18637	15695	27	said	say	VBD
18637	15695	28	:	:	:
18637	15695	29	"	"	``
18637	15695	30	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15695	31	can	can	MD
18637	15695	32	not	not	RB
18637	15695	33	start	start	VB
18637	15695	34	with	with	IN
18637	15695	35	the	the	DT
18637	15695	36	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	15695	37	that	that	IN
18637	15695	38	publications	publication	NNS
18637	15695	39	of	of	IN
18637	15695	40	the	the	DT
18637	15695	41	kind	kind	NN
18637	15695	42	here	here	RB
18637	15695	43	involved	involve	VBN
18637	15695	44	actually	actually	RB
18637	15695	45	do	do	VBP
18637	15695	46	threaten	threaten	VB
18637	15695	47	to	to	TO
18637	15695	48	change	change	VB
18637	15695	49	the	the	DT
18637	15695	50	nature	nature	NN
18637	15695	51	of	of	IN
18637	15695	52	legal	legal	JJ
18637	15695	53	trials	trial	NNS
18637	15695	54	,	,	,
18637	15695	55	and	and	CC
18637	15695	56	that	that	IN
18637	15695	57	to	to	TO
18637	15695	58	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	15695	59	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15695	60	impartiality	impartiality	NN
18637	15695	61	,	,	,
18637	15695	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15695	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	15695	64	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	15695	65	for	for	IN
18637	15695	66	judges	judge	NNS
18637	15695	67	to	to	TO
18637	15695	68	have	have	VB
18637	15695	69	a	a	DT
18637	15695	70	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	15695	71	power	power	NN
18637	15695	72	by	by	IN
18637	15695	73	which	which	WDT
18637	15695	74	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15695	75	can	can	MD
18637	15695	76	close	close	VB
18637	15695	77	all	all	DT
18637	15695	78	channels	channel	NNS
18637	15695	79	of	of	IN
18637	15695	80	public	public	JJ
18637	15695	81	expression	expression	NN
18637	15695	82	to	to	IN
18637	15695	83	all	all	DT
18637	15695	84	matters	matter	NNS
18637	15695	85	which	which	WDT
18637	15695	86	touch	touch	VBP
18637	15695	87	upon	upon	IN
18637	15695	88	pending	pende	VBG
18637	15695	89	cases	case	NNS
18637	15695	90	.	.	.
18637	15696	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15696	2	must	must	MD
18637	15696	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	15696	4	turn	turn	VB
18637	15696	5	to	to	IN
18637	15696	6	the	the	DT
18637	15696	7	particular	particular	JJ
18637	15696	8	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	15696	9	here	here	RB
18637	15696	10	in	in	IN
18637	15696	11	question	question	NN
18637	15696	12	and	and	CC
18637	15696	13	the	the	DT
18637	15696	14	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	15696	15	of	of	IN
18637	15696	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15696	17	publication	publication	NN
18637	15696	18	to	to	TO
18637	15696	19	determine	determine	VB
18637	15696	20	to	to	IN
18637	15696	21	what	what	WDT
18637	15696	22	extent	extent	NN
18637	15696	23	the	the	DT
18637	15696	24	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15696	25	evil	evil	NN
18637	15696	26	of	of	IN
18637	15696	27	unfair	unfair	NNP
18637	15696	28	administration	administration	NNP
18637	15696	29	of	of	IN
18637	15696	30	justice	justice	NNP
18637	15696	31	was	be	VBD
18637	15696	32	a	a	DT
18637	15696	33	likely	likely	JJ
18637	15696	34	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	15696	35	,	,	,
18637	15696	36	and	and	CC
18637	15696	37	whether	whether	IN
18637	15696	38	the	the	DT
18637	15696	39	degree	degree	NN
18637	15696	40	of	of	IN
18637	15696	41	likelihood	likelihood	NN
18637	15696	42	was	be	VBD
18637	15696	43	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	15696	44	to	to	TO
18637	15696	45	justify	justify	VB
18637	15696	46	summary	summary	NN
18637	15696	47	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15696	48	.	.	.
18637	15697	1	"	"	``
18637	15697	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15697	3	137	137	CD
18637	15697	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15697	5	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15697	6	on	on	IN
18637	15697	7	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	15697	8	of	of	IN
18637	15697	9	four	four	CD
18637	15697	10	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	15697	11	members	member	NNS
18637	15697	12	,	,	,
18637	15697	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15697	14	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	15697	15	objected	object	VBD
18637	15697	16	:	:	:
18637	15697	17	"	"	``
18637	15697	18	A	a	DT
18637	15697	19	trial	trial	NN
18637	15697	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	15697	21	not	not	RB
18637	15697	22	a	a	DT
18637	15697	23	'	'	``
18637	15697	24	free	free	JJ
18637	15697	25	trade	trade	NN
18637	15697	26	in	in	IN
18637	15697	27	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	15697	28	,	,	,
18637	15697	29	'	'	''
18637	15697	30	nor	nor	CC
18637	15697	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	15697	32	the	the	DT
18637	15697	33	best	good	JJS
18637	15697	34	test	test	NN
18637	15697	35	of	of	IN
18637	15697	36	truth	truth	NN
18637	15697	37	in	in	IN
18637	15697	38	a	a	DT
18637	15697	39	courtroom	courtroom	NN
18637	15697	40	'	'	''
18637	15697	41	the	the	DT
18637	15697	42	power	power	NN
18637	15697	43	of	of	IN
18637	15697	44	the	the	DT
18637	15697	45	thought	thought	NN
18637	15697	46	to	to	TO
18637	15697	47	get	get	VB
18637	15697	48	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15697	49	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	15697	50	in	in	IN
18637	15697	51	the	the	DT
18637	15697	52	competition	competition	NN
18637	15697	53	of	of	IN
18637	15697	54	the	the	DT
18637	15697	55	market	market	NN
18637	15697	56	.	.	.
18637	15697	57	'	'	''
18637	15698	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15698	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15698	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15698	4	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15698	5	can	can	MD
18637	15698	6	not	not	RB
18637	15698	7	read	read	VB
18637	15698	8	into	into	IN
18637	15698	9	the	the	DT
18637	15698	10	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15698	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15698	12	the	the	DT
18637	15698	13	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15698	14	of	of	IN
18637	15698	15	speech	speech	NN
18637	15698	16	and	and	CC
18637	15698	17	of	of	IN
18637	15698	18	the	the	DT
18637	15698	19	press	press	NN
18637	15698	20	protected	protect	VBN
18637	15698	21	by	by	IN
18637	15698	22	the	the	DT
18637	15698	23	First	First	NNP
18637	15698	24	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15698	25	and	and	CC
18637	15698	26	at	at	IN
18637	15698	27	the	the	DT
18637	15698	28	same	same	JJ
18637	15698	29	time	time	NN
18637	15698	30	read	read	VBD
18637	15698	31	out	out	RP
18637	15698	32	age	age	NN
18637	15698	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	15698	34	old	old	JJ
18637	15698	35	means	mean	NNS
18637	15698	36	employed	employ	VBN
18637	15698	37	by	by	IN
18637	15698	38	states	state	NNS
18637	15698	39	for	for	IN
18637	15698	40	securing	secure	VBG
18637	15698	41	the	the	DT
18637	15698	42	calm	calm	JJ
18637	15698	43	course	course	NN
18637	15698	44	of	of	IN
18637	15698	45	justice	justice	NN
18637	15698	46	.	.	.
18637	15699	1	The	the	DT
18637	15699	2	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15699	3	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15699	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	15699	5	not	not	RB
18637	15699	6	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	15699	7	a	a	DT
18637	15699	8	state	state	NN
18637	15699	9	to	to	TO
18637	15699	10	continue	continue	VB
18637	15699	11	the	the	DT
18637	15699	12	historic	historic	JJ
18637	15699	13	process	process	NN
18637	15699	14	of	of	IN
18637	15699	15	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	15699	16	expressions	expression	NNS
18637	15699	17	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	15699	18	to	to	TO
18637	15699	19	subvert	subvert	VB
18637	15699	20	a	a	DT
18637	15699	21	specific	specific	JJ
18637	15699	22	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15699	23	of	of	IN
18637	15699	24	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15699	25	power	power	NN
18637	15699	26	.	.	.
18637	15700	1	So	so	RB
18637	15700	2	to	to	TO
18637	15700	3	assure	assure	VB
18637	15700	4	the	the	DT
18637	15700	5	impartial	impartial	JJ
18637	15700	6	accomplishment	accomplishment	NN
18637	15700	7	of	of	IN
18637	15700	8	justice	justice	NN
18637	15700	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	15700	10	not	not	RB
18637	15700	11	an	an	DT
18637	15700	12	abridgment	abridgment	NN
18637	15700	13	of	of	IN
18637	15700	14	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15700	15	of	of	IN
18637	15700	16	speech	speech	NN
18637	15700	17	or	or	CC
18637	15700	18	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15700	19	of	of	IN
18637	15700	20	the	the	DT
18637	15700	21	press	press	NN
18637	15700	22	,	,	,
18637	15700	23	as	as	IN
18637	15700	24	these	these	DT
18637	15700	25	phases	phase	NNS
18637	15700	26	of	of	IN
18637	15700	27	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15700	28	have	have	VBP
18637	15700	29	heretofore	heretofore	RB
18637	15700	30	been	be	VBN
18637	15700	31	conceived	conceive	VBN
18637	15700	32	even	even	RB
18637	15700	33	by	by	IN
18637	15700	34	the	the	DT
18637	15700	35	stoutest	stout	JJS
18637	15700	36	libertarians	libertarian	NNS
18637	15700	37	.	.	.
18637	15701	1	In	in	IN
18637	15701	2	act	act	NN
18637	15701	3	,	,	,
18637	15701	4	these	these	DT
18637	15701	5	liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	15701	6	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15701	7	depend	depend	VBP
18637	15701	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	15701	9	an	an	DT
18637	15701	10	untrammeled	untrammeled	JJ
18637	15701	11	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	15701	12	whose	whose	WP$
18637	15701	13	passions	passion	NNS
18637	15701	14	are	be	VBP
18637	15701	15	not	not	RB
18637	15701	16	even	even	RB
18637	15701	17	unconsciously	unconsciously	RB
18637	15701	18	aroused	arouse	VBN
18637	15701	19	and	and	CC
18637	15701	20	whose	whose	WP$
18637	15701	21	minds	mind	NNS
18637	15701	22	are	be	VBP
18637	15701	23	not	not	RB
18637	15701	24	distorted	distort	VBN
18637	15701	25	by	by	IN
18637	15701	26	extrajudicial	extrajudicial	JJ
18637	15701	27	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	15701	28	.	.	.
18637	15702	1	"	"	``
18637	15702	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15702	3	138	138	CD
18637	15702	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15702	5	In	in	IN
18637	15702	6	Pennekamp	Pennekamp	NNP
18637	15702	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15702	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15702	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15702	10	Florida,[139	Florida,[139	NNP
18637	15702	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15702	12	a	a	DT
18637	15702	13	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	15702	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15702	15	held	hold	VBD
18637	15702	16	that	that	IN
18637	15702	17	criticism	criticism	NN
18637	15702	18	of	of	IN
18637	15702	19	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15702	20	action	action	NN
18637	15702	21	already	already	RB
18637	15702	22	taken	take	VBN
18637	15702	23	,	,	,
18637	15702	24	although	although	IN
18637	15702	25	the	the	DT
18637	15702	26	cases	case	NNS
18637	15702	27	were	be	VBD
18637	15702	28	still	still	RB
18637	15702	29	pending	pende	VBG
18637	15702	30	on	on	IN
18637	15702	31	other	other	JJ
18637	15702	32	points	point	NNS
18637	15702	33	,	,	,
18637	15702	34	did	do	VBD
18637	15702	35	not	not	RB
18637	15702	36	create	create	VB
18637	15702	37	a	a	DT
18637	15702	38	danger	danger	NN
18637	15702	39	to	to	TO
18637	15702	40	fair	fair	VB
18637	15702	41	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15702	42	administration	administration	NN
18637	15702	43	of	of	IN
18637	15702	44	the	the	DT
18637	15702	45	"	"	``
18637	15702	46	clearness	clearness	NN
18637	15702	47	and	and	CC
18637	15702	48	immediacy	immediacy	NN
18637	15702	49	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	15702	50	to	to	TO
18637	15702	51	close	close	VB
18637	15702	52	the	the	DT
18637	15702	53	doors	door	NNS
18637	15702	54	of	of	IN
18637	15702	55	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	15702	56	public	public	JJ
18637	15702	57	comment"[140	comment"[140	NN
18637	15702	58	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15702	59	even	even	RB
18637	15702	60	though	though	IN
18637	15702	61	the	the	DT
18637	15702	62	State	State	NNP
18637	15702	63	court	court	NN
18637	15702	64	held	hold	VBD
18637	15702	65	and	and	CC
18637	15702	66	the	the	DT
18637	15702	67	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15702	68	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15702	69	assumed	assume	VBD
18637	15702	70	that	that	IN
18637	15702	71	"	"	``
18637	15702	72	the	the	DT
18637	15702	73	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	15702	74	deliberately	deliberately	RB
18637	15702	75	distorted	distort	VBD
18637	15702	76	the	the	DT
18637	15702	77	facts	fact	NNS
18637	15702	78	to	to	TO
18637	15702	79	abase	abase	VB
18637	15702	80	and	and	CC
18637	15702	81	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	15702	82	the	the	DT
18637	15702	83	efficiency	efficiency	NN
18637	15702	84	of	of	IN
18637	15702	85	the	the	DT
18637	15702	86	court	court	NN
18637	15702	87	.	.	.
18637	15703	1	"	"	``
18637	15703	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15703	3	141	141	CD
18637	15703	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15703	5	And	and	CC
18637	15703	6	in	in	IN
18637	15703	7	Craig	Craig	NNP
18637	15703	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15703	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	15703	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15703	11	Harney,[142	Harney,[142	NNP
18637	15703	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15703	13	a	a	DT
18637	15703	14	divided	divide	VBN
18637	15703	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15703	16	held	hold	VBD
18637	15703	17	that	that	DT
18637	15703	18	publication	publication	NN
18637	15703	19	,	,	,
18637	15703	20	while	while	IN
18637	15703	21	a	a	DT
18637	15703	22	motion	motion	NN
18637	15703	23	for	for	IN
18637	15703	24	a	a	DT
18637	15703	25	new	new	JJ
18637	15703	26	trial	trial	NN
18637	15703	27	was	be	VBD
18637	15703	28	pending	pende	VBG
18637	15703	29	,	,	,
18637	15703	30	of	of	IN
18637	15703	31	an	an	DT
18637	15703	32	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	15703	33	report	report	NN
18637	15703	34	of	of	IN
18637	15703	35	the	the	DT
18637	15703	36	facts	fact	NNS
18637	15703	37	of	of	IN
18637	15703	38	a	a	DT
18637	15703	39	civil	civil	JJ
18637	15703	40	case	case	NN
18637	15703	41	,	,	,
18637	15703	42	accompanied	accompany	VBN
18637	15703	43	by	by	IN
18637	15703	44	intemperate	intemperate	VB
18637	15703	45	criticism	criticism	NN
18637	15703	46	of	of	IN
18637	15703	47	the	the	DT
18637	15703	48	judge	judge	NN
18637	15703	49	's	's	POS
18637	15703	50	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	15703	51	was	be	VBD
18637	15703	52	protected	protect	VBN
18637	15703	53	by	by	IN
18637	15703	54	the	the	DT
18637	15703	55	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15703	56	.	.	.
18637	15704	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	15704	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15704	3	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	15704	4	,	,	,
18637	15704	5	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15704	6	for	for	IN
18637	15704	7	the	the	DT
18637	15704	8	majority	majority	NN
18637	15704	9	:	:	:
18637	15704	10	"	"	``
18637	15704	11	The	the	DT
18637	15704	12	vehemence	vehemence	NN
18637	15704	13	of	of	IN
18637	15704	14	the	the	DT
18637	15704	15	language	language	NN
18637	15704	16	used	use	VBN
18637	15704	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	15704	18	not	not	RB
18637	15704	19	alone	alone	RB
18637	15704	20	the	the	DT
18637	15704	21	measure	measure	NN
18637	15704	22	of	of	IN
18637	15704	23	the	the	DT
18637	15704	24	power	power	NN
18637	15704	25	to	to	TO
18637	15704	26	publish	publish	VB
18637	15704	27	for	for	IN
18637	15704	28	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	15704	29	.	.	.
18637	15705	1	The	the	DT
18637	15705	2	fires	fire	NNS
18637	15705	3	which	which	WDT
18637	15705	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15705	5	kindles	kindle	VBZ
18637	15705	6	must	must	MD
18637	15705	7	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	15705	8	an	an	DT
18637	15705	9	imminent	imminent	NN
18637	15705	10	,	,	,
18637	15705	11	and	and	CC
18637	15705	12	not	not	RB
18637	15705	13	merely	merely	RB
18637	15705	14	a	a	DT
18637	15705	15	likely	likely	JJ
18637	15705	16	,	,	,
18637	15705	17	threat	threat	NN
18637	15705	18	to	to	IN
18637	15705	19	the	the	DT
18637	15705	20	administration	administration	NN
18637	15705	21	of	of	IN
18637	15705	22	justice	justice	NN
18637	15705	23	.	.	.
18637	15706	1	The	the	DT
18637	15706	2	danger	danger	NN
18637	15706	3	must	must	MD
18637	15706	4	not	not	RB
18637	15706	5	be	be	VB
18637	15706	6	remote	remote	JJ
18637	15706	7	or	or	CC
18637	15706	8	even	even	RB
18637	15706	9	probable	probable	JJ
18637	15706	10	;	;	:
18637	15706	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15706	12	must	must	MD
18637	15706	13	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	15706	14	imperil	imperil	VB
18637	15706	15	.	.	.
18637	15707	1	"	"	``
18637	15707	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15707	3	143	143	CD
18637	15707	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15707	5	FREEDOM	freedom	NN
18637	15707	6	OF	of	IN
18637	15707	7	SPEECH	SPEECH	NNP
18637	15707	8	AND	and	CC
18637	15707	9	PRESS	PRESS	NNP
18637	15707	10	IN	in	IN
18637	15707	11	PUBLIC	PUBLIC	NNP
18637	15707	12	PARKS	parks	NN
18637	15707	13	AND	and	CC
18637	15707	14	STREETS	STREETS	NNP
18637	15707	15	Notable	Notable	NNP
18637	15707	16	also	also	RB
18637	15707	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	15707	18	the	the	DT
18637	15707	19	protection	protection	NN
18637	15707	20	which	which	WDT
18637	15707	21	the	the	DT
18637	15707	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15707	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	15707	24	erected	erect	VBN
18637	15707	25	in	in	IN
18637	15707	26	recent	recent	JJ
18637	15707	27	years	year	NNS
18637	15707	28	for	for	IN
18637	15707	29	those	those	DT
18637	15707	30	who	who	WP
18637	15707	31	desire	desire	VBP
18637	15707	32	to	to	TO
18637	15707	33	use	use	VB
18637	15707	34	the	the	DT
18637	15707	35	streets	street	NNS
18637	15707	36	and	and	CC
18637	15707	37	the	the	DT
18637	15707	38	public	public	JJ
18637	15707	39	parks	park	NNS
18637	15707	40	as	as	IN
18637	15707	41	theatres	theatre	NNS
18637	15707	42	of	of	IN
18637	15707	43	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	15707	44	,	,	,
18637	15707	45	agitation	agitation	NN
18637	15707	46	,	,	,
18637	15707	47	and	and	CC
18637	15707	48	propaganda	propaganda	NN
18637	15707	49	dissemination	dissemination	NN
18637	15707	50	.	.	.
18637	15708	1	In	in	IN
18637	15708	2	1897	1897	CD
18637	15708	3	the	the	DT
18637	15708	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15708	5	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	15708	6	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15708	7	an	an	DT
18637	15708	8	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	15708	9	of	of	IN
18637	15708	10	the	the	DT
18637	15708	11	city	city	NN
18637	15708	12	of	of	IN
18637	15708	13	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	15708	14	which	which	WDT
18637	15708	15	provided	provide	VBD
18637	15708	16	that	that	IN
18637	15708	17	"	"	``
18637	15708	18	no	no	DT
18637	15708	19	person	person	NN
18637	15708	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	15708	21	,	,	,
18637	15708	22	in	in	IN
18637	15708	23	or	or	CC
18637	15708	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	15708	25	any	any	DT
18637	15708	26	of	of	IN
18637	15708	27	the	the	DT
18637	15708	28	public	public	JJ
18637	15708	29	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	15708	30	,	,	,
18637	15708	31	make	make	VBP
18637	15708	32	any	any	DT
18637	15708	33	public	public	JJ
18637	15708	34	address	address	NN
18637	15708	35	,	,	,
18637	15708	36	"	"	''
18637	15708	37	etc	etc	FW
18637	15708	38	.	.	.
18637	15708	39	,	,	,
18637	15708	40	"	"	``
18637	15708	41	except	except	IN
18637	15708	42	in	in	IN
18637	15708	43	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	15708	44	with	with	IN
18637	15708	45	a	a	DT
18637	15708	46	permit	permit	NN
18637	15708	47	of	of	IN
18637	15708	48	the	the	DT
18637	15708	49	Mayor,"[144	mayor,"[144	NN
18637	15708	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15708	51	quoting	quote	VBG
18637	15708	52	with	with	IN
18637	15708	53	approval	approval	NN
18637	15708	54	the	the	DT
18637	15708	55	following	following	JJ
18637	15708	56	language	language	NN
18637	15708	57	from	from	IN
18637	15708	58	the	the	DT
18637	15708	59	decision	decision	NN
18637	15708	60	of	of	IN
18637	15708	61	the	the	DT
18637	15708	62	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	15708	63	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15708	64	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	15708	65	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15708	66	in	in	IN
18637	15708	67	the	the	DT
18637	15708	68	same	same	JJ
18637	15708	69	case	case	NN
18637	15708	70	.	.	.
18637	15709	1	"	"	``
18637	15709	2	For	for	IN
18637	15709	3	the	the	DT
18637	15709	4	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	15709	5	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	15709	6	or	or	CC
18637	15709	7	conditionally	conditionally	RB
18637	15709	8	to	to	TO
18637	15709	9	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	15709	10	public	public	JJ
18637	15709	11	speaking	speaking	NN
18637	15709	12	in	in	IN
18637	15709	13	a	a	DT
18637	15709	14	highway	highway	NN
18637	15709	15	or	or	CC
18637	15709	16	public	public	JJ
18637	15709	17	park	park	NN
18637	15709	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	15709	19	no	no	DT
18637	15709	20	more	more	JJR
18637	15709	21	an	an	DT
18637	15709	22	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	15709	23	of	of	IN
18637	15709	24	the	the	DT
18637	15709	25	rights	right	NNS
18637	15709	26	of	of	IN
18637	15709	27	a	a	DT
18637	15709	28	member	member	NN
18637	15709	29	of	of	IN
18637	15709	30	the	the	DT
18637	15709	31	public	public	NN
18637	15709	32	than	than	IN
18637	15709	33	for	for	IN
18637	15709	34	the	the	DT
18637	15709	35	owner	owner	NN
18637	15709	36	of	of	IN
18637	15709	37	a	a	DT
18637	15709	38	private	private	JJ
18637	15709	39	house	house	NN
18637	15709	40	to	to	TO
18637	15709	41	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	15709	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15709	43	in	in	IN
18637	15709	44	the	the	DT
18637	15709	45	house	house	NN
18637	15709	46	.	.	.
18637	15710	1	When	when	WRB
18637	15710	2	no	no	DT
18637	15710	3	proprietary	proprietary	JJ
18637	15710	4	right	right	NN
18637	15710	5	interferes	interfere	VBZ
18637	15710	6	the	the	DT
18637	15710	7	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	15710	8	may	may	MD
18637	15710	9	end	end	VB
18637	15710	10	the	the	DT
18637	15710	11	right	right	NN
18637	15710	12	of	of	IN
18637	15710	13	the	the	DT
18637	15710	14	public	public	NN
18637	15710	15	to	to	TO
18637	15710	16	enter	enter	VB
18637	15710	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	15710	18	the	the	DT
18637	15710	19	public	public	JJ
18637	15710	20	place	place	NN
18637	15710	21	by	by	IN
18637	15710	22	putting	put	VBG
18637	15710	23	an	an	DT
18637	15710	24	end	end	NN
18637	15710	25	to	to	IN
18637	15710	26	the	the	DT
18637	15710	27	dedication	dedication	NN
18637	15710	28	to	to	IN
18637	15710	29	public	public	JJ
18637	15710	30	uses	use	NNS
18637	15710	31	.	.	.
18637	15711	1	So	so	RB
18637	15711	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15711	3	may	may	MD
18637	15711	4	take	take	VB
18637	15711	5	the	the	DT
18637	15711	6	less	less	JJR
18637	15711	7	step	step	NN
18637	15711	8	of	of	IN
18637	15711	9	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	15711	10	the	the	DT
18637	15711	11	public	public	JJ
18637	15711	12	use	use	NN
18637	15711	13	to	to	IN
18637	15711	14	certain	certain	JJ
18637	15711	15	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	15711	16	.	.	.
18637	15712	1	"	"	``
18637	15712	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15712	3	145	145	CD
18637	15712	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15712	5	Forty	forty	CD
18637	15712	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	15712	7	two	two	CD
18637	15712	8	years	year	NNS
18637	15712	9	later	later	RB
18637	15712	10	this	this	DT
18637	15712	11	case	case	NN
18637	15712	12	was	be	VBD
18637	15712	13	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	15712	14	in	in	IN
18637	15712	15	Hague	Hague	NNP
18637	15712	16	_	_	NNP
18637	15712	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	15712	18	_	_	NNP
18637	15712	19	C.I.O.	C.I.O.	NNP
18637	15713	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15713	2	146	146	CD
18637	15713	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15713	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15713	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15713	6	See	See	NNP
18637	15713	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15713	8	p.	p.	NN
18637	15714	1	808	808	CD
18637	15714	2	.	.	.
18637	15714	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15715	1	And	and	CC
18637	15715	2	in	in	IN
18637	15715	3	1948	1948	CD
18637	15715	4	in	in	IN
18637	15715	5	Saia	Saia	NNP
18637	15715	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15715	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15715	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15715	9	New	New	NNP
18637	15715	10	York[147	york[147	NN
18637	15715	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15715	12	an	an	DT
18637	15715	13	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	15715	14	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	15715	15	the	the	DT
18637	15715	16	use	use	NN
18637	15715	17	of	of	IN
18637	15715	18	sound	sound	JJ
18637	15715	19	amplification	amplification	NN
18637	15715	20	devices	device	NNS
18637	15715	21	by	by	IN
18637	15715	22	which	which	WDT
18637	15715	23	sound	sound	NN
18637	15715	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	15715	25	cast	cast	VBN
18637	15715	26	directly	directly	RB
18637	15715	27	upon	upon	IN
18637	15715	28	the	the	DT
18637	15715	29	streets	street	NNS
18637	15715	30	and	and	CC
18637	15715	31	public	public	JJ
18637	15715	32	places	place	NNS
18637	15715	33	,	,	,
18637	15715	34	except	except	IN
18637	15715	35	with	with	IN
18637	15715	36	permission	permission	NN
18637	15715	37	of	of	IN
18637	15715	38	the	the	DT
18637	15715	39	chief	chief	NN
18637	15715	40	of	of	IN
18637	15715	41	police	police	NNS
18637	15715	42	,	,	,
18637	15715	43	for	for	IN
18637	15715	44	the	the	DT
18637	15715	45	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15715	46	of	of	IN
18637	15715	47	whose	whose	WP$
18637	15715	48	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	15715	49	no	no	DT
18637	15715	50	standards	standard	NNS
18637	15715	51	were	be	VBD
18637	15715	52	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	15715	53	,	,	,
18637	15715	54	was	be	VBD
18637	15715	55	held	hold	VBN
18637	15715	56	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	15715	57	as	as	IN
18637	15715	58	applied	apply	VBN
18637	15715	59	to	to	IN
18637	15715	60	one	one	CD
18637	15715	61	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	15715	62	leave	leave	NN
18637	15715	63	to	to	TO
18637	15715	64	amplify	amplify	VB
18637	15715	65	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15715	66	lectures	lecture	NNS
18637	15715	67	in	in	IN
18637	15715	68	a	a	DT
18637	15715	69	public	public	JJ
18637	15715	70	park	park	NN
18637	15715	71	.	.	.
18637	15716	1	The	the	DT
18637	15716	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	15716	3	was	be	VBD
18637	15716	4	a	a	DT
18637	15716	5	five	five	CD
18637	15716	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	15716	7	to	to	IN
18637	15716	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	15716	9	four	four	CD
18637	15716	10	holding	holding	NN
18637	15716	11	;	;	:
18637	15716	12	and	and	CC
18637	15716	13	eight	eight	CD
18637	15716	14	months	month	NNS
18637	15716	15	later	later	RB
18637	15716	16	a	a	DT
18637	15716	17	majority	majority	NN
18637	15716	18	,	,	,
18637	15716	19	comprising	comprise	VBG
18637	15716	20	the	the	DT
18637	15716	21	former	former	JJ
18637	15716	22	dissenters	dissenter	NNS
18637	15716	23	and	and	CC
18637	15716	24	the	the	DT
18637	15716	25	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15716	26	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15716	27	,	,	,
18637	15716	28	held	hold	VBD
18637	15716	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15716	30	to	to	TO
18637	15716	31	be	be	VB
18637	15716	32	a	a	DT
18637	15716	33	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	15716	34	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15716	35	of	of	IN
18637	15716	36	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	15716	37	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	15716	38	to	to	TO
18637	15716	39	bar	bar	NN
18637	15716	40	sound	sound	NN
18637	15716	41	trucks	truck	NNS
18637	15716	42	,	,	,
18637	15716	43	with	with	IN
18637	15716	44	broadcasts	broadcast	NNS
18637	15716	45	of	of	IN
18637	15716	46	public	public	JJ
18637	15716	47	interest	interest	NN
18637	15716	48	,	,	,
18637	15716	49	amplified	amplify	VBD
18637	15716	50	to	to	IN
18637	15716	51	a	a	DT
18637	15716	52	loud	loud	JJ
18637	15716	53	and	and	CC
18637	15716	54	raucous	raucous	JJ
18637	15716	55	volume	volume	NN
18637	15716	56	,	,	,
18637	15716	57	from	from	IN
18637	15716	58	the	the	DT
18637	15716	59	public	public	JJ
18637	15716	60	ways	way	NNS
18637	15716	61	of	of	IN
18637	15716	62	a	a	DT
18637	15716	63	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	15716	64	.	.	.
18637	15717	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15717	2	148	148	CD
18637	15717	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15717	4	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	15717	5	,	,	,
18637	15717	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15717	7	was	be	VBD
18637	15717	8	within	within	IN
18637	15717	9	the	the	DT
18637	15717	10	power	power	NN
18637	15717	11	of	of	IN
18637	15717	12	the	the	DT
18637	15717	13	Public	Public	NNP
18637	15717	14	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	15717	15	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	15717	16	of	of	IN
18637	15717	17	the	the	DT
18637	15717	18	District	District	NNP
18637	15717	19	of	of	IN
18637	15717	20	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	15717	21	,	,	,
18637	15717	22	following	follow	VBG
18637	15717	23	a	a	DT
18637	15717	24	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	15717	25	and	and	CC
18637	15717	26	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	15717	27	,	,	,
18637	15717	28	to	to	TO
18637	15717	29	issue	issue	VB
18637	15717	30	an	an	DT
18637	15717	31	order	order	NN
18637	15717	32	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	15717	33	the	the	DT
18637	15717	34	Capital	Capital	NNP
18637	15717	35	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	15717	36	Company	Company	NNP
18637	15717	37	,	,	,
18637	15717	38	despite	despite	IN
18637	15717	39	the	the	DT
18637	15717	40	protest	protest	NN
18637	15717	41	of	of	IN
18637	15717	42	some	some	DT
18637	15717	43	of	of	IN
18637	15717	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15717	45	patrons	patron	NNS
18637	15717	46	,	,	,
18637	15717	47	to	to	TO
18637	15717	48	receive	receive	VB
18637	15717	49	and	and	CC
18637	15717	50	amplify	amplify	VB
18637	15717	51	on	on	IN
18637	15717	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15717	53	street	street	NN
18637	15717	54	cars	car	NNS
18637	15717	55	and	and	CC
18637	15717	56	buses	bus	NNS
18637	15717	57	radio	radio	NN
18637	15717	58	programs	program	NNS
18637	15717	59	consisting	consist	VBG
18637	15717	60	generally	generally	RB
18637	15717	61	of	of	IN
18637	15717	62	90	90	CD
18637	15717	63	%	%	NN
18637	15717	64	music	music	NN
18637	15717	65	,	,	,
18637	15717	66	5	5	CD
18637	15717	67	%	%	NN
18637	15717	68	announcements	announcement	NNS
18637	15717	69	,	,	,
18637	15717	70	and	and	CC
18637	15717	71	5	5	CD
18637	15717	72	%	%	NN
18637	15717	73	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	15717	74	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	15717	75	.	.	.
18637	15718	1	Neither	neither	DT
18637	15718	2	operation	operation	NN
18637	15718	3	of	of	IN
18637	15718	4	the	the	DT
18637	15718	5	radio	radio	NN
18637	15718	6	service	service	NN
18637	15718	7	nor	nor	CC
18637	15718	8	the	the	DT
18637	15718	9	action	action	NN
18637	15718	10	of	of	IN
18637	15718	11	the	the	DT
18637	15718	12	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	15718	13	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	15718	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15718	15	was	be	VBD
18637	15718	16	precluded	preclude	VBN
18637	15718	17	by	by	IN
18637	15718	18	the	the	DT
18637	15718	19	First	First	NNP
18637	15718	20	and	and	CC
18637	15718	21	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	15718	22	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	15718	23	.	.	.
18637	15719	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15719	2	149	149	CD
18637	15719	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15719	4	Under	under	IN
18637	15719	5	still	still	RB
18637	15719	6	unoverruled	unoverruled	JJ
18637	15719	7	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	15719	8	an	an	DT
18637	15719	9	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	15719	10	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	15719	11	any	any	DT
18637	15719	12	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	15719	13	of	of	IN
18637	15719	14	circulars	circular	NNS
18637	15719	15	,	,	,
18637	15719	16	handbills	handbill	NNS
18637	15719	17	,	,	,
18637	15719	18	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	15719	19	,	,	,
18637	15719	20	or	or	CC
18637	15719	21	literature	literature	NN
18637	15719	22	of	of	IN
18637	15719	23	any	any	DT
18637	15719	24	kind	kind	NN
18637	15719	25	within	within	IN
18637	15719	26	the	the	DT
18637	15719	27	city	city	NN
18637	15719	28	limits	limit	NNS
18637	15719	29	without	without	IN
18637	15719	30	permission	permission	NN
18637	15719	31	of	of	IN
18637	15719	32	the	the	DT
18637	15719	33	City	City	NNP
18637	15719	34	Manager	Manager	NNP
18637	15719	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	15719	36	an	an	DT
18637	15719	37	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	15719	38	abridgment	abridgment	NN
18637	15719	39	of	of	IN
18637	15719	40	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15719	41	of	of	IN
18637	15719	42	the	the	DT
18637	15719	43	press	press	NN
18637	15719	44	.	.	.
18637	15720	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15720	2	150	150	CD
18637	15720	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15720	4	So	so	RB
18637	15720	5	also	also	RB
18637	15720	6	are	be	VBP
18637	15720	7	ordinances	ordinance	NNS
18637	15720	8	which	which	WDT
18637	15720	9	forbid	forbid	VBP
18637	15720	10	,	,	,
18637	15720	11	without	without	IN
18637	15720	12	exception	exception	NN
18637	15720	13	,	,	,
18637	15720	14	any	any	DT
18637	15720	15	distributions	distribution	NNS
18637	15720	16	of	of	IN
18637	15720	17	handbills	handbill	NNS
18637	15720	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	15720	19	the	the	DT
18637	15720	20	streets	street	NNS
18637	15720	21	.	.	.
18637	15721	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15721	2	151	151	CD
18637	15721	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15721	4	Even	even	RB
18637	15721	5	where	where	WRB
18637	15721	6	such	such	JJ
18637	15721	7	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	15721	8	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	15721	9	a	a	DT
18637	15721	10	trespass	trespass	NN
18637	15721	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	15721	12	private	private	JJ
18637	15721	13	property	property	NN
18637	15721	14	in	in	IN
18637	15721	15	a	a	DT
18637	15721	16	company	company	NN
18637	15721	17	owned	own	VBN
18637	15721	18	town,[152	town,[152	NN
18637	15721	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15721	20	or	or	CC
18637	15721	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	15721	22	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15721	23	property	property	NN
18637	15721	24	in	in	IN
18637	15721	25	a	a	DT
18637	15721	26	defense	defense	NN
18637	15721	27	housing	housing	NN
18637	15721	28	development,[153	development,[153	JJ
18637	15721	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15721	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15721	31	can	can	MD
18637	15721	32	not	not	RB
18637	15721	33	be	be	VB
18637	15721	34	stopped	stop	VBN
18637	15721	35	.	.	.
18637	15722	1	The	the	DT
18637	15722	2	passing	pass	VBG
18637	15722	3	out	out	RP
18637	15722	4	of	of	IN
18637	15722	5	handbills	handbill	NNS
18637	15722	6	containing	contain	VBG
18637	15722	7	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	15722	8	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	15722	9	may	may	MD
18637	15722	10	,	,	,
18637	15722	11	however	however	RB
18637	15722	12	,	,	,
18637	15722	13	be	be	VB
18637	15722	14	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	15722	15	;	;	:
18637	15722	16	this	this	DT
18637	15722	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	15722	18	true	true	JJ
18637	15722	19	even	even	RB
18637	15722	20	where	where	WRB
18637	15722	21	such	such	JJ
18637	15722	22	handbills	handbill	NNS
18637	15722	23	may	may	MD
18637	15722	24	contain	contain	VB
18637	15722	25	some	some	DT
18637	15722	26	matter	matter	NN
18637	15722	27	which	which	WDT
18637	15722	28	,	,	,
18637	15722	29	standing	stand	VBG
18637	15722	30	alone	alone	RB
18637	15722	31	would	would	MD
18637	15722	32	be	be	VB
18637	15722	33	immune	immune	JJ
18637	15722	34	from	from	IN
18637	15722	35	the	the	DT
18637	15722	36	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	15722	37	.	.	.
18637	15723	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15723	2	154	154	CD
18637	15723	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15723	4	A	a	DT
18637	15723	5	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	15723	6	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	15723	7	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	15723	8	any	any	DT
18637	15723	9	person	person	NN
18637	15723	10	to	to	TO
18637	15723	11	ring	ring	VB
18637	15723	12	door	door	NN
18637	15723	13	bells	bell	NNS
18637	15723	14	,	,	,
18637	15723	15	or	or	CC
18637	15723	16	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	15723	17	summon	summon	NNP
18637	15723	18	to	to	IN
18637	15723	19	the	the	DT
18637	15723	20	door	door	NN
18637	15723	21	the	the	DT
18637	15723	22	occupants	occupant	NNS
18637	15723	23	of	of	IN
18637	15723	24	any	any	DT
18637	15723	25	residence	residence	NN
18637	15723	26	,	,	,
18637	15723	27	for	for	IN
18637	15723	28	the	the	DT
18637	15723	29	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15723	30	of	of	IN
18637	15723	31	distributing	distribute	VBG
18637	15723	32	to	to	IN
18637	15723	33	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15723	34	circulars	circular	VBZ
18637	15723	35	or	or	CC
18637	15723	36	handbills	handbill	NNS
18637	15723	37	was	be	VBD
18637	15723	38	held	hold	VBN
18637	15723	39	to	to	TO
18637	15723	40	infringe	infringe	VB
18637	15723	41	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15723	42	of	of	IN
18637	15723	43	speech	speech	NN
18637	15723	44	and	and	CC
18637	15723	45	of	of	IN
18637	15723	46	the	the	DT
18637	15723	47	press	press	NN
18637	15723	48	as	as	IN
18637	15723	49	applied	apply	VBN
18637	15723	50	to	to	IN
18637	15723	51	a	a	DT
18637	15723	52	person	person	NN
18637	15723	53	distributing	distribute	VBG
18637	15723	54	advertisements	advertisement	NNS
18637	15723	55	of	of	IN
18637	15723	56	a	a	DT
18637	15723	57	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15723	58	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	15723	59	.	.	.
18637	15724	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15724	2	155	155	CD
18637	15724	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15724	4	But	but	CC
18637	15724	5	an	an	DT
18637	15724	6	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	15724	7	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	15724	8	door	door	NN
18637	15724	9	to	to	TO
18637	15724	10	door	door	NN
18637	15724	11	peddling	peddling	NN
18637	15724	12	or	or	CC
18637	15724	13	canvassing	canvass	VBG
18637	15724	14	unless	unless	IN
18637	15724	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15724	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	15724	17	invited	invite	VBN
18637	15724	18	or	or	CC
18637	15724	19	requested	request	VBN
18637	15724	20	by	by	IN
18637	15724	21	the	the	DT
18637	15724	22	occupant	occupant	NN
18637	15724	23	of	of	IN
18637	15724	24	a	a	DT
18637	15724	25	private	private	JJ
18637	15724	26	residence	residence	NN
18637	15724	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	15724	28	valid	valid	JJ
18637	15724	29	.	.	.
18637	15725	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15725	2	156	156	CD
18637	15725	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15725	4	CENSORSHIP	CENSORSHIP	NNP
18637	15725	5	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	15725	6	from	from	IN
18637	15725	7	previous	previous	JJ
18637	15725	8	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	15725	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	15725	10	never	never	RB
18637	15725	11	been	be	VBN
18637	15725	12	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	15725	13	as	as	IN
18637	15725	14	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	15725	15	.	.	.
18637	15726	1	The	the	DT
18637	15726	2	principle	principle	NN
18637	15726	3	that	that	WDT
18637	15726	4	words	word	VBZ
18637	15726	5	having	have	VBG
18637	15726	6	the	the	DT
18637	15726	7	quality	quality	NN
18637	15726	8	of	of	IN
18637	15726	9	verbal	verbal	JJ
18637	15726	10	acts	act	NNS
18637	15726	11	might	may	MD
18637	15726	12	be	be	VB
18637	15726	13	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	15726	14	by	by	IN
18637	15726	15	court	court	NN
18637	15726	16	order	order	NN
18637	15726	17	was	be	VBD
18637	15726	18	established	establish	VBN
18637	15726	19	in	in	IN
18637	15726	20	Gompers	Gompers	NNP
18637	15726	21	_	_	NNP
18637	15726	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	15726	23	_	_	NNP
18637	15726	24	Bucks	Bucks	NNPS
18637	15726	25	Stove	Stove	NNP
18637	15726	26	and	and	CC
18637	15726	27	Range	Range	NNP
18637	15726	28	Co.;[157	Co.;[157	NNP
18637	15726	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15726	30	and	and	CC
18637	15726	31	in	in	IN
18637	15726	32	Near	Near	NNP
18637	15726	33	_	_	NNP
18637	15726	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	15726	35	_	_	NNP
18637	15726	36	Minnesota[158	Minnesota[158	NNP
18637	15726	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15726	38	the	the	DT
18637	15726	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15726	40	,	,	,
18637	15726	41	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15726	42	through	through	IN
18637	15726	43	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15726	44	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15726	45	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	15726	46	,	,	,
18637	15726	47	even	even	RB
18637	15726	48	while	while	IN
18637	15726	49	extending	extend	VBG
18637	15726	50	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
18637	15726	51	's	's	POS
18637	15726	52	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	15726	53	of	of	IN
18637	15726	54	censorship	censorship	NN
18637	15726	55	to	to	IN
18637	15726	56	a	a	DT
18637	15726	57	statute	statute	NN
18637	15726	58	which	which	WDT
18637	15726	59	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	15726	60	the	the	DT
18637	15726	61	enjoining	enjoining	NN
18637	15726	62	of	of	IN
18637	15726	63	publications	publication	NNS
18637	15726	64	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	15726	65	to	to	TO
18637	15726	66	be	be	VB
18637	15726	67	persistently	persistently	RB
18637	15726	68	defamatory	defamatory	JJ
18637	15726	69	,	,	,
18637	15726	70	criticized	criticize	VBD
18637	15726	71	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15726	72	as	as	IN
18637	15726	73	being	be	VBG
18637	15726	74	in	in	IN
18637	15726	75	some	some	DT
18637	15726	76	respects	respect	NNS
18637	15726	77	too	too	RB
18637	15726	78	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	15726	79	.	.	.
18637	15727	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	15727	2	,	,	,
18637	15727	3	the	the	DT
18637	15727	4	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	15727	5	between	between	IN
18637	15727	6	prevention	prevention	NN
18637	15727	7	and	and	CC
18637	15727	8	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15727	9	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	15727	10	to	to	TO
18637	15727	11	have	have	VB
18637	15727	12	played	play	VBN
18637	15727	13	little	little	JJ
18637	15727	14	or	or	CC
18637	15727	15	no	no	DT
18637	15727	16	part	part	NN
18637	15727	17	in	in	IN
18637	15727	18	determining	determine	VBG
18637	15727	19	when	when	WRB
18637	15727	20	picketing	picket	VBG
18637	15727	21	may	may	MD
18637	15727	22	be	be	VB
18637	15727	23	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	15727	24	in	in	IN
18637	15727	25	labor	labor	NN
18637	15727	26	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	15727	27	.	.	.
18637	15728	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15728	2	159	159	CD
18637	15728	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15728	4	In	in	IN
18637	15728	5	Chaplinsky	Chaplinsky	NNP
18637	15728	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15728	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15728	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15728	9	New	New	NNP
18637	15728	10	Hampshire[160	Hampshire[160	NNP
18637	15728	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15728	12	and	and	CC
18637	15728	13	Board	Board	NNP
18637	15728	14	of	of	IN
18637	15728	15	Education	Education	NNP
18637	15728	16	_	_	NNP
18637	15728	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	15728	18	_	_	NNP
18637	15728	19	Barnette,[161	Barnette,[161	NNP
18637	15728	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15728	21	the	the	DT
18637	15728	22	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	15728	23	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	15728	24	that	that	IN
18637	15728	25	the	the	DT
18637	15728	26	power	power	NN
18637	15728	27	of	of	IN
18637	15728	28	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15728	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	15728	30	measured	measure	VBN
18637	15728	31	by	by	IN
18637	15728	32	the	the	DT
18637	15728	33	same	same	JJ
18637	15728	34	principles	principle	NNS
18637	15728	35	in	in	IN
18637	15728	36	both	both	DT
18637	15728	37	situations	situation	NNS
18637	15728	38	.	.	.
18637	15729	1	In	in	IN
18637	15729	2	the	the	DT
18637	15729	3	former	former	JJ
18637	15729	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15729	5	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	15729	6	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	15729	7	:	:	:
18637	15729	8	"	"	``
18637	15729	9	There	there	EX
18637	15729	10	are	be	VBP
18637	15729	11	certain	certain	JJ
18637	15729	12	well	well	RB
18637	15729	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	15729	14	defined	define	VBN
18637	15729	15	and	and	CC
18637	15729	16	narrowly	narrowly	RB
18637	15729	17	limited	limited	JJ
18637	15729	18	classes	class	NNS
18637	15729	19	of	of	IN
18637	15729	20	speech	speech	NN
18637	15729	21	,	,	,
18637	15729	22	the	the	DT
18637	15729	23	prevention	prevention	NN
18637	15729	24	and	and	CC
18637	15729	25	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15729	26	of	of	IN
18637	15729	27	which	which	WDT
18637	15729	28	have	have	VBP
18637	15729	29	never	never	RB
18637	15729	30	been	be	VBN
18637	15729	31	thought	think	VBN
18637	15729	32	to	to	TO
18637	15729	33	raise	raise	VB
18637	15729	34	any	any	DT
18637	15729	35	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15729	36	problem	problem	NN
18637	15729	37	.	.	.
18637	15730	1	These	these	DT
18637	15730	2	include	include	VBP
18637	15730	3	the	the	DT
18637	15730	4	lewd	lewd	NNS
18637	15730	5	and	and	CC
18637	15730	6	obscene	obscene	JJ
18637	15730	7	,	,	,
18637	15730	8	the	the	DT
18637	15730	9	profane	profane	NN
18637	15730	10	,	,	,
18637	15730	11	the	the	DT
18637	15730	12	libelous	libelous	JJ
18637	15730	13	,	,	,
18637	15730	14	and	and	CC
18637	15730	15	the	the	DT
18637	15730	16	insulting	insulting	JJ
18637	15730	17	or	or	CC
18637	15730	18	'	'	``
18637	15730	19	fighting	fight	VBG
18637	15730	20	'	'	''
18637	15730	21	words	word	NNS
18637	15730	22	--	--	:
18637	15730	23	those	those	DT
18637	15730	24	which	which	WDT
18637	15730	25	by	by	IN
18637	15730	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15730	27	very	very	JJ
18637	15730	28	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	15730	29	inflict	inflict	VB
18637	15730	30	injury	injury	NN
18637	15730	31	or	or	CC
18637	15730	32	tend	tend	VBP
18637	15730	33	to	to	TO
18637	15730	34	incite	incite	VB
18637	15730	35	an	an	DT
18637	15730	36	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	15730	37	breach	breach	NN
18637	15730	38	of	of	IN
18637	15730	39	the	the	DT
18637	15730	40	peace	peace	NN
18637	15730	41	.	.	.
18637	15731	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15731	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	15731	3	been	be	VBN
18637	15731	4	well	well	RB
18637	15731	5	observed	observe	VBN
18637	15731	6	that	that	IN
18637	15731	7	such	such	JJ
18637	15731	8	are	be	VBP
18637	15731	9	no	no	DT
18637	15731	10	essential	essential	JJ
18637	15731	11	part	part	NN
18637	15731	12	of	of	IN
18637	15731	13	any	any	DT
18637	15731	14	exposition	exposition	NN
18637	15731	15	of	of	IN
18637	15731	16	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	15731	17	,	,	,
18637	15731	18	and	and	CC
18637	15731	19	are	be	VBP
18637	15731	20	of	of	IN
18637	15731	21	such	such	JJ
18637	15731	22	slight	slight	JJ
18637	15731	23	social	social	JJ
18637	15731	24	value	value	NN
18637	15731	25	as	as	IN
18637	15731	26	a	a	DT
18637	15731	27	step	step	NN
18637	15731	28	to	to	IN
18637	15731	29	truth	truth	NN
18637	15731	30	that	that	IN
18637	15731	31	any	any	DT
18637	15731	32	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	15731	33	that	that	WDT
18637	15731	34	may	may	MD
18637	15731	35	be	be	VB
18637	15731	36	derived	derive	VBN
18637	15731	37	from	from	IN
18637	15731	38	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15731	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	15731	40	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	15731	41	outweighed	outweigh	VBN
18637	15731	42	by	by	IN
18637	15731	43	the	the	DT
18637	15731	44	social	social	JJ
18637	15731	45	interest	interest	NN
18637	15731	46	in	in	IN
18637	15731	47	order	order	NN
18637	15731	48	and	and	CC
18637	15731	49	morality	morality	NN
18637	15731	50	.	.	.
18637	15732	1	"	"	``
18637	15732	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15732	3	162	162	CD
18637	15732	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15732	5	To	to	TO
18637	15732	6	like	like	IN
18637	15732	7	effect	effect	NN
18637	15732	8	,	,	,
18637	15732	9	in	in	IN
18637	15732	10	Board	Board	NNP
18637	15732	11	of	of	IN
18637	15732	12	Education	Education	NNP
18637	15732	13	_	_	NNP
18637	15732	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	15732	15	_	_	NNP
18637	15732	16	Barnette	Barnette	NNP
18637	15732	17	,	,	,
18637	15732	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15732	19	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	15732	20	set	set	VBD
18637	15732	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15732	22	down	down	RP
18637	15732	23	as	as	IN
18637	15732	24	"	"	``
18637	15732	25	a	a	DT
18637	15732	26	commonplace	commonplace	NN
18637	15732	27	that	that	WDT
18637	15732	28	censorship	censorship	NN
18637	15732	29	or	or	CC
18637	15732	30	suppression	suppression	NN
18637	15732	31	of	of	IN
18637	15732	32	expression	expression	NN
18637	15732	33	of	of	IN
18637	15732	34	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15732	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	15732	36	tolerated	tolerate	VBN
18637	15732	37	by	by	IN
18637	15732	38	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15732	39	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15732	40	only	only	RB
18637	15732	41	when	when	WRB
18637	15732	42	the	the	DT
18637	15732	43	expression	expression	NN
18637	15732	44	presents	present	VBZ
18637	15732	45	a	a	DT
18637	15732	46	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15732	47	and	and	CC
18637	15732	48	present	present	JJ
18637	15732	49	danger	danger	NN
18637	15732	50	of	of	IN
18637	15732	51	action	action	NN
18637	15732	52	of	of	IN
18637	15732	53	a	a	DT
18637	15732	54	kind	kind	NN
18637	15732	55	the	the	DT
18637	15732	56	State	state	NN
18637	15732	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	15732	58	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	15732	59	to	to	TO
18637	15732	60	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	15732	61	and	and	CC
18637	15732	62	punish	punish	VB
18637	15732	63	.	.	.
18637	15733	1	"	"	``
18637	15733	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15733	3	163	163	CD
18637	15733	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15733	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15733	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	15733	7	significant	significant	JJ
18637	15733	8	that	that	IN
18637	15733	9	the	the	DT
18637	15733	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	15733	11	which	which	WDT
18637	15733	12	have	have	VBP
18637	15733	13	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
18637	15733	14	previous	previous	JJ
18637	15733	15	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	15733	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	15733	17	the	the	DT
18637	15733	18	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	15733	19	of	of	IN
18637	15733	20	particular	particular	JJ
18637	15733	21	persons	person	NNS
18637	15733	22	have	have	VBP
18637	15733	23	involved	involve	VBN
18637	15733	24	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	15733	25	by	by	IN
18637	15733	26	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15733	27	,	,	,
18637	15733	28	not	not	RB
18637	15733	29	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	15733	30	action	action	NN
18637	15733	31	.	.	.
18637	15734	1	The	the	DT
18637	15734	2	prime	prime	JJ
18637	15734	3	objective	objective	NN
18637	15734	4	of	of	IN
18637	15734	5	the	the	DT
18637	15734	6	ban	ban	NN
18637	15734	7	on	on	IN
18637	15734	8	previous	previous	JJ
18637	15734	9	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	15734	10	was	be	VBD
18637	15734	11	to	to	TO
18637	15734	12	outlaw	outlaw	VB
18637	15734	13	censorship	censorship	NN
18637	15734	14	accomplished	accomplish	VBN
18637	15734	15	by	by	IN
18637	15734	16	licensing	license	VBG
18637	15734	17	.	.	.
18637	15735	1	"	"	``
18637	15735	2	The	the	DT
18637	15735	3	struggle	struggle	NN
18637	15735	4	for	for	IN
18637	15735	5	the	the	DT
18637	15735	6	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15735	7	of	of	IN
18637	15735	8	the	the	DT
18637	15735	9	press	press	NN
18637	15735	10	was	be	VBD
18637	15735	11	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	15735	12	directed	direct	VBN
18637	15735	13	against	against	IN
18637	15735	14	the	the	DT
18637	15735	15	power	power	NN
18637	15735	16	of	of	IN
18637	15735	17	the	the	DT
18637	15735	18	licensor	licensor	NN
18637	15735	19	.	.	.
18637	15736	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15736	2	was	be	VBD
18637	15736	3	against	against	IN
18637	15736	4	that	that	DT
18637	15736	5	power	power	NN
18637	15736	6	that	that	IN
18637	15736	7	John	John	NNP
18637	15736	8	Milton	Milton	NNP
18637	15736	9	directed	direct	VBD
18637	15736	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15736	11	assault	assault	NN
18637	15736	12	by	by	IN
18637	15736	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15736	14	'	'	``
18637	15736	15	Appeal	appeal	NN
18637	15736	16	for	for	IN
18637	15736	17	the	the	DT
18637	15736	18	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	15736	19	of	of	IN
18637	15736	20	Unlicensed	Unlicensed	NNP
18637	15736	21	Printing	Printing	NNP
18637	15736	22	.	.	.
18637	15736	23	'	'	''
18637	15737	1	And	and	CC
18637	15737	2	the	the	DT
18637	15737	3	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15737	4	of	of	IN
18637	15737	5	the	the	DT
18637	15737	6	press	press	NN
18637	15737	7	became	become	VBD
18637	15737	8	initially	initially	RB
18637	15737	9	a	a	DT
18637	15737	10	right	right	NN
18637	15737	11	to	to	TO
18637	15737	12	publish	publish	VB
18637	15737	13	'	'	''
18637	15737	14	_	_	NNP
18637	15737	15	without	without	IN
18637	15737	16	_	_	NNP
18637	15737	17	a	a	DT
18637	15737	18	license	license	NN
18637	15737	19	what	what	WP
18637	15737	20	formerly	formerly	RB
18637	15737	21	could	could	MD
18637	15737	22	be	be	VB
18637	15737	23	published	publish	VBN
18637	15737	24	only	only	RB
18637	15737	25	_	_	NNP
18637	15737	26	with	with	IN
18637	15737	27	one	one	CD
18637	15737	28	_	_	NNP
18637	15737	29	'	'	''
18637	15737	30	.	.	.
18637	15738	1	"	"	``
18637	15738	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15738	3	164	164	CD
18637	15738	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15738	5	Even	even	RB
18637	15738	6	today	today	NN
18637	15738	7	,	,	,
18637	15738	8	a	a	DT
18637	15738	9	licensing	licensing	NN
18637	15738	10	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	15738	11	will	will	MD
18637	15738	12	bring	bring	VB
18637	15738	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15738	14	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	15738	15	more	more	RBR
18637	15738	16	surely	surely	RB
18637	15738	17	than	than	IN
18637	15738	18	any	any	DT
18637	15738	19	other	other	JJ
18637	15738	20	form	form	NN
18637	15738	21	of	of	IN
18637	15738	22	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	15738	23	.	.	.
18637	15739	1	Except	except	IN
18637	15739	2	where	where	WRB
18637	15739	3	the	the	DT
18637	15739	4	authority	authority	NN
18637	15739	5	of	of	IN
18637	15739	6	the	the	DT
18637	15739	7	licensing	licensing	NN
18637	15739	8	officer	officer	NN
18637	15739	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	15739	10	so	so	RB
18637	15739	11	closely	closely	RB
18637	15739	12	limited	limited	JJ
18637	15739	13	as	as	IN
18637	15739	14	to	to	TO
18637	15739	15	leave	leave	VB
18637	15739	16	no	no	DT
18637	15739	17	room	room	NN
18637	15739	18	for	for	IN
18637	15739	19	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	15739	20	against	against	IN
18637	15739	21	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	15739	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15739	23	does	do	VBZ
18637	15739	24	not	not	RB
18637	15739	25	approve,[165	approve,[165	VB
18637	15739	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15739	27	the	the	DT
18637	15739	28	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15739	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15739	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	15739	31	struck	strike	VBN
18637	15739	32	down	down	RP
18637	15739	33	licensing	licensing	NN
18637	15739	34	ordinances	ordinance	NNS
18637	15739	35	,	,	,
18637	15739	36	even	even	RB
18637	15739	37	in	in	IN
18637	15739	38	respect	respect	NN
18637	15739	39	of	of	IN
18637	15739	40	a	a	DT
18637	15739	41	form	form	NN
18637	15739	42	of	of	IN
18637	15739	43	communication	communication	NN
18637	15739	44	which	which	WDT
18637	15739	45	may	may	MD
18637	15739	46	be	be	VB
18637	15739	47	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	15739	48	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	15739	49	.	.	.
18637	15740	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15740	2	166	166	CD
18637	15740	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15740	4	In	in	IN
18637	15740	5	the	the	DT
18637	15740	6	case	case	NN
18637	15740	7	of	of	IN
18637	15740	8	radio	radio	NN
18637	15740	9	broadcasting	broadcasting	NN
18637	15740	10	,	,	,
18637	15740	11	however	however	RB
18637	15740	12	,	,	,
18637	15740	13	where	where	WRB
18637	15740	14	physical	physical	JJ
18637	15740	15	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	15740	16	make	make	VBP
18637	15740	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15740	18	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	15740	19	for	for	IN
18637	15740	20	everyone	everyone	NN
18637	15740	21	to	to	TO
18637	15740	22	utilize	utilize	VB
18637	15740	23	the	the	DT
18637	15740	24	medium	medium	NN
18637	15740	25	of	of	IN
18637	15740	26	communication	communication	NN
18637	15740	27	,	,	,
18637	15740	28	the	the	DT
18637	15740	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15740	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	15740	31	thus	thus	RB
18637	15740	32	far	far	RB
18637	15740	33	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
18637	15740	34	a	a	DT
18637	15740	35	power	power	NN
18637	15740	36	of	of	IN
18637	15740	37	selective	selective	JJ
18637	15740	38	licensing;[167	licensing;[167	NNS
18637	15740	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15740	40	while	while	IN
18637	15740	41	with	with	IN
18637	15740	42	respect	respect	NN
18637	15740	43	to	to	IN
18637	15740	44	moving	move	VBG
18637	15740	45	pictures	picture	NNS
18637	15740	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15740	47	has	have	VBZ
18637	15740	48	until	until	IN
18637	15740	49	very	very	RB
18637	15740	50	recently	recently	RB
18637	15740	51	held	hold	VBN
18637	15740	52	the	the	DT
18637	15740	53	States	States	NNPS
18637	15740	54	'	'	POS
18637	15740	55	power	power	NN
18637	15740	56	to	to	TO
18637	15740	57	license	license	VB
18637	15740	58	,	,	,
18637	15740	59	and	and	CC
18637	15740	60	hence	hence	RB
18637	15740	61	to	to	TO
18637	15740	62	censor	censor	VB
18637	15740	63	,	,	,
18637	15740	64	films	film	NNS
18637	15740	65	intended	intend	VBN
18637	15740	66	for	for	IN
18637	15740	67	local	local	JJ
18637	15740	68	exhibition	exhibition	NN
18637	15740	69	to	to	TO
18637	15740	70	be	be	VB
18637	15740	71	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	15740	72	unrestricted	unrestricte	VBN
18637	15740	73	,	,	,
18637	15740	74	this	this	DT
18637	15740	75	being	be	VBG
18637	15740	76	"	"	``
18637	15740	77	a	a	DT
18637	15740	78	business	business	NN
18637	15740	79	pure	pure	JJ
18637	15740	80	and	and	CC
18637	15740	81	simple	simple	JJ
18637	15740	82	,	,	,
18637	15740	83	originated	originate	VBD
18637	15740	84	and	and	CC
18637	15740	85	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	15740	86	for	for	IN
18637	15740	87	profit	profit	NN
18637	15740	88	,	,	,
18637	15740	89	"	"	''
18637	15740	90	and	and	CC
18637	15740	91	"	"	``
18637	15740	92	not	not	RB
18637	15740	93	to	to	TO
18637	15740	94	be	be	VB
18637	15740	95	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	15740	96	,	,	,
18637	15740	97	...	...	:
18637	15740	98	as	as	IN
18637	15740	99	part	part	NN
18637	15740	100	of	of	IN
18637	15740	101	the	the	DT
18637	15740	102	press	press	NN
18637	15740	103	of	of	IN
18637	15740	104	the	the	DT
18637	15740	105	country	country	NN
18637	15740	106	or	or	CC
18637	15740	107	as	as	IN
18637	15740	108	organs	organ	NNS
18637	15740	109	of	of	IN
18637	15740	110	public	public	JJ
18637	15740	111	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15740	112	.	.	.
18637	15741	1	"	"	``
18637	15741	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15741	3	168	168	CD
18637	15741	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15741	5	This	this	DT
18637	15741	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15741	7	was	be	VBD
18637	15741	8	laid	lay	VBN
18637	15741	9	down	down	RP
18637	15741	10	in	in	IN
18637	15741	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	15741	12	,	,	,
18637	15741	13	but	but	CC
18637	15741	14	in	in	IN
18637	15741	15	1948	1948	CD
18637	15741	16	,	,	,
18637	15741	17	in	in	IN
18637	15741	18	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15741	19	for	for	IN
18637	15741	20	the	the	DT
18637	15741	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15741	22	,	,	,
18637	15741	23	in	in	IN
18637	15741	24	United	United	NNP
18637	15741	25	States	States	NNP
18637	15741	26	_	_	NNP
18637	15741	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	15741	28	_	_	NNP
18637	15741	29	Paramount	Paramount	NNP
18637	15741	30	Pictures,[169	Pictures,[169	NNP
18637	15741	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15741	32	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15741	33	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	15741	34	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	15741	35	a	a	DT
18637	15741	36	very	very	RB
18637	15741	37	different	different	JJ
18637	15741	38	position	position	NN
18637	15741	39	,	,	,
18637	15741	40	saying	say	VBG
18637	15741	41	:	:	:
18637	15741	42	"	"	``
18637	15741	43	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15741	44	have	have	VBP
18637	15741	45	no	no	DT
18637	15741	46	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	15741	47	that	that	IN
18637	15741	48	moving	move	VBG
18637	15741	49	pictures	picture	NNS
18637	15741	50	,	,	,
18637	15741	51	like	like	IN
18637	15741	52	newspapers	newspaper	NNS
18637	15741	53	and	and	CC
18637	15741	54	radio	radio	NN
18637	15741	55	,	,	,
18637	15741	56	are	be	VBP
18637	15741	57	included	include	VBN
18637	15741	58	in	in	IN
18637	15741	59	the	the	DT
18637	15741	60	press	press	NN
18637	15741	61	whose	whose	WP$
18637	15741	62	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15741	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	15741	64	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	15741	65	by	by	IN
18637	15741	66	the	the	DT
18637	15741	67	First	First	NNP
18637	15741	68	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15741	69	.	.	.
18637	15742	1	"	"	``
18637	15742	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15742	3	170	170	CD
18637	15742	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15742	5	In	in	IN
18637	15742	6	the	the	DT
18637	15742	7	so	so	RB
18637	15742	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	15742	9	called	call	VBN
18637	15742	10	"	"	``
18637	15742	11	Miracle	Miracle	NNP
18637	15742	12	Case,"[171	Case,"[171	NNP
18637	15742	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15742	14	in	in	IN
18637	15742	15	which	which	WDT
18637	15742	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15742	17	was	be	VBD
18637	15742	18	held	hold	VBN
18637	15742	19	that	that	IN
18637	15742	20	under	under	IN
18637	15742	21	the	the	DT
18637	15742	22	First	first	JJ
18637	15742	23	and	and	CC
18637	15742	24	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15742	25	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	15742	26	,	,	,
18637	15742	27	a	a	DT
18637	15742	28	State	state	NN
18637	15742	29	may	may	MD
18637	15742	30	not	not	RB
18637	15742	31	place	place	VB
18637	15742	32	a	a	DT
18637	15742	33	prior	prior	JJ
18637	15742	34	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	15742	35	on	on	IN
18637	15742	36	the	the	DT
18637	15742	37	showing	showing	NN
18637	15742	38	of	of	IN
18637	15742	39	a	a	DT
18637	15742	40	motion	motion	NN
18637	15742	41	picture	picture	NN
18637	15742	42	film	film	NN
18637	15742	43	on	on	IN
18637	15742	44	the	the	DT
18637	15742	45	basis	basis	NN
18637	15742	46	of	of	IN
18637	15742	47	the	the	DT
18637	15742	48	censor	censor	NN
18637	15742	49	's	's	POS
18637	15742	50	finding	finding	NN
18637	15742	51	that	that	IN
18637	15742	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15742	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	15742	54	"	"	``
18637	15742	55	sacrilegious	sacrilegious	JJ
18637	15742	56	,	,	,
18637	15742	57	"	"	''
18637	15742	58	a	a	DT
18637	15742	59	word	word	NN
18637	15742	60	of	of	IN
18637	15742	61	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
18637	15742	62	connotation	connotation	NN
18637	15742	63	,	,	,
18637	15742	64	this	this	DT
18637	15742	65	point	point	NN
18637	15742	66	of	of	IN
18637	15742	67	view	view	NN
18637	15742	68	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	15742	69	the	the	DT
18637	15742	70	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15742	71	of	of	IN
18637	15742	72	the	the	DT
18637	15742	73	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15742	74	and	and	CC
18637	15742	75	the	the	DT
18637	15742	76	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	15742	77	Films	Films	NNPS
18637	15742	78	Case	Case	NNP
18637	15742	79	is	be	VBZ
18637	15742	80	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
18637	15742	81	"	"	``
18637	15742	82	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	15742	83	"	"	''
18637	15742	84	so	so	RB
18637	15742	85	far	far	RB
18637	15742	86	as	as	IN
18637	15742	87	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15742	88	is	be	VBZ
18637	15742	89	out	out	IN
18637	15742	90	of	of	IN
18637	15742	91	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	15742	92	with	with	IN
18637	15742	93	the	the	DT
18637	15742	94	instant	instant	JJ
18637	15742	95	holding	holding	NN
18637	15742	96	.	.	.
18637	15743	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15743	2	172	172	CD
18637	15743	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15743	4	THE	the	DT
18637	15743	5	CLEAR	CLEAR	NNP
18637	15743	6	AND	and	CC
18637	15743	7	PRESENT	PRESENT	NNP
18637	15743	8	DANGER	danger	NN
18637	15743	9	TEST	test	NN
18637	15743	10	:	:	:
18637	15743	11	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	15743	12	DIVERSITIES	diversity	NNS
18637	15743	13	In	in	IN
18637	15743	14	the	the	DT
18637	15743	15	course	course	NN
18637	15743	16	of	of	IN
18637	15743	17	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	15743	18	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	15743	19	this	this	DT
18637	15743	20	test	test	NN
18637	15743	21	of	of	IN
18637	15743	22	state	state	NN
18637	15743	23	action	action	NN
18637	15743	24	with	with	IN
18637	15743	25	respect	respect	NN
18637	15743	26	to	to	IN
18637	15743	27	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15743	28	of	of	IN
18637	15743	29	speech	speech	NN
18637	15743	30	and	and	CC
18637	15743	31	press	press	NN
18637	15743	32	,	,	,
18637	15743	33	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	15743	34	of	of	IN
18637	15743	35	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15743	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	15743	37	appeared	appear	VBN
18637	15743	38	among	among	IN
18637	15743	39	the	the	DT
18637	15743	40	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	15743	41	upon	upon	IN
18637	15743	42	three	three	CD
18637	15743	43	closely	closely	RB
18637	15743	44	related	related	JJ
18637	15743	45	topics	topic	NNS
18637	15743	46	:	:	:
18637	15743	47	first	first	RB
18637	15743	48	,	,	,
18637	15743	49	as	as	IN
18637	15743	50	to	to	IN
18637	15743	51	the	the	DT
18637	15743	52	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	15743	53	force	force	NN
18637	15743	54	of	of	IN
18637	15743	55	the	the	DT
18637	15743	56	test	test	NN
18637	15743	57	;	;	:
18637	15743	58	second	second	LS
18637	15743	59	,	,	,
18637	15743	60	as	as	IN
18637	15743	61	to	to	IN
18637	15743	62	the	the	DT
18637	15743	63	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15743	64	status	status	NN
18637	15743	65	of	of	IN
18637	15743	66	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15743	67	of	of	IN
18637	15743	68	speech	speech	NN
18637	15743	69	and	and	CC
18637	15743	70	press	press	NN
18637	15743	71	;	;	:
18637	15743	72	third	third	RB
18637	15743	73	,	,	,
18637	15743	74	as	as	IN
18637	15743	75	to	to	IN
18637	15743	76	the	the	DT
18637	15743	77	kind	kind	NN
18637	15743	78	of	of	IN
18637	15743	79	speech	speech	NN
18637	15743	80	which	which	WDT
18637	15743	81	the	the	DT
18637	15743	82	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15743	83	is	be	VBZ
18637	15743	84	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	15743	85	to	to	TO
18637	15743	86	protect	protect	VB
18637	15743	87	.	.	.
18637	15744	1	On	on	IN
18637	15744	2	the	the	DT
18637	15744	3	first	first	JJ
18637	15744	4	point	point	NN
18637	15744	5	the	the	DT
18637	15744	6	following	follow	VBG
18637	15744	7	passage	passage	NN
18637	15744	8	from	from	IN
18637	15744	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15744	10	Black	Black	NNP
18637	15744	11	's	's	POS
18637	15744	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15744	13	in	in	IN
18637	15744	14	Bridges	Bridges	NNP
18637	15744	15	_	_	NNP
18637	15744	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	15744	17	_	_	NNP
18637	15744	18	California[173	California[173	NNP
18637	15744	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15744	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	15744	21	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	15744	22	:	:	:
18637	15744	23	"	"	``
18637	15744	24	What	what	WP
18637	15744	25	finally	finally	RB
18637	15744	26	emerges	emerge	VBZ
18637	15744	27	from	from	IN
18637	15744	28	the	the	DT
18637	15744	29	'	'	``
18637	15744	30	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15744	31	and	and	CC
18637	15744	32	present	present	JJ
18637	15744	33	danger	danger	NN
18637	15744	34	'	'	''
18637	15744	35	cases	case	NNS
18637	15744	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	15744	37	a	a	DT
18637	15744	38	working	work	VBG
18637	15744	39	principle	principle	NN
18637	15744	40	that	that	IN
18637	15744	41	the	the	DT
18637	15744	42	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15744	43	evil	evil	NN
18637	15744	44	must	must	MD
18637	15744	45	be	be	VB
18637	15744	46	extremely	extremely	RB
18637	15744	47	serious	serious	JJ
18637	15744	48	and	and	CC
18637	15744	49	the	the	DT
18637	15744	50	degree	degree	NN
18637	15744	51	of	of	IN
18637	15744	52	imminence	imminence	NN
18637	15744	53	extremely	extremely	RB
18637	15744	54	high	high	JJ
18637	15744	55	before	before	IN
18637	15744	56	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	15744	57	can	can	MD
18637	15744	58	be	be	VB
18637	15744	59	punished	punish	VBN
18637	15744	60	.	.	.
18637	15745	1	Those	those	DT
18637	15745	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	15745	3	do	do	VBP
18637	15745	4	not	not	RB
18637	15745	5	purport	purport	VB
18637	15745	6	to	to	TO
18637	15745	7	mark	mark	VB
18637	15745	8	the	the	DT
18637	15745	9	furthermost	furthermost	JJ
18637	15745	10	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15745	11	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	15745	12	of	of	IN
18637	15745	13	protected	protect	VBN
18637	15745	14	expression	expression	NN
18637	15745	15	,	,	,
18637	15745	16	nor	nor	CC
18637	15745	17	do	do	VBP
18637	15745	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15745	19	here	here	RB
18637	15745	20	.	.	.
18637	15746	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15746	2	do	do	VBP
18637	15746	3	no	no	RB
18637	15746	4	more	more	RBR
18637	15746	5	than	than	IN
18637	15746	6	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	15746	7	a	a	DT
18637	15746	8	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	15746	9	compulsion	compulsion	NN
18637	15746	10	of	of	IN
18637	15746	11	the	the	DT
18637	15746	12	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	15746	13	of	of	IN
18637	15746	14	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	15746	15	.	.	.
18637	15747	1	For	for	IN
18637	15747	2	the	the	DT
18637	15747	3	First	First	NNP
18637	15747	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15747	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	15747	6	not	not	RB
18637	15747	7	speak	speak	VB
18637	15747	8	equivocally	equivocally	RB
18637	15747	9	.	.	.
18637	15748	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15748	2	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	15748	3	any	any	DT
18637	15748	4	law	law	NN
18637	15748	5	'	'	''
18637	15748	6	abridging	abridge	VBG
18637	15748	7	the	the	DT
18637	15748	8	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15748	9	of	of	IN
18637	15748	10	speech	speech	NN
18637	15748	11	or	or	CC
18637	15748	12	of	of	IN
18637	15748	13	the	the	DT
18637	15748	14	press	press	NN
18637	15748	15	.	.	.
18637	15748	16	'	'	''
18637	15749	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15749	2	must	must	MD
18637	15749	3	be	be	VB
18637	15749	4	taken	take	VBN
18637	15749	5	as	as	IN
18637	15749	6	a	a	DT
18637	15749	7	command	command	NN
18637	15749	8	of	of	IN
18637	15749	9	the	the	DT
18637	15749	10	broadest	broad	JJS
18637	15749	11	scope	scope	NN
18637	15749	12	that	that	IN
18637	15749	13	explicit	explicit	JJ
18637	15749	14	language	language	NN
18637	15749	15	,	,	,
18637	15749	16	read	read	VBN
18637	15749	17	in	in	IN
18637	15749	18	the	the	DT
18637	15749	19	context	context	NN
18637	15749	20	of	of	IN
18637	15749	21	a	a	DT
18637	15749	22	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15749	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	15749	24	loving	love	VBG
18637	15749	25	society	society	NN
18637	15749	26	,	,	,
18637	15749	27	will	will	MD
18637	15749	28	allow	allow	VB
18637	15749	29	.	.	.
18637	15750	1	"	"	``
18637	15750	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15750	3	174	174	CD
18637	15750	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15750	5	With	with	IN
18637	15750	6	this	this	DT
18637	15750	7	should	should	MD
18637	15750	8	be	be	VB
18637	15750	9	compared	compare	VBN
18637	15750	10	the	the	DT
18637	15750	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	15750	12	words	word	NNS
18637	15750	13	from	from	IN
18637	15750	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15750	15	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	15750	16	's	's	POS
18637	15750	17	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	15750	18	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15750	19	in	in	IN
18637	15750	20	Pennekamp	Pennekamp	NNP
18637	15750	21	_	_	NNP
18637	15750	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	15750	23	_	_	NNP
18637	15750	24	Florida,[175	Florida,[175	NNP
18637	15750	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15750	26	which	which	WDT
18637	15750	27	involved	involve	VBD
18637	15750	28	a	a	DT
18637	15750	29	closely	closely	RB
18637	15750	30	similar	similar	JJ
18637	15750	31	issue	issue	NN
18637	15750	32	to	to	IN
18637	15750	33	the	the	DT
18637	15750	34	one	one	NN
18637	15750	35	dealt	deal	VBD
18637	15750	36	with	with	IN
18637	15750	37	in	in	IN
18637	15750	38	the	the	DT
18637	15750	39	Bridges	Bridges	NNPS
18637	15750	40	Case	case	NN
18637	15750	41	:	:	:
18637	15750	42	"	"	``
18637	15750	43	'	'	``
18637	15750	44	Clear	clear	JJ
18637	15750	45	and	and	CC
18637	15750	46	present	present	JJ
18637	15750	47	danger	danger	NN
18637	15750	48	'	'	''
18637	15750	49	was	be	VBD
18637	15750	50	never	never	RB
18637	15750	51	used	use	VBN
18637	15750	52	by	by	IN
18637	15750	53	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	15750	54	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15750	55	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	15750	56	to	to	TO
18637	15750	57	express	express	VB
18637	15750	58	a	a	DT
18637	15750	59	technical	technical	JJ
18637	15750	60	legal	legal	JJ
18637	15750	61	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15750	62	or	or	CC
18637	15750	63	to	to	TO
18637	15750	64	convey	convey	VB
18637	15750	65	a	a	DT
18637	15750	66	formula	formula	NN
18637	15750	67	for	for	IN
18637	15750	68	adjudicating	adjudicate	VBG
18637	15750	69	cases	case	NNS
18637	15750	70	.	.	.
18637	15751	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15751	2	was	be	VBD
18637	15751	3	a	a	DT
18637	15751	4	literary	literary	JJ
18637	15751	5	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	15751	6	not	not	RB
18637	15751	7	to	to	TO
18637	15751	8	be	be	VB
18637	15751	9	distorted	distort	VBN
18637	15751	10	by	by	IN
18637	15751	11	being	be	VBG
18637	15751	12	taken	take	VBN
18637	15751	13	from	from	IN
18637	15751	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15751	15	context	context	NN
18637	15751	16	.	.	.
18637	15752	1	In	in	IN
18637	15752	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15752	3	setting	setting	NN
18637	15752	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15752	5	served	serve	VBD
18637	15752	6	to	to	TO
18637	15752	7	indicate	indicate	VB
18637	15752	8	the	the	DT
18637	15752	9	importance	importance	NN
18637	15752	10	of	of	IN
18637	15752	11	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15752	12	of	of	IN
18637	15752	13	speech	speech	NN
18637	15752	14	to	to	IN
18637	15752	15	a	a	DT
18637	15752	16	free	free	JJ
18637	15752	17	society	society	NN
18637	15752	18	but	but	CC
18637	15752	19	also	also	RB
18637	15752	20	to	to	TO
18637	15752	21	emphasize	emphasize	VB
18637	15752	22	that	that	IN
18637	15752	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15752	24	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15752	25	must	must	MD
18637	15752	26	be	be	VB
18637	15752	27	compatible	compatible	JJ
18637	15752	28	with	with	IN
18637	15752	29	the	the	DT
18637	15752	30	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	15752	31	of	of	IN
18637	15752	32	other	other	JJ
18637	15752	33	freedoms	freedom	NNS
18637	15752	34	essential	essential	JJ
18637	15752	35	to	to	IN
18637	15752	36	a	a	DT
18637	15752	37	democracy	democracy	NN
18637	15752	38	and	and	CC
18637	15752	39	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	15752	40	by	by	IN
18637	15752	41	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15752	42	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15752	43	.	.	.
18637	15753	1	When	when	WRB
18637	15753	2	those	those	DT
18637	15753	3	other	other	JJ
18637	15753	4	attributes	attribute	NNS
18637	15753	5	of	of	IN
18637	15753	6	a	a	DT
18637	15753	7	democracy	democracy	NN
18637	15753	8	are	be	VBP
18637	15753	9	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	15753	10	by	by	IN
18637	15753	11	speech	speech	NN
18637	15753	12	,	,	,
18637	15753	13	the	the	DT
18637	15753	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15753	15	does	do	VBZ
18637	15753	16	not	not	RB
18637	15753	17	deny	deny	VB
18637	15753	18	power	power	NN
18637	15753	19	to	to	IN
18637	15753	20	the	the	DT
18637	15753	21	states	state	NNS
18637	15753	22	to	to	TO
18637	15753	23	curb	curb	VB
18637	15753	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15753	25	.	.	.
18637	15754	1	"	"	``
18637	15754	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15754	3	176	176	CD
18637	15754	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15754	5	The	the	DT
18637	15754	6	second	second	JJ
18637	15754	7	question	question	NN
18637	15754	8	,	,	,
18637	15754	9	in	in	IN
18637	15754	10	more	more	JJR
18637	15754	11	definite	definite	JJ
18637	15754	12	terms	term	NNS
18637	15754	13	,	,	,
18637	15754	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	15754	15	whether	whether	IN
18637	15754	16	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15754	17	of	of	IN
18637	15754	18	speech	speech	NN
18637	15754	19	and	and	CC
18637	15754	20	press	press	NN
18637	15754	21	occupies	occupy	VBZ
18637	15754	22	a	a	DT
18637	15754	23	"	"	``
18637	15754	24	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	15754	25	position	position	NN
18637	15754	26	"	"	''
18637	15754	27	in	in	IN
18637	15754	28	the	the	DT
18637	15754	29	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15754	30	hierarchy	hierarchy	NN
18637	15754	31	of	of	IN
18637	15754	32	values	value	NNS
18637	15754	33	so	so	IN
18637	15754	34	that	that	IN
18637	15754	35	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15754	36	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	15754	37	of	of	IN
18637	15754	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15754	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	15754	40	presumptively	presumptively	RB
18637	15754	41	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	15754	42	.	.	.
18637	15755	1	An	an	DT
18637	15755	2	important	important	JJ
18637	15755	3	contribution	contribution	NN
18637	15755	4	to	to	IN
18637	15755	5	the	the	DT
18637	15755	6	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	15755	7	view	view	NN
18637	15755	8	on	on	IN
18637	15755	9	this	this	DT
18637	15755	10	point	point	NN
18637	15755	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	15755	12	the	the	DT
18637	15755	13	following	follow	VBG
18637	15755	14	passage	passage	NN
18637	15755	15	from	from	IN
18637	15755	16	an	an	DT
18637	15755	17	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15755	18	of	of	IN
18637	15755	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15755	20	Cardozo	Cardozo	NNP
18637	15755	21	written	write	VBN
18637	15755	22	in	in	IN
18637	15755	23	1937	1937	CD
18637	15755	24	:	:	:
18637	15755	25	"	"	``
18637	15755	26	One	one	PRP
18637	15755	27	may	may	MD
18637	15755	28	say	say	VB
18637	15755	29	that	that	IN
18637	15755	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15755	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	15755	32	the	the	DT
18637	15755	33	matrix	matrix	NN
18637	15755	34	,	,	,
18637	15755	35	the	the	DT
18637	15755	36	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
18637	15755	37	condition	condition	NN
18637	15755	38	,	,	,
18637	15755	39	of	of	IN
18637	15755	40	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	15755	41	every	every	DT
18637	15755	42	other	other	JJ
18637	15755	43	form	form	NN
18637	15755	44	of	of	IN
18637	15755	45	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15755	46	.	.	.
18637	15756	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15756	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15756	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15756	4	So	so	IN
18637	15756	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15756	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	15756	7	come	come	VBN
18637	15756	8	about	about	IN
18637	15756	9	that	that	IN
18637	15756	10	the	the	DT
18637	15756	11	domain	domain	NN
18637	15756	12	of	of	IN
18637	15756	13	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15756	14	,	,	,
18637	15756	15	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	15756	16	by	by	IN
18637	15756	17	the	the	DT
18637	15756	18	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15756	19	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15756	20	from	from	IN
18637	15756	21	encroachment	encroachment	NN
18637	15756	22	by	by	IN
18637	15756	23	the	the	DT
18637	15756	24	states	state	NNS
18637	15756	25	,	,	,
18637	15756	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	15756	27	been	be	VBN
18637	15756	28	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
18637	15756	29	by	by	IN
18637	15756	30	latter	latter	JJ
18637	15756	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	15756	32	day	day	NN
18637	15756	33	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	15756	34	to	to	TO
18637	15756	35	include	include	VB
18637	15756	36	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15756	37	of	of	IN
18637	15756	38	the	the	DT
18637	15756	39	mind	mind	NN
18637	15756	40	as	as	RB
18637	15756	41	well	well	RB
18637	15756	42	as	as	IN
18637	15756	43	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15756	44	of	of	IN
18637	15756	45	action	action	NN
18637	15756	46	.	.	.
18637	15757	1	The	the	DT
18637	15757	2	extension	extension	NN
18637	15757	3	became	become	VBD
18637	15757	4	,	,	,
18637	15757	5	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	15757	6	,	,	,
18637	15757	7	a	a	DT
18637	15757	8	logical	logical	JJ
18637	15757	9	imperative	imperative	NN
18637	15757	10	when	when	WRB
18637	15757	11	once	once	IN
18637	15757	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15757	13	was	be	VBD
18637	15757	14	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	15757	15	,	,	,
18637	15757	16	as	as	RB
18637	15757	17	long	long	RB
18637	15757	18	ago	ago	RB
18637	15757	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15757	20	was	be	VBD
18637	15757	21	,	,	,
18637	15757	22	that	that	DT
18637	15757	23	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15757	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	15757	25	something	something	NN
18637	15757	26	more	more	JJR
18637	15757	27	than	than	IN
18637	15757	28	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	15757	29	from	from	IN
18637	15757	30	physical	physical	JJ
18637	15757	31	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	15757	32	,	,	,
18637	15757	33	and	and	CC
18637	15757	34	that	that	IN
18637	15757	35	even	even	RB
18637	15757	36	in	in	IN
18637	15757	37	the	the	DT
18637	15757	38	field	field	NN
18637	15757	39	of	of	IN
18637	15757	40	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15757	41	rights	right	NNS
18637	15757	42	and	and	CC
18637	15757	43	duties	duty	NNS
18637	15757	44	the	the	DT
18637	15757	45	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	15757	46	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	15757	47	,	,	,
18637	15757	48	if	if	IN
18637	15757	49	oppressive	oppressive	JJ
18637	15757	50	and	and	CC
18637	15757	51	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	15757	52	,	,	,
18637	15757	53	may	may	MD
18637	15757	54	be	be	VB
18637	15757	55	overridden	overridden	JJ
18637	15757	56	by	by	IN
18637	15757	57	the	the	DT
18637	15757	58	courts	court	NNS
18637	15757	59	.	.	.
18637	15758	1	"	"	``
18637	15758	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15758	3	177	177	CD
18637	15758	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15758	5	Touching	touch	VBG
18637	15758	6	on	on	IN
18637	15758	7	the	the	DT
18637	15758	8	same	same	JJ
18637	15758	9	subject	subject	NN
18637	15758	10	a	a	DT
18637	15758	11	few	few	JJ
18637	15758	12	months	month	NNS
18637	15758	13	later	later	RB
18637	15758	14	,	,	,
18637	15758	15	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15758	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15758	17	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	15758	18	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	15758	19	that	that	IN
18637	15758	20	:	:	:
18637	15758	21	"	"	``
18637	15758	22	There	there	EX
18637	15758	23	may	may	MD
18637	15758	24	be	be	VB
18637	15758	25	narrower	narrow	JJR
18637	15758	26	scope	scope	NN
18637	15758	27	for	for	IN
18637	15758	28	operation	operation	NN
18637	15758	29	of	of	IN
18637	15758	30	the	the	DT
18637	15758	31	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	15758	32	of	of	IN
18637	15758	33	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	15758	34	when	when	WRB
18637	15758	35	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15758	36	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	15758	37	on	on	IN
18637	15758	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15758	39	face	face	NN
18637	15758	40	to	to	TO
18637	15758	41	be	be	VB
18637	15758	42	within	within	IN
18637	15758	43	a	a	DT
18637	15758	44	specific	specific	JJ
18637	15758	45	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	15758	46	of	of	IN
18637	15758	47	the	the	DT
18637	15758	48	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15758	49	,	,	,
18637	15758	50	such	such	JJ
18637	15758	51	as	as	IN
18637	15758	52	those	those	DT
18637	15758	53	of	of	IN
18637	15758	54	the	the	DT
18637	15758	55	first	first	JJ
18637	15758	56	ten	ten	CD
18637	15758	57	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	15758	58	,	,	,
18637	15758	59	which	which	WDT
18637	15758	60	are	be	VBP
18637	15758	61	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	15758	62	equally	equally	RB
18637	15758	63	specific	specific	JJ
18637	15758	64	when	when	WRB
18637	15758	65	held	hold	VBN
18637	15758	66	to	to	TO
18637	15758	67	be	be	VB
18637	15758	68	embraced	embrace	VBN
18637	15758	69	within	within	IN
18637	15758	70	the	the	DT
18637	15758	71	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15758	72	.	.	.
18637	15758	73	"	"	''
18637	15759	1	And	and	CC
18637	15759	2	again	again	RB
18637	15759	3	:	:	:
18637	15759	4	"	"	``
18637	15759	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15759	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	15759	7	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	15759	8	to	to	TO
18637	15759	9	consider	consider	VB
18637	15759	10	now	now	RB
18637	15759	11	whether	whether	IN
18637	15759	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15759	13	which	which	WDT
18637	15759	14	restricts	restrict	VBZ
18637	15759	15	those	those	DT
18637	15759	16	political	political	JJ
18637	15759	17	processes	process	NNS
18637	15759	18	which	which	WDT
18637	15759	19	can	can	MD
18637	15759	20	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	15759	21	be	be	VB
18637	15759	22	expected	expect	VBN
18637	15759	23	to	to	TO
18637	15759	24	bring	bring	VB
18637	15759	25	about	about	RP
18637	15759	26	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	15759	27	of	of	IN
18637	15759	28	undesirable	undesirable	JJ
18637	15759	29	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15759	30	,	,	,
18637	15759	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	15759	32	to	to	TO
18637	15759	33	be	be	VB
18637	15759	34	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	15759	35	to	to	IN
18637	15759	36	more	more	RBR
18637	15759	37	exacting	exact	VBG
18637	15759	38	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15759	39	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
18637	15759	40	under	under	IN
18637	15759	41	the	the	DT
18637	15759	42	general	general	JJ
18637	15759	43	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
18637	15759	44	of	of	IN
18637	15759	45	the	the	DT
18637	15759	46	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15759	47	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15759	48	than	than	IN
18637	15759	49	are	be	VBP
18637	15759	50	most	most	JJS
18637	15759	51	other	other	JJ
18637	15759	52	types	type	NNS
18637	15759	53	of	of	IN
18637	15759	54	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15759	55	.	.	.
18637	15760	1	"	"	``
18637	15760	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15760	3	178	178	CD
18637	15760	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15760	5	But	but	CC
18637	15760	6	the	the	DT
18637	15760	7	strongest	strong	JJS
18637	15760	8	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	15760	9	of	of	IN
18637	15760	10	this	this	DT
18637	15760	11	position	position	NN
18637	15760	12	occurs	occur	VBZ
18637	15760	13	in	in	IN
18637	15760	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15760	15	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	15760	16	's	's	POS
18637	15760	17	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15760	18	for	for	IN
18637	15760	19	a	a	DT
18637	15760	20	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	15760	21	divided	divide	VBN
18637	15760	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15760	23	in	in	IN
18637	15760	24	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	15760	25	_	_	NNP
18637	15760	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	15760	27	_	_	NNP
18637	15760	28	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	15760	29	.	.	.
18637	15761	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15761	2	179	179	CD
18637	15761	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15761	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15761	5	says	say	VBZ
18637	15761	6	:	:	:
18637	15761	7	"	"	``
18637	15761	8	The	the	DT
18637	15761	9	case	case	NN
18637	15761	10	confronts	confront	VBZ
18637	15761	11	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15761	12	again	again	RB
18637	15761	13	with	with	IN
18637	15761	14	the	the	DT
18637	15761	15	duty	duty	NN
18637	15761	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15761	17	system	system	NN
18637	15761	18	places	place	VBZ
18637	15761	19	on	on	IN
18637	15761	20	this	this	DT
18637	15761	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15761	22	to	to	TO
18637	15761	23	say	say	VB
18637	15761	24	where	where	WRB
18637	15761	25	the	the	DT
18637	15761	26	individual	individual	NN
18637	15761	27	's	's	POS
18637	15761	28	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15761	29	ends	end	NNS
18637	15761	30	and	and	CC
18637	15761	31	the	the	DT
18637	15761	32	State	State	NNP
18637	15761	33	's	's	POS
18637	15761	34	power	power	NN
18637	15761	35	begins	begin	VBZ
18637	15761	36	.	.	.
18637	15762	1	Choice	choice	NN
18637	15762	2	on	on	IN
18637	15762	3	that	that	DT
18637	15762	4	border	border	NN
18637	15762	5	,	,	,
18637	15762	6	now	now	RB
18637	15762	7	as	as	IN
18637	15762	8	always	always	RB
18637	15762	9	delicate	delicate	JJ
18637	15762	10	,	,	,
18637	15762	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	15762	12	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	15762	13	more	more	RBR
18637	15762	14	so	so	RB
18637	15762	15	where	where	WRB
18637	15762	16	the	the	DT
18637	15762	17	usual	usual	JJ
18637	15762	18	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	15762	19	supporting	support	VBG
18637	15762	20	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15762	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	15762	22	balanced	balance	VBN
18637	15762	23	by	by	IN
18637	15762	24	the	the	DT
18637	15762	25	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	15762	26	place	place	NN
18637	15762	27	given	give	VBN
18637	15762	28	in	in	IN
18637	15762	29	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15762	30	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	15762	31	to	to	IN
18637	15762	32	the	the	DT
18637	15762	33	great	great	JJ
18637	15762	34	,	,	,
18637	15762	35	the	the	DT
18637	15762	36	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
18637	15762	37	democratic	democratic	JJ
18637	15762	38	freedoms	freedom	NNS
18637	15762	39	secured	secure	VBN
18637	15762	40	by	by	IN
18637	15762	41	the	the	DT
18637	15762	42	First	First	NNP
18637	15762	43	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15762	44	.	.	.
18637	15763	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15763	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15763	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15763	4	That	that	DT
18637	15763	5	priority	priority	NN
18637	15763	6	gives	give	VBZ
18637	15763	7	these	these	DT
18637	15763	8	liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	15763	9	a	a	DT
18637	15763	10	sanctity	sanctity	NN
18637	15763	11	and	and	CC
18637	15763	12	a	a	DT
18637	15763	13	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	15763	14	not	not	RB
18637	15763	15	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	15763	16	dubious	dubious	JJ
18637	15763	17	intrusions	intrusion	NNS
18637	15763	18	.	.	.
18637	15764	1	And	and	CC
18637	15764	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15764	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	15764	4	the	the	DT
18637	15764	5	character	character	NN
18637	15764	6	of	of	IN
18637	15764	7	the	the	DT
18637	15764	8	right	right	NN
18637	15764	9	,	,	,
18637	15764	10	not	not	RB
18637	15764	11	of	of	IN
18637	15764	12	the	the	DT
18637	15764	13	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	15764	14	,	,	,
18637	15764	15	which	which	WDT
18637	15764	16	determines	determine	VBZ
18637	15764	17	what	what	WDT
18637	15764	18	standard	standard	NN
18637	15764	19	governs	govern	VBZ
18637	15764	20	the	the	DT
18637	15764	21	choice	choice	NN
18637	15764	22	.	.	.
18637	15765	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15765	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15765	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15765	4	For	for	IN
18637	15765	5	these	these	DT
18637	15765	6	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	15765	7	any	any	DT
18637	15765	8	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	15765	9	to	to	TO
18637	15765	10	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	15765	11	those	those	DT
18637	15765	12	liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	15765	13	must	must	MD
18637	15765	14	be	be	VB
18637	15765	15	justified	justify	VBN
18637	15765	16	by	by	IN
18637	15765	17	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15765	18	public	public	JJ
18637	15765	19	interest	interest	NN
18637	15765	20	,	,	,
18637	15765	21	threatened	threaten	VBD
18637	15765	22	not	not	RB
18637	15765	23	doubtfully	doubtfully	RB
18637	15765	24	or	or	CC
18637	15765	25	remotely	remotely	RB
18637	15765	26	,	,	,
18637	15765	27	but	but	CC
18637	15765	28	by	by	IN
18637	15765	29	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15765	30	and	and	CC
18637	15765	31	present	present	JJ
18637	15765	32	danger	danger	NN
18637	15765	33	.	.	.
18637	15766	1	The	the	DT
18637	15766	2	rational	rational	JJ
18637	15766	3	connection	connection	NN
18637	15766	4	between	between	IN
18637	15766	5	the	the	DT
18637	15766	6	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	15766	7	provided	provide	VBN
18637	15766	8	and	and	CC
18637	15766	9	the	the	DT
18637	15766	10	evil	evil	NN
18637	15766	11	to	to	TO
18637	15766	12	be	be	VB
18637	15766	13	curbed	curb	VBN
18637	15766	14	,	,	,
18637	15766	15	which	which	WDT
18637	15766	16	in	in	IN
18637	15766	17	other	other	JJ
18637	15766	18	contexts	contexts	NN
18637	15766	19	might	may	MD
18637	15766	20	support	support	VB
18637	15766	21	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15766	22	against	against	IN
18637	15766	23	attack	attack	NN
18637	15766	24	on	on	IN
18637	15766	25	due	due	JJ
18637	15766	26	process	process	NN
18637	15766	27	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	15766	28	,	,	,
18637	15766	29	will	will	MD
18637	15766	30	not	not	RB
18637	15766	31	suffice	suffice	VB
18637	15766	32	.	.	.
18637	15767	1	These	these	DT
18637	15767	2	rights	right	NNS
18637	15767	3	rest	rest	VBP
18637	15767	4	on	on	IN
18637	15767	5	firmer	firm	JJR
18637	15767	6	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	15767	7	.	.	.
18637	15768	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	15768	2	,	,	,
18637	15768	3	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	15768	4	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	15768	5	would	would	MD
18637	15768	6	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	15768	7	orderly	orderly	JJ
18637	15768	8	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	15768	9	and	and	CC
18637	15768	10	persuasion	persuasion	NN
18637	15768	11	,	,	,
18637	15768	12	at	at	IN
18637	15768	13	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	15768	14	time	time	NN
18637	15768	15	and	and	CC
18637	15768	16	place	place	NN
18637	15768	17	,	,	,
18637	15768	18	must	must	MD
18637	15768	19	have	have	VB
18637	15768	20	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15768	21	support	support	NN
18637	15768	22	in	in	IN
18637	15768	23	public	public	JJ
18637	15768	24	danger	danger	NN
18637	15768	25	,	,	,
18637	15768	26	actual	actual	JJ
18637	15768	27	or	or	CC
18637	15768	28	impending	impending	JJ
18637	15768	29	.	.	.
18637	15769	1	Only	only	RB
18637	15769	2	the	the	DT
18637	15769	3	gravest	grave	JJS
18637	15769	4	abuses	abuse	NNS
18637	15769	5	,	,	,
18637	15769	6	endangering	endanger	VBG
18637	15769	7	paramount	paramount	JJ
18637	15769	8	interests	interest	NNS
18637	15769	9	,	,	,
18637	15769	10	give	give	VBP
18637	15769	11	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	15769	12	for	for	IN
18637	15769	13	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	15769	14	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	15769	15	.	.	.
18637	15770	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15770	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15770	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	15770	4	in	in	IN
18637	15770	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15770	6	tradition	tradition	NN
18637	15770	7	to	to	TO
18637	15770	8	allow	allow	VB
18637	15770	9	the	the	DT
18637	15770	10	widest	wide	JJS
18637	15770	11	room	room	NN
18637	15770	12	for	for	IN
18637	15770	13	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	15770	14	,	,	,
18637	15770	15	the	the	DT
18637	15770	16	narrowest	narrow	JJS
18637	15770	17	range	range	NN
18637	15770	18	for	for	IN
18637	15770	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15770	20	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	15770	21	,	,	,
18637	15770	22	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	15770	23	when	when	WRB
18637	15770	24	this	this	DT
18637	15770	25	right	right	NN
18637	15770	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	15770	27	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	15770	28	in	in	IN
18637	15770	29	conjunction	conjunction	NN
18637	15770	30	with	with	IN
18637	15770	31	peaceable	peaceable	JJ
18637	15770	32	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	15770	33	.	.	.
18637	15771	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15771	2	was	be	VBD
18637	15771	3	not	not	RB
18637	15771	4	by	by	IN
18637	15771	5	accident	accident	NN
18637	15771	6	or	or	CC
18637	15771	7	coincidence	coincidence	NN
18637	15771	8	that	that	IN
18637	15771	9	the	the	DT
18637	15771	10	rights	right	NNS
18637	15771	11	to	to	IN
18637	15771	12	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15771	13	in	in	IN
18637	15771	14	speech	speech	NN
18637	15771	15	and	and	CC
18637	15771	16	press	press	NN
18637	15771	17	were	be	VBD
18637	15771	18	coupled	couple	VBN
18637	15771	19	in	in	IN
18637	15771	20	a	a	DT
18637	15771	21	single	single	JJ
18637	15771	22	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	15771	23	with	with	IN
18637	15771	24	the	the	DT
18637	15771	25	rights	right	NNS
18637	15771	26	of	of	IN
18637	15771	27	the	the	DT
18637	15771	28	people	people	NNS
18637	15771	29	peaceably	peaceably	RB
18637	15771	30	to	to	TO
18637	15771	31	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	15771	32	and	and	CC
18637	15771	33	to	to	TO
18637	15771	34	petition	petition	VB
18637	15771	35	for	for	IN
18637	15771	36	redress	redress	NN
18637	15771	37	of	of	IN
18637	15771	38	grievances	grievance	NNS
18637	15771	39	.	.	.
18637	15772	1	All	all	PDT
18637	15772	2	these	these	DT
18637	15772	3	,	,	,
18637	15772	4	though	though	IN
18637	15772	5	not	not	RB
18637	15772	6	identical	identical	JJ
18637	15772	7	,	,	,
18637	15772	8	are	be	VBP
18637	15772	9	inseparable	inseparable	JJ
18637	15772	10	.	.	.
18637	15773	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15773	2	are	be	VBP
18637	15773	3	cognate	cognate	NN
18637	15773	4	rights	right	NNS
18637	15773	5	.	.	.
18637	15774	1	"	"	``
18637	15774	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15774	3	180	180	CD
18637	15774	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15774	5	This	this	DT
18637	15774	6	was	be	VBD
18637	15774	7	1945	1945	CD
18637	15774	8	.	.	.
18637	15775	1	Four	four	CD
18637	15775	2	years	year	NNS
18637	15775	3	later	later	RB
18637	15775	4	the	the	DT
18637	15775	5	controlling	control	VBG
18637	15775	6	wing	wing	NN
18637	15775	7	of	of	IN
18637	15775	8	the	the	DT
18637	15775	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15775	10	,	,	,
18637	15775	11	in	in	IN
18637	15775	12	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	15775	13	a	a	DT
18637	15775	14	local	local	JJ
18637	15775	15	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	15775	16	,	,	,
18637	15775	17	endorsed	endorse	VBD
18637	15775	18	a	a	DT
18637	15775	19	considerably	considerably	RB
18637	15775	20	less	less	RBR
18637	15775	21	enthusiastic	enthusiastic	JJ
18637	15775	22	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	15775	23	of	of	IN
18637	15775	24	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15775	25	of	of	IN
18637	15775	26	speech	speech	NN
18637	15775	27	and	and	CC
18637	15775	28	press	press	NN
18637	15775	29	.	.	.
18637	15776	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	15776	2	while	while	IN
18637	15776	3	alluding	allude	VBG
18637	15776	4	to	to	IN
18637	15776	5	"	"	``
18637	15776	6	the	the	DT
18637	15776	7	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	15776	8	position	position	NN
18637	15776	9	of	of	IN
18637	15776	10	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15776	11	of	of	IN
18637	15776	12	speech	speech	NN
18637	15776	13	in	in	IN
18637	15776	14	a	a	DT
18637	15776	15	society	society	NN
18637	15776	16	that	that	WDT
18637	15776	17	cherishes	cherish	VBZ
18637	15776	18	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15776	19	for	for	IN
18637	15776	20	all	all	DT
18637	15776	21	,	,	,
18637	15776	22	"	"	''
18637	15776	23	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15776	24	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	15776	25	went	go	VBD
18637	15776	26	on	on	RP
18637	15776	27	to	to	TO
18637	15776	28	say	say	VB
18637	15776	29	,	,	,
18637	15776	30	that	that	IN
18637	15776	31	this	this	DT
18637	15776	32	"	"	``
18637	15776	33	does	do	VBZ
18637	15776	34	not	not	RB
18637	15776	35	require	require	VB
18637	15776	36	legislators	legislator	NNS
18637	15776	37	to	to	TO
18637	15776	38	be	be	VB
18637	15776	39	insensible	insensible	JJ
18637	15776	40	to	to	IN
18637	15776	41	claims	claim	NNS
18637	15776	42	by	by	IN
18637	15776	43	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	15776	44	to	to	TO
18637	15776	45	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	15776	46	and	and	CC
18637	15776	47	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	15776	48	.	.	.
18637	15777	1	To	to	TO
18637	15777	2	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	15777	3	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15777	4	of	of	IN
18637	15777	5	speech	speech	NN
18637	15777	6	in	in	IN
18637	15777	7	disregard	disregard	NN
18637	15777	8	of	of	IN
18637	15777	9	the	the	DT
18637	15777	10	rights	right	NNS
18637	15777	11	of	of	IN
18637	15777	12	others	other	NNS
18637	15777	13	would	would	MD
18637	15777	14	be	be	VB
18637	15777	15	harsh	harsh	JJ
18637	15777	16	and	and	CC
18637	15777	17	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	15777	18	in	in	IN
18637	15777	19	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15777	20	.	.	.
18637	15778	1	"	"	``
18637	15778	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15778	3	181	181	CD
18637	15778	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15778	5	And	and	CC
18637	15778	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15778	7	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	15778	8	denied	deny	VBD
18637	15778	9	flatly	flatly	RB
18637	15778	10	the	the	DT
18637	15778	11	propriety	propriety	NN
18637	15778	12	of	of	IN
18637	15778	13	the	the	DT
18637	15778	14	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	15778	15	"	"	``
18637	15778	16	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	15778	17	position	position	NN
18637	15778	18	,	,	,
18637	15778	19	"	"	''
18637	15778	20	saying	say	VBG
18637	15778	21	:	:	:
18637	15778	22	"	"	``
18637	15778	23	This	this	DT
18637	15778	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	15778	25	a	a	DT
18637	15778	26	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	15778	27	that	that	WDT
18637	15778	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	15778	29	uncritically	uncritically	RB
18637	15778	30	crept	creep	VBN
18637	15778	31	into	into	IN
18637	15778	32	some	some	DT
18637	15778	33	recent	recent	JJ
18637	15778	34	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	15778	35	of	of	IN
18637	15778	36	this	this	DT
18637	15778	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15778	38	.	.	.
18637	15779	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15779	2	deem	deem	VBP
18637	15779	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15779	4	a	a	DT
18637	15779	5	mischievous	mischievous	JJ
18637	15779	6	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	15779	7	,	,	,
18637	15779	8	if	if	IN
18637	15779	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15779	10	carries	carry	VBZ
18637	15779	11	the	the	DT
18637	15779	12	thought	thought	NN
18637	15779	13	,	,	,
18637	15779	14	which	which	WDT
18637	15779	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15779	16	may	may	MD
18637	15779	17	subtly	subtly	RB
18637	15779	18	imply	imply	VB
18637	15779	19	,	,	,
18637	15779	20	that	that	IN
18637	15779	21	any	any	DT
18637	15779	22	law	law	NN
18637	15779	23	touching	touch	VBG
18637	15779	24	communication	communication	NN
18637	15779	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	15779	26	infected	infect	VBN
18637	15779	27	with	with	IN
18637	15779	28	presumptive	presumptive	JJ
18637	15779	29	invalidity	invalidity	NN
18637	15779	30	.	.	.
18637	15780	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15780	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15780	3	not	not	RB
18637	15780	4	the	the	DT
18637	15780	5	first	first	JJ
18637	15780	6	time	time	NN
18637	15780	7	in	in	IN
18637	15780	8	the	the	DT
18637	15780	9	history	history	NN
18637	15780	10	of	of	IN
18637	15780	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15780	12	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	15780	13	that	that	IN
18637	15780	14	such	such	PDT
18637	15780	15	a	a	DT
18637	15780	16	doctrinaire	doctrinaire	JJ
18637	15780	17	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	15780	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	15780	19	disregarded	disregard	VBN
18637	15780	20	the	the	DT
18637	15780	21	admonition	admonition	NN
18637	15780	22	most	most	RBS
18637	15780	23	to	to	TO
18637	15780	24	be	be	VB
18637	15780	25	observed	observe	VBN
18637	15780	26	in	in	IN
18637	15780	27	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	15780	28	the	the	DT
18637	15780	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15780	30	's	's	POS
18637	15780	31	reviewing	review	VBG
18637	15780	32	power	power	NN
18637	15780	33	over	over	IN
18637	15780	34	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15780	35	,	,	,
18637	15780	36	'	'	''
18637	15780	37	that	that	IN
18637	15780	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15780	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	15780	40	a	a	DT
18637	15780	41	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	15780	42	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15780	43	are	be	VBP
18637	15780	44	expounding	expound	VBG
18637	15780	45	,	,	,
18637	15780	46	'	'	''
18637	15780	47	M'Culloch	M'Culloch	NNP
18637	15780	48	_	_	NNP
18637	15780	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	15780	50	_	_	NNP
18637	15780	51	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	15780	52	,	,	,
18637	15780	53	4	4	CD
18637	15780	54	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	15780	55	.	.	.
18637	15781	1	316	316	CD
18637	15781	2	,	,	,
18637	15781	3	407	407	CD
18637	15781	4	.	.	.
18637	15782	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15782	2	say	say	VBP
18637	15782	3	the	the	DT
18637	15782	4	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	15782	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	15782	6	mischievous	mischievous	JJ
18637	15782	7	because	because	IN
18637	15782	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15782	9	radiates	radiate	VBZ
18637	15782	10	a	a	DT
18637	15782	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15782	12	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15782	13	without	without	IN
18637	15782	14	avowing	avow	VBG
18637	15782	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15782	16	.	.	.
18637	15783	1	Clarity	clarity	NN
18637	15783	2	and	and	CC
18637	15783	3	candor	candor	NN
18637	15783	4	in	in	IN
18637	15783	5	these	these	DT
18637	15783	6	matters	matter	NNS
18637	15783	7	,	,	,
18637	15783	8	so	so	IN
18637	15783	9	as	as	IN
18637	15783	10	to	to	TO
18637	15783	11	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	15783	12	gliding	glide	VBG
18637	15783	13	unwittingly	unwittingly	RB
18637	15783	14	into	into	IN
18637	15783	15	error	error	NN
18637	15783	16	,	,	,
18637	15783	17	make	make	VB
18637	15783	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15783	19	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	15783	20	to	to	TO
18637	15783	21	trace	trace	VB
18637	15783	22	the	the	DT
18637	15783	23	history	history	NN
18637	15783	24	of	of	IN
18637	15783	25	the	the	DT
18637	15783	26	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	15783	27	'	'	POS
18637	15783	28	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	15783	29	position	position	NN
18637	15783	30	.	.	.
18637	15784	1	'	'	``
18637	15784	2	"	"	``
18637	15784	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15784	4	182	182	CD
18637	15784	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15784	6	which	which	WDT
18637	15784	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15784	8	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	15784	9	then	then	RB
18637	15784	10	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	15784	11	to	to	TO
18637	15784	12	do	do	VB
18637	15784	13	.	.	.
18637	15785	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15785	2	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	15785	3	also	also	RB
18637	15785	4	protested	protest	VBD
18637	15785	5	:	:	:
18637	15785	6	"	"	``
18637	15785	7	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15785	8	can	can	MD
18637	15785	9	not	not	RB
18637	15785	10	,	,	,
18637	15785	11	"	"	''
18637	15785	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15785	13	said	say	VBD
18637	15785	14	,	,	,
18637	15785	15	"	"	``
18637	15785	16	give	give	VB
18637	15785	17	some	some	DT
18637	15785	18	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15785	19	rights	right	NNS
18637	15785	20	a	a	DT
18637	15785	21	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	15785	22	position	position	NN
18637	15785	23	without	without	IN
18637	15785	24	relegating	relegate	VBG
18637	15785	25	others	other	NNS
18637	15785	26	to	to	IN
18637	15785	27	a	a	DT
18637	15785	28	deferred	deferred	JJ
18637	15785	29	position	position	NN
18637	15785	30	.	.	.
18637	15786	1	"	"	``
18637	15786	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15786	3	183	183	CD
18637	15786	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15786	5	The	the	DT
18637	15786	6	third	third	JJ
18637	15786	7	question	question	NN
18637	15786	8	concerns	concern	VBZ
18637	15786	9	the	the	DT
18637	15786	10	quality	quality	NN
18637	15786	11	and	and	CC
18637	15786	12	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15786	13	of	of	IN
18637	15786	14	the	the	DT
18637	15786	15	speech	speech	NN
18637	15786	16	which	which	WDT
18637	15786	17	the	the	DT
18637	15786	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15786	19	aims	aim	VBZ
18637	15786	20	to	to	TO
18637	15786	21	protect	protect	VB
18637	15786	22	.	.	.
18637	15787	1	In	in	IN
18637	15787	2	1949	1949	CD
18637	15787	3	,	,	,
18637	15787	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15787	5	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	15787	6	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15787	7	for	for	IN
18637	15787	8	a	a	DT
18637	15787	9	divided	divide	VBN
18637	15787	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15787	11	returned	return	VBD
18637	15787	12	the	the	DT
18637	15787	13	following	follow	VBG
18637	15787	14	robustious	robustious	JJ
18637	15787	15	answer	answer	NN
18637	15787	16	to	to	IN
18637	15787	17	this	this	DT
18637	15787	18	question	question	NN
18637	15787	19	:	:	:
18637	15787	20	"	"	``
18637	15787	21	*	*	NFP
18637	15787	22	*	*	NFP
18637	15787	23	*	*	NFP
18637	15787	24	a	a	DT
18637	15787	25	function	function	NN
18637	15787	26	of	of	IN
18637	15787	27	free	free	JJ
18637	15787	28	speech	speech	NN
18637	15787	29	under	under	IN
18637	15787	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15787	31	system	system	NN
18637	15787	32	of	of	IN
18637	15787	33	government	government	NN
18637	15787	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	15787	35	to	to	TO
18637	15787	36	invite	invite	VB
18637	15787	37	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	15787	38	.	.	.
18637	15788	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15788	2	may	may	MD
18637	15788	3	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	15788	4	best	well	RBS
18637	15788	5	serve	serve	VB
18637	15788	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15788	7	high	high	JJ
18637	15788	8	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15788	9	when	when	WRB
18637	15788	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15788	11	induces	induce	VBZ
18637	15788	12	a	a	DT
18637	15788	13	condition	condition	NN
18637	15788	14	of	of	IN
18637	15788	15	unrest	unrest	NN
18637	15788	16	,	,	,
18637	15788	17	creates	create	VBZ
18637	15788	18	dissatisfaction	dissatisfaction	NN
18637	15788	19	with	with	IN
18637	15788	20	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	15788	21	as	as	IN
18637	15788	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15788	23	are	be	VBP
18637	15788	24	,	,	,
18637	15788	25	or	or	CC
18637	15788	26	even	even	RB
18637	15788	27	stirs	stir	VBZ
18637	15788	28	people	people	NNS
18637	15788	29	to	to	IN
18637	15788	30	anger	anger	NN
18637	15788	31	.	.	.
18637	15789	1	Speech	speech	NN
18637	15789	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15789	3	often	often	RB
18637	15789	4	provocative	provocative	JJ
18637	15789	5	and	and	CC
18637	15789	6	challenging	challenging	JJ
18637	15789	7	.	.	.
18637	15790	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15790	2	may	may	MD
18637	15790	3	strike	strike	VB
18637	15790	4	at	at	IN
18637	15790	5	prejudices	prejudice	NNS
18637	15790	6	and	and	CC
18637	15790	7	preconceptions	preconception	NNS
18637	15790	8	and	and	CC
18637	15790	9	have	have	VBP
18637	15790	10	profound	profound	VBN
18637	15790	11	unsettling	unsettling	JJ
18637	15790	12	effects	effect	NNS
18637	15790	13	as	as	IN
18637	15790	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15790	15	presses	press	VBZ
18637	15790	16	for	for	IN
18637	15790	17	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	15790	18	of	of	IN
18637	15790	19	an	an	DT
18637	15790	20	idea	idea	NN
18637	15790	21	.	.	.
18637	15791	1	That	that	DT
18637	15791	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15791	3	why	why	WRB
18637	15791	4	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15791	5	of	of	IN
18637	15791	6	speech	speech	NN
18637	15791	7	,	,	,
18637	15791	8	though	though	IN
18637	15791	9	not	not	RB
18637	15791	10	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	15791	11	,	,	,
18637	15791	12	Chaplinsky	Chaplinsky	NNP
18637	15791	13	_	_	NNP
18637	15791	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	15791	15	_	_	NNP
18637	15791	16	New	New	NNP
18637	15791	17	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	15791	18	,	,	,
18637	15791	19	supra	supra	NNP
18637	15791	20	,	,	,
18637	15791	21	pp	pp	NNP
18637	15791	22	.	.	.
18637	15792	1	571	571	CD
18637	15792	2	-	-	SYM
18637	15792	3	572	572	CD
18637	15792	4	,	,	,
18637	15792	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	15792	6	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	15792	7	protected	protect	VBN
18637	15792	8	against	against	IN
18637	15792	9	censorship	censorship	NN
18637	15792	10	or	or	CC
18637	15792	11	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	15792	12	,	,	,
18637	15792	13	unless	unless	IN
18637	15792	14	shown	show	VBN
18637	15792	15	likely	likely	RB
18637	15792	16	to	to	TO
18637	15792	17	produce	produce	VB
18637	15792	18	a	a	DT
18637	15792	19	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15792	20	and	and	CC
18637	15792	21	present	present	JJ
18637	15792	22	danger	danger	NN
18637	15792	23	of	of	IN
18637	15792	24	a	a	DT
18637	15792	25	serious	serious	JJ
18637	15792	26	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15792	27	evil	evil	NN
18637	15792	28	that	that	WDT
18637	15792	29	rises	rise	VBZ
18637	15792	30	far	far	RB
18637	15792	31	above	above	IN
18637	15792	32	public	public	JJ
18637	15792	33	inconvenience	inconvenience	NN
18637	15792	34	,	,	,
18637	15792	35	annoyance	annoyance	NN
18637	15792	36	,	,	,
18637	15792	37	or	or	CC
18637	15792	38	unrest	unrest	NN
18637	15792	39	.	.	.
18637	15793	1	"	"	``
18637	15793	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15793	3	184	184	CD
18637	15793	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15793	5	But	but	CC
18637	15793	6	early	early	RB
18637	15793	7	in	in	IN
18637	15793	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	15793	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15793	10	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	15793	11	,	,	,
18637	15793	12	in	in	IN
18637	15793	13	a	a	DT
18637	15793	14	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	15793	15	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15793	16	,	,	,
18637	15793	17	urges	urge	VBZ
18637	15793	18	the	the	DT
18637	15793	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15793	20	to	to	TO
18637	15793	21	review	review	VB
18637	15793	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15793	23	entire	entire	JJ
18637	15793	24	position	position	NN
18637	15793	25	in	in	IN
18637	15793	26	the	the	DT
18637	15793	27	light	light	NN
18637	15793	28	of	of	IN
18637	15793	29	the	the	DT
18637	15793	30	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	15793	31	that	that	IN
18637	15793	32	"	"	``
18637	15793	33	the	the	DT
18637	15793	34	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15793	35	of	of	IN
18637	15793	36	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15793	37	protection	protection	NN
18637	15793	38	of	of	IN
18637	15793	39	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15793	40	of	of	IN
18637	15793	41	speech	speech	NN
18637	15793	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	15793	43	to	to	TO
18637	15793	44	foster	foster	VB
18637	15793	45	peaceful	peaceful	JJ
18637	15793	46	interchange	interchange	NN
18637	15793	47	of	of	IN
18637	15793	48	all	all	DT
18637	15793	49	manner	manner	NN
18637	15793	50	of	of	IN
18637	15793	51	thoughts	thought	NNS
18637	15793	52	,	,	,
18637	15793	53	information	information	NN
18637	15793	54	and	and	CC
18637	15793	55	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	15793	56	,	,	,
18637	15793	57	"	"	''
18637	15793	58	that	that	IN
18637	15793	59	"	"	``
18637	15793	60	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15793	61	policy	policy	NN
18637	15793	62	is	be	VBZ
18637	15793	63	rooted	root	VBN
18637	15793	64	in	in	IN
18637	15793	65	faith	faith	NN
18637	15793	66	of	of	IN
18637	15793	67	the	the	DT
18637	15793	68	force	force	NN
18637	15793	69	of	of	IN
18637	15793	70	reason	reason	NN
18637	15793	71	.	.	.
18637	15794	1	"	"	``
18637	15794	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15794	3	185	185	CD
18637	15794	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15794	5	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15794	6	considers	consider	VBZ
18637	15794	7	that	that	IN
18637	15794	8	the	the	DT
18637	15794	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15794	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	15794	11	been	be	VBN
18637	15794	12	striking	strike	VBG
18637	15794	13	"	"	``
18637	15794	14	rather	rather	RB
18637	15794	15	blindly	blindly	RB
18637	15794	16	at	at	IN
18637	15794	17	permit	permit	NN
18637	15794	18	systems	system	NNS
18637	15794	19	which	which	WDT
18637	15794	20	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	15794	21	may	may	MD
18637	15794	22	affect	affect	VB
18637	15794	23	First	First	NNP
18637	15794	24	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15794	25	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15794	26	.	.	.
18637	15794	27	"	"	''
18637	15795	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15795	2	says	say	VBZ
18637	15795	3	:	:	:
18637	15795	4	"	"	``
18637	15795	5	Cities	city	NNS
18637	15795	6	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	15795	7	the	the	DT
18637	15795	8	country	country	NN
18637	15795	9	have	have	VBP
18637	15795	10	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	15795	11	the	the	DT
18637	15795	12	permit	permit	NN
18637	15795	13	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	15795	14	to	to	TO
18637	15795	15	control	control	VB
18637	15795	16	private	private	JJ
18637	15795	17	activities	activity	NNS
18637	15795	18	on	on	IN
18637	15795	19	public	public	JJ
18637	15795	20	streets	street	NNS
18637	15795	21	and	and	CC
18637	15795	22	for	for	IN
18637	15795	23	other	other	JJ
18637	15795	24	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	15795	25	.	.	.
18637	15796	1	The	the	DT
18637	15796	2	universality	universality	NN
18637	15796	3	of	of	IN
18637	15796	4	this	this	DT
18637	15796	5	type	type	NN
18637	15796	6	of	of	IN
18637	15796	7	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	15796	8	demonstrates	demonstrate	VBZ
18637	15796	9	a	a	DT
18637	15796	10	need	need	NN
18637	15796	11	and	and	CC
18637	15796	12	indicates	indicate	VBZ
18637	15796	13	widespread	widespread	JJ
18637	15796	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15796	15	in	in	IN
18637	15796	16	the	the	DT
18637	15796	17	profession	profession	NN
18637	15796	18	that	that	IN
18637	15796	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15796	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	15796	21	not	not	RB
18637	15796	22	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	15796	23	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
18637	15796	24	with	with	IN
18637	15796	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15796	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15796	27	freedoms	freedom	NNS
18637	15796	28	.	.	.
18637	15797	1	Is	be	VBZ
18637	15797	2	everybody	everybody	NN
18637	15797	3	out	out	IN
18637	15797	4	of	of	IN
18637	15797	5	step	step	NN
18637	15797	6	but	but	CC
18637	15797	7	this	this	DT
18637	15797	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15797	9	?	?	.
18637	15798	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15798	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15798	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15798	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15798	5	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	15798	6	hypercritical	hypercritical	JJ
18637	15798	7	to	to	TO
18637	15798	8	strike	strike	VB
18637	15798	9	down	down	RP
18637	15798	10	local	local	JJ
18637	15798	11	laws	law	NNS
18637	15798	12	on	on	IN
18637	15798	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15798	14	faces	face	NNS
18637	15798	15	for	for	IN
18637	15798	16	want	want	NN
18637	15798	17	of	of	IN
18637	15798	18	standards	standard	NNS
18637	15798	19	when	when	WRB
18637	15798	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15798	21	have	have	VBP
18637	15798	22	no	no	DT
18637	15798	23	standards	standard	NNS
18637	15798	24	.	.	.
18637	15799	1	And	and	CC
18637	15799	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15799	3	do	do	VBP
18637	15799	4	not	not	RB
18637	15799	5	find	find	VB
18637	15799	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15799	7	required	require	VBN
18637	15799	8	by	by	IN
18637	15799	9	existing	exist	VBG
18637	15799	10	authority	authority	NN
18637	15799	11	.	.	.
18637	15800	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15800	2	think	think	VBP
18637	15800	3	that	that	IN
18637	15800	4	where	where	WRB
18637	15800	5	speech	speech	NN
18637	15800	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	15800	7	outside	outside	RB
18637	15800	8	of	of	IN
18637	15800	9	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15800	10	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	15800	11	the	the	DT
18637	15800	12	local	local	JJ
18637	15800	13	community	community	NN
18637	15800	14	or	or	CC
18637	15800	15	the	the	DT
18637	15800	16	State	State	NNP
18637	15800	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	15800	18	left	leave	VBN
18637	15800	19	a	a	DT
18637	15800	20	large	large	JJ
18637	15800	21	measure	measure	NN
18637	15800	22	of	of	IN
18637	15800	23	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	15800	24	as	as	IN
18637	15800	25	to	to	IN
18637	15800	26	the	the	DT
18637	15800	27	means	mean	NNS
18637	15800	28	for	for	IN
18637	15800	29	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	15800	30	with	with	IN
18637	15800	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15800	32	.	.	.
18637	15801	1	"	"	``
18637	15801	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15801	3	186	186	CD
18637	15801	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15801	5	This	this	DT
18637	15801	6	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	15801	7	of	of	IN
18637	15801	8	viewpoint	viewpoint	NN
18637	15801	9	on	on	IN
18637	15801	10	the	the	DT
18637	15801	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15801	12	touching	touch	VBG
18637	15801	13	the	the	DT
18637	15801	14	above	above	JJ
18637	15801	15	questions	question	NNS
18637	15801	16	became	become	VBD
18637	15801	17	of	of	IN
18637	15801	18	importance	importance	NN
18637	15801	19	when	when	WRB
18637	15801	20	,	,	,
18637	15801	21	recently	recently	RB
18637	15801	22	,	,	,
18637	15801	23	the	the	DT
18637	15801	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15801	25	was	be	VBD
18637	15801	26	faced	face	VBN
18637	15801	27	with	with	IN
18637	15801	28	the	the	DT
18637	15801	29	problem	problem	NN
18637	15801	30	of	of	IN
18637	15801	31	the	the	DT
18637	15801	32	relation	relation	NN
18637	15801	33	of	of	IN
18637	15801	34	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15801	35	of	of	IN
18637	15801	36	speech	speech	NN
18637	15801	37	to	to	IN
18637	15801	38	the	the	DT
18637	15801	39	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	15801	40	powers	power	NNS
18637	15801	41	of	of	IN
18637	15801	42	the	the	DT
18637	15801	43	National	National	NNP
18637	15801	44	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15801	45	,	,	,
18637	15801	46	in	in	IN
18637	15801	47	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	15801	48	to	to	IN
18637	15801	49	the	the	DT
18637	15801	50	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	15801	51	residual	residual	JJ
18637	15801	52	powers	power	NNS
18637	15801	53	of	of	IN
18637	15801	54	the	the	DT
18637	15801	55	States	States	NNP
18637	15801	56	.	.	.
18637	15802	1	TAXATION	TAXATION	NNP
18637	15802	2	The	the	DT
18637	15802	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15802	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15802	5	,	,	,
18637	15802	6	citing	cite	VBG
18637	15802	7	the	the	DT
18637	15802	8	fact	fact	NN
18637	15802	9	that	that	IN
18637	15802	10	the	the	DT
18637	15802	11	American	American	NNP
18637	15802	12	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
18637	15802	13	"	"	''
18637	15802	14	really	really	RB
18637	15802	15	began	begin	VBD
18637	15802	16	when	when	WRB
18637	15802	17	*	*	NFP
18637	15802	18	*	*	NFP
18637	15802	19	*	*	NFP
18637	15802	20	that	that	DT
18637	15802	21	government	government	NN
18637	15802	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15802	23	of	of	IN
18637	15802	24	England	England	NNP
18637	15802	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15802	26	sent	send	VBD
18637	15802	27	stamps	stamp	NNS
18637	15802	28	for	for	IN
18637	15802	29	newspaper	newspaper	NN
18637	15802	30	duties	duty	NNS
18637	15802	31	to	to	IN
18637	15802	32	the	the	DT
18637	15802	33	American	american	JJ
18637	15802	34	colonies	colony	NNS
18637	15802	35	"	"	''
18637	15802	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	15802	37	been	be	VBN
18637	15802	38	alert	alert	JJ
18637	15802	39	to	to	IN
18637	15802	40	the	the	DT
18637	15802	41	possible	possible	JJ
18637	15802	42	uses	use	NNS
18637	15802	43	of	of	IN
18637	15802	44	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	15802	45	as	as	IN
18637	15802	46	a	a	DT
18637	15802	47	method	method	NN
18637	15802	48	of	of	IN
18637	15802	49	suppressing	suppress	VBG
18637	15802	50	objectionable	objectionable	JJ
18637	15802	51	publications	publication	NNS
18637	15802	52	.	.	.
18637	15803	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15803	2	187	187	CD
18637	15803	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15803	4	Persons	person	NNS
18637	15803	5	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	15803	6	in	in	IN
18637	15803	7	the	the	DT
18637	15803	8	dissemination	dissemination	NN
18637	15803	9	of	of	IN
18637	15803	10	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	15803	11	are	be	VBP
18637	15803	12	,	,	,
18637	15803	13	to	to	TO
18637	15803	14	be	be	VB
18637	15803	15	sure	sure	JJ
18637	15803	16	,	,	,
18637	15803	17	subject	subject	JJ
18637	15803	18	to	to	IN
18637	15803	19	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	15803	20	forms	form	NNS
18637	15803	21	of	of	IN
18637	15803	22	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	15803	23	in	in	IN
18637	15803	24	like	like	IN
18637	15803	25	manner	manner	NN
18637	15803	26	as	as	IN
18637	15803	27	other	other	JJ
18637	15803	28	persons	person	NNS
18637	15803	29	.	.	.
18637	15804	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15804	2	188	188	CD
18637	15804	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15804	4	With	with	IN
18637	15804	5	respect	respect	NN
18637	15804	6	to	to	TO
18637	15804	7	license	license	NN
18637	15804	8	or	or	CC
18637	15804	9	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	15804	10	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	15804	11	,	,	,
18637	15804	12	however	however	RB
18637	15804	13	,	,	,
18637	15804	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15804	15	stand	stand	VBP
18637	15804	16	on	on	IN
18637	15804	17	a	a	DT
18637	15804	18	different	different	JJ
18637	15804	19	footing	footing	NN
18637	15804	20	.	.	.
18637	15805	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15805	2	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	15805	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	15805	4	granted	grant	VBN
18637	15805	5	by	by	IN
18637	15805	6	the	the	DT
18637	15805	7	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15805	8	and	and	CC
18637	15805	9	can	can	MD
18637	15805	10	not	not	RB
18637	15805	11	be	be	VB
18637	15805	12	withheld	withhold	VBN
18637	15805	13	by	by	IN
18637	15805	14	either	either	DT
18637	15805	15	State	State	NNP
18637	15805	16	or	or	CC
18637	15805	17	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	15805	18	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15805	19	.	.	.
18637	15806	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	15806	2	a	a	DT
18637	15806	3	license	license	NN
18637	15806	4	tax	tax	NN
18637	15806	5	measured	measure	VBN
18637	15806	6	by	by	IN
18637	15806	7	gross	gross	JJ
18637	15806	8	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	15806	9	for	for	IN
18637	15806	10	the	the	DT
18637	15806	11	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	15806	12	of	of	IN
18637	15806	13	engaging	engage	VBG
18637	15806	14	in	in	IN
18637	15806	15	the	the	DT
18637	15806	16	business	business	NN
18637	15806	17	of	of	IN
18637	15806	18	publishing	publishing	NN
18637	15806	19	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	15806	20	in	in	IN
18637	15806	21	any	any	DT
18637	15806	22	newspaper	newspaper	NN
18637	15806	23	or	or	CC
18637	15806	24	other	other	JJ
18637	15806	25	publication	publication	NN
18637	15806	26	was	be	VBD
18637	15806	27	held	hold	VBN
18637	15806	28	invalid[189	invalid[189	``
18637	15806	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15806	30	and	and	CC
18637	15806	31	flat	flat	JJ
18637	15806	32	license	license	NN
18637	15806	33	fees	fee	NNS
18637	15806	34	levied	levy	VBN
18637	15806	35	and	and	CC
18637	15806	36	collected	collect	VBN
18637	15806	37	as	as	IN
18637	15806	38	a	a	DT
18637	15806	39	pre	pre	NN
18637	15806	40	-	-	NN
18637	15806	41	condition	condition	NN
18637	15806	42	to	to	IN
18637	15806	43	the	the	DT
18637	15806	44	sale	sale	NN
18637	15806	45	of	of	IN
18637	15806	46	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15806	47	books	book	NNS
18637	15806	48	and	and	CC
18637	15806	49	pamphlets	pamphlet	NNS
18637	15806	50	have	have	VBP
18637	15806	51	also	also	RB
18637	15806	52	been	be	VBN
18637	15806	53	set	set	VBN
18637	15806	54	side	side	NN
18637	15806	55	.	.	.
18637	15807	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15807	2	190	190	CD
18637	15807	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15807	4	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	15807	5	RESTRAINTS	restraint	NNS
18637	15807	6	ON	on	IN
18637	15807	7	FREEDOM	freedom	NN
18637	15807	8	OF	of	IN
18637	15807	9	SPEECH	SPEECH	NNP
18637	15807	10	AND	and	CC
18637	15807	11	PRESS	PRESS	NNP
18637	15807	12	Regulations	Regulations	NNPS
18637	15807	13	of	of	IN
18637	15807	14	Business	Business	NNP
18637	15807	15	and	and	CC
18637	15807	16	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	15807	17	Activities	Activities	NNPS
18637	15807	18	The	the	DT
18637	15807	19	application	application	NN
18637	15807	20	to	to	IN
18637	15807	21	newspapers	newspaper	NNS
18637	15807	22	of	of	IN
18637	15807	23	the	the	DT
18637	15807	24	Anti	Anti	NNP
18637	15807	25	-	-	NNP
18637	15807	26	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	15807	27	Laws,[191	laws,[191	NN
18637	15807	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15807	29	the	the	DT
18637	15807	30	National	National	NNP
18637	15807	31	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	15807	32	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	15807	33	Act,[192	Act,[192	NNP
18637	15807	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15807	35	or	or	CC
18637	15807	36	the	the	DT
18637	15807	37	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	15807	38	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	15807	39	Standards	Standards	NNP
18637	15807	40	Act,[193	Act,[193	NNP
18637	15807	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15807	42	does	do	VBZ
18637	15807	43	not	not	RB
18637	15807	44	abridge	abridge	VB
18637	15807	45	the	the	DT
18637	15807	46	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15807	47	of	of	IN
18637	15807	48	the	the	DT
18637	15807	49	press	press	NN
18637	15807	50	.	.	.
18637	15808	1	In	in	IN
18637	15808	2	Gompers	Gompers	NNP
18637	15808	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15808	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	15808	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15808	6	Bucks	Bucks	NNPS
18637	15808	7	Stove	Stove	NNP
18637	15808	8	and	and	CC
18637	15808	9	Range	Range	NNP
18637	15808	10	Co	Co	NNP
18637	15808	11	.	.	.
18637	15808	12	,[194	,[194	NFP
18637	15808	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15808	14	the	the	DT
18637	15808	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15808	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15808	17	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	15808	18	held	hold	VBD
18637	15808	19	that	that	IN
18637	15808	20	a	a	DT
18637	15808	21	court	court	NN
18637	15808	22	of	of	IN
18637	15808	23	equity	equity	NN
18637	15808	24	may	may	MD
18637	15808	25	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	15808	26	continuance	continuance	NN
18637	15808	27	of	of	IN
18637	15808	28	a	a	DT
18637	15808	29	boycott	boycott	NN
18637	15808	30	,	,	,
18637	15808	31	despite	despite	IN
18637	15808	32	the	the	DT
18637	15808	33	fact	fact	NN
18637	15808	34	that	that	IN
18637	15808	35	spoken	speak	VBD
18637	15808	36	or	or	CC
18637	15808	37	written	write	VBN
18637	15808	38	speech	speech	NN
18637	15808	39	was	be	VBD
18637	15808	40	used	use	VBN
18637	15808	41	as	as	IN
18637	15808	42	an	an	DT
18637	15808	43	instrumentality	instrumentality	NN
18637	15808	44	by	by	IN
18637	15808	45	which	which	WDT
18637	15808	46	the	the	DT
18637	15808	47	boycott	boycott	NN
18637	15808	48	was	be	VBD
18637	15808	49	made	make	VBN
18637	15808	50	effective	effective	JJ
18637	15808	51	.	.	.
18637	15809	1	"	"	``
18637	15809	2	In	in	IN
18637	15809	3	the	the	DT
18637	15809	4	case	case	NN
18637	15809	5	of	of	IN
18637	15809	6	an	an	DT
18637	15809	7	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	15809	8	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15809	9	,	,	,
18637	15809	10	the	the	DT
18637	15809	11	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	15809	12	to	to	TO
18637	15809	13	act	act	VB
18637	15809	14	in	in	IN
18637	15809	15	concert	concert	NN
18637	15809	16	when	when	WRB
18637	15809	17	the	the	DT
18637	15809	18	signal	signal	NN
18637	15809	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	15809	20	published	publish	VBN
18637	15809	21	gives	give	VBZ
18637	15809	22	the	the	DT
18637	15809	23	words	word	NNS
18637	15809	24	'	'	POS
18637	15809	25	Unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	15809	26	,	,	,
18637	15809	27	'	'	''
18637	15809	28	'	'	''
18637	15809	29	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15809	30	Do	do	VBP
18637	15809	31	n't	not	RB
18637	15809	32	Patronize	patronize	VB
18637	15809	33	,	,	,
18637	15809	34	'	'	''
18637	15809	35	or	or	CC
18637	15809	36	similar	similar	JJ
18637	15809	37	expressions	expression	NNS
18637	15809	38	,	,	,
18637	15809	39	a	a	DT
18637	15809	40	force	force	NN
18637	15809	41	not	not	RB
18637	15809	42	inhering	inhere	VBG
18637	15809	43	in	in	IN
18637	15809	44	the	the	DT
18637	15809	45	words	word	NNS
18637	15809	46	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15809	47	,	,	,
18637	15809	48	and	and	CC
18637	15809	49	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	15809	50	exceeding	exceed	VBG
18637	15809	51	any	any	DT
18637	15809	52	possible	possible	JJ
18637	15809	53	right	right	NN
18637	15809	54	of	of	IN
18637	15809	55	speech	speech	NN
18637	15809	56	which	which	WDT
18637	15809	57	a	a	DT
18637	15809	58	single	single	JJ
18637	15809	59	individual	individual	NN
18637	15809	60	might	may	MD
18637	15809	61	have	have	VB
18637	15809	62	.	.	.
18637	15810	1	Under	under	IN
18637	15810	2	such	such	JJ
18637	15810	3	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	15810	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15810	5	become	become	VBP
18637	15810	6	what	what	WP
18637	15810	7	have	have	VBP
18637	15810	8	been	be	VBN
18637	15810	9	called	call	VBN
18637	15810	10	'	'	''
18637	15810	11	verbal	verbal	JJ
18637	15810	12	acts	act	NNS
18637	15810	13	,	,	,
18637	15810	14	'	'	''
18637	15810	15	and	and	CC
18637	15810	16	as	as	RB
18637	15810	17	much	much	JJ
18637	15810	18	subject	subject	NN
18637	15810	19	to	to	IN
18637	15810	20	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	15810	21	as	as	IN
18637	15810	22	the	the	DT
18637	15810	23	use	use	NN
18637	15810	24	of	of	IN
18637	15810	25	any	any	DT
18637	15810	26	other	other	JJ
18637	15810	27	force	force	NN
18637	15810	28	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	15810	29	property	property	NN
18637	15810	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	15810	31	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	15810	32	damaged	damage	VBN
18637	15810	33	.	.	.
18637	15811	1	"	"	``
18637	15811	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15811	3	195	195	CD
18637	15811	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15811	5	A	a	DT
18637	15811	6	cognate	cognate	NN
18637	15811	7	test	test	NN
18637	15811	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	15811	9	been	be	VBN
18637	15811	10	applied	apply	VBN
18637	15811	11	in	in	IN
18637	15811	12	determining	determine	VBG
18637	15811	13	when	when	WRB
18637	15811	14	communications	communication	NNS
18637	15811	15	by	by	IN
18637	15811	16	an	an	DT
18637	15811	17	employer	employer	NN
18637	15811	18	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	15811	19	an	an	DT
18637	15811	20	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	15811	21	labor	labor	NN
18637	15811	22	practice	practice	NN
18637	15811	23	which	which	WDT
18637	15811	24	may	may	MD
18637	15811	25	be	be	VB
18637	15811	26	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	15811	27	or	or	CC
18637	15811	28	penalized	penalize	VBN
18637	15811	29	under	under	IN
18637	15811	30	the	the	DT
18637	15811	31	National	National	NNP
18637	15811	32	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	15811	33	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	15811	34	Act	Act	NNP
18637	15811	35	without	without	IN
18637	15811	36	infringing	infringe	VBG
18637	15811	37	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15811	38	of	of	IN
18637	15811	39	speech	speech	NN
18637	15811	40	.	.	.
18637	15812	1	In	in	IN
18637	15812	2	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	15812	3	Board	Board	NNP
18637	15812	4	_	_	NNP
18637	15812	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	15812	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15812	7	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	15812	8	Power	Power	NNP
18637	15812	9	Co	Co	NNP
18637	15812	10	.	.	.
18637	15812	11	,[196	,[196	,
18637	15812	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15812	13	the	the	DT
18637	15812	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15812	15	held	hold	VBD
18637	15812	16	that	that	IN
18637	15812	17	the	the	DT
18637	15812	18	sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	15812	19	of	of	IN
18637	15812	20	the	the	DT
18637	15812	21	act	act	NN
18637	15812	22	might	may	MD
18637	15812	23	be	be	VB
18637	15812	24	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	15812	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	15812	26	an	an	DT
18637	15812	27	employer	employer	NN
18637	15812	28	for	for	IN
18637	15812	29	the	the	DT
18637	15812	30	protection	protection	NN
18637	15812	31	of	of	IN
18637	15812	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15812	33	employees	employee	NNS
18637	15812	34	,	,	,
18637	15812	35	where	where	WRB
18637	15812	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15812	37	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	15812	38	"	"	''
18637	15812	39	though	though	IN
18637	15812	40	evidenced	evidence	VBN
18637	15812	41	in	in	IN
18637	15812	42	part	part	NN
18637	15812	43	by	by	IN
18637	15812	44	speech	speech	NN
18637	15812	45	,	,	,
18637	15812	46	*	*	NFP
18637	15812	47	*	*	NFP
18637	15812	48	*	*	NFP
18637	15812	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15812	50	amounted	amount	VBD
18637	15812	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15812	52	to	to	TO
18637	15812	53	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	15812	54	within	within	IN
18637	15812	55	the	the	DT
18637	15812	56	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	15812	57	of	of	IN
18637	15812	58	the	the	DT
18637	15812	59	act	act	NN
18637	15812	60	.	.	.
18637	15813	1	"	"	``
18637	15813	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15813	3	197	197	CD
18637	15813	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15813	5	In	in	IN
18637	15813	6	the	the	DT
18637	15813	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15813	8	of	of	IN
18637	15813	9	the	the	DT
18637	15813	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15813	11	,	,	,
18637	15813	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15813	13	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	15813	14	stated	state	VBD
18637	15813	15	,	,	,
18637	15813	16	"	"	``
18637	15813	17	The	the	DT
18637	15813	18	mere	mere	JJ
18637	15813	19	fact	fact	NN
18637	15813	20	that	that	IN
18637	15813	21	language	language	NN
18637	15813	22	merges	merge	NNS
18637	15813	23	into	into	IN
18637	15813	24	a	a	DT
18637	15813	25	course	course	NN
18637	15813	26	of	of	IN
18637	15813	27	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	15813	28	does	do	VBZ
18637	15813	29	not	not	RB
18637	15813	30	put	put	VB
18637	15813	31	that	that	DT
18637	15813	32	whole	whole	JJ
18637	15813	33	course	course	NN
18637	15813	34	without	without	IN
18637	15813	35	the	the	DT
18637	15813	36	range	range	NN
18637	15813	37	of	of	IN
18637	15813	38	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	15813	39	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	15813	40	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	15813	41	power	power	NN
18637	15813	42	.	.	.
18637	15814	1	In	in	IN
18637	15814	2	determining	determine	VBG
18637	15814	3	whether	whether	IN
18637	15814	4	the	the	DT
18637	15814	5	Company	Company	NNP
18637	15814	6	actually	actually	RB
18637	15814	7	interfered	interfere	VBD
18637	15814	8	with	with	IN
18637	15814	9	,	,	,
18637	15814	10	restrained	restrained	JJ
18637	15814	11	,	,	,
18637	15814	12	and	and	CC
18637	15814	13	coerced	coerce	VBD
18637	15814	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15814	15	employees	employee	NNS
18637	15814	16	,	,	,
18637	15814	17	the	the	DT
18637	15814	18	Board	Board	NNP
18637	15814	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	15814	20	a	a	DT
18637	15814	21	right	right	NN
18637	15814	22	to	to	TO
18637	15814	23	look	look	VB
18637	15814	24	at	at	IN
18637	15814	25	what	what	WP
18637	15814	26	the	the	DT
18637	15814	27	Company	Company	NNP
18637	15814	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	15814	29	said	say	VBN
18637	15814	30	,	,	,
18637	15814	31	as	as	RB
18637	15814	32	well	well	RB
18637	15814	33	as	as	IN
18637	15814	34	what	what	WP
18637	15814	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15814	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	15814	37	done	do	VBN
18637	15814	38	.	.	.
18637	15815	1	"	"	``
18637	15815	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15815	3	198	198	CD
18637	15815	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15815	5	But	but	CC
18637	15815	6	the	the	DT
18637	15815	7	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	15815	8	of	of	IN
18637	15815	9	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15815	10	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	15815	11	the	the	DT
18637	15815	12	publication	publication	NN
18637	15815	13	by	by	IN
18637	15815	14	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	15815	15	and	and	CC
18637	15815	16	unions	union	NNS
18637	15815	17	in	in	IN
18637	15815	18	the	the	DT
18637	15815	19	regular	regular	JJ
18637	15815	20	course	course	NN
18637	15815	21	of	of	IN
18637	15815	22	conducting	conduct	VBG
18637	15815	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15815	24	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	15815	25	of	of	IN
18637	15815	26	periodicals	periodical	NNS
18637	15815	27	advising	advise	VBG
18637	15815	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15815	29	members	member	NNS
18637	15815	30	,	,	,
18637	15815	31	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	15815	32	or	or	CC
18637	15815	33	customers	customer	NNS
18637	15815	34	of	of	IN
18637	15815	35	danger	danger	NN
18637	15815	36	or	or	CC
18637	15815	37	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	15815	38	to	to	IN
18637	15815	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15815	40	interest	interest	NN
18637	15815	41	from	from	IN
18637	15815	42	the	the	DT
18637	15815	43	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	15815	44	of	of	IN
18637	15815	45	measures	measure	NNS
18637	15815	46	or	or	CC
18637	15815	47	the	the	DT
18637	15815	48	election	election	NN
18637	15815	49	to	to	IN
18637	15815	50	office	office	NN
18637	15815	51	of	of	IN
18637	15815	52	men	man	NNS
18637	15815	53	espousing	espouse	VBG
18637	15815	54	such	such	JJ
18637	15815	55	measures	measure	NNS
18637	15815	56	has	have	VBZ
18637	15815	57	been	be	VBN
18637	15815	58	declared	declare	VBN
18637	15815	59	by	by	IN
18637	15815	60	the	the	DT
18637	15815	61	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15815	62	to	to	TO
18637	15815	63	be	be	VB
18637	15815	64	open	open	JJ
18637	15815	65	to	to	IN
18637	15815	66	gravest	gravest	NN
18637	15815	67	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	15815	68	.	.	.
18637	15816	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15816	2	199	199	CD
18637	15816	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15816	4	REGULATION	regulation	NN
18637	15816	5	OF	of	IN
18637	15816	6	POLITICAL	political	JJ
18637	15816	7	ACTIVITIES	activity	NNS
18637	15816	8	OF	of	IN
18637	15816	9	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	15816	10	EMPLOYEES	employees	NN
18637	15816	11	The	the	DT
18637	15816	12	leading	leading	JJ
18637	15816	13	case	case	NN
18637	15816	14	touching	touch	VBG
18637	15816	15	this	this	DT
18637	15816	16	subject	subject	NN
18637	15816	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	15816	18	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	15816	19	parte	parte	NN
18637	15816	20	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	15816	21	,	,	,
18637	15816	22	decided	decide	VBD
18637	15816	23	seventy	seventy	CD
18637	15816	24	years	year	NNS
18637	15816	25	ago	ago	RB
18637	15816	26	.	.	.
18637	15817	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15817	2	200	200	CD
18637	15817	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15817	4	Here	here	RB
18637	15817	5	was	be	VBD
18637	15817	6	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	15817	7	an	an	DT
18637	15817	8	act	act	NN
18637	15817	9	of	of	IN
18637	15817	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15817	11	which	which	WDT
18637	15817	12	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	15817	13	,	,	,
18637	15817	14	under	under	IN
18637	15817	15	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	15817	16	,	,	,
18637	15817	17	certain	certain	JJ
18637	15817	18	categories	category	NNS
18637	15817	19	of	of	IN
18637	15817	20	officers	officer	NNS
18637	15817	21	of	of	IN
18637	15817	22	the	the	DT
18637	15817	23	United	United	NNP
18637	15817	24	States	States	NNP
18637	15817	25	from	from	IN
18637	15817	26	requesting	request	VBG
18637	15817	27	,	,	,
18637	15817	28	giving	give	VBG
18637	15817	29	to	to	IN
18637	15817	30	,	,	,
18637	15817	31	or	or	CC
18637	15817	32	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	15817	33	from	from	IN
18637	15817	34	,	,	,
18637	15817	35	any	any	DT
18637	15817	36	other	other	JJ
18637	15817	37	officer	officer	NN
18637	15817	38	,	,	,
18637	15817	39	money	money	NN
18637	15817	40	or	or	CC
18637	15817	41	property	property	NN
18637	15817	42	or	or	CC
18637	15817	43	other	other	JJ
18637	15817	44	thing	thing	NN
18637	15817	45	of	of	IN
18637	15817	46	value	value	NN
18637	15817	47	for	for	IN
18637	15817	48	political	political	JJ
18637	15817	49	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	15817	50	.	.	.
18637	15818	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15818	2	201	201	CD
18637	15818	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15818	4	Two	two	CD
18637	15818	5	generations	generation	NNS
18637	15818	6	later	later	RB
18637	15818	7	was	be	VBD
18637	15818	8	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	15818	9	the	the	DT
18637	15818	10	so	so	RB
18637	15818	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	15818	12	called	call	VBN
18637	15818	13	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	15818	14	Act[202	Act[202	NNP
18637	15818	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15818	16	which	which	WDT
18637	15818	17	,	,	,
18637	15818	18	while	while	IN
18637	15818	19	making	make	VBG
18637	15818	20	some	some	DT
18637	15818	21	concessions	concession	NNS
18637	15818	22	to	to	IN
18637	15818	23	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15818	24	of	of	IN
18637	15818	25	expression	expression	NN
18637	15818	26	on	on	IN
18637	15818	27	matters	matter	NNS
18637	15818	28	political	political	JJ
18637	15818	29	by	by	IN
18637	15818	30	employees	employee	NNS
18637	15818	31	of	of	IN
18637	15818	32	the	the	DT
18637	15818	33	government	government	NN
18637	15818	34	,	,	,
18637	15818	35	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	15818	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15818	37	active	active	JJ
18637	15818	38	participation	participation	NN
18637	15818	39	in	in	IN
18637	15818	40	political	political	JJ
18637	15818	41	management	management	NN
18637	15818	42	and	and	CC
18637	15818	43	political	political	JJ
18637	15818	44	campaigns	campaign	NNS
18637	15818	45	.	.	.
18637	15819	1	The	the	DT
18637	15819	2	act	act	NN
18637	15819	3	was	be	VBD
18637	15819	4	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	15819	5	against	against	IN
18637	15819	6	objections	objection	NNS
18637	15819	7	based	base	VBN
18637	15819	8	on	on	IN
18637	15819	9	the	the	DT
18637	15819	10	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	15819	11	of	of	IN
18637	15819	12	Rights;[203	Rights;[203	NNP
18637	15819	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15819	14	while	while	IN
18637	15819	15	an	an	DT
18637	15819	16	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	15819	17	to	to	IN
18637	15819	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15819	19	the	the	DT
18637	15819	20	effect	effect	NN
18637	15819	21	of	of	IN
18637	15819	22	which	which	WDT
18637	15819	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	15819	24	to	to	TO
18637	15819	25	diminish	diminish	VB
18637	15819	26	the	the	DT
18637	15819	27	amount	amount	NN
18637	15819	28	of	of	IN
18637	15819	29	a	a	DT
18637	15819	30	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15819	31	grant	grant	NN
18637	15819	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	15819	33	in	in	IN
18637	15819	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	15819	35	aid	aid	NN
18637	15819	36	of	of	IN
18637	15819	37	the	the	DT
18637	15819	38	construction	construction	NN
18637	15819	39	of	of	IN
18637	15819	40	highways	highway	NNS
18637	15819	41	in	in	IN
18637	15819	42	a	a	DT
18637	15819	43	State	state	NN
18637	15819	44	which	which	WDT
18637	15819	45	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	15819	46	to	to	TO
18637	15819	47	remove	remove	VB
18637	15819	48	from	from	IN
18637	15819	49	office	office	NN
18637	15819	50	"	"	``
18637	15819	51	one	one	CD
18637	15819	52	found	find	VBN
18637	15819	53	by	by	IN
18637	15819	54	the	the	DT
18637	15819	55	United	United	NNP
18637	15819	56	States	States	NNP
18637	15819	57	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	15819	58	Service	Service	NNP
18637	15819	59	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	15819	60	to	to	TO
18637	15819	61	have	have	VB
18637	15819	62	taken	take	VBN
18637	15819	63	active	active	JJ
18637	15819	64	part	part	NN
18637	15819	65	in	in	IN
18637	15819	66	political	political	JJ
18637	15819	67	management	management	NN
18637	15819	68	or	or	CC
18637	15819	69	in	in	IN
18637	15819	70	political	political	JJ
18637	15819	71	campaigns	campaign	NNS
18637	15819	72	while	while	IN
18637	15819	73	a	a	DT
18637	15819	74	member	member	NN
18637	15819	75	of	of	IN
18637	15819	76	the	the	DT
18637	15819	77	state	state	NNP
18637	15819	78	highway	highway	NNP
18637	15819	79	commission	commission	NNP
18637	15819	80	,	,	,
18637	15819	81	"	"	``
18637	15819	82	was	be	VBD
18637	15819	83	held	hold	VBN
18637	15819	84	not	not	RB
18637	15819	85	to	to	TO
18637	15819	86	violate	violate	VB
18637	15819	87	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15819	88	X.	X.	NNP
18637	15820	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15820	2	204	204	CD
18637	15820	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15820	4	LEGISLATION	legislation	NN
18637	15820	5	PROTECTIVE	protective	RB
18637	15820	6	OF	of	IN
18637	15820	7	THE	the	DT
18637	15820	8	ARMED	ARMED	NNP
18637	15820	9	FORCES	force	NNS
18637	15820	10	AND	and	CC
18637	15820	11	OF	of	IN
18637	15820	12	THE	the	DT
18637	15820	13	WAR	WAR	NNP
18637	15820	14	POWER	POWER	NNP
18637	15820	15	The	the	DT
18637	15820	16	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	15820	17	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15820	18	may	may	MD
18637	15820	19	punish	punish	VB
18637	15820	20	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	15820	21	which	which	WDT
18637	15820	22	obstruct	obstruct	VBP
18637	15820	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15820	24	recruiting	recruiting	NN
18637	15820	25	or	or	CC
18637	15820	26	enlistment	enlistment	NN
18637	15820	27	service	service	NN
18637	15820	28	,	,	,
18637	15820	29	cause	cause	VB
18637	15820	30	insubordination	insubordination	NN
18637	15820	31	in	in	IN
18637	15820	32	the	the	DT
18637	15820	33	armed	armed	JJ
18637	15820	34	forces	force	NNS
18637	15820	35	,	,	,
18637	15820	36	encourage	encourage	VBP
18637	15820	37	resistance	resistance	NN
18637	15820	38	to	to	IN
18637	15820	39	government	government	NN
18637	15820	40	in	in	IN
18637	15820	41	the	the	DT
18637	15820	42	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	15820	43	of	of	IN
18637	15820	44	war	war	NN
18637	15820	45	,	,	,
18637	15820	46	or	or	CC
18637	15820	47	impede	impede	VB
18637	15820	48	the	the	DT
18637	15820	49	production	production	NN
18637	15820	50	of	of	IN
18637	15820	51	munitions	munition	NNS
18637	15820	52	and	and	CC
18637	15820	53	other	other	JJ
18637	15820	54	essential	essential	JJ
18637	15820	55	war	war	NN
18637	15820	56	material	material	NN
18637	15820	57	.	.	.
18637	15821	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15821	2	205	205	CD
18637	15821	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15821	4	The	the	DT
18637	15821	5	only	only	JJ
18637	15821	6	issue	issue	NN
18637	15821	7	which	which	WDT
18637	15821	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	15821	9	divided	divide	VBN
18637	15821	10	the	the	DT
18637	15821	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15821	12	with	with	IN
18637	15821	13	regard	regard	NN
18637	15821	14	to	to	IN
18637	15821	15	such	such	JJ
18637	15821	16	speech	speech	NN
18637	15821	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	15821	18	been	be	VBN
18637	15821	19	the	the	DT
18637	15821	20	degree	degree	NN
18637	15821	21	of	of	IN
18637	15821	22	danger	danger	NN
18637	15821	23	which	which	WDT
18637	15821	24	must	must	MD
18637	15821	25	exist	exist	VB
18637	15821	26	before	before	IN
18637	15821	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15821	28	may	may	MD
18637	15821	29	be	be	VB
18637	15821	30	punished	punish	VBN
18637	15821	31	.	.	.
18637	15822	1	The	the	DT
18637	15822	2	recent	recent	JJ
18637	15822	3	decision	decision	NN
18637	15822	4	in	in	IN
18637	15822	5	Dennis	Dennis	NNP
18637	15822	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15822	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15822	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15822	9	United	United	NNP
18637	15822	10	States	States	NNP
18637	15822	11	diminishes	diminish	VBZ
18637	15822	12	,	,	,
18637	15822	13	if	if	IN
18637	15822	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15822	15	does	do	VBZ
18637	15822	16	not	not	RB
18637	15822	17	eliminate	eliminate	VB
18637	15822	18	,	,	,
18637	15822	19	this	this	DT
18637	15822	20	issue	issue	NN
18637	15822	21	.	.	.
18637	15823	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15823	2	206	206	CD
18637	15823	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15823	4	LOYALTY	LOYALTY	NNP
18637	15823	5	REGULATIONS	regulation	NNS
18637	15823	6	:	:	:
18637	15823	7	THE	the	DT
18637	15823	8	DOUDS	DOUDS	NNP
18637	15823	9	CASES	case	NNS
18637	15823	10	"	"	``
18637	15823	11	Section	section	NN
18637	15823	12	9	9	CD
18637	15823	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15823	14	h	h	NN
18637	15823	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15823	16	of	of	IN
18637	15823	17	the	the	DT
18637	15823	18	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	15823	19	Management	Management	NNP
18637	15823	20	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	15823	21	Act	Act	NNP
18637	15823	22	requires	require	VBZ
18637	15823	23	,	,	,
18637	15823	24	as	as	IN
18637	15823	25	a	a	DT
18637	15823	26	condition	condition	NN
18637	15823	27	of	of	IN
18637	15823	28	a	a	DT
18637	15823	29	union	union	NN
18637	15823	30	's	's	POS
18637	15823	31	utilizing	utilize	VBG
18637	15823	32	the	the	DT
18637	15823	33	opportunities	opportunity	NNS
18637	15823	34	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	15823	35	by	by	IN
18637	15823	36	the	the	DT
18637	15823	37	act	act	NN
18637	15823	38	,	,	,
18637	15823	39	each	each	DT
18637	15823	40	of	of	IN
18637	15823	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15823	42	officers	officer	NNS
18637	15823	43	to	to	TO
18637	15823	44	file	file	VB
18637	15823	45	an	an	DT
18637	15823	46	affidavit	affidavit	NN
18637	15823	47	with	with	IN
18637	15823	48	the	the	DT
18637	15823	49	National	National	NNP
18637	15823	50	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	15823	51	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	15823	52	Board	Board	NNP
18637	15823	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15823	54	1	1	CD
18637	15823	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15823	56	that	that	IN
18637	15823	57	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15823	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	15823	59	not	not	RB
18637	15823	60	a	a	DT
18637	15823	61	member	member	NN
18637	15823	62	of	of	IN
18637	15823	63	the	the	DT
18637	15823	64	Communist	Communist	NNP
18637	15823	65	Party	Party	NNP
18637	15823	66	or	or	CC
18637	15823	67	affiliated	affiliate	VBN
18637	15823	68	with	with	IN
18637	15823	69	such	such	JJ
18637	15823	70	party	party	NN
18637	15823	71	,	,	,
18637	15823	72	and	and	CC
18637	15823	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15823	74	2	2	LS
18637	15823	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15823	76	that	that	IN
18637	15823	77	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15823	78	does	do	VBZ
18637	15823	79	not	not	RB
18637	15823	80	believe	believe	VB
18637	15823	81	in	in	IN
18637	15823	82	,	,	,
18637	15823	83	and	and	CC
18637	15823	84	is	be	VBZ
18637	15823	85	not	not	RB
18637	15823	86	a	a	DT
18637	15823	87	member	member	NN
18637	15823	88	of	of	IN
18637	15823	89	or	or	CC
18637	15823	90	supports	support	VBZ
18637	15823	91	any	any	DT
18637	15823	92	organization	organization	NN
18637	15823	93	that	that	WDT
18637	15823	94	believes	believe	VBZ
18637	15823	95	in	in	RP
18637	15823	96	or	or	CC
18637	15823	97	teaches	teach	VBZ
18637	15823	98	the	the	DT
18637	15823	99	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	15823	100	of	of	IN
18637	15823	101	the	the	DT
18637	15823	102	United	United	NNP
18637	15823	103	States	States	NNP
18637	15823	104	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15823	105	by	by	IN
18637	15823	106	force	force	NN
18637	15823	107	or	or	CC
18637	15823	108	by	by	IN
18637	15823	109	any	any	DT
18637	15823	110	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	15823	111	or	or	CC
18637	15823	112	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	15823	113	methods	method	NNS
18637	15823	114	.	.	.
18637	15823	115	"	"	''
18637	15824	1	The	the	DT
18637	15824	2	statute	statute	NN
18637	15824	3	also	also	RB
18637	15824	4	makes	make	VBZ
18637	15824	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15824	6	a	a	DT
18637	15824	7	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15824	8	offense	offense	NN
18637	15824	9	to	to	TO
18637	15824	10	make	make	VB
18637	15824	11	willfully	willfully	RB
18637	15824	12	or	or	CC
18637	15824	13	knowingly	knowingly	VB
18637	15824	14	any	any	DT
18637	15824	15	false	false	JJ
18637	15824	16	statement	statement	NN
18637	15824	17	in	in	IN
18637	15824	18	such	such	PDT
18637	15824	19	an	an	DT
18637	15824	20	affidavit	affidavit	NN
18637	15824	21	.	.	.
18637	15825	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15825	2	207	207	CD
18637	15825	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15825	4	In	in	IN
18637	15825	5	American	American	NNP
18637	15825	6	Communications	Communications	NNP
18637	15825	7	Association	Association	NNP
18637	15825	8	,	,	,
18637	15825	9	C.I.O.	C.I.O.	NNP
18637	15826	1	et	et	NNP
18637	15826	2	al	al	NNP
18637	15826	3	.	.	.
18637	15827	1	_	_	NNP
18637	15827	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	15827	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15827	4	Douds[208	Douds[208	NNP
18637	15827	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15827	6	five	five	CD
18637	15827	7	of	of	IN
18637	15827	8	the	the	DT
18637	15827	9	six	six	CD
18637	15827	10	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15827	11	participating	participate	VBG
18637	15827	12	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15827	13	the	the	DT
18637	15827	14	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	15827	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15827	16	1	1	CD
18637	15827	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15827	18	and	and	CC
18637	15827	19	three	three	CD
18637	15827	20	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15827	21	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15827	22	the	the	DT
18637	15827	23	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	15827	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15827	25	2	2	LS
18637	15827	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15827	27	against	against	IN
18637	15827	28	the	the	DT
18637	15827	29	objection	objection	NN
18637	15827	30	that	that	WDT
18637	15827	31	the	the	DT
18637	15827	32	act	act	NN
18637	15827	33	exceeded	exceed	VBD
18637	15827	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15827	35	's	's	POS
18637	15827	36	power	power	NN
18637	15827	37	over	over	IN
18637	15827	38	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	15827	39	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	15827	40	and	and	CC
18637	15827	41	infringed	infringe	VBD
18637	15827	42	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15827	43	of	of	IN
18637	15827	44	speech	speech	NN
18637	15827	45	and	and	CC
18637	15827	46	the	the	DT
18637	15827	47	rights	right	NNS
18637	15827	48	of	of	IN
18637	15827	49	petition	petition	NN
18637	15827	50	and	and	CC
18637	15827	51	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	15827	52	;	;	:
18637	15827	53	and	and	CC
18637	15827	54	in	in	IN
18637	15827	55	Osman	Osman	NNP
18637	15827	56	_	_	NNP
18637	15827	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	15827	58	_	_	NNP
18637	15827	59	Douds[209	Douds[209	NNP
18637	15827	60	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15827	61	the	the	DT
18637	15827	62	same	same	JJ
18637	15827	63	result	result	NN
18637	15827	64	was	be	VBD
18637	15827	65	reached	reach	VBN
18637	15827	66	by	by	IN
18637	15827	67	a	a	DT
18637	15827	68	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15827	69	in	in	IN
18637	15827	70	which	which	WDT
18637	15827	71	only	only	RB
18637	15827	72	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15827	73	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	15827	74	did	do	VBD
18637	15827	75	not	not	RB
18637	15827	76	participate	participate	VB
18637	15827	77	.	.	.
18637	15828	1	In	in	IN
18637	15828	2	the	the	DT
18637	15828	3	end	end	NN
18637	15828	4	only	only	RB
18637	15828	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15828	6	Black	Black	NNP
18637	15828	7	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	15828	8	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	15828	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15828	10	1	1	CD
18637	15828	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15828	12	,	,	,
18637	15828	13	while	while	IN
18637	15828	14	the	the	DT
18637	15828	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15828	16	was	be	VBD
18637	15828	17	evenly	evenly	RB
18637	15828	18	divided	divide	VBN
18637	15828	19	as	as	IN
18637	15828	20	to	to	TO
18637	15828	21	requirement	requirement	VB
18637	15828	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15828	23	2	2	CD
18637	15828	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15828	25	.	.	.
18637	15829	1	In	in	IN
18637	15829	2	the	the	DT
18637	15829	3	course	course	NN
18637	15829	4	of	of	IN
18637	15829	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15829	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15829	7	for	for	IN
18637	15829	8	the	the	DT
18637	15829	9	controlling	control	VBG
18637	15829	10	wing	wing	NN
18637	15829	11	of	of	IN
18637	15829	12	the	the	DT
18637	15829	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15829	14	,	,	,
18637	15829	15	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15829	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15829	17	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	15829	18	said	say	VBD
18637	15829	19	:	:	:
18637	15829	20	"	"	``
18637	15829	21	The	the	DT
18637	15829	22	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	15829	23	to	to	TO
18637	15829	24	apply	apply	VB
18637	15829	25	the	the	DT
18637	15829	26	term	term	NN
18637	15829	27	,	,	,
18637	15829	28	'	'	''
18637	15829	29	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15829	30	and	and	CC
18637	15829	31	present	present	JJ
18637	15829	32	danger	danger	NN
18637	15829	33	,	,	,
18637	15829	34	'	'	''
18637	15829	35	as	as	IN
18637	15829	36	a	a	DT
18637	15829	37	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
18637	15829	38	test	test	NN
18637	15829	39	in	in	IN
18637	15829	40	every	every	DT
18637	15829	41	case	case	NN
18637	15829	42	touching	touch	VBG
18637	15829	43	First	First	NNP
18637	15829	44	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15829	45	freedoms	freedom	NNS
18637	15829	46	,	,	,
18637	15829	47	without	without	IN
18637	15829	48	regard	regard	NN
18637	15829	49	to	to	IN
18637	15829	50	the	the	DT
18637	15829	51	context	context	NN
18637	15829	52	of	of	IN
18637	15829	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15829	54	application	application	NN
18637	15829	55	,	,	,
18637	15829	56	mistakes	mistake	VBZ
18637	15829	57	the	the	DT
18637	15829	58	form	form	NN
18637	15829	59	in	in	IN
18637	15829	60	which	which	WDT
18637	15829	61	an	an	DT
18637	15829	62	idea	idea	NN
18637	15829	63	was	be	VBD
18637	15829	64	cast	cast	VBN
18637	15829	65	for	for	IN
18637	15829	66	the	the	DT
18637	15829	67	substance	substance	NN
18637	15829	68	of	of	IN
18637	15829	69	the	the	DT
18637	15829	70	idea	idea	NN
18637	15829	71	*	*	NFP
18637	15829	72	*	*	NFP
18637	15829	73	*	*	NFP
18637	15829	74	the	the	DT
18637	15829	75	question	question	NN
18637	15829	76	with	with	IN
18637	15829	77	which	which	WDT
18637	15829	78	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15829	79	are	be	VBP
18637	15829	80	here	here	RB
18637	15829	81	faced	faced	JJ
18637	15829	82	is	be	VBZ
18637	15829	83	not	not	RB
18637	15829	84	the	the	DT
18637	15829	85	same	same	JJ
18637	15829	86	one	one	NN
18637	15829	87	that	that	WDT
18637	15829	88	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15829	89	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	15829	90	and	and	CC
18637	15829	91	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	15829	92	found	find	VBD
18637	15829	93	convenient	convenient	JJ
18637	15829	94	to	to	TO
18637	15829	95	consider	consider	VB
18637	15829	96	in	in	IN
18637	15829	97	terms	term	NNS
18637	15829	98	of	of	IN
18637	15829	99	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15829	100	and	and	CC
18637	15829	101	present	present	JJ
18637	15829	102	danger	danger	NN
18637	15829	103	.	.	.
18637	15830	1	Government	government	NN
18637	15830	2	's	's	POS
18637	15830	3	interest	interest	NN
18637	15830	4	here	here	RB
18637	15830	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	15830	6	not	not	RB
18637	15830	7	in	in	IN
18637	15830	8	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	15830	9	the	the	DT
18637	15830	10	dissemination	dissemination	NN
18637	15830	11	of	of	IN
18637	15830	12	Communist	communist	JJ
18637	15830	13	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15830	14	or	or	CC
18637	15830	15	the	the	DT
18637	15830	16	holding	holding	NN
18637	15830	17	of	of	IN
18637	15830	18	particular	particular	JJ
18637	15830	19	beliefs	belief	NNS
18637	15830	20	because	because	IN
18637	15830	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15830	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	15830	23	feared	fear	VBN
18637	15830	24	that	that	IN
18637	15830	25	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	15830	26	action	action	NN
18637	15830	27	will	will	MD
18637	15830	28	result	result	VB
18637	15830	29	therefrom	therefrom	JJ
18637	15830	30	if	if	IN
18637	15830	31	free	free	JJ
18637	15830	32	speech	speech	NN
18637	15830	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	15830	34	practiced	practice	VBN
18637	15830	35	.	.	.
18637	15831	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15831	2	interest	interest	NN
18637	15831	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	15831	4	in	in	IN
18637	15831	5	protecting	protect	VBG
18637	15831	6	the	the	DT
18637	15831	7	free	free	JJ
18637	15831	8	flow	flow	NN
18637	15831	9	of	of	IN
18637	15831	10	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	15831	11	from	from	IN
18637	15831	12	what	what	WP
18637	15831	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15831	14	considers	consider	VBZ
18637	15831	15	to	to	TO
18637	15831	16	be	be	VB
18637	15831	17	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	15831	18	evils	evil	NNS
18637	15831	19	of	of	IN
18637	15831	20	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	15831	21	that	that	WDT
18637	15831	22	are	be	VBP
18637	15831	23	not	not	RB
18637	15831	24	the	the	DT
18637	15831	25	products	product	NNS
18637	15831	26	of	of	IN
18637	15831	27	speech	speech	NN
18637	15831	28	at	at	RB
18637	15831	29	all	all	RB
18637	15831	30	.	.	.
18637	15832	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15832	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15832	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15832	4	The	the	DT
18637	15832	5	contention	contention	NN
18637	15832	6	of	of	IN
18637	15832	7	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	15832	8	*	*	NFP
18637	15832	9	*	*	NFP
18637	15832	10	*	*	NFP
18637	15832	11	that	that	IN
18637	15832	12	this	this	DT
18637	15832	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15832	14	must	must	MD
18637	15832	15	find	find	VB
18637	15832	16	that	that	IN
18637	15832	17	political	political	JJ
18637	15832	18	strikes	strike	NNS
18637	15832	19	create	create	VBP
18637	15832	20	a	a	DT
18637	15832	21	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15832	22	and	and	CC
18637	15832	23	present	present	JJ
18637	15832	24	danger	danger	NN
18637	15832	25	to	to	IN
18637	15832	26	the	the	DT
18637	15832	27	security	security	NN
18637	15832	28	of	of	IN
18637	15832	29	the	the	DT
18637	15832	30	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	15832	31	or	or	CC
18637	15832	32	of	of	IN
18637	15832	33	widespread	widespread	JJ
18637	15832	34	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	15832	35	strife	strife	NN
18637	15832	36	in	in	IN
18637	15832	37	order	order	NN
18637	15832	38	to	to	TO
18637	15832	39	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	15832	40	§	§	NNP
18637	15832	41	9	9	CD
18637	15832	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15832	43	h	h	NN
18637	15832	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15832	45	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	15832	46	misconceives	misconceive	VBZ
18637	15832	47	the	the	DT
18637	15832	48	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15832	49	that	that	DT
18637	15832	50	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	15832	51	was	be	VBD
18637	15832	52	intended	intend	VBN
18637	15832	53	to	to	TO
18637	15832	54	serve	serve	VB
18637	15832	55	.	.	.
18637	15833	1	In	in	IN
18637	15833	2	that	that	DT
18637	15833	3	view	view	NN
18637	15833	4	,	,	,
18637	15833	5	not	not	RB
18637	15833	6	the	the	DT
18637	15833	7	relative	relative	JJ
18637	15833	8	certainty	certainty	NN
18637	15833	9	that	that	IN
18637	15833	10	evil	evil	JJ
18637	15833	11	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	15833	12	will	will	MD
18637	15833	13	result	result	VB
18637	15833	14	from	from	IN
18637	15833	15	speech	speech	NN
18637	15833	16	in	in	IN
18637	15833	17	the	the	DT
18637	15833	18	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	15833	19	future	future	NN
18637	15833	20	,	,	,
18637	15833	21	but	but	CC
18637	15833	22	the	the	DT
18637	15833	23	extent	extent	NN
18637	15833	24	and	and	CC
18637	15833	25	gravity	gravity	NN
18637	15833	26	of	of	IN
18637	15833	27	the	the	DT
18637	15833	28	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15833	29	evil	evil	NN
18637	15833	30	must	must	MD
18637	15833	31	be	be	VB
18637	15833	32	measured	measure	VBN
18637	15833	33	by	by	IN
18637	15833	34	the	the	DT
18637	15833	35	'	'	``
18637	15833	36	test	test	NN
18637	15833	37	'	'	''
18637	15833	38	laid	lay	VBN
18637	15833	39	down	down	RP
18637	15833	40	in	in	IN
18637	15833	41	the	the	DT
18637	15833	42	_	_	NNP
18637	15833	43	Schenck	Schenck	NNP
18637	15833	44	Case	Case	NNP
18637	15833	45	_	_	NNP
18637	15833	46	.	.	.
18637	15834	1	"	"	``
18637	15834	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15834	3	210	210	CD
18637	15834	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15834	5	In	in	IN
18637	15834	6	thus	thus	RB
18637	15834	7	balancing	balance	VBG
18637	15834	8	the	the	DT
18637	15834	9	gravity	gravity	NN
18637	15834	10	of	of	IN
18637	15834	11	the	the	DT
18637	15834	12	interest	interest	NN
18637	15834	13	protected	protect	VBN
18637	15834	14	by	by	IN
18637	15834	15	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15834	16	from	from	IN
18637	15834	17	harmful	harmful	JJ
18637	15834	18	speech	speech	NN
18637	15834	19	against	against	IN
18637	15834	20	the	the	DT
18637	15834	21	demands	demand	NNS
18637	15834	22	of	of	IN
18637	15834	23	the	the	DT
18637	15834	24	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15834	25	and	and	CC
18637	15834	26	present	present	JJ
18637	15834	27	danger	danger	NN
18637	15834	28	rule	rule	NN
18637	15834	29	the	the	DT
18637	15834	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15834	31	paved	pave	VBD
18637	15834	32	the	the	DT
18637	15834	33	way	way	NN
18637	15834	34	for	for	IN
18637	15834	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15834	36	decision	decision	NN
18637	15834	37	a	a	DT
18637	15834	38	year	year	NN
18637	15834	39	later	later	RB
18637	15834	40	in	in	IN
18637	15834	41	Dennis	Dennis	NNP
18637	15834	42	_	_	NNP
18637	15834	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	15834	44	_	_	NNP
18637	15834	45	United	United	NNP
18637	15834	46	States	States	NNP
18637	15834	47	.	.	.
18637	15835	1	THE	the	DT
18637	15835	2	CASE	case	NN
18637	15835	3	OF	of	IN
18637	15835	4	THE	the	DT
18637	15835	5	ELEVEN	ELEVEN	NNP
18637	15835	6	COMMUNISTS	COMMUNISTS	NNP
18637	15835	7	Dennis	Dennis	NNP
18637	15835	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15835	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	15835	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15835	11	United	United	NNP
18637	15835	12	States[211	States[211	NNP
18637	15835	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15835	14	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	15835	15	the	the	DT
18637	15835	16	following	following	JJ
18637	15835	17	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15835	18	:	:	:
18637	15835	19	"	"	``
18637	15835	20	Section	section	NN
18637	15835	21	2	2	CD
18637	15835	22	.	.	.
18637	15836	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15836	2	a	a	LS
18637	15836	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15836	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15836	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	15836	6	be	be	VB
18637	15836	7	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	15836	8	for	for	IN
18637	15836	9	any	any	DT
18637	15836	10	person--	person--	NNP
18637	15836	11	"	"	''
18637	15836	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15836	13	1	1	CD
18637	15836	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15836	15	to	to	TO
18637	15836	16	knowingly	knowingly	RB
18637	15836	17	or	or	CC
18637	15836	18	willfully	willfully	RB
18637	15836	19	advocate	advocate	VB
18637	15836	20	,	,	,
18637	15836	21	abet	abet	NN
18637	15836	22	,	,	,
18637	15836	23	advise	advise	VBP
18637	15836	24	,	,	,
18637	15836	25	or	or	CC
18637	15836	26	teach	teach	VB
18637	15836	27	the	the	DT
18637	15836	28	duty	duty	NN
18637	15836	29	,	,	,
18637	15836	30	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	15836	31	,	,	,
18637	15836	32	desirability	desirability	NN
18637	15836	33	,	,	,
18637	15836	34	or	or	CC
18637	15836	35	propriety	propriety	NN
18637	15836	36	of	of	IN
18637	15836	37	overthrowing	overthrow	VBG
18637	15836	38	or	or	CC
18637	15836	39	destroying	destroy	VBG
18637	15836	40	any	any	DT
18637	15836	41	government	government	NN
18637	15836	42	in	in	IN
18637	15836	43	the	the	DT
18637	15836	44	United	United	NNP
18637	15836	45	States	States	NNP
18637	15836	46	by	by	IN
18637	15836	47	force	force	NN
18637	15836	48	or	or	CC
18637	15836	49	violence	violence	NN
18637	15836	50	,	,	,
18637	15836	51	or	or	CC
18637	15836	52	by	by	IN
18637	15836	53	the	the	DT
18637	15836	54	assassination	assassination	NN
18637	15836	55	of	of	IN
18637	15836	56	any	any	DT
18637	15836	57	officer	officer	NN
18637	15836	58	of	of	IN
18637	15836	59	any	any	DT
18637	15836	60	such	such	JJ
18637	15836	61	government	government	NN
18637	15836	62	;	;	:
18637	15836	63	"	"	''
18637	15836	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15836	65	2	2	LS
18637	15836	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15836	67	with	with	IN
18637	15836	68	the	the	DT
18637	15836	69	intent	intent	NN
18637	15836	70	to	to	TO
18637	15836	71	cause	cause	VB
18637	15836	72	the	the	DT
18637	15836	73	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	15836	74	or	or	CC
18637	15836	75	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	15836	76	of	of	IN
18637	15836	77	any	any	DT
18637	15836	78	government	government	NN
18637	15836	79	in	in	IN
18637	15836	80	the	the	DT
18637	15836	81	United	United	NNP
18637	15836	82	States	States	NNP
18637	15836	83	,	,	,
18637	15836	84	to	to	TO
18637	15836	85	print	print	VB
18637	15836	86	,	,	,
18637	15836	87	publish	publish	VB
18637	15836	88	,	,	,
18637	15836	89	edit	edit	NN
18637	15836	90	,	,	,
18637	15836	91	issue	issue	NN
18637	15836	92	,	,	,
18637	15836	93	circulate	circulate	VBP
18637	15836	94	,	,	,
18637	15836	95	sell	sell	VB
18637	15836	96	,	,	,
18637	15836	97	distribute	distribute	VBP
18637	15836	98	,	,	,
18637	15836	99	or	or	CC
18637	15836	100	publicly	publicly	RB
18637	15836	101	display	display	VB
18637	15836	102	any	any	DT
18637	15836	103	written	write	VBN
18637	15836	104	or	or	CC
18637	15836	105	printed	print	VBN
18637	15836	106	matter	matter	NN
18637	15836	107	advocating	advocate	VBG
18637	15836	108	,	,	,
18637	15836	109	advising	advise	VBG
18637	15836	110	,	,	,
18637	15836	111	or	or	CC
18637	15836	112	teaching	teach	VBG
18637	15836	113	the	the	DT
18637	15836	114	duty	duty	NN
18637	15836	115	,	,	,
18637	15836	116	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	15836	117	,	,	,
18637	15836	118	desirability	desirability	NN
18637	15836	119	,	,	,
18637	15836	120	or	or	CC
18637	15836	121	propriety	propriety	NN
18637	15836	122	of	of	IN
18637	15836	123	overthrowing	overthrow	VBG
18637	15836	124	or	or	CC
18637	15836	125	destroying	destroy	VBG
18637	15836	126	any	any	DT
18637	15836	127	government	government	NN
18637	15836	128	in	in	IN
18637	15836	129	the	the	DT
18637	15836	130	United	United	NNP
18637	15836	131	States	States	NNP
18637	15836	132	by	by	IN
18637	15836	133	force	force	NN
18637	15836	134	or	or	CC
18637	15836	135	violence	violence	NN
18637	15836	136	;	;	:
18637	15836	137	"	"	''
18637	15836	138	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15836	139	3	3	LS
18637	15836	140	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15836	141	to	to	TO
18637	15836	142	organize	organize	VB
18637	15836	143	or	or	CC
18637	15836	144	help	help	VB
18637	15836	145	to	to	TO
18637	15836	146	organize	organize	VB
18637	15836	147	any	any	DT
18637	15836	148	society	society	NN
18637	15836	149	,	,	,
18637	15836	150	group	group	NN
18637	15836	151	,	,	,
18637	15836	152	or	or	CC
18637	15836	153	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	15836	154	of	of	IN
18637	15836	155	persons	person	NNS
18637	15836	156	who	who	WP
18637	15836	157	teach	teach	VBP
18637	15836	158	,	,	,
18637	15836	159	advocate	advocate	VBP
18637	15836	160	,	,	,
18637	15836	161	or	or	CC
18637	15836	162	encourage	encourage	VB
18637	15836	163	the	the	DT
18637	15836	164	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	15836	165	or	or	CC
18637	15836	166	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	15836	167	of	of	IN
18637	15836	168	any	any	DT
18637	15836	169	government	government	NN
18637	15836	170	in	in	IN
18637	15836	171	the	the	DT
18637	15836	172	United	United	NNP
18637	15836	173	States	States	NNP
18637	15836	174	by	by	IN
18637	15836	175	force	force	NN
18637	15836	176	or	or	CC
18637	15836	177	violence	violence	NN
18637	15836	178	;	;	:
18637	15836	179	or	or	CC
18637	15836	180	to	to	TO
18637	15836	181	be	be	VB
18637	15836	182	or	or	CC
18637	15836	183	become	become	VB
18637	15836	184	a	a	DT
18637	15836	185	member	member	NN
18637	15836	186	of	of	IN
18637	15836	187	,	,	,
18637	15836	188	or	or	CC
18637	15836	189	affiliate	affiliate	NN
18637	15836	190	with	with	IN
18637	15836	191	,	,	,
18637	15836	192	any	any	DT
18637	15836	193	such	such	JJ
18637	15836	194	society	society	NN
18637	15836	195	,	,	,
18637	15836	196	group	group	NN
18637	15836	197	,	,	,
18637	15836	198	or	or	CC
18637	15836	199	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	15836	200	of	of	IN
18637	15836	201	persons	person	NNS
18637	15836	202	,	,	,
18637	15836	203	knowing	know	VBG
18637	15836	204	the	the	DT
18637	15836	205	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	15836	206	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	15836	207	.	.	.
18637	15837	1	"	"	``
18637	15837	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15837	3	b	b	NN
18637	15837	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15837	5	For	for	IN
18637	15837	6	the	the	DT
18637	15837	7	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	15837	8	of	of	IN
18637	15837	9	this	this	DT
18637	15837	10	section	section	NN
18637	15837	11	,	,	,
18637	15837	12	the	the	DT
18637	15837	13	term	term	NN
18637	15837	14	'	'	POS
18637	15837	15	government	government	NN
18637	15837	16	in	in	IN
18637	15837	17	the	the	DT
18637	15837	18	United	United	NNP
18637	15837	19	States	States	NNP
18637	15837	20	'	'	POS
18637	15837	21	means	mean	VBZ
18637	15837	22	the	the	DT
18637	15837	23	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15837	24	of	of	IN
18637	15837	25	the	the	DT
18637	15837	26	United	United	NNP
18637	15837	27	States	States	NNP
18637	15837	28	,	,	,
18637	15837	29	the	the	DT
18637	15837	30	government	government	NN
18637	15837	31	of	of	IN
18637	15837	32	any	any	DT
18637	15837	33	State	State	NNP
18637	15837	34	,	,	,
18637	15837	35	Territory	territory	NN
18637	15837	36	,	,	,
18637	15837	37	or	or	CC
18637	15837	38	possession	possession	NN
18637	15837	39	of	of	IN
18637	15837	40	the	the	DT
18637	15837	41	United	United	NNP
18637	15837	42	States	States	NNP
18637	15837	43	,	,	,
18637	15837	44	the	the	DT
18637	15837	45	government	government	NN
18637	15837	46	of	of	IN
18637	15837	47	the	the	DT
18637	15837	48	District	District	NNP
18637	15837	49	of	of	IN
18637	15837	50	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	15837	51	,	,	,
18637	15837	52	or	or	CC
18637	15837	53	the	the	DT
18637	15837	54	government	government	NN
18637	15837	55	of	of	IN
18637	15837	56	any	any	DT
18637	15837	57	political	political	JJ
18637	15837	58	subdivision	subdivision	NN
18637	15837	59	of	of	IN
18637	15837	60	any	any	DT
18637	15837	61	of	of	IN
18637	15837	62	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15837	63	.	.	.
18637	15838	1	"	"	``
18637	15838	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15838	3	212	212	CD
18637	15838	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15838	5	The	the	DT
18637	15838	6	trial	trial	NN
18637	15838	7	court	court	NN
18637	15838	8	had	have	VBD
18637	15838	9	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	15838	10	that	that	IN
18637	15838	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	15838	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15838	13	2	2	CD
18637	15838	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15838	15	of	of	IN
18637	15838	16	the	the	DT
18637	15838	17	act	act	NN
18637	15838	18	qualified	qualify	VBD
18637	15838	19	both	both	CC
18637	15838	20	the	the	DT
18637	15838	21	other	other	JJ
18637	15838	22	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	15838	23	;	;	,
18637	15838	24	and	and	CC
18637	15838	25	this	this	DT
18637	15838	26	construction	construction	NN
18637	15838	27	was	be	VBD
18637	15838	28	endorsed	endorse	VBN
18637	15838	29	by	by	IN
18637	15838	30	the	the	DT
18637	15838	31	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15838	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15838	33	.	.	.
18637	15839	1	The	the	DT
18637	15839	2	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	15839	3	of	of	IN
18637	15839	4	the	the	DT
18637	15839	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15839	6	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	15839	7	the	the	DT
18637	15839	8	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	15839	9	against	against	IN
18637	15839	10	objections	objection	NNS
18637	15839	11	raised	raise	VBN
18637	15839	12	under	under	IN
18637	15839	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15839	14	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15839	15	was	be	VBD
18637	15839	16	supported	support	VBN
18637	15839	17	by	by	IN
18637	15839	18	three	three	CD
18637	15839	19	different	different	JJ
18637	15839	20	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	15839	21	.	.	.
18637	15840	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15840	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15840	3	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	15840	4	,	,	,
18637	15840	5	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15840	6	also	also	RB
18637	15840	7	for	for	IN
18637	15840	8	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15840	9	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	15840	10	,	,	,
18637	15840	11	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	15840	12	and	and	CC
18637	15840	13	Minton	Minton	NNP
18637	15840	14	emphasized	emphasize	VBD
18637	15840	15	the	the	DT
18637	15840	16	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	15840	17	character	character	NN
18637	15840	18	of	of	IN
18637	15840	19	the	the	DT
18637	15840	20	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15840	21	's	's	POS
18637	15840	22	interest	interest	NN
18637	15840	23	in	in	IN
18637	15840	24	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	15840	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15840	26	own	own	JJ
18637	15840	27	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	15840	28	by	by	IN
18637	15840	29	force	force	NN
18637	15840	30	.	.	.
18637	15841	1	"	"	``
18637	15841	2	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	15841	3	,	,	,
18637	15841	4	"	"	''
18637	15841	5	said	say	VBD
18637	15841	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15841	7	,	,	,
18637	15841	8	"	"	``
18637	15841	9	this	this	DT
18637	15841	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	15841	11	the	the	DT
18637	15841	12	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	15841	13	value	value	NN
18637	15841	14	of	of	IN
18637	15841	15	any	any	DT
18637	15841	16	society	society	NN
18637	15841	17	,	,	,
18637	15841	18	for	for	IN
18637	15841	19	if	if	IN
18637	15841	20	a	a	DT
18637	15841	21	society	society	NN
18637	15841	22	can	can	MD
18637	15841	23	not	not	RB
18637	15841	24	protect	protect	VB
18637	15841	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15841	26	very	very	JJ
18637	15841	27	structure	structure	NN
18637	15841	28	from	from	IN
18637	15841	29	armed	armed	JJ
18637	15841	30	internal	internal	JJ
18637	15841	31	attack	attack	NN
18637	15841	32	,	,	,
18637	15841	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15841	34	must	must	MD
18637	15841	35	follow	follow	VB
18637	15841	36	that	that	IN
18637	15841	37	no	no	DT
18637	15841	38	subordinate	subordinate	JJ
18637	15841	39	value	value	NN
18637	15841	40	can	can	MD
18637	15841	41	be	be	VB
18637	15841	42	protected	protect	VBN
18637	15841	43	.	.	.
18637	15842	1	"	"	``
18637	15842	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15842	3	213	213	CD
18637	15842	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15842	5	The	the	DT
18637	15842	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15842	7	continues	continue	VBZ
18637	15842	8	:	:	:
18637	15842	9	"	"	``
18637	15842	10	If	if	IN
18637	15842	11	,	,	,
18637	15842	12	then	then	RB
18637	15842	13	,	,	,
18637	15842	14	this	this	DT
18637	15842	15	interest	interest	NN
18637	15842	16	may	may	MD
18637	15842	17	be	be	VB
18637	15842	18	protected	protect	VBN
18637	15842	19	,	,	,
18637	15842	20	the	the	DT
18637	15842	21	literal	literal	JJ
18637	15842	22	problem	problem	NN
18637	15842	23	which	which	WDT
18637	15842	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	15842	25	presented	present	VBN
18637	15842	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	15842	27	what	what	WP
18637	15842	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	15842	29	been	be	VBN
18637	15842	30	meant	mean	VBN
18637	15842	31	by	by	IN
18637	15842	32	the	the	DT
18637	15842	33	use	use	NN
18637	15842	34	of	of	IN
18637	15842	35	the	the	DT
18637	15842	36	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	15842	37	'	'	``
18637	15842	38	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15842	39	and	and	CC
18637	15842	40	present	present	JJ
18637	15842	41	danger	danger	NN
18637	15842	42	'	'	''
18637	15842	43	of	of	IN
18637	15842	44	the	the	DT
18637	15842	45	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	15842	46	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	15842	47	about	about	RP
18637	15842	48	the	the	DT
18637	15842	49	evil	evil	NN
18637	15842	50	within	within	IN
18637	15842	51	the	the	DT
18637	15842	52	power	power	NN
18637	15842	53	of	of	IN
18637	15842	54	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15842	55	to	to	TO
18637	15842	56	punish	punish	VB
18637	15842	57	.	.	.
18637	15843	1	Obviously	obviously	RB
18637	15843	2	,	,	,
18637	15843	3	the	the	DT
18637	15843	4	words	word	NNS
18637	15843	5	can	can	MD
18637	15843	6	not	not	RB
18637	15843	7	mean	mean	VB
18637	15843	8	that	that	IN
18637	15843	9	before	before	IN
18637	15843	10	the	the	DT
18637	15843	11	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15843	12	may	may	MD
18637	15843	13	act	act	VB
18637	15843	14	,	,	,
18637	15843	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15843	16	must	must	MD
18637	15843	17	wait	wait	VB
18637	15843	18	until	until	IN
18637	15843	19	the	the	DT
18637	15843	20	_	_	NNP
18637	15843	21	putsch	putsch	NN
18637	15843	22	_	_	NNP
18637	15843	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	15843	24	about	about	JJ
18637	15843	25	to	to	TO
18637	15843	26	be	be	VB
18637	15843	27	executed	execute	VBN
18637	15843	28	,	,	,
18637	15843	29	the	the	DT
18637	15843	30	plans	plan	NNS
18637	15843	31	have	have	VBP
18637	15843	32	been	be	VBN
18637	15843	33	laid	lay	VBN
18637	15843	34	and	and	CC
18637	15843	35	the	the	DT
18637	15843	36	signal	signal	NN
18637	15843	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	15843	38	awaited	await	VBN
18637	15843	39	.	.	.
18637	15844	1	If	if	IN
18637	15844	2	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15844	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	15844	4	aware	aware	JJ
18637	15844	5	that	that	IN
18637	15844	6	a	a	DT
18637	15844	7	group	group	NN
18637	15844	8	aiming	aim	VBG
18637	15844	9	at	at	IN
18637	15844	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15844	11	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	15844	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	15844	13	attempting	attempt	VBG
18637	15844	14	to	to	TO
18637	15844	15	indoctrinate	indoctrinate	VB
18637	15844	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15844	17	members	member	NNS
18637	15844	18	and	and	CC
18637	15844	19	to	to	TO
18637	15844	20	commit	commit	VB
18637	15844	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15844	22	to	to	IN
18637	15844	23	a	a	DT
18637	15844	24	course	course	NN
18637	15844	25	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	15844	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15844	27	will	will	MD
18637	15844	28	strike	strike	VB
18637	15844	29	when	when	WRB
18637	15844	30	the	the	DT
18637	15844	31	leaders	leader	NNS
18637	15844	32	feel	feel	VBP
18637	15844	33	the	the	DT
18637	15844	34	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	15844	35	permit	permit	NN
18637	15844	36	,	,	,
18637	15844	37	action	action	NN
18637	15844	38	by	by	IN
18637	15844	39	the	the	DT
18637	15844	40	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15844	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	15844	42	required	require	VBN
18637	15844	43	.	.	.
18637	15845	1	The	the	DT
18637	15845	2	argument	argument	NN
18637	15845	3	that	that	IN
18637	15845	4	there	there	EX
18637	15845	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	15845	6	no	no	DT
18637	15845	7	need	need	NN
18637	15845	8	for	for	IN
18637	15845	9	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15845	10	to	to	TO
18637	15845	11	concern	concern	VB
18637	15845	12	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15845	13	,	,	,
18637	15845	14	for	for	IN
18637	15845	15	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15845	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	15845	17	strong	strong	JJ
18637	15845	18	,	,	,
18637	15845	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15845	20	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	15845	21	ample	ample	JJ
18637	15845	22	powers	power	NNS
18637	15845	23	to	to	TO
18637	15845	24	put	put	VB
18637	15845	25	down	down	RP
18637	15845	26	a	a	DT
18637	15845	27	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	15845	28	,	,	,
18637	15845	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15845	30	may	may	MD
18637	15845	31	defeat	defeat	VB
18637	15845	32	the	the	DT
18637	15845	33	revolution	revolution	NN
18637	15845	34	with	with	IN
18637	15845	35	ease	ease	NN
18637	15845	36	needs	need	VBZ
18637	15845	37	no	no	DT
18637	15845	38	answer	answer	NN
18637	15845	39	.	.	.
18637	15846	1	For	for	IN
18637	15846	2	that	that	DT
18637	15846	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	15846	4	not	not	RB
18637	15846	5	the	the	DT
18637	15846	6	question	question	NN
18637	15846	7	.	.	.
18637	15847	1	Certainly	certainly	RB
18637	15847	2	an	an	DT
18637	15847	3	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	15847	4	to	to	TO
18637	15847	5	overthrow	overthrow	VB
18637	15847	6	the	the	DT
18637	15847	7	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15847	8	by	by	IN
18637	15847	9	force	force	NN
18637	15847	10	,	,	,
18637	15847	11	even	even	RB
18637	15847	12	though	though	IN
18637	15847	13	doomed	doom	VBN
18637	15847	14	from	from	IN
18637	15847	15	the	the	DT
18637	15847	16	outset	outset	NN
18637	15847	17	because	because	IN
18637	15847	18	of	of	IN
18637	15847	19	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
18637	15847	20	numbers	number	NNS
18637	15847	21	or	or	CC
18637	15847	22	power	power	NN
18637	15847	23	of	of	IN
18637	15847	24	the	the	DT
18637	15847	25	revolutionists	revolutionist	NNS
18637	15847	26	,	,	,
18637	15847	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	15847	28	a	a	DT
18637	15847	29	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	15847	30	evil	evil	NN
18637	15847	31	for	for	IN
18637	15847	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15847	33	to	to	TO
18637	15847	34	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	15847	35	.	.	.
18637	15848	1	The	the	DT
18637	15848	2	damage	damage	NN
18637	15848	3	which	which	WDT
18637	15848	4	such	such	JJ
18637	15848	5	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	15848	6	create	create	VBP
18637	15848	7	both	both	DT
18637	15848	8	physically	physically	RB
18637	15848	9	and	and	CC
18637	15848	10	politically	politically	RB
18637	15848	11	to	to	IN
18637	15848	12	a	a	DT
18637	15848	13	nation	nation	NN
18637	15848	14	makes	make	VBZ
18637	15848	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15848	16	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	15848	17	to	to	TO
18637	15848	18	measure	measure	VB
18637	15848	19	the	the	DT
18637	15848	20	validity	validity	NN
18637	15848	21	in	in	IN
18637	15848	22	terms	term	NNS
18637	15848	23	of	of	IN
18637	15848	24	the	the	DT
18637	15848	25	probability	probability	NN
18637	15848	26	of	of	IN
18637	15848	27	success	success	NN
18637	15848	28	or	or	CC
18637	15848	29	the	the	DT
18637	15848	30	immediacy	immediacy	NN
18637	15848	31	of	of	IN
18637	15848	32	a	a	DT
18637	15848	33	successful	successful	JJ
18637	15848	34	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	15848	35	.	.	.
18637	15849	1	"	"	``
18637	15849	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15849	3	214	214	CD
18637	15849	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15849	5	The	the	DT
18637	15849	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15849	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15849	8	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	15849	9	this	this	DT
18637	15849	10	part	part	NN
18637	15849	11	of	of	IN
18637	15849	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15849	13	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15849	14	by	by	IN
18637	15849	15	quoting	quote	VBG
18637	15849	16	from	from	IN
18637	15849	17	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15849	18	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	15849	19	Learned	Learned	NNP
18637	15849	20	Hand	Hand	NNP
18637	15849	21	's	's	POS
18637	15849	22	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15849	23	for	for	IN
18637	15849	24	the	the	DT
18637	15849	25	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
18637	15849	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15849	27	of	of	IN
18637	15849	28	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	15849	29	in	in	IN
18637	15849	30	the	the	DT
18637	15849	31	same	same	JJ
18637	15849	32	case	case	NN
18637	15849	33	,	,	,
18637	15849	34	as	as	IN
18637	15849	35	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	15849	36	:	:	:
18637	15849	37	"	"	``
18637	15849	38	'	'	``
18637	15849	39	In	in	IN
18637	15849	40	each	each	DT
18637	15849	41	case	case	NN
18637	15849	42	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15849	43	courts	court	NNS
18637	15849	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15849	45	must	must	MD
18637	15849	46	ask	ask	VB
18637	15849	47	whether	whether	IN
18637	15849	48	the	the	DT
18637	15849	49	gravity	gravity	NN
18637	15849	50	of	of	IN
18637	15849	51	the	the	DT
18637	15849	52	evil	evil	NN
18637	15849	53	,	,	,
18637	15849	54	discounted	discount	VBN
18637	15849	55	by	by	IN
18637	15849	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15849	57	improbability	improbability	NN
18637	15849	58	,	,	,
18637	15849	59	justifies	justifie	NNS
18637	15849	60	such	such	JJ
18637	15849	61	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	15849	62	of	of	IN
18637	15849	63	free	free	JJ
18637	15849	64	speech	speech	NN
18637	15849	65	as	as	IN
18637	15849	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	15849	67	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	15849	68	to	to	TO
18637	15849	69	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	15849	70	the	the	DT
18637	15849	71	danger	danger	NN
18637	15849	72	.	.	.
18637	15850	1	'	'	``
18637	15850	2	"	"	``
18637	15850	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15850	4	215	215	CD
18637	15850	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15850	6	In	in	IN
18637	15850	7	short	short	JJ
18637	15850	8	,	,	,
18637	15850	9	if	if	IN
18637	15850	10	the	the	DT
18637	15850	11	evil	evil	NN
18637	15850	12	legislated	legislate	VBD
18637	15850	13	against	against	IN
18637	15850	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	15850	15	serious	serious	JJ
18637	15850	16	enough	enough	RB
18637	15850	17	,	,	,
18637	15850	18	advocacy	advocacy	NN
18637	15850	19	of	of	IN
18637	15850	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15850	21	in	in	IN
18637	15850	22	order	order	NN
18637	15850	23	to	to	TO
18637	15850	24	be	be	VB
18637	15850	25	punishable	punishable	JJ
18637	15850	26	does	do	VBZ
18637	15850	27	not	not	RB
18637	15850	28	have	have	VB
18637	15850	29	to	to	TO
18637	15850	30	be	be	VB
18637	15850	31	attended	attend	VBN
18637	15850	32	by	by	IN
18637	15850	33	a	a	DT
18637	15850	34	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15850	35	and	and	CC
18637	15850	36	present	present	JJ
18637	15850	37	danger	danger	NN
18637	15850	38	of	of	IN
18637	15850	39	success	success	NN
18637	15850	40	.	.	.
18637	15851	1	But	but	CC
18637	15851	2	at	at	IN
18637	15851	3	this	this	DT
18637	15851	4	point	point	NN
18637	15851	5	the	the	DT
18637	15851	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15851	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15851	8	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	15851	9	to	to	TO
18637	15851	10	recoil	recoil	VB
18637	15851	11	from	from	IN
18637	15851	12	this	this	DT
18637	15851	13	abrupt	abrupt	JJ
18637	15851	14	dismissal	dismissal	NN
18637	15851	15	of	of	IN
18637	15851	16	the	the	DT
18637	15851	17	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15851	18	and	and	CC
18637	15851	19	present	present	JJ
18637	15851	20	danger	danger	NN
18637	15851	21	formula	formula	NN
18637	15851	22	for	for	IN
18637	15851	23	the	the	DT
18637	15851	24	more	more	RBR
18637	15851	25	serious	serious	JJ
18637	15851	26	cases	case	NNS
18637	15851	27	,	,	,
18637	15851	28	and	and	CC
18637	15851	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15851	30	makes	make	VBZ
18637	15851	31	a	a	DT
18637	15851	32	last	last	JJ
18637	15851	33	moment	moment	NN
18637	15851	34	effort	effort	NN
18637	15851	35	to	to	TO
18637	15851	36	rescue	rescue	VB
18637	15851	37	the	the	DT
18637	15851	38	babe	babe	NN
18637	15851	39	that	that	WDT
18637	15851	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15851	41	has	have	VBZ
18637	15851	42	tossed	toss	VBN
18637	15851	43	out	out	RP
18637	15851	44	with	with	IN
18637	15851	45	the	the	DT
18637	15851	46	bathwater	bathwater	NN
18637	15851	47	.	.	.
18637	15852	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15852	2	says	say	VBZ
18637	15852	3	:	:	:
18637	15852	4	"	"	``
18637	15852	5	As	as	IN
18637	15852	6	articulated	articulate	VBN
18637	15852	7	by	by	IN
18637	15852	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15852	9	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	15852	10	Hand	Hand	NNP
18637	15852	11	,	,	,
18637	15852	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15852	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	15852	14	as	as	RB
18637	15852	15	succinct	succinct	JJ
18637	15852	16	and	and	CC
18637	15852	17	inclusive	inclusive	JJ
18637	15852	18	as	as	IN
18637	15852	19	any	any	DT
18637	15852	20	other	other	JJ
18637	15852	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15852	22	might	may	MD
18637	15852	23	devise	devise	VB
18637	15852	24	at	at	IN
18637	15852	25	this	this	DT
18637	15852	26	time	time	NN
18637	15852	27	.	.	.
18637	15853	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15853	2	takes	take	VBZ
18637	15853	3	into	into	IN
18637	15853	4	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	15853	5	those	those	DT
18637	15853	6	factors	factor	NNS
18637	15853	7	which	which	WDT
18637	15853	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15853	9	deem	deem	VBP
18637	15853	10	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	15853	11	,	,	,
18637	15853	12	and	and	CC
18637	15853	13	relates	relate	VBZ
18637	15853	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15853	15	significances	significance	NNS
18637	15853	16	.	.	.
18637	15854	1	More	more	RBR
18637	15854	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15854	3	can	can	MD
18637	15854	4	not	not	RB
18637	15854	5	expect	expect	VB
18637	15854	6	from	from	IN
18637	15854	7	words	word	NNS
18637	15854	8	.	.	.
18637	15855	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	15855	2	,	,	,
18637	15855	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15855	4	are	be	VBP
18637	15855	5	in	in	IN
18637	15855	6	accord	accord	NN
18637	15855	7	with	with	IN
18637	15855	8	the	the	DT
18637	15855	9	court	court	NN
18637	15855	10	below	below	RB
18637	15855	11	,	,	,
18637	15855	12	which	which	WDT
18637	15855	13	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	15855	14	the	the	DT
18637	15855	15	trial	trial	NN
18637	15855	16	court	court	NN
18637	15855	17	's	's	POS
18637	15855	18	finding	finding	NN
18637	15855	19	that	that	IN
18637	15855	20	the	the	DT
18637	15855	21	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	15855	22	danger	danger	NN
18637	15855	23	existed	exist	VBD
18637	15855	24	.	.	.
18637	15856	1	The	the	DT
18637	15856	2	mere	mere	JJ
18637	15856	3	fact	fact	NN
18637	15856	4	that	that	IN
18637	15856	5	from	from	IN
18637	15856	6	the	the	DT
18637	15856	7	period	period	NN
18637	15856	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	15856	9	to	to	IN
18637	15856	10	1948	1948	CD
18637	15856	11	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	15856	12	'	'	POS
18637	15856	13	activities	activity	NNS
18637	15856	14	did	do	VBD
18637	15856	15	not	not	RB
18637	15856	16	result	result	VB
18637	15856	17	in	in	IN
18637	15856	18	an	an	DT
18637	15856	19	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	15856	20	to	to	TO
18637	15856	21	overthrow	overthrow	VB
18637	15856	22	the	the	DT
18637	15856	23	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15856	24	by	by	IN
18637	15856	25	force	force	NN
18637	15856	26	and	and	CC
18637	15856	27	violence	violence	NN
18637	15856	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	15856	29	of	of	IN
18637	15856	30	course	course	NN
18637	15856	31	no	no	DT
18637	15856	32	answer	answer	NN
18637	15856	33	to	to	IN
18637	15856	34	the	the	DT
18637	15856	35	fact	fact	NN
18637	15856	36	that	that	IN
18637	15856	37	there	there	EX
18637	15856	38	was	be	VBD
18637	15856	39	a	a	DT
18637	15856	40	group	group	NN
18637	15856	41	that	that	WDT
18637	15856	42	was	be	VBD
18637	15856	43	ready	ready	JJ
18637	15856	44	to	to	TO
18637	15856	45	make	make	VB
18637	15856	46	the	the	DT
18637	15856	47	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	15856	48	.	.	.
18637	15857	1	The	the	DT
18637	15857	2	formation	formation	NN
18637	15857	3	by	by	IN
18637	15857	4	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	15857	5	of	of	IN
18637	15857	6	such	such	PDT
18637	15857	7	a	a	DT
18637	15857	8	highly	highly	RB
18637	15857	9	organized	organize	VBN
18637	15857	10	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15857	11	,	,	,
18637	15857	12	with	with	IN
18637	15857	13	rigidly	rigidly	RB
18637	15857	14	disciplined	discipline	VBN
18637	15857	15	members	member	NNS
18637	15857	16	subject	subject	JJ
18637	15857	17	to	to	IN
18637	15857	18	call	call	VB
18637	15857	19	when	when	WRB
18637	15857	20	the	the	DT
18637	15857	21	leaders	leader	NNS
18637	15857	22	,	,	,
18637	15857	23	these	these	DT
18637	15857	24	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	15857	25	,	,	,
18637	15857	26	felt	feel	VBD
18637	15857	27	that	that	IN
18637	15857	28	the	the	DT
18637	15857	29	time	time	NN
18637	15857	30	had	have	VBD
18637	15857	31	come	come	VBN
18637	15857	32	for	for	IN
18637	15857	33	action	action	NN
18637	15857	34	,	,	,
18637	15857	35	coupled	couple	VBN
18637	15857	36	with	with	IN
18637	15857	37	the	the	DT
18637	15857	38	inflammable	inflammable	JJ
18637	15857	39	nature	nature	NN
18637	15857	40	of	of	IN
18637	15857	41	world	world	NN
18637	15857	42	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	15857	43	,	,	,
18637	15857	44	similar	similar	JJ
18637	15857	45	uprisings	uprising	NNS
18637	15857	46	in	in	IN
18637	15857	47	other	other	JJ
18637	15857	48	countries	country	NNS
18637	15857	49	,	,	,
18637	15857	50	and	and	CC
18637	15857	51	the	the	DT
18637	15857	52	touch	touch	NN
18637	15857	53	-	-	HYPH
18637	15857	54	and	and	CC
18637	15857	55	-	-	HYPH
18637	15857	56	go	go	VB
18637	15857	57	nature	nature	NN
18637	15857	58	of	of	IN
18637	15857	59	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15857	60	relations	relation	NNS
18637	15857	61	with	with	IN
18637	15857	62	countries	country	NNS
18637	15857	63	with	with	IN
18637	15857	64	whom	whom	WP
18637	15857	65	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	15857	66	were	be	VBD
18637	15857	67	in	in	IN
18637	15857	68	the	the	DT
18637	15857	69	very	very	RB
18637	15857	70	least	least	JJS
18637	15857	71	ideologically	ideologically	RB
18637	15857	72	attuned	attune	VBN
18637	15857	73	,	,	,
18637	15857	74	convince	convince	VB
18637	15857	75	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15857	76	that	that	IN
18637	15857	77	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15857	78	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	15857	79	were	be	VBD
18637	15857	80	justified	justify	VBN
18637	15857	81	on	on	IN
18637	15857	82	this	this	DT
18637	15857	83	score	score	NN
18637	15857	84	.	.	.
18637	15858	1	And	and	CC
18637	15858	2	this	this	DT
18637	15858	3	analysis	analysis	NN
18637	15858	4	disposes	dispose	VBZ
18637	15858	5	of	of	IN
18637	15858	6	the	the	DT
18637	15858	7	contention	contention	NN
18637	15858	8	that	that	IN
18637	15858	9	a	a	DT
18637	15858	10	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15858	11	to	to	TO
18637	15858	12	advocate	advocate	VB
18637	15858	13	,	,	,
18637	15858	14	as	as	IN
18637	15858	15	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	15858	16	from	from	IN
18637	15858	17	the	the	DT
18637	15858	18	advocacy	advocacy	NN
18637	15858	19	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15858	20	,	,	,
18637	15858	21	can	can	MD
18637	15858	22	not	not	RB
18637	15858	23	be	be	VB
18637	15858	24	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	15858	25	restrained	restrain	VBN
18637	15858	26	,	,	,
18637	15858	27	because	because	IN
18637	15858	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15858	29	comprises	comprise	VBZ
18637	15858	30	only	only	RB
18637	15858	31	the	the	DT
18637	15858	32	preparation	preparation	NN
18637	15858	33	.	.	.
18637	15859	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15859	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15859	3	the	the	DT
18637	15859	4	existence	existence	NN
18637	15859	5	of	of	IN
18637	15859	6	the	the	DT
18637	15859	7	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15859	8	which	which	WDT
18637	15859	9	creates	create	VBZ
18637	15859	10	the	the	DT
18637	15859	11	danger	danger	NN
18637	15859	12	.	.	.
18637	15860	1	"	"	``
18637	15860	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15860	3	216	216	CD
18637	15860	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15860	5	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15860	6	final	final	JJ
18637	15860	7	position	position	NN
18637	15860	8	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	15860	9	to	to	TO
18637	15860	10	be	be	VB
18637	15860	11	that	that	IN
18637	15860	12	,	,	,
18637	15860	13	after	after	RB
18637	15860	14	all	all	RB
18637	15860	15	,	,	,
18637	15860	16	the	the	DT
18637	15860	17	question	question	NN
18637	15860	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	15860	19	one	one	CD
18637	15860	20	for	for	IN
18637	15860	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15860	22	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	15860	23	.	.	.
18637	15861	1	"	"	``
18637	15861	2	When	when	WRB
18637	15861	3	facts	fact	NNS
18637	15861	4	are	be	VBP
18637	15861	5	found	find	VBN
18637	15861	6	that	that	WDT
18637	15861	7	establish	establish	VB
18637	15861	8	the	the	DT
18637	15861	9	violation	violation	NN
18637	15861	10	of	of	IN
18637	15861	11	a	a	DT
18637	15861	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	15861	13	,	,	,
18637	15861	14	the	the	DT
18637	15861	15	protection	protection	NN
18637	15861	16	against	against	IN
18637	15861	17	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15861	18	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	15861	19	by	by	IN
18637	15861	20	the	the	DT
18637	15861	21	First	First	NNP
18637	15861	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15861	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	15861	24	a	a	DT
18637	15861	25	matter	matter	NN
18637	15861	26	of	of	IN
18637	15861	27	law	law	NN
18637	15861	28	.	.	.
18637	15862	1	The	the	DT
18637	15862	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15862	3	that	that	IN
18637	15862	4	there	there	EX
18637	15862	5	must	must	MD
18637	15862	6	be	be	VB
18637	15862	7	a	a	DT
18637	15862	8	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15862	9	and	and	CC
18637	15862	10	present	present	JJ
18637	15862	11	danger	danger	NN
18637	15862	12	of	of	IN
18637	15862	13	a	a	DT
18637	15862	14	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15862	15	evil	evil	NN
18637	15862	16	that	that	WDT
18637	15862	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15862	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	15862	19	a	a	DT
18637	15862	20	right	right	NN
18637	15862	21	to	to	TO
18637	15862	22	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	15862	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	15862	24	a	a	DT
18637	15862	25	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15862	26	rule	rule	NN
18637	15862	27	to	to	TO
18637	15862	28	be	be	VB
18637	15862	29	applied	apply	VBN
18637	15862	30	as	as	IN
18637	15862	31	a	a	DT
18637	15862	32	matter	matter	NN
18637	15862	33	of	of	IN
18637	15862	34	law	law	NN
18637	15862	35	by	by	IN
18637	15862	36	the	the	DT
18637	15862	37	courts	court	NNS
18637	15862	38	.	.	.
18637	15863	1	"	"	``
18637	15863	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15863	3	217	217	CD
18637	15863	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15863	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15863	6	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	15863	7	's	's	POS
18637	15863	8	lengthy	lengthy	JJ
18637	15863	9	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	15863	10	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15863	11	premises	premise	NNS
18637	15863	12	"	"	''
18637	15863	13	the	the	DT
18637	15863	14	right	right	NN
18637	15863	15	of	of	IN
18637	15863	16	a	a	DT
18637	15863	17	government	government	NN
18637	15863	18	to	to	TO
18637	15863	19	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	15863	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15863	21	existence	existence	NN
18637	15863	22	--	--	:
18637	15863	23	self	self	NN
18637	15863	24	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	15863	25	.	.	.
18637	15863	26	"	"	''
18637	15864	1	This	this	DT
18637	15864	2	,	,	,
18637	15864	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15864	4	says	say	VBZ
18637	15864	5	,	,	,
18637	15864	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	15864	7	"	"	``
18637	15864	8	the	the	DT
18637	15864	9	most	most	RBS
18637	15864	10	pervasive	pervasive	JJ
18637	15864	11	aspect	aspect	NN
18637	15864	12	of	of	IN
18637	15864	13	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	15864	14	,	,	,
18637	15864	15	"	"	''
18637	15864	16	citing	cite	VBG
18637	15864	17	The	the	DT
18637	15864	18	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	15864	19	No	no	NN
18637	15864	20	.	.	.
18637	15865	1	41	41	CD
18637	15865	2	,	,	,
18637	15865	3	and	and	CC
18637	15865	4	certain	certain	JJ
18637	15865	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	15865	6	.	.	.
18637	15866	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15866	2	218	218	CD
18637	15866	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15866	4	A	a	DT
18637	15866	5	little	little	JJ
18637	15866	6	later	later	RBR
18637	15866	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15866	8	raises	raise	VBZ
18637	15866	9	the	the	DT
18637	15866	10	question	question	NN
18637	15866	11	,	,	,
18637	15866	12	"	"	``
18637	15866	13	But	but	CC
18637	15866	14	how	how	WRB
18637	15866	15	are	be	VBP
18637	15866	16	competing	compete	VBG
18637	15866	17	interests	interest	NNS
18637	15866	18	to	to	TO
18637	15866	19	be	be	VB
18637	15866	20	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	15866	21	?	?	.
18637	15866	22	"	"	''
18637	15867	1	and	and	CC
18637	15867	2	answers	answer	NNS
18637	15867	3	:	:	:
18637	15867	4	"	"	``
18637	15867	5	Full	full	JJ
18637	15867	6	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	15867	7	for	for	IN
18637	15867	8	the	the	DT
18637	15867	9	choice	choice	NN
18637	15867	10	can	can	MD
18637	15867	11	not	not	RB
18637	15867	12	be	be	VB
18637	15867	13	given	give	VBN
18637	15867	14	to	to	IN
18637	15867	15	the	the	DT
18637	15867	16	courts	court	NNS
18637	15867	17	.	.	.
18637	15868	1	Courts	court	NNS
18637	15868	2	are	be	VBP
18637	15868	3	not	not	RB
18637	15868	4	representative	representative	JJ
18637	15868	5	bodies	body	NNS
18637	15868	6	.	.	.
18637	15869	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15869	2	are	be	VBP
18637	15869	3	not	not	RB
18637	15869	4	designed	design	VBN
18637	15869	5	to	to	TO
18637	15869	6	be	be	VB
18637	15869	7	a	a	DT
18637	15869	8	good	good	JJ
18637	15869	9	reflex	reflex	NN
18637	15869	10	of	of	IN
18637	15869	11	a	a	DT
18637	15869	12	democratic	democratic	JJ
18637	15869	13	society	society	NN
18637	15869	14	.	.	.
18637	15870	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15870	2	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	15870	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	15870	4	best	best	RB
18637	15870	5	informed	informed	JJ
18637	15870	6	,	,	,
18637	15870	7	and	and	CC
18637	15870	8	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	15870	9	most	most	RBS
18637	15870	10	dependable	dependable	JJ
18637	15870	11	,	,	,
18637	15870	12	within	within	IN
18637	15870	13	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	15870	14	limits	limit	NNS
18637	15870	15	.	.	.
18637	15871	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15871	2	essential	essential	JJ
18637	15871	3	quality	quality	NN
18637	15871	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	15871	5	detachment	detachment	NN
18637	15871	6	,	,	,
18637	15871	7	founded	found	VBN
18637	15871	8	on	on	IN
18637	15871	9	independence	independence	NN
18637	15871	10	.	.	.
18637	15872	1	History	history	NN
18637	15872	2	teaches	teach	VBZ
18637	15872	3	that	that	IN
18637	15872	4	the	the	DT
18637	15872	5	independence	independence	NN
18637	15872	6	of	of	IN
18637	15872	7	the	the	DT
18637	15872	8	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	15872	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	15872	10	jeopardized	jeopardize	VBN
18637	15872	11	when	when	WRB
18637	15872	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	15872	13	become	become	VBN
18637	15872	14	embroiled	embroil	VBN
18637	15872	15	in	in	IN
18637	15872	16	the	the	DT
18637	15872	17	passions	passion	NNS
18637	15872	18	of	of	IN
18637	15872	19	the	the	DT
18637	15872	20	day	day	NN
18637	15872	21	and	and	CC
18637	15872	22	assume	assume	VB
18637	15872	23	primary	primary	JJ
18637	15872	24	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	15872	25	in	in	IN
18637	15872	26	choosing	choose	VBG
18637	15872	27	between	between	IN
18637	15872	28	competing	compete	VBG
18637	15872	29	political	political	JJ
18637	15872	30	,	,	,
18637	15872	31	economic	economic	JJ
18637	15872	32	and	and	CC
18637	15872	33	social	social	JJ
18637	15872	34	pressures	pressure	NNS
18637	15872	35	.	.	.
18637	15873	1	Primary	primary	JJ
18637	15873	2	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	15873	3	for	for	IN
18637	15873	4	adjusting	adjust	VBG
18637	15873	5	the	the	DT
18637	15873	6	interests	interest	NNS
18637	15873	7	which	which	WDT
18637	15873	8	compete	compete	VBP
18637	15873	9	in	in	IN
18637	15873	10	the	the	DT
18637	15873	11	situation	situation	NN
18637	15873	12	before	before	IN
18637	15873	13	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15873	14	of	of	IN
18637	15873	15	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	15873	16	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	15873	17	to	to	IN
18637	15873	18	the	the	DT
18637	15873	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15873	20	.	.	.
18637	15874	1	The	the	DT
18637	15874	2	nature	nature	NN
18637	15874	3	of	of	IN
18637	15874	4	the	the	DT
18637	15874	5	power	power	NN
18637	15874	6	to	to	TO
18637	15874	7	be	be	VB
18637	15874	8	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	15874	9	by	by	IN
18637	15874	10	this	this	DT
18637	15874	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15874	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	15874	13	been	be	VBN
18637	15874	14	delineated	delineate	VBN
18637	15874	15	in	in	IN
18637	15874	16	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	15874	17	not	not	RB
18637	15874	18	charged	charge	VBN
18637	15874	19	with	with	IN
18637	15874	20	the	the	DT
18637	15874	21	emotional	emotional	JJ
18637	15874	22	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	15874	23	of	of	IN
18637	15874	24	situations	situation	NNS
18637	15874	25	such	such	JJ
18637	15874	26	as	as	IN
18637	15874	27	that	that	DT
18637	15874	28	now	now	RB
18637	15874	29	before	before	IN
18637	15874	30	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15874	31	.	.	.
18637	15875	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15875	2	are	be	VBP
18637	15875	3	to	to	TO
18637	15875	4	set	set	VB
18637	15875	5	aside	aside	RP
18637	15875	6	the	the	DT
18637	15875	7	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	15875	8	of	of	IN
18637	15875	9	those	those	DT
18637	15875	10	whose	whose	WP$
18637	15875	11	duty	duty	NN
18637	15875	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15875	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	15875	14	to	to	TO
18637	15875	15	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	15875	16	only	only	RB
18637	15875	17	if	if	IN
18637	15875	18	there	there	EX
18637	15875	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	15875	20	no	no	DT
18637	15875	21	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	15875	22	basis	basis	NN
18637	15875	23	for	for	IN
18637	15875	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15875	25	.	.	.
18637	15876	1	"	"	``
18637	15876	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15876	3	219	219	CD
18637	15876	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15876	5	But	but	CC
18637	15876	6	a	a	DT
18637	15876	7	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	15876	8	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	15876	9	,	,	,
18637	15876	10	to	to	IN
18637	15876	11	wit	wit	NN
18637	15876	12	,	,	,
18637	15876	13	in	in	IN
18637	15876	14	the	the	DT
18637	15876	15	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15876	16	and	and	CC
18637	15876	17	present	present	JJ
18637	15876	18	danger	danger	NN
18637	15876	19	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15876	20	.	.	.
18637	15877	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15877	2	says	say	VBZ
18637	15877	3	:	:	:
18637	15877	4	"	"	``
18637	15877	5	In	in	IN
18637	15877	6	all	all	DT
18637	15877	7	fairness	fairness	NN
18637	15877	8	,	,	,
18637	15877	9	the	the	DT
18637	15877	10	argument	argument	NN
18637	15877	11	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15877	12	of	of	IN
18637	15877	13	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	15877	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15877	15	can	can	MD
18637	15877	16	not	not	RB
18637	15877	17	be	be	VB
18637	15877	18	met	meet	VBN
18637	15877	19	by	by	IN
18637	15877	20	reinterpreting	reinterpret	VBG
18637	15877	21	the	the	DT
18637	15877	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15877	23	's	's	POS
18637	15877	24	frequent	frequent	JJ
18637	15877	25	use	use	NN
18637	15877	26	of	of	IN
18637	15877	27	'	'	``
18637	15877	28	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15877	29	'	'	''
18637	15877	30	and	and	CC
18637	15877	31	'	'	``
18637	15877	32	present	present	JJ
18637	15877	33	'	'	''
18637	15877	34	to	to	TO
18637	15877	35	mean	mean	VB
18637	15877	36	an	an	DT
18637	15877	37	entertainable	entertainable	JJ
18637	15877	38	'	'	''
18637	15877	39	probability	probability	NN
18637	15877	40	.	.	.
18637	15877	41	'	'	''
18637	15878	1	In	in	IN
18637	15878	2	giving	give	VBG
18637	15878	3	this	this	DT
18637	15878	4	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	15878	5	to	to	IN
18637	15878	6	the	the	DT
18637	15878	7	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	15878	8	'	'	``
18637	15878	9	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15878	10	and	and	CC
18637	15878	11	present	present	JJ
18637	15878	12	danger	danger	NN
18637	15878	13	,	,	,
18637	15878	14	'	'	''
18637	15878	15	the	the	DT
18637	15878	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15878	17	of	of	IN
18637	15878	18	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	15878	19	was	be	VBD
18637	15878	20	fastidiously	fastidiously	RB
18637	15878	21	confining	confine	VBG
18637	15878	22	the	the	DT
18637	15878	23	rhetoric	rhetoric	NN
18637	15878	24	of	of	IN
18637	15878	25	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	15878	26	to	to	IN
18637	15878	27	the	the	DT
18637	15878	28	exact	exact	JJ
18637	15878	29	scope	scope	NN
18637	15878	30	of	of	IN
18637	15878	31	what	what	WP
18637	15878	32	was	be	VBD
18637	15878	33	decided	decide	VBN
18637	15878	34	by	by	IN
18637	15878	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15878	36	.	.	.
18637	15879	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15879	2	have	have	VBP
18637	15879	3	greater	great	JJR
18637	15879	4	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	15879	5	for	for	IN
18637	15879	6	having	have	VBG
18637	15879	7	given	give	VBN
18637	15879	8	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15879	9	support	support	NN
18637	15879	10	,	,	,
18637	15879	11	over	over	IN
18637	15879	12	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	15879	13	protests	protest	NNS
18637	15879	14	,	,	,
18637	15879	15	to	to	IN
18637	15879	16	uncritical	uncritical	JJ
18637	15879	17	libertarian	libertarian	JJ
18637	15879	18	generalities	generality	NNS
18637	15879	19	.	.	.
18637	15880	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	15880	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15880	3	the	the	DT
18637	15880	4	argument	argument	NN
18637	15880	5	of	of	IN
18637	15880	6	the	the	DT
18637	15880	7	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	15880	8	adequately	adequately	RB
18637	15880	9	met	meet	VBN
18637	15880	10	by	by	IN
18637	15880	11	citing	cite	VBG
18637	15880	12	isolated	isolated	JJ
18637	15880	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	15880	14	.	.	.
18637	15881	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15881	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15881	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15881	4	The	the	DT
18637	15881	5	case	case	NN
18637	15881	6	for	for	IN
18637	15881	7	the	the	DT
18637	15881	8	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	15881	9	requires	require	VBZ
18637	15881	10	that	that	IN
18637	15881	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15881	12	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15881	13	be	be	VB
18637	15881	14	tested	test	VBN
18637	15881	15	against	against	IN
18637	15881	16	the	the	DT
18637	15881	17	entire	entire	JJ
18637	15881	18	body	body	NN
18637	15881	19	of	of	IN
18637	15881	20	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15881	21	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	15881	22	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	15881	23	.	.	.
18637	15882	1	"	"	``
18637	15882	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15882	3	220	220	CD
18637	15882	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15882	5	Turning	turn	VBG
18637	15882	6	then	then	RB
18637	15882	7	to	to	IN
18637	15882	8	the	the	DT
18637	15882	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	15882	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15882	11	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	15882	12	exclaims	exclaim	VBZ
18637	15882	13	at	at	IN
18637	15882	14	last	last	RB
18637	15882	15	:	:	:
18637	15882	16	"	"	``
18637	15882	17	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15882	18	must	must	MD
18637	15882	19	leave	leave	VB
18637	15882	20	to	to	IN
18637	15882	21	others	other	NNS
18637	15882	22	the	the	DT
18637	15882	23	ungrateful	ungrateful	JJ
18637	15882	24	task	task	NN
18637	15882	25	of	of	IN
18637	15882	26	trying	try	VBG
18637	15882	27	to	to	TO
18637	15882	28	reconcile	reconcile	VB
18637	15882	29	all	all	PDT
18637	15882	30	these	these	DT
18637	15882	31	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	15882	32	.	.	.
18637	15883	1	"	"	``
18637	15883	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15883	3	221	221	CD
18637	15883	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15883	5	The	the	DT
18637	15883	6	nearest	near	JJS
18637	15883	7	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	15883	8	was	be	VBD
18637	15883	9	Gitlow	Gitlow	NNP
18637	15883	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15883	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	15883	12	_	_	NNP
18637	15883	13	New	New	NNP
18637	15883	14	York	York	NNP
18637	15883	15	.	.	.
18637	15884	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15884	2	222	222	CD
18637	15884	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15884	4	Here	here	RB
18637	15884	5	"	"	``
18637	15884	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15884	7	put	put	VBP
18637	15884	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15884	9	respect	respect	NN
18637	15884	10	for	for	IN
18637	15884	11	the	the	DT
18637	15884	12	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	15884	13	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	15884	14	in	in	IN
18637	15884	15	terms	term	NNS
18637	15884	16	which	which	WDT
18637	15884	17	,	,	,
18637	15884	18	if	if	IN
18637	15884	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15884	20	were	be	VBD
18637	15884	21	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	15884	22	here	here	RB
18637	15884	23	,	,	,
18637	15884	24	would	would	MD
18637	15884	25	make	make	VB
18637	15884	26	decision	decision	NN
18637	15884	27	easy	easy	RB
18637	15884	28	.	.	.
18637	15885	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15885	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15885	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15885	4	But	but	CC
18637	15885	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15885	6	would	would	MD
18637	15885	7	be	be	VB
18637	15885	8	disingenuous	disingenuous	JJ
18637	15885	9	to	to	TO
18637	15885	10	deny	deny	VB
18637	15885	11	that	that	IN
18637	15885	12	the	the	DT
18637	15885	13	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	15885	14	in	in	IN
18637	15885	15	_	_	NNP
18637	15885	16	Gitlow	Gitlow	NNP
18637	15885	17	_	_	NNP
18637	15885	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	15885	19	been	be	VBN
18637	15885	20	treated	treat	VBN
18637	15885	21	with	with	IN
18637	15885	22	the	the	DT
18637	15885	23	respect	respect	NN
18637	15885	24	usually	usually	RB
18637	15885	25	accorded	accord	VBD
18637	15885	26	a	a	DT
18637	15885	27	decision	decision	NN
18637	15885	28	.	.	.
18637	15886	1	"	"	``
18637	15886	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15886	3	223	223	CD
18637	15886	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15886	5	But	but	CC
18637	15886	6	the	the	DT
18637	15886	7	case	case	NN
18637	15886	8	at	at	IN
18637	15886	9	bar	bar	NN
18637	15886	10	was	be	VBD
18637	15886	11	a	a	DT
18637	15886	12	horse	horse	NN
18637	15886	13	of	of	IN
18637	15886	14	a	a	DT
18637	15886	15	different	different	JJ
18637	15886	16	color	color	NN
18637	15886	17	.	.	.
18637	15887	1	"	"	``
18637	15887	2	In	in	IN
18637	15887	3	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	15887	4	,	,	,
18637	15887	5	there	there	EX
18637	15887	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	15887	7	ample	ample	JJ
18637	15887	8	justification	justification	NN
18637	15887	9	for	for	IN
18637	15887	10	a	a	DT
18637	15887	11	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	15887	12	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	15887	13	that	that	WDT
18637	15887	14	the	the	DT
18637	15887	15	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15887	16	now	now	RB
18637	15887	17	before	before	IN
18637	15887	18	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15887	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	15887	20	a	a	DT
18637	15887	21	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	15887	22	threat	threat	NN
18637	15887	23	to	to	IN
18637	15887	24	national	national	JJ
18637	15887	25	order	order	NN
18637	15887	26	and	and	CC
18637	15887	27	security,"[224	security,"[224	NN
18637	15887	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15887	29	which	which	WDT
18637	15887	30	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	15887	31	to	to	TO
18637	15887	32	be	be	VB
18637	15887	33	in	in	IN
18637	15887	34	essential	essential	JJ
18637	15887	35	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	15887	36	with	with	IN
18637	15887	37	the	the	DT
18637	15887	38	position	position	NN
18637	15887	39	of	of	IN
18637	15887	40	the	the	DT
18637	15887	41	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15887	42	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15887	43	and	and	CC
18637	15887	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15887	45	three	three	CD
18637	15887	46	associates	associate	NNS
18637	15887	47	.	.	.
18637	15888	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15888	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	15888	3	concludes	conclude	VBZ
18637	15888	4	with	with	IN
18637	15888	5	a	a	DT
18637	15888	6	homily	homily	NN
18637	15888	7	on	on	IN
18637	15888	8	the	the	DT
18637	15888	9	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	15888	10	which	which	WDT
18637	15888	11	the	the	DT
18637	15888	12	nature	nature	NN
18637	15888	13	of	of	IN
18637	15888	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15888	15	power	power	NN
18637	15888	16	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	15888	17	,	,	,
18637	15888	18	on	on	IN
18637	15888	19	the	the	DT
18637	15888	20	power	power	NN
18637	15888	21	of	of	IN
18637	15888	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15888	23	review	review	NN
18637	15888	24	.	.	.
18637	15889	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15889	2	says	say	VBZ
18637	15889	3	:	:	:
18637	15889	4	"	"	``
18637	15889	5	Can	Can	MD
18637	15889	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15889	7	then	then	RB
18637	15889	8	say	say	VB
18637	15889	9	that	that	IN
18637	15889	10	the	the	DT
18637	15889	11	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	15889	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15889	13	exercised	exercise	VBD
18637	15889	14	was	be	VBD
18637	15889	15	denied	deny	VBN
18637	15889	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15889	17	by	by	IN
18637	15889	18	the	the	DT
18637	15889	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15889	20	?	?	.
18637	15890	1	Can	Can	MD
18637	15890	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15890	3	establish	establish	VB
18637	15890	4	a	a	DT
18637	15890	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15890	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	15890	7	which	which	WDT
18637	15890	8	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	15890	9	the	the	DT
18637	15890	10	elected	elect	VBN
18637	15890	11	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	15890	12	of	of	IN
18637	15890	13	the	the	DT
18637	15890	14	people	people	NNS
18637	15890	15	to	to	TO
18637	15890	16	make	make	VB
18637	15890	17	this	this	DT
18637	15890	18	choice	choice	NN
18637	15890	19	?	?	.
18637	15891	1	Can	Can	MD
18637	15891	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15891	3	hold	hold	VB
18637	15891	4	that	that	IN
18637	15891	5	the	the	DT
18637	15891	6	First	First	NNP
18637	15891	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15891	8	deprives	deprive	VBZ
18637	15891	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15891	10	of	of	IN
18637	15891	11	what	what	WP
18637	15891	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15891	13	deemed	deem	VBD
18637	15891	14	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	15891	15	for	for	IN
18637	15891	16	the	the	DT
18637	15891	17	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15891	18	's	's	POS
18637	15891	19	protection	protection	NN
18637	15891	20	?	?	.
18637	15892	1	To	to	TO
18637	15892	2	make	make	VB
18637	15892	3	validity	validity	NN
18637	15892	4	of	of	IN
18637	15892	5	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15892	6	depend	depend	VBP
18637	15892	7	on	on	IN
18637	15892	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15892	9	reading	reading	NN
18637	15892	10	of	of	IN
18637	15892	11	events	event	NNS
18637	15892	12	still	still	RB
18637	15892	13	in	in	IN
18637	15892	14	the	the	DT
18637	15892	15	womb	womb	NN
18637	15892	16	of	of	IN
18637	15892	17	time	time	NN
18637	15892	18	--	--	:
18637	15892	19	a	a	DT
18637	15892	20	forecast	forecast	NN
18637	15892	21	,	,	,
18637	15892	22	that	that	RB
18637	15892	23	is	is	RB
18637	15892	24	,	,	,
18637	15892	25	of	of	IN
18637	15892	26	the	the	DT
18637	15892	27	outcome	outcome	NN
18637	15892	28	of	of	IN
18637	15892	29	forces	force	NNS
18637	15892	30	at	at	IN
18637	15892	31	best	good	JJS
18637	15892	32	appreciated	appreciate	VBN
18637	15892	33	only	only	RB
18637	15892	34	with	with	IN
18637	15892	35	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	15892	36	of	of	IN
18637	15892	37	the	the	DT
18637	15892	38	topmost	topmost	JJS
18637	15892	39	secrets	secret	NNS
18637	15892	40	of	of	IN
18637	15892	41	nations	nation	NNS
18637	15892	42	--	--	:
18637	15892	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	15892	44	to	to	TO
18637	15892	45	charge	charge	VB
18637	15892	46	the	the	DT
18637	15892	47	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	15892	48	with	with	IN
18637	15892	49	duties	duty	NNS
18637	15892	50	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	15892	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15892	52	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	15892	53	.	.	.
18637	15893	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15893	2	do	do	VBP
18637	15893	3	not	not	RB
18637	15893	4	expect	expect	VB
18637	15893	5	courts	court	NNS
18637	15893	6	to	to	IN
18637	15893	7	pronounce	pronounce	VB
18637	15893	8	historic	historic	JJ
18637	15893	9	verdicts	verdict	NNS
18637	15893	10	on	on	IN
18637	15893	11	bygone	bygone	JJ
18637	15893	12	events	event	NNS
18637	15893	13	.	.	.
18637	15894	1	Even	even	RB
18637	15894	2	historians	historian	NNS
18637	15894	3	have	have	VBP
18637	15894	4	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	15894	5	views	view	NNS
18637	15894	6	to	to	IN
18637	15894	7	this	this	DT
18637	15894	8	day	day	NN
18637	15894	9	on	on	IN
18637	15894	10	the	the	DT
18637	15894	11	origin	origin	NN
18637	15894	12	and	and	CC
18637	15894	13	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	15894	14	of	of	IN
18637	15894	15	the	the	DT
18637	15894	16	French	French	NNP
18637	15894	17	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
18637	15894	18	.	.	.
18637	15895	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15895	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15895	3	as	as	RB
18637	15895	4	absurd	absurd	JJ
18637	15895	5	to	to	TO
18637	15895	6	be	be	VB
18637	15895	7	confident	confident	JJ
18637	15895	8	that	that	IN
18637	15895	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15895	10	can	can	MD
18637	15895	11	measure	measure	VB
18637	15895	12	the	the	DT
18637	15895	13	present	present	JJ
18637	15895	14	clash	clash	NN
18637	15895	15	of	of	IN
18637	15895	16	forces	force	NNS
18637	15895	17	and	and	CC
18637	15895	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15895	19	outcome	outcome	NN
18637	15895	20	as	as	IN
18637	15895	21	to	to	TO
18637	15895	22	ask	ask	VB
18637	15895	23	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15895	24	to	to	TO
18637	15895	25	read	read	VB
18637	15895	26	history	history	NN
18637	15895	27	still	still	RB
18637	15895	28	enveloped	envelop	VBN
18637	15895	29	in	in	IN
18637	15895	30	clouds	cloud	NNS
18637	15895	31	of	of	IN
18637	15895	32	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	15895	33	.	.	.
18637	15896	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15896	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15896	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15896	4	The	the	DT
18637	15896	5	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	15896	6	which	which	WDT
18637	15896	7	the	the	DT
18637	15896	8	Founders	founder	NNS
18637	15896	9	drew	draw	VBD
18637	15896	10	between	between	IN
18637	15896	11	the	the	DT
18637	15896	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15896	13	's	's	POS
18637	15896	14	duty	duty	NN
18637	15896	15	to	to	TO
18637	15896	16	pass	pass	VB
18637	15896	17	on	on	RP
18637	15896	18	the	the	DT
18637	15896	19	power	power	NN
18637	15896	20	of	of	IN
18637	15896	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15896	22	and	and	CC
18637	15896	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15896	24	complementary	complementary	JJ
18637	15896	25	duty	duty	NN
18637	15896	26	not	not	RB
18637	15896	27	to	to	TO
18637	15896	28	enter	enter	VB
18637	15896	29	directly	directly	RB
18637	15896	30	the	the	DT
18637	15896	31	domain	domain	NN
18637	15896	32	of	of	IN
18637	15896	33	policy	policy	NN
18637	15896	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	15896	35	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	15896	36	.	.	.
18637	15897	1	But	but	CC
18637	15897	2	in	in	IN
18637	15897	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15897	4	actual	actual	JJ
18637	15897	5	operation	operation	NN
18637	15897	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15897	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	15897	8	rather	rather	RB
18637	15897	9	subtle	subtle	JJ
18637	15897	10	,	,	,
18637	15897	11	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	15897	12	to	to	IN
18637	15897	13	the	the	DT
18637	15897	14	common	common	JJ
18637	15897	15	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	15897	16	.	.	.
18637	15898	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15898	2	duty	duty	NN
18637	15898	3	to	to	TO
18637	15898	4	abstain	abstain	VB
18637	15898	5	from	from	IN
18637	15898	6	confounding	confound	VBG
18637	15898	7	policy	policy	NN
18637	15898	8	with	with	IN
18637	15898	9	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	15898	10	demands	demand	VBZ
18637	15898	11	preceptive	preceptive	JJ
18637	15898	12	humility	humility	NN
18637	15898	13	as	as	RB
18637	15898	14	well	well	RB
18637	15898	15	as	as	IN
18637	15898	16	self	self	NN
18637	15898	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	15898	18	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	15898	19	in	in	IN
18637	15898	20	not	not	RB
18637	15898	21	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	15898	22	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	15898	23	what	what	WP
18637	15898	24	in	in	IN
18637	15898	25	a	a	DT
18637	15898	26	judge	judge	NN
18637	15898	27	's	's	POS
18637	15898	28	private	private	JJ
18637	15898	29	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	15898	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	15898	31	unwise	unwise	JJ
18637	15898	32	and	and	CC
18637	15898	33	even	even	RB
18637	15898	34	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	15898	35	.	.	.
18637	15899	1	"	"	``
18637	15899	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15899	3	225	225	CD
18637	15899	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15899	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15899	6	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	15899	7	's	's	POS
18637	15899	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	15899	9	emphasizes	emphasize	VBZ
18637	15899	10	the	the	DT
18637	15899	11	conspiratorial	conspiratorial	JJ
18637	15899	12	element	element	NN
18637	15899	13	of	of	IN
18637	15899	14	the	the	DT
18637	15899	15	case	case	NN
18637	15899	16	,	,	,
18637	15899	17	and	and	CC
18637	15899	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	15899	19	flatfooted	flatfoote	VBN
18637	15899	20	in	in	IN
18637	15899	21	rejecting	reject	VBG
18637	15899	22	the	the	DT
18637	15899	23	'	'	``
18637	15899	24	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15899	25	and	and	CC
18637	15899	26	present	present	JJ
18637	15899	27	danger	danger	NN
18637	15899	28	'	'	''
18637	15899	29	test	test	NN
18637	15899	30	for	for	IN
18637	15899	31	this	this	DT
18637	15899	32	type	type	NN
18637	15899	33	of	of	IN
18637	15899	34	case	case	NN
18637	15899	35	.	.	.
18637	15900	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15900	2	writes	write	VBZ
18637	15900	3	:	:	:
18637	15900	4	"	"	``
18637	15900	5	The	the	DT
18637	15900	6	'	'	``
18637	15900	7	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15900	8	and	and	CC
18637	15900	9	present	present	JJ
18637	15900	10	danger	danger	NN
18637	15900	11	'	'	''
18637	15900	12	test	test	NN
18637	15900	13	was	be	VBD
18637	15900	14	an	an	DT
18637	15900	15	innovation	innovation	NN
18637	15900	16	by	by	IN
18637	15900	17	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	15900	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15900	19	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	15900	20	in	in	IN
18637	15900	21	the	the	DT
18637	15900	22	_	_	NNP
18637	15900	23	Schenck	Schenck	NNP
18637	15900	24	Case	Case	NNP
18637	15900	25	_	_	NNP
18637	15900	26	,	,	,
18637	15900	27	reiterated	reiterate	VBD
18637	15900	28	and	and	CC
18637	15900	29	refined	refine	VBN
18637	15900	30	by	by	IN
18637	15900	31	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15900	32	and	and	CC
18637	15900	33	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	15900	34	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15900	35	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	15900	36	in	in	IN
18637	15900	37	later	later	JJ
18637	15900	38	cases	case	NNS
18637	15900	39	,	,	,
18637	15900	40	all	all	DT
18637	15900	41	arising	arise	VBG
18637	15900	42	before	before	IN
18637	15900	43	the	the	DT
18637	15900	44	era	era	NN
18637	15900	45	of	of	IN
18637	15900	46	World	World	NNP
18637	15900	47	War	War	NNP
18637	15900	48	II	II	NNP
18637	15900	49	revealed	reveal	VBD
18637	15900	50	the	the	DT
18637	15900	51	subtlety	subtlety	NN
18637	15900	52	and	and	CC
18637	15900	53	efficacy	efficacy	NN
18637	15900	54	of	of	IN
18637	15900	55	modernized	modernized	JJ
18637	15900	56	revolutionary	revolutionary	JJ
18637	15900	57	techniques	technique	NNS
18637	15900	58	used	use	VBN
18637	15900	59	by	by	IN
18637	15900	60	totalitarian	totalitarian	JJ
18637	15900	61	parties	party	NNS
18637	15900	62	.	.	.
18637	15901	1	In	in	IN
18637	15901	2	those	those	DT
18637	15901	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	15901	4	,	,	,
18637	15901	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15901	6	were	be	VBD
18637	15901	7	faced	face	VBN
18637	15901	8	with	with	IN
18637	15901	9	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	15901	10	under	under	IN
18637	15901	11	so	so	RB
18637	15901	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	15901	13	called	call	VBN
18637	15901	14	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15901	15	syndicalism	syndicalism	NN
18637	15901	16	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	15901	17	aimed	aim	VBN
18637	15901	18	at	at	IN
18637	15901	19	anarchists	anarchist	NNS
18637	15901	20	but	but	CC
18637	15901	21	which	which	WDT
18637	15901	22	,	,	,
18637	15901	23	loosely	loosely	RB
18637	15901	24	construed	construe	VBN
18637	15901	25	,	,	,
18637	15901	26	had	have	VBD
18637	15901	27	been	be	VBN
18637	15901	28	applied	apply	VBN
18637	15901	29	to	to	IN
18637	15901	30	punish	punish	JJ
18637	15901	31	socialism	socialism	NN
18637	15901	32	,	,	,
18637	15901	33	pacifism	pacifism	NN
18637	15901	34	,	,	,
18637	15901	35	and	and	CC
18637	15901	36	left	left	JJ
18637	15901	37	-	-	HYPH
18637	15901	38	wing	wing	NN
18637	15901	39	ideologies	ideology	NNS
18637	15901	40	,	,	,
18637	15901	41	the	the	DT
18637	15901	42	charges	charge	NNS
18637	15901	43	often	often	RB
18637	15901	44	resting	rest	VBG
18637	15901	45	on	on	IN
18637	15901	46	far	far	RB
18637	15901	47	-	-	HYPH
18637	15901	48	fetched	fetched	JJ
18637	15901	49	inferences	inference	NNS
18637	15901	50	which	which	WDT
18637	15901	51	,	,	,
18637	15901	52	if	if	IN
18637	15901	53	true	true	JJ
18637	15901	54	,	,	,
18637	15901	55	would	would	MD
18637	15901	56	establish	establish	VB
18637	15901	57	only	only	RB
18637	15901	58	technical	technical	JJ
18637	15901	59	or	or	CC
18637	15901	60	trivial	trivial	JJ
18637	15901	61	violations	violation	NNS
18637	15901	62	.	.	.
18637	15902	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15902	2	proposed	propose	VBD
18637	15902	3	'	'	``
18637	15902	4	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15902	5	and	and	CC
18637	15902	6	present	present	JJ
18637	15902	7	danger	danger	NN
18637	15902	8	'	'	''
18637	15902	9	as	as	IN
18637	15902	10	a	a	DT
18637	15902	11	test	test	NN
18637	15902	12	for	for	IN
18637	15902	13	the	the	DT
18637	15902	14	sufficiency	sufficiency	NN
18637	15902	15	of	of	IN
18637	15902	16	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	15902	17	in	in	IN
18637	15902	18	particular	particular	JJ
18637	15902	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	15902	20	.	.	.
18637	15903	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15903	2	would	would	MD
18637	15903	3	save	save	VB
18637	15903	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15903	5	,	,	,
18637	15903	6	unmodified	unmodified	JJ
18637	15903	7	,	,	,
18637	15903	8	for	for	IN
18637	15903	9	application	application	NN
18637	15903	10	as	as	IN
18637	15903	11	a	a	DT
18637	15903	12	'	'	``
18637	15903	13	rule	rule	NN
18637	15903	14	of	of	IN
18637	15903	15	reason	reason	NN
18637	15903	16	'	'	''
18637	15903	17	in	in	IN
18637	15903	18	the	the	DT
18637	15903	19	kind	kind	NN
18637	15903	20	of	of	IN
18637	15903	21	case	case	NN
18637	15903	22	for	for	IN
18637	15903	23	which	which	WDT
18637	15903	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15903	25	was	be	VBD
18637	15903	26	devised	devise	VBN
18637	15903	27	.	.	.
18637	15904	1	When	when	WRB
18637	15904	2	the	the	DT
18637	15904	3	issue	issue	NN
18637	15904	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	15904	5	criminality	criminality	NN
18637	15904	6	of	of	IN
18637	15904	7	a	a	DT
18637	15904	8	hot	hot	RB
18637	15904	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	15904	10	headed	head	VBN
18637	15904	11	speech	speech	NN
18637	15904	12	on	on	IN
18637	15904	13	a	a	DT
18637	15904	14	street	street	NN
18637	15904	15	corner	corner	NN
18637	15904	16	,	,	,
18637	15904	17	or	or	CC
18637	15904	18	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	15904	19	of	of	IN
18637	15904	20	a	a	DT
18637	15904	21	few	few	JJ
18637	15904	22	incendiary	incendiary	JJ
18637	15904	23	pamphlets	pamphlet	NNS
18637	15904	24	or	or	CC
18637	15904	25	parading	parade	VBG
18637	15904	26	by	by	IN
18637	15904	27	some	some	DT
18637	15904	28	zealots	zealot	NNS
18637	15904	29	behind	behind	IN
18637	15904	30	a	a	DT
18637	15904	31	red	red	JJ
18637	15904	32	flag	flag	NN
18637	15904	33	,	,	,
18637	15904	34	or	or	CC
18637	15904	35	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	15904	36	of	of	IN
18637	15904	37	a	a	DT
18637	15904	38	handful	handful	NN
18637	15904	39	of	of	IN
18637	15904	40	school	school	NN
18637	15904	41	children	child	NNS
18637	15904	42	to	to	TO
18637	15904	43	salute	salute	VB
18637	15904	44	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15904	45	flag	flag	NN
18637	15904	46	,	,	,
18637	15904	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15904	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	15904	49	not	not	RB
18637	15904	50	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	15904	51	the	the	DT
18637	15904	52	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	15904	53	of	of	IN
18637	15904	54	the	the	DT
18637	15904	55	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	15904	56	process	process	NN
18637	15904	57	to	to	TO
18637	15904	58	gather	gather	VB
18637	15904	59	,	,	,
18637	15904	60	comprehend	comprehend	VB
18637	15904	61	,	,	,
18637	15904	62	and	and	CC
18637	15904	63	weigh	weigh	VB
18637	15904	64	the	the	DT
18637	15904	65	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	15904	66	materials	material	NNS
18637	15904	67	for	for	IN
18637	15904	68	decision	decision	NN
18637	15904	69	whether	whether	IN
18637	15904	70	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15904	71	is	be	VBZ
18637	15904	72	a	a	DT
18637	15904	73	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15904	74	and	and	CC
18637	15904	75	present	present	JJ
18637	15904	76	danger	danger	NN
18637	15904	77	of	of	IN
18637	15904	78	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	15904	79	evil	evil	NN
18637	15904	80	or	or	CC
18637	15904	81	a	a	DT
18637	15904	82	harmless	harmless	JJ
18637	15904	83	letting	let	VBG
18637	15904	84	off	off	RP
18637	15904	85	of	of	IN
18637	15904	86	steam	steam	NN
18637	15904	87	.	.	.
18637	15905	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15905	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15905	3	not	not	RB
18637	15905	4	a	a	DT
18637	15905	5	prophecy	prophecy	NN
18637	15905	6	,	,	,
18637	15905	7	for	for	IN
18637	15905	8	the	the	DT
18637	15905	9	danger	danger	NN
18637	15905	10	in	in	IN
18637	15905	11	such	such	JJ
18637	15905	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	15905	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	15905	14	matured	mature	VBN
18637	15905	15	by	by	IN
18637	15905	16	the	the	DT
18637	15905	17	time	time	NN
18637	15905	18	of	of	IN
18637	15905	19	trial	trial	NN
18637	15905	20	or	or	CC
18637	15905	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15905	22	was	be	VBD
18637	15905	23	never	never	RB
18637	15905	24	present	present	JJ
18637	15905	25	.	.	.
18637	15906	1	The	the	DT
18637	15906	2	test	test	NN
18637	15906	3	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	15906	4	and	and	CC
18637	15906	5	had	have	VBD
18637	15906	6	meaning	mean	VBG
18637	15906	7	where	where	WRB
18637	15906	8	a	a	DT
18637	15906	9	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15906	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	15906	11	sought	seek	VBN
18637	15906	12	to	to	TO
18637	15906	13	be	be	VB
18637	15906	14	based	base	VBN
18637	15906	15	on	on	IN
18637	15906	16	a	a	DT
18637	15906	17	speech	speech	NN
18637	15906	18	or	or	CC
18637	15906	19	writing	writing	NN
18637	15906	20	which	which	WDT
18637	15906	21	does	do	VBZ
18637	15906	22	not	not	RB
18637	15906	23	directly	directly	RB
18637	15906	24	or	or	CC
18637	15906	25	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	15906	26	advocate	advocate	VB
18637	15906	27	a	a	DT
18637	15906	28	crime	crime	NN
18637	15906	29	but	but	CC
18637	15906	30	to	to	IN
18637	15906	31	which	which	WDT
18637	15906	32	such	such	JJ
18637	15906	33	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	15906	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	15906	35	sought	seek	VBN
18637	15906	36	to	to	TO
18637	15906	37	be	be	VB
18637	15906	38	attributed	attribute	VBN
18637	15906	39	by	by	IN
18637	15906	40	construction	construction	NN
18637	15906	41	or	or	CC
18637	15906	42	by	by	IN
18637	15906	43	implication	implication	NN
18637	15906	44	from	from	IN
18637	15906	45	external	external	JJ
18637	15906	46	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	15906	47	.	.	.
18637	15907	1	The	the	DT
18637	15907	2	formula	formula	NN
18637	15907	3	in	in	IN
18637	15907	4	such	such	JJ
18637	15907	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	15907	6	favors	favor	VBZ
18637	15907	7	freedoms	freedom	NNS
18637	15907	8	that	that	WDT
18637	15907	9	are	be	VBP
18637	15907	10	vital	vital	JJ
18637	15907	11	to	to	IN
18637	15907	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15907	13	society	society	NN
18637	15907	14	,	,	,
18637	15907	15	and	and	CC
18637	15907	16	,	,	,
18637	15907	17	even	even	RB
18637	15907	18	if	if	IN
18637	15907	19	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	15907	20	applied	apply	VBD
18637	15907	21	too	too	RB
18637	15907	22	generously	generously	RB
18637	15907	23	,	,	,
18637	15907	24	the	the	DT
18637	15907	25	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	15907	26	can	can	MD
18637	15907	27	not	not	RB
18637	15907	28	be	be	VB
18637	15907	29	grave	grave	JJ
18637	15907	30	.	.	.
18637	15908	1	But	but	CC
18637	15908	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15908	3	recent	recent	JJ
18637	15908	4	expansion	expansion	NN
18637	15908	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	15908	6	extended	extend	VBN
18637	15908	7	,	,	,
18637	15908	8	in	in	IN
18637	15908	9	particular	particular	JJ
18637	15908	10	to	to	IN
18637	15908	11	Communists	Communists	NNPS
18637	15908	12	,	,	,
18637	15908	13	unprecedented	unprecedented	JJ
18637	15908	14	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	15908	15	.	.	.
18637	15909	1	Unless	unless	IN
18637	15909	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15909	3	are	be	VBP
18637	15909	4	to	to	TO
18637	15909	5	hold	hold	VB
18637	15909	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15909	7	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15909	8	captive	captive	NN
18637	15909	9	in	in	IN
18637	15909	10	a	a	DT
18637	15909	11	judge	judge	NN
18637	15909	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	15909	13	made	make	VBN
18637	15909	14	verbal	verbal	JJ
18637	15909	15	trap	trap	NN
18637	15909	16	,	,	,
18637	15909	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15909	18	must	must	MD
18637	15909	19	approach	approach	VB
18637	15909	20	the	the	DT
18637	15909	21	problem	problem	NN
18637	15909	22	of	of	IN
18637	15909	23	a	a	DT
18637	15909	24	well	well	RB
18637	15909	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	15909	26	organized	organize	VBN
18637	15909	27	,	,	,
18637	15909	28	nation	nation	NN
18637	15909	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	15909	30	wide	wide	JJ
18637	15909	31	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15909	32	,	,	,
18637	15909	33	such	such	JJ
18637	15909	34	as	as	IN
18637	15909	35	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15909	36	have	have	VBP
18637	15909	37	described	describe	VBN
18637	15909	38	,	,	,
18637	15909	39	as	as	RB
18637	15909	40	realistically	realistically	RB
18637	15909	41	as	as	IN
18637	15909	42	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15909	43	predecessors	predecessor	NNS
18637	15909	44	faced	face	VBD
18637	15909	45	the	the	DT
18637	15909	46	trivialities	triviality	NNS
18637	15909	47	that	that	WDT
18637	15909	48	were	be	VBD
18637	15909	49	being	be	VBG
18637	15909	50	prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
18637	15909	51	until	until	IN
18637	15909	52	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15909	53	were	be	VBD
18637	15909	54	checked	check	VBN
18637	15909	55	with	with	IN
18637	15909	56	a	a	DT
18637	15909	57	rule	rule	NN
18637	15909	58	of	of	IN
18637	15909	59	reason	reason	NN
18637	15909	60	.	.	.
18637	15910	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15910	2	think	think	VBP
18637	15910	3	reason	reason	NN
18637	15910	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	15910	5	lacking	lack	VBG
18637	15910	6	for	for	IN
18637	15910	7	applying	apply	VBG
18637	15910	8	that	that	DT
18637	15910	9	test	test	NN
18637	15910	10	to	to	IN
18637	15910	11	this	this	DT
18637	15910	12	case	case	NN
18637	15910	13	.	.	.
18637	15911	1	"	"	``
18637	15911	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15911	3	226	226	CD
18637	15911	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15911	5	And	and	CC
18637	15911	6	again	again	RB
18637	15911	7	,	,	,
18637	15911	8	"	"	``
18637	15911	9	What	what	WP
18637	15911	10	really	really	RB
18637	15911	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	15911	12	under	under	IN
18637	15911	13	review	review	NN
18637	15911	14	here	here	RB
18637	15911	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	15911	16	a	a	DT
18637	15911	17	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	15911	18	of	of	IN
18637	15911	19	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15911	20	,	,	,
18637	15911	21	after	after	IN
18637	15911	22	a	a	DT
18637	15911	23	trial	trial	NN
18637	15911	24	for	for	IN
18637	15911	25	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15911	26	,	,	,
18637	15911	27	on	on	IN
18637	15911	28	an	an	DT
18637	15911	29	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	15911	30	charging	charge	VBG
18637	15911	31	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15911	32	,	,	,
18637	15911	33	brought	bring	VBN
18637	15911	34	under	under	IN
18637	15911	35	a	a	DT
18637	15911	36	statute	statute	NN
18637	15911	37	outlawing	outlaw	VBG
18637	15911	38	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15911	39	.	.	.
18637	15912	1	With	with	IN
18637	15912	2	due	due	JJ
18637	15912	3	respect	respect	NN
18637	15912	4	to	to	IN
18637	15912	5	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15912	6	colleagues	colleague	NNS
18637	15912	7	,	,	,
18637	15912	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15912	9	seem	seem	VBP
18637	15912	10	to	to	IN
18637	15912	11	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15912	12	to	to	TO
18637	15912	13	discuss	discuss	VB
18637	15912	14	anything	anything	NN
18637	15912	15	under	under	IN
18637	15912	16	the	the	DT
18637	15912	17	sun	sun	NN
18637	15912	18	except	except	IN
18637	15912	19	the	the	DT
18637	15912	20	law	law	NN
18637	15912	21	of	of	IN
18637	15912	22	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15912	23	.	.	.
18637	15913	1	One	one	CD
18637	15913	2	of	of	IN
18637	15913	3	the	the	DT
18637	15913	4	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	15913	5	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	15913	6	even	even	RB
18637	15913	7	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	15913	8	to	to	TO
18637	15913	9	chide	chide	VB
18637	15913	10	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15913	11	for	for	IN
18637	15913	12	'	'	``
18637	15913	13	invoking	invoke	VBG
18637	15913	14	the	the	DT
18637	15913	15	law	law	NN
18637	15913	16	of	of	IN
18637	15913	17	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15913	18	.	.	.
18637	15913	19	'	'	''
18637	15914	1	As	as	IN
18637	15914	2	that	that	DT
18637	15914	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	15914	4	the	the	DT
18637	15914	5	case	case	NN
18637	15914	6	before	before	IN
18637	15914	7	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15914	8	,	,	,
18637	15914	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15914	10	may	may	MD
18637	15914	11	be	be	VB
18637	15914	12	more	more	RBR
18637	15914	13	amazing	amazing	JJ
18637	15914	14	that	that	IN
18637	15914	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15914	16	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	15914	17	can	can	MD
18637	15914	18	be	be	VB
18637	15914	19	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	15914	20	without	without	IN
18637	15914	21	even	even	RB
18637	15914	22	considering	consider	VBG
18637	15914	23	the	the	DT
18637	15914	24	law	law	NN
18637	15914	25	of	of	IN
18637	15914	26	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15914	27	.	.	.
18637	15915	1	The	the	DT
18637	15915	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15915	3	does	do	VBZ
18637	15915	4	not	not	RB
18637	15915	5	make	make	VB
18637	15915	6	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15915	7	a	a	DT
18637	15915	8	civil	civil	JJ
18637	15915	9	right	right	NN
18637	15915	10	.	.	.
18637	15916	1	The	the	DT
18637	15916	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15916	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	15916	4	never	never	RB
18637	15916	5	before	before	RB
18637	15916	6	done	do	VBN
18637	15916	7	so	so	RB
18637	15916	8	and	and	CC
18637	15916	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15916	10	think	think	VBP
18637	15916	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15916	12	should	should	MD
18637	15916	13	not	not	RB
18637	15916	14	do	do	VB
18637	15916	15	so	so	RB
18637	15916	16	now	now	RB
18637	15916	17	.	.	.
18637	15917	1	Conspiracies	conspiracy	NNS
18637	15917	2	of	of	IN
18637	15917	3	labor	labor	NN
18637	15917	4	unions	union	NNS
18637	15917	5	,	,	,
18637	15917	6	trade	trade	NN
18637	15917	7	associations	association	NNS
18637	15917	8	,	,	,
18637	15917	9	and	and	CC
18637	15917	10	news	news	NN
18637	15917	11	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	15917	12	have	have	VBP
18637	15917	13	been	be	VBN
18637	15917	14	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	15917	15	,	,	,
18637	15917	16	although	although	IN
18637	15917	17	accomplished	accomplish	VBN
18637	15917	18	,	,	,
18637	15917	19	evidenced	evidence	VBN
18637	15917	20	and	and	CC
18637	15917	21	carried	carry	VBN
18637	15917	22	out	out	RP
18637	15917	23	,	,	,
18637	15917	24	like	like	IN
18637	15917	25	the	the	DT
18637	15917	26	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15917	27	here	here	RB
18637	15917	28	,	,	,
18637	15917	29	chiefly	chiefly	RB
18637	15917	30	by	by	IN
18637	15917	31	letter	letter	NN
18637	15917	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	15917	33	writing	writing	NN
18637	15917	34	,	,	,
18637	15917	35	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	15917	36	,	,	,
18637	15917	37	speeches	speech	NNS
18637	15917	38	and	and	CC
18637	15917	39	organization	organization	NN
18637	15917	40	.	.	.
18637	15918	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	15918	2	,	,	,
18637	15918	3	this	this	DT
18637	15918	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15918	5	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	15918	6	,	,	,
18637	15918	7	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	15918	8	in	in	IN
18637	15918	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	15918	10	where	where	WRB
18637	15918	11	the	the	DT
18637	15918	12	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15918	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	15918	14	economic	economic	JJ
18637	15918	15	ends	end	NNS
18637	15918	16	,	,	,
18637	15918	17	to	to	TO
18637	15918	18	be	be	VB
18637	15918	19	applying	apply	VBG
18637	15918	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15918	21	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	15918	22	with	with	IN
18637	15918	23	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	15918	24	severity	severity	NN
18637	15918	25	.	.	.
18637	15919	1	While	while	IN
18637	15919	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15919	3	consider	consider	VBP
18637	15919	4	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15919	5	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15919	6	a	a	DT
18637	15919	7	dragnet	dragnet	NN
18637	15919	8	device	device	NN
18637	15919	9	capable	capable	JJ
18637	15919	10	of	of	IN
18637	15919	11	perversion	perversion	NN
18637	15919	12	into	into	IN
18637	15919	13	an	an	DT
18637	15919	14	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	15919	15	of	of	IN
18637	15919	16	injustice	injustice	NN
18637	15919	17	in	in	IN
18637	15919	18	the	the	DT
18637	15919	19	hands	hand	NNS
18637	15919	20	of	of	IN
18637	15919	21	a	a	DT
18637	15919	22	partisan	partisan	JJ
18637	15919	23	or	or	CC
18637	15919	24	complacent	complacent	JJ
18637	15919	25	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	15919	26	,	,	,
18637	15919	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15919	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	15919	29	an	an	DT
18637	15919	30	established	established	JJ
18637	15919	31	place	place	NN
18637	15919	32	in	in	IN
18637	15919	33	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15919	34	system	system	NN
18637	15919	35	of	of	IN
18637	15919	36	law	law	NN
18637	15919	37	,	,	,
18637	15919	38	and	and	CC
18637	15919	39	no	no	DT
18637	15919	40	reason	reason	NN
18637	15919	41	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	15919	42	for	for	IN
18637	15919	43	applying	apply	VBG
18637	15919	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15919	45	only	only	RB
18637	15919	46	to	to	IN
18637	15919	47	concerted	concerted	JJ
18637	15919	48	action	action	NN
18637	15919	49	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	15919	50	to	to	TO
18637	15919	51	disturb	disturb	VB
18637	15919	52	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	15919	53	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	15919	54	and	and	CC
18637	15919	55	withholding	withhold	VBG
18637	15919	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15919	57	from	from	IN
18637	15919	58	those	those	DT
18637	15919	59	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	15919	60	to	to	TO
18637	15919	61	undermine	undermine	VB
18637	15919	62	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15919	63	whole	whole	JJ
18637	15919	64	Government	government	NN
18637	15919	65	.	.	.
18637	15920	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15920	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15920	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15920	4	"	"	''
18637	15920	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15920	6	227	227	CD
18637	15920	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15920	8	The	the	DT
18637	15920	9	dissenters	dissenter	NNS
18637	15920	10	were	be	VBD
18637	15920	11	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15920	12	Black	Black	NNP
18637	15920	13	and	and	CC
18637	15920	14	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	15920	15	.	.	.
18637	15921	1	The	the	DT
18637	15921	2	former	former	JJ
18637	15921	3	reiterated	reiterate	VBD
18637	15921	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15921	5	position	position	NN
18637	15921	6	in	in	IN
18637	15921	7	Bridges	Bridges	NNP
18637	15921	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15921	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	15921	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15921	11	California	California	NNP
18637	15921	12	;	;	:
18637	15921	13	the	the	DT
18637	15921	14	latter	latter	JJ
18637	15921	15	italicized	italicize	VBD
18637	15921	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15921	17	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	15921	18	'	'	''
18637	15921	19	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	15921	20	in	in	IN
18637	15921	21	the	the	DT
18637	15921	22	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	15921	23	Case	case	NN
18637	15921	24	:	:	:
18637	15921	25	"	"	``
18637	15921	26	If	if	IN
18637	15921	27	there	there	EX
18637	15921	28	be	be	VBP
18637	15921	29	time	time	NN
18637	15921	30	to	to	TO
18637	15921	31	expose	expose	VB
18637	15921	32	through	through	IN
18637	15921	33	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	15921	34	the	the	DT
18637	15921	35	falsehood	falsehood	NN
18637	15921	36	and	and	CC
18637	15921	37	fallacies	fallacy	NNS
18637	15921	38	,	,	,
18637	15921	39	to	to	TO
18637	15921	40	avert	avert	VB
18637	15921	41	the	the	DT
18637	15921	42	evil	evil	NN
18637	15921	43	by	by	IN
18637	15921	44	the	the	DT
18637	15921	45	processes	process	NNS
18637	15921	46	of	of	IN
18637	15921	47	education	education	NN
18637	15921	48	,	,	,
18637	15921	49	the	the	DT
18637	15921	50	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	15921	51	to	to	TO
18637	15921	52	be	be	VB
18637	15921	53	applied	apply	VBN
18637	15921	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	15921	55	more	more	JJR
18637	15921	56	speech	speech	NN
18637	15921	57	,	,	,
18637	15921	58	not	not	RB
18637	15921	59	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	15921	60	silence	silence	NN
18637	15921	61	.	.	.
18637	15922	1	"	"	``
18637	15922	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15922	3	228	228	CD
18637	15922	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15922	5	The	the	DT
18637	15922	6	answer	answer	NN
18637	15922	7	would	would	MD
18637	15922	8	seem	seem	VB
18637	15922	9	to	to	TO
18637	15922	10	be	be	VB
18637	15922	11	that	that	IN
18637	15922	12	education	education	NN
18637	15922	13	had	have	VBD
18637	15922	14	not	not	RB
18637	15922	15	in	in	IN
18637	15922	16	fact	fact	NN
18637	15922	17	prevented	prevent	VBD
18637	15922	18	the	the	DT
18637	15922	19	formation	formation	NN
18637	15922	20	of	of	IN
18637	15922	21	the	the	DT
18637	15922	22	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15922	23	for	for	IN
18637	15922	24	entering	enter	VBG
18637	15922	25	into	into	IN
18637	15922	26	which	which	WDT
18637	15922	27	the	the	DT
18637	15922	28	eleven	eleven	CD
18637	15922	29	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	15922	30	were	be	VBD
18637	15922	31	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	15922	32	.	.	.
18637	15923	1	If	if	IN
18637	15923	2	that	that	DT
18637	15923	3	be	be	VBP
18637	15923	4	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	15923	5	a	a	DT
18637	15923	6	danger	danger	NN
18637	15923	7	at	at	RB
18637	15923	8	all	all	RB
18637	15923	9	,	,	,
18637	15923	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15923	11	was	be	VBD
18637	15923	12	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	15923	13	a	a	DT
18637	15923	14	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15923	15	and	and	CC
18637	15923	16	present	present	JJ
18637	15923	17	one	one	CD
18637	15923	18	.	.	.
18637	15924	1	Both	both	DT
18637	15924	2	dissenters	dissenter	NNS
18637	15924	3	,	,	,
18637	15924	4	in	in	IN
18637	15924	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	15924	6	,	,	,
18637	15924	7	ignore	ignore	VB
18637	15924	8	the	the	DT
18637	15924	9	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15924	10	element	element	NN
18637	15924	11	.	.	.
18637	15925	1	SUBVERSIVE	SUBVERSIVE	VBG
18637	15925	2	ORGANIZATIONS	organizations	NN
18637	15925	3	In	in	IN
18637	15925	4	a	a	DT
18637	15925	5	series	series	NN
18637	15925	6	of	of	IN
18637	15925	7	cases[229	cases[229	NNP
18637	15925	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15925	9	in	in	IN
18637	15925	10	which	which	WDT
18637	15925	11	certain	certain	JJ
18637	15925	12	organizations	organization	NNS
18637	15925	13	sued	sue	VBD
18637	15925	14	the	the	DT
18637	15925	15	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	15925	16	General	General	NNP
18637	15925	17	for	for	IN
18637	15925	18	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	15925	19	or	or	CC
18637	15925	20	injunctive	injunctive	JJ
18637	15925	21	relief	relief	NN
18637	15925	22	looking	look	VBG
18637	15925	23	to	to	IN
18637	15925	24	the	the	DT
18637	15925	25	deletion	deletion	NN
18637	15925	26	of	of	IN
18637	15925	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15925	28	names	name	NNS
18637	15925	29	from	from	IN
18637	15925	30	a	a	DT
18637	15925	31	list	list	NN
18637	15925	32	of	of	IN
18637	15925	33	organizations	organization	NNS
18637	15925	34	designated	designate	VBN
18637	15925	35	by	by	IN
18637	15925	36	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15925	37	to	to	TO
18637	15925	38	be	be	VB
18637	15925	39	subversive	subversive	JJ
18637	15925	40	,	,	,
18637	15925	41	the	the	DT
18637	15925	42	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15925	43	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	15925	44	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	15925	45	of	of	IN
18637	15925	46	the	the	DT
18637	15925	47	courts	court	NNS
18637	15925	48	below	below	IN
18637	15925	49	which	which	WDT
18637	15925	50	had	have	VBD
18637	15925	51	denied	deny	VBN
18637	15925	52	relief	relief	NN
18637	15925	53	.	.	.
18637	15926	1	Two	two	CD
18637	15926	2	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15926	3	thought	think	VBD
18637	15926	4	the	the	DT
18637	15926	5	order	order	NN
18637	15926	6	not	not	RB
18637	15926	7	within	within	IN
18637	15926	8	the	the	DT
18637	15926	9	President	President	NNP
18637	15926	10	's	's	POS
18637	15926	11	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	15926	12	Order	order	NN
18637	15926	13	No	no	UH
18637	15926	14	.	.	.
18637	15927	1	9835	9835	CD
18637	15927	2	,	,	,
18637	15927	3	which	which	WDT
18637	15927	4	lays	lay	VBZ
18637	15927	5	down	down	RB
18637	15927	6	a	a	DT
18637	15927	7	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	15927	8	for	for	IN
18637	15927	9	the	the	DT
18637	15927	10	determination	determination	NN
18637	15927	11	of	of	IN
18637	15927	12	the	the	DT
18637	15927	13	loyalty	loyalty	NN
18637	15927	14	of	of	IN
18637	15927	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15927	16	employees	employee	NNS
18637	15927	17	or	or	CC
18637	15927	18	would	would	MD
18637	15927	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	15927	20	be	be	VB
18637	15927	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	15927	22	employees	employee	NNS
18637	15927	23	.	.	.
18637	15928	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15928	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	15928	3	thought	think	VBD
18637	15928	4	the	the	DT
18637	15928	5	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	15928	6	General	General	NNP
18637	15928	7	had	have	VBD
18637	15928	8	violated	violate	VBN
18637	15928	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15928	10	I	I	NNP
18637	15928	11	and	and	CC
18637	15928	12	that	that	IN
18637	15928	13	the	the	DT
18637	15928	14	President	President	NNP
18637	15928	15	's	's	POS
18637	15928	16	order	order	NN
18637	15928	17	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	15928	18	a	a	DT
18637	15928	19	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	15928	20	of	of	IN
18637	15928	21	Attainder	Attainder	NNP
18637	15928	22	.	.	.
18637	15929	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15929	2	and	and	CC
18637	15929	3	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	15929	4	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	15929	5	and	and	CC
18637	15929	6	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	15929	7	also	also	RB
18637	15929	8	held	hold	VBD
18637	15929	9	that	that	IN
18637	15929	10	the	the	DT
18637	15929	11	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	15929	12	General	General	NNP
18637	15929	13	had	have	VBD
18637	15929	14	violated	violate	VBN
18637	15929	15	due	due	JJ
18637	15929	16	process	process	NN
18637	15929	17	of	of	IN
18637	15929	18	law	law	NN
18637	15929	19	in	in	IN
18637	15929	20	having	have	VBG
18637	15929	21	failed	fail	VBN
18637	15929	22	to	to	TO
18637	15929	23	give	give	VB
18637	15929	24	the	the	DT
18637	15929	25	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	15929	26	notice	notice	NN
18637	15929	27	and	and	CC
18637	15929	28	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	15929	29	.	.	.
18637	15930	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15930	2	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	15930	3	,	,	,
18637	15930	4	with	with	IN
18637	15930	5	the	the	DT
18637	15930	6	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	15930	7	of	of	IN
18637	15930	8	the	the	DT
18637	15930	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15930	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15930	11	and	and	CC
18637	15930	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15930	13	Minton	Minton	NNP
18637	15930	14	,	,	,
18637	15930	15	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	15930	16	,	,	,
18637	15930	17	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	15930	18	that	that	IN
18637	15930	19	the	the	DT
18637	15930	20	action	action	NN
18637	15930	21	of	of	IN
18637	15930	22	the	the	DT
18637	15930	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15930	24	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	15930	25	an	an	DT
18637	15930	26	interference	interference	NN
18637	15930	27	with	with	IN
18637	15930	28	the	the	DT
18637	15930	29	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	15930	30	of	of	IN
18637	15930	31	the	the	DT
18637	15930	32	executive	executive	NN
18637	15930	33	in	in	IN
18637	15930	34	the	the	DT
18637	15930	35	premises	premise	NNS
18637	15930	36	.	.	.
18637	15931	1	RECENT	recent	JJ
18637	15931	2	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	15931	3	LEGISLATION	LEGISLATION	NNP
18637	15931	4	Loyalty	Loyalty	NNP
18637	15931	5	Tests	test	VBZ
18637	15931	6	The	the	DT
18637	15931	7	decision	decision	NN
18637	15931	8	in	in	IN
18637	15931	9	Dennis	Dennis	NNP
18637	15931	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15931	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	15931	12	_	_	NNP
18637	15931	13	United	United	NNP
18637	15931	14	States,[230	States,[230	NNP
18637	15931	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15931	16	taken	take	VBN
18637	15931	17	in	in	IN
18637	15931	18	conjunction	conjunction	NN
18637	15931	19	with	with	IN
18637	15931	20	those	those	DT
18637	15931	21	in	in	IN
18637	15931	22	the	the	DT
18637	15931	23	two	two	CD
18637	15931	24	Douds[231	douds[231	CD
18637	15931	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15931	26	Cases	case	NNS
18637	15931	27	,	,	,
18637	15931	28	put	put	VB
18637	15931	29	the	the	DT
18637	15931	30	clear	clear	JJ
18637	15931	31	and	and	CC
18637	15931	32	present	present	JJ
18637	15931	33	danger	danger	NN
18637	15931	34	rule	rule	NN
18637	15931	35	on	on	IN
18637	15931	36	the	the	DT
18637	15931	37	defensive	defensive	NN
18637	15931	38	in	in	IN
18637	15931	39	the	the	DT
18637	15931	40	field	field	NN
18637	15931	41	of	of	IN
18637	15931	42	federal	federal	JJ
18637	15931	43	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15931	44	.	.	.
18637	15932	1	Substantially	substantially	RB
18637	15932	2	contemporaneous	contemporaneous	JJ
18637	15932	3	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	15932	4	in	in	IN
18637	15932	5	the	the	DT
18637	15932	6	field	field	NN
18637	15932	7	of	of	IN
18637	15932	8	state	state	NN
18637	15932	9	action	action	NN
18637	15932	10	may	may	MD
18637	15932	11	reflect	reflect	VB
18637	15932	12	a	a	DT
18637	15932	13	similar	similar	JJ
18637	15932	14	trend	trend	NN
18637	15932	15	.	.	.
18637	15933	1	In	in	IN
18637	15933	2	Garner	Garner	NNP
18637	15933	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15933	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	15933	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15933	6	Los	Los	NNP
18637	15933	7	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	15933	8	Board,[232	Board,[232	NNP
18637	15933	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15933	10	the	the	DT
18637	15933	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15933	12	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15933	13	the	the	DT
18637	15933	14	right	right	NN
18637	15933	15	of	of	IN
18637	15933	16	a	a	DT
18637	15933	17	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	15933	18	to	to	TO
18637	15933	19	bar	bar	VB
18637	15933	20	from	from	IN
18637	15933	21	employment	employment	NN
18637	15933	22	persons	person	NNS
18637	15933	23	who	who	WP
18637	15933	24	advise	advise	VBP
18637	15933	25	,	,	,
18637	15933	26	advocate	advocate	UH
18637	15933	27	,	,	,
18637	15933	28	or	or	CC
18637	15933	29	teach	teach	VB
18637	15933	30	the	the	DT
18637	15933	31	violent	violent	JJ
18637	15933	32	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	15933	33	of	of	IN
18637	15933	34	the	the	DT
18637	15933	35	government	government	NN
18637	15933	36	,	,	,
18637	15933	37	or	or	CC
18637	15933	38	who	who	WP
18637	15933	39	are	be	VBP
18637	15933	40	members	member	NNS
18637	15933	41	of	of	IN
18637	15933	42	,	,	,
18637	15933	43	or	or	CC
18637	15933	44	become	become	VB
18637	15933	45	affiliated	affiliated	JJ
18637	15933	46	with	with	IN
18637	15933	47	any	any	DT
18637	15933	48	group	group	NN
18637	15933	49	doing	do	VBG
18637	15933	50	so	so	RB
18637	15933	51	,	,	,
18637	15933	52	and	and	CC
18637	15933	53	to	to	TO
18637	15933	54	exact	exact	VB
18637	15933	55	a	a	DT
18637	15933	56	loyalty	loyalty	NN
18637	15933	57	oath	oath	NN
18637	15933	58	of	of	IN
18637	15933	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15933	60	employees	employee	NNS
18637	15933	61	.	.	.
18637	15934	1	In	in	IN
18637	15934	2	Adler	Adler	NNP
18637	15934	3	_	_	NNP
18637	15934	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	15934	5	_	_	NNP
18637	15934	6	Board	Board	NNP
18637	15934	7	of	of	IN
18637	15934	8	Education[233	Education[233	NNP
18637	15934	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15934	10	the	the	DT
18637	15934	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15934	12	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15934	13	the	the	DT
18637	15934	14	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	15934	15	Service	Service	NNP
18637	15934	16	Law	Law	NNP
18637	15934	17	of	of	IN
18637	15934	18	New	New	NNP
18637	15934	19	York	York	NNP
18637	15934	20	as	as	IN
18637	15934	21	implemented	implement	VBN
18637	15934	22	by	by	IN
18637	15934	23	the	the	DT
18637	15934	24	so	so	RB
18637	15934	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	15934	26	called	call	VBN
18637	15934	27	Feinberg	Feinberg	NNP
18637	15934	28	Law	Law	NNP
18637	15934	29	of	of	IN
18637	15934	30	1949	1949	CD
18637	15934	31	.	.	.
18637	15935	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15935	2	234	234	CD
18637	15935	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15935	4	The	the	DT
18637	15935	5	former	former	JJ
18637	15935	6	makes	make	VBZ
18637	15935	7	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	15935	8	in	in	IN
18637	15935	9	any	any	DT
18637	15935	10	public	public	JJ
18637	15935	11	school	school	NN
18637	15935	12	any	any	DT
18637	15935	13	member	member	NN
18637	15935	14	of	of	IN
18637	15935	15	an	an	DT
18637	15935	16	organization	organization	NN
18637	15935	17	advocating	advocate	VBG
18637	15935	18	the	the	DT
18637	15935	19	overthrow	overthrow	NN
18637	15935	20	of	of	IN
18637	15935	21	government	government	NN
18637	15935	22	by	by	IN
18637	15935	23	force	force	NN
18637	15935	24	,	,	,
18637	15935	25	violence	violence	NN
18637	15935	26	,	,	,
18637	15935	27	or	or	CC
18637	15935	28	any	any	DT
18637	15935	29	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	15935	30	means	mean	NNS
18637	15935	31	.	.	.
18637	15936	1	The	the	DT
18637	15936	2	Feinberg	Feinberg	NNP
18637	15936	3	Law	Law	NNP
18637	15936	4	requires	require	VBZ
18637	15936	5	the	the	DT
18637	15936	6	Board	Board	NNP
18637	15936	7	of	of	IN
18637	15936	8	Regents	Regents	NNPS
18637	15936	9	of	of	IN
18637	15936	10	the	the	DT
18637	15936	11	State	State	NNP
18637	15936	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15936	13	1	1	CD
18637	15936	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15936	15	to	to	TO
18637	15936	16	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	15936	17	and	and	CC
18637	15936	18	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	15936	19	rules	rule	NNS
18637	15936	20	for	for	IN
18637	15936	21	the	the	DT
18637	15936	22	removal	removal	NN
18637	15936	23	of	of	IN
18637	15936	24	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	15936	25	persons	person	NNS
18637	15936	26	;	;	:
18637	15936	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15936	28	2	2	LS
18637	15936	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15936	30	to	to	TO
18637	15936	31	promulgate	promulgate	VB
18637	15936	32	a	a	DT
18637	15936	33	list	list	NN
18637	15936	34	of	of	IN
18637	15936	35	banned	ban	VBN
18637	15936	36	organizations	organization	NNS
18637	15936	37	;	;	,
18637	15936	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15936	39	3	3	LS
18637	15936	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15936	41	to	to	TO
18637	15936	42	make	make	VB
18637	15936	43	membership	membership	NN
18637	15936	44	in	in	IN
18637	15936	45	any	any	DT
18637	15936	46	such	such	JJ
18637	15936	47	organization	organization	NN
18637	15936	48	prima	prima	VB
18637	15936	49	facie	facie	JJ
18637	15936	50	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	15936	51	of	of	IN
18637	15936	52	disqualification	disqualification	NN
18637	15936	53	for	for	IN
18637	15936	54	employment	employment	NN
18637	15936	55	in	in	IN
18637	15936	56	the	the	DT
18637	15936	57	public	public	JJ
18637	15936	58	schools	school	NNS
18637	15936	59	.	.	.
18637	15937	1	Referring	refer	VBG
18637	15937	2	to	to	IN
18637	15937	3	the	the	DT
18637	15937	4	Garner	Garner	NNP
18637	15937	5	Case	Case	NNP
18637	15937	6	above	above	RB
18637	15937	7	,	,	,
18637	15937	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15937	9	Minton	Minton	NNP
18637	15937	10	,	,	,
18637	15937	11	for	for	IN
18637	15937	12	the	the	DT
18637	15937	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15937	14	,	,	,
18637	15937	15	said	say	VBD
18637	15937	16	:	:	:
18637	15937	17	"	"	``
18637	15937	18	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15937	19	adhere	adhere	VBP
18637	15937	20	to	to	IN
18637	15937	21	that	that	DT
18637	15937	22	case	case	NN
18637	15937	23	.	.	.
18637	15938	1	A	a	DT
18637	15938	2	teacher	teacher	NN
18637	15938	3	works	work	VBZ
18637	15938	4	in	in	IN
18637	15938	5	a	a	DT
18637	15938	6	sensitive	sensitive	JJ
18637	15938	7	area	area	NN
18637	15938	8	in	in	IN
18637	15938	9	the	the	DT
18637	15938	10	schoolroom	schoolroom	NN
18637	15938	11	.	.	.
18637	15939	1	There	there	RB
18637	15939	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15939	3	shapes	shape	VBZ
18637	15939	4	the	the	DT
18637	15939	5	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	15939	6	of	of	IN
18637	15939	7	young	young	JJ
18637	15939	8	minds	mind	NNS
18637	15939	9	towards	towards	IN
18637	15939	10	the	the	DT
18637	15939	11	society	society	NN
18637	15939	12	in	in	IN
18637	15939	13	which	which	WDT
18637	15939	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15939	15	live	live	VBP
18637	15939	16	.	.	.
18637	15940	1	In	in	IN
18637	15940	2	this	this	DT
18637	15940	3	,	,	,
18637	15940	4	the	the	DT
18637	15940	5	state	state	NN
18637	15940	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	15940	7	a	a	DT
18637	15940	8	vital	vital	JJ
18637	15940	9	concern	concern	NN
18637	15940	10	.	.	.
18637	15941	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15941	2	must	must	MD
18637	15941	3	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	15941	4	the	the	DT
18637	15941	5	integrity	integrity	NN
18637	15941	6	of	of	IN
18637	15941	7	the	the	DT
18637	15941	8	schools	school	NNS
18637	15941	9	.	.	.
18637	15942	1	That	that	IN
18637	15942	2	the	the	DT
18637	15942	3	school	school	NN
18637	15942	4	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	15942	5	have	have	VBP
18637	15942	6	the	the	DT
18637	15942	7	right	right	NN
18637	15942	8	and	and	CC
18637	15942	9	the	the	DT
18637	15942	10	duty	duty	NN
18637	15942	11	to	to	TO
18637	15942	12	screen	screen	VB
18637	15942	13	the	the	DT
18637	15942	14	officials	official	NNS
18637	15942	15	,	,	,
18637	15942	16	teachers	teacher	NNS
18637	15942	17	,	,	,
18637	15942	18	and	and	CC
18637	15942	19	employees	employee	NNS
18637	15942	20	as	as	IN
18637	15942	21	to	to	IN
18637	15942	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15942	23	fitness	fitness	NN
18637	15942	24	to	to	TO
18637	15942	25	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	15942	26	the	the	DT
18637	15942	27	integrity	integrity	NN
18637	15942	28	of	of	IN
18637	15942	29	the	the	DT
18637	15942	30	schools	school	NNS
18637	15942	31	as	as	IN
18637	15942	32	a	a	DT
18637	15942	33	part	part	NN
18637	15942	34	of	of	IN
18637	15942	35	ordered	order	VBN
18637	15942	36	society	society	NN
18637	15942	37	,	,	,
18637	15942	38	can	can	MD
18637	15942	39	not	not	RB
18637	15942	40	be	be	VB
18637	15942	41	doubted	doubt	VBN
18637	15942	42	.	.	.
18637	15943	1	One	one	CD
18637	15943	2	's	's	POS
18637	15943	3	associates	associate	NNS
18637	15943	4	,	,	,
18637	15943	5	past	past	JJ
18637	15943	6	and	and	CC
18637	15943	7	present	present	JJ
18637	15943	8	,	,	,
18637	15943	9	as	as	RB
18637	15943	10	well	well	RB
18637	15943	11	as	as	IN
18637	15943	12	one	one	PRP
18637	15943	13	's	's	POS
18637	15943	14	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	15943	15	,	,	,
18637	15943	16	may	may	MD
18637	15943	17	properly	properly	RB
18637	15943	18	be	be	VB
18637	15943	19	considered	consider	VBN
18637	15943	20	in	in	IN
18637	15943	21	determining	determine	VBG
18637	15943	22	fitness	fitness	NN
18637	15943	23	and	and	CC
18637	15943	24	loyalty	loyalty	NN
18637	15943	25	.	.	.
18637	15944	1	From	from	IN
18637	15944	2	time	time	NN
18637	15944	3	immemorial	immemorial	JJ
18637	15944	4	,	,	,
18637	15944	5	one	one	NN
18637	15944	6	's	's	POS
18637	15944	7	reputation	reputation	NN
18637	15944	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	15944	9	been	be	VBN
18637	15944	10	determined	determine	VBN
18637	15944	11	in	in	IN
18637	15944	12	part	part	NN
18637	15944	13	by	by	IN
18637	15944	14	the	the	DT
18637	15944	15	company	company	NN
18637	15944	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15944	17	keeps	keep	VBZ
18637	15944	18	.	.	.
18637	15945	1	In	in	IN
18637	15945	2	the	the	DT
18637	15945	3	employment	employment	NN
18637	15945	4	of	of	IN
18637	15945	5	officials	official	NNS
18637	15945	6	and	and	CC
18637	15945	7	teachers	teacher	NNS
18637	15945	8	of	of	IN
18637	15945	9	the	the	DT
18637	15945	10	school	school	NN
18637	15945	11	system	system	NN
18637	15945	12	,	,	,
18637	15945	13	the	the	DT
18637	15945	14	state	state	NN
18637	15945	15	may	may	MD
18637	15945	16	very	very	RB
18637	15945	17	properly	properly	RB
18637	15945	18	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	15945	19	into	into	IN
18637	15945	20	the	the	DT
18637	15945	21	company	company	NN
18637	15945	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15945	23	keep	keep	VBP
18637	15945	24	,	,	,
18637	15945	25	and	and	CC
18637	15945	26	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15945	27	know	know	VBP
18637	15945	28	of	of	IN
18637	15945	29	no	no	DT
18637	15945	30	rule	rule	NN
18637	15945	31	,	,	,
18637	15945	32	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	15945	33	or	or	CC
18637	15945	34	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	15945	35	,	,	,
18637	15945	36	that	that	WDT
18637	15945	37	prevents	prevent	VBZ
18637	15945	38	the	the	DT
18637	15945	39	state	state	NN
18637	15945	40	,	,	,
18637	15945	41	when	when	WRB
18637	15945	42	determining	determine	VBG
18637	15945	43	the	the	DT
18637	15945	44	fitness	fitness	NN
18637	15945	45	and	and	CC
18637	15945	46	loyalty	loyalty	NN
18637	15945	47	of	of	IN
18637	15945	48	such	such	JJ
18637	15945	49	persons	person	NNS
18637	15945	50	,	,	,
18637	15945	51	from	from	IN
18637	15945	52	considering	consider	VBG
18637	15945	53	the	the	DT
18637	15945	54	organizations	organization	NNS
18637	15945	55	and	and	CC
18637	15945	56	persons	person	NNS
18637	15945	57	with	with	IN
18637	15945	58	whom	whom	WP
18637	15945	59	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15945	60	associate	associate	VBP
18637	15945	61	.	.	.
18637	15946	1	"	"	``
18637	15946	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15946	3	235	235	CD
18637	15946	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15946	5	Group	Group	NNP
18637	15946	6	Libel	Libel	NNP
18637	15946	7	In	in	IN
18637	15946	8	1952	1952	CD
18637	15946	9	in	in	IN
18637	15946	10	Beauharnais	Beauharnais	NNP
18637	15946	11	_	_	NNP
18637	15946	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	15946	13	_	_	NNP
18637	15946	14	Illinois[236	Illinois[236	NNP
18637	15946	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15946	16	the	the	DT
18637	15946	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15946	18	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15946	19	an	an	DT
18637	15946	20	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	15946	21	statute	statute	NN
18637	15946	22	which	which	WDT
18637	15946	23	makes	make	VBZ
18637	15946	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15946	25	a	a	DT
18637	15946	26	crime	crime	NN
18637	15946	27	to	to	TO
18637	15946	28	exhibit	exhibit	VB
18637	15946	29	in	in	IN
18637	15946	30	a	a	DT
18637	15946	31	public	public	JJ
18637	15946	32	place	place	NN
18637	15946	33	any	any	DT
18637	15946	34	publication	publication	NN
18637	15946	35	which	which	WDT
18637	15946	36	"	"	``
18637	15946	37	portrays	portray	VBZ
18637	15946	38	depravity	depravity	NN
18637	15946	39	,	,	,
18637	15946	40	criminality	criminality	NN
18637	15946	41	,	,	,
18637	15946	42	unchastity	unchastity	NN
18637	15946	43	,	,	,
18637	15946	44	or	or	CC
18637	15946	45	lack	lack	NN
18637	15946	46	of	of	IN
18637	15946	47	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	15946	48	of	of	IN
18637	15946	49	a	a	DT
18637	15946	50	class	class	NN
18637	15946	51	of	of	IN
18637	15946	52	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	15946	53	,	,	,
18637	15946	54	of	of	IN
18637	15946	55	any	any	DT
18637	15946	56	race	race	NN
18637	15946	57	,	,	,
18637	15946	58	color	color	NN
18637	15946	59	,	,	,
18637	15946	60	creed	creed	NN
18637	15946	61	or	or	CC
18637	15946	62	religion	religion	NN
18637	15946	63	"	"	''
18637	15946	64	or	or	CC
18637	15946	65	which	which	WDT
18637	15946	66	"	"	``
18637	15946	67	exposes	expose	VBZ
18637	15946	68	the	the	DT
18637	15946	69	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	15946	70	of	of	IN
18637	15946	71	any	any	DT
18637	15946	72	race	race	NN
18637	15946	73	,	,	,
18637	15946	74	color	color	NN
18637	15946	75	,	,	,
18637	15946	76	creed	creed	NN
18637	15946	77	or	or	CC
18637	15946	78	religion	religion	NN
18637	15946	79	to	to	TO
18637	15946	80	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	15946	81	,	,	,
18637	15946	82	derision	derision	NN
18637	15946	83	,	,	,
18637	15946	84	or	or	CC
18637	15946	85	obloquy	obloquy	NN
18637	15946	86	.	.	.
18637	15946	87	"	"	''
18637	15947	1	The	the	DT
18637	15947	2	act	act	NN
18637	15947	3	was	be	VBD
18637	15947	4	treated	treat	VBN
18637	15947	5	by	by	IN
18637	15947	6	the	the	DT
18637	15947	7	State	State	NNP
18637	15947	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15947	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15947	10	as	as	IN
18637	15947	11	a	a	DT
18637	15947	12	form	form	NN
18637	15947	13	of	of	IN
18637	15947	14	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15947	15	libel	libel	NN
18637	15947	16	,	,	,
18637	15947	17	with	with	IN
18637	15947	18	the	the	DT
18637	15947	19	result	result	NN
18637	15947	20	that	that	IN
18637	15947	21	defense	defense	NN
18637	15947	22	by	by	IN
18637	15947	23	truth	truth	NN
18637	15947	24	of	of	IN
18637	15947	25	the	the	DT
18637	15947	26	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	15947	27	was	be	VBD
18637	15947	28	not	not	RB
18637	15947	29	under	under	IN
18637	15947	30	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	15947	31	law	law	NN
18637	15947	32	available	available	JJ
18637	15947	33	unless	unless	IN
18637	15947	34	the	the	DT
18637	15947	35	publication	publication	NN
18637	15947	36	was	be	VBD
18637	15947	37	also	also	RB
18637	15947	38	shown	show	VBN
18637	15947	39	to	to	TO
18637	15947	40	have	have	VB
18637	15947	41	been	be	VBN
18637	15947	42	made	make	VBN
18637	15947	43	"	"	``
18637	15947	44	with	with	IN
18637	15947	45	good	good	JJ
18637	15947	46	motives	motive	NNS
18637	15947	47	and	and	CC
18637	15947	48	with	with	IN
18637	15947	49	justifiable	justifiable	JJ
18637	15947	50	ends	end	NNS
18637	15947	51	.	.	.
18637	15947	52	"	"	''
18637	15948	1	So	so	RB
18637	15948	2	construed	construe	VBN
18637	15948	3	,	,	,
18637	15948	4	the	the	DT
18637	15948	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15948	6	held	hold	VBD
18637	15948	7	,	,	,
18637	15948	8	the	the	DT
18637	15948	9	Act	Act	NNP
18637	15948	10	did	do	VBD
18637	15948	11	not	not	RB
18637	15948	12	violate	violate	VB
18637	15948	13	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15948	14	of	of	IN
18637	15948	15	speech	speech	NN
18637	15948	16	and	and	CC
18637	15948	17	press	press	NN
18637	15948	18	as	as	IN
18637	15948	19	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	15948	20	to	to	IN
18637	15948	21	the	the	DT
18637	15948	22	States	States	NNP
18637	15948	23	by	by	IN
18637	15948	24	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15948	25	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	15948	26	.	.	.
18637	15949	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	15949	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15949	3	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	15949	4	:	:	:
18637	15949	5	"	"	``
18637	15949	6	If	if	IN
18637	15949	7	an	an	DT
18637	15949	8	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	15949	9	directed	direct	VBN
18637	15949	10	at	at	IN
18637	15949	11	an	an	DT
18637	15949	12	individual	individual	NN
18637	15949	13	may	may	MD
18637	15949	14	be	be	VB
18637	15949	15	the	the	DT
18637	15949	16	object	object	NN
18637	15949	17	of	of	IN
18637	15949	18	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	15949	19	sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	15949	20	,	,	,
18637	15949	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15949	22	can	can	MD
18637	15949	23	not	not	RB
18637	15949	24	deny	deny	VB
18637	15949	25	to	to	IN
18637	15949	26	a	a	DT
18637	15949	27	State	State	NNP
18637	15949	28	power	power	NN
18637	15949	29	to	to	TO
18637	15949	30	punish	punish	VB
18637	15949	31	the	the	DT
18637	15949	32	same	same	JJ
18637	15949	33	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	15949	34	directed	direct	VBN
18637	15949	35	at	at	IN
18637	15949	36	a	a	DT
18637	15949	37	defined	define	VBN
18637	15949	38	group	group	NN
18637	15949	39	,	,	,
18637	15949	40	unless	unless	IN
18637	15949	41	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15949	42	can	can	MD
18637	15949	43	say	say	VB
18637	15949	44	that	that	IN
18637	15949	45	this	this	DT
18637	15949	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	15949	47	a	a	DT
18637	15949	48	wilful	wilful	JJ
18637	15949	49	and	and	CC
18637	15949	50	purposeless	purposeless	JJ
18637	15949	51	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	15949	52	unrelated	unrelated	JJ
18637	15949	53	to	to	IN
18637	15949	54	the	the	DT
18637	15949	55	peace	peace	NN
18637	15949	56	and	and	CC
18637	15949	57	well	well	RB
18637	15949	58	-	-	HYPH
18637	15949	59	being	being	NN
18637	15949	60	of	of	IN
18637	15949	61	the	the	DT
18637	15949	62	State	State	NNP
18637	15949	63	.	.	.
18637	15950	1	"	"	``
18637	15950	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15950	3	237	237	CD
18637	15950	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15950	5	Pointing	point	VBG
18637	15950	6	then	then	RB
18637	15950	7	to	to	IN
18637	15950	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	15950	9	'	'	POS
18637	15950	10	bad	bad	JJ
18637	15950	11	record	record	NN
18637	15950	12	in	in	IN
18637	15950	13	the	the	DT
18637	15950	14	matter	matter	NN
18637	15950	15	of	of	IN
18637	15950	16	race	race	NN
18637	15950	17	riots	riot	NNS
18637	15950	18	,	,	,
18637	15950	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15950	20	continued	continue	VBD
18637	15950	21	:	:	:
18637	15950	22	"	"	``
18637	15950	23	In	in	IN
18637	15950	24	the	the	DT
18637	15950	25	face	face	NN
18637	15950	26	of	of	IN
18637	15950	27	this	this	DT
18637	15950	28	history	history	NN
18637	15950	29	and	and	CC
18637	15950	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15950	31	frequent	frequent	JJ
18637	15950	32	obligato	obligato	NN
18637	15950	33	of	of	IN
18637	15950	34	extreme	extreme	JJ
18637	15950	35	racial	racial	JJ
18637	15950	36	and	and	CC
18637	15950	37	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15950	38	propaganda	propaganda	NN
18637	15950	39	,	,	,
18637	15950	40	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15950	41	would	would	MD
18637	15950	42	deny	deny	VB
18637	15950	43	experience	experience	NN
18637	15950	44	to	to	TO
18637	15950	45	say	say	VB
18637	15950	46	that	that	IN
18637	15950	47	the	the	DT
18637	15950	48	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	15950	49	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	15950	50	was	be	VBD
18637	15950	51	without	without	IN
18637	15950	52	reason	reason	NN
18637	15950	53	in	in	IN
18637	15950	54	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	15950	55	ways	way	NNS
18637	15950	56	to	to	TO
18637	15950	57	curb	curb	VB
18637	15950	58	false	false	JJ
18637	15950	59	or	or	CC
18637	15950	60	malicious	malicious	JJ
18637	15950	61	defamation	defamation	NN
18637	15950	62	of	of	IN
18637	15950	63	racial	racial	JJ
18637	15950	64	and	and	CC
18637	15950	65	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15950	66	groups	group	NNS
18637	15950	67	,	,	,
18637	15950	68	made	make	VBN
18637	15950	69	in	in	IN
18637	15950	70	public	public	JJ
18637	15950	71	places	place	NNS
18637	15950	72	and	and	CC
18637	15950	73	by	by	IN
18637	15950	74	means	mean	NNS
18637	15950	75	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	15950	76	to	to	TO
18637	15950	77	have	have	VB
18637	15950	78	a	a	DT
18637	15950	79	powerful	powerful	JJ
18637	15950	80	emotional	emotional	JJ
18637	15950	81	impact	impact	NN
18637	15950	82	on	on	IN
18637	15950	83	those	those	DT
18637	15950	84	to	to	IN
18637	15950	85	whom	whom	WP
18637	15950	86	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15950	87	was	be	VBD
18637	15950	88	presented	present	VBN
18637	15950	89	.	.	.
18637	15951	1	'	'	``
18637	15951	2	There	there	EX
18637	15951	3	are	be	VBP
18637	15951	4	limits	limit	NNS
18637	15951	5	to	to	IN
18637	15951	6	the	the	DT
18637	15951	7	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15951	8	of	of	IN
18637	15951	9	these	these	DT
18637	15951	10	liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	15951	11	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15951	12	of	of	IN
18637	15951	13	speech	speech	NN
18637	15951	14	and	and	CC
18637	15951	15	of	of	IN
18637	15951	16	the	the	DT
18637	15951	17	press	press	NN
18637	15951	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15951	19	.	.	.
18637	15952	1	The	the	DT
18637	15952	2	danger	danger	NN
18637	15952	3	in	in	IN
18637	15952	4	these	these	DT
18637	15952	5	times	time	NNS
18637	15952	6	from	from	IN
18637	15952	7	the	the	DT
18637	15952	8	coercive	coercive	JJ
18637	15952	9	activities	activity	NNS
18637	15952	10	of	of	IN
18637	15952	11	those	those	DT
18637	15952	12	who	who	WP
18637	15952	13	in	in	IN
18637	15952	14	the	the	DT
18637	15952	15	delusion	delusion	NN
18637	15952	16	of	of	IN
18637	15952	17	racial	racial	JJ
18637	15952	18	or	or	CC
18637	15952	19	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15952	20	conceit	conceit	NN
18637	15952	21	would	would	MD
18637	15952	22	incite	incite	VB
18637	15952	23	violence	violence	NN
18637	15952	24	and	and	CC
18637	15952	25	breaches	breach	NNS
18637	15952	26	of	of	IN
18637	15952	27	the	the	DT
18637	15952	28	peace	peace	NN
18637	15952	29	in	in	IN
18637	15952	30	order	order	NN
18637	15952	31	to	to	TO
18637	15952	32	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	15952	33	others	other	NNS
18637	15952	34	of	of	IN
18637	15952	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15952	36	equal	equal	JJ
18637	15952	37	right	right	NN
18637	15952	38	to	to	IN
18637	15952	39	the	the	DT
18637	15952	40	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15952	41	of	of	IN
18637	15952	42	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15952	43	liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	15952	44	,	,	,
18637	15952	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	15952	46	emphasized	emphasize	VBN
18637	15952	47	by	by	IN
18637	15952	48	events	event	NNS
18637	15952	49	familiar	familiar	JJ
18637	15952	50	to	to	IN
18637	15952	51	all	all	DT
18637	15952	52	.	.	.
18637	15953	1	These	these	DT
18637	15953	2	and	and	CC
18637	15953	3	other	other	JJ
18637	15953	4	transgressions	transgression	NNS
18637	15953	5	of	of	IN
18637	15953	6	those	those	DT
18637	15953	7	limits	limit	NNS
18637	15953	8	the	the	DT
18637	15953	9	States	States	NNPS
18637	15953	10	appropriately	appropriately	RB
18637	15953	11	may	may	MD
18637	15953	12	punish	punish	VB
18637	15953	13	.	.	.
18637	15953	14	'	'	''
18637	15954	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15954	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15954	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15954	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15954	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	15954	6	not	not	RB
18637	15954	7	within	within	IN
18637	15954	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15954	9	competence	competence	NN
18637	15954	10	to	to	TO
18637	15954	11	confirm	confirm	VB
18637	15954	12	or	or	CC
18637	15954	13	deny	deny	VB
18637	15954	14	claims	claim	NNS
18637	15954	15	of	of	IN
18637	15954	16	social	social	JJ
18637	15954	17	scientists	scientist	NNS
18637	15954	18	as	as	IN
18637	15954	19	to	to	IN
18637	15954	20	the	the	DT
18637	15954	21	dependence	dependence	NN
18637	15954	22	of	of	IN
18637	15954	23	the	the	DT
18637	15954	24	individual	individual	NN
18637	15954	25	on	on	IN
18637	15954	26	the	the	DT
18637	15954	27	position	position	NN
18637	15954	28	of	of	IN
18637	15954	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15954	30	racial	racial	JJ
18637	15954	31	or	or	CC
18637	15954	32	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15954	33	group	group	NN
18637	15954	34	in	in	IN
18637	15954	35	the	the	DT
18637	15954	36	community	community	NN
18637	15954	37	.	.	.
18637	15955	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15955	2	would	would	MD
18637	15955	3	,	,	,
18637	15955	4	however	however	RB
18637	15955	5	,	,	,
18637	15955	6	be	be	VB
18637	15955	7	arrant	arrant	JJ
18637	15955	8	dogmatism	dogmatism	NN
18637	15955	9	,	,	,
18637	15955	10	quite	quite	RB
18637	15955	11	outside	outside	IN
18637	15955	12	the	the	DT
18637	15955	13	scope	scope	NN
18637	15955	14	of	of	IN
18637	15955	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15955	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	15955	17	in	in	IN
18637	15955	18	passing	pass	VBG
18637	15955	19	on	on	IN
18637	15955	20	the	the	DT
18637	15955	21	powers	power	NNS
18637	15955	22	of	of	IN
18637	15955	23	a	a	DT
18637	15955	24	State	State	NNP
18637	15955	25	,	,	,
18637	15955	26	for	for	IN
18637	15955	27	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15955	28	to	to	TO
18637	15955	29	deny	deny	VB
18637	15955	30	that	that	IN
18637	15955	31	the	the	DT
18637	15955	32	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	15955	33	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	15955	34	may	may	MD
18637	15955	35	warrantably	warrantably	RB
18637	15955	36	believe	believe	VB
18637	15955	37	that	that	IN
18637	15955	38	a	a	DT
18637	15955	39	man	man	NN
18637	15955	40	's	's	POS
18637	15955	41	job	job	NN
18637	15955	42	and	and	CC
18637	15955	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15955	44	educational	educational	JJ
18637	15955	45	opportunities	opportunity	NNS
18637	15955	46	and	and	CC
18637	15955	47	the	the	DT
18637	15955	48	dignity	dignity	NN
18637	15955	49	accorded	accord	VBD
18637	15955	50	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15955	51	may	may	MD
18637	15955	52	depend	depend	VB
18637	15955	53	as	as	RB
18637	15955	54	much	much	JJ
18637	15955	55	on	on	IN
18637	15955	56	the	the	DT
18637	15955	57	reputation	reputation	NN
18637	15955	58	of	of	IN
18637	15955	59	the	the	DT
18637	15955	60	racial	racial	JJ
18637	15955	61	and	and	CC
18637	15955	62	religious	religious	JJ
18637	15955	63	group	group	NN
18637	15955	64	to	to	TO
18637	15955	65	which	which	WDT
18637	15955	66	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15955	67	willy	willy	RB
18637	15955	68	-	-	:
18637	15955	69	nilly	nilly	RB
18637	15955	70	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	15955	71	,	,	,
18637	15955	72	as	as	IN
18637	15955	73	on	on	IN
18637	15955	74	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15955	75	own	own	JJ
18637	15955	76	merits	merit	NNS
18637	15955	77	.	.	.
18637	15956	1	This	this	DT
18637	15956	2	being	be	VBG
18637	15956	3	so	so	RB
18637	15956	4	,	,	,
18637	15956	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15956	6	are	be	VBP
18637	15956	7	precluded	preclude	VBN
18637	15956	8	from	from	IN
18637	15956	9	saying	say	VBG
18637	15956	10	that	that	IN
18637	15956	11	speech	speech	NN
18637	15956	12	concededly	concededly	RB
18637	15956	13	punishable	punishable	JJ
18637	15956	14	when	when	WRB
18637	15956	15	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	15956	16	directed	direct	VBN
18637	15956	17	at	at	IN
18637	15956	18	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	15956	19	can	can	MD
18637	15956	20	not	not	RB
18637	15956	21	be	be	VB
18637	15956	22	outlawed	outlaw	VBN
18637	15956	23	if	if	IN
18637	15956	24	directed	direct	VBN
18637	15956	25	at	at	IN
18637	15956	26	groups	group	NNS
18637	15956	27	with	with	IN
18637	15956	28	whose	whose	WP$
18637	15956	29	position	position	NN
18637	15956	30	and	and	CC
18637	15956	31	esteem	esteem	NN
18637	15956	32	in	in	IN
18637	15956	33	society	society	NN
18637	15956	34	the	the	DT
18637	15956	35	affiliated	affiliate	VBN
18637	15956	36	individual	individual	NN
18637	15956	37	may	may	MD
18637	15956	38	be	be	VB
18637	15956	39	inextricably	inextricably	RB
18637	15956	40	involved	involve	VBN
18637	15956	41	.	.	.
18637	15957	1	"	"	``
18637	15957	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15957	3	238	238	CD
18637	15957	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15957	5	CENSORSHIP	CENSORSHIP	NNP
18637	15957	6	OF	of	IN
18637	15957	7	THE	the	DT
18637	15957	8	MAILS	mail	NNS
18637	15957	9	:	:	:
18637	15957	10	FRAUD	fraud	NN
18637	15957	11	ORDER	order	NN
18637	15957	12	By	by	IN
18637	15957	13	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15957	14	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	15957	15	in	in	IN
18637	15957	16	1879	1879	CD
18637	15957	17	and	and	CC
18637	15957	18	1934	1934	CD
18637	15957	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15957	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	15957	21	specified	specify	VBN
18637	15957	22	certain	certain	JJ
18637	15957	23	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	15957	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	15957	25	which	which	WDT
18637	15957	26	a	a	DT
18637	15957	27	publication	publication	NN
18637	15957	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	15957	29	be	be	VB
18637	15957	30	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	15957	31	to	to	IN
18637	15957	32	the	the	DT
18637	15957	33	valuable	valuable	JJ
18637	15957	34	second	second	JJ
18637	15957	35	-	-	HYPH
18637	15957	36	class	class	NN
18637	15957	37	mailing	mailing	NN
18637	15957	38	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	15957	39	,	,	,
18637	15957	40	one	one	CD
18637	15957	41	of	of	IN
18637	15957	42	which	which	WDT
18637	15957	43	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	15957	44	as	as	IN
18637	15957	45	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	15957	46	:	:	:
18637	15957	47	Except	except	IN
18637	15957	48	as	as	RB
18637	15957	49	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	15957	50	provided	provide	VBN
18637	15957	51	by	by	IN
18637	15957	52	law	law	NN
18637	15957	53	,	,	,
18637	15957	54	the	the	DT
18637	15957	55	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	15957	56	upon	upon	IN
18637	15957	57	which	which	WDT
18637	15957	58	a	a	DT
18637	15957	59	publication	publication	NN
18637	15957	60	shall	shall	MD
18637	15957	61	be	be	VB
18637	15957	62	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	15957	63	to	to	IN
18637	15957	64	the	the	DT
18637	15957	65	second	second	JJ
18637	15957	66	-	-	HYPH
18637	15957	67	class	class	NN
18637	15957	68	are	be	VBP
18637	15957	69	as	as	IN
18637	15957	70	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	15957	71	:	:	:
18637	15957	72	"	"	``
18637	15957	73	*	*	NFP
18637	15957	74	*	*	NFP
18637	15957	75	*	*	NFP
18637	15957	76	_	_	NNP
18637	15957	77	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	15957	78	.	.	.
18637	15957	79	_	_	NNP
18637	15957	80	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15957	81	must	must	MD
18637	15957	82	be	be	VB
18637	15957	83	originated	originate	VBN
18637	15957	84	and	and	CC
18637	15957	85	published	publish	VBN
18637	15957	86	for	for	IN
18637	15957	87	the	the	DT
18637	15957	88	dissemination	dissemination	NN
18637	15957	89	of	of	IN
18637	15957	90	information	information	NN
18637	15957	91	of	of	IN
18637	15957	92	a	a	DT
18637	15957	93	public	public	JJ
18637	15957	94	character	character	NN
18637	15957	95	,	,	,
18637	15957	96	or	or	CC
18637	15957	97	devoted	devote	VBN
18637	15957	98	to	to	IN
18637	15957	99	literature	literature	NN
18637	15957	100	,	,	,
18637	15957	101	the	the	DT
18637	15957	102	sciences	science	NNS
18637	15957	103	,	,	,
18637	15957	104	arts	art	NNS
18637	15957	105	,	,	,
18637	15957	106	or	or	CC
18637	15957	107	some	some	DT
18637	15957	108	special	special	JJ
18637	15957	109	industry	industry	NN
18637	15957	110	,	,	,
18637	15957	111	and	and	CC
18637	15957	112	having	have	VBG
18637	15957	113	a	a	DT
18637	15957	114	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	15957	115	list	list	NN
18637	15957	116	of	of	IN
18637	15957	117	subscribers	subscriber	NNS
18637	15957	118	;	;	,
18637	15957	119	*	*	NFP
18637	15957	120	*	*	NFP
18637	15957	121	*	*	NFP
18637	15957	122	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	15957	123	herein	herein	NNP
18637	15957	124	contained	contain	VBD
18637	15957	125	shall	shall	MD
18637	15957	126	be	be	VB
18637	15957	127	so	so	RB
18637	15957	128	construed	construe	VBN
18637	15957	129	as	as	IN
18637	15957	130	to	to	TO
18637	15957	131	admit	admit	VB
18637	15957	132	to	to	IN
18637	15957	133	the	the	DT
18637	15957	134	second	second	JJ
18637	15957	135	-	-	HYPH
18637	15957	136	class	class	NN
18637	15957	137	rate	rate	NN
18637	15957	138	regular	regular	JJ
18637	15957	139	publications	publication	NNS
18637	15957	140	designed	design	VBN
18637	15957	141	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	15957	142	for	for	IN
18637	15957	143	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	15957	144	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	15957	145	,	,	,
18637	15957	146	or	or	CC
18637	15957	147	for	for	IN
18637	15957	148	free	free	JJ
18637	15957	149	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	15957	150	,	,	,
18637	15957	151	or	or	CC
18637	15957	152	for	for	IN
18637	15957	153	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	15957	154	at	at	IN
18637	15957	155	nominal	nominal	JJ
18637	15957	156	rates	rate	NNS
18637	15957	157	.	.	.
18637	15958	1	"	"	``
18637	15958	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15958	3	239	239	CD
18637	15958	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15958	5	In	in	IN
18637	15958	6	Hannegan	Hannegan	NNP
18637	15958	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15958	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15958	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15958	10	Esquire	Esquire	NNP
18637	15958	11	,	,	,
18637	15958	12	Inc	Inc	NNP
18637	15958	13	.	.	.
18637	15958	14	,[240	,[240	NNP
18637	15958	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15958	16	the	the	DT
18637	15958	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15958	18	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15958	19	an	an	DT
18637	15958	20	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	15958	21	against	against	IN
18637	15958	22	an	an	DT
18637	15958	23	order	order	NN
18637	15958	24	of	of	IN
18637	15958	25	the	the	DT
18637	15958	26	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
18637	15958	27	General	General	NNP
18637	15958	28	which	which	WDT
18637	15958	29	suspended	suspend	VBD
18637	15958	30	a	a	DT
18637	15958	31	permit	permit	NN
18637	15958	32	to	to	IN
18637	15958	33	Esquire	Esquire	NNP
18637	15958	34	Magazine	Magazine	NNP
18637	15958	35	on	on	IN
18637	15958	36	the	the	DT
18637	15958	37	ground	ground	NN
18637	15958	38	that	that	IN
18637	15958	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15958	40	did	do	VBD
18637	15958	41	not	not	RB
18637	15958	42	"	"	``
18637	15958	43	contribute	contribute	VB
18637	15958	44	to	to	IN
18637	15958	45	the	the	DT
18637	15958	46	public	public	JJ
18637	15958	47	good	good	NN
18637	15958	48	and	and	CC
18637	15958	49	the	the	DT
18637	15958	50	public	public	JJ
18637	15958	51	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	15958	52	.	.	.
18637	15958	53	"	"	''
18637	15959	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	15959	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15959	3	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	15959	4	for	for	IN
18637	15959	5	the	the	DT
18637	15959	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15959	7	:	:	:
18637	15959	8	"	"	``
18637	15959	9	*	*	NFP
18637	15959	10	*	*	NFP
18637	15959	11	*	*	NFP
18637	15959	12	a	a	DT
18637	15959	13	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	15959	14	that	that	IN
18637	15959	15	literature	literature	NN
18637	15959	16	or	or	CC
18637	15959	17	art	art	NN
18637	15959	18	conform	conform	VB
18637	15959	19	to	to	IN
18637	15959	20	some	some	DT
18637	15959	21	norm	norm	NN
18637	15959	22	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	15959	23	by	by	IN
18637	15959	24	an	an	DT
18637	15959	25	official	official	JJ
18637	15959	26	smacks	smack	NNS
18637	15959	27	of	of	IN
18637	15959	28	an	an	DT
18637	15959	29	ideology	ideology	NN
18637	15959	30	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	15959	31	to	to	IN
18637	15959	32	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15959	33	system	system	NN
18637	15959	34	.	.	.
18637	15960	1	The	the	DT
18637	15960	2	basic	basic	JJ
18637	15960	3	values	value	NNS
18637	15960	4	implicit	implicit	JJ
18637	15960	5	in	in	IN
18637	15960	6	the	the	DT
18637	15960	7	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	15960	8	of	of	IN
18637	15960	9	the	the	DT
18637	15960	10	Fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	15960	11	condition	condition	NN
18637	15960	12	can	can	MD
18637	15960	13	be	be	VB
18637	15960	14	served	serve	VBN
18637	15960	15	only	only	RB
18637	15960	16	by	by	IN
18637	15960	17	uncensored	uncensored	JJ
18637	15960	18	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	15960	19	of	of	IN
18637	15960	20	literature	literature	NN
18637	15960	21	.	.	.
18637	15961	1	From	from	IN
18637	15961	2	the	the	DT
18637	15961	3	multitude	multitude	NN
18637	15961	4	of	of	IN
18637	15961	5	competing	compete	VBG
18637	15961	6	offerings	offering	NNS
18637	15961	7	the	the	DT
18637	15961	8	public	public	NN
18637	15961	9	will	will	MD
18637	15961	10	pick	pick	VB
18637	15961	11	and	and	CC
18637	15961	12	choose	choose	VB
18637	15961	13	.	.	.
18637	15962	1	What	what	WP
18637	15962	2	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	15962	3	to	to	IN
18637	15962	4	one	one	CD
18637	15962	5	to	to	TO
18637	15962	6	be	be	VB
18637	15962	7	trash	trash	NN
18637	15962	8	may	may	MD
18637	15962	9	have	have	VB
18637	15962	10	for	for	IN
18637	15962	11	others	other	NNS
18637	15962	12	fleeting	fleeting	JJ
18637	15962	13	or	or	CC
18637	15962	14	even	even	RB
18637	15962	15	enduring	endure	VBG
18637	15962	16	values	value	NNS
18637	15962	17	.	.	.
18637	15963	1	But	but	CC
18637	15963	2	to	to	TO
18637	15963	3	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	15963	4	the	the	DT
18637	15963	5	second	second	JJ
18637	15963	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	15963	7	class	class	NN
18637	15963	8	rate	rate	NN
18637	15963	9	from	from	IN
18637	15963	10	this	this	DT
18637	15963	11	publication	publication	NN
18637	15963	12	today	today	NN
18637	15963	13	because	because	IN
18637	15963	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15963	15	contents	content	NNS
18637	15963	16	seemed	seem	VBD
18637	15963	17	to	to	IN
18637	15963	18	one	one	CD
18637	15963	19	official	official	NN
18637	15963	20	not	not	RB
18637	15963	21	good	good	JJ
18637	15963	22	for	for	IN
18637	15963	23	the	the	DT
18637	15963	24	public	public	NN
18637	15963	25	would	would	MD
18637	15963	26	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	15963	27	withdrawal	withdrawal	NN
18637	15963	28	of	of	IN
18637	15963	29	the	the	DT
18637	15963	30	second	second	JJ
18637	15963	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	15963	32	class	class	NN
18637	15963	33	rate	rate	NN
18637	15963	34	tomorrow	tomorrow	NN
18637	15963	35	from	from	IN
18637	15963	36	another	another	DT
18637	15963	37	periodical	periodical	JJ
18637	15963	38	whose	whose	WP$
18637	15963	39	social	social	JJ
18637	15963	40	or	or	CC
18637	15963	41	economic	economic	JJ
18637	15963	42	views	view	NNS
18637	15963	43	seemed	seem	VBD
18637	15963	44	harmful	harmful	JJ
18637	15963	45	to	to	IN
18637	15963	46	another	another	DT
18637	15963	47	official	official	NN
18637	15963	48	.	.	.
18637	15964	1	The	the	DT
18637	15964	2	validity	validity	NN
18637	15964	3	of	of	IN
18637	15964	4	the	the	DT
18637	15964	5	obscenity	obscenity	NN
18637	15964	6	laws	law	NNS
18637	15964	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	15964	8	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	15964	9	that	that	IN
18637	15964	10	the	the	DT
18637	15964	11	mails	mail	NNS
18637	15964	12	may	may	MD
18637	15964	13	not	not	RB
18637	15964	14	be	be	VB
18637	15964	15	used	use	VBN
18637	15964	16	to	to	TO
18637	15964	17	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	15964	18	all	all	DT
18637	15964	19	tastes	taste	NNS
18637	15964	20	,	,	,
18637	15964	21	no	no	RB
18637	15964	22	matter	matter	RB
18637	15964	23	how	how	WRB
18637	15964	24	perverted	perverted	JJ
18637	15964	25	.	.	.
18637	15965	1	But	but	CC
18637	15965	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15965	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	15965	4	left	leave	VBN
18637	15965	5	the	the	DT
18637	15965	6	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
18637	15965	7	General	General	NNP
18637	15965	8	with	with	IN
18637	15965	9	no	no	DT
18637	15965	10	power	power	NN
18637	15965	11	to	to	TO
18637	15965	12	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	15965	13	standards	standard	NNS
18637	15965	14	for	for	IN
18637	15965	15	the	the	DT
18637	15965	16	literature	literature	NN
18637	15965	17	or	or	CC
18637	15965	18	the	the	DT
18637	15965	19	art	art	NN
18637	15965	20	which	which	WDT
18637	15965	21	a	a	DT
18637	15965	22	mailable	mailable	JJ
18637	15965	23	periodical	periodical	JJ
18637	15965	24	disseminates	disseminate	NNS
18637	15965	25	.	.	.
18637	15966	1	"	"	``
18637	15966	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15966	3	241	241	CD
18637	15966	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15966	5	In	in	IN
18637	15966	6	Donaldson	Donaldson	NNP
18637	15966	7	_	_	NNP
18637	15966	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	15966	9	_	_	NNP
18637	15966	10	Read	Read	NNP
18637	15966	11	Magazine,[242	Magazine,[242	NNP
18637	15966	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15966	13	however	however	RB
18637	15966	14	,	,	,
18637	15966	15	the	the	DT
18637	15966	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15966	17	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	15966	18	a	a	DT
18637	15966	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15966	20	order	order	NN
18637	15966	21	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	15966	22	the	the	DT
18637	15966	23	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	15966	24	of	of	IN
18637	15966	25	mail	mail	NN
18637	15966	26	and	and	CC
18637	15966	27	money	money	NN
18637	15966	28	orders	order	NNS
18637	15966	29	to	to	IN
18637	15966	30	a	a	DT
18637	15966	31	magazine	magazine	NN
18637	15966	32	conducting	conduct	VBG
18637	15966	33	a	a	DT
18637	15966	34	puzzle	puzzle	NN
18637	15966	35	contest	contest	NN
18637	15966	36	which	which	WDT
18637	15966	37	the	the	DT
18637	15966	38	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
18637	15966	39	-	-	HYPH
18637	15966	40	General	General	NNP
18637	15966	41	had	have	VBD
18637	15966	42	found	find	VBN
18637	15966	43	to	to	TO
18637	15966	44	be	be	VB
18637	15966	45	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	15966	46	.	.	.
18637	15967	1	Freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15967	2	of	of	IN
18637	15967	3	the	the	DT
18637	15967	4	press	press	NN
18637	15967	5	,	,	,
18637	15967	6	said	say	VBD
18637	15967	7	the	the	DT
18637	15967	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15967	9	,	,	,
18637	15967	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	15967	11	not	not	RB
18637	15967	12	include	include	VB
18637	15967	13	the	the	DT
18637	15967	14	right	right	NN
18637	15967	15	to	to	TO
18637	15967	16	raise	raise	VB
18637	15967	17	money	money	NN
18637	15967	18	by	by	IN
18637	15967	19	deception	deception	NN
18637	15967	20	of	of	IN
18637	15967	21	the	the	DT
18637	15967	22	public	public	NN
18637	15967	23	.	.	.
18637	15968	1	The	the	DT
18637	15968	2	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	15968	3	of	of	IN
18637	15968	4	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
18637	15968	5	and	and	CC
18637	15968	6	Petition	Petition	NNP
18637	15968	7	The	the	DT
18637	15968	8	right	right	NN
18637	15968	9	of	of	IN
18637	15968	10	petition	petition	NN
18637	15968	11	took	take	VBD
18637	15968	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15968	13	rise	rise	NN
18637	15968	14	from	from	IN
18637	15968	15	the	the	DT
18637	15968	16	modest	modest	JJ
18637	15968	17	provision	provision	NN
18637	15968	18	made	make	VBN
18637	15968	19	for	for	IN
18637	15968	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15968	21	in	in	IN
18637	15968	22	chapter	chapter	NN
18637	15968	23	61	61	CD
18637	15968	24	of	of	IN
18637	15968	25	Magna	Magna	NNP
18637	15968	26	Carta	Carta	NNP
18637	15968	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	15968	28	1215	1215	CD
18637	15968	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	15968	30	.	.	.
18637	15969	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15969	2	243	243	CD
18637	15969	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15969	4	To	to	IN
18637	15969	5	this	this	DT
18637	15969	6	meagre	meagre	NN
18637	15969	7	beginning	begin	VBG
18637	15969	8	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
18637	15969	9	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15969	10	and	and	CC
18637	15969	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15969	12	procedures	procedure	NNS
18637	15969	13	in	in	IN
18637	15969	14	the	the	DT
18637	15969	15	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	15969	16	of	of	IN
18637	15969	17	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15969	18	,	,	,
18637	15969	19	the	the	DT
18637	15969	20	equity	equity	NN
18637	15969	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	15969	22	of	of	IN
18637	15969	23	the	the	DT
18637	15969	24	Lord	Lord	NNP
18637	15969	25	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
18637	15969	26	,	,	,
18637	15969	27	and	and	CC
18637	15969	28	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	15969	29	against	against	IN
18637	15969	30	the	the	DT
18637	15969	31	Crown	Crown	NNP
18637	15969	32	by	by	IN
18637	15969	33	"	"	``
18637	15969	34	petition	petition	NN
18637	15969	35	of	of	IN
18637	15969	36	right	right	NN
18637	15969	37	"	"	''
18637	15969	38	are	be	VBP
18637	15969	39	all	all	DT
18637	15969	40	in	in	IN
18637	15969	41	some	some	DT
18637	15969	42	measure	measure	NN
18637	15969	43	traceable	traceable	JJ
18637	15969	44	.	.	.
18637	15970	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	15970	2	,	,	,
18637	15970	3	while	while	IN
18637	15970	4	the	the	DT
18637	15970	5	King	King	NNP
18637	15970	6	summoned	summon	VBD
18637	15970	7	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
18637	15970	8	for	for	IN
18637	15970	9	the	the	DT
18637	15970	10	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15970	11	of	of	IN
18637	15970	12	supply	supply	NN
18637	15970	13	,	,	,
18637	15970	14	the	the	DT
18637	15970	15	latter	latter	JJ
18637	15970	16	--	--	:
18637	15970	17	but	but	CC
18637	15970	18	especially	especially	RB
18637	15970	19	the	the	DT
18637	15970	20	House	House	NNP
18637	15970	21	of	of	IN
18637	15970	22	Commons	Commons	NNPS
18637	15970	23	--	--	:
18637	15970	24	petitioned	petition	VBD
18637	15970	25	the	the	DT
18637	15970	26	King	King	NNP
18637	15970	27	for	for	IN
18637	15970	28	a	a	DT
18637	15970	29	redress	redress	NN
18637	15970	30	of	of	IN
18637	15970	31	grievances	grievance	NNS
18637	15970	32	as	as	IN
18637	15970	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15970	34	price	price	NN
18637	15970	35	for	for	IN
18637	15970	36	meeting	meet	VBG
18637	15970	37	the	the	DT
18637	15970	38	financial	financial	JJ
18637	15970	39	needs	need	NNS
18637	15970	40	of	of	IN
18637	15970	41	the	the	DT
18637	15970	42	Monarch	Monarch	NNP
18637	15970	43	;	;	:
18637	15970	44	and	and	CC
18637	15970	45	as	as	IN
18637	15970	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15970	47	increased	increase	VBD
18637	15970	48	in	in	IN
18637	15970	49	importance	importance	NN
18637	15970	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15970	51	came	come	VBD
18637	15970	52	to	to	TO
18637	15970	53	claim	claim	VB
18637	15970	54	the	the	DT
18637	15970	55	right	right	NN
18637	15970	56	to	to	TO
18637	15970	57	dictate	dictate	VB
18637	15970	58	the	the	DT
18637	15970	59	form	form	NN
18637	15970	60	of	of	IN
18637	15970	61	the	the	DT
18637	15970	62	King	King	NNP
18637	15970	63	's	's	POS
18637	15970	64	reply	reply	NN
18637	15970	65	,	,	,
18637	15970	66	until	until	IN
18637	15970	67	in	in	IN
18637	15970	68	1414	1414	CD
18637	15970	69	Commons	Commons	NNPS
18637	15970	70	boldly	boldly	RB
18637	15970	71	declared	declare	VBD
18637	15970	72	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15970	73	to	to	TO
18637	15970	74	be	be	VB
18637	15970	75	"	"	``
18637	15970	76	as	as	RB
18637	15970	77	well	well	RB
18637	15970	78	assenters	assenter	NNS
18637	15970	79	as	as	IN
18637	15970	80	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	15970	81	.	.	.
18637	15970	82	"	"	''
18637	15971	1	Two	two	CD
18637	15971	2	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	15971	3	and	and	CC
18637	15971	4	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	15971	5	years	year	NNS
18637	15971	6	later	later	RB
18637	15971	7	,	,	,
18637	15971	8	in	in	IN
18637	15971	9	1669	1669	CD
18637	15971	10	,	,	,
18637	15971	11	Commons	Commons	NNP
18637	15971	12	further	further	RB
18637	15971	13	resolved	resolve	VBD
18637	15971	14	that	that	IN
18637	15971	15	every	every	DT
18637	15971	16	commoner	commoner	NN
18637	15971	17	in	in	IN
18637	15971	18	England	England	NNP
18637	15971	19	possessed	possess	VBD
18637	15971	20	"	"	``
18637	15971	21	the	the	DT
18637	15971	22	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	15971	23	right	right	NN
18637	15971	24	to	to	TO
18637	15971	25	prepare	prepare	VB
18637	15971	26	and	and	CC
18637	15971	27	present	present	VB
18637	15971	28	petitions	petition	NNS
18637	15971	29	"	"	''
18637	15971	30	to	to	IN
18637	15971	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15971	32	"	"	''
18637	15971	33	in	in	IN
18637	15971	34	case	case	NN
18637	15971	35	of	of	IN
18637	15971	36	grievance	grievance	NN
18637	15971	37	,	,	,
18637	15971	38	"	"	''
18637	15971	39	and	and	CC
18637	15971	40	of	of	IN
18637	15971	41	Commons	Commons	NNP
18637	15971	42	"	"	''
18637	15971	43	to	to	TO
18637	15971	44	receive	receive	VB
18637	15971	45	the	the	DT
18637	15971	46	same	same	JJ
18637	15971	47	"	"	''
18637	15971	48	and	and	CC
18637	15971	49	to	to	TO
18637	15971	50	judge	judge	VB
18637	15971	51	whether	whether	IN
18637	15971	52	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15971	53	were	be	VBD
18637	15971	54	"	"	``
18637	15971	55	fit	fit	JJ
18637	15971	56	"	"	''
18637	15971	57	to	to	TO
18637	15971	58	be	be	VB
18637	15971	59	received	receive	VBN
18637	15971	60	.	.	.
18637	15972	1	Finally	finally	RB
18637	15972	2	Chapter	Chapter	NNP
18637	15972	3	5	5	CD
18637	15972	4	of	of	IN
18637	15972	5	the	the	DT
18637	15972	6	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	15972	7	of	of	IN
18637	15972	8	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	15972	9	of	of	IN
18637	15972	10	1689	1689	CD
18637	15972	11	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	15972	12	the	the	DT
18637	15972	13	right	right	NN
18637	15972	14	of	of	IN
18637	15972	15	the	the	DT
18637	15972	16	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	15972	17	to	to	TO
18637	15972	18	petition	petition	VB
18637	15972	19	the	the	DT
18637	15972	20	King	King	NNP
18637	15972	21	and	and	CC
18637	15972	22	"	"	``
18637	15972	23	all	all	DT
18637	15972	24	commitments	commitment	NNS
18637	15972	25	and	and	CC
18637	15972	26	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	15972	27	for	for	IN
18637	15972	28	such	such	JJ
18637	15972	29	petitioning	petitioning	NN
18637	15972	30	to	to	TO
18637	15972	31	be	be	VB
18637	15972	32	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	15972	33	.	.	.
18637	15973	1	"	"	``
18637	15973	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15973	3	244	244	CD
18637	15973	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15973	5	Historically	historically	RB
18637	15973	6	,	,	,
18637	15973	7	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	15973	8	,	,	,
18637	15973	9	the	the	DT
18637	15973	10	right	right	NN
18637	15973	11	of	of	IN
18637	15973	12	petition	petition	NN
18637	15973	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	15973	14	the	the	DT
18637	15973	15	primary	primary	JJ
18637	15973	16	right	right	NN
18637	15973	17	,	,	,
18637	15973	18	the	the	DT
18637	15973	19	right	right	NN
18637	15973	20	peaceably	peaceably	RB
18637	15973	21	to	to	TO
18637	15973	22	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	15973	23	a	a	DT
18637	15973	24	subordinate	subordinate	JJ
18637	15973	25	and	and	CC
18637	15973	26	instrumental	instrumental	JJ
18637	15973	27	right	right	NN
18637	15973	28	,	,	,
18637	15973	29	as	as	IN
18637	15973	30	if	if	IN
18637	15973	31	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15973	32	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15973	33	read	read	VBD
18637	15973	34	;	;	:
18637	15973	35	"	"	``
18637	15973	36	the	the	DT
18637	15973	37	right	right	NN
18637	15973	38	of	of	IN
18637	15973	39	the	the	DT
18637	15973	40	people	people	NNS
18637	15973	41	peaceably	peaceably	RB
18637	15973	42	to	to	TO
18637	15973	43	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	15973	44	"	"	``
18637	15973	45	_	_	NNP
18637	15973	46	in	in	IN
18637	15973	47	order	order	NN
18637	15973	48	to	to	IN
18637	15973	49	_	_	NNP
18637	15973	50	"	"	''
18637	15973	51	petition	petition	VB
18637	15973	52	the	the	DT
18637	15973	53	government	government	NN
18637	15973	54	.	.	.
18637	15974	1	"	"	``
18637	15974	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15974	3	245	245	CD
18637	15974	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15974	5	Today	today	NN
18637	15974	6	,	,	,
18637	15974	7	however	however	RB
18637	15974	8	,	,	,
18637	15974	9	the	the	DT
18637	15974	10	right	right	NN
18637	15974	11	of	of	IN
18637	15974	12	peaceable	peaceable	JJ
18637	15974	13	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	15974	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	15974	15	,	,	,
18637	15974	16	in	in	IN
18637	15974	17	the	the	DT
18637	15974	18	language	language	NN
18637	15974	19	of	of	IN
18637	15974	20	the	the	DT
18637	15974	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15974	22	,	,	,
18637	15974	23	"	"	''
18637	15974	24	cognate	cognate	VBP
18637	15974	25	to	to	IN
18637	15974	26	those	those	DT
18637	15974	27	of	of	IN
18637	15974	28	free	free	JJ
18637	15974	29	speech	speech	NN
18637	15974	30	and	and	CC
18637	15974	31	free	free	JJ
18637	15974	32	press	press	NN
18637	15974	33	and	and	CC
18637	15974	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	15974	35	equally	equally	RB
18637	15974	36	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	15974	37	*	*	NFP
18637	15974	38	*	*	NFP
18637	15974	39	*	*	NFP
18637	15974	40	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15974	41	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15974	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15974	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	15974	44	one	one	CD
18637	15974	45	that	that	WDT
18637	15974	46	can	can	MD
18637	15974	47	not	not	RB
18637	15974	48	be	be	VB
18637	15974	49	denied	deny	VBN
18637	15974	50	without	without	IN
18637	15974	51	violating	violate	VBG
18637	15974	52	those	those	DT
18637	15974	53	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	15974	54	principles	principle	NNS
18637	15974	55	of	of	IN
18637	15974	56	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	15974	57	and	and	CC
18637	15974	58	justice	justice	NN
18637	15974	59	which	which	WDT
18637	15974	60	lie	lie	VBP
18637	15974	61	at	at	IN
18637	15974	62	the	the	DT
18637	15974	63	base	base	NN
18637	15974	64	of	of	IN
18637	15974	65	all	all	DT
18637	15974	66	civil	civil	JJ
18637	15974	67	and	and	CC
18637	15974	68	political	political	JJ
18637	15974	69	institutions,--principles	institutions,--principles	NNP
18637	15974	70	which	which	WDT
18637	15974	71	the	the	DT
18637	15974	72	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	15974	73	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15974	74	embodies	embody	VBZ
18637	15974	75	in	in	IN
18637	15974	76	the	the	DT
18637	15974	77	general	general	JJ
18637	15974	78	terms	term	NNS
18637	15974	79	of	of	IN
18637	15974	80	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15974	81	due	due	JJ
18637	15974	82	process	process	NN
18637	15974	83	clause	clause	NN
18637	15974	84	.	.	.
18637	15975	1	*	*	NFP
18637	15975	2	*	*	NFP
18637	15975	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15975	4	The	the	DT
18637	15975	5	holding	holding	NN
18637	15975	6	of	of	IN
18637	15975	7	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	15975	8	for	for	IN
18637	15975	9	peaceable	peaceable	JJ
18637	15975	10	political	political	JJ
18637	15975	11	action	action	NN
18637	15975	12	can	can	MD
18637	15975	13	not	not	RB
18637	15975	14	be	be	VB
18637	15975	15	proscribed	proscribe	VBN
18637	15975	16	.	.	.
18637	15976	1	Those	those	DT
18637	15976	2	who	who	WP
18637	15976	3	assist	assist	VBP
18637	15976	4	in	in	IN
18637	15976	5	the	the	DT
18637	15976	6	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	15976	7	of	of	IN
18637	15976	8	such	such	JJ
18637	15976	9	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	15976	10	can	can	MD
18637	15976	11	not	not	RB
18637	15976	12	be	be	VB
18637	15976	13	branded	brand	VBN
18637	15976	14	as	as	IN
18637	15976	15	criminals	criminal	NNS
18637	15976	16	on	on	IN
18637	15976	17	that	that	DT
18637	15976	18	score	score	NN
18637	15976	19	.	.	.
18637	15977	1	The	the	DT
18637	15977	2	question	question	NN
18637	15977	3	*	*	NFP
18637	15977	4	*	*	NFP
18637	15977	5	*	*	NFP
18637	15977	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	15977	7	not	not	RB
18637	15977	8	as	as	IN
18637	15977	9	to	to	IN
18637	15977	10	the	the	DT
18637	15977	11	auspices	auspex	NNS
18637	15977	12	under	under	IN
18637	15977	13	which	which	WDT
18637	15977	14	the	the	DT
18637	15977	15	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	15977	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	15977	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	15977	18	but	but	CC
18637	15977	19	as	as	IN
18637	15977	20	to	to	IN
18637	15977	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15977	22	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	15977	23	;	;	:
18637	15977	24	not	not	RB
18637	15977	25	as	as	IN
18637	15977	26	to	to	IN
18637	15977	27	the	the	DT
18637	15977	28	relation	relation	NN
18637	15977	29	of	of	IN
18637	15977	30	the	the	DT
18637	15977	31	speakers	speaker	NNS
18637	15977	32	,	,	,
18637	15977	33	but	but	CC
18637	15977	34	whether	whether	IN
18637	15977	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15977	36	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	15977	37	transcend	transcend	VBP
18637	15977	38	the	the	DT
18637	15977	39	bounds	bound	NNS
18637	15977	40	of	of	IN
18637	15977	41	the	the	DT
18637	15977	42	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	15977	43	of	of	IN
18637	15977	44	speech	speech	NN
18637	15977	45	which	which	WDT
18637	15977	46	the	the	DT
18637	15977	47	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15977	48	protects	protect	VBZ
18637	15977	49	.	.	.
18637	15978	1	"	"	``
18637	15978	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15978	3	246	246	CD
18637	15978	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15978	5	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	15978	6	,	,	,
18637	15978	7	the	the	DT
18637	15978	8	right	right	NN
18637	15978	9	of	of	IN
18637	15978	10	petition	petition	NN
18637	15978	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	15978	12	expanded	expand	VBN
18637	15978	13	.	.	.
18637	15979	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15979	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	15979	3	no	no	RB
18637	15979	4	longer	long	RBR
18637	15979	5	confined	confine	VBN
18637	15979	6	to	to	IN
18637	15979	7	demands	demand	NNS
18637	15979	8	for	for	IN
18637	15979	9	"	"	``
18637	15979	10	a	a	DT
18637	15979	11	redress	redress	NN
18637	15979	12	of	of	IN
18637	15979	13	grievances	grievance	NNS
18637	15979	14	,	,	,
18637	15979	15	"	"	''
18637	15979	16	in	in	IN
18637	15979	17	any	any	DT
18637	15979	18	accurate	accurate	JJ
18637	15979	19	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	15979	20	of	of	IN
18637	15979	21	these	these	DT
18637	15979	22	words	word	NNS
18637	15979	23	,	,	,
18637	15979	24	but	but	CC
18637	15979	25	comprehends	comprehend	VBZ
18637	15979	26	demands	demand	NNS
18637	15979	27	for	for	IN
18637	15979	28	an	an	DT
18637	15979	29	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15979	30	by	by	IN
18637	15979	31	the	the	DT
18637	15979	32	government	government	NN
18637	15979	33	of	of	IN
18637	15979	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15979	35	powers	power	NNS
18637	15979	36	in	in	IN
18637	15979	37	furtherance	furtherance	NN
18637	15979	38	of	of	IN
18637	15979	39	the	the	DT
18637	15979	40	interests	interest	NNS
18637	15979	41	and	and	CC
18637	15979	42	prosperity	prosperity	NN
18637	15979	43	of	of	IN
18637	15979	44	the	the	DT
18637	15979	45	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	15979	46	,	,	,
18637	15979	47	and	and	CC
18637	15979	48	of	of	IN
18637	15979	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15979	50	views	view	NNS
18637	15979	51	on	on	IN
18637	15979	52	politically	politically	RB
18637	15979	53	contentious	contentious	JJ
18637	15979	54	matters	matter	NNS
18637	15979	55	.	.	.
18637	15980	1	RESTRAINTS	restraint	NNS
18637	15980	2	ON	on	IN
18637	15980	3	THE	the	DT
18637	15980	4	RIGHT	right	NN
18637	15980	5	OF	of	IN
18637	15980	6	PETITION	petition	NN
18637	15980	7	The	the	DT
18637	15980	8	right	right	NN
18637	15980	9	of	of	IN
18637	15980	10	petition	petition	NN
18637	15980	11	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	15980	12	by	by	IN
18637	15980	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	15980	14	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15980	15	first	first	RB
18637	15980	16	came	come	VBD
18637	15980	17	into	into	IN
18637	15980	18	prominence	prominence	NN
18637	15980	19	in	in	IN
18637	15980	20	the	the	DT
18637	15980	21	early	early	JJ
18637	15980	22	1830	1830	CD
18637	15980	23	's	's	POS
18637	15980	24	,	,	,
18637	15980	25	when	when	WRB
18637	15980	26	petitions	petition	NNS
18637	15980	27	against	against	IN
18637	15980	28	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	15980	29	in	in	IN
18637	15980	30	the	the	DT
18637	15980	31	District	District	NNP
18637	15980	32	of	of	IN
18637	15980	33	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	15980	34	began	begin	VBD
18637	15980	35	flowing	flow	VBG
18637	15980	36	into	into	IN
18637	15980	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15980	38	in	in	IN
18637	15980	39	a	a	DT
18637	15980	40	constantly	constantly	RB
18637	15980	41	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	15980	42	stream	stream	NN
18637	15980	43	,	,	,
18637	15980	44	which	which	WDT
18637	15980	45	reached	reach	VBD
18637	15980	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15980	47	climax	climax	NN
18637	15980	48	in	in	IN
18637	15980	49	the	the	DT
18637	15980	50	winter	winter	NN
18637	15980	51	of	of	IN
18637	15980	52	1835	1835	CD
18637	15980	53	.	.	.
18637	15981	1	Finally	finally	RB
18637	15981	2	on	on	IN
18637	15981	3	January	January	NNP
18637	15981	4	28	28	CD
18637	15981	5	,	,	,
18637	15981	6	1840	1840	CD
18637	15981	7	,	,	,
18637	15981	8	the	the	DT
18637	15981	9	House	House	NNP
18637	15981	10	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	15981	11	as	as	IN
18637	15981	12	a	a	DT
18637	15981	13	standing	standing	NN
18637	15981	14	rule	rule	NN
18637	15981	15	:	:	:
18637	15981	16	"	"	``
18637	15981	17	That	that	IN
18637	15981	18	no	no	DT
18637	15981	19	petition	petition	NN
18637	15981	20	,	,	,
18637	15981	21	memorial	memorial	NN
18637	15981	22	,	,	,
18637	15981	23	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	15981	24	,	,	,
18637	15981	25	or	or	CC
18637	15981	26	other	other	JJ
18637	15981	27	paper	paper	NN
18637	15981	28	praying	pray	VBG
18637	15981	29	the	the	DT
18637	15981	30	abolition	abolition	NN
18637	15981	31	of	of	IN
18637	15981	32	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	15981	33	in	in	IN
18637	15981	34	the	the	DT
18637	15981	35	District	District	NNP
18637	15981	36	of	of	IN
18637	15981	37	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	15981	38	,	,	,
18637	15981	39	or	or	CC
18637	15981	40	any	any	DT
18637	15981	41	State	State	NNP
18637	15981	42	or	or	CC
18637	15981	43	Territories	Territories	NNPS
18637	15981	44	of	of	IN
18637	15981	45	the	the	DT
18637	15981	46	United	United	NNP
18637	15981	47	States	States	NNP
18637	15981	48	in	in	IN
18637	15981	49	which	which	WDT
18637	15981	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15981	51	now	now	RB
18637	15981	52	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	15981	53	,	,	,
18637	15981	54	shall	shall	MD
18637	15981	55	be	be	VB
18637	15981	56	received	receive	VBN
18637	15981	57	by	by	IN
18637	15981	58	this	this	DT
18637	15981	59	House	House	NNP
18637	15981	60	,	,	,
18637	15981	61	or	or	CC
18637	15981	62	entertained	entertain	VBD
18637	15981	63	in	in	IN
18637	15981	64	any	any	DT
18637	15981	65	way	way	NN
18637	15981	66	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	15981	67	.	.	.
18637	15981	68	"	"	''
18637	15982	1	Thanks	thank	NNS
18637	15982	2	to	to	IN
18637	15982	3	the	the	DT
18637	15982	4	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	15982	5	of	of	IN
18637	15982	6	John	John	NNP
18637	15982	7	Quincy	Quincy	NNP
18637	15982	8	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	15982	9	this	this	DT
18637	15982	10	rule	rule	NN
18637	15982	11	was	be	VBD
18637	15982	12	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	15982	13	five	five	CD
18637	15982	14	years	year	NNS
18637	15982	15	later	later	RB
18637	15982	16	,	,	,
18637	15982	17	after	after	IN
18637	15982	18	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	15982	19	'	'	POS
18637	15982	20	death	death	NN
18637	15982	21	.	.	.
18637	15983	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15983	2	247	247	CD
18637	15983	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15983	4	For	for	IN
18637	15983	5	many	many	JJ
18637	15983	6	years	year	NNS
18637	15983	7	now	now	RB
18637	15983	8	the	the	DT
18637	15983	9	rules	rule	NNS
18637	15983	10	of	of	IN
18637	15983	11	the	the	DT
18637	15983	12	House	House	NNP
18637	15983	13	of	of	IN
18637	15983	14	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	15983	15	have	have	VBP
18637	15983	16	provided	provide	VBN
18637	15983	17	that	that	IN
18637	15983	18	members	member	NNS
18637	15983	19	having	have	VBG
18637	15983	20	petitions	petition	NNS
18637	15983	21	to	to	TO
18637	15983	22	present	present	VB
18637	15983	23	may	may	MD
18637	15983	24	deliver	deliver	VB
18637	15983	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15983	26	to	to	IN
18637	15983	27	the	the	DT
18637	15983	28	Clerk	Clerk	NNP
18637	15983	29	and	and	CC
18637	15983	30	the	the	DT
18637	15983	31	petitions	petition	NNS
18637	15983	32	,	,	,
18637	15983	33	except	except	IN
18637	15983	34	such	such	JJ
18637	15983	35	as	as	IN
18637	15983	36	,	,	,
18637	15983	37	in	in	IN
18637	15983	38	the	the	DT
18637	15983	39	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	15983	40	of	of	IN
18637	15983	41	the	the	DT
18637	15983	42	Speaker	Speaker	NNP
18637	15983	43	,	,	,
18637	15983	44	are	be	VBP
18637	15983	45	of	of	IN
18637	15983	46	an	an	DT
18637	15983	47	obscene	obscene	JJ
18637	15983	48	or	or	CC
18637	15983	49	insulting	insulting	JJ
18637	15983	50	character	character	NN
18637	15983	51	,	,	,
18637	15983	52	shall	shall	MD
18637	15983	53	be	be	VB
18637	15983	54	entered	enter	VBN
18637	15983	55	on	on	IN
18637	15983	56	the	the	DT
18637	15983	57	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	15983	58	and	and	CC
18637	15983	59	the	the	DT
18637	15983	60	Clerk	Clerk	NNP
18637	15983	61	shall	shall	MD
18637	15983	62	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	15983	63	a	a	DT
18637	15983	64	transcript	transcript	NN
18637	15983	65	of	of	IN
18637	15983	66	such	such	JJ
18637	15983	67	record	record	NN
18637	15983	68	to	to	IN
18637	15983	69	the	the	DT
18637	15983	70	official	official	JJ
18637	15983	71	reporters	reporter	NNS
18637	15983	72	of	of	IN
18637	15983	73	debates	debate	NNS
18637	15983	74	for	for	IN
18637	15983	75	publication	publication	NN
18637	15983	76	in	in	IN
18637	15983	77	the	the	DT
18637	15983	78	Record	Record	NNP
18637	15983	79	.	.	.
18637	15984	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15984	2	248	248	CD
18637	15984	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15984	4	Even	even	RB
18637	15984	5	so	so	RB
18637	15984	6	petitions	petition	NNS
18637	15984	7	for	for	IN
18637	15984	8	the	the	DT
18637	15984	9	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	15984	10	of	of	IN
18637	15984	11	the	the	DT
18637	15984	12	espionage	espionage	NN
18637	15984	13	and	and	CC
18637	15984	14	sedition	sedition	NN
18637	15984	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	15984	16	and	and	CC
18637	15984	17	against	against	IN
18637	15984	18	military	military	JJ
18637	15984	19	measures	measure	NNS
18637	15984	20	for	for	IN
18637	15984	21	recruiting	recruiting	NN
18637	15984	22	resulted	result	VBD
18637	15984	23	,	,	,
18637	15984	24	in	in	IN
18637	15984	25	World	World	NNP
18637	15984	26	War	War	NNP
18637	15984	27	I	I	NNP
18637	15984	28	,	,	,
18637	15984	29	in	in	IN
18637	15984	30	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	15984	31	.	.	.
18637	15985	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15985	2	249	249	CD
18637	15985	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15985	4	Processions	procession	NNS
18637	15985	5	for	for	IN
18637	15985	6	the	the	DT
18637	15985	7	presentation	presentation	NN
18637	15985	8	of	of	IN
18637	15985	9	petitions	petition	NNS
18637	15985	10	in	in	IN
18637	15985	11	the	the	DT
18637	15985	12	United	United	NNP
18637	15985	13	States	States	NNP
18637	15985	14	have	have	VBP
18637	15985	15	not	not	RB
18637	15985	16	been	be	VBN
18637	15985	17	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	15985	18	successful	successful	JJ
18637	15985	19	.	.	.
18637	15986	1	In	in	IN
18637	15986	2	1894	1894	CD
18637	15986	3	General	General	NNP
18637	15986	4	Coxey	Coxey	NNP
18637	15986	5	of	of	IN
18637	15986	6	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	15986	7	organized	organize	VBD
18637	15986	8	armies	army	NNS
18637	15986	9	of	of	IN
18637	15986	10	unemployed	unemployed	JJ
18637	15986	11	to	to	TO
18637	15986	12	march	march	NNP
18637	15986	13	on	on	IN
18637	15986	14	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	15986	15	and	and	CC
18637	15986	16	present	present	JJ
18637	15986	17	petitions	petition	NNS
18637	15986	18	,	,	,
18637	15986	19	only	only	RB
18637	15986	20	to	to	TO
18637	15986	21	see	see	VB
18637	15986	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15986	23	leaders	leader	NNS
18637	15986	24	arrested	arrest	VBN
18637	15986	25	for	for	IN
18637	15986	26	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	15986	27	walking	walk	VBG
18637	15986	28	on	on	IN
18637	15986	29	the	the	DT
18637	15986	30	grass	grass	NN
18637	15986	31	of	of	IN
18637	15986	32	the	the	DT
18637	15986	33	capitol	capitol	NN
18637	15986	34	.	.	.
18637	15987	1	The	the	DT
18637	15987	2	march	march	NN
18637	15987	3	of	of	IN
18637	15987	4	the	the	DT
18637	15987	5	veterans	veteran	NNS
18637	15987	6	on	on	IN
18637	15987	7	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	15987	8	in	in	IN
18637	15987	9	1932	1932	CD
18637	15987	10	demanding	demand	VBG
18637	15987	11	bonus	bonus	NN
18637	15987	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	15987	13	was	be	VBD
18637	15987	14	defended	defend	VBN
18637	15987	15	as	as	IN
18637	15987	16	an	an	DT
18637	15987	17	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15987	18	of	of	IN
18637	15987	19	the	the	DT
18637	15987	20	right	right	NN
18637	15987	21	of	of	IN
18637	15987	22	petition	petition	NN
18637	15987	23	.	.	.
18637	15988	1	The	the	DT
18637	15988	2	administration	administration	NN
18637	15988	3	,	,	,
18637	15988	4	however	however	RB
18637	15988	5	,	,	,
18637	15988	6	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	15988	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15988	8	as	as	IN
18637	15988	9	a	a	DT
18637	15988	10	threat	threat	NN
18637	15988	11	against	against	IN
18637	15988	12	the	the	DT
18637	15988	13	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	15988	14	and	and	CC
18637	15988	15	called	call	VBD
18637	15988	16	out	out	RP
18637	15988	17	the	the	DT
18637	15988	18	army	army	NN
18637	15988	19	to	to	TO
18637	15988	20	expel	expel	VB
18637	15988	21	the	the	DT
18637	15988	22	bonus	bonus	NN
18637	15988	23	marchers	marcher	NNS
18637	15988	24	and	and	CC
18637	15988	25	burn	burn	VB
18637	15988	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15988	27	camps	camp	NNS
18637	15988	28	.	.	.
18637	15989	1	For	for	IN
18637	15989	2	legal	legal	JJ
18637	15989	3	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	15989	4	of	of	IN
18637	15989	5	lobbying	lobbying	NN
18637	15989	6	activities	activity	NNS
18637	15989	7	,	,	,
18637	15989	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15989	9	see	see	VBP
18637	15989	10	_	_	NNP
18637	15989	11	below	below	RB
18637	15989	12	.	.	.
18637	15990	1	THE	the	DT
18637	15990	2	CRUIKSHANK	CRUIKSHANK	NNP
18637	15990	3	CASE	case	NN
18637	15990	4	The	the	DT
18637	15990	5	right	right	NN
18637	15990	6	of	of	IN
18637	15990	7	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	15990	8	was	be	VBD
18637	15990	9	first	first	RB
18637	15990	10	passed	pass	VBN
18637	15990	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	15990	12	by	by	IN
18637	15990	13	the	the	DT
18637	15990	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	15990	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15990	16	in	in	IN
18637	15990	17	1876	1876	CD
18637	15990	18	in	in	IN
18637	15990	19	the	the	DT
18637	15990	20	famous	famous	JJ
18637	15990	21	case	case	NN
18637	15990	22	of	of	IN
18637	15990	23	United	United	NNP
18637	15990	24	States	States	NNP
18637	15990	25	_	_	NNP
18637	15990	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	15990	27	_	_	NNP
18637	15990	28	Cruikshank	Cruikshank	NNP
18637	15990	29	et	et	NNP
18637	15990	30	al	al	NNP
18637	15990	31	.	.	.
18637	15991	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15991	2	250	250	CD
18637	15991	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15991	4	The	the	DT
18637	15991	5	case	case	NN
18637	15991	6	arose	arise	VBD
18637	15991	7	on	on	IN
18637	15991	8	indictments	indictment	NNS
18637	15991	9	under	under	IN
18637	15991	10	section	section	NN
18637	15991	11	6	6	CD
18637	15991	12	of	of	IN
18637	15991	13	the	the	DT
18637	15991	14	so	so	RB
18637	15991	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	15991	16	called	call	VBN
18637	15991	17	Enforcement	Enforcement	NNP
18637	15991	18	Act	Act	NNP
18637	15991	19	of	of	IN
18637	15991	20	May	May	NNP
18637	15991	21	30	30	CD
18637	15991	22	,	,	,
18637	15991	23	1870,[251	1870,[251	NN
18637	15991	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15991	25	which	which	WDT
18637	15991	26	read	read	VBD
18637	15991	27	as	as	IN
18637	15991	28	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	15991	29	:	:	:
18637	15991	30	"	"	``
18637	15991	31	That	that	IN
18637	15991	32	if	if	IN
18637	15991	33	two	two	CD
18637	15991	34	or	or	CC
18637	15991	35	more	more	JJR
18637	15991	36	persons	person	NNS
18637	15991	37	shall	shall	MD
18637	15991	38	band	band	VB
18637	15991	39	or	or	CC
18637	15991	40	conspire	conspire	VB
18637	15991	41	together	together	RB
18637	15991	42	,	,	,
18637	15991	43	or	or	CC
18637	15991	44	go	go	VB
18637	15991	45	in	in	IN
18637	15991	46	disguise	disguise	NN
18637	15991	47	upon	upon	IN
18637	15991	48	the	the	DT
18637	15991	49	public	public	JJ
18637	15991	50	highway	highway	NN
18637	15991	51	,	,	,
18637	15991	52	or	or	CC
18637	15991	53	upon	upon	IN
18637	15991	54	the	the	DT
18637	15991	55	premises	premise	NNS
18637	15991	56	of	of	IN
18637	15991	57	another	another	DT
18637	15991	58	,	,	,
18637	15991	59	with	with	IN
18637	15991	60	intent	intent	NN
18637	15991	61	to	to	TO
18637	15991	62	violate	violate	VB
18637	15991	63	any	any	DT
18637	15991	64	provision	provision	NN
18637	15991	65	of	of	IN
18637	15991	66	this	this	DT
18637	15991	67	act	act	NN
18637	15991	68	,	,	,
18637	15991	69	or	or	CC
18637	15991	70	to	to	TO
18637	15991	71	injure	injure	VB
18637	15991	72	,	,	,
18637	15991	73	oppress	oppress	NN
18637	15991	74	,	,	,
18637	15991	75	threaten	threaten	VB
18637	15991	76	,	,	,
18637	15991	77	or	or	CC
18637	15991	78	intimidate	intimidate	VBP
18637	15991	79	any	any	DT
18637	15991	80	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	15991	81	,	,	,
18637	15991	82	with	with	IN
18637	15991	83	intent	intent	NN
18637	15991	84	to	to	TO
18637	15991	85	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	15991	86	or	or	CC
18637	15991	87	hinder	hinder	VB
18637	15991	88	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15991	89	free	free	JJ
18637	15991	90	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	15991	91	and	and	CC
18637	15991	92	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	15991	93	of	of	IN
18637	15991	94	any	any	DT
18637	15991	95	right	right	NN
18637	15991	96	or	or	CC
18637	15991	97	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	15991	98	granted	grant	VBN
18637	15991	99	or	or	CC
18637	15991	100	secured	secure	VBN
18637	15991	101	to	to	IN
18637	15991	102	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15991	103	by	by	IN
18637	15991	104	the	the	DT
18637	15991	105	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	15991	106	or	or	CC
18637	15991	107	laws	law	NNS
18637	15991	108	of	of	IN
18637	15991	109	the	the	DT
18637	15991	110	United	United	NNP
18637	15991	111	States	States	NNP
18637	15991	112	,	,	,
18637	15991	113	or	or	CC
18637	15991	114	because	because	IN
18637	15991	115	of	of	IN
18637	15991	116	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15991	117	having	have	VBG
18637	15991	118	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	15991	119	the	the	DT
18637	15991	120	same	same	JJ
18637	15991	121	,	,	,
18637	15991	122	such	such	JJ
18637	15991	123	persons	person	NNS
18637	15991	124	shall	shall	MD
18637	15991	125	be	be	VB
18637	15991	126	held	hold	VBN
18637	15991	127	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	15991	128	of	of	IN
18637	15991	129	felony	felony	NN
18637	15991	130	,	,	,
18637	15991	131	etc	etc	FW
18637	15991	132	.	.	.
18637	15991	133	"	"	''
18637	15992	1	The	the	DT
18637	15992	2	indictments	indictment	NNS
18637	15992	3	charged	charge	VBD
18637	15992	4	the	the	DT
18637	15992	5	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	15992	6	with	with	IN
18637	15992	7	having	have	VBG
18637	15992	8	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	15992	9	certain	certain	JJ
18637	15992	10	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	15992	11	of	of	IN
18637	15992	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15992	13	right	right	NN
18637	15992	14	to	to	TO
18637	15992	15	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	15992	16	together	together	RB
18637	15992	17	peaceably	peaceably	RB
18637	15992	18	with	with	IN
18637	15992	19	other	other	JJ
18637	15992	20	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	15992	21	"	"	''
18637	15992	22	for	for	IN
18637	15992	23	a	a	DT
18637	15992	24	peaceful	peaceful	JJ
18637	15992	25	and	and	CC
18637	15992	26	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	15992	27	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15992	28	.	.	.
18637	15992	29	"	"	''
18637	15993	1	The	the	DT
18637	15993	2	court	court	NN
18637	15993	3	held	hold	VBD
18637	15993	4	that	that	IN
18637	15993	5	this	this	DT
18637	15993	6	language	language	NN
18637	15993	7	was	be	VBD
18637	15993	8	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	15993	9	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	15993	10	as	as	IN
18637	15993	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15993	12	did	do	VBD
18637	15993	13	not	not	RB
18637	15993	14	specify	specify	VB
18637	15993	15	that	that	IN
18637	15993	16	the	the	DT
18637	15993	17	attempted	attempt	VBN
18637	15993	18	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	15993	19	was	be	VBD
18637	15993	20	for	for	IN
18637	15993	21	a	a	DT
18637	15993	22	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15993	23	connected	connect	VBN
18637	15993	24	with	with	IN
18637	15993	25	the	the	DT
18637	15993	26	National	National	NNP
18637	15993	27	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15993	28	.	.	.
18637	15994	1	As	as	IN
18637	15994	2	to	to	IN
18637	15994	3	the	the	DT
18637	15994	4	right	right	NN
18637	15994	5	of	of	IN
18637	15994	6	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	15994	7	the	the	DT
18637	15994	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	15994	9	,	,	,
18637	15994	10	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	15994	11	by	by	IN
18637	15994	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	15994	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	15994	14	Waite	Waite	NNP
18637	15994	15	,	,	,
18637	15994	16	went	go	VBD
18637	15994	17	on	on	RP
18637	15994	18	to	to	TO
18637	15994	19	declare	declare	VB
18637	15994	20	:	:	:
18637	15994	21	"	"	``
18637	15994	22	The	the	DT
18637	15994	23	right	right	NN
18637	15994	24	of	of	IN
18637	15994	25	the	the	DT
18637	15994	26	people	people	NNS
18637	15994	27	peaceably	peaceably	RB
18637	15994	28	to	to	TO
18637	15994	29	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	15994	30	for	for	IN
18637	15994	31	the	the	DT
18637	15994	32	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15994	33	of	of	IN
18637	15994	34	petitioning	petition	VBG
18637	15994	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	15994	36	for	for	IN
18637	15994	37	a	a	DT
18637	15994	38	redress	redress	NN
18637	15994	39	of	of	IN
18637	15994	40	grievances	grievance	NNS
18637	15994	41	,	,	,
18637	15994	42	or	or	CC
18637	15994	43	for	for	IN
18637	15994	44	anything	anything	NN
18637	15994	45	else	else	RB
18637	15994	46	connected	connect	VBN
18637	15994	47	with	with	IN
18637	15994	48	the	the	DT
18637	15994	49	powers	power	NNS
18637	15994	50	or	or	CC
18637	15994	51	the	the	DT
18637	15994	52	duties	duty	NNS
18637	15994	53	of	of	IN
18637	15994	54	the	the	DT
18637	15994	55	National	National	NNP
18637	15994	56	Government	Government	NNP
18637	15994	57	,	,	,
18637	15994	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	15994	59	an	an	DT
18637	15994	60	attribute	attribute	NN
18637	15994	61	of	of	IN
18637	15994	62	national	national	JJ
18637	15994	63	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	15994	64	,	,	,
18637	15994	65	and	and	CC
18637	15994	66	,	,	,
18637	15994	67	as	as	IN
18637	15994	68	such	such	JJ
18637	15994	69	,	,	,
18637	15994	70	under	under	IN
18637	15994	71	the	the	DT
18637	15994	72	protection	protection	NN
18637	15994	73	of	of	IN
18637	15994	74	,	,	,
18637	15994	75	and	and	CC
18637	15994	76	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	15994	77	by	by	RB
18637	15994	78	,	,	,
18637	15994	79	the	the	DT
18637	15994	80	United	United	NNP
18637	15994	81	States	States	NNP
18637	15994	82	.	.	.
18637	15995	1	The	the	DT
18637	15995	2	very	very	JJ
18637	15995	3	idea	idea	NN
18637	15995	4	of	of	IN
18637	15995	5	a	a	DT
18637	15995	6	government	government	NN
18637	15995	7	,	,	,
18637	15995	8	republican	republican	JJ
18637	15995	9	in	in	IN
18637	15995	10	form	form	NN
18637	15995	11	,	,	,
18637	15995	12	implies	imply	VBZ
18637	15995	13	a	a	DT
18637	15995	14	right	right	NN
18637	15995	15	on	on	IN
18637	15995	16	the	the	DT
18637	15995	17	part	part	NN
18637	15995	18	of	of	IN
18637	15995	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	15995	20	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	15995	21	to	to	TO
18637	15995	22	meet	meet	VB
18637	15995	23	peaceably	peaceably	RB
18637	15995	24	for	for	IN
18637	15995	25	consultation	consultation	NN
18637	15995	26	in	in	IN
18637	15995	27	respect	respect	NN
18637	15995	28	to	to	IN
18637	15995	29	public	public	JJ
18637	15995	30	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	15995	31	and	and	CC
18637	15995	32	to	to	TO
18637	15995	33	petition	petition	VB
18637	15995	34	for	for	IN
18637	15995	35	a	a	DT
18637	15995	36	redress	redress	NN
18637	15995	37	of	of	IN
18637	15995	38	grievances	grievance	NNS
18637	15995	39	.	.	.
18637	15996	1	If	if	IN
18637	15996	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15996	3	had	have	VBD
18637	15996	4	been	be	VBN
18637	15996	5	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	15996	6	in	in	IN
18637	15996	7	these	these	DT
18637	15996	8	counts	count	NNS
18637	15996	9	that	that	IN
18637	15996	10	the	the	DT
18637	15996	11	object	object	NN
18637	15996	12	of	of	IN
18637	15996	13	the	the	DT
18637	15996	14	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	15996	15	was	be	VBD
18637	15996	16	to	to	TO
18637	15996	17	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	15996	18	a	a	DT
18637	15996	19	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	15996	20	for	for	IN
18637	15996	21	such	such	PDT
18637	15996	22	a	a	DT
18637	15996	23	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15996	24	,	,	,
18637	15996	25	the	the	DT
18637	15996	26	case	case	NN
18637	15996	27	would	would	MD
18637	15996	28	have	have	VB
18637	15996	29	been	be	VBN
18637	15996	30	within	within	IN
18637	15996	31	the	the	DT
18637	15996	32	statute	statute	NN
18637	15996	33	,	,	,
18637	15996	34	and	and	CC
18637	15996	35	within	within	IN
18637	15996	36	the	the	DT
18637	15996	37	scope	scope	NN
18637	15996	38	of	of	IN
18637	15996	39	the	the	DT
18637	15996	40	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	15996	41	of	of	IN
18637	15996	42	the	the	DT
18637	15996	43	United	United	NNP
18637	15996	44	States	States	NNP
18637	15996	45	.	.	.
18637	15997	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	15997	2	,	,	,
18637	15997	3	however	however	RB
18637	15997	4	,	,	,
18637	15997	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	15997	6	not	not	RB
18637	15997	7	the	the	DT
18637	15997	8	case	case	NN
18637	15997	9	.	.	.
18637	15998	1	The	the	DT
18637	15998	2	offence	offence	NN
18637	15998	3	,	,	,
18637	15998	4	as	as	IN
18637	15998	5	stated	state	VBN
18637	15998	6	in	in	IN
18637	15998	7	the	the	DT
18637	15998	8	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	15998	9	,	,	,
18637	15998	10	will	will	MD
18637	15998	11	be	be	VB
18637	15998	12	made	make	VBN
18637	15998	13	out	out	RP
18637	15998	14	,	,	,
18637	15998	15	if	if	IN
18637	15998	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15998	17	be	be	VB
18637	15998	18	shown	show	VBN
18637	15998	19	that	that	IN
18637	15998	20	the	the	DT
18637	15998	21	object	object	NN
18637	15998	22	of	of	IN
18637	15998	23	the	the	DT
18637	15998	24	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	15998	25	was	be	VBD
18637	15998	26	to	to	TO
18637	15998	27	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	15998	28	a	a	DT
18637	15998	29	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	15998	30	for	for	IN
18637	15998	31	any	any	DT
18637	15998	32	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	15998	33	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15998	34	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	15998	35	.	.	.
18637	15999	1	"	"	``
18637	15999	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	15999	3	252	252	CD
18637	15999	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15999	5	HAGUE	HAGUE	NNP
18637	15999	6	_	_	NNP
18637	15999	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	15999	8	_	_	NNP
18637	15999	9	COMMITTEE	COMMITTEE	NNP
18637	15999	10	OF	of	IN
18637	15999	11	INDUSTRIAL	INDUSTRIAL	NNP
18637	15999	12	ORGANIZATION	ORGANIZATION	NNP
18637	15999	13	In	in	IN
18637	15999	14	this	this	DT
18637	15999	15	case[253	case[253	NN
18637	15999	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	15999	17	the	the	DT
18637	15999	18	question	question	NN
18637	15999	19	at	at	IN
18637	15999	20	issue	issue	NN
18637	15999	21	was	be	VBD
18637	15999	22	the	the	DT
18637	15999	23	validity	validity	NN
18637	15999	24	of	of	IN
18637	15999	25	a	a	DT
18637	15999	26	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	15999	27	City	City	NNP
18637	15999	28	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	15999	29	requiring	require	VBG
18637	15999	30	the	the	DT
18637	15999	31	obtaining	obtaining	NN
18637	15999	32	of	of	IN
18637	15999	33	a	a	DT
18637	15999	34	permit	permit	NN
18637	15999	35	for	for	IN
18637	15999	36	a	a	DT
18637	15999	37	public	public	JJ
18637	15999	38	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	15999	39	in	in	IN
18637	15999	40	or	or	CC
18637	15999	41	upon	upon	IN
18637	15999	42	the	the	DT
18637	15999	43	public	public	JJ
18637	15999	44	streets	street	NNS
18637	15999	45	,	,	,
18637	15999	46	highways	highway	NNS
18637	15999	47	,	,	,
18637	15999	48	public	public	JJ
18637	15999	49	parks	park	NNS
18637	15999	50	,	,	,
18637	15999	51	or	or	CC
18637	15999	52	public	public	JJ
18637	15999	53	buildings	building	NNS
18637	15999	54	of	of	IN
18637	15999	55	the	the	DT
18637	15999	56	city	city	NN
18637	15999	57	and	and	CC
18637	15999	58	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	15999	59	the	the	DT
18637	15999	60	director	director	NN
18637	15999	61	of	of	IN
18637	15999	62	public	public	JJ
18637	15999	63	safety	safety	NN
18637	15999	64	,	,	,
18637	15999	65	for	for	IN
18637	15999	66	the	the	DT
18637	15999	67	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	15999	68	of	of	IN
18637	15999	69	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	15999	70	riots	riot	NNS
18637	15999	71	,	,	,
18637	15999	72	disturbances	disturbance	NNS
18637	15999	73	,	,	,
18637	15999	74	or	or	CC
18637	15999	75	disorderly	disorderly	JJ
18637	15999	76	assemblage	assemblage	NN
18637	15999	77	,	,	,
18637	15999	78	to	to	TO
18637	15999	79	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	15999	80	to	to	TO
18637	15999	81	issue	issue	VB
18637	15999	82	a	a	DT
18637	15999	83	permit	permit	NN
18637	15999	84	when	when	WRB
18637	15999	85	after	after	IN
18637	15999	86	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	15999	87	of	of	IN
18637	15999	88	all	all	PDT
18637	15999	89	the	the	DT
18637	15999	90	facts	fact	NNS
18637	15999	91	and	and	CC
18637	15999	92	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	15999	93	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	15999	94	to	to	IN
18637	15999	95	the	the	DT
18637	15999	96	application	application	NN
18637	15999	97	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15999	98	believes	believe	VBZ
18637	15999	99	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	15999	100	to	to	TO
18637	15999	101	be	be	VB
18637	15999	102	proper	proper	JJ
18637	15999	103	to	to	TO
18637	15999	104	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	15999	105	to	to	TO
18637	15999	106	issue	issue	VB
18637	15999	107	a	a	DT
18637	15999	108	permit	permit	NN
18637	15999	109	.	.	.
18637	16000	1	Two	two	CD
18637	16000	2	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	16000	3	held	hold	VBD
18637	16000	4	that	that	IN
18637	16000	5	in	in	IN
18637	16000	6	the	the	DT
18637	16000	7	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	16000	8	of	of	IN
18637	16000	9	the	the	DT
18637	16000	10	case	case	NN
18637	16000	11	the	the	DT
18637	16000	12	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	16000	13	violated	violate	VBD
18637	16000	14	the	the	DT
18637	16000	15	right	right	NN
18637	16000	16	of	of	IN
18637	16000	17	certain	certain	JJ
18637	16000	18	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	16000	19	of	of	IN
18637	16000	20	the	the	DT
18637	16000	21	United	United	NNP
18637	16000	22	States	States	NNP
18637	16000	23	to	to	TO
18637	16000	24	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	16000	25	to	to	TO
18637	16000	26	discuss	discuss	VB
18637	16000	27	certain	certain	JJ
18637	16000	28	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	16000	29	which	which	WDT
18637	16000	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16000	31	enjoyed	enjoy	VBD
18637	16000	32	as	as	IN
18637	16000	33	such	such	JJ
18637	16000	34	,	,	,
18637	16000	35	to	to	IN
18637	16000	36	wit	wit	NN
18637	16000	37	,	,	,
18637	16000	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16000	39	rights	right	NNS
18637	16000	40	and	and	CC
18637	16000	41	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	16000	42	under	under	IN
18637	16000	43	the	the	DT
18637	16000	44	National	National	NNP
18637	16000	45	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	16000	46	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	16000	47	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16000	48	.	.	.
18637	16001	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16001	2	254	254	CD
18637	16001	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16001	4	Said	Said	NNP
18637	16001	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16001	6	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	16001	7	,	,	,
18637	16001	8	expressing	express	VBG
18637	16001	9	this	this	DT
18637	16001	10	point	point	NN
18637	16001	11	of	of	IN
18637	16001	12	view	view	NN
18637	16001	13	:	:	:
18637	16001	14	"	"	``
18637	16001	15	The	the	DT
18637	16001	16	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	16001	17	of	of	IN
18637	16001	18	a	a	DT
18637	16001	19	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	16001	20	of	of	IN
18637	16001	21	the	the	DT
18637	16001	22	United	United	NNP
18637	16001	23	States	States	NNP
18637	16001	24	to	to	TO
18637	16001	25	use	use	VB
18637	16001	26	the	the	DT
18637	16001	27	streets	street	NNS
18637	16001	28	and	and	CC
18637	16001	29	parks	park	NNS
18637	16001	30	for	for	IN
18637	16001	31	communication	communication	NN
18637	16001	32	of	of	IN
18637	16001	33	views	view	NNS
18637	16001	34	on	on	IN
18637	16001	35	national	national	JJ
18637	16001	36	questions	question	NNS
18637	16001	37	may	may	MD
18637	16001	38	be	be	VB
18637	16001	39	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	16001	40	in	in	IN
18637	16001	41	the	the	DT
18637	16001	42	interest	interest	NN
18637	16001	43	of	of	IN
18637	16001	44	all	all	DT
18637	16001	45	;	;	:
18637	16001	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16001	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	16001	48	not	not	RB
18637	16001	49	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	16001	50	,	,	,
18637	16001	51	but	but	CC
18637	16001	52	relative	relative	JJ
18637	16001	53	,	,	,
18637	16001	54	and	and	CC
18637	16001	55	must	must	MD
18637	16001	56	be	be	VB
18637	16001	57	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	16001	58	in	in	IN
18637	16001	59	subordination	subordination	NN
18637	16001	60	to	to	IN
18637	16001	61	the	the	DT
18637	16001	62	general	general	JJ
18637	16001	63	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	16001	64	and	and	CC
18637	16001	65	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	16001	66	,	,	,
18637	16001	67	and	and	CC
18637	16001	68	in	in	IN
18637	16001	69	consonance	consonance	NN
18637	16001	70	with	with	IN
18637	16001	71	peace	peace	NN
18637	16001	72	and	and	CC
18637	16001	73	good	good	JJ
18637	16001	74	order	order	NN
18637	16001	75	;	;	:
18637	16001	76	but	but	CC
18637	16001	77	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16001	78	must	must	MD
18637	16001	79	not	not	RB
18637	16001	80	,	,	,
18637	16001	81	in	in	IN
18637	16001	82	the	the	DT
18637	16001	83	guise	guise	NN
18637	16001	84	of	of	IN
18637	16001	85	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	16001	86	,	,	,
18637	16001	87	be	be	VB
18637	16001	88	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	16001	89	or	or	CC
18637	16001	90	denied	deny	VBN
18637	16001	91	.	.	.
18637	16002	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16002	2	think	think	VBP
18637	16002	3	the	the	DT
18637	16002	4	court	court	NN
18637	16002	5	below	below	RB
18637	16002	6	was	be	VBD
18637	16002	7	right	right	JJ
18637	16002	8	in	in	IN
18637	16002	9	holding	hold	VBG
18637	16002	10	the	the	DT
18637	16002	11	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	16002	12	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	16002	13	in	in	IN
18637	16002	14	Note	Note	NNP
18637	16002	15	1	1	CD
18637	16002	16	void	void	RB
18637	16002	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	16002	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16002	19	face	face	NN
18637	16002	20	.	.	.
18637	16003	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16003	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	16003	3	not	not	RB
18637	16003	4	make	make	VB
18637	16003	5	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	16003	6	or	or	CC
18637	16003	7	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	16003	8	in	in	IN
18637	16003	9	the	the	DT
18637	16003	10	use	use	NN
18637	16003	11	of	of	IN
18637	16003	12	streets	street	NNS
18637	16003	13	or	or	CC
18637	16003	14	parks	park	VBZ
18637	16003	15	the	the	DT
18637	16003	16	standard	standard	NN
18637	16003	17	of	of	IN
18637	16003	18	official	official	JJ
18637	16003	19	action	action	NN
18637	16003	20	.	.	.
18637	16004	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16004	2	enables	enable	VBZ
18637	16004	3	the	the	DT
18637	16004	4	Director	Director	NNP
18637	16004	5	of	of	IN
18637	16004	6	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	16004	7	to	to	TO
18637	16004	8	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	16004	9	a	a	DT
18637	16004	10	permit	permit	NN
18637	16004	11	on	on	IN
18637	16004	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16004	13	mere	mere	JJ
18637	16004	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16004	15	that	that	IN
18637	16004	16	such	such	JJ
18637	16004	17	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	16004	18	will	will	MD
18637	16004	19	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	16004	20	'	'	``
18637	16004	21	riots	riot	NNS
18637	16004	22	,	,	,
18637	16004	23	disturbances	disturbance	NNS
18637	16004	24	or	or	CC
18637	16004	25	disorderly	disorderly	JJ
18637	16004	26	assemblage	assemblage	NN
18637	16004	27	.	.	.
18637	16004	28	'	'	''
18637	16005	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16005	2	can	can	MD
18637	16005	3	thus	thus	RB
18637	16005	4	,	,	,
18637	16005	5	as	as	IN
18637	16005	6	the	the	DT
18637	16005	7	record	record	NN
18637	16005	8	discloses	disclose	VBZ
18637	16005	9	,	,	,
18637	16005	10	be	be	VB
18637	16005	11	made	make	VBN
18637	16005	12	the	the	DT
18637	16005	13	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	16005	14	of	of	IN
18637	16005	15	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	16005	16	suppression	suppression	NN
18637	16005	17	of	of	IN
18637	16005	18	free	free	JJ
18637	16005	19	expression	expression	NN
18637	16005	20	of	of	IN
18637	16005	21	views	view	NNS
18637	16005	22	on	on	IN
18637	16005	23	national	national	JJ
18637	16005	24	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	16005	25	for	for	IN
18637	16005	26	the	the	DT
18637	16005	27	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	16005	28	of	of	IN
18637	16005	29	all	all	DT
18637	16005	30	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	16005	31	will	will	MD
18637	16005	32	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	16005	33	'	'	``
18637	16005	34	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	16005	35	'	'	''
18637	16005	36	such	such	JJ
18637	16005	37	eventualities	eventuality	NNS
18637	16005	38	.	.	.
18637	16006	1	But	but	CC
18637	16006	2	uncontrolled	uncontrolled	JJ
18637	16006	3	official	official	JJ
18637	16006	4	suppression	suppression	NN
18637	16006	5	of	of	IN
18637	16006	6	the	the	DT
18637	16006	7	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	16006	8	can	can	MD
18637	16006	9	not	not	RB
18637	16006	10	be	be	VB
18637	16006	11	made	make	VBN
18637	16006	12	a	a	DT
18637	16006	13	substitute	substitute	NN
18637	16006	14	for	for	IN
18637	16006	15	the	the	DT
18637	16006	16	duty	duty	NN
18637	16006	17	to	to	TO
18637	16006	18	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	16006	19	order	order	NN
18637	16006	20	in	in	IN
18637	16006	21	connection	connection	NN
18637	16006	22	with	with	IN
18637	16006	23	the	the	DT
18637	16006	24	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	16006	25	of	of	IN
18637	16006	26	the	the	DT
18637	16006	27	right	right	NN
18637	16006	28	.	.	.
18637	16007	1	"	"	``
18637	16007	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16007	3	255	255	CD
18637	16007	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16007	5	Two	two	CD
18637	16007	6	other	other	JJ
18637	16007	7	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	16007	8	invoked	invoke	VBD
18637	16007	9	also	also	RB
18637	16007	10	the	the	DT
18637	16007	11	due	due	JJ
18637	16007	12	process	process	NN
18637	16007	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	16007	14	of	of	IN
18637	16007	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16007	16	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	16007	17	,	,	,
18637	16007	18	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	16007	19	claiming	claim	VBG
18637	16007	20	the	the	DT
18637	16007	21	right	right	NN
18637	16007	22	of	of	IN
18637	16007	23	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	16007	24	for	for	IN
18637	16007	25	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	16007	26	as	as	RB
18637	16007	27	well	well	RB
18637	16007	28	as	as	IN
18637	16007	29	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	16007	30	.	.	.
18637	16008	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	16008	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16008	3	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	16008	4	,	,	,
18637	16008	5	who	who	WP
18637	16008	6	expressed	express	VBD
18637	16008	7	this	this	DT
18637	16008	8	view	view	NN
18637	16008	9	:	:	:
18637	16008	10	"	"	``
18637	16008	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16008	12	think	think	VBP
18637	16008	13	respondents	respondent	NNS
18637	16008	14	'	'	POS
18637	16008	15	right	right	NN
18637	16008	16	to	to	TO
18637	16008	17	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	16008	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16008	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	16008	20	not	not	RB
18637	16008	21	depend	depend	VB
18637	16008	22	on	on	IN
18637	16008	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16008	24	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	16008	25	and	and	CC
18637	16008	26	can	can	MD
18637	16008	27	not	not	RB
18637	16008	28	rightly	rightly	RB
18637	16008	29	be	be	VB
18637	16008	30	made	make	VBN
18637	16008	31	to	to	TO
18637	16008	32	turn	turn	VB
18637	16008	33	on	on	RP
18637	16008	34	the	the	DT
18637	16008	35	existence	existence	NN
18637	16008	36	or	or	CC
18637	16008	37	non	non	NN
18637	16008	38	-	-	JJ
18637	16008	39	existence	existence	NN
18637	16008	40	of	of	IN
18637	16008	41	a	a	DT
18637	16008	42	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	16008	43	to	to	TO
18637	16008	44	disseminate	disseminate	VB
18637	16008	45	information	information	NN
18637	16008	46	about	about	IN
18637	16008	47	the	the	DT
18637	16008	48	National	National	NNP
18637	16008	49	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	16008	50	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	16008	51	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16008	52	.	.	.
18637	16009	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16009	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	16009	3	enough	enough	JJ
18637	16009	4	that	that	IN
18637	16009	5	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	16009	6	have	have	VBP
18637	16009	7	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	16009	8	respondents	respondent	NNS
18637	16009	9	from	from	IN
18637	16009	10	holding	hold	VBG
18637	16009	11	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	16009	12	and	and	CC
18637	16009	13	disseminating	disseminate	VBG
18637	16009	14	information	information	NN
18637	16009	15	whether	whether	IN
18637	16009	16	for	for	IN
18637	16009	17	the	the	DT
18637	16009	18	organization	organization	NNP
18637	16009	19	of	of	IN
18637	16009	20	labor	labor	NN
18637	16009	21	unions	union	NNS
18637	16009	22	or	or	CC
18637	16009	23	for	for	IN
18637	16009	24	any	any	DT
18637	16009	25	other	other	JJ
18637	16009	26	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	16009	27	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	16009	28	.	.	.
18637	16010	1	"	"	``
18637	16010	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16010	3	256	256	CD
18637	16010	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16010	5	Both	both	DT
18637	16010	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	16010	7	were	be	VBD
18637	16010	8	in	in	IN
18637	16010	9	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	16010	10	that	that	DT
18637	16010	11	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16010	12	of	of	IN
18637	16010	13	speech	speech	NN
18637	16010	14	and	and	CC
18637	16010	15	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16010	16	of	of	IN
18637	16010	17	assembly	assembly	NNP
18637	16010	18	were	be	VBD
18637	16010	19	claimable	claimable	JJ
18637	16010	20	only	only	RB
18637	16010	21	by	by	IN
18637	16010	22	natural	natural	JJ
18637	16010	23	persons	person	NNS
18637	16010	24	,	,	,
18637	16010	25	and	and	CC
18637	16010	26	not	not	RB
18637	16010	27	by	by	IN
18637	16010	28	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	16010	29	.	.	.
18637	16011	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16011	2	257	257	CD
18637	16011	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16011	4	Two	two	CD
18637	16011	5	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	16011	6	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	16011	7	on	on	IN
18637	16011	8	the	the	DT
18637	16011	9	basis	basis	NN
18637	16011	10	of	of	IN
18637	16011	11	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	16011	12	_	_	NNP
18637	16011	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	16011	14	_	_	NNP
18637	16011	15	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	16011	16	.	.	.
18637	16012	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16012	2	258	258	CD
18637	16012	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16012	4	RECENT	recent	JJ
18637	16012	5	CASES	case	NNS
18637	16012	6	In	in	IN
18637	16012	7	Bridges	Bridges	NNPS
18637	16012	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16012	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	16012	10	_	_	NNP
18637	16012	11	California[259	California[259	NNP
18637	16012	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16012	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16012	14	was	be	VBD
18637	16012	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	16012	16	that	that	IN
18637	16012	17	a	a	DT
18637	16012	18	telegram	telegram	NN
18637	16012	19	addressed	address	VBD
18637	16012	20	to	to	IN
18637	16012	21	the	the	DT
18637	16012	22	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	16012	23	of	of	IN
18637	16012	24	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	16012	25	strongly	strongly	RB
18637	16012	26	criticizing	criticize	VBG
18637	16012	27	the	the	DT
18637	16012	28	action	action	NN
18637	16012	29	of	of	IN
18637	16012	30	a	a	DT
18637	16012	31	State	State	NNP
18637	16012	32	court	court	NN
18637	16012	33	in	in	IN
18637	16012	34	a	a	DT
18637	16012	35	pending	pending	JJ
18637	16012	36	case	case	NN
18637	16012	37	was	be	VBD
18637	16012	38	privileged	privileged	JJ
18637	16012	39	under	under	IN
18637	16012	40	this	this	DT
18637	16012	41	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	16012	42	as	as	IN
18637	16012	43	an	an	DT
18637	16012	44	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	16012	45	of	of	IN
18637	16012	46	the	the	DT
18637	16012	47	right	right	NN
18637	16012	48	of	of	IN
18637	16012	49	petition	petition	NN
18637	16012	50	.	.	.
18637	16013	1	In	in	IN
18637	16013	2	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	16013	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16013	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	16013	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16013	6	Collins[260	Collins[260	NNP
18637	16013	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16013	8	a	a	DT
18637	16013	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	16013	10	requiring	require	VBG
18637	16013	11	registration	registration	NN
18637	16013	12	before	before	IN
18637	16013	13	solicitation	solicitation	NN
18637	16013	14	of	of	IN
18637	16013	15	union	union	NN
18637	16013	16	membership	membership	NN
18637	16013	17	was	be	VBD
18637	16013	18	found	find	VBN
18637	16013	19	to	to	TO
18637	16013	20	violate	violate	VB
18637	16013	21	the	the	DT
18637	16013	22	right	right	NN
18637	16013	23	of	of	IN
18637	16013	24	peaceable	peaceable	JJ
18637	16013	25	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	16013	26	.	.	.
18637	16014	1	But	but	CC
18637	16014	2	a	a	DT
18637	16014	3	closely	closely	RB
18637	16014	4	divided	divide	VBN
18637	16014	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16014	6	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	16014	7	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	16014	8	an	an	DT
18637	16014	9	order	order	NN
18637	16014	10	of	of	IN
18637	16014	11	a	a	DT
18637	16014	12	State	State	NNP
18637	16014	13	Employment	Employment	NNP
18637	16014	14	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	16014	15	Board	Board	NNP
18637	16014	16	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	16014	17	work	work	NN
18637	16014	18	stoppages	stoppage	NNS
18637	16014	19	by	by	IN
18637	16014	20	the	the	DT
18637	16014	21	calling	calling	NN
18637	16014	22	of	of	IN
18637	16014	23	special	special	JJ
18637	16014	24	union	union	NN
18637	16014	25	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	16014	26	during	during	IN
18637	16014	27	working	working	NN
18637	16014	28	hours	hour	NNS
18637	16014	29	.	.	.
18637	16015	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16015	2	261	261	CD
18637	16015	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16015	4	Finally	finally	RB
18637	16015	5	,	,	,
18637	16015	6	a	a	DT
18637	16015	7	divided	divide	VBN
18637	16015	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16015	9	held	hold	VBD
18637	16015	10	June	June	NNP
18637	16015	11	4	4	CD
18637	16015	12	,	,	,
18637	16015	13	1951	1951	CD
18637	16015	14	,	,	,
18637	16015	15	that	that	IN
18637	16015	16	a	a	DT
18637	16015	17	combination	combination	NN
18637	16015	18	to	to	TO
18637	16015	19	break	break	VB
18637	16015	20	up	up	RP
18637	16015	21	by	by	IN
18637	16015	22	force	force	NN
18637	16015	23	and	and	CC
18637	16015	24	threats	threat	NNS
18637	16015	25	of	of	IN
18637	16015	26	force	force	NN
18637	16015	27	of	of	IN
18637	16015	28	a	a	DT
18637	16015	29	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	16015	30	called	call	VBN
18637	16015	31	for	for	IN
18637	16015	32	the	the	DT
18637	16015	33	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	16015	34	of	of	IN
18637	16015	35	adopting	adopt	VBG
18637	16015	36	a	a	DT
18637	16015	37	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	16015	38	against	against	IN
18637	16015	39	the	the	DT
18637	16015	40	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	16015	41	Plan	Plan	NNP
18637	16015	42	did	do	VBD
18637	16015	43	not	not	RB
18637	16015	44	afford	afford	VB
18637	16015	45	a	a	DT
18637	16015	46	right	right	NN
18637	16015	47	of	of	IN
18637	16015	48	action	action	NN
18637	16015	49	against	against	IN
18637	16015	50	the	the	DT
18637	16015	51	conspirators	conspirator	NNS
18637	16015	52	under	under	IN
18637	16015	53	the	the	DT
18637	16015	54	Ku	Ku	NNP
18637	16015	55	Klux	Klux	NNP
18637	16015	56	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16015	57	of	of	IN
18637	16015	58	April	April	NNP
18637	16015	59	20	20	CD
18637	16015	60	,	,	,
18637	16015	61	1871	1871	CD
18637	16015	62	.	.	.
18637	16016	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16016	2	262	262	CD
18637	16016	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16016	4	While	while	IN
18637	16016	5	the	the	DT
18637	16016	6	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	16016	7	alleged	allege	VBD
18637	16016	8	that	that	IN
18637	16016	9	the	the	DT
18637	16016	10	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	16016	11	was	be	VBD
18637	16016	12	entered	enter	VBN
18637	16016	13	into	into	IN
18637	16016	14	for	for	IN
18637	16016	15	the	the	DT
18637	16016	16	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	16016	17	of	of	IN
18637	16016	18	depriving	deprive	VBG
18637	16016	19	the	the	DT
18637	16016	20	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
18637	16016	21	as	as	IN
18637	16016	22	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	16016	23	of	of	IN
18637	16016	24	the	the	DT
18637	16016	25	United	United	NNP
18637	16016	26	States	States	NNP
18637	16016	27	of	of	IN
18637	16016	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16016	29	right	right	NN
18637	16016	30	"	"	''
18637	16016	31	peaceably	peaceably	RB
18637	16016	32	to	to	TO
18637	16016	33	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	16016	34	for	for	IN
18637	16016	35	the	the	DT
18637	16016	36	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	16016	37	of	of	IN
18637	16016	38	discussing	discuss	VBG
18637	16016	39	and	and	CC
18637	16016	40	communicating	communicate	VBG
18637	16016	41	upon	upon	IN
18637	16016	42	national	national	JJ
18637	16016	43	public	public	JJ
18637	16016	44	issues	issue	NNS
18637	16016	45	,	,	,
18637	16016	46	"	"	''
18637	16016	47	the	the	DT
18637	16016	48	Ku	Ku	NNP
18637	16016	49	Klux	Klux	NNP
18637	16016	50	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16016	51	was	be	VBD
18637	16016	52	found	find	VBN
18637	16016	53	not	not	RB
18637	16016	54	to	to	TO
18637	16016	55	extend	extend	VB
18637	16016	56	to	to	IN
18637	16016	57	violations	violation	NNS
18637	16016	58	of	of	IN
18637	16016	59	that	that	DT
18637	16016	60	right	right	NN
18637	16016	61	except	except	IN
18637	16016	62	by	by	IN
18637	16016	63	State	state	NN
18637	16016	64	acts	act	NNS
18637	16016	65	depriving	deprive	VBG
18637	16016	66	persons	person	NNS
18637	16016	67	of	of	IN
18637	16016	68	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16016	69	rights	right	NNS
18637	16016	70	under	under	IN
18637	16016	71	the	the	DT
18637	16016	72	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	16016	73	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16016	74	.	.	.
18637	16017	1	But	but	CC
18637	16017	2	the	the	DT
18637	16017	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16017	4	,	,	,
18637	16017	5	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	16017	6	significantly	significantly	RB
18637	16017	7	,	,	,
18637	16017	8	left	leave	VBD
18637	16017	9	open	open	VB
18637	16017	10	the	the	DT
18637	16017	11	question	question	NN
18637	16017	12	whether	whether	IN
18637	16017	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16017	14	can	can	MD
18637	16017	15	protect	protect	VB
18637	16017	16	such	such	JJ
18637	16017	17	rights	right	NNS
18637	16017	18	against	against	IN
18637	16017	19	private	private	JJ
18637	16017	20	action	action	NN
18637	16017	21	.	.	.
18637	16018	1	"	"	``
18637	16018	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16018	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	16018	4	not	not	RB
18637	16018	5	for	for	IN
18637	16018	6	this	this	DT
18637	16018	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16018	8	,	,	,
18637	16018	9	"	"	''
18637	16018	10	remarked	remark	VBD
18637	16018	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16018	12	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	16018	13	sententiously	sententiously	RB
18637	16018	14	,	,	,
18637	16018	15	"	"	``
18637	16018	16	to	to	TO
18637	16018	17	compete	compete	VB
18637	16018	18	with	with	IN
18637	16018	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16018	20	or	or	CC
18637	16018	21	attempt	attempt	VB
18637	16018	22	to	to	TO
18637	16018	23	replace	replace	VB
18637	16018	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16018	25	as	as	IN
18637	16018	26	the	the	DT
18637	16018	27	Nation	nation	NN
18637	16018	28	's	's	POS
18637	16018	29	law	law	NN
18637	16018	30	-	-	HYPH
18637	16018	31	making	make	VBG
18637	16018	32	body	body	NN
18637	16018	33	.	.	.
18637	16019	1	"	"	``
18637	16019	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16019	3	263	263	CD
18637	16019	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16019	5	LOBBYING	LOBBYING	NNP
18637	16019	6	AND	and	CC
18637	16019	7	THE	the	DT
18637	16019	8	RIGHT	right	NN
18637	16019	9	OF	of	IN
18637	16019	10	PETITION	PETITION	NNP
18637	16019	11	Today	today	NN
18637	16019	12	lobbying	lobbying	NN
18637	16019	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	16019	14	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	16019	15	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	16019	16	as	as	IN
18637	16019	17	the	the	DT
18637	16019	18	most	most	RBS
18637	16019	19	important	important	JJ
18637	16019	20	expression	expression	NN
18637	16019	21	of	of	IN
18637	16019	22	the	the	DT
18637	16019	23	right	right	NN
18637	16019	24	of	of	IN
18637	16019	25	petition	petition	NN
18637	16019	26	.	.	.
18637	16020	1	During	during	IN
18637	16020	2	the	the	DT
18637	16020	3	last	last	JJ
18637	16020	4	half	half	JJ
18637	16020	5	century	century	NN
18637	16020	6	lobbying	lobbying	NN
18637	16020	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	16020	8	reached	reach	VBN
18637	16020	9	tremendous	tremendous	JJ
18637	16020	10	proportions	proportion	NNS
18637	16020	11	;	;	:
18637	16020	12	and	and	CC
18637	16020	13	there	there	EX
18637	16020	14	have	have	VBP
18637	16020	15	been	be	VBN
18637	16020	16	four	four	CD
18637	16020	17	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	16020	18	investigations	investigation	NNS
18637	16020	19	of	of	IN
18637	16020	20	such	such	JJ
18637	16020	21	activities	activity	NNS
18637	16020	22	,	,	,
18637	16020	23	the	the	DT
18637	16020	24	latest	late	JJS
18637	16020	25	by	by	IN
18637	16020	26	a	a	DT
18637	16020	27	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	16020	28	of	of	IN
18637	16020	29	the	the	DT
18637	16020	30	House	House	NNP
18637	16020	31	of	of	IN
18637	16020	32	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	16020	33	.	.	.
18637	16021	1	Meantime	meantime	RB
18637	16021	2	,	,	,
18637	16021	3	in	in	IN
18637	16021	4	1946	1946	CD
18637	16021	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16021	6	passed	pass	VBD
18637	16021	7	the	the	DT
18637	16021	8	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	16021	9	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	16021	10	of	of	IN
18637	16021	11	Lobbying	Lobbying	NNP
18637	16021	12	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16021	13	,	,	,
18637	16021	14	under	under	IN
18637	16021	15	which	which	WDT
18637	16021	16	more	more	JJR
18637	16021	17	than	than	IN
18637	16021	18	2,000	2,000	CD
18637	16021	19	lobbyists	lobbyist	NNS
18637	16021	20	have	have	VBP
18637	16021	21	registered	register	VBN
18637	16021	22	and	and	CC
18637	16021	23	495	495	CD
18637	16021	24	organizations	organization	NNS
18637	16021	25	report	report	VBP
18637	16021	26	lobbying	lobbying	NN
18637	16021	27	contributions	contribution	NNS
18637	16021	28	and	and	CC
18637	16021	29	expenditures	expenditure	NNS
18637	16021	30	.	.	.
18637	16022	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16022	2	264	264	CD
18637	16022	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16022	4	Recently	recently	RB
18637	16022	5	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	16022	6	have	have	VBP
18637	16022	7	been	be	VBN
18637	16022	8	cast	cast	VBN
18637	16022	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	16022	10	the	the	DT
18637	16022	11	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	16022	12	of	of	IN
18637	16022	13	this	this	DT
18637	16022	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	16022	15	by	by	IN
18637	16022	16	two	two	CD
18637	16022	17	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	16022	18	of	of	IN
18637	16022	19	lower	low	JJR
18637	16022	20	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16022	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	16022	22	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	16022	23	in	in	IN
18637	16022	24	the	the	DT
18637	16022	25	District	District	NNP
18637	16022	26	of	of	IN
18637	16022	27	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	16022	28	.	.	.
18637	16023	1	According	accord	VBG
18637	16023	2	to	to	IN
18637	16023	3	the	the	DT
18637	16023	4	District	District	NNP
18637	16023	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16023	6	therein	therein	RB
18637	16023	7	,	,	,
18637	16023	8	to	to	TO
18637	16023	9	subject	subject	VB
18637	16023	10	a	a	DT
18637	16023	11	person	person	NN
18637	16023	12	,	,	,
18637	16023	13	whose	whose	WP$
18637	16023	14	"	"	``
18637	16023	15	principal	principal	JJ
18637	16023	16	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	16023	17	*	*	NFP
18637	16023	18	*	*	NFP
18637	16023	19	*	*	NFP
18637	16023	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	16023	21	to	to	TO
18637	16023	22	aid	aid	VB
18637	16023	23	"	"	``
18637	16023	24	in	in	IN
18637	16023	25	the	the	DT
18637	16023	26	defeat	defeat	NN
18637	16023	27	or	or	CC
18637	16023	28	passage	passage	NN
18637	16023	29	of	of	IN
18637	16023	30	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	16023	31	and	and	CC
18637	16023	32	who	who	WP
18637	16023	33	violates	violate	VBZ
18637	16023	34	this	this	DT
18637	16023	35	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16023	36	by	by	IN
18637	16023	37	failing	fail	VBG
18637	16023	38	to	to	TO
18637	16023	39	file	file	VB
18637	16023	40	a	a	DT
18637	16023	41	detailed	detailed	JJ
18637	16023	42	accounting	accounting	NN
18637	16023	43	,	,	,
18637	16023	44	to	to	IN
18637	16023	45	a	a	DT
18637	16023	46	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	16023	47	entailing	entail	VBG
18637	16023	48	a	a	DT
18637	16023	49	three	three	CD
18637	16023	50	-	-	HYPH
18637	16023	51	year	year	NN
18637	16023	52	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	16023	53	from	from	IN
18637	16023	54	lobbying	lobby	VBG
18637	16023	55	is	be	VBZ
18637	16023	56	to	to	TO
18637	16023	57	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	16023	58	such	such	JJ
18637	16023	59	person	person	NN
18637	16023	60	of	of	IN
18637	16023	61	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16023	62	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16023	63	rights	right	NNS
18637	16023	64	of	of	IN
18637	16023	65	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16023	66	of	of	IN
18637	16023	67	speech	speech	NN
18637	16023	68	and	and	CC
18637	16023	69	petition	petition	NN
18637	16023	70	.	.	.
18637	16024	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16024	2	265	265	CD
18637	16024	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16024	4	Insofar	insofar	RB
18637	16024	5	as	as	IN
18637	16024	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16024	7	legitimately	legitimately	RB
18637	16024	8	may	may	MD
18637	16024	9	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	16024	10	lobbying	lobbying	NN
18637	16024	11	,	,	,
18637	16024	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16024	13	powers	power	NNS
18637	16024	14	in	in	IN
18637	16024	15	relation	relation	NN
18637	16024	16	thereto	thereto	NNP
18637	16024	17	have	have	VBP
18637	16024	18	been	be	VBN
18637	16024	19	declared	declare	VBN
18637	16024	20	not	not	RB
18637	16024	21	to	to	TO
18637	16024	22	extend	extend	VB
18637	16024	23	to	to	IN
18637	16024	24	"	"	``
18637	16024	25	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	16024	26	lobbying	lobbying	NN
18637	16024	27	by	by	IN
18637	16024	28	the	the	DT
18637	16024	29	pressure	pressure	NN
18637	16024	30	of	of	IN
18637	16024	31	public	public	JJ
18637	16024	32	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16024	33	on	on	IN
18637	16024	34	the	the	DT
18637	16024	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16024	36	.	.	.
18637	16024	37	"	"	''
18637	16025	1	The	the	DT
18637	16025	2	latter	latter	NN
18637	16025	3	was	be	VBD
18637	16025	4	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	16025	5	to	to	TO
18637	16025	6	be	be	VB
18637	16025	7	"	"	``
18637	16025	8	the	the	DT
18637	16025	9	healthy	healthy	JJ
18637	16025	10	essence	essence	NN
18637	16025	11	of	of	IN
18637	16025	12	the	the	DT
18637	16025	13	democratic	democratic	JJ
18637	16025	14	process	process	NN
18637	16025	15	.	.	.
18637	16026	1	"	"	``
18637	16026	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16026	3	266	266	CD
18637	16026	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16026	5	Notes	Notes	NNP
18637	16026	6	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16026	7	1	1	CD
18637	16026	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16026	9	268	268	CD
18637	16026	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16026	11	652	652	CD
18637	16026	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16026	13	1925	1925	CD
18637	16026	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16026	15	.	.	.
18637	16027	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16027	2	2	2	LS
18637	16027	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16027	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16027	5	.	.	.
18637	16028	1	666	666	CD
18637	16028	2	.	.	.
18637	16029	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16029	2	3	3	LS
18637	16029	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16029	4	Fiske	Fiske	NNP
18637	16029	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16029	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16029	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16029	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	16029	9	,	,	,
18637	16029	10	274	274	CD
18637	16029	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16029	12	380	380	CD
18637	16029	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16029	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	16029	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16029	16	.	.	.
18637	16030	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16030	2	4	4	CD
18637	16030	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16030	4	Cantwell	Cantwell	NNP
18637	16030	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16030	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16030	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16030	8	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	16030	9	,	,	,
18637	16030	10	310	310	CD
18637	16030	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16030	12	296	296	CD
18637	16030	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16030	14	1940	1940	CD
18637	16030	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16030	16	.	.	.
18637	16031	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16031	2	5	5	CD
18637	16031	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16031	4	Near	Near	NNP
18637	16031	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16031	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16031	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16031	8	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	16031	9	,	,	,
18637	16031	10	283	283	CD
18637	16031	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16031	12	697	697	CD
18637	16031	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16031	14	1931	1931	CD
18637	16031	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16031	16	.	.	.
18637	16032	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16032	2	6	6	CD
18637	16032	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16032	4	De	De	NNP
18637	16032	5	Jonge	Jonge	NNP
18637	16032	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16032	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16032	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16032	9	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	16032	10	,	,	,
18637	16032	11	299	299	CD
18637	16032	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16032	13	353	353	CD
18637	16032	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16032	15	1937	1937	CD
18637	16032	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16032	17	.	.	.
18637	16033	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16033	2	7	7	LS
18637	16033	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16033	4	Annals	Annals	NNP
18637	16033	5	of	of	IN
18637	16033	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16033	7	,	,	,
18637	16033	8	434	434	CD
18637	16033	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16033	10	1789	1789	CD
18637	16033	11	-	-	SYM
18637	16033	12	1791	1791	CD
18637	16033	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16033	14	.	.	.
18637	16034	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16034	2	8	8	CD
18637	16034	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16034	4	Records	Records	NNPS
18637	16034	5	of	of	IN
18637	16034	6	the	the	DT
18637	16034	7	United	United	NNP
18637	16034	8	States	States	NNP
18637	16034	9	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	16034	10	,	,	,
18637	16034	11	Sept.	September	NNP
18637	16034	12	9	9	CD
18637	16034	13	,	,	,
18637	16034	14	1789	1789	CD
18637	16034	15	,	,	,
18637	16034	16	United	United	NNP
18637	16034	17	States	States	NNP
18637	16034	18	Archives	Archives	NNP
18637	16034	19	,	,	,
18637	16034	20	cited	cite	VBN
18637	16034	21	in	in	IN
18637	16034	22	Appellees	Appellees	NNP
18637	16034	23	Brief	Brief	NNP
18637	16034	24	in	in	IN
18637	16034	25	McCollum	McCollum	NNP
18637	16034	26	_	_	NNP
18637	16034	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	16034	28	_	_	NNP
18637	16034	29	Board	Board	NNP
18637	16034	30	of	of	IN
18637	16034	31	Education	Education	NNP
18637	16034	32	,	,	,
18637	16034	33	333	333	CD
18637	16034	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16034	35	203	203	CD
18637	16034	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16034	37	1948	1948	CD
18637	16034	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16034	39	.	.	.
18637	16035	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16035	2	9	9	CD
18637	16035	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16035	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16035	5	.	.	.
18637	16036	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16036	2	10	10	CD
18637	16036	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16036	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16036	5	.	.	.
18637	16037	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16037	2	11	11	CD
18637	16037	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16037	4	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
18637	16037	5	Story	Story	NNP
18637	16037	6	,	,	,
18637	16037	7	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	16037	8	on	on	IN
18637	16037	9	the	the	DT
18637	16037	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	16037	11	,	,	,
18637	16037	12	§	â§	NN
18637	16037	13	1879	1879	CD
18637	16037	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16037	15	1833	1833	CD
18637	16037	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16037	17	.	.	.
18637	16038	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16038	2	12	12	CD
18637	16038	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16038	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16038	5	.	.	.
18637	16039	1	§	§	NNP
18637	16039	2	1874	1874	CD
18637	16039	3	.	.	.
18637	16040	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16040	2	13	13	CD
18637	16040	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16040	4	Principles	principle	NNS
18637	16040	5	of	of	IN
18637	16040	6	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	16040	7	Law	Law	NNP
18637	16040	8	,	,	,
18637	16040	9	224	224	CD
18637	16040	10	-	-	SYM
18637	16040	11	225	225	CD
18637	16040	12	,	,	,
18637	16040	13	3d	3d	NNP
18637	16040	14	ed	ed	NN
18637	16040	15	.	.	.
18637	16041	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16041	2	1898	1898	CD
18637	16041	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16041	4	.	.	.
18637	16042	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16042	2	14	14	CD
18637	16042	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16042	4	Saul	Saul	NNP
18637	16042	5	K.	K.	NNP
18637	16042	6	Padover	Padover	NNP
18637	16042	7	,	,	,
18637	16042	8	The	the	DT
18637	16042	9	Complete	Complete	NNP
18637	16042	10	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	16042	11	,	,	,
18637	16042	12	518	518	CD
18637	16042	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	16042	14	519	519	CD
18637	16042	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16042	16	1943	1943	CD
18637	16042	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16042	18	.	.	.
18637	16043	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16043	2	15	15	CD
18637	16043	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16043	4	98	98	CD
18637	16043	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16043	6	145	145	CD
18637	16043	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16043	8	1879	1879	CD
18637	16043	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16043	10	.	.	.
18637	16044	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16044	2	16	16	CD
18637	16044	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16044	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16044	5	.	.	.
18637	16045	1	164	164	CD
18637	16045	2	.	.	.
18637	16046	1	In	in	IN
18637	16046	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16046	3	2d	2d	CD
18637	16046	4	Inaugural	Inaugural	NNP
18637	16046	5	Address	Address	NNP
18637	16046	6	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	16046	7	expressed	express	VBD
18637	16046	8	a	a	DT
18637	16046	9	very	very	RB
18637	16046	10	different	different	JJ
18637	16046	11	,	,	,
18637	16046	12	and	and	CC
18637	16046	13	presumably	presumably	RB
18637	16046	14	more	more	RBR
18637	16046	15	carefully	carefully	RB
18637	16046	16	considered	consider	VBN
18637	16046	17	,	,	,
18637	16046	18	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16046	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	16046	20	the	the	DT
18637	16046	21	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	16046	22	of	of	IN
18637	16046	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16046	24	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16046	25	:	:	:
18637	16046	26	"	"	``
18637	16046	27	In	in	IN
18637	16046	28	matters	matter	NNS
18637	16046	29	of	of	IN
18637	16046	30	religion	religion	NN
18637	16046	31	,	,	,
18637	16046	32	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16046	33	have	have	VBP
18637	16046	34	considered	consider	VBN
18637	16046	35	that	that	IN
18637	16046	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16046	37	free	free	JJ
18637	16046	38	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	16046	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	16046	40	placed	place	VBN
18637	16046	41	by	by	IN
18637	16046	42	the	the	DT
18637	16046	43	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	16046	44	independent	independent	NN
18637	16046	45	of	of	IN
18637	16046	46	the	the	DT
18637	16046	47	powers	power	NNS
18637	16046	48	of	of	IN
18637	16046	49	of	of	IN
18637	16046	50	the	the	DT
18637	16046	51	general	general	JJ
18637	16046	52	government	government	NN
18637	16046	53	.	.	.
18637	16046	54	"	"	''
18637	16047	1	This	this	DT
18637	16047	2	was	be	VBD
18637	16047	3	said	say	VBN
18637	16047	4	three	three	CD
18637	16047	5	years	year	NNS
18637	16047	6	after	after	IN
18637	16047	7	the	the	DT
18637	16047	8	Danbury	Danbury	NNP
18637	16047	9	letter	letter	NN
18637	16047	10	.	.	.
18637	16048	1	1	1	CD
18637	16048	2	Messages	message	NNS
18637	16048	3	and	and	CC
18637	16048	4	Papers	Papers	NNPS
18637	16048	5	of	of	IN
18637	16048	6	the	the	DT
18637	16048	7	Presidents	president	NNS
18637	16048	8	,	,	,
18637	16048	9	379	379	CD
18637	16048	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16048	11	Richardson	Richardson	NNP
18637	16048	12	ed	ed	NNP
18637	16048	13	.	.	.
18637	16049	1	1896	1896	CD
18637	16049	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16049	3	.	.	.
18637	16050	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16050	2	17	17	CD
18637	16050	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16050	4	Everson	Everson	NNP
18637	16050	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16050	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16050	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16050	8	Board	Board	NNP
18637	16050	9	of	of	IN
18637	16050	10	Education	Education	NNP
18637	16050	11	,	,	,
18637	16050	12	330	330	CD
18637	16050	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16050	14	1	1	CD
18637	16050	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16050	16	1947	1947	CD
18637	16050	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16050	18	.	.	.
18637	16051	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16051	2	18	18	CD
18637	16051	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16051	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16051	5	.	.	.
18637	16052	1	15	15	CD
18637	16052	2	,	,	,
18637	16052	3	16	16	CD
18637	16052	4	.	.	.
18637	16053	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16053	2	19	19	CD
18637	16053	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16053	4	McCollum	McCollum	NNP
18637	16053	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16053	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16053	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16053	8	Board	Board	NNP
18637	16053	9	of	of	IN
18637	16053	10	Education	Education	NNP
18637	16053	11	,	,	,
18637	16053	12	333	333	CD
18637	16053	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16053	14	203	203	CD
18637	16053	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16053	16	1948	1948	CD
18637	16053	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16053	18	.	.	.
18637	16054	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16054	2	20	20	CD
18637	16054	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16054	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16054	5	.	.	.
18637	16055	1	212	212	CD
18637	16055	2	.	.	.
18637	16056	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16056	2	21	21	CD
18637	16056	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16056	4	333	333	CD
18637	16056	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16056	6	203	203	CD
18637	16056	7	,	,	,
18637	16056	8	213	213	CD
18637	16056	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16056	10	1948	1948	CD
18637	16056	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16056	12	.	.	.
18637	16057	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16057	2	22	22	CD
18637	16057	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16057	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16057	5	.	.	.
18637	16058	1	216	216	CD
18637	16058	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16058	3	218	218	CD
18637	16058	4	.	.	.
18637	16059	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16059	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	16059	3	's	's	POS
18637	16059	4	principal	principal	JJ
18637	16059	5	figure	figure	NN
18637	16059	6	in	in	IN
18637	16059	7	the	the	DT
18637	16059	8	fight	fight	NN
18637	16059	9	against	against	IN
18637	16059	10	sectarianism	sectarianism	NN
18637	16059	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	16059	12	Horace	Horace	NNP
18637	16059	13	Mann	Mann	NNP
18637	16059	14	,	,	,
18637	16059	15	who	who	WP
18637	16059	16	was	be	VBD
18637	16059	17	secretary	secretary	NN
18637	16059	18	of	of	IN
18637	16059	19	the	the	DT
18637	16059	20	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	16059	21	Board	Board	NNP
18637	16059	22	of	of	IN
18637	16059	23	Education	Education	NNP
18637	16059	24	,	,	,
18637	16059	25	1837	1837	CD
18637	16059	26	-	-	SYM
18637	16059	27	1848	1848	CD
18637	16059	28	.	.	.
18637	16060	1	Mann	Mann	NNP
18637	16060	2	,	,	,
18637	16060	3	however	however	RB
18637	16060	4	,	,	,
18637	16060	5	strongly	strongly	RB
18637	16060	6	resented	resent	VBD
18637	16060	7	the	the	DT
18637	16060	8	charge	charge	NN
18637	16060	9	that	that	IN
18637	16060	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16060	11	was	be	VBD
18637	16060	12	opposed	opposed	JJ
18637	16060	13	to	to	IN
18637	16060	14	religious	religious	JJ
18637	16060	15	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	16060	16	in	in	IN
18637	16060	17	the	the	DT
18637	16060	18	public	public	JJ
18637	16060	19	schools	school	NNS
18637	16060	20	.	.	.
18637	16061	1	"	"	``
18637	16061	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16061	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	16061	4	true	true	JJ
18637	16061	5	that	that	IN
18637	16061	6	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	16061	7	Mann	Mann	NNP
18637	16061	8	stood	stand	VBD
18637	16061	9	strongly	strongly	RB
18637	16061	10	for	for	IN
18637	16061	11	a	a	DT
18637	16061	12	'	'	``
18637	16061	13	type	type	NN
18637	16061	14	of	of	IN
18637	16061	15	school	school	NN
18637	16061	16	with	with	IN
18637	16061	17	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	16061	18	adapted	adapt	VBN
18637	16061	19	to	to	IN
18637	16061	20	democratic	democratic	JJ
18637	16061	21	and	and	CC
18637	16061	22	national	national	JJ
18637	16061	23	ends	end	NNS
18637	16061	24	.	.	.
18637	16061	25	'	'	''
18637	16062	1	But	but	CC
18637	16062	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16062	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	16062	4	not	not	RB
18637	16062	5	quite	quite	RB
18637	16062	6	just	just	RB
18637	16062	7	to	to	IN
18637	16062	8	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16062	9	to	to	TO
18637	16062	10	contrast	contrast	VB
18637	16062	11	this	this	DT
18637	16062	12	type	type	NN
18637	16062	13	of	of	IN
18637	16062	14	school	school	NN
18637	16062	15	with	with	IN
18637	16062	16	the	the	DT
18637	16062	17	school	school	NN
18637	16062	18	adapted	adapt	VBN
18637	16062	19	to	to	IN
18637	16062	20	religious	religious	JJ
18637	16062	21	ends	end	NNS
18637	16062	22	,	,	,
18637	16062	23	without	without	IN
18637	16062	24	defining	define	VBG
18637	16062	25	terms	term	NNS
18637	16062	26	.	.	.
18637	16063	1	Horace	Horace	NNP
18637	16063	2	Mann	Mann	NNP
18637	16063	3	was	be	VBD
18637	16063	4	opposed	oppose	VBN
18637	16063	5	to	to	IN
18637	16063	6	sectarian	sectarian	JJ
18637	16063	7	doctrinal	doctrinal	JJ
18637	16063	8	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	16063	9	in	in	IN
18637	16063	10	the	the	DT
18637	16063	11	schools	school	NNS
18637	16063	12	,	,	,
18637	16063	13	but	but	CC
18637	16063	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16063	15	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	16063	16	urged	urge	VBD
18637	16063	17	the	the	DT
18637	16063	18	teaching	teaching	NN
18637	16063	19	of	of	IN
18637	16063	20	the	the	DT
18637	16063	21	elements	element	NNS
18637	16063	22	of	of	IN
18637	16063	23	religion	religion	NN
18637	16063	24	common	common	JJ
18637	16063	25	to	to	IN
18637	16063	26	all	all	DT
18637	16063	27	of	of	IN
18637	16063	28	the	the	DT
18637	16063	29	Christian	christian	JJ
18637	16063	30	sects	sect	NNS
18637	16063	31	.	.	.
18637	16064	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16064	2	took	take	VBD
18637	16064	3	a	a	DT
18637	16064	4	firm	firm	JJ
18637	16064	5	stand	stand	NN
18637	16064	6	against	against	IN
18637	16064	7	the	the	DT
18637	16064	8	idea	idea	NN
18637	16064	9	of	of	IN
18637	16064	10	a	a	DT
18637	16064	11	purely	purely	RB
18637	16064	12	secular	secular	JJ
18637	16064	13	education	education	NN
18637	16064	14	,	,	,
18637	16064	15	and	and	CC
18637	16064	16	on	on	IN
18637	16064	17	one	one	CD
18637	16064	18	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	16064	19	said	say	VBD
18637	16064	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16064	21	was	be	VBD
18637	16064	22	in	in	IN
18637	16064	23	favor	favor	NN
18637	16064	24	of	of	IN
18637	16064	25	religious	religious	JJ
18637	16064	26	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	16064	27	'	'	''
18637	16064	28	to	to	IN
18637	16064	29	the	the	DT
18637	16064	30	extremest	extreme	JJS
18637	16064	31	verge	verge	NN
18637	16064	32	to	to	TO
18637	16064	33	which	which	WDT
18637	16064	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16064	35	can	can	MD
18637	16064	36	be	be	VB
18637	16064	37	carried	carry	VBN
18637	16064	38	without	without	IN
18637	16064	39	invading	invade	VBG
18637	16064	40	those	those	DT
18637	16064	41	rights	right	NNS
18637	16064	42	of	of	IN
18637	16064	43	conscience	conscience	NN
18637	16064	44	which	which	WDT
18637	16064	45	are	be	VBP
18637	16064	46	established	establish	VBN
18637	16064	47	by	by	IN
18637	16064	48	the	the	DT
18637	16064	49	laws	law	NNS
18637	16064	50	of	of	IN
18637	16064	51	God	God	NNP
18637	16064	52	,	,	,
18637	16064	53	and	and	CC
18637	16064	54	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	16064	55	to	to	IN
18637	16064	56	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16064	57	by	by	IN
18637	16064	58	the	the	DT
18637	16064	59	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	16064	60	of	of	IN
18637	16064	61	the	the	DT
18637	16064	62	State	State	NNP
18637	16064	63	.	.	.
18637	16064	64	'	'	''
18637	16065	1	At	at	IN
18637	16065	2	another	another	DT
18637	16065	3	time	time	NN
18637	16065	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16065	5	said	say	VBD
18637	16065	6	that	that	IN
18637	16065	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16065	8	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	16065	9	hostility	hostility	NN
18637	16065	10	to	to	IN
18637	16065	11	religion	religion	NN
18637	16065	12	in	in	IN
18637	16065	13	the	the	DT
18637	16065	14	schools	school	NNS
18637	16065	15	as	as	IN
18637	16065	16	the	the	DT
18637	16065	17	greatest	great	JJS
18637	16065	18	crime	crime	NN
18637	16065	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16065	20	could	could	MD
18637	16065	21	commit	commit	VB
18637	16065	22	.	.	.
18637	16066	1	Lest	lest	IN
18637	16066	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16066	3	name	name	NN
18637	16066	4	should	should	MD
18637	16066	5	go	go	VB
18637	16066	6	down	down	RB
18637	16066	7	in	in	IN
18637	16066	8	history	history	NN
18637	16066	9	as	as	IN
18637	16066	10	that	that	DT
18637	16066	11	of	of	IN
18637	16066	12	one	one	NN
18637	16066	13	who	who	WP
18637	16066	14	had	have	VBD
18637	16066	15	attempted	attempt	VBN
18637	16066	16	to	to	TO
18637	16066	17	drive	drive	VB
18637	16066	18	religious	religious	JJ
18637	16066	19	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	16066	20	from	from	IN
18637	16066	21	the	the	DT
18637	16066	22	schools	school	NNS
18637	16066	23	,	,	,
18637	16066	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16066	25	devoted	devote	VBD
18637	16066	26	several	several	JJ
18637	16066	27	pages	page	NNS
18637	16066	28	in	in	IN
18637	16066	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16066	30	final	final	JJ
18637	16066	31	Report	report	NN
18637	16066	32	--	--	:
18637	16066	33	the	the	DT
18637	16066	34	twelfth	twelfth	JJ
18637	16066	35	--	--	:
18637	16066	36	to	to	IN
18637	16066	37	a	a	DT
18637	16066	38	statement	statement	NN
18637	16066	39	in	in	IN
18637	16066	40	which	which	WDT
18637	16066	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16066	42	denied	deny	VBD
18637	16066	43	the	the	DT
18637	16066	44	charges	charge	NNS
18637	16066	45	of	of	IN
18637	16066	46	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16066	47	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	16066	48	.	.	.
18637	16066	49	"	"	''
18637	16067	1	Raymond	Raymond	NNP
18637	16067	2	B.	B.	NNP
18637	16067	3	Culver	Culver	NNP
18637	16067	4	,	,	,
18637	16067	5	Horace	Horace	NNP
18637	16067	6	Mann	Mann	NNP
18637	16067	7	on	on	IN
18637	16067	8	Religion	religion	NN
18637	16067	9	in	in	IN
18637	16067	10	the	the	DT
18637	16067	11	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	16067	12	Public	Public	NNP
18637	16067	13	Schools	Schools	NNP
18637	16067	14	,	,	,
18637	16067	15	235	235	CD
18637	16067	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16067	17	1929	1929	CD
18637	16067	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16067	19	.	.	.
18637	16068	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16068	2	23	23	CD
18637	16068	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16068	4	333	333	CD
18637	16068	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16068	6	203	203	CD
18637	16068	7	,	,	,
18637	16068	8	222	222	CD
18637	16068	9	ff	ff	NN
18637	16068	10	.	.	.
18637	16069	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16069	2	1948	1948	CD
18637	16069	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16069	4	.	.	.
18637	16070	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16070	2	24	24	CD
18637	16070	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16070	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16070	5	.	.	.
18637	16071	1	213	213	CD
18637	16071	2	.	.	.
18637	16072	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16072	2	25	25	CD
18637	16072	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16072	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16072	5	.	.	.
18637	16073	1	225	225	CD
18637	16073	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16073	3	226	226	CD
18637	16073	4	.	.	.
18637	16074	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16074	2	26	26	CD
18637	16074	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16074	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16074	5	.	.	.
18637	16075	1	231	231	CD
18637	16075	2	.	.	.
18637	16076	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16076	2	27	27	CD
18637	16076	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16076	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16076	5	.	.	.
18637	16077	1	232	232	CD
18637	16077	2	,	,	,
18637	16077	3	234	234	CD
18637	16077	4	.	.	.
18637	16078	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16078	2	28	28	CD
18637	16078	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16078	4	333	333	CD
18637	16078	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16078	6	244	244	CD
18637	16078	7	.	.	.
18637	16079	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16079	2	29	29	CD
18637	16079	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16079	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16079	5	.	.	.
18637	16079	6	,	,	,
18637	16079	7	253	253	CD
18637	16079	8	,	,	,
18637	16079	9	254	254	CD
18637	16079	10	.	.	.
18637	16080	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16080	2	30	30	CD
18637	16080	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16080	4	Zorach	Zorach	NNP
18637	16080	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16080	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16080	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16080	8	Clauson	Clauson	NNP
18637	16080	9	,	,	,
18637	16080	10	303	303	CD
18637	16080	11	N.Y.	New York	NNP
18637	16080	12	161	161	CD
18637	16080	13	,	,	,
18637	16080	14	168	168	CD
18637	16080	15	-	-	SYM
18637	16080	16	169	169	CD
18637	16080	17	;	;	:
18637	16080	18	100	100	CD
18637	16080	19	N.E.	N.E.	NNP
18637	16081	1	2d	2d	CD
18637	16081	2	403	403	CD
18637	16081	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16081	4	1951	1951	CD
18637	16081	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16081	6	.	.	.
18637	16082	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16082	2	31	31	CD
18637	16082	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16082	4	Zorach	Zorach	NNP
18637	16082	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16082	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16082	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16082	8	Clauson	Clauson	NNP
18637	16082	9	,	,	,
18637	16082	10	343	343	CD
18637	16082	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16082	12	306	306	CD
18637	16082	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16082	14	1952	1952	CD
18637	16082	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16082	16	.	.	.
18637	16083	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16083	2	32	32	CD
18637	16083	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16083	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16083	5	.	.	.
18637	16083	6	,	,	,
18637	16083	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	16083	8	.	.	.
18637	16084	1	313	313	CD
18637	16084	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16084	3	314	314	CD
18637	16084	4	.	.	.
18637	16085	1	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	16085	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	16085	3	,	,	,
18637	16085	4	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	16085	5	,	,	,
18637	16085	6	and	and	CC
18637	16085	7	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	16085	8	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	16085	9	.	.	.
18637	16086	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16086	2	33	33	CD
18637	16086	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16086	4	Doremus	Doremus	NNP
18637	16086	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16086	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16086	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16086	8	Board	Board	NNP
18637	16086	9	of	of	IN
18637	16086	10	Education	Education	NNP
18637	16086	11	,	,	,
18637	16086	12	342	342	CD
18637	16086	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16086	14	429	429	CD
18637	16086	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16086	16	1952	1952	CD
18637	16086	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16086	18	.	.	.
18637	16087	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16087	2	34	34	CD
18637	16087	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16087	4	Three	three	CD
18637	16087	5	dissenters	dissenter	NNS
18637	16087	6	,	,	,
18637	16087	7	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	16087	8	through	through	IN
18637	16087	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16087	10	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	16087	11	,	,	,
18637	16087	12	argued	argue	VBD
18637	16087	13	that	that	IN
18637	16087	14	,	,	,
18637	16087	15	since	since	IN
18637	16087	16	the	the	DT
18637	16087	17	New	New	NNP
18637	16087	18	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	16087	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16087	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16087	21	had	have	VBD
18637	16087	22	taken	take	VBN
18637	16087	23	the	the	DT
18637	16087	24	case	case	NN
18637	16087	25	and	and	CC
18637	16087	26	decided	decide	VBD
18637	16087	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16087	28	on	on	IN
18637	16087	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16087	30	merits	merit	NNS
18637	16087	31	,	,	,
18637	16087	32	the	the	DT
18637	16087	33	United	United	NNP
18637	16087	34	States	States	NNP
18637	16087	35	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16087	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16087	37	was	be	VBD
18637	16087	38	bound	bind	VBN
18637	16087	39	to	to	TO
18637	16087	40	do	do	VB
18637	16087	41	the	the	DT
18637	16087	42	same	same	JJ
18637	16087	43	.	.	.
18637	16088	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	16088	2	.	.	.
18637	16089	1	435	435	CD
18637	16089	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16089	3	436	436	CD
18637	16089	4	.	.	.
18637	16090	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16090	2	35	35	CD
18637	16090	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16090	4	Bradfield	Bradfield	NNP
18637	16090	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16090	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16090	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16090	8	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	16090	9	,	,	,
18637	16090	10	175	175	CD
18637	16090	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16090	12	291	291	CD
18637	16090	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16090	14	1899	1899	CD
18637	16090	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16090	16	.	.	.
18637	16091	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16091	2	36	36	CD
18637	16091	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16091	4	Quick	Quick	NNP
18637	16091	5	Bear	Bear	NNP
18637	16091	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16091	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16091	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16091	9	Leupp	Leupp	NNP
18637	16091	10	,	,	,
18637	16091	11	210	210	CD
18637	16091	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16091	13	50	50	CD
18637	16091	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16091	15	1908	1908	CD
18637	16091	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16091	17	.	.	.
18637	16092	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16092	2	37	37	CD
18637	16092	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16092	4	Cochran	Cochran	NNP
18637	16092	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16092	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16092	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16092	8	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	16092	9	State	State	NNP
18637	16092	10	Board	Board	NNP
18637	16092	11	of	of	IN
18637	16092	12	Education	Education	NNP
18637	16092	13	,	,	,
18637	16092	14	281	281	CD
18637	16092	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16092	16	370	370	CD
18637	16092	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16092	18	1930	1930	CD
18637	16092	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16092	20	.	.	.
18637	16093	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16093	2	38	38	CD
18637	16093	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16093	4	Everson	Everson	NNP
18637	16093	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16093	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16093	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16093	8	Board	Board	NNP
18637	16093	9	of	of	IN
18637	16093	10	Education	Education	NNP
18637	16093	11	,	,	,
18637	16093	12	330	330	CD
18637	16093	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16093	14	1	1	CD
18637	16093	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16093	16	1947	1947	CD
18637	16093	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16093	18	.	.	.
18637	16094	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16094	2	39	39	CD
18637	16094	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16094	4	42	42	CD
18637	16094	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	16095	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	16095	2	1751	1751	CD
18637	16095	3	-	-	SYM
18637	16095	4	1760	1760	CD
18637	16095	5	;	;	:
18637	16095	6	60	60	CD
18637	16095	7	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	16095	8	.	.	.
18637	16096	1	230	230	CD
18637	16096	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16096	3	1940	1940	CD
18637	16096	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16096	5	.	.	.
18637	16097	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16097	2	40	40	CD
18637	16097	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16097	4	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	16097	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16097	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16097	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16097	8	Benson	Benson	NNP
18637	16097	9	,	,	,
18637	16097	10	133	133	CD
18637	16097	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16097	12	333	333	CD
18637	16097	13	,	,	,
18637	16097	14	342	342	CD
18637	16097	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16097	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	16097	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16097	18	.	.	.
18637	16098	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16098	2	41	41	CD
18637	16098	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16098	4	Cantwell	Cantwell	NNP
18637	16098	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16098	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16098	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16098	8	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	16098	9	,	,	,
18637	16098	10	310	310	CD
18637	16098	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16098	12	296	296	CD
18637	16098	13	,	,	,
18637	16098	14	303	303	CD
18637	16098	15	,	,	,
18637	16098	16	304	304	CD
18637	16098	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16098	18	1940	1940	CD
18637	16098	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16098	20	.	.	.
18637	16099	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16099	2	42	42	CD
18637	16099	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16099	4	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	16099	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16099	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16099	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16099	8	Society	Society	NNP
18637	16099	9	of	of	IN
18637	16099	10	Sisters	Sisters	NNPS
18637	16099	11	of	of	IN
18637	16099	12	Holy	Holy	NNP
18637	16099	13	Names	Names	NNPS
18637	16099	14	,	,	,
18637	16099	15	268	268	CD
18637	16099	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16099	17	510	510	CD
18637	16099	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16099	19	1925	1925	CD
18637	16099	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16099	21	.	.	.
18637	16100	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16100	2	43	43	CD
18637	16100	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16100	4	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	16100	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16100	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16100	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16100	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16100	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16100	10	,	,	,
18637	16100	11	98	98	CD
18637	16100	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16100	13	145	145	CD
18637	16100	14	,	,	,
18637	16100	15	166	166	CD
18637	16100	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16100	17	1879	1879	CD
18637	16100	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16100	19	.	.	.
18637	16101	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16101	2	44	44	CD
18637	16101	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16101	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16101	5	.	.	.
18637	16102	1	167	167	CD
18637	16102	2	.	.	.
18637	16103	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16103	2	45	45	CD
18637	16103	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16103	4	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	16103	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16103	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16103	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16103	8	Beason	Beason	NNP
18637	16103	9	,	,	,
18637	16103	10	133	133	CD
18637	16103	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16103	12	333	333	CD
18637	16103	13	,	,	,
18637	16103	14	345	345	CD
18637	16103	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16103	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	16103	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16103	18	.	.	.
18637	16104	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16104	2	46	46	CD
18637	16104	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16104	4	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	16104	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16104	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16104	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16104	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16104	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16104	10	98	98	CD
18637	16104	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16104	12	145	145	CD
18637	16104	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16104	14	1879	1879	CD
18637	16104	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16104	16	;	;	:
18637	16104	17	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	16104	18	_	_	NNP
18637	16104	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	16104	20	_	_	NNP
18637	16104	21	Beason	Beason	NNP
18637	16104	22	,	,	,
18637	16104	23	133	133	CD
18637	16104	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16104	25	333	333	CD
18637	16104	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16104	27	1890	1890	CD
18637	16104	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16104	29	.	.	.
18637	16105	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16105	2	47	47	CD
18637	16105	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16105	4	322	322	CD
18637	16105	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16105	6	78	78	CD
18637	16105	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16105	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	16105	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16105	10	.	.	.
18637	16106	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16106	2	48	48	CD
18637	16106	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16106	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16106	5	.	.	.
18637	16107	1	89	89	CD
18637	16107	2	.	.	.
18637	16108	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16108	2	49	49	CD
18637	16108	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16108	4	310	310	CD
18637	16108	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16108	6	296	296	CD
18637	16108	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16108	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	16108	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16108	10	.	.	.
18637	16109	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16109	2	50	50	CD
18637	16109	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16109	4	Minersville	Minersville	NNP
18637	16109	5	School	School	NNP
18637	16109	6	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	16109	7	.	.	.
18637	16110	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16110	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	16110	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16110	4	Gobitis	Gobitis	NNP
18637	16110	5	,	,	,
18637	16110	6	310	310	CD
18637	16110	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16110	8	586	586	CD
18637	16110	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16110	10	1940	1940	CD
18637	16110	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16110	12	.	.	.
18637	16111	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16111	2	51	51	CD
18637	16111	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16111	4	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	16111	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16111	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16111	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16111	8	Opelika	Opelika	NNP
18637	16111	9	,	,	,
18637	16111	10	316	316	CD
18637	16111	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16111	12	584	584	CD
18637	16111	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16111	14	1942	1942	CD
18637	16111	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16111	16	.	.	.
18637	16112	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16112	2	52	52	CD
18637	16112	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16112	4	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	16112	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16112	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16112	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16112	8	Opelika	Opelika	NNP
18637	16112	9	,	,	,
18637	16112	10	319	319	CD
18637	16112	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16112	12	103	103	CD
18637	16112	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16112	14	1943	1943	CD
18637	16112	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16112	16	;	;	:
18637	16112	17	Murdock	Murdock	NNP
18637	16112	18	_	_	NNP
18637	16112	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	16112	20	_	_	NNP
18637	16112	21	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	16112	22	,	,	,
18637	16112	23	319	319	CD
18637	16112	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16112	25	105	105	CD
18637	16112	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16112	27	1943	1943	CD
18637	16112	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16112	29	.	.	.
18637	16113	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16113	2	53	53	CD
18637	16113	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16113	4	Board	Board	NNP
18637	16113	5	of	of	IN
18637	16113	6	Education	Education	NNP
18637	16113	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16113	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	16113	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16113	10	Barnette	Barnette	NNP
18637	16113	11	,	,	,
18637	16113	12	319	319	CD
18637	16113	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16113	14	624	624	CD
18637	16113	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16113	16	1943	1943	CD
18637	16113	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16113	18	.	.	.
18637	16114	1	On	on	IN
18637	16114	2	the	the	DT
18637	16114	3	same	same	JJ
18637	16114	4	day	day	NN
18637	16114	5	the	the	DT
18637	16114	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16114	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	16114	8	that	that	IN
18637	16114	9	a	a	DT
18637	16114	10	State	state	NN
18637	16114	11	may	may	MD
18637	16114	12	not	not	RB
18637	16114	13	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	16114	14	the	the	DT
18637	16114	15	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	16114	16	of	of	IN
18637	16114	17	literature	literature	NN
18637	16114	18	urging	urging	NN
18637	16114	19	and	and	CC
18637	16114	20	advising	advising	NN
18637	16114	21	,	,	,
18637	16114	22	on	on	IN
18637	16114	23	religious	religious	JJ
18637	16114	24	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	16114	25	,	,	,
18637	16114	26	that	that	IN
18637	16114	27	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	16114	28	refrain	refrain	VBP
18637	16114	29	from	from	IN
18637	16114	30	saluting	salute	VBG
18637	16114	31	the	the	DT
18637	16114	32	flag	flag	NN
18637	16114	33	.	.	.
18637	16115	1	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	16115	2	_	_	NNP
18637	16115	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	16115	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16115	5	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	16115	6	,	,	,
18637	16115	7	319	319	CD
18637	16115	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16115	9	583	583	CD
18637	16115	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16115	11	1943	1943	CD
18637	16115	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16115	13	.	.	.
18637	16116	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16116	2	54	54	CD
18637	16116	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16116	4	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	16116	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16116	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16116	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16116	8	Struthers	Struthers	NNP
18637	16116	9	,	,	,
18637	16116	10	319	319	CD
18637	16116	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16116	12	141	141	CD
18637	16116	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16116	14	1943	1943	CD
18637	16116	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16116	16	.	.	.
18637	16117	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16117	2	55	55	CD
18637	16117	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16117	4	Prince	Prince	NNP
18637	16117	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16117	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16117	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16117	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	16117	9	,	,	,
18637	16117	10	321	321	CD
18637	16117	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16117	12	158	158	CD
18637	16117	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16117	14	1944	1944	CD
18637	16117	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16117	16	.	.	.
18637	16118	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16118	2	56	56	CD
18637	16118	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16118	4	334	334	CD
18637	16118	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16118	6	558	558	CD
18637	16118	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16118	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	16118	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16118	10	.	.	.
18637	16119	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16119	2	57	57	CD
18637	16119	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16119	4	Kovacs	Kovacs	NNP
18637	16119	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16119	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16119	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16119	8	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	16119	9	,	,	,
18637	16119	10	336	336	CD
18637	16119	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16119	12	77	77	CD
18637	16119	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16119	14	1949	1949	CD
18637	16119	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16119	16	.	.	.
18637	16120	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16120	2	58	58	CD
18637	16120	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16120	4	Kunz	Kunz	NNP
18637	16120	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16120	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16120	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16120	8	New	New	NNP
18637	16120	9	York	York	NNP
18637	16120	10	,	,	,
18637	16120	11	340	340	CD
18637	16120	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16120	13	290	290	CD
18637	16120	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16120	15	1951	1951	CD
18637	16120	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16120	17	.	.	.
18637	16121	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16121	2	59	59	CD
18637	16121	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16121	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16121	5	.	.	.
18637	16122	1	314	314	CD
18637	16122	2	.	.	.
18637	16123	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16123	2	60	60	CD
18637	16123	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16123	4	Niemotko	Niemotko	NNP
18637	16123	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16123	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16123	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16123	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	16123	9	,	,	,
18637	16123	10	340	340	CD
18637	16123	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16123	12	268	268	CD
18637	16123	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16123	14	1951	1951	CD
18637	16123	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16123	16	.	.	.
18637	16124	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16124	2	61	61	CD
18637	16124	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16124	4	Feiner	Feiner	NNP
18637	16124	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16124	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16124	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16124	8	New	New	NNP
18637	16124	9	York	York	NNP
18637	16124	10	,	,	,
18637	16124	11	340	340	CD
18637	16124	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16124	13	315	315	CD
18637	16124	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16124	15	1951	1951	CD
18637	16124	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16124	17	.	.	.
18637	16125	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16125	2	62	62	CD
18637	16125	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16125	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16125	5	See	See	NNP
18637	16125	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16125	7	p.	p.	NN
18637	16125	8	1285	1285	CD
18637	16125	9	.	.	.
18637	16126	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16126	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	16126	3	's	's	POS
18637	16126	4	Note	note	NN
18637	16126	5	:	:	:
18637	16126	6	There	there	EX
18637	16126	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	16126	8	no	no	DT
18637	16126	9	mention	mention	NN
18637	16126	10	of	of	IN
18637	16126	11	the	the	DT
18637	16126	12	Feiner	Feiner	NNP
18637	16126	13	case	case	NN
18637	16126	14	on	on	IN
18637	16126	15	p.	p.	NN
18637	16127	1	1285	1285	CD
18637	16127	2	.	.	.
18637	16127	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16128	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16128	2	63	63	CD
18637	16128	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16128	4	Arver	Arver	NNP
18637	16128	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16128	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16128	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16128	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16128	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16128	10	,	,	,
18637	16128	11	245	245	CD
18637	16128	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16128	13	366	366	CD
18637	16128	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16128	15	1918	1918	CD
18637	16128	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16128	17	.	.	.
18637	16129	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16129	2	64	64	CD
18637	16129	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16129	4	293	293	CD
18637	16129	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16129	6	245	245	CD
18637	16129	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16129	8	1934	1934	CD
18637	16129	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16129	10	.	.	.
18637	16130	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16130	2	65	65	CD
18637	16130	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16130	4	325	325	CD
18637	16130	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16130	6	561	561	CD
18637	16130	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16130	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	16130	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16130	10	.	.	.
18637	16131	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16131	2	cf	cf	NNP
18637	16131	3	.	.	.
18637	16131	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16131	5	Girouard	Girouard	NNP
18637	16131	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16131	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16131	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16131	9	United	United	NNP
18637	16131	10	States	States	NNP
18637	16131	11	,	,	,
18637	16131	12	328	328	CD
18637	16131	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16131	14	61	61	CD
18637	16131	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16131	16	1946	1946	CD
18637	16131	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16131	18	holding	hold	VBG
18637	16131	19	"	"	''
18637	16131	20	an	an	DT
18637	16131	21	alien	alien	NN
18637	16131	22	who	who	WP
18637	16131	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	16131	24	willing	willing	JJ
18637	16131	25	to	to	TO
18637	16131	26	take	take	VB
18637	16131	27	the	the	DT
18637	16131	28	oath	oath	NN
18637	16131	29	of	of	IN
18637	16131	30	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	16131	31	and	and	CC
18637	16131	32	to	to	TO
18637	16131	33	serve	serve	VB
18637	16131	34	in	in	IN
18637	16131	35	the	the	DT
18637	16131	36	army	army	NN
18637	16131	37	as	as	IN
18637	16131	38	a	a	DT
18637	16131	39	non	non	JJ
18637	16131	40	-	-	JJ
18637	16131	41	combatant	combatant	JJ
18637	16131	42	but	but	CC
18637	16131	43	who	who	WP
18637	16131	44	,	,	,
18637	16131	45	because	because	IN
18637	16131	46	of	of	IN
18637	16131	47	religious	religious	JJ
18637	16131	48	scruples	scruple	NNS
18637	16131	49	,	,	,
18637	16131	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	16131	51	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
18637	16131	52	to	to	TO
18637	16131	53	bear	bear	VB
18637	16131	54	arms	arm	NNS
18637	16131	55	in	in	IN
18637	16131	56	defense	defense	NN
18637	16131	57	of	of	IN
18637	16131	58	this	this	DT
18637	16131	59	country	country	NN
18637	16131	60	may	may	MD
18637	16131	61	be	be	VB
18637	16131	62	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	16131	63	to	to	TO
18637	16131	64	citizenship	citizenship	VB
18637	16131	65	*	*	NFP
18637	16131	66	*	*	NFP
18637	16131	67	*	*	NFP
18637	16131	68	"	"	''
18637	16131	69	,	,	,
18637	16131	70	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	16131	71	United	United	NNP
18637	16131	72	States	States	NNP
18637	16131	73	_	_	NNP
18637	16131	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	16131	75	_	_	NNP
18637	16131	76	Schwimmer	Schwimmer	NNP
18637	16131	77	,	,	,
18637	16131	78	279	279	CD
18637	16131	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16131	80	644	644	CD
18637	16131	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16131	82	1929	1929	CD
18637	16131	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16131	84	and	and	CC
18637	16131	85	United	United	NNP
18637	16131	86	States	States	NNP
18637	16131	87	_	_	NNP
18637	16131	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	16131	89	_	_	NNP
18637	16131	90	Macintosh	Macintosh	NNP
18637	16131	91	,	,	,
18637	16131	92	283	283	CD
18637	16131	93	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16131	94	605	605	CD
18637	16131	95	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16131	96	1931	1931	CD
18637	16131	97	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16131	98	.	.	.
18637	16132	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16132	2	66	66	CD
18637	16132	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16132	4	325	325	CD
18637	16132	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16132	6	561	561	CD
18637	16132	7	,	,	,
18637	16132	8	578	578	CD
18637	16132	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16132	10	1945	1945	CD
18637	16132	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16132	12	.	.	.
18637	16133	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16133	2	67	67	CD
18637	16133	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16133	4	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	16133	5	,	,	,
18637	16133	6	Vol	Vol	NNP
18637	16133	7	.	.	.
18637	16134	1	IV	IV	NNP
18637	16134	2	,	,	,
18637	16134	3	151	151	CD
18637	16134	4	-	-	SYM
18637	16134	5	152	152	CD
18637	16134	6	.	.	.
18637	16135	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16135	2	68	68	CD
18637	16135	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16135	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16135	5	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	16135	6	in	in	IN
18637	16135	7	Dennis	Dennis	NNP
18637	16135	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16135	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	16135	10	_	_	NNP
18637	16135	11	United	United	NNP
18637	16135	12	States	States	NNP
18637	16135	13	,	,	,
18637	16135	14	341	341	CD
18637	16135	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16135	16	494	494	CD
18637	16135	17	,	,	,
18637	16135	18	521	521	CD
18637	16135	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	16135	20	522	522	CD
18637	16135	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16135	22	1951	1951	CD
18637	16135	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16135	24	.	.	.
18637	16136	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16136	2	69	69	CD
18637	16136	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16136	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16136	5	.	.	.
18637	16137	1	524	524	CD
18637	16137	2	;	;	:
18637	16137	3	citing	cite	VBG
18637	16137	4	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	16137	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16137	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16137	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16137	8	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	16137	9	,	,	,
18637	16137	10	165	165	CD
18637	16137	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16137	12	275	275	CD
18637	16137	13	,	,	,
18637	16137	14	281	281	CD
18637	16137	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16137	16	1897	1897	CD
18637	16137	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16137	18	.	.	.
18637	16138	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16138	2	70	70	CD
18637	16138	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16138	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16138	5	.	.	.
18637	16139	1	524	524	CD
18637	16139	2	;	;	:
18637	16139	3	citing	cite	VBG
18637	16139	4	Gompers	Gompers	NNPS
18637	16139	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16139	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16139	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16139	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16139	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16139	10	,	,	,
18637	16139	11	233	233	CD
18637	16139	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16139	13	604	604	CD
18637	16139	14	,	,	,
18637	16139	15	610	610	CD
18637	16139	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16139	17	1914	1914	CD
18637	16139	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16139	19	.	.	.
18637	16140	1	"	"	``
18637	16140	2	While	while	IN
18637	16140	3	the	the	DT
18637	16140	4	courts	court	NNS
18637	16140	5	have	have	VBP
18637	16140	6	from	from	IN
18637	16140	7	an	an	DT
18637	16140	8	early	early	JJ
18637	16140	9	date	date	NN
18637	16140	10	taken	take	VBN
18637	16140	11	a	a	DT
18637	16140	12	hand	hand	NN
18637	16140	13	in	in	IN
18637	16140	14	crystallizing	crystallize	VBG
18637	16140	15	American	american	JJ
18637	16140	16	conceptions	conception	NNS
18637	16140	17	of	of	IN
18637	16140	18	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16140	19	of	of	IN
18637	16140	20	speech	speech	NN
18637	16140	21	and	and	CC
18637	16140	22	press	press	NN
18637	16140	23	into	into	IN
18637	16140	24	law	law	NN
18637	16140	25	,	,	,
18637	16140	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16140	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	16140	28	scarcely	scarcely	RB
18637	16140	29	in	in	IN
18637	16140	30	the	the	DT
18637	16140	31	manner	manner	NN
18637	16140	32	or	or	CC
18637	16140	33	to	to	IN
18637	16140	34	the	the	DT
18637	16140	35	extent	extent	NN
18637	16140	36	which	which	WDT
18637	16140	37	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16140	38	are	be	VBP
18637	16140	39	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	16140	40	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	16140	41	to	to	TO
18637	16140	42	have	have	VB
18637	16140	43	done	do	VBN
18637	16140	44	.	.	.
18637	16141	1	The	the	DT
18637	16141	2	great	great	JJ
18637	16141	3	initial	initial	JJ
18637	16141	4	problem	problem	NN
18637	16141	5	in	in	IN
18637	16141	6	this	this	DT
18637	16141	7	realm	realm	NN
18637	16141	8	of	of	IN
18637	16141	9	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16141	10	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16141	11	was	be	VBD
18637	16141	12	to	to	TO
18637	16141	13	get	get	VB
18637	16141	14	rid	rid	VBN
18637	16141	15	of	of	IN
18637	16141	16	the	the	DT
18637	16141	17	common	common	JJ
18637	16141	18	law	law	NN
18637	16141	19	of	of	IN
18637	16141	20	'	'	``
18637	16141	21	seditious	seditious	JJ
18637	16141	22	libel	libel	NN
18637	16141	23	'	'	''
18637	16141	24	which	which	WDT
18637	16141	25	operated	operate	VBD
18637	16141	26	to	to	TO
18637	16141	27	put	put	VB
18637	16141	28	persons	person	NNS
18637	16141	29	in	in	IN
18637	16141	30	authority	authority	NN
18637	16141	31	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	16141	32	the	the	DT
18637	16141	33	reach	reach	NN
18637	16141	34	of	of	IN
18637	16141	35	public	public	JJ
18637	16141	36	criticism	criticism	NN
18637	16141	37	.	.	.
18637	16142	1	The	the	DT
18637	16142	2	first	first	JJ
18637	16142	3	step	step	NN
18637	16142	4	in	in	IN
18637	16142	5	this	this	DT
18637	16142	6	direction	direction	NN
18637	16142	7	was	be	VBD
18637	16142	8	taken	take	VBN
18637	16142	9	in	in	IN
18637	16142	10	the	the	DT
18637	16142	11	famous	famous	JJ
18637	16142	12	,	,	,
18637	16142	13	or	or	CC
18637	16142	14	infamous	infamous	JJ
18637	16142	15	,	,	,
18637	16142	16	Sedition	Sedition	NNP
18637	16142	17	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16142	18	of	of	IN
18637	16142	19	1798	1798	CD
18637	16142	20	,	,	,
18637	16142	21	which	which	WDT
18637	16142	22	admitted	admit	VBD
18637	16142	23	the	the	DT
18637	16142	24	defense	defense	NN
18637	16142	25	of	of	IN
18637	16142	26	truth	truth	NN
18637	16142	27	in	in	IN
18637	16142	28	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	16142	29	brought	bring	VBN
18637	16142	30	under	under	IN
18637	16142	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16142	32	,	,	,
18637	16142	33	and	and	CC
18637	16142	34	submitted	submit	VBD
18637	16142	35	the	the	DT
18637	16142	36	general	general	JJ
18637	16142	37	issue	issue	NN
18637	16142	38	of	of	IN
18637	16142	39	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	16142	40	's	's	POS
18637	16142	41	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	16142	42	to	to	IN
18637	16142	43	the	the	DT
18637	16142	44	jury	jury	NN
18637	16142	45	.	.	.
18637	16143	1	But	but	CC
18637	16143	2	the	the	DT
18637	16143	3	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	16143	4	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	16143	5	of	of	IN
18637	16143	6	'	'	``
18637	16143	7	seditious	seditious	JJ
18637	16143	8	libel	libel	NN
18637	16143	9	'	'	''
18637	16143	10	the	the	DT
18637	16143	11	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16143	12	of	of	IN
18637	16143	13	1798	1798	CD
18637	16143	14	still	still	RB
18637	16143	15	retained	retain	VBN
18637	16143	16	,	,	,
18637	16143	17	a	a	DT
18637	16143	18	circumstance	circumstance	NN
18637	16143	19	which	which	WDT
18637	16143	20	put	put	VBD
18637	16143	21	several	several	JJ
18637	16143	22	critics	critic	NNS
18637	16143	23	of	of	IN
18637	16143	24	President	President	NNP
18637	16143	25	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	16143	26	in	in	IN
18637	16143	27	jail	jail	NN
18637	16143	28	,	,	,
18637	16143	29	and	and	CC
18637	16143	30	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	16143	31	considerably	considerably	RB
18637	16143	32	aided	aid	VBN
18637	16143	33	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	16143	34	's	's	POS
18637	16143	35	election	election	NN
18637	16143	36	as	as	IN
18637	16143	37	President	President	NNP
18637	16143	38	in	in	IN
18637	16143	39	1800	1800	CD
18637	16143	40	.	.	.
18637	16144	1	Once	once	RB
18637	16144	2	in	in	IN
18637	16144	3	office	office	NN
18637	16144	4	,	,	,
18637	16144	5	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	16144	6	,	,	,
18637	16144	7	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	16144	8	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16144	9	appealed	appeal	VBD
18637	16144	10	to	to	IN
18637	16144	11	the	the	DT
18637	16144	12	discredited	discredited	JJ
18637	16144	13	principle	principle	NN
18637	16144	14	against	against	IN
18637	16144	15	partisan	partisan	JJ
18637	16144	16	critics	critic	NNS
18637	16144	17	.	.	.
18637	16145	1	Writing	write	VBG
18637	16145	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16145	3	friend	friend	NN
18637	16145	4	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	16145	5	McKean	McKean	NNP
18637	16145	6	of	of	IN
18637	16145	7	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	16145	8	in	in	IN
18637	16145	9	1803	1803	CD
18637	16145	10	anent	anent	JJ
18637	16145	11	such	such	JJ
18637	16145	12	critics	critic	NNS
18637	16145	13	,	,	,
18637	16145	14	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	16145	15	said	say	VBD
18637	16145	16	:	:	:
18637	16145	17	'	'	``
18637	16145	18	The	the	DT
18637	16145	19	federalists	federalist	NNS
18637	16145	20	having	have	VBG
18637	16145	21	failed	fail	VBN
18637	16145	22	in	in	IN
18637	16145	23	destroying	destroy	VBG
18637	16145	24	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16145	25	of	of	IN
18637	16145	26	the	the	DT
18637	16145	27	press	press	NN
18637	16145	28	by	by	IN
18637	16145	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16145	30	gag	gag	NN
18637	16145	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	16145	32	law	law	NN
18637	16145	33	,	,	,
18637	16145	34	seem	seem	VBP
18637	16145	35	to	to	TO
18637	16145	36	have	have	VB
18637	16145	37	attacked	attack	VBN
18637	16145	38	in	in	IN
18637	16145	39	an	an	DT
18637	16145	40	opposite	opposite	JJ
18637	16145	41	direction	direction	NN
18637	16145	42	;	;	:
18637	16145	43	that	that	DT
18637	16145	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	16145	45	by	by	IN
18637	16145	46	pushing	push	VBG
18637	16145	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16145	48	licentiousness	licentiousness	NN
18637	16145	49	and	and	CC
18637	16145	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16145	51	lying	lying	NN
18637	16145	52	to	to	IN
18637	16145	53	such	such	PDT
18637	16145	54	a	a	DT
18637	16145	55	degree	degree	NN
18637	16145	56	of	of	IN
18637	16145	57	prostitution	prostitution	NN
18637	16145	58	as	as	IN
18637	16145	59	to	to	TO
18637	16145	60	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	16145	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16145	62	of	of	IN
18637	16145	63	all	all	DT
18637	16145	64	credit	credit	NN
18637	16145	65	.	.	.
18637	16146	1	*	*	NFP
18637	16146	2	*	*	NFP
18637	16146	3	*	*	NFP
18637	16146	4	This	this	DT
18637	16146	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	16146	6	a	a	DT
18637	16146	7	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	16146	8	state	state	NN
18637	16146	9	of	of	IN
18637	16146	10	things	thing	NNS
18637	16146	11	,	,	,
18637	16146	12	and	and	CC
18637	16146	13	the	the	DT
18637	16146	14	press	press	NN
18637	16146	15	ought	ought	MD
18637	16146	16	to	to	TO
18637	16146	17	be	be	VB
18637	16146	18	restored	restore	VBN
18637	16146	19	to	to	IN
18637	16146	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16146	21	credibility	credibility	NN
18637	16146	22	if	if	IN
18637	16146	23	possible	possible	JJ
18637	16146	24	.	.	.
18637	16147	1	The	the	DT
18637	16147	2	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	16147	3	provided	provide	VBN
18637	16147	4	by	by	IN
18637	16147	5	the	the	DT
18637	16147	6	laws	law	NNS
18637	16147	7	of	of	IN
18637	16147	8	the	the	DT
18637	16147	9	States	States	NNPS
18637	16147	10	are	be	VBP
18637	16147	11	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	16147	12	for	for	IN
18637	16147	13	this	this	DT
18637	16147	14	,	,	,
18637	16147	15	if	if	IN
18637	16147	16	applied	apply	VBN
18637	16147	17	.	.	.
18637	16148	1	And	and	CC
18637	16148	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16148	3	have	have	VBP
18637	16148	4	,	,	,
18637	16148	5	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	16148	6	,	,	,
18637	16148	7	long	long	RB
18637	16148	8	thought	think	VBD
18637	16148	9	that	that	IN
18637	16148	10	a	a	DT
18637	16148	11	few	few	JJ
18637	16148	12	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	16148	13	of	of	IN
18637	16148	14	the	the	DT
18637	16148	15	most	most	RBS
18637	16148	16	prominent	prominent	JJ
18637	16148	17	offenders	offender	NNS
18637	16148	18	would	would	MD
18637	16148	19	have	have	VB
18637	16148	20	a	a	DT
18637	16148	21	wholesome	wholesome	JJ
18637	16148	22	effect	effect	NN
18637	16148	23	in	in	IN
18637	16148	24	restoring	restore	VBG
18637	16148	25	the	the	DT
18637	16148	26	integrity	integrity	NN
18637	16148	27	of	of	IN
18637	16148	28	the	the	DT
18637	16148	29	presses	press	NNS
18637	16148	30	.	.	.
18637	16149	1	Not	not	RB
18637	16149	2	a	a	DT
18637	16149	3	general	general	JJ
18637	16149	4	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	16149	5	,	,	,
18637	16149	6	for	for	IN
18637	16149	7	that	that	DT
18637	16149	8	would	would	MD
18637	16149	9	look	look	VB
18637	16149	10	like	like	IN
18637	16149	11	persecution	persecution	NN
18637	16149	12	;	;	:
18637	16149	13	but	but	CC
18637	16149	14	a	a	DT
18637	16149	15	selected	select	VBN
18637	16149	16	one	one	CD
18637	16149	17	.	.	.
18637	16149	18	'	'	''
18637	16150	1	Works	Works	NNP
18637	16150	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16150	3	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	16150	4	ed	ed	NNP
18637	16150	5	.	.	NNP
18637	16150	6	,	,	,
18637	16150	7	1905	1905	CD
18637	16150	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16150	9	,	,	,
18637	16150	10	IX	IX	NNP
18637	16150	11	451	451	CD
18637	16150	12	-	-	SYM
18637	16150	13	52	52	CD
18637	16150	14	.	.	.
18637	16151	1	"	"	``
18637	16151	2	In	in	IN
18637	16151	3	the	the	DT
18637	16151	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16151	5	Memorial	Memorial	NNP
18637	16151	6	Edition	Edition	NNP
18637	16151	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16151	8	of	of	IN
18637	16151	9	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	16151	10	's	's	POS
18637	16151	11	works	work	NNS
18637	16151	12	this	this	DT
18637	16151	13	letter	letter	NN
18637	16151	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	16151	15	not	not	RB
18637	16151	16	included	include	VBN
18637	16151	17	;	;	:
18637	16151	18	nor	nor	CC
18637	16151	19	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	16151	20	was	be	VBD
18637	16151	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16151	22	known	known	JJ
18637	16151	23	to	to	IN
18637	16151	24	the	the	DT
18637	16151	25	Honorable	honorable	JJ
18637	16151	26	Josephus	Josephus	NNP
18637	16151	27	Daniels	Daniels	NNP
18637	16151	28	,	,	,
18637	16151	29	whose	whose	WP$
18637	16151	30	enthusiastic	enthusiastic	JJ
18637	16151	31	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	16151	32	to	to	IN
18637	16151	33	one	one	CD
18637	16151	34	of	of	IN
18637	16151	35	these	these	DT
18637	16151	36	volumes	volume	NNS
18637	16151	37	makes	make	VBZ
18637	16151	38	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	16151	39	out	out	RP
18637	16151	40	to	to	TO
18637	16151	41	have	have	VB
18637	16151	42	been	be	VBN
18637	16151	43	the	the	DT
18637	16151	44	father	father	NN
18637	16151	45	of	of	IN
18637	16151	46	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16151	47	of	of	IN
18637	16151	48	speech	speech	NN
18637	16151	49	and	and	CC
18637	16151	50	press	press	NN
18637	16151	51	in	in	IN
18637	16151	52	this	this	DT
18637	16151	53	country	country	NN
18637	16151	54	,	,	,
18637	16151	55	if	if	IN
18637	16151	56	not	not	RB
18637	16151	57	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	16151	58	the	the	DT
18637	16151	59	world	world	NN
18637	16151	60	.	.	.
18637	16152	1	The	the	DT
18637	16152	2	sober	sober	JJ
18637	16152	3	truth	truth	NN
18637	16152	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	16152	5	that	that	IN
18637	16152	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16152	7	was	be	VBD
18637	16152	8	that	that	DT
18637	16152	9	archenemy	archenemy	NN
18637	16152	10	of	of	IN
18637	16152	11	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	16152	12	and	and	CC
18637	16152	13	of	of	IN
18637	16152	14	democracy	democracy	NN
18637	16152	15	,	,	,
18637	16152	16	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	16152	17	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	16152	18	,	,	,
18637	16152	19	who	who	WP
18637	16152	20	made	make	VBD
18637	16152	21	the	the	DT
18637	16152	22	greatest	great	JJS
18637	16152	23	single	single	JJ
18637	16152	24	contribution	contribution	NN
18637	16152	25	toward	toward	IN
18637	16152	26	rescuing	rescue	VBG
18637	16152	27	this	this	DT
18637	16152	28	particular	particular	JJ
18637	16152	29	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16152	30	as	as	IN
18637	16152	31	a	a	DT
18637	16152	32	political	political	JJ
18637	16152	33	weapon	weapon	NN
18637	16152	34	from	from	IN
18637	16152	35	the	the	DT
18637	16152	36	coils	coil	NNS
18637	16152	37	and	and	CC
18637	16152	38	toils	toil	NNS
18637	16152	39	of	of	IN
18637	16152	40	the	the	DT
18637	16152	41	common	common	JJ
18637	16152	42	law	law	NN
18637	16152	43	,	,	,
18637	16152	44	and	and	CC
18637	16152	45	that	that	IN
18637	16152	46	in	in	IN
18637	16152	47	connection	connection	NN
18637	16152	48	with	with	IN
18637	16152	49	one	one	CD
18637	16152	50	of	of	IN
18637	16152	51	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	16152	52	's	's	POS
18637	16152	53	'	'	``
18637	16152	54	selected	select	VBN
18637	16152	55	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	16152	56	.	.	.
18637	16152	57	'	'	''
18637	16153	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16153	2	refer	refer	VBP
18637	16153	3	to	to	IN
18637	16153	4	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	16153	5	's	's	POS
18637	16153	6	many	many	JJ
18637	16153	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	16153	8	times	time	NNS
18637	16153	9	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	16153	10	formula	formula	NN
18637	16153	11	in	in	IN
18637	16153	12	the	the	DT
18637	16153	13	Croswell	Croswell	NNP
18637	16153	14	case	case	NN
18637	16153	15	in	in	IN
18637	16153	16	1804	1804	CD
18637	16153	17	:	:	:
18637	16153	18	'	'	''
18637	16153	19	The	the	DT
18637	16153	20	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16153	21	of	of	IN
18637	16153	22	the	the	DT
18637	16153	23	press	press	NN
18637	16153	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	16153	25	the	the	DT
18637	16153	26	right	right	NN
18637	16153	27	to	to	TO
18637	16153	28	publish	publish	VB
18637	16153	29	with	with	IN
18637	16153	30	impunity	impunity	NN
18637	16153	31	,	,	,
18637	16153	32	truth	truth	NN
18637	16153	33	,	,	,
18637	16153	34	with	with	IN
18637	16153	35	good	good	JJ
18637	16153	36	motives	motive	NNS
18637	16153	37	,	,	,
18637	16153	38	for	for	IN
18637	16153	39	justifiable	justifiable	JJ
18637	16153	40	ends	end	NNS
18637	16153	41	though	though	IN
18637	16153	42	reflecting	reflect	VBG
18637	16153	43	on	on	IN
18637	16153	44	government	government	NN
18637	16153	45	,	,	,
18637	16153	46	magistracy	magistracy	NN
18637	16153	47	,	,	,
18637	16153	48	or	or	CC
18637	16153	49	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	16153	50	.	.	.
18637	16153	51	'	'	''
18637	16154	1	People	People	NNS
18637	16154	2	_	_	NNP
18637	16154	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	16154	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16154	5	Croswell	Croswell	NNP
18637	16154	6	,	,	,
18637	16154	7	3	3	CD
18637	16154	8	Johns	Johns	NNP
18637	16154	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16154	10	NY	NY	NNP
18637	16154	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16154	12	337	337	CD
18637	16154	13	.	.	.
18637	16155	1	Equipped	equip	VBN
18637	16155	2	with	with	IN
18637	16155	3	this	this	DT
18637	16155	4	brocard	brocard	NN
18637	16155	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16155	6	State	state	NN
18637	16155	7	courts	court	NNS
18637	16155	8	working	work	VBG
18637	16155	9	in	in	IN
18637	16155	10	co	co	NN
18637	16155	11	-	-	NN
18637	16155	12	operation	operation	NN
18637	16155	13	with	with	IN
18637	16155	14	juries	jury	NNS
18637	16155	15	,	,	,
18637	16155	16	whose	whose	WP$
18637	16155	17	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	16155	18	usually	usually	RB
18637	16155	19	reflected	reflect	VBD
18637	16155	20	the	the	DT
18637	16155	21	robustiousness	robustiousness	NN
18637	16155	22	of	of	IN
18637	16155	23	American	american	JJ
18637	16155	24	political	political	JJ
18637	16155	25	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	16155	26	before	before	IN
18637	16155	27	the	the	DT
18637	16155	28	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	16155	29	War	War	NNP
18637	16155	30	,	,	,
18637	16155	31	gradually	gradually	RB
18637	16155	32	wrote	write	VBD
18637	16155	33	into	into	IN
18637	16155	34	the	the	DT
18637	16155	35	common	common	JJ
18637	16155	36	law	law	NN
18637	16155	37	of	of	IN
18637	16155	38	the	the	DT
18637	16155	39	States	States	NNPS
18637	16155	40	the	the	DT
18637	16155	41	principle	principle	NN
18637	16155	42	of	of	IN
18637	16155	43	'	'	``
18637	16155	44	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	16155	45	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	16155	46	,	,	,
18637	16155	47	'	'	''
18637	16155	48	which	which	WDT
18637	16155	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	16155	50	a	a	DT
18637	16155	51	notification	notification	NN
18637	16155	52	to	to	IN
18637	16155	53	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
18637	16155	54	in	in	IN
18637	16155	55	libel	libel	NN
18637	16155	56	suits	suit	VBZ
18637	16155	57	that	that	IN
18637	16155	58	if	if	IN
18637	16155	59	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16155	60	are	be	VBP
18637	16155	61	unlucky	unlucky	JJ
18637	16155	62	enough	enough	RB
18637	16155	63	to	to	TO
18637	16155	64	be	be	VB
18637	16155	65	officeholders	officeholder	NNS
18637	16155	66	or	or	CC
18637	16155	67	office	office	NN
18637	16155	68	seekers	seeker	NNS
18637	16155	69	,	,	,
18637	16155	70	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16155	71	must	must	MD
18637	16155	72	be	be	VB
18637	16155	73	prepared	prepare	VBN
18637	16155	74	to	to	TO
18637	16155	75	shoulder	shoulder	VB
18637	16155	76	the	the	DT
18637	16155	77	almost	almost	RB
18637	16155	78	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	16155	79	burden	burden	NN
18637	16155	80	of	of	IN
18637	16155	81	showing	show	VBG
18637	16155	82	defendant	defendant	NNP
18637	16155	83	's	's	POS
18637	16155	84	'	'	``
18637	16155	85	special	special	JJ
18637	16155	86	malice	malice	NN
18637	16155	87	.	.	.
18637	16155	88	'	'	''
18637	16156	1	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	16156	2	,	,	,
18637	16156	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16156	4	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	16156	5	Limitations	Limitations	NNPS
18637	16156	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16156	7	,	,	,
18637	16156	8	Chap	Chap	NNP
18637	16156	9	.	.	.
18637	16157	1	XII	XII	NNP
18637	16157	2	:	:	:
18637	16157	3	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
18637	16157	4	A.	A.	NNP
18637	16157	5	Dawson	Dawson	NNP
18637	16157	6	,	,	,
18637	16157	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16157	8	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	16157	9	of	of	IN
18637	16157	10	the	the	DT
18637	16157	11	Press	Press	NNP
18637	16157	12	,	,	,
18637	16157	13	A	A	NNP
18637	16157	14	Study	Study	NNP
18637	16157	15	of	of	IN
18637	16157	16	the	the	DT
18637	16157	17	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	16157	18	of	of	IN
18637	16157	19	'	'	''
18637	16157	20	Qualified	Qualified	NNP
18637	16157	21	Privilege	Privilege	NNP
18637	16157	22	'	'	''
18637	16157	23	_	_	NNP
18637	16157	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16157	25	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	16157	26	Univ	Univ	NNP
18637	16157	27	.	.	.
18637	16158	1	Press	Press	NNP
18637	16158	2	,	,	,
18637	16158	3	1924	1924	CD
18637	16158	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16158	5	.	.	.
18637	16158	6	"	"	''
18637	16159	1	Edward	Edward	NNP
18637	16159	2	S.	S.	NNP
18637	16159	3	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	16159	4	,	,	,
18637	16159	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16159	6	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	16159	7	Against	Against	NNP
18637	16159	8	Government	Government	NNP
18637	16159	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16159	10	.	.	.
18637	16160	1	157	157	CD
18637	16160	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16160	3	159	159	CD
18637	16160	4	fn	fn	CD
18637	16160	5	.	.	.
18637	16161	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16161	2	L.S.U.	L.S.U.	NNP
18637	16162	1	Press	Press	NNP
18637	16162	2	,	,	,
18637	16162	3	1948	1948	CD
18637	16162	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16162	5	.	.	.
18637	16163	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16163	2	71	71	CD
18637	16163	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16163	4	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	16163	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16163	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16163	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16163	8	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	16163	9	,	,	,
18637	16163	10	205	205	CD
18637	16163	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16163	12	454	454	CD
18637	16163	13	,	,	,
18637	16163	14	462	462	CD
18637	16163	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16163	16	1907	1907	CD
18637	16163	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16163	18	.	.	.
18637	16164	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16164	2	72	72	CD
18637	16164	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16164	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16164	5	.	.	.
18637	16165	1	461	461	CD
18637	16165	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16165	3	73	73	CD
18637	16165	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16165	5	Prudential	Prudential	NNP
18637	16165	6	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	16165	7	.	.	.
18637	16166	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16166	2	_	_	NNP
18637	16166	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	16166	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16166	5	Cheek	Cheek	NNP
18637	16166	6	,	,	,
18637	16166	7	259	259	CD
18637	16166	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16166	9	530	530	CD
18637	16166	10	,	,	,
18637	16166	11	543	543	CD
18637	16166	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16166	13	1922	1922	CD
18637	16166	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16166	15	.	.	.
18637	16167	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16167	2	74	74	CD
18637	16167	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16167	4	Schenck	Schenck	NNP
18637	16167	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16167	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16167	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16167	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16167	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16167	10	,	,	,
18637	16167	11	249	249	CD
18637	16167	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16167	13	47	47	CD
18637	16167	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16167	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	16167	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16167	17	;	;	:
18637	16167	18	and	and	CC
18637	16167	19	_	_	NNP
18637	16167	20	see	see	VBP
18637	16167	21	_	_	NNP
18637	16167	22	below	below	RB
18637	16167	23	.	.	.
18637	16168	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16168	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	16168	3	's	's	POS
18637	16168	4	Note	note	NN
18637	16168	5	:	:	:
18637	16168	6	Reference	reference	NN
18637	16168	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	16168	8	to	to	IN
18637	16168	9	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	16168	10	75	75	CD
18637	16168	11	,	,	,
18637	16168	12	below	below	RB
18637	16168	13	.	.	.
18637	16168	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16169	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16169	2	75	75	CD
18637	16169	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16169	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16169	5	See	See	NNP
18637	16169	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16169	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16169	8	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	16169	9	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	16169	10	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16169	11	in	in	IN
18637	16169	12	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	16169	13	_	_	NNP
18637	16169	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	16169	15	_	_	NNP
18637	16169	16	California	California	NNP
18637	16169	17	,	,	,
18637	16169	18	274	274	CD
18637	16169	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16169	20	357	357	CD
18637	16169	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16169	22	1927	1927	CD
18637	16169	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16169	24	;	;	:
18637	16169	25	and	and	CC
18637	16169	26	cases	case	NNS
18637	16169	27	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	16169	28	below	below	RB
18637	16169	29	.	.	.
18637	16170	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16170	2	76	76	CD
18637	16170	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16170	4	Fiske	Fiske	NNP
18637	16170	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16170	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16170	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16170	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	16170	9	,	,	,
18637	16170	10	274	274	CD
18637	16170	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16170	12	380	380	CD
18637	16170	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16170	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	16170	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16170	16	.	.	.
18637	16171	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16171	2	77	77	CD
18637	16171	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16171	4	133	133	CD
18637	16171	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16171	6	333	333	CD
18637	16171	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16171	8	1890	1890	CD
18637	16171	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16171	10	.	.	.
18637	16172	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16172	2	78	78	CD
18637	16172	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16172	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16172	5	.	.	.
18637	16173	1	341	341	CD
18637	16173	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16173	3	342	342	CD
18637	16173	4	.	.	.
18637	16174	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16174	2	79	79	CD
18637	16174	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16174	4	236	236	CD
18637	16174	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16174	6	273	273	CD
18637	16174	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16174	8	1915	1915	CD
18637	16174	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16174	10	.	.	.
18637	16175	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16175	2	80	80	CD
18637	16175	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16175	4	Fiske	Fiske	NNP
18637	16175	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16175	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16175	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16175	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	16175	9	,	,	,
18637	16175	10	274	274	CD
18637	16175	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16175	12	380	380	CD
18637	16175	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16175	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	16175	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16175	16	.	.	.
18637	16176	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16176	2	81	81	CD
18637	16176	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16176	4	Stromberg	Stromberg	NNP
18637	16176	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16176	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16176	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16176	8	California	California	NNP
18637	16176	9	,	,	,
18637	16176	10	283	283	CD
18637	16176	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16176	12	359	359	CD
18637	16176	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16176	14	1931	1931	CD
18637	16176	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16176	16	.	.	.
18637	16177	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16177	2	82	82	CD
18637	16177	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16177	4	De	De	NNP
18637	16177	5	Jonge	Jonge	NNP
18637	16177	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16177	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16177	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16177	9	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	16177	10	,	,	,
18637	16177	11	299	299	CD
18637	16177	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16177	13	353	353	CD
18637	16177	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16177	15	1937	1937	CD
18637	16177	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16177	17	.	.	.
18637	16178	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16178	2	83	83	CD
18637	16178	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16178	4	249	249	CD
18637	16178	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16178	6	47	47	CD
18637	16178	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16178	8	1919	1919	CD
18637	16178	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16178	10	.	.	.
18637	16179	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16179	2	84	84	CD
18637	16179	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16179	4	40	40	CD
18637	16179	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	16179	6	.	.	.
18637	16180	1	217	217	CD
18637	16180	2	,	,	,
18637	16180	3	219	219	CD
18637	16180	4	.	.	.
18637	16181	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16181	2	85	85	CD
18637	16181	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16181	4	205	205	CD
18637	16181	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16181	6	454	454	CD
18637	16181	7	,	,	,
18637	16181	8	462	462	CD
18637	16181	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16181	10	1907	1907	CD
18637	16181	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16181	12	.	.	.
18637	16182	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16182	2	86	86	CD
18637	16182	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16182	4	249	249	CD
18637	16182	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16182	6	47	47	CD
18637	16182	7	,	,	,
18637	16182	8	51	51	CD
18637	16182	9	-	-	SYM
18637	16182	10	52	52	CD
18637	16182	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16182	12	1919	1919	CD
18637	16182	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16182	14	.	.	.
18637	16183	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16183	2	87	87	CD
18637	16183	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16183	4	249	249	CD
18637	16183	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16183	6	204	204	CD
18637	16183	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16183	8	1919	1919	CD
18637	16183	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16183	10	.	.	.
18637	16184	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16184	2	88	88	CD
18637	16184	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16184	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16184	5	.	.	.
18637	16185	1	206	206	CD
18637	16185	2	.	.	.
18637	16186	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16186	2	89	89	CD
18637	16186	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16186	4	249	249	CD
18637	16186	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16186	6	211	211	CD
18637	16186	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16186	8	1919	1919	CD
18637	16186	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16186	10	.	.	.
18637	16187	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16187	2	90	90	CD
18637	16187	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16187	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16187	5	.	.	.
18637	16188	1	215	215	CD
18637	16188	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16188	3	216	216	CD
18637	16188	4	.	.	.
18637	16189	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16189	2	91	91	CD
18637	16189	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16189	4	250	250	CD
18637	16189	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16189	6	616	616	CD
18637	16189	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16189	8	1919	1919	CD
18637	16189	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16189	10	.	.	.
18637	16190	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16190	2	92	92	CD
18637	16190	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16190	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16190	5	.	.	.
18637	16191	1	627	627	CD
18637	16191	2	.	.	.
18637	16192	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16192	2	should	should	MD
18637	16192	3	be	be	VB
18637	16192	4	noted	note	VBN
18637	16192	5	that	that	IN
18637	16192	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16192	7	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	16192	8	couples	couple	NNS
18637	16192	9	with	with	IN
18637	16192	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16192	11	invocation	invocation	NN
18637	16192	12	of	of	IN
18637	16192	13	the	the	DT
18637	16192	14	clear	clear	JJ
18637	16192	15	and	and	CC
18637	16192	16	present	present	JJ
18637	16192	17	danger	danger	NN
18637	16192	18	test	test	NN
18637	16192	19	in	in	IN
18637	16192	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16192	21	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	16192	22	in	in	IN
18637	16192	23	this	this	DT
18637	16192	24	case	case	NN
18637	16192	25	the	the	DT
18637	16192	26	contention	contention	NN
18637	16192	27	that	that	WDT
18637	16192	28	rightly	rightly	RB
18637	16192	29	construed	construe	VBD
18637	16192	30	the	the	DT
18637	16192	31	act	act	NN
18637	16192	32	of	of	IN
18637	16192	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16192	34	involved	involve	VBN
18637	16192	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16192	36	The	the	DT
18637	16192	37	Espionage	Espionage	NNP
18637	16192	38	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16192	39	of	of	IN
18637	16192	40	May	May	NNP
18637	16192	41	16	16	CD
18637	16192	42	,	,	,
18637	16192	43	1918	1918	CD
18637	16192	44	;	;	:
18637	16192	45	40	40	CD
18637	16192	46	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	16192	47	.	.	.
18637	16193	1	553	553	CD
18637	16193	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16193	3	required	require	VBD
18637	16193	4	that	that	IN
18637	16193	5	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	16193	6	's	's	POS
18637	16193	7	intent	intent	NN
18637	16193	8	be	be	VB
18637	16193	9	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	16193	10	proved	prove	VBN
18637	16193	11	.	.	.
18637	16194	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16194	2	wrote	write	VBD
18637	16194	3	:	:	:
18637	16194	4	"	"	``
18637	16194	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16194	6	am	be	VBP
18637	16194	7	aware	aware	JJ
18637	16194	8	of	of	IN
18637	16194	9	course	course	NN
18637	16194	10	that	that	WDT
18637	16194	11	the	the	DT
18637	16194	12	word	word	NN
18637	16194	13	intent	intent	NN
18637	16194	14	as	as	IN
18637	16194	15	vaguely	vaguely	RB
18637	16194	16	used	use	VBN
18637	16194	17	in	in	IN
18637	16194	18	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	16194	19	legal	legal	JJ
18637	16194	20	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	16194	21	means	mean	VBZ
18637	16194	22	no	no	DT
18637	16194	23	more	more	JJR
18637	16194	24	than	than	IN
18637	16194	25	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	16194	26	at	at	IN
18637	16194	27	the	the	DT
18637	16194	28	time	time	NN
18637	16194	29	of	of	IN
18637	16194	30	the	the	DT
18637	16194	31	act	act	NN
18637	16194	32	that	that	WDT
18637	16194	33	the	the	DT
18637	16194	34	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	16194	35	said	say	VBD
18637	16194	36	to	to	TO
18637	16194	37	be	be	VB
18637	16194	38	intended	intend	VBN
18637	16194	39	will	will	MD
18637	16194	40	ensue	ensue	VB
18637	16194	41	.	.	.
18637	16195	1	Even	even	RB
18637	16195	2	less	less	JJR
18637	16195	3	than	than	IN
18637	16195	4	that	that	DT
18637	16195	5	will	will	MD
18637	16195	6	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	16195	7	the	the	DT
18637	16195	8	general	general	JJ
18637	16195	9	principle	principle	NN
18637	16195	10	of	of	IN
18637	16195	11	civil	civil	JJ
18637	16195	12	and	and	CC
18637	16195	13	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16195	14	liability	liability	NN
18637	16195	15	.	.	.
18637	16196	1	A	a	DT
18637	16196	2	man	man	NN
18637	16196	3	may	may	MD
18637	16196	4	have	have	VB
18637	16196	5	to	to	TO
18637	16196	6	pay	pay	VB
18637	16196	7	damages	damage	NNS
18637	16196	8	,	,	,
18637	16196	9	may	may	MD
18637	16196	10	be	be	VB
18637	16196	11	sent	send	VBN
18637	16196	12	to	to	IN
18637	16196	13	prison	prison	NN
18637	16196	14	,	,	,
18637	16196	15	at	at	IN
18637	16196	16	common	common	JJ
18637	16196	17	law	law	NN
18637	16196	18	might	may	MD
18637	16196	19	be	be	VB
18637	16196	20	hanged	hang	VBN
18637	16196	21	,	,	,
18637	16196	22	if	if	IN
18637	16196	23	at	at	IN
18637	16196	24	the	the	DT
18637	16196	25	time	time	NN
18637	16196	26	of	of	IN
18637	16196	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16196	28	act	act	NN
18637	16196	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16196	30	knew	know	VBD
18637	16196	31	facts	fact	NNS
18637	16196	32	from	from	IN
18637	16196	33	which	which	WDT
18637	16196	34	common	common	JJ
18637	16196	35	experience	experience	NN
18637	16196	36	showed	show	VBD
18637	16196	37	that	that	IN
18637	16196	38	the	the	DT
18637	16196	39	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	16196	40	would	would	MD
18637	16196	41	follow	follow	VB
18637	16196	42	,	,	,
18637	16196	43	whether	whether	IN
18637	16196	44	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16196	45	individually	individually	RB
18637	16196	46	could	could	MD
18637	16196	47	foresee	foresee	VB
18637	16196	48	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16196	49	or	or	CC
18637	16196	50	not	not	RB
18637	16196	51	.	.	.
18637	16197	1	But	but	CC
18637	16197	2	,	,	,
18637	16197	3	when	when	WRB
18637	16197	4	words	word	NNS
18637	16197	5	are	be	VBP
18637	16197	6	used	use	VBN
18637	16197	7	exactly	exactly	RB
18637	16197	8	,	,	,
18637	16197	9	a	a	DT
18637	16197	10	deed	deed	NN
18637	16197	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	16197	12	not	not	RB
18637	16197	13	done	do	VBN
18637	16197	14	with	with	IN
18637	16197	15	intent	intent	NN
18637	16197	16	to	to	TO
18637	16197	17	produce	produce	VB
18637	16197	18	a	a	DT
18637	16197	19	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	16197	20	unless	unless	IN
18637	16197	21	that	that	DT
18637	16197	22	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	16197	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	16197	24	the	the	DT
18637	16197	25	aim	aim	NN
18637	16197	26	of	of	IN
18637	16197	27	the	the	DT
18637	16197	28	deed	deed	NN
18637	16197	29	.	.	.
18637	16198	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16198	2	may	may	MD
18637	16198	3	be	be	VB
18637	16198	4	obvious	obvious	JJ
18637	16198	5	,	,	,
18637	16198	6	and	and	CC
18637	16198	7	obvious	obvious	JJ
18637	16198	8	to	to	IN
18637	16198	9	the	the	DT
18637	16198	10	actor	actor	NN
18637	16198	11	,	,	,
18637	16198	12	that	that	IN
18637	16198	13	the	the	DT
18637	16198	14	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	16198	15	will	will	MD
18637	16198	16	follow	follow	VB
18637	16198	17	,	,	,
18637	16198	18	and	and	CC
18637	16198	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16198	20	may	may	MD
18637	16198	21	be	be	VB
18637	16198	22	liable	liable	JJ
18637	16198	23	for	for	IN
18637	16198	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16198	25	even	even	RB
18637	16198	26	if	if	IN
18637	16198	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16198	28	regrets	regret	VBZ
18637	16198	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16198	30	,	,	,
18637	16198	31	but	but	CC
18637	16198	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16198	33	does	do	VBZ
18637	16198	34	not	not	RB
18637	16198	35	do	do	VB
18637	16198	36	the	the	DT
18637	16198	37	act	act	NN
18637	16198	38	with	with	IN
18637	16198	39	intent	intent	NN
18637	16198	40	to	to	TO
18637	16198	41	produce	produce	VB
18637	16198	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16198	43	unless	unless	IN
18637	16198	44	to	to	TO
18637	16198	45	aim	aim	VB
18637	16198	46	to	to	TO
18637	16198	47	produce	produce	VB
18637	16198	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16198	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	16198	50	the	the	DT
18637	16198	51	proximate	proximate	NN
18637	16198	52	motive	motive	NN
18637	16198	53	of	of	IN
18637	16198	54	the	the	DT
18637	16198	55	specific	specific	JJ
18637	16198	56	act	act	NN
18637	16198	57	,	,	,
18637	16198	58	although	although	IN
18637	16198	59	there	there	EX
18637	16198	60	may	may	MD
18637	16198	61	be	be	VB
18637	16198	62	some	some	DT
18637	16198	63	deeper	deep	JJR
18637	16198	64	motive	motive	JJ
18637	16198	65	behind	behind	RB
18637	16198	66	.	.	.
18637	16199	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16199	2	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	16199	3	to	to	IN
18637	16199	4	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16199	5	that	that	IN
18637	16199	6	this	this	DT
18637	16199	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	16199	8	must	must	MD
18637	16199	9	be	be	VB
18637	16199	10	taken	take	VBN
18637	16199	11	to	to	TO
18637	16199	12	use	use	VB
18637	16199	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16199	14	words	word	NNS
18637	16199	15	in	in	IN
18637	16199	16	a	a	DT
18637	16199	17	strict	strict	JJ
18637	16199	18	and	and	CC
18637	16199	19	accurate	accurate	JJ
18637	16199	20	sense	sense	NN
18637	16199	21	.	.	.
18637	16199	22	"	"	''
18637	16200	1	250	250	CD
18637	16200	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16200	3	at	at	IN
18637	16200	4	626	626	CD
18637	16200	5	-	-	SYM
18637	16200	6	627	627	CD
18637	16200	7	.	.	.
18637	16201	1	In	in	IN
18637	16201	2	the	the	DT
18637	16201	3	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	16201	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	16201	5	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	16201	6	Letters	Letters	NNP
18637	16201	7	this	this	DT
18637	16201	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	16201	9	the	the	DT
18637	16201	10	main	main	JJ
18637	16201	11	point	point	NN
18637	16201	12	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	16201	13	by	by	IN
18637	16201	14	the	the	DT
18637	16201	15	two	two	CD
18637	16201	16	correspondents	correspondent	NNS
18637	16201	17	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	16201	18	the	the	DT
18637	16201	19	Abrams	Abrams	NNP
18637	16201	20	Case	Case	NNP
18637	16201	21	;	;	:
18637	16201	22	the	the	DT
18637	16201	23	clear	clear	JJ
18637	16201	24	and	and	CC
18637	16201	25	present	present	JJ
18637	16201	26	danger	danger	NN
18637	16201	27	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	16201	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	16201	29	not	not	RB
18637	16201	30	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	16201	31	.	.	.
18637	16202	1	2	2	CD
18637	16202	2	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	16202	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	16202	4	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	16202	5	Letters	Letters	NNPS
18637	16202	6	,	,	,
18637	16202	7	29	29	CD
18637	16202	8	,	,	,
18637	16202	9	31	31	CD
18637	16202	10	,	,	,
18637	16202	11	32	32	CD
18637	16202	12	,	,	,
18637	16202	13	42	42	CD
18637	16202	14	,	,	,
18637	16202	15	44	44	CD
18637	16202	16	-	-	SYM
18637	16202	17	45	45	CD
18637	16202	18	,	,	,
18637	16202	19	48	48	CD
18637	16202	20	,	,	,
18637	16202	21	65	65	CD
18637	16202	22	.	.	.
18637	16203	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16203	2	93	93	CD
18637	16203	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16203	4	251	251	CD
18637	16203	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16203	6	466	466	CD
18637	16203	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16203	8	1920	1920	CD
18637	16203	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16203	10	.	.	.
18637	16204	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16204	2	94	94	CD
18637	16204	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16204	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16204	5	.	.	.
18637	16205	1	479	479	CD
18637	16205	2	.	.	.
18637	16206	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16206	2	See	See	NNP
18637	16206	3	also	also	RB
18637	16206	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16206	5	to	to	IN
18637	16206	6	the	the	DT
18637	16206	7	same	same	JJ
18637	16206	8	effect	effect	NN
18637	16206	9	:	:	:
18637	16206	10	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	16206	11	_	_	NNP
18637	16206	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	16206	13	_	_	NNP
18637	16206	14	United	United	NNP
18637	16206	15	States	States	NNP
18637	16206	16	,	,	,
18637	16206	17	252	252	CD
18637	16206	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16206	19	239	239	CD
18637	16206	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16206	21	1920	1920	CD
18637	16206	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16206	23	.	.	.
18637	16207	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16207	2	95	95	CD
18637	16207	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16207	4	268	268	CD
18637	16207	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16207	6	652	652	CD
18637	16207	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16207	8	1925	1925	CD
18637	16207	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16207	10	.	.	.
18637	16208	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16208	2	96	96	CD
18637	16208	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16208	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16208	5	.	.	.
18637	16209	1	668	668	CD
18637	16209	2	,	,	,
18637	16209	3	669	669	CD
18637	16209	4	.	.	.
18637	16210	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16210	2	97	97	CD
18637	16210	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16210	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16210	5	.	.	.
18637	16211	1	670	670	CD
18637	16211	2	.	.	.
18637	16212	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16212	2	98	98	CD
18637	16212	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16212	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16212	5	.	.	.
18637	16213	1	671	671	CD
18637	16213	2	.	.	.
18637	16214	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16214	2	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	16214	3	presented	present	VBD
18637	16214	4	a	a	DT
18637	16214	5	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	16214	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16214	7	for	for	IN
18637	16214	8	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16214	9	and	and	CC
18637	16214	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16214	11	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	16214	12	which	which	WDT
18637	16214	13	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	16214	14	a	a	DT
18637	16214	15	curious	curious	JJ
18637	16214	16	note	note	NN
18637	16214	17	of	of	IN
18637	16214	18	fatalism	fatalism	NN
18637	16214	19	.	.	.
18637	16215	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16215	2	said	say	VBD
18637	16215	3	:	:	:
18637	16215	4	"	"	``
18637	16215	5	If	if	IN
18637	16215	6	what	what	WP
18637	16215	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16215	8	think	think	VBP
18637	16215	9	the	the	DT
18637	16215	10	correct	correct	JJ
18637	16215	11	test	test	NN
18637	16215	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	16215	13	applied	apply	VBN
18637	16215	14	,	,	,
18637	16215	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16215	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	16215	17	manifest	manifest	NN
18637	16215	18	that	that	IN
18637	16215	19	there	there	EX
18637	16215	20	was	be	VBD
18637	16215	21	no	no	DT
18637	16215	22	present	present	JJ
18637	16215	23	danger	danger	NN
18637	16215	24	of	of	IN
18637	16215	25	an	an	DT
18637	16215	26	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	16215	27	to	to	TO
18637	16215	28	overthrow	overthrow	VB
18637	16215	29	the	the	DT
18637	16215	30	government	government	NN
18637	16215	31	by	by	IN
18637	16215	32	force	force	NN
18637	16215	33	on	on	IN
18637	16215	34	the	the	DT
18637	16215	35	part	part	NN
18637	16215	36	of	of	IN
18637	16215	37	the	the	DT
18637	16215	38	admittedly	admittedly	RB
18637	16215	39	small	small	JJ
18637	16215	40	minority	minority	NN
18637	16215	41	who	who	WP
18637	16215	42	shared	share	VBD
18637	16215	43	the	the	DT
18637	16215	44	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	16215	45	's	's	POS
18637	16215	46	views	view	NNS
18637	16215	47	.	.	.
18637	16216	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16216	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	16216	3	said	say	VBN
18637	16216	4	that	that	IN
18637	16216	5	this	this	DT
18637	16216	6	Manifesto	Manifesto	NNP
18637	16216	7	was	be	VBD
18637	16216	8	more	more	JJR
18637	16216	9	than	than	IN
18637	16216	10	a	a	DT
18637	16216	11	theory	theory	NN
18637	16216	12	,	,	,
18637	16216	13	that	that	IN
18637	16216	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16216	15	was	be	VBD
18637	16216	16	an	an	DT
18637	16216	17	incitement	incitement	NN
18637	16216	18	.	.	.
18637	16217	1	Every	every	DT
18637	16217	2	idea	idea	NN
18637	16217	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	16217	4	an	an	DT
18637	16217	5	incitement	incitement	NN
18637	16217	6	.	.	.
18637	16218	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16218	2	offers	offer	VBZ
18637	16218	3	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16218	4	for	for	IN
18637	16218	5	belief	belief	NN
18637	16218	6	,	,	,
18637	16218	7	and	and	CC
18637	16218	8	,	,	,
18637	16218	9	if	if	IN
18637	16218	10	believed	believe	VBN
18637	16218	11	,	,	,
18637	16218	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16218	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	16218	14	acted	act	VBN
18637	16218	15	on	on	IN
18637	16218	16	unless	unless	IN
18637	16218	17	some	some	DT
18637	16218	18	other	other	JJ
18637	16218	19	belief	belief	NN
18637	16218	20	outweighs	outweigh	VBZ
18637	16218	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16218	22	,	,	,
18637	16218	23	or	or	CC
18637	16218	24	some	some	DT
18637	16218	25	failure	failure	NN
18637	16218	26	of	of	IN
18637	16218	27	energy	energy	NN
18637	16218	28	stifles	stifle	VBZ
18637	16218	29	the	the	DT
18637	16218	30	movement	movement	NN
18637	16218	31	at	at	IN
18637	16218	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16218	33	birth	birth	NN
18637	16218	34	.	.	.
18637	16219	1	The	the	DT
18637	16219	2	only	only	JJ
18637	16219	3	difference	difference	NN
18637	16219	4	between	between	IN
18637	16219	5	the	the	DT
18637	16219	6	expression	expression	NN
18637	16219	7	of	of	IN
18637	16219	8	an	an	DT
18637	16219	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16219	10	and	and	CC
18637	16219	11	an	an	DT
18637	16219	12	incitement	incitement	NN
18637	16219	13	in	in	IN
18637	16219	14	the	the	DT
18637	16219	15	narrower	narrow	JJR
18637	16219	16	sense	sense	NN
18637	16219	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	16219	18	the	the	DT
18637	16219	19	speaker	speaker	NN
18637	16219	20	's	's	POS
18637	16219	21	enthusiasm	enthusiasm	NN
18637	16219	22	for	for	IN
18637	16219	23	the	the	DT
18637	16219	24	result	result	NN
18637	16219	25	.	.	.
18637	16220	1	Eloquence	eloquence	NN
18637	16220	2	may	may	MD
18637	16220	3	set	set	VB
18637	16220	4	fire	fire	NN
18637	16220	5	to	to	IN
18637	16220	6	reason	reason	NN
18637	16220	7	.	.	.
18637	16221	1	But	but	CC
18637	16221	2	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	16221	3	may	may	MD
18637	16221	4	be	be	VB
18637	16221	5	thought	think	VBN
18637	16221	6	of	of	IN
18637	16221	7	the	the	DT
18637	16221	8	redundant	redundant	JJ
18637	16221	9	discourse	discourse	NN
18637	16221	10	before	before	IN
18637	16221	11	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16221	12	,	,	,
18637	16221	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16221	14	had	have	VBD
18637	16221	15	no	no	DT
18637	16221	16	chance	chance	NN
18637	16221	17	of	of	IN
18637	16221	18	starting	start	VBG
18637	16221	19	a	a	DT
18637	16221	20	present	present	JJ
18637	16221	21	conflagration	conflagration	NN
18637	16221	22	.	.	.
18637	16222	1	If	if	IN
18637	16222	2	,	,	,
18637	16222	3	in	in	IN
18637	16222	4	the	the	DT
18637	16222	5	long	long	JJ
18637	16222	6	run	run	NN
18637	16222	7	,	,	,
18637	16222	8	the	the	DT
18637	16222	9	beliefs	belief	NNS
18637	16222	10	expressed	express	VBN
18637	16222	11	in	in	IN
18637	16222	12	proletarian	proletarian	JJ
18637	16222	13	dictatorship	dictatorship	NN
18637	16222	14	are	be	VBP
18637	16222	15	destined	destine	VBN
18637	16222	16	to	to	TO
18637	16222	17	be	be	VB
18637	16222	18	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	16222	19	by	by	IN
18637	16222	20	the	the	DT
18637	16222	21	dominant	dominant	JJ
18637	16222	22	forces	force	NNS
18637	16222	23	of	of	IN
18637	16222	24	the	the	DT
18637	16222	25	community	community	NN
18637	16222	26	,	,	,
18637	16222	27	the	the	DT
18637	16222	28	only	only	JJ
18637	16222	29	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	16222	30	of	of	IN
18637	16222	31	free	free	JJ
18637	16222	32	speech	speech	NN
18637	16222	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	16222	34	that	that	IN
18637	16222	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16222	36	should	should	MD
18637	16222	37	be	be	VB
18637	16222	38	given	give	VBN
18637	16222	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16222	40	chance	chance	NN
18637	16222	41	and	and	CC
18637	16222	42	have	have	VBP
18637	16222	43	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16222	44	way	way	NN
18637	16222	45	.	.	.
18637	16222	46	"	"	''
18637	16223	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	16223	2	.	.	.
18637	16224	1	673	673	CD
18637	16224	2	.	.	.
18637	16225	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16225	2	99	99	CD
18637	16225	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16225	4	274	274	CD
18637	16225	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16225	6	357	357	CD
18637	16225	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16225	8	1927	1927	CD
18637	16225	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16225	10	.	.	.
18637	16226	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16226	2	100	100	CD
18637	16226	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16226	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16226	5	.	.	.
18637	16227	1	373	373	CD
18637	16227	2	,	,	,
18637	16227	3	377	377	CD
18637	16227	4	.	.	.
18637	16228	1	Apparently	apparently	RB
18637	16228	2	this	this	DT
18637	16228	3	means	mean	VBZ
18637	16228	4	that	that	IN
18637	16228	5	the	the	DT
18637	16228	6	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	16228	7	test	test	NN
18637	16228	8	of	of	IN
18637	16228	9	the	the	DT
18637	16228	10	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	16228	11	of	of	IN
18637	16228	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	16228	13	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	16228	14	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16228	15	of	of	IN
18637	16228	16	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	16228	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	16228	18	whether	whether	IN
18637	16228	19	there	there	EX
18637	16228	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	16228	21	still	still	RB
18637	16228	22	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	16228	23	time	time	NN
18637	16228	24	to	to	TO
18637	16228	25	educate	educate	VB
18637	16228	26	the	the	DT
18637	16228	27	utterers	utterer	NNS
18637	16228	28	out	out	IN
18637	16228	29	of	of	IN
18637	16228	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16228	31	mistaken	mistaken	JJ
18637	16228	32	frame	frame	NN
18637	16228	33	of	of	IN
18637	16228	34	mind	mind	NN
18637	16228	35	,	,	,
18637	16228	36	and	and	CC
18637	16228	37	the	the	DT
18637	16228	38	final	final	JJ
18637	16228	39	say	say	NN
18637	16228	40	on	on	IN
18637	16228	41	this	this	DT
18637	16228	42	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	16228	43	recondite	recondite	JJ
18637	16228	44	matter	matter	NN
18637	16228	45	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	16228	46	with	with	IN
18637	16228	47	the	the	DT
18637	16228	48	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16228	49	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16228	50	!	!	.
18637	16229	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16229	2	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	16229	3	also	also	RB
18637	16229	4	asserts	assert	VBZ
18637	16229	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16229	6	274	274	CD
18637	16229	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16229	8	at	at	IN
18637	16229	9	376	376	CD
18637	16229	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16229	11	that	that	IN
18637	16229	12	there	there	EX
18637	16229	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	16229	14	a	a	DT
18637	16229	15	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	16229	16	between	between	IN
18637	16229	17	"	"	``
18637	16229	18	advocacy	advocacy	NN
18637	16229	19	"	"	''
18637	16229	20	and	and	CC
18637	16229	21	"	"	``
18637	16229	22	incitement	incitement	JJ
18637	16229	23	,	,	,
18637	16229	24	"	"	''
18637	16229	25	but	but	CC
18637	16229	26	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	16229	27	to	to	TO
18637	16229	28	adduce	adduce	VB
18637	16229	29	any	any	DT
18637	16229	30	supporting	support	VBG
18637	16229	31	authority	authority	NN
18637	16229	32	.	.	.
18637	16230	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16230	2	101	101	CD
18637	16230	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16230	4	301	301	CD
18637	16230	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16230	6	242	242	CD
18637	16230	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16230	8	1937	1937	CD
18637	16230	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16230	10	.	.	.
18637	16231	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16231	2	102	102	CD
18637	16231	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16231	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16231	5	.	.	.
18637	16232	1	261	261	CD
18637	16232	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16232	3	263	263	CD
18637	16232	4	.	.	.
18637	16233	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16233	2	103	103	CD
18637	16233	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16233	4	310	310	CD
18637	16233	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16233	6	88	88	CD
18637	16233	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16233	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	16233	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16233	10	.	.	.
18637	16234	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16234	2	104	104	CD
18637	16234	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16234	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16234	5	.	.	.
18637	16235	1	105	105	CD
18637	16235	2	.	.	.
18637	16236	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16236	2	105	105	CD
18637	16236	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16236	4	Cantwell	Cantwell	NNP
18637	16236	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16236	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16236	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16236	8	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	16236	9	,	,	,
18637	16236	10	310	310	CD
18637	16236	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16236	12	296	296	CD
18637	16236	13	,	,	,
18637	16236	14	308	308	CD
18637	16236	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16236	16	1940	1940	CD
18637	16236	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16236	18	.	.	.
18637	16237	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16237	2	106	106	CD
18637	16237	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16237	4	Stromberg	Stromberg	NNP
18637	16237	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16237	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16237	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16237	8	California	California	NNP
18637	16237	9	,	,	,
18637	16237	10	283	283	CD
18637	16237	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16237	12	359	359	CD
18637	16237	13	,	,	,
18637	16237	14	369	369	CD
18637	16237	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16237	16	1931	1931	CD
18637	16237	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16237	18	.	.	.
18637	16238	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16238	2	107	107	CD
18637	16238	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16238	4	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	16238	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16238	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16238	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16238	8	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	16238	9	,	,	,
18637	16238	10	236	236	CD
18637	16238	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16238	12	273	273	CD
18637	16238	13	,	,	,
18637	16238	14	277	277	CD
18637	16238	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16238	16	1915	1915	CD
18637	16238	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16238	18	.	.	.
18637	16239	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16239	2	108	108	CD
18637	16239	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16239	4	Gitlow	Gitlow	NNP
18637	16239	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16239	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16239	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16239	8	New	New	NNP
18637	16239	9	York	York	NNP
18637	16239	10	,	,	,
18637	16239	11	268	268	CD
18637	16239	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16239	13	652	652	CD
18637	16239	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16239	15	1925	1925	CD
18637	16239	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16239	17	.	.	.
18637	16240	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16240	2	109	109	CD
18637	16240	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16240	4	Terminiello	Terminiello	NNP
18637	16240	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16240	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16240	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16240	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	16240	9	,	,	,
18637	16240	10	337	337	CD
18637	16240	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16240	12	1	1	CD
18637	16240	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16240	14	1949	1949	CD
18637	16240	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16240	16	.	.	.
18637	16241	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16241	2	110	110	CD
18637	16241	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16241	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16241	5	.	.	.
18637	16242	1	4	4	LS
18637	16242	2	.	.	.
18637	16243	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16243	2	111	111	CD
18637	16243	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16243	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16243	5	.	.	.
18637	16244	1	33	33	CD
18637	16244	2	.	.	.
18637	16245	1	Dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	16245	2	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	16245	3	were	be	VBD
18637	16245	4	written	write	VBN
18637	16245	5	by	by	IN
18637	16245	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	16245	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16245	8	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	16245	9	,	,	,
18637	16245	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16245	11	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	16245	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16245	13	with	with	IN
18637	16245	14	whom	whom	WP
18637	16245	15	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	16245	16	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	16245	17	and	and	CC
18637	16245	18	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	16245	19	concurred	concur	VBN
18637	16245	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16245	21	and	and	CC
18637	16245	22	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16245	23	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	16245	24	,	,	,
18637	16245	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16245	26	with	with	IN
18637	16245	27	whom	whom	WP
18637	16245	28	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16245	29	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	16245	30	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	16245	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16245	32	.	.	.
18637	16246	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16246	2	112	112	CD
18637	16246	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16246	4	340	340	CD
18637	16246	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16246	6	315	315	CD
18637	16246	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16246	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	16246	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16246	10	.	.	.
18637	16247	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16247	2	113	113	CD
18637	16247	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16247	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16247	5	.	.	.
18637	16248	1	319	319	CD
18637	16248	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16248	3	320	320	CD
18637	16248	4	.	.	.
18637	16249	1	Anent	anent	VB
18637	16249	2	this	this	DT
18637	16249	3	finding	finding	NN
18637	16249	4	,	,	,
18637	16249	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16249	6	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	16249	7	,	,	,
18637	16249	8	in	in	IN
18637	16249	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16249	10	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	16249	11	,	,	,
18637	16249	12	declared	declare	VBD
18637	16249	13	that	that	DT
18637	16249	14	:	:	:
18637	16249	15	"	"	``
18637	16249	16	Public	public	JJ
18637	16249	17	assemblies	assembly	NNS
18637	16249	18	and	and	CC
18637	16249	19	public	public	JJ
18637	16249	20	speech	speech	NN
18637	16249	21	occupy	occupy	VBP
18637	16249	22	an	an	DT
18637	16249	23	important	important	JJ
18637	16249	24	role	role	NN
18637	16249	25	in	in	IN
18637	16249	26	American	american	JJ
18637	16249	27	life	life	NN
18637	16249	28	.	.	.
18637	16250	1	One	one	CD
18637	16250	2	high	high	JJ
18637	16250	3	function	function	NN
18637	16250	4	of	of	IN
18637	16250	5	the	the	DT
18637	16250	6	police	police	NN
18637	16250	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	16250	8	to	to	TO
18637	16250	9	protect	protect	VB
18637	16250	10	these	these	DT
18637	16250	11	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	16250	12	gatherings	gathering	NNS
18637	16250	13	so	so	IN
18637	16250	14	that	that	IN
18637	16250	15	the	the	DT
18637	16250	16	speakers	speaker	NNS
18637	16250	17	may	may	MD
18637	16250	18	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	16250	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16250	20	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16250	21	rights	right	NNS
18637	16250	22	.	.	.
18637	16251	1	When	when	WRB
18637	16251	2	unpopular	unpopular	JJ
18637	16251	3	causes	cause	NNS
18637	16251	4	are	be	VBP
18637	16251	5	sponsored	sponsor	VBN
18637	16251	6	from	from	IN
18637	16251	7	the	the	DT
18637	16251	8	public	public	JJ
18637	16251	9	platform	platform	NN
18637	16251	10	,	,	,
18637	16251	11	there	there	EX
18637	16251	12	will	will	MD
18637	16251	13	commonly	commonly	RB
18637	16251	14	be	be	VB
18637	16251	15	mutterings	muttering	NNS
18637	16251	16	and	and	CC
18637	16251	17	unrest	unrest	JJ
18637	16251	18	and	and	CC
18637	16251	19	heckling	heckle	VBG
18637	16251	20	from	from	IN
18637	16251	21	the	the	DT
18637	16251	22	crowd	crowd	NN
18637	16251	23	.	.	.
18637	16252	1	*	*	NFP
18637	16252	2	*	*	NFP
18637	16252	3	*	*	NFP
18637	16252	4	But	but	CC
18637	16252	5	those	those	DT
18637	16252	6	extravagances	extravagance	NNS
18637	16252	7	*	*	NFP
18637	16252	8	*	*	NFP
18637	16252	9	*	*	NFP
18637	16252	10	,	,	,
18637	16252	11	do	do	VBP
18637	16252	12	not	not	RB
18637	16252	13	justify	justify	VB
18637	16252	14	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	16252	15	the	the	DT
18637	16252	16	speaker	speaker	NN
18637	16252	17	by	by	IN
18637	16252	18	depriving	deprive	VBG
18637	16252	19	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16252	20	of	of	IN
18637	16252	21	the	the	DT
18637	16252	22	platform	platform	NN
18637	16252	23	or	or	CC
18637	16252	24	by	by	IN
18637	16252	25	punishing	punish	VBG
18637	16252	26	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16252	27	for	for	IN
18637	16252	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16252	29	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	16252	30	.	.	.
18637	16253	1	*	*	NFP
18637	16253	2	*	*	NFP
18637	16253	3	*	*	NFP
18637	16253	4	If	if	IN
18637	16253	5	*	*	NFP
18637	16253	6	*	*	NFP
18637	16253	7	*	*	NFP
18637	16253	8	the	the	DT
18637	16253	9	police	police	NNS
18637	16253	10	throw	throw	VBP
18637	16253	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16253	12	weight	weight	NN
18637	16253	13	on	on	IN
18637	16253	14	the	the	DT
18637	16253	15	side	side	NN
18637	16253	16	of	of	IN
18637	16253	17	those	those	DT
18637	16253	18	who	who	WP
18637	16253	19	would	would	MD
18637	16253	20	break	break	VB
18637	16253	21	up	up	RP
18637	16253	22	the	the	DT
18637	16253	23	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	16253	24	,	,	,
18637	16253	25	the	the	DT
18637	16253	26	police	police	NNS
18637	16253	27	become	become	VBP
18637	16253	28	the	the	DT
18637	16253	29	new	new	JJ
18637	16253	30	censors	censor	NNS
18637	16253	31	of	of	IN
18637	16253	32	speech	speech	NN
18637	16253	33	.	.	.
18637	16254	1	Police	police	NN
18637	16254	2	censorship	censorship	NN
18637	16254	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	16254	4	all	all	PDT
18637	16254	5	the	the	DT
18637	16254	6	vices	vice	NNS
18637	16254	7	of	of	IN
18637	16254	8	the	the	DT
18637	16254	9	censorship	censorship	NN
18637	16254	10	from	from	IN
18637	16254	11	city	city	NN
18637	16254	12	halls	hall	NNS
18637	16254	13	which	which	WDT
18637	16254	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16254	15	have	have	VBP
18637	16254	16	repeatedy	repeatedy	JJ
18637	16254	17	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16254	18	sic	sic	NN
18637	16254	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16254	20	struck	strike	VBN
18637	16254	21	down	down	RP
18637	16254	22	.	.	.
18637	16254	23	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	16254	24	.	.	.
18637	16255	1	330	330	CD
18637	16255	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16255	3	331	331	CD
18637	16255	4	.	.	.
18637	16256	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16256	2	114	114	CD
18637	16256	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16256	4	333	333	CD
18637	16256	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16256	6	507	507	CD
18637	16256	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16256	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	16256	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16256	10	.	.	.
18637	16257	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16257	2	115	115	CD
18637	16257	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16257	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16257	5	.	.	.
18637	16258	1	514	514	CD
18637	16258	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16258	3	515	515	CD
18637	16258	4	.	.	.
18637	16259	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16259	2	116	116	CD
18637	16259	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16259	4	Musser	Musser	NNP
18637	16259	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16259	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16259	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16259	8	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	16259	9	,	,	,
18637	16259	10	333	333	CD
18637	16259	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16259	12	95	95	CD
18637	16259	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16259	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	16259	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16259	16	.	.	.
18637	16260	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16260	2	117	117	CD
18637	16260	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16260	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16260	5	.	.	.
18637	16261	1	101	101	CD
18637	16261	2	.	.	.
18637	16262	1	This	this	DT
18637	16262	2	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	16262	3	probably	probably	RB
18637	16262	4	marks	mark	VBZ
18637	16262	5	the	the	DT
18637	16262	6	climax	climax	NN
18637	16262	7	of	of	IN
18637	16262	8	the	the	DT
18637	16262	9	clear	clear	JJ
18637	16262	10	and	and	CC
18637	16262	11	present	present	JJ
18637	16262	12	danger	danger	NN
18637	16262	13	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	16262	14	.	.	.
18637	16263	1	"	"	``
18637	16263	2	On	on	IN
18637	16263	3	March	March	NNP
18637	16263	4	20	20	CD
18637	16263	5	,	,	,
18637	16263	6	1949	1949	CD
18637	16263	7	,	,	,
18637	16263	8	members	member	NNS
18637	16263	9	of	of	IN
18637	16263	10	the	the	DT
18637	16263	11	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	16263	12	Squad	Squad	NNP
18637	16263	13	of	of	IN
18637	16263	14	the	the	DT
18637	16263	15	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	16263	16	Police	Police	NNP
18637	16263	17	Department	Department	NNP
18637	16263	18	,	,	,
18637	16263	19	at	at	IN
18637	16263	20	the	the	DT
18637	16263	21	direction	direction	NN
18637	16263	22	of	of	IN
18637	16263	23	Inspector	Inspector	NNP
18637	16263	24	Craig	Craig	NNP
18637	16263	25	Ellis	Ellis	NNP
18637	16263	26	,	,	,
18637	16263	27	head	head	NN
18637	16263	28	of	of	IN
18637	16263	29	the	the	DT
18637	16263	30	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	16263	31	Squad	Squad	NNP
18637	16263	32	,	,	,
18637	16263	33	commenced	commence	VBD
18637	16263	34	a	a	DT
18637	16263	35	series	series	NN
18637	16263	36	of	of	IN
18637	16263	37	mass	mass	JJ
18637	16263	38	raids	raid	NNS
18637	16263	39	upon	upon	IN
18637	16263	40	book	book	NN
18637	16263	41	stores	store	NNS
18637	16263	42	and	and	CC
18637	16263	43	booksellers	bookseller	NNS
18637	16263	44	in	in	IN
18637	16263	45	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	16263	46	.	.	.
18637	16264	1	Inspector	Inspector	NNP
18637	16264	2	Ellis	Ellis	NNP
18637	16264	3	gave	give	VBD
18637	16264	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16264	5	men	man	NNS
18637	16264	6	a	a	DT
18637	16264	7	list	list	NN
18637	16264	8	of	of	IN
18637	16264	9	books	book	NNS
18637	16264	10	that	that	WDT
18637	16264	11	in	in	IN
18637	16264	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16264	13	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16264	14	were	be	VBD
18637	16264	15	obscene	obscene	JJ
18637	16264	16	,	,	,
18637	16264	17	and	and	CC
18637	16264	18	directed	direct	VBD
18637	16264	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16264	20	to	to	TO
18637	16264	21	seize	seize	VB
18637	16264	22	the	the	DT
18637	16264	23	books	book	NNS
18637	16264	24	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	16264	25	found	find	VBN
18637	16264	26	.	.	.
18637	16265	1	Fifty	fifty	CD
18637	16265	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	16265	3	four	four	CD
18637	16265	4	booksellers	bookseller	NNS
18637	16265	5	were	be	VBD
18637	16265	6	raided	raid	VBN
18637	16265	7	,	,	,
18637	16265	8	and	and	CC
18637	16265	9	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	16265	10	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	16265	11	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	16265	12	copies	copy	NNS
18637	16265	13	of	of	IN
18637	16265	14	the	the	DT
18637	16265	15	books	book	NNS
18637	16265	16	were	be	VBD
18637	16265	17	confiscated	confiscate	VBN
18637	16265	18	.	.	.
18637	16266	1	"	"	``
18637	16266	2	These	these	DT
18637	16266	3	raids	raid	NNS
18637	16266	4	were	be	VBD
18637	16266	5	remarkable	remarkable	JJ
18637	16266	6	not	not	RB
18637	16266	7	only	only	RB
18637	16266	8	because	because	IN
18637	16266	9	of	of	IN
18637	16266	10	the	the	DT
18637	16266	11	scale	scale	NN
18637	16266	12	on	on	IN
18637	16266	13	which	which	WDT
18637	16266	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16266	15	were	be	VBD
18637	16266	16	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	16266	17	,	,	,
18637	16266	18	but	but	CC
18637	16266	19	in	in	IN
18637	16266	20	several	several	JJ
18637	16266	21	other	other	JJ
18637	16266	22	respects	respect	NNS
18637	16266	23	.	.	.
18637	16267	1	First	first	RB
18637	16267	2	,	,	,
18637	16267	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16267	4	were	be	VBD
18637	16267	5	directed	direct	VBN
18637	16267	6	in	in	IN
18637	16267	7	major	major	JJ
18637	16267	8	part	part	NN
18637	16267	9	against	against	IN
18637	16267	10	books	book	NNS
18637	16267	11	written	write	VBN
18637	16267	12	by	by	IN
18637	16267	13	authors	author	NNS
18637	16267	14	in	in	IN
18637	16267	15	the	the	DT
18637	16267	16	forefront	forefront	NN
18637	16267	17	of	of	IN
18637	16267	18	American	american	JJ
18637	16267	19	literature	literature	NN
18637	16267	20	and	and	CC
18637	16267	21	published	publish	VBN
18637	16267	22	by	by	IN
18637	16267	23	some	some	DT
18637	16267	24	of	of	IN
18637	16267	25	the	the	DT
18637	16267	26	leading	lead	VBG
18637	16267	27	publishers	publisher	NNS
18637	16267	28	in	in	IN
18637	16267	29	America	America	NNP
18637	16267	30	.	.	.
18637	16268	1	Second	second	JJ
18637	16268	2	,	,	,
18637	16268	3	the	the	DT
18637	16268	4	raids	raid	NNS
18637	16268	5	were	be	VBD
18637	16268	6	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	16268	7	and	and	CC
18637	16268	8	the	the	DT
18637	16268	9	books	book	NNS
18637	16268	10	were	be	VBD
18637	16268	11	confiscated	confiscate	VBN
18637	16268	12	without	without	IN
18637	16268	13	warrants	warrant	NNS
18637	16268	14	of	of	IN
18637	16268	15	search	search	NN
18637	16268	16	or	or	CC
18637	16268	17	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16268	18	or	or	CC
18637	16268	19	court	court	NN
18637	16268	20	order	order	NN
18637	16268	21	of	of	IN
18637	16268	22	any	any	DT
18637	16268	23	kind	kind	NN
18637	16268	24	.	.	.
18637	16269	1	Third	third	JJ
18637	16269	2	,	,	,
18637	16269	3	the	the	DT
18637	16269	4	list	list	NN
18637	16269	5	of	of	IN
18637	16269	6	books	book	NNS
18637	16269	7	to	to	TO
18637	16269	8	be	be	VB
18637	16269	9	seized	seize	VBN
18637	16269	10	was	be	VBD
18637	16269	11	compiled	compile	VBN
18637	16269	12	by	by	IN
18637	16269	13	Inspector	Inspector	NNP
18637	16269	14	Ellis	Ellis	NNP
18637	16269	15	and	and	CC
18637	16269	16	a	a	DT
18637	16269	17	patrolman	patrolman	NN
18637	16269	18	in	in	IN
18637	16269	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16269	20	office	office	NN
18637	16269	21	,	,	,
18637	16269	22	without	without	IN
18637	16269	23	consultation	consultation	NN
18637	16269	24	with	with	IN
18637	16269	25	the	the	DT
18637	16269	26	District	District	NNP
18637	16269	27	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	16269	28	's	's	POS
18637	16269	29	office	office	NN
18637	16269	30	or	or	CC
18637	16269	31	the	the	DT
18637	16269	32	obtaining	obtaining	NN
18637	16269	33	of	of	IN
18637	16269	34	any	any	DT
18637	16269	35	legal	legal	JJ
18637	16269	36	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16269	37	as	as	IN
18637	16269	38	to	to	IN
18637	16269	39	whether	whether	IN
18637	16269	40	the	the	DT
18637	16269	41	books	book	NNS
18637	16269	42	were	be	VBD
18637	16269	43	obscene	obscene	JJ
18637	16269	44	under	under	IN
18637	16269	45	the	the	DT
18637	16269	46	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	16269	47	statute	statute	NN
18637	16269	48	.	.	.
18637	16270	1	"	"	``
18637	16270	2	For	for	IN
18637	16270	3	once	once	RB
18637	16270	4	the	the	DT
18637	16270	5	publishers	publisher	NNS
18637	16270	6	took	take	VBD
18637	16270	7	the	the	DT
18637	16270	8	offensive	offensive	NN
18637	16270	9	.	.	.
18637	16271	1	Houghton	Houghton	NNP
18637	16271	2	Mifflin	Mifflin	NNP
18637	16271	3	Company	Company	NNP
18637	16271	4	,	,	,
18637	16271	5	publisher	publisher	NN
18637	16271	6	of	of	IN
18637	16271	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16271	8	Raintree	Raintree	NNP
18637	16271	9	County	County	NNP
18637	16271	10	_	_	NNP
18637	16271	11	,	,	,
18637	16271	12	Alfred	Alfred	NNP
18637	16271	13	A.	A.	NNP
18637	16271	14	Knopf	Knopf	NNP
18637	16271	15	,	,	,
18637	16271	16	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	16271	17	,	,	,
18637	16271	18	publisher	publisher	NN
18637	16271	19	of	of	IN
18637	16271	20	_	_	NNP
18637	16271	21	Never	Never	NNP
18637	16271	22	Love	Love	NNP
18637	16271	23	a	a	DT
18637	16271	24	Stranger	Stranger	NNP
18637	16271	25	_	_	NNP
18637	16271	26	,	,	,
18637	16271	27	and	and	CC
18637	16271	28	The	the	DT
18637	16271	29	Vanguard	Vanguard	NNP
18637	16271	30	Press	Press	NNP
18637	16271	31	,	,	,
18637	16271	32	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	16271	33	,	,	,
18637	16271	34	publisher	publisher	NN
18637	16271	35	of	of	IN
18637	16271	36	books	book	NNS
18637	16271	37	by	by	IN
18637	16271	38	James	James	NNP
18637	16271	39	T.	T.	NNP
18637	16271	40	Farrell	Farrell	NNP
18637	16271	41	and	and	CC
18637	16271	42	Calder	Calder	NNP
18637	16271	43	Willingham	Willingham	NNP
18637	16271	44	among	among	IN
18637	16271	45	those	those	DT
18637	16271	46	seized	seize	VBN
18637	16271	47	,	,	,
18637	16271	48	commenced	commence	VBN
18637	16271	49	actions	action	NNS
18637	16271	50	in	in	IN
18637	16271	51	the	the	DT
18637	16271	52	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	16271	53	District	District	NNP
18637	16271	54	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16271	55	in	in	IN
18637	16271	56	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	16271	57	to	to	TO
18637	16271	58	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	16271	59	further	further	JJ
18637	16271	60	police	police	NN
18637	16271	61	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	16271	62	of	of	IN
18637	16271	63	these	these	DT
18637	16271	64	books	book	NNS
18637	16271	65	and	and	CC
18637	16271	66	to	to	TO
18637	16271	67	recover	recover	VB
18637	16271	68	damages	damage	NNS
18637	16271	69	from	from	IN
18637	16271	70	the	the	DT
18637	16271	71	police	police	NN
18637	16271	72	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16271	73	for	for	IN
18637	16271	74	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16271	75	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	16271	76	acts	act	NNS
18637	16271	77	.	.	.
18637	16272	1	In	in	IN
18637	16272	2	these	these	DT
18637	16272	3	two	two	CD
18637	16272	4	actions	action	NNS
18637	16272	5	the	the	DT
18637	16272	6	authors	author	NNS
18637	16272	7	Harold	Harold	NNP
18637	16272	8	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	16272	9	and	and	CC
18637	16272	10	James	James	NNP
18637	16272	11	T.	T.	NNP
18637	16272	12	Farrell	Farrell	NNP
18637	16272	13	,	,	,
18637	16272	14	as	as	RB
18637	16272	15	well	well	RB
18637	16272	16	as	as	IN
18637	16272	17	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	16272	18	Praissman	Praissman	NNP
18637	16272	19	,	,	,
18637	16272	20	a	a	DT
18637	16272	21	courageous	courageous	JJ
18637	16272	22	bookseller	bookseller	NN
18637	16272	23	whose	whose	WP$
18637	16272	24	stores	store	NNS
18637	16272	25	had	have	VBD
18637	16272	26	been	be	VBN
18637	16272	27	raided	raid	VBN
18637	16272	28	,	,	,
18637	16272	29	joined	join	VBD
18637	16272	30	the	the	DT
18637	16272	31	publishers	publisher	NNS
18637	16272	32	as	as	IN
18637	16272	33	parties	party	NNS
18637	16272	34	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	16272	35	.	.	.
18637	16273	1	The	the	DT
18637	16273	2	District	District	NNP
18637	16273	3	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	16273	4	of	of	IN
18637	16273	5	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	16273	6	countered	counter	VBN
18637	16273	7	by	by	IN
18637	16273	8	commencing	commence	VBG
18637	16273	9	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16273	10	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16273	11	against	against	IN
18637	16273	12	five	five	CD
18637	16273	13	of	of	IN
18637	16273	14	the	the	DT
18637	16273	15	booksellers	bookseller	NNS
18637	16273	16	whose	whose	WP$
18637	16273	17	stores	store	NNS
18637	16273	18	had	have	VBD
18637	16273	19	been	be	VBN
18637	16273	20	raided	raid	VBN
18637	16273	21	,	,	,
18637	16273	22	and	and	CC
18637	16273	23	on	on	IN
18637	16273	24	June	June	NNP
18637	16273	25	30	30	CD
18637	16273	26	,	,	,
18637	16273	27	1948	1948	CD
18637	16273	28	the	the	DT
18637	16273	29	grand	grand	JJ
18637	16273	30	jury	jury	NN
18637	16273	31	,	,	,
18637	16273	32	upon	upon	IN
18637	16273	33	presentation	presentation	NN
18637	16273	34	of	of	IN
18637	16273	35	the	the	DT
18637	16273	36	District	District	NNP
18637	16273	37	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	16273	38	,	,	,
18637	16273	39	indicted	indict	VBD
18637	16273	40	the	the	DT
18637	16273	41	booksellers	bookseller	NNS
18637	16273	42	on	on	IN
18637	16273	43	a	a	DT
18637	16273	44	charge	charge	NN
18637	16273	45	of	of	IN
18637	16273	46	having	have	VBG
18637	16273	47	violated	violate	VBN
18637	16273	48	the	the	DT
18637	16273	49	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	16273	50	statute	statute	NN
18637	16273	51	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	16273	52	the	the	DT
18637	16273	53	sale	sale	NN
18637	16273	54	of	of	IN
18637	16273	55	obscene	obscene	JJ
18637	16273	56	books	book	NNS
18637	16273	57	.	.	.
18637	16274	1	"	"	``
18637	16274	2	In	in	IN
18637	16274	3	the	the	DT
18637	16274	4	meantime	meantime	NN
18637	16274	5	the	the	DT
18637	16274	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	16274	7	court	court	NN
18637	16274	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	16274	9	brought	bring	VBN
18637	16274	10	by	by	IN
18637	16274	11	the	the	DT
18637	16274	12	publishers	publisher	NNS
18637	16274	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	16274	14	come	come	VBN
18637	16274	15	to	to	IN
18637	16274	16	trial	trial	NN
18637	16274	17	before	before	IN
18637	16274	18	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	16274	19	Guy	Guy	NNP
18637	16274	20	K.	K.	NNP
18637	16274	21	Bard	Bard	NNP
18637	16274	22	,	,	,
18637	16274	23	and	and	CC
18637	16274	24	at	at	IN
18637	16274	25	the	the	DT
18637	16274	26	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	16274	27	of	of	IN
18637	16274	28	the	the	DT
18637	16274	29	trials	trial	NNS
18637	16274	30	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	16274	31	Bard	Bard	NNP
18637	16274	32	had	have	VBD
18637	16274	33	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	16274	34	further	further	JJ
18637	16274	35	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	16274	36	of	of	IN
18637	16274	37	the	the	DT
18637	16274	38	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	16274	39	's	's	POS
18637	16274	40	books	book	NNS
18637	16274	41	,	,	,
18637	16274	42	as	as	RB
18637	16274	43	well	well	RB
18637	16274	44	as	as	IN
18637	16274	45	police	police	NN
18637	16274	46	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	16274	47	of	of	IN
18637	16274	48	Praissman	Praissman	NNP
18637	16274	49	's	's	POS
18637	16274	50	stores	store	NNS
18637	16274	51	or	or	CC
18637	16274	52	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16274	53	of	of	IN
18637	16274	54	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16274	55	books	book	NNS
18637	16274	56	without	without	IN
18637	16274	57	a	a	DT
18637	16274	58	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16274	59	.	.	.
18637	16275	1	At	at	IN
18637	16275	2	the	the	DT
18637	16275	3	time	time	NN
18637	16275	4	of	of	IN
18637	16275	5	this	this	DT
18637	16275	6	writing	writing	NN
18637	16275	7	,	,	,
18637	16275	8	the	the	DT
18637	16275	9	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	16275	10	court	court	NN
18637	16275	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	16275	12	have	have	VBP
18637	16275	13	not	not	RB
18637	16275	14	been	be	VBN
18637	16275	15	finally	finally	RB
18637	16275	16	decided	decide	VBN
18637	16275	17	.	.	.
18637	16276	1	"	"	``
18637	16276	2	On	on	IN
18637	16276	3	January	January	NNP
18637	16276	4	3	3	CD
18637	16276	5	,	,	,
18637	16276	6	1949	1949	CD
18637	16276	7	the	the	DT
18637	16276	8	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16276	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	16276	10	came	come	VBD
18637	16276	11	on	on	RP
18637	16276	12	for	for	IN
18637	16276	13	trial	trial	NN
18637	16276	14	before	before	IN
18637	16276	15	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	16276	16	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	16276	17	Bok	Bok	NNP
18637	16276	18	of	of	IN
18637	16276	19	the	the	DT
18637	16276	20	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	16276	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16276	22	of	of	IN
18637	16276	23	Quarter	Quarter	NNP
18637	16276	24	Sessions	Sessions	NNP
18637	16276	25	.	.	.
18637	16277	1	The	the	DT
18637	16277	2	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	16277	3	pleaded	plead	VBD
18637	16277	4	not	not	RB
18637	16277	5	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	16277	6	and	and	CC
18637	16277	7	waived	waive	VBD
18637	16277	8	trial	trial	NN
18637	16277	9	by	by	IN
18637	16277	10	jury	jury	NN
18637	16277	11	.	.	.
18637	16278	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16278	2	stipulated	stipulate	VBD
18637	16278	3	that	that	IN
18637	16278	4	at	at	IN
18637	16278	5	the	the	DT
18637	16278	6	times	time	NNS
18637	16278	7	and	and	CC
18637	16278	8	places	place	NNS
18637	16278	9	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	16278	10	in	in	IN
18637	16278	11	the	the	DT
18637	16278	12	indictments	indictment	NNS
18637	16278	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16278	14	had	have	VBD
18637	16278	15	had	have	VBN
18637	16278	16	possession	possession	NN
18637	16278	17	of	of	IN
18637	16278	18	the	the	DT
18637	16278	19	books	book	NNS
18637	16278	20	for	for	IN
18637	16278	21	the	the	DT
18637	16278	22	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	16278	23	of	of	IN
18637	16278	24	offering	offer	VBG
18637	16278	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16278	26	for	for	IN
18637	16278	27	sale	sale	NN
18637	16278	28	to	to	IN
18637	16278	29	the	the	DT
18637	16278	30	public	public	NN
18637	16278	31	.	.	.
18637	16279	1	The	the	DT
18637	16279	2	books	book	NNS
18637	16279	3	were	be	VBD
18637	16279	4	then	then	RB
18637	16279	5	placed	place	VBN
18637	16279	6	in	in	IN
18637	16279	7	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16279	8	,	,	,
18637	16279	9	and	and	CC
18637	16279	10	the	the	DT
18637	16279	11	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	16279	12	rested	rest	VBD
18637	16279	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16279	14	case	case	NN
18637	16279	15	.	.	.
18637	16280	1	The	the	DT
18637	16280	2	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	16280	3	'	'	''
18637	16280	4	demurred	demur	VBD
18637	16280	5	to	to	IN
18637	16280	6	the	the	DT
18637	16280	7	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16280	8	,	,	,
18637	16280	9	'	'	''
18637	16280	10	the	the	DT
18637	16280	11	effect	effect	NN
18637	16280	12	of	of	IN
18637	16280	13	which	which	WDT
18637	16280	14	was	be	VBD
18637	16280	15	to	to	TO
18637	16280	16	raise	raise	VB
18637	16280	17	the	the	DT
18637	16280	18	issue	issue	NN
18637	16280	19	of	of	IN
18637	16280	20	whether	whether	IN
18637	16280	21	the	the	DT
18637	16280	22	court	court	NN
18637	16280	23	,	,	,
18637	16280	24	in	in	IN
18637	16280	25	the	the	DT
18637	16280	26	light	light	NN
18637	16280	27	of	of	IN
18637	16280	28	the	the	DT
18637	16280	29	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16280	30	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	16280	31	of	of	IN
18637	16280	32	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16280	33	of	of	IN
18637	16280	34	the	the	DT
18637	16280	35	press	press	NN
18637	16280	36	,	,	,
18637	16280	37	could	could	MD
18637	16280	38	hold	hold	VB
18637	16280	39	,	,	,
18637	16280	40	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	16280	41	a	a	DT
18637	16280	42	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	16280	43	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	16280	44	,	,	,
18637	16280	45	that	that	IN
18637	16280	46	the	the	DT
18637	16280	47	books	book	NNS
18637	16280	48	before	before	IN
18637	16280	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16280	50	were	be	VBD
18637	16280	51	obscene	obscene	JJ
18637	16280	52	within	within	IN
18637	16280	53	the	the	DT
18637	16280	54	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	16280	55	of	of	IN
18637	16280	56	the	the	DT
18637	16280	57	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	16280	58	obscenity	obscenity	NN
18637	16280	59	statute	statute	NN
18637	16280	60	.	.	.
18637	16280	61	"	"	''
18637	16281	1	Introductory	Introductory	NNP
18637	16281	2	note	note	VBP
18637	16281	3	to	to	IN
18637	16281	4	a	a	DT
18637	16281	5	republication	republication	NN
18637	16281	6	by	by	IN
18637	16281	7	Alfred	Alfred	NNP
18637	16281	8	Knopf	Knopf	NNP
18637	16281	9	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	16281	10	of	of	IN
18637	16281	11	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	16281	12	Bok	Bok	NNP
18637	16281	13	's	's	POS
18637	16281	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16281	15	in	in	IN
18637	16281	16	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
18637	16281	17	_	_	NNP
18637	16281	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	16281	19	_	_	NNP
18637	16281	20	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	16281	21	_	_	NNP
18637	16281	22	et	et	FW
18637	16281	23	al	al	NNP
18637	16281	24	.	.	NNP
18637	16281	25	_	_	NNP
18637	16281	26	,	,	,
18637	16281	27	66	66	CD
18637	16281	28	D	D	NNP
18637	16281	29	&	&	CC
18637	16281	30	C	C	NNP
18637	16281	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16281	32	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	16281	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16281	34	101	101	CD
18637	16281	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16281	36	1949	1949	CD
18637	16281	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16281	38	.	.	.
18637	16282	1	On	on	IN
18637	16282	2	March	March	NNP
18637	16282	3	18	18	CD
18637	16282	4	,	,	,
18637	16282	5	1949	1949	CD
18637	16282	6	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	16282	7	Bok	Bok	NNP
18637	16282	8	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	16282	9	the	the	DT
18637	16282	10	demurrers	demurrer	NNS
18637	16282	11	and	and	CC
18637	16282	12	entered	enter	VBD
18637	16282	13	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16282	14	in	in	IN
18637	16282	15	favor	favor	NN
18637	16282	16	of	of	IN
18637	16282	17	the	the	DT
18637	16282	18	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	16282	19	.	.	.
18637	16283	1	The	the	DT
18637	16283	2	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16283	3	which	which	WDT
18637	16283	4	accompanies	accompany	VBZ
18637	16283	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16283	6	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16283	7	pivots	pivot	NNS
18637	16283	8	in	in	IN
18637	16283	9	part	part	NN
18637	16283	10	on	on	IN
18637	16283	11	the	the	DT
18637	16283	12	clear	clear	JJ
18637	16283	13	and	and	CC
18637	16283	14	present	present	JJ
18637	16283	15	danger	danger	NN
18637	16283	16	rule	rule	NN
18637	16283	17	.	.	.
18637	16284	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16284	2	reads	read	VBZ
18637	16284	3	:	:	:
18637	16284	4	"	"	``
18637	16284	5	The	the	DT
18637	16284	6	only	only	JJ
18637	16284	7	clear	clear	JJ
18637	16284	8	and	and	CC
18637	16284	9	present	present	JJ
18637	16284	10	danger	danger	NN
18637	16284	11	to	to	TO
18637	16284	12	be	be	VB
18637	16284	13	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	16284	14	by	by	IN
18637	16284	15	section	section	NN
18637	16284	16	524	524	CD
18637	16284	17	that	that	WDT
18637	16284	18	will	will	MD
18637	16284	19	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	16284	20	both	both	CC
18637	16284	21	the	the	DT
18637	16284	22	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	16284	23	and	and	CC
18637	16284	24	the	the	DT
18637	16284	25	current	current	JJ
18637	16284	26	customs	custom	NNS
18637	16284	27	of	of	IN
18637	16284	28	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16284	29	era	era	NN
18637	16284	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	16284	31	the	the	DT
18637	16284	32	imminence	imminence	NN
18637	16284	33	of	of	IN
18637	16284	34	the	the	DT
18637	16284	35	commission	commission	NNP
18637	16284	36	of	of	IN
18637	16284	37	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16284	38	behavior	behavior	NN
18637	16284	39	resulting	result	VBG
18637	16284	40	from	from	IN
18637	16284	41	the	the	DT
18637	16284	42	reading	reading	NN
18637	16284	43	of	of	IN
18637	16284	44	a	a	DT
18637	16284	45	book	book	NN
18637	16284	46	.	.	.
18637	16285	1	Publication	publication	NN
18637	16285	2	alone	alone	RB
18637	16285	3	can	can	MD
18637	16285	4	have	have	VB
18637	16285	5	no	no	DT
18637	16285	6	such	such	JJ
18637	16285	7	automatic	automatic	JJ
18637	16285	8	effect	effect	NN
18637	16285	9	.	.	.
18637	16285	10	"	"	''
18637	16286	1	This	this	DT
18637	16286	2	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	16286	3	overlooks	overlook	VBZ
18637	16286	4	the	the	DT
18637	16286	5	primary	primary	JJ
18637	16286	6	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	16286	7	of	of	IN
18637	16286	8	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	16286	9	interference	interference	NN
18637	16286	10	with	with	IN
18637	16286	11	the	the	DT
18637	16286	12	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	16286	13	of	of	IN
18637	16286	14	"	"	``
18637	16286	15	obscene	obscene	JJ
18637	16286	16	literature	literature	NN
18637	16286	17	,	,	,
18637	16286	18	"	"	''
18637	16286	19	namely	namely	RB
18637	16286	20	to	to	TO
18637	16286	21	protect	protect	VB
18637	16286	22	immature	immature	JJ
18637	16286	23	minds	mind	NNS
18637	16286	24	from	from	IN
18637	16286	25	contamination	contamination	NN
18637	16286	26	.	.	.
18637	16287	1	Dealing	deal	VBG
18637	16287	2	with	with	IN
18637	16287	3	this	this	DT
18637	16287	4	point	point	NN
18637	16287	5	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	16287	6	Bok	Bok	NNP
18637	16287	7	protests	protest	NNS
18637	16287	8	against	against	IN
18637	16287	9	putting	put	VBG
18637	16287	10	"	"	``
18637	16287	11	the	the	DT
18637	16287	12	entire	entire	JJ
18637	16287	13	reading	read	VBG
18637	16287	14	public	public	NN
18637	16287	15	at	at	IN
18637	16287	16	the	the	DT
18637	16287	17	mercy	mercy	NN
18637	16287	18	of	of	IN
18637	16287	19	the	the	DT
18637	16287	20	adolescent	adolescent	JJ
18637	16287	21	mind	mind	NN
18637	16287	22	.	.	.
18637	16287	23	"	"	''
18637	16288	1	Should	Should	MD
18637	16288	2	,	,	,
18637	16288	3	on	on	IN
18637	16288	4	the	the	DT
18637	16288	5	other	other	JJ
18637	16288	6	hand	hand	NN
18637	16288	7	,	,	,
18637	16288	8	the	the	DT
18637	16288	9	adolescent	adolescent	JJ
18637	16288	10	mind	mind	NN
18637	16288	11	be	be	VB
18637	16288	12	put	put	VBN
18637	16288	13	at	at	IN
18637	16288	14	the	the	DT
18637	16288	15	mercy	mercy	NN
18637	16288	16	of	of	IN
18637	16288	17	the	the	DT
18637	16288	18	uninhibited	uninhibited	JJ
18637	16288	19	reading	read	VBG
18637	16288	20	tastes	taste	NNS
18637	16288	21	of	of	IN
18637	16288	22	an	an	DT
18637	16288	23	elderly	elderly	JJ
18637	16288	24	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16288	25	judge	judge	NN
18637	16288	26	?	?	.
18637	16289	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16289	2	118	118	CD
18637	16289	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16289	4	310	310	CD
18637	16289	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16289	6	88	88	CD
18637	16289	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16289	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	16289	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16289	10	.	.	.
18637	16290	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16290	2	119	119	CD
18637	16290	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16290	4	310	310	CD
18637	16290	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16290	6	106	106	CD
18637	16290	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16290	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	16290	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16290	10	.	.	.
18637	16291	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16291	2	120	120	CD
18637	16291	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16291	4	Thornhill	Thornhill	NNP
18637	16291	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16291	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16291	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16291	8	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	16291	9	,	,	,
18637	16291	10	310	310	CD
18637	16291	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16291	12	88	88	CD
18637	16291	13	,	,	,
18637	16291	14	102	102	CD
18637	16291	15	,	,	,
18637	16291	16	105	105	CD
18637	16291	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16291	18	1940	1940	CD
18637	16291	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16291	20	.	.	.
18637	16292	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16292	2	121	121	CD
18637	16292	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16292	4	Drivers	Drivers	NNPS
18637	16292	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	16292	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16292	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16292	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16292	9	Meadowmoor	Meadowmoor	NNP
18637	16292	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16292	11	,	,	,
18637	16292	12	312	312	CD
18637	16292	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16292	14	287	287	CD
18637	16292	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16292	16	1941	1941	CD
18637	16292	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16292	18	;	;	:
18637	16292	19	_	_	NNP
18637	16292	20	See	See	NNP
18637	16292	21	also	also	RB
18637	16292	22	_	_	NNP
18637	16292	23	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	16292	24	and	and	CC
18637	16292	25	Restaurant	Restaurant	NNP
18637	16292	26	Employees	Employees	NNP
18637	16292	27	'	'	POS
18637	16292	28	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	16292	29	_	_	NNP
18637	16292	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	16292	31	_	_	NNP
18637	16292	32	Board	Board	NNP
18637	16292	33	,	,	,
18637	16292	34	315	315	CD
18637	16292	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16292	36	437	437	CD
18637	16292	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16292	38	1942	1942	CD
18637	16292	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16292	40	.	.	.
18637	16293	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16293	2	122	122	CD
18637	16293	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16293	4	Drivers	Drivers	NNPS
18637	16293	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	16293	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16293	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16293	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16293	9	Meadowmoor	Meadowmoor	NNP
18637	16293	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16293	11	,	,	,
18637	16293	12	312	312	CD
18637	16293	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16293	14	287	287	CD
18637	16293	15	,	,	,
18637	16293	16	293	293	CD
18637	16293	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16293	18	1941	1941	CD
18637	16293	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16293	20	.	.	.
18637	16294	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16294	2	123	123	CD
18637	16294	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16294	4	American	American	NNP
18637	16294	5	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	16294	6	of	of	IN
18637	16294	7	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	16294	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16294	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	16294	10	_	_	NNP
18637	16294	11	Swing	Swing	NNP
18637	16294	12	,	,	,
18637	16294	13	312	312	CD
18637	16294	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16294	15	321	321	CD
18637	16294	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16294	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	16294	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16294	19	;	;	:
18637	16294	20	Bakery	bakery	NN
18637	16294	21	and	and	CC
18637	16294	22	Pastry	Pastry	NNP
18637	16294	23	Drivers	Drivers	NNPS
18637	16294	24	_	_	NNP
18637	16294	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	16294	26	_	_	NNP
18637	16294	27	Wohl	Wohl	NNP
18637	16294	28	,	,	,
18637	16294	29	315	315	CD
18637	16294	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16294	31	769	769	CD
18637	16294	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16294	33	1942	1942	CD
18637	16294	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16294	35	;	;	:
18637	16294	36	Cafeteria	Cafeteria	NNP
18637	16294	37	Employees	Employees	NNPS
18637	16294	38	Union	Union	NNP
18637	16294	39	_	_	NNP
18637	16294	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	16294	41	_	_	NNP
18637	16294	42	Gus	Gus	NNP
18637	16294	43	Angelos	Angelos	NNP
18637	16294	44	,	,	,
18637	16294	45	320	320	CD
18637	16294	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16294	47	293	293	CD
18637	16294	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16294	49	1943	1943	CD
18637	16294	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16294	51	.	.	.
18637	16295	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16295	2	124	124	CD
18637	16295	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16295	4	Teamsters	Teamsters	NNPS
18637	16295	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	16295	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16295	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16295	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16295	9	Hanke	Hanke	NNP
18637	16295	10	,	,	,
18637	16295	11	339	339	CD
18637	16295	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16295	13	470	470	CD
18637	16295	14	,	,	,
18637	16295	15	474	474	CD
18637	16295	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16295	17	1950	1950	CD
18637	16295	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16295	19	.	.	.
18637	16296	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16296	2	125	125	CD
18637	16296	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16296	4	Giboney	Giboney	NNP
18637	16296	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16296	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16296	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16296	8	Empire	Empire	NNP
18637	16296	9	Storage	Storage	NNP
18637	16296	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16296	11	,	,	,
18637	16296	12	336	336	CD
18637	16296	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16296	14	490	490	CD
18637	16296	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16296	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	16296	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16296	18	.	.	.
18637	16297	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16297	2	126	126	CD
18637	16297	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16297	4	Building	Building	NNP
18637	16297	5	Service	Service	NNP
18637	16297	6	Union	Union	NNP
18637	16297	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16297	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	16297	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16297	10	Gazzam	Gazzam	NNP
18637	16297	11	,	,	,
18637	16297	12	339	339	CD
18637	16297	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16297	14	532	532	CD
18637	16297	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16297	16	1950	1950	CD
18637	16297	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16297	18	.	.	.
18637	16298	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16298	2	127	127	CD
18637	16298	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16298	4	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	16298	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16298	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16298	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16298	8	Superior	Superior	NNP
18637	16298	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16298	10	,	,	,
18637	16298	11	339	339	CD
18637	16298	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16298	13	460	460	CD
18637	16298	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16298	15	1950	1950	CD
18637	16298	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16298	17	.	.	.
18637	16299	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16299	2	128	128	CD
18637	16299	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16299	4	Carpenters	Carpenters	NNPS
18637	16299	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	16299	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16299	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16299	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16299	9	Ritter	Ritter	NNP
18637	16299	10	's	's	POS
18637	16299	11	Cafe	Cafe	NNP
18637	16299	12	,	,	,
18637	16299	13	315	315	CD
18637	16299	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16299	15	722	722	CD
18637	16299	16	,	,	,
18637	16299	17	728	728	CD
18637	16299	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16299	19	1942	1942	CD
18637	16299	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16299	21	.	.	.
18637	16300	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16300	2	129	129	CD
18637	16300	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16300	4	Giboney	Giboney	NNP
18637	16300	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16300	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16300	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16300	8	Empire	Empire	NNP
18637	16300	9	Storage	Storage	NNP
18637	16300	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16300	11	,	,	,
18637	16300	12	336	336	CD
18637	16300	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16300	14	490	490	CD
18637	16300	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16300	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	16300	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16300	18	.	.	.
18637	16301	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16301	2	130	130	CD
18637	16301	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16301	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16301	5	.	.	.
18637	16302	1	501	501	CD
18637	16302	2	,	,	,
18637	16302	3	502	502	CD
18637	16302	4	,	,	,
18637	16302	5	citing	cite	VBG
18637	16302	6	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	16302	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16302	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	16302	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16302	10	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	16302	11	,	,	,
18637	16302	12	236	236	CD
18637	16302	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16302	14	273	273	CD
18637	16302	15	,	,	,
18637	16302	16	277	277	CD
18637	16302	17	,	,	,
18637	16302	18	which	which	WDT
18637	16302	19	predates	predate	VBZ
18637	16302	20	any	any	DT
18637	16302	21	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	16302	22	of	of	IN
18637	16302	23	the	the	DT
18637	16302	24	clear	clear	JJ
18637	16302	25	and	and	CC
18637	16302	26	present	present	JJ
18637	16302	27	danger	danger	NN
18637	16302	28	formula	formula	NN
18637	16302	29	.	.	.
18637	16303	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16303	2	See	See	NNP
18637	16303	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16303	4	above	above	RB
18637	16303	5	.	.	.
18637	16304	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16304	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	16304	3	's	's	POS
18637	16304	4	Note	note	NN
18637	16304	5	:	:	:
18637	16304	6	Reference	reference	NN
18637	16304	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	16304	8	to	to	IN
18637	16304	9	Section	section	NN
18637	16304	10	CONTRASTING	contrast	VBG
18637	16304	11	OPERATION	operation	NN
18637	16304	12	OF	of	IN
18637	16304	13	THE	the	DT
18637	16304	14	COMMON	COMMON	NNP
18637	16304	15	LAW	law	NN
18637	16304	16	RULE	rule	NN
18637	16304	17	,	,	,
18637	16304	18	above	above	RB
18637	16304	19	.	.	.
18637	16304	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16305	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16305	2	131	131	CD
18637	16305	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16305	4	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	16305	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	16305	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16305	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16305	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16305	9	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	16305	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16305	11	,	,	,
18637	16305	12	335	335	CD
18637	16305	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16305	14	525	525	CD
18637	16305	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16305	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	16305	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16305	18	;	;	:
18637	16305	19	A.F.	A.F.	NNP
18637	16306	1	of	of	IN
18637	16306	2	L.	L.	NNP
18637	16306	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16306	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	16306	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16306	6	American	American	NNP
18637	16306	7	Sash	Sash	NNP
18637	16306	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16306	9	,	,	,
18637	16306	10	ibid	ibid	NNP
18637	16306	11	.	.	.
18637	16306	12	,	,	,
18637	16306	13	538	538	CD
18637	16306	14	.	.	.
18637	16307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16307	2	132	132	CD
18637	16307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16307	4	Auto	Auto	NNP
18637	16307	5	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	16307	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16307	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16307	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16307	9	Wis.	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	16307	10	Board	Board	NNP
18637	16307	11	,	,	,
18637	16307	12	336	336	CD
18637	16307	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16307	14	245	245	CD
18637	16307	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16307	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	16307	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16307	18	.	.	.
18637	16308	1	In	in	IN
18637	16308	2	Teamsters	Teamsters	NNPS
18637	16308	3	Union	Union	NNP
18637	16308	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16308	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	16308	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16308	7	Hanke	Hanke	NNP
18637	16308	8	,	,	,
18637	16308	9	339	339	CD
18637	16308	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16308	11	470	470	CD
18637	16308	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16308	13	1950	1950	CD
18637	16308	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16308	15	,	,	,
18637	16308	16	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	16308	17	by	by	IN
18637	16308	18	State	state	NN
18637	16308	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	16308	20	against	against	IN
18637	16308	21	picketing	picket	VBG
18637	16308	22	of	of	IN
18637	16308	23	a	a	DT
18637	16308	24	self	self	NN
18637	16308	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	16308	26	employer	employer	NN
18637	16308	27	's	's	POS
18637	16308	28	place	place	NN
18637	16308	29	of	of	IN
18637	16308	30	business	business	NN
18637	16308	31	to	to	TO
18637	16308	32	compel	compel	VB
18637	16308	33	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16308	34	to	to	TO
18637	16308	35	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	16308	36	a	a	DT
18637	16308	37	union	union	NN
18637	16308	38	shop	shop	NN
18637	16308	39	were	be	VBD
18637	16308	40	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	16308	41	.	.	.
18637	16309	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16309	2	133	133	CD
18637	16309	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16309	4	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	16309	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16309	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16309	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16309	8	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	16309	9	,	,	,
18637	16309	10	323	323	CD
18637	16309	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16309	12	516	516	CD
18637	16309	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16309	14	1945	1945	CD
18637	16309	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16309	16	.	.	.
18637	16310	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16310	2	134	134	CD
18637	16310	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16310	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16310	5	.	.	.
18637	16311	1	566	566	CD
18637	16311	2	.	.	.
18637	16312	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16312	2	135	135	CD
18637	16312	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16312	4	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	16312	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16312	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16312	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16312	8	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	16312	9	,	,	,
18637	16312	10	205	205	CD
18637	16312	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16312	12	454	454	CD
18637	16312	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16312	14	1907	1907	CD
18637	16312	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16312	16	.	.	.
18637	16313	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16313	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	16313	3	.	.	.
18637	16313	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16313	5	Toledo	Toledo	NNP
18637	16313	6	Newspaper	Newspaper	NNP
18637	16313	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16313	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16313	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	16313	10	_	_	NNP
18637	16313	11	United	United	NNP
18637	16313	12	States	States	NNP
18637	16313	13	,	,	,
18637	16313	14	247	247	CD
18637	16313	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16313	16	402	402	CD
18637	16313	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16313	18	1918	1918	CD
18637	16313	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16313	20	in	in	IN
18637	16313	21	which	which	WDT
18637	16313	22	the	the	DT
18637	16313	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16313	24	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	16313	25	a	a	DT
18637	16313	26	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16313	27	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	16313	28	a	a	DT
18637	16313	29	fine	fine	NN
18637	16313	30	for	for	IN
18637	16313	31	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	16313	32	of	of	IN
18637	16313	33	court	court	NN
18637	16313	34	on	on	IN
18637	16313	35	an	an	DT
18637	16313	36	editor	editor	NN
18637	16313	37	who	who	WP
18637	16313	38	had	have	VBD
18637	16313	39	criticized	criticize	VBN
18637	16313	40	the	the	DT
18637	16313	41	action	action	NN
18637	16313	42	of	of	IN
18637	16313	43	a	a	DT
18637	16313	44	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16313	45	judge	judge	NN
18637	16313	46	in	in	IN
18637	16313	47	a	a	DT
18637	16313	48	pending	pending	JJ
18637	16313	49	case	case	NN
18637	16313	50	.	.	.
18637	16314	1	The	the	DT
18637	16314	2	majority	majority	NN
18637	16314	3	held	hold	VBD
18637	16314	4	that	that	IN
18637	16314	5	such	such	JJ
18637	16314	6	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	16314	7	did	do	VBD
18637	16314	8	not	not	RB
18637	16314	9	violate	violate	VB
18637	16314	10	the	the	DT
18637	16314	11	First	First	NNP
18637	16314	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16314	13	.	.	.
18637	16315	1	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	16315	2	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	16315	3	and	and	CC
18637	16315	4	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	16315	5	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	16315	6	on	on	IN
18637	16315	7	the	the	DT
18637	16315	8	ground	ground	NN
18637	16315	9	that	that	IN
18637	16315	10	the	the	DT
18637	16315	11	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16315	12	did	do	VBD
18637	16315	13	not	not	RB
18637	16315	14	come	come	VB
18637	16315	15	within	within	IN
18637	16315	16	the	the	DT
18637	16315	17	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	16315	18	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16315	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	16315	20	,	,	,
18637	16315	21	but	but	CC
18637	16315	22	did	do	VBD
18637	16315	23	not	not	RB
18637	16315	24	discuss	discuss	VB
18637	16315	25	the	the	DT
18637	16315	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16315	27	issue	issue	NN
18637	16315	28	.	.	.
18637	16316	1	This	this	DT
18637	16316	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	16316	3	was	be	VBD
18637	16316	4	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	16316	5	in	in	IN
18637	16316	6	Nye	Nye	NNP
18637	16316	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16316	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	16316	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16316	10	United	United	NNP
18637	16316	11	States	States	NNP
18637	16316	12	,	,	,
18637	16316	13	313	313	CD
18637	16316	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16316	15	33	33	CD
18637	16316	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16316	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	16316	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16316	19	.	.	.
18637	16317	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16317	2	136	136	CD
18637	16317	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16317	4	314	314	CD
18637	16317	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16317	6	252	252	CD
18637	16317	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16317	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	16317	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16317	10	.	.	.
18637	16318	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16318	2	137	137	CD
18637	16318	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16318	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16318	5	.	.	.
18637	16319	1	271	271	CD
18637	16319	2	.	.	.
18637	16320	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16320	2	138	138	CD
18637	16320	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16320	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16320	5	.	.	.
18637	16321	1	283	283	CD
18637	16321	2	,	,	,
18637	16321	3	284	284	CD
18637	16321	4	.	.	.
18637	16322	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16322	2	139	139	CD
18637	16322	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16322	4	328	328	CD
18637	16322	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16322	6	331	331	CD
18637	16322	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16322	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	16322	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16322	10	.	.	.
18637	16323	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16323	2	140	140	CD
18637	16323	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16323	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16323	5	.	.	.
18637	16324	1	350	350	CD
18637	16324	2	.	.	.
18637	16325	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16325	2	141	141	CD
18637	16325	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16325	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16325	5	.	.	.
18637	16326	1	349	349	CD
18637	16326	2	.	.	.
18637	16327	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16327	2	142	142	CD
18637	16327	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16327	4	331	331	CD
18637	16327	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16327	6	367	367	CD
18637	16327	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16327	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	16327	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16327	10	.	.	.
18637	16328	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16328	2	143	143	CD
18637	16328	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16328	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16328	5	.	.	.
18637	16329	1	376	376	CD
18637	16329	2	.	.	.
18637	16330	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16330	2	144	144	CD
18637	16330	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16330	4	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	16330	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16330	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16330	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16330	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	16330	9	,	,	,
18637	16330	10	107	107	CD
18637	16330	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16330	12	43	43	CD
18637	16330	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16330	14	1897	1897	CD
18637	16330	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16330	16	.	.	.
18637	16331	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16331	2	145	145	CD
18637	16331	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16331	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16331	5	.	.	.
18637	16332	1	47	47	CD
18637	16332	2	.	.	.
18637	16333	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16333	2	146	146	CD
18637	16333	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16333	4	307	307	CD
18637	16333	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16333	6	496	496	CD
18637	16333	7	,	,	,
18637	16333	8	515	515	CD
18637	16333	9	,	,	,
18637	16333	10	516	516	CD
18637	16333	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16333	12	1939	1939	CD
18637	16333	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16333	14	.	.	.
18637	16334	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16334	2	147	147	CD
18637	16334	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16334	4	334	334	CD
18637	16334	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16334	6	558	558	CD
18637	16334	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16334	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	16334	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16334	10	.	.	.
18637	16335	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16335	2	148	148	CD
18637	16335	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16335	4	Kovacs	Kovacs	NNP
18637	16335	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16335	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16335	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16335	8	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	16335	9	,	,	,
18637	16335	10	336	336	CD
18637	16335	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16335	12	77	77	CD
18637	16335	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16335	14	1949	1949	CD
18637	16335	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16335	16	.	.	.
18637	16336	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16336	2	149	149	CD
18637	16336	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16336	4	Public	Public	NNP
18637	16336	5	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	16336	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	16336	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16336	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	16336	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16336	10	Pollak	Pollak	NNP
18637	16336	11	,	,	,
18637	16336	12	343	343	CD
18637	16336	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16336	14	451	451	CD
18637	16336	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16336	16	1952	1952	CD
18637	16336	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16336	18	.	.	.
18637	16337	1	The	the	DT
18637	16337	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	16337	3	overruled	overrule	VBD
18637	16337	4	the	the	DT
18637	16337	5	United	United	NNP
18637	16337	6	States	States	NNP
18637	16337	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16337	8	of	of	IN
18637	16337	9	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	16337	10	for	for	IN
18637	16337	11	the	the	DT
18637	16337	12	District	District	NNP
18637	16337	13	of	of	IN
18637	16337	14	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	16337	15	.	.	.
18637	16338	1	Here	here	RB
18637	16338	2	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	16338	3	Edgerton	Edgerton	NNP
18637	16338	4	,	,	,
18637	16338	5	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	16338	6	for	for	IN
18637	16338	7	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16338	8	and	and	CC
18637	16338	9	two	two	CD
18637	16338	10	associates	associate	NNS
18637	16338	11	,	,	,
18637	16338	12	said	say	VBD
18637	16338	13	:	:	:
18637	16338	14	"	"	``
18637	16338	15	Exploitation	exploitation	NN
18637	16338	16	of	of	IN
18637	16338	17	this	this	DT
18637	16338	18	audience	audience	NN
18637	16338	19	through	through	IN
18637	16338	20	assault	assault	NN
18637	16338	21	on	on	IN
18637	16338	22	the	the	DT
18637	16338	23	unavertible	unavertible	JJ
18637	16338	24	sense	sense	NN
18637	16338	25	of	of	IN
18637	16338	26	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16338	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	16338	28	a	a	DT
18637	16338	29	new	new	JJ
18637	16338	30	phenomenon	phenomenon	NN
18637	16338	31	.	.	.
18637	16339	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16339	2	raises	raise	VBZ
18637	16339	3	'	'	''
18637	16339	4	issues	issue	NNS
18637	16339	5	that	that	WDT
18637	16339	6	were	be	VBD
18637	16339	7	not	not	RB
18637	16339	8	implied	imply	VBN
18637	16339	9	in	in	IN
18637	16339	10	the	the	DT
18637	16339	11	means	mean	NNS
18637	16339	12	of	of	IN
18637	16339	13	communication	communication	NN
18637	16339	14	known	know	VBN
18637	16339	15	or	or	CC
18637	16339	16	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
18637	16339	17	by	by	IN
18637	16339	18	Franklin	Franklin	NNP
18637	16339	19	and	and	CC
18637	16339	20	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	16339	21	and	and	CC
18637	16339	22	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	16339	23	.	.	.
18637	16339	24	'	'	''
18637	16340	1	But	but	CC
18637	16340	2	the	the	DT
18637	16340	3	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	16340	4	of	of	IN
18637	16340	5	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	16340	6	,	,	,
18637	16340	7	as	as	IN
18637	16340	8	appellants	appellant	NNS
18637	16340	9	say	say	VBP
18637	16340	10	in	in	IN
18637	16340	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16340	12	brief	brief	NN
18637	16340	13	,	,	,
18637	16340	14	can	can	MD
18637	16340	15	keep	keep	VB
18637	16340	16	up	up	RP
18637	16340	17	with	with	IN
18637	16340	18	anything	anything	NN
18637	16340	19	an	an	DT
18637	16340	20	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	16340	21	man	man	NN
18637	16340	22	or	or	CC
18637	16340	23	an	an	DT
18637	16340	24	electronics	electronic	NNS
18637	16340	25	engineer	engineer	NN
18637	16340	26	can	can	MD
18637	16340	27	think	think	VB
18637	16340	28	of	of	IN
18637	16340	29	.	.	.
18637	16341	1	*	*	NFP
18637	16341	2	*	*	NFP
18637	16341	3	*	*	NFP
18637	16341	4	"	"	''
18637	16341	5	If	if	IN
18637	16341	6	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	16341	7	obliged	oblige	VBD
18637	16341	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16341	9	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	16341	10	to	to	TO
18637	16341	11	read	read	VB
18637	16341	12	what	what	WP
18637	16341	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16341	14	liked	like	VBD
18637	16341	15	or	or	CC
18637	16341	16	get	get	VB
18637	16341	17	off	off	IN
18637	16341	18	the	the	DT
18637	16341	19	car	car	NN
18637	16341	20	,	,	,
18637	16341	21	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	16341	22	of	of	IN
18637	16341	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16341	24	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16341	25	would	would	MD
18637	16341	26	be	be	VB
18637	16341	27	obvious	obvious	JJ
18637	16341	28	.	.	.
18637	16342	1	Transit	transit	NN
18637	16342	2	obliges	oblige	VBZ
18637	16342	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16342	4	to	to	TO
18637	16342	5	hear	hear	VB
18637	16342	6	what	what	WP
18637	16342	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16342	8	likes	like	VBZ
18637	16342	9	or	or	CC
18637	16342	10	get	get	VB
18637	16342	11	off	off	IN
18637	16342	12	the	the	DT
18637	16342	13	car	car	NN
18637	16342	14	.	.	.
18637	16343	1	Freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16343	2	of	of	IN
18637	16343	3	attention	attention	NN
18637	16343	4	,	,	,
18637	16343	5	which	which	WDT
18637	16343	6	forced	force	VBD
18637	16343	7	listening	listening	NN
18637	16343	8	destroys	destroy	NNS
18637	16343	9	,	,	,
18637	16343	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	16343	11	a	a	DT
18637	16343	12	part	part	NN
18637	16343	13	of	of	IN
18637	16343	14	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16343	15	essential	essential	JJ
18637	16343	16	to	to	IN
18637	16343	17	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	16343	18	and	and	CC
18637	16343	19	to	to	IN
18637	16343	20	society	society	NN
18637	16343	21	.	.	.
18637	16344	1	The	the	DT
18637	16344	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16344	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16344	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	16344	5	said	say	VBN
18637	16344	6	that	that	IN
18637	16344	7	the	the	DT
18637	16344	8	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16344	9	guarantee	guarantee	NN
18637	16344	10	of	of	IN
18637	16344	11	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16344	12	'	'	POS
18637	16344	13	embraces	embrace	NNS
18637	16344	14	not	not	RB
18637	16344	15	only	only	RB
18637	16344	16	the	the	DT
18637	16344	17	right	right	NN
18637	16344	18	of	of	IN
18637	16344	19	a	a	DT
18637	16344	20	person	person	NN
18637	16344	21	to	to	TO
18637	16344	22	be	be	VB
18637	16344	23	free	free	JJ
18637	16344	24	from	from	IN
18637	16344	25	physical	physical	JJ
18637	16344	26	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	16344	27	,	,	,
18637	16344	28	but	but	CC
18637	16344	29	the	the	DT
18637	16344	30	right	right	NN
18637	16344	31	to	to	TO
18637	16344	32	be	be	VB
18637	16344	33	free	free	JJ
18637	16344	34	in	in	IN
18637	16344	35	the	the	DT
18637	16344	36	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	16344	37	of	of	IN
18637	16344	38	all	all	PDT
18637	16344	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16344	40	faculties	faculty	NNS
18637	16344	41	*	*	NFP
18637	16344	42	*	*	NFP
18637	16344	43	*	*	NFP
18637	16344	44	.	.	.
18637	16344	45	'	'	''
18637	16345	1	One	one	CD
18637	16345	2	who	who	WP
18637	16345	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	16345	4	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	16345	5	to	to	IN
18637	16345	6	forced	force	VBN
18637	16345	7	listening	listening	NN
18637	16345	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	16345	9	not	not	RB
18637	16345	10	free	free	JJ
18637	16345	11	in	in	IN
18637	16345	12	the	the	DT
18637	16345	13	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	16345	14	of	of	IN
18637	16345	15	all	all	PDT
18637	16345	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16345	17	faculties	faculty	NNS
18637	16345	18	.	.	.
18637	16345	19	"	"	''
18637	16346	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16346	2	quoted	quote	VBD
18637	16346	3	with	with	IN
18637	16346	4	approval	approval	NN
18637	16346	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16346	6	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	16346	7	's	's	POS
18637	16346	8	statement	statement	NN
18637	16346	9	in	in	IN
18637	16346	10	Kovacs	Kovacs	NNP
18637	16346	11	_	_	NNP
18637	16346	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	16346	13	_	_	NNP
18637	16346	14	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	16346	15	,	,	,
18637	16346	16	"	"	``
18637	16346	17	The	the	DT
18637	16346	18	right	right	NN
18637	16346	19	of	of	IN
18637	16346	20	free	free	JJ
18637	16346	21	speech	speech	NN
18637	16346	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	16346	23	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	16346	24	every	every	DT
18637	16346	25	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	16346	26	that	that	WDT
18637	16346	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16346	28	may	may	MD
18637	16346	29	reach	reach	VB
18637	16346	30	the	the	DT
18637	16346	31	minds	mind	NNS
18637	16346	32	of	of	IN
18637	16346	33	willing	willing	JJ
18637	16346	34	listeners	listener	NNS
18637	16346	35	.	.	.
18637	16346	36	"	"	''
18637	16347	1	--191	--191	:
18637	16347	2	F.	F.	NNP
18637	16347	3	2d	2d	NNP
18637	16347	4	450	450	CD
18637	16347	5	,	,	,
18637	16347	6	456	456	CD
18637	16347	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16347	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	16347	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16347	10	.	.	.
18637	16348	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16348	2	150	150	CD
18637	16348	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16348	4	Lovell	Lovell	NNP
18637	16348	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16348	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16348	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16348	8	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	16348	9	,	,	,
18637	16348	10	303	303	CD
18637	16348	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16348	12	444	444	CD
18637	16348	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16348	14	1938	1938	CD
18637	16348	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16348	16	;	;	:
18637	16348	17	Schneider	Schneider	NNP
18637	16348	18	_	_	NNP
18637	16348	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	16348	20	_	_	NNP
18637	16348	21	State	State	NNP
18637	16348	22	,	,	,
18637	16348	23	308	308	CD
18637	16348	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16348	25	147	147	CD
18637	16348	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16348	27	1939	1939	CD
18637	16348	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16348	29	;	;	:
18637	16348	30	Largent	Largent	NNP
18637	16348	31	_	_	NNP
18637	16348	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	16348	33	_	_	NNP
18637	16348	34	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	16348	35	,	,	,
18637	16348	36	318	318	CD
18637	16348	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16348	38	418	418	CD
18637	16348	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16348	40	1943	1943	CD
18637	16348	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16348	42	.	.	.
18637	16349	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16349	2	151	151	CD
18637	16349	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16349	4	Schneider	Schneider	NNP
18637	16349	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16349	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16349	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16349	8	State	State	NNP
18637	16349	9	,	,	,
18637	16349	10	308	308	CD
18637	16349	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16349	12	147	147	CD
18637	16349	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16349	14	1930	1930	CD
18637	16349	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16349	16	;	;	:
18637	16349	17	Jamison	Jamison	NNP
18637	16349	18	_	_	NNP
18637	16349	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	16349	20	_	_	NNP
18637	16349	21	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	16349	22	,	,	,
18637	16349	23	318	318	CD
18637	16349	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16349	25	413	413	CD
18637	16349	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16349	27	1943	1943	CD
18637	16349	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16349	29	.	.	.
18637	16350	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16350	2	152	152	CD
18637	16350	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16350	4	Marsh	Marsh	NNP
18637	16350	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16350	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16350	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16350	8	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	16350	9	,	,	,
18637	16350	10	326	326	CD
18637	16350	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16350	12	501	501	CD
18637	16350	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16350	14	1946	1946	CD
18637	16350	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16350	16	.	.	.
18637	16351	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16351	2	153	153	CD
18637	16351	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16351	4	Tucker	Tucker	NNP
18637	16351	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16351	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16351	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16351	8	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	16351	9	,	,	,
18637	16351	10	326	326	CD
18637	16351	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16351	12	517	517	CD
18637	16351	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16351	14	1946	1946	CD
18637	16351	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16351	16	.	.	.
18637	16352	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16352	2	154	154	CD
18637	16352	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16352	4	Valentine	Valentine	NNP
18637	16352	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16352	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16352	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16352	8	Chrestensen	Chrestensen	NNP
18637	16352	9	,	,	,
18637	16352	10	316	316	CD
18637	16352	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16352	12	52	52	CD
18637	16352	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16352	14	1942	1942	CD
18637	16352	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16352	16	.	.	.
18637	16353	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16353	2	155	155	CD
18637	16353	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16353	4	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	16353	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16353	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16353	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16353	8	Struthers	Struthers	NNP
18637	16353	9	,	,	,
18637	16353	10	319	319	CD
18637	16353	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16353	12	141	141	CD
18637	16353	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16353	14	1943	1943	CD
18637	16353	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16353	16	.	.	.
18637	16354	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16354	2	156	156	CD
18637	16354	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16354	4	Breard	Breard	NNP
18637	16354	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16354	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16354	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16354	8	Alexandria	Alexandria	NNP
18637	16354	9	,	,	,
18637	16354	10	341	341	CD
18637	16354	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16354	12	622	622	CD
18637	16354	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16354	14	1951	1951	CD
18637	16354	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16354	16	.	.	.
18637	16355	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16355	2	157	157	CD
18637	16355	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16355	4	221	221	CD
18637	16355	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16355	6	418	418	CD
18637	16355	7	,	,	,
18637	16355	8	439	439	CD
18637	16355	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16355	10	1911	1911	CD
18637	16355	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16355	12	.	.	.
18637	16356	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16356	2	See	See	NNP
18637	16356	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16356	4	below	below	RB
18637	16356	5	.	.	.
18637	16357	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16357	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	16357	3	's	's	POS
18637	16357	4	Note	note	NN
18637	16357	5	:	:	:
18637	16357	6	Reference	reference	NN
18637	16357	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	16357	8	to	to	IN
18637	16357	9	Section	section	NN
18637	16357	10	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	16357	11	RESTRAINTS	restraint	NNS
18637	16357	12	ON	on	IN
18637	16357	13	FREEDOM	freedom	NN
18637	16357	14	OF	of	IN
18637	16357	15	SPEECH	SPEECH	NNP
18637	16357	16	AND	and	CC
18637	16357	17	PRESS	PRESS	NNP
18637	16357	18	,	,	,
18637	16357	19	above	above	RB
18637	16357	20	.	.	.
18637	16357	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16358	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16358	2	158	158	CD
18637	16358	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16358	4	Near	Near	NNP
18637	16358	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16358	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16358	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16358	8	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	16358	9	,	,	,
18637	16358	10	283	283	CD
18637	16358	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16358	12	697	697	CD
18637	16358	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16358	14	1931	1931	CD
18637	16358	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16358	16	.	.	.
18637	16359	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16359	2	159	159	CD
18637	16359	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16359	4	Drivers	Drivers	NNPS
18637	16359	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	16359	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16359	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16359	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16359	9	Meadowmoor	Meadowmoor	NNP
18637	16359	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16359	11	,	,	,
18637	16359	12	312	312	CD
18637	16359	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16359	14	287	287	CD
18637	16359	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16359	16	1941	1941	CD
18637	16359	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16359	18	;	;	:
18637	16359	19	Carpenters	Carpenters	NNP
18637	16359	20	Union	Union	NNP
18637	16359	21	_	_	NNP
18637	16359	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	16359	23	_	_	NNP
18637	16359	24	Ritter	Ritter	NNP
18637	16359	25	's	's	POS
18637	16359	26	Cafe	Cafe	NNP
18637	16359	27	,	,	,
18637	16359	28	315	315	CD
18637	16359	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16359	30	722	722	CD
18637	16359	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16359	32	1942	1942	CD
18637	16359	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16359	34	.	.	.
18637	16360	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16360	2	160	160	CD
18637	16360	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16360	4	315	315	CD
18637	16360	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16360	6	568	568	CD
18637	16360	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16360	8	1942	1942	CD
18637	16360	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16360	10	.	.	.
18637	16361	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16361	2	161	161	CD
18637	16361	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16361	4	319	319	CD
18637	16361	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16361	6	624	624	CD
18637	16361	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16361	8	1943	1943	CD
18637	16361	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16361	10	.	.	.
18637	16362	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16362	2	162	162	CD
18637	16362	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16362	4	315	315	CD
18637	16362	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16362	6	568	568	CD
18637	16362	7	,	,	,
18637	16362	8	571	571	CD
18637	16362	9	,	,	,
18637	16362	10	572	572	CD
18637	16362	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16362	12	1942	1942	CD
18637	16362	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16362	14	.	.	.
18637	16363	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16363	2	163	163	CD
18637	16363	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16363	4	319	319	CD
18637	16363	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16363	6	624	624	CD
18637	16363	7	,	,	,
18637	16363	8	633	633	CD
18637	16363	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16363	10	1943	1943	CD
18637	16363	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16363	12	.	.	.
18637	16364	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16364	2	164	164	CD
18637	16364	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16364	4	Lovell	Lovell	NNP
18637	16364	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16364	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16364	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16364	8	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	16364	9	,	,	,
18637	16364	10	303	303	CD
18637	16364	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16364	12	444	444	CD
18637	16364	13	,	,	,
18637	16364	14	451	451	CD
18637	16364	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16364	16	1938	1938	CD
18637	16364	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16364	18	.	.	.
18637	16365	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16365	2	165	165	CD
18637	16365	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16365	4	Chaplinsky	Chaplinsky	NNP
18637	16365	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16365	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16365	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16365	8	New	New	NNP
18637	16365	9	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	16365	10	,	,	,
18637	16365	11	315	315	CD
18637	16365	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16365	13	568	568	CD
18637	16365	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16365	15	1942	1942	CD
18637	16365	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16365	17	;	;	:
18637	16365	18	Cox	Cox	NNP
18637	16365	19	_	_	NNP
18637	16365	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	16365	21	_	_	NNP
18637	16365	22	New	New	NNP
18637	16365	23	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	16365	24	,	,	,
18637	16365	25	312	312	CD
18637	16365	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16365	27	569	569	CD
18637	16365	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16365	29	1941	1941	CD
18637	16365	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16365	31	.	.	.
18637	16366	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16366	2	166	166	CD
18637	16366	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16366	4	Lovell	Lovell	NNP
18637	16366	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16366	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16366	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16366	8	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	16366	9	,	,	,
18637	16366	10	303	303	CD
18637	16366	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16366	12	444	444	CD
18637	16366	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16366	14	1938	1938	CD
18637	16366	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16366	16	;	;	:
18637	16366	17	Hague	Hague	NNP
18637	16366	18	_	_	NNP
18637	16366	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	16366	20	_	_	NNP
18637	16366	21	C.I.O.	C.I.O.	NNP
18637	16366	22	,	,	,
18637	16366	23	307	307	CD
18637	16366	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16366	25	496	496	CD
18637	16366	26	,	,	,
18637	16366	27	516	516	CD
18637	16366	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16366	29	1939	1939	CD
18637	16366	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16366	31	;	;	:
18637	16366	32	Schneider	Schneider	NNP
18637	16366	33	_	_	NNP
18637	16366	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	16366	35	_	_	NNP
18637	16366	36	State	State	NNP
18637	16366	37	,	,	,
18637	16366	38	308	308	CD
18637	16366	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16366	40	147	147	CD
18637	16366	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16366	42	1939	1939	CD
18637	16366	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16366	44	;	;	:
18637	16366	45	Cantwell	Cantwell	NNP
18637	16366	46	_	_	NNP
18637	16366	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	16366	48	_	_	NNP
18637	16366	49	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	16366	50	,	,	,
18637	16366	51	310	310	CD
18637	16366	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16366	53	296	296	CD
18637	16366	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16366	55	1940	1940	CD
18637	16366	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16366	57	;	;	:
18637	16366	58	Largent	Largent	NNP
18637	16366	59	_	_	NNP
18637	16366	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	16366	61	_	_	NNP
18637	16366	62	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	16366	63	,	,	,
18637	16366	64	318	318	CD
18637	16366	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16366	66	418	418	CD
18637	16366	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16366	68	1943	1943	CD
18637	16366	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16366	70	;	;	:
18637	16366	71	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	16366	72	_	_	NNP
18637	16366	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	16366	74	_	_	NNP
18637	16366	75	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	16366	76	,	,	,
18637	16366	77	323	323	CD
18637	16366	78	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16366	79	516	516	CD
18637	16366	80	,	,	,
18637	16366	81	538	538	CD
18637	16366	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16366	83	1945	1945	CD
18637	16366	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16366	85	;	;	:
18637	16366	86	Saia	Saia	NNP
18637	16366	87	_	_	NNP
18637	16366	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	16366	89	_	_	NNP
18637	16366	90	New	New	NNP
18637	16366	91	York	York	NNP
18637	16366	92	,	,	,
18637	16366	93	334	334	CD
18637	16366	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16366	95	558	558	CD
18637	16366	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16366	97	1948	1948	CD
18637	16366	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16366	99	.	.	.
18637	16367	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16367	2	167	167	CD
18637	16367	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16367	4	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	16367	5	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	16367	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16367	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16367	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16367	9	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	16367	10	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	16367	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16367	12	,	,	,
18637	16367	13	289	289	CD
18637	16367	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16367	15	266	266	CD
18637	16367	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16367	17	1933	1933	CD
18637	16367	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16367	19	;	;	:
18637	16367	20	Communications	Communications	NNP
18637	16367	21	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
18637	16367	22	.	.	.
18637	16368	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16368	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	16368	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16368	4	N.B.C.	N.B.C.	NNP
18637	16368	5	,	,	,
18637	16368	6	319	319	CD
18637	16368	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16368	8	239	239	CD
18637	16368	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16368	10	1943	1943	CD
18637	16368	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16368	12	.	.	.
18637	16369	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16369	2	168	168	CD
18637	16369	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16369	4	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	16369	5	Film	Film	NNP
18637	16369	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	16369	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16369	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	16369	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16369	10	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	16369	11	Indus'l	Indus'l	NNP
18637	16369	12	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	16369	13	.	.	NNP
18637	16369	14	,	,	,
18637	16369	15	236	236	CD
18637	16369	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16369	17	230	230	CD
18637	16369	18	,	,	,
18637	16369	19	244	244	CD
18637	16369	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16369	21	1915	1915	CD
18637	16369	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16369	23	.	.	.
18637	16370	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16370	2	169	169	CD
18637	16370	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16370	4	334	334	CD
18637	16370	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16370	6	131	131	CD
18637	16370	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16370	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	16370	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16370	10	.	.	.
18637	16371	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16371	2	170	170	CD
18637	16371	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16371	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16371	5	.	.	.
18637	16372	1	166	166	CD
18637	16372	2	.	.	.
18637	16373	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16373	2	171	171	CD
18637	16373	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16373	4	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
18637	16373	5	Burstyn	Burstyn	NNP
18637	16373	6	,	,	,
18637	16373	7	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	16373	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16373	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	16373	10	_	_	NNP
18637	16373	11	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	16373	12	,	,	,
18637	16373	13	343	343	CD
18637	16373	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16373	15	495	495	CD
18637	16373	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16373	17	1952	1952	CD
18637	16373	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16373	19	.	.	.
18637	16374	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16374	2	172	172	CD
18637	16374	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16374	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16374	5	.	.	.
18637	16375	1	502	502	CD
18637	16375	2	.	.	.
18637	16376	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16376	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	16376	3	,	,	,
18637	16376	4	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	16376	5	for	for	IN
18637	16376	6	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16376	7	and	and	CC
18637	16376	8	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	16376	9	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	16376	10	and	and	CC
18637	16376	11	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	16376	12	,	,	,
18637	16376	13	elaborates	elaborate	VBZ
18637	16376	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	16376	15	the	the	DT
18637	16376	16	vagueness	vagueness	NN
18637	16376	17	of	of	IN
18637	16376	18	connotation	connotation	NN
18637	16376	19	of	of	IN
18637	16376	20	the	the	DT
18637	16376	21	New	New	NNP
18637	16376	22	York	York	NNP
18637	16376	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16376	24	's	's	POS
18637	16376	25	use	use	NN
18637	16376	26	of	of	IN
18637	16376	27	the	the	DT
18637	16376	28	word	word	NN
18637	16376	29	"	"	``
18637	16376	30	sacrilegious	sacrilegious	JJ
18637	16376	31	.	.	.
18637	16376	32	"	"	''
18637	16377	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16377	2	See	See	NNP
18637	16377	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16377	4	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
18637	16377	5	to	to	IN
18637	16377	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16377	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16377	8	,	,	,
18637	16377	9	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16377	10	.	.	.
18637	16378	1	533	533	CD
18637	16378	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16378	3	40	40	CD
18637	16378	4	.	.	.
18637	16379	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16379	2	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	16379	3	,	,	,
18637	16379	4	in	in	IN
18637	16379	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16379	6	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	16379	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16379	8	,	,	,
18637	16379	9	suggests	suggest	VBZ
18637	16379	10	that	that	IN
18637	16379	11	the	the	DT
18637	16379	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16379	13	will	will	MD
18637	16379	14	now	now	RB
18637	16379	15	have	have	VB
18637	16379	16	the	the	DT
18637	16379	17	duty	duty	NN
18637	16379	18	of	of	IN
18637	16379	19	examining	examine	VBG
18637	16379	20	"	"	``
18637	16379	21	the	the	DT
18637	16379	22	facts	fact	NNS
18637	16379	23	of	of	IN
18637	16379	24	the	the	DT
18637	16379	25	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	16379	26	of	of	IN
18637	16379	27	a	a	DT
18637	16379	28	license	license	NN
18637	16379	29	in	in	IN
18637	16379	30	each	each	DT
18637	16379	31	case	case	NN
18637	16379	32	to	to	TO
18637	16379	33	determine	determine	VB
18637	16379	34	whether	whether	IN
18637	16379	35	the	the	DT
18637	16379	36	principles	principle	NNS
18637	16379	37	of	of	IN
18637	16379	38	the	the	DT
18637	16379	39	First	First	NNP
18637	16379	40	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16379	41	have	have	VBP
18637	16379	42	been	be	VBN
18637	16379	43	honored	honor	VBN
18637	16379	44	.	.	.
18637	16379	45	"	"	''
18637	16380	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	16380	2	.	.	.
18637	16381	1	506	506	CD
18637	16381	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16381	3	507	507	CD
18637	16381	4	.	.	.
18637	16382	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16382	2	173	173	CD
18637	16382	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16382	4	314	314	CD
18637	16382	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16382	6	252	252	CD
18637	16382	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16382	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	16382	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16382	10	.	.	.
18637	16383	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16383	2	174	174	CD
18637	16383	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16383	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16383	5	.	.	.
18637	16384	1	263	263	CD
18637	16384	2	.	.	.
18637	16385	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16385	2	175	175	CD
18637	16385	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16385	4	323	323	CD
18637	16385	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16385	6	516	516	CD
18637	16385	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16385	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	16385	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16385	10	.	.	.
18637	16386	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16386	2	176	176	CD
18637	16386	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16386	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16386	5	.	.	.
18637	16387	1	529	529	CD
18637	16387	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	16387	3	530	530	CD
18637	16387	4	.	.	.
18637	16388	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16388	2	177	177	CD
18637	16388	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16388	4	Palko	Palko	NNP
18637	16388	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16388	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16388	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16388	8	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	16388	9	,	,	,
18637	16388	10	302	302	CD
18637	16388	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16388	12	319	319	CD
18637	16388	13	,	,	,
18637	16388	14	327	327	CD
18637	16388	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16388	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	16388	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16388	18	.	.	.
18637	16389	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16389	2	178	178	CD
18637	16389	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16389	4	United	United	NNP
18637	16389	5	States	States	NNP
18637	16389	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16389	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16389	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16389	9	Carolene	Carolene	NNP
18637	16389	10	Products	Products	NNP
18637	16389	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16389	12	,	,	,
18637	16389	13	304	304	CD
18637	16389	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16389	15	144	144	CD
18637	16389	16	,	,	,
18637	16389	17	152	152	CD
18637	16389	18	,	,	,
18637	16389	19	fn	fn	CD
18637	16389	20	.	.	.
18637	16390	1	4	4	CD
18637	16390	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16390	3	1938	1938	CD
18637	16390	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16390	5	.	.	.
18637	16391	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16391	2	179	179	CD
18637	16391	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16391	4	328	328	CD
18637	16391	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16391	6	331	331	CD
18637	16391	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16391	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	16391	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16391	10	.	.	.
18637	16392	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16392	2	180	180	CD
18637	16392	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16392	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16392	5	.	.	.
18637	16393	1	353	353	CD
18637	16393	2	.	.	.
18637	16394	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16394	2	181	181	CD
18637	16394	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16394	4	Kovacs	Kovacs	NNP
18637	16394	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16394	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16394	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16394	8	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	16394	9	,	,	,
18637	16394	10	336	336	CD
18637	16394	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16394	12	77	77	CD
18637	16394	13	,	,	,
18637	16394	14	88	88	CD
18637	16394	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16394	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	16394	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16394	18	.	.	.
18637	16395	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16395	2	182	182	CD
18637	16395	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16395	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16395	5	.	.	.
18637	16396	1	90	90	CD
18637	16396	2	.	.	.
18637	16397	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16397	2	183	183	CD
18637	16397	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16397	4	Brinegar	Brinegar	NNP
18637	16397	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16397	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16397	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16397	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16397	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16397	10	,	,	,
18637	16397	11	338	338	CD
18637	16397	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16397	13	160	160	CD
18637	16397	14	,	,	,
18637	16397	15	180	180	CD
18637	16397	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16397	17	1949	1949	CD
18637	16397	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16397	19	.	.	.
18637	16398	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16398	2	184	184	CD
18637	16398	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16398	4	Terminiello	Terminiello	NNP
18637	16398	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16398	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16398	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16398	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	16398	9	,	,	,
18637	16398	10	337	337	CD
18637	16398	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16398	12	1	1	CD
18637	16398	13	,	,	,
18637	16398	14	4	4	CD
18637	16398	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16398	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	16398	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16398	18	.	.	.
18637	16399	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16399	2	185	185	CD
18637	16399	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16399	4	Kunz	Kunz	NNP
18637	16399	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16399	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16399	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16399	8	New	New	NNP
18637	16399	9	York	York	NNP
18637	16399	10	,	,	,
18637	16399	11	340	340	CD
18637	16399	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16399	13	290	290	CD
18637	16399	14	,	,	,
18637	16399	15	302	302	CD
18637	16399	16	.	.	.
18637	16400	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16400	2	186	186	CD
18637	16400	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16400	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16400	5	.	.	.
18637	16401	1	309	309	CD
18637	16401	2	.	.	.
18637	16402	1	In	in	IN
18637	16402	2	a	a	DT
18637	16402	3	footnote	footnote	NN
18637	16402	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16402	5	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	16402	6	points	point	VBZ
18637	16402	7	to	to	IN
18637	16402	8	the	the	DT
18637	16402	9	peculiarly	peculiarly	RB
18637	16402	10	protected	protect	VBN
18637	16402	11	position	position	NN
18637	16402	12	of	of	IN
18637	16402	13	the	the	DT
18637	16402	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16402	15	today	today	NN
18637	16402	16	,	,	,
18637	16402	17	thanks	thank	NNS
18637	16402	18	to	to	IN
18637	16402	19	ch	ch	NN
18637	16402	20	.	.	.
18637	16403	1	479	479	CD
18637	16403	2	,	,	,
18637	16403	3	Public	Public	NNP
18637	16403	4	Law	Law	NNP
18637	16403	5	250	250	CD
18637	16403	6	,	,	,
18637	16403	7	81st	81st	JJ
18637	16403	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16403	9	,	,	,
18637	16403	10	approved	approve	VBD
18637	16403	11	August	August	NNP
18637	16403	12	18	18	CD
18637	16403	13	,	,	,
18637	16403	14	1949	1949	CD
18637	16403	15	.	.	.
18637	16404	1	This	this	DT
18637	16404	2	makes	make	VBZ
18637	16404	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16404	4	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	16404	5	to	to	TO
18637	16404	6	"	"	``
18637	16404	7	make	make	VB
18637	16404	8	any	any	DT
18637	16404	9	harangue	harangue	NN
18637	16404	10	or	or	CC
18637	16404	11	oration	oration	NN
18637	16404	12	,	,	,
18637	16404	13	or	or	CC
18637	16404	14	utter	utter	JJ
18637	16404	15	loud	loud	JJ
18637	16404	16	,	,	,
18637	16404	17	threatening	threaten	VBG
18637	16404	18	,	,	,
18637	16404	19	or	or	CC
18637	16404	20	abusive	abusive	JJ
18637	16404	21	language	language	NN
18637	16404	22	in	in	IN
18637	16404	23	the	the	DT
18637	16404	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16404	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16404	26	Building	Building	NNP
18637	16404	27	or	or	CC
18637	16404	28	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	16404	29	.	.	.
18637	16404	30	"	"	''
18637	16405	1	§	§	NNP
18637	16405	2	5	5	CD
18637	16405	3	.	.	.
18637	16406	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16406	2	also	also	RB
18637	16406	3	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	16406	4	display	display	NN
18637	16406	5	of	of	IN
18637	16406	6	any	any	DT
18637	16406	7	"	"	``
18637	16406	8	flag	flag	NN
18637	16406	9	,	,	,
18637	16406	10	banner	banner	NN
18637	16406	11	,	,	,
18637	16406	12	or	or	CC
18637	16406	13	device	device	NN
18637	16406	14	designed	design	VBN
18637	16406	15	or	or	CC
18637	16406	16	adapted	adapt	VBN
18637	16406	17	to	to	TO
18637	16406	18	bring	bring	VB
18637	16406	19	into	into	IN
18637	16406	20	public	public	JJ
18637	16406	21	notice	notice	NN
18637	16406	22	any	any	DT
18637	16406	23	party	party	NN
18637	16406	24	,	,	,
18637	16406	25	organization	organization	NN
18637	16406	26	,	,	,
18637	16406	27	or	or	CC
18637	16406	28	movement	movement	NN
18637	16406	29	.	.	.
18637	16406	30	"	"	''
18637	16407	1	§	§	NNP
18637	16407	2	6	6	CD
18637	16407	3	.	.	.
18637	16408	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	16408	2	,	,	,
18637	16408	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16408	4	authorizes	authorize	VBZ
18637	16408	5	the	the	DT
18637	16408	6	marshal	marshal	NN
18637	16408	7	to	to	TO
18637	16408	8	"	"	``
18637	16408	9	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	16408	10	such	such	JJ
18637	16408	11	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	16408	12	approved	approve	VBN
18637	16408	13	by	by	IN
18637	16408	14	the	the	DT
18637	16408	15	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	16408	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16408	17	of	of	IN
18637	16408	18	the	the	DT
18637	16408	19	United	United	NNP
18637	16408	20	States	States	NNP
18637	16408	21	,	,	,
18637	16408	22	as	as	IN
18637	16408	23	may	may	MD
18637	16408	24	be	be	VB
18637	16408	25	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	16408	26	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	16408	27	for	for	IN
18637	16408	28	the	the	DT
18637	16408	29	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	16408	30	protection	protection	NN
18637	16408	31	of	of	IN
18637	16408	32	the	the	DT
18637	16408	33	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16408	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16408	35	Building	Building	NNP
18637	16408	36	and	and	CC
18637	16408	37	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	16408	38	and	and	CC
18637	16408	39	of	of	IN
18637	16408	40	persons	person	NNS
18637	16408	41	and	and	CC
18637	16408	42	property	property	NN
18637	16408	43	therein	therein	RB
18637	16408	44	,	,	,
18637	16408	45	and	and	CC
18637	16408	46	for	for	IN
18637	16408	47	the	the	DT
18637	16408	48	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	16408	49	of	of	IN
18637	16408	50	suitable	suitable	JJ
18637	16408	51	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	16408	52	.	.	.
18637	16408	53	"	"	''
18637	16409	1	§	§	NNP
18637	16409	2	7	7	CD
18637	16409	3	.	.	.
18637	16410	1	Violation	violation	NN
18637	16410	2	of	of	IN
18637	16410	3	these	these	DT
18637	16410	4	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	16410	5	or	or	CC
18637	16410	6	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	16410	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	16410	8	an	an	DT
18637	16410	9	offense	offense	NN
18637	16410	10	punishable	punishable	JJ
18637	16410	11	by	by	IN
18637	16410	12	fine	fine	JJ
18637	16410	13	and	and	CC
18637	16410	14	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	16410	15	.	.	.
18637	16411	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16411	2	187	187	CD
18637	16411	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16411	4	Grosjean	Grosjean	NNP
18637	16411	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16411	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16411	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16411	8	American	American	NNP
18637	16411	9	Press	Press	NNP
18637	16411	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16411	11	,	,	,
18637	16411	12	297	297	CD
18637	16411	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16411	14	233	233	CD
18637	16411	15	,	,	,
18637	16411	16	246	246	CD
18637	16411	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16411	18	1936	1936	CD
18637	16411	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16411	20	.	.	.
18637	16412	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16412	2	188	188	CD
18637	16412	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16412	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16412	5	.	.	.
18637	16413	1	250	250	CD
18637	16413	2	.	.	.
18637	16414	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16414	2	189	189	CD
18637	16414	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16414	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16414	5	.	.	.
18637	16415	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16415	2	190	190	CD
18637	16415	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16415	4	Murdock	Murdock	NNP
18637	16415	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16415	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16415	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16415	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	16415	9	,	,	,
18637	16415	10	319	319	CD
18637	16415	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16415	12	105	105	CD
18637	16415	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16415	14	1943	1943	CD
18637	16415	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16415	16	;	;	:
18637	16415	17	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	16415	18	_	_	NNP
18637	16415	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	16415	20	_	_	NNP
18637	16415	21	Opelika	Opelika	NNP
18637	16415	22	,	,	,
18637	16415	23	319	319	CD
18637	16415	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16415	25	103	103	CD
18637	16415	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16415	27	1943	1943	CD
18637	16415	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16415	29	;	;	:
18637	16415	30	Follett	Follett	NNP
18637	16415	31	_	_	NNP
18637	16415	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	16415	33	_	_	NNP
18637	16415	34	McCormick	McCormick	NNP
18637	16415	35	,	,	,
18637	16415	36	321	321	CD
18637	16415	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16415	38	573	573	CD
18637	16415	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16415	40	1944	1944	CD
18637	16415	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16415	42	.	.	.
18637	16416	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16416	2	191	191	CD
18637	16416	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16416	4	Associated	Associated	NNP
18637	16416	5	Press	Press	NNP
18637	16416	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16416	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16416	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16416	9	United	United	NNP
18637	16416	10	States	States	NNP
18637	16416	11	,	,	,
18637	16416	12	326	326	CD
18637	16416	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16416	14	1	1	CD
18637	16416	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16416	16	1945	1945	CD
18637	16416	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16416	18	.	.	.
18637	16417	1	A	a	DT
18637	16417	2	newspaper	newspaper	NN
18637	16417	3	publisher	publisher	NN
18637	16417	4	who	who	WP
18637	16417	5	enjoyed	enjoy	VBD
18637	16417	6	a	a	DT
18637	16417	7	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	16417	8	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	16417	9	of	of	IN
18637	16417	10	mass	mass	JJ
18637	16417	11	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	16417	12	of	of	IN
18637	16417	13	news	news	NN
18637	16417	14	was	be	VBD
18637	16417	15	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	16417	16	from	from	IN
18637	16417	17	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	16417	18	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	16417	19	from	from	IN
18637	16417	20	persons	person	NNS
18637	16417	21	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	16417	22	over	over	IN
18637	16417	23	a	a	DT
18637	16417	24	competing	compete	VBG
18637	16417	25	radio	radio	NN
18637	16417	26	station	station	NN
18637	16417	27	.	.	.
18637	16418	1	The	the	DT
18637	16418	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16418	3	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	16418	4	the	the	DT
18637	16418	5	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	16418	6	against	against	IN
18637	16418	7	the	the	DT
18637	16418	8	objection	objection	NN
18637	16418	9	that	that	WDT
18637	16418	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16418	11	violated	violate	VBD
18637	16418	12	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16418	13	of	of	IN
18637	16418	14	the	the	DT
18637	16418	15	press	press	NN
18637	16418	16	,	,	,
18637	16418	17	holding	hold	VBG
18637	16418	18	that	that	DT
18637	16418	19	appellant	appellant	NN
18637	16418	20	was	be	VBD
18637	16418	21	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	16418	22	of	of	IN
18637	16418	23	attempting	attempt	VBG
18637	16418	24	to	to	TO
18637	16418	25	monopolize	monopolize	VB
18637	16418	26	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	16418	27	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	16418	28	.	.	.
18637	16419	1	Lorain	Lorain	NNP
18637	16419	2	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	16419	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16419	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	16419	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16419	6	United	United	NNP
18637	16419	7	States	States	NNP
18637	16419	8	,	,	,
18637	16419	9	342	342	CD
18637	16419	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16419	11	143	143	CD
18637	16419	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16419	13	1951	1951	CD
18637	16419	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16419	15	.	.	.
18637	16420	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16420	2	192	192	CD
18637	16420	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16420	4	Associated	Associated	NNP
18637	16420	5	Press	Press	NNP
18637	16420	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16420	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16420	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16420	9	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	16420	10	Board	Board	NNP
18637	16420	11	,	,	,
18637	16420	12	301	301	CD
18637	16420	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16420	14	103	103	CD
18637	16420	15	,	,	,
18637	16420	16	133	133	CD
18637	16420	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16420	18	1937	1937	CD
18637	16420	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16420	20	.	.	.
18637	16421	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16421	2	193	193	CD
18637	16421	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16421	4	Okla.	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	16421	5	Press	Press	NNP
18637	16421	6	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	16421	7	.	.	.
18637	16422	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16422	2	_	_	NNP
18637	16422	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	16422	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16422	5	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	16422	6	,	,	,
18637	16422	7	327	327	CD
18637	16422	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16422	9	186	186	CD
18637	16422	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16422	11	1946	1946	CD
18637	16422	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16422	13	.	.	.
18637	16423	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16423	2	194	194	CD
18637	16423	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16423	4	221	221	CD
18637	16423	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16423	6	418	418	CD
18637	16423	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16423	8	1911	1911	CD
18637	16423	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16423	10	.	.	.
18637	16424	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16424	2	195	195	CD
18637	16424	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16424	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16424	5	.	.	.
18637	16425	1	430	430	CD
18637	16425	2	.	.	.
18637	16426	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16426	2	196	196	CD
18637	16426	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16426	4	314	314	CD
18637	16426	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16426	6	469	469	CD
18637	16426	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16426	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	16426	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16426	10	.	.	.
18637	16427	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16427	2	197	197	CD
18637	16427	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16427	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16427	5	:	:	:
18637	16427	6	477	477	CD
18637	16427	7	.	.	.
18637	16428	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16428	2	198	198	CD
18637	16428	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16428	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16428	5	.	.	.
18637	16429	1	478	478	LS
18637	16429	2	.	.	.
18637	16430	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16430	2	199	199	CD
18637	16430	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16430	4	United	United	NNP
18637	16430	5	States	States	NNP
18637	16430	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16430	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16430	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16430	9	C.I.O.	C.I.O.	NNP
18637	16430	10	,	,	,
18637	16430	11	335	335	CD
18637	16430	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16430	13	106	106	CD
18637	16430	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16430	15	1948	1948	CD
18637	16430	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16430	17	.	.	.
18637	16431	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16431	2	200	200	CD
18637	16431	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16431	4	106	106	CD
18637	16431	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16431	6	371	371	CD
18637	16431	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16431	8	1882	1882	CD
18637	16431	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16431	10	.	.	.
18637	16432	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16432	2	201	201	CD
18637	16432	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16432	4	19	19	CD
18637	16432	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	16432	6	.	.	.
18637	16433	1	143	143	CD
18637	16433	2	§	§	NNP
18637	16433	3	6	6	CD
18637	16433	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16433	5	1876	1876	CD
18637	16433	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16433	7	.	.	.
18637	16434	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16434	2	202	202	CD
18637	16434	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16434	4	53	53	CD
18637	16434	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	16434	6	.	.	.
18637	16435	1	1147	1147	CD
18637	16435	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16435	3	1939	1939	CD
18637	16435	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16435	5	.	.	.
18637	16436	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16436	2	203	203	CD
18637	16436	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16436	4	United	United	NNP
18637	16436	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	16436	6	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	16436	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16436	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	16436	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16436	10	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	16436	11	,	,	,
18637	16436	12	330	330	CD
18637	16436	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16436	14	75	75	CD
18637	16436	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16436	16	1947	1947	CD
18637	16436	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16436	18	.	.	.
18637	16437	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16437	2	204	204	CD
18637	16437	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16437	4	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	16437	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16437	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16437	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16437	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16437	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16437	10	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	16437	11	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	16437	12	.	.	.
18637	16438	1	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	16438	2	.	.	NNP
18637	16438	3	,	,	,
18637	16438	4	330	330	CD
18637	16438	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16438	6	127	127	CD
18637	16438	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16438	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	16438	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16438	10	.	.	.
18637	16439	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16439	2	205	205	CD
18637	16439	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16439	4	Schenck	Schenck	NNP
18637	16439	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16439	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16439	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16439	10	,	,	,
18637	16439	11	249	249	CD
18637	16439	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16439	13	47	47	CD
18637	16439	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16439	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	16439	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16439	17	;	;	:
18637	16439	18	Frohwerk	Frohwerk	NNP
18637	16439	19	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	16439	21	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	22	United	United	NNP
18637	16439	23	States	States	NNP
18637	16439	24	,	,	,
18637	16439	25	249	249	CD
18637	16439	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16439	27	204	204	CD
18637	16439	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16439	29	1919	1919	CD
18637	16439	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16439	31	;	;	:
18637	16439	32	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	16439	33	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	16439	35	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	36	United	United	NNP
18637	16439	37	States	States	NNP
18637	16439	38	,	,	,
18637	16439	39	249	249	CD
18637	16439	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16439	41	211	211	CD
18637	16439	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16439	43	1919	1919	CD
18637	16439	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16439	45	;	;	:
18637	16439	46	Abrams	Abrams	NNP
18637	16439	47	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	16439	49	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	50	United	United	NNP
18637	16439	51	States	States	NNP
18637	16439	52	,	,	,
18637	16439	53	250	250	CD
18637	16439	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16439	55	616	616	CD
18637	16439	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16439	57	1919	1919	CD
18637	16439	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16439	59	;	;	:
18637	16439	60	Schaefer	Schaefer	NNP
18637	16439	61	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	16439	63	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	64	United	United	NNP
18637	16439	65	States	States	NNP
18637	16439	66	,	,	,
18637	16439	67	251	251	CD
18637	16439	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16439	69	466	466	CD
18637	16439	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16439	71	1919	1919	CD
18637	16439	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16439	73	;	;	:
18637	16439	74	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	16439	75	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	16439	77	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	78	United	United	NNP
18637	16439	79	States	States	NNP
18637	16439	80	,	,	,
18637	16439	81	252	252	CD
18637	16439	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16439	83	239	239	CD
18637	16439	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16439	85	1920	1920	CD
18637	16439	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16439	87	;	;	:
18637	16439	88	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	89	cf	cf	NNP
18637	16439	90	.	.	.
18637	16439	91	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	92	Gilbert	Gilbert	NNP
18637	16439	93	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	94	v.	v.	IN
18637	16439	95	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	96	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	16439	97	254	254	CD
18637	16439	98	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16439	99	325	325	CD
18637	16439	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16439	101	1920	1920	CD
18637	16439	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16439	103	;	;	:
18637	16439	104	Hartzel	Hartzel	NNP
18637	16439	105	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	106	v.	v.	IN
18637	16439	107	_	_	NNP
18637	16439	108	.	.	.
18637	16440	1	United	United	NNP
18637	16440	2	States	States	NNP
18637	16440	3	,	,	,
18637	16440	4	322	322	CD
18637	16440	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16440	6	680	680	CD
18637	16440	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16440	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	16440	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16440	10	.	.	.
18637	16441	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16441	2	206	206	CD
18637	16441	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16441	4	341	341	CD
18637	16441	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16441	6	494	494	CD
18637	16441	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16441	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	16441	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16441	10	.	.	.
18637	16442	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16442	2	207	207	CD
18637	16442	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16442	4	61	61	CD
18637	16442	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	16442	6	.	.	.
18637	16443	1	136	136	CD
18637	16443	2	,	,	,
18637	16443	3	146	146	CD
18637	16443	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16443	5	1947	1947	CD
18637	16443	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16443	7	;	;	:
18637	16443	8	"	"	``
18637	16443	9	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	16443	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	16443	11	Hartley	Hartley	NNP
18637	16443	12	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16443	13	.	.	.
18637	16443	14	"	"	''
18637	16444	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16444	2	208	208	CD
18637	16444	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16444	4	339	339	CD
18637	16444	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16444	6	382	382	CD
18637	16444	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16444	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	16444	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16444	10	.	.	.
18637	16445	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16445	2	209	209	CD
18637	16445	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16445	4	339	339	CD
18637	16445	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16445	6	846	846	CD
18637	16445	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16445	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	16445	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16445	10	.	.	.
18637	16446	1	Answering	answer	VBG
18637	16446	2	in	in	IN
18637	16446	3	1882	1882	CD
18637	16446	4	the	the	DT
18637	16446	5	objection	objection	NN
18637	16446	6	of	of	IN
18637	16446	7	a	a	DT
18637	16446	8	pensioner	pensioner	NN
18637	16446	9	to	to	IN
18637	16446	10	the	the	DT
18637	16446	11	terms	term	NNS
18637	16446	12	of	of	IN
18637	16446	13	an	an	DT
18637	16446	14	act	act	NN
18637	16446	15	under	under	IN
18637	16446	16	which	which	WDT
18637	16446	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16446	18	received	receive	VBD
18637	16446	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16446	20	pension	pension	NN
18637	16446	21	from	from	IN
18637	16446	22	the	the	DT
18637	16446	23	Government	Government	NNP
18637	16446	24	,	,	,
18637	16446	25	the	the	DT
18637	16446	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16446	27	answered	answer	VBD
18637	16446	28	:	:	:
18637	16446	29	"	"	``
18637	16446	30	Pensions	pension	NNS
18637	16446	31	are	be	VBP
18637	16446	32	the	the	DT
18637	16446	33	bounties	bounty	NNS
18637	16446	34	of	of	IN
18637	16446	35	the	the	DT
18637	16446	36	government	government	NN
18637	16446	37	,	,	,
18637	16446	38	which	which	WDT
18637	16446	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16446	40	has	have	VBZ
18637	16446	41	the	the	DT
18637	16446	42	right	right	NN
18637	16446	43	to	to	TO
18637	16446	44	give	give	VB
18637	16446	45	,	,	,
18637	16446	46	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	16446	47	,	,	,
18637	16446	48	distribute	distribute	VB
18637	16446	49	or	or	CC
18637	16446	50	recall	recall	VB
18637	16446	51	,	,	,
18637	16446	52	at	at	IN
18637	16446	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16446	54	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	16446	55	.	.	.
18637	16446	56	"	"	''
18637	16447	1	United	United	NNP
18637	16447	2	States	States	NNP
18637	16447	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16447	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	16447	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16447	6	Teller	Teller	NNP
18637	16447	7	,	,	,
18637	16447	8	107	107	CD
18637	16447	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16447	10	64	64	CD
18637	16447	11	,	,	,
18637	16447	12	68	68	CD
18637	16447	13	.	.	.
18637	16448	1	Can	Can	MD
18637	16448	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16448	3	be	be	VB
18637	16448	4	doubted	doubt	VBN
18637	16448	5	that	that	IN
18637	16448	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16448	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	16448	8	power	power	NN
18637	16448	9	to	to	TO
18637	16448	10	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	16448	11	at	at	IN
18637	16448	12	any	any	DT
18637	16448	13	time	time	NN
18637	16448	14	the	the	DT
18637	16448	15	protection	protection	NN
18637	16448	16	which	which	WDT
18637	16448	17	present	present	JJ
18637	16448	18	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	16448	19	affords	afford	NNS
18637	16448	20	organized	organize	VBN
18637	16448	21	labor	labor	NN
18637	16448	22	?	?	.
18637	16449	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16449	2	210	210	CD
18637	16449	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16449	4	339	339	CD
18637	16449	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16449	6	382	382	CD
18637	16449	7	,	,	,
18637	16449	8	394	394	CD
18637	16449	9	,	,	,
18637	16449	10	397	397	CD
18637	16449	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16449	12	1950	1950	CD
18637	16449	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16449	14	.	.	.
18637	16450	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16450	2	211	211	CD
18637	16450	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16450	4	Dennis	Dennis	NNP
18637	16450	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16450	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16450	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16450	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16450	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16450	10	,	,	,
18637	16450	11	341	341	CD
18637	16450	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16450	13	494	494	CD
18637	16450	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16450	15	1951	1951	CD
18637	16450	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16450	17	.	.	.
18637	16451	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16451	2	212	212	CD
18637	16451	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16451	4	54	54	CD
18637	16451	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	16451	6	.	.	.
18637	16452	1	670	670	CD
18637	16452	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16452	3	1940	1940	CD
18637	16452	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16452	5	.	.	.
18637	16453	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16453	2	213	213	CD
18637	16453	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16453	4	341	341	CD
18637	16453	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16453	6	494	494	CD
18637	16453	7	,	,	,
18637	16453	8	509	509	CD
18637	16453	9	.	.	.
18637	16454	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16454	2	214	214	CD
18637	16454	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16454	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16454	5	.	.	.
18637	16455	1	509	509	CD
18637	16455	2	.	.	.
18637	16456	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16456	2	215	215	CD
18637	16456	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16456	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16456	5	.	.	.
18637	16457	1	510	510	CD
18637	16457	2	;	;	:
18637	16457	3	citing	cite	VBG
18637	16457	4	183	183	CD
18637	16457	5	F.	F.	NNP
18637	16457	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16457	7	2d	2d	NNP
18637	16457	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16457	9	at	at	IN
18637	16457	10	212	212	CD
18637	16457	11	.	.	.
18637	16458	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16458	2	216	216	CD
18637	16458	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16458	4	341	341	CD
18637	16458	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16458	6	494	494	CD
18637	16458	7	,	,	,
18637	16458	8	510	510	CD
18637	16458	9	-	-	SYM
18637	16458	10	511	511	CD
18637	16458	11	.	.	.
18637	16459	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16459	2	217	217	CD
18637	16459	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16459	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16459	5	.	.	.
18637	16460	1	513	513	CD
18637	16460	2	.	.	.
18637	16461	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16461	2	218	218	CD
18637	16461	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16461	4	341	341	CD
18637	16461	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16461	6	494	494	CD
18637	16461	7	,	,	,
18637	16461	8	519	519	CD
18637	16461	9	-	-	SYM
18637	16461	10	520	520	CD
18637	16461	11	.	.	.
18637	16462	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16462	2	219	219	CD
18637	16462	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16462	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16462	5	.	.	.
18637	16463	1	525	525	CD
18637	16463	2	.	.	.
18637	16464	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16464	2	220	220	CD
18637	16464	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16464	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16464	5	.	.	.
18637	16465	1	527	527	CD
18637	16465	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16465	3	528	528	CD
18637	16465	4	.	.	.
18637	16466	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16466	2	221	221	CD
18637	16466	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16466	4	341	341	CD
18637	16466	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16466	6	494	494	CD
18637	16466	7	,	,	,
18637	16466	8	539	539	CD
18637	16466	9	.	.	.
18637	16467	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16467	2	222	222	CD
18637	16467	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16467	4	268	268	CD
18637	16467	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16467	6	652	652	CD
18637	16467	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16467	8	1925	1925	CD
18637	16467	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16467	10	.	.	.
18637	16468	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16468	2	223	223	CD
18637	16468	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16468	4	341	341	CD
18637	16468	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16468	6	494	494	CD
18637	16468	7	,	,	,
18637	16468	8	541	541	CD
18637	16468	9	.	.	.
18637	16469	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16469	2	224	224	CD
18637	16469	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16469	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16469	5	.	.	.
18637	16470	1	542	542	CD
18637	16470	2	.	.	.
18637	16471	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16471	2	225	225	CD
18637	16471	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16471	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16471	5	.	.	.
18637	16472	1	551	551	CD
18637	16472	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16472	3	552	552	CD
18637	16472	4	.	.	.
18637	16473	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16473	2	226	226	CD
18637	16473	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16473	4	341	341	CD
18637	16473	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16473	6	494	494	CD
18637	16473	7	,	,	,
18637	16473	8	567	567	CD
18637	16473	9	-	-	SYM
18637	16473	10	569	569	CD
18637	16473	11	.	.	.
18637	16474	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16474	2	227	227	CD
18637	16474	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16474	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16474	5	.	.	.
18637	16475	1	572	572	CD
18637	16475	2	.	.	.
18637	16476	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16476	2	228	228	CD
18637	16476	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16476	4	341	341	CD
18637	16476	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16476	6	494	494	CD
18637	16476	7	,	,	,
18637	16476	8	586	586	CD
18637	16476	9	;	;	:
18637	16476	10	citing	cite	VBG
18637	16476	11	274	274	CD
18637	16476	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16476	13	357	357	CD
18637	16476	14	,	,	,
18637	16476	15	376	376	CD
18637	16476	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	16476	17	377	377	CD
18637	16476	18	.	.	.
18637	16477	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16477	2	229	229	CD
18637	16477	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16477	4	Anti	Anti	NNP
18637	16477	5	-	-	NNP
18637	16477	6	Fascist	Fascist	NNP
18637	16477	7	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	16477	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16477	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	16477	10	_	_	NNP
18637	16477	11	McGrath	McGrath	NNP
18637	16477	12	,	,	,
18637	16477	13	341	341	CD
18637	16477	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16477	15	123	123	CD
18637	16477	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16477	17	1951	1951	CD
18637	16477	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16477	19	heads	head	VBZ
18637	16477	20	the	the	DT
18637	16477	21	list	list	NN
18637	16477	22	.	.	.
18637	16478	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16478	2	230	230	CD
18637	16478	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16478	4	341	341	CD
18637	16478	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16478	6	494	494	CD
18637	16478	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16478	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	16478	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16478	10	.	.	.
18637	16479	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16479	2	231	231	CD
18637	16479	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16479	4	339	339	CD
18637	16479	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16479	6	382	382	CD
18637	16479	7	;	;	:
18637	16479	8	ibid	ibid	RB
18637	16479	9	.	.	.
18637	16480	1	846	846	CD
18637	16480	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16480	3	1950	1950	CD
18637	16480	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16480	5	.	.	.
18637	16481	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16481	2	232	232	CD
18637	16481	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16481	4	341	341	CD
18637	16481	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16481	6	716	716	CD
18637	16481	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16481	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	16481	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16481	10	.	.	.
18637	16482	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16482	2	233	233	CD
18637	16482	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16482	4	342	342	CD
18637	16482	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16482	6	485	485	CD
18637	16482	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16482	8	1952	1952	CD
18637	16482	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16482	10	.	.	.
18637	16483	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16483	2	234	234	CD
18637	16483	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16483	4	New	New	NNP
18637	16483	5	York	York	NNP
18637	16483	6	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	16483	7	,	,	,
18637	16483	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	16483	9	,	,	,
18637	16483	10	c.	c.	NNP
18637	16483	11	360	360	CD
18637	16483	12	.	.	.
18637	16484	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16484	2	235	235	CD
18637	16484	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16484	4	342	342	CD
18637	16484	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16484	6	485	485	CD
18637	16484	7	,	,	,
18637	16484	8	493	493	CD
18637	16484	9	.	.	.
18637	16485	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16485	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	16485	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	16485	4	on	on	IN
18637	16485	5	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	16485	6	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	16485	7	.	.	.
18637	16486	1	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	16486	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	16486	3	and	and	CC
18637	16486	4	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	16486	5	attacked	attack	VBD
18637	16486	6	the	the	DT
18637	16486	7	merits	merit	NNS
18637	16486	8	of	of	IN
18637	16486	9	the	the	DT
18637	16486	10	decision	decision	NN
18637	16486	11	.	.	.
18637	16487	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	16487	2	the	the	DT
18637	16487	3	latter	latter	NN
18637	16487	4	:	:	:
18637	16487	5	"	"	``
18637	16487	6	What	what	WP
18637	16487	7	happens	happen	VBZ
18637	16487	8	under	under	IN
18637	16487	9	this	this	DT
18637	16487	10	law	law	NN
18637	16487	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	16487	12	typical	typical	JJ
18637	16487	13	of	of	IN
18637	16487	14	what	what	WP
18637	16487	15	happens	happen	VBZ
18637	16487	16	in	in	IN
18637	16487	17	a	a	DT
18637	16487	18	police	police	NN
18637	16487	19	state	state	NN
18637	16487	20	.	.	.
18637	16488	1	Teachers	teacher	NNS
18637	16488	2	are	be	VBP
18637	16488	3	under	under	IN
18637	16488	4	constant	constant	JJ
18637	16488	5	surveillance	surveillance	NN
18637	16488	6	;	;	:
18637	16488	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16488	8	pasts	past	NNS
18637	16488	9	are	be	VBP
18637	16488	10	combed	comb	VBN
18637	16488	11	for	for	IN
18637	16488	12	signs	sign	NNS
18637	16488	13	of	of	IN
18637	16488	14	disloyalty	disloyalty	NN
18637	16488	15	;	;	:
18637	16488	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16488	17	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	16488	18	are	be	VBP
18637	16488	19	watched	watch	VBN
18637	16488	20	for	for	IN
18637	16488	21	clues	clue	NNS
18637	16488	22	to	to	IN
18637	16488	23	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	16488	24	thoughts	thought	NNS
18637	16488	25	.	.	.
18637	16489	1	A	a	DT
18637	16489	2	pall	pall	NN
18637	16489	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	16489	4	cast	cast	VBN
18637	16489	5	over	over	IN
18637	16489	6	the	the	DT
18637	16489	7	classrooms	classroom	NNS
18637	16489	8	.	.	.
18637	16490	1	There	there	EX
18637	16490	2	can	can	MD
18637	16490	3	be	be	VB
18637	16490	4	no	no	DT
18637	16490	5	real	real	JJ
18637	16490	6	academic	academic	JJ
18637	16490	7	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16490	8	in	in	IN
18637	16490	9	that	that	DT
18637	16490	10	environment	environment	NN
18637	16490	11	.	.	.
18637	16491	1	Where	where	WRB
18637	16491	2	suspicion	suspicion	NN
18637	16491	3	fills	fill	VBZ
18637	16491	4	the	the	DT
18637	16491	5	air	air	NN
18637	16491	6	and	and	CC
18637	16491	7	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	16491	8	scholars	scholar	NNS
18637	16491	9	in	in	IN
18637	16491	10	line	line	NN
18637	16491	11	for	for	IN
18637	16491	12	fear	fear	NN
18637	16491	13	of	of	IN
18637	16491	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16491	15	jobs	job	NNS
18637	16491	16	,	,	,
18637	16491	17	there	there	EX
18637	16491	18	can	can	MD
18637	16491	19	be	be	VB
18637	16491	20	no	no	DT
18637	16491	21	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	16491	22	of	of	IN
18637	16491	23	the	the	DT
18637	16491	24	free	free	JJ
18637	16491	25	intellect	intellect	NN
18637	16491	26	.	.	.
18637	16492	1	Supineness	supineness	NN
18637	16492	2	and	and	CC
18637	16492	3	dogmatism	dogmatism	NN
18637	16492	4	take	take	VBP
18637	16492	5	the	the	DT
18637	16492	6	place	place	NN
18637	16492	7	of	of	IN
18637	16492	8	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	16492	9	.	.	.
18637	16493	1	A	a	DT
18637	16493	2	'	'	``
18637	16493	3	party	party	NN
18637	16493	4	line'--as	line'--as	NNP
18637	16493	5	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	16493	6	as	as	IN
18637	16493	7	the	the	DT
18637	16493	8	'	'	``
18637	16493	9	party	party	NN
18637	16493	10	line	line	NN
18637	16493	11	'	'	''
18637	16493	12	of	of	IN
18637	16493	13	the	the	DT
18637	16493	14	Communists	Communists	NNPS
18637	16493	15	--	--	:
18637	16493	16	lays	lay	VBZ
18637	16493	17	hold	hold	VBP
18637	16493	18	.	.	.
18637	16494	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16494	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	16494	3	the	the	DT
18637	16494	4	'	'	``
18637	16494	5	party	party	NN
18637	16494	6	line	line	NN
18637	16494	7	'	'	''
18637	16494	8	of	of	IN
18637	16494	9	the	the	DT
18637	16494	10	orthodox	orthodox	JJ
18637	16494	11	view	view	NN
18637	16494	12	,	,	,
18637	16494	13	of	of	IN
18637	16494	14	the	the	DT
18637	16494	15	conventional	conventional	JJ
18637	16494	16	thought	thought	NN
18637	16494	17	,	,	,
18637	16494	18	of	of	IN
18637	16494	19	the	the	DT
18637	16494	20	accepted	accepted	JJ
18637	16494	21	approach	approach	NN
18637	16494	22	.	.	.
18637	16495	1	A	a	DT
18637	16495	2	problem	problem	NN
18637	16495	3	can	can	MD
18637	16495	4	no	no	RB
18637	16495	5	longer	longer	RB
18637	16495	6	be	be	VB
18637	16495	7	pursued	pursue	VBN
18637	16495	8	with	with	IN
18637	16495	9	impunity	impunity	NN
18637	16495	10	to	to	IN
18637	16495	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16495	12	edges	edge	NNS
18637	16495	13	.	.	.
18637	16496	1	Fear	fear	NN
18637	16496	2	stalks	stalk	VBZ
18637	16496	3	the	the	DT
18637	16496	4	classroom	classroom	NN
18637	16496	5	.	.	.
18637	16497	1	The	the	DT
18637	16497	2	teacher	teacher	NN
18637	16497	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	16497	4	no	no	RB
18637	16497	5	longer	long	RBR
18637	16497	6	a	a	DT
18637	16497	7	stimulant	stimulant	NN
18637	16497	8	to	to	IN
18637	16497	9	adventurous	adventurous	JJ
18637	16497	10	thinking	thinking	NN
18637	16497	11	;	;	:
18637	16497	12	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16497	13	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	16497	14	instead	instead	RB
18637	16497	15	a	a	DT
18637	16497	16	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	16497	17	line	line	NN
18637	16497	18	for	for	IN
18637	16497	19	safe	safe	JJ
18637	16497	20	and	and	CC
18637	16497	21	sound	sound	JJ
18637	16497	22	information	information	NN
18637	16497	23	.	.	.
18637	16498	1	A	a	DT
18637	16498	2	deadening	deaden	VBG
18637	16498	3	dogma	dogma	NN
18637	16498	4	takes	take	VBZ
18637	16498	5	the	the	DT
18637	16498	6	place	place	NN
18637	16498	7	of	of	IN
18637	16498	8	free	free	JJ
18637	16498	9	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	16498	10	.	.	.
18637	16499	1	Instruction	instruction	NN
18637	16499	2	tends	tend	VBZ
18637	16499	3	to	to	TO
18637	16499	4	become	become	VB
18637	16499	5	sterile	sterile	JJ
18637	16499	6	;	;	:
18637	16499	7	pursuit	pursuit	NN
18637	16499	8	of	of	IN
18637	16499	9	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	16499	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	16499	11	discouraged	discourage	VBN
18637	16499	12	;	;	:
18637	16499	13	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	16499	14	often	often	RB
18637	16499	15	leaves	leave	VBZ
18637	16499	16	off	off	RP
18637	16499	17	where	where	WRB
18637	16499	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16499	19	should	should	MD
18637	16499	20	begin	begin	VB
18637	16499	21	.	.	.
18637	16499	22	"	"	''
18637	16500	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	16500	2	.	.	.
18637	16501	1	510	510	CD
18637	16501	2	.	.	.
18637	16502	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16502	2	236	236	CD
18637	16502	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16502	4	343	343	CD
18637	16502	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16502	6	250	250	CD
18637	16502	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16502	8	1952	1952	CD
18637	16502	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16502	10	.	.	.
18637	16503	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16503	2	237	237	CD
18637	16503	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16503	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16503	5	.	.	.
18637	16504	1	258	258	CD
18637	16504	2	.	.	.
18637	16505	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16505	2	238	238	CD
18637	16505	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16505	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16505	5	,	,	,
18637	16505	6	259	259	CD
18637	16505	7	-	-	SYM
18637	16505	8	263	263	CD
18637	16505	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16505	10	passim	passim	NN
18637	16505	11	_	_	NNP
18637	16505	12	.	.	.
18637	16506	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16506	2	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	16506	3	,	,	,
18637	16506	4	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	16506	5	,	,	,
18637	16506	6	urged	urge	VBD
18637	16506	7	the	the	DT
18637	16506	8	"	"	``
18637	16506	9	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	16506	10	"	"	''
18637	16506	11	character	character	NN
18637	16506	12	of	of	IN
18637	16506	13	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16506	14	of	of	IN
18637	16506	15	speech	speech	NN
18637	16506	16	and	and	CC
18637	16506	17	deplored	deplore	VBD
18637	16506	18	recent	recent	JJ
18637	16506	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	16506	20	in	in	IN
18637	16506	21	which	which	WDT
18637	16506	22	,	,	,
18637	16506	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16506	24	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	16506	25	,	,	,
18637	16506	26	the	the	DT
18637	16506	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16506	28	"	"	``
18637	16506	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	16506	30	engrafted	engraft	VBN
18637	16506	31	the	the	DT
18637	16506	32	right	right	NN
18637	16506	33	of	of	IN
18637	16506	34	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	16506	35	onto	onto	IN
18637	16506	36	the	the	DT
18637	16506	37	First	First	NNP
18637	16506	38	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16506	39	by	by	IN
18637	16506	40	placing	place	VBG
18637	16506	41	in	in	IN
18637	16506	42	the	the	DT
18637	16506	43	hands	hand	NNS
18637	16506	44	of	of	IN
18637	16506	45	the	the	DT
18637	16506	46	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	16506	47	branch	branch	NN
18637	16506	48	the	the	DT
18637	16506	49	right	right	NN
18637	16506	50	to	to	TO
18637	16506	51	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	16506	52	'	'	''
18637	16506	53	within	within	IN
18637	16506	54	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	16506	55	length	length	NN
18637	16506	56	'	'	''
18637	16506	57	the	the	DT
18637	16506	58	right	right	NN
18637	16506	59	of	of	IN
18637	16506	60	free	free	JJ
18637	16506	61	speech	speech	NN
18637	16506	62	.	.	.
18637	16507	1	This	this	DT
18637	16507	2	to	to	IN
18637	16507	3	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16507	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	16507	5	an	an	DT
18637	16507	6	ominous	ominous	JJ
18637	16507	7	and	and	CC
18637	16507	8	alarming	alarming	JJ
18637	16507	9	trend	trend	NN
18637	16507	10	.	.	.
18637	16507	11	"	"	''
18637	16508	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	16508	2	.	.	.
18637	16509	1	285	285	CD
18637	16509	2	.	.	.
18637	16510	1	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	16510	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	16510	3	,	,	,
18637	16510	4	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	16510	5	and	and	CC
18637	16510	6	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	16510	7	also	also	RB
18637	16510	8	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	16510	9	.	.	.
18637	16511	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16511	2	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	16511	3	's	's	POS
18637	16511	4	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	16511	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16511	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	16511	7	characteristically	characteristically	RB
18637	16511	8	paradoxical	paradoxical	JJ
18637	16511	9	:	:	:
18637	16511	10	"	"	``
18637	16511	11	An	an	DT
18637	16511	12	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	16511	13	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16511	14	,	,	,
18637	16511	15	construed	construe	VBN
18637	16511	16	by	by	IN
18637	16511	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16511	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16511	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16511	20	to	to	TO
18637	16511	21	be	be	VB
18637	16511	22	a	a	DT
18637	16511	23	'	'	``
18637	16511	24	group	group	NN
18637	16511	25	libel	libel	NN
18637	16511	26	'	'	''
18637	16511	27	statute	statute	NN
18637	16511	28	,	,	,
18637	16511	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	16511	30	been	be	VBN
18637	16511	31	used	use	VBN
18637	16511	32	to	to	TO
18637	16511	33	punish	punish	VB
18637	16511	34	criminally	criminally	RB
18637	16511	35	the	the	DT
18637	16511	36	author	author	NN
18637	16511	37	and	and	CC
18637	16511	38	distributor	distributor	NN
18637	16511	39	of	of	IN
18637	16511	40	an	an	DT
18637	16511	41	obnoxious	obnoxious	JJ
18637	16511	42	leaflet	leaflet	NN
18637	16511	43	attacking	attack	VBG
18637	16511	44	the	the	DT
18637	16511	45	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	16511	46	race	race	NN
18637	16511	47	.	.	.
18637	16512	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16512	2	answers	answer	VBZ
18637	16512	3	that	that	IN
18637	16512	4	,	,	,
18637	16512	5	as	as	IN
18637	16512	6	applied	apply	VBN
18637	16512	7	,	,	,
18637	16512	8	the	the	DT
18637	16512	9	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16512	10	denies	deny	VBZ
18637	16512	11	a	a	DT
18637	16512	12	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16512	13	secured	secure	VBN
18637	16512	14	to	to	IN
18637	16512	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16512	16	by	by	IN
18637	16512	17	the	the	DT
18637	16512	18	Due	Due	NNP
18637	16512	19	Process	Process	NNP
18637	16512	20	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	16512	21	of	of	IN
18637	16512	22	the	the	DT
18637	16512	23	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	16512	24	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16512	25	.	.	.
18637	16513	1	What	what	WP
18637	16513	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	16513	3	the	the	DT
18637	16513	4	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16513	5	which	which	WDT
18637	16513	6	that	that	DT
18637	16513	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	16513	8	underwrites	underwrite	VBZ
18637	16513	9	?	?	.
18637	16514	1	The	the	DT
18637	16514	2	spectrum	spectrum	NN
18637	16514	3	of	of	IN
18637	16514	4	views	view	NNS
18637	16514	5	expressed	express	VBN
18637	16514	6	by	by	IN
18637	16514	7	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16514	8	seniors	senior	NNS
18637	16514	9	shows	show	VBZ
18637	16514	10	that	that	DT
18637	16514	11	disagreement	disagreement	NN
18637	16514	12	as	as	IN
18637	16514	13	to	to	IN
18637	16514	14	the	the	DT
18637	16514	15	scope	scope	NN
18637	16514	16	and	and	CC
18637	16514	17	effect	effect	NN
18637	16514	18	of	of	IN
18637	16514	19	this	this	DT
18637	16514	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16514	21	underlies	underlie	VBZ
18637	16514	22	this	this	DT
18637	16514	23	,	,	,
18637	16514	24	as	as	IN
18637	16514	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16514	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	16514	27	many	many	JJ
18637	16514	28	another	another	DT
18637	16514	29	,	,	,
18637	16514	30	division	division	NN
18637	16514	31	of	of	IN
18637	16514	32	the	the	DT
18637	16514	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16514	34	.	.	.
18637	16515	1	All	all	DT
18637	16515	2	agree	agree	VBP
18637	16515	3	that	that	IN
18637	16515	4	the	the	DT
18637	16515	5	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	16515	6	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	16515	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	16515	8	confine	confine	VB
18637	16515	9	the	the	DT
18637	16515	10	power	power	NN
18637	16515	11	of	of	IN
18637	16515	12	the	the	DT
18637	16515	13	State	State	NNP
18637	16515	14	to	to	TO
18637	16515	15	make	make	VB
18637	16515	16	printed	print	VBN
18637	16515	17	words	word	NNS
18637	16515	18	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16515	19	.	.	.
18637	16516	1	Whence	whence	UH
18637	16516	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16516	3	are	be	VBP
18637	16516	4	to	to	TO
18637	16516	5	derive	derive	VB
18637	16516	6	metes	mete	NNS
18637	16516	7	and	and	CC
18637	16516	8	bounds	bound	NNS
18637	16516	9	of	of	IN
18637	16516	10	the	the	DT
18637	16516	11	state	state	NN
18637	16516	12	power	power	NN
18637	16516	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	16516	14	a	a	DT
18637	16516	15	subject	subject	NN
18637	16516	16	to	to	IN
18637	16516	17	the	the	DT
18637	16516	18	confusion	confusion	NN
18637	16516	19	of	of	IN
18637	16516	20	which	which	WDT
18637	16516	21	,	,	,
18637	16516	22	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16516	23	regret	regret	VBP
18637	16516	24	to	to	TO
18637	16516	25	say	say	VB
18637	16516	26	,	,	,
18637	16516	27	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16516	28	have	have	VBP
18637	16516	29	contributed	contribute	VBN
18637	16516	30	--	--	:
18637	16516	31	comforted	comfort	VBN
18637	16516	32	in	in	IN
18637	16516	33	the	the	DT
18637	16516	34	acknowledgment	acknowledgment	NN
18637	16516	35	,	,	,
18637	16516	36	however	however	RB
18637	16516	37	,	,	,
18637	16516	38	by	by	IN
18637	16516	39	recalling	recall	VBG
18637	16516	40	that	that	IN
18637	16516	41	this	this	DT
18637	16516	42	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16516	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	16516	44	so	so	RB
18637	16516	45	enigmatic	enigmatic	JJ
18637	16516	46	and	and	CC
18637	16516	47	abstruse	abstruse	VB
18637	16516	48	that	that	WDT
18637	16516	49	judges	judge	VBZ
18637	16516	50	more	more	RBR
18637	16516	51	experienced	experienced	JJ
18637	16516	52	than	than	IN
18637	16516	53	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16516	54	have	have	VBP
18637	16516	55	had	have	VBN
18637	16516	56	to	to	TO
18637	16516	57	reverse	reverse	VB
18637	16516	58	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16516	59	as	as	IN
18637	16516	60	to	to	IN
18637	16516	61	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16516	62	effect	effect	NN
18637	16516	63	on	on	IN
18637	16516	64	state	state	NN
18637	16516	65	power	power	NN
18637	16516	66	.	.	.
18637	16517	1	The	the	DT
18637	16517	2	thesis	thesis	NN
18637	16517	3	now	now	RB
18637	16517	4	tendered	tender	VBN
18637	16517	5	in	in	IN
18637	16517	6	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	16517	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	16517	8	that	that	IN
18637	16517	9	the	the	DT
18637	16517	10	'	'	``
18637	16517	11	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16517	12	'	'	''
18637	16517	13	which	which	WDT
18637	16517	14	the	the	DT
18637	16517	15	Due	Due	NNP
18637	16517	16	Process	Process	NNP
18637	16517	17	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	16517	18	of	of	IN
18637	16517	19	the	the	DT
18637	16517	20	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	16517	21	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16517	22	protects	protect	VBZ
18637	16517	23	against	against	IN
18637	16517	24	denial	denial	NN
18637	16517	25	by	by	IN
18637	16517	26	the	the	DT
18637	16517	27	States	States	NNP
18637	16517	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	16517	29	the	the	DT
18637	16517	30	literal	literal	JJ
18637	16517	31	and	and	CC
18637	16517	32	identical	identical	JJ
18637	16517	33	'	'	''
18637	16517	34	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16517	35	of	of	IN
18637	16517	36	speech	speech	NN
18637	16517	37	or	or	CC
18637	16517	38	of	of	IN
18637	16517	39	the	the	DT
18637	16517	40	press	press	NN
18637	16517	41	'	'	''
18637	16517	42	which	which	WDT
18637	16517	43	the	the	DT
18637	16517	44	First	First	NNP
18637	16517	45	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16517	46	forbids	forbid	NNS
18637	16517	47	only	only	RB
18637	16517	48	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16517	49	to	to	TO
18637	16517	50	abridge	abridge	VB
18637	16517	51	.	.	.
18637	16518	1	The	the	DT
18637	16518	2	history	history	NN
18637	16518	3	of	of	IN
18637	16518	4	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16518	5	libel	libel	NN
18637	16518	6	in	in	IN
18637	16518	7	America	America	NNP
18637	16518	8	convinces	convince	VBZ
18637	16518	9	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16518	10	that	that	IN
18637	16518	11	the	the	DT
18637	16518	12	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	16518	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16518	14	did	do	VBD
18637	16518	15	not	not	RB
18637	16518	16	'	'	``
18637	16518	17	incorporate	incorporate	VB
18637	16518	18	'	'	''
18637	16518	19	the	the	DT
18637	16518	20	First	first	JJ
18637	16518	21	,	,	,
18637	16518	22	that	that	IN
18637	16518	23	the	the	DT
18637	16518	24	powers	power	NNS
18637	16518	25	of	of	IN
18637	16518	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16518	27	and	and	CC
18637	16518	28	of	of	IN
18637	16518	29	the	the	DT
18637	16518	30	States	States	NNPS
18637	16518	31	over	over	IN
18637	16518	32	this	this	DT
18637	16518	33	subject	subject	NN
18637	16518	34	are	be	VBP
18637	16518	35	not	not	RB
18637	16518	36	of	of	IN
18637	16518	37	the	the	DT
18637	16518	38	same	same	JJ
18637	16518	39	dimensions	dimension	NNS
18637	16518	40	,	,	,
18637	16518	41	and	and	CC
18637	16518	42	that	that	IN
18637	16518	43	because	because	IN
18637	16518	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16518	45	probably	probably	RB
18637	16518	46	could	could	MD
18637	16518	47	not	not	RB
18637	16518	48	enact	enact	VB
18637	16518	49	this	this	DT
18637	16518	50	law	law	NN
18637	16518	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16518	52	does	do	VBZ
18637	16518	53	not	not	RB
18637	16518	54	follow	follow	VB
18637	16518	55	that	that	IN
18637	16518	56	the	the	DT
18637	16518	57	States	States	NNPS
18637	16518	58	may	may	MD
18637	16518	59	not	not	RB
18637	16518	60	.	.	.
18637	16518	61	"	"	''
18637	16519	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	16519	2	.	.	.
18637	16520	1	287	287	CD
18637	16520	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16520	3	288	288	CD
18637	16520	4	.	.	.
18637	16521	1	Proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	16521	2	from	from	IN
18637	16521	3	this	this	DT
18637	16521	4	position	position	NN
18637	16521	5	,	,	,
18637	16521	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16521	7	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	16521	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	16521	9	able	able	JJ
18637	16521	10	,	,	,
18637	16521	11	none	none	VB
18637	16521	12	the	the	DT
18637	16521	13	less	less	RBR
18637	16521	14	,	,	,
18637	16521	15	to	to	IN
18637	16521	16	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	16521	17	from	from	IN
18637	16521	18	the	the	DT
18637	16521	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16521	20	's	's	POS
18637	16521	21	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16521	22	.	.	.
18637	16522	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16522	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	16522	3	.	.	.
18637	16522	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16522	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	16522	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16522	7	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	16522	8	's	's	POS
18637	16522	9	position	position	NN
18637	16522	10	in	in	IN
18637	16522	11	United	United	NNP
18637	16522	12	States	States	NNP
18637	16522	13	_	_	NNP
18637	16522	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	16522	15	_	_	NNP
18637	16522	16	Carolene	Carolene	NNP
18637	16522	17	Products	Products	NNP
18637	16522	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16522	19	,	,	,
18637	16522	20	304	304	CD
18637	16522	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16522	22	144	144	CD
18637	16522	23	,	,	,
18637	16522	24	at	at	IN
18637	16522	25	152	152	CD
18637	16522	26	-	-	SYM
18637	16522	27	53	53	CD
18637	16522	28	,	,	,
18637	16522	29	note	note	VBP
18637	16522	30	4	4	CD
18637	16522	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16522	32	1938	1938	CD
18637	16522	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16522	34	.	.	.
18637	16523	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16523	2	239	239	CD
18637	16523	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16523	4	20	20	CD
18637	16523	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	16523	6	.	.	.
18637	16524	1	355	355	CD
18637	16524	2	,	,	,
18637	16524	3	358	358	CD
18637	16524	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16524	5	1879	1879	CD
18637	16524	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16524	7	;	;	:
18637	16524	8	48	48	CD
18637	16524	9	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	16524	10	.	.	.
18637	16525	1	928	928	CD
18637	16525	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16525	3	1934	1934	CD
18637	16525	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16525	5	.	.	.
18637	16526	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16526	2	240	240	CD
18637	16526	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16526	4	327	327	CD
18637	16526	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16526	6	146	146	CD
18637	16526	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16526	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	16526	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16526	10	.	.	.
18637	16527	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16527	2	241	241	CD
18637	16527	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16527	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16527	5	.	.	.
18637	16528	1	158	158	CD
18637	16528	2	.	.	.
18637	16529	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16529	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	16529	3	,	,	,
18637	16529	4	while	while	IN
18637	16529	5	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	16529	6	,	,	,
18637	16529	7	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	16529	8	thought	think	VBN
18637	16529	9	that	that	IN
18637	16529	10	the	the	DT
18637	16529	11	question	question	NN
18637	16529	12	of	of	IN
18637	16529	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16529	14	's	's	POS
18637	16529	15	power	power	NN
18637	16529	16	in	in	IN
18637	16529	17	the	the	DT
18637	16529	18	premises	premise	NNS
18637	16529	19	was	be	VBD
18637	16529	20	not	not	RB
18637	16529	21	involved	involve	VBN
18637	16529	22	.	.	.
18637	16530	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	16530	2	.	.	.
18637	16531	1	159	159	CD
18637	16531	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16531	3	160	160	CD
18637	16531	4	.	.	.
18637	16532	1	On	on	IN
18637	16532	2	this	this	DT
18637	16532	3	broader	broad	JJR
18637	16532	4	question	question	NN
18637	16532	5	,	,	,
18637	16532	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16532	7	see	see	VBP
18637	16532	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16532	9	p.	p.	NN
18637	16532	10	269	269	CD
18637	16532	11	.	.	.
18637	16533	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16533	2	The	the	DT
18637	16533	3	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	16533	4	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	16533	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16533	6	.	.	.
18637	16534	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16534	2	242	242	CD
18637	16534	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16534	4	333	333	CD
18637	16534	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16534	6	178	178	CD
18637	16534	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16534	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	16534	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16534	10	;	;	:
18637	16534	11	Public	Public	NNP
18637	16534	12	Clearing	Clearing	NNP
18637	16534	13	House	House	NNP
18637	16534	14	_	_	NNP
18637	16534	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	16534	16	_	_	NNP
18637	16534	17	Coyne	Coyne	NNP
18637	16534	18	,	,	,
18637	16534	19	194	194	CD
18637	16534	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16534	21	497	497	CD
18637	16534	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16534	23	1904	1904	CD
18637	16534	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16534	25	.	.	.
18637	16535	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16535	2	243	243	CD
18637	16535	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16535	4	Here	here	RB
18637	16535	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16535	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	16535	7	recited	recite	VBN
18637	16535	8	in	in	IN
18637	16535	9	part	part	NN
18637	16535	10	:	:	:
18637	16535	11	"	"	``
18637	16535	12	That	that	IN
18637	16535	13	if	if	IN
18637	16535	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16535	15	,	,	,
18637	16535	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16535	17	justiciary	justiciary	NNP
18637	16535	18	,	,	,
18637	16535	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16535	20	bailiffs	bailiff	NNS
18637	16535	21	,	,	,
18637	16535	22	or	or	CC
18637	16535	23	any	any	DT
18637	16535	24	of	of	IN
18637	16535	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16535	26	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16535	27	,	,	,
18637	16535	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	16535	29	in	in	IN
18637	16535	30	any	any	DT
18637	16535	31	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	16535	32	have	have	VBP
18637	16535	33	failed	fail	VBN
18637	16535	34	in	in	IN
18637	16535	35	the	the	DT
18637	16535	36	performance	performance	NN
18637	16535	37	of	of	IN
18637	16535	38	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16535	39	toward	toward	IN
18637	16535	40	any	any	DT
18637	16535	41	person	person	NN
18637	16535	42	,	,	,
18637	16535	43	or	or	CC
18637	16535	44	shall	shall	MD
18637	16535	45	have	have	VB
18637	16535	46	broken	break	VBN
18637	16535	47	through	through	IN
18637	16535	48	any	any	DT
18637	16535	49	of	of	IN
18637	16535	50	these	these	DT
18637	16535	51	articles	article	NNS
18637	16535	52	of	of	IN
18637	16535	53	peace	peace	NN
18637	16535	54	and	and	CC
18637	16535	55	security	security	NN
18637	16535	56	,	,	,
18637	16535	57	and	and	CC
18637	16535	58	the	the	DT
18637	16535	59	offence	offence	NN
18637	16535	60	be	be	VB
18637	16535	61	notified	notify	VBN
18637	16535	62	to	to	IN
18637	16535	63	four	four	CD
18637	16535	64	barons	baron	NNS
18637	16535	65	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	16535	66	out	out	IN
18637	16535	67	of	of	IN
18637	16535	68	the	the	DT
18637	16535	69	five	five	CD
18637	16535	70	-	-	HYPH
18637	16535	71	and	and	CC
18637	16535	72	-	-	HYPH
18637	16535	73	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	16535	74	before	before	IN
18637	16535	75	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	16535	76	,	,	,
18637	16535	77	the	the	DT
18637	16535	78	said	say	VBD
18637	16535	79	four	four	CD
18637	16535	80	barons	baron	NNS
18637	16535	81	shall	shall	MD
18637	16535	82	repair	repair	VB
18637	16535	83	to	to	IN
18637	16535	84	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16535	85	,	,	,
18637	16535	86	or	or	CC
18637	16535	87	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16535	88	justiciary	justiciary	NNP
18637	16535	89	,	,	,
18637	16535	90	if	if	IN
18637	16535	91	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16535	92	are	be	VBP
18637	16535	93	out	out	IN
18637	16535	94	of	of	IN
18637	16535	95	the	the	DT
18637	16535	96	realm	realm	NN
18637	16535	97	,	,	,
18637	16535	98	and	and	CC
18637	16535	99	laying	lay	VBG
18637	16535	100	open	open	JJ
18637	16535	101	the	the	DT
18637	16535	102	grievance	grievance	NN
18637	16535	103	,	,	,
18637	16535	104	shall	shall	MD
18637	16535	105	petition	petition	VB
18637	16535	106	to	to	TO
18637	16535	107	have	have	VB
18637	16535	108	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16535	109	redressed	redress	VBN
18637	16535	110	without	without	IN
18637	16535	111	delay	delay	NN
18637	16535	112	.	.	.
18637	16535	113	"	"	''
18637	16536	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16536	2	244	244	CD
18637	16536	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16536	4	12	12	CD
18637	16536	5	Encyclopedia	Encyclopedia	NNS
18637	16536	6	of	of	IN
18637	16536	7	the	the	DT
18637	16536	8	Social	Social	NNP
18637	16536	9	Sciences	Sciences	NNPS
18637	16536	10	,	,	,
18637	16536	11	98	98	CD
18637	16536	12	ff	ff	NN
18637	16536	13	,	,	,
18637	16536	14	"	"	''
18637	16536	15	Petition	Petition	NNP
18637	16536	16	,	,	,
18637	16536	17	Right	right	RB
18637	16536	18	of	of	IN
18637	16536	19	"	"	``
18637	16536	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16536	21	New	New	NNP
18637	16536	22	York	York	NNP
18637	16536	23	,	,	,
18637	16536	24	1934	1934	CD
18637	16536	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16536	26	.	.	.
18637	16537	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16537	2	245	245	CD
18637	16537	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16537	4	United	United	NNP
18637	16537	5	States	States	NNP
18637	16537	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16537	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16537	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16537	9	Cruikshank	Cruikshank	NNP
18637	16537	10	,	,	,
18637	16537	11	92	92	CD
18637	16537	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16537	13	542	542	CD
18637	16537	14	,	,	,
18637	16537	15	552	552	CD
18637	16537	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16537	17	1876	1876	CD
18637	16537	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16537	19	reflects	reflect	VBZ
18637	16537	20	this	this	DT
18637	16537	21	older	old	JJR
18637	16537	22	view	view	NN
18637	16537	23	.	.	.
18637	16538	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16538	2	246	246	CD
18637	16538	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16538	4	De	De	NNP
18637	16538	5	Jonge	Jonge	NNP
18637	16538	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16538	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16538	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16538	9	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	16538	10	,	,	,
18637	16538	11	299	299	CD
18637	16538	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16538	13	353	353	CD
18637	16538	14	,	,	,
18637	16538	15	364	364	CD
18637	16538	16	,	,	,
18637	16538	17	365	365	CD
18637	16538	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16538	19	1937	1937	CD
18637	16538	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16538	21	.	.	.
18637	16539	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16539	2	See	See	NNP
18637	16539	3	also	also	RB
18637	16539	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16539	5	Herndon	Herndon	NNP
18637	16539	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16539	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16539	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16539	9	Lowry	Lowry	NNP
18637	16539	10	,	,	,
18637	16539	11	301	301	CD
18637	16539	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16539	13	242	242	CD
18637	16539	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16539	15	1937	1937	CD
18637	16539	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16539	17	.	.	.
18637	16540	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16540	2	247	247	CD
18637	16540	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16540	4	For	for	IN
18637	16540	5	the	the	DT
18637	16540	6	details	detail	NNS
18637	16540	7	of	of	IN
18637	16540	8	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	16540	9	'	'	POS
18637	16540	10	famous	famous	JJ
18637	16540	11	fight	fight	NN
18637	16540	12	on	on	IN
18637	16540	13	"	"	``
18637	16540	14	The	the	DT
18637	16540	15	Gag	Gag	NNP
18637	16540	16	Rule	Rule	NNP
18637	16540	17	,	,	,
18637	16540	18	"	"	''
18637	16540	19	_	_	NNP
18637	16540	20	see	see	VBP
18637	16540	21	_	_	NNP
18637	16540	22	Andrew	Andrew	NNP
18637	16540	23	C.	C.	NNP
18637	16540	24	McLaughlin	McLaughlin	NNP
18637	16540	25	,	,	,
18637	16540	26	A	a	DT
18637	16540	27	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16540	28	History	history	NN
18637	16540	29	of	of	IN
18637	16540	30	the	the	DT
18637	16540	31	United	United	NNP
18637	16540	32	States	States	NNP
18637	16540	33	,	,	,
18637	16540	34	pp	pp	NNP
18637	16540	35	.	.	.
18637	16541	1	478	478	CD
18637	16541	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16541	3	481	481	CD
18637	16541	4	,	,	,
18637	16541	5	Appleton	Appleton	NNP
18637	16541	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	16541	7	Century	Century	NNP
18637	16541	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	16541	9	Crofts	Crofts	NNP
18637	16541	10	,	,	,
18637	16541	11	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	16541	12	,	,	,
18637	16541	13	New	New	NNP
18637	16541	14	York	York	NNP
18637	16541	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16541	16	1935	1935	CD
18637	16541	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16541	18	.	.	.
18637	16542	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16542	2	248	248	CD
18637	16542	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16542	4	Rules	Rules	NNPS
18637	16542	5	and	and	CC
18637	16542	6	Manual	Manual	NNP
18637	16542	7	United	United	NNP
18637	16542	8	States	States	NNP
18637	16542	9	House	House	NNP
18637	16542	10	of	of	IN
18637	16542	11	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	16542	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16542	13	1949	1949	CD
18637	16542	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16542	15	,	,	,
18637	16542	16	Eighty	Eighty	NNP
18637	16542	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	16542	18	first	first	JJ
18637	16542	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16542	20	,	,	,
18637	16542	21	by	by	IN
18637	16542	22	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	16542	23	Deschler	Deschler	NNP
18637	16542	24	,	,	,
18637	16542	25	Parliamentarian	Parliamentarian	NNP
18637	16542	26	,	,	,
18637	16542	27	United	United	NNP
18637	16542	28	States	States	NNP
18637	16542	29	Government	Government	NNP
18637	16542	30	Printing	Printing	NNP
18637	16542	31	Office	Office	NNP
18637	16542	32	,	,	,
18637	16542	33	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	16542	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16542	35	1949	1949	CD
18637	16542	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16542	37	,	,	,
18637	16542	38	pp	pp	NNP
18637	16542	39	.	.	.
18637	16543	1	430	430	CD
18637	16543	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16543	3	433	433	CD
18637	16543	4	.	.	.
18637	16544	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16544	2	249	249	CD
18637	16544	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16544	4	United	United	NNP
18637	16544	5	States	States	NNP
18637	16544	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16544	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16544	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16544	9	Baltzer	Baltzer	NNP
18637	16544	10	,	,	,
18637	16544	11	Report	Report	NNP
18637	16544	12	of	of	IN
18637	16544	13	the	the	DT
18637	16544	14	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	16544	15	General	General	NNP
18637	16544	16	,	,	,
18637	16544	17	1918	1918	CD
18637	16544	18	,	,	,
18637	16544	19	p.	p.	NN
18637	16544	20	48	48	CD
18637	16544	21	.	.	.
18637	16545	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16545	2	250	250	CD
18637	16545	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16545	4	92	92	CD
18637	16545	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16545	6	542	542	CD
18637	16545	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16545	8	1876	1876	CD
18637	16545	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16545	10	.	.	.
18637	16546	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16546	2	251	251	CD
18637	16546	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16546	4	16	16	CD
18637	16546	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	16546	6	.	.	.
18637	16547	1	141	141	CD
18637	16547	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16547	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	16547	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16547	5	.	.	.
18637	16548	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16548	2	252	252	CD
18637	16548	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16548	4	92	92	CD
18637	16548	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16548	6	542	542	CD
18637	16548	7	,	,	,
18637	16548	8	552	552	CD
18637	16548	9	-	-	SYM
18637	16548	10	553	553	CD
18637	16548	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16548	12	1876	1876	CD
18637	16548	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16548	14	.	.	.
18637	16549	1	At	at	IN
18637	16549	2	a	a	DT
18637	16549	3	later	later	JJ
18637	16549	4	point	point	NN
18637	16549	5	in	in	IN
18637	16549	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16549	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16549	8	the	the	DT
18637	16549	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16549	10	used	use	VBD
18637	16549	11	the	the	DT
18637	16549	12	following	following	JJ
18637	16549	13	language	language	NN
18637	16549	14	:	:	:
18637	16549	15	"	"	``
18637	16549	16	Every	every	DT
18637	16549	17	republican	republican	JJ
18637	16549	18	government	government	NN
18637	16549	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	16549	20	in	in	IN
18637	16549	21	duty	duty	NN
18637	16549	22	bound	bind	VBN
18637	16549	23	to	to	TO
18637	16549	24	protect	protect	VB
18637	16549	25	all	all	PDT
18637	16549	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16549	27	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	16549	28	in	in	IN
18637	16549	29	the	the	DT
18637	16549	30	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	16549	31	of	of	IN
18637	16549	32	an	an	DT
18637	16549	33	equality	equality	NN
18637	16549	34	of	of	IN
18637	16549	35	right	right	NN
18637	16549	36	.	.	.
18637	16550	1	That	that	DT
18637	16550	2	duty	duty	NN
18637	16550	3	was	be	VBD
18637	16550	4	originally	originally	RB
18637	16550	5	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	16550	6	by	by	IN
18637	16550	7	the	the	DT
18637	16550	8	States	States	NNPS
18637	16550	9	;	;	:
18637	16550	10	and	and	CC
18637	16550	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16550	12	still	still	RB
18637	16550	13	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	16550	14	there	there	RB
18637	16550	15	.	.	.
18637	16551	1	The	the	DT
18637	16551	2	only	only	JJ
18637	16551	3	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	16551	4	resting	rest	VBG
18637	16551	5	upon	upon	IN
18637	16551	6	the	the	DT
18637	16551	7	United	United	NNP
18637	16551	8	States	States	NNP
18637	16551	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	16551	10	to	to	TO
18637	16551	11	see	see	VB
18637	16551	12	that	that	IN
18637	16551	13	the	the	DT
18637	16551	14	States	state	NNS
18637	16551	15	do	do	VBP
18637	16551	16	not	not	RB
18637	16551	17	deny	deny	VB
18637	16551	18	the	the	DT
18637	16551	19	right	right	NN
18637	16551	20	.	.	.
18637	16552	1	This	this	DT
18637	16552	2	the	the	DT
18637	16552	3	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16552	4	guarantees	guarantee	NNS
18637	16552	5	,	,	,
18637	16552	6	but	but	CC
18637	16552	7	no	no	DT
18637	16552	8	more	more	JJR
18637	16552	9	.	.	.
18637	16553	1	The	the	DT
18637	16553	2	power	power	NN
18637	16553	3	of	of	IN
18637	16553	4	the	the	DT
18637	16553	5	national	national	JJ
18637	16553	6	government	government	NN
18637	16553	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	16553	8	limited	limit	VBN
18637	16553	9	to	to	IN
18637	16553	10	the	the	DT
18637	16553	11	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	16553	12	of	of	IN
18637	16553	13	this	this	DT
18637	16553	14	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	16553	15	.	.	.
18637	16553	16	"	"	''
18637	16554	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	16554	2	.	.	.
18637	16555	1	555	555	CD
18637	16555	2	.	.	.
18637	16556	1	These	these	DT
18637	16556	2	words	word	NNS
18637	16556	3	have	have	VBP
18637	16556	4	reference	reference	NN
18637	16556	5	,	,	,
18637	16556	6	quite	quite	RB
18637	16556	7	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	16556	8	,	,	,
18637	16556	9	to	to	IN
18637	16556	10	counts	count	NNS
18637	16556	11	of	of	IN
18637	16556	12	the	the	DT
18637	16556	13	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16556	14	alleging	allege	VBG
18637	16556	15	acts	act	NNS
18637	16556	16	of	of	IN
18637	16556	17	the	the	DT
18637	16556	18	conspirators	conspirator	NNS
18637	16556	19	denying	deny	VBG
18637	16556	20	"	"	``
18637	16556	21	equal	equal	JJ
18637	16556	22	protection	protection	NN
18637	16556	23	of	of	IN
18637	16556	24	the	the	DT
18637	16556	25	laws	law	NNS
18637	16556	26	"	"	''
18637	16556	27	"	"	''
18637	16556	28	to	to	IN
18637	16556	29	persons	person	NNS
18637	16556	30	of	of	IN
18637	16556	31	color	color	NN
18637	16556	32	,	,	,
18637	16556	33	"	"	''
18637	16556	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16556	35	's	's	POS
18637	16556	36	power	power	NN
18637	16556	37	to	to	TO
18637	16556	38	protect	protect	VB
18637	16556	39	which	which	WDT
18637	16556	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	16556	41	derived	derive	VBN
18637	16556	42	from	from	IN
18637	16556	43	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16556	44	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	16556	45	and	and	CC
18637	16556	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	16556	47	confined	confine	VBN
18637	16556	48	as	as	IN
18637	16556	49	the	the	DT
18637	16556	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16556	51	says	say	VBZ
18637	16556	52	,	,	,
18637	16556	53	to	to	IN
18637	16556	54	protection	protection	NN
18637	16556	55	against	against	IN
18637	16556	56	State	state	NN
18637	16556	57	acts	act	NNS
18637	16556	58	.	.	.
18637	16557	1	The	the	DT
18637	16557	2	above	above	RB
18637	16557	3	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	16557	4	words	word	NNS
18637	16557	5	have	have	VBP
18637	16557	6	,	,	,
18637	16557	7	however	however	RB
18637	16557	8	,	,	,
18637	16557	9	caused	cause	VBD
18637	16557	10	confusion	confusion	NN
18637	16557	11	.	.	.
18637	16558	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16558	2	See	See	NNP
18637	16558	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16558	4	pp	pp	NNP
18637	16558	5	.	.	.
18637	16559	1	1176	1176	CD
18637	16559	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16559	3	1177	1177	CD
18637	16559	4	.	.	.
18637	16560	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16560	2	253	253	CD
18637	16560	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16560	4	Hague	Hague	NNP
18637	16560	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16560	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16560	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16560	8	C.I.O.	C.I.O.	NNP
18637	16560	9	,	,	,
18637	16560	10	307	307	CD
18637	16560	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16560	12	496	496	CD
18637	16560	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16560	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	16560	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16560	16	.	.	.
18637	16561	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16561	2	254	254	CD
18637	16561	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16561	4	49	49	CD
18637	16561	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	16561	6	.	.	.
18637	16562	1	449	449	CD
18637	16562	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16562	3	1935	1935	CD
18637	16562	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16562	5	.	.	.
18637	16563	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16563	2	255	255	CD
18637	16563	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16563	4	307	307	CD
18637	16563	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16563	6	496	496	CD
18637	16563	7	,	,	,
18637	16563	8	515	515	CD
18637	16563	9	-	-	SYM
18637	16563	10	516	516	CD
18637	16563	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16563	12	1939	1939	CD
18637	16563	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16563	14	.	.	.
18637	16564	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16564	2	256	256	CD
18637	16564	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16564	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16564	5	.	.	.
18637	16565	1	525	525	CD
18637	16565	2	.	.	.
18637	16566	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16566	2	257	257	CD
18637	16566	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16566	4	"	"	``
18637	16566	5	As	as	IN
18637	16566	6	to	to	IN
18637	16566	7	the	the	DT
18637	16566	8	American	American	NNP
18637	16566	9	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	16566	10	Liberties	Liberties	NNPS
18637	16566	11	Union	Union	NNP
18637	16566	12	,	,	,
18637	16566	13	which	which	WDT
18637	16566	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	16566	15	a	a	DT
18637	16566	16	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	16566	17	,	,	,
18637	16566	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16566	19	can	can	MD
18637	16566	20	not	not	RB
18637	16566	21	be	be	VB
18637	16566	22	said	say	VBN
18637	16566	23	to	to	TO
18637	16566	24	be	be	VB
18637	16566	25	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	16566	26	of	of	IN
18637	16566	27	the	the	DT
18637	16566	28	civil	civil	JJ
18637	16566	29	rights	right	NNS
18637	16566	30	of	of	IN
18637	16566	31	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	16566	32	of	of	IN
18637	16566	33	speech	speech	NN
18637	16566	34	and	and	CC
18637	16566	35	of	of	IN
18637	16566	36	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	16566	37	,	,	,
18637	16566	38	for	for	IN
18637	16566	39	the	the	DT
18637	16566	40	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16566	41	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	16566	42	by	by	IN
18637	16566	43	the	the	DT
18637	16566	44	due	due	JJ
18637	16566	45	process	process	NN
18637	16566	46	clause	clause	NN
18637	16566	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	16566	48	the	the	DT
18637	16566	49	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16566	50	of	of	IN
18637	16566	51	natural	natural	JJ
18637	16566	52	,	,	,
18637	16566	53	not	not	RB
18637	16566	54	artificial	artificial	JJ
18637	16566	55	,	,	,
18637	16566	56	persons	person	NNS
18637	16566	57	.	.	.
18637	16567	1	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	16567	2	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	16567	3	.	.	.
18637	16568	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	16568	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	16568	3	.	.	.
18637	16569	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16569	2	_	_	NNP
18637	16569	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	16569	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16569	5	Riggs	Riggs	NNP
18637	16569	6	,	,	,
18637	16569	7	203	203	CD
18637	16569	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16569	9	243	243	CD
18637	16569	10	,	,	,
18637	16569	11	255	255	CD
18637	16569	12	;	;	:
18637	16569	13	Western	western	JJ
18637	16569	14	Turf	Turf	NNP
18637	16569	15	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	16569	16	.	.	.
18637	16570	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16570	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	16570	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16570	4	Greenberg	Greenberg	NNP
18637	16570	5	,	,	,
18637	16570	6	204	204	CD
18637	16570	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16570	8	359	359	CD
18637	16570	9	,	,	,
18637	16570	10	363	363	CD
18637	16570	11	;	;	:
18637	16570	12	"	"	``
18637	16570	13	307	307	CD
18637	16570	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16570	15	496	496	CD
18637	16570	16	,	,	,
18637	16570	17	527	527	CD
18637	16570	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16570	19	1939	1939	CD
18637	16570	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16570	21	.	.	.
18637	16571	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16571	2	See	See	NNP
18637	16571	3	also	also	RB
18637	16571	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16571	5	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	16571	6	.	.	.
18637	16572	1	514	514	CD
18637	16572	2	.	.	.
18637	16573	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16573	2	258	258	CD
18637	16573	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16573	4	167	167	CD
18637	16573	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16573	6	43	43	CD
18637	16573	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16573	8	1897	1897	CD
18637	16573	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16573	10	.	.	.
18637	16574	1	This	this	DT
18637	16574	2	case	case	NN
18637	16574	3	was	be	VBD
18637	16574	4	treated	treat	VBN
18637	16574	5	above	above	IN
18637	16574	6	,	,	,
18637	16574	7	at	at	IN
18637	16574	8	p.	p.	NN
18637	16574	9	784	784	CD
18637	16574	10	.	.	.
18637	16575	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16575	2	259	259	CD
18637	16575	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16575	4	314	314	CD
18637	16575	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16575	6	252	252	CD
18637	16575	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16575	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	16575	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16575	10	.	.	.
18637	16576	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16576	2	260	260	CD
18637	16576	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16576	4	323	323	CD
18637	16576	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16576	6	516	516	CD
18637	16576	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16576	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	16576	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16576	10	.	.	.
18637	16577	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16577	2	261	261	CD
18637	16577	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16577	4	Auto	Auto	NNP
18637	16577	5	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	16577	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16577	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16577	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16577	9	Wis.	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	16577	10	Board	Board	NNP
18637	16577	11	,	,	,
18637	16577	12	336	336	CD
18637	16577	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16577	14	245	245	CD
18637	16577	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16577	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	16577	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16577	18	.	.	.
18637	16578	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16578	2	262	262	CD
18637	16578	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16578	4	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	16578	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16578	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16578	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16578	8	Hardyman	Hardyman	NNP
18637	16578	9	,	,	,
18637	16578	10	341	341	CD
18637	16578	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16578	12	651	651	CD
18637	16578	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16578	14	1951	1951	CD
18637	16578	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16578	16	;	;	:
18637	16578	17	17	17	CD
18637	16578	18	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	16578	19	.	.	.
18637	16579	1	13	13	CD
18637	16579	2	,	,	,
18637	16579	3	8	8	CD
18637	16579	4	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	16580	1	§	§	NNP
18637	16580	2	47	47	CD
18637	16580	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16580	4	3	3	CD
18637	16580	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16580	6	.	.	.
18637	16581	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16581	2	263	263	CD
18637	16581	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16581	4	341	341	CD
18637	16581	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16581	6	651	651	CD
18637	16581	7	,	,	,
18637	16581	8	663	663	CD
18637	16581	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16581	10	1951	1951	CD
18637	16581	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16581	12	.	.	.
18637	16582	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16582	2	264	264	CD
18637	16582	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16582	4	2	2	CD
18637	16582	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
18637	16583	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	16583	2	261	261	CD
18637	16583	3	-	-	SYM
18637	16583	4	270	270	CD
18637	16583	5	.	.	.
18637	16584	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16584	2	See	See	NNP
18637	16584	3	also	also	RB
18637	16584	4	:	:	:
18637	16584	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16584	6	General	General	NNP
18637	16584	7	Interim	Interim	NNP
18637	16584	8	Report	Report	NNP
18637	16584	9	of	of	IN
18637	16584	10	the	the	DT
18637	16584	11	House	House	NNP
18637	16584	12	Select	Select	NNP
18637	16584	13	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	16584	14	on	on	IN
18637	16584	15	Lobbying	Lobbying	NNP
18637	16584	16	Activities	Activities	NNPS
18637	16584	17	,	,	,
18637	16584	18	Eighty	Eighty	NNP
18637	16584	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	16584	20	First	First	NNP
18637	16584	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16584	22	,	,	,
18637	16584	23	Second	Second	NNP
18637	16584	24	Session	Session	NNP
18637	16584	25	,	,	,
18637	16584	26	created	create	VBN
18637	16584	27	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	16584	28	to	to	IN
18637	16584	29	H.	H.	NNP
18637	16584	30	Res	Res	NNP
18637	16584	31	.	.	.
18637	16585	1	298	298	CD
18637	16585	2	,	,	,
18637	16585	3	October	October	NNP
18637	16585	4	20	20	CD
18637	16585	5	,	,	,
18637	16585	6	1950	1950	CD
18637	16585	7	,	,	,
18637	16585	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16585	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16585	10	Government	Government	NNP
18637	16585	11	Printing	Printing	NNP
18637	16585	12	Office	Office	NNP
18637	16585	13	,	,	,
18637	16585	14	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	16585	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16585	16	1950	1950	CD
18637	16585	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16585	18	:	:	:
18637	16585	19	_	_	NNP
18637	16585	20	see	see	VB
18637	16585	21	also	also	RB
18637	16585	22	_	_	NNP
18637	16585	23	9	9	CD
18637	16585	24	Encyclopedia	Encyclopedia	NNP
18637	16585	25	of	of	IN
18637	16585	26	the	the	DT
18637	16585	27	Social	Social	NNP
18637	16585	28	Sciences	Sciences	NNPS
18637	16585	29	567	567	CD
18637	16585	30	,	,	,
18637	16585	31	"	"	``
18637	16585	32	Lobbying	lobby	VBG
18637	16585	33	.	.	.
18637	16585	34	"	"	''
18637	16586	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16586	2	265	265	CD
18637	16586	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16586	4	National	National	NNP
18637	16586	5	Association	Association	NNP
18637	16586	6	of	of	IN
18637	16586	7	Manufacturers	Manufacturers	NNPS
18637	16586	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16586	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	16586	10	_	_	NNP
18637	16586	11	McGrath	McGrath	NNP
18637	16586	12	,	,	,
18637	16586	13	103	103	CD
18637	16586	14	F.	F.	NNP
18637	16586	15	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	16586	16	.	.	.
18637	16587	1	510	510	CD
18637	16587	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16587	3	1952	1952	CD
18637	16587	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16587	5	.	.	.
18637	16588	1	Upon	upon	IN
18637	16588	2	review	review	NN
18637	16588	3	,	,	,
18637	16588	4	the	the	DT
18637	16588	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16588	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16588	7	vacated	vacate	VBD
18637	16588	8	this	this	DT
18637	16588	9	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16588	10	as	as	IN
18637	16588	11	moot.--334	moot.--334	NNP
18637	16588	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16588	13	804	804	CD
18637	16588	14	,	,	,
18637	16588	15	807	807	CD
18637	16588	16	.	.	.
18637	16589	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16589	2	266	266	CD
18637	16589	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16589	4	Rumely	Rumely	NNP
18637	16589	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16589	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16589	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16589	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16589	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16589	10	,	,	,
18637	16589	11	197	197	CD
18637	16589	12	F.	F.	NNP
18637	16589	13	2d	2d	CD
18637	16589	14	166	166	CD
18637	16589	15	,	,	,
18637	16589	16	174	174	CD
18637	16589	17	-	-	SYM
18637	16589	18	175	175	CD
18637	16589	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16589	20	1952	1952	CD
18637	16589	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16589	22	.	.	.
18637	16590	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	16590	2	2	2	CD
18637	16590	3	BEARING	bearing	NN
18637	16590	4	ARMS	ARMS	NNP
18637	16590	5	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	16590	6	2	2	CD
18637	16590	7	A	a	DT
18637	16590	8	well	well	RB
18637	16590	9	regulated	regulated	JJ
18637	16590	10	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	16590	11	,	,	,
18637	16590	12	being	be	VBG
18637	16590	13	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	16590	14	to	to	IN
18637	16590	15	the	the	DT
18637	16590	16	security	security	NN
18637	16590	17	of	of	IN
18637	16590	18	a	a	DT
18637	16590	19	free	free	JJ
18637	16590	20	State	State	NNP
18637	16590	21	,	,	,
18637	16590	22	the	the	DT
18637	16590	23	right	right	NN
18637	16590	24	of	of	IN
18637	16590	25	the	the	DT
18637	16590	26	people	people	NNS
18637	16590	27	to	to	TO
18637	16590	28	keep	keep	VB
18637	16590	29	and	and	CC
18637	16590	30	bear	bear	VB
18637	16590	31	Arms	arm	NNS
18637	16590	32	shall	shall	MD
18637	16590	33	not	not	RB
18637	16590	34	be	be	VB
18637	16590	35	infringed	infringe	VBN
18637	16590	36	.	.	.
18637	16591	1	The	the	DT
18637	16591	2	protection	protection	NN
18637	16591	3	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	16591	4	by	by	IN
18637	16591	5	this	this	DT
18637	16591	6	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	16591	7	prevents	prevent	VBZ
18637	16591	8	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	16591	9	by	by	IN
18637	16591	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16591	11	of	of	IN
18637	16591	12	the	the	DT
18637	16591	13	right	right	NN
18637	16591	14	to	to	TO
18637	16591	15	bear	bear	VB
18637	16591	16	arms	arm	NNS
18637	16591	17	for	for	IN
18637	16591	18	a	a	DT
18637	16591	19	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	16591	20	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	16591	21	,	,	,
18637	16591	22	but	but	CC
18637	16591	23	does	do	VBZ
18637	16591	24	not	not	RB
18637	16591	25	apply	apply	VB
18637	16591	26	to	to	IN
18637	16591	27	such	such	JJ
18637	16591	28	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	16591	29	by	by	IN
18637	16591	30	private	private	JJ
18637	16591	31	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	16591	32	.	.	.
18637	16592	1	For	for	IN
18637	16592	2	this	this	DT
18637	16592	3	reason	reason	NN
18637	16592	4	an	an	DT
18637	16592	5	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16592	6	under	under	IN
18637	16592	7	the	the	DT
18637	16592	8	Enforcement	Enforcement	NNP
18637	16592	9	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16592	10	of	of	IN
18637	16592	11	1870,[1	1870,[1	NNP
18637	16592	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16592	13	charging	charge	VBG
18637	16592	14	a	a	DT
18637	16592	15	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	16592	16	to	to	TO
18637	16592	17	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	16592	18	Negroes	negro	NNS
18637	16592	19	from	from	IN
18637	16592	20	bearing	bear	VBG
18637	16592	21	arms	arm	NNS
18637	16592	22	for	for	IN
18637	16592	23	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	16592	24	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	16592	25	was	be	VBD
18637	16592	26	held	hold	VBN
18637	16592	27	defective	defective	JJ
18637	16592	28	.	.	.
18637	16593	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16593	2	2	2	LS
18637	16593	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16593	4	A	a	DT
18637	16593	5	State	State	NNP
18637	16593	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	16593	7	which	which	WDT
18637	16593	8	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	16593	9	bodies	body	NNS
18637	16593	10	of	of	IN
18637	16593	11	men	man	NNS
18637	16593	12	to	to	TO
18637	16593	13	associate	associate	VB
18637	16593	14	together	together	RB
18637	16593	15	as	as	IN
18637	16593	16	military	military	JJ
18637	16593	17	organizations	organization	NNS
18637	16593	18	,	,	,
18637	16593	19	or	or	CC
18637	16593	20	to	to	TO
18637	16593	21	drill	drill	VB
18637	16593	22	or	or	CC
18637	16593	23	parade	parade	VB
18637	16593	24	with	with	IN
18637	16593	25	arms	arm	NNS
18637	16593	26	in	in	IN
18637	16593	27	cities	city	NNS
18637	16593	28	and	and	CC
18637	16593	29	towns	town	NNS
18637	16593	30	unless	unless	IN
18637	16593	31	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	16593	32	by	by	IN
18637	16593	33	law	law	NN
18637	16593	34	,	,	,
18637	16593	35	does	do	VBZ
18637	16593	36	not	not	RB
18637	16593	37	abridge	abridge	VB
18637	16593	38	the	the	DT
18637	16593	39	right	right	NN
18637	16593	40	of	of	IN
18637	16593	41	the	the	DT
18637	16593	42	people	people	NNS
18637	16593	43	to	to	TO
18637	16593	44	keep	keep	VB
18637	16593	45	and	and	CC
18637	16593	46	bear	bear	VB
18637	16593	47	arms	arm	NNS
18637	16593	48	.	.	.
18637	16594	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16594	2	3	3	CD
18637	16594	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16594	4	In	in	IN
18637	16594	5	the	the	DT
18637	16594	6	absence	absence	NN
18637	16594	7	of	of	IN
18637	16594	8	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16594	9	tending	tend	VBG
18637	16594	10	to	to	TO
18637	16594	11	show	show	VB
18637	16594	12	that	that	DT
18637	16594	13	possession	possession	NN
18637	16594	14	or	or	CC
18637	16594	15	use	use	NN
18637	16594	16	of	of	IN
18637	16594	17	a	a	DT
18637	16594	18	shotgun	shotgun	NN
18637	16594	19	having	have	VBG
18637	16594	20	a	a	DT
18637	16594	21	barrel	barrel	NN
18637	16594	22	of	of	IN
18637	16594	23	less	less	JJR
18637	16594	24	than	than	IN
18637	16594	25	18	18	CD
18637	16594	26	inches	inch	NNS
18637	16594	27	in	in	IN
18637	16594	28	length	length	NN
18637	16594	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	16594	30	some	some	DT
18637	16594	31	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	16594	32	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	16594	33	to	to	IN
18637	16594	34	the	the	DT
18637	16594	35	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	16594	36	or	or	CC
18637	16594	37	efficiency	efficiency	NN
18637	16594	38	of	of	IN
18637	16594	39	a	a	DT
18637	16594	40	well	well	RB
18637	16594	41	regulated	regulated	JJ
18637	16594	42	militia	militia	NN
18637	16594	43	,	,	,
18637	16594	44	the	the	DT
18637	16594	45	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16594	46	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	16594	47	to	to	TO
18637	16594	48	hold	hold	VB
18637	16594	49	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	16594	50	a	a	DT
18637	16594	51	provision	provision	NN
18637	16594	52	in	in	IN
18637	16594	53	the	the	DT
18637	16594	54	National	National	NNP
18637	16594	55	Firearms	Firearms	NNPS
18637	16594	56	Act[4	Act[4	NNP
18637	16594	57	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16594	58	against	against	IN
18637	16594	59	the	the	DT
18637	16594	60	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	16594	61	of	of	IN
18637	16594	62	unregistered	unregistered	JJ
18637	16594	63	shotguns	shotgun	NNS
18637	16594	64	in	in	IN
18637	16594	65	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	16594	66	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	16594	67	.	.	.
18637	16595	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16595	2	5	5	CD
18637	16595	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16595	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	16595	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16595	6	1	1	CD
18637	16595	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16595	8	16	16	CD
18637	16595	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	16595	10	.	.	.
18637	16596	1	140	140	CD
18637	16596	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16596	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	16596	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16596	5	.	.	.
18637	16597	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16597	2	2	2	CD
18637	16597	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16597	4	United	United	NNP
18637	16597	5	States	States	NNP
18637	16597	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16597	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16597	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16597	9	Cruikshank	Cruikshank	NNP
18637	16597	10	,	,	,
18637	16597	11	92	92	CD
18637	16597	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16597	13	542	542	CD
18637	16597	14	,	,	,
18637	16597	15	553	553	CD
18637	16597	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16597	17	1876	1876	CD
18637	16597	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16597	19	.	.	.
18637	16598	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16598	2	3	3	LS
18637	16598	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16598	4	Presser	Presser	NNP
18637	16598	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16598	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16598	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16598	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	16598	9	,	,	,
18637	16598	10	116	116	CD
18637	16598	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16598	12	252	252	CD
18637	16598	13	,	,	,
18637	16598	14	265	265	CD
18637	16598	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16598	16	1886	1886	CD
18637	16598	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16598	18	.	.	.
18637	16599	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16599	2	4	4	CD
18637	16599	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16599	4	48	48	CD
18637	16599	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	16599	6	.	.	.
18637	16600	1	1236	1236	CD
18637	16600	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16600	3	1934	1934	CD
18637	16600	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16600	5	.	.	.
18637	16601	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16601	2	5	5	CD
18637	16601	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16601	4	United	United	NNP
18637	16601	5	States	States	NNP
18637	16601	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16601	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16601	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16601	9	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	16601	10	,	,	,
18637	16601	11	307	307	CD
18637	16601	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16601	13	174	174	CD
18637	16601	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16601	15	1939	1939	CD
18637	16601	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16601	17	.	.	.
18637	16602	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	16602	2	3	3	CD
18637	16602	3	QUARTERING	QUARTERING	NNP
18637	16602	4	SOLDIERS	SOLDIERS	NNPS
18637	16602	5	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16602	6	3	3	CD
18637	16602	7	No	no	DT
18637	16602	8	Soldier	soldier	NN
18637	16602	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	16602	10	,	,	,
18637	16602	11	in	in	IN
18637	16602	12	time	time	NN
18637	16602	13	of	of	IN
18637	16602	14	peace	peace	NN
18637	16602	15	be	be	VB
18637	16602	16	quartered	quarter	VBN
18637	16602	17	in	in	IN
18637	16602	18	any	any	DT
18637	16602	19	house	house	NN
18637	16602	20	,	,	,
18637	16602	21	without	without	IN
18637	16602	22	the	the	DT
18637	16602	23	consent	consent	NN
18637	16602	24	of	of	IN
18637	16602	25	the	the	DT
18637	16602	26	Owner	Owner	NNP
18637	16602	27	,	,	,
18637	16602	28	nor	nor	CC
18637	16602	29	in	in	IN
18637	16602	30	time	time	NN
18637	16602	31	of	of	IN
18637	16602	32	war	war	NN
18637	16602	33	,	,	,
18637	16602	34	but	but	CC
18637	16602	35	in	in	IN
18637	16602	36	a	a	DT
18637	16602	37	manner	manner	NN
18637	16602	38	to	to	TO
18637	16602	39	be	be	VB
18637	16602	40	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	16602	41	by	by	IN
18637	16602	42	law	law	NN
18637	16602	43	.	.	.
18637	16603	1	"	"	``
18637	16603	2	This	this	DT
18637	16603	3	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	16603	4	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	16603	5	to	to	TO
18637	16603	6	have	have	VB
18637	16603	7	been	be	VBN
18637	16603	8	thought	think	VBN
18637	16603	9	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	16603	10	.	.	.
18637	16604	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16604	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	16604	3	not	not	RB
18637	16604	4	appear	appear	VB
18637	16604	5	to	to	TO
18637	16604	6	have	have	VB
18637	16604	7	been	be	VBN
18637	16604	8	the	the	DT
18637	16604	9	subject	subject	NN
18637	16604	10	of	of	IN
18637	16604	11	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16604	12	exposition	exposition	NN
18637	16604	13	;	;	:
18637	16604	14	and	and	CC
18637	16604	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16604	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	16604	17	so	so	RB
18637	16604	18	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
18637	16604	19	in	in	IN
18637	16604	20	accord	accord	NN
18637	16604	21	with	with	IN
18637	16604	22	all	all	PDT
18637	16604	23	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16604	24	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	16604	25	,	,	,
18637	16604	26	that	that	IN
18637	16604	27	further	further	JJ
18637	16604	28	comment	comment	NN
18637	16604	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	16604	30	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	16604	31	.	.	.
18637	16605	1	"	"	``
18637	16605	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16605	3	1	1	CD
18637	16605	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16605	5	Notes	note	NNS
18637	16605	6	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16605	7	1	1	CD
18637	16605	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16605	9	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	16605	10	,	,	,
18637	16605	11	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
18637	16605	12	F.	F.	NNP
18637	16605	13	,	,	,
18637	16605	14	The	the	DT
18637	16605	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	16605	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16605	17	1893	1893	CD
18637	16605	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16605	19	,	,	,
18637	16605	20	page	page	NN
18637	16605	21	646	646	CD
18637	16605	22	.	.	.
18637	16606	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	16606	2	4	4	CD
18637	16606	3	SEARCHES	SEARCHES	NNP
18637	16606	4	AND	and	CC
18637	16606	5	SEIZURES	SEIZURES	NNP
18637	16606	6	Page	Page	NNP
18637	16606	7	Coverage	Coverage	NNP
18637	16606	8	of	of	IN
18637	16606	9	the	the	DT
18637	16606	10	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	16606	11	823	823	CD
18637	16606	12	Necessity	Necessity	NNP
18637	16606	13	,	,	,
18637	16606	14	sufficiency	sufficiency	NN
18637	16606	15	and	and	CC
18637	16606	16	effect	effect	NN
18637	16606	17	of	of	IN
18637	16606	18	warrants	warrant	NNS
18637	16606	19	825	825	CD
18637	16606	20	Records	Records	NNPS
18637	16606	21	,	,	,
18637	16606	22	reports	report	NNS
18637	16606	23	and	and	CC
18637	16606	24	subpoenas	subpoena	NNS
18637	16606	25	825	825	CD
18637	16606	26	Search	Search	NNP
18637	16606	27	and	and	CC
18637	16606	28	seizure	seizure	VB
18637	16606	29	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	16606	30	to	to	TO
18637	16606	31	arrest	arrest	VB
18637	16606	32	828	828	CD
18637	16606	33	Search	Search	NNP
18637	16606	34	of	of	IN
18637	16606	35	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	16606	36	830	830	CD
18637	16606	37	Use	use	NN
18637	16606	38	of	of	IN
18637	16606	39	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16606	40	830	830	CD
18637	16606	41	SEARCHES	SEARCHES	NNP
18637	16606	42	AND	and	CC
18637	16606	43	SEIZURES	SEIZURES	NNP
18637	16606	44	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16606	45	4	4	CD
18637	16606	46	The	the	DT
18637	16606	47	right	right	NN
18637	16606	48	of	of	IN
18637	16606	49	the	the	DT
18637	16606	50	people	people	NNS
18637	16606	51	to	to	TO
18637	16606	52	be	be	VB
18637	16606	53	secure	secure	JJ
18637	16606	54	in	in	IN
18637	16606	55	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16606	56	persons	person	NNS
18637	16606	57	,	,	,
18637	16606	58	houses	house	NNS
18637	16606	59	,	,	,
18637	16606	60	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16606	61	,	,	,
18637	16606	62	and	and	CC
18637	16606	63	effects	effect	NNS
18637	16606	64	,	,	,
18637	16606	65	against	against	IN
18637	16606	66	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	16606	67	searches	search	NNS
18637	16606	68	and	and	CC
18637	16606	69	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	16606	70	,	,	,
18637	16606	71	shall	shall	MD
18637	16606	72	not	not	RB
18637	16606	73	be	be	VB
18637	16606	74	violated	violate	VBN
18637	16606	75	,	,	,
18637	16606	76	and	and	CC
18637	16606	77	no	no	DT
18637	16606	78	Warrants	Warrants	NNP
18637	16606	79	shall	shall	MD
18637	16606	80	issue	issue	VB
18637	16606	81	,	,	,
18637	16606	82	but	but	CC
18637	16606	83	upon	upon	IN
18637	16606	84	probable	probable	JJ
18637	16606	85	cause	cause	NN
18637	16606	86	,	,	,
18637	16606	87	supported	support	VBN
18637	16606	88	by	by	IN
18637	16606	89	Oath	Oath	NNP
18637	16606	90	or	or	CC
18637	16606	91	affirmation	affirmation	NN
18637	16606	92	,	,	,
18637	16606	93	and	and	CC
18637	16606	94	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	16606	95	describing	describe	VBG
18637	16606	96	the	the	DT
18637	16606	97	place	place	NN
18637	16606	98	to	to	TO
18637	16606	99	be	be	VB
18637	16606	100	searched	search	VBN
18637	16606	101	,	,	,
18637	16606	102	and	and	CC
18637	16606	103	the	the	DT
18637	16606	104	persons	person	NNS
18637	16606	105	or	or	CC
18637	16606	106	things	thing	NNS
18637	16606	107	to	to	TO
18637	16606	108	be	be	VB
18637	16606	109	seized	seize	VBN
18637	16606	110	.	.	.
18637	16607	1	Coverage	coverage	NN
18637	16607	2	of	of	IN
18637	16607	3	the	the	DT
18637	16607	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16607	5	This	this	DT
18637	16607	6	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	16607	7	denounces	denounce	VBZ
18637	16607	8	only	only	RB
18637	16607	9	such	such	JJ
18637	16607	10	searches	search	NNS
18637	16607	11	and	and	CC
18637	16607	12	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	16607	13	as	as	IN
18637	16607	14	are	be	VBP
18637	16607	15	"	"	``
18637	16607	16	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	16607	17	,	,	,
18637	16607	18	"	"	''
18637	16607	19	and	and	CC
18637	16607	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	16607	21	to	to	TO
18637	16607	22	be	be	VB
18637	16607	23	construed	construe	VBN
18637	16607	24	in	in	IN
18637	16607	25	the	the	DT
18637	16607	26	light	light	NN
18637	16607	27	of	of	IN
18637	16607	28	what	what	WP
18637	16607	29	was	be	VBD
18637	16607	30	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	16607	31	an	an	DT
18637	16607	32	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	16607	33	search	search	NN
18637	16607	34	and	and	CC
18637	16607	35	seizure	seizure	VB
18637	16607	36	when	when	WRB
18637	16607	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16607	38	was	be	VBD
18637	16607	39	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	16607	40	and	and	CC
18637	16607	41	in	in	IN
18637	16607	42	a	a	DT
18637	16607	43	manner	manner	NN
18637	16607	44	to	to	TO
18637	16607	45	conserve	conserve	VB
18637	16607	46	public	public	JJ
18637	16607	47	interests	interest	NNS
18637	16607	48	as	as	RB
18637	16607	49	well	well	RB
18637	16607	50	as	as	IN
18637	16607	51	the	the	DT
18637	16607	52	rights	right	NNS
18637	16607	53	of	of	IN
18637	16607	54	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	16607	55	.	.	.
18637	16608	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16608	2	1	1	CD
18637	16608	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16608	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16608	5	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	16608	6	only	only	RB
18637	16608	7	to	to	IN
18637	16608	8	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	16608	9	action	action	NN
18637	16608	10	,	,	,
18637	16608	11	not	not	RB
18637	16608	12	to	to	IN
18637	16608	13	the	the	DT
18637	16608	14	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	16608	15	acts	act	NNS
18637	16608	16	of	of	IN
18637	16608	17	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	16608	18	in	in	IN
18637	16608	19	which	which	WDT
18637	16608	20	the	the	DT
18637	16608	21	government	government	NN
18637	16608	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	16608	23	no	no	DT
18637	16608	24	part	part	NN
18637	16608	25	.	.	.
18637	16609	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16609	2	2	2	LS
18637	16609	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16609	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16609	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	16609	6	no	no	DT
18637	16609	7	reference	reference	NN
18637	16609	8	to	to	IN
18637	16609	9	civil	civil	JJ
18637	16609	10	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16609	11	for	for	IN
18637	16609	12	the	the	DT
18637	16609	13	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	16609	14	of	of	IN
18637	16609	15	debts	debt	NNS
18637	16609	16	;	;	:
18637	16609	17	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	16609	18	,	,	,
18637	16609	19	a	a	DT
18637	16609	20	distress	distress	NN
18637	16609	21	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16609	22	issued	issue	VBN
18637	16609	23	by	by	IN
18637	16609	24	the	the	DT
18637	16609	25	Solicitor	Solicitor	NNP
18637	16609	26	of	of	IN
18637	16609	27	the	the	DT
18637	16609	28	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	16609	29	under	under	IN
18637	16609	30	an	an	DT
18637	16609	31	act	act	NN
18637	16609	32	of	of	IN
18637	16609	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16609	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	16609	35	not	not	RB
18637	16609	36	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	16609	37	,	,	,
18637	16609	38	though	though	IN
18637	16609	39	issued	issue	VBN
18637	16609	40	without	without	IN
18637	16609	41	support	support	NN
18637	16609	42	of	of	IN
18637	16609	43	an	an	DT
18637	16609	44	oath	oath	NN
18637	16609	45	or	or	CC
18637	16609	46	affirmation	affirmation	NN
18637	16609	47	.	.	.
18637	16610	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16610	2	3	3	CD
18637	16610	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16610	4	But	but	CC
18637	16610	5	the	the	DT
18637	16610	6	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	16610	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	16610	8	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	16610	9	to	to	TO
18637	16610	10	search	search	VB
18637	16610	11	warrants	warrant	NNS
18637	16610	12	issued	issue	VBN
18637	16610	13	under	under	IN
18637	16610	14	any	any	DT
18637	16610	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	16610	16	,	,	,
18637	16610	17	including	include	VBG
18637	16610	18	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	16610	19	and	and	CC
18637	16610	20	tariff	tariff	NN
18637	16610	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	16610	22	.	.	.
18637	16611	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16611	2	4	4	LS
18637	16611	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16611	4	Security	security	NN
18637	16611	5	"	"	''
18637	16611	6	in	in	IN
18637	16611	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16611	8	persons	person	NNS
18637	16611	9	,	,	,
18637	16611	10	houses	house	NNS
18637	16611	11	,	,	,
18637	16611	12	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16611	13	and	and	CC
18637	16611	14	effects	effect	NNS
18637	16611	15	"	"	''
18637	16611	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	16611	17	assured	assure	VBN
18637	16611	18	to	to	IN
18637	16611	19	the	the	DT
18637	16611	20	people	people	NNS
18637	16611	21	by	by	IN
18637	16611	22	this	this	DT
18637	16611	23	article	article	NN
18637	16611	24	.	.	.
18637	16612	1	Not	not	RB
18637	16612	2	only	only	RB
18637	16612	3	the	the	DT
18637	16612	4	search	search	NN
18637	16612	5	of	of	IN
18637	16612	6	a	a	DT
18637	16612	7	dwelling	dwelling	NN
18637	16612	8	,	,	,
18637	16612	9	but	but	CC
18637	16612	10	also	also	RB
18637	16612	11	of	of	IN
18637	16612	12	a	a	DT
18637	16612	13	place	place	NN
18637	16612	14	of	of	IN
18637	16612	15	business,[5	business,[5	NNP
18637	16612	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16612	17	a	a	DT
18637	16612	18	garage,[6	garage,[6	NN
18637	16612	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16612	20	or	or	CC
18637	16612	21	a	a	DT
18637	16612	22	vehicle,[7	vehicle,[7	NN
18637	16612	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16612	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	16612	25	limited	limit	VBN
18637	16612	26	by	by	IN
18637	16612	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16612	28	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	16612	29	.	.	.
18637	16613	1	But	but	CC
18637	16613	2	open	open	JJ
18637	16613	3	fields	field	NNS
18637	16613	4	are	be	VBP
18637	16613	5	not	not	RB
18637	16613	6	covered	cover	VBN
18637	16613	7	by	by	IN
18637	16613	8	the	the	DT
18637	16613	9	term	term	NN
18637	16613	10	"	"	``
18637	16613	11	house	house	NN
18637	16613	12	"	"	''
18637	16613	13	;	;	:
18637	16613	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16613	15	may	may	MD
18637	16613	16	be	be	VB
18637	16613	17	searched	search	VBN
18637	16613	18	without	without	IN
18637	16613	19	a	a	DT
18637	16613	20	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16613	21	.	.	.
18637	16614	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16614	2	8	8	LS
18637	16614	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16614	4	A	a	DT
18637	16614	5	sealed	seal	VBN
18637	16614	6	letter	letter	NN
18637	16614	7	deposited	deposit	VBN
18637	16614	8	in	in	IN
18637	16614	9	the	the	DT
18637	16614	10	mails	mail	NNS
18637	16614	11	may	may	MD
18637	16614	12	not	not	RB
18637	16614	13	be	be	VB
18637	16614	14	opened	open	VBN
18637	16614	15	by	by	IN
18637	16614	16	the	the	DT
18637	16614	17	postal	postal	JJ
18637	16614	18	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	16614	19	without	without	IN
18637	16614	20	the	the	DT
18637	16614	21	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	16614	22	of	of	IN
18637	16614	23	a	a	DT
18637	16614	24	magistrate	magistrate	NN
18637	16614	25	.	.	.
18637	16615	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16615	2	9	9	CD
18637	16615	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16615	4	The	the	DT
18637	16615	5	subpoena	subpoena	NN
18637	16615	6	of	of	IN
18637	16615	7	private	private	JJ
18637	16615	8	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16615	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	16615	10	subject	subject	JJ
18637	16615	11	to	to	IN
18637	16615	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16615	13	test	test	NN
18637	16615	14	of	of	IN
18637	16615	15	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	16615	16	.	.	.
18637	16616	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16616	2	10	10	CD
18637	16616	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16616	4	Retention	retention	NN
18637	16616	5	for	for	IN
18637	16616	6	use	use	NN
18637	16616	7	as	as	IN
18637	16616	8	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16616	9	of	of	IN
18637	16616	10	a	a	DT
18637	16616	11	letter	letter	NN
18637	16616	12	voluntarily	voluntarily	RB
18637	16616	13	written	write	VBN
18637	16616	14	by	by	IN
18637	16616	15	a	a	DT
18637	16616	16	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	16616	17	,	,	,
18637	16616	18	which	which	WDT
18637	16616	19	,	,	,
18637	16616	20	without	without	IN
18637	16616	21	threat	threat	NN
18637	16616	22	or	or	CC
18637	16616	23	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	16616	24	,	,	,
18637	16616	25	came	come	VBD
18637	16616	26	into	into	IN
18637	16616	27	the	the	DT
18637	16616	28	possession	possession	NN
18637	16616	29	of	of	IN
18637	16616	30	prison	prison	NN
18637	16616	31	officials	official	NNS
18637	16616	32	under	under	IN
18637	16616	33	the	the	DT
18637	16616	34	practice	practice	NN
18637	16616	35	and	and	CC
18637	16616	36	discipline	discipline	NN
18637	16616	37	of	of	IN
18637	16616	38	the	the	DT
18637	16616	39	institution	institution	NN
18637	16616	40	,	,	,
18637	16616	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	16616	42	not	not	RB
18637	16616	43	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	16616	44	.	.	.
18637	16617	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16617	2	11	11	CD
18637	16617	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16617	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	16617	5	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16617	6	demand	demand	VBP
18637	16617	7	admission	admission	NN
18637	16617	8	to	to	IN
18637	16617	9	private	private	JJ
18637	16617	10	premises	premise	NNS
18637	16617	11	in	in	IN
18637	16617	12	the	the	DT
18637	16617	13	name	name	NN
18637	16617	14	of	of	IN
18637	16617	15	the	the	DT
18637	16617	16	law	law	NN
18637	16617	17	,	,	,
18637	16617	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16617	19	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	16617	20	explorations	exploration	NNS
18637	16617	21	are	be	VBP
18637	16617	22	searches	search	NNS
18637	16617	23	within	within	IN
18637	16617	24	the	the	DT
18637	16617	25	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	16617	26	of	of	IN
18637	16617	27	the	the	DT
18637	16617	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	16617	29	,	,	,
18637	16617	30	even	even	RB
18637	16617	31	though	though	IN
18637	16617	32	the	the	DT
18637	16617	33	occupant	occupant	NN
18637	16617	34	opens	open	VBZ
18637	16617	35	the	the	DT
18637	16617	36	door	door	NN
18637	16617	37	to	to	TO
18637	16617	38	admit	admit	VB
18637	16617	39	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16617	40	.	.	.
18637	16618	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16618	2	12	12	CD
18637	16618	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16618	4	A	a	DT
18637	16618	5	peremptory	peremptory	JJ
18637	16618	6	demand	demand	NN
18637	16618	7	by	by	IN
18637	16618	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16618	9	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16618	10	that	that	WDT
18637	16618	11	a	a	DT
18637	16618	12	person	person	NN
18637	16618	13	suspected	suspect	VBN
18637	16618	14	of	of	IN
18637	16618	15	crime	crime	NN
18637	16618	16	open	open	VB
18637	16618	17	a	a	DT
18637	16618	18	locked	lock	VBN
18637	16618	19	room	room	NN
18637	16618	20	and	and	CC
18637	16618	21	hand	hand	VB
18637	16618	22	over	over	RP
18637	16618	23	ration	ration	NN
18637	16618	24	coupons	coupon	NNS
18637	16618	25	kept	keep	VBD
18637	16618	26	there	there	EX
18637	16618	27	was	be	VBD
18637	16618	28	held	hold	VBN
18637	16618	29	not	not	RB
18637	16618	30	to	to	TO
18637	16618	31	amount	amount	VB
18637	16618	32	to	to	IN
18637	16618	33	a	a	DT
18637	16618	34	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16618	35	in	in	IN
18637	16618	36	view	view	NN
18637	16618	37	of	of	IN
18637	16618	38	the	the	DT
18637	16618	39	fact	fact	NN
18637	16618	40	that	that	IN
18637	16618	41	the	the	DT
18637	16618	42	coupons	coupon	NNS
18637	16618	43	were	be	VBD
18637	16618	44	government	government	NN
18637	16618	45	property	property	NN
18637	16618	46	which	which	WDT
18637	16618	47	the	the	DT
18637	16618	48	custodian	custodian	NN
18637	16618	49	was	be	VBD
18637	16618	50	under	under	IN
18637	16618	51	a	a	DT
18637	16618	52	duty	duty	NN
18637	16618	53	to	to	TO
18637	16618	54	surrender	surrender	VB
18637	16618	55	.	.	.
18637	16619	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16619	2	13	13	CD
18637	16619	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16619	4	Neither	neither	CC
18637	16619	5	wiretapping,[14	wiretapping,[14	CD
18637	16619	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16619	7	nor	nor	CC
18637	16619	8	the	the	DT
18637	16619	9	use	use	NN
18637	16619	10	of	of	IN
18637	16619	11	a	a	DT
18637	16619	12	detectaphone	detectaphone	NN
18637	16619	13	to	to	TO
18637	16619	14	listen	listen	VB
18637	16619	15	to	to	IN
18637	16619	16	a	a	DT
18637	16619	17	conversation	conversation	NN
18637	16619	18	in	in	IN
18637	16619	19	an	an	DT
18637	16619	20	adjoining	adjoining	JJ
18637	16619	21	room,[15	room,[15	CD
18637	16619	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16619	23	nor	nor	CC
18637	16619	24	interrogation	interrogation	NN
18637	16619	25	under	under	IN
18637	16619	26	oath	oath	NN
18637	16619	27	by	by	IN
18637	16619	28	a	a	DT
18637	16619	29	government	government	NN
18637	16619	30	official	official	NN
18637	16619	31	of	of	IN
18637	16619	32	a	a	DT
18637	16619	33	person	person	NN
18637	16619	34	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	16619	35	in	in	IN
18637	16619	36	confinement[16	confinement[16	NN
18637	16619	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16619	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	16619	39	within	within	IN
18637	16619	40	the	the	DT
18637	16619	41	purview	purview	NN
18637	16619	42	of	of	IN
18637	16619	43	this	this	DT
18637	16619	44	article	article	NN
18637	16619	45	.	.	.
18637	16620	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	16620	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	16620	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16620	4	apply	apply	VB
18637	16620	5	to	to	IN
18637	16620	6	statements	statement	NNS
18637	16620	7	made	make	VBN
18637	16620	8	by	by	IN
18637	16620	9	an	an	DT
18637	16620	10	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16620	11	on	on	IN
18637	16620	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16620	13	own	own	JJ
18637	16620	14	premises	premise	NNS
18637	16620	15	to	to	IN
18637	16620	16	an	an	DT
18637	16620	17	"	"	``
18637	16620	18	undercover	undercover	JJ
18637	16620	19	agent	agent	NN
18637	16620	20	"	"	''
18637	16620	21	whose	whose	WP$
18637	16620	22	identity	identity	NN
18637	16620	23	was	be	VBD
18637	16620	24	not	not	RB
18637	16620	25	suspected	suspect	VBN
18637	16620	26	and	and	CC
18637	16620	27	who	who	WP
18637	16620	28	had	have	VBD
18637	16620	29	on	on	IN
18637	16620	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16620	31	person	person	NN
18637	16620	32	a	a	DT
18637	16620	33	radio	radio	NN
18637	16620	34	transmitter	transmitter	NN
18637	16620	35	which	which	WDT
18637	16620	36	communicated	communicate	VBD
18637	16620	37	the	the	DT
18637	16620	38	statements	statement	NNS
18637	16620	39	to	to	IN
18637	16620	40	another	another	DT
18637	16620	41	agent	agent	NN
18637	16620	42	outside	outside	IN
18637	16620	43	the	the	DT
18637	16620	44	building	building	NN
18637	16620	45	.	.	.
18637	16621	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16621	2	17	17	CD
18637	16621	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16621	4	Said	Said	NNP
18637	16621	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16621	6	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	16621	7	for	for	IN
18637	16621	8	the	the	DT
18637	16621	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16621	10	:	:	:
18637	16621	11	"	"	``
18637	16621	12	Petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	16621	13	relies	rely	VBZ
18637	16621	14	on	on	IN
18637	16621	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	16621	16	relating	relate	VBG
18637	16621	17	to	to	IN
18637	16621	18	the	the	DT
18637	16621	19	more	more	RBR
18637	16621	20	common	common	JJ
18637	16621	21	and	and	CC
18637	16621	22	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	16621	23	distinguishable	distinguishable	JJ
18637	16621	24	problems	problem	NNS
18637	16621	25	raised	raise	VBN
18637	16621	26	where	where	WRB
18637	16621	27	tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	16621	28	property	property	NN
18637	16621	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	16621	30	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	16621	31	seized	seize	VBN
18637	16621	32	.	.	.
18637	16622	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	16622	2	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	16622	3	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16622	4	may	may	MD
18637	16622	5	violate	violate	VB
18637	16622	6	the	the	DT
18637	16622	7	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	16622	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16622	9	,	,	,
18637	16622	10	even	even	RB
18637	16622	11	though	though	IN
18637	16622	12	the	the	DT
18637	16622	13	entry	entry	NN
18637	16622	14	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16622	15	was	be	VBD
18637	16622	16	by	by	IN
18637	16622	17	subterfuge	subterfuge	NN
18637	16622	18	or	or	CC
18637	16622	19	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	16622	20	rather	rather	RB
18637	16622	21	than	than	IN
18637	16622	22	force	force	NN
18637	16622	23	.	.	.
18637	16623	1	But	but	CC
18637	16623	2	such	such	JJ
18637	16623	3	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	16623	4	are	be	VBP
18637	16623	5	inapposite	inapposite	JJ
18637	16623	6	in	in	IN
18637	16623	7	the	the	DT
18637	16623	8	field	field	NN
18637	16623	9	of	of	IN
18637	16623	10	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
18637	16623	11	or	or	CC
18637	16623	12	electronic	electronic	JJ
18637	16623	13	devices	device	NNS
18637	16623	14	designed	design	VBN
18637	16623	15	to	to	TO
18637	16623	16	overhear	overhear	VB
18637	16623	17	or	or	CC
18637	16623	18	intercept	intercept	VB
18637	16623	19	conversation	conversation	NN
18637	16623	20	,	,	,
18637	16623	21	at	at	IN
18637	16623	22	least	least	JJS
18637	16623	23	where	where	WRB
18637	16623	24	access	access	NN
18637	16623	25	to	to	IN
18637	16623	26	the	the	DT
18637	16623	27	listening	listening	NN
18637	16623	28	post	post	NN
18637	16623	29	was	be	VBD
18637	16623	30	not	not	RB
18637	16623	31	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	16623	32	by	by	IN
18637	16623	33	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	16623	34	methods	method	NNS
18637	16623	35	.	.	.
18637	16624	1	"	"	``
18637	16624	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16624	3	18	18	CD
18637	16624	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16624	5	But	but	CC
18637	16624	6	narcotics	narcotic	NNS
18637	16624	7	seized	seize	VBN
18637	16624	8	in	in	IN
18637	16624	9	a	a	DT
18637	16624	10	hotel	hotel	NN
18637	16624	11	room	room	NN
18637	16624	12	during	during	IN
18637	16624	13	absence	absence	NN
18637	16624	14	of	of	IN
18637	16624	15	the	the	DT
18637	16624	16	owner	owner	NN
18637	16624	17	,	,	,
18637	16624	18	in	in	IN
18637	16624	19	the	the	DT
18637	16624	20	course	course	NN
18637	16624	21	of	of	IN
18637	16624	22	a	a	DT
18637	16624	23	search	search	NN
18637	16624	24	without	without	IN
18637	16624	25	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16624	26	for	for	IN
18637	16624	27	either	either	DT
18637	16624	28	search	search	NN
18637	16624	29	or	or	CC
18637	16624	30	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16624	31	,	,	,
18637	16624	32	were	be	VBD
18637	16624	33	not	not	RB
18637	16624	34	adducible	adducible	JJ
18637	16624	35	as	as	IN
18637	16624	36	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16624	37	against	against	IN
18637	16624	38	the	the	DT
18637	16624	39	owner	owner	NN
18637	16624	40	,	,	,
18637	16624	41	who	who	WP
18637	16624	42	,	,	,
18637	16624	43	however	however	RB
18637	16624	44	,	,	,
18637	16624	45	was	be	VBD
18637	16624	46	not	not	RB
18637	16624	47	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	16624	48	to	to	TO
18637	16624	49	have	have	VB
18637	16624	50	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16624	51	returned	return	VBN
18637	16624	52	since	since	IN
18637	16624	53	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16624	54	were	be	VBD
18637	16624	55	legal	legal	JJ
18637	16624	56	contraband	contraband	NN
18637	16624	57	.	.	.
18637	16625	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16625	2	19	19	CD
18637	16625	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16625	4	Necessity	Necessity	NNP
18637	16625	5	,	,	,
18637	16625	6	Sufficiency	Sufficiency	NNP
18637	16625	7	and	and	CC
18637	16625	8	Effect	Effect	NNP
18637	16625	9	of	of	IN
18637	16625	10	Warrants	Warrants	NNP
18637	16625	11	A	a	DT
18637	16625	12	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16625	13	of	of	IN
18637	16625	14	commitment	commitment	NN
18637	16625	15	by	by	IN
18637	16625	16	a	a	DT
18637	16625	17	justice	justice	NN
18637	16625	18	of	of	IN
18637	16625	19	the	the	DT
18637	16625	20	peace	peace	NN
18637	16625	21	must	must	MD
18637	16625	22	state	state	VB
18637	16625	23	a	a	DT
18637	16625	24	good	good	JJ
18637	16625	25	cause	cause	NN
18637	16625	26	certain	certain	JJ
18637	16625	27	and	and	CC
18637	16625	28	be	be	VB
18637	16625	29	supported	support	VBN
18637	16625	30	by	by	IN
18637	16625	31	oath	oath	NN
18637	16625	32	.	.	.
18637	16626	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16626	2	20	20	CD
18637	16626	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16626	4	A	a	DT
18637	16626	5	notary	notary	JJ
18637	16626	6	public	public	NN
18637	16626	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	16626	8	not	not	RB
18637	16626	9	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	16626	10	to	to	TO
18637	16626	11	administer	administer	VB
18637	16626	12	oaths	oath	NNS
18637	16626	13	in	in	IN
18637	16626	14	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16626	15	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16626	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16626	17	;	;	:
18637	16626	18	hence	hence	RB
18637	16626	19	a	a	DT
18637	16626	20	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16626	21	based	base	VBN
18637	16626	22	on	on	IN
18637	16626	23	affidavits	affidavit	NNS
18637	16626	24	verified	verify	VBN
18637	16626	25	before	before	IN
18637	16626	26	a	a	DT
18637	16626	27	notary	notary	NN
18637	16626	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	16626	29	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	16626	30	.	.	.
18637	16627	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16627	2	21	21	CD
18637	16627	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16627	4	A	a	DT
18637	16627	5	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16627	6	of	of	IN
18637	16627	7	the	the	DT
18637	16627	8	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	16627	9	for	for	IN
18637	16627	10	attachment	attachment	NN
18637	16627	11	of	of	IN
18637	16627	12	a	a	DT
18637	16627	13	person	person	NN
18637	16627	14	who	who	WP
18637	16627	15	ignored	ignore	VBD
18637	16627	16	a	a	DT
18637	16627	17	subpoena	subpoena	NN
18637	16627	18	from	from	IN
18637	16627	19	a	a	DT
18637	16627	20	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	16627	21	committee	committee	NN
18637	16627	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	16627	23	supported	support	VBN
18637	16627	24	by	by	IN
18637	16627	25	oath	oath	NN
18637	16627	26	within	within	IN
18637	16627	27	the	the	DT
18637	16627	28	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	16627	29	of	of	IN
18637	16627	30	this	this	DT
18637	16627	31	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	16627	32	when	when	WRB
18637	16627	33	based	base	VBN
18637	16627	34	upon	upon	IN
18637	16627	35	the	the	DT
18637	16627	36	committee	committee	NN
18637	16627	37	's	's	POS
18637	16627	38	report	report	NN
18637	16627	39	of	of	IN
18637	16627	40	the	the	DT
18637	16627	41	facts	fact	NNS
18637	16627	42	of	of	IN
18637	16627	43	the	the	DT
18637	16627	44	contumacy	contumacy	NN
18637	16627	45	,	,	,
18637	16627	46	made	make	VBN
18637	16627	47	on	on	IN
18637	16627	48	the	the	DT
18637	16627	49	committee	committee	NN
18637	16627	50	's	's	POS
18637	16627	51	own	own	JJ
18637	16627	52	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	16627	53	and	and	CC
18637	16627	54	having	have	VBG
18637	16627	55	the	the	DT
18637	16627	56	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	16627	57	of	of	IN
18637	16627	58	the	the	DT
18637	16627	59	oath	oath	NN
18637	16627	60	of	of	IN
18637	16627	61	office	office	NN
18637	16627	62	of	of	IN
18637	16627	63	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16627	64	members	member	NNS
18637	16627	65	.	.	.
18637	16628	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16628	2	22	22	CD
18637	16628	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16628	4	A	a	DT
18637	16628	5	belief	belief	NN
18637	16628	6	,	,	,
18637	16628	7	however	however	RB
18637	16628	8	well	well	RB
18637	16628	9	founded	found	VBN
18637	16628	10	,	,	,
18637	16628	11	that	that	IN
18637	16628	12	an	an	DT
18637	16628	13	article	article	NN
18637	16628	14	sought	seek	VBN
18637	16628	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	16628	16	concealed	conceal	VBN
18637	16628	17	in	in	IN
18637	16628	18	a	a	DT
18637	16628	19	dwelling	dwelling	JJ
18637	16628	20	house	house	NN
18637	16628	21	furnishes	furnish	VBZ
18637	16628	22	no	no	DT
18637	16628	23	justification	justification	NN
18637	16628	24	for	for	IN
18637	16628	25	a	a	DT
18637	16628	26	search	search	NN
18637	16628	27	without	without	IN
18637	16628	28	a	a	DT
18637	16628	29	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16628	30	.	.	.
18637	16629	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16629	2	23	23	CD
18637	16629	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16629	4	A	a	DT
18637	16629	5	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16629	6	issued	issue	VBN
18637	16629	7	upon	upon	IN
18637	16629	8	an	an	DT
18637	16629	9	information	information	NN
18637	16629	10	stating	state	VBG
18637	16629	11	only	only	RB
18637	16629	12	that	that	IN
18637	16629	13	"	"	``
18637	16629	14	affiant	affiant	JJ
18637	16629	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	16629	16	good	good	JJ
18637	16629	17	reason	reason	NN
18637	16629	18	to	to	TO
18637	16629	19	believe	believe	VB
18637	16629	20	and	and	CC
18637	16629	21	does	do	VBZ
18637	16629	22	believe	believe	VB
18637	16629	23	"	"	``
18637	16629	24	that	that	DT
18637	16629	25	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	16629	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	16629	27	contraband	contraband	NN
18637	16629	28	materials	material	NNS
18637	16629	29	in	in	IN
18637	16629	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16629	31	possession	possession	NN
18637	16629	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	16629	33	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	16629	34	bad	bad	JJ
18637	16629	35	under	under	IN
18637	16629	36	the	the	DT
18637	16629	37	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	16629	38	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16629	39	.	.	.
18637	16630	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16630	2	24	24	CD
18637	16630	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16630	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16630	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	16630	6	enough	enough	JJ
18637	16630	7	,	,	,
18637	16630	8	however	however	RB
18637	16630	9	,	,	,
18637	16630	10	if	if	IN
18637	16630	11	the	the	DT
18637	16630	12	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	16630	13	facts	fact	NNS
18637	16630	14	set	set	VBD
18637	16630	15	out	out	RP
18637	16630	16	in	in	IN
18637	16630	17	the	the	DT
18637	16630	18	affidavit	affidavit	NN
18637	16630	19	are	be	VBP
18637	16630	20	such	such	JJ
18637	16630	21	that	that	IN
18637	16630	22	a	a	DT
18637	16630	23	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	16630	24	discreet	discreet	JJ
18637	16630	25	and	and	CC
18637	16630	26	prudent	prudent	JJ
18637	16630	27	man	man	NN
18637	16630	28	would	would	MD
18637	16630	29	be	be	VB
18637	16630	30	led	lead	VBN
18637	16630	31	to	to	TO
18637	16630	32	believe	believe	VB
18637	16630	33	that	that	IN
18637	16630	34	the	the	DT
18637	16630	35	offense	offense	NN
18637	16630	36	charged	charge	VBD
18637	16630	37	had	have	VBD
18637	16630	38	been	be	VBN
18637	16630	39	committed	commit	VBN
18637	16630	40	.	.	.
18637	16631	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16631	2	25	25	CD
18637	16631	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16631	4	The	the	DT
18637	16631	5	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	16631	6	of	of	IN
18637	16631	7	the	the	DT
18637	16631	8	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	16631	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16631	10	that	that	IN
18637	16631	11	warrants	warrant	NNS
18637	16631	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	16631	13	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	16631	14	describe	describe	VB
18637	16631	15	the	the	DT
18637	16631	16	things	thing	NNS
18637	16631	17	to	to	TO
18637	16631	18	be	be	VB
18637	16631	19	seized	seize	VBN
18637	16631	20	makes	make	VBZ
18637	16631	21	general	general	JJ
18637	16631	22	searches	search	NNS
18637	16631	23	under	under	IN
18637	16631	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16631	25	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	16631	26	and	and	CC
18637	16631	27	prevents	prevent	VBZ
18637	16631	28	the	the	DT
18637	16631	29	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16631	30	of	of	IN
18637	16631	31	one	one	CD
18637	16631	32	thing	thing	NN
18637	16631	33	under	under	IN
18637	16631	34	a	a	DT
18637	16631	35	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16631	36	describing	describe	VBG
18637	16631	37	another	another	DT
18637	16631	38	.	.	.
18637	16632	1	As	as	IN
18637	16632	2	to	to	IN
18637	16632	3	what	what	WP
18637	16632	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	16632	5	to	to	TO
18637	16632	6	be	be	VB
18637	16632	7	taken	take	VBN
18637	16632	8	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	16632	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	16632	10	left	leave	VBN
18637	16632	11	to	to	IN
18637	16632	12	the	the	DT
18637	16632	13	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	16632	14	of	of	IN
18637	16632	15	the	the	DT
18637	16632	16	officer	officer	NN
18637	16632	17	executing	execute	VBG
18637	16632	18	the	the	DT
18637	16632	19	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16632	20	.	.	.
18637	16633	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16633	2	26	26	CD
18637	16633	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16633	4	Private	private	JJ
18637	16633	5	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16633	6	of	of	IN
18637	16633	7	no	no	DT
18637	16633	8	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
18637	16633	9	value	value	NN
18637	16633	10	,	,	,
18637	16633	11	in	in	IN
18637	16633	12	which	which	WDT
18637	16633	13	the	the	DT
18637	16633	14	sole	sole	JJ
18637	16633	15	interest	interest	NN
18637	16633	16	of	of	IN
18637	16633	17	the	the	DT
18637	16633	18	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	16633	19	Government	Government	NNP
18637	16633	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	16633	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16633	22	value	value	NN
18637	16633	23	as	as	IN
18637	16633	24	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16633	25	against	against	IN
18637	16633	26	the	the	DT
18637	16633	27	owner	owner	NN
18637	16633	28	in	in	IN
18637	16633	29	a	a	DT
18637	16633	30	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
18637	16633	31	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16633	32	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	16633	33	,	,	,
18637	16633	34	may	may	MD
18637	16633	35	not	not	RB
18637	16633	36	be	be	VB
18637	16633	37	taken	take	VBN
18637	16633	38	from	from	IN
18637	16633	39	the	the	DT
18637	16633	40	owner	owner	NN
18637	16633	41	's	's	POS
18637	16633	42	house	house	NN
18637	16633	43	or	or	CC
18637	16633	44	office	office	NN
18637	16633	45	under	under	IN
18637	16633	46	a	a	DT
18637	16633	47	search	search	NN
18637	16633	48	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16633	49	.	.	.
18637	16634	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16634	2	27	27	CD
18637	16634	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16634	4	Records	Records	NNPS
18637	16634	5	,	,	,
18637	16634	6	Reports	Reports	NNPS
18637	16634	7	and	and	CC
18637	16634	8	Subpoenas	Subpoenas	NNP
18637	16634	9	Since	since	IN
18637	16634	10	the	the	DT
18637	16634	11	common	common	JJ
18637	16634	12	law	law	NN
18637	16634	13	did	do	VBD
18637	16634	14	not	not	RB
18637	16634	15	countenance	countenance	VB
18637	16634	16	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	16634	17	self	self	NN
18637	16634	18	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	16634	19	,	,	,
18637	16634	20	many	many	JJ
18637	16634	21	years	year	NNS
18637	16634	22	passed	pass	VBN
18637	16634	23	before	before	IN
18637	16634	24	the	the	DT
18637	16634	25	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16634	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16634	27	was	be	VBD
18637	16634	28	called	call	VBN
18637	16634	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	16634	30	to	to	TO
18637	16634	31	interpret	interpret	VB
18637	16634	32	the	the	DT
18637	16634	33	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16634	34	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	16634	35	bearing	bear	VBG
18637	16634	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	16634	37	the	the	DT
18637	16634	38	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	16634	39	against	against	IN
18637	16634	40	such	such	JJ
18637	16634	41	testimonial	testimonial	JJ
18637	16634	42	compulsion	compulsion	NN
18637	16634	43	.	.	.
18637	16635	1	Not	not	RB
18637	16635	2	until	until	IN
18637	16635	3	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
18637	16635	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16635	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	16635	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16635	7	United	United	NNP
18637	16635	8	States[28	States[28	NNP
18637	16635	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16635	10	did	do	VBD
18637	16635	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16635	12	have	have	VB
18637	16635	13	to	to	TO
18637	16635	14	meet	meet	VB
18637	16635	15	the	the	DT
18637	16635	16	issue	issue	NN
18637	16635	17	;	;	:
18637	16635	18	there	there	RB
18637	16635	19	,	,	,
18637	16635	20	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	16635	21	to	to	IN
18637	16635	22	an	an	DT
18637	16635	23	act	act	NN
18637	16635	24	of	of	IN
18637	16635	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16635	26	,	,	,
18637	16635	27	a	a	DT
18637	16635	28	court	court	NN
18637	16635	29	had	have	VBD
18637	16635	30	issued	issue	VBN
18637	16635	31	an	an	DT
18637	16635	32	order	order	NN
18637	16635	33	in	in	IN
18637	16635	34	a	a	DT
18637	16635	35	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	16635	36	for	for	IN
18637	16635	37	the	the	DT
18637	16635	38	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	16635	39	of	of	IN
18637	16635	40	goods	good	NNS
18637	16635	41	for	for	IN
18637	16635	42	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	16635	43	nonpayment	nonpayment	NN
18637	16635	44	of	of	IN
18637	16635	45	customs	custom	NNS
18637	16635	46	duties	duty	NNS
18637	16635	47	,	,	,
18637	16635	48	requiring	require	VBG
18637	16635	49	the	the	DT
18637	16635	50	claimant	claimant	NN
18637	16635	51	to	to	TO
18637	16635	52	produce	produce	VB
18637	16635	53	in	in	IN
18637	16635	54	court	court	NN
18637	16635	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16635	56	invoices	invoice	NNS
18637	16635	57	covering	cover	VBG
18637	16635	58	the	the	DT
18637	16635	59	goods	good	NNS
18637	16635	60	,	,	,
18637	16635	61	on	on	IN
18637	16635	62	pain	pain	NN
18637	16635	63	of	of	IN
18637	16635	64	having	have	VBG
18637	16635	65	the	the	DT
18637	16635	66	allegation	allegation	NN
18637	16635	67	taken	take	VBN
18637	16635	68	as	as	IN
18637	16635	69	confessed	confess	VBN
18637	16635	70	against	against	IN
18637	16635	71	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16635	72	.	.	.
18637	16636	1	The	the	DT
18637	16636	2	order	order	NN
18637	16636	3	and	and	CC
18637	16636	4	the	the	DT
18637	16636	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	16636	6	which	which	WDT
18637	16636	7	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	16636	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16636	9	were	be	VBD
18637	16636	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	16636	11	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	16636	12	in	in	IN
18637	16636	13	a	a	DT
18637	16636	14	notable	notable	JJ
18637	16636	15	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16636	16	by	by	IN
18637	16636	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16636	18	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	16636	19	,	,	,
18637	16636	20	as	as	IN
18637	16636	21	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	16636	22	:	:	:
18637	16636	23	"	"	``
18637	16636	24	Breaking	break	VBG
18637	16636	25	into	into	IN
18637	16636	26	a	a	DT
18637	16636	27	house	house	NN
18637	16636	28	and	and	CC
18637	16636	29	opening	opening	NN
18637	16636	30	boxes	box	NNS
18637	16636	31	and	and	CC
18637	16636	32	drawers	drawer	NNS
18637	16636	33	are	be	VBP
18637	16636	34	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	16636	35	of	of	IN
18637	16636	36	aggravation	aggravation	NN
18637	16636	37	;	;	:
18637	16636	38	but	but	CC
18637	16636	39	any	any	DT
18637	16636	40	forcible	forcible	JJ
18637	16636	41	and	and	CC
18637	16636	42	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	16636	43	extortion	extortion	NN
18637	16636	44	of	of	IN
18637	16636	45	a	a	DT
18637	16636	46	man	man	NN
18637	16636	47	's	's	POS
18637	16636	48	own	own	JJ
18637	16636	49	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	16636	50	or	or	CC
18637	16636	51	of	of	IN
18637	16636	52	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16636	53	private	private	JJ
18637	16636	54	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16636	55	to	to	TO
18637	16636	56	be	be	VB
18637	16636	57	used	use	VBN
18637	16636	58	as	as	IN
18637	16636	59	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16636	60	to	to	TO
18637	16636	61	convict	convict	VB
18637	16636	62	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16636	63	of	of	IN
18637	16636	64	crime	crime	NN
18637	16636	65	or	or	CC
18637	16636	66	to	to	TO
18637	16636	67	forfeit	forfeit	VB
18637	16636	68	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16636	69	goods	good	NNS
18637	16636	70	,	,	,
18637	16636	71	is	be	VBZ
18637	16636	72	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16636	73	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	16636	74	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16636	75	*	*	NFP
18637	16636	76	*	*	NFP
18637	16636	77	*	*	NFP
18637	16636	78	In	in	IN
18637	16636	79	this	this	DT
18637	16636	80	regard	regard	NN
18637	16636	81	the	the	DT
18637	16636	82	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	16636	83	and	and	CC
18637	16636	84	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	16636	85	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	16636	86	run	run	VBP
18637	16636	87	almost	almost	RB
18637	16636	88	into	into	IN
18637	16636	89	each	each	DT
18637	16636	90	other	other	JJ
18637	16636	91	.	.	.
18637	16637	1	"	"	``
18637	16637	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16637	3	29	29	CD
18637	16637	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16637	5	Thus	thus	RB
18637	16637	6	the	the	DT
18637	16637	7	case	case	NN
18637	16637	8	established	establish	VBD
18637	16637	9	three	three	CD
18637	16637	10	propositions	proposition	NNS
18637	16637	11	of	of	IN
18637	16637	12	far	far	RB
18637	16637	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	16637	14	reaching	reach	VBG
18637	16637	15	significance	significance	NN
18637	16637	16	:	:	:
18637	16637	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16637	18	1	1	LS
18637	16637	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16637	20	that	that	IN
18637	16637	21	a	a	DT
18637	16637	22	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	16637	23	production	production	NN
18637	16637	24	of	of	IN
18637	16637	25	the	the	DT
18637	16637	26	private	private	JJ
18637	16637	27	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16637	28	of	of	IN
18637	16637	29	the	the	DT
18637	16637	30	owner	owner	NN
18637	16637	31	in	in	IN
18637	16637	32	such	such	PDT
18637	16637	33	a	a	DT
18637	16637	34	suit	suit	NN
18637	16637	35	was	be	VBD
18637	16637	36	a	a	DT
18637	16637	37	search	search	NN
18637	16637	38	and	and	CC
18637	16637	39	seizure	seizure	VB
18637	16637	40	within	within	IN
18637	16637	41	the	the	DT
18637	16637	42	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	16637	43	of	of	IN
18637	16637	44	the	the	DT
18637	16637	45	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	16637	46	Amendment;[30	Amendment;[30	NNP
18637	16637	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16637	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16637	49	2	2	LS
18637	16637	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16637	51	that	that	IN
18637	16637	52	in	in	IN
18637	16637	53	substance	substance	NN
18637	16637	54	such	such	JJ
18637	16637	55	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16637	56	compelled	compel	VBD
18637	16637	57	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16637	58	to	to	TO
18637	16637	59	be	be	VB
18637	16637	60	a	a	DT
18637	16637	61	witness	witness	NN
18637	16637	62	against	against	IN
18637	16637	63	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16637	64	in	in	IN
18637	16637	65	violation	violation	NN
18637	16637	66	of	of	IN
18637	16637	67	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16637	68	V,[31	V,[31	NNP
18637	16637	69	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16637	70	and	and	CC
18637	16637	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16637	72	3	3	LS
18637	16637	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16637	74	that	that	IN
18637	16637	75	,	,	,
18637	16637	76	because	because	IN
18637	16637	77	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16637	78	was	be	VBD
18637	16637	79	a	a	DT
18637	16637	80	violation	violation	NN
18637	16637	81	of	of	IN
18637	16637	82	the	the	DT
18637	16637	83	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	16637	84	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16637	85	,	,	,
18637	16637	86	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16637	87	was	be	VBD
18637	16637	88	also	also	RB
18637	16637	89	an	an	DT
18637	16637	90	_	_	NNP
18637	16637	91	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	16637	92	_	_	NNP
18637	16637	93	search	search	NN
18637	16637	94	and	and	CC
18637	16637	95	seizure	seizure	VB
18637	16637	96	under	under	IN
18637	16637	97	the	the	DT
18637	16637	98	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	16637	99	.	.	.
18637	16638	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16638	2	32	32	CD
18637	16638	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16638	4	Only	only	RB
18637	16638	5	natural	natural	JJ
18637	16638	6	persons	person	NNS
18637	16638	7	can	can	MD
18637	16638	8	resist	resist	VB
18637	16638	9	the	the	DT
18637	16638	10	subpoena	subpoena	NN
18637	16638	11	of	of	IN
18637	16638	12	private	private	JJ
18637	16638	13	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16638	14	on	on	IN
18637	16638	15	the	the	DT
18637	16638	16	ground	ground	NN
18637	16638	17	of	of	IN
18637	16638	18	self	self	NN
18637	16638	19	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	16638	20	.	.	.
18637	16639	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16639	2	33	33	CD
18637	16639	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16639	4	Even	even	RB
18637	16639	5	an	an	DT
18637	16639	6	individual	individual	NN
18637	16639	7	can	can	MD
18637	16639	8	not	not	RB
18637	16639	9	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	16639	10	to	to	TO
18637	16639	11	produce	produce	VB
18637	16639	12	records	record	NNS
18637	16639	13	which	which	WDT
18637	16639	14	are	be	VBP
18637	16639	15	in	in	IN
18637	16639	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16639	17	custody	custody	NN
18637	16639	18	on	on	IN
18637	16639	19	the	the	DT
18637	16639	20	plea	plea	NN
18637	16639	21	that	that	WDT
18637	16639	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16639	23	might	may	MD
18637	16639	24	incriminate	incriminate	VB
18637	16639	25	the	the	DT
18637	16639	26	owner	owner	NN
18637	16639	27	or	or	CC
18637	16639	28	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16639	29	where	where	WRB
18637	16639	30	the	the	DT
18637	16639	31	documents	document	NNS
18637	16639	32	belong	belong	VBP
18637	16639	33	to	to	IN
18637	16639	34	a	a	DT
18637	16639	35	corporation,[34	corporation,[34	NN
18637	16639	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16639	37	or	or	CC
18637	16639	38	to	to	IN
18637	16639	39	a	a	DT
18637	16639	40	labor	labor	NN
18637	16639	41	union	union	NN
18637	16639	42	.	.	.
18637	16640	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16640	2	35	35	CD
18637	16640	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16640	4	A	a	DT
18637	16640	5	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
18637	16640	6	can	can	MD
18637	16640	7	be	be	VB
18637	16640	8	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	16640	9	to	to	TO
18637	16640	10	turn	turn	VB
18637	16640	11	over	over	RP
18637	16640	12	records	record	NNS
18637	16640	13	which	which	WDT
18637	16640	14	are	be	VBP
18637	16640	15	part	part	NN
18637	16640	16	of	of	IN
18637	16640	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16640	18	estate	estate	NN
18637	16640	19	.	.	.
18637	16641	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16641	2	36	36	CD
18637	16641	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16641	4	Papers	paper	NNS
18637	16641	5	already	already	RB
18637	16641	6	in	in	IN
18637	16641	7	the	the	DT
18637	16641	8	custody	custody	NN
18637	16641	9	of	of	IN
18637	16641	10	a	a	DT
18637	16641	11	United	United	NNP
18637	16641	12	States	States	NNP
18637	16641	13	court	court	NN
18637	16641	14	in	in	IN
18637	16641	15	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	16641	16	of	of	IN
18637	16641	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16641	18	having	have	VBG
18637	16641	19	been	be	VBN
18637	16641	20	used	use	VBN
18637	16641	21	by	by	IN
18637	16641	22	the	the	DT
18637	16641	23	owner	owner	NN
18637	16641	24	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16641	25	as	as	IN
18637	16641	26	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16641	27	on	on	IN
18637	16641	28	another	another	DT
18637	16641	29	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	16641	30	may	may	MD
18637	16641	31	be	be	VB
18637	16641	32	used	use	VBN
18637	16641	33	before	before	IN
18637	16641	34	a	a	DT
18637	16641	35	grand	grand	JJ
18637	16641	36	jury	jury	NN
18637	16641	37	as	as	IN
18637	16641	38	a	a	DT
18637	16641	39	basis	basis	NN
18637	16641	40	for	for	IN
18637	16641	41	an	an	DT
18637	16641	42	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16641	43	for	for	IN
18637	16641	44	perjury	perjury	NN
18637	16641	45	.	.	.
18637	16642	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16642	2	37	37	CD
18637	16642	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16642	4	A	a	DT
18637	16642	5	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	16642	6	may	may	MD
18637	16642	7	challenge	challenge	VB
18637	16642	8	an	an	DT
18637	16642	9	order	order	NN
18637	16642	10	for	for	IN
18637	16642	11	the	the	DT
18637	16642	12	production	production	NN
18637	16642	13	of	of	IN
18637	16642	14	records	record	NNS
18637	16642	15	if	if	IN
18637	16642	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16642	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	16642	18	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	16642	19	on	on	IN
18637	16642	20	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	16642	21	other	other	JJ
18637	16642	22	than	than	IN
18637	16642	23	self	self	NN
18637	16642	24	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	16642	25	,	,	,
18637	16642	26	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	16642	27	,	,	,
18637	16642	28	if	if	IN
18637	16642	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16642	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	16642	31	too	too	RB
18637	16642	32	sweeping,[38	sweeping,[38	CD
18637	16642	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16642	34	if	if	IN
18637	16642	35	the	the	DT
18637	16642	36	information	information	NN
18637	16642	37	sought	seek	VBD
18637	16642	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	16642	39	not	not	RB
18637	16642	40	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	16642	41	to	to	IN
18637	16642	42	any	any	DT
18637	16642	43	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	16642	44	inquiry,[39	inquiry,[39	CD
18637	16642	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16642	46	or	or	CC
18637	16642	47	if	if	IN
18637	16642	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16642	49	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	16642	50	"	"	``
18637	16642	51	a	a	DT
18637	16642	52	fishing	fishing	NN
18637	16642	53	expedition	expedition	NN
18637	16642	54	"	"	''
18637	16642	55	in	in	IN
18637	16642	56	quest	quest	NN
18637	16642	57	of	of	IN
18637	16642	58	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16642	59	of	of	IN
18637	16642	60	crime	crime	NN
18637	16642	61	.	.	.
18637	16643	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16643	2	40	40	CD
18637	16643	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16643	4	In	in	IN
18637	16643	5	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	16643	6	Press	Press	NNP
18637	16643	7	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	16643	8	.	.	.
18637	16644	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16644	2	_	_	NNP
18637	16644	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	16644	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16644	5	Walling,[41	Walling,[41	NNP
18637	16644	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16644	7	the	the	DT
18637	16644	8	question	question	NN
18637	16644	9	of	of	IN
18637	16644	10	the	the	DT
18637	16644	11	protection	protection	NN
18637	16644	12	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	16644	13	by	by	IN
18637	16644	14	the	the	DT
18637	16644	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	16644	16	against	against	IN
18637	16644	17	the	the	DT
18637	16644	18	subpoena	subpoena	NN
18637	16644	19	of	of	IN
18637	16644	20	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	16644	21	records	record	NNS
18637	16644	22	was	be	VBD
18637	16644	23	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
18637	16644	24	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	16644	25	.	.	.
18637	16645	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16645	2	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	16645	3	summarized	summarize	VBD
18637	16645	4	the	the	DT
18637	16645	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16645	6	's	's	POS
18637	16645	7	views	view	NNS
18637	16645	8	in	in	IN
18637	16645	9	the	the	DT
18637	16645	10	following	follow	VBG
18637	16645	11	words	word	NNS
18637	16645	12	:	:	:
18637	16645	13	"	"	``
18637	16645	14	*	*	NFP
18637	16645	15	*	*	NFP
18637	16645	16	*	*	NFP
18637	16645	17	the	the	DT
18637	16645	18	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	16645	19	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16645	20	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	16645	21	no	no	DT
18637	16645	22	protection	protection	NN
18637	16645	23	by	by	IN
18637	16645	24	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	16645	25	of	of	IN
18637	16645	26	the	the	DT
18637	16645	27	self	self	NN
18637	16645	28	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	16645	29	provision	provision	NN
18637	16645	30	,	,	,
18637	16645	31	whether	whether	IN
18637	16645	32	for	for	IN
18637	16645	33	the	the	DT
18637	16645	34	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	16645	35	or	or	CC
18637	16645	36	for	for	IN
18637	16645	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16645	38	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16645	39	;	;	:
18637	16645	40	and	and	CC
18637	16645	41	the	the	DT
18637	16645	42	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	16645	43	,	,	,
18637	16645	44	if	if	IN
18637	16645	45	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	16645	46	,	,	,
18637	16645	47	at	at	IN
18637	16645	48	the	the	DT
18637	16645	49	most	most	JJS
18637	16645	50	guards	guard	NNS
18637	16645	51	against	against	IN
18637	16645	52	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	16645	53	only	only	RB
18637	16645	54	by	by	IN
18637	16645	55	way	way	NN
18637	16645	56	of	of	IN
18637	16645	57	too	too	RB
18637	16645	58	much	much	JJ
18637	16645	59	indefiniteness	indefiniteness	NN
18637	16645	60	or	or	CC
18637	16645	61	breadth	breadth	NN
18637	16645	62	in	in	IN
18637	16645	63	the	the	DT
18637	16645	64	things	thing	NNS
18637	16645	65	required	require	VBN
18637	16645	66	to	to	TO
18637	16645	67	be	be	VB
18637	16645	68	'	'	``
18637	16645	69	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	16645	70	described	describe	VBN
18637	16645	71	,	,	,
18637	16645	72	'	'	''
18637	16645	73	if	if	IN
18637	16645	74	also	also	RB
18637	16645	75	the	the	DT
18637	16645	76	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	16645	77	is	be	VBZ
18637	16645	78	one	one	CD
18637	16645	79	the	the	DT
18637	16645	80	demanding	demand	VBG
18637	16645	81	agency	agency	NN
18637	16645	82	is	be	VBZ
18637	16645	83	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	16645	84	by	by	IN
18637	16645	85	law	law	NN
18637	16645	86	to	to	TO
18637	16645	87	make	make	VB
18637	16645	88	and	and	CC
18637	16645	89	the	the	DT
18637	16645	90	materials	material	NNS
18637	16645	91	specified	specify	VBN
18637	16645	92	are	be	VBP
18637	16645	93	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	16645	94	.	.	.
18637	16646	1	The	the	DT
18637	16646	2	gist	gist	NN
18637	16646	3	of	of	IN
18637	16646	4	the	the	DT
18637	16646	5	protection	protection	NN
18637	16646	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	16646	7	in	in	IN
18637	16646	8	the	the	DT
18637	16646	9	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	16646	10	,	,	,
18637	16646	11	expressed	express	VBN
18637	16646	12	in	in	IN
18637	16646	13	terms	term	NNS
18637	16646	14	,	,	,
18637	16646	15	that	that	IN
18637	16646	16	the	the	DT
18637	16646	17	disclosure	disclosure	NN
18637	16646	18	sought	seek	VBD
18637	16646	19	shall	shall	MD
18637	16646	20	not	not	RB
18637	16646	21	be	be	VB
18637	16646	22	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	16646	23	.	.	.
18637	16647	1	*	*	NFP
18637	16647	2	*	*	NFP
18637	16647	3	*	*	NFP
18637	16647	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16647	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	16647	6	not	not	RB
18637	16647	7	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	16647	8	,	,	,
18637	16647	9	as	as	IN
18637	16647	10	in	in	IN
18637	16647	11	the	the	DT
18637	16647	12	case	case	NN
18637	16647	13	of	of	IN
18637	16647	14	a	a	DT
18637	16647	15	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16647	16	,	,	,
18637	16647	17	that	that	IN
18637	16647	18	a	a	DT
18637	16647	19	specific	specific	JJ
18637	16647	20	charge	charge	NN
18637	16647	21	or	or	CC
18637	16647	22	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	16647	23	of	of	IN
18637	16647	24	violation	violation	NN
18637	16647	25	of	of	IN
18637	16647	26	law	law	NN
18637	16647	27	be	be	VBP
18637	16647	28	pending	pende	VBG
18637	16647	29	or	or	CC
18637	16647	30	that	that	IN
18637	16647	31	the	the	DT
18637	16647	32	order	order	NN
18637	16647	33	be	be	VB
18637	16647	34	made	make	VBN
18637	16647	35	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	16647	36	to	to	IN
18637	16647	37	one	one	CD
18637	16647	38	.	.	.
18637	16648	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16648	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	16648	3	enough	enough	JJ
18637	16648	4	that	that	IN
18637	16648	5	the	the	DT
18637	16648	6	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	16648	7	be	be	VB
18637	16648	8	for	for	IN
18637	16648	9	a	a	DT
18637	16648	10	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	16648	11	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	16648	12	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	16648	13	,	,	,
18637	16648	14	within	within	IN
18637	16648	15	the	the	DT
18637	16648	16	power	power	NN
18637	16648	17	of	of	IN
18637	16648	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16648	19	to	to	TO
18637	16648	20	command	command	VB
18637	16648	21	.	.	.
18637	16649	1	*	*	NFP
18637	16649	2	*	*	NFP
18637	16649	3	*	*	NFP
18637	16649	4	The	the	DT
18637	16649	5	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	16649	6	of	of	IN
18637	16649	7	'	'	``
18637	16649	8	probable	probable	JJ
18637	16649	9	cause	cause	NN
18637	16649	10	,	,	,
18637	16649	11	supported	support	VBN
18637	16649	12	by	by	IN
18637	16649	13	oath	oath	NN
18637	16649	14	or	or	CC
18637	16649	15	affirmation	affirmation	NN
18637	16649	16	,	,	,
18637	16649	17	'	'	''
18637	16649	18	literally	literally	RB
18637	16649	19	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	16649	20	in	in	IN
18637	16649	21	the	the	DT
18637	16649	22	case	case	NN
18637	16649	23	of	of	IN
18637	16649	24	a	a	DT
18637	16649	25	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16649	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	16649	27	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	16649	28	,	,	,
18637	16649	29	in	in	IN
18637	16649	30	that	that	DT
18637	16649	31	of	of	IN
18637	16649	32	an	an	DT
18637	16649	33	order	order	NN
18637	16649	34	for	for	IN
18637	16649	35	production	production	NN
18637	16649	36	,	,	,
18637	16649	37	by	by	IN
18637	16649	38	the	the	DT
18637	16649	39	court	court	NN
18637	16649	40	's	's	POS
18637	16649	41	determination	determination	NN
18637	16649	42	that	that	IN
18637	16649	43	the	the	DT
18637	16649	44	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	16649	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	16649	46	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	16649	47	by	by	IN
18637	16649	48	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16649	49	,	,	,
18637	16649	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	16649	51	for	for	IN
18637	16649	52	a	a	DT
18637	16649	53	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	16649	54	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16649	55	can	can	MD
18637	16649	56	order	order	VB
18637	16649	57	,	,	,
18637	16649	58	and	and	CC
18637	16649	59	the	the	DT
18637	16649	60	documents	document	NNS
18637	16649	61	sought	seek	VBN
18637	16649	62	are	be	VBP
18637	16649	63	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	16649	64	to	to	IN
18637	16649	65	the	the	DT
18637	16649	66	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	16649	67	.	.	.
18637	16650	1	Beyond	beyond	IN
18637	16650	2	this	this	DT
18637	16650	3	the	the	DT
18637	16650	4	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	16650	5	of	of	IN
18637	16650	6	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	16650	7	,	,	,
18637	16650	8	including	include	VBG
18637	16650	9	particularity	particularity	NN
18637	16650	10	in	in	IN
18637	16650	11	'	'	''
18637	16650	12	describing	describe	VBG
18637	16650	13	the	the	DT
18637	16650	14	place	place	NN
18637	16650	15	to	to	TO
18637	16650	16	be	be	VB
18637	16650	17	searched	search	VBN
18637	16650	18	,	,	,
18637	16650	19	and	and	CC
18637	16650	20	the	the	DT
18637	16650	21	persons	person	NNS
18637	16650	22	or	or	CC
18637	16650	23	things	thing	NNS
18637	16650	24	to	to	TO
18637	16650	25	be	be	VB
18637	16650	26	seized	seize	VBN
18637	16650	27	,	,	,
18637	16650	28	'	'	''
18637	16650	29	also	also	RB
18637	16650	30	literally	literally	RB
18637	16650	31	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	16650	32	to	to	TO
18637	16650	33	warrant	warrant	VB
18637	16650	34	,	,	,
18637	16650	35	comes	come	VBZ
18637	16650	36	down	down	RP
18637	16650	37	to	to	IN
18637	16650	38	specification	specification	NN
18637	16650	39	of	of	IN
18637	16650	40	the	the	DT
18637	16650	41	documents	document	NNS
18637	16650	42	to	to	TO
18637	16650	43	be	be	VB
18637	16650	44	produced	produce	VBN
18637	16650	45	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	16650	46	,	,	,
18637	16650	47	but	but	CC
18637	16650	48	not	not	RB
18637	16650	49	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	16650	50	,	,	,
18637	16650	51	for	for	IN
18637	16650	52	the	the	DT
18637	16650	53	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	16650	54	of	of	IN
18637	16650	55	the	the	DT
18637	16650	56	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	16650	57	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	16650	58	.	.	.
18637	16651	1	"	"	``
18637	16651	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16651	3	42	42	CD
18637	16651	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16651	5	As	as	IN
18637	16651	6	a	a	DT
18637	16651	7	means	means	NN
18637	16651	8	of	of	IN
18637	16651	9	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	16651	10	a	a	DT
18637	16651	11	valid	valid	JJ
18637	16651	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	16651	13	,	,	,
18637	16651	14	the	the	DT
18637	16651	15	Government	Government	NNP
18637	16651	16	may	may	MD
18637	16651	17	require	require	VB
18637	16651	18	any	any	DT
18637	16651	19	person	person	NN
18637	16651	20	subject	subject	JJ
18637	16651	21	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	16651	22	"	"	''
18637	16651	23	to	to	TO
18637	16651	24	keep	keep	VB
18637	16651	25	a	a	DT
18637	16651	26	record	record	NN
18637	16651	27	showing	show	VBG
18637	16651	28	whether	whether	IN
18637	16651	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16651	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	16651	31	in	in	IN
18637	16651	32	fact	fact	NN
18637	16651	33	complied	comply	VBN
18637	16651	34	with	with	IN
18637	16651	35	it,"[43	it,"[43	NNP
18637	16651	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16651	37	and	and	CC
18637	16651	38	to	to	TO
18637	16651	39	submit	submit	VB
18637	16651	40	that	that	DT
18637	16651	41	record	record	NN
18637	16651	42	to	to	IN
18637	16651	43	inspection	inspection	NN
18637	16651	44	by	by	IN
18637	16651	45	government	government	NN
18637	16651	46	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16651	47	.	.	.
18637	16652	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16652	2	44	44	CD
18637	16652	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16652	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16652	5	may	may	MD
18637	16652	6	also	also	RB
18637	16652	7	compel	compel	VB
18637	16652	8	the	the	DT
18637	16652	9	filing	filing	NN
18637	16652	10	of	of	IN
18637	16652	11	returns	return	NNS
18637	16652	12	disclosing	disclose	VBG
18637	16652	13	the	the	DT
18637	16652	14	amount	amount	NN
18637	16652	15	of	of	IN
18637	16652	16	tax	tax	NN
18637	16652	17	liability,[45	liability,[45	CD
18637	16652	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16652	19	and	and	CC
18637	16652	20	of	of	IN
18637	16652	21	reports	report	NNS
18637	16652	22	under	under	IN
18637	16652	23	oath	oath	NN
18637	16652	24	showing	show	VBG
18637	16652	25	instances	instance	NNS
18637	16652	26	where	where	WRB
18637	16652	27	employees	employee	NNS
18637	16652	28	have	have	VBP
18637	16652	29	worked	work	VBN
18637	16652	30	in	in	IN
18637	16652	31	excess	excess	NN
18637	16652	32	of	of	IN
18637	16652	33	hours	hour	NNS
18637	16652	34	of	of	IN
18637	16652	35	labor	labor	NN
18637	16652	36	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	16652	37	by	by	IN
18637	16652	38	law	law	NN
18637	16652	39	.	.	.
18637	16653	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16653	2	46	46	CD
18637	16653	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16653	4	Without	without	IN
18637	16653	5	violating	violate	VBG
18637	16653	6	either	either	CC
18637	16653	7	the	the	DT
18637	16653	8	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	16653	9	or	or	CC
18637	16653	10	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	16653	11	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	16653	12	,	,	,
18637	16653	13	a	a	DT
18637	16653	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16653	15	decree	decree	NN
18637	16653	16	enjoining	enjoin	VBG
18637	16653	17	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	16653	18	practices	practice	NNS
18637	16653	19	under	under	IN
18637	16653	20	the	the	DT
18637	16653	21	Antitrust	Antitrust	NNP
18637	16653	22	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16653	23	may	may	MD
18637	16653	24	provide	provide	VB
18637	16653	25	that	that	IN
18637	16653	26	the	the	DT
18637	16653	27	Department	Department	NNP
18637	16653	28	of	of	IN
18637	16653	29	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16653	30	shall	shall	MD
18637	16653	31	be	be	VB
18637	16653	32	given	give	VBN
18637	16653	33	access	access	NN
18637	16653	34	to	to	IN
18637	16653	35	all	all	DT
18637	16653	36	records	record	NNS
18637	16653	37	and	and	CC
18637	16653	38	documents	document	NNS
18637	16653	39	of	of	IN
18637	16653	40	the	the	DT
18637	16653	41	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	16653	42	relating	relate	VBG
18637	16653	43	to	to	IN
18637	16653	44	the	the	DT
18637	16653	45	matter	matter	NN
18637	16653	46	covered	cover	VBN
18637	16653	47	by	by	IN
18637	16653	48	the	the	DT
18637	16653	49	decree	decree	NN
18637	16653	50	.	.	.
18637	16654	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16654	2	47	47	CD
18637	16654	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16654	4	The	the	DT
18637	16654	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16654	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16654	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	16654	8	intimated	intimate	VBN
18637	16654	9	,	,	,
18637	16654	10	however	however	RB
18637	16654	11	,	,	,
18637	16654	12	that	that	IN
18637	16654	13	record	record	NN
18637	16654	14	keeping	keeping	NN
18637	16654	15	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	16654	16	must	must	MD
18637	16654	17	be	be	VB
18637	16654	18	limited	limit	VBN
18637	16654	19	to	to	IN
18637	16654	20	data	datum	NNS
18637	16654	21	which	which	WDT
18637	16654	22	are	be	VBP
18637	16654	23	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	16654	24	to	to	IN
18637	16654	25	the	the	DT
18637	16654	26	effective	effective	JJ
18637	16654	27	administration	administration	NN
18637	16654	28	of	of	IN
18637	16654	29	the	the	DT
18637	16654	30	law	law	NN
18637	16654	31	.	.	.
18637	16655	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16655	2	48	48	CD
18637	16655	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16655	4	Search	Search	NNP
18637	16655	5	and	and	CC
18637	16655	6	Seizure	seizure	VB
18637	16655	7	Incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	16655	8	to	to	TO
18637	16655	9	Arrest	arrest	VB
18637	16655	10	The	the	DT
18637	16655	11	right	right	NN
18637	16655	12	to	to	TO
18637	16655	13	search	search	VB
18637	16655	14	the	the	DT
18637	16655	15	person	person	NN
18637	16655	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	16655	17	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16655	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	16655	19	long	long	RB
18637	16655	20	been	be	VBN
18637	16655	21	recognized[49	recognized[49	NN
18637	16655	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16655	23	but	but	CC
18637	16655	24	authority	authority	NN
18637	16655	25	to	to	TO
18637	16655	26	search	search	VB
18637	16655	27	the	the	DT
18637	16655	28	premises	premise	NNS
18637	16655	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	16655	30	which	which	WDT
18637	16655	31	the	the	DT
18637	16655	32	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16655	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	16655	34	made	make	VBN
18637	16655	35	has	have	VBZ
18637	16655	36	been	be	VBN
18637	16655	37	approved	approve	VBN
18637	16655	38	only	only	RB
18637	16655	39	in	in	IN
18637	16655	40	recent	recent	JJ
18637	16655	41	years	year	NNS
18637	16655	42	.	.	.
18637	16656	1	In	in	IN
18637	16656	2	Agnello	Agnello	NNP
18637	16656	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16656	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	16656	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16656	6	United	United	NNP
18637	16656	7	States,[50	States,[50	NNP
18637	16656	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16656	9	the	the	DT
18637	16656	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16656	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16656	12	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	16656	13	that	that	DT
18637	16656	14	:	:	:
18637	16656	15	"	"	``
18637	16656	16	The	the	DT
18637	16656	17	right	right	NN
18637	16656	18	without	without	IN
18637	16656	19	a	a	DT
18637	16656	20	search	search	NN
18637	16656	21	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16656	22	contemporaneously	contemporaneously	RB
18637	16656	23	to	to	TO
18637	16656	24	search	search	VB
18637	16656	25	persons	person	NNS
18637	16656	26	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	16656	27	arrested	arrest	VBN
18637	16656	28	while	while	IN
18637	16656	29	committing	commit	VBG
18637	16656	30	crime	crime	NN
18637	16656	31	and	and	CC
18637	16656	32	to	to	TO
18637	16656	33	search	search	VB
18637	16656	34	the	the	DT
18637	16656	35	place	place	NN
18637	16656	36	where	where	WRB
18637	16656	37	the	the	DT
18637	16656	38	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16656	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	16656	40	made	make	VBN
18637	16656	41	in	in	IN
18637	16656	42	order	order	NN
18637	16656	43	to	to	TO
18637	16656	44	find	find	VB
18637	16656	45	and	and	CC
18637	16656	46	seize	seize	VB
18637	16656	47	things	thing	NNS
18637	16656	48	connected	connect	VBN
18637	16656	49	with	with	IN
18637	16656	50	the	the	DT
18637	16656	51	crime	crime	NN
18637	16656	52	as	as	IN
18637	16656	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16656	54	fruits	fruit	NNS
18637	16656	55	or	or	CC
18637	16656	56	as	as	IN
18637	16656	57	the	the	DT
18637	16656	58	means	mean	NNS
18637	16656	59	by	by	IN
18637	16656	60	which	which	WDT
18637	16656	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16656	62	was	be	VBD
18637	16656	63	committed	commit	VBN
18637	16656	64	,	,	,
18637	16656	65	as	as	RB
18637	16656	66	well	well	RB
18637	16656	67	as	as	IN
18637	16656	68	weapons	weapon	NNS
18637	16656	69	and	and	CC
18637	16656	70	other	other	JJ
18637	16656	71	things	thing	NNS
18637	16656	72	to	to	TO
18637	16656	73	effect	effect	VB
18637	16656	74	an	an	DT
18637	16656	75	escape	escape	NN
18637	16656	76	from	from	IN
18637	16656	77	custody	custody	NN
18637	16656	78	,	,	,
18637	16656	79	is	be	VBZ
18637	16656	80	not	not	RB
18637	16656	81	to	to	TO
18637	16656	82	be	be	VB
18637	16656	83	doubted	doubt	VBN
18637	16656	84	.	.	.
18637	16657	1	"	"	``
18637	16657	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16657	3	51	51	CD
18637	16657	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16657	5	Books	book	NNS
18637	16657	6	and	and	CC
18637	16657	7	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16657	8	used	use	VBN
18637	16657	9	to	to	TO
18637	16657	10	carry	carry	VB
18637	16657	11	on	on	RP
18637	16657	12	a	a	DT
18637	16657	13	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16657	14	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	16657	15	,	,	,
18637	16657	16	which	which	WDT
18637	16657	17	are	be	VBP
18637	16657	18	in	in	IN
18637	16657	19	the	the	DT
18637	16657	20	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	16657	21	possession	possession	NN
18637	16657	22	and	and	CC
18637	16657	23	control	control	NN
18637	16657	24	of	of	IN
18637	16657	25	a	a	DT
18637	16657	26	person	person	NN
18637	16657	27	arrested	arrest	VBN
18637	16657	28	for	for	IN
18637	16657	29	commission	commission	NN
18637	16657	30	of	of	IN
18637	16657	31	an	an	DT
18637	16657	32	offense	offense	NN
18637	16657	33	in	in	IN
18637	16657	34	the	the	DT
18637	16657	35	presence	presence	NN
18637	16657	36	of	of	IN
18637	16657	37	the	the	DT
18637	16657	38	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16657	39	may	may	MD
18637	16657	40	be	be	VB
18637	16657	41	seized	seize	VBN
18637	16657	42	when	when	WRB
18637	16657	43	discovered	discover	VBN
18637	16657	44	in	in	IN
18637	16657	45	plain	plain	JJ
18637	16657	46	view	view	NN
18637	16657	47	during	during	IN
18637	16657	48	a	a	DT
18637	16657	49	search	search	NN
18637	16657	50	of	of	IN
18637	16657	51	the	the	DT
18637	16657	52	premises	premise	NNS
18637	16657	53	following	follow	VBG
18637	16657	54	the	the	DT
18637	16657	55	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16657	56	.	.	.
18637	16658	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16658	2	52	52	CD
18637	16658	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16658	4	The	the	DT
18637	16658	5	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	16658	6	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16658	7	of	of	IN
18637	16658	8	persons	person	NNS
18637	16658	9	at	at	IN
18637	16658	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16658	11	place	place	NN
18637	16658	12	of	of	IN
18637	16658	13	business	business	NN
18637	16658	14	does	do	VBZ
18637	16658	15	not	not	RB
18637	16658	16	justify	justify	VB
18637	16658	17	a	a	DT
18637	16658	18	search	search	NN
18637	16658	19	of	of	IN
18637	16658	20	desks	desk	NNS
18637	16658	21	and	and	CC
18637	16658	22	files	file	NNS
18637	16658	23	in	in	IN
18637	16658	24	the	the	DT
18637	16658	25	offices	office	NNS
18637	16658	26	where	where	WRB
18637	16658	27	the	the	DT
18637	16658	28	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16658	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	16658	30	made	make	VBN
18637	16658	31	and	and	CC
18637	16658	32	seizure	seizure	VB
18637	16658	33	of	of	IN
18637	16658	34	private	private	JJ
18637	16658	35	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16658	36	found	find	VBD
18637	16658	37	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	16658	38	.	.	.
18637	16659	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16659	2	53	53	CD
18637	16659	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16659	4	A	a	DT
18637	16659	5	search	search	NN
18637	16659	6	which	which	WDT
18637	16659	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	16659	8	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	16659	9	undertaken	undertake	VBN
18637	16659	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	16659	11	not	not	RB
18637	16659	12	made	make	VBN
18637	16659	13	valid	valid	JJ
18637	16659	14	by	by	IN
18637	16659	15	the	the	DT
18637	16659	16	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16659	17	of	of	IN
18637	16659	18	crime	crime	NN
18637	16659	19	which	which	WDT
18637	16659	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16659	21	brings	bring	VBZ
18637	16659	22	to	to	IN
18637	16659	23	light	light	NN
18637	16659	24	.	.	.
18637	16660	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16660	2	54	54	CD
18637	16660	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16660	4	By	by	IN
18637	16660	5	a	a	DT
18637	16660	6	five	five	CD
18637	16660	7	to	to	TO
18637	16660	8	four	four	CD
18637	16660	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	16660	10	in	in	IN
18637	16660	11	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	16660	12	_	_	NNP
18637	16660	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	16660	14	_	_	NNP
18637	16660	15	United	United	NNP
18637	16660	16	States[55	States[55	NNP
18637	16660	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16660	18	the	the	DT
18637	16660	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16660	20	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	16660	21	,	,	,
18637	16660	22	as	as	IN
18637	16660	23	an	an	DT
18637	16660	24	incident	incident	NN
18637	16660	25	to	to	IN
18637	16660	26	a	a	DT
18637	16660	27	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	16660	28	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16660	29	,	,	,
18637	16660	30	a	a	DT
18637	16660	31	five	five	CD
18637	16660	32	hour	hour	NN
18637	16660	33	search	search	NN
18637	16660	34	by	by	IN
18637	16660	35	four	four	CD
18637	16660	36	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16660	37	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16660	38	of	of	IN
18637	16660	39	every	every	DT
18637	16660	40	nook	nook	NNP
18637	16660	41	and	and	CC
18637	16660	42	cranny	cranny	NN
18637	16660	43	of	of	IN
18637	16660	44	a	a	DT
18637	16660	45	four	four	CD
18637	16660	46	-	-	HYPH
18637	16660	47	room	room	NN
18637	16660	48	apartment	apartment	NN
18637	16660	49	.	.	.
18637	16661	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16661	2	also	also	RB
18637	16661	3	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	16661	4	the	the	DT
18637	16661	5	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16661	6	of	of	IN
18637	16661	7	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16661	8	unrelated	unrelated	JJ
18637	16661	9	to	to	IN
18637	16661	10	the	the	DT
18637	16661	11	crime	crime	NN
18637	16661	12	for	for	IN
18637	16661	13	which	which	WDT
18637	16661	14	the	the	DT
18637	16661	15	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16661	16	was	be	VBD
18637	16661	17	made	make	VBN
18637	16661	18	,	,	,
18637	16661	19	namely	namely	RB
18637	16661	20	,	,	,
18637	16661	21	Selective	Selective	NNP
18637	16661	22	Service	Service	NNP
18637	16661	23	Registration	Registration	NNP
18637	16661	24	cards	card	NNS
18637	16661	25	which	which	WDT
18637	16661	26	were	be	VBD
18637	16661	27	discovered	discover	VBN
18637	16661	28	in	in	IN
18637	16661	29	a	a	DT
18637	16661	30	sealed	seal	VBN
18637	16661	31	envelope	envelope	NN
18637	16661	32	in	in	IN
18637	16661	33	the	the	DT
18637	16661	34	bottom	bottom	NN
18637	16661	35	of	of	IN
18637	16661	36	a	a	DT
18637	16661	37	bureau	bureau	NN
18637	16661	38	drawer	drawer	NN
18637	16661	39	.	.	.
18637	16662	1	In	in	IN
18637	16662	2	justification	justification	NN
18637	16662	3	of	of	IN
18637	16662	4	this	this	DT
18637	16662	5	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	16662	6	,	,	,
18637	16662	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	16662	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16662	9	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	16662	10	wrote	write	VBD
18637	16662	11	:	:	:
18637	16662	12	"	"	``
18637	16662	13	Here	here	RB
18637	16662	14	the	the	DT
18637	16662	15	agents	agent	NNS
18637	16662	16	entered	enter	VBD
18637	16662	17	the	the	DT
18637	16662	18	apartment	apartment	NN
18637	16662	19	under	under	IN
18637	16662	20	the	the	DT
18637	16662	21	authority	authority	NN
18637	16662	22	of	of	IN
18637	16662	23	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	16662	24	warrants	warrant	NNS
18637	16662	25	of	of	IN
18637	16662	26	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16662	27	.	.	.
18637	16663	1	Neither	neither	DT
18637	16663	2	was	be	VBD
18637	16663	3	the	the	DT
18637	16663	4	entry	entry	NN
18637	16663	5	tortious	tortious	JJ
18637	16663	6	nor	nor	CC
18637	16663	7	was	be	VBD
18637	16663	8	the	the	DT
18637	16663	9	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16663	10	which	which	WDT
18637	16663	11	followed	follow	VBD
18637	16663	12	in	in	IN
18637	16663	13	any	any	DT
18637	16663	14	sense	sense	NN
18637	16663	15	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	16663	16	.	.	.
18637	16664	1	*	*	NFP
18637	16664	2	*	*	NFP
18637	16664	3	*	*	NFP
18637	16664	4	The	the	DT
18637	16664	5	search	search	NN
18637	16664	6	was	be	VBD
18637	16664	7	not	not	RB
18637	16664	8	a	a	DT
18637	16664	9	general	general	JJ
18637	16664	10	exploration	exploration	NN
18637	16664	11	but	but	CC
18637	16664	12	was	be	VBD
18637	16664	13	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	16664	14	directed	direct	VBN
18637	16664	15	to	to	IN
18637	16664	16	the	the	DT
18637	16664	17	means	mean	NNS
18637	16664	18	and	and	CC
18637	16664	19	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	16664	20	by	by	IN
18637	16664	21	which	which	WDT
18637	16664	22	the	the	DT
18637	16664	23	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	16664	24	charged	charge	VBN
18637	16664	25	had	have	VBD
18637	16664	26	been	be	VBN
18637	16664	27	committed	commit	VBN
18637	16664	28	,	,	,
18637	16664	29	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	16664	30	the	the	DT
18637	16664	31	two	two	CD
18637	16664	32	canceled	cancel	VBN
18637	16664	33	checks	check	NNS
18637	16664	34	of	of	IN
18637	16664	35	the	the	DT
18637	16664	36	Mudge	Mudge	NNP
18637	16664	37	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	16664	38	Company	Company	NNP
18637	16664	39	.	.	.
18637	16665	1	*	*	NFP
18637	16665	2	*	*	NFP
18637	16665	3	*	*	NFP
18637	16665	4	If	if	IN
18637	16665	5	entry	entry	NN
18637	16665	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	16665	7	the	the	DT
18637	16665	8	premises	premise	NNS
18637	16665	9	be	be	VB
18637	16665	10	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	16665	11	and	and	CC
18637	16665	12	the	the	DT
18637	16665	13	search	search	NN
18637	16665	14	which	which	WDT
18637	16665	15	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	16665	16	be	be	VB
18637	16665	17	valid	valid	JJ
18637	16665	18	,	,	,
18637	16665	19	there	there	EX
18637	16665	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	16665	21	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	16665	22	in	in	IN
18637	16665	23	the	the	DT
18637	16665	24	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	16665	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16665	26	which	which	WDT
18637	16665	27	inhibits	inhibit	VBZ
18637	16665	28	the	the	DT
18637	16665	29	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16665	30	by	by	IN
18637	16665	31	law	law	NN
18637	16665	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	16665	33	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	16665	34	agents	agent	NNS
18637	16665	35	of	of	IN
18637	16665	36	government	government	NN
18637	16665	37	property	property	VB
18637	16665	38	the	the	DT
18637	16665	39	possession	possession	NN
18637	16665	40	of	of	IN
18637	16665	41	which	which	WDT
18637	16665	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	16665	43	a	a	DT
18637	16665	44	crime	crime	NN
18637	16665	45	,	,	,
18637	16665	46	even	even	RB
18637	16665	47	though	though	IN
18637	16665	48	the	the	DT
18637	16665	49	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16665	50	are	be	VBP
18637	16665	51	not	not	RB
18637	16665	52	aware	aware	JJ
18637	16665	53	that	that	IN
18637	16665	54	such	such	JJ
18637	16665	55	property	property	NN
18637	16665	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	16665	57	on	on	IN
18637	16665	58	the	the	DT
18637	16665	59	premises	premise	NNS
18637	16665	60	when	when	WRB
18637	16665	61	the	the	DT
18637	16665	62	search	search	NN
18637	16665	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	16665	64	initiated	initiate	VBN
18637	16665	65	.	.	.
18637	16666	1	"	"	``
18637	16666	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16666	3	56	56	CD
18637	16666	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16666	5	In	in	IN
18637	16666	6	a	a	DT
18637	16666	7	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	16666	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16666	9	in	in	IN
18637	16666	10	which	which	WDT
18637	16666	11	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	16666	12	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	16666	13	and	and	CC
18637	16666	14	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	16666	15	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	16666	16	,	,	,
18637	16666	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16666	18	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	16666	19	challenged	challenge	VBD
18637	16666	20	the	the	DT
18637	16666	21	major	major	JJ
18637	16666	22	premises	premise	NNS
18637	16666	23	announced	announce	VBN
18637	16666	24	by	by	IN
18637	16666	25	the	the	DT
18637	16666	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16666	27	.	.	.
18637	16667	1	"	"	``
18637	16667	2	To	to	TO
18637	16667	3	derive	derive	VB
18637	16667	4	from	from	IN
18637	16667	5	the	the	DT
18637	16667	6	common	common	JJ
18637	16667	7	law	law	NN
18637	16667	8	right	right	RB
18637	16667	9	to	to	TO
18637	16667	10	search	search	VB
18637	16667	11	the	the	DT
18637	16667	12	person	person	NN
18637	16667	13	as	as	IN
18637	16667	14	an	an	DT
18637	16667	15	incident	incident	NN
18637	16667	16	of	of	IN
18637	16667	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16667	18	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16667	19	the	the	DT
18637	16667	20	right	right	NN
18637	16667	21	of	of	IN
18637	16667	22	indiscriminate	indiscriminate	NN
18637	16667	23	search	search	NN
18637	16667	24	of	of	IN
18637	16667	25	all	all	PDT
18637	16667	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16667	27	belongings	belonging	NNS
18637	16667	28	,	,	,
18637	16667	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	16667	30	to	to	TO
18637	16667	31	disregard	disregard	VB
18637	16667	32	the	the	DT
18637	16667	33	fact	fact	NN
18637	16667	34	that	that	IN
18637	16667	35	the	the	DT
18637	16667	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	16667	37	protects	protect	VBZ
18637	16667	38	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16667	39	against	against	IN
18637	16667	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16667	41	both	both	CC
18637	16667	42	unauthorized	unauthorized	JJ
18637	16667	43	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16667	44	and	and	CC
18637	16667	45	unauthorized	unauthorized	JJ
18637	16667	46	search	search	NN
18637	16667	47	.	.	.
18637	16668	1	Authority	authority	NN
18637	16668	2	to	to	TO
18637	16668	3	arrest	arrest	VB
18637	16668	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	16668	5	not	not	RB
18637	16668	6	dispense	dispense	VB
18637	16668	7	with	with	IN
18637	16668	8	the	the	DT
18637	16668	9	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	16668	10	of	of	IN
18637	16668	11	authority	authority	NN
18637	16668	12	to	to	TO
18637	16668	13	search	search	VB
18637	16668	14	.	.	.
18637	16669	1	*	*	NFP
18637	16669	2	*	*	NFP
18637	16669	3	*	*	NFP
18637	16669	4	But	but	CC
18637	16669	5	even	even	RB
18637	16669	6	if	if	IN
18637	16669	7	the	the	DT
18637	16669	8	search	search	NN
18637	16669	9	was	be	VBD
18637	16669	10	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	16669	11	,	,	,
18637	16669	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16669	13	does	do	VBZ
18637	16669	14	not	not	RB
18637	16669	15	follow	follow	VB
18637	16669	16	that	that	IN
18637	16669	17	the	the	DT
18637	16669	18	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16669	19	was	be	VBD
18637	16669	20	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	16669	21	.	.	.
18637	16670	1	If	if	IN
18637	16670	2	the	the	DT
18637	16670	3	agents	agent	NNS
18637	16670	4	had	have	VBD
18637	16670	5	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	16670	6	a	a	DT
18637	16670	7	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16670	8	to	to	TO
18637	16670	9	look	look	VB
18637	16670	10	for	for	IN
18637	16670	11	the	the	DT
18637	16670	12	canceled	cancel	VBN
18637	16670	13	checks	check	NNS
18637	16670	14	,	,	,
18637	16670	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16670	16	would	would	MD
18637	16670	17	not	not	RB
18637	16670	18	be	be	VB
18637	16670	19	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	16670	20	to	to	TO
18637	16670	21	seize	seize	VB
18637	16670	22	other	other	JJ
18637	16670	23	items	item	NNS
18637	16670	24	discovered	discover	VBN
18637	16670	25	in	in	IN
18637	16670	26	the	the	DT
18637	16670	27	process	process	NN
18637	16670	28	.	.	.
18637	16671	1	*	*	NFP
18637	16671	2	*	*	NFP
18637	16671	3	*	*	NFP
18637	16671	4	The	the	DT
18637	16671	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16671	6	's	's	POS
18637	16671	7	decision	decision	NN
18637	16671	8	achieves	achieve	VBZ
18637	16671	9	the	the	DT
18637	16671	10	novel	novel	NN
18637	16671	11	and	and	CC
18637	16671	12	startling	startling	JJ
18637	16671	13	result	result	NN
18637	16671	14	of	of	IN
18637	16671	15	making	make	VBG
18637	16671	16	the	the	DT
18637	16671	17	scope	scope	NN
18637	16671	18	of	of	IN
18637	16671	19	search	search	NN
18637	16671	20	without	without	IN
18637	16671	21	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16671	22	broader	broad	JJR
18637	16671	23	than	than	IN
18637	16671	24	an	an	DT
18637	16671	25	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	16671	26	search	search	NN
18637	16671	27	.	.	.
18637	16672	1	"	"	``
18637	16672	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16672	3	57	57	CD
18637	16672	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16672	5	A	a	DT
18637	16672	6	more	more	RBR
18637	16672	7	limited	limited	JJ
18637	16672	8	search	search	NN
18637	16672	9	in	in	IN
18637	16672	10	connection	connection	NN
18637	16672	11	with	with	IN
18637	16672	12	an	an	DT
18637	16672	13	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16672	14	was	be	VBD
18637	16672	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	16672	16	valid	valid	JJ
18637	16672	17	in	in	IN
18637	16672	18	United	United	NNP
18637	16672	19	States	States	NNP
18637	16672	20	_	_	NNP
18637	16672	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	16672	22	_	_	NNP
18637	16672	23	Rabinowitz	Rabinowitz	NNP
18637	16672	24	.	.	.
18637	16673	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16673	2	58	58	CD
18637	16673	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16673	4	In	in	IN
18637	16673	5	that	that	DT
18637	16673	6	case	case	NN
18637	16673	7	,	,	,
18637	16673	8	government	government	NN
18637	16673	9	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16673	10	,	,	,
18637	16673	11	armed	arm	VBN
18637	16673	12	with	with	IN
18637	16673	13	a	a	DT
18637	16673	14	valid	valid	JJ
18637	16673	15	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16673	16	for	for	IN
18637	16673	17	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16673	18	,	,	,
18637	16673	19	had	have	VBD
18637	16673	20	arrested	arrest	VBN
18637	16673	21	respondent	respondent	NN
18637	16673	22	in	in	IN
18637	16673	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16673	24	one	one	CD
18637	16673	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	16673	26	room	room	NN
18637	16673	27	office	office	NN
18637	16673	28	which	which	WDT
18637	16673	29	was	be	VBD
18637	16673	30	open	open	JJ
18637	16673	31	to	to	IN
18637	16673	32	the	the	DT
18637	16673	33	public	public	NN
18637	16673	34	.	.	.
18637	16674	1	Thereupon	thereupon	RB
18637	16674	2	,	,	,
18637	16674	3	over	over	IN
18637	16674	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16674	5	objection	objection	NN
18637	16674	6	,	,	,
18637	16674	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16674	8	searched	search	VBD
18637	16674	9	the	the	DT
18637	16674	10	desk	desk	NN
18637	16674	11	,	,	,
18637	16674	12	safe	safe	JJ
18637	16674	13	and	and	CC
18637	16674	14	file	file	NN
18637	16674	15	cabinets	cabinet	NNS
18637	16674	16	in	in	IN
18637	16674	17	the	the	DT
18637	16674	18	office	office	NN
18637	16674	19	for	for	IN
18637	16674	20	about	about	RB
18637	16674	21	an	an	DT
18637	16674	22	hour	hour	NN
18637	16674	23	and	and	CC
18637	16674	24	a	a	DT
18637	16674	25	half	half	NN
18637	16674	26	and	and	CC
18637	16674	27	seized	seize	VBD
18637	16674	28	573	573	CD
18637	16674	29	forged	forge	VBN
18637	16674	30	and	and	CC
18637	16674	31	altered	alter	VBN
18637	16674	32	stamps	stamp	NNS
18637	16674	33	.	.	.
18637	16675	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16675	2	Minton	Minton	NNP
18637	16675	3	assigned	assign	VBD
18637	16675	4	five	five	CD
18637	16675	5	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	16675	6	for	for	IN
18637	16675	7	holding	hold	VBG
18637	16675	8	that	that	IN
18637	16675	9	the	the	DT
18637	16675	10	search	search	NN
18637	16675	11	and	and	CC
18637	16675	12	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16675	13	was	be	VBD
18637	16675	14	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	16675	15	:	:	:
18637	16675	16	"	"	''
18637	16675	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16675	18	1	1	LS
18637	16675	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16675	20	the	the	DT
18637	16675	21	search	search	NN
18637	16675	22	and	and	CC
18637	16675	23	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16675	24	were	be	VBD
18637	16675	25	incident	incident	NN
18637	16675	26	to	to	IN
18637	16675	27	a	a	DT
18637	16675	28	valid	valid	JJ
18637	16675	29	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16675	30	;	;	,
18637	16675	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16675	32	2	2	LS
18637	16675	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16675	34	the	the	DT
18637	16675	35	place	place	NN
18637	16675	36	of	of	IN
18637	16675	37	the	the	DT
18637	16675	38	search	search	NN
18637	16675	39	was	be	VBD
18637	16675	40	a	a	DT
18637	16675	41	business	business	NN
18637	16675	42	room	room	NN
18637	16675	43	to	to	TO
18637	16675	44	which	which	WDT
18637	16675	45	the	the	DT
18637	16675	46	public	public	NN
18637	16675	47	,	,	,
18637	16675	48	including	include	VBG
18637	16675	49	the	the	DT
18637	16675	50	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16675	51	,	,	,
18637	16675	52	was	be	VBD
18637	16675	53	invited	invite	VBN
18637	16675	54	;	;	:
18637	16675	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16675	56	3	3	LS
18637	16675	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16675	58	the	the	DT
18637	16675	59	room	room	NN
18637	16675	60	was	be	VBD
18637	16675	61	small	small	JJ
18637	16675	62	and	and	CC
18637	16675	63	under	under	IN
18637	16675	64	the	the	DT
18637	16675	65	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	16675	66	and	and	CC
18637	16675	67	complete	complete	JJ
18637	16675	68	control	control	NN
18637	16675	69	of	of	IN
18637	16675	70	respondent	respondent	NN
18637	16675	71	;	;	:
18637	16675	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16675	73	4	4	LS
18637	16675	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16675	75	the	the	DT
18637	16675	76	search	search	NN
18637	16675	77	did	do	VBD
18637	16675	78	not	not	RB
18637	16675	79	extend	extend	VB
18637	16675	80	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	16675	81	the	the	DT
18637	16675	82	room	room	NN
18637	16675	83	used	use	VBN
18637	16675	84	for	for	IN
18637	16675	85	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	16675	86	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	16675	87	;	;	:
18637	16675	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16675	89	5	5	LS
18637	16675	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16675	91	the	the	DT
18637	16675	92	possession	possession	NN
18637	16675	93	of	of	IN
18637	16675	94	the	the	DT
18637	16675	95	forged	forge	VBN
18637	16675	96	and	and	CC
18637	16675	97	altered	alter	VBN
18637	16675	98	stamps	stamp	NNS
18637	16675	99	was	be	VBD
18637	16675	100	a	a	DT
18637	16675	101	crime	crime	NN
18637	16675	102	,	,	,
18637	16675	103	just	just	RB
18637	16675	104	as	as	IN
18637	16675	105	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16675	106	is	be	VBZ
18637	16675	107	a	a	DT
18637	16675	108	crime	crime	NN
18637	16675	109	to	to	TO
18637	16675	110	possess	possess	VB
18637	16675	111	burglars	burglar	NNS
18637	16675	112	'	'	POS
18637	16675	113	tools	tool	NNS
18637	16675	114	,	,	,
18637	16675	115	lottery	lottery	NN
18637	16675	116	tickets	ticket	NNS
18637	16675	117	or	or	CC
18637	16675	118	counterfeit	counterfeit	JJ
18637	16675	119	money	money	NN
18637	16675	120	.	.	.
18637	16676	1	"	"	``
18637	16676	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16676	3	59	59	CD
18637	16676	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16676	5	This	this	DT
18637	16676	6	decision	decision	NN
18637	16676	7	also	also	RB
18637	16676	8	overruled	overrule	VBD
18637	16676	9	an	an	DT
18637	16676	10	intermediate	intermediate	JJ
18637	16676	11	case	case	NN
18637	16676	12	,	,	,
18637	16676	13	Trupiano	Trupiano	NNP
18637	16676	14	_	_	NNP
18637	16676	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	16676	16	_	_	NNP
18637	16676	17	United	United	NNP
18637	16676	18	States,[60	States,[60	NNP
18637	16676	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16676	20	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	16676	21	the	the	DT
18637	16676	22	practical	practical	JJ
18637	16676	23	effect	effect	NN
18637	16676	24	of	of	IN
18637	16676	25	the	the	DT
18637	16676	26	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	16676	27	decision	decision	NN
18637	16676	28	had	have	VBD
18637	16676	29	been	be	VBN
18637	16676	30	circumscribed	circumscribe	VBN
18637	16676	31	by	by	IN
18637	16676	32	a	a	DT
18637	16676	33	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	16676	34	that	that	IN
18637	16676	35	even	even	RB
18637	16676	36	where	where	WRB
18637	16676	37	a	a	DT
18637	16676	38	valid	valid	JJ
18637	16676	39	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16676	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	16676	41	made	make	VBN
18637	16676	42	,	,	,
18637	16676	43	a	a	DT
18637	16676	44	search	search	NN
18637	16676	45	without	without	IN
18637	16676	46	a	a	DT
18637	16676	47	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16676	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	16676	49	not	not	RB
18637	16676	50	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	16676	51	if	if	IN
18637	16676	52	the	the	DT
18637	16676	53	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	16676	54	make	make	VBP
18637	16676	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16676	56	feasible	feasible	JJ
18637	16676	57	to	to	TO
18637	16676	58	procure	procure	VB
18637	16676	59	a	a	DT
18637	16676	60	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16676	61	in	in	IN
18637	16676	62	advance	advance	NN
18637	16676	63	.	.	.
18637	16677	1	Search	search	NN
18637	16677	2	of	of	IN
18637	16677	3	Vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	16677	4	The	the	DT
18637	16677	5	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	16677	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16677	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	16677	8	been	be	VBN
18637	16677	9	construed	construe	VBN
18637	16677	10	"	"	``
18637	16677	11	*	*	NFP
18637	16677	12	*	*	NFP
18637	16677	13	*	*	NFP
18637	16677	14	,	,	,
18637	16677	15	as	as	IN
18637	16677	16	recognizing	recognize	VBG
18637	16677	17	a	a	DT
18637	16677	18	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	16677	19	difference	difference	NN
18637	16677	20	between	between	IN
18637	16677	21	a	a	DT
18637	16677	22	search	search	NN
18637	16677	23	of	of	IN
18637	16677	24	a	a	DT
18637	16677	25	store	store	NN
18637	16677	26	,	,	,
18637	16677	27	dwelling	dwell	VBG
18637	16677	28	house	house	NN
18637	16677	29	,	,	,
18637	16677	30	or	or	CC
18637	16677	31	other	other	JJ
18637	16677	32	structure	structure	NN
18637	16677	33	in	in	IN
18637	16677	34	respect	respect	NN
18637	16677	35	of	of	IN
18637	16677	36	which	which	WDT
18637	16677	37	a	a	DT
18637	16677	38	proper	proper	JJ
18637	16677	39	official	official	JJ
18637	16677	40	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16677	41	readily	readily	RB
18637	16677	42	may	may	MD
18637	16677	43	be	be	VB
18637	16677	44	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	16677	45	,	,	,
18637	16677	46	and	and	CC
18637	16677	47	a	a	DT
18637	16677	48	search	search	NN
18637	16677	49	of	of	IN
18637	16677	50	a	a	DT
18637	16677	51	ship	ship	NN
18637	16677	52	,	,	,
18637	16677	53	motor	motor	NNP
18637	16677	54	boat	boat	NNP
18637	16677	55	,	,	,
18637	16677	56	wagon	wagon	NNP
18637	16677	57	,	,	,
18637	16677	58	or	or	CC
18637	16677	59	automobile	automobile	NN
18637	16677	60	for	for	IN
18637	16677	61	contraband	contraband	NN
18637	16677	62	goods	good	NNS
18637	16677	63	,	,	,
18637	16677	64	where	where	WRB
18637	16677	65	is	be	VBZ
18637	16677	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16677	67	not	not	RB
18637	16677	68	practicable	practicable	JJ
18637	16677	69	to	to	TO
18637	16677	70	secure	secure	VB
18637	16677	71	a	a	DT
18637	16677	72	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16677	73	because	because	IN
18637	16677	74	the	the	DT
18637	16677	75	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	16677	76	can	can	MD
18637	16677	77	be	be	VB
18637	16677	78	quickly	quickly	RB
18637	16677	79	moved	move	VBN
18637	16677	80	out	out	IN
18637	16677	81	of	of	IN
18637	16677	82	the	the	DT
18637	16677	83	locality	locality	NN
18637	16677	84	or	or	CC
18637	16677	85	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	16677	86	in	in	IN
18637	16677	87	which	which	WDT
18637	16677	88	the	the	DT
18637	16677	89	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16677	90	must	must	MD
18637	16677	91	be	be	VB
18637	16677	92	sought	seek	VBN
18637	16677	93	.	.	.
18637	16678	1	*	*	NFP
18637	16678	2	*	*	NFP
18637	16678	3	*	*	NFP
18637	16678	4	The	the	DT
18637	16678	5	measure	measure	NN
18637	16678	6	of	of	IN
18637	16678	7	legality	legality	NN
18637	16678	8	of	of	IN
18637	16678	9	such	such	PDT
18637	16678	10	a	a	DT
18637	16678	11	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16678	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	16678	13	,	,	,
18637	16678	14	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	16678	15	,	,	,
18637	16678	16	that	that	IN
18637	16678	17	the	the	DT
18637	16678	18	seizing	seize	VBG
18637	16678	19	officer	officer	NN
18637	16678	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	16678	21	have	have	VB
18637	16678	22	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	16678	23	or	or	CC
18637	16678	24	probable	probable	JJ
18637	16678	25	cause	cause	NN
18637	16678	26	for	for	IN
18637	16678	27	believing	believe	VBG
18637	16678	28	that	that	IN
18637	16678	29	the	the	DT
18637	16678	30	automobile	automobile	NN
18637	16678	31	which	which	WDT
18637	16678	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16678	33	stops	stop	VBZ
18637	16678	34	and	and	CC
18637	16678	35	seizes	seize	VBZ
18637	16678	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	16678	37	contraband	contraband	NNP
18637	16678	38	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	16678	39	therein	therein	RB
18637	16678	40	which	which	WDT
18637	16678	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	16678	42	being	be	VBG
18637	16678	43	illegally	illegally	RB
18637	16678	44	transported	transport	VBN
18637	16678	45	.	.	.
18637	16679	1	"	"	``
18637	16679	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16679	3	61	61	CD
18637	16679	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16679	5	Where	where	WRB
18637	16679	6	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16679	7	have	have	VBP
18637	16679	8	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	16679	9	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	16679	10	for	for	IN
18637	16679	11	searching	search	VBG
18637	16679	12	an	an	DT
18637	16679	13	automobile	automobile	NN
18637	16679	14	which	which	WDT
18637	16679	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16679	16	are	be	VBP
18637	16679	17	following	follow	VBG
18637	16679	18	,	,	,
18637	16679	19	a	a	DT
18637	16679	20	search	search	NN
18637	16679	21	of	of	IN
18637	16679	22	the	the	DT
18637	16679	23	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	16679	24	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	16679	25	after	after	IN
18637	16679	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16679	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	16679	28	been	be	VBN
18637	16679	29	driven	drive	VBN
18637	16679	30	into	into	IN
18637	16679	31	an	an	DT
18637	16679	32	open	open	JJ
18637	16679	33	garage	garage	NN
18637	16679	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	16679	35	valid	valid	JJ
18637	16679	36	.	.	.
18637	16680	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16680	2	62	62	CD
18637	16680	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16680	4	The	the	DT
18637	16680	5	existence	existence	NN
18637	16680	6	of	of	IN
18637	16680	7	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	16680	8	cause	cause	NN
18637	16680	9	for	for	IN
18637	16680	10	searching	search	VBG
18637	16680	11	an	an	DT
18637	16680	12	automobile	automobile	NN
18637	16680	13	does	do	VBZ
18637	16680	14	not	not	RB
18637	16680	15	,	,	,
18637	16680	16	however	however	RB
18637	16680	17	,	,	,
18637	16680	18	warrant	warrant	VB
18637	16680	19	the	the	DT
18637	16680	20	search	search	NN
18637	16680	21	of	of	IN
18637	16680	22	an	an	DT
18637	16680	23	occupant	occupant	NN
18637	16680	24	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	16680	25	,	,	,
18637	16680	26	although	although	IN
18637	16680	27	the	the	DT
18637	16680	28	contraband	contraband	NN
18637	16680	29	sought	seek	VBD
18637	16680	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	16680	31	of	of	IN
18637	16680	32	a	a	DT
18637	16680	33	character	character	NN
18637	16680	34	which	which	WDT
18637	16680	35	might	may	MD
18637	16680	36	be	be	VB
18637	16680	37	concealed	conceal	VBN
18637	16680	38	on	on	IN
18637	16680	39	the	the	DT
18637	16680	40	person	person	NN
18637	16680	41	.	.	.
18637	16681	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16681	2	63	63	CD
18637	16681	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16681	4	Use	Use	NNP
18637	16681	5	of	of	IN
18637	16681	6	Evidence	Evidence	NNP
18637	16681	7	To	to	TO
18637	16681	8	remove	remove	VB
18637	16681	9	the	the	DT
18637	16681	10	temptation	temptation	NN
18637	16681	11	to	to	TO
18637	16681	12	ignore	ignore	VB
18637	16681	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16681	14	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	16681	15	on	on	IN
18637	16681	16	search	search	NN
18637	16681	17	and	and	CC
18637	16681	18	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16681	19	,	,	,
18637	16681	20	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16681	21	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	16681	22	in	in	IN
18637	16681	23	violation	violation	NN
18637	16681	24	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	16681	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	16681	26	made	make	VBN
18637	16681	27	inadmissible	inadmissible	JJ
18637	16681	28	against	against	IN
18637	16681	29	an	an	DT
18637	16681	30	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16681	31	in	in	IN
18637	16681	32	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16681	33	courts	court	NNS
18637	16681	34	.	.	.
18637	16682	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16682	2	64	64	CD
18637	16682	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16682	4	This	this	DT
18637	16682	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	16682	6	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	16682	7	to	to	IN
18637	16682	8	the	the	DT
18637	16682	9	practice	practice	NN
18637	16682	10	prevailing	prevail	VBG
18637	16682	11	in	in	IN
18637	16682	12	the	the	DT
18637	16682	13	majority	majority	NN
18637	16682	14	of	of	IN
18637	16682	15	States	States	NNP
18637	16682	16	and	and	CC
18637	16682	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	16682	18	been	be	VBN
18637	16682	19	severely	severely	RB
18637	16682	20	criticized	criticize	VBN
18637	16682	21	as	as	IN
18637	16682	22	a	a	DT
18637	16682	23	matter	matter	NN
18637	16682	24	of	of	IN
18637	16682	25	principle	principle	NN
18637	16682	26	.	.	.
18637	16683	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16683	2	65	65	CD
18637	16683	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16683	4	The	the	DT
18637	16683	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16683	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	16683	7	intimated	intimate	VBN
18637	16683	8	recently	recently	RB
18637	16683	9	that	that	IN
18637	16683	10	the	the	DT
18637	16683	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16683	12	exclusionary	exclusionary	JJ
18637	16683	13	rule	rule	NN
18637	16683	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	16683	15	not	not	RB
18637	16683	16	a	a	DT
18637	16683	17	command	command	NN
18637	16683	18	of	of	IN
18637	16683	19	the	the	DT
18637	16683	20	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	16683	21	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16683	22	,	,	,
18637	16683	23	but	but	CC
18637	16683	24	merely	merely	RB
18637	16683	25	a	a	DT
18637	16683	26	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	16683	27	created	create	VBN
18637	16683	28	rule	rule	NN
18637	16683	29	of	of	IN
18637	16683	30	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16683	31	which	which	WDT
18637	16683	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16683	33	could	could	MD
18637	16683	34	overrule	overrule	VB
18637	16683	35	.	.	.
18637	16684	1	In	in	IN
18637	16684	2	Wolf	Wolf	NNP
18637	16684	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16684	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	16684	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16684	6	Colorado,[66	Colorado,[66	NNP
18637	16684	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16684	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16684	9	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	16684	10	that	that	IN
18637	16684	11	while	while	IN
18637	16684	12	that	that	DT
18637	16684	13	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	16684	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	16684	15	binding	bind	VBG
18637	16684	16	on	on	IN
18637	16684	17	the	the	DT
18637	16684	18	States	States	NNPS
18637	16684	19	,	,	,
18637	16684	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16684	21	does	do	VBZ
18637	16684	22	not	not	RB
18637	16684	23	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	16684	24	State	state	NN
18637	16684	25	courts	court	NNS
18637	16684	26	from	from	IN
18637	16684	27	admitting	admit	VBG
18637	16684	28	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16684	29	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	16684	30	by	by	IN
18637	16684	31	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	16684	32	search	search	NN
18637	16684	33	.	.	.
18637	16685	1	With	with	IN
18637	16685	2	respect	respect	NN
18637	16685	3	to	to	IN
18637	16685	4	the	the	DT
18637	16685	5	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16685	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	16685	7	,	,	,
18637	16685	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16685	9	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	16685	10	said	say	VBD
18637	16685	11	:	:	:
18637	16685	12	"	"	``
18637	16685	13	*	*	NFP
18637	16685	14	*	*	NFP
18637	16685	15	*	*	NFP
18637	16685	16	though	though	IN
18637	16685	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16685	18	have	have	VBP
18637	16685	19	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	16685	20	the	the	DT
18637	16685	21	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	16685	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16685	23	to	to	TO
18637	16685	24	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	16685	25	the	the	DT
18637	16685	26	admission	admission	NN
18637	16685	27	of	of	IN
18637	16685	28	such	such	JJ
18637	16685	29	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16685	30	,	,	,
18637	16685	31	a	a	DT
18637	16685	32	different	different	JJ
18637	16685	33	question	question	NN
18637	16685	34	would	would	MD
18637	16685	35	be	be	VB
18637	16685	36	presented	present	VBN
18637	16685	37	if	if	IN
18637	16685	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16685	39	,	,	,
18637	16685	40	under	under	IN
18637	16685	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16685	42	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	16685	43	powers	power	NNS
18637	16685	44	,	,	,
18637	16685	45	were	be	VBD
18637	16685	46	to	to	TO
18637	16685	47	pass	pass	VB
18637	16685	48	a	a	DT
18637	16685	49	statute	statute	NN
18637	16685	50	purporting	purporting	NN
18637	16685	51	to	to	TO
18637	16685	52	negate	negate	VB
18637	16685	53	the	the	DT
18637	16685	54	_	_	NNP
18637	16685	55	Weeks	Weeks	NNPS
18637	16685	56	_	_	NNP
18637	16685	57	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	16685	58	.	.	.
18637	16686	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16686	2	would	would	MD
18637	16686	3	then	then	RB
18637	16686	4	be	be	VB
18637	16686	5	faced	face	VBN
18637	16686	6	with	with	IN
18637	16686	7	the	the	DT
18637	16686	8	problem	problem	NN
18637	16686	9	of	of	IN
18637	16686	10	the	the	DT
18637	16686	11	respect	respect	NN
18637	16686	12	to	to	TO
18637	16686	13	be	be	VB
18637	16686	14	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	16686	15	the	the	DT
18637	16686	16	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	16686	17	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16686	18	on	on	IN
18637	16686	19	an	an	DT
18637	16686	20	issue	issue	NN
18637	16686	21	as	as	IN
18637	16686	22	to	to	IN
18637	16686	23	which	which	WDT
18637	16686	24	,	,	,
18637	16686	25	in	in	IN
18637	16686	26	default	default	NN
18637	16686	27	of	of	IN
18637	16686	28	that	that	DT
18637	16686	29	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16686	30	,	,	,
18637	16686	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16686	32	have	have	VBP
18637	16686	33	been	be	VBN
18637	16686	34	forced	force	VBN
18637	16686	35	to	to	TO
18637	16686	36	depend	depend	VB
18637	16686	37	upon	upon	IN
18637	16686	38	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16686	39	own	own	JJ
18637	16686	40	.	.	.
18637	16687	1	"	"	``
18637	16687	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16687	3	67	67	CD
18637	16687	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16687	5	This	this	DT
18637	16687	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	16687	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	16687	8	not	not	RB
18637	16687	9	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	16687	10	the	the	DT
18637	16687	11	use	use	NN
18637	16687	12	of	of	IN
18637	16687	13	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16687	14	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	16687	15	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	16687	16	by	by	IN
18637	16687	17	individuals,[68	individuals,[68	NNP
18637	16687	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16687	19	or	or	CC
18637	16687	20	by	by	IN
18637	16687	21	State	State	NNP
18637	16687	22	officers,[69	officers,[69	NNP
18637	16687	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16687	24	unless	unless	IN
18637	16687	25	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16687	26	agents	agent	NNS
18637	16687	27	had	have	VBD
18637	16687	28	a	a	DT
18637	16687	29	part	part	NN
18637	16687	30	in	in	IN
18637	16687	31	the	the	DT
18637	16687	32	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	16687	33	acquisition,[70	acquisition,[70	CD
18637	16687	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16687	35	or	or	CC
18637	16687	36	unless	unless	IN
18637	16687	37	the	the	DT
18637	16687	38	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	16687	39	and	and	CC
18637	16687	40	search	search	NN
18637	16687	41	were	be	VBD
18637	16687	42	made	make	VBN
18637	16687	43	for	for	IN
18637	16687	44	an	an	DT
18637	16687	45	offense	offense	NN
18637	16687	46	punishable	punishable	JJ
18637	16687	47	only	only	RB
18637	16687	48	by	by	IN
18637	16687	49	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16687	50	law	law	NN
18637	16687	51	.	.	.
18637	16688	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16688	2	71	71	CD
18637	16688	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16688	4	A	a	DT
18637	16688	5	search	search	NN
18637	16688	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	16688	7	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	16688	8	to	to	TO
18637	16688	9	be	be	VB
18637	16688	10	"	"	``
18637	16688	11	a	a	DT
18637	16688	12	search	search	NN
18637	16688	13	by	by	IN
18637	16688	14	a	a	DT
18637	16688	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16688	16	official	official	NN
18637	16688	17	if	if	IN
18637	16688	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16688	19	had	have	VBD
18637	16688	20	a	a	DT
18637	16688	21	hand	hand	NN
18637	16688	22	in	in	IN
18637	16688	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16688	24	;	;	:
18637	16688	25	*	*	NFP
18637	16688	26	*	*	NFP
18637	16688	27	*	*	NFP
18637	16688	28	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16688	29	but	but	CC
18637	16688	30	not	not	RB
18637	16688	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16688	32	if	if	IN
18637	16688	33	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16688	34	secured	secure	VBN
18637	16688	35	by	by	IN
18637	16688	36	State	State	NNP
18637	16688	37	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	16688	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	16688	39	turned	turn	VBN
18637	16688	40	over	over	RP
18637	16688	41	to	to	IN
18637	16688	42	the	the	DT
18637	16688	43	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16688	44	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	16688	45	on	on	IN
18637	16688	46	a	a	DT
18637	16688	47	silver	silver	JJ
18637	16688	48	platter	platter	NN
18637	16688	49	.	.	.
18637	16689	1	The	the	DT
18637	16689	2	decisive	decisive	JJ
18637	16689	3	factor	factor	NN
18637	16689	4	*	*	NFP
18637	16689	5	*	*	NFP
18637	16689	6	*	*	NFP
18637	16689	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	16689	8	the	the	DT
18637	16689	9	actuality	actuality	NN
18637	16689	10	of	of	IN
18637	16689	11	a	a	DT
18637	16689	12	share	share	NN
18637	16689	13	by	by	IN
18637	16689	14	a	a	DT
18637	16689	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16689	16	official	official	NN
18637	16689	17	in	in	IN
18637	16689	18	the	the	DT
18637	16689	19	total	total	JJ
18637	16689	20	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	16689	21	of	of	IN
18637	16689	22	securing	secure	VBG
18637	16689	23	and	and	CC
18637	16689	24	selecting	select	VBG
18637	16689	25	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16689	26	by	by	IN
18637	16689	27	other	other	JJ
18637	16689	28	than	than	IN
18637	16689	29	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
18637	16689	30	means	mean	NNS
18637	16689	31	.	.	.
18637	16690	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16690	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	16690	3	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
18637	16690	4	whether	whether	IN
18637	16690	5	a	a	DT
18637	16690	6	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16690	7	agent	agent	NN
18637	16690	8	originated	originate	VBD
18637	16690	9	the	the	DT
18637	16690	10	idea	idea	NN
18637	16690	11	or	or	CC
18637	16690	12	joined	join	VBD
18637	16690	13	in	in	IN
18637	16690	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16690	15	while	while	IN
18637	16690	16	the	the	DT
18637	16690	17	search	search	NN
18637	16690	18	was	be	VBD
18637	16690	19	in	in	IN
18637	16690	20	progress	progress	NN
18637	16690	21	.	.	.
18637	16691	1	So	so	RB
18637	16691	2	long	long	RB
18637	16691	3	as	as	IN
18637	16691	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16691	5	was	be	VBD
18637	16691	6	in	in	IN
18637	16691	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16691	8	before	before	IN
18637	16691	9	the	the	DT
18637	16691	10	object	object	NN
18637	16691	11	of	of	IN
18637	16691	12	the	the	DT
18637	16691	13	search	search	NN
18637	16691	14	was	be	VBD
18637	16691	15	completely	completely	RB
18637	16691	16	accomplished	accomplish	VBN
18637	16691	17	,	,	,
18637	16691	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16691	19	must	must	MD
18637	16691	20	be	be	VB
18637	16691	21	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	16691	22	to	to	TO
18637	16691	23	have	have	VB
18637	16691	24	participated	participate	VBN
18637	16691	25	in	in	IN
18637	16691	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16691	27	.	.	.
18637	16692	1	"	"	``
18637	16692	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16692	3	72	72	CD
18637	16692	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16692	5	Samples	sample	NNS
18637	16692	6	of	of	IN
18637	16692	7	illicit	illicit	JJ
18637	16692	8	goods	good	NNS
18637	16692	9	constituting	constitute	VBG
18637	16692	10	part	part	NN
18637	16692	11	of	of	IN
18637	16692	12	a	a	DT
18637	16692	13	quantity	quantity	NN
18637	16692	14	seized	seize	VBN
18637	16692	15	by	by	IN
18637	16692	16	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16692	17	officials	official	NNS
18637	16692	18	under	under	IN
18637	16692	19	a	a	DT
18637	16692	20	valid	valid	JJ
18637	16692	21	search	search	NN
18637	16692	22	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	16692	23	may	may	MD
18637	16692	24	be	be	VB
18637	16692	25	used	use	VBN
18637	16692	26	as	as	IN
18637	16692	27	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16692	28	,	,	,
18637	16692	29	whether	whether	IN
18637	16692	30	or	or	CC
18637	16692	31	not	not	RB
18637	16692	32	the	the	DT
18637	16692	33	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16692	34	become	become	VBP
18637	16692	35	civilly	civilly	RB
18637	16692	36	liable	liable	JJ
18637	16692	37	as	as	IN
18637	16692	38	trespassers	trespasser	NNS
18637	16692	39	_	_	NNP
18637	16692	40	ab	ab	NNP
18637	16692	41	initio	initio	NNP
18637	16692	42	_	_	NNP
18637	16692	43	,	,	,
18637	16692	44	by	by	IN
18637	16692	45	reason	reason	NN
18637	16692	46	of	of	IN
18637	16692	47	the	the	DT
18637	16692	48	fact	fact	NN
18637	16692	49	that	that	IN
18637	16692	50	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16692	51	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	16692	52	destroyed	destroy	VBD
18637	16692	53	the	the	DT
18637	16692	54	remainder	remainder	NN
18637	16692	55	of	of	IN
18637	16692	56	the	the	DT
18637	16692	57	goods	good	NNS
18637	16692	58	at	at	IN
18637	16692	59	the	the	DT
18637	16692	60	time	time	NN
18637	16692	61	the	the	DT
18637	16692	62	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16692	63	was	be	VBD
18637	16692	64	made	make	VBN
18637	16692	65	.	.	.
18637	16693	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16693	2	73	73	CD
18637	16693	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16693	4	In	in	IN
18637	16693	5	Silver	Silver	NNP
18637	16693	6	Thorne	Thorne	NNP
18637	16693	7	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	16693	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16693	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16693	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	16693	11	_	_	NNP
18637	16693	12	.	.	.
18637	16694	1	United	United	NNP
18637	16694	2	States,[74	States,[74	NNP
18637	16694	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16694	4	the	the	DT
18637	16694	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16694	6	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	16694	7	to	to	TO
18637	16694	8	permit	permit	VB
18637	16694	9	the	the	DT
18637	16694	10	Government	Government	NNP
18637	16694	11	to	to	TO
18637	16694	12	subpoena	subpoena	VB
18637	16694	13	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	16694	14	records	record	NNS
18637	16694	15	of	of	IN
18637	16694	16	which	which	WDT
18637	16694	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16694	18	had	have	VBD
18637	16694	19	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	16694	20	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	16694	21	by	by	IN
18637	16694	22	an	an	DT
18637	16694	23	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	16694	24	search	search	NN
18637	16694	25	.	.	.
18637	16695	1	To	to	TO
18637	16695	2	permit	permit	VB
18637	16695	3	"	"	``
18637	16695	4	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	16695	5	gained	gain	VBN
18637	16695	6	by	by	IN
18637	16695	7	the	the	DT
18637	16695	8	Government	Government	NNP
18637	16695	9	's	's	POS
18637	16695	10	own	own	JJ
18637	16695	11	wrong	wrong	NN
18637	16695	12	"	"	''
18637	16695	13	to	to	TO
18637	16695	14	be	be	VB
18637	16695	15	so	so	RB
18637	16695	16	used	used	JJ
18637	16695	17	would	would	MD
18637	16695	18	do	do	VB
18637	16695	19	violence	violence	NN
18637	16695	20	to	to	IN
18637	16695	21	the	the	DT
18637	16695	22	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	16695	23	of	of	IN
18637	16695	24	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	16695	25	.	.	.
18637	16696	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16696	2	75	75	CD
18637	16696	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16696	4	But	but	CC
18637	16696	5	a	a	DT
18637	16696	6	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	16696	7	in	in	IN
18637	16696	8	a	a	DT
18637	16696	9	civil	civil	JJ
18637	16696	10	antitrust	antitrust	JJ
18637	16696	11	suit	suit	NN
18637	16696	12	may	may	MD
18637	16696	13	be	be	VB
18637	16696	14	required	require	VBN
18637	16696	15	to	to	TO
18637	16696	16	produce	produce	VB
18637	16696	17	records	record	NNS
18637	16696	18	which	which	WDT
18637	16696	19	had	have	VBD
18637	16696	20	been	be	VBN
18637	16696	21	previously	previously	RB
18637	16696	22	subpoenaed	subpoena	VBN
18637	16696	23	before	before	IN
18637	16696	24	a	a	DT
18637	16696	25	grand	grand	JJ
18637	16696	26	jury	jury	NN
18637	16696	27	,	,	,
18637	16696	28	despite	despite	IN
18637	16696	29	the	the	DT
18637	16696	30	fact	fact	NN
18637	16696	31	that	that	IN
18637	16696	32	the	the	DT
18637	16696	33	grand	grand	JJ
18637	16696	34	jury	jury	NN
18637	16696	35	was	be	VBD
18637	16696	36	illegally	illegally	RB
18637	16696	37	constituted	constituted	JJ
18637	16696	38	because	because	IN
18637	16696	39	women	woman	NNS
18637	16696	40	were	be	VBD
18637	16696	41	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	16696	42	from	from	IN
18637	16696	43	the	the	DT
18637	16696	44	panel	panel	NN
18637	16696	45	.	.	.
18637	16697	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16697	2	76	76	CD
18637	16697	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16697	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	16697	5	government	government	NN
18637	16697	6	agents	agent	NNS
18637	16697	7	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	16697	8	obtained	obtain	VBD
18637	16697	9	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	16697	10	of	of	IN
18637	16697	11	the	the	DT
18637	16697	12	contents	content	NNS
18637	16697	13	of	of	IN
18637	16697	14	a	a	DT
18637	16697	15	cancelled	cancel	VBN
18637	16697	16	check	check	NN
18637	16697	17	during	during	IN
18637	16697	18	examination	examination	NN
18637	16697	19	of	of	IN
18637	16697	20	the	the	DT
18637	16697	21	records	record	NNS
18637	16697	22	of	of	IN
18637	16697	23	a	a	DT
18637	16697	24	government	government	NN
18637	16697	25	contractor	contractor	NN
18637	16697	26	,	,	,
18637	16697	27	the	the	DT
18637	16697	28	admission	admission	NN
18637	16697	29	of	of	IN
18637	16697	30	such	such	JJ
18637	16697	31	check	check	NN
18637	16697	32	in	in	IN
18637	16697	33	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16697	34	was	be	VBD
18637	16697	35	held	hold	VBN
18637	16697	36	not	not	RB
18637	16697	37	to	to	TO
18637	16697	38	be	be	VB
18637	16697	39	an	an	DT
18637	16697	40	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	16697	41	of	of	IN
18637	16697	42	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	16697	43	even	even	RB
18637	16697	44	if	if	IN
18637	16697	45	the	the	DT
18637	16697	46	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16697	47	of	of	IN
18637	16697	48	the	the	DT
18637	16697	49	check	check	NN
18637	16697	50	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16697	51	was	be	VBD
18637	16697	52	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	16697	53	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	16697	54	.	.	.
18637	16698	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16698	2	77	77	CD
18637	16698	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16698	4	The	the	DT
18637	16698	5	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16698	6	of	of	IN
18637	16698	7	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16698	8	under	under	IN
18637	16698	9	a	a	DT
18637	16698	10	writ	writ	NNP
18637	16698	11	of	of	IN
18637	16698	12	replevin	replevin	NNS
18637	16698	13	issued	issue	VBN
18637	16698	14	in	in	IN
18637	16698	15	a	a	DT
18637	16698	16	civil	civil	JJ
18637	16698	17	suit	suit	NN
18637	16698	18	between	between	IN
18637	16698	19	private	private	JJ
18637	16698	20	persons	person	NNS
18637	16698	21	does	do	VBZ
18637	16698	22	not	not	RB
18637	16698	23	violate	violate	VB
18637	16698	24	the	the	DT
18637	16698	25	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	16698	26	and	and	CC
18637	16698	27	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	16698	28	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	16698	29	.	.	.
18637	16699	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16699	2	78	78	CD
18637	16699	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16699	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	16699	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16699	6	1	1	CD
18637	16699	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16699	8	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	16699	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16699	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	16699	11	_	_	NNP
18637	16699	12	United	United	NNP
18637	16699	13	States	States	NNP
18637	16699	14	,	,	,
18637	16699	15	267	267	CD
18637	16699	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16699	17	132	132	CD
18637	16699	18	,	,	,
18637	16699	19	147	147	CD
18637	16699	20	,	,	,
18637	16699	21	149	149	CD
18637	16699	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16699	23	1925	1925	CD
18637	16699	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16699	25	.	.	.
18637	16700	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16700	2	2	2	LS
18637	16700	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16700	4	Burdeau	Burdeau	NNP
18637	16700	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16700	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16700	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16700	8	McDowell	McDowell	NNP
18637	16700	9	,	,	,
18637	16700	10	256	256	CD
18637	16700	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16700	12	465	465	CD
18637	16700	13	,	,	,
18637	16700	14	475	475	CD
18637	16700	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16700	16	1921	1921	CD
18637	16700	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16700	18	.	.	.
18637	16701	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16701	2	3	3	LS
18637	16701	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16701	4	Den	Den	NNP
18637	16701	5	ex	ex	FW
18637	16701	6	dem	dem	NNP
18637	16701	7	.	.	.
18637	16702	1	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	16702	2	_	_	NNP
18637	16702	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	16702	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16702	5	Hoboken	Hoboken	NNP
18637	16702	6	Land	Land	NNP
18637	16702	7	&	&	CC
18637	16702	8	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	16702	9	.	.	.
18637	16703	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16703	2	,	,	,
18637	16703	3	18	18	CD
18637	16703	4	How	how	WRB
18637	16703	5	.	.	.
18637	16704	1	272	272	CD
18637	16704	2	,	,	,
18637	16704	3	285	285	CD
18637	16704	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16704	5	1856	1856	CD
18637	16704	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16704	7	.	.	.
18637	16705	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16705	2	4	4	CD
18637	16705	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16705	4	Nathanson	Nathanson	NNP
18637	16705	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16705	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16705	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16705	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16705	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16705	10	,	,	,
18637	16705	11	290	290	CD
18637	16705	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16705	13	41	41	CD
18637	16705	14	,	,	,
18637	16705	15	47	47	CD
18637	16705	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16705	17	1933	1933	CD
18637	16705	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16705	19	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16705	20	5	5	CD
18637	16705	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16705	22	Gouled	Gouled	NNP
18637	16705	23	_	_	NNP
18637	16705	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	16705	25	_	_	NNP
18637	16705	26	United	United	NNP
18637	16705	27	States	States	NNP
18637	16705	28	,	,	,
18637	16705	29	255	255	CD
18637	16705	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16705	31	298	298	CD
18637	16705	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16705	33	1921	1921	CD
18637	16705	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16705	35	.	.	.
18637	16706	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16706	2	6	6	CD
18637	16706	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16706	4	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	16706	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16706	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16706	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16706	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16706	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16706	10	,	,	,
18637	16706	11	286	286	CD
18637	16706	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16706	13	1	1	CD
18637	16706	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16706	15	1932	1932	CD
18637	16706	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16706	17	.	.	.
18637	16707	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16707	2	7	7	CD
18637	16707	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16707	4	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	16707	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16707	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16707	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16707	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16707	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16707	10	,	,	,
18637	16707	11	267	267	CD
18637	16707	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16707	13	132	132	CD
18637	16707	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16707	15	1925	1925	CD
18637	16707	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16707	17	.	.	.
18637	16708	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16708	2	8	8	CD
18637	16708	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16708	4	Hester	Hester	NNP
18637	16708	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16708	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16708	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16708	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16708	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16708	10	,	,	,
18637	16708	11	265	265	CD
18637	16708	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16708	13	57	57	CD
18637	16708	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16708	15	1924	1924	CD
18637	16708	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16708	17	.	.	.
18637	16709	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16709	2	9	9	CD
18637	16709	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16709	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	16709	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	16709	6	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	16709	7	,	,	,
18637	16709	8	96	96	CD
18637	16709	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16709	10	727	727	CD
18637	16709	11	,	,	,
18637	16709	12	733	733	CD
18637	16709	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16709	14	1878	1878	CD
18637	16709	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16709	16	.	.	.
18637	16710	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16710	2	10	10	CD
18637	16710	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16710	4	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
18637	16710	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16710	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16710	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16710	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16710	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16710	10	,	,	,
18637	16710	11	116	116	CD
18637	16710	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16710	13	616	616	CD
18637	16710	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16710	15	1886	1886	CD
18637	16710	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16710	17	;	;	:
18637	16710	18	Hale	Hale	NNP
18637	16710	19	_	_	NNP
18637	16710	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	16710	21	_	_	NNP
18637	16710	22	Henkel	Henkel	NNP
18637	16710	23	,	,	,
18637	16710	24	201	201	CD
18637	16710	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16710	26	43	43	CD
18637	16710	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16710	28	1906	1906	CD
18637	16710	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16710	30	.	.	.
18637	16711	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16711	2	11	11	CD
18637	16711	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16711	4	Stroud	Stroud	NNP
18637	16711	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16711	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16711	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16711	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16711	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16711	10	,	,	,
18637	16711	11	251	251	CD
18637	16711	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16711	13	15	15	CD
18637	16711	14	,	,	,
18637	16711	15	21	21	CD
18637	16711	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16711	17	1919	1919	CD
18637	16711	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16711	19	.	.	.
18637	16712	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16712	2	12	12	CD
18637	16712	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16712	4	Amos	Amos	NNP
18637	16712	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16712	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16712	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16712	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16712	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16712	10	,	,	,
18637	16712	11	255	255	CD
18637	16712	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16712	13	313	313	CD
18637	16712	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16712	15	1921	1921	CD
18637	16712	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16712	17	;	;	:
18637	16712	18	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	16712	19	_	_	NNP
18637	16712	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	16712	21	_	_	NNP
18637	16712	22	United	United	NNP
18637	16712	23	States	States	NNP
18637	16712	24	,	,	,
18637	16712	25	333	333	CD
18637	16712	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16712	27	10	10	CD
18637	16712	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16712	29	1948	1948	CD
18637	16712	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16712	31	.	.	.
18637	16713	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16713	2	13	13	CD
18637	16713	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16713	4	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	16713	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16713	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16713	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16713	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16713	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16713	10	,	,	,
18637	16713	11	328	328	CD
18637	16713	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16713	13	582	582	CD
18637	16713	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16713	15	1946	1946	CD
18637	16713	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16713	17	.	.	.
18637	16714	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16714	2	14	14	CD
18637	16714	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16714	4	Olmstead	Olmstead	NNP
18637	16714	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16714	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16714	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16714	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16714	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16714	10	,	,	,
18637	16714	11	277	277	CD
18637	16714	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16714	13	438	438	CD
18637	16714	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16714	15	1928	1928	CD
18637	16714	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16714	17	.	.	.
18637	16715	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16715	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	16715	3	.	.	.
18637	16715	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16715	5	Nardone	Nardone	NNP
18637	16715	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16715	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16715	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16715	9	United	United	NNP
18637	16715	10	States	States	NNP
18637	16715	11	,	,	,
18637	16715	12	302	302	CD
18637	16715	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16715	14	379	379	CD
18637	16715	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16715	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	16715	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16715	18	;	;	:
18637	16715	19	308	308	CD
18637	16715	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16715	21	338	338	CD
18637	16715	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16715	23	1939	1939	CD
18637	16715	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16715	25	.	.	.
18637	16716	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16716	2	15	15	CD
18637	16716	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16716	4	Goldman	Goldman	NNP
18637	16716	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16716	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16716	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16716	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16716	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16716	10	,	,	,
18637	16716	11	316	316	CD
18637	16716	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16716	13	129	129	CD
18637	16716	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16716	15	1942	1942	CD
18637	16716	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16716	17	.	.	.
18637	16717	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16717	2	16	16	CD
18637	16717	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16717	4	Bilokumsky	Bilokumsky	NNP
18637	16717	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16717	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16717	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16717	8	Tod	Tod	NNP
18637	16717	9	,	,	,
18637	16717	10	203	203	CD
18637	16717	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16717	12	149	149	CD
18637	16717	13	,	,	,
18637	16717	14	155	155	CD
18637	16717	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16717	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	16717	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16717	18	.	.	.
18637	16718	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16718	2	17	17	CD
18637	16718	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16718	4	On	on	IN
18637	16718	5	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	16718	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16718	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16718	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16718	9	United	United	NNP
18637	16718	10	States	States	NNP
18637	16718	11	,	,	,
18637	16718	12	343	343	CD
18637	16718	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16718	14	747	747	CD
18637	16718	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16718	16	1952	1952	CD
18637	16718	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16718	18	.	.	.
18637	16719	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16719	2	18	18	CD
18637	16719	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16719	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16719	5	.	.	.
18637	16720	1	753	753	CD
18637	16720	2	.	.	.
18637	16721	1	Four	four	CD
18637	16721	2	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	16721	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	16721	4	,	,	,
18637	16721	5	relying	rely	VBG
18637	16721	6	in	in	IN
18637	16721	7	the	the	DT
18637	16721	8	main	main	JJ
18637	16721	9	on	on	IN
18637	16721	10	the	the	DT
18637	16721	11	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	16721	12	in	in	IN
18637	16721	13	the	the	DT
18637	16721	14	Olmstead	Olmstead	NNP
18637	16721	15	case	case	NN
18637	16721	16	,	,	,
18637	16721	17	which	which	WDT
18637	16721	18	came	come	VBD
18637	16721	19	later	later	RB
18637	16721	20	to	to	TO
18637	16721	21	be	be	VB
18637	16721	22	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	16721	23	by	by	IN
18637	16721	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16721	25	.	.	.
18637	16722	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16722	2	See	See	NNP
18637	16722	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16722	4	note	note	NN
18637	16722	5	10	10	CD
18637	16722	6	above	above	RB
18637	16722	7	.	.	.
18637	16723	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16723	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	16723	3	's	's	POS
18637	16723	4	Note	note	NN
18637	16723	5	:	:	:
18637	16723	6	Reference	reference	NN
18637	16723	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	16723	8	to	to	IN
18637	16723	9	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	16723	10	14	14	CD
18637	16723	11	,	,	,
18637	16723	12	above	above	RB
18637	16723	13	.	.	.
18637	16723	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16724	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16724	2	19	19	CD
18637	16724	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16724	4	United	United	NNP
18637	16724	5	States	States	NNP
18637	16724	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16724	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16724	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16724	9	Jeffers	Jeffers	NNP
18637	16724	10	,	,	,
18637	16724	11	342	342	CD
18637	16724	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16724	13	48	48	CD
18637	16724	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16724	15	1951	1951	CD
18637	16724	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16724	17	.	.	.
18637	16725	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16725	2	20	20	CD
18637	16725	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16725	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	16725	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	16725	6	Burford	Burford	NNP
18637	16725	7	,	,	,
18637	16725	8	3	3	CD
18637	16725	9	Cr	Cr	NNP
18637	16725	10	.	.	.
18637	16726	1	448	448	CD
18637	16726	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16726	3	1806	1806	CD
18637	16726	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16726	5	.	.	.
18637	16727	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16727	2	21	21	CD
18637	16727	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16727	4	Albrecht	Albrecht	NNP
18637	16727	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16727	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16727	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16727	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16727	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16727	10	,	,	,
18637	16727	11	273	273	CD
18637	16727	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16727	13	1	1	CD
18637	16727	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16727	15	1927	1927	CD
18637	16727	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16727	17	.	.	.
18637	16728	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16728	2	22	22	CD
18637	16728	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16728	4	McGrain	McGrain	NNP
18637	16728	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16728	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16728	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16728	8	Daugherty	Daugherty	NNP
18637	16728	9	,	,	,
18637	16728	10	273	273	CD
18637	16728	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16728	12	135	135	CD
18637	16728	13	,	,	,
18637	16728	14	156	156	CD
18637	16728	15	,	,	,
18637	16728	16	158	158	CD
18637	16728	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16728	18	1927	1927	CD
18637	16728	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16728	20	.	.	.
18637	16729	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16729	2	23	23	CD
18637	16729	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16729	4	Agnello	Agnello	NNP
18637	16729	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16729	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16729	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16729	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16729	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16729	10	,	,	,
18637	16729	11	269	269	CD
18637	16729	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16729	13	20	20	CD
18637	16729	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16729	15	1925	1925	CD
18637	16729	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16729	17	.	.	.
18637	16730	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16730	2	24	24	CD
18637	16730	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16730	4	Byars	Byars	NNPS
18637	16730	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16730	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16730	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16730	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16730	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16730	10	,	,	,
18637	16730	11	273	273	CD
18637	16730	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16730	13	28	28	CD
18637	16730	14	,	,	,
18637	16730	15	29	29	CD
18637	16730	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16730	17	1927	1927	CD
18637	16730	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16730	19	.	.	.
18637	16731	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16731	2	25	25	CD
18637	16731	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16731	4	Steele	Steele	NNP
18637	16731	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16731	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16731	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16731	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16731	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16731	10	,	,	,
18637	16731	11	No	no	UH
18637	16731	12	.	.	.
18637	16732	1	1	1	CD
18637	16732	2	,	,	,
18637	16732	3	267	267	CD
18637	16732	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16732	5	498	498	CD
18637	16732	6	,	,	,
18637	16732	7	504	504	CD
18637	16732	8	,	,	,
18637	16732	9	505	505	CD
18637	16732	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16732	11	1925	1925	CD
18637	16732	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16732	13	;	;	:
18637	16732	14	Dumbra	Dumbra	NNP
18637	16732	15	_	_	NNP
18637	16732	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	16732	17	_	_	NNP
18637	16732	18	United	United	NNP
18637	16732	19	States	States	NNP
18637	16732	20	,	,	,
18637	16732	21	268	268	CD
18637	16732	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16732	23	435	435	CD
18637	16732	24	,	,	,
18637	16732	25	441	441	CD
18637	16732	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16732	27	1925	1925	CD
18637	16732	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16732	29	.	.	.
18637	16733	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16733	2	26	26	CD
18637	16733	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16733	4	Marron	Marron	NNP
18637	16733	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16733	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16733	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16733	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16733	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16733	10	,	,	,
18637	16733	11	275	275	CD
18637	16733	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16733	13	192	192	CD
18637	16733	14	,	,	,
18637	16733	15	196	196	CD
18637	16733	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16733	17	1927	1927	CD
18637	16733	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16733	19	.	.	.
18637	16734	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16734	2	27	27	CD
18637	16734	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16734	4	Gouled	Gouled	NNP
18637	16734	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16734	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16734	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16734	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16734	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16734	10	,	,	,
18637	16734	11	255	255	CD
18637	16734	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16734	13	298	298	CD
18637	16734	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16734	15	1921	1921	CD
18637	16734	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16734	17	.	.	.
18637	16735	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16735	2	28	28	CD
18637	16735	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16735	4	116	116	CD
18637	16735	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16735	6	616	616	CD
18637	16735	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16735	8	1886	1886	CD
18637	16735	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16735	10	.	.	.
18637	16736	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16736	2	29	29	CD
18637	16736	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16736	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16736	5	.	.	.
18637	16737	1	630	630	CD
18637	16737	2	.	.	.
18637	16738	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16738	2	30	30	CD
18637	16738	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16738	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16738	5	.	.	.
18637	16739	1	634	634	CD
18637	16739	2	,	,	,
18637	16739	3	635	635	CD
18637	16739	4	.	.	.
18637	16740	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16740	2	31	31	CD
18637	16740	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16740	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16740	5	.	.	.
18637	16741	1	633	633	CD
18637	16741	2	.	.	.
18637	16742	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16742	2	32	32	CD
18637	16742	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16742	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16742	5	.	.	.
18637	16743	1	635	635	CD
18637	16743	2	.	.	.
18637	16744	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16744	2	33	33	CD
18637	16744	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16744	4	Hale	Hale	NNP
18637	16744	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16744	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16744	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16744	8	Henkel	Henkel	NNP
18637	16744	9	,	,	,
18637	16744	10	201	201	CD
18637	16744	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16744	12	43	43	CD
18637	16744	13	,	,	,
18637	16744	14	74	74	CD
18637	16744	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16744	16	1906	1906	CD
18637	16744	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16744	18	;	;	:
18637	16744	19	Essgee	Essgee	NNP
18637	16744	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16744	21	_	_	NNP
18637	16744	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	16744	23	_	_	NNP
18637	16744	24	United	United	NNP
18637	16744	25	States	States	NNP
18637	16744	26	,	,	,
18637	16744	27	262	262	CD
18637	16744	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16744	29	151	151	CD
18637	16744	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16744	31	1923	1923	CD
18637	16744	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16744	33	.	.	.
18637	16745	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16745	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	16745	3	.	.	.
18637	16745	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16745	5	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	16745	6	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	16745	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	16745	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16745	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	16745	10	_	_	NNP
18637	16745	11	Baird	Baird	NNP
18637	16745	12	,	,	,
18637	16745	13	194	194	CD
18637	16745	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16745	15	25	25	CD
18637	16745	16	,	,	,
18637	16745	17	46	46	CD
18637	16745	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16745	19	1904	1904	CD
18637	16745	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16745	21	.	.	.
18637	16746	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16746	2	34	34	CD
18637	16746	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16746	4	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	16746	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16746	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16746	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16746	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16746	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16746	10	,	,	,
18637	16746	11	221	221	CD
18637	16746	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16746	13	361	361	CD
18637	16746	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16746	15	1911	1911	CD
18637	16746	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16746	17	.	.	.
18637	16747	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16747	2	See	See	NNP
18637	16747	3	also	also	RB
18637	16747	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16747	5	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	16747	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16747	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16747	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16747	9	United	United	NNP
18637	16747	10	States	States	NNP
18637	16747	11	,	,	,
18637	16747	12	226	226	CD
18637	16747	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16747	14	478	478	CD
18637	16747	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16747	16	1913	1913	CD
18637	16747	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16747	18	;	;	:
18637	16747	19	Grant	Grant	NNP
18637	16747	20	_	_	NNP
18637	16747	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	16747	22	_	_	NNP
18637	16747	23	United	United	NNP
18637	16747	24	States	States	NNP
18637	16747	25	,	,	,
18637	16747	26	227	227	CD
18637	16747	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16747	28	74	74	CD
18637	16747	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16747	30	1913	1913	CD
18637	16747	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16747	32	.	.	.
18637	16748	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16748	2	35	35	CD
18637	16748	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16748	4	United	United	NNP
18637	16748	5	States	States	NNP
18637	16748	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16748	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16748	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16748	9	White	White	NNP
18637	16748	10	,	,	,
18637	16748	11	322	322	CD
18637	16748	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16748	13	694	694	CD
18637	16748	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16748	15	1944	1944	CD
18637	16748	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16748	17	.	.	.
18637	16749	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16749	2	36	36	CD
18637	16749	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16749	4	Re	Re	NNP
18637	16749	5	Fuller	Fuller	NNP
18637	16749	6	,	,	,
18637	16749	7	262	262	CD
18637	16749	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16749	9	91	91	CD
18637	16749	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16749	11	1923	1923	CD
18637	16749	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16749	13	.	.	.
18637	16750	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16750	2	See	See	NNP
18637	16750	3	also	also	RB
18637	16750	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16750	5	McCarthy	McCarthy	NNP
18637	16750	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16750	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16750	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16750	9	Arndstein	Arndstein	NNP
18637	16750	10	,	,	,
18637	16750	11	266	266	CD
18637	16750	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16750	13	34	34	CD
18637	16750	14	,	,	,
18637	16750	15	41	41	CD
18637	16750	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16750	17	1924	1924	CD
18637	16750	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16750	19	.	.	.
18637	16751	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16751	2	37	37	CD
18637	16751	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16751	4	Perlman	Perlman	NNP
18637	16751	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16751	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16751	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16751	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16751	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16751	10	,	,	,
18637	16751	11	247	247	CD
18637	16751	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16751	13	7	7	CD
18637	16751	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16751	15	1918	1918	CD
18637	16751	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16751	17	.	.	.
18637	16752	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16752	2	38	38	CD
18637	16752	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16752	4	Hale	Hale	NNP
18637	16752	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16752	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16752	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16752	8	Henkel	Henkel	NNP
18637	16752	9	,	,	,
18637	16752	10	201	201	CD
18637	16752	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16752	12	43	43	CD
18637	16752	13	,	,	,
18637	16752	14	76	76	CD
18637	16752	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16752	16	1906	1906	CD
18637	16752	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16752	18	.	.	.
18637	16753	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16753	2	39	39	CD
18637	16753	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16753	4	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	16753	5	Press	Press	NNP
18637	16753	6	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	16753	7	.	.	.
18637	16754	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16754	2	_	_	NNP
18637	16754	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	16754	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16754	5	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	16754	6	,	,	,
18637	16754	7	327	327	CD
18637	16754	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16754	9	186	186	CD
18637	16754	10	,	,	,
18637	16754	11	208	208	CD
18637	16754	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16754	13	1946	1946	CD
18637	16754	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16754	15	.	.	.
18637	16755	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16755	2	40	40	CD
18637	16755	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16755	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	16755	5	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	16755	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	16755	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16755	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	16755	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16755	10	American	American	NNP
18637	16755	11	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	16755	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16755	13	264	264	CD
18637	16755	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16755	15	298	298	CD
18637	16755	16	,	,	,
18637	16755	17	305	305	CD
18637	16755	18	-	-	SYM
18637	16755	19	306	306	CD
18637	16755	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16755	21	1924	1924	CD
18637	16755	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16755	23	.	.	.
18637	16756	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16756	2	41	41	CD
18637	16756	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16756	4	327	327	CD
18637	16756	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16756	6	186	186	CD
18637	16756	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16756	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	16756	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16756	10	.	.	.
18637	16757	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16757	2	42	42	CD
18637	16757	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16757	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16757	5	.	.	.
18637	16758	1	208	208	CD
18637	16758	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16758	3	209	209	CD
18637	16758	4	.	.	.
18637	16759	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16759	2	43	43	CD
18637	16759	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16759	4	United	United	NNP
18637	16759	5	States	States	NNP
18637	16759	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16759	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16759	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16759	9	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	16759	10	,	,	,
18637	16759	11	312	312	CD
18637	16759	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16759	13	100	100	CD
18637	16759	14	,	,	,
18637	16759	15	125	125	CD
18637	16759	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16759	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	16759	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16759	19	.	.	.
18637	16760	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16760	2	44	44	CD
18637	16760	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16760	4	Shapiro	Shapiro	NNP
18637	16760	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16760	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16760	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16760	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16760	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16760	10	,	,	,
18637	16760	11	335	335	CD
18637	16760	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16760	13	1	1	CD
18637	16760	14	,	,	,
18637	16760	15	32	32	CD
18637	16760	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16760	17	1918	1918	CD
18637	16760	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16760	19	.	.	.
18637	16761	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16761	2	45	45	CD
18637	16761	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16761	4	Flint	Flint	NNP
18637	16761	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16761	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16761	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16761	8	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	16761	9	Tracy	Tracy	NNP
18637	16761	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16761	11	,	,	,
18637	16761	12	220	220	CD
18637	16761	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16761	14	107	107	CD
18637	16761	15	,	,	,
18637	16761	16	175	175	CD
18637	16761	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16761	18	1911	1911	CD
18637	16761	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16761	20	.	.	.
18637	16762	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16762	2	46	46	CD
18637	16762	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16762	4	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	16762	5	&	&	CC
18637	16762	6	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	16763	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16763	2	_	_	NNP
18637	16763	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	16763	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16763	5	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	16763	6	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	16763	7	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	16763	8	.	.	.
18637	16763	9	,	,	,
18637	16763	10	21	21	CD
18637	16763	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16763	12	612	612	CD
18637	16763	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16763	14	1911	1911	CD
18637	16763	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16763	16	.	.	.
18637	16764	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16764	2	47	47	CD
18637	16764	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16764	4	United	United	NNP
18637	16764	5	States	States	NNP
18637	16764	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16764	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16764	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16764	9	Bausch	Bausch	NNP
18637	16764	10	&	&	CC
18637	16764	11	L.	L.	NNP
18637	16764	12	Optical	Optical	NNP
18637	16764	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16764	14	,	,	,
18637	16764	15	321	321	CD
18637	16764	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16764	17	707	707	CD
18637	16764	18	,	,	,
18637	16764	19	725	725	CD
18637	16764	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16764	21	1944	1944	CD
18637	16764	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16764	23	.	.	.
18637	16765	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16765	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	16765	3	.	.	.
18637	16765	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16765	5	United	United	NNP
18637	16765	6	States	States	NNP
18637	16765	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16765	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	16765	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16765	10	Morton	Morton	NNP
18637	16765	11	Salt	Salt	NNP
18637	16765	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16765	13	,	,	,
18637	16765	14	338	338	CD
18637	16765	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16765	16	632	632	CD
18637	16765	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16765	18	1950	1950	CD
18637	16765	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16765	20	.	.	.
18637	16766	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16766	2	48	48	CD
18637	16766	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16766	4	Shapiro	Shapiro	NNP
18637	16766	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16766	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16766	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16766	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16766	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16766	10	,	,	,
18637	16766	11	335	335	CD
18637	16766	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16766	13	1	1	CD
18637	16766	14	,	,	,
18637	16766	15	32	32	CD
18637	16766	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16766	17	1948	1948	CD
18637	16766	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16766	19	;	;	:
18637	16766	20	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	16766	21	Press	Press	NNP
18637	16766	22	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	16766	23	.	.	.
18637	16767	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16767	2	_	_	NNP
18637	16767	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	16767	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16767	5	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	16767	6	,	,	,
18637	16767	7	327	327	CD
18637	16767	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16767	9	186	186	CD
18637	16767	10	,	,	,
18637	16767	11	208	208	CD
18637	16767	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16767	13	1946	1946	CD
18637	16767	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16767	15	.	.	.
18637	16768	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16768	2	49	49	CD
18637	16768	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16768	4	Weeks	Weeks	NNP
18637	16768	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16768	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16768	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16768	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16768	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16768	10	,	,	,
18637	16768	11	232	232	CD
18637	16768	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16768	13	383	383	CD
18637	16768	14	,	,	,
18637	16768	15	392	392	CD
18637	16768	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16768	17	1914	1914	CD
18637	16768	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16768	19	.	.	.
18637	16769	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16769	2	50	50	CD
18637	16769	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16769	4	269	269	CD
18637	16769	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16769	6	20	20	CD
18637	16769	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16769	8	1925	1925	CD
18637	16769	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16769	10	.	.	.
18637	16770	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16770	2	51	51	CD
18637	16770	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16770	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16770	5	.	.	.
18637	16771	1	30	30	CD
18637	16771	2	.	.	.
18637	16772	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16772	2	52	52	CD
18637	16772	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16772	4	Marron	Marron	NNP
18637	16772	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16772	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16772	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16772	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16772	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16772	10	,	,	,
18637	16772	11	275	275	CD
18637	16772	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16772	13	192	192	CD
18637	16772	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16772	15	1927	1927	CD
18637	16772	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16772	17	.	.	.
18637	16773	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16773	2	53	53	CD
18637	16773	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16773	4	Go	go	VB
18637	16773	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	16773	6	Bart	Bart	NNP
18637	16773	7	Importing	Importing	NNP
18637	16773	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16773	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16773	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	16773	11	_	_	NNP
18637	16773	12	United	United	NNP
18637	16773	13	States	States	NNP
18637	16773	14	,	,	,
18637	16773	15	282	282	CD
18637	16773	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16773	17	344	344	CD
18637	16773	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16773	19	1931	1931	CD
18637	16773	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16773	21	;	;	:
18637	16773	22	United	United	NNP
18637	16773	23	States	States	NNP
18637	16773	24	_	_	NNP
18637	16773	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	16773	26	_	_	NNP
18637	16773	27	Lefkowitz	Lefkowitz	NNP
18637	16773	28	,	,	,
18637	16773	29	285	285	CD
18637	16773	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16773	31	452	452	CD
18637	16773	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16773	33	1932	1932	CD
18637	16773	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16773	35	.	.	.
18637	16774	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16774	2	54	54	CD
18637	16774	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16774	4	Byars	Byars	NNPS
18637	16774	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16774	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16774	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16774	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16774	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16774	10	,	,	,
18637	16774	11	273	273	CD
18637	16774	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16774	13	28	28	CD
18637	16774	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16774	15	1927	1927	CD
18637	16774	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16774	17	;	;	:
18637	16774	18	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	16774	19	_	_	NNP
18637	16774	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	16774	21	_	_	NNP
18637	16774	22	United	United	NNP
18637	16774	23	States	States	NNP
18637	16774	24	,	,	,
18637	16774	25	333	333	CD
18637	16774	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16774	27	10	10	CD
18637	16774	28	,	,	,
18637	16774	29	16	16	CD
18637	16774	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16774	31	1948	1948	CD
18637	16774	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16774	33	.	.	.
18637	16775	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16775	2	55	55	CD
18637	16775	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16775	4	331	331	CD
18637	16775	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16775	6	145	145	CD
18637	16775	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16775	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	16775	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16775	10	.	.	.
18637	16776	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16776	2	56	56	CD
18637	16776	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16776	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16776	5	.	.	.
18637	16777	1	153	153	CD
18637	16777	2	,	,	,
18637	16777	3	155	155	CD
18637	16777	4	.	.	.
18637	16778	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16778	2	57	57	CD
18637	16778	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16778	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16778	5	.	.	.
18637	16779	1	165	165	CD
18637	16779	2	.	.	.
18637	16780	1	Separate	separate	JJ
18637	16780	2	dissenting	dissenting	NN
18637	16780	3	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	16780	4	were	be	VBD
18637	16780	5	written	write	VBN
18637	16780	6	by	by	IN
18637	16780	7	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	16780	8	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	16780	9	and	and	CC
18637	16780	10	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	16780	11	.	.	.
18637	16781	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16781	2	58	58	CD
18637	16781	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16781	4	339	339	CD
18637	16781	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16781	6	56	56	CD
18637	16781	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16781	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	16781	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16781	10	.	.	.
18637	16782	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16782	2	59	59	CD
18637	16782	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16782	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16782	5	.	.	.
18637	16783	1	64	64	CD
18637	16783	2	.	.	.
18637	16784	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16784	2	60	60	CD
18637	16784	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16784	4	334	334	CD
18637	16784	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16784	6	699	699	CD
18637	16784	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16784	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	16784	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16784	10	;	;	:
18637	16784	11	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	16784	12	_	_	NNP
18637	16784	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	16784	14	_	_	NNP
18637	16784	15	United	United	NNP
18637	16784	16	States	States	NNP
18637	16784	17	,	,	,
18637	16784	18	335	335	CD
18637	16784	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16784	20	451	451	CD
18637	16784	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16784	22	1948	1948	CD
18637	16784	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16784	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	16784	25	also	also	RB
18637	16784	26	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	16784	27	in	in	IN
18637	16784	28	effect	effect	NN
18637	16784	29	,	,	,
18637	16784	30	although	although	IN
18637	16784	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16784	32	was	be	VBD
18637	16784	33	not	not	RB
18637	16784	34	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	16784	35	in	in	IN
18637	16784	36	the	the	DT
18637	16784	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16784	38	's	's	POS
18637	16784	39	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16784	40	.	.	.
18637	16785	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16785	2	61	61	CD
18637	16785	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16785	4	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	16785	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16785	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16785	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16785	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16785	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16785	10	,	,	,
18637	16785	11	267	267	CD
18637	16785	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16785	13	132	132	CD
18637	16785	14	,	,	,
18637	16785	15	153	153	CD
18637	16785	16	-	-	SYM
18637	16785	17	156	156	CD
18637	16785	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16785	19	1925	1925	CD
18637	16785	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16785	21	.	.	.
18637	16786	1	Husty	Husty	NNP
18637	16786	2	_	_	NNP
18637	16786	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	16786	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16786	5	United	United	NNP
18637	16786	6	States	States	NNP
18637	16786	7	,	,	,
18637	16786	8	282	282	CD
18637	16786	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16786	10	694	694	CD
18637	16786	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16786	12	1931	1931	CD
18637	16786	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16786	14	;	;	:
18637	16786	15	Brinegar	Brinegar	NNP
18637	16786	16	_	_	NNP
18637	16786	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	16786	18	_	_	NNP
18637	16786	19	United	United	NNP
18637	16786	20	States	States	NNP
18637	16786	21	,	,	,
18637	16786	22	338	338	CD
18637	16786	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16786	24	160	160	CD
18637	16786	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16786	26	1949	1949	CD
18637	16786	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16786	28	.	.	.
18637	16787	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16787	2	62	62	CD
18637	16787	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16787	4	Scher	Scher	NNP
18637	16787	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16787	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16787	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16787	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16787	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16787	10	,	,	,
18637	16787	11	305	305	CD
18637	16787	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16787	13	251	251	CD
18637	16787	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16787	15	1938	1938	CD
18637	16787	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16787	17	.	.	.
18637	16788	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16788	2	63	63	CD
18637	16788	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16788	4	United	United	NNP
18637	16788	5	States	States	NNP
18637	16788	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16788	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16788	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16788	9	Di	Di	NNP
18637	16788	10	Re	Re	NNP
18637	16788	11	,	,	,
18637	16788	12	332	332	CD
18637	16788	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16788	14	581	581	CD
18637	16788	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16788	16	1948	1948	CD
18637	16788	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16788	18	.	.	.
18637	16789	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16789	2	64	64	CD
18637	16789	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16789	4	Weeks	Weeks	NNP
18637	16789	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16789	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16789	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16789	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16789	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16789	10	,	,	,
18637	16789	11	232	232	CD
18637	16789	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16789	13	383	383	CD
18637	16789	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16789	15	1914	1914	CD
18637	16789	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16789	17	.	.	.
18637	16790	1	This	this	DT
18637	16790	2	case	case	NN
18637	16790	3	was	be	VBD
18637	16790	4	a	a	DT
18637	16790	5	virtual	virtual	JJ
18637	16790	6	repudiation	repudiation	NN
18637	16790	7	of	of	IN
18637	16790	8	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	16790	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16790	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	16790	11	_	_	NNP
18637	16790	12	New	New	NNP
18637	16790	13	York	York	NNP
18637	16790	14	,	,	,
18637	16790	15	192	192	CD
18637	16790	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16790	17	585	585	CD
18637	16790	18	,	,	,
18637	16790	19	597	597	CD
18637	16790	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16790	21	1904	1904	CD
18637	16790	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16790	23	.	.	.
18637	16791	1	There	there	RB
18637	16791	2	the	the	DT
18637	16791	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16791	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16791	5	had	have	VBD
18637	16791	6	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	16791	7	that	that	IN
18637	16791	8	in	in	IN
18637	16791	9	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16791	10	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16791	11	in	in	IN
18637	16791	12	a	a	DT
18637	16791	13	State	State	NNP
18637	16791	14	court	court	NN
18637	16791	15	the	the	DT
18637	16791	16	use	use	NN
18637	16791	17	of	of	IN
18637	16791	18	private	private	JJ
18637	16791	19	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16791	20	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	16791	21	by	by	IN
18637	16791	22	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	16791	23	search	search	NN
18637	16791	24	and	and	CC
18637	16791	25	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16791	26	"	"	''
18637	16791	27	was	be	VBD
18637	16791	28	no	no	DT
18637	16791	29	violation	violation	NN
18637	16791	30	of	of	IN
18637	16791	31	the	the	DT
18637	16791	32	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16791	33	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	16791	34	of	of	IN
18637	16791	35	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	16791	36	from	from	IN
18637	16791	37	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	16791	38	search	search	NN
18637	16791	39	or	or	CC
18637	16791	40	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	16791	41	.	.	.
18637	16791	42	"	"	''
18637	16792	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16792	2	added	add	VBD
18637	16792	3	:	:	:
18637	16792	4	"	"	``
18637	16792	5	Nor	nor	CC
18637	16792	6	do	do	VBP
18637	16792	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16792	8	think	think	VB
18637	16792	9	the	the	DT
18637	16792	10	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16792	11	was	be	VBD
18637	16792	12	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	16792	13	to	to	TO
18637	16792	14	incriminate	incriminate	VB
18637	16792	15	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16792	16	.	.	.
18637	16792	17	"	"	''
18637	16793	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16793	2	65	65	CD
18637	16793	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16793	4	Wolf	Wolf	NNP
18637	16793	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16793	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16793	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16793	8	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	16793	9	,	,	,
18637	16793	10	338	338	CD
18637	16793	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16793	12	25	25	CD
18637	16793	13	,	,	,
18637	16793	14	29	29	CD
18637	16793	15	,	,	,
18637	16793	16	38	38	CD
18637	16793	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16793	18	1949	1949	CD
18637	16793	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16793	20	;	;	:
18637	16793	21	8	8	CD
18637	16793	22	Wigmore	wigmore	RB
18637	16793	23	on	on	IN
18637	16793	24	Evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16793	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16793	26	3d	3d	NNP
18637	16793	27	ed	ed	NNP
18637	16793	28	.	.	.
18637	16793	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16794	1	§	§	NNP
18637	16794	2	2184	2184	CD
18637	16794	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16794	4	1940	1940	CD
18637	16794	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16794	6	.	.	.
18637	16795	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16795	2	66	66	CD
18637	16795	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16795	4	338	338	CD
18637	16795	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16795	6	25	25	CD
18637	16795	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16795	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	16795	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16795	10	.	.	.
18637	16796	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16796	2	67	67	CD
18637	16796	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16796	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16796	5	.	.	.
18637	16797	1	33	33	CD
18637	16797	2	.	.	.
18637	16798	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16798	2	68	68	CD
18637	16798	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16798	4	Burdeau	Burdeau	NNP
18637	16798	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16798	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16798	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16798	8	McDowell	McDowell	NNP
18637	16798	9	,	,	,
18637	16798	10	256	256	CD
18637	16798	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16798	12	465	465	CD
18637	16798	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16798	14	1921	1921	CD
18637	16798	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16798	16	.	.	.
18637	16799	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16799	2	69	69	CD
18637	16799	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16799	4	Byars	Byars	NNPS
18637	16799	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16799	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16799	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16799	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16799	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16799	10	,	,	,
18637	16799	11	273	273	CD
18637	16799	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16799	13	28	28	CD
18637	16799	14	,	,	,
18637	16799	15	33	33	CD
18637	16799	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16799	17	1927	1927	CD
18637	16799	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16799	19	.	.	.
18637	16800	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16800	2	70	70	CD
18637	16800	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16800	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16800	5	.	.	.
18637	16801	1	32	32	LS
18637	16801	2	;	;	:
18637	16801	3	Lustig	Lustig	NNP
18637	16801	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16801	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	16801	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16801	7	United	United	NNP
18637	16801	8	States	States	NNP
18637	16801	9	,	,	,
18637	16801	10	338	338	CD
18637	16801	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16801	12	74	74	CD
18637	16801	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16801	14	1949	1949	CD
18637	16801	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16801	16	.	.	.
18637	16802	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16802	2	71	71	CD
18637	16802	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16802	4	Gambino	Gambino	NNP
18637	16802	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16802	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16802	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16802	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16802	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16802	10	,	,	,
18637	16802	11	275	275	CD
18637	16802	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16802	13	310	310	CD
18637	16802	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16802	15	1927	1927	CD
18637	16802	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16802	17	.	.	.
18637	16803	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16803	2	72	72	CD
18637	16803	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16803	4	Lustig	Lustig	NNP
18637	16803	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16803	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16803	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16803	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16803	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16803	10	,	,	,
18637	16803	11	338	338	CD
18637	16803	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16803	13	74	74	CD
18637	16803	14	,	,	,
18637	16803	15	78	78	CD
18637	16803	16	,	,	,
18637	16803	17	79	79	CD
18637	16803	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16803	19	1949	1949	CD
18637	16803	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16803	21	.	.	.
18637	16804	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16804	2	73	73	CD
18637	16804	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16804	4	McGuire	McGuire	NNP
18637	16804	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16804	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16804	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16804	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16804	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16804	10	,	,	,
18637	16804	11	273	273	CD
18637	16804	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16804	13	95	95	CD
18637	16804	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16804	15	1927	1927	CD
18637	16804	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16804	17	.	.	.
18637	16805	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16805	2	74	74	CD
18637	16805	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16805	4	251	251	CD
18637	16805	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16805	6	385	385	CD
18637	16805	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16805	8	1920	1920	CD
18637	16805	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16805	10	.	.	.
18637	16806	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16806	2	75	75	CD
18637	16806	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16806	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	16806	5	.	.	.
18637	16807	1	392	392	CD
18637	16807	2	.	.	.
18637	16808	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16808	2	76	76	CD
18637	16808	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16808	4	United	United	NNP
18637	16808	5	States	States	NNP
18637	16808	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16808	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16808	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16808	9	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	16808	10	&	&	CC
18637	16808	11	Tiernan	Tiernan	NNP
18637	16808	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16808	13	,	,	,
18637	16808	14	336	336	CD
18637	16808	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16808	16	793	793	CD
18637	16808	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16808	18	1949	1949	CD
18637	16808	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16808	20	.	.	.
18637	16809	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16809	2	77	77	CD
18637	16809	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16809	4	Zap	Zap	NNP
18637	16809	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16809	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16809	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16809	8	United	United	NNP
18637	16809	9	States	States	NNP
18637	16809	10	,	,	,
18637	16809	11	328	328	CD
18637	16809	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16809	13	624	624	CD
18637	16809	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16809	15	1946	1946	CD
18637	16809	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16809	17	.	.	.
18637	16810	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16810	2	78	78	CD
18637	16810	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16810	4	American	American	NNP
18637	16810	5	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	16810	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16810	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16810	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	16810	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16810	10	Werckmeister	Werckmeister	NNP
18637	16810	11	,	,	,
18637	16810	12	207	207	CD
18637	16810	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	16810	14	284	284	CD
18637	16810	15	,	,	,
18637	16810	16	302	302	CD
18637	16810	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16810	18	1907	1907	CD
18637	16810	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16810	20	.	.	.
18637	16811	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	16811	2	5	5	CD
18637	16811	3	RIGHTS	right	NNS
18637	16811	4	OF	of	IN
18637	16811	5	PERSONS	PERSONS	NNP
18637	16811	6	Page	Page	NNP
18637	16811	7	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	16811	8	of	of	IN
18637	16811	9	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16811	10	persons	person	NNS
18637	16811	11	837	837	CD
18637	16811	12	The	the	DT
18637	16811	13	grand	grand	JJ
18637	16811	14	jury	jury	NN
18637	16811	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	16811	16	837	837	CD
18637	16811	17	Double	double	JJ
18637	16811	18	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	16811	19	838	838	CD
18637	16811	20	Self	self	NN
18637	16811	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	16811	22	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	16811	23	841	841	CD
18637	16811	24	Source	Source	NNP
18637	16811	25	of	of	IN
18637	16811	26	the	the	DT
18637	16811	27	clause	clause	NN
18637	16811	28	841	841	CD
18637	16811	29	Due	due	JJ
18637	16811	30	process	process	NN
18637	16811	31	of	of	IN
18637	16811	32	law	law	NN
18637	16811	33	844	844	CD
18637	16811	34	Source	source	NN
18637	16811	35	and	and	CC
18637	16811	36	evolution	evolution	NN
18637	16811	37	of	of	IN
18637	16811	38	the	the	DT
18637	16811	39	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	16811	40	of	of	IN
18637	16811	41	the	the	DT
18637	16811	42	term	term	NN
18637	16811	43	844	844	CD
18637	16811	44	Scope	scope	NN
18637	16811	45	of	of	IN
18637	16811	46	the	the	DT
18637	16811	47	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	16811	48	846	846	CD
18637	16811	49	Procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	16811	50	due	due	JJ
18637	16811	51	process	process	NN
18637	16811	52	846	846	CD
18637	16811	53	General	General	NNP
18637	16811	54	846	846	CD
18637	16811	55	Criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16811	56	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	16811	57	847	847	CD
18637	16811	58	Notice	notice	NN
18637	16811	59	and	and	CC
18637	16811	60	hearing	hear	VBG
18637	16811	61	847	847	CD
18637	16811	62	Evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16811	63	and	and	CC
18637	16811	64	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	16811	65	in	in	IN
18637	16811	66	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16811	67	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16811	68	848	848	CD
18637	16811	69	Administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	16811	70	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16811	71	849	849	CD
18637	16811	72	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	16811	73	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16811	74	849	849	CD
18637	16811	75	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16811	76	review	review	NN
18637	16811	77	850	850	CD
18637	16811	78	Aliens	Aliens	NNP
18637	16811	79	851	851	CD
18637	16811	80	Deportation	Deportation	NNP
18637	16811	81	852	852	CD
18637	16811	82	Substantive	Substantive	NNP
18637	16811	83	due	due	JJ
18637	16811	84	process	process	NN
18637	16811	85	853	853	CD
18637	16811	86	Discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	16811	87	853	853	CD
18637	16811	88	Deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	16811	89	of	of	IN
18637	16811	90	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16811	91	854	854	CD
18637	16811	92	Deprivation	Deprivation	NNP
18637	16811	93	of	of	IN
18637	16811	94	property	property	NN
18637	16811	95	855	855	CD
18637	16811	96	Retroactive	Retroactive	NNP
18637	16811	97	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	16811	98	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	16811	99	855	855	CD
18637	16811	100	Retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	16811	101	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	16811	102	disallowed	disallow	VBD
18637	16811	103	857	857	CD
18637	16811	104	Bankruptcy	Bankruptcy	NNP
18637	16811	105	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	16811	106	857	857	CD
18637	16811	107	Right	right	JJ
18637	16811	108	to	to	TO
18637	16811	109	sue	sue	VB
18637	16811	110	the	the	DT
18637	16811	111	government	government	NN
18637	16811	112	858	858	CD
18637	16811	113	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	16811	114	police	police	NN
18637	16811	115	measures	measure	NNS
18637	16811	116	859	859	CD
18637	16811	117	The	the	DT
18637	16811	118	postal	postal	JJ
18637	16811	119	service	service	NN
18637	16811	120	859	859	CD
18637	16811	121	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	16811	122	of	of	IN
18637	16811	123	public	public	JJ
18637	16811	124	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	16811	125	860	860	CD
18637	16811	126	Regulation	regulation	NN
18637	16811	127	of	of	IN
18637	16811	128	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	16811	129	861	861	CD
18637	16811	130	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	16811	131	862	862	CD
18637	16811	132	Retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	16811	133	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	16811	134	863	863	CD
18637	16811	135	Governance	governance	NN
18637	16811	136	of	of	IN
18637	16811	137	the	the	DT
18637	16811	138	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	16811	139	864	864	CD
18637	16811	140	The	the	DT
18637	16811	141	national	national	JJ
18637	16811	142	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	16811	143	domain	domain	NN
18637	16811	144	power	power	NN
18637	16811	145	864	864	CD
18637	16811	146	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	16811	147	of	of	IN
18637	16811	148	power	power	NN
18637	16811	149	864	864	CD
18637	16811	150	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	16811	151	property	property	NN
18637	16811	152	865	865	CD
18637	16811	153	Public	public	JJ
18637	16811	154	use	use	NN
18637	16811	155	865	865	CD
18637	16811	156	Rights	right	NNS
18637	16811	157	for	for	IN
18637	16811	158	which	which	WDT
18637	16811	159	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	16811	160	must	must	MD
18637	16811	161	be	be	VB
18637	16811	162	made	make	VBN
18637	16811	163	866	866	CD
18637	16811	164	When	when	WRB
18637	16811	165	property	property	NN
18637	16811	166	is	be	VBZ
18637	16811	167	taken	take	VBN
18637	16811	168	867	867	CD
18637	16811	169	Navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	16811	170	waters	water	NNS
18637	16811	171	867	867	CD
18637	16811	172	Just	just	RB
18637	16811	173	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	16811	174	869	869	CD
18637	16811	175	Interest	interest	NN
18637	16811	176	871	871	CD
18637	16811	177	Enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	16811	178	of	of	IN
18637	16811	179	right	right	NN
18637	16811	180	to	to	IN
18637	16811	181	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	16811	182	872	872	CD
18637	16811	183	RIGHTS	right	NNS
18637	16811	184	OF	of	IN
18637	16811	185	PERSONS	PERSONS	NNP
18637	16811	186	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16811	187	5	5	CD
18637	16811	188	No	no	DT
18637	16811	189	person	person	NN
18637	16811	190	shall	shall	MD
18637	16811	191	be	be	VB
18637	16811	192	held	hold	VBN
18637	16811	193	to	to	TO
18637	16811	194	answer	answer	VB
18637	16811	195	for	for	IN
18637	16811	196	a	a	DT
18637	16811	197	capital	capital	NN
18637	16811	198	,	,	,
18637	16811	199	or	or	CC
18637	16811	200	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	16811	201	infamous	infamous	JJ
18637	16811	202	crime	crime	NN
18637	16811	203	,	,	,
18637	16811	204	unless	unless	IN
18637	16811	205	on	on	IN
18637	16811	206	a	a	DT
18637	16811	207	presentment	presentment	NN
18637	16811	208	or	or	CC
18637	16811	209	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16811	210	of	of	IN
18637	16811	211	a	a	DT
18637	16811	212	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	16811	213	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	16811	214	,	,	,
18637	16811	215	except	except	IN
18637	16811	216	in	in	IN
18637	16811	217	cases	case	NNS
18637	16811	218	arising	arise	VBG
18637	16811	219	in	in	IN
18637	16811	220	the	the	DT
18637	16811	221	land	land	NN
18637	16811	222	or	or	CC
18637	16811	223	naval	naval	JJ
18637	16811	224	forces	force	NNS
18637	16811	225	,	,	,
18637	16811	226	or	or	CC
18637	16811	227	in	in	IN
18637	16811	228	the	the	DT
18637	16811	229	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	16811	230	,	,	,
18637	16811	231	when	when	WRB
18637	16811	232	in	in	IN
18637	16811	233	actual	actual	JJ
18637	16811	234	service	service	NN
18637	16811	235	in	in	IN
18637	16811	236	time	time	NN
18637	16811	237	of	of	IN
18637	16811	238	War	War	NNP
18637	16811	239	or	or	CC
18637	16811	240	public	public	JJ
18637	16811	241	danger	danger	NN
18637	16811	242	;	;	:
18637	16811	243	nor	nor	CC
18637	16811	244	shall	shall	MD
18637	16811	245	any	any	DT
18637	16811	246	person	person	NN
18637	16811	247	be	be	VB
18637	16811	248	subject	subject	JJ
18637	16811	249	for	for	IN
18637	16811	250	the	the	DT
18637	16811	251	same	same	JJ
18637	16811	252	offense	offense	NN
18637	16811	253	to	to	TO
18637	16811	254	be	be	VB
18637	16811	255	twice	twice	RB
18637	16811	256	put	put	VBN
18637	16811	257	in	in	IN
18637	16811	258	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	16811	259	of	of	IN
18637	16811	260	life	life	NN
18637	16811	261	or	or	CC
18637	16811	262	limb	limb	NN
18637	16811	263	;	;	,
18637	16811	264	nor	nor	CC
18637	16811	265	shall	shall	MD
18637	16811	266	be	be	VB
18637	16811	267	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	16811	268	in	in	IN
18637	16811	269	any	any	DT
18637	16811	270	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16811	271	case	case	NN
18637	16811	272	to	to	TO
18637	16811	273	be	be	VB
18637	16811	274	a	a	DT
18637	16811	275	witness	witness	NN
18637	16811	276	against	against	IN
18637	16811	277	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16811	278	,	,	,
18637	16811	279	nor	nor	CC
18637	16811	280	be	be	VB
18637	16811	281	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	16811	282	of	of	IN
18637	16811	283	life	life	NN
18637	16811	284	,	,	,
18637	16811	285	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16811	286	,	,	,
18637	16811	287	or	or	CC
18637	16811	288	property	property	NN
18637	16811	289	,	,	,
18637	16811	290	without	without	IN
18637	16811	291	due	due	JJ
18637	16811	292	process	process	NN
18637	16811	293	of	of	IN
18637	16811	294	law	law	NN
18637	16811	295	;	;	:
18637	16811	296	nor	nor	CC
18637	16811	297	shall	shall	MD
18637	16811	298	private	private	JJ
18637	16811	299	property	property	NN
18637	16811	300	be	be	VB
18637	16811	301	taken	take	VBN
18637	16811	302	for	for	IN
18637	16811	303	public	public	JJ
18637	16811	304	use	use	NN
18637	16811	305	,	,	,
18637	16811	306	without	without	IN
18637	16811	307	just	just	RB
18637	16811	308	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	16811	309	.	.	.
18637	16812	1	Rights	right	NNS
18637	16812	2	of	of	IN
18637	16812	3	Accused	Accused	NNP
18637	16812	4	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	16812	5	THE	the	DT
18637	16812	6	GRAND	GRAND	NNP
18637	16812	7	JURY	jury	NN
18637	16812	8	CLAUSE	CLAUSE	VBN
18637	16812	9	Within	within	IN
18637	16812	10	the	the	DT
18637	16812	11	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	16812	12	of	of	IN
18637	16812	13	this	this	DT
18637	16812	14	article	article	NN
18637	16812	15	a	a	DT
18637	16812	16	crime	crime	NN
18637	16812	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	16812	18	made	make	VBN
18637	16812	19	"	"	``
18637	16812	20	infamous	infamous	JJ
18637	16812	21	"	"	''
18637	16812	22	by	by	IN
18637	16812	23	the	the	DT
18637	16812	24	quality	quality	NN
18637	16812	25	of	of	IN
18637	16812	26	the	the	DT
18637	16812	27	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	16812	28	which	which	WDT
18637	16812	29	may	may	MD
18637	16812	30	be	be	VB
18637	16812	31	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	16812	32	.	.	.
18637	16813	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16813	2	1	1	LS
18637	16813	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16813	4	The	the	DT
18637	16813	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16813	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	16813	7	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	16813	8	that	that	DT
18637	16813	9	:	:	:
18637	16813	10	"	"	``
18637	16813	11	What	what	WDT
18637	16813	12	punishments	punishment	NNS
18637	16813	13	shall	shall	MD
18637	16813	14	be	be	VB
18637	16813	15	considered	consider	VBN
18637	16813	16	as	as	IN
18637	16813	17	infamous	infamous	JJ
18637	16813	18	may	may	MD
18637	16813	19	be	be	VB
18637	16813	20	affected	affect	VBN
18637	16813	21	by	by	IN
18637	16813	22	the	the	DT
18637	16813	23	changes	change	NNS
18637	16813	24	of	of	IN
18637	16813	25	public	public	JJ
18637	16813	26	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16813	27	from	from	IN
18637	16813	28	one	one	CD
18637	16813	29	age	age	NN
18637	16813	30	to	to	IN
18637	16813	31	another	another	DT
18637	16813	32	.	.	.
18637	16814	1	"	"	``
18637	16814	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16814	3	2	2	CD
18637	16814	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16814	5	Imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	16814	6	in	in	IN
18637	16814	7	a	a	DT
18637	16814	8	State	State	NNP
18637	16814	9	prison	prison	NN
18637	16814	10	or	or	CC
18637	16814	11	penitentiary	penitentiary	JJ
18637	16814	12	,	,	,
18637	16814	13	with	with	IN
18637	16814	14	or	or	CC
18637	16814	15	without	without	IN
18637	16814	16	hard	hard	JJ
18637	16814	17	labor,[3	labor,[3	NN
18637	16814	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16814	19	or	or	CC
18637	16814	20	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	16814	21	at	at	IN
18637	16814	22	hard	hard	JJ
18637	16814	23	labor	labor	NN
18637	16814	24	in	in	IN
18637	16814	25	the	the	DT
18637	16814	26	workhouse	workhouse	NN
18637	16814	27	of	of	IN
18637	16814	28	the	the	DT
18637	16814	29	District	District	NNP
18637	16814	30	of	of	IN
18637	16814	31	Columbia,[4	Columbia,[4	NNP
18637	16814	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16814	33	falls	fall	VBZ
18637	16814	34	within	within	IN
18637	16814	35	this	this	DT
18637	16814	36	category	category	NN
18637	16814	37	.	.	.
18637	16815	1	The	the	DT
18637	16815	2	pivotal	pivotal	JJ
18637	16815	3	question	question	NN
18637	16815	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	16815	5	whether	whether	IN
18637	16815	6	the	the	DT
18637	16815	7	offense	offense	NN
18637	16815	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	16815	9	one	one	CD
18637	16815	10	for	for	IN
18637	16815	11	which	which	WDT
18637	16815	12	the	the	DT
18637	16815	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16815	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	16815	15	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	16815	16	to	to	TO
18637	16815	17	award	award	VB
18637	16815	18	such	such	JJ
18637	16815	19	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	16815	20	;	;	:
18637	16815	21	the	the	DT
18637	16815	22	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	16815	23	actually	actually	RB
18637	16815	24	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	16815	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	16815	26	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
18637	16815	27	.	.	.
18637	16816	1	When	when	WRB
18637	16816	2	an	an	DT
18637	16816	3	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16816	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	16816	5	in	in	IN
18637	16816	6	danger	danger	NN
18637	16816	7	of	of	IN
18637	16816	8	being	be	VBG
18637	16816	9	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	16816	10	to	to	IN
18637	16816	11	an	an	DT
18637	16816	12	infamous	infamous	JJ
18637	16816	13	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	16816	14	if	if	IN
18637	16816	15	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	16816	16	,	,	,
18637	16816	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16816	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	16816	19	the	the	DT
18637	16816	20	right	right	NN
18637	16816	21	to	to	TO
18637	16816	22	insist	insist	VB
18637	16816	23	that	that	IN
18637	16816	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16816	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	16816	26	not	not	RB
18637	16816	27	be	be	VB
18637	16816	28	put	put	VBN
18637	16816	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	16816	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16816	31	trial	trial	NN
18637	16816	32	,	,	,
18637	16816	33	except	except	IN
18637	16816	34	on	on	IN
18637	16816	35	the	the	DT
18637	16816	36	accusation	accusation	NN
18637	16816	37	of	of	IN
18637	16816	38	a	a	DT
18637	16816	39	grand	grand	JJ
18637	16816	40	jury	jury	NN
18637	16816	41	.	.	.
18637	16817	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16817	2	5	5	CD
18637	16817	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16817	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	16817	5	,	,	,
18637	16817	6	an	an	DT
18637	16817	7	act	act	NN
18637	16817	8	which	which	WDT
18637	16817	9	authorizes	authorize	VBZ
18637	16817	10	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	16817	11	at	at	IN
18637	16817	12	hard	hard	JJ
18637	16817	13	labor	labor	NN
18637	16817	14	for	for	IN
18637	16817	15	one	one	CD
18637	16817	16	year	year	NN
18637	16817	17	,	,	,
18637	16817	18	as	as	RB
18637	16817	19	well	well	RB
18637	16817	20	as	as	IN
18637	16817	21	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	16817	22	,	,	,
18637	16817	23	of	of	IN
18637	16817	24	Chinese	chinese	JJ
18637	16817	25	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	16817	26	found	find	VBN
18637	16817	27	to	to	TO
18637	16817	28	be	be	VB
18637	16817	29	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	16817	30	within	within	IN
18637	16817	31	the	the	DT
18637	16817	32	United	United	NNP
18637	16817	33	States	States	NNP
18637	16817	34	,	,	,
18637	16817	35	creates	create	VBZ
18637	16817	36	an	an	DT
18637	16817	37	offense	offense	NN
18637	16817	38	which	which	WDT
18637	16817	39	can	can	MD
18637	16817	40	be	be	VB
18637	16817	41	tried	try	VBN
18637	16817	42	only	only	RB
18637	16817	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	16817	44	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16817	45	.	.	.
18637	16818	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16818	2	6	6	CD
18637	16818	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16818	4	Counterfeiting,[7	Counterfeiting,[7	NNP
18637	16818	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16818	6	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	16818	7	alteration	alteration	NN
18637	16818	8	of	of	IN
18637	16818	9	poll	poll	NNP
18637	16818	10	books,[8	books,[8	NNP
18637	16818	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16818	12	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	16818	13	voting,[9	voting,[9	NNPS
18637	16818	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16818	15	and	and	CC
18637	16818	16	embezzlement[10	embezzlement[10	NNP
18637	16818	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16818	18	have	have	VBP
18637	16818	19	been	be	VBN
18637	16818	20	declared	declare	VBN
18637	16818	21	to	to	TO
18637	16818	22	be	be	VB
18637	16818	23	infamous	infamous	JJ
18637	16818	24	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	16818	25	.	.	.
18637	16819	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16819	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	16819	3	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
18637	16819	4	how	how	WRB
18637	16819	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16819	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	16819	7	classified	classify	VBN
18637	16819	8	the	the	DT
18637	16819	9	offense	offense	NN
18637	16819	10	.	.	.
18637	16820	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16820	2	11	11	CD
18637	16820	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16820	4	An	an	DT
18637	16820	5	act	act	NN
18637	16820	6	punishable	punishable	JJ
18637	16820	7	by	by	IN
18637	16820	8	a	a	DT
18637	16820	9	fine	fine	NN
18637	16820	10	of	of	IN
18637	16820	11	not	not	RB
18637	16820	12	more	more	JJR
18637	16820	13	than	than	IN
18637	16820	14	$	$	$
18637	16820	15	1,000	1,000	CD
18637	16820	16	or	or	CC
18637	16820	17	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	16820	18	for	for	IN
18637	16820	19	not	not	RB
18637	16820	20	more	more	JJR
18637	16820	21	than	than	IN
18637	16820	22	six	six	CD
18637	16820	23	months	month	NNS
18637	16820	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	16820	25	a	a	DT
18637	16820	26	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
18637	16820	27	,	,	,
18637	16820	28	which	which	WDT
18637	16820	29	can	can	MD
18637	16820	30	be	be	VB
18637	16820	31	tried	try	VBN
18637	16820	32	without	without	IN
18637	16820	33	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16820	34	,	,	,
18637	16820	35	even	even	RB
18637	16820	36	though	though	IN
18637	16820	37	the	the	DT
18637	16820	38	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	16820	39	exceeds	exceed	VBZ
18637	16820	40	that	that	IN
18637	16820	41	specified	specify	VBN
18637	16820	42	in	in	IN
18637	16820	43	the	the	DT
18637	16820	44	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	16820	45	definition	definition	NN
18637	16820	46	of	of	IN
18637	16820	47	"	"	``
18637	16820	48	petty	petty	JJ
18637	16820	49	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	16820	50	.	.	.
18637	16821	1	"	"	``
18637	16821	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16821	3	12	12	CD
18637	16821	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16821	5	A	a	DT
18637	16821	6	person	person	NN
18637	16821	7	can	can	MD
18637	16821	8	be	be	VB
18637	16821	9	tried	try	VBN
18637	16821	10	only	only	RB
18637	16821	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	16821	12	the	the	DT
18637	16821	13	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16821	14	as	as	IN
18637	16821	15	found	find	VBN
18637	16821	16	by	by	IN
18637	16821	17	the	the	DT
18637	16821	18	grand	grand	JJ
18637	16821	19	jury	jury	NN
18637	16821	20	,	,	,
18637	16821	21	and	and	CC
18637	16821	22	especially	especially	RB
18637	16821	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	16821	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16821	25	language	language	NN
18637	16821	26	found	find	VBN
18637	16821	27	in	in	IN
18637	16821	28	the	the	DT
18637	16821	29	charging	charge	VBG
18637	16821	30	part	part	NN
18637	16821	31	of	of	IN
18637	16821	32	the	the	DT
18637	16821	33	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	16821	34	.	.	.
18637	16822	1	A	a	DT
18637	16822	2	change	change	NN
18637	16822	3	in	in	IN
18637	16822	4	the	the	DT
18637	16822	5	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16822	6	deprives	deprive	VBZ
18637	16822	7	the	the	DT
18637	16822	8	court	court	NN
18637	16822	9	of	of	IN
18637	16822	10	the	the	DT
18637	16822	11	power	power	NN
18637	16822	12	to	to	TO
18637	16822	13	try	try	VB
18637	16822	14	the	the	DT
18637	16822	15	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16822	16	.	.	.
18637	16823	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16823	2	13	13	CD
18637	16823	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16823	4	There	there	EX
18637	16823	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	16823	6	no	no	DT
18637	16823	7	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16823	8	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	16823	9	that	that	IN
18637	16823	10	an	an	DT
18637	16823	11	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16823	12	be	be	VB
18637	16823	13	presented	present	VBN
18637	16823	14	by	by	IN
18637	16823	15	a	a	DT
18637	16823	16	grand	grand	JJ
18637	16823	17	jury	jury	NN
18637	16823	18	in	in	IN
18637	16823	19	a	a	DT
18637	16823	20	body	body	NN
18637	16823	21	;	;	:
18637	16823	22	an	an	DT
18637	16823	23	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16823	24	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	16823	25	by	by	IN
18637	16823	26	the	the	DT
18637	16823	27	foreman	foreman	NN
18637	16823	28	in	in	IN
18637	16823	29	the	the	DT
18637	16823	30	absence	absence	NN
18637	16823	31	of	of	IN
18637	16823	32	the	the	DT
18637	16823	33	other	other	JJ
18637	16823	34	grand	grand	JJ
18637	16823	35	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	16823	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	16823	37	valid	valid	JJ
18637	16823	38	.	.	.
18637	16824	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16824	2	14	14	CD
18637	16824	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16824	4	The	the	DT
18637	16824	5	words	word	NNS
18637	16824	6	"	"	``
18637	16824	7	when	when	WRB
18637	16824	8	in	in	IN
18637	16824	9	actual	actual	JJ
18637	16824	10	service	service	NN
18637	16824	11	in	in	IN
18637	16824	12	time	time	NN
18637	16824	13	of	of	IN
18637	16824	14	war	war	NN
18637	16824	15	or	or	CC
18637	16824	16	public	public	JJ
18637	16824	17	danger	danger	NN
18637	16824	18	"	"	''
18637	16824	19	apply	apply	VB
18637	16824	20	to	to	IN
18637	16824	21	the	the	DT
18637	16824	22	militia	militia	NN
18637	16824	23	only	only	RB
18637	16824	24	.	.	.
18637	16825	1	All	all	DT
18637	16825	2	persons	person	NNS
18637	16825	3	in	in	IN
18637	16825	4	the	the	DT
18637	16825	5	regular	regular	JJ
18637	16825	6	army	army	NNP
18637	16825	7	or	or	CC
18637	16825	8	navy	navy	NNP
18637	16825	9	are	be	VBP
18637	16825	10	subject	subject	JJ
18637	16825	11	to	to	IN
18637	16825	12	court	court	NN
18637	16825	13	martial	martial	JJ
18637	16825	14	rather	rather	RB
18637	16825	15	than	than	IN
18637	16825	16	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16825	17	or	or	CC
18637	16825	18	trial	trial	NN
18637	16825	19	by	by	IN
18637	16825	20	jury	jury	NN
18637	16825	21	,	,	,
18637	16825	22	at	at	IN
18637	16825	23	all	all	DT
18637	16825	24	times	time	NNS
18637	16825	25	.	.	.
18637	16826	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16826	2	15	15	CD
18637	16826	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16826	4	The	the	DT
18637	16826	5	exception	exception	NN
18637	16826	6	of	of	IN
18637	16826	7	"	"	``
18637	16826	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	16826	9	arising	arise	VBG
18637	16826	10	in	in	IN
18637	16826	11	the	the	DT
18637	16826	12	land	land	NN
18637	16826	13	or	or	CC
18637	16826	14	naval	naval	JJ
18637	16826	15	forces	force	NNS
18637	16826	16	"	"	''
18637	16826	17	was	be	VBD
18637	16826	18	not	not	RB
18637	16826	19	aimed	aim	VBN
18637	16826	20	at	at	IN
18637	16826	21	trials	trial	NNS
18637	16826	22	of	of	IN
18637	16826	23	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	16826	24	against	against	IN
18637	16826	25	the	the	DT
18637	16826	26	laws	law	NNS
18637	16826	27	of	of	IN
18637	16826	28	war	war	NN
18637	16826	29	.	.	.
18637	16827	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16827	2	objective	objective	NN
18637	16827	3	was	be	VBD
18637	16827	4	to	to	TO
18637	16827	5	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	16827	6	trial	trial	NN
18637	16827	7	by	by	IN
18637	16827	8	court	court	NN
18637	16827	9	martial	martial	NN
18637	16827	10	of	of	IN
18637	16827	11	the	the	DT
18637	16827	12	members	member	NNS
18637	16827	13	of	of	IN
18637	16827	14	the	the	DT
18637	16827	15	Armed	Armed	NNP
18637	16827	16	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	16827	17	for	for	IN
18637	16827	18	all	all	PDT
18637	16827	19	that	that	DT
18637	16827	20	class	class	NN
18637	16827	21	of	of	IN
18637	16827	22	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	16827	23	which	which	WDT
18637	16827	24	under	under	IN
18637	16827	25	the	the	DT
18637	16827	26	Fifth	fifth	JJ
18637	16827	27	and	and	CC
18637	16827	28	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	16827	29	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	16827	30	might	may	MD
18637	16827	31	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	16827	32	have	have	VB
18637	16827	33	been	be	VBN
18637	16827	34	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	16827	35	triable	triable	JJ
18637	16827	36	in	in	IN
18637	16827	37	the	the	DT
18637	16827	38	civil	civil	JJ
18637	16827	39	court	court	NN
18637	16827	40	.	.	.
18637	16828	1	Either	either	DT
18637	16828	2	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	16828	3	or	or	CC
18637	16828	4	alien	alien	JJ
18637	16828	5	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	16828	6	belligerents	belligerent	NNS
18637	16828	7	may	may	MD
18637	16828	8	be	be	VB
18637	16828	9	tried	try	VBN
18637	16828	10	by	by	IN
18637	16828	11	a	a	DT
18637	16828	12	military	military	JJ
18637	16828	13	commission	commission	NN
18637	16828	14	for	for	IN
18637	16828	15	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	16828	16	against	against	IN
18637	16828	17	the	the	DT
18637	16828	18	laws	law	NNS
18637	16828	19	of	of	IN
18637	16828	20	war	war	NN
18637	16828	21	.	.	.
18637	16829	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16829	2	16	16	CD
18637	16829	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16829	4	DOUBLE	DOUBLE	NNP
18637	16829	5	JEOPARDY	JEOPARDY	NNP
18637	16829	6	By	by	IN
18637	16829	7	the	the	DT
18637	16829	8	common	common	JJ
18637	16829	9	law	law	NN
18637	16829	10	not	not	RB
18637	16829	11	only	only	RB
18637	16829	12	was	be	VBD
18637	16829	13	a	a	DT
18637	16829	14	second	second	JJ
18637	16829	15	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	16829	16	for	for	IN
18637	16829	17	the	the	DT
18637	16829	18	same	same	JJ
18637	16829	19	offense	offense	NN
18637	16829	20	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	16829	21	,	,	,
18637	16829	22	but	but	CC
18637	16829	23	a	a	DT
18637	16829	24	second	second	JJ
18637	16829	25	trial	trial	NN
18637	16829	26	was	be	VBD
18637	16829	27	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	16829	28	whether	whether	IN
18637	16829	29	or	or	CC
18637	16829	30	not	not	RB
18637	16829	31	the	the	DT
18637	16829	32	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16829	33	had	have	VBD
18637	16829	34	suffered	suffer	VBN
18637	16829	35	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	16829	36	,	,	,
18637	16829	37	or	or	CC
18637	16829	38	had	have	VBD
18637	16829	39	been	be	VBN
18637	16829	40	acquitted	acquit	VBN
18637	16829	41	or	or	CC
18637	16829	42	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	16829	43	.	.	.
18637	16830	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16830	2	17	17	CD
18637	16830	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16830	4	This	this	DT
18637	16830	5	clause	clause	NN
18637	16830	6	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	16830	7	all	all	DT
18637	16830	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	16830	9	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	16830	10	a	a	DT
18637	16830	11	second	second	JJ
18637	16830	12	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	16830	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	16830	14	attempted	attempt	VBN
18637	16830	15	for	for	IN
18637	16830	16	the	the	DT
18637	16830	17	same	same	JJ
18637	16830	18	violation	violation	NN
18637	16830	19	of	of	IN
18637	16830	20	law	law	NN
18637	16830	21	,	,	,
18637	16830	22	whether	whether	IN
18637	16830	23	felony	felony	NN
18637	16830	24	or	or	CC
18637	16830	25	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
18637	16830	26	.	.	.
18637	16831	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16831	2	18	18	CD
18637	16831	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16831	4	Seventy	seventy	CD
18637	16831	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	16831	6	five	five	CD
18637	16831	7	years	year	NNS
18637	16831	8	ago	ago	RB
18637	16831	9	a	a	DT
18637	16831	10	closely	closely	RB
18637	16831	11	divided	divide	VBN
18637	16831	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16831	13	held	hold	VBD
18637	16831	14	that	that	IN
18637	16831	15	the	the	DT
18637	16831	16	protection	protection	NN
18637	16831	17	against	against	IN
18637	16831	18	double	double	JJ
18637	16831	19	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	16831	20	prevented	prevent	VBD
18637	16831	21	an	an	DT
18637	16831	22	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	16831	23	by	by	IN
18637	16831	24	the	the	DT
18637	16831	25	Government	Government	NNP
18637	16831	26	after	after	IN
18637	16831	27	a	a	DT
18637	16831	28	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	16831	29	of	of	IN
18637	16831	30	acquittal	acquittal	NN
18637	16831	31	.	.	.
18637	16832	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16832	2	19	19	CD
18637	16832	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16832	4	A	a	DT
18637	16832	5	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16832	6	of	of	IN
18637	16832	7	acquittal	acquittal	NN
18637	16832	8	on	on	IN
18637	16832	9	the	the	DT
18637	16832	10	ground	ground	NN
18637	16832	11	of	of	IN
18637	16832	12	the	the	DT
18637	16832	13	bar	bar	NN
18637	16832	14	of	of	IN
18637	16832	15	the	the	DT
18637	16832	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	16832	17	of	of	IN
18637	16832	18	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	16832	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	16832	20	a	a	DT
18637	16832	21	protection	protection	NN
18637	16832	22	against	against	IN
18637	16832	23	a	a	DT
18637	16832	24	second	second	JJ
18637	16832	25	trial,[20	trial,[20	CD
18637	16832	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16832	27	as	as	IN
18637	16832	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	16832	29	also	also	RB
18637	16832	30	a	a	DT
18637	16832	31	general	general	JJ
18637	16832	32	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	16832	33	of	of	IN
18637	16832	34	acquittal	acquittal	JJ
18637	16832	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	16832	36	an	an	DT
18637	16832	37	issue	issue	NN
18637	16832	38	of	of	IN
18637	16832	39	not	not	RB
18637	16832	40	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	16832	41	to	to	IN
18637	16832	42	an	an	DT
18637	16832	43	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16832	44	which	which	WDT
18637	16832	45	was	be	VBD
18637	16832	46	not	not	RB
18637	16832	47	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	16832	48	as	as	IN
18637	16832	49	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	16832	50	before	before	IN
18637	16832	51	the	the	DT
18637	16832	52	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	16832	53	.	.	.
18637	16833	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16833	2	21	21	CD
18637	16833	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16833	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	16833	5	a	a	DT
18637	16833	6	court	court	NN
18637	16833	7	inadvertently	inadvertently	RB
18637	16833	8	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	16833	9	both	both	CC
18637	16833	10	a	a	DT
18637	16833	11	fine	fine	JJ
18637	16833	12	and	and	CC
18637	16833	13	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	16833	14	for	for	IN
18637	16833	15	a	a	DT
18637	16833	16	crime	crime	NN
18637	16833	17	for	for	IN
18637	16833	18	which	which	WDT
18637	16833	19	the	the	DT
18637	16833	20	law	law	NN
18637	16833	21	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	16833	22	either	either	DT
18637	16833	23	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	16833	24	,	,	,
18637	16833	25	but	but	CC
18637	16833	26	not	not	RB
18637	16833	27	both	both	DT
18637	16833	28	,	,	,
18637	16833	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16833	30	could	could	MD
18637	16833	31	not	not	RB
18637	16833	32	,	,	,
18637	16833	33	after	after	IN
18637	16833	34	the	the	DT
18637	16833	35	fine	fine	NN
18637	16833	36	had	have	VBD
18637	16833	37	been	be	VBN
18637	16833	38	paid	pay	VBN
18637	16833	39	,	,	,
18637	16833	40	during	during	IN
18637	16833	41	the	the	DT
18637	16833	42	same	same	JJ
18637	16833	43	term	term	NN
18637	16833	44	of	of	IN
18637	16833	45	court	court	NN
18637	16833	46	,	,	,
18637	16833	47	change	change	VB
18637	16833	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16833	49	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16833	50	by	by	IN
18637	16833	51	sentencing	sentence	VBG
18637	16833	52	the	the	DT
18637	16833	53	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	16833	54	to	to	TO
18637	16833	55	imprisonment	imprisonment	VB
18637	16833	56	.	.	.
18637	16834	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16834	2	22	22	CD
18637	16834	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16834	4	But	but	CC
18637	16834	5	where	where	WRB
18637	16834	6	a	a	DT
18637	16834	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	16834	8	carried	carry	VBD
18637	16834	9	a	a	DT
18637	16834	10	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	16834	11	mandatory	mandatory	JJ
18637	16834	12	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	16834	13	of	of	IN
18637	16834	14	both	both	CC
18637	16834	15	a	a	DT
18637	16834	16	fine	fine	JJ
18637	16834	17	and	and	CC
18637	16834	18	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	16834	19	,	,	,
18637	16834	20	the	the	DT
18637	16834	21	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	16834	22	of	of	IN
18637	16834	23	the	the	DT
18637	16834	24	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	16834	25	fine	fine	JJ
18637	16834	26	five	five	CD
18637	16834	27	hours	hour	NNS
18637	16834	28	after	after	IN
18637	16834	29	the	the	DT
18637	16834	30	court	court	NN
18637	16834	31	had	have	VBD
18637	16834	32	erroneously	erroneously	RB
18637	16834	33	sentenced	sentence	VBN
18637	16834	34	the	the	DT
18637	16834	35	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	16834	36	to	to	TO
18637	16834	37	imprisonment	imprisonment	VB
18637	16834	38	only	only	RB
18637	16834	39	did	do	VBD
18637	16834	40	not	not	RB
18637	16834	41	amount	amount	VB
18637	16834	42	to	to	IN
18637	16834	43	double	double	JJ
18637	16834	44	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	16834	45	.	.	.
18637	16835	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16835	2	23	23	CD
18637	16835	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16835	4	Whether	whether	IN
18637	16835	5	or	or	CC
18637	16835	6	not	not	RB
18637	16835	7	the	the	DT
18637	16835	8	discontinuance	discontinuance	NN
18637	16835	9	of	of	IN
18637	16835	10	a	a	DT
18637	16835	11	trial	trial	NN
18637	16835	12	without	without	IN
18637	16835	13	a	a	DT
18637	16835	14	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	16835	15	bars	bar	VBZ
18637	16835	16	a	a	DT
18637	16835	17	second	second	JJ
18637	16835	18	trial	trial	NN
18637	16835	19	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	16835	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	16835	21	the	the	DT
18637	16835	22	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	16835	23	of	of	IN
18637	16835	24	each	each	DT
18637	16835	25	case	case	NN
18637	16835	26	.	.	.
18637	16836	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16836	2	24	24	CD
18637	16836	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16836	4	Discharge	discharge	NN
18637	16836	5	of	of	IN
18637	16836	6	a	a	DT
18637	16836	7	jury	jury	NN
18637	16836	8	because	because	IN
18637	16836	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16836	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	16836	11	unable	unable	JJ
18637	16836	12	to	to	TO
18637	16836	13	reach	reach	VB
18637	16836	14	an	an	DT
18637	16836	15	agreement[25	agreement[25	NN
18637	16836	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16836	17	or	or	CC
18637	16836	18	because	because	IN
18637	16836	19	of	of	IN
18637	16836	20	the	the	DT
18637	16836	21	disqualification	disqualification	NN
18637	16836	22	of	of	IN
18637	16836	23	a	a	DT
18637	16836	24	juror[26	juror[26	NNP
18637	16836	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16836	26	does	do	VBZ
18637	16836	27	not	not	RB
18637	16836	28	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	16836	29	a	a	DT
18637	16836	30	second	second	JJ
18637	16836	31	trial	trial	NN
18637	16836	32	.	.	.
18637	16837	1	Where	where	WRB
18637	16837	2	,	,	,
18637	16837	3	after	after	IN
18637	16837	4	a	a	DT
18637	16837	5	demurrer	demurrer	NN
18637	16837	6	to	to	IN
18637	16837	7	the	the	DT
18637	16837	8	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16837	9	was	be	VBD
18637	16837	10	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	16837	11	,	,	,
18637	16837	12	a	a	DT
18637	16837	13	jury	jury	NN
18637	16837	14	was	be	VBD
18637	16837	15	impaneled	impanel	VBN
18637	16837	16	and	and	CC
18637	16837	17	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	16837	18	sworn	swear	VBN
18637	16837	19	,	,	,
18637	16837	20	the	the	DT
18637	16837	21	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	16837	22	of	of	IN
18637	16837	23	the	the	DT
18637	16837	24	jury	jury	NN
18637	16837	25	to	to	TO
18637	16837	26	permit	permit	VB
18637	16837	27	the	the	DT
18637	16837	28	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	16837	29	to	to	TO
18637	16837	30	be	be	VB
18637	16837	31	arraigned	arraign	VBN
18637	16837	32	did	do	VBD
18637	16837	33	not	not	RB
18637	16837	34	bar	bar	VB
18637	16837	35	a	a	DT
18637	16837	36	trial	trial	NN
18637	16837	37	before	before	IN
18637	16837	38	a	a	DT
18637	16837	39	new	new	JJ
18637	16837	40	jury	jury	NN
18637	16837	41	.	.	.
18637	16838	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16838	2	27	27	CD
18637	16838	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16838	4	The	the	DT
18637	16838	5	withdrawal	withdrawal	NN
18637	16838	6	of	of	IN
18637	16838	7	charges	charge	NNS
18637	16838	8	after	after	IN
18637	16838	9	a	a	DT
18637	16838	10	trial	trial	NN
18637	16838	11	by	by	IN
18637	16838	12	a	a	DT
18637	16838	13	general	general	JJ
18637	16838	14	court	court	NN
18637	16838	15	martial	martial	NN
18637	16838	16	had	have	VBD
18637	16838	17	begun	begin	VBN
18637	16838	18	,	,	,
18637	16838	19	because	because	IN
18637	16838	20	the	the	DT
18637	16838	21	tactical	tactical	JJ
18637	16838	22	situation	situation	NN
18637	16838	23	brought	bring	VBN
18637	16838	24	about	about	RP
18637	16838	25	by	by	IN
18637	16838	26	the	the	DT
18637	16838	27	rapid	rapid	JJ
18637	16838	28	advance	advance	NN
18637	16838	29	of	of	IN
18637	16838	30	the	the	DT
18637	16838	31	army	army	NN
18637	16838	32	made	make	VBD
18637	16838	33	continuance	continuance	NN
18637	16838	34	of	of	IN
18637	16838	35	the	the	DT
18637	16838	36	trial	trial	NN
18637	16838	37	impracticable	impracticable	JJ
18637	16838	38	,	,	,
18637	16838	39	did	do	VBD
18637	16838	40	not	not	RB
18637	16838	41	bar	bar	VB
18637	16838	42	a	a	DT
18637	16838	43	trial	trial	NN
18637	16838	44	before	before	IN
18637	16838	45	a	a	DT
18637	16838	46	second	second	JJ
18637	16838	47	court	court	NN
18637	16838	48	martial	martial	NN
18637	16838	49	.	.	.
18637	16839	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16839	2	28	28	CD
18637	16839	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16839	4	An	an	DT
18637	16839	5	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16839	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	16839	7	not	not	RB
18637	16839	8	put	put	VBN
18637	16839	9	in	in	IN
18637	16839	10	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	16839	11	by	by	IN
18637	16839	12	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	16839	13	examination	examination	NN
18637	16839	14	and	and	CC
18637	16839	15	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	16839	16	by	by	IN
18637	16839	17	the	the	DT
18637	16839	18	examining	examine	VBG
18637	16839	19	magistrate,[29	magistrate,[29	CD
18637	16839	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16839	21	by	by	IN
18637	16839	22	an	an	DT
18637	16839	23	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16839	24	which	which	WDT
18637	16839	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	16839	26	quashed,[30	quashed,[30	NNP
18637	16839	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16839	28	nor	nor	CC
18637	16839	29	by	by	IN
18637	16839	30	arraignment	arraignment	NN
18637	16839	31	and	and	CC
18637	16839	32	pleading	plead	VBG
18637	16839	33	to	to	IN
18637	16839	34	the	the	DT
18637	16839	35	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16839	36	.	.	.
18637	16840	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16840	2	31	31	CD
18637	16840	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16840	4	In	in	IN
18637	16840	5	order	order	NN
18637	16840	6	to	to	TO
18637	16840	7	bar	bar	NN
18637	16840	8	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	16840	9	,	,	,
18637	16840	10	a	a	DT
18637	16840	11	former	former	JJ
18637	16840	12	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	16840	13	must	must	MD
18637	16840	14	be	be	VB
18637	16840	15	pleaded	plead	VBN
18637	16840	16	.	.	.
18637	16841	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16841	2	32	32	CD
18637	16841	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16841	4	A	a	DT
18637	16841	5	plea	plea	NN
18637	16841	6	of	of	IN
18637	16841	7	former	former	JJ
18637	16841	8	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	16841	9	must	must	MD
18637	16841	10	be	be	VB
18637	16841	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	16841	12	a	a	DT
18637	16841	13	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	16841	14	for	for	IN
18637	16841	15	the	the	DT
18637	16841	16	same	same	JJ
18637	16841	17	identical	identical	JJ
18637	16841	18	offense	offense	NN
18637	16841	19	.	.	.
18637	16842	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16842	2	33	33	CD
18637	16842	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16842	4	The	the	DT
18637	16842	5	test	test	NN
18637	16842	6	of	of	IN
18637	16842	7	identity	identity	NN
18637	16842	8	of	of	IN
18637	16842	9	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	16842	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	16842	11	whether	whether	IN
18637	16842	12	the	the	DT
18637	16842	13	same	same	JJ
18637	16842	14	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16842	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	16842	16	required	require	VBN
18637	16842	17	to	to	TO
18637	16842	18	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	16842	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16842	20	;	;	:
18637	16842	21	if	if	IN
18637	16842	22	not	not	RB
18637	16842	23	,	,	,
18637	16842	24	the	the	DT
18637	16842	25	fact	fact	NN
18637	16842	26	that	that	IN
18637	16842	27	both	both	DT
18637	16842	28	charges	charge	NNS
18637	16842	29	relate	relate	VBP
18637	16842	30	to	to	IN
18637	16842	31	one	one	CD
18637	16842	32	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	16842	33	does	do	VBZ
18637	16842	34	not	not	RB
18637	16842	35	make	make	VB
18637	16842	36	a	a	DT
18637	16842	37	single	single	JJ
18637	16842	38	offense	offense	NN
18637	16842	39	where	where	WRB
18637	16842	40	two	two	CD
18637	16842	41	are	be	VBP
18637	16842	42	defined	define	VBN
18637	16842	43	by	by	IN
18637	16842	44	the	the	DT
18637	16842	45	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	16842	46	.	.	.
18637	16843	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16843	2	34	34	CD
18637	16843	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16843	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	16843	5	a	a	DT
18637	16843	6	person	person	NN
18637	16843	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	16843	8	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	16843	9	of	of	IN
18637	16843	10	a	a	DT
18637	16843	11	crime	crime	NN
18637	16843	12	which	which	WDT
18637	16843	13	includes	include	VBZ
18637	16843	14	several	several	JJ
18637	16843	15	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	16843	16	,	,	,
18637	16843	17	a	a	DT
18637	16843	18	second	second	JJ
18637	16843	19	trial	trial	NN
18637	16843	20	for	for	IN
18637	16843	21	one	one	CD
18637	16843	22	of	of	IN
18637	16843	23	those	those	DT
18637	16843	24	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	16843	25	puts	put	VBZ
18637	16843	26	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16843	27	twice	twice	RB
18637	16843	28	in	in	IN
18637	16843	29	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	16843	30	.	.	.
18637	16844	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16844	2	35	35	CD
18637	16844	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16844	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16844	5	may	may	MD
18637	16844	6	impose	impose	VB
18637	16844	7	both	both	CC
18637	16844	8	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16844	9	and	and	CC
18637	16844	10	civil	civil	JJ
18637	16844	11	sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	16844	12	with	with	IN
18637	16844	13	respect	respect	NN
18637	16844	14	to	to	IN
18637	16844	15	the	the	DT
18637	16844	16	same	same	JJ
18637	16844	17	act	act	NN
18637	16844	18	or	or	CC
18637	16844	19	omission,[36	omission,[36	CD
18637	16844	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16844	21	and	and	CC
18637	16844	22	may	may	MD
18637	16844	23	separate	separate	VB
18637	16844	24	a	a	DT
18637	16844	25	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	16844	26	to	to	TO
18637	16844	27	commit	commit	VB
18637	16844	28	a	a	DT
18637	16844	29	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	16844	30	offense	offense	NN
18637	16844	31	from	from	IN
18637	16844	32	the	the	DT
18637	16844	33	commission	commission	NN
18637	16844	34	of	of	IN
18637	16844	35	the	the	DT
18637	16844	36	offense	offense	NN
18637	16844	37	and	and	CC
18637	16844	38	affix	affix	VB
18637	16844	39	to	to	IN
18637	16844	40	each	each	DT
18637	16844	41	a	a	DT
18637	16844	42	different	different	JJ
18637	16844	43	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	16844	44	.	.	.
18637	16845	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16845	2	37	37	CD
18637	16845	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16845	4	A	a	DT
18637	16845	5	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	16845	6	for	for	IN
18637	16845	7	the	the	DT
18637	16845	8	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	16845	9	may	may	MD
18637	16845	10	be	be	VB
18637	16845	11	had	have	VBN
18637	16845	12	though	though	IN
18637	16845	13	the	the	DT
18637	16845	14	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	16845	15	offense	offense	NN
18637	16845	16	was	be	VBD
18637	16845	17	not	not	RB
18637	16845	18	completed	complete	VBN
18637	16845	19	.	.	.
18637	16846	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16846	2	38	38	CD
18637	16846	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16846	4	Separate	separate	JJ
18637	16846	5	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	16846	6	under	under	IN
18637	16846	7	different	different	JJ
18637	16846	8	counts	count	NNS
18637	16846	9	charging	charge	VBG
18637	16846	10	a	a	DT
18637	16846	11	monopolization	monopolization	NN
18637	16846	12	and	and	CC
18637	16846	13	a	a	DT
18637	16846	14	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	16846	15	to	to	TO
18637	16846	16	monopolize	monopolize	VB
18637	16846	17	trade	trade	NN
18637	16846	18	,	,	,
18637	16846	19	in	in	IN
18637	16846	20	an	an	DT
18637	16846	21	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16846	22	under	under	IN
18637	16846	23	the	the	DT
18637	16846	24	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	16846	25	Antitrust	Antitrust	NNP
18637	16846	26	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16846	27	,	,	,
18637	16846	28	do	do	VB
18637	16846	29	not	not	RB
18637	16846	30	amount	amount	VB
18637	16846	31	to	to	TO
18637	16846	32	double	double	JJ
18637	16846	33	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	16846	34	.	.	.
18637	16847	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16847	2	39	39	CD
18637	16847	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16847	4	In	in	IN
18637	16847	5	United	United	NNP
18637	16847	6	States	States	NNP
18637	16847	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16847	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	16847	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16847	10	National	National	NNP
18637	16847	11	Association	Association	NNP
18637	16847	12	of	of	IN
18637	16847	13	Real	Real	NNP
18637	16847	14	Estate	Estate	NNP
18637	16847	15	Boards,[40	Boards,[40	,
18637	16847	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16847	17	the	the	DT
18637	16847	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16847	19	held	hold	VBD
18637	16847	20	that	that	IN
18637	16847	21	an	an	DT
18637	16847	22	acquittal	acquittal	NN
18637	16847	23	in	in	IN
18637	16847	24	a	a	DT
18637	16847	25	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16847	26	suit	suit	NN
18637	16847	27	charging	charge	VBG
18637	16847	28	violation	violation	NN
18637	16847	29	of	of	IN
18637	16847	30	the	the	DT
18637	16847	31	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	16847	32	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16847	33	does	do	VBZ
18637	16847	34	not	not	RB
18637	16847	35	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	16847	36	the	the	DT
18637	16847	37	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	16847	38	of	of	IN
18637	16847	39	an	an	DT
18637	16847	40	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	16847	41	against	against	IN
18637	16847	42	future	future	JJ
18637	16847	43	violations	violation	NNS
18637	16847	44	.	.	.
18637	16848	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16848	2	distinguished	distinguish	VBD
18637	16848	3	but	but	CC
18637	16848	4	did	do	VBD
18637	16848	5	not	not	RB
18637	16848	6	overrule	overrule	VB
18637	16848	7	an	an	DT
18637	16848	8	early	early	JJ
18637	16848	9	case	case	NN
18637	16848	10	which	which	WDT
18637	16848	11	held	hold	VBD
18637	16848	12	that	that	IN
18637	16848	13	where	where	WRB
18637	16848	14	an	an	DT
18637	16848	15	issue	issue	NN
18637	16848	16	as	as	IN
18637	16848	17	to	to	IN
18637	16848	18	the	the	DT
18637	16848	19	existence	existence	NN
18637	16848	20	of	of	IN
18637	16848	21	a	a	DT
18637	16848	22	fact	fact	NN
18637	16848	23	or	or	CC
18637	16848	24	act	act	NN
18637	16848	25	had	have	VBD
18637	16848	26	been	be	VBN
18637	16848	27	tried	try	VBN
18637	16848	28	in	in	IN
18637	16848	29	a	a	DT
18637	16848	30	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16848	31	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	16848	32	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	16848	33	by	by	IN
18637	16848	34	the	the	DT
18637	16848	35	United	United	NNP
18637	16848	36	States	States	NNP
18637	16848	37	,	,	,
18637	16848	38	a	a	DT
18637	16848	39	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16848	40	of	of	IN
18637	16848	41	acquittal	acquittal	NN
18637	16848	42	,	,	,
18637	16848	43	was	be	VBD
18637	16848	44	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	16848	45	in	in	IN
18637	16848	46	a	a	DT
18637	16848	47	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	16848	48	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	16848	49	_	_	NNP
18637	16848	50	in	in	IN
18637	16848	51	rem	rem	NNP
18637	16848	52	_	_	NNP
18637	16848	53	involving	involve	VBG
18637	16848	54	the	the	DT
18637	16848	55	same	same	JJ
18637	16848	56	matter	matter	NN
18637	16848	57	.	.	.
18637	16849	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16849	2	41	41	CD
18637	16849	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16849	4	A	a	DT
18637	16849	5	civil	civil	JJ
18637	16849	6	action	action	NN
18637	16849	7	to	to	TO
18637	16849	8	recover	recover	VB
18637	16849	9	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	16849	10	which	which	WDT
18637	16849	11	were	be	VBD
18637	16849	12	in	in	IN
18637	16849	13	fact	fact	NN
18637	16849	14	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	16849	15	for	for	IN
18637	16849	16	violation	violation	NN
18637	16849	17	of	of	IN
18637	16849	18	another	another	DT
18637	16849	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	16849	20	was	be	VBD
18637	16849	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	16849	22	to	to	TO
18637	16849	23	be	be	VB
18637	16849	24	punitive	punitive	JJ
18637	16849	25	in	in	IN
18637	16849	26	character	character	NN
18637	16849	27	and	and	CC
18637	16849	28	barred	bar	VBN
18637	16849	29	by	by	IN
18637	16849	30	a	a	DT
18637	16849	31	prior	prior	JJ
18637	16849	32	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	16849	33	of	of	IN
18637	16849	34	the	the	DT
18637	16849	35	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	16849	36	for	for	IN
18637	16849	37	a	a	DT
18637	16849	38	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16849	39	offense	offense	NN
18637	16849	40	involving	involve	VBG
18637	16849	41	the	the	DT
18637	16849	42	same	same	JJ
18637	16849	43	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	16849	44	.	.	.
18637	16850	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16850	2	42	42	CD
18637	16850	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16850	4	In	in	IN
18637	16850	5	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	16850	6	,	,	,
18637	16850	7	the	the	DT
18637	16850	8	additional	additional	JJ
18637	16850	9	income	income	NN
18637	16850	10	tax	tax	NN
18637	16850	11	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	16850	12	when	when	WRB
18637	16850	13	a	a	DT
18637	16850	14	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	16850	15	return	return	NN
18637	16850	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	16850	17	filed	file	VBN
18637	16850	18	,	,	,
18637	16850	19	was	be	VBD
18637	16850	20	found	find	VBN
18637	16850	21	to	to	TO
18637	16850	22	be	be	VB
18637	16850	23	a	a	DT
18637	16850	24	civil	civil	JJ
18637	16850	25	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	16850	26	designed	design	VBN
18637	16850	27	to	to	TO
18637	16850	28	protect	protect	VB
18637	16850	29	the	the	DT
18637	16850	30	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	16850	31	,	,	,
18637	16850	32	which	which	WDT
18637	16850	33	might	may	MD
18637	16850	34	be	be	VB
18637	16850	35	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	16850	36	after	after	IN
18637	16850	37	acquittal	acquittal	NN
18637	16850	38	of	of	IN
18637	16850	39	the	the	DT
18637	16850	40	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	16850	41	for	for	IN
18637	16850	42	the	the	DT
18637	16850	43	same	same	JJ
18637	16850	44	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	16850	45	.	.	.
18637	16851	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16851	2	43	43	CD
18637	16851	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16851	4	A	a	DT
18637	16851	5	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	16851	6	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	16851	7	for	for	IN
18637	16851	8	defrauding	defraud	VBG
18637	16851	9	the	the	DT
18637	16851	10	Government	Government	NNP
18637	16851	11	of	of	IN
18637	16851	12	a	a	DT
18637	16851	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	16851	14	on	on	IN
18637	16851	15	alcohol	alcohol	NN
18637	16851	16	diverted	divert	VBN
18637	16851	17	to	to	IN
18637	16851	18	beverage	beverage	NN
18637	16851	19	uses	use	NNS
18637	16851	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	16851	21	a	a	DT
18637	16851	22	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	16851	23	_	_	NNP
18637	16851	24	in	in	IN
18637	16851	25	rem	rem	NNP
18637	16851	26	_	_	NNP
18637	16851	27	,	,	,
18637	16851	28	rather	rather	RB
18637	16851	29	than	than	IN
18637	16851	30	a	a	DT
18637	16851	31	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	16851	32	for	for	IN
18637	16851	33	a	a	DT
18637	16851	34	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16851	35	offense	offense	NN
18637	16851	36	,	,	,
18637	16851	37	and	and	CC
18637	16851	38	may	may	MD
18637	16851	39	be	be	VB
18637	16851	40	prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
18637	16851	41	after	after	IN
18637	16851	42	a	a	DT
18637	16851	43	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	16851	44	of	of	IN
18637	16851	45	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	16851	46	to	to	TO
18637	16851	47	violate	violate	VB
18637	16851	48	the	the	DT
18637	16851	49	statute	statute	NN
18637	16851	50	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	16851	51	the	the	DT
18637	16851	52	tax	tax	NN
18637	16851	53	.	.	.
18637	16852	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16852	2	44	44	CD
18637	16852	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16852	4	In	in	IN
18637	16852	5	an	an	DT
18637	16852	6	early	early	JJ
18637	16852	7	case	case	NN
18637	16852	8	,	,	,
18637	16852	9	the	the	DT
18637	16852	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16852	11	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	16852	12	that	that	IN
18637	16852	13	since	since	IN
18637	16852	14	robbery	robbery	NN
18637	16852	15	on	on	IN
18637	16852	16	the	the	DT
18637	16852	17	high	high	JJ
18637	16852	18	seas	sea	NNS
18637	16852	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	16852	20	considered	consider	VBN
18637	16852	21	an	an	DT
18637	16852	22	offense	offense	NN
18637	16852	23	within	within	IN
18637	16852	24	the	the	DT
18637	16852	25	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16852	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	16852	27	of	of	IN
18637	16852	28	all	all	DT
18637	16852	29	nations	nation	NNS
18637	16852	30	,	,	,
18637	16852	31	the	the	DT
18637	16852	32	plea	plea	NN
18637	16852	33	of	of	IN
18637	16852	34	_	_	NNP
18637	16852	35	autre	autre	NNP
18637	16852	36	fois	fois	NNP
18637	16852	37	acquit	acquit	NNP
18637	16852	38	_	_	NNP
18637	16852	39	would	would	MD
18637	16852	40	be	be	VB
18637	16852	41	good	good	JJ
18637	16852	42	in	in	IN
18637	16852	43	any	any	DT
18637	16852	44	civilized	civilized	JJ
18637	16852	45	State	State	NNP
18637	16852	46	,	,	,
18637	16852	47	though	though	IN
18637	16852	48	resting	rest	VBG
18637	16852	49	on	on	IN
18637	16852	50	a	a	DT
18637	16852	51	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	16852	52	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	16852	53	in	in	IN
18637	16852	54	the	the	DT
18637	16852	55	courts	court	NNS
18637	16852	56	of	of	IN
18637	16852	57	any	any	DT
18637	16852	58	other	other	JJ
18637	16852	59	civilized	civilized	JJ
18637	16852	60	State	State	NNP
18637	16852	61	.	.	.
18637	16853	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16853	2	45	45	CD
18637	16853	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16853	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16853	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	16853	6	held	hold	VBN
18637	16853	7	,	,	,
18637	16853	8	however	however	RB
18637	16853	9	,	,	,
18637	16853	10	that	that	IN
18637	16853	11	where	where	WRB
18637	16853	12	the	the	DT
18637	16853	13	same	same	JJ
18637	16853	14	act	act	NN
18637	16853	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	16853	16	an	an	DT
18637	16853	17	offense	offense	NN
18637	16853	18	against	against	IN
18637	16853	19	both	both	CC
18637	16853	20	the	the	DT
18637	16853	21	State	State	NNP
18637	16853	22	and	and	CC
18637	16853	23	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	16853	24	Governments	Governments	NNPS
18637	16853	25	,	,	,
18637	16853	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16853	27	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	16853	28	and	and	CC
18637	16853	29	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	16853	30	by	by	IN
18637	16853	31	both	both	DT
18637	16853	32	Governments	government	NNS
18637	16853	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	16853	34	not	not	RB
18637	16853	35	double	double	JJ
18637	16853	36	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	16853	37	.	.	.
18637	16854	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16854	2	46	46	CD
18637	16854	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16854	4	A	a	DT
18637	16854	5	contumacious	contumacious	JJ
18637	16854	6	witness	witness	NN
18637	16854	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	16854	8	not	not	RB
18637	16854	9	twice	twice	RB
18637	16854	10	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	16854	11	to	to	IN
18637	16854	12	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	16854	13	for	for	IN
18637	16854	14	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	16854	15	to	to	TO
18637	16854	16	testify	testify	VB
18637	16854	17	before	before	IN
18637	16854	18	a	a	DT
18637	16854	19	committee	committee	NN
18637	16854	20	of	of	IN
18637	16854	21	the	the	DT
18637	16854	22	United	United	NNP
18637	16854	23	States	States	NNP
18637	16854	24	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	16854	25	,	,	,
18637	16854	26	by	by	IN
18637	16854	27	being	be	VBG
18637	16854	28	punished	punish	VBN
18637	16854	29	for	for	IN
18637	16854	30	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	16854	31	of	of	IN
18637	16854	32	the	the	DT
18637	16854	33	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	16854	34	and	and	CC
18637	16854	35	also	also	RB
18637	16854	36	indicted	indict	VBN
18637	16854	37	for	for	IN
18637	16854	38	a	a	DT
18637	16854	39	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
18637	16854	40	for	for	IN
18637	16854	41	such	such	JJ
18637	16854	42	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	16854	43	.	.	.
18637	16855	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16855	2	47	47	CD
18637	16855	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16855	4	Self	Self	NNP
18637	16855	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	16855	6	Incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	16855	7	SOURCE	SOURCE	NNP
18637	16855	8	OF	of	IN
18637	16855	9	THE	the	DT
18637	16855	10	CLAUSE	CLAUSE	NNP
18637	16855	11	"	"	''
18637	16855	12	Nor	nor	CC
18637	16855	13	shall	shall	MD
18637	16855	14	be	be	VB
18637	16855	15	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	16855	16	in	in	IN
18637	16855	17	any	any	DT
18637	16855	18	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16855	19	case	case	NN
18637	16855	20	to	to	TO
18637	16855	21	be	be	VB
18637	16855	22	a	a	DT
18637	16855	23	witness	witness	NN
18637	16855	24	against	against	IN
18637	16855	25	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16855	26	.	.	.
18637	16855	27	"	"	''
18637	16856	1	The	the	DT
18637	16856	2	source	source	NN
18637	16856	3	of	of	IN
18637	16856	4	this	this	DT
18637	16856	5	clause	clause	NN
18637	16856	6	was	be	VBD
18637	16856	7	the	the	DT
18637	16856	8	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	16856	9	that	that	IN
18637	16856	10	"	"	``
18637	16856	11	no	no	DT
18637	16856	12	man	man	NN
18637	16856	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	16856	14	bound	bind	VBN
18637	16856	15	to	to	TO
18637	16856	16	accuse	accuse	VB
18637	16856	17	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16856	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16856	19	_	_	NNP
18637	16856	20	nemo	nemo	NNP
18637	16856	21	tenetur	tenetur	NNP
18637	16856	22	prodere_--or	prodere_--or	:
18637	16856	23	_	_	NNP
18637	16856	24	accusare	accusare	NNP
18637	16856	25	seipsum	seipsum	NN
18637	16856	26	_	_	NNP
18637	16856	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16856	28	,	,	,
18637	16856	29	"	"	''
18637	16856	30	which	which	WDT
18637	16856	31	was	be	VBD
18637	16856	32	brought	bring	VBN
18637	16856	33	forward	forward	RB
18637	16856	34	in	in	IN
18637	16856	35	England	England	NNP
18637	16856	36	late	late	RB
18637	16856	37	in	in	IN
18637	16856	38	the	the	DT
18637	16856	39	sixteenth	sixteenth	JJ
18637	16856	40	century	century	NN
18637	16856	41	in	in	IN
18637	16856	42	protest	protest	NN
18637	16856	43	against	against	IN
18637	16856	44	the	the	DT
18637	16856	45	inquisitorial	inquisitorial	JJ
18637	16856	46	methods	method	NNS
18637	16856	47	of	of	IN
18637	16856	48	the	the	DT
18637	16856	49	ecclesiastical	ecclesiastical	JJ
18637	16856	50	courts	court	NNS
18637	16856	51	.	.	.
18637	16857	1	At	at	IN
18637	16857	2	that	that	DT
18637	16857	3	time	time	NN
18637	16857	4	the	the	DT
18637	16857	5	common	common	JJ
18637	16857	6	law	law	NN
18637	16857	7	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16857	8	permitted	permit	VBD
18637	16857	9	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16857	10	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	16857	11	to	to	TO
18637	16857	12	be	be	VB
18637	16857	13	questioned	question	VBN
18637	16857	14	.	.	.
18637	16858	1	What	what	WP
18637	16858	2	the	the	DT
18637	16858	3	advocates	advocate	NNS
18637	16858	4	of	of	IN
18637	16858	5	the	the	DT
18637	16858	6	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	16858	7	meant	mean	VBN
18637	16858	8	was	be	VBD
18637	16858	9	merely	merely	RB
18637	16858	10	that	that	IN
18637	16858	11	a	a	DT
18637	16858	12	person	person	NN
18637	16858	13	ought	ought	MD
18637	16858	14	not	not	RB
18637	16858	15	to	to	TO
18637	16858	16	be	be	VB
18637	16858	17	put	put	VBN
18637	16858	18	on	on	IN
18637	16858	19	trial	trial	NN
18637	16858	20	and	and	CC
18637	16858	21	compelled	compel	VBD
18637	16858	22	to	to	TO
18637	16858	23	answer	answer	VB
18637	16858	24	questions	question	NNS
18637	16858	25	to	to	IN
18637	16858	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16858	27	detriment	detriment	NN
18637	16858	28	unless	unless	IN
18637	16858	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16858	30	had	have	VBD
18637	16858	31	first	first	RB
18637	16858	32	been	be	VBN
18637	16858	33	properly	properly	RB
18637	16858	34	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16858	35	,	,	,
18637	16858	36	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	16858	37	,	,	,
18637	16858	38	by	by	IN
18637	16858	39	the	the	DT
18637	16858	40	grand	grand	JJ
18637	16858	41	jury	jury	NN
18637	16858	42	.	.	.
18637	16859	1	But	but	CC
18637	16859	2	the	the	DT
18637	16859	3	idea	idea	NN
18637	16859	4	once	once	RB
18637	16859	5	set	set	VBD
18637	16859	6	going	go	VBG
18637	16859	7	gained	gain	VBN
18637	16859	8	headway	headway	NN
18637	16859	9	rapidly	rapidly	RB
18637	16859	10	,	,	,
18637	16859	11	especially	especially	RB
18637	16859	12	after	after	IN
18637	16859	13	1660	1660	CD
18637	16859	14	,	,	,
18637	16859	15	when	when	WRB
18637	16859	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16859	17	came	come	VBD
18637	16859	18	to	to	TO
18637	16859	19	have	have	VB
18637	16859	20	attached	attach	VBN
18637	16859	21	to	to	IN
18637	16859	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16859	23	most	most	JJS
18637	16859	24	of	of	IN
18637	16859	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16859	26	present	present	JJ
18637	16859	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	16859	28	day	day	NN
18637	16859	29	corollaries	corollary	NNS
18637	16859	30	.	.	.
18637	16860	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16860	2	48	48	CD
18637	16860	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16860	4	Under	under	IN
18637	16860	5	the	the	DT
18637	16860	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	16860	7	a	a	DT
18637	16860	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16860	9	witness	witness	NN
18637	16860	10	_	_	NNP
18637	16860	11	in	in	IN
18637	16860	12	any	any	DT
18637	16860	13	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	16860	14	whatsoever	whatsoever	RB
18637	16860	15	in	in	IN
18637	16860	16	which	which	WDT
18637	16860	17	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	16860	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	16860	19	legally	legally	RB
18637	16860	20	required	require	VBN
18637	16860	21	may	may	MD
18637	16860	22	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	16860	23	to	to	TO
18637	16860	24	answer	answer	VB
18637	16860	25	any	any	DT
18637	16860	26	question	question	NN
18637	16860	27	,	,	,
18637	16860	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16860	29	answer	answer	NN
18637	16860	30	to	to	TO
18637	16860	31	which	which	WDT
18637	16860	32	might	may	MD
18637	16860	33	be	be	VB
18637	16860	34	used	use	VBN
18637	16860	35	against	against	IN
18637	16860	36	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16860	37	in	in	IN
18637	16860	38	a	a	DT
18637	16860	39	future	future	JJ
18637	16860	40	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16860	41	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	16860	42	,	,	,
18637	16860	43	or	or	CC
18637	16860	44	which	which	WDT
18637	16860	45	might	may	MD
18637	16860	46	uncover	uncover	VB
18637	16860	47	further	further	JJ
18637	16860	48	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16860	49	against	against	IN
18637	16860	50	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16860	51	.	.	.
18637	16861	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16861	2	49	49	CD
18637	16861	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16861	4	The	the	DT
18637	16861	5	witness	witness	NN
18637	16861	6	must	must	MD
18637	16861	7	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	16861	8	claim	claim	VB
18637	16861	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16861	10	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16861	11	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	16861	12	or	or	CC
18637	16861	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16861	14	will	will	MD
18637	16861	15	be	be	VB
18637	16861	16	considered	consider	VBN
18637	16861	17	to	to	TO
18637	16861	18	have	have	VB
18637	16861	19	waived	waive	VBN
18637	16861	20	it;[50	it;[50	NNP
18637	16861	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16861	22	but	but	CC
18637	16861	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16861	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	16861	25	not	not	RB
18637	16861	26	the	the	DT
18637	16861	27	final	final	JJ
18637	16861	28	judge	judge	NN
18637	16861	29	of	of	IN
18637	16861	30	the	the	DT
18637	16861	31	validity	validity	NN
18637	16861	32	of	of	IN
18637	16861	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16861	34	claim	claim	NN
18637	16861	35	.	.	.
18637	16862	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16862	2	51	51	CD
18637	16862	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16862	4	The	the	DT
18637	16862	5	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	16862	6	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	16862	7	solely	solely	RB
18637	16862	8	for	for	IN
18637	16862	9	the	the	DT
18637	16862	10	protection	protection	NN
18637	16862	11	of	of	IN
18637	16862	12	the	the	DT
18637	16862	13	witness	witness	NN
18637	16862	14	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16862	15	,	,	,
18637	16862	16	and	and	CC
18637	16862	17	may	may	MD
18637	16862	18	not	not	RB
18637	16862	19	be	be	VB
18637	16862	20	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	16862	21	for	for	IN
18637	16862	22	the	the	DT
18637	16862	23	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	16862	24	of	of	IN
18637	16862	25	third	third	JJ
18637	16862	26	parties	party	NNS
18637	16862	27	.	.	.
18637	16863	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16863	2	52	52	CD
18637	16863	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16863	4	The	the	DT
18637	16863	5	clause	clause	NN
18637	16863	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	16863	7	not	not	RB
18637	16863	8	impair	impair	VB
18637	16863	9	the	the	DT
18637	16863	10	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	16863	11	of	of	IN
18637	16863	12	a	a	DT
18637	16863	13	witness	witness	NN
18637	16863	14	to	to	TO
18637	16863	15	testify	testify	VB
18637	16863	16	if	if	IN
18637	16863	17	a	a	DT
18637	16863	18	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	16863	19	against	against	IN
18637	16863	20	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16863	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	16863	22	barred	bar	VBN
18637	16863	23	by	by	IN
18637	16863	24	lapse	lapse	NN
18637	16863	25	of	of	IN
18637	16863	26	time	time	NN
18637	16863	27	,	,	,
18637	16863	28	by	by	IN
18637	16863	29	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	16863	30	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	16863	31	,	,	,
18637	16863	32	or	or	CC
18637	16863	33	by	by	IN
18637	16863	34	a	a	DT
18637	16863	35	pardon;[53	pardon;[53	NNP
18637	16863	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16863	37	but	but	CC
18637	16863	38	the	the	DT
18637	16863	39	effect	effect	NN
18637	16863	40	of	of	IN
18637	16863	41	a	a	DT
18637	16863	42	mere	mere	JJ
18637	16863	43	tender	tender	NN
18637	16863	44	of	of	IN
18637	16863	45	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	16863	46	by	by	IN
18637	16863	47	the	the	DT
18637	16863	48	President	President	NNP
18637	16863	49	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	16863	50	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
18637	16863	51	.	.	.
18637	16864	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16864	2	54	54	CD
18637	16864	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16864	4	A	a	DT
18637	16864	5	witness	witness	NN
18637	16864	6	may	may	MD
18637	16864	7	not	not	RB
18637	16864	8	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	16864	9	to	to	TO
18637	16864	10	answer	answer	VB
18637	16864	11	questions	question	NNS
18637	16864	12	on	on	IN
18637	16864	13	the	the	DT
18637	16864	14	ground	ground	NN
18637	16864	15	that	that	IN
18637	16864	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16864	17	would	would	MD
18637	16864	18	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	16864	19	expose	expose	VB
18637	16864	20	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16864	21	to	to	IN
18637	16864	22	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	16864	23	by	by	IN
18637	16864	24	a	a	DT
18637	16864	25	state	state	NN
18637	16864	26	.	.	.
18637	16865	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16865	2	55	55	CD
18637	16865	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16865	4	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	16865	5	,	,	,
18637	16865	6	the	the	DT
18637	16865	7	admission	admission	NN
18637	16865	8	against	against	IN
18637	16865	9	a	a	DT
18637	16865	10	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	16865	11	in	in	IN
18637	16865	12	a	a	DT
18637	16865	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16865	14	court	court	NN
18637	16865	15	of	of	IN
18637	16865	16	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	16865	17	given	give	VBN
18637	16865	18	by	by	IN
18637	16865	19	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16865	20	in	in	IN
18637	16865	21	a	a	DT
18637	16865	22	state	state	NN
18637	16865	23	court	court	NN
18637	16865	24	under	under	IN
18637	16865	25	a	a	DT
18637	16865	26	statute	statute	NN
18637	16865	27	of	of	IN
18637	16865	28	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	16865	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	16865	30	valid	valid	JJ
18637	16865	31	.	.	.
18637	16866	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16866	2	56	56	CD
18637	16866	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16866	4	If	if	IN
18637	16866	5	an	an	DT
18637	16866	6	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16866	7	takes	take	VBZ
18637	16866	8	the	the	DT
18637	16866	9	stand	stand	NN
18637	16866	10	in	in	IN
18637	16866	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16866	12	own	own	JJ
18637	16866	13	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	16866	14	,	,	,
18637	16866	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16866	16	must	must	MD
18637	16866	17	submit	submit	VB
18637	16866	18	to	to	IN
18637	16866	19	cross	cross	JJ
18637	16866	20	-	-	VBN
18637	16866	21	examination;[57	examination;[57	NN
18637	16866	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16866	23	while	while	IN
18637	16866	24	if	if	IN
18637	16866	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16866	26	does	do	VBZ
18637	16866	27	not	not	RB
18637	16866	28	,	,	,
18637	16866	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16866	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	16866	31	by	by	IN
18637	16866	32	no	no	DT
18637	16866	33	means	mean	NNS
18637	16866	34	certain	certain	JJ
18637	16866	35	that	that	IN
18637	16866	36	the	the	DT
18637	16866	37	trial	trial	NN
18637	16866	38	judge	judge	NN
18637	16866	39	in	in	IN
18637	16866	40	a	a	DT
18637	16866	41	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16866	42	court	court	NN
18637	16866	43	may	may	MD
18637	16866	44	not	not	RB
18637	16866	45	,	,	,
18637	16866	46	without	without	IN
18637	16866	47	violation	violation	NN
18637	16866	48	of	of	IN
18637	16866	49	the	the	DT
18637	16866	50	clause	clause	NN
18637	16866	51	,	,	,
18637	16866	52	draw	draw	VB
18637	16866	53	the	the	DT
18637	16866	54	jury	jury	NN
18637	16866	55	's	's	POS
18637	16866	56	attention	attention	NN
18637	16866	57	to	to	IN
18637	16866	58	the	the	DT
18637	16866	59	fact	fact	NN
18637	16866	60	.	.	.
18637	16867	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16867	2	58	58	CD
18637	16867	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16867	4	Neither	neither	CC
18637	16867	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	16867	6	the	the	DT
18637	16867	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16867	8	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	16867	9	the	the	DT
18637	16867	10	admission	admission	NN
18637	16867	11	in	in	IN
18637	16867	12	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16867	13	against	against	IN
18637	16867	14	an	an	DT
18637	16867	15	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16867	16	of	of	IN
18637	16867	17	a	a	DT
18637	16867	18	confession	confession	NN
18637	16867	19	made	make	VBN
18637	16867	20	while	while	IN
18637	16867	21	in	in	IN
18637	16867	22	the	the	DT
18637	16867	23	custody	custody	NN
18637	16867	24	of	of	IN
18637	16867	25	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16867	26	,	,	,
18637	16867	27	if	if	IN
18637	16867	28	the	the	DT
18637	16867	29	confession	confession	NN
18637	16867	30	was	be	VBD
18637	16867	31	made	make	VBN
18637	16867	32	freely	freely	RB
18637	16867	33	,	,	,
18637	16867	34	voluntarily	voluntarily	RB
18637	16867	35	,	,	,
18637	16867	36	and	and	CC
18637	16867	37	without	without	IN
18637	16867	38	compulsion	compulsion	NN
18637	16867	39	or	or	CC
18637	16867	40	inducement	inducement	NN
18637	16867	41	of	of	IN
18637	16867	42	any	any	DT
18637	16867	43	sort	sort	NN
18637	16867	44	.	.	.
18637	16868	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16868	2	59	59	CD
18637	16868	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16868	4	But	but	CC
18637	16868	5	in	in	IN
18637	16868	6	McNabb	McNabb	NNP
18637	16868	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16868	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	16868	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16868	10	United	United	NNP
18637	16868	11	States	States	NNP
18637	16868	12	the	the	DT
18637	16868	13	Court[60	Court[60	NNP
18637	16868	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16868	15	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	16868	16	a	a	DT
18637	16868	17	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	16868	18	in	in	IN
18637	16868	19	a	a	DT
18637	16868	20	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16868	21	court	court	NN
18637	16868	22	,	,	,
18637	16868	23	based	base	VBN
18637	16868	24	on	on	IN
18637	16868	25	a	a	DT
18637	16868	26	confession	confession	NN
18637	16868	27	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	16868	28	by	by	IN
18637	16868	29	questioning	question	VBG
18637	16868	30	the	the	DT
18637	16868	31	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	16868	32	for	for	IN
18637	16868	33	prolonged	prolonged	JJ
18637	16868	34	periods	period	NNS
18637	16868	35	in	in	IN
18637	16868	36	the	the	DT
18637	16868	37	absence	absence	NN
18637	16868	38	of	of	IN
18637	16868	39	friends	friend	NNS
18637	16868	40	and	and	CC
18637	16868	41	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	16868	42	and	and	CC
18637	16868	43	without	without	IN
18637	16868	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16868	45	being	be	VBG
18637	16868	46	brought	bring	VBN
18637	16868	47	before	before	RB
18637	16868	48	a	a	DT
18637	16868	49	commissioner	commissioner	NN
18637	16868	50	or	or	CC
18637	16868	51	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16868	52	officer	officer	NN
18637	16868	53	,	,	,
18637	16868	54	as	as	IN
18637	16868	55	required	require	VBN
18637	16868	56	by	by	IN
18637	16868	57	law	law	NN
18637	16868	58	.	.	.
18637	16869	1	Without	without	IN
18637	16869	2	purporting	purport	VBG
18637	16869	3	to	to	TO
18637	16869	4	decide	decide	VB
18637	16869	5	the	the	DT
18637	16869	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16869	7	issue	issue	NN
18637	16869	8	,	,	,
18637	16869	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16869	10	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	16869	11	's	's	POS
18637	16869	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16869	13	urged	urge	VBD
18637	16869	14	the	the	DT
18637	16869	15	duty	duty	NN
18637	16869	16	of	of	IN
18637	16869	17	the	the	DT
18637	16869	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16869	19	,	,	,
18637	16869	20	in	in	IN
18637	16869	21	supervising	supervise	VBG
18637	16869	22	the	the	DT
18637	16869	23	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	16869	24	of	of	IN
18637	16869	25	the	the	DT
18637	16869	26	lower	low	JJR
18637	16869	27	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16869	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	16869	29	,	,	,
18637	16869	30	to	to	TO
18637	16869	31	establish	establish	VB
18637	16869	32	and	and	CC
18637	16869	33	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	16869	34	"	"	``
18637	16869	35	civilized	civilized	JJ
18637	16869	36	standards	standard	NNS
18637	16869	37	of	of	IN
18637	16869	38	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	16869	39	and	and	CC
18637	16869	40	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16869	41	.	.	.
18637	16870	1	"	"	``
18637	16870	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16870	3	61	61	CD
18637	16870	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16870	5	An	an	DT
18637	16870	6	individual	individual	NN
18637	16870	7	who	who	WP
18637	16870	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	16870	9	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	16870	10	income	income	NN
18637	16870	11	by	by	IN
18637	16870	12	illicit	illicit	JJ
18637	16870	13	means	mean	VBZ
18637	16870	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	16870	15	not	not	RB
18637	16870	16	excused	excuse	VBN
18637	16870	17	from	from	IN
18637	16870	18	making	make	VBG
18637	16870	19	out	out	RP
18637	16870	20	an	an	DT
18637	16870	21	income	income	NN
18637	16870	22	tax	tax	NN
18637	16870	23	return	return	NN
18637	16870	24	because	because	IN
18637	16870	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16870	26	might	may	MD
18637	16870	27	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	16870	28	expose	expose	VB
18637	16870	29	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16870	30	to	to	IN
18637	16870	31	a	a	DT
18637	16870	32	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16870	33	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	16870	34	by	by	IN
18637	16870	35	the	the	DT
18637	16870	36	United	United	NNP
18637	16870	37	States	States	NNP
18637	16870	38	.	.	.
18637	16871	1	"	"	``
18637	16871	2	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16871	3	could	could	MD
18637	16871	4	not	not	RB
18637	16871	5	draw	draw	VB
18637	16871	6	a	a	DT
18637	16871	7	conjurer	conjurer	NN
18637	16871	8	's	's	POS
18637	16871	9	circle	circle	NN
18637	16871	10	around	around	IN
18637	16871	11	the	the	DT
18637	16871	12	whole	whole	JJ
18637	16871	13	matter	matter	NN
18637	16871	14	,	,	,
18637	16871	15	"	"	''
18637	16871	16	said	say	VBD
18637	16871	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16871	18	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	16871	19	,	,	,
18637	16871	20	"	"	``
18637	16871	21	by	by	IN
18637	16871	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16871	23	own	own	JJ
18637	16871	24	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	16871	25	that	that	IN
18637	16871	26	to	to	TO
18637	16871	27	write	write	VB
18637	16871	28	any	any	DT
18637	16871	29	word	word	NN
18637	16871	30	upon	upon	IN
18637	16871	31	the	the	DT
18637	16871	32	government	government	NN
18637	16871	33	blank	blank	NN
18637	16871	34	would	would	MD
18637	16871	35	bring	bring	VB
18637	16871	36	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16871	37	into	into	IN
18637	16871	38	danger	danger	NN
18637	16871	39	of	of	IN
18637	16871	40	the	the	DT
18637	16871	41	law	law	NN
18637	16871	42	.	.	.
18637	16872	1	"	"	``
18637	16872	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16872	3	62	62	CD
18637	16872	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16872	5	But	but	CC
18637	16872	6	a	a	DT
18637	16872	7	witness	witness	NN
18637	16872	8	called	call	VBN
18637	16872	9	to	to	TO
18637	16872	10	testify	testify	VB
18637	16872	11	before	before	IN
18637	16872	12	a	a	DT
18637	16872	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16872	14	grand	grand	JJ
18637	16872	15	jury	jury	NN
18637	16872	16	as	as	IN
18637	16872	17	to	to	IN
18637	16872	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16872	19	relations	relation	NNS
18637	16872	20	with	with	IN
18637	16872	21	the	the	DT
18637	16872	22	Communist	Communist	NNP
18637	16872	23	Party	Party	NNP
18637	16872	24	can	can	MD
18637	16872	25	not	not	RB
18637	16872	26	,	,	,
18637	16872	27	in	in	IN
18637	16872	28	view	view	NN
18637	16872	29	of	of	IN
18637	16872	30	existing	exist	VBG
18637	16872	31	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	16872	32	touching	touch	VBG
18637	16872	33	the	the	DT
18637	16872	34	subject	subject	NN
18637	16872	35	,	,	,
18637	16872	36	be	be	VB
18637	16872	37	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	16872	38	to	to	TO
18637	16872	39	answer	answer	VB
18637	16872	40	.	.	.
18637	16873	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16873	2	63]he	63]he	CD
18637	16873	3	clause	clause	NN
18637	16873	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	16873	5	not	not	RB
18637	16873	6	require	require	VB
18637	16873	7	the	the	DT
18637	16873	8	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	16873	9	of	of	IN
18637	16873	10	the	the	DT
18637	16873	11	body	body	NN
18637	16873	12	of	of	IN
18637	16873	13	an	an	DT
18637	16873	14	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16873	15	as	as	IN
18637	16873	16	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16873	17	of	of	IN
18637	16873	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16873	19	identity;[64	identity;[64	NNP
18637	16873	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16873	21	but	but	CC
18637	16873	22	the	the	DT
18637	16873	23	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	16873	24	into	into	IN
18637	16873	25	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16873	26	against	against	IN
18637	16873	27	one	one	CD
18637	16873	28	who	who	WP
18637	16873	29	was	be	VBD
18637	16873	30	being	be	VBG
18637	16873	31	prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
18637	16873	32	by	by	IN
18637	16873	33	a	a	DT
18637	16873	34	State	State	NNP
18637	16873	35	for	for	IN
18637	16873	36	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	16873	37	possession	possession	NN
18637	16873	38	of	of	IN
18637	16873	39	morphine	morphine	NN
18637	16873	40	of	of	IN
18637	16873	41	two	two	CD
18637	16873	42	capsules	capsule	NNS
18637	16873	43	which	which	WDT
18637	16873	44	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16873	45	had	have	VBD
18637	16873	46	swallowed	swallow	VBN
18637	16873	47	and	and	CC
18637	16873	48	had	have	VBD
18637	16873	49	then	then	RB
18637	16873	50	been	be	VBN
18637	16873	51	forced	force	VBN
18637	16873	52	by	by	IN
18637	16873	53	the	the	DT
18637	16873	54	police	police	NN
18637	16873	55	to	to	TO
18637	16873	56	disgorge	disgorge	NNP
18637	16873	57	,	,	,
18637	16873	58	was	be	VBD
18637	16873	59	held	hold	VBN
18637	16873	60	to	to	TO
18637	16873	61	violate	violate	VB
18637	16873	62	due	due	JJ
18637	16873	63	process	process	NN
18637	16873	64	of	of	IN
18637	16873	65	law	law	NN
18637	16873	66	.	.	.
18637	16874	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16874	2	65	65	CD
18637	16874	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16874	4	A	a	DT
18637	16874	5	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
18637	16874	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	16874	7	not	not	RB
18637	16874	8	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	16874	9	of	of	IN
18637	16874	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16874	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16874	12	right	right	NN
18637	16874	13	not	not	RB
18637	16874	14	to	to	TO
18637	16874	15	testify	testify	VB
18637	16874	16	against	against	IN
18637	16874	17	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16874	18	by	by	IN
18637	16874	19	an	an	DT
18637	16874	20	order	order	NN
18637	16874	21	requiring	require	VBG
18637	16874	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16874	23	to	to	TO
18637	16874	24	surrender	surrender	VB
18637	16874	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16874	26	books	book	NNS
18637	16874	27	to	to	IN
18637	16874	28	a	a	DT
18637	16874	29	duly	duly	RB
18637	16874	30	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	16874	31	receiver	receiver	NN
18637	16874	32	.	.	.
18637	16875	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16875	2	66	66	CD
18637	16875	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16875	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16875	5	may	may	MD
18637	16875	6	not	not	RB
18637	16875	7	object	object	VB
18637	16875	8	to	to	IN
18637	16875	9	the	the	DT
18637	16875	10	use	use	NN
18637	16875	11	of	of	IN
18637	16875	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16875	13	books	book	NNS
18637	16875	14	and	and	CC
18637	16875	15	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16875	16	as	as	IN
18637	16875	17	incriminating	incriminate	VBG
18637	16875	18	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16875	19	against	against	IN
18637	16875	20	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16875	21	while	while	IN
18637	16875	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16875	23	are	be	VBP
18637	16875	24	in	in	IN
18637	16875	25	the	the	DT
18637	16875	26	custody	custody	NN
18637	16875	27	of	of	IN
18637	16875	28	the	the	DT
18637	16875	29	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	16875	30	court;[67	court;[67	NNS
18637	16875	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16875	32	nor	nor	CC
18637	16875	33	may	may	MD
18637	16875	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16875	35	condition	condition	VB
18637	16875	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16875	37	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	16875	38	by	by	IN
18637	16875	39	requiring	require	VBG
18637	16875	40	a	a	DT
18637	16875	41	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	16875	42	that	that	WDT
18637	16875	43	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16875	44	will	will	MD
18637	16875	45	not	not	RB
18637	16875	46	be	be	VB
18637	16875	47	used	use	VBN
18637	16875	48	as	as	IN
18637	16875	49	incriminating	incriminate	VBG
18637	16875	50	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16875	51	.	.	.
18637	16876	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16876	2	68	68	CD
18637	16876	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16876	4	The	the	DT
18637	16876	5	filing	filing	NN
18637	16876	6	of	of	IN
18637	16876	7	schedules	schedule	NNS
18637	16876	8	by	by	IN
18637	16876	9	a	a	DT
18637	16876	10	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
18637	16876	11	does	do	VBZ
18637	16876	12	not	not	RB
18637	16876	13	waive	waive	VB
18637	16876	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16876	15	right	right	NN
18637	16876	16	to	to	TO
18637	16876	17	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	16876	18	to	to	TO
18637	16876	19	answer	answer	VB
18637	16876	20	questions	question	NNS
18637	16876	21	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	16876	22	to	to	IN
18637	16876	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16876	24	when	when	WRB
18637	16876	25	to	to	TO
18637	16876	26	do	do	VB
18637	16876	27	so	so	RB
18637	16876	28	may	may	MD
18637	16876	29	incriminate	incriminate	VB
18637	16876	30	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16876	31	.	.	.
18637	16877	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16877	2	69	69	CD
18637	16877	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16877	4	A	a	DT
18637	16877	5	disclosure	disclosure	NN
18637	16877	6	,	,	,
18637	16877	7	not	not	RB
18637	16877	8	amounting	amount	VBG
18637	16877	9	to	to	IN
18637	16877	10	an	an	DT
18637	16877	11	actual	actual	JJ
18637	16877	12	admission	admission	NN
18637	16877	13	of	of	IN
18637	16877	14	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	16877	15	or	or	CC
18637	16877	16	of	of	IN
18637	16877	17	incriminating	incriminate	VBG
18637	16877	18	facts	fact	NNS
18637	16877	19	,	,	,
18637	16877	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	16877	21	not	not	RB
18637	16877	22	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	16877	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16877	24	of	of	IN
18637	16877	25	the	the	DT
18637	16877	26	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	16877	27	of	of	IN
18637	16877	28	stopping	stop	VBG
18637	16877	29	short	short	RB
18637	16877	30	in	in	IN
18637	16877	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16877	32	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	16877	33	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	16877	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16877	35	may	may	MD
18637	16877	36	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	16877	37	tend	tend	VB
18637	16877	38	to	to	TO
18637	16877	39	incriminate	incriminate	VB
18637	16877	40	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16877	41	.	.	.
18637	16878	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16878	2	70	70	CD
18637	16878	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16878	4	The	the	DT
18637	16878	5	rule	rule	NN
18637	16878	6	against	against	IN
18637	16878	7	self	self	NN
18637	16878	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	16878	9	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	16878	10	may	may	MD
18637	16878	11	be	be	VB
18637	16878	12	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	16878	13	by	by	IN
18637	16878	14	a	a	DT
18637	16878	15	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
18637	16878	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16878	17	in	in	IN
18637	16878	18	the	the	DT
18637	16878	19	absence	absence	NN
18637	16878	20	of	of	IN
18637	16878	21	any	any	DT
18637	16878	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	16878	23	affording	afford	VBG
18637	16878	24	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16878	25	complete	complete	JJ
18637	16878	26	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	16878	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16878	28	when	when	WRB
18637	16878	29	being	be	VBG
18637	16878	30	examined	examine	VBN
18637	16878	31	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	16878	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16878	33	estate	estate	NN
18637	16878	34	.	.	.
18637	16879	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16879	2	71	71	CD
18637	16879	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16879	4	The	the	DT
18637	16879	5	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	16879	6	of	of	IN
18637	16879	7	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	16879	8	,	,	,
18637	16879	9	being	be	VBG
18637	16879	10	a	a	DT
18637	16879	11	purely	purely	RB
18637	16879	12	personal	personal	JJ
18637	16879	13	one	one	NN
18637	16879	14	,	,	,
18637	16879	15	may	may	MD
18637	16879	16	not	not	RB
18637	16879	17	be	be	VB
18637	16879	18	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	16879	19	by	by	IN
18637	16879	20	an	an	DT
18637	16879	21	agent	agent	NN
18637	16879	22	or	or	CC
18637	16879	23	officer	officer	NN
18637	16879	24	of	of	IN
18637	16879	25	a	a	DT
18637	16879	26	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	16879	27	either	either	CC
18637	16879	28	in	in	IN
18637	16879	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16879	30	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	16879	31	or	or	CC
18637	16879	32	in	in	IN
18637	16879	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16879	34	own	own	JJ
18637	16879	35	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	16879	36	as	as	IN
18637	16879	37	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	16879	38	books	book	NNS
18637	16879	39	and	and	CC
18637	16879	40	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16879	41	of	of	IN
18637	16879	42	the	the	DT
18637	16879	43	corporation;[72	corporation;[72	NNP
18637	16879	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16879	45	and	and	CC
18637	16879	46	the	the	DT
18637	16879	47	same	same	JJ
18637	16879	48	rule	rule	NN
18637	16879	49	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	16879	50	in	in	IN
18637	16879	51	the	the	DT
18637	16879	52	case	case	NN
18637	16879	53	of	of	IN
18637	16879	54	the	the	DT
18637	16879	55	custodian	custodian	NN
18637	16879	56	of	of	IN
18637	16879	57	the	the	DT
18637	16879	58	records	record	NNS
18637	16879	59	of	of	IN
18637	16879	60	a	a	DT
18637	16879	61	labor	labor	NN
18637	16879	62	union;[73	union;[73	NNP
18637	16879	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16879	64	nor	nor	CC
18637	16879	65	does	do	VBZ
18637	16879	66	the	the	DT
18637	16879	67	Communist	Communist	NNP
18637	16879	68	Party	Party	NNP
18637	16879	69	enjoy	enjoy	VB
18637	16879	70	any	any	DT
18637	16879	71	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	16879	72	as	as	IN
18637	16879	73	to	to	IN
18637	16879	74	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16879	75	books	book	NNS
18637	16879	76	and	and	CC
18637	16879	77	records	record	NNS
18637	16879	78	.	.	.
18637	16880	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16880	2	74	74	CD
18637	16880	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16880	4	Finally	finally	RB
18637	16880	5	,	,	,
18637	16880	6	this	this	DT
18637	16880	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16880	8	,	,	,
18637	16880	9	in	in	IN
18637	16880	10	connection	connection	NN
18637	16880	11	with	with	IN
18637	16880	12	the	the	DT
18637	16880	13	interdiction	interdiction	NN
18637	16880	14	of	of	IN
18637	16880	15	the	the	DT
18637	16880	16	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	16880	17	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16880	18	against	against	IN
18637	16880	19	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	16880	20	searches	search	NNS
18637	16880	21	and	and	CC
18637	16880	22	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	16880	23	,	,	,
18637	16880	24	protects	protect	VBZ
18637	16880	25	an	an	DT
18637	16880	26	individual	individual	NN
18637	16880	27	from	from	IN
18637	16880	28	the	the	DT
18637	16880	29	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	16880	30	production	production	NN
18637	16880	31	of	of	IN
18637	16880	32	private	private	JJ
18637	16880	33	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16880	34	which	which	WDT
18637	16880	35	would	would	MD
18637	16880	36	incriminate	incriminate	VB
18637	16880	37	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16880	38	.	.	.
18637	16881	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16881	2	75	75	CD
18637	16881	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16881	4	The	the	DT
18637	16881	5	scope	scope	NN
18637	16881	6	of	of	IN
18637	16881	7	this	this	DT
18637	16881	8	latter	latter	JJ
18637	16881	9	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	16881	10	was	be	VBD
18637	16881	11	,	,	,
18637	16881	12	however	however	RB
18637	16881	13	,	,	,
18637	16881	14	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	16881	15	narrowed	narrow	VBN
18637	16881	16	by	by	IN
18637	16881	17	the	the	DT
18637	16881	18	decision	decision	NN
18637	16881	19	in	in	IN
18637	16881	20	Shapiro	Shapiro	NNP
18637	16881	21	_	_	NNP
18637	16881	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	16881	23	_	_	NNP
18637	16881	24	United	United	NNP
18637	16881	25	States	States	NNP
18637	16881	26	.	.	.
18637	16882	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16882	2	76	76	CD
18637	16882	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16882	4	There	there	RB
18637	16882	5	,	,	,
18637	16882	6	by	by	IN
18637	16882	7	a	a	DT
18637	16882	8	five	five	CD
18637	16882	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	16882	10	to	to	IN
18637	16882	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	16882	12	four	four	CD
18637	16882	13	majority	majority	NN
18637	16882	14	,	,	,
18637	16882	15	the	the	DT
18637	16882	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16882	17	held	hold	VBD
18637	16882	18	that	that	IN
18637	16882	19	the	the	DT
18637	16882	20	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	16882	21	against	against	IN
18637	16882	22	self	self	NN
18637	16882	23	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	16882	24	does	do	VBZ
18637	16882	25	not	not	RB
18637	16882	26	extend	extend	VB
18637	16882	27	to	to	IN
18637	16882	28	books	book	NNS
18637	16882	29	and	and	CC
18637	16882	30	records	record	NNS
18637	16882	31	which	which	WDT
18637	16882	32	an	an	DT
18637	16882	33	individual	individual	NN
18637	16882	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	16882	35	required	require	VBN
18637	16882	36	to	to	TO
18637	16882	37	keep	keep	VB
18637	16882	38	to	to	TO
18637	16882	39	evidence	evidence	VB
18637	16882	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16882	41	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	16882	42	with	with	IN
18637	16882	43	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	16882	44	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	16882	45	.	.	.
18637	16883	1	A	a	DT
18637	16883	2	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	16883	3	for	for	IN
18637	16883	4	violation	violation	NN
18637	16883	5	of	of	IN
18637	16883	6	OPA	opa	NN
18637	16883	7	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	16883	8	was	be	VBD
18637	16883	9	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	16883	10	,	,	,
18637	16883	11	as	as	IN
18637	16883	12	against	against	IN
18637	16883	13	the	the	DT
18637	16883	14	contention	contention	NN
18637	16883	15	that	that	IN
18637	16883	16	the	the	DT
18637	16883	17	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	16883	18	was	be	VBD
18637	16883	19	barred	bar	VBN
18637	16883	20	because	because	IN
18637	16883	21	the	the	DT
18637	16883	22	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16883	23	had	have	VBD
18637	16883	24	been	be	VBN
18637	16883	25	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	16883	26	over	over	IN
18637	16883	27	claim	claim	NN
18637	16883	28	of	of	IN
18637	16883	29	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16883	30	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	16883	31	to	to	TO
18637	16883	32	produce	produce	VB
18637	16883	33	records	record	NNS
18637	16883	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16883	35	was	be	VBD
18637	16883	36	required	require	VBN
18637	16883	37	to	to	TO
18637	16883	38	keep	keep	VB
18637	16883	39	under	under	IN
18637	16883	40	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	16883	41	OPA	opa	NN
18637	16883	42	orders	order	NNS
18637	16883	43	.	.	.
18637	16884	1	After	after	IN
18637	16884	2	construing	construe	VBG
18637	16884	3	the	the	DT
18637	16884	4	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	16884	5	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	16884	6	as	as	IN
18637	16884	7	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	16884	8	to	to	IN
18637	16884	9	the	the	DT
18637	16884	10	case	case	NN
18637	16884	11	,	,	,
18637	16884	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	16884	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16884	14	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	16884	15	disposed	dispose	VBD
18637	16884	16	of	of	IN
18637	16884	17	the	the	DT
18637	16884	18	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16884	19	objections	objection	NNS
18637	16884	20	by	by	IN
18637	16884	21	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	16884	22	that	that	IN
18637	16884	23	"	"	``
18637	16884	24	the	the	DT
18637	16884	25	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	16884	26	which	which	WDT
18637	16884	27	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	16884	28	as	as	IN
18637	16884	29	to	to	IN
18637	16884	30	private	private	JJ
18637	16884	31	papers	paper	NNS
18637	16884	32	can	can	MD
18637	16884	33	not	not	RB
18637	16884	34	be	be	VB
18637	16884	35	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	16884	36	in	in	IN
18637	16884	37	relation	relation	NN
18637	16884	38	to	to	IN
18637	16884	39	'	'	``
18637	16884	40	records	record	NNS
18637	16884	41	required	require	VBN
18637	16884	42	by	by	IN
18637	16884	43	law	law	NN
18637	16884	44	to	to	TO
18637	16884	45	be	be	VB
18637	16884	46	kept	keep	VBN
18637	16884	47	in	in	IN
18637	16884	48	order	order	NN
18637	16884	49	that	that	IN
18637	16884	50	there	there	EX
18637	16884	51	may	may	MD
18637	16884	52	be	be	VB
18637	16884	53	suitable	suitable	JJ
18637	16884	54	information	information	NN
18637	16884	55	of	of	IN
18637	16884	56	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	16884	57	which	which	WDT
18637	16884	58	are	be	VBP
18637	16884	59	the	the	DT
18637	16884	60	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	16884	61	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	16884	62	of	of	IN
18637	16884	63	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	16884	64	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	16884	65	and	and	CC
18637	16884	66	the	the	DT
18637	16884	67	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	16884	68	of	of	IN
18637	16884	69	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	16884	70	validly	validly	RB
18637	16884	71	established	establish	VBN
18637	16884	72	.	.	.
18637	16885	1	'	'	``
18637	16885	2	"	"	``
18637	16885	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16885	4	77	77	CD
18637	16885	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16885	6	Due	Due	NNP
18637	16885	7	Process	Process	NNP
18637	16885	8	of	of	IN
18637	16885	9	Law	Law	NNP
18637	16885	10	SOURCE	SOURCE	NNP
18637	16885	11	AND	and	CC
18637	16885	12	EVOLUTION	evolution	NN
18637	16885	13	OF	of	IN
18637	16885	14	THE	the	DT
18637	16885	15	MEANING	MEANING	NNP
18637	16885	16	OF	of	IN
18637	16885	17	THE	the	DT
18637	16885	18	TERM	term	NN
18637	16885	19	The	the	DT
18637	16885	20	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	16885	21	"	"	``
18637	16885	22	due	due	JJ
18637	16885	23	process	process	NN
18637	16885	24	of	of	IN
18637	16885	25	law	law	NN
18637	16885	26	"	"	''
18637	16885	27	comes	come	VBZ
18637	16885	28	from	from	IN
18637	16885	29	chapter	chapter	NN
18637	16885	30	3	3	CD
18637	16885	31	of	of	IN
18637	16885	32	28	28	CD
18637	16885	33	Edw	Edw	NNP
18637	16885	34	.	.	.
18637	16886	1	III	III	NNP
18637	16886	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16886	3	1355	1355	CD
18637	16886	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16886	5	,	,	,
18637	16886	6	which	which	WDT
18637	16886	7	reads	read	VBZ
18637	16886	8	:	:	:
18637	16886	9	"	"	``
18637	16886	10	No	no	DT
18637	16886	11	man	man	NN
18637	16886	12	of	of	IN
18637	16886	13	what	what	WP
18637	16886	14	state	state	NN
18637	16886	15	or	or	CC
18637	16886	16	condition	condition	NN
18637	16886	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16886	18	be	be	VB
18637	16886	19	,	,	,
18637	16886	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	16886	21	be	be	VB
18637	16886	22	put	put	VBN
18637	16886	23	out	out	IN
18637	16886	24	of	of	IN
18637	16886	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16886	26	lands	land	NNS
18637	16886	27	or	or	CC
18637	16886	28	tenements	tenement	NNS
18637	16886	29	nor	nor	CC
18637	16886	30	taken	take	VBN
18637	16886	31	,	,	,
18637	16886	32	nor	nor	CC
18637	16886	33	disinherited	disinherit	VBN
18637	16886	34	,	,	,
18637	16886	35	nor	nor	CC
18637	16886	36	put	put	VBN
18637	16886	37	to	to	IN
18637	16886	38	death	death	NN
18637	16886	39	,	,	,
18637	16886	40	without	without	IN
18637	16886	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16886	42	be	be	VB
18637	16886	43	brought	bring	VBN
18637	16886	44	to	to	TO
18637	16886	45	answer	answer	VB
18637	16886	46	by	by	IN
18637	16886	47	due	due	JJ
18637	16886	48	process	process	NN
18637	16886	49	of	of	IN
18637	16886	50	law	law	NN
18637	16886	51	.	.	.
18637	16886	52	"	"	''
18637	16887	1	This	this	DT
18637	16887	2	statute	statute	NN
18637	16887	3	,	,	,
18637	16887	4	in	in	IN
18637	16887	5	turn	turn	NN
18637	16887	6	,	,	,
18637	16887	7	harks	hark	VBZ
18637	16887	8	back	back	RB
18637	16887	9	to	to	IN
18637	16887	10	the	the	DT
18637	16887	11	famous	famous	JJ
18637	16887	12	chapter	chapter	NN
18637	16887	13	29	29	CD
18637	16887	14	of	of	IN
18637	16887	15	Magna	Magna	NNPS
18637	16887	16	Carta	Carta	NNP
18637	16887	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16887	18	issue	issue	NN
18637	16887	19	of	of	IN
18637	16887	20	1225	1225	CD
18637	16887	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16887	22	,	,	,
18637	16887	23	where	where	WRB
18637	16887	24	the	the	DT
18637	16887	25	King	King	NNP
18637	16887	26	promises	promise	VBZ
18637	16887	27	that	that	IN
18637	16887	28	"	"	``
18637	16887	29	no	no	DT
18637	16887	30	free	free	JJ
18637	16887	31	man	man	NN
18637	16887	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16887	33	_	_	NNP
18637	16887	34	nullus	nullus	JJ
18637	16887	35	liber	liber	NNP
18637	16887	36	homo	homo	NN
18637	16887	37	_	_	NNP
18637	16887	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16887	39	shall	shall	MD
18637	16887	40	be	be	VB
18637	16887	41	taken	take	VBN
18637	16887	42	or	or	CC
18637	16887	43	imprisoned	imprison	VBN
18637	16887	44	or	or	CC
18637	16887	45	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	16887	46	of	of	IN
18637	16887	47	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16887	48	freehold	freehold	JJ
18637	16887	49	or	or	CC
18637	16887	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16887	51	liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	16887	52	or	or	CC
18637	16887	53	free	free	JJ
18637	16887	54	customs	custom	NNS
18637	16887	55	,	,	,
18637	16887	56	or	or	CC
18637	16887	57	outlawed	outlaw	VBN
18637	16887	58	or	or	CC
18637	16887	59	exiled	exile	VBN
18637	16887	60	,	,	,
18637	16887	61	or	or	CC
18637	16887	62	in	in	IN
18637	16887	63	any	any	DT
18637	16887	64	manner	manner	NN
18637	16887	65	destroyed	destroy	VBN
18637	16887	66	,	,	,
18637	16887	67	nor	nor	CC
18637	16887	68	shall	shall	MD
18637	16887	69	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16887	70	come	come	VB
18637	16887	71	upon	upon	IN
18637	16887	72	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16887	73	or	or	CC
18637	16887	74	send	send	VB
18637	16887	75	against	against	IN
18637	16887	76	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16887	77	,	,	,
18637	16887	78	except	except	IN
18637	16887	79	by	by	IN
18637	16887	80	a	a	DT
18637	16887	81	legal	legal	JJ
18637	16887	82	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16887	83	of	of	IN
18637	16887	84	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16887	85	peers	peer	NNS
18637	16887	86	or	or	CC
18637	16887	87	by	by	IN
18637	16887	88	the	the	DT
18637	16887	89	law	law	NN
18637	16887	90	of	of	IN
18637	16887	91	the	the	DT
18637	16887	92	land	land	NN
18637	16887	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	16887	94	_	_	NNP
18637	16887	95	per	per	IN
18637	16887	96	legem	legem	NNP
18637	16887	97	terrae	terrae	NNP
18637	16887	98	_	_	NNP
18637	16887	99	)	)	-RRB-
18637	16887	100	.	.	.
18637	16887	101	"	"	''
18637	16888	1	Coke	Coke	NNP
18637	16888	2	in	in	IN
18637	16888	3	Part	Part	NNP
18637	16888	4	II	II	NNP
18637	16888	5	of	of	IN
18637	16888	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16888	7	Institutes	Institutes	NNPS
18637	16888	8	,	,	,
18637	16888	9	which	which	WDT
18637	16888	10	was	be	VBD
18637	16888	11	the	the	DT
18637	16888	12	source	source	NN
18637	16888	13	from	from	IN
18637	16888	14	which	which	WDT
18637	16888	15	the	the	DT
18637	16888	16	founders	founder	NNS
18637	16888	17	of	of	IN
18637	16888	18	the	the	DT
18637	16888	19	American	American	NNP
18637	16888	20	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	16888	21	System	System	NNP
18637	16888	22	derived	derive	VBD
18637	16888	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16888	24	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	16888	25	of	of	IN
18637	16888	26	the	the	DT
18637	16888	27	matter	matter	NN
18637	16888	28	,	,	,
18637	16888	29	equates	equate	VBZ
18637	16888	30	the	the	DT
18637	16888	31	term	term	NN
18637	16888	32	"	"	''
18637	16888	33	by	by	IN
18637	16888	34	law	law	NN
18637	16888	35	of	of	IN
18637	16888	36	the	the	DT
18637	16888	37	land	land	NN
18637	16888	38	"	"	''
18637	16888	39	with	with	IN
18637	16888	40	"	"	''
18637	16888	41	by	by	IN
18637	16888	42	due	due	JJ
18637	16888	43	process	process	NN
18637	16888	44	of	of	IN
18637	16888	45	law	law	NN
18637	16888	46	,	,	,
18637	16888	47	"	"	''
18637	16888	48	which	which	WDT
18637	16888	49	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16888	50	in	in	IN
18637	16888	51	turn	turn	NN
18637	16888	52	defines	define	NNS
18637	16888	53	as	as	IN
18637	16888	54	"	"	``
18637	16888	55	by	by	IN
18637	16888	56	due	due	JJ
18637	16888	57	process	process	NN
18637	16888	58	of	of	IN
18637	16888	59	the	the	DT
18637	16888	60	common	common	JJ
18637	16888	61	law	law	NN
18637	16888	62	,	,	,
18637	16888	63	"	"	''
18637	16888	64	that	that	DT
18637	16888	65	is	be	VBZ
18637	16888	66	"	"	``
18637	16888	67	by	by	IN
18637	16888	68	the	the	DT
18637	16888	69	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	16888	70	or	or	CC
18637	16888	71	presentment	presentment	NN
18637	16888	72	of	of	IN
18637	16888	73	good	good	JJ
18637	16888	74	and	and	CC
18637	16888	75	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	16888	76	men	man	NNS
18637	16888	77	*	*	NFP
18637	16888	78	*	*	NFP
18637	16888	79	*	*	NFP
18637	16888	80	or	or	CC
18637	16888	81	by	by	IN
18637	16888	82	writ	writ	VBN
18637	16888	83	original	original	JJ
18637	16888	84	of	of	IN
18637	16888	85	the	the	DT
18637	16888	86	Common	Common	NNP
18637	16888	87	Law	Law	NNP
18637	16888	88	.	.	.
18637	16889	1	"	"	``
18637	16889	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16889	3	78	78	CD
18637	16889	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16889	5	The	the	DT
18637	16889	6	significance	significance	NN
18637	16889	7	of	of	IN
18637	16889	8	both	both	DT
18637	16889	9	terms	term	NNS
18637	16889	10	was	be	VBD
18637	16889	11	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	16889	12	purely	purely	RB
18637	16889	13	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	16889	14	;	;	:
18637	16889	15	the	the	DT
18637	16889	16	term	term	NN
18637	16889	17	"	"	``
18637	16889	18	writ	writ	JJ
18637	16889	19	original	original	JJ
18637	16889	20	of	of	IN
18637	16889	21	the	the	DT
18637	16889	22	common	common	JJ
18637	16889	23	law	law	NN
18637	16889	24	"	"	''
18637	16889	25	referring	refer	VBG
18637	16889	26	to	to	IN
18637	16889	27	the	the	DT
18637	16889	28	writs	writ	NNS
18637	16889	29	on	on	IN
18637	16889	30	which	which	WDT
18637	16889	31	civil	civil	JJ
18637	16889	32	actions	action	NNS
18637	16889	33	were	be	VBD
18637	16889	34	brought	bring	VBN
18637	16889	35	into	into	IN
18637	16889	36	the	the	DT
18637	16889	37	King	king	NN
18637	16889	38	's	's	POS
18637	16889	39	courts	court	NNS
18637	16889	40	;	;	:
18637	16889	41	and	and	CC
18637	16889	42	this	this	DT
18637	16889	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	16889	44	the	the	DT
18637	16889	45	significance	significance	NN
18637	16889	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16889	47	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	16889	48	have	have	VBP
18637	16889	49	in	in	IN
18637	16889	50	the	the	DT
18637	16889	51	State	State	NNP
18637	16889	52	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	16889	53	.	.	.
18637	16890	1	In	in	IN
18637	16890	2	the	the	DT
18637	16890	3	earlier	early	JJR
18637	16890	4	of	of	IN
18637	16890	5	such	such	JJ
18637	16890	6	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	16890	7	the	the	DT
18637	16890	8	term	term	NN
18637	16890	9	"	"	``
18637	16890	10	law	law	NN
18637	16890	11	of	of	IN
18637	16890	12	the	the	DT
18637	16890	13	land	land	NN
18637	16890	14	"	"	''
18637	16890	15	was	be	VBD
18637	16890	16	the	the	DT
18637	16890	17	form	form	NN
18637	16890	18	preferred	prefer	VBN
18637	16890	19	,	,	,
18637	16890	20	but	but	CC
18637	16890	21	following	follow	VBG
18637	16890	22	the	the	DT
18637	16890	23	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	16890	24	of	of	IN
18637	16890	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16890	26	V	V	NNP
18637	16890	27	"	"	``
18637	16890	28	due	due	JJ
18637	16890	29	process	process	NN
18637	16890	30	of	of	IN
18637	16890	31	law	law	NN
18637	16890	32	"	"	''
18637	16890	33	became	become	VBD
18637	16890	34	the	the	DT
18637	16890	35	vogue	vogue	NN
18637	16890	36	with	with	IN
18637	16890	37	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	16890	38	draftsmen	draftsman	NNS
18637	16890	39	.	.	.
18637	16891	1	Some	some	DT
18637	16891	2	State	state	NN
18637	16891	3	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	16891	4	even	even	RB
18637	16891	5	today	today	NN
18637	16891	6	employ	employ	VB
18637	16891	7	both	both	DT
18637	16891	8	terms	term	NNS
18637	16891	9	.	.	.
18637	16892	1	Whichever	whichever	WDT
18637	16892	2	phraseology	phraseology	NN
18637	16892	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	16892	4	used	use	VBN
18637	16892	5	always	always	RB
18637	16892	6	occurs	occur	VBZ
18637	16892	7	in	in	IN
18637	16892	8	close	close	JJ
18637	16892	9	association	association	NN
18637	16892	10	with	with	IN
18637	16892	11	other	other	JJ
18637	16892	12	safeguards	safeguard	NNS
18637	16892	13	of	of	IN
18637	16892	14	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16892	15	persons	person	NNS
18637	16892	16	,	,	,
18637	16892	17	just	just	RB
18637	16892	18	as	as	IN
18637	16892	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	16892	20	the	the	DT
18637	16892	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	16892	22	here	here	RB
18637	16892	23	under	under	IN
18637	16892	24	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	16892	25	in	in	IN
18637	16892	26	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16892	27	V.	V.	NNP
18637	16892	28	As	as	IN
18637	16892	29	a	a	DT
18637	16892	30	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	16892	31	,	,	,
18637	16892	32	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	16892	33	,	,	,
18637	16892	34	on	on	IN
18637	16892	35	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	16892	36	power	power	NN
18637	16892	37	the	the	DT
18637	16892	38	due	due	JJ
18637	16892	39	process	process	NN
18637	16892	40	clause	clause	NN
18637	16892	41	originally	originally	RB
18637	16892	42	operated	operate	VBD
18637	16892	43	simply	simply	RB
18637	16892	44	to	to	TO
18637	16892	45	place	place	VB
18637	16892	46	certain	certain	JJ
18637	16892	47	procedures	procedure	NNS
18637	16892	48	,	,	,
18637	16892	49	and	and	CC
18637	16892	50	especially	especially	RB
18637	16892	51	the	the	DT
18637	16892	52	grand	grand	JJ
18637	16892	53	jury	jury	NN
18637	16892	54	-	-	HYPH
18637	16892	55	petit	petit	NN
18637	16892	56	jury	jury	NN
18637	16892	57	process	process	NN
18637	16892	58	,	,	,
18637	16892	59	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	16892	60	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16892	61	reach	reach	NN
18637	16892	62	,	,	,
18637	16892	63	but	but	CC
18637	16892	64	this	this	DT
18637	16892	65	did	do	VBD
18637	16892	66	not	not	RB
18637	16892	67	remain	remain	VB
18637	16892	68	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16892	69	sole	sole	JJ
18637	16892	70	importance	importance	NN
18637	16892	71	or	or	CC
18637	16892	72	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16892	73	principal	principal	JJ
18637	16892	74	importance	importance	NN
18637	16892	75	.	.	.
18637	16893	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16893	2	79	79	CD
18637	16893	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16893	4	Today	today	NN
18637	16893	5	the	the	DT
18637	16893	6	due	due	JJ
18637	16893	7	process	process	NN
18637	16893	8	clause	clause	NN
18637	16893	9	in	in	IN
18637	16893	10	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16893	11	V	V	NNP
18637	16893	12	,	,	,
18637	16893	13	in	in	IN
18637	16893	14	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16893	15	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	16893	16	,	,	,
18637	16893	17	and	and	CC
18637	16893	18	in	in	IN
18637	16893	19	the	the	DT
18637	16893	20	State	State	NNP
18637	16893	21	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	16893	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	16893	23	important	important	JJ
18637	16893	24	chiefly	chiefly	NN
18637	16893	25	,	,	,
18637	16893	26	not	not	RB
18637	16893	27	as	as	IN
18637	16893	28	consecrating	consecrate	VBG
18637	16893	29	certain	certain	JJ
18637	16893	30	procedures	procedure	NNS
18637	16893	31	,	,	,
18637	16893	32	but	but	CC
18637	16893	33	as	as	IN
18637	16893	34	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	16893	35	the	the	DT
18637	16893	36	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	16893	37	content	content	NN
18637	16893	38	of	of	IN
18637	16893	39	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	16893	40	.	.	.
18637	16894	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	16894	2	one	one	CD
18637	16894	3	of	of	IN
18637	16894	4	the	the	DT
18637	16894	5	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	16894	6	on	on	IN
18637	16894	7	which	which	WDT
18637	16894	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	16894	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16894	10	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	16894	11	,	,	,
18637	16894	12	in	in	IN
18637	16894	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16894	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16894	15	in	in	IN
18637	16894	16	the	the	DT
18637	16894	17	Dred	Dred	NNP
18637	16894	18	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	16894	19	Case	Case	NNP
18637	16894	20	,	,	,
18637	16894	21	stigmatized	stigmatize	VBD
18637	16894	22	the	the	DT
18637	16894	23	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	16894	24	Compromise	Compromise	NNP
18637	16894	25	as	as	IN
18637	16894	26	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	16894	27	was	be	VBD
18637	16894	28	that	that	IN
18637	16894	29	an	an	DT
18637	16894	30	act	act	NN
18637	16894	31	of	of	IN
18637	16894	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16894	33	which	which	WDT
18637	16894	34	deprived	deprive	VBD
18637	16894	35	"	"	``
18637	16894	36	a	a	DT
18637	16894	37	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	16894	38	of	of	IN
18637	16894	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16894	40	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16894	41	or	or	CC
18637	16894	42	property	property	NN
18637	16894	43	merely	merely	RB
18637	16894	44	because	because	IN
18637	16894	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16894	46	came	come	VBD
18637	16894	47	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16894	48	or	or	CC
18637	16894	49	brought	bring	VBD
18637	16894	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16894	51	property	property	NN
18637	16894	52	into	into	IN
18637	16894	53	a	a	DT
18637	16894	54	particular	particular	JJ
18637	16894	55	territory	territory	NN
18637	16894	56	of	of	IN
18637	16894	57	the	the	DT
18637	16894	58	United	United	NNP
18637	16894	59	States	States	NNP
18637	16894	60	,	,	,
18637	16894	61	and	and	CC
18637	16894	62	who	who	WP
18637	16894	63	had	have	VBD
18637	16894	64	committed	commit	VBN
18637	16894	65	no	no	DT
18637	16894	66	offence	offence	NN
18637	16894	67	against	against	IN
18637	16894	68	the	the	DT
18637	16894	69	laws	law	NNS
18637	16894	70	,	,	,
18637	16894	71	could	could	MD
18637	16894	72	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	16894	73	be	be	VB
18637	16894	74	dignified	dignify	VBN
18637	16894	75	with	with	IN
18637	16894	76	the	the	DT
18637	16894	77	name	name	NN
18637	16894	78	of	of	IN
18637	16894	79	due	due	JJ
18637	16894	80	process	process	NN
18637	16894	81	of	of	IN
18637	16894	82	law";[80	law";[80	NNP
18637	16894	83	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16894	84	and	and	CC
18637	16894	85	sixty	sixty	CD
18637	16894	86	-	-	HYPH
18637	16894	87	six	six	CD
18637	16894	88	years	year	NNS
18637	16894	89	later	later	RBR
18637	16894	90	the	the	DT
18637	16894	91	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16894	92	held	hold	VBD
18637	16894	93	the	the	DT
18637	16894	94	District	District	NNP
18637	16894	95	of	of	IN
18637	16894	96	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	16894	97	Minimum	Minimum	NNP
18637	16894	98	Wage	Wage	NNP
18637	16894	99	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16894	100	for	for	IN
18637	16894	101	women	woman	NNS
18637	16894	102	and	and	CC
18637	16894	103	minors	minor	NNS
18637	16894	104	to	to	TO
18637	16894	105	be	be	VB
18637	16894	106	void	void	JJ
18637	16894	107	under	under	IN
18637	16894	108	the	the	DT
18637	16894	109	due	due	JJ
18637	16894	110	process	process	NN
18637	16894	111	clause	clause	NN
18637	16894	112	of	of	IN
18637	16894	113	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16894	114	V	V	NNP
18637	16894	115	,	,	,
18637	16894	116	not	not	RB
18637	16894	117	on	on	IN
18637	16894	118	account	account	NN
18637	16894	119	of	of	IN
18637	16894	120	any	any	DT
18637	16894	121	objection	objection	NN
18637	16894	122	to	to	IN
18637	16894	123	the	the	DT
18637	16894	124	methods	method	NNS
18637	16894	125	by	by	IN
18637	16894	126	which	which	WDT
18637	16894	127	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16894	128	was	be	VBD
18637	16894	129	to	to	TO
18637	16894	130	be	be	VB
18637	16894	131	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	16894	132	but	but	CC
18637	16894	133	because	because	IN
18637	16894	134	of	of	IN
18637	16894	135	the	the	DT
18637	16894	136	content	content	NN
18637	16894	137	of	of	IN
18637	16894	138	the	the	DT
18637	16894	139	act	act	NN
18637	16894	140	--	--	:
18637	16894	141	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16894	142	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	16894	143	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	16894	144	.	.	.
18637	16895	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16895	2	81	81	CD
18637	16895	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16895	4	And	and	CC
18637	16895	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16895	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	16895	7	because	because	IN
18637	16895	8	of	of	IN
18637	16895	9	this	this	DT
18637	16895	10	extension	extension	NN
18637	16895	11	of	of	IN
18637	16895	12	the	the	DT
18637	16895	13	term	term	NN
18637	16895	14	"	"	``
18637	16895	15	due	due	JJ
18637	16895	16	process	process	NN
18637	16895	17	of	of	IN
18637	16895	18	law	law	NN
18637	16895	19	"	"	''
18637	16895	20	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	16895	21	the	the	DT
18637	16895	22	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	16895	23	field	field	NN
18637	16895	24	that	that	WDT
18637	16895	25	the	the	DT
18637	16895	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16895	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	16895	28	been	be	VBN
18637	16895	29	asked	ask	VBN
18637	16895	30	to	to	TO
18637	16895	31	pass	pass	VB
18637	16895	32	upon	upon	IN
18637	16895	33	literally	literally	JJ
18637	16895	34	hundreds	hundred	NNS
18637	16895	35	of	of	IN
18637	16895	36	State	state	NN
18637	16895	37	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	16895	38	since	since	IN
18637	16895	39	about	about	RB
18637	16895	40	1890	1890	CD
18637	16895	41	on	on	IN
18637	16895	42	the	the	DT
18637	16895	43	representation	representation	NN
18637	16895	44	that	that	IN
18637	16895	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16895	46	invaded	invade	VBD
18637	16895	47	the	the	DT
18637	16895	48	"	"	``
18637	16895	49	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16895	50	"	"	''
18637	16895	51	or	or	CC
18637	16895	52	property	property	NN
18637	16895	53	rights	right	NNS
18637	16895	54	of	of	IN
18637	16895	55	certain	certain	JJ
18637	16895	56	persons	person	NNS
18637	16895	57	"	"	``
18637	16895	58	unreasonably	unreasonably	RB
18637	16895	59	.	.	.
18637	16895	60	"	"	''
18637	16896	1	In	in	IN
18637	16896	2	short	short	JJ
18637	16896	3	,	,	,
18637	16896	4	this	this	DT
18637	16896	5	development	development	NN
18637	16896	6	of	of	IN
18637	16896	7	the	the	DT
18637	16896	8	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	16896	9	of	of	IN
18637	16896	10	"	"	``
18637	16896	11	due	due	JJ
18637	16896	12	process	process	NN
18637	16896	13	of	of	IN
18637	16896	14	law	law	NN
18637	16896	15	"	"	''
18637	16896	16	came	come	VBD
18637	16896	17	in	in	IN
18637	16896	18	time	time	NN
18637	16896	19	to	to	TO
18637	16896	20	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	16896	21	one	one	CD
18637	16896	22	of	of	IN
18637	16896	23	the	the	DT
18637	16896	24	principal	principal	JJ
18637	16896	25	bases	basis	NNS
18637	16896	26	of	of	IN
18637	16896	27	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16896	28	review	review	NN
18637	16896	29	,	,	,
18637	16896	30	and	and	CC
18637	16896	31	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	16896	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16896	33	still	still	RB
18637	16896	34	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	16896	35	such	such	JJ
18637	16896	36	so	so	RB
18637	16896	37	far	far	RB
18637	16896	38	as	as	IN
18637	16896	39	State	State	NNP
18637	16896	40	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	16896	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	16896	42	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	16896	43	.	.	.
18637	16897	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16897	2	See	See	NNP
18637	16897	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16897	4	pp	pp	NNP
18637	16897	5	.	.	.
18637	16898	1	971	971	CD
18637	16898	2	-	-	SYM
18637	16898	3	974	974	CD
18637	16898	4	.	.	.
18637	16899	1	SCOPE	scope	NN
18637	16899	2	OF	of	IN
18637	16899	3	GUARANTY	GUARANTY	NNP
18637	16899	4	This	this	DT
18637	16899	5	clause	clause	NN
18637	16899	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	16899	7	a	a	DT
18637	16899	8	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	16899	9	on	on	IN
18637	16899	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16899	11	as	as	RB
18637	16899	12	well	well	RB
18637	16899	13	as	as	IN
18637	16899	14	on	on	IN
18637	16899	15	the	the	DT
18637	16899	16	executive	executive	JJ
18637	16899	17	and	and	CC
18637	16899	18	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16899	19	powers	power	NNS
18637	16899	20	of	of	IN
18637	16899	21	the	the	DT
18637	16899	22	National	National	NNP
18637	16899	23	Government	Government	NNP
18637	16899	24	;	;	:
18637	16899	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16899	26	can	can	MD
18637	16899	27	not	not	RB
18637	16899	28	be	be	VB
18637	16899	29	so	so	RB
18637	16899	30	construed	construe	VBN
18637	16899	31	as	as	IN
18637	16899	32	to	to	TO
18637	16899	33	leave	leave	VB
18637	16899	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16899	35	free	free	JJ
18637	16899	36	to	to	TO
18637	16899	37	make	make	VB
18637	16899	38	any	any	DT
18637	16899	39	process	process	NN
18637	16899	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16899	41	chooses	choose	VBZ
18637	16899	42	"	"	``
18637	16899	43	due	due	JJ
18637	16899	44	process	process	NN
18637	16899	45	of	of	IN
18637	16899	46	law	law	NN
18637	16899	47	.	.	.
18637	16900	1	"	"	``
18637	16900	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16900	3	82	82	CD
18637	16900	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16900	5	All	all	DT
18637	16900	6	persons	person	NNS
18637	16900	7	within	within	IN
18637	16900	8	the	the	DT
18637	16900	9	territory	territory	NN
18637	16900	10	of	of	IN
18637	16900	11	the	the	DT
18637	16900	12	United	United	NNP
18637	16900	13	States	States	NNP
18637	16900	14	are	be	VBP
18637	16900	15	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	16900	16	to	to	IN
18637	16900	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16900	18	protection	protection	NN
18637	16900	19	,	,	,
18637	16900	20	including	include	VBG
18637	16900	21	corporations,[83	corporations,[83	CD
18637	16900	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16900	23	aliens,[84	aliens,[84	CD
18637	16900	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16900	25	and	and	CC
18637	16900	26	presumptively	presumptively	RB
18637	16900	27	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	16900	28	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	16900	29	readmission	readmission	NN
18637	16900	30	to	to	IN
18637	16900	31	the	the	DT
18637	16900	32	United	United	NNP
18637	16900	33	States	States	NNP
18637	16900	34	.	.	.
18637	16901	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16901	2	85	85	CD
18637	16901	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16901	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16901	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	16901	6	effective	effective	JJ
18637	16901	7	in	in	IN
18637	16901	8	the	the	DT
18637	16901	9	District	District	NNP
18637	16901	10	of	of	IN
18637	16901	11	Columbia[86	Columbia[86	NNP
18637	16901	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16901	13	and	and	CC
18637	16901	14	in	in	IN
18637	16901	15	territories	territory	NNS
18637	16901	16	which	which	WDT
18637	16901	17	are	be	VBP
18637	16901	18	part	part	NN
18637	16901	19	of	of	IN
18637	16901	20	the	the	DT
18637	16901	21	United	United	NNP
18637	16901	22	States,[87	States,[87	NNP
18637	16901	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16901	24	but	but	CC
18637	16901	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16901	26	does	do	VBZ
18637	16901	27	not	not	RB
18637	16901	28	apply	apply	VB
18637	16901	29	of	of	IN
18637	16901	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16901	31	own	own	JJ
18637	16901	32	force	force	NN
18637	16901	33	to	to	IN
18637	16901	34	unincorporated	unincorporated	JJ
18637	16901	35	territories	territory	NNS
18637	16901	36	.	.	.
18637	16902	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16902	2	88	88	CD
18637	16902	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16902	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	16902	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	16902	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16902	7	reach	reach	VB
18637	16902	8	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	16902	9	alien	alien	JJ
18637	16902	10	belligerents	belligerent	NNS
18637	16902	11	tried	try	VBN
18637	16902	12	by	by	IN
18637	16902	13	military	military	JJ
18637	16902	14	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	16902	15	outside	outside	IN
18637	16902	16	the	the	DT
18637	16902	17	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	16902	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	16902	19	of	of	IN
18637	16902	20	the	the	DT
18637	16902	21	United	United	NNP
18637	16902	22	States	States	NNP
18637	16902	23	.	.	.
18637	16903	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16903	2	89	89	CD
18637	16903	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16903	4	Procedural	Procedural	NNP
18637	16903	5	Due	Due	NNP
18637	16903	6	Process	Process	NNP
18637	16903	7	GENERAL	GENERAL	NNP
18637	16903	8	The	the	DT
18637	16903	9	words	word	NNS
18637	16903	10	"	"	``
18637	16903	11	due	due	JJ
18637	16903	12	process	process	NN
18637	16903	13	of	of	IN
18637	16903	14	law	law	NN
18637	16903	15	"	"	''
18637	16903	16	do	do	VBP
18637	16903	17	not	not	RB
18637	16903	18	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	16903	19	imply	imply	VB
18637	16903	20	a	a	DT
18637	16903	21	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	16903	22	in	in	IN
18637	16903	23	a	a	DT
18637	16903	24	court	court	NN
18637	16903	25	of	of	IN
18637	16903	26	justice,[90	justice,[90	NNP
18637	16903	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16903	28	or	or	CC
18637	16903	29	a	a	DT
18637	16903	30	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	16903	31	suit	suit	NN
18637	16903	32	and	and	CC
18637	16903	33	trial	trial	NN
18637	16903	34	by	by	IN
18637	16903	35	jury	jury	NN
18637	16903	36	in	in	IN
18637	16903	37	every	every	DT
18637	16903	38	case	case	NN
18637	16903	39	where	where	WRB
18637	16903	40	personal	personal	JJ
18637	16903	41	or	or	CC
18637	16903	42	property	property	NN
18637	16903	43	rights	right	NNS
18637	16903	44	are	be	VBP
18637	16903	45	involved	involve	VBN
18637	16903	46	.	.	.
18637	16904	1	"	"	``
18637	16904	2	In	in	IN
18637	16904	3	all	all	DT
18637	16904	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	16904	5	,	,	,
18637	16904	6	that	that	DT
18637	16904	7	kind	kind	NN
18637	16904	8	of	of	IN
18637	16904	9	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	16904	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	16904	11	due	due	JJ
18637	16904	12	process	process	NN
18637	16904	13	of	of	IN
18637	16904	14	law	law	NN
18637	16904	15	which	which	WDT
18637	16904	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	16904	17	suitable	suitable	JJ
18637	16904	18	and	and	CC
18637	16904	19	proper	proper	JJ
18637	16904	20	to	to	IN
18637	16904	21	the	the	DT
18637	16904	22	nature	nature	NN
18637	16904	23	of	of	IN
18637	16904	24	the	the	DT
18637	16904	25	case	case	NN
18637	16904	26	,	,	,
18637	16904	27	and	and	CC
18637	16904	28	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
18637	16904	29	by	by	IN
18637	16904	30	the	the	DT
18637	16904	31	established	establish	VBN
18637	16904	32	customs	custom	NNS
18637	16904	33	and	and	CC
18637	16904	34	usages	usage	NNS
18637	16904	35	of	of	IN
18637	16904	36	the	the	DT
18637	16904	37	courts	court	NNS
18637	16904	38	.	.	.
18637	16905	1	"	"	``
18637	16905	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16905	3	91	91	CD
18637	16905	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16905	5	Proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16905	6	for	for	IN
18637	16905	7	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	16905	8	of	of	IN
18637	16905	9	court[92	court[92	NN
18637	16905	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16905	11	or	or	CC
18637	16905	12	to	to	TO
18637	16905	13	disbar	disbar	VB
18637	16905	14	an	an	DT
18637	16905	15	attorney[93	attorney[93	NN
18637	16905	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16905	17	may	may	MD
18637	16905	18	be	be	VB
18637	16905	19	determined	determine	VBN
18637	16905	20	by	by	IN
18637	16905	21	a	a	DT
18637	16905	22	court	court	NN
18637	16905	23	without	without	IN
18637	16905	24	a	a	DT
18637	16905	25	jury	jury	NN
18637	16905	26	trial	trial	NN
18637	16905	27	.	.	.
18637	16906	1	For	for	IN
18637	16906	2	persons	person	NNS
18637	16906	3	in	in	IN
18637	16906	4	the	the	DT
18637	16906	5	military	military	JJ
18637	16906	6	or	or	CC
18637	16906	7	naval	naval	JJ
18637	16906	8	services	service	NNS
18637	16906	9	of	of	IN
18637	16906	10	the	the	DT
18637	16906	11	United	United	NNP
18637	16906	12	States,[94	States,[94	.
18637	16906	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16906	14	trial	trial	NN
18637	16906	15	by	by	IN
18637	16906	16	military	military	JJ
18637	16906	17	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	16906	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	16906	19	due	due	JJ
18637	16906	20	process	process	NN
18637	16906	21	.	.	.
18637	16907	1	This	this	DT
18637	16907	2	principle	principle	NN
18637	16907	3	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	16907	4	to	to	IN
18637	16907	5	persons	person	NNS
18637	16907	6	who	who	WP
18637	16907	7	commit	commit	VBP
18637	16907	8	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	16907	9	while	while	IN
18637	16907	10	undergoing	undergoing	JJ
18637	16907	11	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	16907	12	inflicted	inflict	VBN
18637	16907	13	by	by	IN
18637	16907	14	court	court	NN
18637	16907	15	martial	martial	NN
18637	16907	16	;	;	:
18637	16907	17	as	as	IN
18637	16907	18	military	military	JJ
18637	16907	19	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
18637	16907	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16907	21	are	be	VBP
18637	16907	22	still	still	RB
18637	16907	23	subject	subject	JJ
18637	16907	24	to	to	IN
18637	16907	25	military	military	JJ
18637	16907	26	law	law	NN
18637	16907	27	.	.	.
18637	16908	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16908	2	95	95	CD
18637	16908	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16908	4	CRIMINAL	criminal	JJ
18637	16908	5	PROSECUTIONS	prosecutions	NN
18637	16908	6	The	the	DT
18637	16908	7	due	due	JJ
18637	16908	8	process	process	NN
18637	16908	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	16908	10	supplements	supplement	VBZ
18637	16908	11	the	the	DT
18637	16908	12	specific	specific	JJ
18637	16908	13	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	16908	14	guaranties	guaranty	NNS
18637	16908	15	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	16908	16	in	in	IN
18637	16908	17	the	the	DT
18637	16908	18	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	16908	19	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16908	20	and	and	CC
18637	16908	21	in	in	IN
18637	16908	22	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	16908	23	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	16908	24	of	of	IN
18637	16908	25	the	the	DT
18637	16908	26	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	16908	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16908	28	for	for	IN
18637	16908	29	the	the	DT
18637	16908	30	protection	protection	NN
18637	16908	31	of	of	IN
18637	16908	32	persons	person	NNS
18637	16908	33	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16908	34	of	of	IN
18637	16908	35	crime	crime	NN
18637	16908	36	.	.	.
18637	16909	1	The	the	DT
18637	16909	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16909	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	16909	4	relied	rely	VBN
18637	16909	5	upon	upon	IN
18637	16909	6	this	this	DT
18637	16909	7	provision	provision	NN
18637	16909	8	in	in	IN
18637	16909	9	holding	hold	VBG
18637	16909	10	that	that	IN
18637	16909	11	an	an	DT
18637	16909	12	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16909	13	shall	shall	MD
18637	16909	14	plead	plead	VB
18637	16909	15	,	,	,
18637	16909	16	or	or	CC
18637	16909	17	be	be	VB
18637	16909	18	ordered	order	VBN
18637	16909	19	to	to	TO
18637	16909	20	plead	plead	VB
18637	16909	21	,	,	,
18637	16909	22	or	or	CC
18637	16909	23	a	a	DT
18637	16909	24	plea	plea	NN
18637	16909	25	of	of	IN
18637	16909	26	not	not	RB
18637	16909	27	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	16909	28	be	be	VB
18637	16909	29	entered	enter	VBN
18637	16909	30	for	for	IN
18637	16909	31	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16909	32	before	before	IN
18637	16909	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16909	34	trial	trial	NN
18637	16909	35	proceeds;[96	proceeds;[96	NNP
18637	16909	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16909	37	and	and	CC
18637	16909	38	in	in	IN
18637	16909	39	ruling	rule	VBG
18637	16909	40	that	that	IN
18637	16909	41	if	if	IN
18637	16909	42	the	the	DT
18637	16909	43	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16909	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	16909	45	in	in	IN
18637	16909	46	custody	custody	NN
18637	16909	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16909	48	must	must	MD
18637	16909	49	be	be	VB
18637	16909	50	personally	personally	RB
18637	16909	51	present	present	JJ
18637	16909	52	at	at	IN
18637	16909	53	every	every	DT
18637	16909	54	stage	stage	NN
18637	16909	55	of	of	IN
18637	16909	56	the	the	DT
18637	16909	57	trial	trial	NN
18637	16909	58	where	where	WRB
18637	16909	59	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16909	60	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	16909	61	rights	right	NNS
18637	16909	62	may	may	MD
18637	16909	63	be	be	VB
18637	16909	64	affected	affect	VBN
18637	16909	65	by	by	IN
18637	16909	66	the	the	DT
18637	16909	67	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16909	68	against	against	IN
18637	16909	69	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16909	70	.	.	.
18637	16910	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16910	2	97	97	CD
18637	16910	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16910	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16910	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	16910	6	not	not	RB
18637	16910	7	within	within	IN
18637	16910	8	the	the	DT
18637	16910	9	power	power	NN
18637	16910	10	of	of	IN
18637	16910	11	the	the	DT
18637	16910	12	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16910	13	or	or	CC
18637	16910	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16910	15	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	16910	16	to	to	TO
18637	16910	17	waive	waive	VB
18637	16910	18	such	such	JJ
18637	16910	19	right	right	RB
18637	16910	20	.	.	.
18637	16911	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	16911	2	as	as	IN
18637	16911	3	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16911	4	for	for	IN
18637	16911	5	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16911	6	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	16911	7	do	do	VBP
18637	16911	8	not	not	RB
18637	16911	9	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	16911	10	a	a	DT
18637	16911	11	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16911	12	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	16911	13	,	,	,
18637	16911	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16911	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	16911	16	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
18637	16911	17	if	if	IN
18637	16911	18	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16911	19	are	be	VBP
18637	16911	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	16911	21	in	in	IN
18637	16911	22	the	the	DT
18637	16911	23	absence	absence	NN
18637	16911	24	of	of	IN
18637	16911	25	the	the	DT
18637	16911	26	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	16911	27	;	;	:
18637	16911	28	the	the	DT
18637	16911	29	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	16911	30	of	of	IN
18637	16911	31	due	due	JJ
18637	16911	32	process	process	NN
18637	16911	33	of	of	IN
18637	16911	34	law	law	NN
18637	16911	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	16911	36	satisfied	satisfy	VBN
18637	16911	37	by	by	IN
18637	16911	38	suitable	suitable	JJ
18637	16911	39	notice	notice	NN
18637	16911	40	and	and	CC
18637	16911	41	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	16911	42	to	to	TO
18637	16911	43	be	be	VB
18637	16911	44	heard	hear	VBN
18637	16911	45	.	.	.
18637	16912	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16912	2	98	98	CD
18637	16912	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16912	4	NOTICE	notice	NN
18637	16912	5	AND	and	CC
18637	16912	6	HEARING	hearing	NN
18637	16912	7	Due	due	IN
18637	16912	8	process	process	NN
18637	16912	9	of	of	IN
18637	16912	10	law	law	NN
18637	16912	11	signifies	signify	VBZ
18637	16912	12	a	a	DT
18637	16912	13	right	right	NN
18637	16912	14	to	to	TO
18637	16912	15	be	be	VB
18637	16912	16	heard	hear	VBN
18637	16912	17	.	.	.
18637	16913	1	A	a	DT
18637	16913	2	decree	decree	NN
18637	16913	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16913	4	pro	pro	JJ
18637	16913	5	confesso	confesso	NNP
18637	16913	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16913	7	entered	enter	VBD
18637	16913	8	against	against	IN
18637	16913	9	a	a	DT
18637	16913	10	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	16913	11	after	after	IN
18637	16913	12	striking	strike	VBG
18637	16913	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16913	14	answer	answer	NN
18637	16913	15	from	from	IN
18637	16913	16	the	the	DT
18637	16913	17	files	file	NNS
18637	16913	18	for	for	IN
18637	16913	19	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	16913	20	of	of	IN
18637	16913	21	court	court	NN
18637	16913	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	16913	23	void	void	JJ
18637	16913	24	.	.	.
18637	16914	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16914	2	99	99	CD
18637	16914	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16914	4	A	a	DT
18637	16914	5	man	man	NN
18637	16914	6	may	may	MD
18637	16914	7	,	,	,
18637	16914	8	however	however	RB
18637	16914	9	,	,	,
18637	16914	10	consent	consent	VBP
18637	16914	11	to	to	TO
18637	16914	12	be	be	VB
18637	16914	13	bound	bind	VBN
18637	16914	14	by	by	IN
18637	16914	15	a	a	DT
18637	16914	16	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16914	17	in	in	IN
18637	16914	18	a	a	DT
18637	16914	19	case	case	NN
18637	16914	20	in	in	IN
18637	16914	21	which	which	WDT
18637	16914	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16914	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	16914	24	no	no	DT
18637	16914	25	right	right	NN
18637	16914	26	to	to	TO
18637	16914	27	participate	participate	VB
18637	16914	28	.	.	.
18637	16915	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16915	2	100	100	CD
18637	16915	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16915	4	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	16915	5	,	,	,
18637	16915	6	due	due	JJ
18637	16915	7	process	process	NN
18637	16915	8	of	of	IN
18637	16915	9	law	law	NN
18637	16915	10	was	be	VBD
18637	16915	11	held	hold	VBN
18637	16915	12	not	not	RB
18637	16915	13	to	to	TO
18637	16915	14	be	be	VB
18637	16915	15	denied	deny	VBN
18637	16915	16	to	to	IN
18637	16915	17	a	a	DT
18637	16915	18	surety	surety	NN
18637	16915	19	on	on	IN
18637	16915	20	an	an	DT
18637	16915	21	undertaking	undertaking	NN
18637	16915	22	for	for	IN
18637	16915	23	the	the	DT
18637	16915	24	release	release	NN
18637	16915	25	of	of	IN
18637	16915	26	attached	attached	JJ
18637	16915	27	property	property	NN
18637	16915	28	when	when	WRB
18637	16915	29	the	the	DT
18637	16915	30	undertaking	undertaking	NN
18637	16915	31	required	require	VBD
18637	16915	32	the	the	DT
18637	16915	33	parties	party	NNS
18637	16915	34	to	to	TO
18637	16915	35	submit	submit	VB
18637	16915	36	to	to	IN
18637	16915	37	the	the	DT
18637	16915	38	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	16915	39	of	of	IN
18637	16915	40	the	the	DT
18637	16915	41	court	court	NN
18637	16915	42	and	and	CC
18637	16915	43	to	to	TO
18637	16915	44	agree	agree	VB
18637	16915	45	to	to	TO
18637	16915	46	abide	abide	VB
18637	16915	47	by	by	IN
18637	16915	48	the	the	DT
18637	16915	49	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16915	50	in	in	IN
18637	16915	51	relation	relation	NN
18637	16915	52	to	to	IN
18637	16915	53	the	the	DT
18637	16915	54	property	property	NN
18637	16915	55	attached	attach	VBN
18637	16915	56	.	.	.
18637	16916	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16916	2	101	101	CD
18637	16916	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16916	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	16916	5	,	,	,
18637	16916	6	in	in	IN
18637	16916	7	a	a	DT
18637	16916	8	suit	suit	NN
18637	16916	9	for	for	IN
18637	16916	10	specific	specific	JJ
18637	16916	11	performance	performance	NN
18637	16916	12	of	of	IN
18637	16916	13	a	a	DT
18637	16916	14	contract	contract	NN
18637	16916	15	,	,	,
18637	16916	16	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16916	17	admitted	admit	VBD
18637	16916	18	without	without	IN
18637	16916	19	objection	objection	NN
18637	16916	20	at	at	IN
18637	16916	21	the	the	DT
18637	16916	22	trial	trial	NN
18637	16916	23	established	establish	VBD
18637	16916	24	all	all	PDT
18637	16916	25	the	the	DT
18637	16916	26	facts	fact	NNS
18637	16916	27	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	16916	28	for	for	IN
18637	16916	29	application	application	NN
18637	16916	30	of	of	IN
18637	16916	31	the	the	DT
18637	16916	32	formula	formula	NN
18637	16916	33	specified	specify	VBN
18637	16916	34	by	by	IN
18637	16916	35	the	the	DT
18637	16916	36	contract	contract	NN
18637	16916	37	,	,	,
18637	16916	38	the	the	DT
18637	16916	39	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	16916	40	court	court	NN
18637	16916	41	which	which	WDT
18637	16916	42	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	16916	43	the	the	DT
18637	16916	44	trial	trial	NN
18637	16916	45	court	court	NN
18637	16916	46	's	's	POS
18637	16916	47	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	16916	48	of	of	IN
18637	16916	49	the	the	DT
18637	16916	50	contract	contract	NN
18637	16916	51	did	do	VBD
18637	16916	52	not	not	RB
18637	16916	53	infringe	infringe	VB
18637	16916	54	the	the	DT
18637	16916	55	right	right	NN
18637	16916	56	to	to	IN
18637	16916	57	a	a	DT
18637	16916	58	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16916	59	by	by	IN
18637	16916	60	entering	enter	VBG
18637	16916	61	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16916	62	without	without	IN
18637	16916	63	remanding	remand	VBG
18637	16916	64	the	the	DT
18637	16916	65	case	case	NN
18637	16916	66	for	for	IN
18637	16916	67	a	a	DT
18637	16916	68	new	new	JJ
18637	16916	69	trial	trial	NN
18637	16916	70	.	.	.
18637	16917	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16917	2	102	102	CD
18637	16917	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16917	4	After	after	IN
18637	16917	5	a	a	DT
18637	16917	6	State	State	NNP
18637	16917	7	court	court	NN
18637	16917	8	,	,	,
18637	16917	9	in	in	IN
18637	16917	10	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16917	11	designed	design	VBN
18637	16917	12	_	_	NNP
18637	16917	13	inter	inter	NNP
18637	16917	14	alia	alia	NNP
18637	16917	15	_	_	NNP
18637	16917	16	to	to	TO
18637	16917	17	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	16917	18	certain	certain	JJ
18637	16917	19	releases	release	NNS
18637	16917	20	,	,	,
18637	16917	21	rendered	render	VBN
18637	16917	22	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16917	23	without	without	IN
18637	16917	24	a	a	DT
18637	16917	25	special	special	JJ
18637	16917	26	finding	finding	NN
18637	16917	27	on	on	IN
18637	16917	28	the	the	DT
18637	16917	29	exact	exact	JJ
18637	16917	30	point	point	NN
18637	16917	31	,	,	,
18637	16917	32	a	a	DT
18637	16917	33	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16917	34	court	court	NN
18637	16917	35	did	do	VBD
18637	16917	36	not	not	RB
18637	16917	37	deny	deny	VB
18637	16917	38	due	due	JJ
18637	16917	39	process	process	NN
18637	16917	40	in	in	IN
18637	16917	41	a	a	DT
18637	16917	42	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	16917	43	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	16917	44	by	by	IN
18637	16917	45	treating	treat	VBG
18637	16917	46	such	such	JJ
18637	16917	47	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16917	48	as	as	IN
18637	16917	49	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	16917	50	on	on	IN
18637	16917	51	the	the	DT
18637	16917	52	validity	validity	NN
18637	16917	53	of	of	IN
18637	16917	54	the	the	DT
18637	16917	55	releases	release	NNS
18637	16917	56	.	.	.
18637	16918	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16918	2	103	103	CD
18637	16918	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16918	4	Since	since	IN
18637	16918	5	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16918	6	in	in	IN
18637	16918	7	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	16918	8	are	be	VBP
18637	16918	9	in	in	IN
18637	16918	10	the	the	DT
18637	16918	11	nature	nature	NN
18637	16918	12	of	of	IN
18637	16918	13	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16918	14	_	_	NNP
18637	16918	15	in	in	IN
18637	16918	16	rem	rem	NNP
18637	16918	17	_	_	NNP
18637	16918	18	,	,	,
18637	16918	19	personal	personal	JJ
18637	16918	20	notice	notice	NN
18637	16918	21	to	to	IN
18637	16918	22	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	16918	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	16918	24	not	not	RB
18637	16918	25	required	require	VBN
18637	16918	26	;	;	:
18637	16918	27	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	16918	28	are	be	VBP
18637	16918	29	bound	bind	VBN
18637	16918	30	by	by	IN
18637	16918	31	the	the	DT
18637	16918	32	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16918	33	in	in	IN
18637	16918	34	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	16918	35	on	on	IN
18637	16918	36	notice	notice	NN
18637	16918	37	by	by	IN
18637	16918	38	publication	publication	NN
18637	16918	39	and	and	CC
18637	16918	40	mail	mail	NN
18637	16918	41	.	.	.
18637	16919	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16919	2	104	104	CD
18637	16919	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16919	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	16919	5	a	a	DT
18637	16919	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	16919	7	providing	provide	VBG
18637	16919	8	for	for	IN
18637	16919	9	a	a	DT
18637	16919	10	public	public	JJ
18637	16919	11	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	16919	12	levied	levy	VBD
18637	16919	13	an	an	DT
18637	16919	14	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	16919	15	against	against	IN
18637	16919	16	abutting	abut	VBG
18637	16919	17	property	property	NN
18637	16919	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16919	19	was	be	VBD
18637	16919	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	16919	21	to	to	TO
18637	16919	22	be	be	VB
18637	16919	23	"	"	``
18637	16919	24	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	16919	25	alike	alike	RB
18637	16919	26	of	of	IN
18637	16919	27	the	the	DT
18637	16919	28	question	question	NN
18637	16919	29	of	of	IN
18637	16919	30	the	the	DT
18637	16919	31	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	16919	32	of	of	IN
18637	16919	33	the	the	DT
18637	16919	34	work	work	NN
18637	16919	35	and	and	CC
18637	16919	36	of	of	IN
18637	16919	37	the	the	DT
18637	16919	38	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	16919	39	as	as	IN
18637	16919	40	against	against	IN
18637	16919	41	abutting	abut	VBG
18637	16919	42	property	property	NN
18637	16919	43	.	.	.
18637	16920	1	"	"	``
18637	16920	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16920	3	105	105	CD
18637	16920	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16920	5	Notice	notice	NN
18637	16920	6	to	to	IN
18637	16920	7	the	the	DT
18637	16920	8	property	property	NN
18637	16920	9	owner	owner	NN
18637	16920	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	16920	11	not	not	RB
18637	16920	12	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	16920	13	to	to	TO
18637	16920	14	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	16920	15	the	the	DT
18637	16920	16	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	16920	17	.	.	.
18637	16921	1	On	on	IN
18637	16921	2	the	the	DT
18637	16921	3	other	other	JJ
18637	16921	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	16921	5	,	,	,
18637	16921	6	when	when	WRB
18637	16921	7	the	the	DT
18637	16921	8	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	16921	9	submits	submit	VBZ
18637	16921	10	these	these	DT
18637	16921	11	questions	question	NNS
18637	16921	12	to	to	IN
18637	16921	13	a	a	DT
18637	16921	14	commission	commission	NN
18637	16921	15	or	or	CC
18637	16921	16	other	other	JJ
18637	16921	17	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16921	18	the	the	DT
18637	16921	19	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	16921	20	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	16921	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16921	22	and	and	CC
18637	16921	23	the	the	DT
18637	16921	24	property	property	NN
18637	16921	25	owner	owner	NN
18637	16921	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	16921	27	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	16921	28	to	to	TO
18637	16921	29	notice	notice	VB
18637	16921	30	or	or	CC
18637	16921	31	an	an	DT
18637	16921	32	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	16921	33	to	to	TO
18637	16921	34	be	be	VB
18637	16921	35	heard	hear	VBN
18637	16921	36	.	.	.
18637	16922	1	Notice	notice	NN
18637	16922	2	by	by	IN
18637	16922	3	publication	publication	NN
18637	16922	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	16922	5	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	16922	6	.	.	.
18637	16923	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16923	2	106	106	CD
18637	16923	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16923	4	EVIDENCE	evidence	NN
18637	16923	5	AND	and	CC
18637	16923	6	PRESUMPTION	presumption	NN
18637	16923	7	IN	in	IN
18637	16923	8	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	16923	9	PROCEEDINGS	PROCEEDINGS	NNP
18637	16923	10	Error	Error	NNP
18637	16923	11	in	in	IN
18637	16923	12	the	the	DT
18637	16923	13	admission	admission	NN
18637	16923	14	of	of	IN
18637	16923	15	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16923	16	or	or	CC
18637	16923	17	the	the	DT
18637	16923	18	entry	entry	NN
18637	16923	19	of	of	IN
18637	16923	20	an	an	DT
18637	16923	21	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
18637	16923	22	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16923	23	after	after	IN
18637	16923	24	a	a	DT
18637	16923	25	full	full	JJ
18637	16923	26	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16923	27	does	do	VBZ
18637	16923	28	not	not	RB
18637	16923	29	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	16923	30	a	a	DT
18637	16923	31	denial	denial	NN
18637	16923	32	of	of	IN
18637	16923	33	due	due	JJ
18637	16923	34	process	process	NN
18637	16923	35	.	.	.
18637	16924	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16924	2	107	107	CD
18637	16924	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16924	4	A	a	DT
18637	16924	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	16924	6	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	16924	7	cancellation	cancellation	NN
18637	16924	8	of	of	IN
18637	16924	9	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	16924	10	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	16924	11	for	for	IN
18637	16924	12	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	16924	13	and	and	CC
18637	16924	14	providing	provide	VBG
18637	16924	15	that	that	IN
18637	16924	16	the	the	DT
18637	16924	17	taking	take	VBG
18637	16924	18	up	up	RP
18637	16924	19	of	of	IN
18637	16924	20	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	16924	21	residence	residence	NN
18637	16924	22	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	16924	23	within	within	IN
18637	16924	24	five	five	CD
18637	16924	25	years	year	NNS
18637	16924	26	after	after	IN
18637	16924	27	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	16924	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	16924	29	be	be	VB
18637	16924	30	_	_	NNP
18637	16924	31	prima	prima	NN
18637	16924	32	facie	facie	VBN
18637	16924	33	_	_	NNP
18637	16924	34	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16924	35	of	of	IN
18637	16924	36	lack	lack	NN
18637	16924	37	of	of	IN
18637	16924	38	intention	intention	NN
18637	16924	39	to	to	TO
18637	16924	40	become	become	VB
18637	16924	41	a	a	DT
18637	16924	42	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	16924	43	resident	resident	NN
18637	16924	44	of	of	IN
18637	16924	45	the	the	DT
18637	16924	46	United	United	NNP
18637	16924	47	States	States	NNP
18637	16924	48	at	at	IN
18637	16924	49	the	the	DT
18637	16924	50	time	time	NN
18637	16924	51	of	of	IN
18637	16924	52	applying	apply	VBG
18637	16924	53	for	for	IN
18637	16924	54	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	16924	55	was	be	VBD
18637	16924	56	found	find	VBN
18637	16924	57	not	not	RB
18637	16924	58	to	to	TO
18637	16924	59	be	be	VB
18637	16924	60	so	so	RB
18637	16924	61	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	16924	62	as	as	IN
18637	16924	63	to	to	TO
18637	16924	64	deny	deny	VB
18637	16924	65	due	due	JJ
18637	16924	66	process	process	NN
18637	16924	67	of	of	IN
18637	16924	68	law	law	NN
18637	16924	69	.	.	.
18637	16925	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16925	2	108	108	CD
18637	16925	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16925	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	16925	5	,	,	,
18637	16925	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16925	7	was	be	VBD
18637	16925	8	held	hold	VBN
18637	16925	9	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	16925	10	for	for	IN
18637	16925	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16925	12	to	to	TO
18637	16925	13	enact	enact	VB
18637	16925	14	that	that	IN
18637	16925	15	a	a	DT
18637	16925	16	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	16925	17	who	who	WP
18637	16925	18	was	be	VBD
18637	16925	19	discovered	discover	VBN
18637	16925	20	to	to	TO
18637	16925	21	be	be	VB
18637	16925	22	in	in	IN
18637	16925	23	possession	possession	NN
18637	16925	24	of	of	IN
18637	16925	25	opium	opium	NN
18637	16925	26	should	should	MD
18637	16925	27	be	be	VB
18637	16925	28	required	require	VBN
18637	16925	29	to	to	TO
18637	16925	30	assume	assume	VB
18637	16925	31	the	the	DT
18637	16925	32	burden	burden	NN
18637	16925	33	of	of	IN
18637	16925	34	proving	prove	VBG
18637	16925	35	that	that	IN
18637	16925	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16925	37	had	have	VBD
18637	16925	38	not	not	RB
18637	16925	39	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	16925	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16925	41	through	through	IN
18637	16925	42	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	16925	43	importation	importation	NN
18637	16925	44	.	.	.
18637	16926	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16926	2	109	109	CD
18637	16926	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16926	4	But	but	CC
18637	16926	5	a	a	DT
18637	16926	6	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	16926	7	that	that	IN
18637	16926	8	a	a	DT
18637	16926	9	firearm	firearm	NN
18637	16926	10	or	or	CC
18637	16926	11	ammunition	ammunition	NN
18637	16926	12	in	in	IN
18637	16926	13	the	the	DT
18637	16926	14	possession	possession	NN
18637	16926	15	of	of	IN
18637	16926	16	a	a	DT
18637	16926	17	person	person	NN
18637	16926	18	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	16926	19	of	of	IN
18637	16926	20	a	a	DT
18637	16926	21	crime	crime	NN
18637	16926	22	of	of	IN
18637	16926	23	violence	violence	NN
18637	16926	24	was	be	VBD
18637	16926	25	transported	transport	VBN
18637	16926	26	or	or	CC
18637	16926	27	received	receive	VBN
18637	16926	28	in	in	IN
18637	16926	29	violation	violation	NN
18637	16926	30	of	of	IN
18637	16926	31	law	law	NN
18637	16926	32	was	be	VBD
18637	16926	33	held	hold	VBN
18637	16926	34	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	16926	35	because	because	IN
18637	16926	36	there	there	EX
18637	16926	37	was	be	VBD
18637	16926	38	no	no	DT
18637	16926	39	rational	rational	JJ
18637	16926	40	connections	connection	NNS
18637	16926	41	between	between	IN
18637	16926	42	the	the	DT
18637	16926	43	facts	fact	NNS
18637	16926	44	proved	prove	VBN
18637	16926	45	and	and	CC
18637	16926	46	that	that	DT
18637	16926	47	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	16926	48	.	.	.
18637	16927	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16927	2	110	110	CD
18637	16927	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16927	4	ADMINISTRATIVE	administrative	NN
18637	16927	5	PROCEEDINGS	proceeding	NNS
18637	16927	6	With	with	IN
18637	16927	7	respect	respect	NN
18637	16927	8	to	to	IN
18637	16927	9	action	action	NN
18637	16927	10	taken	take	VBN
18637	16927	11	by	by	IN
18637	16927	12	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	16927	13	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	16927	14	the	the	DT
18637	16927	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16927	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	16927	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	16927	18	that	that	IN
18637	16927	19	the	the	DT
18637	16927	20	demands	demand	NNS
18637	16927	21	of	of	IN
18637	16927	22	due	due	JJ
18637	16927	23	process	process	NN
18637	16927	24	do	do	VBP
18637	16927	25	not	not	RB
18637	16927	26	require	require	VB
18637	16927	27	a	a	DT
18637	16927	28	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16927	29	at	at	IN
18637	16927	30	the	the	DT
18637	16927	31	initial	initial	JJ
18637	16927	32	stage	stage	NN
18637	16927	33	,	,	,
18637	16927	34	or	or	CC
18637	16927	35	at	at	IN
18637	16927	36	any	any	DT
18637	16927	37	particular	particular	JJ
18637	16927	38	point	point	NN
18637	16927	39	in	in	IN
18637	16927	40	the	the	DT
18637	16927	41	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	16927	42	so	so	RB
18637	16927	43	long	long	RB
18637	16927	44	as	as	IN
18637	16927	45	a	a	DT
18637	16927	46	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16927	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	16927	48	held	hold	VBN
18637	16927	49	before	before	IN
18637	16927	50	the	the	DT
18637	16927	51	final	final	JJ
18637	16927	52	order	order	NN
18637	16927	53	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	16927	54	effective	effective	JJ
18637	16927	55	.	.	.
18637	16928	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16928	2	111	111	CD
18637	16928	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16928	4	In	in	IN
18637	16928	5	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	16928	6	_	_	NNP
18637	16928	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	16928	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16928	9	Willingham,[112	Willingham,[112	NNP
18637	16928	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16928	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16928	12	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	16928	13	orders	order	NNS
18637	16928	14	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	16928	15	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	16928	16	rents	rent	NNS
18637	16928	17	issued	issue	VBN
18637	16928	18	without	without	IN
18637	16928	19	a	a	DT
18637	16928	20	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16928	21	at	at	IN
18637	16928	22	any	any	DT
18637	16928	23	stage	stage	NN
18637	16928	24	,	,	,
18637	16928	25	saying	say	VBG
18637	16928	26	"	"	``
18637	16928	27	*	*	NFP
18637	16928	28	*	*	NFP
18637	16928	29	*	*	NFP
18637	16928	30	where	where	WRB
18637	16928	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16928	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	16928	33	provided	provide	VBN
18637	16928	34	for	for	IN
18637	16928	35	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16928	36	review	review	NN
18637	16928	37	after	after	IN
18637	16928	38	the	the	DT
18637	16928	39	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	16928	40	or	or	CC
18637	16928	41	orders	order	NNS
18637	16928	42	have	have	VBP
18637	16928	43	been	be	VBN
18637	16928	44	made	make	VBN
18637	16928	45	effective	effective	JJ
18637	16928	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16928	47	has	have	VBZ
18637	16928	48	all	all	PDT
18637	16928	49	that	that	DT
18637	16928	50	due	due	JJ
18637	16928	51	process	process	NN
18637	16928	52	under	under	IN
18637	16928	53	the	the	DT
18637	16928	54	war	war	NN
18637	16928	55	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	16928	56	requires	require	VBZ
18637	16928	57	.	.	.
18637	16929	1	"	"	``
18637	16929	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16929	3	113	113	CD
18637	16929	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16929	5	But	but	CC
18637	16929	6	where	where	WRB
18637	16929	7	,	,	,
18637	16929	8	after	after	IN
18637	16929	9	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	16929	10	of	of	IN
18637	16929	11	charges	charge	NNS
18637	16929	12	brought	bring	VBN
18637	16929	13	against	against	IN
18637	16929	14	an	an	DT
18637	16929	15	employer	employer	NN
18637	16929	16	by	by	IN
18637	16929	17	a	a	DT
18637	16929	18	complaining	complaining	NN
18637	16929	19	union	union	NN
18637	16929	20	,	,	,
18637	16929	21	the	the	DT
18637	16929	22	National	National	NNP
18637	16929	23	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	16929	24	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	16929	25	Board	Board	NNP
18637	16929	26	undertook	undertake	VBD
18637	16929	27	to	to	TO
18637	16929	28	void	void	VB
18637	16929	29	an	an	DT
18637	16929	30	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	16929	31	between	between	IN
18637	16929	32	an	an	DT
18637	16929	33	employer	employer	NN
18637	16929	34	and	and	CC
18637	16929	35	another	another	DT
18637	16929	36	independent	independent	JJ
18637	16929	37	union	union	NN
18637	16929	38	,	,	,
18637	16929	39	the	the	DT
18637	16929	40	latter	latter	JJ
18637	16929	41	was	be	VBD
18637	16929	42	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	16929	43	to	to	TO
18637	16929	44	notice	notice	NN
18637	16929	45	and	and	CC
18637	16929	46	an	an	DT
18637	16929	47	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	16929	48	to	to	TO
18637	16929	49	participate	participate	VB
18637	16929	50	in	in	IN
18637	16929	51	the	the	DT
18637	16929	52	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16929	53	.	.	.
18637	16930	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16930	2	114	114	CD
18637	16930	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16930	4	Although	although	IN
18637	16930	5	a	a	DT
18637	16930	6	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	16930	7	must	must	MD
18637	16930	8	be	be	VB
18637	16930	9	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	16930	10	a	a	DT
18637	16930	11	fair	fair	JJ
18637	16930	12	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	16930	13	for	for	IN
18637	16930	14	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16930	15	in	in	IN
18637	16930	16	connection	connection	NN
18637	16930	17	with	with	IN
18637	16930	18	the	the	DT
18637	16930	19	collection	collection	NN
18637	16930	20	of	of	IN
18637	16930	21	taxes,[115	taxes,[115	NNP
18637	16930	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16930	23	collection	collection	NN
18637	16930	24	by	by	IN
18637	16930	25	distraint	distraint	NN
18637	16930	26	of	of	IN
18637	16930	27	personal	personal	JJ
18637	16930	28	property	property	NN
18637	16930	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	16930	30	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	16930	31	if	if	IN
18637	16930	32	the	the	DT
18637	16930	33	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	16930	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	16930	35	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	16930	36	a	a	DT
18637	16930	37	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16930	38	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	16930	39	.	.	.
18637	16931	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16931	2	116	116	CD
18637	16931	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16931	4	"	"	``
18637	16931	5	A	a	DT
18637	16931	6	FAIR	fair	NN
18637	16931	7	HEARING	hearing	NN
18637	16931	8	"	"	''
18637	16931	9	When	when	WRB
18637	16931	10	the	the	DT
18637	16931	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	16931	12	requires	require	VBZ
18637	16931	13	a	a	DT
18637	16931	14	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16931	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16931	16	requires	require	VBZ
18637	16931	17	a	a	DT
18637	16931	18	fair	fair	JJ
18637	16931	19	one	one	NN
18637	16931	20	,	,	,
18637	16931	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	16931	22	before	before	IN
18637	16931	23	a	a	DT
18637	16931	24	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	16931	25	which	which	WDT
18637	16931	26	at	at	IN
18637	16931	27	least	least	JJS
18637	16931	28	meets	meet	VBZ
18637	16931	29	currently	currently	RB
18637	16931	30	prevailing	prevail	VBG
18637	16931	31	standards	standard	NNS
18637	16931	32	of	of	IN
18637	16931	33	impartiality	impartiality	NN
18637	16931	34	.	.	.
18637	16932	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16932	2	117	117	CD
18637	16932	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16932	4	An	an	DT
18637	16932	5	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	16932	6	must	must	MD
18637	16932	7	be	be	VB
18637	16932	8	given	give	VBN
18637	16932	9	not	not	RB
18637	16932	10	only	only	RB
18637	16932	11	to	to	TO
18637	16932	12	present	present	VB
18637	16932	13	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16932	14	,	,	,
18637	16932	15	but	but	CC
18637	16932	16	also	also	RB
18637	16932	17	to	to	TO
18637	16932	18	know	know	VB
18637	16932	19	the	the	DT
18637	16932	20	claims	claim	NNS
18637	16932	21	of	of	IN
18637	16932	22	the	the	DT
18637	16932	23	opposing	oppose	VBG
18637	16932	24	party	party	NN
18637	16932	25	and	and	CC
18637	16932	26	to	to	TO
18637	16932	27	meet	meet	VB
18637	16932	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16932	29	.	.	.
18637	16933	1	Those	those	DT
18637	16933	2	who	who	WP
18637	16933	3	are	be	VBP
18637	16933	4	brought	bring	VBN
18637	16933	5	into	into	IN
18637	16933	6	contest	contest	NN
18637	16933	7	with	with	IN
18637	16933	8	the	the	DT
18637	16933	9	Government	Government	NNP
18637	16933	10	in	in	IN
18637	16933	11	a	a	DT
18637	16933	12	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	16933	13	-	-	JJ
18637	16933	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16933	15	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	16933	16	aimed	aim	VBN
18637	16933	17	at	at	IN
18637	16933	18	control	control	NN
18637	16933	19	of	of	IN
18637	16933	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16933	21	activities	activity	NNS
18637	16933	22	are	be	VBP
18637	16933	23	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	16933	24	to	to	TO
18637	16933	25	be	be	VB
18637	16933	26	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	16933	27	advised	advise	VBN
18637	16933	28	of	of	IN
18637	16933	29	what	what	WP
18637	16933	30	the	the	DT
18637	16933	31	Government	Government	NNP
18637	16933	32	proposes	propose	VBZ
18637	16933	33	and	and	CC
18637	16933	34	to	to	TO
18637	16933	35	be	be	VB
18637	16933	36	heard	hear	VBN
18637	16933	37	upon	upon	IN
18637	16933	38	the	the	DT
18637	16933	39	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	16933	40	before	before	IN
18637	16933	41	the	the	DT
18637	16933	42	final	final	JJ
18637	16933	43	command	command	NN
18637	16933	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	16933	45	issued	issue	VBN
18637	16933	46	.	.	.
18637	16934	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16934	2	118	118	CD
18637	16934	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16934	4	But	but	CC
18637	16934	5	a	a	DT
18637	16934	6	variance	variance	NN
18637	16934	7	between	between	IN
18637	16934	8	the	the	DT
18637	16934	9	charges	charge	NNS
18637	16934	10	and	and	CC
18637	16934	11	findings	finding	NNS
18637	16934	12	will	will	MD
18637	16934	13	not	not	RB
18637	16934	14	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	16934	15	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	16934	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16934	17	where	where	WRB
18637	16934	18	the	the	DT
18637	16934	19	record	record	NN
18637	16934	20	shows	show	VBZ
18637	16934	21	that	that	IN
18637	16934	22	at	at	IN
18637	16934	23	no	no	DT
18637	16934	24	time	time	NN
18637	16934	25	during	during	IN
18637	16934	26	the	the	DT
18637	16934	27	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16934	28	was	be	VBD
18637	16934	29	there	there	RB
18637	16934	30	any	any	DT
18637	16934	31	misunderstanding	misunderstanding	NN
18637	16934	32	as	as	IN
18637	16934	33	to	to	IN
18637	16934	34	the	the	DT
18637	16934	35	basis	basis	NN
18637	16934	36	of	of	IN
18637	16934	37	the	the	DT
18637	16934	38	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	16934	39	.	.	.
18637	16935	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16935	2	119	119	CD
18637	16935	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16935	4	The	the	DT
18637	16935	5	mere	mere	JJ
18637	16935	6	admission	admission	NN
18637	16935	7	of	of	IN
18637	16935	8	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16935	9	which	which	WDT
18637	16935	10	would	would	MD
18637	16935	11	be	be	VB
18637	16935	12	inadmissible	inadmissible	JJ
18637	16935	13	in	in	IN
18637	16935	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16935	15	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16935	16	does	do	VBZ
18637	16935	17	not	not	RB
18637	16935	18	vitiate	vitiate	VB
18637	16935	19	the	the	DT
18637	16935	20	order	order	NN
18637	16935	21	of	of	IN
18637	16935	22	an	an	DT
18637	16935	23	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	16935	24	agency	agency	NN
18637	16935	25	.	.	.
18637	16936	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16936	2	120	120	CD
18637	16936	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16936	4	A	a	DT
18637	16936	5	provision	provision	NN
18637	16936	6	that	that	IN
18637	16936	7	such	such	PDT
18637	16936	8	a	a	DT
18637	16936	9	body	body	NN
18637	16936	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	16936	11	not	not	RB
18637	16936	12	be	be	VB
18637	16936	13	controlled	control	VBN
18637	16936	14	by	by	IN
18637	16936	15	rules	rule	NNS
18637	16936	16	of	of	IN
18637	16936	17	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16936	18	does	do	VBZ
18637	16936	19	not	not	RB
18637	16936	20	,	,	,
18637	16936	21	however	however	RB
18637	16936	22	,	,	,
18637	16936	23	justify	justify	NNP
18637	16936	24	orders	order	NNS
18637	16936	25	without	without	IN
18637	16936	26	a	a	DT
18637	16936	27	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	16936	28	in	in	IN
18637	16936	29	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16936	30	having	have	VBG
18637	16936	31	rational	rational	JJ
18637	16936	32	probative	probative	JJ
18637	16936	33	force	force	NN
18637	16936	34	.	.	.
18637	16937	1	Mere	mere	JJ
18637	16937	2	uncorroborated	uncorroborated	JJ
18637	16937	3	hearsay	hearsay	NN
18637	16937	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	16937	5	not	not	RB
18637	16937	6	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	16937	7	the	the	DT
18637	16937	8	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	16937	9	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16937	10	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	16937	11	to	to	TO
18637	16937	12	support	support	VB
18637	16937	13	the	the	DT
18637	16937	14	findings	finding	NNS
18637	16937	15	of	of	IN
18637	16937	16	the	the	DT
18637	16937	17	agency	agency	NN
18637	16937	18	.	.	.
18637	16938	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16938	2	121	121	CD
18637	16938	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16938	4	While	while	IN
18637	16938	5	the	the	DT
18637	16938	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16938	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	16938	8	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	16938	9	that	that	IN
18637	16938	10	in	in	IN
18637	16938	11	some	some	DT
18637	16938	12	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	16938	13	a	a	DT
18637	16938	14	"	"	``
18637	16938	15	fair	fair	JJ
18637	16938	16	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16938	17	"	"	''
18637	16938	18	implies	imply	VBZ
18637	16938	19	a	a	DT
18637	16938	20	right	right	NN
18637	16938	21	to	to	IN
18637	16938	22	oral	oral	JJ
18637	16938	23	argument,[122	argument,[122	NN
18637	16938	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16938	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16938	26	refuses	refuse	VBZ
18637	16938	27	to	to	TO
18637	16938	28	lay	lay	VB
18637	16938	29	down	down	RP
18637	16938	30	a	a	DT
18637	16938	31	general	general	JJ
18637	16938	32	rule	rule	NN
18637	16938	33	that	that	WDT
18637	16938	34	would	would	MD
18637	16938	35	cover	cover	VB
18637	16938	36	all	all	DT
18637	16938	37	cases	case	NNS
18637	16938	38	.	.	.
18637	16939	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16939	2	123	123	CD
18637	16939	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16939	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16939	5	says	say	VBZ
18637	16939	6	:	:	:
18637	16939	7	"	"	``
18637	16939	8	Certainly	certainly	RB
18637	16939	9	the	the	DT
18637	16939	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	16939	11	does	do	VBZ
18637	16939	12	not	not	RB
18637	16939	13	require	require	VB
18637	16939	14	oral	oral	JJ
18637	16939	15	argument	argument	NN
18637	16939	16	in	in	IN
18637	16939	17	all	all	DT
18637	16939	18	cases	case	NNS
18637	16939	19	where	where	WRB
18637	16939	20	only	only	RB
18637	16939	21	insubstantial	insubstantial	JJ
18637	16939	22	or	or	CC
18637	16939	23	frivolous	frivolous	JJ
18637	16939	24	questions	question	NNS
18637	16939	25	of	of	IN
18637	16939	26	law	law	NN
18637	16939	27	,	,	,
18637	16939	28	or	or	CC
18637	16939	29	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	16939	30	even	even	RB
18637	16939	31	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	16939	32	ones	one	NNS
18637	16939	33	,	,	,
18637	16939	34	are	be	VBP
18637	16939	35	raised	raise	VBN
18637	16939	36	.	.	.
18637	16940	1	Equally	equally	RB
18637	16940	2	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	16940	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16940	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	16940	5	left	leave	VBN
18637	16940	6	wide	wide	JJ
18637	16940	7	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	16940	8	to	to	IN
18637	16940	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16940	10	in	in	IN
18637	16940	11	creating	create	VBG
18637	16940	12	the	the	DT
18637	16940	13	procedures	procedure	NNS
18637	16940	14	to	to	TO
18637	16940	15	be	be	VB
18637	16940	16	followed	follow	VBN
18637	16940	17	in	in	IN
18637	16940	18	both	both	CC
18637	16940	19	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	16940	20	and	and	CC
18637	16940	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16940	22	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16940	23	,	,	,
18637	16940	24	as	as	RB
18637	16940	25	well	well	RB
18637	16940	26	as	as	IN
18637	16940	27	in	in	IN
18637	16940	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16940	29	conjunction	conjunction	NN
18637	16940	30	.	.	.
18637	16941	1	"	"	``
18637	16941	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16941	3	124	124	CD
18637	16941	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16941	5	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	16941	6	REVIEW	REVIEW	NNP
18637	16941	7	To	to	IN
18637	16941	8	the	the	DT
18637	16941	9	extent	extent	NN
18637	16941	10	that	that	IN
18637	16941	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16941	12	rights	right	NNS
18637	16941	13	are	be	VBP
18637	16941	14	involved	involve	VBN
18637	16941	15	,	,	,
18637	16941	16	due	due	JJ
18637	16941	17	process	process	NN
18637	16941	18	of	of	IN
18637	16941	19	law	law	NN
18637	16941	20	imports	import	VBZ
18637	16941	21	a	a	DT
18637	16941	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16941	23	review	review	NN
18637	16941	24	of	of	IN
18637	16941	25	the	the	DT
18637	16941	26	action	action	NN
18637	16941	27	of	of	IN
18637	16941	28	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	16941	29	or	or	CC
18637	16941	30	executive	executive	JJ
18637	16941	31	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16941	32	.	.	.
18637	16942	1	This	this	DT
18637	16942	2	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	16942	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	16942	4	undisputed	undisputed	JJ
18637	16942	5	so	so	RB
18637	16942	6	far	far	RB
18637	16942	7	as	as	IN
18637	16942	8	questions	question	NNS
18637	16942	9	of	of	IN
18637	16942	10	law	law	NN
18637	16942	11	are	be	VBP
18637	16942	12	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	16942	13	,	,	,
18637	16942	14	but	but	CC
18637	16942	15	the	the	DT
18637	16942	16	extent	extent	NN
18637	16942	17	to	to	TO
18637	16942	18	which	which	WDT
18637	16942	19	the	the	DT
18637	16942	20	courts	court	NNS
18637	16942	21	should	should	MD
18637	16942	22	and	and	CC
18637	16942	23	will	will	MD
18637	16942	24	go	go	VB
18637	16942	25	in	in	IN
18637	16942	26	reviewing	review	VBG
18637	16942	27	determinations	determination	NNS
18637	16942	28	of	of	IN
18637	16942	29	fact	fact	NN
18637	16942	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	16942	31	been	be	VBN
18637	16942	32	a	a	DT
18637	16942	33	highly	highly	RB
18637	16942	34	controversial	controversial	JJ
18637	16942	35	issue	issue	NN
18637	16942	36	.	.	.
18637	16943	1	In	in	IN
18637	16943	2	St.	St.	NNP
18637	16943	3	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
18637	16943	4	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	16943	5	Yards	Yards	NNP
18637	16943	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16943	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16943	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	16943	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16943	10	United	United	NNP
18637	16943	11	States,[125	States,[125	NNP
18637	16943	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16943	13	the	the	DT
18637	16943	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16943	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16943	16	held	hold	VBD
18637	16943	17	that	that	IN
18637	16943	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	16943	19	review	review	NN
18637	16943	20	of	of	IN
18637	16943	21	an	an	DT
18637	16943	22	order	order	NN
18637	16943	23	of	of	IN
18637	16943	24	the	the	DT
18637	16943	25	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	16943	26	of	of	IN
18637	16943	27	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	16943	28	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	16943	29	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	16943	30	rates	rate	NNS
18637	16943	31	for	for	IN
18637	16943	32	services	service	NNS
18637	16943	33	rendered	render	VBN
18637	16943	34	by	by	IN
18637	16943	35	a	a	DT
18637	16943	36	stock	stock	NN
18637	16943	37	yard	yard	NN
18637	16943	38	company	company	NN
18637	16943	39	,	,	,
18637	16943	40	due	due	JJ
18637	16943	41	process	process	NN
18637	16943	42	required	require	VBD
18637	16943	43	that	that	IN
18637	16943	44	the	the	DT
18637	16943	45	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16943	46	exercise	exercise	VBP
18637	16943	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16943	48	independent	independent	JJ
18637	16943	49	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16943	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	16943	51	the	the	DT
18637	16943	52	facts	fact	NNS
18637	16943	53	to	to	TO
18637	16943	54	determine	determine	VB
18637	16943	55	whether	whether	IN
18637	16943	56	the	the	DT
18637	16943	57	rates	rate	NNS
18637	16943	58	were	be	VBD
18637	16943	59	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	16943	60	.	.	.
18637	16944	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16944	2	126	126	CD
18637	16944	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16944	4	Subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	16944	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	16944	6	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	16944	7	rate	rate	NN
18637	16944	8	orders	order	NNS
18637	16944	9	of	of	IN
18637	16944	10	the	the	DT
18637	16944	11	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	16944	12	Power	Power	NNP
18637	16944	13	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	16944	14	have	have	VBP
18637	16944	15	not	not	RB
18637	16944	16	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	16944	17	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	16944	18	with	with	IN
18637	16944	19	this	this	DT
18637	16944	20	point	point	NN
18637	16944	21	.	.	.
18637	16945	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16945	2	127	127	CD
18637	16945	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16945	4	The	the	DT
18637	16945	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16945	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	16945	7	said	say	VBN
18637	16945	8	simply	simply	RB
18637	16945	9	that	that	IN
18637	16945	10	a	a	DT
18637	16945	11	person	person	NN
18637	16945	12	assailing	assail	VBG
18637	16945	13	such	such	PDT
18637	16945	14	an	an	DT
18637	16945	15	order	order	NN
18637	16945	16	"	"	``
18637	16945	17	carries	carry	VBZ
18637	16945	18	the	the	DT
18637	16945	19	heavy	heavy	JJ
18637	16945	20	burden	burden	NN
18637	16945	21	of	of	IN
18637	16945	22	making	make	VBG
18637	16945	23	a	a	DT
18637	16945	24	convincing	convincing	JJ
18637	16945	25	showing	showing	NN
18637	16945	26	that	that	IN
18637	16945	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16945	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	16945	29	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	16945	30	because	because	IN
18637	16945	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16945	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	16945	33	unjust	unjust	JJ
18637	16945	34	and	and	CC
18637	16945	35	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	16945	36	in	in	IN
18637	16945	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16945	38	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	16945	39	.	.	.
18637	16946	1	"	"	``
18637	16946	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16946	3	128	128	CD
18637	16946	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16946	5	There	there	EX
18637	16946	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	16946	7	been	be	VBN
18637	16946	8	a	a	DT
18637	16946	9	division	division	NN
18637	16946	10	of	of	IN
18637	16946	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16946	12	in	in	IN
18637	16946	13	the	the	DT
18637	16946	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16946	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16946	16	as	as	IN
18637	16946	17	to	to	IN
18637	16946	18	what	what	WDT
18637	16946	19	extent	extent	NN
18637	16946	20	,	,	,
18637	16946	21	if	if	IN
18637	16946	22	at	at	RB
18637	16946	23	all	all	RB
18637	16946	24	,	,	,
18637	16946	25	the	the	DT
18637	16946	26	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16946	27	before	before	IN
18637	16946	28	military	military	JJ
18637	16946	29	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	16946	30	should	should	MD
18637	16946	31	be	be	VB
18637	16946	32	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	16946	33	by	by	IN
18637	16946	34	the	the	DT
18637	16946	35	courts	court	NNS
18637	16946	36	for	for	IN
18637	16946	37	the	the	DT
18637	16946	38	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	16946	39	of	of	IN
18637	16946	40	determining	determine	VBG
18637	16946	41	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	16946	42	with	with	IN
18637	16946	43	the	the	DT
18637	16946	44	due	due	JJ
18637	16946	45	process	process	NN
18637	16946	46	clause	clause	NN
18637	16946	47	.	.	.
18637	16947	1	In	in	IN
18637	16947	2	In	in	IN
18637	16947	3	re	re	NN
18637	16947	4	Yamashita[129	Yamashita[129	NNP
18637	16947	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16947	6	the	the	DT
18637	16947	7	majority	majority	NN
18637	16947	8	denied	deny	VBD
18637	16947	9	a	a	DT
18637	16947	10	petition	petition	NN
18637	16947	11	for	for	IN
18637	16947	12	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	16947	13	and	and	CC
18637	16947	14	petitions	petition	NNS
18637	16947	15	for	for	IN
18637	16947	16	writs	writ	NNS
18637	16947	17	of	of	IN
18637	16947	18	_	_	NNP
18637	16947	19	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	16947	20	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	16947	21	_	_	NNP
18637	16947	22	to	to	TO
18637	16947	23	review	review	VB
18637	16947	24	the	the	DT
18637	16947	25	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	16947	26	of	of	IN
18637	16947	27	a	a	DT
18637	16947	28	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	16947	29	war	war	NN
18637	16947	30	criminal	criminal	NN
18637	16947	31	by	by	IN
18637	16947	32	a	a	DT
18637	16947	33	military	military	JJ
18637	16947	34	commission	commission	NN
18637	16947	35	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	16947	36	in	in	IN
18637	16947	37	the	the	DT
18637	16947	38	Philippine	Philippine	NNP
18637	16947	39	Islands	Islands	NNPS
18637	16947	40	.	.	.
18637	16948	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16948	2	held	hold	VBD
18637	16948	3	that	that	IN
18637	16948	4	since	since	IN
18637	16948	5	the	the	DT
18637	16948	6	military	military	JJ
18637	16948	7	commission	commission	NN
18637	16948	8	,	,	,
18637	16948	9	in	in	IN
18637	16948	10	admitting	admit	VBG
18637	16948	11	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16948	12	to	to	IN
18637	16948	13	which	which	WDT
18637	16948	14	objection	objection	NN
18637	16948	15	was	be	VBD
18637	16948	16	made	make	VBN
18637	16948	17	,	,	,
18637	16948	18	had	have	VBD
18637	16948	19	not	not	RB
18637	16948	20	violated	violate	VBN
18637	16948	21	any	any	DT
18637	16948	22	act	act	NN
18637	16948	23	of	of	IN
18637	16948	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16948	25	,	,	,
18637	16948	26	a	a	DT
18637	16948	27	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	16948	28	or	or	CC
18637	16948	29	a	a	DT
18637	16948	30	military	military	JJ
18637	16948	31	command	command	NN
18637	16948	32	defining	define	VBG
18637	16948	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16948	34	authority	authority	NN
18637	16948	35	,	,	,
18637	16948	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16948	37	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	16948	38	on	on	IN
18637	16948	39	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16948	40	and	and	CC
18637	16948	41	on	on	IN
18637	16948	42	the	the	DT
18637	16948	43	mode	mode	NN
18637	16948	44	of	of	IN
18637	16948	45	conducting	conduct	VBG
18637	16948	46	the	the	DT
18637	16948	47	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16948	48	were	be	VBD
18637	16948	49	not	not	RB
18637	16948	50	reviewable	reviewable	JJ
18637	16948	51	by	by	IN
18637	16948	52	the	the	DT
18637	16948	53	courts	court	NNS
18637	16948	54	.	.	.
18637	16949	1	Without	without	IN
18637	16949	2	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	16949	3	,	,	,
18637	16949	4	the	the	DT
18637	16949	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16949	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16949	7	in	in	IN
18637	16949	8	Hiatt	Hiatt	NNP
18637	16949	9	_	_	NNP
18637	16949	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	16949	11	_	_	NNP
18637	16949	12	Brown[130	Brown[130	NNP
18637	16949	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16949	14	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	16949	15	the	the	DT
18637	16949	16	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16949	17	of	of	IN
18637	16949	18	a	a	DT
18637	16949	19	lower	low	JJR
18637	16949	20	court	court	NN
18637	16949	21	which	which	WDT
18637	16949	22	had	have	VBD
18637	16949	23	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	16949	24	a	a	DT
18637	16949	25	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	16949	26	serving	serve	VBG
18637	16949	27	a	a	DT
18637	16949	28	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	16949	29	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	16949	30	by	by	IN
18637	16949	31	a	a	DT
18637	16949	32	court	court	NN
18637	16949	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	16949	34	martial	martial	JJ
18637	16949	35	,	,	,
18637	16949	36	because	because	IN
18637	16949	37	of	of	IN
18637	16949	38	errors	error	NNS
18637	16949	39	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	16949	40	the	the	DT
18637	16949	41	respondent	respondent	NN
18637	16949	42	had	have	VBD
18637	16949	43	been	be	VBN
18637	16949	44	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	16949	45	of	of	IN
18637	16949	46	due	due	JJ
18637	16949	47	process	process	NN
18637	16949	48	of	of	IN
18637	16949	49	law	law	NN
18637	16949	50	.	.	.
18637	16950	1	The	the	DT
18637	16950	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16950	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16950	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	16950	5	that	that	IN
18637	16950	6	the	the	DT
18637	16950	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16950	8	below	below	RB
18637	16950	9	had	have	VBD
18637	16950	10	erred	err	VBN
18637	16950	11	in	in	IN
18637	16950	12	extending	extend	VBG
18637	16950	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16950	14	review	review	NN
18637	16950	15	,	,	,
18637	16950	16	for	for	IN
18637	16950	17	the	the	DT
18637	16950	18	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	16950	19	of	of	IN
18637	16950	20	determining	determine	VBG
18637	16950	21	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	16950	22	with	with	IN
18637	16950	23	the	the	DT
18637	16950	24	due	due	JJ
18637	16950	25	process	process	NN
18637	16950	26	clause	clause	NN
18637	16950	27	,	,	,
18637	16950	28	to	to	IN
18637	16950	29	such	such	JJ
18637	16950	30	matters	matter	NNS
18637	16950	31	as	as	IN
18637	16950	32	the	the	DT
18637	16950	33	propositions	proposition	NNS
18637	16950	34	of	of	IN
18637	16950	35	law	law	NN
18637	16950	36	set	set	VBN
18637	16950	37	forth	forth	RP
18637	16950	38	in	in	IN
18637	16950	39	the	the	DT
18637	16950	40	staff	staff	NN
18637	16950	41	judge	judge	NN
18637	16950	42	advocate	advocate	NN
18637	16950	43	's	's	POS
18637	16950	44	report	report	NN
18637	16950	45	,	,	,
18637	16950	46	the	the	DT
18637	16950	47	sufficiency	sufficiency	NN
18637	16950	48	of	of	IN
18637	16950	49	the	the	DT
18637	16950	50	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16950	51	to	to	TO
18637	16950	52	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	16950	53	respondent	respondent	NN
18637	16950	54	's	's	POS
18637	16950	55	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	16950	56	,	,	,
18637	16950	57	the	the	DT
18637	16950	58	adequacy	adequacy	NN
18637	16950	59	of	of	IN
18637	16950	60	the	the	DT
18637	16950	61	pre	pre	JJ
18637	16950	62	-	-	JJ
18637	16950	63	trial	trial	JJ
18637	16950	64	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	16950	65	,	,	,
18637	16950	66	and	and	CC
18637	16950	67	the	the	DT
18637	16950	68	competence	competence	NN
18637	16950	69	of	of	IN
18637	16950	70	the	the	DT
18637	16950	71	law	law	NN
18637	16950	72	member	member	NN
18637	16950	73	and	and	CC
18637	16950	74	defense	defense	NN
18637	16950	75	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	16950	76	.	.	.
18637	16951	1	In	in	IN
18637	16951	2	summary	summary	NN
18637	16951	3	,	,	,
18637	16951	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16951	5	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	16951	6	wrote	write	VBD
18637	16951	7	:	:	:
18637	16951	8	"	"	``
18637	16951	9	In	in	IN
18637	16951	10	this	this	DT
18637	16951	11	case	case	NN
18637	16951	12	the	the	DT
18637	16951	13	court	court	NN
18637	16951	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	16951	15	martial	martial	JJ
18637	16951	16	had	have	VBD
18637	16951	17	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	16951	18	of	of	IN
18637	16951	19	the	the	DT
18637	16951	20	person	person	NN
18637	16951	21	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	16951	22	and	and	CC
18637	16951	23	the	the	DT
18637	16951	24	offense	offense	NN
18637	16951	25	charged	charge	VBD
18637	16951	26	,	,	,
18637	16951	27	and	and	CC
18637	16951	28	acted	act	VBD
18637	16951	29	within	within	IN
18637	16951	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16951	31	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	16951	32	powers	power	NNS
18637	16951	33	.	.	.
18637	16952	1	The	the	DT
18637	16952	2	correction	correction	NN
18637	16952	3	of	of	IN
18637	16952	4	any	any	DT
18637	16952	5	errors	error	NNS
18637	16952	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16952	7	may	may	MD
18637	16952	8	have	have	VB
18637	16952	9	committed	commit	VBN
18637	16952	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	16952	11	for	for	IN
18637	16952	12	the	the	DT
18637	16952	13	military	military	JJ
18637	16952	14	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	16952	15	which	which	WDT
18637	16952	16	are	be	VBP
18637	16952	17	alone	alone	RB
18637	16952	18	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	16952	19	to	to	TO
18637	16952	20	review	review	VB
18637	16952	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16952	22	decision	decision	NN
18637	16952	23	.	.	.
18637	16953	1	"	"	``
18637	16953	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16953	3	131	131	CD
18637	16953	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16953	5	Again	again	RB
18637	16953	6	in	in	IN
18637	16953	7	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	16953	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16953	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	16953	10	_	_	NNP
18637	16953	11	Eisentrager[132	Eisentrager[132	NNP
18637	16953	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16953	13	the	the	DT
18637	16953	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16953	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16953	16	overruled	overrule	VBD
18637	16953	17	a	a	DT
18637	16953	18	lower	low	JJR
18637	16953	19	court	court	NN
18637	16953	20	decision	decision	NN
18637	16953	21	,	,	,
18637	16953	22	which	which	WDT
18637	16953	23	,	,	,
18637	16953	24	in	in	IN
18637	16953	25	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	16953	26	upon	upon	IN
18637	16953	27	the	the	DT
18637	16953	28	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	16953	29	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16953	30	in	in	IN
18637	16953	31	the	the	DT
18637	16953	32	Yamashita	Yamashita	NNP
18637	16953	33	Case	Case	NNP
18637	16953	34	,	,	,
18637	16953	35	had	have	VBD
18637	16953	36	held	hold	VBN
18637	16953	37	that	that	IN
18637	16953	38	the	the	DT
18637	16953	39	due	due	JJ
18637	16953	40	process	process	NN
18637	16953	41	clause	clause	NN
18637	16953	42	required	require	VBN
18637	16953	43	that	that	IN
18637	16953	44	the	the	DT
18637	16953	45	legality	legality	NN
18637	16953	46	of	of	IN
18637	16953	47	the	the	DT
18637	16953	48	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	16953	49	of	of	IN
18637	16953	50	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	16953	51	alien	alien	NN
18637	16953	52	belligerents	belligerent	NNS
18637	16953	53	by	by	IN
18637	16953	54	military	military	JJ
18637	16953	55	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	16953	56	should	should	MD
18637	16953	57	be	be	VB
18637	16953	58	tested	test	VBN
18637	16953	59	by	by	IN
18637	16953	60	the	the	DT
18637	16953	61	writ	writ	NNP
18637	16953	62	of	of	IN
18637	16953	63	_	_	NNP
18637	16953	64	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	16953	65	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	16953	66	_	_	NNP
18637	16953	67	.	.	.
18637	16954	1	ALIENS	ALIENS	NNP
18637	16954	2	To	to	IN
18637	16954	3	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	16954	4	who	who	WP
18637	16954	5	have	have	VBP
18637	16954	6	never	never	RB
18637	16954	7	been	be	VBN
18637	16954	8	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	16954	9	or	or	CC
18637	16954	10	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	16954	11	any	any	DT
18637	16954	12	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	16954	13	or	or	CC
18637	16954	14	residence	residence	NN
18637	16954	15	in	in	IN
18637	16954	16	the	the	DT
18637	16954	17	United	United	NNP
18637	16954	18	States	States	NNP
18637	16954	19	,	,	,
18637	16954	20	the	the	DT
18637	16954	21	decision	decision	NN
18637	16954	22	of	of	IN
18637	16954	23	an	an	DT
18637	16954	24	executive	executive	JJ
18637	16954	25	or	or	CC
18637	16954	26	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	16954	27	officer	officer	NN
18637	16954	28	,	,	,
18637	16954	29	acting	act	VBG
18637	16954	30	within	within	IN
18637	16954	31	powers	power	NNS
18637	16954	32	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	16954	33	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	16954	34	by	by	IN
18637	16954	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16954	36	,	,	,
18637	16954	37	as	as	IN
18637	16954	38	to	to	IN
18637	16954	39	whether	whether	IN
18637	16954	40	or	or	CC
18637	16954	41	not	not	RB
18637	16954	42	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16954	43	shall	shall	MD
18637	16954	44	be	be	VB
18637	16954	45	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	16954	46	to	to	TO
18637	16954	47	enter	enter	VB
18637	16954	48	the	the	DT
18637	16954	49	country	country	NN
18637	16954	50	,	,	,
18637	16954	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	16954	52	due	due	JJ
18637	16954	53	process	process	NN
18637	16954	54	of	of	IN
18637	16954	55	law	law	NN
18637	16954	56	.	.	.
18637	16955	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16955	2	133	133	CD
18637	16955	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16955	4	The	the	DT
18637	16955	5	complete	complete	JJ
18637	16955	6	authority	authority	NN
18637	16955	7	of	of	IN
18637	16955	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16955	9	in	in	IN
18637	16955	10	the	the	DT
18637	16955	11	matter	matter	NN
18637	16955	12	of	of	IN
18637	16955	13	admission	admission	NN
18637	16955	14	of	of	IN
18637	16955	15	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	16955	16	justifies	justifie	NNS
18637	16955	17	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	16955	18	of	of	IN
18637	16955	19	power	power	NN
18637	16955	20	to	to	IN
18637	16955	21	executive	executive	JJ
18637	16955	22	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16955	23	to	to	TO
18637	16955	24	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	16955	25	the	the	DT
18637	16955	26	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	16955	27	of	of	IN
18637	16955	28	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	16955	29	afflicted	afflict	VBN
18637	16955	30	with	with	IN
18637	16955	31	contagious	contagious	JJ
18637	16955	32	diseases	disease	NNS
18637	16955	33	by	by	IN
18637	16955	34	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	16955	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	16955	36	the	the	DT
18637	16955	37	owner	owner	NN
18637	16955	38	of	of	IN
18637	16955	39	the	the	DT
18637	16955	40	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	16955	41	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	16955	42	any	any	DT
18637	16955	43	such	such	JJ
18637	16955	44	alien	alien	NN
18637	16955	45	into	into	IN
18637	16955	46	the	the	DT
18637	16955	47	country	country	NN
18637	16955	48	,	,	,
18637	16955	49	a	a	DT
18637	16955	50	money	money	NN
18637	16955	51	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	16955	52	,	,	,
18637	16955	53	collectible	collectible	JJ
18637	16955	54	before	before	RB
18637	16955	55	and	and	CC
18637	16955	56	as	as	IN
18637	16955	57	a	a	DT
18637	16955	58	condition	condition	NN
18637	16955	59	of	of	IN
18637	16955	60	the	the	DT
18637	16955	61	grant	grant	NN
18637	16955	62	of	of	IN
18637	16955	63	clearance	clearance	NN
18637	16955	64	.	.	.
18637	16956	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16956	2	134	134	CD
18637	16956	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16956	4	If	if	IN
18637	16956	5	the	the	DT
18637	16956	6	person	person	NN
18637	16956	7	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	16956	8	admission	admission	NN
18637	16956	9	claims	claim	VBZ
18637	16956	10	American	american	JJ
18637	16956	11	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	16956	12	,	,	,
18637	16956	13	the	the	DT
18637	16956	14	decision	decision	NN
18637	16956	15	of	of	IN
18637	16956	16	the	the	DT
18637	16956	17	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	16956	18	of	of	IN
18637	16956	19	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	16956	20	may	may	MD
18637	16956	21	be	be	VB
18637	16956	22	made	make	VBN
18637	16956	23	final	final	JJ
18637	16956	24	,	,	,
18637	16956	25	but	but	CC
18637	16956	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16956	27	must	must	MD
18637	16956	28	be	be	VB
18637	16956	29	made	make	VBN
18637	16956	30	after	after	IN
18637	16956	31	a	a	DT
18637	16956	32	fair	fair	JJ
18637	16956	33	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16956	34	,	,	,
18637	16956	35	however	however	RB
18637	16956	36	summary	summary	NN
18637	16956	37	,	,	,
18637	16956	38	and	and	CC
18637	16956	39	must	must	MD
18637	16956	40	find	find	VB
18637	16956	41	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	16956	42	support	support	NN
18637	16956	43	in	in	IN
18637	16956	44	the	the	DT
18637	16956	45	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16956	46	.	.	.
18637	16957	1	A	a	DT
18637	16957	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	16957	3	based	base	VBN
18637	16957	4	upon	upon	IN
18637	16957	5	a	a	DT
18637	16957	6	record	record	NN
18637	16957	7	from	from	IN
18637	16957	8	which	which	WDT
18637	16957	9	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	16957	10	and	and	CC
18637	16957	11	probative	probative	JJ
18637	16957	12	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16957	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	16957	14	been	be	VBN
18637	16957	15	omitted	omit	VBN
18637	16957	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	16957	17	not	not	RB
18637	16957	18	a	a	DT
18637	16957	19	fair	fair	JJ
18637	16957	20	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16957	21	.	.	.
18637	16958	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16958	2	135	135	CD
18637	16958	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16958	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	16958	5	the	the	DT
18637	16958	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	16958	7	made	make	VBD
18637	16958	8	the	the	DT
18637	16958	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	16958	10	of	of	IN
18637	16958	11	an	an	DT
18637	16958	12	immigration	immigration	NN
18637	16958	13	inspector	inspector	NN
18637	16958	14	final	final	JJ
18637	16958	15	unless	unless	IN
18637	16958	16	an	an	DT
18637	16958	17	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	16958	18	was	be	VBD
18637	16958	19	taken	take	VBN
18637	16958	20	to	to	IN
18637	16958	21	the	the	DT
18637	16958	22	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	16958	23	of	of	IN
18637	16958	24	the	the	DT
18637	16958	25	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	16958	26	,	,	,
18637	16958	27	a	a	DT
18637	16958	28	person	person	NN
18637	16958	29	who	who	WP
18637	16958	30	failed	fail	VBD
18637	16958	31	to	to	TO
18637	16958	32	take	take	VB
18637	16958	33	such	such	PDT
18637	16958	34	an	an	DT
18637	16958	35	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	16958	36	did	do	VBD
18637	16958	37	not	not	RB
18637	16958	38	,	,	,
18637	16958	39	by	by	IN
18637	16958	40	an	an	DT
18637	16958	41	allegation	allegation	NN
18637	16958	42	of	of	IN
18637	16958	43	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	16958	44	,	,	,
18637	16958	45	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	16958	46	a	a	DT
18637	16958	47	right	right	NN
18637	16958	48	to	to	IN
18637	16958	49	a	a	DT
18637	16958	50	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16958	51	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16958	52	on	on	IN
18637	16958	53	_	_	NNP
18637	16958	54	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	16958	55	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	16958	56	_	_	NNP
18637	16958	57	.	.	.
18637	16959	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16959	2	136	136	CD
18637	16959	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16959	4	DEPORTATION	DEPORTATION	NNP
18637	16959	5	Deportation	Deportation	NNP
18637	16959	6	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16959	7	are	be	VBP
18637	16959	8	not	not	RB
18637	16959	9	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	16959	10	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	16959	11	within	within	IN
18637	16959	12	the	the	DT
18637	16959	13	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	16959	14	of	of	IN
18637	16959	15	the	the	DT
18637	16959	16	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	16959	17	of	of	IN
18637	16959	18	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	16959	19	.	.	.
18637	16960	1	The	the	DT
18637	16960	2	authority	authority	NN
18637	16960	3	to	to	TO
18637	16960	4	deport	deport	VB
18637	16960	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	16960	6	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	16960	7	from	from	IN
18637	16960	8	the	the	DT
18637	16960	9	power	power	NN
18637	16960	10	of	of	IN
18637	16960	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16960	12	to	to	TO
18637	16960	13	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	16960	14	the	the	DT
18637	16960	15	entrance	entrance	NN
18637	16960	16	of	of	IN
18637	16960	17	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	16960	18	and	and	CC
18637	16960	19	impose	impose	VB
18637	16960	20	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	16960	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	16960	22	the	the	DT
18637	16960	23	performance	performance	NN
18637	16960	24	of	of	IN
18637	16960	25	which	which	WDT
18637	16960	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16960	27	continued	continue	VBN
18637	16960	28	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16960	29	to	to	TO
18637	16960	30	reside	reside	VB
18637	16960	31	within	within	IN
18637	16960	32	the	the	DT
18637	16960	33	United	United	NNP
18637	16960	34	States	States	NNP
18637	16960	35	may	may	MD
18637	16960	36	be	be	VB
18637	16960	37	made	make	VBN
18637	16960	38	to	to	TO
18637	16960	39	depend	depend	VB
18637	16960	40	.	.	.
18637	16961	1	Findings	finding	NNS
18637	16961	2	of	of	IN
18637	16961	3	fact	fact	NN
18637	16961	4	reached	reach	VBN
18637	16961	5	by	by	IN
18637	16961	6	executive	executive	JJ
18637	16961	7	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16961	8	after	after	IN
18637	16961	9	a	a	DT
18637	16961	10	fair	fair	NN
18637	16961	11	,	,	,
18637	16961	12	though	though	IN
18637	16961	13	summary	summary	NN
18637	16961	14	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	16961	15	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16961	16	may	may	MD
18637	16961	17	be	be	VB
18637	16961	18	made	make	VBN
18637	16961	19	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	16961	20	.	.	.
18637	16962	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16962	2	137	137	CD
18637	16962	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16962	4	In	in	IN
18637	16962	5	Wong	Wong	NNP
18637	16962	6	Yang	Yang	NNP
18637	16962	7	Sung	Sung	NNP
18637	16962	8	_	_	NNP
18637	16962	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	16962	10	_	_	NNP
18637	16962	11	McGrath,[138	McGrath,[138	NNP
18637	16962	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16962	13	however	however	RB
18637	16962	14	,	,	,
18637	16962	15	the	the	DT
18637	16962	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16962	17	intimated	intimate	VBD
18637	16962	18	that	that	IN
18637	16962	19	a	a	DT
18637	16962	20	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16962	21	before	before	IN
18637	16962	22	a	a	DT
18637	16962	23	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	16962	24	which	which	WDT
18637	16962	25	did	do	VBD
18637	16962	26	not	not	RB
18637	16962	27	meet	meet	VB
18637	16962	28	the	the	DT
18637	16962	29	standards	standard	NNS
18637	16962	30	of	of	IN
18637	16962	31	impartiality	impartiality	NN
18637	16962	32	embodied	embody	VBN
18637	16962	33	in	in	IN
18637	16962	34	the	the	DT
18637	16962	35	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	16962	36	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	16962	37	Act[139	Act[139	NNP
18637	16962	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16962	39	might	may	MD
18637	16962	40	not	not	RB
18637	16962	41	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	16962	42	the	the	DT
18637	16962	43	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	16962	44	of	of	IN
18637	16962	45	due	due	JJ
18637	16962	46	process	process	NN
18637	16962	47	of	of	IN
18637	16962	48	law	law	NN
18637	16962	49	.	.	.
18637	16963	1	To	to	TO
18637	16963	2	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	16963	3	such	such	JJ
18637	16963	4	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16963	5	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	16963	6	,	,	,
18637	16963	7	the	the	DT
18637	16963	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16963	9	construed	construe	VBD
18637	16963	10	the	the	DT
18637	16963	11	law	law	NN
18637	16963	12	to	to	TO
18637	16963	13	disqualify	disqualify	VB
18637	16963	14	immigration	immigration	NN
18637	16963	15	inspectors	inspector	NNS
18637	16963	16	as	as	IN
18637	16963	17	presiding	preside	VBG
18637	16963	18	officers	officer	NNS
18637	16963	19	in	in	IN
18637	16963	20	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	16963	21	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	16963	22	.	.	.
18637	16964	1	Except	except	IN
18637	16964	2	in	in	IN
18637	16964	3	time	time	NN
18637	16964	4	of	of	IN
18637	16964	5	war	war	NN
18637	16964	6	,	,	,
18637	16964	7	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	16964	8	without	without	IN
18637	16964	9	a	a	DT
18637	16964	10	fair	fair	JJ
18637	16964	11	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16964	12	or	or	CC
18637	16964	13	on	on	IN
18637	16964	14	charges	charge	NNS
18637	16964	15	unsupported	unsupporte	VBN
18637	16964	16	by	by	IN
18637	16964	17	any	any	DT
18637	16964	18	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	16964	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	16964	20	a	a	DT
18637	16964	21	denial	denial	NN
18637	16964	22	of	of	IN
18637	16964	23	due	due	JJ
18637	16964	24	process	process	NN
18637	16964	25	which	which	WDT
18637	16964	26	may	may	MD
18637	16964	27	be	be	VB
18637	16964	28	corrected	correct	VBN
18637	16964	29	on	on	IN
18637	16964	30	_	_	NNP
18637	16964	31	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	16964	32	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	16964	33	_	_	NNP
18637	16964	34	.	.	.
18637	16965	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16965	2	140	140	CD
18637	16965	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16965	4	In	in	IN
18637	16965	5	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	16965	6	with	with	IN
18637	16965	7	the	the	DT
18637	16965	8	decision	decision	NN
18637	16965	9	in	in	IN
18637	16965	10	United	United	NNP
18637	16965	11	States	States	NNP
18637	16965	12	_	_	NNP
18637	16965	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	16965	14	_	_	NNP
18637	16965	15	Ju	Ju	NNP
18637	16965	16	Toy[141	Toy[141	NNP
18637	16965	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16965	18	that	that	IN
18637	16965	19	a	a	DT
18637	16965	20	person	person	NN
18637	16965	21	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	16965	22	entrance	entrance	NN
18637	16965	23	to	to	IN
18637	16965	24	the	the	DT
18637	16965	25	United	United	NNP
18637	16965	26	States	States	NNP
18637	16965	27	was	be	VBD
18637	16965	28	not	not	RB
18637	16965	29	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	16965	30	to	to	IN
18637	16965	31	a	a	DT
18637	16965	32	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16965	33	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16965	34	on	on	IN
18637	16965	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16965	36	claim	claim	NN
18637	16965	37	of	of	IN
18637	16965	38	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	16965	39	,	,	,
18637	16965	40	a	a	DT
18637	16965	41	person	person	NN
18637	16965	42	arrested	arrest	VBN
18637	16965	43	and	and	CC
18637	16965	44	held	hold	VBN
18637	16965	45	for	for	IN
18637	16965	46	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	16965	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	16965	48	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	16965	49	to	to	IN
18637	16965	50	a	a	DT
18637	16965	51	day	day	NN
18637	16965	52	in	in	IN
18637	16965	53	court	court	NN
18637	16965	54	if	if	IN
18637	16965	55	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16965	56	denies	deny	VBZ
18637	16965	57	that	that	IN
18637	16965	58	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16965	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	16965	60	an	an	DT
18637	16965	61	alien	alien	NN
18637	16965	62	.	.	.
18637	16966	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16966	2	142	142	CD
18637	16966	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16966	4	A	a	DT
18637	16966	5	closely	closely	RB
18637	16966	6	divided	divide	VBN
18637	16966	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16966	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	16966	9	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	16966	10	that	that	IN
18637	16966	11	in	in	IN
18637	16966	12	time	time	NN
18637	16966	13	of	of	IN
18637	16966	14	war	war	NN
18637	16966	15	the	the	DT
18637	16966	16	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	16966	17	of	of	IN
18637	16966	18	an	an	DT
18637	16966	19	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	16966	20	alien	alien	NN
18637	16966	21	may	may	MD
18637	16966	22	be	be	VB
18637	16966	23	ordered	order	VBN
18637	16966	24	summarily	summarily	RB
18637	16966	25	by	by	IN
18637	16966	26	executive	executive	JJ
18637	16966	27	action	action	NN
18637	16966	28	;	;	:
18637	16966	29	due	due	JJ
18637	16966	30	process	process	NN
18637	16966	31	of	of	IN
18637	16966	32	law	law	NN
18637	16966	33	does	do	VBZ
18637	16966	34	not	not	RB
18637	16966	35	require	require	VB
18637	16966	36	the	the	DT
18637	16966	37	courts	court	NNS
18637	16966	38	to	to	TO
18637	16966	39	determine	determine	VB
18637	16966	40	the	the	DT
18637	16966	41	sufficiency	sufficiency	NN
18637	16966	42	of	of	IN
18637	16966	43	any	any	DT
18637	16966	44	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	16966	45	which	which	WDT
18637	16966	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	16966	47	gratuitously	gratuitously	RB
18637	16966	48	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	16966	49	to	to	IN
18637	16966	50	the	the	DT
18637	16966	51	alien	alien	NN
18637	16966	52	.	.	.
18637	16967	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16967	2	143	143	CD
18637	16967	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16967	4	Substantive	Substantive	NNP
18637	16967	5	Due	Due	NNP
18637	16967	6	Process	Process	NNP
18637	16967	7	DISCRIMINATION	DISCRIMINATION	VBD
18637	16967	8	Almost	almost	RB
18637	16967	9	all	all	DT
18637	16967	10	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	16967	11	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	16967	12	some	some	DT
18637	16967	13	degree	degree	NN
18637	16967	14	of	of	IN
18637	16967	15	classification	classification	NN
18637	16967	16	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	16967	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16967	18	operation	operation	NN
18637	16967	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	16967	20	directed	direct	VBN
18637	16967	21	to	to	IN
18637	16967	22	particular	particular	JJ
18637	16967	23	categories	category	NNS
18637	16967	24	of	of	IN
18637	16967	25	persons	person	NNS
18637	16967	26	,	,	,
18637	16967	27	things	thing	NNS
18637	16967	28	,	,	,
18637	16967	29	or	or	CC
18637	16967	30	events	event	NNS
18637	16967	31	;	;	:
18637	16967	32	and	and	CC
18637	16967	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16967	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	16967	35	partly	partly	RB
18637	16967	36	in	in	IN
18637	16967	37	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	16967	38	of	of	IN
18637	16967	39	this	this	DT
18637	16967	40	fact	fact	NN
18637	16967	41	that	that	IN
18637	16967	42	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16967	43	Fourteen	Fourteen	NNP
18637	16967	44	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	16967	45	the	the	DT
18637	16967	46	States	state	NNS
18637	16967	47	to	to	TO
18637	16967	48	deny	deny	VB
18637	16967	49	to	to	IN
18637	16967	50	persons	person	NNS
18637	16967	51	within	within	IN
18637	16967	52	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16967	53	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	16967	54	"	"	``
18637	16967	55	equal	equal	JJ
18637	16967	56	protection	protection	NN
18637	16967	57	of	of	IN
18637	16967	58	the	the	DT
18637	16967	59	laws	law	NNS
18637	16967	60	.	.	.
18637	16967	61	"	"	''
18637	16968	1	But	but	CC
18637	16968	2	this	this	DT
18637	16968	3	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	16968	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	16968	5	not	not	RB
18637	16968	6	rule	rule	VB
18637	16968	7	out	out	RP
18637	16968	8	classifications	classification	NNS
18637	16968	9	that	that	WDT
18637	16968	10	are	be	VBP
18637	16968	11	"	"	``
18637	16968	12	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	16968	13	"	"	''
18637	16968	14	;	;	:
18637	16968	15	and	and	CC
18637	16968	16	the	the	DT
18637	16968	17	due	due	JJ
18637	16968	18	process	process	NN
18637	16968	19	of	of	IN
18637	16968	20	law	law	NN
18637	16968	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	16968	22	of	of	IN
18637	16968	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16968	24	Five	Five	NNP
18637	16968	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	16968	26	at	at	IN
18637	16968	27	least	least	JJS
18637	16968	28	as	as	IN
18637	16968	29	tolerant	tolerant	JJ
18637	16968	30	of	of	IN
18637	16968	31	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	16968	32	classifications	classification	NNS
18637	16968	33	,	,	,
18637	16968	34	which	which	WDT
18637	16968	35	would	would	MD
18637	16968	36	have	have	VB
18637	16968	37	to	to	TO
18637	16968	38	be	be	VB
18637	16968	39	arbitrarily	arbitrarily	RB
18637	16968	40	and	and	CC
18637	16968	41	unreasonably	unreasonably	RB
18637	16968	42	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	16968	43	to	to	TO
18637	16968	44	incur	incur	VB
18637	16968	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16968	46	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	16968	47	.	.	.
18637	16969	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16969	2	144	144	CD
18637	16969	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16969	4	In	in	IN
18637	16969	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	16969	6	,	,	,
18637	16969	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16969	8	does	do	VBZ
18637	16969	9	not	not	RB
18637	16969	10	appear	appear	VB
18637	16969	11	that	that	IN
18637	16969	12	the	the	DT
18637	16969	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16969	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	16969	15	up	up	IN
18637	16969	16	to	to	IN
18637	16969	17	this	this	DT
18637	16969	18	time	time	NN
18637	16969	19	ever	ever	RB
18637	16969	20	held	hold	VBD
18637	16969	21	an	an	DT
18637	16969	22	act	act	NN
18637	16969	23	of	of	IN
18637	16969	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16969	25	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	16969	26	on	on	IN
18637	16969	27	this	this	DT
18637	16969	28	ground	ground	NN
18637	16969	29	.	.	.
18637	16970	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	16970	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16970	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	16970	4	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	16970	5	a	a	DT
18637	16970	6	law	law	NN
18637	16970	7	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	16970	8	greater	great	JJR
18637	16970	9	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	16970	10	for	for	IN
18637	16970	11	an	an	DT
18637	16970	12	offense	offense	NN
18637	16970	13	involving	involve	VBG
18637	16970	14	rights	right	NNS
18637	16970	15	and	and	CC
18637	16970	16	property	property	NN
18637	16970	17	of	of	IN
18637	16970	18	the	the	DT
18637	16970	19	United	United	NNP
18637	16970	20	States	States	NNP
18637	16970	21	than	than	IN
18637	16970	22	for	for	IN
18637	16970	23	a	a	DT
18637	16970	24	like	like	JJ
18637	16970	25	offense	offense	NN
18637	16970	26	involving	involve	VBG
18637	16970	27	the	the	DT
18637	16970	28	rights	right	NNS
18637	16970	29	of	of	IN
18637	16970	30	property	property	NN
18637	16970	31	of	of	IN
18637	16970	32	a	a	DT
18637	16970	33	private	private	JJ
18637	16970	34	person	person	NN
18637	16970	35	.	.	.
18637	16971	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16971	2	145	145	CD
18637	16971	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16971	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	16971	5	,	,	,
18637	16971	6	a	a	DT
18637	16971	7	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	16971	8	that	that	WDT
18637	16971	9	improved	improve	VBD
18637	16971	10	property	property	NN
18637	16971	11	in	in	IN
18637	16971	12	the	the	DT
18637	16971	13	District	District	NNP
18637	16971	14	of	of	IN
18637	16971	15	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	16971	16	be	be	VB
18637	16971	17	connected	connect	VBN
18637	16971	18	with	with	IN
18637	16971	19	the	the	DT
18637	16971	20	city	city	NN
18637	16971	21	sewage	sewage	NN
18637	16971	22	system	system	NN
18637	16971	23	,	,	,
18637	16971	24	with	with	IN
18637	16971	25	different	different	JJ
18637	16971	26	sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	16971	27	for	for	IN
18637	16971	28	residents	resident	NNS
18637	16971	29	and	and	CC
18637	16971	30	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	16971	31	was	be	VBD
18637	16971	32	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	16971	33	over	over	IN
18637	16971	34	the	the	DT
18637	16971	35	argument	argument	NN
18637	16971	36	that	that	IN
18637	16971	37	the	the	DT
18637	16971	38	classification	classification	NN
18637	16971	39	was	be	VBD
18637	16971	40	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	16971	41	.	.	.
18637	16972	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16972	2	146	146	CD
18637	16972	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16972	4	The	the	DT
18637	16972	5	allowance	allowance	NN
18637	16972	6	to	to	IN
18637	16972	7	injured	injured	JJ
18637	16972	8	seamen	seaman	NNS
18637	16972	9	of	of	IN
18637	16972	10	a	a	DT
18637	16972	11	choice	choice	NN
18637	16972	12	between	between	IN
18637	16972	13	several	several	JJ
18637	16972	14	measures	measure	NNS
18637	16972	15	of	of	IN
18637	16972	16	redress	redress	NN
18637	16972	17	without	without	IN
18637	16972	18	any	any	DT
18637	16972	19	corresponding	correspond	VBG
18637	16972	20	right	right	NN
18637	16972	21	in	in	IN
18637	16972	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16972	23	employer	employer	NN
18637	16972	24	was	be	VBD
18637	16972	25	held	hold	VBN
18637	16972	26	not	not	RB
18637	16972	27	to	to	TO
18637	16972	28	deny	deny	VB
18637	16972	29	due	due	JJ
18637	16972	30	process	process	NN
18637	16972	31	of	of	IN
18637	16972	32	law	law	NN
18637	16972	33	.	.	.
18637	16973	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16973	2	147	147	CD
18637	16973	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16973	4	Differences	difference	NNS
18637	16973	5	of	of	IN
18637	16973	6	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	16973	7	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	16973	8	marketing	market	VBG
18637	16973	9	cooperatives	cooperative	NNS
18637	16973	10	in	in	IN
18637	16973	11	milk	milk	NN
18637	16973	12	marketing	marketing	NN
18637	16973	13	orders	order	NNS
18637	16973	14	issued	issue	VBN
18637	16973	15	by	by	IN
18637	16973	16	the	the	DT
18637	16973	17	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	16973	18	of	of	IN
18637	16973	19	Agriculture[148	Agriculture[148	NNP
18637	16973	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16973	21	and	and	CC
18637	16973	22	the	the	DT
18637	16973	23	selection	selection	NN
18637	16973	24	of	of	IN
18637	16973	25	a	a	DT
18637	16973	26	limited	limited	JJ
18637	16973	27	number	number	NN
18637	16973	28	of	of	IN
18637	16973	29	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	16973	30	markets	market	NNS
18637	16973	31	for	for	IN
18637	16973	32	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	16973	33	grading	grading	NN
18637	16973	34	of	of	IN
18637	16973	35	tobacco[149	tobacco[149	DT
18637	16973	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16973	37	have	have	VBP
18637	16973	38	also	also	RB
18637	16973	39	been	be	VBN
18637	16973	40	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	16973	41	.	.	.
18637	16974	1	The	the	DT
18637	16974	2	priority	priority	NN
18637	16974	3	of	of	IN
18637	16974	4	a	a	DT
18637	16974	5	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16974	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	16974	7	lien	lien	NN
18637	16974	8	against	against	IN
18637	16974	9	property	property	NN
18637	16974	10	passing	pass	VBG
18637	16974	11	at	at	IN
18637	16974	12	death	death	NN
18637	16974	13	,	,	,
18637	16974	14	may	may	MD
18637	16974	15	,	,	,
18637	16974	16	without	without	IN
18637	16974	17	offending	offend	VBG
18637	16974	18	the	the	DT
18637	16974	19	due	due	JJ
18637	16974	20	process	process	NN
18637	16974	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	16974	22	,	,	,
18637	16974	23	be	be	VB
18637	16974	24	different	different	JJ
18637	16974	25	from	from	IN
18637	16974	26	that	that	DT
18637	16974	27	which	which	WDT
18637	16974	28	attaches	attach	VBZ
18637	16974	29	to	to	IN
18637	16974	30	property	property	NN
18637	16974	31	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	16974	32	_	_	NNP
18637	16974	33	inter	inter	NN
18637	16974	34	vivos	vivos	NNP
18637	16974	35	_	_	NNP
18637	16974	36	in	in	IN
18637	16974	37	contemplation	contemplation	NN
18637	16974	38	of	of	IN
18637	16974	39	death	death	NN
18637	16974	40	.	.	.
18637	16975	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16975	2	150	150	CD
18637	16975	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16975	4	There	there	EX
18637	16975	5	are	be	VBP
18637	16975	6	indications	indication	NNS
18637	16975	7	,	,	,
18637	16975	8	however	however	RB
18637	16975	9	,	,	,
18637	16975	10	that	that	IN
18637	16975	11	the	the	DT
18637	16975	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16975	13	may	may	MD
18637	16975	14	be	be	VB
18637	16975	15	prepared	prepared	JJ
18637	16975	16	to	to	TO
18637	16975	17	go	go	VB
18637	16975	18	further	far	RBR
18637	16975	19	than	than	IN
18637	16975	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16975	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	16975	22	in	in	IN
18637	16975	23	the	the	DT
18637	16975	24	past	past	NN
18637	16975	25	in	in	IN
18637	16975	26	condemning	condemn	VBG
18637	16975	27	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	16975	28	as	as	IN
18637	16975	29	a	a	DT
18637	16975	30	denial	denial	NN
18637	16975	31	of	of	IN
18637	16975	32	due	due	JJ
18637	16975	33	process	process	NN
18637	16975	34	of	of	IN
18637	16975	35	law	law	NN
18637	16975	36	.	.	.
18637	16976	1	Relying	rely	VBG
18637	16976	2	upon	upon	IN
18637	16976	3	public	public	JJ
18637	16976	4	policy	policy	NN
18637	16976	5	and	and	CC
18637	16976	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16976	7	supervisory	supervisory	JJ
18637	16976	8	authority	authority	NN
18637	16976	9	over	over	IN
18637	16976	10	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16976	11	courts	court	NNS
18637	16976	12	,	,	,
18637	16976	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16976	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	16976	15	reached	reach	VBN
18637	16976	16	results	result	NNS
18637	16976	17	similar	similar	JJ
18637	16976	18	to	to	IN
18637	16976	19	those	those	DT
18637	16976	20	arrived	arrive	VBN
18637	16976	21	at	at	IN
18637	16976	22	under	under	IN
18637	16976	23	the	the	DT
18637	16976	24	equal	equal	JJ
18637	16976	25	protection	protection	NN
18637	16976	26	clause	clause	NN
18637	16976	27	of	of	IN
18637	16976	28	the	the	DT
18637	16976	29	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	16976	30	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16976	31	,	,	,
18637	16976	32	in	in	IN
18637	16976	33	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	16976	34	to	to	TO
18637	16976	35	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	16976	36	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	16976	37	covenants	covenant	NNS
18637	16976	38	in	in	IN
18637	16976	39	the	the	DT
18637	16976	40	District	District	NNP
18637	16976	41	of	of	IN
18637	16976	42	Columbia,[151	Columbia,[151	NNP
18637	16976	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16976	44	and	and	CC
18637	16976	45	in	in	IN
18637	16976	46	reversing	reverse	VBG
18637	16976	47	a	a	DT
18637	16976	48	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16976	49	of	of	IN
18637	16976	50	a	a	DT
18637	16976	51	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	16976	52	District	District	NNP
18637	16976	53	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16976	54	because	because	IN
18637	16976	55	of	of	IN
18637	16976	56	the	the	DT
18637	16976	57	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	16976	58	of	of	IN
18637	16976	59	day	day	NN
18637	16976	60	laborers	laborer	NNS
18637	16976	61	from	from	IN
18637	16976	62	the	the	DT
18637	16976	63	jury	jury	NN
18637	16976	64	panel;[152	panel;[152	NNS
18637	16976	65	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16976	66	and	and	CC
18637	16976	67	in	in	IN
18637	16976	68	Steele	Steele	NNP
18637	16976	69	_	_	NNP
18637	16976	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	16976	71	_	_	NNP
18637	16976	72	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	16976	73	&	&	CC
18637	16976	74	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	16977	1	Co.[153	co.[153	RB
18637	16977	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16977	3	the	the	DT
18637	16977	4	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	16977	5	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	16977	6	Act	Act	NNP
18637	16977	7	was	be	VBD
18637	16977	8	construed	construe	VBN
18637	16977	9	to	to	TO
18637	16977	10	require	require	VB
18637	16977	11	a	a	DT
18637	16977	12	collective	collective	JJ
18637	16977	13	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	16977	14	representative	representative	NN
18637	16977	15	to	to	TO
18637	16977	16	act	act	VB
18637	16977	17	for	for	IN
18637	16977	18	the	the	DT
18637	16977	19	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	16977	20	of	of	IN
18637	16977	21	all	all	DT
18637	16977	22	members	member	NNS
18637	16977	23	of	of	IN
18637	16977	24	the	the	DT
18637	16977	25	craft	craft	NN
18637	16977	26	without	without	IN
18637	16977	27	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	16977	28	on	on	IN
18637	16977	29	account	account	NN
18637	16977	30	of	of	IN
18637	16977	31	race	race	NN
18637	16977	32	.	.	.
18637	16978	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	16978	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16978	3	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	16978	4	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	16978	5	that	that	IN
18637	16978	6	any	any	DT
18637	16978	7	other	other	JJ
18637	16978	8	construction	construction	NN
18637	16978	9	would	would	MD
18637	16978	10	raise	raise	VB
18637	16978	11	grave	grave	JJ
18637	16978	12	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	16978	13	doubts,[154	doubts,[154	NN
18637	16978	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16978	15	while	while	IN
18637	16978	16	in	in	IN
18637	16978	17	a	a	DT
18637	16978	18	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	16978	19	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	16978	20	,	,	,
18637	16978	21	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	16978	22	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	16978	23	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	16978	24	unequivocally	unequivocally	RB
18637	16978	25	that	that	IN
18637	16978	26	the	the	DT
18637	16978	27	act	act	NN
18637	16978	28	would	would	MD
18637	16978	29	be	be	VB
18637	16978	30	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	16978	31	with	with	IN
18637	16978	32	the	the	DT
18637	16978	33	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	16978	34	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16978	35	if	if	IN
18637	16978	36	the	the	DT
18637	16978	37	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	16978	38	agent	agent	NN
18637	16978	39	,	,	,
18637	16978	40	acting	act	VBG
18637	16978	41	under	under	IN
18637	16978	42	color	color	NN
18637	16978	43	of	of	IN
18637	16978	44	federal	federal	JJ
18637	16978	45	authority	authority	NN
18637	16978	46	,	,	,
18637	16978	47	were	be	VBD
18637	16978	48	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	16978	49	to	to	TO
18637	16978	50	discriminate	discriminate	VB
18637	16978	51	against	against	IN
18637	16978	52	any	any	DT
18637	16978	53	of	of	IN
18637	16978	54	the	the	DT
18637	16978	55	persons	person	NNS
18637	16978	56	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16978	57	was	be	VBD
18637	16978	58	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	16978	59	to	to	TO
18637	16978	60	represent	represent	VB
18637	16978	61	.	.	.
18637	16979	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16979	2	155	155	CD
18637	16979	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16979	4	DEPRIVATION	deprivation	NN
18637	16979	5	OF	of	IN
18637	16979	6	LIBERTY	liberty	NN
18637	16979	7	In	in	IN
18637	16979	8	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	16979	9	of	of	IN
18637	16979	10	the	the	DT
18637	16979	11	explicit	explicit	JJ
18637	16979	12	assurances	assurance	NNS
18637	16979	13	of	of	IN
18637	16979	14	individual	individual	JJ
18637	16979	15	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16979	16	contained	contain	VBN
18637	16979	17	in	in	IN
18637	16979	18	other	other	JJ
18637	16979	19	articles	article	NNS
18637	16979	20	of	of	IN
18637	16979	21	the	the	DT
18637	16979	22	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	16979	23	of	of	IN
18637	16979	24	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	16979	25	,	,	,
18637	16979	26	the	the	DT
18637	16979	27	clause	clause	NN
18637	16979	28	in	in	IN
18637	16979	29	the	the	DT
18637	16979	30	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	16979	31	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	16979	32	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	16979	33	the	the	DT
18637	16979	34	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	16979	35	of	of	IN
18637	16979	36	"	"	``
18637	16979	37	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16979	38	"	"	''
18637	16979	39	without	without	IN
18637	16979	40	due	due	JJ
18637	16979	41	process	process	NN
18637	16979	42	of	of	IN
18637	16979	43	law	law	NN
18637	16979	44	has	have	VBZ
18637	16979	45	been	be	VBN
18637	16979	46	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	16979	47	chiefly	chiefly	RB
18637	16979	48	in	in	IN
18637	16979	49	resistance	resistance	NN
18637	16979	50	to	to	IN
18637	16979	51	measures	measure	NNS
18637	16979	52	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	16979	53	to	to	TO
18637	16979	54	abridge	abridge	VB
18637	16979	55	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16979	56	of	of	IN
18637	16979	57	contract	contract	NN
18637	16979	58	.	.	.
18637	16980	1	The	the	DT
18637	16980	2	two	two	CD
18637	16980	3	leading	leading	JJ
18637	16980	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	16980	5	which	which	WDT
18637	16980	6	held	hold	VBD
18637	16980	7	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	16980	8	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	16980	9	on	on	IN
18637	16980	10	this	this	DT
18637	16980	11	ground	ground	NN
18637	16980	12	have	have	VBP
18637	16980	13	,	,	,
18637	16980	14	however	however	RB
18637	16980	15	,	,	,
18637	16980	16	both	both	DT
18637	16980	17	been	be	VBN
18637	16980	18	overturned	overturn	VBN
18637	16980	19	in	in	IN
18637	16980	20	recent	recent	JJ
18637	16980	21	years	year	NNS
18637	16980	22	.	.	.
18637	16981	1	Adair	Adair	NNP
18637	16981	2	_	_	NNP
18637	16981	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	16981	4	_	_	NNP
18637	16981	5	United	United	NNP
18637	16981	6	States,[156	States,[156	NNP
18637	16981	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16981	8	which	which	WDT
18637	16981	9	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
18637	16981	10	an	an	DT
18637	16981	11	act	act	NN
18637	16981	12	of	of	IN
18637	16981	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16981	14	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	16981	15	any	any	DT
18637	16981	16	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	16981	17	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	16981	18	from	from	IN
18637	16981	19	threatening	threaten	VBG
18637	16981	20	an	an	DT
18637	16981	21	employee	employee	NN
18637	16981	22	with	with	IN
18637	16981	23	loss	loss	NN
18637	16981	24	of	of	IN
18637	16981	25	employment	employment	NN
18637	16981	26	if	if	IN
18637	16981	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16981	28	joined	join	VBD
18637	16981	29	a	a	DT
18637	16981	30	labor	labor	NN
18637	16981	31	union	union	NN
18637	16981	32	,	,	,
18637	16981	33	was	be	VBD
18637	16981	34	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	16981	35	in	in	IN
18637	16981	36	substance	substance	NN
18637	16981	37	by	by	IN
18637	16981	38	Phelps	Phelps	NNP
18637	16981	39	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	16981	40	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	16981	41	_	_	NNP
18637	16981	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	16981	43	_	_	NNP
18637	16981	44	National	National	NNP
18637	16981	45	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	16981	46	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	16981	47	Board	Board	NNP
18637	16981	48	.	.	.
18637	16982	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16982	2	157	157	CD
18637	16982	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16982	4	Adkins	Adkins	NNPS
18637	16982	5	_	_	NNP
18637	16982	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	16982	7	_	_	NNP
18637	16982	8	Children	Children	NNP
18637	16982	9	's	's	POS
18637	16982	10	Hospital,[158	hospital,[158	ADD
18637	16982	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16982	12	in	in	IN
18637	16982	13	which	which	WDT
18637	16982	14	a	a	DT
18637	16982	15	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	16982	16	wage	wage	NN
18637	16982	17	law	law	NN
18637	16982	18	for	for	IN
18637	16982	19	the	the	DT
18637	16982	20	District	District	NNP
18637	16982	21	of	of	IN
18637	16982	22	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	16982	23	was	be	VBD
18637	16982	24	found	find	VBN
18637	16982	25	to	to	TO
18637	16982	26	be	be	VB
18637	16982	27	an	an	DT
18637	16982	28	unwarranted	unwarranted	JJ
18637	16982	29	abridgment	abridgment	NN
18637	16982	30	of	of	IN
18637	16982	31	the	the	DT
18637	16982	32	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	16982	33	of	of	IN
18637	16982	34	contract	contract	NN
18637	16982	35	,	,	,
18637	16982	36	was	be	VBD
18637	16982	37	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	16982	38	repudiated	repudiate	VBN
18637	16982	39	by	by	IN
18637	16982	40	West	West	NNP
18637	16982	41	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	16982	42	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	16982	43	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	16982	44	_	_	NNP
18637	16982	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	16982	46	_	_	NNP
18637	16982	47	Parrish	Parrish	NNP
18637	16982	48	.	.	.
18637	16983	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16983	2	159	159	CD
18637	16983	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16983	4	Numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	16983	5	other	other	JJ
18637	16983	6	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	16983	7	--	--	:
18637	16983	8	antitrust	antitrust	JJ
18637	16983	9	laws,[160	laws,[160	NN
18637	16983	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16983	11	acts	act	VBZ
18637	16983	12	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	16983	13	hours	hour	NNS
18637	16983	14	of	of	IN
18637	16983	15	labor,[161	labor,[161	NN
18637	16983	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16983	17	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	16983	18	advance	advance	NN
18637	16983	19	of	of	IN
18637	16983	20	wages	wage	NNS
18637	16983	21	to	to	IN
18637	16983	22	seamen,[162	seamen,[162	NNP
18637	16983	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16983	24	making	make	VBG
18637	16983	25	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	16983	26	liable	liable	JJ
18637	16983	27	for	for	IN
18637	16983	28	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	16983	29	suffered	suffer	VBN
18637	16983	30	by	by	IN
18637	16983	31	employees	employee	NNS
18637	16983	32	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	16983	33	of	of	IN
18637	16983	34	previous	previous	JJ
18637	16983	35	contractual	contractual	JJ
18637	16983	36	arrangements,[163	arrangements,[163	NNP
18637	16983	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16983	38	requiring	require	VBG
18637	16983	39	employers	employer	NNS
18637	16983	40	to	to	TO
18637	16983	41	bargain	bargain	VB
18637	16983	42	collectively	collectively	RB
18637	16983	43	with	with	IN
18637	16983	44	employees[164	employees[164	NNS
18637	16983	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16983	46	and	and	CC
18637	16983	47	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	16983	48	prices	price	NNS
18637	16983	49	of	of	IN
18637	16983	50	commodities[165	commodities[165	NNP
18637	16983	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16983	52	have	have	VBP
18637	16983	53	been	be	VBN
18637	16983	54	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	16983	55	against	against	IN
18637	16983	56	attack	attack	NN
18637	16983	57	on	on	IN
18637	16983	58	this	this	DT
18637	16983	59	ground	ground	NN
18637	16983	60	.	.	.
18637	16984	1	Interpreting	interpreting	NN
18637	16984	2	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	16984	3	which	which	WDT
18637	16984	4	made	make	VBD
18637	16984	5	the	the	DT
18637	16984	6	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	16984	7	of	of	IN
18637	16984	8	due	due	JJ
18637	16984	9	process	process	NN
18637	16984	10	of	of	IN
18637	16984	11	law	law	NN
18637	16984	12	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	16984	13	to	to	IN
18637	16984	14	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	16984	15	and	and	CC
18637	16984	16	the	the	DT
18637	16984	17	Philippine	Philippine	NNP
18637	16984	18	Islands	Islands	NNPS
18637	16984	19	,	,	,
18637	16984	20	the	the	DT
18637	16984	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16984	22	enjoined	enjoin	VBD
18637	16984	23	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	16984	24	of	of	IN
18637	16984	25	an	an	DT
18637	16984	26	act	act	NN
18637	16984	27	of	of	IN
18637	16984	28	the	the	DT
18637	16984	29	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	16984	30	of	of	IN
18637	16984	31	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	16984	32	which	which	WDT
18637	16984	33	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	16984	34	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	16984	35	of	of	IN
18637	16984	36	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	16984	37	-	-	HYPH
18637	16984	38	language	language	NN
18637	16984	39	schools	school	NNS
18637	16984	40	except	except	IN
18637	16984	41	upon	upon	IN
18637	16984	42	written	write	VBN
18637	16984	43	permit	permit	NN
18637	16984	44	and	and	CC
18637	16984	45	payment	payment	NN
18637	16984	46	of	of	IN
18637	16984	47	a	a	DT
18637	16984	48	fee	fee	NN
18637	16984	49	based	base	VBN
18637	16984	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	16984	51	attendance,[166	attendance,[166	NN
18637	16984	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16984	53	and	and	CC
18637	16984	54	held	hold	VBD
18637	16984	55	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	16984	56	a	a	DT
18637	16984	57	Philippine	philippine	JJ
18637	16984	58	statute	statute	NN
18637	16984	59	which	which	WDT
18637	16984	60	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	16984	61	Chinese	chinese	JJ
18637	16984	62	merchants	merchant	NNS
18637	16984	63	from	from	IN
18637	16984	64	keeping	keep	VBG
18637	16984	65	any	any	DT
18637	16984	66	accounts	account	NNS
18637	16984	67	in	in	IN
18637	16984	68	Chinese	Chinese	NNP
18637	16984	69	.	.	.
18637	16985	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16985	2	167	167	CD
18637	16985	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16985	4	DEPRIVATION	deprivation	NN
18637	16985	5	OF	of	IN
18637	16985	6	PROPERTY	PROPERTY	NNP
18637	16985	7	Retroactive	Retroactive	NNP
18637	16985	8	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
18637	16985	9	Sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	16985	10	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	16985	11	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	16985	12	of	of	IN
18637	16985	13	future	future	JJ
18637	16985	14	action	action	NN
18637	16985	15	,	,	,
18637	16985	16	based	base	VBN
18637	16985	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	16985	18	rights	right	NNS
18637	16985	19	previously	previously	RB
18637	16985	20	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	16985	21	by	by	IN
18637	16985	22	the	the	DT
18637	16985	23	person	person	NN
18637	16985	24	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	16985	25	,	,	,
18637	16985	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	16985	27	not	not	RB
18637	16985	28	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	16985	29	by	by	IN
18637	16985	30	the	the	DT
18637	16985	31	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	16985	32	.	.	.
18637	16986	1	So	so	RB
18637	16986	2	long	long	RB
18637	16986	3	as	as	IN
18637	16986	4	the	the	DT
18637	16986	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	16986	6	authorizes	authorize	VBZ
18637	16986	7	the	the	DT
18637	16986	8	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	16986	9	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	16986	10	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	16986	11	,	,	,
18637	16986	12	the	the	DT
18637	16986	13	fact	fact	NN
18637	16986	14	that	that	IN
18637	16986	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16986	16	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	16986	17	limit	limit	VBP
18637	16986	18	or	or	CC
18637	16986	19	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	16986	20	with	with	IN
18637	16986	21	previously	previously	RB
18637	16986	22	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	16986	23	rights	right	NNS
18637	16986	24	does	do	VBZ
18637	16986	25	not	not	RB
18637	16986	26	condemn	condemn	VB
18637	16986	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16986	28	.	.	.
18637	16987	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	16987	2	,	,	,
18637	16987	3	rent	rent	NN
18637	16987	4	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	16987	5	were	be	VBD
18637	16987	6	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	16987	7	as	as	IN
18637	16987	8	applied	apply	VBN
18637	16987	9	to	to	TO
18637	16987	10	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	16987	11	execution	execution	NN
18637	16987	12	of	of	IN
18637	16987	13	a	a	DT
18637	16987	14	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16987	15	of	of	IN
18637	16987	16	eviction	eviction	NN
18637	16987	17	rendered	render	VBN
18637	16987	18	by	by	IN
18637	16987	19	a	a	DT
18637	16987	20	State	State	NNP
18637	16987	21	court	court	NN
18637	16987	22	before	before	IN
18637	16987	23	the	the	DT
18637	16987	24	enabling	enable	VBG
18637	16987	25	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	16987	26	was	be	VBD
18637	16987	27	passed	pass	VBN
18637	16987	28	.	.	.
18637	16988	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16988	2	168	168	CD
18637	16988	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16988	4	An	an	DT
18637	16988	5	order	order	NN
18637	16988	6	by	by	IN
18637	16988	7	an	an	DT
18637	16988	8	Area	Area	NNP
18637	16988	9	Rent	Rent	NNP
18637	16988	10	Director	Director	NNP
18637	16988	11	reducing	reduce	VBG
18637	16988	12	an	an	DT
18637	16988	13	unapproved	unapproved	JJ
18637	16988	14	rental	rental	NN
18637	16988	15	and	and	CC
18637	16988	16	requiring	require	VBG
18637	16988	17	the	the	DT
18637	16988	18	landlord	landlord	NN
18637	16988	19	to	to	TO
18637	16988	20	refund	refund	VB
18637	16988	21	the	the	DT
18637	16988	22	excess	excess	JJ
18637	16988	23	previously	previously	RB
18637	16988	24	collected	collect	VBN
18637	16988	25	,	,	,
18637	16988	26	was	be	VBD
18637	16988	27	held	hold	VBN
18637	16988	28	,	,	,
18637	16988	29	with	with	IN
18637	16988	30	one	one	CD
18637	16988	31	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	16988	32	vote	vote	NN
18637	16988	33	,	,	,
18637	16988	34	not	not	RB
18637	16988	35	to	to	TO
18637	16988	36	be	be	VB
18637	16988	37	the	the	DT
18637	16988	38	type	type	NN
18637	16988	39	of	of	IN
18637	16988	40	retroactivity	retroactivity	NN
18637	16988	41	which	which	WDT
18637	16988	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	16988	43	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	16988	44	by	by	IN
18637	16988	45	law	law	NN
18637	16988	46	.	.	.
18637	16989	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16989	2	169	169	CD
18637	16989	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16989	4	The	the	DT
18637	16989	5	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	16989	6	effect	effect	NN
18637	16989	7	of	of	IN
18637	16989	8	a	a	DT
18637	16989	9	new	new	JJ
18637	16989	10	principle	principle	NN
18637	16989	11	announced	announce	VBN
18637	16989	12	by	by	IN
18637	16989	13	a	a	DT
18637	16989	14	decision	decision	NN
18637	16989	15	of	of	IN
18637	16989	16	an	an	DT
18637	16989	17	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	16989	18	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	16989	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	16989	20	been	be	VBN
18637	16989	21	likened	liken	VBN
18637	16989	22	to	to	IN
18637	16989	23	the	the	DT
18637	16989	24	effect	effect	NN
18637	16989	25	of	of	IN
18637	16989	26	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	16989	27	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	16989	28	in	in	IN
18637	16989	29	cases	case	NNS
18637	16989	30	of	of	IN
18637	16989	31	first	first	JJ
18637	16989	32	impression	impression	NN
18637	16989	33	.	.	.
18637	16990	1	In	in	IN
18637	16990	2	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	16990	3	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	16990	4	.	.	.
18637	16991	1	_	_	NNP
18637	16991	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	16991	3	_	_	NNP
18637	16991	4	Chenery	Chenery	NNP
18637	16991	5	Corp	Corp	NNP
18637	16991	6	.	.	NNP
18637	16991	7	,[170	,[170	,
18637	16991	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16991	9	the	the	DT
18637	16991	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	16991	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16991	12	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	16991	13	a	a	DT
18637	16991	14	decision	decision	NN
18637	16991	15	of	of	IN
18637	16991	16	the	the	DT
18637	16991	17	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	16991	18	which	which	WDT
18637	16991	19	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	16991	20	to	to	TO
18637	16991	21	approve	approve	VB
18637	16991	22	a	a	DT
18637	16991	23	plan	plan	NN
18637	16991	24	of	of	IN
18637	16991	25	reorganization	reorganization	NN
18637	16991	26	for	for	IN
18637	16991	27	a	a	DT
18637	16991	28	public	public	JJ
18637	16991	29	utility	utility	NN
18637	16991	30	holding	hold	VBG
18637	16991	31	company	company	NN
18637	16991	32	so	so	RB
18637	16991	33	long	long	RB
18637	16991	34	as	as	IN
18637	16991	35	the	the	DT
18637	16991	36	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	16991	37	stock	stock	NN
18637	16991	38	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	16991	39	by	by	IN
18637	16991	40	the	the	DT
18637	16991	41	management	management	NN
18637	16991	42	was	be	VBD
18637	16991	43	treated	treat	VBN
18637	16991	44	on	on	IN
18637	16991	45	a	a	DT
18637	16991	46	parity	parity	NN
18637	16991	47	with	with	IN
18637	16991	48	other	other	JJ
18637	16991	49	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	16991	50	stock	stock	NN
18637	16991	51	even	even	RB
18637	16991	52	though	though	IN
18637	16991	53	the	the	DT
18637	16991	54	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	16991	55	of	of	IN
18637	16991	56	such	such	JJ
18637	16991	57	stock	stock	NN
18637	16991	58	,	,	,
18637	16991	59	when	when	WRB
18637	16991	60	made	make	VBN
18637	16991	61	,	,	,
18637	16991	62	did	do	VBD
18637	16991	63	not	not	RB
18637	16991	64	conflict	conflict	VB
18637	16991	65	with	with	IN
18637	16991	66	any	any	DT
18637	16991	67	law	law	NN
18637	16991	68	or	or	CC
18637	16991	69	rule	rule	NN
18637	16991	70	of	of	IN
18637	16991	71	the	the	DT
18637	16991	72	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	16991	73	.	.	.
18637	16992	1	In	in	IN
18637	16992	2	the	the	DT
18637	16992	3	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	16992	4	of	of	IN
18637	16992	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16992	6	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	16992	7	powers	power	NNS
18637	16992	8	over	over	IN
18637	16992	9	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	16992	10	,	,	,
18637	16992	11	finance	finance	NN
18637	16992	12	and	and	CC
18637	16992	13	currency	currency	NN
18637	16992	14	,	,	,
18637	16992	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16992	16	may	may	MD
18637	16992	17	make	make	VB
18637	16992	18	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	16992	19	notes	note	NNS
18637	16992	20	legal	legal	JJ
18637	16992	21	tender	tender	NN
18637	16992	22	in	in	IN
18637	16992	23	payment	payment	NN
18637	16992	24	of	of	IN
18637	16992	25	debts	debt	NNS
18637	16992	26	previously	previously	RB
18637	16992	27	contracted[171	contracted[171	FW
18637	16992	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16992	29	and	and	CC
18637	16992	30	may	may	MD
18637	16992	31	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	16992	32	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	16992	33	in	in	IN
18637	16992	34	private	private	JJ
18637	16992	35	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	16992	36	calling	call	VBG
18637	16992	37	for	for	IN
18637	16992	38	payment	payment	NN
18637	16992	39	in	in	IN
18637	16992	40	gold	gold	NN
18637	16992	41	coin	coin	NN
18637	16992	42	.	.	.
18637	16993	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16993	2	172	172	CD
18637	16993	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16993	4	An	an	DT
18637	16993	5	award	award	NN
18637	16993	6	of	of	IN
18637	16993	7	additional	additional	JJ
18637	16993	8	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	16993	9	under	under	IN
18637	16993	10	the	the	DT
18637	16993	11	Longshoremen	Longshoremen	NNP
18637	16993	12	's	's	POS
18637	16993	13	and	and	CC
18637	16993	14	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	16993	15	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	16993	16	'	'	POS
18637	16993	17	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	16993	18	Act,[173	Act,[173	NNP
18637	16993	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16993	20	made	make	VBN
18637	16993	21	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	16993	22	to	to	IN
18637	16993	23	a	a	DT
18637	16993	24	private	private	JJ
18637	16993	25	act	act	NN
18637	16993	26	of	of	IN
18637	16993	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16993	28	passed	pass	VBD
18637	16993	29	after	after	IN
18637	16993	30	expiration	expiration	NN
18637	16993	31	of	of	IN
18637	16993	32	the	the	DT
18637	16993	33	period	period	NN
18637	16993	34	for	for	IN
18637	16993	35	review	review	NN
18637	16993	36	of	of	IN
18637	16993	37	the	the	DT
18637	16993	38	original	original	JJ
18637	16993	39	award	award	NN
18637	16993	40	,	,	,
18637	16993	41	directing	direct	VBG
18637	16993	42	the	the	DT
18637	16993	43	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	16993	44	to	to	TO
18637	16993	45	review	review	VB
18637	16993	46	the	the	DT
18637	16993	47	case	case	NN
18637	16993	48	and	and	CC
18637	16993	49	issue	issue	VB
18637	16993	50	a	a	DT
18637	16993	51	new	new	JJ
18637	16993	52	order	order	NN
18637	16993	53	,	,	,
18637	16993	54	was	be	VBD
18637	16993	55	held	hold	VBN
18637	16993	56	valid	valid	JJ
18637	16993	57	against	against	IN
18637	16993	58	the	the	DT
18637	16993	59	employer	employer	NN
18637	16993	60	and	and	CC
18637	16993	61	insurer	insurer	NN
18637	16993	62	.	.	.
18637	16994	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16994	2	174	174	CD
18637	16994	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16994	4	The	the	DT
18637	16994	5	application	application	NN
18637	16994	6	of	of	IN
18637	16994	7	a	a	DT
18637	16994	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	16994	9	providing	provide	VBG
18637	16994	10	for	for	IN
18637	16994	11	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	16994	12	marketing	marketing	NN
18637	16994	13	quotas	quota	NNS
18637	16994	14	,	,	,
18637	16994	15	to	to	IN
18637	16994	16	a	a	DT
18637	16994	17	crop	crop	NN
18637	16994	18	planted	plant	VBN
18637	16994	19	prior	prior	RB
18637	16994	20	to	to	IN
18637	16994	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	16994	22	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	16994	23	,	,	,
18637	16994	24	was	be	VBD
18637	16994	25	held	hold	VBN
18637	16994	26	not	not	RB
18637	16994	27	to	to	TO
18637	16994	28	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	16994	29	the	the	DT
18637	16994	30	producers	producer	NNS
18637	16994	31	of	of	IN
18637	16994	32	property	property	NN
18637	16994	33	without	without	IN
18637	16994	34	due	due	JJ
18637	16994	35	process	process	NN
18637	16994	36	of	of	IN
18637	16994	37	law	law	NN
18637	16994	38	since	since	IN
18637	16994	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	16994	40	operated	operate	VBD
18637	16994	41	,	,	,
18637	16994	42	not	not	RB
18637	16994	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	16994	44	production	production	NN
18637	16994	45	,	,	,
18637	16994	46	but	but	CC
18637	16994	47	upon	upon	IN
18637	16994	48	the	the	DT
18637	16994	49	marketing	marketing	NN
18637	16994	50	of	of	IN
18637	16994	51	the	the	DT
18637	16994	52	product	product	NN
18637	16994	53	after	after	IN
18637	16994	54	the	the	DT
18637	16994	55	act	act	NN
18637	16994	56	was	be	VBD
18637	16994	57	passed	pass	VBN
18637	16994	58	.	.	.
18637	16995	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16995	2	175	175	CD
18637	16995	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16995	4	The	the	DT
18637	16995	5	validation	validation	NN
18637	16995	6	by	by	IN
18637	16995	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	16995	8	of	of	IN
18637	16995	9	a	a	DT
18637	16995	10	prior	prior	JJ
18637	16995	11	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	16995	12	of	of	IN
18637	16995	13	personal	personal	JJ
18637	16995	14	property	property	NN
18637	16995	15	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	16995	16	because	because	IN
18637	16995	17	improperly	improperly	RB
18637	16995	18	recorded	record	VBN
18637	16995	19	,	,	,
18637	16995	20	did	do	VBD
18637	16995	21	not	not	RB
18637	16995	22	deny	deny	VB
18637	16995	23	due	due	JJ
18637	16995	24	process	process	NN
18637	16995	25	of	of	IN
18637	16995	26	law	law	NN
18637	16995	27	to	to	IN
18637	16995	28	a	a	DT
18637	16995	29	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	16995	30	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	16995	31	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	16995	32	to	to	TO
18637	16995	33	levy	levy	VB
18637	16995	34	an	an	DT
18637	16995	35	attachment	attachment	NN
18637	16995	36	on	on	IN
18637	16995	37	the	the	DT
18637	16995	38	mortgaged	mortgage	VBN
18637	16995	39	property	property	NN
18637	16995	40	.	.	.
18637	16996	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16996	2	176	176	CD
18637	16996	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16996	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	16996	5	was	be	VBD
18637	16996	6	property	property	NN
18637	16996	7	taken	take	VBN
18637	16996	8	without	without	IN
18637	16996	9	due	due	JJ
18637	16996	10	process	process	NN
18637	16996	11	of	of	IN
18637	16996	12	law	law	NN
18637	16996	13	by	by	IN
18637	16996	14	a	a	DT
18637	16996	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	16996	16	of	of	IN
18637	16996	17	New	New	NNP
18637	16996	18	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	16996	19	territory	territory	NN
18637	16996	20	,	,	,
18637	16996	21	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	16996	22	disseisin	disseisin	NN
18637	16996	23	of	of	IN
18637	16996	24	real	real	JJ
18637	16996	25	property	property	NN
18637	16996	26	to	to	TO
18637	16996	27	ripen	ripen	VB
18637	16996	28	into	into	IN
18637	16996	29	title	title	NN
18637	16996	30	after	after	IN
18637	16996	31	ten	ten	CD
18637	16996	32	years	year	NNS
18637	16996	33	.	.	.
18637	16997	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16997	2	177	177	CD
18637	16997	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16997	4	An	an	DT
18637	16997	5	order	order	NN
18637	16997	6	of	of	IN
18637	16997	7	the	the	DT
18637	16997	8	military	military	JJ
18637	16997	9	governor	governor	NN
18637	16997	10	of	of	IN
18637	16997	11	Porto	Porto	NNP
18637	16997	12	Rico	Rico	NNP
18637	16997	13	reducing	reduce	VBG
18637	16997	14	the	the	DT
18637	16997	15	period	period	NN
18637	16997	16	during	during	IN
18637	16997	17	which	which	WDT
18637	16997	18	the	the	DT
18637	16997	19	possession	possession	NN
18637	16997	20	of	of	IN
18637	16997	21	real	real	JJ
18637	16997	22	estate	estate	NN
18637	16997	23	must	must	MD
18637	16997	24	continue	continue	VB
18637	16997	25	,	,	,
18637	16997	26	to	to	TO
18637	16997	27	permit	permit	VB
18637	16997	28	an	an	DT
18637	16997	29	_	_	NNP
18637	16997	30	ex	ex	NNP
18637	16997	31	parte	parte	NNP
18637	16997	32	_	_	NNP
18637	16997	33	conversion	conversion	NN
18637	16997	34	of	of	IN
18637	16997	35	an	an	DT
18637	16997	36	entry	entry	NN
18637	16997	37	of	of	IN
18637	16997	38	possessory	possessory	JJ
18637	16997	39	title	title	NN
18637	16997	40	into	into	IN
18637	16997	41	record	record	JJ
18637	16997	42	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	16997	43	was	be	VBD
18637	16997	44	construed	construe	VBN
18637	16997	45	to	to	TO
18637	16997	46	apply	apply	VB
18637	16997	47	only	only	RB
18637	16997	48	where	where	WRB
18637	16997	49	there	there	EX
18637	16997	50	still	still	RB
18637	16997	51	remained	remain	VBD
18637	16997	52	a	a	DT
18637	16997	53	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	16997	54	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	16997	55	for	for	IN
18637	16997	56	the	the	DT
18637	16997	57	true	true	JJ
18637	16997	58	owners	owner	NNS
18637	16997	59	to	to	TO
18637	16997	60	contest	contest	VB
18637	16997	61	the	the	DT
18637	16997	62	claim	claim	NN
18637	16997	63	.	.	.
18637	16998	1	The	the	DT
18637	16998	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	16998	3	said	say	VBD
18637	16998	4	that	that	IN
18637	16998	5	any	any	DT
18637	16998	6	other	other	JJ
18637	16998	7	construction	construction	NN
18637	16998	8	would	would	MD
18637	16998	9	permit	permit	VB
18637	16998	10	a	a	DT
18637	16998	11	taking	taking	NN
18637	16998	12	of	of	IN
18637	16998	13	property	property	NN
18637	16998	14	without	without	IN
18637	16998	15	due	due	JJ
18637	16998	16	process	process	NN
18637	16998	17	of	of	IN
18637	16998	18	law	law	NN
18637	16998	19	.	.	.
18637	16999	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	16999	2	178	178	CD
18637	16999	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	16999	4	Rights	right	NNS
18637	16999	5	created	create	VBN
18637	16999	6	by	by	IN
18637	16999	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	16999	8	are	be	VBP
18637	16999	9	subject	subject	JJ
18637	16999	10	to	to	IN
18637	16999	11	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	16999	12	by	by	IN
18637	16999	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	16999	14	;	;	:
18637	16999	15	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	16999	16	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	16999	17	gratuitously	gratuitously	RB
18637	16999	18	may	may	MD
18637	16999	19	be	be	VB
18637	16999	20	redistributed	redistribute	VBN
18637	16999	21	or	or	CC
18637	16999	22	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	16999	23	at	at	IN
18637	16999	24	any	any	DT
18637	16999	25	time	time	NN
18637	16999	26	.	.	.
18637	17000	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17000	2	179	179	CD
18637	17000	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17000	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	17000	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17000	6	provided	provide	VBD
18637	17000	7	,	,	,
18637	17000	8	in	in	IN
18637	17000	9	granting	grant	VBG
18637	17000	10	lands	land	NNS
18637	17000	11	to	to	IN
18637	17000	12	a	a	DT
18637	17000	13	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	17000	14	,	,	,
18637	17000	15	that	that	IN
18637	17000	16	such	such	JJ
18637	17000	17	land	land	NN
18637	17000	18	could	could	MD
18637	17000	19	be	be	VB
18637	17000	20	resold	resold	VBN
18637	17000	21	only	only	RB
18637	17000	22	to	to	IN
18637	17000	23	actual	actual	JJ
18637	17000	24	settlers	settler	NNS
18637	17000	25	,	,	,
18637	17000	26	at	at	IN
18637	17000	27	a	a	DT
18637	17000	28	price	price	NN
18637	17000	29	not	not	RB
18637	17000	30	exceeding	exceed	VBG
18637	17000	31	$	$	$
18637	17000	32	2.50	2.50	CD
18637	17000	33	per	per	IN
18637	17000	34	acre	acre	NN
18637	17000	35	,	,	,
18637	17000	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17000	37	could	could	MD
18637	17000	38	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	17000	39	,	,	,
18637	17000	40	for	for	IN
18637	17000	41	breach	breach	NN
18637	17000	42	of	of	IN
18637	17000	43	performance	performance	NN
18637	17000	44	,	,	,
18637	17000	45	resume	resume	VB
18637	17000	46	title	title	NN
18637	17000	47	to	to	IN
18637	17000	48	the	the	DT
18637	17000	49	lands	land	NNS
18637	17000	50	while	while	IN
18637	17000	51	assuring	assure	VBG
18637	17000	52	the	the	DT
18637	17000	53	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	17000	54	the	the	DT
18637	17000	55	equivalent	equivalent	NN
18637	17000	56	of	of	IN
18637	17000	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17000	58	interest	interest	NN
18637	17000	59	.	.	.
18637	17001	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17001	2	180	180	CD
18637	17001	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17001	4	An	an	DT
18637	17001	5	act	act	NN
18637	17001	6	making	make	VBG
18637	17001	7	an	an	DT
18637	17001	8	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	17001	9	for	for	IN
18637	17001	10	a	a	DT
18637	17001	11	private	private	JJ
18637	17001	12	claim	claim	NN
18637	17001	13	which	which	WDT
18637	17001	14	restricted	restrict	VBD
18637	17001	15	the	the	DT
18637	17001	16	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	17001	17	's	's	POS
18637	17001	18	fees	fee	NNS
18637	17001	19	payable	payable	JJ
18637	17001	20	therefrom	therefrom	NN
18637	17001	21	to	to	IN
18637	17001	22	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	17001	23	per	per	IN
18637	17001	24	cent	cent	NN
18637	17001	25	was	be	VBD
18637	17001	26	valid	valid	JJ
18637	17001	27	although	although	IN
18637	17001	28	inconsistent	inconsistent	NN
18637	17001	29	with	with	IN
18637	17001	30	a	a	DT
18637	17001	31	prior	prior	JJ
18637	17001	32	contract	contract	NN
18637	17001	33	with	with	IN
18637	17001	34	the	the	DT
18637	17001	35	claimant	claimant	NN
18637	17001	36	allowing	allow	VBG
18637	17001	37	a	a	DT
18637	17001	38	larger	large	JJR
18637	17001	39	fee	fee	NN
18637	17001	40	.	.	.
18637	17002	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17002	2	181	181	CD
18637	17002	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17002	4	Statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	17002	5	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	17002	6	on	on	IN
18637	17002	7	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17002	8	for	for	IN
18637	17002	9	services	service	NNS
18637	17002	10	in	in	IN
18637	17002	11	connection	connection	NN
18637	17002	12	with	with	IN
18637	17002	13	veterans	veteran	NNS
18637	17002	14	'	'	POS
18637	17002	15	pensions	pension	NNS
18637	17002	16	or	or	CC
18637	17002	17	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	17002	18	have	have	VBP
18637	17002	19	been	be	VBN
18637	17002	20	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	17002	21	.	.	.
18637	17003	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17003	2	182	182	CD
18637	17003	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17003	4	An	an	DT
18637	17003	5	increase	increase	NN
18637	17003	6	in	in	IN
18637	17003	7	the	the	DT
18637	17003	8	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	17003	9	for	for	IN
18637	17003	10	production	production	NN
18637	17003	11	of	of	IN
18637	17003	12	wheat	wheat	NN
18637	17003	13	in	in	IN
18637	17003	14	excess	excess	NN
18637	17003	15	of	of	IN
18637	17003	16	quota	quota	NN
18637	17003	17	was	be	VBD
18637	17003	18	not	not	RB
18637	17003	19	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	17003	20	as	as	IN
18637	17003	21	applied	apply	VBN
18637	17003	22	retroactively	retroactively	RB
18637	17003	23	to	to	IN
18637	17003	24	wheat	wheat	NN
18637	17003	25	already	already	RB
18637	17003	26	planted	plant	VBN
18637	17003	27	,	,	,
18637	17003	28	where	where	WRB
18637	17003	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17003	30	concurrently	concurrently	RB
18637	17003	31	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	17003	32	a	a	DT
18637	17003	33	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	17003	34	increase	increase	NN
18637	17003	35	in	in	IN
18637	17003	36	the	the	DT
18637	17003	37	amount	amount	NN
18637	17003	38	of	of	IN
18637	17003	39	the	the	DT
18637	17003	40	loan	loan	NN
18637	17003	41	which	which	WDT
18637	17003	42	might	may	MD
18637	17003	43	be	be	VB
18637	17003	44	made	make	VBN
18637	17003	45	to	to	IN
18637	17003	46	cooperating	cooperate	VBG
18637	17003	47	farmers	farmer	NNS
18637	17003	48	upon	upon	IN
18637	17003	49	stored	store	VBN
18637	17003	50	"	"	``
18637	17003	51	farm	farm	NN
18637	17003	52	marketing	marketing	NN
18637	17003	53	excess	excess	NN
18637	17003	54	wheat	wheat	NN
18637	17003	55	.	.	.
18637	17004	1	"	"	``
18637	17004	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17004	3	183	183	CD
18637	17004	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17004	5	Retroactive	Retroactive	NNP
18637	17004	6	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
18637	17004	7	Disallowed	disallow	VBD
18637	17004	8	The	the	DT
18637	17004	9	due	due	JJ
18637	17004	10	process	process	NN
18637	17004	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	17004	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	17004	13	been	be	VBN
18637	17004	14	successfully	successfully	RB
18637	17004	15	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	17004	16	to	to	TO
18637	17004	17	defeat	defeat	VB
18637	17004	18	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	17004	19	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	17004	20	or	or	CC
18637	17004	21	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	17004	22	of	of	IN
18637	17004	23	property	property	NN
18637	17004	24	rights	right	NNS
18637	17004	25	in	in	IN
18637	17004	26	a	a	DT
18637	17004	27	few	few	JJ
18637	17004	28	cases	case	NNS
18637	17004	29	.	.	.
18637	17005	1	A	a	DT
18637	17005	2	revocation	revocation	NN
18637	17005	3	by	by	IN
18637	17005	4	the	the	DT
18637	17005	5	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	17005	6	of	of	IN
18637	17005	7	the	the	DT
18637	17005	8	Interior	Interior	NNP
18637	17005	9	of	of	IN
18637	17005	10	previous	previous	JJ
18637	17005	11	approval	approval	NN
18637	17005	12	of	of	IN
18637	17005	13	plats	plat	NNS
18637	17005	14	and	and	CC
18637	17005	15	papers	paper	NNS
18637	17005	16	showing	show	VBG
18637	17005	17	that	that	IN
18637	17005	18	a	a	DT
18637	17005	19	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	17005	20	was	be	VBD
18637	17005	21	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	17005	22	to	to	IN
18637	17005	23	land	land	NN
18637	17005	24	under	under	IN
18637	17005	25	a	a	DT
18637	17005	26	grant	grant	NN
18637	17005	27	was	be	VBD
18637	17005	28	held	hold	VBN
18637	17005	29	void	void	JJ
18637	17005	30	as	as	IN
18637	17005	31	an	an	DT
18637	17005	32	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	17005	33	to	to	TO
18637	17005	34	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	17005	35	the	the	DT
18637	17005	36	company	company	NN
18637	17005	37	of	of	IN
18637	17005	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17005	39	property	property	NN
18637	17005	40	without	without	IN
18637	17005	41	due	due	JJ
18637	17005	42	process	process	NN
18637	17005	43	of	of	IN
18637	17005	44	law	law	NN
18637	17005	45	.	.	.
18637	17006	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17006	2	184	184	CD
18637	17006	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17006	4	The	the	DT
18637	17006	5	exception	exception	NN
18637	17006	6	of	of	IN
18637	17006	7	the	the	DT
18637	17006	8	period	period	NN
18637	17006	9	of	of	IN
18637	17006	10	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17006	11	control	control	NN
18637	17006	12	from	from	IN
18637	17006	13	the	the	DT
18637	17006	14	time	time	NN
18637	17006	15	limit	limit	NN
18637	17006	16	set	set	VBN
18637	17006	17	by	by	IN
18637	17006	18	law	law	NN
18637	17006	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	17006	20	claims	claim	NNS
18637	17006	21	against	against	IN
18637	17006	22	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	17006	23	for	for	IN
18637	17006	24	damages	damage	NNS
18637	17006	25	caused	cause	VBN
18637	17006	26	by	by	IN
18637	17006	27	misrouting	misrouting	NN
18637	17006	28	of	of	IN
18637	17006	29	goods	good	NNS
18637	17006	30	,	,	,
18637	17006	31	was	be	VBD
18637	17006	32	read	read	VBN
18637	17006	33	as	as	IN
18637	17006	34	prospective	prospective	JJ
18637	17006	35	only	only	RB
18637	17006	36	because	because	IN
18637	17006	37	the	the	DT
18637	17006	38	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	17006	39	was	be	VBD
18637	17006	40	an	an	DT
18637	17006	41	integral	integral	JJ
18637	17006	42	part	part	NN
18637	17006	43	of	of	IN
18637	17006	44	the	the	DT
18637	17006	45	liability	liability	NN
18637	17006	46	,	,	,
18637	17006	47	not	not	RB
18637	17006	48	merely	merely	RB
18637	17006	49	a	a	DT
18637	17006	50	matter	matter	NN
18637	17006	51	of	of	IN
18637	17006	52	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	17006	53	,	,	,
18637	17006	54	and	and	CC
18637	17006	55	would	would	MD
18637	17006	56	violate	violate	VB
18637	17006	57	the	the	DT
18637	17006	58	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	17006	59	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17006	60	if	if	IN
18637	17006	61	retroactive	retroactive	NN
18637	17006	62	.	.	.
18637	17007	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17007	2	185	185	CD
18637	17007	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17007	4	Rights	right	NNS
18637	17007	5	against	against	IN
18637	17007	6	the	the	DT
18637	17007	7	United	United	NNP
18637	17007	8	States	States	NNP
18637	17007	9	arising	arise	VBG
18637	17007	10	out	out	IN
18637	17007	11	of	of	IN
18637	17007	12	contract	contract	NN
18637	17007	13	are	be	VBP
18637	17007	14	protected	protect	VBN
18637	17007	15	by	by	IN
18637	17007	16	the	the	DT
18637	17007	17	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	17007	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17007	19	;	;	:
18637	17007	20	hence	hence	RB
18637	17007	21	a	a	DT
18637	17007	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	17007	23	abrogating	abrogate	VBG
18637	17007	24	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	17007	25	of	of	IN
18637	17007	26	war	war	NN
18637	17007	27	risk	risk	NN
18637	17007	28	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	17007	29	was	be	VBD
18637	17007	30	held	hold	VBN
18637	17007	31	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	17007	32	as	as	IN
18637	17007	33	applied	apply	VBN
18637	17007	34	to	to	IN
18637	17007	35	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	17007	36	policies	policy	NNS
18637	17007	37	.	.	.
18637	17008	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17008	2	186	186	CD
18637	17008	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17008	4	Bankruptcy	Bankruptcy	NNP
18637	17008	5	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
18637	17008	6	The	the	DT
18637	17008	7	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	17008	8	power	power	NN
18637	17008	9	of	of	IN
18637	17008	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17008	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	17008	12	subject	subject	JJ
18637	17008	13	to	to	IN
18637	17008	14	the	the	DT
18637	17008	15	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	17008	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17008	17	.	.	.
18637	17009	1	A	a	DT
18637	17009	2	statute	statute	NN
18637	17009	3	which	which	WDT
18637	17009	4	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	17009	5	a	a	DT
18637	17009	6	court	court	NN
18637	17009	7	to	to	TO
18637	17009	8	stay	stay	VB
18637	17009	9	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	17009	10	for	for	IN
18637	17009	11	the	the	DT
18637	17009	12	foreclosure	foreclosure	NN
18637	17009	13	of	of	IN
18637	17009	14	a	a	DT
18637	17009	15	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	17009	16	for	for	IN
18637	17009	17	five	five	CD
18637	17009	18	years	year	NNS
18637	17009	19	,	,	,
18637	17009	20	the	the	DT
18637	17009	21	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	17009	22	to	to	TO
18637	17009	23	remain	remain	VB
18637	17009	24	in	in	IN
18637	17009	25	possession	possession	NN
18637	17009	26	at	at	IN
18637	17009	27	a	a	DT
18637	17009	28	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	17009	29	rental	rental	NN
18637	17009	30	,	,	,
18637	17009	31	with	with	IN
18637	17009	32	the	the	DT
18637	17009	33	option	option	NN
18637	17009	34	of	of	IN
18637	17009	35	purchasing	purchase	VBG
18637	17009	36	the	the	DT
18637	17009	37	property	property	NN
18637	17009	38	at	at	IN
18637	17009	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17009	40	appraised	appraise	VBN
18637	17009	41	value	value	NN
18637	17009	42	at	at	IN
18637	17009	43	the	the	DT
18637	17009	44	end	end	NN
18637	17009	45	of	of	IN
18637	17009	46	the	the	DT
18637	17009	47	stay	stay	NN
18637	17009	48	,	,	,
18637	17009	49	was	be	VBD
18637	17009	50	held	hold	VBN
18637	17009	51	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	17009	52	because	because	IN
18637	17009	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17009	54	deprived	deprive	VBD
18637	17009	55	the	the	DT
18637	17009	56	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	17009	57	of	of	IN
18637	17009	58	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	17009	59	property	property	NN
18637	17009	60	rights	right	NNS
18637	17009	61	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	17009	62	prior	prior	RB
18637	17009	63	to	to	IN
18637	17009	64	the	the	DT
18637	17009	65	passage	passage	NN
18637	17009	66	of	of	IN
18637	17009	67	the	the	DT
18637	17009	68	act	act	NN
18637	17009	69	.	.	.
18637	17010	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17010	2	187	187	CD
18637	17010	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17010	4	A	a	DT
18637	17010	5	modified	modify	VBN
18637	17010	6	law	law	NN
18637	17010	7	,	,	,
18637	17010	8	under	under	IN
18637	17010	9	which	which	WDT
18637	17010	10	the	the	DT
18637	17010	11	stay	stay	NN
18637	17010	12	was	be	VBD
18637	17010	13	subject	subject	JJ
18637	17010	14	to	to	IN
18637	17010	15	termination	termination	NN
18637	17010	16	by	by	IN
18637	17010	17	the	the	DT
18637	17010	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17010	19	,	,	,
18637	17010	20	and	and	CC
18637	17010	21	which	which	WDT
18637	17010	22	continued	continue	VBD
18637	17010	23	the	the	DT
18637	17010	24	right	right	NN
18637	17010	25	of	of	IN
18637	17010	26	the	the	DT
18637	17010	27	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	17010	28	to	to	TO
18637	17010	29	have	have	VB
18637	17010	30	the	the	DT
18637	17010	31	property	property	NN
18637	17010	32	sold	sell	VBN
18637	17010	33	to	to	TO
18637	17010	34	pay	pay	VB
18637	17010	35	the	the	DT
18637	17010	36	debt	debt	NN
18637	17010	37	was	be	VBD
18637	17010	38	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	17010	39	.	.	.
18637	17011	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17011	2	188	188	CD
18637	17011	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17011	4	Without	without	IN
18637	17011	5	violation	violation	NN
18637	17011	6	of	of	IN
18637	17011	7	the	the	DT
18637	17011	8	due	due	JJ
18637	17011	9	process	process	NN
18637	17011	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	17011	11	,	,	,
18637	17011	12	the	the	DT
18637	17011	13	sale	sale	NN
18637	17011	14	of	of	IN
18637	17011	15	collateral	collateral	NN
18637	17011	16	under	under	IN
18637	17011	17	the	the	DT
18637	17011	18	terms	term	NNS
18637	17011	19	of	of	IN
18637	17011	20	a	a	DT
18637	17011	21	contract	contract	NN
18637	17011	22	may	may	MD
18637	17011	23	be	be	VB
18637	17011	24	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	17011	25	,	,	,
18637	17011	26	if	if	IN
18637	17011	27	such	such	JJ
18637	17011	28	sale	sale	NN
18637	17011	29	would	would	MD
18637	17011	30	hinder	hinder	VB
18637	17011	31	the	the	DT
18637	17011	32	preparation	preparation	NN
18637	17011	33	or	or	CC
18637	17011	34	consummation	consummation	NN
18637	17011	35	of	of	IN
18637	17011	36	a	a	DT
18637	17011	37	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	17011	38	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	17011	39	reorganization	reorganization	NN
18637	17011	40	,	,	,
18637	17011	41	provided	provide	VBD
18637	17011	42	the	the	DT
18637	17011	43	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	17011	44	does	do	VBZ
18637	17011	45	no	no	DT
18637	17011	46	more	more	RBR
18637	17011	47	than	than	IN
18637	17011	48	delay	delay	VB
18637	17011	49	the	the	DT
18637	17011	50	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	17011	51	of	of	IN
18637	17011	52	the	the	DT
18637	17011	53	contract	contract	NN
18637	17011	54	.	.	.
18637	17012	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17012	2	189	189	CD
18637	17012	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17012	4	A	a	DT
18637	17012	5	provision	provision	NN
18637	17012	6	that	that	WDT
18637	17012	7	claims	claim	VBZ
18637	17012	8	resulting	result	VBG
18637	17012	9	from	from	IN
18637	17012	10	rejection	rejection	NN
18637	17012	11	of	of	IN
18637	17012	12	an	an	DT
18637	17012	13	unexpired	unexpired	JJ
18637	17012	14	lease	lease	NN
18637	17012	15	should	should	MD
18637	17012	16	be	be	VB
18637	17012	17	treated	treat	VBN
18637	17012	18	as	as	IN
18637	17012	19	on	on	IN
18637	17012	20	a	a	DT
18637	17012	21	parity	parity	NN
18637	17012	22	with	with	IN
18637	17012	23	provable	provable	JJ
18637	17012	24	debts	debt	NNS
18637	17012	25	,	,	,
18637	17012	26	but	but	CC
18637	17012	27	limited	limit	VBN
18637	17012	28	to	to	IN
18637	17012	29	an	an	DT
18637	17012	30	amount	amount	NN
18637	17012	31	equal	equal	JJ
18637	17012	32	to	to	IN
18637	17012	33	three	three	CD
18637	17012	34	years	year	NNS
18637	17012	35	rent	rent	NN
18637	17012	36	,	,	,
18637	17012	37	was	be	VBD
18637	17012	38	held	hold	VBN
18637	17012	39	not	not	RB
18637	17012	40	to	to	TO
18637	17012	41	amount	amount	VB
18637	17012	42	to	to	IN
18637	17012	43	a	a	DT
18637	17012	44	taking	taking	NN
18637	17012	45	of	of	IN
18637	17012	46	property	property	NN
18637	17012	47	without	without	IN
18637	17012	48	due	due	JJ
18637	17012	49	process	process	NN
18637	17012	50	of	of	IN
18637	17012	51	law	law	NN
18637	17012	52	,	,	,
18637	17012	53	since	since	IN
18637	17012	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17012	55	provided	provide	VBD
18637	17012	56	a	a	DT
18637	17012	57	new	new	JJ
18637	17012	58	and	and	CC
18637	17012	59	more	more	RBR
18637	17012	60	certain	certain	JJ
18637	17012	61	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	17012	62	for	for	IN
18637	17012	63	a	a	DT
18637	17012	64	limited	limited	JJ
18637	17012	65	amount	amount	NN
18637	17012	66	,	,	,
18637	17012	67	in	in	IN
18637	17012	68	lieu	lieu	NN
18637	17012	69	of	of	IN
18637	17012	70	an	an	DT
18637	17012	71	existing	exist	VBG
18637	17012	72	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	17012	73	inefficient	inefficient	JJ
18637	17012	74	and	and	CC
18637	17012	75	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
18637	17012	76	in	in	IN
18637	17012	77	result	result	NN
18637	17012	78	.	.	.
18637	17013	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17013	2	190	190	CD
18637	17013	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17013	4	A	a	DT
18637	17013	5	right	right	NN
18637	17013	6	of	of	IN
18637	17013	7	redemption	redemption	NN
18637	17013	8	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	17013	9	by	by	IN
18637	17013	10	State	State	NNP
18637	17013	11	law	law	NN
18637	17013	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	17013	13	foreclosure	foreclosure	NN
18637	17013	14	of	of	IN
18637	17013	15	a	a	DT
18637	17013	16	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	17013	17	was	be	VBD
18637	17013	18	unavailing	unavaile	VBG
18637	17013	19	to	to	TO
18637	17013	20	defeat	defeat	VB
18637	17013	21	a	a	DT
18637	17013	22	plan	plan	NN
18637	17013	23	for	for	IN
18637	17013	24	reorganization	reorganization	NN
18637	17013	25	of	of	IN
18637	17013	26	a	a	DT
18637	17013	27	debt	debt	NN
18637	17013	28	or	or	CC
18637	17013	29	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	17013	30	where	where	WRB
18637	17013	31	the	the	DT
18637	17013	32	trial	trial	NN
18637	17013	33	court	court	NN
18637	17013	34	found	find	VBD
18637	17013	35	that	that	IN
18637	17013	36	the	the	DT
18637	17013	37	claims	claim	NNS
18637	17013	38	of	of	IN
18637	17013	39	junior	junior	JJ
18637	17013	40	lienholders	lienholder	NNS
18637	17013	41	had	have	VBD
18637	17013	42	no	no	DT
18637	17013	43	value	value	NN
18637	17013	44	.	.	.
18637	17014	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17014	2	191	191	CD
18637	17014	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17014	4	Right	right	UH
18637	17014	5	To	to	IN
18637	17014	6	Sue	Sue	NNP
18637	17014	7	the	the	DT
18637	17014	8	Government	government	NN
18637	17014	9	A	a	DT
18637	17014	10	right	right	NN
18637	17014	11	to	to	TO
18637	17014	12	sue	sue	VB
18637	17014	13	the	the	DT
18637	17014	14	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17014	15	on	on	IN
18637	17014	16	a	a	DT
18637	17014	17	contract	contract	NN
18637	17014	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	17014	19	a	a	DT
18637	17014	20	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	17014	21	,	,	,
18637	17014	22	not	not	RB
18637	17014	23	a	a	DT
18637	17014	24	property	property	NN
18637	17014	25	right	right	NN
18637	17014	26	protected	protect	VBN
18637	17014	27	by	by	IN
18637	17014	28	the	the	DT
18637	17014	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	17014	30	.	.	.
18637	17015	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17015	2	192	192	CD
18637	17015	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17015	4	The	the	DT
18637	17015	5	right	right	NN
18637	17015	6	to	to	TO
18637	17015	7	sue	sue	VB
18637	17015	8	for	for	IN
18637	17015	9	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	17015	10	of	of	IN
18637	17015	11	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	17015	12	paid	pay	VBN
18637	17015	13	may	may	MD
18637	17015	14	be	be	VB
18637	17015	15	conditioned	condition	VBN
18637	17015	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	17015	17	an	an	DT
18637	17015	18	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	17015	19	to	to	IN
18637	17015	20	the	the	DT
18637	17015	21	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	17015	22	and	and	CC
18637	17015	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17015	24	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	17015	25	to	to	IN
18637	17015	26	refund	refund	NN
18637	17015	27	.	.	.
18637	17016	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17016	2	193	193	CD
18637	17016	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17016	4	There	there	EX
18637	17016	5	was	be	VBD
18637	17016	6	no	no	DT
18637	17016	7	denial	denial	NN
18637	17016	8	of	of	IN
18637	17016	9	due	due	JJ
18637	17016	10	process	process	NN
18637	17016	11	when	when	WRB
18637	17016	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17016	13	took	take	VBD
18637	17016	14	away	away	RB
18637	17016	15	the	the	DT
18637	17016	16	right	right	NN
18637	17016	17	to	to	TO
18637	17016	18	sue	sue	VB
18637	17016	19	for	for	IN
18637	17016	20	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	17016	21	of	of	IN
18637	17016	22	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	17016	23	,	,	,
18637	17016	24	where	where	WRB
18637	17016	25	the	the	DT
18637	17016	26	claim	claim	NN
18637	17016	27	for	for	IN
18637	17016	28	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	17016	29	was	be	VBD
18637	17016	30	without	without	IN
18637	17016	31	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	17016	32	equity	equity	NN
18637	17016	33	,	,	,
18637	17016	34	having	have	VBG
18637	17016	35	arisen	arise	VBN
18637	17016	36	from	from	IN
18637	17016	37	the	the	DT
18637	17016	38	mistake	mistake	NN
18637	17016	39	of	of	IN
18637	17016	40	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	17016	41	officials	official	NNS
18637	17016	42	in	in	IN
18637	17016	43	allowing	allow	VBG
18637	17016	44	the	the	DT
18637	17016	45	statute	statute	NN
18637	17016	46	of	of	IN
18637	17016	47	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	17016	48	to	to	TO
18637	17016	49	run	run	VB
18637	17016	50	before	before	IN
18637	17016	51	collecting	collect	VBG
18637	17016	52	the	the	DT
18637	17016	53	tax	tax	NN
18637	17016	54	.	.	.
18637	17017	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17017	2	194	194	CD
18637	17017	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17017	4	The	the	DT
18637	17017	5	denial	denial	NN
18637	17017	6	to	to	IN
18637	17017	7	taxpayers	taxpayer	NNS
18637	17017	8	of	of	IN
18637	17017	9	the	the	DT
18637	17017	10	right	right	NN
18637	17017	11	to	to	TO
18637	17017	12	sue	sue	VB
18637	17017	13	for	for	IN
18637	17017	14	refund	refund	NN
18637	17017	15	of	of	IN
18637	17017	16	processing	processing	NN
18637	17017	17	and	and	CC
18637	17017	18	floor	floor	NN
18637	17017	19	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	17017	20	collected	collect	VBN
18637	17017	21	under	under	IN
18637	17017	22	a	a	DT
18637	17017	23	law	law	NN
18637	17017	24	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	17017	25	held	hold	VBD
18637	17017	26	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	17017	27	,	,	,
18637	17017	28	and	and	CC
18637	17017	29	the	the	DT
18637	17017	30	substitution	substitution	NN
18637	17017	31	of	of	IN
18637	17017	32	a	a	DT
18637	17017	33	new	new	JJ
18637	17017	34	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	17017	35	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	17017	36	for	for	IN
18637	17017	37	the	the	DT
18637	17017	38	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	17017	39	of	of	IN
18637	17017	40	such	such	JJ
18637	17017	41	sums	sum	NNS
18637	17017	42	,	,	,
18637	17017	43	was	be	VBD
18637	17017	44	held	hold	VBN
18637	17017	45	valid	valid	JJ
18637	17017	46	.	.	.
18637	17018	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17018	2	195	195	CD
18637	17018	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17018	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17018	5	may	may	MD
18637	17018	6	cut	cut	VB
18637	17018	7	off	off	RP
18637	17018	8	the	the	DT
18637	17018	9	right	right	NN
18637	17018	10	to	to	TO
18637	17018	11	recover	recover	VB
18637	17018	12	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	17018	13	illegally	illegally	RB
18637	17018	14	collected	collect	VBN
18637	17018	15	by	by	IN
18637	17018	16	ratifying	ratify	VBG
18637	17018	17	the	the	DT
18637	17018	18	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	17018	19	and	and	CC
18637	17018	20	collection	collection	NN
18637	17018	21	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	17018	22	,	,	,
18637	17018	23	where	where	WRB
18637	17018	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17018	25	could	could	MD
18637	17018	26	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	17018	27	have	have	VB
18637	17018	28	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	17018	29	such	such	JJ
18637	17018	30	exactions	exaction	NNS
18637	17018	31	prior	prior	RB
18637	17018	32	to	to	IN
18637	17018	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17018	34	collection	collection	NN
18637	17018	35	.	.	.
18637	17019	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17019	2	196	196	CD
18637	17019	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17019	4	CONGRESSIONAL	congressional	JJ
18637	17019	5	POLICE	police	NN
18637	17019	6	MEASURES	measure	VBD
18637	17019	7	Numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	17019	8	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	17019	9	of	of	IN
18637	17019	10	a	a	DT
18637	17019	11	police	police	NN
18637	17019	12	nature	nature	NN
18637	17019	13	,	,	,
18637	17019	14	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	17019	15	under	under	IN
18637	17019	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	17019	17	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	17019	18	granted	grant	VBN
18637	17019	19	to	to	IN
18637	17019	20	the	the	DT
18637	17019	21	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	17019	22	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17019	23	,	,	,
18637	17019	24	have	have	VBP
18637	17019	25	been	be	VBN
18637	17019	26	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	17019	27	over	over	IN
18637	17019	28	objections	objection	NNS
18637	17019	29	based	base	VBN
18637	17019	30	on	on	IN
18637	17019	31	the	the	DT
18637	17019	32	due	due	JJ
18637	17019	33	process	process	NN
18637	17019	34	clause	clause	NN
18637	17019	35	.	.	.
18637	17020	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17020	2	may	may	MD
18637	17020	3	require	require	VB
18637	17020	4	the	the	DT
18637	17020	5	owner	owner	NN
18637	17020	6	of	of	IN
18637	17020	7	a	a	DT
18637	17020	8	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	17020	9	on	on	IN
18637	17020	10	which	which	WDT
18637	17020	11	alien	alien	JJ
18637	17020	12	seamen	seaman	NNS
18637	17020	13	suffering	suffer	VBG
18637	17020	14	from	from	IN
18637	17020	15	specified	specified	JJ
18637	17020	16	diseases	disease	NNS
18637	17020	17	are	be	VBP
18637	17020	18	brought	bring	VBN
18637	17020	19	into	into	IN
18637	17020	20	the	the	DT
18637	17020	21	country	country	NN
18637	17020	22	to	to	TO
18637	17020	23	bear	bear	VB
18637	17020	24	the	the	DT
18637	17020	25	expense	expense	NN
18637	17020	26	of	of	IN
18637	17020	27	caring	care	VBG
18637	17020	28	for	for	IN
18637	17020	29	such	such	JJ
18637	17020	30	persons	person	NNS
18637	17020	31	.	.	.
18637	17021	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17021	2	197	197	CD
18637	17021	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17021	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17021	5	may	may	MD
18637	17021	6	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	17021	7	the	the	DT
18637	17021	8	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	17021	9	in	in	IN
18637	17021	10	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	17021	11	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	17021	12	of	of	IN
18637	17021	13	filled	fill	VBN
18637	17021	14	milk,[198	milk,[198	NNP
18637	17021	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17021	16	or	or	CC
18637	17021	17	the	the	DT
18637	17021	18	importation	importation	NN
18637	17021	19	of	of	IN
18637	17021	20	convict	convict	NN
18637	17021	21	made	make	VBD
18637	17021	22	goods	good	NNS
18637	17021	23	into	into	IN
18637	17021	24	any	any	DT
18637	17021	25	State	State	NNP
18637	17021	26	where	where	WRB
18637	17021	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17021	28	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	17021	29	,	,	,
18637	17021	30	possession	possession	NN
18637	17021	31	or	or	CC
18637	17021	32	sale	sale	NN
18637	17021	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	17021	34	a	a	DT
18637	17021	35	violation	violation	NN
18637	17021	36	of	of	IN
18637	17021	37	local	local	JJ
18637	17021	38	law	law	NN
18637	17021	39	.	.	.
18637	17022	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17022	2	199	199	CD
18637	17022	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17022	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17022	5	may	may	MD
18637	17022	6	require	require	VB
18637	17022	7	employers	employer	NNS
18637	17022	8	to	to	TO
18637	17022	9	bargain	bargain	VB
18637	17022	10	collectively	collectively	RB
18637	17022	11	with	with	IN
18637	17022	12	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	17022	13	of	of	IN
18637	17022	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17022	15	employees	employee	NNS
18637	17022	16	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	17022	17	in	in	IN
18637	17022	18	a	a	DT
18637	17022	19	manner	manner	NN
18637	17022	20	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	17022	21	by	by	IN
18637	17022	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	17022	23	,	,	,
18637	17022	24	to	to	TO
18637	17022	25	reinstate	reinstate	VB
18637	17022	26	employees	employee	NNS
18637	17022	27	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	17022	28	in	in	IN
18637	17022	29	violation	violation	NN
18637	17022	30	of	of	IN
18637	17022	31	law,[200	law,[200	NNP
18637	17022	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17022	33	and	and	CC
18637	17022	34	to	to	TO
18637	17022	35	permit	permit	VB
18637	17022	36	use	use	NN
18637	17022	37	of	of	IN
18637	17022	38	a	a	DT
18637	17022	39	company	company	NN
18637	17022	40	owned	own	VBN
18637	17022	41	hall	hall	NN
18637	17022	42	for	for	IN
18637	17022	43	union	union	NN
18637	17022	44	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	17022	45	.	.	.
18637	17023	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17023	2	201	201	CD
18637	17023	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17023	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17023	5	may	may	MD
18637	17023	6	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	17023	7	continuance	continuance	NN
18637	17023	8	of	of	IN
18637	17023	9	the	the	DT
18637	17023	10	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	17023	11	of	of	IN
18637	17023	12	employer	employer	NN
18637	17023	13	and	and	CC
18637	17023	14	employee	employee	NN
18637	17023	15	in	in	IN
18637	17023	16	the	the	DT
18637	17023	17	event	event	NN
18637	17023	18	of	of	IN
18637	17023	19	a	a	DT
18637	17023	20	strike	strike	NN
18637	17023	21	as	as	IN
18637	17023	22	a	a	DT
18637	17023	23	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	17023	24	of	of	IN
18637	17023	25	,	,	,
18637	17023	26	or	or	CC
18637	17023	27	in	in	IN
18637	17023	28	connection	connection	NN
18637	17023	29	with	with	IN
18637	17023	30	,	,	,
18637	17023	31	a	a	DT
18637	17023	32	current	current	JJ
18637	17023	33	labor	labor	NN
18637	17023	34	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	17023	35	.	.	.
18637	17024	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17024	2	202	202	CD
18637	17024	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17024	4	The	the	DT
18637	17024	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	17024	6	that	that	IN
18637	17024	7	property	property	NN
18637	17024	8	subject	subject	NN
18637	17024	9	to	to	IN
18637	17024	10	rent	rent	NN
18637	17024	11	control	control	NN
18637	17024	12	in	in	IN
18637	17024	13	time	time	NN
18637	17024	14	of	of	IN
18637	17024	15	war	war	NN
18637	17024	16	suffers	suffer	VBZ
18637	17024	17	a	a	DT
18637	17024	18	decrease	decrease	NN
18637	17024	19	in	in	IN
18637	17024	20	value	value	NN
18637	17024	21	does	do	VBZ
18637	17024	22	not	not	RB
18637	17024	23	make	make	VB
18637	17024	24	such	such	JJ
18637	17024	25	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	17024	26	offensive	offensive	JJ
18637	17024	27	to	to	IN
18637	17024	28	the	the	DT
18637	17024	29	due	due	JJ
18637	17024	30	process	process	NN
18637	17024	31	clause	clause	NN
18637	17024	32	.	.	.
18637	17025	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17025	2	203	203	CD
18637	17025	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17025	4	The	the	DT
18637	17025	5	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	17025	6	Service	Service	NNP
18637	17025	7	In	in	IN
18637	17025	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17025	9	complete	complete	JJ
18637	17025	10	control	control	NN
18637	17025	11	over	over	IN
18637	17025	12	the	the	DT
18637	17025	13	postal	postal	JJ
18637	17025	14	service	service	NN
18637	17025	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17025	16	may	may	MD
18637	17025	17	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	17025	18	lottery	lottery	NN
18637	17025	19	advertisements	advertisement	NNS
18637	17025	20	or	or	CC
18637	17025	21	any	any	DT
18637	17025	22	other	other	JJ
18637	17025	23	matter	matter	NN
18637	17025	24	objectionable	objectionable	JJ
18637	17025	25	on	on	IN
18637	17025	26	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	17025	27	of	of	IN
18637	17025	28	public	public	JJ
18637	17025	29	policy	policy	NN
18637	17025	30	.	.	.
18637	17026	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17026	2	204	204	CD
18637	17026	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17026	4	An	an	DT
18637	17026	5	order	order	NN
18637	17026	6	requiring	require	VBG
18637	17026	7	return	return	NN
18637	17026	8	to	to	IN
18637	17026	9	the	the	DT
18637	17026	10	senders	sender	NNS
18637	17026	11	of	of	IN
18637	17026	12	all	all	DT
18637	17026	13	letters	letter	NNS
18637	17026	14	addressed	address	VBD
18637	17026	15	to	to	IN
18637	17026	16	a	a	DT
18637	17026	17	concern	concern	NN
18637	17026	18	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	17026	19	in	in	IN
18637	17026	20	a	a	DT
18637	17026	21	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	17026	22	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	17026	23	,	,	,
18637	17026	24	or	or	CC
18637	17026	25	to	to	IN
18637	17026	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17026	27	officers	officer	NNS
18637	17026	28	as	as	IN
18637	17026	29	such	such	JJ
18637	17026	30	was	be	VBD
18637	17026	31	held	hold	VBN
18637	17026	32	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	17026	33	and	and	CC
18637	17026	34	valid	valid	JJ
18637	17026	35	because	because	IN
18637	17026	36	an	an	DT
18637	17026	37	order	order	NN
18637	17026	38	limited	limit	VBN
18637	17026	39	to	to	TO
18637	17026	40	matter	matter	VB
18637	17026	41	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	17026	42	connected	connect	VBN
18637	17026	43	with	with	IN
18637	17026	44	the	the	DT
18637	17026	45	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	17026	46	would	would	MD
18637	17026	47	be	be	VB
18637	17026	48	a	a	DT
18637	17026	49	practical	practical	JJ
18637	17026	50	nullity	nullity	NN
18637	17026	51	.	.	.
18637	17027	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17027	2	205	205	CD
18637	17027	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17027	4	Such	such	PDT
18637	17027	5	an	an	DT
18637	17027	6	order	order	NN
18637	17027	7	may	may	MD
18637	17027	8	be	be	VB
18637	17027	9	issued	issue	VBN
18637	17027	10	by	by	IN
18637	17027	11	the	the	DT
18637	17027	12	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
18637	17027	13	General	General	NNP
18637	17027	14	"	"	''
18637	17027	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	17027	16	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17027	17	satisfactory	satisfactory	JJ
18637	17027	18	to	to	IN
18637	17027	19	him,"[206	him,"[206	LS
18637	17027	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17027	21	but	but	CC
18637	17027	22	if	if	IN
18637	17027	23	issued	issue	VBN
18637	17027	24	under	under	IN
18637	17027	25	a	a	DT
18637	17027	26	"	"	``
18637	17027	27	mistake	mistake	NN
18637	17027	28	of	of	IN
18637	17027	29	law	law	NN
18637	17027	30	"	"	''
18637	17027	31	as	as	IN
18637	17027	32	to	to	IN
18637	17027	33	what	what	WDT
18637	17027	34	facts	fact	NNS
18637	17027	35	may	may	MD
18637	17027	36	properly	properly	RB
18637	17027	37	be	be	VB
18637	17027	38	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	17027	39	to	to	TO
18637	17027	40	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	17027	41	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	17027	42	,	,	,
18637	17027	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17027	44	will	will	MD
18637	17027	45	be	be	VB
18637	17027	46	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	17027	47	by	by	IN
18637	17027	48	the	the	DT
18637	17027	49	courts	court	NNS
18637	17027	50	.	.	.
18637	17028	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17028	2	207	207	CD
18637	17028	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17028	4	A	a	DT
18637	17028	5	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	17028	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	17028	7	revocation	revocation	NN
18637	17028	8	of	of	IN
18637	17028	9	second	second	JJ
18637	17028	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	17028	11	class	class	NN
18637	17028	12	mailing	mailing	NN
18637	17028	13	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	17028	14	by	by	IN
18637	17028	15	an	an	DT
18637	17028	16	assistant	assistant	JJ
18637	17028	17	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
18637	17028	18	General	General	NNP
18637	17028	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	17028	20	notice	notice	NN
18637	17028	21	,	,	,
18637	17028	22	at	at	IN
18637	17028	23	which	which	WDT
18637	17028	24	relator	relator	NN
18637	17028	25	was	be	VBD
18637	17028	26	heard	hear	VBN
18637	17028	27	and	and	CC
18637	17028	28	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17028	29	received	receive	VBD
18637	17028	30	was	be	VBD
18637	17028	31	due	due	JJ
18637	17028	32	process	process	NN
18637	17028	33	.	.	.
18637	17029	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17029	2	208	208	CD
18637	17029	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17029	4	Congressional	Congressional	NNP
18637	17029	5	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	17029	6	of	of	IN
18637	17029	7	Public	Public	NNP
18637	17029	8	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	17029	9	Inasmuch	Inasmuch	NNP
18637	17029	10	as	as	IN
18637	17029	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17029	12	,	,	,
18637	17029	13	in	in	IN
18637	17029	14	giving	give	VBG
18637	17029	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17029	16	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	17029	17	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	17029	18	over	over	IN
18637	17029	19	various	various	JJ
18637	17029	20	public	public	JJ
18637	17029	21	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	17029	22	,	,	,
18637	17029	23	usually	usually	RB
18637	17029	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	17029	25	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	17029	26	standards	standard	NNS
18637	17029	27	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	17029	28	identical	identical	JJ
18637	17029	29	with	with	IN
18637	17029	30	those	those	DT
18637	17029	31	by	by	IN
18637	17029	32	which	which	WDT
18637	17029	33	the	the	DT
18637	17029	34	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	17029	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17029	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	17029	37	tested	test	VBN
18637	17029	38	the	the	DT
18637	17029	39	validity	validity	NN
18637	17029	40	of	of	IN
18637	17029	41	State	State	NNP
18637	17029	42	action	action	NN
18637	17029	43	,	,	,
18637	17029	44	the	the	DT
18637	17029	45	review	review	NN
18637	17029	46	of	of	IN
18637	17029	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17029	48	orders	order	NNS
18637	17029	49	seldom	seldom	RB
18637	17029	50	has	have	VBZ
18637	17029	51	turned	turn	VBN
18637	17029	52	on	on	RP
18637	17029	53	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17029	54	issues	issue	NNS
18637	17029	55	.	.	.
18637	17030	1	In	in	IN
18637	17030	2	two	two	CD
18637	17030	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	17030	4	,	,	,
18637	17030	5	however	however	RB
18637	17030	6	,	,	,
18637	17030	7	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	17030	8	rates	rate	NNS
18637	17030	9	for	for	IN
18637	17030	10	stockyard	stockyard	NN
18637	17030	11	companies	company	NNS
18637	17030	12	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	17030	13	by	by	IN
18637	17030	14	the	the	DT
18637	17030	15	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	17030	16	of	of	IN
18637	17030	17	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	17030	18	were	be	VBD
18637	17030	19	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	17030	20	only	only	RB
18637	17030	21	after	after	IN
18637	17030	22	detailed	detailed	JJ
18637	17030	23	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	17030	24	of	of	IN
18637	17030	25	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	17030	26	items	item	NNS
18637	17030	27	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	17030	28	from	from	IN
18637	17030	29	the	the	DT
18637	17030	30	rate	rate	NN
18637	17030	31	base	base	NN
18637	17030	32	or	or	CC
18637	17030	33	from	from	IN
18637	17030	34	operating	operating	NN
18637	17030	35	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	17030	36	,	,	,
18637	17030	37	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	17030	38	on	on	IN
18637	17030	39	the	the	DT
18637	17030	40	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	17030	41	that	that	IN
18637	17030	42	error	error	VBP
18637	17030	43	with	with	IN
18637	17030	44	respect	respect	NN
18637	17030	45	to	to	IN
18637	17030	46	any	any	DT
18637	17030	47	such	such	JJ
18637	17030	48	item	item	NN
18637	17030	49	would	would	MD
18637	17030	50	render	render	VB
18637	17030	51	the	the	DT
18637	17030	52	rates	rate	NNS
18637	17030	53	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	17030	54	and	and	CC
18637	17030	55	void	void	JJ
18637	17030	56	.	.	.
18637	17031	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17031	2	209	209	CD
18637	17031	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17031	4	A	a	DT
18637	17031	5	few	few	JJ
18637	17031	6	years	year	NNS
18637	17031	7	later	later	RB
18637	17031	8	,	,	,
18637	17031	9	in	in	IN
18637	17031	10	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	17031	11	Power	Power	NNP
18637	17031	12	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	17031	13	_	_	NNP
18637	17031	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	17031	15	_	_	NNP
18637	17031	16	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	17031	17	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	17031	18	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	17031	19	Co	Co	NNP
18637	17031	20	.	.	.
18637	17031	21	,[210	,[210	NFP
18637	17031	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17031	23	the	the	DT
18637	17031	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17031	25	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	17031	26	an	an	DT
18637	17031	27	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	17031	28	different	different	JJ
18637	17031	29	approach	approach	NN
18637	17031	30	.	.	.
18637	17032	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17032	2	took	take	VBD
18637	17032	3	the	the	DT
18637	17032	4	position	position	NN
18637	17032	5	that	that	IN
18637	17032	6	the	the	DT
18637	17032	7	validity	validity	NN
18637	17032	8	of	of	IN
18637	17032	9	the	the	DT
18637	17032	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	17032	11	's	's	POS
18637	17032	12	order	order	NN
18637	17032	13	depended	depend	VBD
18637	17032	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	17032	15	whether	whether	IN
18637	17032	16	the	the	DT
18637	17032	17	impact	impact	NN
18637	17032	18	or	or	CC
18637	17032	19	total	total	JJ
18637	17032	20	effect	effect	NN
18637	17032	21	of	of	IN
18637	17032	22	the	the	DT
18637	17032	23	order	order	NN
18637	17032	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	17032	25	just	just	RB
18637	17032	26	and	and	CC
18637	17032	27	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	17032	28	,	,	,
18637	17032	29	rather	rather	RB
18637	17032	30	than	than	IN
18637	17032	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	17032	32	the	the	DT
18637	17032	33	method	method	NN
18637	17032	34	of	of	IN
18637	17032	35	computing	compute	VBG
18637	17032	36	the	the	DT
18637	17032	37	rate	rate	NN
18637	17032	38	base	base	NN
18637	17032	39	.	.	.
18637	17033	1	Rates	rate	NNS
18637	17033	2	which	which	WDT
18637	17033	3	enable	enable	VBP
18637	17033	4	a	a	DT
18637	17033	5	company	company	NN
18637	17033	6	to	to	TO
18637	17033	7	operate	operate	VB
18637	17033	8	successfully	successfully	RB
18637	17033	9	,	,	,
18637	17033	10	to	to	TO
18637	17033	11	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	17033	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17033	13	financial	financial	JJ
18637	17033	14	integrity	integrity	NN
18637	17033	15	,	,	,
18637	17033	16	to	to	TO
18637	17033	17	attract	attract	VB
18637	17033	18	capital	capital	NN
18637	17033	19	,	,	,
18637	17033	20	and	and	CC
18637	17033	21	to	to	TO
18637	17033	22	compensate	compensate	VB
18637	17033	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17033	24	investors	investor	NNS
18637	17033	25	for	for	IN
18637	17033	26	the	the	DT
18637	17033	27	risks	risk	NNS
18637	17033	28	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	17033	29	can	can	MD
18637	17033	30	not	not	RB
18637	17033	31	be	be	VB
18637	17033	32	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	17033	33	as	as	IN
18637	17033	34	unjust	unjust	JJ
18637	17033	35	and	and	CC
18637	17033	36	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	17033	37	even	even	RB
18637	17033	38	though	though	IN
18637	17033	39	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17033	40	might	may	MD
18637	17033	41	produce	produce	VB
18637	17033	42	only	only	RB
18637	17033	43	a	a	DT
18637	17033	44	meager	meager	JJ
18637	17033	45	return	return	NN
18637	17033	46	in	in	IN
18637	17033	47	a	a	DT
18637	17033	48	rate	rate	NN
18637	17033	49	base	base	NN
18637	17033	50	computed	compute	VBN
18637	17033	51	by	by	IN
18637	17033	52	the	the	DT
18637	17033	53	"	"	``
18637	17033	54	present	present	JJ
18637	17033	55	fair	fair	JJ
18637	17033	56	value	value	NN
18637	17033	57	"	"	''
18637	17033	58	method	method	NN
18637	17033	59	.	.	.
18637	17034	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17034	2	211	211	CD
18637	17034	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17034	4	Orders	order	NNS
18637	17034	5	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	17034	6	the	the	DT
18637	17034	7	form	form	NN
18637	17034	8	and	and	CC
18637	17034	9	contents	content	NNS
18637	17034	10	of	of	IN
18637	17034	11	accounts	account	NNS
18637	17034	12	kept	keep	VBN
18637	17034	13	by	by	IN
18637	17034	14	public	public	JJ
18637	17034	15	utility	utility	NN
18637	17034	16	companies,[212	companies,[212	NN
18637	17034	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17034	18	and	and	CC
18637	17034	19	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	17034	20	requiring	require	VBG
18637	17034	21	a	a	DT
18637	17034	22	private	private	JJ
18637	17034	23	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	17034	24	to	to	TO
18637	17034	25	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	17034	26	information	information	NN
18637	17034	27	for	for	IN
18637	17034	28	valuing	value	VBG
18637	17034	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17034	30	property	property	NN
18637	17034	31	to	to	IN
18637	17034	32	the	the	DT
18637	17034	33	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	17034	34	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	17034	35	Commission[213	Commission[213	NNP
18637	17034	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17034	37	have	have	VBP
18637	17034	38	been	be	VBN
18637	17034	39	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	17034	40	against	against	IN
18637	17034	41	the	the	DT
18637	17034	42	objection	objection	NN
18637	17034	43	that	that	IN
18637	17034	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17034	45	were	be	VBD
18637	17034	46	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	17034	47	and	and	CC
18637	17034	48	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	17034	49	.	.	.
18637	17035	1	An	an	DT
18637	17035	2	order	order	NN
18637	17035	3	of	of	IN
18637	17035	4	the	the	DT
18637	17035	5	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	17035	6	of	of	IN
18637	17035	7	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	17035	8	directed	direct	VBD
18637	17035	9	to	to	IN
18637	17035	10	a	a	DT
18637	17035	11	single	single	JJ
18637	17035	12	common	common	JJ
18637	17035	13	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	17035	14	by	by	IN
18637	17035	15	water	water	NN
18637	17035	16	requiring	require	VBG
18637	17035	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17035	18	to	to	TO
18637	17035	19	file	file	VB
18637	17035	20	a	a	DT
18637	17035	21	summary	summary	NN
18637	17035	22	of	of	IN
18637	17035	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17035	24	books	book	NNS
18637	17035	25	and	and	CC
18637	17035	26	records	record	NNS
18637	17035	27	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	17035	28	to	to	IN
18637	17035	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17035	30	rates	rate	NNS
18637	17035	31	was	be	VBD
18637	17035	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	17035	33	not	not	RB
18637	17035	34	to	to	TO
18637	17035	35	violate	violate	VB
18637	17035	36	the	the	DT
18637	17035	37	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	17035	38	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17035	39	.	.	.
18637	17036	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17036	2	214	214	CD
18637	17036	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17036	4	Congressional	Congressional	NNP
18637	17036	5	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	17036	6	of	of	IN
18637	17036	7	Railroads	Railroads	NNP
18637	17036	8	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
18637	17036	9	or	or	CC
18637	17036	10	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	17036	11	orders	order	NNS
18637	17036	12	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	17036	13	to	to	IN
18637	17036	14	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	17036	15	have	have	VBP
18637	17036	16	been	be	VBN
18637	17036	17	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	17036	18	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	17036	19	under	under	IN
18637	17036	20	the	the	DT
18637	17036	21	due	due	JJ
18637	17036	22	process	process	NN
18637	17036	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	17036	24	but	but	CC
18637	17036	25	seldom	seldom	RB
18637	17036	26	with	with	IN
18637	17036	27	success	success	NN
18637	17036	28	.	.	.
18637	17037	1	Orders	order	NNS
18637	17037	2	of	of	IN
18637	17037	3	the	the	DT
18637	17037	4	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	17037	5	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	17037	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	17037	7	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	17037	8	through	through	IN
18637	17037	9	routes	route	NNS
18637	17037	10	and	and	CC
18637	17037	11	joint	joint	JJ
18637	17037	12	rates	rate	NNS
18637	17037	13	have	have	VBP
18637	17037	14	been	be	VBN
18637	17037	15	sustained,[215	sustained,[215	NNP
18637	17037	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17037	17	as	as	IN
18637	17037	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	17037	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17037	20	division	division	NN
18637	17037	21	of	of	IN
18637	17037	22	joint	joint	JJ
18637	17037	23	rates	rate	NNS
18637	17037	24	to	to	TO
18637	17037	25	give	give	VB
18637	17037	26	a	a	DT
18637	17037	27	weaker	weak	JJR
18637	17037	28	group	group	NN
18637	17037	29	of	of	IN
18637	17037	30	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	17037	31	a	a	DT
18637	17037	32	greater	great	JJR
18637	17037	33	share	share	NN
18637	17037	34	of	of	IN
18637	17037	35	such	such	JJ
18637	17037	36	rates	rate	NNS
18637	17037	37	where	where	WRB
18637	17037	38	the	the	DT
18637	17037	39	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	17037	40	allotted	allot	VBD
18637	17037	41	to	to	IN
18637	17037	42	the	the	DT
18637	17037	43	stronger	strong	JJR
18637	17037	44	group	group	NN
18637	17037	45	was	be	VBD
18637	17037	46	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	17037	47	to	to	TO
18637	17037	48	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	17037	49	confiscation	confiscation	NN
18637	17037	50	.	.	.
18637	17038	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17038	2	216	216	CD
18637	17038	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17038	4	The	the	DT
18637	17038	5	recapture	recapture	NN
18637	17038	6	of	of	IN
18637	17038	7	one	one	CD
18637	17038	8	half	half	NN
18637	17038	9	of	of	IN
18637	17038	10	the	the	DT
18637	17038	11	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	17038	12	of	of	IN
18637	17038	13	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	17038	14	in	in	IN
18637	17038	15	excess	excess	NN
18637	17038	16	of	of	IN
18637	17038	17	a	a	DT
18637	17038	18	fair	fair	JJ
18637	17038	19	net	net	JJ
18637	17038	20	operating	operating	NN
18637	17038	21	income	income	NN
18637	17038	22	,	,	,
18637	17038	23	such	such	JJ
18637	17038	24	recaptured	recapture	VBN
18637	17038	25	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	17038	26	to	to	TO
18637	17038	27	be	be	VB
18637	17038	28	available	available	JJ
18637	17038	29	as	as	IN
18637	17038	30	a	a	DT
18637	17038	31	revolving	revolving	JJ
18637	17038	32	fund	fund	NN
18637	17038	33	for	for	IN
18637	17038	34	loans	loan	NNS
18637	17038	35	to	to	IN
18637	17038	36	weaker	weak	JJR
18637	17038	37	roads	road	NNS
18637	17038	38	,	,	,
18637	17038	39	was	be	VBD
18637	17038	40	held	hold	VBN
18637	17038	41	valid	valid	JJ
18637	17038	42	on	on	IN
18637	17038	43	the	the	DT
18637	17038	44	ground	ground	NN
18637	17038	45	that	that	IN
18637	17038	46	any	any	DT
18637	17038	47	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	17038	48	earning	earn	VBG
18637	17038	49	an	an	DT
18637	17038	50	excess	excess	NN
18637	17038	51	held	hold	VBN
18637	17038	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17038	53	as	as	IN
18637	17038	54	trustee	trustee	NN
18637	17038	55	.	.	.
18637	17039	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17039	2	217	217	CD
18637	17039	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17039	4	An	an	DT
18637	17039	5	order	order	NN
18637	17039	6	enjoining	enjoin	VBG
18637	17039	7	certain	certain	JJ
18637	17039	8	steam	steam	NN
18637	17039	9	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	17039	10	from	from	IN
18637	17039	11	discriminating	discriminate	VBG
18637	17039	12	against	against	IN
18637	17039	13	an	an	DT
18637	17039	14	electric	electric	JJ
18637	17039	15	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	17039	16	by	by	IN
18637	17039	17	denying	deny	VBG
18637	17039	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17039	19	reciprocal	reciprocal	JJ
18637	17039	20	switching	switching	NN
18637	17039	21	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	17039	22	did	do	VBD
18637	17039	23	not	not	RB
18637	17039	24	violate	violate	VB
18637	17039	25	the	the	DT
18637	17039	26	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	17039	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17039	28	even	even	RB
18637	17039	29	though	though	IN
18637	17039	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17039	31	practical	practical	JJ
18637	17039	32	effect	effect	NN
18637	17039	33	was	be	VBD
18637	17039	34	to	to	TO
18637	17039	35	admit	admit	VB
18637	17039	36	the	the	DT
18637	17039	37	electric	electric	JJ
18637	17039	38	road	road	NN
18637	17039	39	to	to	IN
18637	17039	40	a	a	DT
18637	17039	41	part	part	NN
18637	17039	42	of	of	IN
18637	17039	43	the	the	DT
18637	17039	44	business	business	NN
18637	17039	45	being	be	VBG
18637	17039	46	adequately	adequately	RB
18637	17039	47	handled	handle	VBN
18637	17039	48	by	by	IN
18637	17039	49	the	the	DT
18637	17039	50	steam	steam	NN
18637	17039	51	roads	road	NNS
18637	17039	52	.	.	.
18637	17040	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17040	2	218	218	CD
18637	17040	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17040	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	17040	5	,	,	,
18637	17040	6	the	the	DT
18637	17040	7	fact	fact	NN
18637	17040	8	that	that	IN
18637	17040	9	a	a	DT
18637	17040	10	rule	rule	NN
18637	17040	11	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	17040	12	the	the	DT
18637	17040	13	allotment	allotment	NN
18637	17040	14	of	of	IN
18637	17040	15	coal	coal	NN
18637	17040	16	cars	car	NNS
18637	17040	17	operated	operate	VBN
18637	17040	18	to	to	TO
18637	17040	19	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	17040	20	the	the	DT
18637	17040	21	use	use	NN
18637	17040	22	of	of	IN
18637	17040	23	private	private	JJ
18637	17040	24	cars	car	NNS
18637	17040	25	did	do	VBD
18637	17040	26	not	not	RB
18637	17040	27	amount	amount	VB
18637	17040	28	to	to	IN
18637	17040	29	a	a	DT
18637	17040	30	taking	taking	NN
18637	17040	31	of	of	IN
18637	17040	32	property	property	NN
18637	17040	33	.	.	.
18637	17041	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17041	2	219	219	CD
18637	17041	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17041	4	Railroad	railroad	NN
18637	17041	5	companies	company	NNS
18637	17041	6	were	be	VBD
18637	17041	7	not	not	RB
18637	17041	8	denied	deny	VBN
18637	17041	9	due	due	JJ
18637	17041	10	process	process	NN
18637	17041	11	of	of	IN
18637	17041	12	law	law	NN
18637	17041	13	by	by	IN
18637	17041	14	a	a	DT
18637	17041	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	17041	16	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	17041	17	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17041	18	to	to	TO
18637	17041	19	transport	transport	VB
18637	17041	20	in	in	IN
18637	17041	21	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	17041	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	17041	23	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	17041	24	which	which	WDT
18637	17041	25	have	have	VBP
18637	17041	26	been	be	VBN
18637	17041	27	manufactured	manufacture	VBN
18637	17041	28	,	,	,
18637	17041	29	mined	mine	VBN
18637	17041	30	or	or	CC
18637	17041	31	produced	produce	VBN
18637	17041	32	by	by	IN
18637	17041	33	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17041	34	.	.	.
18637	17042	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17042	2	220	220	CD
18637	17042	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17042	4	An	an	DT
18637	17042	5	order	order	NN
18637	17042	6	approving	approve	VBG
18637	17042	7	a	a	DT
18637	17042	8	lease	lease	NN
18637	17042	9	of	of	IN
18637	17042	10	one	one	CD
18637	17042	11	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	17042	12	by	by	IN
18637	17042	13	another	another	DT
18637	17042	14	,	,	,
18637	17042	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	17042	16	condition	condition	NN
18637	17042	17	that	that	IN
18637	17042	18	displaced	displace	VBD
18637	17042	19	employees	employee	NNS
18637	17042	20	of	of	IN
18637	17042	21	the	the	DT
18637	17042	22	lessor	lessor	NN
18637	17042	23	should	should	MD
18637	17042	24	receive	receive	VB
18637	17042	25	partial	partial	JJ
18637	17042	26	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17042	27	for	for	IN
18637	17042	28	the	the	DT
18637	17042	29	loss	loss	NN
18637	17042	30	suffered	suffer	VBN
18637	17042	31	by	by	IN
18637	17042	32	reason	reason	NN
18637	17042	33	of	of	IN
18637	17042	34	the	the	DT
18637	17042	35	lease[221	lease[221	NNP
18637	17042	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17042	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	17042	38	consonant	consonant	JJ
18637	17042	39	with	with	IN
18637	17042	40	due	due	JJ
18637	17042	41	process	process	NN
18637	17042	42	of	of	IN
18637	17042	43	law	law	NN
18637	17042	44	.	.	.
18637	17043	1	A	a	DT
18637	17043	2	law	law	NN
18637	17043	3	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	17043	4	the	the	DT
18637	17043	5	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	17043	6	of	of	IN
18637	17043	7	free	free	JJ
18637	17043	8	passes	pass	NNS
18637	17043	9	was	be	VBD
18637	17043	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	17043	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17043	12	even	even	RB
18637	17043	13	as	as	IN
18637	17043	14	applied	apply	VBN
18637	17043	15	to	to	IN
18637	17043	16	abolish	abolish	VB
18637	17043	17	rights	right	NNS
18637	17043	18	created	create	VBN
18637	17043	19	by	by	IN
18637	17043	20	a	a	DT
18637	17043	21	prior	prior	JJ
18637	17043	22	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	17043	23	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	17043	24	the	the	DT
18637	17043	25	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	17043	26	bound	bind	VBD
18637	17043	27	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17043	28	to	to	TO
18637	17043	29	issue	issue	VB
18637	17043	30	such	such	JJ
18637	17043	31	passes	pass	VBZ
18637	17043	32	annually	annually	RB
18637	17043	33	for	for	IN
18637	17043	34	life	life	NN
18637	17043	35	,	,	,
18637	17043	36	in	in	IN
18637	17043	37	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	17043	38	of	of	IN
18637	17043	39	a	a	DT
18637	17043	40	claim	claim	NN
18637	17043	41	for	for	IN
18637	17043	42	personal	personal	JJ
18637	17043	43	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	17043	44	.	.	.
18637	17044	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17044	2	222	222	CD
18637	17044	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17044	4	Occasionally	occasionally	RB
18637	17044	5	,	,	,
18637	17044	6	however	however	RB
18637	17044	7	,	,	,
18637	17044	8	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	17044	9	action	action	NN
18637	17044	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	17044	11	been	be	VBN
18637	17044	12	held	hold	VBN
18637	17044	13	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	17044	14	under	under	IN
18637	17044	15	the	the	DT
18637	17044	16	due	due	JJ
18637	17044	17	process	process	NN
18637	17044	18	clause	clause	NN
18637	17044	19	.	.	.
18637	17045	1	An	an	DT
18637	17045	2	order	order	NN
18637	17045	3	issued	issue	VBN
18637	17045	4	by	by	IN
18637	17045	5	the	the	DT
18637	17045	6	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	17045	7	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	17045	8	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	17045	9	relieving	relieve	VBG
18637	17045	10	short	short	JJ
18637	17045	11	line	line	NN
18637	17045	12	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	17045	13	from	from	IN
18637	17045	14	the	the	DT
18637	17045	15	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	17045	16	to	to	TO
18637	17045	17	pay	pay	VB
18637	17045	18	the	the	DT
18637	17045	19	usual	usual	JJ
18637	17045	20	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	17045	21	sum	sum	NN
18637	17045	22	per	per	IN
18637	17045	23	day	day	NN
18637	17045	24	rental	rental	NN
18637	17045	25	for	for	IN
18637	17045	26	cars	car	NNS
18637	17045	27	used	use	VBN
18637	17045	28	on	on	IN
18637	17045	29	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	17045	30	roads	road	NNS
18637	17045	31	,	,	,
18637	17045	32	for	for	IN
18637	17045	33	a	a	DT
18637	17045	34	space	space	NN
18637	17045	35	of	of	IN
18637	17045	36	two	two	CD
18637	17045	37	days	day	NNS
18637	17045	38	was	be	VBD
18637	17045	39	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	17045	40	and	and	CC
18637	17045	41	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	17045	42	.	.	.
18637	17046	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17046	2	223	223	CD
18637	17046	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17046	4	A	a	DT
18637	17046	5	retirement	retirement	NN
18637	17046	6	act	act	NN
18637	17046	7	which	which	WDT
18637	17046	8	made	make	VBD
18637	17046	9	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	17046	10	for	for	IN
18637	17046	11	pensions	pension	NNS
18637	17046	12	all	all	DT
18637	17046	13	persons	person	NNS
18637	17046	14	who	who	WP
18637	17046	15	had	have	VBD
18637	17046	16	been	be	VBN
18637	17046	17	in	in	IN
18637	17046	18	the	the	DT
18637	17046	19	service	service	NN
18637	17046	20	of	of	IN
18637	17046	21	any	any	DT
18637	17046	22	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	17046	23	within	within	IN
18637	17046	24	one	one	CD
18637	17046	25	year	year	NN
18637	17046	26	prior	prior	RB
18637	17046	27	to	to	IN
18637	17046	28	the	the	DT
18637	17046	29	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	17046	30	of	of	IN
18637	17046	31	the	the	DT
18637	17046	32	law	law	NN
18637	17046	33	,	,	,
18637	17046	34	counted	count	VBN
18637	17046	35	past	past	JJ
18637	17046	36	unconnected	unconnected	JJ
18637	17046	37	service	service	NN
18637	17046	38	of	of	IN
18637	17046	39	an	an	DT
18637	17046	40	employee	employee	NN
18637	17046	41	toward	toward	IN
18637	17046	42	the	the	DT
18637	17046	43	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	17046	44	for	for	IN
18637	17046	45	a	a	DT
18637	17046	46	pension	pension	NN
18637	17046	47	without	without	IN
18637	17046	48	any	any	DT
18637	17046	49	contribution	contribution	NN
18637	17046	50	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	17046	51	,	,	,
18637	17046	52	and	and	CC
18637	17046	53	treated	treat	VBD
18637	17046	54	all	all	DT
18637	17046	55	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	17046	56	as	as	IN
18637	17046	57	a	a	DT
18637	17046	58	single	single	JJ
18637	17046	59	employer	employer	NN
18637	17046	60	and	and	CC
18637	17046	61	pooled	pool	VBD
18637	17046	62	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17046	63	assets	asset	NNS
18637	17046	64	,	,	,
18637	17046	65	without	without	IN
18637	17046	66	regard	regard	NN
18637	17046	67	to	to	IN
18637	17046	68	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17046	69	individual	individual	JJ
18637	17046	70	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	17046	71	,	,	,
18637	17046	72	was	be	VBD
18637	17046	73	held	hold	VBN
18637	17046	74	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	17046	75	.	.	.
18637	17047	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17047	2	224	224	CD
18637	17047	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17047	4	TAXATION	TAXATION	NNP
18637	17047	5	In	in	IN
18637	17047	6	laying	lay	VBG
18637	17047	7	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	17047	8	,	,	,
18637	17047	9	the	the	DT
18637	17047	10	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	17047	11	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17047	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	17047	13	less	less	RBR
18637	17047	14	narrowly	narrowly	RB
18637	17047	15	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	17047	16	by	by	IN
18637	17047	17	the	the	DT
18637	17047	18	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	17047	19	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17047	20	than	than	IN
18637	17047	21	are	be	VBP
18637	17047	22	the	the	DT
18637	17047	23	States	States	NNP
18637	17047	24	by	by	IN
18637	17047	25	the	the	DT
18637	17047	26	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	17047	27	.	.	.
18637	17048	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17048	2	may	may	MD
18637	17048	3	tax	tax	VB
18637	17048	4	property	property	NN
18637	17048	5	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	17048	6	to	to	IN
18637	17048	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17048	8	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	17048	9	,	,	,
18637	17048	10	even	even	RB
18637	17048	11	if	if	IN
18637	17048	12	such	such	JJ
18637	17048	13	property	property	NN
18637	17048	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	17048	15	never	never	RB
18637	17048	16	situated	situate	VBN
18637	17048	17	within	within	IN
18637	17048	18	the	the	DT
18637	17048	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	17048	20	of	of	IN
18637	17048	21	the	the	DT
18637	17048	22	United	United	NNP
18637	17048	23	States,[225	States,[225	NNP
18637	17048	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17048	25	or	or	CC
18637	17048	26	the	the	DT
18637	17048	27	income	income	NN
18637	17048	28	of	of	IN
18637	17048	29	a	a	DT
18637	17048	30	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	17048	31	resident	resident	NN
18637	17048	32	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	17048	33	,	,	,
18637	17048	34	which	which	WDT
18637	17048	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	17048	36	derived	derive	VBN
18637	17048	37	from	from	IN
18637	17048	38	property	property	NN
18637	17048	39	located	locate	VBN
18637	17048	40	at	at	IN
18637	17048	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17048	42	residence	residence	NN
18637	17048	43	.	.	.
18637	17049	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17049	2	226	226	CD
18637	17049	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17049	4	The	the	DT
18637	17049	5	difference	difference	NN
18637	17049	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	17049	7	explained	explain	VBN
18637	17049	8	by	by	IN
18637	17049	9	the	the	DT
18637	17049	10	fact	fact	NN
18637	17049	11	that	that	IN
18637	17049	12	the	the	DT
18637	17049	13	protection	protection	NN
18637	17049	14	of	of	IN
18637	17049	15	the	the	DT
18637	17049	16	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	17049	17	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17049	18	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	17049	19	the	the	DT
18637	17049	20	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	17049	21	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	17049	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17049	23	goes	go	VBZ
18637	17049	24	,	,	,
18637	17049	25	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	17049	26	the	the	DT
18637	17049	27	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	17049	28	of	of	IN
18637	17049	29	State	State	NNP
18637	17049	30	government	government	NN
18637	17049	31	accrue	accrue	NN
18637	17049	32	only	only	RB
18637	17049	33	to	to	IN
18637	17049	34	persons	person	NNS
18637	17049	35	and	and	CC
18637	17049	36	property	property	NN
18637	17049	37	within	within	IN
18637	17049	38	the	the	DT
18637	17049	39	State	State	NNP
18637	17049	40	's	's	POS
18637	17049	41	borders	border	NNS
18637	17049	42	.	.	.
18637	17050	1	The	the	DT
18637	17050	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	17050	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17050	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	17050	5	said	say	VBN
18637	17050	6	that	that	IN
18637	17050	7	,	,	,
18637	17050	8	in	in	IN
18637	17050	9	the	the	DT
18637	17050	10	absence	absence	NN
18637	17050	11	of	of	IN
18637	17050	12	an	an	DT
18637	17050	13	equal	equal	JJ
18637	17050	14	protection	protection	NN
18637	17050	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	17050	16	,	,	,
18637	17050	17	"	"	''
18637	17050	18	a	a	DT
18637	17050	19	claim	claim	NN
18637	17050	20	of	of	IN
18637	17050	21	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	17050	22	classification	classification	NN
18637	17050	23	or	or	CC
18637	17050	24	inequality	inequality	NN
18637	17050	25	in	in	IN
18637	17050	26	the	the	DT
18637	17050	27	incidence	incidence	NN
18637	17050	28	or	or	CC
18637	17050	29	application	application	NN
18637	17050	30	of	of	IN
18637	17050	31	a	a	DT
18637	17050	32	tax	tax	NN
18637	17050	33	raises	raise	VBZ
18637	17050	34	no	no	DT
18637	17050	35	question	question	NN
18637	17050	36	under	under	IN
18637	17050	37	the	the	DT
18637	17050	38	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	17050	39	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17050	40	,	,	,
18637	17050	41	*	*	NFP
18637	17050	42	*	*	NFP
18637	17050	43	*	*	NFP
18637	17050	44	"	"	''
18637	17050	45	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17050	46	227	227	CD
18637	17050	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17050	48	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17050	49	has	have	VBZ
18637	17050	50	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	17050	51	,	,	,
18637	17050	52	over	over	IN
18637	17050	53	charges	charge	NNS
18637	17050	54	of	of	IN
18637	17050	55	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	17050	56	differentiation	differentiation	NN
18637	17050	57	between	between	IN
18637	17050	58	persons	person	NNS
18637	17050	59	,	,	,
18637	17050	60	a	a	DT
18637	17050	61	graduated	graduate	VBN
18637	17050	62	income	income	NN
18637	17050	63	tax;[228	tax;[228	NNP
18637	17050	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17050	65	a	a	DT
18637	17050	66	higher	high	JJR
18637	17050	67	tax	tax	NN
18637	17050	68	on	on	IN
18637	17050	69	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
18637	17050	70	than	than	IN
18637	17050	71	on	on	IN
18637	17050	72	butter;[229	butter;[229	NNPS
18637	17050	73	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17050	74	an	an	DT
18637	17050	75	excise	excise	NN
18637	17050	76	tax	tax	NN
18637	17050	77	on	on	IN
18637	17050	78	"	"	``
18637	17050	79	puts	put	NNS
18637	17050	80	"	"	''
18637	17050	81	but	but	CC
18637	17050	82	not	not	RB
18637	17050	83	on	on	IN
18637	17050	84	"	"	``
18637	17050	85	calls";[230	calls";[230	NNP
18637	17050	86	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17050	87	a	a	DT
18637	17050	88	tax	tax	NN
18637	17050	89	on	on	IN
18637	17050	90	the	the	DT
18637	17050	91	income	income	NN
18637	17050	92	of	of	IN
18637	17050	93	businesses	business	NNS
18637	17050	94	operated	operate	VBN
18637	17050	95	by	by	IN
18637	17050	96	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	17050	97	but	but	CC
18637	17050	98	not	not	RB
18637	17050	99	on	on	IN
18637	17050	100	similar	similar	JJ
18637	17050	101	enterprises	enterprise	NNS
18637	17050	102	carried	carry	VBN
18637	17050	103	on	on	RP
18637	17050	104	by	by	IN
18637	17050	105	individuals;[231	individuals;[231	NNPS
18637	17050	106	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17050	107	an	an	DT
18637	17050	108	income	income	NN
18637	17050	109	tax	tax	NN
18637	17050	110	on	on	IN
18637	17050	111	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	17050	112	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	17050	113	,	,	,
18637	17050	114	based	base	VBN
18637	17050	115	on	on	IN
18637	17050	116	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17050	117	income	income	NN
18637	17050	118	from	from	IN
18637	17050	119	sources	source	NNS
18637	17050	120	within	within	IN
18637	17050	121	the	the	DT
18637	17050	122	United	United	NNP
18637	17050	123	States	States	NNP
18637	17050	124	,	,	,
18637	17050	125	while	while	IN
18637	17050	126	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	17050	127	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	17050	128	are	be	VBP
18637	17050	129	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	17050	130	on	on	IN
18637	17050	131	income	income	NN
18637	17050	132	from	from	IN
18637	17050	133	all	all	DT
18637	17050	134	sources;[232	sources;[232	NNS
18637	17050	135	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17050	136	a	a	DT
18637	17050	137	tax	tax	NN
18637	17050	138	on	on	IN
18637	17050	139	foreign	foreign	NN
18637	17050	140	-	-	HYPH
18637	17050	141	built	build	VBN
18637	17050	142	but	but	CC
18637	17050	143	not	not	RB
18637	17050	144	upon	upon	IN
18637	17050	145	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	17050	146	yachts;[233	yachts;[233	NN
18637	17050	147	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17050	148	a	a	DT
18637	17050	149	tax	tax	NN
18637	17050	150	on	on	IN
18637	17050	151	employers	employer	NNS
18637	17050	152	of	of	IN
18637	17050	153	eight	eight	CD
18637	17050	154	or	or	CC
18637	17050	155	more	more	JJR
18637	17050	156	persons	person	NNS
18637	17050	157	,	,	,
18637	17050	158	with	with	IN
18637	17050	159	exemptions	exemption	NNS
18637	17050	160	for	for	IN
18637	17050	161	agricultural	agricultural	JJ
18637	17050	162	labor	labor	NN
18637	17050	163	and	and	CC
18637	17050	164	domestic	domestic	NN
18637	17050	165	service;[234	service;[234	:
18637	17050	166	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17050	167	a	a	DT
18637	17050	168	gift	gift	NN
18637	17050	169	tax	tax	NN
18637	17050	170	law	law	NN
18637	17050	171	embodying	embody	VBG
18637	17050	172	a	a	DT
18637	17050	173	plan	plan	NN
18637	17050	174	of	of	IN
18637	17050	175	graduations	graduation	NNS
18637	17050	176	and	and	CC
18637	17050	177	exemptions	exemption	NNS
18637	17050	178	under	under	IN
18637	17050	179	which	which	WDT
18637	17050	180	donors	donor	NNS
18637	17050	181	of	of	IN
18637	17050	182	the	the	DT
18637	17050	183	same	same	JJ
18637	17050	184	amount	amount	NN
18637	17050	185	might	may	MD
18637	17050	186	be	be	VB
18637	17050	187	liable	liable	JJ
18637	17050	188	for	for	IN
18637	17050	189	different	different	JJ
18637	17050	190	sums;[235	sums;[235	:
18637	17050	191	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17050	192	an	an	DT
18637	17050	193	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	17050	194	statute	statute	NN
18637	17050	195	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	17050	196	license	license	NN
18637	17050	197	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	17050	198	only	only	RB
18637	17050	199	on	on	IN
18637	17050	200	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	17050	201	fisherman;[236	fisherman;[236	NNPS
18637	17050	202	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17050	203	an	an	DT
18637	17050	204	act	act	NN
18637	17050	205	which	which	WDT
18637	17050	206	taxed	tax	VBD
18637	17050	207	the	the	DT
18637	17050	208	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	17050	209	of	of	IN
18637	17050	210	oil	oil	NN
18637	17050	211	and	and	CC
18637	17050	212	fertilizer	fertilizer	NN
18637	17050	213	from	from	IN
18637	17050	214	herring	herre	VBG
18637	17050	215	at	at	IN
18637	17050	216	a	a	DT
18637	17050	217	higher	high	JJR
18637	17050	218	rate	rate	NN
18637	17050	219	than	than	IN
18637	17050	220	similar	similar	JJ
18637	17050	221	processing	processing	NN
18637	17050	222	of	of	IN
18637	17050	223	other	other	JJ
18637	17050	224	fish	fish	NN
18637	17050	225	or	or	CC
18637	17050	226	fish	fish	NN
18637	17050	227	offal;[237	offal;[237	LS
18637	17050	228	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17050	229	an	an	DT
18637	17050	230	excess	excess	JJ
18637	17050	231	profits	profit	NNS
18637	17050	232	tax	tax	NN
18637	17050	233	which	which	WDT
18637	17050	234	defined	define	VBD
18637	17050	235	"	"	``
18637	17050	236	invested	invest	VBN
18637	17050	237	capital	capital	NN
18637	17050	238	"	"	''
18637	17050	239	with	with	IN
18637	17050	240	reference	reference	NN
18637	17050	241	to	to	IN
18637	17050	242	the	the	DT
18637	17050	243	original	original	JJ
18637	17050	244	cost	cost	NN
18637	17050	245	of	of	IN
18637	17050	246	the	the	DT
18637	17050	247	property	property	NN
18637	17050	248	rather	rather	RB
18637	17050	249	than	than	IN
18637	17050	250	to	to	IN
18637	17050	251	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17050	252	present	present	JJ
18637	17050	253	value;[238	value;[238	NNS
18637	17050	254	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17050	255	and	and	CC
18637	17050	256	an	an	DT
18637	17050	257	undistributed	undistributed	JJ
18637	17050	258	profits	profit	NNS
18637	17050	259	tax	tax	NN
18637	17050	260	in	in	IN
18637	17050	261	the	the	DT
18637	17050	262	computation	computation	NN
18637	17050	263	of	of	IN
18637	17050	264	which	which	WDT
18637	17050	265	special	special	JJ
18637	17050	266	credits	credit	NNS
18637	17050	267	were	be	VBD
18637	17050	268	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	17050	269	to	to	IN
18637	17050	270	certain	certain	JJ
18637	17050	271	taxpayers;[239	taxpayers;[239	:
18637	17050	272	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17050	273	an	an	DT
18637	17050	274	estate	estate	NN
18637	17050	275	tax	tax	NN
18637	17050	276	upon	upon	IN
18637	17050	277	the	the	DT
18637	17050	278	estate	estate	NN
18637	17050	279	of	of	IN
18637	17050	280	a	a	DT
18637	17050	281	deceased	deceased	JJ
18637	17050	282	spouse	spouse	NN
18637	17050	283	in	in	IN
18637	17050	284	respect	respect	NN
18637	17050	285	of	of	IN
18637	17050	286	the	the	DT
18637	17050	287	moiety	moiety	NN
18637	17050	288	of	of	IN
18637	17050	289	the	the	DT
18637	17050	290	surviving	survive	VBG
18637	17050	291	spouse	spouse	NN
18637	17050	292	where	where	WRB
18637	17050	293	the	the	DT
18637	17050	294	effect	effect	NN
18637	17050	295	of	of	IN
18637	17050	296	the	the	DT
18637	17050	297	dissolution	dissolution	NN
18637	17050	298	of	of	IN
18637	17050	299	the	the	DT
18637	17050	300	community	community	NN
18637	17050	301	is	be	VBZ
18637	17050	302	to	to	TO
18637	17050	303	enhance	enhance	VB
18637	17050	304	the	the	DT
18637	17050	305	value	value	NN
18637	17050	306	of	of	IN
18637	17050	307	the	the	DT
18637	17050	308	survivor	survivor	NN
18637	17050	309	's	's	POS
18637	17050	310	moiety	moiety	NN
18637	17050	311	.	.	.
18637	17051	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17051	2	240	240	CD
18637	17051	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17051	4	Retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	17051	5	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	17051	6	A	a	DT
18637	17051	7	gift	gift	NN
18637	17051	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	17051	9	can	can	MD
18637	17051	10	not	not	RB
18637	17051	11	be	be	VB
18637	17051	12	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	17051	13	on	on	IN
18637	17051	14	gifts	gift	NNS
18637	17051	15	consummated	consummate	VBN
18637	17051	16	before	before	IN
18637	17051	17	the	the	DT
18637	17051	18	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	17051	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	17051	20	was	be	VBD
18637	17051	21	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	17051	22	.	.	.
18637	17052	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17052	2	241	241	CD
18637	17052	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17052	4	A	a	DT
18637	17052	5	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	17052	6	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	17052	7	that	that	WDT
18637	17052	8	gifts	gift	NNS
18637	17052	9	made	make	VBN
18637	17052	10	within	within	IN
18637	17052	11	two	two	CD
18637	17052	12	years	year	NNS
18637	17052	13	of	of	IN
18637	17052	14	death	death	NN
18637	17052	15	were	be	VBD
18637	17052	16	made	make	VBN
18637	17052	17	in	in	IN
18637	17052	18	contemplation	contemplation	NN
18637	17052	19	of	of	IN
18637	17052	20	death	death	NN
18637	17052	21	was	be	VBD
18637	17052	22	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	17052	23	as	as	IN
18637	17052	24	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	17052	25	and	and	CC
18637	17052	26	capricious	capricious	JJ
18637	17052	27	even	even	RB
18637	17052	28	with	with	IN
18637	17052	29	respect	respect	NN
18637	17052	30	to	to	IN
18637	17052	31	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	17052	32	transfers	transfer	NNS
18637	17052	33	.	.	.
18637	17053	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17053	2	242	242	CD
18637	17053	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17053	4	A	a	DT
18637	17053	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	17053	6	may	may	MD
18637	17053	7	be	be	VB
18637	17053	8	made	make	VBN
18637	17053	9	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	17053	10	for	for	IN
18637	17053	11	a	a	DT
18637	17053	12	short	short	JJ
18637	17053	13	period	period	NN
18637	17053	14	to	to	TO
18637	17053	15	include	include	VB
18637	17053	16	profits	profit	NNS
18637	17053	17	made	make	VBN
18637	17053	18	while	while	IN
18637	17053	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17053	20	was	be	VBD
18637	17053	21	in	in	IN
18637	17053	22	process	process	NN
18637	17053	23	of	of	IN
18637	17053	24	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	17053	25	.	.	.
18637	17054	1	A	a	DT
18637	17054	2	special	special	JJ
18637	17054	3	income	income	NN
18637	17054	4	tax	tax	NN
18637	17054	5	on	on	IN
18637	17054	6	profits	profit	NNS
18637	17054	7	realized	realize	VBN
18637	17054	8	by	by	IN
18637	17054	9	the	the	DT
18637	17054	10	sale	sale	NN
18637	17054	11	of	of	IN
18637	17054	12	silver	silver	NN
18637	17054	13	,	,	,
18637	17054	14	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	17054	15	for	for	IN
18637	17054	16	35	35	CD
18637	17054	17	days	day	NNS
18637	17054	18	,	,	,
18637	17054	19	which	which	WDT
18637	17054	20	was	be	VBD
18637	17054	21	approximately	approximately	RB
18637	17054	22	the	the	DT
18637	17054	23	period	period	NN
18637	17054	24	during	during	IN
18637	17054	25	which	which	WDT
18637	17054	26	the	the	DT
18637	17054	27	silver	silver	JJ
18637	17054	28	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	17054	29	bill	bill	NN
18637	17054	30	was	be	VBD
18637	17054	31	before	before	IN
18637	17054	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17054	33	,	,	,
18637	17054	34	was	be	VBD
18637	17054	35	held	hold	VBN
18637	17054	36	valid	valid	JJ
18637	17054	37	.	.	.
18637	17055	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17055	2	243	243	CD
18637	17055	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17055	4	An	an	DT
18637	17055	5	income	income	NN
18637	17055	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	17055	7	law	law	NN
18637	17055	8	,	,	,
18637	17055	9	made	make	VBN
18637	17055	10	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	17055	11	to	to	IN
18637	17055	12	the	the	DT
18637	17055	13	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	17055	14	of	of	IN
18637	17055	15	the	the	DT
18637	17055	16	calendar	calendar	NN
18637	17055	17	year	year	NN
18637	17055	18	in	in	IN
18637	17055	19	which	which	WDT
18637	17055	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17055	21	was	be	VBD
18637	17055	22	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	17055	23	,	,	,
18637	17055	24	was	be	VBD
18637	17055	25	found	find	VBN
18637	17055	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17055	27	as	as	IN
18637	17055	28	applied	apply	VBN
18637	17055	29	to	to	IN
18637	17055	30	the	the	DT
18637	17055	31	gain	gain	NN
18637	17055	32	from	from	IN
18637	17055	33	the	the	DT
18637	17055	34	sale	sale	NN
18637	17055	35	,	,	,
18637	17055	36	shortly	shortly	RB
18637	17055	37	before	before	IN
18637	17055	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17055	39	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	17055	40	,	,	,
18637	17055	41	of	of	IN
18637	17055	42	property	property	NN
18637	17055	43	received	receive	VBN
18637	17055	44	as	as	IN
18637	17055	45	a	a	DT
18637	17055	46	gift	gift	NN
18637	17055	47	during	during	IN
18637	17055	48	the	the	DT
18637	17055	49	year	year	NN
18637	17055	50	.	.	.
18637	17056	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17056	2	244	244	CD
18637	17056	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17056	4	Retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	17056	5	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	17056	6	of	of	IN
18637	17056	7	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	17056	8	for	for	IN
18637	17056	9	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	17056	10	or	or	CC
18637	17056	11	negligence,[245	negligence,[245	NN
18637	17056	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17056	13	or	or	CC
18637	17056	14	of	of	IN
18637	17056	15	an	an	DT
18637	17056	16	additional	additional	JJ
18637	17056	17	tax	tax	NN
18637	17056	18	on	on	IN
18637	17056	19	the	the	DT
18637	17056	20	income	income	NN
18637	17056	21	of	of	IN
18637	17056	22	a	a	DT
18637	17056	23	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	17056	24	used	use	VBN
18637	17056	25	to	to	TO
18637	17056	26	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	17056	27	a	a	DT
18637	17056	28	surtax	surtax	NN
18637	17056	29	on	on	IN
18637	17056	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17056	31	shareholders,[246	shareholders,[246	NNP
18637	17056	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17056	33	does	do	VBZ
18637	17056	34	not	not	RB
18637	17056	35	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	17056	36	the	the	DT
18637	17056	37	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	17056	38	of	of	IN
18637	17056	39	property	property	NN
18637	17056	40	without	without	IN
18637	17056	41	due	due	JJ
18637	17056	42	process	process	NN
18637	17056	43	of	of	IN
18637	17056	44	law	law	NN
18637	17056	45	.	.	.
18637	17057	1	An	an	DT
18637	17057	2	additional	additional	JJ
18637	17057	3	excise	excise	NN
18637	17057	4	tax	tax	NN
18637	17057	5	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	17057	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	17057	7	property	property	NN
18637	17057	8	still	still	RB
18637	17057	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	17057	10	for	for	IN
18637	17057	11	sale	sale	NN
18637	17057	12	,	,	,
18637	17057	13	after	after	IN
18637	17057	14	one	one	CD
18637	17057	15	excise	excise	NN
18637	17057	16	tax	tax	NN
18637	17057	17	had	have	VBD
18637	17057	18	been	be	VBN
18637	17057	19	paid	pay	VBN
18637	17057	20	by	by	IN
18637	17057	21	a	a	DT
18637	17057	22	previous	previous	JJ
18637	17057	23	owner	owner	NN
18637	17057	24	,	,	,
18637	17057	25	does	do	VBZ
18637	17057	26	not	not	RB
18637	17057	27	violate	violate	VB
18637	17057	28	the	the	DT
18637	17057	29	due	due	JJ
18637	17057	30	process	process	NN
18637	17057	31	clause	clause	NN
18637	17057	32	.	.	.
18637	17058	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17058	2	247	247	CD
18637	17058	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17058	4	A	a	DT
18637	17058	5	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	17058	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	17058	7	measured	measure	VBN
18637	17058	8	in	in	IN
18637	17058	9	part	part	NN
18637	17058	10	by	by	IN
18637	17058	11	the	the	DT
18637	17058	12	value	value	NN
18637	17058	13	of	of	IN
18637	17058	14	property	property	NN
18637	17058	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	17058	16	jointly	jointly	RB
18637	17058	17	by	by	IN
18637	17058	18	a	a	DT
18637	17058	19	husband	husband	NN
18637	17058	20	and	and	CC
18637	17058	21	wife	wife	NN
18637	17058	22	,	,	,
18637	17058	23	including	include	VBG
18637	17058	24	that	that	DT
18637	17058	25	which	which	WDT
18637	17058	26	comes	come	VBZ
18637	17058	27	to	to	IN
18637	17058	28	the	the	DT
18637	17058	29	joint	joint	JJ
18637	17058	30	tenancy	tenancy	NN
18637	17058	31	as	as	IN
18637	17058	32	a	a	DT
18637	17058	33	gift	gift	NN
18637	17058	34	from	from	IN
18637	17058	35	the	the	DT
18637	17058	36	decedent	decedent	NNP
18637	17058	37	spouse	spouse	NN
18637	17058	38	,	,	,
18637	17058	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	17058	40	valid,[248	valid,[248	NNP
18637	17058	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17058	42	as	as	IN
18637	17058	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	17058	44	the	the	DT
18637	17058	45	inclusion	inclusion	NN
18637	17058	46	in	in	IN
18637	17058	47	the	the	DT
18637	17058	48	gross	gross	JJ
18637	17058	49	income	income	NN
18637	17058	50	of	of	IN
18637	17058	51	the	the	DT
18637	17058	52	settler	settler	NN
18637	17058	53	of	of	IN
18637	17058	54	income	income	NN
18637	17058	55	accruing	accrue	VBG
18637	17058	56	to	to	IN
18637	17058	57	a	a	DT
18637	17058	58	revocable	revocable	JJ
18637	17058	59	trust	trust	NN
18637	17058	60	during	during	IN
18637	17058	61	any	any	DT
18637	17058	62	period	period	NN
18637	17058	63	when	when	WRB
18637	17058	64	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17058	65	had	have	VBD
18637	17058	66	power	power	NN
18637	17058	67	to	to	TO
18637	17058	68	revoke	revoke	VB
18637	17058	69	or	or	CC
18637	17058	70	modify	modify	VB
18637	17058	71	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17058	72	.	.	.
18637	17059	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17059	2	249	249	CD
18637	17059	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17059	4	GOVERNANCE	governance	NN
18637	17059	5	OF	of	IN
18637	17059	6	THE	the	DT
18637	17059	7	INDIANS	INDIANS	NNP
18637	17059	8	The	the	DT
18637	17059	9	power	power	NN
18637	17059	10	of	of	IN
18637	17059	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17059	12	in	in	IN
18637	17059	13	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	17059	14	of	of	IN
18637	17059	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17059	16	wardship	wardship	NN
18637	17059	17	over	over	IN
18637	17059	18	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	17059	19	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	17059	20	to	to	IN
18637	17059	21	a	a	DT
18637	17059	22	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	17059	23	on	on	IN
18637	17059	24	alienation	alienation	NN
18637	17059	25	of	of	IN
18637	17059	26	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	17059	27	lands	land	NNS
18637	17059	28	even	even	RB
18637	17059	29	after	after	IN
18637	17059	30	a	a	DT
18637	17059	31	particular	particular	JJ
18637	17059	32	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	17059	33	has	have	VBZ
18637	17059	34	been	be	VBN
18637	17059	35	granted	grant	VBN
18637	17059	36	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	17059	37	.	.	.
18637	17060	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17060	2	250	250	CD
18637	17060	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17060	4	But	but	CC
18637	17060	5	rights	right	NNS
18637	17060	6	of	of	IN
18637	17060	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	17060	8	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	17060	9	accruing	accrue	VBG
18637	17060	10	to	to	IN
18637	17060	11	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	17060	12	allotments	allotment	NNS
18637	17060	13	under	under	IN
18637	17060	14	an	an	DT
18637	17060	15	act	act	NN
18637	17060	16	of	of	IN
18637	17060	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17060	18	,	,	,
18637	17060	19	which	which	WDT
18637	17060	20	have	have	VBP
18637	17060	21	become	become	VBN
18637	17060	22	vested	vest	VBN
18637	17060	23	,	,	,
18637	17060	24	are	be	VBP
18637	17060	25	protected	protect	VBN
18637	17060	26	by	by	IN
18637	17060	27	this	this	DT
18637	17060	28	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	17060	29	against	against	IN
18637	17060	30	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	17060	31	.	.	.
18637	17061	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17061	2	251	251	CD
18637	17061	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17061	4	One	one	CD
18637	17061	5	who	who	WP
18637	17061	6	was	be	VBD
18637	17061	7	duly	duly	RB
18637	17061	8	enrolled	enrol	VBN
18637	17061	9	as	as	IN
18637	17061	10	a	a	DT
18637	17061	11	member	member	NN
18637	17061	12	of	of	IN
18637	17061	13	the	the	DT
18637	17061	14	Chickasaw	Chickasaw	NNP
18637	17061	15	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	17061	16	acquired	acquire	VBD
18637	17061	17	valuable	valuable	JJ
18637	17061	18	rights	right	NNS
18637	17061	19	which	which	WDT
18637	17061	20	the	the	DT
18637	17061	21	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	17061	22	of	of	IN
18637	17061	23	the	the	DT
18637	17061	24	Interior	Interior	NNP
18637	17061	25	could	could	MD
18637	17061	26	not	not	RB
18637	17061	27	strike	strike	VB
18637	17061	28	down	down	RP
18637	17061	29	without	without	IN
18637	17061	30	notice	notice	NN
18637	17061	31	and	and	CC
18637	17061	32	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	17061	33	.	.	.
18637	17062	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17062	2	252	252	CD
18637	17062	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17062	4	An	an	DT
18637	17062	5	act	act	NN
18637	17062	6	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	17062	7	suit	suit	NN
18637	17062	8	against	against	IN
18637	17062	9	allottees	allottee	NNS
18637	17062	10	of	of	IN
18637	17062	11	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	17062	12	property	property	NN
18637	17062	13	as	as	IN
18637	17062	14	a	a	DT
18637	17062	15	class	class	NN
18637	17062	16	,	,	,
18637	17062	17	for	for	IN
18637	17062	18	the	the	DT
18637	17062	19	value	value	NN
18637	17062	20	of	of	IN
18637	17062	21	services	service	NNS
18637	17062	22	in	in	IN
18637	17062	23	securing	secure	VBG
18637	17062	24	the	the	DT
18637	17062	25	allotments	allotment	NNS
18637	17062	26	,	,	,
18637	17062	27	which	which	WDT
18637	17062	28	provided	provide	VBD
18637	17062	29	for	for	IN
18637	17062	30	notice	notice	NN
18637	17062	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	17062	32	the	the	DT
18637	17062	33	governor	governor	NN
18637	17062	34	of	of	IN
18637	17062	35	the	the	DT
18637	17062	36	tribe	tribe	NN
18637	17062	37	and	and	CC
18637	17062	38	designated	designate	VBD
18637	17062	39	the	the	DT
18637	17062	40	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	17062	41	General	General	NNP
18637	17062	42	to	to	TO
18637	17062	43	defend	defend	VB
18637	17062	44	the	the	DT
18637	17062	45	suit	suit	NN
18637	17062	46	,	,	,
18637	17062	47	was	be	VBD
18637	17062	48	consonant	consonant	JJ
18637	17062	49	with	with	IN
18637	17062	50	due	due	JJ
18637	17062	51	process	process	NN
18637	17062	52	.	.	.
18637	17063	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17063	2	253	253	CD
18637	17063	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17063	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	17063	5	the	the	DT
18637	17063	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	17063	7	which	which	WDT
18637	17063	8	created	create	VBD
18637	17063	9	a	a	DT
18637	17063	10	tribal	tribal	JJ
18637	17063	11	council	council	NN
18637	17063	12	for	for	IN
18637	17063	13	the	the	DT
18637	17063	14	Osage	Osage	NNP
18637	17063	15	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	17063	16	,	,	,
18637	17063	17	to	to	TO
18637	17063	18	be	be	VB
18637	17063	19	elected	elect	VBN
18637	17063	20	by	by	IN
18637	17063	21	the	the	DT
18637	17063	22	tribe	tribe	NN
18637	17063	23	,	,	,
18637	17063	24	at	at	IN
18637	17063	25	the	the	DT
18637	17063	26	same	same	JJ
18637	17063	27	time	time	NN
18637	17063	28	vested	vest	VBD
18637	17063	29	the	the	DT
18637	17063	30	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	17063	31	of	of	IN
18637	17063	32	the	the	DT
18637	17063	33	Interior	Interior	NNP
18637	17063	34	with	with	IN
18637	17063	35	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	17063	36	to	to	TO
18637	17063	37	remove	remove	VB
18637	17063	38	a	a	DT
18637	17063	39	member	member	NN
18637	17063	40	without	without	IN
18637	17063	41	notice	notice	NN
18637	17063	42	or	or	CC
18637	17063	43	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	17063	44	,	,	,
18637	17063	45	there	there	EX
18637	17063	46	was	be	VBD
18637	17063	47	no	no	DT
18637	17063	48	denial	denial	NN
18637	17063	49	of	of	IN
18637	17063	50	due	due	JJ
18637	17063	51	process	process	NN
18637	17063	52	of	of	IN
18637	17063	53	law	law	NN
18637	17063	54	since	since	IN
18637	17063	55	the	the	DT
18637	17063	56	right	right	NN
18637	17063	57	to	to	TO
18637	17063	58	elect	elect	VB
18637	17063	59	was	be	VBD
18637	17063	60	united	united	JJ
18637	17063	61	in	in	IN
18637	17063	62	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17063	63	creation	creation	NN
18637	17063	64	with	with	IN
18637	17063	65	the	the	DT
18637	17063	66	right	right	NN
18637	17063	67	of	of	IN
18637	17063	68	removal	removal	NN
18637	17063	69	.	.	.
18637	17064	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17064	2	254	254	CD
18637	17064	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17064	4	A	a	DT
18637	17064	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	17064	6	of	of	IN
18637	17064	7	the	the	DT
18637	17064	8	Choctaw	Choctaw	NNP
18637	17064	9	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	17064	10	providing	provide	VBG
18637	17064	11	for	for	IN
18637	17064	12	the	the	DT
18637	17064	13	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	17064	14	and	and	CC
18637	17064	15	sale	sale	NN
18637	17064	16	of	of	IN
18637	17064	17	buildings	building	NNS
18637	17064	18	erected	erect	VBN
18637	17064	19	on	on	IN
18637	17064	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17064	21	lands	land	NNS
18637	17064	22	,	,	,
18637	17064	23	was	be	VBD
18637	17064	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	17064	25	to	to	TO
18637	17064	26	be	be	VB
18637	17064	27	unenforceable	unenforceable	JJ
18637	17064	28	without	without	IN
18637	17064	29	giving	give	VBG
18637	17064	30	the	the	DT
18637	17064	31	builder	builder	NN
18637	17064	32	an	an	DT
18637	17064	33	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	17064	34	to	to	TO
18637	17064	35	be	be	VB
18637	17064	36	heard	hear	VBN
18637	17064	37	.	.	.
18637	17065	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17065	2	255	255	CD
18637	17065	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17065	4	The	the	DT
18637	17065	5	National	National	NNP
18637	17065	6	Eminent	Eminent	NNP
18637	17065	7	Domain	Domain	NNP
18637	17065	8	Power	Power	NNP
18637	17065	9	SCOPE	SCOPE	NNP
18637	17065	10	OF	of	IN
18637	17065	11	POWER	power	NN
18637	17065	12	Being	be	VBG
18637	17065	13	an	an	DT
18637	17065	14	incident	incident	NN
18637	17065	15	of	of	IN
18637	17065	16	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	17065	17	,	,	,
18637	17065	18	the	the	DT
18637	17065	19	right	right	NN
18637	17065	20	of	of	IN
18637	17065	21	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	17065	22	domain	domain	NN
18637	17065	23	requires	require	VBZ
18637	17065	24	no	no	DT
18637	17065	25	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17065	26	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	17065	27	.	.	.
18637	17066	1	The	the	DT
18637	17066	2	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	17066	3	of	of	IN
18637	17066	4	just	just	RB
18637	17066	5	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17066	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	17066	7	merely	merely	RB
18637	17066	8	a	a	DT
18637	17066	9	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	17066	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	17066	11	the	the	DT
18637	17066	12	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	17066	13	of	of	IN
18637	17066	14	a	a	DT
18637	17066	15	preexisting	preexisting	NN
18637	17066	16	power[256	power[256	NN
18637	17066	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17066	18	to	to	TO
18637	17066	19	which	which	WDT
18637	17066	20	all	all	DT
18637	17066	21	private	private	JJ
18637	17066	22	property	property	NN
18637	17066	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	17066	24	subject	subject	JJ
18637	17066	25	.	.	.
18637	17067	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17067	2	257	257	CD
18637	17067	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17067	4	This	this	DT
18637	17067	5	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	17067	6	of	of	IN
18637	17067	7	the	the	DT
18637	17067	8	National	National	NNP
18637	17067	9	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17067	10	can	can	MD
18637	17067	11	neither	neither	CC
18637	17067	12	be	be	VB
18637	17067	13	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
18637	17067	14	nor	nor	CC
18637	17067	15	diminished	diminish	VBN
18637	17067	16	by	by	IN
18637	17067	17	a	a	DT
18637	17067	18	State	state	NN
18637	17067	19	.	.	.
18637	17068	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17068	2	258	258	CD
18637	17068	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17068	4	Whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	17068	5	lands	land	VBZ
18637	17068	6	in	in	IN
18637	17068	7	a	a	DT
18637	17068	8	State	state	NN
18637	17068	9	are	be	VBP
18637	17068	10	needed	need	VBN
18637	17068	11	for	for	IN
18637	17068	12	a	a	DT
18637	17068	13	public	public	JJ
18637	17068	14	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	17068	15	,	,	,
18637	17068	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17068	17	may	may	MD
18637	17068	18	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	17068	19	that	that	IN
18637	17068	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17068	21	be	be	VBP
18637	17068	22	taken	take	VBN
18637	17068	23	,	,	,
18637	17068	24	either	either	CC
18637	17068	25	by	by	IN
18637	17068	26	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	17068	27	in	in	IN
18637	17068	28	the	the	DT
18637	17068	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	17068	30	of	of	IN
18637	17068	31	the	the	DT
18637	17068	32	State	State	NNP
18637	17068	33	,	,	,
18637	17068	34	with	with	IN
18637	17068	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17068	36	consent	consent	NN
18637	17068	37	,	,	,
18637	17068	38	or	or	CC
18637	17068	39	by	by	IN
18637	17068	40	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	17068	41	in	in	IN
18637	17068	42	the	the	DT
18637	17068	43	courts	court	NNS
18637	17068	44	of	of	IN
18637	17068	45	the	the	DT
18637	17068	46	United	United	NNP
18637	17068	47	States	States	NNP
18637	17068	48	,	,	,
18637	17068	49	with	with	IN
18637	17068	50	or	or	CC
18637	17068	51	without	without	IN
18637	17068	52	any	any	DT
18637	17068	53	consent	consent	NN
18637	17068	54	or	or	CC
18637	17068	55	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	17068	56	act	act	NN
18637	17068	57	of	of	IN
18637	17068	58	the	the	DT
18637	17068	59	State	State	NNP
18637	17068	60	.	.	.
18637	17069	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17069	2	259	259	CD
18637	17069	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17069	4	The	the	DT
18637	17069	5	facts	fact	NNS
18637	17069	6	that	that	WDT
18637	17069	7	land	land	NN
18637	17069	8	included	include	VBN
18637	17069	9	in	in	IN
18637	17069	10	a	a	DT
18637	17069	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17069	12	reservoir	reservoir	NN
18637	17069	13	project	project	NN
18637	17069	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	17069	15	owned	own	VBN
18637	17069	16	by	by	IN
18637	17069	17	a	a	DT
18637	17069	18	State	state	NN
18637	17069	19	,	,	,
18637	17069	20	or	or	CC
18637	17069	21	that	that	IN
18637	17069	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17069	23	taking	taking	NN
18637	17069	24	may	may	MD
18637	17069	25	impair	impair	VB
18637	17069	26	the	the	DT
18637	17069	27	tax	tax	NN
18637	17069	28	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	17069	29	of	of	IN
18637	17069	30	the	the	DT
18637	17069	31	State	State	NNP
18637	17069	32	,	,	,
18637	17069	33	that	that	IN
18637	17069	34	the	the	DT
18637	17069	35	reservoir	reservoir	NN
18637	17069	36	will	will	MD
18637	17069	37	obliterate	obliterate	VB
18637	17069	38	part	part	NN
18637	17069	39	of	of	IN
18637	17069	40	the	the	DT
18637	17069	41	State	State	NNP
18637	17069	42	's	's	POS
18637	17069	43	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	17069	44	and	and	CC
18637	17069	45	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	17069	46	with	with	IN
18637	17069	47	the	the	DT
18637	17069	48	State	State	NNP
18637	17069	49	's	's	POS
18637	17069	50	own	own	JJ
18637	17069	51	project	project	NN
18637	17069	52	for	for	IN
18637	17069	53	water	water	NN
18637	17069	54	development	development	NN
18637	17069	55	and	and	CC
18637	17069	56	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	17069	57	,	,	,
18637	17069	58	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	17069	59	no	no	DT
18637	17069	60	barrier	barrier	NN
18637	17069	61	to	to	IN
18637	17069	62	the	the	DT
18637	17069	63	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	17069	64	of	of	IN
18637	17069	65	the	the	DT
18637	17069	66	land	land	NN
18637	17069	67	by	by	IN
18637	17069	68	the	the	DT
18637	17069	69	United	United	NNP
18637	17069	70	States	States	NNP
18637	17069	71	under	under	IN
18637	17069	72	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17069	73	superior	superior	JJ
18637	17069	74	power	power	NN
18637	17069	75	of	of	IN
18637	17069	76	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	17069	77	domain	domain	NN
18637	17069	78	.	.	.
18637	17070	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17070	2	260	260	CD
18637	17070	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17070	4	ALIEN	ALIEN	NNP
18637	17070	5	PROPERTY	property	NN
18637	17070	6	There	there	EX
18637	17070	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	17070	8	no	no	DT
18637	17070	9	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17070	10	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	17070	11	against	against	IN
18637	17070	12	confiscation	confiscation	NN
18637	17070	13	of	of	IN
18637	17070	14	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	17070	15	property	property	NN
18637	17070	16	.	.	.
18637	17071	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17071	2	261	261	CD
18637	17071	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17071	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17071	5	may	may	MD
18637	17071	6	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	17071	7	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	17071	8	and	and	CC
18637	17071	9	sequestration	sequestration	NN
18637	17071	10	through	through	IN
18637	17071	11	executive	executive	JJ
18637	17071	12	channels	channel	NNS
18637	17071	13	of	of	IN
18637	17071	14	property	property	NN
18637	17071	15	believed	believe	VBN
18637	17071	16	to	to	TO
18637	17071	17	be	be	VB
18637	17071	18	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	17071	19	owned	own	VBN
18637	17071	20	if	if	IN
18637	17071	21	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	17071	22	provision	provision	NN
18637	17071	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	17071	24	made	make	VBN
18637	17071	25	for	for	IN
18637	17071	26	return	return	NN
18637	17071	27	in	in	IN
18637	17071	28	case	case	NN
18637	17071	29	of	of	IN
18637	17071	30	mistake	mistake	NN
18637	17071	31	.	.	.
18637	17072	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17072	2	262	262	CD
18637	17072	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17072	4	An	an	DT
18637	17072	5	alien	alien	JJ
18637	17072	6	friend	friend	NN
18637	17072	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	17072	8	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	17072	9	to	to	IN
18637	17072	10	the	the	DT
18637	17072	11	protection	protection	NN
18637	17072	12	of	of	IN
18637	17072	13	the	the	DT
18637	17072	14	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	17072	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17072	16	against	against	IN
18637	17072	17	a	a	DT
18637	17072	18	taking	taking	NN
18637	17072	19	of	of	IN
18637	17072	20	property	property	NN
18637	17072	21	for	for	IN
18637	17072	22	public	public	JJ
18637	17072	23	use	use	NN
18637	17072	24	without	without	IN
18637	17072	25	just	just	JJ
18637	17072	26	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17072	27	.	.	.
18637	17073	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17073	2	263	263	CD
18637	17073	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17073	4	The	the	DT
18637	17073	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	17073	6	that	that	IN
18637	17073	7	property	property	NN
18637	17073	8	of	of	IN
18637	17073	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17073	10	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	17073	11	may	may	MD
18637	17073	12	be	be	VB
18637	17073	13	confiscated	confiscate	VBN
18637	17073	14	in	in	IN
18637	17073	15	that	that	DT
18637	17073	16	alien	alien	NN
18637	17073	17	's	's	POS
18637	17073	18	country	country	NN
18637	17073	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	17073	20	not	not	RB
18637	17073	21	subject	subject	VB
18637	17073	22	the	the	DT
18637	17073	23	alien	alien	JJ
18637	17073	24	friend	friend	NN
18637	17073	25	's	's	POS
18637	17073	26	property	property	NN
18637	17073	27	to	to	TO
18637	17073	28	confiscation	confiscation	VB
18637	17073	29	here	here	RB
18637	17073	30	.	.	.
18637	17074	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17074	2	264	264	CD
18637	17074	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17074	4	PUBLIC	public	NN
18637	17074	5	USE	use	VB
18637	17074	6	The	the	DT
18637	17074	7	extent	extent	NN
18637	17074	8	to	to	TO
18637	17074	9	which	which	WDT
18637	17074	10	private	private	JJ
18637	17074	11	property	property	NN
18637	17074	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	17074	13	be	be	VB
18637	17074	14	taken	take	VBN
18637	17074	15	for	for	IN
18637	17074	16	public	public	JJ
18637	17074	17	use	use	NN
18637	17074	18	rests	rest	NNS
18637	17074	19	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	17074	20	in	in	IN
18637	17074	21	the	the	DT
18637	17074	22	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	17074	23	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	17074	24	.	.	.
18637	17075	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17075	2	265	265	CD
18637	17075	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17075	4	Whether	whether	IN
18637	17075	5	the	the	DT
18637	17075	6	courts	court	NNS
18637	17075	7	have	have	VBP
18637	17075	8	power	power	NN
18637	17075	9	to	to	TO
18637	17075	10	review	review	VB
18637	17075	11	a	a	DT
18637	17075	12	determination	determination	NN
18637	17075	13	of	of	IN
18637	17075	14	the	the	DT
18637	17075	15	lawmakers	lawmaker	NNS
18637	17075	16	that	that	WDT
18637	17075	17	a	a	DT
18637	17075	18	particular	particular	JJ
18637	17075	19	use	use	NN
18637	17075	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	17075	21	a	a	DT
18637	17075	22	public	public	JJ
18637	17075	23	use	use	NN
18637	17075	24	was	be	VBD
18637	17075	25	left	leave	VBN
18637	17075	26	in	in	IN
18637	17075	27	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	17075	28	by	by	IN
18637	17075	29	the	the	DT
18637	17075	30	decision	decision	NN
18637	17075	31	in	in	IN
18637	17075	32	United	United	NNP
18637	17075	33	States	States	NNP
18637	17075	34	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17075	35	rel	rel	NN
18637	17075	36	.	.	.
18637	17076	1	T.V.A.	T.V.A.	NNP
18637	17077	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17077	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	17077	3	_	_	NNP
18637	17077	4	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	17077	5	.	.	.
18637	17078	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17078	2	266	266	CD
18637	17078	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17078	4	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	17078	5	for	for	IN
18637	17078	6	the	the	DT
18637	17078	7	majority	majority	NN
18637	17078	8	,	,	,
18637	17078	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	17078	10	Black	Black	NNP
18637	17078	11	declared	declare	VBD
18637	17078	12	:	:	:
18637	17078	13	"	"	``
18637	17078	14	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17078	15	think	think	VBP
18637	17078	16	that	that	IN
18637	17078	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17078	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	17078	19	the	the	DT
18637	17078	20	function	function	NN
18637	17078	21	of	of	IN
18637	17078	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17078	23	to	to	TO
18637	17078	24	decide	decide	VB
18637	17078	25	what	what	WDT
18637	17078	26	type	type	NN
18637	17078	27	of	of	IN
18637	17078	28	taking	taking	NN
18637	17078	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	17078	30	for	for	IN
18637	17078	31	a	a	DT
18637	17078	32	public	public	JJ
18637	17078	33	use	use	NN
18637	17078	34	*	*	NFP
18637	17078	35	*	*	NFP
18637	17078	36	*	*	NFP
18637	17078	37	"	"	''
18637	17078	38	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17078	39	267	267	CD
18637	17078	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17078	41	In	in	IN
18637	17078	42	a	a	DT
18637	17078	43	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	17078	44	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17078	45	in	in	IN
18637	17078	46	which	which	WDT
18637	17078	47	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	17078	48	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	17078	49	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	17078	50	joined	join	VBD
18637	17078	51	,	,	,
18637	17078	52	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	17078	53	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	17078	54	took	take	VBD
18637	17078	55	exception	exception	NN
18637	17078	56	to	to	IN
18637	17078	57	that	that	DT
18637	17078	58	portion	portion	NN
18637	17078	59	of	of	IN
18637	17078	60	the	the	DT
18637	17078	61	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17078	62	,	,	,
18637	17078	63	insisting	insist	VBG
18637	17078	64	that	that	IN
18637	17078	65	whether	whether	IN
18637	17078	66	or	or	CC
18637	17078	67	not	not	RB
18637	17078	68	a	a	DT
18637	17078	69	taking	taking	NN
18637	17078	70	is	be	VBZ
18637	17078	71	for	for	IN
18637	17078	72	a	a	DT
18637	17078	73	public	public	JJ
18637	17078	74	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	17078	75	is	be	VBZ
18637	17078	76	a	a	DT
18637	17078	77	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	17078	78	question	question	NN
18637	17078	79	.	.	.
18637	17079	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17079	2	268	268	CD
18637	17079	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17079	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	17079	5	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	17079	6	interpreted	interpret	VBD
18637	17079	7	the	the	DT
18637	17079	8	controlling	control	VBG
18637	17079	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17079	10	as	as	IN
18637	17079	11	recognizing	recognize	VBG
18637	17079	12	the	the	DT
18637	17079	13	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	17079	14	that	that	IN
18637	17079	15	"	"	``
18637	17079	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	17079	17	a	a	DT
18637	17079	18	taking	taking	NN
18637	17079	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	17079	20	for	for	IN
18637	17079	21	a	a	DT
18637	17079	22	public	public	JJ
18637	17079	23	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	17079	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	17079	25	not	not	RB
18637	17079	26	a	a	DT
18637	17079	27	question	question	NN
18637	17079	28	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	17079	29	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	17079	30	competence	competence	NN
18637	17079	31	.	.	.
18637	17080	1	"	"	``
18637	17080	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17080	3	269	269	CD
18637	17080	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17080	5	All	all	DT
18637	17080	6	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	17080	7	that	that	IN
18637	17080	8	the	the	DT
18637	17080	9	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	17080	10	of	of	IN
18637	17080	11	property	property	NN
18637	17080	12	which	which	WDT
18637	17080	13	had	have	VBD
18637	17080	14	been	be	VBN
18637	17080	15	isolated	isolate	VBN
18637	17080	16	by	by	IN
18637	17080	17	the	the	DT
18637	17080	18	flooding	flooding	NN
18637	17080	19	of	of	IN
18637	17080	20	a	a	DT
18637	17080	21	highway	highway	NN
18637	17080	22	,	,	,
18637	17080	23	to	to	TO
18637	17080	24	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	17080	25	the	the	DT
18637	17080	26	expense	expense	NN
18637	17080	27	of	of	IN
18637	17080	28	constructing	construct	VBG
18637	17080	29	a	a	DT
18637	17080	30	new	new	JJ
18637	17080	31	highway	highway	NN
18637	17080	32	,	,	,
18637	17080	33	was	be	VBD
18637	17080	34	a	a	DT
18637	17080	35	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	17080	36	public	public	JJ
18637	17080	37	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	17080	38	.	.	.
18637	17081	1	Previous	previous	JJ
18637	17081	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	17081	3	have	have	VBP
18637	17081	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	17081	5	that	that	IN
18637	17081	6	the	the	DT
18637	17081	7	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	17081	8	for	for	IN
18637	17081	9	memorial	memorial	JJ
18637	17081	10	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	17081	11	of	of	IN
18637	17081	12	the	the	DT
18637	17081	13	line	line	NN
18637	17081	14	of	of	IN
18637	17081	15	battle	battle	NN
18637	17081	16	at	at	IN
18637	17081	17	Gettysburg	Gettysburg	NNP
18637	17081	18	was	be	VBD
18637	17081	19	a	a	DT
18637	17081	20	public	public	JJ
18637	17081	21	use	use	NN
18637	17081	22	for	for	IN
18637	17081	23	which	which	WDT
18637	17081	24	private	private	JJ
18637	17081	25	property	property	NN
18637	17081	26	could	could	MD
18637	17081	27	be	be	VB
18637	17081	28	taken	take	VBN
18637	17081	29	by	by	IN
18637	17081	30	condemnation;[270	condemnation;[270	NNS
18637	17081	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17081	32	that	that	IN
18637	17081	33	where	where	WRB
18637	17081	34	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	17081	35	of	of	IN
18637	17081	36	a	a	DT
18637	17081	37	reservoir	reservoir	NN
18637	17081	38	involved	involve	VBN
18637	17081	39	flooding	flooding	NN
18637	17081	40	part	part	NN
18637	17081	41	of	of	IN
18637	17081	42	a	a	DT
18637	17081	43	town	town	NN
18637	17081	44	,	,	,
18637	17081	45	the	the	DT
18637	17081	46	United	United	NNP
18637	17081	47	States	States	NNP
18637	17081	48	might	may	MD
18637	17081	49	take	take	VB
18637	17081	50	nearby	nearby	JJ
18637	17081	51	property	property	NN
18637	17081	52	for	for	IN
18637	17081	53	a	a	DT
18637	17081	54	new	new	JJ
18637	17081	55	townsite	townsite	NN
18637	17081	56	and	and	CC
18637	17081	57	the	the	DT
18637	17081	58	fact	fact	NN
18637	17081	59	that	that	IN
18637	17081	60	there	there	EX
18637	17081	61	might	may	MD
18637	17081	62	be	be	VB
18637	17081	63	some	some	DT
18637	17081	64	surplus	surplus	JJ
18637	17081	65	lots	lot	NNS
18637	17081	66	to	to	TO
18637	17081	67	be	be	VB
18637	17081	68	sold	sell	VBN
18637	17081	69	did	do	VBD
18637	17081	70	not	not	RB
18637	17081	71	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	17081	72	the	the	DT
18637	17081	73	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	17081	74	of	of	IN
18637	17081	75	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17081	76	character	character	NN
18637	17081	77	as	as	IN
18637	17081	78	taking	take	VBG
18637	17081	79	for	for	IN
18637	17081	80	public	public	JJ
18637	17081	81	use	use	NN
18637	17081	82	.	.	.
18637	17082	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17082	2	271	271	CD
18637	17082	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17082	4	RIGHTS	RIGHTS	NNP
18637	17082	5	FOR	for	IN
18637	17082	6	WHICH	which	WDT
18637	17082	7	COMPENSATION	COMPENSATION	NNS
18637	17082	8	MUST	MUST	MD
18637	17082	9	BE	be	VB
18637	17082	10	MADE	make	VBN
18637	17082	11	The	the	DT
18637	17082	12	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	17082	13	of	of	IN
18637	17082	14	a	a	DT
18637	17082	15	private	private	JJ
18637	17082	16	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	17082	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	17082	18	property	property	NN
18637	17082	19	which	which	WDT
18637	17082	20	can	can	MD
18637	17082	21	not	not	RB
18637	17082	22	be	be	VB
18637	17082	23	taken	take	VBN
18637	17082	24	for	for	IN
18637	17082	25	public	public	JJ
18637	17082	26	use	use	NN
18637	17082	27	without	without	IN
18637	17082	28	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17082	29	.	.	.
18637	17083	1	Upon	upon	IN
18637	17083	2	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	17083	3	of	of	IN
18637	17083	4	a	a	DT
18637	17083	5	lock	lock	NN
18637	17083	6	and	and	CC
18637	17083	7	dam	dam	NN
18637	17083	8	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	17083	9	to	to	IN
18637	17083	10	a	a	DT
18637	17083	11	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	17083	12	company	company	NN
18637	17083	13	,	,	,
18637	17083	14	the	the	DT
18637	17083	15	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17083	16	was	be	VBD
18637	17083	17	required	require	VBN
18637	17083	18	to	to	TO
18637	17083	19	pay	pay	VB
18637	17083	20	for	for	IN
18637	17083	21	the	the	DT
18637	17083	22	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	17083	23	to	to	TO
18637	17083	24	take	take	VB
18637	17083	25	tolls	toll	NNS
18637	17083	26	as	as	RB
18637	17083	27	well	well	RB
18637	17083	28	as	as	IN
18637	17083	29	for	for	IN
18637	17083	30	the	the	DT
18637	17083	31	tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	17083	32	property	property	NN
18637	17083	33	.	.	.
18637	17084	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17084	2	272	272	CD
18637	17084	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17084	4	Letters	letter	NNS
18637	17084	5	patent	patent	NN
18637	17084	6	for	for	IN
18637	17084	7	a	a	DT
18637	17084	8	new	new	JJ
18637	17084	9	invention	invention	NN
18637	17084	10	or	or	CC
18637	17084	11	discovery	discovery	NN
18637	17084	12	in	in	IN
18637	17084	13	the	the	DT
18637	17084	14	arts	art	NNS
18637	17084	15	confer	confer	VBP
18637	17084	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	17084	17	the	the	DT
18637	17084	18	patentee	patentee	NN
18637	17084	19	an	an	DT
18637	17084	20	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	17084	21	property	property	NN
18637	17084	22	for	for	IN
18637	17084	23	which	which	WDT
18637	17084	24	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17084	25	must	must	MD
18637	17084	26	be	be	VB
18637	17084	27	made	make	VBN
18637	17084	28	when	when	WRB
18637	17084	29	the	the	DT
18637	17084	30	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17084	31	uses	use	VBZ
18637	17084	32	the	the	DT
18637	17084	33	patent	patent	NN
18637	17084	34	.	.	.
18637	17085	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17085	2	273	273	CD
18637	17085	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17085	4	The	the	DT
18637	17085	5	frustration	frustration	NN
18637	17085	6	of	of	IN
18637	17085	7	a	a	DT
18637	17085	8	private	private	JJ
18637	17085	9	contract	contract	NN
18637	17085	10	by	by	IN
18637	17085	11	the	the	DT
18637	17085	12	requisitioning	requisitioning	NN
18637	17085	13	of	of	IN
18637	17085	14	the	the	DT
18637	17085	15	entire	entire	JJ
18637	17085	16	output	output	NN
18637	17085	17	of	of	IN
18637	17085	18	a	a	DT
18637	17085	19	steel	steel	NN
18637	17085	20	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
18637	17085	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	17085	22	not	not	RB
18637	17085	23	a	a	DT
18637	17085	24	taking	taking	NN
18637	17085	25	for	for	IN
18637	17085	26	which	which	WDT
18637	17085	27	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17085	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	17085	29	required	require	VBN
18637	17085	30	.	.	.
18637	17086	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17086	2	274	274	CD
18637	17086	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17086	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	17086	5	,	,	,
18637	17086	6	however	however	RB
18637	17086	7	,	,	,
18637	17086	8	the	the	DT
18637	17086	9	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17086	10	requisitioned	requisition	VBD
18637	17086	11	from	from	IN
18637	17086	12	a	a	DT
18637	17086	13	power	power	NN
18637	17086	14	company	company	NN
18637	17086	15	all	all	DT
18637	17086	16	of	of	IN
18637	17086	17	the	the	DT
18637	17086	18	electric	electric	JJ
18637	17086	19	power	power	NN
18637	17086	20	which	which	WDT
18637	17086	21	could	could	MD
18637	17086	22	be	be	VB
18637	17086	23	produced	produce	VBN
18637	17086	24	by	by	IN
18637	17086	25	use	use	NN
18637	17086	26	of	of	IN
18637	17086	27	the	the	DT
18637	17086	28	water	water	NN
18637	17086	29	diverted	divert	VBN
18637	17086	30	through	through	IN
18637	17086	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17086	32	intake	intake	JJ
18637	17086	33	canal	canal	NN
18637	17086	34	,	,	,
18637	17086	35	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	17086	36	cutting	cut	VBG
18637	17086	37	off	off	RP
18637	17086	38	the	the	DT
18637	17086	39	supply	supply	NN
18637	17086	40	of	of	IN
18637	17086	41	a	a	DT
18637	17086	42	lessee	lessee	NN
18637	17086	43	which	which	WDT
18637	17086	44	had	have	VBD
18637	17086	45	a	a	DT
18637	17086	46	right	right	NN
18637	17086	47	,	,	,
18637	17086	48	amounting	amount	VBG
18637	17086	49	to	to	IN
18637	17086	50	a	a	DT
18637	17086	51	corporeal	corporeal	JJ
18637	17086	52	hereditament	hereditament	NN
18637	17086	53	under	under	IN
18637	17086	54	State	State	NNP
18637	17086	55	law	law	NN
18637	17086	56	,	,	,
18637	17086	57	to	to	TO
18637	17086	58	draw	draw	VB
18637	17086	59	a	a	DT
18637	17086	60	portion	portion	NN
18637	17086	61	of	of	IN
18637	17086	62	that	that	DT
18637	17086	63	water	water	NN
18637	17086	64	,	,	,
18637	17086	65	the	the	DT
18637	17086	66	latter	latter	JJ
18637	17086	67	was	be	VBD
18637	17086	68	awarded	award	VBN
18637	17086	69	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17086	70	for	for	IN
18637	17086	71	the	the	DT
18637	17086	72	rights	right	NNS
18637	17086	73	taken	take	VBN
18637	17086	74	.	.	.
18637	17087	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17087	2	275	275	CD
18637	17087	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17087	4	An	an	DT
18637	17087	5	order	order	NN
18637	17087	6	requiring	require	VBG
18637	17087	7	the	the	DT
18637	17087	8	removal	removal	NN
18637	17087	9	or	or	CC
18637	17087	10	alteration	alteration	NN
18637	17087	11	of	of	IN
18637	17087	12	a	a	DT
18637	17087	13	bridge	bridge	NN
18637	17087	14	over	over	IN
18637	17087	15	a	a	DT
18637	17087	16	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	17087	17	river	river	NN
18637	17087	18	,	,	,
18637	17087	19	to	to	TO
18637	17087	20	abate	abate	VB
18637	17087	21	the	the	DT
18637	17087	22	obstruction	obstruction	NN
18637	17087	23	to	to	IN
18637	17087	24	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	17087	25	,	,	,
18637	17087	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	17087	27	not	not	RB
18637	17087	28	a	a	DT
18637	17087	29	taking	taking	NN
18637	17087	30	of	of	IN
18637	17087	31	property	property	NN
18637	17087	32	within	within	IN
18637	17087	33	the	the	DT
18637	17087	34	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	17087	35	of	of	IN
18637	17087	36	the	the	DT
18637	17087	37	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	17087	38	.	.	.
18637	17088	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17088	2	276	276	CD
18637	17088	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17088	4	The	the	DT
18637	17088	5	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	17088	6	,	,	,
18637	17088	7	from	from	IN
18637	17088	8	the	the	DT
18637	17088	9	amount	amount	NN
18637	17088	10	to	to	TO
18637	17088	11	be	be	VB
18637	17088	12	paid	pay	VBN
18637	17088	13	to	to	IN
18637	17088	14	the	the	DT
18637	17088	15	owners	owner	NNS
18637	17088	16	of	of	IN
18637	17088	17	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	17088	18	property	property	NN
18637	17088	19	,	,	,
18637	17088	20	of	of	IN
18637	17088	21	the	the	DT
18637	17088	22	value	value	NN
18637	17088	23	of	of	IN
18637	17088	24	improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	17088	25	made	make	VBN
18637	17088	26	by	by	IN
18637	17088	27	the	the	DT
18637	17088	28	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17088	29	under	under	IN
18637	17088	30	a	a	DT
18637	17088	31	lease	lease	NN
18637	17088	32	,	,	,
18637	17088	33	was	be	VBD
18637	17088	34	held	hold	VBN
18637	17088	35	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17088	36	.	.	.
18637	17089	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17089	2	277	277	CD
18637	17089	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17089	4	An	an	DT
18637	17089	5	undertaking	undertaking	NN
18637	17089	6	to	to	TO
18637	17089	7	reduce	reduce	VB
18637	17089	8	the	the	DT
18637	17089	9	menace	menace	NN
18637	17089	10	from	from	IN
18637	17089	11	flood	flood	NN
18637	17089	12	damages	damage	NNS
18637	17089	13	which	which	WDT
18637	17089	14	was	be	VBD
18637	17089	15	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
18637	17089	16	but	but	CC
18637	17089	17	for	for	IN
18637	17089	18	the	the	DT
18637	17089	19	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17089	20	's	's	POS
18637	17089	21	work	work	NN
18637	17089	22	does	do	VBZ
18637	17089	23	not	not	RB
18637	17089	24	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	17089	25	the	the	DT
18637	17089	26	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17089	27	a	a	DT
18637	17089	28	taker	taker	NN
18637	17089	29	of	of	IN
18637	17089	30	all	all	DT
18637	17089	31	lands	land	NNS
18637	17089	32	not	not	RB
18637	17089	33	fully	fully	RB
18637	17089	34	protected	protect	VBN
18637	17089	35	;	;	:
18637	17089	36	the	the	DT
18637	17089	37	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17089	38	does	do	VBZ
18637	17089	39	not	not	RB
18637	17089	40	owe	owe	VB
18637	17089	41	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17089	42	under	under	IN
18637	17089	43	the	the	DT
18637	17089	44	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	17089	45	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17089	46	to	to	IN
18637	17089	47	every	every	DT
18637	17089	48	landowner	landowner	NN
18637	17089	49	whom	whom	WP
18637	17089	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17089	51	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	17089	52	to	to	IN
18637	17089	53	or	or	CC
18637	17089	54	can	can	MD
18637	17089	55	not	not	RB
18637	17089	56	protect	protect	VB
18637	17089	57	.	.	.
18637	17090	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17090	2	278	278	CD
18637	17090	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17090	4	When	when	WRB
18637	17090	5	Property	Property	NNP
18637	17090	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	17090	7	Taken	take	VBN
18637	17090	8	According	accord	VBG
18637	17090	9	to	to	IN
18637	17090	10	the	the	DT
18637	17090	11	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	17090	12	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	17090	13	Cases,[279	Cases,[279	NNP
18637	17090	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17090	15	the	the	DT
18637	17090	16	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	17090	17	of	of	IN
18637	17090	18	just	just	JJ
18637	17090	19	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17090	20	for	for	IN
18637	17090	21	property	property	NN
18637	17090	22	taken	take	VBN
18637	17090	23	for	for	IN
18637	17090	24	public	public	JJ
18637	17090	25	use	use	NN
18637	17090	26	refers	refer	VBZ
18637	17090	27	only	only	RB
18637	17090	28	to	to	TO
18637	17090	29	direct	direct	VB
18637	17090	30	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	17090	31	and	and	CC
18637	17090	32	not	not	RB
18637	17090	33	to	to	IN
18637	17090	34	consequential	consequential	JJ
18637	17090	35	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	17090	36	resulting	result	VBG
18637	17090	37	from	from	IN
18637	17090	38	the	the	DT
18637	17090	39	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	17090	40	of	of	IN
18637	17090	41	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	17090	42	power	power	NN
18637	17090	43	.	.	.
18637	17091	1	This	this	DT
18637	17091	2	formula	formula	NN
18637	17091	3	leaves	leave	VBZ
18637	17091	4	open	open	VBP
18637	17091	5	the	the	DT
18637	17091	6	question	question	NN
18637	17091	7	as	as	IN
18637	17091	8	to	to	IN
18637	17091	9	whether	whether	IN
18637	17091	10	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	17091	11	are	be	VBP
18637	17091	12	"	"	``
18637	17091	13	consequential	consequential	JJ
18637	17091	14	"	"	''
18637	17091	15	merely	merely	RB
18637	17091	16	.	.	.
18637	17092	1	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	17092	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	17092	3	embodies	embody	VBZ
18637	17092	4	a	a	DT
18637	17092	5	more	more	RBR
18637	17092	6	definite	definite	JJ
18637	17092	7	test	test	NN
18637	17092	8	.	.	.
18637	17093	1	In	in	IN
18637	17093	2	United	United	NNP
18637	17093	3	States	States	NNP
18637	17093	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17093	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	17093	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17093	7	Dickinson,[280	Dickinson,[280	NNP
18637	17093	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17093	9	the	the	DT
18637	17093	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	17093	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17093	12	held	hold	VBD
18637	17093	13	that	that	IN
18637	17093	14	property	property	NN
18637	17093	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	17093	16	"	"	``
18637	17093	17	taken	take	VBN
18637	17093	18	"	"	''
18637	17093	19	within	within	IN
18637	17093	20	the	the	DT
18637	17093	21	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	17093	22	of	of	IN
18637	17093	23	the	the	DT
18637	17093	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	17093	25	"	"	''
18637	17093	26	when	when	WRB
18637	17093	27	inroads	inroad	NNS
18637	17093	28	are	be	VBP
18637	17093	29	made	make	VBN
18637	17093	30	upon	upon	IN
18637	17093	31	the	the	DT
18637	17093	32	owner	owner	NN
18637	17093	33	's	's	POS
18637	17093	34	use	use	NN
18637	17093	35	of	of	IN
18637	17093	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17093	37	to	to	IN
18637	17093	38	an	an	DT
18637	17093	39	extent	extent	NN
18637	17093	40	that	that	IN
18637	17093	41	,	,	,
18637	17093	42	as	as	IN
18637	17093	43	between	between	IN
18637	17093	44	private	private	JJ
18637	17093	45	parties	party	NNS
18637	17093	46	,	,	,
18637	17093	47	a	a	DT
18637	17093	48	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	17093	49	has	have	VBZ
18637	17093	50	been	be	VBN
18637	17093	51	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	17093	52	either	either	CC
18637	17093	53	by	by	IN
18637	17093	54	an	an	DT
18637	17093	55	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	17093	56	or	or	CC
18637	17093	57	in	in	IN
18637	17093	58	course	course	NN
18637	17093	59	of	of	IN
18637	17093	60	time	time	NN
18637	17093	61	.	.	.
18637	17094	1	"	"	``
18637	17094	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17094	3	281	281	CD
18637	17094	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17094	5	Where	where	WRB
18637	17094	6	the	the	DT
18637	17094	7	noise	noise	NN
18637	17094	8	and	and	CC
18637	17094	9	glaring	glaring	JJ
18637	17094	10	lights	light	NNS
18637	17094	11	of	of	IN
18637	17094	12	planes	plane	NNS
18637	17094	13	landing	land	VBG
18637	17094	14	at	at	IN
18637	17094	15	or	or	CC
18637	17094	16	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	17094	17	an	an	DT
18637	17094	18	airport	airport	NN
18637	17094	19	leased	lease	VBN
18637	17094	20	to	to	IN
18637	17094	21	the	the	DT
18637	17094	22	United	United	NNP
18637	17094	23	States	States	NNP
18637	17094	24	,	,	,
18637	17094	25	flying	fly	VBG
18637	17094	26	below	below	IN
18637	17094	27	the	the	DT
18637	17094	28	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	17094	29	air	air	NN
18637	17094	30	space	space	NN
18637	17094	31	as	as	IN
18637	17094	32	defined	define	VBN
18637	17094	33	by	by	IN
18637	17094	34	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17094	35	,	,	,
18637	17094	36	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	17094	37	with	with	IN
18637	17094	38	the	the	DT
18637	17094	39	normal	normal	JJ
18637	17094	40	use	use	NN
18637	17094	41	of	of	IN
18637	17094	42	a	a	DT
18637	17094	43	neighboring	neighboring	JJ
18637	17094	44	farm	farm	NN
18637	17094	45	as	as	IN
18637	17094	46	a	a	DT
18637	17094	47	chicken	chicken	NN
18637	17094	48	farm	farm	NN
18637	17094	49	,	,	,
18637	17094	50	there	there	EX
18637	17094	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	17094	52	such	such	PDT
18637	17094	53	a	a	DT
18637	17094	54	taking	taking	NN
18637	17094	55	as	as	IN
18637	17094	56	to	to	TO
18637	17094	57	give	give	VB
18637	17094	58	the	the	DT
18637	17094	59	owner	owner	NN
18637	17094	60	a	a	DT
18637	17094	61	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17094	62	right	right	NN
18637	17094	63	to	to	IN
18637	17094	64	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17094	65	.	.	.
18637	17095	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17095	2	282	282	CD
18637	17095	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17095	4	That	that	IN
18637	17095	5	the	the	DT
18637	17095	6	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17095	7	had	have	VBD
18637	17095	8	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	17095	9	a	a	DT
18637	17095	10	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	17095	11	on	on	IN
18637	17095	12	land	land	NN
18637	17095	13	adjoining	adjoin	VBG
18637	17095	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17095	15	fort	fort	NN
18637	17095	16	so	so	IN
18637	17095	17	as	as	IN
18637	17095	18	to	to	TO
18637	17095	19	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	17095	20	a	a	DT
18637	17095	21	taking	taking	NN
18637	17095	22	within	within	IN
18637	17095	23	the	the	DT
18637	17095	24	law	law	NN
18637	17095	25	of	of	IN
18637	17095	26	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	17095	27	domain	domain	NN
18637	17095	28	may	may	MD
18637	17095	29	be	be	VB
18637	17095	30	found	find	VBN
18637	17095	31	from	from	IN
18637	17095	32	the	the	DT
18637	17095	33	facts	fact	NNS
18637	17095	34	that	that	WDT
18637	17095	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17095	36	had	have	VBD
18637	17095	37	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	17095	38	fired	fire	VBN
18637	17095	39	the	the	DT
18637	17095	40	guns	gun	NNS
18637	17095	41	of	of	IN
18637	17095	42	the	the	DT
18637	17095	43	fort	fort	NN
18637	17095	44	across	across	IN
18637	17095	45	the	the	DT
18637	17095	46	land	land	NN
18637	17095	47	and	and	CC
18637	17095	48	had	have	VBD
18637	17095	49	established	establish	VBN
18637	17095	50	a	a	DT
18637	17095	51	fire	fire	NN
18637	17095	52	control	control	NN
18637	17095	53	service	service	NN
18637	17095	54	there	there	RB
18637	17095	55	.	.	.
18637	17096	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17096	2	283	283	CD
18637	17096	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17096	4	A	a	DT
18637	17096	5	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	17096	6	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	17096	7	by	by	IN
18637	17096	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17096	9	to	to	TO
18637	17096	10	construct	construct	VB
18637	17096	11	a	a	DT
18637	17096	12	tunnel	tunnel	NN
18637	17096	13	and	and	CC
18637	17096	14	operate	operate	VB
18637	17096	15	railway	railway	NN
18637	17096	16	trains	train	NNS
18637	17096	17	therein	therein	RB
18637	17096	18	was	be	VBD
18637	17096	19	held	hold	VBN
18637	17096	20	liable	liable	JJ
18637	17096	21	for	for	IN
18637	17096	22	damages	damage	NNS
18637	17096	23	in	in	IN
18637	17096	24	the	the	DT
18637	17096	25	suit	suit	NN
18637	17096	26	by	by	IN
18637	17096	27	an	an	DT
18637	17096	28	individual	individual	NN
18637	17096	29	whose	whose	WP$
18637	17096	30	property	property	NN
18637	17096	31	was	be	VBD
18637	17096	32	so	so	RB
18637	17096	33	injured	injure	VBN
18637	17096	34	by	by	IN
18637	17096	35	smoke	smoke	NN
18637	17096	36	and	and	CC
18637	17096	37	gas	gas	NN
18637	17096	38	forced	force	VBN
18637	17096	39	from	from	IN
18637	17096	40	the	the	DT
18637	17096	41	tunnel	tunnel	NN
18637	17096	42	as	as	IN
18637	17096	43	to	to	TO
18637	17096	44	amount	amount	VB
18637	17096	45	to	to	IN
18637	17096	46	a	a	DT
18637	17096	47	taking	taking	NN
18637	17096	48	of	of	IN
18637	17096	49	private	private	JJ
18637	17096	50	property	property	NN
18637	17096	51	.	.	.
18637	17097	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17097	2	284	284	CD
18637	17097	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17097	4	Navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	17097	5	Waters	Waters	NNPS
18637	17097	6	Riparian	riparian	JJ
18637	17097	7	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	17097	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	17097	9	subject	subject	JJ
18637	17097	10	to	to	IN
18637	17097	11	the	the	DT
18637	17097	12	power	power	NN
18637	17097	13	of	of	IN
18637	17097	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17097	15	to	to	TO
18637	17097	16	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	17097	17	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	17097	18	.	.	.
18637	17098	1	When	when	WRB
18637	17098	2	damage	damage	NN
18637	17098	3	results	result	NNS
18637	17098	4	consequentially	consequentially	RB
18637	17098	5	from	from	IN
18637	17098	6	an	an	DT
18637	17098	7	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	17098	8	of	of	IN
18637	17098	9	a	a	DT
18637	17098	10	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	17098	11	river	river	NN
18637	17098	12	,	,	,
18637	17098	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17098	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	17098	15	not	not	RB
18637	17098	16	a	a	DT
18637	17098	17	taking	taking	NN
18637	17098	18	of	of	IN
18637	17098	19	property	property	NN
18637	17098	20	,	,	,
18637	17098	21	but	but	CC
18637	17098	22	merely	merely	RB
18637	17098	23	the	the	DT
18637	17098	24	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	17098	25	of	of	IN
18637	17098	26	a	a	DT
18637	17098	27	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	17098	28	to	to	TO
18637	17098	29	which	which	WDT
18637	17098	30	the	the	DT
18637	17098	31	property	property	NN
18637	17098	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	17098	33	always	always	RB
18637	17098	34	subject	subject	JJ
18637	17098	35	.	.	.
18637	17099	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17099	2	285	285	CD
18637	17099	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17099	4	What	what	WP
18637	17099	5	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	17099	6	a	a	DT
18637	17099	7	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	17099	8	river	river	NN
18637	17099	9	within	within	IN
18637	17099	10	the	the	DT
18637	17099	11	purview	purview	NN
18637	17099	12	of	of	IN
18637	17099	13	the	the	DT
18637	17099	14	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	17099	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	17099	16	often	often	RB
18637	17099	17	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	17099	18	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	17099	19	disputed	dispute	VBN
18637	17099	20	issues	issue	NNS
18637	17099	21	of	of	IN
18637	17099	22	fact	fact	NN
18637	17099	23	and	and	CC
18637	17099	24	of	of	IN
18637	17099	25	law	law	NN
18637	17099	26	.	.	.
18637	17100	1	In	in	IN
18637	17100	2	the	the	DT
18637	17100	3	leading	leading	JJ
18637	17100	4	case	case	NN
18637	17100	5	of	of	IN
18637	17100	6	The	the	DT
18637	17100	7	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	17100	8	Ball[286	ball[286	NN
18637	17100	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17100	10	the	the	DT
18637	17100	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17100	12	laid	lay	VBD
18637	17100	13	down	down	RP
18637	17100	14	the	the	DT
18637	17100	15	rule	rule	NN
18637	17100	16	that	that	WDT
18637	17100	17	:	:	:
18637	17100	18	"	"	``
18637	17100	19	Those	those	DT
18637	17100	20	rivers	river	NNS
18637	17100	21	must	must	MD
18637	17100	22	be	be	VB
18637	17100	23	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	17100	24	as	as	IN
18637	17100	25	public	public	JJ
18637	17100	26	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	17100	27	rivers	river	NNS
18637	17100	28	in	in	IN
18637	17100	29	law	law	NN
18637	17100	30	which	which	WDT
18637	17100	31	are	be	VBP
18637	17100	32	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	17100	33	in	in	IN
18637	17100	34	fact	fact	NN
18637	17100	35	.	.	.
18637	17101	1	And	and	CC
18637	17101	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17101	3	are	be	VBP
18637	17101	4	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	17101	5	in	in	IN
18637	17101	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	17101	7	when	when	WRB
18637	17101	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17101	9	are	be	VBP
18637	17101	10	used	use	VBN
18637	17101	11	,	,	,
18637	17101	12	or	or	CC
18637	17101	13	are	be	VBP
18637	17101	14	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
18637	17101	15	of	of	IN
18637	17101	16	being	be	VBG
18637	17101	17	used	use	VBN
18637	17101	18	,	,	,
18637	17101	19	as	as	IN
18637	17101	20	highways	highway	NNS
18637	17101	21	for	for	IN
18637	17101	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	17101	23	,	,	,
18637	17101	24	over	over	IN
18637	17101	25	which	which	WDT
18637	17101	26	trade	trade	NN
18637	17101	27	and	and	CC
18637	17101	28	travel	travel	NN
18637	17101	29	are	be	VBP
18637	17101	30	or	or	CC
18637	17101	31	may	may	MD
18637	17101	32	be	be	VB
18637	17101	33	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	17101	34	in	in	IN
18637	17101	35	the	the	DT
18637	17101	36	customary	customary	JJ
18637	17101	37	modes	mode	NNS
18637	17101	38	of	of	IN
18637	17101	39	trade	trade	NN
18637	17101	40	and	and	CC
18637	17101	41	travel	travel	NN
18637	17101	42	on	on	IN
18637	17101	43	water	water	NN
18637	17101	44	.	.	.
18637	17102	1	"	"	``
18637	17102	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17102	3	287	287	CD
18637	17102	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17102	5	In	in	IN
18637	17102	6	1940	1940	CD
18637	17102	7	,	,	,
18637	17102	8	over	over	IN
18637	17102	9	the	the	DT
18637	17102	10	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	17102	11	of	of	IN
18637	17102	12	two	two	CD
18637	17102	13	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	17102	14	,	,	,
18637	17102	15	the	the	DT
18637	17102	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17102	17	held	hold	VBD
18637	17102	18	that	that	IN
18637	17102	19	the	the	DT
18637	17102	20	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	17102	21	"	"	``
18637	17102	22	natural	natural	JJ
18637	17102	23	and	and	CC
18637	17102	24	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	17102	25	condition	condition	NN
18637	17102	26	"	"	''
18637	17102	27	refers	refer	VBZ
18637	17102	28	to	to	IN
18637	17102	29	volume	volume	NN
18637	17102	30	of	of	IN
18637	17102	31	water	water	NN
18637	17102	32	,	,	,
18637	17102	33	the	the	DT
18637	17102	34	gradients	gradient	NNS
18637	17102	35	and	and	CC
18637	17102	36	the	the	DT
18637	17102	37	regularity	regularity	NN
18637	17102	38	of	of	IN
18637	17102	39	the	the	DT
18637	17102	40	flow	flow	NN
18637	17102	41	.	.	.
18637	17103	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17103	2	further	further	RB
18637	17103	3	held	hold	VBD
18637	17103	4	that	that	IN
18637	17103	5	in	in	IN
18637	17103	6	determining	determine	VBG
18637	17103	7	the	the	DT
18637	17103	8	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	17103	9	character	character	NN
18637	17103	10	of	of	IN
18637	17103	11	a	a	DT
18637	17103	12	river	river	NN
18637	17103	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17103	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	17103	15	proper	proper	JJ
18637	17103	16	to	to	TO
18637	17103	17	consider	consider	VB
18637	17103	18	"	"	``
18637	17103	19	the	the	DT
18637	17103	20	feasibility	feasibility	NN
18637	17103	21	of	of	IN
18637	17103	22	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	17103	23	use	use	NN
18637	17103	24	after	after	IN
18637	17103	25	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	17103	26	improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	17103	27	which	which	WDT
18637	17103	28	might	may	MD
18637	17103	29	be	be	VB
18637	17103	30	made	make	VBN
18637	17103	31	.	.	.
18637	17104	1	"	"	``
18637	17104	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17104	3	288	288	CD
18637	17104	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17104	5	A	a	DT
18637	17104	6	few	few	JJ
18637	17104	7	months	month	NNS
18637	17104	8	later	later	RB
18637	17104	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17104	10	decided	decide	VBD
18637	17104	11	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	17104	12	that	that	IN
18637	17104	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17104	14	may	may	MD
18637	17104	15	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	17104	16	the	the	DT
18637	17104	17	power	power	NN
18637	17104	18	of	of	IN
18637	17104	19	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	17104	20	domain	domain	NN
18637	17104	21	in	in	IN
18637	17104	22	connection	connection	NN
18637	17104	23	with	with	IN
18637	17104	24	the	the	DT
18637	17104	25	construction	construction	NN
18637	17104	26	of	of	IN
18637	17104	27	a	a	DT
18637	17104	28	dam	dam	NN
18637	17104	29	and	and	CC
18637	17104	30	reservoir	reservoir	NN
18637	17104	31	on	on	IN
18637	17104	32	the	the	DT
18637	17104	33	nonnavigable	nonnavigable	JJ
18637	17104	34	stretches	stretch	NNS
18637	17104	35	of	of	IN
18637	17104	36	a	a	DT
18637	17104	37	river	river	NN
18637	17104	38	in	in	IN
18637	17104	39	order	order	NN
18637	17104	40	to	to	TO
18637	17104	41	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	17104	42	or	or	CC
18637	17104	43	promote	promote	VB
18637	17104	44	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	17104	45	on	on	IN
18637	17104	46	the	the	DT
18637	17104	47	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	17104	48	portions	portion	NNS
18637	17104	49	.	.	.
18637	17105	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17105	2	289	289	CD
18637	17105	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17105	4	The	the	DT
18637	17105	5	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17105	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	17105	7	not	not	RB
18637	17105	8	have	have	VB
18637	17105	9	to	to	TO
18637	17105	10	compensate	compensate	VB
18637	17105	11	a	a	DT
18637	17105	12	riparian	riparian	JJ
18637	17105	13	owner	owner	NN
18637	17105	14	for	for	IN
18637	17105	15	cutting	cut	VBG
18637	17105	16	off	off	RP
18637	17105	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17105	18	access	access	NN
18637	17105	19	to	to	IN
18637	17105	20	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	17105	21	waters	water	NNS
18637	17105	22	by	by	IN
18637	17105	23	changing	change	VBG
18637	17105	24	the	the	DT
18637	17105	25	course	course	NN
18637	17105	26	of	of	IN
18637	17105	27	the	the	DT
18637	17105	28	stream	stream	NN
18637	17105	29	in	in	IN
18637	17105	30	order	order	NN
18637	17105	31	to	to	TO
18637	17105	32	improve	improve	VB
18637	17105	33	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	17105	34	.	.	.
18637	17106	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17106	2	290	290	CD
18637	17106	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17106	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	17106	5	submerged	submerged	JJ
18637	17106	6	land	land	NN
18637	17106	7	under	under	IN
18637	17106	8	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	17106	9	waters	water	NNS
18637	17106	10	of	of	IN
18637	17106	11	a	a	DT
18637	17106	12	bay	bay	NN
18637	17106	13	are	be	VBP
18637	17106	14	planted	plant	VBN
18637	17106	15	with	with	IN
18637	17106	16	oysters	oyster	NNS
18637	17106	17	,	,	,
18637	17106	18	the	the	DT
18637	17106	19	action	action	NN
18637	17106	20	of	of	IN
18637	17106	21	the	the	DT
18637	17106	22	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17106	23	in	in	IN
18637	17106	24	dredging	dredge	VBG
18637	17106	25	a	a	DT
18637	17106	26	channel	channel	NN
18637	17106	27	across	across	IN
18637	17106	28	the	the	DT
18637	17106	29	bay	bay	NN
18637	17106	30	in	in	IN
18637	17106	31	such	such	PDT
18637	17106	32	a	a	DT
18637	17106	33	way	way	NN
18637	17106	34	as	as	IN
18637	17106	35	to	to	TO
18637	17106	36	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	17106	37	the	the	DT
18637	17106	38	oyster	oyster	JJ
18637	17106	39	bed	bed	NN
18637	17106	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	17106	41	not	not	RB
18637	17106	42	a	a	DT
18637	17106	43	"	"	``
18637	17106	44	taking	taking	NN
18637	17106	45	"	"	''
18637	17106	46	of	of	IN
18637	17106	47	property	property	NN
18637	17106	48	in	in	IN
18637	17106	49	the	the	DT
18637	17106	50	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17106	51	sense	sense	NN
18637	17106	52	.	.	.
18637	17107	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17107	2	291	291	CD
18637	17107	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17107	4	The	the	DT
18637	17107	5	determination	determination	NN
18637	17107	6	by	by	IN
18637	17107	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17107	8	that	that	IN
18637	17107	9	the	the	DT
18637	17107	10	whole	whole	JJ
18637	17107	11	flow	flow	NN
18637	17107	12	of	of	IN
18637	17107	13	a	a	DT
18637	17107	14	stream	stream	NN
18637	17107	15	should	should	MD
18637	17107	16	be	be	VB
18637	17107	17	devoted	devote	VBN
18637	17107	18	to	to	IN
18637	17107	19	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	17107	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	17107	21	not	not	RB
18637	17107	22	take	take	VB
18637	17107	23	any	any	DT
18637	17107	24	private	private	JJ
18637	17107	25	property	property	NN
18637	17107	26	rights	right	NNS
18637	17107	27	of	of	IN
18637	17107	28	a	a	DT
18637	17107	29	water	water	NN
18637	17107	30	power	power	NN
18637	17107	31	company	company	NN
18637	17107	32	which	which	WDT
18637	17107	33	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	17107	34	a	a	DT
18637	17107	35	revocable	revocable	JJ
18637	17107	36	permit	permit	NN
18637	17107	37	to	to	TO
18637	17107	38	erect	erect	VB
18637	17107	39	dams	dam	NNS
18637	17107	40	and	and	CC
18637	17107	41	dykes	dyke	VBZ
18637	17107	42	for	for	IN
18637	17107	43	the	the	DT
18637	17107	44	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	17107	45	of	of	IN
18637	17107	46	controlling	control	VBG
18637	17107	47	the	the	DT
18637	17107	48	current	current	NN
18637	17107	49	and	and	CC
18637	17107	50	using	use	VBG
18637	17107	51	the	the	DT
18637	17107	52	power	power	NN
18637	17107	53	for	for	IN
18637	17107	54	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	17107	55	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	17107	56	.	.	.
18637	17108	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17108	2	292	292	CD
18637	17108	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17108	4	The	the	DT
18637	17108	5	interest	interest	NN
18637	17108	6	of	of	IN
18637	17108	7	a	a	DT
18637	17108	8	riparian	riparian	JJ
18637	17108	9	owner	owner	NN
18637	17108	10	in	in	IN
18637	17108	11	keeping	keep	VBG
18637	17108	12	the	the	DT
18637	17108	13	level	level	NN
18637	17108	14	of	of	IN
18637	17108	15	a	a	DT
18637	17108	16	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	17108	17	stream	stream	NN
18637	17108	18	low	low	JJ
18637	17108	19	enough	enough	RB
18637	17108	20	to	to	TO
18637	17108	21	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	17108	22	a	a	DT
18637	17108	23	power	power	NN
18637	17108	24	head	head	NN
18637	17108	25	for	for	IN
18637	17108	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17108	27	use	use	NN
18637	17108	28	was	be	VBD
18637	17108	29	not	not	RB
18637	17108	30	one	one	CD
18637	17108	31	for	for	IN
18637	17108	32	which	which	WDT
18637	17108	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17108	34	was	be	VBD
18637	17108	35	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	17108	36	to	to	TO
18637	17108	37	be	be	VB
18637	17108	38	compensated	compensate	VBN
18637	17108	39	when	when	WRB
18637	17108	40	the	the	DT
18637	17108	41	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17108	42	raised	raise	VBD
18637	17108	43	the	the	DT
18637	17108	44	level	level	NN
18637	17108	45	by	by	IN
18637	17108	46	erecting	erect	VBG
18637	17108	47	a	a	DT
18637	17108	48	dam	dam	NN
18637	17108	49	to	to	TO
18637	17108	50	improve	improve	VB
18637	17108	51	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	17108	52	.	.	.
18637	17109	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17109	2	293	293	CD
18637	17109	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17109	4	Inasmuch	Inasmuch	NNP
18637	17109	5	as	as	IN
18637	17109	6	a	a	DT
18637	17109	7	riparian	riparian	JJ
18637	17109	8	owner	owner	NN
18637	17109	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	17109	10	no	no	DT
18637	17109	11	private	private	JJ
18637	17109	12	property	property	NN
18637	17109	13	in	in	IN
18637	17109	14	the	the	DT
18637	17109	15	flow	flow	NN
18637	17109	16	of	of	IN
18637	17109	17	the	the	DT
18637	17109	18	stream	stream	NN
18637	17109	19	,	,	,
18637	17109	20	a	a	DT
18637	17109	21	license	license	NN
18637	17109	22	to	to	TO
18637	17109	23	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	17109	24	a	a	DT
18637	17109	25	hydroelectric	hydroelectric	JJ
18637	17109	26	dam	dam	NN
18637	17109	27	,	,	,
18637	17109	28	may	may	MD
18637	17109	29	,	,	,
18637	17109	30	without	without	IN
18637	17109	31	offending	offend	VBG
18637	17109	32	the	the	DT
18637	17109	33	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	17109	34	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17109	35	,	,	,
18637	17109	36	contain	contain	VB
18637	17109	37	a	a	DT
18637	17109	38	provision	provision	NN
18637	17109	39	giving	give	VBG
18637	17109	40	the	the	DT
18637	17109	41	United	United	NNP
18637	17109	42	States	States	NNP
18637	17109	43	an	an	DT
18637	17109	44	option	option	NN
18637	17109	45	to	to	TO
18637	17109	46	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	17109	47	the	the	DT
18637	17109	48	property	property	NN
18637	17109	49	at	at	IN
18637	17109	50	a	a	DT
18637	17109	51	value	value	NN
18637	17109	52	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	17109	53	to	to	TO
18637	17109	54	be	be	VB
18637	17109	55	less	less	JJR
18637	17109	56	than	than	IN
18637	17109	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17109	58	fair	fair	JJ
18637	17109	59	value	value	NN
18637	17109	60	at	at	IN
18637	17109	61	the	the	DT
18637	17109	62	time	time	NN
18637	17109	63	of	of	IN
18637	17109	64	taking	take	VBG
18637	17109	65	.	.	.
18637	17110	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17110	2	294	294	CD
18637	17110	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17110	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	17110	5	the	the	DT
18637	17110	6	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17110	7	erects	erect	VBZ
18637	17110	8	dams	dam	NNS
18637	17110	9	and	and	CC
18637	17110	10	other	other	JJ
18637	17110	11	obstructions	obstruction	NNS
18637	17110	12	across	across	IN
18637	17110	13	a	a	DT
18637	17110	14	river	river	NN
18637	17110	15	,	,	,
18637	17110	16	causing	cause	VBG
18637	17110	17	an	an	DT
18637	17110	18	overflow	overflow	NN
18637	17110	19	of	of	IN
18637	17110	20	water	water	NN
18637	17110	21	which	which	WDT
18637	17110	22	renders	render	VBZ
18637	17110	23	the	the	DT
18637	17110	24	property	property	NN
18637	17110	25	affected	affect	VBD
18637	17110	26	unfit	unfit	JJ
18637	17110	27	for	for	IN
18637	17110	28	agricultural	agricultural	JJ
18637	17110	29	use	use	NN
18637	17110	30	and	and	CC
18637	17110	31	deprives	deprive	VBZ
18637	17110	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17110	33	of	of	IN
18637	17110	34	all	all	DT
18637	17110	35	value	value	NN
18637	17110	36	,	,	,
18637	17110	37	there	there	EX
18637	17110	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	17110	39	taking	take	VBG
18637	17110	40	of	of	IN
18637	17110	41	property	property	NN
18637	17110	42	for	for	IN
18637	17110	43	which	which	WDT
18637	17110	44	the	the	DT
18637	17110	45	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17110	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	17110	47	under	under	IN
18637	17110	48	an	an	DT
18637	17110	49	implied	imply	VBN
18637	17110	50	contract	contract	NN
18637	17110	51	to	to	TO
18637	17110	52	make	make	VB
18637	17110	53	just	just	RB
18637	17110	54	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17110	55	.	.	.
18637	17111	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17111	2	295	295	CD
18637	17111	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17111	4	The	the	DT
18637	17111	5	construction	construction	NN
18637	17111	6	of	of	IN
18637	17111	7	locks	lock	NNS
18637	17111	8	and	and	CC
18637	17111	9	for	for	IN
18637	17111	10	"	"	``
18637	17111	11	canalizing	canalize	VBG
18637	17111	12	"	"	''
18637	17111	13	a	a	DT
18637	17111	14	river	river	NN
18637	17111	15	,	,	,
18637	17111	16	which	which	WDT
18637	17111	17	cause	cause	VBP
18637	17111	18	recurrent	recurrent	JJ
18637	17111	19	overflows	overflow	NNS
18637	17111	20	,	,	,
18637	17111	21	impairing	impair	VBG
18637	17111	22	but	but	CC
18637	17111	23	not	not	RB
18637	17111	24	destroying	destroy	VBG
18637	17111	25	the	the	DT
18637	17111	26	value	value	NN
18637	17111	27	of	of	IN
18637	17111	28	the	the	DT
18637	17111	29	land	land	NN
18637	17111	30	amounts	amount	VBZ
18637	17111	31	to	to	IN
18637	17111	32	a	a	DT
18637	17111	33	partial	partial	JJ
18637	17111	34	taking	taking	NN
18637	17111	35	of	of	IN
18637	17111	36	property	property	NN
18637	17111	37	within	within	IN
18637	17111	38	the	the	DT
18637	17111	39	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	17111	40	of	of	IN
18637	17111	41	the	the	DT
18637	17111	42	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	17111	43	Amendment;--the	amendment;--the	DT
18637	17111	44	fee	fee	NN
18637	17111	45	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	17111	46	in	in	IN
18637	17111	47	the	the	DT
18637	17111	48	owner	owner	NN
18637	17111	49	,	,	,
18637	17111	50	subject	subject	JJ
18637	17111	51	to	to	IN
18637	17111	52	an	an	DT
18637	17111	53	easement	easement	NN
18637	17111	54	in	in	IN
18637	17111	55	the	the	DT
18637	17111	56	United	United	NNP
18637	17111	57	States	States	NNP
18637	17111	58	to	to	TO
18637	17111	59	overflow	overflow	VB
18637	17111	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17111	61	as	as	RB
18637	17111	62	often	often	RB
18637	17111	63	as	as	IN
18637	17111	64	may	may	MD
18637	17111	65	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	17111	66	result	result	VB
18637	17111	67	from	from	IN
18637	17111	68	the	the	DT
18637	17111	69	operation	operation	NN
18637	17111	70	of	of	IN
18637	17111	71	the	the	DT
18637	17111	72	lock	lock	NN
18637	17111	73	and	and	CC
18637	17111	74	dam	dam	NN
18637	17111	75	for	for	IN
18637	17111	76	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	17111	77	of	of	IN
18637	17111	78	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	17111	79	.	.	.
18637	17112	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17112	2	296	296	CD
18637	17112	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17112	4	Compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17112	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	17112	6	been	be	VBN
18637	17112	7	awarded	award	VBN
18637	17112	8	for	for	IN
18637	17112	9	the	the	DT
18637	17112	10	erosion	erosion	NN
18637	17112	11	of	of	IN
18637	17112	12	land	land	NN
18637	17112	13	by	by	IN
18637	17112	14	waters	water	NNS
18637	17112	15	impounded	impound	VBN
18637	17112	16	by	by	IN
18637	17112	17	a	a	DT
18637	17112	18	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17112	19	dam,[297	dam,[297	NNS
18637	17112	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17112	21	and	and	CC
18637	17112	22	for	for	IN
18637	17112	23	the	the	DT
18637	17112	24	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	17112	25	of	of	IN
18637	17112	26	the	the	DT
18637	17112	27	agricultural	agricultural	JJ
18637	17112	28	value	value	NN
18637	17112	29	of	of	IN
18637	17112	30	land	land	NN
18637	17112	31	located	locate	VBN
18637	17112	32	on	on	IN
18637	17112	33	a	a	DT
18637	17112	34	nonnavigable	nonnavigable	JJ
18637	17112	35	tributary	tributary	NN
18637	17112	36	of	of	IN
18637	17112	37	the	the	DT
18637	17112	38	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	17112	39	River	River	NNP
18637	17112	40	,	,	,
18637	17112	41	which	which	WDT
18637	17112	42	as	as	IN
18637	17112	43	a	a	DT
18637	17112	44	result	result	NN
18637	17112	45	of	of	IN
18637	17112	46	the	the	DT
18637	17112	47	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	17112	48	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	17112	49	of	of	IN
18637	17112	50	the	the	DT
18637	17112	51	river	river	NN
18637	17112	52	's	's	POS
18637	17112	53	level	level	NN
18637	17112	54	at	at	IN
18637	17112	55	high	high	JJ
18637	17112	56	water	water	NN
18637	17112	57	mark	mark	NN
18637	17112	58	,	,	,
18637	17112	59	was	be	VBD
18637	17112	60	permanently	permanently	RB
18637	17112	61	invaded	invade	VBN
18637	17112	62	by	by	IN
18637	17112	63	the	the	DT
18637	17112	64	percolation	percolation	NN
18637	17112	65	of	of	IN
18637	17112	66	the	the	DT
18637	17112	67	waters	water	NNS
18637	17112	68	,	,	,
18637	17112	69	and	and	CC
18637	17112	70	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17112	71	drainage	drainage	NN
18637	17112	72	obstructed	obstruct	VBN
18637	17112	73	.	.	.
18637	17113	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17113	2	298	298	CD
18637	17113	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17113	4	When	when	WRB
18637	17113	5	the	the	DT
18637	17113	6	construction	construction	NN
18637	17113	7	of	of	IN
18637	17113	8	locks	lock	NNS
18637	17113	9	and	and	CC
18637	17113	10	dams	dam	NNS
18637	17113	11	raised	raise	VBD
18637	17113	12	the	the	DT
18637	17113	13	water	water	NN
18637	17113	14	in	in	IN
18637	17113	15	a	a	DT
18637	17113	16	nonnavigable	nonnavigable	JJ
18637	17113	17	creek	creek	NN
18637	17113	18	to	to	IN
18637	17113	19	about	about	RB
18637	17113	20	one	one	CD
18637	17113	21	foot	foot	NN
18637	17113	22	below	below	IN
18637	17113	23	the	the	DT
18637	17113	24	crest	crest	NN
18637	17113	25	of	of	IN
18637	17113	26	an	an	DT
18637	17113	27	upper	upper	JJ
18637	17113	28	milldam	milldam	NN
18637	17113	29	,	,	,
18637	17113	30	thus	thus	RB
18637	17113	31	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	17113	32	the	the	DT
18637	17113	33	drop	drop	NN
18637	17113	34	in	in	IN
18637	17113	35	the	the	DT
18637	17113	36	current	current	JJ
18637	17113	37	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	17113	38	to	to	TO
18637	17113	39	run	run	VB
18637	17113	40	the	the	DT
18637	17113	41	mill	mill	NN
18637	17113	42	,	,	,
18637	17113	43	there	there	EX
18637	17113	44	was	be	VBD
18637	17113	45	a	a	DT
18637	17113	46	taking	taking	NN
18637	17113	47	of	of	IN
18637	17113	48	property	property	NN
18637	17113	49	in	in	IN
18637	17113	50	the	the	DT
18637	17113	51	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17113	52	sense	sense	NN
18637	17113	53	.	.	.
18637	17114	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17114	2	299	299	CD
18637	17114	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17114	4	A	a	DT
18637	17114	5	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	17114	6	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	17114	7	was	be	VBD
18637	17114	8	reached	reach	VBN
18637	17114	9	with	with	IN
18637	17114	10	respect	respect	NN
18637	17114	11	to	to	IN
18637	17114	12	the	the	DT
18637	17114	13	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	17114	14	of	of	IN
18637	17114	15	property	property	NN
18637	17114	16	of	of	IN
18637	17114	17	the	the	DT
18637	17114	18	owner	owner	NN
18637	17114	19	of	of	IN
18637	17114	20	a	a	DT
18637	17114	21	lake	lake	NN
18637	17114	22	through	through	IN
18637	17114	23	the	the	DT
18637	17114	24	raising	raising	NN
18637	17114	25	of	of	IN
18637	17114	26	the	the	DT
18637	17114	27	lake	lake	NN
18637	17114	28	level	level	NN
18637	17114	29	as	as	IN
18637	17114	30	a	a	DT
18637	17114	31	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	17114	32	of	of	IN
18637	17114	33	an	an	DT
18637	17114	34	irrigation	irrigation	NN
18637	17114	35	project	project	NN
18637	17114	36	,	,	,
18637	17114	37	where	where	WRB
18637	17114	38	the	the	DT
18637	17114	39	result	result	NN
18637	17114	40	to	to	IN
18637	17114	41	the	the	DT
18637	17114	42	lake	lake	NN
18637	17114	43	owner	owner	NN
18637	17114	44	's	's	POS
18637	17114	45	property	property	NN
18637	17114	46	could	could	MD
18637	17114	47	not	not	RB
18637	17114	48	have	have	VB
18637	17114	49	been	be	VBN
18637	17114	50	foreseen	foresee	VBN
18637	17114	51	.	.	.
18637	17115	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17115	2	300	300	CD
18637	17115	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17115	4	JUST	just	RB
18637	17115	5	COMPENSATION	COMPENSATION	VBN
18637	17115	6	If	if	IN
18637	17115	7	only	only	RB
18637	17115	8	a	a	DT
18637	17115	9	portion	portion	NN
18637	17115	10	of	of	IN
18637	17115	11	a	a	DT
18637	17115	12	single	single	JJ
18637	17115	13	tract	tract	NN
18637	17115	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	17115	15	taken	take	VBN
18637	17115	16	,	,	,
18637	17115	17	the	the	DT
18637	17115	18	owner	owner	NN
18637	17115	19	's	's	POS
18637	17115	20	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17115	21	includes	include	VBZ
18637	17115	22	any	any	DT
18637	17115	23	element	element	NN
18637	17115	24	of	of	IN
18637	17115	25	value	value	NN
18637	17115	26	arising	arise	VBG
18637	17115	27	out	out	IN
18637	17115	28	of	of	IN
18637	17115	29	the	the	DT
18637	17115	30	relation	relation	NN
18637	17115	31	of	of	IN
18637	17115	32	the	the	DT
18637	17115	33	part	part	NN
18637	17115	34	taken	take	VBN
18637	17115	35	to	to	IN
18637	17115	36	the	the	DT
18637	17115	37	entire	entire	JJ
18637	17115	38	tract	tract	NN
18637	17115	39	.	.	.
18637	17116	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17116	2	301	301	CD
18637	17116	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17116	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	17116	5	,	,	,
18637	17116	6	where	where	WRB
18637	17116	7	the	the	DT
18637	17116	8	taking	taking	NN
18637	17116	9	of	of	IN
18637	17116	10	a	a	DT
18637	17116	11	strip	strip	NN
18637	17116	12	of	of	IN
18637	17116	13	land	land	NN
18637	17116	14	across	across	IN
18637	17116	15	a	a	DT
18637	17116	16	farm	farm	NN
18637	17116	17	closed	close	VBD
18637	17116	18	a	a	DT
18637	17116	19	private	private	JJ
18637	17116	20	right	right	NN
18637	17116	21	of	of	IN
18637	17116	22	way	way	NN
18637	17116	23	,	,	,
18637	17116	24	an	an	DT
18637	17116	25	allowance	allowance	NN
18637	17116	26	was	be	VBD
18637	17116	27	properly	properly	RB
18637	17116	28	made	make	VBN
18637	17116	29	for	for	IN
18637	17116	30	value	value	NN
18637	17116	31	of	of	IN
18637	17116	32	the	the	DT
18637	17116	33	easement	easement	NN
18637	17116	34	.	.	.
18637	17117	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17117	2	302	302	CD
18637	17117	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17117	4	On	on	IN
18637	17117	5	the	the	DT
18637	17117	6	other	other	JJ
18637	17117	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	17117	8	,	,	,
18637	17117	9	if	if	IN
18637	17117	10	the	the	DT
18637	17117	11	taking	taking	NN
18637	17117	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	17117	13	in	in	IN
18637	17117	14	fact	fact	NN
18637	17117	15	benefited	benefit	VBD
18637	17117	16	the	the	DT
18637	17117	17	owner	owner	NN
18637	17117	18	,	,	,
18637	17117	19	the	the	DT
18637	17117	20	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	17117	21	may	may	MD
18637	17117	22	be	be	VB
18637	17117	23	set	set	VBN
18637	17117	24	off	off	RP
18637	17117	25	against	against	IN
18637	17117	26	the	the	DT
18637	17117	27	value	value	NN
18637	17117	28	of	of	IN
18637	17117	29	the	the	DT
18637	17117	30	land	land	NN
18637	17117	31	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	17117	32	.	.	.
18637	17118	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17118	2	303	303	CD
18637	17118	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17118	4	But	but	CC
18637	17118	5	there	there	EX
18637	17118	6	may	may	MD
18637	17118	7	not	not	RB
18637	17118	8	be	be	VB
18637	17118	9	taken	take	VBN
18637	17118	10	into	into	IN
18637	17118	11	account	account	NN
18637	17118	12	any	any	DT
18637	17118	13	supposed	suppose	VBN
18637	17118	14	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	17118	15	which	which	WDT
18637	17118	16	the	the	DT
18637	17118	17	owner	owner	NN
18637	17118	18	may	may	MD
18637	17118	19	receive	receive	VB
18637	17118	20	in	in	IN
18637	17118	21	common	common	NN
18637	17118	22	with	with	IN
18637	17118	23	all	all	DT
18637	17118	24	from	from	IN
18637	17118	25	the	the	DT
18637	17118	26	public	public	JJ
18637	17118	27	use	use	NN
18637	17118	28	to	to	TO
18637	17118	29	which	which	WDT
18637	17118	30	the	the	DT
18637	17118	31	property	property	NN
18637	17118	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	17118	33	appropriated	appropriate	VBN
18637	17118	34	.	.	.
18637	17119	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17119	2	304	304	CD
18637	17119	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17119	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	17119	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17119	6	condemned	condemn	VBD
18637	17119	7	certain	certain	JJ
18637	17119	8	lands	land	NNS
18637	17119	9	for	for	IN
18637	17119	10	park	park	NN
18637	17119	11	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	17119	12	,	,	,
18637	17119	13	setting	set	VBG
18637	17119	14	off	off	RP
18637	17119	15	resulting	result	VBG
18637	17119	16	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	17119	17	against	against	IN
18637	17119	18	the	the	DT
18637	17119	19	value	value	NN
18637	17119	20	of	of	IN
18637	17119	21	property	property	NN
18637	17119	22	taken	take	VBN
18637	17119	23	,	,	,
18637	17119	24	and	and	CC
18637	17119	25	by	by	IN
18637	17119	26	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	17119	27	act	act	NN
18637	17119	28	directed	direct	VBD
18637	17119	29	the	the	DT
18637	17119	30	erection	erection	NN
18637	17119	31	of	of	IN
18637	17119	32	a	a	DT
18637	17119	33	fire	fire	NN
18637	17119	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	17119	35	station	station	NN
18637	17119	36	house	house	NN
18637	17119	37	therein	therein	RB
18637	17119	38	,	,	,
18637	17119	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17119	40	was	be	VBD
18637	17119	41	held	hold	VBN
18637	17119	42	that	that	IN
18637	17119	43	property	property	NN
18637	17119	44	was	be	VBD
18637	17119	45	not	not	RB
18637	17119	46	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	17119	47	taken	take	VBN
18637	17119	48	without	without	IN
18637	17119	49	just	just	RB
18637	17119	50	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17119	51	.	.	.
18637	17120	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17120	2	305	305	CD
18637	17120	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17120	4	The	the	DT
18637	17120	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	17120	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	17120	7	not	not	RB
18637	17120	8	require	require	VB
18637	17120	9	payment	payment	NN
18637	17120	10	of	of	IN
18637	17120	11	consequential	consequential	JJ
18637	17120	12	damages	damage	NNS
18637	17120	13	to	to	IN
18637	17120	14	other	other	JJ
18637	17120	15	property	property	NN
18637	17120	16	of	of	IN
18637	17120	17	the	the	DT
18637	17120	18	owner	owner	NN
18637	17120	19	consisting	consist	VBG
18637	17120	20	of	of	IN
18637	17120	21	separate	separate	JJ
18637	17120	22	tracts	tract	NNS
18637	17120	23	adjoining	adjoin	VBG
18637	17120	24	that	that	IN
18637	17120	25	affected	affect	VBN
18637	17120	26	by	by	IN
18637	17120	27	the	the	DT
18637	17120	28	taking	taking	NN
18637	17120	29	.	.	.
18637	17121	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17121	2	306	306	CD
18637	17121	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17121	4	Just	just	RB
18637	17121	5	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17121	6	means	mean	VBZ
18637	17121	7	the	the	DT
18637	17121	8	full	full	JJ
18637	17121	9	and	and	CC
18637	17121	10	perfect	perfect	JJ
18637	17121	11	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
18637	17121	12	,	,	,
18637	17121	13	in	in	IN
18637	17121	14	money	money	NN
18637	17121	15	,	,	,
18637	17121	16	of	of	IN
18637	17121	17	the	the	DT
18637	17121	18	property	property	NN
18637	17121	19	taken	take	VBN
18637	17121	20	.	.	.
18637	17122	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17122	2	307	307	CD
18637	17122	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17122	4	The	the	DT
18637	17122	5	owner	owner	NN
18637	17122	6	's	's	POS
18637	17122	7	loss	loss	NN
18637	17122	8	,	,	,
18637	17122	9	not	not	RB
18637	17122	10	the	the	DT
18637	17122	11	taker	taker	NN
18637	17122	12	's	's	POS
18637	17122	13	gain	gain	NN
18637	17122	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	17122	15	the	the	DT
18637	17122	16	measure	measure	NN
18637	17122	17	of	of	IN
18637	17122	18	such	such	JJ
18637	17122	19	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17122	20	.	.	.
18637	17123	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17123	2	308	308	CD
18637	17123	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17123	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	17123	5	the	the	DT
18637	17123	6	property	property	NN
18637	17123	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	17123	8	a	a	DT
18637	17123	9	determinable	determinable	JJ
18637	17123	10	market	market	NN
18637	17123	11	value	value	NN
18637	17123	12	,	,	,
18637	17123	13	that	that	DT
18637	17123	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	17123	15	the	the	DT
18637	17123	16	normal	normal	JJ
18637	17123	17	measure	measure	NN
18637	17123	18	of	of	IN
18637	17123	19	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	17123	20	.	.	.
18637	17124	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17124	2	309	309	CD
18637	17124	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17124	4	Market	market	NN
18637	17124	5	value	value	NN
18637	17124	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	17124	7	"	"	``
18637	17124	8	what	what	WP
18637	17124	9	a	a	DT
18637	17124	10	willing	willing	JJ
18637	17124	11	buyer	buyer	NN
18637	17124	12	would	would	MD
18637	17124	13	pay	pay	VB
18637	17124	14	in	in	IN
18637	17124	15	cash	cash	NN
18637	17124	16	to	to	IN
18637	17124	17	a	a	DT
18637	17124	18	willing	willing	JJ
18637	17124	19	seller	seller	NN
18637	17124	20	.	.	.
18637	17125	1	"	"	``
18637	17125	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17125	3	310	310	CD
18637	17125	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17125	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17125	6	may	may	MD
18637	17125	7	reflect	reflect	VB
18637	17125	8	not	not	RB
18637	17125	9	only	only	RB
18637	17125	10	the	the	DT
18637	17125	11	use	use	NN
18637	17125	12	to	to	TO
18637	17125	13	which	which	WDT
18637	17125	14	the	the	DT
18637	17125	15	property	property	NN
18637	17125	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	17125	17	presently	presently	RB
18637	17125	18	devoted	devoted	JJ
18637	17125	19	but	but	CC
18637	17125	20	also	also	RB
18637	17125	21	that	that	DT
18637	17125	22	to	to	TO
18637	17125	23	which	which	WDT
18637	17125	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17125	25	may	may	MD
18637	17125	26	be	be	VB
18637	17125	27	readily	readily	RB
18637	17125	28	converted	convert	VBN
18637	17125	29	.	.	.
18637	17126	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17126	2	311	311	CD
18637	17126	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17126	4	But	but	CC
18637	17126	5	the	the	DT
18637	17126	6	value	value	NN
18637	17126	7	of	of	IN
18637	17126	8	the	the	DT
18637	17126	9	property	property	NN
18637	17126	10	to	to	IN
18637	17126	11	the	the	DT
18637	17126	12	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17126	13	for	for	IN
18637	17126	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17126	15	particular	particular	JJ
18637	17126	16	use	use	NN
18637	17126	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	17126	18	not	not	RB
18637	17126	19	a	a	DT
18637	17126	20	criterion	criterion	NN
18637	17126	21	.	.	.
18637	17127	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17127	2	312	312	CD
18637	17127	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17127	4	In	in	IN
18637	17127	5	two	two	CD
18637	17127	6	recent	recent	JJ
18637	17127	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	17127	8	the	the	DT
18637	17127	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17127	10	held	hold	VBD
18637	17127	11	that	that	IN
18637	17127	12	the	the	DT
18637	17127	13	owners	owner	NNS
18637	17127	14	of	of	IN
18637	17127	15	cured	cure	VBN
18637	17127	16	pork[313	pork[313	NNP
18637	17127	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17127	18	and	and	CC
18637	17127	19	black	black	JJ
18637	17127	20	pepper[314	pepper[314	NN
18637	17127	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17127	22	which	which	WDT
18637	17127	23	was	be	VBD
18637	17127	24	requisitioned	requisition	VBN
18637	17127	25	by	by	IN
18637	17127	26	the	the	DT
18637	17127	27	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17127	28	during	during	IN
18637	17127	29	the	the	DT
18637	17127	30	war	war	NN
18637	17127	31	could	could	MD
18637	17127	32	recover	recover	VB
18637	17127	33	only	only	RB
18637	17127	34	the	the	DT
18637	17127	35	O.P.A.	O.P.A.	NNP
18637	17128	1	ceiling	ceiling	NN
18637	17128	2	price	price	NN
18637	17128	3	for	for	IN
18637	17128	4	those	those	DT
18637	17128	5	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	17128	6	,	,	,
18637	17128	7	despite	despite	IN
18637	17128	8	findings	finding	NNS
18637	17128	9	of	of	IN
18637	17128	10	the	the	DT
18637	17128	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17128	12	of	of	IN
18637	17128	13	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	17128	14	that	that	IN
18637	17128	15	the	the	DT
18637	17128	16	replacement	replacement	NN
18637	17128	17	cost	cost	NN
18637	17128	18	of	of	IN
18637	17128	19	the	the	DT
18637	17128	20	meat	meat	NN
18637	17128	21	exceeded	exceed	VBD
18637	17128	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17128	23	ceiling	ceiling	NN
18637	17128	24	price	price	NN
18637	17128	25	,	,	,
18637	17128	26	and	and	CC
18637	17128	27	that	that	IN
18637	17128	28	the	the	DT
18637	17128	29	pepper	pepper	NN
18637	17128	30	had	have	VBD
18637	17128	31	a	a	DT
18637	17128	32	"	"	``
18637	17128	33	retention	retention	NN
18637	17128	34	value	value	NN
18637	17128	35	"	"	''
18637	17128	36	in	in	IN
18637	17128	37	excess	excess	NN
18637	17128	38	of	of	IN
18637	17128	39	that	that	DT
18637	17128	40	price	price	NN
18637	17128	41	.	.	.
18637	17129	1	By	by	IN
18637	17129	2	a	a	DT
18637	17129	3	five	five	CD
18637	17129	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	17129	5	to	to	IN
18637	17129	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	17129	7	four	four	CD
18637	17129	8	decision	decision	NN
18637	17129	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17129	10	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	17129	11	that	that	IN
18637	17129	12	the	the	DT
18637	17129	13	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17129	14	was	be	VBD
18637	17129	15	not	not	RB
18637	17129	16	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	17129	17	to	to	TO
18637	17129	18	pay	pay	VB
18637	17129	19	the	the	DT
18637	17129	20	market	market	NN
18637	17129	21	value	value	NN
18637	17129	22	of	of	IN
18637	17129	23	a	a	DT
18637	17129	24	tug	tug	NN
18637	17129	25	where	where	WRB
18637	17129	26	such	such	JJ
18637	17129	27	value	value	NN
18637	17129	28	had	have	VBD
18637	17129	29	been	be	VBN
18637	17129	30	enhanced	enhance	VBN
18637	17129	31	as	as	IN
18637	17129	32	a	a	DT
18637	17129	33	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	17129	34	of	of	IN
18637	17129	35	the	the	DT
18637	17129	36	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17129	37	's	's	POS
18637	17129	38	urgent	urgent	JJ
18637	17129	39	war	war	NN
18637	17129	40	time	time	NN
18637	17129	41	needs	need	VBZ
18637	17129	42	.	.	.
18637	17130	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17130	2	315	315	CD
18637	17130	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17130	4	Consequential	consequential	JJ
18637	17130	5	damages	damage	NNS
18637	17130	6	such	such	JJ
18637	17130	7	as	as	IN
18637	17130	8	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	17130	9	of	of	IN
18637	17130	10	a	a	DT
18637	17130	11	business,[316	business,[316	NN
18637	17130	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17130	13	the	the	DT
18637	17130	14	expense	expense	NN
18637	17130	15	of	of	IN
18637	17130	16	moving	move	VBG
18637	17130	17	fixtures	fixture	NNS
18637	17130	18	and	and	CC
18637	17130	19	personal	personal	JJ
18637	17130	20	property	property	NN
18637	17130	21	from	from	IN
18637	17130	22	the	the	DT
18637	17130	23	premises	premise	NNS
18637	17130	24	,	,	,
18637	17130	25	or	or	CC
18637	17130	26	the	the	DT
18637	17130	27	loss	loss	NN
18637	17130	28	of	of	IN
18637	17130	29	goodwill	goodwill	NN
18637	17130	30	which	which	WDT
18637	17130	31	inheres	inhere	VBZ
18637	17130	32	in	in	IN
18637	17130	33	the	the	DT
18637	17130	34	location	location	NN
18637	17130	35	of	of	IN
18637	17130	36	the	the	DT
18637	17130	37	land	land	NN
18637	17130	38	,	,	,
18637	17130	39	are	be	VBP
18637	17130	40	not	not	RB
18637	17130	41	recoverable	recoverable	JJ
18637	17130	42	when	when	WRB
18637	17130	43	property	property	NN
18637	17130	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	17130	45	taken	take	VBN
18637	17130	46	in	in	IN
18637	17130	47	fee	fee	NN
18637	17130	48	.	.	.
18637	17131	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17131	2	317	317	CD
18637	17131	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17131	4	But	but	CC
18637	17131	5	a	a	DT
18637	17131	6	different	different	JJ
18637	17131	7	principle	principle	NN
18637	17131	8	obtains	obtain	NNS
18637	17131	9	where	where	WRB
18637	17131	10	only	only	RB
18637	17131	11	a	a	DT
18637	17131	12	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	17131	13	occupancy	occupancy	NN
18637	17131	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	17131	15	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	17131	16	.	.	.
18637	17132	1	If	if	IN
18637	17132	2	a	a	DT
18637	17132	3	portion	portion	NN
18637	17132	4	of	of	IN
18637	17132	5	a	a	DT
18637	17132	6	long	long	JJ
18637	17132	7	term	term	NN
18637	17132	8	lease	lease	NN
18637	17132	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	17132	10	taken	take	VBN
18637	17132	11	,	,	,
18637	17132	12	damage	damage	NN
18637	17132	13	to	to	IN
18637	17132	14	fixtures	fixture	NNS
18637	17132	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	17132	16	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	17132	17	in	in	IN
18637	17132	18	addition	addition	NN
18637	17132	19	to	to	IN
18637	17132	20	the	the	DT
18637	17132	21	value	value	NN
18637	17132	22	of	of	IN
18637	17132	23	the	the	DT
18637	17132	24	occupancy	occupancy	NN
18637	17132	25	,	,	,
18637	17132	26	and	and	CC
18637	17132	27	the	the	DT
18637	17132	28	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	17132	29	of	of	IN
18637	17132	30	moving	move	VBG
18637	17132	31	,	,	,
18637	17132	32	storage	storage	NN
18637	17132	33	charges	charge	NNS
18637	17132	34	,	,	,
18637	17132	35	and	and	CC
18637	17132	36	the	the	DT
18637	17132	37	cost	cost	NN
18637	17132	38	of	of	IN
18637	17132	39	preparing	prepare	VBG
18637	17132	40	the	the	DT
18637	17132	41	space	space	NN
18637	17132	42	for	for	IN
18637	17132	43	occupancy	occupancy	NN
18637	17132	44	by	by	IN
18637	17132	45	the	the	DT
18637	17132	46	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17132	47	are	be	VBP
18637	17132	48	proper	proper	JJ
18637	17132	49	elements	element	NNS
18637	17132	50	to	to	TO
18637	17132	51	be	be	VB
18637	17132	52	considered	consider	VBN
18637	17132	53	in	in	IN
18637	17132	54	determining	determine	VBG
18637	17132	55	the	the	DT
18637	17132	56	fair	fair	JJ
18637	17132	57	rental	rental	JJ
18637	17132	58	value	value	NN
18637	17132	59	of	of	IN
18637	17132	60	the	the	DT
18637	17132	61	premises	premise	NNS
18637	17132	62	for	for	IN
18637	17132	63	the	the	DT
18637	17132	64	period	period	NN
18637	17132	65	taken	take	VBN
18637	17132	66	.	.	.
18637	17133	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17133	2	318	318	CD
18637	17133	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17133	4	These	these	DT
18637	17133	5	elements	element	NNS
18637	17133	6	are	be	VBP
18637	17133	7	not	not	RB
18637	17133	8	taken	take	VBN
18637	17133	9	into	into	IN
18637	17133	10	account	account	NN
18637	17133	11	in	in	IN
18637	17133	12	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	17133	13	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17133	14	for	for	IN
18637	17133	15	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	17133	16	of	of	IN
18637	17133	17	leaseholds	leasehold	NNS
18637	17133	18	for	for	IN
18637	17133	19	the	the	DT
18637	17133	20	remainder	remainder	NN
18637	17133	21	of	of	IN
18637	17133	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17133	23	term	term	NN
18637	17133	24	.	.	.
18637	17134	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17134	2	319	319	CD
18637	17134	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17134	4	In	in	IN
18637	17134	5	Kimball	Kimball	NNP
18637	17134	6	Laundry	Laundry	NNP
18637	17134	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17134	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17134	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17134	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17134	11	United	United	NNP
18637	17134	12	States,[320	States,[320	NNP
18637	17134	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17134	14	the	the	DT
18637	17134	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17134	16	by	by	IN
18637	17134	17	a	a	DT
18637	17134	18	close	close	JJ
18637	17134	19	division	division	NN
18637	17134	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	17134	21	that	that	IN
18637	17134	22	when	when	WRB
18637	17134	23	the	the	DT
18637	17134	24	United	United	NNP
18637	17134	25	States	States	NNP
18637	17134	26	condemned	condemn	VBD
18637	17134	27	a	a	DT
18637	17134	28	laundry	laundry	JJ
18637	17134	29	plant	plant	NN
18637	17134	30	for	for	IN
18637	17134	31	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	17134	32	occupancy	occupancy	NN
18637	17134	33	,	,	,
18637	17134	34	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17134	35	should	should	MD
18637	17134	36	have	have	VB
18637	17134	37	been	be	VBN
18637	17134	38	received	receive	VBN
18637	17134	39	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	17134	40	the	the	DT
18637	17134	41	diminution	diminution	NN
18637	17134	42	in	in	IN
18637	17134	43	the	the	DT
18637	17134	44	value	value	NN
18637	17134	45	of	of	IN
18637	17134	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17134	47	business	business	NN
18637	17134	48	due	due	IN
18637	17134	49	to	to	IN
18637	17134	50	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	17134	51	of	of	IN
18637	17134	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17134	53	trade	trade	NN
18637	17134	54	routes	route	NNS
18637	17134	55	,	,	,
18637	17134	56	and	and	CC
18637	17134	57	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17134	58	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	17134	59	for	for	IN
18637	17134	60	any	any	DT
18637	17134	61	demonstrable	demonstrable	JJ
18637	17134	62	loss	loss	NN
18637	17134	63	of	of	IN
18637	17134	64	going	go	VBG
18637	17134	65	-	-	HYPH
18637	17134	66	concern	concern	NN
18637	17134	67	value	value	NN
18637	17134	68	.	.	.
18637	17135	1	In	in	IN
18637	17135	2	United	United	NNP
18637	17135	3	States	States	NNP
18637	17135	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17135	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	17135	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17135	7	Pewee	Pewee	NNP
18637	17135	8	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	17135	9	Co	Co	NNP
18637	17135	10	.	.	.
18637	17135	11	,[321	,[321	NFP
18637	17135	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17135	13	involving	involve	VBG
18637	17135	14	another	another	DT
18637	17135	15	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	17135	16	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	17135	17	by	by	IN
18637	17135	18	the	the	DT
18637	17135	19	government	government	NN
18637	17135	20	,	,	,
18637	17135	21	a	a	DT
18637	17135	22	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	17135	23	divided	divide	VBN
18637	17135	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17135	25	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	17135	26	the	the	DT
18637	17135	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17135	28	of	of	IN
18637	17135	29	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	17135	30	in	in	IN
18637	17135	31	awarding	award	VBG
18637	17135	32	the	the	DT
18637	17135	33	company	company	NN
18637	17135	34	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17135	35	for	for	IN
18637	17135	36	losses	loss	NNS
18637	17135	37	attributable	attributable	JJ
18637	17135	38	to	to	IN
18637	17135	39	increased	increase	VBN
18637	17135	40	wage	wage	NN
18637	17135	41	payments	payment	NNS
18637	17135	42	by	by	IN
18637	17135	43	the	the	DT
18637	17135	44	government	government	NN
18637	17135	45	.	.	.
18637	17136	1	Four	four	CD
18637	17136	2	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	17136	3	thought	think	VBD
18637	17136	4	no	no	DT
18637	17136	5	such	such	JJ
18637	17136	6	loss	loss	NN
18637	17136	7	had	have	VBD
18637	17136	8	been	be	VBN
18637	17136	9	shown	show	VBN
18637	17136	10	.	.	.
18637	17137	1	Interest	interest	NN
18637	17137	2	Ordinarily	Ordinarily	NNP
18637	17137	3	property	property	NN
18637	17137	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	17137	5	taken	take	VBN
18637	17137	6	under	under	IN
18637	17137	7	a	a	DT
18637	17137	8	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	17137	9	suit	suit	NN
18637	17137	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	17137	11	the	the	DT
18637	17137	12	payment	payment	NN
18637	17137	13	of	of	IN
18637	17137	14	the	the	DT
18637	17137	15	money	money	NN
18637	17137	16	award	award	NN
18637	17137	17	by	by	IN
18637	17137	18	the	the	DT
18637	17137	19	condemner	condemner	NN
18637	17137	20	and	and	CC
18637	17137	21	no	no	DT
18637	17137	22	interest	interest	NN
18637	17137	23	accrues	accrue	VBZ
18637	17137	24	.	.	.
18637	17138	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17138	2	322	322	CD
18637	17138	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17138	4	If	if	IN
18637	17138	5	,	,	,
18637	17138	6	however	however	RB
18637	17138	7	,	,	,
18637	17138	8	the	the	DT
18637	17138	9	property	property	NN
18637	17138	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	17138	11	taken	take	VBN
18637	17138	12	in	in	IN
18637	17138	13	fact	fact	NN
18637	17138	14	before	before	IN
18637	17138	15	payment	payment	NN
18637	17138	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	17138	17	made	make	VBN
18637	17138	18	,	,	,
18637	17138	19	just	just	RB
18637	17138	20	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17138	21	includes	include	VBZ
18637	17138	22	an	an	DT
18637	17138	23	increment	increment	NN
18637	17138	24	which	which	WDT
18637	17138	25	,	,	,
18637	17138	26	to	to	TO
18637	17138	27	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	17138	28	use	use	NN
18637	17138	29	of	of	IN
18637	17138	30	the	the	DT
18637	17138	31	term	term	NN
18637	17138	32	"	"	``
18637	17138	33	interest	interest	NN
18637	17138	34	,	,	,
18637	17138	35	"	"	''
18637	17138	36	the	the	DT
18637	17138	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17138	38	has	have	VBZ
18637	17138	39	called	call	VBN
18637	17138	40	"	"	``
18637	17138	41	an	an	DT
18637	17138	42	amount	amount	NN
18637	17138	43	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	17138	44	to	to	TO
18637	17138	45	produce	produce	VB
18637	17138	46	the	the	DT
18637	17138	47	full	full	JJ
18637	17138	48	equivalent	equivalent	NN
18637	17138	49	of	of	IN
18637	17138	50	that	that	DT
18637	17138	51	value	value	NN
18637	17138	52	paid	pay	VBD
18637	17138	53	contemporaneously	contemporaneously	RB
18637	17138	54	with	with	IN
18637	17138	55	the	the	DT
18637	17138	56	taking	taking	NN
18637	17138	57	.	.	.
18637	17139	1	"	"	``
18637	17139	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17139	3	323	323	CD
18637	17139	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17139	5	If	if	IN
18637	17139	6	the	the	DT
18637	17139	7	owner	owner	NN
18637	17139	8	and	and	CC
18637	17139	9	the	the	DT
18637	17139	10	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17139	11	enter	enter	VBP
18637	17139	12	into	into	IN
18637	17139	13	a	a	DT
18637	17139	14	contract	contract	NN
18637	17139	15	which	which	WDT
18637	17139	16	stipulates	stipulate	VBZ
18637	17139	17	the	the	DT
18637	17139	18	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	17139	19	price	price	NN
18637	17139	20	for	for	IN
18637	17139	21	lands	land	NNS
18637	17139	22	to	to	TO
18637	17139	23	be	be	VB
18637	17139	24	taken	take	VBN
18637	17139	25	,	,	,
18637	17139	26	with	with	IN
18637	17139	27	no	no	DT
18637	17139	28	provision	provision	NN
18637	17139	29	for	for	IN
18637	17139	30	interest	interest	NN
18637	17139	31	,	,	,
18637	17139	32	the	the	DT
18637	17139	33	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	17139	34	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17139	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	17139	36	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	17139	37	and	and	CC
18637	17139	38	the	the	DT
18637	17139	39	landowner	landowner	NN
18637	17139	40	can	can	MD
18637	17139	41	not	not	RB
18637	17139	42	recover	recover	VB
18637	17139	43	interest	interest	NN
18637	17139	44	even	even	RB
18637	17139	45	though	though	IN
18637	17139	46	payment	payment	NN
18637	17139	47	of	of	IN
18637	17139	48	the	the	DT
18637	17139	49	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	17139	50	price	price	NN
18637	17139	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	17139	52	delayed	delay	VBN
18637	17139	53	.	.	.
18637	17140	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17140	2	324	324	CD
18637	17140	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17140	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	17140	5	property	property	NN
18637	17140	6	of	of	IN
18637	17140	7	a	a	DT
18637	17140	8	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	17140	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	17140	10	been	be	VBN
18637	17140	11	mistakenly	mistakenly	RB
18637	17140	12	seized	seize	VBN
18637	17140	13	by	by	IN
18637	17140	14	the	the	DT
18637	17140	15	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17140	16	,	,	,
18637	17140	17	converted	convert	VBD
18637	17140	18	into	into	IN
18637	17140	19	money	money	NN
18637	17140	20	and	and	CC
18637	17140	21	invested	invest	VBN
18637	17140	22	,	,	,
18637	17140	23	the	the	DT
18637	17140	24	owner	owner	NN
18637	17140	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	17140	26	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	17140	27	,	,	,
18637	17140	28	in	in	IN
18637	17140	29	recovering	recover	VBG
18637	17140	30	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17140	31	,	,	,
18637	17140	32	to	to	IN
18637	17140	33	an	an	DT
18637	17140	34	allowance	allowance	NN
18637	17140	35	for	for	IN
18637	17140	36	the	the	DT
18637	17140	37	use	use	NN
18637	17140	38	of	of	IN
18637	17140	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17140	40	property	property	NN
18637	17140	41	.	.	.
18637	17141	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17141	2	325	325	CD
18637	17141	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17141	4	Enforcement	Enforcement	NNP
18637	17141	5	of	of	IN
18637	17141	6	Right	right	NN
18637	17141	7	to	to	IN
18637	17141	8	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	17141	9	When	when	WRB
18637	17141	10	a	a	DT
18637	17141	11	taking	taking	NN
18637	17141	12	of	of	IN
18637	17141	13	private	private	JJ
18637	17141	14	property	property	NN
18637	17141	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	17141	16	been	be	VBN
18637	17141	17	ordered	order	VBN
18637	17141	18	,	,	,
18637	17141	19	the	the	DT
18637	17141	20	question	question	NN
18637	17141	21	of	of	IN
18637	17141	22	just	just	RB
18637	17141	23	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17141	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	17141	25	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	17141	26	.	.	.
18637	17142	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17142	2	326	326	CD
18637	17142	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17142	4	The	the	DT
18637	17142	5	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17142	6	to	to	TO
18637	17142	7	be	be	VB
18637	17142	8	paid	pay	VBN
18637	17142	9	may	may	MD
18637	17142	10	be	be	VB
18637	17142	11	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	17142	12	by	by	IN
18637	17142	13	any	any	DT
18637	17142	14	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	17142	15	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	17142	16	capable	capable	JJ
18637	17142	17	of	of	IN
18637	17142	18	estimating	estimate	VBG
18637	17142	19	the	the	DT
18637	17142	20	value	value	NN
18637	17142	21	of	of	IN
18637	17142	22	the	the	DT
18637	17142	23	property	property	NN
18637	17142	24	.	.	.
18637	17143	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	17143	2	the	the	DT
18637	17143	3	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	17143	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	17143	5	be	be	VB
18637	17143	6	created	create	VBN
18637	17143	7	directly	directly	RB
18637	17143	8	by	by	IN
18637	17143	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17143	10	or	or	CC
18637	17143	11	one	one	NN
18637	17143	12	already	already	RB
18637	17143	13	established	establish	VBN
18637	17143	14	by	by	IN
18637	17143	15	the	the	DT
18637	17143	16	State	State	NNP
18637	17143	17	shall	shall	MD
18637	17143	18	be	be	VB
18637	17143	19	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	17143	20	for	for	IN
18637	17143	21	the	the	DT
18637	17143	22	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	17143	23	,	,	,
18637	17143	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	17143	25	a	a	DT
18637	17143	26	matter	matter	NN
18637	17143	27	of	of	IN
18637	17143	28	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	17143	29	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	17143	30	.	.	.
18637	17144	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17144	2	327	327	CD
18637	17144	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17144	4	The	the	DT
18637	17144	5	estimate	estimate	NN
18637	17144	6	of	of	IN
18637	17144	7	just	just	RB
18637	17144	8	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17144	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	17144	10	not	not	RB
18637	17144	11	required	require	VBN
18637	17144	12	to	to	TO
18637	17144	13	be	be	VB
18637	17144	14	made	make	VBN
18637	17144	15	by	by	IN
18637	17144	16	a	a	DT
18637	17144	17	jury	jury	NN
18637	17144	18	,	,	,
18637	17144	19	but	but	CC
18637	17144	20	may	may	MD
18637	17144	21	be	be	VB
18637	17144	22	entrusted	entrust	VBN
18637	17144	23	to	to	IN
18637	17144	24	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	17144	25	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	17144	26	by	by	IN
18637	17144	27	a	a	DT
18637	17144	28	court	court	NN
18637	17144	29	or	or	CC
18637	17144	30	by	by	IN
18637	17144	31	the	the	DT
18637	17144	32	executive	executive	NN
18637	17144	33	,	,	,
18637	17144	34	or	or	CC
18637	17144	35	to	to	IN
18637	17144	36	an	an	DT
18637	17144	37	inquest	inquest	NN
18637	17144	38	consisting	consisting	NN
18637	17144	39	of	of	IN
18637	17144	40	more	more	JJR
18637	17144	41	or	or	CC
18637	17144	42	fewer	few	JJR
18637	17144	43	men	man	NNS
18637	17144	44	than	than	IN
18637	17144	45	an	an	DT
18637	17144	46	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	17144	47	jury	jury	NN
18637	17144	48	.	.	.
18637	17145	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17145	2	328	328	CD
18637	17145	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17145	4	The	the	DT
18637	17145	5	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17145	6	courts	court	NNS
18637	17145	7	may	may	MD
18637	17145	8	take	take	VB
18637	17145	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	17145	10	of	of	IN
18637	17145	11	an	an	DT
18637	17145	12	action	action	NN
18637	17145	13	in	in	IN
18637	17145	14	ejectment	ejectment	NN
18637	17145	15	by	by	IN
18637	17145	16	a	a	DT
18637	17145	17	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	17145	18	against	against	IN
18637	17145	19	officers	officer	NNS
18637	17145	20	of	of	IN
18637	17145	21	the	the	DT
18637	17145	22	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17145	23	,	,	,
18637	17145	24	to	to	TO
18637	17145	25	recover	recover	VB
18637	17145	26	property	property	NN
18637	17145	27	of	of	IN
18637	17145	28	which	which	WDT
18637	17145	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17145	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	17145	31	been	be	VBN
18637	17145	32	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	17145	33	by	by	IN
18637	17145	34	force	force	NN
18637	17145	35	and	and	CC
18637	17145	36	which	which	WDT
18637	17145	37	has	have	VBZ
18637	17145	38	been	be	VBN
18637	17145	39	converted	convert	VBN
18637	17145	40	to	to	IN
18637	17145	41	the	the	DT
18637	17145	42	use	use	NN
18637	17145	43	of	of	IN
18637	17145	44	the	the	DT
18637	17145	45	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17145	46	without	without	IN
18637	17145	47	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	17145	48	authority	authority	NN
18637	17145	49	and	and	CC
18637	17145	50	without	without	IN
18637	17145	51	just	just	RB
18637	17145	52	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17145	53	.	.	.
18637	17146	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17146	2	329	329	CD
18637	17146	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17146	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	17146	5	property	property	NN
18637	17146	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	17146	7	taken	take	VBN
18637	17146	8	by	by	IN
18637	17146	9	the	the	DT
18637	17146	10	United	United	NNP
18637	17146	11	States	States	NNP
18637	17146	12	in	in	IN
18637	17146	13	the	the	DT
18637	17146	14	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	17146	15	of	of	IN
18637	17146	16	the	the	DT
18637	17146	17	power	power	NN
18637	17146	18	of	of	IN
18637	17146	19	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	17146	20	domain	domain	NN
18637	17146	21	,	,	,
18637	17146	22	but	but	CC
18637	17146	23	without	without	IN
18637	17146	24	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	17146	25	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	17146	26	,	,	,
18637	17146	27	the	the	DT
18637	17146	28	owner	owner	NN
18637	17146	29	may	may	MD
18637	17146	30	,	,	,
18637	17146	31	under	under	IN
18637	17146	32	the	the	DT
18637	17146	33	Tucker	Tucker	NNP
18637	17146	34	Act	Act	NNP
18637	17146	35	,	,	,
18637	17146	36	bring	bring	VB
18637	17146	37	suit	suit	NN
18637	17146	38	for	for	IN
18637	17146	39	just	just	RB
18637	17146	40	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17146	41	in	in	IN
18637	17146	42	the	the	DT
18637	17146	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17146	44	of	of	IN
18637	17146	45	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	17146	46	or	or	CC
18637	17146	47	in	in	IN
18637	17146	48	a	a	DT
18637	17146	49	district	district	NN
18637	17146	50	court	court	NN
18637	17146	51	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	17146	52	as	as	IN
18637	17146	53	a	a	DT
18637	17146	54	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17146	55	of	of	IN
18637	17146	56	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	17146	57	.	.	.
18637	17147	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17147	2	330	330	CD
18637	17147	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17147	4	The	the	DT
18637	17147	5	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	17147	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17147	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	17147	8	not	not	RB
18637	17147	9	require	require	VB
18637	17147	10	that	that	IN
18637	17147	11	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17147	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	17147	13	actually	actually	RB
18637	17147	14	be	be	VB
18637	17147	15	paid	pay	VBN
18637	17147	16	in	in	IN
18637	17147	17	advance	advance	NN
18637	17147	18	of	of	IN
18637	17147	19	the	the	DT
18637	17147	20	taking[331	taking[331	NN
18637	17147	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17147	22	but	but	CC
18637	17147	23	the	the	DT
18637	17147	24	owner	owner	NN
18637	17147	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	17147	26	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	17147	27	to	to	TO
18637	17147	28	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	17147	29	,	,	,
18637	17147	30	certain	certain	JJ
18637	17147	31	,	,	,
18637	17147	32	and	and	CC
18637	17147	33	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	17147	34	provision	provision	NN
18637	17147	35	for	for	IN
18637	17147	36	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	17147	37	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17147	38	before	before	IN
18637	17147	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17147	40	occupancy	occupancy	NN
18637	17147	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	17147	42	disturbed	disturb	VBN
18637	17147	43	.	.	.
18637	17148	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17148	2	332	332	CD
18637	17148	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17148	4	In	in	IN
18637	17148	5	time	time	NN
18637	17148	6	of	of	IN
18637	17148	7	war	war	NN
18637	17148	8	or	or	CC
18637	17148	9	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	17148	10	public	public	JJ
18637	17148	11	danger	danger	NN
18637	17148	12	private	private	JJ
18637	17148	13	property	property	NN
18637	17148	14	may	may	MD
18637	17148	15	be	be	VB
18637	17148	16	impressed	impress	VBN
18637	17148	17	into	into	IN
18637	17148	18	public	public	JJ
18637	17148	19	service	service	NN
18637	17148	20	without	without	IN
18637	17148	21	the	the	DT
18637	17148	22	consent	consent	NN
18637	17148	23	of	of	IN
18637	17148	24	the	the	DT
18637	17148	25	owner	owner	NN
18637	17148	26	,	,	,
18637	17148	27	but	but	CC
18637	17148	28	such	such	JJ
18637	17148	29	taking	taking	NN
18637	17148	30	raises	raise	VBZ
18637	17148	31	an	an	DT
18637	17148	32	implied	implied	JJ
18637	17148	33	promise	promise	NN
18637	17148	34	on	on	IN
18637	17148	35	the	the	DT
18637	17148	36	part	part	NN
18637	17148	37	of	of	IN
18637	17148	38	the	the	DT
18637	17148	39	United	United	NNP
18637	17148	40	States	States	NNP
18637	17148	41	to	to	TO
18637	17148	42	reimburse	reimburse	VB
18637	17148	43	the	the	DT
18637	17148	44	owner	owner	NN
18637	17148	45	.	.	.
18637	17149	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17149	2	333	333	CD
18637	17149	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17149	4	An	an	DT
18637	17149	5	objection	objection	NN
18637	17149	6	that	that	IN
18637	17149	7	an	an	DT
18637	17149	8	act	act	NN
18637	17149	9	of	of	IN
18637	17149	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17149	11	providing	provide	VBG
18637	17149	12	for	for	IN
18637	17149	13	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	17149	14	of	of	IN
18637	17149	15	land	land	NN
18637	17149	16	for	for	IN
18637	17149	17	a	a	DT
18637	17149	18	public	public	JJ
18637	17149	19	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	17149	20	limited	limit	VBD
18637	17149	21	the	the	DT
18637	17149	22	aggregate	aggregate	JJ
18637	17149	23	amount	amount	NN
18637	17149	24	to	to	TO
18637	17149	25	be	be	VB
18637	17149	26	expended	expend	VBN
18637	17149	27	was	be	VBD
18637	17149	28	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	17149	29	,	,	,
18637	17149	30	since	since	IN
18637	17149	31	the	the	DT
18637	17149	32	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	17149	33	did	do	VBD
18637	17149	34	not	not	RB
18637	17149	35	affect	affect	VB
18637	17149	36	the	the	DT
18637	17149	37	right	right	NN
18637	17149	38	of	of	IN
18637	17149	39	property	property	NN
18637	17149	40	holders	holder	NNS
18637	17149	41	in	in	IN
18637	17149	42	the	the	DT
18637	17149	43	event	event	NN
18637	17149	44	of	of	IN
18637	17149	45	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	17149	46	.	.	.
18637	17150	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17150	2	334	334	CD
18637	17150	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17150	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	17150	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17150	6	1	1	CD
18637	17150	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17150	8	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17150	9	parte	parte	NN
18637	17150	10	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	17150	11	,	,	,
18637	17150	12	114	114	CD
18637	17150	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17150	14	417	417	CD
18637	17150	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17150	16	1885	1885	CD
18637	17150	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17150	18	.	.	.
18637	17151	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17151	2	2	2	LS
18637	17151	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17151	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17151	5	.	.	.
18637	17152	1	427	427	CD
18637	17152	2	.	.	.
18637	17153	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17153	2	3	3	LS
18637	17153	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17153	4	Mackin	Mackin	NNP
18637	17153	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17153	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17153	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17153	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17153	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17153	10	,	,	,
18637	17153	11	117	117	CD
18637	17153	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17153	13	348	348	CD
18637	17153	14	,	,	,
18637	17153	15	352	352	CD
18637	17153	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17153	17	1886	1886	CD
18637	17153	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17153	19	.	.	.
18637	17154	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17154	2	4	4	CD
18637	17154	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17154	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17154	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17154	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17154	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17154	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17154	9	Moreland	Moreland	NNP
18637	17154	10	,	,	,
18637	17154	11	258	258	CD
18637	17154	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17154	13	433	433	CD
18637	17154	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17154	15	1922	1922	CD
18637	17154	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17154	17	.	.	.
18637	17155	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17155	2	5	5	CD
18637	17155	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17155	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17155	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	17155	6	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	17155	7	,	,	,
18637	17155	8	114	114	CD
18637	17155	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17155	10	417	417	CD
18637	17155	11	,	,	,
18637	17155	12	426	426	CD
18637	17155	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17155	14	1885	1885	CD
18637	17155	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17155	16	.	.	.
18637	17156	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17156	2	6	6	CD
18637	17156	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17156	4	Wong	Wong	NNP
18637	17156	5	Wing	Wing	NNP
18637	17156	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17156	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17156	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17156	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17156	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17156	11	,	,	,
18637	17156	12	163	163	CD
18637	17156	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17156	14	228	228	CD
18637	17156	15	,	,	,
18637	17156	16	237	237	CD
18637	17156	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17156	18	1896	1896	CD
18637	17156	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17156	20	.	.	.
18637	17157	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17157	2	7	7	LS
18637	17157	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17157	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17157	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	17157	6	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	17157	7	,	,	,
18637	17157	8	114	114	CD
18637	17157	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17157	10	417	417	CD
18637	17157	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17157	12	1885	1885	CD
18637	17157	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17157	14	.	.	.
18637	17158	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17158	2	8	8	CD
18637	17158	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17158	4	Mackin	Mackin	NNP
18637	17158	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17158	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17158	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17158	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17158	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17158	10	,	,	,
18637	17158	11	117	117	CD
18637	17158	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17158	13	348	348	CD
18637	17158	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17158	15	1886	1886	CD
18637	17158	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17158	17	.	.	.
18637	17159	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17159	2	9	9	CD
18637	17159	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17159	4	Parkinson	Parkinson	NNP
18637	17159	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17159	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17159	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17159	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17159	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17159	10	,	,	,
18637	17159	11	121	121	CD
18637	17159	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17159	13	281	281	CD
18637	17159	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17159	15	1887	1887	CD
18637	17159	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17159	17	.	.	.
18637	17160	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17160	2	10	10	CD
18637	17160	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17160	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17160	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17160	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17160	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17160	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17160	9	DeWalt	DeWalt	NNP
18637	17160	10	,	,	,
18637	17160	11	128	128	CD
18637	17160	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17160	13	393	393	CD
18637	17160	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17160	15	1888	1888	CD
18637	17160	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17160	17	.	.	.
18637	17161	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17161	2	11	11	CD
18637	17161	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17161	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17161	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	17161	6	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	17161	7	,	,	,
18637	17161	8	114	114	CD
18637	17161	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17161	10	417	417	CD
18637	17161	11	,	,	,
18637	17161	12	426	426	CD
18637	17161	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17161	14	1885	1885	CD
18637	17161	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17161	16	.	.	.
18637	17162	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17162	2	12	12	CD
18637	17162	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17162	4	Duke	Duke	NNP
18637	17162	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17162	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17162	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17162	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17162	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17162	10	,	,	,
18637	17162	11	301	301	CD
18637	17162	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17162	13	492	492	CD
18637	17162	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17162	15	1937	1937	CD
18637	17162	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17162	17	.	.	.
18637	17163	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17163	2	13	13	CD
18637	17163	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17163	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17163	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	17163	6	Bain	Bain	NNP
18637	17163	7	,	,	,
18637	17163	8	121	121	CD
18637	17163	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17163	10	1	1	CD
18637	17163	11	,	,	,
18637	17163	12	12	12	CD
18637	17163	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17163	14	1887	1887	CD
18637	17163	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17163	16	.	.	.
18637	17164	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17164	2	14	14	CD
18637	17164	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17164	4	Breese	Breese	NNP
18637	17164	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17164	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17164	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17164	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17164	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17164	10	,	,	,
18637	17164	11	226	226	CD
18637	17164	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17164	13	1	1	CD
18637	17164	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17164	15	1912	1912	CD
18637	17164	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17164	17	.	.	.
18637	17165	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17165	2	15	15	CD
18637	17165	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17165	4	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	17165	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17165	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17165	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17165	8	Sayre	Sayre	NNP
18637	17165	9	,	,	,
18637	17165	10	158	158	CD
18637	17165	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17165	12	109	109	CD
18637	17165	13	,	,	,
18637	17165	14	114	114	CD
18637	17165	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17165	16	1895	1895	CD
18637	17165	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17165	18	.	.	.
18637	17166	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17166	2	16	16	CD
18637	17166	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17166	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17166	5	parte	parte	NNP
18637	17166	6	Quirin	Quirin	NNP
18637	17166	7	,	,	,
18637	17166	8	317	317	CD
18637	17166	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17166	10	1	1	CD
18637	17166	11	,	,	,
18637	17166	12	43	43	CD
18637	17166	13	,	,	,
18637	17166	14	44	44	CD
18637	17166	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17166	16	1942	1942	CD
18637	17166	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17166	18	.	.	.
18637	17167	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17167	2	17	17	CD
18637	17167	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17167	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17167	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	17167	6	Lange	Lange	NNP
18637	17167	7	,	,	,
18637	17167	8	18	18	CD
18637	17167	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17167	10	.	.	.
18637	17168	1	103	103	CD
18637	17168	2	,	,	,
18637	17168	3	169	169	CD
18637	17168	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17168	5	1874	1874	CD
18637	17168	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17168	7	.	.	.
18637	17169	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17169	2	18	18	CD
18637	17169	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17169	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17169	5	.	.	.
18637	17170	1	172	172	CD
18637	17170	2	,	,	,
18637	17170	3	173	173	CD
18637	17170	4	.	.	.
18637	17171	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17171	2	19	19	CD
18637	17171	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17171	4	Kepner	Kepner	NNP
18637	17171	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17171	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17171	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17171	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17171	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17171	10	,	,	,
18637	17171	11	195	195	CD
18637	17171	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17171	13	100	100	CD
18637	17171	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17171	15	1904	1904	CD
18637	17171	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17171	17	.	.	.
18637	17172	1	This	this	DT
18637	17172	2	case	case	NN
18637	17172	3	arose	arise	VBD
18637	17172	4	under	under	IN
18637	17172	5	the	the	DT
18637	17172	6	act	act	NN
18637	17172	7	of	of	IN
18637	17172	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17172	9	of	of	IN
18637	17172	10	July	July	NNP
18637	17172	11	1	1	CD
18637	17172	12	,	,	,
18637	17172	13	1902	1902	CD
18637	17172	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17172	15	32	32	CD
18637	17172	16	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	17172	17	.	.	.
18637	17173	1	631	631	CD
18637	17173	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17173	3	for	for	IN
18637	17173	4	the	the	DT
18637	17173	5	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	17173	6	civil	civil	JJ
18637	17173	7	government	government	NN
18637	17173	8	of	of	IN
18637	17173	9	the	the	DT
18637	17173	10	Philippine	Philippine	NNP
18637	17173	11	Islands	Islands	NNPS
18637	17173	12	.	.	.
18637	17174	1	To	to	IN
18637	17174	2	the	the	DT
18637	17174	3	same	same	JJ
18637	17174	4	effect	effect	NN
18637	17174	5	are	be	VBP
18637	17174	6	United	United	NNP
18637	17174	7	States	States	NNP
18637	17174	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17174	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17174	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17174	11	Sanges	Sanges	NNP
18637	17174	12	,	,	,
18637	17174	13	144	144	CD
18637	17174	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17174	15	310	310	CD
18637	17174	16	,	,	,
18637	17174	17	323	323	CD
18637	17174	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17174	19	1892	1892	CD
18637	17174	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17174	21	,	,	,
18637	17174	22	and	and	CC
18637	17174	23	United	United	NNP
18637	17174	24	States	States	NNP
18637	17174	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17174	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	17174	27	_	_	NNP
18637	17174	28	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	17174	29	,	,	,
18637	17174	30	213	213	CD
18637	17174	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17174	32	297	297	CD
18637	17174	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17174	34	1909	1909	CD
18637	17174	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17174	36	,	,	,
18637	17174	37	both	both	DT
18637	17174	38	cases	case	NNS
18637	17174	39	arising	arise	VBG
18637	17174	40	within	within	IN
18637	17174	41	the	the	DT
18637	17174	42	United	United	NNP
18637	17174	43	States	States	NNP
18637	17174	44	.	.	.
18637	17175	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17175	2	20	20	CD
18637	17175	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17175	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17175	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17175	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17175	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17175	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17175	9	Oppenheimer	Oppenheimer	NNP
18637	17175	10	,	,	,
18637	17175	11	242	242	CD
18637	17175	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17175	13	85	85	CD
18637	17175	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17175	15	1916	1916	CD
18637	17175	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17175	17	.	.	.
18637	17176	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17176	2	21	21	CD
18637	17176	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17176	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17176	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17176	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17176	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17176	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17176	9	Ball	Ball	NNP
18637	17176	10	,	,	,
18637	17176	11	161	161	CD
18637	17176	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17176	13	622	622	CD
18637	17176	14	,	,	,
18637	17176	15	669	669	CD
18637	17176	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17176	17	1896	1896	CD
18637	17176	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17176	19	.	.	.
18637	17177	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17177	2	22	22	CD
18637	17177	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17177	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17177	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	17177	6	Lange	Lange	NNP
18637	17177	7	,	,	,
18637	17177	8	18	18	CD
18637	17177	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17177	10	.	.	.
18637	17178	1	163	163	CD
18637	17178	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17178	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	17178	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17178	5	.	.	.
18637	17179	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17179	2	23	23	CD
18637	17179	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17179	4	Bozza	Bozza	NNP
18637	17179	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17179	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17179	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17179	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17179	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17179	10	,	,	,
18637	17179	11	330	330	CD
18637	17179	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17179	13	160	160	CD
18637	17179	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17179	15	1947	1947	CD
18637	17179	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17179	17	.	.	.
18637	17180	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17180	2	24	24	CD
18637	17180	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17180	4	Wade	Wade	NNP
18637	17180	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17180	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17180	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17180	8	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	17180	9	,	,	,
18637	17180	10	336	336	CD
18637	17180	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17180	12	684	684	CD
18637	17180	13	,	,	,
18637	17180	14	689	689	CD
18637	17180	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17180	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	17180	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17180	18	.	.	.
18637	17181	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17181	2	25	25	CD
18637	17181	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17181	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17181	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17181	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17181	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17181	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17181	9	Perez	Perez	NNP
18637	17181	10	,	,	,
18637	17181	11	9	9	CD
18637	17181	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	17181	13	.	.	.
18637	17182	1	579	579	CD
18637	17182	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17182	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	17182	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17182	5	;	;	:
18637	17182	6	Logan	Logan	NNP
18637	17182	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17182	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17182	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17182	10	United	United	NNP
18637	17182	11	States	States	NNP
18637	17182	12	,	,	,
18637	17182	13	144	144	CD
18637	17182	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17182	15	263	263	CD
18637	17182	16	,	,	,
18637	17182	17	298	298	CD
18637	17182	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17182	19	1892	1892	CD
18637	17182	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17182	21	.	.	.
18637	17183	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17183	2	26	26	CD
18637	17183	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17183	4	Simmons	Simmons	NNP
18637	17183	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17183	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17183	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17183	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17183	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17183	10	,	,	,
18637	17183	11	142	142	CD
18637	17183	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17183	13	148	148	CD
18637	17183	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17183	15	1891	1891	CD
18637	17183	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17183	17	;	;	:
18637	17183	18	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	17183	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17183	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	17183	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17183	22	United	United	NNP
18637	17183	23	States	States	NNP
18637	17183	24	,	,	,
18637	17183	25	155	155	CD
18637	17183	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17183	27	271	271	CD
18637	17183	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17183	29	1894	1894	CD
18637	17183	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17183	31	.	.	.
18637	17184	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17184	2	27	27	CD
18637	17184	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17184	4	Lovato	Lovato	NNP
18637	17184	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17184	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17184	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17184	8	New	New	NNP
18637	17184	9	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	17184	10	,	,	,
18637	17184	11	242	242	CD
18637	17184	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17184	13	199	199	CD
18637	17184	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17184	15	1916	1916	CD
18637	17184	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17184	17	.	.	.
18637	17185	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17185	2	28	28	CD
18637	17185	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17185	4	Wade	Wade	NNP
18637	17185	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17185	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17185	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17185	8	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	17185	9	,	,	,
18637	17185	10	336	336	CD
18637	17185	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17185	12	684	684	CD
18637	17185	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17185	14	1949	1949	CD
18637	17185	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17185	16	.	.	.
18637	17186	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17186	2	29	29	CD
18637	17186	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17186	4	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	17186	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17186	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17186	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17186	8	Loisel	Loisel	NNP
18637	17186	9	,	,	,
18637	17186	10	262	262	CD
18637	17186	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17186	12	426	426	CD
18637	17186	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17186	14	1923	1923	CD
18637	17186	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17186	16	.	.	.
18637	17187	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17187	2	30	30	CD
18637	17187	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17187	4	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	17187	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17187	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17187	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17187	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17187	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17187	10	,	,	,
18637	17187	11	207	207	CD
18637	17187	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17187	13	120	120	CD
18637	17187	14	,	,	,
18637	17187	15	127	127	CD
18637	17187	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17187	17	1907	1907	CD
18637	17187	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17187	19	.	.	.
18637	17188	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17188	2	31	31	CD
18637	17188	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17188	4	Bassing	basse	VBG
18637	17188	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17188	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17188	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17188	8	Cady	Cady	NNP
18637	17188	9	,	,	,
18637	17188	10	208	208	CD
18637	17188	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17188	12	386	386	CD
18637	17188	13	,	,	,
18637	17188	14	391	391	CD
18637	17188	15	-	-	SYM
18637	17188	16	392	392	CD
18637	17188	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17188	18	1908	1908	CD
18637	17188	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17188	20	.	.	.
18637	17189	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17189	2	32	32	CD
18637	17189	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17189	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17189	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17189	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17189	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17189	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17189	9	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	17189	10	,	,	,
18637	17189	11	7	7	CD
18637	17189	12	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	17189	13	.	.	.
18637	17190	1	150	150	CD
18637	17190	2	,	,	,
18637	17190	3	160	160	CD
18637	17190	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17190	5	1883	1883	CD
18637	17190	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17190	7	.	.	.
18637	17191	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17191	2	33	33	CD
18637	17191	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17191	4	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	17191	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17191	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17191	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17191	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17191	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17191	10	,	,	,
18637	17191	11	202	202	CD
18637	17191	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17191	13	344	344	CD
18637	17191	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17191	15	1906	1906	CD
18637	17191	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17191	17	;	;	:
18637	17191	18	United	United	NNP
18637	17191	19	States	States	NNP
18637	17191	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17191	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	17191	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17191	23	Randenbush	Randenbush	NNP
18637	17191	24	,	,	,
18637	17191	25	8	8	CD
18637	17191	26	Pet	pet	NN
18637	17191	27	.	.	.
18637	17192	1	288	288	CD
18637	17192	2	,	,	,
18637	17192	3	289	289	CD
18637	17192	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17192	5	1834	1834	CD
18637	17192	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17192	7	.	.	.
18637	17193	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17193	2	34	34	CD
18637	17193	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17193	4	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	17193	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17193	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17193	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17193	8	Devine	Devine	NNP
18637	17193	9	,	,	,
18637	17193	10	237	237	CD
18637	17193	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17193	12	632	632	CD
18637	17193	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17193	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	17193	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17193	16	.	.	.
18637	17194	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17194	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17194	3	also	also	RB
18637	17194	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17194	5	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	17194	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17194	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17194	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17194	9	McClaughry	McClaughry	NNP
18637	17194	10	,	,	,
18637	17194	11	183	183	CD
18637	17194	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17194	13	365	365	CD
18637	17194	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17194	15	1902	1902	CD
18637	17194	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17194	17	;	;	:
18637	17194	18	Albrecht	Albrecht	NNP
18637	17194	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17194	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	17194	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17194	22	United	United	NNP
18637	17194	23	States	States	NNP
18637	17194	24	,	,	,
18637	17194	25	273	273	CD
18637	17194	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17194	27	1	1	CD
18637	17194	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17194	29	1927	1927	CD
18637	17194	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17194	31	.	.	.
18637	17195	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17195	2	35	35	CD
18637	17195	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17195	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17195	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	17195	6	Nielsen	Nielsen	NNP
18637	17195	7	,	,	,
18637	17195	8	131	131	CD
18637	17195	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17195	10	176	176	CD
18637	17195	11	,	,	,
18637	17195	12	188	188	CD
18637	17195	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17195	14	1889	1889	CD
18637	17195	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17195	16	.	.	.
18637	17196	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17196	2	36	36	CD
18637	17196	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17196	4	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	17196	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17196	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17196	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17196	8	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	17196	9	,	,	,
18637	17196	10	303	303	CD
18637	17196	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17196	12	391	391	CD
18637	17196	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17196	14	1938	1938	CD
18637	17196	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17196	16	.	.	.
18637	17197	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17197	2	37	37	CD
18637	17197	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17197	4	Pinkerton	Pinkerton	NNP
18637	17197	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17197	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17197	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17197	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17197	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17197	10	,	,	,
18637	17197	11	328	328	CD
18637	17197	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17197	13	640	640	CD
18637	17197	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17197	15	1946	1946	CD
18637	17197	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17197	17	;	;	:
18637	17197	18	United	United	NNP
18637	17197	19	States	States	NNP
18637	17197	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17197	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	17197	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17197	23	Bayer	Bayer	NNP
18637	17197	24	,	,	,
18637	17197	25	331	331	CD
18637	17197	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17197	27	532	532	CD
18637	17197	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17197	29	1947	1947	CD
18637	17197	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17197	31	.	.	.
18637	17198	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17198	2	38	38	CD
18637	17198	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17198	4	Pinkerton	Pinkerton	NNP
18637	17198	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17198	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17198	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17198	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17198	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17198	10	,	,	,
18637	17198	11	328	328	CD
18637	17198	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17198	13	640	640	CD
18637	17198	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17198	15	1946	1946	CD
18637	17198	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17198	17	.	.	.
18637	17199	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17199	2	39	39	CD
18637	17199	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17199	4	American	American	NNP
18637	17199	5	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	17199	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17199	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17199	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17199	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17199	10	United	United	NNP
18637	17199	11	States	States	NNP
18637	17199	12	,	,	,
18637	17199	13	328	328	CD
18637	17199	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17199	15	781	781	CD
18637	17199	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17199	17	1946	1946	CD
18637	17199	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17199	19	.	.	.
18637	17200	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17200	2	40	40	CD
18637	17200	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17200	4	339	339	CD
18637	17200	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17200	6	485	485	CD
18637	17200	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17200	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	17200	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17200	10	.	.	.
18637	17201	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17201	2	41	41	CD
18637	17201	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17201	4	Coffey	Coffey	NNP
18637	17201	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17201	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17201	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17201	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17201	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17201	10	,	,	,
18637	17201	11	116	116	CD
18637	17201	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17201	13	436	436	CD
18637	17201	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17201	15	1886	1886	CD
18637	17201	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17201	17	.	.	.
18637	17202	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17202	2	42	42	CD
18637	17202	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17202	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17202	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17202	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17202	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17202	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17202	9	La	La	NNP
18637	17202	10	Franca	Franca	NNP
18637	17202	11	,	,	,
18637	17202	12	282	282	CD
18637	17202	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17202	14	568	568	CD
18637	17202	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17202	16	1931	1931	CD
18637	17202	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17202	18	.	.	.
18637	17203	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17203	2	43	43	CD
18637	17203	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17203	4	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	17203	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17203	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17203	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17203	8	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	17203	9	,	,	,
18637	17203	10	303	303	CD
18637	17203	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17203	12	391	391	CD
18637	17203	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17203	14	1938	1938	CD
18637	17203	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17203	16	.	.	.
18637	17204	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17204	2	44	44	CD
18637	17204	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17204	4	Waterloo	Waterloo	NNP
18637	17204	5	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	17204	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	17204	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17204	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17204	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17204	10	United	United	NNP
18637	17204	11	States	States	NNP
18637	17204	12	,	,	,
18637	17204	13	282	282	CD
18637	17204	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17204	15	577	577	CD
18637	17204	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17204	17	1931	1931	CD
18637	17204	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17204	19	.	.	.
18637	17205	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17205	2	45	45	CD
18637	17205	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17205	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17205	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17205	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17205	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17205	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17205	9	Furlong	Furlong	NNP
18637	17205	10	,	,	,
18637	17205	11	5	5	CD
18637	17205	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	17205	13	.	.	.
18637	17206	1	184	184	CD
18637	17206	2	,	,	,
18637	17206	3	197	197	CD
18637	17206	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17206	5	1820	1820	CD
18637	17206	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17206	7	.	.	.
18637	17207	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17207	2	46	46	CD
18637	17207	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17207	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17207	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17207	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17207	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17207	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17207	9	Lanza	Lanza	NNP
18637	17207	10	,	,	,
18637	17207	11	260	260	CD
18637	17207	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17207	13	377	377	CD
18637	17207	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17207	15	1922	1922	CD
18637	17207	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17207	17	;	;	:
18637	17207	18	Jerome	Jerome	NNP
18637	17207	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17207	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	17207	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17207	22	United	United	NNP
18637	17207	23	States	States	NNP
18637	17207	24	,	,	,
18637	17207	25	318	318	CD
18637	17207	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17207	27	101	101	CD
18637	17207	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17207	29	1943	1943	CD
18637	17207	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17207	31	.	.	.
18637	17208	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17208	2	47	47	CD
18637	17208	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17208	4	In	in	IN
18637	17208	5	re	re	IN
18637	17208	6	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	17208	7	,	,	,
18637	17208	8	166	166	CD
18637	17208	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17208	10	661	661	CD
18637	17208	11	,	,	,
18637	17208	12	672	672	CD
18637	17208	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17208	14	1897	1897	CD
18637	17208	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17208	16	.	.	.
18637	17209	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17209	2	48	48	CD
18637	17209	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17209	4	See	see	VB
18637	17209	5	generally	generally	RB
18637	17209	6	J.H.	J.H.	NNP
18637	17210	1	Wigmore	wigmore	RB
18637	17210	2	,	,	,
18637	17210	3	4	4	CD
18637	17210	4	Evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17210	5	in	in	IN
18637	17210	6	Trials	Trials	NNPS
18637	17210	7	at	at	IN
18637	17210	8	Common	Common	NNP
18637	17210	9	Law	Law	NNP
18637	17210	10	,	,	,
18637	17210	11	§	§	NNP
18637	17210	12	2250	2250	CD
18637	17210	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17210	14	2nd	2nd	NNP
18637	17210	15	ed	ed	NNP
18637	17210	16	.	.	NNP
18637	17210	17	,	,	,
18637	17210	18	1923	1923	CD
18637	17210	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17210	20	;	;	:
18637	17210	21	also	also	RB
18637	17210	22	Edward	Edward	NNP
18637	17210	23	S.	S.	NNP
18637	17210	24	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	17210	25	,	,	,
18637	17210	26	The	the	DT
18637	17210	27	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	17210	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17210	29	's	's	POS
18637	17210	30	Construction	Construction	NNP
18637	17210	31	of	of	IN
18637	17210	32	the	the	DT
18637	17210	33	Self	Self	NNP
18637	17210	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	17210	35	Incrimination	Incrimination	NNP
18637	17210	36	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	17210	37	,	,	,
18637	17210	38	29	29	CD
18637	17210	39	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	17210	40	Law	Law	NNP
18637	17210	41	Review	Review	NNP
18637	17210	42	,	,	,
18637	17210	43	1	1	CD
18637	17210	44	-	-	SYM
18637	17210	45	27	27	CD
18637	17210	46	,	,	,
18637	17210	47	195	195	CD
18637	17210	48	-	-	SYM
18637	17210	49	207	207	CD
18637	17210	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17210	51	1930	1930	CD
18637	17210	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17210	53	.	.	.
18637	17211	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17211	2	49	49	CD
18637	17211	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17211	4	McCarthy	McCarthy	NNP
18637	17211	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17211	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17211	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17211	8	Arndstein	Arndstein	NNP
18637	17211	9	,	,	,
18637	17211	10	266	266	CD
18637	17211	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17211	12	34	34	CD
18637	17211	13	,	,	,
18637	17211	14	40	40	CD
18637	17211	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17211	16	1924	1924	CD
18637	17211	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17211	18	.	.	.
18637	17212	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17212	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17212	3	also	also	RB
18637	17212	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17212	5	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
18637	17212	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17212	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17212	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17212	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17212	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17212	11	,	,	,
18637	17212	12	116	116	CD
18637	17212	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17212	14	616	616	CD
18637	17212	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17212	16	1886	1886	CD
18637	17212	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17212	18	;	;	:
18637	17212	19	Counselman	Counselman	NNP
18637	17212	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17212	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	17212	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17212	23	Hitchcock	Hitchcock	NNP
18637	17212	24	,	,	,
18637	17212	25	142	142	CD
18637	17212	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17212	27	547	547	CD
18637	17212	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17212	29	1892	1892	CD
18637	17212	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17212	31	;	;	:
18637	17212	32	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	17212	33	_	_	NNP
18637	17212	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	17212	35	_	_	NNP
18637	17212	36	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	17212	37	,	,	,
18637	17212	38	161	161	CD
18637	17212	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17212	40	591	591	CD
18637	17212	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17212	42	1896	1896	CD
18637	17212	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17212	44	.	.	.
18637	17213	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17213	2	50	50	CD
18637	17213	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17213	4	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	17213	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17213	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17213	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17213	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17213	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17213	10	,	,	,
18637	17213	11	340	340	CD
18637	17213	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17213	13	367	367	CD
18637	17213	14	,	,	,
18637	17213	15	370	370	CD
18637	17213	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17213	17	1951	1951	CD
18637	17213	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17213	19	;	;	:
18637	17213	20	United	United	NNP
18637	17213	21	States	States	NNP
18637	17213	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17213	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	17213	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17213	25	Monia	Monia	NNP
18637	17213	26	,	,	,
18637	17213	27	317	317	CD
18637	17213	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17213	29	424	424	CD
18637	17213	30	,	,	,
18637	17213	31	427	427	CD
18637	17213	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17213	33	1943	1943	CD
18637	17213	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17213	35	.	.	.
18637	17214	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17214	2	51	51	CD
18637	17214	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17214	4	Hoffman	Hoffman	NNP
18637	17214	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17214	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17214	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17214	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17214	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17214	10	,	,	,
18637	17214	11	341	341	CD
18637	17214	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17214	13	479	479	CD
18637	17214	14	,	,	,
18637	17214	15	486	486	CD
18637	17214	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17214	17	1951	1951	CD
18637	17214	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17214	19	;	;	:
18637	17214	20	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	17214	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17214	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	17214	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17214	24	United	United	NNP
18637	17214	25	States	States	NNP
18637	17214	26	,	,	,
18637	17214	27	244	244	CD
18637	17214	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17214	29	362	362	CD
18637	17214	30	,	,	,
18637	17214	31	363	363	CD
18637	17214	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17214	33	1917	1917	CD
18637	17214	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17214	35	.	.	.
18637	17215	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17215	2	52	52	CD
18637	17215	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17215	4	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	17215	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17215	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17215	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17215	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17215	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17215	10	,	,	,
18637	17215	11	340	340	CD
18637	17215	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17215	13	367	367	CD
18637	17215	14	,	,	,
18637	17215	15	371	371	CD
18637	17215	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17215	17	1951	1951	CD
18637	17215	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17215	19	;	;	:
18637	17215	20	United	United	NNP
18637	17215	21	States	States	NNP
18637	17215	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17215	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	17215	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17215	25	Murdock	Murdock	NNP
18637	17215	26	,	,	,
18637	17215	27	284	284	CD
18637	17215	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17215	29	141	141	CD
18637	17215	30	,	,	,
18637	17215	31	148	148	CD
18637	17215	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17215	33	1931	1931	CD
18637	17215	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17215	35	.	.	.
18637	17216	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17216	2	53	53	CD
18637	17216	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17216	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	17216	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17216	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17216	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17216	8	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	17216	9	,	,	,
18637	17216	10	161	161	CD
18637	17216	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17216	12	591	591	CD
18637	17216	13	,	,	,
18637	17216	14	598	598	CD
18637	17216	15	-	-	SYM
18637	17216	16	599	599	CD
18637	17216	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17216	18	1896	1896	CD
18637	17216	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17216	20	.	.	.
18637	17217	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17217	2	54	54	CD
18637	17217	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17217	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17217	5	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	17217	6	.	.	.
18637	17217	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17217	8	Burdick	Burdick	NNP
18637	17217	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17217	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17217	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17217	12	United	United	NNP
18637	17217	13	States	States	NNP
18637	17217	14	,	,	,
18637	17217	15	236	236	CD
18637	17217	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17217	17	79	79	CD
18637	17217	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17217	19	1915	1915	CD
18637	17217	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17217	21	;	;	:
18637	17217	22	and	and	CC
18637	17217	23	Biddle	Biddle	NNP
18637	17217	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17217	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	17217	26	_	_	NNP
18637	17217	27	Perovich	Perovich	NNP
18637	17217	28	,	,	,
18637	17217	29	274	274	CD
18637	17217	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17217	31	480	480	CD
18637	17217	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17217	33	1927	1927	CD
18637	17217	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17217	35	.	.	.
18637	17218	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17218	2	55	55	CD
18637	17218	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17218	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17218	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17218	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17218	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17218	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17218	9	Murdock	Murdock	NNP
18637	17218	10	,	,	,
18637	17218	11	284	284	CD
18637	17218	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17218	13	141	141	CD
18637	17218	14	,	,	,
18637	17218	15	149	149	CD
18637	17218	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17218	17	1931	1931	CD
18637	17218	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17218	19	.	.	.
18637	17219	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17219	2	56	56	CD
18637	17219	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17219	4	Feldman	Feldman	NNP
18637	17219	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17219	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17219	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17219	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17219	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17219	10	,	,	,
18637	17219	11	322	322	CD
18637	17219	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17219	13	487	487	CD
18637	17219	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17219	15	1944	1944	CD
18637	17219	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17219	17	.	.	.
18637	17220	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17220	2	57	57	CD
18637	17220	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17220	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	17220	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17220	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17220	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17220	8	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	17220	9	,	,	,
18637	17220	10	161	161	CD
18637	17220	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17220	12	591	591	CD
18637	17220	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17220	14	1896	1896	CD
18637	17220	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17220	16	;	;	:
18637	17220	17	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	17220	18	_	_	NNP
18637	17220	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	17220	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17220	21	United	United	NNP
18637	17220	22	States	States	NNP
18637	17220	23	,	,	,
18637	17220	24	318	318	CD
18637	17220	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17220	26	189	189	CD
18637	17220	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17220	28	1943	1943	CD
18637	17220	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17220	30	.	.	.
18637	17221	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17221	2	58	58	CD
18637	17221	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17221	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17221	5	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	17221	6	.	.	.
18637	17221	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17221	8	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	17221	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17221	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17221	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17221	12	New	New	NNP
18637	17221	13	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	17221	14	,	,	,
18637	17221	15	211	211	CD
18637	17221	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17221	17	78	78	CD
18637	17221	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17221	19	1908	1908	CD
18637	17221	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17221	21	.	.	.
18637	17222	1	However	however	RB
18637	17222	2	,	,	,
18637	17222	3	a	a	DT
18637	17222	4	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17222	5	in	in	IN
18637	17222	6	a	a	DT
18637	17222	7	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	17222	8	by	by	IN
18637	17222	9	the	the	DT
18637	17222	10	United	United	NNP
18637	17222	11	States	States	NNP
18637	17222	12	enjoys	enjoy	VBZ
18637	17222	13	a	a	DT
18637	17222	14	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	17222	15	right	right	NN
18637	17222	16	to	to	TO
18637	17222	17	have	have	VB
18637	17222	18	the	the	DT
18637	17222	19	jury	jury	NN
18637	17222	20	instructed	instruct	VBD
18637	17222	21	that	that	IN
18637	17222	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17222	23	failure	failure	NN
18637	17222	24	to	to	TO
18637	17222	25	testify	testify	VB
18637	17222	26	creates	create	VBZ
18637	17222	27	no	no	DT
18637	17222	28	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	17222	29	against	against	IN
18637	17222	30	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17222	31	.	.	.
18637	17223	1	28	28	CD
18637	17223	2	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
18637	17224	1	632	632	LS
18637	17224	2	;	;	:
18637	17224	3	Bruno	Bruno	NNP
18637	17224	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17224	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	17224	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17224	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17224	8	,	,	,
18637	17224	9	308	308	CD
18637	17224	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17224	11	287	287	CD
18637	17224	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17224	13	1939	1939	CD
18637	17224	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17224	15	.	.	.
18637	17225	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17225	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17225	3	also	also	RB
18637	17225	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17225	5	318	318	CD
18637	17225	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17225	7	at	at	IN
18637	17225	8	196	196	CD
18637	17225	9	.	.	.
18637	17226	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17226	2	59	59	CD
18637	17226	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17226	4	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	17226	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17226	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17226	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17226	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17226	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17226	10	,	,	,
18637	17226	11	160	160	CD
18637	17226	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17226	13	355	355	CD
18637	17226	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17226	15	1896	1896	CD
18637	17226	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17226	17	;	;	:
18637	17226	18	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	17226	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17226	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	17226	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17226	22	United	United	NNP
18637	17226	23	States	States	NNP
18637	17226	24	,	,	,
18637	17226	25	162	162	CD
18637	17226	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17226	27	613	613	CD
18637	17226	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17226	29	1896	1896	CD
18637	17226	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17226	31	;	;	:
18637	17226	32	United	United	NNP
18637	17226	33	States	States	NNP
18637	17226	34	_	_	NNP
18637	17226	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	17226	36	_	_	NNP
18637	17226	37	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	17226	38	,	,	,
18637	17226	39	322	322	CD
18637	17226	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17226	41	65	65	CD
18637	17226	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17226	43	1944	1944	CD
18637	17226	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17226	45	.	.	.
18637	17227	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17227	2	60	60	CD
18637	17227	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17227	4	318	318	CD
18637	17227	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17227	6	332	332	CD
18637	17227	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17227	8	1943	1943	CD
18637	17227	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17227	10	.	.	.
18637	17228	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17228	2	61	61	CD
18637	17228	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17228	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17228	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17228	6	.	.	.
18637	17228	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17228	8	,	,	,
18637	17228	9	340	340	CD
18637	17228	10	.	.	.
18637	17229	1	In	in	IN
18637	17229	2	Upshaw	Upshaw	NNP
18637	17229	3	_	_	NNP
18637	17229	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	17229	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17229	6	United	United	NNP
18637	17229	7	States	States	NNP
18637	17229	8	,	,	,
18637	17229	9	335	335	CD
18637	17229	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17229	11	410	410	CD
18637	17229	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17229	13	1948	1948	CD
18637	17229	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17229	15	,	,	,
18637	17229	16	a	a	DT
18637	17229	17	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	17229	18	divided	divide	VBN
18637	17229	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17229	20	found	find	VBD
18637	17229	21	the	the	DT
18637	17229	22	McNabb	McNabb	NNP
18637	17229	23	case	case	NN
18637	17229	24	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	17229	25	to	to	IN
18637	17229	26	a	a	DT
18637	17229	27	case	case	NN
18637	17229	28	in	in	IN
18637	17229	29	which	which	WDT
18637	17229	30	respondent	respondent	NN
18637	17229	31	,	,	,
18637	17229	32	while	while	IN
18637	17229	33	under	under	IN
18637	17229	34	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	17229	35	for	for	IN
18637	17229	36	assault	assault	NN
18637	17229	37	with	with	IN
18637	17229	38	intent	intent	NN
18637	17229	39	to	to	TO
18637	17229	40	rape	rape	VB
18637	17229	41	,	,	,
18637	17229	42	was	be	VBD
18637	17229	43	brought	bring	VBN
18637	17229	44	,	,	,
18637	17229	45	by	by	IN
18637	17229	46	extended	extended	JJ
18637	17229	47	questioning	questioning	NN
18637	17229	48	,	,	,
18637	17229	49	to	to	TO
18637	17229	50	confess	confess	VB
18637	17229	51	having	have	VBG
18637	17229	52	previously	previously	RB
18637	17229	53	committed	commit	VBN
18637	17229	54	murder	murder	NN
18637	17229	55	in	in	IN
18637	17229	56	an	an	DT
18637	17229	57	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	17229	58	to	to	TO
18637	17229	59	rape	rape	VB
18637	17229	60	.	.	.
18637	17230	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17230	2	62	62	CD
18637	17230	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17230	4	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
18637	17230	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17230	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17230	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17230	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17230	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17230	10	,	,	,
18637	17230	11	274	274	CD
18637	17230	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17230	13	259	259	CD
18637	17230	14	,	,	,
18637	17230	15	263	263	CD
18637	17230	16	264	264	CD
18637	17230	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17230	18	1927	1927	CD
18637	17230	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17230	20	.	.	.
18637	17231	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17231	2	63	63	CD
18637	17231	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17231	4	Blau	Blau	NNP
18637	17231	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17231	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17231	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17231	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17231	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17231	10	,	,	,
18637	17231	11	340	340	CD
18637	17231	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17231	13	159	159	CD
18637	17231	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17231	15	1950	1950	CD
18637	17231	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17231	17	.	.	.
18637	17232	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17232	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17232	3	also	also	RB
18637	17232	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17232	5	Blau	Blau	NNP
18637	17232	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17232	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17232	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17232	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17232	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17232	11	,	,	,
18637	17232	12	340	340	CD
18637	17232	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17232	14	332	332	CD
18637	17232	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17232	16	1951	1951	CD
18637	17232	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17232	18	;	;	:
18637	17232	19	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	17232	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17232	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	17232	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17232	23	United	United	NNP
18637	17232	24	States	States	NNP
18637	17232	25	,	,	,
18637	17232	26	340	340	CD
18637	17232	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17232	28	367	367	CD
18637	17232	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17232	30	1951	1951	CD
18637	17232	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17232	32	;	;	:
18637	17232	33	Dennis	Dennis	NNP
18637	17232	34	_	_	NNP
18637	17232	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	17232	36	_	_	NNP
18637	17232	37	United	United	NNP
18637	17232	38	States	States	NNP
18637	17232	39	,	,	,
18637	17232	40	341	341	CD
18637	17232	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17232	42	494	494	CD
18637	17232	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17232	44	1951	1951	CD
18637	17232	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17232	46	.	.	.
18637	17233	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17233	2	64	64	CD
18637	17233	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17233	4	Holt	Holt	NNP
18637	17233	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17233	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17233	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17233	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17233	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17233	10	,	,	,
18637	17233	11	218	218	CD
18637	17233	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17233	13	245	245	CD
18637	17233	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17233	15	1910	1910	CD
18637	17233	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17233	17	.	.	.
18637	17234	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17234	2	65	65	CD
18637	17234	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17234	4	Rochin	Rochin	NNP
18637	17234	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17234	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17234	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17234	8	California	California	NNP
18637	17234	9	,	,	,
18637	17234	10	342	342	CD
18637	17234	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17234	12	165	165	CD
18637	17234	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17234	14	1952	1952	CD
18637	17234	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17234	16	.	.	.
18637	17235	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17235	2	66	66	CD
18637	17235	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17235	4	Re	Re	NNP
18637	17235	5	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	17235	6	,	,	,
18637	17235	7	221	221	CD
18637	17235	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17235	9	274	274	CD
18637	17235	10	,	,	,
18637	17235	11	279	279	CD
18637	17235	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17235	13	1911	1911	CD
18637	17235	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17235	15	.	.	.
18637	17236	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17236	2	67	67	CD
18637	17236	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17236	4	Dier	Dier	NNP
18637	17236	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17236	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17236	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17236	8	Banton	Banton	NNP
18637	17236	9	,	,	,
18637	17236	10	262	262	CD
18637	17236	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17236	12	147	147	CD
18637	17236	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17236	14	1923	1923	CD
18637	17236	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17236	16	.	.	.
18637	17237	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17237	2	68	68	CD
18637	17237	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17237	4	Re	Re	NNP
18637	17237	5	Fuller	Fuller	NNP
18637	17237	6	,	,	,
18637	17237	7	262	262	CD
18637	17237	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17237	9	91	91	CD
18637	17237	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17237	11	1923	1923	CD
18637	17237	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17237	13	.	.	.
18637	17238	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17238	2	69	69	CD
18637	17238	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17238	4	Arndstein	Arndstein	NNP
18637	17238	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17238	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17238	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17238	8	McCarthy	McCarthy	NNP
18637	17238	9	,	,	,
18637	17238	10	254	254	CD
18637	17238	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17238	12	71	71	CD
18637	17238	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17238	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	17238	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17238	16	.	.	.
18637	17239	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17239	2	70	70	CD
18637	17239	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17239	4	McCarthy	McCarthy	NNP
18637	17239	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17239	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17239	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17239	8	Arndstein	Arndstein	NNP
18637	17239	9	,	,	,
18637	17239	10	262	262	CD
18637	17239	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17239	12	355	355	CD
18637	17239	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17239	14	1923	1923	CD
18637	17239	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17239	16	.	.	.
18637	17240	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17240	2	71	71	CD
18637	17240	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17240	4	McCarthy	McCarthy	NNP
18637	17240	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17240	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17240	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17240	8	Arndstein	Arndstein	NNP
18637	17240	9	,	,	,
18637	17240	10	266	266	CD
18637	17240	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17240	12	34	34	CD
18637	17240	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17240	14	1924	1924	CD
18637	17240	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17240	16	.	.	.
18637	17241	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17241	2	72	72	CD
18637	17241	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17241	4	Hale	Hale	NNP
18637	17241	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17241	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17241	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17241	8	Henkel	Henkel	NNP
18637	17241	9	,	,	,
18637	17241	10	201	201	CD
18637	17241	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17241	12	43	43	CD
18637	17241	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17241	14	1906	1906	CD
18637	17241	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17241	16	;	;	:
18637	17241	17	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	17241	18	_	_	NNP
18637	17241	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	17241	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17241	21	United	United	NNP
18637	17241	22	States	States	NNP
18637	17241	23	,	,	,
18637	17241	24	221	221	CD
18637	17241	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17241	26	361	361	CD
18637	17241	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17241	28	1911	1911	CD
18637	17241	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17241	30	;	;	:
18637	17241	31	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	17241	32	Press	Press	NNP
18637	17241	33	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	17241	34	.	.	.
18637	17242	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17242	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17242	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17242	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17242	5	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	17242	6	,	,	,
18637	17242	7	327	327	CD
18637	17242	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17242	9	186	186	CD
18637	17242	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17242	11	1946	1946	CD
18637	17242	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17242	13	.	.	.
18637	17243	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17243	2	73	73	CD
18637	17243	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17243	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17243	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17243	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17243	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17243	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17243	9	White	White	NNP
18637	17243	10	,	,	,
18637	17243	11	322	322	CD
18637	17243	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17243	13	694	694	CD
18637	17243	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17243	15	1944	1944	CD
18637	17243	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17243	17	.	.	.
18637	17244	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17244	2	74	74	CD
18637	17244	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17244	4	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	17244	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17244	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17244	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17244	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17244	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17244	10	,	,	,
18637	17244	11	340	340	CD
18637	17244	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17244	13	367	367	CD
18637	17244	14	,	,	,
18637	17244	15	372	372	CD
18637	17244	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17244	17	1951	1951	CD
18637	17244	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17244	19	.	.	.
18637	17245	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17245	2	75	75	CD
18637	17245	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17245	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17245	5	See	See	NNP
18637	17245	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17245	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	17245	8	.	.	.
18637	17246	1	825	825	CD
18637	17246	2	-	-	SYM
18637	17246	3	828	828	CD
18637	17246	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17246	5	ante	ante	NNP
18637	17246	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17246	7	.	.	.
18637	17247	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17247	2	76	76	CD
18637	17247	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17247	4	335	335	CD
18637	17247	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17247	6	1	1	CD
18637	17247	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17247	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	17247	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17247	10	.	.	.
18637	17248	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17248	2	77	77	CD
18637	17248	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17248	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17248	5	.	.	.
18637	17249	1	33	33	CD
18637	17249	2	.	.	.
18637	17250	1	In	in	IN
18637	17250	2	a	a	DT
18637	17250	3	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	17250	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17250	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	17250	6	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	17250	7	argued	argue	VBD
18637	17250	8	:	:	:
18637	17250	9	"	"	``
18637	17250	10	The	the	DT
18637	17250	11	underlying	underlie	VBG
18637	17250	12	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	17250	13	of	of	IN
18637	17250	14	the	the	DT
18637	17250	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17250	16	's	's	POS
18637	17250	17	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17250	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	17250	19	that	that	IN
18637	17250	20	all	all	DT
18637	17250	21	records	record	NNS
18637	17250	22	which	which	WDT
18637	17250	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17250	24	in	in	IN
18637	17250	25	the	the	DT
18637	17250	26	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	17250	27	of	of	IN
18637	17250	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17250	29	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17250	30	powers	power	NNS
18637	17250	31	may	may	MD
18637	17250	32	require	require	VB
18637	17250	33	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	17250	34	to	to	TO
18637	17250	35	keep	keep	VB
18637	17250	36	in	in	IN
18637	17250	37	the	the	DT
18637	17250	38	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	17250	39	of	of	IN
18637	17250	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17250	41	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	17250	42	,	,	,
18637	17250	43	because	because	IN
18637	17250	44	those	those	DT
18637	17250	45	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	17250	46	also	also	RB
18637	17250	47	have	have	VBP
18637	17250	48	aspects	aspect	NNS
18637	17250	49	of	of	IN
18637	17250	50	public	public	JJ
18637	17250	51	interest	interest	NN
18637	17250	52	,	,	,
18637	17250	53	become	become	VB
18637	17250	54	'	'	``
18637	17250	55	public	public	JJ
18637	17250	56	'	'	''
18637	17250	57	records	record	NNS
18637	17250	58	in	in	IN
18637	17250	59	the	the	DT
18637	17250	60	sense	sense	NN
18637	17250	61	that	that	IN
18637	17250	62	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17250	63	fall	fall	VBP
18637	17250	64	outside	outside	IN
18637	17250	65	the	the	DT
18637	17250	66	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17250	67	protection	protection	NN
18637	17250	68	of	of	IN
18637	17250	69	the	the	DT
18637	17250	70	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	17250	71	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17250	72	.	.	.
18637	17251	1	The	the	DT
18637	17251	2	validity	validity	NN
18637	17251	3	of	of	IN
18637	17251	4	such	such	PDT
18637	17251	5	a	a	DT
18637	17251	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	17251	7	lies	lie	VBZ
18637	17251	8	in	in	IN
18637	17251	9	the	the	DT
18637	17251	10	scope	scope	NN
18637	17251	11	of	of	IN
18637	17251	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17251	13	implications	implication	NNS
18637	17251	14	.	.	.
18637	17252	1	The	the	DT
18637	17252	2	claim	claim	NN
18637	17252	3	touches	touch	VBZ
18637	17252	4	records	record	NNS
18637	17252	5	that	that	WDT
18637	17252	6	may	may	MD
18637	17252	7	be	be	VB
18637	17252	8	required	require	VBN
18637	17252	9	to	to	TO
18637	17252	10	be	be	VB
18637	17252	11	kept	keep	VBN
18637	17252	12	by	by	IN
18637	17252	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17252	14	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	17252	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	17252	16	,	,	,
18637	17252	17	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	17252	18	measures	measure	NNS
18637	17252	19	,	,	,
18637	17252	20	labor	labor	NN
18637	17252	21	and	and	CC
18637	17252	22	census	census	NN
18637	17252	23	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	17252	24	in	in	IN
18637	17252	25	the	the	DT
18637	17252	26	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	17252	27	of	of	IN
18637	17252	28	business	business	NN
18637	17252	29	which	which	WDT
18637	17252	30	the	the	DT
18637	17252	31	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	17252	32	and	and	CC
18637	17252	33	feeling	feeling	NN
18637	17252	34	of	of	IN
18637	17252	35	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17252	36	people	people	NNS
18637	17252	37	still	still	RB
18637	17252	38	treat	treat	VBP
18637	17252	39	as	as	IN
18637	17252	40	private	private	JJ
18637	17252	41	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	17252	42	,	,	,
18637	17252	43	even	even	RB
18637	17252	44	though	though	IN
18637	17252	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17252	46	relations	relation	NNS
18637	17252	47	to	to	IN
18637	17252	48	the	the	DT
18637	17252	49	public	public	NN
18637	17252	50	may	may	MD
18637	17252	51	call	call	VB
18637	17252	52	for	for	IN
18637	17252	53	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	17252	54	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	17252	55	,	,	,
18637	17252	56	including	include	VBG
18637	17252	57	the	the	DT
18637	17252	58	duty	duty	NN
18637	17252	59	to	to	TO
18637	17252	60	keep	keep	VB
18637	17252	61	designated	designate	VBN
18637	17252	62	records	record	NNS
18637	17252	63	....	....	.
18637	17253	1	If	if	IN
18637	17253	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17253	3	by	by	IN
18637	17253	4	the	the	DT
18637	17253	5	easy	easy	JJ
18637	17253	6	device	device	NN
18637	17253	7	of	of	IN
18637	17253	8	requiring	require	VBG
18637	17253	9	a	a	DT
18637	17253	10	man	man	NN
18637	17253	11	to	to	TO
18637	17253	12	keep	keep	VB
18637	17253	13	the	the	DT
18637	17253	14	private	private	JJ
18637	17253	15	papers	paper	NNS
18637	17253	16	that	that	WDT
18637	17253	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17253	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	17253	19	customarily	customarily	RB
18637	17253	20	kept	keep	VBN
18637	17253	21	can	can	MD
18637	17253	22	render	render	VB
18637	17253	23	such	such	JJ
18637	17253	24	papers	paper	NNS
18637	17253	25	'	'	POS
18637	17253	26	public	public	NN
18637	17253	27	'	'	''
18637	17253	28	and	and	CC
18637	17253	29	nonprivileged	nonprivilege	VBD
18637	17253	30	,	,	,
18637	17253	31	there	there	EX
18637	17253	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	17253	33	little	little	JJ
18637	17253	34	left	leave	VBN
18637	17253	35	to	to	IN
18637	17253	36	either	either	CC
18637	17253	37	the	the	DT
18637	17253	38	right	right	NN
18637	17253	39	of	of	IN
18637	17253	40	privacy	privacy	NN
18637	17253	41	or	or	CC
18637	17253	42	the	the	DT
18637	17253	43	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17253	44	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	17253	45	.	.	.
18637	17253	46	"	"	''
18637	17254	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	17254	2	.	.	.
18637	17255	1	70	70	CD
18637	17255	2	.	.	.
18637	17256	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17256	2	78	78	CD
18637	17256	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17256	4	The	the	DT
18637	17256	5	Institutes	Institutes	NNPS
18637	17256	6	,	,	,
18637	17256	7	Part	Part	NNP
18637	17256	8	2	2	CD
18637	17256	9	,	,	,
18637	17256	10	50	50	CD
18637	17256	11	-	-	SYM
18637	17256	12	51	51	CD
18637	17256	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17256	14	1669	1669	CD
18637	17256	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17256	16	.	.	.
18637	17257	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17257	2	79	79	CD
18637	17257	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17257	4	On	on	IN
18637	17257	5	the	the	DT
18637	17257	6	above	above	JJ
18637	17257	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17257	8	see	see	VB
18637	17257	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17257	10	especially	especially	RB
18637	17257	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	17257	12	Harlan	Harlan	NNP
18637	17257	13	's	's	POS
18637	17257	14	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	17257	15	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17257	16	in	in	IN
18637	17257	17	Hurtado	Hurtado	NNP
18637	17257	18	_	_	NNP
18637	17257	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	17257	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17257	21	California	California	NNP
18637	17257	22	,	,	,
18637	17257	23	110	110	CD
18637	17257	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17257	25	516	516	CD
18637	17257	26	,	,	,
18637	17257	27	538	538	CD
18637	17257	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17257	29	1884	1884	CD
18637	17257	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17257	31	;	;	:
18637	17257	32	_	_	NNP
18637	17257	33	also	also	RB
18637	17257	34	_	_	NNP
18637	17257	35	Den	Den	NNP
18637	17257	36	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17257	37	dem	dem	NNP
18637	17257	38	.	.	.
18637	17258	1	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	17258	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17258	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17258	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17258	5	Hoboken	Hoboken	NNP
18637	17258	6	Land	Land	NNP
18637	17258	7	&	&	CC
18637	17258	8	Improvement	Improvement	NNP
18637	17258	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17258	10	,	,	,
18637	17258	11	18	18	CD
18637	17258	12	How	how	WRB
18637	17258	13	.	.	.
18637	17259	1	272	272	CD
18637	17259	2	,	,	,
18637	17259	3	280	280	CD
18637	17259	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17259	5	1856	1856	CD
18637	17259	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17259	7	;	;	:
18637	17259	8	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	17259	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17259	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17259	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17259	12	New	New	NNP
18637	17259	13	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	17259	14	,	,	,
18637	17259	15	211	211	CD
18637	17259	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17259	17	78	78	CD
18637	17259	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17259	19	1908	1908	CD
18637	17259	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17259	21	;	;	:
18637	17259	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17259	23	also	also	RB
18637	17259	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17259	25	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	17259	26	,	,	,
18637	17259	27	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	17259	28	Against	against	IN
18637	17259	29	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17259	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17259	31	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	17259	32	State	State	NNP
18637	17259	33	University	University	NNP
18637	17259	34	Press	Press	NNP
18637	17259	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17259	36	,	,	,
18637	17259	37	chap	chap	NNP
18637	17259	38	.	.	.
18637	17260	1	III	iii	CD
18637	17260	2	.	.	.
18637	17261	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17261	2	80	80	CD
18637	17261	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17261	4	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	17261	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17261	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17261	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17261	8	Sandford	Sandford	NNP
18637	17261	9	,	,	,
18637	17261	10	10	10	CD
18637	17261	11	How	how	WRB
18637	17261	12	.	.	.
18637	17262	1	393	393	CD
18637	17262	2	,	,	,
18637	17262	3	450	450	CD
18637	17262	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17262	5	1857	1857	CD
18637	17262	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17262	7	.	.	.
18637	17263	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17263	2	81	81	CD
18637	17263	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17263	4	Adkins	Adkins	NNPS
18637	17263	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17263	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17263	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17263	8	Children	Children	NNP
18637	17263	9	's	's	POS
18637	17263	10	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	17263	11	,	,	,
18637	17263	12	261	261	CD
18637	17263	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17263	14	525	525	CD
18637	17263	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17263	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	17263	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17263	18	.	.	.
18637	17264	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17264	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17264	3	also	also	RB
18637	17264	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17264	5	Adair	Adair	NNP
18637	17264	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17264	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17264	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17264	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17264	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17264	11	,	,	,
18637	17264	12	208	208	CD
18637	17264	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17264	14	161	161	CD
18637	17264	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17264	16	1908	1908	CD
18637	17264	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17264	18	;	;	:
18637	17264	19	and	and	CC
18637	17264	20	Lochner	Lochner	NNP
18637	17264	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17264	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	17264	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17264	24	New	New	NNP
18637	17264	25	York	York	NNP
18637	17264	26	,	,	,
18637	17264	27	198	198	CD
18637	17264	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17264	29	45	45	CD
18637	17264	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17264	31	1905	1905	CD
18637	17264	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17264	33	.	.	.
18637	17265	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17265	2	82	82	CD
18637	17265	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17265	4	Den	Den	NNP
18637	17265	5	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17265	6	dem	dem	NNP
18637	17265	7	.	.	.
18637	17266	1	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	17266	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17266	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17266	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17266	5	Hoboken	Hoboken	NNP
18637	17266	6	Land	Land	NNP
18637	17266	7	&	&	CC
18637	17266	8	Improvement	Improvement	NNP
18637	17266	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17266	10	,	,	,
18637	17266	11	18	18	CD
18637	17266	12	How	how	WRB
18637	17266	13	.	.	.
18637	17267	1	272	272	CD
18637	17267	2	,	,	,
18637	17267	3	276	276	CD
18637	17267	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17267	5	1856	1856	CD
18637	17267	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17267	7	.	.	.
18637	17268	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17268	2	83	83	CD
18637	17268	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17268	4	Union	Union	NNP
18637	17268	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	17269	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17269	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17269	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17269	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17269	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17269	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17269	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17269	8	Sinking	Sinking	NNP
18637	17269	9	Fund	Fund	NNP
18637	17269	10	Cases	case	NNS
18637	17269	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17269	12	,	,	,
18637	17269	13	99	99	CD
18637	17269	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17269	15	700	700	CD
18637	17269	16	,	,	,
18637	17269	17	719	719	CD
18637	17269	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17269	19	1879	1879	CD
18637	17269	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17269	21	.	.	.
18637	17270	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17270	2	84	84	CD
18637	17270	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17270	4	Wong	Wong	NNP
18637	17270	5	Wing	Wing	NNP
18637	17270	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17270	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17270	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17270	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17270	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17270	11	,	,	,
18637	17270	12	163	163	CD
18637	17270	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17270	14	228	228	CD
18637	17270	15	,	,	,
18637	17270	16	238	238	CD
18637	17270	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17270	18	1896	1896	CD
18637	17270	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17270	20	.	.	.
18637	17271	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17271	2	85	85	CD
18637	17271	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17271	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17271	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17271	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17271	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17271	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17271	9	Ju	Ju	NNP
18637	17271	10	Toy	Toy	NNP
18637	17271	11	,	,	,
18637	17271	12	198	198	CD
18637	17271	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17271	14	253	253	CD
18637	17271	15	,	,	,
18637	17271	16	263	263	CD
18637	17271	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17271	18	1905	1905	CD
18637	17271	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17271	20	;	;	:
18637	17271	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17271	22	cf	cf	NNP
18637	17271	23	.	.	.
18637	17271	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17271	25	Quon	Quon	NNP
18637	17271	26	Quon	Quon	NNP
18637	17271	27	Poy	Poy	NNP
18637	17271	28	_	_	NNP
18637	17271	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	17271	30	_	_	NNP
18637	17271	31	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	17271	32	,	,	,
18637	17271	33	273	273	CD
18637	17271	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17271	35	352	352	CD
18637	17271	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17271	37	1927	1927	CD
18637	17271	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17271	39	.	.	.
18637	17272	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17272	2	86	86	CD
18637	17272	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17272	4	Wight	Wight	NNP
18637	17272	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17272	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17272	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17272	8	Davidson	Davidson	NNP
18637	17272	9	,	,	,
18637	17272	10	181	181	CD
18637	17272	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17272	12	371	371	CD
18637	17272	13	,	,	,
18637	17272	14	384	384	CD
18637	17272	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17272	16	1901	1901	CD
18637	17272	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17272	18	.	.	.
18637	17273	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17273	2	87	87	CD
18637	17273	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17273	4	Lovato	Lovato	NNP
18637	17273	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17273	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17273	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17273	8	New	New	NNP
18637	17273	9	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	17273	10	,	,	,
18637	17273	11	242	242	CD
18637	17273	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17273	13	199	199	CD
18637	17273	14	,	,	,
18637	17273	15	201	201	CD
18637	17273	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17273	17	1916	1916	CD
18637	17273	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17273	19	.	.	.
18637	17274	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17274	2	88	88	CD
18637	17274	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17274	4	Public	Public	NNP
18637	17274	5	Utility	Utility	NNP
18637	17274	6	Comrs	Comrs	NNP
18637	17274	7	.	.	.
18637	17275	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17275	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	17275	3	_	_	NNP
18637	17275	4	Ynchausti	Ynchausti	NNP
18637	17275	5	&	&	CC
18637	17275	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17275	7	,	,	,
18637	17275	8	251	251	CD
18637	17275	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17275	10	401	401	CD
18637	17275	11	,	,	,
18637	17275	12	406	406	CD
18637	17275	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17275	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	17275	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17275	16	.	.	.
18637	17276	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17276	2	89	89	CD
18637	17276	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17276	4	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	17276	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17276	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17276	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17276	8	Eisentrager	Eisentrager	NNP
18637	17276	9	,	,	,
18637	17276	10	339	339	CD
18637	17276	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17276	12	763	763	CD
18637	17276	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17276	14	1950	1950	CD
18637	17276	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17276	16	;	;	:
18637	17276	17	_	_	NNP
18637	17276	18	cf	cf	NNP
18637	17276	19	.	.	.
18637	17276	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17276	21	In	in	IN
18637	17276	22	re	re	IN
18637	17276	23	Yamashita	Yamashita	NNP
18637	17276	24	,	,	,
18637	17276	25	327	327	CD
18637	17276	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17276	27	1	1	CD
18637	17276	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17276	29	1946	1946	CD
18637	17276	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17276	31	.	.	.
18637	17277	1	Both	both	DT
18637	17277	2	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	17277	3	were	be	VBD
18637	17277	4	reached	reach	VBN
18637	17277	5	by	by	IN
18637	17277	6	a	a	DT
18637	17277	7	divided	divide	VBN
18637	17277	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17277	9	.	.	.
18637	17278	1	In	in	IN
18637	17278	2	the	the	DT
18637	17278	3	Yamashita	Yamashita	NNP
18637	17278	4	Case	Case	NNP
18637	17278	5	,	,	,
18637	17278	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	17278	7	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	17278	8	and	and	CC
18637	17278	9	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	17278	10	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	17278	11	on	on	IN
18637	17278	12	the	the	DT
18637	17278	13	ground	ground	NN
18637	17278	14	that	that	IN
18637	17278	15	the	the	DT
18637	17278	16	due	due	JJ
18637	17278	17	process	process	NN
18637	17278	18	clause	clause	NN
18637	17278	19	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	17278	20	to	to	IN
18637	17278	21	every	every	DT
18637	17278	22	human	human	NN
18637	17278	23	being	being	NN
18637	17278	24	,	,	,
18637	17278	25	including	include	VBG
18637	17278	26	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	17278	27	belligerents	belligerent	NNS
18637	17278	28	.	.	.
18637	17279	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17279	2	90	90	CD
18637	17279	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17279	4	Davidson	Davidson	NNP
18637	17279	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17279	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17279	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17279	8	New	New	NNP
18637	17279	9	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	17279	10	,	,	,
18637	17279	11	96	96	CD
18637	17279	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17279	13	97	97	CD
18637	17279	14	,	,	,
18637	17279	15	102	102	CD
18637	17279	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17279	17	1878	1878	CD
18637	17279	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17279	19	.	.	.
18637	17280	1	Public	Public	NNP
18637	17280	2	Clearing	Clearing	NNP
18637	17280	3	House	House	NNP
18637	17280	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17280	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	17280	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17280	7	Coyne	Coyne	NNP
18637	17280	8	,	,	,
18637	17280	9	194	194	CD
18637	17280	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17280	11	497	497	CD
18637	17280	12	,	,	,
18637	17280	13	508	508	CD
18637	17280	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17280	15	1904	1904	CD
18637	17280	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17280	17	.	.	.
18637	17281	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17281	2	91	91	CD
18637	17281	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17281	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17281	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	17281	6	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17281	7	,	,	,
18637	17281	8	107	107	CD
18637	17281	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17281	10	265	265	CD
18637	17281	11	,	,	,
18637	17281	12	289	289	CD
18637	17281	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17281	14	1883	1883	CD
18637	17281	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17281	16	.	.	.
18637	17282	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17282	2	92	92	CD
18637	17282	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17282	4	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	17282	5	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	17282	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	17282	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17282	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17282	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17282	10	Brimson	Brimson	NNP
18637	17282	11	,	,	,
18637	17282	12	154	154	CD
18637	17282	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17282	14	447	447	CD
18637	17282	15	,	,	,
18637	17282	16	489	489	CD
18637	17282	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17282	18	1894	1894	CD
18637	17282	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17282	20	;	;	:
18637	17282	21	Cooke	Cooke	NNP
18637	17282	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17282	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	17282	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17282	25	United	United	NNP
18637	17282	26	States	States	NNP
18637	17282	27	,	,	,
18637	17282	28	267	267	CD
18637	17282	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17282	30	517	517	CD
18637	17282	31	,	,	,
18637	17282	32	537	537	CD
18637	17282	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17282	34	1925	1925	CD
18637	17282	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17282	36	.	.	.
18637	17283	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17283	2	93	93	CD
18637	17283	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17283	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17283	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	17283	6	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17283	7	,	,	,
18637	17283	8	107	107	CD
18637	17283	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17283	10	265	265	CD
18637	17283	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17283	12	1883	1883	CD
18637	17283	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17283	14	.	.	.
18637	17284	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17284	2	94	94	CD
18637	17284	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17284	4	Reaves	Reaves	NNP
18637	17284	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17284	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17284	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17284	8	Ainsworth	Ainsworth	NNP
18637	17284	9	,	,	,
18637	17284	10	219	219	CD
18637	17284	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17284	12	296	296	CD
18637	17284	13	,	,	,
18637	17284	14	304	304	CD
18637	17284	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17284	16	1911	1911	CD
18637	17284	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17284	18	.	.	.
18637	17285	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17285	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17285	3	also	also	RB
18637	17285	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17285	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17285	6	parte	parte	NN
18637	17285	7	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	17285	8	,	,	,
18637	17285	9	100	100	CD
18637	17285	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17285	11	13	13	CD
18637	17285	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17285	13	1879	1879	CD
18637	17285	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17285	15	;	;	:
18637	17285	16	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	17285	17	_	_	NNP
18637	17285	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	17285	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17285	20	Sayre	Sayre	NNP
18637	17285	21	,	,	,
18637	17285	22	158	158	CD
18637	17285	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17285	24	109	109	CD
18637	17285	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17285	26	1895	1895	CD
18637	17285	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17285	28	;	;	:
18637	17285	29	Mullan	Mullan	NNP
18637	17285	30	_	_	NNP
18637	17285	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	17285	32	_	_	NNP
18637	17285	33	United	United	NNP
18637	17285	34	States	States	NNP
18637	17285	35	,	,	,
18637	17285	36	212	212	CD
18637	17285	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17285	38	516	516	CD
18637	17285	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17285	40	1909	1909	CD
18637	17285	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17285	42	;	;	:
18637	17285	43	United	United	NNP
18637	17285	44	States	States	NNP
18637	17285	45	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17285	46	rel	rel	NN
18637	17285	47	.	.	.
18637	17286	1	Creary	Creary	NNP
18637	17286	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17286	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17286	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17286	5	Weeks	Weeks	NNP
18637	17286	6	,	,	,
18637	17286	7	259	259	CD
18637	17286	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17286	9	336	336	CD
18637	17286	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17286	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	17286	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17286	13	.	.	.
18637	17287	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17287	2	95	95	CD
18637	17287	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17287	4	Kahn	Kahn	NNP
18637	17287	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17287	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17287	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17287	8	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	17287	9	,	,	,
18637	17287	10	255	255	CD
18637	17287	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17287	12	1	1	CD
18637	17287	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17287	14	1921	1921	CD
18637	17287	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17287	16	.	.	.
18637	17288	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17288	2	96	96	CD
18637	17288	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17288	4	Crain	Crain	NNP
18637	17288	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17288	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17288	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17288	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17288	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17288	10	,	,	,
18637	17288	11	162	162	CD
18637	17288	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17288	13	625	625	CD
18637	17288	14	,	,	,
18637	17288	15	645	645	CD
18637	17288	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17288	17	1896	1896	CD
18637	17288	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17288	19	.	.	.
18637	17289	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17289	2	97	97	CD
18637	17289	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17289	4	Hopt	Hopt	NNP
18637	17289	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17289	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17289	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17289	8	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	17289	9	,	,	,
18637	17289	10	110	110	CD
18637	17289	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17289	12	574	574	CD
18637	17289	13	,	,	,
18637	17289	14	579	579	CD
18637	17289	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17289	16	1884	1884	CD
18637	17289	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17289	18	.	.	.
18637	17290	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17290	2	98	98	CD
18637	17290	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17290	4	Blackmer	Blackmer	NNP
18637	17290	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17290	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17290	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17290	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17290	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17290	10	,	,	,
18637	17290	11	284	284	CD
18637	17290	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17290	13	421	421	CD
18637	17290	14	,	,	,
18637	17290	15	440	440	CD
18637	17290	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17290	17	1932	1932	CD
18637	17290	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17290	19	.	.	.
18637	17291	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17291	2	99	99	CD
18637	17291	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17291	4	Hovey	Hovey	NNP
18637	17291	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17291	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17291	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17291	8	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	17291	9	,	,	,
18637	17291	10	167	167	CD
18637	17291	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17291	12	409	409	CD
18637	17291	13	,	,	,
18637	17291	14	417	417	CD
18637	17291	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17291	16	1897	1897	CD
18637	17291	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17291	18	.	.	.
18637	17292	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17292	2	100	100	CD
18637	17292	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17292	4	Beall	Beall	NNP
18637	17292	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17292	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17292	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17292	8	New	New	NNP
18637	17292	9	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	17292	10	ex	ex	NN
18637	17292	11	rel	rel	NN
18637	17292	12	.	.	.
18637	17293	1	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	17293	2	,	,	,
18637	17293	3	16	16	CD
18637	17293	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17293	5	.	.	.
18637	17294	1	535	535	CD
18637	17294	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17294	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	17294	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17294	5	.	.	.
18637	17295	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17295	2	101	101	CD
18637	17295	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17295	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17295	5	Surety	Surety	NNP
18637	17295	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17295	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17295	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17295	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17295	10	American	American	NNP
18637	17295	11	Fruit	Fruit	NNP
18637	17295	12	Product	Product	NNP
18637	17295	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17295	14	,	,	,
18637	17295	15	238	238	CD
18637	17295	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17295	17	140	140	CD
18637	17295	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17295	19	1915	1915	CD
18637	17295	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17295	21	.	.	.
18637	17296	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17296	2	102	102	CD
18637	17296	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17296	4	Helis	Helis	NNP
18637	17296	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17296	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17296	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17296	8	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	17296	9	,	,	,
18637	17296	10	308	308	CD
18637	17296	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17296	12	365	365	CD
18637	17296	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17296	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	17296	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17296	16	.	.	.
18637	17297	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17297	2	103	103	CD
18637	17297	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17297	4	Fayerweather	Fayerweather	NNP
18637	17297	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17297	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17297	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17297	8	Ritch	Ritch	NNP
18637	17297	9	,	,	,
18637	17297	10	195	195	CD
18637	17297	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17297	12	276	276	CD
18637	17297	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17297	14	1904	1904	CD
18637	17297	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17297	16	.	.	.
18637	17298	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17298	2	104	104	CD
18637	17298	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17298	4	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
18637	17298	5	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	17298	6	.	.	.
18637	17299	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	17299	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17299	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17299	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17299	5	Moyses	Moyses	NNP
18637	17299	6	,	,	,
18637	17299	7	186	186	CD
18637	17299	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17299	9	181	181	CD
18637	17299	10	,	,	,
18637	17299	11	192	192	CD
18637	17299	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17299	13	1902	1902	CD
18637	17299	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17299	15	.	.	.
18637	17300	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17300	2	105	105	CD
18637	17300	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17300	4	Parsons	Parsons	NNPS
18637	17300	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17300	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17300	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17300	8	District	District	NNP
18637	17300	9	of	of	IN
18637	17300	10	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	17300	11	,	,	,
18637	17300	12	170	170	CD
18637	17300	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17300	14	45	45	CD
18637	17300	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17300	16	1898	1898	CD
18637	17300	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17300	18	.	.	.
18637	17301	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17301	2	106	106	CD
18637	17301	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17301	4	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	17301	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17301	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17301	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17301	8	Davidson	Davidson	NNP
18637	17301	9	,	,	,
18637	17301	10	181	181	CD
18637	17301	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17301	12	371	371	CD
18637	17301	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17301	14	1901	1901	CD
18637	17301	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17301	16	.	.	.
18637	17302	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17302	2	107	107	CD
18637	17302	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17302	4	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	17302	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17302	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17302	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17302	8	Buffalo	Buffalo	NNP
18637	17302	9	Creek	Creek	NNP
18637	17302	10	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	17302	11	&	&	CC
18637	17302	12	Coke	Coke	NNP
18637	17302	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17302	14	,	,	,
18637	17302	15	245	245	CD
18637	17302	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17302	17	328	328	CD
18637	17302	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17302	19	1917	1917	CD
18637	17302	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17302	21	.	.	.
18637	17303	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17303	2	108	108	CD
18637	17303	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17303	4	Luria	Luria	NNP
18637	17303	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17303	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17303	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17303	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17303	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17303	10	,	,	,
18637	17303	11	231	231	CD
18637	17303	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17303	13	9	9	CD
18637	17303	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17303	15	1913	1913	CD
18637	17303	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17303	17	.	.	.
18637	17304	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17304	2	109	109	CD
18637	17304	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17304	4	Yee	Yee	NNP
18637	17304	5	Hem	Hem	NNP
18637	17304	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17304	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17304	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17304	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17304	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17304	11	,	,	,
18637	17304	12	268	268	CD
18637	17304	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17304	14	178	178	CD
18637	17304	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17304	16	1925	1925	CD
18637	17304	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17304	18	.	.	.
18637	17305	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17305	2	110	110	CD
18637	17305	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17305	4	Tot	Tot	NNP
18637	17305	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17305	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17305	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17305	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17305	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17305	10	,	,	,
18637	17305	11	319	319	CD
18637	17305	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17305	13	463	463	CD
18637	17305	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17305	15	1943	1943	CD
18637	17305	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17305	17	.	.	.
18637	17306	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17306	2	111	111	CD
18637	17306	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17306	4	Opp	Opp	NNP
18637	17306	5	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	17306	6	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	17306	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17306	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17306	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17306	10	Administrator	Administrator	NNP
18637	17306	11	,	,	,
18637	17306	12	312	312	CD
18637	17306	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17306	14	126	126	CD
18637	17306	15	,	,	,
18637	17306	16	152	152	CD
18637	17306	17	,	,	,
18637	17306	18	153	153	CD
18637	17306	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17306	20	1941	1941	CD
18637	17306	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17306	22	.	.	.
18637	17307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17307	2	112	112	CD
18637	17307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17307	4	321	321	CD
18637	17307	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17307	6	503	503	CD
18637	17307	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17307	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	17307	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17307	10	.	.	.
18637	17308	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17308	2	113	113	CD
18637	17308	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17308	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17308	5	.	.	.
18637	17309	1	521	521	CD
18637	17309	2	.	.	.
18637	17310	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17310	2	114	114	CD
18637	17310	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17310	4	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	17310	5	Edison	Edison	NNP
18637	17310	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17310	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17310	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17310	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17310	10	National	National	NNP
18637	17310	11	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	17310	12	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	17310	13	Board	Board	NNP
18637	17310	14	,	,	,
18637	17310	15	305	305	CD
18637	17310	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17310	17	197	197	CD
18637	17310	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17310	19	1938	1938	CD
18637	17310	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17310	21	.	.	.
18637	17311	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17311	2	115	115	CD
18637	17311	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17311	4	Central	Central	NNP
18637	17311	5	of	of	IN
18637	17311	6	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	17311	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	17311	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17311	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17311	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17311	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17311	12	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	17311	13	,	,	,
18637	17311	14	207	207	CD
18637	17311	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17311	16	127	127	CD
18637	17311	17	,	,	,
18637	17311	18	136	136	CD
18637	17311	19	,	,	,
18637	17311	20	138	138	CD
18637	17311	21	,	,	,
18637	17311	22	142	142	CD
18637	17311	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17311	24	1907	1907	CD
18637	17311	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17311	26	;	;	:
18637	17311	27	Lipke	Lipke	NNP
18637	17311	28	_	_	NNP
18637	17311	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	17311	30	_	_	NNP
18637	17311	31	Lederer	Lederer	NNP
18637	17311	32	,	,	,
18637	17311	33	259	259	CD
18637	17311	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17311	35	557	557	CD
18637	17311	36	,	,	,
18637	17311	37	562	562	CD
18637	17311	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17311	39	1922	1922	CD
18637	17311	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17311	41	.	.	.
18637	17312	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17312	2	116	116	CD
18637	17312	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17312	4	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	17312	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17312	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17312	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17312	8	Comr	Comr	NNP
18637	17312	9	.	.	.
18637	17313	1	of	of	IN
18637	17313	2	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	17313	3	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	17313	4	,	,	,
18637	17313	5	283	283	CD
18637	17313	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17313	7	589	589	CD
18637	17313	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17313	9	1931	1931	CD
18637	17313	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17313	11	.	.	.
18637	17314	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17314	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	17314	3	.	.	.
18637	17314	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17314	5	Springer	Springer	NNP
18637	17314	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17314	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17314	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17314	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17314	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17314	11	,	,	,
18637	17314	12	102	102	CD
18637	17314	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17314	14	586	586	CD
18637	17314	15	,	,	,
18637	17314	16	593	593	CD
18637	17314	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17314	18	1881	1881	CD
18637	17314	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17314	20	;	;	:
18637	17314	21	and	and	CC
18637	17314	22	Passavant	Passavant	NNP
18637	17314	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17314	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	17314	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17314	26	United	United	NNP
18637	17314	27	States	States	NNP
18637	17314	28	,	,	,
18637	17314	29	148	148	CD
18637	17314	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17314	31	214	214	CD
18637	17314	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17314	33	1893	1893	CD
18637	17314	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17314	35	.	.	.
18637	17315	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17315	2	117	117	CD
18637	17315	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17315	4	Wong	Wong	NNP
18637	17315	5	Yang	Yang	NNP
18637	17315	6	Sung	Sung	NNP
18637	17315	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17315	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17315	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17315	10	McGrath	McGrath	NNP
18637	17315	11	,	,	,
18637	17315	12	339	339	CD
18637	17315	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17315	14	33	33	CD
18637	17315	15	,	,	,
18637	17315	16	50	50	CD
18637	17315	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17315	18	1950	1950	CD
18637	17315	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17315	20	.	.	.
18637	17316	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17316	2	118	118	CD
18637	17316	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17316	4	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	17316	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17316	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17316	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17316	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17316	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17316	10	,	,	,
18637	17316	11	304	304	CD
18637	17316	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17316	13	1	1	CD
18637	17316	14	,	,	,
18637	17316	15	18	18	CD
18637	17316	16	-	-	SYM
18637	17316	17	19	19	CD
18637	17316	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17316	19	1938	1938	CD
18637	17316	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17316	21	.	.	.
18637	17317	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17317	2	119	119	CD
18637	17317	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17317	4	National	National	NNP
18637	17317	5	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	17317	6	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	17317	7	Board	Board	NNP
18637	17317	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17317	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17317	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17317	11	Mackay	Mackay	NNP
18637	17317	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17317	13	,	,	,
18637	17317	14	304	304	CD
18637	17317	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17317	16	333	333	CD
18637	17317	17	,	,	,
18637	17317	18	349	349	CD
18637	17317	19	-	-	SYM
18637	17317	20	350	350	CD
18637	17317	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17317	22	1938	1938	CD
18637	17317	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17317	24	.	.	.
18637	17318	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17318	2	120	120	CD
18637	17318	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17318	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	17318	5	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	17318	6	Makers	Makers	NNPS
18637	17318	7	'	'	POS
18637	17318	8	Chemical	Chemical	NNP
18637	17318	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17318	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17318	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	17318	12	_	_	NNP
18637	17318	13	United	United	NNP
18637	17318	14	States	States	NNP
18637	17318	15	,	,	,
18637	17318	16	271	271	CD
18637	17318	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17318	18	268	268	CD
18637	17318	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17318	20	1926	1926	CD
18637	17318	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17318	22	.	.	.
18637	17319	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17319	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17319	3	also	also	RB
18637	17319	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17319	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17319	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17319	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17319	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17319	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17319	10	Abilene	Abilene	NNP
18637	17319	11	&	&	CC
18637	17319	12	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	17320	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17320	2	,	,	,
18637	17320	3	265	265	CD
18637	17320	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17320	5	274	274	CD
18637	17320	6	,	,	,
18637	17320	7	288	288	CD
18637	17320	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17320	9	1924	1924	CD
18637	17320	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17320	11	.	.	.
18637	17321	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17321	2	121	121	CD
18637	17321	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17321	4	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	17321	5	Edison	Edison	NNP
18637	17321	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17321	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17321	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17321	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17321	10	National	National	NNP
18637	17321	11	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	17321	12	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	17321	13	Board	Board	NNP
18637	17321	14	,	,	,
18637	17321	15	305	305	CD
18637	17321	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17321	17	197	197	CD
18637	17321	18	,	,	,
18637	17321	19	229	229	CD
18637	17321	20	-	-	SYM
18637	17321	21	230	230	CD
18637	17321	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17321	23	1938	1938	CD
18637	17321	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17321	25	.	.	.
18637	17322	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17322	2	122	122	CD
18637	17322	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17322	4	Londoner	Londoner	NNP
18637	17322	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17322	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17322	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17322	8	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	17322	9	,	,	,
18637	17322	10	210	210	CD
18637	17322	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17322	12	373	373	CD
18637	17322	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17322	14	1908	1908	CD
18637	17322	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17322	16	.	.	.
18637	17323	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17323	2	123	123	CD
18637	17323	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17323	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	17323	5	Communications	Communications	NNPS
18637	17323	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	17323	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17323	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17323	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17323	10	WJR	WJR	NNP
18637	17323	11	,	,	,
18637	17323	12	337	337	CD
18637	17323	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17323	14	265	265	CD
18637	17323	15	,	,	,
18637	17323	16	274	274	CD
18637	17323	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	17323	18	277	277	CD
18637	17323	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17323	20	1949	1949	CD
18637	17323	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17323	22	.	.	.
18637	17324	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17324	2	124	124	CD
18637	17324	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17324	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17324	5	.	.	.
18637	17325	1	276	276	CD
18637	17325	2	.	.	.
18637	17326	1	"	"	``
18637	17326	2	The	the	DT
18637	17326	3	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	17326	4	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	17326	5	by	by	IN
18637	17326	6	the	the	DT
18637	17326	7	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	17326	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17326	9	of	of	IN
18637	17326	10	due	due	JJ
18637	17326	11	process	process	NN
18637	17326	12	of	of	IN
18637	17326	13	law	law	NN
18637	17326	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17326	15	are	be	VBP
18637	17326	16	not	not	RB
18637	17326	17	technical	technical	JJ
18637	17326	18	,	,	,
18637	17326	19	nor	nor	CC
18637	17326	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	17326	21	any	any	DT
18637	17326	22	particular	particular	JJ
18637	17326	23	form	form	NN
18637	17326	24	of	of	IN
18637	17326	25	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	17326	26	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	17326	27	.	.	.
18637	17326	28	"	"	''
18637	17327	1	Inland	Inland	NNP
18637	17327	2	Empire	Empire	NNP
18637	17327	3	Council	Council	NNP
18637	17327	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17327	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	17327	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17327	7	Millis	Millis	NNP
18637	17327	8	,	,	,
18637	17327	9	325	325	CD
18637	17327	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17327	11	697	697	CD
18637	17327	12	,	,	,
18637	17327	13	710	710	CD
18637	17327	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17327	15	1945	1945	CD
18637	17327	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17327	17	.	.	.
18637	17328	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17328	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17328	3	_	_	NNP
18637	17328	4	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	17328	5	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	17328	6	Act	Act	NNP
18637	17328	7	,	,	,
18637	17328	8	60	60	CD
18637	17328	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	17328	10	.	.	.
18637	17329	1	237	237	CD
18637	17329	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17329	3	1946	1946	CD
18637	17329	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17329	5	;	;	:
18637	17329	6	5	5	CD
18637	17329	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	17330	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	17330	2	1001	1001	CD
18637	17330	3	-	-	SYM
18637	17330	4	1011	1011	CD
18637	17330	5	.	.	.
18637	17331	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17331	2	125	125	CD
18637	17331	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17331	4	298	298	CD
18637	17331	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17331	6	38	38	CD
18637	17331	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17331	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	17331	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17331	10	.	.	.
18637	17332	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17332	2	126	126	CD
18637	17332	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17332	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17332	5	.	.	.
18637	17333	1	51	51	CD
18637	17333	2	-	-	SYM
18637	17333	3	54	54	CD
18637	17333	4	.	.	.
18637	17334	1	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	17334	2	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	17334	3	,	,	,
18637	17334	4	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	17334	5	and	and	CC
18637	17334	6	Cardozo	Cardozo	NNP
18637	17334	7	,	,	,
18637	17334	8	while	while	IN
18637	17334	9	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	17334	10	in	in	IN
18637	17334	11	the	the	DT
18637	17334	12	result	result	NN
18637	17334	13	,	,	,
18637	17334	14	took	take	VBD
18637	17334	15	exception	exception	NN
18637	17334	16	to	to	IN
18637	17334	17	this	this	DT
18637	17334	18	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	17334	19	.	.	.
18637	17335	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17335	2	127	127	CD
18637	17335	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17335	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	17335	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	17335	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	17335	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17335	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17335	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17335	10	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	17335	11	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	17335	12	Pipeline	Pipeline	NNP
18637	17335	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17335	14	,	,	,
18637	17335	15	315	315	CD
18637	17335	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17335	17	575	575	CD
18637	17335	18	,	,	,
18637	17335	19	586	586	CD
18637	17335	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17335	21	1942	1942	CD
18637	17335	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17335	23	;	;	:
18637	17335	24	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	17335	25	Power	Power	NNP
18637	17335	26	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	17335	27	_	_	NNP
18637	17335	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	17335	29	_	_	NNP
18637	17335	30	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	17335	31	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	17335	32	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	17335	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17335	34	,	,	,
18637	17335	35	320	320	CD
18637	17335	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17335	37	591	591	CD
18637	17335	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17335	39	1944	1944	CD
18637	17335	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17335	41	.	.	.
18637	17336	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17336	2	128	128	CD
18637	17336	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17336	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	17336	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	17336	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	17336	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17336	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17336	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17336	10	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	17336	11	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	17336	12	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	17336	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17336	14	,	,	,
18637	17336	15	320	320	CD
18637	17336	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17336	17	591	591	CD
18637	17336	18	,	,	,
18637	17336	19	602	602	CD
18637	17336	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17336	21	1944	1944	CD
18637	17336	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17336	23	.	.	.
18637	17337	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17337	2	129	129	CD
18637	17337	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17337	4	327	327	CD
18637	17337	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17337	6	1	1	CD
18637	17337	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17337	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	17337	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17337	10	.	.	.
18637	17338	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17338	2	130	130	CD
18637	17338	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17338	4	339	339	CD
18637	17338	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17338	6	103	103	CD
18637	17338	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17338	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	17338	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17338	10	.	.	.
18637	17339	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17339	2	131	131	CD
18637	17339	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17339	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17339	5	.	.	.
18637	17340	1	111	111	CD
18637	17340	2	.	.	.
18637	17341	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17341	2	132	132	CD
18637	17341	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17341	4	339	339	CD
18637	17341	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17341	6	703	703	CD
18637	17341	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17341	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	17341	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17341	10	.	.	.
18637	17342	1	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	17342	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	17342	3	,	,	,
18637	17342	4	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	17342	5	and	and	CC
18637	17342	6	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	17342	7	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	17342	8	.	.	.
18637	17343	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17343	2	133	133	CD
18637	17343	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17343	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17343	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17343	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17343	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17343	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17343	9	Ju	Ju	NNP
18637	17343	10	Toy	Toy	NNP
18637	17343	11	,	,	,
18637	17343	12	198	198	CD
18637	17343	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17343	14	253	253	CD
18637	17343	15	,	,	,
18637	17343	16	263	263	CD
18637	17343	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17343	18	1905	1905	CD
18637	17343	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17343	20	.	.	.
18637	17344	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17344	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17344	3	also	also	RB
18637	17344	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17344	5	Yamataya	Yamataya	NNP
18637	17344	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17344	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17344	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17344	9	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	17344	10	,	,	,
18637	17344	11	189	189	CD
18637	17344	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17344	13	86	86	CD
18637	17344	14	,	,	,
18637	17344	15	100	100	CD
18637	17344	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17344	17	1903	1903	CD
18637	17344	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17344	19	.	.	.
18637	17345	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17345	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	17345	3	.	.	.
18637	17345	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17345	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17345	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17345	7	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17345	8	rel	rel	NN
18637	17345	9	.	.	.
18637	17346	1	Knauff	Knauff	NNP
18637	17346	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17346	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17346	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17346	5	Shaughnessy	Shaughnessy	NNP
18637	17346	6	,	,	,
18637	17346	7	338	338	CD
18637	17346	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17346	9	537	537	CD
18637	17346	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17346	11	1950	1950	CD
18637	17346	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17346	13	.	.	.
18637	17347	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17347	2	134	134	CD
18637	17347	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17347	4	Oceanic	Oceanic	NNP
18637	17347	5	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	17347	6	Navig	Navig	NNP
18637	17347	7	.	.	.
18637	17348	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17348	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17348	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17348	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17348	5	Stranahan	Stranahan	NNP
18637	17348	6	,	,	,
18637	17348	7	214	214	CD
18637	17348	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17348	9	320	320	CD
18637	17348	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17348	11	1909	1909	CD
18637	17348	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17348	13	.	.	.
18637	17349	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17349	2	135	135	CD
18637	17349	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17349	4	Kwock	Kwock	NNP
18637	17349	5	Jan	Jan	NNP
18637	17349	6	Fat	Fat	NNP
18637	17349	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17349	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17349	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17349	10	White	White	NNP
18637	17349	11	,	,	,
18637	17349	12	253	253	CD
18637	17349	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17349	14	454	454	CD
18637	17349	15	,	,	,
18637	17349	16	457	457	CD
18637	17349	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17349	18	1920	1920	CD
18637	17349	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17349	20	.	.	.
18637	17350	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17350	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17350	3	also	also	RB
18637	17350	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17350	5	Chin	Chin	NNP
18637	17350	6	Yow	Yow	NNP
18637	17350	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17350	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17350	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17350	10	United	United	NNP
18637	17350	11	States	States	NNP
18637	17350	12	,	,	,
18637	17350	13	208	208	CD
18637	17350	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17350	15	8	8	CD
18637	17350	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17350	17	1908	1908	CD
18637	17350	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17350	19	.	.	.
18637	17351	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17351	2	136	136	CD
18637	17351	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17351	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17351	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17351	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17351	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17351	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17351	9	Sing	Sing	NNP
18637	17351	10	Tuck	Tuck	NNP
18637	17351	11	,	,	,
18637	17351	12	194	194	CD
18637	17351	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17351	14	161	161	CD
18637	17351	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17351	16	1904	1904	CD
18637	17351	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17351	18	.	.	.
18637	17352	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17352	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17352	3	also	also	RB
18637	17352	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17352	5	Quon	Quon	NNP
18637	17352	6	Quon	Quon	NNP
18637	17352	7	Poy	Poy	NNP
18637	17352	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17352	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17352	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17352	11	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	17352	12	,	,	,
18637	17352	13	273	273	CD
18637	17352	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17352	15	352	352	CD
18637	17352	16	,	,	,
18637	17352	17	358	358	CD
18637	17352	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17352	19	1927	1927	CD
18637	17352	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17352	21	.	.	.
18637	17353	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17353	2	137	137	CD
18637	17353	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17353	4	Zakonaite	Zakonaite	NNP
18637	17353	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17353	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17353	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17353	8	Wolf	Wolf	NNP
18637	17353	9	,	,	,
18637	17353	10	226	226	CD
18637	17353	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17353	12	272	272	CD
18637	17353	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17353	14	1012	1012	CD
18637	17353	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17353	16	.	.	.
18637	17354	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17354	2	138	138	CD
18637	17354	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17354	4	339	339	CD
18637	17354	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17354	6	33	33	CD
18637	17354	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17354	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	17354	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17354	10	.	.	.
18637	17355	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17355	2	139	139	CD
18637	17355	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17355	4	60	60	CD
18637	17355	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	17355	6	.	.	.
18637	17356	1	237	237	CD
18637	17356	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17356	3	1946	1946	CD
18637	17356	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17356	5	;	;	:
18637	17356	6	5	5	CD
18637	17356	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	17357	1	§	§	NNP
18637	17357	2	1001	1001	CD
18637	17357	3	_	_	NNP
18637	17357	4	et	et	NNP
18637	17357	5	seq	seq	NN
18637	17357	6	.	.	.
18637	17357	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17357	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17357	9	1946	1946	CD
18637	17357	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17357	11	.	.	.
18637	17358	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17358	2	140	140	CD
18637	17358	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17358	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17358	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17358	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17358	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	17358	8	.	.	.
18637	17359	1	Vajtauer	Vajtauer	NNP
18637	17359	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17359	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17359	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17359	5	Comr	Comr	NNP
18637	17359	6	.	.	.
18637	17360	1	of	of	IN
18637	17360	2	Immigration	Immigration	NNP
18637	17360	3	,	,	,
18637	17360	4	273	273	CD
18637	17360	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17360	6	103	103	CD
18637	17360	7	,	,	,
18637	17360	8	106	106	CD
18637	17360	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17360	10	1927	1927	CD
18637	17360	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17360	12	.	.	.
18637	17361	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17361	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17361	3	also	also	RB
18637	17361	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17361	5	Mahler	Mahler	NNP
18637	17361	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17361	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17361	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17361	9	Eby	Eby	NNP
18637	17361	10	,	,	,
18637	17361	11	264	264	CD
18637	17361	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17361	13	32	32	CD
18637	17361	14	,	,	,
18637	17361	15	41	41	CD
18637	17361	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17361	17	1924	1924	CD
18637	17361	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17361	19	.	.	.
18637	17362	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17362	2	141	141	CD
18637	17362	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17362	4	198	198	CD
18637	17362	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17362	6	253	253	CD
18637	17362	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17362	8	1905	1905	CD
18637	17362	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17362	10	.	.	.
18637	17363	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17363	2	142	142	CD
18637	17363	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17363	4	Ng	Ng	NNP
18637	17363	5	Fung	Fung	NNP
18637	17363	6	Ho	Ho	NNP
18637	17363	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17363	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17363	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17363	10	White	White	NNP
18637	17363	11	,	,	,
18637	17363	12	259	259	CD
18637	17363	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17363	14	276	276	CD
18637	17363	15	,	,	,
18637	17363	16	281	281	CD
18637	17363	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17363	18	1922	1922	CD
18637	17363	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17363	20	.	.	.
18637	17364	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17364	2	143	143	CD
18637	17364	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17364	4	Ludecke	Ludecke	NNP
18637	17364	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17364	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17364	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17364	8	Watkins	Watkins	NNP
18637	17364	9	,	,	,
18637	17364	10	335	335	CD
18637	17364	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17364	12	160	160	CD
18637	17364	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17364	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	17364	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17364	16	.	.	.
18637	17365	1	Three	three	CD
18637	17365	2	of	of	IN
18637	17365	3	the	the	DT
18637	17365	4	four	four	CD
18637	17365	5	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	17365	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	17365	7	,	,	,
18637	17365	8	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	17365	9	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	17365	10	,	,	,
18637	17365	11	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	17365	12	and	and	CC
18637	17365	13	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	17365	14	,	,	,
18637	17365	15	argued	argue	VBD
18637	17365	16	that	that	IN
18637	17365	17	even	even	RB
18637	17365	18	an	an	DT
18637	17365	19	enemy	enemy	NN
18637	17365	20	alien	alien	NN
18637	17365	21	could	could	MD
18637	17365	22	not	not	RB
18637	17365	23	be	be	VB
18637	17365	24	deported	deport	VBN
18637	17365	25	without	without	IN
18637	17365	26	a	a	DT
18637	17365	27	fair	fair	JJ
18637	17365	28	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	17365	29	.	.	.
18637	17366	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17366	2	144	144	CD
18637	17366	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17366	4	Steward	Steward	NNP
18637	17366	5	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	17366	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17366	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17366	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17366	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17366	10	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	17366	11	,	,	,
18637	17366	12	301	301	CD
18637	17366	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17366	14	548	548	CD
18637	17366	15	,	,	,
18637	17366	16	584	584	CD
18637	17366	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	17366	18	585	585	CD
18637	17366	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17366	20	1937	1937	CD
18637	17366	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17366	22	;	;	:
18637	17366	23	Currin	Currin	NNP
18637	17366	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17366	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	17366	26	_	_	NNP
18637	17366	27	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	17366	28	,	,	,
18637	17366	29	306	306	CD
18637	17366	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17366	31	1	1	CD
18637	17366	32	,	,	,
18637	17366	33	14	14	CD
18637	17366	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17366	35	1939	1939	CD
18637	17366	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17366	37	;	;	:
18637	17366	38	Sunshine	Sunshine	NNP
18637	17366	39	Anthracite	Anthracite	NNP
18637	17366	40	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	17366	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17366	42	_	_	NNP
18637	17366	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	17366	44	_	_	NNP
18637	17366	45	Adkins	Adkins	NNP
18637	17366	46	,	,	,
18637	17366	47	310	310	CD
18637	17366	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17366	49	381	381	CD
18637	17366	50	,	,	,
18637	17366	51	401	401	CD
18637	17366	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17366	53	1940	1940	CD
18637	17366	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17366	55	;	;	:
18637	17366	56	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	17366	57	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	17366	58	_	_	NNP
18637	17366	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	17366	60	_	_	NNP
18637	17366	61	United	United	NNP
18637	17366	62	States	States	NNP
18637	17366	63	,	,	,
18637	17366	64	317	317	CD
18637	17366	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17366	66	329	329	CD
18637	17366	67	,	,	,
18637	17366	68	337	337	CD
18637	17366	69	,	,	,
18637	17366	70	338	338	CD
18637	17366	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17366	72	1943	1943	CD
18637	17366	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17366	74	.	.	.
18637	17367	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17367	2	145	145	CD
18637	17367	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17367	4	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	17367	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17367	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17367	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17367	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17367	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17367	10	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17367	11	rel	rel	NN
18637	17367	12	.	.	.
18637	17368	1	Weiner	Weiner	NNP
18637	17368	2	,	,	,
18637	17368	3	300	300	CD
18637	17368	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17368	5	105	105	CD
18637	17368	6	,	,	,
18637	17368	7	109	109	CD
18637	17368	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17368	9	1937	1937	CD
18637	17368	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17368	11	.	.	.
18637	17369	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17369	2	146	146	CD
18637	17369	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17369	4	District	District	NNP
18637	17369	5	of	of	IN
18637	17369	6	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	17369	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17369	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17369	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17369	10	Brooke	Brooke	NNP
18637	17369	11	,	,	,
18637	17369	12	214	214	CD
18637	17369	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17369	14	138	138	CD
18637	17369	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17369	16	1909	1909	CD
18637	17369	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17369	18	.	.	.
18637	17370	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17370	2	147	147	CD
18637	17370	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17370	4	Panama	Panama	NNP
18637	17370	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	17370	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17370	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17370	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17370	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17370	10	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	17370	11	,	,	,
18637	17370	12	264	264	CD
18637	17370	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17370	14	375	375	CD
18637	17370	15	,	,	,
18637	17370	16	392	392	CD
18637	17370	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17370	18	1924	1924	CD
18637	17370	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17370	20	.	.	.
18637	17371	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17371	2	148	148	CD
18637	17371	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17371	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17371	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17371	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17371	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17371	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17371	9	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	17371	10	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	17371	11	Co	Co	NNP
18637	17371	12	-	-	NN
18637	17371	13	operative	operative	NNP
18637	17371	14	,	,	,
18637	17371	15	307	307	CD
18637	17371	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17371	17	533	533	CD
18637	17371	18	,	,	,
18637	17371	19	562	562	CD
18637	17371	20	,	,	,
18637	17371	21	565	565	CD
18637	17371	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17371	23	1939	1939	CD
18637	17371	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17371	25	.	.	.
18637	17372	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17372	2	149	149	CD
18637	17372	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17372	4	Currin	Currin	NNP
18637	17372	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17372	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17372	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17372	8	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	17372	9	,	,	,
18637	17372	10	306	306	CD
18637	17372	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17372	12	1	1	CD
18637	17372	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17372	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	17372	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17372	16	.	.	.
18637	17373	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17373	2	150	150	CD
18637	17373	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17373	4	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	17373	5	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	17373	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17373	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17373	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17373	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17373	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17373	11	,	,	,
18637	17373	12	317	317	CD
18637	17373	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17373	14	329	329	CD
18637	17373	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17373	16	1943	1943	CD
18637	17373	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17373	18	.	.	.
18637	17374	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17374	2	151	151	CD
18637	17374	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17374	4	Hurd	Hurd	NNP
18637	17374	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17374	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17374	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17374	8	Hodge	Hodge	NNP
18637	17374	9	,	,	,
18637	17374	10	334	334	CD
18637	17374	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17374	12	24	24	CD
18637	17374	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17374	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	17374	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17374	16	.	.	.
18637	17375	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17375	2	152	152	CD
18637	17375	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17375	4	Thiel	Thiel	NNP
18637	17375	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17375	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17375	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17375	8	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	17375	9	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	17375	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17375	11	,	,	,
18637	17375	12	328	328	CD
18637	17375	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17375	14	217	217	CD
18637	17375	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17375	16	1946	1946	CD
18637	17375	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17375	18	.	.	.
18637	17376	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17376	2	153	153	CD
18637	17376	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17376	4	323	323	CD
18637	17376	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17376	6	192	192	CD
18637	17376	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17376	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	17376	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17376	10	.	.	.
18637	17377	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17377	2	154	154	CD
18637	17377	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17377	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17377	5	.	.	.
18637	17378	1	198	198	CD
18637	17378	2	,	,	,
18637	17378	3	199	199	CD
18637	17378	4	.	.	.
18637	17379	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17379	2	155	155	CD
18637	17379	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17379	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17379	5	.	.	.
18637	17380	1	208	208	CD
18637	17380	2	,	,	,
18637	17380	3	209	209	CD
18637	17380	4	.	.	.
18637	17381	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17381	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	17381	3	.	.	.
18637	17381	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17381	5	the	the	DT
18637	17381	6	following	follow	VBG
18637	17381	7	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	17381	8	from	from	IN
18637	17381	9	the	the	DT
18637	17381	10	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	17381	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17381	12	of	of	IN
18637	17381	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	17381	14	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	17381	15	in	in	IN
18637	17381	16	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	17381	17	Express	Express	NNP
18637	17381	18	Agency	Agency	NNP
18637	17381	19	,	,	,
18637	17381	20	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	17381	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17381	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	17381	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17381	24	New	New	NNP
18637	17381	25	York	York	NNP
18637	17381	26	,	,	,
18637	17381	27	336	336	CD
18637	17381	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17381	29	106	106	CD
18637	17381	30	,	,	,
18637	17381	31	112	112	CD
18637	17381	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17381	33	1949	1949	CD
18637	17381	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17381	35	:	:	:
18637	17381	36	"	"	``
18637	17381	37	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17381	38	regard	regard	VBP
18637	17381	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17381	40	as	as	IN
18637	17381	41	a	a	DT
18637	17381	42	salutary	salutary	JJ
18637	17381	43	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	17381	44	that	that	IN
18637	17381	45	cities	city	NNS
18637	17381	46	,	,	,
18637	17381	47	states	state	NNS
18637	17381	48	and	and	CC
18637	17381	49	the	the	DT
18637	17381	50	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	17381	51	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17381	52	must	must	MD
18637	17381	53	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	17381	54	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17381	55	powers	power	NNS
18637	17381	56	so	so	IN
18637	17381	57	as	as	IN
18637	17381	58	not	not	RB
18637	17381	59	to	to	TO
18637	17381	60	discriminate	discriminate	VB
18637	17381	61	between	between	IN
18637	17381	62	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17381	63	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	17381	64	except	except	IN
18637	17381	65	upon	upon	IN
18637	17381	66	some	some	DT
18637	17381	67	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	17381	68	differentiation	differentiation	NN
18637	17381	69	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	17381	70	related	relate	VBN
18637	17381	71	to	to	IN
18637	17381	72	the	the	DT
18637	17381	73	object	object	NN
18637	17381	74	of	of	IN
18637	17381	75	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	17381	76	.	.	.
18637	17381	77	"	"	''
18637	17382	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17382	2	156	156	CD
18637	17382	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17382	4	208	208	CD
18637	17382	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17382	6	161	161	CD
18637	17382	7	,	,	,
18637	17382	8	174	174	CD
18637	17382	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17382	10	1908	1908	CD
18637	17382	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17382	12	.	.	.
18637	17383	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17383	2	157	157	CD
18637	17383	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17383	4	313	313	CD
18637	17383	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17383	6	177	177	CD
18637	17383	7	,	,	,
18637	17383	8	187	187	CD
18637	17383	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17383	10	1941	1941	CD
18637	17383	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17383	12	.	.	.
18637	17384	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17384	2	158	158	CD
18637	17384	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17384	4	261	261	CD
18637	17384	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17384	6	525	525	CD
18637	17384	7	,	,	,
18637	17384	8	546	546	CD
18637	17384	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17384	10	1923	1923	CD
18637	17384	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17384	12	.	.	.
18637	17385	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17385	2	159	159	CD
18637	17385	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17385	4	300	300	CD
18637	17385	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17385	6	379	379	CD
18637	17385	7	,	,	,
18637	17385	8	400	400	CD
18637	17385	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17385	10	1937	1937	CD
18637	17385	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17385	12	.	.	.
18637	17386	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17386	2	160	160	CD
18637	17386	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17386	4	Addyston	Addyston	NNP
18637	17386	5	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	17386	6	and	and	CC
18637	17386	7	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	17386	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17386	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17386	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17386	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17386	12	United	United	NNP
18637	17386	13	States	States	NNP
18637	17386	14	,	,	,
18637	17386	15	175	175	CD
18637	17386	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17386	17	211	211	CD
18637	17386	18	,	,	,
18637	17386	19	229	229	CD
18637	17386	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17386	21	1899	1899	CD
18637	17386	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17386	23	.	.	.
18637	17387	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17387	2	161	161	CD
18637	17387	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17387	4	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	17387	5	&	&	CC
18637	17387	6	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	17388	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17388	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17388	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17388	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17388	5	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	17388	6	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	17388	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	17388	8	,	,	,
18637	17388	9	221	221	CD
18637	17388	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17388	11	612	612	CD
18637	17388	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17388	13	1911	1911	CD
18637	17388	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17388	15	;	;	:
18637	17388	16	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	17388	17	_	_	NNP
18637	17388	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	17388	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17388	20	New	New	NNP
18637	17388	21	,	,	,
18637	17388	22	243	243	CD
18637	17388	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17388	24	322	322	CD
18637	17388	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17388	26	1917	1917	CD
18637	17388	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17388	28	;	;	:
18637	17388	29	Ellis	Ellis	NNP
18637	17388	30	_	_	NNP
18637	17388	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	17388	32	_	_	NNP
18637	17388	33	United	United	NNP
18637	17388	34	States	States	NNP
18637	17388	35	,	,	,
18637	17388	36	206	206	CD
18637	17388	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17388	38	246	246	CD
18637	17388	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17388	40	1907	1907	CD
18637	17388	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17388	42	.	.	.
18637	17389	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17389	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17389	3	also	also	RB
18637	17389	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17389	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17389	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17389	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17389	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17389	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17389	10	Garbish	Garbish	NNP
18637	17389	11	,	,	,
18637	17389	12	222	222	CD
18637	17389	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17389	14	257	257	CD
18637	17389	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17389	16	1911	1911	CD
18637	17389	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17389	18	.	.	.
18637	17390	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17390	2	162	162	CD
18637	17390	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17390	4	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	17390	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17390	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17390	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17390	8	The	the	DT
18637	17390	9	"	"	``
18637	17390	10	Eudora	Eudora	NNP
18637	17390	11	,	,	,
18637	17390	12	"	"	''
18637	17390	13	190	190	CD
18637	17390	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17390	15	169	169	CD
18637	17390	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17390	17	1903	1903	CD
18637	17390	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17390	19	.	.	.
18637	17391	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17391	2	163	163	CD
18637	17391	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17391	4	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	17391	5	,	,	,
18637	17391	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	17392	1	&	&	CC
18637	17392	2	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	17392	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17392	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17392	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	17392	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17392	7	Schubert	Schubert	NNP
18637	17392	8	,	,	,
18637	17392	9	224	224	CD
18637	17392	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17392	11	603	603	CD
18637	17392	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17392	13	1912	1912	CD
18637	17392	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17392	15	.	.	.
18637	17393	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17393	2	164	164	NNP
18637	17393	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17393	4	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	17393	5	&	&	CC
18637	17393	6	N.O.R.	N.O.R.	NNP
18637	17394	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17394	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17394	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17394	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17394	5	Brotherhood	Brotherhood	NNP
18637	17394	6	of	of	IN
18637	17394	7	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	17394	8	&	&	CC
18637	17394	9	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	17394	10	Clerks	Clerks	NNP
18637	17394	11	,	,	,
18637	17394	12	281	281	CD
18637	17394	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17394	14	548	548	CD
18637	17394	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17394	16	1930	1930	CD
18637	17394	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17394	18	;	;	:
18637	17394	19	Virginian	Virginian	NNP
18637	17394	20	R.	R.	NNP
18637	17394	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17394	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17394	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	17394	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17394	25	System	System	NNP
18637	17394	26	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	17394	27	,	,	,
18637	17394	28	300	300	CD
18637	17394	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17394	30	515	515	CD
18637	17394	31	,	,	,
18637	17394	32	559	559	CD
18637	17394	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17394	34	1937	1937	CD
18637	17394	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17394	36	;	;	:
18637	17394	37	National	National	NNP
18637	17394	38	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	17394	39	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	17394	40	Board	Board	NNP
18637	17394	41	_	_	NNP
18637	17394	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	17394	43	_	_	NNP
18637	17394	44	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	17394	45	&	&	CC
18637	17394	46	Laughlin	Laughlin	NNP
18637	17394	47	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	17394	48	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	17394	49	,	,	,
18637	17394	50	301	301	CD
18637	17394	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17394	52	1	1	CD
18637	17394	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17394	54	1937	1937	CD
18637	17394	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17394	56	.	.	.
18637	17395	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17395	2	165	165	CD
18637	17395	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17395	4	Highland	Highland	NNP
18637	17395	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17395	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17395	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17395	8	Russell	Russell	NNP
18637	17395	9	Car	Car	NNP
18637	17395	10	&	&	CC
18637	17395	11	Snow	Snow	NNP
18637	17395	12	Plow	Plow	NNP
18637	17395	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17395	14	,	,	,
18637	17395	15	279	279	CD
18637	17395	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17395	17	253	253	CD
18637	17395	18	,	,	,
18637	17395	19	261	261	CD
18637	17395	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17395	21	1929	1929	CD
18637	17395	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17395	23	;	;	:
18637	17395	24	United	United	NNP
18637	17395	25	States	States	NNP
18637	17395	26	_	_	NNP
18637	17395	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	17395	28	_	_	NNP
18637	17395	29	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	17395	30	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	17395	31	Co	Co	NNP
18637	17395	32	-	-	NN
18637	17395	33	operative	operative	NNP
18637	17395	34	,	,	,
18637	17395	35	307	307	CD
18637	17395	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17395	37	533	533	CD
18637	17395	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17395	39	1939	1939	CD
18637	17395	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17395	41	;	;	:
18637	17395	42	Sunshine	Sunshine	NNP
18637	17395	43	Anthracite	Anthracite	NNP
18637	17395	44	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	17395	45	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17395	46	_	_	NNP
18637	17395	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	17395	48	_	_	NNP
18637	17395	49	Adkins	Adkins	NNP
18637	17395	50	,	,	,
18637	17395	51	310	310	CD
18637	17395	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17395	53	381	381	CD
18637	17395	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17395	55	1940	1940	CD
18637	17395	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17395	57	;	;	:
18637	17395	58	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	17395	59	_	_	NNP
18637	17395	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	17395	61	_	_	NNP
18637	17395	62	Willingham	Willingham	NNP
18637	17395	63	,	,	,
18637	17395	64	321	321	CD
18637	17395	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17395	66	503	503	CD
18637	17395	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17395	68	1944	1944	CD
18637	17395	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17395	70	.	.	.
18637	17396	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17396	2	166	166	CD
18637	17396	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17396	4	Farrington	Farrington	NNP
18637	17396	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17396	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17396	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17396	8	Tokushige	Tokushige	NNP
18637	17396	9	,	,	,
18637	17396	10	273	273	CD
18637	17396	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17396	12	284	284	CD
18637	17396	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17396	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	17396	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17396	16	.	.	.
18637	17397	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17397	2	167	167	CD
18637	17397	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17397	4	Yu	Yu	NNP
18637	17397	5	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	17397	6	Eng	Eng	NNP
18637	17397	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17397	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17397	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17397	10	Trinidad	Trinidad	NNP
18637	17397	11	,	,	,
18637	17397	12	271	271	CD
18637	17397	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17397	14	500	500	CD
18637	17397	15	,	,	,
18637	17397	16	525	525	CD
18637	17397	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17397	18	1926	1926	CD
18637	17397	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17397	20	.	.	.
18637	17398	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17398	2	168	168	CD
18637	17398	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17398	4	Fleming	Fleming	NNP
18637	17398	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17398	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17398	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17398	8	Rhodes	Rhodes	NNP
18637	17398	9	,	,	,
18637	17398	10	331	331	CD
18637	17398	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17398	12	100	100	CD
18637	17398	13	,	,	,
18637	17398	14	107	107	CD
18637	17398	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17398	16	1947	1947	CD
18637	17398	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17398	18	.	.	.
18637	17399	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17399	2	169	169	CD
18637	17399	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17399	4	Woods	Woods	NNP
18637	17399	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17399	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17399	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17399	8	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	17399	9	,	,	,
18637	17399	10	333	333	CD
18637	17399	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17399	12	472	472	CD
18637	17399	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17399	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	17399	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17399	16	.	.	.
18637	17400	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17400	2	170	170	CD
18637	17400	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17400	4	332	332	CD
18637	17400	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17400	6	194	194	CD
18637	17400	7	,	,	,
18637	17400	8	203	203	CD
18637	17400	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17400	10	1947	1947	CD
18637	17400	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17400	12	.	.	.
18637	17401	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17401	2	171	171	CD
18637	17401	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17401	4	Knox	Knox	NNP
18637	17401	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17401	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17401	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17401	8	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	17401	9	,	,	,
18637	17401	10	12	12	CD
18637	17401	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17401	12	.	.	.
18637	17402	1	457	457	CD
18637	17402	2	,	,	,
18637	17402	3	551	551	CD
18637	17402	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17402	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	17402	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17402	7	.	.	.
18637	17403	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17403	2	172	172	CD
18637	17403	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17403	4	Norman	Norman	NNP
18637	17403	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17403	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17403	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17403	8	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	17403	9	&	&	CC
18637	17403	10	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	17404	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17404	2	,	,	,
18637	17404	3	294	294	CD
18637	17404	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17404	5	240	240	CD
18637	17404	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17404	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	17404	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17404	9	.	.	.
18637	17405	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17405	2	173	173	CD
18637	17405	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17405	4	44	44	CD
18637	17405	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	17405	6	.	.	.
18637	17406	1	1424	1424	CD
18637	17406	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17406	3	1927	1927	CD
18637	17406	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17406	5	,	,	,
18637	17406	6	33	33	CD
18637	17406	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
18637	17407	1	901	901	CD
18637	17407	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17407	3	et	et	NNP
18637	17407	4	seq	seq	NN
18637	17407	5	.	.	.
18637	17407	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17407	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17407	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	17407	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17407	10	.	.	.
18637	17408	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17408	2	174	174	CD
18637	17408	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17408	4	Paramino	Paramino	NNP
18637	17408	5	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	17408	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17408	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17408	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17408	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17408	10	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	17408	11	,	,	,
18637	17408	12	309	309	CD
18637	17408	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17408	14	370	370	CD
18637	17408	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17408	16	1940	1940	CD
18637	17408	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17408	18	.	.	.
18637	17409	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17409	2	175	175	CD
18637	17409	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17409	4	Mulford	Mulford	NNP
18637	17409	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17409	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17409	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17409	8	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	17409	9	,	,	,
18637	17409	10	307	307	CD
18637	17409	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17409	12	38	38	CD
18637	17409	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17409	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	17409	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17409	16	.	.	.
18637	17410	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17410	2	176	176	CD
18637	17410	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17410	4	McFaddin	McFaddin	NNP
18637	17410	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17410	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17410	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17410	8	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	17410	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	17410	10	Snider	Snider	NNP
18637	17410	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	17410	12	Buel	Buel	NNP
18637	17410	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17410	14	,	,	,
18637	17410	15	185	185	CD
18637	17410	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17410	17	505	505	CD
18637	17410	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17410	19	1902	1902	CD
18637	17410	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17410	21	.	.	.
18637	17411	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17411	2	177	177	CD
18637	17411	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17411	4	Montoya	Montoya	NNP
18637	17411	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17411	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17411	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17411	8	Gonzales	Gonzales	NNP
18637	17411	9	,	,	,
18637	17411	10	232	232	CD
18637	17411	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17411	12	375	375	CD
18637	17411	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17411	14	1914	1914	CD
18637	17411	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17411	16	.	.	.
18637	17412	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17412	2	178	178	CD
18637	17412	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17412	4	Ochoa	Ochoa	NNP
18637	17412	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17412	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17412	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17412	8	Hernandez	Hernandez	NNP
18637	17412	9	y	y	NNP
18637	17412	10	Morales	Morales	NNP
18637	17412	11	,	,	,
18637	17412	12	230	230	CD
18637	17412	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17412	14	139	139	CD
18637	17412	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17412	16	1913	1913	CD
18637	17412	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17412	18	.	.	.
18637	17413	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17413	2	179	179	CD
18637	17413	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17413	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17413	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17413	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17413	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	17413	8	.	.	.
18637	17414	1	Burnett	Burnett	NNP
18637	17414	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17414	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17414	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17414	5	Teller	Teller	NNP
18637	17414	6	,	,	,
18637	17414	7	107	107	CD
18637	17414	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17414	9	64	64	CD
18637	17414	10	,	,	,
18637	17414	11	68	68	CD
18637	17414	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17414	13	1883	1883	CD
18637	17414	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17414	15	.	.	.
18637	17415	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17415	2	180	180	CD
18637	17415	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17415	4	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	17415	5	&	&	CC
18637	17415	6	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	17416	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17416	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17416	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17416	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17416	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17416	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17416	7	,	,	,
18637	17416	8	243	243	CD
18637	17416	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17416	10	549	549	CD
18637	17416	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17416	12	1917	1917	CD
18637	17416	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17416	14	.	.	.
18637	17417	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17417	2	181	181	CD
18637	17417	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17417	4	Capital	Capital	NNP
18637	17417	5	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	17417	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17417	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17417	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17417	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17417	10	Calhoun	Calhoun	NNP
18637	17417	11	,	,	,
18637	17417	12	250	250	CD
18637	17417	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17417	14	208	208	CD
18637	17417	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17417	16	1919	1919	CD
18637	17417	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17417	18	.	.	.
18637	17418	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17418	2	182	182	CD
18637	17418	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17418	4	Frisbie	Frisbie	NNP
18637	17418	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17418	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17418	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17418	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17418	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17418	10	,	,	,
18637	17418	11	157	157	CD
18637	17418	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17418	13	160	160	CD
18637	17418	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17418	15	1895	1895	CD
18637	17418	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17418	17	;	;	:
18637	17418	18	_	_	NNP
18637	17418	19	see	see	VB
18637	17418	20	also	also	RB
18637	17418	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17418	22	Margolin	Margolin	NNP
18637	17418	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17418	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	17418	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17418	26	United	United	NNP
18637	17418	27	States	States	NNP
18637	17418	28	,	,	,
18637	17418	29	269	269	CD
18637	17418	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17418	31	93	93	CD
18637	17418	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17418	33	1925	1925	CD
18637	17418	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17418	35	;	;	:
18637	17418	36	Hines	Hines	NNP
18637	17418	37	_	_	NNP
18637	17418	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	17418	39	_	_	NNP
18637	17418	40	Lowrey	Lowrey	NNP
18637	17418	41	,	,	,
18637	17418	42	305	305	CD
18637	17418	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17418	44	85	85	CD
18637	17418	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17418	46	1938	1938	CD
18637	17418	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17418	48	.	.	.
18637	17419	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17419	2	183	183	CD
18637	17419	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17419	4	Wickard	Wickard	NNP
18637	17419	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17419	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17419	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17419	8	Filburn	Filburn	NNP
18637	17419	9	,	,	,
18637	17419	10	317	317	CD
18637	17419	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17419	12	111	111	CD
18637	17419	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17419	14	1942	1942	CD
18637	17419	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17419	16	.	.	.
18637	17420	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17420	2	184	184	CD
18637	17420	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17420	4	Noble	Noble	NNP
18637	17420	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17420	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17420	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17420	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	17420	9	River	River	NNP
18637	17420	10	Logging	Logging	NNP
18637	17420	11	R.	R.	NNP
18637	17420	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17420	13	,	,	,
18637	17420	14	147	147	CD
18637	17420	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17420	16	165	165	CD
18637	17420	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17420	18	1893	1893	CD
18637	17420	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17420	20	.	.	.
18637	17421	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17421	2	185	185	CD
18637	17421	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17421	4	Danzer	Danzer	NNP
18637	17421	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17421	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17421	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17421	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17421	9	Gulf	Gulf	NNP
18637	17421	10	&	&	CC
18637	17421	11	S.I.R.	S.I.R.	NNP
18637	17422	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17422	2	,	,	,
18637	17422	3	268	268	CD
18637	17422	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17422	5	633	633	CD
18637	17422	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17422	7	1925	1925	CD
18637	17422	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17422	9	.	.	.
18637	17423	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17423	2	186	186	CD
18637	17423	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17423	4	Lynch	Lynch	NNP
18637	17423	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17423	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17423	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17423	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17423	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17423	10	,	,	,
18637	17423	11	292	292	CD
18637	17423	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17423	13	571	571	CD
18637	17423	14	,	,	,
18637	17423	15	579	579	CD
18637	17423	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17423	17	1934	1934	CD
18637	17423	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17423	19	.	.	.
18637	17424	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17424	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17424	3	also	also	RB
18637	17424	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17424	5	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	17424	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17424	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17424	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17424	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17424	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17424	11	,	,	,
18637	17424	12	294	294	CD
18637	17424	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17424	14	330	330	CD
18637	17424	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17424	16	1935	1935	CD
18637	17424	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17424	18	.	.	.
18637	17425	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17425	2	187	187	CD
18637	17425	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17425	4	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	17425	5	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	17425	6	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	17425	7	Land	Land	NNP
18637	17425	8	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	17425	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17425	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17425	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17425	12	Radford	Radford	NNP
18637	17425	13	,	,	,
18637	17425	14	295	295	CD
18637	17425	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17425	16	555	555	CD
18637	17425	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17425	18	1935	1935	CD
18637	17425	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17425	20	.	.	.
18637	17426	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17426	2	188	188	CD
18637	17426	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17426	4	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	17426	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17426	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17426	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17426	8	Mountain	Mountain	NNP
18637	17426	9	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	17426	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17426	11	,	,	,
18637	17426	12	300	300	CD
18637	17426	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17426	14	440	440	CD
18637	17426	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17426	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	17426	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17426	18	.	.	.
18637	17427	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17427	2	189	189	CD
18637	17427	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17427	4	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	17427	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	17427	6	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	17427	7	.	.	.
18637	17428	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	17428	2	&	&	CC
18637	17428	3	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	17428	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17428	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17428	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17428	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17428	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	17428	9	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	17428	10	&	&	CC
18637	17428	11	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	17429	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17429	2	,	,	,
18637	17429	3	294	294	CD
18637	17429	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17429	5	648	648	CD
18637	17429	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17429	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	17429	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17429	9	.	.	.
18637	17430	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17430	2	190	190	CD
18637	17430	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17430	4	Kuehner	Kuehner	NNP
18637	17430	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17430	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17430	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17430	8	Irving	Irving	NNP
18637	17430	9	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	17430	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17430	11	,	,	,
18637	17430	12	299	299	CD
18637	17430	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17430	14	445	445	CD
18637	17430	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17430	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	17430	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17430	18	.	.	.
18637	17431	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17431	2	191	191	CD
18637	17431	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17431	4	Re	Re	NNP
18637	17431	5	620	620	CD
18637	17431	6	Church	Church	NNP
18637	17431	7	Street	Street	NNP
18637	17431	8	Bldg	Bldg	NNP
18637	17431	9	.	.	.
18637	17432	1	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	17432	2	,	,	,
18637	17432	3	299	299	CD
18637	17432	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17432	5	24	24	CD
18637	17432	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17432	7	1936	1936	CD
18637	17432	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17432	9	.	.	.
18637	17433	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17433	2	192	192	CD
18637	17433	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17433	4	Lynch	Lynch	NNP
18637	17433	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17433	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17433	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17433	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17433	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17433	10	,	,	,
18637	17433	11	292	292	CD
18637	17433	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17433	13	571	571	CD
18637	17433	14	,	,	,
18637	17433	15	581	581	CD
18637	17433	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17433	17	1934	1934	CD
18637	17433	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17433	19	.	.	.
18637	17434	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17434	2	193	193	CD
18637	17434	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17434	4	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	17434	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17434	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17434	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17434	8	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	17434	9	,	,	,
18637	17434	10	240	240	CD
18637	17434	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17434	12	118	118	CD
18637	17434	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17434	14	1916	1916	CD
18637	17434	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17434	16	.	.	.
18637	17435	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17435	2	194	194	CD
18637	17435	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17435	4	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	17435	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17435	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17435	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17435	8	Goodcell	Goodcell	NNP
18637	17435	9	,	,	,
18637	17435	10	228	228	CD
18637	17435	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17435	12	409	409	CD
18637	17435	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17435	14	1931	1931	CD
18637	17435	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17435	16	.	.	.
18637	17436	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17436	2	195	195	CD
18637	17436	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17436	4	Anniston	Anniston	NNP
18637	17436	5	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	17436	6	.	.	.
18637	17437	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17437	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17437	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17437	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17437	5	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	17437	6	,	,	,
18637	17437	7	301	301	CD
18637	17437	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17437	9	337	337	CD
18637	17437	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17437	11	1937	1937	CD
18637	17437	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17437	13	.	.	.
18637	17438	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17438	2	196	196	CD
18637	17438	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17438	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17438	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17438	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17438	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17438	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17438	9	Heinszen	Heinszen	NNP
18637	17438	10	&	&	CC
18637	17438	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17438	12	,	,	,
18637	17438	13	206	206	CD
18637	17438	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17438	15	370	370	CD
18637	17438	16	,	,	,
18637	17438	17	386	386	CD
18637	17438	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17438	19	1907	1907	CD
18637	17438	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17438	21	.	.	.
18637	17439	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17439	2	197	197	CD
18637	17439	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17439	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17439	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17439	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17439	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17439	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17439	9	New	New	NNP
18637	17439	10	York	York	NNP
18637	17439	11	&	&	CC
18637	17439	12	C.	C.	NNP
18637	17439	13	Mail	Mail	NNP
18637	17439	14	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	17439	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17439	16	,	,	,
18637	17439	17	269	269	CD
18637	17439	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17439	19	304	304	CD
18637	17439	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17439	21	1925	1925	CD
18637	17439	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17439	23	.	.	.
18637	17440	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17440	2	198	198	CD
18637	17440	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17440	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17440	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17440	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17440	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17440	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17440	9	Carolene	Carolene	NNP
18637	17440	10	Products	Products	NNP
18637	17440	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17440	12	,	,	,
18637	17440	13	304	304	CD
18637	17440	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17440	15	144	144	CD
18637	17440	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17440	17	1938	1938	CD
18637	17440	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17440	19	;	;	:
18637	17440	20	Carolene	Carolene	NNP
18637	17440	21	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	17440	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17440	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17440	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	17440	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17440	26	United	United	NNP
18637	17440	27	States	States	NNP
18637	17440	28	,	,	,
18637	17440	29	323	323	CD
18637	17440	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17440	31	18	18	CD
18637	17440	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17440	33	1944	1944	CD
18637	17440	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17440	35	.	.	.
18637	17441	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17441	2	199	199	CD
18637	17441	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17441	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	17441	5	Whip	Whip	NNP
18637	17441	6	Collar	Collar	NNP
18637	17441	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17441	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17441	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17441	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17441	11	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	17441	12	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	17442	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17442	2	,	,	,
18637	17442	3	299	299	CD
18637	17442	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17442	5	334	334	CD
18637	17442	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17442	7	1937	1937	CD
18637	17442	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17442	9	.	.	.
18637	17443	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17443	2	200	200	CD
18637	17443	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17443	4	Virginian	Virginian	NNP
18637	17443	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	17443	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17443	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17443	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17443	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17443	10	System	System	NNP
18637	17443	11	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	17443	12	,	,	,
18637	17443	13	300	300	CD
18637	17443	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17443	15	515	515	CD
18637	17443	16	,	,	,
18637	17443	17	559	559	CD
18637	17443	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17443	19	1937	1937	CD
18637	17443	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17443	21	;	;	:
18637	17443	22	National	National	NNP
18637	17443	23	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	17443	24	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	17443	25	Board	Board	NNP
18637	17443	26	_	_	NNP
18637	17443	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	17443	28	_	_	NNP
18637	17443	29	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	17443	30	&	&	CC
18637	17443	31	Laughlin	Laughlin	NNP
18637	17443	32	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	17443	33	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	17443	34	,	,	,
18637	17443	35	301	301	CD
18637	17443	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17443	37	1	1	CD
18637	17443	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17443	39	1937	1937	CD
18637	17443	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17443	41	.	.	.
18637	17444	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17444	2	201	201	CD
18637	17444	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17444	4	National	National	NNP
18637	17444	5	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	17444	6	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	17444	7	Board	Board	NNP
18637	17444	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17444	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17444	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17444	11	Stowe	Stowe	NNP
18637	17444	12	Spinning	Spinning	NNP
18637	17444	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17444	14	,	,	,
18637	17444	15	336	336	CD
18637	17444	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17444	17	226	226	CD
18637	17444	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17444	19	1949	1949	CD
18637	17444	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17444	21	.	.	.
18637	17445	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17445	2	202	202	CD
18637	17445	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17445	4	National	National	NNP
18637	17445	5	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	17445	6	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	17445	7	Board	Board	NNP
18637	17445	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17445	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17445	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17445	11	Mackay	Mackay	NNP
18637	17445	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17445	13	,	,	,
18637	17445	14	304	304	CD
18637	17445	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17445	16	333	333	CD
18637	17445	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17445	18	1938	1938	CD
18637	17445	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17445	20	.	.	.
18637	17446	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17446	2	203	203	CD
18637	17446	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17446	4	Woods	Woods	NNP
18637	17446	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17446	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17446	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17446	8	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	17446	9	,	,	,
18637	17446	10	333	333	CD
18637	17446	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17446	12	138	138	CD
18637	17446	13	,	,	,
18637	17446	14	146	146	CD
18637	17446	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17446	16	1948	1948	CD
18637	17446	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17446	18	.	.	.
18637	17447	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17447	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17447	3	also	also	RB
18637	17447	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17447	5	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	17447	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17447	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17447	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17447	9	Willingham	Willingham	NNP
18637	17447	10	,	,	,
18637	17447	11	321	321	CD
18637	17447	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17447	13	503	503	CD
18637	17447	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17447	15	1944	1944	CD
18637	17447	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17447	17	.	.	.
18637	17448	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17448	2	204	204	CD
18637	17448	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17448	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17448	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	17448	6	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	17448	7	,	,	,
18637	17448	8	96	96	CD
18637	17448	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17448	10	727	727	CD
18637	17448	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17448	12	1878	1878	CD
18637	17448	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17448	14	.	.	.
18637	17449	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17449	2	205	205	CD
18637	17449	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17449	4	Public	Public	NNP
18637	17449	5	Clearing	Clearing	NNP
18637	17449	6	House	House	NNP
18637	17449	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17449	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17449	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17449	10	Coyne	Coyne	NNP
18637	17449	11	,	,	,
18637	17449	12	194	194	CD
18637	17449	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17449	14	497	497	CD
18637	17449	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17449	16	1904	1904	CD
18637	17449	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17449	18	;	;	,
18637	17449	19	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	17449	20	in	in	IN
18637	17449	21	Donaldson	Donaldson	NNP
18637	17449	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17449	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	17449	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17449	25	Read	Read	NNP
18637	17449	26	Magazine	Magazine	NNP
18637	17449	27	,	,	,
18637	17449	28	333	333	CD
18637	17449	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17449	30	178	178	CD
18637	17449	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17449	32	1948	1948	CD
18637	17449	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17449	34	.	.	.
18637	17450	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17450	2	206	206	CD
18637	17450	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17450	4	194	194	CD
18637	17450	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17450	6	497	497	CD
18637	17450	7	,	,	,
18637	17450	8	505	505	CD
18637	17450	9	-	-	SYM
18637	17450	10	506	506	CD
18637	17450	11	.	.	.
18637	17451	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17451	2	207	207	CD
18637	17451	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17451	4	American	American	NNP
18637	17451	5	School	School	NNP
18637	17451	6	of	of	IN
18637	17451	7	Magnetic	Magnetic	NNP
18637	17451	8	Healing	Healing	NNP
18637	17451	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17451	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17451	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17451	12	McAnnulty	McAnnulty	NNP
18637	17451	13	,	,	,
18637	17451	14	187	187	CD
18637	17451	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17451	16	94	94	CD
18637	17451	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17451	18	1902	1902	CD
18637	17451	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17451	20	.	.	.
18637	17452	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17452	2	208	208	CD
18637	17452	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17452	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17452	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17452	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17452	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	17452	8	.	.	.
18637	17453	1	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	17453	2	Social	Social	NNP
18637	17453	3	Democratic	Democratic	NNP
18637	17453	4	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	17453	5	.	.	.
18637	17454	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17454	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17454	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17454	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17454	5	Burleson	Burleson	NNP
18637	17454	6	,	,	,
18637	17454	7	255	255	CD
18637	17454	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17454	9	407	407	CD
18637	17454	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17454	11	1921	1921	CD
18637	17454	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17454	13	.	.	.
18637	17455	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17455	2	209	209	CD
18637	17455	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17455	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	17455	5	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
18637	17455	6	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	17455	7	Yards	Yards	NNP
18637	17455	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17455	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17455	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17455	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17455	12	United	United	NNP
18637	17455	13	States	States	NNP
18637	17455	14	,	,	,
18637	17455	15	298	298	CD
18637	17455	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17455	17	38	38	CD
18637	17455	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17455	19	1936	1936	CD
18637	17455	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17455	21	;	;	:
18637	17455	22	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	17455	23	Union	Union	NNP
18637	17455	24	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	17455	25	Yards	Yards	NNP
18637	17455	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17455	27	_	_	NNP
18637	17455	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	17455	29	_	_	NNP
18637	17455	30	United	United	NNP
18637	17455	31	States	States	NNP
18637	17455	32	,	,	,
18637	17455	33	304	304	CD
18637	17455	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17455	35	470	470	CD
18637	17455	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17455	37	1938	1938	CD
18637	17455	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17455	39	.	.	.
18637	17456	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17456	2	210	210	CD
18637	17456	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17456	4	320	320	CD
18637	17456	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17456	6	591	591	CD
18637	17456	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17456	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	17456	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17456	10	.	.	.
18637	17457	1	The	the	DT
18637	17457	2	result	result	NN
18637	17457	3	of	of	IN
18637	17457	4	this	this	DT
18637	17457	5	case	case	NN
18637	17457	6	had	have	VBD
18637	17457	7	been	be	VBN
18637	17457	8	foreshadowed	foreshadow	VBN
18637	17457	9	by	by	IN
18637	17457	10	the	the	DT
18637	17457	11	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17457	12	of	of	IN
18637	17457	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	17457	14	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	17457	15	in	in	IN
18637	17457	16	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	17457	17	Power	Power	NNP
18637	17457	18	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	17457	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17457	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	17457	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17457	22	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	17457	23	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	17457	24	Pipeline	Pipeline	NNP
18637	17457	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17457	26	,	,	,
18637	17457	27	315	315	CD
18637	17457	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17457	29	575	575	CD
18637	17457	30	,	,	,
18637	17457	31	586	586	CD
18637	17457	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17457	33	1942	1942	CD
18637	17457	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17457	35	to	to	IN
18637	17457	36	the	the	DT
18637	17457	37	effect	effect	NN
18637	17457	38	that	that	WDT
18637	17457	39	the	the	DT
18637	17457	40	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	17457	41	was	be	VBD
18637	17457	42	not	not	RB
18637	17457	43	bound	bind	VBN
18637	17457	44	to	to	IN
18637	17457	45	the	the	DT
18637	17457	46	use	use	NN
18637	17457	47	of	of	IN
18637	17457	48	any	any	DT
18637	17457	49	single	single	JJ
18637	17457	50	formula	formula	NN
18637	17457	51	or	or	CC
18637	17457	52	combination	combination	NN
18637	17457	53	of	of	IN
18637	17457	54	formulas	formula	NNS
18637	17457	55	in	in	IN
18637	17457	56	determining	determine	VBG
18637	17457	57	rates	rate	NNS
18637	17457	58	.	.	.
18637	17458	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17458	2	211	211	CD
18637	17458	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17458	4	320	320	CD
18637	17458	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17458	6	591	591	CD
18637	17458	7	,	,	,
18637	17458	8	602	602	CD
18637	17458	9	,	,	,
18637	17458	10	605	605	CD
18637	17458	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17458	12	1944	1944	CD
18637	17458	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17458	14	.	.	.
18637	17459	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17459	2	212	212	CD
18637	17459	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17459	4	American	American	NNP
18637	17459	5	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	17459	6	&	&	CC
18637	17459	7	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	17459	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17459	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17459	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17459	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17459	12	United	United	NNP
18637	17459	13	States	States	NNP
18637	17459	14	,	,	,
18637	17459	15	299	299	CD
18637	17459	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17459	17	232	232	CD
18637	17459	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17459	19	1936	1936	CD
18637	17459	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17459	21	;	;	:
18637	17459	22	United	United	NNP
18637	17459	23	States	States	NNP
18637	17459	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17459	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	17459	26	_	_	NNP
18637	17459	27	New	New	NNP
18637	17459	28	York	York	NNP
18637	17459	29	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	17459	30	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17459	31	,	,	,
18637	17459	32	326	326	CD
18637	17459	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17459	34	638	638	CD
18637	17459	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17459	36	1946	1946	CD
18637	17459	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17459	38	;	;	:
18637	17459	39	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	17459	40	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	17459	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17459	42	_	_	NNP
18637	17459	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	17459	44	_	_	NNP
18637	17459	45	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	17459	46	Power	Power	NNP
18637	17459	47	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	17459	48	,	,	,
18637	17459	49	321	321	CD
18637	17459	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17459	51	119	119	CD
18637	17459	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17459	53	1944	1944	CD
18637	17459	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17459	55	.	.	.
18637	17460	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17460	2	213	213	CD
18637	17460	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17460	4	Valvoline	Valvoline	NNP
18637	17460	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	17460	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17460	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17460	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17460	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17460	10	United	United	NNP
18637	17460	11	States	States	NNP
18637	17460	12	,	,	,
18637	17460	13	308	308	CD
18637	17460	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17460	15	141	141	CD
18637	17460	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17460	17	1939	1939	CD
18637	17460	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17460	19	;	;	:
18637	17460	20	Champlin	Champlin	NNP
18637	17460	21	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	17460	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17460	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17460	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	17460	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17460	26	United	United	NNP
18637	17460	27	States	States	NNP
18637	17460	28	,	,	,
18637	17460	29	329	329	CD
18637	17460	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17460	31	29	29	CD
18637	17460	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17460	33	1946	1946	CD
18637	17460	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17460	35	.	.	.
18637	17461	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17461	2	214	214	CD
18637	17461	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17461	4	Isbrandtsen	Isbrandtsen	NNP
18637	17461	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	17461	6	Moller	Moller	NNP
18637	17461	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17461	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17461	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17461	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17461	11	United	United	NNP
18637	17461	12	States	States	NNP
18637	17461	13	,	,	,
18637	17461	14	300	300	CD
18637	17461	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17461	16	139	139	CD
18637	17461	17	,	,	,
18637	17461	18	146	146	CD
18637	17461	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17461	20	1937	1937	CD
18637	17461	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17461	22	.	.	.
18637	17462	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17462	2	215	215	CD
18637	17462	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17462	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	17462	5	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	17462	6	S.W.	S.W.	NNP
18637	17463	1	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	17463	2	.	.	.
18637	17464	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17464	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17464	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17464	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17464	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17464	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17464	7	,	,	,
18637	17464	8	245	245	CD
18637	17464	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17464	10	136	136	CD
18637	17464	11	,	,	,
18637	17464	12	143	143	CD
18637	17464	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17464	14	1917	1917	CD
18637	17464	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17464	16	.	.	.
18637	17465	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17465	2	216	216	CD
18637	17465	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17465	4	Akron	Akron	NNP
18637	17465	5	C.	C.	NNP
18637	17465	6	&	&	CC
18637	17465	7	Y.R.	Y.R.	NNP
18637	17466	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17466	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17466	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17466	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17466	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17466	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17466	7	,	,	,
18637	17466	8	261	261	CD
18637	17466	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17466	10	184	184	CD
18637	17466	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17466	12	1923	1923	CD
18637	17466	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17466	14	.	.	.
18637	17467	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17467	2	217	217	CD
18637	17467	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17467	4	Dayton	Dayton	NNP
18637	17467	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	17467	6	Goose	Goose	NNP
18637	17467	7	Creek	Creek	NNP
18637	17467	8	R.	R.	NNP
18637	17467	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17467	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17467	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	17467	12	_	_	NNP
18637	17467	13	United	United	NNP
18637	17467	14	States	States	NNP
18637	17467	15	,	,	,
18637	17467	16	263	263	CD
18637	17467	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17467	18	456	456	CD
18637	17467	19	,	,	,
18637	17467	20	481	481	CD
18637	17467	21	,	,	,
18637	17467	22	483	483	CD
18637	17467	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17467	24	1924	1924	CD
18637	17467	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17467	26	.	.	.
18637	17468	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17468	2	218	218	CD
18637	17468	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17468	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	17468	5	,	,	,
18637	17468	6	I.	I.	NNP
18637	17469	1	&	&	CC
18637	17469	2	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	17470	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17470	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17470	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17470	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17470	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17470	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17470	7	,	,	,
18637	17470	8	270	270	CD
18637	17470	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17470	10	287	287	CD
18637	17470	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17470	12	1926	1926	CD
18637	17470	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17470	14	.	.	.
18637	17471	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17471	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	17471	3	.	.	.
18637	17471	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17471	5	Seaboard	Seaboard	NNP
18637	17471	6	Air	Air	NNP
18637	17471	7	Line	Line	NNP
18637	17471	8	R.	R.	NNP
18637	17471	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17471	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17471	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	17471	12	_	_	NNP
18637	17471	13	United	United	NNP
18637	17471	14	States	States	NNP
18637	17471	15	,	,	,
18637	17471	16	254	254	CD
18637	17471	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17471	18	57	57	CD
18637	17471	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17471	20	1920	1920	CD
18637	17471	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17471	22	.	.	.
18637	17472	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17472	2	219	219	CD
18637	17472	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17472	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17472	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17472	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17472	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17472	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17472	9	Berwind	Berwind	NNP
18637	17472	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	17472	11	White	White	NNP
18637	17472	12	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	17472	13	Mine	Mine	NNP
18637	17472	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17472	15	,	,	,
18637	17472	16	274	274	CD
18637	17472	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17472	18	564	564	CD
18637	17472	19	,	,	,
18637	17472	20	575	575	CD
18637	17472	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17472	22	1927	1927	CD
18637	17472	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17472	24	.	.	.
18637	17473	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17473	2	220	220	CD
18637	17473	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17473	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17473	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17473	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17473	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	17473	8	.	.	.
18637	17474	1	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	17474	2	General	General	NNP
18637	17474	3	_	_	NNP
18637	17474	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	17474	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17474	6	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	17474	7	&	&	CC
18637	17474	8	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	17474	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17474	10	,	,	,
18637	17474	11	213	213	CD
18637	17474	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17474	13	366	366	CD
18637	17474	14	,	,	,
18637	17474	15	405	405	CD
18637	17474	16	,	,	,
18637	17474	17	411	411	CD
18637	17474	18	,	,	,
18637	17474	19	415	415	CD
18637	17474	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17474	21	1909	1909	CD
18637	17474	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17474	23	.	.	.
18637	17475	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17475	2	221	221	CD
18637	17475	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17475	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17475	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17475	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17475	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17475	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17475	9	Lowden	Lowden	NNP
18637	17475	10	,	,	,
18637	17475	11	308	308	CD
18637	17475	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17475	13	225	225	CD
18637	17475	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17475	15	1939	1939	CD
18637	17475	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17475	17	.	.	.
18637	17476	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17476	2	222	222	CD
18637	17476	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17476	4	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	17476	5	&	&	CC
18637	17476	6	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	17477	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17477	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17477	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17477	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17477	5	Mottley	Mottley	NNP
18637	17477	6	,	,	,
18637	17477	7	219	219	CD
18637	17477	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17477	9	467	467	CD
18637	17477	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17477	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	17477	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17477	13	.	.	.
18637	17478	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17478	2	223	223	CD
18637	17478	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17478	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	17478	5	,	,	,
18637	17478	6	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	17478	7	&	&	CC
18637	17478	8	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	17479	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17479	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17479	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17479	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17479	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17479	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17479	7	,	,	,
18637	17479	8	284	284	CD
18637	17479	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17479	10	80	80	CD
18637	17479	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17479	12	1931	1931	CD
18637	17479	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17479	14	.	.	.
18637	17480	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17480	2	224	224	CD
18637	17480	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17480	4	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	17480	5	Retirement	Retirement	NNP
18637	17480	6	Board	Board	NNP
18637	17480	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17480	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17480	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17480	10	Alton	Alton	NNP
18637	17480	11	R.	R.	NNP
18637	17480	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17480	13	,	,	,
18637	17480	14	295	295	CD
18637	17480	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17480	16	330	330	CD
18637	17480	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17480	18	1935	1935	CD
18637	17480	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17480	20	.	.	.
18637	17481	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17481	2	225	225	CD
18637	17481	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17481	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17481	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17481	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17481	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17481	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17481	9	Bennett	Bennett	NNP
18637	17481	10	,	,	,
18637	17481	11	232	232	CD
18637	17481	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17481	13	299	299	CD
18637	17481	14	,	,	,
18637	17481	15	307	307	CD
18637	17481	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17481	17	1914	1914	CD
18637	17481	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17481	19	.	.	.
18637	17482	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17482	2	226	226	CD
18637	17482	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17482	4	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	17482	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17482	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17482	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17482	8	Tait	Tait	NNP
18637	17482	9	,	,	,
18637	17482	10	265	265	CD
18637	17482	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17482	12	47	47	CD
18637	17482	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17482	14	1924	1924	CD
18637	17482	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17482	16	.	.	.
18637	17483	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17483	2	227	227	CD
18637	17483	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17483	4	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	17483	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17483	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17483	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17483	8	Lerner	Lerner	NNP
18637	17483	9	Stores	Stores	NNP
18637	17483	10	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	17483	11	,	,	,
18637	17483	12	314	314	CD
18637	17483	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17483	14	463	463	CD
18637	17483	15	,	,	,
18637	17483	16	468	468	CD
18637	17483	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17483	18	1941	1941	CD
18637	17483	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17483	20	.	.	.
18637	17484	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17484	2	228	228	CD
18637	17484	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17484	4	Brushaber	Brushaber	NNP
18637	17484	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17484	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17484	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17484	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	17484	9	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	17485	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17485	2	,	,	,
18637	17485	3	240	240	CD
18637	17485	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17485	5	1	1	CD
18637	17485	6	,	,	,
18637	17485	7	24	24	CD
18637	17485	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17485	9	1916	1916	CD
18637	17485	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17485	11	.	.	.
18637	17486	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17486	2	229	229	CD
18637	17486	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17486	4	McCray	McCray	NNP
18637	17486	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17486	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17486	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17486	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17486	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17486	10	,	,	,
18637	17486	11	195	195	CD
18637	17486	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17486	13	27	27	CD
18637	17486	14	,	,	,
18637	17486	15	61	61	CD
18637	17486	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17486	17	1904	1904	CD
18637	17486	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17486	19	.	.	.
18637	17487	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17487	2	230	230	CD
18637	17487	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17487	4	Treat	Treat	NNP
18637	17487	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17487	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17487	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17487	8	White	White	NNP
18637	17487	9	,	,	,
18637	17487	10	181	181	CD
18637	17487	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17487	12	264	264	CD
18637	17487	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17487	14	1901	1901	CD
18637	17487	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17487	16	.	.	.
18637	17488	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17488	2	231	231	CD
18637	17488	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17488	4	Flint	Flint	NNP
18637	17488	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17488	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17488	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17488	8	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	17488	9	Tracy	Tracy	NNP
18637	17488	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17488	11	,	,	,
18637	17488	12	220	220	CD
18637	17488	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17488	14	107	107	CD
18637	17488	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17488	16	1911	1911	CD
18637	17488	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17488	18	.	.	.
18637	17489	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17489	2	232	232	CD
18637	17489	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17489	4	National	National	NNP
18637	17489	5	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	17489	6	&	&	CC
18637	17489	7	Type	Type	NNP
18637	17489	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17489	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17489	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17489	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17489	12	Bowers	Bowers	NNP
18637	17489	13	,	,	,
18637	17489	14	266	266	CD
18637	17489	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17489	16	373	373	CD
18637	17489	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17489	18	1924	1924	CD
18637	17489	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17489	20	.	.	.
18637	17490	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17490	2	233	233	CD
18637	17490	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17490	4	Billings	Billings	NNP
18637	17490	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17490	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17490	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17490	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17490	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17490	10	,	,	,
18637	17490	11	232	232	CD
18637	17490	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17490	13	261	261	CD
18637	17490	14	,	,	,
18637	17490	15	282	282	CD
18637	17490	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17490	17	1914	1914	CD
18637	17490	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17490	19	.	.	.
18637	17491	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17491	2	234	234	CD
18637	17491	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17491	4	Steward	Steward	NNP
18637	17491	5	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	17491	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17491	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17491	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17491	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17491	10	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	17491	11	,	,	,
18637	17491	12	301	301	CD
18637	17491	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17491	14	548	548	CD
18637	17491	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17491	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	17491	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17491	18	;	;	:
18637	17491	19	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	17491	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17491	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	17491	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17491	23	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	17491	24	,	,	,
18637	17491	25	301	301	CD
18637	17491	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17491	27	619	619	CD
18637	17491	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17491	29	1937	1937	CD
18637	17491	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17491	31	.	.	.
18637	17492	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17492	2	235	235	CD
18637	17492	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17492	4	Bromley	Bromley	NNP
18637	17492	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17492	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17492	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17492	8	McCaughn	McCaughn	NNP
18637	17492	9	,	,	,
18637	17492	10	280	280	CD
18637	17492	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17492	12	124	124	CD
18637	17492	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17492	14	1929	1929	CD
18637	17492	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17492	16	.	.	.
18637	17493	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17493	2	236	236	CD
18637	17493	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17493	4	Haavik	Haavik	NNP
18637	17493	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17493	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17493	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17493	8	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	17493	9	Packers	Packers	NNP
18637	17493	10	'	'	POS
18637	17493	11	Association	Association	NNP
18637	17493	12	,	,	,
18637	17493	13	263	263	CD
18637	17493	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17493	15	510	510	CD
18637	17493	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17493	17	1924	1924	CD
18637	17493	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17493	19	.	.	.
18637	17494	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17494	2	237	237	CD
18637	17494	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17494	4	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	17494	5	Fish	Fish	NNP
18637	17494	6	Salting	Salting	NNP
18637	17494	7	&	&	CC
18637	17494	8	By	By	NNP
18637	17494	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	17494	10	Products	Products	NNP
18637	17494	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17494	12	_	_	NNP
18637	17494	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	17494	14	_	_	NNP
18637	17494	15	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	17494	16	,	,	,
18637	17494	17	255	255	CD
18637	17494	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17494	19	44	44	CD
18637	17494	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17494	21	1921	1921	CD
18637	17494	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17494	23	.	.	.
18637	17495	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17495	2	238	238	CD
18637	17495	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17495	4	La	La	NNP
18637	17495	5	Belle	Belle	NNP
18637	17495	6	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	17495	7	Works	Works	NNP
18637	17495	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17495	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17495	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17495	11	United	United	NNP
18637	17495	12	States	States	NNP
18637	17495	13	,	,	,
18637	17495	14	256	256	CD
18637	17495	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17495	16	377	377	CD
18637	17495	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17495	18	1921	1921	CD
18637	17495	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17495	20	.	.	.
18637	17496	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17496	2	239	239	CD
18637	17496	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17496	4	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	17496	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17496	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17496	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17496	8	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	17496	9	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	17496	10	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	17496	11	,	,	,
18637	17496	12	311	311	CD
18637	17496	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17496	14	46	46	CD
18637	17496	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17496	16	1940	1940	CD
18637	17496	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17496	18	.	.	.
18637	17497	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17497	2	240	240	CD
18637	17497	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17497	4	Fernandez	Fernandez	NNP
18637	17497	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17497	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17497	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17497	8	Wiener	Wiener	NNP
18637	17497	9	,	,	,
18637	17497	10	326	326	CD
18637	17497	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17497	12	340	340	CD
18637	17497	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17497	14	1945	1945	CD
18637	17497	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17497	16	;	;	:
18637	17497	17	_	_	NNP
18637	17497	18	cf	cf	NNP
18637	17497	19	.	.	NNP
18637	17497	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17497	21	Coolidge	Coolidge	NNP
18637	17497	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17497	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	17497	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17497	25	Long	Long	NNP
18637	17497	26	,	,	,
18637	17497	27	282	282	CD
18637	17497	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17497	29	582	582	CD
18637	17497	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17497	31	1931	1931	CD
18637	17497	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17497	33	.	.	.
18637	17498	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17498	2	241	241	CD
18637	17498	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17498	4	Untermeyer	Untermeyer	NNP
18637	17498	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17498	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17498	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17498	8	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	17498	9	,	,	,
18637	17498	10	276	276	CD
18637	17498	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17498	12	440	440	CD
18637	17498	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17498	14	1928	1928	CD
18637	17498	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17498	16	.	.	.
18637	17499	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17499	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17499	3	also	also	RB
18637	17499	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17499	5	Blodgett	Blodgett	NNP
18637	17499	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17499	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17499	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17499	9	Holden	Holden	NNP
18637	17499	10	,	,	,
18637	17499	11	275	275	CD
18637	17499	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17499	13	142	142	CD
18637	17499	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17499	15	1927	1927	CD
18637	17499	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17499	17	;	;	:
18637	17499	18	Nichols	Nichols	NNP
18637	17499	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17499	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	17499	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17499	22	Coolidge	Coolidge	NNP
18637	17499	23	,	,	,
18637	17499	24	274	274	CD
18637	17499	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17499	26	531	531	CD
18637	17499	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17499	28	1927	1927	CD
18637	17499	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17499	30	.	.	.
18637	17500	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17500	2	242	242	CD
18637	17500	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17500	4	Heiner	Heiner	NNP
18637	17500	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17500	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17500	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17500	8	Donnan	Donnan	NNP
18637	17500	9	,	,	,
18637	17500	10	285	285	CD
18637	17500	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17500	12	312	312	CD
18637	17500	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17500	14	1932	1932	CD
18637	17500	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17500	16	.	.	.
18637	17501	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17501	2	243	243	CD
18637	17501	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17501	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17501	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17501	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17501	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17501	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17501	9	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	17501	10	,	,	,
18637	17501	11	299	299	CD
18637	17501	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17501	13	498	498	CD
18637	17501	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17501	15	1937	1937	CD
18637	17501	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17501	17	.	.	.
18637	17502	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17502	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17502	3	also	also	RB
18637	17502	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17502	5	Stockdale	Stockdale	NNP
18637	17502	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17502	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17502	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17502	9	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	17502	10	Companies	Companies	NNP
18637	17502	11	,	,	,
18637	17502	12	20	20	CD
18637	17502	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17502	14	.	.	.
18637	17503	1	323	323	CD
18637	17503	2	,	,	,
18637	17503	3	331	331	CD
18637	17503	4	,	,	,
18637	17503	5	341	341	CD
18637	17503	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17503	7	1874	1874	CD
18637	17503	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17503	9	;	;	:
18637	17503	10	Brushaber	Brushaber	NNP
18637	17503	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17503	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	17503	13	_	_	NNP
18637	17503	14	Union	Union	NNP
18637	17503	15	Pac	Pac	NNP
18637	17503	16	.	.	.
18637	17504	1	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	17504	2	,	,	,
18637	17504	3	240	240	CD
18637	17504	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17504	5	1	1	CD
18637	17504	6	,	,	,
18637	17504	7	20	20	CD
18637	17504	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17504	9	1916	1916	CD
18637	17504	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17504	11	;	;	:
18637	17504	12	Lynch	Lynch	NNP
18637	17504	13	_	_	NNP
18637	17504	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	17504	15	_	_	NNP
18637	17504	16	Hornby	Hornby	NNP
18637	17504	17	,	,	,
18637	17504	18	247	247	CD
18637	17504	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17504	20	339	339	CD
18637	17504	21	,	,	,
18637	17504	22	343	343	CD
18637	17504	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17504	24	1918	1918	CD
18637	17504	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17504	26	.	.	.
18637	17505	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17505	2	244	244	CD
18637	17505	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17505	4	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	17505	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17505	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17505	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17505	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17505	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17505	10	,	,	,
18637	17505	11	280	280	CD
18637	17505	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17505	13	409	409	CD
18637	17505	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17505	15	1930	1930	CD
18637	17505	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17505	17	;	;	:
18637	17505	18	_	_	NNP
18637	17505	19	see	see	VB
18637	17505	20	also	also	RB
18637	17505	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17505	22	Reinecke	Reinecke	NNP
18637	17505	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17505	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	17505	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17505	26	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	17505	27	,	,	,
18637	17505	28	289	289	CD
18637	17505	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17505	30	172	172	CD
18637	17505	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17505	32	1933	1933	CD
18637	17505	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17505	34	.	.	.
18637	17506	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17506	2	245	245	CD
18637	17506	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17506	4	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	17506	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17506	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17506	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17506	8	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	17506	9	,	,	,
18637	17506	10	303	303	CD
18637	17506	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17506	12	391	391	CD
18637	17506	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17506	14	1938	1938	CD
18637	17506	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17506	16	.	.	.
18637	17507	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17507	2	246	246	CD
18637	17507	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17507	4	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	17507	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17507	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17507	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17507	8	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	17507	9	.	.	.
18637	17508	1	Grocery	Grocery	NNP
18637	17508	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17508	3	,	,	,
18637	17508	4	304	304	CD
18637	17508	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17508	6	282	282	CD
18637	17508	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17508	8	1938	1938	CD
18637	17508	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17508	10	.	.	.
18637	17509	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17509	2	247	247	CD
18637	17509	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17509	4	Patton	Patton	NNP
18637	17509	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17509	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17509	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17509	8	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	17509	9	,	,	,
18637	17509	10	184	184	CD
18637	17509	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17509	12	608	608	CD
18637	17509	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17509	14	1902	1902	CD
18637	17509	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17509	16	.	.	.
18637	17510	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17510	2	248	248	CD
18637	17510	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17510	4	Tyler	Tyler	NNP
18637	17510	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17510	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17510	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17510	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17510	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17510	10	,	,	,
18637	17510	11	281	281	CD
18637	17510	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17510	13	497	497	CD
18637	17510	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17510	15	1930	1930	CD
18637	17510	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17510	17	;	;	:
18637	17510	18	United	United	NNP
18637	17510	19	States	States	NNP
18637	17510	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17510	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	17510	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17510	23	Jacobs	Jacobs	NNP
18637	17510	24	,	,	,
18637	17510	25	306	306	CD
18637	17510	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17510	27	363	363	CD
18637	17510	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17510	29	1939	1939	CD
18637	17510	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17510	31	.	.	.
18637	17511	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17511	2	249	249	CD
18637	17511	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17511	4	Reinecke	Reinecke	NNP
18637	17511	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17511	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17511	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17511	8	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	17511	9	,	,	,
18637	17511	10	289	289	CD
18637	17511	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17511	12	172	172	CD
18637	17511	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17511	14	1933	1933	CD
18637	17511	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17511	16	.	.	.
18637	17512	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17512	2	250	250	CD
18637	17512	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17512	4	Tiger	Tiger	NNP
18637	17512	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17512	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17512	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17512	8	Western	Western	NNP
18637	17512	9	Investment	Investment	NNP
18637	17512	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17512	11	,	,	,
18637	17512	12	221	221	CD
18637	17512	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17512	14	286	286	CD
18637	17512	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17512	16	1911	1911	CD
18637	17512	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17512	18	.	.	.
18637	17513	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17513	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17513	3	also	also	RB
18637	17513	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17513	5	Brader	Brader	NNP
18637	17513	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17513	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17513	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17513	9	James	James	NNP
18637	17513	10	,	,	,
18637	17513	11	246	246	CD
18637	17513	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17513	13	88	88	CD
18637	17513	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17513	15	1918	1918	CD
18637	17513	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17513	17	;	;	:
18637	17513	18	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	17513	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17513	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	17513	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17513	22	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	17513	23	,	,	,
18637	17513	24	239	239	CD
18637	17513	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17513	26	414	414	CD
18637	17513	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17513	28	1915	1915	CD
18637	17513	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17513	30	;	;	:
18637	17513	31	Lone	Lone	NNP
18637	17513	32	Wolf	Wolf	NNP
18637	17513	33	_	_	NNP
18637	17513	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	17513	35	_	_	NNP
18637	17513	36	.	.	.
18637	17514	1	Hitchcock	hitchcock	NN
18637	17514	2	,	,	,
18637	17514	3	187	187	CD
18637	17514	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17514	5	553	553	CD
18637	17514	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17514	7	1903	1903	CD
18637	17514	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17514	9	.	.	.
18637	17515	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17515	2	251	251	CD
18637	17515	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17515	4	Choate	Choate	NNP
18637	17515	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17515	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17515	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17515	8	Trapp	Trapp	NNP
18637	17515	9	,	,	,
18637	17515	10	224	224	CD
18637	17515	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17515	12	665	665	CD
18637	17515	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17515	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	17515	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17515	16	.	.	.
18637	17516	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17516	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17516	3	also	also	RB
18637	17516	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17516	5	English	English	NNP
18637	17516	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17516	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17516	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17516	9	Richardson	Richardson	NNP
18637	17516	10	,	,	,
18637	17516	11	224	224	CD
18637	17516	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17516	13	680	680	CD
18637	17516	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17516	15	1912	1912	CD
18637	17516	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17516	17	.	.	.
18637	17517	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17517	2	252	252	CD
18637	17517	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17517	4	Garfield	Garfield	NNP
18637	17517	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17517	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17517	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17517	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17517	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17517	10	,	,	,
18637	17517	11	211	211	CD
18637	17517	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17517	13	249	249	CD
18637	17517	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17517	15	1908	1908	CD
18637	17517	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17517	17	.	.	.
18637	17518	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17518	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17518	3	also	also	RB
18637	17518	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17518	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17518	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17518	7	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17518	8	rel	rel	NN
18637	17518	9	.	.	.
18637	17519	1	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	17519	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17519	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17519	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17519	5	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	17519	6	,	,	,
18637	17519	7	222	222	CD
18637	17519	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17519	9	204	204	CD
18637	17519	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17519	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	17519	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17519	13	.	.	.
18637	17520	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17520	2	253	253	CD
18637	17520	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17520	4	Winton	Winton	NNP
18637	17520	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17520	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17520	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17520	8	Amos	Amos	NNP
18637	17520	9	,	,	,
18637	17520	10	255	255	CD
18637	17520	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17520	12	373	373	CD
18637	17520	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17520	14	1921	1921	CD
18637	17520	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17520	16	.	.	.
18637	17521	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17521	2	254	254	CD
18637	17521	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17521	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17521	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17521	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17521	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	17521	8	.	.	.
18637	17522	1	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	17522	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17522	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17522	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17522	5	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	17522	6	,	,	,
18637	17522	7	232	232	CD
18637	17522	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17522	9	598	598	CD
18637	17522	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17522	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	17522	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17522	13	.	.	.
18637	17523	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17523	2	255	255	CD
18637	17523	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17523	4	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	17523	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17523	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17523	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17523	8	McLoud	McLoud	NNP
18637	17523	9	,	,	,
18637	17523	10	204	204	CD
18637	17523	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17523	12	302	302	CD
18637	17523	13	,	,	,
18637	17523	14	309	309	CD
18637	17523	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17523	16	1907	1907	CD
18637	17523	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17523	18	;	;	:
18637	17523	19	Carpenter	Carpenter	NNP
18637	17523	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17523	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	17523	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17523	23	Shaw	Shaw	NNP
18637	17523	24	,	,	,
18637	17523	25	280	280	CD
18637	17523	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17523	27	363	363	CD
18637	17523	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17523	29	1930	1930	CD
18637	17523	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17523	31	.	.	.
18637	17524	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17524	2	256	256	CD
18637	17524	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17524	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17524	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17524	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17524	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17524	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17524	9	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	17524	10	,	,	,
18637	17524	11	109	109	CD
18637	17524	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17524	13	513	513	CD
18637	17524	14	,	,	,
18637	17524	15	518	518	CD
18637	17524	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17524	17	1883	1883	CD
18637	17524	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17524	19	;	;	:
18637	17524	20	United	United	NNP
18637	17524	21	States	States	NNP
18637	17524	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17524	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	17524	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17524	25	Carmack	Carmack	NNP
18637	17524	26	,	,	,
18637	17524	27	329	329	CD
18637	17524	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17524	29	230	230	CD
18637	17524	30	,	,	,
18637	17524	31	241	241	CD
18637	17524	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17524	33	1946	1946	CD
18637	17524	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17524	35	.	.	.
18637	17525	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17525	2	257	257	CD
18637	17525	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17525	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17525	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17525	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17525	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17525	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17525	9	Lynah	Lynah	NNP
18637	17525	10	,	,	,
18637	17525	11	188	188	CD
18637	17525	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17525	13	445	445	CD
18637	17525	14	,	,	,
18637	17525	15	465	465	CD
18637	17525	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17525	17	1903	1903	CD
18637	17525	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17525	19	.	.	.
18637	17526	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17526	2	258	258	CD
18637	17526	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17526	4	Kohl	Kohl	NNP
18637	17526	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17526	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17526	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17526	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17526	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17526	10	,	,	,
18637	17526	11	91	91	CD
18637	17526	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17526	13	367	367	CD
18637	17526	14	,	,	,
18637	17526	15	374	374	CD
18637	17526	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17526	17	1876	1876	CD
18637	17526	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17526	19	.	.	.
18637	17527	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17527	2	259	259	CD
18637	17527	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17527	4	Chappell	Chappell	NNP
18637	17527	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17527	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17527	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17527	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17527	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17527	10	,	,	,
18637	17527	11	160	160	CD
18637	17527	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17527	13	499	499	CD
18637	17527	14	,	,	,
18637	17527	15	510	510	CD
18637	17527	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17527	17	1896	1896	CD
18637	17527	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17527	19	.	.	.
18637	17528	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17528	2	260	260	CD
18637	17528	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17528	4	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	17528	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17528	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17528	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17528	8	Atkinson	Atkinson	NNP
18637	17528	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17528	10	,	,	,
18637	17528	11	313	313	CD
18637	17528	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17528	13	508	508	CD
18637	17528	14	,	,	,
18637	17528	15	534	534	CD
18637	17528	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17528	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	17528	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17528	19	.	.	.
18637	17529	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17529	2	261	261	CD
18637	17529	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17529	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17529	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17529	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17529	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17529	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17529	9	Chemical	Chemical	NNP
18637	17529	10	Foundation	Foundation	NNP
18637	17529	11	,	,	,
18637	17529	12	272	272	CD
18637	17529	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17529	14	1	1	CD
18637	17529	15	,	,	,
18637	17529	16	11	11	CD
18637	17529	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17529	18	1926	1926	CD
18637	17529	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17529	20	.	.	.
18637	17530	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17530	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17530	3	also	also	RB
18637	17530	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17530	5	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	17530	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17530	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17530	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17530	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17530	10	,	,	,
18637	17530	11	8	8	CD
18637	17530	12	Cr	cr	NN
18637	17530	13	.	.	.
18637	17531	1	110	110	CD
18637	17531	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17531	3	1814	1814	CD
18637	17531	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17531	5	;	;	:
18637	17531	6	Page	Page	NNP
18637	17531	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17531	8	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	17531	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17531	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17531	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	17531	12	_	_	NNP
18637	17531	13	United	United	NNP
18637	17531	14	States	States	NNP
18637	17531	15	,	,	,
18637	17531	16	11	11	CD
18637	17531	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17531	18	.	.	.
18637	17532	1	268	268	CD
18637	17532	2	,	,	,
18637	17532	3	304	304	CD
18637	17532	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17532	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	17532	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17532	7	;	;	:
18637	17532	8	Woodson	Woodson	NNP
18637	17532	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17532	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17532	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17532	12	Deutsche	Deutsche	NNP
18637	17532	13	G.	G.	NNP
18637	17532	14	&	&	CC
18637	17532	15	S.S.V.	S.S.V.	NNP
18637	17533	1	Roessler	Roessler	NNP
18637	17533	2	,	,	,
18637	17533	3	292	292	CD
18637	17533	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17533	5	449	449	CD
18637	17533	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17533	7	1934	1934	CD
18637	17533	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17533	9	;	;	:
18637	17533	10	United	United	NNP
18637	17533	11	States	States	NNP
18637	17533	12	_	_	NNP
18637	17533	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	17533	14	_	_	NNP
18637	17533	15	Dunnington	Dunnington	NNP
18637	17533	16	,	,	,
18637	17533	17	146	146	CD
18637	17533	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17533	19	338	338	CD
18637	17533	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17533	21	1892	1892	CD
18637	17533	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17533	23	;	;	:
18637	17533	24	Cummings	Cummings	NNP
18637	17533	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17533	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	17533	27	_	_	NNP
18637	17533	28	Deutsche	Deutsche	NNP
18637	17533	29	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	17533	30	,	,	,
18637	17533	31	300	300	CD
18637	17533	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17533	33	115	115	CD
18637	17533	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17533	35	1937	1937	CD
18637	17533	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17533	37	.	.	.
18637	17534	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17534	2	262	262	CD
18637	17534	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17534	4	Stoehr	Stoehr	NNP
18637	17534	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17534	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17534	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17534	8	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	17534	9	,	,	,
18637	17534	10	255	255	CD
18637	17534	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17534	12	239	239	CD
18637	17534	13	,	,	,
18637	17534	14	245	245	CD
18637	17534	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17534	16	1921	1921	CD
18637	17534	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17534	18	.	.	.
18637	17535	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17535	2	263	263	CD
18637	17535	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17535	4	Silesian	Silesian	NNP
18637	17535	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	17535	6	American	American	NNP
18637	17535	7	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	17535	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17535	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17535	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17535	11	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	17535	12	,	,	,
18637	17535	13	332	332	CD
18637	17535	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17535	15	469	469	CD
18637	17535	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17535	17	1947	1947	CD
18637	17535	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17535	19	;	;	:
18637	17535	20	Becker	Becker	NNP
18637	17535	21	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	17535	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17535	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17535	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	17535	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17535	26	Cummings	Cummings	NNP
18637	17535	27	,	,	,
18637	17535	28	296	296	CD
18637	17535	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17535	30	74	74	CD
18637	17535	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17535	32	1935	1935	CD
18637	17535	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17535	34	.	.	.
18637	17536	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17536	2	264	264	CD
18637	17536	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17536	4	Russian	Russian	NNP
18637	17536	5	Volunteer	Volunteer	NNP
18637	17536	6	Fleet	Fleet	NNP
18637	17536	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17536	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17536	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17536	10	United	United	NNP
18637	17536	11	States	States	NNP
18637	17536	12	,	,	,
18637	17536	13	282	282	CD
18637	17536	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17536	15	481	481	CD
18637	17536	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17536	17	1931	1931	CD
18637	17536	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17536	19	,	,	,
18637	17536	20	followed	follow	VBN
18637	17536	21	in	in	IN
18637	17536	22	Guessefeldt	Guessefeldt	NNP
18637	17536	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17536	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	17536	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17536	26	McGrath	McGrath	NNP
18637	17536	27	,	,	,
18637	17536	28	342	342	CD
18637	17536	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17536	30	308	308	CD
18637	17536	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17536	32	1952	1952	CD
18637	17536	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17536	34	.	.	.
18637	17537	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17537	2	265	265	CD
18637	17537	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17537	4	Shoemaker	Shoemaker	NNP
18637	17537	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17537	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17537	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17537	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17537	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17537	10	,	,	,
18637	17537	11	147	147	CD
18637	17537	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17537	13	282	282	CD
18637	17537	14	,	,	,
18637	17537	15	298	298	CD
18637	17537	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17537	17	1893	1893	CD
18637	17537	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17537	19	.	.	.
18637	17538	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17538	2	266	266	CD
18637	17538	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17538	4	327	327	CD
18637	17538	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17538	6	546	546	CD
18637	17538	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17538	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	17538	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17538	10	.	.	.
18637	17539	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17539	2	267	267	CD
18637	17539	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17539	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17539	5	.	.	.
18637	17540	1	551	551	CD
18637	17540	2	.	.	.
18637	17541	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17541	2	268	268	CD
18637	17541	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17541	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17541	5	.	.	.
18637	17542	1	556	556	CD
18637	17542	2	-	-	SYM
18637	17542	3	557	557	CD
18637	17542	4	;	;	:
18637	17542	5	citing	cite	VBG
18637	17542	6	United	United	NNP
18637	17542	7	States	States	NNP
18637	17542	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17542	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17542	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17542	11	Gettysburg	Gettysburg	NNP
18637	17542	12	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	17542	13	R.	R.	NNP
18637	17542	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17542	15	,	,	,
18637	17542	16	160	160	CD
18637	17542	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17542	18	668	668	CD
18637	17542	19	,	,	,
18637	17542	20	680	680	CD
18637	17542	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17542	22	1896	1896	CD
18637	17542	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17542	24	;	;	:
18637	17542	25	Rindge	Rindge	NNP
18637	17542	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17542	27	_	_	NNP
18637	17542	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	17542	29	_	_	NNP
18637	17542	30	Los	Los	NNP
18637	17542	31	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	17542	32	County	County	NNP
18637	17542	33	,	,	,
18637	17542	34	262	262	CD
18637	17542	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17542	36	700	700	CD
18637	17542	37	,	,	,
18637	17542	38	709	709	CD
18637	17542	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17542	40	1923	1923	CD
18637	17542	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17542	42	;	;	:
18637	17542	43	Old	Old	NNP
18637	17542	44	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	17542	45	Land	Land	NNP
18637	17542	46	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17542	47	_	_	NNP
18637	17542	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	17542	49	_	_	NNP
18637	17542	50	United	United	NNP
18637	17542	51	States	States	NNP
18637	17542	52	,	,	,
18637	17542	53	269	269	CD
18637	17542	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17542	55	55	55	CD
18637	17542	56	,	,	,
18637	17542	57	66	66	CD
18637	17542	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17542	59	1925	1925	CD
18637	17542	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17542	61	;	;	:
18637	17542	62	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	17542	63	_	_	NNP
18637	17542	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	17542	65	_	_	NNP
18637	17542	66	Vester	Vester	NNP
18637	17542	67	,	,	,
18637	17542	68	281	281	CD
18637	17542	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17542	70	439	439	CD
18637	17542	71	,	,	,
18637	17542	72	446	446	CD
18637	17542	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17542	74	1930	1930	CD
18637	17542	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17542	76	.	.	.
18637	17543	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17543	2	269	269	CD
18637	17543	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17543	4	327	327	CD
18637	17543	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17543	6	546	546	CD
18637	17543	7	,	,	,
18637	17543	8	557	557	CD
18637	17543	9	-	-	SYM
18637	17543	10	558	558	CD
18637	17543	11	.	.	.
18637	17544	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17544	2	270	270	CD
18637	17544	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17544	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17544	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17544	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17544	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17544	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17544	9	Gettysburg	Gettysburg	NNP
18637	17544	10	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	17544	11	R.	R.	NNP
18637	17544	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17544	13	,	,	,
18637	17544	14	160	160	CD
18637	17544	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17544	16	668	668	CD
18637	17544	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17544	18	1896	1896	CD
18637	17544	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17544	20	.	.	.
18637	17545	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17545	2	271	271	CD
18637	17545	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17545	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	17545	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17545	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17545	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17545	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17545	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17545	10	,	,	,
18637	17545	11	263	263	CD
18637	17545	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17545	13	78	78	CD
18637	17545	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17545	15	1923	1923	CD
18637	17545	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17545	17	.	.	.
18637	17546	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17546	2	272	272	CD
18637	17546	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17546	4	Monongahela	Monongahela	NNP
18637	17546	5	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	17546	6	.	.	.
18637	17547	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17547	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17547	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17547	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17547	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17547	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17547	7	,	,	,
18637	17547	8	148	148	CD
18637	17547	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17547	10	312	312	CD
18637	17547	11	,	,	,
18637	17547	12	345	345	CD
18637	17547	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17547	14	1893	1893	CD
18637	17547	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17547	16	.	.	.
18637	17548	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17548	2	273	273	CD
18637	17548	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17548	4	James	James	NNP
18637	17548	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17548	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17548	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17548	8	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
18637	17548	9	,	,	,
18637	17548	10	104	104	CD
18637	17548	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17548	12	356	356	CD
18637	17548	13	,	,	,
18637	17548	14	358	358	CD
18637	17548	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17548	16	1882	1882	CD
18637	17548	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17548	18	.	.	.
18637	17549	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17549	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17549	3	also	also	RB
18637	17549	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17549	5	Hollister	Hollister	NNP
18637	17549	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17549	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17549	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17549	9	Benedict	Benedict	NNP
18637	17549	10	&	&	CC
18637	17549	11	B.	B.	NNP
18637	17549	12	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	17549	13	.	.	.
18637	17550	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17550	2	,	,	,
18637	17550	3	113	113	CD
18637	17550	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17550	5	59	59	CD
18637	17550	6	,	,	,
18637	17550	7	67	67	CD
18637	17550	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17550	9	1885	1885	CD
18637	17550	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17550	11	.	.	.
18637	17551	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17551	2	274	274	CD
18637	17551	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17551	4	Omnia	Omnia	NNP
18637	17551	5	Commercial	Commercial	NNP
18637	17551	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17551	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17551	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17551	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17551	10	United	United	NNP
18637	17551	11	States	States	NNP
18637	17551	12	,	,	,
18637	17551	13	261	261	CD
18637	17551	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17551	15	502	502	CD
18637	17551	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17551	17	1923	1923	CD
18637	17551	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17551	19	.	.	.
18637	17552	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17552	2	275	275	CD
18637	17552	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17552	4	International	International	NNP
18637	17552	5	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	17552	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17552	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17552	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17552	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17552	10	United	United	NNP
18637	17552	11	States	States	NNP
18637	17552	12	,	,	,
18637	17552	13	282	282	CD
18637	17552	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17552	15	399	399	CD
18637	17552	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17552	17	1931	1931	CD
18637	17552	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17552	19	.	.	.
18637	17553	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17553	2	276	276	CD
18637	17553	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17553	4	Hannibal	Hannibal	NNP
18637	17553	5	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	17553	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17553	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17553	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17553	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17553	10	United	United	NNP
18637	17553	11	States	States	NNP
18637	17553	12	,	,	,
18637	17553	13	221	221	CD
18637	17553	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17553	15	194	194	CD
18637	17553	16	,	,	,
18637	17553	17	205	205	CD
18637	17553	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17553	19	1911	1911	CD
18637	17553	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17553	21	.	.	.
18637	17554	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17554	2	277	277	CD
18637	17554	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17554	4	Old	Old	NNP
18637	17554	5	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	17554	6	Land	Land	NNP
18637	17554	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17554	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17554	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17554	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17554	11	United	United	NNP
18637	17554	12	States	States	NNP
18637	17554	13	,	,	,
18637	17554	14	269	269	CD
18637	17554	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17554	16	55	55	CD
18637	17554	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17554	18	1925	1925	CD
18637	17554	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17554	20	.	.	.
18637	17555	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17555	2	278	278	CD
18637	17555	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17555	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17555	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17555	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17555	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17555	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17555	9	Sponenbarger	Sponenbarger	NNP
18637	17555	10	,	,	,
18637	17555	11	308	308	CD
18637	17555	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17555	13	256	256	CD
18637	17555	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17555	15	1939	1939	CD
18637	17555	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17555	17	.	.	.
18637	17556	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17556	2	279	279	CD
18637	17556	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17556	4	12	12	CD
18637	17556	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17556	6	.	.	.
18637	17557	1	457	457	CD
18637	17557	2	,	,	,
18637	17557	3	551	551	CD
18637	17557	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17557	5	1871	1871	CD
18637	17557	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17557	7	.	.	.
18637	17558	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17558	2	280	280	CD
18637	17558	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17558	4	331	331	CD
18637	17558	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17558	6	745	745	CD
18637	17558	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17558	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	17558	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17558	10	.	.	.
18637	17559	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17559	2	281	281	CD
18637	17559	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17559	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17559	5	.	.	.
18637	17560	1	748	748	CD
18637	17560	2	.	.	.
18637	17561	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17561	2	282	282	CD
18637	17561	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17561	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17561	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17561	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17561	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17561	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17561	9	Causby	Causby	NNP
18637	17561	10	,	,	,
18637	17561	11	328	328	CD
18637	17561	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17561	13	256	256	CD
18637	17561	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17561	15	1946	1946	CD
18637	17561	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17561	17	.	.	.
18637	17562	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17562	2	283	283	CD
18637	17562	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17562	4	Portsmouth	Portsmouth	NNP
18637	17562	5	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	17562	6	Land	Land	NNP
18637	17562	7	&	&	CC
18637	17562	8	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	17562	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17562	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17562	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	17562	12	_	_	NNP
18637	17562	13	United	United	NNP
18637	17562	14	States	States	NNP
18637	17562	15	,	,	,
18637	17562	16	260	260	CD
18637	17562	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17562	18	327	327	CD
18637	17562	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17562	20	1922	1922	CD
18637	17562	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17562	22	.	.	.
18637	17563	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17563	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	17563	3	.	.	.
18637	17563	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17563	5	Portsmouth	Portsmouth	NNP
18637	17563	6	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	17563	7	Land	Land	NNP
18637	17563	8	&	&	CC
18637	17563	9	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	17563	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17563	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17563	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	17563	13	_	_	NNP
18637	17563	14	United	United	NNP
18637	17563	15	States	States	NNP
18637	17563	16	,	,	,
18637	17563	17	250	250	CD
18637	17563	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17563	19	1	1	CD
18637	17563	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17563	21	1919	1919	CD
18637	17563	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17563	23	;	;	:
18637	17563	24	Peabody	Peabody	NNP
18637	17563	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17563	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	17563	27	_	_	NNP
18637	17563	28	United	United	NNP
18637	17563	29	States	States	NNP
18637	17563	30	,	,	,
18637	17563	31	231	231	CD
18637	17563	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17563	33	530	530	CD
18637	17563	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17563	35	1913	1913	CD
18637	17563	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17563	37	.	.	.
18637	17564	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17564	2	284	284	CD
18637	17564	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17564	4	Richards	Richards	NNP
18637	17564	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17564	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17564	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17564	8	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	17564	9	Terminal	Terminal	NNP
18637	17564	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17564	11	,	,	,
18637	17564	12	233	233	CD
18637	17564	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17564	14	546	546	CD
18637	17564	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17564	16	1914	1914	CD
18637	17564	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17564	18	.	.	.
18637	17565	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17565	2	285	285	CD
18637	17565	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17565	4	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	17565	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17565	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17565	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17565	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17565	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17565	10	,	,	,
18637	17565	11	166	166	CD
18637	17565	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17565	13	269	269	CD
18637	17565	14	,	,	,
18637	17565	15	271	271	CD
18637	17565	16	,	,	,
18637	17565	17	272	272	CD
18637	17565	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17565	19	1897	1897	CD
18637	17565	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17565	21	.	.	.
18637	17566	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17566	2	286	286	CD
18637	17566	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17566	4	10	10	CD
18637	17566	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17566	6	.	.	.
18637	17567	1	557	557	CD
18637	17567	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17567	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	17567	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17567	5	.	.	.
18637	17568	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17568	2	287	287	CD
18637	17568	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17568	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17568	5	.	.	.
18637	17569	1	563	563	CD
18637	17569	2	.	.	.
18637	17570	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17570	2	288	288	CD
18637	17570	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17570	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17570	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17570	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17570	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17570	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17570	9	Appalachian	Appalachian	NNP
18637	17570	10	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	17570	11	Power	Power	NNP
18637	17570	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17570	13	,	,	,
18637	17570	14	311	311	CD
18637	17570	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17570	16	377	377	CD
18637	17570	17	,	,	,
18637	17570	18	407	407	CD
18637	17570	19	,	,	,
18637	17570	20	409	409	CD
18637	17570	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17570	22	1940	1940	CD
18637	17570	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17570	24	.	.	.
18637	17571	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17571	2	289	289	CD
18637	17571	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17571	4	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	17571	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17571	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17571	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17571	8	Atkinson	Atkinson	NNP
18637	17571	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17571	10	,	,	,
18637	17571	11	313	313	CD
18637	17571	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17571	13	508	508	CD
18637	17571	14	,	,	,
18637	17571	15	523	523	CD
18637	17571	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17571	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	17571	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17571	19	.	.	.
18637	17572	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17572	2	290	290	CD
18637	17572	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17572	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17572	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17572	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17572	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17572	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17572	9	Commodore	Commodore	NNP
18637	17572	10	Park	Park	NNP
18637	17572	11	,	,	,
18637	17572	12	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	17572	13	,	,	,
18637	17572	14	324	324	CD
18637	17572	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17572	16	386	386	CD
18637	17572	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17572	18	1945	1945	CD
18637	17572	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17572	20	.	.	.
18637	17573	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17573	2	291	291	CD
18637	17573	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17573	4	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	17573	5	Blue	Blue	NNP
18637	17573	6	Point	Point	NNP
18637	17573	7	Oyster	Oyster	NNP
18637	17573	8	Cultivation	Cultivation	NNP
18637	17573	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17573	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17573	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	17573	12	_	_	NNP
18637	17573	13	Briggs	Briggs	NNP
18637	17573	14	,	,	,
18637	17573	15	229	229	CD
18637	17573	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17573	17	82	82	CD
18637	17573	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17573	19	1913	1913	CD
18637	17573	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17573	21	.	.	.
18637	17574	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17574	2	292	292	CD
18637	17574	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17574	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17574	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17574	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17574	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17574	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17574	9	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	17574	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	17574	11	Dunbar	Dunbar	NNP
18637	17574	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17574	13	,	,	,
18637	17574	14	229	229	CD
18637	17574	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17574	16	53	53	CD
18637	17574	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17574	18	1913	1913	CD
18637	17574	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17574	20	.	.	.
18637	17575	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17575	2	293	293	CD
18637	17575	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17575	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17575	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17575	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17575	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17575	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17575	9	Willow	Willow	NNP
18637	17575	10	River	River	NNP
18637	17575	11	Power	Power	NNP
18637	17575	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17575	13	,	,	,
18637	17575	14	324	324	CD
18637	17575	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17575	16	499	499	CD
18637	17575	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17575	18	1945	1945	CD
18637	17575	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17575	20	.	.	.
18637	17576	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17576	2	294	294	CD
18637	17576	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17576	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17576	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17576	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17576	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17576	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17576	9	Appalachian	Appalachian	NNP
18637	17576	10	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	17576	11	Power	Power	NNP
18637	17576	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17576	13	,	,	,
18637	17576	14	311	311	CD
18637	17576	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17576	16	377	377	CD
18637	17576	17	,	,	,
18637	17576	18	427	427	CD
18637	17576	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17576	20	1940	1940	CD
18637	17576	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17576	22	.	.	.
18637	17577	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17577	2	295	295	CD
18637	17577	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17577	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17577	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17577	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17577	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17577	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17577	9	Lynah	Lynah	NNP
18637	17577	10	,	,	,
18637	17577	11	188	188	CD
18637	17577	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17577	13	445	445	CD
18637	17577	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17577	15	1903	1903	CD
18637	17577	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17577	17	.	.	.
18637	17578	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17578	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17578	3	also	also	RB
18637	17578	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17578	5	Jacobs	Jacobs	NNP
18637	17578	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17578	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17578	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17578	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17578	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17578	11	,	,	,
18637	17578	12	290	290	CD
18637	17578	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17578	14	13	13	CD
18637	17578	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17578	16	1933	1933	CD
18637	17578	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17578	18	.	.	.
18637	17579	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17579	2	296	296	CD
18637	17579	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17579	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17579	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17579	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17579	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17579	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17579	9	Cress	Cress	NNP
18637	17579	10	,	,	,
18637	17579	11	243	243	CD
18637	17579	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17579	13	316	316	CD
18637	17579	14	,	,	,
18637	17579	15	328	328	CD
18637	17579	16	,	,	,
18637	17579	17	329	329	CD
18637	17579	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17579	19	1917	1917	CD
18637	17579	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17579	21	.	.	.
18637	17580	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17580	2	297	297	CD
18637	17580	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17580	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17580	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17580	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17580	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17580	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17580	9	Dickinson	Dickinson	NNP
18637	17580	10	,	,	,
18637	17580	11	331	331	CD
18637	17580	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17580	13	745	745	CD
18637	17580	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17580	15	1947	1947	CD
18637	17580	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17580	17	.	.	.
18637	17581	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17581	2	298	298	CD
18637	17581	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17581	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17581	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17581	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17581	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17581	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17581	9	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	17581	10	City	City	NNP
18637	17581	11	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	17581	12	.	.	.
18637	17582	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17582	2	,	,	,
18637	17582	3	339	339	CD
18637	17582	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17582	5	799	799	CD
18637	17582	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17582	7	1950	1950	CD
18637	17582	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17582	9	.	.	.
18637	17583	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17583	2	299	299	CD
18637	17583	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17583	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17583	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17583	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17583	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17583	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17583	9	Cress	Cress	NNP
18637	17583	10	,	,	,
18637	17583	11	243	243	CD
18637	17583	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17583	13	316	316	CD
18637	17583	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17583	15	1917	1917	CD
18637	17583	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17583	17	.	.	.
18637	17584	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17584	2	300	300	CD
18637	17584	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17584	4	Horstmann	Horstmann	NNP
18637	17584	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17584	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17584	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17584	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17584	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17584	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17584	11	,	,	,
18637	17584	12	257	257	CD
18637	17584	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17584	14	138	138	CD
18637	17584	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17584	16	1921	1921	CD
18637	17584	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17584	18	.	.	.
18637	17585	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17585	2	301	301	CD
18637	17585	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17585	4	Bauman	Bauman	NNP
18637	17585	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17585	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17585	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17585	8	Ross	Ross	NNP
18637	17585	9	,	,	,
18637	17585	10	167	167	CD
18637	17585	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17585	12	548	548	CD
18637	17585	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17585	14	1897	1897	CD
18637	17585	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17585	16	;	;	:
18637	17585	17	Sharp	Sharp	NNP
18637	17585	18	_	_	NNP
18637	17585	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	17585	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17585	21	United	United	NNP
18637	17585	22	States	States	NNP
18637	17585	23	,	,	,
18637	17585	24	191	191	CD
18637	17585	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17585	26	341	341	CD
18637	17585	27	,	,	,
18637	17585	28	351	351	CD
18637	17585	29	-	-	SYM
18637	17585	30	352	352	CD
18637	17585	31	,	,	,
18637	17585	32	354	354	CD
18637	17585	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17585	34	1903	1903	CD
18637	17585	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17585	36	.	.	.
18637	17586	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17586	2	302	302	CD
18637	17586	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17586	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17586	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17586	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17586	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17586	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17586	9	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	17586	10	,	,	,
18637	17586	11	217	217	CD
18637	17586	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17586	13	333	333	CD
18637	17586	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17586	15	1910	1910	CD
18637	17586	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17586	17	.	.	.
18637	17587	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17587	2	303	303	CD
18637	17587	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17587	4	Bauman	Bauman	NNP
18637	17587	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17587	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17587	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17587	8	Ross	Ross	NNP
18637	17587	9	,	,	,
18637	17587	10	167	167	CD
18637	17587	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17587	12	548	548	CD
18637	17587	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17587	14	1897	1897	CD
18637	17587	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17587	16	.	.	.
18637	17588	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17588	2	304	304	CD
18637	17588	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17588	4	Monongahela	Monongahela	NNP
18637	17588	5	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	17588	6	.	.	.
18637	17589	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17589	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17589	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17589	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17589	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17589	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17589	7	,	,	,
18637	17589	8	148	148	CD
18637	17589	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17589	10	312	312	CD
18637	17589	11	,	,	,
18637	17589	12	326	326	CD
18637	17589	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17589	14	1893	1893	CD
18637	17589	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17589	16	.	.	.
18637	17590	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17590	2	305	305	CD
18637	17590	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17590	4	Reichelderfer	Reichelderfer	NNP
18637	17590	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17590	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17590	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17590	8	Quinn	Quinn	NNP
18637	17590	9	,	,	,
18637	17590	10	287	287	CD
18637	17590	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17590	12	315	315	CD
18637	17590	13	,	,	,
18637	17590	14	318	318	CD
18637	17590	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17590	16	1932	1932	CD
18637	17590	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17590	18	.	.	.
18637	17591	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17591	2	306	306	CD
18637	17591	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17591	4	Sharp	Sharp	NNP
18637	17591	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17591	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17591	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17591	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17591	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17591	10	,	,	,
18637	17591	11	191	191	CD
18637	17591	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17591	13	341	341	CD
18637	17591	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17591	15	1903	1903	CD
18637	17591	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17591	17	.	.	.
18637	17592	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17592	2	307	307	CD
18637	17592	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17592	4	Monongahela	Monongahela	NNP
18637	17592	5	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	17592	6	.	.	.
18637	17593	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17593	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17593	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17593	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17593	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17593	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17593	7	,	,	,
18637	17593	8	148	148	CD
18637	17593	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17593	10	312	312	CD
18637	17593	11	,	,	,
18637	17593	12	326	326	CD
18637	17593	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17593	14	1893	1893	CD
18637	17593	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17593	16	.	.	.
18637	17594	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17594	2	308	308	CD
18637	17594	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17594	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17594	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17594	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17594	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	17594	8	.	.	.
18637	17595	1	T.V.A.	T.V.A.	NNP
18637	17596	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17596	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	17596	3	_	_	NNP
18637	17596	4	Powelson	Powelson	NNP
18637	17596	5	,	,	,
18637	17596	6	319	319	CD
18637	17596	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17596	8	266	266	CD
18637	17596	9	,	,	,
18637	17596	10	281	281	CD
18637	17596	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17596	12	1943	1943	CD
18637	17596	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17596	14	;	;	:
18637	17596	15	United	United	NNP
18637	17596	16	States	States	NNP
18637	17596	17	_	_	NNP
18637	17596	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	17596	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17596	20	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	17596	21	,	,	,
18637	17596	22	317	317	CD
18637	17596	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17596	24	369	369	CD
18637	17596	25	,	,	,
18637	17596	26	375	375	CD
18637	17596	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17596	28	1943	1943	CD
18637	17596	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17596	30	.	.	.
18637	17597	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17597	2	309	309	CD
18637	17597	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17597	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17597	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17597	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17597	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	17597	8	.	.	.
18637	17598	1	T.V.A.	T.V.A.	NNP
18637	17599	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17599	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	17599	3	_	_	NNP
18637	17599	4	Powelson	Powelson	NNP
18637	17599	5	,	,	,
18637	17599	6	319	319	CD
18637	17599	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17599	8	266	266	CD
18637	17599	9	,	,	,
18637	17599	10	275	275	CD
18637	17599	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17599	12	1943	1943	CD
18637	17599	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17599	14	;	;	:
18637	17599	15	United	United	NNP
18637	17599	16	States	States	NNP
18637	17599	17	_	_	NNP
18637	17599	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	17599	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17599	20	New	New	NNP
18637	17599	21	River	River	NNP
18637	17599	22	Collieries	Collieries	NNPS
18637	17599	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17599	24	,	,	,
18637	17599	25	262	262	CD
18637	17599	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17599	27	341	341	CD
18637	17599	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17599	29	1923	1923	CD
18637	17599	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17599	31	.	.	.
18637	17600	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17600	2	310	310	CD
18637	17600	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17600	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17600	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17600	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17600	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17600	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17600	9	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	17600	10	,	,	,
18637	17600	11	317	317	CD
18637	17600	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17600	13	369	369	CD
18637	17600	14	,	,	,
18637	17600	15	374	374	CD
18637	17600	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17600	17	1943	1943	CD
18637	17600	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17600	19	.	.	.
18637	17601	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17601	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17601	3	also	also	RB
18637	17601	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17601	5	Olson	Olson	NNP
18637	17601	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17601	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17601	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17601	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17601	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17601	11	,	,	,
18637	17601	12	292	292	CD
18637	17601	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17601	14	246	246	CD
18637	17601	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17601	16	1934	1934	CD
18637	17601	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17601	18	.	.	.
18637	17602	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17602	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	17602	3	.	.	.
18637	17602	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17602	5	Kimball	Kimball	NNP
18637	17602	6	Laundry	Laundry	NNP
18637	17602	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17602	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17602	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17602	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17602	11	United	United	NNP
18637	17602	12	States	States	NNP
18637	17602	13	,	,	,
18637	17602	14	338	338	CD
18637	17602	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17602	16	1	1	CD
18637	17602	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17602	18	1949	1949	CD
18637	17602	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17602	20	.	.	.
18637	17603	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17603	2	311	311	CD
18637	17603	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17603	4	Boom	Boom	NNP
18637	17603	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17603	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17603	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17603	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17603	9	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	17603	10	,	,	,
18637	17603	11	98	98	CD
18637	17603	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17603	13	403	403	CD
18637	17603	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17603	15	1879	1879	CD
18637	17603	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17603	17	;	;	:
18637	17603	18	McCandless	McCandless	NNP
18637	17603	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17603	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	17603	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17603	22	United	United	NNP
18637	17603	23	States	States	NNP
18637	17603	24	,	,	,
18637	17603	25	298	298	CD
18637	17603	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17603	27	342	342	CD
18637	17603	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17603	29	1936	1936	CD
18637	17603	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17603	31	.	.	.
18637	17604	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17604	2	312	312	CD
18637	17604	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17604	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17604	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17604	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17604	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17604	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17604	9	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	17604	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	17604	11	Dunbar	Dunbar	NNP
18637	17604	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17604	13	,	,	,
18637	17604	14	229	229	CD
18637	17604	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17604	16	53	53	CD
18637	17604	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17604	18	1913	1913	CD
18637	17604	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17604	20	.	.	.
18637	17605	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17605	2	313	313	CD
18637	17605	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17605	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17605	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17605	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17605	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17605	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17605	9	John	John	NNP
18637	17605	10	J.	J.	NNP
18637	17605	11	Felin	Felin	NNP
18637	17605	12	&	&	CC
18637	17605	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17605	14	,	,	,
18637	17605	15	334	334	CD
18637	17605	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17605	17	624	624	CD
18637	17605	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17605	19	1948	1948	CD
18637	17605	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17605	21	.	.	.
18637	17606	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17606	2	314	314	CD
18637	17606	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17606	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17606	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17606	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17606	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17606	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17606	9	Commodities	Commodities	NNPS
18637	17606	10	Trading	Trading	NNP
18637	17606	11	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	17606	12	,	,	,
18637	17606	13	339	339	CD
18637	17606	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17606	15	121	121	CD
18637	17606	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17606	17	1950	1950	CD
18637	17606	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17606	19	.	.	.
18637	17607	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17607	2	315	315	CD
18637	17607	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17607	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17607	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17607	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17607	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17607	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17607	9	Cors	Cors	NNP
18637	17607	10	,	,	,
18637	17607	11	337	337	CD
18637	17607	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17607	13	325	325	CD
18637	17607	14	,	,	,
18637	17607	15	333	333	CD
18637	17607	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17607	17	1949	1949	CD
18637	17607	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17607	19	.	.	.
18637	17608	1	In	in	IN
18637	17608	2	United	United	NNP
18637	17608	3	States	States	NNP
18637	17608	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17608	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	17608	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17608	7	Toronto	Toronto	NNP
18637	17608	8	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	17608	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17608	10	,	,	,
18637	17608	11	338	338	CD
18637	17608	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17608	13	396	396	CD
18637	17608	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17608	15	1949	1949	CD
18637	17608	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17608	17	the	the	DT
18637	17608	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17608	19	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	17608	20	a	a	DT
18637	17608	21	decision	decision	NN
18637	17608	22	of	of	IN
18637	17608	23	the	the	DT
18637	17608	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17608	25	of	of	IN
18637	17608	26	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	17608	27	which	which	WDT
18637	17608	28	based	base	VBD
18637	17608	29	an	an	DT
18637	17608	30	award	award	NN
18637	17608	31	for	for	IN
18637	17608	32	an	an	DT
18637	17608	33	obsolete	obsolete	JJ
18637	17608	34	Great	Great	NNP
18637	17608	35	Lakes	Lakes	NNP
18637	17608	36	car	car	NN
18637	17608	37	ferry	ferry	NN
18637	17608	38	in	in	IN
18637	17608	39	part	part	NN
18637	17608	40	on	on	IN
18637	17608	41	a	a	DT
18637	17608	42	capitalization	capitalization	NN
18637	17608	43	of	of	IN
18637	17608	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17608	45	prior	prior	JJ
18637	17608	46	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	17608	47	,	,	,
18637	17608	48	and	and	CC
18637	17608	49	in	in	IN
18637	17608	50	part	part	NN
18637	17608	51	on	on	IN
18637	17608	52	isolated	isolated	JJ
18637	17608	53	sales	sale	NNS
18637	17608	54	of	of	IN
18637	17608	55	similar	similar	JJ
18637	17608	56	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	17608	57	used	use	VBN
18637	17608	58	between	between	IN
18637	17608	59	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	17608	60	and	and	CC
18637	17608	61	Cuba	Cuba	NNP
18637	17608	62	.	.	.
18637	17609	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17609	2	316	316	CD
18637	17609	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17609	4	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	17609	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17609	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17609	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17609	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17609	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17609	10	,	,	,
18637	17609	11	267	267	CD
18637	17609	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17609	13	341	341	CD
18637	17609	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17609	15	1925	1925	CD
18637	17609	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17609	17	.	.	.
18637	17610	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17610	2	317	317	CD
18637	17610	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17610	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17610	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17610	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17610	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17610	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17610	9	General	General	NNP
18637	17610	10	Motors	Motors	NNPS
18637	17610	11	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	17610	12	,	,	,
18637	17610	13	323	323	CD
18637	17610	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17610	15	373	373	CD
18637	17610	16	,	,	,
18637	17610	17	379	379	CD
18637	17610	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17610	19	1945	1945	CD
18637	17610	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17610	21	.	.	.
18637	17611	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17611	2	318	318	CD
18637	17611	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17611	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17611	5	.	.	.
18637	17612	1	382	382	CD
18637	17612	2	-	-	SYM
18637	17612	3	384	384	CD
18637	17612	4	.	.	.
18637	17613	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17613	2	319	319	CD
18637	17613	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17613	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17613	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17613	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17613	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17613	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17613	9	Petty	Petty	NNP
18637	17613	10	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	17613	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17613	12	,	,	,
18637	17613	13	327	327	CD
18637	17613	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17613	15	372	372	CD
18637	17613	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17613	17	1946	1946	CD
18637	17613	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17613	19	.	.	.
18637	17614	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17614	2	320	320	CD
18637	17614	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17614	4	338	338	CD
18637	17614	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17614	6	1	1	CD
18637	17614	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17614	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	17614	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17614	10	.	.	.
18637	17615	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17615	2	321	321	CD
18637	17615	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17615	4	341	341	CD
18637	17615	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17615	6	114	114	CD
18637	17615	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17615	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	17615	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17615	10	.	.	.
18637	17616	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17616	2	322	322	CD
18637	17616	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17616	4	Danforth	Danforth	NNP
18637	17616	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17616	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17616	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17616	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17616	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17616	10	,	,	,
18637	17616	11	308	308	CD
18637	17616	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17616	13	271	271	CD
18637	17616	14	,	,	,
18637	17616	15	284	284	CD
18637	17616	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17616	17	1939	1939	CD
18637	17616	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17616	19	.	.	.
18637	17617	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17617	2	323	323	CD
18637	17617	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17617	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17617	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17617	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17617	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17617	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17617	9	Klamath	Klamath	NNP
18637	17617	10	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	17617	11	,	,	,
18637	17617	12	304	304	CD
18637	17617	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17617	14	119	119	CD
18637	17617	15	,	,	,
18637	17617	16	123	123	CD
18637	17617	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17617	18	1938	1938	CD
18637	17617	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17617	20	;	;	:
18637	17617	21	Jacobs	Jacobs	NNP
18637	17617	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17617	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	17617	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17617	25	United	United	NNP
18637	17617	26	States	States	NNP
18637	17617	27	,	,	,
18637	17617	28	290	290	CD
18637	17617	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17617	30	13	13	CD
18637	17617	31	,	,	,
18637	17617	32	17	17	CD
18637	17617	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17617	34	1933	1933	CD
18637	17617	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17617	36	.	.	.
18637	17618	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17618	2	324	324	CD
18637	17618	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17618	4	Albrecht	Albrecht	NNP
18637	17618	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17618	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17618	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17618	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17618	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17618	10	,	,	,
18637	17618	11	329	329	CD
18637	17618	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17618	13	599	599	CD
18637	17618	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17618	15	1947	1947	CD
18637	17618	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17618	17	.	.	.
18637	17619	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17619	2	325	325	CD
18637	17619	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17619	4	Henkels	Henkels	NNP
18637	17619	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17619	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17619	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17619	8	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	17619	9	,	,	,
18637	17619	10	271	271	CD
18637	17619	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17619	12	298	298	CD
18637	17619	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17619	14	1926	1926	CD
18637	17619	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17619	16	.	.	.
18637	17620	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17620	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17620	3	also	also	RB
18637	17620	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17620	5	Phelps	Phelps	NNP
18637	17620	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17620	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17620	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17620	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17620	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17620	11	,	,	,
18637	17620	12	274	274	CD
18637	17620	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17620	14	341	341	CD
18637	17620	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17620	16	1927	1927	CD
18637	17620	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17620	18	.	.	.
18637	17621	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17621	2	326	326	CD
18637	17621	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17621	4	Monongahela	Monongahela	NNP
18637	17621	5	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	17621	6	.	.	.
18637	17622	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17622	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17622	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17622	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17622	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17622	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17622	7	,	,	,
18637	17622	8	148	148	CD
18637	17622	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17622	10	312	312	CD
18637	17622	11	,	,	,
18637	17622	12	327	327	CD
18637	17622	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17622	14	1893	1893	CD
18637	17622	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17622	16	.	.	.
18637	17623	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17623	2	327	327	CD
18637	17623	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17623	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17623	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17623	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17623	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17623	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17623	9	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	17623	10	,	,	,
18637	17623	11	109	109	CD
18637	17623	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17623	13	513	513	CD
18637	17623	14	,	,	,
18637	17623	15	519	519	CD
18637	17623	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17623	17	1883	1883	CD
18637	17623	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17623	19	.	.	.
18637	17624	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17624	2	328	328	CD
18637	17624	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17624	4	Bauman	Bauman	NNP
18637	17624	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17624	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17624	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17624	8	Ross	Ross	NNP
18637	17624	9	,	,	,
18637	17624	10	167	167	CD
18637	17624	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17624	12	548	548	CD
18637	17624	13	,	,	,
18637	17624	14	593	593	CD
18637	17624	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17624	16	1897	1897	CD
18637	17624	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17624	18	.	.	.
18637	17625	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17625	2	329	329	CD
18637	17625	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17625	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17625	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17625	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17625	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17625	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17625	9	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	17625	10	,	,	,
18637	17625	11	106	106	CD
18637	17625	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17625	13	196	196	CD
18637	17625	14	,	,	,
18637	17625	15	220	220	CD
18637	17625	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17625	17	1882	1882	CD
18637	17625	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17625	19	.	.	.
18637	17626	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17626	2	330	330	CD
18637	17626	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17626	4	Jacobs	Jacobs	NNP
18637	17626	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17626	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17626	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17626	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17626	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17626	10	,	,	,
18637	17626	11	290	290	CD
18637	17626	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17626	13	13	13	CD
18637	17626	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17626	15	1933	1933	CD
18637	17626	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17626	17	;	;	:
18637	17626	18	United	United	NNP
18637	17626	19	States	States	NNP
18637	17626	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17626	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	17626	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17626	23	Great	Great	NNP
18637	17626	24	Falls	Falls	NNP
18637	17626	25	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	17626	26	.	.	.
18637	17627	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17627	2	,	,	,
18637	17627	3	112	112	CD
18637	17627	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17627	5	645	645	CD
18637	17627	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17627	7	1884	1884	CD
18637	17627	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17627	9	.	.	.
18637	17628	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17628	2	331	331	CD
18637	17628	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17628	4	Hurley	Hurley	NNP
18637	17628	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17628	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17628	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17628	8	Kincaid	Kincaid	NNP
18637	17628	9	,	,	,
18637	17628	10	285	285	CD
18637	17628	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17628	12	95	95	CD
18637	17628	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17628	14	1932	1932	CD
18637	17628	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17628	16	.	.	.
18637	17629	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17629	2	332	332	CD
18637	17629	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17629	4	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	17629	5	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	17629	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17629	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17629	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17629	9	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	17629	10	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	17629	11	R.	R.	NNP
18637	17629	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17629	13	,	,	,
18637	17629	14	135	135	CD
18637	17629	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17629	16	641	641	CD
18637	17629	17	,	,	,
18637	17629	18	659	659	CD
18637	17629	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17629	20	1890	1890	CD
18637	17629	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17629	22	.	.	.
18637	17630	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17630	2	333	333	CD
18637	17630	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17630	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17630	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17630	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17630	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17630	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17630	9	Russell	Russell	NNP
18637	17630	10	,	,	,
18637	17630	11	13	13	CD
18637	17630	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17630	13	.	.	.
18637	17631	1	623	623	CD
18637	17631	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17631	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	17631	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17631	5	.	.	.
18637	17632	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17632	2	334	334	CD
18637	17632	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17632	4	Shoemaker	Shoemaker	NNP
18637	17632	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17632	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17632	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17632	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17632	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17632	10	,	,	,
18637	17632	11	147	147	CD
18637	17632	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17632	13	282	282	CD
18637	17632	14	,	,	,
18637	17632	15	302	302	CD
18637	17632	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17632	17	1893	1893	CD
18637	17632	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17632	19	.	.	.
18637	17633	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	17633	2	6	6	CD
18637	17633	3	RIGHTS	right	NNS
18637	17633	4	OF	of	IN
18637	17633	5	ACCUSED	accused	NN
18637	17633	6	IN	in	IN
18637	17633	7	CRIMINAL	criminal	JJ
18637	17633	8	PROSECUTIONS	prosecutions	NN
18637	17633	9	Page	Page	NNP
18637	17633	10	Coverage	Coverage	NNP
18637	17633	11	of	of	IN
18637	17633	12	the	the	DT
18637	17633	13	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	17633	14	877	877	CD
18637	17633	15	Offenses	offense	NNS
18637	17633	16	against	against	IN
18637	17633	17	the	the	DT
18637	17633	18	United	United	NNP
18637	17633	19	States	States	NNP
18637	17633	20	877	877	NNP
18637	17633	21	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	17633	22	by	by	IN
18637	17633	23	jury	jury	NN
18637	17633	24	878	878	CD
18637	17633	25	Impartial	impartial	JJ
18637	17633	26	jury	jury	NN
18637	17633	27	879	879	CD
18637	17633	28	Place	Place	NNP
18637	17633	29	of	of	IN
18637	17633	30	trial	trial	NN
18637	17633	31	880	880	CD
18637	17633	32	Definition	definition	NN
18637	17633	33	of	of	IN
18637	17633	34	crime	crime	NN
18637	17633	35	881	881	CD
18637	17633	36	Right	right	NN
18637	17633	37	of	of	IN
18637	17633	38	confrontation	confrontation	NN
18637	17633	39	884	884	CD
18637	17633	40	Assistance	assistance	NN
18637	17633	41	of	of	IN
18637	17633	42	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	17633	43	884	884	CD
18637	17633	44	RIGHTS	right	NNS
18637	17633	45	OF	of	IN
18637	17633	46	ACCUSED	accused	NN
18637	17633	47	IN	in	IN
18637	17633	48	CRIMINAL	criminal	JJ
18637	17633	49	PROSECUTIONS	prosecutions	NN
18637	17633	50	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	17633	51	6	6	CD
18637	17633	52	In	in	IN
18637	17633	53	all	all	DT
18637	17633	54	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	17633	55	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	17633	56	,	,	,
18637	17633	57	the	the	DT
18637	17633	58	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17633	59	shall	shall	MD
18637	17633	60	enjoy	enjoy	VB
18637	17633	61	the	the	DT
18637	17633	62	right	right	NN
18637	17633	63	to	to	IN
18637	17633	64	a	a	DT
18637	17633	65	speedy	speedy	JJ
18637	17633	66	and	and	CC
18637	17633	67	public	public	JJ
18637	17633	68	trial	trial	NN
18637	17633	69	,	,	,
18637	17633	70	by	by	IN
18637	17633	71	an	an	DT
18637	17633	72	impartial	impartial	JJ
18637	17633	73	jury	jury	NN
18637	17633	74	of	of	IN
18637	17633	75	the	the	DT
18637	17633	76	State	State	NNP
18637	17633	77	and	and	CC
18637	17633	78	district	district	NN
18637	17633	79	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	17633	80	the	the	DT
18637	17633	81	crime	crime	NN
18637	17633	82	shall	shall	MD
18637	17633	83	have	have	VB
18637	17633	84	been	be	VBN
18637	17633	85	committed	commit	VBN
18637	17633	86	,	,	,
18637	17633	87	which	which	WDT
18637	17633	88	district	district	NN
18637	17633	89	shall	shall	MD
18637	17633	90	have	have	VB
18637	17633	91	been	be	VBN
18637	17633	92	previously	previously	RB
18637	17633	93	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	17633	94	by	by	IN
18637	17633	95	law	law	NN
18637	17633	96	,	,	,
18637	17633	97	and	and	CC
18637	17633	98	to	to	TO
18637	17633	99	be	be	VB
18637	17633	100	informed	inform	VBN
18637	17633	101	of	of	IN
18637	17633	102	the	the	DT
18637	17633	103	nature	nature	NN
18637	17633	104	and	and	CC
18637	17633	105	cause	cause	NN
18637	17633	106	of	of	IN
18637	17633	107	the	the	DT
18637	17633	108	accusation	accusation	NN
18637	17633	109	;	;	:
18637	17633	110	to	to	TO
18637	17633	111	be	be	VB
18637	17633	112	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	17633	113	with	with	IN
18637	17633	114	the	the	DT
18637	17633	115	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	17633	116	against	against	IN
18637	17633	117	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17633	118	;	;	:
18637	17633	119	to	to	TO
18637	17633	120	have	have	VB
18637	17633	121	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	17633	122	process	process	NN
18637	17633	123	for	for	IN
18637	17633	124	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	17633	125	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	17633	126	in	in	IN
18637	17633	127	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17633	128	favor	favor	NN
18637	17633	129	,	,	,
18637	17633	130	and	and	CC
18637	17633	131	to	to	TO
18637	17633	132	have	have	VB
18637	17633	133	the	the	DT
18637	17633	134	Assistance	assistance	NN
18637	17633	135	of	of	IN
18637	17633	136	Counsel	Counsel	NNP
18637	17633	137	for	for	IN
18637	17633	138	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17633	139	defense	defense	NN
18637	17633	140	.	.	.
18637	17634	1	Coverage	coverage	NN
18637	17634	2	of	of	IN
18637	17634	3	the	the	DT
18637	17634	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17634	5	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
18637	17634	6	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	17634	7	in	in	IN
18637	17634	8	the	the	DT
18637	17634	9	District	District	NNP
18637	17634	10	of	of	IN
18637	17634	11	Columbia[1	Columbia[1	NNP
18637	17634	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17634	13	and	and	CC
18637	17634	14	in	in	IN
18637	17634	15	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	17634	16	territories[2	territories[2	''
18637	17634	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17634	18	must	must	MD
18637	17634	19	conform	conform	VB
18637	17634	20	to	to	IN
18637	17634	21	this	this	DT
18637	17634	22	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	17634	23	,	,	,
18637	17634	24	but	but	CC
18637	17634	25	those	those	DT
18637	17634	26	in	in	IN
18637	17634	27	unincorporated	unincorporated	JJ
18637	17634	28	territories	territory	NNS
18637	17634	29	need	need	VBP
18637	17634	30	not	not	RB
18637	17634	31	.	.	.
18637	17635	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17635	2	3	3	CD
18637	17635	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17635	4	For	for	IN
18637	17635	5	this	this	DT
18637	17635	6	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	17635	7	,	,	,
18637	17635	8	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	17635	9	was	be	VBD
18637	17635	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	17635	11	to	to	TO
18637	17635	12	be	be	VB
18637	17635	13	an	an	DT
18637	17635	14	incorporated	incorporated	JJ
18637	17635	15	territory	territory	NN
18637	17635	16	even	even	RB
18637	17635	17	before	before	IN
18637	17635	18	the	the	DT
18637	17635	19	organization	organization	NN
18637	17635	20	of	of	IN
18637	17635	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17635	22	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	17635	23	government	government	NN
18637	17635	24	.	.	.
18637	17636	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17636	2	4	4	CD
18637	17636	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17636	4	In	in	IN
18637	17636	5	in	in	IN
18637	17636	6	re	re	NNP
18637	17636	7	Ross[5	Ross[5	NNP
18637	17636	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17636	9	the	the	DT
18637	17636	10	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	17636	11	of	of	IN
18637	17636	12	this	this	DT
18637	17636	13	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	17636	14	were	be	VBD
18637	17636	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	17636	16	to	to	TO
18637	17636	17	cover	cover	VB
18637	17636	18	only	only	JJ
18637	17636	19	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	17636	20	and	and	CC
18637	17636	21	others	other	NNS
18637	17636	22	within	within	IN
18637	17636	23	the	the	DT
18637	17636	24	United	United	NNP
18637	17636	25	States	States	NNP
18637	17636	26	or	or	CC
18637	17636	27	who	who	WP
18637	17636	28	are	be	VBP
18637	17636	29	brought	bring	VBN
18637	17636	30	to	to	IN
18637	17636	31	the	the	DT
18637	17636	32	United	United	NNP
18637	17636	33	States	States	NNP
18637	17636	34	for	for	IN
18637	17636	35	trial	trial	NN
18637	17636	36	for	for	IN
18637	17636	37	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	17636	38	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	17636	39	committed	commit	VBN
18637	17636	40	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	17636	41	,	,	,
18637	17636	42	not	not	RB
18637	17636	43	to	to	IN
18637	17636	44	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	17636	45	residing	reside	VBG
18637	17636	46	or	or	CC
18637	17636	47	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	17636	48	sojourning	sojourn	VBG
18637	17636	49	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	17636	50	.	.	.
18637	17637	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17637	2	6	6	CD
18637	17637	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17637	4	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	17637	5	,	,	,
18637	17637	6	laws	law	NNS
18637	17637	7	passed	pass	VBD
18637	17637	8	to	to	TO
18637	17637	9	carry	carry	VB
18637	17637	10	into	into	IN
18637	17637	11	effect	effect	NN
18637	17637	12	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	17637	13	granting	grant	VBG
18637	17637	14	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	JJ
18637	17637	15	rights	right	NNS
18637	17637	16	were	be	VBD
18637	17637	17	not	not	RB
18637	17637	18	rendered	render	VBN
18637	17637	19	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	17637	20	by	by	IN
18637	17637	21	the	the	DT
18637	17637	22	fact	fact	NN
18637	17637	23	that	that	IN
18637	17637	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17637	25	did	do	VBD
18637	17637	26	not	not	RB
18637	17637	27	secure	secure	VB
18637	17637	28	to	to	IN
18637	17637	29	an	an	DT
18637	17637	30	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17637	31	the	the	DT
18637	17637	32	right	right	NN
18637	17637	33	to	to	IN
18637	17637	34	trial	trial	NN
18637	17637	35	by	by	IN
18637	17637	36	jury	jury	NN
18637	17637	37	.	.	.
18637	17638	1	Offenses	Offenses	NNP
18637	17638	2	Against	against	IN
18637	17638	3	the	the	DT
18637	17638	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17638	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17638	6	There	there	EX
18637	17638	7	are	be	VBP
18637	17638	8	no	no	DT
18637	17638	9	common	common	JJ
18637	17638	10	law	law	NN
18637	17638	11	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	17638	12	against	against	IN
18637	17638	13	the	the	DT
18637	17638	14	United	United	NNP
18637	17638	15	States	States	NNP
18637	17638	16	.	.	.
18637	17639	1	Only	only	RB
18637	17639	2	those	those	DT
18637	17639	3	acts	act	NNS
18637	17639	4	which	which	WDT
18637	17639	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17639	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	17639	7	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	17639	8	,	,	,
18637	17639	9	with	with	IN
18637	17639	10	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	17639	11	for	for	IN
18637	17639	12	disobedience	disobedience	NN
18637	17639	13	of	of	IN
18637	17639	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17639	15	command	command	NN
18637	17639	16	,	,	,
18637	17639	17	are	be	VBP
18637	17639	18	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	17639	19	.	.	.
18637	17640	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17640	2	7	7	CD
18637	17640	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17640	4	As	as	IN
18637	17640	5	used	use	VBN
18637	17640	6	in	in	IN
18637	17640	7	the	the	DT
18637	17640	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	17640	9	the	the	DT
18637	17640	10	word	word	NN
18637	17640	11	"	"	``
18637	17640	12	crime	crime	NN
18637	17640	13	"	"	''
18637	17640	14	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	17640	15	only	only	RB
18637	17640	16	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	17640	17	of	of	IN
18637	17640	18	a	a	DT
18637	17640	19	serious	serious	JJ
18637	17640	20	character	character	NN
18637	17640	21	.	.	.
18637	17641	1	Petty	petty	JJ
18637	17641	2	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	17641	3	may	may	MD
18637	17641	4	be	be	VB
18637	17641	5	proceeded	proceed	VBN
18637	17641	6	against	against	IN
18637	17641	7	summarily	summarily	RB
18637	17641	8	in	in	IN
18637	17641	9	any	any	DT
18637	17641	10	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	17641	11	legally	legally	RB
18637	17641	12	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	17641	13	for	for	IN
18637	17641	14	that	that	DT
18637	17641	15	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	17641	16	.	.	.
18637	17642	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17642	2	8	8	LS
18637	17642	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17642	4	The	the	DT
18637	17642	5	nature	nature	NN
18637	17642	6	of	of	IN
18637	17642	7	the	the	DT
18637	17642	8	act	act	NN
18637	17642	9	and	and	CC
18637	17642	10	the	the	DT
18637	17642	11	severity	severity	NN
18637	17642	12	of	of	IN
18637	17642	13	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	17642	14	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	17642	15	determine	determine	NN
18637	17642	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	17642	17	an	an	DT
18637	17642	18	offense	offense	NN
18637	17642	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	17642	20	serious	serious	JJ
18637	17642	21	or	or	CC
18637	17642	22	petty	petty	JJ
18637	17642	23	.	.	.
18637	17643	1	A	a	DT
18637	17643	2	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	17643	3	of	of	IN
18637	17643	4	$	$	$
18637	17643	5	50	50	CD
18637	17643	6	for	for	IN
18637	17643	7	a	a	DT
18637	17643	8	violation	violation	NN
18637	17643	9	,	,	,
18637	17643	10	not	not	RB
18637	17643	11	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	17643	12	involving	involve	VBG
18637	17643	13	moral	moral	JJ
18637	17643	14	delinquency	delinquency	NN
18637	17643	15	,	,	,
18637	17643	16	of	of	IN
18637	17643	17	a	a	DT
18637	17643	18	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	17643	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	17643	20	indicates	indicate	VBZ
18637	17643	21	only	only	RB
18637	17643	22	a	a	DT
18637	17643	23	petty	petty	JJ
18637	17643	24	offense	offense	NN
18637	17643	25	.	.	.
18637	17644	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17644	2	9	9	CD
18637	17644	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17644	4	The	the	DT
18637	17644	5	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	17644	6	sale	sale	NN
18637	17644	7	of	of	IN
18637	17644	8	the	the	DT
18637	17644	9	unused	unused	JJ
18637	17644	10	portion	portion	NN
18637	17644	11	of	of	IN
18637	17644	12	railway	railway	NN
18637	17644	13	excursion	excursion	NN
18637	17644	14	tickets	ticket	NNS
18637	17644	15	without	without	IN
18637	17644	16	a	a	DT
18637	17644	17	license	license	NN
18637	17644	18	,	,	,
18637	17644	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	17644	20	at	at	IN
18637	17644	21	most	most	RBS
18637	17644	22	an	an	DT
18637	17644	23	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	17644	24	of	of	IN
18637	17644	25	local	local	JJ
18637	17644	26	police	police	NN
18637	17644	27	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	17644	28	;	;	:
18637	17644	29	and	and	CC
18637	17644	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17644	31	moral	moral	JJ
18637	17644	32	quality	quality	NN
18637	17644	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	17644	34	relatively	relatively	RB
18637	17644	35	inoffensive	inoffensive	JJ
18637	17644	36	;	;	:
18637	17644	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17644	38	may	may	MD
18637	17644	39	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	17644	40	be	be	VB
18637	17644	41	tried	try	VBN
18637	17644	42	without	without	IN
18637	17644	43	a	a	DT
18637	17644	44	jury	jury	NN
18637	17644	45	.	.	.
18637	17645	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17645	2	10	10	CD
18637	17645	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17645	4	But	but	CC
18637	17645	5	a	a	DT
18637	17645	6	charge	charge	NN
18637	17645	7	of	of	IN
18637	17645	8	driving	drive	VBG
18637	17645	9	an	an	DT
18637	17645	10	automobile	automobile	NN
18637	17645	11	recklessly	recklessly	RB
18637	17645	12	,	,	,
18637	17645	13	so	so	IN
18637	17645	14	as	as	IN
18637	17645	15	to	to	TO
18637	17645	16	endanger	endanger	VB
18637	17645	17	life	life	NN
18637	17645	18	and	and	CC
18637	17645	19	property	property	NN
18637	17645	20	,	,	,
18637	17645	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	17645	22	a	a	DT
18637	17645	23	"	"	``
18637	17645	24	grave	grave	JJ
18637	17645	25	offense	offense	NN
18637	17645	26	"	"	''
18637	17645	27	for	for	IN
18637	17645	28	which	which	WDT
18637	17645	29	a	a	DT
18637	17645	30	jury	jury	NN
18637	17645	31	trial	trial	NN
18637	17645	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	17645	33	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	17645	34	.	.	.
18637	17646	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17646	2	11	11	CD
18637	17646	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17646	4	A	a	DT
18637	17646	5	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	17646	6	to	to	TO
18637	17646	7	invade	invade	VB
18637	17646	8	the	the	DT
18637	17646	9	rights	right	NNS
18637	17646	10	of	of	IN
18637	17646	11	another	another	DT
18637	17646	12	person	person	NN
18637	17646	13	also	also	RB
18637	17646	14	falls	fall	VBZ
18637	17646	15	in	in	IN
18637	17646	16	that	that	DT
18637	17646	17	category	category	NN
18637	17646	18	.	.	.
18637	17647	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17647	2	12	12	CD
18637	17647	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17647	4	Actions	Actions	NNPS
18637	17647	5	to	to	TO
18637	17647	6	recover	recover	VB
18637	17647	7	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	17647	8	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	17647	9	by	by	IN
18637	17647	10	act	act	NN
18637	17647	11	of	of	IN
18637	17647	12	Congress,[13	Congress,[13	NNP
18637	17647	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17647	14	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	17647	15	proceedings[14	proceedings[14	NNP
18637	17647	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17647	17	and	and	CC
18637	17647	18	contempt	contempt	VB
18637	17647	19	proceedings[15	proceedings[15	NNP
18637	17647	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17647	21	for	for	IN
18637	17647	22	violation	violation	NN
18637	17647	23	of	of	IN
18637	17647	24	an	an	DT
18637	17647	25	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	17647	26	have	have	VBP
18637	17647	27	been	be	VBN
18637	17647	28	held	hold	VBN
18637	17647	29	not	not	RB
18637	17647	30	to	to	TO
18637	17647	31	be	be	VB
18637	17647	32	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	17647	33	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	17647	34	.	.	.
18637	17648	1	Only	only	RB
18637	17648	2	a	a	DT
18637	17648	3	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	17648	4	which	which	WDT
18637	17648	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	17648	6	technically	technically	RB
18637	17648	7	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	17648	8	in	in	IN
18637	17648	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17648	10	nature	nature	NN
18637	17648	11	falls	fall	VBZ
18637	17648	12	within	within	IN
18637	17648	13	the	the	DT
18637	17648	14	purview	purview	NN
18637	17648	15	of	of	IN
18637	17648	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17648	17	VI	VI	NNP
18637	17648	18	.	.	.
18637	17649	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17649	2	16	16	CD
18637	17649	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17649	4	The	the	DT
18637	17649	5	concept	concept	NN
18637	17649	6	of	of	IN
18637	17649	7	a	a	DT
18637	17649	8	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	17649	9	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	17649	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	17649	11	much	much	RB
18637	17649	12	narrower	narrow	JJR
18637	17649	13	than	than	IN
18637	17649	14	that	that	DT
18637	17649	15	of	of	IN
18637	17649	16	a	a	DT
18637	17649	17	"	"	``
18637	17649	18	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	17649	19	case	case	NN
18637	17649	20	"	"	''
18637	17649	21	under	under	IN
18637	17649	22	the	the	DT
18637	17649	23	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	17649	24	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17649	25	.	.	.
18637	17650	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17650	2	17	17	CD
18637	17650	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17650	4	Trial	trial	NN
18637	17650	5	by	by	IN
18637	17650	6	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	17650	7	The	the	DT
18637	17650	8	trial	trial	NN
18637	17650	9	by	by	IN
18637	17650	10	jury	jury	NN
18637	17650	11	required	require	VBN
18637	17650	12	by	by	IN
18637	17650	13	the	the	DT
18637	17650	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	17650	15	includes	include	VBZ
18637	17650	16	all	all	PDT
18637	17650	17	the	the	DT
18637	17650	18	essential	essential	JJ
18637	17650	19	elements	element	NNS
18637	17650	20	of	of	IN
18637	17650	21	jury	jury	NN
18637	17650	22	trial	trial	NN
18637	17650	23	which	which	WDT
18637	17650	24	were	be	VBD
18637	17650	25	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	17650	26	in	in	IN
18637	17650	27	this	this	DT
18637	17650	28	country	country	NN
18637	17650	29	and	and	CC
18637	17650	30	in	in	IN
18637	17650	31	England	England	NNP
18637	17650	32	when	when	WRB
18637	17650	33	the	the	DT
18637	17650	34	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	17650	35	was	be	VBD
18637	17650	36	adopted;[18	adopted;[18	VBN
18637	17650	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17650	38	a	a	DT
18637	17650	39	jury	jury	NN
18637	17650	40	must	must	MD
18637	17650	41	consist	consist	VB
18637	17650	42	of	of	IN
18637	17650	43	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	17650	44	men	man	NNS
18637	17650	45	,	,	,
18637	17650	46	neither	neither	CC
18637	17650	47	more	more	JJR
18637	17650	48	nor	nor	CC
18637	17650	49	less;[19	less;[19	IN
18637	17650	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17650	51	the	the	DT
18637	17650	52	trial	trial	NN
18637	17650	53	must	must	MD
18637	17650	54	be	be	VB
18637	17650	55	held	hold	VBN
18637	17650	56	in	in	IN
18637	17650	57	the	the	DT
18637	17650	58	presence	presence	NN
18637	17650	59	and	and	CC
18637	17650	60	under	under	IN
18637	17650	61	the	the	DT
18637	17650	62	superintendence	superintendence	NN
18637	17650	63	of	of	IN
18637	17650	64	a	a	DT
18637	17650	65	judge	judge	NN
18637	17650	66	having	have	VBG
18637	17650	67	power	power	NN
18637	17650	68	to	to	TO
18637	17650	69	instruct	instruct	VB
18637	17650	70	the	the	DT
18637	17650	71	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	17650	72	as	as	IN
18637	17650	73	to	to	IN
18637	17650	74	the	the	DT
18637	17650	75	law	law	NN
18637	17650	76	and	and	CC
18637	17650	77	advise	advise	VB
18637	17650	78	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17650	79	in	in	IN
18637	17650	80	respect	respect	NN
18637	17650	81	of	of	IN
18637	17650	82	the	the	DT
18637	17650	83	facts,[20	facts,[20	CD
18637	17650	84	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17650	85	and	and	CC
18637	17650	86	the	the	DT
18637	17650	87	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	17650	88	must	must	MD
18637	17650	89	be	be	VB
18637	17650	90	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	17650	91	.	.	.
18637	17651	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17651	2	21	21	CD
18637	17651	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17651	4	But	but	CC
18637	17651	5	the	the	DT
18637	17651	6	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	17651	7	of	of	IN
18637	17651	8	a	a	DT
18637	17651	9	jury	jury	NN
18637	17651	10	trial	trial	NN
18637	17651	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	17651	12	not	not	RB
18637	17651	13	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	17651	14	;	;	:
18637	17651	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17651	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	17651	17	a	a	DT
18637	17651	18	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	17651	19	which	which	WDT
18637	17651	20	the	the	DT
18637	17651	21	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17651	22	may	may	MD
18637	17651	23	waive	waive	VB
18637	17651	24	with	with	IN
18637	17651	25	the	the	DT
18637	17651	26	consent	consent	NN
18637	17651	27	of	of	IN
18637	17651	28	the	the	DT
18637	17651	29	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17651	30	and	and	CC
18637	17651	31	the	the	DT
18637	17651	32	approval	approval	NN
18637	17651	33	of	of	IN
18637	17651	34	the	the	DT
18637	17651	35	court	court	NN
18637	17651	36	.	.	.
18637	17652	1	There	there	EX
18637	17652	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	17652	3	no	no	DT
18637	17652	4	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	17652	5	between	between	IN
18637	17652	6	a	a	DT
18637	17652	7	complete	complete	JJ
18637	17652	8	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	17652	9	of	of	IN
18637	17652	10	a	a	DT
18637	17652	11	jury	jury	NN
18637	17652	12	and	and	CC
18637	17652	13	a	a	DT
18637	17652	14	consent	consent	NN
18637	17652	15	to	to	TO
18637	17652	16	be	be	VB
18637	17652	17	tried	try	VBN
18637	17652	18	by	by	IN
18637	17652	19	less	less	JJR
18637	17652	20	than	than	IN
18637	17652	21	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	17652	22	men	man	NNS
18637	17652	23	.	.	.
18637	17653	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17653	2	22	22	CD
18637	17653	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17653	4	When	when	WRB
18637	17653	5	a	a	DT
18637	17653	6	person	person	NN
18637	17653	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	17653	8	charged	charge	VBN
18637	17653	9	with	with	IN
18637	17653	10	more	more	JJR
18637	17653	11	than	than	IN
18637	17653	12	one	one	CD
18637	17653	13	crime	crime	NN
18637	17653	14	,	,	,
18637	17653	15	the	the	DT
18637	17653	16	right	right	NN
18637	17653	17	to	to	IN
18637	17653	18	a	a	DT
18637	17653	19	speedy	speedy	JJ
18637	17653	20	trial	trial	NN
18637	17653	21	does	do	VBZ
18637	17653	22	not	not	RB
18637	17653	23	require	require	VB
18637	17653	24	that	that	IN
18637	17653	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17653	26	be	be	VB
18637	17653	27	first	first	RB
18637	17653	28	tried	try	VBN
18637	17653	29	on	on	IN
18637	17653	30	the	the	DT
18637	17653	31	earliest	early	JJS
18637	17653	32	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	17653	33	;	;	:
18637	17653	34	no	no	DT
18637	17653	35	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17653	36	right	right	NN
18637	17653	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	17653	38	violated	violate	VBN
18637	17653	39	by	by	IN
18637	17653	40	removing	remove	VBG
18637	17653	41	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17653	42	to	to	IN
18637	17653	43	another	another	DT
18637	17653	44	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	17653	45	for	for	IN
18637	17653	46	trial	trial	NN
18637	17653	47	on	on	IN
18637	17653	48	a	a	DT
18637	17653	49	later	later	JJ
18637	17653	50	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	17653	51	.	.	.
18637	17654	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17654	2	23	23	CD
18637	17654	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17654	4	Impartial	Impartial	NNP
18637	17654	5	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	17654	6	"	"	''
18637	17654	7	*	*	NFP
18637	17654	8	*	*	NFP
18637	17654	9	*	*	NFP
18637	17654	10	,	,	,
18637	17654	11	the	the	DT
18637	17654	12	guarantee	guarantee	NN
18637	17654	13	of	of	IN
18637	17654	14	an	an	DT
18637	17654	15	impartial	impartial	JJ
18637	17654	16	jury	jury	NN
18637	17654	17	to	to	IN
18637	17654	18	the	the	DT
18637	17654	19	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17654	20	in	in	IN
18637	17654	21	a	a	DT
18637	17654	22	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	17654	23	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	17654	24	,	,	,
18637	17654	25	*	*	NFP
18637	17654	26	*	*	NFP
18637	17654	27	*	*	NFP
18637	17654	28	,	,	,
18637	17654	29	secures	secure	NNS
18637	17654	30	to	to	IN
18637	17654	31	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17654	32	the	the	DT
18637	17654	33	right	right	NN
18637	17654	34	to	to	TO
18637	17654	35	enjoy	enjoy	VB
18637	17654	36	that	that	DT
18637	17654	37	mode	mode	NN
18637	17654	38	of	of	IN
18637	17654	39	trial	trial	NN
18637	17654	40	from	from	IN
18637	17654	41	the	the	DT
18637	17654	42	first	first	JJ
18637	17654	43	moment	moment	NN
18637	17654	44	,	,	,
18637	17654	45	and	and	CC
18637	17654	46	in	in	IN
18637	17654	47	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	17654	48	court	court	NN
18637	17654	49	,	,	,
18637	17654	50	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17654	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	17654	52	put	put	VBN
18637	17654	53	on	on	IN
18637	17654	54	trial	trial	NN
18637	17654	55	for	for	IN
18637	17654	56	the	the	DT
18637	17654	57	offense	offense	NN
18637	17654	58	charged	charge	VBD
18637	17654	59	.	.	.
18637	17655	1	*	*	NFP
18637	17655	2	*	*	NFP
18637	17655	3	*	*	NFP
18637	17655	4	To	to	TO
18637	17655	5	accord	accord	VB
18637	17655	6	to	to	IN
18637	17655	7	the	the	DT
18637	17655	8	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17655	9	a	a	DT
18637	17655	10	right	right	NN
18637	17655	11	to	to	TO
18637	17655	12	be	be	VB
18637	17655	13	tried	try	VBN
18637	17655	14	by	by	IN
18637	17655	15	a	a	DT
18637	17655	16	jury	jury	NN
18637	17655	17	,	,	,
18637	17655	18	in	in	IN
18637	17655	19	an	an	DT
18637	17655	20	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	17655	21	court	court	NN
18637	17655	22	,	,	,
18637	17655	23	after	after	IN
18637	17655	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17655	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	17655	26	been	be	VBN
18637	17655	27	once	once	RB
18637	17655	28	fully	fully	RB
18637	17655	29	tried	try	VBN
18637	17655	30	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	17655	31	than	than	IN
18637	17655	32	by	by	IN
18637	17655	33	a	a	DT
18637	17655	34	jury	jury	NN
18637	17655	35	,	,	,
18637	17655	36	in	in	IN
18637	17655	37	the	the	DT
18637	17655	38	court	court	NN
18637	17655	39	of	of	IN
18637	17655	40	original	original	JJ
18637	17655	41	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	17655	42	,	,	,
18637	17655	43	and	and	CC
18637	17655	44	sentenced	sentence	VBN
18637	17655	45	to	to	TO
18637	17655	46	pay	pay	VB
18637	17655	47	a	a	DT
18637	17655	48	fine	fine	NN
18637	17655	49	or	or	CC
18637	17655	50	be	be	VB
18637	17655	51	imprisoned	imprison	VBN
18637	17655	52	for	for	IN
18637	17655	53	not	not	RB
18637	17655	54	paying	pay	VBG
18637	17655	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17655	56	,	,	,
18637	17655	57	does	do	VBZ
18637	17655	58	not	not	RB
18637	17655	59	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	17655	60	the	the	DT
18637	17655	61	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	17655	62	of	of	IN
18637	17655	63	the	the	DT
18637	17655	64	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	17655	65	.	.	.
18637	17656	1	"	"	``
18637	17656	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17656	3	24	24	CD
18637	17656	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17656	5	The	the	DT
18637	17656	6	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	17656	7	of	of	IN
18637	17656	8	government	government	NN
18637	17656	9	employees	employee	NNS
18637	17656	10	to	to	TO
18637	17656	11	serve	serve	VB
18637	17656	12	on	on	IN
18637	17656	13	juries	jury	NNS
18637	17656	14	in	in	IN
18637	17656	15	the	the	DT
18637	17656	16	District	District	NNP
18637	17656	17	of	of	IN
18637	17656	18	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	17656	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	17656	20	been	be	VBN
18637	17656	21	the	the	DT
18637	17656	22	principal	principal	JJ
18637	17656	23	source	source	NN
18637	17656	24	of	of	IN
18637	17656	25	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	17656	26	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	17656	27	the	the	DT
18637	17656	28	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	17656	29	of	of	IN
18637	17656	30	the	the	DT
18637	17656	31	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	17656	32	"	"	``
18637	17656	33	impartial	impartial	JJ
18637	17656	34	jury	jury	NN
18637	17656	35	.	.	.
18637	17656	36	"	"	''
18637	17657	1	In	in	IN
18637	17657	2	1909	1909	CD
18637	17657	3	,	,	,
18637	17657	4	the	the	DT
18637	17657	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	17657	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17657	7	decided	decide	VBD
18637	17657	8	,	,	,
18637	17657	9	on	on	IN
18637	17657	10	common	common	JJ
18637	17657	11	law	law	NN
18637	17657	12	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	17657	13	,	,	,
18637	17657	14	that	that	IN
18637	17657	15	such	such	JJ
18637	17657	16	employees	employee	NNS
18637	17657	17	were	be	VBD
18637	17657	18	disqualified	disqualify	VBN
18637	17657	19	in	in	IN
18637	17657	20	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	17657	21	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	17657	22	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	17657	23	by	by	IN
18637	17657	24	the	the	DT
18637	17657	25	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17657	26	.	.	.
18637	17658	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17658	2	25	25	CD
18637	17658	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17658	4	As	as	IN
18637	17658	5	the	the	DT
18637	17658	6	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	17658	7	of	of	IN
18637	17658	8	public	public	NN
18637	17658	9	to	to	IN
18637	17658	10	private	private	JJ
18637	17658	11	employees	employee	NNS
18637	17658	12	increased	increase	VBD
18637	17658	13	,	,	,
18637	17658	14	this	this	DT
18637	17658	15	decision	decision	NN
18637	17658	16	created	create	VBD
18637	17658	17	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	17658	18	in	in	IN
18637	17658	19	securing	secure	VBG
18637	17658	20	properly	properly	RB
18637	17658	21	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	17658	22	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	17658	23	.	.	.
18637	17659	1	To	to	TO
18637	17659	2	meet	meet	VB
18637	17659	3	the	the	DT
18637	17659	4	situation	situation	NN
18637	17659	5	,	,	,
18637	17659	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17659	7	removed	remove	VBD
18637	17659	8	the	the	DT
18637	17659	9	disqualification	disqualification	NN
18637	17659	10	by	by	IN
18637	17659	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	17659	12	in	in	IN
18637	17659	13	1935	1935	CD
18637	17659	14	.	.	.
18637	17660	1	In	in	IN
18637	17660	2	United	United	NNP
18637	17660	3	States	States	NNP
18637	17660	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17660	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	17660	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17660	7	Wood,[26	Wood,[26	NNP
18637	17660	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17660	9	the	the	DT
18637	17660	10	act	act	NN
18637	17660	11	was	be	VBD
18637	17660	12	held	hold	VBN
18637	17660	13	valid	valid	JJ
18637	17660	14	as	as	IN
18637	17660	15	applied	apply	VBN
18637	17660	16	in	in	IN
18637	17660	17	a	a	DT
18637	17660	18	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	17660	19	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	17660	20	for	for	IN
18637	17660	21	theft	theft	NN
18637	17660	22	from	from	IN
18637	17660	23	a	a	DT
18637	17660	24	private	private	JJ
18637	17660	25	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	17660	26	.	.	.
18637	17661	1	By	by	IN
18637	17661	2	a	a	DT
18637	17661	3	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	17661	4	majority	majority	NN
18637	17661	5	the	the	DT
18637	17661	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17661	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	17661	8	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	17661	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	17661	10	that	that	IN
18637	17661	11	government	government	NN
18637	17661	12	employees	employee	NNS
18637	17661	13	as	as	IN
18637	17661	14	a	a	DT
18637	17661	15	class	class	NN
18637	17661	16	are	be	VBP
18637	17661	17	not	not	RB
18637	17661	18	disqualified	disqualify	VBN
18637	17661	19	by	by	IN
18637	17661	20	an	an	DT
18637	17661	21	implied	imply	VBN
18637	17661	22	bias	bias	NN
18637	17661	23	against	against	IN
18637	17661	24	a	a	DT
18637	17661	25	person	person	NN
18637	17661	26	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17661	27	of	of	IN
18637	17661	28	violating	violate	VBG
18637	17661	29	the	the	DT
18637	17661	30	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17661	31	narcotics	narcotic	NNS
18637	17661	32	statutes,[27	statutes,[27	CD
18637	17661	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17661	34	nor	nor	CC
18637	17661	35	against	against	IN
18637	17661	36	an	an	DT
18637	17661	37	officer	officer	NN
18637	17661	38	of	of	IN
18637	17661	39	the	the	DT
18637	17661	40	Communist	Communist	NNP
18637	17661	41	party	party	NN
18637	17661	42	charged	charge	VBN
18637	17661	43	with	with	IN
18637	17661	44	willful	willful	JJ
18637	17661	45	failure	failure	NN
18637	17661	46	to	to	TO
18637	17661	47	appear	appear	VB
18637	17661	48	before	before	IN
18637	17661	49	a	a	DT
18637	17661	50	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	17661	51	committee	committee	NN
18637	17661	52	in	in	IN
18637	17661	53	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	17661	54	with	with	IN
18637	17661	55	a	a	DT
18637	17661	56	subpoena	subpoena	NN
18637	17661	57	.	.	.
18637	17662	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17662	2	28	28	CD
18637	17662	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17662	4	In	in	IN
18637	17662	5	both	both	DT
18637	17662	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	17662	7	,	,	,
18637	17662	8	the	the	DT
18637	17662	9	way	way	NN
18637	17662	10	was	be	VBD
18637	17662	11	left	leave	VBN
18637	17662	12	open	open	JJ
18637	17662	13	for	for	IN
18637	17662	14	a	a	DT
18637	17662	15	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17662	16	to	to	TO
18637	17662	17	establish	establish	VB
18637	17662	18	the	the	DT
18637	17662	19	disqualification	disqualification	NN
18637	17662	20	of	of	IN
18637	17662	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17662	22	employees	employee	NNS
18637	17662	23	by	by	IN
18637	17662	24	adducing	adduce	VBG
18637	17662	25	proof	proof	NN
18637	17662	26	of	of	IN
18637	17662	27	actual	actual	JJ
18637	17662	28	bias	bias	NN
18637	17662	29	.	.	.
18637	17663	1	The	the	DT
18637	17663	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	17663	3	does	do	VBZ
18637	17663	4	not	not	RB
18637	17663	5	require	require	VB
18637	17663	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17663	7	to	to	TO
18637	17663	8	allow	allow	VB
18637	17663	9	peremptory	peremptory	JJ
18637	17663	10	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	17663	11	to	to	IN
18637	17663	12	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	17663	13	in	in	IN
18637	17663	14	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	17663	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	17663	16	.	.	.
18637	17664	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	17664	2	the	the	DT
18637	17664	3	contention	contention	NN
18637	17664	4	that	that	IN
18637	17664	5	several	several	JJ
18637	17664	6	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	17664	7	being	be	VBG
18637	17664	8	tried	try	VBN
18637	17664	9	together	together	RB
18637	17664	10	on	on	IN
18637	17664	11	a	a	DT
18637	17664	12	charge	charge	NN
18637	17664	13	of	of	IN
18637	17664	14	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	17664	15	were	be	VBD
18637	17664	16	denied	deny	VBN
18637	17664	17	a	a	DT
18637	17664	18	trial	trial	NN
18637	17664	19	by	by	IN
18637	17664	20	an	an	DT
18637	17664	21	impartial	impartial	JJ
18637	17664	22	jury	jury	NN
18637	17664	23	because	because	IN
18637	17664	24	each	each	DT
18637	17664	25	was	be	VBD
18637	17664	26	not	not	RB
18637	17664	27	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	17664	28	the	the	DT
18637	17664	29	full	full	JJ
18637	17664	30	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	17664	31	number	number	NN
18637	17664	32	of	of	IN
18637	17664	33	peremptory	peremptory	JJ
18637	17664	34	challenges	challenge	NNS
18637	17664	35	was	be	VBD
18637	17664	36	without	without	IN
18637	17664	37	merit	merit	NN
18637	17664	38	.	.	.
18637	17665	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17665	2	29	29	CD
18637	17665	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17665	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17665	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	17665	6	good	good	JJ
18637	17665	7	ground	ground	NN
18637	17665	8	for	for	IN
18637	17665	9	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	17665	10	for	for	IN
18637	17665	11	cause	cause	NN
18637	17665	12	that	that	IN
18637	17665	13	a	a	DT
18637	17665	14	juror	juror	NN
18637	17665	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	17665	16	formed	form	VBN
18637	17665	17	an	an	DT
18637	17665	18	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17665	19	as	as	IN
18637	17665	20	to	to	IN
18637	17665	21	the	the	DT
18637	17665	22	issue	issue	NN
18637	17665	23	to	to	TO
18637	17665	24	be	be	VB
18637	17665	25	tried	try	VBN
18637	17665	26	.	.	.
18637	17666	1	But	but	CC
18637	17666	2	every	every	DT
18637	17666	3	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17666	4	which	which	WDT
18637	17666	5	a	a	DT
18637	17666	6	juror	juror	NN
18637	17666	7	may	may	MD
18637	17666	8	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	17666	9	does	do	VBZ
18637	17666	10	not	not	RB
18637	17666	11	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	17666	12	disqualify	disqualify	VB
18637	17666	13	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17666	14	.	.	.
18637	17667	1	Upon	upon	IN
18637	17667	2	the	the	DT
18637	17667	3	trial	trial	NN
18637	17667	4	of	of	IN
18637	17667	5	the	the	DT
18637	17667	6	issue	issue	NN
18637	17667	7	of	of	IN
18637	17667	8	fact	fact	NN
18637	17667	9	raised	raise	VBN
18637	17667	10	by	by	IN
18637	17667	11	such	such	PDT
18637	17667	12	a	a	DT
18637	17667	13	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	17667	14	,	,	,
18637	17667	15	the	the	DT
18637	17667	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17667	17	must	must	MD
18637	17667	18	determine	determine	VB
18637	17667	19	whether	whether	IN
18637	17667	20	the	the	DT
18637	17667	21	nature	nature	NN
18637	17667	22	and	and	CC
18637	17667	23	strength	strength	NN
18637	17667	24	of	of	IN
18637	17667	25	the	the	DT
18637	17667	26	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17667	27	are	be	VBP
18637	17667	28	such	such	JJ
18637	17667	29	as	as	IN
18637	17667	30	in	in	IN
18637	17667	31	law	law	NN
18637	17667	32	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	17667	33	to	to	TO
18637	17667	34	raise	raise	VB
18637	17667	35	the	the	DT
18637	17667	36	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	17667	37	of	of	IN
18637	17667	38	partiality	partiality	NN
18637	17667	39	.	.	.
18637	17668	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17668	2	30	30	CD
18637	17668	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17668	4	A	a	DT
18637	17668	5	member	member	NN
18637	17668	6	of	of	IN
18637	17668	7	the	the	DT
18637	17668	8	Socialist	Socialist	NNP
18637	17668	9	party	party	NN
18637	17668	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	17668	11	not	not	RB
18637	17668	12	denied	deny	VBN
18637	17668	13	any	any	DT
18637	17668	14	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17668	15	right	right	NN
18637	17668	16	by	by	IN
18637	17668	17	being	be	VBG
18637	17668	18	tried	try	VBN
18637	17668	19	by	by	IN
18637	17668	20	a	a	DT
18637	17668	21	jury	jury	NN
18637	17668	22	composed	compose	VBN
18637	17668	23	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	17668	24	of	of	IN
18637	17668	25	members	member	NNS
18637	17668	26	of	of	IN
18637	17668	27	other	other	JJ
18637	17668	28	parties	party	NNS
18637	17668	29	and	and	CC
18637	17668	30	of	of	IN
18637	17668	31	property	property	NN
18637	17668	32	owners	owner	NNS
18637	17668	33	.	.	.
18637	17669	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17669	2	31	31	CD
18637	17669	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17669	4	Place	Place	NNP
18637	17669	5	of	of	IN
18637	17669	6	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	17669	7	An	An	NNP
18637	17669	8	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17669	9	can	can	MD
18637	17669	10	not	not	RB
18637	17669	11	be	be	VB
18637	17669	12	tried	try	VBN
18637	17669	13	in	in	IN
18637	17669	14	one	one	CD
18637	17669	15	district	district	NN
18637	17669	16	under	under	IN
18637	17669	17	an	an	DT
18637	17669	18	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	17669	19	showing	show	VBG
18637	17669	20	that	that	IN
18637	17669	21	the	the	DT
18637	17669	22	offense	offense	NN
18637	17669	23	was	be	VBD
18637	17669	24	committed	commit	VBN
18637	17669	25	in	in	IN
18637	17669	26	another;[32	another;[32	NNP
18637	17669	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17669	28	the	the	DT
18637	17669	29	locality	locality	NN
18637	17669	30	in	in	IN
18637	17669	31	which	which	WDT
18637	17669	32	the	the	DT
18637	17669	33	offense	offense	NN
18637	17669	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	17669	35	charged	charge	VBN
18637	17669	36	to	to	TO
18637	17669	37	have	have	VB
18637	17669	38	been	be	VBN
18637	17669	39	committed	commit	VBN
18637	17669	40	determines	determine	VBZ
18637	17669	41	the	the	DT
18637	17669	42	place	place	NN
18637	17669	43	and	and	CC
18637	17669	44	court	court	NN
18637	17669	45	of	of	IN
18637	17669	46	trial	trial	NN
18637	17669	47	.	.	.
18637	17670	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17670	2	33	33	CD
18637	17670	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17670	4	In	in	IN
18637	17670	5	a	a	DT
18637	17670	6	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	17670	7	for	for	IN
18637	17670	8	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	17670	9	,	,	,
18637	17670	10	the	the	DT
18637	17670	11	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17670	12	may	may	MD
18637	17670	13	be	be	VB
18637	17670	14	tried	try	VBN
18637	17670	15	in	in	IN
18637	17670	16	any	any	DT
18637	17670	17	State	State	NNP
18637	17670	18	and	and	CC
18637	17670	19	district	district	NN
18637	17670	20	where	where	WRB
18637	17670	21	an	an	DT
18637	17670	22	overt	overt	JJ
18637	17670	23	act	act	NN
18637	17670	24	was	be	VBD
18637	17670	25	performed	perform	VBN
18637	17670	26	.	.	.
18637	17671	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17671	2	34	34	CD
18637	17671	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17671	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	17671	5	a	a	DT
18637	17671	6	United	United	NNP
18637	17671	7	States	States	NNP
18637	17671	8	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	17671	9	was	be	VBD
18637	17671	10	indicted	indict	VBN
18637	17671	11	for	for	IN
18637	17671	12	agreeing	agree	VBG
18637	17671	13	to	to	TO
18637	17671	14	receive	receive	VB
18637	17671	15	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	17671	16	for	for	IN
18637	17671	17	services	service	NNS
18637	17671	18	to	to	TO
18637	17671	19	be	be	VB
18637	17671	20	rendered	render	VBN
18637	17671	21	in	in	IN
18637	17671	22	a	a	DT
18637	17671	23	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	17671	24	before	before	IN
18637	17671	25	a	a	DT
18637	17671	26	government	government	NN
18637	17671	27	department	department	NN
18637	17671	28	,	,	,
18637	17671	29	and	and	CC
18637	17671	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17671	31	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	17671	32	that	that	IN
18637	17671	33	a	a	DT
18637	17671	34	tentative	tentative	JJ
18637	17671	35	arrangement	arrangement	NN
18637	17671	36	for	for	IN
18637	17671	37	such	such	JJ
18637	17671	38	services	service	NNS
18637	17671	39	was	be	VBD
18637	17671	40	made	make	VBN
18637	17671	41	in	in	IN
18637	17671	42	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	17671	43	and	and	CC
18637	17671	44	confirmed	confirm	VBD
18637	17671	45	in	in	IN
18637	17671	46	St.	St.	NNP
18637	17671	47	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	17671	48	,	,	,
18637	17671	49	the	the	DT
18637	17671	50	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17671	51	was	be	VBD
18637	17671	52	properly	properly	RB
18637	17671	53	tried	try	VBN
18637	17671	54	in	in	IN
18637	17671	55	St.	St.	NNP
18637	17671	56	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	17671	57	,	,	,
18637	17671	58	although	although	IN
18637	17671	59	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17671	60	was	be	VBD
18637	17671	61	not	not	RB
18637	17671	62	physically	physically	RB
18637	17671	63	present	present	JJ
18637	17671	64	in	in	IN
18637	17671	65	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	17671	66	when	when	WRB
18637	17671	67	notice	notice	NN
18637	17671	68	of	of	IN
18637	17671	69	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	17671	70	was	be	VBD
18637	17671	71	dispatched	dispatch	VBN
18637	17671	72	.	.	.
18637	17672	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17672	2	35	35	CD
18637	17672	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17672	4	The	the	DT
18637	17672	5	offense	offense	NN
18637	17672	6	of	of	IN
18637	17672	7	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	17672	8	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	17672	9	of	of	IN
18637	17672	10	property	property	NN
18637	17672	11	in	in	IN
18637	17672	12	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	17672	13	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	17672	14	at	at	IN
18637	17672	15	less	less	JJR
18637	17672	16	than	than	IN
18637	17672	17	the	the	DT
18637	17672	18	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	17672	19	's	's	POS
18637	17672	20	published	publish	VBN
18637	17672	21	rates,[36	rates,[36	CD
18637	17672	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17672	23	or	or	CC
18637	17672	24	the	the	DT
18637	17672	25	sending	sending	NN
18637	17672	26	of	of	IN
18637	17672	27	excluded	excluded	JJ
18637	17672	28	matter	matter	NN
18637	17672	29	through	through	IN
18637	17672	30	the	the	DT
18637	17672	31	mails,[37	mails,[37	CD
18637	17672	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17672	33	may	may	MD
18637	17672	34	be	be	VB
18637	17672	35	made	make	VBN
18637	17672	36	triable	triable	JJ
18637	17672	37	in	in	IN
18637	17672	38	any	any	DT
18637	17672	39	district	district	NN
18637	17672	40	through	through	IN
18637	17672	41	which	which	WDT
18637	17672	42	the	the	DT
18637	17672	43	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	17672	44	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	17672	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	17672	46	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	17672	47	.	.	.
18637	17673	1	By	by	IN
18637	17673	2	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	17673	3	of	of	IN
18637	17673	4	a	a	DT
18637	17673	5	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	17673	6	that	that	IN
18637	17673	7	a	a	DT
18637	17673	8	letter	letter	NN
18637	17673	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	17673	10	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	17673	11	in	in	IN
18637	17673	12	the	the	DT
18637	17673	13	district	district	NN
18637	17673	14	to	to	TO
18637	17673	15	which	which	WDT
18637	17673	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17673	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	17673	18	addressed	address	VBN
18637	17673	19	,	,	,
18637	17673	20	the	the	DT
18637	17673	21	offense	offense	NN
18637	17673	22	of	of	IN
18637	17673	23	scheming	scheme	VBG
18637	17673	24	to	to	TO
18637	17673	25	defraud	defraud	VB
18637	17673	26	a	a	DT
18637	17673	27	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	17673	28	by	by	IN
18637	17673	29	mail	mail	NN
18637	17673	30	was	be	VBD
18637	17673	31	held	hold	VBN
18637	17673	32	to	to	TO
18637	17673	33	have	have	VB
18637	17673	34	been	be	VBN
18637	17673	35	committed	commit	VBN
18637	17673	36	in	in	IN
18637	17673	37	that	that	DT
18637	17673	38	district	district	NN
18637	17673	39	although	although	IN
18637	17673	40	the	the	DT
18637	17673	41	letter	letter	NN
18637	17673	42	was	be	VBD
18637	17673	43	posted	post	VBN
18637	17673	44	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	17673	45	.	.	.
18637	17674	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17674	2	38	38	CD
18637	17674	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17674	4	The	the	DT
18637	17674	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	17674	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	17674	7	not	not	RB
18637	17674	8	require	require	VB
18637	17674	9	any	any	DT
18637	17674	10	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	17674	11	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	17674	12	before	before	IN
18637	17674	13	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	17674	14	of	of	IN
18637	17674	15	a	a	DT
18637	17674	16	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	17674	17	for	for	IN
18637	17674	18	removal	removal	NN
18637	17674	19	of	of	IN
18637	17674	20	an	an	DT
18637	17674	21	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17674	22	to	to	IN
18637	17674	23	the	the	DT
18637	17674	24	court	court	NN
18637	17674	25	having	have	VBG
18637	17674	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	17674	27	of	of	IN
18637	17674	28	the	the	DT
18637	17674	29	charge	charge	NN
18637	17674	30	.	.	.
18637	17675	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17675	2	39	39	CD
18637	17675	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17675	4	The	the	DT
18637	17675	5	assignment	assignment	NN
18637	17675	6	of	of	IN
18637	17675	7	a	a	DT
18637	17675	8	district	district	NN
18637	17675	9	judge	judge	NN
18637	17675	10	from	from	IN
18637	17675	11	one	one	CD
18637	17675	12	district	district	NN
18637	17675	13	to	to	IN
18637	17675	14	another	another	DT
18637	17675	15	,	,	,
18637	17675	16	conformably	conformably	RB
18637	17675	17	to	to	TO
18637	17675	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	17675	19	,	,	,
18637	17675	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	17675	21	not	not	RB
18637	17675	22	create	create	VB
18637	17675	23	a	a	DT
18637	17675	24	new	new	JJ
18637	17675	25	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	17675	26	district	district	NN
18637	17675	27	whose	whose	WP$
18637	17675	28	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	17675	29	are	be	VBP
18637	17675	30	undefined	undefined	JJ
18637	17675	31	nor	nor	CC
18637	17675	32	subject	subject	JJ
18637	17675	33	the	the	DT
18637	17675	34	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17675	35	to	to	IN
18637	17675	36	trial	trial	NN
18637	17675	37	in	in	IN
18637	17675	38	a	a	DT
18637	17675	39	district	district	NN
18637	17675	40	not	not	RB
18637	17675	41	established	establish	VBN
18637	17675	42	when	when	WRB
18637	17675	43	the	the	DT
18637	17675	44	offense	offense	NN
18637	17675	45	with	with	IN
18637	17675	46	which	which	WDT
18637	17675	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17675	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	17675	49	charged	charge	VBN
18637	17675	50	was	be	VBD
18637	17675	51	committed	commit	VBN
18637	17675	52	.	.	.
18637	17676	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17676	2	40	40	CD
18637	17676	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17676	4	For	for	IN
18637	17676	5	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	17676	6	against	against	IN
18637	17676	7	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17676	8	laws	law	NNS
18637	17676	9	not	not	RB
18637	17676	10	committed	commit	VBN
18637	17676	11	within	within	IN
18637	17676	12	any	any	DT
18637	17676	13	State	State	NNP
18637	17676	14	,	,	,
18637	17676	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17676	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	17676	17	the	the	DT
18637	17676	18	sole	sole	JJ
18637	17676	19	power	power	NN
18637	17676	20	to	to	TO
18637	17676	21	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	17676	22	the	the	DT
18637	17676	23	place	place	NN
18637	17676	24	of	of	IN
18637	17676	25	trial	trial	NN
18637	17676	26	;	;	:
18637	17676	27	such	such	PDT
18637	17676	28	an	an	DT
18637	17676	29	offense	offense	NN
18637	17676	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	17676	31	not	not	RB
18637	17676	32	local	local	JJ
18637	17676	33	and	and	CC
18637	17676	34	may	may	MD
18637	17676	35	be	be	VB
18637	17676	36	tried	try	VBN
18637	17676	37	at	at	IN
18637	17676	38	such	such	JJ
18637	17676	39	place	place	NN
18637	17676	40	as	as	IN
18637	17676	41	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17676	42	may	may	MD
18637	17676	43	designate	designate	VB
18637	17676	44	.	.	.
18637	17677	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17677	2	41	41	CD
18637	17677	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17677	4	The	the	DT
18637	17677	5	place	place	NN
18637	17677	6	of	of	IN
18637	17677	7	trial	trial	NN
18637	17677	8	may	may	MD
18637	17677	9	be	be	VB
18637	17677	10	designated	designate	VBN
18637	17677	11	by	by	IN
18637	17677	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	17677	13	after	after	IN
18637	17677	14	the	the	DT
18637	17677	15	offense	offense	NN
18637	17677	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	17677	17	been	be	VBN
18637	17677	18	committed	commit	VBN
18637	17677	19	.	.	.
18637	17678	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17678	2	42	42	CD
18637	17678	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17678	4	Definition	Definition	NNP
18637	17678	5	of	of	IN
18637	17678	6	Crime	Crime	NNP
18637	17678	7	The	the	DT
18637	17678	8	effect	effect	NN
18637	17678	9	of	of	IN
18637	17678	10	the	the	DT
18637	17678	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	17678	12	entitling	entitle	VBG
18637	17678	13	an	an	DT
18637	17678	14	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17678	15	to	to	TO
18637	17678	16	know	know	VB
18637	17678	17	the	the	DT
18637	17678	18	nature	nature	NN
18637	17678	19	and	and	CC
18637	17678	20	cause	cause	NN
18637	17678	21	of	of	IN
18637	17678	22	the	the	DT
18637	17678	23	accusation	accusation	NN
18637	17678	24	against	against	IN
18637	17678	25	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17678	26	commences	commence	VBZ
18637	17678	27	with	with	IN
18637	17678	28	the	the	DT
18637	17678	29	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	17678	30	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	17678	31	or	or	CC
18637	17678	32	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	17678	33	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	17678	34	.	.	.
18637	17679	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17679	2	adopts	adopt	VBZ
18637	17679	3	the	the	DT
18637	17679	4	general	general	JJ
18637	17679	5	rule	rule	NN
18637	17679	6	of	of	IN
18637	17679	7	the	the	DT
18637	17679	8	common	common	JJ
18637	17679	9	law	law	NN
18637	17679	10	that	that	IN
18637	17679	11	such	such	JJ
18637	17679	12	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	17679	13	are	be	VBP
18637	17679	14	not	not	RB
18637	17679	15	to	to	TO
18637	17679	16	be	be	VB
18637	17679	17	construed	construe	VBN
18637	17679	18	to	to	TO
18637	17679	19	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	17679	20	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	17679	21	which	which	WDT
18637	17679	22	are	be	VBP
18637	17679	23	not	not	RB
18637	17679	24	within	within	IN
18637	17679	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17679	26	intention	intention	NN
18637	17679	27	and	and	CC
18637	17679	28	terms	term	NNS
18637	17679	29	.	.	.
18637	17680	1	Under	under	IN
18637	17680	2	this	this	DT
18637	17680	3	clause	clause	NN
18637	17680	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17680	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	17680	6	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	17680	7	that	that	IN
18637	17680	8	a	a	DT
18637	17680	9	crime	crime	NN
18637	17680	10	"	"	``
18637	17680	11	be	be	VB
18637	17680	12	in	in	IN
18637	17680	13	some	some	DT
18637	17680	14	way	way	NN
18637	17680	15	declared	declare	VBN
18637	17680	16	by	by	IN
18637	17680	17	the	the	DT
18637	17680	18	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	17680	19	power	power	NN
18637	17680	20	"	"	''
18637	17680	21	;	;	:
18637	17680	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17680	23	"	"	``
18637	17680	24	can	can	MD
18637	17680	25	not	not	RB
18637	17680	26	be	be	VB
18637	17680	27	constructed	construct	VBN
18637	17680	28	by	by	IN
18637	17680	29	the	the	DT
18637	17680	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	17680	31	from	from	IN
18637	17680	32	any	any	DT
18637	17680	33	supposed	suppose	VBN
18637	17680	34	intention	intention	NN
18637	17680	35	of	of	IN
18637	17680	36	the	the	DT
18637	17680	37	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	17680	38	which	which	WDT
18637	17680	39	the	the	DT
18637	17680	40	statute	statute	NN
18637	17680	41	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	17680	42	to	to	IN
18637	17680	43	state	state	NN
18637	17680	44	.	.	.
18637	17681	1	"	"	``
18637	17681	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17681	3	43	43	CD
18637	17681	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17681	5	A	a	DT
18637	17681	6	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	17681	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	17681	8	which	which	WDT
18637	17681	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	17681	10	so	so	RB
18637	17681	11	vague	vague	JJ
18637	17681	12	that	that	IN
18637	17681	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17681	14	leaves	leave	VBZ
18637	17681	15	the	the	DT
18637	17681	16	standard	standard	NN
18637	17681	17	of	of	IN
18637	17681	18	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	17681	19	to	to	IN
18637	17681	20	the	the	DT
18637	17681	21	"	"	``
18637	17681	22	variant	variant	JJ
18637	17681	23	views	view	NNS
18637	17681	24	of	of	IN
18637	17681	25	the	the	DT
18637	17681	26	different	different	JJ
18637	17681	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	17681	28	and	and	CC
18637	17681	29	juries	jury	NNS
18637	17681	30	which	which	WDT
18637	17681	31	may	may	MD
18637	17681	32	be	be	VB
18637	17681	33	called	call	VBN
18637	17681	34	on	on	RP
18637	17681	35	to	to	TO
18637	17681	36	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	17681	37	it"[44	it"[44	NNS
18637	17681	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17681	39	can	can	MD
18637	17681	40	not	not	RB
18637	17681	41	be	be	VB
18637	17681	42	squared	square	VBN
18637	17681	43	with	with	IN
18637	17681	44	this	this	DT
18637	17681	45	provision	provision	NN
18637	17681	46	.	.	.
18637	17682	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	17682	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17682	3	was	be	VBD
18637	17682	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	17682	5	,	,	,
18637	17682	6	in	in	IN
18637	17682	7	the	the	DT
18637	17682	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17682	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17682	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17682	11	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
18637	17682	12	Grocery	Grocery	NNP
18637	17682	13	Co	Co	NNP
18637	17682	14	.	.	NNP
18637	17682	15	,[45	,[45	NFP
18637	17682	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17682	17	that	that	IN
18637	17682	18	a	a	DT
18637	17682	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	17682	20	making	make	VBG
18637	17682	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17682	22	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	17682	23	"	"	''
18637	17682	24	for	for	IN
18637	17682	25	any	any	DT
18637	17682	26	person	person	NN
18637	17682	27	willfully	willfully	RB
18637	17682	28	*	*	NFP
18637	17682	29	*	*	NFP
18637	17682	30	*	*	NFP
18637	17682	31	to	to	TO
18637	17682	32	make	make	VB
18637	17682	33	any	any	DT
18637	17682	34	unjust	unjust	JJ
18637	17682	35	or	or	CC
18637	17682	36	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	17682	37	rate	rate	NN
18637	17682	38	or	or	CC
18637	17682	39	charge	charge	NN
18637	17682	40	in	in	IN
18637	17682	41	handling	handling	NN
18637	17682	42	or	or	CC
18637	17682	43	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	17682	44	in	in	RB
18637	17682	45	or	or	CC
18637	17682	46	with	with	IN
18637	17682	47	any	any	DT
18637	17682	48	necessaries	necessary	NNS
18637	17682	49	"	"	``
18637	17682	50	was	be	VBD
18637	17682	51	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	17682	52	because	because	IN
18637	17682	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17682	54	was	be	VBD
18637	17682	55	not	not	RB
18637	17682	56	"	"	``
18637	17682	57	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	17682	58	to	to	TO
18637	17682	59	inform	inform	VB
18637	17682	60	persons	person	NNS
18637	17682	61	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17682	62	of	of	IN
18637	17682	63	violation	violation	NN
18637	17682	64	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	17682	65	of	of	IN
18637	17682	66	the	the	DT
18637	17682	67	nature	nature	NN
18637	17682	68	and	and	CC
18637	17682	69	cause	cause	NN
18637	17682	70	of	of	IN
18637	17682	71	the	the	DT
18637	17682	72	accusation	accusation	NN
18637	17682	73	against	against	IN
18637	17682	74	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17682	75	.	.	.
18637	17683	1	"	"	``
18637	17683	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17683	3	46	46	CD
18637	17683	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17683	5	But	but	CC
18637	17683	6	a	a	DT
18637	17683	7	provision	provision	NN
18637	17683	8	of	of	IN
18637	17683	9	the	the	DT
18637	17683	10	Immigration	Immigration	NNP
18637	17683	11	Act[47	Act[47	NFP
18637	17683	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17683	13	which	which	WDT
18637	17683	14	makes	make	VBZ
18637	17683	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17683	16	a	a	DT
18637	17683	17	felony	felony	NN
18637	17683	18	for	for	IN
18637	17683	19	an	an	DT
18637	17683	20	alien	alien	NN
18637	17683	21	against	against	IN
18637	17683	22	whom	whom	WP
18637	17683	23	a	a	DT
18637	17683	24	specified	specify	VBN
18637	17683	25	order	order	NN
18637	17683	26	of	of	IN
18637	17683	27	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	17683	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	17683	29	pending	pende	VBG
18637	17683	30	to	to	TO
18637	17683	31	"	"	``
18637	17683	32	willfully	willfully	RB
18637	17683	33	fail	fail	VB
18637	17683	34	or	or	CC
18637	17683	35	refuse	refuse	VBP
18637	17683	36	to	to	TO
18637	17683	37	make	make	VB
18637	17683	38	timely	timely	JJ
18637	17683	39	application	application	NN
18637	17683	40	in	in	IN
18637	17683	41	good	good	JJ
18637	17683	42	faith	faith	NN
18637	17683	43	for	for	IN
18637	17683	44	travel	travel	NN
18637	17683	45	or	or	CC
18637	17683	46	other	other	JJ
18637	17683	47	documents	document	NNS
18637	17683	48	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	17683	49	to	to	IN
18637	17683	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17683	51	departure	departure	NN
18637	17683	52	"	"	``
18637	17683	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	17683	54	not	not	RB
18637	17683	55	,	,	,
18637	17683	56	on	on	IN
18637	17683	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17683	58	face	face	NN
18637	17683	59	,	,	,
18637	17683	60	void	void	VB
18637	17683	61	for	for	IN
18637	17683	62	indefiniteness	indefiniteness	NN
18637	17683	63	.	.	.
18637	17684	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17684	2	48	48	CD
18637	17684	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17684	4	An	an	DT
18637	17684	5	important	important	JJ
18637	17684	6	aspect	aspect	NN
18637	17684	7	of	of	IN
18637	17684	8	this	this	DT
18637	17684	9	problem	problem	NN
18637	17684	10	was	be	VBD
18637	17684	11	presented	present	VBN
18637	17684	12	,	,	,
18637	17684	13	but	but	CC
18637	17684	14	not	not	RB
18637	17684	15	definitely	definitely	RB
18637	17684	16	settled	settle	VBN
18637	17684	17	,	,	,
18637	17684	18	in	in	IN
18637	17684	19	Screws	Screws	NNP
18637	17684	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17684	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	17684	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17684	23	United	United	NNP
18637	17684	24	States	States	NNP
18637	17684	25	.	.	.
18637	17685	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17685	2	49	49	CD
18637	17685	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17685	4	There	there	EX
18637	17685	5	State	state	NN
18637	17685	6	law	law	NN
18637	17685	7	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	17685	8	officers	officer	NNS
18637	17685	9	had	have	VBD
18637	17685	10	been	be	VBN
18637	17685	11	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	17685	12	of	of	IN
18637	17685	13	violating	violate	VBG
18637	17685	14	a	a	DT
18637	17685	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17685	16	law	law	NN
18637	17685	17	making	make	VBG
18637	17685	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17685	19	a	a	DT
18637	17685	20	crime	crime	NN
18637	17685	21	for	for	IN
18637	17685	22	anyone	anyone	NN
18637	17685	23	acting	act	VBG
18637	17685	24	under	under	IN
18637	17685	25	color	color	NN
18637	17685	26	of	of	IN
18637	17685	27	any	any	DT
18637	17685	28	law	law	NN
18637	17685	29	willfully	willfully	RB
18637	17685	30	to	to	TO
18637	17685	31	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	17685	32	anyone	anyone	NN
18637	17685	33	of	of	IN
18637	17685	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	17685	35	secured	secure	VBN
18637	17685	36	by	by	IN
18637	17685	37	the	the	DT
18637	17685	38	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	17685	39	of	of	IN
18637	17685	40	the	the	DT
18637	17685	41	United	United	NNP
18637	17685	42	States	States	NNP
18637	17685	43	.	.	.
18637	17686	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17686	2	50	50	CD
18637	17686	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17686	4	The	the	DT
18637	17686	5	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	17686	6	charged	charge	VBD
18637	17686	7	that	that	IN
18637	17686	8	in	in	IN
18637	17686	9	beating	beat	VBG
18637	17686	10	to	to	IN
18637	17686	11	death	death	NN
18637	17686	12	a	a	DT
18637	17686	13	man	man	NN
18637	17686	14	whom	whom	WP
18637	17686	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17686	16	had	have	VBD
18637	17686	17	just	just	RB
18637	17686	18	arrested	arrest	VBN
18637	17686	19	,	,	,
18637	17686	20	these	these	DT
18637	17686	21	officers	officer	NNS
18637	17686	22	had	have	VBD
18637	17686	23	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	17686	24	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17686	25	of	of	IN
18637	17686	26	life	life	NN
18637	17686	27	without	without	IN
18637	17686	28	due	due	JJ
18637	17686	29	process	process	NN
18637	17686	30	of	of	IN
18637	17686	31	law	law	NN
18637	17686	32	.	.	.
18637	17687	1	The	the	DT
18637	17687	2	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17687	3	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	17687	4	that	that	IN
18637	17687	5	the	the	DT
18637	17687	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	17687	7	was	be	VBD
18637	17687	8	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	17687	9	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	17687	10	as	as	IN
18637	17687	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17687	12	made	make	VBD
18637	17687	13	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	17687	14	acts	act	NNS
18637	17687	15	in	in	IN
18637	17687	16	violation	violation	NN
18637	17687	17	of	of	IN
18637	17687	18	the	the	DT
18637	17687	19	due	due	JJ
18637	17687	20	process	process	NN
18637	17687	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	17687	22	,	,	,
18637	17687	23	because	because	IN
18637	17687	24	that	that	DT
18637	17687	25	concept	concept	NN
18637	17687	26	was	be	VBD
18637	17687	27	too	too	RB
18637	17687	28	vague	vague	JJ
18637	17687	29	to	to	TO
18637	17687	30	supply	supply	VB
18637	17687	31	an	an	DT
18637	17687	32	ascertainable	ascertainable	JJ
18637	17687	33	standard	standard	NN
18637	17687	34	of	of	IN
18637	17687	35	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	17687	36	.	.	.
18637	17688	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17688	2	51	51	CD
18637	17688	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17688	4	Four	four	CD
18637	17688	5	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	17688	6	were	be	VBD
18637	17688	7	written	write	VBN
18637	17688	8	in	in	IN
18637	17688	9	the	the	DT
18637	17688	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	17688	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17688	12	,	,	,
18637	17688	13	no	no	DT
18637	17688	14	one	one	NN
18637	17688	15	of	of	IN
18637	17688	16	which	which	WDT
18637	17688	17	obtained	obtain	VBD
18637	17688	18	the	the	DT
18637	17688	19	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	17688	20	of	of	IN
18637	17688	21	a	a	DT
18637	17688	22	majority	majority	NN
18637	17688	23	of	of	IN
18637	17688	24	the	the	DT
18637	17688	25	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	17688	26	.	.	.
18637	17689	1	To	to	TO
18637	17689	2	"	"	``
18637	17689	3	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	17689	4	grave	grave	JJ
18637	17689	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17689	6	questions	question	NNS
18637	17689	7	"	"	``
18637	17689	8	four	four	CD
18637	17689	9	members	member	NNS
18637	17689	10	construed	construe	VBD
18637	17689	11	the	the	DT
18637	17689	12	word	word	NN
18637	17689	13	"	"	``
18637	17689	14	willfully	willfully	RB
18637	17689	15	"	"	''
18637	17689	16	as	as	IN
18637	17689	17	"	"	``
18637	17689	18	connoting	connote	VBG
18637	17689	19	a	a	DT
18637	17689	20	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	17689	21	to	to	TO
18637	17689	22	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	17689	23	a	a	DT
18637	17689	24	person	person	NN
18637	17689	25	of	of	IN
18637	17689	26	a	a	DT
18637	17689	27	specific	specific	JJ
18637	17689	28	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17689	29	right,"[52	right,"[52	NN
18637	17689	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17689	31	and	and	CC
18637	17689	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	17689	33	that	that	IN
18637	17689	34	such	such	JJ
18637	17689	35	"	"	``
18637	17689	36	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	17689	37	of	of	IN
18637	17689	38	a	a	DT
18637	17689	39	specific	specific	JJ
18637	17689	40	intent	intent	NN
18637	17689	41	to	to	TO
18637	17689	42	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	17689	43	a	a	DT
18637	17689	44	person	person	NN
18637	17689	45	of	of	IN
18637	17689	46	a	a	DT
18637	17689	47	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17689	48	right	right	NN
18637	17689	49	made	make	VBN
18637	17689	50	definite	definite	JJ
18637	17689	51	by	by	IN
18637	17689	52	decision	decision	NN
18637	17689	53	or	or	CC
18637	17689	54	other	other	JJ
18637	17689	55	rule	rule	NN
18637	17689	56	of	of	IN
18637	17689	57	law	law	NN
18637	17689	58	saves	save	VBZ
18637	17689	59	the	the	DT
18637	17689	60	Act	act	NN
18637	17689	61	from	from	IN
18637	17689	62	any	any	DT
18637	17689	63	charge	charge	NN
18637	17689	64	of	of	IN
18637	17689	65	unconstitutionality	unconstitutionality	NN
18637	17689	66	on	on	IN
18637	17689	67	the	the	DT
18637	17689	68	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	17689	69	of	of	IN
18637	17689	70	vagueness	vagueness	NN
18637	17689	71	.	.	.
18637	17690	1	"	"	``
18637	17690	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17690	3	53	53	CD
18637	17690	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17690	5	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	17690	6	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	17690	7	and	and	CC
18637	17690	8	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	17690	9	considered	consider	VBD
18637	17690	10	the	the	DT
18637	17690	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	17690	12	to	to	TO
18637	17690	13	be	be	VB
18637	17690	14	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	17690	15	definite	definite	JJ
18637	17690	16	with	with	IN
18637	17690	17	respect	respect	NN
18637	17690	18	to	to	IN
18637	17690	19	the	the	DT
18637	17690	20	offense	offense	NN
18637	17690	21	charged	charge	VBN
18637	17690	22	and	and	CC
18637	17690	23	thought	think	VBD
18637	17690	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17690	25	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	17690	26	to	to	TO
18637	17690	27	anticipate	anticipate	VB
18637	17690	28	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	17690	29	that	that	WDT
18637	17690	30	might	may	MD
18637	17690	31	arise	arise	VB
18637	17690	32	in	in	IN
18637	17690	33	other	other	JJ
18637	17690	34	cases	case	NNS
18637	17690	35	.	.	.
18637	17691	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17691	2	54	54	CD
18637	17691	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17691	4	However	however	RB
18637	17691	5	,	,	,
18637	17691	6	to	to	TO
18637	17691	7	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	17691	8	a	a	DT
18637	17691	9	stalemate	stalemate	NN
18637	17691	10	,	,	,
18637	17691	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	17691	12	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	17691	13	voted	vote	VBD
18637	17691	14	with	with	IN
18637	17691	15	the	the	DT
18637	17691	16	four	four	CD
18637	17691	17	members	member	NNS
18637	17691	18	who	who	WP
18637	17691	19	believed	believe	VBD
18637	17691	20	the	the	DT
18637	17691	21	case	case	NN
18637	17691	22	should	should	MD
18637	17691	23	be	be	VB
18637	17691	24	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	17691	25	to	to	TO
18637	17691	26	be	be	VB
18637	17691	27	tried	try	VBN
18637	17691	28	again	again	RB
18637	17691	29	on	on	IN
18637	17691	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17691	31	narrower	narrow	JJR
18637	17691	32	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	17691	33	of	of	IN
18637	17691	34	the	the	DT
18637	17691	35	statute	statute	NN
18637	17691	36	.	.	.
18637	17692	1	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	17692	2	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	17692	3	,	,	,
18637	17692	4	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	17692	5	and	and	CC
18637	17692	6	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	17692	7	found	find	VBD
18637	17692	8	the	the	DT
18637	17692	9	act	act	NN
18637	17692	10	too	too	RB
18637	17692	11	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	17692	12	to	to	TO
18637	17692	13	be	be	VB
18637	17692	14	rescued	rescue	VBN
18637	17692	15	by	by	IN
18637	17692	16	a	a	DT
18637	17692	17	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	17692	18	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	17692	19	.	.	.
18637	17693	1	With	with	IN
18637	17693	2	respect	respect	NN
18637	17693	3	to	to	IN
18637	17693	4	the	the	DT
18637	17693	5	effect	effect	NN
18637	17693	6	of	of	IN
18637	17693	7	the	the	DT
18637	17693	8	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	17693	9	of	of	IN
18637	17693	10	willfulness	willfulness	NN
18637	17693	11	,	,	,
18637	17693	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17693	13	said	say	VBD
18637	17693	14	:	:	:
18637	17693	15	"	"	``
18637	17693	16	If	if	IN
18637	17693	17	a	a	DT
18637	17693	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	17693	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	17693	20	not	not	RB
18637	17693	21	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	17693	22	the	the	DT
18637	17693	23	due	due	JJ
18637	17693	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	17693	25	process	process	NN
18637	17693	26	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	17693	27	of	of	IN
18637	17693	28	giving	give	VBG
18637	17693	29	decent	decent	JJ
18637	17693	30	advance	advance	NN
18637	17693	31	notice	notice	NN
18637	17693	32	of	of	IN
18637	17693	33	what	what	WP
18637	17693	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17693	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	17693	36	which	which	WDT
18637	17693	37	,	,	,
18637	17693	38	if	if	IN
18637	17693	39	happening	happen	VBG
18637	17693	40	,	,	,
18637	17693	41	will	will	MD
18637	17693	42	be	be	VB
18637	17693	43	visited	visit	VBN
18637	17693	44	with	with	IN
18637	17693	45	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	17693	46	,	,	,
18637	17693	47	so	so	IN
18637	17693	48	that	that	IN
18637	17693	49	men	man	NNS
18637	17693	50	may	may	MD
18637	17693	51	presumably	presumably	RB
18637	17693	52	have	have	VB
18637	17693	53	an	an	DT
18637	17693	54	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	17693	55	to	to	TO
18637	17693	56	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	17693	57	the	the	DT
18637	17693	58	happening	happening	NN
18637	17693	59	*	*	NFP
18637	17693	60	*	*	NFP
18637	17693	61	*	*	NFP
18637	17693	62	,	,	,
18637	17693	63	then	then	RB
18637	17693	64	'	'	``
18637	17693	65	willfully	willfully	RB
18637	17693	66	'	'	''
18637	17693	67	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	17693	68	to	to	TO
18637	17693	69	pass	pass	VB
18637	17693	70	such	such	PDT
18637	17693	71	an	an	DT
18637	17693	72	undefined	undefined	JJ
18637	17693	73	and	and	CC
18637	17693	74	too	too	RB
18637	17693	75	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
18637	17693	76	event	event	NN
18637	17693	77	can	can	MD
18637	17693	78	not	not	RB
18637	17693	79	make	make	VB
18637	17693	80	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17693	81	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	17693	82	definite	definite	JJ
18637	17693	83	and	and	CC
18637	17693	84	ascertainable	ascertainable	JJ
18637	17693	85	.	.	.
18637	17694	1	'	'	``
18637	17694	2	Willfully	willfully	RB
18637	17694	3	'	'	''
18637	17694	4	doing	do	VBG
18637	17694	5	something	something	NN
18637	17694	6	that	that	WDT
18637	17694	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	17694	8	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	17694	9	,	,	,
18637	17694	10	when	when	WRB
18637	17694	11	that	that	IN
18637	17694	12	something	something	NN
18637	17694	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	17694	14	not	not	RB
18637	17694	15	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	17694	16	defined	define	VBN
18637	17694	17	according	accord	VBG
18637	17694	18	to	to	IN
18637	17694	19	the	the	DT
18637	17694	20	general	general	JJ
18637	17694	21	conceptions	conception	NNS
18637	17694	22	of	of	IN
18637	17694	23	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	17694	24	certainty	certainty	NN
18637	17694	25	in	in	IN
18637	17694	26	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17694	27	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	17694	28	law	law	NN
18637	17694	29	,	,	,
18637	17694	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	17694	31	not	not	RB
18637	17694	32	rendered	render	VBN
18637	17694	33	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	17694	34	definite	definite	JJ
18637	17694	35	by	by	IN
18637	17694	36	that	that	DT
18637	17694	37	unknowable	unknowable	NN
18637	17694	38	having	have	VBG
18637	17694	39	been	be	VBN
18637	17694	40	done	do	VBN
18637	17694	41	'	'	''
18637	17694	42	willfully	willfully	RB
18637	17694	43	.	.	.
18637	17694	44	'	'	''
18637	17695	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17695	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	17695	3	true	true	JJ
18637	17695	4	also	also	RB
18637	17695	5	of	of	IN
18637	17695	6	a	a	DT
18637	17695	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	17695	8	that	that	IN
18637	17695	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17695	10	can	can	MD
18637	17695	11	not	not	RB
18637	17695	12	lift	lift	VB
18637	17695	13	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17695	14	up	up	RP
18637	17695	15	by	by	IN
18637	17695	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17695	17	bootstraps	bootstrap	NNS
18637	17695	18	.	.	.
18637	17696	1	"	"	``
18637	17696	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17696	3	55	55	CD
18637	17696	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17696	5	In	in	IN
18637	17696	6	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	17696	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17696	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17696	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17696	10	United	United	NNP
18637	17696	11	States,[56	States,[56	NNP
18637	17696	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17696	13	however	however	RB
18637	17696	14	,	,	,
18637	17696	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17696	16	was	be	VBD
18637	17696	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	17696	18	by	by	IN
18637	17696	19	a	a	DT
18637	17696	20	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	17696	21	divided	divide	VBN
18637	17696	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17696	23	that	that	IN
18637	17696	24	§	§	NNP
18637	17696	25	20	20	CD
18637	17696	26	did	do	VBD
18637	17696	27	not	not	RB
18637	17696	28	err	err	VB
18637	17696	29	for	for	IN
18637	17696	30	vagueness	vagueness	NN
18637	17696	31	where	where	WRB
18637	17696	32	the	the	DT
18637	17696	33	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	17696	34	made	make	VBD
18637	17696	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17696	36	clear	clear	JJ
18637	17696	37	that	that	IN
18637	17696	38	the	the	DT
18637	17696	39	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17696	40	right	right	NN
18637	17696	41	violated	violate	VBN
18637	17696	42	by	by	IN
18637	17696	43	the	the	DT
18637	17696	44	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17696	45	was	be	VBD
18637	17696	46	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	17696	47	from	from	IN
18637	17696	48	the	the	DT
18637	17696	49	use	use	NN
18637	17696	50	of	of	IN
18637	17696	51	force	force	NN
18637	17696	52	and	and	CC
18637	17696	53	violence	violence	NN
18637	17696	54	to	to	TO
18637	17696	55	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	17696	56	a	a	DT
18637	17696	57	confession	confession	NN
18637	17696	58	,	,	,
18637	17696	59	and	and	CC
18637	17696	60	this	this	DT
18637	17696	61	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	17696	62	was	be	VBD
18637	17696	63	also	also	RB
18637	17696	64	made	make	VBN
18637	17696	65	clear	clear	JJ
18637	17696	66	by	by	IN
18637	17696	67	the	the	DT
18637	17696	68	trial	trial	NN
18637	17696	69	judge	judge	NN
18637	17696	70	's	's	POS
18637	17696	71	charge	charge	NN
18637	17696	72	to	to	IN
18637	17696	73	the	the	DT
18637	17696	74	jury	jury	NN
18637	17696	75	.	.	.
18637	17697	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17697	2	57	57	CD
18637	17697	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17697	4	Statutes	statute	NNS
18637	17697	5	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	17697	6	the	the	DT
18637	17697	7	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	17697	8	of	of	IN
18637	17697	9	employers	employer	NNS
18637	17697	10	to	to	TO
18637	17697	11	hire	hire	VB
18637	17697	12	unneeded	unneeded	JJ
18637	17697	13	employees,[58	employees,[58	.
18637	17697	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17697	15	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	17697	16	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	17697	17	wages	wage	NNS
18637	17697	18	and	and	CC
18637	17697	19	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	17697	20	hours	hour	NNS
18637	17697	21	of	of	IN
18637	17697	22	service	service	NN
18637	17697	23	for	for	IN
18637	17697	24	persons	person	NNS
18637	17697	25	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	17697	26	in	in	IN
18637	17697	27	the	the	DT
18637	17697	28	production	production	NN
18637	17697	29	of	of	IN
18637	17697	30	goods	good	NNS
18637	17697	31	for	for	IN
18637	17697	32	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	17697	33	commerce,[59	commerce,[59	SYM
18637	17697	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17697	35	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	17697	36	undue	undue	JJ
18637	17697	37	or	or	CC
18637	17697	38	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	17697	39	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	17697	40	of	of	IN
18637	17697	41	trade,[60	trade,[60	CD
18637	17697	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17697	43	making	make	VBG
18637	17697	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17697	45	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	17697	46	to	to	TO
18637	17697	47	build	build	VB
18637	17697	48	fires	fire	NNS
18637	17697	49	near	near	IN
18637	17697	50	any	any	DT
18637	17697	51	forest	forest	NN
18637	17697	52	or	or	CC
18637	17697	53	inflammable	inflammable	JJ
18637	17697	54	material,[61	material,[61	NNP
18637	17697	55	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17697	56	banning	ban	VBG
18637	17697	57	the	the	DT
18637	17697	58	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	17697	59	of	of	IN
18637	17697	60	contributions	contribution	NNS
18637	17697	61	by	by	IN
18637	17697	62	members	member	NNS
18637	17697	63	of	of	IN
18637	17697	64	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17697	65	from	from	IN
18637	17697	66	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17697	67	employees	employee	NNS
18637	17697	68	for	for	IN
18637	17697	69	any	any	DT
18637	17697	70	political	political	JJ
18637	17697	71	purpose,[62	purpose,[62	NN
18637	17697	72	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17697	73	or	or	CC
18637	17697	74	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	17697	75	the	the	DT
18637	17697	76	copying	copying	NN
18637	17697	77	or	or	CC
18637	17697	78	taking	taking	NN
18637	17697	79	of	of	IN
18637	17697	80	documents	document	NNS
18637	17697	81	connected	connect	VBN
18637	17697	82	with	with	IN
18637	17697	83	the	the	DT
18637	17697	84	national	national	JJ
18637	17697	85	defense	defense	NN
18637	17697	86	,	,	,
18637	17697	87	with	with	IN
18637	17697	88	intent	intent	NN
18637	17697	89	,	,	,
18637	17697	90	or	or	CC
18637	17697	91	reason	reason	NN
18637	17697	92	to	to	TO
18637	17697	93	believe	believe	VB
18637	17697	94	that	that	IN
18637	17697	95	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17697	96	are	be	VBP
18637	17697	97	to	to	TO
18637	17697	98	be	be	VB
18637	17697	99	used	use	VBN
18637	17697	100	to	to	IN
18637	17697	101	the	the	DT
18637	17697	102	injury	injury	NN
18637	17697	103	of	of	IN
18637	17697	104	the	the	DT
18637	17697	105	United	United	NNP
18637	17697	106	States	States	NNP
18637	17697	107	or	or	CC
18637	17697	108	to	to	IN
18637	17697	109	the	the	DT
18637	17697	110	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	17697	111	of	of	IN
18637	17697	112	a	a	DT
18637	17697	113	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	17697	114	nation,[63	nation,[63	NNP
18637	17697	115	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17697	116	have	have	VBP
18637	17697	117	been	be	VBN
18637	17697	118	held	hold	VBN
18637	17697	119	to	to	TO
18637	17697	120	be	be	VB
18637	17697	121	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	17697	122	definite	definite	JJ
18637	17697	123	to	to	TO
18637	17697	124	be	be	VB
18637	17697	125	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17697	126	.	.	.
18637	17698	1	A	a	DT
18637	17698	2	provision	provision	NN
18637	17698	3	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	17698	4	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	17698	5	charges	charge	NNS
18637	17698	6	in	in	IN
18637	17698	7	connection	connection	NN
18637	17698	8	with	with	IN
18637	17698	9	loans	loan	NNS
18637	17698	10	from	from	IN
18637	17698	11	the	the	DT
18637	17698	12	Home	Home	NNP
18637	17698	13	Owners	Owners	NNP
18637	17698	14	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	17698	15	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	17698	16	was	be	VBD
18637	17698	17	not	not	RB
18637	17698	18	rendered	render	VBN
18637	17698	19	indefinite	indefinite	RB
18637	17698	20	by	by	IN
18637	17698	21	the	the	DT
18637	17698	22	exception	exception	NN
18637	17698	23	of	of	IN
18637	17698	24	"	"	``
18637	17698	25	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	17698	26	fees	fee	NNS
18637	17698	27	for	for	IN
18637	17698	28	services	service	NNS
18637	17698	29	actually	actually	RB
18637	17698	30	rendered,"[64	rendered,"[64	NNP
18637	17698	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17698	32	nor	nor	CC
18637	17698	33	was	be	VBD
18637	17698	34	a	a	DT
18637	17698	35	statute	statute	NN
18637	17698	36	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	17698	37	misstatement	misstatement	NN
18637	17698	38	of	of	IN
18637	17698	39	the	the	DT
18637	17698	40	quantity	quantity	NN
18637	17698	41	of	of	IN
18637	17698	42	the	the	DT
18637	17698	43	contents	content	NNS
18637	17698	44	of	of	IN
18637	17698	45	a	a	DT
18637	17698	46	package	package	NN
18637	17698	47	wanting	want	VBG
18637	17698	48	in	in	IN
18637	17698	49	certainty	certainty	NN
18637	17698	50	by	by	IN
18637	17698	51	reason	reason	NN
18637	17698	52	of	of	IN
18637	17698	53	a	a	DT
18637	17698	54	proviso	proviso	NN
18637	17698	55	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	17698	56	"	"	``
18637	17698	57	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	17698	58	variations	variation	NNS
18637	17698	59	.	.	.
18637	17699	1	"	"	``
18637	17699	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17699	3	65	65	CD
18637	17699	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17699	5	The	the	DT
18637	17699	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17699	7	right	right	NN
18637	17699	8	to	to	TO
18637	17699	9	be	be	VB
18637	17699	10	informed	inform	VBN
18637	17699	11	of	of	IN
18637	17699	12	the	the	DT
18637	17699	13	nature	nature	NN
18637	17699	14	and	and	CC
18637	17699	15	cause	cause	NN
18637	17699	16	of	of	IN
18637	17699	17	the	the	DT
18637	17699	18	accusation	accusation	NN
18637	17699	19	entitles	entitle	VBZ
18637	17699	20	the	the	DT
18637	17699	21	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17699	22	to	to	TO
18637	17699	23	insist	insist	VB
18637	17699	24	that	that	IN
18637	17699	25	the	the	DT
18637	17699	26	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	17699	27	apprise	apprise	VB
18637	17699	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17699	29	of	of	IN
18637	17699	30	the	the	DT
18637	17699	31	crime	crime	NN
18637	17699	32	charged	charge	VBN
18637	17699	33	with	with	IN
18637	17699	34	such	such	JJ
18637	17699	35	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	17699	36	certainty	certainty	NN
18637	17699	37	that	that	IN
18637	17699	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17699	39	can	can	MD
18637	17699	40	make	make	VB
18637	17699	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17699	42	defense	defense	NN
18637	17699	43	and	and	CC
18637	17699	44	protect	protect	VB
18637	17699	45	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17699	46	after	after	IN
18637	17699	47	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	17699	48	against	against	IN
18637	17699	49	another	another	DT
18637	17699	50	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	17699	51	on	on	IN
18637	17699	52	the	the	DT
18637	17699	53	same	same	JJ
18637	17699	54	charge	charge	NN
18637	17699	55	.	.	.
18637	17700	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17700	2	66	66	CD
18637	17700	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17700	4	No	no	DT
18637	17700	5	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	17700	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	17700	7	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	17700	8	if	if	IN
18637	17700	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17700	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	17700	11	not	not	RB
18637	17700	12	allege	allege	VB
18637	17700	13	all	all	DT
18637	17700	14	of	of	IN
18637	17700	15	the	the	DT
18637	17700	16	ingredients	ingredient	NNS
18637	17700	17	which	which	WDT
18637	17700	18	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	17700	19	the	the	DT
18637	17700	20	crime	crime	NN
18637	17700	21	.	.	.
18637	17701	1	Where	where	WRB
18637	17701	2	the	the	DT
18637	17701	3	language	language	NN
18637	17701	4	of	of	IN
18637	17701	5	a	a	DT
18637	17701	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	17701	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	17701	8	,	,	,
18637	17701	9	according	accord	VBG
18637	17701	10	to	to	IN
18637	17701	11	the	the	DT
18637	17701	12	natural	natural	JJ
18637	17701	13	import	import	NN
18637	17701	14	of	of	IN
18637	17701	15	the	the	DT
18637	17701	16	words	word	NNS
18637	17701	17	,	,	,
18637	17701	18	fully	fully	RB
18637	17701	19	descriptive	descriptive	JJ
18637	17701	20	of	of	IN
18637	17701	21	the	the	DT
18637	17701	22	offense	offense	NN
18637	17701	23	,	,	,
18637	17701	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17701	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	17701	26	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	17701	27	if	if	IN
18637	17701	28	the	the	DT
18637	17701	29	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	17701	30	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	17701	31	the	the	DT
18637	17701	32	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	17701	33	phraseology;[67	phraseology;[67	NNP
18637	17701	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17701	35	but	but	CC
18637	17701	36	where	where	WRB
18637	17701	37	the	the	DT
18637	17701	38	elements	element	NNS
18637	17701	39	of	of	IN
18637	17701	40	the	the	DT
18637	17701	41	crime	crime	NN
18637	17701	42	have	have	VBP
18637	17701	43	to	to	TO
18637	17701	44	be	be	VB
18637	17701	45	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	17701	46	by	by	IN
18637	17701	47	reference	reference	NN
18637	17701	48	to	to	IN
18637	17701	49	the	the	DT
18637	17701	50	common	common	JJ
18637	17701	51	law	law	NN
18637	17701	52	or	or	CC
18637	17701	53	to	to	IN
18637	17701	54	other	other	JJ
18637	17701	55	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	17701	56	,	,	,
18637	17701	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17701	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	17701	59	not	not	RB
18637	17701	60	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	17701	61	to	to	TO
18637	17701	62	set	set	VB
18637	17701	63	forth	forth	RP
18637	17701	64	the	the	DT
18637	17701	65	offense	offense	NN
18637	17701	66	in	in	IN
18637	17701	67	the	the	DT
18637	17701	68	words	word	NNS
18637	17701	69	of	of	IN
18637	17701	70	the	the	DT
18637	17701	71	statute	statute	NN
18637	17701	72	;	;	:
18637	17701	73	the	the	DT
18637	17701	74	facts	fact	NNS
18637	17701	75	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	17701	76	to	to	TO
18637	17701	77	bring	bring	VB
18637	17701	78	the	the	DT
18637	17701	79	case	case	NN
18637	17701	80	within	within	IN
18637	17701	81	the	the	DT
18637	17701	82	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	17701	83	definition	definition	NN
18637	17701	84	must	must	MD
18637	17701	85	also	also	RB
18637	17701	86	be	be	VB
18637	17701	87	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	17701	88	.	.	.
18637	17702	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17702	2	68	68	CD
18637	17702	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17702	4	If	if	IN
18637	17702	5	an	an	DT
18637	17702	6	offense	offense	NN
18637	17702	7	can	can	MD
18637	17702	8	not	not	RB
18637	17702	9	be	be	VB
18637	17702	10	accurately	accurately	RB
18637	17702	11	and	and	CC
18637	17702	12	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	17702	13	described	describe	VBN
18637	17702	14	without	without	IN
18637	17702	15	an	an	DT
18637	17702	16	allegation	allegation	NN
18637	17702	17	that	that	IN
18637	17702	18	the	the	DT
18637	17702	19	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17702	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	17702	21	not	not	RB
18637	17702	22	within	within	IN
18637	17702	23	an	an	DT
18637	17702	24	exception	exception	NN
18637	17702	25	contained	contain	VBN
18637	17702	26	in	in	IN
18637	17702	27	the	the	DT
18637	17702	28	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	17702	29	,	,	,
18637	17702	30	an	an	DT
18637	17702	31	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	17702	32	which	which	WDT
18637	17702	33	does	do	VBZ
18637	17702	34	not	not	RB
18637	17702	35	contain	contain	VB
18637	17702	36	such	such	JJ
18637	17702	37	allegation	allegation	NN
18637	17702	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	17702	39	defective	defective	JJ
18637	17702	40	.	.	.
18637	17703	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17703	2	69	69	CD
18637	17703	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17703	4	Despite	despite	IN
18637	17703	5	the	the	DT
18637	17703	6	omission	omission	NN
18637	17703	7	of	of	IN
18637	17703	8	obscene	obscene	JJ
18637	17703	9	particulars	particular	NNS
18637	17703	10	,	,	,
18637	17703	11	an	an	DT
18637	17703	12	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	17703	13	in	in	IN
18637	17703	14	general	general	JJ
18637	17703	15	language	language	NN
18637	17703	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	17703	17	good	good	JJ
18637	17703	18	if	if	IN
18637	17703	19	the	the	DT
18637	17703	20	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	17703	21	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	17703	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	17703	23	so	so	RB
18637	17703	24	described	described	JJ
18637	17703	25	so	so	IN
18637	17703	26	as	as	IN
18637	17703	27	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	17703	28	to	to	TO
18637	17703	29	inform	inform	VB
18637	17703	30	the	the	DT
18637	17703	31	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17703	32	of	of	IN
18637	17703	33	the	the	DT
18637	17703	34	nature	nature	NN
18637	17703	35	of	of	IN
18637	17703	36	the	the	DT
18637	17703	37	charge	charge	NN
18637	17703	38	sought	seek	VBD
18637	17703	39	to	to	TO
18637	17703	40	be	be	VB
18637	17703	41	established	establish	VBN
18637	17703	42	against	against	IN
18637	17703	43	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17703	44	.	.	.
18637	17704	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17704	2	70	70	CD
18637	17704	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17704	4	The	the	DT
18637	17704	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	17704	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	17704	7	not	not	RB
18637	17704	8	require	require	VB
18637	17704	9	the	the	DT
18637	17704	10	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17704	11	to	to	TO
18637	17704	12	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	17704	13	a	a	DT
18637	17704	14	copy	copy	NN
18637	17704	15	of	of	IN
18637	17704	16	the	the	DT
18637	17704	17	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	17704	18	to	to	IN
18637	17704	19	an	an	DT
18637	17704	20	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17704	21	.	.	.
18637	17705	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17705	2	71	71	CD
18637	17705	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17705	4	Right	right	UH
18637	17705	5	of	of	IN
18637	17705	6	Confrontation	confrontation	NN
18637	17705	7	The	the	DT
18637	17705	8	right	right	NN
18637	17705	9	of	of	IN
18637	17705	10	confrontation	confrontation	NN
18637	17705	11	did	do	VBD
18637	17705	12	not	not	RB
18637	17705	13	originate	originate	VB
18637	17705	14	in	in	IN
18637	17705	15	the	the	DT
18637	17705	16	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	17705	17	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17705	18	;	;	:
18637	17705	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17705	20	was	be	VBD
18637	17705	21	a	a	DT
18637	17705	22	common	common	JJ
18637	17705	23	law	law	NN
18637	17705	24	right	right	RB
18637	17705	25	having	have	VBG
18637	17705	26	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	17705	27	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	17705	28	.	.	.
18637	17706	1	The	the	DT
18637	17706	2	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	17706	3	of	of	IN
18637	17706	4	the	the	DT
18637	17706	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17706	6	provision	provision	NN
18637	17706	7	was	be	VBD
18637	17706	8	to	to	TO
18637	17706	9	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	17706	10	that	that	DT
18637	17706	11	right	right	UH
18637	17706	12	,	,	,
18637	17706	13	but	but	CC
18637	17706	14	not	not	RB
18637	17706	15	to	to	TO
18637	17706	16	broaden	broaden	VB
18637	17706	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17706	18	or	or	CC
18637	17706	19	wipe	wipe	VB
18637	17706	20	out	out	RP
18637	17706	21	the	the	DT
18637	17706	22	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	17706	23	.	.	.
18637	17707	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17707	2	72	72	CD
18637	17707	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17707	4	The	the	DT
18637	17707	5	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	17707	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	17707	7	not	not	RB
18637	17707	8	accord	accord	VB
18637	17707	9	a	a	DT
18637	17707	10	right	right	NN
18637	17707	11	to	to	TO
18637	17707	12	be	be	VB
18637	17707	13	apprised	apprise	VBN
18637	17707	14	of	of	IN
18637	17707	15	the	the	DT
18637	17707	16	names	name	NNS
18637	17707	17	of	of	IN
18637	17707	18	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	17707	19	who	who	WP
18637	17707	20	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	17707	21	before	before	IN
18637	17707	22	a	a	DT
18637	17707	23	grand	grand	JJ
18637	17707	24	jury	jury	NN
18637	17707	25	.	.	.
18637	17708	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17708	2	73	73	CD
18637	17708	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17708	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17708	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	17708	6	not	not	RB
18637	17708	7	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	17708	8	the	the	DT
18637	17708	9	admission	admission	NN
18637	17708	10	of	of	IN
18637	17708	11	dying	die	VBG
18637	17708	12	declarations,[74	declarations,[74	NNP
18637	17708	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17708	14	nor	nor	CC
18637	17708	15	of	of	IN
18637	17708	16	the	the	DT
18637	17708	17	stenographic	stenographic	JJ
18637	17708	18	report	report	NN
18637	17708	19	of	of	IN
18637	17708	20	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	17708	21	given	give	VBN
18637	17708	22	at	at	IN
18637	17708	23	a	a	DT
18637	17708	24	former	former	JJ
18637	17708	25	trial	trial	NN
18637	17708	26	by	by	IN
18637	17708	27	a	a	DT
18637	17708	28	witness	witness	NN
18637	17708	29	since	since	IN
18637	17708	30	deceased	deceased	JJ
18637	17708	31	.	.	.
18637	17709	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17709	2	75	75	CD
18637	17709	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17709	4	An	an	DT
18637	17709	5	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17709	6	who	who	WP
18637	17709	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	17709	8	instrumental	instrumental	JJ
18637	17709	9	in	in	IN
18637	17709	10	concealing	conceal	VBG
18637	17709	11	a	a	DT
18637	17709	12	witness	witness	NN
18637	17709	13	can	can	MD
18637	17709	14	not	not	RB
18637	17709	15	complain	complain	VB
18637	17709	16	of	of	IN
18637	17709	17	the	the	DT
18637	17709	18	admission	admission	NN
18637	17709	19	of	of	IN
18637	17709	20	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17709	21	to	to	TO
18637	17709	22	prove	prove	VB
18637	17709	23	what	what	WP
18637	17709	24	that	that	DT
18637	17709	25	witness	witness	NN
18637	17709	26	testified	testify	VBD
18637	17709	27	at	at	IN
18637	17709	28	a	a	DT
18637	17709	29	former	former	JJ
18637	17709	30	trial	trial	NN
18637	17709	31	on	on	IN
18637	17709	32	a	a	DT
18637	17709	33	different	different	JJ
18637	17709	34	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	17709	35	.	.	.
18637	17710	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17710	2	76	76	CD
18637	17710	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17710	4	If	if	IN
18637	17710	5	the	the	DT
18637	17710	6	absence	absence	NN
18637	17710	7	of	of	IN
18637	17710	8	the	the	DT
18637	17710	9	witness	witness	NN
18637	17710	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	17710	11	chargeable	chargeable	JJ
18637	17710	12	to	to	IN
18637	17710	13	the	the	DT
18637	17710	14	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	17710	15	of	of	IN
18637	17710	16	the	the	DT
18637	17710	17	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	17710	18	,	,	,
18637	17710	19	rather	rather	RB
18637	17710	20	than	than	IN
18637	17710	21	to	to	IN
18637	17710	22	the	the	DT
18637	17710	23	procurement	procurement	NN
18637	17710	24	of	of	IN
18637	17710	25	the	the	DT
18637	17710	26	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17710	27	,	,	,
18637	17710	28	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17710	29	given	give	VBN
18637	17710	30	in	in	IN
18637	17710	31	a	a	DT
18637	17710	32	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	17710	33	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	17710	34	before	before	IN
18637	17710	35	a	a	DT
18637	17710	36	United	United	NNP
18637	17710	37	States	States	NNP
18637	17710	38	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	17710	39	can	can	MD
18637	17710	40	not	not	RB
18637	17710	41	be	be	VB
18637	17710	42	used	use	VBN
18637	17710	43	at	at	IN
18637	17710	44	the	the	DT
18637	17710	45	trial	trial	NN
18637	17710	46	.	.	.
18637	17711	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17711	2	77	77	CD
18637	17711	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17711	4	A	a	DT
18637	17711	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	17711	6	which	which	WDT
18637	17711	7	declared	declare	VBD
18637	17711	8	that	that	IN
18637	17711	9	the	the	DT
18637	17711	10	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	17711	11	of	of	IN
18637	17711	12	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	17711	13	against	against	IN
18637	17711	14	the	the	DT
18637	17711	15	principal	principal	JJ
18637	17711	16	felons	felon	NNS
18637	17711	17	should	should	MD
18637	17711	18	be	be	VB
18637	17711	19	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	17711	20	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17711	21	,	,	,
18637	17711	22	in	in	IN
18637	17711	23	a	a	DT
18637	17711	24	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	17711	25	against	against	IN
18637	17711	26	persons	person	NNS
18637	17711	27	to	to	IN
18637	17711	28	whom	whom	WP
18637	17711	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17711	30	had	have	VBD
18637	17711	31	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	17711	32	property	property	NN
18637	17711	33	,	,	,
18637	17711	34	that	that	IN
18637	17711	35	the	the	DT
18637	17711	36	property	property	NN
18637	17711	37	had	have	VBD
18637	17711	38	been	be	VBN
18637	17711	39	stolen	steal	VBN
18637	17711	40	or	or	CC
18637	17711	41	embezzled	embezzle	VBN
18637	17711	42	from	from	IN
18637	17711	43	the	the	DT
18637	17711	44	United	United	NNP
18637	17711	45	States	States	NNP
18637	17711	46	,	,	,
18637	17711	47	was	be	VBD
18637	17711	48	held	hold	VBN
18637	17711	49	to	to	TO
18637	17711	50	contravene	contravene	VB
18637	17711	51	this	this	DT
18637	17711	52	clause	clause	NN
18637	17711	53	.	.	.
18637	17712	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17712	2	78	78	CD
18637	17712	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17712	4	Assistance	assistance	NN
18637	17712	5	of	of	IN
18637	17712	6	Counsel	Counsel	NNP
18637	17712	7	The	The	NNP
18637	17712	8	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	17712	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17712	10	withholds	withhold	VBZ
18637	17712	11	from	from	IN
18637	17712	12	the	the	DT
18637	17712	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17712	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	17712	15	,	,	,
18637	17712	16	in	in	IN
18637	17712	17	all	all	DT
18637	17712	18	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	17712	19	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	17712	20	,	,	,
18637	17712	21	the	the	DT
18637	17712	22	power	power	NN
18637	17712	23	to	to	TO
18637	17712	24	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	17712	25	an	an	DT
18637	17712	26	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	17712	27	of	of	IN
18637	17712	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17712	29	life	life	NN
18637	17712	30	or	or	CC
18637	17712	31	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	17712	32	unless	unless	IN
18637	17712	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17712	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	17712	35	waived	waive	VBN
18637	17712	36	,	,	,
18637	17712	37	or	or	CC
18637	17712	38	waives	waif	NNS
18637	17712	39	,	,	,
18637	17712	40	the	the	DT
18637	17712	41	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	17712	42	of	of	IN
18637	17712	43	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	17712	44	.	.	.
18637	17713	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17713	2	79	79	CD
18637	17713	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17713	4	Since	since	IN
18637	17713	5	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	17713	6	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	17713	7	are	be	VBP
18637	17713	8	not	not	RB
18637	17713	9	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	17713	10	in	in	IN
18637	17713	11	character	character	NN
18637	17713	12	,	,	,
18637	17713	13	the	the	DT
18637	17713	14	admission	admission	NN
18637	17713	15	of	of	IN
18637	17713	16	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	17713	17	given	give	VBN
18637	17713	18	by	by	IN
18637	17713	19	the	the	DT
18637	17713	20	alien	alien	NN
18637	17713	21	during	during	IN
18637	17713	22	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	17713	23	prior	prior	RB
18637	17713	24	to	to	TO
18637	17713	25	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	17713	26	did	do	VBD
18637	17713	27	not	not	RB
18637	17713	28	render	render	VB
18637	17713	29	the	the	DT
18637	17713	30	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	17713	31	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	17713	32	,	,	,
18637	17713	33	despite	despite	IN
18637	17713	34	the	the	DT
18637	17713	35	fact	fact	NN
18637	17713	36	that	that	IN
18637	17713	37	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17713	38	had	have	VBD
18637	17713	39	not	not	RB
18637	17713	40	been	be	VBN
18637	17713	41	advised	advise	VBN
18637	17713	42	of	of	IN
18637	17713	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17713	44	right	right	NN
18637	17713	45	to	to	TO
18637	17713	46	have	have	VB
18637	17713	47	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	17713	48	or	or	CC
18637	17713	49	to	to	TO
18637	17713	50	decline	decline	VB
18637	17713	51	to	to	TO
18637	17713	52	answer	answer	VB
18637	17713	53	questions	question	NNS
18637	17713	54	as	as	IN
18637	17713	55	to	to	IN
18637	17713	56	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17713	57	alienage	alienage	NN
18637	17713	58	.	.	.
18637	17714	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17714	2	80	80	CD
18637	17714	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17714	4	The	the	DT
18637	17714	5	right	right	NN
18637	17714	6	to	to	IN
18637	17714	7	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	17714	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	17714	9	violated	violate	VBN
18637	17714	10	where	where	WRB
18637	17714	11	,	,	,
18637	17714	12	over	over	IN
18637	17714	13	the	the	DT
18637	17714	14	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17714	15	's	's	POS
18637	17714	16	objection	objection	NN
18637	17714	17	,	,	,
18637	17714	18	the	the	DT
18637	17714	19	court	court	NN
18637	17714	20	requires	require	VBZ
18637	17714	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17714	22	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	17714	23	to	to	TO
18637	17714	24	represent	represent	VB
18637	17714	25	a	a	DT
18637	17714	26	co	co	NN
18637	17714	27	-	-	NN
18637	17714	28	defendant	defendant	JJ
18637	17714	29	whose	whose	WP$
18637	17714	30	interest	interest	NN
18637	17714	31	may	may	MD
18637	17714	32	possibly	possibly	RB
18637	17714	33	conflict	conflict	VB
18637	17714	34	with	with	IN
18637	17714	35	his;[81	his;[81	NN
18637	17714	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17714	37	likewise	likewise	RB
18637	17714	38	where	where	WRB
18637	17714	39	the	the	DT
18637	17714	40	trial	trial	NN
18637	17714	41	judge	judge	NN
18637	17714	42	decided	decide	VBD
18637	17714	43	,	,	,
18637	17714	44	without	without	IN
18637	17714	45	notice	notice	NN
18637	17714	46	to	to	IN
18637	17714	47	a	a	DT
18637	17714	48	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17714	49	and	and	CC
18637	17714	50	without	without	IN
18637	17714	51	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17714	52	presence	presence	NN
18637	17714	53	,	,	,
18637	17714	54	that	that	IN
18637	17714	55	the	the	DT
18637	17714	56	latter	latter	JJ
18637	17714	57	had	have	VBD
18637	17714	58	consented	consent	VBN
18637	17714	59	to	to	TO
18637	17714	60	be	be	VB
18637	17714	61	represented	represent	VBN
18637	17714	62	by	by	IN
18637	17714	63	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	17714	64	who	who	WP
18637	17714	65	also	also	RB
18637	17714	66	represented	represent	VBD
18637	17714	67	another	another	DT
18637	17714	68	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17714	69	in	in	IN
18637	17714	70	the	the	DT
18637	17714	71	same	same	JJ
18637	17714	72	case	case	NN
18637	17714	73	.	.	.
18637	17715	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17715	2	82	82	CD
18637	17715	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17715	4	The	the	DT
18637	17715	5	right	right	NN
18637	17715	6	may	may	MD
18637	17715	7	be	be	VB
18637	17715	8	waived	waive	VBN
18637	17715	9	by	by	IN
18637	17715	10	a	a	DT
18637	17715	11	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17715	12	whose	whose	WP$
18637	17715	13	education	education	NN
18637	17715	14	qualifies	qualify	VBZ
18637	17715	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17715	16	to	to	TO
18637	17715	17	make	make	VB
18637	17715	18	an	an	DT
18637	17715	19	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
18637	17715	20	choice	choice	NN
18637	17715	21	.	.	.
18637	17716	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17716	2	83	83	CD
18637	17716	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17716	4	A	a	DT
18637	17716	5	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	17716	6	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	17716	7	upon	upon	IN
18637	17716	8	a	a	DT
18637	17716	9	plea	plea	NN
18637	17716	10	of	of	IN
18637	17716	11	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	17716	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	17716	13	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	17716	14	if	if	IN
18637	17716	15	such	such	JJ
18637	17716	16	plea	plea	NN
18637	17716	17	was	be	VBD
18637	17716	18	entered	enter	VBN
18637	17716	19	through	through	IN
18637	17716	20	deception	deception	NN
18637	17716	21	or	or	CC
18637	17716	22	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	17716	23	of	of	IN
18637	17716	24	the	the	DT
18637	17716	25	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
18637	17716	26	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	17716	27	,	,	,
18637	17716	28	or	or	CC
18637	17716	29	in	in	IN
18637	17716	30	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	17716	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	17716	32	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
18637	17716	33	advice	advice	NN
18637	17716	34	given	give	VBN
18637	17716	35	by	by	IN
18637	17716	36	a	a	DT
18637	17716	37	lawyer	lawyer	NN
18637	17716	38	in	in	IN
18637	17716	39	the	the	DT
18637	17716	40	employ	employ	NN
18637	17716	41	of	of	IN
18637	17716	42	the	the	DT
18637	17716	43	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17716	44	,	,	,
18637	17716	45	where	where	WRB
18637	17716	46	the	the	DT
18637	17716	47	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17716	48	did	do	VBD
18637	17716	49	not	not	RB
18637	17716	50	have	have	VB
18637	17716	51	the	the	DT
18637	17716	52	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	17716	53	of	of	IN
18637	17716	54	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	17716	55	and	and	CC
18637	17716	56	had	have	VBD
18637	17716	57	not	not	RB
18637	17716	58	understandingly	understandingly	RB
18637	17716	59	waived	waive	VBN
18637	17716	60	the	the	DT
18637	17716	61	right	right	NN
18637	17716	62	to	to	IN
18637	17716	63	such	such	JJ
18637	17716	64	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	17716	65	.	.	.
18637	17717	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17717	2	84	84	CD
18637	17717	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17717	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	17717	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17717	6	1	1	CD
18637	17717	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17717	8	Callan	Callan	NNP
18637	17717	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17717	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17717	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17717	12	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	17717	13	,	,	,
18637	17717	14	127	127	CD
18637	17717	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17717	16	540	540	CD
18637	17717	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17717	18	1888	1888	CD
18637	17717	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17717	20	.	.	.
18637	17718	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17718	2	2	2	LS
18637	17718	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17718	4	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	17718	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17718	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17718	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17718	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17718	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17718	10	,	,	,
18637	17718	11	98	98	CD
18637	17718	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17718	13	145	145	CD
18637	17718	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17718	15	1879	1879	CD
18637	17718	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17718	17	.	.	.
18637	17719	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17719	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17719	3	also	also	RB
18637	17719	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17719	5	Lovato	Lovato	NNP
18637	17719	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17719	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17719	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17719	9	New	New	NNP
18637	17719	10	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	17719	11	,	,	,
18637	17719	12	242	242	CD
18637	17719	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17719	14	199	199	CD
18637	17719	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17719	16	1916	1916	CD
18637	17719	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17719	18	.	.	.
18637	17720	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17720	2	3	3	CD
18637	17720	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17720	4	Balzac	Balzac	NNP
18637	17720	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17720	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17720	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17720	8	Porto	Porto	NNP
18637	17720	9	Rico	Rico	NNP
18637	17720	10	,	,	,
18637	17720	11	258	258	CD
18637	17720	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17720	13	298	298	CD
18637	17720	14	,	,	,
18637	17720	15	304	304	CD
18637	17720	16	-	-	SYM
18637	17720	17	305	305	CD
18637	17720	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17720	19	1922	1922	CD
18637	17720	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17720	21	.	.	.
18637	17721	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17721	2	4	4	CD
18637	17721	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17721	4	Rassmussen	Rassmussen	NNP
18637	17721	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17721	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17721	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17721	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17721	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17721	10	,	,	,
18637	17721	11	197	197	CD
18637	17721	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17721	13	516	516	CD
18637	17721	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17721	15	1905	1905	CD
18637	17721	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17721	17	.	.	.
18637	17722	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17722	2	5	5	CD
18637	17722	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17722	4	140	140	CD
18637	17722	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17722	6	453	453	CD
18637	17722	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17722	8	1891	1891	CD
18637	17722	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17722	10	.	.	.
18637	17723	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17723	2	6	6	CD
18637	17723	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17723	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17723	5	.	.	.
18637	17724	1	464	464	CD
18637	17724	2	.	.	.
18637	17725	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17725	2	7	7	CD
18637	17725	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17725	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17725	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17725	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17725	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17725	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17725	9	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	17725	10	&	&	CC
18637	17725	11	Goodwin	Goodwin	NNP
18637	17725	12	,	,	,
18637	17725	13	7	7	CD
18637	17725	14	Cr	Cr	NNP
18637	17725	15	.	.	.
18637	17726	1	32	32	CD
18637	17726	2	,	,	,
18637	17726	3	33	33	CD
18637	17726	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17726	5	1812	1812	CD
18637	17726	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17726	7	;	;	:
18637	17726	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17726	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17726	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17726	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	17726	12	_	_	NNP
18637	17726	13	Coolidge	Coolidge	NNP
18637	17726	14	,	,	,
18637	17726	15	1	1	CD
18637	17726	16	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	17726	17	.	.	.
18637	17727	1	415	415	CD
18637	17727	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17727	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	17727	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17727	5	;	;	:
18637	17727	6	United	United	NNP
18637	17727	7	States	States	NNP
18637	17727	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17727	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17727	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17727	11	Britton	Britton	NNP
18637	17727	12	,	,	,
18637	17727	13	108	108	CD
18637	17727	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17727	15	199	199	CD
18637	17727	16	,	,	,
18637	17727	17	206	206	CD
18637	17727	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17727	19	1883	1883	CD
18637	17727	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17727	21	;	;	:
18637	17727	22	United	United	NNP
18637	17727	23	States	States	NNP
18637	17727	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17727	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	17727	26	_	_	NNP
18637	17727	27	Eaton	Eaton	NNP
18637	17727	28	,	,	,
18637	17727	29	144	144	CD
18637	17727	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17727	31	677	677	CD
18637	17727	32	,	,	,
18637	17727	33	687	687	CD
18637	17727	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17727	35	1892	1892	CD
18637	17727	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17727	37	.	.	.
18637	17728	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17728	2	8	8	CD
18637	17728	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17728	4	Callan	Callan	NNP
18637	17728	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17728	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17728	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17728	8	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	17728	9	,	,	,
18637	17728	10	127	127	CD
18637	17728	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17728	12	540	540	CD
18637	17728	13	,	,	,
18637	17728	14	552	552	CD
18637	17728	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17728	16	1888	1888	CD
18637	17728	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17728	18	.	.	.
18637	17729	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17729	2	9	9	CD
18637	17729	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17729	4	Schick	Schick	NNP
18637	17729	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17729	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17729	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17729	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17729	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17729	10	,	,	,
18637	17729	11	195	195	CD
18637	17729	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17729	13	65	65	CD
18637	17729	14	,	,	,
18637	17729	15	68	68	CD
18637	17729	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17729	17	1904	1904	CD
18637	17729	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17729	19	.	.	.
18637	17730	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17730	2	10	10	CD
18637	17730	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17730	4	District	District	NNP
18637	17730	5	of	of	IN
18637	17730	6	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	17730	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17730	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17730	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17730	10	Clawans	Clawans	NNP
18637	17730	11	,	,	,
18637	17730	12	300	300	CD
18637	17730	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17730	14	617	617	CD
18637	17730	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17730	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	17730	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17730	18	.	.	.
18637	17731	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17731	2	11	11	CD
18637	17731	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17731	4	District	District	NNP
18637	17731	5	of	of	IN
18637	17731	6	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	17731	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17731	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17731	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17731	10	Colts	Colts	NNP
18637	17731	11	,	,	,
18637	17731	12	282	282	CD
18637	17731	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17731	14	63	63	CD
18637	17731	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17731	16	1930	1930	CD
18637	17731	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17731	18	.	.	.
18637	17732	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17732	2	12	12	CD
18637	17732	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17732	4	Callan	Callan	NNP
18637	17732	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17732	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17732	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17732	8	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	17732	9	,	,	,
18637	17732	10	127	127	CD
18637	17732	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17732	12	540	540	CD
18637	17732	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17732	14	1888	1888	CD
18637	17732	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17732	16	.	.	.
18637	17733	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17733	2	13	13	CD
18637	17733	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17733	4	Oceanic	Oceanic	NNP
18637	17733	5	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	17733	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17733	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17733	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17733	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17733	10	Stranahan	Stranahan	NNP
18637	17733	11	,	,	,
18637	17733	12	214	214	CD
18637	17733	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17733	14	320	320	CD
18637	17733	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17733	16	1909	1909	CD
18637	17733	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17733	18	;	;	:
18637	17733	19	Hepner	Hepner	NNP
18637	17733	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17733	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	17733	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17733	23	United	United	NNP
18637	17733	24	States	States	NNP
18637	17733	25	,	,	,
18637	17733	26	213	213	CD
18637	17733	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17733	28	103	103	CD
18637	17733	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17733	30	1909	1909	CD
18637	17733	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17733	32	;	;	:
18637	17733	33	United	United	NNP
18637	17733	34	States	States	NNP
18637	17733	35	_	_	NNP
18637	17733	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	17733	37	_	_	NNP
18637	17733	38	Regan	Regan	NNP
18637	17733	39	,	,	,
18637	17733	40	232	232	CD
18637	17733	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17733	42	37	37	CD
18637	17733	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17733	44	1914	1914	CD
18637	17733	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17733	46	.	.	.
18637	17734	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17734	2	14	14	CD
18637	17734	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17734	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17734	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17734	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17734	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	17734	8	.	.	.
18637	17735	1	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	17735	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17735	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17735	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17735	5	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	17735	6	,	,	,
18637	17735	7	194	194	CD
18637	17735	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17735	9	279	279	CD
18637	17735	10	,	,	,
18637	17735	11	289	289	CD
18637	17735	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17735	13	1904	1904	CD
18637	17735	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17735	15	;	;	:
18637	17735	16	Zakonaite	Zakonaite	NNP
18637	17735	17	_	_	NNP
18637	17735	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	17735	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17735	20	Wolf	Wolf	NNP
18637	17735	21	,	,	,
18637	17735	22	226	226	CD
18637	17735	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17735	24	272	272	CD
18637	17735	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17735	26	1912	1912	CD
18637	17735	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17735	28	.	.	.
18637	17736	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17736	2	15	15	CD
18637	17736	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17736	4	In	in	IN
18637	17736	5	re	re	NN
18637	17736	6	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	17736	7	,	,	,
18637	17736	8	158	158	CD
18637	17736	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17736	10	564	564	CD
18637	17736	11	,	,	,
18637	17736	12	594	594	CD
18637	17736	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17736	14	1895	1895	CD
18637	17736	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17736	16	;	;	:
18637	17736	17	Gompers	Gompers	NNP
18637	17736	18	_	_	NNP
18637	17736	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	17736	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17736	21	United	United	NNP
18637	17736	22	States	States	NNP
18637	17736	23	,	,	,
18637	17736	24	233	233	CD
18637	17736	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17736	26	604	604	CD
18637	17736	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17736	28	1914	1914	CD
18637	17736	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17736	30	;	;	:
18637	17736	31	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	17736	32	_	_	NNP
18637	17736	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	17736	34	_	_	NNP
18637	17736	35	United	United	NNP
18637	17736	36	States	States	NNP
18637	17736	37	,	,	,
18637	17736	38	264	264	CD
18637	17736	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17736	40	95	95	CD
18637	17736	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17736	42	1924	1924	CD
18637	17736	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17736	44	.	.	.
18637	17737	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17737	2	16	16	CD
18637	17737	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17737	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17737	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17737	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17737	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17737	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17737	9	Zucker	Zucker	NNP
18637	17737	10	,	,	,
18637	17737	11	161	161	CD
18637	17737	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17737	13	475	475	CD
18637	17737	14	,	,	,
18637	17737	15	481	481	CD
18637	17737	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17737	17	1896	1896	CD
18637	17737	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17737	19	.	.	.
18637	17738	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17738	2	17	17	CD
18637	17738	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17738	4	Counselman	Counselman	NNP
18637	17738	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17738	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17738	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17738	8	Hitchcock	Hitchcock	NNP
18637	17738	9	,	,	,
18637	17738	10	142	142	CD
18637	17738	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17738	12	547	547	CD
18637	17738	13	,	,	,
18637	17738	14	563	563	CD
18637	17738	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17738	16	1892	1892	CD
18637	17738	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17738	18	.	.	.
18637	17739	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17739	2	18	18	CD
18637	17739	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17739	4	Patton	Patton	NNP
18637	17739	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17739	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17739	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17739	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17739	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17739	10	,	,	,
18637	17739	11	281	281	CD
18637	17739	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17739	13	276	276	CD
18637	17739	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17739	15	1930	1930	CD
18637	17739	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17739	17	.	.	.
18637	17740	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17740	2	19	19	CD
18637	17740	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17740	4	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	17740	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17740	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17740	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17740	8	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	17740	9	,	,	,
18637	17740	10	170	170	CD
18637	17740	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17740	12	343	343	CD
18637	17740	13	,	,	,
18637	17740	14	350	350	CD
18637	17740	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17740	16	1898	1898	CD
18637	17740	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17740	18	;	;	:
18637	17740	19	Rassmussen	Rassmussen	NNP
18637	17740	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17740	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	17740	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17740	23	United	United	NNP
18637	17740	24	States	States	NNP
18637	17740	25	,	,	,
18637	17740	26	197	197	CD
18637	17740	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17740	28	518	518	CD
18637	17740	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17740	30	1905	1905	CD
18637	17740	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17740	32	.	.	.
18637	17741	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17741	2	20	20	CD
18637	17741	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17741	4	Capital	Capital	NNP
18637	17741	5	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	17741	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17741	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17741	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17741	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17741	10	Hof	Hof	NNP
18637	17741	11	,	,	,
18637	17741	12	174	174	CD
18637	17741	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17741	14	1	1	CD
18637	17741	15	,	,	,
18637	17741	16	13	13	CD
18637	17741	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17741	18	1899	1899	CD
18637	17741	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17741	20	.	.	.
18637	17742	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17742	2	21	21	CD
18637	17742	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17742	4	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	17742	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17742	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17742	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17742	8	Dow	Dow	NNP
18637	17742	9	,	,	,
18637	17742	10	176	176	CD
18637	17742	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17742	12	581	581	CD
18637	17742	13	,	,	,
18637	17742	14	586	586	CD
18637	17742	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17742	16	1900	1900	CD
18637	17742	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17742	18	;	;	:
18637	17742	19	Andres	Andres	NNP
18637	17742	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17742	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	17742	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17742	23	United	United	NNP
18637	17742	24	States	States	NNP
18637	17742	25	,	,	,
18637	17742	26	333	333	CD
18637	17742	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17742	28	740	740	CD
18637	17742	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17742	30	1948	1948	CD
18637	17742	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17742	32	.	.	.
18637	17743	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17743	2	22	22	CD
18637	17743	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17743	4	Patton	Patton	NNP
18637	17743	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17743	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17743	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17743	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17743	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17743	10	,	,	,
18637	17743	11	281	281	CD
18637	17743	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17743	13	276	276	CD
18637	17743	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17743	15	1930	1930	CD
18637	17743	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17743	17	.	.	.
18637	17744	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17744	2	23	23	CD
18637	17744	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17744	4	Beavers	Beavers	NNP
18637	17744	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17744	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17744	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17744	8	Haubert	Haubert	NNP
18637	17744	9	,	,	,
18637	17744	10	198	198	CD
18637	17744	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17744	12	77	77	CD
18637	17744	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17744	14	1905	1905	CD
18637	17744	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17744	16	.	.	.
18637	17745	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17745	2	24	24	CD
18637	17745	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17745	4	Callan	Callan	NNP
18637	17745	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17745	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17745	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17745	8	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	17745	9	,	,	,
18637	17745	10	127	127	CD
18637	17745	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17745	12	540	540	CD
18637	17745	13	,	,	,
18637	17745	14	557	557	CD
18637	17745	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17745	16	1888	1888	CD
18637	17745	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17745	18	.	.	.
18637	17746	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17746	2	25	25	CD
18637	17746	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17746	4	Crawford	Crawford	NNP
18637	17746	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17746	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17746	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17746	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17746	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17746	10	,	,	,
18637	17746	11	212	212	CD
18637	17746	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17746	13	183	183	CD
18637	17746	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17746	15	1909	1909	CD
18637	17746	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17746	17	.	.	.
18637	17747	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17747	2	26	26	CD
18637	17747	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17747	4	299	299	CD
18637	17747	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17747	6	123	123	CD
18637	17747	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17747	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	17747	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17747	10	.	.	.
18637	17748	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17748	2	27	27	CD
18637	17748	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17748	4	Frazier	Frazier	NNP
18637	17748	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17748	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17748	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17748	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17748	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17748	10	,	,	,
18637	17748	11	335	335	CD
18637	17748	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17748	13	497	497	CD
18637	17748	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17748	15	1948	1948	CD
18637	17748	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17748	17	.	.	.
18637	17749	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17749	2	28	28	CD
18637	17749	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17749	4	Dennis	Dennis	NNP
18637	17749	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17749	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17749	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17749	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17749	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17749	10	,	,	,
18637	17749	11	339	339	CD
18637	17749	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17749	13	162	162	CD
18637	17749	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17749	15	1950	1950	CD
18637	17749	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17749	17	.	.	.
18637	17750	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17750	2	29	29	CD
18637	17750	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17750	4	Stilson	Stilson	NNP
18637	17750	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17750	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17750	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17750	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17750	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17750	10	,	,	,
18637	17750	11	250	250	CD
18637	17750	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17750	13	583	583	CD
18637	17750	14	,	,	,
18637	17750	15	586	586	CD
18637	17750	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17750	17	1919	1919	CD
18637	17750	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17750	19	.	.	.
18637	17751	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17751	2	30	30	CD
18637	17751	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17751	4	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	17751	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17751	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17751	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17751	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17751	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17751	10	,	,	,
18637	17751	11	98	98	CD
18637	17751	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17751	13	145	145	CD
18637	17751	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17751	15	1879	1879	CD
18637	17751	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17751	17	.	.	.
18637	17752	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17752	2	31	31	CD
18637	17752	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17752	4	Ruthenberg	Ruthenberg	NNP
18637	17752	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17752	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17752	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17752	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17752	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17752	10	,	,	,
18637	17752	11	245	245	CD
18637	17752	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17752	13	480	480	CD
18637	17752	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17752	15	1918	1918	CD
18637	17752	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17752	17	.	.	.
18637	17753	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17753	2	32	32	CD
18637	17753	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17753	4	Salinger	Salinger	NNP
18637	17753	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17753	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17753	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17753	8	Loisel	Loisel	NNP
18637	17753	9	,	,	,
18637	17753	10	265	265	CD
18637	17753	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17753	12	224	224	CD
18637	17753	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17753	14	1924	1924	CD
18637	17753	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17753	16	.	.	.
18637	17754	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17754	2	33	33	CD
18637	17754	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17754	4	Beavers	Beavers	NNP
18637	17754	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17754	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17754	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17754	8	Henkel	Henkel	NNP
18637	17754	9	,	,	,
18637	17754	10	194	194	CD
18637	17754	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17754	12	73	73	CD
18637	17754	13	,	,	,
18637	17754	14	83	83	CD
18637	17754	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17754	16	1904	1904	CD
18637	17754	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17754	18	.	.	.
18637	17755	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17755	2	34	34	CD
18637	17755	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17755	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	17755	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17755	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17755	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17755	8	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	17755	9	,	,	,
18637	17755	10	225	225	CD
18637	17755	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17755	12	392	392	CD
18637	17755	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17755	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	17755	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17755	16	;	;	:
18637	17755	17	Hyde	Hyde	NNP
18637	17755	18	_	_	NNP
18637	17755	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	17755	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17755	21	United	United	NNP
18637	17755	22	States	States	NNP
18637	17755	23	,	,	,
18637	17755	24	225	225	CD
18637	17755	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17755	26	347	347	CD
18637	17755	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17755	28	1912	1912	CD
18637	17755	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17755	30	;	;	:
18637	17755	31	Haas	Haas	NNP
18637	17755	32	_	_	NNP
18637	17755	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	17755	34	_	_	NNP
18637	17755	35	Henkel	Henkel	NNP
18637	17755	36	,	,	,
18637	17755	37	216	216	CD
18637	17755	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17755	39	462	462	CD
18637	17755	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17755	41	1910	1910	CD
18637	17755	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17755	43	.	.	.
18637	17756	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17756	2	35	35	CD
18637	17756	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17756	4	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	17756	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17756	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17756	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17756	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17756	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17756	10	,	,	,
18637	17756	11	202	202	CD
18637	17756	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17756	13	344	344	CD
18637	17756	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17756	15	1906	1906	CD
18637	17756	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17756	17	.	.	.
18637	17757	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17757	2	36	36	CD
18637	17757	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17757	4	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	17757	5	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	17757	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17757	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17757	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17757	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17757	10	United	United	NNP
18637	17757	11	States	States	NNP
18637	17757	12	,	,	,
18637	17757	13	209	209	CD
18637	17757	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17757	15	56	56	CD
18637	17757	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17757	17	1908	1908	CD
18637	17757	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17757	19	.	.	.
18637	17758	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17758	2	37	37	CD
18637	17758	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17758	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17758	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17758	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17758	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17758	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17758	9	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	17758	10	,	,	,
18637	17758	11	323	323	CD
18637	17758	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17758	13	273	273	CD
18637	17758	14	,	,	,
18637	17758	15	274	274	CD
18637	17758	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17758	17	1944	1944	CD
18637	17758	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17758	19	.	.	.
18637	17759	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17759	2	38	38	CD
18637	17759	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17759	4	Hagner	Hagner	NNP
18637	17759	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17759	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17759	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17759	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17759	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17759	10	,	,	,
18637	17759	11	285	285	CD
18637	17759	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17759	13	427	427	CD
18637	17759	14	,	,	,
18637	17759	15	429	429	CD
18637	17759	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17759	17	1932	1932	CD
18637	17759	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17759	19	.	.	.
18637	17760	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17760	2	39	39	CD
18637	17760	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17760	4	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	17760	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17760	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17760	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17760	8	Gault	Gault	NNP
18637	17760	9	,	,	,
18637	17760	10	271	271	CD
18637	17760	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17760	12	142	142	CD
18637	17760	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17760	14	1926	1926	CD
18637	17760	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17760	16	.	.	.
18637	17761	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17761	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	17761	3	.	.	.
18637	17761	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17761	5	Tinsley	Tinsley	NNP
18637	17761	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17761	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17761	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17761	9	Treat	Treat	NNP
18637	17761	10	,	,	,
18637	17761	11	205	205	CD
18637	17761	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17761	13	20	20	CD
18637	17761	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17761	15	1907	1907	CD
18637	17761	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17761	17	;	;	:
18637	17761	18	Beavers	Beavers	NNP
18637	17761	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17761	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	17761	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17761	22	Henkel	Henkel	NNP
18637	17761	23	,	,	,
18637	17761	24	194	194	CD
18637	17761	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17761	26	73	73	CD
18637	17761	27	,	,	,
18637	17761	28	84	84	CD
18637	17761	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17761	30	1904	1904	CD
18637	17761	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17761	32	.	.	.
18637	17762	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17762	2	40	40	CD
18637	17762	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17762	4	Lamar	Lamar	NNP
18637	17762	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17762	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17762	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17762	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17762	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17762	10	,	,	,
18637	17762	11	241	241	CD
18637	17762	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17762	13	103	103	CD
18637	17762	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17762	15	1916	1916	CD
18637	17762	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17762	17	.	.	.
18637	17763	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17763	2	41	41	CD
18637	17763	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17763	4	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	17763	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17763	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17763	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17763	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17763	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17763	10	,	,	,
18637	17763	11	137	137	CD
18637	17763	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17763	13	202	202	CD
18637	17763	14	,	,	,
18637	17763	15	211	211	CD
18637	17763	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17763	17	1890	1890	CD
18637	17763	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17763	19	;	;	:
18637	17763	20	United	United	NNP
18637	17763	21	States	States	NNP
18637	17763	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17763	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	17763	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17763	25	Dawson	Dawson	NNP
18637	17763	26	,	,	,
18637	17763	27	15	15	CD
18637	17763	28	How	how	WRB
18637	17763	29	.	.	.
18637	17764	1	467	467	CD
18637	17764	2	,	,	,
18637	17764	3	488	488	CD
18637	17764	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17764	5	1853	1853	CD
18637	17764	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17764	7	.	.	.
18637	17765	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17765	2	42	42	CD
18637	17765	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17765	4	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	17765	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17765	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17765	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17765	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17765	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17765	10	,	,	,
18637	17765	11	138	138	CD
18637	17765	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17765	13	157	157	CD
18637	17765	14	,	,	,
18637	17765	15	182	182	CD
18637	17765	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17765	17	1891	1891	CD
18637	17765	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17765	19	.	.	.
18637	17766	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17766	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17766	3	also	also	RB
18637	17766	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17766	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17766	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17766	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17766	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17766	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17766	10	Socony	Socony	NNP
18637	17766	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	17766	12	Vacuum	Vacuum	NNP
18637	17766	13	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	17766	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17766	15	,	,	,
18637	17766	16	310	310	CD
18637	17766	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17766	18	150	150	CD
18637	17766	19	,	,	,
18637	17766	20	250	250	CD
18637	17766	21	-	-	SYM
18637	17766	22	254	254	CD
18637	17766	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17766	24	1940	1940	CD
18637	17766	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17766	26	;	;	:
18637	17766	27	_	_	NNP
18637	17766	28	also	also	RB
18637	17766	29	_	_	NNP
18637	17766	30	United	United	NNP
18637	17766	31	States	States	NNP
18637	17766	32	_	_	NNP
18637	17766	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	17766	34	_	_	NNP
18637	17766	35	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	17766	36	,	,	,
18637	17766	37	323	323	CD
18637	17766	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17766	39	273	273	CD
18637	17766	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17766	41	1944	1944	CD
18637	17766	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17766	43	.	.	.
18637	17767	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17767	2	43	43	CD
18637	17767	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17767	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17767	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17767	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17767	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17767	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17767	9	Potter	Potter	NNP
18637	17767	10	,	,	,
18637	17767	11	56	56	CD
18637	17767	12	F.	F.	NNP
18637	17767	13	83	83	CD
18637	17767	14	,	,	,
18637	17767	15	88	88	CD
18637	17767	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17767	17	1892	1892	CD
18637	17767	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17767	19	.	.	.
18637	17768	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17768	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17768	3	also	also	RB
18637	17768	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17768	5	Viereck	Viereck	NNP
18637	17768	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17768	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17768	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17768	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17768	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17768	11	,	,	,
18637	17768	12	318	318	CD
18637	17768	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17768	14	236	236	CD
18637	17768	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17768	16	1943	1943	CD
18637	17768	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17768	18	;	;	:
18637	17768	19	Kraus	Kraus	NNP
18637	17768	20	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	17768	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17768	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	17768	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17768	24	United	United	NNP
18637	17768	25	States	States	NNP
18637	17768	26	,	,	,
18637	17768	27	327	327	CD
18637	17768	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17768	29	614	614	CD
18637	17768	30	,	,	,
18637	17768	31	621	621	CD
18637	17768	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17768	33	1946	1946	CD
18637	17768	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17768	35	.	.	.
18637	17769	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17769	2	44	44	CD
18637	17769	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17769	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17769	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17769	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17769	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17769	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17769	9	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
18637	17769	10	Grocery	Grocery	NNP
18637	17769	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17769	12	,	,	,
18637	17769	13	264	264	CD
18637	17769	14	F.	F.	NNP
18637	17769	15	218	218	CD
18637	17769	16	,	,	,
18637	17769	17	220	220	CD
18637	17769	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17769	19	1920	1920	CD
18637	17769	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17769	21	,	,	,
18637	17769	22	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	17769	23	255	255	CD
18637	17769	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17769	25	81	81	CD
18637	17769	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17769	27	1921	1921	CD
18637	17769	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17769	29	.	.	.
18637	17770	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17770	2	45	45	CD
18637	17770	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17770	4	255	255	CD
18637	17770	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17770	6	81	81	CD
18637	17770	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17770	8	1921	1921	CD
18637	17770	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17770	10	.	.	.
18637	17771	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17771	2	46	46	CD
18637	17771	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17771	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17771	5	.	.	.
18637	17772	1	89	89	CD
18637	17772	2	.	.	.
18637	17773	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17773	2	47	47	CD
18637	17773	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17773	4	8	8	CD
18637	17773	5	U.S.C.	u.s.c.	NN
18637	17774	1	§	§	NNP
18637	17774	2	145	145	CD
18637	17774	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17774	4	c	c	NN
18637	17774	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17774	6	.	.	.
18637	17775	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17775	2	48	48	CD
18637	17775	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17775	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17775	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17775	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17775	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17775	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17775	9	Spector	Spector	NNP
18637	17775	10	,	,	,
18637	17775	11	343	343	CD
18637	17775	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17775	13	169	169	CD
18637	17775	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17775	15	1952	1952	CD
18637	17775	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17775	17	.	.	.
18637	17776	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17776	2	49	49	CD
18637	17776	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17776	4	325	325	CD
18637	17776	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17776	6	91	91	CD
18637	17776	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17776	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	17776	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17776	10	.	.	.
18637	17777	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17777	2	50	50	CD
18637	17777	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17777	4	Section	section	NN
18637	17777	5	20	20	CD
18637	17777	6	of	of	IN
18637	17777	7	the	the	DT
18637	17777	8	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
18637	17777	9	Code	Code	NNP
18637	17777	10	;	;	:
18637	17777	11	18	18	CD
18637	17777	12	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	17778	1	§	§	NNP
18637	17778	2	242	242	CD
18637	17778	3	.	.	.
18637	17779	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17779	2	51	51	CD
18637	17779	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17779	4	325	325	CD
18637	17779	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17779	6	91	91	CD
18637	17779	7	,	,	,
18637	17779	8	94	94	CD
18637	17779	9	,	,	,
18637	17779	10	95	95	CD
18637	17779	11	.	.	.
18637	17780	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17780	2	52	52	CD
18637	17780	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17780	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17780	5	.	.	.
18637	17781	1	101	101	CD
18637	17781	2	.	.	.
18637	17782	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17782	2	53	53	CD
18637	17782	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17782	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17782	5	.	.	.
18637	17783	1	103	103	CD
18637	17783	2	.	.	.
18637	17784	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17784	2	54	54	CD
18637	17784	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17784	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17784	5	.	.	.
18637	17785	1	113	113	CD
18637	17785	2	,	,	,
18637	17785	3	135	135	CD
18637	17785	4	.	.	.
18637	17786	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17786	2	55	55	CD
18637	17786	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17786	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17786	5	.	.	.
18637	17787	1	154	154	CD
18637	17787	2	.	.	.
18637	17788	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17788	2	56	56	CD
18637	17788	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17788	4	341	341	CD
18637	17788	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17788	6	97	97	CD
18637	17788	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17788	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	17788	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17788	10	.	.	.
18637	17789	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17789	2	57	57	CD
18637	17789	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17789	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17789	5	See	See	NNP
18637	17789	6	also	also	RB
18637	17789	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17789	8	Koehler	Koehler	NNP
18637	17789	9	et	et	FW
18637	17789	10	al	al	NNP
18637	17789	11	.	.	.
18637	17790	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17790	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	17790	3	_	_	NNP
18637	17790	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17790	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17790	6	,	,	,
18637	17790	7	342	342	CD
18637	17790	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17790	9	852	852	CD
18637	17790	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17790	11	1951	1951	CD
18637	17790	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17790	13	.	.	.
18637	17791	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17791	2	58	58	CD
18637	17791	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17791	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17791	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17791	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17791	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17791	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17791	9	Petrillo	Petrillo	NNP
18637	17791	10	,	,	,
18637	17791	11	332	332	CD
18637	17791	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17791	13	1	1	CD
18637	17791	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17791	15	1947	1947	CD
18637	17791	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17791	17	.	.	.
18637	17792	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17792	2	59	59	CD
18637	17792	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17792	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17792	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17792	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17792	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17792	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17792	9	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	17792	10	,	,	,
18637	17792	11	312	312	CD
18637	17792	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17792	13	100	100	CD
18637	17792	14	,	,	,
18637	17792	15	125	125	CD
18637	17792	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17792	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	17792	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17792	19	.	.	.
18637	17793	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17793	2	60	60	CD
18637	17793	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17793	4	Nash	Nash	NNP
18637	17793	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17793	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17793	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17793	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17793	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17793	10	,	,	,
18637	17793	11	229	229	CD
18637	17793	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17793	13	373	373	CD
18637	17793	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17793	15	1913	1913	CD
18637	17793	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17793	17	.	.	.
18637	17794	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17794	2	61	61	CD
18637	17794	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17794	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17794	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17794	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17794	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17794	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17794	9	Alford	Alford	NNP
18637	17794	10	,	,	,
18637	17794	11	274	274	CD
18637	17794	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17794	13	264	264	CD
18637	17794	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17794	15	1927	1927	CD
18637	17794	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17794	17	.	.	.
18637	17795	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17795	2	62	62	CD
18637	17795	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17795	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17795	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17795	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17795	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17795	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17795	9	Wurzbach	Wurzbach	NNP
18637	17795	10	,	,	,
18637	17795	11	280	280	CD
18637	17795	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17795	13	396	396	CD
18637	17795	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17795	15	1930	1930	CD
18637	17795	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17795	17	.	.	.
18637	17796	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17796	2	63	63	CD
18637	17796	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17796	4	Gorin	Gorin	NNP
18637	17796	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17796	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17796	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17796	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17796	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17796	10	,	,	,
18637	17796	11	312	312	CD
18637	17796	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17796	13	19	19	CD
18637	17796	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17796	15	1941	1941	CD
18637	17796	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17796	17	.	.	.
18637	17797	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17797	2	64	64	CD
18637	17797	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17797	4	Kay	Kay	NNP
18637	17797	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17797	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17797	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17797	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17797	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17797	10	,	,	,
18637	17797	11	303	303	CD
18637	17797	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17797	13	1	1	CD
18637	17797	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17797	15	1938	1938	CD
18637	17797	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17797	17	.	.	.
18637	17798	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17798	2	65	65	CD
18637	17798	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17798	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17798	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17798	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17798	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17798	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17798	9	Shreveport	Shreveport	NNP
18637	17798	10	Grain	Grain	NNP
18637	17798	11	&	&	CC
18637	17798	12	Elevator	Elevator	NNP
18637	17798	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17798	14	,	,	,
18637	17798	15	287	287	CD
18637	17798	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17798	17	77	77	CD
18637	17798	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17798	19	1932	1932	CD
18637	17798	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17798	21	.	.	.
18637	17799	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17799	2	66	66	CD
18637	17799	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17799	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17799	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17799	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17799	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17799	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17799	9	Cruikshank	Cruikshank	NNP
18637	17799	10	,	,	,
18637	17799	11	92	92	CD
18637	17799	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17799	13	542	542	CD
18637	17799	14	,	,	,
18637	17799	15	544	544	CD
18637	17799	16	,	,	,
18637	17799	17	558	558	CD
18637	17799	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17799	19	1876	1876	CD
18637	17799	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17799	21	;	;	:
18637	17799	22	United	United	NNP
18637	17799	23	States	States	NNP
18637	17799	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17799	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	17799	26	_	_	NNP
18637	17799	27	Simmons	Simmons	NNP
18637	17799	28	,	,	,
18637	17799	29	96	96	CD
18637	17799	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17799	31	360	360	CD
18637	17799	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17799	33	1878	1878	CD
18637	17799	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17799	35	;	;	:
18637	17799	36	Bartell	Bartell	NNP
18637	17799	37	_	_	NNP
18637	17799	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	17799	39	_	_	NNP
18637	17799	40	United	United	NNP
18637	17799	41	States	States	NNP
18637	17799	42	,	,	,
18637	17799	43	227	227	CD
18637	17799	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17799	45	427	427	CD
18637	17799	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17799	47	1913	1913	CD
18637	17799	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17799	49	;	;	:
18637	17799	50	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	17799	51	_	_	NNP
18637	17799	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	17799	53	_	_	NNP
18637	17799	54	United	United	NNP
18637	17799	55	States	States	NNP
18637	17799	56	,	,	,
18637	17799	57	202	202	CD
18637	17799	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17799	59	344	344	CD
18637	17799	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17799	61	1906	1906	CD
18637	17799	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17799	63	.	.	.
18637	17800	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17800	2	67	67	CD
18637	17800	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17800	4	Potter	Potter	NNP
18637	17800	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17800	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17800	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17800	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17800	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17800	10	,	,	,
18637	17800	11	155	155	CD
18637	17800	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17800	13	438	438	CD
18637	17800	14	,	,	,
18637	17800	15	444	444	CD
18637	17800	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17800	17	1894	1894	CD
18637	17800	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17800	19	.	.	.
18637	17801	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17801	2	68	68	CD
18637	17801	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17801	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17801	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17801	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17801	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17801	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17801	9	Carll	Carll	NNP
18637	17801	10	,	,	,
18637	17801	11	105	105	CD
18637	17801	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17801	13	611	611	CD
18637	17801	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17801	15	1882	1882	CD
18637	17801	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17801	17	.	.	.
18637	17802	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17802	2	69	69	CD
18637	17802	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17802	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17802	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17802	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17802	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17802	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17802	9	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	17802	10	,	,	,
18637	17802	11	17	17	CD
18637	17802	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17802	13	.	.	.
18637	17803	1	168	168	CD
18637	17803	2	,	,	,
18637	17803	3	174	174	CD
18637	17803	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17803	5	1872	1872	CD
18637	17803	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17803	7	.	.	.
18637	17804	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17804	2	70	70	CD
18637	17804	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17804	4	Rosen	Rosen	NNP
18637	17804	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17804	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17804	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17804	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17804	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17804	10	,	,	,
18637	17804	11	161	161	CD
18637	17804	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17804	13	29	29	CD
18637	17804	14	,	,	,
18637	17804	15	40	40	CD
18637	17804	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17804	17	1896	1896	CD
18637	17804	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17804	19	.	.	.
18637	17805	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17805	2	71	71	CD
18637	17805	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17805	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17805	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17805	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17805	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17805	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17805	9	Van	Van	NNP
18637	17805	10	Duzee	Duzee	NNP
18637	17805	11	,	,	,
18637	17805	12	140	140	CD
18637	17805	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17805	14	169	169	CD
18637	17805	15	,	,	,
18637	17805	16	173	173	CD
18637	17805	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17805	18	1891	1891	CD
18637	17805	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17805	20	.	.	.
18637	17806	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17806	2	72	72	CD
18637	17806	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17806	4	Salinger	Salinger	NNP
18637	17806	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17806	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17806	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17806	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17806	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17806	10	,	,	,
18637	17806	11	272	272	CD
18637	17806	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17806	13	542	542	CD
18637	17806	14	,	,	,
18637	17806	15	548	548	CD
18637	17806	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17806	17	1926	1926	CD
18637	17806	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17806	19	.	.	.
18637	17807	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17807	2	73	73	CD
18637	17807	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17807	4	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	17807	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17807	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17807	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17807	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17807	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17807	10	,	,	,
18637	17807	11	221	221	CD
18637	17807	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17807	13	361	361	CD
18637	17807	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17807	15	1911	1911	CD
18637	17807	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17807	17	.	.	.
18637	17808	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17808	2	74	74	CD
18637	17808	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17808	4	Kirby	Kirby	NNP
18637	17808	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17808	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17808	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17808	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17808	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17808	10	,	,	,
18637	17808	11	174	174	CD
18637	17808	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17808	13	47	47	CD
18637	17808	14	,	,	,
18637	17808	15	61	61	CD
18637	17808	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17808	17	1809	1809	CD
18637	17808	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17808	19	;	;	:
18637	17808	20	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	17808	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17808	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	17808	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17808	24	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	17808	25	,	,	,
18637	17808	26	165	165	CD
18637	17808	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17808	28	275	275	CD
18637	17808	29	,	,	,
18637	17808	30	282	282	CD
18637	17808	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17808	32	1897	1897	CD
18637	17808	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17808	34	.	.	.
18637	17809	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17809	2	75	75	CD
18637	17809	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17809	4	Mattox	Mattox	NNP
18637	17809	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17809	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17809	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17809	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17809	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17809	10	,	,	,
18637	17809	11	156	156	CD
18637	17809	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17809	13	237	237	CD
18637	17809	14	,	,	,
18637	17809	15	240	240	CD
18637	17809	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17809	17	1895	1895	CD
18637	17809	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17809	19	.	.	.
18637	17810	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17810	2	76	76	CD
18637	17810	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17810	4	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	17810	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17810	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17810	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17810	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17810	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17810	10	,	,	,
18637	17810	11	98	98	CD
18637	17810	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17810	13	145	145	CD
18637	17810	14	,	,	,
18637	17810	15	160	160	CD
18637	17810	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17810	17	1879	1879	CD
18637	17810	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17810	19	.	.	.
18637	17811	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17811	2	77	77	CD
18637	17811	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17811	4	Motes	Motes	NNP
18637	17811	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17811	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17811	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17811	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17811	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17811	10	,	,	,
18637	17811	11	178	178	CD
18637	17811	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17811	13	458	458	CD
18637	17811	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17811	15	1900	1900	CD
18637	17811	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17811	17	.	.	.
18637	17812	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17812	2	78	78	CD
18637	17812	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17812	4	Kirby	Kirby	NNP
18637	17812	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17812	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17812	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17812	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17812	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17812	10	,	,	,
18637	17812	11	174	174	CD
18637	17812	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17812	13	47	47	CD
18637	17812	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17812	15	1899	1899	CD
18637	17812	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17812	17	.	.	.
18637	17813	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17813	2	79	79	CD
18637	17813	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17813	4	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	17813	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17813	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17813	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17813	8	Zerbst	Zerbst	NNP
18637	17813	9	,	,	,
18637	17813	10	304	304	CD
18637	17813	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17813	12	458	458	CD
18637	17813	13	,	,	,
18637	17813	14	463	463	CD
18637	17813	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17813	16	1938	1938	CD
18637	17813	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17813	18	.	.	.
18637	17814	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17814	2	80	80	CD
18637	17814	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17814	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17814	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17814	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17814	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	17814	8	.	.	.
18637	17815	1	Bilokumsky	Bilokumsky	NNP
18637	17815	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17815	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17815	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17815	5	Tod	Tod	NNP
18637	17815	6	,	,	,
18637	17815	7	263	263	CD
18637	17815	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17815	9	149	149	CD
18637	17815	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17815	11	1923	1923	CD
18637	17815	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17815	13	.	.	.
18637	17816	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17816	2	81	81	CD
18637	17816	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17816	4	Glasser	Glasser	NNP
18637	17816	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17816	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17816	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17816	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17816	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17816	10	,	,	,
18637	17816	11	315	315	CD
18637	17816	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17816	13	60	60	CD
18637	17816	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17816	15	1942	1942	CD
18637	17816	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17816	17	.	.	.
18637	17817	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17817	2	82	82	CD
18637	17817	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17817	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17817	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17817	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17817	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17817	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17817	9	Hayman	Hayman	NNP
18637	17817	10	,	,	,
18637	17817	11	342	342	CD
18637	17817	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17817	13	205	205	CD
18637	17817	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17817	15	1952	1952	CD
18637	17817	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17817	17	.	.	.
18637	17818	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17818	2	83	83	CD
18637	17818	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17818	4	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	17818	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17818	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17818	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17818	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17818	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17818	10	,	,	,
18637	17818	11	317	317	CD
18637	17818	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17818	13	269	269	CD
18637	17818	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17818	15	1942	1942	CD
18637	17818	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17818	17	.	.	.
18637	17819	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17819	2	84	84	CD
18637	17819	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17819	4	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	17819	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17819	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17819	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17819	8	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	17819	9	,	,	,
18637	17819	10	312	312	CD
18637	17819	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17819	12	275	275	CD
18637	17819	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17819	14	1941	1941	CD
18637	17819	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17819	16	;	;	:
18637	17819	17	Von	Von	NNP
18637	17819	18	Moltke	Moltke	NNP
18637	17819	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17819	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	17819	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17819	22	Gillies	Gillies	NNPS
18637	17819	23	,	,	,
18637	17819	24	332	332	CD
18637	17819	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17819	26	708	708	CD
18637	17819	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17819	28	1948	1948	CD
18637	17819	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17819	30	.	.	.
18637	17820	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17820	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17820	3	also	also	RB
18637	17820	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17820	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17820	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17820	7	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17820	8	rel	rel	NN
18637	17820	9	.	.	.
18637	17821	1	McCann	McCann	NNP
18637	17821	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17821	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17821	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17821	5	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	17821	6	,	,	,
18637	17821	7	320	320	CD
18637	17821	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17821	9	220	220	CD
18637	17821	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17821	11	1943	1943	CD
18637	17821	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17821	13	.	.	.
18637	17822	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	17822	2	7	7	CD
18637	17822	3	CIVIL	civil	NN
18637	17822	4	TRIALS	trial	NNS
18637	17822	5	Page	page	NN
18637	17822	6	Trial	trial	NN
18637	17822	7	by	by	IN
18637	17822	8	jury	jury	NN
18637	17822	9	in	in	IN
18637	17822	10	civil	civil	JJ
18637	17822	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	17822	12	891	891	CD
18637	17822	13	Origin	origin	NN
18637	17822	14	and	and	CC
18637	17822	15	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	17822	16	of	of	IN
18637	17822	17	the	the	DT
18637	17822	18	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	17822	19	891	891	CD
18637	17822	20	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	17822	21	by	by	IN
18637	17822	22	jury	jury	NN
18637	17822	23	,	,	,
18637	17822	24	elements	element	NNS
18637	17822	25	of	of	IN
18637	17822	26	,	,	,
18637	17822	27	preserved	preserve	VBD
18637	17822	28	891	891	CD
18637	17822	29	To	to	IN
18637	17822	30	what	what	WP
18637	17822	31	courts	court	NNS
18637	17822	32	and	and	CC
18637	17822	33	cases	case	NNS
18637	17822	34	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	17822	35	892	892	CD
18637	17822	36	Cases	case	NNS
18637	17822	37	not	not	RB
18637	17822	38	governed	govern	VBN
18637	17822	39	by	by	IN
18637	17822	40	the	the	DT
18637	17822	41	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	17822	42	893	893	CD
18637	17822	43	Restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	17822	44	force	force	NN
18637	17822	45	of	of	IN
18637	17822	46	the	the	DT
18637	17822	47	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	17822	48	894	894	CD
18637	17822	49	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	17822	50	and	and	CC
18637	17822	51	jury	jury	NN
18637	17822	52	895	895	CD
18637	17822	53	Line	line	NN
18637	17822	54	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	17822	55	by	by	IN
18637	17822	56	the	the	DT
18637	17822	57	common	common	JJ
18637	17822	58	law	law	NN
18637	17822	59	895	895	CD
18637	17822	60	Directed	direct	VBN
18637	17822	61	verdicts	verdict	NNS
18637	17822	62	896	896	CD
18637	17822	63	Waiver	waiver	NN
18637	17822	64	of	of	IN
18637	17822	65	right	right	NN
18637	17822	66	of	of	IN
18637	17822	67	trial	trial	NN
18637	17822	68	by	by	IN
18637	17822	69	jury	jury	NN
18637	17822	70	897	897	CD
18637	17822	71	Appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	17822	72	from	from	IN
18637	17822	73	State	state	NN
18637	17822	74	courts	court	NNS
18637	17822	75	to	to	IN
18637	17822	76	the	the	DT
18637	17822	77	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	17822	78	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17822	79	897	897	CD
18637	17822	80	CIVIL	civil	NN
18637	17822	81	TRIALS	trial	NNS
18637	17822	82	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17822	83	7	7	CD
18637	17822	84	In	in	IN
18637	17822	85	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	17822	86	at	at	IN
18637	17822	87	common	common	JJ
18637	17822	88	law	law	NN
18637	17822	89	,	,	,
18637	17822	90	where	where	WRB
18637	17822	91	the	the	DT
18637	17822	92	value	value	NN
18637	17822	93	in	in	IN
18637	17822	94	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	17822	95	shall	shall	MD
18637	17822	96	exceed	exceed	VB
18637	17822	97	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	17822	98	dollars	dollar	NNS
18637	17822	99	,	,	,
18637	17822	100	the	the	DT
18637	17822	101	right	right	NN
18637	17822	102	of	of	IN
18637	17822	103	trial	trial	NN
18637	17822	104	by	by	IN
18637	17822	105	jury	jury	NN
18637	17822	106	shall	shall	MD
18637	17822	107	be	be	VB
18637	17822	108	preserved	preserve	VBN
18637	17822	109	,	,	,
18637	17822	110	and	and	CC
18637	17822	111	no	no	DT
18637	17822	112	fact	fact	NN
18637	17822	113	tried	try	VBN
18637	17822	114	by	by	IN
18637	17822	115	a	a	DT
18637	17822	116	jury	jury	NN
18637	17822	117	,	,	,
18637	17822	118	shall	shall	MD
18637	17822	119	be	be	VB
18637	17822	120	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	17822	121	re	re	JJ
18637	17822	122	-	-	VBN
18637	17822	123	examined	examine	VBN
18637	17822	124	in	in	IN
18637	17822	125	any	any	DT
18637	17822	126	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17822	127	of	of	IN
18637	17822	128	the	the	DT
18637	17822	129	United	United	NNP
18637	17822	130	States	States	NNP
18637	17822	131	,	,	,
18637	17822	132	than	than	IN
18637	17822	133	according	accord	VBG
18637	17822	134	to	to	IN
18637	17822	135	the	the	DT
18637	17822	136	rules	rule	NNS
18637	17822	137	of	of	IN
18637	17822	138	the	the	DT
18637	17822	139	common	common	JJ
18637	17822	140	law	law	NN
18637	17822	141	.	.	.
18637	17823	1	Trial	trial	NN
18637	17823	2	by	by	IN
18637	17823	3	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	17823	4	in	in	IN
18637	17823	5	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	17823	6	Cases	case	NNS
18637	17823	7	ORIGIN	origin	NN
18637	17823	8	AND	and	CC
18637	17823	9	PURPOSE	purpose	NN
18637	17823	10	OF	of	IN
18637	17823	11	THE	the	DT
18637	17823	12	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	17823	13	Late	late	RB
18637	17823	14	in	in	IN
18637	17823	15	the	the	DT
18637	17823	16	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	17823	17	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	17823	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17823	19	was	be	VBD
18637	17823	20	moved	move	VBN
18637	17823	21	that	that	IN
18637	17823	22	a	a	DT
18637	17823	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	17823	24	be	be	VB
18637	17823	25	inserted	insert	VBN
18637	17823	26	in	in	IN
18637	17823	27	article	article	NN
18637	17823	28	III	III	NNP
18637	17823	29	,	,	,
18637	17823	30	section	section	NN
18637	17823	31	2	2	CD
18637	17823	32	of	of	IN
18637	17823	33	the	the	DT
18637	17823	34	draft	draft	NN
18637	17823	35	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	17823	36	to	to	TO
18637	17823	37	read	read	VB
18637	17823	38	"	"	``
18637	17823	39	*	*	NFP
18637	17823	40	*	*	NFP
18637	17823	41	*	*	NFP
18637	17823	42	and	and	CC
18637	17823	43	a	a	DT
18637	17823	44	trial	trial	NN
18637	17823	45	by	by	IN
18637	17823	46	jury	jury	NN
18637	17823	47	shall	shall	MD
18637	17823	48	be	be	VB
18637	17823	49	preserved	preserve	VBN
18637	17823	50	as	as	IN
18637	17823	51	usual	usual	JJ
18637	17823	52	in	in	IN
18637	17823	53	civil	civil	JJ
18637	17823	54	cases	case	NNS
18637	17823	55	.	.	.
18637	17823	56	"	"	''
18637	17824	1	The	the	DT
18637	17824	2	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	17824	3	failed	fail	VBD
18637	17824	4	when	when	WRB
18637	17824	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17824	6	was	be	VBD
18637	17824	7	pointed	point	VBN
18637	17824	8	out	out	RP
18637	17824	9	that	that	IN
18637	17824	10	the	the	DT
18637	17824	11	make	make	NN
18637	17824	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	17824	13	up	up	NN
18637	17824	14	and	and	CC
18637	17824	15	powers	power	NNS
18637	17824	16	of	of	IN
18637	17824	17	juries	jury	NNS
18637	17824	18	differed	differ	VBD
18637	17824	19	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	17824	20	in	in	IN
18637	17824	21	different	different	JJ
18637	17824	22	States	state	NNS
18637	17824	23	and	and	CC
18637	17824	24	that	that	IN
18637	17824	25	a	a	DT
18637	17824	26	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	17824	27	provision	provision	NN
18637	17824	28	for	for	IN
18637	17824	29	all	all	DT
18637	17824	30	States	States	NNP
18637	17824	31	was	be	VBD
18637	17824	32	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	17824	33	.	.	.
18637	17825	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17825	2	1	1	LS
18637	17825	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17825	4	The	the	DT
18637	17825	5	objection	objection	NN
18637	17825	6	evidently	evidently	RB
18637	17825	7	anticipated	anticipate	VBD
18637	17825	8	that	that	IN
18637	17825	9	in	in	IN
18637	17825	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	17825	11	falling	fall	VBG
18637	17825	12	to	to	IN
18637	17825	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17825	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	17825	15	on	on	IN
18637	17825	16	account	account	NN
18637	17825	17	of	of	IN
18637	17825	18	the	the	DT
18637	17825	19	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	17825	20	of	of	IN
18637	17825	21	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	17825	22	of	of	IN
18637	17825	23	the	the	DT
18637	17825	24	parties	party	NNS
18637	17825	25	,	,	,
18637	17825	26	the	the	DT
18637	17825	27	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17825	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	17825	29	would	would	MD
18637	17825	30	conform	conform	VB
18637	17825	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17825	32	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	17825	33	to	to	IN
18637	17825	34	the	the	DT
18637	17825	35	laws	law	NNS
18637	17825	36	of	of	IN
18637	17825	37	the	the	DT
18637	17825	38	several	several	JJ
18637	17825	39	States	state	NNS
18637	17825	40	.	.	.
18637	17826	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17826	2	2	2	LS
18637	17826	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17826	4	The	the	DT
18637	17826	5	omission	omission	NN
18637	17826	6	,	,	,
18637	17826	7	however	however	RB
18637	17826	8	,	,	,
18637	17826	9	raised	raise	VBD
18637	17826	10	an	an	DT
18637	17826	11	objection	objection	NN
18637	17826	12	to	to	IN
18637	17826	13	the	the	DT
18637	17826	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	17826	15	which	which	WDT
18637	17826	16	"	"	``
18637	17826	17	was	be	VBD
18637	17826	18	pressed	press	VBN
18637	17826	19	with	with	IN
18637	17826	20	an	an	DT
18637	17826	21	urgency	urgency	NN
18637	17826	22	and	and	CC
18637	17826	23	zeal	zeal	NN
18637	17826	24	*	*	NFP
18637	17826	25	*	*	NFP
18637	17826	26	*	*	NFP
18637	17826	27	well	well	NN
18637	17826	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	17826	29	nigh	nigh	NN
18637	17826	30	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	17826	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17826	32	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	17826	33	.	.	.
18637	17827	1	"	"	``
18637	17827	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17827	3	3	3	CD
18637	17827	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17827	5	Nor	nor	CC
18637	17827	6	was	be	VBD
18637	17827	7	the	the	DT
18637	17827	8	agitation	agitation	NN
18637	17827	9	assuaged	assuage	VBN
18637	17827	10	by	by	IN
18637	17827	11	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	17827	12	's	's	POS
18637	17827	13	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	17827	14	in	in	IN
18637	17827	15	The	the	DT
18637	17827	16	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	17827	17	that	that	IN
18637	17827	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17827	19	would	would	MD
18637	17827	20	have	have	VB
18637	17827	21	ample	ample	JJ
18637	17827	22	power	power	NN
18637	17827	23	,	,	,
18637	17827	24	in	in	IN
18637	17827	25	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	17827	26	the	the	DT
18637	17827	27	lower	low	JJR
18637	17827	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17827	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	17827	30	and	and	CC
18637	17827	31	in	in	IN
18637	17827	32	making	make	VBG
18637	17827	33	"	"	``
18637	17827	34	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	17827	35	"	"	''
18637	17827	36	to	to	IN
18637	17827	37	the	the	DT
18637	17827	38	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	17827	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17827	40	's	's	POS
18637	17827	41	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	17827	42	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	17827	43	,	,	,
18637	17827	44	to	to	TO
18637	17827	45	safeguard	safeguard	VB
18637	17827	46	jury	jury	NN
18637	17827	47	trial	trial	NN
18637	17827	48	in	in	IN
18637	17827	49	civil	civil	JJ
18637	17827	50	cases	case	NNS
18637	17827	51	according	accord	VBG
18637	17827	52	to	to	IN
18637	17827	53	the	the	DT
18637	17827	54	standards	standard	NNS
18637	17827	55	of	of	IN
18637	17827	56	the	the	DT
18637	17827	57	common	common	JJ
18637	17827	58	law	law	NN
18637	17827	59	.	.	.
18637	17828	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17828	2	4	4	LS
18637	17828	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17828	4	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17828	5	argument	argument	NN
18637	17828	6	bore	bear	VBD
18637	17828	7	fruit	fruit	NN
18637	17828	8	,	,	,
18637	17828	9	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	17828	10	,	,	,
18637	17828	11	in	in	IN
18637	17828	12	the	the	DT
18637	17828	13	Seventh	Seventh	NNP
18637	17828	14	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17828	15	,	,	,
18637	17828	16	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	17828	17	,	,	,
18637	17828	18	in	in	IN
18637	17828	19	the	the	DT
18637	17828	20	words	word	NNS
18637	17828	21	of	of	IN
18637	17828	22	the	the	DT
18637	17828	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17828	24	,	,	,
18637	17828	25	the	the	DT
18637	17828	26	right	right	NN
18637	17828	27	of	of	IN
18637	17828	28	trial	trial	NN
18637	17828	29	by	by	IN
18637	17828	30	jury	jury	NN
18637	17828	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	17828	32	preserved	preserve	VBN
18637	17828	33	as	as	IN
18637	17828	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17828	35	"	"	``
18637	17828	36	existed	exist	VBD
18637	17828	37	under	under	IN
18637	17828	38	the	the	DT
18637	17828	39	English	english	JJ
18637	17828	40	common	common	JJ
18637	17828	41	law	law	NN
18637	17828	42	when	when	WRB
18637	17828	43	the	the	DT
18637	17828	44	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	17828	45	was	be	VBD
18637	17828	46	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	17828	47	.	.	.
18637	17829	1	"	"	``
18637	17829	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17829	3	5	5	CD
18637	17829	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17829	5	TRIAL	trial	NN
18637	17829	6	BY	by	IN
18637	17829	7	JURY	JURY	NNS
18637	17829	8	,	,	,
18637	17829	9	ELEMENTS	element	NNS
18637	17829	10	OF	of	IN
18637	17829	11	,	,	,
18637	17829	12	PRESERVED	preserve	VBN
18637	17829	13	"	"	``
18637	17829	14	Trial	trial	NN
18637	17829	15	by	by	IN
18637	17829	16	jury	jury	NN
18637	17829	17	,	,	,
18637	17829	18	"	"	``
18637	17829	19	in	in	IN
18637	17829	20	the	the	DT
18637	17829	21	sense	sense	NN
18637	17829	22	of	of	IN
18637	17829	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17829	24	VII	VII	NNP
18637	17829	25	,	,	,
18637	17829	26	"	"	''
18637	17829	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	17829	28	a	a	DT
18637	17829	29	trial	trial	NN
18637	17829	30	by	by	IN
18637	17829	31	a	a	DT
18637	17829	32	jury	jury	NN
18637	17829	33	of	of	IN
18637	17829	34	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	17829	35	men	man	NNS
18637	17829	36	,	,	,
18637	17829	37	in	in	IN
18637	17829	38	the	the	DT
18637	17829	39	presence	presence	NN
18637	17829	40	and	and	CC
18637	17829	41	under	under	IN
18637	17829	42	the	the	DT
18637	17829	43	superintendence	superintendence	NN
18637	17829	44	of	of	IN
18637	17829	45	a	a	DT
18637	17829	46	judge	judge	NN
18637	17829	47	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	17829	48	to	to	TO
18637	17829	49	instruct	instruct	VB
18637	17829	50	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17829	51	on	on	IN
18637	17829	52	the	the	DT
18637	17829	53	law	law	NN
18637	17829	54	and	and	CC
18637	17829	55	to	to	TO
18637	17829	56	advise	advise	VB
18637	17829	57	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17829	58	on	on	IN
18637	17829	59	the	the	DT
18637	17829	60	facts	fact	NNS
18637	17829	61	and	and	CC
18637	17829	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17829	63	except	except	IN
18637	17829	64	in	in	IN
18637	17829	65	acquittal	acquittal	NN
18637	17829	66	of	of	IN
18637	17829	67	a	a	DT
18637	17829	68	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	17829	69	charge	charge	NN
18637	17829	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17829	71	to	to	TO
18637	17829	72	set	set	VB
18637	17829	73	aside	aside	RP
18637	17829	74	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17829	75	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	17829	76	if	if	IN
18637	17829	77	in	in	IN
18637	17829	78	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17829	79	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17829	80	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17829	81	is	be	VBZ
18637	17829	82	against	against	IN
18637	17829	83	the	the	DT
18637	17829	84	law	law	NN
18637	17829	85	or	or	CC
18637	17829	86	the	the	DT
18637	17829	87	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17829	88	.	.	.
18637	17830	1	"	"	``
18637	17830	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17830	3	6	6	CD
18637	17830	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17830	5	A	a	DT
18637	17830	6	further	further	JJ
18637	17830	7	requisite	requisite	NN
18637	17830	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	17830	9	"	"	``
18637	17830	10	that	that	IN
18637	17830	11	there	there	EX
18637	17830	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	17830	13	be	be	VB
18637	17830	14	a	a	DT
18637	17830	15	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	17830	16	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	17830	17	of	of	IN
18637	17830	18	the	the	DT
18637	17830	19	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	17830	20	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	17830	21	in	in	IN
18637	17830	22	all	all	DT
18637	17830	23	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17830	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	17830	25	where	where	WRB
18637	17830	26	a	a	DT
18637	17830	27	jury	jury	NN
18637	17830	28	trial	trial	NN
18637	17830	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	17830	30	held	hold	VBN
18637	17830	31	.	.	.
18637	17831	1	"	"	``
18637	17831	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17831	3	7	7	CD
18637	17831	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17831	5	Assuming	assume	VBG
18637	17831	6	such	such	PDT
18637	17831	7	a	a	DT
18637	17831	8	jury	jury	NN
18637	17831	9	,	,	,
18637	17831	10	the	the	DT
18637	17831	11	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	17831	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	17831	13	for	for	IN
18637	17831	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17831	15	primary	primary	JJ
18637	17831	16	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	17831	17	the	the	DT
18637	17831	18	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	17831	19	of	of	IN
18637	17831	20	"	"	``
18637	17831	21	*	*	NFP
18637	17831	22	*	*	NFP
18637	17831	23	*	*	NFP
18637	17831	24	the	the	DT
18637	17831	25	common	common	JJ
18637	17831	26	law	law	NN
18637	17831	27	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	17831	28	between	between	IN
18637	17831	29	the	the	DT
18637	17831	30	province	province	NN
18637	17831	31	of	of	IN
18637	17831	32	the	the	DT
18637	17831	33	court	court	NN
18637	17831	34	and	and	CC
18637	17831	35	that	that	DT
18637	17831	36	of	of	IN
18637	17831	37	the	the	DT
18637	17831	38	jury	jury	NN
18637	17831	39	,	,	,
18637	17831	40	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	17831	41	,	,	,
18637	17831	42	in	in	IN
18637	17831	43	the	the	DT
18637	17831	44	absence	absence	NN
18637	17831	45	of	of	IN
18637	17831	46	express	express	JJ
18637	17831	47	or	or	CC
18637	17831	48	implied	imply	VBN
18637	17831	49	consent	consent	NN
18637	17831	50	to	to	IN
18637	17831	51	the	the	DT
18637	17831	52	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	17831	53	,	,	,
18637	17831	54	issues	issue	NNS
18637	17831	55	of	of	IN
18637	17831	56	law	law	NN
18637	17831	57	are	be	VBP
18637	17831	58	resolved	resolve	VBN
18637	17831	59	by	by	IN
18637	17831	60	the	the	DT
18637	17831	61	court	court	NN
18637	17831	62	and	and	CC
18637	17831	63	issues	issue	NNS
18637	17831	64	of	of	IN
18637	17831	65	fact	fact	NN
18637	17831	66	are	be	VBP
18637	17831	67	to	to	TO
18637	17831	68	be	be	VB
18637	17831	69	determined	determine	VBN
18637	17831	70	by	by	IN
18637	17831	71	the	the	DT
18637	17831	72	jury	jury	NN
18637	17831	73	under	under	IN
18637	17831	74	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	17831	75	instructions	instruction	NNS
18637	17831	76	by	by	IN
18637	17831	77	the	the	DT
18637	17831	78	court	court	NN
18637	17831	79	.	.	.
18637	17832	1	"	"	``
18637	17832	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17832	3	8	8	CD
18637	17832	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17832	5	But	but	CC
18637	17832	6	the	the	DT
18637	17832	7	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	17832	8	"	"	``
18637	17832	9	does	do	VBZ
18637	17832	10	not	not	RB
18637	17832	11	exact	exact	VB
18637	17832	12	the	the	DT
18637	17832	13	retention	retention	NN
18637	17832	14	of	of	IN
18637	17832	15	old	old	JJ
18637	17832	16	forms	form	NNS
18637	17832	17	of	of	IN
18637	17832	18	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	17832	19	"	"	''
18637	17832	20	nor	nor	CC
18637	17832	21	does	do	VBZ
18637	17832	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17832	23	"	"	``
18637	17832	24	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	17832	25	the	the	DT
18637	17832	26	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	17832	27	of	of	IN
18637	17832	28	new	new	JJ
18637	17832	29	methods	method	NNS
18637	17832	30	of	of	IN
18637	17832	31	ascertaining	ascertain	VBG
18637	17832	32	what	what	WDT
18637	17832	33	facts	fact	NNS
18637	17832	34	are	be	VBP
18637	17832	35	in	in	IN
18637	17832	36	issue	issue	NN
18637	17832	37	*	*	NFP
18637	17832	38	*	*	NFP
18637	17832	39	*	*	NFP
18637	17832	40	"	"	''
18637	17832	41	or	or	CC
18637	17832	42	new	new	JJ
18637	17832	43	rules	rule	NNS
18637	17832	44	of	of	IN
18637	17832	45	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17832	46	.	.	.
18637	17833	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17833	2	9	9	CD
18637	17833	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17833	4	TO	to	IN
18637	17833	5	WHAT	what	WDT
18637	17833	6	COURTS	court	NNS
18637	17833	7	AND	and	CC
18637	17833	8	CASES	case	NNS
18637	17833	9	APPLICABLE	APPLICABLE	NNP
18637	17833	10	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17833	11	VII	VII	NNP
18637	17833	12	governs	govern	VBZ
18637	17833	13	only	only	RB
18637	17833	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	17833	15	which	which	WDT
18637	17833	16	sit	sit	VBP
18637	17833	17	under	under	IN
18637	17833	18	the	the	DT
18637	17833	19	authority	authority	NN
18637	17833	20	of	of	IN
18637	17833	21	the	the	DT
18637	17833	22	United	United	NNP
18637	17833	23	States,[10	States,[10	NNP
18637	17833	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17833	25	including	include	VBG
18637	17833	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	17833	27	in	in	IN
18637	17833	28	the	the	DT
18637	17833	29	territories[11	territories[11	NNP
18637	17833	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17833	31	and	and	CC
18637	17833	32	the	the	DT
18637	17833	33	District	District	NNP
18637	17833	34	of	of	IN
18637	17833	35	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	17833	36	.	.	.
18637	17834	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17834	2	12	12	CD
18637	17834	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17834	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17834	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	17834	6	not	not	RB
18637	17834	7	apply	apply	VB
18637	17834	8	to	to	IN
18637	17834	9	a	a	DT
18637	17834	10	State	State	NNP
18637	17834	11	court	court	NN
18637	17834	12	even	even	RB
18637	17834	13	when	when	WRB
18637	17834	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17834	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	17834	16	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	17834	17	a	a	DT
18637	17834	18	right	right	JJ
18637	17834	19	created	create	VBN
18637	17834	20	by	by	IN
18637	17834	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17834	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	17834	23	.	.	.
18637	17835	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17835	2	13	13	CD
18637	17835	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17835	4	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17835	5	coverage	coverage	NN
18637	17835	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	17835	7	"	"	``
18637	17835	8	*	*	NFP
18637	17835	9	*	*	NFP
18637	17835	10	*	*	NFP
18637	17835	11	limited	limit	VBN
18637	17835	12	to	to	IN
18637	17835	13	rights	right	NNS
18637	17835	14	and	and	CC
18637	17835	15	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	17835	16	peculiarly	peculiarly	RB
18637	17835	17	legal	legal	JJ
18637	17835	18	in	in	IN
18637	17835	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17835	20	nature	nature	NN
18637	17835	21	,	,	,
18637	17835	22	and	and	CC
18637	17835	23	such	such	JJ
18637	17835	24	as	as	IN
18637	17835	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17835	26	was	be	VBD
18637	17835	27	proper	proper	JJ
18637	17835	28	to	to	TO
18637	17835	29	assert	assert	VB
18637	17835	30	in	in	IN
18637	17835	31	courts	court	NNS
18637	17835	32	of	of	IN
18637	17835	33	law	law	NN
18637	17835	34	and	and	CC
18637	17835	35	by	by	IN
18637	17835	36	the	the	DT
18637	17835	37	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	17835	38	modes	mode	NNS
18637	17835	39	and	and	CC
18637	17835	40	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	17835	41	of	of	IN
18637	17835	42	courts	court	NNS
18637	17835	43	of	of	IN
18637	17835	44	law	law	NN
18637	17835	45	.	.	.
18637	17836	1	"	"	``
18637	17836	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17836	3	14	14	CD
18637	17836	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17836	5	The	the	DT
18637	17836	6	term	term	NN
18637	17836	7	"	"	``
18637	17836	8	common	common	JJ
18637	17836	9	law	law	NN
18637	17836	10	"	"	''
18637	17836	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	17836	12	used	use	VBN
18637	17836	13	in	in	IN
18637	17836	14	contradistinction	contradistinction	NN
18637	17836	15	to	to	IN
18637	17836	16	suits	suit	NNS
18637	17836	17	in	in	IN
18637	17836	18	which	which	WDT
18637	17836	19	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	17836	20	rights	right	NNS
18637	17836	21	alone	alone	RB
18637	17836	22	were	be	VBD
18637	17836	23	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	17836	24	at	at	IN
18637	17836	25	the	the	DT
18637	17836	26	time	time	NN
18637	17836	27	of	of	IN
18637	17836	28	the	the	DT
18637	17836	29	framing	framing	NN
18637	17836	30	of	of	IN
18637	17836	31	the	the	DT
18637	17836	32	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	17836	33	and	and	CC
18637	17836	34	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	17836	35	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	17836	36	were	be	VBD
18637	17836	37	administered	administer	VBN
18637	17836	38	.	.	.
18637	17837	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17837	2	15	15	CD
18637	17837	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17837	4	Hence	hence	RB
18637	17837	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17837	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	17837	7	not	not	RB
18637	17837	8	apply	apply	VB
18637	17837	9	to	to	IN
18637	17837	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	17837	11	where	where	WRB
18637	17837	12	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	17837	13	of	of	IN
18637	17837	14	money	money	NN
18637	17837	15	damages	damage	NNS
18637	17837	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	17837	17	incident	incident	NN
18637	17837	18	to	to	TO
18637	17837	19	equitable	equitable	VB
18637	17837	20	relief	relief	NN
18637	17837	21	even	even	RB
18637	17837	22	though	though	IN
18637	17837	23	damages	damage	NNS
18637	17837	24	might	may	MD
18637	17837	25	have	have	VB
18637	17837	26	been	be	VBN
18637	17837	27	recovered	recover	VBN
18637	17837	28	in	in	IN
18637	17837	29	an	an	DT
18637	17837	30	action	action	NN
18637	17837	31	at	at	IN
18637	17837	32	law	law	NN
18637	17837	33	.	.	.
18637	17838	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17838	2	16	16	CD
18637	17838	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17838	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	17838	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	17838	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17838	7	apply	apply	VB
18637	17838	8	to	to	IN
18637	17838	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	17838	10	in	in	IN
18637	17838	11	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	17838	12	and	and	CC
18637	17838	13	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	17838	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	17838	15	,	,	,
18637	17838	16	in	in	IN
18637	17838	17	which	which	WDT
18637	17838	18	the	the	DT
18637	17838	19	trial	trial	NN
18637	17838	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	17838	21	by	by	IN
18637	17838	22	a	a	DT
18637	17838	23	court	court	NN
18637	17838	24	without	without	IN
18637	17838	25	a	a	DT
18637	17838	26	jury	jury	NN
18637	17838	27	.	.	.
18637	17839	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17839	2	17	17	CD
18637	17839	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17839	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	17839	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	17839	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17839	7	reach	reach	VB
18637	17839	8	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	17839	9	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	17839	10	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	17839	11	to	to	IN
18637	17839	12	the	the	DT
18637	17839	13	common	common	JJ
18637	17839	14	law	law	NN
18637	17839	15	,	,	,
18637	17839	16	such	such	JJ
18637	17839	17	as	as	IN
18637	17839	18	an	an	DT
18637	17839	19	application	application	NN
18637	17839	20	to	to	IN
18637	17839	21	a	a	DT
18637	17839	22	court	court	NN
18637	17839	23	of	of	IN
18637	17839	24	equity	equity	NN
18637	17839	25	to	to	TO
18637	17839	26	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	17839	27	an	an	DT
18637	17839	28	order	order	NN
18637	17839	29	of	of	IN
18637	17839	30	an	an	DT
18637	17839	31	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	17839	32	body	body	NN
18637	17839	33	.	.	.
18637	17840	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17840	2	18	18	CD
18637	17840	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17840	4	CASES	case	NNS
18637	17840	5	NOT	not	RB
18637	17840	6	GOVERNED	governed	VBP
18637	17840	7	BY	by	IN
18637	17840	8	THE	the	DT
18637	17840	9	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	17840	10	Omission	Omission	NNP
18637	17840	11	of	of	IN
18637	17840	12	a	a	DT
18637	17840	13	jury	jury	NN
18637	17840	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	17840	15	been	be	VBN
18637	17840	16	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	17840	17	in	in	IN
18637	17840	18	the	the	DT
18637	17840	19	following	follow	VBG
18637	17840	20	instances	instance	NNS
18637	17840	21	on	on	IN
18637	17840	22	the	the	DT
18637	17840	23	ground	ground	NN
18637	17840	24	that	that	IN
18637	17840	25	the	the	DT
18637	17840	26	suit	suit	NN
18637	17840	27	in	in	IN
18637	17840	28	question	question	NN
18637	17840	29	was	be	VBD
18637	17840	30	not	not	RB
18637	17840	31	a	a	DT
18637	17840	32	suit	suit	NN
18637	17840	33	at	at	IN
18637	17840	34	common	common	JJ
18637	17840	35	law	law	NN
18637	17840	36	within	within	IN
18637	17840	37	the	the	DT
18637	17840	38	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	17840	39	of	of	IN
18637	17840	40	the	the	DT
18637	17840	41	Seventh	Seventh	NNP
18637	17840	42	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17840	43	;	;	:
18637	17840	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17840	45	1	1	LS
18637	17840	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17840	47	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	17840	48	to	to	TO
18637	17840	49	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	17840	50	claims	claim	NNS
18637	17840	51	against	against	IN
18637	17840	52	the	the	DT
18637	17840	53	United	United	NNP
18637	17840	54	States	States	NNP
18637	17840	55	.	.	.
18637	17841	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17841	2	19	19	CD
18637	17841	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17841	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17841	5	2	2	LS
18637	17841	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17841	7	Suit	suit	NN
18637	17841	8	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	17841	9	by	by	IN
18637	17841	10	Territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	17841	11	law	law	NN
18637	17841	12	against	against	IN
18637	17841	13	a	a	DT
18637	17841	14	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	17841	15	,	,	,
18637	17841	16	based	base	VBN
18637	17841	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	17841	18	a	a	DT
18637	17841	19	moral	moral	JJ
18637	17841	20	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	17841	21	only	only	RB
18637	17841	22	.	.	.
18637	17842	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17842	2	20	20	CD
18637	17842	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17842	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17842	5	3	3	LS
18637	17842	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17842	7	Suit	suit	NN
18637	17842	8	to	to	TO
18637	17842	9	cancel	cancel	VB
18637	17842	10	a	a	DT
18637	17842	11	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	17842	12	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	17842	13	for	for	IN
18637	17842	14	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	17842	15	.	.	.
18637	17843	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17843	2	21	21	CD
18637	17843	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17843	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17843	5	4	4	LS
18637	17843	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17843	7	Order	order	NN
18637	17843	8	of	of	IN
18637	17843	9	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	17843	10	of	of	IN
18637	17843	11	an	an	DT
18637	17843	12	alien	alien	NN
18637	17843	13	.	.	.
18637	17844	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17844	2	22	22	CD
18637	17844	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17844	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17844	5	5	5	LS
18637	17844	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17844	7	Assessment	assessment	NN
18637	17844	8	of	of	IN
18637	17844	9	damages	damage	NNS
18637	17844	10	in	in	IN
18637	17844	11	patent	patent	NN
18637	17844	12	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	17844	13	suit	suit	NN
18637	17844	14	.	.	.
18637	17845	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17845	2	23	23	CD
18637	17845	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17845	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17845	5	6	6	CD
18637	17845	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17845	7	Longshoremen	Longshoremen	NNP
18637	17845	8	's	's	POS
18637	17845	9	and	and	CC
18637	17845	10	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	17845	11	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	17845	12	'	'	POS
18637	17845	13	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	17845	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	17845	15	.	.	.
18637	17846	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17846	2	24	24	CD
18637	17846	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17846	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17846	5	7	7	LS
18637	17846	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17846	7	Jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	17846	8	of	of	IN
18637	17846	9	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	17846	10	court	court	NN
18637	17846	11	to	to	TO
18637	17846	12	examine	examine	VB
18637	17846	13	into	into	IN
18637	17846	14	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	17846	15	of	of	IN
18637	17846	16	fees	fee	NNS
18637	17846	17	paid	pay	VBN
18637	17846	18	by	by	IN
18637	17846	19	person	person	NN
18637	17846	20	for	for	IN
18637	17846	21	legal	legal	JJ
18637	17846	22	services	service	NNS
18637	17846	23	in	in	IN
18637	17846	24	contemplation	contemplation	NN
18637	17846	25	of	of	IN
18637	17846	26	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	17846	27	.	.	.
18637	17847	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17847	2	25	25	CD
18637	17847	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17847	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17847	5	8)	8)	CD
18637	17847	6	Final	final	JJ
18637	17847	7	decision	decision	NN
18637	17847	8	of	of	IN
18637	17847	9	customs	custom	NNS
18637	17847	10	appraisers	appraiser	NNS
18637	17847	11	in	in	IN
18637	17847	12	regard	regard	NN
18637	17847	13	to	to	IN
18637	17847	14	value	value	NN
18637	17847	15	of	of	IN
18637	17847	16	imports	import	NNS
18637	17847	17	.	.	.
18637	17848	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17848	2	26	26	CD
18637	17848	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17848	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17848	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	17848	6	been	be	VBN
18637	17848	7	further	far	RBR
18637	17848	8	held	hold	VBN
18637	17848	9	that	that	IN
18637	17848	10	there	there	EX
18637	17848	11	was	be	VBD
18637	17848	12	no	no	DT
18637	17848	13	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	17848	14	of	of	IN
18637	17848	15	the	the	DT
18637	17848	16	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17848	17	right	right	NN
18637	17848	18	to	to	IN
18637	17848	19	trial	trial	NN
18637	17848	20	by	by	IN
18637	17848	21	jury	jury	NN
18637	17848	22	in	in	IN
18637	17848	23	the	the	DT
18637	17848	24	following	following	JJ
18637	17848	25	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	17848	26	:	:	:
18637	17848	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17848	28	1	1	LS
18637	17848	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17848	30	A	a	DT
18637	17848	31	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	17848	32	statute	statute	NN
18637	17848	33	requiring	require	VBG
18637	17848	34	specific	specific	JJ
18637	17848	35	answers	answer	NNS
18637	17848	36	to	to	IN
18637	17848	37	special	special	JJ
18637	17848	38	interrogations	interrogation	NNS
18637	17848	39	,	,	,
18637	17848	40	in	in	IN
18637	17848	41	addition	addition	NN
18637	17848	42	to	to	IN
18637	17848	43	a	a	DT
18637	17848	44	general	general	JJ
18637	17848	45	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	17848	46	.	.	.
18637	17849	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17849	2	27	27	CD
18637	17849	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17849	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17849	5	2	2	LS
18637	17849	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17849	7	A	a	DT
18637	17849	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	17849	9	of	of	IN
18637	17849	10	a	a	DT
18637	17849	11	District	District	NNP
18637	17849	12	of	of	IN
18637	17849	13	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	17849	14	court	court	NN
18637	17849	15	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	17849	16	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	17849	17	by	by	IN
18637	17849	18	default	default	NN
18637	17849	19	in	in	IN
18637	17849	20	an	an	DT
18637	17849	21	action	action	NN
18637	17849	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17849	23	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17849	24	contractu	contractu	NN
18637	17849	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17849	26	,	,	,
18637	17849	27	on	on	IN
18637	17849	28	failure	failure	NN
18637	17849	29	to	to	TO
18637	17849	30	show	show	VB
18637	17849	31	by	by	IN
18637	17849	32	affidavit	affidavit	VB
18637	17849	33	a	a	DT
18637	17849	34	good	good	JJ
18637	17849	35	defense	defense	NN
18637	17849	36	.	.	.
18637	17850	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17850	2	28	28	CD
18637	17850	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17850	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17850	5	3	3	LS
18637	17850	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17850	7	A	a	DT
18637	17850	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17850	9	court	court	NN
18637	17850	10	's	's	POS
18637	17850	11	observance	observance	NN
18637	17850	12	of	of	IN
18637	17850	13	a	a	DT
18637	17850	14	State	State	NNP
18637	17850	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	17850	16	making	make	VBG
18637	17850	17	a	a	DT
18637	17850	18	certified	certify	VBN
18637	17850	19	copy	copy	NN
18637	17850	20	of	of	IN
18637	17850	21	a	a	DT
18637	17850	22	coroner	coroner	NN
18637	17850	23	's	's	POS
18637	17850	24	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	17850	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17850	26	prima	prima	NN
18637	17850	27	facie	facie	NNP
18637	17850	28	_	_	NNP
18637	17850	29	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17850	30	of	of	IN
18637	17850	31	the	the	DT
18637	17850	32	facts	fact	NNS
18637	17850	33	stated	state	VBN
18637	17850	34	.	.	.
18637	17851	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17851	2	29	29	CD
18637	17851	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17851	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17851	5	4	4	LS
18637	17851	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17851	7	A	a	DT
18637	17851	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17851	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	17851	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17851	11	24	24	CD
18637	17851	12	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	17851	13	.	.	.
18637	17852	1	379	379	CD
18637	17852	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17852	3	giving	give	VBG
18637	17852	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17852	5	prima	prima	NN
18637	17852	6	facie	facie	NNP
18637	17852	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17852	8	effect	effect	NN
18637	17852	9	to	to	IN
18637	17852	10	findings	finding	NNS
18637	17852	11	of	of	IN
18637	17852	12	the	the	DT
18637	17852	13	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	17852	14	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	17852	15	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	17852	16	.	.	.
18637	17853	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17853	2	30	30	CD
18637	17853	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17853	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17853	5	5	5	LS
18637	17853	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17853	7	An	an	DT
18637	17853	8	order	order	NN
18637	17853	9	of	of	IN
18637	17853	10	a	a	DT
18637	17853	11	District	District	NNP
18637	17853	12	of	of	IN
18637	17853	13	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	17853	14	court	court	NN
18637	17853	15	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	17853	16	an	an	DT
18637	17853	17	auditor	auditor	NN
18637	17853	18	in	in	IN
18637	17853	19	a	a	DT
18637	17853	20	law	law	NN
18637	17853	21	case	case	NN
18637	17853	22	to	to	TO
18637	17853	23	examine	examine	VB
18637	17853	24	books	book	NNS
18637	17853	25	and	and	CC
18637	17853	26	papers	paper	NNS
18637	17853	27	,	,	,
18637	17853	28	make	make	VB
18637	17853	29	computations	computation	NNS
18637	17853	30	,	,	,
18637	17853	31	hear	hear	VB
18637	17853	32	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	17853	33	,	,	,
18637	17853	34	and	and	CC
18637	17853	35	render	render	VB
18637	17853	36	a	a	DT
18637	17853	37	report	report	NN
18637	17853	38	which	which	WDT
18637	17853	39	will	will	MD
18637	17853	40	serve	serve	VB
18637	17853	41	as	as	IN
18637	17853	42	_	_	NNP
18637	17853	43	prima	prima	NN
18637	17853	44	facie	facie	VBD
18637	17853	45	_	_	NNP
18637	17853	46	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17853	47	of	of	IN
18637	17853	48	the	the	DT
18637	17853	49	facts	fact	NNS
18637	17853	50	found	find	VBN
18637	17853	51	and	and	CC
18637	17853	52	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
18637	17853	53	reached	reach	VBN
18637	17853	54	,	,	,
18637	17853	55	unless	unless	IN
18637	17853	56	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	17853	57	by	by	IN
18637	17853	58	the	the	DT
18637	17853	59	court	court	NN
18637	17853	60	.	.	.
18637	17854	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17854	2	31	31	CD
18637	17854	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17854	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17854	5	6	6	LS
18637	17854	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17854	7	A	a	DT
18637	17854	8	decree	decree	NN
18637	17854	9	of	of	IN
18637	17854	10	the	the	DT
18637	17854	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	17854	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17854	13	enjoining	enjoining	NN
18637	17854	14	,	,	,
18637	17854	15	in	in	IN
18637	17854	16	the	the	DT
18637	17854	17	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	17854	18	of	of	IN
18637	17854	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17854	20	original	original	JJ
18637	17854	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	17854	22	,	,	,
18637	17854	23	the	the	DT
18637	17854	24	State	State	NNP
18637	17854	25	of	of	IN
18637	17854	26	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	17854	27	from	from	IN
18637	17854	28	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	17854	29	to	to	IN
18637	17854	30	trespass	trespass	NN
18637	17854	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	17854	32	lands	land	NNS
18637	17854	33	under	under	IN
18637	17854	34	the	the	DT
18637	17854	35	ocean	ocean	NN
18637	17854	36	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	17854	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17854	38	coasts	coast	NNS
18637	17854	39	and	and	CC
18637	17854	40	requiring	require	VBG
18637	17854	41	the	the	DT
18637	17854	42	State	State	NNP
18637	17854	43	to	to	TO
18637	17854	44	account	account	VB
18637	17854	45	for	for	IN
18637	17854	46	the	the	DT
18637	17854	47	money	money	NN
18637	17854	48	derived	derive	VBN
18637	17854	49	from	from	IN
18637	17854	50	that	that	DT
18637	17854	51	area	area	NN
18637	17854	52	.	.	.
18637	17855	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17855	2	32	32	CD
18637	17855	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17855	4	RESTRICTIVE	restrictive	NN
18637	17855	5	FORCE	force	NN
18637	17855	6	OF	of	IN
18637	17855	7	THE	the	DT
18637	17855	8	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	17855	9	But	but	CC
18637	17855	10	the	the	DT
18637	17855	11	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	17855	12	right	right	NN
18637	17855	13	to	to	IN
18637	17855	14	a	a	DT
18637	17855	15	trial	trial	NN
18637	17855	16	of	of	IN
18637	17855	17	the	the	DT
18637	17855	18	facts	fact	NNS
18637	17855	19	by	by	IN
18637	17855	20	a	a	DT
18637	17855	21	jury	jury	NN
18637	17855	22	may	may	MD
18637	17855	23	not	not	RB
18637	17855	24	be	be	VB
18637	17855	25	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	17855	26	by	by	IN
18637	17855	27	any	any	DT
18637	17855	28	blending	blending	NN
18637	17855	29	with	with	IN
18637	17855	30	a	a	DT
18637	17855	31	claim	claim	NN
18637	17855	32	,	,	,
18637	17855	33	properly	properly	RB
18637	17855	34	cognizable	cognizable	JJ
18637	17855	35	at	at	IN
18637	17855	36	law	law	NN
18637	17855	37	,	,	,
18637	17855	38	of	of	IN
18637	17855	39	a	a	DT
18637	17855	40	demand	demand	NN
18637	17855	41	for	for	IN
18637	17855	42	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	17855	43	relief	relief	NN
18637	17855	44	in	in	IN
18637	17855	45	aid	aid	NN
18637	17855	46	of	of	IN
18637	17855	47	the	the	DT
18637	17855	48	legal	legal	JJ
18637	17855	49	action	action	NN
18637	17855	50	or	or	CC
18637	17855	51	during	during	IN
18637	17855	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17855	53	pendency	pendency	NN
18637	17855	54	.	.	.
18637	17856	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	17856	2	aid	aid	NN
18637	17856	3	in	in	IN
18637	17856	4	the	the	DT
18637	17856	5	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17856	6	courts	court	NNS
18637	17856	7	must	must	MD
18637	17856	8	be	be	VB
18637	17856	9	sought	seek	VBN
18637	17856	10	in	in	IN
18637	17856	11	separate	separate	JJ
18637	17856	12	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	17856	13	.	.	.
18637	17857	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17857	2	33	33	CD
18637	17857	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17857	4	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	17857	5	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	17857	6	from	from	IN
18637	17857	7	Revised	revise	VBN
18637	17857	8	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	17857	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17857	10	§	§	NNP
18637	17857	11	723	723	CD
18637	17857	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17857	13	through	through	IN
18637	17857	14	the	the	DT
18637	17857	15	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	17857	16	Code	Code	NNP
18637	17857	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17857	18	§	§	NNP
18637	17857	19	267	267	CD
18637	17857	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17857	21	,	,	,
18637	17857	22	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	17857	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	17857	24	of	of	IN
18637	17857	25	the	the	DT
18637	17857	26	United	United	NNP
18637	17857	27	States	States	NNP
18637	17857	28	to	to	TO
18637	17857	29	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	17857	30	suits	suit	NNS
18637	17857	31	in	in	IN
18637	17857	32	equity	equity	NN
18637	17857	33	where	where	WRB
18637	17857	34	the	the	DT
18637	17857	35	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	17857	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	17857	37	complete	complete	JJ
18637	17857	38	at	at	IN
18637	17857	39	law	law	NN
18637	17857	40	,	,	,
18637	17857	41	serve	serve	VB
18637	17857	42	to	to	TO
18637	17857	43	guard	guard	VB
18637	17857	44	the	the	DT
18637	17857	45	right	right	NN
18637	17857	46	of	of	IN
18637	17857	47	trial	trial	NN
18637	17857	48	by	by	IN
18637	17857	49	jury	jury	NN
18637	17857	50	,	,	,
18637	17857	51	and	and	CC
18637	17857	52	should	should	MD
18637	17857	53	be	be	VB
18637	17857	54	liberally	liberally	RB
18637	17857	55	construed	construe	VBN
18637	17857	56	.	.	.
18637	17858	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17858	2	34	34	CD
18637	17858	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17858	4	So	so	RB
18637	17858	5	also	also	RB
18637	17858	6	should	should	MD
18637	17858	7	Equity	Equity	NNP
18637	17858	8	Rule	Rule	NNP
18637	17858	9	30	30	CD
18637	17858	10	,	,	,
18637	17858	11	requiring	require	VBG
18637	17858	12	the	the	DT
18637	17858	13	answer	answer	NN
18637	17858	14	to	to	IN
18637	17858	15	a	a	DT
18637	17858	16	bill	bill	NN
18637	17858	17	in	in	IN
18637	17858	18	equity	equity	NN
18637	17858	19	to	to	TO
18637	17858	20	state	state	VB
18637	17858	21	any	any	DT
18637	17858	22	counterclaim	counterclaim	NN
18637	17858	23	arising	arise	VBG
18637	17858	24	out	out	IN
18637	17858	25	of	of	IN
18637	17858	26	the	the	DT
18637	17858	27	same	same	JJ
18637	17858	28	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	17858	29	;	;	:
18637	17858	30	such	such	JJ
18637	17858	31	rule	rule	NN
18637	17858	32	was	be	VBD
18637	17858	33	not	not	RB
18637	17858	34	intended	intend	VBN
18637	17858	35	to	to	TO
18637	17858	36	change	change	VB
18637	17858	37	the	the	DT
18637	17858	38	line	line	NN
18637	17858	39	between	between	IN
18637	17858	40	law	law	NN
18637	17858	41	and	and	CC
18637	17858	42	equity	equity	NN
18637	17858	43	,	,	,
18637	17858	44	and	and	CC
18637	17858	45	must	must	MD
18637	17858	46	be	be	VB
18637	17858	47	construed	construe	VBN
18637	17858	48	as	as	IN
18637	17858	49	referring	refer	VBG
18637	17858	50	to	to	IN
18637	17858	51	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	17858	52	counterclaims	counterclaim	NNS
18637	17858	53	only	only	RB
18637	17858	54	.	.	.
18637	17859	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17859	2	35	35	CD
18637	17859	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17859	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	17859	5	may	may	MD
18637	17859	6	the	the	DT
18637	17859	7	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	17859	8	between	between	IN
18637	17859	9	law	law	NN
18637	17859	10	and	and	CC
18637	17859	11	equity	equity	NN
18637	17859	12	,	,	,
18637	17859	13	so	so	RB
18637	17859	14	far	far	RB
18637	17859	15	as	as	IN
18637	17859	16	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17859	17	courts	court	NNS
18637	17859	18	are	be	VBP
18637	17859	19	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	17859	20	,	,	,
18637	17859	21	be	be	VB
18637	17859	22	obliterated	obliterate	VBN
18637	17859	23	by	by	IN
18637	17859	24	State	State	NNP
18637	17859	25	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	17859	26	.	.	.
18637	17860	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17860	2	36	36	CD
18637	17860	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17860	4	So	so	CC
18637	17860	5	,	,	,
18637	17860	6	where	where	WRB
18637	17860	7	State	state	NN
18637	17860	8	law	law	NN
18637	17860	9	,	,	,
18637	17860	10	in	in	IN
18637	17860	11	advance	advance	NN
18637	17860	12	of	of	IN
18637	17860	13	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	17860	14	,	,	,
18637	17860	15	treated	treat	VBD
18637	17860	16	the	the	DT
18637	17860	17	whole	whole	JJ
18637	17860	18	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	17860	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	17860	20	a	a	DT
18637	17860	21	simple	simple	JJ
18637	17860	22	contract	contract	NN
18637	17860	23	,	,	,
18637	17860	24	including	include	VBG
18637	17860	25	determination	determination	NN
18637	17860	26	of	of	IN
18637	17860	27	validity	validity	NN
18637	17860	28	and	and	CC
18637	17860	29	of	of	IN
18637	17860	30	amount	amount	NN
18637	17860	31	due	due	JJ
18637	17860	32	,	,	,
18637	17860	33	as	as	IN
18637	17860	34	an	an	DT
18637	17860	35	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	17860	36	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	17860	37	,	,	,
18637	17860	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17860	39	brought	bring	VBD
18637	17860	40	the	the	DT
18637	17860	41	case	case	NN
18637	17860	42	within	within	IN
18637	17860	43	the	the	DT
18637	17860	44	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17860	45	equity	equity	NN
18637	17860	46	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	17860	47	on	on	IN
18637	17860	48	removal	removal	NN
18637	17860	49	.	.	.
18637	17861	1	Ascertainment	ascertainment	NN
18637	17861	2	of	of	IN
18637	17861	3	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	17861	4	's	's	POS
18637	17861	5	demand	demand	NN
18637	17861	6	being	be	VBG
18637	17861	7	properly	properly	RB
18637	17861	8	by	by	IN
18637	17861	9	action	action	NN
18637	17861	10	at	at	IN
18637	17861	11	law	law	NN
18637	17861	12	,	,	,
18637	17861	13	however	however	RB
18637	17861	14	,	,	,
18637	17861	15	the	the	DT
18637	17861	16	fact	fact	NN
18637	17861	17	that	that	IN
18637	17861	18	the	the	DT
18637	17861	19	equity	equity	NN
18637	17861	20	court	court	NN
18637	17861	21	had	have	VBD
18637	17861	22	power	power	NN
18637	17861	23	to	to	TO
18637	17861	24	summon	summon	VB
18637	17861	25	a	a	DT
18637	17861	26	jury	jury	NN
18637	17861	27	on	on	IN
18637	17861	28	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	17861	29	did	do	VBD
18637	17861	30	not	not	RB
18637	17861	31	afford	afford	VB
18637	17861	32	an	an	DT
18637	17861	33	equivalent	equivalent	NN
18637	17861	34	of	of	IN
18637	17861	35	the	the	DT
18637	17861	36	right	right	NN
18637	17861	37	of	of	IN
18637	17861	38	trial	trial	NN
18637	17861	39	by	by	IN
18637	17861	40	jury	jury	NN
18637	17861	41	secured	secure	VBN
18637	17861	42	by	by	IN
18637	17861	43	the	the	DT
18637	17861	44	Seventh	Seventh	NNP
18637	17861	45	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17861	46	.	.	.
18637	17862	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17862	2	37	37	CD
18637	17862	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17862	4	But	but	CC
18637	17862	5	where	where	WRB
18637	17862	6	State	State	NNP
18637	17862	7	law	law	NN
18637	17862	8	gives	give	VBZ
18637	17862	9	an	an	DT
18637	17862	10	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	17862	11	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	17862	12	,	,	,
18637	17862	13	such	such	JJ
18637	17862	14	as	as	IN
18637	17862	15	to	to	IN
18637	17862	16	quiet	quiet	JJ
18637	17862	17	title	title	NN
18637	17862	18	to	to	TO
18637	17862	19	land	land	NN
18637	17862	20	,	,	,
18637	17862	21	the	the	DT
18637	17862	22	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17862	23	courts	court	NNS
18637	17862	24	will	will	MD
18637	17862	25	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	17862	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17862	27	if	if	IN
18637	17862	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17862	29	does	do	VBZ
18637	17862	30	not	not	RB
18637	17862	31	obstruct	obstruct	VB
18637	17862	32	the	the	DT
18637	17862	33	rights	right	NNS
18637	17862	34	of	of	IN
18637	17862	35	the	the	DT
18637	17862	36	parties	party	NNS
18637	17862	37	as	as	IN
18637	17862	38	to	to	IN
18637	17862	39	trial	trial	NN
18637	17862	40	by	by	IN
18637	17862	41	jury	jury	NN
18637	17862	42	.	.	.
18637	17863	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17863	2	38	38	CD
18637	17863	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17863	4	An	an	DT
18637	17863	5	order	order	NN
18637	17863	6	of	of	IN
18637	17863	7	the	the	DT
18637	17863	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17863	9	of	of	IN
18637	17863	10	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	17863	11	attempting	attempt	VBG
18637	17863	12	to	to	TO
18637	17863	13	reinstate	reinstate	VB
18637	17863	14	a	a	DT
18637	17863	15	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
18637	17863	16	case	case	NN
18637	17863	17	in	in	IN
18637	17863	18	violation	violation	NN
18637	17863	19	of	of	IN
18637	17863	20	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	17863	21	's	's	POS
18637	17863	22	right	right	NN
18637	17863	23	to	to	TO
18637	17863	24	dismiss	dismiss	VB
18637	17863	25	violates	violate	VBZ
18637	17863	26	the	the	DT
18637	17863	27	latter	latter	NN
18637	17863	28	's	's	POS
18637	17863	29	right	right	NN
18637	17863	30	to	to	IN
18637	17863	31	trial	trial	NN
18637	17863	32	by	by	IN
18637	17863	33	jury	jury	NN
18637	17863	34	and	and	CC
18637	17863	35	may	may	MD
18637	17863	36	be	be	VB
18637	17863	37	corrected	correct	VBN
18637	17863	38	by	by	IN
18637	17863	39	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	17863	40	.	.	.
18637	17864	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17864	2	39	39	CD
18637	17864	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17864	4	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	17864	5	and	and	CC
18637	17864	6	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	17864	7	LINE	line	NN
18637	17864	8	DRAWN	draw	VBN
18637	17864	9	BY	by	IN
18637	17864	10	THE	the	DT
18637	17864	11	COMMON	common	JJ
18637	17864	12	LAW	law	NN
18637	17864	13	As	as	IN
18637	17864	14	was	be	VBD
18637	17864	15	noted	note	VBN
18637	17864	16	above	above	IN
18637	17864	17	,	,	,
18637	17864	18	the	the	DT
18637	17864	19	primary	primary	JJ
18637	17864	20	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	17864	21	of	of	IN
18637	17864	22	the	the	DT
18637	17864	23	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	17864	24	was	be	VBD
18637	17864	25	to	to	TO
18637	17864	26	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	17864	27	the	the	DT
18637	17864	28	historic	historic	JJ
18637	17864	29	line	line	NN
18637	17864	30	separating	separate	VBG
18637	17864	31	the	the	DT
18637	17864	32	province	province	NN
18637	17864	33	of	of	IN
18637	17864	34	the	the	DT
18637	17864	35	jury	jury	NN
18637	17864	36	from	from	IN
18637	17864	37	that	that	DT
18637	17864	38	of	of	IN
18637	17864	39	the	the	DT
18637	17864	40	judge	judge	NN
18637	17864	41	,	,	,
18637	17864	42	without	without	IN
18637	17864	43	at	at	IN
18637	17864	44	the	the	DT
18637	17864	45	same	same	JJ
18637	17864	46	time	time	NN
18637	17864	47	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	17864	48	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	17864	49	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	17864	50	which	which	WDT
18637	17864	51	did	do	VBD
18637	17864	52	not	not	RB
18637	17864	53	transgress	transgress	VB
18637	17864	54	this	this	DT
18637	17864	55	line	line	NN
18637	17864	56	.	.	.
18637	17865	1	Elucidating	elucidate	VBG
18637	17865	2	this	this	DT
18637	17865	3	formula	formula	NN
18637	17865	4	,	,	,
18637	17865	5	the	the	DT
18637	17865	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17865	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	17865	8	achieved	achieve	VBN
18637	17865	9	the	the	DT
18637	17865	10	following	follow	VBG
18637	17865	11	results	result	NNS
18637	17865	12	:	:	:
18637	17865	13	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17865	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	17865	15	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	17865	16	for	for	IN
18637	17865	17	a	a	DT
18637	17865	18	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17865	19	judge	judge	NN
18637	17865	20	,	,	,
18637	17865	21	in	in	IN
18637	17865	22	the	the	DT
18637	17865	23	course	course	NN
18637	17865	24	of	of	IN
18637	17865	25	trial	trial	NN
18637	17865	26	,	,	,
18637	17865	27	to	to	TO
18637	17865	28	express	express	VB
18637	17865	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17865	30	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17865	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	17865	32	the	the	DT
18637	17865	33	facts	fact	NNS
18637	17865	34	,	,	,
18637	17865	35	provided	provide	VBN
18637	17865	36	all	all	DT
18637	17865	37	questions	question	NNS
18637	17865	38	of	of	IN
18637	17865	39	fact	fact	NN
18637	17865	40	are	be	VBP
18637	17865	41	ultimately	ultimately	RB
18637	17865	42	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	17865	43	to	to	IN
18637	17865	44	the	the	DT
18637	17865	45	jury;[40	jury;[40	NN
18637	17865	46	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17865	47	to	to	TO
18637	17865	48	call	call	VB
18637	17865	49	the	the	DT
18637	17865	50	jury	jury	NN
18637	17865	51	's	's	POS
18637	17865	52	attention	attention	NN
18637	17865	53	to	to	IN
18637	17865	54	parts	part	NNS
18637	17865	55	of	of	IN
18637	17865	56	the	the	DT
18637	17865	57	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17865	58	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17865	59	deems	deem	VBZ
18637	17865	60	of	of	IN
18637	17865	61	special	special	JJ
18637	17865	62	importance,[41	importance,[41	CD
18637	17865	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17865	64	being	be	VBG
18637	17865	65	careful	careful	JJ
18637	17865	66	to	to	TO
18637	17865	67	distinguish	distinguish	VB
18637	17865	68	between	between	IN
18637	17865	69	matters	matter	NNS
18637	17865	70	of	of	IN
18637	17865	71	law	law	NN
18637	17865	72	and	and	CC
18637	17865	73	matters	matter	NNS
18637	17865	74	of	of	IN
18637	17865	75	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17865	76	in	in	IN
18637	17865	77	relation	relation	NN
18637	17865	78	thereto;[42	thereto;[42	NNP
18637	17865	79	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17865	80	to	to	TO
18637	17865	81	inform	inform	VB
18637	17865	82	the	the	DT
18637	17865	83	jury	jury	NN
18637	17865	84	when	when	WRB
18637	17865	85	there	there	EX
18637	17865	86	is	be	VBZ
18637	17865	87	not	not	RB
18637	17865	88	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	17865	89	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17865	90	to	to	TO
18637	17865	91	justify	justify	VB
18637	17865	92	a	a	DT
18637	17865	93	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	17865	94	,	,	,
18637	17865	95	that	that	IN
18637	17865	96	such	such	JJ
18637	17865	97	is	be	VBZ
18637	17865	98	the	the	DT
18637	17865	99	case;[43	case;[43	NNP
18637	17865	100	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17865	101	to	to	TO
18637	17865	102	direct	direct	VB
18637	17865	103	the	the	DT
18637	17865	104	jury	jury	NN
18637	17865	105	,	,	,
18637	17865	106	after	after	IN
18637	17865	107	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	17865	108	's	's	POS
18637	17865	109	case	case	NN
18637	17865	110	is	be	VBZ
18637	17865	111	all	all	DT
18637	17865	112	in	in	RB
18637	17865	113	,	,	,
18637	17865	114	to	to	TO
18637	17865	115	return	return	VB
18637	17865	116	a	a	DT
18637	17865	117	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	17865	118	for	for	IN
18637	17865	119	the	the	DT
18637	17865	120	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17865	121	on	on	IN
18637	17865	122	the	the	DT
18637	17865	123	ground	ground	NN
18637	17865	124	of	of	IN
18637	17865	125	the	the	DT
18637	17865	126	insufficiency	insufficiency	NN
18637	17865	127	of	of	IN
18637	17865	128	the	the	DT
18637	17865	129	evidence;[44	evidence;[44	NNP
18637	17865	130	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17865	131	to	to	TO
18637	17865	132	set	set	VB
18637	17865	133	aside	aside	RP
18637	17865	134	a	a	DT
18637	17865	135	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	17865	136	which	which	WDT
18637	17865	137	in	in	IN
18637	17865	138	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17865	139	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17865	140	is	be	VBZ
18637	17865	141	against	against	IN
18637	17865	142	the	the	DT
18637	17865	143	law	law	NN
18637	17865	144	or	or	CC
18637	17865	145	the	the	DT
18637	17865	146	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17865	147	,	,	,
18637	17865	148	and	and	CC
18637	17865	149	order	order	VB
18637	17865	150	a	a	DT
18637	17865	151	new	new	JJ
18637	17865	152	trial;[45	trial;[45	NN
18637	17865	153	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17865	154	to	to	TO
18637	17865	155	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	17865	156	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17865	157	a	a	DT
18637	17865	158	new	new	JJ
18637	17865	159	trial	trial	NN
18637	17865	160	on	on	IN
18637	17865	161	the	the	DT
18637	17865	162	condition	condition	NN
18637	17865	163	,	,	,
18637	17865	164	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	17865	165	by	by	IN
18637	17865	166	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	17865	167	,	,	,
18637	17865	168	that	that	IN
18637	17865	169	the	the	DT
18637	17865	170	latter	latter	JJ
18637	17865	171	remit	remit	VB
18637	17865	172	a	a	DT
18637	17865	173	portion	portion	NN
18637	17865	174	of	of	IN
18637	17865	175	the	the	DT
18637	17865	176	damages	damage	NNS
18637	17865	177	awarded	award	VBD
18637	17865	178	him;[46	him;[46	NNP
18637	17865	179	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17865	180	but	but	CC
18637	17865	181	not	not	RB
18637	17865	182	,	,	,
18637	17865	183	on	on	IN
18637	17865	184	the	the	DT
18637	17865	185	other	other	JJ
18637	17865	186	hand	hand	NN
18637	17865	187	,	,	,
18637	17865	188	to	to	TO
18637	17865	189	deny	deny	VB
18637	17865	190	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	17865	191	a	a	DT
18637	17865	192	new	new	JJ
18637	17865	193	trial	trial	NN
18637	17865	194	on	on	IN
18637	17865	195	the	the	DT
18637	17865	196	converse	converse	NN
18637	17865	197	condition	condition	NN
18637	17865	198	,	,	,
18637	17865	199	although	although	IN
18637	17865	200	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17865	201	accepted	accept	VBD
18637	17865	202	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17865	203	.	.	.
18637	17866	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17866	2	47	47	CD
18637	17866	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17866	4	DIRECTED	direct	VBN
18637	17866	5	VERDICTS	verdicts	NN
18637	17866	6	In	in	IN
18637	17866	7	1913	1913	CD
18637	17866	8	the	the	DT
18637	17866	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17866	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	17866	11	,	,	,
18637	17866	12	in	in	IN
18637	17866	13	Slocum	Slocum	NNP
18637	17866	14	_	_	NNP
18637	17866	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	17866	16	_	_	NNP
18637	17866	17	New	New	NNP
18637	17866	18	York	York	NNP
18637	17866	19	Life	Life	NNP
18637	17866	20	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	17866	21	Company,[48	Company,[48	NNP
18637	17866	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17866	23	that	that	IN
18637	17866	24	where	where	WRB
18637	17866	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	17866	26	the	the	DT
18637	17866	27	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17866	28	a	a	DT
18637	17866	29	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17866	30	trial	trial	NN
18637	17866	31	court	court	NN
18637	17866	32	,	,	,
18637	17866	33	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	17866	34	in	in	IN
18637	17866	35	New	New	NNP
18637	17866	36	York	York	NNP
18637	17866	37	,	,	,
18637	17866	38	ought	ought	MD
18637	17866	39	to	to	TO
18637	17866	40	have	have	VB
18637	17866	41	directed	direct	VBN
18637	17866	42	a	a	DT
18637	17866	43	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	17866	44	for	for	IN
18637	17866	45	one	one	CD
18637	17866	46	party	party	NN
18637	17866	47	but	but	CC
18637	17866	48	the	the	DT
18637	17866	49	jury	jury	NN
18637	17866	50	found	find	VBD
18637	17866	51	for	for	IN
18637	17866	52	the	the	DT
18637	17866	53	other	other	JJ
18637	17866	54	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	17866	55	to	to	IN
18637	17866	56	the	the	DT
18637	17866	57	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17866	58	,	,	,
18637	17866	59	the	the	DT
18637	17866	60	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	17866	61	rendered	render	VBD
18637	17866	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17866	63	improper	improper	JJ
18637	17866	64	for	for	IN
18637	17866	65	a	a	DT
18637	17866	66	federal	federal	JJ
18637	17866	67	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	17866	68	court	court	NN
18637	17866	69	to	to	TO
18637	17866	70	order	order	VB
18637	17866	71	,	,	,
18637	17866	72	in	in	IN
18637	17866	73	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	17866	74	with	with	IN
18637	17866	75	New	New	NNP
18637	17866	76	York	York	NNP
18637	17866	77	practice	practice	NN
18637	17866	78	,	,	,
18637	17866	79	the	the	DT
18637	17866	80	entry	entry	NN
18637	17866	81	of	of	IN
18637	17866	82	a	a	DT
18637	17866	83	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	17866	84	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	17866	85	to	to	IN
18637	17866	86	the	the	DT
18637	17866	87	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	17866	88	;	;	:
18637	17866	89	that	that	IN
18637	17866	90	the	the	DT
18637	17866	91	only	only	JJ
18637	17866	92	course	course	NN
18637	17866	93	open	open	JJ
18637	17866	94	to	to	IN
18637	17866	95	either	either	DT
18637	17866	96	court	court	NN
18637	17866	97	was	be	VBD
18637	17866	98	to	to	TO
18637	17866	99	order	order	VB
18637	17866	100	a	a	DT
18637	17866	101	new	new	JJ
18637	17866	102	trial	trial	NN
18637	17866	103	.	.	.
18637	17867	1	While	while	IN
18637	17867	2	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	17867	3	in	in	IN
18637	17867	4	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	17867	5	with	with	IN
18637	17867	6	the	the	DT
18637	17867	7	common	common	JJ
18637	17867	8	law	law	NN
18637	17867	9	as	as	IN
18637	17867	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17867	11	stood	stand	VBD
18637	17867	12	in	in	IN
18637	17867	13	1791	1791	CD
18637	17867	14	,	,	,
18637	17867	15	the	the	DT
18637	17867	16	decision	decision	NN
18637	17867	17	was	be	VBD
18637	17867	18	five	five	CD
18637	17867	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	17867	20	to	to	IN
18637	17867	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	17867	22	four	four	CD
18637	17867	23	and	and	CC
18637	17867	24	was	be	VBD
18637	17867	25	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	17867	26	to	to	IN
18637	17867	27	a	a	DT
18637	17867	28	heavy	heavy	JJ
18637	17867	29	fire	fire	NN
18637	17867	30	of	of	IN
18637	17867	31	professional	professional	JJ
18637	17867	32	criticism	criticism	NN
18637	17867	33	urging	urge	VBG
18637	17867	34	the	the	DT
18637	17867	35	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	17867	36	of	of	IN
18637	17867	37	the	the	DT
18637	17867	38	thing	thing	NN
18637	17867	39	and	and	CC
18637	17867	40	the	the	DT
18637	17867	41	theory	theory	NN
18637	17867	42	of	of	IN
18637	17867	43	the	the	DT
18637	17867	44	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	17867	45	of	of	IN
18637	17867	46	the	the	DT
18637	17867	47	common	common	JJ
18637	17867	48	law	law	NN
18637	17867	49	for	for	IN
18637	17867	50	growth	growth	NN
18637	17867	51	.	.	.
18637	17868	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17868	2	49	49	CD
18637	17868	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17868	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17868	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	17868	6	,	,	,
18637	17868	7	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	17868	8	,	,	,
18637	17868	9	been	be	VBN
18637	17868	10	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	17868	11	,	,	,
18637	17868	12	if	if	IN
18637	17868	13	not	not	RB
18637	17868	14	completely	completely	RB
18637	17868	15	undermined	undermine	VBN
18637	17868	16	by	by	IN
18637	17868	17	certain	certain	JJ
18637	17868	18	more	more	RBR
18637	17868	19	recent	recent	JJ
18637	17868	20	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	17868	21	.	.	.
18637	17869	1	In	in	IN
18637	17869	2	the	the	DT
18637	17869	3	first	first	JJ
18637	17869	4	of	of	IN
18637	17869	5	these,[50	these,[50	NN
18637	17869	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17869	7	in	in	IN
18637	17869	8	which	which	WDT
18637	17869	9	the	the	DT
18637	17869	10	same	same	JJ
18637	17869	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	17869	12	spoke	speak	VBD
18637	17869	13	for	for	IN
18637	17869	14	the	the	DT
18637	17869	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17869	16	as	as	IN
18637	17869	17	in	in	IN
18637	17869	18	the	the	DT
18637	17869	19	Slocum	Slocum	NNP
18637	17869	20	Case	Case	NNP
18637	17869	21	,	,	,
18637	17869	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17869	23	was	be	VBD
18637	17869	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	17869	25	that	that	IN
18637	17869	26	a	a	DT
18637	17869	27	trial	trial	NN
18637	17869	28	court	court	NN
18637	17869	29	had	have	VBD
18637	17869	30	the	the	DT
18637	17869	31	right	right	NN
18637	17869	32	to	to	TO
18637	17869	33	enter	enter	VB
18637	17869	34	a	a	DT
18637	17869	35	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	17869	36	on	on	IN
18637	17869	37	the	the	DT
18637	17869	38	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	17869	39	of	of	IN
18637	17869	40	the	the	DT
18637	17869	41	jury	jury	NN
18637	17869	42	for	for	IN
18637	17869	43	the	the	DT
18637	17869	44	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	17869	45	after	after	IN
18637	17869	46	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	17869	47	a	a	DT
18637	17869	48	motion	motion	NN
18637	17869	49	by	by	IN
18637	17869	50	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17869	51	for	for	IN
18637	17869	52	dismissal	dismissal	NN
18637	17869	53	on	on	IN
18637	17869	54	the	the	DT
18637	17869	55	ground	ground	NN
18637	17869	56	of	of	IN
18637	17869	57	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	17869	58	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17869	59	.	.	.
18637	17870	1	The	the	DT
18637	17870	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17870	3	owned	own	VBD
18637	17870	4	that	that	IN
18637	17870	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17870	6	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	17870	7	was	be	VBD
18637	17870	8	out	out	IN
18637	17870	9	of	of	IN
18637	17870	10	line	line	NN
18637	17870	11	with	with	IN
18637	17870	12	some	some	DT
18637	17870	13	of	of	IN
18637	17870	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17870	15	expressions	expression	NNS
18637	17870	16	in	in	IN
18637	17870	17	the	the	DT
18637	17870	18	Slocum	Slocum	NNP
18637	17870	19	Case	Case	NNP
18637	17870	20	.	.	.
18637	17871	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17871	2	51	51	CD
18637	17871	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17871	4	In	in	IN
18637	17871	5	the	the	DT
18637	17871	6	second	second	JJ
18637	17871	7	case[52	case[52	NN
18637	17871	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17871	9	the	the	DT
18637	17871	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17871	11	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	17871	12	a	a	DT
18637	17871	13	United	United	NNP
18637	17871	14	States	States	NNP
18637	17871	15	district	district	NN
18637	17871	16	court	court	NN
18637	17871	17	in	in	IN
18637	17871	18	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	17871	19	,	,	,
18637	17871	20	in	in	IN
18637	17871	21	an	an	DT
18637	17871	22	action	action	NN
18637	17871	23	between	between	IN
18637	17871	24	parties	party	NNS
18637	17871	25	of	of	IN
18637	17871	26	diverse	diverse	JJ
18637	17871	27	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	17871	28	,	,	,
18637	17871	29	in	in	IN
18637	17871	30	rejecting	reject	VBG
18637	17871	31	a	a	DT
18637	17871	32	motion	motion	NN
18637	17871	33	by	by	IN
18637	17871	34	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	17871	35	for	for	IN
18637	17871	36	dismissal	dismissal	NN
18637	17871	37	and	and	CC
18637	17871	38	peremptorily	peremptorily	RB
18637	17871	39	directing	direct	VBG
18637	17871	40	a	a	DT
18637	17871	41	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	17871	42	for	for	IN
18637	17871	43	the	the	DT
18637	17871	44	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	17871	45	.	.	.
18637	17872	1	The	the	DT
18637	17872	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	17872	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17872	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	17872	5	that	that	IN
18637	17872	6	there	there	EX
18637	17872	7	was	be	VBD
18637	17872	8	ample	ample	JJ
18637	17872	9	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17872	10	to	to	TO
18637	17872	11	support	support	VB
18637	17872	12	the	the	DT
18637	17872	13	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	17872	14	and	and	CC
18637	17872	15	that	that	IN
18637	17872	16	the	the	DT
18637	17872	17	trial	trial	NN
18637	17872	18	court	court	NN
18637	17872	19	,	,	,
18637	17872	20	in	in	IN
18637	17872	21	following	follow	VBG
18637	17872	22	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	17872	23	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	17872	24	,	,	,
18637	17872	25	had	have	VBD
18637	17872	26	acted	act	VBN
18637	17872	27	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	17872	28	with	with	IN
18637	17872	29	the	the	DT
18637	17872	30	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	17872	31	Conformity	Conformity	NNP
18637	17872	32	Act	Act	NNP
18637	17872	33	.	.	.
18637	17873	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17873	2	53	53	CD
18637	17873	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17873	4	In	in	IN
18637	17873	5	the	the	DT
18637	17873	6	third	third	JJ
18637	17873	7	case,[54	case,[54	NFP
18637	17873	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17873	9	which	which	WDT
18637	17873	10	involved	involve	VBD
18637	17873	11	an	an	DT
18637	17873	12	action	action	NN
18637	17873	13	against	against	IN
18637	17873	14	the	the	DT
18637	17873	15	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17873	16	for	for	IN
18637	17873	17	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	17873	18	under	under	IN
18637	17873	19	a	a	DT
18637	17873	20	war	war	NN
18637	17873	21	risk	risk	NN
18637	17873	22	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	17873	23	policy	policy	NN
18637	17873	24	which	which	WDT
18637	17873	25	had	have	VBD
18637	17873	26	been	be	VBN
18637	17873	27	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	17873	28	to	to	TO
18637	17873	29	lapse	lapse	VB
18637	17873	30	,	,	,
18637	17873	31	the	the	DT
18637	17873	32	trial	trial	NN
18637	17873	33	court	court	NN
18637	17873	34	directed	direct	VBD
18637	17873	35	a	a	DT
18637	17873	36	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	17873	37	for	for	IN
18637	17873	38	the	the	DT
18637	17873	39	Government	Government	NNP
18637	17873	40	on	on	IN
18637	17873	41	the	the	DT
18637	17873	42	ground	ground	NN
18637	17873	43	of	of	IN
18637	17873	44	the	the	DT
18637	17873	45	insufficiency	insufficiency	NN
18637	17873	46	of	of	IN
18637	17873	47	the	the	DT
18637	17873	48	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	17873	49	and	and	CC
18637	17873	50	was	be	VBD
18637	17873	51	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	17873	52	in	in	IN
18637	17873	53	so	so	RB
18637	17873	54	doing	do	VBG
18637	17873	55	by	by	IN
18637	17873	56	both	both	DT
18637	17873	57	the	the	DT
18637	17873	58	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	17873	59	court	court	NN
18637	17873	60	of	of	IN
18637	17873	61	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	17873	62	and	and	CC
18637	17873	63	the	the	DT
18637	17873	64	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	17873	65	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17873	66	.	.	.
18637	17874	1	Three	three	CD
18637	17874	2	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	17874	3	,	,	,
18637	17874	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	17874	5	by	by	IN
18637	17874	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	17874	7	Black	Black	NNP
18637	17874	8	,	,	,
18637	17874	9	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	17874	10	in	in	IN
18637	17874	11	an	an	DT
18637	17874	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	17874	13	in	in	IN
18637	17874	14	which	which	WDT
18637	17874	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17874	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	17874	17	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	17874	18	that	that	IN
18637	17874	19	"	"	``
18637	17874	20	today	today	NN
18637	17874	21	's	's	POS
18637	17874	22	decision	decision	NN
18637	17874	23	marks	mark	VBZ
18637	17874	24	a	a	DT
18637	17874	25	continuation	continuation	NN
18637	17874	26	of	of	IN
18637	17874	27	the	the	DT
18637	17874	28	gradual	gradual	JJ
18637	17874	29	process	process	NN
18637	17874	30	of	of	IN
18637	17874	31	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	17874	32	erosion	erosion	NN
18637	17874	33	which	which	WDT
18637	17874	34	in	in	IN
18637	17874	35	one	one	CD
18637	17874	36	-	-	HYPH
18637	17874	37	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	17874	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	17874	39	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	17874	40	years	year	NNS
18637	17874	41	has	have	VBZ
18637	17874	42	slowly	slowly	RB
18637	17874	43	worn	wear	VBN
18637	17874	44	away	away	RP
18637	17874	45	a	a	DT
18637	17874	46	major	major	JJ
18637	17874	47	portion	portion	NN
18637	17874	48	of	of	IN
18637	17874	49	the	the	DT
18637	17874	50	essential	essential	JJ
18637	17874	51	guarantee	guarantee	NN
18637	17874	52	of	of	IN
18637	17874	53	the	the	DT
18637	17874	54	Seventh	Seventh	NNP
18637	17874	55	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17874	56	.	.	.
18637	17875	1	"	"	``
18637	17875	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17875	3	55	55	CD
18637	17875	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17875	5	That	that	IN
18637	17875	6	the	the	DT
18637	17875	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17875	8	should	should	MD
18637	17875	9	experience	experience	VB
18637	17875	10	occasional	occasional	JJ
18637	17875	11	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	17875	12	in	in	IN
18637	17875	13	harmonizing	harmonize	VBG
18637	17875	14	the	the	DT
18637	17875	15	idea	idea	NN
18637	17875	16	of	of	IN
18637	17875	17	preserving	preserve	VBG
18637	17875	18	the	the	DT
18637	17875	19	historic	historic	JJ
18637	17875	20	common	common	JJ
18637	17875	21	law	law	NN
18637	17875	22	covering	cover	VBG
18637	17875	23	the	the	DT
18637	17875	24	relations	relation	NNS
18637	17875	25	of	of	IN
18637	17875	26	judge	judge	NN
18637	17875	27	and	and	CC
18637	17875	28	jury	jury	NN
18637	17875	29	with	with	IN
18637	17875	30	the	the	DT
18637	17875	31	notion	notion	NN
18637	17875	32	of	of	IN
18637	17875	33	a	a	DT
18637	17875	34	developing	develop	VBG
18637	17875	35	common	common	JJ
18637	17875	36	law	law	NN
18637	17875	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	17875	38	not	not	RB
18637	17875	39	surprising	surprising	JJ
18637	17875	40	.	.	.
18637	17876	1	WAIVER	waiver	NN
18637	17876	2	OF	of	IN
18637	17876	3	RIGHT	right	NN
18637	17876	4	OF	of	IN
18637	17876	5	TRIAL	trial	NN
18637	17876	6	BY	by	IN
18637	17876	7	JURY	jury	NN
18637	17876	8	Parties	party	NNS
18637	17876	9	have	have	VBP
18637	17876	10	a	a	DT
18637	17876	11	right	right	NN
18637	17876	12	to	to	TO
18637	17876	13	enter	enter	VB
18637	17876	14	into	into	IN
18637	17876	15	a	a	DT
18637	17876	16	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	17876	17	waiving	waive	VBG
18637	17876	18	a	a	DT
18637	17876	19	jury	jury	NN
18637	17876	20	and	and	CC
18637	17876	21	submitting	submit	VBG
18637	17876	22	the	the	DT
18637	17876	23	case	case	NN
18637	17876	24	to	to	IN
18637	17876	25	the	the	DT
18637	17876	26	court	court	NN
18637	17876	27	upon	upon	IN
18637	17876	28	an	an	DT
18637	17876	29	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	17876	30	statement	statement	NN
18637	17876	31	of	of	IN
18637	17876	32	facts	fact	NNS
18637	17876	33	,	,	,
18637	17876	34	even	even	RB
18637	17876	35	without	without	IN
18637	17876	36	any	any	DT
18637	17876	37	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	17876	38	provision	provision	NN
18637	17876	39	for	for	IN
18637	17876	40	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	17876	41	.	.	.
18637	17877	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17877	2	56	56	CD
18637	17877	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17877	4	"	"	``
18637	17877	5	*	*	NFP
18637	17877	6	*	*	NFP
18637	17877	7	*	*	NFP
18637	17877	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17877	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	17877	10	,	,	,
18637	17877	11	by	by	IN
18637	17877	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	17877	13	,	,	,
18637	17877	14	provided	provide	VBN
18637	17877	15	for	for	IN
18637	17877	16	the	the	DT
18637	17877	17	trial	trial	NN
18637	17877	18	of	of	IN
18637	17877	19	issues	issue	NNS
18637	17877	20	of	of	IN
18637	17877	21	fact	fact	NN
18637	17877	22	in	in	IN
18637	17877	23	civil	civil	JJ
18637	17877	24	cases	case	NNS
18637	17877	25	by	by	IN
18637	17877	26	the	the	DT
18637	17877	27	court	court	NN
18637	17877	28	without	without	IN
18637	17877	29	the	the	DT
18637	17877	30	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	17877	31	of	of	IN
18637	17877	32	a	a	DT
18637	17877	33	jury	jury	NN
18637	17877	34	,	,	,
18637	17877	35	only	only	RB
18637	17877	36	when	when	WRB
18637	17877	37	the	the	DT
18637	17877	38	parties	party	NNS
18637	17877	39	waive	waive	VBP
18637	17877	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17877	41	right	right	NN
18637	17877	42	to	to	IN
18637	17877	43	a	a	DT
18637	17877	44	jury	jury	NN
18637	17877	45	by	by	IN
18637	17877	46	a	a	DT
18637	17877	47	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	17877	48	in	in	IN
18637	17877	49	writing	writing	NN
18637	17877	50	.	.	.
18637	17878	1	Revised	revise	VBN
18637	17878	2	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	17878	3	sections	section	NNS
18637	17878	4	648	648	CD
18637	17878	5	,	,	,
18637	17878	6	649	649	CD
18637	17878	7	.	.	.
18637	17879	1	"	"	``
18637	17879	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17879	3	57	57	CD
18637	17879	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17879	5	This	this	DT
18637	17879	6	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	17879	7	provision	provision	NN
18637	17879	8	for	for	IN
18637	17879	9	a	a	DT
18637	17879	10	written	write	VBN
18637	17879	11	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	17879	12	,	,	,
18637	17879	13	however	however	RB
18637	17879	14	,	,	,
18637	17879	15	does	do	VBZ
18637	17879	16	not	not	RB
18637	17879	17	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	17879	18	other	other	JJ
18637	17879	19	kinds	kind	NNS
18637	17879	20	of	of	IN
18637	17879	21	waivers	waiver	NNS
18637	17879	22	.	.	.
18637	17880	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17880	2	58	58	CD
18637	17880	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17880	4	But	but	CC
18637	17880	5	every	every	DT
18637	17880	6	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	17880	7	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	17880	8	should	should	MD
18637	17880	9	be	be	VB
18637	17880	10	indulged	indulge	VBN
18637	17880	11	against	against	IN
18637	17880	12	a	a	DT
18637	17880	13	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	17880	14	.	.	.
18637	17881	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17881	2	59	59	CD
18637	17881	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17881	4	None	none	NN
18637	17881	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	17881	6	to	to	TO
18637	17881	7	be	be	VB
18637	17881	8	implied	imply	VBN
18637	17881	9	from	from	IN
18637	17881	10	a	a	DT
18637	17881	11	request	request	NN
18637	17881	12	for	for	IN
18637	17881	13	a	a	DT
18637	17881	14	directed	direct	VBN
18637	17881	15	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	17881	16	.	.	.
18637	17882	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17882	2	60	60	CD
18637	17882	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17882	4	APPEALS	appeal	NNS
18637	17882	5	FROM	from	IN
18637	17882	6	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	17882	7	COURTS	court	VBN
18637	17882	8	TO	to	IN
18637	17882	9	THE	the	DT
18637	17882	10	SUPREME	SUPREME	NNP
18637	17882	11	COURT	COURT	NNP
18637	17882	12	The	the	DT
18637	17882	13	last	last	JJ
18637	17882	14	clause	clause	NN
18637	17882	15	of	of	IN
18637	17882	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17882	17	VII	VII	NNP
18637	17882	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	17882	19	not	not	RB
18637	17882	20	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	17882	21	in	in	IN
18637	17882	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	17882	23	application	application	NN
18637	17882	24	to	to	IN
18637	17882	25	suits	suit	NNS
18637	17882	26	at	at	IN
18637	17882	27	common	common	JJ
18637	17882	28	law	law	NN
18637	17882	29	tried	try	VBN
18637	17882	30	before	before	IN
18637	17882	31	juries	jury	NNS
18637	17882	32	in	in	IN
18637	17882	33	United	United	NNP
18637	17882	34	States	States	NNP
18637	17882	35	courts	court	NNS
18637	17882	36	.	.	.
18637	17883	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17883	2	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	17883	3	equally	equally	RB
18637	17883	4	to	to	IN
18637	17883	5	a	a	DT
18637	17883	6	case	case	NN
18637	17883	7	tried	try	VBN
18637	17883	8	before	before	IN
18637	17883	9	a	a	DT
18637	17883	10	jury	jury	NN
18637	17883	11	in	in	IN
18637	17883	12	a	a	DT
18637	17883	13	State	State	NNP
18637	17883	14	court	court	NN
18637	17883	15	and	and	CC
18637	17883	16	brought	bring	VBD
18637	17883	17	to	to	IN
18637	17883	18	the	the	DT
18637	17883	19	United	United	NNP
18637	17883	20	States	States	NNP
18637	17883	21	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	17883	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	17883	23	on	on	IN
18637	17883	24	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	17883	25	.	.	.
18637	17884	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17884	2	61	61	CD
18637	17884	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17884	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	17884	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17884	6	1	1	CD
18637	17884	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17884	8	2	2	CD
18637	17884	9	Farrand	Farrand	NNP
18637	17884	10	,	,	,
18637	17884	11	Records	Records	NNPS
18637	17884	12	,	,	,
18637	17884	13	628	628	CD
18637	17884	14	.	.	.
18637	17885	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17885	2	2	2	LS
18637	17885	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17885	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17885	5	See	See	NNP
18637	17885	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17885	7	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	17885	8	Conformity	Conformity	NNP
18637	17885	9	Act	Act	NNP
18637	17885	10	,	,	,
18637	17885	11	28	28	CD
18637	17885	12	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	17886	1	§	§	NNP
18637	17886	2	724	724	CD
18637	17886	3	.	.	.
18637	17887	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17887	2	3	3	CD
18637	17887	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17887	4	2	2	CD
18637	17887	5	Story	Story	NNP
18637	17887	6	,	,	,
18637	17887	7	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
18637	17887	8	on	on	IN
18637	17887	9	the	the	DT
18637	17887	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	17887	11	,	,	,
18637	17887	12	§	â§	NN
18637	17887	13	1763	1763	CD
18637	17887	14	.	.	.
18637	17888	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17888	2	4	4	CD
18637	17888	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17888	4	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	17888	5	,	,	,
18637	17888	6	Nos	Nos	NNP
18637	17888	7	.	.	.
18637	17889	1	81	81	CD
18637	17889	2	and	and	CC
18637	17889	3	83	83	CD
18637	17889	4	.	.	.
18637	17890	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17890	2	5	5	CD
18637	17890	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17890	4	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	17890	5	&	&	CC
18637	17890	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	17890	7	Line	Line	NNP
18637	17890	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17890	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17890	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17890	11	Redman	Redman	NNP
18637	17890	12	,	,	,
18637	17890	13	295	295	CD
18637	17890	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17890	15	654	654	CD
18637	17890	16	,	,	,
18637	17890	17	657	657	CD
18637	17890	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17890	19	1935	1935	CD
18637	17890	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17890	21	;	;	:
18637	17890	22	Parsons	Parsons	NNP
18637	17890	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17890	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	17890	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17890	26	Bedford	Bedford	NNP
18637	17890	27	,	,	,
18637	17890	28	3	3	CD
18637	17890	29	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	17890	30	.	.	.
18637	17891	1	433	433	CD
18637	17891	2	,	,	,
18637	17891	3	446	446	CD
18637	17891	4	-	-	SYM
18637	17891	5	448	448	CD
18637	17891	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17891	7	1830	1830	CD
18637	17891	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17891	9	.	.	.
18637	17892	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17892	2	6	6	CD
18637	17892	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17892	4	Capital	Capital	NNP
18637	17892	5	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	17892	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17892	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17892	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17892	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17892	10	Hof	Hof	NNP
18637	17892	11	,	,	,
18637	17892	12	174	174	CD
18637	17892	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17892	14	1	1	CD
18637	17892	15	,	,	,
18637	17892	16	13	13	CD
18637	17892	17	,	,	,
18637	17892	18	14	14	CD
18637	17892	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17892	20	1899	1899	CD
18637	17892	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17892	22	.	.	.
18637	17893	1	Here	here	RB
18637	17893	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	17893	3	was	be	VBD
18637	17893	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	17893	5	that	that	IN
18637	17893	6	a	a	DT
18637	17893	7	civil	civil	JJ
18637	17893	8	trial	trial	NN
18637	17893	9	before	before	IN
18637	17893	10	a	a	DT
18637	17893	11	justice	justice	NN
18637	17893	12	of	of	IN
18637	17893	13	the	the	DT
18637	17893	14	peace	peace	NN
18637	17893	15	in	in	IN
18637	17893	16	the	the	DT
18637	17893	17	District	District	NNP
18637	17893	18	of	of	IN
18637	17893	19	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	17893	20	,	,	,
18637	17893	21	although	although	IN
18637	17893	22	by	by	IN
18637	17893	23	a	a	DT
18637	17893	24	jury	jury	NN
18637	17893	25	of	of	IN
18637	17893	26	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	17893	27	men	man	NNS
18637	17893	28	,	,	,
18637	17893	29	was	be	VBD
18637	17893	30	not	not	RB
18637	17893	31	a	a	DT
18637	17893	32	jury	jury	NN
18637	17893	33	trial	trial	NN
18637	17893	34	in	in	IN
18637	17893	35	the	the	DT
18637	17893	36	sense	sense	NN
18637	17893	37	of	of	IN
18637	17893	38	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	17893	39	VII	VII	NNP
18637	17893	40	.	.	.
18637	17894	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17894	2	7	7	LS
18637	17894	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17894	4	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	17894	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17894	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17894	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17894	8	Dow	Dow	NNP
18637	17894	9	,	,	,
18637	17894	10	176	176	CD
18637	17894	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17894	12	581	581	CD
18637	17894	13	,	,	,
18637	17894	14	586	586	CD
18637	17894	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17894	16	1900	1900	CD
18637	17894	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17894	18	.	.	.
18637	17895	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17895	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17895	3	also	also	RB
18637	17895	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17895	5	American	American	NNP
18637	17895	6	Publishing	Publishing	NNP
18637	17895	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17895	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17895	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17895	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17895	11	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	17895	12	,	,	,
18637	17895	13	166	166	CD
18637	17895	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17895	15	464	464	CD
18637	17895	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17895	17	1897	1897	CD
18637	17895	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17895	19	;	;	:
18637	17895	20	Springville	Springville	NNP
18637	17895	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17895	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	17895	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17895	24	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	17895	25	,	,	,
18637	17895	26	166	166	CD
18637	17895	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17895	28	707	707	CD
18637	17895	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17895	30	1897	1897	CD
18637	17895	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17895	32	;	;	:
18637	17895	33	Andres	Andres	NNP
18637	17895	34	_	_	NNP
18637	17895	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	17895	36	_	_	NNP
18637	17895	37	United	United	NNP
18637	17895	38	States	States	NNP
18637	17895	39	,	,	,
18637	17895	40	333	333	CD
18637	17895	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17895	42	740	740	CD
18637	17895	43	,	,	,
18637	17895	44	748	748	CD
18637	17895	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17895	46	1948	1948	CD
18637	17895	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17895	48	.	.	.
18637	17896	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17896	2	8	8	CD
18637	17896	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17896	4	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	17896	5	&	&	CC
18637	17896	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	17896	7	Line	Line	NNP
18637	17896	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17896	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17896	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17896	11	Redman	Redman	NNP
18637	17896	12	,	,	,
18637	17896	13	295	295	CD
18637	17896	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17896	15	654	654	CD
18637	17896	16	,	,	,
18637	17896	17	657	657	CD
18637	17896	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17896	19	1935	1935	CD
18637	17896	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17896	21	;	;	:
18637	17896	22	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	17896	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17896	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	17896	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17896	26	New	New	NNP
18637	17896	27	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	17896	28	,	,	,
18637	17896	29	&	&	CC
18637	17896	30	S.P.R.	S.P.R.	NNP
18637	17897	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17897	2	,	,	,
18637	17897	3	165	165	CD
18637	17897	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17897	5	593	593	CD
18637	17897	6	,	,	,
18637	17897	7	596	596	CD
18637	17897	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17897	9	1897	1897	CD
18637	17897	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17897	11	;	;	:
18637	17897	12	Gasoline	Gasoline	NNP
18637	17897	13	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	17897	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17897	15	_	_	NNP
18637	17897	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	17897	17	_	_	NNP
18637	17897	18	Champlin	Champlin	NNP
18637	17897	19	Ref	Ref	NNP
18637	17897	20	.	.	.
18637	17898	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17898	2	,	,	,
18637	17898	3	283	283	CD
18637	17898	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17898	5	494	494	CD
18637	17898	6	,	,	,
18637	17898	7	497	497	CD
18637	17898	8	-	-	SYM
18637	17898	9	499	499	CD
18637	17898	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17898	11	1931	1931	CD
18637	17898	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17898	13	;	;	:
18637	17898	14	Dimick	Dimick	NNP
18637	17898	15	_	_	NNP
18637	17898	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	17898	17	_	_	NNP
18637	17898	18	Schiedt	Schiedt	NNP
18637	17898	19	,	,	,
18637	17898	20	293	293	CD
18637	17898	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17898	22	474	474	CD
18637	17898	23	,	,	,
18637	17898	24	476	476	CD
18637	17898	25	,	,	,
18637	17898	26	485	485	CD
18637	17898	27	-	-	SYM
18637	17898	28	486	486	CD
18637	17898	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17898	30	1935	1935	CD
18637	17898	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17898	32	.	.	.
18637	17899	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17899	2	9	9	CD
18637	17899	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17899	4	Gasoline	Gasoline	NNP
18637	17899	5	Products	Products	NNP
18637	17899	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17899	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17899	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17899	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17899	10	Champlin	Champlin	NNP
18637	17899	11	Ref	Ref	NNP
18637	17899	12	.	.	.
18637	17900	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17900	2	,	,	,
18637	17900	3	283	283	CD
18637	17900	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17900	5	494	494	CD
18637	17900	6	,	,	,
18637	17900	7	498	498	CD
18637	17900	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17900	9	1931	1931	CD
18637	17900	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17900	11	;	;	:
18637	17900	12	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17900	13	parte	parte	VBZ
18637	17900	14	Peterson	Peterson	NNP
18637	17900	15	,	,	,
18637	17900	16	253	253	CD
18637	17900	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17900	18	300	300	CD
18637	17900	19	,	,	,
18637	17900	20	309	309	CD
18637	17900	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17900	22	1920	1920	CD
18637	17900	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17900	24	.	.	.
18637	17901	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17901	2	10	10	CD
18637	17901	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17901	4	Pearson	Pearson	NNP
18637	17901	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17901	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17901	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17901	8	Yewdall	Yewdall	NNP
18637	17901	9	,	,	,
18637	17901	10	95	95	CD
18637	17901	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17901	12	294	294	CD
18637	17901	13	,	,	,
18637	17901	14	296	296	CD
18637	17901	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17901	16	1877	1877	CD
18637	17901	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17901	18	.	.	.
18637	17902	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17902	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17902	3	also	also	RB
18637	17902	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17902	5	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	17902	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17902	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17902	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17902	9	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	17902	10	,	,	,
18637	17902	11	21	21	CD
18637	17902	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17902	13	.	.	.
18637	17903	1	532	532	CD
18637	17903	2	,	,	,
18637	17903	3	557	557	CD
18637	17903	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17903	5	1874	1874	CD
18637	17903	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17903	7	;	;	:
18637	17903	8	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	17903	9	of	of	IN
18637	17903	10	the	the	DT
18637	17903	11	Sup	Sup	NNP
18637	17903	12	.	.	.
18637	17904	1	Ct	Ct	NNP
18637	17904	2	.	.	NNP
18637	17904	3	_	_	NNP
18637	17904	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	17904	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17904	6	United	United	NNP
18637	17904	7	States	States	NNP
18637	17904	8	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17904	9	rel	rel	NN
18637	17904	10	.	.	.
18637	17905	1	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	17905	2	,	,	,
18637	17905	3	9	9	CD
18637	17905	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17905	5	.	.	.
18637	17906	1	274	274	CD
18637	17906	2	,	,	,
18637	17906	3	277	277	CD
18637	17906	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17906	5	1870	1870	CD
18637	17906	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17906	7	;	;	:
18637	17906	8	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	17906	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17906	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17906	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17906	12	Sauvinet	Sauvinet	NNP
18637	17906	13	,	,	,
18637	17906	14	92	92	CD
18637	17906	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17906	16	90	90	CD
18637	17906	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17906	18	1876	1876	CD
18637	17906	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17906	20	;	;	:
18637	17906	21	St.	St.	NNP
18637	17906	22	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	17906	23	&	&	CC
18637	17906	24	K.C.	K.C.	NNP
18637	17907	1	Land	Land	NNP
18637	17907	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17907	3	_	_	NNP
18637	17907	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	17907	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17907	6	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	17907	7	City	City	NNP
18637	17907	8	,	,	,
18637	17907	9	241	241	CD
18637	17907	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17907	11	419	419	CD
18637	17907	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17907	13	1916	1916	CD
18637	17907	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17907	15	.	.	.
18637	17908	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17908	2	11	11	CD
18637	17908	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17908	4	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	17908	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17908	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17908	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17908	8	Reid	Reid	NNP
18637	17908	9	,	,	,
18637	17908	10	11	11	CD
18637	17908	11	How	how	WRB
18637	17908	12	.	.	.
18637	17909	1	437	437	CD
18637	17909	2	,	,	,
18637	17909	3	460	460	CD
18637	17909	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17909	5	1851	1851	CD
18637	17909	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17909	7	;	;	:
18637	17909	8	Kennon	Kennon	NNP
18637	17909	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17909	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17909	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17909	12	Gilmer	Gilmer	NNP
18637	17909	13	,	,	,
18637	17909	14	131	131	CD
18637	17909	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17909	16	22	22	CD
18637	17909	17	,	,	,
18637	17909	18	28	28	CD
18637	17909	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17909	20	1889	1889	CD
18637	17909	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17909	22	.	.	.
18637	17910	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17910	2	12	12	CD
18637	17910	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17910	4	Capital	Capital	NNP
18637	17910	5	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	17910	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17910	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17910	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17910	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17910	10	Hof	Hof	NNP
18637	17910	11	,	,	,
18637	17910	12	174	174	CD
18637	17910	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17910	14	1	1	CD
18637	17910	15	,	,	,
18637	17910	16	5	5	CD
18637	17910	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17910	18	1899	1899	CD
18637	17910	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17910	20	.	.	.
18637	17911	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17911	2	13	13	CD
18637	17911	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17911	4	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
18637	17911	5	&	&	CC
18637	17911	6	St.	St.	NNP
18637	17911	7	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	17912	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17912	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17912	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17912	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17912	5	Bombolis	Bombolis	NNP
18637	17912	6	,	,	,
18637	17912	7	241	241	CD
18637	17912	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17912	9	211	211	CD
18637	17912	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17912	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	17912	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17912	13	,	,	,
18637	17912	14	which	which	WDT
18637	17912	15	involved	involve	VBD
18637	17912	16	The	the	DT
18637	17912	17	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	17912	18	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	17912	19	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	17912	20	Act	Act	NNP
18637	17912	21	of	of	IN
18637	17912	22	1908	1908	CD
18637	17912	23	.	.	.
18637	17913	1	The	the	DT
18637	17913	2	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	17913	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	17913	4	followed	follow	VBN
18637	17913	5	in	in	IN
18637	17913	6	four	four	CD
18637	17913	7	other	other	JJ
18637	17913	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	17913	9	in	in	IN
18637	17913	10	the	the	DT
18637	17913	11	same	same	JJ
18637	17913	12	volume	volume	NN
18637	17913	13	.	.	.
18637	17914	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17914	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17914	3	_	_	NNP
18637	17914	4	ibid	ibid	NN
18637	17914	5	.	.	.
18637	17915	1	241	241	CD
18637	17915	2	,	,	,
18637	17915	3	261	261	CD
18637	17915	4	,	,	,
18637	17915	5	485	485	CD
18637	17915	6	and	and	CC
18637	17915	7	494	494	CD
18637	17915	8	.	.	.
18637	17916	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17916	2	14	14	CD
18637	17916	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17916	4	Shields	Shields	NNP
18637	17916	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17916	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17916	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17916	8	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	17916	9	,	,	,
18637	17916	10	18	18	CD
18637	17916	11	How	how	WRB
18637	17916	12	.	.	.
18637	17917	1	253	253	CD
18637	17917	2	,	,	,
18637	17917	3	262	262	CD
18637	17917	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17917	5	1856	1856	CD
18637	17917	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17917	7	.	.	.
18637	17918	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17918	2	15	15	CD
18637	17918	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17918	4	Parsons	Parsons	NNPS
18637	17918	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17918	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17918	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17918	8	Bedford	Bedford	NNP
18637	17918	9	,	,	,
18637	17918	10	3	3	CD
18637	17918	11	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	17918	12	.	.	.
18637	17919	1	433	433	CD
18637	17919	2	,	,	,
18637	17919	3	447	447	CD
18637	17919	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17919	5	1830	1830	CD
18637	17919	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17919	7	;	;	:
18637	17919	8	Barton	Barton	NNP
18637	17919	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17919	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17919	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17919	12	Barbour	Barbour	NNP
18637	17919	13	,	,	,
18637	17919	14	104	104	CD
18637	17919	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17919	16	126	126	CD
18637	17919	17	,	,	,
18637	17919	18	133	133	CD
18637	17919	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17919	20	1881	1881	CD
18637	17919	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17919	22	.	.	.
18637	17920	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17920	2	16	16	CD
18637	17920	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17920	4	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	17920	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17920	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17920	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17920	8	Wooster	Wooster	NNP
18637	17920	9	,	,	,
18637	17920	10	119	119	CD
18637	17920	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17920	12	322	322	CD
18637	17920	13	,	,	,
18637	17920	14	325	325	CD
18637	17920	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17920	16	1886	1886	CD
18637	17920	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17920	18	;	;	:
18637	17920	19	Pease	Pease	NNP
18637	17920	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17920	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	17920	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17920	23	Rathbun	Rathbun	NNP
18637	17920	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	17920	25	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	17920	26	Eng	Eng	NNP
18637	17920	27	.	.	.
18637	17921	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17921	2	,	,	,
18637	17921	3	243	243	CD
18637	17921	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17921	5	273	273	CD
18637	17921	6	,	,	,
18637	17921	7	279	279	CD
18637	17921	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17921	9	1917	1917	CD
18637	17921	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17921	11	.	.	.
18637	17922	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17922	2	17	17	CD
18637	17922	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17922	4	Parsons	Parsons	NNPS
18637	17922	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17922	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17922	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17922	8	Bedford	Bedford	NNP
18637	17922	9	,	,	,
18637	17922	10	above	above	RB
18637	17922	11	;	;	:
18637	17922	12	Waring	Waring	NNP
18637	17922	13	_	_	NNP
18637	17922	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	17922	15	_	_	NNP
18637	17922	16	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	17922	17	,	,	,
18637	17922	18	5	5	CD
18637	17922	19	How	how	WRB
18637	17922	20	.	.	.
18637	17923	1	441	441	CD
18637	17923	2	,	,	,
18637	17923	3	460	460	CD
18637	17923	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17923	5	1847	1847	CD
18637	17923	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17923	7	.	.	.
18637	17924	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17924	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17924	3	also	also	RB
18637	17924	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17924	5	The	the	DT
18637	17924	6	"	"	``
18637	17924	7	Sarah	Sarah	NNP
18637	17924	8	,	,	,
18637	17924	9	"	"	''
18637	17924	10	8	8	CD
18637	17924	11	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	17924	12	.	.	.
18637	17925	1	390	390	CD
18637	17925	2	,	,	,
18637	17925	3	391	391	CD
18637	17925	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17925	5	1823	1823	CD
18637	17925	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17925	7	,	,	,
18637	17925	8	and	and	CC
18637	17925	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	17925	10	there	there	RB
18637	17925	11	cited	cite	VBD
18637	17925	12	.	.	.
18637	17926	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17926	2	18	18	CD
18637	17926	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17926	4	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	17926	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	17926	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17926	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17926	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17926	9	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	17926	10	&	&	CC
18637	17926	11	Laughlin	Laughlin	NNP
18637	17926	12	,	,	,
18637	17926	13	301	301	CD
18637	17926	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17926	15	1	1	CD
18637	17926	16	,	,	,
18637	17926	17	48	48	CD
18637	17926	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17926	19	1937	1937	CD
18637	17926	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17926	21	.	.	.
18637	17927	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17927	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17927	3	also	also	RB
18637	17927	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17927	5	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	17927	6	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	17927	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	17927	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17927	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17927	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17927	11	Brimson	Brimson	NNP
18637	17927	12	,	,	,
18637	17927	13	154	154	CD
18637	17927	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17927	15	447	447	CD
18637	17927	16	,	,	,
18637	17927	17	488	488	CD
18637	17927	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17927	19	1894	1894	CD
18637	17927	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17927	21	;	;	:
18637	17927	22	Yakus	Yakus	NNP
18637	17927	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17927	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	17927	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17927	26	United	United	NNP
18637	17927	27	States	States	NNP
18637	17927	28	,	,	,
18637	17927	29	321	321	CD
18637	17927	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17927	31	414	414	CD
18637	17927	32	,	,	,
18637	17927	33	447	447	CD
18637	17927	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17927	35	1944	1944	CD
18637	17927	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17927	37	.	.	.
18637	17928	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17928	2	19	19	CD
18637	17928	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17928	4	McElrath	McElrath	NNP
18637	17928	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17928	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17928	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17928	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17928	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17928	10	,	,	,
18637	17928	11	102	102	CD
18637	17928	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17928	13	426	426	CD
18637	17928	14	,	,	,
18637	17928	15	440	440	CD
18637	17928	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17928	17	1880	1880	CD
18637	17928	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17928	19	.	.	.
18637	17929	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17929	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17929	3	also	also	RB
18637	17929	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17929	5	Galloway	Galloway	NNP
18637	17929	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17929	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17929	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17929	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17929	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17929	11	,	,	,
18637	17929	12	319	319	CD
18637	17929	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17929	14	372	372	CD
18637	17929	15	,	,	,
18637	17929	16	388	388	CD
18637	17929	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17929	18	1943	1943	CD
18637	17929	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17929	20	.	.	.
18637	17930	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17930	2	20	20	CD
18637	17930	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17930	4	Guthrie	Guthrie	NNP
18637	17930	5	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	17930	6	.	.	.
18637	17931	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	17931	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17931	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17931	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17931	5	Guthrie	Guthrie	NNP
18637	17931	6	,	,	,
18637	17931	7	173	173	CD
18637	17931	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17931	9	528	528	CD
18637	17931	10	,	,	,
18637	17931	11	534	534	CD
18637	17931	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17931	13	1899	1899	CD
18637	17931	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17931	15	.	.	.
18637	17932	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17932	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17932	3	also	also	RB
18637	17932	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17932	5	United	United	NNP
18637	17932	6	States	States	NNP
18637	17932	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17932	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17932	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17932	10	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	17932	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17932	12	,	,	,
18637	17932	13	163	163	CD
18637	17932	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17932	15	427	427	CD
18637	17932	16	,	,	,
18637	17932	17	439	439	CD
18637	17932	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17932	19	1896	1896	CD
18637	17932	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17932	21	;	;	:
18637	17932	22	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	17932	23	City	City	NNP
18637	17932	24	Gaslight	Gaslight	NNP
18637	17932	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17932	26	_	_	NNP
18637	17932	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	17932	28	_	_	NNP
18637	17932	29	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	17932	30	,	,	,
18637	17932	31	95	95	CD
18637	17932	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17932	33	644	644	CD
18637	17932	34	,	,	,
18637	17932	35	653	653	CD
18637	17932	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17932	37	1877	1877	CD
18637	17932	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17932	39	.	.	.
18637	17933	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17933	2	21	21	CD
18637	17933	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17933	4	Luria	Luria	NNP
18637	17933	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17933	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17933	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17933	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17933	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17933	10	,	,	,
18637	17933	11	231	231	CD
18637	17933	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17933	13	9	9	CD
18637	17933	14	,	,	,
18637	17933	15	27	27	CD
18637	17933	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17933	17	1913	1913	CD
18637	17933	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17933	19	.	.	.
18637	17934	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17934	2	22	22	CD
18637	17934	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17934	4	Gee	Gee	NNP
18637	17934	5	Wah	Wah	NNP
18637	17934	6	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	17934	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17934	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17934	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17934	10	United	United	NNP
18637	17934	11	States	States	NNP
18637	17934	12	,	,	,
18637	17934	13	25	25	CD
18637	17934	14	F.	F.	NNP
18637	17934	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17934	16	2d	2d	NNP
18637	17934	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17934	18	107	107	CD
18637	17934	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17934	20	1928	1928	CD
18637	17934	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17934	22	;	;	:
18637	17934	23	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	17934	24	denied	deny	VBD
18637	17934	25	,	,	,
18637	17934	26	277	277	CD
18637	17934	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17934	28	608	608	CD
18637	17934	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17934	30	1928	1928	CD
18637	17934	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17934	32	.	.	.
18637	17935	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17935	2	23	23	CD
18637	17935	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17935	4	Filer	Filer	NNP
18637	17935	5	&	&	CC
18637	17935	6	S.	S.	NNP
18637	17935	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17935	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17935	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17935	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17935	11	Diamond	Diamond	NNP
18637	17935	12	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	17935	13	Works	Works	NNP
18637	17935	14	,	,	,
18637	17935	15	270	270	CD
18637	17935	16	F.	F.	NNP
18637	17935	17	489	489	CD
18637	17935	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17935	19	1921	1921	CD
18637	17935	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17935	21	;	;	:
18637	17935	22	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	17935	23	denied	denied	NNP
18637	17935	24	,	,	,
18637	17935	25	256	256	CD
18637	17935	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17935	27	691	691	CD
18637	17935	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17935	29	1921	1921	CD
18637	17935	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17935	31	.	.	.
18637	17936	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17936	2	24	24	CD
18637	17936	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17936	4	Crowell	Crowell	NNP
18637	17936	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17936	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17936	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17936	8	Benson	Benson	NNP
18637	17936	9	,	,	,
18637	17936	10	285	285	CD
18637	17936	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17936	12	22	22	CD
18637	17936	13	,	,	,
18637	17936	14	45	45	CD
18637	17936	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17936	16	1932	1932	CD
18637	17936	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17936	18	.	.	.
18637	17937	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17937	2	25	25	CD
18637	17937	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17937	4	In	in	IN
18637	17937	5	re	re	FW
18637	17937	6	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	17937	7	and	and	CC
18637	17937	8	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	17937	9	,	,	,
18637	17937	10	210	210	CD
18637	17937	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17937	12	246	246	CD
18637	17937	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17937	14	1908	1908	CD
18637	17937	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17937	16	.	.	.
18637	17938	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17938	2	26	26	CD
18637	17938	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17938	4	Auffmordt	Auffmordt	NNP
18637	17938	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17938	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17938	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17938	8	Hedden	Hedden	NNP
18637	17938	9	,	,	,
18637	17938	10	137	137	CD
18637	17938	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17938	12	310	310	CD
18637	17938	13	,	,	,
18637	17938	14	329	329	CD
18637	17938	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17938	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	17938	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17938	18	.	.	.
18637	17939	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17939	2	27	27	CD
18637	17939	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17939	4	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	17939	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17939	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17939	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17939	8	New	New	NNP
18637	17939	9	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	17939	10	&	&	CC
18637	17939	11	S.P.R.	S.P.R.	NNP
18637	17940	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17940	2	,	,	,
18637	17940	3	165	165	CD
18637	17940	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17940	5	593	593	CD
18637	17940	6	,	,	,
18637	17940	7	598	598	CD
18637	17940	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17940	9	1897	1897	CD
18637	17940	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17940	11	.	.	.
18637	17941	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17941	2	28	28	CD
18637	17941	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17941	4	Fidelity	Fidelity	NNP
18637	17941	5	&	&	CC
18637	17941	6	D.	D.	NNP
18637	17941	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17941	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17941	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17941	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17941	11	United	United	NNP
18637	17941	12	States	States	NNP
18637	17941	13	,	,	,
18637	17941	14	187	187	CD
18637	17941	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17941	16	315	315	CD
18637	17941	17	,	,	,
18637	17941	18	320	320	CD
18637	17941	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17941	20	1902	1902	CD
18637	17941	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17941	22	.	.	.
18637	17942	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17942	2	29	29	CD
18637	17942	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17942	4	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	17942	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17942	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17942	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17942	8	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	17942	9	Life	Life	NNP
18637	17942	10	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	17942	11	.	.	.
18637	17943	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17943	2	,	,	,
18637	17943	3	28	28	CD
18637	17943	4	F.	F.	NNP
18637	17943	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17943	6	2d	2d	NNP
18637	17943	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17943	8	545	545	CD
18637	17943	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17943	10	1928	1928	CD
18637	17943	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17943	12	,	,	,
18637	17943	13	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	17943	14	denied	deny	VBD
18637	17943	15	,	,	,
18637	17943	16	279	279	CD
18637	17943	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17943	18	842	842	CD
18637	17943	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17943	20	1929	1929	CD
18637	17943	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17943	22	.	.	.
18637	17944	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17944	2	30	30	CD
18637	17944	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17944	4	Meeker	Meeker	NNP
18637	17944	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17944	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17944	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17944	8	Lehigh	Lehigh	NNP
18637	17944	9	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	17944	10	R.	R.	NNP
18637	17944	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17944	12	,	,	,
18637	17944	13	236	236	CD
18637	17944	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17944	15	434	434	CD
18637	17944	16	,	,	,
18637	17944	17	439	439	CD
18637	17944	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17944	19	1915	1915	CD
18637	17944	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17944	21	.	.	.
18637	17945	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17945	2	31	31	CD
18637	17945	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17945	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17945	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	17945	6	Peterson	Peterson	NNP
18637	17945	7	,	,	,
18637	17945	8	253	253	CD
18637	17945	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17945	10	300	300	CD
18637	17945	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17945	12	1920	1920	CD
18637	17945	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17945	14	.	.	.
18637	17946	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17946	2	32	32	CD
18637	17946	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17946	4	United	United	NNP
18637	17946	5	States	States	NNP
18637	17946	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17946	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17946	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17946	9	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	17946	10	,	,	,
18637	17946	11	339	339	CD
18637	17946	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17946	13	699	699	CD
18637	17946	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17946	15	1950	1950	CD
18637	17946	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17946	17	.	.	.
18637	17947	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17947	2	33	33	CD
18637	17947	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17947	4	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	17947	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17947	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17947	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17947	8	Neely	neely	RB
18637	17947	9	,	,	,
18637	17947	10	140	140	CD
18637	17947	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17947	12	106	106	CD
18637	17947	13	,	,	,
18637	17947	14	109	109	CD
18637	17947	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17947	16	1891	1891	CD
18637	17947	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17947	18	.	.	.
18637	17948	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17948	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17948	3	also	also	RB
18637	17948	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17948	5	Bennett	Bennett	NNP
18637	17948	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17948	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17948	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17948	9	Butterworth	Butterworth	NNP
18637	17948	10	,	,	,
18637	17948	11	11	11	CD
18637	17948	12	How	how	WRB
18637	17948	13	.	.	.
18637	17949	1	669	669	CD
18637	17949	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17949	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	17949	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17949	5	;	;	:
18637	17949	6	Hipp	Hipp	NNP
18637	17949	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17949	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17949	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17949	10	Babin	Babin	NNP
18637	17949	11	,	,	,
18637	17949	12	19	19	CD
18637	17949	13	How	how	WRB
18637	17949	14	.	.	.
18637	17950	1	271	271	CD
18637	17950	2	,	,	,
18637	17950	3	278	278	CD
18637	17950	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17950	5	1857	1857	CD
18637	17950	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17950	7	;	;	:
18637	17950	8	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	17950	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17950	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17950	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17950	12	Cocks	Cocks	NNP
18637	17950	13	,	,	,
18637	17950	14	23	23	CD
18637	17950	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17950	16	.	.	.
18637	17951	1	466	466	CD
18637	17951	2	,	,	,
18637	17951	3	470	470	CD
18637	17951	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17951	5	1874	1874	CD
18637	17951	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17951	7	;	;	:
18637	17951	8	Killian	Killian	NNP
18637	17951	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17951	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17951	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17951	12	Ebbinghaus	Ebbinghaus	NNP
18637	17951	13	,	,	,
18637	17951	14	110	110	CD
18637	17951	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17951	16	568	568	CD
18637	17951	17	,	,	,
18637	17951	18	573	573	CD
18637	17951	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17951	20	1884	1884	CD
18637	17951	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17951	22	;	;	:
18637	17951	23	Buzard	Buzard	NNP
18637	17951	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17951	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	17951	26	_	_	NNP
18637	17951	27	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	17951	28	,	,	,
18637	17951	29	119	119	CD
18637	17951	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17951	31	347	347	CD
18637	17951	32	,	,	,
18637	17951	33	351	351	CD
18637	17951	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17951	35	1886	1886	CD
18637	17951	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17951	37	.	.	.
18637	17952	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17952	2	34	34	CD
18637	17952	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17952	4	Schoenthal	Schoenthal	NNP
18637	17952	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17952	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17952	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17952	8	Irving	Irving	NNP
18637	17952	9	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	17952	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17952	11	,	,	,
18637	17952	12	287	287	CD
18637	17952	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17952	14	92	92	CD
18637	17952	15	,	,	,
18637	17952	16	94	94	CD
18637	17952	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17952	18	1932	1932	CD
18637	17952	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17952	20	.	.	.
18637	17953	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17953	2	35	35	CD
18637	17953	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17953	4	American	American	NNP
18637	17953	5	Mills	Mills	NNPS
18637	17953	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17953	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17953	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17953	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17953	10	American	American	NNP
18637	17953	11	Surety	Surety	NNP
18637	17953	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17953	13	,	,	,
18637	17953	14	260	260	CD
18637	17953	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17953	16	360	360	CD
18637	17953	17	,	,	,
18637	17953	18	364	364	CD
18637	17953	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17953	20	1922	1922	CD
18637	17953	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17953	22	.	.	.
18637	17954	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17954	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17954	3	also	also	RB
18637	17954	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17954	5	Stamey	Stamey	NNP
18637	17954	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17954	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17954	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17954	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17954	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17954	11	,	,	,
18637	17954	12	37	37	CD
18637	17954	13	F.	F.	NNP
18637	17954	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17954	15	2d	2d	NNP
18637	17954	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17954	17	188	188	CD
18637	17954	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17954	19	1929	1929	CD
18637	17954	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17954	21	.	.	.
18637	17955	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17955	2	36	36	CD
18637	17955	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17955	4	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	17955	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17955	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17955	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17955	8	Central	Central	NNP
18637	17955	9	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	17955	10	R.	R.	NNP
18637	17955	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17955	12	,	,	,
18637	17955	13	6	6	CD
18637	17955	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17955	15	.	.	.
18637	17956	1	134	134	CD
18637	17956	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17956	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	17956	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17956	5	.	.	.
18637	17957	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17957	2	37	37	CD
18637	17957	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17957	4	Whitehead	Whitehead	NNP
18637	17957	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17957	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17957	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17957	8	Shattuck	Shattuck	NNP
18637	17957	9	,	,	,
18637	17957	10	138	138	CD
18637	17957	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17957	12	146	146	CD
18637	17957	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17957	14	1891	1891	CD
18637	17957	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17957	16	;	;	:
18637	17957	17	Buzard	Buzard	NNP
18637	17957	18	_	_	NNP
18637	17957	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	17957	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17957	21	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	17957	22	,	,	,
18637	17957	23	119	119	CD
18637	17957	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17957	25	347	347	CD
18637	17957	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17957	27	1886	1886	CD
18637	17957	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17957	29	;	;	:
18637	17957	30	Greeley	Greeley	NNP
18637	17957	31	_	_	NNP
18637	17957	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	17957	33	_	_	NNP
18637	17957	34	Lowe	Lowe	NNP
18637	17957	35	,	,	,
18637	17957	36	155	155	CD
18637	17957	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17957	38	58	58	CD
18637	17957	39	,	,	,
18637	17957	40	75	75	CD
18637	17957	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17957	42	1894	1894	CD
18637	17957	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17957	44	.	.	.
18637	17958	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17958	2	38	38	CD
18637	17958	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17958	4	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	17958	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17958	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17958	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17958	8	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	17958	9	,	,	,
18637	17958	10	13	13	CD
18637	17958	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	17958	12	.	.	.
18637	17959	1	195	195	CD
18637	17959	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17959	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	17959	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17959	5	;	;	:
18637	17959	6	Holland	Holland	NNP
18637	17959	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17959	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17959	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17959	10	Challen	Challen	NNP
18637	17959	11	,	,	,
18637	17959	12	110	110	CD
18637	17959	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17959	14	15	15	CD
18637	17959	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17959	16	1884	1884	CD
18637	17959	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17959	18	;	;	:
18637	17959	19	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	17959	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17959	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	17959	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17959	23	Crawfordsville	Crawfordsville	NNP
18637	17959	24	First	First	NNP
18637	17959	25	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	17959	26	.	.	.
18637	17960	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	17960	2	,	,	,
18637	17960	3	112	112	CD
18637	17960	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17960	5	405	405	CD
18637	17960	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17960	7	1884	1884	CD
18637	17960	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17960	9	;	;	:
18637	17960	10	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	17960	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17960	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	17960	13	_	_	NNP
18637	17960	14	Brewer	Brewer	NNP
18637	17960	15	,	,	,
18637	17960	16	114	114	CD
18637	17960	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17960	18	158	158	CD
18637	17960	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17960	20	1885	1885	CD
18637	17960	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17960	22	;	;	:
18637	17960	23	Cummings	Cummings	NNP
18637	17960	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17960	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	17960	26	_	_	NNP
18637	17960	27	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	17960	28	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	17960	29	.	.	.
18637	17961	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	17961	2	,	,	,
18637	17961	3	101	101	CD
18637	17961	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17961	5	153	153	CD
18637	17961	6	,	,	,
18637	17961	7	157	157	CD
18637	17961	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17961	9	1880	1880	CD
18637	17961	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17961	11	;	;	:
18637	17961	12	United	United	NNP
18637	17961	13	States	States	NNP
18637	17961	14	_	_	NNP
18637	17961	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	17961	16	_	_	NNP
18637	17961	17	Landram	Landram	NNP
18637	17961	18	,	,	,
18637	17961	19	118	118	CD
18637	17961	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17961	21	81	81	CD
18637	17961	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17961	23	1886	1886	CD
18637	17961	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17961	25	;	;	:
18637	17961	26	More	more	RBR
18637	17961	27	_	_	NNP
18637	17961	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	17961	29	_	_	NNP
18637	17961	30	Steinbach	Steinbach	NNP
18637	17961	31	,	,	,
18637	17961	32	127	127	CD
18637	17961	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17961	34	70	70	CD
18637	17961	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17961	36	1888	1888	CD
18637	17961	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17961	38	.	.	.
18637	17962	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17962	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	17962	3	.	.	.
18637	17962	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17962	5	Re	Re	NNP
18637	17962	6	Simons	Simons	NNPS
18637	17962	7	,	,	,
18637	17962	8	247	247	CD
18637	17962	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17962	10	231	231	CD
18637	17962	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17962	12	1918	1918	CD
18637	17962	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17962	14	.	.	.
18637	17963	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17963	2	39	39	CD
18637	17963	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17963	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	17963	5	parte	parte	NNP
18637	17963	6	Skinner	Skinner	NNP
18637	17963	7	&	&	CC
18637	17963	8	Eddy	Eddy	NNP
18637	17963	9	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	17963	10	,	,	,
18637	17963	11	265	265	CD
18637	17963	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17963	13	86	86	CD
18637	17963	14	,	,	,
18637	17963	15	96	96	CD
18637	17963	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17963	17	1924	1924	CD
18637	17963	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17963	19	.	.	.
18637	17964	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17964	2	40	40	CD
18637	17964	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17964	4	Vicksburg	Vicksburg	NNP
18637	17964	5	&	&	CC
18637	17964	6	M.R.	M.R.	NNP
18637	17965	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17965	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17965	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17965	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17965	5	Putnam	Putnam	NNP
18637	17965	6	,	,	,
18637	17965	7	118	118	CD
18637	17965	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17965	9	545	545	CD
18637	17965	10	,	,	,
18637	17965	11	553	553	CD
18637	17965	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17965	13	1886	1886	CD
18637	17965	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17965	15	;	;	:
18637	17965	16	United	United	NNP
18637	17965	17	States	States	NNP
18637	17965	18	_	_	NNP
18637	17965	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	17965	20	_	_	NNP
18637	17965	21	Reading	Reading	NNP
18637	17965	22	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	17965	23	,	,	,
18637	17965	24	123	123	CD
18637	17965	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17965	26	113	113	CD
18637	17965	27	,	,	,
18637	17965	28	114	114	CD
18637	17965	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17965	30	1887	1887	CD
18637	17965	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17965	32	.	.	.
18637	17966	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17966	2	41	41	CD
18637	17966	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17966	4	118	118	CD
18637	17966	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17966	6	545	545	CD
18637	17966	7	;	;	:
18637	17966	8	where	where	WRB
18637	17966	9	are	be	VBP
18637	17966	10	cited	cite	VBN
18637	17966	11	Carver	Carver	NNP
18637	17966	12	_	_	NNP
18637	17966	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	17966	14	_	_	NNP
18637	17966	15	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	17966	16	ex	ex	NNP
18637	17966	17	dem	dem	NNP
18637	17966	18	.	.	.
18637	17967	1	Astor	Astor	NNP
18637	17967	2	et	et	NNP
18637	17967	3	al	al	NNP
18637	17967	4	.	.	NNP
18637	17967	5	,	,	,
18637	17967	6	4	4	CD
18637	17967	7	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	17967	8	.	.	.
18637	17968	1	1	1	CD
18637	17968	2	,	,	,
18637	17968	3	80	80	CD
18637	17968	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17968	5	1830	1830	CD
18637	17968	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17968	7	;	;	:
18637	17968	8	Magniac	Magniac	NNP
18637	17968	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17968	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17968	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17968	12	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	17968	13	,	,	,
18637	17968	14	7	7	CD
18637	17968	15	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	17968	16	.	.	.
18637	17969	1	348	348	CD
18637	17969	2	,	,	,
18637	17969	3	390	390	CD
18637	17969	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17969	5	1833	1833	CD
18637	17969	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17969	7	;	;	:
18637	17969	8	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	17969	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17969	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17969	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17969	12	Harmony	Harmony	NNP
18637	17969	13	,	,	,
18637	17969	14	13	13	CD
18637	17969	15	How	how	WRB
18637	17969	16	.	.	.
18637	17970	1	115	115	CD
18637	17970	2	,	,	,
18637	17970	3	131	131	CD
18637	17970	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17970	5	1852	1852	CD
18637	17970	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17970	7	;	;	:
18637	17970	8	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	17970	9	Line	Line	NNP
18637	17970	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17970	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	17970	12	_	_	NNP
18637	17970	13	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	17970	14	,	,	,
18637	17970	15	95	95	CD
18637	17970	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17970	17	297	297	CD
18637	17970	18	,	,	,
18637	17970	19	302	302	CD
18637	17970	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17970	21	1877	1877	CD
18637	17970	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17970	23	.	.	.
18637	17971	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17971	2	42	42	CD
18637	17971	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17971	4	Games	Games	NNPS
18637	17971	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17971	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17971	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17971	8	Dunn	Dunn	NNP
18637	17971	9	,	,	,
18637	17971	10	14	14	CD
18637	17971	11	Pet	pet	NN
18637	17971	12	.	.	.
18637	17972	1	322	322	CD
18637	17972	2	,	,	,
18637	17972	3	327	327	CD
18637	17972	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17972	5	1840	1840	CD
18637	17972	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17972	7	.	.	.
18637	17973	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17973	2	43	43	CD
18637	17973	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17973	4	Sparf	Sparf	NNP
18637	17973	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17973	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17973	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17973	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17973	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17973	10	,	,	,
18637	17973	11	156	156	CD
18637	17973	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17973	13	51	51	CD
18637	17973	14	,	,	,
18637	17973	15	99	99	CD
18637	17973	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	17973	17	100	100	CD
18637	17973	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17973	19	1895	1895	CD
18637	17973	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17973	21	;	;	:
18637	17973	22	Pleasants	Pleasants	NNP
18637	17973	23	_	_	NNP
18637	17973	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	17973	25	_	_	NNP
18637	17973	26	Fant	Fant	NNP
18637	17973	27	,	,	,
18637	17973	28	22	22	CD
18637	17973	29	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17973	30	.	.	.
18637	17974	1	116	116	CD
18637	17974	2	,	,	,
18637	17974	3	121	121	CD
18637	17974	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17974	5	1875	1875	CD
18637	17974	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17974	7	;	;	:
18637	17974	8	Randall	Randall	NNP
18637	17974	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17974	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17974	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17974	12	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	17974	13	&	&	CC
18637	17974	14	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	17974	15	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	17975	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17975	2	,	,	,
18637	17975	3	109	109	CD
18637	17975	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17975	5	478	478	CD
18637	17975	6	,	,	,
18637	17975	7	482	482	CD
18637	17975	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17975	9	1883	1883	CD
18637	17975	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17975	11	;	;	:
18637	17975	12	Meehan	Meehan	NNP
18637	17975	13	_	_	NNP
18637	17975	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	17975	15	_	_	NNP
18637	17975	16	Valentine	Valentine	NNP
18637	17975	17	,	,	,
18637	17975	18	145	145	CD
18637	17975	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17975	20	611	611	CD
18637	17975	21	,	,	,
18637	17975	22	625	625	CD
18637	17975	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17975	24	1892	1892	CD
18637	17975	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17975	26	;	;	:
18637	17975	27	Coughran	Coughran	NNP
18637	17975	28	_	_	NNP
18637	17975	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	17975	30	_	_	NNP
18637	17975	31	Bigelow	Bigelow	NNP
18637	17975	32	,	,	,
18637	17975	33	164	164	CD
18637	17975	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17975	35	301	301	CD
18637	17975	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17975	37	1896	1896	CD
18637	17975	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17975	39	.	.	.
18637	17976	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17976	2	44	44	CD
18637	17976	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17976	4	Treat	Treat	NNP
18637	17976	5	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	17976	6	.	.	.
18637	17977	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17977	2	_	_	NNP
18637	17977	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	17977	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17977	5	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	17977	6	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	17977	7	&	&	CC
18637	17977	8	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	17977	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17977	10	,	,	,
18637	17977	11	157	157	CD
18637	17977	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17977	13	674	674	CD
18637	17977	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17977	15	1895	1895	CD
18637	17977	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17977	17	;	;	:
18637	17977	18	Randall	Randall	NNP
18637	17977	19	_	_	NNP
18637	17977	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	17977	21	_	_	NNP
18637	17977	22	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	17977	23	&	&	CC
18637	17977	24	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	17977	25	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	17978	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17978	2	,	,	,
18637	17978	3	109	109	CD
18637	17978	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17978	5	478	478	CD
18637	17978	6	,	,	,
18637	17978	7	482	482	CD
18637	17978	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17978	9	1883	1883	CD
18637	17978	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17978	11	and	and	CC
18637	17978	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	17978	13	there	there	RB
18637	17978	14	cited	cite	VBD
18637	17978	15	.	.	.
18637	17979	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17979	2	45	45	CD
18637	17979	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17979	4	Capital	Capital	NNP
18637	17979	5	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	17979	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17979	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17979	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17979	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17979	10	Hof	Hof	NNP
18637	17979	11	,	,	,
18637	17979	12	174	174	CD
18637	17979	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17979	14	1	1	CD
18637	17979	15	,	,	,
18637	17979	16	13	13	CD
18637	17979	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17979	18	1899	1899	CD
18637	17979	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17979	20	.	.	.
18637	17980	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17980	2	46	46	CD
18637	17980	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17980	4	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	17980	5	Land	Land	NNP
18637	17980	6	&	&	CC
18637	17980	7	Cattle	Cattle	NNP
18637	17980	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	17980	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17980	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	17980	11	_	_	NNP
18637	17980	12	Mann	Mann	NNP
18637	17980	13	,	,	,
18637	17980	14	130	130	CD
18637	17980	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17980	16	69	69	CD
18637	17980	17	,	,	,
18637	17980	18	74	74	CD
18637	17980	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17980	20	1889	1889	CD
18637	17980	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17980	22	.	.	.
18637	17981	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17981	2	47	47	CD
18637	17981	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17981	4	Dimick	Dimick	NNP
18637	17981	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17981	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17981	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17981	8	Schiedt	Schiedt	NNP
18637	17981	9	,	,	,
18637	17981	10	293	293	CD
18637	17981	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17981	12	474	474	CD
18637	17981	13	,	,	,
18637	17981	14	476	476	CD
18637	17981	15	-	-	SYM
18637	17981	16	478	478	CD
18637	17981	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17981	18	1935	1935	CD
18637	17981	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17981	20	.	.	.
18637	17982	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17982	2	48	48	CD
18637	17982	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17982	4	228	228	CD
18637	17982	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17982	6	364	364	CD
18637	17982	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17982	8	1913	1913	CD
18637	17982	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17982	10	.	.	.
18637	17983	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17983	2	49	49	CD
18637	17983	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17983	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17983	5	See	See	NNP
18637	17983	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17983	7	Austin	Austin	NNP
18637	17983	8	Wakeman	Wakeman	NNP
18637	17983	9	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	17983	10	,	,	,
18637	17983	11	Fundamentals	fundamental	NNS
18637	17983	12	of	of	IN
18637	17983	13	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	17983	14	in	in	IN
18637	17983	15	Actions	Actions	NNPS
18637	17983	16	at	at	IN
18637	17983	17	Law	Law	NNP
18637	17983	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17983	19	1922	1922	CD
18637	17983	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17983	21	,	,	,
18637	17983	22	103	103	CD
18637	17983	23	and	and	CC
18637	17983	24	articles	article	NNS
18637	17983	25	there	there	RB
18637	17983	26	cited	cite	VBD
18637	17983	27	.	.	.
18637	17984	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17984	2	50	50	CD
18637	17984	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17984	4	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	17984	5	&	&	CC
18637	17984	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	17984	7	Line	Line	NNP
18637	17984	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17984	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	17984	10	_	_	NNP
18637	17984	11	Redman	Redman	NNP
18637	17984	12	,	,	,
18637	17984	13	295	295	CD
18637	17984	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17984	15	654	654	CD
18637	17984	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17984	17	1935	1935	CD
18637	17984	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17984	19	.	.	.
18637	17985	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17985	2	51	51	CD
18637	17985	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17985	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17985	5	.	.	.
18637	17986	1	661	661	CD
18637	17986	2	.	.	.
18637	17987	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17987	2	52	52	CD
18637	17987	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17987	4	Lyon	Lyon	NNP
18637	17987	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17987	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17987	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17987	8	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	17987	9	Benefit	Benefit	NNP
18637	17987	10	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	17987	11	.	.	.
18637	17987	12	,	,	,
18637	17987	13	305	305	CD
18637	17987	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17987	15	484	484	CD
18637	17987	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17987	17	1939	1939	CD
18637	17987	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17987	19	.	.	.
18637	17988	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17988	2	53	53	CD
18637	17988	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17988	4	28	28	CD
18637	17988	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	17989	1	§	§	NNP
18637	17989	2	724	724	CD
18637	17989	3	.	.	.
18637	17990	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17990	2	54	54	CD
18637	17990	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17990	4	Galloway	Galloway	NNP
18637	17990	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17990	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17990	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17990	8	United	United	NNP
18637	17990	9	States	States	NNP
18637	17990	10	,	,	,
18637	17990	11	319	319	CD
18637	17990	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17990	13	372	372	CD
18637	17990	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17990	15	1943	1943	CD
18637	17990	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17990	17	.	.	.
18637	17991	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17991	2	55	55	CD
18637	17991	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17991	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	17991	5	.	.	.
18637	17992	1	397	397	CD
18637	17992	2	.	.	.
18637	17993	1	As	as	IN
18637	17993	2	a	a	DT
18637	17993	3	matter	matter	NN
18637	17993	4	of	of	IN
18637	17993	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	17993	6	,	,	,
18637	17993	7	the	the	DT
18637	17993	8	case	case	NN
18637	17993	9	being	be	VBG
18637	17993	10	a	a	DT
18637	17993	11	claim	claim	NN
18637	17993	12	against	against	IN
18637	17993	13	the	the	DT
18637	17993	14	United	United	NNP
18637	17993	15	States	States	NNP
18637	17993	16	need	nee	MD
18637	17993	17	not	not	RB
18637	17993	18	have	have	VB
18637	17993	19	been	be	VBN
18637	17993	20	tried	try	VBN
18637	17993	21	by	by	IN
18637	17993	22	a	a	DT
18637	17993	23	jury	jury	NN
18637	17993	24	except	except	IN
18637	17993	25	for	for	IN
18637	17993	26	the	the	DT
18637	17993	27	allowance	allowance	NN
18637	17993	28	of	of	IN
18637	17993	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	17993	30	.	.	.
18637	17994	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17994	2	56	56	CD
18637	17994	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17994	4	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	17994	5	's	's	POS
18637	17994	6	Distilled	Distilled	NNP
18637	17994	7	Spirits	Spirits	NNPS
18637	17994	8	,	,	,
18637	17994	9	14	14	CD
18637	17994	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	17994	11	.	.	.
18637	17995	1	44	44	CD
18637	17995	2	,	,	,
18637	17995	3	53	53	CD
18637	17995	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17995	5	1872	1872	CD
18637	17995	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17995	7	.	.	.
18637	17996	1	_	_	NNP
18637	17996	2	See	See	NNP
18637	17996	3	also	also	RB
18637	17996	4	_	_	NNP
18637	17996	5	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	17996	6	_	_	NNP
18637	17996	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	17996	8	_	_	NNP
18637	17996	9	United	United	NNP
18637	17996	10	States	States	NNP
18637	17996	11	,	,	,
18637	17996	12	141	141	CD
18637	17996	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	17996	14	548	548	CD
18637	17996	15	,	,	,
18637	17996	16	554	554	CD
18637	17996	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17996	18	1891	1891	CD
18637	17996	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17996	20	;	;	:
18637	17996	21	Parsons	Parsons	NNP
18637	17996	22	_	_	NNP
18637	17996	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	17996	24	_	_	NNP
18637	17996	25	Armor	Armor	NNP
18637	17996	26	,	,	,
18637	17996	27	3	3	CD
18637	17996	28	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	17996	29	.	.	.
18637	17997	1	413	413	CD
18637	17997	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17997	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	17997	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17997	5	;	;	:
18637	17997	6	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
18637	17997	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17997	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	17997	9	_	_	NNP
18637	17997	10	Boyreau	Boyreau	NNP
18637	17997	11	,	,	,
18637	17997	12	21	21	CD
18637	17997	13	How	how	WRB
18637	17997	14	.	.	.
18637	17998	1	223	223	CD
18637	17998	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	17998	3	1859	1859	CD
18637	17998	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	17998	5	.	.	.
18637	17999	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	17999	2	57	57	CD
18637	17999	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	17999	4	Baylis	Baylis	NNP
18637	17999	5	_	_	NNP
18637	17999	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	17999	7	_	_	NNP
18637	17999	8	Travelers	Travelers	NNPS
18637	17999	9	'	'	POS
18637	17999	10	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	17999	11	.	.	.
18637	18000	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18000	2	,	,	,
18637	18000	3	113	113	CD
18637	18000	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18000	5	316	316	CD
18637	18000	6	,	,	,
18637	18000	7	321	321	CD
18637	18000	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18000	9	1885	1885	CD
18637	18000	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18000	11	,	,	,
18637	18000	12	holding	hold	VBG
18637	18000	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18000	14	error	error	NN
18637	18000	15	for	for	IN
18637	18000	16	a	a	DT
18637	18000	17	judge	judge	NN
18637	18000	18	,	,	,
18637	18000	19	in	in	IN
18637	18000	20	absence	absence	NN
18637	18000	21	of	of	IN
18637	18000	22	any	any	DT
18637	18000	23	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	18000	24	,	,	,
18637	18000	25	to	to	TO
18637	18000	26	find	find	VB
18637	18000	27	the	the	DT
18637	18000	28	facts	fact	NNS
18637	18000	29	and	and	CC
18637	18000	30	render	render	VB
18637	18000	31	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18000	32	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	18000	33	.	.	.
18637	18001	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18001	2	58	58	CD
18637	18001	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18001	4	Duignan	Duignan	NNP
18637	18001	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18001	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18001	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18001	8	United	United	NNP
18637	18001	9	States	States	NNP
18637	18001	10	,	,	,
18637	18001	11	274	274	CD
18637	18001	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18001	13	195	195	CD
18637	18001	14	,	,	,
18637	18001	15	198	198	CD
18637	18001	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18001	17	1927	1927	CD
18637	18001	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18001	19	,	,	,
18637	18001	20	holding	hold	VBG
18637	18001	21	jury	jury	NN
18637	18001	22	trial	trial	NN
18637	18001	23	waived	waive	VBN
18637	18001	24	by	by	IN
18637	18001	25	an	an	DT
18637	18001	26	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	18001	27	and	and	CC
18637	18001	28	participation	participation	NN
18637	18001	29	in	in	IN
18637	18001	30	the	the	DT
18637	18001	31	trial	trial	NN
18637	18001	32	without	without	IN
18637	18001	33	demanding	demand	VBG
18637	18001	34	a	a	DT
18637	18001	35	jury	jury	NN
18637	18001	36	.	.	.
18637	18002	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18002	2	59	59	CD
18637	18002	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18002	4	Hodges	Hodges	NNP
18637	18002	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18002	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18002	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18002	8	Easton	Easton	NNP
18637	18002	9	,	,	,
18637	18002	10	106	106	CD
18637	18002	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18002	12	408	408	CD
18637	18002	13	,	,	,
18637	18002	14	412	412	CD
18637	18002	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18002	16	1883	1883	CD
18637	18002	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18002	18	.	.	.
18637	18003	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18003	2	60	60	CD
18637	18003	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18003	4	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	18003	5	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	18003	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18003	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18003	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18003	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18003	10	Kennedy	Kennedy	NNP
18637	18003	11	,	,	,
18637	18003	12	301	301	CD
18637	18003	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18003	14	389	389	CD
18637	18003	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18003	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	18003	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18003	18	.	.	.
18637	18004	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18004	2	61	61	CD
18637	18004	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18004	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18004	5	See	See	NNP
18637	18004	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18004	7	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	18004	8	of	of	IN
18637	18004	9	the	the	DT
18637	18004	10	Sup	Sup	NNP
18637	18004	11	.	.	.
18637	18005	1	Ct	Ct	NNP
18637	18005	2	.	.	NNP
18637	18005	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18005	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	18005	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18005	6	United	United	NNP
18637	18005	7	States	States	NNP
18637	18005	8	ex	ex	NNP
18637	18005	9	rel	rel	NN
18637	18005	10	.	.	.
18637	18006	1	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	18006	2	,	,	,
18637	18006	3	9	9	CD
18637	18006	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	18006	5	.	.	.
18637	18007	1	274	274	CD
18637	18007	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18007	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	18007	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18007	5	;	;	:
18637	18007	6	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	18007	7	,	,	,
18637	18007	8	B.	B.	NNP
18637	18008	1	&	&	CC
18637	18008	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	18009	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18009	2	_	_	NNP
18637	18009	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	18009	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18009	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	18009	6	,	,	,
18637	18009	7	166	166	CD
18637	18009	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18009	9	226	226	CD
18637	18009	10	,	,	,
18637	18009	11	242	242	CD
18637	18009	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18009	13	1897	1897	CD
18637	18009	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18009	15	.	.	.
18637	18010	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	18010	2	8	8	CD
18637	18010	3	BAIL	BAIL	NNP
18637	18010	4	,	,	,
18637	18010	5	FINES	FINES	NNP
18637	18010	6	,	,	,
18637	18010	7	AND	and	CC
18637	18010	8	OTHER	other	JJ
18637	18010	9	PUNISHMENT	punishment	NN
18637	18010	10	FOR	for	IN
18637	18010	11	CRIME	crime	NN
18637	18010	12	Page	page	NN
18637	18010	13	Excessive	Excessive	NNP
18637	18010	14	bail	bail	NN
18637	18010	15	903	903	CD
18637	18010	16	Excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	18010	17	fines	fine	NNS
18637	18010	18	904	904	CD
18637	18010	19	Cruel	cruel	JJ
18637	18010	20	and	and	CC
18637	18010	21	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	18010	22	punishments	punishment	NNS
18637	18010	23	904	904	CD
18637	18010	24	PUNISHMENT	PUNISHMENT	NNP
18637	18010	25	FOR	for	IN
18637	18010	26	CRIME	crime	NN
18637	18010	27	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18010	28	8	8	CD
18637	18010	29	Excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	18010	30	bail	bail	NN
18637	18010	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	18010	32	not	not	RB
18637	18010	33	be	be	VB
18637	18010	34	required	require	VBN
18637	18010	35	,	,	,
18637	18010	36	nor	nor	CC
18637	18010	37	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	18010	38	fines	fine	NNS
18637	18010	39	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18010	40	,	,	,
18637	18010	41	nor	nor	CC
18637	18010	42	cruel	cruel	JJ
18637	18010	43	and	and	CC
18637	18010	44	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	18010	45	punishments	punishment	NNS
18637	18010	46	inflicted	inflict	VBN
18637	18010	47	.	.	.
18637	18011	1	When	when	WRB
18637	18011	2	the	the	DT
18637	18011	3	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	18011	4	of	of	IN
18637	18011	5	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	18011	6	was	be	VBD
18637	18011	7	being	be	VBG
18637	18011	8	debated	debate	VBN
18637	18011	9	in	in	IN
18637	18011	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18011	11	,	,	,
18637	18011	12	two	two	CD
18637	18011	13	members	member	NNS
18637	18011	14	took	take	VBD
18637	18011	15	exception	exception	NN
18637	18011	16	to	to	IN
18637	18011	17	this	this	DT
18637	18011	18	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	18011	19	.	.	.
18637	18012	1	One	one	CD
18637	18012	2	"	"	``
18637	18012	3	objected	object	VBD
18637	18012	4	to	to	IN
18637	18012	5	the	the	DT
18637	18012	6	words	word	NNS
18637	18012	7	'	'	POS
18637	18012	8	nor	nor	CC
18637	18012	9	cruel	cruel	JJ
18637	18012	10	and	and	CC
18637	18012	11	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	18012	12	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	18012	13	,	,	,
18637	18012	14	'	'	''
18637	18012	15	the	the	DT
18637	18012	16	import	import	NN
18637	18012	17	of	of	IN
18637	18012	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18012	19	being	be	VBG
18637	18012	20	too	too	RB
18637	18012	21	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	18012	22	.	.	.
18637	18013	1	"	"	``
18637	18013	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18013	3	1	1	LS
18637	18013	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18013	5	Another	another	DT
18637	18013	6	leveled	level	VBD
18637	18013	7	a	a	DT
18637	18013	8	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18013	9	criticism	criticism	NN
18637	18013	10	at	at	IN
18637	18013	11	the	the	DT
18637	18013	12	entire	entire	JJ
18637	18013	13	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18013	14	;	;	:
18637	18013	15	"	"	``
18637	18013	16	What	what	WP
18637	18013	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	18013	18	meant	mean	VBN
18637	18013	19	by	by	IN
18637	18013	20	the	the	DT
18637	18013	21	terms	term	NNS
18637	18013	22	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	18013	23	bail	bail	NN
18637	18013	24	?	?	.
18637	18014	1	Who	who	WP
18637	18014	2	are	be	VBP
18637	18014	3	to	to	TO
18637	18014	4	be	be	VB
18637	18014	5	the	the	DT
18637	18014	6	judges	judge	NNS
18637	18014	7	?	?	.
18637	18015	1	What	what	WP
18637	18015	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	18015	3	understood	understand	VBN
18637	18015	4	by	by	IN
18637	18015	5	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	18015	6	fines	fine	NNS
18637	18015	7	?	?	.
18637	18016	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18016	2	lies	lie	VBZ
18637	18016	3	with	with	IN
18637	18016	4	the	the	DT
18637	18016	5	court	court	NN
18637	18016	6	to	to	TO
18637	18016	7	determine	determine	VB
18637	18016	8	.	.	.
18637	18017	1	No	no	DT
18637	18017	2	cruel	cruel	JJ
18637	18017	3	and	and	CC
18637	18017	4	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	18017	5	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	18017	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	18017	7	to	to	TO
18637	18017	8	be	be	VB
18637	18017	9	inflicted	inflict	VBN
18637	18017	10	;	;	:
18637	18017	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18017	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	18017	13	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	18017	14	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18017	15	to	to	TO
18637	18017	16	hang	hang	VB
18637	18017	17	a	a	DT
18637	18017	18	man	man	NN
18637	18017	19	,	,	,
18637	18017	20	villains	villain	NNS
18637	18017	21	often	often	RB
18637	18017	22	deserve	deserve	VBP
18637	18017	23	whipping	whip	VBG
18637	18017	24	,	,	,
18637	18017	25	and	and	CC
18637	18017	26	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	18017	27	having	have	VBG
18637	18017	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18017	29	ears	ear	NNS
18637	18017	30	cut	cut	VBN
18637	18017	31	off	off	RP
18637	18017	32	;	;	:
18637	18017	33	but	but	CC
18637	18017	34	are	be	VBP
18637	18017	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18017	36	in	in	IN
18637	18017	37	future	future	NN
18637	18017	38	to	to	TO
18637	18017	39	be	be	VB
18637	18017	40	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	18017	41	from	from	IN
18637	18017	42	inflicting	inflict	VBG
18637	18017	43	these	these	DT
18637	18017	44	punishments	punishment	NNS
18637	18017	45	because	because	IN
18637	18017	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18017	47	are	be	VBP
18637	18017	48	cruel	cruel	JJ
18637	18017	49	?	?	.
18637	18018	1	If	if	IN
18637	18018	2	a	a	DT
18637	18018	3	more	more	RBR
18637	18018	4	lenient	lenient	JJ
18637	18018	5	mode	mode	NN
18637	18018	6	of	of	IN
18637	18018	7	correcting	correct	VBG
18637	18018	8	vice	vice	NN
18637	18018	9	and	and	CC
18637	18018	10	deterring	deter	VBG
18637	18018	11	others	other	NNS
18637	18018	12	from	from	IN
18637	18018	13	the	the	DT
18637	18018	14	commission	commission	NN
18637	18018	15	of	of	IN
18637	18018	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18018	17	could	could	MD
18637	18018	18	be	be	VB
18637	18018	19	invented	invent	VBN
18637	18018	20	,	,	,
18637	18018	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18018	22	would	would	MD
18637	18018	23	be	be	VB
18637	18018	24	very	very	RB
18637	18018	25	prudent	prudent	JJ
18637	18018	26	in	in	IN
18637	18018	27	the	the	DT
18637	18018	28	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	18018	29	to	to	TO
18637	18018	30	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	18018	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18018	32	;	;	:
18637	18018	33	but	but	CC
18637	18018	34	until	until	IN
18637	18018	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18018	36	have	have	VBP
18637	18018	37	some	some	DT
18637	18018	38	security	security	NN
18637	18018	39	that	that	IN
18637	18018	40	this	this	DT
18637	18018	41	will	will	MD
18637	18018	42	be	be	VB
18637	18018	43	done	do	VBN
18637	18018	44	,	,	,
18637	18018	45	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18018	46	ought	ought	MD
18637	18018	47	not	not	RB
18637	18018	48	to	to	TO
18637	18018	49	be	be	VB
18637	18018	50	restrained	restrain	VBN
18637	18018	51	from	from	IN
18637	18018	52	making	make	VBG
18637	18018	53	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18018	54	laws	law	NNS
18637	18018	55	by	by	IN
18637	18018	56	any	any	DT
18637	18018	57	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	18018	58	of	of	IN
18637	18018	59	this	this	DT
18637	18018	60	kind	kind	NN
18637	18018	61	.	.	.
18637	18019	1	"	"	``
18637	18019	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18019	3	2	2	LS
18637	18019	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18019	5	Excessive	Excessive	NNP
18637	18019	6	Bail	Bail	NNP
18637	18019	7	A	A	NNP
18637	18019	8	United	United	NNP
18637	18019	9	States	States	NNP
18637	18019	10	District	District	NNP
18637	18019	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18019	12	fixed	fix	VBD
18637	18019	13	the	the	DT
18637	18019	14	bail	bail	NN
18637	18019	15	of	of	IN
18637	18019	16	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	18019	17	persons	person	NNS
18637	18019	18	who	who	WP
18637	18019	19	were	be	VBD
18637	18019	20	arrested	arrest	VBN
18637	18019	21	on	on	IN
18637	18019	22	charge	charge	NN
18637	18019	23	of	of	IN
18637	18019	24	conspiring	conspire	VBG
18637	18019	25	to	to	TO
18637	18019	26	violate	violate	VB
18637	18019	27	the	the	DT
18637	18019	28	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	18019	29	Act[3	Act[3	NNP
18637	18019	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18019	31	at	at	IN
18637	18019	32	$	$	$
18637	18019	33	50,000	50,000	CD
18637	18019	34	each	each	DT
18637	18019	35	.	.	.
18637	18020	1	This	this	DT
18637	18020	2	was	be	VBD
18637	18020	3	on	on	IN
18637	18020	4	the	the	DT
18637	18020	5	theory	theory	NN
18637	18020	6	advanced	advance	VBN
18637	18020	7	by	by	IN
18637	18020	8	the	the	DT
18637	18020	9	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18020	10	that	that	IN
18637	18020	11	each	each	DT
18637	18020	12	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	18020	13	was	be	VBD
18637	18020	14	a	a	DT
18637	18020	15	pawn	pawn	NN
18637	18020	16	in	in	IN
18637	18020	17	a	a	DT
18637	18020	18	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	18020	19	and	and	CC
18637	18020	20	in	in	IN
18637	18020	21	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	18020	22	to	to	IN
18637	18020	23	a	a	DT
18637	18020	24	superior	superior	JJ
18637	18020	25	would	would	MD
18637	18020	26	flee	flee	VB
18637	18020	27	the	the	DT
18637	18020	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18020	29	,	,	,
18637	18020	30	a	a	DT
18637	18020	31	theory	theory	NN
18637	18020	32	to	to	TO
18637	18020	33	support	support	VB
18637	18020	34	which	which	WDT
18637	18020	35	no	no	DT
18637	18020	36	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18020	37	was	be	VBD
18637	18020	38	introduced	introduce	VBN
18637	18020	39	.	.	.
18637	18021	1	The	the	DT
18637	18021	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18021	3	held	hold	VBD
18637	18021	4	that	that	DT
18637	18021	5	bail	bail	NN
18637	18021	6	set	set	VBN
18637	18021	7	before	before	IN
18637	18021	8	trial	trial	NN
18637	18021	9	at	at	IN
18637	18021	10	a	a	DT
18637	18021	11	figure	figure	NN
18637	18021	12	higher	high	JJR
18637	18021	13	than	than	IN
18637	18021	14	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	18021	15	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	18021	16	to	to	TO
18637	18021	17	assure	assure	VB
18637	18021	18	the	the	DT
18637	18021	19	presence	presence	NN
18637	18021	20	of	of	IN
18637	18021	21	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	18021	22	at	at	IN
18637	18021	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18021	24	trial	trial	NN
18637	18021	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	18021	26	"	"	``
18637	18021	27	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	18021	28	"	"	''
18637	18021	29	in	in	IN
18637	18021	30	the	the	DT
18637	18021	31	sense	sense	NN
18637	18021	32	of	of	IN
18637	18021	33	the	the	DT
18637	18021	34	Eighth	Eighth	NNP
18637	18021	35	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18021	36	,	,	,
18637	18021	37	and	and	CC
18637	18021	38	that	that	IN
18637	18021	39	the	the	DT
18637	18021	40	case	case	NN
18637	18021	41	of	of	IN
18637	18021	42	each	each	DT
18637	18021	43	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	18021	44	must	must	MD
18637	18021	45	be	be	VB
18637	18021	46	determined	determine	VBN
18637	18021	47	on	on	IN
18637	18021	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18021	49	merits	merit	NNS
18637	18021	50	.	.	.
18637	18022	1	Bail	bail	NN
18637	18022	2	of	of	IN
18637	18022	3	larger	large	JJR
18637	18022	4	amount	amount	NN
18637	18022	5	than	than	IN
18637	18022	6	that	that	DT
18637	18022	7	usually	usually	RB
18637	18022	8	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	18022	9	for	for	IN
18637	18022	10	serious	serious	JJ
18637	18022	11	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	18022	12	must	must	MD
18637	18022	13	be	be	VB
18637	18022	14	justified	justify	VBN
18637	18022	15	by	by	IN
18637	18022	16	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18022	17	to	to	IN
18637	18022	18	the	the	DT
18637	18022	19	point	point	NN
18637	18022	20	.	.	.
18637	18023	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18023	2	4	4	CD
18637	18023	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18023	4	But	but	CC
18637	18023	5	the	the	DT
18637	18023	6	power	power	NN
18637	18023	7	of	of	IN
18637	18023	8	the	the	DT
18637	18023	9	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	18023	10	General	General	NNP
18637	18023	11	,	,	,
18637	18023	12	under	under	IN
18637	18023	13	§	§	NNP
18637	18023	14	23	23	CD
18637	18023	15	of	of	IN
18637	18023	16	the	the	DT
18637	18023	17	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	18023	18	Security	Security	NNP
18637	18023	19	Act	Act	NNP
18637	18023	20	of	of	IN
18637	18023	21	1950,[5	1950,[5	CD
18637	18023	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18023	23	to	to	TO
18637	18023	24	hold	hold	VB
18637	18023	25	in	in	IN
18637	18023	26	custody	custody	NN
18637	18023	27	without	without	IN
18637	18023	28	bail	bail	NN
18637	18023	29	,	,	,
18637	18023	30	at	at	IN
18637	18023	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18023	32	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	18023	33	,	,	,
18637	18023	34	pending	pende	VBG
18637	18023	35	determination	determination	NN
18637	18023	36	as	as	IN
18637	18023	37	to	to	IN
18637	18023	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18023	39	deportability	deportability	NN
18637	18023	40	,	,	,
18637	18023	41	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	18023	42	who	who	WP
18637	18023	43	are	be	VBP
18637	18023	44	members	member	NNS
18637	18023	45	of	of	IN
18637	18023	46	the	the	DT
18637	18023	47	Communist	Communist	NNP
18637	18023	48	Party	Party	NNP
18637	18023	49	of	of	IN
18637	18023	50	the	the	DT
18637	18023	51	United	United	NNP
18637	18023	52	States	States	NNP
18637	18023	53	,	,	,
18637	18023	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	18023	55	not	not	RB
18637	18023	56	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18023	57	.	.	.
18637	18024	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18024	2	6	6	CD
18637	18024	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18024	4	Excessive	Excessive	NNP
18637	18024	5	Fines	fine	NNS
18637	18024	6	The	the	DT
18637	18024	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	18024	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18024	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	18024	10	had	have	VBN
18637	18024	11	little	little	JJ
18637	18024	12	to	to	TO
18637	18024	13	say	say	VB
18637	18024	14	with	with	IN
18637	18024	15	reference	reference	NN
18637	18024	16	to	to	IN
18637	18024	17	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	18024	18	fines	fine	NNS
18637	18024	19	or	or	CC
18637	18024	20	bail	bail	NN
18637	18024	21	.	.	.
18637	18025	1	In	in	IN
18637	18025	2	an	an	DT
18637	18025	3	early	early	JJ
18637	18025	4	case	case	NN
18637	18025	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18025	6	held	hold	VBD
18637	18025	7	that	that	IN
18637	18025	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18025	9	had	have	VBD
18637	18025	10	no	no	DT
18637	18025	11	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	18025	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18025	13	to	to	TO
18637	18025	14	revise	revise	VB
18637	18025	15	the	the	DT
18637	18025	16	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	18025	17	of	of	IN
18637	18025	18	an	an	DT
18637	18025	19	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	18025	20	court	court	NN
18637	18025	21	,	,	,
18637	18025	22	even	even	RB
18637	18025	23	though	though	IN
18637	18025	24	the	the	DT
18637	18025	25	excessiveness	excessiveness	NN
18637	18025	26	of	of	IN
18637	18025	27	the	the	DT
18637	18025	28	fine	fine	NN
18637	18025	29	was	be	VBD
18637	18025	30	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	18025	31	on	on	IN
18637	18025	32	the	the	DT
18637	18025	33	face	face	NN
18637	18025	34	of	of	IN
18637	18025	35	the	the	DT
18637	18025	36	record	record	NN
18637	18025	37	.	.	.
18637	18026	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18026	2	7	7	CD
18637	18026	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18026	4	In	in	IN
18637	18026	5	a	a	DT
18637	18026	6	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	18026	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	18026	8	in	in	IN
18637	18026	9	United	United	NNP
18637	18026	10	States	States	NNP
18637	18026	11	ex	ex	NNP
18637	18026	12	rel	rel	NN
18637	18026	13	.	.	.
18637	18027	1	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	18027	2	Publishing	Publishing	NNP
18637	18027	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18027	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18027	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	18027	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18027	7	Burleson,[8	Burleson,[8	NNP
18637	18027	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18027	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18027	10	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	18027	11	intimated	intimate	VBD
18637	18027	12	that	that	IN
18637	18027	13	the	the	DT
18637	18027	14	additional	additional	JJ
18637	18027	15	mailing	mailing	NN
18637	18027	16	costs	cost	NNS
18637	18027	17	incurred	incur	VBN
18637	18027	18	by	by	IN
18637	18027	19	a	a	DT
18637	18027	20	newspaper	newspaper	NN
18637	18027	21	to	to	TO
18637	18027	22	which	which	WDT
18637	18027	23	the	the	DT
18637	18027	24	second	second	JJ
18637	18027	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	18027	26	class	class	NN
18637	18027	27	mailing	mailing	NN
18637	18027	28	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18027	29	had	have	VBD
18637	18027	30	been	be	VBN
18637	18027	31	denied	deny	VBN
18637	18027	32	constituted	constitute	VBN
18637	18027	33	,	,	,
18637	18027	34	in	in	IN
18637	18027	35	effect	effect	NN
18637	18027	36	,	,	,
18637	18027	37	a	a	DT
18637	18027	38	fine	fine	NN
18637	18027	39	for	for	IN
18637	18027	40	a	a	DT
18637	18027	41	past	past	JJ
18637	18027	42	offense	offense	NN
18637	18027	43	which	which	WDT
18637	18027	44	,	,	,
18637	18027	45	since	since	IN
18637	18027	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18027	47	was	be	VBD
18637	18027	48	made	make	VBN
18637	18027	49	to	to	TO
18637	18027	50	grow	grow	VB
18637	18027	51	indefinitely	indefinitely	RB
18637	18027	52	each	each	DT
18637	18027	53	day	day	NN
18637	18027	54	,	,	,
18637	18027	55	was	be	VBD
18637	18027	56	an	an	DT
18637	18027	57	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	18027	58	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	18027	59	interdicted	interdict	VBN
18637	18027	60	by	by	IN
18637	18027	61	the	the	DT
18637	18027	62	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18027	63	.	.	.
18637	18028	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18028	2	9	9	CD
18637	18028	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18028	4	Cruel	Cruel	NNP
18637	18028	5	and	and	CC
18637	18028	6	Unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	18028	7	Punishments	punishment	NNS
18637	18028	8	The	the	DT
18637	18028	9	ban	ban	NN
18637	18028	10	against	against	IN
18637	18028	11	"	"	``
18637	18028	12	cruel	cruel	JJ
18637	18028	13	and	and	CC
18637	18028	14	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	18028	15	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	18028	16	"	"	''
18637	18028	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	18028	18	received	receive	VBN
18637	18028	19	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	18028	20	greater	great	JJR
18637	18028	21	attention	attention	NN
18637	18028	22	.	.	.
18637	18029	1	In	in	IN
18637	18029	2	Wilkerson	Wilkerson	NNP
18637	18029	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18029	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	18029	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18029	6	Utah[10	Utah[10	NNP
18637	18029	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18029	8	the	the	DT
18637	18029	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18029	10	observed	observe	VBD
18637	18029	11	that	that	DT
18637	18029	12	:	:	:
18637	18029	13	"	"	``
18637	18029	14	Difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	18029	15	would	would	MD
18637	18029	16	attend	attend	VB
18637	18029	17	the	the	DT
18637	18029	18	effort	effort	NN
18637	18029	19	to	to	TO
18637	18029	20	define	define	VB
18637	18029	21	with	with	IN
18637	18029	22	exactness	exactness	NN
18637	18029	23	the	the	DT
18637	18029	24	extent	extent	NN
18637	18029	25	of	of	IN
18637	18029	26	the	the	DT
18637	18029	27	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18029	28	provision	provision	NN
18637	18029	29	which	which	WDT
18637	18029	30	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	18029	31	that	that	IN
18637	18029	32	cruel	cruel	JJ
18637	18029	33	and	and	CC
18637	18029	34	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	18029	35	punishments	punishment	NNS
18637	18029	36	shall	shall	MD
18637	18029	37	not	not	RB
18637	18029	38	be	be	VB
18637	18029	39	inflicted	inflict	VBN
18637	18029	40	,	,	,
18637	18029	41	but	but	CC
18637	18029	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18029	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	18029	44	safe	safe	JJ
18637	18029	45	to	to	TO
18637	18029	46	affirm	affirm	VB
18637	18029	47	that	that	IN
18637	18029	48	punishments	punishment	NNS
18637	18029	49	of	of	IN
18637	18029	50	torture	torture	NN
18637	18029	51	,	,	,
18637	18029	52	...	...	NFP
18637	18029	53	and	and	CC
18637	18029	54	all	all	DT
18637	18029	55	others	other	NNS
18637	18029	56	in	in	IN
18637	18029	57	the	the	DT
18637	18029	58	same	same	JJ
18637	18029	59	line	line	NN
18637	18029	60	of	of	IN
18637	18029	61	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	18029	62	cruelty	cruelty	NN
18637	18029	63	,	,	,
18637	18029	64	are	be	VBP
18637	18029	65	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	18029	66	by	by	IN
18637	18029	67	that	that	DT
18637	18029	68	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18029	69	to	to	IN
18637	18029	70	the	the	DT
18637	18029	71	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18029	72	.	.	.
18637	18030	1	"	"	``
18637	18030	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18030	3	11	11	CD
18637	18030	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18030	5	Shooting	shoot	VBG
18637	18030	6	as	as	IN
18637	18030	7	a	a	DT
18637	18030	8	mode	mode	NN
18637	18030	9	of	of	IN
18637	18030	10	executing	execute	VBG
18637	18030	11	the	the	DT
18637	18030	12	death	death	NN
18637	18030	13	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	18030	14	was	be	VBD
18637	18030	15	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18030	16	over	over	IN
18637	18030	17	the	the	DT
18637	18030	18	objection	objection	NN
18637	18030	19	that	that	IN
18637	18030	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18030	21	was	be	VBD
18637	18030	22	cruel	cruel	JJ
18637	18030	23	and	and	CC
18637	18030	24	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	18030	25	.	.	.
18637	18031	1	A	a	DT
18637	18031	2	partially	partially	RB
18637	18031	3	successful	successful	JJ
18637	18031	4	effort	effort	NN
18637	18031	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	18031	6	been	be	VBN
18637	18031	7	made	make	VBN
18637	18031	8	to	to	TO
18637	18031	9	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	18031	10	the	the	DT
18637	18031	11	concept	concept	NN
18637	18031	12	of	of	IN
18637	18031	13	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	18031	14	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	18031	15	to	to	TO
18637	18031	16	cover	cover	VB
18637	18031	17	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	18031	18	which	which	WDT
18637	18031	19	shock	shock	VBP
18637	18031	20	the	the	DT
18637	18031	21	sense	sense	NN
18637	18031	22	of	of	IN
18637	18031	23	justice	justice	NN
18637	18031	24	by	by	IN
18637	18031	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18031	26	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	18031	27	or	or	CC
18637	18031	28	relative	relative	JJ
18637	18031	29	severity	severity	NN
18637	18031	30	.	.	.
18637	18032	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18032	2	Field	Field	NNP
18637	18032	3	pointed	point	VBD
18637	18032	4	the	the	DT
18637	18032	5	way	way	NN
18637	18032	6	for	for	IN
18637	18032	7	this	this	DT
18637	18032	8	development	development	NN
18637	18032	9	in	in	IN
18637	18032	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18032	11	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	18032	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	18032	13	in	in	IN
18637	18032	14	O'Neil	O'Neil	NNP
18637	18032	15	_	_	NNP
18637	18032	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	18032	17	_	_	NNP
18637	18032	18	Vermont,[12	Vermont,[12	NNP
18637	18032	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18032	20	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	18032	21	the	the	DT
18637	18032	22	majority	majority	NN
18637	18032	23	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	18032	24	to	to	TO
18637	18032	25	apply	apply	VB
18637	18032	26	the	the	DT
18637	18032	27	Eighth	Eighth	NNP
18637	18032	28	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18032	29	to	to	IN
18637	18032	30	a	a	DT
18637	18032	31	State	state	NN
18637	18032	32	.	.	.
18637	18033	1	With	with	IN
18637	18033	2	the	the	DT
18637	18033	3	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	18033	4	of	of	IN
18637	18033	5	two	two	CD
18637	18033	6	other	other	JJ
18637	18033	7	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	18033	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18033	9	wrote	write	VBD
18637	18033	10	that	that	IN
18637	18033	11	the	the	DT
18637	18033	12	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18033	13	was	be	VBD
18637	18033	14	directed	direct	VBN
18637	18033	15	"	"	``
18637	18033	16	against	against	IN
18637	18033	17	all	all	DT
18637	18033	18	punishments	punishment	NNS
18637	18033	19	which	which	WDT
18637	18033	20	by	by	IN
18637	18033	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18033	22	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	18033	23	length	length	NN
18637	18033	24	or	or	CC
18637	18033	25	severity	severity	NN
18637	18033	26	are	be	VBP
18637	18033	27	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	18033	28	disproportioned	disproportione	VBN
18637	18033	29	to	to	IN
18637	18033	30	the	the	DT
18637	18033	31	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	18033	32	charged	charge	VBN
18637	18033	33	.	.	.
18637	18034	1	"	"	``
18637	18034	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18034	3	13	13	CD
18637	18034	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18034	5	Eighteen	eighteen	CD
18637	18034	6	years	year	NNS
18637	18034	7	later	later	RB
18637	18034	8	a	a	DT
18637	18034	9	divided	divide	VBN
18637	18034	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18034	11	condemned	condemn	VBD
18637	18034	12	a	a	DT
18637	18034	13	Philippine	philippine	JJ
18637	18034	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	18034	15	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	18034	16	fine	fine	JJ
18637	18034	17	and	and	CC
18637	18034	18	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	18034	19	of	of	IN
18637	18034	20	from	from	IN
18637	18034	21	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	18034	22	to	to	TO
18637	18034	23	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	18034	24	years	year	NNS
18637	18034	25	for	for	IN
18637	18034	26	entry	entry	NN
18637	18034	27	of	of	IN
18637	18034	28	a	a	DT
18637	18034	29	known	know	VBN
18637	18034	30	false	false	JJ
18637	18034	31	statement	statement	NN
18637	18034	32	in	in	IN
18637	18034	33	a	a	DT
18637	18034	34	public	public	JJ
18637	18034	35	record	record	NN
18637	18034	36	,	,	,
18637	18034	37	on	on	IN
18637	18034	38	the	the	DT
18637	18034	39	ground	ground	NN
18637	18034	40	that	that	IN
18637	18034	41	the	the	DT
18637	18034	42	gross	gross	JJ
18637	18034	43	disparity	disparity	NN
18637	18034	44	between	between	IN
18637	18034	45	this	this	DT
18637	18034	46	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	18034	47	and	and	CC
18637	18034	48	that	that	DT
18637	18034	49	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18034	50	for	for	IN
18637	18034	51	other	other	JJ
18637	18034	52	more	more	RBR
18637	18034	53	serious	serious	JJ
18637	18034	54	fines	fine	NNS
18637	18034	55	made	make	VBD
18637	18034	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18034	57	cruel	cruel	JJ
18637	18034	58	and	and	CC
18637	18034	59	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	18034	60	,	,	,
18637	18034	61	and	and	CC
18637	18034	62	as	as	IN
18637	18034	63	such	such	JJ
18637	18034	64	,	,	,
18637	18034	65	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	18034	66	to	to	IN
18637	18034	67	the	the	DT
18637	18034	68	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	18034	69	of	of	IN
18637	18034	70	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	18034	71	.	.	.
18637	18035	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18035	2	14	14	CD
18637	18035	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18035	4	No	no	DT
18637	18035	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18035	6	infirmity	infirmity	NN
18637	18035	7	was	be	VBD
18637	18035	8	discovered	discover	VBN
18637	18035	9	in	in	IN
18637	18035	10	a	a	DT
18637	18035	11	measure	measure	NN
18637	18035	12	punishing	punish	VBG
18637	18035	13	as	as	IN
18637	18035	14	a	a	DT
18637	18035	15	separate	separate	JJ
18637	18035	16	offense	offense	NN
18637	18035	17	each	each	DT
18637	18035	18	act	act	NN
18637	18035	19	of	of	IN
18637	18035	20	placing	place	VBG
18637	18035	21	a	a	DT
18637	18035	22	letter	letter	NN
18637	18035	23	in	in	IN
18637	18035	24	the	the	DT
18637	18035	25	mails	mail	NNS
18637	18035	26	in	in	IN
18637	18035	27	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	18035	28	of	of	IN
18637	18035	29	a	a	DT
18637	18035	30	single	single	JJ
18637	18035	31	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	18035	32	to	to	TO
18637	18035	33	defraud	defraud	VB
18637	18035	34	.	.	.
18637	18036	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18036	2	15	15	CD
18637	18036	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18036	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	18036	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18036	6	1	1	CD
18637	18036	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18036	8	1	1	CD
18637	18036	9	Annals	Annals	NNPS
18637	18036	10	of	of	IN
18637	18036	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18036	12	754	754	CD
18637	18036	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18036	14	1791	1791	CD
18637	18036	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18036	16	.	.	.
18637	18037	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18037	2	2	2	LS
18637	18037	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18037	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18037	5	.	.	.
18637	18038	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18038	2	3	3	CD
18637	18038	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18038	4	18	18	CD
18637	18038	5	U.S.C.	u.s.c.	NN
18637	18039	1	§§	§§	NNP
18637	18039	2	371	371	CD
18637	18039	3	,	,	,
18637	18039	4	2385	2385	CD
18637	18039	5	.	.	.
18637	18040	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18040	2	4	4	CD
18637	18040	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18040	4	Stack	Stack	NNP
18637	18040	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18040	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18040	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18040	8	Boyle	Boyle	NNP
18637	18040	9	,	,	,
18637	18040	10	342	342	CD
18637	18040	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18040	12	1	1	CD
18637	18040	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18040	14	1951	1951	CD
18637	18040	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18040	16	.	.	.
18637	18041	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18041	2	5	5	CD
18637	18041	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18041	4	8	8	CD
18637	18041	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	18042	1	§	§	NNP
18637	18042	2	156	156	CD
18637	18042	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18042	4	a	a	NN
18637	18042	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18042	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18042	7	1	1	CD
18637	18042	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18042	9	;	;	:
18637	18042	10	64	64	CD
18637	18042	11	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	18042	12	.	.	.
18637	18043	1	1011	1011	CD
18637	18043	2	.	.	.
18637	18044	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18044	2	6	6	CD
18637	18044	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18044	4	Carlson	Carlson	NNP
18637	18044	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18044	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18044	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18044	8	Landon	Landon	NNP
18637	18044	9	,	,	,
18637	18044	10	342	342	CD
18637	18044	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18044	12	524	524	CD
18637	18044	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18044	14	1952	1952	CD
18637	18044	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18044	16	.	.	.
18637	18045	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18045	2	7	7	LS
18637	18045	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18045	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	18045	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	18045	6	Watkins	Watkins	NNP
18637	18045	7	,	,	,
18637	18045	8	7	7	CD
18637	18045	9	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	18045	10	.	.	.
18637	18046	1	568	568	CD
18637	18046	2	,	,	,
18637	18046	3	574	574	CD
18637	18046	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18046	5	1833	1833	CD
18637	18046	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18046	7	.	.	.
18637	18047	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18047	2	8	8	CD
18637	18047	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18047	4	255	255	CD
18637	18047	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18047	6	407	407	CD
18637	18047	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18047	8	1921	1921	CD
18637	18047	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18047	10	.	.	.
18637	18048	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18048	2	9	9	CD
18637	18048	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18048	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18048	5	.	.	.
18637	18049	1	435	435	CD
18637	18049	2	.	.	.
18637	18050	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18050	2	10	10	CD
18637	18050	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18050	4	99	99	CD
18637	18050	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18050	6	130	130	CD
18637	18050	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18050	8	1879	1879	CD
18637	18050	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18050	10	.	.	.
18637	18051	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18051	2	11	11	CD
18637	18051	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18051	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18051	5	.	.	.
18637	18052	1	135	135	CD
18637	18052	2	.	.	.
18637	18053	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18053	2	12	12	CD
18637	18053	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18053	4	144	144	CD
18637	18053	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18053	6	323	323	CD
18637	18053	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18053	8	1892	1892	CD
18637	18053	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18053	10	.	.	.
18637	18054	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18054	2	13	13	CD
18637	18054	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18054	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18054	5	.	.	.
18637	18055	1	339	339	CD
18637	18055	2	,	,	,
18637	18055	3	340	340	CD
18637	18055	4	.	.	.
18637	18056	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18056	2	14	14	CD
18637	18056	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18056	4	Weems	Weems	NNPS
18637	18056	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18056	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18056	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18056	8	United	United	NNP
18637	18056	9	States	States	NNP
18637	18056	10	,	,	,
18637	18056	11	217	217	CD
18637	18056	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18056	13	349	349	CD
18637	18056	14	,	,	,
18637	18056	15	371	371	CD
18637	18056	16	,	,	,
18637	18056	17	382	382	CD
18637	18056	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18056	19	1910	1910	CD
18637	18056	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18056	21	.	.	.
18637	18057	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18057	2	15	15	CD
18637	18057	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18057	4	Badders	Badders	NNP
18637	18057	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18057	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18057	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18057	8	United	United	NNP
18637	18057	9	States	States	NNP
18637	18057	10	,	,	,
18637	18057	11	240	240	CD
18637	18057	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18057	13	391	391	CD
18637	18057	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18057	15	1916	1916	CD
18637	18057	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18057	17	.	.	.
18637	18058	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18058	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	18058	3	.	.	.
18637	18058	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18058	5	Donaldson	Donaldson	NNP
18637	18058	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18058	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18058	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18058	9	Read	Read	NNP
18637	18058	10	Magazine	Magazine	NNP
18637	18058	11	,	,	,
18637	18058	12	333	333	CD
18637	18058	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18058	14	178	178	CD
18637	18058	15	,	,	,
18637	18058	16	191	191	CD
18637	18058	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18058	18	1948	1948	CD
18637	18058	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18058	20	.	.	.
18637	18059	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	18059	2	9	9	CD
18637	18059	3	RIGHTS	right	NNS
18637	18059	4	RETAINED	retained	VBP
18637	18059	5	BY	by	IN
18637	18059	6	THE	the	DT
18637	18059	7	PEOPLE	PEOPLE	NNS
18637	18059	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18059	9	9	9	CD
18637	18059	10	The	the	DT
18637	18059	11	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	18059	12	in	in	IN
18637	18059	13	the	the	DT
18637	18059	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18059	15	,	,	,
18637	18059	16	of	of	IN
18637	18059	17	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18059	18	rights	right	NNS
18637	18059	19	,	,	,
18637	18059	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	18059	21	not	not	RB
18637	18059	22	be	be	VB
18637	18059	23	construed	construe	VBN
18637	18059	24	to	to	TO
18637	18059	25	deny	deny	VB
18637	18059	26	or	or	CC
18637	18059	27	disparage	disparage	VB
18637	18059	28	others	other	NNS
18637	18059	29	retained	retain	VBN
18637	18059	30	by	by	IN
18637	18059	31	the	the	DT
18637	18059	32	people	people	NNS
18637	18059	33	.	.	.
18637	18060	1	The	the	DT
18637	18060	2	only	only	JJ
18637	18060	3	right	right	NN
18637	18060	4	which	which	WDT
18637	18060	5	the	the	DT
18637	18060	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	18060	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18060	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	18060	9	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	18060	10	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	18060	11	as	as	IN
18637	18060	12	protected	protect	VBN
18637	18060	13	by	by	IN
18637	18060	14	this	this	DT
18637	18060	15	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18060	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	18060	17	the	the	DT
18637	18060	18	right	right	NN
18637	18060	19	to	to	TO
18637	18060	20	engage	engage	VB
18637	18060	21	in	in	IN
18637	18060	22	political	political	JJ
18637	18060	23	activity	activity	NN
18637	18060	24	.	.	.
18637	18061	1	That	that	DT
18637	18061	2	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	18061	3	was	be	VBD
18637	18061	4	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	18061	5	by	by	IN
18637	18061	6	way	way	NN
18637	18061	7	of	of	IN
18637	18061	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18061	9	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	18061	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18061	11	in	in	IN
18637	18061	12	United	United	NNP
18637	18061	13	Public	Public	NNP
18637	18061	14	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	18061	15	_	_	NNP
18637	18061	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	18061	17	_	_	NNP
18637	18061	18	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	18061	19	,	,	,
18637	18061	20	where	where	WRB
18637	18061	21	the	the	DT
18637	18061	22	powers	power	NNS
18637	18061	23	of	of	IN
18637	18061	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18061	25	to	to	TO
18637	18061	26	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	18061	27	the	the	DT
18637	18061	28	political	political	JJ
18637	18061	29	activities	activity	NNS
18637	18061	30	of	of	IN
18637	18061	31	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18061	32	employees	employee	NNS
18637	18061	33	was	be	VBD
18637	18061	34	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18061	35	.	.	.
18637	18062	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18062	2	1	1	LS
18637	18062	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18062	4	An	an	DT
18637	18062	5	argument	argument	NN
18637	18062	6	that	that	IN
18637	18062	7	the	the	DT
18637	18062	8	competition	competition	NN
18637	18062	9	of	of	IN
18637	18062	10	the	the	DT
18637	18062	11	TVA	TVA	NNP
18637	18062	12	in	in	IN
18637	18062	13	selling	sell	VBG
18637	18062	14	electricity	electricity	NN
18637	18062	15	at	at	IN
18637	18062	16	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18062	17	lower	low	JJR
18637	18062	18	than	than	IN
18637	18062	19	those	those	DT
18637	18062	20	previously	previously	RB
18637	18062	21	charged	charge	VBN
18637	18062	22	by	by	IN
18637	18062	23	private	private	JJ
18637	18062	24	companies	company	NNS
18637	18062	25	serving	serve	VBG
18637	18062	26	the	the	DT
18637	18062	27	area	area	NN
18637	18062	28	amounted	amount	VBD
18637	18062	29	to	to	IN
18637	18062	30	an	an	DT
18637	18062	31	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	18062	32	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18062	33	of	of	IN
18637	18062	34	the	the	DT
18637	18062	35	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18062	36	of	of	IN
18637	18062	37	those	those	DT
18637	18062	38	companies	company	NNS
18637	18062	39	and	and	CC
18637	18062	40	a	a	DT
18637	18062	41	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	18062	42	of	of	IN
18637	18062	43	the	the	DT
18637	18062	44	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18062	45	said	say	VBD
18637	18062	46	to	to	TO
18637	18062	47	be	be	VB
18637	18062	48	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	18062	49	by	by	IN
18637	18062	50	the	the	DT
18637	18062	51	Ninth	Ninth	NNP
18637	18062	52	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18062	53	to	to	IN
18637	18062	54	the	the	DT
18637	18062	55	people	people	NNS
18637	18062	56	of	of	IN
18637	18062	57	the	the	DT
18637	18062	58	States	States	NNPS
18637	18062	59	to	to	TO
18637	18062	60	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	18062	61	property	property	NN
18637	18062	62	and	and	CC
18637	18062	63	employ	employ	VB
18637	18062	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18062	65	in	in	IN
18637	18062	66	a	a	DT
18637	18062	67	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	18062	68	business	business	NN
18637	18062	69	,	,	,
18637	18062	70	was	be	VBD
18637	18062	71	summarily	summarily	RB
18637	18062	72	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	18062	73	.	.	.
18637	18063	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18063	2	2	2	CD
18637	18063	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18063	4	Previously	previously	RB
18637	18063	5	the	the	DT
18637	18063	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18063	7	had	have	VBD
18637	18063	8	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	18063	9	the	the	DT
18637	18063	10	right	right	NN
18637	18063	11	of	of	IN
18637	18063	12	the	the	DT
18637	18063	13	TVA	TVA	NNP
18637	18063	14	to	to	TO
18637	18063	15	sell	sell	VB
18637	18063	16	electricity	electricity	NN
18637	18063	17	,	,	,
18637	18063	18	saying	say	VBG
18637	18063	19	that	that	IN
18637	18063	20	the	the	DT
18637	18063	21	Ninth	Ninth	NNP
18637	18063	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18063	23	did	do	VBD
18637	18063	24	not	not	RB
18637	18063	25	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	18063	26	the	the	DT
18637	18063	27	right	right	NN
18637	18063	28	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	18063	29	granted	grant	VBN
18637	18063	30	by	by	IN
18637	18063	31	section	section	NN
18637	18063	32	3	3	CD
18637	18063	33	of	of	IN
18637	18063	34	article	article	NN
18637	18063	35	IV	IV	NNP
18637	18063	36	to	to	TO
18637	18063	37	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	18063	38	of	of	IN
18637	18063	39	property	property	NN
18637	18063	40	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	18063	41	to	to	IN
18637	18063	42	the	the	DT
18637	18063	43	United	United	NNP
18637	18063	44	States	States	NNP
18637	18063	45	.	.	.
18637	18064	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18064	2	3	3	LS
18637	18064	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18064	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	18064	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18064	6	1	1	CD
18637	18064	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18064	8	330	330	CD
18637	18064	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18064	10	75	75	CD
18637	18064	11	,	,	,
18637	18064	12	94	94	CD
18637	18064	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18064	14	1947	1947	CD
18637	18064	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18064	16	.	.	.
18637	18065	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18065	2	2	2	LS
18637	18065	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18065	4	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	18065	5	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	18065	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	18065	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18065	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18065	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	18065	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18065	11	T.V.A.	T.V.A.	NNP
18637	18065	12	,	,	,
18637	18065	13	306	306	CD
18637	18065	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18065	15	118	118	CD
18637	18065	16	,	,	,
18637	18065	17	143	143	CD
18637	18065	18	,	,	,
18637	18065	19	144	144	CD
18637	18065	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18065	21	1939	1939	CD
18637	18065	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18065	23	.	.	.
18637	18066	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18066	2	3	3	LS
18637	18066	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18066	4	Ashwander	Ashwander	NNP
18637	18066	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18066	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18066	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18066	8	T.V.A.	T.V.A.	NNP
18637	18066	9	,	,	,
18637	18066	10	297	297	CD
18637	18066	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18066	12	288	288	CD
18637	18066	13	,	,	,
18637	18066	14	330	330	CD
18637	18066	15	,	,	,
18637	18066	16	331	331	CD
18637	18066	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18066	18	1936	1936	CD
18637	18066	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18066	20	.	.	.
18637	18067	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18067	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18067	3	also	also	RB
18637	18067	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18067	5	the	the	DT
18637	18067	6	language	language	NN
18637	18067	7	of	of	IN
18637	18067	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18067	9	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	18067	10	in	in	IN
18637	18067	11	Calder	Calder	NNP
18637	18067	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18067	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	18067	14	_	_	NNP
18637	18067	15	Bull	Bull	NNP
18637	18067	16	,	,	,
18637	18067	17	3	3	CD
18637	18067	18	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	18067	19	.	.	.
18637	18068	1	386	386	CD
18637	18068	2	,	,	,
18637	18068	3	388	388	CD
18637	18068	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18068	5	1798	1798	CD
18637	18068	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18068	7	;	;	:
18637	18068	8	and	and	CC
18637	18068	9	of	of	IN
18637	18068	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18068	11	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	18068	12	for	for	IN
18637	18068	13	the	the	DT
18637	18068	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18068	15	in	in	IN
18637	18068	16	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	18068	17	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	18068	18	.	.	.
18637	18069	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18069	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	18069	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18069	4	Topeka	Topeka	NNP
18637	18069	5	,	,	,
18637	18069	6	20	20	CD
18637	18069	7	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	18069	8	.	.	.
18637	18070	1	655	655	CD
18637	18070	2	,	,	,
18637	18070	3	662	662	CD
18637	18070	4	-	-	SYM
18637	18070	5	663	663	CD
18637	18070	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18070	7	1874	1874	CD
18637	18070	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18070	9	.	.	.
18637	18071	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	18071	2	10	10	CD
18637	18071	3	RESERVED	reserved	JJ
18637	18071	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	18071	5	POWERS	power	NNS
18637	18071	6	Page	Page	NNP
18637	18071	7	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	18071	8	and	and	CC
18637	18071	9	purpose	purpose	VB
18637	18071	10	915	915	CD
18637	18071	11	The	the	DT
18637	18071	12	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	18071	13	power	power	NN
18637	18071	14	916	916	CD
18637	18071	15	The	the	DT
18637	18071	16	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18071	17	power	power	NN
18637	18071	18	917	917	CD
18637	18071	19	Police	police	NN
18637	18071	20	power	power	NN
18637	18071	21	918	918	CD
18637	18071	22	State	state	NN
18637	18071	23	activities	activity	NNS
18637	18071	24	and	and	CC
18637	18071	25	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	18071	26	919	919	CD
18637	18071	27	RESERVED	reserved	JJ
18637	18071	28	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	18071	29	POWERS	power	NNS
18637	18071	30	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18071	31	10	10	CD
18637	18071	32	The	the	DT
18637	18071	33	powers	power	NNS
18637	18071	34	not	not	RB
18637	18071	35	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	18071	36	to	to	IN
18637	18071	37	the	the	DT
18637	18071	38	United	United	NNP
18637	18071	39	States	States	NNP
18637	18071	40	by	by	IN
18637	18071	41	the	the	DT
18637	18071	42	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18071	43	,	,	,
18637	18071	44	nor	nor	CC
18637	18071	45	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	18071	46	by	by	IN
18637	18071	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18071	48	to	to	IN
18637	18071	49	the	the	DT
18637	18071	50	States	States	NNP
18637	18071	51	,	,	,
18637	18071	52	are	be	VBP
18637	18071	53	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	18071	54	to	to	IN
18637	18071	55	the	the	DT
18637	18071	56	States	States	NNP
18637	18071	57	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	18071	58	,	,	,
18637	18071	59	or	or	CC
18637	18071	60	to	to	IN
18637	18071	61	the	the	DT
18637	18071	62	people	people	NNS
18637	18071	63	.	.	.
18637	18072	1	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	18072	2	and	and	CC
18637	18072	3	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	18072	4	"	"	``
18637	18072	5	The	the	DT
18637	18072	6	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18072	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18072	8	was	be	VBD
18637	18072	9	intended	intend	VBN
18637	18072	10	to	to	TO
18637	18072	11	confirm	confirm	VB
18637	18072	12	the	the	DT
18637	18072	13	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	18072	14	of	of	IN
18637	18072	15	the	the	DT
18637	18072	16	people	people	NNS
18637	18072	17	at	at	IN
18637	18072	18	the	the	DT
18637	18072	19	time	time	NN
18637	18072	20	the	the	DT
18637	18072	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18072	22	was	be	VBD
18637	18072	23	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	18072	24	,	,	,
18637	18072	25	that	that	IN
18637	18072	26	powers	power	NNS
18637	18072	27	not	not	RB
18637	18072	28	granted	grant	VBN
18637	18072	29	to	to	IN
18637	18072	30	the	the	DT
18637	18072	31	United	United	NNP
18637	18072	32	States	States	NNP
18637	18072	33	were	be	VBD
18637	18072	34	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	18072	35	to	to	IN
18637	18072	36	the	the	DT
18637	18072	37	States	States	NNP
18637	18072	38	or	or	CC
18637	18072	39	to	to	IN
18637	18072	40	the	the	DT
18637	18072	41	people	people	NNS
18637	18072	42	.	.	.
18637	18073	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18073	2	added	add	VBD
18637	18073	3	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	18073	4	to	to	IN
18637	18073	5	the	the	DT
18637	18073	6	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	18073	7	as	as	RB
18637	18073	8	originally	originally	RB
18637	18073	9	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	18073	10	*	*	NFP
18637	18073	11	*	*	NFP
18637	18073	12	*	*	NFP
18637	18073	13	.	.	.
18637	18074	1	"	"	``
18637	18074	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18074	3	1	1	CD
18637	18074	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18074	5	That	that	IN
18637	18074	6	this	this	DT
18637	18074	7	provision	provision	NN
18637	18074	8	was	be	VBD
18637	18074	9	not	not	RB
18637	18074	10	conceived	conceive	VBN
18637	18074	11	to	to	TO
18637	18074	12	be	be	VB
18637	18074	13	a	a	DT
18637	18074	14	yardstick	yardstick	NN
18637	18074	15	for	for	IN
18637	18074	16	measuring	measure	VBG
18637	18074	17	the	the	DT
18637	18074	18	powers	power	NNS
18637	18074	19	granted	grant	VBN
18637	18074	20	to	to	IN
18637	18074	21	the	the	DT
18637	18074	22	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18074	23	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18074	24	or	or	CC
18637	18074	25	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	18074	26	to	to	IN
18637	18074	27	the	the	DT
18637	18074	28	States	States	NNP
18637	18074	29	was	be	VBD
18637	18074	30	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	18074	31	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	18074	32	by	by	IN
18637	18074	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18074	34	sponsor	sponsor	NN
18637	18074	35	,	,	,
18637	18074	36	James	James	NNP
18637	18074	37	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	18074	38	,	,	,
18637	18074	39	in	in	IN
18637	18074	40	the	the	DT
18637	18074	41	course	course	NN
18637	18074	42	of	of	IN
18637	18074	43	the	the	DT
18637	18074	44	debate	debate	NN
18637	18074	45	which	which	WDT
18637	18074	46	took	take	VBD
18637	18074	47	place	place	NN
18637	18074	48	while	while	IN
18637	18074	49	the	the	DT
18637	18074	50	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18074	51	was	be	VBD
18637	18074	52	pending	pende	VBG
18637	18074	53	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	18074	54	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	18074	55	's	's	POS
18637	18074	56	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	18074	57	to	to	TO
18637	18074	58	establish	establish	VB
18637	18074	59	a	a	DT
18637	18074	60	national	national	JJ
18637	18074	61	bank	bank	NN
18637	18074	62	.	.	.
18637	18075	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18075	2	declared	declare	VBD
18637	18075	3	that	that	DT
18637	18075	4	:	:	:
18637	18075	5	"	"	``
18637	18075	6	Interference	interference	NN
18637	18075	7	with	with	IN
18637	18075	8	the	the	DT
18637	18075	9	power	power	NN
18637	18075	10	of	of	IN
18637	18075	11	the	the	DT
18637	18075	12	States	States	NNPS
18637	18075	13	was	be	VBD
18637	18075	14	no	no	DT
18637	18075	15	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18075	16	criterion	criterion	NN
18637	18075	17	of	of	IN
18637	18075	18	the	the	DT
18637	18075	19	power	power	NN
18637	18075	20	of	of	IN
18637	18075	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18075	22	.	.	.
18637	18076	1	If	if	IN
18637	18076	2	the	the	DT
18637	18076	3	power	power	NN
18637	18076	4	was	be	VBD
18637	18076	5	not	not	RB
18637	18076	6	given	give	VBN
18637	18076	7	,	,	,
18637	18076	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18076	9	could	could	MD
18637	18076	10	not	not	RB
18637	18076	11	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	18076	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18076	13	;	;	:
18637	18076	14	if	if	IN
18637	18076	15	given	give	VBN
18637	18076	16	,	,	,
18637	18076	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18076	18	might	may	MD
18637	18076	19	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	18076	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18076	21	,	,	,
18637	18076	22	although	although	IN
18637	18076	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18076	24	should	should	MD
18637	18076	25	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	18076	26	with	with	IN
18637	18076	27	the	the	DT
18637	18076	28	laws	law	NNS
18637	18076	29	,	,	,
18637	18076	30	or	or	CC
18637	18076	31	even	even	RB
18637	18076	32	the	the	DT
18637	18076	33	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
18637	18076	34	of	of	IN
18637	18076	35	the	the	DT
18637	18076	36	States	States	NNP
18637	18076	37	.	.	.
18637	18077	1	"	"	``
18637	18077	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18077	3	2	2	CD
18637	18077	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18077	5	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	18077	6	,	,	,
18637	18077	7	for	for	IN
18637	18077	8	approximately	approximately	RB
18637	18077	9	a	a	DT
18637	18077	10	century	century	NN
18637	18077	11	,	,	,
18637	18077	12	from	from	IN
18637	18077	13	the	the	DT
18637	18077	14	death	death	NN
18637	18077	15	of	of	IN
18637	18077	16	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	18077	17	until	until	IN
18637	18077	18	1937	1937	CD
18637	18077	19	,	,	,
18637	18077	20	the	the	DT
18637	18077	21	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18077	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18077	23	was	be	VBD
18637	18077	24	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	18077	25	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	18077	26	to	to	TO
18637	18077	27	curtail	curtail	VB
18637	18077	28	powers	power	NNS
18637	18077	29	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	18077	30	granted	grant	VBN
18637	18077	31	to	to	IN
18637	18077	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18077	33	,	,	,
18637	18077	34	notably	notably	RB
18637	18077	35	the	the	DT
18637	18077	36	powers	power	NNS
18637	18077	37	to	to	TO
18637	18077	38	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	18077	39	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	18077	40	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18077	41	,	,	,
18637	18077	42	to	to	TO
18637	18077	43	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	18077	44	the	the	DT
18637	18077	45	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18077	46	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18077	47	and	and	CC
18637	18077	48	to	to	TO
18637	18077	49	lay	lay	VB
18637	18077	50	and	and	CC
18637	18077	51	collect	collect	VB
18637	18077	52	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18077	53	.	.	.
18637	18078	1	The	the	DT
18637	18078	2	first	first	JJ
18637	18078	3	,	,	,
18637	18078	4	and	and	CC
18637	18078	5	logically	logically	RB
18637	18078	6	the	the	DT
18637	18078	7	strongest	strong	JJS
18637	18078	8	,	,	,
18637	18078	9	effort	effort	NN
18637	18078	10	to	to	TO
18637	18078	11	set	set	VB
18637	18078	12	up	up	RP
18637	18078	13	the	the	DT
18637	18078	14	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18078	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18078	16	as	as	IN
18637	18078	17	a	a	DT
18637	18078	18	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	18078	19	on	on	IN
18637	18078	20	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18078	21	power	power	NN
18637	18078	22	was	be	VBD
18637	18078	23	directed	direct	VBN
18637	18078	24	to	to	IN
18637	18078	25	the	the	DT
18637	18078	26	expansion	expansion	NN
18637	18078	27	of	of	IN
18637	18078	28	that	that	DT
18637	18078	29	power	power	NN
18637	18078	30	by	by	IN
18637	18078	31	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	18078	32	of	of	IN
18637	18078	33	the	the	DT
18637	18078	34	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18078	35	and	and	CC
18637	18078	36	proper	proper	JJ
18637	18078	37	clause	clause	NN
18637	18078	38	.	.	.
18637	18079	1	In	in	IN
18637	18079	2	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	18079	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18079	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	18079	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18079	6	Maryland,[3	Maryland,[3	NNP
18637	18079	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18079	8	the	the	DT
18637	18079	9	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	18079	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	18079	11	General	General	NNP
18637	18079	12	of	of	IN
18637	18079	13	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	18079	14	cited	cite	VBD
18637	18079	15	the	the	DT
18637	18079	16	charges	charge	NNS
18637	18079	17	made	make	VBN
18637	18079	18	by	by	IN
18637	18079	19	the	the	DT
18637	18079	20	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	18079	21	of	of	IN
18637	18079	22	the	the	DT
18637	18079	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18079	24	that	that	IN
18637	18079	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18079	26	contained	contain	VBD
18637	18079	27	"	"	``
18637	18079	28	*	*	NFP
18637	18079	29	*	*	NFP
18637	18079	30	*	*	NFP
18637	18079	31	a	a	DT
18637	18079	32	vast	vast	JJ
18637	18079	33	variety	variety	NN
18637	18079	34	of	of	IN
18637	18079	35	powers	power	NNS
18637	18079	36	,	,	,
18637	18079	37	lurking	lurk	VBG
18637	18079	38	under	under	IN
18637	18079	39	the	the	DT
18637	18079	40	generality	generality	NN
18637	18079	41	of	of	IN
18637	18079	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18079	43	phraseology	phraseology	NN
18637	18079	44	,	,	,
18637	18079	45	which	which	WDT
18637	18079	46	would	would	MD
18637	18079	47	prove	prove	VB
18637	18079	48	highly	highly	RB
18637	18079	49	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	18079	50	to	to	IN
18637	18079	51	the	the	DT
18637	18079	52	liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	18079	53	of	of	IN
18637	18079	54	the	the	DT
18637	18079	55	people	people	NNS
18637	18079	56	,	,	,
18637	18079	57	and	and	CC
18637	18079	58	the	the	DT
18637	18079	59	rights	right	NNS
18637	18079	60	of	of	IN
18637	18079	61	the	the	DT
18637	18079	62	states	state	NNS
18637	18079	63	,	,	,
18637	18079	64	*	*	NFP
18637	18079	65	*	*	NFP
18637	18079	66	*	*	NFP
18637	18079	67	"	"	''
18637	18079	68	and	and	CC
18637	18079	69	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18079	70	cited	cite	VBD
18637	18079	71	the	the	DT
18637	18079	72	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	18079	73	of	of	IN
18637	18079	74	the	the	DT
18637	18079	75	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18079	76	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18079	77	to	to	TO
18637	18079	78	allay	allay	VB
18637	18079	79	these	these	DT
18637	18079	80	apprehensions	apprehension	NNS
18637	18079	81	,	,	,
18637	18079	82	in	in	IN
18637	18079	83	support	support	NN
18637	18079	84	of	of	IN
18637	18079	85	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18079	86	contention	contention	NN
18637	18079	87	that	that	IN
18637	18079	88	the	the	DT
18637	18079	89	power	power	NN
18637	18079	90	to	to	TO
18637	18079	91	create	create	VB
18637	18079	92	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18079	93	was	be	VBD
18637	18079	94	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	18079	95	by	by	IN
18637	18079	96	that	that	DT
18637	18079	97	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18079	98	to	to	IN
18637	18079	99	the	the	DT
18637	18079	100	States	States	NNP
18637	18079	101	.	.	.
18637	18080	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18080	2	4	4	CD
18637	18080	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18080	4	Stressing	stress	VBG
18637	18080	5	the	the	DT
18637	18080	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	18080	7	that	that	IN
18637	18080	8	this	this	DT
18637	18080	9	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18080	10	,	,	,
18637	18080	11	unlike	unlike	IN
18637	18080	12	the	the	DT
18637	18080	13	cognate	cognate	NN
18637	18080	14	section	section	NN
18637	18080	15	of	of	IN
18637	18080	16	the	the	DT
18637	18080	17	Articles	Articles	NNPS
18637	18080	18	of	of	IN
18637	18080	19	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
18637	18080	20	,	,	,
18637	18080	21	omitted	omit	VBD
18637	18080	22	the	the	DT
18637	18080	23	word	word	NN
18637	18080	24	"	"	``
18637	18080	25	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	18080	26	"	"	''
18637	18080	27	as	as	IN
18637	18080	28	a	a	DT
18637	18080	29	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	18080	30	of	of	IN
18637	18080	31	the	the	DT
18637	18080	32	powers	power	NNS
18637	18080	33	granted	grant	VBN
18637	18080	34	to	to	IN
18637	18080	35	the	the	DT
18637	18080	36	National	National	NNP
18637	18080	37	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18080	38	,	,	,
18637	18080	39	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	18080	40	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18080	41	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	18080	42	declared	declare	VBD
18637	18080	43	that	that	IN
18637	18080	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18080	45	effect	effect	NN
18637	18080	46	was	be	VBD
18637	18080	47	to	to	TO
18637	18080	48	leave	leave	VB
18637	18080	49	the	the	DT
18637	18080	50	question	question	NN
18637	18080	51	"	"	''
18637	18080	52	whether	whether	IN
18637	18080	53	the	the	DT
18637	18080	54	particular	particular	JJ
18637	18080	55	power	power	NN
18637	18080	56	which	which	WDT
18637	18080	57	may	may	MD
18637	18080	58	become	become	VB
18637	18080	59	the	the	DT
18637	18080	60	subject	subject	NN
18637	18080	61	of	of	IN
18637	18080	62	contest	contest	NN
18637	18080	63	has	have	VBZ
18637	18080	64	been	be	VBN
18637	18080	65	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	18080	66	to	to	IN
18637	18080	67	the	the	DT
18637	18080	68	one	one	CD
18637	18080	69	government	government	NN
18637	18080	70	,	,	,
18637	18080	71	or	or	CC
18637	18080	72	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	18080	73	to	to	IN
18637	18080	74	the	the	DT
18637	18080	75	other	other	JJ
18637	18080	76	,	,	,
18637	18080	77	to	to	TO
18637	18080	78	depend	depend	VB
18637	18080	79	upon	upon	IN
18637	18080	80	a	a	DT
18637	18080	81	fair	fair	JJ
18637	18080	82	construction	construction	NN
18637	18080	83	of	of	IN
18637	18080	84	the	the	DT
18637	18080	85	whole	whole	JJ
18637	18080	86	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	18080	87	.	.	.
18637	18081	1	"	"	``
18637	18081	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18081	3	5	5	CD
18637	18081	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18081	5	The	the	DT
18637	18081	6	Taxing	Taxing	NNP
18637	18081	7	Power	Power	NNP
18637	18081	8	Not	not	RB
18637	18081	9	until	until	IN
18637	18081	10	after	after	IN
18637	18081	11	the	the	DT
18637	18081	12	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	18081	13	War	War	NNP
18637	18081	14	was	be	VBD
18637	18081	15	the	the	DT
18637	18081	16	idea	idea	NN
18637	18081	17	that	that	IN
18637	18081	18	the	the	DT
18637	18081	19	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	18081	20	powers	power	NNS
18637	18081	21	of	of	IN
18637	18081	22	the	the	DT
18637	18081	23	States	States	NNPS
18637	18081	24	comprise	comprise	VBP
18637	18081	25	an	an	DT
18637	18081	26	independent	independent	JJ
18637	18081	27	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	18081	28	of	of	IN
18637	18081	29	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	18081	30	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18081	31	acts	act	NNS
18637	18081	32	of	of	IN
18637	18081	33	the	the	DT
18637	18081	34	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18081	35	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18081	36	actually	actually	RB
18637	18081	37	applied	apply	VBD
18637	18081	38	to	to	TO
18637	18081	39	nullify	nullify	VB
18637	18081	40	,	,	,
18637	18081	41	in	in	IN
18637	18081	42	part	part	NN
18637	18081	43	,	,	,
18637	18081	44	an	an	DT
18637	18081	45	act	act	NN
18637	18081	46	of	of	IN
18637	18081	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18081	48	.	.	.
18637	18082	1	This	this	DT
18637	18082	2	result	result	NN
18637	18082	3	was	be	VBD
18637	18082	4	first	first	RB
18637	18082	5	reached	reach	VBN
18637	18082	6	in	in	IN
18637	18082	7	a	a	DT
18637	18082	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	18082	9	case	case	NN
18637	18082	10	--	--	:
18637	18082	11	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	18082	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18082	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	18082	14	_	_	NNP
18637	18082	15	Day	Day	NNP
18637	18082	16	.	.	.
18637	18083	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18083	2	6	6	CD
18637	18083	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18083	4	Holding	hold	VBG
18637	18083	5	that	that	IN
18637	18083	6	a	a	DT
18637	18083	7	national	national	JJ
18637	18083	8	income	income	NN
18637	18083	9	tax	tax	NN
18637	18083	10	,	,	,
18637	18083	11	in	in	IN
18637	18083	12	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18083	13	valid	valid	JJ
18637	18083	14	,	,	,
18637	18083	15	could	could	MD
18637	18083	16	not	not	RB
18637	18083	17	be	be	VB
18637	18083	18	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	18083	19	levied	levy	VBN
18637	18083	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	18083	21	the	the	DT
18637	18083	22	official	official	JJ
18637	18083	23	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	18083	24	of	of	IN
18637	18083	25	State	state	NN
18637	18083	26	officers	officer	NNS
18637	18083	27	,	,	,
18637	18083	28	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18083	29	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	18083	30	made	make	VBD
18637	18083	31	the	the	DT
18637	18083	32	sweeping	sweeping	JJ
18637	18083	33	statement	statement	NN
18637	18083	34	that	that	IN
18637	18083	35	"	"	``
18637	18083	36	*	*	NFP
18637	18083	37	*	*	NFP
18637	18083	38	*	*	NFP
18637	18083	39	the	the	DT
18637	18083	40	States	state	NNS
18637	18083	41	within	within	IN
18637	18083	42	the	the	DT
18637	18083	43	limits	limit	NNS
18637	18083	44	of	of	IN
18637	18083	45	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18083	46	powers	power	NNS
18637	18083	47	not	not	RB
18637	18083	48	granted	grant	VBN
18637	18083	49	,	,	,
18637	18083	50	or	or	CC
18637	18083	51	,	,	,
18637	18083	52	in	in	IN
18637	18083	53	the	the	DT
18637	18083	54	language	language	NN
18637	18083	55	of	of	IN
18637	18083	56	the	the	DT
18637	18083	57	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18083	58	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18083	59	,	,	,
18637	18083	60	'	'	''
18637	18083	61	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	18083	62	,	,	,
18637	18083	63	'	'	''
18637	18083	64	are	be	VBP
18637	18083	65	as	as	RB
18637	18083	66	independent	independent	JJ
18637	18083	67	of	of	IN
18637	18083	68	the	the	DT
18637	18083	69	general	general	JJ
18637	18083	70	government	government	NN
18637	18083	71	as	as	IN
18637	18083	72	that	that	DT
18637	18083	73	government	government	NN
18637	18083	74	within	within	IN
18637	18083	75	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18083	76	sphere	sphere	NN
18637	18083	77	is	be	VBZ
18637	18083	78	independent	independent	JJ
18637	18083	79	of	of	IN
18637	18083	80	the	the	DT
18637	18083	81	States	States	NNP
18637	18083	82	.	.	.
18637	18084	1	"	"	``
18637	18084	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18084	3	7	7	CD
18637	18084	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18084	5	In	in	IN
18637	18084	6	1939	1939	CD
18637	18084	7	,	,	,
18637	18084	8	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	18084	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18084	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	18084	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18084	12	Day	Day	NNP
18637	18084	13	was	be	VBD
18637	18084	14	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	18084	15	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	18084	16	.	.	.
18637	18085	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18085	2	8	8	CD
18637	18085	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18085	4	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	18085	5	,	,	,
18637	18085	6	the	the	DT
18637	18085	7	problem	problem	NN
18637	18085	8	of	of	IN
18637	18085	9	reconciling	reconcile	VBG
18637	18085	10	State	state	NN
18637	18085	11	and	and	CC
18637	18085	12	national	national	JJ
18637	18085	13	interests	interest	NNS
18637	18085	14	still	still	RB
18637	18085	15	confronts	confront	VBZ
18637	18085	16	the	the	DT
18637	18085	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18085	18	occasionally	occasionally	RB
18637	18085	19	,	,	,
18637	18085	20	and	and	CC
18637	18085	21	was	be	VBD
18637	18085	22	elaborately	elaborately	RB
18637	18085	23	considered	consider	VBN
18637	18085	24	in	in	IN
18637	18085	25	New	New	NNP
18637	18085	26	York	York	NNP
18637	18085	27	_	_	NNP
18637	18085	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	18085	29	_	_	NNP
18637	18085	30	United	United	NNP
18637	18085	31	States,[9	States,[9	NNP
18637	18085	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18085	33	where	where	WRB
18637	18085	34	,	,	,
18637	18085	35	by	by	IN
18637	18085	36	a	a	DT
18637	18085	37	vote	vote	NN
18637	18085	38	of	of	IN
18637	18085	39	six	six	CD
18637	18085	40	-	-	HYPH
18637	18085	41	to	to	IN
18637	18085	42	-	-	HYPH
18637	18085	43	two	two	CD
18637	18085	44	,	,	,
18637	18085	45	the	the	DT
18637	18085	46	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18085	47	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	18085	48	the	the	DT
18637	18085	49	right	right	NN
18637	18085	50	of	of	IN
18637	18085	51	the	the	DT
18637	18085	52	United	United	NNP
18637	18085	53	States	States	NNP
18637	18085	54	to	to	TO
18637	18085	55	tax	tax	VB
18637	18085	56	the	the	DT
18637	18085	57	sale	sale	NN
18637	18085	58	of	of	IN
18637	18085	59	mineral	mineral	NN
18637	18085	60	waters	water	NNS
18637	18085	61	taken	take	VBN
18637	18085	62	from	from	IN
18637	18085	63	property	property	NN
18637	18085	64	owned	own	VBN
18637	18085	65	by	by	IN
18637	18085	66	a	a	DT
18637	18085	67	State	state	NN
18637	18085	68	.	.	.
18637	18086	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	18086	2	for	for	IN
18637	18086	3	four	four	CD
18637	18086	4	members	member	NNS
18637	18086	5	of	of	IN
18637	18086	6	the	the	DT
18637	18086	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18086	8	,	,	,
18637	18086	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	18086	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18086	11	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	18086	12	justified	justify	VBD
18637	18086	13	the	the	DT
18637	18086	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	18086	15	on	on	IN
18637	18086	16	the	the	DT
18637	18086	17	ground	ground	NN
18637	18086	18	that	that	IN
18637	18086	19	"	"	``
18637	18086	20	The	the	DT
18637	18086	21	national	national	JJ
18637	18086	22	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	18086	23	power	power	NN
18637	18086	24	would	would	MD
18637	18086	25	be	be	VB
18637	18086	26	unduly	unduly	RB
18637	18086	27	curtailed	curtail	VBN
18637	18086	28	if	if	IN
18637	18086	29	the	the	DT
18637	18086	30	State	State	NNP
18637	18086	31	,	,	,
18637	18086	32	by	by	IN
18637	18086	33	extending	extend	VBG
18637	18086	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18086	35	activities	activity	NNS
18637	18086	36	,	,	,
18637	18086	37	could	could	MD
18637	18086	38	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	18086	39	from	from	IN
18637	18086	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18086	41	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	18086	42	of	of	IN
18637	18086	43	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	18086	44	traditionally	traditionally	RB
18637	18086	45	within	within	IN
18637	18086	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18086	47	.	.	.
18637	18087	1	"	"	``
18637	18087	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18087	3	10	10	CD
18637	18087	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18087	5	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	18087	6	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	18087	7	and	and	CC
18637	18087	8	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	18087	9	found	find	VBD
18637	18087	10	in	in	IN
18637	18087	11	the	the	DT
18637	18087	12	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18087	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18087	14	"	"	''
18637	18087	15	*	*	NFP
18637	18087	16	*	*	NFP
18637	18087	17	*	*	NFP
18637	18087	18	no	no	DT
18637	18087	19	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	18087	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	18087	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18087	22	to	to	TO
18637	18087	23	include	include	VB
18637	18087	24	the	the	DT
18637	18087	25	States	States	NNP
18637	18087	26	in	in	IN
18637	18087	27	levying	levy	VBG
18637	18087	28	a	a	DT
18637	18087	29	tax	tax	NN
18637	18087	30	exacted	exact	VBN
18637	18087	31	equally	equally	RB
18637	18087	32	from	from	IN
18637	18087	33	private	private	JJ
18637	18087	34	persons	person	NNS
18637	18087	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	18087	36	the	the	DT
18637	18087	37	same	same	JJ
18637	18087	38	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18087	39	matter	matter	NN
18637	18087	40	.	.	.
18637	18088	1	"	"	``
18637	18088	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18088	3	11	11	CD
18637	18088	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18088	5	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	18088	6	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	18088	7	and	and	CC
18637	18088	8	Black	Black	NNP
18637	18088	9	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	18088	10	,	,	,
18637	18088	11	saying	say	VBG
18637	18088	12	:	:	:
18637	18088	13	"	"	``
18637	18088	14	If	if	IN
18637	18088	15	the	the	DT
18637	18088	16	power	power	NN
18637	18088	17	of	of	IN
18637	18088	18	the	the	DT
18637	18088	19	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18088	20	government	government	NN
18637	18088	21	to	to	TO
18637	18088	22	tax	tax	VB
18637	18088	23	the	the	DT
18637	18088	24	States	States	NNP
18637	18088	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	18088	26	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	18088	27	,	,	,
18637	18088	28	the	the	DT
18637	18088	29	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	18088	30	power	power	NN
18637	18088	31	of	of	IN
18637	18088	32	the	the	DT
18637	18088	33	States	States	NNPS
18637	18088	34	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	18088	35	by	by	IN
18637	18088	36	the	the	DT
18637	18088	37	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18088	38	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18088	39	does	do	VBZ
18637	18088	40	not	not	RB
18637	18088	41	give	give	VB
18637	18088	42	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18088	43	the	the	DT
18637	18088	44	independence	independence	NN
18637	18088	45	which	which	WDT
18637	18088	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18088	47	have	have	VBP
18637	18088	48	always	always	RB
18637	18088	49	been	be	VBN
18637	18088	50	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	18088	51	to	to	TO
18637	18088	52	have	have	VB
18637	18088	53	.	.	.
18637	18089	1	"	"	``
18637	18089	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18089	3	12	12	CD
18637	18089	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18089	5	The	the	DT
18637	18089	6	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	18089	7	Power	Power	NNP
18637	18089	8	A	a	DT
18637	18089	9	year	year	NN
18637	18089	10	before	before	IN
18637	18089	11	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	18089	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18089	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	18089	14	_	_	NNP
18637	18089	15	Day	Day	NNP
18637	18089	16	was	be	VBD
18637	18089	17	decided	decide	VBN
18637	18089	18	,	,	,
18637	18089	19	the	the	DT
18637	18089	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18089	21	held	hold	VBD
18637	18089	22	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	18089	23	,	,	,
18637	18089	24	except	except	IN
18637	18089	25	as	as	IN
18637	18089	26	applied	apply	VBN
18637	18089	27	in	in	IN
18637	18089	28	the	the	DT
18637	18089	29	District	District	NNP
18637	18089	30	of	of	IN
18637	18089	31	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	18089	32	and	and	CC
18637	18089	33	other	other	JJ
18637	18089	34	areas	area	NNS
18637	18089	35	over	over	IN
18637	18089	36	which	which	WDT
18637	18089	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18089	38	has	have	VBZ
18637	18089	39	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	18089	40	authority	authority	NN
18637	18089	41	,	,	,
18637	18089	42	a	a	DT
18637	18089	43	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18089	44	statute	statute	NN
18637	18089	45	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	18089	46	the	the	DT
18637	18089	47	sale	sale	NN
18637	18089	48	of	of	IN
18637	18089	49	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	18089	50	illuminating	illuminating	NN
18637	18089	51	oils	oil	NNS
18637	18089	52	.	.	.
18637	18090	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18090	2	13	13	CD
18637	18090	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18090	4	The	the	DT
18637	18090	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18090	6	did	do	VBD
18637	18090	7	not	not	RB
18637	18090	8	refer	refer	VB
18637	18090	9	to	to	IN
18637	18090	10	the	the	DT
18637	18090	11	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18090	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18090	13	.	.	.
18637	18091	1	Instead	instead	RB
18637	18091	2	,	,	,
18637	18091	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18091	4	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	18091	5	that	that	IN
18637	18091	6	the	the	DT
18637	18091	7	"	"	``
18637	18091	8	*	*	NFP
18637	18091	9	*	*	NFP
18637	18091	10	*	*	NFP
18637	18091	11	express	express	JJ
18637	18091	12	grant	grant	NN
18637	18091	13	of	of	IN
18637	18091	14	power	power	NN
18637	18091	15	to	to	TO
18637	18091	16	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	18091	17	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18091	18	among	among	IN
18637	18091	19	the	the	DT
18637	18091	20	States	States	NNP
18637	18091	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	18091	22	always	always	RB
18637	18091	23	been	be	VBN
18637	18091	24	understood	understand	VBN
18637	18091	25	as	as	IN
18637	18091	26	limited	limit	VBN
18637	18091	27	by	by	IN
18637	18091	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18091	29	terms	term	NNS
18637	18091	30	;	;	:
18637	18091	31	and	and	CC
18637	18091	32	as	as	IN
18637	18091	33	a	a	DT
18637	18091	34	virtual	virtual	JJ
18637	18091	35	denial	denial	NN
18637	18091	36	of	of	IN
18637	18091	37	any	any	DT
18637	18091	38	power	power	NN
18637	18091	39	to	to	TO
18637	18091	40	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	18091	41	with	with	IN
18637	18091	42	the	the	DT
18637	18091	43	internal	internal	JJ
18637	18091	44	trade	trade	NN
18637	18091	45	and	and	CC
18637	18091	46	business	business	NN
18637	18091	47	of	of	IN
18637	18091	48	the	the	DT
18637	18091	49	separate	separate	JJ
18637	18091	50	States	state	NNS
18637	18091	51	;	;	:
18637	18091	52	except	except	IN
18637	18091	53	,	,	,
18637	18091	54	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	18091	55	,	,	,
18637	18091	56	as	as	IN
18637	18091	57	a	a	DT
18637	18091	58	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18091	59	and	and	CC
18637	18091	60	proper	proper	JJ
18637	18091	61	means	mean	NNS
18637	18091	62	for	for	IN
18637	18091	63	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	18091	64	into	into	IN
18637	18091	65	execution	execution	NN
18637	18091	66	some	some	DT
18637	18091	67	other	other	JJ
18637	18091	68	power	power	NN
18637	18091	69	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	18091	70	granted	grant	VBN
18637	18091	71	or	or	CC
18637	18091	72	vested	vest	VBN
18637	18091	73	.	.	.
18637	18092	1	"	"	``
18637	18092	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18092	3	14	14	CD
18637	18092	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18092	5	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18092	6	,	,	,
18637	18092	7	in	in	IN
18637	18092	8	the	the	DT
18637	18092	9	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	18092	10	'	'	POS
18637	18092	11	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	18092	12	Cases,[15	cases,[15	NN
18637	18092	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18092	14	an	an	DT
18637	18092	15	act	act	NN
18637	18092	16	of	of	IN
18637	18092	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18092	18	making	make	VBG
18637	18092	19	every	every	DT
18637	18092	20	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18092	21	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	18092	22	in	in	IN
18637	18092	23	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	18092	24	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18092	25	liable	liable	JJ
18637	18092	26	to	to	IN
18637	18092	27	"	"	``
18637	18092	28	any	any	DT
18637	18092	29	"	"	``
18637	18092	30	employee	employee	NN
18637	18092	31	,	,	,
18637	18092	32	including	include	VBG
18637	18092	33	those	those	DT
18637	18092	34	whose	whose	WP$
18637	18092	35	activities	activity	NNS
18637	18092	36	related	relate	VBN
18637	18092	37	solely	solely	RB
18637	18092	38	to	to	IN
18637	18092	39	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	18092	40	activities	activity	NNS
18637	18092	41	,	,	,
18637	18092	42	for	for	IN
18637	18092	43	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	18092	44	caused	cause	VBN
18637	18092	45	by	by	IN
18637	18092	46	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	18092	47	,	,	,
18637	18092	48	was	be	VBD
18637	18092	49	held	hold	VBN
18637	18092	50	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18092	51	by	by	IN
18637	18092	52	a	a	DT
18637	18092	53	closely	closely	RB
18637	18092	54	divided	divide	VBN
18637	18092	55	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18092	56	,	,	,
18637	18092	57	without	without	IN
18637	18092	58	explicit	explicit	JJ
18637	18092	59	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	18092	60	on	on	IN
18637	18092	61	the	the	DT
18637	18092	62	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18092	63	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18092	64	.	.	.
18637	18093	1	Not	not	RB
18637	18093	2	until	until	IN
18637	18093	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18093	4	was	be	VBD
18637	18093	5	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	18093	6	with	with	IN
18637	18093	7	the	the	DT
18637	18093	8	Child	Child	NNP
18637	18093	9	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	18093	10	Law	Law	NNP
18637	18093	11	,	,	,
18637	18093	12	which	which	WDT
18637	18093	13	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	18093	14	the	the	DT
18637	18093	15	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	18093	16	in	in	IN
18637	18093	17	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	18093	18	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18093	19	of	of	IN
18637	18093	20	goods	good	NNS
18637	18093	21	produced	produce	VBN
18637	18093	22	in	in	IN
18637	18093	23	establishments	establishment	NNS
18637	18093	24	in	in	IN
18637	18093	25	which	which	WDT
18637	18093	26	child	child	NN
18637	18093	27	labor	labor	NN
18637	18093	28	was	be	VBD
18637	18093	29	employed	employ	VBN
18637	18093	30	,	,	,
18637	18093	31	did	do	VBD
18637	18093	32	the	the	DT
18637	18093	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18093	34	hold	hold	VB
18637	18093	35	that	that	IN
18637	18093	36	the	the	DT
18637	18093	37	State	State	NNP
18637	18093	38	police	police	NN
18637	18093	39	power	power	NN
18637	18093	40	was	be	VBD
18637	18093	41	an	an	DT
18637	18093	42	obstacle	obstacle	NN
18637	18093	43	to	to	IN
18637	18093	44	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	18093	45	of	of	IN
18637	18093	46	a	a	DT
18637	18093	47	measure	measure	NN
18637	18093	48	which	which	WDT
18637	18093	49	operated	operate	VBD
18637	18093	50	directly	directly	RB
18637	18093	51	and	and	CC
18637	18093	52	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	18093	53	upon	upon	IN
18637	18093	54	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	18093	55	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18093	56	.	.	.
18637	18094	1	In	in	IN
18637	18094	2	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	18094	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18094	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	18094	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18094	6	Dagenhart,[16	Dagenhart,[16	NNP
18637	18094	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18094	8	five	five	CD
18637	18094	9	members	member	NNS
18637	18094	10	of	of	IN
18637	18094	11	the	the	DT
18637	18094	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18094	13	found	find	VBD
18637	18094	14	in	in	IN
18637	18094	15	the	the	DT
18637	18094	16	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18094	17	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18094	18	a	a	DT
18637	18094	19	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	18094	20	to	to	TO
18637	18094	21	nullify	nullify	VB
18637	18094	22	this	this	DT
18637	18094	23	law	law	NN
18637	18094	24	as	as	IN
18637	18094	25	an	an	DT
18637	18094	26	unwarranted	unwarranted	JJ
18637	18094	27	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	18094	28	of	of	IN
18637	18094	29	the	the	DT
18637	18094	30	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	18094	31	powers	power	NNS
18637	18094	32	of	of	IN
18637	18094	33	the	the	DT
18637	18094	34	States	States	NNP
18637	18094	35	.	.	.
18637	18095	1	This	this	DT
18637	18095	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	18095	3	was	be	VBD
18637	18095	4	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	18095	5	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	18095	6	in	in	IN
18637	18095	7	United	United	NNP
18637	18095	8	States	States	NNP
18637	18095	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18095	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	18095	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18095	12	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	18095	13	.	.	.
18637	18096	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18096	2	17	17	CD
18637	18096	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18096	4	During	during	IN
18637	18096	5	the	the	DT
18637	18096	6	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	18096	7	years	year	NNS
18637	18096	8	following	follow	VBG
18637	18096	9	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	18096	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18096	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	18096	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18096	13	Dagenhart	Dagenhart	NNP
18637	18096	14	,	,	,
18637	18096	15	a	a	DT
18637	18096	16	variety	variety	NN
18637	18096	17	of	of	IN
18637	18096	18	measures	measure	NNS
18637	18096	19	designed	design	VBN
18637	18096	20	to	to	TO
18637	18096	21	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	18096	22	economic	economic	JJ
18637	18096	23	activities	activity	NNS
18637	18096	24	,	,	,
18637	18096	25	directly	directly	RB
18637	18096	26	or	or	CC
18637	18096	27	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	18096	28	,	,	,
18637	18096	29	were	be	VBD
18637	18096	30	held	hold	VBN
18637	18096	31	void	void	JJ
18637	18096	32	on	on	IN
18637	18096	33	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18096	34	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	18096	35	.	.	.
18637	18097	1	Excise	excise	VB
18637	18097	2	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18097	3	on	on	IN
18637	18097	4	the	the	DT
18637	18097	5	profits	profit	NNS
18637	18097	6	of	of	IN
18637	18097	7	factories	factory	NNS
18637	18097	8	in	in	IN
18637	18097	9	which	which	WDT
18637	18097	10	child	child	NN
18637	18097	11	labor	labor	NN
18637	18097	12	was	be	VBD
18637	18097	13	employed,[18	employed,[18	CD
18637	18097	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18097	15	on	on	IN
18637	18097	16	the	the	DT
18637	18097	17	sale	sale	NN
18637	18097	18	of	of	IN
18637	18097	19	grain	grain	NN
18637	18097	20	futures	future	NNS
18637	18097	21	on	on	IN
18637	18097	22	markets	market	NNS
18637	18097	23	which	which	WDT
18637	18097	24	failed	fail	VBD
18637	18097	25	to	to	TO
18637	18097	26	comply	comply	VB
18637	18097	27	with	with	IN
18637	18097	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18097	29	regulations,[19	regulations,[19	CD
18637	18097	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18097	31	on	on	IN
18637	18097	32	the	the	DT
18637	18097	33	sale	sale	NN
18637	18097	34	of	of	IN
18637	18097	35	coal	coal	NN
18637	18097	36	produced	produce	VBN
18637	18097	37	by	by	IN
18637	18097	38	nonmembers	nonmember	NNS
18637	18097	39	of	of	IN
18637	18097	40	a	a	DT
18637	18097	41	coal	coal	NN
18637	18097	42	code	code	NN
18637	18097	43	established	establish	VBN
18637	18097	44	as	as	IN
18637	18097	45	a	a	DT
18637	18097	46	part	part	NN
18637	18097	47	of	of	IN
18637	18097	48	a	a	DT
18637	18097	49	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18097	50	regulatory	regulatory	NNP
18637	18097	51	scheme,[20	scheme,[20	CD
18637	18097	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18097	53	and	and	CC
18637	18097	54	a	a	DT
18637	18097	55	tax	tax	NN
18637	18097	56	on	on	IN
18637	18097	57	the	the	DT
18637	18097	58	processing	processing	NN
18637	18097	59	of	of	IN
18637	18097	60	agricultural	agricultural	JJ
18637	18097	61	products	product	NNS
18637	18097	62	,	,	,
18637	18097	63	the	the	DT
18637	18097	64	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	18097	65	of	of	IN
18637	18097	66	which	which	WDT
18637	18097	67	were	be	VBD
18637	18097	68	paid	pay	VBN
18637	18097	69	to	to	IN
18637	18097	70	farmers	farmer	NNS
18637	18097	71	who	who	WP
18637	18097	72	complied	comply	VBD
18637	18097	73	with	with	IN
18637	18097	74	production	production	NN
18637	18097	75	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	18097	76	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18097	77	by	by	IN
18637	18097	78	the	the	DT
18637	18097	79	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18097	80	Government,[21	Government,[21	NNP
18637	18097	81	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18097	82	were	be	VBD
18637	18097	83	all	all	DT
18637	18097	84	found	find	VBN
18637	18097	85	to	to	TO
18637	18097	86	invade	invade	VB
18637	18097	87	the	the	DT
18637	18097	88	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	18097	89	powers	power	NNS
18637	18097	90	of	of	IN
18637	18097	91	the	the	DT
18637	18097	92	States	States	NNP
18637	18097	93	.	.	.
18637	18098	1	In	in	IN
18637	18098	2	Schechter	Schechter	NNP
18637	18098	3	Poultry	Poultry	NNP
18637	18098	4	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	18098	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18098	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18098	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18098	8	United	United	NNP
18637	18098	9	States[22	States[22	NNP
18637	18098	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18098	11	the	the	DT
18637	18098	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18098	13	,	,	,
18637	18098	14	after	after	IN
18637	18098	15	holding	hold	VBG
18637	18098	16	that	that	IN
18637	18098	17	the	the	DT
18637	18098	18	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	18098	19	power	power	NN
18637	18098	20	did	do	VBD
18637	18098	21	not	not	RB
18637	18098	22	extend	extend	VB
18637	18098	23	to	to	IN
18637	18098	24	local	local	JJ
18637	18098	25	sales	sale	NNS
18637	18098	26	of	of	IN
18637	18098	27	poultry	poultry	NN
18637	18098	28	,	,	,
18637	18098	29	cited	cite	VBD
18637	18098	30	the	the	DT
18637	18098	31	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18098	32	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18098	33	to	to	TO
18637	18098	34	refute	refute	VB
18637	18098	35	the	the	DT
18637	18098	36	argument	argument	NN
18637	18098	37	that	that	IN
18637	18098	38	the	the	DT
18637	18098	39	existence	existence	NN
18637	18098	40	of	of	IN
18637	18098	41	an	an	DT
18637	18098	42	economic	economic	JJ
18637	18098	43	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	18098	44	justified	justify	VBD
18637	18098	45	the	the	DT
18637	18098	46	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18098	47	of	of	IN
18637	18098	48	what	what	WP
18637	18098	49	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	18098	50	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18098	51	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	18098	52	called	call	VBD
18637	18098	53	"	"	``
18637	18098	54	extraconstitutional	extraconstitutional	JJ
18637	18098	55	authority	authority	NN
18637	18098	56	.	.	.
18637	18099	1	"	"	``
18637	18099	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18099	3	23	23	CD
18637	18099	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18099	5	In	in	IN
18637	18099	6	1941	1941	CD
18637	18099	7	the	the	DT
18637	18099	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18099	9	came	come	VBD
18637	18099	10	full	full	JJ
18637	18099	11	circle	circle	NN
18637	18099	12	in	in	IN
18637	18099	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18099	14	exposition	exposition	NN
18637	18099	15	of	of	IN
18637	18099	16	this	this	DT
18637	18099	17	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18099	18	.	.	.
18637	18100	1	Having	have	VBG
18637	18100	2	returned	return	VBN
18637	18100	3	to	to	IN
18637	18100	4	the	the	DT
18637	18100	5	position	position	NN
18637	18100	6	of	of	IN
18637	18100	7	John	John	NNP
18637	18100	8	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	18100	9	four	four	CD
18637	18100	10	years	year	NNS
18637	18100	11	earlier	early	RBR
18637	18100	12	when	when	WRB
18637	18100	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18100	14	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	18100	15	the	the	DT
18637	18100	16	Social	Social	NNP
18637	18100	17	Security[24	security[24	ADD
18637	18100	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18100	19	and	and	CC
18637	18100	20	National	National	NNP
18637	18100	21	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	18100	22	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	18100	23	Acts,[25	Acts,[25	NNP
18637	18100	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18100	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18100	26	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	18100	27	restated	restate	VBD
18637	18100	28	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	18100	29	's	's	POS
18637	18100	30	thesis	thesis	NN
18637	18100	31	in	in	IN
18637	18100	32	upholding	uphold	VBG
18637	18100	33	the	the	DT
18637	18100	34	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	18100	35	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	18100	36	Standards	Standards	NNPS
18637	18100	37	Act	Act	NNP
18637	18100	38	in	in	IN
18637	18100	39	United	United	NNP
18637	18100	40	States	States	NNP
18637	18100	41	_	_	NNP
18637	18100	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	18100	43	_	_	NNP
18637	18100	44	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	18100	45	.	.	.
18637	18101	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18101	2	26	26	CD
18637	18101	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18101	4	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	18101	5	for	for	IN
18637	18101	6	a	a	DT
18637	18101	7	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	18101	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18101	9	,	,	,
18637	18101	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	18101	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18101	12	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	18101	13	wrote	write	VBD
18637	18101	14	:	:	:
18637	18101	15	"	"	``
18637	18101	16	The	the	DT
18637	18101	17	power	power	NN
18637	18101	18	of	of	IN
18637	18101	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18101	20	over	over	IN
18637	18101	21	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	18101	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18101	23	'	'	''
18637	18101	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	18101	25	complete	complete	JJ
18637	18101	26	in	in	IN
18637	18101	27	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18101	28	,	,	,
18637	18101	29	may	may	MD
18637	18101	30	be	be	VB
18637	18101	31	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	18101	32	to	to	IN
18637	18101	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18101	34	utmost	utmost	JJ
18637	18101	35	extent	extent	NN
18637	18101	36	,	,	,
18637	18101	37	and	and	CC
18637	18101	38	acknowledges	acknowledge	VBZ
18637	18101	39	no	no	DT
18637	18101	40	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	18101	41	other	other	JJ
18637	18101	42	than	than	IN
18637	18101	43	are	be	VBP
18637	18101	44	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	18101	45	in	in	IN
18637	18101	46	the	the	DT
18637	18101	47	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18101	48	.	.	.
18637	18101	49	'	'	''
18637	18102	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18102	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18102	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18102	4	That	that	DT
18637	18102	5	power	power	NN
18637	18102	6	can	can	MD
18637	18102	7	neither	neither	CC
18637	18102	8	be	be	VB
18637	18102	9	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
18637	18102	10	nor	nor	CC
18637	18102	11	diminished	diminish	VBN
18637	18102	12	by	by	IN
18637	18102	13	the	the	DT
18637	18102	14	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18102	15	or	or	CC
18637	18102	16	non	non	NN
18637	18102	17	-	-	NN
18637	18102	18	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18102	19	of	of	IN
18637	18102	20	state	state	NN
18637	18102	21	power	power	NN
18637	18102	22	.	.	.
18637	18103	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18103	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18103	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18103	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18103	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	18103	6	no	no	DT
18637	18103	7	objection	objection	NN
18637	18103	8	to	to	IN
18637	18103	9	the	the	DT
18637	18103	10	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	18103	11	of	of	IN
18637	18103	12	the	the	DT
18637	18103	13	power	power	NN
18637	18103	14	to	to	TO
18637	18103	15	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	18103	16	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	18103	17	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18103	18	that	that	WDT
18637	18103	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18103	20	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18103	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	18103	22	attended	attend	VBN
18637	18103	23	by	by	IN
18637	18103	24	the	the	DT
18637	18103	25	same	same	JJ
18637	18103	26	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	18103	27	which	which	WDT
18637	18103	28	attend	attend	VBP
18637	18103	29	the	the	DT
18637	18103	30	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18103	31	of	of	IN
18637	18103	32	the	the	DT
18637	18103	33	police	police	NN
18637	18103	34	power	power	NN
18637	18103	35	of	of	IN
18637	18103	36	the	the	DT
18637	18103	37	states	state	NNS
18637	18103	38	.	.	.
18637	18104	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18104	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18104	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18104	4	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18104	5	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	18104	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	18104	7	unaffected	unaffected	JJ
18637	18104	8	by	by	IN
18637	18104	9	the	the	DT
18637	18104	10	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18104	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18104	12	which	which	WDT
18637	18104	13	*	*	NFP
18637	18104	14	*	*	NFP
18637	18104	15	*	*	NFP
18637	18104	16	states	state	NNS
18637	18104	17	but	but	CC
18637	18104	18	a	a	DT
18637	18104	19	truism	truism	NN
18637	18104	20	that	that	WDT
18637	18104	21	all	all	DT
18637	18104	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	18104	23	retained	retain	VBN
18637	18104	24	which	which	WDT
18637	18104	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	18104	26	not	not	RB
18637	18104	27	been	be	VBN
18637	18104	28	surrendered	surrender	VBN
18637	18104	29	.	.	.
18637	18105	1	"	"	``
18637	18105	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18105	3	27	27	CD
18637	18105	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18105	5	Police	Police	NNP
18637	18105	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	18105	7	But	but	CC
18637	18105	8	even	even	RB
18637	18105	9	prior	prior	RB
18637	18105	10	to	to	IN
18637	18105	11	1937	1937	CD
18637	18105	12	not	not	RB
18637	18105	13	all	all	DT
18637	18105	14	measures	measure	NNS
18637	18105	15	taken	take	VBN
18637	18105	16	to	to	TO
18637	18105	17	promote	promote	VB
18637	18105	18	objectives	objective	NNS
18637	18105	19	which	which	WDT
18637	18105	20	had	have	VBD
18637	18105	21	traditionally	traditionally	RB
18637	18105	22	been	be	VBN
18637	18105	23	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	18105	24	as	as	IN
18637	18105	25	the	the	DT
18637	18105	26	responsibilities	responsibility	NNS
18637	18105	27	of	of	IN
18637	18105	28	the	the	DT
18637	18105	29	States	States	NNPS
18637	18105	30	had	have	VBD
18637	18105	31	been	be	VBN
18637	18105	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	18105	33	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	18105	34	.	.	.
18637	18106	1	In	in	IN
18637	18106	2	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	18106	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18106	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	18106	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18106	6	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	18106	7	Distilleries	Distilleries	NNP
18637	18106	8	Co	Co	NNP
18637	18106	9	.	.	NNP
18637	18106	10	,[28	,[28	NFP
18637	18106	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18106	12	a	a	DT
18637	18106	13	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	18106	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18106	15	,	,	,
18637	18106	16	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	18106	17	by	by	IN
18637	18106	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18106	19	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	18106	20	,	,	,
18637	18106	21	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	18106	22	"	"	``
18637	18106	23	War	War	NNP
18637	18106	24	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	18106	25	"	"	''
18637	18106	26	,	,	,
18637	18106	27	saying	say	VBG
18637	18106	28	:	:	:
18637	18106	29	"	"	``
18637	18106	30	That	that	IN
18637	18106	31	the	the	DT
18637	18106	32	United	United	NNP
18637	18106	33	States	States	NNP
18637	18106	34	lacks	lack	VBZ
18637	18106	35	the	the	DT
18637	18106	36	police	police	NN
18637	18106	37	power	power	NN
18637	18106	38	,	,	,
18637	18106	39	and	and	CC
18637	18106	40	that	that	IN
18637	18106	41	this	this	DT
18637	18106	42	was	be	VBD
18637	18106	43	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	18106	44	to	to	IN
18637	18106	45	the	the	DT
18637	18106	46	States	States	NNP
18637	18106	47	by	by	IN
18637	18106	48	the	the	DT
18637	18106	49	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18106	50	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18106	51	,	,	,
18637	18106	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	18106	53	true	true	JJ
18637	18106	54	.	.	.
18637	18107	1	But	but	CC
18637	18107	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18107	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	18107	4	none	none	NN
18637	18107	5	the	the	DT
18637	18107	6	less	less	RBR
18637	18107	7	true	true	JJ
18637	18107	8	that	that	IN
18637	18107	9	when	when	WRB
18637	18107	10	the	the	DT
18637	18107	11	United	United	NNP
18637	18107	12	States	States	NNP
18637	18107	13	exerts	exert	VBZ
18637	18107	14	any	any	DT
18637	18107	15	of	of	IN
18637	18107	16	the	the	DT
18637	18107	17	powers	power	NNS
18637	18107	18	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	18107	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	18107	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18107	21	by	by	IN
18637	18107	22	the	the	DT
18637	18107	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18107	24	,	,	,
18637	18107	25	no	no	DT
18637	18107	26	valid	valid	JJ
18637	18107	27	objection	objection	NN
18637	18107	28	can	can	MD
18637	18107	29	be	be	VB
18637	18107	30	based	base	VBN
18637	18107	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	18107	32	the	the	DT
18637	18107	33	fact	fact	NN
18637	18107	34	that	that	IN
18637	18107	35	such	such	JJ
18637	18107	36	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18107	37	may	may	MD
18637	18107	38	be	be	VB
18637	18107	39	attended	attend	VBN
18637	18107	40	by	by	IN
18637	18107	41	the	the	DT
18637	18107	42	same	same	JJ
18637	18107	43	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	18107	44	which	which	WDT
18637	18107	45	attend	attend	VBP
18637	18107	46	the	the	DT
18637	18107	47	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18107	48	by	by	IN
18637	18107	49	a	a	DT
18637	18107	50	State	state	NN
18637	18107	51	of	of	IN
18637	18107	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18107	53	police	police	NN
18637	18107	54	power	power	NN
18637	18107	55	.	.	.
18637	18108	1	"	"	``
18637	18108	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18108	3	29	29	CD
18637	18108	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18108	5	And	and	CC
18637	18108	6	in	in	IN
18637	18108	7	a	a	DT
18637	18108	8	series	series	NN
18637	18108	9	of	of	IN
18637	18108	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	18108	11	,	,	,
18637	18108	12	which	which	WDT
18637	18108	13	today	today	NN
18637	18108	14	seem	seem	VBP
18637	18108	15	irreconcilable	irreconcilable	JJ
18637	18108	16	with	with	IN
18637	18108	17	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	18108	18	_	_	NNP
18637	18108	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	18108	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18108	21	Dagenhart	Dagenhart	NNP
18637	18108	22	,	,	,
18637	18108	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18108	24	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	18108	25	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18108	26	laws	law	NNS
18637	18108	27	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	18108	28	the	the	DT
18637	18108	29	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	18108	30	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	18108	31	of	of	IN
18637	18108	32	lottery	lottery	NNP
18637	18108	33	tickets,[30	tickets,[30	CD
18637	18108	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18108	35	of	of	IN
18637	18108	36	women	woman	NNS
18637	18108	37	for	for	IN
18637	18108	38	immoral	immoral	JJ
18637	18108	39	purposes,[31	purposes,[31	NNP
18637	18108	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18108	41	of	of	IN
18637	18108	42	stolen	steal	VBN
18637	18108	43	automobiles,[32	automobiles,[32	CD
18637	18108	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18108	45	and	and	CC
18637	18108	46	of	of	IN
18637	18108	47	tick	tick	VB
18637	18108	48	-	-	HYPH
18637	18108	49	infested	infest	VBN
18637	18108	50	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	18108	51	.	.	.
18637	18109	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18109	2	33	33	CD
18637	18109	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18109	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18109	5	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	18109	6	the	the	DT
18637	18109	7	power	power	NN
18637	18109	8	of	of	IN
18637	18109	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18109	10	to	to	TO
18637	18109	11	punish	punish	VB
18637	18109	12	the	the	DT
18637	18109	13	forgery	forgery	NN
18637	18109	14	of	of	IN
18637	18109	15	bills	bill	NNS
18637	18109	16	of	of	IN
18637	18109	17	lading	lading	NN
18637	18109	18	purporting	purport	VBG
18637	18109	19	to	to	TO
18637	18109	20	cover	cover	VB
18637	18109	21	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	18109	22	shipments	shipment	NNS
18637	18109	23	of	of	IN
18637	18109	24	merchandise,[34	merchandise,[34	CD
18637	18109	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18109	26	to	to	TO
18637	18109	27	subject	subject	VB
18637	18109	28	prison	prison	NN
18637	18109	29	made	make	VBD
18637	18109	30	goods	good	NNS
18637	18109	31	moved	move	VBN
18637	18109	32	from	from	IN
18637	18109	33	one	one	CD
18637	18109	34	State	state	NN
18637	18109	35	to	to	IN
18637	18109	36	another	another	DT
18637	18109	37	to	to	IN
18637	18109	38	the	the	DT
18637	18109	39	laws	law	NNS
18637	18109	40	of	of	IN
18637	18109	41	the	the	DT
18637	18109	42	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	18109	43	State,[35	State,[35	NNP
18637	18109	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18109	45	and	and	CC
18637	18109	46	to	to	TO
18637	18109	47	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	18109	48	prescriptions	prescription	NNS
18637	18109	49	for	for	IN
18637	18109	50	the	the	DT
18637	18109	51	medicinal	medicinal	JJ
18637	18109	52	use	use	NN
18637	18109	53	of	of	IN
18637	18109	54	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	18109	55	as	as	IN
18637	18109	56	an	an	DT
18637	18109	57	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	18109	58	measure	measure	NN
18637	18109	59	for	for	IN
18637	18109	60	the	the	DT
18637	18109	61	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18109	62	of	of	IN
18637	18109	63	the	the	DT
18637	18109	64	Eighteenth	Eighteenth	NNP
18637	18109	65	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18109	66	.	.	.
18637	18110	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18110	2	36	36	CD
18637	18110	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18110	4	But	but	CC
18637	18110	5	while	while	IN
18637	18110	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18110	7	might	may	MD
18637	18110	8	thus	thus	RB
18637	18110	9	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18110	10	the	the	DT
18637	18110	11	use	use	NN
18637	18110	12	of	of	IN
18637	18110	13	the	the	DT
18637	18110	14	channels	channel	NNS
18637	18110	15	of	of	IN
18637	18110	16	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	18110	17	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18110	18	to	to	TO
18637	18110	19	frustrate	frustrate	VB
18637	18110	20	State	state	NN
18637	18110	21	law	law	NN
18637	18110	22	,	,	,
18637	18110	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18110	24	could	could	MD
18637	18110	25	not	not	RB
18637	18110	26	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18110	27	,	,	,
18637	18110	28	the	the	DT
18637	18110	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18110	30	held	hold	VBD
18637	18110	31	,	,	,
18637	18110	32	undertake	undertake	VBP
18637	18110	33	to	to	TO
18637	18110	34	punish	punish	VB
18637	18110	35	a	a	DT
18637	18110	36	violation	violation	NN
18637	18110	37	of	of	IN
18637	18110	38	that	that	DT
18637	18110	39	law	law	NN
18637	18110	40	by	by	IN
18637	18110	41	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	18110	42	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	18110	43	;	;	,
18637	18110	44	and	and	CC
18637	18110	45	in	in	IN
18637	18110	46	United	United	NNP
18637	18110	47	States	States	NNP
18637	18110	48	_	_	NNP
18637	18110	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	18110	50	_	_	NNP
18637	18110	51	Constantine,[37	Constantine,[37	NNP
18637	18110	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18110	53	a	a	DT
18637	18110	54	grossly	grossly	RB
18637	18110	55	disproportionate	disproportionate	JJ
18637	18110	56	excise	excise	NN
18637	18110	57	tax	tax	NN
18637	18110	58	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18110	59	on	on	IN
18637	18110	60	retail	retail	JJ
18637	18110	61	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	18110	62	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	18110	63	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	18110	64	on	on	IN
18637	18110	65	business	business	NN
18637	18110	66	in	in	IN
18637	18110	67	violation	violation	NN
18637	18110	68	of	of	IN
18637	18110	69	local	local	JJ
18637	18110	70	law	law	NN
18637	18110	71	was	be	VBD
18637	18110	72	held	hold	VBN
18637	18110	73	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18110	74	.	.	.
18637	18111	1	State	State	NNP
18637	18111	2	Activities	Activities	NNPS
18637	18111	3	and	and	CC
18637	18111	4	Instrumentalities	Instrumentalities	NNPS
18637	18111	5	Today	Today	NNP
18637	18111	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18111	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	18111	8	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	18111	9	that	that	IN
18637	18111	10	the	the	DT
18637	18111	11	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18111	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18111	13	does	do	VBZ
18637	18111	14	not	not	RB
18637	18111	15	shield	shield	VB
18637	18111	16	the	the	DT
18637	18111	17	States	States	NNPS
18637	18111	18	nor	nor	CC
18637	18111	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18111	20	political	political	JJ
18637	18111	21	subdivisions	subdivision	NNS
18637	18111	22	from	from	IN
18637	18111	23	the	the	DT
18637	18111	24	impact	impact	NN
18637	18111	25	of	of	IN
18637	18111	26	the	the	DT
18637	18111	27	authority	authority	NN
18637	18111	28	affirmatively	affirmatively	RB
18637	18111	29	granted	grant	VBD
18637	18111	30	to	to	IN
18637	18111	31	the	the	DT
18637	18111	32	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18111	33	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18111	34	.	.	.
18637	18112	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18112	2	was	be	VBD
18637	18112	3	cited	cite	VBN
18637	18112	4	to	to	IN
18637	18112	5	no	no	DT
18637	18112	6	avail	avail	NN
18637	18112	7	in	in	IN
18637	18112	8	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18112	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18112	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	18112	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18112	12	Bowles,[38	Bowles,[38	NNP
18637	18112	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18112	14	where	where	WRB
18637	18112	15	a	a	DT
18637	18112	16	State	state	NN
18637	18112	17	officer	officer	NN
18637	18112	18	was	be	VBD
18637	18112	19	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	18112	20	from	from	IN
18637	18112	21	selling	sell	VBG
18637	18112	22	timber	timber	NN
18637	18112	23	on	on	IN
18637	18112	24	school	school	NN
18637	18112	25	lands	land	NNS
18637	18112	26	at	at	IN
18637	18112	27	a	a	DT
18637	18112	28	price	price	NN
18637	18112	29	in	in	IN
18637	18112	30	excess	excess	NN
18637	18112	31	of	of	IN
18637	18112	32	the	the	DT
18637	18112	33	maximum	maximum	NN
18637	18112	34	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	18112	35	by	by	IN
18637	18112	36	the	the	DT
18637	18112	37	Office	Office	NNP
18637	18112	38	of	of	IN
18637	18112	39	Price	Price	NNP
18637	18112	40	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	18112	41	.	.	.
18637	18113	1	When	when	WRB
18637	18113	2	California	California	NNP
18637	18113	3	violated	violate	VBD
18637	18113	4	the	the	DT
18637	18113	5	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18113	6	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	18113	7	Appliance	Appliance	NNP
18637	18113	8	Act	Act	NNP
18637	18113	9	in	in	IN
18637	18113	10	the	the	DT
18637	18113	11	operation	operation	NN
18637	18113	12	of	of	IN
18637	18113	13	the	the	DT
18637	18113	14	State	State	NNP
18637	18113	15	Belt	Belt	NNP
18637	18113	16	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	18113	17	as	as	IN
18637	18113	18	a	a	DT
18637	18113	19	common	common	JJ
18637	18113	20	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18113	21	in	in	IN
18637	18113	22	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	18113	23	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	18113	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18113	25	was	be	VBD
18637	18113	26	held	hold	VBN
18637	18113	27	liable	liable	JJ
18637	18113	28	for	for	IN
18637	18113	29	the	the	DT
18637	18113	30	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	18113	31	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	18113	32	.	.	.
18637	18114	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18114	2	39	39	CD
18637	18114	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18114	4	At	at	IN
18637	18114	5	the	the	DT
18637	18114	6	suit	suit	NN
18637	18114	7	of	of	IN
18637	18114	8	the	the	DT
18637	18114	9	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	18114	10	General	General	NNP
18637	18114	11	of	of	IN
18637	18114	12	the	the	DT
18637	18114	13	United	United	NNP
18637	18114	14	States	States	NNP
18637	18114	15	,	,	,
18637	18114	16	the	the	DT
18637	18114	17	Sanitary	Sanitary	NNP
18637	18114	18	District	District	NNP
18637	18114	19	of	of	IN
18637	18114	20	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	18114	21	was	be	VBD
18637	18114	22	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	18114	23	from	from	IN
18637	18114	24	diverting	divert	VBG
18637	18114	25	water	water	NN
18637	18114	26	from	from	IN
18637	18114	27	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	18114	28	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	18114	29	in	in	IN
18637	18114	30	excess	excess	NN
18637	18114	31	of	of	IN
18637	18114	32	a	a	DT
18637	18114	33	specified	specify	VBN
18637	18114	34	rate	rate	NN
18637	18114	35	.	.	.
18637	18115	1	On	on	IN
18637	18115	2	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	18115	3	of	of	IN
18637	18115	4	a	a	DT
18637	18115	5	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	18115	6	court	court	NN
18637	18115	7	,	,	,
18637	18115	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18115	9	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	18115	10	wrote	write	VBD
18637	18115	11	:	:	:
18637	18115	12	"	"	``
18637	18115	13	This	this	DT
18637	18115	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	18115	15	not	not	RB
18637	18115	16	a	a	DT
18637	18115	17	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	18115	18	among	among	IN
18637	18115	19	equals	equal	NNS
18637	18115	20	.	.	.
18637	18116	1	The	the	DT
18637	18116	2	United	United	NNP
18637	18116	3	States	States	NNP
18637	18116	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	18116	5	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	18116	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18116	7	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	18116	8	power	power	NN
18637	18116	9	to	to	TO
18637	18116	10	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	18116	11	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18116	12	and	and	CC
18637	18116	13	to	to	TO
18637	18116	14	control	control	VB
18637	18116	15	the	the	DT
18637	18116	16	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	18116	17	waters	water	NNS
18637	18116	18	within	within	IN
18637	18116	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18116	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18116	21	.	.	.
18637	18117	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18117	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18117	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18117	4	There	there	EX
18637	18117	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	18117	6	no	no	DT
18637	18117	7	question	question	NN
18637	18117	8	that	that	IN
18637	18117	9	this	this	DT
18637	18117	10	power	power	NN
18637	18117	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	18117	12	superior	superior	JJ
18637	18117	13	to	to	IN
18637	18117	14	that	that	DT
18637	18117	15	of	of	IN
18637	18117	16	the	the	DT
18637	18117	17	States	States	NNPS
18637	18117	18	to	to	TO
18637	18117	19	provide	provide	VB
18637	18117	20	for	for	IN
18637	18117	21	the	the	DT
18637	18117	22	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	18117	23	or	or	CC
18637	18117	24	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	18117	25	of	of	IN
18637	18117	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18117	27	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	18117	28	.	.	.
18637	18118	1	"	"	``
18637	18118	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18118	3	40	40	CD
18637	18118	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18118	5	Some	some	DT
18637	18118	6	years	year	NNS
18637	18118	7	earlier	early	RBR
18637	18118	8	,	,	,
18637	18118	9	in	in	IN
18637	18118	10	a	a	DT
18637	18118	11	suit	suit	NN
18637	18118	12	brought	bring	VBN
18637	18118	13	by	by	IN
18637	18118	14	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	18118	15	to	to	TO
18637	18118	16	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18118	17	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	18118	18	from	from	IN
18637	18118	19	using	use	VBG
18637	18118	20	the	the	DT
18637	18118	21	waters	water	NNS
18637	18118	22	of	of	IN
18637	18118	23	the	the	DT
18637	18118	24	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	18118	25	River	River	NNP
18637	18118	26	for	for	IN
18637	18118	27	irrigation	irrigation	NN
18637	18118	28	,	,	,
18637	18118	29	the	the	DT
18637	18118	30	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	18118	31	General	General	NNP
18637	18118	32	of	of	IN
18637	18118	33	the	the	DT
18637	18118	34	United	United	NNP
18637	18118	35	States	States	NNP
18637	18118	36	had	have	VBD
18637	18118	37	unsuccessfully	unsuccessfully	RB
18637	18118	38	advanced	advance	VBN
18637	18118	39	the	the	DT
18637	18118	40	claim	claim	NN
18637	18118	41	that	that	IN
18637	18118	42	the	the	DT
18637	18118	43	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18118	44	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18118	45	had	have	VBD
18637	18118	46	an	an	DT
18637	18118	47	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	18118	48	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18118	49	authority	authority	NN
18637	18118	50	to	to	TO
18637	18118	51	deal	deal	VB
18637	18118	52	with	with	IN
18637	18118	53	the	the	DT
18637	18118	54	matter	matter	NN
18637	18118	55	.	.	.
18637	18119	1	In	in	IN
18637	18119	2	a	a	DT
18637	18119	3	petition	petition	NN
18637	18119	4	to	to	TO
18637	18119	5	intervene	intervene	VB
18637	18119	6	in	in	IN
18637	18119	7	the	the	DT
18637	18119	8	suit	suit	NN
18637	18119	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18119	10	had	have	VBD
18637	18119	11	taken	take	VBN
18637	18119	12	the	the	DT
18637	18119	13	position	position	NN
18637	18119	14	,	,	,
18637	18119	15	as	as	IN
18637	18119	16	summarized	summarize	VBN
18637	18119	17	by	by	IN
18637	18119	18	the	the	DT
18637	18119	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	18119	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18119	21	,	,	,
18637	18119	22	that	that	IN
18637	18119	23	"	"	``
18637	18119	24	the	the	DT
18637	18119	25	National	National	NNP
18637	18119	26	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18119	27	*	*	NFP
18637	18119	28	*	*	NFP
18637	18119	29	*	*	NFP
18637	18119	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	18119	31	the	the	DT
18637	18119	32	right	right	NN
18637	18119	33	to	to	TO
18637	18119	34	make	make	VB
18637	18119	35	such	such	JJ
18637	18119	36	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18119	37	provision	provision	NN
18637	18119	38	as	as	IN
18637	18119	39	in	in	IN
18637	18119	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18119	41	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18119	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	18119	43	needful	needful	JJ
18637	18119	44	for	for	IN
18637	18119	45	the	the	DT
18637	18119	46	reclamation	reclamation	NN
18637	18119	47	of	of	IN
18637	18119	48	all	all	PDT
18637	18119	49	these	these	DT
18637	18119	50	arid	arid	JJ
18637	18119	51	lands	land	NNS
18637	18119	52	and	and	CC
18637	18119	53	for	for	IN
18637	18119	54	that	that	DT
18637	18119	55	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18119	56	to	to	TO
18637	18119	57	appropriate	appropriate	VB
18637	18119	58	the	the	DT
18637	18119	59	accessible	accessible	JJ
18637	18119	60	waters	water	NNS
18637	18119	61	.	.	.
18637	18120	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18120	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18120	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18120	4	All	all	DT
18637	18120	5	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18120	6	power	power	NN
18637	18120	7	must	must	MD
18637	18120	8	be	be	VB
18637	18120	9	vested	vest	VBN
18637	18120	10	in	in	IN
18637	18120	11	either	either	CC
18637	18120	12	the	the	DT
18637	18120	13	state	state	NN
18637	18120	14	or	or	CC
18637	18120	15	the	the	DT
18637	18120	16	National	National	NNP
18637	18120	17	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18120	18	;	;	:
18637	18120	19	no	no	DT
18637	18120	20	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18120	21	powers	power	NNS
18637	18120	22	belong	belong	VBP
18637	18120	23	to	to	IN
18637	18120	24	a	a	DT
18637	18120	25	state	state	NN
18637	18120	26	government	government	NN
18637	18120	27	other	other	JJ
18637	18120	28	than	than	IN
18637	18120	29	those	those	DT
18637	18120	30	which	which	WDT
18637	18120	31	affect	affect	VBP
18637	18120	32	solely	solely	RB
18637	18120	33	the	the	DT
18637	18120	34	internal	internal	JJ
18637	18120	35	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	18120	36	of	of	IN
18637	18120	37	that	that	DT
18637	18120	38	State	state	NN
18637	18120	39	;	;	:
18637	18120	40	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	18120	41	all	all	DT
18637	18120	42	powers	power	NNS
18637	18120	43	which	which	WDT
18637	18120	44	are	be	VBP
18637	18120	45	national	national	JJ
18637	18120	46	in	in	IN
18637	18120	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18120	48	scope	scope	NN
18637	18120	49	must	must	MD
18637	18120	50	be	be	VB
18637	18120	51	found	find	VBN
18637	18120	52	vested	vest	VBN
18637	18120	53	in	in	IN
18637	18120	54	the	the	DT
18637	18120	55	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18120	56	of	of	IN
18637	18120	57	the	the	DT
18637	18120	58	United	United	NNP
18637	18120	59	States	States	NNP
18637	18120	60	.	.	.
18637	18121	1	"	"	``
18637	18121	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18121	3	41	41	CD
18637	18121	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18121	5	The	the	DT
18637	18121	6	petition	petition	NN
18637	18121	7	to	to	TO
18637	18121	8	intervene	intervene	VB
18637	18121	9	was	be	VBD
18637	18121	10	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
18637	18121	11	on	on	IN
18637	18121	12	the	the	DT
18637	18121	13	ground	ground	NN
18637	18121	14	that	that	IN
18637	18121	15	the	the	DT
18637	18121	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	18121	17	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	18121	18	for	for	IN
18637	18121	19	the	the	DT
18637	18121	20	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18121	21	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18121	22	was	be	VBD
18637	18121	23	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
18637	18121	24	with	with	IN
18637	18121	25	the	the	DT
18637	18121	26	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18121	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18121	28	;	;	:
18637	18121	29	but	but	CC
18637	18121	30	this	this	DT
18637	18121	31	could	could	MD
18637	18121	32	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	18121	33	happen	happen	VB
18637	18121	34	today	today	NN
18637	18121	35	.	.	.
18637	18122	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18122	2	42	42	CD
18637	18122	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18122	4	Under	under	IN
18637	18122	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18122	6	superior	superior	JJ
18637	18122	7	power	power	NN
18637	18122	8	of	of	IN
18637	18122	9	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	18122	10	domain	domain	NN
18637	18122	11	,	,	,
18637	18122	12	the	the	DT
18637	18122	13	United	United	NNP
18637	18122	14	States	States	NNP
18637	18122	15	may	may	MD
18637	18122	16	condemn	condemn	VB
18637	18122	17	land	land	NN
18637	18122	18	owned	own	VBN
18637	18122	19	by	by	IN
18637	18122	20	a	a	DT
18637	18122	21	State	State	NNP
18637	18122	22	even	even	RB
18637	18122	23	where	where	WRB
18637	18122	24	the	the	DT
18637	18122	25	taking	taking	NN
18637	18122	26	will	will	MD
18637	18122	27	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	18122	28	with	with	IN
18637	18122	29	the	the	DT
18637	18122	30	State	State	NNP
18637	18122	31	's	's	POS
18637	18122	32	own	own	JJ
18637	18122	33	project	project	NN
18637	18122	34	for	for	IN
18637	18122	35	water	water	NN
18637	18122	36	development	development	NN
18637	18122	37	and	and	CC
18637	18122	38	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	18122	39	.	.	.
18637	18123	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18123	2	43	43	CD
18637	18123	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18123	4	The	the	DT
18637	18123	5	rights	right	NNS
18637	18123	6	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	18123	7	to	to	IN
18637	18123	8	the	the	DT
18637	18123	9	States	state	NNS
18637	18123	10	are	be	VBP
18637	18123	11	not	not	RB
18637	18123	12	invaded	invade	VBN
18637	18123	13	by	by	IN
18637	18123	14	a	a	DT
18637	18123	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	18123	16	which	which	WDT
18637	18123	17	requires	require	VBZ
18637	18123	18	a	a	DT
18637	18123	19	reduction	reduction	NN
18637	18123	20	in	in	IN
18637	18123	21	the	the	DT
18637	18123	22	amount	amount	NN
18637	18123	23	of	of	IN
18637	18123	24	a	a	DT
18637	18123	25	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18123	26	grant	grant	NN
18637	18123	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	18123	28	in	in	IN
18637	18123	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	18123	30	aid	aid	NN
18637	18123	31	of	of	IN
18637	18123	32	the	the	DT
18637	18123	33	construction	construction	NN
18637	18123	34	of	of	IN
18637	18123	35	highways	highway	NNS
18637	18123	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	18123	37	failure	failure	NN
18637	18123	38	of	of	IN
18637	18123	39	a	a	DT
18637	18123	40	State	state	NN
18637	18123	41	to	to	TO
18637	18123	42	remove	remove	VB
18637	18123	43	from	from	IN
18637	18123	44	office	office	NN
18637	18123	45	a	a	DT
18637	18123	46	member	member	NN
18637	18123	47	of	of	IN
18637	18123	48	the	the	DT
18637	18123	49	State	State	NNP
18637	18123	50	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	18123	51	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18123	52	found	find	VBD
18637	18123	53	to	to	TO
18637	18123	54	have	have	VB
18637	18123	55	violated	violate	VBN
18637	18123	56	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18123	57	law	law	NN
18637	18123	58	by	by	IN
18637	18123	59	participating	participate	VBG
18637	18123	60	in	in	IN
18637	18123	61	a	a	DT
18637	18123	62	political	political	JJ
18637	18123	63	campaign	campaign	NN
18637	18123	64	.	.	.
18637	18124	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18124	2	44	44	CD
18637	18124	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18124	4	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	18124	5	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18124	6	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	18124	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	18124	8	been	be	VBN
18637	18124	9	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	18124	10	as	as	IN
18637	18124	11	an	an	DT
18637	18124	12	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18124	13	interference	interference	NN
18637	18124	14	with	with	IN
18637	18124	15	the	the	DT
18637	18124	16	prerogative	prerogative	NN
18637	18124	17	of	of	IN
18637	18124	18	the	the	DT
18637	18124	19	States	States	NNPS
18637	18124	20	to	to	TO
18637	18124	21	control	control	VB
18637	18124	22	the	the	DT
18637	18124	23	entities	entity	NNS
18637	18124	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18124	25	create	create	VBP
18637	18124	26	,	,	,
18637	18124	27	but	but	CC
18637	18124	28	the	the	DT
18637	18124	29	attack	attack	NN
18637	18124	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	18124	31	been	be	VBN
18637	18124	32	successful	successful	JJ
18637	18124	33	only	only	RB
18637	18124	34	once	once	RB
18637	18124	35	,	,	,
18637	18124	36	in	in	IN
18637	18124	37	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	18124	38	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18124	39	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	18124	40	and	and	CC
18637	18124	41	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	18124	42	Association	Association	NNP
18637	18124	43	_	_	NNP
18637	18124	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	18124	45	_	_	NNP
18637	18124	46	Cleary	Cleary	NNP
18637	18124	47	.	.	.
18637	18125	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18125	2	45	45	CD
18637	18125	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18125	4	There	there	RB
18637	18125	5	an	an	DT
18637	18125	6	act	act	NN
18637	18125	7	of	of	IN
18637	18125	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18125	9	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	18125	10	the	the	DT
18637	18125	11	conversion	conversion	NN
18637	18125	12	of	of	IN
18637	18125	13	State	State	NNP
18637	18125	14	building	building	NN
18637	18125	15	and	and	CC
18637	18125	16	loan	loan	NN
18637	18125	17	associations	association	NNS
18637	18125	18	without	without	IN
18637	18125	19	State	state	NN
18637	18125	20	consent	consent	NN
18637	18125	21	was	be	VBD
18637	18125	22	found	find	VBN
18637	18125	23	to	to	TO
18637	18125	24	contravene	contravene	VB
18637	18125	25	the	the	DT
18637	18125	26	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18125	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18125	28	.	.	.
18637	18126	1	Thirty	thirty	CD
18637	18126	2	years	year	NNS
18637	18126	3	earlier	early	RBR
18637	18126	4	,	,	,
18637	18126	5	in	in	IN
18637	18126	6	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	18126	7	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	18126	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18126	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18126	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	18126	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18126	12	United	United	NNP
18637	18126	13	States,[46	States,[46	NNP
18637	18126	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18126	15	a	a	DT
18637	18126	16	closely	closely	RB
18637	18126	17	divided	divide	VBN
18637	18126	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18126	19	had	have	VBD
18637	18126	20	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	18126	21	that	that	IN
18637	18126	22	this	this	DT
18637	18126	23	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18126	24	was	be	VBD
18637	18126	25	no	no	DT
18637	18126	26	barrier	barrier	NN
18637	18126	27	to	to	IN
18637	18126	28	the	the	DT
18637	18126	29	application	application	NN
18637	18126	30	of	of	IN
18637	18126	31	the	the	DT
18637	18126	32	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	18126	33	Antitrust	Antitrust	NNP
18637	18126	34	Act	Act	NNP
18637	18126	35	to	to	TO
18637	18126	36	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18126	37	one	one	CD
18637	18126	38	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18126	39	from	from	IN
18637	18126	40	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	18126	41	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18126	42	by	by	IN
18637	18126	43	means	mean	NNS
18637	18126	44	of	of	IN
18637	18126	45	stock	stock	NN
18637	18126	46	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	18126	47	in	in	IN
18637	18126	48	two	two	CD
18637	18126	49	competing	compete	VBG
18637	18126	50	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18126	51	.	.	.
18637	18127	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18127	2	announced	announce	VBD
18637	18127	3	the	the	DT
18637	18127	4	general	general	JJ
18637	18127	5	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	18127	6	that	that	WDT
18637	18127	7	:	:	:
18637	18127	8	"	"	``
18637	18127	9	No	no	DT
18637	18127	10	State	State	NNP
18637	18127	11	can	can	MD
18637	18127	12	,	,	,
18637	18127	13	by	by	IN
18637	18127	14	merely	merely	RB
18637	18127	15	creating	create	VBG
18637	18127	16	a	a	DT
18637	18127	17	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18127	18	,	,	,
18637	18127	19	or	or	CC
18637	18127	20	in	in	IN
18637	18127	21	any	any	DT
18637	18127	22	other	other	JJ
18637	18127	23	mode	mode	NN
18637	18127	24	,	,	,
18637	18127	25	project	project	VB
18637	18127	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18127	27	authority	authority	NN
18637	18127	28	into	into	IN
18637	18127	29	other	other	JJ
18637	18127	30	States	States	NNPS
18637	18127	31	,	,	,
18637	18127	32	and	and	CC
18637	18127	33	across	across	IN
18637	18127	34	the	the	DT
18637	18127	35	continent	continent	NN
18637	18127	36	,	,	,
18637	18127	37	so	so	IN
18637	18127	38	as	as	IN
18637	18127	39	to	to	TO
18637	18127	40	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18127	41	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18127	42	from	from	IN
18637	18127	43	exerting	exert	VBG
18637	18127	44	the	the	DT
18637	18127	45	power	power	NN
18637	18127	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18127	47	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	18127	48	under	under	IN
18637	18127	49	the	the	DT
18637	18127	50	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18127	51	over	over	IN
18637	18127	52	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	18127	53	and	and	CC
18637	18127	54	international	international	JJ
18637	18127	55	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18127	56	,	,	,
18637	18127	57	or	or	CC
18637	18127	58	so	so	RB
18637	18127	59	as	as	IN
18637	18127	60	to	to	TO
18637	18127	61	exempt	exempt	VB
18637	18127	62	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18127	63	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18127	64	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	18127	65	in	in	IN
18637	18127	66	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	18127	67	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18127	68	from	from	IN
18637	18127	69	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	18127	70	to	to	IN
18637	18127	71	any	any	DT
18637	18127	72	rule	rule	NN
18637	18127	73	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	18127	74	established	establish	VBN
18637	18127	75	by	by	IN
18637	18127	76	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18127	77	for	for	IN
18637	18127	78	such	such	JJ
18637	18127	79	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18127	80	.	.	.
18637	18128	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18128	2	can	can	MD
18637	18128	3	not	not	RB
18637	18128	4	be	be	VB
18637	18128	5	said	say	VBN
18637	18128	6	that	that	IN
18637	18128	7	any	any	DT
18637	18128	8	State	State	NNP
18637	18128	9	may	may	MD
18637	18128	10	give	give	VB
18637	18128	11	a	a	DT
18637	18128	12	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18128	13	,	,	,
18637	18128	14	created	create	VBN
18637	18128	15	under	under	IN
18637	18128	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18128	17	laws	law	NNS
18637	18128	18	,	,	,
18637	18128	19	authority	authority	NN
18637	18128	20	to	to	TO
18637	18128	21	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	18128	22	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	18128	23	or	or	CC
18637	18128	24	international	international	JJ
18637	18128	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18128	26	against	against	IN
18637	18128	27	the	the	DT
18637	18128	28	will	will	NN
18637	18128	29	of	of	IN
18637	18128	30	the	the	DT
18637	18128	31	nation	nation	NN
18637	18128	32	as	as	IN
18637	18128	33	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	18128	34	expressed	express	VBN
18637	18128	35	by	by	IN
18637	18128	36	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18128	37	.	.	.
18637	18129	1	Every	every	DT
18637	18129	2	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18129	3	created	create	VBN
18637	18129	4	by	by	IN
18637	18129	5	a	a	DT
18637	18129	6	State	state	NN
18637	18129	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	18129	8	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	18129	9	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18129	10	to	to	IN
18637	18129	11	the	the	DT
18637	18129	12	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	18129	13	law	law	NNP
18637	18129	14	of	of	IN
18637	18129	15	the	the	DT
18637	18129	16	land	land	NN
18637	18129	17	.	.	.
18637	18130	1	"	"	``
18637	18130	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18130	3	47	47	CD
18637	18130	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18130	5	Even	even	RB
18637	18130	6	a	a	DT
18637	18130	7	charter	charter	NN
18637	18130	8	contract	contract	NN
18637	18130	9	between	between	IN
18637	18130	10	a	a	DT
18637	18130	11	State	state	NN
18637	18130	12	and	and	CC
18637	18130	13	an	an	DT
18637	18130	14	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	18130	15	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18130	16	,	,	,
18637	18130	17	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	18130	18	the	the	DT
18637	18130	19	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18130	20	of	of	IN
18637	18130	21	the	the	DT
18637	18130	22	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18130	23	,	,	,
18637	18130	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	18130	25	no	no	DT
18637	18130	26	barrier	barrier	NN
18637	18130	27	to	to	IN
18637	18130	28	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18130	29	of	of	IN
18637	18130	30	an	an	DT
18637	18130	31	order	order	NN
18637	18130	32	of	of	IN
18637	18130	33	the	the	DT
18637	18130	34	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	18130	35	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	18130	36	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18130	37	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18130	38	an	an	DT
18637	18130	39	increase	increase	NN
18637	18130	40	in	in	IN
18637	18130	41	local	local	JJ
18637	18130	42	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18130	43	to	to	TO
18637	18130	44	remove	remove	VB
18637	18130	45	a	a	DT
18637	18130	46	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	18130	47	against	against	IN
18637	18130	48	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	18130	49	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	18130	50	.	.	.
18637	18131	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18131	2	48	48	CD
18637	18131	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18131	4	An	an	DT
18637	18131	5	order	order	NN
18637	18131	6	of	of	IN
18637	18131	7	the	the	DT
18637	18131	8	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18131	9	Power	Power	NNP
18637	18131	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18131	11	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	18131	12	the	the	DT
18637	18131	13	methods	method	NNS
18637	18131	14	of	of	IN
18637	18131	15	keeping	keep	VBG
18637	18131	16	the	the	DT
18637	18131	17	accounts	account	NNS
18637	18131	18	of	of	IN
18637	18131	19	an	an	DT
18637	18131	20	electric	electric	JJ
18637	18131	21	company	company	NN
18637	18131	22	was	be	VBD
18637	18131	23	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18131	24	over	over	IN
18637	18131	25	the	the	DT
18637	18131	26	objection	objection	NN
18637	18131	27	that	that	WDT
18637	18131	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18131	29	violated	violate	VBD
18637	18131	30	the	the	DT
18637	18131	31	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	18131	32	right	right	NN
18637	18131	33	of	of	IN
18637	18131	34	the	the	DT
18637	18131	35	States	States	NNPS
18637	18131	36	under	under	IN
18637	18131	37	the	the	DT
18637	18131	38	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	18131	39	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18131	40	.	.	.
18637	18132	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18132	2	49	49	CD
18637	18132	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18132	4	A	a	DT
18637	18132	5	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18132	6	objection	objection	NN
18637	18132	7	to	to	IN
18637	18132	8	the	the	DT
18637	18132	9	levy	levy	NN
18637	18132	10	of	of	IN
18637	18132	11	a	a	DT
18637	18132	12	special	special	JJ
18637	18132	13	surtax	surtax	NN
18637	18132	14	on	on	IN
18637	18132	15	any	any	DT
18637	18132	16	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18132	17	formed	form	VBN
18637	18132	18	or	or	CC
18637	18132	19	availed	availed	JJ
18637	18132	20	of	of	IN
18637	18132	21	to	to	TO
18637	18132	22	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18132	23	the	the	DT
18637	18132	24	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	18132	25	of	of	IN
18637	18132	26	a	a	DT
18637	18132	27	surtax	surtax	NN
18637	18132	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	18132	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18132	30	shareholders	shareholder	NNS
18637	18132	31	was	be	VBD
18637	18132	32	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	18132	33	,	,	,
18637	18132	34	since	since	IN
18637	18132	35	the	the	DT
18637	18132	36	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	18132	37	statute	statute	NN
18637	18132	38	did	do	VBD
18637	18132	39	not	not	RB
18637	18132	40	limit	limit	VB
18637	18132	41	in	in	IN
18637	18132	42	any	any	DT
18637	18132	43	way	way	NN
18637	18132	44	the	the	DT
18637	18132	45	power	power	NN
18637	18132	46	of	of	IN
18637	18132	47	the	the	DT
18637	18132	48	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18132	49	to	to	TO
18637	18132	50	declare	declare	VB
18637	18132	51	or	or	CC
18637	18132	52	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	18132	53	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	18132	54	as	as	IN
18637	18132	55	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	18132	56	by	by	IN
18637	18132	57	State	State	NNP
18637	18132	58	law	law	NN
18637	18132	59	.	.	.
18637	18133	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18133	2	50	50	CD
18637	18133	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18133	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	18133	5	,	,	,
18637	18133	6	the	the	DT
18637	18133	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18133	8	held	hold	VBD
18637	18133	9	that	that	IN
18637	18133	10	the	the	DT
18637	18133	11	failure	failure	NN
18637	18133	12	to	to	TO
18637	18133	13	allow	allow	VB
18637	18133	14	a	a	DT
18637	18133	15	credit	credit	NN
18637	18133	16	against	against	IN
18637	18133	17	the	the	DT
18637	18133	18	undistributed	undistributed	JJ
18637	18133	19	profits	profit	NNS
18637	18133	20	tax	tax	NN
18637	18133	21	for	for	IN
18637	18133	22	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	18133	23	which	which	WDT
18637	18133	24	could	could	MD
18637	18133	25	not	not	RB
18637	18133	26	be	be	VB
18637	18133	27	distributed	distribute	VBN
18637	18133	28	under	under	IN
18637	18133	29	State	State	NNP
18637	18133	30	law	law	NN
18637	18133	31	did	do	VBD
18637	18133	32	not	not	RB
18637	18133	33	infringe	infringe	VB
18637	18133	34	the	the	DT
18637	18133	35	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	18133	36	power	power	NN
18637	18133	37	of	of	IN
18637	18133	38	the	the	DT
18637	18133	39	State	State	NNP
18637	18133	40	over	over	IN
18637	18133	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18133	42	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	18133	43	offspring	offspring	NN
18637	18133	44	.	.	.
18637	18134	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18134	2	51	51	CD
18637	18134	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18134	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	18134	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18134	6	1	1	CD
18637	18134	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18134	8	United	United	NNP
18637	18134	9	States	States	NNP
18637	18134	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18134	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	18134	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18134	13	Sprague	Sprague	NNP
18637	18134	14	,	,	,
18637	18134	15	282	282	CD
18637	18134	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18134	17	716	716	CD
18637	18134	18	,	,	,
18637	18134	19	733	733	CD
18637	18134	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18134	21	1931	1931	CD
18637	18134	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18134	23	.	.	.
18637	18135	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18135	2	2	2	CD
18637	18135	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18135	4	II	II	NNP
18637	18135	5	Annals	Annals	NNPS
18637	18135	6	of	of	IN
18637	18135	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18135	8	1897	1897	CD
18637	18135	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18135	10	1791	1791	CD
18637	18135	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18135	12	.	.	.
18637	18136	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18136	2	3	3	CD
18637	18136	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18136	4	4	4	CD
18637	18136	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	18136	6	.	.	.
18637	18137	1	316	316	CD
18637	18137	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18137	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	18137	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18137	5	.	.	.
18637	18138	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18138	2	4	4	LS
18637	18138	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18138	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18138	5	.	.	.
18637	18139	1	372	372	CD
18637	18139	2	.	.	.
18637	18140	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18140	2	5	5	CD
18637	18140	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18140	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18140	5	.	.	.
18637	18141	1	406	406	CD
18637	18141	2	.	.	.
18637	18142	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18142	2	6	6	CD
18637	18142	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18142	4	11	11	CD
18637	18142	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	18142	6	.	.	.
18637	18143	1	113	113	CD
18637	18143	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18143	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	18143	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18143	5	.	.	.
18637	18144	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18144	2	7	7	CD
18637	18144	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18144	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18144	5	.	.	.
18637	18145	1	124	124	CD
18637	18145	2	.	.	.
18637	18146	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18146	2	8	8	CD
18637	18146	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18146	4	Graves	Graves	NNPS
18637	18146	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18146	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18146	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18146	8	O'Keefe	O'Keefe	NNP
18637	18146	9	,	,	,
18637	18146	10	306	306	CD
18637	18146	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18146	12	466	466	CD
18637	18146	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18146	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	18146	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18146	16	.	.	.
18637	18147	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18147	2	9	9	CD
18637	18147	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18147	4	326	326	CD
18637	18147	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18147	6	572	572	CD
18637	18147	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18147	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	18147	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18147	10	.	.	.
18637	18148	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18148	2	10	10	CD
18637	18148	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18148	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18148	5	.	.	.
18637	18149	1	589	589	CD
18637	18149	2	.	.	.
18637	18150	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18150	2	11	11	CD
18637	18150	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18150	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18150	5	.	.	.
18637	18151	1	584	584	CD
18637	18151	2	.	.	.
18637	18152	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18152	2	12	12	CD
18637	18152	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18152	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18152	5	.	.	.
18637	18153	1	595	595	CD
18637	18153	2	.	.	.
18637	18154	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18154	2	13	13	CD
18637	18154	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18154	4	United	United	NNP
18637	18154	5	States	States	NNP
18637	18154	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18154	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18154	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18154	9	Dewitt	Dewitt	NNP
18637	18154	10	,	,	,
18637	18154	11	9	9	CD
18637	18154	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	18154	13	.	.	.
18637	18155	1	41	41	CD
18637	18155	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18155	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	18155	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18155	5	.	.	.
18637	18156	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18156	2	14	14	CD
18637	18156	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18156	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18156	5	.	.	.
18637	18157	1	44	44	CD
18637	18157	2	.	.	.
18637	18158	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18158	2	15	15	CD
18637	18158	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18158	4	207	207	CD
18637	18158	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18158	6	463	463	CD
18637	18158	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18158	8	1908	1908	CD
18637	18158	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18158	10	.	.	.
18637	18159	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18159	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18159	3	also	also	RB
18637	18159	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18159	5	Keller	Keller	NNP
18637	18159	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18159	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18159	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18159	9	United	United	NNP
18637	18159	10	States	States	NNP
18637	18159	11	,	,	,
18637	18159	12	213	213	CD
18637	18159	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18159	14	138	138	CD
18637	18159	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18159	16	1909	1909	CD
18637	18159	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18159	18	.	.	.
18637	18160	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18160	2	16	16	CD
18637	18160	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18160	4	247	247	CD
18637	18160	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18160	6	251	251	CD
18637	18160	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18160	8	1918	1918	CD
18637	18160	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18160	10	.	.	.
18637	18161	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18161	2	17	17	CD
18637	18161	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18161	4	312	312	CD
18637	18161	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18161	6	100	100	CD
18637	18161	7	,	,	,
18637	18161	8	116	116	CD
18637	18161	9	,	,	,
18637	18161	10	117	117	CD
18637	18161	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18161	12	1941	1941	CD
18637	18161	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18161	14	.	.	.
18637	18162	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18162	2	18	18	CD
18637	18162	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18162	4	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	18162	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18162	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18162	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18162	8	Drexel	Drexel	NNP
18637	18162	9	Furniture	Furniture	NNP
18637	18162	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18162	11	,	,	,
18637	18162	12	259	259	CD
18637	18162	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18162	14	20	20	CD
18637	18162	15	,	,	,
18637	18162	16	36	36	CD
18637	18162	17	,	,	,
18637	18162	18	38	38	CD
18637	18162	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18162	20	1922	1922	CD
18637	18162	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18162	22	.	.	.
18637	18163	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18163	2	19	19	CD
18637	18163	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18163	4	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	18163	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18163	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18163	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18163	8	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	18163	9	,	,	,
18637	18163	10	259	259	CD
18637	18163	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18163	12	44	44	CD
18637	18163	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18163	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	18163	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18163	16	.	.	.
18637	18164	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18164	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18164	3	also	also	RB
18637	18164	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18164	5	Trusler	Trusler	NNP
18637	18164	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18164	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18164	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18164	9	Crooks	Crooks	NNP
18637	18164	10	,	,	,
18637	18164	11	269	269	CD
18637	18164	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18164	13	475	475	CD
18637	18164	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18164	15	1926	1926	CD
18637	18164	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18164	17	.	.	.
18637	18165	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18165	2	20	20	CD
18637	18165	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18165	4	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	18165	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18165	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18165	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18165	8	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	18165	9	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	18165	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18165	11	,	,	,
18637	18165	12	298	298	CD
18637	18165	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18165	14	238	238	CD
18637	18165	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18165	16	1936	1936	CD
18637	18165	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18165	18	.	.	.
18637	18166	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18166	2	21	21	CD
18637	18166	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18166	4	United	United	NNP
18637	18166	5	States	States	NNP
18637	18166	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18166	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18166	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18166	9	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	18166	10	,	,	,
18637	18166	11	297	297	CD
18637	18166	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18166	13	1	1	CD
18637	18166	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18166	15	1936	1936	CD
18637	18166	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18166	17	.	.	.
18637	18167	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18167	2	22	22	CD
18637	18167	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18167	4	295	295	CD
18637	18167	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18167	6	495	495	CD
18637	18167	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18167	8	1935	1935	CD
18637	18167	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18167	10	.	.	.
18637	18168	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18168	2	23	23	CD
18637	18168	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18168	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18168	5	.	.	.
18637	18169	1	529	529	CD
18637	18169	2	.	.	.
18637	18170	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18170	2	24	24	CD
18637	18170	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18170	4	Steward	Steward	NNP
18637	18170	5	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	18170	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18170	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18170	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18170	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18170	10	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	18170	11	,	,	,
18637	18170	12	301	301	CD
18637	18170	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18170	14	548	548	CD
18637	18170	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18170	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	18170	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18170	18	;	;	:
18637	18170	19	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	18170	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18170	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	18170	22	_	_	NNP
18637	18170	23	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	18170	24	,	,	,
18637	18170	25	301	301	CD
18637	18170	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18170	27	619	619	CD
18637	18170	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18170	29	1937	1937	CD
18637	18170	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18170	31	.	.	.
18637	18171	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18171	2	25	25	CD
18637	18171	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18171	4	National	National	NNP
18637	18171	5	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	18171	6	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	18171	7	Board	Board	NNP
18637	18171	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18171	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	18171	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18171	11	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	18171	12	&	&	CC
18637	18171	13	Laughlin	Laughlin	NNP
18637	18171	14	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	18171	15	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	18171	16	,	,	,
18637	18171	17	301	301	CD
18637	18171	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18171	19	1	1	CD
18637	18171	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18171	21	1937	1937	CD
18637	18171	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18171	23	.	.	.
18637	18172	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18172	2	26	26	CD
18637	18172	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18172	4	312	312	CD
18637	18172	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18172	6	100	100	CD
18637	18172	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18172	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	18172	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18172	10	.	.	.
18637	18173	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18173	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18173	3	also	also	RB
18637	18173	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18173	5	United	United	NNP
18637	18173	6	States	States	NNP
18637	18173	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18173	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18173	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18173	10	Carolene	Carolene	NNP
18637	18173	11	Products	Products	NNP
18637	18173	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18173	13	,	,	,
18637	18173	14	304	304	CD
18637	18173	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18173	16	144	144	CD
18637	18173	17	,	,	,
18637	18173	18	147	147	CD
18637	18173	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18173	20	1938	1938	CD
18637	18173	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18173	22	;	;	:
18637	18173	23	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18173	24	_	_	NNP
18637	18173	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	18173	26	_	_	NNP
18637	18173	27	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	18173	28	,	,	,
18637	18173	29	327	327	CD
18637	18173	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18173	31	92	92	CD
18637	18173	32	,	,	,
18637	18173	33	101	101	CD
18637	18173	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18173	35	1946	1946	CD
18637	18173	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18173	37	.	.	.
18637	18174	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18174	2	27	27	CD
18637	18174	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18174	4	312	312	CD
18637	18174	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18174	6	100	100	CD
18637	18174	7	,	,	,
18637	18174	8	114	114	CD
18637	18174	9	,	,	,
18637	18174	10	123	123	CD
18637	18174	11	,	,	,
18637	18174	12	124	124	CD
18637	18174	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18174	14	1941	1941	CD
18637	18174	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18174	16	.	.	.
18637	18175	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18175	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18175	3	also	also	RB
18637	18175	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18175	5	Fernandez	Fernandez	NNP
18637	18175	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18175	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18175	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18175	9	Wiener	Wiener	NNP
18637	18175	10	,	,	,
18637	18175	11	326	326	CD
18637	18175	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18175	13	340	340	CD
18637	18175	14	,	,	,
18637	18175	15	362	362	CD
18637	18175	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18175	17	1945	1945	CD
18637	18175	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18175	19	.	.	.
18637	18176	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18176	2	28	28	CD
18637	18176	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18176	4	251	251	CD
18637	18176	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18176	6	146	146	CD
18637	18176	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18176	8	1919	1919	CD
18637	18176	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18176	10	.	.	.
18637	18177	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18177	2	29	29	CD
18637	18177	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18177	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18177	5	.	.	.
18637	18178	1	156	156	CD
18637	18178	2	.	.	.
18637	18179	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18179	2	30	30	CD
18637	18179	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18179	4	Champion	Champion	NNP
18637	18179	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18179	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18179	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18179	8	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	18179	9	,	,	,
18637	18179	10	188	188	CD
18637	18179	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18179	12	321	321	CD
18637	18179	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18179	14	1903	1903	CD
18637	18179	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18179	16	.	.	.
18637	18180	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18180	2	31	31	CD
18637	18180	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18180	4	Hoke	Hoke	NNP
18637	18180	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18180	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18180	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18180	8	United	United	NNP
18637	18180	9	States	States	NNP
18637	18180	10	,	,	,
18637	18180	11	227	227	CD
18637	18180	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18180	13	308	308	CD
18637	18180	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18180	15	1913	1913	CD
18637	18180	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18180	17	.	.	.
18637	18181	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18181	2	32	32	CD
18637	18181	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18181	4	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
18637	18181	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18181	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18181	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18181	8	United	United	NNP
18637	18181	9	States	States	NNP
18637	18181	10	,	,	,
18637	18181	11	267	267	CD
18637	18181	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18181	13	432	432	CD
18637	18181	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18181	15	1925	1925	CD
18637	18181	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18181	17	.	.	.
18637	18182	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18182	2	33	33	CD
18637	18182	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18182	4	Thornton	Thornton	NNP
18637	18182	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18182	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18182	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18182	8	United	United	NNP
18637	18182	9	States	States	NNP
18637	18182	10	,	,	,
18637	18182	11	271	271	CD
18637	18182	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18182	13	414	414	CD
18637	18182	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18182	15	1926	1926	CD
18637	18182	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18182	17	.	.	.
18637	18183	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18183	2	34	34	CD
18637	18183	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18183	4	United	United	NNP
18637	18183	5	States	States	NNP
18637	18183	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18183	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18183	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18183	9	Ferger	Ferger	NNP
18637	18183	10	,	,	,
18637	18183	11	250	250	CD
18637	18183	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18183	13	199	199	CD
18637	18183	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18183	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	18183	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18183	17	.	.	.
18637	18184	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18184	2	35	35	CD
18637	18184	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18184	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	18184	5	Whip	Whip	NNP
18637	18184	6	&	&	CC
18637	18184	7	Collar	Collar	NNP
18637	18184	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18184	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18184	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	18184	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18184	12	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	18184	13	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	18185	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18185	2	,	,	,
18637	18185	3	299	299	CD
18637	18185	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18185	5	334	334	CD
18637	18185	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18185	7	1937	1937	CD
18637	18185	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18185	9	.	.	.
18637	18186	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18186	2	36	36	CD
18637	18186	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18186	4	Everhard	Everhard	NNP
18637	18186	5	's	's	POS
18637	18186	6	Breweries	Breweries	NNP
18637	18186	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18186	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18186	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18186	10	Day	Day	NNP
18637	18186	11	,	,	,
18637	18186	12	265	265	CD
18637	18186	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18186	14	545	545	CD
18637	18186	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18186	16	1924	1924	CD
18637	18186	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18186	18	.	.	.
18637	18187	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18187	2	37	37	CD
18637	18187	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18187	4	296	296	CD
18637	18187	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18187	6	287	287	CD
18637	18187	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18187	8	1935	1935	CD
18637	18187	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18187	10	.	.	.
18637	18188	1	The	the	DT
18637	18188	2	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	18188	3	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	18188	4	Act	Act	NNP
18637	18188	5	of	of	IN
18637	18188	6	1875	1875	CD
18637	18188	7	,	,	,
18637	18188	8	which	which	WDT
18637	18188	9	made	make	VBD
18637	18188	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18188	11	a	a	DT
18637	18188	12	crime	crime	NN
18637	18188	13	for	for	IN
18637	18188	14	one	one	CD
18637	18188	15	person	person	NN
18637	18188	16	to	to	TO
18637	18188	17	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	18188	18	another	another	DT
18637	18188	19	of	of	IN
18637	18188	20	equal	equal	JJ
18637	18188	21	accommodations	accommodation	NNS
18637	18188	22	at	at	IN
18637	18188	23	inns	inn	NNS
18637	18188	24	,	,	,
18637	18188	25	theaters	theater	NNS
18637	18188	26	or	or	CC
18637	18188	27	public	public	JJ
18637	18188	28	conveyances	conveyance	NNS
18637	18188	29	was	be	VBD
18637	18188	30	found	find	VBN
18637	18188	31	to	to	TO
18637	18188	32	exceed	exceed	VB
18637	18188	33	the	the	DT
18637	18188	34	powers	power	NNS
18637	18188	35	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	18188	36	on	on	IN
18637	18188	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18188	38	by	by	IN
18637	18188	39	the	the	DT
18637	18188	40	Thirteenth	Thirteenth	NNP
18637	18188	41	and	and	CC
18637	18188	42	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18188	43	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	18188	44	,	,	,
18637	18188	45	and	and	CC
18637	18188	46	hence	hence	RB
18637	18188	47	to	to	TO
18637	18188	48	be	be	VB
18637	18188	49	an	an	DT
18637	18188	50	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	18188	51	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	18188	52	of	of	IN
18637	18188	53	the	the	DT
18637	18188	54	powers	power	NNS
18637	18188	55	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	18188	56	to	to	IN
18637	18188	57	the	the	DT
18637	18188	58	States	States	NNP
18637	18188	59	by	by	IN
18637	18188	60	the	the	DT
18637	18188	61	Tenth	tenth	JJ
18637	18188	62	--	--	:
18637	18188	63	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	18188	64	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	18188	65	Cases	case	NNS
18637	18188	66	,	,	,
18637	18188	67	109	109	CD
18637	18188	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18188	69	3	3	CD
18637	18188	70	,	,	,
18637	18188	71	15	15	CD
18637	18188	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18188	73	1883	1883	CD
18637	18188	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18188	75	.	.	.
18637	18189	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18189	2	38	38	CD
18637	18189	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18189	4	327	327	CD
18637	18189	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18189	6	92	92	CD
18637	18189	7	,	,	,
18637	18189	8	102	102	CD
18637	18189	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18189	10	1946	1946	CD
18637	18189	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18189	12	.	.	.
18637	18190	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18190	2	39	39	CD
18637	18190	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18190	4	United	United	NNP
18637	18190	5	States	States	NNP
18637	18190	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18190	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18190	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18190	9	California	California	NNP
18637	18190	10	,	,	,
18637	18190	11	297	297	CD
18637	18190	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18190	13	175	175	CD
18637	18190	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18190	15	1936	1936	CD
18637	18190	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18190	17	.	.	.
18637	18191	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18191	2	40	40	CD
18637	18191	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18191	4	Sanitary	Sanitary	NNP
18637	18191	5	District	District	NNP
18637	18191	6	of	of	IN
18637	18191	7	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	18191	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18191	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	18191	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18191	11	United	United	NNP
18637	18191	12	States	States	NNP
18637	18191	13	,	,	,
18637	18191	14	266	266	CD
18637	18191	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18191	16	405	405	CD
18637	18191	17	,	,	,
18637	18191	18	425	425	CD
18637	18191	19	,	,	,
18637	18191	20	426	426	CD
18637	18191	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18191	22	1925	1925	CD
18637	18191	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18191	24	.	.	.
18637	18192	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18192	2	41	41	CD
18637	18192	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18192	4	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	18192	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18192	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18192	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18192	8	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	18192	9	,	,	,
18637	18192	10	206	206	CD
18637	18192	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18192	12	46	46	CD
18637	18192	13	,	,	,
18637	18192	14	87	87	CD
18637	18192	15	,	,	,
18637	18192	16	89	89	CD
18637	18192	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18192	18	1907	1907	CD
18637	18192	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18192	20	.	.	.
18637	18193	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18193	2	42	42	CD
18637	18193	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18193	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18193	5	See	See	NNP
18637	18193	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18193	7	United	United	NNP
18637	18193	8	States	States	NNP
18637	18193	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18193	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	18193	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18193	12	Appalachian	Appalachian	NNP
18637	18193	13	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	18193	14	Power	Power	NNP
18637	18193	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18193	16	,	,	,
18637	18193	17	311	311	CD
18637	18193	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18193	19	377	377	CD
18637	18193	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18193	21	1940	1940	CD
18637	18193	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18193	23	.	.	.
18637	18194	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18194	2	43	43	CD
18637	18194	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18194	4	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	18194	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18194	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18194	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18194	8	Atkinson	Atkinson	NNP
18637	18194	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18194	10	,	,	,
18637	18194	11	313	313	CD
18637	18194	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18194	13	508	508	CD
18637	18194	14	,	,	,
18637	18194	15	534	534	CD
18637	18194	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18194	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	18194	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18194	19	.	.	.
18637	18195	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18195	2	44	44	CD
18637	18195	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18195	4	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	18195	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18195	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18195	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18195	8	United	United	NNP
18637	18195	9	States	States	NNP
18637	18195	10	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	18195	11	Service	Service	NNP
18637	18195	12	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18195	13	,	,	,
18637	18195	14	330	330	CD
18637	18195	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18195	16	127	127	CD
18637	18195	17	,	,	,
18637	18195	18	142	142	CD
18637	18195	19	-	-	SYM
18637	18195	20	144	144	CD
18637	18195	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18195	22	1947	1947	CD
18637	18195	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18195	24	.	.	.
18637	18196	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18196	2	45	45	CD
18637	18196	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18196	4	296	296	CD
18637	18196	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18196	6	315	315	CD
18637	18196	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18196	8	1935	1935	CD
18637	18196	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18196	10	.	.	.
18637	18197	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18197	2	46	46	CD
18637	18197	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18197	4	193	193	CD
18637	18197	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18197	6	197	197	CD
18637	18197	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18197	8	1904	1904	CD
18637	18197	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18197	10	.	.	.
18637	18198	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18198	2	47	47	CD
18637	18198	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18198	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18198	5	.	.	.
18637	18199	1	345	345	CD
18637	18199	2	,	,	,
18637	18199	3	346	346	CD
18637	18199	4	.	.	.
18637	18200	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18200	2	48	48	CD
18637	18200	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18200	4	New	New	NNP
18637	18200	5	York	York	NNP
18637	18200	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18200	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18200	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18200	9	United	United	NNP
18637	18200	10	States	States	NNP
18637	18200	11	,	,	,
18637	18200	12	257	257	CD
18637	18200	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18200	14	591	591	CD
18637	18200	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18200	16	1922	1922	CD
18637	18200	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18200	18	.	.	.
18637	18201	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18201	2	49	49	CD
18637	18201	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18201	4	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	18201	5	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	18201	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18201	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18201	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18201	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18201	10	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18201	11	Power	Power	NNP
18637	18201	12	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18201	13	,	,	,
18637	18201	14	321	321	CD
18637	18201	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18201	16	119	119	CD
18637	18201	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18201	18	1944	1944	CD
18637	18201	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18201	20	.	.	.
18637	18202	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18202	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18202	3	also	also	RB
18637	18202	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18202	5	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18202	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	18202	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18202	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18202	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	18202	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18202	11	East	East	NNP
18637	18202	12	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	18202	13	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	18202	14	Company	Company	NNP
18637	18202	15	,	,	,
18637	18202	16	338	338	CD
18637	18202	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18202	18	404	404	CD
18637	18202	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18202	20	1950	1950	CD
18637	18202	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18202	22	.	.	.
18637	18203	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18203	2	50	50	CD
18637	18203	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18203	4	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	18203	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18203	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18203	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18203	8	National	National	NNP
18637	18203	9	Grocery	Grocery	NNP
18637	18203	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18203	11	,	,	,
18637	18203	12	304	304	CD
18637	18203	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18203	14	282	282	CD
18637	18203	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18203	16	1938	1938	CD
18637	18203	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18203	18	.	.	.
18637	18204	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18204	2	51	51	CD
18637	18204	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18204	4	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	18204	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18204	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18204	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18204	8	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	18204	9	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	18204	10	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	18204	11	,	,	,
18637	18204	12	311	311	CD
18637	18204	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18204	14	46	46	CD
18637	18204	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18204	16	1940	1940	CD
18637	18204	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18204	18	.	.	.
18637	18205	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	18205	2	11	11	CD
18637	18205	3	SUITS	suits	JJ
18637	18205	4	AGAINST	against	IN
18637	18205	5	STATES	state	NNS
18637	18205	6	Page	Page	NNP
18637	18205	7	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	18205	8	and	and	CC
18637	18205	9	early	early	JJ
18637	18205	10	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	18205	11	929	929	CD
18637	18205	12	Expansion	expansion	NN
18637	18205	13	of	of	IN
18637	18205	14	state	state	NN
18637	18205	15	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	18205	16	930	930	CD
18637	18205	17	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	18205	18	against	against	IN
18637	18205	19	state	state	NN
18637	18205	20	officials	official	NNS
18637	18205	21	:	:	:
18637	18205	22	two	two	CD
18637	18205	23	categories	category	NNS
18637	18205	24	930	930	CD
18637	18205	25	Mandamus	Mandamus	NNP
18637	18205	26	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18205	27	932	932	CD
18637	18205	28	Early	early	JJ
18637	18205	29	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	18205	30	on	on	IN
18637	18205	31	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	18205	32	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18205	33	932	932	CD
18637	18205	34	Injunction	Injunction	NNP
18637	18205	35	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18205	36	today	today	NN
18637	18205	37	:	:	:
18637	18205	38	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	18205	39	parte	parte	NN
18637	18205	40	Young	Young	NNP
18637	18205	41	933	933	CD
18637	18205	42	Tort	tort	NN
18637	18205	43	action	action	NN
18637	18205	44	against	against	IN
18637	18205	45	state	state	NN
18637	18205	46	officials	official	NNS
18637	18205	47	934	934	CD
18637	18205	48	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	18205	49	to	to	TO
18637	18205	50	recover	recover	VB
18637	18205	51	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18205	52	935	935	CD
18637	18205	53	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	18205	54	of	of	IN
18637	18205	55	State	State	NNP
18637	18205	56	to	to	TO
18637	18205	57	be	be	VB
18637	18205	58	sued	sue	VBN
18637	18205	59	935	935	CD
18637	18205	60	Waiver	Waiver	NNP
18637	18205	61	of	of	IN
18637	18205	62	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	18205	63	936	936	CD
18637	18205	64	SUITS	SUITS	NNP
18637	18205	65	AGAINST	against	IN
18637	18205	66	STATES	state	NNS
18637	18205	67	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18205	68	11	11	CD
18637	18205	69	The	the	DT
18637	18205	70	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18205	71	power	power	NN
18637	18205	72	of	of	IN
18637	18205	73	the	the	DT
18637	18205	74	United	United	NNP
18637	18205	75	States	States	NNP
18637	18205	76	shall	shall	MD
18637	18205	77	not	not	RB
18637	18205	78	be	be	VB
18637	18205	79	construed	construe	VBN
18637	18205	80	to	to	TO
18637	18205	81	extend	extend	VB
18637	18205	82	to	to	IN
18637	18205	83	any	any	DT
18637	18205	84	suit	suit	NN
18637	18205	85	in	in	IN
18637	18205	86	law	law	NN
18637	18205	87	or	or	CC
18637	18205	88	equity	equity	NN
18637	18205	89	,	,	,
18637	18205	90	commenced	commence	VBD
18637	18205	91	or	or	CC
18637	18205	92	prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
18637	18205	93	against	against	IN
18637	18205	94	one	one	CD
18637	18205	95	of	of	IN
18637	18205	96	the	the	DT
18637	18205	97	United	United	NNP
18637	18205	98	States	States	NNP
18637	18205	99	by	by	IN
18637	18205	100	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	18205	101	of	of	IN
18637	18205	102	another	another	DT
18637	18205	103	State	state	NN
18637	18205	104	,	,	,
18637	18205	105	or	or	CC
18637	18205	106	by	by	IN
18637	18205	107	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	18205	108	or	or	CC
18637	18205	109	Subjects	Subjects	NNPS
18637	18205	110	of	of	IN
18637	18205	111	any	any	DT
18637	18205	112	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	18205	113	State	State	NNP
18637	18205	114	.	.	.
18637	18206	1	Purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18206	2	and	and	CC
18637	18206	3	Early	early	JJ
18637	18206	4	Interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	18206	5	The	the	DT
18637	18206	6	action	action	NN
18637	18206	7	of	of	IN
18637	18206	8	the	the	DT
18637	18206	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	18206	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18206	11	in	in	IN
18637	18206	12	accepting	accept	VBG
18637	18206	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18206	14	of	of	IN
18637	18206	15	a	a	DT
18637	18206	16	suit	suit	NN
18637	18206	17	against	against	IN
18637	18206	18	a	a	DT
18637	18206	19	State	state	NN
18637	18206	20	by	by	IN
18637	18206	21	a	a	DT
18637	18206	22	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18206	23	of	of	IN
18637	18206	24	another	another	DT
18637	18206	25	State	State	NNP
18637	18206	26	in	in	IN
18637	18206	27	1793	1793	CD
18637	18206	28	,	,	,
18637	18206	29	in	in	IN
18637	18206	30	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
18637	18206	31	_	_	NNP
18637	18206	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	18206	33	_	_	NNP
18637	18206	34	Georgia[1	Georgia[1	NNP
18637	18206	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18206	36	provoked	provoke	VBD
18637	18206	37	such	such	JJ
18637	18206	38	angry	angry	JJ
18637	18206	39	reactions	reaction	NNS
18637	18206	40	in	in	IN
18637	18206	41	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	18206	42	and	and	CC
18637	18206	43	such	such	JJ
18637	18206	44	anxieties	anxiety	NNS
18637	18206	45	in	in	IN
18637	18206	46	other	other	JJ
18637	18206	47	States	States	NNP
18637	18206	48	that	that	IN
18637	18206	49	at	at	IN
18637	18206	50	the	the	DT
18637	18206	51	first	first	JJ
18637	18206	52	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	18206	53	of	of	IN
18637	18206	54	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18206	55	after	after	IN
18637	18206	56	this	this	DT
18637	18206	57	decision	decision	NN
18637	18206	58	what	what	WP
18637	18206	59	became	become	VBD
18637	18206	60	the	the	DT
18637	18206	61	Eleventh	Eleventh	NNP
18637	18206	62	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18206	63	was	be	VBD
18637	18206	64	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	18206	65	by	by	IN
18637	18206	66	an	an	DT
18637	18206	67	overwhelming	overwhelming	JJ
18637	18206	68	vote	vote	NN
18637	18206	69	and	and	CC
18637	18206	70	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	18206	71	with	with	IN
18637	18206	72	"	"	``
18637	18206	73	vehement	vehement	JJ
18637	18206	74	speed	speed	NN
18637	18206	75	.	.	.
18637	18207	1	"	"	``
18637	18207	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18207	3	2	2	LS
18637	18207	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18207	5	The	the	DT
18637	18207	6	earliest	early	JJS
18637	18207	7	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	18207	8	interpretative	interpretative	JJ
18637	18207	9	of	of	IN
18637	18207	10	the	the	DT
18637	18207	11	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18207	12	were	be	VBD
18637	18207	13	three	three	CD
18637	18207	14	by	by	IN
18637	18207	15	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	18207	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18207	17	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	18207	18	.	.	.
18637	18208	1	In	in	IN
18637	18208	2	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	18208	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18208	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	18208	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18208	6	Virginia,[3	Virginia,[3	NNP
18637	18208	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18208	8	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	18208	9	for	for	IN
18637	18208	10	the	the	DT
18637	18208	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18208	12	,	,	,
18637	18208	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18208	14	held	hold	VBD
18637	18208	15	that	that	IN
18637	18208	16	the	the	DT
18637	18208	17	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	18208	18	of	of	IN
18637	18208	19	a	a	DT
18637	18208	20	writ	writ	NN
18637	18208	21	of	of	IN
18637	18208	22	error	error	NN
18637	18208	23	to	to	TO
18637	18208	24	review	review	VB
18637	18208	25	a	a	DT
18637	18208	26	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18208	27	of	of	IN
18637	18208	28	a	a	DT
18637	18208	29	State	State	NNP
18637	18208	30	court	court	NN
18637	18208	31	,	,	,
18637	18208	32	alleged	allege	VBD
18637	18208	33	to	to	TO
18637	18208	34	be	be	VB
18637	18208	35	in	in	IN
18637	18208	36	violation	violation	NN
18637	18208	37	of	of	IN
18637	18208	38	the	the	DT
18637	18208	39	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18208	40	or	or	CC
18637	18208	41	laws	law	NNS
18637	18208	42	of	of	IN
18637	18208	43	the	the	DT
18637	18208	44	United	United	NNP
18637	18208	45	States	States	NNP
18637	18208	46	,	,	,
18637	18208	47	"	"	``
18637	18208	48	does	do	VBZ
18637	18208	49	not	not	RB
18637	18208	50	commence	commence	VB
18637	18208	51	or	or	CC
18637	18208	52	prosecute	prosecute	VB
18637	18208	53	a	a	DT
18637	18208	54	suit	suit	NN
18637	18208	55	against	against	IN
18637	18208	56	the	the	DT
18637	18208	57	State	State	NNP
18637	18208	58	,	,	,
18637	18208	59	"	"	''
18637	18208	60	but	but	CC
18637	18208	61	continues	continue	VBZ
18637	18208	62	one	one	CD
18637	18208	63	commenced	commence	VBN
18637	18208	64	by	by	IN
18637	18208	65	the	the	DT
18637	18208	66	State	State	NNP
18637	18208	67	.	.	.
18637	18209	1	The	the	DT
18637	18209	2	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	18209	3	holding	holding	NN
18637	18209	4	would	would	MD
18637	18209	5	have	have	VB
18637	18209	6	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	18209	7	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	18209	8	the	the	DT
18637	18209	9	25th	25th	JJ
18637	18209	10	Section	Section	NNP
18637	18209	11	of	of	IN
18637	18209	12	the	the	DT
18637	18209	13	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
18637	18209	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	18209	15	of	of	IN
18637	18209	16	1789	1789	CD
18637	18209	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18209	18	_	_	NNP
18637	18209	19	see	see	VBP
18637	18209	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18209	21	p.	p.	NN
18637	18209	22	554	554	CD
18637	18209	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18209	24	,	,	,
18637	18209	25	and	and	CC
18637	18209	26	brought	bring	VBD
18637	18209	27	something	something	NN
18637	18209	28	like	like	IN
18637	18209	29	anarchy	anarchy	NN
18637	18209	30	in	in	IN
18637	18209	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18209	32	wake	wake	NN
18637	18209	33	.	.	.
18637	18210	1	In	in	IN
18637	18210	2	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	18210	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18210	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	18210	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18210	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	18210	7	of	of	IN
18637	18210	8	the	the	DT
18637	18210	9	United	United	NNP
18637	18210	10	States,[4	States,[4	NNP
18637	18210	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18210	12	decided	decide	VBD
18637	18210	13	three	three	CD
18637	18210	14	years	year	NNS
18637	18210	15	later	later	RBR
18637	18210	16	,	,	,
18637	18210	17	the	the	DT
18637	18210	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18210	19	laid	lay	VBD
18637	18210	20	down	down	RP
18637	18210	21	two	two	CD
18637	18210	22	rules	rule	NNS
18637	18210	23	,	,	,
18637	18210	24	one	one	CD
18637	18210	25	of	of	IN
18637	18210	26	which	which	WDT
18637	18210	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	18210	28	survived	survive	VBN
18637	18210	29	and	and	CC
18637	18210	30	the	the	DT
18637	18210	31	other	other	JJ
18637	18210	32	of	of	IN
18637	18210	33	which	which	WDT
18637	18210	34	was	be	VBD
18637	18210	35	soon	soon	RB
18637	18210	36	abandoned	abandon	VBN
18637	18210	37	.	.	.
18637	18211	1	The	the	DT
18637	18211	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18211	3	was	be	VBD
18637	18211	4	the	the	DT
18637	18211	5	holding	holding	NN
18637	18211	6	that	that	IN
18637	18211	7	a	a	DT
18637	18211	8	suit	suit	NN
18637	18211	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	18211	10	not	not	RB
18637	18211	11	one	one	CD
18637	18211	12	against	against	IN
18637	18211	13	a	a	DT
18637	18211	14	State	State	NNP
18637	18211	15	unless	unless	IN
18637	18211	16	the	the	DT
18637	18211	17	State	state	NN
18637	18211	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	18211	19	a	a	DT
18637	18211	20	party	party	NN
18637	18211	21	to	to	IN
18637	18211	22	the	the	DT
18637	18211	23	record	record	NN
18637	18211	24	.	.	.
18637	18212	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18212	2	5	5	LS
18637	18212	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18212	4	This	this	DT
18637	18212	5	rule	rule	NN
18637	18212	6	the	the	DT
18637	18212	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18212	8	was	be	VBD
18637	18212	9	forced	force	VBN
18637	18212	10	to	to	TO
18637	18212	11	repudiate	repudiate	VB
18637	18212	12	seven	seven	CD
18637	18212	13	years	year	NNS
18637	18212	14	later	later	RB
18637	18212	15	in	in	IN
18637	18212	16	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	18212	17	of	of	IN
18637	18212	18	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	18212	19	_	_	NNP
18637	18212	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	18212	21	_	_	NNP
18637	18212	22	Madrazo,[6	Madrazo,[6	NNP
18637	18212	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18212	24	in	in	IN
18637	18212	25	which	which	WDT
18637	18212	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18212	27	was	be	VBD
18637	18212	28	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	18212	29	that	that	IN
18637	18212	30	the	the	DT
18637	18212	31	suit	suit	NN
18637	18212	32	had	have	VBD
18637	18212	33	been	be	VBN
18637	18212	34	brought	bring	VBN
18637	18212	35	against	against	IN
18637	18212	36	the	the	DT
18637	18212	37	governor	governor	NN
18637	18212	38	solely	solely	RB
18637	18212	39	in	in	IN
18637	18212	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18212	41	official	official	JJ
18637	18212	42	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	18212	43	and	and	CC
18637	18212	44	with	with	IN
18637	18212	45	the	the	DT
18637	18212	46	design	design	NN
18637	18212	47	of	of	IN
18637	18212	48	forcing	force	VBG
18637	18212	49	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18212	50	to	to	TO
18637	18212	51	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	18212	52	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18212	53	official	official	JJ
18637	18212	54	powers	power	NNS
18637	18212	55	.	.	.
18637	18213	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18213	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	18213	3	now	now	RB
18637	18213	4	a	a	DT
18637	18213	5	well	well	RB
18637	18213	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	18213	7	settled	settle	VBN
18637	18213	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	18213	9	that	that	IN
18637	18213	10	in	in	IN
18637	18213	11	determining	determine	VBG
18637	18213	12	whether	whether	IN
18637	18213	13	a	a	DT
18637	18213	14	suit	suit	NN
18637	18213	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	18213	16	prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
18637	18213	17	against	against	IN
18637	18213	18	a	a	DT
18637	18213	19	State	State	NNP
18637	18213	20	"	"	''
18637	18213	21	the	the	DT
18637	18213	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18213	23	will	will	MD
18637	18213	24	look	look	VB
18637	18213	25	behind	behind	RB
18637	18213	26	and	and	CC
18637	18213	27	through	through	IN
18637	18213	28	the	the	DT
18637	18213	29	nominal	nominal	JJ
18637	18213	30	parties	party	NNS
18637	18213	31	on	on	IN
18637	18213	32	the	the	DT
18637	18213	33	record	record	NN
18637	18213	34	to	to	IN
18637	18213	35	ascertain	ascertain	NN
18637	18213	36	who	who	WP
18637	18213	37	are	be	VBP
18637	18213	38	the	the	DT
18637	18213	39	real	real	JJ
18637	18213	40	parties	party	NNS
18637	18213	41	to	to	IN
18637	18213	42	the	the	DT
18637	18213	43	suit	suit	NN
18637	18213	44	.	.	.
18637	18214	1	"	"	``
18637	18214	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18214	3	7	7	CD
18637	18214	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18214	5	The	the	DT
18637	18214	6	other	other	JJ
18637	18214	7	,	,	,
18637	18214	8	more	more	RBR
18637	18214	9	successful	successful	JJ
18637	18214	10	rule	rule	NN
18637	18214	11	was	be	VBD
18637	18214	12	that	that	IN
18637	18214	13	a	a	DT
18637	18214	14	State	State	NNP
18637	18214	15	official	official	NN
18637	18214	16	possesses	possess	VBZ
18637	18214	17	no	no	DT
18637	18214	18	official	official	JJ
18637	18214	19	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	18214	20	when	when	WRB
18637	18214	21	acting	act	VBG
18637	18214	22	illegally	illegally	RB
18637	18214	23	and	and	CC
18637	18214	24	hence	hence	RB
18637	18214	25	can	can	MD
18637	18214	26	derive	derive	VB
18637	18214	27	no	no	DT
18637	18214	28	protection	protection	NN
18637	18214	29	from	from	IN
18637	18214	30	an	an	DT
18637	18214	31	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18214	32	statute	statute	NN
18637	18214	33	of	of	IN
18637	18214	34	a	a	DT
18637	18214	35	State	State	NNP
18637	18214	36	.	.	.
18637	18215	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18215	2	8	8	CD
18637	18215	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18215	4	Expansion	Expansion	NNP
18637	18215	5	of	of	IN
18637	18215	6	State	State	NNP
18637	18215	7	Immunity	Immunity	NNP
18637	18215	8	Subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	18215	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	18215	10	giving	give	VBG
18637	18215	11	the	the	DT
18637	18215	12	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18215	13	a	a	DT
18637	18215	14	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	18215	15	effect	effect	NN
18637	18215	16	are	be	VBP
18637	18215	17	those	those	DT
18637	18215	18	holding	hold	VBG
18637	18215	19	that	that	IN
18637	18215	20	counties	county	NNS
18637	18215	21	and	and	CC
18637	18215	22	municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	18215	23	are	be	VBP
18637	18215	24	suable	suable	JJ
18637	18215	25	in	in	IN
18637	18215	26	the	the	DT
18637	18215	27	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18215	28	courts;[9	courts;[9	NN
18637	18215	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18215	30	and	and	CC
18637	18215	31	that	that	IN
18637	18215	32	government	government	NN
18637	18215	33	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18215	34	of	of	IN
18637	18215	35	the	the	DT
18637	18215	36	State	State	NNP
18637	18215	37	are	be	VBP
18637	18215	38	not	not	RB
18637	18215	39	immune	immune	JJ
18637	18215	40	when	when	WRB
18637	18215	41	suable	suable	JJ
18637	18215	42	under	under	IN
18637	18215	43	the	the	DT
18637	18215	44	law	law	NN
18637	18215	45	which	which	WDT
18637	18215	46	created	create	VBD
18637	18215	47	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18215	48	.	.	.
18637	18216	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18216	2	10	10	CD
18637	18216	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18216	4	Meantime	meantime	RB
18637	18216	5	other	other	JJ
18637	18216	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	18216	7	have	have	VBP
18637	18216	8	expanded	expand	VBN
18637	18216	9	the	the	DT
18637	18216	10	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
18637	18216	11	of	of	IN
18637	18216	12	the	the	DT
18637	18216	13	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18216	14	to	to	TO
18637	18216	15	include	include	VB
18637	18216	16	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18216	17	brought	bring	VBN
18637	18216	18	against	against	IN
18637	18216	19	a	a	DT
18637	18216	20	State	state	NN
18637	18216	21	by	by	IN
18637	18216	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18216	23	own	own	JJ
18637	18216	24	citizens,[11	citizens,[11	NN
18637	18216	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18216	26	by	by	IN
18637	18216	27	a	a	DT
18637	18216	28	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18216	29	state,[12	state,[12	NN
18637	18216	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18216	31	by	by	IN
18637	18216	32	a	a	DT
18637	18216	33	federally	federally	RB
18637	18216	34	chartered	chartered	JJ
18637	18216	35	corporation,[13	corporation,[13	NNP
18637	18216	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18216	37	or	or	CC
18637	18216	38	by	by	IN
18637	18216	39	a	a	DT
18637	18216	40	State	State	NNP
18637	18216	41	as	as	IN
18637	18216	42	an	an	DT
18637	18216	43	agent	agent	NN
18637	18216	44	of	of	IN
18637	18216	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18216	46	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18216	47	to	to	TO
18637	18216	48	collect	collect	VB
18637	18216	49	debts	debt	NNS
18637	18216	50	owed	owe	VBN
18637	18216	51	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18216	52	by	by	IN
18637	18216	53	another	another	DT
18637	18216	54	State	state	NN
18637	18216	55	.	.	.
18637	18217	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18217	2	14	14	CD
18637	18217	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18217	4	These	these	DT
18637	18217	5	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	18217	6	are	be	VBP
18637	18217	7	based	base	VBN
18637	18217	8	on	on	IN
18637	18217	9	the	the	DT
18637	18217	10	premise	premise	NN
18637	18217	11	expressed	express	VBN
18637	18217	12	in	in	IN
18637	18217	13	Hans	Hans	NNP
18637	18217	14	_	_	NNP
18637	18217	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	18217	16	_	_	NNP
18637	18217	17	Louisiana[15	Louisiana[15	NNP
18637	18217	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18217	19	that	that	IN
18637	18217	20	the	the	DT
18637	18217	21	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18217	22	"	"	``
18637	18217	23	actually	actually	RB
18637	18217	24	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	18217	25	the	the	DT
18637	18217	26	decision	decision	NN
18637	18217	27	"	"	''
18637	18217	28	in	in	IN
18637	18217	29	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
18637	18217	30	_	_	NNP
18637	18217	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	18217	32	_	_	NNP
18637	18217	33	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	18217	34	and	and	CC
18637	18217	35	,	,	,
18637	18217	36	as	as	IN
18637	18217	37	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	18217	38	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18217	39	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	18217	40	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	18217	41	in	in	IN
18637	18217	42	Monaco	Monaco	NNP
18637	18217	43	_	_	NNP
18637	18217	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	18217	45	_	_	NNP
18637	18217	46	Mississippi,[16	Mississippi,[16	NNP
18637	18217	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18217	48	had	have	VBD
18637	18217	49	the	the	DT
18637	18217	50	effect	effect	NN
18637	18217	51	of	of	IN
18637	18217	52	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	18217	53	any	any	DT
18637	18217	54	suit	suit	NN
18637	18217	55	against	against	IN
18637	18217	56	a	a	DT
18637	18217	57	State	State	NNP
18637	18217	58	without	without	IN
18637	18217	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18217	60	consent	consent	NN
18637	18217	61	except	except	IN
18637	18217	62	when	when	WRB
18637	18217	63	brought	bring	VBN
18637	18217	64	by	by	IN
18637	18217	65	the	the	DT
18637	18217	66	United	United	NNP
18637	18217	67	States[17	States[17	NNP
18637	18217	68	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18217	69	or	or	CC
18637	18217	70	another	another	DT
18637	18217	71	State	state	NN
18637	18217	72	.	.	.
18637	18218	1	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	18218	2	Against	against	IN
18637	18218	3	State	State	NNP
18637	18218	4	Officials	Officials	NNPS
18637	18218	5	:	:	:
18637	18218	6	Two	two	CD
18637	18218	7	Categories	category	NNS
18637	18218	8	Most	Most	JJS
18637	18218	9	of	of	IN
18637	18218	10	the	the	DT
18637	18218	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	18218	12	involving	involve	VBG
18637	18218	13	the	the	DT
18637	18218	14	Eleventh	Eleventh	NNP
18637	18218	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18218	16	and	and	CC
18637	18218	17	those	those	DT
18637	18218	18	creating	create	VBG
18637	18218	19	the	the	DT
18637	18218	20	greatest	great	JJS
18637	18218	21	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
18637	18218	22	are	be	VBP
18637	18218	23	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18218	24	brought	bring	VBN
18637	18218	25	against	against	IN
18637	18218	26	State	State	NNP
18637	18218	27	officials	official	NNS
18637	18218	28	.	.	.
18637	18219	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	18219	2	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18219	3	are	be	VBP
18637	18219	4	governed	govern	VBN
18637	18219	5	by	by	IN
18637	18219	6	the	the	DT
18637	18219	7	same	same	JJ
18637	18219	8	rules	rule	NNS
18637	18219	9	and	and	CC
18637	18219	10	principles	principle	NNS
18637	18219	11	as	as	IN
18637	18219	12	pertain	pertain	NN
18637	18219	13	to	to	IN
18637	18219	14	the	the	DT
18637	18219	15	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	18219	16	of	of	IN
18637	18219	17	the	the	DT
18637	18219	18	United	United	NNP
18637	18219	19	States	States	NNP
18637	18219	20	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18219	21	from	from	IN
18637	18219	22	suits,[18	suits,[18	CD
18637	18219	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18219	24	with	with	IN
18637	18219	25	the	the	DT
18637	18219	26	result	result	NN
18637	18219	27	that	that	IN
18637	18219	28	the	the	DT
18637	18219	29	rules	rule	NNS
18637	18219	30	of	of	IN
18637	18219	31	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	18219	32	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	18219	33	from	from	IN
18637	18219	34	suit	suit	NN
18637	18219	35	generally	generally	RB
18637	18219	36	are	be	VBP
18637	18219	37	grounded	ground	VBN
18637	18219	38	on	on	IN
18637	18219	39	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	18219	40	arising	arise	VBG
18637	18219	41	under	under	IN
18637	18219	42	both	both	DT
18637	18219	43	article	article	NN
18637	18219	44	III	iii	CD
18637	18219	45	and	and	CC
18637	18219	46	the	the	DT
18637	18219	47	Eleventh	Eleventh	NNP
18637	18219	48	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18219	49	without	without	IN
18637	18219	50	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	18219	51	as	as	IN
18637	18219	52	to	to	IN
18637	18219	53	whether	whether	IN
18637	18219	54	a	a	DT
18637	18219	55	suit	suit	NN
18637	18219	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	18219	57	against	against	IN
18637	18219	58	the	the	DT
18637	18219	59	United	United	NNP
18637	18219	60	States	States	NNP
18637	18219	61	or	or	CC
18637	18219	62	a	a	DT
18637	18219	63	State	state	NN
18637	18219	64	.	.	.
18637	18220	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18220	2	19	19	CD
18637	18220	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18220	4	The	the	DT
18637	18220	5	line	line	NN
18637	18220	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	18220	7	not	not	RB
18637	18220	8	always	always	RB
18637	18220	9	easy	easy	JJ
18637	18220	10	to	to	TO
18637	18220	11	draw	draw	VB
18637	18220	12	,	,	,
18637	18220	13	nor	nor	CC
18637	18220	14	are	be	VBP
18637	18220	15	the	the	DT
18637	18220	16	cases	case	NNS
18637	18220	17	always	always	RB
18637	18220	18	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	18220	19	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	18220	20	.	.	.
18637	18221	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18221	2	do	do	VBP
18637	18221	3	yield	yield	VB
18637	18221	4	,	,	,
18637	18221	5	however	however	RB
18637	18221	6	,	,	,
18637	18221	7	to	to	IN
18637	18221	8	the	the	DT
18637	18221	9	formulation	formulation	NN
18637	18221	10	of	of	IN
18637	18221	11	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18221	12	general	general	JJ
18637	18221	13	rules	rule	NNS
18637	18221	14	.	.	.
18637	18222	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18222	2	,	,	,
18637	18222	3	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18222	4	brought	bring	VBN
18637	18222	5	against	against	IN
18637	18222	6	State	State	NNP
18637	18222	7	officials	official	NNS
18637	18222	8	acting	act	VBG
18637	18222	9	either	either	CC
18637	18222	10	in	in	IN
18637	18222	11	excess	excess	NN
18637	18222	12	of	of	IN
18637	18222	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18222	14	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	18222	15	authority[20	authority[20	NNP
18637	18222	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18222	17	or	or	CC
18637	18222	18	in	in	IN
18637	18222	19	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	18222	20	of	of	IN
18637	18222	21	an	an	DT
18637	18222	22	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18222	23	statute[21	statute[21	NN
18637	18222	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18222	25	are	be	VBP
18637	18222	26	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18222	27	against	against	IN
18637	18222	28	the	the	DT
18637	18222	29	officer	officer	NN
18637	18222	30	in	in	IN
18637	18222	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18222	32	individual	individual	JJ
18637	18222	33	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	18222	34	and	and	CC
18637	18222	35	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	18222	36	are	be	VBP
18637	18222	37	not	not	RB
18637	18222	38	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	18222	39	by	by	IN
18637	18222	40	the	the	DT
18637	18222	41	Eleventh	Eleventh	NNP
18637	18222	42	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18222	43	;	;	:
18637	18222	44	and	and	CC
18637	18222	45	suits	suit	VBZ
18637	18222	46	against	against	IN
18637	18222	47	an	an	DT
18637	18222	48	officer	officer	NN
18637	18222	49	for	for	IN
18637	18222	50	the	the	DT
18637	18222	51	commission	commission	NN
18637	18222	52	of	of	IN
18637	18222	53	a	a	DT
18637	18222	54	common	common	JJ
18637	18222	55	law	law	NN
18637	18222	56	tort	tort	NN
18637	18222	57	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	18222	58	to	to	TO
18637	18222	59	be	be	VB
18637	18222	60	justified	justify	VBN
18637	18222	61	by	by	IN
18637	18222	62	a	a	DT
18637	18222	63	statute	statute	NN
18637	18222	64	or	or	CC
18637	18222	65	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	18222	66	order	order	NN
18637	18222	67	of	of	IN
18637	18222	68	the	the	DT
18637	18222	69	State	State	NNP
18637	18222	70	belong	belong	VBP
18637	18222	71	to	to	IN
18637	18222	72	the	the	DT
18637	18222	73	same	same	JJ
18637	18222	74	category	category	NN
18637	18222	75	.	.	.
18637	18223	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18223	2	22	22	CD
18637	18223	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18223	4	On	on	IN
18637	18223	5	the	the	DT
18637	18223	6	other	other	JJ
18637	18223	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	18223	8	,	,	,
18637	18223	9	suits	suit	VBZ
18637	18223	10	against	against	IN
18637	18223	11	the	the	DT
18637	18223	12	officers	officer	NNS
18637	18223	13	of	of	IN
18637	18223	14	a	a	DT
18637	18223	15	State	state	NN
18637	18223	16	involving	involve	VBG
18637	18223	17	what	what	WP
18637	18223	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	18223	19	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	18223	20	to	to	TO
18637	18223	21	be	be	VB
18637	18223	22	State	state	NN
18637	18223	23	property	property	NN
18637	18223	24	or	or	CC
18637	18223	25	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18223	26	asking	ask	VBG
18637	18223	27	for	for	IN
18637	18223	28	relief	relief	NN
18637	18223	29	which	which	WDT
18637	18223	30	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	18223	31	call	call	VBP
18637	18223	32	for	for	IN
18637	18223	33	the	the	DT
18637	18223	34	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18223	35	of	of	IN
18637	18223	36	official	official	JJ
18637	18223	37	authority	authority	NN
18637	18223	38	can	can	MD
18637	18223	39	not	not	RB
18637	18223	40	be	be	VB
18637	18223	41	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18223	42	.	.	.
18637	18224	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18224	2	23	23	CD
18637	18224	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18224	4	Mandamus	Mandamus	NNP
18637	18224	5	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNP
18637	18224	6	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18224	7	mandamus	mandamus	VBP
18637	18224	8	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18224	9	which	which	WDT
18637	18224	10	seek	seek	VBP
18637	18224	11	"	"	``
18637	18224	12	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	18224	13	official	official	JJ
18637	18224	14	action	action	NN
18637	18224	15	"	"	''
18637	18224	16	on	on	IN
18637	18224	17	the	the	DT
18637	18224	18	part	part	NN
18637	18224	19	of	of	IN
18637	18224	20	State	State	NNP
18637	18224	21	officials	official	NNS
18637	18224	22	as	as	IN
18637	18224	23	"	"	``
18637	18224	24	the	the	DT
18637	18224	25	performance	performance	NN
18637	18224	26	of	of	IN
18637	18224	27	an	an	DT
18637	18224	28	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	18224	29	which	which	WDT
18637	18224	30	belongs	belong	VBZ
18637	18224	31	to	to	IN
18637	18224	32	the	the	DT
18637	18224	33	State	State	NNP
18637	18224	34	in	in	IN
18637	18224	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18224	36	political	political	JJ
18637	18224	37	capacity"[24	capacity"[24	''
18637	18224	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18224	39	are	be	VBP
18637	18224	40	uniformly	uniformly	RB
18637	18224	41	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	18224	42	as	as	IN
18637	18224	43	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18224	44	against	against	IN
18637	18224	45	the	the	DT
18637	18224	46	State	State	NNP
18637	18224	47	.	.	.
18637	18225	1	This	this	DT
18637	18225	2	rule	rule	NN
18637	18225	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	18225	4	well	well	RB
18637	18225	5	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
18637	18225	6	by	by	IN
18637	18225	7	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	18225	8	ex	ex	NNP
18637	18225	9	rel	rel	NNP
18637	18225	10	.	.	.
18637	18226	1	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	18226	2	_	_	NNP
18637	18226	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	18226	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18226	5	Jumel[25	Jumel[25	NNP
18637	18226	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18226	7	where	where	WRB
18637	18226	8	a	a	DT
18637	18226	9	holder	holder	NN
18637	18226	10	of	of	IN
18637	18226	11	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	18226	12	State	State	NNP
18637	18226	13	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	18226	14	sought	seek	VBD
18637	18226	15	to	to	TO
18637	18226	16	compel	compel	VB
18637	18226	17	the	the	DT
18637	18226	18	State	State	NNP
18637	18226	19	treasurer	treasurer	NN
18637	18226	20	to	to	TO
18637	18226	21	apply	apply	VB
18637	18226	22	a	a	DT
18637	18226	23	sinking	sinking	NN
18637	18226	24	fund	fund	NN
18637	18226	25	that	that	WDT
18637	18226	26	had	have	VBD
18637	18226	27	been	be	VBN
18637	18226	28	created	create	VBN
18637	18226	29	under	under	IN
18637	18226	30	an	an	DT
18637	18226	31	earlier	early	JJR
18637	18226	32	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	18226	33	for	for	IN
18637	18226	34	the	the	DT
18637	18226	35	payment	payment	NN
18637	18226	36	of	of	IN
18637	18226	37	the	the	DT
18637	18226	38	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	18226	39	to	to	IN
18637	18226	40	such	such	JJ
18637	18226	41	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18226	42	after	after	IN
18637	18226	43	a	a	DT
18637	18226	44	new	new	JJ
18637	18226	45	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	18226	46	had	have	VBD
18637	18226	47	abolished	abolish	VBN
18637	18226	48	this	this	DT
18637	18226	49	provision	provision	NN
18637	18226	50	for	for	IN
18637	18226	51	retiring	retire	VBG
18637	18226	52	the	the	DT
18637	18226	53	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	18226	54	.	.	.
18637	18227	1	The	the	DT
18637	18227	2	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	18227	3	was	be	VBD
18637	18227	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	18227	5	to	to	TO
18637	18227	6	be	be	VB
18637	18227	7	a	a	DT
18637	18227	8	suit	suit	NN
18637	18227	9	against	against	IN
18637	18227	10	the	the	DT
18637	18227	11	State	State	NNP
18637	18227	12	because	because	IN
18637	18227	13	:	:	:
18637	18227	14	"	"	``
18637	18227	15	The	the	DT
18637	18227	16	relief	relief	NN
18637	18227	17	asked	ask	VBD
18637	18227	18	will	will	MD
18637	18227	19	require	require	VB
18637	18227	20	the	the	DT
18637	18227	21	officers	officer	NNS
18637	18227	22	against	against	IN
18637	18227	23	whom	whom	WP
18637	18227	24	the	the	DT
18637	18227	25	process	process	NN
18637	18227	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	18227	27	issued	issue	VBN
18637	18227	28	to	to	TO
18637	18227	29	act	act	VB
18637	18227	30	contrary	contrary	RB
18637	18227	31	to	to	IN
18637	18227	32	the	the	DT
18637	18227	33	positive	positive	JJ
18637	18227	34	orders	order	NNS
18637	18227	35	of	of	IN
18637	18227	36	the	the	DT
18637	18227	37	supreme	supreme	JJ
18637	18227	38	political	political	JJ
18637	18227	39	power	power	NN
18637	18227	40	of	of	IN
18637	18227	41	the	the	DT
18637	18227	42	State	State	NNP
18637	18227	43	,	,	,
18637	18227	44	whose	whose	WP$
18637	18227	45	creatures	creature	NNS
18637	18227	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18227	47	are	be	VBP
18637	18227	48	,	,	,
18637	18227	49	and	and	CC
18637	18227	50	to	to	TO
18637	18227	51	which	which	WDT
18637	18227	52	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18227	53	are	be	VBP
18637	18227	54	ultimately	ultimately	RB
18637	18227	55	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	18227	56	in	in	IN
18637	18227	57	law	law	NN
18637	18227	58	for	for	IN
18637	18227	59	what	what	WP
18637	18227	60	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18227	61	do	do	VBP
18637	18227	62	.	.	.
18637	18228	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18228	2	must	must	MD
18637	18228	3	use	use	VB
18637	18228	4	the	the	DT
18637	18228	5	public	public	JJ
18637	18228	6	money	money	NN
18637	18228	7	in	in	IN
18637	18228	8	the	the	DT
18637	18228	9	treasury	treasury	NN
18637	18228	10	and	and	CC
18637	18228	11	under	under	IN
18637	18228	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18228	13	official	official	JJ
18637	18228	14	control	control	NN
18637	18228	15	in	in	IN
18637	18228	16	one	one	CD
18637	18228	17	way	way	NN
18637	18228	18	,	,	,
18637	18228	19	when	when	WRB
18637	18228	20	the	the	DT
18637	18228	21	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	18228	22	power	power	NNP
18637	18228	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	18228	24	directed	direct	VBN
18637	18228	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18228	26	to	to	TO
18637	18228	27	use	use	VB
18637	18228	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18228	29	in	in	IN
18637	18228	30	another	another	DT
18637	18228	31	,	,	,
18637	18228	32	and	and	CC
18637	18228	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18228	34	must	must	MD
18637	18228	35	raise	raise	VB
18637	18228	36	more	more	JJR
18637	18228	37	money	money	NN
18637	18228	38	by	by	IN
18637	18228	39	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	18228	40	when	when	WRB
18637	18228	41	the	the	DT
18637	18228	42	same	same	JJ
18637	18228	43	power	power	NN
18637	18228	44	has	have	VBZ
18637	18228	45	declared	declare	VBN
18637	18228	46	that	that	IN
18637	18228	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18228	48	shall	shall	MD
18637	18228	49	not	not	RB
18637	18228	50	be	be	VB
18637	18228	51	done	do	VBN
18637	18228	52	.	.	.
18637	18229	1	"	"	``
18637	18229	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18229	3	26	26	CD
18637	18229	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18229	5	However	however	RB
18637	18229	6	,	,	,
18637	18229	7	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	18229	8	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18229	9	to	to	TO
18637	18229	10	compel	compel	VB
18637	18229	11	a	a	DT
18637	18229	12	State	State	NNP
18637	18229	13	official	official	NN
18637	18229	14	to	to	TO
18637	18229	15	perform	perform	VB
18637	18229	16	a	a	DT
18637	18229	17	plain	plain	JJ
18637	18229	18	or	or	CC
18637	18229	19	ministerial	ministerial	JJ
18637	18229	20	duty	duty	NN
18637	18229	21	which	which	WDT
18637	18229	22	admits	admit	VBZ
18637	18229	23	of	of	IN
18637	18229	24	no	no	DT
18637	18229	25	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	18229	26	are	be	VBP
18637	18229	27	not	not	RB
18637	18229	28	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18229	29	against	against	IN
18637	18229	30	the	the	DT
18637	18229	31	State	State	NNP
18637	18229	32	since	since	IN
18637	18229	33	the	the	DT
18637	18229	34	official	official	NN
18637	18229	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	18229	36	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	18229	37	as	as	IN
18637	18229	38	acting	act	VBG
18637	18229	39	in	in	IN
18637	18229	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18229	41	individual	individual	JJ
18637	18229	42	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	18229	43	in	in	IN
18637	18229	44	failing	fail	VBG
18637	18229	45	to	to	TO
18637	18229	46	act	act	VB
18637	18229	47	according	accord	VBG
18637	18229	48	to	to	IN
18637	18229	49	law	law	NN
18637	18229	50	.	.	.
18637	18230	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18230	2	27	27	CD
18637	18230	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18230	4	Early	early	JJ
18637	18230	5	Limitation	limitation	NN
18637	18230	6	on	on	IN
18637	18230	7	Injunction	Injunction	NNP
18637	18230	8	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNP
18637	18230	9	In	in	IN
18637	18230	10	spite	spite	NN
18637	18230	11	of	of	IN
18637	18230	12	a	a	DT
18637	18230	13	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	18230	14	by	by	IN
18637	18230	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18230	16	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	18230	17	in	in	IN
18637	18230	18	the	the	DT
18637	18230	19	McComb	McComb	NNP
18637	18230	20	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18230	21	that	that	IN
18637	18230	22	the	the	DT
18637	18230	23	writs	writ	NNS
18637	18230	24	of	of	IN
18637	18230	25	mandamus	mandamus	NNP
18637	18230	26	and	and	CC
18637	18230	27	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	18230	28	are	be	VBP
18637	18230	29	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	18230	30	correlative	correlative	JJ
18637	18230	31	to	to	IN
18637	18230	32	each	each	DT
18637	18230	33	other	other	JJ
18637	18230	34	in	in	IN
18637	18230	35	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18230	36	against	against	IN
18637	18230	37	State	State	NNP
18637	18230	38	officials	official	NNS
18637	18230	39	for	for	IN
18637	18230	40	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	18230	41	actions,[28	actions,[28	CD
18637	18230	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18230	43	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	18230	44	against	against	IN
18637	18230	45	State	State	NNP
18637	18230	46	officials	official	NNS
18637	18230	47	to	to	TO
18637	18230	48	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	18230	49	the	the	DT
18637	18230	50	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18230	51	of	of	IN
18637	18230	52	an	an	DT
18637	18230	53	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18230	54	statute	statute	NN
18637	18230	55	or	or	CC
18637	18230	56	action	action	NN
18637	18230	57	in	in	IN
18637	18230	58	excess	excess	NN
18637	18230	59	of	of	IN
18637	18230	60	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	18230	61	authority	authority	NN
18637	18230	62	are	be	VBP
18637	18230	63	more	more	RBR
18637	18230	64	readily	readily	RB
18637	18230	65	obtainable	obtainable	JJ
18637	18230	66	.	.	.
18637	18231	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18231	2	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	18231	3	in	in	IN
18637	18231	4	fact	fact	NN
18637	18231	5	the	the	DT
18637	18231	6	single	single	JJ
18637	18231	7	largest	large	JJS
18637	18231	8	class	class	NN
18637	18231	9	of	of	IN
18637	18231	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	18231	11	involving	involve	VBG
18637	18231	12	the	the	DT
18637	18231	13	issue	issue	NN
18637	18231	14	of	of	IN
18637	18231	15	State	State	NNP
18637	18231	16	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	18231	17	.	.	.
18637	18232	1	Until	until	IN
18637	18232	2	Reagan	Reagan	NNP
18637	18232	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18232	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	18232	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18232	6	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	18232	7	'	'	POS
18637	18232	8	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	18232	9	and	and	CC
18637	18232	10	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	18232	11	Company[29	company[29	ADD
18637	18232	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18232	13	the	the	DT
18637	18232	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18232	15	maintained	maintain	VBD
18637	18232	16	a	a	DT
18637	18232	17	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	18232	18	between	between	IN
18637	18232	19	the	the	DT
18637	18232	20	duty	duty	NN
18637	18232	21	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18232	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	18232	23	an	an	DT
18637	18232	24	official	official	NN
18637	18232	25	by	by	IN
18637	18232	26	the	the	DT
18637	18232	27	general	general	JJ
18637	18232	28	laws	law	NNS
18637	18232	29	of	of	IN
18637	18232	30	the	the	DT
18637	18232	31	State	State	NNP
18637	18232	32	and	and	CC
18637	18232	33	the	the	DT
18637	18232	34	duty	duty	NN
18637	18232	35	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18232	36	by	by	IN
18637	18232	37	a	a	DT
18637	18232	38	specific	specific	JJ
18637	18232	39	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18232	40	statute	statute	NN
18637	18232	41	and	and	CC
18637	18232	42	held	hold	VBD
18637	18232	43	that	that	IN
18637	18232	44	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	18232	45	an	an	DT
18637	18232	46	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	18232	47	would	would	MD
18637	18232	48	not	not	RB
18637	18232	49	lie	lie	VB
18637	18232	50	to	to	TO
18637	18232	51	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	18232	52	a	a	DT
18637	18232	53	State	State	NNP
18637	18232	54	official	official	NN
18637	18232	55	from	from	IN
18637	18232	56	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	18232	57	an	an	DT
18637	18232	58	act	act	NN
18637	18232	59	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	18232	60	to	to	TO
18637	18232	61	be	be	VB
18637	18232	62	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18232	63	in	in	IN
18637	18232	64	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	18232	65	of	of	IN
18637	18232	66	the	the	DT
18637	18232	67	general	general	JJ
18637	18232	68	duties	duty	NNS
18637	18232	69	of	of	IN
18637	18232	70	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18232	71	office	office	NN
18637	18232	72	,	,	,
18637	18232	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18232	74	would	would	MD
18637	18232	75	lie	lie	VB
18637	18232	76	to	to	TO
18637	18232	77	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	18232	78	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18232	79	from	from	IN
18637	18232	80	performing	perform	VBG
18637	18232	81	special	special	JJ
18637	18232	82	duties	duty	NNS
18637	18232	83	vested	vest	VBN
18637	18232	84	in	in	IN
18637	18232	85	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18232	86	by	by	IN
18637	18232	87	an	an	DT
18637	18232	88	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18232	89	statute	statute	NN
18637	18232	90	.	.	.
18637	18233	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18233	2	30	30	CD
18637	18233	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18233	4	The	the	DT
18637	18233	5	leading	lead	VBG
18637	18233	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	18233	7	assertive	assertive	JJ
18637	18233	8	of	of	IN
18637	18233	9	this	this	DT
18637	18233	10	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	18233	11	are	be	VBP
18637	18233	12	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	18233	13	parte	parte	VBZ
18637	18233	14	Ayers	Ayers	NNP
18637	18233	15	and	and	CC
18637	18233	16	Fitts	Fitts	NNP
18637	18233	17	_	_	NNP
18637	18233	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	18233	19	_	_	NNP
18637	18233	20	McGhee	McGhee	NNP
18637	18233	21	,	,	,
18637	18233	22	decided	decide	VBD
18637	18233	23	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	18233	24	in	in	IN
18637	18233	25	1887	1887	CD
18637	18233	26	and	and	CC
18637	18233	27	1899	1899	CD
18637	18233	28	.	.	.
18637	18234	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18234	2	31	31	CD
18637	18234	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18234	4	Injunction	Injunction	NNP
18637	18234	5	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNP
18637	18234	6	Today	today	NN
18637	18234	7	:	:	:
18637	18234	8	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	18234	9	parte	parte	NN
18637	18234	10	Young	Young	NNP
18637	18234	11	However	however	RB
18637	18234	12	,	,	,
18637	18234	13	the	the	DT
18637	18234	14	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	18234	15	between	between	IN
18637	18234	16	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	18234	17	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18234	18	to	to	TO
18637	18234	19	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	18234	20	an	an	DT
18637	18234	21	official	official	NN
18637	18234	22	from	from	IN
18637	18234	23	pursuing	pursue	VBG
18637	18234	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18234	25	general	general	JJ
18637	18234	26	duties	duty	NNS
18637	18234	27	under	under	IN
18637	18234	28	the	the	DT
18637	18234	29	law	law	NN
18637	18234	30	and	and	CC
18637	18234	31	those	those	DT
18637	18234	32	to	to	TO
18637	18234	33	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	18234	34	the	the	DT
18637	18234	35	performance	performance	NN
18637	18234	36	of	of	IN
18637	18234	37	special	special	JJ
18637	18234	38	duties	duty	NNS
18637	18234	39	under	under	IN
18637	18234	40	an	an	DT
18637	18234	41	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18234	42	statute	statute	NN
18637	18234	43	had	have	VBD
18637	18234	44	been	be	VBN
18637	18234	45	largely	largely	RB
18637	18234	46	lost	lose	VBN
18637	18234	47	even	even	RB
18637	18234	48	before	before	IN
18637	18234	49	Fitts	Fitts	NNP
18637	18234	50	_	_	NNP
18637	18234	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	18234	52	_	_	NNP
18637	18234	53	McGhee	McGhee	NNP
18637	18234	54	,	,	,
18637	18234	55	in	in	IN
18637	18234	56	Reagan	Reagan	NNP
18637	18234	57	_	_	NNP
18637	18234	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	18234	59	_	_	NNP
18637	18234	60	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	18234	61	'	'	POS
18637	18234	62	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	18234	63	and	and	CC
18637	18234	64	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	18234	65	Company[32	Company[32	NNP
18637	18234	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18234	67	and	and	CC
18637	18234	68	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
18637	18234	69	_	_	NNP
18637	18234	70	v.	v.	NN
18637	18234	71	_	_	NNP
18637	18234	72	Ames,[33	Ames,[33	NNP
18637	18234	73	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18234	74	where	where	WRB
18637	18234	75	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	18234	76	issued	issue	VBN
18637	18234	77	by	by	IN
18637	18234	78	the	the	DT
18637	18234	79	lower	low	JJR
18637	18234	80	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18234	81	courts	court	NNS
18637	18234	82	to	to	TO
18637	18234	83	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	18234	84	the	the	DT
18637	18234	85	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18234	86	of	of	IN
18637	18234	87	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18234	88	rate	rate	NN
18637	18234	89	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18234	90	were	be	VBD
18637	18234	91	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18234	92	even	even	RB
18637	18234	93	though	though	IN
18637	18234	94	the	the	DT
18637	18234	95	officials	official	NNS
18637	18234	96	against	against	IN
18637	18234	97	whom	whom	WP
18637	18234	98	the	the	DT
18637	18234	99	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18234	100	were	be	VBD
18637	18234	101	brought	bring	VBN
18637	18234	102	were	be	VBD
18637	18234	103	acting	act	VBG
18637	18234	104	under	under	IN
18637	18234	105	general	general	JJ
18637	18234	106	law	law	NN
18637	18234	107	.	.	.
18637	18235	1	What	what	WP
18637	18235	2	remained	remain	VBD
18637	18235	3	of	of	IN
18637	18235	4	the	the	DT
18637	18235	5	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	18235	6	as	as	IN
18637	18235	7	a	a	DT
18637	18235	8	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	18235	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	18235	10	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18235	11	against	against	IN
18637	18235	12	State	State	NNP
18637	18235	13	officials	official	NNS
18637	18235	14	was	be	VBD
18637	18235	15	dispelled	dispel	VBN
18637	18235	16	by	by	IN
18637	18235	17	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	18235	18	parte	parte	NNP
18637	18235	19	Young,[34	Young,[34	NNP
18637	18235	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18235	21	which	which	WDT
18637	18235	22	not	not	RB
18637	18235	23	only	only	RB
18637	18235	24	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	18235	25	an	an	DT
18637	18235	26	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	18235	27	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	18235	28	State	state	NN
18637	18235	29	officials	official	NNS
18637	18235	30	from	from	IN
18637	18235	31	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	18235	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18235	33	discretionary	discretionary	JJ
18637	18235	34	duties	duty	NNS
18637	18235	35	but	but	CC
18637	18235	36	also	also	RB
18637	18235	37	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	18235	38	the	the	DT
18637	18235	39	authority	authority	NN
18637	18235	40	of	of	IN
18637	18235	41	the	the	DT
18637	18235	42	lower	low	JJR
18637	18235	43	court	court	NN
18637	18235	44	to	to	TO
18637	18235	45	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	18235	46	the	the	DT
18637	18235	47	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18235	48	of	of	IN
18637	18235	49	the	the	DT
18637	18235	50	statute	statute	NN
18637	18235	51	prior	prior	RB
18637	18235	52	to	to	IN
18637	18235	53	a	a	DT
18637	18235	54	determination	determination	NN
18637	18235	55	of	of	IN
18637	18235	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18235	57	unconstitutionality	unconstitutionality	NN
18637	18235	58	.	.	.
18637	18236	1	While	while	IN
18637	18236	2	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	18236	3	parte	parte	VBZ
18637	18236	4	Ayers	Ayers	NNP
18637	18236	5	and	and	CC
18637	18236	6	Fitts	Fitts	NNP
18637	18236	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18236	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18236	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18236	10	McGhee[35	McGhee[35	NNP
18637	18236	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18236	12	were	be	VBD
18637	18236	13	not	not	RB
18637	18236	14	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	18236	15	,	,	,
18637	18236	16	the	the	DT
18637	18236	17	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
18637	18236	18	effect	effect	NN
18637	18236	19	of	of	IN
18637	18236	20	the	the	DT
18637	18236	21	Young	Young	NNP
18637	18236	22	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18236	23	was	be	VBD
18637	18236	24	to	to	TO
18637	18236	25	abrogate	abrogate	VB
18637	18236	26	the	the	DT
18637	18236	27	rule	rule	NN
18637	18236	28	that	that	IN
18637	18236	29	a	a	DT
18637	18236	30	suit	suit	NN
18637	18236	31	in	in	IN
18637	18236	32	equity	equity	NN
18637	18236	33	against	against	IN
18637	18236	34	a	a	DT
18637	18236	35	State	State	NNP
18637	18236	36	official	official	NN
18637	18236	37	to	to	TO
18637	18236	38	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	18236	39	discretionary	discretionary	JJ
18637	18236	40	action	action	NN
18637	18236	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	18236	42	a	a	DT
18637	18236	43	suit	suit	NN
18637	18236	44	against	against	IN
18637	18236	45	the	the	DT
18637	18236	46	State	State	NNP
18637	18236	47	,	,	,
18637	18236	48	and	and	CC
18637	18236	49	to	to	TO
18637	18236	50	convert	convert	VB
18637	18236	51	the	the	DT
18637	18236	52	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	18236	53	into	into	IN
18637	18236	54	a	a	DT
18637	18236	55	device	device	NN
18637	18236	56	to	to	TO
18637	18236	57	test	test	VB
18637	18236	58	the	the	DT
18637	18236	59	validity	validity	NN
18637	18236	60	of	of	IN
18637	18236	61	State	State	NNP
18637	18236	62	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18236	63	in	in	IN
18637	18236	64	the	the	DT
18637	18236	65	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18236	66	courts	court	NNS
18637	18236	67	prior	prior	RB
18637	18236	68	to	to	IN
18637	18236	69	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18236	70	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	18236	71	in	in	IN
18637	18236	72	the	the	DT
18637	18236	73	State	State	NNP
18637	18236	74	courts	court	NNS
18637	18236	75	and	and	CC
18637	18236	76	prior	prior	RB
18637	18236	77	to	to	IN
18637	18236	78	any	any	DT
18637	18236	79	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	18236	80	for	for	IN
18637	18236	81	State	state	NN
18637	18236	82	officials	official	NNS
18637	18236	83	to	to	TO
18637	18236	84	put	put	VB
18637	18236	85	the	the	DT
18637	18236	86	act	act	NN
18637	18236	87	into	into	IN
18637	18236	88	operation	operation	NN
18637	18236	89	.	.	.
18637	18237	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18237	2	36	36	CD
18637	18237	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18237	4	But	but	CC
18637	18237	5	the	the	DT
18637	18237	6	earlier	early	JJR
18637	18237	7	rule	rule	NN
18637	18237	8	still	still	RB
18637	18237	9	crops	crop	VBZ
18637	18237	10	up	up	RP
18637	18237	11	at	at	IN
18637	18237	12	times	time	NNS
18637	18237	13	.	.	.
18637	18238	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18238	2	as	as	RB
18637	18238	3	recently	recently	RB
18637	18238	4	as	as	IN
18637	18238	5	1937	1937	CD
18637	18238	6	,	,	,
18637	18238	7	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	18238	8	parte	parte	NN
18637	18238	9	Ayers[37	Ayers[37	NNP
18637	18238	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18238	11	was	be	VBD
18637	18238	12	applied	apply	VBN
18637	18238	13	to	to	IN
18637	18238	14	the	the	DT
18637	18238	15	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	18238	16	of	of	IN
18637	18238	17	the	the	DT
18637	18238	18	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18238	19	Interpleader	Interpleader	NNP
18637	18238	20	Act,[38	Act,[38	NNP
18637	18238	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18238	22	so	so	IN
18637	18238	23	as	as	IN
18637	18238	24	to	to	TO
18637	18238	25	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18238	26	taxpayers	taxpayer	NNS
18637	18238	27	from	from	IN
18637	18238	28	enjoining	enjoin	VBG
18637	18238	29	tax	tax	NN
18637	18238	30	officials	official	NNS
18637	18238	31	from	from	IN
18637	18238	32	collecting	collect	VBG
18637	18238	33	death	death	NN
18637	18238	34	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18238	35	arising	arise	VBG
18637	18238	36	from	from	IN
18637	18238	37	the	the	DT
18637	18238	38	competing	compete	VBG
18637	18238	39	claims	claim	NNS
18637	18238	40	of	of	IN
18637	18238	41	two	two	CD
18637	18238	42	States	States	NNPS
18637	18238	43	as	as	IN
18637	18238	44	being	be	VBG
18637	18238	45	the	the	DT
18637	18238	46	last	last	JJ
18637	18238	47	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	18238	48	of	of	IN
18637	18238	49	a	a	DT
18637	18238	50	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	18238	51	.	.	.
18637	18239	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18239	2	39	39	CD
18637	18239	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18239	4	On	on	IN
18637	18239	5	the	the	DT
18637	18239	6	other	other	JJ
18637	18239	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	18239	8	,	,	,
18637	18239	9	the	the	DT
18637	18239	10	Eleventh	Eleventh	NNP
18637	18239	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18239	12	was	be	VBD
18637	18239	13	held	hold	VBN
18637	18239	14	not	not	RB
18637	18239	15	to	to	TO
18637	18239	16	be	be	VB
18637	18239	17	infringed	infringe	VBN
18637	18239	18	by	by	IN
18637	18239	19	joinder	joinder	NN
18637	18239	20	of	of	IN
18637	18239	21	a	a	DT
18637	18239	22	State	State	NNP
18637	18239	23	court	court	NN
18637	18239	24	judge	judge	NN
18637	18239	25	and	and	CC
18637	18239	26	receiver	receiver	VB
18637	18239	27	in	in	IN
18637	18239	28	an	an	DT
18637	18239	29	interpleader	interpleader	NN
18637	18239	30	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	18239	31	in	in	IN
18637	18239	32	which	which	WDT
18637	18239	33	the	the	DT
18637	18239	34	State	State	NNP
18637	18239	35	had	have	VBD
18637	18239	36	no	no	DT
18637	18239	37	interest	interest	NN
18637	18239	38	and	and	CC
18637	18239	39	neither	neither	CC
18637	18239	40	the	the	DT
18637	18239	41	judge	judge	NN
18637	18239	42	nor	nor	CC
18637	18239	43	the	the	DT
18637	18239	44	receiver	receiver	NN
18637	18239	45	was	be	VBD
18637	18239	46	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
18637	18239	47	by	by	IN
18637	18239	48	the	the	DT
18637	18239	49	final	final	JJ
18637	18239	50	decree	decree	NN
18637	18239	51	.	.	.
18637	18240	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18240	2	40	40	CD
18637	18240	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18240	4	Tort	Tort	NNP
18637	18240	5	Actions	Actions	NNP
18637	18240	6	Against	against	IN
18637	18240	7	State	State	NNP
18637	18240	8	Officials	Officials	NNPS
18637	18240	9	In	in	IN
18637	18240	10	tort	tort	NN
18637	18240	11	actions	action	NNS
18637	18240	12	against	against	IN
18637	18240	13	State	State	NNP
18637	18240	14	officials	official	NNS
18637	18240	15	the	the	DT
18637	18240	16	rule	rule	NN
18637	18240	17	of	of	IN
18637	18240	18	United	United	NNP
18637	18240	19	States	States	NNP
18637	18240	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18240	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	18240	22	_	_	NNP
18637	18240	23	Lee[41	Lee[41	NNP
18637	18240	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18240	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	18240	26	been	be	VBN
18637	18240	27	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	18240	28	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	18240	29	into	into	IN
18637	18240	30	the	the	DT
18637	18240	31	Eleventh	Eleventh	NNP
18637	18240	32	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18240	33	.	.	.
18637	18241	1	In	in	IN
18637	18241	2	Tindal	Tindal	NNP
18637	18241	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18241	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	18241	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18241	6	Wesley[42	Wesley[42	NNP
18637	18241	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18241	8	the	the	DT
18637	18241	9	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	18241	10	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18241	11	was	be	VBD
18637	18241	12	held	hold	VBN
18637	18241	13	to	to	TO
18637	18241	14	permit	permit	VB
18637	18241	15	a	a	DT
18637	18241	16	suit	suit	NN
18637	18241	17	by	by	IN
18637	18241	18	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	18241	19	to	to	IN
18637	18241	20	real	real	JJ
18637	18241	21	property	property	NN
18637	18241	22	in	in	IN
18637	18241	23	South	South	NNP
18637	18241	24	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	18241	25	which	which	WDT
18637	18241	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18241	27	had	have	VBD
18637	18241	28	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	18241	29	from	from	IN
18637	18241	30	the	the	DT
18637	18241	31	State	State	NNP
18637	18241	32	sinking	sink	VBG
18637	18241	33	fund	fund	NN
18637	18241	34	commission	commission	NN
18637	18241	35	but	but	CC
18637	18241	36	which	which	WDT
18637	18241	37	had	have	VBD
18637	18241	38	been	be	VBN
18637	18241	39	retaken	retake	VBN
18637	18241	40	by	by	IN
18637	18241	41	the	the	DT
18637	18241	42	State	State	NNP
18637	18241	43	because	because	IN
18637	18241	44	the	the	DT
18637	18241	45	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	18241	46	insisted	insist	VBD
18637	18241	47	on	on	IN
18637	18241	48	paying	pay	VBG
18637	18241	49	for	for	IN
18637	18241	50	the	the	DT
18637	18241	51	property	property	NN
18637	18241	52	with	with	IN
18637	18241	53	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	18241	54	bond	bond	NN
18637	18241	55	scrip	scrip	NNP
18637	18241	56	issued	issue	VBN
18637	18241	57	by	by	IN
18637	18241	58	the	the	DT
18637	18241	59	State	State	NNP
18637	18241	60	.	.	.
18637	18242	1	In	in	IN
18637	18242	2	other	other	JJ
18637	18242	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	18242	4	the	the	DT
18637	18242	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18242	6	had	have	VBD
18637	18242	7	held	hold	VBN
18637	18242	8	that	that	IN
18637	18242	9	the	the	DT
18637	18242	10	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	18242	11	of	of	IN
18637	18242	12	a	a	DT
18637	18242	13	State	State	NNP
18637	18242	14	from	from	IN
18637	18242	15	suit	suit	NN
18637	18242	16	does	do	VBZ
18637	18242	17	not	not	RB
18637	18242	18	extend	extend	VB
18637	18242	19	to	to	IN
18637	18242	20	actions	action	NNS
18637	18242	21	against	against	IN
18637	18242	22	State	State	NNP
18637	18242	23	officials	official	NNS
18637	18242	24	for	for	IN
18637	18242	25	damages	damage	NNS
18637	18242	26	arising	arise	VBG
18637	18242	27	out	out	IN
18637	18242	28	of	of	IN
18637	18242	29	willful	willful	JJ
18637	18242	30	and	and	CC
18637	18242	31	negligent	negligent	JJ
18637	18242	32	disregard	disregard	NN
18637	18242	33	of	of	IN
18637	18242	34	State	State	NNP
18637	18242	35	laws	law	NNS
18637	18242	36	.	.	.
18637	18243	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18243	2	43	43	CD
18637	18243	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18243	4	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	18243	5	to	to	IN
18637	18243	6	Recover	recover	VB
18637	18243	7	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18243	8	Recent	recent	JJ
18637	18243	9	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	18243	10	,	,	,
18637	18243	11	however	however	RB
18637	18243	12	,	,	,
18637	18243	13	have	have	VBP
18637	18243	14	rendered	render	VBN
18637	18243	15	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18243	16	against	against	IN
18637	18243	17	State	State	NNP
18637	18243	18	officials	official	NNS
18637	18243	19	to	to	TO
18637	18243	20	recover	recover	VB
18637	18243	21	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18243	22	increasingly	increasingly	RB
18637	18243	23	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	18243	24	to	to	TO
18637	18243	25	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	18243	26	.	.	.
18637	18244	1	Although	although	IN
18637	18244	2	the	the	DT
18637	18244	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18244	4	long	long	RB
18637	18244	5	ago	ago	RB
18637	18244	6	held	hold	VBD
18637	18244	7	that	that	IN
18637	18244	8	the	the	DT
18637	18244	9	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	18244	10	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	18244	11	of	of	IN
18637	18244	12	the	the	DT
18637	18244	13	State	State	NNP
18637	18244	14	prevented	prevent	VBD
18637	18244	15	a	a	DT
18637	18244	16	suit	suit	NN
18637	18244	17	to	to	TO
18637	18244	18	recover	recover	VB
18637	18244	19	money	money	NN
18637	18244	20	in	in	IN
18637	18244	21	the	the	DT
18637	18244	22	general	general	JJ
18637	18244	23	treasury,[44	treasury,[44	CD
18637	18244	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18244	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18244	26	also	also	RB
18637	18244	27	held	hold	VBD
18637	18244	28	that	that	IN
18637	18244	29	a	a	DT
18637	18244	30	suit	suit	NN
18637	18244	31	would	would	MD
18637	18244	32	lie	lie	VB
18637	18244	33	against	against	IN
18637	18244	34	a	a	DT
18637	18244	35	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	18244	36	officer	officer	NN
18637	18244	37	to	to	TO
18637	18244	38	recover	recover	VB
18637	18244	39	tax	tax	NN
18637	18244	40	moneys	money	NNS
18637	18244	41	illegally	illegally	RB
18637	18244	42	collected	collect	VBN
18637	18244	43	and	and	CC
18637	18244	44	still	still	RB
18637	18244	45	in	in	IN
18637	18244	46	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18244	47	possession	possession	NN
18637	18244	48	.	.	.
18637	18245	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18245	2	45	45	CD
18637	18245	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18245	4	Beginning	begin	VBG
18637	18245	5	,	,	,
18637	18245	6	however	however	RB
18637	18245	7	,	,	,
18637	18245	8	with	with	IN
18637	18245	9	Great	Great	NNP
18637	18245	10	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	18245	11	Life	Life	NNP
18637	18245	12	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	18245	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18245	14	_	_	NNP
18637	18245	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	18245	16	_	_	NNP
18637	18245	17	Read[46	Read[46	NNP
18637	18245	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18245	19	in	in	IN
18637	18245	20	1944	1944	CD
18637	18245	21	the	the	DT
18637	18245	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18245	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	18245	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	18245	25	that	that	IN
18637	18245	26	this	this	DT
18637	18245	27	kind	kind	NN
18637	18245	28	of	of	IN
18637	18245	29	suit	suit	NN
18637	18245	30	can	can	MD
18637	18245	31	not	not	RB
18637	18245	32	be	be	VB
18637	18245	33	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	18245	34	unless	unless	IN
18637	18245	35	the	the	DT
18637	18245	36	State	State	NNP
18637	18245	37	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	18245	38	consents	consent	VBZ
18637	18245	39	to	to	IN
18637	18245	40	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18245	41	in	in	IN
18637	18245	42	the	the	DT
18637	18245	43	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18245	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	18245	45	.	.	.
18637	18246	1	In	in	IN
18637	18246	2	this	this	DT
18637	18246	3	case	case	NN
18637	18246	4	the	the	DT
18637	18246	5	State	State	NNP
18637	18246	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	18246	7	provided	provide	VBN
18637	18246	8	for	for	IN
18637	18246	9	the	the	DT
18637	18246	10	payment	payment	NN
18637	18246	11	of	of	IN
18637	18246	12	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18246	13	under	under	IN
18637	18246	14	protest	protest	NN
18637	18246	15	and	and	CC
18637	18246	16	for	for	IN
18637	18246	17	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18246	18	afterwards	afterwards	RB
18637	18246	19	against	against	IN
18637	18246	20	State	state	NN
18637	18246	21	tax	tax	NN
18637	18246	22	collection	collection	NN
18637	18246	23	officials	official	NNS
18637	18246	24	for	for	IN
18637	18246	25	the	the	DT
18637	18246	26	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	18246	27	of	of	IN
18637	18246	28	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18246	29	illegally	illegally	RB
18637	18246	30	collected	collect	VBN
18637	18246	31	.	.	.
18637	18247	1	The	the	DT
18637	18247	2	act	act	NN
18637	18247	3	also	also	RB
18637	18247	4	provided	provide	VBD
18637	18247	5	for	for	IN
18637	18247	6	the	the	DT
18637	18247	7	segregation	segregation	NN
18637	18247	8	by	by	IN
18637	18247	9	the	the	DT
18637	18247	10	collector	collector	NN
18637	18247	11	of	of	IN
18637	18247	12	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18247	13	paid	pay	VBN
18637	18247	14	under	under	IN
18637	18247	15	protest	protest	NN
18637	18247	16	.	.	.
18637	18248	1	The	the	DT
18637	18248	2	Read	Read	NNP
18637	18248	3	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18248	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	18248	5	been	be	VBN
18637	18248	6	followed	follow	VBN
18637	18248	7	in	in	IN
18637	18248	8	two	two	CD
18637	18248	9	more	more	JJR
18637	18248	10	recent	recent	JJ
18637	18248	11	cases[47	cases[47	NN
18637	18248	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18248	13	involving	involve	VBG
18637	18248	14	a	a	DT
18637	18248	15	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18248	16	state	state	NN
18637	18248	17	of	of	IN
18637	18248	18	facts	fact	NNS
18637	18248	19	,	,	,
18637	18248	20	with	with	IN
18637	18248	21	the	the	DT
18637	18248	22	result	result	NN
18637	18248	23	that	that	IN
18637	18248	24	the	the	DT
18637	18248	25	rule	rule	NN
18637	18248	26	once	once	RB
18637	18248	27	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	18248	28	such	such	JJ
18637	18248	29	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18248	30	to	to	TO
18637	18248	31	recover	recover	VB
18637	18248	32	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18248	33	from	from	IN
18637	18248	34	a	a	DT
18637	18248	35	segregated	segregated	JJ
18637	18248	36	fund	fund	NN
18637	18248	37	has	have	VBZ
18637	18248	38	been	be	VBN
18637	18248	39	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	18248	40	away	away	RB
18637	18248	41	.	.	.
18637	18249	1	Consent	Consent	NNP
18637	18249	2	of	of	IN
18637	18249	3	State	State	NNP
18637	18249	4	to	to	TO
18637	18249	5	be	be	VB
18637	18249	6	Sued	sue	VBN
18637	18249	7	Although	although	IN
18637	18249	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18249	9	dicta	dicta	NN
18637	18249	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18249	11	in	in	IN
18637	18249	12	some	some	DT
18637	18249	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	18249	14	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	18249	15	that	that	IN
18637	18249	16	once	once	RB
18637	18249	17	a	a	DT
18637	18249	18	State	state	NN
18637	18249	19	consented	consent	VBD
18637	18249	20	generally	generally	RB
18637	18249	21	to	to	TO
18637	18249	22	be	be	VB
18637	18249	23	sued	sue	VBN
18637	18249	24	in	in	IN
18637	18249	25	a	a	DT
18637	18249	26	court	court	NN
18637	18249	27	of	of	IN
18637	18249	28	competent	competent	JJ
18637	18249	29	jurisdiction,[48	jurisdiction,[48	NNP
18637	18249	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18249	31	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18249	32	could	could	MD
18637	18249	33	be	be	VB
18637	18249	34	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	18249	35	against	against	IN
18637	18249	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18249	37	in	in	IN
18637	18249	38	the	the	DT
18637	18249	39	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18249	40	courts	court	NNS
18637	18249	41	,	,	,
18637	18249	42	later	later	JJ
18637	18249	43	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	18249	44	involving	involve	VBG
18637	18249	45	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	18249	46	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	18249	47	for	for	IN
18637	18249	48	the	the	DT
18637	18249	49	payment	payment	NN
18637	18249	50	of	of	IN
18637	18249	51	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18249	52	under	under	IN
18637	18249	53	protest	protest	NN
18637	18249	54	followed	follow	VBN
18637	18249	55	by	by	IN
18637	18249	56	a	a	DT
18637	18249	57	suit	suit	NN
18637	18249	58	in	in	IN
18637	18249	59	a	a	DT
18637	18249	60	court	court	NN
18637	18249	61	of	of	IN
18637	18249	62	competent	competent	JJ
18637	18249	63	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18249	64	to	to	TO
18637	18249	65	recover	recover	VB
18637	18249	66	do	do	VBP
18637	18249	67	not	not	RB
18637	18249	68	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	18249	69	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18249	70	in	in	IN
18637	18249	71	the	the	DT
18637	18249	72	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18249	73	courts	court	NNS
18637	18249	74	.	.	.
18637	18250	1	These	these	DT
18637	18250	2	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	18250	3	are	be	VBP
18637	18250	4	based	base	VBN
18637	18250	5	on	on	IN
18637	18250	6	the	the	DT
18637	18250	7	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	18250	8	that	that	IN
18637	18250	9	when	when	WRB
18637	18250	10	the	the	DT
18637	18250	11	court	court	NN
18637	18250	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	18250	13	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	18250	14	"	"	``
18637	18250	15	with	with	IN
18637	18250	16	the	the	DT
18637	18250	17	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	18250	18	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	18250	19	from	from	IN
18637	18250	20	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18250	21	interference	interference	NN
18637	18250	22	in	in	IN
18637	18250	23	the	the	DT
18637	18250	24	vital	vital	JJ
18637	18250	25	field	field	NN
18637	18250	26	of	of	IN
18637	18250	27	financial	financial	JJ
18637	18250	28	administration	administration	NN
18637	18250	29	a	a	DT
18637	18250	30	clear	clear	JJ
18637	18250	31	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	18250	32	of	of	IN
18637	18250	33	the	the	DT
18637	18250	34	State	State	NNP
18637	18250	35	's	's	POS
18637	18250	36	intention	intention	NN
18637	18250	37	to	to	TO
18637	18250	38	submit	submit	VB
18637	18250	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18250	40	fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	18250	41	problems	problem	NNS
18637	18250	42	to	to	IN
18637	18250	43	other	other	JJ
18637	18250	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	18250	45	than	than	IN
18637	18250	46	those	those	DT
18637	18250	47	of	of	IN
18637	18250	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18250	49	own	own	JJ
18637	18250	50	creation	creation	NN
18637	18250	51	must	must	MD
18637	18250	52	be	be	VB
18637	18250	53	found	find	VBN
18637	18250	54	.	.	.
18637	18251	1	"	"	``
18637	18251	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18251	3	49	49	CD
18637	18251	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18251	5	Long	long	RB
18637	18251	6	before	before	IN
18637	18251	7	these	these	DT
18637	18251	8	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	18251	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18251	10	had	have	VBD
18637	18251	11	been	be	VBN
18637	18251	12	settled	settle	VBN
18637	18251	13	that	that	IN
18637	18251	14	a	a	DT
18637	18251	15	State	state	NN
18637	18251	16	could	could	MD
18637	18251	17	confine	confine	VB
18637	18251	18	to	to	IN
18637	18251	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18251	20	own	own	JJ
18637	18251	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	18251	22	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18251	23	against	against	IN
18637	18251	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18251	25	to	to	TO
18637	18251	26	recover	recover	VB
18637	18251	27	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18251	28	.	.	.
18637	18252	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18252	2	50	50	CD
18637	18252	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18252	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18252	5	the	the	DT
18637	18252	6	questions	question	NNS
18637	18252	7	involved	involve	VBN
18637	18252	8	in	in	IN
18637	18252	9	the	the	DT
18637	18252	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	18252	11	laying	lay	VBG
18637	18252	12	down	down	RP
18637	18252	13	the	the	DT
18637	18252	14	above	above	JJ
18637	18252	15	rule	rule	NN
18637	18252	16	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	18252	17	only	only	RB
18637	18252	18	the	the	DT
18637	18252	19	lack	lack	NN
18637	18252	20	of	of	IN
18637	18252	21	an	an	DT
18637	18252	22	express	express	JJ
18637	18252	23	consent	consent	NN
18637	18252	24	to	to	TO
18637	18252	25	suit	suit	VB
18637	18252	26	in	in	IN
18637	18252	27	the	the	DT
18637	18252	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18252	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	18252	30	.	.	.
18637	18253	1	Waiver	waiver	NN
18637	18253	2	of	of	IN
18637	18253	3	Immunity	immunity	NN
18637	18253	4	The	the	DT
18637	18253	5	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	18253	6	of	of	IN
18637	18253	7	a	a	DT
18637	18253	8	State	state	NN
18637	18253	9	from	from	IN
18637	18253	10	suit	suit	NN
18637	18253	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	18253	12	a	a	DT
18637	18253	13	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18253	14	which	which	WDT
18637	18253	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18253	16	may	may	MD
18637	18253	17	waive	waive	VB
18637	18253	18	at	at	IN
18637	18253	19	pleasure	pleasure	NN
18637	18253	20	by	by	IN
18637	18253	21	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	18253	22	submission	submission	NN
18637	18253	23	to	to	IN
18637	18253	24	suit,[51	suit,[51	ADD
18637	18253	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18253	26	as	as	IN
18637	18253	27	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	18253	28	from	from	IN
18637	18253	29	appearing	appear	VBG
18637	18253	30	in	in	IN
18637	18253	31	a	a	DT
18637	18253	32	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18253	33	suit	suit	NN
18637	18253	34	to	to	TO
18637	18253	35	defend	defend	VB
18637	18253	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18253	37	officials,[52	officials,[52	CD
18637	18253	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18253	39	and	and	CC
18637	18253	40	by	by	IN
18637	18253	41	general	general	JJ
18637	18253	42	law	law	NN
18637	18253	43	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	18253	44	consenting	consent	VBG
18637	18253	45	to	to	TO
18637	18253	46	suit	suit	VB
18637	18253	47	in	in	IN
18637	18253	48	the	the	DT
18637	18253	49	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18253	50	courts	court	NNS
18637	18253	51	.	.	.
18637	18254	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	18254	2	consent	consent	NN
18637	18254	3	must	must	MD
18637	18254	4	be	be	VB
18637	18254	5	clear	clear	JJ
18637	18254	6	and	and	CC
18637	18254	7	specific	specific	JJ
18637	18254	8	and	and	CC
18637	18254	9	consent	consent	NN
18637	18254	10	to	to	TO
18637	18254	11	suit	suit	VB
18637	18254	12	in	in	IN
18637	18254	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18254	14	own	own	JJ
18637	18254	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	18254	16	does	do	VBZ
18637	18254	17	not	not	RB
18637	18254	18	imply	imply	VB
18637	18254	19	a	a	DT
18637	18254	20	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	18254	21	of	of	IN
18637	18254	22	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	18254	23	in	in	IN
18637	18254	24	the	the	DT
18637	18254	25	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18254	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	18254	27	.	.	.
18637	18255	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18255	2	53	53	CD
18637	18255	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18255	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18255	5	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	18255	6	,	,	,
18637	18255	7	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	18255	8	,	,	,
18637	18255	9	that	that	IN
18637	18255	10	in	in	IN
18637	18255	11	consenting	consent	VBG
18637	18255	12	to	to	TO
18637	18255	13	be	be	VB
18637	18255	14	sued	sue	VBN
18637	18255	15	,	,	,
18637	18255	16	the	the	DT
18637	18255	17	States	States	NNPS
18637	18255	18	,	,	,
18637	18255	19	like	like	IN
18637	18255	20	the	the	DT
18637	18255	21	National	National	NNP
18637	18255	22	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18255	23	,	,	,
18637	18255	24	may	may	MD
18637	18255	25	attach	attach	VB
18637	18255	26	such	such	JJ
18637	18255	27	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	18255	28	to	to	TO
18637	18255	29	suit	suit	VB
18637	18255	30	as	as	IN
18637	18255	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18255	32	deem	deem	VBP
18637	18255	33	fit	fit	JJ
18637	18255	34	.	.	.
18637	18256	1	Notes	note	NNS
18637	18256	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18256	3	1	1	CD
18637	18256	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18256	5	2	2	CD
18637	18256	6	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	18256	7	.	.	.
18637	18257	1	419	419	CD
18637	18257	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18257	3	1793	1793	CD
18637	18257	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18257	5	.	.	.
18637	18258	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18258	2	2	2	LS
18637	18258	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18258	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18258	5	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	18258	6	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	18258	7	in	in	IN
18637	18258	8	Larson	Larson	NNP
18637	18258	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18258	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	18258	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18258	12	Domestic	Domestic	NNP
18637	18258	13	&	&	CC
18637	18258	14	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	18258	15	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	18258	16	,	,	,
18637	18258	17	337	337	CD
18637	18258	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18258	19	682	682	CD
18637	18258	20	,	,	,
18637	18258	21	708	708	CD
18637	18258	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18258	23	1949	1949	CD
18637	18258	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18258	25	.	.	.
18637	18259	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18259	2	3	3	CD
18637	18259	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18259	4	6	6	CD
18637	18259	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	18259	6	.	.	.
18637	18260	1	264	264	CD
18637	18260	2	,	,	,
18637	18260	3	411	411	CD
18637	18260	4	-	-	SYM
18637	18260	5	412	412	CD
18637	18260	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18260	7	1821	1821	CD
18637	18260	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18260	9	.	.	.
18637	18261	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18261	2	4	4	CD
18637	18261	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18261	4	9	9	CD
18637	18261	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	18261	6	.	.	.
18637	18262	1	738	738	CD
18637	18262	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18262	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	18262	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18262	5	.	.	.
18637	18263	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18263	2	5	5	CD
18637	18263	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18263	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18263	5	.	.	.
18637	18264	1	850	850	CD
18637	18264	2	-	-	SYM
18637	18264	3	858	858	CD
18637	18264	4	.	.	.
18637	18265	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18265	2	6	6	CD
18637	18265	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18265	4	1	1	CD
18637	18265	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	18265	6	.	.	.
18637	18266	1	110	110	CD
18637	18266	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18266	3	1828	1828	CD
18637	18266	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18266	5	.	.	.
18637	18267	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18267	2	7	7	LS
18637	18267	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18267	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	18267	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	18267	6	Ayers	Ayers	NNP
18637	18267	7	,	,	,
18637	18267	8	123	123	CD
18637	18267	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18267	10	443	443	CD
18637	18267	11	,	,	,
18637	18267	12	487	487	CD
18637	18267	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18267	14	1887	1887	CD
18637	18267	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18267	16	.	.	.
18637	18268	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18268	2	8	8	CD
18637	18268	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18268	4	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	18268	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18268	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18268	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18268	8	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	18268	9	of	of	IN
18637	18268	10	the	the	DT
18637	18268	11	United	United	NNP
18637	18268	12	States	States	NNP
18637	18268	13	,	,	,
18637	18268	14	9	9	CD
18637	18268	15	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	18268	16	.	.	.
18637	18269	1	at	at	IN
18637	18269	2	858	858	CD
18637	18269	3	,	,	,
18637	18269	4	859	859	CD
18637	18269	5	,	,	,
18637	18269	6	868	868	CD
18637	18269	7	.	.	.
18637	18270	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18270	2	9	9	CD
18637	18270	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18270	4	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	18270	5	County	County	NNP
18637	18270	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18270	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18270	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18270	9	Luning	Luning	NNP
18637	18270	10	,	,	,
18637	18270	11	133	133	CD
18637	18270	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18270	13	529	529	CD
18637	18270	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18270	15	1890	1890	CD
18637	18270	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18270	17	.	.	.
18637	18271	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18271	2	10	10	CD
18637	18271	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18271	4	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	18271	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18271	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18271	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18271	8	Clemson	Clemson	NNP
18637	18271	9	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	18271	10	College	College	NNP
18637	18271	11	,	,	,
18637	18271	12	221	221	CD
18637	18271	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18271	14	636	636	CD
18637	18271	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18271	16	1911	1911	CD
18637	18271	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18271	18	.	.	.
18637	18272	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18272	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18272	3	also	also	RB
18637	18272	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18272	5	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	18272	6	of	of	IN
18637	18272	7	the	the	DT
18637	18272	8	United	United	NNP
18637	18272	9	States	States	NNP
18637	18272	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18272	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	18272	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18272	13	Planters	Planters	NNPS
18637	18272	14	'	'	POS
18637	18272	15	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	18272	16	of	of	IN
18637	18272	17	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	18272	18	,	,	,
18637	18272	19	9	9	CD
18637	18272	20	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	18272	21	.	.	.
18637	18273	1	904	904	CD
18637	18273	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18273	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	18273	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18273	5	,	,	,
18637	18273	6	where	where	WRB
18637	18273	7	a	a	DT
18637	18273	8	State	State	NNP
18637	18273	9	bank	bank	NN
18637	18273	10	was	be	VBD
18637	18273	11	held	hold	VBN
18637	18273	12	liable	liable	JJ
18637	18273	13	to	to	TO
18637	18273	14	suit	suit	VB
18637	18273	15	although	although	IN
18637	18273	16	the	the	DT
18637	18273	17	State	State	NNP
18637	18273	18	owned	own	VBD
18637	18273	19	a	a	DT
18637	18273	20	portion	portion	NN
18637	18273	21	of	of	IN
18637	18273	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18273	23	stock	stock	NN
18637	18273	24	,	,	,
18637	18273	25	and	and	CC
18637	18273	26	Briscoe	Briscoe	NNP
18637	18273	27	_	_	NNP
18637	18273	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	18273	29	_	_	NNP
18637	18273	30	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	18273	31	of	of	IN
18637	18273	32	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	18273	33	,	,	,
18637	18273	34	11	11	CD
18637	18273	35	Pet	pet	NN
18637	18273	36	.	.	.
18637	18274	1	257	257	CD
18637	18274	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18274	3	1837	1837	CD
18637	18274	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18274	5	,	,	,
18637	18274	6	and	and	CC
18637	18274	7	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	18274	8	of	of	IN
18637	18274	9	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	18274	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18274	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	18274	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18274	13	Wister	Wister	NNP
18637	18274	14	,	,	,
18637	18274	15	2	2	CD
18637	18274	16	Pet	pet	NN
18637	18274	17	.	.	.
18637	18275	1	318	318	CD
18637	18275	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18275	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	18275	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18275	5	,	,	,
18637	18275	6	where	where	WRB
18637	18275	7	the	the	DT
18637	18275	8	State	State	NNP
18637	18275	9	bank	bank	NN
18637	18275	10	was	be	VBD
18637	18275	11	held	hold	VBN
18637	18275	12	liable	liable	JJ
18637	18275	13	to	to	TO
18637	18275	14	suit	suit	VB
18637	18275	15	even	even	RB
18637	18275	16	though	though	IN
18637	18275	17	the	the	DT
18637	18275	18	State	state	NN
18637	18275	19	owned	own	VBD
18637	18275	20	all	all	DT
18637	18275	21	of	of	IN
18637	18275	22	the	the	DT
18637	18275	23	stock	stock	NN
18637	18275	24	.	.	.
18637	18276	1	Compare	compare	VB
18637	18276	2	,	,	,
18637	18276	3	however	however	RB
18637	18276	4	,	,	,
18637	18276	5	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	18276	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18276	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18276	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18276	9	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	18276	10	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	18276	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18276	12	,	,	,
18637	18276	13	213	213	CD
18637	18276	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18276	15	151	151	CD
18637	18276	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18276	17	1909	1909	CD
18637	18276	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18276	19	,	,	,
18637	18276	20	which	which	WDT
18637	18276	21	held	hold	VBD
18637	18276	22	that	that	IN
18637	18276	23	a	a	DT
18637	18276	24	State	state	NN
18637	18276	25	in	in	IN
18637	18276	26	engaging	engage	VBG
18637	18276	27	in	in	IN
18637	18276	28	the	the	DT
18637	18276	29	retail	retail	JJ
18637	18276	30	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	18276	31	business	business	NN
18637	18276	32	does	do	VBZ
18637	18276	33	not	not	RB
18637	18276	34	surrender	surrender	VB
18637	18276	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18276	36	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	18276	37	to	to	TO
18637	18276	38	suit	suit	VB
18637	18276	39	for	for	IN
18637	18276	40	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	18276	41	of	of	IN
18637	18276	42	a	a	DT
18637	18276	43	nongovernmental	nongovernmental	JJ
18637	18276	44	nature	nature	NN
18637	18276	45	.	.	.
18637	18277	1	Here	here	RB
18637	18277	2	the	the	DT
18637	18277	3	State	state	NN
18637	18277	4	conducted	conduct	VBD
18637	18277	5	the	the	DT
18637	18277	6	business	business	NN
18637	18277	7	directly	directly	RB
18637	18277	8	rather	rather	RB
18637	18277	9	than	than	IN
18637	18277	10	through	through	IN
18637	18277	11	the	the	DT
18637	18277	12	medium	medium	NN
18637	18277	13	of	of	IN
18637	18277	14	a	a	DT
18637	18277	15	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18277	16	.	.	.
18637	18278	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18278	2	11	11	CD
18637	18278	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18278	4	Hans	Hans	NNP
18637	18278	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18278	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18278	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18278	8	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	18278	9	,	,	,
18637	18278	10	134	134	CD
18637	18278	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18278	12	1	1	CD
18637	18278	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18278	14	1890	1890	CD
18637	18278	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18278	16	;	;	:
18637	18278	17	Fitts	Fitts	NNP
18637	18278	18	_	_	NNP
18637	18278	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	18278	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18278	21	McGhee	McGhee	NNP
18637	18278	22	,	,	,
18637	18278	23	172	172	CD
18637	18278	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18278	25	516	516	CD
18637	18278	26	,	,	,
18637	18278	27	524	524	CD
18637	18278	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18278	29	1899	1899	CD
18637	18278	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18278	31	;	;	:
18637	18278	32	Duhne	Duhne	NNP
18637	18278	33	_	_	NNP
18637	18278	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	18278	35	_	_	NNP
18637	18278	36	New	New	NNP
18637	18278	37	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	18278	38	,	,	,
18637	18278	39	251	251	CD
18637	18278	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18278	41	311	311	CD
18637	18278	42	,	,	,
18637	18278	43	313	313	CD
18637	18278	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18278	45	1920	1920	CD
18637	18278	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18278	47	;	;	:
18637	18278	48	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	18278	49	parte	parte	VBZ
18637	18278	50	New	New	NNP
18637	18278	51	York	York	NNP
18637	18278	52	,	,	,
18637	18278	53	256	256	CD
18637	18278	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18278	55	490	490	CD
18637	18278	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18278	57	1921	1921	CD
18637	18278	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18278	59	.	.	.
18637	18279	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18279	2	12	12	CD
18637	18279	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18279	4	Monaco	Monaco	NNP
18637	18279	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18279	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18279	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18279	8	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	18279	9	,	,	,
18637	18279	10	292	292	CD
18637	18279	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18279	12	313	313	CD
18637	18279	13	,	,	,
18637	18279	14	329	329	CD
18637	18279	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18279	16	1934	1934	CD
18637	18279	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18279	18	.	.	.
18637	18280	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18280	2	13	13	CD
18637	18280	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18280	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	18280	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18280	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18280	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18280	8	Reeves	Reeves	NNP
18637	18280	9	,	,	,
18637	18280	10	178	178	CD
18637	18280	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18280	12	436	436	CD
18637	18280	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18280	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	18280	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18280	16	.	.	.
18637	18281	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18281	2	14	14	CD
18637	18281	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18281	4	New	New	NNP
18637	18281	5	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	18281	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18281	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18281	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18281	9	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	18281	10	,	,	,
18637	18281	11	108	108	CD
18637	18281	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18281	13	76	76	CD
18637	18281	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18281	15	1883	1883	CD
18637	18281	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18281	17	.	.	.
18637	18282	1	However	however	RB
18637	18282	2	,	,	,
18637	18282	3	this	this	DT
18637	18282	4	rule	rule	NN
18637	18282	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	18282	6	not	not	RB
18637	18282	7	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	18282	8	a	a	DT
18637	18282	9	suit	suit	NN
18637	18282	10	by	by	IN
18637	18282	11	a	a	DT
18637	18282	12	State	State	NNP
18637	18282	13	to	to	TO
18637	18282	14	collect	collect	VB
18637	18282	15	debts	debt	NNS
18637	18282	16	which	which	WDT
18637	18282	17	have	have	VBP
18637	18282	18	been	be	VBN
18637	18282	19	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	18282	20	to	to	IN
18637	18282	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18282	22	and	and	CC
18637	18282	23	the	the	DT
18637	18282	24	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	18282	25	of	of	IN
18637	18282	26	which	which	WDT
18637	18282	27	will	will	MD
18637	18282	28	remain	remain	VB
18637	18282	29	with	with	IN
18637	18282	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18282	31	.	.	.
18637	18283	1	South	South	NNP
18637	18283	2	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	18283	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18283	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	18283	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18283	6	North	North	NNP
18637	18283	7	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	18283	8	,	,	,
18637	18283	9	192	192	CD
18637	18283	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18283	11	286	286	CD
18637	18283	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18283	13	1904	1904	CD
18637	18283	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18283	15	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18283	16	15	15	CD
18637	18283	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18283	18	134	134	CD
18637	18283	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18283	20	1	1	CD
18637	18283	21	,	,	,
18637	18283	22	11	11	CD
18637	18283	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18283	24	1890	1890	CD
18637	18283	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18283	26	.	.	.
18637	18284	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18284	2	16	16	CD
18637	18284	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18284	4	292	292	CD
18637	18284	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18284	6	313	313	CD
18637	18284	7	,	,	,
18637	18284	8	328	328	CD
18637	18284	9	-	-	SYM
18637	18284	10	332	332	CD
18637	18284	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18284	12	1934	1934	CD
18637	18284	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18284	14	.	.	.
18637	18285	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18285	2	17	17	CD
18637	18285	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18285	4	For	for	IN
18637	18285	5	the	the	DT
18637	18285	6	liability	liability	NN
18637	18285	7	of	of	IN
18637	18285	8	the	the	DT
18637	18285	9	States	States	NNPS
18637	18285	10	to	to	TO
18637	18285	11	suit	suit	VB
18637	18285	12	by	by	IN
18637	18285	13	the	the	DT
18637	18285	14	United	United	NNP
18637	18285	15	States	States	NNP
18637	18285	16	_	_	NNP
18637	18285	17	see	see	VBP
18637	18285	18	_	_	NNP
18637	18285	19	the	the	DT
18637	18285	20	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	18285	21	of	of	IN
18637	18285	22	the	the	DT
18637	18285	23	right	right	NN
18637	18285	24	of	of	IN
18637	18285	25	the	the	DT
18637	18285	26	United	United	NNP
18637	18285	27	States	States	NNP
18637	18285	28	to	to	TO
18637	18285	29	sue	sue	VB
18637	18285	30	under	under	IN
18637	18285	31	article	article	NN
18637	18285	32	III	III	NNP
18637	18285	33	,	,	,
18637	18285	34	§	â§	NN
18637	18285	35	2	2	CD
18637	18285	36	,	,	,
18637	18285	37	_	_	NNP
18637	18285	38	supra	supra	NNP
18637	18285	39	_	_	NNP
18637	18285	40	,	,	,
18637	18285	41	pp	pp	NNP
18637	18285	42	.	.	.
18637	18286	1	584	584	CD
18637	18286	2	-	-	SYM
18637	18286	3	585	585	CD
18637	18286	4	.	.	.
18637	18287	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18287	2	18	18	CD
18637	18287	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18287	4	Tindal	Tindal	NNP
18637	18287	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18287	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18287	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18287	8	Wesley	Wesley	NNP
18637	18287	9	,	,	,
18637	18287	10	167	167	CD
18637	18287	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18287	12	204	204	CD
18637	18287	13	,	,	,
18637	18287	14	213	213	CD
18637	18287	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18287	16	1897	1897	CD
18637	18287	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18287	18	.	.	.
18637	18288	1	This	this	DT
18637	18288	2	case	case	NN
18637	18288	3	applied	apply	VBD
18637	18288	4	the	the	DT
18637	18288	5	rule	rule	NN
18637	18288	6	of	of	IN
18637	18288	7	United	United	NNP
18637	18288	8	States	States	NNP
18637	18288	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18288	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	18288	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18288	12	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	18288	13	,	,	,
18637	18288	14	106	106	CD
18637	18288	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18288	16	196	196	CD
18637	18288	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18288	18	1882	1882	CD
18637	18288	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18288	20	,	,	,
18637	18288	21	to	to	IN
18637	18288	22	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18288	23	against	against	IN
18637	18288	24	States	States	NNP
18637	18288	25	.	.	.
18637	18289	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18289	2	19	19	CD
18637	18289	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18289	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18289	5	See	See	NNP
18637	18289	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18289	7	for	for	IN
18637	18289	8	example	example	NN
18637	18289	9	Larson	Larson	NNP
18637	18289	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18289	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	18289	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18289	13	Domestic	Domestic	NNP
18637	18289	14	&	&	CC
18637	18289	15	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	18289	16	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	18289	17	,	,	,
18637	18289	18	337	337	CD
18637	18289	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18289	20	682	682	CD
18637	18289	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18289	22	1949	1949	CD
18637	18289	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18289	24	,	,	,
18637	18289	25	where	where	WRB
18637	18289	26	both	both	CC
18637	18289	27	the	the	DT
18637	18289	28	majority	majority	NN
18637	18289	29	and	and	CC
18637	18289	30	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	18289	31	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	18289	32	utilize	utilize	VB
18637	18289	33	both	both	DT
18637	18289	34	types	type	NNS
18637	18289	35	of	of	IN
18637	18289	36	cases	case	NNS
18637	18289	37	in	in	IN
18637	18289	38	a	a	DT
18637	18289	39	suit	suit	NN
18637	18289	40	against	against	IN
18637	18289	41	a	a	DT
18637	18289	42	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18289	43	official	official	NN
18637	18289	44	.	.	.
18637	18290	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18290	2	20	20	CD
18637	18290	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18290	4	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
18637	18290	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18290	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18290	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18290	8	McConnaughy	McConnaughy	NNP
18637	18290	9	,	,	,
18637	18290	10	140	140	CD
18637	18290	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18290	12	1	1	CD
18637	18290	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18290	14	1891	1891	CD
18637	18290	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18290	16	;	;	:
18637	18290	17	Scully	scully	RB
18637	18290	18	_	_	NNP
18637	18290	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	18290	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18290	21	Bird	Bird	NNP
18637	18290	22	,	,	,
18637	18290	23	209	209	CD
18637	18290	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18290	25	481	481	CD
18637	18290	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18290	27	1908	1908	CD
18637	18290	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18290	29	;	;	:
18637	18290	30	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	18290	31	,	,	,
18637	18290	32	Topeka	Topeka	NNP
18637	18290	33	&	&	CC
18637	18290	34	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	18291	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18291	2	_	_	NNP
18637	18291	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	18291	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18291	5	O'Connor	O'Connor	NNP
18637	18291	6	,	,	,
18637	18291	7	223	223	CD
18637	18291	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18291	9	280	280	CD
18637	18291	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18291	11	1912	1912	CD
18637	18291	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18291	13	;	;	:
18637	18291	14	Greene	Greene	NNP
18637	18291	15	_	_	NNP
18637	18291	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	18291	17	_	_	NNP
18637	18291	18	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	18291	19	&	&	CC
18637	18291	20	I.R.	I.R.	NNP
18637	18292	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18292	2	,	,	,
18637	18292	3	244	244	CD
18637	18292	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18292	5	499	499	CD
18637	18292	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18292	7	1917	1917	CD
18637	18292	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18292	9	;	;	:
18637	18292	10	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	18292	11	&	&	CC
18637	18292	12	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	18292	13	R.	R.	NNP
18637	18292	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18292	15	_	_	NNP
18637	18292	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	18292	17	_	_	NNP
18637	18292	18	Greene	Greene	NNP
18637	18292	19	,	,	,
18637	18292	20	244	244	CD
18637	18292	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18292	22	522	522	CD
18637	18292	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18292	24	1917	1917	CD
18637	18292	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18292	26	.	.	.
18637	18293	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18293	2	21	21	CD
18637	18293	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18293	4	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	18293	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18293	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18293	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18293	8	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	18293	9	of	of	IN
18637	18293	10	the	the	DT
18637	18293	11	United	United	NNP
18637	18293	12	States	States	NNP
18637	18293	13	,	,	,
18637	18293	14	9	9	CD
18637	18293	15	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	18293	16	.	.	.
18637	18294	1	728	728	CD
18637	18294	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18294	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	18294	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18294	5	;	;	:
18637	18294	6	Board	Board	NNP
18637	18294	7	of	of	IN
18637	18294	8	Liquidation	Liquidation	NNP
18637	18294	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	18294	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	12	McComb	McComb	NNP
18637	18294	13	,	,	,
18637	18294	14	92	92	CD
18637	18294	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18294	16	531	531	CD
18637	18294	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18294	18	1876	1876	CD
18637	18294	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18294	20	;	;	:
18637	18294	21	Poindexter	Poindexter	NNP
18637	18294	22	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	18294	24	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	25	Greenhow	Greenhow	NNP
18637	18294	26	,	,	,
18637	18294	27	114	114	CD
18637	18294	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18294	29	270	270	CD
18637	18294	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18294	31	1885	1885	CD
18637	18294	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18294	33	;	;	:
18637	18294	34	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
18637	18294	35	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	18294	37	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	38	McConnaughy	McConnaughy	NNP
18637	18294	39	,	,	,
18637	18294	40	140	140	CD
18637	18294	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18294	42	1	1	CD
18637	18294	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18294	44	1891	1891	CD
18637	18294	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18294	46	;	;	:
18637	18294	47	Reagan	Reagan	NNP
18637	18294	48	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	18294	50	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	51	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	18294	52	'	'	POS
18637	18294	53	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	18294	54	&	&	CC
18637	18294	55	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	18294	56	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18294	57	,	,	,
18637	18294	58	154	154	CD
18637	18294	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18294	60	362	362	CD
18637	18294	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18294	62	1894	1894	CD
18637	18294	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18294	64	;	;	:
18637	18294	65	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
18637	18294	66	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	18294	68	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	69	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	18294	70	,	,	,
18637	18294	71	169	169	CD
18637	18294	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18294	73	466	466	CD
18637	18294	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18294	75	1898	1898	CD
18637	18294	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18294	77	;	;	:
18637	18294	78	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	18294	79	parte	parte	NN
18637	18294	80	Young	Young	NNP
18637	18294	81	,	,	,
18637	18294	82	209	209	CD
18637	18294	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18294	84	123	123	CD
18637	18294	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18294	86	1908	1908	CD
18637	18294	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18294	88	;	;	:
18637	18294	89	Truax	Truax	NNP
18637	18294	90	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	91	v.	v.	IN
18637	18294	92	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	93	Raich	Raich	NNP
18637	18294	94	,	,	,
18637	18294	95	239	239	CD
18637	18294	96	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18294	97	33	33	CD
18637	18294	98	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18294	99	1915	1915	CD
18637	18294	100	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18294	101	;	;	:
18637	18294	102	Public	Public	NNP
18637	18294	103	Service	Service	NNP
18637	18294	104	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18294	105	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	106	v.	v.	IN
18637	18294	107	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	108	Corboy	Corboy	NNP
18637	18294	109	,	,	,
18637	18294	110	250	250	CD
18637	18294	111	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18294	112	153	153	CD
18637	18294	113	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18294	114	1919	1919	CD
18637	18294	115	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18294	116	;	;	:
18637	18294	117	Sterling	Sterling	NNP
18637	18294	118	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	18294	120	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	121	Constantin	Constantin	NNP
18637	18294	122	,	,	,
18637	18294	123	287	287	CD
18637	18294	124	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18294	125	378	378	CD
18637	18294	126	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18294	127	1932	1932	CD
18637	18294	128	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18294	129	;	;	:
18637	18294	130	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	18294	131	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	132	v.	v.	IN
18637	18294	133	_	_	NNP
18637	18294	134	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	18294	135	,	,	,
18637	18294	136	16	16	CD
18637	18294	137	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	18294	138	.	.	.
18637	18295	1	203	203	CD
18637	18295	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18295	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	18295	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18295	5	;	;	:
18637	18295	6	Tomlinson	Tomlinson	NNP
18637	18295	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18295	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18295	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18295	10	Branch	Branch	NNP
18637	18295	11	,	,	,
18637	18295	12	15	15	CD
18637	18295	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	18295	14	.	.	.
18637	18296	1	460	460	CD
18637	18296	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18296	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	18296	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18296	5	;	;	:
18637	18296	6	Litchfield	Litchfield	NNP
18637	18296	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18296	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18296	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18296	10	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	18296	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18296	12	,	,	,
18637	18296	13	101	101	CD
18637	18296	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18296	15	773	773	CD
18637	18296	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18296	17	1880	1880	CD
18637	18296	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18296	19	;	;	:
18637	18296	20	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	18296	21	_	_	NNP
18637	18296	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	18296	23	_	_	NNP
18637	18296	24	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	18296	25	&	&	CC
18637	18296	26	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	18297	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18297	2	,	,	,
18637	18297	3	114	114	CD
18637	18297	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18297	5	311	311	CD
18637	18297	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18297	7	1885	1885	CD
18637	18297	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18297	9	;	;	:
18637	18297	10	Gunter	Gunter	NNP
18637	18297	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18297	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	18297	13	_	_	NNP
18637	18297	14	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	18297	15	C.L.R.	C.L.R.	NNP
18637	18298	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18298	2	,	,	,
18637	18298	3	200	200	CD
18637	18298	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18298	5	273	273	CD
18637	18298	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18298	7	1906	1906	CD
18637	18298	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18298	9	;	;	:
18637	18298	10	Prout	Prout	NNP
18637	18298	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18298	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	18298	13	_	_	NNP
18637	18298	14	Starr	Starr	NNP
18637	18298	15	,	,	,
18637	18298	16	188	188	CD
18637	18298	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18298	18	537	537	CD
18637	18298	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18298	20	1903	1903	CD
18637	18298	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18298	22	;	;	:
18637	18298	23	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	18298	24	_	_	NNP
18637	18298	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	18298	26	_	_	NNP
18637	18298	27	Donald	Donald	NNP
18637	18298	28	,	,	,
18637	18298	29	165	165	CD
18637	18298	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18298	31	58	58	CD
18637	18298	32	;	;	:
18637	18298	33	_	_	NNP
18637	18298	34	also	also	RB
18637	18298	35	_	_	NNP
18637	18298	36	165	165	CD
18637	18298	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18298	38	107	107	CD
18637	18298	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18298	40	1897	1897	CD
18637	18298	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18298	42	.	.	.
18637	18299	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18299	2	22	22	CD
18637	18299	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18299	4	South	South	NNP
18637	18299	5	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	18299	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18299	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18299	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18299	9	Wesley	Wesley	NNP
18637	18299	10	,	,	,
18637	18299	11	155	155	CD
18637	18299	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18299	13	542	542	CD
18637	18299	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18299	15	1895	1895	CD
18637	18299	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18299	17	;	;	:
18637	18299	18	Tindal	Tindal	NNP
18637	18299	19	_	_	NNP
18637	18299	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	18299	21	_	_	NNP
18637	18299	22	Wesley	Wesley	NNP
18637	18299	23	,	,	,
18637	18299	24	167	167	CD
18637	18299	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18299	26	204	204	CD
18637	18299	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18299	28	1897	1897	CD
18637	18299	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18299	30	;	;	:
18637	18299	31	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	18299	32	_	_	NNP
18637	18299	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	18299	34	_	_	NNP
18637	18299	35	Clemson	Clemson	NNP
18637	18299	36	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	18299	37	College	College	NNP
18637	18299	38	,	,	,
18637	18299	39	221	221	CD
18637	18299	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18299	41	636	636	CD
18637	18299	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18299	43	1911	1911	CD
18637	18299	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18299	45	.	.	.
18637	18300	1	In	in	IN
18637	18300	2	this	this	DT
18637	18300	3	last	last	JJ
18637	18300	4	case	case	NN
18637	18300	5	the	the	DT
18637	18300	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18300	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	18300	8	that	that	IN
18637	18300	9	a	a	DT
18637	18300	10	suit	suit	NN
18637	18300	11	would	would	MD
18637	18300	12	lie	lie	VB
18637	18300	13	against	against	IN
18637	18300	14	the	the	DT
18637	18300	15	State	State	NNP
18637	18300	16	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	18300	17	College	College	NNP
18637	18300	18	,	,	,
18637	18300	19	and	and	CC
18637	18300	20	relief	relief	NN
18637	18300	21	could	could	MD
18637	18300	22	be	be	VB
18637	18300	23	granted	grant	VBN
18637	18300	24	to	to	IN
18637	18300	25	the	the	DT
18637	18300	26	extent	extent	NN
18637	18300	27	that	that	IN
18637	18300	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18300	29	would	would	MD
18637	18300	30	not	not	RB
18637	18300	31	affect	affect	VB
18637	18300	32	the	the	DT
18637	18300	33	property	property	NN
18637	18300	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	18300	35	of	of	IN
18637	18300	36	the	the	DT
18637	18300	37	State	State	NNP
18637	18300	38	.	.	.
18637	18301	1	These	these	DT
18637	18301	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	18301	3	involve	involve	VBP
18637	18301	4	such	such	JJ
18637	18301	5	matters	matter	NNS
18637	18301	6	as	as	IN
18637	18301	7	the	the	DT
18637	18301	8	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	18301	9	and	and	CC
18637	18301	10	distraint	distraint	NN
18637	18301	11	of	of	IN
18637	18301	12	property	property	NN
18637	18301	13	,	,	,
18637	18301	14	wrongs	wrong	NNS
18637	18301	15	done	do	VBN
18637	18301	16	by	by	IN
18637	18301	17	government	government	NN
18637	18301	18	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18301	19	,	,	,
18637	18301	20	etc	etc	FW
18637	18301	21	.	.	.
18637	18302	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18302	2	23	23	CD
18637	18302	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18302	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18302	5	See	See	NNP
18637	18302	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18302	7	for	for	IN
18637	18302	8	example	example	NN
18637	18302	9	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	18302	10	of	of	IN
18637	18302	11	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	18302	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18302	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	18302	14	_	_	NNP
18637	18302	15	Madrazo	Madrazo	NNP
18637	18302	16	,	,	,
18637	18302	17	1	1	CD
18637	18302	18	Pet	pet	NN
18637	18302	19	.	.	.
18637	18303	1	110	110	CD
18637	18303	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18303	3	1828	1828	CD
18637	18303	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18303	5	;	;	:
18637	18303	6	Cunningham	Cunningham	NNP
18637	18303	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18303	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18303	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18303	10	Macon	Macon	NNP
18637	18303	11	and	and	CC
18637	18303	12	Brunswick	Brunswick	NNP
18637	18303	13	R.	R.	NNP
18637	18303	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18303	15	,	,	,
18637	18303	16	109	109	CD
18637	18303	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18303	18	446	446	CD
18637	18303	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18303	20	1883	1883	CD
18637	18303	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18303	22	;	;	:
18637	18303	23	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	18303	24	ex	ex	NNP
18637	18303	25	rel	rel	NN
18637	18303	26	.	.	.
18637	18304	1	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	18304	2	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	18304	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	5	Jumel	Jumel	NNP
18637	18304	6	,	,	,
18637	18304	7	107	107	CD
18637	18304	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18304	9	711	711	CD
18637	18304	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18304	11	1883	1883	CD
18637	18304	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18304	13	;	;	:
18637	18304	14	Hagood	Hagood	NNP
18637	18304	15	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	18304	17	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	18	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	18304	19	,	,	,
18637	18304	20	117	117	CD
18637	18304	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18304	22	52	52	CD
18637	18304	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18304	24	1886	1886	CD
18637	18304	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18304	26	;	;	:
18637	18304	27	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	18304	28	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	18304	30	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	31	Dix	Dix	NNP
18637	18304	32	,	,	,
18637	18304	33	194	194	CD
18637	18304	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18304	35	590	590	CD
18637	18304	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18304	37	1904	1904	CD
18637	18304	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18304	39	;	;	:
18637	18304	40	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	18304	41	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	18304	43	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	44	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	18304	45	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	18304	46	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18304	47	,	,	,
18637	18304	48	213	213	CD
18637	18304	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18304	50	151	151	CD
18637	18304	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18304	52	1909	1909	CD
18637	18304	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18304	54	;	;	:
18637	18304	55	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	18304	56	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	18304	58	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	59	Clemson	Clemson	NNP
18637	18304	60	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	18304	61	College	College	NNP
18637	18304	62	,	,	,
18637	18304	63	221	221	CD
18637	18304	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18304	65	636	636	CD
18637	18304	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18304	67	1911	1911	CD
18637	18304	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18304	69	;	;	:
18637	18304	70	Lankford	Lankford	NNP
18637	18304	71	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	18304	73	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	74	Platte	Platte	NNP
18637	18304	75	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	18304	76	Works	Works	NNP
18637	18304	77	,	,	,
18637	18304	78	235	235	CD
18637	18304	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18304	80	461	461	CD
18637	18304	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18304	82	1915	1915	CD
18637	18304	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18304	84	;	;	:
18637	18304	85	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	18304	86	Glass	Glass	NNP
18637	18304	87	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18304	88	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	18304	90	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	91	South	South	NNP
18637	18304	92	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	18304	93	,	,	,
18637	18304	94	240	240	CD
18637	18304	95	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18304	96	305	305	CD
18637	18304	97	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18304	98	1916	1916	CD
18637	18304	99	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18304	100	;	;	:
18637	18304	101	Kennecott	Kennecott	NNP
18637	18304	102	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	18304	103	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	18304	104	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	105	v.	v.	IN
18637	18304	106	_	_	NNP
18637	18304	107	State	State	NNP
18637	18304	108	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	18304	109	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18304	110	,	,	,
18637	18304	111	327	327	CD
18637	18304	112	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18304	113	573	573	CD
18637	18304	114	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18304	115	1946	1946	CD
18637	18304	116	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18304	117	.	.	.
18637	18305	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18305	2	24	24	CD
18637	18305	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18305	4	Hagood	Hagood	NNP
18637	18305	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18305	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18305	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18305	8	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	18305	9	,	,	,
18637	18305	10	117	117	CD
18637	18305	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18305	12	52	52	CD
18637	18305	13	,	,	,
18637	18305	14	70	70	CD
18637	18305	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18305	16	1886	1886	CD
18637	18305	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18305	18	.	.	.
18637	18306	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18306	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18306	3	also	also	RB
18637	18306	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18306	5	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
18637	18306	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18306	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18306	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18306	9	McConnaughy	McConnaughy	NNP
18637	18306	10	,	,	,
18637	18306	11	140	140	CD
18637	18306	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18306	13	1	1	CD
18637	18306	14	,	,	,
18637	18306	15	10	10	CD
18637	18306	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18306	17	1891	1891	CD
18637	18306	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18306	19	where	where	WRB
18637	18306	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18306	21	Lamar	Lamar	NNP
18637	18306	22	also	also	RB
18637	18306	23	emphasizes	emphasize	VBZ
18637	18306	24	the	the	DT
18637	18306	25	operation	operation	NN
18637	18306	26	of	of	IN
18637	18306	27	the	the	DT
18637	18306	28	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18306	29	against	against	IN
18637	18306	30	the	the	DT
18637	18306	31	State	State	NNP
18637	18306	32	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18306	33	.	.	.
18637	18307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18307	2	25	25	CD
18637	18307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18307	4	107	107	CD
18637	18307	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18307	6	711	711	CD
18637	18307	7	,	,	,
18637	18307	8	721	721	CD
18637	18307	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18307	10	1883	1883	CD
18637	18307	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18307	12	.	.	.
18637	18308	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18308	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18308	3	also	also	RB
18637	18308	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18308	5	Christian	Christian	NNP
18637	18308	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18308	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18308	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18308	9	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	18308	10	&	&	CC
18637	18308	11	N.C.R.	N.C.R.	NNP
18637	18309	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18309	2	,	,	,
18637	18309	3	133	133	CD
18637	18309	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18309	5	233	233	CD
18637	18309	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18309	7	1890	1890	CD
18637	18309	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18309	9	.	.	.
18637	18310	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18310	2	26	26	CD
18637	18310	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18310	4	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	18310	5	ex	ex	NN
18637	18310	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	18310	7	.	.	.
18637	18311	1	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	18311	2	_	_	NNP
18637	18311	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	18311	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18311	5	Jumel	Jumel	NNP
18637	18311	6	,	,	,
18637	18311	7	107	107	CD
18637	18311	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18311	9	711	711	CD
18637	18311	10	,	,	,
18637	18311	11	721	721	CD
18637	18311	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18311	13	1883	1883	CD
18637	18311	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18311	15	.	.	.
18637	18312	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18312	2	27	27	CD
18637	18312	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18312	4	Board	Board	NNP
18637	18312	5	of	of	IN
18637	18312	6	Liquidation	Liquidation	NNP
18637	18312	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18312	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18312	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18312	10	McComb	McComb	NNP
18637	18312	11	,	,	,
18637	18312	12	92	92	CD
18637	18312	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18312	14	531	531	CD
18637	18312	15	,	,	,
18637	18312	16	541	541	CD
18637	18312	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18312	18	1876	1876	CD
18637	18312	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18312	20	.	.	.
18637	18313	1	This	this	DT
18637	18313	2	was	be	VBD
18637	18313	3	a	a	DT
18637	18313	4	case	case	NN
18637	18313	5	involving	involve	VBG
18637	18313	6	an	an	DT
18637	18313	7	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	18313	8	,	,	,
18637	18313	9	but	but	CC
18637	18313	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18313	11	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	18313	12	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	18313	13	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	18313	14	and	and	CC
18637	18313	15	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	18313	16	as	as	IN
18637	18313	17	correlative	correlative	JJ
18637	18313	18	to	to	IN
18637	18313	19	each	each	DT
18637	18313	20	other	other	JJ
18637	18313	21	in	in	IN
18637	18313	22	cases	case	NNS
18637	18313	23	where	where	WRB
18637	18313	24	the	the	DT
18637	18313	25	official	official	NN
18637	18313	26	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	18313	27	commits	commit	VBZ
18637	18313	28	or	or	CC
18637	18313	29	omits	omit	VBZ
18637	18313	30	an	an	DT
18637	18313	31	act	act	NN
18637	18313	32	.	.	.
18637	18314	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18314	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18314	3	also	also	RB
18637	18314	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18314	5	Rolston	Rolston	NNP
18637	18314	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18314	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18314	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18314	9	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	18314	10	Fund	Fund	NNP
18637	18314	11	Commissioners	Commissioners	NNPS
18637	18314	12	,	,	,
18637	18314	13	120	120	CD
18637	18314	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18314	15	390	390	CD
18637	18314	16	,	,	,
18637	18314	17	411	411	CD
18637	18314	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18314	19	1887	1887	CD
18637	18314	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18314	21	,	,	,
18637	18314	22	where	where	WRB
18637	18314	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18314	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	18314	25	held	hold	VBN
18637	18314	26	that	that	IN
18637	18314	27	an	an	DT
18637	18314	28	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	18314	29	would	would	MD
18637	18314	30	lie	lie	VB
18637	18314	31	to	to	TO
18637	18314	32	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	18314	33	the	the	DT
18637	18314	34	sale	sale	NN
18637	18314	35	of	of	IN
18637	18314	36	a	a	DT
18637	18314	37	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18314	38	on	on	IN
18637	18314	39	the	the	DT
18637	18314	40	ground	ground	NN
18637	18314	41	that	that	IN
18637	18314	42	a	a	DT
18637	18314	43	suit	suit	NN
18637	18314	44	to	to	TO
18637	18314	45	compel	compel	VB
18637	18314	46	a	a	DT
18637	18314	47	State	State	NNP
18637	18314	48	official	official	NN
18637	18314	49	to	to	TO
18637	18314	50	do	do	VB
18637	18314	51	what	what	WP
18637	18314	52	the	the	DT
18637	18314	53	law	law	NN
18637	18314	54	requires	require	VBZ
18637	18314	55	of	of	IN
18637	18314	56	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18314	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	18314	58	not	not	RB
18637	18314	59	a	a	DT
18637	18314	60	suit	suit	NN
18637	18314	61	against	against	IN
18637	18314	62	the	the	DT
18637	18314	63	State	State	NNP
18637	18314	64	.	.	.
18637	18315	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18315	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18315	3	also	also	RB
18637	18315	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18315	5	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	18315	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18315	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18315	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18315	9	Ormes	Ormes	NNP
18637	18315	10	,	,	,
18637	18315	11	252	252	CD
18637	18315	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18315	13	469	469	CD
18637	18315	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18315	15	1920	1920	CD
18637	18315	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18315	17	.	.	.
18637	18316	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18316	2	28	28	CD
18637	18316	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18316	4	Board	Board	NNP
18637	18316	5	of	of	IN
18637	18316	6	Liquidation	Liquidation	NNP
18637	18316	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18316	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18316	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18316	10	McComb	McComb	NNP
18637	18316	11	,	,	,
18637	18316	12	92	92	CD
18637	18316	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18316	14	531	531	CD
18637	18316	15	,	,	,
18637	18316	16	541	541	CD
18637	18316	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18316	18	1876	1876	CD
18637	18316	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18316	20	.	.	.
18637	18317	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18317	2	29	29	CD
18637	18317	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18317	4	154	154	CD
18637	18317	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18317	6	362	362	CD
18637	18317	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18317	8	1894	1894	CD
18637	18317	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18317	10	.	.	.
18637	18318	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18318	2	30	30	CD
18637	18318	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18318	4	Poindexter	Poindexter	NNP
18637	18318	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18318	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18318	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18318	8	Greenhow	Greenhow	NNP
18637	18318	9	,	,	,
18637	18318	10	114	114	CD
18637	18318	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18318	12	270	270	CD
18637	18318	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18318	14	1885	1885	CD
18637	18318	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18318	16	;	;	:
18637	18318	17	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	18318	18	_	_	NNP
18637	18318	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	18318	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18318	21	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	18318	22	&	&	CC
18637	18318	23	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	18319	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18319	2	,	,	,
18637	18319	3	114	114	CD
18637	18319	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18319	5	311	311	CD
18637	18319	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18319	7	1885	1885	CD
18637	18319	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18319	9	;	;	:
18637	18319	10	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
18637	18319	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18319	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	18319	13	_	_	NNP
18637	18319	14	McConnaughy	McConnaughy	NNP
18637	18319	15	,	,	,
18637	18319	16	140	140	CD
18637	18319	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18319	18	1	1	CD
18637	18319	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18319	20	1891	1891	CD
18637	18319	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18319	22	;	;	:
18637	18319	23	In	in	IN
18637	18319	24	re	re	NN
18637	18319	25	Tyler	Tyler	NNP
18637	18319	26	,	,	,
18637	18319	27	149	149	CD
18637	18319	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18319	29	164	164	CD
18637	18319	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18319	31	1893	1893	CD
18637	18319	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18319	33	.	.	.
18637	18320	1	As	as	IN
18637	18320	2	stated	state	VBN
18637	18320	3	by	by	IN
18637	18320	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18320	5	Harlan	Harlan	NNP
18637	18320	6	in	in	IN
18637	18320	7	Fitts	Fitts	NNP
18637	18320	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18320	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	18320	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18320	11	McGhee	McGhee	NNP
18637	18320	12	,	,	,
18637	18320	13	172	172	CD
18637	18320	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18320	15	516	516	CD
18637	18320	16	,	,	,
18637	18320	17	529	529	CD
18637	18320	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	18320	19	530	530	CD
18637	18320	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18320	21	1899	1899	CD
18637	18320	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18320	23	,	,	,
18637	18320	24	"	"	``
18637	18320	25	There	there	EX
18637	18320	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	18320	27	a	a	DT
18637	18320	28	wide	wide	JJ
18637	18320	29	difference	difference	NN
18637	18320	30	between	between	IN
18637	18320	31	a	a	DT
18637	18320	32	suit	suit	NN
18637	18320	33	against	against	IN
18637	18320	34	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	18320	35	,	,	,
18637	18320	36	holding	hold	VBG
18637	18320	37	official	official	JJ
18637	18320	38	positions	position	NNS
18637	18320	39	under	under	IN
18637	18320	40	a	a	DT
18637	18320	41	State	state	NN
18637	18320	42	,	,	,
18637	18320	43	to	to	TO
18637	18320	44	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18320	45	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18320	46	,	,	,
18637	18320	47	under	under	IN
18637	18320	48	the	the	DT
18637	18320	49	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	18320	50	of	of	IN
18637	18320	51	an	an	DT
18637	18320	52	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18320	53	statute	statute	NN
18637	18320	54	,	,	,
18637	18320	55	from	from	IN
18637	18320	56	committing	commit	VBG
18637	18320	57	by	by	IN
18637	18320	58	some	some	DT
18637	18320	59	positive	positive	JJ
18637	18320	60	act	act	NN
18637	18320	61	a	a	DT
18637	18320	62	wrong	wrong	JJ
18637	18320	63	or	or	CC
18637	18320	64	trespass	trespass	NN
18637	18320	65	,	,	,
18637	18320	66	and	and	CC
18637	18320	67	a	a	DT
18637	18320	68	suit	suit	NN
18637	18320	69	against	against	IN
18637	18320	70	officers	officer	NNS
18637	18320	71	of	of	IN
18637	18320	72	a	a	DT
18637	18320	73	State	State	NNP
18637	18320	74	merely	merely	RB
18637	18320	75	to	to	TO
18637	18320	76	test	test	VB
18637	18320	77	the	the	DT
18637	18320	78	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	18320	79	of	of	IN
18637	18320	80	a	a	DT
18637	18320	81	state	state	NN
18637	18320	82	statute	statute	NN
18637	18320	83	,	,	,
18637	18320	84	in	in	IN
18637	18320	85	the	the	DT
18637	18320	86	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18320	87	of	of	IN
18637	18320	88	which	which	WDT
18637	18320	89	those	those	DT
18637	18320	90	officers	officer	NNS
18637	18320	91	will	will	MD
18637	18320	92	act	act	VB
18637	18320	93	only	only	RB
18637	18320	94	by	by	IN
18637	18320	95	formal	formal	JJ
18637	18320	96	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18320	97	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18320	98	in	in	IN
18637	18320	99	the	the	DT
18637	18320	100	courts	court	NNS
18637	18320	101	of	of	IN
18637	18320	102	the	the	DT
18637	18320	103	State	State	NNP
18637	18320	104	.	.	.
18637	18320	105	"	"	''
18637	18321	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18321	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18321	3	also	also	RB
18637	18321	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18321	5	North	North	NNP
18637	18321	6	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	18321	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18321	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18321	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18321	10	Temple	Temple	NNP
18637	18321	11	,	,	,
18637	18321	12	134	134	CD
18637	18321	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18321	14	22	22	CD
18637	18321	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18321	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	18321	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18321	18	.	.	.
18637	18322	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18322	2	31	31	CD
18637	18322	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18322	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18322	5	See	See	NNP
18637	18322	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18322	7	123	123	CD
18637	18322	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18322	9	443	443	CD
18637	18322	10	;	;	:
18637	18322	11	and	and	CC
18637	18322	12	172	172	CD
18637	18322	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18322	14	516	516	CD
18637	18322	15	.	.	.
18637	18323	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18323	2	32	32	CD
18637	18323	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18323	4	154	154	CD
18637	18323	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18323	6	362	362	CD
18637	18323	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18323	8	1894	1894	CD
18637	18323	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18323	10	.	.	.
18637	18324	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18324	2	33	33	CD
18637	18324	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18324	4	169	169	CD
18637	18324	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18324	6	466	466	CD
18637	18324	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18324	8	1898	1898	CD
18637	18324	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18324	10	.	.	.
18637	18325	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18325	2	34	34	CD
18637	18325	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18325	4	209	209	CD
18637	18325	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18325	6	123	123	CD
18637	18325	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18325	8	1908	1908	CD
18637	18325	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18325	10	.	.	.
18637	18326	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18326	2	35	35	CD
18637	18326	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18326	4	123	123	CD
18637	18326	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18326	6	443	443	CD
18637	18326	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18326	8	1887	1887	CD
18637	18326	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18326	10	;	;	:
18637	18326	11	172	172	CD
18637	18326	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18326	13	516	516	CD
18637	18326	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18326	15	1899	1899	CD
18637	18326	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18326	17	.	.	.
18637	18327	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18327	2	36	36	CD
18637	18327	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18327	4	For	for	IN
18637	18327	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	18327	6	following	follow	VBG
18637	18327	7	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	18327	8	parte	parte	NN
18637	18327	9	Young	Young	NNP
18637	18327	10	,	,	,
18637	18327	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	12	see	see	VBP
18637	18327	13	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	14	Home	Home	NNP
18637	18327	15	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	18327	16	&	&	CC
18637	18327	17	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	18327	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18327	19	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	18327	21	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	22	Los	Los	NNP
18637	18327	23	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	18327	24	,	,	,
18637	18327	25	227	227	CD
18637	18327	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18327	27	278	278	CD
18637	18327	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18327	29	1913	1913	CD
18637	18327	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18327	31	;	;	:
18637	18327	32	Truax	Truax	NNP
18637	18327	33	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	18327	35	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	36	Raich	Raich	NNP
18637	18327	37	,	,	,
18637	18327	38	239	239	CD
18637	18327	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18327	40	33	33	CD
18637	18327	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18327	42	1915	1915	CD
18637	18327	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18327	44	;	;	:
18637	18327	45	Cavanaugh	Cavanaugh	NNP
18637	18327	46	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	18327	48	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	49	Looney	Looney	NNP
18637	18327	50	,	,	,
18637	18327	51	248	248	CD
18637	18327	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18327	53	453	453	CD
18637	18327	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18327	55	1919	1919	CD
18637	18327	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18327	57	;	;	:
18637	18327	58	Terrace	Terrace	NNP
18637	18327	59	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	18327	61	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	62	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	18327	63	,	,	,
18637	18327	64	263	263	CD
18637	18327	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18327	66	197	197	CD
18637	18327	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18327	68	1923	1923	CD
18637	18327	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18327	70	;	;	:
18637	18327	71	Hygrade	Hygrade	NNP
18637	18327	72	Provision	Provision	NNP
18637	18327	73	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18327	74	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	18327	76	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	77	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	18327	78	,	,	,
18637	18327	79	266	266	CD
18637	18327	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18327	81	497	497	CD
18637	18327	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18327	83	1925	1925	CD
18637	18327	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18327	85	;	;	:
18637	18327	86	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	18327	87	State	State	NNP
18637	18327	88	Grange	Grange	NNP
18637	18327	89	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	18327	91	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	92	Benton	Benton	NNP
18637	18327	93	,	,	,
18637	18327	94	272	272	CD
18637	18327	95	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18327	96	525	525	CD
18637	18327	97	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18327	98	1926	1926	CD
18637	18327	99	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18327	100	;	;	:
18637	18327	101	Hawks	Hawks	NNP
18637	18327	102	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	103	v.	v.	IN
18637	18327	104	_	_	NNP
18637	18327	105	Hamill	Hamill	NNP
18637	18327	106	,	,	,
18637	18327	107	288	288	CD
18637	18327	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18327	109	52	52	CD
18637	18327	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18327	111	1933	1933	CD
18637	18327	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18327	113	.	.	.
18637	18328	1	These	these	DT
18637	18328	2	last	last	JJ
18637	18328	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	18328	4	,	,	,
18637	18328	5	however	however	RB
18637	18328	6	,	,	,
18637	18328	7	emphasize	emphasize	VB
18637	18328	8	"	"	``
18637	18328	9	manifest	manifest	NN
18637	18328	10	oppression	oppression	NN
18637	18328	11	"	"	''
18637	18328	12	as	as	IN
18637	18328	13	a	a	DT
18637	18328	14	prerequisite	prerequisite	NN
18637	18328	15	to	to	IN
18637	18328	16	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	18328	17	of	of	IN
18637	18328	18	such	such	JJ
18637	18328	19	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	18328	20	.	.	.
18637	18329	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18329	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18329	3	also	also	RB
18637	18329	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18329	5	Fenner	Fenner	NNP
18637	18329	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18329	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18329	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18329	9	Boykin	Boykin	NNP
18637	18329	10	,	,	,
18637	18329	11	271	271	CD
18637	18329	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18329	13	240	240	CD
18637	18329	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18329	15	1926	1926	CD
18637	18329	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18329	17	,	,	,
18637	18329	18	where	where	WRB
18637	18329	19	an	an	DT
18637	18329	20	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	18329	21	to	to	TO
18637	18329	22	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	18329	23	the	the	DT
18637	18329	24	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18329	25	of	of	IN
18637	18329	26	a	a	DT
18637	18329	27	State	State	NNP
18637	18329	28	law	law	NN
18637	18329	29	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	18329	30	gambling	gambling	NN
18637	18329	31	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	18329	32	was	be	VBD
18637	18329	33	denied	deny	VBN
18637	18329	34	.	.	.
18637	18330	1	The	the	DT
18637	18330	2	rule	rule	NN
18637	18330	3	of	of	IN
18637	18330	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	18330	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	18330	6	Young	Young	NNP
18637	18330	7	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	18330	8	equally	equally	RB
18637	18330	9	to	to	IN
18637	18330	10	the	the	DT
18637	18330	11	governor	governor	NN
18637	18330	12	of	of	IN
18637	18330	13	a	a	DT
18637	18330	14	State	State	NNP
18637	18330	15	in	in	IN
18637	18330	16	the	the	DT
18637	18330	17	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18330	18	of	of	IN
18637	18330	19	an	an	DT
18637	18330	20	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18330	21	statute	statute	NN
18637	18330	22	.	.	.
18637	18331	1	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	18331	2	Baking	Baking	NNP
18637	18331	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18331	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18331	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	18331	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18331	7	Woodring	Woodring	NNP
18637	18331	8	,	,	,
18637	18331	9	286	286	CD
18637	18331	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18331	11	352	352	CD
18637	18331	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18331	13	1932	1932	CD
18637	18331	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18331	15	;	;	:
18637	18331	16	Sterling	Sterling	NNP
18637	18331	17	_	_	NNP
18637	18331	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	18331	19	_	_	NNP
18637	18331	20	Constantin	Constantin	NNP
18637	18331	21	,	,	,
18637	18331	22	287	287	CD
18637	18331	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18331	24	378	378	CD
18637	18331	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18331	26	1932	1932	CD
18637	18331	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18331	28	.	.	.
18637	18332	1	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
18637	18332	2	D.	D.	NNP
18637	18332	3	Block	Block	NNP
18637	18332	4	,	,	,
18637	18332	5	"	"	``
18637	18332	6	Suit	Suit	NNP
18637	18332	7	Against	against	IN
18637	18332	8	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18332	9	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	18332	10	and	and	CC
18637	18332	11	the	the	DT
18637	18332	12	Sovereign	Sovereign	NNP
18637	18332	13	Immunity	Immunity	NNP
18637	18332	14	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	18332	15	,	,	,
18637	18332	16	"	"	''
18637	18332	17	59	59	CD
18637	18332	18	Harv	Harv	NNP
18637	18332	19	.	.	.
18637	18333	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	18333	2	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	18334	1	1060	1060	CD
18637	18334	2	,	,	,
18637	18334	3	1078	1078	CD
18637	18334	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18334	5	1946	1946	CD
18637	18334	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18334	7	,	,	,
18637	18334	8	points	point	VBZ
18637	18334	9	out	out	RP
18637	18334	10	that	that	IN
18637	18334	11	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	18334	12	parte	parte	NN
18637	18334	13	Young	Young	NNP
18637	18334	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	18334	15	enunciating	enunciate	VBG
18637	18334	16	the	the	DT
18637	18334	17	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	18334	18	that	that	IN
18637	18334	19	an	an	DT
18637	18334	20	official	official	JJ
18637	18334	21	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	18334	22	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	RB
18637	18334	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	18334	24	"	"	``
18637	18334	25	stripped	strip	VBN
18637	18334	26	of	of	IN
18637	18334	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18334	28	official	official	JJ
18637	18334	29	...	...	:
18637	18334	30	character	character	NN
18637	18334	31	"	"	''
18637	18334	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	18334	33	given	give	VBN
18637	18334	34	impetus	impetus	NN
18637	18334	35	to	to	IN
18637	18334	36	the	the	DT
18637	18334	37	fiction	fiction	NN
18637	18334	38	that	that	IN
18637	18334	39	the	the	DT
18637	18334	40	suit	suit	NN
18637	18334	41	must	must	MD
18637	18334	42	be	be	VB
18637	18334	43	against	against	IN
18637	18334	44	the	the	DT
18637	18334	45	officer	officer	NN
18637	18334	46	as	as	IN
18637	18334	47	an	an	DT
18637	18334	48	individual	individual	NN
18637	18334	49	to	to	TO
18637	18334	50	be	be	VB
18637	18334	51	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	18334	52	under	under	IN
18637	18334	53	the	the	DT
18637	18334	54	Eleventh	Eleventh	NNP
18637	18334	55	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18334	56	.	.	.
18637	18335	1	Two	two	CD
18637	18335	2	recent	recent	JJ
18637	18335	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	18335	4	in	in	IN
18637	18335	5	which	which	WDT
18637	18335	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	18335	7	parte	parte	NN
18637	18335	8	Young	Young	NNP
18637	18335	9	was	be	VBD
18637	18335	10	followed	follow	VBN
18637	18335	11	are	be	VBP
18637	18335	12	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	18335	13	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	18335	14	_	_	NNP
18637	18335	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	18335	16	_	_	NNP
18637	18335	17	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	18335	18	R.	R.	NNP
18637	18335	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18335	20	,	,	,
18637	18335	21	341	341	CD
18637	18335	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18335	23	341	341	CD
18637	18335	24	,	,	,
18637	18335	25	344	344	CD
18637	18335	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18335	27	1951	1951	CD
18637	18335	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18335	29	;	;	:
18637	18335	30	and	and	CC
18637	18335	31	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	18335	32	R.	R.	NNP
18637	18335	33	_	_	NNP
18637	18335	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	18335	35	_	_	NNP
18637	18335	36	Redwine	Redwine	NNP
18637	18335	37	,	,	,
18637	18335	38	342	342	CD
18637	18335	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18335	40	299	299	CD
18637	18335	41	,	,	,
18637	18335	42	304	304	CD
18637	18335	43	-	-	SYM
18637	18335	44	305	305	CD
18637	18335	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18335	46	1952	1952	CD
18637	18335	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18335	48	.	.	.
18637	18336	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18336	2	37	37	CD
18637	18336	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18336	4	123	123	CD
18637	18336	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18336	6	443	443	CD
18637	18336	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18336	8	1887	1887	CD
18637	18336	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18336	10	.	.	.
18637	18337	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18337	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18337	3	also	also	RB
18637	18337	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18337	5	Larson	Larson	NNP
18637	18337	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18337	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18337	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18337	9	Domestic	Domestic	NNP
18637	18337	10	and	and	CC
18637	18337	11	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	18337	12	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	18337	13	,	,	,
18637	18337	14	337	337	CD
18637	18337	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18337	16	682	682	CD
18637	18337	17	,	,	,
18637	18337	18	687	687	CD
18637	18337	19	-	-	SYM
18637	18337	20	688	688	CD
18637	18337	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18337	22	1949	1949	CD
18637	18337	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18337	24	.	.	.
18637	18338	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18338	2	38	38	CD
18637	18338	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18338	4	49	49	CD
18637	18338	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	18338	6	.	.	.
18637	18339	1	1096	1096	CD
18637	18339	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18339	3	1936	1936	CD
18637	18339	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18339	5	.	.	.
18637	18340	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18340	2	39	39	CD
18637	18340	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18340	4	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
18637	18340	5	County	County	NNP
18637	18340	6	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	18340	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18340	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18340	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	18340	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18340	11	Riley	Riley	NNP
18637	18340	12	,	,	,
18637	18340	13	302	302	CD
18637	18340	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18340	15	292	292	CD
18637	18340	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18340	17	1937	1937	CD
18637	18340	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18340	19	;	;	:
18637	18340	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18340	21	see	see	VB
18637	18340	22	also	also	RB
18637	18340	23	_	_	NNP
18637	18340	24	Old	Old	NNP
18637	18340	25	Colony	Colony	NNP
18637	18340	26	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	18340	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18340	28	_	_	NNP
18637	18340	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	18340	30	_	_	NNP
18637	18340	31	Seattle	Seattle	NNP
18637	18340	32	,	,	,
18637	18340	33	271	271	CD
18637	18340	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18340	35	426	426	CD
18637	18340	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18340	37	1926	1926	CD
18637	18340	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18340	39	.	.	.
18637	18341	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18341	2	40	40	CD
18637	18341	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18341	4	Treinies	Treinies	NNP
18637	18341	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18341	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18341	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18341	8	Sunshine	Sunshine	NNP
18637	18341	9	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	18341	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18341	11	,	,	,
18637	18341	12	308	308	CD
18637	18341	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18341	14	66	66	CD
18637	18341	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18341	16	1939	1939	CD
18637	18341	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18341	18	.	.	.
18637	18342	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18342	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18342	3	also	also	RB
18637	18342	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18342	5	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	18342	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18342	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18342	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18342	9	Fiske	Fiske	NNP
18637	18342	10	,	,	,
18637	18342	11	290	290	CD
18637	18342	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18342	13	18	18	CD
18637	18342	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18342	15	1933	1933	CD
18637	18342	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18342	17	.	.	.
18637	18343	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18343	2	41	41	CD
18637	18343	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18343	4	106	106	CD
18637	18343	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18343	6	196	196	CD
18637	18343	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18343	8	1882	1882	CD
18637	18343	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18343	10	.	.	.
18637	18344	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18344	2	42	42	CD
18637	18344	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18344	4	167	167	CD
18637	18344	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18344	6	204	204	CD
18637	18344	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18344	8	1897	1897	CD
18637	18344	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18344	10	.	.	.
18637	18345	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18345	2	43	43	CD
18637	18345	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18345	4	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	18345	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18345	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18345	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18345	8	Lankford	Lankford	NNP
18637	18345	9	,	,	,
18637	18345	10	245	245	CD
18637	18345	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18345	12	541	541	CD
18637	18345	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18345	14	1918	1918	CD
18637	18345	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18345	16	;	;	:
18637	18345	17	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	18345	18	_	_	NNP
18637	18345	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	18345	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18345	21	Lankford	Lankford	NNP
18637	18345	22	,	,	,
18637	18345	23	245	245	CD
18637	18345	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18345	25	547	547	CD
18637	18345	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18345	27	1918	1918	CD
18637	18345	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18345	29	.	.	.
18637	18346	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18346	2	44	44	CD
18637	18346	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18346	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	18346	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18346	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18346	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18346	8	Reeves	Reeves	NNP
18637	18346	9	,	,	,
18637	18346	10	178	178	CD
18637	18346	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18346	12	436	436	CD
18637	18346	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18346	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	18346	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18346	16	.	.	.
18637	18347	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18347	2	45	45	CD
18637	18347	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18347	4	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	18347	5	,	,	,
18637	18347	6	Topeka	Topeka	NNP
18637	18347	7	&	&	CC
18637	18347	8	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	18348	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18348	2	_	_	NNP
18637	18348	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	18348	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18348	5	O'Connor	O'Connor	NNP
18637	18348	6	,	,	,
18637	18348	7	223	223	CD
18637	18348	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18348	9	280	280	CD
18637	18348	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18348	11	1912	1912	CD
18637	18348	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18348	13	.	.	.
18637	18349	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18349	2	46	46	CD
18637	18349	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18349	4	322	322	CD
18637	18349	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18349	6	47	47	CD
18637	18349	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18349	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	18349	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18349	10	.	.	.
18637	18350	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18350	2	47	47	CD
18637	18350	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18350	4	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	18350	5	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	18350	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18350	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18350	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18350	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18350	10	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	18350	11	.	.	.
18637	18351	1	of	of	IN
18637	18351	2	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	18351	3	of	of	IN
18637	18351	4	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	18351	5	,	,	,
18637	18351	6	323	323	CD
18637	18351	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18351	8	459	459	CD
18637	18351	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18351	10	1945	1945	CD
18637	18351	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18351	12	;	;	:
18637	18351	13	Kennecott	Kennecott	NNP
18637	18351	14	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	18351	15	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	18351	16	_	_	NNP
18637	18351	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	18351	18	_	_	NNP
18637	18351	19	State	State	NNP
18637	18351	20	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	18351	21	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18351	22	,	,	,
18637	18351	23	327	327	CD
18637	18351	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18351	25	573	573	CD
18637	18351	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18351	27	1946	1946	CD
18637	18351	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18351	29	.	.	.
18637	18352	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18352	2	48	48	CD
18637	18352	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18352	4	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	18352	5	County	County	NNP
18637	18352	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18352	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18352	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18352	9	Luning	Luning	NNP
18637	18352	10	,	,	,
18637	18352	11	133	133	CD
18637	18352	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18352	13	529	529	CD
18637	18352	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18352	15	1890	1890	CD
18637	18352	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18352	17	;	;	:
18637	18352	18	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	18352	19	_	_	NNP
18637	18352	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	18352	21	_	_	NNP
18637	18352	22	Clemson	Clemson	NNP
18637	18352	23	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	18352	24	College	College	NNP
18637	18352	25	,	,	,
18637	18352	26	221	221	CD
18637	18352	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18352	28	636	636	CD
18637	18352	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18352	30	1911	1911	CD
18637	18352	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18352	32	.	.	.
18637	18353	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18353	2	49	49	CD
18637	18353	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18353	4	Great	Great	NNP
18637	18353	5	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	18353	6	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	18353	7	.	.	.
18637	18354	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18354	2	_	_	NNP
18637	18354	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	18354	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18354	5	Read	Read	NNP
18637	18354	6	,	,	,
18637	18354	7	322	322	CD
18637	18354	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18354	9	47	47	CD
18637	18354	10	,	,	,
18637	18354	11	54	54	CD
18637	18354	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18354	13	1944	1944	CD
18637	18354	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18354	15	;	;	:
18637	18354	16	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	18354	17	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	18354	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18354	19	_	_	NNP
18637	18354	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	18354	21	_	_	NNP
18637	18354	22	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	18354	23	.	.	.
18637	18355	1	of	of	IN
18637	18355	2	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	18355	3	of	of	IN
18637	18355	4	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	18355	5	,	,	,
18637	18355	6	323	323	CD
18637	18355	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18355	8	459	459	CD
18637	18355	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18355	10	1945	1945	CD
18637	18355	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18355	12	;	;	:
18637	18355	13	Kennecott	Kennecott	NNP
18637	18355	14	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	18355	15	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	18355	16	_	_	NNP
18637	18355	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	18355	18	_	_	NNP
18637	18355	19	State	State	NNP
18637	18355	20	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	18355	21	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18355	22	,	,	,
18637	18355	23	327	327	CD
18637	18355	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18355	25	573	573	CD
18637	18355	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18355	27	1946	1946	CD
18637	18355	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18355	29	.	.	.
18637	18356	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18356	2	50	50	CD
18637	18356	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18356	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	18356	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18356	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18356	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18356	8	Reeves	Reeves	NNP
18637	18356	9	,	,	,
18637	18356	10	178	178	CD
18637	18356	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18356	12	436	436	CD
18637	18356	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18356	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	18356	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18356	16	.	.	.
18637	18357	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18357	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18357	3	also	also	RB
18637	18357	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18357	5	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	18357	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18357	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18357	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18357	9	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	18357	10	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	18357	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18357	12	,	,	,
18637	18357	13	213	213	CD
18637	18357	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18357	15	151	151	CD
18637	18357	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18357	17	1909	1909	CD
18637	18357	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18357	19	;	;	:
18637	18357	20	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	18357	21	_	_	NNP
18637	18357	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	18357	23	_	_	NNP
18637	18357	24	Dix	Dix	NNP
18637	18357	25	,	,	,
18637	18357	26	194	194	CD
18637	18357	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18357	28	590	590	CD
18637	18357	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18357	30	1904	1904	CD
18637	18357	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18357	32	.	.	.
18637	18358	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18358	2	51	51	CD
18637	18358	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18358	4	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	18358	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18358	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18358	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18358	8	Barnard	Barnard	NNP
18637	18358	9	,	,	,
18637	18358	10	108	108	CD
18637	18358	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18358	12	436	436	CD
18637	18358	13	,	,	,
18637	18358	14	447	447	CD
18637	18358	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18358	16	1883	1883	CD
18637	18358	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18358	18	;	;	:
18637	18358	19	Ashton	Ashton	NNP
18637	18358	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18358	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	18358	22	_	_	NNP
18637	18358	23	Cameron	Cameron	NNP
18637	18358	24	County	County	NNP
18637	18358	25	Water	Water	NNP
18637	18358	26	Improvement	Improvement	NNP
18637	18358	27	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	18358	28	.	.	NNP
18637	18358	29	,	,	,
18637	18358	30	298	298	CD
18637	18358	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18358	32	513	513	CD
18637	18358	33	,	,	,
18637	18358	34	531	531	CD
18637	18358	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18358	36	1936	1936	CD
18637	18358	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18358	38	.	.	.
18637	18359	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18359	2	52	52	CD
18637	18359	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18359	4	Farish	Farish	NNP
18637	18359	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18359	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18359	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18359	8	State	State	NNP
18637	18359	9	Banking	Banking	NNP
18637	18359	10	Board	Board	NNP
18637	18359	11	,	,	,
18637	18359	12	235	235	CD
18637	18359	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18359	14	498	498	CD
18637	18359	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18359	16	1915	1915	CD
18637	18359	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18359	18	;	;	:
18637	18359	19	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	18359	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18359	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	18359	22	_	_	NNP
18637	18359	23	Fiske	Fiske	NNP
18637	18359	24	,	,	,
18637	18359	25	290	290	CD
18637	18359	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18359	27	18	18	CD
18637	18359	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18359	29	1933	1933	CD
18637	18359	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18359	31	.	.	.
18637	18360	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18360	2	53	53	CD
18637	18360	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18360	4	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	18360	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18360	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18360	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18360	8	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	18360	9	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	18360	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18360	11	,	,	,
18637	18360	12	213	213	CD
18637	18360	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18360	14	151	151	CD
18637	18360	15	,	,	,
18637	18360	16	172	172	CD
18637	18360	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18360	18	1909	1909	CD
18637	18360	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18360	20	,	,	,
18637	18360	21	citing	cite	VBG
18637	18360	22	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	18360	23	_	_	NNP
18637	18360	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	18360	25	_	_	NNP
18637	18360	26	Reeves	Reeves	NNP
18637	18360	27	,	,	,
18637	18360	28	178	178	CD
18637	18360	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18360	30	436	436	CD
18637	18360	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18360	32	1900	1900	CD
18637	18360	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18360	34	;	;	:
18637	18360	35	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	18360	36	_	_	NNP
18637	18360	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	18360	38	_	_	NNP
18637	18360	39	Dix	Dix	NNP
18637	18360	40	,	,	,
18637	18360	41	194	194	CD
18637	18360	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18360	43	590	590	CD
18637	18360	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18360	45	1904	1904	CD
18637	18360	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18360	47	.	.	.
18637	18361	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18361	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18361	3	also	also	RB
18637	18361	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18361	5	Graves	Graves	NNP
18637	18361	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18361	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18361	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18361	9	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	18361	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18361	11	,	,	,
18637	18361	12	298	298	CD
18637	18361	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18361	14	393	393	CD
18637	18361	15	,	,	,
18637	18361	16	403	403	CD
18637	18361	17	-	-	SYM
18637	18361	18	404	404	CD
18637	18361	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18361	20	1936	1936	CD
18637	18361	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18361	22	.	.	.
18637	18362	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	18362	2	12	12	CD
18637	18362	3	ELECTION	election	NN
18637	18362	4	OF	of	IN
18637	18362	5	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	18362	6	Page	Page	NNP
18637	18362	7	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	18362	8	and	and	CC
18637	18362	9	operation	operation	NN
18637	18362	10	of	of	IN
18637	18362	11	the	the	DT
18637	18362	12	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18362	13	942	942	CD
18637	18362	14	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	18362	15	as	as	IN
18637	18362	16	free	free	JJ
18637	18362	17	agents	agent	NNS
18637	18362	18	942	942	CD
18637	18362	19	ELECTION	election	NN
18637	18362	20	OF	of	IN
18637	18362	21	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	18362	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18362	23	12	12	CD
18637	18362	24	The	the	DT
18637	18362	25	Electors	Electors	NNPS
18637	18362	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	18362	27	meet	meet	VB
18637	18362	28	in	in	IN
18637	18362	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18362	30	respective	respective	JJ
18637	18362	31	states	state	NNS
18637	18362	32	,	,	,
18637	18362	33	and	and	CC
18637	18362	34	vote	vote	NN
18637	18362	35	by	by	IN
18637	18362	36	ballot	ballot	NN
18637	18362	37	for	for	IN
18637	18362	38	President	President	NNP
18637	18362	39	and	and	CC
18637	18362	40	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	18362	41	-	-	HYPH
18637	18362	42	President	President	NNP
18637	18362	43	,	,	,
18637	18362	44	one	one	CD
18637	18362	45	of	of	IN
18637	18362	46	whom	whom	WP
18637	18362	47	,	,	,
18637	18362	48	at	at	IN
18637	18362	49	least	least	JJS
18637	18362	50	,	,	,
18637	18362	51	shall	shall	MD
18637	18362	52	not	not	RB
18637	18362	53	be	be	VB
18637	18362	54	an	an	DT
18637	18362	55	inhabitant	inhabitant	NN
18637	18362	56	of	of	IN
18637	18362	57	the	the	DT
18637	18362	58	same	same	JJ
18637	18362	59	state	state	NN
18637	18362	60	with	with	IN
18637	18362	61	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18362	62	;	;	:
18637	18362	63	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18362	64	shall	shall	MD
18637	18362	65	name	name	VB
18637	18362	66	in	in	IN
18637	18362	67	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18362	68	ballots	ballot	NNS
18637	18362	69	the	the	DT
18637	18362	70	person	person	NN
18637	18362	71	voted	vote	VBD
18637	18362	72	for	for	IN
18637	18362	73	as	as	IN
18637	18362	74	President	President	NNP
18637	18362	75	,	,	,
18637	18362	76	and	and	CC
18637	18362	77	in	in	IN
18637	18362	78	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	18362	79	ballots	ballot	NNS
18637	18362	80	the	the	DT
18637	18362	81	person	person	NN
18637	18362	82	voted	vote	VBD
18637	18362	83	for	for	IN
18637	18362	84	as	as	IN
18637	18362	85	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	18362	86	-	-	HYPH
18637	18362	87	President	President	NNP
18637	18362	88	,	,	,
18637	18362	89	and	and	CC
18637	18362	90	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18362	91	shall	shall	MD
18637	18362	92	make	make	VB
18637	18362	93	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	18362	94	lists	list	NNS
18637	18362	95	of	of	IN
18637	18362	96	all	all	DT
18637	18362	97	persons	person	NNS
18637	18362	98	voted	vote	VBD
18637	18362	99	for	for	IN
18637	18362	100	as	as	IN
18637	18362	101	President	President	NNP
18637	18362	102	,	,	,
18637	18362	103	and	and	CC
18637	18362	104	of	of	IN
18637	18362	105	all	all	DT
18637	18362	106	persons	person	NNS
18637	18362	107	voted	vote	VBD
18637	18362	108	for	for	IN
18637	18362	109	as	as	IN
18637	18362	110	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	18362	111	-	-	HYPH
18637	18362	112	President	President	NNP
18637	18362	113	,	,	,
18637	18362	114	and	and	CC
18637	18362	115	of	of	IN
18637	18362	116	the	the	DT
18637	18362	117	number	number	NN
18637	18362	118	of	of	IN
18637	18362	119	votes	vote	NNS
18637	18362	120	for	for	IN
18637	18362	121	each	each	DT
18637	18362	122	,	,	,
18637	18362	123	which	which	WDT
18637	18362	124	lists	list	VBZ
18637	18362	125	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18362	126	shall	shall	MD
18637	18362	127	sign	sign	VB
18637	18362	128	and	and	CC
18637	18362	129	certify	certify	VB
18637	18362	130	,	,	,
18637	18362	131	and	and	CC
18637	18362	132	transmit	transmit	VB
18637	18362	133	sealed	seal	VBN
18637	18362	134	to	to	IN
18637	18362	135	the	the	DT
18637	18362	136	seat	seat	NN
18637	18362	137	of	of	IN
18637	18362	138	the	the	DT
18637	18362	139	government	government	NN
18637	18362	140	of	of	IN
18637	18362	141	the	the	DT
18637	18362	142	United	United	NNP
18637	18362	143	States	States	NNP
18637	18362	144	,	,	,
18637	18362	145	directed	direct	VBN
18637	18362	146	to	to	IN
18637	18362	147	the	the	DT
18637	18362	148	President	President	NNP
18637	18362	149	of	of	IN
18637	18362	150	the	the	DT
18637	18362	151	Senate;--The	senate;--the	JJ
18637	18362	152	President	President	NNP
18637	18362	153	of	of	IN
18637	18362	154	the	the	DT
18637	18362	155	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	18362	156	shall	shall	MD
18637	18362	157	,	,	,
18637	18362	158	in	in	IN
18637	18362	159	the	the	DT
18637	18362	160	presence	presence	NN
18637	18362	161	of	of	IN
18637	18362	162	the	the	DT
18637	18362	163	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	18362	164	and	and	CC
18637	18362	165	House	House	NNP
18637	18362	166	of	of	IN
18637	18362	167	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	18362	168	,	,	,
18637	18362	169	open	open	VB
18637	18362	170	all	all	PDT
18637	18362	171	the	the	DT
18637	18362	172	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	18362	173	and	and	CC
18637	18362	174	the	the	DT
18637	18362	175	votes	vote	NNS
18637	18362	176	shall	shall	MD
18637	18362	177	then	then	RB
18637	18362	178	be	be	VB
18637	18362	179	counted;--The	counted;--The	.
18637	18362	180	person	person	NN
18637	18362	181	having	have	VBG
18637	18362	182	the	the	DT
18637	18362	183	greatest	great	JJS
18637	18362	184	number	number	NN
18637	18362	185	of	of	IN
18637	18362	186	votes	vote	NNS
18637	18362	187	for	for	IN
18637	18362	188	President	President	NNP
18637	18362	189	,	,	,
18637	18362	190	shall	shall	MD
18637	18362	191	be	be	VB
18637	18362	192	the	the	DT
18637	18362	193	President	President	NNP
18637	18362	194	,	,	,
18637	18362	195	if	if	IN
18637	18362	196	such	such	JJ
18637	18362	197	number	number	NN
18637	18362	198	be	be	VB
18637	18362	199	a	a	DT
18637	18362	200	majority	majority	NN
18637	18362	201	of	of	IN
18637	18362	202	the	the	DT
18637	18362	203	whole	whole	JJ
18637	18362	204	number	number	NN
18637	18362	205	of	of	IN
18637	18362	206	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	18362	207	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	18362	208	;	;	:
18637	18362	209	and	and	CC
18637	18362	210	if	if	IN
18637	18362	211	no	no	DT
18637	18362	212	person	person	NN
18637	18362	213	have	have	VBP
18637	18362	214	such	such	JJ
18637	18362	215	majority	majority	NN
18637	18362	216	,	,	,
18637	18362	217	then	then	RB
18637	18362	218	from	from	IN
18637	18362	219	the	the	DT
18637	18362	220	persons	person	NNS
18637	18362	221	having	have	VBG
18637	18362	222	the	the	DT
18637	18362	223	highest	high	JJS
18637	18362	224	numbers	number	NNS
18637	18362	225	not	not	RB
18637	18362	226	exceeding	exceed	VBG
18637	18362	227	three	three	CD
18637	18362	228	on	on	IN
18637	18362	229	the	the	DT
18637	18362	230	list	list	NN
18637	18362	231	of	of	IN
18637	18362	232	those	those	DT
18637	18362	233	voted	vote	VBN
18637	18362	234	for	for	IN
18637	18362	235	as	as	IN
18637	18362	236	President	President	NNP
18637	18362	237	,	,	,
18637	18362	238	the	the	DT
18637	18362	239	House	House	NNP
18637	18362	240	of	of	IN
18637	18362	241	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	18362	242	shall	shall	MD
18637	18362	243	choose	choose	VB
18637	18362	244	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	18362	245	,	,	,
18637	18362	246	by	by	IN
18637	18362	247	ballot	ballot	NN
18637	18362	248	,	,	,
18637	18362	249	the	the	DT
18637	18362	250	President	President	NNP
18637	18362	251	.	.	.
18637	18363	1	But	but	CC
18637	18363	2	in	in	IN
18637	18363	3	choosing	choose	VBG
18637	18363	4	the	the	DT
18637	18363	5	President	President	NNP
18637	18363	6	,	,	,
18637	18363	7	the	the	DT
18637	18363	8	votes	vote	NNS
18637	18363	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	18363	10	be	be	VB
18637	18363	11	taken	take	VBN
18637	18363	12	by	by	IN
18637	18363	13	states	state	NNS
18637	18363	14	,	,	,
18637	18363	15	the	the	DT
18637	18363	16	representation	representation	NN
18637	18363	17	from	from	IN
18637	18363	18	each	each	DT
18637	18363	19	state	state	NN
18637	18363	20	having	have	VBG
18637	18363	21	one	one	CD
18637	18363	22	vote	vote	NN
18637	18363	23	;	;	:
18637	18363	24	a	a	DT
18637	18363	25	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	18363	26	for	for	IN
18637	18363	27	this	this	DT
18637	18363	28	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18363	29	shall	shall	MD
18637	18363	30	consist	consist	VB
18637	18363	31	of	of	IN
18637	18363	32	a	a	DT
18637	18363	33	member	member	NN
18637	18363	34	or	or	CC
18637	18363	35	members	member	NNS
18637	18363	36	from	from	IN
18637	18363	37	two	two	CD
18637	18363	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	18363	39	thirds	third	NNS
18637	18363	40	of	of	IN
18637	18363	41	the	the	DT
18637	18363	42	states	state	NNS
18637	18363	43	,	,	,
18637	18363	44	and	and	CC
18637	18363	45	a	a	DT
18637	18363	46	majority	majority	NN
18637	18363	47	of	of	IN
18637	18363	48	all	all	PDT
18637	18363	49	the	the	DT
18637	18363	50	states	state	NNS
18637	18363	51	shall	shall	MD
18637	18363	52	be	be	VB
18637	18363	53	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18363	54	to	to	IN
18637	18363	55	a	a	DT
18637	18363	56	choice	choice	NN
18637	18363	57	.	.	.
18637	18364	1	And	and	CC
18637	18364	2	if	if	IN
18637	18364	3	the	the	DT
18637	18364	4	House	House	NNP
18637	18364	5	of	of	IN
18637	18364	6	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	18364	7	shall	shall	MD
18637	18364	8	not	not	RB
18637	18364	9	choose	choose	VB
18637	18364	10	a	a	DT
18637	18364	11	President	President	NNP
18637	18364	12	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	18364	13	the	the	DT
18637	18364	14	right	right	NN
18637	18364	15	of	of	IN
18637	18364	16	choice	choice	NN
18637	18364	17	shall	shall	MD
18637	18364	18	devolve	devolve	VB
18637	18364	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	18364	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18364	21	,	,	,
18637	18364	22	before	before	IN
18637	18364	23	the	the	DT
18637	18364	24	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	18364	25	day	day	NN
18637	18364	26	of	of	IN
18637	18364	27	March[1	March[1	NNP
18637	18364	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18364	29	next	next	RB
18637	18364	30	following	following	NN
18637	18364	31	,	,	,
18637	18364	32	then	then	RB
18637	18364	33	the	the	DT
18637	18364	34	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	18364	35	-	-	HYPH
18637	18364	36	President	President	NNP
18637	18364	37	shall	shall	MD
18637	18364	38	act	act	VB
18637	18364	39	as	as	IN
18637	18364	40	President	President	NNP
18637	18364	41	,	,	,
18637	18364	42	as	as	IN
18637	18364	43	in	in	IN
18637	18364	44	the	the	DT
18637	18364	45	case	case	NN
18637	18364	46	of	of	IN
18637	18364	47	the	the	DT
18637	18364	48	death	death	NN
18637	18364	49	or	or	CC
18637	18364	50	other	other	JJ
18637	18364	51	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18364	52	disability	disability	NN
18637	18364	53	of	of	IN
18637	18364	54	the	the	DT
18637	18364	55	President	President	NNP
18637	18364	56	.	.	.
18637	18365	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18365	2	2]--The	2]--the	CD
18637	18365	3	person	person	NN
18637	18365	4	having	have	VBG
18637	18365	5	the	the	DT
18637	18365	6	greatest	great	JJS
18637	18365	7	number	number	NN
18637	18365	8	of	of	IN
18637	18365	9	votes	vote	NNS
18637	18365	10	as	as	IN
18637	18365	11	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	18365	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	18365	13	President	President	NNP
18637	18365	14	,	,	,
18637	18365	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	18365	16	be	be	VB
18637	18365	17	the	the	DT
18637	18365	18	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	18365	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	18365	20	President	President	NNP
18637	18365	21	,	,	,
18637	18365	22	if	if	IN
18637	18365	23	such	such	JJ
18637	18365	24	number	number	NN
18637	18365	25	be	be	VB
18637	18365	26	a	a	DT
18637	18365	27	majority	majority	NN
18637	18365	28	of	of	IN
18637	18365	29	the	the	DT
18637	18365	30	whole	whole	JJ
18637	18365	31	number	number	NN
18637	18365	32	of	of	IN
18637	18365	33	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	18365	34	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	18365	35	,	,	,
18637	18365	36	and	and	CC
18637	18365	37	if	if	IN
18637	18365	38	no	no	DT
18637	18365	39	person	person	NN
18637	18365	40	have	have	VBP
18637	18365	41	a	a	DT
18637	18365	42	majority	majority	NN
18637	18365	43	,	,	,
18637	18365	44	then	then	RB
18637	18365	45	from	from	IN
18637	18365	46	the	the	DT
18637	18365	47	two	two	CD
18637	18365	48	highest	high	JJS
18637	18365	49	numbers	number	NNS
18637	18365	50	on	on	IN
18637	18365	51	the	the	DT
18637	18365	52	list	list	NN
18637	18365	53	,	,	,
18637	18365	54	the	the	DT
18637	18365	55	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	18365	56	shall	shall	MD
18637	18365	57	choose	choose	VB
18637	18365	58	the	the	DT
18637	18365	59	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	18365	60	-	-	HYPH
18637	18365	61	President	President	NNP
18637	18365	62	;	;	:
18637	18365	63	a	a	DT
18637	18365	64	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	18365	65	for	for	IN
18637	18365	66	the	the	DT
18637	18365	67	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18365	68	shall	shall	MD
18637	18365	69	consist	consist	VB
18637	18365	70	of	of	IN
18637	18365	71	two	two	CD
18637	18365	72	-	-	HYPH
18637	18365	73	thirds	third	NNS
18637	18365	74	of	of	IN
18637	18365	75	the	the	DT
18637	18365	76	whole	whole	JJ
18637	18365	77	number	number	NN
18637	18365	78	of	of	IN
18637	18365	79	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	18365	80	,	,	,
18637	18365	81	and	and	CC
18637	18365	82	a	a	DT
18637	18365	83	majority	majority	NN
18637	18365	84	of	of	IN
18637	18365	85	the	the	DT
18637	18365	86	whole	whole	JJ
18637	18365	87	number	number	NN
18637	18365	88	shall	shall	MD
18637	18365	89	be	be	VB
18637	18365	90	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18365	91	to	to	IN
18637	18365	92	a	a	DT
18637	18365	93	choice	choice	NN
18637	18365	94	.	.	.
18637	18366	1	But	but	CC
18637	18366	2	no	no	DT
18637	18366	3	person	person	NN
18637	18366	4	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	18366	5	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	18366	6	to	to	IN
18637	18366	7	the	the	DT
18637	18366	8	office	office	NN
18637	18366	9	of	of	IN
18637	18366	10	President	President	NNP
18637	18366	11	shall	shall	MD
18637	18366	12	be	be	VB
18637	18366	13	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	18366	14	to	to	IN
18637	18366	15	that	that	DT
18637	18366	16	of	of	IN
18637	18366	17	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	18366	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	18366	19	President	President	NNP
18637	18366	20	of	of	IN
18637	18366	21	the	the	DT
18637	18366	22	United	United	NNP
18637	18366	23	States	States	NNP
18637	18366	24	.	.	.
18637	18367	1	Purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18367	2	and	and	CC
18637	18367	3	Operation	Operation	NNP
18637	18367	4	of	of	IN
18637	18367	5	the	the	DT
18637	18367	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18367	7	This	This	NNP
18637	18367	8	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18367	9	,	,	,
18637	18367	10	which	which	WDT
18637	18367	11	supersedes	supersede	VBZ
18637	18367	12	clause	clause	NN
18637	18367	13	3	3	CD
18637	18367	14	of	of	IN
18637	18367	15	section	section	NN
18637	18367	16	1	1	CD
18637	18367	17	of	of	IN
18637	18367	18	article	article	NN
18637	18367	19	II	II	NNP
18637	18367	20	,	,	,
18637	18367	21	of	of	IN
18637	18367	22	the	the	DT
18637	18367	23	original	original	JJ
18637	18367	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18367	25	,	,	,
18637	18367	26	was	be	VBD
18637	18367	27	inserted	insert	VBN
18637	18367	28	on	on	IN
18637	18367	29	account	account	NN
18637	18367	30	of	of	IN
18637	18367	31	the	the	DT
18637	18367	32	tie	tie	NN
18637	18367	33	between	between	IN
18637	18367	34	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	18367	35	and	and	CC
18637	18367	36	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	18367	37	in	in	IN
18637	18367	38	the	the	DT
18637	18367	39	election	election	NN
18637	18367	40	of	of	IN
18637	18367	41	1800	1800	CD
18637	18367	42	.	.	.
18637	18368	1	The	the	DT
18637	18368	2	difference	difference	NN
18637	18368	3	between	between	IN
18637	18368	4	the	the	DT
18637	18368	5	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	18368	6	which	which	WDT
18637	18368	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18368	8	defines	define	VBZ
18637	18368	9	and	and	CC
18637	18368	10	that	that	IN
18637	18368	11	which	which	WDT
18637	18368	12	was	be	VBD
18637	18368	13	laid	lay	VBN
18637	18368	14	down	down	RP
18637	18368	15	in	in	IN
18637	18368	16	the	the	DT
18637	18368	17	original	original	JJ
18637	18368	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18368	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	18368	20	in	in	IN
18637	18368	21	the	the	DT
18637	18368	22	provision	provision	NN
18637	18368	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18368	24	makes	make	VBZ
18637	18368	25	for	for	IN
18637	18368	26	a	a	DT
18637	18368	27	separate	separate	JJ
18637	18368	28	designation	designation	NN
18637	18368	29	by	by	IN
18637	18368	30	the	the	DT
18637	18368	31	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	18368	32	of	of	IN
18637	18368	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18368	34	choices	choice	NNS
18637	18368	35	for	for	IN
18637	18368	36	President	President	NNP
18637	18368	37	and	and	CC
18637	18368	38	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	18368	39	President	President	NNP
18637	18368	40	,	,	,
18637	18368	41	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	18368	42	.	.	.
18637	18369	1	The	the	DT
18637	18369	2	final	final	JJ
18637	18369	3	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	18369	4	of	of	IN
18637	18369	5	clause	clause	NN
18637	18369	6	1	1	CD
18637	18369	7	,	,	,
18637	18369	8	above	above	RB
18637	18369	9	,	,	,
18637	18369	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	18369	11	been	be	VBN
18637	18369	12	in	in	IN
18637	18369	13	turn	turn	NN
18637	18369	14	superseded	supersede	VBN
18637	18369	15	today	today	NN
18637	18369	16	by	by	IN
18637	18369	17	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18369	18	XX	XX	NNP
18637	18369	19	.	.	.
18637	18370	1	In	in	IN
18637	18370	2	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	18370	3	of	of	IN
18637	18370	4	the	the	DT
18637	18370	5	disputed	dispute	VBN
18637	18370	6	election	election	NN
18637	18370	7	of	of	IN
18637	18370	8	1876	1876	CD
18637	18370	9	,	,	,
18637	18370	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18370	11	,	,	,
18637	18370	12	by	by	IN
18637	18370	13	an	an	DT
18637	18370	14	act	act	NN
18637	18370	15	passed	pass	VBN
18637	18370	16	in	in	IN
18637	18370	17	1887	1887	CD
18637	18370	18	,	,	,
18637	18370	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	18370	20	laid	lay	VBN
18637	18370	21	down	down	RP
18637	18370	22	the	the	DT
18637	18370	23	rule	rule	NN
18637	18370	24	that	that	IN
18637	18370	25	if	if	IN
18637	18370	26	the	the	DT
18637	18370	27	vote	vote	NN
18637	18370	28	of	of	IN
18637	18370	29	a	a	DT
18637	18370	30	State	state	NN
18637	18370	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	18370	32	not	not	RB
18637	18370	33	certified	certify	VBN
18637	18370	34	by	by	IN
18637	18370	35	the	the	DT
18637	18370	36	governor	governor	NN
18637	18370	37	under	under	IN
18637	18370	38	the	the	DT
18637	18370	39	seal	seal	NN
18637	18370	40	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18370	41	,	,	,
18637	18370	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18370	43	shall	shall	MD
18637	18370	44	not	not	RB
18637	18370	45	be	be	VB
18637	18370	46	counted	count	VBN
18637	18370	47	unless	unless	IN
18637	18370	48	both	both	DT
18637	18370	49	Houses	Houses	NNPS
18637	18370	50	of	of	IN
18637	18370	51	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18370	52	are	be	VBP
18637	18370	53	favorable	favorable	JJ
18637	18370	54	.	.	.
18637	18371	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18371	2	3	3	LS
18637	18371	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18371	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18371	5	should	should	MD
18637	18371	6	be	be	VB
18637	18371	7	noted	note	VBN
18637	18371	8	that	that	IN
18637	18371	9	no	no	DT
18637	18371	10	provision	provision	NN
18637	18371	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	18371	12	made	make	VBN
18637	18371	13	by	by	IN
18637	18371	14	this	this	DT
18637	18371	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18371	16	for	for	IN
18637	18371	17	the	the	DT
18637	18371	18	situation	situation	NN
18637	18371	19	which	which	WDT
18637	18371	20	would	would	MD
18637	18371	21	result	result	VB
18637	18371	22	from	from	IN
18637	18371	23	a	a	DT
18637	18371	24	failure	failure	NN
18637	18371	25	to	to	TO
18637	18371	26	choose	choose	VB
18637	18371	27	either	either	CC
18637	18371	28	a	a	DT
18637	18371	29	President	President	NNP
18637	18371	30	or	or	CC
18637	18371	31	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	18371	32	President	President	NNP
18637	18371	33	,	,	,
18637	18371	34	an	an	DT
18637	18371	35	inadequacy	inadequacy	NN
18637	18371	36	which	which	WDT
18637	18371	37	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18371	38	XX	XX	NNP
18637	18371	39	undertakes	undertake	VBZ
18637	18371	40	to	to	TO
18637	18371	41	cure	cure	VB
18637	18371	42	.	.	.
18637	18372	1	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	18372	2	as	as	IN
18637	18372	3	Free	Free	NNP
18637	18372	4	Agents	Agents	NNPS
18637	18372	5	Acting	act	VBG
18637	18372	6	under	under	IN
18637	18372	7	the	the	DT
18637	18372	8	authority	authority	NN
18637	18372	9	of	of	IN
18637	18372	10	state	state	NN
18637	18372	11	law	law	NN
18637	18372	12	,	,	,
18637	18372	13	the	the	DT
18637	18372	14	Democratic	Democratic	NNP
18637	18372	15	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	18372	16	of	of	IN
18637	18372	17	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	18372	18	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	18372	19	a	a	DT
18637	18372	20	rule	rule	NN
18637	18372	21	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18372	22	that	that	IN
18637	18372	23	a	a	DT
18637	18372	24	party	party	NN
18637	18372	25	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	18372	26	for	for	IN
18637	18372	27	the	the	DT
18637	18372	28	office	office	NN
18637	18372	29	of	of	IN
18637	18372	30	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	18372	31	Elector	Elector	NNP
18637	18372	32	take	take	VB
18637	18372	33	a	a	DT
18637	18372	34	pledge	pledge	NN
18637	18372	35	to	to	TO
18637	18372	36	support	support	VB
18637	18372	37	the	the	DT
18637	18372	38	nominees	nominee	NNS
18637	18372	39	of	of	IN
18637	18372	40	the	the	DT
18637	18372	41	party	party	NN
18637	18372	42	's	's	POS
18637	18372	43	National	National	NNP
18637	18372	44	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	18372	45	for	for	IN
18637	18372	46	President	President	NNP
18637	18372	47	and	and	CC
18637	18372	48	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	18372	49	President	President	NNP
18637	18372	50	and	and	CC
18637	18372	51	that	that	IN
18637	18372	52	the	the	DT
18637	18372	53	party	party	NN
18637	18372	54	's	's	POS
18637	18372	55	officers	officer	NNS
18637	18372	56	refuse	refuse	VBP
18637	18372	57	to	to	TO
18637	18372	58	certify	certify	VB
18637	18372	59	as	as	IN
18637	18372	60	a	a	DT
18637	18372	61	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	18372	62	for	for	IN
18637	18372	63	such	such	JJ
18637	18372	64	office	office	NN
18637	18372	65	any	any	DT
18637	18372	66	person	person	NN
18637	18372	67	who	who	WP
18637	18372	68	,	,	,
18637	18372	69	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	18372	70	qualified	qualify	VBD
18637	18372	71	,	,	,
18637	18372	72	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	18372	73	to	to	TO
18637	18372	74	take	take	VB
18637	18372	75	such	such	PDT
18637	18372	76	a	a	DT
18637	18372	77	pledge	pledge	NN
18637	18372	78	.	.	.
18637	18373	1	One	one	CD
18637	18373	2	Blair	Blair	NNP
18637	18373	3	did	do	VBD
18637	18373	4	so	so	RB
18637	18373	5	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	18373	6	and	and	CC
18637	18373	7	was	be	VBD
18637	18373	8	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	18373	9	,	,	,
18637	18373	10	in	in	IN
18637	18373	11	mandamus	mandamus	NNP
18637	18373	12	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18373	13	,	,	,
18637	18373	14	by	by	IN
18637	18373	15	the	the	DT
18637	18373	16	State	State	NNP
18637	18373	17	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	18373	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18373	19	,	,	,
18637	18373	20	which	which	WDT
18637	18373	21	ordered	order	VBD
18637	18373	22	the	the	DT
18637	18373	23	Chairman	Chairman	NNP
18637	18373	24	of	of	IN
18637	18373	25	the	the	DT
18637	18373	26	State	State	NNP
18637	18373	27	Democratic	Democratic	NNP
18637	18373	28	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	18373	29	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	18373	30	to	to	TO
18637	18373	31	certify	certify	VB
18637	18373	32	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18373	33	to	to	IN
18637	18373	34	the	the	DT
18637	18373	35	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	18373	36	of	of	IN
18637	18373	37	State	State	NNP
18637	18373	38	as	as	IN
18637	18373	39	a	a	DT
18637	18373	40	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	18373	41	for	for	IN
18637	18373	42	the	the	DT
18637	18373	43	office	office	NN
18637	18373	44	of	of	IN
18637	18373	45	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	18373	46	Elector	Elector	NNP
18637	18373	47	in	in	IN
18637	18373	48	the	the	DT
18637	18373	49	Democratic	Democratic	NNP
18637	18373	50	Primary	Primary	NNP
18637	18373	51	to	to	TO
18637	18373	52	be	be	VB
18637	18373	53	held	hold	VBN
18637	18373	54	on	on	IN
18637	18373	55	May	May	NNP
18637	18373	56	6	6	CD
18637	18373	57	,	,	,
18637	18373	58	1952	1952	CD
18637	18373	59	.	.	.
18637	18374	1	The	the	DT
18637	18374	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	18374	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18374	4	at	at	IN
18637	18374	5	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	18374	6	granted	grant	VBD
18637	18374	7	certiorari	certiorari	JJ
18637	18374	8	and	and	CC
18637	18374	9	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	18374	10	this	this	DT
18637	18374	11	holding	holding	NN
18637	18374	12	.	.	.
18637	18375	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18375	2	4	4	LS
18637	18375	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18375	4	The	the	DT
18637	18375	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18375	6	issue	issue	NN
18637	18375	7	arose	arise	VBD
18637	18375	8	out	out	IN
18637	18375	9	of	of	IN
18637	18375	10	the	the	DT
18637	18375	11	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	18375	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18375	13	's	's	POS
18637	18375	14	findings	finding	NNS
18637	18375	15	that	that	WDT
18637	18375	16	the	the	DT
18637	18375	17	required	require	VBN
18637	18375	18	pledge	pledge	NN
18637	18375	19	was	be	VBD
18637	18375	20	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
18637	18375	21	with	with	IN
18637	18375	22	the	the	DT
18637	18375	23	Twelfth	Twelfth	NNP
18637	18375	24	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18375	25	,	,	,
18637	18375	26	which	which	WDT
18637	18375	27	contemplated	contemplate	VBD
18637	18375	28	that	that	IN
18637	18375	29	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	18375	30	,	,	,
18637	18375	31	once	once	RB
18637	18375	32	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	18375	33	,	,	,
18637	18375	34	should	should	MD
18637	18375	35	be	be	VB
18637	18375	36	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	18375	37	free	free	JJ
18637	18375	38	to	to	TO
18637	18375	39	vote	vote	VB
18637	18375	40	for	for	IN
18637	18375	41	any	any	DT
18637	18375	42	person	person	NN
18637	18375	43	who	who	WP
18637	18375	44	was	be	VBD
18637	18375	45	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	18375	46	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	18375	47	to	to	IN
18637	18375	48	the	the	DT
18637	18375	49	office	office	NN
18637	18375	50	of	of	IN
18637	18375	51	President	President	NNP
18637	18375	52	or	or	CC
18637	18375	53	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	18375	54	President	President	NNP
18637	18375	55	.	.	.
18637	18376	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18376	2	5	5	LS
18637	18376	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18376	4	This	this	DT
18637	18376	5	position	position	NN
18637	18376	6	the	the	DT
18637	18376	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	18376	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18376	9	combatted	combat	VBD
18637	18376	10	as	as	IN
18637	18376	11	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	18376	12	:	:	:
18637	18376	13	"	"	``
18637	18376	14	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18376	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	18376	16	true	true	JJ
18637	18376	17	that	that	IN
18637	18376	18	the	the	DT
18637	18376	19	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18376	20	says	say	VBZ
18637	18376	21	the	the	DT
18637	18376	22	electors	elector	NNS
18637	18376	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	18376	24	vote	vote	VB
18637	18376	25	by	by	IN
18637	18376	26	ballot	ballot	NN
18637	18376	27	.	.	.
18637	18377	1	But	but	CC
18637	18377	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18377	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	18377	4	also	also	RB
18637	18377	5	true	true	JJ
18637	18377	6	that	that	IN
18637	18377	7	the	the	DT
18637	18377	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18377	9	does	do	VBZ
18637	18377	10	not	not	RB
18637	18377	11	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	18377	12	an	an	DT
18637	18377	13	elector	elector	NN
18637	18377	14	's	's	POS
18637	18377	15	announcing	announce	VBG
18637	18377	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18377	17	choice	choice	NN
18637	18377	18	beforehand	beforehand	RB
18637	18377	19	,	,	,
18637	18377	20	pledging	pledge	VBG
18637	18377	21	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18377	22	.	.	.
18637	18378	1	The	the	DT
18637	18378	2	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	18378	3	that	that	IN
18637	18378	4	in	in	IN
18637	18378	5	the	the	DT
18637	18378	6	early	early	JJ
18637	18378	7	elections	election	NNS
18637	18378	8	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	18378	9	for	for	IN
18637	18378	10	electors	elector	NNS
18637	18378	11	--	--	:
18637	18378	12	contemporaries	contemporary	NNS
18637	18378	13	of	of	IN
18637	18378	14	the	the	DT
18637	18378	15	Founders	founder	NNS
18637	18378	16	--	--	:
18637	18378	17	would	would	MD
18637	18378	18	have	have	VB
18637	18378	19	hesitated	hesitate	VBN
18637	18378	20	,	,	,
18637	18378	21	because	because	IN
18637	18378	22	of	of	IN
18637	18378	23	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18378	24	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	18378	25	,	,	,
18637	18378	26	to	to	TO
18637	18378	27	pledge	pledge	VB
18637	18378	28	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18378	29	to	to	TO
18637	18378	30	support	support	VB
18637	18378	31	party	party	NN
18637	18378	32	nominees	nominee	NNS
18637	18378	33	in	in	IN
18637	18378	34	the	the	DT
18637	18378	35	event	event	NN
18637	18378	36	of	of	IN
18637	18378	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18378	38	selection	selection	NN
18637	18378	39	as	as	IN
18637	18378	40	electors	elector	NNS
18637	18378	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	18378	42	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	18378	43	to	to	TO
18637	18378	44	accept	accept	VB
18637	18378	45	.	.	.
18637	18379	1	History	history	NN
18637	18379	2	teaches	teach	VBZ
18637	18379	3	that	that	IN
18637	18379	4	the	the	DT
18637	18379	5	electors	elector	NNS
18637	18379	6	were	be	VBD
18637	18379	7	expected	expect	VBN
18637	18379	8	to	to	TO
18637	18379	9	support	support	VB
18637	18379	10	the	the	DT
18637	18379	11	party	party	NN
18637	18379	12	nominees	nominee	NNS
18637	18379	13	.	.	.
18637	18380	1	Experts	expert	NNS
18637	18380	2	in	in	IN
18637	18380	3	the	the	DT
18637	18380	4	history	history	NN
18637	18380	5	of	of	IN
18637	18380	6	government	government	NN
18637	18380	7	recognize	recognize	VBP
18637	18380	8	the	the	DT
18637	18380	9	longstanding	longstanding	JJ
18637	18380	10	practice	practice	NN
18637	18380	11	.	.	.
18637	18381	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	18381	2	,	,	,
18637	18381	3	more	more	JJR
18637	18381	4	than	than	IN
18637	18381	5	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	18381	6	states	state	NNS
18637	18381	7	do	do	VBP
18637	18381	8	not	not	RB
18637	18381	9	print	print	VB
18637	18381	10	the	the	DT
18637	18381	11	names	name	NNS
18637	18381	12	of	of	IN
18637	18381	13	the	the	DT
18637	18381	14	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	18381	15	for	for	IN
18637	18381	16	electors	elector	NNS
18637	18381	17	on	on	IN
18637	18381	18	the	the	DT
18637	18381	19	general	general	JJ
18637	18381	20	election	election	NN
18637	18381	21	ballot	ballot	NN
18637	18381	22	.	.	.
18637	18382	1	Instead	instead	RB
18637	18382	2	,	,	,
18637	18382	3	in	in	IN
18637	18382	4	one	one	CD
18637	18382	5	form	form	NN
18637	18382	6	or	or	CC
18637	18382	7	another	another	DT
18637	18382	8	,	,	,
18637	18382	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18382	10	allow	allow	VBP
18637	18382	11	a	a	DT
18637	18382	12	vote	vote	NN
18637	18382	13	for	for	IN
18637	18382	14	the	the	DT
18637	18382	15	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	18382	16	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	18382	17	of	of	IN
18637	18382	18	the	the	DT
18637	18382	19	national	national	JJ
18637	18382	20	conventions	convention	NNS
18637	18382	21	to	to	TO
18637	18382	22	be	be	VB
18637	18382	23	counted	count	VBN
18637	18382	24	as	as	IN
18637	18382	25	a	a	DT
18637	18382	26	vote	vote	NN
18637	18382	27	for	for	IN
18637	18382	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18382	29	party	party	NN
18637	18382	30	's	's	POS
18637	18382	31	nominees	nominee	NNS
18637	18382	32	for	for	IN
18637	18382	33	the	the	DT
18637	18382	34	electoral	electoral	JJ
18637	18382	35	college	college	NN
18637	18382	36	.	.	.
18637	18383	1	This	this	DT
18637	18383	2	long	long	RB
18637	18383	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	18383	4	continued	continue	VBN
18637	18383	5	practical	practical	JJ
18637	18383	6	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	18383	7	of	of	IN
18637	18383	8	the	the	DT
18637	18383	9	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18383	10	propriety	propriety	NN
18637	18383	11	of	of	IN
18637	18383	12	an	an	DT
18637	18383	13	implied	implied	JJ
18637	18383	14	or	or	CC
18637	18383	15	oral	oral	JJ
18637	18383	16	pledge	pledge	NN
18637	18383	17	of	of	IN
18637	18383	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18383	19	ballot	ballot	NN
18637	18383	20	by	by	IN
18637	18383	21	a	a	DT
18637	18383	22	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	18383	23	for	for	IN
18637	18383	24	elector	elector	NN
18637	18383	25	as	as	IN
18637	18383	26	to	to	IN
18637	18383	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18383	28	vote	vote	NN
18637	18383	29	in	in	IN
18637	18383	30	the	the	DT
18637	18383	31	electoral	electoral	JJ
18637	18383	32	college	college	NN
18637	18383	33	weighs	weigh	VBZ
18637	18383	34	heavily	heavily	RB
18637	18383	35	in	in	IN
18637	18383	36	considering	consider	VBG
18637	18383	37	the	the	DT
18637	18383	38	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	18383	39	of	of	IN
18637	18383	40	a	a	DT
18637	18383	41	pledge	pledge	NN
18637	18383	42	,	,	,
18637	18383	43	such	such	JJ
18637	18383	44	as	as	IN
18637	18383	45	the	the	DT
18637	18383	46	one	one	NN
18637	18383	47	here	here	RB
18637	18383	48	required	require	VBN
18637	18383	49	,	,	,
18637	18383	50	in	in	IN
18637	18383	51	the	the	DT
18637	18383	52	primary	primary	NN
18637	18383	53	.	.	.
18637	18384	1	However	however	RB
18637	18384	2	,	,	,
18637	18384	3	even	even	RB
18637	18384	4	if	if	IN
18637	18384	5	such	such	JJ
18637	18384	6	promises	promise	NNS
18637	18384	7	of	of	IN
18637	18384	8	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	18384	9	for	for	IN
18637	18384	10	the	the	DT
18637	18384	11	electoral	electoral	JJ
18637	18384	12	college	college	NN
18637	18384	13	are	be	VBP
18637	18384	14	legally	legally	RB
18637	18384	15	unenforceable	unenforceable	JJ
18637	18384	16	because	because	IN
18637	18384	17	violative	violative	JJ
18637	18384	18	of	of	IN
18637	18384	19	an	an	DT
18637	18384	20	assumed	assumed	JJ
18637	18384	21	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18384	22	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18384	23	of	of	IN
18637	18384	24	the	the	DT
18637	18384	25	elector	elector	NN
18637	18384	26	under	under	IN
18637	18384	27	the	the	DT
18637	18384	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18384	29	,	,	,
18637	18384	30	Art	art	NN
18637	18384	31	.	.	.
18637	18385	1	II	II	NNP
18637	18385	2	,	,	,
18637	18385	3	§	§	NNP
18637	18385	4	1	1	CD
18637	18385	5	,	,	,
18637	18385	6	to	to	TO
18637	18385	7	vote	vote	VB
18637	18385	8	as	as	IN
18637	18385	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18385	10	may	may	MD
18637	18385	11	choose	choose	VB
18637	18385	12	in	in	IN
18637	18385	13	the	the	DT
18637	18385	14	electoral	electoral	JJ
18637	18385	15	college	college	NN
18637	18385	16	,	,	,
18637	18385	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18385	18	would	would	MD
18637	18385	19	not	not	RB
18637	18385	20	follow	follow	VB
18637	18385	21	that	that	IN
18637	18385	22	the	the	DT
18637	18385	23	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	18385	24	of	of	IN
18637	18385	25	a	a	DT
18637	18385	26	pledge	pledge	NN
18637	18385	27	in	in	IN
18637	18385	28	the	the	DT
18637	18385	29	primary	primary	NN
18637	18385	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	18385	31	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18385	32	.	.	.
18637	18386	1	A	a	DT
18637	18386	2	candidacy	candidacy	NN
18637	18386	3	in	in	IN
18637	18386	4	the	the	DT
18637	18386	5	primary	primary	NN
18637	18386	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	18386	7	a	a	DT
18637	18386	8	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	18386	9	act	act	NN
18637	18386	10	of	of	IN
18637	18386	11	the	the	DT
18637	18386	12	applicant	applicant	NN
18637	18386	13	.	.	.
18637	18387	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18387	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	18387	3	not	not	RB
18637	18387	4	barred	bar	VBN
18637	18387	5	,	,	,
18637	18387	6	discriminatorily	discriminatorily	RB
18637	18387	7	,	,	,
18637	18387	8	from	from	IN
18637	18387	9	participating	participate	VBG
18637	18387	10	but	but	CC
18637	18387	11	must	must	MD
18637	18387	12	comply	comply	VB
18637	18387	13	with	with	IN
18637	18387	14	the	the	DT
18637	18387	15	rules	rule	NNS
18637	18387	16	of	of	IN
18637	18387	17	the	the	DT
18637	18387	18	party	party	NN
18637	18387	19	.	.	.
18637	18388	1	Surely	surely	RB
18637	18388	2	one	one	PRP
18637	18388	3	may	may	MD
18637	18388	4	voluntarily	voluntarily	RB
18637	18388	5	assume	assume	VB
18637	18388	6	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	18388	7	to	to	TO
18637	18388	8	vote	vote	VB
18637	18388	9	for	for	IN
18637	18388	10	a	a	DT
18637	18388	11	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18388	12	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	18388	13	.	.	.
18637	18389	1	The	the	DT
18637	18389	2	state	state	NN
18637	18389	3	offers	offer	VBZ
18637	18389	4	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18389	5	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	18389	6	to	to	TO
18637	18389	7	become	become	VB
18637	18389	8	a	a	DT
18637	18389	9	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	18389	10	for	for	IN
18637	18389	11	elector	elector	NN
18637	18389	12	on	on	IN
18637	18389	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18389	14	own	own	JJ
18637	18389	15	terms	term	NNS
18637	18389	16	,	,	,
18637	18389	17	although	although	IN
18637	18389	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18389	19	must	must	MD
18637	18389	20	file	file	VB
18637	18389	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18389	22	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	18389	23	before	before	IN
18637	18389	24	the	the	DT
18637	18389	25	primary	primary	NN
18637	18389	26	.	.	.
18637	18390	1	Ala.	Alabama	NNP
18637	18390	2	Code	Code	NNP
18637	18390	3	,	,	,
18637	18390	4	Tit	Tit	NNP
18637	18390	5	.	.	.
18637	18391	1	17	17	CD
18637	18391	2	,	,	,
18637	18391	3	§	§	NNP
18637	18391	4	145	145	CD
18637	18391	5	.	.	.
18637	18392	1	Even	even	RB
18637	18392	2	though	though	IN
18637	18392	3	the	the	DT
18637	18392	4	victory	victory	NN
18637	18392	5	of	of	IN
18637	18392	6	an	an	DT
18637	18392	7	independent	independent	JJ
18637	18392	8	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	18392	9	for	for	IN
18637	18392	10	elector	elector	NN
18637	18392	11	in	in	IN
18637	18392	12	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	18392	13	can	can	MD
18637	18392	14	not	not	RB
18637	18392	15	be	be	VB
18637	18392	16	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
18637	18392	17	,	,	,
18637	18392	18	the	the	DT
18637	18392	19	state	state	NN
18637	18392	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	18392	21	offer	offer	VB
18637	18392	22	the	the	DT
18637	18392	23	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	18392	24	for	for	IN
18637	18392	25	the	the	DT
18637	18392	26	development	development	NN
18637	18392	27	of	of	IN
18637	18392	28	other	other	JJ
18637	18392	29	strong	strong	JJ
18637	18392	30	political	political	JJ
18637	18392	31	organizations	organization	NNS
18637	18392	32	where	where	WRB
18637	18392	33	the	the	DT
18637	18392	34	need	need	NN
18637	18392	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	18392	36	felt	feel	VBN
18637	18392	37	for	for	IN
18637	18392	38	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18392	39	by	by	IN
18637	18392	40	a	a	DT
18637	18392	41	sizable	sizable	JJ
18637	18392	42	block	block	NN
18637	18392	43	of	of	IN
18637	18392	44	voters	voter	NNS
18637	18392	45	.	.	.
18637	18393	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	18393	2	parties	party	NNS
18637	18393	3	may	may	MD
18637	18393	4	leave	leave	VB
18637	18393	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18393	6	electors	elector	NNS
18637	18393	7	to	to	IN
18637	18393	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18393	9	own	own	JJ
18637	18393	10	choice	choice	NN
18637	18393	11	.	.	.
18637	18394	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18394	2	conclude	conclude	VBP
18637	18394	3	that	that	IN
18637	18394	4	the	the	DT
18637	18394	5	Twelfth	Twelfth	NNP
18637	18394	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18394	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	18394	8	not	not	RB
18637	18394	9	bar	bar	VB
18637	18394	10	a	a	DT
18637	18394	11	political	political	JJ
18637	18394	12	party	party	NN
18637	18394	13	from	from	IN
18637	18394	14	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18394	15	the	the	DT
18637	18394	16	pledge	pledge	NN
18637	18394	17	to	to	TO
18637	18394	18	support	support	VB
18637	18394	19	the	the	DT
18637	18394	20	nominees	nominee	NNS
18637	18394	21	of	of	IN
18637	18394	22	the	the	DT
18637	18394	23	National	National	NNP
18637	18394	24	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	18394	25	.	.	.
18637	18395	1	Where	where	WRB
18637	18395	2	a	a	DT
18637	18395	3	state	state	NN
18637	18395	4	authorizes	authorize	VBZ
18637	18395	5	a	a	DT
18637	18395	6	party	party	NN
18637	18395	7	to	to	TO
18637	18395	8	choose	choose	VB
18637	18395	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18395	10	nominees	nominee	NNS
18637	18395	11	for	for	IN
18637	18395	12	elector	elector	NN
18637	18395	13	in	in	IN
18637	18395	14	a	a	DT
18637	18395	15	party	party	NN
18637	18395	16	primary	primary	NN
18637	18395	17	and	and	CC
18637	18395	18	to	to	TO
18637	18395	19	fix	fix	VB
18637	18395	20	the	the	DT
18637	18395	21	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	18395	22	for	for	IN
18637	18395	23	the	the	DT
18637	18395	24	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	18395	25	,	,	,
18637	18395	26	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18395	27	see	see	VBP
18637	18395	28	no	no	DT
18637	18395	29	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18395	30	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18395	31	objection	objection	NN
18637	18395	32	to	to	IN
18637	18395	33	the	the	DT
18637	18395	34	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	18395	35	of	of	IN
18637	18395	36	this	this	DT
18637	18395	37	pledge	pledge	NN
18637	18395	38	.	.	.
18637	18396	1	"	"	``
18637	18396	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18396	3	6	6	CD
18637	18396	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18396	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18396	6	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	18396	7	conceding	concede	VBG
18637	18396	8	that	that	IN
18637	18396	9	"	"	``
18637	18396	10	as	as	IN
18637	18396	11	an	an	DT
18637	18396	12	institution	institution	NN
18637	18396	13	the	the	DT
18637	18396	14	Electoral	Electoral	NNP
18637	18396	15	College	College	NNP
18637	18396	16	suffered	suffer	VBD
18637	18396	17	atrophy	atrophy	NN
18637	18396	18	almost	almost	RB
18637	18396	19	indistinguishable	indistinguishable	JJ
18637	18396	20	from	from	IN
18637	18396	21	_	_	NNP
18637	18396	22	rigor	rigor	NNP
18637	18396	23	mortis	mortis	NNP
18637	18396	24	_	_	NNP
18637	18396	25	,	,	,
18637	18396	26	"	"	''
18637	18396	27	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	18396	28	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	18396	29	on	on	IN
18637	18396	30	the	the	DT
18637	18396	31	following	follow	VBG
18637	18396	32	ground	ground	NN
18637	18396	33	:	:	:
18637	18396	34	"	"	``
18637	18396	35	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18396	36	may	may	MD
18637	18396	37	be	be	VB
18637	18396	38	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	18396	39	that	that	IN
18637	18396	40	this	this	DT
18637	18396	41	law	law	NN
18637	18396	42	does	do	VBZ
18637	18396	43	no	no	DT
18637	18396	44	more	more	JJR
18637	18396	45	than	than	IN
18637	18396	46	to	to	TO
18637	18396	47	make	make	VB
18637	18396	48	a	a	DT
18637	18396	49	legal	legal	JJ
18637	18396	50	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	18396	51	of	of	IN
18637	18396	52	what	what	WP
18637	18396	53	has	have	VBZ
18637	18396	54	been	be	VBN
18637	18396	55	a	a	DT
18637	18396	56	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	18396	57	general	general	JJ
18637	18396	58	practice	practice	NN
18637	18396	59	.	.	.
18637	18397	1	If	if	IN
18637	18397	2	custom	custom	NN
18637	18397	3	were	be	VBD
18637	18397	4	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	18397	5	authority	authority	NN
18637	18397	6	for	for	IN
18637	18397	7	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18397	8	of	of	IN
18637	18397	9	the	the	DT
18637	18397	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18397	11	by	by	IN
18637	18397	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18397	13	decree	decree	NN
18637	18397	14	,	,	,
18637	18397	15	the	the	DT
18637	18397	16	decision	decision	NN
18637	18397	17	in	in	IN
18637	18397	18	this	this	DT
18637	18397	19	matter	matter	NN
18637	18397	20	would	would	MD
18637	18397	21	be	be	VB
18637	18397	22	warranted	warrant	VBN
18637	18397	23	.	.	.
18637	18398	1	Usage	usage	NN
18637	18398	2	may	may	MD
18637	18398	3	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	18398	4	impart	impart	VB
18637	18398	5	changed	change	VBN
18637	18398	6	content	content	NN
18637	18398	7	to	to	IN
18637	18398	8	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18398	9	generalities	generality	NNS
18637	18398	10	,	,	,
18637	18398	11	such	such	JJ
18637	18398	12	as	as	IN
18637	18398	13	'	'	``
18637	18398	14	due	due	JJ
18637	18398	15	process	process	NN
18637	18398	16	of	of	IN
18637	18398	17	law	law	NN
18637	18398	18	,	,	,
18637	18398	19	'	'	''
18637	18398	20	'	'	``
18637	18398	21	equal	equal	JJ
18637	18398	22	protection	protection	NN
18637	18398	23	,	,	,
18637	18398	24	'	'	''
18637	18398	25	or	or	CC
18637	18398	26	'	'	''
18637	18398	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18398	28	among	among	IN
18637	18398	29	the	the	DT
18637	18398	30	states	state	NNS
18637	18398	31	.	.	.
18637	18398	32	'	'	''
18637	18399	1	But	but	CC
18637	18399	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18399	3	do	do	VBP
18637	18399	4	not	not	RB
18637	18399	5	think	think	VB
18637	18399	6	powers	power	NNS
18637	18399	7	or	or	CC
18637	18399	8	discretions	discretion	NNS
18637	18399	9	granted	grant	VBN
18637	18399	10	to	to	IN
18637	18399	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18399	12	officials	official	NNS
18637	18399	13	by	by	IN
18637	18399	14	the	the	DT
18637	18399	15	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18399	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18399	17	can	can	MD
18637	18399	18	be	be	VB
18637	18399	19	forfeited	forfeit	VBN
18637	18399	20	by	by	IN
18637	18399	21	the	the	DT
18637	18399	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18399	23	for	for	IN
18637	18399	24	disuse	disuse	NN
18637	18399	25	.	.	.
18637	18400	1	A	a	DT
18637	18400	2	political	political	JJ
18637	18400	3	practice	practice	NN
18637	18400	4	which	which	WDT
18637	18400	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	18400	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18400	7	origin	origin	NN
18637	18400	8	in	in	IN
18637	18400	9	custom	custom	NN
18637	18400	10	must	must	MD
18637	18400	11	rely	rely	VB
18637	18400	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	18400	13	custom	custom	NN
18637	18400	14	for	for	IN
18637	18400	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18400	16	sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	18400	17	.	.	.
18637	18401	1	"	"	``
18637	18401	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18401	3	7	7	CD
18637	18401	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18401	5	Notes	note	NNS
18637	18401	6	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18401	7	1	1	CD
18637	18401	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18401	9	By	by	IN
18637	18401	10	the	the	DT
18637	18401	11	Twentieth	Twentieth	NNP
18637	18401	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18401	13	,	,	,
18637	18401	14	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	18401	15	in	in	IN
18637	18401	16	1933	1933	CD
18637	18401	17	,	,	,
18637	18401	18	the	the	DT
18637	18401	19	term	term	NN
18637	18401	20	of	of	IN
18637	18401	21	the	the	DT
18637	18401	22	President	President	NNP
18637	18401	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	18401	24	to	to	TO
18637	18401	25	begin	begin	VB
18637	18401	26	on	on	IN
18637	18401	27	the	the	DT
18637	18401	28	20th	20th	NN
18637	18401	29	of	of	IN
18637	18401	30	January	January	NNP
18637	18401	31	.	.	.
18637	18402	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18402	2	2	2	LS
18637	18402	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18402	4	Under	under	IN
18637	18402	5	the	the	DT
18637	18402	6	Twentieth	Twentieth	NNP
18637	18402	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18402	8	,	,	,
18637	18402	9	§	§	NNP
18637	18402	10	3	3	CD
18637	18402	11	,	,	,
18637	18402	12	in	in	IN
18637	18402	13	case	case	NN
18637	18402	14	a	a	DT
18637	18402	15	President	President	NNP
18637	18402	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	18402	17	not	not	RB
18637	18402	18	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	18402	19	before	before	IN
18637	18402	20	the	the	DT
18637	18402	21	time	time	NN
18637	18402	22	for	for	IN
18637	18402	23	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	18402	24	of	of	IN
18637	18402	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18402	26	term	term	NN
18637	18402	27	,	,	,
18637	18402	28	the	the	DT
18637	18402	29	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	18402	30	President	President	NNP
18637	18402	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	18402	32	elect	elect	NNP
18637	18402	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	18402	34	act	act	VB
18637	18402	35	as	as	IN
18637	18402	36	President	President	NNP
18637	18402	37	,	,	,
18637	18402	38	until	until	IN
18637	18402	39	a	a	DT
18637	18402	40	President	President	NNP
18637	18402	41	shall	shall	MD
18637	18402	42	have	have	VB
18637	18402	43	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	18402	44	.	.	.
18637	18403	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18403	2	3	3	CD
18637	18403	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18403	4	3	3	CD
18637	18403	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	18404	1	§	§	NNP
18637	18404	2	17	17	CD
18637	18404	3	.	.	.
18637	18405	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18405	2	4	4	CD
18637	18405	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18405	4	Ray	Ray	NNP
18637	18405	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18405	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18405	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18405	8	Blair	Blair	NNP
18637	18405	9	,	,	,
18637	18405	10	343	343	CD
18637	18405	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18405	12	214	214	CD
18637	18405	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18405	14	1952	1952	CD
18637	18405	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18405	16	.	.	.
18637	18406	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18406	2	5	5	CD
18637	18406	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18406	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18406	5	.	.	.
18637	18407	1	218	218	CD
18637	18407	2	-	-	SYM
18637	18407	3	219	219	CD
18637	18407	4	.	.	.
18637	18408	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18408	2	6	6	CD
18637	18408	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18408	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18408	5	.	.	.
18637	18409	1	228	228	CD
18637	18409	2	-	-	SYM
18637	18409	3	231	231	CD
18637	18409	4	.	.	.
18637	18410	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18410	2	7	7	CD
18637	18410	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18410	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18410	5	.	.	.
18637	18411	1	232	232	CD
18637	18411	2	-	-	SYM
18637	18411	3	233	233	CD
18637	18411	4	.	.	.
18637	18412	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	18412	2	13	13	CD
18637	18412	3	SLAVERY	SLAVERY	NNS
18637	18412	4	AND	and	CC
18637	18412	5	INVOLUNTARY	INVOLUNTARY	NNP
18637	18412	6	SERVITUDE	SERVITUDE	NNP
18637	18412	7	Page	page	NN
18637	18412	8	Origin	Origin	NNP
18637	18412	9	and	and	CC
18637	18412	10	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18412	11	of	of	IN
18637	18412	12	the	the	DT
18637	18412	13	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18412	14	949	949	CD
18637	18412	15	Peonage	Peonage	NNP
18637	18412	16	950	950	CD
18637	18412	17	Discriminations	Discriminations	NNPS
18637	18412	18	and	and	CC
18637	18412	19	legal	legal	JJ
18637	18412	20	compulsions	compulsion	NNS
18637	18412	21	less	less	JJR
18637	18412	22	than	than	IN
18637	18412	23	servitude	servitude	VB
18637	18412	24	951	951	CD
18637	18412	25	Enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18412	26	953	953	CD
18637	18412	27	SLAVERY	SLAVERY	NNS
18637	18412	28	AND	and	CC
18637	18412	29	INVOLUNTARY	INVOLUNTARY	NNP
18637	18412	30	SERVITUDE	SERVITUDE	NNP
18637	18412	31	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18412	32	13	13	CD
18637	18412	33	Section	Section	NNP
18637	18412	34	1	1	CD
18637	18412	35	.	.	.
18637	18413	1	Neither	neither	DT
18637	18413	2	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	18413	3	nor	nor	CC
18637	18413	4	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	18413	5	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18413	6	,	,	,
18637	18413	7	except	except	IN
18637	18413	8	as	as	IN
18637	18413	9	a	a	DT
18637	18413	10	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	18413	11	for	for	IN
18637	18413	12	crime	crime	NN
18637	18413	13	whereof	whereof	IN
18637	18413	14	the	the	DT
18637	18413	15	party	party	NN
18637	18413	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	18413	17	have	have	VB
18637	18413	18	been	be	VBN
18637	18413	19	duly	duly	RB
18637	18413	20	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	18413	21	,	,	,
18637	18413	22	shall	shall	MD
18637	18413	23	exist	exist	VB
18637	18413	24	within	within	IN
18637	18413	25	the	the	DT
18637	18413	26	United	United	NNP
18637	18413	27	States	States	NNP
18637	18413	28	,	,	,
18637	18413	29	or	or	CC
18637	18413	30	any	any	DT
18637	18413	31	place	place	NN
18637	18413	32	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18413	33	to	to	IN
18637	18413	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18413	35	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18413	36	.	.	.
18637	18414	1	Section	section	NN
18637	18414	2	2	2	CD
18637	18414	3	.	.	.
18637	18415	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18415	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	18415	3	have	have	VB
18637	18415	4	power	power	NN
18637	18415	5	to	to	TO
18637	18415	6	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	18415	7	this	this	DT
18637	18415	8	article	article	NN
18637	18415	9	by	by	IN
18637	18415	10	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	18415	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18415	12	.	.	.
18637	18416	1	Origin	Origin	NNP
18637	18416	2	and	and	CC
18637	18416	3	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	18416	4	of	of	IN
18637	18416	5	the	the	DT
18637	18416	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18416	7	"	"	``
18637	18416	8	The	the	DT
18637	18416	9	language	language	NN
18637	18416	10	of	of	IN
18637	18416	11	the	the	DT
18637	18416	12	Thirteenth	Thirteenth	NNP
18637	18416	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18416	14	,	,	,
18637	18416	15	"	"	''
18637	18416	16	which	which	WDT
18637	18416	17	"	"	''
18637	18416	18	reproduced	reproduce	VBD
18637	18416	19	the	the	DT
18637	18416	20	historic	historic	JJ
18637	18416	21	words	word	NNS
18637	18416	22	of	of	IN
18637	18416	23	the	the	DT
18637	18416	24	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	18416	25	of	of	IN
18637	18416	26	1787	1787	CD
18637	18416	27	for	for	IN
18637	18416	28	the	the	DT
18637	18416	29	government	government	NN
18637	18416	30	of	of	IN
18637	18416	31	the	the	DT
18637	18416	32	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	18416	33	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	18416	34	,	,	,
18637	18416	35	and	and	CC
18637	18416	36	gave	give	VBD
18637	18416	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18416	38	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
18637	18416	39	application	application	NN
18637	18416	40	within	within	IN
18637	18416	41	the	the	DT
18637	18416	42	United	United	NNP
18637	18416	43	States,"[1	States,"[1	NNP
18637	18416	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18416	45	was	be	VBD
18637	18416	46	first	first	RB
18637	18416	47	construed	construe	VBN
18637	18416	48	in	in	IN
18637	18416	49	the	the	DT
18637	18416	50	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	18416	51	-	-	HYPH
18637	18416	52	House	House	NNP
18637	18416	53	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	18416	54	.	.	.
18637	18417	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18417	2	2	2	LS
18637	18417	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18417	4	Presented	present	VBN
18637	18417	5	there	there	RB
18637	18417	6	with	with	IN
18637	18417	7	the	the	DT
18637	18417	8	contention	contention	NN
18637	18417	9	that	that	IN
18637	18417	10	a	a	DT
18637	18417	11	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	18417	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	18417	13	,	,	,
18637	18417	14	by	by	IN
18637	18417	15	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	18417	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	18417	17	a	a	DT
18637	18417	18	single	single	JJ
18637	18417	19	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18417	20	the	the	DT
18637	18417	21	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	18417	22	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18417	23	of	of	IN
18637	18417	24	slaughtering	slaughter	VBG
18637	18417	25	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	18417	26	in	in	IN
18637	18417	27	New	New	NNP
18637	18417	28	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	18417	29	,	,	,
18637	18417	30	had	have	VBD
18637	18417	31	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18417	32	an	an	DT
18637	18417	33	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18417	34	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18417	35	on	on	IN
18637	18417	36	the	the	DT
18637	18417	37	property	property	NN
18637	18417	38	of	of	IN
18637	18417	39	other	other	JJ
18637	18417	40	butchers	butcher	NNS
18637	18417	41	disadvantaged	disadvantage	VBD
18637	18417	42	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	18417	43	,	,	,
18637	18417	44	the	the	DT
18637	18417	45	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18417	46	expressed	express	VBD
18637	18417	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18417	48	inability	inability	NN
18637	18417	49	,	,	,
18637	18417	50	even	even	RB
18637	18417	51	after	after	IN
18637	18417	52	"	"	``
18637	18417	53	a	a	DT
18637	18417	54	microscopic	microscopic	JJ
18637	18417	55	search	search	NN
18637	18417	56	,	,	,
18637	18417	57	"	"	''
18637	18417	58	to	to	TO
18637	18417	59	find	find	VB
18637	18417	60	in	in	RB
18637	18417	61	said	say	VBN
18637	18417	62	amendment	amendment	NNP
18637	18417	63	any	any	DT
18637	18417	64	"	"	``
18637	18417	65	reference	reference	NN
18637	18417	66	to	to	IN
18637	18417	67	servitudes	servitude	NNS
18637	18417	68	,	,	,
18637	18417	69	which	which	WDT
18637	18417	70	may	may	MD
18637	18417	71	have	have	VB
18637	18417	72	been	be	VBN
18637	18417	73	attached	attach	VBN
18637	18417	74	to	to	IN
18637	18417	75	property	property	NN
18637	18417	76	in	in	IN
18637	18417	77	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18417	78	localities	locality	NNS
18637	18417	79	*	*	NFP
18637	18417	80	*	*	NFP
18637	18417	81	*	*	NFP
18637	18417	82	.	.	.
18637	18417	83	"	"	''
18637	18418	1	On	on	IN
18637	18418	2	the	the	DT
18637	18418	3	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	18418	4	,	,	,
18637	18418	5	the	the	DT
18637	18418	6	term	term	NN
18637	18418	7	"	"	``
18637	18418	8	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18418	9	"	"	''
18637	18418	10	appearing	appear	VBG
18637	18418	11	therein	therein	RB
18637	18418	12	was	be	VBD
18637	18418	13	declared	declare	VBN
18637	18418	14	to	to	TO
18637	18418	15	mean	mean	VB
18637	18418	16	"	"	``
18637	18418	17	a	a	DT
18637	18418	18	personal	personal	JJ
18637	18418	19	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18418	20	*	*	NFP
18637	18418	21	*	*	NFP
18637	18418	22	*	*	NFP
18637	18418	23	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18418	24	as	as	IN
18637	18418	25	proven	prove	VBN
18637	18418	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18418	27	by	by	IN
18637	18418	28	the	the	DT
18637	18418	29	use	use	NN
18637	18418	30	of	of	IN
18637	18418	31	the	the	DT
18637	18418	32	word	word	NN
18637	18418	33	'	'	``
18637	18418	34	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	18418	35	,	,	,
18637	18418	36	'	'	''
18637	18418	37	which	which	WDT
18637	18418	38	can	can	MD
18637	18418	39	only	only	RB
18637	18418	40	apply	apply	VB
18637	18418	41	to	to	IN
18637	18418	42	human	human	JJ
18637	18418	43	beings	being	NNS
18637	18418	44	.	.	.
18637	18419	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18419	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18419	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18419	4	The	the	DT
18637	18419	5	word	word	NN
18637	18419	6	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18419	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	18419	8	of	of	IN
18637	18419	9	larger	large	JJR
18637	18419	10	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	18419	11	than	than	IN
18637	18419	12	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	18419	13	,	,	,
18637	18419	14	*	*	NFP
18637	18419	15	*	*	NFP
18637	18419	16	*	*	NFP
18637	18419	17	,	,	,
18637	18419	18	and	and	CC
18637	18419	19	the	the	DT
18637	18419	20	obvious	obvious	JJ
18637	18419	21	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18419	22	was	be	VBD
18637	18419	23	to	to	TO
18637	18419	24	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	18419	25	all	all	DT
18637	18419	26	shades	shade	NNS
18637	18419	27	and	and	CC
18637	18419	28	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	18419	29	of	of	IN
18637	18419	30	African	african	JJ
18637	18419	31	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	18419	32	.	.	.
18637	18419	33	"	"	''
18637	18420	1	But	but	CC
18637	18420	2	while	while	IN
18637	18420	3	the	the	DT
18637	18420	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18420	5	was	be	VBD
18637	18420	6	initially	initially	RB
18637	18420	7	in	in	IN
18637	18420	8	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	18420	9	as	as	IN
18637	18420	10	to	to	IN
18637	18420	11	whether	whether	IN
18637	18420	12	persons	person	NNS
18637	18420	13	other	other	JJ
18637	18420	14	than	than	IN
18637	18420	15	negroes	negro	NNS
18637	18420	16	could	could	MD
18637	18420	17	share	share	VB
18637	18420	18	in	in	IN
18637	18420	19	the	the	DT
18637	18420	20	protection	protection	NN
18637	18420	21	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	18420	22	by	by	IN
18637	18420	23	this	this	DT
18637	18420	24	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18420	25	,	,	,
18637	18420	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18420	27	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	18420	28	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	18420	29	that	that	IN
18637	18420	30	although	although	IN
18637	18420	31	"	"	``
18637	18420	32	*	*	NFP
18637	18420	33	*	*	NFP
18637	18420	34	*	*	NFP
18637	18420	35	negro	negro	JJ
18637	18420	36	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	18420	37	alone	alone	RB
18637	18420	38	was	be	VBD
18637	18420	39	in	in	IN
18637	18420	40	the	the	DT
18637	18420	41	mind	mind	NN
18637	18420	42	of	of	IN
18637	18420	43	the	the	DT
18637	18420	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18420	45	which	which	WDT
18637	18420	46	proposed	propose	VBD
18637	18420	47	the	the	DT
18637	18420	48	thirteenth	thirteenth	JJ
18637	18420	49	article	article	NN
18637	18420	50	,	,	,
18637	18420	51	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18420	52	the	the	DT
18637	18420	53	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18420	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18420	55	forbids	forbid	NNS
18637	18420	56	any	any	DT
18637	18420	57	other	other	JJ
18637	18420	58	kind	kind	NN
18637	18420	59	of	of	IN
18637	18420	60	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	18420	61	,	,	,
18637	18420	62	now	now	RB
18637	18420	63	or	or	CC
18637	18420	64	hereafter	hereafter	RB
18637	18420	65	.	.	.
18637	18421	1	If	if	IN
18637	18421	2	Mexican	mexican	JJ
18637	18421	3	peonage	peonage	NN
18637	18421	4	or	or	CC
18637	18421	5	the	the	DT
18637	18421	6	Chinese	chinese	JJ
18637	18421	7	coolie	coolie	NN
18637	18421	8	labor	labor	NN
18637	18421	9	system	system	NN
18637	18421	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	18421	11	develop	develop	VB
18637	18421	12	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	18421	13	of	of	IN
18637	18421	14	the	the	DT
18637	18421	15	Mexican	mexican	JJ
18637	18421	16	or	or	CC
18637	18421	17	Chinese	chinese	JJ
18637	18421	18	race	race	NN
18637	18421	19	within	within	IN
18637	18421	20	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18421	21	territory	territory	NN
18637	18421	22	,	,	,
18637	18421	23	this	this	DT
18637	18421	24	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18421	25	may	may	MD
18637	18421	26	safely	safely	RB
18637	18421	27	be	be	VB
18637	18421	28	trusted	trust	VBN
18637	18421	29	to	to	TO
18637	18421	30	make	make	VB
18637	18421	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18421	32	void	void	JJ
18637	18421	33	.	.	.
18637	18422	1	"	"	``
18637	18422	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18422	3	3	3	LS
18637	18422	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18422	5	All	all	DT
18637	18422	6	uncertainty	uncertainty	NN
18637	18422	7	on	on	IN
18637	18422	8	this	this	DT
18637	18422	9	score	score	NN
18637	18422	10	was	be	VBD
18637	18422	11	dispelled	dispel	VBN
18637	18422	12	in	in	IN
18637	18422	13	later	later	JJ
18637	18422	14	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	18422	15	;	;	:
18637	18422	16	and	and	CC
18637	18422	17	in	in	IN
18637	18422	18	Hodges	Hodges	NNP
18637	18422	19	_	_	NNP
18637	18422	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	18422	21	_	_	NNP
18637	18422	22	United	United	NNP
18637	18422	23	States[4	States[4	NNP
18637	18422	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18422	25	the	the	DT
18637	18422	26	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	18422	27	proclaimed	proclaim	VBD
18637	18422	28	unequivocally	unequivocally	RB
18637	18422	29	that	that	IN
18637	18422	30	the	the	DT
18637	18422	31	Thirteenth	Thirteenth	NNP
18637	18422	32	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18422	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	18422	34	"	"	``
18637	18422	35	not	not	RB
18637	18422	36	a	a	DT
18637	18422	37	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	18422	38	in	in	IN
18637	18422	39	favor	favor	NN
18637	18422	40	of	of	IN
18637	18422	41	a	a	DT
18637	18422	42	particular	particular	JJ
18637	18422	43	people	people	NNS
18637	18422	44	.	.	.
18637	18423	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18423	2	reaches	reach	VBZ
18637	18423	3	every	every	DT
18637	18423	4	race	race	NN
18637	18423	5	and	and	CC
18637	18423	6	every	every	DT
18637	18423	7	individual	individual	NN
18637	18423	8	,	,	,
18637	18423	9	and	and	CC
18637	18423	10	if	if	IN
18637	18423	11	in	in	IN
18637	18423	12	any	any	DT
18637	18423	13	respect	respect	NN
18637	18423	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18423	15	commits	commit	VBZ
18637	18423	16	one	one	CD
18637	18423	17	race	race	NN
18637	18423	18	to	to	IN
18637	18423	19	the	the	DT
18637	18423	20	nation	nation	NN
18637	18423	21	,	,	,
18637	18423	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18423	23	commits	commit	VBZ
18637	18423	24	every	every	DT
18637	18423	25	race	race	NN
18637	18423	26	and	and	CC
18637	18423	27	every	every	DT
18637	18423	28	individual	individual	NN
18637	18423	29	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18423	30	.	.	.
18637	18424	1	Slavery	slavery	NN
18637	18424	2	or	or	CC
18637	18424	3	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	18424	4	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18424	5	of	of	IN
18637	18424	6	the	the	DT
18637	18424	7	Chinese	Chinese	NNPS
18637	18424	8	,	,	,
18637	18424	9	of	of	IN
18637	18424	10	the	the	DT
18637	18424	11	Italian	Italian	NNP
18637	18424	12	,	,	,
18637	18424	13	of	of	IN
18637	18424	14	the	the	DT
18637	18424	15	Anglo	Anglo	NNP
18637	18424	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	18424	17	Saxon	Saxon	NNP
18637	18424	18	are	be	VBP
18637	18424	19	as	as	RB
18637	18424	20	much	much	JJ
18637	18424	21	within	within	IN
18637	18424	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18424	23	compass	compass	NN
18637	18424	24	as	as	IN
18637	18424	25	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	18424	26	or	or	CC
18637	18424	27	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	18424	28	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18424	29	of	of	IN
18637	18424	30	the	the	DT
18637	18424	31	African	African	NNP
18637	18424	32	.	.	.
18637	18425	1	"	"	``
18637	18425	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18425	3	5	5	CD
18637	18425	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18425	5	Peonage	Peonage	NNP
18637	18425	6	Notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	18425	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18425	8	early	early	JJ
18637	18425	9	acknowledgment	acknowledgment	NN
18637	18425	10	in	in	IN
18637	18425	11	the	the	DT
18637	18425	12	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	18425	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	18425	14	House	House	NNP
18637	18425	15	Cases	case	NNS
18637	18425	16	that	that	WDT
18637	18425	17	peonage	peonage	NN
18637	18425	18	was	be	VBD
18637	18425	19	comprehended	comprehend	VBN
18637	18425	20	within	within	IN
18637	18425	21	the	the	DT
18637	18425	22	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	18425	23	and	and	CC
18637	18425	24	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	18425	25	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18425	26	proscribed	proscribe	VBN
18637	18425	27	by	by	IN
18637	18425	28	the	the	DT
18637	18425	29	Thirteenth	Thirteenth	NNP
18637	18425	30	Amendment,[6	amendment,[6	NN
18637	18425	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18425	32	the	the	DT
18637	18425	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18425	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	18425	35	had	have	VBN
18637	18425	36	frequent	frequent	JJ
18637	18425	37	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	18425	38	to	to	TO
18637	18425	39	determine	determine	VB
18637	18425	40	whether	whether	IN
18637	18425	41	State	State	NNP
18637	18425	42	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18425	43	or	or	CC
18637	18425	44	the	the	DT
18637	18425	45	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	18425	46	of	of	IN
18637	18425	47	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	18425	48	has	have	VBZ
18637	18425	49	contributed	contribute	VBN
18637	18425	50	to	to	TO
18637	18425	51	reestablishment	reestablishment	VB
18637	18425	52	of	of	IN
18637	18425	53	that	that	DT
18637	18425	54	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	18425	55	status	status	NN
18637	18425	56	.	.	.
18637	18426	1	Defined	define	VBN
18637	18426	2	as	as	IN
18637	18426	3	a	a	DT
18637	18426	4	condition	condition	NN
18637	18426	5	of	of	IN
18637	18426	6	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	18426	7	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18426	8	by	by	IN
18637	18426	9	which	which	WDT
18637	18426	10	the	the	DT
18637	18426	11	servitor	servitor	NN
18637	18426	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	18426	13	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	18426	14	to	to	IN
18637	18426	15	labor	labor	NN
18637	18426	16	in	in	IN
18637	18426	17	liquidation	liquidation	NN
18637	18426	18	of	of	IN
18637	18426	19	some	some	DT
18637	18426	20	debt	debt	NN
18637	18426	21	or	or	CC
18637	18426	22	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	18426	23	,	,	,
18637	18426	24	either	either	CC
18637	18426	25	real	real	JJ
18637	18426	26	or	or	CC
18637	18426	27	pretended	pretended	JJ
18637	18426	28	,	,	,
18637	18426	29	against	against	IN
18637	18426	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18426	31	will	will	NN
18637	18426	32	,	,	,
18637	18426	33	peonage	peonage	NN
18637	18426	34	was	be	VBD
18637	18426	35	found	find	VBN
18637	18426	36	to	to	TO
18637	18426	37	have	have	VB
18637	18426	38	been	be	VBN
18637	18426	39	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	RB
18637	18426	40	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
18637	18426	41	by	by	IN
18637	18426	42	an	an	DT
18637	18426	43	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	18426	44	statute	statute	NN
18637	18426	45	,	,	,
18637	18426	46	directed	direct	VBN
18637	18426	47	at	at	IN
18637	18426	48	defaulting	default	VBG
18637	18426	49	sharecroppers	sharecropper	NNS
18637	18426	50	,	,	,
18637	18426	51	which	which	WDT
18637	18426	52	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	18426	53	a	a	DT
18637	18426	54	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	18426	55	liability	liability	NN
18637	18426	56	and	and	CC
18637	18426	57	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	18426	58	to	to	IN
18637	18426	59	imprisonment	imprisonment	JJ
18637	18426	60	farm	farm	NN
18637	18426	61	workers	worker	NNS
18637	18426	62	or	or	CC
18637	18426	63	tenants	tenant	NNS
18637	18426	64	who	who	WP
18637	18426	65	abandoned	abandon	VBD
18637	18426	66	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18426	67	employment	employment	NN
18637	18426	68	,	,	,
18637	18426	69	breached	breach	VBD
18637	18426	70	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18426	71	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	18426	72	,	,	,
18637	18426	73	and	and	CC
18637	18426	74	exercised	exercise	VBD
18637	18426	75	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18426	76	legal	legal	JJ
18637	18426	77	right	right	NN
18637	18426	78	to	to	TO
18637	18426	79	enter	enter	VB
18637	18426	80	into	into	IN
18637	18426	81	employment	employment	NN
18637	18426	82	of	of	IN
18637	18426	83	a	a	DT
18637	18426	84	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18426	85	nature	nature	NN
18637	18426	86	with	with	IN
18637	18426	87	another	another	DT
18637	18426	88	person	person	NN
18637	18426	89	.	.	.
18637	18427	1	The	the	DT
18637	18427	2	clear	clear	JJ
18637	18427	3	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18427	4	of	of	IN
18637	18427	5	such	such	PDT
18637	18427	6	a	a	DT
18637	18427	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	18427	8	was	be	VBD
18637	18427	9	declared	declare	VBN
18637	18427	10	to	to	TO
18637	18427	11	be	be	VB
18637	18427	12	the	the	DT
18637	18427	13	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	18427	14	of	of	IN
18637	18427	15	payment	payment	NN
18637	18427	16	,	,	,
18637	18427	17	by	by	IN
18637	18427	18	means	mean	NNS
18637	18427	19	of	of	IN
18637	18427	20	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	18427	21	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18427	22	,	,	,
18637	18427	23	of	of	IN
18637	18427	24	a	a	DT
18637	18427	25	purely	purely	RB
18637	18427	26	civil	civil	JJ
18637	18427	27	liability	liability	NN
18637	18427	28	arising	arise	VBG
18637	18427	29	from	from	IN
18637	18427	30	breach	breach	NN
18637	18427	31	of	of	IN
18637	18427	32	contract	contract	NN
18637	18427	33	.	.	.
18637	18428	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18428	2	7	7	LS
18637	18428	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18428	4	Several	several	JJ
18637	18428	5	years	year	NNS
18637	18428	6	later	later	RB
18637	18428	7	,	,	,
18637	18428	8	in	in	IN
18637	18428	9	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	18428	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18428	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	18428	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18428	13	Alabama,[8	Alabama,[8	NNP
18637	18428	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18428	15	the	the	DT
18637	18428	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18428	17	voided	void	VBD
18637	18428	18	another	another	DT
18637	18428	19	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	18428	20	statute	statute	NN
18637	18428	21	which	which	WDT
18637	18428	22	made	make	VBD
18637	18428	23	the	the	DT
18637	18428	24	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	18428	25	without	without	IN
18637	18428	26	just	just	RB
18637	18428	27	cause	cause	VB
18637	18428	28	to	to	TO
18637	18428	29	perform	perform	VB
18637	18428	30	the	the	DT
18637	18428	31	labor	labor	NN
18637	18428	32	called	call	VBN
18637	18428	33	for	for	IN
18637	18428	34	in	in	IN
18637	18428	35	a	a	DT
18637	18428	36	written	write	VBN
18637	18428	37	contract	contract	NN
18637	18428	38	of	of	IN
18637	18428	39	employment	employment	NN
18637	18428	40	,	,	,
18637	18428	41	or	or	CC
18637	18428	42	to	to	TO
18637	18428	43	refund	refund	VB
18637	18428	44	the	the	DT
18637	18428	45	money	money	NN
18637	18428	46	or	or	CC
18637	18428	47	pay	pay	VB
18637	18428	48	for	for	IN
18637	18428	49	the	the	DT
18637	18428	50	property	property	NN
18637	18428	51	advanced	advanced	JJ
18637	18428	52	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	18428	53	,	,	,
18637	18428	54	_	_	NNP
18637	18428	55	prima	prima	NN
18637	18428	56	facie	facie	VBD
18637	18428	57	_	_	NNP
18637	18428	58	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18428	59	of	of	IN
18637	18428	60	an	an	DT
18637	18428	61	intent	intent	NN
18637	18428	62	to	to	TO
18637	18428	63	defraud	defraud	VB
18637	18428	64	and	and	CC
18637	18428	65	punishable	punishable	JJ
18637	18428	66	as	as	IN
18637	18428	67	a	a	DT
18637	18428	68	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	18428	69	offense	offense	NN
18637	18428	70	;	;	:
18637	18428	71	and	and	CC
18637	18428	72	which	which	WDT
18637	18428	73	was	be	VBD
18637	18428	74	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	18428	75	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18428	76	to	to	IN
18637	18428	77	a	a	DT
18637	18428	78	local	local	JJ
18637	18428	79	rule	rule	NN
18637	18428	80	of	of	IN
18637	18428	81	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18428	82	which	which	WDT
18637	18428	83	prevented	prevent	VBD
18637	18428	84	the	the	DT
18637	18428	85	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	18428	86	,	,	,
18637	18428	87	for	for	IN
18637	18428	88	the	the	DT
18637	18428	89	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18428	90	of	of	IN
18637	18428	91	rebutting	rebut	VBG
18637	18428	92	the	the	DT
18637	18428	93	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	18428	94	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	18428	95	,	,	,
18637	18428	96	from	from	IN
18637	18428	97	testifying	testify	VBG
18637	18428	98	as	as	IN
18637	18428	99	to	to	IN
18637	18428	100	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18428	101	"	"	``
18637	18428	102	uncommunicated	uncommunicated	JJ
18637	18428	103	motives	motive	NNS
18637	18428	104	,	,	,
18637	18428	105	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18428	106	,	,	,
18637	18428	107	or	or	CC
18637	18428	108	intention	intention	NN
18637	18428	109	.	.	.
18637	18428	110	"	"	''
18637	18429	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	18429	2	as	as	IN
18637	18429	3	a	a	DT
18637	18429	4	State	state	NN
18637	18429	5	"	"	``
18637	18429	6	may	may	MD
18637	18429	7	not	not	RB
18637	18429	8	compel	compel	VB
18637	18429	9	one	one	CD
18637	18429	10	man	man	NN
18637	18429	11	to	to	IN
18637	18429	12	labor	labor	NN
18637	18429	13	for	for	IN
18637	18429	14	another	another	DT
18637	18429	15	in	in	IN
18637	18429	16	payment	payment	NN
18637	18429	17	of	of	IN
18637	18429	18	a	a	DT
18637	18429	19	debt	debt	NN
18637	18429	20	by	by	IN
18637	18429	21	punishing	punish	VBG
18637	18429	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18429	23	as	as	IN
18637	18429	24	a	a	DT
18637	18429	25	criminal	criminal	NN
18637	18429	26	if	if	IN
18637	18429	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18429	28	does	do	VBZ
18637	18429	29	not	not	RB
18637	18429	30	perform	perform	VB
18637	18429	31	the	the	DT
18637	18429	32	service	service	NN
18637	18429	33	or	or	CC
18637	18429	34	pay	pay	VB
18637	18429	35	the	the	DT
18637	18429	36	debt	debt	NN
18637	18429	37	,	,	,
18637	18429	38	"	"	''
18637	18429	39	the	the	DT
18637	18429	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18429	41	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	18429	42	to	to	TO
18637	18429	43	permit	permit	VB
18637	18429	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18429	45	"	"	''
18637	18429	46	to	to	TO
18637	18429	47	accomplish	accomplish	VB
18637	18429	48	the	the	DT
18637	18429	49	same	same	JJ
18637	18429	50	result	result	NN
18637	18429	51	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18429	52	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	18429	53	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18429	54	by	by	IN
18637	18429	55	creating	create	VBG
18637	18429	56	a	a	DT
18637	18429	57	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	18429	58	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	18429	59	which	which	WDT
18637	18429	60	,	,	,
18637	18429	61	upon	upon	IN
18637	18429	62	proof	proof	NN
18637	18429	63	of	of	IN
18637	18429	64	no	no	DT
18637	18429	65	other	other	JJ
18637	18429	66	fact	fact	NN
18637	18429	67	,	,	,
18637	18429	68	exposes	expose	VBZ
18637	18429	69	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18429	70	to	to	IN
18637	18429	71	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	18429	72	.	.	.
18637	18430	1	"	"	``
18637	18430	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18430	3	9	9	CD
18637	18430	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18430	5	In	in	IN
18637	18430	6	1914	1914	CD
18637	18430	7	,	,	,
18637	18430	8	in	in	IN
18637	18430	9	United	United	NNP
18637	18430	10	States	States	NNP
18637	18430	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18430	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	18430	13	_	_	NNP
18637	18430	14	Reynolds,[10	reynolds,[10	NN
18637	18430	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18430	16	a	a	DT
18637	18430	17	third	third	JJ
18637	18430	18	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	18430	19	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	18430	20	was	be	VBD
18637	18430	21	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	18430	22	as	as	IN
18637	18430	23	conducive	conducive	JJ
18637	18430	24	to	to	TO
18637	18430	25	peonage	peonage	VB
18637	18430	26	through	through	IN
18637	18430	27	the	the	DT
18637	18430	28	permission	permission	NN
18637	18430	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18430	30	accorded	accord	VBD
18637	18430	31	to	to	IN
18637	18430	32	persons	person	NNS
18637	18430	33	,	,	,
18637	18430	34	fined	fine	VBN
18637	18430	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	18430	36	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	18430	37	for	for	IN
18637	18430	38	a	a	DT
18637	18430	39	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
18637	18430	40	,	,	,
18637	18430	41	to	to	TO
18637	18430	42	confess	confess	VB
18637	18430	43	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18430	44	with	with	IN
18637	18430	45	a	a	DT
18637	18430	46	surety	surety	NN
18637	18430	47	in	in	IN
18637	18430	48	the	the	DT
18637	18430	49	amount	amount	NN
18637	18430	50	of	of	IN
18637	18430	51	the	the	DT
18637	18430	52	fine	fine	JJ
18637	18430	53	and	and	CC
18637	18430	54	costs	cost	NNS
18637	18430	55	,	,	,
18637	18430	56	and	and	CC
18637	18430	57	then	then	RB
18637	18430	58	to	to	TO
18637	18430	59	agree	agree	VB
18637	18430	60	with	with	IN
18637	18430	61	said	say	VBN
18637	18430	62	surety	surety	NN
18637	18430	63	,	,	,
18637	18430	64	in	in	IN
18637	18430	65	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	18430	66	of	of	IN
18637	18430	67	the	the	DT
18637	18430	68	latter	latter	NN
18637	18430	69	's	's	POS
18637	18430	70	payment	payment	NN
18637	18430	71	of	of	IN
18637	18430	72	the	the	DT
18637	18430	73	confessed	confessed	JJ
18637	18430	74	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18430	75	,	,	,
18637	18430	76	to	to	TO
18637	18430	77	reimburse	reimburse	VB
18637	18430	78	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18430	79	by	by	IN
18637	18430	80	working	work	VBG
18637	18430	81	for	for	IN
18637	18430	82	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18430	83	upon	upon	IN
18637	18430	84	terms	term	NNS
18637	18430	85	approved	approve	VBN
18637	18430	86	by	by	IN
18637	18430	87	the	the	DT
18637	18430	88	court	court	NN
18637	18430	89	,	,	,
18637	18430	90	which	which	WDT
18637	18430	91	,	,	,
18637	18430	92	the	the	DT
18637	18430	93	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18430	94	pointed	point	VBD
18637	18430	95	out	out	RP
18637	18430	96	,	,	,
18637	18430	97	might	may	MD
18637	18430	98	prove	prove	VB
18637	18430	99	more	more	RBR
18637	18430	100	onerous	onerous	JJ
18637	18430	101	than	than	IN
18637	18430	102	if	if	IN
18637	18430	103	the	the	DT
18637	18430	104	convict	convict	NN
18637	18430	105	had	have	VBD
18637	18430	106	been	be	VBN
18637	18430	107	sentenced	sentence	VBN
18637	18430	108	to	to	IN
18637	18430	109	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	18430	110	at	at	IN
18637	18430	111	hard	hard	JJ
18637	18430	112	labor	labor	NN
18637	18430	113	in	in	IN
18637	18430	114	the	the	DT
18637	18430	115	first	first	JJ
18637	18430	116	place	place	NN
18637	18430	117	.	.	.
18637	18431	1	Fulfillment	fulfillment	NN
18637	18431	2	of	of	IN
18637	18431	3	such	such	PDT
18637	18431	4	a	a	DT
18637	18431	5	contract	contract	NN
18637	18431	6	with	with	IN
18637	18431	7	the	the	DT
18637	18431	8	surety	surety	NN
18637	18431	9	was	be	VBD
18637	18431	10	viewed	view	VBN
18637	18431	11	as	as	IN
18637	18431	12	being	be	VBG
18637	18431	13	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	18431	14	coerced	coerce	VBN
18637	18431	15	by	by	IN
18637	18431	16	the	the	DT
18637	18431	17	constant	constant	JJ
18637	18431	18	fear	fear	NN
18637	18431	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18431	20	induced	induce	VBN
18637	18431	21	of	of	IN
18637	18431	22	rearrest	rearrest	NN
18637	18431	23	,	,	,
18637	18431	24	a	a	DT
18637	18431	25	new	new	JJ
18637	18431	26	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	18431	27	,	,	,
18637	18431	28	and	and	CC
18637	18431	29	a	a	DT
18637	18431	30	new	new	JJ
18637	18431	31	fine	fine	NN
18637	18431	32	for	for	IN
18637	18431	33	breach	breach	NN
18637	18431	34	of	of	IN
18637	18431	35	contract	contract	NN
18637	18431	36	,	,	,
18637	18431	37	which	which	WDT
18637	18431	38	new	new	JJ
18637	18431	39	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	18431	40	the	the	DT
18637	18431	41	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	18431	42	person	person	NN
18637	18431	43	might	may	MD
18637	18431	44	undertake	undertake	VB
18637	18431	45	to	to	TO
18637	18431	46	liquidate	liquidate	VB
18637	18431	47	in	in	IN
18637	18431	48	a	a	DT
18637	18431	49	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18431	50	manner	manner	NN
18637	18431	51	attended	attend	VBN
18637	18431	52	by	by	IN
18637	18431	53	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18431	54	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	18431	55	.	.	.
18637	18432	1	More	more	RBR
18637	18432	2	recently	recently	RB
18637	18432	3	,	,	,
18637	18432	4	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	18432	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18432	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18432	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18432	8	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	18432	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	18432	10	been	be	VBN
18637	18432	11	followed	follow	VBN
18637	18432	12	in	in	IN
18637	18432	13	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	18432	14	_	_	NNP
18637	18432	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	18432	16	_	_	NNP
18637	18432	17	Georgia[11	Georgia[11	,
18637	18432	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18432	19	and	and	CC
18637	18432	20	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	18432	21	_	_	NNP
18637	18432	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	18432	23	_	_	NNP
18637	18432	24	Williams,[12	Williams,[12	NNP
18637	18432	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18432	26	in	in	IN
18637	18432	27	which	which	WDT
18637	18432	28	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18432	29	of	of	IN
18637	18432	30	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	18432	31	and	and	CC
18637	18432	32	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	18432	33	not	not	RB
18637	18432	34	materially	materially	RB
18637	18432	35	different	different	JJ
18637	18432	36	from	from	IN
18637	18432	37	that	that	DT
18637	18432	38	voided	void	VBD
18637	18432	39	in	in	IN
18637	18432	40	the	the	DT
18637	18432	41	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	18432	42	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18432	43	,	,	,
18637	18432	44	were	be	VBD
18637	18432	45	found	find	VBN
18637	18432	46	to	to	TO
18637	18432	47	be	be	VB
18637	18432	48	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18432	49	.	.	.
18637	18433	1	Although	although	IN
18637	18433	2	the	the	DT
18637	18433	3	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	18433	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	18433	5	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	18433	6	the	the	DT
18637	18433	7	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	18433	8	from	from	IN
18637	18433	9	testifying	testify	VBG
18637	18433	10	under	under	IN
18637	18433	11	oath	oath	NN
18637	18433	12	,	,	,
18637	18433	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18433	14	did	do	VBD
18637	18433	15	not	not	RB
18637	18433	16	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18433	17	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18433	18	from	from	IN
18637	18433	19	entering	enter	VBG
18637	18433	20	an	an	DT
18637	18433	21	unsworn	unsworn	JJ
18637	18433	22	denial	denial	NN
18637	18433	23	both	both	DT
18637	18433	24	of	of	IN
18637	18433	25	the	the	DT
18637	18433	26	contract	contract	NN
18637	18433	27	and	and	CC
18637	18433	28	of	of	IN
18637	18433	29	the	the	DT
18637	18433	30	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	18433	31	of	of	IN
18637	18433	32	any	any	DT
18637	18433	33	cash	cash	NN
18637	18433	34	advancement	advancement	NN
18637	18433	35	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	18433	36	,	,	,
18637	18433	37	a	a	DT
18637	18433	38	factor	factor	NN
18637	18433	39	which	which	WDT
18637	18433	40	,	,	,
18637	18433	41	the	the	DT
18637	18433	42	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18433	43	emphasized	emphasize	VBD
18637	18433	44	,	,	,
18637	18433	45	was	be	VBD
18637	18433	46	no	no	DT
18637	18433	47	more	more	RBR
18637	18433	48	controlling	controlling	JJ
18637	18433	49	than	than	IN
18637	18433	50	the	the	DT
18637	18433	51	customary	customary	JJ
18637	18433	52	rule	rule	NN
18637	18433	53	of	of	IN
18637	18433	54	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18433	55	in	in	IN
18637	18433	56	the	the	DT
18637	18433	57	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	18433	58	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18433	59	.	.	.
18637	18434	1	In	in	IN
18637	18434	2	the	the	DT
18637	18434	3	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	18434	4	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18434	5	,	,	,
18637	18434	6	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	18434	7	the	the	DT
18637	18434	8	fact	fact	NN
18637	18434	9	that	that	IN
18637	18434	10	the	the	DT
18637	18434	11	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	18434	12	pleaded	plead	VBD
18637	18434	13	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	18434	14	and	and	CC
18637	18434	15	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	18434	16	obviated	obviate	VBD
18637	18434	17	the	the	DT
18637	18434	18	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	18434	19	of	of	IN
18637	18434	20	applying	apply	VBG
18637	18434	21	the	the	DT
18637	18434	22	_	_	NNP
18637	18434	23	prima	prima	NN
18637	18434	24	facie	facie	NNP
18637	18434	25	_	_	NNP
18637	18434	26	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	18434	27	provision	provision	NN
18637	18434	28	,	,	,
18637	18434	29	the	the	DT
18637	18434	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18434	31	reached	reach	VBD
18637	18434	32	an	an	DT
18637	18434	33	identical	identical	JJ
18637	18434	34	result	result	NN
18637	18434	35	,	,	,
18637	18434	36	chiefly	chiefly	RB
18637	18434	37	on	on	IN
18637	18434	38	the	the	DT
18637	18434	39	ground	ground	NN
18637	18434	40	that	that	IN
18637	18434	41	the	the	DT
18637	18434	42	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	18434	43	provision	provision	NN
18637	18434	44	,	,	,
18637	18434	45	despite	despite	IN
18637	18434	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18434	47	nonapplication	nonapplication	NN
18637	18434	48	,	,	,
18637	18434	49	"	"	''
18637	18434	50	had	have	VBD
18637	18434	51	a	a	DT
18637	18434	52	coercive	coercive	JJ
18637	18434	53	effect	effect	NN
18637	18434	54	in	in	IN
18637	18434	55	producing	produce	VBG
18637	18434	56	the	the	DT
18637	18434	57	plea	plea	NN
18637	18434	58	of	of	IN
18637	18434	59	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	18434	60	.	.	.
18637	18434	61	"	"	''
18637	18435	1	Discriminations	discrimination	NNS
18637	18435	2	and	and	CC
18637	18435	3	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	18435	4	Compulsions	Compulsions	NNPS
18637	18435	5	Less	Less	JJR
18637	18435	6	Than	than	IN
18637	18435	7	Servitude	Servitude	NNP
18637	18435	8	A	a	DT
18637	18435	9	contention	contention	NN
18637	18435	10	of	of	IN
18637	18435	11	"	"	``
18637	18435	12	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	18435	13	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18435	14	"	"	''
18637	18435	15	was	be	VBD
18637	18435	16	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	18435	17	in	in	IN
18637	18435	18	the	the	DT
18637	18435	19	following	follow	VBG
18637	18435	20	cases	case	NNS
18637	18435	21	:	:	:
18637	18435	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18435	23	1	1	LS
18637	18435	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18435	25	Racial	racial	JJ
18637	18435	26	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	18435	27	.	.	.
18637	18436	1	Denial	denial	NN
18637	18436	2	of	of	IN
18637	18436	3	admission	admission	NN
18637	18436	4	to	to	IN
18637	18436	5	public	public	JJ
18637	18436	6	places	place	NNS
18637	18436	7	,	,	,
18637	18436	8	such	such	JJ
18637	18436	9	as	as	IN
18637	18436	10	inns	inn	NNS
18637	18436	11	,	,	,
18637	18436	12	restaurants	restaurant	NNS
18637	18436	13	,	,	,
18637	18436	14	or	or	CC
18637	18436	15	theaters	theater	NNS
18637	18436	16	,	,	,
18637	18436	17	or	or	CC
18637	18436	18	the	the	DT
18637	18436	19	segregation	segregation	NN
18637	18436	20	of	of	IN
18637	18436	21	races	race	NNS
18637	18436	22	in	in	IN
18637	18436	23	public	public	JJ
18637	18436	24	conveyances	conveyance	NNS
18637	18436	25	,	,	,
18637	18436	26	etc	etc	FW
18637	18436	27	.	.	.
18637	18436	28	,	,	,
18637	18436	29	was	be	VBD
18637	18436	30	held	hold	VBN
18637	18436	31	not	not	RB
18637	18436	32	to	to	TO
18637	18436	33	give	give	VB
18637	18436	34	rise	rise	NN
18637	18436	35	to	to	IN
18637	18436	36	a	a	DT
18637	18436	37	"	"	``
18637	18436	38	condition	condition	NN
18637	18436	39	of	of	IN
18637	18436	40	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	18436	41	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	18436	42	service	service	NN
18637	18436	43	of	of	IN
18637	18436	44	one	one	CD
18637	18436	45	to	to	IN
18637	18436	46	another	another	DT
18637	18436	47	,	,	,
18637	18436	48	"	"	''
18637	18436	49	and	and	CC
18637	18436	50	effected	effect	VBD
18637	18436	51	no	no	DT
18637	18436	52	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18436	53	of	of	IN
18637	18436	54	one	one	NN
18637	18436	55	's	's	POS
18637	18436	56	legal	legal	JJ
18637	18436	57	right	right	NN
18637	18436	58	to	to	TO
18637	18436	59	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	18436	60	of	of	IN
18637	18436	61	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18436	62	person	person	NN
18637	18436	63	,	,	,
18637	18436	64	property	property	NN
18637	18436	65	,	,	,
18637	18436	66	and	and	CC
18637	18436	67	services	service	NNS
18637	18436	68	.	.	.
18637	18437	1	Even	even	RB
18637	18437	2	prior	prior	RB
18637	18437	3	to	to	IN
18637	18437	4	the	the	DT
18637	18437	5	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18437	6	,	,	,
18637	18437	7	such	such	JJ
18637	18437	8	discriminations	discrimination	NNS
18637	18437	9	had	have	VBD
18637	18437	10	never	never	RB
18637	18437	11	been	be	VBN
18637	18437	12	"	"	``
18637	18437	13	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	18437	14	as	as	IN
18637	18437	15	badges	badge	NNS
18637	18437	16	of	of	IN
18637	18437	17	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	18437	18	"	"	''
18637	18437	19	;	;	:
18637	18437	20	and	and	CC
18637	18437	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18437	22	was	be	VBD
18637	18437	23	not	not	RB
18637	18437	24	"	"	``
18637	18437	25	the	the	DT
18637	18437	26	intent	intent	NN
18637	18437	27	of	of	IN
18637	18437	28	the	the	DT
18637	18437	29	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18437	30	to	to	TO
18637	18437	31	denounce	denounce	VB
18637	18437	32	every	every	DT
18637	18437	33	act	act	NN
18637	18437	34	which	which	WDT
18637	18437	35	was	be	VBD
18637	18437	36	wrong	wrong	JJ
18637	18437	37	if	if	IN
18637	18437	38	done	do	VBN
18637	18437	39	to	to	IN
18637	18437	40	a	a	DT
18637	18437	41	free	free	JJ
18637	18437	42	man	man	NN
18637	18437	43	and	and	CC
18637	18437	44	yet	yet	RB
18637	18437	45	justified	justify	VBN
18637	18437	46	in	in	IN
18637	18437	47	a	a	DT
18637	18437	48	condition	condition	NN
18637	18437	49	of	of	IN
18637	18437	50	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	18437	51	.	.	.
18637	18438	1	"	"	``
18637	18438	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18438	3	13	13	CD
18637	18438	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18438	5	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	18438	6	,	,	,
18637	18438	7	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	18438	8	who	who	WP
18637	18438	9	conspired	conspire	VBD
18637	18438	10	to	to	TO
18637	18438	11	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18438	12	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18438	13	of	of	IN
18637	18438	14	African	african	JJ
18637	18438	15	descent	descent	NN
18637	18438	16	,	,	,
18637	18438	17	because	because	IN
18637	18438	18	of	of	IN
18637	18438	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18438	20	race	race	NN
18637	18438	21	or	or	CC
18637	18438	22	color	color	NN
18637	18438	23	,	,	,
18637	18438	24	from	from	IN
18637	18438	25	making	make	VBG
18637	18438	26	or	or	CC
18637	18438	27	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	18438	28	out	out	RP
18637	18438	29	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	18438	30	of	of	IN
18637	18438	31	labor	labor	NN
18637	18438	32	,	,	,
18637	18438	33	and	and	CC
18637	18438	34	so	so	RB
18637	18438	35	from	from	IN
18637	18438	36	pursuing	pursue	VBG
18637	18438	37	a	a	DT
18637	18438	38	common	common	JJ
18637	18438	39	calling	calling	NN
18637	18438	40	,	,	,
18637	18438	41	were	be	VBD
18637	18438	42	not	not	RB
18637	18438	43	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	18438	44	to	to	TO
18637	18438	45	have	have	VB
18637	18438	46	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	18438	47	negroes	negro	NNS
18637	18438	48	to	to	IN
18637	18438	49	a	a	DT
18637	18438	50	condition	condition	NN
18637	18438	51	of	of	IN
18637	18438	52	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	18438	53	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18438	54	;	;	:
18637	18438	55	and	and	CC
18637	18438	56	hence	hence	RB
18637	18438	57	a	a	DT
18637	18438	58	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18438	59	statute	statute	NN
18637	18438	60	which	which	WDT
18637	18438	61	penalized	penalize	VBD
18637	18438	62	such	such	PDT
18637	18438	63	a	a	DT
18637	18438	64	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	18438	65	was	be	VBD
18637	18438	66	declared	declare	VBN
18637	18438	67	to	to	TO
18637	18438	68	be	be	VB
18637	18438	69	in	in	IN
18637	18438	70	excess	excess	NN
18637	18438	71	of	of	IN
18637	18438	72	the	the	DT
18637	18438	73	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18438	74	powers	power	NNS
18637	18438	75	vested	vest	VBN
18637	18438	76	in	in	IN
18637	18438	77	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18438	78	by	by	IN
18637	18438	79	the	the	DT
18637	18438	80	Thirteenth	Thirteenth	NNP
18637	18438	81	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18438	82	.	.	.
18637	18439	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18439	2	14	14	CD
18637	18439	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18439	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18439	5	2	2	LS
18637	18439	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18439	7	"	"	``
18637	18439	8	Services	service	NNS
18637	18439	9	which	which	WDT
18637	18439	10	have	have	VBP
18637	18439	11	from	from	IN
18637	18439	12	time	time	NN
18637	18439	13	immemorial	immemorial	JJ
18637	18439	14	been	be	VBN
18637	18439	15	treated	treat	VBN
18637	18439	16	as	as	IN
18637	18439	17	exceptional	exceptional	JJ
18637	18439	18	.	.	.
18637	18439	19	"	"	''
18637	18440	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18440	2	,	,	,
18637	18440	3	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	18440	4	of	of	IN
18637	18440	5	seamen	seaman	NNS
18637	18440	6	,	,	,
18637	18440	7	which	which	WDT
18637	18440	8	have	have	VBP
18637	18440	9	from	from	IN
18637	18440	10	earliest	early	JJS
18637	18440	11	historical	historical	JJ
18637	18440	12	times	time	NNS
18637	18440	13	been	be	VBN
18637	18440	14	treated	treat	VBN
18637	18440	15	as	as	IN
18637	18440	16	exceptional	exceptional	JJ
18637	18440	17	,	,	,
18637	18440	18	and	and	CC
18637	18440	19	involving	involve	VBG
18637	18440	20	,	,	,
18637	18440	21	to	to	IN
18637	18440	22	a	a	DT
18637	18440	23	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18440	24	extent	extent	NN
18637	18440	25	,	,	,
18637	18440	26	the	the	DT
18637	18440	27	surrender	surrender	NN
18637	18440	28	of	of	IN
18637	18440	29	personal	personal	JJ
18637	18440	30	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18440	31	may	may	MD
18637	18440	32	be	be	VB
18637	18440	33	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	18440	34	without	without	IN
18637	18440	35	regard	regard	NN
18637	18440	36	to	to	IN
18637	18440	37	the	the	DT
18637	18440	38	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18440	39	.	.	.
18637	18441	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18441	2	15	15	CD
18637	18441	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18441	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18441	5	3	3	CD
18637	18441	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18441	7	"	"	``
18637	18441	8	Enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18441	9	of	of	IN
18637	18441	10	those	those	DT
18637	18441	11	duties	duty	NNS
18637	18441	12	which	which	WDT
18637	18441	13	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	18441	14	owe	owe	VBP
18637	18441	15	the	the	DT
18637	18441	16	State	State	NNP
18637	18441	17	,	,	,
18637	18441	18	such	such	JJ
18637	18441	19	as	as	IN
18637	18441	20	services	service	NNS
18637	18441	21	in	in	IN
18637	18441	22	the	the	DT
18637	18441	23	army	army	NN
18637	18441	24	,	,	,
18637	18441	25	militia	militia	NN
18637	18441	26	,	,	,
18637	18441	27	on	on	IN
18637	18441	28	the	the	DT
18637	18441	29	jury	jury	NN
18637	18441	30	,	,	,
18637	18441	31	etc	etc	FW
18637	18441	32	.	.	.
18637	18441	33	"	"	''
18637	18442	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18442	2	,	,	,
18637	18442	3	"	"	''
18637	18442	4	a	a	DT
18637	18442	5	State	state	NN
18637	18442	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	18442	7	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	18442	8	power	power	NN
18637	18442	9	to	to	TO
18637	18442	10	require	require	VB
18637	18442	11	every	every	DT
18637	18442	12	able	able	JJ
18637	18442	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	18442	14	bodied	bodied	JJ
18637	18442	15	man	man	NN
18637	18442	16	within	within	IN
18637	18442	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18442	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18442	19	to	to	IN
18637	18442	20	labor	labor	NN
18637	18442	21	for	for	IN
18637	18442	22	a	a	DT
18637	18442	23	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18442	24	time	time	NN
18637	18442	25	on	on	IN
18637	18442	26	public	public	JJ
18637	18442	27	roads	road	NNS
18637	18442	28	near	near	IN
18637	18442	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18442	30	residence	residence	NN
18637	18442	31	without	without	IN
18637	18442	32	direct	direct	JJ
18637	18442	33	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18442	34	.	.	.
18637	18443	1	"	"	``
18637	18443	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18443	3	16	16	CD
18637	18443	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18443	5	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18443	6	,	,	,
18637	18443	7	the	the	DT
18637	18443	8	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	18443	9	by	by	IN
18637	18443	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18443	11	of	of	IN
18637	18443	12	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	18443	13	military	military	JJ
18637	18443	14	duty	duty	NN
18637	18443	15	from	from	IN
18637	18443	16	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18443	17	of	of	IN
18637	18443	18	the	the	DT
18637	18443	19	United	United	NNP
18637	18443	20	States	States	NNP
18637	18443	21	,	,	,
18637	18443	22	as	as	IN
18637	18443	23	was	be	VBD
18637	18443	24	done	do	VBN
18637	18443	25	by	by	IN
18637	18443	26	the	the	DT
18637	18443	27	Selective	Selective	NNP
18637	18443	28	Service	Service	NNP
18637	18443	29	Act	Act	NNP
18637	18443	30	of	of	IN
18637	18443	31	May	May	NNP
18637	18443	32	18	18	CD
18637	18443	33	,	,	,
18637	18443	34	1917	1917	CD
18637	18443	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18443	36	40	40	CD
18637	18443	37	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	18443	38	.	.	.
18637	18444	1	76	76	CD
18637	18444	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18444	3	;	;	:
18637	18444	4	and	and	CC
18637	18444	5	the	the	DT
18637	18444	6	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	18444	7	,	,	,
18637	18444	8	under	under	IN
18637	18444	9	the	the	DT
18637	18444	10	Selective	Selective	NNP
18637	18444	11	Training	Training	NNP
18637	18444	12	and	and	CC
18637	18444	13	Service	Service	NNP
18637	18444	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	18444	15	of	of	IN
18637	18444	16	1940	1940	CD
18637	18444	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18444	18	50	50	CD
18637	18444	19	U.S.C.A.	U.S.C.A.	NNP
18637	18445	1	App	App	NNP
18637	18445	2	.	.	.
18637	18446	1	§	§	NNP
18637	18446	2	305	305	CD
18637	18446	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18446	4	g	g	NNP
18637	18446	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18446	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18446	7	,	,	,
18637	18446	8	that	that	IN
18637	18446	9	conscientious	conscientious	JJ
18637	18446	10	objectors	objector	NNS
18637	18446	11	be	be	VB
18637	18446	12	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	18446	13	to	to	IN
18637	18446	14	work	work	NN
18637	18446	15	of	of	IN
18637	18446	16	national	national	JJ
18637	18446	17	importance	importance	NN
18637	18446	18	under	under	IN
18637	18446	19	civilian	civilian	JJ
18637	18446	20	direction	direction	NN
18637	18446	21	,	,	,
18637	18446	22	were	be	VBD
18637	18446	23	held	hold	VBN
18637	18446	24	not	not	RB
18637	18446	25	to	to	TO
18637	18446	26	contravene	contravene	VB
18637	18446	27	the	the	DT
18637	18446	28	Thirteenth	Thirteenth	NNP
18637	18446	29	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18446	30	.	.	.
18637	18447	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18447	2	17	17	CD
18637	18447	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18447	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18447	5	4	4	LS
18637	18447	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18447	7	A	a	DT
18637	18447	8	State	State	NNP
18637	18447	9	law	law	NN
18637	18447	10	which	which	WDT
18637	18447	11	made	make	VBD
18637	18447	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18447	13	a	a	DT
18637	18447	14	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
18637	18447	15	for	for	IN
18637	18447	16	a	a	DT
18637	18447	17	lessor	lessor	NN
18637	18447	18	,	,	,
18637	18447	19	or	or	CC
18637	18447	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18447	21	agent	agent	NN
18637	18447	22	or	or	CC
18637	18447	23	janitor	janitor	NN
18637	18447	24	,	,	,
18637	18447	25	intentionally	intentionally	RB
18637	18447	26	to	to	TO
18637	18447	27	fail	fail	VB
18637	18447	28	to	to	TO
18637	18447	29	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	18447	30	such	such	JJ
18637	18447	31	water	water	NN
18637	18447	32	,	,	,
18637	18447	33	heat	heat	NN
18637	18447	34	,	,	,
18637	18447	35	light	light	NN
18637	18447	36	,	,	,
18637	18447	37	elevator	elevator	NN
18637	18447	38	,	,	,
18637	18447	39	telephone	telephone	NN
18637	18447	40	,	,	,
18637	18447	41	or	or	CC
18637	18447	42	other	other	JJ
18637	18447	43	service	service	NN
18637	18447	44	as	as	IN
18637	18447	45	may	may	MD
18637	18447	46	be	be	VB
18637	18447	47	required	require	VBN
18637	18447	48	by	by	IN
18637	18447	49	the	the	DT
18637	18447	50	terms	term	NNS
18637	18447	51	of	of	IN
18637	18447	52	the	the	DT
18637	18447	53	lease	lease	NN
18637	18447	54	and	and	CC
18637	18447	55	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18447	56	to	to	IN
18637	18447	57	the	the	DT
18637	18447	58	proper	proper	JJ
18637	18447	59	and	and	CC
18637	18447	60	customary	customary	JJ
18637	18447	61	use	use	NN
18637	18447	62	of	of	IN
18637	18447	63	the	the	DT
18637	18447	64	building	building	NN
18637	18447	65	,	,	,
18637	18447	66	did	do	VBD
18637	18447	67	not	not	RB
18637	18447	68	create	create	VB
18637	18447	69	an	an	DT
18637	18447	70	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	18447	71	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18447	72	.	.	.
18637	18448	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18448	2	18	18	CD
18637	18448	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18448	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18448	5	5	5	CD
18637	18448	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18448	7	Section	section	NN
18637	18448	8	506	506	CD
18637	18448	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18448	10	a	a	NN
18637	18448	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18448	12	of	of	IN
18637	18448	13	the	the	DT
18637	18448	14	Communications	Communications	NNPS
18637	18448	15	Act	Act	NNP
18637	18448	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18448	17	47	47	CD
18637	18448	18	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	18449	1	§	§	NNP
18637	18449	2	506	506	CD
18637	18449	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18449	4	making	make	VBG
18637	18449	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18449	6	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	18449	7	to	to	IN
18637	18449	8	coerce	coerce	VB
18637	18449	9	,	,	,
18637	18449	10	compel	compel	NN
18637	18449	11	,	,	,
18637	18449	12	or	or	CC
18637	18449	13	constrain	constrain	VB
18637	18449	14	a	a	DT
18637	18449	15	licensee	licensee	NN
18637	18449	16	to	to	TO
18637	18449	17	employ	employ	VB
18637	18449	18	persons	person	NNS
18637	18449	19	in	in	IN
18637	18449	20	excess	excess	NN
18637	18449	21	of	of	IN
18637	18449	22	the	the	DT
18637	18449	23	number	number	NN
18637	18449	24	of	of	IN
18637	18449	25	the	the	DT
18637	18449	26	employees	employee	NNS
18637	18449	27	needed	need	VBN
18637	18449	28	by	by	IN
18637	18449	29	the	the	DT
18637	18449	30	licensee	licensee	NN
18637	18449	31	in	in	IN
18637	18449	32	the	the	DT
18637	18449	33	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	18449	34	of	of	IN
18637	18449	35	a	a	DT
18637	18449	36	radio	radio	NN
18637	18449	37	broadcasting	broadcasting	NN
18637	18449	38	business	business	NN
18637	18449	39	,	,	,
18637	18449	40	on	on	IN
18637	18449	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18449	42	face	face	NN
18637	18449	43	,	,	,
18637	18449	44	was	be	VBD
18637	18449	45	construed	construe	VBN
18637	18449	46	as	as	IN
18637	18449	47	not	not	RB
18637	18449	48	violating	violate	VBG
18637	18449	49	this	this	DT
18637	18449	50	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18449	51	.	.	.
18637	18450	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18450	2	19	19	CD
18637	18450	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18450	4	Enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18450	5	"	"	''
18637	18450	6	*	*	NFP
18637	18450	7	*	*	NFP
18637	18450	8	*	*	NFP
18637	18450	9	this	this	DT
18637	18450	10	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18450	11	,	,	,
18637	18450	12	besides	besides	IN
18637	18450	13	abolishing	abolish	VBG
18637	18450	14	forever	forever	RB
18637	18450	15	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	18450	16	and	and	CC
18637	18450	17	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	18450	18	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18450	19	*	*	NFP
18637	18450	20	*	*	NFP
18637	18450	21	*	*	NFP
18637	18450	22	,	,	,
18637	18450	23	gives	give	VBZ
18637	18450	24	power	power	NN
18637	18450	25	to	to	IN
18637	18450	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18450	27	to	to	TO
18637	18450	28	protect	protect	VB
18637	18450	29	all	all	DT
18637	18450	30	persons	person	NNS
18637	18450	31	within	within	IN
18637	18450	32	the	the	DT
18637	18450	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18450	34	of	of	IN
18637	18450	35	the	the	DT
18637	18450	36	United	United	NNP
18637	18450	37	States	States	NNP
18637	18450	38	from	from	IN
18637	18450	39	being	be	VBG
18637	18450	40	in	in	IN
18637	18450	41	any	any	DT
18637	18450	42	way	way	NN
18637	18450	43	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18450	44	to	to	IN
18637	18450	45	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	18450	46	or	or	CC
18637	18450	47	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	18450	48	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18450	49	,	,	,
18637	18450	50	except	except	IN
18637	18450	51	as	as	IN
18637	18450	52	a	a	DT
18637	18450	53	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	18450	54	for	for	IN
18637	18450	55	crime	crime	NN
18637	18450	56	,	,	,
18637	18450	57	and	and	CC
18637	18450	58	in	in	IN
18637	18450	59	the	the	DT
18637	18450	60	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	18450	61	of	of	IN
18637	18450	62	that	that	DT
18637	18450	63	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18450	64	which	which	WDT
18637	18450	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18450	66	was	be	VBD
18637	18450	67	the	the	DT
18637	18450	68	object	object	NN
18637	18450	69	of	of	IN
18637	18450	70	the	the	DT
18637	18450	71	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18450	72	to	to	TO
18637	18450	73	secure	secure	VB
18637	18450	74	.	.	.
18637	18451	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18451	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18451	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18451	4	"	"	''
18637	18451	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18451	6	20	20	CD
18637	18451	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18451	8	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18451	9	"	"	``
18637	18451	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	18451	11	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	18451	12	self	self	NN
18637	18451	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	18451	14	executing	execute	VBG
18637	18451	15	without	without	IN
18637	18451	16	any	any	DT
18637	18451	17	ancillary	ancillary	JJ
18637	18451	18	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18451	19	,	,	,
18637	18451	20	*	*	NFP
18637	18451	21	*	*	NFP
18637	18451	22	*	*	NFP
18637	18451	23	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18451	24	but	but	CC
18637	18451	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18451	26	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18451	27	may	may	MD
18637	18451	28	be	be	VB
18637	18451	29	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18451	30	and	and	CC
18637	18451	31	proper	proper	JJ
18637	18451	32	to	to	TO
18637	18451	33	meet	meet	VB
18637	18451	34	all	all	PDT
18637	18451	35	the	the	DT
18637	18451	36	various	various	JJ
18637	18451	37	*	*	NFP
18637	18451	38	*	*	NFP
18637	18451	39	*	*	NFP
18637	18451	40	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	18451	41	to	to	TO
18637	18451	42	be	be	VB
18637	18451	43	affected	affect	VBN
18637	18451	44	by	by	IN
18637	18451	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18451	46	,	,	,
18637	18451	47	and	and	CC
18637	18451	48	to	to	TO
18637	18451	49	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	18451	50	proper	proper	JJ
18637	18451	51	modes	mode	NNS
18637	18451	52	of	of	IN
18637	18451	53	redress	redress	NN
18637	18451	54	for	for	IN
18637	18451	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18451	56	violation	violation	NN
18637	18451	57	in	in	IN
18637	18451	58	letter	letter	NN
18637	18451	59	or	or	CC
18637	18451	60	spirit	spirit	NN
18637	18451	61	.	.	.
18637	18451	62	"	"	''
18637	18452	1	This	this	DT
18637	18452	2	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18452	3	,	,	,
18637	18452	4	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	18452	5	,	,	,
18637	18452	6	"	"	``
18637	18452	7	may	may	MD
18637	18452	8	be	be	VB
18637	18452	9	direct	direct	JJ
18637	18452	10	and	and	CC
18637	18452	11	primary	primary	JJ
18637	18452	12	,	,	,
18637	18452	13	operating	operate	VBG
18637	18452	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	18452	15	the	the	DT
18637	18452	16	acts	act	NNS
18637	18452	17	of	of	IN
18637	18452	18	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	18452	19	,	,	,
18637	18452	20	whether	whether	IN
18637	18452	21	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
18637	18452	22	by	by	IN
18637	18452	23	State	State	NNP
18637	18452	24	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18452	25	or	or	CC
18637	18452	26	not	not	RB
18637	18452	27	;	;	:
18637	18452	28	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18452	29	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	18452	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18452	31	under	under	IN
18637	18452	32	the	the	DT
18637	18452	33	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18452	34	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18452	35	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18452	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18452	37	,	,	,
18637	18452	38	*	*	NFP
18637	18452	39	*	*	NFP
18637	18452	40	*	*	NFP
18637	18452	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18452	42	*	*	NFP
18637	18452	43	*	*	NFP
18637	18452	44	*	*	NFP
18637	18452	45	can	can	MD
18637	18452	46	only	only	RB
18637	18452	47	be	be	VB
18637	18452	48	,	,	,
18637	18452	49	corrective	corrective	JJ
18637	18452	50	in	in	IN
18637	18452	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18452	52	character	character	NN
18637	18452	53	,	,	,
18637	18452	54	addressed	address	VBD
18637	18452	55	to	to	TO
18637	18452	56	counteract	counteract	VB
18637	18452	57	and	and	CC
18637	18452	58	afford	afford	VB
18637	18452	59	relief	relief	NN
18637	18452	60	against	against	IN
18637	18452	61	State	State	NNP
18637	18452	62	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18452	63	or	or	CC
18637	18452	64	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18452	65	.	.	.
18637	18453	1	"	"	``
18637	18453	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18453	3	21	21	CD
18637	18453	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18453	5	Pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	18453	6	to	to	IN
18637	18453	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18453	8	powers	power	NNS
18637	18453	9	of	of	IN
18637	18453	10	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18453	11	under	under	IN
18637	18453	12	section	section	NN
18637	18453	13	two	two	CD
18637	18453	14	of	of	IN
18637	18453	15	this	this	DT
18637	18453	16	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18453	17	,	,	,
18637	18453	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18453	19	on	on	IN
18637	18453	20	March	March	NNP
18637	18453	21	2	2	CD
18637	18453	22	,	,	,
18637	18453	23	1867	1867	CD
18637	18453	24	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	18453	25	a	a	DT
18637	18453	26	statute[22	statute[22	NN
18637	18453	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18453	28	by	by	IN
18637	18453	29	the	the	DT
18637	18453	30	terms	term	NNS
18637	18453	31	of	of	IN
18637	18453	32	which	which	WDT
18637	18453	33	the	the	DT
18637	18453	34	system	system	NN
18637	18453	35	of	of	IN
18637	18453	36	peonage	peonage	NN
18637	18453	37	was	be	VBD
18637	18453	38	abolished	abolish	VBN
18637	18453	39	and	and	CC
18637	18453	40	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	18453	41	and	and	CC
18637	18453	42	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	18453	43	were	be	VBD
18637	18453	44	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18453	45	on	on	IN
18637	18453	46	anyone	anyone	NN
18637	18453	47	who	who	WP
18637	18453	48	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	18453	49	,	,	,
18637	18453	50	arrests	arrest	NNS
18637	18453	51	,	,	,
18637	18453	52	or	or	CC
18637	18453	53	returns	return	NNS
18637	18453	54	,	,	,
18637	18453	55	or	or	CC
18637	18453	56	causes	cause	NNS
18637	18453	57	,	,	,
18637	18453	58	or	or	CC
18637	18453	59	aids	aids	NNP
18637	18453	60	in	in	IN
18637	18453	61	the	the	DT
18637	18453	62	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	18453	63	or	or	CC
18637	18453	64	return	return	NN
18637	18453	65	of	of	IN
18637	18453	66	a	a	DT
18637	18453	67	person	person	NN
18637	18453	68	to	to	TO
18637	18453	69	peonage	peonage	VB
18637	18453	70	.	.	.
18637	18454	1	The	the	DT
18637	18454	2	validity	validity	NN
18637	18454	3	of	of	IN
18637	18454	4	this	this	DT
18637	18454	5	act	act	NN
18637	18454	6	was	be	VBD
18637	18454	7	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18454	8	in	in	IN
18637	18454	9	Clyatt	Clyatt	NNP
18637	18454	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18454	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	18454	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18454	13	United	United	NNP
18637	18454	14	States;[23	States;[23	NNP
18637	18454	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18454	16	and	and	CC
18637	18454	17	more	more	RBR
18637	18454	18	recently	recently	RB
18637	18454	19	,	,	,
18637	18454	20	in	in	IN
18637	18454	21	United	United	NNP
18637	18454	22	States	States	NNP
18637	18454	23	_	_	NNP
18637	18454	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	18454	25	_	_	NNP
18637	18454	26	Gaskin,[24	Gaskin,[24	NNP
18637	18454	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18454	28	a	a	DT
18637	18454	29	proviso	proviso	NN
18637	18454	30	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18454	31	was	be	VBD
18637	18454	32	construed	construe	VBN
18637	18454	33	as	as	RB
18637	18454	34	capable	capable	JJ
18637	18454	35	of	of	IN
18637	18454	36	supporting	support	VBG
18637	18454	37	a	a	DT
18637	18454	38	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	18454	39	for	for	IN
18637	18454	40	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	18454	41	with	with	IN
18637	18454	42	intent	intent	NN
18637	18454	43	to	to	TO
18637	18454	44	compel	compel	VB
18637	18454	45	performance	performance	NN
18637	18454	46	of	of	IN
18637	18454	47	labor	labor	NN
18637	18454	48	even	even	RB
18637	18454	49	though	though	IN
18637	18454	50	the	the	DT
18637	18454	51	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	18454	52	in	in	IN
18637	18454	53	fact	fact	NN
18637	18454	54	rendered	render	VBN
18637	18454	55	no	no	DT
18637	18454	56	service	service	NN
18637	18454	57	after	after	IN
18637	18454	58	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18454	59	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	18454	60	.	.	.
18637	18455	1	Each	each	DT
18637	18455	2	of	of	IN
18637	18455	3	the	the	DT
18637	18455	4	acts	act	NNS
18637	18455	5	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	18455	6	in	in	IN
18637	18455	7	that	that	DT
18637	18455	8	proviso	proviso	NN
18637	18455	9	,	,	,
18637	18455	10	the	the	DT
18637	18455	11	"	"	``
18637	18455	12	holding	holding	NN
18637	18455	13	,	,	,
18637	18455	14	arresting	arrest	VBG
18637	18455	15	,	,	,
18637	18455	16	or	or	CC
18637	18455	17	the	the	DT
18637	18455	18	returning	returning	NN
18637	18455	19	,	,	,
18637	18455	20	may	may	MD
18637	18455	21	be	be	VB
18637	18455	22	the	the	DT
18637	18455	23	subject	subject	NN
18637	18455	24	of	of	IN
18637	18455	25	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	18455	26	and	and	CC
18637	18455	27	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	18455	28	.	.	.
18637	18455	29	"	"	''
18637	18456	1	Notes	note	NNS
18637	18456	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18456	3	1	1	CD
18637	18456	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18456	5	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	18456	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18456	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18456	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18456	9	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	18456	10	,	,	,
18637	18456	11	219	219	CD
18637	18456	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18456	13	219	219	CD
18637	18456	14	,	,	,
18637	18456	15	240	240	CD
18637	18456	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18456	17	1911	1911	CD
18637	18456	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18456	19	.	.	.
18637	18457	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18457	2	2	2	CD
18637	18457	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18457	4	16	16	CD
18637	18457	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	18457	6	.	.	.
18637	18458	1	36	36	CD
18637	18458	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18458	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	18458	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18458	5	.	.	.
18637	18459	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18459	2	3	3	LS
18637	18459	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18459	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18459	5	.	.	.
18637	18460	1	69	69	CD
18637	18460	2	,	,	,
18637	18460	3	71	71	CD
18637	18460	4	-	-	SYM
18637	18460	5	72	72	CD
18637	18460	6	.	.	.
18637	18461	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18461	2	4	4	CD
18637	18461	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18461	4	203	203	CD
18637	18461	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18461	6	1	1	CD
18637	18461	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18461	8	1906	1906	CD
18637	18461	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18461	10	.	.	.
18637	18462	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18462	2	5	5	CD
18637	18462	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18462	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18462	5	.	.	.
18637	18463	1	16	16	CD
18637	18463	2	-	-	SYM
18637	18463	3	17	17	CD
18637	18463	4	.	.	.
18637	18464	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18464	2	6	6	CD
18637	18464	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18464	4	Pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	18464	5	to	to	IN
18637	18464	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18464	7	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18464	8	powers	power	NNS
18637	18464	9	under	under	IN
18637	18464	10	section	section	NN
18637	18464	11	2	2	CD
18637	18464	12	of	of	IN
18637	18464	13	this	this	DT
18637	18464	14	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18464	15	,	,	,
18637	18464	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18464	17	,	,	,
18637	18464	18	on	on	IN
18637	18464	19	March	March	NNP
18637	18464	20	2	2	CD
18637	18464	21	,	,	,
18637	18464	22	1867	1867	CD
18637	18464	23	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	18464	24	a	a	DT
18637	18464	25	statute	statute	NN
18637	18464	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18464	27	14	14	CD
18637	18464	28	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	18464	29	.	.	.
18637	18465	1	546	546	CD
18637	18465	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18465	3	,	,	,
18637	18465	4	which	which	WDT
18637	18465	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	18465	6	now	now	RB
18637	18465	7	found	find	VBN
18637	18465	8	in	in	IN
18637	18465	9	8	8	CD
18637	18465	10	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	18466	1	§	§	NNP
18637	18466	2	56	56	CD
18637	18466	3	and	and	CC
18637	18466	4	18	18	CD
18637	18466	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	18467	1	§	§	NNP
18637	18467	2	1581	1581	CD
18637	18467	3	,	,	,
18637	18467	4	by	by	IN
18637	18467	5	the	the	DT
18637	18467	6	terms	term	NNS
18637	18467	7	of	of	IN
18637	18467	8	which	which	WDT
18637	18467	9	peonage	peonage	NN
18637	18467	10	was	be	VBD
18637	18467	11	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	18467	12	,	,	,
18637	18467	13	and	and	CC
18637	18467	14	persons	person	NNS
18637	18467	15	returning	return	VBG
18637	18467	16	any	any	DT
18637	18467	17	one	one	CD
18637	18467	18	to	to	IN
18637	18467	19	a	a	DT
18637	18467	20	condition	condition	NN
18637	18467	21	of	of	IN
18637	18467	22	peonage	peonage	NN
18637	18467	23	were	be	VBD
18637	18467	24	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	18467	25	to	to	IN
18637	18467	26	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	18467	27	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	18467	28	.	.	.
18637	18468	1	This	this	DT
18637	18468	2	statute	statute	NN
18637	18468	3	was	be	VBD
18637	18468	4	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	18468	5	in	in	IN
18637	18468	6	Clyatt	Clyatt	NNP
18637	18468	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18468	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18468	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18468	10	United	United	NNP
18637	18468	11	States	States	NNP
18637	18468	12	,	,	,
18637	18468	13	197	197	CD
18637	18468	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18468	15	207	207	CD
18637	18468	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18468	17	1905	1905	CD
18637	18468	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18468	19	.	.	.
18637	18469	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18469	2	7	7	LS
18637	18469	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18469	4	Peonage	peonage	NN
18637	18469	5	Cases	case	NNS
18637	18469	6	,	,	,
18637	18469	7	123	123	CD
18637	18469	8	F.	f.	NN
18637	18469	9	671	671	CD
18637	18469	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18469	11	1903	1903	CD
18637	18469	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18469	13	.	.	.
18637	18470	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18470	2	8	8	CD
18637	18470	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18470	4	219	219	CD
18637	18470	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18470	6	219	219	CD
18637	18470	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18470	8	1911	1911	CD
18637	18470	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18470	10	.	.	.
18637	18471	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18471	2	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	18471	3	,	,	,
18637	18471	4	who	who	WP
18637	18471	5	was	be	VBD
18637	18471	6	joined	join	VBN
18637	18471	7	by	by	IN
18637	18471	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18471	9	Lurton	Lurton	NNP
18637	18471	10	,	,	,
18637	18471	11	dissented	dissent	VBN
18637	18471	12	on	on	IN
18637	18471	13	the	the	DT
18637	18471	14	ground	ground	NN
18637	18471	15	that	that	IN
18637	18471	16	a	a	DT
18637	18471	17	State	state	NN
18637	18471	18	was	be	VBD
18637	18471	19	not	not	RB
18637	18471	20	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	18471	21	by	by	IN
18637	18471	22	this	this	DT
18637	18471	23	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18471	24	from	from	IN
18637	18471	25	punishing	punish	VBG
18637	18471	26	a	a	DT
18637	18471	27	breach	breach	NN
18637	18471	28	of	of	IN
18637	18471	29	contract	contract	NN
18637	18471	30	as	as	IN
18637	18471	31	a	a	DT
18637	18471	32	crime	crime	NN
18637	18471	33	.	.	.
18637	18472	1	"	"	``
18637	18472	2	Compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	18472	3	work	work	NN
18637	18472	4	for	for	IN
18637	18472	5	no	no	DT
18637	18472	6	private	private	JJ
18637	18472	7	master	master	NN
18637	18472	8	in	in	IN
18637	18472	9	a	a	DT
18637	18472	10	jail	jail	NN
18637	18472	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	18472	12	not	not	RB
18637	18472	13	peonage	peonage	NN
18637	18472	14	.	.	.
18637	18472	15	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	18472	16	.	.	.
18637	18473	1	247	247	CD
18637	18473	2	.	.	.
18637	18474	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18474	2	9	9	CD
18637	18474	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18474	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	18474	5	.	.	.
18637	18475	1	244	244	CD
18637	18475	2	.	.	.
18637	18476	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18476	2	10	10	CD
18637	18476	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18476	4	235	235	CD
18637	18476	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18476	6	133	133	CD
18637	18476	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18476	8	1914	1914	CD
18637	18476	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18476	10	.	.	.
18637	18477	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18477	2	11	11	CD
18637	18477	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18477	4	315	315	CD
18637	18477	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18477	6	25	25	CD
18637	18477	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18477	8	1942	1942	CD
18637	18477	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18477	10	.	.	.
18637	18478	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18478	2	12	12	CD
18637	18478	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18478	4	322	322	CD
18637	18478	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18478	6	4	4	CD
18637	18478	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18478	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	18478	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18478	10	.	.	.
18637	18479	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18479	2	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	18479	3	,	,	,
18637	18479	4	with	with	IN
18637	18479	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	18479	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18479	7	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	18479	8	concurring	concurring	NN
18637	18479	9	,	,	,
18637	18479	10	contended	contend	VBN
18637	18479	11	in	in	IN
18637	18479	12	a	a	DT
18637	18479	13	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	18479	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	18479	15	that	that	IN
18637	18479	16	a	a	DT
18637	18479	17	State	state	NN
18637	18479	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	18479	19	not	not	RB
18637	18479	20	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	18479	21	by	by	IN
18637	18479	22	the	the	DT
18637	18479	23	Thirteenth	Thirteenth	NNP
18637	18479	24	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18479	25	from	from	IN
18637	18479	26	"	"	``
18637	18479	27	punishing	punish	VBG
18637	18479	28	the	the	DT
18637	18479	29	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	18479	30	procurement	procurement	NN
18637	18479	31	of	of	IN
18637	18479	32	an	an	DT
18637	18479	33	advance	advance	NN
18637	18479	34	in	in	IN
18637	18479	35	wages	wage	NNS
18637	18479	36	.	.	.
18637	18479	37	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	18479	38	.	.	.
18637	18480	1	27	27	CD
18637	18480	2	.	.	.
18637	18481	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18481	2	13	13	CD
18637	18481	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18481	4	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	18481	5	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	18481	6	Cases	case	NNS
18637	18481	7	,	,	,
18637	18481	8	109	109	CD
18637	18481	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18481	10	3	3	CD
18637	18481	11	,	,	,
18637	18481	12	23	23	CD
18637	18481	13	-	-	SYM
18637	18481	14	25	25	CD
18637	18481	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18481	16	1883	1883	CD
18637	18481	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18481	18	;	;	:
18637	18481	19	Plessy	Plessy	NNP
18637	18481	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18481	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	18481	22	_	_	NNP
18637	18481	23	Ferguson	Ferguson	NNP
18637	18481	24	,	,	,
18637	18481	25	163	163	CD
18637	18481	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18481	27	537	537	CD
18637	18481	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18481	29	1896	1896	CD
18637	18481	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18481	31	.	.	.
18637	18482	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18482	2	14	14	CD
18637	18482	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18482	4	Hodges	Hodges	NNP
18637	18482	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18482	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18482	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18482	8	United	United	NNP
18637	18482	9	States	States	NNP
18637	18482	10	;	;	:
18637	18482	11	203	203	CD
18637	18482	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18482	13	1	1	CD
18637	18482	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18482	15	1906	1906	CD
18637	18482	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18482	17	.	.	.
18637	18483	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18483	2	15	15	CD
18637	18483	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18483	4	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	18483	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18483	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18483	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18483	8	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	18483	9	,	,	,
18637	18483	10	165	165	CD
18637	18483	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18483	12	275	275	CD
18637	18483	13	,	,	,
18637	18483	14	282	282	CD
18637	18483	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18483	16	1897	1897	CD
18637	18483	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18483	18	.	.	.
18637	18484	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18484	2	16	16	CD
18637	18484	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18484	4	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	18484	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18484	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18484	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18484	8	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	18484	9	,	,	,
18637	18484	10	240	240	CD
18637	18484	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18484	12	328	328	CD
18637	18484	13	,	,	,
18637	18484	14	333	333	CD
18637	18484	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18484	16	1916).--Work	1916).--work	CD
18637	18484	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	18484	18	or	or	CC
18637	18484	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	18484	20	fight	fight	VB
18637	18484	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	18484	22	,	,	,
18637	18484	23	such	such	JJ
18637	18484	24	as	as	IN
18637	18484	25	States	state	NNS
18637	18484	26	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	18484	27	during	during	IN
18637	18484	28	World	World	NNP
18637	18484	29	War	War	NNP
18637	18484	30	I	I	NNP
18637	18484	31	,	,	,
18637	18484	32	which	which	WDT
18637	18484	33	required	require	VBD
18637	18484	34	male	male	JJ
18637	18484	35	residents	resident	NNS
18637	18484	36	to	to	TO
18637	18484	37	be	be	VB
18637	18484	38	employed	employ	VBN
18637	18484	39	during	during	IN
18637	18484	40	the	the	DT
18637	18484	41	period	period	NN
18637	18484	42	of	of	IN
18637	18484	43	that	that	DT
18637	18484	44	War	War	NNP
18637	18484	45	were	be	VBD
18637	18484	46	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18484	47	on	on	IN
18637	18484	48	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18484	49	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	18484	50	,	,	,
18637	18484	51	as	as	IN
18637	18484	52	were	be	VBD
18637	18484	53	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	18484	54	ordinances	ordinance	NNS
18637	18484	55	,	,	,
18637	18484	56	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	18484	57	during	during	IN
18637	18484	58	the	the	DT
18637	18484	59	Depression	Depression	NNP
18637	18484	60	,	,	,
18637	18484	61	which	which	WDT
18637	18484	62	compelled	compel	VBD
18637	18484	63	indigents	indigent	NNS
18637	18484	64	physically	physically	RB
18637	18484	65	able	able	JJ
18637	18484	66	to	to	TO
18637	18484	67	perform	perform	VB
18637	18484	68	manual	manual	JJ
18637	18484	69	labor	labor	NN
18637	18484	70	to	to	TO
18637	18484	71	serve	serve	VB
18637	18484	72	the	the	DT
18637	18484	73	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	18484	74	without	without	IN
18637	18484	75	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18484	76	as	as	IN
18637	18484	77	a	a	DT
18637	18484	78	condition	condition	NN
18637	18484	79	of	of	IN
18637	18484	80	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	18484	81	financial	financial	JJ
18637	18484	82	assistance.--State	assistance.--state	NN
18637	18484	83	_	_	NNP
18637	18484	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	18484	85	_	_	NNP
18637	18484	86	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	18484	87	,	,	,
18637	18484	88	7	7	CD
18637	18484	89	Boyce	Boyce	NNP
18637	18484	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18484	91	Del.	Delaware	NNP
18637	18484	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18485	1	265	265	CD
18637	18485	2	;	;	:
18637	18485	3	105	105	CD
18637	18485	4	A.	a.	NN
18637	18486	1	712	712	CD
18637	18486	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18486	3	1919	1919	CD
18637	18486	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18486	5	;	;	:
18637	18486	6	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
18637	18486	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18486	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18486	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18486	10	Pouliot	Pouliot	NNP
18637	18486	11	,	,	,
18637	18486	12	292	292	CD
18637	18486	13	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	18487	1	229	229	CD
18637	18487	2	;	;	:
18637	18487	3	198	198	CD
18637	18487	4	N.E.	N.E.	NNP
18637	18488	1	256	256	CD
18637	18488	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18488	3	1935	1935	CD
18637	18488	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18488	5	.	.	.
18637	18489	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18489	2	17	17	CD
18637	18489	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18489	4	Arver	Arver	NNP
18637	18489	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18489	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18489	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18489	8	United	United	NNP
18637	18489	9	States	States	NNP
18637	18489	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18489	11	Selective	Selective	NNP
18637	18489	12	Draft	Draft	NNP
18637	18489	13	Law	Law	NNP
18637	18489	14	Cases	case	NNS
18637	18489	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18489	16	,	,	,
18637	18489	17	245	245	CD
18637	18489	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18489	19	366	366	CD
18637	18489	20	,	,	,
18637	18489	21	390	390	CD
18637	18489	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18489	23	1918	1918	CD
18637	18489	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18489	25	;	;	:
18637	18489	26	United	United	NNP
18637	18489	27	States	States	NNP
18637	18489	28	_	_	NNP
18637	18489	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	18489	30	_	_	NNP
18637	18489	31	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
18637	18489	32	,	,	,
18637	18489	33	54	54	CD
18637	18489	34	F.	F.	NNP
18637	18489	35	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	18489	36	.	.	.
18637	18490	1	995	995	CD
18637	18490	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18490	3	1944	1944	CD
18637	18490	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18490	5	;	;	:
18637	18490	6	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	18490	7	147	147	CD
18637	18490	8	F.	F.	NNP
18637	18490	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18490	10	2d	2d	CD
18637	18490	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18490	12	134	134	CD
18637	18490	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18490	14	1945	1945	CD
18637	18490	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18490	16	;	;	:
18637	18490	17	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	18490	18	denied	denied	NNP
18637	18490	19	,	,	,
18637	18490	20	324	324	CD
18637	18490	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18490	22	878	878	CD
18637	18490	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18490	24	1945	1945	CD
18637	18490	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18490	26	.	.	.
18637	18491	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18491	2	may	may	MD
18637	18491	3	be	be	VB
18637	18491	4	noted	note	VBN
18637	18491	5	in	in	IN
18637	18491	6	this	this	DT
18637	18491	7	connection	connection	NN
18637	18491	8	that	that	IN
18637	18491	9	labor	labor	NN
18637	18491	10	leaders	leader	NNS
18637	18491	11	have	have	VBP
18637	18491	12	contended	contend	VBN
18637	18491	13	that	that	IN
18637	18491	14	conscription	conscription	NN
18637	18491	15	of	of	IN
18637	18491	16	labor	labor	NN
18637	18491	17	in	in	IN
18637	18491	18	time	time	NN
18637	18491	19	of	of	IN
18637	18491	20	war	war	NN
18637	18491	21	,	,	,
18637	18491	22	unaccompanied	unaccompanied	JJ
18637	18491	23	by	by	IN
18637	18491	24	nationalization	nationalization	NN
18637	18491	25	of	of	IN
18637	18491	26	industry	industry	NN
18637	18491	27	,	,	,
18637	18491	28	would	would	MD
18637	18491	29	mean	mean	VB
18637	18491	30	that	that	IN
18637	18491	31	the	the	DT
18637	18491	32	conscripts	conscript	NNS
18637	18491	33	,	,	,
18637	18491	34	having	have	VBG
18637	18491	35	thus	thus	RB
18637	18491	36	been	be	VBN
18637	18491	37	forced	force	VBN
18637	18491	38	by	by	IN
18637	18491	39	the	the	DT
18637	18491	40	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18491	41	to	to	TO
18637	18491	42	work	work	VB
18637	18491	43	for	for	IN
18637	18491	44	private	private	JJ
18637	18491	45	profit	profit	NN
18637	18491	46	,	,	,
18637	18491	47	would	would	MD
18637	18491	48	be	be	VB
18637	18491	49	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	18491	50	to	to	IN
18637	18491	51	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	18491	52	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18491	53	.	.	.
18637	18492	1	This	this	DT
18637	18492	2	position	position	NN
18637	18492	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	18492	4	not	not	RB
18637	18492	5	supported	support	VBN
18637	18492	6	by	by	IN
18637	18492	7	the	the	DT
18637	18492	8	precedents.--_See	precedents.--_see	NN
18637	18492	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18492	10	Corwin	Corwin	NNP
18637	18492	11	,	,	,
18637	18492	12	Total	Total	NNP
18637	18492	13	War	War	NNP
18637	18492	14	and	and	CC
18637	18492	15	the	the	DT
18637	18492	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18492	17	,	,	,
18637	18492	18	89	89	CD
18637	18492	19	-	-	SYM
18637	18492	20	90	90	CD
18637	18492	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18492	22	1947	1947	CD
18637	18492	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18492	24	.	.	.
18637	18493	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18493	2	18	18	CD
18637	18493	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18493	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	18493	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18493	6	Marcus	Marcus	NNP
18637	18493	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18493	8	Holding	Holding	NNP
18637	18493	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18493	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18493	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	18493	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18493	13	Feldman	Feldman	NNP
18637	18493	14	,	,	,
18637	18493	15	256	256	CD
18637	18493	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18493	17	170	170	CD
18637	18493	18	,	,	,
18637	18493	19	109	109	CD
18637	18493	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18493	21	1921	1921	CD
18637	18493	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18493	23	.	.	.
18637	18494	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18494	2	19	19	CD
18637	18494	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18494	4	United	United	NNP
18637	18494	5	States	States	NNP
18637	18494	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18494	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18494	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18494	9	Petrillo	Petrillo	NNP
18637	18494	10	,	,	,
18637	18494	11	332	332	CD
18637	18494	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18494	13	1	1	CD
18637	18494	14	,	,	,
18637	18494	15	12	12	CD
18637	18494	16	-	-	SYM
18637	18494	17	13	13	CD
18637	18494	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18494	19	1947	1947	CD
18637	18494	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18494	21	.	.	.
18637	18495	1	Injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	18495	2	and	and	CC
18637	18495	3	"	"	``
18637	18495	4	cease	cease	VB
18637	18495	5	and	and	CC
18637	18495	6	desist	desist	VB
18637	18495	7	"	"	''
18637	18495	8	orders	order	NNS
18637	18495	9	in	in	IN
18637	18495	10	labor	labor	NN
18637	18495	11	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	18495	12	have	have	VBP
18637	18495	13	also	also	RB
18637	18495	14	been	be	VBN
18637	18495	15	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	18495	16	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18495	17	against	against	IN
18637	18495	18	charges	charge	NNS
18637	18495	19	by	by	IN
18637	18495	20	labor	labor	NN
18637	18495	21	that	that	WDT
18637	18495	22	the	the	DT
18637	18495	23	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
18637	18495	24	of	of	IN
18637	18495	25	this	this	DT
18637	18495	26	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18495	27	had	have	VBD
18637	18495	28	been	be	VBN
18637	18495	29	violated	violate	VBN
18637	18495	30	.	.	.
18637	18496	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18496	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18496	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18496	4	Auto	Auto	NNP
18637	18496	5	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	18496	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18496	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18496	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18496	9	Wis.	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	18496	10	Board	Board	NNP
18637	18496	11	,	,	,
18637	18496	12	336	336	CD
18637	18496	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18496	14	245	245	CD
18637	18496	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18496	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	18496	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18496	18	,	,	,
18637	18496	19	in	in	IN
18637	18496	20	which	which	WDT
18637	18496	21	application	application	NN
18637	18496	22	of	of	IN
18637	18496	23	the	the	DT
18637	18496	24	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	18496	25	Employment	Employment	NNP
18637	18496	26	Peace	Peace	NNP
18637	18496	27	Act	Act	NNP
18637	18496	28	in	in	IN
18637	18496	29	support	support	NN
18637	18496	30	of	of	IN
18637	18496	31	an	an	DT
18637	18496	32	order	order	NN
18637	18496	33	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	18496	34	recurrent	recurrent	NN
18637	18496	35	,	,	,
18637	18496	36	intermittent	intermittent	JJ
18637	18496	37	work	work	NN
18637	18496	38	stoppages	stoppage	NNS
18637	18496	39	for	for	IN
18637	18496	40	unstated	unstated	JJ
18637	18496	41	ends	end	NNS
18637	18496	42	was	be	VBD
18637	18496	43	held	hold	VBN
18637	18496	44	not	not	RB
18637	18496	45	to	to	TO
18637	18496	46	have	have	VB
18637	18496	47	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18496	48	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	18496	49	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	18496	50	.	.	.
18637	18497	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18497	2	See	See	NNP
18637	18497	3	also	also	RB
18637	18497	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18497	5	Western	Western	NNP
18637	18497	6	Union	Union	NNP
18637	18497	7	Tel	Tel	NNP
18637	18497	8	.	.	.
18637	18498	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18498	2	_	_	NNP
18637	18498	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	18498	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18498	5	International	International	NNP
18637	18498	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	18498	7	of	of	IN
18637	18498	8	E.	E.	NNP
18637	18498	9	Workers	Workers	NNP
18637	18498	10	,	,	,
18637	18498	11	2	2	CD
18637	18498	12	F.	F.	NNP
18637	18498	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18498	14	2d	2d	NNP
18637	18498	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18498	16	993	993	CD
18637	18498	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18498	18	1924	1924	CD
18637	18498	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18498	20	;	;	:
18637	18498	21	International	International	NNP
18637	18498	22	Brotherhood	Brotherhood	NNP
18637	18498	23	,	,	,
18637	18498	24	Etc	Etc	NNP
18637	18498	25	.	.	.
18637	18499	1	_	_	NNP
18637	18499	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	18499	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18499	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	18499	5	U.	U.	NNP
18637	18499	6	Tel	Tel	NNP
18637	18499	7	.	.	.
18637	18500	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18500	2	,	,	,
18637	18500	3	46	46	CD
18637	18500	4	F.	F.	NNP
18637	18500	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18500	6	2d	2d	NNP
18637	18500	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18500	8	736	736	CD
18637	18500	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18500	10	1931	1931	CD
18637	18500	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18500	12	,	,	,
18637	18500	13	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	18500	14	denied	deny	VBD
18637	18500	15	,	,	,
18637	18500	16	284	284	CD
18637	18500	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18500	18	630	630	CD
18637	18500	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18500	20	1931	1931	CD
18637	18500	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18500	22	.	.	.
18637	18501	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18501	2	20	20	CD
18637	18501	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18501	4	United	United	NNP
18637	18501	5	States	States	NNP
18637	18501	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18501	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18501	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18501	9	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	18501	10	,	,	,
18637	18501	11	106	106	CD
18637	18501	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18501	13	629	629	CD
18637	18501	14	,	,	,
18637	18501	15	640	640	CD
18637	18501	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18501	17	1883	1883	CD
18637	18501	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18501	19	.	.	.
18637	18502	1	An	an	DT
18637	18502	2	act	act	NN
18637	18502	3	of	of	IN
18637	18502	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18502	5	which	which	WDT
18637	18502	6	penalized	penalize	VBD
18637	18502	7	a	a	DT
18637	18502	8	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	18502	9	to	to	TO
18637	18502	10	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	18502	11	any	any	DT
18637	18502	12	person	person	NN
18637	18502	13	of	of	IN
18637	18502	14	the	the	DT
18637	18502	15	equal	equal	JJ
18637	18502	16	protection	protection	NN
18637	18502	17	of	of	IN
18637	18502	18	the	the	DT
18637	18502	19	laws	law	NNS
18637	18502	20	or	or	CC
18637	18502	21	of	of	IN
18637	18502	22	equal	equal	JJ
18637	18502	23	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18502	24	and	and	CC
18637	18502	25	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	18502	26	under	under	IN
18637	18502	27	the	the	DT
18637	18502	28	laws	law	NNS
18637	18502	29	was	be	VBD
18637	18502	30	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	18502	31	held	hold	VBN
18637	18502	32	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18502	33	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	18502	34	as	as	IN
18637	18502	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18502	36	validity	validity	NN
18637	18502	37	was	be	VBD
18637	18502	38	made	make	VBN
18637	18502	39	to	to	TO
18637	18502	40	depend	depend	VB
18637	18502	41	upon	upon	IN
18637	18502	42	the	the	DT
18637	18502	43	Thirteenth	Thirteenth	NNP
18637	18502	44	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18502	45	.	.	.
18637	18503	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18503	2	21	21	CD
18637	18503	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18503	4	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	18503	5	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	18503	6	Cases	case	NNS
18637	18503	7	,	,	,
18637	18503	8	109	109	CD
18637	18503	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18503	10	3	3	CD
18637	18503	11	,	,	,
18637	18503	12	20	20	CD
18637	18503	13	,	,	,
18637	18503	14	23	23	CD
18637	18503	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18503	16	1883	1883	CD
18637	18503	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18503	18	.	.	.
18637	18504	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18504	2	22	22	CD
18637	18504	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18504	4	14	14	CD
18637	18504	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	18504	6	.	.	.
18637	18505	1	546	546	CD
18637	18505	2	;	;	:
18637	18505	3	8	8	CD
18637	18505	4	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	18506	1	§	§	NNP
18637	18506	2	56	56	CD
18637	18506	3	;	;	:
18637	18506	4	18	18	CD
18637	18506	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	18507	1	§	§	NNP
18637	18507	2	1581	1581	CD
18637	18507	3	.	.	.
18637	18508	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18508	2	23	23	CD
18637	18508	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18508	4	197	197	CD
18637	18508	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18508	6	207	207	CD
18637	18508	7	,	,	,
18637	18508	8	218	218	CD
18637	18508	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18508	10	1905	1905	CD
18637	18508	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18508	12	.	.	.
18637	18509	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18509	2	24	24	CD
18637	18509	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18509	4	320	320	CD
18637	18509	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18509	6	527	527	CD
18637	18509	7	,	,	,
18637	18509	8	529	529	CD
18637	18509	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18509	10	1944	1944	CD
18637	18509	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18509	12	.	.	.
18637	18510	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	18510	2	14	14	CD
18637	18510	3	RIGHTS	right	NNS
18637	18510	4	OF	of	IN
18637	18510	5	CITIZENS	CITIZENS	NNP
18637	18510	6	Page	Page	NNP
18637	18510	7	Section	Section	NNP
18637	18510	8	1	1	CD
18637	18510	9	.	.	.
18637	18511	1	Citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18511	2	;	;	:
18637	18511	3	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18511	4	and	and	CC
18637	18511	5	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	18511	6	;	;	:
18637	18511	7	due	due	JJ
18637	18511	8	process	process	NN
18637	18511	9	;	;	:
18637	18511	10	equal	equal	JJ
18637	18511	11	protection	protection	NN
18637	18511	12	963	963	CD
18637	18511	13	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	18511	14	of	of	IN
18637	18511	15	the	the	DT
18637	18511	16	United	United	NNP
18637	18511	17	States	States	NNP
18637	18511	18	963	963	CD
18637	18511	19	Kinds	Kinds	NNPS
18637	18511	20	and	and	CC
18637	18511	21	sources	source	NNS
18637	18511	22	of	of	IN
18637	18511	23	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18511	24	963	963	CD
18637	18511	25	History	history	NN
18637	18511	26	963	963	CD
18637	18511	27	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18511	28	elucidation	elucidation	NN
18637	18511	29	of	of	IN
18637	18511	30	the	the	DT
18637	18511	31	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18511	32	clause	clause	NN
18637	18511	33	964	964	CD
18637	18511	34	National	National	NNP
18637	18511	35	and	and	CC
18637	18511	36	State	State	NNP
18637	18511	37	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18511	38	965	965	CD
18637	18511	39	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18511	40	965	965	CD
18637	18511	41	Privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18511	42	and	and	CC
18637	18511	43	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	18511	44	965	965	CD
18637	18511	45	Purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18511	46	and	and	CC
18637	18511	47	early	early	JJ
18637	18511	48	history	history	NN
18637	18511	49	of	of	IN
18637	18511	50	the	the	DT
18637	18511	51	clause	clause	NN
18637	18511	52	965	965	CD
18637	18511	53	Privileges	Privileges	NNPS
18637	18511	54	and	and	CC
18637	18511	55	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	18511	56	of	of	IN
18637	18511	57	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18511	58	of	of	IN
18637	18511	59	the	the	DT
18637	18511	60	United	United	NNP
18637	18511	61	States	States	NNP
18637	18511	62	967	967	NNP
18637	18511	63	Privileges	Privileges	NNPS
18637	18511	64	held	hold	VBN
18637	18511	65	not	not	RB
18637	18511	66	within	within	IN
18637	18511	67	the	the	DT
18637	18511	68	protection	protection	NN
18637	18511	69	of	of	IN
18637	18511	70	the	the	DT
18637	18511	71	clause	clause	NN
18637	18511	72	969	969	CD
18637	18511	73	Due	due	JJ
18637	18511	74	process	process	NN
18637	18511	75	of	of	IN
18637	18511	76	law	law	NN
18637	18511	77	clause	clause	NN
18637	18511	78	971	971	CD
18637	18511	79	Historical	historical	JJ
18637	18511	80	development	development	NN
18637	18511	81	971	971	CD
18637	18511	82	Police	police	NN
18637	18511	83	power	power	NN
18637	18511	84	:	:	:
18637	18511	85	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18511	86	:	:	:
18637	18511	87	property	property	NN
18637	18511	88	974	974	CD
18637	18511	89	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	18511	90	of	of	IN
18637	18511	91	contract	contract	NN
18637	18511	92	--	--	:
18637	18511	93	labor	labor	NN
18637	18511	94	relations	relation	NNS
18637	18511	95	976	976	CD
18637	18511	96	Definitions	definition	NNS
18637	18511	97	981	981	CD
18637	18511	98	"	"	``
18637	18511	99	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	18511	100	"	"	''
18637	18511	101	defined	define	VBD
18637	18511	102	981	981	CD
18637	18511	103	Due	Due	NNP
18637	18511	104	process	process	NN
18637	18511	105	and	and	CC
18637	18511	106	the	the	DT
18637	18511	107	police	police	NN
18637	18511	108	power	power	NN
18637	18511	109	982	982	CD
18637	18511	110	Definition	Definition	NNP
18637	18511	111	982	982	CD
18637	18511	112	Limitations	Limitations	NNPS
18637	18511	113	on	on	IN
18637	18511	114	the	the	DT
18637	18511	115	police	police	NN
18637	18511	116	power	power	NN
18637	18511	117	982	982	CD
18637	18511	118	"	"	``
18637	18511	119	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	18511	120	,	,	,
18637	18511	121	"	"	''
18637	18511	122	in	in	IN
18637	18511	123	general	general	JJ
18637	18511	124	983	983	CD
18637	18511	125	Definitions	definition	NNS
18637	18511	126	983	983	CD
18637	18511	127	Personal	personal	JJ
18637	18511	128	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18511	129	:	:	:
18637	18511	130	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	18511	131	vaccination	vaccination	NN
18637	18511	132	:	:	:
18637	18511	133	sexual	sexual	JJ
18637	18511	134	sterilization	sterilization	NN
18637	18511	135	984	984	CD
18637	18511	136	Liberties	Liberties	NNPS
18637	18511	137	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	18511	138	to	to	IN
18637	18511	139	education	education	NN
18637	18511	140	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18511	141	of	of	IN
18637	18511	142	teachers	teacher	NNS
18637	18511	143	,	,	,
18637	18511	144	parents	parent	NNS
18637	18511	145	,	,	,
18637	18511	146	pupils	pupil	NNS
18637	18511	147	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18511	148	984	984	CD
18637	18511	149	Liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	18511	150	safeguarded	safeguard	VBN
18637	18511	151	by	by	IN
18637	18511	152	the	the	DT
18637	18511	153	first	first	JJ
18637	18511	154	eight	eight	CD
18637	18511	155	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	18511	156	985	985	CD
18637	18511	157	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	18511	158	of	of	IN
18637	18511	159	contract	contract	NN
18637	18511	160	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18511	161	labor	labor	NN
18637	18511	162	relations	relation	NNS
18637	18511	163	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18511	164	985	985	CD
18637	18511	165	In	in	IN
18637	18511	166	general	general	JJ
18637	18511	167	985	985	CD
18637	18511	168	Laws	law	NNS
18637	18511	169	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	18511	170	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18511	171	of	of	IN
18637	18511	172	labor	labor	NN
18637	18511	173	986	986	CD
18637	18511	174	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	18511	175	regulating	regulating	NN
18637	18511	176	labor	labor	NN
18637	18511	177	in	in	IN
18637	18511	178	mines	mine	NNS
18637	18511	179	987	987	CD
18637	18511	180	Laws	law	NNS
18637	18511	181	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	18511	182	employment	employment	NN
18637	18511	183	of	of	IN
18637	18511	184	children	child	NNS
18637	18511	185	in	in	IN
18637	18511	186	hazardous	hazardous	JJ
18637	18511	187	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	18511	188	987	987	CD
18637	18511	189	Laws	law	NNS
18637	18511	190	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	18511	191	payment	payment	NN
18637	18511	192	of	of	IN
18637	18511	193	wages	wage	NNS
18637	18511	194	987	987	CD
18637	18511	195	Minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	18511	196	wage	wage	NN
18637	18511	197	laws	law	NNS
18637	18511	198	988	988	CD
18637	18511	199	Workmen	workman	NNS
18637	18511	200	's	's	POS
18637	18511	201	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18511	202	laws	law	NNS
18637	18511	203	989	989	CD
18637	18511	204	Collective	collective	JJ
18637	18511	205	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	18511	206	991	991	CD
18637	18511	207	Regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18511	208	of	of	IN
18637	18511	209	charges	charge	NNS
18637	18511	210	;	;	:
18637	18511	211	Business	business	NN
18637	18511	212	affected	affect	VBD
18637	18511	213	with	with	IN
18637	18511	214	a	a	DT
18637	18511	215	Public	Public	NNP
18637	18511	216	Interest	interest	NN
18637	18511	217	994	994	CD
18637	18511	218	History	history	NN
18637	18511	219	994	994	CD
18637	18511	220	Nebbia	Nebbia	NNP
18637	18511	221	_	_	NNP
18637	18511	222	v.	v.	IN
18637	18511	223	_	_	NNP
18637	18511	224	New	New	NNP
18637	18511	225	York	York	NNP
18637	18511	226	996	996	CD
18637	18511	227	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18511	228	review	review	NN
18637	18511	229	of	of	IN
18637	18511	230	publicly	publicly	RB
18637	18511	231	determined	determine	VBN
18637	18511	232	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18511	233	and	and	CC
18637	18511	234	charges	charge	VBZ
18637	18511	235	998	998	CD
18637	18511	236	Development	Development	NNP
18637	18511	237	998	998	CD
18637	18511	238	Limitations	Limitations	NNPS
18637	18511	239	on	on	IN
18637	18511	240	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18511	241	review	review	NN
18637	18511	242	1000	1000	CD
18637	18511	243	Ben	Ben	NNP
18637	18511	244	Avon	Avon	NNP
18637	18511	245	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18511	246	1003	1003	CD
18637	18511	247	History	history	NN
18637	18511	248	of	of	IN
18637	18511	249	the	the	DT
18637	18511	250	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	18511	251	question	question	NN
18637	18511	252	1004	1004	CD
18637	18511	253	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	18511	254	of	of	IN
18637	18511	255	public	public	JJ
18637	18511	256	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	18511	257	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18511	258	other	other	JJ
18637	18511	259	than	than	IN
18637	18511	260	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18511	261	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18511	262	1008	1008	CD
18637	18511	263	In	in	IN
18637	18511	264	general	general	JJ
18637	18511	265	1008	1008	CD
18637	18511	266	Compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	18511	267	expenditures	expenditure	NNS
18637	18511	268	1009	1009	CD
18637	18511	269	Grade	Grade	NNP
18637	18511	270	crossings	crossing	NNS
18637	18511	271	and	and	CC
18637	18511	272	other	other	JJ
18637	18511	273	expenditures	expenditure	NNS
18637	18511	274	by	by	IN
18637	18511	275	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	18511	276	1010	1010	CD
18637	18511	277	Compellable	compellable	JJ
18637	18511	278	services	service	NNS
18637	18511	279	1011	1011	CD
18637	18511	280	Intercompany	intercompany	JJ
18637	18511	281	railway	railway	NN
18637	18511	282	service	service	NN
18637	18511	283	1012	1012	CD
18637	18511	284	Intercompany	intercompany	JJ
18637	18511	285	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	18511	286	service	service	NN
18637	18511	287	charges	charge	VBZ
18637	18511	288	1013	1013	CD
18637	18511	289	Safety	safety	NN
18637	18511	290	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18511	291	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	18511	292	to	to	IN
18637	18511	293	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	18511	294	1014	1014	CD
18637	18511	295	Liabilities	liability	NNS
18637	18511	296	and	and	CC
18637	18511	297	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	18511	298	1014	1014	CD
18637	18511	299	Regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18511	300	of	of	IN
18637	18511	301	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18511	302	,	,	,
18637	18511	303	business	business	NN
18637	18511	304	,	,	,
18637	18511	305	professions	profession	NNS
18637	18511	306	,	,	,
18637	18511	307	and	and	CC
18637	18511	308	trades	trade	VBZ
18637	18511	309	1016	1016	CD
18637	18511	310	Domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	18511	311	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18511	312	1016	1016	CD
18637	18511	313	Foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18511	314	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18511	315	1016	1016	CD
18637	18511	316	Business	business	NN
18637	18511	317	in	in	IN
18637	18511	318	general	general	JJ
18637	18511	319	1017	1017	CD
18637	18511	320	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	18511	321	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	18511	322	trusts	trust	NNS
18637	18511	323	,	,	,
18637	18511	324	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	18511	325	,	,	,
18637	18511	326	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18511	327	of	of	IN
18637	18511	328	trade	trade	NN
18637	18511	329	1017	1017	CD
18637	18511	330	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	18511	331	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	18511	332	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	18511	333	in	in	IN
18637	18511	334	sale	sale	NN
18637	18511	335	of	of	IN
18637	18511	336	goods	good	NNS
18637	18511	337	1018	1018	CD
18637	18511	338	Blue	blue	JJ
18637	18511	339	sky	sky	NN
18637	18511	340	laws	law	NNS
18637	18511	341	;	;	:
18637	18511	342	laws	law	NNS
18637	18511	343	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	18511	344	boards	board	NNS
18637	18511	345	of	of	IN
18637	18511	346	trade	trade	NN
18637	18511	347	,	,	,
18637	18511	348	etc	etc	FW
18637	18511	349	.	.	.
18637	18512	1	1019	1019	CD
18637	18512	2	Trading	trading	NN
18637	18512	3	stamps	stamp	NNS
18637	18512	4	1019	1019	CD
18637	18512	5	Banking	banking	NN
18637	18512	6	1020	1020	CD
18637	18512	7	Loans	Loans	NNPS
18637	18512	8	,	,	,
18637	18512	9	interest	interest	NN
18637	18512	10	,	,	,
18637	18512	11	assignments	assignment	VBZ
18637	18512	12	1020	1020	CD
18637	18512	13	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	18512	14	1021	1021	CD
18637	18512	15	Professions	Professions	NNPS
18637	18512	16	,	,	,
18637	18512	17	trades	trade	NNS
18637	18512	18	,	,	,
18637	18512	19	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	18512	20	1023	1023	CD
18637	18512	21	Pharmacies	pharmacy	NNS
18637	18512	22	1023	1023	CD
18637	18512	23	Miscellaneous	miscellaneous	JJ
18637	18512	24	business	business	NN
18637	18512	25	,	,	,
18637	18512	26	professions	profession	NNS
18637	18512	27	,	,	,
18637	18512	28	trades	trade	NNS
18637	18512	29	,	,	,
18637	18512	30	and	and	CC
18637	18512	31	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	18512	32	1023	1023	CD
18637	18512	33	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	18512	34	of	of	IN
18637	18512	35	resources	resource	NNS
18637	18512	36	of	of	IN
18637	18512	37	the	the	DT
18637	18512	38	State	State	NNP
18637	18512	39	1025	1025	CD
18637	18512	40	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	18512	41	and	and	CC
18637	18512	42	gas	gas	NN
18637	18512	43	1025	1025	CD
18637	18512	44	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	18512	45	of	of	IN
18637	18512	46	property	property	NN
18637	18512	47	damaged	damage	VBN
18637	18512	48	by	by	IN
18637	18512	49	mining	mining	NN
18637	18512	50	or	or	CC
18637	18512	51	drilling	drilling	NN
18637	18512	52	of	of	IN
18637	18512	53	wells	wells	NNP
18637	18512	54	1026	1026	CD
18637	18512	55	Water	Water	NNP
18637	18512	56	1026	1026	CD
18637	18512	57	Apple	Apple	NNP
18637	18512	58	and	and	CC
18637	18512	59	citrus	citrus	NN
18637	18512	60	fruit	fruit	NN
18637	18512	61	industries	industry	NNS
18637	18512	62	1026	1026	CD
18637	18512	63	Fish	fish	NN
18637	18512	64	and	and	CC
18637	18512	65	game	game	NN
18637	18512	66	1027	1027	CD
18637	18512	67	Limitations	Limitations	NNP
18637	18512	68	on	on	IN
18637	18512	69	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	18512	70	1027	1027	CD
18637	18512	71	Zoning	zoning	NN
18637	18512	72	,	,	,
18637	18512	73	building	building	NN
18637	18512	74	lines	line	NNS
18637	18512	75	,	,	,
18637	18512	76	etc	etc	FW
18637	18512	77	.	.	.
18637	18513	1	1027	1027	CD
18637	18513	2	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	18513	3	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18513	4	1029	1029	CD
18637	18513	5	Police	police	NN
18637	18513	6	power	power	NN
18637	18513	7	1029	1029	CD
18637	18513	8	General	General	NNP
18637	18513	9	1029	1029	CD
18637	18513	10	Health	Health	NNP
18637	18513	11	measures	measure	NNS
18637	18513	12	1030	1030	CD
18637	18513	13	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	18513	14	of	of	IN
18637	18513	15	water	water	NN
18637	18513	16	supply	supply	NN
18637	18513	17	1030	1030	CD
18637	18513	18	Garbage	Garbage	NNP
18637	18513	19	1030	1030	CD
18637	18513	20	Sewers	Sewers	NNP
18637	18513	21	1030	1030	CD
18637	18513	22	Food	Food	NNP
18637	18513	23	and	and	CC
18637	18513	24	Drugs	Drugs	NNPS
18637	18513	25	,	,	,
18637	18513	26	etc	etc	FW
18637	18513	27	.	.	.
18637	18514	1	1030	1030	CD
18637	18514	2	Milk	milk	NN
18637	18514	3	1030	1030	CD
18637	18514	4	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	18514	5	of	of	IN
18637	18514	6	public	public	JJ
18637	18514	7	morals	moral	NNS
18637	18514	8	1031	1031	CD
18637	18514	9	Gambling	gambling	NN
18637	18514	10	and	and	CC
18637	18514	11	lotteries	lottery	NNS
18637	18514	12	1031	1031	CD
18637	18514	13	Red	red	JJ
18637	18514	14	light	light	NN
18637	18514	15	districts	district	NNS
18637	18514	16	1031	1031	CD
18637	18514	17	Sunday	Sunday	NNP
18637	18514	18	blue	blue	JJ
18637	18514	19	laws	law	NNS
18637	18514	20	1031	1031	CD
18637	18514	21	Intoxicating	Intoxicating	NNP
18637	18514	22	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	18514	23	1031	1031	CD
18637	18514	24	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	18514	25	of	of	IN
18637	18514	26	motor	motor	NN
18637	18514	27	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	18514	28	and	and	CC
18637	18514	29	motor	motor	NN
18637	18514	30	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	18514	31	1032	1032	CD
18637	18514	32	Succession	Succession	NNP
18637	18514	33	to	to	IN
18637	18514	34	property	property	NN
18637	18514	35	1033	1033	CD
18637	18514	36	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	18514	37	of	of	IN
18637	18514	38	estates	estate	NNS
18637	18514	39	1034	1034	CD
18637	18514	40	Abandoned	abandoned	JJ
18637	18514	41	property	property	NN
18637	18514	42	1034	1034	CD
18637	18514	43	Vested	vested	JJ
18637	18514	44	rights	right	NNS
18637	18514	45	,	,	,
18637	18514	46	remedial	remedial	JJ
18637	18514	47	rights	right	NNS
18637	18514	48	;	;	,
18637	18514	49	political	political	JJ
18637	18514	50	candidacy	candidacy	NN
18637	18514	51	1034	1034	CD
18637	18514	52	Man	Man	NNP
18637	18514	53	's	's	POS
18637	18514	54	best	good	JJS
18637	18514	55	friend	friend	NN
18637	18514	56	1035	1035	CD
18637	18514	57	Control	Control	NNP
18637	18514	58	of	of	IN
18637	18514	59	local	local	JJ
18637	18514	60	units	unit	NNS
18637	18514	61	of	of	IN
18637	18514	62	government	government	NN
18637	18514	63	1035	1035	CD
18637	18514	64	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	18514	65	1036	1036	CD
18637	18514	66	In	in	IN
18637	18514	67	general	general	JJ
18637	18514	68	1036	1036	CD
18637	18514	69	Public	public	JJ
18637	18514	70	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18514	71	1036	1036	CD
18637	18514	72	Other	other	JJ
18637	18514	73	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	18514	74	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	18514	75	validity	validity	NN
18637	18514	76	:	:	:
18637	18514	77	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	18514	78	burden	burden	NN
18637	18514	79	;	;	:
18637	18514	80	ration	ration	NN
18637	18514	81	of	of	IN
18637	18514	82	amount	amount	NN
18637	18514	83	to	to	TO
18637	18514	84	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	18514	85	received	receive	VBD
18637	18514	86	1037	1037	CD
18637	18514	87	Estate	Estate	NNP
18637	18514	88	,	,	,
18637	18514	89	gift	gift	NN
18637	18514	90	and	and	CC
18637	18514	91	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	18514	92	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	93	1037	1037	CD
18637	18514	94	Other	other	JJ
18637	18514	95	types	type	NNS
18637	18514	96	of	of	IN
18637	18514	97	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	98	1036	1036	CD
18637	18514	99	Income	income	NN
18637	18514	100	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	101	1036	1036	CD
18637	18514	102	Franchise	Franchise	NNP
18637	18514	103	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	104	1036	1036	CD
18637	18514	105	Severance	severance	NN
18637	18514	106	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	107	1036	1036	CD
18637	18514	108	Real	real	JJ
18637	18514	109	property	property	NN
18637	18514	110	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	111	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18514	112	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	18514	113	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18514	114	1036	1036	CD
18637	18514	115	Real	real	JJ
18637	18514	116	property	property	NN
18637	18514	117	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18514	119	special	special	JJ
18637	18514	120	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	18514	121	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18514	122	1040	1040	CD
18637	18514	123	Jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18514	124	to	to	TO
18637	18514	125	tax	tax	VB
18637	18514	126	1041	1041	CD
18637	18514	127	Land	land	NN
18637	18514	128	1041	1041	CD
18637	18514	129	Tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	18514	130	personalty	personalty	NN
18637	18514	131	1041	1041	CD
18637	18514	132	Intangible	intangible	JJ
18637	18514	133	personalty	personalty	NN
18637	18514	134	1042	1042	CD
18637	18514	135	General	General	NNP
18637	18514	136	1042	1042	CD
18637	18514	137	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	138	on	on	IN
18637	18514	139	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	18514	140	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	18514	141	1042	1042	CD
18637	18514	142	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	143	on	on	IN
18637	18514	144	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	18514	145	invalidated	invalidate	VBN
18637	18514	146	1044	1044	CD
18637	18514	147	Transfer	Transfer	NNP
18637	18514	148	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	149	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18514	150	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	18514	151	,	,	,
18637	18514	152	estate	estate	NN
18637	18514	153	,	,	,
18637	18514	154	gift	gift	NN
18637	18514	155	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	156	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18514	157	1045	1045	CD
18637	18514	158	Corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18514	159	taxes	tax	VBZ
18637	18514	160	1049	1049	CD
18637	18514	161	Intangible	intangible	JJ
18637	18514	162	personal	personal	JJ
18637	18514	163	property	property	NN
18637	18514	164	1049	1049	CD
18637	18514	165	Privilege	Privilege	NNP
18637	18514	166	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	167	measured	measure	VBN
18637	18514	168	by	by	IN
18637	18514	169	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	18514	170	stock	stock	NN
18637	18514	171	1050	1050	CD
18637	18514	172	Privilege	Privilege	NNP
18637	18514	173	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	174	measured	measure	VBN
18637	18514	175	by	by	IN
18637	18514	176	gross	gross	JJ
18637	18514	177	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	18514	178	1051	1051	CD
18637	18514	179	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	180	on	on	IN
18637	18514	181	tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	18514	182	personal	personal	JJ
18637	18514	183	property	property	NN
18637	18514	184	1052	1052	CD
18637	18514	185	Income	Income	NNP
18637	18514	186	and	and	CC
18637	18514	187	other	other	JJ
18637	18514	188	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	189	1053	1053	CD
18637	18514	190	Individual	individual	JJ
18637	18514	191	incomes	income	NNS
18637	18514	192	1053	1053	CD
18637	18514	193	Incomes	income	NNS
18637	18514	194	of	of	IN
18637	18514	195	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18514	196	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18514	197	1054	1054	CD
18637	18514	198	Chain	chain	NN
18637	18514	199	store	store	NN
18637	18514	200	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	201	1055	1055	CD
18637	18514	202	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	18514	203	company	company	NN
18637	18514	204	taxes	tax	VBZ
18637	18514	205	1055	1055	CD
18637	18514	206	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	18514	207	in	in	IN
18637	18514	208	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	18514	209	1056	1056	CD
18637	18514	210	In	in	IN
18637	18514	211	general	general	JJ
18637	18514	212	1056	1056	CD
18637	18514	213	Notice	Notice	NNP
18637	18514	214	and	and	CC
18637	18514	215	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	18514	216	in	in	IN
18637	18514	217	relation	relation	NN
18637	18514	218	to	to	IN
18637	18514	219	general	general	JJ
18637	18514	220	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	221	1057	1057	CD
18637	18514	222	Notice	notice	NN
18637	18514	223	and	and	CC
18637	18514	224	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	18514	225	in	in	IN
18637	18514	226	relation	relation	NN
18637	18514	227	to	to	IN
18637	18514	228	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	18514	229	1057	1057	CD
18637	18514	230	Notice	notice	NN
18637	18514	231	and	and	CC
18637	18514	232	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	18514	233	in	in	IN
18637	18514	234	relation	relation	NN
18637	18514	235	to	to	IN
18637	18514	236	special	special	JJ
18637	18514	237	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	18514	238	1058	1058	CD
18637	18514	239	Sufficiency	Sufficiency	NNP
18637	18514	240	and	and	CC
18637	18514	241	manner	manner	NN
18637	18514	242	of	of	IN
18637	18514	243	giving	give	VBG
18637	18514	244	notice	notice	NN
18637	18514	245	1060	1060	CD
18637	18514	246	Sufficiency	sufficiency	NN
18637	18514	247	of	of	IN
18637	18514	248	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	18514	249	1060	1060	CD
18637	18514	250	Laches	Laches	NNP
18637	18514	251	1061	1061	CD
18637	18514	252	Collection	Collection	NNP
18637	18514	253	of	of	IN
18637	18514	254	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18514	255	1061	1061	CD
18637	18514	256	Eminent	Eminent	NNP
18637	18514	257	Domain	Domain	NNP
18637	18514	258	1062	1062	CD
18637	18514	259	Historical	historical	JJ
18637	18514	260	development	development	NN
18637	18514	261	1062	1062	CD
18637	18514	262	Public	public	JJ
18637	18514	263	use	use	NN
18637	18514	264	1063	1063	CD
18637	18514	265	Necessity	necessity	NN
18637	18514	266	for	for	IN
18637	18514	267	a	a	DT
18637	18514	268	taking	take	VBG
18637	18514	269	1064	1064	CD
18637	18514	270	What	what	WP
18637	18514	271	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	18514	272	a	a	DT
18637	18514	273	taking	taking	NN
18637	18514	274	for	for	IN
18637	18514	275	a	a	DT
18637	18514	276	public	public	JJ
18637	18514	277	use	use	NN
18637	18514	278	1064	1064	CD
18637	18514	279	Just	just	RB
18637	18514	280	compensation	compensation	VB
18637	18514	281	1066	1066	CD
18637	18514	282	Uncompensated	uncompensated	JJ
18637	18514	283	takings	taking	NNS
18637	18514	284	1067	1067	CD
18637	18514	285	Consequential	consequential	JJ
18637	18514	286	damages	damage	NNS
18637	18514	287	1067	1067	CD
18637	18514	288	Limits	limit	NNS
18637	18514	289	to	to	IN
18637	18514	290	the	the	DT
18637	18514	291	above	above	JJ
18637	18514	292	rule	rule	NN
18637	18514	293	1068	1068	CD
18637	18514	294	Due	due	JJ
18637	18514	295	process	process	NN
18637	18514	296	in	in	IN
18637	18514	297	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	18514	298	domain	domain	NN
18637	18514	299	1069	1069	CD
18637	18514	300	Notice	Notice	NNP
18637	18514	301	1069	1069	CD
18637	18514	302	Hearing	hear	VBG
18637	18514	303	1069	1069	CD
18637	18514	304	Occupation	Occupation	NNP
18637	18514	305	in	in	IN
18637	18514	306	advance	advance	NN
18637	18514	307	of	of	IN
18637	18514	308	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	18514	309	1070	1070	CD
18637	18514	310	Due	due	IN
18637	18514	311	process	process	NN
18637	18514	312	in	in	IN
18637	18514	313	civil	civil	JJ
18637	18514	314	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18514	315	1070	1070	CD
18637	18514	316	Some	some	DT
18637	18514	317	general	general	JJ
18637	18514	318	criteria	criterion	NNS
18637	18514	319	1070	1070	CD
18637	18514	320	Ancient	ancient	JJ
18637	18514	321	usage	usage	NN
18637	18514	322	and	and	CC
18637	18514	323	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	18514	324	1070	1070	CD
18637	18514	325	Equality	Equality	NNP
18637	18514	326	1071	1071	CD
18637	18514	327	Due	Due	NNP
18637	18514	328	process	process	NN
18637	18514	329	and	and	CC
18637	18514	330	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18514	331	process	process	NN
18637	18514	332	1071	1071	CD
18637	18514	333	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	18514	334	1072	1072	CD
18637	18514	335	In	in	IN
18637	18514	336	general	general	JJ
18637	18514	337	1072	1072	CD
18637	18514	338	How	how	WRB
18637	18514	339	perfected	perfect	VBN
18637	18514	340	:	:	:
18637	18514	341	by	by	IN
18637	18514	342	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	18514	343	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	18514	344	or	or	CC
18637	18514	345	service	service	NN
18637	18514	346	of	of	IN
18637	18514	347	process	process	NN
18637	18514	348	1072	1072	CD
18637	18514	349	Service	Service	NNP
18637	18514	350	of	of	IN
18637	18514	351	process	process	NN
18637	18514	352	in	in	IN
18637	18514	353	actions	action	NNS
18637	18514	354	in	in	IN
18637	18514	355	personam	personam	NNP
18637	18514	356	:	:	:
18637	18514	357	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	18514	358	,	,	,
18637	18514	359	resident	resident	NN
18637	18514	360	and	and	CC
18637	18514	361	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	18514	362	1073	1073	CD
18637	18514	363	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	18514	364	in	in	IN
18637	18514	365	personam	personam	NNP
18637	18514	366	1075	1075	CD
18637	18514	367	Suability	suability	NN
18637	18514	368	of	of	IN
18637	18514	369	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18514	370	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18514	371	1075	1075	CD
18637	18514	372	Service	Service	NNP
18637	18514	373	of	of	IN
18637	18514	374	process	process	NN
18637	18514	375	1080	1080	CD
18637	18514	376	Actions	Actions	NNPS
18637	18514	377	in	in	IN
18637	18514	378	rem	rem	NN
18637	18514	379	--	--	:
18637	18514	380	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18514	381	against	against	IN
18637	18514	382	land	land	NN
18637	18514	383	1080	1080	CD
18637	18514	384	Actions	Actions	NNPS
18637	18514	385	in	in	IN
18637	18514	386	rem	rem	NN
18637	18514	387	--	--	:
18637	18514	388	attachment	attachment	NN
18637	18514	389	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18514	390	1081	1081	CD
18637	18514	391	Actions	Actions	NNPS
18637	18514	392	in	in	IN
18637	18514	393	rem	rem	NN
18637	18514	394	--	--	:
18637	18514	395	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18514	396	,	,	,
18637	18514	397	estates	estate	NNS
18637	18514	398	,	,	,
18637	18514	399	trusts	trust	NNS
18637	18514	400	,	,	,
18637	18514	401	etc	etc	FW
18637	18514	402	.	.	.
18637	18515	1	1081	1081	CD
18637	18515	2	Actions	action	NNS
18637	18515	3	in	in	IN
18637	18515	4	rem	rem	NN
18637	18515	5	--	--	:
18637	18515	6	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	18515	7	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18515	8	1083	1083	CD
18637	18515	9	Misnomer	Misnomer	NNP
18637	18515	10	of	of	IN
18637	18515	11	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	18515	12	--	--	:
18637	18515	13	false	false	JJ
18637	18515	14	return	return	NN
18637	18515	15	,	,	,
18637	18515	16	etc	etc	FW
18637	18515	17	.	.	.
18637	18516	1	1083	1083	CD
18637	18516	2	Notice	notice	NN
18637	18516	3	and	and	CC
18637	18516	4	hearing	hear	VBG
18637	18516	5	1084	1084	CD
18637	18516	6	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18516	7	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18516	8	1084	1084	CD
18637	18516	9	Administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	18516	10	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18516	11	1084	1084	CD
18637	18516	12	Statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	18516	13	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18516	14	1087	1087	CD
18637	18516	15	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18516	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18516	17	1087	1087	CD
18637	18516	18	Sufficiency	Sufficiency	NNP
18637	18516	19	of	of	IN
18637	18516	20	notice	notice	NN
18637	18516	21	and	and	CC
18637	18516	22	hearing	hear	VBG
18637	18516	23	1088	1088	CD
18637	18516	24	Power	Power	NNP
18637	18516	25	of	of	IN
18637	18516	26	States	States	NNPS
18637	18516	27	to	to	TO
18637	18516	28	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	18516	29	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	18516	30	1089	1089	CD
18637	18516	31	Generally	generally	RB
18637	18516	32	1089	1089	CD
18637	18516	33	Pleading	pleading	NN
18637	18516	34	and	and	CC
18637	18516	35	practice	practice	NN
18637	18516	36	1089	1089	CD
18637	18516	37	Commencement	commencement	NN
18637	18516	38	of	of	IN
18637	18516	39	actions	action	NNS
18637	18516	40	1089	1089	CD
18637	18516	41	Pleas	Pleas	NNPS
18637	18516	42	in	in	IN
18637	18516	43	abatement	abatement	NN
18637	18516	44	1090	1090	CD
18637	18516	45	Defenses	defense	NNS
18637	18516	46	1090	1090	CD
18637	18516	47	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	18516	48	and	and	CC
18637	18516	49	continuances	continuance	NNS
18637	18516	50	1091	1091	CD
18637	18516	51	Costs	cost	NNS
18637	18516	52	,	,	,
18637	18516	53	damages	damage	NNS
18637	18516	54	,	,	,
18637	18516	55	and	and	CC
18637	18516	56	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	18516	57	1091	1091	CD
18637	18516	58	Statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18516	59	of	of	IN
18637	18516	60	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	18516	61	1092	1092	CD
18637	18516	62	Evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18516	63	and	and	CC
18637	18516	64	presumptions	presumption	NNS
18637	18516	65	1093	1093	CD
18637	18516	66	Jury	jury	NN
18637	18516	67	trials	trial	NNS
18637	18516	68	:	:	:
18637	18516	69	dispensing	dispense	VBG
18637	18516	70	with	with	IN
18637	18516	71	trials	trial	NNS
18637	18516	72	1096	1096	CD
18637	18516	73	Due	due	IN
18637	18516	74	process	process	NN
18637	18516	75	in	in	IN
18637	18516	76	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	18516	77	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18516	78	1096	1096	CD
18637	18516	79	General	General	NNP
18637	18516	80	1096	1096	CD
18637	18516	81	Indefinite	Indefinite	NNP
18637	18516	82	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18516	83	:	:	:
18637	18516	84	right	right	RB
18637	18516	85	of	of	IN
18637	18516	86	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	18516	87	to	to	IN
18637	18516	88	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	18516	89	of	of	IN
18637	18516	90	offense	offense	NN
18637	18516	91	1097	1097	CD
18637	18516	92	Abolition	Abolition	NNP
18637	18516	93	of	of	IN
18637	18516	94	the	the	DT
18637	18516	95	grand	grand	JJ
18637	18516	96	jury	jury	NN
18637	18516	97	1098	1098	CD
18637	18516	98	Right	right	JJ
18637	18516	99	to	to	TO
18637	18516	100	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	18516	101	1098	1098	CD
18637	18516	102	Right	right	UH
18637	18516	103	to	to	IN
18637	18516	104	trial	trial	NN
18637	18516	105	by	by	IN
18637	18516	106	jury	jury	NN
18637	18516	107	1109	1109	CD
18637	18516	108	Self	self	NN
18637	18516	109	-	-	HYPH
18637	18516	110	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	18516	111	:	:	:
18637	18516	112	forced	force	VBN
18637	18516	113	confessions	confession	NNS
18637	18516	114	1111	1111	CD
18637	18516	115	Unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18516	116	searches	search	NNS
18637	18516	117	and	and	CC
18637	18516	118	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	18516	119	1121	1121	CD
18637	18516	120	Conviction	Conviction	NNP
18637	18516	121	based	base	VBN
18637	18516	122	on	on	IN
18637	18516	123	perjured	perjured	JJ
18637	18516	124	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	18516	125	1124	1124	CD
18637	18516	126	Confrontation	confrontation	NN
18637	18516	127	:	:	:
18637	18516	128	presence	presence	NN
18637	18516	129	of	of	IN
18637	18516	130	the	the	DT
18637	18516	131	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	18516	132	;	;	:
18637	18516	133	public	public	JJ
18637	18516	134	trial	trial	NN
18637	18516	135	1126	1126	CD
18637	18516	136	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	18516	137	by	by	IN
18637	18516	138	impartial	impartial	JJ
18637	18516	139	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	18516	140	1131	1131	CD
18637	18516	141	Other	other	JJ
18637	18516	142	attributes	attribute	NNS
18637	18516	143	of	of	IN
18637	18516	144	a	a	DT
18637	18516	145	fair	fair	JJ
18637	18516	146	trial	trial	NN
18637	18516	147	1132	1132	CD
18637	18516	148	Excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	18516	149	bail	bail	NN
18637	18516	150	,	,	,
18637	18516	151	cruel	cruel	JJ
18637	18516	152	and	and	CC
18637	18516	153	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	18516	154	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	18516	155	,	,	,
18637	18516	156	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	18516	157	1133	1133	CD
18637	18516	158	Double	double	JJ
18637	18516	159	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	18516	160	1135	1135	CD
18637	18516	161	Rights	right	NNS
18637	18516	162	of	of	IN
18637	18516	163	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
18637	18516	164	1137	1137	CD
18637	18516	165	Access	access	NN
18637	18516	166	to	to	IN
18637	18516	167	the	the	DT
18637	18516	168	courts	court	NNS
18637	18516	169	1137	1137	CD
18637	18516	170	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	18516	171	:	:	:
18637	18516	172	corrective	corrective	JJ
18637	18516	173	process	process	NN
18637	18516	174	1137	1137	CD
18637	18516	175	Due	due	JJ
18637	18516	176	process	process	NN
18637	18516	177	:	:	:
18637	18516	178	miscellaneous	miscellaneous	JJ
18637	18516	179	1139	1139	CD
18637	18516	180	Appeals	Appeals	NNP
18637	18516	181	1139	1139	CD
18637	18516	182	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18516	183	review	review	NN
18637	18516	184	of	of	IN
18637	18516	185	State	State	NNP
18637	18516	186	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	18516	187	1140	1140	CD
18637	18516	188	Equal	equal	JJ
18637	18516	189	protection	protection	NN
18637	18516	190	of	of	IN
18637	18516	191	the	the	DT
18637	18516	192	laws	law	NNS
18637	18516	193	1141	1141	CD
18637	18516	194	Definition	definition	NN
18637	18516	195	of	of	IN
18637	18516	196	terms	term	NNS
18637	18516	197	1141	1141	CD
18637	18516	198	What	what	WP
18637	18516	199	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	18516	200	State	state	NN
18637	18516	201	action	action	NN
18637	18516	202	1141	1141	CD
18637	18516	203	"	"	``
18637	18516	204	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	18516	205	"	"	``
18637	18516	206	1142	1142	CD
18637	18516	207	"	"	''
18637	18516	208	Within	within	IN
18637	18516	209	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18516	210	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18516	211	"	"	``
18637	18516	212	1143	1143	CD
18637	18516	213	"	"	''
18637	18516	214	Equal	equal	JJ
18637	18516	215	protection	protection	NN
18637	18516	216	of	of	IN
18637	18516	217	the	the	DT
18637	18516	218	laws	law	NNS
18637	18516	219	"	"	''
18637	18516	220	1144	1144	CD
18637	18516	221	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18516	222	classifications	classification	NNS
18637	18516	223	1145	1145	CD
18637	18516	224	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	18516	225	1146	1146	CD
18637	18516	226	Classifications	classification	NNS
18637	18516	227	for	for	IN
18637	18516	228	the	the	DT
18637	18516	229	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18516	230	of	of	IN
18637	18516	231	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	18516	232	1147	1147	CD
18637	18516	233	Foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18516	234	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18516	235	1149	1149	CD
18637	18516	236	Income	income	NN
18637	18516	237	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18516	238	1150	1150	CD
18637	18516	239	Inheritance	Inheritance	NNP
18637	18516	240	taxes	tax	VBZ
18637	18516	241	1150	1150	CD
18637	18516	242	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	18516	243	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	18516	244	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18516	245	1151	1151	CD
18637	18516	246	Poll	Poll	NNP
18637	18516	247	taxes	tax	VBZ
18637	18516	248	1152	1152	CD
18637	18516	249	Property	property	NN
18637	18516	250	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18516	251	1152	1152	CD
18637	18516	252	Special	special	JJ
18637	18516	253	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	18516	254	1152	1152	CD
18637	18516	255	Police	police	NN
18637	18516	256	power	power	NN
18637	18516	257	1153	1153	CD
18637	18516	258	Classification	classification	NN
18637	18516	259	1153	1153	CD
18637	18516	260	Administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	18516	261	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	18516	262	1157	1157	CD
18637	18516	263	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	18516	264	laws	law	NNS
18637	18516	265	1157	1157	CD
18637	18516	266	Labor	labor	NN
18637	18516	267	relations	relation	NNS
18637	18516	268	1158	1158	CD
18637	18516	269	Monopolies	monopolies	NN
18637	18516	270	1160	1160	CD
18637	18516	271	Punishment	punishment	NN
18637	18516	272	for	for	IN
18637	18516	273	crime	crime	NN
18637	18516	274	1160	1160	CD
18637	18516	275	Segregation	segregation	NN
18637	18516	276	1161	1161	CD
18637	18516	277	Political	political	JJ
18637	18516	278	rights	right	NNS
18637	18516	279	1163	1163	CD
18637	18516	280	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	18516	281	1165	1165	CD
18637	18516	282	General	general	JJ
18637	18516	283	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	18516	284	1165	1165	CD
18637	18516	285	Access	Access	NNP
18637	18516	286	to	to	IN
18637	18516	287	courts	court	NNS
18637	18516	288	1166	1166	CD
18637	18516	289	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18516	290	1166	1166	CD
18637	18516	291	Expenses	expense	NNS
18637	18516	292	of	of	IN
18637	18516	293	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	18516	294	1167	1167	CD
18637	18516	295	Selection	Selection	NNP
18637	18516	296	of	of	IN
18637	18516	297	jury	jury	NN
18637	18516	298	1167	1167	CD
18637	18516	299	Section	Section	NNP
18637	18516	300	2	2	CD
18637	18516	301	.	.	.
18637	18517	1	Apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	18517	2	of	of	IN
18637	18517	3	representation	representation	NN
18637	18517	4	1170	1170	CD
18637	18517	5	In	in	IN
18637	18517	6	general	general	JJ
18637	18517	7	1171	1171	CD
18637	18517	8	"	"	``
18637	18517	9	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	18517	10	not	not	RB
18637	18517	11	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	18517	12	"	"	''
18637	18517	13	1171	1171	CD
18637	18517	14	Right	right	UH
18637	18517	15	to	to	TO
18637	18517	16	vote	vote	VB
18637	18517	17	1172	1172	CD
18637	18517	18	Reduction	Reduction	NNP
18637	18517	19	of	of	IN
18637	18517	20	State	State	NNP
18637	18517	21	's	's	POS
18637	18517	22	representation	representation	NN
18637	18517	23	1172	1172	CD
18637	18517	24	Section	Section	NNP
18637	18517	25	3	3	CD
18637	18517	26	.	.	.
18637	18518	1	Disqualification	disqualification	NN
18637	18518	2	of	of	IN
18637	18518	3	officers	officer	NNS
18637	18518	4	1173	1173	CD
18637	18518	5	In	in	IN
18637	18518	6	general	general	JJ
18637	18518	7	1173	1173	CD
18637	18518	8	Section	Section	NNP
18637	18518	9	4	4	CD
18637	18518	10	.	.	.
18637	18519	1	Public	public	JJ
18637	18519	2	debt	debt	NN
18637	18519	3	,	,	,
18637	18519	4	etc	etc	FW
18637	18519	5	.	.	.
18637	18520	1	1174	1174	CD
18637	18520	2	Section	Section	NNP
18637	18520	3	5	5	CD
18637	18520	4	.	.	.
18637	18521	1	Enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18521	2	1175	1175	CD
18637	18521	3	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	18521	4	of	of	IN
18637	18521	5	the	the	DT
18637	18521	6	provision	provision	NN
18637	18521	7	1175	1175	CD
18637	18521	8	RIGHTS	right	NNS
18637	18521	9	OF	of	IN
18637	18521	10	CITIZENS	CITIZENS	NNP
18637	18521	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18521	12	14	14	CD
18637	18521	13	Section	Section	NNP
18637	18521	14	1	1	CD
18637	18521	15	.	.	.
18637	18522	1	All	all	DT
18637	18522	2	persons	person	NNS
18637	18522	3	born	bear	VBN
18637	18522	4	or	or	CC
18637	18522	5	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	18522	6	in	in	IN
18637	18522	7	the	the	DT
18637	18522	8	United	United	NNP
18637	18522	9	States	States	NNP
18637	18522	10	,	,	,
18637	18522	11	and	and	CC
18637	18522	12	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18522	13	to	to	IN
18637	18522	14	the	the	DT
18637	18522	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18522	16	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18522	17	,	,	,
18637	18522	18	are	be	VBP
18637	18522	19	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18522	20	of	of	IN
18637	18522	21	the	the	DT
18637	18522	22	United	United	NNP
18637	18522	23	States	States	NNP
18637	18522	24	and	and	CC
18637	18522	25	of	of	IN
18637	18522	26	the	the	DT
18637	18522	27	State	State	NNP
18637	18522	28	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	18522	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18522	30	reside	reside	VBP
18637	18522	31	.	.	.
18637	18523	1	No	no	DT
18637	18523	2	State	state	NN
18637	18523	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	18523	4	make	make	VB
18637	18523	5	or	or	CC
18637	18523	6	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	18523	7	any	any	DT
18637	18523	8	law	law	NN
18637	18523	9	which	which	WDT
18637	18523	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	18523	11	abridge	abridge	VB
18637	18523	12	the	the	DT
18637	18523	13	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18523	14	or	or	CC
18637	18523	15	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	18523	16	of	of	IN
18637	18523	17	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18523	18	of	of	IN
18637	18523	19	the	the	DT
18637	18523	20	United	United	NNP
18637	18523	21	States	States	NNP
18637	18523	22	;	;	:
18637	18523	23	nor	nor	CC
18637	18523	24	shall	shall	MD
18637	18523	25	any	any	DT
18637	18523	26	State	state	NN
18637	18523	27	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	18523	28	any	any	DT
18637	18523	29	person	person	NN
18637	18523	30	of	of	IN
18637	18523	31	life	life	NN
18637	18523	32	,	,	,
18637	18523	33	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18523	34	,	,	,
18637	18523	35	or	or	CC
18637	18523	36	property	property	NN
18637	18523	37	,	,	,
18637	18523	38	without	without	IN
18637	18523	39	due	due	JJ
18637	18523	40	process	process	NN
18637	18523	41	of	of	IN
18637	18523	42	law	law	NN
18637	18523	43	;	;	:
18637	18523	44	nor	nor	CC
18637	18523	45	deny	deny	VB
18637	18523	46	to	to	IN
18637	18523	47	any	any	DT
18637	18523	48	person	person	NN
18637	18523	49	within	within	IN
18637	18523	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18523	51	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18523	52	the	the	DT
18637	18523	53	equal	equal	JJ
18637	18523	54	protection	protection	NN
18637	18523	55	of	of	IN
18637	18523	56	the	the	DT
18637	18523	57	laws	law	NNS
18637	18523	58	.	.	.
18637	18524	1	Citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18524	2	of	of	IN
18637	18524	3	the	the	DT
18637	18524	4	United	United	NNP
18637	18524	5	States	States	NNP
18637	18524	6	KIND	KIND	NNP
18637	18524	7	AND	and	CC
18637	18524	8	SOURCES	source	NNS
18637	18524	9	OF	of	IN
18637	18524	10	CITIZENSHIP	CITIZENSHIP	NNP
18637	18524	11	There	there	EX
18637	18524	12	are	be	VBP
18637	18524	13	three	three	CD
18637	18524	14	categories	category	NNS
18637	18524	15	of	of	IN
18637	18524	16	persons	person	NNS
18637	18524	17	who	who	WP
18637	18524	18	,	,	,
18637	18524	19	if	if	IN
18637	18524	20	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18524	21	to	to	IN
18637	18524	22	the	the	DT
18637	18524	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18524	24	of	of	IN
18637	18524	25	the	the	DT
18637	18524	26	United	United	NNP
18637	18524	27	States	States	NNP
18637	18524	28	,	,	,
18637	18524	29	are	be	VBP
18637	18524	30	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18524	31	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18524	32	:	:	:
18637	18524	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18524	34	1	1	LS
18637	18524	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18524	36	those	those	DT
18637	18524	37	who	who	WP
18637	18524	38	are	be	VBP
18637	18524	39	born	bear	VBN
18637	18524	40	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18524	41	,	,	,
18637	18524	42	of	of	IN
18637	18524	43	whom	whom	WP
18637	18524	44	there	there	EX
18637	18524	45	are	be	VBP
18637	18524	46	two	two	CD
18637	18524	47	classes	class	NNS
18637	18524	48	,	,	,
18637	18524	49	those	those	DT
18637	18524	50	who	who	WP
18637	18524	51	are	be	VBP
18637	18524	52	born	bear	VBN
18637	18524	53	in	in	IN
18637	18524	54	the	the	DT
18637	18524	55	United	United	NNP
18637	18524	56	States	States	NNP
18637	18524	57	and	and	CC
18637	18524	58	those	those	DT
18637	18524	59	who	who	WP
18637	18524	60	are	be	VBP
18637	18524	61	born	bear	VBN
18637	18524	62	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	18524	63	of	of	IN
18637	18524	64	American	american	JJ
18637	18524	65	parentage	parentage	NN
18637	18524	66	;	;	:
18637	18524	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18524	68	2	2	LS
18637	18524	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18524	70	those	those	DT
18637	18524	71	who	who	WP
18637	18524	72	achieve	achieve	VBP
18637	18524	73	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18524	74	by	by	IN
18637	18524	75	qualifying	qualify	VBG
18637	18524	76	for	for	IN
18637	18524	77	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18524	78	in	in	IN
18637	18524	79	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	18524	80	with	with	IN
18637	18524	81	the	the	DT
18637	18524	82	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	18524	83	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18524	84	;	;	:
18637	18524	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18524	86	3	3	LS
18637	18524	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18524	88	those	those	DT
18637	18524	89	who	who	WP
18637	18524	90	have	have	VBP
18637	18524	91	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18524	92	thrust	thrust	VBN
18637	18524	93	upon	upon	IN
18637	18524	94	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18524	95	,	,	,
18637	18524	96	such	such	JJ
18637	18524	97	as	as	IN
18637	18524	98	the	the	DT
18637	18524	99	members	member	NNS
18637	18524	100	of	of	IN
18637	18524	101	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18524	102	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	18524	103	tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	18524	104	and	and	CC
18637	18524	105	the	the	DT
18637	18524	106	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	18524	107	of	of	IN
18637	18524	108	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18524	109	dependencies	dependency	NNS
18637	18524	110	of	of	IN
18637	18524	111	the	the	DT
18637	18524	112	United	United	NNP
18637	18524	113	States	States	NNP
18637	18524	114	.	.	.
18637	18525	1	In	in	IN
18637	18525	2	the	the	DT
18637	18525	3	present	present	JJ
18637	18525	4	connection	connection	NN
18637	18525	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18525	6	are	be	VBP
18637	18525	7	interested	interested	JJ
18637	18525	8	in	in	IN
18637	18525	9	those	those	DT
18637	18525	10	who	who	WP
18637	18525	11	are	be	VBP
18637	18525	12	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18525	13	by	by	IN
18637	18525	14	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	18525	15	of	of	IN
18637	18525	16	birth	birth	NN
18637	18525	17	in	in	IN
18637	18525	18	the	the	DT
18637	18525	19	United	United	NNP
18637	18525	20	States	States	NNP
18637	18525	21	.	.	.
18637	18526	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18526	2	1	1	LS
18637	18526	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18526	4	HISTORY	history	NN
18637	18526	5	In	in	IN
18637	18526	6	the	the	DT
18637	18526	7	famous	famous	JJ
18637	18526	8	Dred	Dred	NNP
18637	18526	9	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	18526	10	Case,[2	Case,[2	NNP
18637	18526	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18526	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	18526	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18526	14	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	18526	15	had	have	VBD
18637	18526	16	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	18526	17	that	that	IN
18637	18526	18	United	United	NNP
18637	18526	19	States	States	NNP
18637	18526	20	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18526	21	was	be	VBD
18637	18526	22	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
18637	18526	23	by	by	IN
18637	18526	24	two	two	CD
18637	18526	25	classes	class	NNS
18637	18526	26	of	of	IN
18637	18526	27	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	18526	28	:	:	:
18637	18526	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18526	30	1	1	LS
18637	18526	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18526	32	white	white	JJ
18637	18526	33	persons	person	NNS
18637	18526	34	born	bear	VBN
18637	18526	35	in	in	IN
18637	18526	36	the	the	DT
18637	18526	37	United	United	NNP
18637	18526	38	States	States	NNP
18637	18526	39	as	as	IN
18637	18526	40	descendants	descendant	NNS
18637	18526	41	of	of	IN
18637	18526	42	"	"	``
18637	18526	43	persons	person	NNS
18637	18526	44	,	,	,
18637	18526	45	who	who	WP
18637	18526	46	were	be	VBD
18637	18526	47	at	at	IN
18637	18526	48	the	the	DT
18637	18526	49	time	time	NN
18637	18526	50	of	of	IN
18637	18526	51	the	the	DT
18637	18526	52	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	18526	53	of	of	IN
18637	18526	54	the	the	DT
18637	18526	55	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18526	56	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	18526	57	as	as	IN
18637	18526	58	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18526	59	in	in	IN
18637	18526	60	the	the	DT
18637	18526	61	several	several	JJ
18637	18526	62	States	state	NNS
18637	18526	63	and	and	CC
18637	18526	64	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18526	65	who	who	WP
18637	18526	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18526	67	became	become	VBD
18637	18526	68	also	also	RB
18637	18526	69	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18526	70	of	of	IN
18637	18526	71	this	this	DT
18637	18526	72	new	new	JJ
18637	18526	73	political	political	JJ
18637	18526	74	body	body	NN
18637	18526	75	,	,	,
18637	18526	76	"	"	''
18637	18526	77	the	the	DT
18637	18526	78	United	United	NNP
18637	18526	79	States	States	NNP
18637	18526	80	of	of	IN
18637	18526	81	America	America	NNP
18637	18526	82	,	,	,
18637	18526	83	and	and	CC
18637	18526	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18526	85	2	2	LS
18637	18526	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18526	87	those	those	DT
18637	18526	88	who	who	WP
18637	18526	89	,	,	,
18637	18526	90	having	have	VBG
18637	18526	91	been	be	VBN
18637	18526	92	"	"	``
18637	18526	93	born	bear	VBN
18637	18526	94	outside	outside	IN
18637	18526	95	the	the	DT
18637	18526	96	dominions	dominion	NNS
18637	18526	97	of	of	IN
18637	18526	98	the	the	DT
18637	18526	99	United	United	NNP
18637	18526	100	States	States	NNP
18637	18526	101	,	,	,
18637	18526	102	"	"	''
18637	18526	103	had	have	VBD
18637	18526	104	migrated	migrate	VBN
18637	18526	105	thereto	thereto	NNP
18637	18526	106	and	and	CC
18637	18526	107	been	be	VBN
18637	18526	108	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	18526	109	therein	therein	RB
18637	18526	110	.	.	.
18637	18527	1	The	the	DT
18637	18527	2	States	States	NNPS
18637	18527	3	were	be	VBD
18637	18527	4	competent	competent	JJ
18637	18527	5	,	,	,
18637	18527	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18527	7	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	18527	8	,	,	,
18637	18527	9	to	to	TO
18637	18527	10	confer	confer	VB
18637	18527	11	State	State	NNP
18637	18527	12	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18527	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	18527	14	anyone	anyone	NN
18637	18527	15	in	in	IN
18637	18527	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18527	17	midst	midst	NN
18637	18527	18	,	,	,
18637	18527	19	but	but	CC
18637	18527	20	could	could	MD
18637	18527	21	not	not	RB
18637	18527	22	make	make	VB
18637	18527	23	the	the	DT
18637	18527	24	recipient	recipient	NN
18637	18527	25	of	of	IN
18637	18527	26	such	such	JJ
18637	18527	27	status	status	NN
18637	18527	28	a	a	DT
18637	18527	29	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18527	30	of	of	IN
18637	18527	31	the	the	DT
18637	18527	32	United	United	NNP
18637	18527	33	States	States	NNP
18637	18527	34	.	.	.
18637	18528	1	The	the	DT
18637	18528	2	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	18528	3	,	,	,
18637	18528	4	however	however	RB
18637	18528	5	,	,	,
18637	18528	6	according	accord	VBG
18637	18528	7	to	to	IN
18637	18528	8	the	the	DT
18637	18528	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	18528	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18528	11	,	,	,
18637	18528	12	was	be	VBD
18637	18528	13	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	18528	14	to	to	TO
18637	18528	15	attain	attain	VB
18637	18528	16	United	United	NNP
18637	18528	17	States	States	NNP
18637	18528	18	citizenship	citizenship	VB
18637	18528	19	either	either	CC
18637	18528	20	from	from	IN
18637	18528	21	a	a	DT
18637	18528	22	State	state	NN
18637	18528	23	or	or	CC
18637	18528	24	by	by	IN
18637	18528	25	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	18528	26	of	of	IN
18637	18528	27	birth	birth	NN
18637	18528	28	in	in	IN
18637	18528	29	the	the	DT
18637	18528	30	United	United	NNP
18637	18528	31	States	States	NNP
18637	18528	32	,	,	,
18637	18528	33	even	even	RB
18637	18528	34	as	as	IN
18637	18528	35	a	a	DT
18637	18528	36	free	free	JJ
18637	18528	37	man	man	NN
18637	18528	38	descended	descend	VBD
18637	18528	39	from	from	IN
18637	18528	40	a	a	DT
18637	18528	41	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	18528	42	residing	reside	VBG
18637	18528	43	as	as	IN
18637	18528	44	a	a	DT
18637	18528	45	free	free	JJ
18637	18528	46	man	man	NN
18637	18528	47	in	in	IN
18637	18528	48	one	one	CD
18637	18528	49	of	of	IN
18637	18528	50	the	the	DT
18637	18528	51	States	States	NNPS
18637	18528	52	at	at	IN
18637	18528	53	the	the	DT
18637	18528	54	date	date	NN
18637	18528	55	of	of	IN
18637	18528	56	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	18528	57	of	of	IN
18637	18528	58	the	the	DT
18637	18528	59	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18528	60	.	.	.
18637	18529	1	That	that	DT
18637	18529	2	basic	basic	JJ
18637	18529	3	document	document	NN
18637	18529	4	did	do	VBD
18637	18529	5	not	not	RB
18637	18529	6	contemplate	contemplate	VB
18637	18529	7	the	the	DT
18637	18529	8	possibility	possibility	NN
18637	18529	9	of	of	IN
18637	18529	10	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	18529	11	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18529	12	.	.	.
18637	18530	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18530	2	3	3	LS
18637	18530	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18530	4	By	by	IN
18637	18530	5	the	the	DT
18637	18530	6	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18530	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18530	8	this	this	DT
18637	18530	9	deficiency	deficiency	NN
18637	18530	10	of	of	IN
18637	18530	11	the	the	DT
18637	18530	12	original	original	JJ
18637	18530	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18530	14	was	be	VBD
18637	18530	15	cured	cure	VBN
18637	18530	16	.	.	.
18637	18531	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18531	2	4	4	LS
18637	18531	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18531	4	JUDICIAL	judicial	NN
18637	18531	5	ELUCIDATION	ELUCIDATION	NNP
18637	18531	6	OF	of	IN
18637	18531	7	THE	the	DT
18637	18531	8	CITIZENSHIP	CITIZENSHIP	NNP
18637	18531	9	CLAUSE	CLAUSE	NNP
18637	18531	10	By	by	IN
18637	18531	11	the	the	DT
18637	18531	12	decision	decision	NN
18637	18531	13	in	in	IN
18637	18531	14	1898	1898	CD
18637	18531	15	in	in	IN
18637	18531	16	United	United	NNP
18637	18531	17	States	States	NNP
18637	18531	18	_	_	NNP
18637	18531	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	18531	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18531	21	Wong	Wong	NNP
18637	18531	22	Kim	Kim	NNP
18637	18531	23	Ark,[5	Ark,[5	NNP
18637	18531	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18531	25	all	all	DT
18637	18531	26	children	child	NNS
18637	18531	27	born	bear	VBN
18637	18531	28	in	in	IN
18637	18531	29	the	the	DT
18637	18531	30	United	United	NNP
18637	18531	31	States	States	NNP
18637	18531	32	to	to	IN
18637	18531	33	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	18531	34	,	,	,
18637	18531	35	even	even	RB
18637	18531	36	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	18531	37	sojourners	sojourner	NNS
18637	18531	38	,	,	,
18637	18531	39	if	if	IN
18637	18531	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18531	41	are	be	VBP
18637	18531	42	not	not	RB
18637	18531	43	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	18531	44	from	from	IN
18637	18531	45	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	18531	46	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18531	47	,	,	,
18637	18531	48	are	be	VBP
18637	18531	49	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18531	50	irrespective	irrespective	JJ
18637	18531	51	of	of	IN
18637	18531	52	race	race	NN
18637	18531	53	or	or	CC
18637	18531	54	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	18531	55	.	.	.
18637	18532	1	But	but	CC
18637	18532	2	children	child	NNS
18637	18532	3	born	bear	VBN
18637	18532	4	in	in	IN
18637	18532	5	the	the	DT
18637	18532	6	United	United	NNP
18637	18532	7	States	States	NNP
18637	18532	8	to	to	TO
18637	18532	9	alien	alien	VB
18637	18532	10	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	18532	11	in	in	IN
18637	18532	12	hostile	hostile	JJ
18637	18532	13	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	18532	14	or	or	CC
18637	18532	15	to	to	IN
18637	18532	16	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	18532	17	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	18532	18	of	of	IN
18637	18532	19	a	a	DT
18637	18532	20	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18532	21	state	state	NN
18637	18532	22	,	,	,
18637	18532	23	not	not	RB
18637	18532	24	being	be	VBG
18637	18532	25	"	"	``
18637	18532	26	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18532	27	to	to	IN
18637	18532	28	the	the	DT
18637	18532	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18532	30	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18532	31	,	,	,
18637	18532	32	"	"	''
18637	18532	33	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	18532	34	,	,	,
18637	18532	35	of	of	IN
18637	18532	36	the	the	DT
18637	18532	37	United	United	NNP
18637	18532	38	States	States	NNP
18637	18532	39	,	,	,
18637	18532	40	are	be	VBP
18637	18532	41	not	not	RB
18637	18532	42	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18532	43	.	.	.
18637	18533	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18533	2	6	6	CD
18637	18533	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18533	4	Likewise	Likewise	NNP
18637	18533	5	persons	person	NNS
18637	18533	6	born	bear	VBN
18637	18533	7	on	on	IN
18637	18533	8	a	a	DT
18637	18533	9	public	public	JJ
18637	18533	10	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	18533	11	of	of	IN
18637	18533	12	a	a	DT
18637	18533	13	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18533	14	country	country	NN
18637	18533	15	while	while	IN
18637	18533	16	within	within	IN
18637	18533	17	the	the	DT
18637	18533	18	waters	water	NNS
18637	18533	19	of	of	IN
18637	18533	20	the	the	DT
18637	18533	21	United	United	NNP
18637	18533	22	States	States	NNP
18637	18533	23	are	be	VBP
18637	18533	24	not	not	RB
18637	18533	25	considered	consider	VBN
18637	18533	26	as	as	IN
18637	18533	27	having	have	VBG
18637	18533	28	been	be	VBN
18637	18533	29	born	bear	VBN
18637	18533	30	within	within	IN
18637	18533	31	the	the	DT
18637	18533	32	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18533	33	of	of	IN
18637	18533	34	the	the	DT
18637	18533	35	United	United	NNP
18637	18533	36	States	States	NNP
18637	18533	37	,	,	,
18637	18533	38	and	and	CC
18637	18533	39	hence	hence	RB
18637	18533	40	are	be	VBP
18637	18533	41	not	not	RB
18637	18533	42	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18533	43	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18533	44	.	.	.
18637	18534	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18534	2	7	7	CD
18637	18534	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18534	4	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	18534	5	,	,	,
18637	18534	6	a	a	DT
18637	18534	7	Chinese	Chinese	NNPS
18637	18534	8	born	bear	VBN
18637	18534	9	on	on	IN
18637	18534	10	the	the	DT
18637	18534	11	high	high	JJ
18637	18534	12	seas	sea	NNS
18637	18534	13	aboard	aboard	IN
18637	18534	14	an	an	DT
18637	18534	15	American	american	JJ
18637	18534	16	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	18534	17	of	of	IN
18637	18534	18	Chinese	chinese	JJ
18637	18534	19	parents	parent	NNS
18637	18534	20	residing	reside	VBG
18637	18534	21	in	in	IN
18637	18534	22	the	the	DT
18637	18534	23	United	United	NNP
18637	18534	24	States	States	NNP
18637	18534	25	was	be	VBD
18637	18534	26	declared	declare	VBN
18637	18534	27	not	not	RB
18637	18534	28	to	to	TO
18637	18534	29	be	be	VB
18637	18534	30	a	a	DT
18637	18534	31	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18534	32	on	on	IN
18637	18534	33	the	the	DT
18637	18534	34	ground	ground	NN
18637	18534	35	of	of	IN
18637	18534	36	not	not	RB
18637	18534	37	having	have	VBG
18637	18534	38	been	be	VBN
18637	18534	39	born	bear	VBN
18637	18534	40	"	"	''
18637	18534	41	in	in	IN
18637	18534	42	the	the	DT
18637	18534	43	United	United	NNP
18637	18534	44	States	States	NNP
18637	18534	45	.	.	.
18637	18535	1	"	"	``
18637	18535	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18535	3	8	8	CD
18637	18535	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18535	5	But	but	CC
18637	18535	6	a	a	DT
18637	18535	7	child	child	NN
18637	18535	8	who	who	WP
18637	18535	9	was	be	VBD
18637	18535	10	born	bear	VBN
18637	18535	11	in	in	IN
18637	18535	12	like	like	IN
18637	18535	13	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	18535	14	of	of	IN
18637	18535	15	parents	parent	NNS
18637	18535	16	who	who	WP
18637	18535	17	were	be	VBD
18637	18535	18	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18535	19	of	of	IN
18637	18535	20	the	the	DT
18637	18535	21	United	United	NNP
18637	18535	22	States	States	NNP
18637	18535	23	was	be	VBD
18637	18535	24	declared	declare	VBN
18637	18535	25	,	,	,
18637	18535	26	shortly	shortly	RB
18637	18535	27	before	before	IN
18637	18535	28	the	the	DT
18637	18535	29	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	18535	30	War	War	NNP
18637	18535	31	,	,	,
18637	18535	32	to	to	TO
18637	18535	33	be	be	VB
18637	18535	34	a	a	DT
18637	18535	35	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18535	36	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18535	37	.	.	.
18637	18536	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18536	2	9	9	CD
18637	18536	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18536	4	NATIONAL	NATIONAL	NNP
18637	18536	5	AND	and	CC
18637	18536	6	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	18536	7	CITIZENSHIP	citizenship	VBP
18637	18536	8	With	with	IN
18637	18536	9	the	the	DT
18637	18536	10	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	18536	11	of	of	IN
18637	18536	12	the	the	DT
18637	18536	13	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18536	14	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18536	15	a	a	DT
18637	18536	16	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	18536	17	between	between	IN
18637	18536	18	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18536	19	of	of	IN
18637	18536	20	the	the	DT
18637	18536	21	United	United	NNP
18637	18536	22	States	States	NNP
18637	18536	23	and	and	CC
18637	18536	24	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18536	25	of	of	IN
18637	18536	26	a	a	DT
18637	18536	27	State	State	NNP
18637	18536	28	was	be	VBD
18637	18536	29	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	18536	30	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	18536	31	and	and	CC
18637	18536	32	established	establish	VBN
18637	18536	33	.	.	.
18637	18537	1	"	"	``
18637	18537	2	Not	not	RB
18637	18537	3	only	only	RB
18637	18537	4	may	may	MD
18637	18537	5	a	a	DT
18637	18537	6	man	man	NN
18637	18537	7	be	be	VB
18637	18537	8	a	a	DT
18637	18537	9	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18537	10	of	of	IN
18637	18537	11	the	the	DT
18637	18537	12	United	United	NNP
18637	18537	13	States	States	NNP
18637	18537	14	without	without	IN
18637	18537	15	being	be	VBG
18637	18537	16	a	a	DT
18637	18537	17	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18537	18	of	of	IN
18637	18537	19	a	a	DT
18637	18537	20	State	State	NNP
18637	18537	21	,	,	,
18637	18537	22	but	but	CC
18637	18537	23	an	an	DT
18637	18537	24	important	important	JJ
18637	18537	25	element	element	NN
18637	18537	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	18537	27	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18537	28	to	to	TO
18637	18537	29	convert	convert	VB
18637	18537	30	the	the	DT
18637	18537	31	former	former	JJ
18637	18537	32	into	into	IN
18637	18537	33	the	the	DT
18637	18537	34	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18537	35	.	.	.
18637	18538	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18538	2	must	must	MD
18637	18538	3	reside	reside	VB
18637	18538	4	within	within	IN
18637	18538	5	the	the	DT
18637	18538	6	State	State	NNP
18637	18538	7	to	to	TO
18637	18538	8	make	make	VB
18637	18538	9	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18538	10	a	a	DT
18637	18538	11	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18538	12	of	of	IN
18637	18538	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18538	14	,	,	,
18637	18538	15	but	but	CC
18637	18538	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18538	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	18538	18	only	only	RB
18637	18538	19	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18538	20	that	that	IN
18637	18538	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18538	22	should	should	MD
18637	18538	23	be	be	VB
18637	18538	24	born	bear	VBN
18637	18538	25	or	or	CC
18637	18538	26	naturalized	naturalize	VBN
18637	18538	27	in	in	IN
18637	18538	28	the	the	DT
18637	18538	29	United	United	NNP
18637	18538	30	States	States	NNP
18637	18538	31	to	to	TO
18637	18538	32	be	be	VB
18637	18538	33	a	a	DT
18637	18538	34	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18538	35	of	of	IN
18637	18538	36	the	the	DT
18637	18538	37	Union	Union	NNP
18637	18538	38	.	.	.
18637	18539	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18539	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	18539	3	quite	quite	RB
18637	18539	4	clear	clear	JJ
18637	18539	5	,	,	,
18637	18539	6	then	then	RB
18637	18539	7	,	,	,
18637	18539	8	that	that	IN
18637	18539	9	there	there	EX
18637	18539	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	18539	11	a	a	DT
18637	18539	12	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18539	13	of	of	IN
18637	18539	14	the	the	DT
18637	18539	15	United	United	NNP
18637	18539	16	States	States	NNP
18637	18539	17	,	,	,
18637	18539	18	and	and	CC
18637	18539	19	a	a	DT
18637	18539	20	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18539	21	of	of	IN
18637	18539	22	a	a	DT
18637	18539	23	State	State	NNP
18637	18539	24	,	,	,
18637	18539	25	which	which	WDT
18637	18539	26	are	be	VBP
18637	18539	27	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	18539	28	from	from	IN
18637	18539	29	each	each	DT
18637	18539	30	other	other	JJ
18637	18539	31	,	,	,
18637	18539	32	and	and	CC
18637	18539	33	which	which	WDT
18637	18539	34	depend	depend	VBP
18637	18539	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	18539	36	different	different	JJ
18637	18539	37	characteristics	characteristic	NNS
18637	18539	38	or	or	CC
18637	18539	39	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	18539	40	in	in	IN
18637	18539	41	the	the	DT
18637	18539	42	individual	individual	NN
18637	18539	43	.	.	.
18637	18540	1	"	"	``
18637	18540	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18540	3	10	10	CD
18637	18540	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18540	5	National	national	JJ
18637	18540	6	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18540	7	,	,	,
18637	18540	8	although	although	IN
18637	18540	9	not	not	RB
18637	18540	10	created	create	VBN
18637	18540	11	by	by	IN
18637	18540	12	this	this	DT
18637	18540	13	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18540	14	,	,	,
18637	18540	15	was	be	VBD
18637	18540	16	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	18540	17	made	make	VBN
18637	18540	18	"	"	``
18637	18540	19	paramount	paramount	JJ
18637	18540	20	and	and	CC
18637	18540	21	dominant	dominant	JJ
18637	18540	22	.	.	.
18637	18541	1	"	"	``
18637	18541	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18541	3	11	11	CD
18637	18541	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18541	5	CORPORATIONS	corporations	NN
18637	18541	6	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	18541	7	of	of	IN
18637	18541	8	the	the	DT
18637	18541	9	United	United	NNP
18637	18541	10	States	States	NNP
18637	18541	11	within	within	IN
18637	18541	12	the	the	DT
18637	18541	13	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	18541	14	of	of	IN
18637	18541	15	this	this	DT
18637	18541	16	article	article	NN
18637	18541	17	must	must	MD
18637	18541	18	be	be	VB
18637	18541	19	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18541	20	and	and	CC
18637	18541	21	not	not	RB
18637	18541	22	artificial	artificial	JJ
18637	18541	23	persons	person	NNS
18637	18541	24	;	;	:
18637	18541	25	a	a	DT
18637	18541	26	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	18541	27	body	body	NN
18637	18541	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	18541	29	not	not	RB
18637	18541	30	a	a	DT
18637	18541	31	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18541	32	of	of	IN
18637	18541	33	the	the	DT
18637	18541	34	United	United	NNP
18637	18541	35	States	States	NNP
18637	18541	36	.	.	.
18637	18542	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18542	2	12	12	CD
18637	18542	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18542	4	Privileges	Privileges	NNPS
18637	18542	5	and	and	CC
18637	18542	6	Immunities	Immunities	NNPS
18637	18542	7	PURPOSE	PURPOSE	NNP
18637	18542	8	AND	and	CC
18637	18542	9	EARLY	early	NN
18637	18542	10	HISTORY	history	NN
18637	18542	11	OF	of	IN
18637	18542	12	THE	the	DT
18637	18542	13	CLAUSE	CLAUSE	NNP
18637	18542	14	Unique	Unique	NNP
18637	18542	15	among	among	IN
18637	18542	16	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18542	17	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	18542	18	,	,	,
18637	18542	19	the	the	DT
18637	18542	20	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18542	21	and	and	CC
18637	18542	22	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	18542	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	18542	24	of	of	IN
18637	18542	25	the	the	DT
18637	18542	26	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18542	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18542	28	enjoys	enjoy	VBZ
18637	18542	29	the	the	DT
18637	18542	30	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	18542	31	of	of	IN
18637	18542	32	having	have	VBG
18637	18542	33	been	be	VBN
18637	18542	34	rendered	render	VBN
18637	18542	35	a	a	DT
18637	18542	36	"	"	``
18637	18542	37	practical	practical	JJ
18637	18542	38	nullity	nullity	NN
18637	18542	39	"	"	''
18637	18542	40	by	by	IN
18637	18542	41	a	a	DT
18637	18542	42	single	single	JJ
18637	18542	43	decision	decision	NN
18637	18542	44	of	of	IN
18637	18542	45	the	the	DT
18637	18542	46	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	18542	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18542	48	rendered	render	VBD
18637	18542	49	within	within	IN
18637	18542	50	five	five	CD
18637	18542	51	years	year	NNS
18637	18542	52	after	after	IN
18637	18542	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18542	54	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	18542	55	.	.	.
18637	18543	1	In	in	IN
18637	18543	2	the	the	DT
18637	18543	3	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	18543	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	18543	5	House	House	NNP
18637	18543	6	Cases[13	Cases[13	NNP
18637	18543	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18543	8	a	a	DT
18637	18543	9	bare	bare	JJ
18637	18543	10	majority	majority	NN
18637	18543	11	of	of	IN
18637	18543	12	the	the	DT
18637	18543	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18543	14	frustrated	frustrate	VBD
18637	18543	15	the	the	DT
18637	18543	16	aims	aim	NNS
18637	18543	17	of	of	IN
18637	18543	18	the	the	DT
18637	18543	19	most	most	RBS
18637	18543	20	aggressive	aggressive	JJ
18637	18543	21	sponsors	sponsor	NNS
18637	18543	22	of	of	IN
18637	18543	23	this	this	DT
18637	18543	24	clause	clause	NN
18637	18543	25	,	,	,
18637	18543	26	to	to	IN
18637	18543	27	whom	whom	WP
18637	18543	28	was	be	VBD
18637	18543	29	attributed	attribute	VBN
18637	18543	30	an	an	DT
18637	18543	31	intention	intention	NN
18637	18543	32	to	to	TO
18637	18543	33	centralize	centralize	VB
18637	18543	34	"	"	''
18637	18543	35	in	in	IN
18637	18543	36	the	the	DT
18637	18543	37	hands	hand	NNS
18637	18543	38	of	of	IN
18637	18543	39	the	the	DT
18637	18543	40	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18543	41	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18543	42	large	large	JJ
18637	18543	43	powers	power	NNS
18637	18543	44	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
18637	18543	45	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	18543	46	by	by	IN
18637	18543	47	the	the	DT
18637	18543	48	States	States	NNP
18637	18543	49	"	"	''
18637	18543	50	with	with	IN
18637	18543	51	a	a	DT
18637	18543	52	view	view	NN
18637	18543	53	to	to	IN
18637	18543	54	enabling	enable	VBG
18637	18543	55	business	business	NN
18637	18543	56	to	to	TO
18637	18543	57	develop	develop	VB
18637	18543	58	unimpeded	unimpeded	JJ
18637	18543	59	by	by	IN
18637	18543	60	State	state	NN
18637	18543	61	interference	interference	NN
18637	18543	62	.	.	.
18637	18544	1	This	this	DT
18637	18544	2	expansive	expansive	JJ
18637	18544	3	alteration	alteration	NN
18637	18544	4	of	of	IN
18637	18544	5	the	the	DT
18637	18544	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18544	7	System	System	NNP
18637	18544	8	was	be	VBD
18637	18544	9	to	to	TO
18637	18544	10	have	have	VB
18637	18544	11	been	be	VBN
18637	18544	12	achieved	achieve	VBN
18637	18544	13	by	by	IN
18637	18544	14	converting	convert	VBG
18637	18544	15	the	the	DT
18637	18544	16	rights	right	NNS
18637	18544	17	of	of	IN
18637	18544	18	the	the	DT
18637	18544	19	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18544	20	of	of	IN
18637	18544	21	each	each	DT
18637	18544	22	State	State	NNP
18637	18544	23	as	as	IN
18637	18544	24	of	of	IN
18637	18544	25	the	the	DT
18637	18544	26	date	date	NN
18637	18544	27	of	of	IN
18637	18544	28	the	the	DT
18637	18544	29	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	18544	30	of	of	IN
18637	18544	31	the	the	DT
18637	18544	32	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18544	33	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18544	34	into	into	IN
18637	18544	35	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18544	36	and	and	CC
18637	18544	37	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	18544	38	of	of	IN
18637	18544	39	United	United	NNP
18637	18544	40	States	States	NNP
18637	18544	41	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18544	42	and	and	CC
18637	18544	43	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	18544	44	perpetuating	perpetuate	VBG
18637	18544	45	this	this	DT
18637	18544	46	newly	newly	RB
18637	18544	47	defined	define	VBN
18637	18544	48	_	_	NNP
18637	18544	49	status	status	NN
18637	18544	50	quo	quo	FW
18637	18544	51	_	_	NNP
18637	18544	52	through	through	IN
18637	18544	53	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18544	54	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	18544	55	of	of	IN
18637	18544	56	any	any	DT
18637	18544	57	State	State	NNP
18637	18544	58	law	law	NN
18637	18544	59	challenged	challenge	VBD
18637	18544	60	as	as	IN
18637	18544	61	"	"	``
18637	18544	62	abridging	abridge	VBG
18637	18544	63	"	"	''
18637	18544	64	any	any	DT
18637	18544	65	one	one	CD
18637	18544	66	of	of	IN
18637	18544	67	the	the	DT
18637	18544	68	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18544	69	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18544	70	.	.	.
18637	18545	1	To	to	TO
18637	18545	2	have	have	VB
18637	18545	3	fostered	foster	VBN
18637	18545	4	such	such	JJ
18637	18545	5	intentions	intention	NNS
18637	18545	6	,	,	,
18637	18545	7	the	the	DT
18637	18545	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18545	9	declared	declare	VBD
18637	18545	10	,	,	,
18637	18545	11	would	would	MD
18637	18545	12	have	have	VB
18637	18545	13	been	be	VBN
18637	18545	14	"	"	``
18637	18545	15	to	to	TO
18637	18545	16	transfer	transfer	VB
18637	18545	17	the	the	DT
18637	18545	18	security	security	NN
18637	18545	19	and	and	CC
18637	18545	20	protection	protection	NN
18637	18545	21	of	of	IN
18637	18545	22	all	all	PDT
18637	18545	23	the	the	DT
18637	18545	24	civil	civil	JJ
18637	18545	25	rights	right	NNS
18637	18545	26	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	27	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	28	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	29	to	to	IN
18637	18545	30	the	the	DT
18637	18545	31	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18545	32	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18545	33	,	,	,
18637	18545	34	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	35	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	36	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	37	to	to	TO
18637	18545	38	bring	bring	VB
18637	18545	39	within	within	IN
18637	18545	40	the	the	DT
18637	18545	41	power	power	NN
18637	18545	42	of	of	IN
18637	18545	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18545	44	the	the	DT
18637	18545	45	entire	entire	JJ
18637	18545	46	domain	domain	NN
18637	18545	47	of	of	IN
18637	18545	48	civil	civil	JJ
18637	18545	49	rights	right	NNS
18637	18545	50	heretofore	heretofore	RB
18637	18545	51	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	18545	52	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	18545	53	to	to	IN
18637	18545	54	the	the	DT
18637	18545	55	States	States	NNPS
18637	18545	56	,	,	,
18637	18545	57	"	"	''
18637	18545	58	and	and	CC
18637	18545	59	to	to	TO
18637	18545	60	"	"	``
18637	18545	61	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	18545	62	this	this	DT
18637	18545	63	court	court	NN
18637	18545	64	a	a	DT
18637	18545	65	perpetual	perpetual	JJ
18637	18545	66	censor	censor	NN
18637	18545	67	upon	upon	IN
18637	18545	68	all	all	DT
18637	18545	69	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18545	70	of	of	IN
18637	18545	71	the	the	DT
18637	18545	72	States	States	NNPS
18637	18545	73	,	,	,
18637	18545	74	on	on	IN
18637	18545	75	the	the	DT
18637	18545	76	civil	civil	JJ
18637	18545	77	rights	right	NNS
18637	18545	78	of	of	IN
18637	18545	79	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18545	80	own	own	JJ
18637	18545	81	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18545	82	,	,	,
18637	18545	83	with	with	IN
18637	18545	84	authority	authority	NN
18637	18545	85	to	to	TO
18637	18545	86	nullify	nullify	VB
18637	18545	87	such	such	JJ
18637	18545	88	as	as	IN
18637	18545	89	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18545	90	did	do	VBD
18637	18545	91	not	not	RB
18637	18545	92	approve	approve	VB
18637	18545	93	as	as	RB
18637	18545	94	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	18545	95	with	with	IN
18637	18545	96	those	those	DT
18637	18545	97	rights	right	NNS
18637	18545	98	,	,	,
18637	18545	99	as	as	IN
18637	18545	100	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18545	101	existed	exist	VBD
18637	18545	102	at	at	IN
18637	18545	103	the	the	DT
18637	18545	104	time	time	NN
18637	18545	105	of	of	IN
18637	18545	106	the	the	DT
18637	18545	107	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	18545	108	of	of	IN
18637	18545	109	this	this	DT
18637	18545	110	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18545	111	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	112	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	113	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	114	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18545	115	The	the	DT
18637	18545	116	effect	effect	NN
18637	18545	117	of	of	IN
18637	18545	118	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18545	119	so	so	RB
18637	18545	120	great	great	JJ
18637	18545	121	a	a	DT
18637	18545	122	departure	departure	NN
18637	18545	123	from	from	IN
18637	18545	124	the	the	DT
18637	18545	125	structure	structure	NN
18637	18545	126	and	and	CC
18637	18545	127	spirit	spirit	NN
18637	18545	128	of	of	IN
18637	18545	129	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18545	130	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	18545	131	;	;	:
18637	18545	132	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	133	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	134	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	135	is	be	VBZ
18637	18545	136	to	to	TO
18637	18545	137	fetter	fetter	VB
18637	18545	138	and	and	CC
18637	18545	139	degrade	degrade	VB
18637	18545	140	the	the	DT
18637	18545	141	State	state	NN
18637	18545	142	governments	government	NNS
18637	18545	143	by	by	IN
18637	18545	144	subjecting	subject	VBG
18637	18545	145	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18545	146	to	to	IN
18637	18545	147	the	the	DT
18637	18545	148	control	control	NN
18637	18545	149	of	of	IN
18637	18545	150	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18545	151	,	,	,
18637	18545	152	in	in	IN
18637	18545	153	the	the	DT
18637	18545	154	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18545	155	of	of	IN
18637	18545	156	powers	power	NNS
18637	18545	157	heretofore	heretofore	RB
18637	18545	158	universally	universally	RB
18637	18545	159	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	18545	160	to	to	IN
18637	18545	161	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18545	162	of	of	IN
18637	18545	163	the	the	DT
18637	18545	164	most	most	RBS
18637	18545	165	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	18545	166	and	and	CC
18637	18545	167	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	18545	168	character	character	NN
18637	18545	169	;	;	,
18637	18545	170	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	171	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	172	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	173	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18545	174	are	be	VBP
18637	18545	175	convinced	convinced	JJ
18637	18545	176	that	that	IN
18637	18545	177	no	no	DT
18637	18545	178	such	such	JJ
18637	18545	179	results	result	NNS
18637	18545	180	were	be	VBD
18637	18545	181	intended	intend	VBN
18637	18545	182	by	by	IN
18637	18545	183	the	the	DT
18637	18545	184	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18545	185	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	186	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	187	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	188	,	,	,
18637	18545	189	nor	nor	CC
18637	18545	190	by	by	IN
18637	18545	191	the	the	DT
18637	18545	192	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	18545	193	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	194	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	195	*	*	NFP
18637	18545	196	which	which	WDT
18637	18545	197	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	18545	198	"	"	``
18637	18545	199	this	this	DT
18637	18545	200	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18545	201	,	,	,
18637	18545	202	and	and	CC
18637	18545	203	that	that	IN
18637	18545	204	the	the	DT
18637	18545	205	sole	sole	JJ
18637	18545	206	"	"	``
18637	18545	207	pervading	pervade	VBG
18637	18545	208	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18545	209	"	"	''
18637	18545	210	of	of	IN
18637	18545	211	this	this	DT
18637	18545	212	and	and	CC
18637	18545	213	the	the	DT
18637	18545	214	other	other	JJ
18637	18545	215	War	War	NNP
18637	18545	216	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	18545	217	was	be	VBD
18637	18545	218	"	"	``
18637	18545	219	the	the	DT
18637	18545	220	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18545	221	of	of	IN
18637	18545	222	the	the	DT
18637	18545	223	slave	slave	NN
18637	18545	224	race	race	NN
18637	18545	225	.	.	.
18637	18545	226	"	"	''
18637	18546	1	Conformably	conformably	RB
18637	18546	2	to	to	IN
18637	18546	3	these	these	DT
18637	18546	4	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
18637	18546	5	the	the	DT
18637	18546	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18546	7	advised	advise	VBD
18637	18546	8	the	the	DT
18637	18546	9	New	New	NNP
18637	18546	10	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	18546	11	butchers	butcher	NNS
18637	18546	12	that	that	IN
18637	18546	13	the	the	DT
18637	18546	14	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	18546	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	18546	16	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	18546	17	on	on	IN
18637	18546	18	a	a	DT
18637	18546	19	single	single	JJ
18637	18546	20	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18546	21	a	a	DT
18637	18546	22	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	18546	23	of	of	IN
18637	18546	24	the	the	DT
18637	18546	25	business	business	NN
18637	18546	26	of	of	IN
18637	18546	27	slaughtering	slaughter	VBG
18637	18546	28	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	18546	29	abrogated	abrogate	VBD
18637	18546	30	no	no	DT
18637	18546	31	rights	right	NNS
18637	18546	32	possessed	possess	VBN
18637	18546	33	by	by	IN
18637	18546	34	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18546	35	as	as	IN
18637	18546	36	United	United	NNP
18637	18546	37	States	States	NNP
18637	18546	38	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18546	39	and	and	CC
18637	18546	40	that	that	IN
18637	18546	41	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	18546	42	as	as	IN
18637	18546	43	that	that	DT
18637	18546	44	law	law	NN
18637	18546	45	interfered	interfere	VBD
18637	18546	46	with	with	IN
18637	18546	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18546	48	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	18546	49	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18546	50	of	of	IN
18637	18546	51	pursuing	pursue	VBG
18637	18546	52	the	the	DT
18637	18546	53	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	18546	54	calling	calling	NN
18637	18546	55	of	of	IN
18637	18546	56	butchering	butcher	VBG
18637	18546	57	animals	animal	NNS
18637	18546	58	,	,	,
18637	18546	59	the	the	DT
18637	18546	60	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18546	61	thus	thus	RB
18637	18546	62	terminated	terminate	VBN
18637	18546	63	was	be	VBD
18637	18546	64	merely	merely	RB
18637	18546	65	one	one	CD
18637	18546	66	of	of	IN
18637	18546	67	"	"	``
18637	18546	68	those	those	DT
18637	18546	69	which	which	WDT
18637	18546	70	belonged	belong	VBD
18637	18546	71	to	to	IN
18637	18546	72	the	the	DT
18637	18546	73	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18546	74	of	of	IN
18637	18546	75	the	the	DT
18637	18546	76	States	States	NNP
18637	18546	77	as	as	IN
18637	18546	78	such	such	JJ
18637	18546	79	,	,	,
18637	18546	80	and	and	CC
18637	18546	81	"	"	``
18637	18546	82	that	that	IN
18637	18546	83	these	these	DT
18637	18546	84	had	have	VBD
18637	18546	85	been	be	VBN
18637	18546	86	"	"	``
18637	18546	87	left	leave	VBN
18637	18546	88	to	to	IN
18637	18546	89	the	the	DT
18637	18546	90	State	state	NN
18637	18546	91	governments	government	NNS
18637	18546	92	for	for	IN
18637	18546	93	security	security	NN
18637	18546	94	and	and	CC
18637	18546	95	protection	protection	NN
18637	18546	96	"	"	''
18637	18546	97	and	and	CC
18637	18546	98	had	have	VBD
18637	18546	99	not	not	RB
18637	18546	100	been	be	VBN
18637	18546	101	by	by	IN
18637	18546	102	this	this	DT
18637	18546	103	clause	clause	NN
18637	18546	104	"	"	''
18637	18546	105	placed	place	VBN
18637	18546	106	under	under	IN
18637	18546	107	the	the	DT
18637	18546	108	special	special	JJ
18637	18546	109	care	care	NN
18637	18546	110	of	of	IN
18637	18546	111	the	the	DT
18637	18546	112	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18546	113	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18546	114	.	.	.
18637	18546	115	"	"	''
18637	18547	1	The	the	DT
18637	18547	2	only	only	JJ
18637	18547	3	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18547	4	which	which	WDT
18637	18547	5	the	the	DT
18637	18547	6	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18547	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	18547	8	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	18547	9	protected	protect	VBN
18637	18547	10	against	against	IN
18637	18547	11	State	State	NNP
18637	18547	12	encroachment	encroachment	NN
18637	18547	13	were	be	VBD
18637	18547	14	declared	declare	VBN
18637	18547	15	to	to	TO
18637	18547	16	be	be	VB
18637	18547	17	those	those	DT
18637	18547	18	"	"	``
18637	18547	19	which	which	WDT
18637	18547	20	owe	owe	VBP
18637	18547	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18547	22	existence	existence	NN
18637	18547	23	to	to	IN
18637	18547	24	the	the	DT
18637	18547	25	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18547	26	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18547	27	,	,	,
18637	18547	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18547	29	National	national	JJ
18637	18547	30	character	character	NN
18637	18547	31	,	,	,
18637	18547	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18547	33	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18547	34	,	,	,
18637	18547	35	or	or	CC
18637	18547	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18547	37	laws	law	NNS
18637	18547	38	.	.	.
18637	18547	39	"	"	''
18637	18548	1	--privileges	--privilege	NNS
18637	18548	2	,	,	,
18637	18548	3	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	18548	4	,	,	,
18637	18548	5	which	which	WDT
18637	18548	6	had	have	VBD
18637	18548	7	been	be	VBN
18637	18548	8	available	available	JJ
18637	18548	9	to	to	IN
18637	18548	10	United	United	NNP
18637	18548	11	States	States	NNP
18637	18548	12	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18548	13	even	even	RB
18637	18548	14	prior	prior	RB
18637	18548	15	to	to	IN
18637	18548	16	the	the	DT
18637	18548	17	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	18548	18	of	of	IN
18637	18548	19	the	the	DT
18637	18548	20	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18548	21	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18548	22	;	;	:
18637	18548	23	and	and	CC
18637	18548	24	inasmuch	inasmuch	VB
18637	18548	25	as	as	IN
18637	18548	26	under	under	IN
18637	18548	27	the	the	DT
18637	18548	28	principle	principle	NN
18637	18548	29	of	of	IN
18637	18548	30	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18548	31	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	18548	32	no	no	DT
18637	18548	33	State	State	NNP
18637	18548	34	ever	ever	RB
18637	18548	35	was	be	VBD
18637	18548	36	competent	competent	JJ
18637	18548	37	to	to	TO
18637	18548	38	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	18548	39	with	with	IN
18637	18548	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18548	41	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	18548	42	,	,	,
18637	18548	43	the	the	DT
18637	18548	44	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18548	45	and	and	CC
18637	18548	46	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	18548	47	clause	clause	NN
18637	18548	48	of	of	IN
18637	18548	49	the	the	DT
18637	18548	50	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18548	51	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18548	52	was	be	VBD
18637	18548	53	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	18548	54	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	18548	55	to	to	IN
18637	18548	56	a	a	DT
18637	18548	57	superfluous	superfluous	JJ
18637	18548	58	reiteration	reiteration	NN
18637	18548	59	of	of	IN
18637	18548	60	a	a	DT
18637	18548	61	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	18548	62	already	already	RB
18637	18548	63	operative	operative	JJ
18637	18548	64	against	against	IN
18637	18548	65	the	the	DT
18637	18548	66	States	States	NNP
18637	18548	67	.	.	.
18637	18549	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18549	2	14	14	CD
18637	18549	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18549	4	PRIVILEGES	privileges	NN
18637	18549	5	AND	and	CC
18637	18549	6	IMMUNITIES	immunity	NNS
18637	18549	7	OF	of	IN
18637	18549	8	CITIZENS	citizen	NNS
18637	18549	9	OF	of	IN
18637	18549	10	THE	the	DT
18637	18549	11	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	18549	12	STATES	STATES	NNP
18637	18549	13	Although	although	IN
18637	18549	14	the	the	DT
18637	18549	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18549	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	18549	17	expressed	express	VBN
18637	18549	18	a	a	DT
18637	18549	19	reluctance	reluctance	NN
18637	18549	20	to	to	TO
18637	18549	21	attempt	attempt	VB
18637	18549	22	a	a	DT
18637	18549	23	definitive	definitive	JJ
18637	18549	24	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	18549	25	of	of	IN
18637	18549	26	those	those	DT
18637	18549	27	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18549	28	and	and	CC
18637	18549	29	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	18549	30	of	of	IN
18637	18549	31	United	United	NNP
18637	18549	32	States	States	NNP
18637	18549	33	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18549	34	such	such	JJ
18637	18549	35	as	as	IN
18637	18549	36	are	be	VBP
18637	18549	37	protected	protect	VBN
18637	18549	38	against	against	IN
18637	18549	39	State	state	NN
18637	18549	40	encroachment	encroachment	NN
18637	18549	41	,	,	,
18637	18549	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18549	43	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	18549	44	felt	feel	VBD
18637	18549	45	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	18549	46	in	in	IN
18637	18549	47	the	the	DT
18637	18549	48	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	18549	49	-	-	HYPH
18637	18549	50	House	House	NNP
18637	18549	51	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	18549	52	"	"	``
18637	18549	53	to	to	TO
18637	18549	54	suggest	suggest	VB
18637	18549	55	some	some	DT
18637	18549	56	which	which	WDT
18637	18549	57	owe	owe	VBP
18637	18549	58	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18549	59	existence	existence	NN
18637	18549	60	to	to	IN
18637	18549	61	the	the	DT
18637	18549	62	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18549	63	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18549	64	,	,	,
18637	18549	65	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18549	66	National	national	JJ
18637	18549	67	character	character	NN
18637	18549	68	,	,	,
18637	18549	69	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18549	70	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18549	71	,	,	,
18637	18549	72	or	or	CC
18637	18549	73	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18549	74	laws	law	NNS
18637	18549	75	.	.	.
18637	18549	76	"	"	''
18637	18550	1	Among	among	IN
18637	18550	2	those	those	DT
18637	18550	3	then	then	RB
18637	18550	4	identified	identify	VBN
18637	18550	5	were	be	VBD
18637	18550	6	the	the	DT
18637	18550	7	following	follow	VBG
18637	18550	8	:	:	:
18637	18550	9	right	right	NN
18637	18550	10	of	of	IN
18637	18550	11	access	access	NN
18637	18550	12	to	to	IN
18637	18550	13	the	the	DT
18637	18550	14	seat	seat	NN
18637	18550	15	of	of	IN
18637	18550	16	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18550	17	,	,	,
18637	18550	18	and	and	CC
18637	18550	19	to	to	IN
18637	18550	20	the	the	DT
18637	18550	21	seaports	seaport	NNS
18637	18550	22	,	,	,
18637	18550	23	subtreasuries	subtreasury	NNS
18637	18550	24	,	,	,
18637	18550	25	land	land	NN
18637	18550	26	offices	office	NNS
18637	18550	27	,	,	,
18637	18550	28	and	and	CC
18637	18550	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	18550	30	of	of	IN
18637	18550	31	justice	justice	NN
18637	18550	32	in	in	IN
18637	18550	33	the	the	DT
18637	18550	34	several	several	JJ
18637	18550	35	States	state	NNS
18637	18550	36	;	;	:
18637	18550	37	right	right	JJ
18637	18550	38	to	to	TO
18637	18550	39	demand	demand	VB
18637	18550	40	protection	protection	NN
18637	18550	41	of	of	IN
18637	18550	42	the	the	DT
18637	18550	43	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18550	44	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18550	45	on	on	IN
18637	18550	46	the	the	DT
18637	18550	47	high	high	JJ
18637	18550	48	seas	sea	NNS
18637	18550	49	,	,	,
18637	18550	50	or	or	CC
18637	18550	51	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	18550	52	;	;	:
18637	18550	53	right	right	RB
18637	18550	54	of	of	IN
18637	18550	55	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	18550	56	and	and	CC
18637	18550	57	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18550	58	of	of	IN
18637	18550	59	the	the	DT
18637	18550	60	writ	writ	NNP
18637	18550	61	of	of	IN
18637	18550	62	_	_	NNP
18637	18550	63	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	18550	64	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	18550	65	_	_	NNP
18637	18550	66	;	;	:
18637	18550	67	right	right	JJ
18637	18550	68	to	to	TO
18637	18550	69	use	use	VB
18637	18550	70	the	the	DT
18637	18550	71	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	18550	72	waters	water	NNS
18637	18550	73	of	of	IN
18637	18550	74	the	the	DT
18637	18550	75	United	United	NNP
18637	18550	76	States	States	NNP
18637	18550	77	;	;	:
18637	18550	78	and	and	CC
18637	18550	79	rights	right	NNS
18637	18550	80	secured	secure	VBN
18637	18550	81	by	by	IN
18637	18550	82	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	18550	83	.	.	.
18637	18551	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18551	2	15	15	CD
18637	18551	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18551	4	In	in	IN
18637	18551	5	a	a	DT
18637	18551	6	later	later	JJ
18637	18551	7	listing	listing	NN
18637	18551	8	in	in	IN
18637	18551	9	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	18551	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18551	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	18551	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18551	13	New	New	NNP
18637	18551	14	Jersey,[16	Jersey,[16	NNP
18637	18551	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18551	16	decided	decide	VBD
18637	18551	17	in	in	IN
18637	18551	18	1908	1908	CD
18637	18551	19	,	,	,
18637	18551	20	the	the	DT
18637	18551	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18551	22	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	18551	23	"	"	''
18637	18551	24	among	among	IN
18637	18551	25	the	the	DT
18637	18551	26	rights	right	NNS
18637	18551	27	and	and	CC
18637	18551	28	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18551	29	"	"	''
18637	18551	30	of	of	IN
18637	18551	31	national	national	JJ
18637	18551	32	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18551	33	the	the	DT
18637	18551	34	following	follow	VBG
18637	18551	35	:	:	:
18637	18551	36	The	the	DT
18637	18551	37	right	right	NN
18637	18551	38	to	to	TO
18637	18551	39	pass	pass	VB
18637	18551	40	freely	freely	RB
18637	18551	41	from	from	IN
18637	18551	42	State	State	NNP
18637	18551	43	to	to	IN
18637	18551	44	State;[17	State;[17	NNP
18637	18551	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18551	46	the	the	DT
18637	18551	47	right	right	NN
18637	18551	48	to	to	TO
18637	18551	49	petition	petition	VB
18637	18551	50	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18551	51	for	for	IN
18637	18551	52	a	a	DT
18637	18551	53	redress	redress	NN
18637	18551	54	of	of	IN
18637	18551	55	grievances;[18	grievances;[18	NNP
18637	18551	56	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18551	57	the	the	DT
18637	18551	58	right	right	NN
18637	18551	59	to	to	TO
18637	18551	60	vote	vote	VB
18637	18551	61	for	for	IN
18637	18551	62	national	national	JJ
18637	18551	63	officers;[19	officers;[19	NN
18637	18551	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18551	65	the	the	DT
18637	18551	66	right	right	NN
18637	18551	67	to	to	TO
18637	18551	68	enter	enter	VB
18637	18551	69	public	public	JJ
18637	18551	70	lands;[20	lands;[20	.
18637	18551	71	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18551	72	the	the	DT
18637	18551	73	right	right	NN
18637	18551	74	to	to	TO
18637	18551	75	be	be	VB
18637	18551	76	protected	protect	VBN
18637	18551	77	against	against	IN
18637	18551	78	violence	violence	NN
18637	18551	79	while	while	IN
18637	18551	80	in	in	IN
18637	18551	81	the	the	DT
18637	18551	82	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	18551	83	custody	custody	NN
18637	18551	84	of	of	IN
18637	18551	85	a	a	DT
18637	18551	86	United	United	NNP
18637	18551	87	States	States	NNP
18637	18551	88	marshal;[21	marshal;[21	NNP
18637	18551	89	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18551	90	and	and	CC
18637	18551	91	the	the	DT
18637	18551	92	right	right	NN
18637	18551	93	to	to	TO
18637	18551	94	inform	inform	VB
18637	18551	95	the	the	DT
18637	18551	96	United	United	NNP
18637	18551	97	States	States	NNP
18637	18551	98	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	18551	99	of	of	IN
18637	18551	100	violations	violation	NNS
18637	18551	101	of	of	IN
18637	18551	102	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18551	103	laws	law	NNS
18637	18551	104	.	.	.
18637	18552	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18552	2	22	22	CD
18637	18552	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18552	4	Earlier	early	RBR
18637	18552	5	in	in	IN
18637	18552	6	a	a	DT
18637	18552	7	decision	decision	NN
18637	18552	8	not	not	RB
18637	18552	9	referred	refer	VBN
18637	18552	10	to	to	IN
18637	18552	11	in	in	IN
18637	18552	12	the	the	DT
18637	18552	13	aforementioned	aforementioned	JJ
18637	18552	14	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	18552	15	,	,	,
18637	18552	16	the	the	DT
18637	18552	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18552	18	had	have	VBD
18637	18552	19	also	also	RB
18637	18552	20	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	18552	21	that	that	IN
18637	18552	22	the	the	DT
18637	18552	23	carrying	carrying	NN
18637	18552	24	on	on	RP
18637	18552	25	of	of	IN
18637	18552	26	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	18552	27	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18552	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	18552	29	"	"	``
18637	18552	30	a	a	DT
18637	18552	31	right	right	NN
18637	18552	32	which	which	WDT
18637	18552	33	every	every	DT
18637	18552	34	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18552	35	of	of	IN
18637	18552	36	the	the	DT
18637	18552	37	United	United	NNP
18637	18552	38	States	States	NNP
18637	18552	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	18552	40	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	18552	41	to	to	TO
18637	18552	42	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	18552	43	.	.	.
18637	18553	1	"	"	``
18637	18553	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18553	3	23	23	CD
18637	18553	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18553	5	During	during	IN
18637	18553	6	the	the	DT
18637	18553	7	past	past	JJ
18637	18553	8	fifteen	fifteen	CD
18637	18553	9	years	year	NNS
18637	18553	10	this	this	DT
18637	18553	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	18553	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	18553	13	been	be	VBN
18637	18553	14	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	18553	15	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	18553	16	uneven	uneven	JJ
18637	18553	17	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	18553	18	by	by	IN
18637	18553	19	the	the	DT
18637	18553	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18553	21	which	which	WDT
18637	18553	22	,	,	,
18637	18553	23	on	on	IN
18637	18553	24	two	two	CD
18637	18553	25	occasions	occasion	NNS
18637	18553	26	at	at	IN
18637	18553	27	least	least	JJS
18637	18553	28	,	,	,
18637	18553	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	18553	30	manifested	manifest	VBN
18637	18553	31	a	a	DT
18637	18553	32	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	18553	33	to	to	TO
18637	18553	34	magnify	magnify	VB
18637	18553	35	the	the	DT
18637	18553	36	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18553	37	which	which	WDT
18637	18553	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18553	39	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	18553	40	on	on	IN
18637	18553	41	State	state	NN
18637	18553	42	action	action	NN
18637	18553	43	by	by	IN
18637	18553	44	enlarging	enlarge	VBG
18637	18553	45	previous	previous	JJ
18637	18553	46	enumerations	enumeration	NNS
18637	18553	47	of	of	IN
18637	18553	48	the	the	DT
18637	18553	49	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18553	50	protected	protect	VBN
18637	18553	51	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	18553	52	.	.	.
18637	18554	1	In	in	IN
18637	18554	2	Hague	Hague	NNP
18637	18554	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18554	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	18554	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18554	6	C.I.O.,[24	C.I.O.,[24	NNP
18637	18554	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18554	8	decided	decide	VBN
18637	18554	9	in	in	IN
18637	18554	10	1939	1939	CD
18637	18554	11	,	,	,
18637	18554	12	the	the	DT
18637	18554	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18554	14	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	18554	15	that	that	IN
18637	18554	16	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18554	17	to	to	TO
18637	18554	18	use	use	VB
18637	18554	19	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	18554	20	streets	street	NNS
18637	18554	21	and	and	CC
18637	18554	22	parks	park	NNS
18637	18554	23	for	for	IN
18637	18554	24	the	the	DT
18637	18554	25	dissemination	dissemination	NN
18637	18554	26	of	of	IN
18637	18554	27	information	information	NN
18637	18554	28	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	18554	29	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	18554	30	of	of	IN
18637	18554	31	a	a	DT
18637	18554	32	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18554	33	statute	statute	NN
18637	18554	34	and	and	CC
18637	18554	35	to	to	TO
18637	18554	36	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	18554	37	peacefully	peacefully	RB
18637	18554	38	therein	therein	RB
18637	18554	39	for	for	IN
18637	18554	40	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	18554	41	of	of	IN
18637	18554	42	the	the	DT
18637	18554	43	advantages	advantage	NNS
18637	18554	44	and	and	CC
18637	18554	45	opportunities	opportunity	NNS
18637	18554	46	offered	offer	VBN
18637	18554	47	by	by	IN
18637	18554	48	such	such	JJ
18637	18554	49	act	act	NN
18637	18554	50	was	be	VBD
18637	18554	51	a	a	DT
18637	18554	52	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18554	53	and	and	CC
18637	18554	54	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	18554	55	of	of	IN
18637	18554	56	a	a	DT
18637	18554	57	United	United	NNP
18637	18554	58	States	States	NNP
18637	18554	59	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18554	60	.	.	.
18637	18555	1	The	the	DT
18637	18555	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18555	3	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18555	4	was	be	VBD
18637	18555	5	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	18555	6	to	to	TO
18637	18555	7	have	have	VB
18637	18555	8	been	be	VBN
18637	18555	9	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	18555	10	by	by	IN
18637	18555	11	city	city	NN
18637	18555	12	officials	official	NNS
18637	18555	13	who	who	WP
18637	18555	14	acted	act	VBD
18637	18555	15	in	in	IN
18637	18555	16	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	18555	17	of	of	IN
18637	18555	18	a	a	DT
18637	18555	19	void	void	JJ
18637	18555	20	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	18555	21	which	which	WDT
18637	18555	22	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	18555	23	a	a	DT
18637	18555	24	director	director	NN
18637	18555	25	of	of	IN
18637	18555	26	safety	safety	NN
18637	18555	27	to	to	TO
18637	18555	28	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	18555	29	permits	permit	NNS
18637	18555	30	for	for	IN
18637	18555	31	parades	parade	NNS
18637	18555	32	or	or	CC
18637	18555	33	assemblies	assembly	NNS
18637	18555	34	on	on	IN
18637	18555	35	streets	street	NNS
18637	18555	36	or	or	CC
18637	18555	37	parks	park	NNS
18637	18555	38	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	18555	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18555	40	believed	believe	VBD
18637	18555	41	riots	riot	NNS
18637	18555	42	could	could	MD
18637	18555	43	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	18555	44	be	be	VB
18637	18555	45	avoided	avoid	VBN
18637	18555	46	and	and	CC
18637	18555	47	who	who	WP
18637	18555	48	forcibly	forcibly	RB
18637	18555	49	evicted	evict	VBD
18637	18555	50	from	from	IN
18637	18555	51	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18555	52	city	city	NN
18637	18555	53	union	union	NN
18637	18555	54	organizers	organizer	NNS
18637	18555	55	who	who	WP
18637	18555	56	sought	seek	VBD
18637	18555	57	to	to	TO
18637	18555	58	use	use	VB
18637	18555	59	the	the	DT
18637	18555	60	streets	street	NNS
18637	18555	61	and	and	CC
18637	18555	62	parks	park	NNS
18637	18555	63	for	for	IN
18637	18555	64	the	the	DT
18637	18555	65	aforementioned	aforementioned	JJ
18637	18555	66	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	18555	67	.	.	.
18637	18556	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18556	2	25	25	CD
18637	18556	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18556	4	Again	again	RB
18637	18556	5	in	in	IN
18637	18556	6	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	18556	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18556	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18556	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18556	10	California,[26	California,[26	NNP
18637	18556	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18556	12	four	four	CD
18637	18556	13	Justices[27	Justices[27	NNPS
18637	18556	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18556	15	who	who	WP
18637	18556	16	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	18556	17	in	in	IN
18637	18556	18	the	the	DT
18637	18556	19	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18556	20	that	that	WDT
18637	18556	21	a	a	DT
18637	18556	22	California	California	NNP
18637	18556	23	statute	statute	NN
18637	18556	24	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	18556	25	the	the	DT
18637	18556	26	entry	entry	NN
18637	18556	27	of	of	IN
18637	18556	28	indigent	indigent	JJ
18637	18556	29	migrants	migrant	NNS
18637	18556	30	was	be	VBD
18637	18556	31	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18556	32	preferred	prefer	VBD
18637	18556	33	to	to	TO
18637	18556	34	rest	rest	VB
18637	18556	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18556	36	decision	decision	NN
18637	18556	37	on	on	IN
18637	18556	38	the	the	DT
18637	18556	39	ground	ground	NN
18637	18556	40	that	that	IN
18637	18556	41	the	the	DT
18637	18556	42	act	act	NN
18637	18556	43	interfered	interfere	VBD
18637	18556	44	with	with	IN
18637	18556	45	the	the	DT
18637	18556	46	right	right	NN
18637	18556	47	of	of	IN
18637	18556	48	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18556	49	to	to	TO
18637	18556	50	move	move	VB
18637	18556	51	freely	freely	RB
18637	18556	52	from	from	IN
18637	18556	53	State	State	NNP
18637	18556	54	to	to	IN
18637	18556	55	State	State	NNP
18637	18556	56	.	.	.
18637	18557	1	In	in	IN
18637	18557	2	thus	thus	RB
18637	18557	3	rejecting	reject	VBG
18637	18557	4	the	the	DT
18637	18557	5	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	18557	6	clause	clause	NN
18637	18557	7	,	,	,
18637	18557	8	relied	rely	VBN
18637	18557	9	on	on	RP
18637	18557	10	by	by	IN
18637	18557	11	the	the	DT
18637	18557	12	majority	majority	NN
18637	18557	13	as	as	IN
18637	18557	14	the	the	DT
18637	18557	15	basis	basis	NN
18637	18557	16	for	for	IN
18637	18557	17	disposing	dispose	VBG
18637	18557	18	of	of	IN
18637	18557	19	this	this	DT
18637	18557	20	case	case	NN
18637	18557	21	,	,	,
18637	18557	22	the	the	DT
18637	18557	23	minority	minority	NN
18637	18557	24	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	18557	25	resurrected	resurrect	VBD
18637	18557	26	an	an	DT
18637	18557	27	issue	issue	NN
18637	18557	28	first	first	RB
18637	18557	29	advanced	advance	VBN
18637	18557	30	in	in	IN
18637	18557	31	the	the	DT
18637	18557	32	old	old	JJ
18637	18557	33	decision	decision	NN
18637	18557	34	of	of	IN
18637	18557	35	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	18557	36	_	_	NNP
18637	18557	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	18557	38	_	_	NNP
18637	18557	39	Nevada[28	Nevada[28	NNP
18637	18557	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18557	41	and	and	CC
18637	18557	42	believed	believe	VBN
18637	18557	43	to	to	TO
18637	18557	44	have	have	VB
18637	18557	45	been	be	VBN
18637	18557	46	resolved	resolve	VBN
18637	18557	47	in	in	IN
18637	18557	48	favor	favor	NN
18637	18557	49	of	of	IN
18637	18557	50	the	the	DT
18637	18557	51	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18557	52	clause	clause	NN
18637	18557	53	by	by	IN
18637	18557	54	Helson	Helson	NNP
18637	18557	55	and	and	CC
18637	18557	56	Randolph	Randolph	NNP
18637	18557	57	_	_	NNP
18637	18557	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	18557	59	_	_	NNP
18637	18557	60	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	18557	61	.	.	.
18637	18558	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18558	2	29	29	CD
18637	18558	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18558	4	Colgate	Colgate	NNP
18637	18558	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18558	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18558	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18558	8	Harvey,[30	Harvey,[30	VBD
18637	18558	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18558	10	however	however	RB
18637	18558	11	,	,	,
18637	18558	12	which	which	WDT
18637	18558	13	was	be	VBD
18637	18558	14	decided	decide	VBN
18637	18558	15	in	in	IN
18637	18558	16	1935	1935	CD
18637	18558	17	and	and	CC
18637	18558	18	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	18558	19	in	in	IN
18637	18558	20	1940,[31	1940,[31	CD
18637	18558	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18558	22	represented	represent	VBD
18637	18558	23	the	the	DT
18637	18558	24	first	first	JJ
18637	18558	25	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	18558	26	by	by	IN
18637	18558	27	the	the	DT
18637	18558	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18558	29	since	since	IN
18637	18558	30	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	18558	31	of	of	IN
18637	18558	32	the	the	DT
18637	18558	33	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18558	34	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18558	35	to	to	TO
18637	18558	36	convert	convert	VB
18637	18558	37	the	the	DT
18637	18558	38	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18558	39	and	and	CC
18637	18558	40	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	18558	41	clause	clause	NN
18637	18558	42	into	into	IN
18637	18558	43	a	a	DT
18637	18558	44	source	source	NN
18637	18558	45	of	of	IN
18637	18558	46	protection	protection	NN
18637	18558	47	of	of	IN
18637	18558	48	other	other	JJ
18637	18558	49	than	than	IN
18637	18558	50	those	those	DT
18637	18558	51	"	"	``
18637	18558	52	interests	interest	NNS
18637	18558	53	growing	grow	VBG
18637	18558	54	out	out	IN
18637	18558	55	of	of	IN
18637	18558	56	the	the	DT
18637	18558	57	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	18558	58	between	between	IN
18637	18558	59	the	the	DT
18637	18558	60	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18558	61	and	and	CC
18637	18558	62	the	the	DT
18637	18558	63	national	national	JJ
18637	18558	64	government	government	NN
18637	18558	65	.	.	.
18637	18558	66	"	"	''
18637	18559	1	Here	here	RB
18637	18559	2	the	the	DT
18637	18559	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18559	4	declared	declare	VBD
18637	18559	5	that	that	IN
18637	18559	6	the	the	DT
18637	18559	7	right	right	NN
18637	18559	8	of	of	IN
18637	18559	9	a	a	DT
18637	18559	10	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18559	11	,	,	,
18637	18559	12	resident	resident	NN
18637	18559	13	in	in	IN
18637	18559	14	one	one	CD
18637	18559	15	State	state	NN
18637	18559	16	,	,	,
18637	18559	17	to	to	TO
18637	18559	18	contract	contract	VB
18637	18559	19	in	in	IN
18637	18559	20	another	another	DT
18637	18559	21	,	,	,
18637	18559	22	to	to	TO
18637	18559	23	transact	transact	VB
18637	18559	24	any	any	DT
18637	18559	25	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	18559	26	business	business	NN
18637	18559	27	,	,	,
18637	18559	28	or	or	CC
18637	18559	29	to	to	TO
18637	18559	30	make	make	VB
18637	18559	31	a	a	DT
18637	18559	32	loan	loan	NN
18637	18559	33	of	of	IN
18637	18559	34	money	money	NN
18637	18559	35	,	,	,
18637	18559	36	in	in	IN
18637	18559	37	any	any	DT
18637	18559	38	State	State	NNP
18637	18559	39	other	other	JJ
18637	18559	40	than	than	IN
18637	18559	41	that	that	DT
18637	18559	42	in	in	IN
18637	18559	43	which	which	WDT
18637	18559	44	the	the	DT
18637	18559	45	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18559	46	resides	reside	VBZ
18637	18559	47	was	be	VBD
18637	18559	48	a	a	DT
18637	18559	49	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18559	50	of	of	IN
18637	18559	51	national	national	JJ
18637	18559	52	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18559	53	which	which	WDT
18637	18559	54	was	be	VBD
18637	18559	55	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	18559	56	by	by	IN
18637	18559	57	a	a	DT
18637	18559	58	State	State	NNP
18637	18559	59	income	income	NN
18637	18559	60	tax	tax	NN
18637	18559	61	law	law	NN
18637	18559	62	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	18559	63	from	from	IN
18637	18559	64	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	18559	65	income	income	NN
18637	18559	66	interest	interest	NN
18637	18559	67	received	receive	VBN
18637	18559	68	on	on	IN
18637	18559	69	money	money	NN
18637	18559	70	loaned	loan	VBN
18637	18559	71	within	within	IN
18637	18559	72	the	the	DT
18637	18559	73	State	State	NNP
18637	18559	74	.	.	.
18637	18560	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18560	2	32	32	CD
18637	18560	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18560	4	Whether	whether	IN
18637	18560	5	or	or	CC
18637	18560	6	not	not	RB
18637	18560	7	this	this	DT
18637	18560	8	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	18560	9	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	18560	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	18560	11	again	again	RB
18637	18560	12	to	to	TO
18637	18560	13	be	be	VB
18637	18560	14	revived	revive	VBN
18637	18560	15	and	and	CC
18637	18560	16	the	the	DT
18637	18560	17	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18560	18	and	and	CC
18637	18560	19	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	18560	20	clause	clause	NN
18637	18560	21	again	again	RB
18637	18560	22	placed	place	VBN
18637	18560	23	in	in	IN
18637	18560	24	readiness	readiness	NN
18637	18560	25	for	for	IN
18637	18560	26	further	further	JJ
18637	18560	27	expansion	expansion	NN
18637	18560	28	can	can	MD
18637	18560	29	not	not	RB
18637	18560	30	yet	yet	RB
18637	18560	31	be	be	VB
18637	18560	32	determined	determine	VBN
18637	18560	33	with	with	IN
18637	18560	34	assurance	assurance	NN
18637	18560	35	;	;	:
18637	18560	36	but	but	CC
18637	18560	37	in	in	IN
18637	18560	38	Oyama	Oyama	NNP
18637	18560	39	_	_	NNP
18637	18560	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	18560	41	_	_	NNP
18637	18560	42	California,[33	California,[33	NNP
18637	18560	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18560	44	decided	decide	VBD
18637	18560	45	in	in	IN
18637	18560	46	1948	1948	CD
18637	18560	47	,	,	,
18637	18560	48	the	the	DT
18637	18560	49	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18560	50	,	,	,
18637	18560	51	in	in	IN
18637	18560	52	a	a	DT
18637	18560	53	single	single	JJ
18637	18560	54	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	18560	55	,	,	,
18637	18560	56	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	18560	57	the	the	DT
18637	18560	58	contention	contention	NN
18637	18560	59	of	of	IN
18637	18560	60	a	a	DT
18637	18560	61	native	native	NN
18637	18560	62	-	-	HYPH
18637	18560	63	born	bear	VBN
18637	18560	64	youth	youth	NN
18637	18560	65	that	that	IN
18637	18560	66	California	California	NNP
18637	18560	67	's	's	POS
18637	18560	68	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	18560	69	Land	Land	NNP
18637	18560	70	Law	Law	NNP
18637	18560	71	,	,	,
18637	18560	72	applied	apply	VBD
18637	18560	73	so	so	IN
18637	18560	74	as	as	IN
18637	18560	75	to	to	TO
18637	18560	76	work	work	VB
18637	18560	77	a	a	DT
18637	18560	78	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	18560	79	of	of	IN
18637	18560	80	property	property	NN
18637	18560	81	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	18560	82	in	in	IN
18637	18560	83	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18560	84	name	name	NN
18637	18560	85	with	with	IN
18637	18560	86	funds	fund	NNS
18637	18560	87	advanced	advance	VBN
18637	18560	88	by	by	IN
18637	18560	89	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18560	90	parent	parent	NN
18637	18560	91	,	,	,
18637	18560	92	a	a	DT
18637	18560	93	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	18560	94	alien	alien	NN
18637	18560	95	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	18560	96	to	to	TO
18637	18560	97	citizenship	citizenship	VB
18637	18560	98	and	and	CC
18637	18560	99	precluded	preclude	VBD
18637	18560	100	from	from	IN
18637	18560	101	owning	own	VBG
18637	18560	102	land	land	NN
18637	18560	103	by	by	IN
18637	18560	104	the	the	DT
18637	18560	105	terms	term	NNS
18637	18560	106	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18560	107	,	,	,
18637	18560	108	deprived	deprive	VBD
18637	18560	109	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18560	110	"	"	``
18637	18560	111	of	of	IN
18637	18560	112	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18560	113	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18560	114	as	as	IN
18637	18560	115	an	an	DT
18637	18560	116	American	american	JJ
18637	18560	117	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18560	118	.	.	.
18637	18560	119	"	"	''
18637	18561	1	In	in	IN
18637	18561	2	none	none	NN
18637	18561	3	of	of	IN
18637	18561	4	the	the	DT
18637	18561	5	previous	previous	JJ
18637	18561	6	enumerations	enumeration	NNS
18637	18561	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	18561	8	the	the	DT
18637	18561	9	right	right	NN
18637	18561	10	to	to	TO
18637	18561	11	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	18561	12	and	and	CC
18637	18561	13	retain	retain	VB
18637	18561	14	property	property	NN
18637	18561	15	been	be	VBN
18637	18561	16	set	set	VBN
18637	18561	17	forth	forth	RP
18637	18561	18	as	as	IN
18637	18561	19	one	one	CD
18637	18561	20	of	of	IN
18637	18561	21	the	the	DT
18637	18561	22	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18561	23	of	of	IN
18637	18561	24	American	american	JJ
18637	18561	25	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18561	26	protected	protect	VBD
18637	18561	27	against	against	IN
18637	18561	28	State	State	NNP
18637	18561	29	abridgment	abridgment	NN
18637	18561	30	;	;	:
18637	18561	31	nor	nor	CC
18637	18561	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	18561	33	any	any	DT
18637	18561	34	connection	connection	NN
18637	18561	35	readily	readily	RB
18637	18561	36	discernible	discernible	JJ
18637	18561	37	between	between	IN
18637	18561	38	this	this	DT
18637	18561	39	right	right	NN
18637	18561	40	and	and	CC
18637	18561	41	the	the	DT
18637	18561	42	"	"	``
18637	18561	43	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	18561	44	between	between	IN
18637	18561	45	the	the	DT
18637	18561	46	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18561	47	and	and	CC
18637	18561	48	the	the	DT
18637	18561	49	national	national	JJ
18637	18561	50	government	government	NN
18637	18561	51	.	.	.
18637	18561	52	"	"	''
18637	18562	1	However	however	RB
18637	18562	2	,	,	,
18637	18562	3	the	the	DT
18637	18562	4	right	right	NN
18637	18562	5	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	18562	6	by	by	IN
18637	18562	7	Oyama	Oyama	NNP
18637	18562	8	was	be	VBD
18637	18562	9	supported	support	VBN
18637	18562	10	by	by	IN
18637	18562	11	a	a	DT
18637	18562	12	"	"	``
18637	18562	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18562	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	18562	15	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	18562	16	before	before	IN
18637	18562	17	the	the	DT
18637	18562	18	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18562	19	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18562	20	"	"	''
18637	18562	21	which	which	WDT
18637	18562	22	provided	provide	VBD
18637	18562	23	that	that	IN
18637	18562	24	"	"	``
18637	18562	25	all	all	DT
18637	18562	26	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18562	27	of	of	IN
18637	18562	28	the	the	DT
18637	18562	29	United	United	NNP
18637	18562	30	States	States	NNP
18637	18562	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	18562	32	have	have	VB
18637	18562	33	the	the	DT
18637	18562	34	same	same	JJ
18637	18562	35	right	right	NN
18637	18562	36	,	,	,
18637	18562	37	in	in	IN
18637	18562	38	every	every	DT
18637	18562	39	State	State	NNP
18637	18562	40	and	and	CC
18637	18562	41	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	18562	42	,	,	,
18637	18562	43	as	as	IN
18637	18562	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	18562	45	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
18637	18562	46	by	by	IN
18637	18562	47	white	white	JJ
18637	18562	48	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18562	49	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18562	50	to	to	IN
18637	18562	51	*	*	NFP
18637	18562	52	*	*	NFP
18637	18562	53	*	*	NFP
18637	18562	54	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	18562	55	,	,	,
18637	18562	56	*	*	NFP
18637	18562	57	*	*	NFP
18637	18562	58	*	*	NFP
18637	18562	59	and	and	CC
18637	18562	60	hold	hold	VB
18637	18562	61	*	*	NFP
18637	18562	62	*	*	NFP
18637	18562	63	*	*	NFP
18637	18562	64	real	real	JJ
18637	18562	65	*	*	NFP
18637	18562	66	*	*	NFP
18637	18562	67	*	*	NFP
18637	18562	68	property	property	NN
18637	18562	69	.	.	.
18637	18563	1	"	"	``
18637	18563	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18563	3	34	34	CD
18637	18563	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18563	5	PRIVILEGES	privileges	NN
18637	18563	6	HELD	HELD	NNP
18637	18563	7	NOT	not	RB
18637	18563	8	WITHIN	within	IN
18637	18563	9	THE	the	DT
18637	18563	10	PROTECTION	PROTECTION	NNP
18637	18563	11	OF	of	IN
18637	18563	12	THE	the	DT
18637	18563	13	CLAUSE	CLAUSE	NNP
18637	18563	14	In	in	IN
18637	18563	15	the	the	DT
18637	18563	16	following	follow	VBG
18637	18563	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	18563	18	State	State	NNP
18637	18563	19	action	action	NN
18637	18563	20	was	be	VBD
18637	18563	21	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	18563	22	against	against	IN
18637	18563	23	the	the	DT
18637	18563	24	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	18563	25	that	that	WDT
18637	18563	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18563	27	abridged	abridge	VBD
18637	18563	28	the	the	DT
18637	18563	29	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	18563	30	or	or	CC
18637	18563	31	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18563	32	of	of	IN
18637	18563	33	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18563	34	of	of	IN
18637	18563	35	the	the	DT
18637	18563	36	United	United	NNP
18637	18563	37	States	States	NNP
18637	18563	38	:	:	:
18637	18563	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18563	40	1	1	LS
18637	18563	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18563	42	Statute	statute	NN
18637	18563	43	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	18563	44	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18563	45	of	of	IN
18637	18563	46	labor	labor	NN
18637	18563	47	in	in	IN
18637	18563	48	mines	mine	NNS
18637	18563	49	.	.	.
18637	18564	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18564	2	35	35	CD
18637	18564	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18564	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18564	5	2	2	LS
18637	18564	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18564	7	Statute	statute	NN
18637	18564	8	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	18564	9	the	the	DT
18637	18564	10	business	business	NN
18637	18564	11	of	of	IN
18637	18564	12	hiring	hire	VBG
18637	18564	13	persons	person	NNS
18637	18564	14	to	to	IN
18637	18564	15	labor	labor	NN
18637	18564	16	outside	outside	IN
18637	18564	17	the	the	DT
18637	18564	18	State	State	NNP
18637	18564	19	.	.	.
18637	18565	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18565	2	36	36	CD
18637	18565	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18565	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18565	5	3	3	LS
18637	18565	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18565	7	Statute	statute	NN
18637	18565	8	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18565	9	employment	employment	NN
18637	18565	10	of	of	IN
18637	18565	11	only	only	RB
18637	18565	12	licensed	license	VBN
18637	18565	13	mine	mine	NN
18637	18565	14	managers	manager	NNS
18637	18565	15	and	and	CC
18637	18565	16	examiners	examiner	NNS
18637	18565	17	,	,	,
18637	18565	18	and	and	CC
18637	18565	19	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	18565	20	liability	liability	NN
18637	18565	21	on	on	IN
18637	18565	22	the	the	DT
18637	18565	23	mine	mine	NN
18637	18565	24	owner	owner	NN
18637	18565	25	for	for	IN
18637	18565	26	failure	failure	NN
18637	18565	27	to	to	TO
18637	18565	28	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	18565	29	a	a	DT
18637	18565	30	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	18565	31	safe	safe	JJ
18637	18565	32	place	place	NN
18637	18565	33	for	for	IN
18637	18565	34	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	18565	35	.	.	.
18637	18566	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18566	2	37	37	CD
18637	18566	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18566	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18566	5	4	4	LS
18637	18566	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18566	7	Statute	statute	NN
18637	18566	8	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	18566	9	employment	employment	NN
18637	18566	10	under	under	IN
18637	18566	11	public	public	JJ
18637	18566	12	works	work	NNS
18637	18566	13	of	of	IN
18637	18566	14	the	the	DT
18637	18566	15	State	State	NNP
18637	18566	16	to	to	IN
18637	18566	17	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18566	18	of	of	IN
18637	18566	19	the	the	DT
18637	18566	20	United	United	NNP
18637	18566	21	States	States	NNP
18637	18566	22	,	,	,
18637	18566	23	with	with	IN
18637	18566	24	a	a	DT
18637	18566	25	preference	preference	NN
18637	18566	26	to	to	IN
18637	18566	27	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18566	28	of	of	IN
18637	18566	29	the	the	DT
18637	18566	30	State	State	NNP
18637	18566	31	.	.	.
18637	18567	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18567	2	38	38	CD
18637	18567	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18567	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18567	5	5	5	LS
18637	18567	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18567	7	Statute	statute	NN
18637	18567	8	making	make	VBG
18637	18567	9	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	18567	10	liable	liable	JJ
18637	18567	11	to	to	IN
18637	18567	12	employees	employee	NNS
18637	18567	13	for	for	IN
18637	18567	14	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	18567	15	caused	cause	VBN
18637	18567	16	by	by	IN
18637	18567	17	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	18567	18	of	of	IN
18637	18567	19	fellow	fellow	JJ
18637	18567	20	servants	servant	NNS
18637	18567	21	,	,	,
18637	18567	22	and	and	CC
18637	18567	23	abolishing	abolish	VBG
18637	18567	24	the	the	DT
18637	18567	25	defense	defense	NN
18637	18567	26	of	of	IN
18637	18567	27	contributory	contributory	JJ
18637	18567	28	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	18567	29	.	.	.
18637	18568	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18568	2	39	39	CD
18637	18568	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18568	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18568	5	6	6	CD
18637	18568	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18568	7	Statute	statute	NN
18637	18568	8	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	18568	9	a	a	DT
18637	18568	10	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	18568	11	against	against	IN
18637	18568	12	liability	liability	NN
18637	18568	13	for	for	IN
18637	18568	14	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	18568	15	in	in	IN
18637	18568	16	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	18568	17	of	of	IN
18637	18568	18	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	18568	19	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	18568	20	messages	message	NNS
18637	18568	21	.	.	.
18637	18569	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18569	2	40	40	CD
18637	18569	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18569	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18569	5	7	7	LS
18637	18569	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18569	7	Refusal	Refusal	NNP
18637	18569	8	of	of	IN
18637	18569	9	State	State	NNP
18637	18569	10	court	court	NN
18637	18569	11	to	to	TO
18637	18569	12	license	license	VB
18637	18569	13	a	a	DT
18637	18569	14	woman	woman	NN
18637	18569	15	to	to	TO
18637	18569	16	practice	practice	VB
18637	18569	17	law	law	NN
18637	18569	18	.	.	.
18637	18570	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18570	2	41	41	CD
18637	18570	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18570	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18570	5	8)	8)	CD
18637	18570	6	Law	law	NN
18637	18570	7	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	18570	8	in	in	IN
18637	18570	9	the	the	DT
18637	18570	10	hands	hand	NNS
18637	18570	11	of	of	IN
18637	18570	12	a	a	DT
18637	18570	13	resident	resident	JJ
18637	18570	14	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18570	15	a	a	DT
18637	18570	16	debt	debt	NN
18637	18570	17	owing	owe	VBG
18637	18570	18	from	from	IN
18637	18570	19	a	a	DT
18637	18570	20	resident	resident	NN
18637	18570	21	of	of	IN
18637	18570	22	another	another	DT
18637	18570	23	State	state	NN
18637	18570	24	and	and	CC
18637	18570	25	secured	secure	VBN
18637	18570	26	by	by	IN
18637	18570	27	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	18570	28	of	of	IN
18637	18570	29	land	land	NN
18637	18570	30	in	in	IN
18637	18570	31	the	the	DT
18637	18570	32	debtors	debtor	NNS
18637	18570	33	'	'	POS
18637	18570	34	State	state	NN
18637	18570	35	.	.	.
18637	18571	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18571	2	42	42	CD
18637	18571	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18571	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18571	5	9	9	CD
18637	18571	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18571	7	Statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18571	8	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	18571	9	the	the	DT
18637	18571	10	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	18571	11	and	and	CC
18637	18571	12	sale	sale	NN
18637	18571	13	of	of	IN
18637	18571	14	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	18571	15	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	18571	16	.	.	.
18637	18572	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18572	2	43	43	CD
18637	18572	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18572	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18572	5	10	10	CD
18637	18572	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18572	7	Statute	statute	NN
18637	18572	8	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	18572	9	the	the	DT
18637	18572	10	method	method	NN
18637	18572	11	of	of	IN
18637	18572	12	capital	capital	JJ
18637	18572	13	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	18572	14	.	.	.
18637	18573	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18573	2	44	44	CD
18637	18573	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18573	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18573	5	11	11	CD
18637	18573	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18573	7	Statute	statute	NN
18637	18573	8	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	18573	9	the	the	DT
18637	18573	10	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	18573	11	to	to	IN
18637	18573	12	male	male	JJ
18637	18573	13	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18573	14	.	.	.
18637	18574	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18574	2	45	45	CD
18637	18574	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18574	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18574	5	12	12	CD
18637	18574	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18574	7	Statute	statute	NN
18637	18574	8	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18574	9	persons	person	NNS
18637	18574	10	coming	come	VBG
18637	18574	11	into	into	IN
18637	18574	12	a	a	DT
18637	18574	13	State	State	NNP
18637	18574	14	to	to	TO
18637	18574	15	make	make	VB
18637	18574	16	a	a	DT
18637	18574	17	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	18574	18	of	of	IN
18637	18574	19	intention	intention	NN
18637	18574	20	to	to	TO
18637	18574	21	become	become	VB
18637	18574	22	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18574	23	and	and	CC
18637	18574	24	residents	resident	NNS
18637	18574	25	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18574	26	before	before	IN
18637	18574	27	being	be	VBG
18637	18574	28	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	18574	29	to	to	TO
18637	18574	30	register	register	VB
18637	18574	31	as	as	IN
18637	18574	32	voters	voter	NNS
18637	18574	33	.	.	.
18637	18575	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18575	2	46	46	CD
18637	18575	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18575	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18575	5	13	13	CD
18637	18575	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18575	7	Statute	statute	NN
18637	18575	8	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	18575	9	dower	dower	NN
18637	18575	10	,	,	,
18637	18575	11	in	in	IN
18637	18575	12	case	case	NN
18637	18575	13	wife	wife	NN
18637	18575	14	at	at	IN
18637	18575	15	time	time	NN
18637	18575	16	of	of	IN
18637	18575	17	husband	husband	NN
18637	18575	18	's	's	POS
18637	18575	19	death	death	NN
18637	18575	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	18575	21	a	a	DT
18637	18575	22	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	18575	23	,	,	,
18637	18575	24	to	to	IN
18637	18575	25	lands	land	NNS
18637	18575	26	of	of	IN
18637	18575	27	which	which	WDT
18637	18575	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18575	29	died	die	VBD
18637	18575	30	seized	seize	VBD
18637	18575	31	.	.	.
18637	18576	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18576	2	47	47	CD
18637	18576	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18576	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18576	5	14	14	CD
18637	18576	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18576	7	Statute	statute	NN
18637	18576	8	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	18576	9	right	right	NN
18637	18576	10	to	to	IN
18637	18576	11	jury	jury	NN
18637	18576	12	trial	trial	NN
18637	18576	13	in	in	IN
18637	18576	14	civil	civil	JJ
18637	18576	15	suits	suit	NNS
18637	18576	16	at	at	IN
18637	18576	17	common	common	JJ
18637	18576	18	law	law	NN
18637	18576	19	.	.	.
18637	18577	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18577	2	48	48	CD
18637	18577	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18577	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18577	5	15	15	CD
18637	18577	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18577	7	Statute	statute	NN
18637	18577	8	restricting	restricting	NN
18637	18577	9	drilling	drilling	NN
18637	18577	10	or	or	CC
18637	18577	11	parading	parade	VBG
18637	18577	12	in	in	IN
18637	18577	13	any	any	DT
18637	18577	14	city	city	NN
18637	18577	15	by	by	IN
18637	18577	16	any	any	DT
18637	18577	17	body	body	NN
18637	18577	18	of	of	IN
18637	18577	19	men	man	NNS
18637	18577	20	without	without	IN
18637	18577	21	license	license	NN
18637	18577	22	of	of	IN
18637	18577	23	the	the	DT
18637	18577	24	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	18577	25	.	.	.
18637	18578	1	"	"	``
18637	18578	2	The	the	DT
18637	18578	3	right	right	UH
18637	18578	4	voluntarily	voluntarily	RB
18637	18578	5	to	to	TO
18637	18578	6	associate	associate	VB
18637	18578	7	together	together	RB
18637	18578	8	as	as	IN
18637	18578	9	a	a	DT
18637	18578	10	military	military	JJ
18637	18578	11	company	company	NN
18637	18578	12	or	or	CC
18637	18578	13	organization	organization	NN
18637	18578	14	,	,	,
18637	18578	15	or	or	CC
18637	18578	16	to	to	TO
18637	18578	17	drill	drill	VB
18637	18578	18	*	*	NFP
18637	18578	19	*	*	NFP
18637	18578	20	*	*	NFP
18637	18578	21	,	,	,
18637	18578	22	without	without	IN
18637	18578	23	,	,	,
18637	18578	24	and	and	CC
18637	18578	25	independent	independent	JJ
18637	18578	26	of	of	IN
18637	18578	27	,	,	,
18637	18578	28	an	an	DT
18637	18578	29	act	act	NN
18637	18578	30	of	of	IN
18637	18578	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18578	32	or	or	CC
18637	18578	33	law	law	NN
18637	18578	34	of	of	IN
18637	18578	35	the	the	DT
18637	18578	36	State	State	NNP
18637	18578	37	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	18578	38	the	the	DT
18637	18578	39	same	same	JJ
18637	18578	40	,	,	,
18637	18578	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	18578	42	not	not	RB
18637	18578	43	an	an	DT
18637	18578	44	attribute	attribute	NN
18637	18578	45	of	of	IN
18637	18578	46	national	national	JJ
18637	18578	47	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18578	48	.	.	.
18637	18579	1	"	"	``
18637	18579	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18579	3	49	49	CD
18637	18579	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18579	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18579	6	16	16	CD
18637	18579	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18579	8	Provision	provision	NN
18637	18579	9	for	for	IN
18637	18579	10	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	18579	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	18579	12	information	information	NN
18637	18579	13	,	,	,
18637	18579	14	and	and	CC
18637	18579	15	for	for	IN
18637	18579	16	a	a	DT
18637	18579	17	jury	jury	NN
18637	18579	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18579	19	except	except	IN
18637	18579	20	in	in	IN
18637	18579	21	capital	capital	NN
18637	18579	22	cases	case	NNS
18637	18579	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18579	24	of	of	IN
18637	18579	25	eight	eight	CD
18637	18579	26	persons	person	NNS
18637	18579	27	.	.	.
18637	18580	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18580	2	50	50	CD
18637	18580	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18580	4	Upon	upon	IN
18637	18580	5	an	an	DT
18637	18580	6	extended	extended	JJ
18637	18580	7	review	review	NN
18637	18580	8	of	of	IN
18637	18580	9	the	the	DT
18637	18580	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	18580	11	,	,	,
18637	18580	12	the	the	DT
18637	18580	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18580	14	held	hold	VBD
18637	18580	15	that	that	IN
18637	18580	16	"	"	``
18637	18580	17	the	the	DT
18637	18580	18	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18580	19	and	and	CC
18637	18580	20	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	18580	21	of	of	IN
18637	18580	22	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18580	23	of	of	IN
18637	18580	24	the	the	DT
18637	18580	25	United	United	NNP
18637	18580	26	States	States	NNP
18637	18580	27	do	do	VBP
18637	18580	28	not	not	RB
18637	18580	29	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	18580	30	include	include	VB
18637	18580	31	all	all	PDT
18637	18580	32	the	the	DT
18637	18580	33	rights	right	NNS
18637	18580	34	protected	protect	VBN
18637	18580	35	by	by	IN
18637	18580	36	the	the	DT
18637	18580	37	first	first	JJ
18637	18580	38	eight	eight	CD
18637	18580	39	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	18580	40	to	to	IN
18637	18580	41	the	the	DT
18637	18580	42	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18580	43	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18580	44	against	against	IN
18637	18580	45	the	the	DT
18637	18580	46	powers	power	NNS
18637	18580	47	of	of	IN
18637	18580	48	the	the	DT
18637	18580	49	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18580	50	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18580	51	"	"	''
18637	18580	52	;	;	:
18637	18580	53	and	and	CC
18637	18580	54	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	18580	55	,	,	,
18637	18580	56	that	that	IN
18637	18580	57	the	the	DT
18637	18580	58	right	right	NN
18637	18580	59	to	to	TO
18637	18580	60	be	be	VB
18637	18580	61	tried	try	VBN
18637	18580	62	for	for	IN
18637	18580	63	an	an	DT
18637	18580	64	offense	offense	NN
18637	18580	65	only	only	RB
18637	18580	66	upon	upon	IN
18637	18580	67	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	18580	68	,	,	,
18637	18580	69	and	and	CC
18637	18580	70	by	by	IN
18637	18580	71	a	a	DT
18637	18580	72	jury	jury	NN
18637	18580	73	of	of	IN
18637	18580	74	12	12	CD
18637	18580	75	,	,	,
18637	18580	76	rests	rest	NNS
18637	18580	77	with	with	IN
18637	18580	78	the	the	DT
18637	18580	79	State	state	NN
18637	18580	80	governments	government	NNS
18637	18580	81	and	and	CC
18637	18580	82	is	be	VBZ
18637	18580	83	not	not	RB
18637	18580	84	protected	protect	VBN
18637	18580	85	by	by	IN
18637	18580	86	the	the	DT
18637	18580	87	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18580	88	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18580	89	.	.	.
18637	18581	1	"	"	``
18637	18581	2	Those	those	DT
18637	18581	3	are	be	VBP
18637	18581	4	not	not	RB
18637	18581	5	distinctly	distinctly	RB
18637	18581	6	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18581	7	or	or	CC
18637	18581	8	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	18581	9	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18581	10	of	of	IN
18637	18581	11	national	national	JJ
18637	18581	12	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18581	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18581	14	where	where	WRB
18637	18581	15	everyone	everyone	NN
18637	18581	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	18581	17	the	the	DT
18637	18581	18	same	same	JJ
18637	18581	19	as	as	IN
18637	18581	20	against	against	IN
18637	18581	21	the	the	DT
18637	18581	22	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18581	23	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18581	24	,	,	,
18637	18581	25	whether	whether	IN
18637	18581	26	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18581	27	or	or	CC
18637	18581	28	not	not	RB
18637	18581	29	.	.	.
18637	18581	30	"	"	''
18637	18582	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18582	2	,	,	,
18637	18582	3	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18582	4	from	from	IN
18637	18582	5	testimonial	testimonial	JJ
18637	18582	6	compulsion	compulsion	NN
18637	18582	7	,	,	,
18637	18582	8	or	or	CC
18637	18582	9	self	self	NN
18637	18582	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	18582	11	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	18582	12	,	,	,
18637	18582	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	18582	14	not	not	RB
18637	18582	15	"	"	``
18637	18582	16	an	an	DT
18637	18582	17	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	18582	18	that	that	WDT
18637	18582	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	18582	20	protected	protect	VBN
18637	18582	21	by	by	IN
18637	18582	22	the	the	DT
18637	18582	23	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18582	24	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18582	25	against	against	IN
18637	18582	26	State	state	NN
18637	18582	27	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	18582	28	.	.	.
18637	18583	1	"	"	``
18637	18583	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18583	3	51	51	CD
18637	18583	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18583	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18583	6	17	17	CD
18637	18583	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18583	8	Statute	statute	NN
18637	18583	9	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	18583	10	the	the	DT
18637	18583	11	becoming	become	VBG
18637	18583	12	or	or	CC
18637	18583	13	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	18583	14	a	a	DT
18637	18583	15	member	member	NN
18637	18583	16	of	of	IN
18637	18583	17	any	any	DT
18637	18583	18	oath	oath	NN
18637	18583	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	18583	20	bound	bind	VBN
18637	18583	21	association	association	NNP
18637	18583	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18583	23	other	other	JJ
18637	18583	24	than	than	IN
18637	18583	25	benevolent	benevolent	JJ
18637	18583	26	orders	order	NNS
18637	18583	27	,	,	,
18637	18583	28	etc	etc	FW
18637	18583	29	.	.	.
18637	18583	30	,	,	,
18637	18583	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18583	32	with	with	IN
18637	18583	33	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	18583	34	that	that	IN
18637	18583	35	the	the	DT
18637	18583	36	association	association	NN
18637	18583	37	has	have	VBZ
18637	18583	38	failed	fail	VBN
18637	18583	39	to	to	TO
18637	18583	40	file	file	VB
18637	18583	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18583	42	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	18583	43	and	and	CC
18637	18583	44	membership	membership	NN
18637	18583	45	lists	list	NNS
18637	18583	46	.	.	.
18637	18584	1	The	the	DT
18637	18584	2	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18584	3	of	of	IN
18637	18584	4	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	18584	5	a	a	DT
18637	18584	6	member	member	NN
18637	18584	7	of	of	IN
18637	18584	8	such	such	PDT
18637	18584	9	an	an	DT
18637	18584	10	association	association	NN
18637	18584	11	,	,	,
18637	18584	12	"	"	``
18637	18584	13	if	if	IN
18637	18584	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18584	15	be	be	VB
18637	18584	16	a	a	DT
18637	18584	17	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18584	18	arising	arise	VBG
18637	18584	19	out	out	IN
18637	18584	20	of	of	IN
18637	18584	21	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18584	22	at	at	RB
18637	18584	23	all	all	RB
18637	18584	24	,	,	,
18637	18584	25	"	"	``
18637	18584	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	18584	27	an	an	DT
18637	18584	28	incident	incident	NN
18637	18584	29	of	of	IN
18637	18584	30	State	State	NNP
18637	18584	31	rather	rather	RB
18637	18584	32	than	than	IN
18637	18584	33	United	United	NNP
18637	18584	34	States	States	NNP
18637	18584	35	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18584	36	.	.	.
18637	18585	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18585	2	52	52	CD
18637	18585	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18585	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18585	5	18	18	CD
18637	18585	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18585	7	Statute	Statute	NNP
18637	18585	8	allowing	allow	VBG
18637	18585	9	a	a	DT
18637	18585	10	State	state	NN
18637	18585	11	to	to	TO
18637	18585	12	appeal	appeal	VB
18637	18585	13	in	in	IN
18637	18585	14	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	18585	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	18585	16	for	for	IN
18637	18585	17	errors	error	NNS
18637	18585	18	of	of	IN
18637	18585	19	law	law	NN
18637	18585	20	and	and	CC
18637	18585	21	to	to	TO
18637	18585	22	retry	retry	VB
18637	18585	23	the	the	DT
18637	18585	24	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	18585	25	.	.	.
18637	18586	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18586	2	53	53	CD
18637	18586	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18586	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18586	5	19	19	CD
18637	18586	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18586	7	Statute	statute	NN
18637	18586	8	making	make	VBG
18637	18586	9	the	the	DT
18637	18586	10	payment	payment	NN
18637	18586	11	of	of	IN
18637	18586	12	poll	poll	NN
18637	18586	13	taxes	tax	VBZ
18637	18586	14	a	a	DT
18637	18586	15	prerequisite	prerequisite	NN
18637	18586	16	to	to	IN
18637	18586	17	the	the	DT
18637	18586	18	right	right	NN
18637	18586	19	to	to	TO
18637	18586	20	vote	vote	VB
18637	18586	21	.	.	.
18637	18587	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18587	2	54	54	CD
18637	18587	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18587	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18587	5	20	20	CD
18637	18587	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18587	7	Statute	statute	NN
18637	18587	8	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	18587	9	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	18587	10	in	in	IN
18637	18587	11	banks	bank	NNS
18637	18587	12	outside	outside	IN
18637	18587	13	the	the	DT
18637	18587	14	State	state	NN
18637	18587	15	are	be	VBP
18637	18587	16	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	18587	17	at	at	IN
18637	18587	18	50¢	50â¢	CD
18637	18587	19	per	per	IN
18637	18587	20	$	$	$
18637	18587	21	100	100	CD
18637	18587	22	and	and	CC
18637	18587	23	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	18587	24	in	in	IN
18637	18587	25	banks	bank	NNS
18637	18587	26	within	within	IN
18637	18587	27	the	the	DT
18637	18587	28	State	state	NN
18637	18587	29	are	be	VBP
18637	18587	30	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	18587	31	at	at	IN
18637	18587	32	10¢	10â¢	CD
18637	18587	33	per	per	IN
18637	18587	34	$	$	$
18637	18587	35	100	100	CD
18637	18587	36	.	.	.
18637	18588	1	"	"	``
18637	18588	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18588	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18588	4	*	*	NFP
18637	18588	5	the	the	DT
18637	18588	6	right	right	NN
18637	18588	7	to	to	TO
18637	18588	8	carry	carry	VB
18637	18588	9	out	out	RP
18637	18588	10	an	an	DT
18637	18588	11	incident	incident	NN
18637	18588	12	to	to	IN
18637	18588	13	a	a	DT
18637	18588	14	trade	trade	NN
18637	18588	15	,	,	,
18637	18588	16	business	business	NN
18637	18588	17	or	or	CC
18637	18588	18	calling	call	VBG
18637	18588	19	such	such	JJ
18637	18588	20	as	as	IN
18637	18588	21	the	the	DT
18637	18588	22	deposit	deposit	NN
18637	18588	23	of	of	IN
18637	18588	24	money	money	NN
18637	18588	25	in	in	IN
18637	18588	26	banks	bank	NNS
18637	18588	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	18588	28	not	not	RB
18637	18588	29	a	a	DT
18637	18588	30	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18588	31	of	of	IN
18637	18588	32	national	national	JJ
18637	18588	33	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18588	34	.	.	.
18637	18589	1	"	"	``
18637	18589	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18589	3	55	55	CD
18637	18589	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18589	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18589	6	21	21	LS
18637	18589	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18589	8	The	the	DT
18637	18589	9	right	right	NN
18637	18589	10	to	to	TO
18637	18589	11	become	become	VB
18637	18589	12	a	a	DT
18637	18589	13	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	18589	14	for	for	IN
18637	18589	15	State	State	NNP
18637	18589	16	office	office	NN
18637	18589	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	18589	18	a	a	DT
18637	18589	19	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18589	20	of	of	IN
18637	18589	21	State	State	NNP
18637	18589	22	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18589	23	,	,	,
18637	18589	24	not	not	RB
18637	18589	25	national	national	JJ
18637	18589	26	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18589	27	.	.	.
18637	18590	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18590	2	56	56	CD
18637	18590	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18590	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18590	5	22	22	CD
18637	18590	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18590	7	The	the	DT
18637	18590	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	18590	9	Election	Election	NNP
18637	18590	10	Code	Code	NNP
18637	18590	11	which	which	WDT
18637	18590	12	requires	require	VBZ
18637	18590	13	that	that	IN
18637	18590	14	a	a	DT
18637	18590	15	petition	petition	NN
18637	18590	16	to	to	TO
18637	18590	17	form	form	VB
18637	18590	18	and	and	CC
18637	18590	19	nominate	nominate	VB
18637	18590	20	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	18590	21	for	for	IN
18637	18590	22	a	a	DT
18637	18590	23	new	new	JJ
18637	18590	24	political	political	JJ
18637	18590	25	party	party	NN
18637	18590	26	be	be	VB
18637	18590	27	signed	sign	VBN
18637	18590	28	by	by	IN
18637	18590	29	at	at	RB
18637	18590	30	least	least	RBS
18637	18590	31	200	200	CD
18637	18590	32	voters	voter	NNS
18637	18590	33	from	from	IN
18637	18590	34	each	each	DT
18637	18590	35	of	of	IN
18637	18590	36	at	at	RB
18637	18590	37	least	least	JJS
18637	18590	38	50	50	CD
18637	18590	39	of	of	IN
18637	18590	40	the	the	DT
18637	18590	41	102	102	CD
18637	18590	42	counties	county	NNS
18637	18590	43	in	in	IN
18637	18590	44	the	the	DT
18637	18590	45	State	State	NNP
18637	18590	46	,	,	,
18637	18590	47	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	18590	48	that	that	IN
18637	18590	49	52	52	CD
18637	18590	50	%	%	NN
18637	18590	51	of	of	IN
18637	18590	52	the	the	DT
18637	18590	53	voters	voter	NNS
18637	18590	54	reside	reside	VBP
18637	18590	55	in	in	IN
18637	18590	56	only	only	RB
18637	18590	57	one	one	CD
18637	18590	58	county	county	NN
18637	18590	59	and	and	CC
18637	18590	60	87	87	CD
18637	18590	61	%	%	NN
18637	18590	62	,	,	,
18637	18590	63	in	in	IN
18637	18590	64	the	the	DT
18637	18590	65	49	49	CD
18637	18590	66	most	most	RBS
18637	18590	67	populous	populous	JJ
18637	18590	68	counties	county	NNS
18637	18590	69	.	.	.
18637	18591	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18591	2	57	57	CD
18637	18591	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18591	4	Due	Due	NNP
18637	18591	5	Process	Process	NNP
18637	18591	6	of	of	IN
18637	18591	7	Law	Law	NNP
18637	18591	8	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	18591	9	HISTORICAL	HISTORICAL	NNP
18637	18591	10	DEVELOPMENT	DEVELOPMENT	NNP
18637	18591	11	Although	although	IN
18637	18591	12	many	many	JJ
18637	18591	13	years	year	NNS
18637	18591	14	after	after	IN
18637	18591	15	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	18591	16	the	the	DT
18637	18591	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18591	18	ventured	venture	VBD
18637	18591	19	the	the	DT
18637	18591	20	not	not	RB
18637	18591	21	very	very	RB
18637	18591	22	informative	informative	JJ
18637	18591	23	observation	observation	NN
18637	18591	24	that	that	IN
18637	18591	25	the	the	DT
18637	18591	26	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18591	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18591	28	"	"	''
18637	18591	29	operates	operate	VBZ
18637	18591	30	to	to	TO
18637	18591	31	extend	extend	VB
18637	18591	32	*	*	NFP
18637	18591	33	*	*	NFP
18637	18591	34	*	*	NFP
18637	18591	35	the	the	DT
18637	18591	36	same	same	JJ
18637	18591	37	protection	protection	NN
18637	18591	38	against	against	IN
18637	18591	39	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18591	40	State	State	NNP
18637	18591	41	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18591	42	,	,	,
18637	18591	43	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	18591	44	life	life	NN
18637	18591	45	,	,	,
18637	18591	46	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18591	47	and	and	CC
18637	18591	48	property	property	NN
18637	18591	49	,	,	,
18637	18591	50	as	as	IN
18637	18591	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	18591	52	offered	offer	VBN
18637	18591	53	by	by	IN
18637	18591	54	the	the	DT
18637	18591	55	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	18591	56	Amendment,"[58	Amendment,"[58	NNP
18637	18591	57	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18591	58	and	and	CC
18637	18591	59	that	that	IN
18637	18591	60	"	"	``
18637	18591	61	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	18591	62	if	if	IN
18637	18591	63	an	an	DT
18637	18591	64	act	act	NN
18637	18591	65	of	of	IN
18637	18591	66	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	18591	67	is	be	VBZ
18637	18591	68	valid	valid	JJ
18637	18591	69	under	under	IN
18637	18591	70	the	the	DT
18637	18591	71	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	18591	72	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18591	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18591	74	would	would	MD
18637	18591	75	be	be	VB
18637	18591	76	hard	hard	JJ
18637	18591	77	to	to	TO
18637	18591	78	say	say	VB
18637	18591	79	that	that	IN
18637	18591	80	a	a	DT
18637	18591	81	State	State	NNP
18637	18591	82	law	law	NN
18637	18591	83	in	in	IN
18637	18591	84	like	like	IN
18637	18591	85	terms	term	NNS
18637	18591	86	was	be	VBD
18637	18591	87	void	void	JJ
18637	18591	88	under	under	IN
18637	18591	89	the	the	DT
18637	18591	90	Fourteenth,"[59	Fourteenth,"[59	NNP
18637	18591	91	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18591	92	the	the	DT
18637	18591	93	significance	significance	NN
18637	18591	94	of	of	IN
18637	18591	95	the	the	DT
18637	18591	96	due	due	JJ
18637	18591	97	process	process	NN
18637	18591	98	clause	clause	NN
18637	18591	99	as	as	IN
18637	18591	100	a	a	DT
18637	18591	101	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18591	102	on	on	IN
18637	18591	103	State	State	NNP
18637	18591	104	action	action	NN
18637	18591	105	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	18591	106	to	to	TO
18637	18591	107	have	have	VB
18637	18591	108	been	be	VBN
18637	18591	109	grossly	grossly	RB
18637	18591	110	underestimated	underestimate	VBN
18637	18591	111	by	by	IN
18637	18591	112	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	18591	113	no	no	DT
18637	18591	114	less	less	JJR
18637	18591	115	than	than	IN
18637	18591	116	by	by	IN
18637	18591	117	the	the	DT
18637	18591	118	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18591	119	in	in	IN
18637	18591	120	the	the	DT
18637	18591	121	years	year	NNS
18637	18591	122	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	18591	123	following	follow	VBG
18637	18591	124	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18591	125	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	18591	126	.	.	.
18637	18592	1	From	from	IN
18637	18592	2	the	the	DT
18637	18592	3	outset	outset	NN
18637	18592	4	of	of	IN
18637	18592	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18592	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18592	7	history	history	NN
18637	18592	8	due	due	JJ
18637	18592	9	process	process	NN
18637	18592	10	of	of	IN
18637	18592	11	law	law	NN
18637	18592	12	as	as	IN
18637	18592	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18592	14	occurs	occur	VBZ
18637	18592	15	in	in	IN
18637	18592	16	the	the	DT
18637	18592	17	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	18592	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18592	19	had	have	VBD
18637	18592	20	been	be	VBN
18637	18592	21	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	18592	22	as	as	IN
18637	18592	23	a	a	DT
18637	18592	24	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18592	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	18592	26	government	government	NN
18637	18592	27	,	,	,
18637	18592	28	but	but	CC
18637	18592	29	,	,	,
18637	18592	30	with	with	IN
18637	18592	31	one	one	CD
18637	18592	32	conspicuous	conspicuous	JJ
18637	18592	33	exception,[60	exception,[60	CD
18637	18592	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18592	35	only	only	RB
18637	18592	36	in	in	IN
18637	18592	37	the	the	DT
18637	18592	38	narrower	narrow	JJR
18637	18592	39	sense	sense	NN
18637	18592	40	that	that	IN
18637	18592	41	a	a	DT
18637	18592	42	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18592	43	must	must	MD
18637	18592	44	provide	provide	VB
18637	18592	45	"	"	``
18637	18592	46	due	due	JJ
18637	18592	47	process	process	NN
18637	18592	48	for	for	IN
18637	18592	49	the	the	DT
18637	18592	50	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18592	51	of	of	IN
18637	18592	52	law	law	NN
18637	18592	53	"	"	''
18637	18592	54	;	;	:
18637	18592	55	and	and	CC
18637	18592	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18592	57	was	be	VBD
18637	18592	58	in	in	IN
18637	18592	59	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	18592	60	with	with	IN
18637	18592	61	this	this	DT
18637	18592	62	limited	limited	JJ
18637	18592	63	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	18592	64	of	of	IN
18637	18592	65	the	the	DT
18637	18592	66	clause	clause	NN
18637	18592	67	that	that	WDT
18637	18592	68	the	the	DT
18637	18592	69	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18592	70	disposed	dispose	VBD
18637	18592	71	of	of	IN
18637	18592	72	early	early	JJ
18637	18592	73	cases	case	NNS
18637	18592	74	arising	arise	VBG
18637	18592	75	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	18592	76	.	.	.
18637	18593	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18593	2	,	,	,
18637	18593	3	in	in	IN
18637	18593	4	the	the	DT
18637	18593	5	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	18593	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	18593	7	House	House	NNP
18637	18593	8	Cases,[61	cases,[61	NN
18637	18593	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18593	10	in	in	IN
18637	18593	11	which	which	WDT
18637	18593	12	the	the	DT
18637	18593	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	18593	14	was	be	VBD
18637	18593	15	timidly	timidly	RB
18637	18593	16	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	18593	17	by	by	IN
18637	18593	18	a	a	DT
18637	18593	19	group	group	NN
18637	18593	20	of	of	IN
18637	18593	21	butchers	butcher	NNS
18637	18593	22	challenging	challenge	VBG
18637	18593	23	on	on	IN
18637	18593	24	several	several	JJ
18637	18593	25	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	18593	26	the	the	DT
18637	18593	27	validity	validity	NN
18637	18593	28	of	of	IN
18637	18593	29	a	a	DT
18637	18593	30	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	18593	31	statute	statute	NN
18637	18593	32	which	which	WDT
18637	18593	33	conferred	confer	VBD
18637	18593	34	upon	upon	IN
18637	18593	35	one	one	CD
18637	18593	36	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18593	37	the	the	DT
18637	18593	38	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	18593	39	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18593	40	of	of	IN
18637	18593	41	butchering	butcher	VBG
18637	18593	42	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	18593	43	in	in	IN
18637	18593	44	New	New	NNP
18637	18593	45	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	18593	46	,	,	,
18637	18593	47	the	the	DT
18637	18593	48	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18593	49	declared	declare	VBD
18637	18593	50	that	that	IN
18637	18593	51	the	the	DT
18637	18593	52	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	18593	53	against	against	IN
18637	18593	54	a	a	DT
18637	18593	55	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18593	56	of	of	IN
18637	18593	57	property	property	NN
18637	18593	58	"	"	''
18637	18593	59	has	have	VBZ
18637	18593	60	been	be	VBN
18637	18593	61	in	in	IN
18637	18593	62	the	the	DT
18637	18593	63	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18593	64	since	since	IN
18637	18593	65	the	the	DT
18637	18593	66	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	18593	67	of	of	IN
18637	18593	68	the	the	DT
18637	18593	69	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	18593	70	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18593	71	,	,	,
18637	18593	72	as	as	IN
18637	18593	73	a	a	DT
18637	18593	74	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18593	75	upon	upon	IN
18637	18593	76	the	the	DT
18637	18593	77	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18593	78	power	power	NN
18637	18593	79	.	.	.
18637	18594	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18594	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	18594	3	also	also	RB
18637	18594	4	to	to	TO
18637	18594	5	be	be	VB
18637	18594	6	found	find	VBN
18637	18594	7	in	in	IN
18637	18594	8	some	some	DT
18637	18594	9	form	form	NN
18637	18594	10	of	of	IN
18637	18594	11	expression	expression	NN
18637	18594	12	in	in	IN
18637	18594	13	the	the	DT
18637	18594	14	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	18594	15	of	of	IN
18637	18594	16	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	18594	17	all	all	PDT
18637	18594	18	the	the	DT
18637	18594	19	States	States	NNPS
18637	18594	20	,	,	,
18637	18594	21	as	as	IN
18637	18594	22	a	a	DT
18637	18594	23	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18594	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	18594	25	the	the	DT
18637	18594	26	power	power	NN
18637	18594	27	of	of	IN
18637	18594	28	the	the	DT
18637	18594	29	States	States	NNP
18637	18594	30	.	.	.
18637	18595	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18595	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18595	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18595	4	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18595	5	are	be	VBP
18637	18595	6	not	not	RB
18637	18595	7	without	without	IN
18637	18595	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18595	9	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	18595	10	,	,	,
18637	18595	11	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	18595	12	,	,	,
18637	18595	13	both	both	CC
18637	18595	14	State	State	NNP
18637	18595	15	and	and	CC
18637	18595	16	National	National	NNP
18637	18595	17	,	,	,
18637	18595	18	of	of	IN
18637	18595	19	the	the	DT
18637	18595	20	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	18595	21	of	of	IN
18637	18595	22	this	this	DT
18637	18595	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	18595	24	.	.	.
18637	18596	1	And	and	CC
18637	18596	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18596	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	18596	4	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	18596	5	to	to	TO
18637	18596	6	say	say	VB
18637	18596	7	that	that	IN
18637	18596	8	under	under	IN
18637	18596	9	no	no	DT
18637	18596	10	construction	construction	NN
18637	18596	11	of	of	IN
18637	18596	12	that	that	DT
18637	18596	13	provision	provision	NN
18637	18596	14	that	that	IN
18637	18596	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18596	16	have	have	VBP
18637	18596	17	ever	ever	RB
18637	18596	18	seen	see	VBN
18637	18596	19	,	,	,
18637	18596	20	or	or	CC
18637	18596	21	any	any	DT
18637	18596	22	that	that	IN
18637	18596	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18596	24	deem	deem	VBP
18637	18596	25	admissible	admissible	JJ
18637	18596	26	,	,	,
18637	18596	27	can	can	MD
18637	18596	28	the	the	DT
18637	18596	29	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18596	30	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18596	31	by	by	IN
18637	18596	32	the	the	DT
18637	18596	33	State	State	NNP
18637	18596	34	of	of	IN
18637	18596	35	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	18596	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	18596	37	the	the	DT
18637	18596	38	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18596	39	of	of	IN
18637	18596	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18596	41	trade	trade	NN
18637	18596	42	by	by	IN
18637	18596	43	the	the	DT
18637	18596	44	butchers	butcher	NNS
18637	18596	45	of	of	IN
18637	18596	46	New	New	NNP
18637	18596	47	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	18596	48	be	be	VB
18637	18596	49	held	hold	VBN
18637	18596	50	to	to	TO
18637	18596	51	be	be	VB
18637	18596	52	a	a	DT
18637	18596	53	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18596	54	of	of	IN
18637	18596	55	property	property	NN
18637	18596	56	within	within	IN
18637	18596	57	the	the	DT
18637	18596	58	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	18596	59	of	of	IN
18637	18596	60	that	that	DT
18637	18596	61	provision	provision	NN
18637	18596	62	.	.	.
18637	18597	1	"	"	``
18637	18597	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18597	3	62	62	CD
18637	18597	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18597	5	Four	four	CD
18637	18597	6	years	year	NNS
18637	18597	7	later	later	RB
18637	18597	8	,	,	,
18637	18597	9	in	in	IN
18637	18597	10	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	18597	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18597	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	18597	13	_	_	NNP
18637	18597	14	Illinois,[63	Illinois,[63	NNP
18637	18597	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18597	16	the	the	DT
18637	18597	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18597	18	again	again	RB
18637	18597	19	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	18597	20	to	to	TO
18637	18597	21	interpret	interpret	VB
18637	18597	22	the	the	DT
18637	18597	23	due	due	JJ
18637	18597	24	process	process	NN
18637	18597	25	clause	clause	NN
18637	18597	26	as	as	IN
18637	18597	27	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
18637	18597	28	State	State	NNP
18637	18597	29	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18597	30	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	18597	31	the	the	DT
18637	18597	32	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18597	33	charged	charge	VBN
18637	18597	34	for	for	IN
18637	18597	35	the	the	DT
18637	18597	36	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	18597	37	and	and	CC
18637	18597	38	warehousing	warehousing	NN
18637	18597	39	of	of	IN
18637	18597	40	grain	grain	NN
18637	18597	41	.	.	.
18637	18598	1	Overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	18598	2	contentions	contention	NNS
18637	18598	3	that	that	IN
18637	18598	4	such	such	JJ
18637	18598	5	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18598	6	effected	effect	VBD
18637	18598	7	an	an	DT
18637	18598	8	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18598	9	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18598	10	of	of	IN
18637	18598	11	property	property	NN
18637	18598	12	by	by	IN
18637	18598	13	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	18598	14	the	the	DT
18637	18598	15	owner	owner	NN
18637	18598	16	from	from	IN
18637	18598	17	earning	earn	VBG
18637	18598	18	a	a	DT
18637	18598	19	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18598	20	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18598	21	for	for	IN
18637	18598	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18598	23	use	use	NN
18637	18598	24	and	and	CC
18637	18598	25	by	by	IN
18637	18598	26	transferring	transfer	VBG
18637	18598	27	to	to	IN
18637	18598	28	the	the	DT
18637	18598	29	public	public	NN
18637	18598	30	an	an	DT
18637	18598	31	interest	interest	NN
18637	18598	32	in	in	IN
18637	18598	33	a	a	DT
18637	18598	34	private	private	JJ
18637	18598	35	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	18598	36	,	,	,
18637	18598	37	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	18598	38	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18598	39	Waite	Waite	NNP
18637	18598	40	emphasized	emphasize	VBD
18637	18598	41	that	that	IN
18637	18598	42	"	"	``
18637	18598	43	the	the	DT
18637	18598	44	great	great	JJ
18637	18598	45	office	office	NN
18637	18598	46	of	of	IN
18637	18598	47	statutes	statutes	NNPS
18637	18598	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	18598	49	to	to	TO
18637	18598	50	remedy	remedy	VB
18637	18598	51	defects	defect	NNS
18637	18598	52	in	in	IN
18637	18598	53	the	the	DT
18637	18598	54	common	common	JJ
18637	18598	55	law	law	NN
18637	18598	56	as	as	IN
18637	18598	57	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18598	58	are	be	VBP
18637	18598	59	developed	develop	VBN
18637	18598	60	,	,	,
18637	18598	61	*	*	NFP
18637	18598	62	*	*	NFP
18637	18598	63	*	*	NFP
18637	18598	64	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18598	65	know	know	VBP
18637	18598	66	that	that	IN
18637	18598	67	this	this	DT
18637	18598	68	power	power	NN
18637	18598	69	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18598	70	of	of	IN
18637	18598	71	rate	rate	NN
18637	18598	72	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18598	73	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18598	74	may	may	MD
18637	18598	75	be	be	VB
18637	18598	76	abused	abuse	VBN
18637	18598	77	;	;	:
18637	18598	78	but	but	CC
18637	18598	79	that	that	DT
18637	18598	80	is	be	VBZ
18637	18598	81	no	no	DT
18637	18598	82	argument	argument	NN
18637	18598	83	against	against	IN
18637	18598	84	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18598	85	existence	existence	NN
18637	18598	86	.	.	.
18637	18599	1	For	for	IN
18637	18599	2	protection	protection	NN
18637	18599	3	against	against	IN
18637	18599	4	abuses	abuse	NNS
18637	18599	5	by	by	IN
18637	18599	6	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	18599	7	the	the	DT
18637	18599	8	people	people	NNS
18637	18599	9	must	must	MD
18637	18599	10	resort	resort	VB
18637	18599	11	to	to	IN
18637	18599	12	the	the	DT
18637	18599	13	polls	poll	NNS
18637	18599	14	,	,	,
18637	18599	15	not	not	RB
18637	18599	16	to	to	IN
18637	18599	17	the	the	DT
18637	18599	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	18599	19	.	.	.
18637	18600	1	"	"	``
18637	18600	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18600	3	64	64	CD
18637	18600	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18600	5	Deploring	deplore	VBG
18637	18600	6	such	such	JJ
18637	18600	7	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	18600	8	,	,	,
18637	18600	9	nullified	nullify	VBD
18637	18600	10	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	18600	11	in	in	IN
18637	18600	12	the	the	DT
18637	18600	13	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	18600	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	18600	15	,	,	,
18637	18600	16	to	to	TO
18637	18600	17	convert	convert	VB
18637	18600	18	the	the	DT
18637	18600	19	due	due	JJ
18637	18600	20	process	process	NN
18637	18600	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	18600	22	into	into	IN
18637	18600	23	a	a	DT
18637	18600	24	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	18600	25	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18600	26	on	on	IN
18637	18600	27	the	the	DT
18637	18600	28	powers	power	NNS
18637	18600	29	of	of	IN
18637	18600	30	the	the	DT
18637	18600	31	States	States	NNPS
18637	18600	32	,	,	,
18637	18600	33	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18600	34	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	18600	35	in	in	IN
18637	18600	36	Davidson	Davidson	NNP
18637	18600	37	_	_	NNP
18637	18600	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	18600	39	_	_	NNP
18637	18600	40	New	New	NNP
18637	18600	41	Orleans[65	Orleans[65	NNP
18637	18600	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18600	43	obliquely	obliquely	RB
18637	18600	44	counseled	counsel	VBN
18637	18600	45	against	against	IN
18637	18600	46	a	a	DT
18637	18600	47	departure	departure	NN
18637	18600	48	from	from	IN
18637	18600	49	the	the	DT
18637	18600	50	conventional	conventional	JJ
18637	18600	51	application	application	NN
18637	18600	52	of	of	IN
18637	18600	53	the	the	DT
18637	18600	54	clause	clause	NN
18637	18600	55	,	,	,
18637	18600	56	albeit	albeit	IN
18637	18600	57	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18600	58	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBD
18637	18600	59	the	the	DT
18637	18600	60	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	18600	61	of	of	IN
18637	18600	62	arriving	arrive	VBG
18637	18600	63	at	at	IN
18637	18600	64	a	a	DT
18637	18600	65	precise	precise	JJ
18637	18600	66	,	,	,
18637	18600	67	all	all	DT
18637	18600	68	inclusive	inclusive	JJ
18637	18600	69	,	,	,
18637	18600	70	definition	definition	NN
18637	18600	71	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18600	72	.	.	.
18637	18601	1	"	"	``
18637	18601	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18601	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	18601	4	not	not	RB
18637	18601	5	a	a	DT
18637	18601	6	little	little	JJ
18637	18601	7	remarkable	remarkable	JJ
18637	18601	8	,	,	,
18637	18601	9	"	"	''
18637	18601	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18601	11	observed	observe	VBD
18637	18601	12	,	,	,
18637	18601	13	"	"	``
18637	18601	14	that	that	IN
18637	18601	15	while	while	IN
18637	18601	16	this	this	DT
18637	18601	17	provision	provision	NN
18637	18601	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	18601	19	been	be	VBN
18637	18601	20	in	in	IN
18637	18601	21	the	the	DT
18637	18601	22	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18601	23	of	of	IN
18637	18601	24	the	the	DT
18637	18601	25	United	United	NNP
18637	18601	26	States	States	NNP
18637	18601	27	,	,	,
18637	18601	28	as	as	IN
18637	18601	29	a	a	DT
18637	18601	30	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18601	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	18601	32	the	the	DT
18637	18601	33	authority	authority	NN
18637	18601	34	of	of	IN
18637	18601	35	the	the	DT
18637	18601	36	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18601	37	Government	Government	NNP
18637	18601	38	,	,	,
18637	18601	39	for	for	IN
18637	18601	40	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	18601	41	a	a	DT
18637	18601	42	century	century	NN
18637	18601	43	,	,	,
18637	18601	44	and	and	CC
18637	18601	45	while	while	IN
18637	18601	46	,	,	,
18637	18601	47	during	during	IN
18637	18601	48	all	all	PDT
18637	18601	49	that	that	DT
18637	18601	50	time	time	NN
18637	18601	51	,	,	,
18637	18601	52	the	the	DT
18637	18601	53	manner	manner	NN
18637	18601	54	in	in	IN
18637	18601	55	which	which	WDT
18637	18601	56	the	the	DT
18637	18601	57	powers	power	NNS
18637	18601	58	of	of	IN
18637	18601	59	that	that	DT
18637	18601	60	government	government	NN
18637	18601	61	have	have	VBP
18637	18601	62	been	be	VBN
18637	18601	63	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	18601	64	has	have	VBZ
18637	18601	65	been	be	VBN
18637	18601	66	watched	watch	VBN
18637	18601	67	with	with	IN
18637	18601	68	jealousy	jealousy	NN
18637	18601	69	,	,	,
18637	18601	70	and	and	CC
18637	18601	71	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	18601	72	to	to	IN
18637	18601	73	the	the	DT
18637	18601	74	most	most	RBS
18637	18601	75	rigid	rigid	JJ
18637	18601	76	criticism	criticism	NN
18637	18601	77	in	in	IN
18637	18601	78	all	all	DT
18637	18601	79	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18601	80	branches	branch	NNS
18637	18601	81	,	,	,
18637	18601	82	this	this	DT
18637	18601	83	special	special	JJ
18637	18601	84	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	18601	85	upon	upon	IN
18637	18601	86	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18601	87	powers	power	NNS
18637	18601	88	has	have	VBZ
18637	18601	89	rarely	rarely	RB
18637	18601	90	been	be	VBN
18637	18601	91	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	18601	92	in	in	IN
18637	18601	93	the	the	DT
18637	18601	94	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18601	95	forum	forum	NN
18637	18601	96	or	or	CC
18637	18601	97	the	the	DT
18637	18601	98	more	more	RBR
18637	18601	99	enlarged	enlarged	JJ
18637	18601	100	theatre	theatre	NN
18637	18601	101	of	of	IN
18637	18601	102	public	public	JJ
18637	18601	103	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	18601	104	.	.	.
18637	18602	1	But	but	CC
18637	18602	2	while	while	IN
18637	18602	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18602	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	18602	5	been	be	VBN
18637	18602	6	part	part	NN
18637	18602	7	of	of	IN
18637	18602	8	the	the	DT
18637	18602	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18602	10	,	,	,
18637	18602	11	as	as	IN
18637	18602	12	a	a	DT
18637	18602	13	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18602	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	18602	15	the	the	DT
18637	18602	16	power	power	NN
18637	18602	17	of	of	IN
18637	18602	18	the	the	DT
18637	18602	19	States	States	NNPS
18637	18602	20	,	,	,
18637	18602	21	only	only	RB
18637	18602	22	a	a	DT
18637	18602	23	very	very	RB
18637	18602	24	few	few	JJ
18637	18602	25	years	year	NNS
18637	18602	26	,	,	,
18637	18602	27	the	the	DT
18637	18602	28	docket	docket	NN
18637	18602	29	of	of	IN
18637	18602	30	this	this	DT
18637	18602	31	court	court	NN
18637	18602	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	18602	33	crowded	crowd	VBN
18637	18602	34	with	with	IN
18637	18602	35	cases	case	NNS
18637	18602	36	in	in	IN
18637	18602	37	which	which	WDT
18637	18602	38	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18602	39	are	be	VBP
18637	18602	40	asked	ask	VBN
18637	18602	41	to	to	TO
18637	18602	42	hold	hold	VB
18637	18602	43	that	that	IN
18637	18602	44	State	State	NNP
18637	18602	45	courts	court	NNS
18637	18602	46	and	and	CC
18637	18602	47	State	state	NN
18637	18602	48	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	18602	49	have	have	VBP
18637	18602	50	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	18602	51	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18602	52	own	own	JJ
18637	18602	53	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18602	54	of	of	IN
18637	18602	55	life	life	NN
18637	18602	56	,	,	,
18637	18602	57	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18602	58	,	,	,
18637	18602	59	or	or	CC
18637	18602	60	property	property	NN
18637	18602	61	without	without	IN
18637	18602	62	due	due	JJ
18637	18602	63	process	process	NN
18637	18602	64	of	of	IN
18637	18602	65	law	law	NN
18637	18602	66	.	.	.
18637	18603	1	There	there	EX
18637	18603	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	18603	3	here	here	RB
18637	18603	4	abundant	abundant	JJ
18637	18603	5	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18603	6	that	that	IN
18637	18603	7	there	there	EX
18637	18603	8	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	18603	9	some	some	DT
18637	18603	10	strange	strange	JJ
18637	18603	11	misconception	misconception	NN
18637	18603	12	of	of	IN
18637	18603	13	the	the	DT
18637	18603	14	scope	scope	NN
18637	18603	15	of	of	IN
18637	18603	16	this	this	DT
18637	18603	17	provision	provision	NN
18637	18603	18	as	as	IN
18637	18603	19	found	find	VBN
18637	18603	20	in	in	IN
18637	18603	21	the	the	DT
18637	18603	22	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18603	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18603	24	.	.	.
18637	18604	1	In	in	IN
18637	18604	2	fact	fact	NN
18637	18604	3	,	,	,
18637	18604	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18604	5	would	would	MD
18637	18604	6	seem	seem	VB
18637	18604	7	,	,	,
18637	18604	8	from	from	IN
18637	18604	9	the	the	DT
18637	18604	10	character	character	NN
18637	18604	11	of	of	IN
18637	18604	12	many	many	JJ
18637	18604	13	of	of	IN
18637	18604	14	the	the	DT
18637	18604	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	18604	16	before	before	IN
18637	18604	17	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18604	18	,	,	,
18637	18604	19	and	and	CC
18637	18604	20	the	the	DT
18637	18604	21	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	18604	22	made	make	VBD
18637	18604	23	in	in	IN
18637	18604	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18604	25	,	,	,
18637	18604	26	that	that	IN
18637	18604	27	the	the	DT
18637	18604	28	clause	clause	NN
18637	18604	29	under	under	IN
18637	18604	30	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	18604	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	18604	32	looked	look	VBN
18637	18604	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	18604	34	as	as	IN
18637	18604	35	a	a	DT
18637	18604	36	means	means	NN
18637	18604	37	of	of	IN
18637	18604	38	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	18604	39	to	to	IN
18637	18604	40	the	the	DT
18637	18604	41	test	test	NN
18637	18604	42	of	of	IN
18637	18604	43	the	the	DT
18637	18604	44	decision	decision	NN
18637	18604	45	of	of	IN
18637	18604	46	this	this	DT
18637	18604	47	court	court	NN
18637	18604	48	the	the	DT
18637	18604	49	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	18604	50	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	18604	51	of	of	IN
18637	18604	52	every	every	DT
18637	18604	53	unsuccessful	unsuccessful	JJ
18637	18604	54	litigant	litigant	NN
18637	18604	55	in	in	IN
18637	18604	56	a	a	DT
18637	18604	57	State	State	NNP
18637	18604	58	court	court	NN
18637	18604	59	of	of	IN
18637	18604	60	the	the	DT
18637	18604	61	justice	justice	NN
18637	18604	62	of	of	IN
18637	18604	63	the	the	DT
18637	18604	64	decision	decision	NN
18637	18604	65	against	against	IN
18637	18604	66	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18604	67	,	,	,
18637	18604	68	and	and	CC
18637	18604	69	of	of	IN
18637	18604	70	the	the	DT
18637	18604	71	merits	merit	NNS
18637	18604	72	of	of	IN
18637	18604	73	the	the	DT
18637	18604	74	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18604	75	on	on	IN
18637	18604	76	which	which	WDT
18637	18604	77	such	such	PDT
18637	18604	78	a	a	DT
18637	18604	79	decision	decision	NN
18637	18604	80	may	may	MD
18637	18604	81	be	be	VB
18637	18604	82	founded	found	VBN
18637	18604	83	.	.	.
18637	18605	1	If	if	IN
18637	18605	2	,	,	,
18637	18605	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	18605	4	,	,	,
18637	18605	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18605	6	were	be	VBD
18637	18605	7	possible	possible	JJ
18637	18605	8	to	to	TO
18637	18605	9	define	define	VB
18637	18605	10	what	what	WP
18637	18605	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18605	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	18605	13	for	for	IN
18637	18605	14	a	a	DT
18637	18605	15	State	State	NNP
18637	18605	16	to	to	TO
18637	18605	17	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	18605	18	a	a	DT
18637	18605	19	person	person	NN
18637	18605	20	of	of	IN
18637	18605	21	life	life	NN
18637	18605	22	,	,	,
18637	18605	23	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18605	24	,	,	,
18637	18605	25	or	or	CC
18637	18605	26	property	property	NN
18637	18605	27	without	without	IN
18637	18605	28	due	due	JJ
18637	18605	29	process	process	NN
18637	18605	30	of	of	IN
18637	18605	31	law	law	NN
18637	18605	32	,	,	,
18637	18605	33	in	in	IN
18637	18605	34	terms	term	NNS
18637	18605	35	which	which	WDT
18637	18605	36	would	would	MD
18637	18605	37	cover	cover	VB
18637	18605	38	every	every	DT
18637	18605	39	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18605	40	of	of	IN
18637	18605	41	power	power	NN
18637	18605	42	thus	thus	RB
18637	18605	43	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	18605	44	to	to	IN
18637	18605	45	the	the	DT
18637	18605	46	State	State	NNP
18637	18605	47	,	,	,
18637	18605	48	and	and	CC
18637	18605	49	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	18605	50	those	those	DT
18637	18605	51	which	which	WDT
18637	18605	52	are	be	VBP
18637	18605	53	not	not	RB
18637	18605	54	,	,	,
18637	18605	55	no	no	DT
18637	18605	56	more	more	RBR
18637	18605	57	useful	useful	JJ
18637	18605	58	construction	construction	NN
18637	18605	59	could	could	MD
18637	18605	60	be	be	VB
18637	18605	61	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	18605	62	by	by	IN
18637	18605	63	this	this	DT
18637	18605	64	or	or	CC
18637	18605	65	any	any	DT
18637	18605	66	other	other	JJ
18637	18605	67	court	court	NN
18637	18605	68	to	to	IN
18637	18605	69	any	any	DT
18637	18605	70	part	part	NN
18637	18605	71	of	of	IN
18637	18605	72	the	the	DT
18637	18605	73	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	18605	74	law	law	NN
18637	18605	75	.	.	.
18637	18606	1	But	but	CC
18637	18606	2	,	,	,
18637	18606	3	apart	apart	RB
18637	18606	4	from	from	IN
18637	18606	5	the	the	DT
18637	18606	6	imminent	imminent	JJ
18637	18606	7	risk	risk	NN
18637	18606	8	of	of	IN
18637	18606	9	a	a	DT
18637	18606	10	failure	failure	NN
18637	18606	11	to	to	TO
18637	18606	12	give	give	VB
18637	18606	13	any	any	DT
18637	18606	14	definition	definition	NN
18637	18606	15	which	which	WDT
18637	18606	16	would	would	MD
18637	18606	17	be	be	VB
18637	18606	18	at	at	IN
18637	18606	19	once	once	RB
18637	18606	20	perspicuous	perspicuous	JJ
18637	18606	21	,	,	,
18637	18606	22	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	18606	23	,	,	,
18637	18606	24	and	and	CC
18637	18606	25	satisfactory	satisfactory	JJ
18637	18606	26	,	,	,
18637	18606	27	there	there	EX
18637	18606	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	18606	29	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	18606	30	,	,	,
18637	18606	31	*	*	NFP
18637	18606	32	*	*	NFP
18637	18606	33	*	*	NFP
18637	18606	34	,	,	,
18637	18606	35	in	in	IN
18637	18606	36	the	the	DT
18637	18606	37	ascertaining	ascertaining	NN
18637	18606	38	of	of	IN
18637	18606	39	the	the	DT
18637	18606	40	intent	intent	NN
18637	18606	41	and	and	CC
18637	18606	42	application	application	NN
18637	18606	43	of	of	IN
18637	18606	44	such	such	PDT
18637	18606	45	an	an	DT
18637	18606	46	important	important	JJ
18637	18606	47	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	18606	48	in	in	IN
18637	18606	49	the	the	DT
18637	18606	50	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18606	51	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18606	52	,	,	,
18637	18606	53	by	by	IN
18637	18606	54	the	the	DT
18637	18606	55	gradual	gradual	JJ
18637	18606	56	process	process	NN
18637	18606	57	of	of	IN
18637	18606	58	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18606	59	inclusion	inclusion	NN
18637	18606	60	and	and	CC
18637	18606	61	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	18606	62	,	,	,
18637	18606	63	as	as	IN
18637	18606	64	the	the	DT
18637	18606	65	cases	case	NNS
18637	18606	66	presented	present	VBN
18637	18606	67	for	for	IN
18637	18606	68	decision	decision	NN
18637	18606	69	shall	shall	MD
18637	18606	70	require	require	VB
18637	18606	71	,	,	,
18637	18606	72	*	*	NFP
18637	18606	73	*	*	NFP
18637	18606	74	*	*	NFP
18637	18606	75	"	"	''
18637	18606	76	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18606	77	66	66	CD
18637	18606	78	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18606	79	In	in	IN
18637	18606	80	thus	thus	RB
18637	18606	81	persisting	persist	VBG
18637	18606	82	in	in	IN
18637	18606	83	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18606	84	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	18606	85	to	to	TO
18637	18606	86	review	review	VB
18637	18606	87	,	,	,
18637	18606	88	on	on	IN
18637	18606	89	other	other	JJ
18637	18606	90	than	than	IN
18637	18606	91	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	18606	92	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	18606	93	,	,	,
18637	18606	94	the	the	DT
18637	18606	95	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	18606	96	of	of	IN
18637	18606	97	State	State	NNP
18637	18606	98	action	action	NN
18637	18606	99	,	,	,
18637	18606	100	the	the	DT
18637	18606	101	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18606	102	was	be	VBD
18637	18606	103	rejecting	reject	VBG
18637	18606	104	additional	additional	JJ
18637	18606	105	business	business	NN
18637	18606	106	;	;	:
18637	18606	107	but	but	CC
18637	18606	108	a	a	DT
18637	18606	109	bare	bare	JJ
18637	18606	110	half	half	JJ
18637	18606	111	-	-	HYPH
18637	18606	112	dozen	dozen	NN
18637	18606	113	years	year	NNS
18637	18606	114	later	later	RB
18637	18606	115	,	,	,
18637	18606	116	in	in	IN
18637	18606	117	again	again	RB
18637	18606	118	reaching	reach	VBG
18637	18606	119	a	a	DT
18637	18606	120	result	result	NN
18637	18606	121	in	in	IN
18637	18606	122	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	18606	123	with	with	IN
18637	18606	124	past	past	JJ
18637	18606	125	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	18606	126	,	,	,
18637	18606	127	the	the	DT
18637	18606	128	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	18606	129	gave	give	VBD
18637	18606	130	fair	fair	JJ
18637	18606	131	warning	warning	NN
18637	18606	132	of	of	IN
18637	18606	133	the	the	DT
18637	18606	134	imminence	imminence	NN
18637	18606	135	of	of	IN
18637	18606	136	a	a	DT
18637	18606	137	modification	modification	NN
18637	18606	138	of	of	IN
18637	18606	139	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18606	140	views	view	NNS
18637	18606	141	.	.	.
18637	18607	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18607	2	,	,	,
18637	18607	3	after	after	IN
18637	18607	4	noting	note	VBG
18637	18607	5	that	that	IN
18637	18607	6	the	the	DT
18637	18607	7	due	due	JJ
18637	18607	8	process	process	NN
18637	18607	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	18607	10	,	,	,
18637	18607	11	by	by	IN
18637	18607	12	reason	reason	NN
18637	18607	13	of	of	IN
18637	18607	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18607	15	operation	operation	NN
18637	18607	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	18607	17	"	"	``
18637	18607	18	all	all	PDT
18637	18607	19	the	the	DT
18637	18607	20	powers	power	NNS
18637	18607	21	of	of	IN
18637	18607	22	government	government	NN
18637	18607	23	,	,	,
18637	18607	24	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18607	25	as	as	RB
18637	18607	26	well	well	RB
18637	18607	27	as	as	IN
18637	18607	28	executive	executive	JJ
18637	18607	29	and	and	CC
18637	18607	30	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18607	31	,	,	,
18637	18607	32	"	"	``
18637	18607	33	could	could	MD
18637	18607	34	not	not	RB
18637	18607	35	be	be	VB
18637	18607	36	appraised	appraise	VBN
18637	18607	37	solely	solely	RB
18637	18607	38	in	in	IN
18637	18607	39	terms	term	NNS
18637	18607	40	of	of	IN
18637	18607	41	the	the	DT
18637	18607	42	"	"	``
18637	18607	43	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	18607	44	of	of	IN
18637	18607	45	settled	settle	VBN
18637	18607	46	usage	usage	NN
18637	18607	47	,	,	,
18637	18607	48	"	"	''
18637	18607	49	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18607	50	Mathews	Mathews	NNP
18637	18607	51	,	,	,
18637	18607	52	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	18607	53	for	for	IN
18637	18607	54	the	the	DT
18637	18607	55	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18607	56	in	in	IN
18637	18607	57	Hurtado	Hurtado	NNP
18637	18607	58	_	_	NNP
18637	18607	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	18607	60	_	_	NNP
18637	18607	61	California,[67	California,[67	NNP
18637	18607	62	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18607	63	declared	declare	VBD
18637	18607	64	that	that	IN
18637	18607	65	,	,	,
18637	18607	66	"	"	``
18637	18607	67	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18607	68	power	power	NN
18637	18607	69	,	,	,
18637	18607	70	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	18607	71	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18607	72	edicts	edict	NNS
18637	18607	73	to	to	IN
18637	18607	74	the	the	DT
18637	18607	75	injury	injury	NN
18637	18607	76	of	of	IN
18637	18607	77	the	the	DT
18637	18607	78	persons	person	NNS
18637	18607	79	and	and	CC
18637	18607	80	property	property	NN
18637	18607	81	of	of	IN
18637	18607	82	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18607	83	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	18607	84	,	,	,
18637	18607	85	is	be	VBZ
18637	18607	86	not	not	RB
18637	18607	87	law	law	NN
18637	18607	88	,	,	,
18637	18607	89	whether	whether	IN
18637	18607	90	manifested	manifest	VBN
18637	18607	91	as	as	IN
18637	18607	92	the	the	DT
18637	18607	93	decree	decree	NN
18637	18607	94	of	of	IN
18637	18607	95	a	a	DT
18637	18607	96	personal	personal	JJ
18637	18607	97	monarch	monarch	NN
18637	18607	98	or	or	CC
18637	18607	99	of	of	IN
18637	18607	100	an	an	DT
18637	18607	101	impersonal	impersonal	JJ
18637	18607	102	multitude	multitude	NN
18637	18607	103	.	.	.
18637	18608	1	And	and	CC
18637	18608	2	the	the	DT
18637	18608	3	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	18608	4	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18608	5	by	by	IN
18637	18608	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18608	7	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18608	8	law	law	NN
18637	18608	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	18608	10	the	the	DT
18637	18608	11	action	action	NN
18637	18608	12	of	of	IN
18637	18608	13	the	the	DT
18637	18608	14	governments	government	NNS
18637	18608	15	,	,	,
18637	18608	16	both	both	CC
18637	18608	17	State	State	NNP
18637	18608	18	and	and	CC
18637	18608	19	national	national	JJ
18637	18608	20	,	,	,
18637	18608	21	are	be	VBP
18637	18608	22	essential	essential	JJ
18637	18608	23	to	to	IN
18637	18608	24	the	the	DT
18637	18608	25	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	18608	26	of	of	IN
18637	18608	27	public	public	JJ
18637	18608	28	and	and	CC
18637	18608	29	private	private	JJ
18637	18608	30	rights	right	NNS
18637	18608	31	,	,	,
18637	18608	32	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	18608	33	the	the	DT
18637	18608	34	representative	representative	JJ
18637	18608	35	character	character	NN
18637	18608	36	of	of	IN
18637	18608	37	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18608	38	political	political	JJ
18637	18608	39	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	18608	40	.	.	.
18637	18609	1	The	the	DT
18637	18609	2	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18609	3	of	of	IN
18637	18609	4	these	these	DT
18637	18609	5	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	18609	6	by	by	IN
18637	18609	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18609	8	process	process	NN
18637	18609	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	18609	10	the	the	DT
18637	18609	11	device	device	NN
18637	18609	12	of	of	IN
18637	18609	13	self	self	NN
18637	18609	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	18609	15	governing	govern	VBG
18637	18609	16	communities	community	NNS
18637	18609	17	to	to	TO
18637	18609	18	protect	protect	VB
18637	18609	19	the	the	DT
18637	18609	20	rights	right	NNS
18637	18609	21	of	of	IN
18637	18609	22	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	18609	23	and	and	CC
18637	18609	24	minorities	minority	NNS
18637	18609	25	,	,	,
18637	18609	26	as	as	RB
18637	18609	27	well	well	RB
18637	18609	28	against	against	IN
18637	18609	29	the	the	DT
18637	18609	30	power	power	NN
18637	18609	31	of	of	IN
18637	18609	32	numbers	number	NNS
18637	18609	33	,	,	,
18637	18609	34	as	as	IN
18637	18609	35	against	against	IN
18637	18609	36	the	the	DT
18637	18609	37	violence	violence	NN
18637	18609	38	of	of	IN
18637	18609	39	public	public	JJ
18637	18609	40	agents	agent	NNS
18637	18609	41	transcending	transcend	VBG
18637	18609	42	the	the	DT
18637	18609	43	limits	limit	NNS
18637	18609	44	of	of	IN
18637	18609	45	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	18609	46	authority	authority	NN
18637	18609	47	,	,	,
18637	18609	48	even	even	RB
18637	18609	49	when	when	WRB
18637	18609	50	acting	act	VBG
18637	18609	51	in	in	IN
18637	18609	52	the	the	DT
18637	18609	53	name	name	NN
18637	18609	54	and	and	CC
18637	18609	55	wielding	wield	VBG
18637	18609	56	the	the	DT
18637	18609	57	force	force	NN
18637	18609	58	of	of	IN
18637	18609	59	the	the	DT
18637	18609	60	government	government	NN
18637	18609	61	.	.	.
18637	18610	1	"	"	``
18637	18610	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18610	3	68	68	CD
18637	18610	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18610	5	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18610	6	were	be	VBD
18637	18610	7	the	the	DT
18637	18610	8	States	States	NNPS
18637	18610	9	put	put	VBD
18637	18610	10	on	on	IN
18637	18610	11	notice	notice	NN
18637	18610	12	that	that	IN
18637	18610	13	every	every	DT
18637	18610	14	species	species	NN
18637	18610	15	of	of	IN
18637	18610	16	State	State	NNP
18637	18610	17	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18610	18	,	,	,
18637	18610	19	whether	whether	IN
18637	18610	20	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	18610	21	with	with	IN
18637	18610	22	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	18610	23	or	or	CC
18637	18610	24	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	18610	25	rights	right	NNS
18637	18610	26	,	,	,
18637	18610	27	was	be	VBD
18637	18610	28	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18610	29	to	to	IN
18637	18610	30	the	the	DT
18637	18610	31	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
18637	18610	32	of	of	IN
18637	18610	33	the	the	DT
18637	18610	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18610	35	when	when	WRB
18637	18610	36	the	the	DT
18637	18610	37	question	question	NN
18637	18610	38	of	of	IN
18637	18610	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18610	40	essential	essential	JJ
18637	18610	41	justice	justice	NN
18637	18610	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	18610	43	raised	raise	VBN
18637	18610	44	.	.	.
18637	18611	1	Police	Police	NNP
18637	18611	2	Power	Power	NNP
18637	18611	3	:	:	:
18637	18611	4	Liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18611	5	:	:	:
18637	18611	6	Property	Property	NNP
18637	18611	7	What	what	WP
18637	18611	8	induced	induce	VBD
18637	18611	9	the	the	DT
18637	18611	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18611	11	to	to	TO
18637	18611	12	dismiss	dismiss	VB
18637	18611	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18611	14	fears	fear	NNS
18637	18611	15	of	of	IN
18637	18611	16	upsetting	upset	VBG
18637	18611	17	the	the	DT
18637	18611	18	balance	balance	NN
18637	18611	19	in	in	IN
18637	18611	20	the	the	DT
18637	18611	21	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	18611	22	of	of	IN
18637	18611	23	powers	power	NNS
18637	18611	24	under	under	IN
18637	18611	25	the	the	DT
18637	18611	26	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18611	27	System	System	NNP
18637	18611	28	and	and	CC
18637	18611	29	to	to	TO
18637	18611	30	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	18611	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18611	32	own	own	JJ
18637	18611	33	supervisory	supervisory	JJ
18637	18611	34	powers	power	NNS
18637	18611	35	over	over	IN
18637	18611	36	state	state	NN
18637	18611	37	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18611	38	were	be	VBD
18637	18611	39	the	the	DT
18637	18611	40	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	18611	41	more	more	RBR
18637	18611	42	and	and	CC
18637	18611	43	more	more	RBR
18637	18611	44	addressed	address	VBD
18637	18611	45	to	to	IN
18637	18611	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18611	47	for	for	IN
18637	18611	48	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	18611	49	protection	protection	NN
18637	18611	50	of	of	IN
18637	18611	51	property	property	NN
18637	18611	52	rights	right	NNS
18637	18611	53	against	against	IN
18637	18611	54	the	the	DT
18637	18611	55	remedial	remedial	JJ
18637	18611	56	social	social	JJ
18637	18611	57	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18611	58	which	which	WDT
18637	18611	59	the	the	DT
18637	18611	60	States	States	NNPS
18637	18611	61	were	be	VBD
18637	18611	62	increasingly	increasingly	RB
18637	18611	63	enacting	enact	VBG
18637	18611	64	in	in	IN
18637	18611	65	the	the	DT
18637	18611	66	wake	wake	NN
18637	18611	67	of	of	IN
18637	18611	68	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	18611	69	expansion	expansion	NN
18637	18611	70	.	.	.
18637	18612	1	At	at	IN
18637	18612	2	the	the	DT
18637	18612	3	same	same	JJ
18637	18612	4	time	time	NN
18637	18612	5	the	the	DT
18637	18612	6	added	add	VBN
18637	18612	7	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	18612	8	on	on	IN
18637	18612	9	the	the	DT
18637	18612	10	due	due	JJ
18637	18612	11	process	process	NN
18637	18612	12	clause	clause	NN
18637	18612	13	which	which	WDT
18637	18612	14	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
18637	18612	15	of	of	IN
18637	18612	16	these	these	DT
18637	18612	17	requests	request	NNS
18637	18612	18	entailed	entail	VBD
18637	18612	19	afforded	afford	VBD
18637	18612	20	the	the	DT
18637	18612	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18612	22	an	an	DT
18637	18612	23	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	18612	24	to	to	TO
18637	18612	25	compensate	compensate	VB
18637	18612	26	for	for	IN
18637	18612	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18612	28	earlier	early	JJR
18637	18612	29	virtual	virtual	JJ
18637	18612	30	nullification	nullification	NN
18637	18612	31	of	of	IN
18637	18612	32	the	the	DT
18637	18612	33	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18612	34	and	and	CC
18637	18612	35	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	18612	36	clause	clause	NN
18637	18612	37	of	of	IN
18637	18612	38	the	the	DT
18637	18612	39	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18612	40	.	.	.
18637	18613	1	So	so	RB
18637	18613	2	far	far	RB
18637	18613	3	as	as	IN
18637	18613	4	such	such	JJ
18637	18613	5	modification	modification	NN
18637	18613	6	of	of	IN
18637	18613	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18613	8	position	position	NN
18637	18613	9	needed	need	VBN
18637	18613	10	to	to	TO
18637	18613	11	be	be	VB
18637	18613	12	justified	justify	VBN
18637	18613	13	in	in	IN
18637	18613	14	legal	legal	JJ
18637	18613	15	terms	term	NNS
18637	18613	16	,	,	,
18637	18613	17	theories	theory	NNS
18637	18613	18	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	18613	19	the	the	DT
18637	18613	20	relation	relation	NN
18637	18613	21	of	of	IN
18637	18613	22	government	government	NN
18637	18613	23	to	to	IN
18637	18613	24	private	private	JJ
18637	18613	25	rights	right	NNS
18637	18613	26	were	be	VBD
18637	18613	27	available	available	JJ
18637	18613	28	to	to	TO
18637	18613	29	demonstrate	demonstrate	VB
18637	18613	30	the	the	DT
18637	18613	31	impropriety	impropriety	NN
18637	18613	32	of	of	IN
18637	18613	33	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	18613	34	to	to	IN
18637	18613	35	the	the	DT
18637	18613	36	state	state	NN
18637	18613	37	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	18613	38	the	the	DT
18637	18613	39	same	same	JJ
18637	18613	40	ample	ample	JJ
18637	18613	41	range	range	NN
18637	18613	42	of	of	IN
18637	18613	43	police	police	NN
18637	18613	44	power	power	NN
18637	18613	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18613	46	had	have	VBD
18637	18613	47	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
18637	18613	48	prior	prior	RB
18637	18613	49	to	to	IN
18637	18613	50	the	the	DT
18637	18613	51	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	18613	52	War	War	NNP
18637	18613	53	.	.	.
18637	18614	1	Preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	18614	2	,	,	,
18637	18614	3	however	however	RB
18637	18614	4	,	,	,
18637	18614	5	to	to	IN
18637	18614	6	this	this	DT
18637	18614	7	consummation	consummation	NN
18637	18614	8	the	the	DT
18637	18614	9	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	18614	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	18614	11	House	House	NNP
18637	18614	12	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	18614	13	and	and	CC
18637	18614	14	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	18614	15	_	_	NNP
18637	18614	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	18614	17	_	_	NNP
18637	18614	18	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	18614	19	had	have	VBD
18637	18614	20	to	to	TO
18637	18614	21	be	be	VB
18637	18614	22	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	18614	23	in	in	IN
18637	18614	24	part	part	NN
18637	18614	25	,	,	,
18637	18614	26	at	at	IN
18637	18614	27	least	least	JJS
18637	18614	28	,	,	,
18637	18614	29	and	and	CC
18637	18614	30	the	the	DT
18637	18614	31	views	view	NNS
18637	18614	32	of	of	IN
18637	18614	33	the	the	DT
18637	18614	34	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	18614	35	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	18614	36	in	in	IN
18637	18614	37	those	those	DT
18637	18614	38	cases	case	NNS
18637	18614	39	converted	convert	VBN
18637	18614	40	into	into	IN
18637	18614	41	majority	majority	NN
18637	18614	42	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	18614	43	.	.	.
18637	18615	1	About	about	RB
18637	18615	2	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	18615	3	years	year	NNS
18637	18615	4	were	be	VBD
18637	18615	5	required	require	VBN
18637	18615	6	to	to	TO
18637	18615	7	complete	complete	VB
18637	18615	8	this	this	DT
18637	18615	9	process	process	NN
18637	18615	10	,	,	,
18637	18615	11	in	in	IN
18637	18615	12	the	the	DT
18637	18615	13	course	course	NN
18637	18615	14	of	of	IN
18637	18615	15	which	which	WDT
18637	18615	16	the	the	DT
18637	18615	17	restricted	restricted	JJ
18637	18615	18	view	view	NN
18637	18615	19	of	of	IN
18637	18615	20	the	the	DT
18637	18615	21	police	police	NN
18637	18615	22	power	power	NN
18637	18615	23	advanced	advance	VBN
18637	18615	24	by	by	IN
18637	18615	25	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18615	26	Field	Field	NNP
18637	18615	27	in	in	IN
18637	18615	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18615	29	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	18615	30	in	in	IN
18637	18615	31	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	18615	32	_	_	NNP
18637	18615	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	18615	34	_	_	NNP
18637	18615	35	Illinois,[69	Illinois,[69	NNP
18637	18615	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18615	37	namely	namely	RB
18637	18615	38	,	,	,
18637	18615	39	that	that	IN
18637	18615	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18615	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	18615	42	solely	solely	RB
18637	18615	43	a	a	DT
18637	18615	44	power	power	NN
18637	18615	45	to	to	TO
18637	18615	46	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18615	47	injury	injury	NN
18637	18615	48	,	,	,
18637	18615	49	was	be	VBD
18637	18615	50	in	in	IN
18637	18615	51	effect	effect	NN
18637	18615	52	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	18615	53	by	by	IN
18637	18615	54	the	the	DT
18637	18615	55	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18615	56	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18615	57	.	.	.
18637	18616	1	This	this	DT
18637	18616	2	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	18616	3	in	in	IN
18637	18616	4	1887	1887	CD
18637	18616	5	,	,	,
18637	18616	6	in	in	IN
18637	18616	7	Mugler	Mugler	NNP
18637	18616	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18616	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	18616	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18616	11	Kansas,[70	Kansas,[70	NNP
18637	18616	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18616	13	where	where	WRB
18637	18616	14	the	the	DT
18637	18616	15	power	power	NN
18637	18616	16	was	be	VBD
18637	18616	17	defined	define	VBN
18637	18616	18	as	as	IN
18637	18616	19	embracing	embrace	VBG
18637	18616	20	no	no	RB
18637	18616	21	more	more	JJR
18637	18616	22	than	than	IN
18637	18616	23	the	the	DT
18637	18616	24	power	power	NN
18637	18616	25	to	to	TO
18637	18616	26	promote	promote	VB
18637	18616	27	public	public	JJ
18637	18616	28	health	health	NN
18637	18616	29	,	,	,
18637	18616	30	morals	moral	NNS
18637	18616	31	,	,	,
18637	18616	32	and	and	CC
18637	18616	33	safety	safety	NN
18637	18616	34	.	.	.
18637	18617	1	During	during	IN
18637	18617	2	the	the	DT
18637	18617	3	same	same	JJ
18637	18617	4	interval	interval	NN
18637	18617	5	,	,	,
18637	18617	6	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	18617	7	embodying	embody	VBG
18637	18617	8	the	the	DT
18637	18617	9	social	social	JJ
18637	18617	10	compact	compact	JJ
18637	18617	11	and	and	CC
18637	18617	12	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18617	13	rights	right	NNS
18637	18617	14	,	,	,
18637	18617	15	which	which	WDT
18637	18617	16	had	have	VBD
18637	18617	17	been	be	VBN
18637	18617	18	espoused	espouse	VBN
18637	18617	19	by	by	IN
18637	18617	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18617	21	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	18617	22	in	in	IN
18637	18617	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18617	24	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	18617	25	in	in	IN
18637	18617	26	the	the	DT
18637	18617	27	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	18617	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	18617	29	House	House	NNP
18637	18617	30	Cases,[71	Cases,[71	NNP
18637	18617	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18617	32	had	have	VBD
18637	18617	33	been	be	VBN
18637	18617	34	transformed	transform	VBN
18637	18617	35	tentatively	tentatively	RB
18637	18617	36	into	into	IN
18637	18617	37	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	18617	38	enforceable	enforceable	JJ
18637	18617	39	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	18617	40	upon	upon	IN
18637	18617	41	government,[72	government,[72	CD
18637	18617	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18617	43	with	with	IN
18637	18617	44	the	the	DT
18637	18617	45	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	18617	46	that	that	IN
18637	18617	47	the	the	DT
18637	18617	48	States	States	NNPS
18637	18617	49	,	,	,
18637	18617	50	in	in	IN
18637	18617	51	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	18617	52	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18617	53	police	police	NN
18637	18617	54	power	power	NN
18637	18617	55	,	,	,
18637	18617	56	could	could	MD
18637	18617	57	foster	foster	VB
18637	18617	58	only	only	RB
18637	18617	59	those	those	DT
18637	18617	60	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	18617	61	of	of	IN
18637	18617	62	health	health	NN
18637	18617	63	,	,	,
18637	18617	64	morals	moral	NNS
18637	18617	65	,	,	,
18637	18617	66	and	and	CC
18637	18617	67	safety	safety	NN
18637	18617	68	which	which	WDT
18637	18617	69	the	the	DT
18637	18617	70	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18617	71	had	have	VBD
18637	18617	72	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	18617	73	and	and	CC
18637	18617	74	could	could	MD
18637	18617	75	employ	employ	VB
18637	18617	76	only	only	RB
18637	18617	77	such	such	JJ
18637	18617	78	means	mean	NNS
18637	18617	79	as	as	IN
18637	18617	80	would	would	MD
18637	18617	81	not	not	RB
18637	18617	82	unreasonably	unreasonably	RB
18637	18617	83	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	18617	84	with	with	IN
18637	18617	85	the	the	DT
18637	18617	86	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	18617	87	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18617	88	rights	right	NNS
18637	18617	89	of	of	IN
18637	18617	90	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18617	91	and	and	CC
18637	18617	92	property	property	NN
18637	18617	93	,	,	,
18637	18617	94	which	which	WDT
18637	18617	95	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18617	96	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	18617	97	had	have	VBD
18637	18617	98	equated	equate	VBN
18637	18617	99	with	with	IN
18637	18617	100	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18617	101	to	to	TO
18637	18617	102	pursue	pursue	VB
18637	18617	103	a	a	DT
18637	18617	104	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	18617	105	calling	calling	NN
18637	18617	106	and	and	CC
18637	18617	107	to	to	TO
18637	18617	108	make	make	VB
18637	18617	109	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	18617	110	for	for	IN
18637	18617	111	that	that	DT
18637	18617	112	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18617	113	.	.	.
18637	18618	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18618	2	73	73	CD
18637	18618	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18618	4	So	so	RB
18637	18618	5	having	have	VBG
18637	18618	6	narrowed	narrow	VBN
18637	18618	7	the	the	DT
18637	18618	8	scope	scope	NN
18637	18618	9	of	of	IN
18637	18618	10	the	the	DT
18637	18618	11	State	State	NNP
18637	18618	12	's	's	POS
18637	18618	13	police	police	NN
18637	18618	14	power	power	NN
18637	18618	15	in	in	IN
18637	18618	16	deference	deference	NN
18637	18618	17	to	to	IN
18637	18618	18	the	the	DT
18637	18618	19	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18618	20	rights	right	NNS
18637	18618	21	of	of	IN
18637	18618	22	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18618	23	and	and	CC
18637	18618	24	property	property	NN
18637	18618	25	,	,	,
18637	18618	26	the	the	DT
18637	18618	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18618	28	next	next	RB
18637	18618	29	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	18618	30	to	to	TO
18637	18618	31	read	read	VB
18637	18618	32	into	into	IN
18637	18618	33	the	the	DT
18637	18618	34	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18618	35	currently	currently	RB
18637	18618	36	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	18618	37	theories	theory	NNS
18637	18618	38	of	of	IN
18637	18618	39	_	_	NNP
18637	18618	40	laissez	laissez	NNP
18637	18618	41	faire	faire	NN
18637	18618	42	_	_	NNP
18637	18618	43	economics	economic	NNS
18637	18618	44	,	,	,
18637	18618	45	reinforced	reinforce	VBN
18637	18618	46	by	by	IN
18637	18618	47	the	the	DT
18637	18618	48	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	18618	49	of	of	IN
18637	18618	50	evolution	evolution	NN
18637	18618	51	as	as	IN
18637	18618	52	elaborated	elaborate	VBN
18637	18618	53	by	by	IN
18637	18618	54	Herbert	Herbert	NNP
18637	18618	55	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
18637	18618	56	,	,	,
18637	18618	57	to	to	IN
18637	18618	58	the	the	DT
18637	18618	59	end	end	NN
18637	18618	60	that	that	IN
18637	18618	61	"	"	``
18637	18618	62	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18618	63	"	"	''
18637	18618	64	,	,	,
18637	18618	65	in	in	IN
18637	18618	66	particular	particular	JJ
18637	18618	67	,	,	,
18637	18618	68	became	become	VBD
18637	18618	69	synonymous	synonymous	JJ
18637	18618	70	with	with	IN
18637	18618	71	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	18618	72	hands	hand	NNS
18637	18618	73	-	-	HYPH
18637	18618	74	off	off	RP
18637	18618	75	in	in	IN
18637	18618	76	the	the	DT
18637	18618	77	field	field	NN
18637	18618	78	of	of	IN
18637	18618	79	private	private	JJ
18637	18618	80	economic	economic	JJ
18637	18618	81	relations	relation	NNS
18637	18618	82	.	.	.
18637	18619	1	In	in	IN
18637	18619	2	Budd	Budd	NNP
18637	18619	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18619	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	18619	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18619	6	New	New	NNP
18637	18619	7	York,[74	York,[74	NNP
18637	18619	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18619	9	decided	decide	VBD
18637	18619	10	in	in	IN
18637	18619	11	1892	1892	CD
18637	18619	12	,	,	,
18637	18619	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18619	14	Brewer	Brewer	NNP
18637	18619	15	in	in	IN
18637	18619	16	a	a	DT
18637	18619	17	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	18619	18	declared	declare	VBN
18637	18619	19	:	:	:
18637	18619	20	"	"	``
18637	18619	21	The	the	DT
18637	18619	22	paternal	paternal	JJ
18637	18619	23	theory	theory	NN
18637	18619	24	of	of	IN
18637	18619	25	government	government	NN
18637	18619	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	18619	27	to	to	IN
18637	18619	28	me	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18619	29	odious	odious	JJ
18637	18619	30	.	.	.
18637	18620	1	The	the	DT
18637	18620	2	utmost	utmost	JJ
18637	18620	3	possible	possible	JJ
18637	18620	4	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18620	5	to	to	IN
18637	18620	6	the	the	DT
18637	18620	7	individual	individual	NN
18637	18620	8	,	,	,
18637	18620	9	and	and	CC
18637	18620	10	the	the	DT
18637	18620	11	fullest	full	JJS
18637	18620	12	possible	possible	JJ
18637	18620	13	protection	protection	NN
18637	18620	14	to	to	IN
18637	18620	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18620	16	and	and	CC
18637	18620	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18620	18	property	property	NN
18637	18620	19	,	,	,
18637	18620	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	18620	21	both	both	CC
18637	18620	22	the	the	DT
18637	18620	23	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	18620	24	and	and	CC
18637	18620	25	duty	duty	NN
18637	18620	26	of	of	IN
18637	18620	27	government	government	NN
18637	18620	28	.	.	.
18637	18620	29	"	"	''
18637	18621	1	And	and	CC
18637	18621	2	to	to	TO
18637	18621	3	implement	implement	VB
18637	18621	4	this	this	DT
18637	18621	5	point	point	NN
18637	18621	6	of	of	IN
18637	18621	7	view	view	NN
18637	18621	8	the	the	DT
18637	18621	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18621	10	next	next	RB
18637	18621	11	undertook	undertake	VBD
18637	18621	12	to	to	TO
18637	18621	13	water	water	VB
18637	18621	14	down	down	RP
18637	18621	15	the	the	DT
18637	18621	16	accepted	accepted	JJ
18637	18621	17	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	18621	18	that	that	IN
18637	18621	19	a	a	DT
18637	18621	20	State	state	NN
18637	18621	21	statute	statute	NN
18637	18621	22	must	must	MD
18637	18621	23	be	be	VB
18637	18621	24	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	18621	25	to	to	TO
18637	18621	26	be	be	VB
18637	18621	27	valid	valid	JJ
18637	18621	28	until	until	IN
18637	18621	29	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	18621	30	shown	show	VBN
18637	18621	31	to	to	TO
18637	18621	32	be	be	VB
18637	18621	33	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	18621	34	.	.	.
18637	18622	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18622	2	75	75	CD
18637	18622	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18622	4	The	the	DT
18637	18622	5	first	first	JJ
18637	18622	6	step	step	NN
18637	18622	7	was	be	VBD
18637	18622	8	taken	take	VBN
18637	18622	9	with	with	IN
18637	18622	10	the	the	DT
18637	18622	11	opposite	opposite	JJ
18637	18622	12	intention	intention	NN
18637	18622	13	.	.	.
18637	18623	1	This	this	DT
18637	18623	2	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	18623	3	in	in	IN
18637	18623	4	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	18623	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18623	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18623	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18623	8	Illinois,[76	Illinois,[76	NNP
18637	18623	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18623	10	where	where	WRB
18637	18623	11	the	the	DT
18637	18623	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18623	13	,	,	,
18637	18623	14	in	in	IN
18637	18623	15	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	18623	16	the	the	DT
18637	18623	17	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18623	18	before	before	IN
18637	18623	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18623	20	,	,	,
18637	18623	21	declared	declare	VBD
18637	18623	22	:	:	:
18637	18623	23	"	"	``
18637	18623	24	For	for	IN
18637	18623	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18623	26	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	18623	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18623	28	must	must	MD
18637	18623	29	assume	assume	VB
18637	18623	30	that	that	IN
18637	18623	31	,	,	,
18637	18623	32	if	if	IN
18637	18623	33	a	a	DT
18637	18623	34	state	state	NN
18637	18623	35	of	of	IN
18637	18623	36	facts	fact	NNS
18637	18623	37	could	could	MD
18637	18623	38	exist	exist	VB
18637	18623	39	that	that	WDT
18637	18623	40	would	would	MD
18637	18623	41	justify	justify	VB
18637	18623	42	such	such	JJ
18637	18623	43	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18623	44	,	,	,
18637	18623	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18623	46	actually	actually	RB
18637	18623	47	did	do	VBD
18637	18623	48	exist	exist	VB
18637	18623	49	when	when	WRB
18637	18623	50	the	the	DT
18637	18623	51	statute	statute	NN
18637	18623	52	now	now	RB
18637	18623	53	under	under	IN
18637	18623	54	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	18623	55	was	be	VBD
18637	18623	56	passed	pass	VBN
18637	18623	57	.	.	.
18637	18624	1	"	"	``
18637	18624	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18624	3	77	77	CD
18637	18624	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18624	5	Ten	ten	CD
18637	18624	6	years	year	NNS
18637	18624	7	later	later	RB
18637	18624	8	,	,	,
18637	18624	9	in	in	IN
18637	18624	10	Mugler	Mugler	NNP
18637	18624	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18624	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	18624	13	_	_	NNP
18637	18624	14	Kansas[78	Kansas[78	NNP
18637	18624	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18624	16	this	this	DT
18637	18624	17	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	18624	18	was	be	VBD
18637	18624	19	improved	improve	VBN
18637	18624	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	18624	21	,	,	,
18637	18624	22	and	and	CC
18637	18624	23	a	a	DT
18637	18624	24	State	state	NN
18637	18624	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	18624	26	wide	wide	JJ
18637	18624	27	anti	anti	JJ
18637	18624	28	-	-	JJ
18637	18624	29	liquor	liquor	JJ
18637	18624	30	law	law	NN
18637	18624	31	was	be	VBD
18637	18624	32	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18624	33	on	on	IN
18637	18624	34	the	the	DT
18637	18624	35	basis	basis	NN
18637	18624	36	of	of	IN
18637	18624	37	the	the	DT
18637	18624	38	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	18624	39	that	that	IN
18637	18624	40	deleterious	deleterious	JJ
18637	18624	41	social	social	JJ
18637	18624	42	effects	effect	NNS
18637	18624	43	of	of	IN
18637	18624	44	the	the	DT
18637	18624	45	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	18624	46	use	use	NN
18637	18624	47	of	of	IN
18637	18624	48	alcoholic	alcoholic	JJ
18637	18624	49	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	18624	50	were	be	VBD
18637	18624	51	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	18624	52	notorious	notorious	JJ
18637	18624	53	for	for	IN
18637	18624	54	the	the	DT
18637	18624	55	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18624	56	to	to	TO
18637	18624	57	be	be	VB
18637	18624	58	able	able	JJ
18637	18624	59	to	to	TO
18637	18624	60	take	take	VB
18637	18624	61	notice	notice	NN
18637	18624	62	of	of	IN
18637	18624	63	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18624	64	;	;	:
18637	18624	65	that	that	DT
18637	18624	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	18624	67	to	to	TO
18637	18624	68	say	say	VB
18637	18624	69	,	,	,
18637	18624	70	for	for	IN
18637	18624	71	the	the	DT
18637	18624	72	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18624	73	to	to	TO
18637	18624	74	review	review	VB
18637	18624	75	and	and	CC
18637	18624	76	appraise	appraise	VB
18637	18624	77	the	the	DT
18637	18624	78	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	18624	79	which	which	WDT
18637	18624	80	had	have	VBD
18637	18624	81	induced	induce	VBN
18637	18624	82	the	the	DT
18637	18624	83	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18624	84	to	to	TO
18637	18624	85	enact	enact	VB
18637	18624	86	the	the	DT
18637	18624	87	statute	statute	NN
18637	18624	88	in	in	IN
18637	18624	89	the	the	DT
18637	18624	90	first	first	JJ
18637	18624	91	place	place	NN
18637	18624	92	.	.	.
18637	18625	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18625	2	79	79	CD
18637	18625	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18625	4	However	however	RB
18637	18625	5	,	,	,
18637	18625	6	in	in	IN
18637	18625	7	Powell	Powell	NNP
18637	18625	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18625	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	18625	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18625	11	Pennsylvania,[80	Pennsylvania,[80	NNP
18637	18625	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18625	13	decided	decide	VBD
18637	18625	14	the	the	DT
18637	18625	15	following	follow	VBG
18637	18625	16	year	year	NN
18637	18625	17	,	,	,
18637	18625	18	the	the	DT
18637	18625	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18625	20	,	,	,
18637	18625	21	being	be	VBG
18637	18625	22	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	18625	23	with	with	IN
18637	18625	24	a	a	DT
18637	18625	25	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18625	26	act	act	NN
18637	18625	27	involving	involve	VBG
18637	18625	28	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
18637	18625	29	,	,	,
18637	18625	30	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	18625	31	which	which	WDT
18637	18625	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18625	33	was	be	VBD
18637	18625	34	unable	unable	JJ
18637	18625	35	to	to	TO
18637	18625	36	claim	claim	VB
18637	18625	37	a	a	DT
18637	18625	38	like	like	JJ
18637	18625	39	measure	measure	NN
18637	18625	40	of	of	IN
18637	18625	41	common	common	JJ
18637	18625	42	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	18625	43	,	,	,
18637	18625	44	fell	fall	VBD
18637	18625	45	back	back	RB
18637	18625	46	upon	upon	IN
18637	18625	47	the	the	DT
18637	18625	48	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	18625	49	of	of	IN
18637	18625	50	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	18625	51	validity	validity	NN
18637	18625	52	,	,	,
18637	18625	53	and	and	CC
18637	18625	54	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	18625	55	that	that	IN
18637	18625	56	"	"	``
18637	18625	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18625	58	does	do	VBZ
18637	18625	59	not	not	RB
18637	18625	60	appear	appear	VB
18637	18625	61	upon	upon	IN
18637	18625	62	the	the	DT
18637	18625	63	face	face	NN
18637	18625	64	of	of	IN
18637	18625	65	the	the	DT
18637	18625	66	statute	statute	NN
18637	18625	67	,	,	,
18637	18625	68	or	or	CC
18637	18625	69	from	from	IN
18637	18625	70	any	any	DT
18637	18625	71	of	of	IN
18637	18625	72	the	the	DT
18637	18625	73	facts	fact	NNS
18637	18625	74	of	of	IN
18637	18625	75	which	which	WDT
18637	18625	76	the	the	DT
18637	18625	77	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18625	78	must	must	MD
18637	18625	79	take	take	VB
18637	18625	80	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18625	81	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	18625	82	,	,	,
18637	18625	83	that	that	IN
18637	18625	84	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18625	85	infringes	infringe	VBZ
18637	18625	86	rights	right	NNS
18637	18625	87	secured	secure	VBN
18637	18625	88	by	by	IN
18637	18625	89	the	the	DT
18637	18625	90	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	18625	91	law	law	NN
18637	18625	92	,	,	,
18637	18625	93	*	*	NFP
18637	18625	94	*	*	NFP
18637	18625	95	*	*	NFP
18637	18625	96	"	"	''
18637	18625	97	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18625	98	81	81	CD
18637	18625	99	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18625	100	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	18625	101	the	the	DT
18637	18625	102	measure	measure	NN
18637	18625	103	.	.	.
18637	18626	1	In	in	IN
18637	18626	2	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	18626	3	to	to	IN
18637	18626	4	the	the	DT
18637	18626	5	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	18626	6	validity	validity	NN
18637	18626	7	rule	rule	NN
18637	18626	8	under	under	IN
18637	18626	9	which	which	WDT
18637	18626	10	the	the	DT
18637	18626	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18626	12	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	18626	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	18626	14	not	not	RB
18637	18626	15	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	18626	16	to	to	TO
18637	18626	17	go	go	VB
18637	18626	18	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	18626	19	the	the	DT
18637	18626	20	record	record	NN
18637	18626	21	of	of	IN
18637	18626	22	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18626	23	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	18626	24	by	by	IN
18637	18626	25	the	the	DT
18637	18626	26	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	18626	27	in	in	IN
18637	18626	28	determining	determine	VBG
18637	18626	29	the	the	DT
18637	18626	30	validity	validity	NN
18637	18626	31	of	of	IN
18637	18626	32	a	a	DT
18637	18626	33	statute	statute	NN
18637	18626	34	,	,	,
18637	18626	35	the	the	DT
18637	18626	36	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18626	37	notice	notice	NN
18637	18626	38	principle	principle	NN
18637	18626	39	,	,	,
18637	18626	40	as	as	IN
18637	18626	41	developed	develop	VBN
18637	18626	42	in	in	IN
18637	18626	43	Mugler	Mugler	NNP
18637	18626	44	_	_	NNP
18637	18626	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	18626	46	_	_	NNP
18637	18626	47	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	18626	48	,	,	,
18637	18626	49	carried	carry	VBD
18637	18626	50	the	the	DT
18637	18626	51	inference	inference	NN
18637	18626	52	that	that	IN
18637	18626	53	unless	unless	IN
18637	18626	54	the	the	DT
18637	18626	55	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18626	56	,	,	,
18637	18626	57	independently	independently	RB
18637	18626	58	of	of	IN
18637	18626	59	the	the	DT
18637	18626	60	record	record	NN
18637	18626	61	,	,	,
18637	18626	62	is	be	VBZ
18637	18626	63	able	able	JJ
18637	18626	64	to	to	TO
18637	18626	65	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	18626	66	the	the	DT
18637	18626	67	existence	existence	NN
18637	18626	68	of	of	IN
18637	18626	69	justifying	justify	VBG
18637	18626	70	facts	fact	NNS
18637	18626	71	accessible	accessible	JJ
18637	18626	72	to	to	IN
18637	18626	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18626	74	by	by	IN
18637	18626	75	the	the	DT
18637	18626	76	rules	rule	NNS
18637	18626	77	governing	govern	VBG
18637	18626	78	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18626	79	notice	notice	NN
18637	18626	80	,	,	,
18637	18626	81	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18626	82	will	will	MD
18637	18626	83	be	be	VB
18637	18626	84	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	18626	85	to	to	TO
18637	18626	86	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	18626	87	a	a	DT
18637	18626	88	police	police	NN
18637	18626	89	power	power	NN
18637	18626	90	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18626	91	as	as	IN
18637	18626	92	bearing	bear	VBG
18637	18626	93	no	no	DT
18637	18626	94	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18626	95	or	or	CC
18637	18626	96	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	18626	97	relation	relation	NN
18637	18626	98	to	to	IN
18637	18626	99	the	the	DT
18637	18626	100	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	18626	101	to	to	TO
18637	18626	102	be	be	VB
18637	18626	103	subserved	subserve	VBN
18637	18626	104	by	by	IN
18637	18626	105	the	the	DT
18637	18626	106	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18626	107	;	;	:
18637	18626	108	namely	namely	RB
18637	18626	109	,	,	,
18637	18626	110	health	health	NN
18637	18626	111	,	,	,
18637	18626	112	morals	moral	NNS
18637	18626	113	,	,	,
18637	18626	114	or	or	CC
18637	18626	115	safety	safety	NN
18637	18626	116	.	.	.
18637	18627	1	For	for	IN
18637	18627	2	appraising	appraise	VBG
18637	18627	3	State	state	NN
18637	18627	4	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18627	5	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	18627	6	neither	neither	CC
18637	18627	7	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18627	8	nor	nor	CC
18637	18627	9	property	property	NN
18637	18627	10	,	,	,
18637	18627	11	the	the	DT
18637	18627	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18627	13	found	find	VBD
18637	18627	14	the	the	DT
18637	18627	15	rule	rule	NN
18637	18627	16	of	of	IN
18637	18627	17	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	18627	18	validity	validity	NN
18637	18627	19	quite	quite	RB
18637	18627	20	serviceable	serviceable	JJ
18637	18627	21	;	;	:
18637	18627	22	but	but	CC
18637	18627	23	for	for	IN
18637	18627	24	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
18637	18627	25	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18627	26	constituting	constitute	VBG
18637	18627	27	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	18627	28	interference	interference	NN
18637	18627	29	in	in	IN
18637	18627	30	the	the	DT
18637	18627	31	field	field	NN
18637	18627	32	of	of	IN
18637	18627	33	economic	economic	JJ
18637	18627	34	relations	relation	NNS
18637	18627	35	,	,	,
18637	18627	36	and	and	CC
18637	18627	37	,	,	,
18637	18627	38	more	more	RBR
18637	18627	39	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	18627	40	,	,	,
18637	18627	41	labor	labor	NN
18637	18627	42	-	-	HYPH
18637	18627	43	management	management	NN
18637	18627	44	relations	relation	NNS
18637	18627	45	,	,	,
18637	18627	46	the	the	DT
18637	18627	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18627	48	found	find	VBD
18637	18627	49	the	the	DT
18637	18627	50	principle	principle	NN
18637	18627	51	of	of	IN
18637	18627	52	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18627	53	notice	notice	NN
18637	18627	54	more	more	RBR
18637	18627	55	advantageous	advantageous	JJ
18637	18627	56	.	.	.
18637	18628	1	This	this	DT
18637	18628	2	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	18628	3	was	be	VBD
18637	18628	4	enhanced	enhance	VBN
18637	18628	5	by	by	IN
18637	18628	6	the	the	DT
18637	18628	7	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	18628	8	of	of	IN
18637	18628	9	the	the	DT
18637	18628	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18628	11	,	,	,
18637	18628	12	in	in	IN
18637	18628	13	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	18628	14	embracing	embrace	VBG
18637	18628	15	the	the	DT
18637	18628	16	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18628	17	type	type	NN
18637	18628	18	of	of	IN
18637	18628	19	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18628	20	,	,	,
18637	18628	21	to	to	TO
18637	18628	22	shift	shift	VB
18637	18628	23	the	the	DT
18637	18628	24	burden	burden	NN
18637	18628	25	of	of	IN
18637	18628	26	proof	proof	NN
18637	18628	27	from	from	IN
18637	18628	28	the	the	DT
18637	18628	29	litigant	litigant	JJ
18637	18628	30	charging	charge	VBG
18637	18628	31	unconstitutionality	unconstitutionality	NN
18637	18628	32	to	to	IN
18637	18628	33	the	the	DT
18637	18628	34	State	state	NN
18637	18628	35	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	18628	36	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18628	37	.	.	.
18637	18629	1	To	to	IN
18637	18629	2	the	the	DT
18637	18629	3	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18629	4	was	be	VBD
18637	18629	5	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	18629	6	the	the	DT
18637	18629	7	task	task	NN
18637	18629	8	of	of	IN
18637	18629	9	demonstrating	demonstrate	VBG
18637	18629	10	that	that	IN
18637	18629	11	a	a	DT
18637	18629	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	18629	13	interfering	interfere	VBG
18637	18629	14	with	with	IN
18637	18629	15	the	the	DT
18637	18629	16	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18629	17	right	right	NN
18637	18629	18	of	of	IN
18637	18629	19	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18629	20	or	or	CC
18637	18629	21	property	property	NN
18637	18629	22	was	be	VBD
18637	18629	23	in	in	IN
18637	18629	24	fact	fact	NN
18637	18629	25	"	"	``
18637	18629	26	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	18629	27	"	"	''
18637	18629	28	by	by	IN
18637	18629	29	the	the	DT
18637	18629	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18629	31	and	and	CC
18637	18629	32	not	not	RB
18637	18629	33	merely	merely	RB
18637	18629	34	that	that	IN
18637	18629	35	the	the	DT
18637	18629	36	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18629	37	did	do	VBD
18637	18629	38	not	not	RB
18637	18629	39	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	18629	40	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	18629	41	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	18629	42	of	of	IN
18637	18629	43	the	the	DT
18637	18629	44	same	same	JJ
18637	18629	45	.	.	.
18637	18630	1	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	18630	2	of	of	IN
18637	18630	3	Contract	Contract	NNP
18637	18630	4	--	--	:
18637	18630	5	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	18630	6	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	18630	7	Although	although	IN
18637	18630	8	occasionally	occasionally	RB
18637	18630	9	acknowledging	acknowledge	VBG
18637	18630	10	in	in	IN
18637	18630	11	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	18630	12	terms	term	NNS
18637	18630	13	that	that	IN
18637	18630	14	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18630	15	of	of	IN
18637	18630	16	contract	contract	NN
18637	18630	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	18630	18	not	not	RB
18637	18630	19	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	18630	20	but	but	CC
18637	18630	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	18630	22	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18630	23	to	to	IN
18637	18630	24	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18630	25	by	by	IN
18637	18630	26	the	the	DT
18637	18630	27	State	State	NNP
18637	18630	28	in	in	IN
18637	18630	29	the	the	DT
18637	18630	30	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18630	31	of	of	IN
18637	18630	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18630	33	police	police	NN
18637	18630	34	powers	power	NNS
18637	18630	35	,	,	,
18637	18630	36	the	the	DT
18637	18630	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18630	38	,	,	,
18637	18630	39	in	in	IN
18637	18630	40	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	18630	41	with	with	IN
18637	18630	42	the	the	DT
18637	18630	43	aforementioned	aforementioned	JJ
18637	18630	44	theories	theory	NNS
18637	18630	45	of	of	IN
18637	18630	46	economics	economic	NNS
18637	18630	47	and	and	CC
18637	18630	48	evolution	evolution	NN
18637	18630	49	,	,	,
18637	18630	50	was	be	VBD
18637	18630	51	in	in	IN
18637	18630	52	fact	fact	NN
18637	18630	53	committed	commit	VBN
18637	18630	54	to	to	IN
18637	18630	55	the	the	DT
18637	18630	56	principle	principle	NN
18637	18630	57	that	that	DT
18637	18630	58	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18630	59	of	of	IN
18637	18630	60	contract	contract	NN
18637	18630	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	18630	62	the	the	DT
18637	18630	63	general	general	JJ
18637	18630	64	rule	rule	NN
18637	18630	65	and	and	CC
18637	18630	66	that	that	IN
18637	18630	67	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18630	68	authority	authority	NN
18637	18630	69	to	to	TO
18637	18630	70	abridge	abridge	VB
18637	18630	71	the	the	DT
18637	18630	72	same	same	JJ
18637	18630	73	could	could	MD
18637	18630	74	be	be	VB
18637	18630	75	justified	justify	VBN
18637	18630	76	only	only	RB
18637	18630	77	by	by	IN
18637	18630	78	exceptional	exceptional	JJ
18637	18630	79	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	18630	80	.	.	.
18637	18631	1	To	to	TO
18637	18631	2	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	18631	3	such	such	JJ
18637	18631	4	abridgments	abridgment	NNS
18637	18631	5	at	at	IN
18637	18631	6	a	a	DT
18637	18631	7	minimum	minimum	NN
18637	18631	8	,	,	,
18637	18631	9	the	the	DT
18637	18631	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18631	11	intermittently	intermittently	RB
18637	18631	12	employed	employ	VBD
18637	18631	13	the	the	DT
18637	18631	14	rule	rule	NN
18637	18631	15	of	of	IN
18637	18631	16	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18631	17	notice	notice	NN
18637	18631	18	in	in	IN
18637	18631	19	a	a	DT
18637	18631	20	manner	manner	NN
18637	18631	21	best	best	RB
18637	18631	22	exemplified	exemplify	VBN
18637	18631	23	by	by	IN
18637	18631	24	a	a	DT
18637	18631	25	comparison	comparison	NN
18637	18631	26	of	of	IN
18637	18631	27	the	the	DT
18637	18631	28	early	early	JJ
18637	18631	29	cases	case	NNS
18637	18631	30	of	of	IN
18637	18631	31	Holden	Holden	NNP
18637	18631	32	_	_	NNP
18637	18631	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	18631	34	_	_	NNP
18637	18631	35	Hardy[82	hardy[82	ADD
18637	18631	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18631	37	and	and	CC
18637	18631	38	Lochner	Lochner	NNP
18637	18631	39	_	_	NNP
18637	18631	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	18631	41	_	_	NNP
18637	18631	42	New	New	NNP
18637	18631	43	York,[83	York,[83	NNP
18637	18631	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18631	45	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	18631	46	which	which	WDT
18637	18631	47	bear	bear	VBP
18637	18631	48	the	the	DT
18637	18631	49	same	same	JJ
18637	18631	50	relation	relation	NN
18637	18631	51	to	to	IN
18637	18631	52	each	each	DT
18637	18631	53	other	other	JJ
18637	18631	54	as	as	IN
18637	18631	55	Powell	Powell	NNP
18637	18631	56	_	_	NNP
18637	18631	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	18631	58	_	_	NNP
18637	18631	59	Pennsylvania[84	Pennsylvania[84	NNP
18637	18631	60	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18631	61	and	and	CC
18637	18631	62	Mugler	Mugler	NNP
18637	18631	63	_	_	NNP
18637	18631	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	18631	65	_	_	NNP
18637	18631	66	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	18631	67	.	.	.
18637	18632	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18632	2	85	85	CD
18637	18632	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18632	4	In	in	IN
18637	18632	5	Holden	Holden	NNP
18637	18632	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18632	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18632	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18632	9	Hardy	Hardy	NNP
18637	18632	10	,	,	,
18637	18632	11	decided	decide	VBD
18637	18632	12	in	in	IN
18637	18632	13	1898	1898	CD
18637	18632	14	,	,	,
18637	18632	15	the	the	DT
18637	18632	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18632	17	,	,	,
18637	18632	18	in	in	IN
18637	18632	19	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	18632	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	18632	21	the	the	DT
18637	18632	22	principle	principle	NN
18637	18632	23	of	of	IN
18637	18632	24	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	18632	25	validity	validity	NN
18637	18632	26	,	,	,
18637	18632	27	allowed	allow	VBD
18637	18632	28	the	the	DT
18637	18632	29	burden	burden	NN
18637	18632	30	of	of	IN
18637	18632	31	proof	proof	NN
18637	18632	32	to	to	TO
18637	18632	33	remain	remain	VB
18637	18632	34	with	with	IN
18637	18632	35	those	those	DT
18637	18632	36	attacking	attack	VBG
18637	18632	37	the	the	DT
18637	18632	38	validity	validity	NN
18637	18632	39	of	of	IN
18637	18632	40	a	a	DT
18637	18632	41	statute	statute	NN
18637	18632	42	and	and	CC
18637	18632	43	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	18632	44	a	a	DT
18637	18632	45	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	18632	46	act	act	NN
18637	18632	47	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	18632	48	the	the	DT
18637	18632	49	period	period	NN
18637	18632	50	of	of	IN
18637	18632	51	labor	labor	NN
18637	18632	52	in	in	IN
18637	18632	53	mines	mine	NNS
18637	18632	54	to	to	IN
18637	18632	55	eight	eight	CD
18637	18632	56	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18632	57	per	per	IN
18637	18632	58	day	day	NN
18637	18632	59	.	.	.
18637	18633	1	Taking	take	VBG
18637	18633	2	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	18633	3	of	of	IN
18637	18633	4	the	the	DT
18637	18633	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	18633	6	that	that	IN
18637	18633	7	labor	labor	NN
18637	18633	8	below	below	IN
18637	18633	9	the	the	DT
18637	18633	10	surface	surface	NN
18637	18633	11	of	of	IN
18637	18633	12	the	the	DT
18637	18633	13	earth	earth	NN
18637	18633	14	was	be	VBD
18637	18633	15	attended	attend	VBN
18637	18633	16	by	by	IN
18637	18633	17	risk	risk	NN
18637	18633	18	to	to	IN
18637	18633	19	person	person	NN
18637	18633	20	and	and	CC
18637	18633	21	to	to	TO
18637	18633	22	health	health	VB
18637	18633	23	and	and	CC
18637	18633	24	for	for	IN
18637	18633	25	these	these	DT
18637	18633	26	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	18633	27	had	have	VBD
18637	18633	28	long	long	RB
18637	18633	29	been	be	VBN
18637	18633	30	the	the	DT
18637	18633	31	subject	subject	NN
18637	18633	32	of	of	IN
18637	18633	33	State	state	NN
18637	18633	34	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	18633	35	,	,	,
18637	18633	36	the	the	DT
18637	18633	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18633	38	registered	register	VBD
18637	18633	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18633	40	willingness	willingness	NN
18637	18633	41	to	to	TO
18637	18633	42	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	18633	43	a	a	DT
18637	18633	44	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	18633	45	on	on	IN
18637	18633	46	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18633	47	of	of	IN
18637	18633	48	contract	contract	NN
18637	18633	49	which	which	WDT
18637	18633	50	a	a	DT
18637	18633	51	State	state	NN
18637	18633	52	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18633	53	had	have	VBD
18637	18633	54	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
18637	18633	55	"	"	``
18637	18633	56	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18633	57	for	for	IN
18637	18633	58	the	the	DT
18637	18633	59	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	18633	60	of	of	IN
18637	18633	61	health	health	NN
18637	18633	62	of	of	IN
18637	18633	63	employees	employee	NNS
18637	18633	64	,	,	,
18637	18633	65	"	"	''
18637	18633	66	and	and	CC
18637	18633	67	for	for	IN
18637	18633	68	which	which	WDT
18637	18633	69	there	there	EX
18637	18633	70	were	be	VBD
18637	18633	71	"	"	``
18637	18633	72	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18633	73	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	18633	74	for	for	IN
18637	18633	75	believing	believe	VBG
18637	18633	76	that	that	IN
18637	18633	77	*	*	NFP
18637	18633	78	*	*	NFP
18637	18633	79	*	*	NFP
18637	18633	80	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18633	81	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18633	82	was	be	VBD
18637	18633	83	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18633	84	supported	support	VBN
18637	18633	85	by	by	IN
18637	18633	86	the	the	DT
18637	18633	87	facts	fact	NNS
18637	18633	88	.	.	.
18637	18634	1	"	"	``
18637	18634	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18634	3	86	86	CD
18637	18634	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18634	5	Seven	seven	CD
18637	18634	6	years	year	NNS
18637	18634	7	later	later	RB
18637	18634	8	,	,	,
18637	18634	9	however	however	RB
18637	18634	10	,	,	,
18637	18634	11	a	a	DT
18637	18634	12	radically	radically	RB
18637	18634	13	altered	alter	VBN
18637	18634	14	court	court	NN
18637	18634	15	was	be	VBD
18637	18634	16	predisposed	predispose	VBN
18637	18634	17	in	in	IN
18637	18634	18	favor	favor	NN
18637	18634	19	of	of	IN
18637	18634	20	the	the	DT
18637	18634	21	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	18634	22	of	of	IN
18637	18634	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18634	24	notice	notice	NN
18637	18634	25	,	,	,
18637	18634	26	through	through	IN
18637	18634	27	application	application	NN
18637	18634	28	of	of	IN
18637	18634	29	which	which	WDT
18637	18634	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18634	31	arrived	arrive	VBD
18637	18634	32	at	at	IN
18637	18634	33	the	the	DT
18637	18634	34	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	18634	35	,	,	,
18637	18634	36	in	in	IN
18637	18634	37	Lochner	Lochner	NNP
18637	18634	38	_	_	NNP
18637	18634	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	18634	40	_	_	NNP
18637	18634	41	New	New	NNP
18637	18634	42	York	York	NNP
18637	18634	43	,	,	,
18637	18634	44	that	that	IN
18637	18634	45	a	a	DT
18637	18634	46	law	law	NN
18637	18634	47	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	18634	48	employment	employment	NN
18637	18634	49	in	in	IN
18637	18634	50	bakeries	bakery	NNS
18637	18634	51	to	to	IN
18637	18634	52	ten	ten	CD
18637	18634	53	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18634	54	per	per	IN
18637	18634	55	day	day	NN
18637	18634	56	and	and	CC
18637	18634	57	60	60	CD
18637	18634	58	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18634	59	per	per	IN
18637	18634	60	week	week	NN
18637	18634	61	was	be	VBD
18637	18634	62	an	an	DT
18637	18634	63	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18634	64	interference	interference	NN
18637	18634	65	with	with	IN
18637	18634	66	the	the	DT
18637	18634	67	right	right	NN
18637	18634	68	of	of	IN
18637	18634	69	adult	adult	NN
18637	18634	70	laborers	laborer	NNS
18637	18634	71	,	,	,
18637	18634	72	_	_	NNP
18637	18634	73	sui	sui	NNP
18637	18634	74	juris	juris	NNP
18637	18634	75	_	_	NNP
18637	18634	76	,	,	,
18637	18634	77	to	to	TO
18637	18634	78	contract	contract	VB
18637	18634	79	with	with	IN
18637	18634	80	respect	respect	NN
18637	18634	81	to	to	IN
18637	18634	82	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18634	83	means	mean	NNS
18637	18634	84	of	of	IN
18637	18634	85	livelihood	livelihood	NN
18637	18634	86	.	.	.
18637	18635	1	Denying	deny	VBG
18637	18635	2	that	that	DT
18637	18635	3	in	in	IN
18637	18635	4	so	so	RB
18637	18635	5	holding	hold	VBG
18637	18635	6	that	that	IN
18637	18635	7	the	the	DT
18637	18635	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18635	9	was	be	VBD
18637	18635	10	in	in	IN
18637	18635	11	effect	effect	NN
18637	18635	12	substituting	substitute	VBG
18637	18635	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18635	14	own	own	JJ
18637	18635	15	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18635	16	for	for	IN
18637	18635	17	that	that	DT
18637	18635	18	of	of	IN
18637	18635	19	the	the	DT
18637	18635	20	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18635	21	,	,	,
18637	18635	22	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18635	23	Peckham	Peckham	NNP
18637	18635	24	,	,	,
18637	18635	25	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	18635	26	,	,	,
18637	18635	27	maintained	maintain	VBD
18637	18635	28	that	that	IN
18637	18635	29	whether	whether	IN
18637	18635	30	the	the	DT
18637	18635	31	act	act	NN
18637	18635	32	was	be	VBD
18637	18635	33	within	within	IN
18637	18635	34	the	the	DT
18637	18635	35	police	police	NN
18637	18635	36	power	power	NN
18637	18635	37	of	of	IN
18637	18635	38	the	the	DT
18637	18635	39	State	State	NNP
18637	18635	40	was	be	VBD
18637	18635	41	a	a	DT
18637	18635	42	"	"	``
18637	18635	43	question	question	NN
18637	18635	44	that	that	WDT
18637	18635	45	must	must	MD
18637	18635	46	be	be	VB
18637	18635	47	answered	answer	VBN
18637	18635	48	by	by	IN
18637	18635	49	the	the	DT
18637	18635	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18635	51	"	"	''
18637	18635	52	;	;	:
18637	18635	53	and	and	CC
18637	18635	54	then	then	RB
18637	18635	55	,	,	,
18637	18635	56	in	in	IN
18637	18635	57	disregard	disregard	NN
18637	18635	58	of	of	IN
18637	18635	59	the	the	DT
18637	18635	60	accumulated	accumulate	VBN
18637	18635	61	medical	medical	JJ
18637	18635	62	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18635	63	proffered	proffer	VBN
18637	18635	64	in	in	IN
18637	18635	65	support	support	NN
18637	18635	66	of	of	IN
18637	18635	67	the	the	DT
18637	18635	68	act	act	NN
18637	18635	69	,	,	,
18637	18635	70	uttered	utter	VBD
18637	18635	71	the	the	DT
18637	18635	72	following	follow	VBG
18637	18635	73	observation	observation	NN
18637	18635	74	:	:	:
18637	18635	75	"	"	``
18637	18635	76	In	in	IN
18637	18635	77	looking	look	VBG
18637	18635	78	through	through	IN
18637	18635	79	statistics	statistic	NNS
18637	18635	80	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	18635	81	all	all	DT
18637	18635	82	trades	trade	NNS
18637	18635	83	and	and	CC
18637	18635	84	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	18635	85	,	,	,
18637	18635	86	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18635	87	may	may	MD
18637	18635	88	be	be	VB
18637	18635	89	true	true	JJ
18637	18635	90	that	that	IN
18637	18635	91	the	the	DT
18637	18635	92	trade	trade	NN
18637	18635	93	of	of	IN
18637	18635	94	a	a	DT
18637	18635	95	baker	baker	NN
18637	18635	96	does	do	VBZ
18637	18635	97	not	not	RB
18637	18635	98	appear	appear	VB
18637	18635	99	to	to	TO
18637	18635	100	be	be	VB
18637	18635	101	as	as	RB
18637	18635	102	healthy	healthy	JJ
18637	18635	103	as	as	IN
18637	18635	104	some	some	DT
18637	18635	105	trades	trade	NNS
18637	18635	106	,	,	,
18637	18635	107	and	and	CC
18637	18635	108	is	be	VBZ
18637	18635	109	also	also	RB
18637	18635	110	vastly	vastly	RB
18637	18635	111	more	more	RBR
18637	18635	112	healthy	healthy	JJ
18637	18635	113	than	than	IN
18637	18635	114	still	still	RB
18637	18635	115	others	other	NNS
18637	18635	116	.	.	.
18637	18636	1	To	to	IN
18637	18636	2	the	the	DT
18637	18636	3	common	common	JJ
18637	18636	4	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	18636	5	the	the	DT
18637	18636	6	trade	trade	NN
18637	18636	7	of	of	IN
18637	18636	8	a	a	DT
18637	18636	9	baker	baker	NN
18637	18636	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	18636	11	never	never	RB
18637	18636	12	been	be	VBN
18637	18636	13	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	18636	14	as	as	IN
18637	18636	15	an	an	DT
18637	18636	16	unhealthy	unhealthy	JJ
18637	18636	17	one	one	CD
18637	18636	18	.	.	.
18637	18637	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18637	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18637	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18637	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18637	5	might	may	MD
18637	18637	6	be	be	VB
18637	18637	7	safely	safely	RB
18637	18637	8	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	18637	9	that	that	IN
18637	18637	10	almost	almost	RB
18637	18637	11	all	all	DT
18637	18637	12	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	18637	13	more	more	RBR
18637	18637	14	or	or	CC
18637	18637	15	less	less	RBR
18637	18637	16	affect	affect	VB
18637	18637	17	the	the	DT
18637	18637	18	health	health	NN
18637	18637	19	.	.	.
18637	18638	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18638	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18638	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18638	4	But	but	CC
18637	18638	5	are	be	VBP
18637	18638	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18638	7	all	all	DT
18637	18638	8	,	,	,
18637	18638	9	on	on	IN
18637	18638	10	that	that	DT
18637	18638	11	account	account	NN
18637	18638	12	,	,	,
18637	18638	13	at	at	IN
18637	18638	14	the	the	DT
18637	18638	15	mercy	mercy	NN
18637	18638	16	of	of	IN
18637	18638	17	the	the	DT
18637	18638	18	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18638	19	majorities	majority	NNS
18637	18638	20	?	?	.
18637	18639	1	"	"	``
18637	18639	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18639	3	87	87	CD
18637	18639	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18639	5	Of	of	IN
18637	18639	6	two	two	CD
18637	18639	7	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	18639	8	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	18639	9	filed	file	VBN
18637	18639	10	in	in	IN
18637	18639	11	the	the	DT
18637	18639	12	case	case	NN
18637	18639	13	,	,	,
18637	18639	14	one	one	CD
18637	18639	15	,	,	,
18637	18639	16	prepared	prepare	VBN
18637	18639	17	by	by	IN
18637	18639	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18639	19	Harlan	Harlan	NNP
18637	18639	20	,	,	,
18637	18639	21	stressed	stress	VBD
18637	18639	22	the	the	DT
18637	18639	23	abundance	abundance	NN
18637	18639	24	of	of	IN
18637	18639	25	medical	medical	JJ
18637	18639	26	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	18639	27	tending	tend	VBG
18637	18639	28	to	to	TO
18637	18639	29	show	show	VB
18637	18639	30	that	that	IN
18637	18639	31	the	the	DT
18637	18639	32	life	life	NN
18637	18639	33	expectancy	expectancy	NN
18637	18639	34	of	of	IN
18637	18639	35	bakers	baker	NNS
18637	18639	36	was	be	VBD
18637	18639	37	below	below	IN
18637	18639	38	average	average	JJ
18637	18639	39	,	,	,
18637	18639	40	that	that	IN
18637	18639	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18639	42	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	18639	43	to	to	TO
18637	18639	44	resist	resist	VB
18637	18639	45	diseases	disease	NNS
18637	18639	46	was	be	VBD
18637	18639	47	low	low	JJ
18637	18639	48	,	,	,
18637	18639	49	and	and	CC
18637	18639	50	that	that	IN
18637	18639	51	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18639	52	were	be	VBD
18637	18639	53	peculiarly	peculiarly	RB
18637	18639	54	prone	prone	JJ
18637	18639	55	to	to	TO
18637	18639	56	suffer	suffer	VB
18637	18639	57	irritations	irritation	NNS
18637	18639	58	of	of	IN
18637	18639	59	the	the	DT
18637	18639	60	eyes	eye	NNS
18637	18639	61	,	,	,
18637	18639	62	lungs	lung	NNS
18637	18639	63	,	,	,
18637	18639	64	and	and	CC
18637	18639	65	bronchial	bronchial	JJ
18637	18639	66	passages	passage	NNS
18637	18639	67	;	;	:
18637	18639	68	and	and	CC
18637	18639	69	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	18639	70	that	that	IN
18637	18639	71	the	the	DT
18637	18639	72	very	very	JJ
18637	18639	73	existence	existence	NN
18637	18639	74	of	of	IN
18637	18639	75	such	such	JJ
18637	18639	76	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18639	77	left	leave	VBD
18637	18639	78	the	the	DT
18637	18639	79	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	18639	80	of	of	IN
18637	18639	81	the	the	DT
18637	18639	82	measure	measure	NN
18637	18639	83	under	under	IN
18637	18639	84	review	review	NN
18637	18639	85	open	open	JJ
18637	18639	86	to	to	IN
18637	18639	87	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	18639	88	and	and	CC
18637	18639	89	that	that	IN
18637	18639	90	the	the	DT
18637	18639	91	the	the	DT
18637	18639	92	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18639	93	fact	fact	NN
18637	18639	94	,	,	,
18637	18639	95	of	of	IN
18637	18639	96	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18639	97	,	,	,
18637	18639	98	put	put	VBD
18637	18639	99	the	the	DT
18637	18639	100	statute	statute	NN
18637	18639	101	within	within	IN
18637	18639	102	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18639	103	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	18639	104	.	.	.
18637	18640	1	"	"	``
18637	18640	2	'	'	``
18637	18640	3	Responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	18640	4	,	,	,
18637	18640	5	'	'	''
18637	18640	6	according	accord	VBG
18637	18640	7	to	to	IN
18637	18640	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18640	9	Harlan	Harlan	NNP
18637	18640	10	,	,	,
18637	18640	11	'	'	''
18637	18640	12	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	18640	13	,	,	,
18637	18640	14	rests	rest	NNS
18637	18640	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	18640	16	the	the	DT
18637	18640	17	legislators	legislator	NNS
18637	18640	18	,	,	,
18637	18640	19	not	not	RB
18637	18640	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	18640	21	the	the	DT
18637	18640	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	18640	23	.	.	.
18637	18641	1	No	no	DT
18637	18641	2	evils	evil	NNS
18637	18641	3	arising	arise	VBG
18637	18641	4	from	from	IN
18637	18641	5	such	such	JJ
18637	18641	6	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18641	7	could	could	MD
18637	18641	8	be	be	VB
18637	18641	9	more	more	RBR
18637	18641	10	far	far	RB
18637	18641	11	reaching	reach	VBG
18637	18641	12	than	than	IN
18637	18641	13	those	those	DT
18637	18641	14	that	that	WDT
18637	18641	15	might	may	MD
18637	18641	16	come	come	VB
18637	18641	17	to	to	IN
18637	18641	18	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18641	19	system	system	NN
18637	18641	20	of	of	IN
18637	18641	21	government	government	NN
18637	18641	22	if	if	IN
18637	18641	23	the	the	DT
18637	18641	24	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	18641	25	,	,	,
18637	18641	26	abandoning	abandon	VBG
18637	18641	27	the	the	DT
18637	18641	28	sphere	sphere	RB
18637	18641	29	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	18641	30	to	to	IN
18637	18641	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18641	32	by	by	IN
18637	18641	33	the	the	DT
18637	18641	34	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	18641	35	law	law	NN
18637	18641	36	,	,	,
18637	18641	37	should	should	MD
18637	18641	38	enter	enter	VB
18637	18641	39	the	the	DT
18637	18641	40	domain	domain	NN
18637	18641	41	of	of	IN
18637	18641	42	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18641	43	,	,	,
18637	18641	44	and	and	CC
18637	18641	45	upon	upon	IN
18637	18641	46	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	18641	47	merely	merely	RB
18637	18641	48	of	of	IN
18637	18641	49	justice	justice	NN
18637	18641	50	or	or	CC
18637	18641	51	reason	reason	NN
18637	18641	52	or	or	CC
18637	18641	53	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	18641	54	annul	annul	NN
18637	18641	55	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18641	56	that	that	WDT
18637	18641	57	had	have	VBD
18637	18641	58	received	receive	VBN
18637	18641	59	the	the	DT
18637	18641	60	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	18641	61	of	of	IN
18637	18641	62	the	the	DT
18637	18641	63	people	people	NNS
18637	18641	64	's	's	POS
18637	18641	65	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	18641	66	.	.	.
18637	18642	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18642	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18642	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18642	4	The	the	DT
18637	18642	5	public	public	JJ
18637	18642	6	interest	interest	NN
18637	18642	7	imperatively	imperatively	RB
18637	18642	8	demand	demand	VBP
18637	18642	9	--	--	:
18637	18642	10	that	that	IN
18637	18642	11	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18642	12	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	18642	13	should	should	MD
18637	18642	14	be	be	VB
18637	18642	15	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	18642	16	and	and	CC
18637	18642	17	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	18642	18	by	by	IN
18637	18642	19	the	the	DT
18637	18642	20	courts	court	NNS
18637	18642	21	as	as	IN
18637	18642	22	embodying	embody	VBG
18637	18642	23	the	the	DT
18637	18642	24	will	will	NN
18637	18642	25	of	of	IN
18637	18642	26	the	the	DT
18637	18642	27	people	people	NNS
18637	18642	28	,	,	,
18637	18642	29	unless	unless	IN
18637	18642	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18642	31	are	be	VBP
18637	18642	32	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	18642	33	and	and	CC
18637	18642	34	palpably	palpably	RB
18637	18642	35	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	18642	36	all	all	DT
18637	18642	37	question	question	NN
18637	18642	38	in	in	IN
18637	18642	39	violation	violation	NN
18637	18642	40	of	of	IN
18637	18642	41	the	the	DT
18637	18642	42	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	18642	43	law	law	NN
18637	18642	44	of	of	IN
18637	18642	45	the	the	DT
18637	18642	46	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18642	47	.	.	.
18637	18643	1	'	'	``
18637	18643	2	"	"	``
18637	18643	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18643	4	88	88	CD
18637	18643	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18643	6	The	the	DT
18637	18643	7	second	second	JJ
18637	18643	8	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	18643	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	18643	10	written	write	VBN
18637	18643	11	by	by	IN
18637	18643	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18643	13	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	18643	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	18643	15	received	receive	VBN
18637	18643	16	the	the	DT
18637	18643	17	greater	great	JJR
18637	18643	18	measure	measure	NN
18637	18643	19	of	of	IN
18637	18643	20	attention	attention	NN
18637	18643	21	,	,	,
18637	18643	22	however	however	RB
18637	18643	23	,	,	,
18637	18643	24	for	for	IN
18637	18643	25	the	the	DT
18637	18643	26	views	view	NNS
18637	18643	27	expressed	express	VBN
18637	18643	28	therein	therein	RB
18637	18643	29	were	be	VBD
18637	18643	30	a	a	DT
18637	18643	31	forecast	forecast	NN
18637	18643	32	of	of	IN
18637	18643	33	the	the	DT
18637	18643	34	line	line	NN
18637	18643	35	of	of	IN
18637	18643	36	reasoning	reason	VBG
18637	18643	37	to	to	TO
18637	18643	38	be	be	VB
18637	18643	39	followed	follow	VBN
18637	18643	40	by	by	IN
18637	18643	41	the	the	DT
18637	18643	42	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18643	43	some	some	DT
18637	18643	44	decades	decade	NNS
18637	18643	45	later	later	RB
18637	18643	46	.	.	.
18637	18644	1	According	accord	VBG
18637	18644	2	to	to	IN
18637	18644	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18644	4	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	18644	5	:	:	:
18637	18644	6	"	"	``
18637	18644	7	This	this	DT
18637	18644	8	case	case	NN
18637	18644	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	18644	10	decided	decide	VBN
18637	18644	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	18644	12	an	an	DT
18637	18644	13	economic	economic	JJ
18637	18644	14	theory	theory	NN
18637	18644	15	which	which	WDT
18637	18644	16	a	a	DT
18637	18644	17	large	large	JJ
18637	18644	18	part	part	NN
18637	18644	19	of	of	IN
18637	18644	20	the	the	DT
18637	18644	21	country	country	NN
18637	18644	22	does	do	VBZ
18637	18644	23	not	not	RB
18637	18644	24	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	18644	25	.	.	.
18637	18645	1	If	if	IN
18637	18645	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18645	3	were	be	VBD
18637	18645	4	a	a	DT
18637	18645	5	question	question	NN
18637	18645	6	whether	whether	IN
18637	18645	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18645	8	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	18645	9	with	with	IN
18637	18645	10	that	that	DT
18637	18645	11	theory	theory	NN
18637	18645	12	,	,	,
18637	18645	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18645	14	should	should	MD
18637	18645	15	desire	desire	VB
18637	18645	16	to	to	TO
18637	18645	17	study	study	VB
18637	18645	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18645	19	further	further	RB
18637	18645	20	and	and	CC
18637	18645	21	long	long	RB
18637	18645	22	before	before	IN
18637	18645	23	making	make	VBG
18637	18645	24	up	up	RP
18637	18645	25	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18645	26	mind	mind	NN
18637	18645	27	.	.	.
18637	18646	1	But	but	CC
18637	18646	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18646	3	do	do	VBP
18637	18646	4	not	not	RB
18637	18646	5	conceive	conceive	VB
18637	18646	6	that	that	DT
18637	18646	7	to	to	TO
18637	18646	8	be	be	VB
18637	18646	9	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18646	10	duty	duty	NN
18637	18646	11	,	,	,
18637	18646	12	because	because	IN
18637	18646	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18646	14	strongly	strongly	RB
18637	18646	15	believe	believe	VBP
18637	18646	16	that	that	IN
18637	18646	17	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18646	18	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	18646	19	or	or	CC
18637	18646	20	disagreement	disagreement	NN
18637	18646	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	18646	22	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	18646	23	to	to	TO
18637	18646	24	do	do	VB
18637	18646	25	with	with	IN
18637	18646	26	the	the	DT
18637	18646	27	right	right	NN
18637	18646	28	of	of	IN
18637	18646	29	a	a	DT
18637	18646	30	majority	majority	NN
18637	18646	31	to	to	TO
18637	18646	32	embody	embody	VB
18637	18646	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18646	34	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	18646	35	in	in	IN
18637	18646	36	law	law	NN
18637	18646	37	.	.	.
18637	18647	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18647	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	18647	3	settled	settle	VBN
18637	18647	4	by	by	IN
18637	18647	5	various	various	JJ
18637	18647	6	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	18647	7	of	of	IN
18637	18647	8	this	this	DT
18637	18647	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18647	10	that	that	WDT
18637	18647	11	State	State	NNP
18637	18647	12	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	18647	13	and	and	CC
18637	18647	14	State	state	NN
18637	18647	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	18647	16	may	may	MD
18637	18647	17	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	18647	18	life	life	NN
18637	18647	19	in	in	IN
18637	18647	20	many	many	JJ
18637	18647	21	ways	way	NNS
18637	18647	22	which	which	WDT
18637	18647	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18647	24	as	as	IN
18637	18647	25	legislators	legislator	NNS
18637	18647	26	might	may	MD
18637	18647	27	think	think	VB
18637	18647	28	as	as	RB
18637	18647	29	injudicious	injudicious	JJ
18637	18647	30	or	or	CC
18637	18647	31	if	if	IN
18637	18647	32	you	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18647	33	like	like	VBP
18637	18647	34	as	as	RB
18637	18647	35	tyrannical	tyrannical	JJ
18637	18647	36	as	as	IN
18637	18647	37	this	this	DT
18637	18647	38	,	,	,
18637	18647	39	and	and	CC
18637	18647	40	which	which	WDT
18637	18647	41	equally	equally	RB
18637	18647	42	with	with	IN
18637	18647	43	this	this	DT
18637	18647	44	interfere	interfere	NN
18637	18647	45	with	with	IN
18637	18647	46	the	the	DT
18637	18647	47	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18647	48	to	to	TO
18637	18647	49	contract	contract	VB
18637	18647	50	.	.	.
18637	18648	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18648	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18648	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18648	4	The	the	DT
18637	18648	5	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18648	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18648	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	18648	8	not	not	RB
18637	18648	9	enact	enact	VB
18637	18648	10	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	18648	11	Herbert	Herbert	NNP
18637	18648	12	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
18637	18648	13	's	's	POS
18637	18648	14	Social	Social	NNP
18637	18648	15	Statics	Statics	NNPS
18637	18648	16	.	.	.
18637	18649	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18649	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18649	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18649	4	But	but	CC
18637	18649	5	a	a	DT
18637	18649	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18649	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	18649	8	not	not	RB
18637	18649	9	intended	intend	VBN
18637	18649	10	to	to	TO
18637	18649	11	embody	embody	VB
18637	18649	12	a	a	DT
18637	18649	13	particular	particular	JJ
18637	18649	14	economic	economic	JJ
18637	18649	15	theory	theory	NN
18637	18649	16	,	,	,
18637	18649	17	whether	whether	IN
18637	18649	18	of	of	IN
18637	18649	19	paternalism	paternalism	NN
18637	18649	20	and	and	CC
18637	18649	21	the	the	DT
18637	18649	22	organic	organic	JJ
18637	18649	23	relation	relation	NN
18637	18649	24	of	of	IN
18637	18649	25	the	the	DT
18637	18649	26	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18649	27	to	to	IN
18637	18649	28	the	the	DT
18637	18649	29	State	State	NNP
18637	18649	30	or	or	CC
18637	18649	31	of	of	IN
18637	18649	32	_	_	NNP
18637	18649	33	laissez	laissez	NNP
18637	18649	34	faire	faire	NN
18637	18649	35	_	_	NNP
18637	18649	36	.	.	.
18637	18650	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18650	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	18650	3	made	make	VBN
18637	18650	4	for	for	IN
18637	18650	5	people	people	NNS
18637	18650	6	of	of	IN
18637	18650	7	fundamentally	fundamentally	RB
18637	18650	8	differing	differ	VBG
18637	18650	9	views	view	NNS
18637	18650	10	,	,	,
18637	18650	11	and	and	CC
18637	18650	12	the	the	DT
18637	18650	13	accident	accident	NN
18637	18650	14	of	of	IN
18637	18650	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18650	16	finding	find	VBG
18637	18650	17	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18650	18	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	18650	19	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18650	20	and	and	CC
18637	18650	21	familiar	familiar	JJ
18637	18650	22	or	or	CC
18637	18650	23	novel	novel	JJ
18637	18650	24	and	and	CC
18637	18650	25	even	even	RB
18637	18650	26	shocking	shocking	JJ
18637	18650	27	ought	ought	MD
18637	18650	28	not	not	RB
18637	18650	29	to	to	TO
18637	18650	30	conclude	conclude	VB
18637	18650	31	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18650	32	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18650	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	18650	34	the	the	DT
18637	18650	35	question	question	NN
18637	18650	36	whether	whether	IN
18637	18650	37	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18650	38	embodying	embody	VBG
18637	18650	39	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18650	40	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	18650	41	with	with	IN
18637	18650	42	the	the	DT
18637	18650	43	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18650	44	*	*	NFP
18637	18650	45	*	*	NFP
18637	18650	46	*	*	NFP
18637	18650	47	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18650	48	think	think	VBP
18637	18650	49	that	that	IN
18637	18650	50	the	the	DT
18637	18650	51	word	word	NN
18637	18650	52	'	'	``
18637	18650	53	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18650	54	,	,	,
18637	18650	55	'	'	''
18637	18650	56	in	in	IN
18637	18650	57	the	the	DT
18637	18650	58	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18650	59	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18650	60	is	be	VBZ
18637	18650	61	perverted	pervert	VBN
18637	18650	62	when	when	WRB
18637	18650	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18650	64	is	be	VBZ
18637	18650	65	held	hold	VBN
18637	18650	66	to	to	TO
18637	18650	67	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18650	68	the	the	DT
18637	18650	69	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18650	70	outcome	outcome	NN
18637	18650	71	of	of	IN
18637	18650	72	a	a	DT
18637	18650	73	dominant	dominant	JJ
18637	18650	74	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	18650	75	,	,	,
18637	18650	76	unless	unless	IN
18637	18650	77	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18650	78	can	can	MD
18637	18650	79	be	be	VB
18637	18650	80	said	say	VBN
18637	18650	81	that	that	IN
18637	18650	82	a	a	DT
18637	18650	83	rational	rational	JJ
18637	18650	84	and	and	CC
18637	18650	85	fair	fair	JJ
18637	18650	86	man	man	NN
18637	18650	87	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	18650	88	would	would	MD
18637	18650	89	admit	admit	VB
18637	18650	90	that	that	IN
18637	18650	91	the	the	DT
18637	18650	92	statute	statute	NN
18637	18650	93	proposed	propose	VBD
18637	18650	94	would	would	MD
18637	18650	95	infringe	infringe	VB
18637	18650	96	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	18650	97	principles	principle	NNS
18637	18650	98	as	as	IN
18637	18650	99	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18650	100	have	have	VBP
18637	18650	101	been	be	VBN
18637	18650	102	understood	understand	VBN
18637	18650	103	by	by	IN
18637	18650	104	the	the	DT
18637	18650	105	traditions	tradition	NNS
18637	18650	106	of	of	IN
18637	18650	107	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18650	108	people	people	NNS
18637	18650	109	and	and	CC
18637	18650	110	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18650	111	law	law	NN
18637	18650	112	.	.	.
18637	18651	1	"	"	``
18637	18651	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18651	3	89	89	CD
18637	18651	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18651	5	In	in	IN
18637	18651	6	part	part	NN
18637	18651	7	,	,	,
18637	18651	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18651	9	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	18651	10	's	's	POS
18637	18651	11	criticism	criticism	NN
18637	18651	12	of	of	IN
18637	18651	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18651	14	colleagues	colleague	NNS
18637	18651	15	was	be	VBD
18637	18651	16	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	18651	17	,	,	,
18637	18651	18	for	for	IN
18637	18651	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18651	20	"	"	``
18637	18651	21	rational	rational	JJ
18637	18651	22	and	and	CC
18637	18651	23	fair	fair	JJ
18637	18651	24	man	man	NN
18637	18651	25	"	"	''
18637	18651	26	could	could	MD
18637	18651	27	not	not	RB
18637	18651	28	function	function	VB
18637	18651	29	in	in	IN
18637	18651	30	a	a	DT
18637	18651	31	vacuum	vacuum	NN
18637	18651	32	,	,	,
18637	18651	33	and	and	CC
18637	18651	34	,	,	,
18637	18651	35	in	in	IN
18637	18651	36	appraising	appraise	VBG
18637	18651	37	the	the	DT
18637	18651	38	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	18651	39	of	of	IN
18637	18651	40	State	State	NNP
18637	18651	41	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18651	42	,	,	,
18637	18651	43	could	could	MD
18637	18651	44	no	no	DT
18637	18651	45	more	more	RBR
18637	18651	46	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	18651	47	being	be	VBG
18637	18651	48	guided	guide	VBN
18637	18651	49	by	by	IN
18637	18651	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18651	51	preferences	preference	NNS
18637	18651	52	or	or	CC
18637	18651	53	"	"	``
18637	18651	54	economic	economic	JJ
18637	18651	55	predilections	predilection	NNS
18637	18651	56	"	"	''
18637	18651	57	than	than	IN
18637	18651	58	were	be	VBD
18637	18651	59	the	the	DT
18637	18651	60	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	18651	61	constituting	constitute	VBG
18637	18651	62	the	the	DT
18637	18651	63	majority	majority	NN
18637	18651	64	.	.	.
18637	18652	1	Insofar	insofar	RB
18637	18652	2	as	as	IN
18637	18652	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18652	4	was	be	VBD
18637	18652	5	resigned	resign	VBN
18637	18652	6	to	to	TO
18637	18652	7	accept	accept	VB
18637	18652	8	the	the	DT
18637	18652	9	broader	broad	JJR
18637	18652	10	conception	conception	NN
18637	18652	11	of	of	IN
18637	18652	12	due	due	JJ
18637	18652	13	process	process	NN
18637	18652	14	of	of	IN
18637	18652	15	law	law	NN
18637	18652	16	in	in	IN
18637	18652	17	preference	preference	NN
18637	18652	18	to	to	IN
18637	18652	19	the	the	DT
18637	18652	20	historical	historical	JJ
18637	18652	21	concept	concept	NN
18637	18652	22	thereof	thereof	IN
18637	18652	23	as	as	IN
18637	18652	24	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	18652	25	to	to	IN
18637	18652	26	the	the	DT
18637	18652	27	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18652	28	rather	rather	RB
18637	18652	29	than	than	IN
18637	18652	30	the	the	DT
18637	18652	31	making	making	NN
18637	18652	32	of	of	IN
18637	18652	33	law	law	NN
18637	18652	34	and	and	CC
18637	18652	35	did	do	VBD
18637	18652	36	not	not	RB
18637	18652	37	affirmatively	affirmatively	RB
18637	18652	38	advocate	advocate	VB
18637	18652	39	a	a	DT
18637	18652	40	return	return	NN
18637	18652	41	to	to	IN
18637	18652	42	the	the	DT
18637	18652	43	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	18652	44	that	that	IN
18637	18652	45	the	the	DT
18637	18652	46	possibility	possibility	NN
18637	18652	47	of	of	IN
18637	18652	48	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	18652	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	18652	50	no	no	DT
18637	18652	51	argument	argument	NN
18637	18652	52	against	against	IN
18637	18652	53	possession	possession	NN
18637	18652	54	of	of	IN
18637	18652	55	a	a	DT
18637	18652	56	power	power	NN
18637	18652	57	,	,	,
18637	18652	58	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18652	59	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	18652	60	,	,	,
18637	18652	61	whether	whether	IN
18637	18652	62	consciously	consciously	RB
18637	18652	63	or	or	CC
18637	18652	64	not	not	RB
18637	18652	65	,	,	,
18637	18652	66	was	be	VBD
18637	18652	67	thus	thus	RB
18637	18652	68	prepared	prepare	VBN
18637	18652	69	to	to	TO
18637	18652	70	observe	observe	VB
18637	18652	71	,	,	,
18637	18652	72	along	along	IN
18637	18652	73	with	with	IN
18637	18652	74	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18652	75	opponents	opponent	NNS
18637	18652	76	in	in	IN
18637	18652	77	the	the	DT
18637	18652	78	majority	majority	NN
18637	18652	79	,	,	,
18637	18652	80	the	the	DT
18637	18652	81	very	very	JJ
18637	18652	82	practices	practice	NNS
18637	18652	83	which	which	WDT
18637	18652	84	were	be	VBD
18637	18652	85	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	18652	86	to	to	TO
18637	18652	87	have	have	VB
18637	18652	88	rendered	render	VBN
18637	18652	89	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
18637	18652	90	the	the	DT
18637	18652	91	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	18652	92	by	by	IN
18637	18652	93	the	the	DT
18637	18652	94	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18652	95	of	of	IN
18637	18652	96	a	a	DT
18637	18652	97	"	"	``
18637	18652	98	perpetual	perpetual	JJ
18637	18652	99	censorship	censorship	NN
18637	18652	100	"	"	''
18637	18652	101	over	over	IN
18637	18652	102	State	State	NNP
18637	18652	103	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18652	104	.	.	.
18637	18653	1	The	the	DT
18637	18653	2	basic	basic	JJ
18637	18653	3	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	18653	4	,	,	,
18637	18653	5	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	18653	6	,	,	,
18637	18653	7	between	between	IN
18637	18653	8	the	the	DT
18637	18653	9	positions	position	NNS
18637	18653	10	taken	take	VBN
18637	18653	11	by	by	IN
18637	18653	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18653	13	Peckham	Peckham	NNP
18637	18653	14	for	for	IN
18637	18653	15	the	the	DT
18637	18653	16	majority	majority	NN
18637	18653	17	and	and	CC
18637	18653	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18653	19	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	18653	20	,	,	,
18637	18653	21	for	for	IN
18637	18653	22	what	what	WP
18637	18653	23	was	be	VBD
18637	18653	24	then	then	RB
18637	18653	25	the	the	DT
18637	18653	26	minority	minority	NN
18637	18653	27	,	,	,
18637	18653	28	was	be	VBD
18637	18653	29	the	the	DT
18637	18653	30	espousal	espousal	NN
18637	18653	31	of	of	IN
18637	18653	32	the	the	DT
18637	18653	33	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	18653	34	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	18653	35	of	of	IN
18637	18653	36	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18653	37	notice	notice	NN
18637	18653	38	by	by	IN
18637	18653	39	the	the	DT
18637	18653	40	former	former	JJ
18637	18653	41	and	and	CC
18637	18653	42	of	of	IN
18637	18653	43	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	18653	44	validity	validity	NN
18637	18653	45	by	by	IN
18637	18653	46	the	the	DT
18637	18653	47	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18653	48	.	.	.
18637	18654	1	Although	although	IN
18637	18654	2	the	the	DT
18637	18654	3	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	18654	4	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	18654	5	bore	bear	VBD
18637	18654	6	fruit	fruit	NN
18637	18654	7	in	in	IN
18637	18654	8	time	time	NN
18637	18654	9	in	in	IN
18637	18654	10	the	the	DT
18637	18654	11	form	form	NN
18637	18654	12	of	of	IN
18637	18654	13	the	the	DT
18637	18654	14	Bunting	Bunting	NNP
18637	18654	15	_	_	NNP
18637	18654	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	18654	17	_	_	NNP
18637	18654	18	Oregon[90	Oregon[90	NNP
18637	18654	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18654	20	and	and	CC
18637	18654	21	Muller	Muller	NNP
18637	18654	22	_	_	NNP
18637	18654	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	18654	24	_	_	NNP
18637	18654	25	Oregon[91	Oregon[91	NNP
18637	18654	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18654	27	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	18654	28	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	18654	29	the	the	DT
18637	18654	30	Lochner	Lochner	NNP
18637	18654	31	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18654	32	,	,	,
18637	18654	33	the	the	DT
18637	18654	34	doctrinal	doctrinal	JJ
18637	18654	35	approach	approach	NN
18637	18654	36	employed	employ	VBN
18637	18654	37	in	in	IN
18637	18654	38	the	the	DT
18637	18654	39	earlier	early	JJR
18637	18654	40	of	of	IN
18637	18654	41	these	these	DT
18637	18654	42	by	by	IN
18637	18654	43	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18654	44	Brewer	Brewer	NNP
18637	18654	45	continued	continue	VBD
18637	18654	46	to	to	TO
18637	18654	47	prevail	prevail	VB
18637	18654	48	until	until	IN
18637	18654	49	the	the	DT
18637	18654	50	depression	depression	NN
18637	18654	51	in	in	IN
18637	18654	52	the	the	DT
18637	18654	53	1930	1930	CD
18637	18654	54	's	's	POS
18637	18654	55	.	.	.
18637	18655	1	In	in	IN
18637	18655	2	view	view	NN
18637	18655	3	of	of	IN
18637	18655	4	the	the	DT
18637	18655	5	shift	shift	NN
18637	18655	6	in	in	IN
18637	18655	7	the	the	DT
18637	18655	8	burden	burden	NN
18637	18655	9	of	of	IN
18637	18655	10	proof	proof	NN
18637	18655	11	which	which	WDT
18637	18655	12	application	application	NN
18637	18655	13	of	of	IN
18637	18655	14	the	the	DT
18637	18655	15	principle	principle	NN
18637	18655	16	of	of	IN
18637	18655	17	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18655	18	notice	notice	NN
18637	18655	19	entailed	entail	VBD
18637	18655	20	,	,	,
18637	18655	21	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	18655	22	defending	defend	VBG
18637	18655	23	the	the	DT
18637	18655	24	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	18655	25	of	of	IN
18637	18655	26	social	social	JJ
18637	18655	27	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18655	28	developed	develop	VBD
18637	18655	29	the	the	DT
18637	18655	30	practice	practice	NN
18637	18655	31	of	of	IN
18637	18655	32	submitting	submit	VBG
18637	18655	33	voluminous	voluminous	JJ
18637	18655	34	factual	factual	JJ
18637	18655	35	briefs	brief	NNS
18637	18655	36	replete	replete	JJ
18637	18655	37	with	with	IN
18637	18655	38	medical	medical	JJ
18637	18655	39	or	or	CC
18637	18655	40	other	other	JJ
18637	18655	41	scientific	scientific	JJ
18637	18655	42	data	datum	NNS
18637	18655	43	intended	intend	VBN
18637	18655	44	to	to	TO
18637	18655	45	establish	establish	VB
18637	18655	46	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	18655	47	question	question	NN
18637	18655	48	a	a	DT
18637	18655	49	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	18655	50	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	18655	51	between	between	IN
18637	18655	52	the	the	DT
18637	18655	53	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	18655	54	statute	statute	NN
18637	18655	55	and	and	CC
18637	18655	56	public	public	JJ
18637	18655	57	health	health	NN
18637	18655	58	,	,	,
18637	18655	59	safety	safety	NN
18637	18655	60	,	,	,
18637	18655	61	or	or	CC
18637	18655	62	morals	moral	NNS
18637	18655	63	.	.	.
18637	18656	1	Whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	18656	2	the	the	DT
18637	18656	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18656	4	was	be	VBD
18637	18656	5	disposed	dispose	VBN
18637	18656	6	to	to	TO
18637	18656	7	uphold	uphold	VB
18637	18656	8	measures	measure	NNS
18637	18656	9	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	18656	10	to	to	IN
18637	18656	11	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	18656	12	relations	relation	NNS
18637	18656	13	,	,	,
18637	18656	14	such	such	JJ
18637	18656	15	as	as	IN
18637	18656	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	18656	17	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	18656	18	hours[92	hours[92	LS
18637	18656	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18656	20	of	of	IN
18637	18656	21	work	work	NN
18637	18656	22	,	,	,
18637	18656	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18656	24	generally	generally	RB
18637	18656	25	intimated	intimate	VBD
18637	18656	26	that	that	IN
18637	18656	27	the	the	DT
18637	18656	28	facts	fact	NNS
18637	18656	29	thus	thus	RB
18637	18656	30	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	18656	31	by	by	IN
18637	18656	32	way	way	NN
18637	18656	33	of	of	IN
18637	18656	34	justification	justification	NN
18637	18656	35	had	have	VBD
18637	18656	36	been	be	VBN
18637	18656	37	authenticated	authenticate	VBN
18637	18656	38	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	18656	39	for	for	IN
18637	18656	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18656	41	to	to	TO
18637	18656	42	take	take	VB
18637	18656	43	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18656	44	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	18656	45	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18656	46	;	;	:
18637	18656	47	but	but	CC
18637	18656	48	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	18656	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18656	50	chose	choose	VBD
18637	18656	51	to	to	TO
18637	18656	52	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	18656	53	comparable	comparable	JJ
18637	18656	54	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18656	55	,	,	,
18637	18656	56	such	such	JJ
18637	18656	57	as	as	IN
18637	18656	58	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	18656	59	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	18656	60	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	18656	61	wages	wage	NNS
18637	18656	62	for	for	IN
18637	18656	63	women	woman	NNS
18637	18656	64	and	and	CC
18637	18656	65	children,[93	children,[93	NNP
18637	18656	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18656	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18656	68	brushed	brush	VBD
18637	18656	69	aside	aside	RB
18637	18656	70	such	such	JJ
18637	18656	71	supporting	support	VBG
18637	18656	72	data	datum	NNS
18637	18656	73	,	,	,
18637	18656	74	proclaimed	proclaim	VBD
18637	18656	75	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18656	76	inability	inability	NN
18637	18656	77	to	to	TO
18637	18656	78	perceive	perceive	VB
18637	18656	79	any	any	DT
18637	18656	80	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18656	81	connection	connection	NN
18637	18656	82	between	between	IN
18637	18656	83	the	the	DT
18637	18656	84	statute	statute	NN
18637	18656	85	and	and	CC
18637	18656	86	the	the	DT
18637	18656	87	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	18656	88	objectives	objective	NNS
18637	18656	89	of	of	IN
18637	18656	90	health	health	NN
18637	18656	91	or	or	CC
18637	18656	92	safety	safety	NN
18637	18656	93	,	,	,
18637	18656	94	and	and	CC
18637	18656	95	condemned	condemn	VBD
18637	18656	96	the	the	DT
18637	18656	97	former	former	JJ
18637	18656	98	as	as	IN
18637	18656	99	an	an	DT
18637	18656	100	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18656	101	interference	interference	NN
18637	18656	102	with	with	IN
18637	18656	103	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18656	104	of	of	IN
18637	18656	105	contract	contract	NN
18637	18656	106	.	.	.
18637	18657	1	During	during	IN
18637	18657	2	the	the	DT
18637	18657	3	great	great	JJ
18637	18657	4	Depression	depression	NN
18637	18657	5	,	,	,
18637	18657	6	however	however	RB
18637	18657	7	,	,	,
18637	18657	8	the	the	DT
18637	18657	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18657	10	laissez	laissez	NN
18637	18657	11	faire	faire	NN
18637	18657	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18657	13	tenet	tenet	NN
18637	18657	14	of	of	IN
18637	18657	15	self	self	NN
18637	18657	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	18657	17	help	help	NN
18637	18657	18	was	be	VBD
18637	18657	19	supplanted	supplant	VBN
18637	18657	20	by	by	IN
18637	18657	21	the	the	DT
18637	18657	22	belief	belief	NN
18637	18657	23	that	that	IN
18637	18657	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18657	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	18657	26	peculiarly	peculiarly	RB
18637	18657	27	the	the	DT
18637	18657	28	duty	duty	NN
18637	18657	29	of	of	IN
18637	18657	30	government	government	NN
18637	18657	31	to	to	TO
18637	18657	32	help	help	VB
18637	18657	33	those	those	DT
18637	18657	34	who	who	WP
18637	18657	35	are	be	VBP
18637	18657	36	unable	unable	JJ
18637	18657	37	to	to	TO
18637	18657	38	help	help	VB
18637	18657	39	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18657	40	;	;	:
18637	18657	41	and	and	CC
18637	18657	42	to	to	TO
18637	18657	43	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	18657	44	remedial	remedial	JJ
18637	18657	45	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18657	46	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	18657	47	in	in	IN
18637	18657	48	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	18657	49	with	with	IN
18637	18657	50	the	the	DT
18637	18657	51	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18657	52	philosophy	philosophy	NN
18637	18657	53	,	,	,
18637	18657	54	the	the	DT
18637	18657	55	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18657	56	had	have	VBD
18637	18657	57	to	to	TO
18637	18657	58	revise	revise	VB
18637	18657	59	extensively	extensively	RB
18637	18657	60	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18657	61	previously	previously	RB
18637	18657	62	formulated	formulate	VBN
18637	18657	63	concepts	concept	NNS
18637	18657	64	of	of	IN
18637	18657	65	"	"	``
18637	18657	66	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18657	67	"	"	''
18637	18657	68	under	under	IN
18637	18657	69	the	the	DT
18637	18657	70	due	due	JJ
18637	18657	71	process	process	NN
18637	18657	72	clause	clause	NN
18637	18657	73	.	.	.
18637	18658	1	Not	not	RB
18637	18658	2	only	only	RB
18637	18658	3	did	do	VBD
18637	18658	4	the	the	DT
18637	18658	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18658	6	take	take	VB
18637	18658	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18658	8	notice	notice	NN
18637	18658	9	of	of	IN
18637	18658	10	the	the	DT
18637	18658	11	demands	demand	NNS
18637	18658	12	for	for	IN
18637	18658	13	relief	relief	NN
18637	18658	14	arising	arise	VBG
18637	18658	15	from	from	IN
18637	18658	16	the	the	DT
18637	18658	17	depression	depression	NN
18637	18658	18	when	when	WRB
18637	18658	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18658	20	overturned	overturn	VBD
18637	18658	21	prior	prior	JJ
18637	18658	22	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	18658	23	and	and	CC
18637	18658	24	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	18658	25	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	18658	26	wage	wage	NN
18637	18658	27	legislation,[94	legislation,[94	CD
18637	18658	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18658	29	but	but	CC
18637	18658	30	in	in	IN
18637	18658	31	upholding	uphold	VBG
18637	18658	32	State	State	NNP
18637	18658	33	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18658	34	designed	design	VBN
18637	18658	35	to	to	TO
18637	18658	36	protect	protect	VB
18637	18658	37	workers	worker	NNS
18637	18658	38	in	in	IN
18637	18658	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18658	40	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	18658	41	to	to	TO
18637	18658	42	organize	organize	VB
18637	18658	43	and	and	CC
18637	18658	44	bargain	bargain	NN
18637	18658	45	collectively	collectively	RB
18637	18658	46	,	,	,
18637	18658	47	the	the	DT
18637	18658	48	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18658	49	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	18658	50	had	have	VBD
18637	18658	51	to	to	TO
18637	18658	52	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	18658	53	from	from	IN
18637	18658	54	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	18658	55	the	the	DT
18637	18658	56	employer	employer	NN
18637	18658	57	's	's	POS
18637	18658	58	contention	contention	NN
18637	18658	59	that	that	IN
18637	18658	60	such	such	JJ
18637	18658	61	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18658	62	interfered	interfere	VBD
18637	18658	63	with	with	IN
18637	18658	64	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18658	65	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18658	66	of	of	IN
18637	18658	67	contract	contract	NN
18637	18658	68	in	in	IN
18637	18658	69	contravention	contravention	NN
18637	18658	70	of	of	IN
18637	18658	71	the	the	DT
18637	18658	72	due	due	JJ
18637	18658	73	process	process	NN
18637	18658	74	clause	clause	NN
18637	18658	75	and	and	CC
18637	18658	76	to	to	TO
18637	18658	77	exalt	exalt	VB
18637	18658	78	as	as	IN
18637	18658	79	a	a	DT
18637	18658	80	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	18658	81	right	right	NN
18637	18658	82	the	the	DT
18637	18658	83	correlative	correlative	JJ
18637	18658	84	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18658	85	of	of	IN
18637	18658	86	employees	employee	NNS
18637	18658	87	,	,	,
18637	18658	88	which	which	WDT
18637	18658	89	right	right	VBD
18637	18658	90	the	the	DT
18637	18658	91	State	state	NN
18637	18658	92	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	18658	93	were	be	VBD
18637	18658	94	declared	declare	VBN
18637	18658	95	to	to	TO
18637	18658	96	be	be	VB
18637	18658	97	competent	competent	JJ
18637	18658	98	to	to	TO
18637	18658	99	protect	protect	VB
18637	18658	100	against	against	IN
18637	18658	101	interference	interference	NN
18637	18658	102	from	from	IN
18637	18658	103	private	private	JJ
18637	18658	104	sources	source	NNS
18637	18658	105	.	.	.
18637	18659	1	To	to	TO
18637	18659	2	enable	enable	VB
18637	18659	3	these	these	DT
18637	18659	4	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	18659	5	to	to	TO
18637	18659	6	balance	balance	VB
18637	18659	7	the	the	DT
18637	18659	8	equities	equity	NNS
18637	18659	9	,	,	,
18637	18659	10	that	that	RB
18637	18659	11	is	is	RB
18637	18659	12	,	,	,
18637	18659	13	to	to	TO
18637	18659	14	achieve	achieve	VB
18637	18659	15	equality	equality	NN
18637	18659	16	in	in	IN
18637	18659	17	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	18659	18	power	power	NN
18637	18659	19	between	between	IN
18637	18659	20	employer	employer	NN
18637	18659	21	and	and	CC
18637	18659	22	employees	employee	NNS
18637	18659	23	,	,	,
18637	18659	24	the	the	DT
18637	18659	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18659	26	thus	thus	RB
18637	18659	27	sanctioned	sanction	VBD
18637	18659	28	a	a	DT
18637	18659	29	diminution	diminution	NN
18637	18659	30	of	of	IN
18637	18659	31	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18659	32	in	in	IN
18637	18659	33	the	the	DT
18637	18659	34	sense	sense	NN
18637	18659	35	of	of	IN
18637	18659	36	the	the	DT
18637	18659	37	employer	employer	NN
18637	18659	38	's	's	POS
18637	18659	39	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18659	40	of	of	IN
18637	18659	41	contract	contract	NN
18637	18659	42	and	and	CC
18637	18659	43	a	a	DT
18637	18659	44	corresponding	corresponding	JJ
18637	18659	45	increase	increase	NN
18637	18659	46	in	in	IN
18637	18659	47	the	the	DT
18637	18659	48	measure	measure	NN
18637	18659	49	of	of	IN
18637	18659	50	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18659	51	enjoyable	enjoyable	JJ
18637	18659	52	by	by	IN
18637	18659	53	the	the	DT
18637	18659	54	workers	worker	NNS
18637	18659	55	.	.	.
18637	18660	1	To	to	IN
18637	18660	2	the	the	DT
18637	18660	3	extent	extent	NN
18637	18660	4	that	that	IN
18637	18660	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18660	6	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBD
18637	18660	7	that	that	IN
18637	18660	8	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18660	9	of	of	IN
18637	18660	10	the	the	DT
18637	18660	11	individual	individual	NN
18637	18660	12	may	may	MD
18637	18660	13	be	be	VB
18637	18660	14	infringed	infringe	VBN
18637	18660	15	by	by	IN
18637	18660	16	the	the	DT
18637	18660	17	coercive	coercive	JJ
18637	18660	18	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	18660	19	of	of	IN
18637	18660	20	other	other	JJ
18637	18660	21	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	18660	22	no	no	RB
18637	18660	23	less	less	JJR
18637	18660	24	than	than	IN
18637	18660	25	by	by	IN
18637	18660	26	the	the	DT
18637	18660	27	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18660	28	action	action	NN
18637	18660	29	of	of	IN
18637	18660	30	public	public	JJ
18637	18660	31	officials	official	NNS
18637	18660	32	,	,	,
18637	18660	33	the	the	DT
18637	18660	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18660	35	in	in	IN
18637	18660	36	effect	effect	NN
18637	18660	37	transformed	transform	VBD
18637	18660	38	the	the	DT
18637	18660	39	due	due	JJ
18637	18660	40	process	process	NN
18637	18660	41	clause	clause	NN
18637	18660	42	into	into	IN
18637	18660	43	a	a	DT
18637	18660	44	source	source	NN
18637	18660	45	of	of	IN
18637	18660	46	encouragement	encouragement	NN
18637	18660	47	to	to	IN
18637	18660	48	State	State	NNP
18637	18660	49	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	18660	50	to	to	TO
18637	18660	51	intervene	intervene	VB
18637	18660	52	affirmatively	affirmatively	RB
18637	18660	53	by	by	IN
18637	18660	54	way	way	NN
18637	18660	55	of	of	IN
18637	18660	56	mitigating	mitigate	VBG
18637	18660	57	the	the	DT
18637	18660	58	effects	effect	NNS
18637	18660	59	of	of	IN
18637	18660	60	such	such	JJ
18637	18660	61	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	18660	62	.	.	.
18637	18661	1	By	by	IN
18637	18661	2	such	such	JJ
18637	18661	3	modification	modification	NN
18637	18661	4	of	of	IN
18637	18661	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18661	6	views	view	NNS
18637	18661	7	,	,	,
18637	18661	8	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18661	9	,	,	,
18637	18661	10	in	in	IN
18637	18661	11	the	the	DT
18637	18661	12	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18661	13	sense	sense	NN
18637	18661	14	of	of	IN
18637	18661	15	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18661	16	resulting	result	VBG
18637	18661	17	from	from	IN
18637	18661	18	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18661	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	18661	20	government	government	NN
18637	18661	21	,	,	,
18637	18661	22	was	be	VBD
18637	18661	23	replaced	replace	VBN
18637	18661	24	by	by	IN
18637	18661	25	the	the	DT
18637	18661	26	civil	civil	JJ
18637	18661	27	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18661	28	which	which	WDT
18637	18661	29	an	an	DT
18637	18661	30	individual	individual	JJ
18637	18661	31	enjoys	enjoy	VBZ
18637	18661	32	by	by	IN
18637	18661	33	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	18661	34	of	of	IN
18637	18661	35	the	the	DT
18637	18661	36	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	18661	37	which	which	WDT
18637	18661	38	government	government	NN
18637	18661	39	,	,	,
18637	18661	40	in	in	IN
18637	18661	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18661	42	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	18661	43	,	,	,
18637	18661	44	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	18661	45	upon	upon	IN
18637	18661	46	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18661	47	neighbors	neighbor	NNS
18637	18661	48	.	.	.
18637	18662	1	DEFINITIONS	DEFINITIONS	NNP
18637	18662	2	"	"	``
18637	18662	3	Persons	person	NNS
18637	18662	4	"	"	''
18637	18662	5	Defined	define	VBN
18637	18662	6	Notwithstanding	Notwithstanding	NNP
18637	18662	7	the	the	DT
18637	18662	8	historical	historical	JJ
18637	18662	9	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	18662	10	that	that	WDT
18637	18662	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	18662	12	been	be	VBN
18637	18662	13	waged	wage	VBN
18637	18662	14	as	as	IN
18637	18662	15	to	to	IN
18637	18662	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	18662	17	the	the	DT
18637	18662	18	framers	framer	NNS
18637	18662	19	of	of	IN
18637	18662	20	the	the	DT
18637	18662	21	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18662	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18662	23	intended	intend	VBD
18637	18662	24	the	the	DT
18637	18662	25	word	word	NN
18637	18662	26	,	,	,
18637	18662	27	"	"	''
18637	18662	28	person	person	NN
18637	18662	29	,	,	,
18637	18662	30	"	"	''
18637	18662	31	to	to	TO
18637	18662	32	mean	mean	VB
18637	18662	33	only	only	JJ
18637	18662	34	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18662	35	persons	person	NNS
18637	18662	36	,	,	,
18637	18662	37	or	or	CC
18637	18662	38	whether	whether	IN
18637	18662	39	the	the	DT
18637	18662	40	word	word	NN
18637	18662	41	,	,	,
18637	18662	42	"	"	''
18637	18662	43	person	person	NN
18637	18662	44	,	,	,
18637	18662	45	"	"	''
18637	18662	46	was	be	VBD
18637	18662	47	substituted	substitute	VBN
18637	18662	48	for	for	IN
18637	18662	49	the	the	DT
18637	18662	50	word	word	NN
18637	18662	51	,	,	,
18637	18662	52	"	"	``
18637	18662	53	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18662	54	,	,	,
18637	18662	55	"	"	''
18637	18662	56	with	with	IN
18637	18662	57	a	a	DT
18637	18662	58	view	view	NN
18637	18662	59	to	to	IN
18637	18662	60	protecting	protect	VBG
18637	18662	61	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18662	62	from	from	IN
18637	18662	63	oppressive	oppressive	JJ
18637	18662	64	state	state	NN
18637	18662	65	legislation,[95	legislation,[95	CD
18637	18662	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18662	67	the	the	DT
18637	18662	68	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	18662	69	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18662	70	,	,	,
18637	18662	71	as	as	RB
18637	18662	72	early	early	RB
18637	18662	73	as	as	IN
18637	18662	74	the	the	DT
18637	18662	75	Granger	Granger	NNP
18637	18662	76	cases,[96	cases,[96	NNP
18637	18662	77	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18662	78	decided	decide	VBN
18637	18662	79	in	in	IN
18637	18662	80	1877	1877	CD
18637	18662	81	,	,	,
18637	18662	82	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	18662	83	on	on	IN
18637	18662	84	the	the	DT
18637	18662	85	merits	merit	NNS
18637	18662	86	various	various	JJ
18637	18662	87	state	state	NN
18637	18662	88	laws	law	NNS
18637	18662	89	without	without	IN
18637	18662	90	raising	raise	VBG
18637	18662	91	any	any	DT
18637	18662	92	question	question	NN
18637	18662	93	as	as	IN
18637	18662	94	to	to	IN
18637	18662	95	the	the	DT
18637	18662	96	status	status	NN
18637	18662	97	of	of	IN
18637	18662	98	railway	railway	NN
18637	18662	99	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18662	100	-	-	HYPH
18637	18662	101	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
18637	18662	102	to	to	TO
18637	18662	103	advance	advance	VB
18637	18662	104	due	due	JJ
18637	18662	105	process	process	NN
18637	18662	106	contentions	contention	NNS
18637	18662	107	.	.	.
18637	18663	1	There	there	EX
18637	18663	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	18663	3	no	no	DT
18637	18663	4	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	18663	5	that	that	IN
18637	18663	6	a	a	DT
18637	18663	7	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18663	8	may	may	MD
18637	18663	9	not	not	RB
18637	18663	10	be	be	VB
18637	18663	11	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	18663	12	of	of	IN
18637	18663	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18663	14	property	property	NN
18637	18663	15	without	without	IN
18637	18663	16	due	due	JJ
18637	18663	17	process	process	NN
18637	18663	18	of	of	IN
18637	18663	19	law;[97	law;[97	NNP
18637	18663	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18663	21	and	and	CC
18637	18663	22	although	although	IN
18637	18663	23	prior	prior	JJ
18637	18663	24	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	18663	25	have	have	VBP
18637	18663	26	held	hold	VBN
18637	18663	27	that	that	IN
18637	18663	28	the	the	DT
18637	18663	29	"	"	``
18637	18663	30	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18663	31	"	"	''
18637	18663	32	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	18663	33	by	by	IN
18637	18663	34	the	the	DT
18637	18663	35	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18663	36	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18663	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	18663	38	the	the	DT
18637	18663	39	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18663	40	of	of	IN
18637	18663	41	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18663	42	,	,	,
18637	18663	43	not	not	RB
18637	18663	44	artificial	artificial	JJ
18637	18663	45	,	,	,
18637	18663	46	persons,[98	persons,[98	LS
18637	18663	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18663	48	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	18663	49	a	a	DT
18637	18663	50	newspaper	newspaper	NN
18637	18663	51	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18663	52	was	be	VBD
18637	18663	53	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18663	54	,	,	,
18637	18663	55	in	in	IN
18637	18663	56	1936	1936	CD
18637	18663	57	,	,	,
18637	18663	58	in	in	IN
18637	18663	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18663	60	objection	objection	NN
18637	18663	61	that	that	IN
18637	18663	62	a	a	DT
18637	18663	63	state	state	NN
18637	18663	64	law	law	NN
18637	18663	65	deprived	deprive	VBD
18637	18663	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18663	67	of	of	IN
18637	18663	68	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18663	69	of	of	IN
18637	18663	70	press	press	NN
18637	18663	71	.	.	.
18637	18664	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18664	2	99	99	CD
18637	18664	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18664	4	As	as	IN
18637	18664	5	to	to	IN
18637	18664	6	the	the	DT
18637	18664	7	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18664	8	persons	person	NNS
18637	18664	9	protected	protect	VBN
18637	18664	10	by	by	IN
18637	18664	11	the	the	DT
18637	18664	12	due	due	JJ
18637	18664	13	process	process	NN
18637	18664	14	clause	clause	NN
18637	18664	15	,	,	,
18637	18664	16	these	these	DT
18637	18664	17	include	include	VBP
18637	18664	18	all	all	DT
18637	18664	19	human	human	JJ
18637	18664	20	beings	being	NNS
18637	18664	21	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	18664	22	of	of	IN
18637	18664	23	race	race	NN
18637	18664	24	,	,	,
18637	18664	25	color	color	NN
18637	18664	26	,	,	,
18637	18664	27	or	or	CC
18637	18664	28	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	18664	29	.	.	.
18637	18665	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18665	2	100	100	CD
18637	18665	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18665	4	Ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	18665	5	,	,	,
18637	18665	6	the	the	DT
18637	18665	7	mere	mere	JJ
18637	18665	8	interest	interest	NN
18637	18665	9	of	of	IN
18637	18665	10	an	an	DT
18637	18665	11	official	official	NN
18637	18665	12	as	as	IN
18637	18665	13	such	such	JJ
18637	18665	14	,	,	,
18637	18665	15	in	in	IN
18637	18665	16	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	18665	17	to	to	IN
18637	18665	18	an	an	DT
18637	18665	19	actual	actual	JJ
18637	18665	20	injury	injury	NN
18637	18665	21	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18665	22	by	by	IN
18637	18665	23	a	a	DT
18637	18665	24	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18665	25	or	or	CC
18637	18665	26	artificial	artificial	JJ
18637	18665	27	person	person	NN
18637	18665	28	through	through	IN
18637	18665	29	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	18665	30	of	of	IN
18637	18665	31	personal	personal	JJ
18637	18665	32	or	or	CC
18637	18665	33	property	property	NN
18637	18665	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	18665	35	,	,	,
18637	18665	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	18665	37	not	not	RB
18637	18665	38	been	be	VBN
18637	18665	39	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	18665	40	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	18665	41	to	to	TO
18637	18665	42	enable	enable	VB
18637	18665	43	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18665	44	to	to	TO
18637	18665	45	invoke	invoke	VB
18637	18665	46	the	the	DT
18637	18665	47	protection	protection	NN
18637	18665	48	of	of	IN
18637	18665	49	the	the	DT
18637	18665	50	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18665	51	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18665	52	against	against	IN
18637	18665	53	State	State	NNP
18637	18665	54	action	action	NN
18637	18665	55	.	.	.
18637	18666	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18666	2	101	101	CD
18637	18666	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18666	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18666	5	,	,	,
18637	18666	6	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	18666	7	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18666	8	are	be	VBP
18637	18666	9	viewed	view	VBN
18637	18666	10	as	as	IN
18637	18666	11	having	have	VBG
18637	18666	12	no	no	DT
18637	18666	13	standing	standing	NN
18637	18666	14	"	"	''
18637	18666	15	to	to	TO
18637	18666	16	invoke	invoke	VB
18637	18666	17	the	the	DT
18637	18666	18	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	18666	19	of	of	IN
18637	18666	20	the	the	DT
18637	18666	21	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18666	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18666	23	in	in	IN
18637	18666	24	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	18666	25	to	to	IN
18637	18666	26	the	the	DT
18637	18666	27	will	will	NN
18637	18666	28	of	of	IN
18637	18666	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18666	30	creator	creator	NN
18637	18666	31	,	,	,
18637	18666	32	"	"	''
18637	18666	33	the	the	DT
18637	18666	34	State	State	NNP
18637	18666	35	.	.	.
18637	18667	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18667	2	102	102	CD
18637	18667	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18667	4	However	however	RB
18637	18667	5	,	,	,
18637	18667	6	State	state	NN
18637	18667	7	officers	officer	NNS
18637	18667	8	are	be	VBP
18637	18667	9	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	18667	10	to	to	TO
18637	18667	11	have	have	VB
18637	18667	12	an	an	DT
18637	18667	13	interest	interest	NN
18637	18667	14	,	,	,
18637	18667	15	despite	despite	IN
18637	18667	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18667	17	not	not	RB
18637	18667	18	having	have	VBG
18637	18667	19	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18667	20	any	any	DT
18637	18667	21	"	"	``
18637	18667	22	private	private	JJ
18637	18667	23	damage	damage	NN
18637	18667	24	,	,	,
18637	18667	25	"	"	''
18637	18667	26	in	in	IN
18637	18667	27	resisting	resist	VBG
18637	18667	28	an	an	DT
18637	18667	29	"	"	``
18637	18667	30	endeavor	endeavor	NN
18637	18667	31	to	to	TO
18637	18667	32	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18667	33	the	the	DT
18637	18667	34	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18667	35	of	of	IN
18637	18667	36	laws	law	NNS
18637	18667	37	in	in	IN
18637	18667	38	relation	relation	NN
18637	18667	39	to	to	IN
18637	18667	40	which	which	WDT
18637	18667	41	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18667	42	have	have	VBP
18637	18667	43	official	official	JJ
18637	18667	44	duties	duty	NNS
18637	18667	45	,	,	,
18637	18667	46	"	"	''
18637	18667	47	and	and	CC
18637	18667	48	,	,	,
18637	18667	49	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	18667	50	,	,	,
18637	18667	51	may	may	MD
18637	18667	52	apply	apply	VB
18637	18667	53	to	to	IN
18637	18667	54	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18667	55	courts	court	NNS
18637	18667	56	for	for	IN
18637	18667	57	the	the	DT
18637	18667	58	"	"	``
18637	18667	59	review	review	NN
18637	18667	60	of	of	IN
18637	18667	61	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	18667	62	of	of	IN
18637	18667	63	State	State	NNP
18637	18667	64	courts	court	NNS
18637	18667	65	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	18667	66	State	state	NN
18637	18667	67	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18667	68	which	which	WDT
18637	18667	69	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18667	70	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18667	71	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18667	72	seek	seek	VBP
18637	18667	73	to	to	TO
18637	18667	74	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	18667	75	to	to	TO
18637	18667	76	be	be	VB
18637	18667	77	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	18667	78	to	to	IN
18637	18667	79	the	the	DT
18637	18667	80	"	"	``
18637	18667	81	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18667	82	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18667	83	.	.	.
18637	18668	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18668	2	103	103	CD
18637	18668	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18668	4	Due	Due	NNP
18637	18668	5	Process	Process	NNP
18637	18668	6	and	and	CC
18637	18668	7	the	the	DT
18637	18668	8	Police	Police	NNP
18637	18668	9	Power	Power	NNP
18637	18668	10	Definition.--The	Definition.--The	NNP
18637	18668	11	police	police	NN
18637	18668	12	power	power	NN
18637	18668	13	of	of	IN
18637	18668	14	a	a	DT
18637	18668	15	State	State	NNP
18637	18668	16	today	today	NN
18637	18668	17	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	18668	18	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18668	19	designed	design	VBN
18637	18668	20	to	to	TO
18637	18668	21	promote	promote	VB
18637	18668	22	the	the	DT
18637	18668	23	public	public	JJ
18637	18668	24	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	18668	25	or	or	CC
18637	18668	26	the	the	DT
18637	18668	27	general	general	JJ
18637	18668	28	prosperity	prosperity	NN
18637	18668	29	as	as	RB
18637	18668	30	well	well	RB
18637	18668	31	as	as	IN
18637	18668	32	those	those	DT
18637	18668	33	to	to	TO
18637	18668	34	promote	promote	VB
18637	18668	35	public	public	JJ
18637	18668	36	safety	safety	NN
18637	18668	37	,	,	,
18637	18668	38	health	health	NN
18637	18668	39	,	,	,
18637	18668	40	morals	moral	NNS
18637	18668	41	,	,	,
18637	18668	42	and	and	CC
18637	18668	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	18668	44	not	not	RB
18637	18668	45	confined	confine	VBN
18637	18668	46	to	to	IN
18637	18668	47	the	the	DT
18637	18668	48	suppression	suppression	NN
18637	18668	49	of	of	IN
18637	18668	50	what	what	WP
18637	18668	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	18668	52	offensive	offensive	JJ
18637	18668	53	,	,	,
18637	18668	54	disorderly	disorderly	JJ
18637	18668	55	,	,	,
18637	18668	56	or	or	CC
18637	18668	57	unsanitary	unsanitary	JJ
18637	18668	58	,	,	,
18637	18668	59	but	but	CC
18637	18668	60	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	18668	61	to	to	IN
18637	18668	62	what	what	WP
18637	18668	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	18668	64	for	for	IN
18637	18668	65	the	the	DT
18637	18668	66	greatest	great	JJS
18637	18668	67	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	18668	68	of	of	IN
18637	18668	69	the	the	DT
18637	18668	70	State	State	NNP
18637	18668	71	.	.	.
18637	18669	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18669	2	104	104	CD
18637	18669	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18669	4	Limitations	Limitations	NNP
18637	18669	5	on	on	IN
18637	18669	6	the	the	DT
18637	18669	7	Police	Police	NNS
18637	18669	8	Power.--Because	power.--because	VB
18637	18669	9	the	the	DT
18637	18669	10	police	police	NN
18637	18669	11	power	power	NN
18637	18669	12	of	of	IN
18637	18669	13	a	a	DT
18637	18669	14	State	State	NNP
18637	18669	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	18669	16	the	the	DT
18637	18669	17	least	least	JJS
18637	18669	18	limitable	limitable	JJ
18637	18669	19	of	of	IN
18637	18669	20	the	the	DT
18637	18669	21	exercises	exercise	NNS
18637	18669	22	of	of	IN
18637	18669	23	government	government	NN
18637	18669	24	,	,	,
18637	18669	25	such	such	JJ
18637	18669	26	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	18669	27	as	as	IN
18637	18669	28	are	be	VBP
18637	18669	29	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	18669	30	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	18669	31	are	be	VBP
18637	18669	32	not	not	RB
18637	18669	33	readily	readily	RB
18637	18669	34	definable	definable	JJ
18637	18669	35	.	.	.
18637	18670	1	Being	be	VBG
18637	18670	2	neither	neither	CC
18637	18670	3	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
18637	18670	4	of	of	IN
18637	18670	5	circumstantial	circumstantial	JJ
18637	18670	6	precision	precision	NN
18637	18670	7	,	,	,
18637	18670	8	nor	nor	CC
18637	18670	9	discoverable	discoverable	JJ
18637	18670	10	by	by	IN
18637	18670	11	any	any	DT
18637	18670	12	formula	formula	NN
18637	18670	13	,	,	,
18637	18670	14	these	these	DT
18637	18670	15	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	18670	16	can	can	MD
18637	18670	17	be	be	VB
18637	18670	18	determined	determine	VBN
18637	18670	19	only	only	RB
18637	18670	20	through	through	IN
18637	18670	21	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	18670	22	regard	regard	NN
18637	18670	23	to	to	IN
18637	18670	24	the	the	DT
18637	18670	25	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18670	26	matter	matter	NN
18637	18670	27	of	of	IN
18637	18670	28	the	the	DT
18637	18670	29	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18670	30	of	of	IN
18637	18670	31	that	that	DT
18637	18670	32	power	power	NN
18637	18670	33	.	.	.
18637	18671	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18671	2	105	105	CD
18637	18671	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18671	4	"	"	``
18637	18671	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18671	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	18671	7	settled	settle	VBN
18637	18671	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18671	9	however	however	RB
18637	18671	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18671	11	that	that	IN
18637	18671	12	neither	neither	CC
18637	18671	13	the	the	DT
18637	18671	14	'	'	``
18637	18671	15	contract	contract	NN
18637	18671	16	'	'	''
18637	18671	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	18671	18	nor	nor	CC
18637	18671	19	the	the	DT
18637	18671	20	'	'	``
18637	18671	21	due	due	JJ
18637	18671	22	process	process	NN
18637	18671	23	'	'	''
18637	18671	24	clause	clause	NN
18637	18671	25	had	have	VBD
18637	18671	26	the	the	DT
18637	18671	27	effect	effect	NN
18637	18671	28	of	of	IN
18637	18671	29	overriding	override	VBG
18637	18671	30	the	the	DT
18637	18671	31	power	power	NN
18637	18671	32	of	of	IN
18637	18671	33	the	the	DT
18637	18671	34	State	State	NNP
18637	18671	35	to	to	TO
18637	18671	36	establish	establish	VB
18637	18671	37	all	all	DT
18637	18671	38	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18671	39	that	that	WDT
18637	18671	40	are	be	VBP
18637	18671	41	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	18671	42	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18671	43	to	to	TO
18637	18671	44	secure	secure	VB
18637	18671	45	the	the	DT
18637	18671	46	health	health	NN
18637	18671	47	,	,	,
18637	18671	48	safety	safety	NN
18637	18671	49	,	,	,
18637	18671	50	good	good	JJ
18637	18671	51	order	order	NN
18637	18671	52	,	,	,
18637	18671	53	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	18671	54	,	,	,
18637	18671	55	or	or	CC
18637	18671	56	general	general	JJ
18637	18671	57	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	18671	58	of	of	IN
18637	18671	59	the	the	DT
18637	18671	60	community	community	NN
18637	18671	61	;	;	:
18637	18671	62	that	that	IN
18637	18671	63	this	this	DT
18637	18671	64	power	power	NN
18637	18671	65	can	can	MD
18637	18671	66	neither	neither	CC
18637	18671	67	be	be	VB
18637	18671	68	abdicated	abdicate	VBN
18637	18671	69	nor	nor	CC
18637	18671	70	bargained	bargain	VBN
18637	18671	71	away	away	RP
18637	18671	72	,	,	,
18637	18671	73	and	and	CC
18637	18671	74	is	be	VBZ
18637	18671	75	inalienable	inalienable	JJ
18637	18671	76	even	even	RB
18637	18671	77	by	by	IN
18637	18671	78	express	express	NNP
18637	18671	79	grant	grant	NN
18637	18671	80	;	;	:
18637	18671	81	and	and	CC
18637	18671	82	that	that	IN
18637	18671	83	all	all	DT
18637	18671	84	contract	contract	NN
18637	18671	85	and	and	CC
18637	18671	86	property	property	NN
18637	18671	87	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18671	88	or	or	CC
18637	18671	89	other	other	JJ
18637	18671	90	vested	vested	JJ
18637	18671	91	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18671	92	rights	right	NNS
18637	18671	93	are	be	VBP
18637	18671	94	held	hold	VBN
18637	18671	95	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18671	96	to	to	IN
18637	18671	97	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18671	98	fair	fair	JJ
18637	18671	99	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18671	100	.	.	.
18637	18672	1	"	"	``
18637	18672	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18672	3	106	106	CD
18637	18672	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18672	5	Insofar	insofar	RB
18637	18672	6	as	as	IN
18637	18672	7	the	the	DT
18637	18672	8	police	police	NN
18637	18672	9	power	power	NN
18637	18672	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	18672	11	utilized	utilize	VBN
18637	18672	12	by	by	IN
18637	18672	13	a	a	DT
18637	18672	14	State	State	NNP
18637	18672	15	,	,	,
18637	18672	16	the	the	DT
18637	18672	17	means	mean	NNS
18637	18672	18	employed	employ	VBN
18637	18672	19	to	to	TO
18637	18672	20	effect	effect	VB
18637	18672	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18672	22	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18672	23	can	can	MD
18637	18672	24	be	be	VB
18637	18672	25	neither	neither	CC
18637	18672	26	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18672	27	nor	nor	CC
18637	18672	28	oppressive	oppressive	JJ
18637	18672	29	,	,	,
18637	18672	30	but	but	CC
18637	18672	31	must	must	MD
18637	18672	32	bear	bear	VB
18637	18672	33	a	a	DT
18637	18672	34	real	real	JJ
18637	18672	35	and	and	CC
18637	18672	36	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	18672	37	relation	relation	NN
18637	18672	38	to	to	IN
18637	18672	39	an	an	DT
18637	18672	40	end	end	NN
18637	18672	41	which	which	WDT
18637	18672	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	18672	43	public	public	JJ
18637	18672	44	,	,	,
18637	18672	45	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	18672	46	,	,	,
18637	18672	47	the	the	DT
18637	18672	48	public	public	JJ
18637	18672	49	health	health	NN
18637	18672	50	,	,	,
18637	18672	51	public	public	JJ
18637	18672	52	safety	safety	NN
18637	18672	53	,	,	,
18637	18672	54	or	or	CC
18637	18672	55	public	public	JJ
18637	18672	56	morals	moral	NNS
18637	18672	57	,	,	,
18637	18672	58	or	or	CC
18637	18672	59	some	some	DT
18637	18672	60	other	other	JJ
18637	18672	61	phase	phase	NN
18637	18672	62	of	of	IN
18637	18672	63	the	the	DT
18637	18672	64	general	general	JJ
18637	18672	65	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	18672	66	.	.	.
18637	18673	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18673	2	107	107	CD
18637	18673	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18673	4	The	the	DT
18637	18673	5	general	general	JJ
18637	18673	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	18673	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	18673	8	that	that	IN
18637	18673	9	if	if	IN
18637	18673	10	a	a	DT
18637	18673	11	police	police	NN
18637	18673	12	power	power	NN
18637	18673	13	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18673	14	goes	go	VBZ
18637	18673	15	too	too	RB
18637	18673	16	far	far	RB
18637	18673	17	,	,	,
18637	18673	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18673	19	will	will	MD
18637	18673	20	be	be	VB
18637	18673	21	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	18673	22	as	as	IN
18637	18673	23	a	a	DT
18637	18673	24	taking	taking	NN
18637	18673	25	of	of	IN
18637	18673	26	property	property	NN
18637	18673	27	for	for	IN
18637	18673	28	which	which	WDT
18637	18673	29	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18673	30	must	must	MD
18637	18673	31	be	be	VB
18637	18673	32	paid	pay	VBN
18637	18673	33	.	.	.
18637	18674	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18674	2	108	108	CD
18637	18674	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18674	4	Yet	yet	CC
18637	18674	5	where	where	WRB
18637	18674	6	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	18674	7	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	18674	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	18674	9	a	a	DT
18637	18674	10	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	18674	11	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18674	12	,	,	,
18637	18674	13	an	an	DT
18637	18674	14	ulterior	ulterior	JJ
18637	18674	15	public	public	JJ
18637	18674	16	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	18674	17	may	may	MD
18637	18674	18	justify	justify	VB
18637	18674	19	a	a	DT
18637	18674	20	comparatively	comparatively	RB
18637	18674	21	insignificant	insignificant	JJ
18637	18674	22	taking	taking	NN
18637	18674	23	of	of	IN
18637	18674	24	private	private	JJ
18637	18674	25	property	property	NN
18637	18674	26	for	for	IN
18637	18674	27	what	what	WP
18637	18674	28	in	in	IN
18637	18674	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18674	30	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	18674	31	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18674	32	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	18674	33	to	to	TO
18637	18674	34	be	be	VB
18637	18674	35	a	a	DT
18637	18674	36	private	private	JJ
18637	18674	37	use	use	NN
18637	18674	38	.	.	.
18637	18675	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18675	2	109	109	CD
18637	18675	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18675	4	On	on	IN
18637	18675	5	the	the	DT
18637	18675	6	other	other	JJ
18637	18675	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	18675	8	,	,	,
18637	18675	9	mere	mere	JJ
18637	18675	10	"	"	``
18637	18675	11	cost	cost	NN
18637	18675	12	and	and	CC
18637	18675	13	inconvenience	inconvenience	NN
18637	18675	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18675	15	different	different	JJ
18637	18675	16	words	word	NNS
18637	18675	17	,	,	,
18637	18675	18	probably	probably	RB
18637	18675	19	,	,	,
18637	18675	20	for	for	IN
18637	18675	21	the	the	DT
18637	18675	22	same	same	JJ
18637	18675	23	thing	thing	NN
18637	18675	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18675	25	would	would	MD
18637	18675	26	have	have	VB
18637	18675	27	to	to	TO
18637	18675	28	be	be	VB
18637	18675	29	very	very	RB
18637	18675	30	great	great	JJ
18637	18675	31	before	before	IN
18637	18675	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18675	33	could	could	MD
18637	18675	34	become	become	VB
18637	18675	35	an	an	DT
18637	18675	36	element	element	NN
18637	18675	37	in	in	IN
18637	18675	38	the	the	DT
18637	18675	39	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	18675	40	of	of	IN
18637	18675	41	the	the	DT
18637	18675	42	right	right	NN
18637	18675	43	of	of	IN
18637	18675	44	a	a	DT
18637	18675	45	State	State	NNP
18637	18675	46	to	to	TO
18637	18675	47	exert	exert	VB
18637	18675	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18675	49	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	18675	50	power	power	NN
18637	18675	51	or	or	CC
18637	18675	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18675	53	police	police	NN
18637	18675	54	power	power	NN
18637	18675	55	.	.	.
18637	18676	1	"	"	``
18637	18676	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18676	3	110	110	CD
18637	18676	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18676	5	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	18676	6	,	,	,
18637	18676	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18676	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	18676	9	elementary	elementary	JJ
18637	18676	10	that	that	DT
18637	18676	11	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18676	12	of	of	IN
18637	18676	13	uncompensated	uncompensated	JJ
18637	18676	14	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	18676	15	to	to	IN
18637	18676	16	a	a	DT
18637	18676	17	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18676	18	passed	pass	VBN
18637	18676	19	in	in	IN
18637	18676	20	the	the	DT
18637	18676	21	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	18676	22	exertion	exertion	NN
18637	18676	23	of	of	IN
18637	18676	24	the	the	DT
18637	18676	25	police	police	NN
18637	18676	26	power	power	NN
18637	18676	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	18676	28	not	not	RB
18637	18676	29	a	a	DT
18637	18676	30	taking	taking	NN
18637	18676	31	without	without	IN
18637	18676	32	due	due	JJ
18637	18676	33	process	process	NN
18637	18676	34	of	of	IN
18637	18676	35	law	law	NN
18637	18676	36	.	.	.
18637	18677	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18677	2	111	111	CD
18637	18677	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18677	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18677	5	,	,	,
18637	18677	6	initial	initial	JJ
18637	18677	7	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	18677	8	with	with	IN
18637	18677	9	a	a	DT
18637	18677	10	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18677	11	which	which	WDT
18637	18677	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	18677	13	valid	valid	JJ
18637	18677	14	when	when	WRB
18637	18677	15	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	18677	16	occasions	occasion	NNS
18637	18677	17	no	no	DT
18637	18677	18	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	18677	19	of	of	IN
18637	18677	20	the	the	DT
18637	18677	21	right	right	NN
18637	18677	22	to	to	TO
18637	18677	23	protest	protest	VB
18637	18677	24	when	when	WRB
18637	18677	25	that	that	DT
18637	18677	26	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18677	27	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	18677	28	loses	lose	VBZ
18637	18677	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18677	30	validity	validity	NN
18637	18677	31	by	by	IN
18637	18677	32	becoming	become	VBG
18637	18677	33	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	18677	34	in	in	IN
18637	18677	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18677	36	operation	operation	NN
18637	18677	37	.	.	.
18637	18678	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18678	2	112	112	CD
18637	18678	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18678	4	"	"	``
18637	18678	5	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	18678	6	"	"	''
18637	18678	7	in	in	IN
18637	18678	8	General	General	NNP
18637	18678	9	Definition.--"While	Definition.--"While	NNP
18637	18678	10	*	*	NFP
18637	18678	11	*	*	NFP
18637	18678	12	*	*	NFP
18637	18678	13	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18678	14	the	the	DT
18637	18678	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18678	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18678	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	18678	18	not	not	RB
18637	18678	19	attempted	attempt	VBN
18637	18678	20	to	to	TO
18637	18678	21	define	define	VB
18637	18678	22	with	with	IN
18637	18678	23	exactness	exactness	NN
18637	18678	24	the	the	DT
18637	18678	25	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18678	26	thus	thus	RB
18637	18678	27	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	18678	28	,	,	,
18637	18678	29	the	the	DT
18637	18678	30	term	term	NN
18637	18678	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	18678	32	received	receive	VBN
18637	18678	33	much	much	JJ
18637	18678	34	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	18678	35	and	and	CC
18637	18678	36	some	some	DT
18637	18678	37	of	of	IN
18637	18678	38	the	the	DT
18637	18678	39	included	include	VBN
18637	18678	40	things	thing	NNS
18637	18678	41	have	have	VBP
18637	18678	42	been	be	VBN
18637	18678	43	definitely	definitely	RB
18637	18678	44	stated	state	VBN
18637	18678	45	.	.	.
18637	18679	1	Without	without	IN
18637	18679	2	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	18679	3	,	,	,
18637	18679	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18679	5	denotes	denote	VBZ
18637	18679	6	not	not	RB
18637	18679	7	merely	merely	RB
18637	18679	8	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18679	9	from	from	IN
18637	18679	10	bodily	bodily	JJ
18637	18679	11	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18679	12	but	but	CC
18637	18679	13	also	also	RB
18637	18679	14	right	right	RB
18637	18679	15	of	of	IN
18637	18679	16	the	the	DT
18637	18679	17	individual	individual	NN
18637	18679	18	to	to	TO
18637	18679	19	contract	contract	VB
18637	18679	20	,	,	,
18637	18679	21	to	to	TO
18637	18679	22	engage	engage	VB
18637	18679	23	in	in	IN
18637	18679	24	any	any	DT
18637	18679	25	of	of	IN
18637	18679	26	the	the	DT
18637	18679	27	common	common	JJ
18637	18679	28	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	18679	29	of	of	IN
18637	18679	30	life	life	NN
18637	18679	31	,	,	,
18637	18679	32	to	to	TO
18637	18679	33	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	18679	34	useful	useful	JJ
18637	18679	35	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	18679	36	,	,	,
18637	18679	37	to	to	TO
18637	18679	38	marry	marry	VB
18637	18679	39	,	,	,
18637	18679	40	establish	establish	VB
18637	18679	41	a	a	DT
18637	18679	42	home	home	NN
18637	18679	43	and	and	CC
18637	18679	44	bring	bring	VB
18637	18679	45	up	up	RP
18637	18679	46	children	child	NNS
18637	18679	47	,	,	,
18637	18679	48	to	to	TO
18637	18679	49	worship	worship	VB
18637	18679	50	God	God	NNP
18637	18679	51	according	accord	VBG
18637	18679	52	to	to	IN
18637	18679	53	the	the	DT
18637	18679	54	dictates	dictate	NNS
18637	18679	55	of	of	IN
18637	18679	56	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18679	57	own	own	JJ
18637	18679	58	conscience	conscience	NN
18637	18679	59	,	,	,
18637	18679	60	and	and	CC
18637	18679	61	generally	generally	RB
18637	18679	62	to	to	TO
18637	18679	63	enjoy	enjoy	VB
18637	18679	64	those	those	DT
18637	18679	65	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18679	66	long	long	RB
18637	18679	67	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	18679	68	at	at	IN
18637	18679	69	common	common	JJ
18637	18679	70	law	law	NN
18637	18679	71	as	as	IN
18637	18679	72	essential	essential	JJ
18637	18679	73	to	to	IN
18637	18679	74	the	the	DT
18637	18679	75	orderly	orderly	JJ
18637	18679	76	pursuit	pursuit	NN
18637	18679	77	of	of	IN
18637	18679	78	happiness	happiness	NN
18637	18679	79	by	by	IN
18637	18679	80	free	free	JJ
18637	18679	81	men	man	NNS
18637	18679	82	.	.	.
18637	18680	1	"	"	``
18637	18680	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18680	3	113	113	CD
18637	18680	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18680	5	Personal	Personal	NNP
18637	18680	6	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	18680	7	:	:	:
18637	18680	8	Compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	18680	9	Vaccination	Vaccination	NNP
18637	18680	10	:	:	:
18637	18680	11	Sexual	sexual	JJ
18637	18680	12	Sterilization.--Personal	sterilization.--personal	JJ
18637	18680	13	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18680	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	18680	15	not	not	RB
18637	18680	16	infringed	infringe	VBN
18637	18680	17	by	by	IN
18637	18680	18	a	a	DT
18637	18680	19	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	18680	20	vaccination	vaccination	NN
18637	18680	21	law[114	law[114	NN
18637	18680	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18680	23	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	18680	24	by	by	IN
18637	18680	25	a	a	DT
18637	18680	26	State	state	NN
18637	18680	27	or	or	CC
18637	18680	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18680	29	local	local	JJ
18637	18680	30	subdivisions	subdivision	NNS
18637	18680	31	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	18680	32	to	to	IN
18637	18680	33	the	the	DT
18637	18680	34	police	police	NN
18637	18680	35	power	power	NN
18637	18680	36	for	for	IN
18637	18680	37	the	the	DT
18637	18680	38	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18680	39	of	of	IN
18637	18680	40	protecting	protect	VBG
18637	18680	41	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	18680	42	against	against	IN
18637	18680	43	the	the	DT
18637	18680	44	spread	spread	NN
18637	18680	45	of	of	IN
18637	18680	46	smallpox	smallpox	NN
18637	18680	47	.	.	.
18637	18681	1	"	"	``
18637	18681	2	The	the	DT
18637	18681	3	principle	principle	NN
18637	18681	4	that	that	WDT
18637	18681	5	sustains	sustain	VBZ
18637	18681	6	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	18681	7	vaccination	vaccination	NN
18637	18681	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	18681	9	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18681	10	also	also	RB
18637	18681	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18681	12	broad	broad	RB
18637	18681	13	enough	enough	RB
18637	18681	14	to	to	TO
18637	18681	15	cover	cover	VB
18637	18681	16	"	"	``
18637	18681	17	a	a	DT
18637	18681	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	18681	19	providing	provide	VBG
18637	18681	20	for	for	IN
18637	18681	21	sexual	sexual	JJ
18637	18681	22	sterilization	sterilization	NN
18637	18681	23	of	of	IN
18637	18681	24	inmates	inmate	NNS
18637	18681	25	of	of	IN
18637	18681	26	State	State	NNP
18637	18681	27	supported	support	VBD
18637	18681	28	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	18681	29	who	who	WP
18637	18681	30	are	be	VBP
18637	18681	31	found	find	VBN
18637	18681	32	to	to	TO
18637	18681	33	be	be	VB
18637	18681	34	afflicted	afflict	VBN
18637	18681	35	with	with	IN
18637	18681	36	an	an	DT
18637	18681	37	hereditary	hereditary	JJ
18637	18681	38	form	form	NN
18637	18681	39	of	of	IN
18637	18681	40	insanity	insanity	NN
18637	18681	41	or	or	CC
18637	18681	42	imbecility	imbecility	NN
18637	18681	43	.	.	.
18637	18682	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18682	2	115	115	CD
18637	18682	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18682	4	Equally	equally	RB
18637	18682	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18682	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	18682	7	a	a	DT
18637	18682	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	18682	9	which	which	WDT
18637	18682	10	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	18682	11	for	for	IN
18637	18682	12	the	the	DT
18637	18682	13	commitment	commitment	NN
18637	18682	14	,	,	,
18637	18682	15	after	after	IN
18637	18682	16	probate	probate	NN
18637	18682	17	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18682	18	,	,	,
18637	18682	19	of	of	IN
18637	18682	20	a	a	DT
18637	18682	21	psychopathic	psychopathic	JJ
18637	18682	22	personality	personality	NN
18637	18682	23	,	,	,
18637	18682	24	defined	define	VBN
18637	18682	25	by	by	IN
18637	18682	26	the	the	DT
18637	18682	27	State	State	NNP
18637	18682	28	court	court	NN
18637	18682	29	as	as	IN
18637	18682	30	including	include	VBG
18637	18682	31	those	those	DT
18637	18682	32	persons	person	NNS
18637	18682	33	who	who	WP
18637	18682	34	,	,	,
18637	18682	35	by	by	IN
18637	18682	36	habitual	habitual	JJ
18637	18682	37	course	course	NN
18637	18682	38	of	of	IN
18637	18682	39	misconduct	misconduct	NN
18637	18682	40	in	in	IN
18637	18682	41	sexual	sexual	JJ
18637	18682	42	matters	matter	NNS
18637	18682	43	,	,	,
18637	18682	44	have	have	VBP
18637	18682	45	evidenced	evidence	VBN
18637	18682	46	utter	utter	JJ
18637	18682	47	lack	lack	NN
18637	18682	48	of	of	IN
18637	18682	49	power	power	NN
18637	18682	50	to	to	TO
18637	18682	51	control	control	VB
18637	18682	52	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18682	53	sexual	sexual	JJ
18637	18682	54	impulses	impulse	NNS
18637	18682	55	and	and	CC
18637	18682	56	are	be	VBP
18637	18682	57	likely	likely	JJ
18637	18682	58	to	to	TO
18637	18682	59	commit	commit	VB
18637	18682	60	injury	injury	NN
18637	18682	61	.	.	.
18637	18683	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18683	2	116	116	CD
18637	18683	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18683	4	However	however	RB
18637	18683	5	,	,	,
18637	18683	6	a	a	DT
18637	18683	7	person	person	NN
18637	18683	8	can	can	MD
18637	18683	9	not	not	RB
18637	18683	10	be	be	VB
18637	18683	11	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	18683	12	of	of	IN
18637	18683	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18683	14	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18683	15	under	under	IN
18637	18683	16	a	a	DT
18637	18683	17	vague	vague	JJ
18637	18683	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	18683	19	which	which	WDT
18637	18683	20	subjected	subject	VBD
18637	18683	21	to	to	IN
18637	18683	22	fine	fine	JJ
18637	18683	23	or	or	CC
18637	18683	24	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	18683	25	,	,	,
18637	18683	26	as	as	IN
18637	18683	27	a	a	DT
18637	18683	28	"	"	``
18637	18683	29	gangster	gangster	NN
18637	18683	30	,	,	,
18637	18683	31	"	"	''
18637	18683	32	any	any	DT
18637	18683	33	one	one	NN
18637	18683	34	not	not	RB
18637	18683	35	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	18683	36	in	in	IN
18637	18683	37	any	any	DT
18637	18683	38	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	18683	39	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	18683	40	,	,	,
18637	18683	41	known	know	VBN
18637	18683	42	to	to	TO
18637	18683	43	be	be	VB
18637	18683	44	a	a	DT
18637	18683	45	member	member	NN
18637	18683	46	of	of	IN
18637	18683	47	a	a	DT
18637	18683	48	gang	gang	NN
18637	18683	49	consisting	consist	VBG
18637	18683	50	of	of	IN
18637	18683	51	two	two	CD
18637	18683	52	or	or	CC
18637	18683	53	more	more	JJR
18637	18683	54	persons	person	NNS
18637	18683	55	,	,	,
18637	18683	56	and	and	CC
18637	18683	57	who	who	WP
18637	18683	58	had	have	VBD
18637	18683	59	been	be	VBN
18637	18683	60	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	18683	61	of	of	IN
18637	18683	62	a	a	DT
18637	18683	63	crime	crime	NN
18637	18683	64	in	in	IN
18637	18683	65	any	any	DT
18637	18683	66	State	State	NNP
18637	18683	67	in	in	IN
18637	18683	68	the	the	DT
18637	18683	69	Union	Union	NNP
18637	18683	70	.	.	.
18637	18684	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18684	2	117	117	CD
18637	18684	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18684	4	Liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	18684	5	Pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	18684	6	to	to	IN
18637	18684	7	Education	education	NN
18637	18684	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18684	9	of	of	IN
18637	18684	10	Teachers	Teachers	NNPS
18637	18684	11	,	,	,
18637	18684	12	Parents	Parents	NNPS
18637	18684	13	,	,	,
18637	18684	14	Pupils).--A	Pupils).--A	NNP
18637	18684	15	State	State	NNP
18637	18684	16	law	law	NN
18637	18684	17	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	18684	18	the	the	DT
18637	18684	19	teaching	teaching	NN
18637	18684	20	in	in	IN
18637	18684	21	any	any	DT
18637	18684	22	private	private	JJ
18637	18684	23	denominational	denominational	JJ
18637	18684	24	,	,	,
18637	18684	25	parochial	parochial	JJ
18637	18684	26	,	,	,
18637	18684	27	or	or	CC
18637	18684	28	public	public	JJ
18637	18684	29	school	school	NN
18637	18684	30	,	,	,
18637	18684	31	of	of	IN
18637	18684	32	any	any	DT
18637	18684	33	modern	modern	JJ
18637	18684	34	language	language	NN
18637	18684	35	,	,	,
18637	18684	36	other	other	JJ
18637	18684	37	than	than	IN
18637	18684	38	English	English	NNP
18637	18684	39	,	,	,
18637	18684	40	to	to	IN
18637	18684	41	any	any	DT
18637	18684	42	child	child	NN
18637	18684	43	who	who	WP
18637	18684	44	has	have	VBZ
18637	18684	45	not	not	RB
18637	18684	46	successfully	successfully	RB
18637	18684	47	passed	pass	VBN
18637	18684	48	the	the	DT
18637	18684	49	eighth	eighth	JJ
18637	18684	50	grade	grade	NN
18637	18684	51	was	be	VBD
18637	18684	52	declared	declare	VBN
18637	18684	53	,	,	,
18637	18684	54	in	in	IN
18637	18684	55	Meyer	Meyer	NNP
18637	18684	56	_	_	NNP
18637	18684	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	18684	58	_	_	NNP
18637	18684	59	Nebraska[118	Nebraska[118	NNP
18637	18684	60	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18684	61	to	to	TO
18637	18684	62	be	be	VB
18637	18684	63	an	an	DT
18637	18684	64	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18684	65	interference	interference	NN
18637	18684	66	with	with	IN
18637	18684	67	the	the	DT
18637	18684	68	right	right	NN
18637	18684	69	of	of	IN
18637	18684	70	a	a	DT
18637	18684	71	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18684	72	language	language	NN
18637	18684	73	teacher	teacher	NN
18637	18684	74	to	to	TO
18637	18684	75	teach	teach	VB
18637	18684	76	and	and	CC
18637	18684	77	"	"	``
18637	18684	78	of	of	IN
18637	18684	79	parents	parent	NNS
18637	18684	80	to	to	TO
18637	18684	81	engage	engage	VB
18637	18684	82	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18684	83	so	so	RB
18637	18684	84	to	to	TO
18637	18684	85	instruct	instruct	VB
18637	18684	86	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18684	87	children	child	NNS
18637	18684	88	.	.	.
18637	18684	89	"	"	''
18637	18685	1	Although	although	IN
18637	18685	2	the	the	DT
18637	18685	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18685	4	did	do	VBD
18637	18685	5	incorporate	incorporate	VB
18637	18685	6	into	into	IN
18637	18685	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18685	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	18685	9	in	in	IN
18637	18685	10	this	this	DT
18637	18685	11	case	case	NN
18637	18685	12	the	the	DT
18637	18685	13	general	general	JJ
18637	18685	14	definition	definition	NN
18637	18685	15	of	of	IN
18637	18685	16	"	"	``
18637	18685	17	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18685	18	"	"	''
18637	18685	19	set	set	VBN
18637	18685	20	forth	forth	RB
18637	18685	21	above	above	RB
18637	18685	22	,	,	,
18637	18685	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18685	24	holding	holding	NN
18637	18685	25	was	be	VBD
18637	18685	26	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	18685	27	a	a	DT
18637	18685	28	reaffirmation	reaffirmation	NN
18637	18685	29	of	of	IN
18637	18685	30	the	the	DT
18637	18685	31	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18685	32	,	,	,
18637	18685	33	in	in	IN
18637	18685	34	this	this	DT
18637	18685	35	instance	instance	NN
18637	18685	36	of	of	IN
18637	18685	37	the	the	DT
18637	18685	38	teacher	teacher	NN
18637	18685	39	,	,	,
18637	18685	40	to	to	TO
18637	18685	41	pursue	pursue	VB
18637	18685	42	a	a	DT
18637	18685	43	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	18685	44	calling	call	VBG
18637	18685	45	free	free	JJ
18637	18685	46	and	and	CC
18637	18685	47	clear	clear	JJ
18637	18685	48	of	of	IN
18637	18685	49	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18685	50	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	18685	51	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18685	52	by	by	IN
18637	18685	53	the	the	DT
18637	18685	54	State	State	NNP
18637	18685	55	.	.	.
18637	18686	1	In	in	IN
18637	18686	2	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	18686	3	_	_	NNP
18637	18686	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	18686	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18686	6	Society	Society	NNP
18637	18686	7	of	of	IN
18637	18686	8	the	the	DT
18637	18686	9	Sisters,[119	sisters,[119	NN
18637	18686	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18686	11	the	the	DT
18637	18686	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18686	13	elaborated	elaborate	VBD
18637	18686	14	further	further	RB
18637	18686	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	18686	16	the	the	DT
18637	18686	17	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18686	18	of	of	IN
18637	18686	19	parents	parent	NNS
18637	18686	20	when	when	WRB
18637	18686	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18686	22	declared	declare	VBD
18637	18686	23	that	that	IN
18637	18686	24	a	a	DT
18637	18686	25	State	State	NNP
18637	18686	26	law	law	NN
18637	18686	27	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18686	28	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	18686	29	public	public	JJ
18637	18686	30	school	school	NN
18637	18686	31	education	education	NN
18637	18686	32	of	of	IN
18637	18686	33	children	child	NNS
18637	18686	34	,	,	,
18637	18686	35	aged	age	VBN
18637	18686	36	eight	eight	CD
18637	18686	37	to	to	TO
18637	18686	38	sixteen	sixteen	CD
18637	18686	39	,	,	,
18637	18686	40	"	"	``
18637	18686	41	unreasonably	unreasonably	RB
18637	18686	42	interferes	interfere	VBZ
18637	18686	43	with	with	IN
18637	18686	44	the	the	DT
18637	18686	45	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18686	46	of	of	IN
18637	18686	47	parents	parent	NNS
18637	18686	48	and	and	CC
18637	18686	49	guardians	guardian	NNS
18637	18686	50	to	to	TO
18637	18686	51	direct	direct	VB
18637	18686	52	the	the	DT
18637	18686	53	upbringing	upbringing	NN
18637	18686	54	and	and	CC
18637	18686	55	education	education	NN
18637	18686	56	of	of	IN
18637	18686	57	children	child	NNS
18637	18686	58	under	under	IN
18637	18686	59	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18686	60	control	control	NN
18637	18686	61	.	.	.
18637	18687	1	"	"	``
18637	18687	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18687	3	120	120	CD
18637	18687	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18687	5	As	as	IN
18637	18687	6	to	to	IN
18637	18687	7	a	a	DT
18637	18687	8	student	student	NN
18637	18687	9	,	,	,
18637	18687	10	neither	neither	CC
18637	18687	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18687	12	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18687	13	to	to	TO
18637	18687	14	pursue	pursue	VB
18637	18687	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18687	16	happiness	happiness	NN
18637	18687	17	nor	nor	CC
18637	18687	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18687	19	property	property	NN
18637	18687	20	or	or	CC
18637	18687	21	property	property	NN
18637	18687	22	rights	right	NNS
18637	18687	23	were	be	VBD
18637	18687	24	infringed	infringe	VBN
18637	18687	25	when	when	WRB
18637	18687	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18687	27	was	be	VBD
18637	18687	28	denied	deny	VBN
18637	18687	29	admission	admission	NN
18637	18687	30	to	to	IN
18637	18687	31	a	a	DT
18637	18687	32	State	State	NNP
18637	18687	33	university	university	NN
18637	18687	34	for	for	IN
18637	18687	35	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	18687	36	to	to	TO
18637	18687	37	comply	comply	VB
18637	18687	38	with	with	IN
18637	18687	39	a	a	DT
18637	18687	40	law	law	NN
18637	18687	41	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18687	42	renunciation	renunciation	NN
18637	18687	43	of	of	IN
18637	18687	44	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	18687	45	to	to	IN
18637	18687	46	,	,	,
18637	18687	47	or	or	CC
18637	18687	48	affiliation	affiliation	NN
18637	18687	49	with	with	IN
18637	18687	50	,	,	,
18637	18687	51	a	a	DT
18637	18687	52	Greek	greek	JJ
18637	18687	53	letter	letter	NN
18637	18687	54	fraternity	fraternity	NN
18637	18687	55	.	.	.
18637	18688	1	The	the	DT
18637	18688	2	right	right	NN
18637	18688	3	to	to	TO
18637	18688	4	attend	attend	VB
18637	18688	5	such	such	PDT
18637	18688	6	an	an	DT
18637	18688	7	institution	institution	NN
18637	18688	8	was	be	VBD
18637	18688	9	labelled	label	VBN
18637	18688	10	,	,	,
18637	18688	11	not	not	RB
18637	18688	12	an	an	DT
18637	18688	13	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	18688	14	,	,	,
18637	18688	15	but	but	CC
18637	18688	16	a	a	DT
18637	18688	17	conditional	conditional	JJ
18637	18688	18	right	right	NN
18637	18688	19	;	;	:
18637	18688	20	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	18688	21	as	as	IN
18637	18688	22	the	the	DT
18637	18688	23	school	school	NN
18637	18688	24	was	be	VBD
18637	18688	25	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	18688	26	under	under	IN
18637	18688	27	the	the	DT
18637	18688	28	control	control	NN
18637	18688	29	of	of	IN
18637	18688	30	the	the	DT
18637	18688	31	State	State	NNP
18637	18688	32	,	,	,
18637	18688	33	the	the	DT
18637	18688	34	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18688	35	was	be	VBD
18637	18688	36	competent	competent	JJ
18637	18688	37	to	to	TO
18637	18688	38	enact	enact	VB
18637	18688	39	measures	measure	NNS
18637	18688	40	such	such	JJ
18637	18688	41	as	as	IN
18637	18688	42	the	the	DT
18637	18688	43	present	present	JJ
18637	18688	44	one	one	CD
18637	18688	45	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	18688	46	internal	internal	JJ
18637	18688	47	discipline	discipline	NN
18637	18688	48	thereat	thereat	VB
18637	18688	49	.	.	.
18637	18689	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18689	2	121	121	CD
18637	18689	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18689	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18689	5	,	,	,
18637	18689	6	"	"	''
18637	18689	7	the	the	DT
18637	18689	8	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18689	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18689	10	as	as	IN
18637	18689	11	a	a	DT
18637	18689	12	safeguard	safeguard	NN
18637	18689	13	of	of	IN
18637	18689	14	'	'	``
18637	18689	15	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18689	16	'	'	''
18637	18689	17	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18689	18	does	do	VBZ
18637	18689	19	not	not	RB
18637	18689	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18689	21	confer	confer	VB
18637	18689	22	the	the	DT
18637	18689	23	right	right	NN
18637	18689	24	to	to	TO
18637	18689	25	be	be	VB
18637	18689	26	students	student	NNS
18637	18689	27	in	in	IN
18637	18689	28	the	the	DT
18637	18689	29	State	State	NNP
18637	18689	30	university	university	NN
18637	18689	31	free	free	JJ
18637	18689	32	from	from	IN
18637	18689	33	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	18689	34	to	to	TO
18637	18689	35	take	take	VB
18637	18689	36	military	military	JJ
18637	18689	37	training	training	NN
18637	18689	38	as	as	IN
18637	18689	39	one	one	CD
18637	18689	40	of	of	IN
18637	18689	41	the	the	DT
18637	18689	42	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	18689	43	of	of	IN
18637	18689	44	attendance	attendance	NN
18637	18689	45	.	.	.
18637	18690	1	"	"	``
18637	18690	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18690	3	122	122	CD
18637	18690	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18690	5	Liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	18690	6	Safeguarded	safeguard	VBN
18637	18690	7	by	by	IN
18637	18690	8	the	the	DT
18637	18690	9	First	First	NNP
18637	18690	10	Eight	eight	CD
18637	18690	11	Amendments.--In	Amendments.--In	NNP
18637	18690	12	what	what	WP
18637	18690	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	18690	14	amounted	amount	VBN
18637	18690	15	to	to	IN
18637	18690	16	a	a	DT
18637	18690	17	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18690	18	revolution	revolution	NN
18637	18690	19	,	,	,
18637	18690	20	the	the	DT
18637	18690	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18690	22	,	,	,
18637	18690	23	since	since	IN
18637	18690	24	the	the	DT
18637	18690	25	end	end	NN
18637	18690	26	of	of	IN
18637	18690	27	World	World	NNP
18637	18690	28	War	War	NNP
18637	18690	29	I	I	NNP
18637	18690	30	,	,	,
18637	18690	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	18690	32	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	18690	33	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
18637	18690	34	the	the	DT
18637	18690	35	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	18690	36	of	of	IN
18637	18690	37	the	the	DT
18637	18690	38	term	term	NN
18637	18690	39	,	,	,
18637	18690	40	"	"	``
18637	18690	41	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18690	42	,	,	,
18637	18690	43	"	"	''
18637	18690	44	appearing	appear	VBG
18637	18690	45	in	in	IN
18637	18690	46	the	the	DT
18637	18690	47	due	due	JJ
18637	18690	48	process	process	NN
18637	18690	49	clause	clause	NN
18637	18690	50	of	of	IN
18637	18690	51	the	the	DT
18637	18690	52	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18690	53	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18690	54	.	.	.
18637	18691	1	As	as	IN
18637	18691	2	a	a	DT
18637	18691	3	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	18691	4	of	of	IN
18637	18691	5	this	this	DT
18637	18691	6	altered	altered	JJ
18637	18691	7	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	18691	8	,	,	,
18637	18691	9	States	States	NNP
18637	18691	10	and	and	CC
18637	18691	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18691	12	local	local	JJ
18637	18691	13	subdivisions	subdivision	NNS
18637	18691	14	have	have	VBP
18637	18691	15	been	be	VBN
18637	18691	16	restrained	restrain	VBN
18637	18691	17	in	in	IN
18637	18691	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18691	19	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	18691	20	to	to	TO
18637	18691	21	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	18691	22	with	with	IN
18637	18691	23	the	the	DT
18637	18691	24	press	press	NN
18637	18691	25	,	,	,
18637	18691	26	or	or	CC
18637	18691	27	with	with	IN
18637	18691	28	the	the	DT
18637	18691	29	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18691	30	of	of	IN
18637	18691	31	speech	speech	NN
18637	18691	32	,	,	,
18637	18691	33	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	18691	34	,	,	,
18637	18691	35	or	or	CC
18637	18691	36	religious	religious	JJ
18637	18691	37	precepts	precept	NNS
18637	18691	38	of	of	IN
18637	18691	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18691	40	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	18691	41	,	,	,
18637	18691	42	and	and	CC
18637	18691	43	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	18691	44	from	from	IN
18637	18691	45	withholding	withholding	NN
18637	18691	46	from	from	IN
18637	18691	47	persons	person	NNS
18637	18691	48	charged	charge	VBN
18637	18691	49	with	with	IN
18637	18691	50	commission	commission	NN
18637	18691	51	of	of	IN
18637	18691	52	a	a	DT
18637	18691	53	crime	crime	NN
18637	18691	54	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18691	55	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18691	56	deemed	deem	VBD
18637	18691	57	essential	essential	JJ
18637	18691	58	to	to	IN
18637	18691	59	the	the	DT
18637	18691	60	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	18691	61	of	of	IN
18637	18691	62	a	a	DT
18637	18691	63	"	"	``
18637	18691	64	fair	fair	JJ
18637	18691	65	trial	trial	NN
18637	18691	66	.	.	.
18637	18691	67	"	"	''
18637	18692	1	Cases	case	NNS
18637	18692	2	revealing	reveal	VBG
18637	18692	3	to	to	IN
18637	18692	4	what	what	WDT
18637	18692	5	extent	extent	NN
18637	18692	6	there	there	EX
18637	18692	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	18692	8	been	be	VBN
18637	18692	9	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	18692	10	into	into	IN
18637	18692	11	the	the	DT
18637	18692	12	"	"	``
18637	18692	13	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18692	14	"	"	''
18637	18692	15	of	of	IN
18637	18692	16	the	the	DT
18637	18692	17	due	due	JJ
18637	18692	18	process	process	NN
18637	18692	19	clause	clause	NN
18637	18692	20	of	of	IN
18637	18692	21	the	the	DT
18637	18692	22	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18692	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18692	24	the	the	DT
18637	18692	25	substance	substance	NN
18637	18692	26	of	of	IN
18637	18692	27	the	the	DT
18637	18692	28	First	First	NNP
18637	18692	29	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18692	30	are	be	VBP
18637	18692	31	set	set	VBN
18637	18692	32	forth	forth	RP
18637	18692	33	in	in	IN
18637	18692	34	the	the	DT
18637	18692	35	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	18692	36	presented	present	VBN
18637	18692	37	under	under	IN
18637	18692	38	the	the	DT
18637	18692	39	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18692	40	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18692	41	;	;	:
18637	18692	42	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	18692	43	the	the	DT
18637	18692	44	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	18692	45	indicating	indicate	VBG
18637	18692	46	the	the	DT
18637	18692	47	scope	scope	NN
18637	18692	48	of	of	IN
18637	18692	49	the	the	DT
18637	18692	50	absorption	absorption	NN
18637	18692	51	into	into	IN
18637	18692	52	the	the	DT
18637	18692	53	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18692	54	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18692	55	of	of	IN
18637	18692	56	the	the	DT
18637	18692	57	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	18692	58	protection	protection	NN
18637	18692	59	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	18692	60	by	by	IN
18637	18692	61	the	the	DT
18637	18692	62	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	18692	63	,	,	,
18637	18692	64	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	18692	65	,	,	,
18637	18692	66	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	18692	67	,	,	,
18637	18692	68	and	and	CC
18637	18692	69	Eighth	Eighth	NNP
18637	18692	70	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	18692	71	are	be	VBP
18637	18692	72	included	include	VBN
18637	18692	73	in	in	IN
18637	18692	74	the	the	DT
18637	18692	75	material	material	NN
18637	18692	76	hereinafter	hereinafter	NN
18637	18692	77	presented	present	VBN
18637	18692	78	under	under	IN
18637	18692	79	the	the	DT
18637	18692	80	subtitle	subtitle	NN
18637	18692	81	,	,	,
18637	18692	82	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
18637	18692	83	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNPS
18637	18692	84	.	.	.
18637	18693	1	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	18693	2	of	of	IN
18637	18693	3	Contract	Contract	NNP
18637	18693	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18693	5	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	18693	6	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	18693	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18693	8	In	in	IN
18637	18693	9	General.--Liberty	general.--liberty	NN
18637	18693	10	of	of	IN
18637	18693	11	contract	contract	NN
18637	18693	12	,	,	,
18637	18693	13	a	a	DT
18637	18693	14	concept	concept	NN
18637	18693	15	originally	originally	RB
18637	18693	16	advanced	advance	VBN
18637	18693	17	by	by	IN
18637	18693	18	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	18693	19	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	18693	20	and	and	CC
18637	18693	21	Field	Field	NNP
18637	18693	22	in	in	IN
18637	18693	23	the	the	DT
18637	18693	24	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	18693	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	18693	26	House	House	NNP
18637	18693	27	Cases,[123	Cases,[123	NNP
18637	18693	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18693	29	was	be	VBD
18637	18693	30	elevated	elevate	VBN
18637	18693	31	to	to	IN
18637	18693	32	the	the	DT
18637	18693	33	status	status	NN
18637	18693	34	of	of	IN
18637	18693	35	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	18693	36	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	18693	37	in	in	IN
18637	18693	38	1897	1897	CD
18637	18693	39	in	in	IN
18637	18693	40	Allgeyer	Allgeyer	NNP
18637	18693	41	_	_	NNP
18637	18693	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	18693	43	_	_	NNP
18637	18693	44	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	18693	45	.	.	.
18637	18694	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18694	2	124	124	CD
18637	18694	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18694	4	Applied	Applied	NNP
18637	18694	5	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	18694	6	in	in	IN
18637	18694	7	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	18694	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	18694	9	as	as	IN
18637	18694	10	a	a	DT
18637	18694	11	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18694	12	on	on	IN
18637	18694	13	State	State	NNP
18637	18694	14	power	power	NN
18637	18694	15	,	,	,
18637	18694	16	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18694	17	of	of	IN
18637	18694	18	contract	contract	NN
18637	18694	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	18694	20	also	also	RB
18637	18694	21	been	be	VBN
18637	18694	22	alluded	allude	VBN
18637	18694	23	to	to	IN
18637	18694	24	as	as	IN
18637	18694	25	a	a	DT
18637	18694	26	property	property	NN
18637	18694	27	right	right	NN
18637	18694	28	,	,	,
18637	18694	29	as	as	IN
18637	18694	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	18694	31	evident	evident	JJ
18637	18694	32	in	in	IN
18637	18694	33	the	the	DT
18637	18694	34	language	language	NN
18637	18694	35	of	of	IN
18637	18694	36	the	the	DT
18637	18694	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18694	38	in	in	IN
18637	18694	39	Coppage	Coppage	NNP
18637	18694	40	_	_	NNP
18637	18694	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	18694	42	_	_	NNP
18637	18694	43	Kansas:[125	Kansas:[125	NNP
18637	18694	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18694	45	"	"	``
18637	18694	46	Included	include	VBN
18637	18694	47	in	in	IN
18637	18694	48	the	the	DT
18637	18694	49	right	right	NN
18637	18694	50	of	of	IN
18637	18694	51	personal	personal	JJ
18637	18694	52	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18694	53	and	and	CC
18637	18694	54	the	the	DT
18637	18694	55	right	right	NN
18637	18694	56	of	of	IN
18637	18694	57	private	private	JJ
18637	18694	58	property	property	NN
18637	18694	59	--	--	:
18637	18694	60	partaking	partaking	NN
18637	18694	61	of	of	IN
18637	18694	62	the	the	DT
18637	18694	63	nature	nature	NN
18637	18694	64	of	of	IN
18637	18694	65	each	each	DT
18637	18694	66	--	--	:
18637	18694	67	is	be	VBZ
18637	18694	68	the	the	DT
18637	18694	69	right	right	NN
18637	18694	70	to	to	TO
18637	18694	71	make	make	VB
18637	18694	72	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	18694	73	for	for	IN
18637	18694	74	the	the	DT
18637	18694	75	acquisition	acquisition	NN
18637	18694	76	of	of	IN
18637	18694	77	property	property	NN
18637	18694	78	.	.	.
18637	18695	1	Chief	chief	NN
18637	18695	2	among	among	IN
18637	18695	3	such	such	JJ
18637	18695	4	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	18695	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	18695	6	that	that	DT
18637	18695	7	of	of	IN
18637	18695	8	personal	personal	JJ
18637	18695	9	employment	employment	NN
18637	18695	10	,	,	,
18637	18695	11	by	by	IN
18637	18695	12	which	which	WDT
18637	18695	13	labor	labor	NN
18637	18695	14	and	and	CC
18637	18695	15	other	other	JJ
18637	18695	16	services	service	NNS
18637	18695	17	are	be	VBP
18637	18695	18	exchanged	exchange	VBN
18637	18695	19	for	for	IN
18637	18695	20	money	money	NN
18637	18695	21	or	or	CC
18637	18695	22	other	other	JJ
18637	18695	23	forms	form	NNS
18637	18695	24	of	of	IN
18637	18695	25	property	property	NN
18637	18695	26	.	.	.
18637	18696	1	If	if	IN
18637	18696	2	this	this	DT
18637	18696	3	right	right	NN
18637	18696	4	be	be	VB
18637	18696	5	struck	strike	VBN
18637	18696	6	down	down	RP
18637	18696	7	or	or	CC
18637	18696	8	arbitrarily	arbitrarily	RB
18637	18696	9	interfered	interfere	VBN
18637	18696	10	with	with	IN
18637	18696	11	,	,	,
18637	18696	12	there	there	EX
18637	18696	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	18696	14	a	a	DT
18637	18696	15	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	18696	16	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	18696	17	of	of	IN
18637	18696	18	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18696	19	in	in	IN
18637	18696	20	the	the	DT
18637	18696	21	long	long	RB
18637	18696	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	18696	23	established	establish	VBN
18637	18696	24	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18696	25	sense	sense	NN
18637	18696	26	.	.	.
18637	18696	27	"	"	''
18637	18697	1	However	however	RB
18637	18697	2	,	,	,
18637	18697	3	by	by	IN
18637	18697	4	a	a	DT
18637	18697	5	process	process	NN
18637	18697	6	of	of	IN
18637	18697	7	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	18697	8	that	that	WDT
18637	18697	9	was	be	VBD
18637	18697	10	almost	almost	RB
18637	18697	11	completely	completely	RB
18637	18697	12	discarded	discard	VBN
18637	18697	13	during	during	IN
18637	18697	14	the	the	DT
18637	18697	15	depression	depression	NN
18637	18697	16	,	,	,
18637	18697	17	the	the	DT
18637	18697	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18697	19	was	be	VBD
18637	18697	20	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	18697	21	able	able	JJ
18637	18697	22	,	,	,
18637	18697	23	prior	prior	JJ
18637	18697	24	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	18697	25	,	,	,
18637	18697	26	to	to	TO
18637	18697	27	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	18697	28	State	State	NNP
18637	18697	29	ameliorative	ameliorative	JJ
18637	18697	30	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18697	31	by	by	IN
18637	18697	32	acknowledging	acknowledge	VBG
18637	18697	33	that	that	IN
18637	18697	34	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18697	35	of	of	IN
18637	18697	36	contract	contract	NN
18637	18697	37	was	be	VBD
18637	18697	38	"	"	``
18637	18697	39	a	a	DT
18637	18697	40	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	18697	41	and	and	CC
18637	18697	42	not	not	RB
18637	18697	43	an	an	DT
18637	18697	44	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	18697	45	right	right	NN
18637	18697	46	.	.	.
18637	18698	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18698	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18698	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18698	4	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	18698	5	implies	imply	VBZ
18637	18698	6	the	the	DT
18637	18698	7	absence	absence	NN
18637	18698	8	of	of	IN
18637	18698	9	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18698	10	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18698	11	,	,	,
18637	18698	12	not	not	RB
18637	18698	13	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	18698	14	from	from	IN
18637	18698	15	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18698	16	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18698	17	and	and	CC
18637	18698	18	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
18637	18698	19	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18698	20	in	in	IN
18637	18698	21	the	the	DT
18637	18698	22	interests	interest	NNS
18637	18698	23	of	of	IN
18637	18698	24	the	the	DT
18637	18698	25	community	community	NN
18637	18698	26	.	.	.
18637	18699	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18699	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18699	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18699	4	In	in	IN
18637	18699	5	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	18699	6	with	with	IN
18637	18699	7	the	the	DT
18637	18699	8	relation	relation	NN
18637	18699	9	of	of	IN
18637	18699	10	the	the	DT
18637	18699	11	employer	employer	NN
18637	18699	12	and	and	CC
18637	18699	13	employed	employ	VBN
18637	18699	14	,	,	,
18637	18699	15	the	the	DT
18637	18699	16	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18699	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	18699	18	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	18699	19	a	a	DT
18637	18699	20	wide	wide	JJ
18637	18699	21	field	field	NN
18637	18699	22	of	of	IN
18637	18699	23	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	18699	24	in	in	IN
18637	18699	25	order	order	NN
18637	18699	26	that	that	IN
18637	18699	27	there	there	EX
18637	18699	28	may	may	MD
18637	18699	29	be	be	VB
18637	18699	30	suitable	suitable	JJ
18637	18699	31	protection	protection	NN
18637	18699	32	of	of	IN
18637	18699	33	health	health	NN
18637	18699	34	and	and	CC
18637	18699	35	safety	safety	NN
18637	18699	36	,	,	,
18637	18699	37	and	and	CC
18637	18699	38	that	that	IN
18637	18699	39	peace	peace	NN
18637	18699	40	and	and	CC
18637	18699	41	good	good	JJ
18637	18699	42	order	order	NN
18637	18699	43	may	may	MD
18637	18699	44	be	be	VB
18637	18699	45	promoted	promote	VBN
18637	18699	46	through	through	IN
18637	18699	47	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18699	48	designed	design	VBN
18637	18699	49	to	to	TO
18637	18699	50	insure	insure	VB
18637	18699	51	wholesome	wholesome	JJ
18637	18699	52	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	18699	53	of	of	IN
18637	18699	54	work	work	NN
18637	18699	55	and	and	CC
18637	18699	56	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18699	57	from	from	IN
18637	18699	58	oppression	oppression	NN
18637	18699	59	.	.	.
18637	18700	1	"	"	``
18637	18700	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18700	3	126	126	CD
18637	18700	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18700	5	Through	through	IN
18637	18700	6	observance	observance	NN
18637	18700	7	of	of	IN
18637	18700	8	such	such	JJ
18637	18700	9	qualifying	qualify	VBG
18637	18700	10	statement	statement	NN
18637	18700	11	the	the	DT
18637	18700	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18700	13	was	be	VBD
18637	18700	14	induced	induce	VBN
18637	18700	15	to	to	TO
18637	18700	16	uphold	uphold	VB
18637	18700	17	the	the	DT
18637	18700	18	following	follow	VBG
18637	18700	19	types	type	NNS
18637	18700	20	of	of	IN
18637	18700	21	labor	labor	NN
18637	18700	22	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18700	23	.	.	.
18637	18701	1	Laws	law	NNS
18637	18701	2	Regulating	regulating	NN
18637	18701	3	Hours	hour	NNS
18637	18701	4	of	of	IN
18637	18701	5	Labor.--The	Labor.--The	NNP
18637	18701	6	due	due	JJ
18637	18701	7	process	process	NN
18637	18701	8	clause	clause	NN
18637	18701	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	18701	10	been	be	VBN
18637	18701	11	construed	construe	VBN
18637	18701	12	as	as	IN
18637	18701	13	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	18701	14	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	18701	15	by	by	IN
18637	18701	16	the	the	DT
18637	18701	17	States	States	NNP
18637	18701	18	of	of	IN
18637	18701	19	laws	law	NNS
18637	18701	20	:	:	:
18637	18701	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18701	22	1	1	LS
18637	18701	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18701	24	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	18701	25	the	the	DT
18637	18701	26	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18701	27	of	of	IN
18637	18701	28	labor	labor	NN
18637	18701	29	in	in	IN
18637	18701	30	mines	mine	NNS
18637	18701	31	and	and	CC
18637	18701	32	smelters	smelter	NNS
18637	18701	33	to	to	IN
18637	18701	34	eight	eight	CD
18637	18701	35	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18701	36	per	per	IN
18637	18701	37	day;[127	day;[127	NNP
18637	18701	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18701	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18701	40	2	2	LS
18637	18701	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18701	42	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	18701	43	eight	eight	CD
18637	18701	44	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18701	45	a	a	DT
18637	18701	46	day	day	NN
18637	18701	47	or	or	CC
18637	18701	48	a	a	DT
18637	18701	49	maximum	maximum	NN
18637	18701	50	of	of	IN
18637	18701	51	48	48	CD
18637	18701	52	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18701	53	per	per	IN
18637	18701	54	week	week	NN
18637	18701	55	as	as	IN
18637	18701	56	a	a	DT
18637	18701	57	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	18701	58	of	of	IN
18637	18701	59	the	the	DT
18637	18701	60	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18701	61	at	at	IN
18637	18701	62	which	which	WDT
18637	18701	63	women	woman	NNS
18637	18701	64	may	may	MD
18637	18701	65	labor;[128	labor;[128	,
18637	18701	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18701	67	and	and	CC
18637	18701	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18701	69	3	3	LS
18637	18701	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18701	71	providing	provide	VBG
18637	18701	72	that	that	IN
18637	18701	73	no	no	DT
18637	18701	74	person	person	NN
18637	18701	75	shall	shall	MD
18637	18701	76	work	work	VB
18637	18701	77	in	in	IN
18637	18701	78	any	any	DT
18637	18701	79	mill	mill	NN
18637	18701	80	,	,	,
18637	18701	81	etc	etc	FW
18637	18701	82	.	.	FW
18637	18701	83	,	,	,
18637	18701	84	more	more	JJR
18637	18701	85	than	than	IN
18637	18701	86	ten	ten	CD
18637	18701	87	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18701	88	per	per	IN
18637	18701	89	day	day	NN
18637	18701	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18701	91	with	with	IN
18637	18701	92	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	18701	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18701	94	but	but	CC
18637	18701	95	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	18701	96	overtime	overtime	NN
18637	18701	97	,	,	,
18637	18701	98	not	not	RB
18637	18701	99	to	to	TO
18637	18701	100	exceed	exceed	VB
18637	18701	101	three	three	CD
18637	18701	102	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18701	103	a	a	DT
18637	18701	104	day	day	NN
18637	18701	105	,	,	,
18637	18701	106	on	on	IN
18637	18701	107	condition	condition	NN
18637	18701	108	that	that	IN
18637	18701	109	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18701	110	is	be	VBZ
18637	18701	111	paid	pay	VBN
18637	18701	112	at	at	IN
18637	18701	113	the	the	DT
18637	18701	114	rate	rate	NN
18637	18701	115	of	of	IN
18637	18701	116	one	one	CD
18637	18701	117	and	and	CC
18637	18701	118	one	one	CD
18637	18701	119	-	-	HYPH
18637	18701	120	half	half	NN
18637	18701	121	times	time	NNS
18637	18701	122	the	the	DT
18637	18701	123	regular	regular	JJ
18637	18701	124	wage	wage	NN
18637	18701	125	.	.	.
18637	18702	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18702	2	129	129	CD
18637	18702	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18702	4	Because	because	IN
18637	18702	5	of	of	IN
18637	18702	6	the	the	DT
18637	18702	7	almost	almost	RB
18637	18702	8	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	18702	9	powers	power	NNS
18637	18702	10	of	of	IN
18637	18702	11	the	the	DT
18637	18702	12	State	State	NNP
18637	18702	13	and	and	CC
18637	18702	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18702	15	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	18702	16	subdivisions	subdivision	NNS
18637	18702	17	to	to	TO
18637	18702	18	determine	determine	VB
18637	18702	19	the	the	DT
18637	18702	20	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	18702	21	under	under	IN
18637	18702	22	which	which	WDT
18637	18702	23	work	work	NN
18637	18702	24	shall	shall	MD
18637	18702	25	go	go	VB
18637	18702	26	forward	forward	RB
18637	18702	27	on	on	IN
18637	18702	28	public	public	JJ
18637	18702	29	projects	project	NNS
18637	18702	30	,	,	,
18637	18702	31	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18702	32	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	18702	33	the	the	DT
18637	18702	34	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18702	35	of	of	IN
18637	18702	36	labor	labor	NN
18637	18702	37	on	on	IN
18637	18702	38	public	public	JJ
18637	18702	39	works	work	NNS
18637	18702	40	were	be	VBD
18637	18702	41	also	also	RB
18637	18702	42	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	18702	43	at	at	IN
18637	18702	44	a	a	DT
18637	18702	45	relatively	relatively	RB
18637	18702	46	early	early	JJ
18637	18702	47	date	date	NN
18637	18702	48	.	.	.
18637	18703	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18703	2	130	130	CD
18637	18703	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18703	4	Laws	law	NNS
18637	18703	5	Regulating	Regulating	NNP
18637	18703	6	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	18703	7	in	in	IN
18637	18703	8	Mines.--The	Mines.--The	NNP
18637	18703	9	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18703	10	of	of	IN
18637	18703	11	mines	mine	NNS
18637	18703	12	being	be	VBG
18637	18703	13	so	so	RB
18637	18703	14	patently	patently	RB
18637	18703	15	within	within	IN
18637	18703	16	the	the	DT
18637	18703	17	police	police	NN
18637	18703	18	power	power	NN
18637	18703	19	,	,	,
18637	18703	20	States	States	NNP
18637	18703	21	have	have	VBP
18637	18703	22	been	be	VBN
18637	18703	23	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	18703	24	in	in	IN
18637	18703	25	the	the	DT
18637	18703	26	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	18703	27	of	of	IN
18637	18703	28	laws	law	NNS
18637	18703	29	providing	provide	VBG
18637	18703	30	for	for	IN
18637	18703	31	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	18703	32	of	of	IN
18637	18703	33	mining	mining	NN
18637	18703	34	inspectors	inspector	NNS
18637	18703	35	and	and	CC
18637	18703	36	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18703	37	payment	payment	NN
18637	18703	38	of	of	IN
18637	18703	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18703	40	fees	fee	NNS
18637	18703	41	by	by	IN
18637	18703	42	mine	mine	VBG
18637	18703	43	owners,[131	owners,[131	NNP
18637	18703	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18703	45	compelling	compelling	JJ
18637	18703	46	employment	employment	NN
18637	18703	47	of	of	IN
18637	18703	48	only	only	RB
18637	18703	49	licensed	license	VBN
18637	18703	50	mine	mine	NN
18637	18703	51	managers	manager	NNS
18637	18703	52	and	and	CC
18637	18703	53	mine	mine	NN
18637	18703	54	examiners	examiner	NNS
18637	18703	55	,	,	,
18637	18703	56	and	and	CC
18637	18703	57	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	18703	58	upon	upon	IN
18637	18703	59	mine	mine	NN
18637	18703	60	owners	owner	NNS
18637	18703	61	liability	liability	NN
18637	18703	62	for	for	IN
18637	18703	63	the	the	DT
18637	18703	64	wilful	wilful	JJ
18637	18703	65	failure	failure	NN
18637	18703	66	of	of	IN
18637	18703	67	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18703	68	manager	manager	NN
18637	18703	69	and	and	CC
18637	18703	70	examiner	examiner	NN
18637	18703	71	to	to	TO
18637	18703	72	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	18703	73	a	a	DT
18637	18703	74	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	18703	75	safe	safe	JJ
18637	18703	76	place	place	NN
18637	18703	77	for	for	IN
18637	18703	78	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	18703	79	.	.	.
18637	18704	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18704	2	132	132	CD
18637	18704	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18704	4	Other	other	JJ
18637	18704	5	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18704	6	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18704	7	which	which	WDT
18637	18704	8	have	have	VBP
18637	18704	9	been	be	VBN
18637	18704	10	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18704	11	have	have	VBP
18637	18704	12	included	include	VBN
18637	18704	13	laws	law	NNS
18637	18704	14	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18704	15	that	that	IN
18637	18704	16	entries	entry	NNS
18637	18704	17	be	be	VBP
18637	18704	18	of	of	IN
18637	18704	19	a	a	DT
18637	18704	20	specified	specified	JJ
18637	18704	21	width,[133	width,[133	NNP
18637	18704	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18704	23	that	that	IN
18637	18704	24	boundary	boundary	JJ
18637	18704	25	pillars	pillar	NNS
18637	18704	26	be	be	VB
18637	18704	27	installed	instal	VBN
18637	18704	28	between	between	IN
18637	18704	29	adjoining	adjoin	VBG
18637	18704	30	coal	coal	NN
18637	18704	31	properties	property	NNS
18637	18704	32	as	as	IN
18637	18704	33	a	a	DT
18637	18704	34	protection	protection	NN
18637	18704	35	against	against	IN
18637	18704	36	flood	flood	NN
18637	18704	37	in	in	IN
18637	18704	38	case	case	NN
18637	18704	39	of	of	IN
18637	18704	40	abandonment,[134	abandonment,[134	NN
18637	18704	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18704	42	and	and	CC
18637	18704	43	that	that	IN
18637	18704	44	washhouses	washhouse	NNS
18637	18704	45	be	be	VB
18637	18704	46	provided	provide	VBN
18637	18704	47	for	for	IN
18637	18704	48	employees	employee	NNS
18637	18704	49	.	.	.
18637	18705	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18705	2	135	135	CD
18637	18705	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18705	4	Laws	Laws	NNP
18637	18705	5	Prohibiting	Prohibiting	NNP
18637	18705	6	Employment	Employment	NNP
18637	18705	7	of	of	IN
18637	18705	8	Children	Children	NNPS
18637	18705	9	in	in	IN
18637	18705	10	Hazardous	hazardous	JJ
18637	18705	11	Occupations.--To	Occupations.--To	NNP
18637	18705	12	make	make	VBP
18637	18705	13	effective	effective	JJ
18637	18705	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18705	15	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	18705	16	against	against	IN
18637	18705	17	the	the	DT
18637	18705	18	employment	employment	NN
18637	18705	19	of	of	IN
18637	18705	20	persons	person	NNS
18637	18705	21	under	under	IN
18637	18705	22	16	16	CD
18637	18705	23	years	year	NNS
18637	18705	24	of	of	IN
18637	18705	25	age	age	NN
18637	18705	26	in	in	IN
18637	18705	27	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	18705	28	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	18705	29	,	,	,
18637	18705	30	a	a	DT
18637	18705	31	State	state	NN
18637	18705	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	18705	33	been	be	VBN
18637	18705	34	held	hold	VBN
18637	18705	35	to	to	TO
18637	18705	36	be	be	VB
18637	18705	37	competent	competent	JJ
18637	18705	38	to	to	TO
18637	18705	39	require	require	VB
18637	18705	40	employers	employer	NNS
18637	18705	41	at	at	IN
18637	18705	42	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18705	43	peril	peril	NN
18637	18705	44	to	to	TO
18637	18705	45	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	18705	46	whether	whether	IN
18637	18705	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18705	48	employees	employee	NNS
18637	18705	49	are	be	VBP
18637	18705	50	in	in	IN
18637	18705	51	fact	fact	NN
18637	18705	52	below	below	IN
18637	18705	53	that	that	DT
18637	18705	54	age	age	NN
18637	18705	55	.	.	.
18637	18706	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18706	2	136	136	CD
18637	18706	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18706	4	Laws	law	NNS
18637	18706	5	Regulating	Regulating	NNP
18637	18706	6	Payment	Payment	NNP
18637	18706	7	of	of	IN
18637	18706	8	Wages.--No	wages.--no	IN
18637	18706	9	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18706	10	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18706	11	of	of	IN
18637	18706	12	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18706	13	of	of	IN
18637	18706	14	contract	contract	NN
18637	18706	15	was	be	VBD
18637	18706	16	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	18706	17	to	to	TO
18637	18706	18	have	have	VB
18637	18706	19	been	be	VBN
18637	18706	20	occasioned	occasion	VBN
18637	18706	21	by	by	IN
18637	18706	22	a	a	DT
18637	18706	23	statute	statute	NN
18637	18706	24	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18706	25	redemption	redemption	NN
18637	18706	26	in	in	IN
18637	18706	27	cash	cash	NN
18637	18706	28	of	of	IN
18637	18706	29	store	store	NN
18637	18706	30	orders	order	NNS
18637	18706	31	or	or	CC
18637	18706	32	other	other	JJ
18637	18706	33	evidences	evidence	NNS
18637	18706	34	of	of	IN
18637	18706	35	indebtedness	indebtedness	NN
18637	18706	36	issued	issue	VBN
18637	18706	37	by	by	IN
18637	18706	38	employers	employer	NNS
18637	18706	39	in	in	IN
18637	18706	40	payment	payment	NN
18637	18706	41	of	of	IN
18637	18706	42	wages	wage	NNS
18637	18706	43	.	.	.
18637	18707	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18707	2	137	137	CD
18637	18707	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18707	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	18707	5	was	be	VBD
18637	18707	6	any	any	DT
18637	18707	7	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18707	8	defect	defect	NN
18637	18707	9	discernible	discernible	JJ
18637	18707	10	in	in	IN
18637	18707	11	laws	law	NNS
18637	18707	12	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18707	13	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	18707	14	to	to	TO
18637	18707	15	pay	pay	VB
18637	18707	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18707	17	employees	employee	NNS
18637	18707	18	semimonthly[138	semimonthly[138	JJ
18637	18707	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18707	20	and	and	CC
18637	18707	21	to	to	TO
18637	18707	22	pay	pay	VB
18637	18707	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18707	24	on	on	IN
18637	18707	25	the	the	DT
18637	18707	26	day	day	NN
18637	18707	27	of	of	IN
18637	18707	28	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	18707	29	,	,	,
18637	18707	30	without	without	IN
18637	18707	31	abatement	abatement	NN
18637	18707	32	or	or	CC
18637	18707	33	reduction	reduction	NN
18637	18707	34	,	,	,
18637	18707	35	any	any	DT
18637	18707	36	funds	fund	NNS
18637	18707	37	due	due	VBP
18637	18707	38	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18707	39	.	.	.
18637	18708	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18708	2	139	139	CD
18637	18708	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18708	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18708	5	,	,	,
18637	18708	6	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18708	7	of	of	IN
18637	18708	8	contract	contract	NN
18637	18708	9	was	be	VBD
18637	18708	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	18708	11	not	not	RB
18637	18708	12	to	to	TO
18637	18708	13	be	be	VB
18637	18708	14	infringed	infringe	VBN
18637	18708	15	by	by	IN
18637	18708	16	an	an	DT
18637	18708	17	act	act	NN
18637	18708	18	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18708	19	that	that	IN
18637	18708	20	miners	miner	NNS
18637	18708	21	,	,	,
18637	18708	22	whose	whose	WP$
18637	18708	23	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18708	24	was	be	VBD
18637	18708	25	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	18708	26	on	on	IN
18637	18708	27	the	the	DT
18637	18708	28	basis	basis	NN
18637	18708	29	of	of	IN
18637	18708	30	weight	weight	NN
18637	18708	31	,	,	,
18637	18708	32	be	be	VB
18637	18708	33	paid	pay	VBN
18637	18708	34	according	accord	VBG
18637	18708	35	to	to	IN
18637	18708	36	coal	coal	NN
18637	18708	37	in	in	IN
18637	18708	38	the	the	DT
18637	18708	39	mine	mine	NN
18637	18708	40	car	car	NN
18637	18708	41	rather	rather	RB
18637	18708	42	than	than	IN
18637	18708	43	at	at	IN
18637	18708	44	a	a	DT
18637	18708	45	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18708	46	price	price	NN
18637	18708	47	per	per	IN
18637	18708	48	ton	ton	NN
18637	18708	49	for	for	IN
18637	18708	50	coal	coal	NN
18637	18708	51	screened	screen	VBN
18637	18708	52	after	after	IN
18637	18708	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18708	54	has	have	VBZ
18637	18708	55	been	be	VBN
18637	18708	56	brought	bring	VBN
18637	18708	57	to	to	IN
18637	18708	58	the	the	DT
18637	18708	59	surface	surface	NN
18637	18708	60	,	,	,
18637	18708	61	and	and	CC
18637	18708	62	conditioning	condition	VBG
18637	18708	63	such	such	JJ
18637	18708	64	payment	payment	NN
18637	18708	65	on	on	IN
18637	18708	66	the	the	DT
18637	18708	67	presence	presence	NN
18637	18708	68	of	of	IN
18637	18708	69	no	no	DT
18637	18708	70	greater	great	JJR
18637	18708	71	percentage	percentage	NN
18637	18708	72	of	of	IN
18637	18708	73	dirt	dirt	NN
18637	18708	74	or	or	CC
18637	18708	75	impurities	impurity	NNS
18637	18708	76	than	than	IN
18637	18708	77	that	that	DT
18637	18708	78	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	18708	79	as	as	IN
18637	18708	80	unavoidable	unavoidable	JJ
18637	18708	81	by	by	IN
18637	18708	82	the	the	DT
18637	18708	83	State	State	NNP
18637	18708	84	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	18708	85	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18708	86	.	.	.
18637	18709	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18709	2	140	140	CD
18637	18709	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18709	4	Minimum	Minimum	NNP
18637	18709	5	Wage	wage	NN
18637	18709	6	Laws.--The	laws.--the	NN
18637	18709	7	theory	theory	NN
18637	18709	8	that	that	IN
18637	18709	9	a	a	DT
18637	18709	10	law	law	NN
18637	18709	11	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	18709	12	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	18709	13	wages	wage	NNS
18637	18709	14	for	for	IN
18637	18709	15	women	woman	NNS
18637	18709	16	and	and	CC
18637	18709	17	children	child	NNS
18637	18709	18	violates	violate	VBZ
18637	18709	19	due	due	JJ
18637	18709	20	process	process	NN
18637	18709	21	by	by	IN
18637	18709	22	impairing	impair	VBG
18637	18709	23	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18709	24	of	of	IN
18637	18709	25	contract	contract	NN
18637	18709	26	was	be	VBD
18637	18709	27	finally	finally	RB
18637	18709	28	discarded	discard	VBN
18637	18709	29	in	in	IN
18637	18709	30	1937	1937	CD
18637	18709	31	.	.	.
18637	18710	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18710	2	141	141	CD
18637	18710	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18710	4	The	the	DT
18637	18710	5	current	current	JJ
18637	18710	6	theory	theory	NN
18637	18710	7	of	of	IN
18637	18710	8	the	the	DT
18637	18710	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18710	10	,	,	,
18637	18710	11	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	18710	12	when	when	WRB
18637	18710	13	labor	labor	NN
18637	18710	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	18710	15	the	the	DT
18637	18710	16	beneficiary	beneficiary	NN
18637	18710	17	of	of	IN
18637	18710	18	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18710	19	,	,	,
18637	18710	20	was	be	VBD
18637	18710	21	recently	recently	RB
18637	18710	22	stated	state	VBN
18637	18710	23	by	by	IN
18637	18710	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18710	25	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	18710	26	for	for	IN
18637	18710	27	a	a	DT
18637	18710	28	majority	majority	NN
18637	18710	29	of	of	IN
18637	18710	30	the	the	DT
18637	18710	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18710	32	,	,	,
18637	18710	33	in	in	IN
18637	18710	34	the	the	DT
18637	18710	35	following	following	JJ
18637	18710	36	terms	term	NNS
18637	18710	37	:	:	:
18637	18710	38	"	"	``
18637	18710	39	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18710	40	recent	recent	JJ
18637	18710	41	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	18710	42	make	make	VBP
18637	18710	43	plain	plain	JJ
18637	18710	44	that	that	IN
18637	18710	45	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18710	46	do	do	VBP
18637	18710	47	not	not	RB
18637	18710	48	sit	sit	VB
18637	18710	49	as	as	IN
18637	18710	50	a	a	DT
18637	18710	51	superlegislature	superlegislature	NN
18637	18710	52	to	to	TO
18637	18710	53	weigh	weigh	VB
18637	18710	54	the	the	DT
18637	18710	55	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	18710	56	of	of	IN
18637	18710	57	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18710	58	nor	nor	CC
18637	18710	59	to	to	TO
18637	18710	60	decide	decide	VB
18637	18710	61	whether	whether	IN
18637	18710	62	the	the	DT
18637	18710	63	policy	policy	NN
18637	18710	64	which	which	WDT
18637	18710	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18710	66	expresses	express	VBZ
18637	18710	67	offends	offend	VBZ
18637	18710	68	the	the	DT
18637	18710	69	public	public	JJ
18637	18710	70	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	18710	71	.	.	.
18637	18711	1	The	the	DT
18637	18711	2	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18711	3	power	power	NN
18637	18711	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	18711	5	limits	limit	NNS
18637	18711	6	*	*	NFP
18637	18711	7	*	*	NFP
18637	18711	8	*	*	NFP
18637	18711	9	.	.	.
18637	18712	1	But	but	CC
18637	18712	2	the	the	DT
18637	18712	3	state	state	NN
18637	18712	4	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	18712	5	have	have	VBP
18637	18712	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18712	7	authority	authority	NN
18637	18712	8	to	to	TO
18637	18712	9	experiment	experiment	VB
18637	18712	10	with	with	IN
18637	18712	11	new	new	JJ
18637	18712	12	techniques	technique	NNS
18637	18712	13	;	;	:
18637	18712	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18712	15	are	be	VBP
18637	18712	16	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	18712	17	to	to	IN
18637	18712	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18712	19	own	own	JJ
18637	18712	20	standard	standard	NN
18637	18712	21	of	of	IN
18637	18712	22	the	the	DT
18637	18712	23	public	public	JJ
18637	18712	24	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	18712	25	;	;	:
18637	18712	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18712	27	may	may	MD
18637	18712	28	within	within	IN
18637	18712	29	extremely	extremely	RB
18637	18712	30	broad	broad	JJ
18637	18712	31	limits	limit	NNS
18637	18712	32	control	control	VBP
18637	18712	33	practices	practice	NNS
18637	18712	34	in	in	IN
18637	18712	35	the	the	DT
18637	18712	36	business	business	NN
18637	18712	37	-	-	HYPH
18637	18712	38	labor	labor	NN
18637	18712	39	field	field	NN
18637	18712	40	,	,	,
18637	18712	41	so	so	RB
18637	18712	42	long	long	RB
18637	18712	43	as	as	IN
18637	18712	44	specific	specific	JJ
18637	18712	45	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18712	46	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
18637	18712	47	are	be	VBP
18637	18712	48	not	not	RB
18637	18712	49	violated	violate	VBN
18637	18712	50	and	and	CC
18637	18712	51	so	so	RB
18637	18712	52	long	long	RB
18637	18712	53	as	as	IN
18637	18712	54	conflicts	conflict	NNS
18637	18712	55	with	with	IN
18637	18712	56	valid	valid	JJ
18637	18712	57	and	and	CC
18637	18712	58	controlling	control	VBG
18637	18712	59	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18712	60	laws	law	NNS
18637	18712	61	are	be	VBP
18637	18712	62	avoided	avoid	VBN
18637	18712	63	.	.	.
18637	18713	1	"	"	``
18637	18713	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18713	3	142	142	CD
18637	18713	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18713	5	Proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	18713	6	from	from	IN
18637	18713	7	this	this	DT
18637	18713	8	basis	basis	NN
18637	18713	9	the	the	DT
18637	18713	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18713	11	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	18713	12	a	a	DT
18637	18713	13	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	18713	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	18713	15	giving	give	VBG
18637	18713	16	employees	employee	NNS
18637	18713	17	the	the	DT
18637	18713	18	right	right	NN
18637	18713	19	to	to	TO
18637	18713	20	absent	absent	VB
18637	18713	21	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18713	22	four	four	CD
18637	18713	23	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18713	24	on	on	IN
18637	18713	25	election	election	NN
18637	18713	26	day	day	NN
18637	18713	27	,	,	,
18637	18713	28	between	between	IN
18637	18713	29	the	the	DT
18637	18713	30	opening	opening	NN
18637	18713	31	and	and	CC
18637	18713	32	closing	closing	NN
18637	18713	33	of	of	IN
18637	18713	34	the	the	DT
18637	18713	35	polls	poll	NNS
18637	18713	36	,	,	,
18637	18713	37	without	without	IN
18637	18713	38	deduction	deduction	NN
18637	18713	39	of	of	IN
18637	18713	40	wages	wage	NNS
18637	18713	41	for	for	IN
18637	18713	42	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18713	43	absence	absence	NN
18637	18713	44	.	.	.
18637	18714	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18714	2	was	be	VBD
18637	18714	3	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	18714	4	that	that	IN
18637	18714	5	this	this	DT
18637	18714	6	was	be	VBD
18637	18714	7	a	a	DT
18637	18714	8	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	18714	9	wage	wage	NN
18637	18714	10	law	law	NN
18637	18714	11	,	,	,
18637	18714	12	but	but	CC
18637	18714	13	,	,	,
18637	18714	14	said	say	VBD
18637	18714	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18714	16	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	18714	17	,	,	,
18637	18714	18	"	"	''
18637	18714	19	the	the	DT
18637	18714	20	protection	protection	NN
18637	18714	21	of	of	IN
18637	18714	22	the	the	DT
18637	18714	23	right	right	NN
18637	18714	24	of	of	IN
18637	18714	25	suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	18714	26	under	under	IN
18637	18714	27	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18714	28	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	18714	29	of	of	IN
18637	18714	30	things	thing	NNS
18637	18714	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	18714	32	basic	basic	JJ
18637	18714	33	and	and	CC
18637	18714	34	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	18714	35	,	,	,
18637	18714	36	"	"	''
18637	18714	37	and	and	CC
18637	18714	38	hence	hence	RB
18637	18714	39	within	within	IN
18637	18714	40	the	the	DT
18637	18714	41	police	police	NN
18637	18714	42	power	power	NN
18637	18714	43	.	.	.
18637	18715	1	"	"	``
18637	18715	2	Of	of	RB
18637	18715	3	course	course	RB
18637	18715	4	,	,	,
18637	18715	5	"	"	''
18637	18715	6	the	the	DT
18637	18715	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18715	8	added	add	VBD
18637	18715	9	,	,	,
18637	18715	10	"	"	``
18637	18715	11	many	many	JJ
18637	18715	12	forms	form	NNS
18637	18715	13	of	of	IN
18637	18715	14	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18715	15	reduce	reduce	VBP
18637	18715	16	the	the	DT
18637	18715	17	net	net	JJ
18637	18715	18	return	return	NN
18637	18715	19	of	of	IN
18637	18715	20	the	the	DT
18637	18715	21	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	18715	22	*	*	NFP
18637	18715	23	*	*	NFP
18637	18715	24	*	*	NFP
18637	18715	25	Most	Most	JJS
18637	18715	26	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18715	27	of	of	IN
18637	18715	28	business	business	NN
18637	18715	29	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	18715	30	impose	impose	VBP
18637	18715	31	financial	financial	JJ
18637	18715	32	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	18715	33	on	on	IN
18637	18715	34	the	the	DT
18637	18715	35	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	18715	36	for	for	IN
18637	18715	37	which	which	WDT
18637	18715	38	no	no	DT
18637	18715	39	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18715	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	18715	41	paid	pay	VBN
18637	18715	42	.	.	.
18637	18716	1	Those	those	DT
18637	18716	2	are	be	VBP
18637	18716	3	part	part	NN
18637	18716	4	of	of	IN
18637	18716	5	the	the	DT
18637	18716	6	costs	cost	NNS
18637	18716	7	of	of	IN
18637	18716	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18716	9	civilization	civilization	NN
18637	18716	10	.	.	.
18637	18717	1	Extreme	extreme	JJ
18637	18717	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	18717	3	are	be	VBP
18637	18717	4	conjured	conjure	VBN
18637	18717	5	up	up	RP
18637	18717	6	where	where	WRB
18637	18717	7	an	an	DT
18637	18717	8	employer	employer	NN
18637	18717	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	18717	10	required	require	VBN
18637	18717	11	to	to	TO
18637	18717	12	pay	pay	VB
18637	18717	13	wages	wage	NNS
18637	18717	14	for	for	IN
18637	18717	15	a	a	DT
18637	18717	16	period	period	NN
18637	18717	17	that	that	WDT
18637	18717	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	18717	19	no	no	DT
18637	18717	20	relation	relation	NN
18637	18717	21	to	to	IN
18637	18717	22	the	the	DT
18637	18717	23	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	18717	24	end	end	NN
18637	18717	25	.	.	.
18637	18718	1	Those	those	DT
18637	18718	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	18718	3	can	can	MD
18637	18718	4	await	await	VB
18637	18718	5	decision	decision	NN
18637	18718	6	as	as	IN
18637	18718	7	and	and	CC
18637	18718	8	when	when	WRB
18637	18718	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18718	10	arise	arise	VBP
18637	18718	11	.	.	.
18637	18719	1	The	the	DT
18637	18719	2	present	present	JJ
18637	18719	3	law	law	NN
18637	18719	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	18719	5	no	no	DT
18637	18719	6	such	such	JJ
18637	18719	7	infirmity	infirmity	NN
18637	18719	8	.	.	.
18637	18720	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18720	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	18720	3	designed	design	VBN
18637	18720	4	to	to	TO
18637	18720	5	eliminate	eliminate	VB
18637	18720	6	any	any	DT
18637	18720	7	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	18720	8	for	for	IN
18637	18720	9	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	18720	10	the	the	DT
18637	18720	11	right	right	NN
18637	18720	12	of	of	IN
18637	18720	13	suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	18720	14	and	and	CC
18637	18720	15	to	to	TO
18637	18720	16	remove	remove	VB
18637	18720	17	a	a	DT
18637	18720	18	practical	practical	JJ
18637	18720	19	obstacle	obstacle	NN
18637	18720	20	to	to	IN
18637	18720	21	getting	get	VBG
18637	18720	22	out	out	RP
18637	18720	23	the	the	DT
18637	18720	24	vote	vote	NN
18637	18720	25	.	.	.
18637	18721	1	The	the	DT
18637	18721	2	public	public	JJ
18637	18721	3	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	18721	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	18721	5	a	a	DT
18637	18721	6	broad	broad	JJ
18637	18721	7	and	and	CC
18637	18721	8	inclusive	inclusive	JJ
18637	18721	9	concept	concept	NN
18637	18721	10	.	.	.
18637	18722	1	The	the	DT
18637	18722	2	moral	moral	JJ
18637	18722	3	,	,	,
18637	18722	4	social	social	JJ
18637	18722	5	,	,	,
18637	18722	6	economic	economic	JJ
18637	18722	7	,	,	,
18637	18722	8	and	and	CC
18637	18722	9	physical	physical	JJ
18637	18722	10	well	well	NN
18637	18722	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	18722	12	being	being	NN
18637	18722	13	of	of	IN
18637	18722	14	the	the	DT
18637	18722	15	community	community	NN
18637	18722	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	18722	17	one	one	CD
18637	18722	18	part	part	NN
18637	18722	19	of	of	IN
18637	18722	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18722	21	;	;	:
18637	18722	22	the	the	DT
18637	18722	23	political	political	JJ
18637	18722	24	well	well	NN
18637	18722	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	18722	26	being	being	NN
18637	18722	27	,	,	,
18637	18722	28	another	another	DT
18637	18722	29	.	.	.
18637	18723	1	The	the	DT
18637	18723	2	police	police	NN
18637	18723	3	power	power	NN
18637	18723	4	which	which	WDT
18637	18723	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	18723	6	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	18723	7	to	to	TO
18637	18723	8	fix	fix	VB
18637	18723	9	the	the	DT
18637	18723	10	financial	financial	JJ
18637	18723	11	burden	burden	NN
18637	18723	12	for	for	IN
18637	18723	13	one	one	CD
18637	18723	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	18723	15	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	18723	16	for	for	IN
18637	18723	17	the	the	DT
18637	18723	18	other	other	JJ
18637	18723	19	.	.	.
18637	18724	1	The	the	DT
18637	18724	2	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18724	3	of	of	IN
18637	18724	4	the	the	DT
18637	18724	5	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18724	6	that	that	DT
18637	18724	7	time	time	NN
18637	18724	8	out	out	RP
18637	18724	9	for	for	IN
18637	18724	10	voting	voting	NN
18637	18724	11	should	should	MD
18637	18724	12	cost	cost	VB
18637	18724	13	the	the	DT
18637	18724	14	employee	employee	NN
18637	18724	15	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	18724	16	may	may	MD
18637	18724	17	be	be	VB
18637	18724	18	a	a	DT
18637	18724	19	debatable	debatable	JJ
18637	18724	20	one	one	NN
18637	18724	21	.	.	.
18637	18725	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18725	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	18725	3	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	18725	4	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	18725	5	by	by	IN
18637	18725	6	the	the	DT
18637	18725	7	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	18725	8	to	to	TO
18637	18725	9	be	be	VB
18637	18725	10	such	such	JJ
18637	18725	11	.	.	.
18637	18726	1	But	but	CC
18637	18726	2	if	if	IN
18637	18726	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18726	4	recent	recent	JJ
18637	18726	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	18726	6	mean	mean	VBP
18637	18726	7	anything	anything	NN
18637	18726	8	,	,	,
18637	18726	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18726	10	leave	leave	VBP
18637	18726	11	debatable	debatable	JJ
18637	18726	12	issues	issue	NNS
18637	18726	13	as	as	IN
18637	18726	14	respects	respect	NNS
18637	18726	15	business	business	NN
18637	18726	16	,	,	,
18637	18726	17	economic	economic	JJ
18637	18726	18	,	,	,
18637	18726	19	and	and	CC
18637	18726	20	social	social	JJ
18637	18726	21	affairs	affair	NNS
18637	18726	22	to	to	IN
18637	18726	23	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18726	24	decision	decision	NN
18637	18726	25	.	.	.
18637	18727	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18727	2	could	could	MD
18637	18727	3	strike	strike	VB
18637	18727	4	down	down	RP
18637	18727	5	this	this	DT
18637	18727	6	law	law	NN
18637	18727	7	only	only	RB
18637	18727	8	if	if	IN
18637	18727	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18727	10	returned	return	VBD
18637	18727	11	to	to	IN
18637	18727	12	the	the	DT
18637	18727	13	philosophy	philosophy	NN
18637	18727	14	of	of	IN
18637	18727	15	the	the	DT
18637	18727	16	_	_	NNP
18637	18727	17	Lochner	Lochner	NNP
18637	18727	18	_	_	NNP
18637	18727	19	,	,	,
18637	18727	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18727	21	Coppage	Coppage	NNP
18637	18727	22	_	_	NNP
18637	18727	23	,	,	,
18637	18727	24	and	and	CC
18637	18727	25	_	_	NNP
18637	18727	26	Adkins	Adkins	NNP
18637	18727	27	_	_	NNP
18637	18727	28	cases	case	NNS
18637	18727	29	.	.	.
18637	18728	1	"	"	``
18637	18728	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18728	3	143	143	CD
18637	18728	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18728	5	Workmen	Workmen	NNP
18637	18728	6	's	's	POS
18637	18728	7	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	18728	8	Laws.--"This	Laws.--"This	NNP
18637	18728	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18728	10	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
18637	18728	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	18728	12	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	18728	13	the	the	DT
18637	18728	14	authority	authority	NN
18637	18728	15	of	of	IN
18637	18728	16	the	the	DT
18637	18728	17	States	States	NNPS
18637	18728	18	to	to	TO
18637	18728	19	establish	establish	VB
18637	18728	20	by	by	IN
18637	18728	21	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18728	22	departures	departure	NNS
18637	18728	23	from	from	IN
18637	18728	24	the	the	DT
18637	18728	25	fellow	fellow	JJ
18637	18728	26	-	-	HYPH
18637	18728	27	servant	servant	JJ
18637	18728	28	rule	rule	NN
18637	18728	29	and	and	CC
18637	18728	30	other	other	JJ
18637	18728	31	common	common	JJ
18637	18728	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	18728	33	law	law	NN
18637	18728	34	rules	rule	NNS
18637	18728	35	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	18728	36	the	the	DT
18637	18728	37	employer	employer	NN
18637	18728	38	's	's	POS
18637	18728	39	liability	liability	NN
18637	18728	40	for	for	IN
18637	18728	41	personal	personal	JJ
18637	18728	42	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	18728	43	to	to	IN
18637	18728	44	the	the	DT
18637	18728	45	employee	employee	NN
18637	18728	46	.	.	.
18637	18729	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18729	2	144	144	CD
18637	18729	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18729	4	*	*	NFP
18637	18729	5	*	*	NFP
18637	18729	6	*	*	NFP
18637	18729	7	These	these	DT
18637	18729	8	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	18729	9	have	have	VBP
18637	18729	10	established	establish	VBN
18637	18729	11	the	the	DT
18637	18729	12	propositions	proposition	NNS
18637	18729	13	that	that	WDT
18637	18729	14	the	the	DT
18637	18729	15	rules	rule	NNS
18637	18729	16	of	of	IN
18637	18729	17	law	law	NN
18637	18729	18	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	18729	19	the	the	DT
18637	18729	20	employer	employer	NN
18637	18729	21	's	's	POS
18637	18729	22	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	18729	23	for	for	IN
18637	18729	24	personal	personal	JJ
18637	18729	25	injury	injury	NN
18637	18729	26	or	or	CC
18637	18729	27	death	death	NN
18637	18729	28	of	of	IN
18637	18729	29	an	an	DT
18637	18729	30	employee	employee	NN
18637	18729	31	arising	arise	VBG
18637	18729	32	in	in	IN
18637	18729	33	the	the	DT
18637	18729	34	course	course	NN
18637	18729	35	of	of	IN
18637	18729	36	employment	employment	NN
18637	18729	37	are	be	VBP
18637	18729	38	not	not	RB
18637	18729	39	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	18729	40	alteration	alteration	NN
18637	18729	41	by	by	IN
18637	18729	42	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18729	43	in	in	IN
18637	18729	44	the	the	DT
18637	18729	45	public	public	JJ
18637	18729	46	interest	interest	NN
18637	18729	47	;	;	:
18637	18729	48	that	that	IN
18637	18729	49	no	no	DT
18637	18729	50	person	person	NN
18637	18729	51	has	have	VBZ
18637	18729	52	a	a	DT
18637	18729	53	vested	vested	JJ
18637	18729	54	right	right	NN
18637	18729	55	entitling	entitle	VBG
18637	18729	56	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18729	57	to	to	TO
18637	18729	58	have	have	VB
18637	18729	59	these	these	DT
18637	18729	60	any	any	DT
18637	18729	61	more	more	JJR
18637	18729	62	than	than	IN
18637	18729	63	other	other	JJ
18637	18729	64	rules	rule	NNS
18637	18729	65	of	of	IN
18637	18729	66	law	law	NN
18637	18729	67	remain	remain	VBP
18637	18729	68	unchanged	unchanged	JJ
18637	18729	69	for	for	IN
18637	18729	70	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18729	71	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	18729	72	;	;	:
18637	18729	73	and	and	CC
18637	18729	74	that	that	IN
18637	18729	75	,	,	,
18637	18729	76	if	if	IN
18637	18729	77	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18729	78	exclude	exclude	VBP
18637	18729	79	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18729	80	and	and	CC
18637	18729	81	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18729	82	changes	change	NNS
18637	18729	83	,	,	,
18637	18729	84	liability	liability	NN
18637	18729	85	may	may	MD
18637	18729	86	be	be	VB
18637	18729	87	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18729	88	upon	upon	IN
18637	18729	89	the	the	DT
18637	18729	90	employer	employer	NN
18637	18729	91	without	without	IN
18637	18729	92	fault	fault	NN
18637	18729	93	,	,	,
18637	18729	94	and	and	CC
18637	18729	95	the	the	DT
18637	18729	96	rules	rule	NNS
18637	18729	97	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	18729	98	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18729	99	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	18729	100	to	to	IN
18637	18729	101	one	one	CD
18637	18729	102	employee	employee	NN
18637	18729	103	for	for	IN
18637	18729	104	the	the	DT
18637	18729	105	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	18729	106	of	of	IN
18637	18729	107	another	another	DT
18637	18729	108	and	and	CC
18637	18729	109	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	18729	110	contributory	contributory	JJ
18637	18729	111	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	18729	112	and	and	CC
18637	18729	113	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	18729	114	of	of	IN
18637	18729	115	risk	risk	NN
18637	18729	116	are	be	VBP
18637	18729	117	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18729	118	to	to	IN
18637	18729	119	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18729	120	change	change	NN
18637	18729	121	.	.	.
18637	18730	1	"	"	``
18637	18730	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18730	3	145	145	CD
18637	18730	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18730	5	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	18730	6	,	,	,
18637	18730	7	a	a	DT
18637	18730	8	State	State	NNP
18637	18730	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	18730	10	which	which	WDT
18637	18730	11	provided	provide	VBD
18637	18730	12	an	an	DT
18637	18730	13	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	18730	14	system	system	NN
18637	18730	15	to	to	TO
18637	18730	16	govern	govern	VB
18637	18730	17	the	the	DT
18637	18730	18	liabilities	liability	NNS
18637	18730	19	of	of	IN
18637	18730	20	employers	employer	NNS
18637	18730	21	and	and	CC
18637	18730	22	the	the	DT
18637	18730	23	rights	right	NNS
18637	18730	24	of	of	IN
18637	18730	25	employees	employee	NNS
18637	18730	26	and	and	CC
18637	18730	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18730	28	dependents	dependent	NNS
18637	18730	29	,	,	,
18637	18730	30	in	in	IN
18637	18730	31	respect	respect	NN
18637	18730	32	of	of	IN
18637	18730	33	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18730	34	for	for	IN
18637	18730	35	disabling	disable	VBG
18637	18730	36	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	18730	37	and	and	CC
18637	18730	38	death	death	NN
18637	18730	39	caused	cause	VBN
18637	18730	40	by	by	IN
18637	18730	41	accident	accident	NN
18637	18730	42	in	in	IN
18637	18730	43	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18730	44	hazardous	hazardous	JJ
18637	18730	45	occupations,[146	occupations,[146	NN
18637	18730	46	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18730	47	was	be	VBD
18637	18730	48	held	hold	VBN
18637	18730	49	not	not	RB
18637	18730	50	to	to	TO
18637	18730	51	work	work	VB
18637	18730	52	a	a	DT
18637	18730	53	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18730	54	of	of	IN
18637	18730	55	property	property	NN
18637	18730	56	without	without	IN
18637	18730	57	due	due	JJ
18637	18730	58	process	process	NN
18637	18730	59	of	of	IN
18637	18730	60	law	law	NN
18637	18730	61	in	in	IN
18637	18730	62	rendering	render	VBG
18637	18730	63	the	the	DT
18637	18730	64	employer	employer	NN
18637	18730	65	liable	liable	JJ
18637	18730	66	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	18730	67	of	of	IN
18637	18730	68	the	the	DT
18637	18730	69	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	18730	70	of	of	IN
18637	18730	71	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	18730	72	,	,	,
18637	18730	73	contributory	contributory	JJ
18637	18730	74	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	18730	75	,	,	,
18637	18730	76	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	18730	77	of	of	IN
18637	18730	78	risk	risk	NN
18637	18730	79	,	,	,
18637	18730	80	and	and	CC
18637	18730	81	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	18730	82	of	of	IN
18637	18730	83	fellow	fellow	NN
18637	18730	84	-	-	HYPH
18637	18730	85	servants	servant	NNS
18637	18730	86	,	,	,
18637	18730	87	nor	nor	CC
18637	18730	88	in	in	IN
18637	18730	89	depriving	deprive	VBG
18637	18730	90	the	the	DT
18637	18730	91	employee	employee	NN
18637	18730	92	,	,	,
18637	18730	93	or	or	CC
18637	18730	94	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18730	95	dependents	dependent	NNS
18637	18730	96	,	,	,
18637	18730	97	of	of	IN
18637	18730	98	the	the	DT
18637	18730	99	higher	high	JJR
18637	18730	100	damages	damage	NNS
18637	18730	101	which	which	WDT
18637	18730	102	,	,	,
18637	18730	103	in	in	IN
18637	18730	104	some	some	DT
18637	18730	105	cases	case	NNS
18637	18730	106	,	,	,
18637	18730	107	might	may	MD
18637	18730	108	be	be	VB
18637	18730	109	rendered	render	VBN
18637	18730	110	under	under	IN
18637	18730	111	these	these	DT
18637	18730	112	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	18730	113	.	.	.
18637	18731	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18731	2	147	147	CD
18637	18731	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18731	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	18731	5	,	,	,
18637	18731	6	an	an	DT
18637	18731	7	act	act	NN
18637	18731	8	which	which	WDT
18637	18731	9	allowed	allow	VBD
18637	18731	10	an	an	DT
18637	18731	11	injured	injure	VBN
18637	18731	12	employee	employee	NN
18637	18731	13	an	an	DT
18637	18731	14	election	election	NN
18637	18731	15	of	of	IN
18637	18731	16	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	18731	17	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	18731	18	restricted	restricted	JJ
18637	18731	19	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	18731	20	under	under	IN
18637	18731	21	a	a	DT
18637	18731	22	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18731	23	law	law	NN
18637	18731	24	although	although	IN
18637	18731	25	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	18731	26	of	of	IN
18637	18731	27	contributory	contributory	JJ
18637	18731	28	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	18731	29	,	,	,
18637	18731	30	and	and	CC
18637	18731	31	full	full	JJ
18637	18731	32	compensatory	compensatory	JJ
18637	18731	33	damages	damage	NNS
18637	18731	34	under	under	IN
18637	18731	35	the	the	DT
18637	18731	36	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	18731	37	'	'	POS
18637	18731	38	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	18731	39	Act	Act	NNP
18637	18731	40	did	do	VBD
18637	18731	41	not	not	RB
18637	18731	42	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	18731	43	an	an	DT
18637	18731	44	employer	employer	NN
18637	18731	45	of	of	IN
18637	18731	46	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18731	47	property	property	NN
18637	18731	48	without	without	IN
18637	18731	49	due	due	JJ
18637	18731	50	process	process	NN
18637	18731	51	of	of	IN
18637	18731	52	law	law	NN
18637	18731	53	.	.	.
18637	18732	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18732	2	148	148	CD
18637	18732	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18732	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18732	5	,	,	,
18637	18732	6	an	an	DT
18637	18732	7	elective	elective	JJ
18637	18732	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	18732	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	18732	10	been	be	VBN
18637	18732	11	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18732	12	which	which	WDT
18637	18732	13	provided	provide	VBN
18637	18732	14	that	that	IN
18637	18732	15	,	,	,
18637	18732	16	in	in	IN
18637	18732	17	actions	action	NNS
18637	18732	18	against	against	IN
18637	18732	19	employers	employer	NNS
18637	18732	20	rejecting	reject	VBG
18637	18732	21	the	the	DT
18637	18732	22	system	system	NN
18637	18732	23	,	,	,
18637	18732	24	the	the	DT
18637	18732	25	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	18732	26	should	should	MD
18637	18732	27	be	be	VB
18637	18732	28	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	18732	29	to	to	TO
18637	18732	30	have	have	VB
18637	18732	31	resulted	result	VBN
18637	18732	32	directly	directly	RB
18637	18732	33	from	from	IN
18637	18732	34	the	the	DT
18637	18732	35	employer	employer	NN
18637	18732	36	's	's	POS
18637	18732	37	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	18732	38	and	and	CC
18637	18732	39	the	the	DT
18637	18732	40	burden	burden	NN
18637	18732	41	of	of	IN
18637	18732	42	rebutting	rebut	VBG
18637	18732	43	said	say	VBD
18637	18732	44	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	18732	45	shall	shall	MD
18637	18732	46	rest	rest	VB
18637	18732	47	upon	upon	IN
18637	18732	48	the	the	DT
18637	18732	49	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18732	50	.	.	.
18637	18733	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18733	2	149	149	CD
18637	18733	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18733	4	Contracts	contract	NNS
18637	18733	5	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	18733	6	liability	liability	NN
18637	18733	7	for	for	IN
18637	18733	8	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	18733	9	,	,	,
18637	18733	10	consummated	consummate	VBN
18637	18733	11	in	in	IN
18637	18733	12	advance	advance	NN
18637	18733	13	of	of	IN
18637	18733	14	the	the	DT
18637	18733	15	injury	injury	NN
18637	18733	16	received	receive	VBN
18637	18733	17	,	,	,
18637	18733	18	may	may	MD
18637	18733	19	be	be	VB
18637	18733	20	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	18733	21	by	by	IN
18637	18733	22	the	the	DT
18637	18733	23	State	State	NNP
18637	18733	24	,	,	,
18637	18733	25	which	which	WDT
18637	18733	26	may	may	MD
18637	18733	27	further	further	RB
18637	18733	28	stipulate	stipulate	VB
18637	18733	29	that	that	IN
18637	18733	30	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	18733	31	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	18733	32	of	of	IN
18637	18733	33	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	18733	34	under	under	IN
18637	18733	35	such	such	JJ
18637	18733	36	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	18733	37	shall	shall	MD
18637	18733	38	not	not	RB
18637	18733	39	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	18733	40	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
18637	18733	41	of	of	IN
18637	18733	42	a	a	DT
18637	18733	43	claim	claim	NN
18637	18733	44	for	for	IN
18637	18733	45	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	18733	46	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	18733	47	sustained	sustained	JJ
18637	18733	48	.	.	.
18637	18734	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18734	2	150	150	CD
18637	18734	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18734	4	Also	also	RB
18637	18734	5	,	,	,
18637	18734	6	as	as	IN
18637	18734	7	applied	apply	VBN
18637	18734	8	to	to	IN
18637	18734	9	a	a	DT
18637	18734	10	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	18734	11	alien	alien	JJ
18637	18734	12	employee	employee	NN
18637	18734	13	hired	hire	VBN
18637	18734	14	within	within	IN
18637	18734	15	the	the	DT
18637	18734	16	State	State	NNP
18637	18734	17	but	but	CC
18637	18734	18	injured	injure	VBN
18637	18734	19	on	on	IN
18637	18734	20	the	the	DT
18637	18734	21	outside	outside	NN
18637	18734	22	,	,	,
18637	18734	23	an	an	DT
18637	18734	24	act	act	NN
18637	18734	25	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	18734	26	any	any	DT
18637	18734	27	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	18734	28	exempting	exempt	VBG
18637	18734	29	employers	employer	NNS
18637	18734	30	from	from	IN
18637	18734	31	liability	liability	NN
18637	18734	32	for	for	IN
18637	18734	33	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	18734	34	outside	outside	IN
18637	18734	35	the	the	DT
18637	18734	36	State	state	NN
18637	18734	37	has	have	VBZ
18637	18734	38	been	be	VBN
18637	18734	39	construed	construe	VBN
18637	18734	40	as	as	IN
18637	18734	41	not	not	RB
18637	18734	42	denying	deny	VBG
18637	18734	43	due	due	JJ
18637	18734	44	process	process	NN
18637	18734	45	to	to	IN
18637	18734	46	the	the	DT
18637	18734	47	employer	employer	NN
18637	18734	48	.	.	.
18637	18735	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18735	2	151	151	CD
18637	18735	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18735	4	The	the	DT
18637	18735	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	18735	6	that	that	IN
18637	18735	7	a	a	DT
18637	18735	8	State	state	NN
18637	18735	9	,	,	,
18637	18735	10	after	after	IN
18637	18735	11	having	have	VBG
18637	18735	12	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	18735	13	employers	employer	NNS
18637	18735	14	to	to	TO
18637	18735	15	cover	cover	VB
18637	18735	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18735	17	liability	liability	NN
18637	18735	18	with	with	IN
18637	18735	19	a	a	DT
18637	18735	20	private	private	JJ
18637	18735	21	insurer	insurer	NN
18637	18735	22	,	,	,
18637	18735	23	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	18735	24	withdrew	withdraw	VBD
18637	18735	25	that	that	DT
18637	18735	26	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18735	27	and	and	CC
18637	18735	28	required	require	VBD
18637	18735	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18735	30	to	to	TO
18637	18735	31	contribute	contribute	VB
18637	18735	32	to	to	IN
18637	18735	33	a	a	DT
18637	18735	34	State	State	NNP
18637	18735	35	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	18735	36	Fund	Fund	NNP
18637	18735	37	was	be	VBD
18637	18735	38	held	hold	VBN
18637	18735	39	to	to	TO
18637	18735	40	effect	effect	VB
18637	18735	41	no	no	DT
18637	18735	42	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18735	43	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18735	44	as	as	IN
18637	18735	45	applied	apply	VBN
18637	18735	46	to	to	IN
18637	18735	47	an	an	DT
18637	18735	48	employer	employer	NN
18637	18735	49	who	who	WP
18637	18735	50	had	have	VBD
18637	18735	51	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	18735	52	protection	protection	NN
18637	18735	53	from	from	IN
18637	18735	54	an	an	DT
18637	18735	55	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18735	56	company	company	NN
18637	18735	57	before	before	IN
18637	18735	58	this	this	DT
18637	18735	59	change	change	NN
18637	18735	60	went	go	VBD
18637	18735	61	into	into	IN
18637	18735	62	effect	effect	NN
18637	18735	63	.	.	.
18637	18736	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18736	2	152	152	CD
18637	18736	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18736	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	18736	5	,	,	,
18637	18736	6	as	as	RB
18637	18736	7	long	long	RB
18637	18736	8	as	as	IN
18637	18736	9	the	the	DT
18637	18736	10	right	right	NN
18637	18736	11	to	to	TO
18637	18736	12	come	come	VB
18637	18736	13	under	under	IN
18637	18736	14	a	a	DT
18637	18736	15	workmen	workmen	NN
18637	18736	16	's	's	POS
18637	18736	17	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18736	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	18736	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	18736	20	optional	optional	JJ
18637	18736	21	with	with	IN
18637	18736	22	an	an	DT
18637	18736	23	employer	employer	NN
18637	18736	24	,	,	,
18637	18736	25	the	the	DT
18637	18736	26	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18736	27	,	,	,
18637	18736	28	having	have	VBG
18637	18736	29	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	18736	30	to	to	TO
18637	18736	31	accept	accept	VB
18637	18736	32	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	18736	33	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18736	34	,	,	,
18637	18736	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	18736	36	estopped	estop	VBN
18637	18736	37	from	from	IN
18637	18736	38	attempting	attempt	VBG
18637	18736	39	to	to	TO
18637	18736	40	escape	escape	VB
18637	18736	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18736	42	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	18736	43	by	by	IN
18637	18736	44	challenging	challenge	VBG
18637	18736	45	the	the	DT
18637	18736	46	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	18736	47	of	of	IN
18637	18736	48	a	a	DT
18637	18736	49	provision	provision	NN
18637	18736	50	thereof	thereof	IN
18637	18736	51	which	which	WDT
18637	18736	52	makes	make	VBZ
18637	18736	53	the	the	DT
18637	18736	54	finding	finding	NN
18637	18736	55	of	of	IN
18637	18736	56	fact	fact	NN
18637	18736	57	of	of	IN
18637	18736	58	an	an	DT
18637	18736	59	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	18736	60	commission	commission	NN
18637	18736	61	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	18736	62	if	if	IN
18637	18736	63	supported	support	VBN
18637	18736	64	by	by	IN
18637	18736	65	any	any	DT
18637	18736	66	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18736	67	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	18736	68	of	of	IN
18637	18736	69	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18736	70	preponderance	preponderance	NN
18637	18736	71	.	.	.
18637	18737	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18737	2	153	153	CD
18637	18737	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18737	4	When	when	WRB
18637	18737	5	,	,	,
18637	18737	6	by	by	IN
18637	18737	7	the	the	DT
18637	18737	8	terms	term	NNS
18637	18737	9	of	of	IN
18637	18737	10	a	a	DT
18637	18737	11	workmen	workmen	NN
18637	18737	12	's	's	POS
18637	18737	13	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18737	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	18737	15	,	,	,
18637	18737	16	the	the	DT
18637	18737	17	wrongdoer	wrongdoer	NN
18637	18737	18	,	,	,
18637	18737	19	in	in	IN
18637	18737	20	case	case	NN
18637	18737	21	of	of	IN
18637	18737	22	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
18637	18737	23	death	death	NN
18637	18737	24	,	,	,
18637	18737	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	18737	26	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	18737	27	to	to	TO
18637	18737	28	indemnify	indemnify	VB
18637	18737	29	the	the	DT
18637	18737	30	employer	employer	NN
18637	18737	31	or	or	CC
18637	18737	32	the	the	DT
18637	18737	33	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18737	34	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18737	35	of	of	IN
18637	18737	36	the	the	DT
18637	18737	37	employer	employer	NN
18637	18737	38	of	of	IN
18637	18737	39	the	the	DT
18637	18737	40	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	18737	41	,	,	,
18637	18737	42	in	in	IN
18637	18737	43	the	the	DT
18637	18737	44	amount	amount	NN
18637	18737	45	which	which	WDT
18637	18737	46	the	the	DT
18637	18737	47	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18737	48	were	be	VBD
18637	18737	49	required	require	VBN
18637	18737	50	under	under	IN
18637	18737	51	said	say	VBN
18637	18737	52	act	act	NNP
18637	18737	53	to	to	TO
18637	18737	54	contribute	contribute	VB
18637	18737	55	into	into	IN
18637	18737	56	special	special	JJ
18637	18737	57	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18737	58	funds	fund	NNS
18637	18737	59	,	,	,
18637	18737	60	no	no	DT
18637	18737	61	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18737	62	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18737	63	of	of	IN
18637	18737	64	the	the	DT
18637	18737	65	wrongdoer	wrongdoer	NN
18637	18737	66	's	's	POS
18637	18737	67	property	property	NN
18637	18737	68	was	be	VBD
18637	18737	69	discernible	discernible	JJ
18637	18737	70	.	.	.
18637	18738	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18738	2	154	154	CD
18637	18738	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18738	4	By	by	IN
18637	18738	5	the	the	DT
18637	18738	6	same	same	JJ
18637	18738	7	course	course	NN
18637	18738	8	of	of	IN
18637	18738	9	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	18738	10	neither	neither	CC
18637	18738	11	the	the	DT
18637	18738	12	employer	employer	NN
18637	18738	13	nor	nor	CC
18637	18738	14	the	the	DT
18637	18738	15	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18738	16	was	be	VBD
18637	18738	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	18738	18	to	to	TO
18637	18738	19	have	have	VB
18637	18738	20	been	be	VBN
18637	18738	21	denied	deny	VBN
18637	18738	22	due	due	JJ
18637	18738	23	process	process	NN
18637	18738	24	by	by	IN
18637	18738	25	another	another	DT
18637	18738	26	provision	provision	NN
18637	18738	27	in	in	IN
18637	18738	28	an	an	DT
18637	18738	29	act	act	NN
18637	18738	30	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18738	31	payments	payment	NNS
18637	18738	32	by	by	IN
18637	18738	33	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18738	34	,	,	,
18637	18738	35	in	in	IN
18637	18738	36	case	case	NN
18637	18738	37	an	an	DT
18637	18738	38	injured	injure	VBN
18637	18738	39	employee	employee	NN
18637	18738	40	dies	die	VBZ
18637	18738	41	without	without	IN
18637	18738	42	dependents	dependent	NNS
18637	18738	43	,	,	,
18637	18738	44	into	into	IN
18637	18738	45	special	special	JJ
18637	18738	46	funds	fund	NNS
18637	18738	47	to	to	TO
18637	18738	48	be	be	VB
18637	18738	49	used	use	VBN
18637	18738	50	for	for	IN
18637	18738	51	vocational	vocational	JJ
18637	18738	52	rehabilitation	rehabilitation	NN
18637	18738	53	or	or	CC
18637	18738	54	disability	disability	NN
18637	18738	55	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18738	56	of	of	IN
18637	18738	57	injured	injured	JJ
18637	18738	58	workers	worker	NNS
18637	18738	59	of	of	IN
18637	18738	60	other	other	JJ
18637	18738	61	establishments	establishment	NNS
18637	18738	62	.	.	.
18637	18739	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18739	2	155	155	CD
18637	18739	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18739	4	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	18739	5	also	also	RB
18637	18739	6	need	nee	MD
18637	18739	7	not	not	RB
18637	18739	8	be	be	VB
18637	18739	9	based	base	VBN
18637	18739	10	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	18739	11	on	on	IN
18637	18739	12	loss	loss	NN
18637	18739	13	of	of	IN
18637	18739	14	earning	earn	VBG
18637	18739	15	power	power	NN
18637	18739	16	,	,	,
18637	18739	17	and	and	CC
18637	18739	18	an	an	DT
18637	18739	19	award	award	NN
18637	18739	20	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	18739	21	by	by	IN
18637	18739	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	18739	23	for	for	IN
18637	18739	24	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	18739	25	resulting	result	VBG
18637	18739	26	in	in	IN
18637	18739	27	disfigurement	disfigurement	NN
18637	18739	28	of	of	IN
18637	18739	29	the	the	DT
18637	18739	30	face	face	NN
18637	18739	31	or	or	CC
18637	18739	32	head	head	NN
18637	18739	33	,	,	,
18637	18739	34	independent	independent	JJ
18637	18739	35	of	of	IN
18637	18739	36	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18739	37	for	for	IN
18637	18739	38	inability	inability	NN
18637	18739	39	to	to	TO
18637	18739	40	work	work	VB
18637	18739	41	,	,	,
18637	18739	42	has	have	VBZ
18637	18739	43	been	be	VBN
18637	18739	44	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	18739	45	to	to	TO
18637	18739	46	be	be	VB
18637	18739	47	neither	neither	CC
18637	18739	48	an	an	DT
18637	18739	49	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18739	50	nor	nor	CC
18637	18739	51	oppressive	oppressive	JJ
18637	18739	52	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18739	53	of	of	IN
18637	18739	54	the	the	DT
18637	18739	55	police	police	NN
18637	18739	56	power	power	NN
18637	18739	57	.	.	.
18637	18740	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18740	2	156	156	CD
18637	18740	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18740	4	Collective	Collective	NNP
18637	18740	5	Bargaining.--During	Bargaining.--During	NNP
18637	18740	6	the	the	DT
18637	18740	7	1930	1930	CD
18637	18740	8	's	's	POS
18637	18740	9	,	,	,
18637	18740	10	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18740	11	,	,	,
18637	18740	12	in	in	IN
18637	18740	13	the	the	DT
18637	18740	14	sense	sense	NN
18637	18740	15	of	of	IN
18637	18740	16	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18740	17	of	of	IN
18637	18740	18	contract	contract	NN
18637	18740	19	,	,	,
18637	18740	20	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	18740	21	translated	translate	VBD
18637	18740	22	into	into	IN
18637	18740	23	what	what	WP
18637	18740	24	one	one	CD
18637	18740	25	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18740	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	18740	27	labelled	label	VBN
18637	18740	28	the	the	DT
18637	18740	29	Allgeyer	Allgeyer	NNP
18637	18740	30	-	-	HYPH
18637	18740	31	Lochner	Lochner	NNP
18637	18740	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	18740	33	Adair	Adair	NNP
18637	18740	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	18740	35	Coppage	Coppage	NNP
18637	18740	36	doctrine,[157	doctrine,[157	NNP
18637	18740	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18740	38	lost	lose	VBD
18637	18740	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18740	40	potency	potency	NN
18637	18740	41	as	as	IN
18637	18740	42	an	an	DT
18637	18740	43	obstacle	obstacle	NN
18637	18740	44	to	to	IN
18637	18740	45	the	the	DT
18637	18740	46	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18740	47	of	of	IN
18637	18740	48	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18740	49	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	18740	50	to	to	TO
18637	18740	51	enhance	enhance	VB
18637	18740	52	the	the	DT
18637	18740	53	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	18740	54	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	18740	55	of	of	IN
18637	18740	56	workers	worker	NNS
18637	18740	57	as	as	IN
18637	18740	58	against	against	IN
18637	18740	59	that	that	DT
18637	18740	60	already	already	RB
18637	18740	61	possessed	possess	VBN
18637	18740	62	by	by	IN
18637	18740	63	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18740	64	employers	employer	NNS
18637	18740	65	.	.	.
18637	18741	1	Prior	prior	RB
18637	18741	2	to	to	IN
18637	18741	3	the	the	DT
18637	18741	4	manifestation	manifestation	NN
18637	18741	5	,	,	,
18637	18741	6	in	in	IN
18637	18741	7	Senn	Senn	NNP
18637	18741	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18741	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	18741	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18741	11	Tile	Tile	NNP
18637	18741	12	Layers	Layers	NNP
18637	18741	13	Protective	Protective	NNP
18637	18741	14	Union,[158	Union,[158	NNP
18637	18741	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18741	16	decided	decide	VBD
18637	18741	17	in	in	IN
18637	18741	18	1937	1937	CD
18637	18741	19	,	,	,
18637	18741	20	of	of	IN
18637	18741	21	a	a	DT
18637	18741	22	greater	great	JJR
18637	18741	23	willingness	willingness	NN
18637	18741	24	to	to	TO
18637	18741	25	defer	defer	VB
18637	18741	26	to	to	IN
18637	18741	27	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18741	28	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18741	29	as	as	IN
18637	18741	30	to	to	IN
18637	18741	31	the	the	DT
18637	18741	32	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	18741	33	and	and	CC
18637	18741	34	need	need	NN
18637	18741	35	of	of	IN
18637	18741	36	such	such	JJ
18637	18741	37	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	18741	38	,	,	,
18637	18741	39	the	the	DT
18637	18741	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18741	41	had	have	VBD
18637	18741	42	,	,	,
18637	18741	43	on	on	IN
18637	18741	44	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	18741	45	,	,	,
18637	18741	46	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	18741	47	measures	measure	NNS
18637	18741	48	such	such	JJ
18637	18741	49	as	as	IN
18637	18741	50	one	one	CD
18637	18741	51	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18741	52	every	every	DT
18637	18741	53	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18741	54	to	to	TO
18637	18741	55	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	18741	56	,	,	,
18637	18741	57	upon	upon	IN
18637	18741	58	request	request	NN
18637	18741	59	,	,	,
18637	18741	60	to	to	IN
18637	18741	61	any	any	DT
18637	18741	62	employee	employee	NN
18637	18741	63	,	,	,
18637	18741	64	when	when	WRB
18637	18741	65	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	18741	66	or	or	CC
18637	18741	67	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	18741	68	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18741	69	service	service	NN
18637	18741	70	,	,	,
18637	18741	71	a	a	DT
18637	18741	72	letter	letter	NN
18637	18741	73	,	,	,
18637	18741	74	signed	sign	VBN
18637	18741	75	by	by	IN
18637	18741	76	the	the	DT
18637	18741	77	superintendent	superintendent	NN
18637	18741	78	or	or	CC
18637	18741	79	manager	manager	NN
18637	18741	80	,	,	,
18637	18741	81	setting	set	VBG
18637	18741	82	forth	forth	RP
18637	18741	83	the	the	DT
18637	18741	84	nature	nature	NN
18637	18741	85	and	and	CC
18637	18741	86	duration	duration	NN
18637	18741	87	of	of	IN
18637	18741	88	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18741	89	service	service	NN
18637	18741	90	to	to	IN
18637	18741	91	the	the	DT
18637	18741	92	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18741	93	and	and	CC
18637	18741	94	stating	state	VBG
18637	18741	95	truly	truly	RB
18637	18741	96	the	the	DT
18637	18741	97	cause	cause	NN
18637	18741	98	of	of	IN
18637	18741	99	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18741	100	leaving	leaving	NN
18637	18741	101	.	.	.
18637	18742	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18742	2	159	159	CD
18637	18742	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18742	4	Added	add	VBN
18637	18742	5	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	18742	6	that	that	IN
18637	18742	7	such	such	JJ
18637	18742	8	letters	letter	NNS
18637	18742	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	18742	10	be	be	VB
18637	18742	11	on	on	IN
18637	18742	12	plain	plain	JJ
18637	18742	13	paper	paper	NN
18637	18742	14	selected	select	VBN
18637	18742	15	by	by	IN
18637	18742	16	the	the	DT
18637	18742	17	employee	employee	NN
18637	18742	18	,	,	,
18637	18742	19	signed	sign	VBN
18637	18742	20	in	in	IN
18637	18742	21	ink	ink	NN
18637	18742	22	and	and	CC
18637	18742	23	sealed	sealed	JJ
18637	18742	24	,	,	,
18637	18742	25	and	and	CC
18637	18742	26	free	free	JJ
18637	18742	27	from	from	IN
18637	18742	28	superfluous	superfluous	JJ
18637	18742	29	figures	figure	NNS
18637	18742	30	,	,	,
18637	18742	31	and	and	CC
18637	18742	32	words	word	NNS
18637	18742	33	,	,	,
18637	18742	34	were	be	VBD
18637	18742	35	also	also	RB
18637	18742	36	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18742	37	as	as	IN
18637	18742	38	not	not	RB
18637	18742	39	amounting	amount	VBG
18637	18742	40	to	to	IN
18637	18742	41	any	any	DT
18637	18742	42	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18742	43	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18742	44	of	of	IN
18637	18742	45	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18742	46	and	and	CC
18637	18742	47	property	property	NN
18637	18742	48	.	.	.
18637	18743	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18743	2	160	160	CD
18637	18743	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18743	4	On	on	IN
18637	18743	5	the	the	DT
18637	18743	6	ground	ground	NN
18637	18743	7	that	that	IN
18637	18743	8	the	the	DT
18637	18743	9	right	right	NN
18637	18743	10	to	to	TO
18637	18743	11	strike	strike	VB
18637	18743	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	18743	13	not	not	RB
18637	18743	14	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	18743	15	,	,	,
18637	18743	16	the	the	DT
18637	18743	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18743	18	in	in	IN
18637	18743	19	a	a	DT
18637	18743	20	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18743	21	manner	manner	NN
18637	18743	22	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	18743	23	a	a	DT
18637	18743	24	statute	statute	NN
18637	18743	25	by	by	IN
18637	18743	26	the	the	DT
18637	18743	27	terms	term	NNS
18637	18743	28	of	of	IN
18637	18743	29	which	which	WDT
18637	18743	30	an	an	DT
18637	18743	31	officer	officer	NN
18637	18743	32	of	of	IN
18637	18743	33	a	a	DT
18637	18743	34	labor	labor	NN
18637	18743	35	union	union	NN
18637	18743	36	was	be	VBD
18637	18743	37	punished	punish	VBN
18637	18743	38	for	for	IN
18637	18743	39	having	have	VBG
18637	18743	40	ordered	order	VBN
18637	18743	41	a	a	DT
18637	18743	42	strike	strike	NN
18637	18743	43	for	for	IN
18637	18743	44	the	the	DT
18637	18743	45	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18743	46	of	of	IN
18637	18743	47	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	18743	48	a	a	DT
18637	18743	49	payment	payment	NN
18637	18743	50	to	to	IN
18637	18743	51	a	a	DT
18637	18743	52	former	former	JJ
18637	18743	53	employee	employee	NN
18637	18743	54	of	of	IN
18637	18743	55	a	a	DT
18637	18743	56	stale	stale	JJ
18637	18743	57	claim	claim	NN
18637	18743	58	for	for	IN
18637	18743	59	wages	wage	NNS
18637	18743	60	.	.	.
18637	18744	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18744	2	161	161	CD
18637	18744	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18744	4	The	the	DT
18637	18744	5	significance	significance	NN
18637	18744	6	of	of	IN
18637	18744	7	the	the	DT
18637	18744	8	case	case	NN
18637	18744	9	of	of	IN
18637	18744	10	Senn	Senn	NNP
18637	18744	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18744	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	18744	13	_	_	NNP
18637	18744	14	Tile	Tile	NNP
18637	18744	15	Layers	Layers	NNP
18637	18744	16	Protective	Protective	NNP
18637	18744	17	Union[162	union[162	CD
18637	18744	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18744	19	as	as	IN
18637	18744	20	an	an	DT
18637	18744	21	indicator	indicator	NN
18637	18744	22	of	of	IN
18637	18744	23	the	the	DT
18637	18744	24	range	range	NN
18637	18744	25	of	of	IN
18637	18744	26	the	the	DT
18637	18744	27	alteration	alteration	NN
18637	18744	28	of	of	IN
18637	18744	29	the	the	DT
18637	18744	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18744	31	's	's	POS
18637	18744	32	views	view	NNS
18637	18744	33	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	18744	34	the	the	DT
18637	18744	35	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	18744	36	of	of	IN
18637	18744	37	State	State	NNP
18637	18744	38	labor	labor	NN
18637	18744	39	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18744	40	derives	derive	VBZ
18637	18744	41	in	in	IN
18637	18744	42	part	part	NN
18637	18744	43	from	from	IN
18637	18744	44	the	the	DT
18637	18744	45	fact	fact	NN
18637	18744	46	that	that	IN
18637	18744	47	the	the	DT
18637	18744	48	statute	statute	NN
18637	18744	49	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	18744	50	therein	therein	RB
18637	18744	51	was	be	VBD
18637	18744	52	not	not	RB
18637	18744	53	appreciably	appreciably	RB
18637	18744	54	different	different	JJ
18637	18744	55	from	from	IN
18637	18744	56	that	that	DT
18637	18744	57	voided	void	VBD
18637	18744	58	in	in	IN
18637	18744	59	Truax	Truax	NNP
18637	18744	60	_	_	NNP
18637	18744	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	18744	62	_	_	NNP
18637	18744	63	Corrigan	Corrigan	NNP
18637	18744	64	.	.	.
18637	18745	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18745	2	163	163	CD
18637	18745	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18745	4	Both	both	DT
18637	18745	5	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18745	6	were	be	VBD
18637	18745	7	alike	alike	RB
18637	18745	8	in	in	IN
18637	18745	9	that	that	IN
18637	18745	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18745	11	withheld	withhold	VBD
18637	18745	12	the	the	DT
18637	18745	13	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	18745	14	of	of	IN
18637	18745	15	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	18745	16	;	;	:
18637	18745	17	but	but	CC
18637	18745	18	by	by	IN
18637	18745	19	reason	reason	NN
18637	18745	20	of	of	IN
18637	18745	21	the	the	DT
18637	18745	22	fact	fact	NN
18637	18745	23	that	that	IN
18637	18745	24	the	the	DT
18637	18745	25	invalidated	invalidated	JJ
18637	18745	26	act	act	NN
18637	18745	27	did	do	VBD
18637	18745	28	not	not	RB
18637	18745	29	contain	contain	VB
18637	18745	30	the	the	DT
18637	18745	31	more	more	RBR
18637	18745	32	liberal	liberal	JJ
18637	18745	33	and	and	CC
18637	18745	34	also	also	RB
18637	18745	35	more	more	RBR
18637	18745	36	precise	precise	JJ
18637	18745	37	definition	definition	NN
18637	18745	38	of	of	IN
18637	18745	39	a	a	DT
18637	18745	40	labor	labor	NN
18637	18745	41	dispute	dispute	NN
18637	18745	42	set	set	VBN
18637	18745	43	forth	forth	RP
18637	18745	44	in	in	IN
18637	18745	45	the	the	DT
18637	18745	46	later	later	JJ
18637	18745	47	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	18745	48	and	and	CC
18637	18745	49	,	,	,
18637	18745	50	above	above	IN
18637	18745	51	all	all	DT
18637	18745	52	,	,	,
18637	18745	53	did	do	VBD
18637	18745	54	not	not	RB
18637	18745	55	affirmatively	affirmatively	RB
18637	18745	56	purport	purport	VB
18637	18745	57	to	to	IN
18637	18745	58	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	18745	59	peaceful	peaceful	JJ
18637	18745	60	picketing	picketing	NN
18637	18745	61	only	only	RB
18637	18745	62	,	,	,
18637	18745	63	the	the	DT
18637	18745	64	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18745	65	was	be	VBD
18637	18745	66	enabled	enable	VBN
18637	18745	67	to	to	TO
18637	18745	68	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	18745	69	that	that	IN
18637	18745	70	Truax	Truax	NNP
18637	18745	71	_	_	NNP
18637	18745	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	18745	73	_	_	NNP
18637	18745	74	Corrigan	Corrigan	NNP
18637	18745	75	,	,	,
18637	18745	76	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	18745	77	as	as	IN
18637	18745	78	"	"	``
18637	18745	79	the	the	DT
18637	18745	80	statute	statute	NN
18637	18745	81	there	there	RB
18637	18745	82	in	in	IN
18637	18745	83	question	question	NN
18637	18745	84	was	be	VBD
18637	18745	85	*	*	NFP
18637	18745	86	*	*	NFP
18637	18745	87	*	*	NFP
18637	18745	88	applied	apply	VBD
18637	18745	89	to	to	TO
18637	18745	90	legalize	legalize	VB
18637	18745	91	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	18745	92	which	which	WDT
18637	18745	93	was	be	VBD
18637	18745	94	not	not	RB
18637	18745	95	simply	simply	RB
18637	18745	96	peaceful	peaceful	JJ
18637	18745	97	picketing	picketing	NN
18637	18745	98	,	,	,
18637	18745	99	"	"	``
18637	18745	100	was	be	VBD
18637	18745	101	distinguishable	distinguishable	JJ
18637	18745	102	.	.	.
18637	18746	1	Specifically	specifically	RB
18637	18746	2	,	,	,
18637	18746	3	the	the	DT
18637	18746	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18746	5	in	in	IN
18637	18746	6	the	the	DT
18637	18746	7	Senn	Senn	NNP
18637	18746	8	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18746	9	gave	give	VBD
18637	18746	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18746	11	approval	approval	NN
18637	18746	12	to	to	IN
18637	18746	13	the	the	DT
18637	18746	14	application	application	NN
18637	18746	15	of	of	IN
18637	18746	16	a	a	DT
18637	18746	17	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	18746	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	18746	19	which	which	WDT
18637	18746	20	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	18746	21	the	the	DT
18637	18746	22	giving	giving	NN
18637	18746	23	of	of	IN
18637	18746	24	publicity	publicity	NN
18637	18746	25	to	to	IN
18637	18746	26	labor	labor	NN
18637	18746	27	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	18746	28	,	,	,
18637	18746	29	declared	declare	VBD
18637	18746	30	peaceful	peaceful	JJ
18637	18746	31	picketing	picketing	NN
18637	18746	32	and	and	CC
18637	18746	33	patrolling	patrol	VBG
18637	18746	34	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	18746	35	,	,	,
18637	18746	36	and	and	CC
18637	18746	37	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	18746	38	the	the	DT
18637	18746	39	granting	granting	NN
18637	18746	40	of	of	IN
18637	18746	41	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	18746	42	against	against	IN
18637	18746	43	such	such	JJ
18637	18746	44	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	18746	45	to	to	IN
18637	18746	46	a	a	DT
18637	18746	47	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	18746	48	in	in	IN
18637	18746	49	which	which	WDT
18637	18746	50	the	the	DT
18637	18746	51	matter	matter	NN
18637	18746	52	at	at	IN
18637	18746	53	issue	issue	NN
18637	18746	54	was	be	VBD
18637	18746	55	the	the	DT
18637	18746	56	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	18746	57	of	of	IN
18637	18746	58	a	a	DT
18637	18746	59	tiling	tile	VBG
18637	18746	60	contractor	contractor	NN
18637	18746	61	employing	employ	VBG
18637	18746	62	nonunion	nonunion	NN
18637	18746	63	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	18746	64	to	to	TO
18637	18746	65	sign	sign	VB
18637	18746	66	a	a	DT
18637	18746	67	closed	close	VBN
18637	18746	68	shop	shop	NN
18637	18746	69	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	18746	70	unless	unless	IN
18637	18746	71	a	a	DT
18637	18746	72	provision	provision	NN
18637	18746	73	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18746	74	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18746	75	to	to	TO
18637	18746	76	abstain	abstain	VB
18637	18746	77	from	from	IN
18637	18746	78	working	work	VBG
18637	18746	79	in	in	IN
18637	18746	80	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18746	81	business	business	NN
18637	18746	82	as	as	IN
18637	18746	83	a	a	DT
18637	18746	84	tile	tile	NN
18637	18746	85	layer	layer	NN
18637	18746	86	or	or	CC
18637	18746	87	helper	helper	NN
18637	18746	88	should	should	MD
18637	18746	89	be	be	VB
18637	18746	90	eliminated	eliminate	VBN
18637	18746	91	.	.	.
18637	18747	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	18747	2	as	as	IN
18637	18747	3	the	the	DT
18637	18747	4	enhancement	enhancement	NN
18637	18747	5	of	of	IN
18637	18747	6	job	job	NN
18637	18747	7	opportunities	opportunity	NNS
18637	18747	8	for	for	IN
18637	18747	9	members	member	NNS
18637	18747	10	of	of	IN
18637	18747	11	the	the	DT
18637	18747	12	union	union	NN
18637	18747	13	was	be	VBD
18637	18747	14	a	a	DT
18637	18747	15	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	18747	16	objective	objective	NN
18637	18747	17	,	,	,
18637	18747	18	the	the	DT
18637	18747	19	State	state	NN
18637	18747	20	was	be	VBD
18637	18747	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	18747	22	competent	competent	JJ
18637	18747	23	to	to	TO
18637	18747	24	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	18747	25	the	the	DT
18637	18747	26	fostering	fostering	NN
18637	18747	27	of	of	IN
18637	18747	28	that	that	DT
18637	18747	29	end	end	NN
18637	18747	30	by	by	IN
18637	18747	31	peaceful	peaceful	JJ
18637	18747	32	picketing	picketing	NN
18637	18747	33	,	,	,
18637	18747	34	and	and	CC
18637	18747	35	the	the	DT
18637	18747	36	fact	fact	NN
18637	18747	37	that	that	IN
18637	18747	38	the	the	DT
18637	18747	39	sustaining	sustaining	NN
18637	18747	40	of	of	IN
18637	18747	41	the	the	DT
18637	18747	42	union	union	NN
18637	18747	43	in	in	IN
18637	18747	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18747	45	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	18747	46	at	at	IN
18637	18747	47	peaceful	peaceful	JJ
18637	18747	48	persuasion	persuasion	NN
18637	18747	49	might	may	MD
18637	18747	50	have	have	VB
18637	18747	51	the	the	DT
18637	18747	52	effect	effect	NN
18637	18747	53	of	of	IN
18637	18747	54	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	18747	55	Senn	Senn	NNP
18637	18747	56	from	from	IN
18637	18747	57	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	18747	58	in	in	IN
18637	18747	59	business	business	NN
18637	18747	60	as	as	IN
18637	18747	61	an	an	DT
18637	18747	62	independent	independent	JJ
18637	18747	63	entrepreneur	entrepreneur	NN
18637	18747	64	was	be	VBD
18637	18747	65	declared	declare	VBN
18637	18747	66	to	to	TO
18637	18747	67	present	present	VB
18637	18747	68	an	an	DT
18637	18747	69	issue	issue	NN
18637	18747	70	of	of	IN
18637	18747	71	public	public	JJ
18637	18747	72	policy	policy	NN
18637	18747	73	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	18747	74	for	for	IN
18637	18747	75	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18747	76	determination	determination	NN
18637	18747	77	.	.	.
18637	18748	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18748	2	164	164	CD
18637	18748	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18748	4	The	the	DT
18637	18748	5	policy	policy	NN
18637	18748	6	of	of	IN
18637	18748	7	many	many	JJ
18637	18748	8	State	State	NNP
18637	18748	9	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	18748	10	in	in	IN
18637	18748	11	recent	recent	JJ
18637	18748	12	years	year	NNS
18637	18748	13	,	,	,
18637	18748	14	however	however	RB
18637	18748	15	,	,	,
18637	18748	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	18748	17	been	be	VBN
18637	18748	18	to	to	TO
18637	18748	19	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	18748	20	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18748	21	designed	design	VBN
18637	18748	22	to	to	TO
18637	18748	23	control	control	VB
18637	18748	24	the	the	DT
18637	18748	25	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	18748	26	of	of	IN
18637	18748	27	the	the	DT
18637	18748	28	enormous	enormous	JJ
18637	18748	29	economic	economic	JJ
18637	18748	30	power	power	NN
18637	18748	31	which	which	WDT
18637	18748	32	previously	previously	RB
18637	18748	33	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	18748	34	protective	protective	JJ
18637	18748	35	measures	measure	NNS
18637	18748	36	enabled	enable	VBD
18637	18748	37	labor	labor	NN
18637	18748	38	unions	union	NNS
18637	18748	39	to	to	IN
18637	18748	40	amass	amass	VB
18637	18748	41	;	;	:
18637	18748	42	and	and	CC
18637	18748	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18748	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	18748	45	the	the	DT
18637	18748	46	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	18748	47	of	of	IN
18637	18748	48	such	such	JJ
18637	18748	49	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	18748	50	measures	measure	NNS
18637	18748	51	that	that	WDT
18637	18748	52	has	have	VBZ
18637	18748	53	lately	lately	RB
18637	18748	54	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	18748	55	the	the	DT
18637	18748	56	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18748	57	.	.	.
18637	18749	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18749	2	,	,	,
18637	18749	3	in	in	IN
18637	18749	4	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	18749	5	Mail	Mail	NNP
18637	18749	6	Association	Association	NNP
18637	18749	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18749	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	18749	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18749	10	Corsi,[165	Corsi,[165	NNP
18637	18749	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18749	12	section	section	NN
18637	18749	13	43	43	CD
18637	18749	14	of	of	IN
18637	18749	15	New	New	NNP
18637	18749	16	York	York	NNP
18637	18749	17	's	's	POS
18637	18749	18	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	18749	19	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	18749	20	Law	Law	NNP
18637	18749	21	which	which	WDT
18637	18749	22	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	18749	23	a	a	DT
18637	18749	24	labor	labor	NN
18637	18749	25	organization	organization	NN
18637	18749	26	to	to	TO
18637	18749	27	deny	deny	VB
18637	18749	28	any	any	DT
18637	18749	29	person	person	NN
18637	18749	30	membership	membership	NN
18637	18749	31	by	by	IN
18637	18749	32	reason	reason	NN
18637	18749	33	of	of	IN
18637	18749	34	race	race	NN
18637	18749	35	,	,	,
18637	18749	36	color	color	NN
18637	18749	37	,	,	,
18637	18749	38	or	or	CC
18637	18749	39	creed	creed	NN
18637	18749	40	,	,	,
18637	18749	41	or	or	CC
18637	18749	42	to	to	TO
18637	18749	43	deny	deny	VB
18637	18749	44	any	any	DT
18637	18749	45	member	member	NN
18637	18749	46	,	,	,
18637	18749	47	on	on	IN
18637	18749	48	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18749	49	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	18749	50	,	,	,
18637	18749	51	equal	equal	JJ
18637	18749	52	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	18749	53	in	in	IN
18637	18749	54	designation	designation	NN
18637	18749	55	for	for	IN
18637	18749	56	employment	employment	NN
18637	18749	57	,	,	,
18637	18749	58	promotion	promotion	NN
18637	18749	59	,	,	,
18637	18749	60	or	or	CC
18637	18749	61	dismissal	dismissal	NN
18637	18749	62	by	by	IN
18637	18749	63	an	an	DT
18637	18749	64	employer	employer	NN
18637	18749	65	was	be	VBD
18637	18749	66	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18749	67	,	,	,
18637	18749	68	when	when	WRB
18637	18749	69	applied	apply	VBN
18637	18749	70	to	to	IN
18637	18749	71	an	an	DT
18637	18749	72	organization	organization	NN
18637	18749	73	of	of	IN
18637	18749	74	railway	railway	NN
18637	18749	75	mail	mail	NN
18637	18749	76	clerks	clerk	NNS
18637	18749	77	,	,	,
18637	18749	78	as	as	IN
18637	18749	79	not	not	RB
18637	18749	80	interfering	interfere	VBG
18637	18749	81	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	18749	82	with	with	IN
18637	18749	83	the	the	DT
18637	18749	84	latter	latter	NN
18637	18749	85	's	's	POS
18637	18749	86	right	right	NN
18637	18749	87	to	to	TO
18637	18749	88	choose	choose	VB
18637	18749	89	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18749	90	members	member	NNS
18637	18749	91	nor	nor	CC
18637	18749	92	abridging	abridge	VBG
18637	18749	93	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18749	94	property	property	NN
18637	18749	95	rights	right	NNS
18637	18749	96	,	,	,
18637	18749	97	or	or	CC
18637	18749	98	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18749	99	of	of	IN
18637	18749	100	contract	contract	NN
18637	18749	101	.	.	.
18637	18750	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	18750	2	as	as	IN
18637	18750	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18750	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	18750	5	"	"	``
18637	18750	6	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18750	7	out	out	RP
18637	18750	8	to	to	TO
18637	18750	9	represent	represent	VB
18637	18750	10	the	the	DT
18637	18750	11	general	general	JJ
18637	18750	12	business	business	NN
18637	18750	13	needs	need	NNS
18637	18750	14	of	of	IN
18637	18750	15	employees	employee	NNS
18637	18750	16	"	"	''
18637	18750	17	and	and	CC
18637	18750	18	functioned	function	VBD
18637	18750	19	"	"	``
18637	18750	20	under	under	IN
18637	18750	21	the	the	DT
18637	18750	22	protection	protection	NN
18637	18750	23	of	of	IN
18637	18750	24	the	the	DT
18637	18750	25	State	State	NNP
18637	18750	26	,	,	,
18637	18750	27	"	"	''
18637	18750	28	the	the	DT
18637	18750	29	union	union	NN
18637	18750	30	was	be	VBD
18637	18750	31	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	18750	32	to	to	TO
18637	18750	33	have	have	VB
18637	18750	34	forfeited	forfeit	VBN
18637	18750	35	the	the	DT
18637	18750	36	right	right	NN
18637	18750	37	to	to	TO
18637	18750	38	claim	claim	VB
18637	18750	39	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	18750	40	from	from	IN
18637	18750	41	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18750	42	protecting	protect	VBG
18637	18750	43	workers	worker	NNS
18637	18750	44	against	against	IN
18637	18750	45	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	18750	46	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	18750	47	.	.	.
18637	18751	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18751	2	166	166	CD
18637	18751	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18751	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18751	5	approved	approve	VBN
18637	18751	6	as	as	IN
18637	18751	7	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18751	8	in	in	IN
18637	18751	9	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	18751	10	Union	Union	NNP
18637	18751	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18751	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	18751	13	_	_	NNP
18637	18751	14	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	18751	15	Co.[167	Co.[167	NNP
18637	18751	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18751	17	and	and	CC
18637	18751	18	American	American	NNP
18637	18751	19	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	18751	20	of	of	IN
18637	18751	21	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	18751	22	_	_	NNP
18637	18751	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	18751	24	_	_	NNP
18637	18751	25	American	American	NNP
18637	18751	26	Sash	Sash	NNP
18637	18751	27	Co.[168	Co.[168	NNP
18637	18751	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18751	29	were	be	VBD
18637	18751	30	State	state	NN
18637	18751	31	laws	law	NNS
18637	18751	32	outlawing	outlaw	VBG
18637	18751	33	the	the	DT
18637	18751	34	closed	closed	JJ
18637	18751	35	shop	shop	NN
18637	18751	36	;	;	:
18637	18751	37	and	and	CC
18637	18751	38	when	when	WRB
18637	18751	39	labor	labor	NN
18637	18751	40	unions	union	NNS
18637	18751	41	invoked	invoke	VBD
18637	18751	42	in	in	IN
18637	18751	43	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18751	44	own	own	JJ
18637	18751	45	defense	defense	NN
18637	18751	46	the	the	DT
18637	18751	47	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18751	48	of	of	IN
18637	18751	49	contract	contract	NN
18637	18751	50	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	18751	51	that	that	WDT
18637	18751	52	hitherto	hitherto	NNP
18637	18751	53	had	have	VBD
18637	18751	54	been	be	VBN
18637	18751	55	employed	employ	VBN
18637	18751	56	to	to	TO
18637	18751	57	nullify	nullify	VB
18637	18751	58	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18751	59	intended	intend	VBN
18637	18751	60	for	for	IN
18637	18751	61	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18751	62	protection	protection	NN
18637	18751	63	,	,	,
18637	18751	64	the	the	DT
18637	18751	65	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18751	66	,	,	,
18637	18751	67	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	18751	68	through	through	IN
18637	18751	69	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18751	70	Black	Black	NNP
18637	18751	71	announced	announce	VBD
18637	18751	72	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18751	73	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	18751	74	"	"	''
18637	18751	75	to	to	TO
18637	18751	76	return	return	VB
18637	18751	77	,	,	,
18637	18751	78	*	*	NFP
18637	18751	79	*	*	NFP
18637	18751	80	*	*	NFP
18637	18751	81	to	to	IN
18637	18751	82	*	*	NFP
18637	18751	83	*	*	NFP
18637	18751	84	*	*	NFP
18637	18751	85	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18751	86	a	a	DT
18637	18751	87	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18751	88	due	due	JJ
18637	18751	89	process	process	NN
18637	18751	90	philosophy	philosophy	NN
18637	18751	91	that	that	WDT
18637	18751	92	has	have	VBZ
18637	18751	93	been	be	VBN
18637	18751	94	deliberately	deliberately	RB
18637	18751	95	discarded	discard	VBN
18637	18751	96	.	.	.
18637	18752	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18752	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18752	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18752	4	The	the	DT
18637	18752	5	due	due	JJ
18637	18752	6	process	process	NN
18637	18752	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	18752	8	,	,	,
18637	18752	9	"	"	''
18637	18752	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18752	11	maintained	maintain	VBD
18637	18752	12	,	,	,
18637	18752	13	does	do	VBZ
18637	18752	14	not	not	RB
18637	18752	15	"	"	``
18637	18752	16	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	18752	17	a	a	DT
18637	18752	18	State	state	NN
18637	18752	19	to	to	TO
18637	18752	20	pass	pass	VB
18637	18752	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	18752	22	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	18752	23	designed	design	VBN
18637	18752	24	to	to	TO
18637	18752	25	safeguard	safeguard	VB
18637	18752	26	the	the	DT
18637	18752	27	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	18752	28	of	of	IN
18637	18752	29	nonunion	nonunion	NN
18637	18752	30	workers	worker	NNS
18637	18752	31	to	to	TO
18637	18752	32	get	get	VB
18637	18752	33	and	and	CC
18637	18752	34	hold	hold	VB
18637	18752	35	jobs	job	NNS
18637	18752	36	,	,	,
18637	18752	37	free	free	JJ
18637	18752	38	from	from	IN
18637	18752	39	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	18752	40	against	against	IN
18637	18752	41	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18752	42	because	because	IN
18637	18752	43	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18752	44	are	be	VBP
18637	18752	45	nonunion	nonunion	NN
18637	18752	46	workers	worker	NNS
18637	18752	47	.	.	.
18637	18753	1	"	"	``
18637	18753	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18753	3	169	169	CD
18637	18753	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18753	5	Also	also	RB
18637	18753	6	in	in	IN
18637	18753	7	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	18753	8	with	with	IN
18637	18753	9	the	the	DT
18637	18753	10	last	last	JJ
18637	18753	11	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	18753	12	pair	pair	NN
18637	18753	13	of	of	IN
18637	18753	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	18753	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	18753	16	Auto	Auto	NNP
18637	18753	17	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	18753	18	_	_	NNP
18637	18753	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	18753	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18753	21	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	18753	22	Board[170	Board[170	NNP
18637	18753	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18753	24	in	in	IN
18637	18753	25	which	which	WDT
18637	18753	26	was	be	VBD
18637	18753	27	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	18753	28	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18753	29	of	of	IN
18637	18753	30	the	the	DT
18637	18753	31	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	18753	32	Employment	Employment	NNP
18637	18753	33	Peace	Peace	NNP
18637	18753	34	Act	Act	NNP
18637	18753	35	which	which	WDT
18637	18753	36	proscribed	proscribe	VBD
18637	18753	37	as	as	IN
18637	18753	38	an	an	DT
18637	18753	39	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	18753	40	labor	labor	NN
18637	18753	41	practice	practice	NN
18637	18753	42	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	18753	43	of	of	IN
18637	18753	44	a	a	DT
18637	18753	45	union	union	NN
18637	18753	46	,	,	,
18637	18753	47	after	after	IN
18637	18753	48	collective	collective	JJ
18637	18753	49	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	18753	50	negotiations	negotiation	NNS
18637	18753	51	had	have	VBD
18637	18753	52	become	become	VBN
18637	18753	53	deadlocked	deadlocked	JJ
18637	18753	54	,	,	,
18637	18753	55	to	to	TO
18637	18753	56	coerce	coerce	VB
18637	18753	57	an	an	DT
18637	18753	58	employer	employer	NN
18637	18753	59	through	through	IN
18637	18753	60	a	a	DT
18637	18753	61	"	"	``
18637	18753	62	slow	slow	RB
18637	18753	63	-	-	HYPH
18637	18753	64	down	down	NN
18637	18753	65	"	"	''
18637	18753	66	in	in	IN
18637	18753	67	production	production	NN
18637	18753	68	achieved	achieve	VBN
18637	18753	69	by	by	IN
18637	18753	70	the	the	DT
18637	18753	71	irregular	irregular	NN
18637	18753	72	,	,	,
18637	18753	73	but	but	CC
18637	18753	74	frequent	frequent	JJ
18637	18753	75	,	,	,
18637	18753	76	calling	call	VBG
18637	18753	77	of	of	IN
18637	18753	78	union	union	NN
18637	18753	79	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	18753	80	during	during	IN
18637	18753	81	working	work	VBG
18637	18753	82	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18753	83	without	without	IN
18637	18753	84	advance	advance	NN
18637	18753	85	notice	notice	NN
18637	18753	86	to	to	IN
18637	18753	87	the	the	DT
18637	18753	88	employer	employer	NN
18637	18753	89	or	or	CC
18637	18753	90	notice	notice	VB
18637	18753	91	as	as	IN
18637	18753	92	to	to	IN
18637	18753	93	whether	whether	IN
18637	18753	94	or	or	CC
18637	18753	95	when	when	WRB
18637	18753	96	the	the	DT
18637	18753	97	employees	employee	NNS
18637	18753	98	would	would	MD
18637	18753	99	return	return	VB
18637	18753	100	,	,	,
18637	18753	101	and	and	CC
18637	18753	102	without	without	IN
18637	18753	103	informing	inform	VBG
18637	18753	104	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18753	105	of	of	IN
18637	18753	106	the	the	DT
18637	18753	107	specific	specific	JJ
18637	18753	108	terms	term	NNS
18637	18753	109	sought	seek	VBN
18637	18753	110	by	by	IN
18637	18753	111	such	such	JJ
18637	18753	112	tactics	tactic	NNS
18637	18753	113	.	.	.
18637	18754	1	"	"	``
18637	18754	2	No	no	DT
18637	18754	3	one	one	NN
18637	18754	4	,	,	,
18637	18754	5	"	"	''
18637	18754	6	declared	declare	VBD
18637	18754	7	the	the	DT
18637	18754	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18754	9	,	,	,
18637	18754	10	can	can	MD
18637	18754	11	question	question	VB
18637	18754	12	"	"	``
18637	18754	13	the	the	DT
18637	18754	14	State	State	NNP
18637	18754	15	's	's	POS
18637	18754	16	power	power	NN
18637	18754	17	to	to	TO
18637	18754	18	police	police	NN
18637	18754	19	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	18754	20	by	by	IN
18637	18754	21	*	*	NFP
18637	18754	22	*	*	NFP
18637	18754	23	*	*	NFP
18637	18754	24	methods	method	NNS
18637	18754	25	"	"	''
18637	18754	26	which	which	WDT
18637	18754	27	involve	involve	VBP
18637	18754	28	"	"	``
18637	18754	29	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	18754	30	injury	injury	NN
18637	18754	31	to	to	IN
18637	18754	32	property	property	NN
18637	18754	33	and	and	CC
18637	18754	34	intimidation	intimidation	NN
18637	18754	35	of	of	IN
18637	18754	36	other	other	JJ
18637	18754	37	employees	employee	NNS
18637	18754	38	by	by	IN
18637	18754	39	threats	threat	NNS
18637	18754	40	.	.	.
18637	18755	1	"	"	``
18637	18755	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18755	3	171	171	CD
18637	18755	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18755	5	Finally	finally	RB
18637	18755	6	,	,	,
18637	18755	7	in	in	IN
18637	18755	8	Giboney	Giboney	NNP
18637	18755	9	_	_	NNP
18637	18755	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	18755	11	_	_	NNP
18637	18755	12	Empire	Empire	NNP
18637	18755	13	Storage	Storage	NNP
18637	18755	14	Co	Co	NNP
18637	18755	15	.	.	.
18637	18755	16	,[172	,[172	NFP
18637	18755	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18755	18	the	the	DT
18637	18755	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18755	20	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBD
18637	18755	21	that	that	IN
18637	18755	22	no	no	DT
18637	18755	23	violation	violation	NN
18637	18755	24	of	of	IN
18637	18755	25	the	the	DT
18637	18755	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18755	27	results	result	VBZ
18637	18755	28	when	when	WRB
18637	18755	29	a	a	DT
18637	18755	30	State	State	NNP
18637	18755	31	law	law	NN
18637	18755	32	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	18755	33	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	18755	34	in	in	IN
18637	18755	35	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18755	36	of	of	IN
18637	18755	37	trade	trade	NN
18637	18755	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	18755	39	construed	construe	VBN
18637	18755	40	by	by	IN
18637	18755	41	State	State	NNP
18637	18755	42	courts	court	NNS
18637	18755	43	as	as	IN
18637	18755	44	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	18755	45	members	member	NNS
18637	18755	46	of	of	IN
18637	18755	47	a	a	DT
18637	18755	48	union	union	NN
18637	18755	49	of	of	IN
18637	18755	50	ice	ice	NN
18637	18755	51	peddlers	peddler	NNS
18637	18755	52	from	from	IN
18637	18755	53	peacefully	peacefully	RB
18637	18755	54	picketing	picket	VBG
18637	18755	55	a	a	DT
18637	18755	56	wholesale	wholesale	JJ
18637	18755	57	ice	ice	NN
18637	18755	58	distributor	distributor	NN
18637	18755	59	's	's	POS
18637	18755	60	place	place	NN
18637	18755	61	of	of	IN
18637	18755	62	business	business	NN
18637	18755	63	for	for	IN
18637	18755	64	the	the	DT
18637	18755	65	sole	sole	JJ
18637	18755	66	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18755	67	of	of	IN
18637	18755	68	inducing	induce	VBG
18637	18755	69	the	the	DT
18637	18755	70	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18755	71	not	not	RB
18637	18755	72	to	to	TO
18637	18755	73	sell	sell	VB
18637	18755	74	to	to	IN
18637	18755	75	nonunion	nonunion	NN
18637	18755	76	peddlers	peddler	NNS
18637	18755	77	.	.	.
18637	18756	1	REGULATION	regulation	NN
18637	18756	2	OF	of	IN
18637	18756	3	CHARGES	charge	NNS
18637	18756	4	;	;	:
18637	18756	5	"	"	``
18637	18756	6	BUSINESSES	business	NNS
18637	18756	7	AFFECTED	affect	VBD
18637	18756	8	WITH	with	IN
18637	18756	9	A	a	DT
18637	18756	10	PUBLIC	public	JJ
18637	18756	11	INTEREST	interest	NN
18637	18756	12	"	"	``
18637	18756	13	History	history	NN
18637	18756	14	In	in	IN
18637	18756	15	endeavoring	endeavor	VBG
18637	18756	16	to	to	TO
18637	18756	17	measure	measure	VB
18637	18756	18	the	the	DT
18637	18756	19	impact	impact	NN
18637	18756	20	of	of	IN
18637	18756	21	the	the	DT
18637	18756	22	due	due	JJ
18637	18756	23	process	process	NN
18637	18756	24	clause	clause	NN
18637	18756	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	18756	26	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	18756	27	by	by	IN
18637	18756	28	the	the	DT
18637	18756	29	States	States	NNPS
18637	18756	30	to	to	TO
18637	18756	31	control	control	VB
18637	18756	32	the	the	DT
18637	18756	33	charges	charge	NNS
18637	18756	34	exacted	exact	VBN
18637	18756	35	by	by	IN
18637	18756	36	various	various	JJ
18637	18756	37	businesses	business	NNS
18637	18756	38	for	for	IN
18637	18756	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18756	40	services	service	NNS
18637	18756	41	,	,	,
18637	18756	42	the	the	DT
18637	18756	43	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	18756	44	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18756	45	,	,	,
18637	18756	46	almost	almost	RB
18637	18756	47	from	from	IN
18637	18756	48	the	the	DT
18637	18756	49	inception	inception	NN
18637	18756	50	of	of	IN
18637	18756	51	the	the	DT
18637	18756	52	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18756	53	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18756	54	,	,	,
18637	18756	55	has	have	VBZ
18637	18756	56	devoted	devote	VBN
18637	18756	57	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18756	58	to	to	IN
18637	18756	59	the	the	DT
18637	18756	60	examination	examination	NN
18637	18756	61	of	of	IN
18637	18756	62	two	two	CD
18637	18756	63	questions	question	NNS
18637	18756	64	:	:	:
18637	18756	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18756	66	1	1	LS
18637	18756	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18756	68	whether	whether	IN
18637	18756	69	that	that	DT
18637	18756	70	clause	clause	NN
18637	18756	71	precluded	preclude	VBD
18637	18756	72	that	that	DT
18637	18756	73	kind	kind	NN
18637	18756	74	of	of	IN
18637	18756	75	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18756	76	of	of	IN
18637	18756	77	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18756	78	types	type	NNS
18637	18756	79	of	of	IN
18637	18756	80	business	business	NN
18637	18756	81	,	,	,
18637	18756	82	and	and	CC
18637	18756	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18756	84	2	2	LS
18637	18756	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18756	86	the	the	DT
18637	18756	87	nature	nature	NN
18637	18756	88	of	of	IN
18637	18756	89	the	the	DT
18637	18756	90	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18756	91	,	,	,
18637	18756	92	if	if	IN
18637	18756	93	any	any	DT
18637	18756	94	,	,	,
18637	18756	95	which	which	WDT
18637	18756	96	this	this	DT
18637	18756	97	clause	clause	NN
18637	18756	98	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	18756	99	on	on	IN
18637	18756	100	State	state	NN
18637	18756	101	control	control	NN
18637	18756	102	of	of	IN
18637	18756	103	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18756	104	in	in	IN
18637	18756	105	the	the	DT
18637	18756	106	case	case	NN
18637	18756	107	of	of	IN
18637	18756	108	businesses	business	NNS
18637	18756	109	as	as	IN
18637	18756	110	to	to	IN
18637	18756	111	which	which	WDT
18637	18756	112	such	such	JJ
18637	18756	113	control	control	NN
18637	18756	114	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	18756	115	.	.	.
18637	18757	1	For	for	IN
18637	18757	2	a	a	DT
18637	18757	3	brief	brief	JJ
18637	18757	4	interval	interval	NN
18637	18757	5	following	follow	VBG
18637	18757	6	the	the	DT
18637	18757	7	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	18757	8	of	of	IN
18637	18757	9	the	the	DT
18637	18757	10	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18757	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18757	12	,	,	,
18637	18757	13	the	the	DT
18637	18757	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	18757	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18757	16	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	18757	17	to	to	TO
18637	18757	18	have	have	VB
18637	18757	19	underestimated	underestimate	VBN
18637	18757	20	the	the	DT
18637	18757	21	significance	significance	NN
18637	18757	22	of	of	IN
18637	18757	23	this	this	DT
18637	18757	24	clause	clause	NN
18637	18757	25	as	as	IN
18637	18757	26	a	a	DT
18637	18757	27	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	18757	28	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18757	29	on	on	IN
18637	18757	30	the	the	DT
18637	18757	31	power	power	NN
18637	18757	32	of	of	IN
18637	18757	33	States	States	NNPS
18637	18757	34	to	to	TO
18637	18757	35	fix	fix	VB
18637	18757	36	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18757	37	chargeable	chargeable	VB
18637	18757	38	by	by	IN
18637	18757	39	an	an	DT
18637	18757	40	industry	industry	NN
18637	18757	41	deemed	deem	VBD
18637	18757	42	appropriately	appropriately	RB
18637	18757	43	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18757	44	to	to	IN
18637	18757	45	such	such	JJ
18637	18757	46	controls	control	NNS
18637	18757	47	.	.	.
18637	18758	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18758	2	,	,	,
18637	18758	3	in	in	IN
18637	18758	4	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	18758	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18758	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18758	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18758	8	Illinois,[173	Illinois,[173	NNP
18637	18758	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18758	10	the	the	DT
18637	18758	11	first	first	JJ
18637	18758	12	of	of	IN
18637	18758	13	the	the	DT
18637	18758	14	"	"	``
18637	18758	15	Granger	Granger	NNP
18637	18758	16	"	"	''
18637	18758	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	18758	18	,	,	,
18637	18758	19	in	in	IN
18637	18758	20	which	which	WDT
18637	18758	21	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	18758	22	charges	charge	NNS
18637	18758	23	established	establish	VBN
18637	18758	24	by	by	IN
18637	18758	25	a	a	DT
18637	18758	26	State	State	NNP
18637	18758	27	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18758	28	for	for	IN
18637	18758	29	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	18758	30	grain	grain	NN
18637	18758	31	elevator	elevator	NN
18637	18758	32	companies	company	NNS
18637	18758	33	were	be	VBD
18637	18758	34	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	18758	35	,	,	,
18637	18758	36	not	not	RB
18637	18758	37	as	as	IN
18637	18758	38	being	be	VBG
18637	18758	39	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	18758	40	in	in	IN
18637	18758	41	character	character	NN
18637	18758	42	,	,	,
18637	18758	43	but	but	CC
18637	18758	44	rather	rather	RB
18637	18758	45	as	as	IN
18637	18758	46	a	a	DT
18637	18758	47	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18758	48	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	18758	49	the	the	DT
18637	18758	50	power	power	NN
18637	18758	51	of	of	IN
18637	18758	52	any	any	DT
18637	18758	53	State	State	NNP
18637	18758	54	agency	agency	NN
18637	18758	55	to	to	TO
18637	18758	56	impose	impose	VB
18637	18758	57	,	,	,
18637	18758	58	the	the	DT
18637	18758	59	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18758	60	,	,	,
18637	18758	61	in	in	IN
18637	18758	62	an	an	DT
18637	18758	63	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	18758	64	that	that	WDT
18637	18758	65	was	be	VBD
18637	18758	66	largely	largely	RB
18637	18758	67	an	an	DT
18637	18758	68	_	_	NNP
18637	18758	69	obiter	obiter	NN
18637	18758	70	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	18758	71	_	_	NNP
18637	18758	72	,	,	,
18637	18758	73	declared	declare	VBD
18637	18758	74	that	that	IN
18637	18758	75	the	the	DT
18637	18758	76	due	due	JJ
18637	18758	77	process	process	NN
18637	18758	78	clause	clause	NN
18637	18758	79	did	do	VBD
18637	18758	80	not	not	RB
18637	18758	81	operate	operate	VB
18637	18758	82	as	as	IN
18637	18758	83	a	a	DT
18637	18758	84	safeguard	safeguard	NN
18637	18758	85	against	against	IN
18637	18758	86	oppressive	oppressive	JJ
18637	18758	87	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18758	88	,	,	,
18637	18758	89	that	that	IN
18637	18758	90	if	if	IN
18637	18758	91	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18758	92	was	be	VBD
18637	18758	93	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	18758	94	,	,	,
18637	18758	95	the	the	DT
18637	18758	96	severity	severity	NN
18637	18758	97	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18758	98	was	be	VBD
18637	18758	99	within	within	IN
18637	18758	100	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18758	101	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	18758	102	and	and	CC
18637	18758	103	could	could	MD
18637	18758	104	be	be	VB
18637	18758	105	ameliorated	ameliorate	VBN
18637	18758	106	only	only	RB
18637	18758	107	by	by	IN
18637	18758	108	resort	resort	NN
18637	18758	109	to	to	IN
18637	18758	110	the	the	DT
18637	18758	111	polls	poll	NNS
18637	18758	112	.	.	.
18637	18759	1	Not	not	RB
18637	18759	2	much	much	JJ
18637	18759	3	time	time	NN
18637	18759	4	was	be	VBD
18637	18759	5	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	18759	6	to	to	TO
18637	18759	7	elapse	elapse	VB
18637	18759	8	,	,	,
18637	18759	9	however	however	RB
18637	18759	10	,	,	,
18637	18759	11	before	before	IN
18637	18759	12	the	the	DT
18637	18759	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18759	14	effected	effect	VBD
18637	18759	15	a	a	DT
18637	18759	16	complete	complete	JJ
18637	18759	17	withdrawal	withdrawal	NN
18637	18759	18	from	from	IN
18637	18759	19	this	this	DT
18637	18759	20	position	position	NN
18637	18759	21	;	;	:
18637	18759	22	and	and	CC
18637	18759	23	by	by	IN
18637	18759	24	1890[174	1890[174	CD
18637	18759	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18759	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18759	27	had	have	VBD
18637	18759	28	fully	fully	RB
18637	18759	29	converted	convert	VBN
18637	18759	30	the	the	DT
18637	18759	31	due	due	JJ
18637	18759	32	process	process	NN
18637	18759	33	clause	clause	NN
18637	18759	34	into	into	IN
18637	18759	35	a	a	DT
18637	18759	36	positive	positive	JJ
18637	18759	37	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	18759	38	which	which	WDT
18637	18759	39	the	the	DT
18637	18759	40	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18759	41	branch	branch	NN
18637	18759	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	18759	43	duty	duty	NN
18637	18759	44	bound	bind	VBN
18637	18759	45	to	to	TO
18637	18759	46	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	18759	47	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	18759	48	State	state	NN
18637	18759	49	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	18759	50	seek	seek	VBP
18637	18759	51	to	to	TO
18637	18759	52	impose	impose	VB
18637	18759	53	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18759	54	which	which	WDT
18637	18759	55	,	,	,
18637	18759	56	in	in	IN
18637	18759	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18759	58	estimation	estimation	NN
18637	18759	59	,	,	,
18637	18759	60	are	be	VBP
18637	18759	61	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18759	62	or	or	CC
18637	18759	63	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18759	64	.	.	.
18637	18760	1	In	in	IN
18637	18760	2	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	18760	3	to	to	IN
18637	18760	4	the	the	DT
18637	18760	5	speed	speed	NN
18637	18760	6	with	with	IN
18637	18760	7	which	which	WDT
18637	18760	8	the	the	DT
18637	18760	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18760	10	arrived	arrive	VBD
18637	18760	11	at	at	IN
18637	18760	12	those	those	DT
18637	18760	13	above	above	IN
18637	18760	14	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	18760	15	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
18637	18760	16	,	,	,
18637	18760	17	more	more	JJR
18637	18760	18	than	than	IN
18637	18760	19	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	18760	20	years	year	NNS
18637	18760	21	were	be	VBD
18637	18760	22	to	to	TO
18637	18760	23	elapse	elapse	VB
18637	18760	24	before	before	IN
18637	18760	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18760	26	developed	develop	VBD
18637	18760	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18760	28	currently	currently	RB
18637	18760	29	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	18760	30	formula	formula	NN
18637	18760	31	for	for	IN
18637	18760	32	determining	determine	VBG
18637	18760	33	the	the	DT
18637	18760	34	propriety	propriety	NN
18637	18760	35	of	of	IN
18637	18760	36	subjecting	subject	VBG
18637	18760	37	specific	specific	JJ
18637	18760	38	businesses	business	NNS
18637	18760	39	to	to	IN
18637	18760	40	State	state	NN
18637	18760	41	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18760	42	of	of	IN
18637	18760	43	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18760	44	prices	price	NNS
18637	18760	45	or	or	CC
18637	18760	46	charges	charge	NNS
18637	18760	47	.	.	.
18637	18761	1	Prior	prior	RB
18637	18761	2	to	to	IN
18637	18761	3	1934	1934	CD
18637	18761	4	,	,	,
18637	18761	5	unless	unless	IN
18637	18761	6	a	a	DT
18637	18761	7	business	business	NN
18637	18761	8	were	be	VBD
18637	18761	9	"	"	``
18637	18761	10	affected	affect	VBN
18637	18761	11	with	with	IN
18637	18761	12	a	a	DT
18637	18761	13	public	public	JJ
18637	18761	14	interest	interest	NN
18637	18761	15	,	,	,
18637	18761	16	"	"	''
18637	18761	17	control	control	NN
18637	18761	18	of	of	IN
18637	18761	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18761	20	prices	price	NNS
18637	18761	21	,	,	,
18637	18761	22	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18761	23	,	,	,
18637	18761	24	or	or	CC
18637	18761	25	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	18761	26	of	of	IN
18637	18761	27	service	service	NN
18637	18761	28	was	be	VBD
18637	18761	29	viewed	view	VBN
18637	18761	30	as	as	IN
18637	18761	31	an	an	DT
18637	18761	32	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18761	33	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18761	34	of	of	IN
18637	18761	35	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18761	36	and	and	CC
18637	18761	37	property	property	NN
18637	18761	38	without	without	IN
18637	18761	39	due	due	JJ
18637	18761	40	process	process	NN
18637	18761	41	of	of	IN
18637	18761	42	law	law	NN
18637	18761	43	.	.	.
18637	18762	1	During	during	IN
18637	18762	2	the	the	DT
18637	18762	3	period	period	NN
18637	18762	4	of	of	IN
18637	18762	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18762	6	application	application	NN
18637	18762	7	,	,	,
18637	18762	8	however	however	RB
18637	18762	9	,	,	,
18637	18762	10	this	this	DT
18637	18762	11	standard	standard	NN
18637	18762	12	,	,	,
18637	18762	13	"	"	''
18637	18762	14	business	business	NN
18637	18762	15	affected	affect	VBN
18637	18762	16	with	with	IN
18637	18762	17	a	a	DT
18637	18762	18	public	public	JJ
18637	18762	19	interest	interest	NN
18637	18762	20	,	,	,
18637	18762	21	"	"	''
18637	18762	22	never	never	RB
18637	18762	23	acquired	acquire	VBD
18637	18762	24	any	any	DT
18637	18762	25	precise	precise	JJ
18637	18762	26	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	18762	27	;	;	:
18637	18762	28	and	and	CC
18637	18762	29	as	as	IN
18637	18762	30	a	a	DT
18637	18762	31	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	18762	32	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
18637	18762	33	were	be	VBD
18637	18762	34	never	never	RB
18637	18762	35	able	able	JJ
18637	18762	36	to	to	TO
18637	18762	37	identify	identify	VB
18637	18762	38	all	all	PDT
18637	18762	39	those	those	DT
18637	18762	40	qualities	quality	NNS
18637	18762	41	or	or	CC
18637	18762	42	attributes	attribute	NNS
18637	18762	43	which	which	WDT
18637	18762	44	invariably	invariably	RB
18637	18762	45	distinguished	distinguish	VBD
18637	18762	46	a	a	DT
18637	18762	47	business	business	NN
18637	18762	48	so	so	RB
18637	18762	49	affected	affect	VBN
18637	18762	50	from	from	IN
18637	18762	51	one	one	CD
18637	18762	52	not	not	RB
18637	18762	53	so	so	RB
18637	18762	54	affected	affected	JJ
18637	18762	55	.	.	.
18637	18763	1	The	the	DT
18637	18763	2	best	good	JJS
18637	18763	3	the	the	DT
18637	18763	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18763	5	ever	ever	RB
18637	18763	6	offered	offer	VBN
18637	18763	7	by	by	IN
18637	18763	8	way	way	NN
18637	18763	9	of	of	IN
18637	18763	10	enlightenment	enlightenment	NN
18637	18763	11	was	be	VBD
18637	18763	12	the	the	DT
18637	18763	13	following	follow	VBG
18637	18763	14	classification	classification	NN
18637	18763	15	of	of	IN
18637	18763	16	businesses	business	NNS
18637	18763	17	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18763	18	to	to	IN
18637	18763	19	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18763	20	,	,	,
18637	18763	21	prepared	prepare	VBN
18637	18763	22	by	by	IN
18637	18763	23	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	18763	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18763	25	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	18763	26	.	.	.
18637	18764	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18764	2	175	175	CD
18637	18764	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18764	4	These	these	DT
18637	18764	5	were	be	VBD
18637	18764	6	said	say	VBN
18637	18764	7	to	to	TO
18637	18764	8	comprise	comprise	VB
18637	18764	9	:	:	:
18637	18764	10	"	"	''
18637	18764	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18764	12	1	1	LS
18637	18764	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18764	14	Those	those	DT
18637	18764	15	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18764	16	businesses	business	NNS
18637	18764	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18764	18	which	which	WDT
18637	18764	19	are	be	VBP
18637	18764	20	carried	carry	VBN
18637	18764	21	on	on	RP
18637	18764	22	under	under	IN
18637	18764	23	the	the	DT
18637	18764	24	authority	authority	NN
18637	18764	25	of	of	IN
18637	18764	26	a	a	DT
18637	18764	27	public	public	JJ
18637	18764	28	grant	grant	NN
18637	18764	29	of	of	IN
18637	18764	30	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18764	31	which	which	WDT
18637	18764	32	either	either	CC
18637	18764	33	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	18764	34	or	or	CC
18637	18764	35	impliedly	impliedly	RB
18637	18764	36	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	18764	37	the	the	DT
18637	18764	38	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	18764	39	duty	duty	NN
18637	18764	40	of	of	IN
18637	18764	41	rendering	render	VBG
18637	18764	42	a	a	DT
18637	18764	43	public	public	JJ
18637	18764	44	service	service	NN
18637	18764	45	demanded	demand	VBN
18637	18764	46	by	by	IN
18637	18764	47	any	any	DT
18637	18764	48	member	member	NN
18637	18764	49	of	of	IN
18637	18764	50	the	the	DT
18637	18764	51	public	public	NN
18637	18764	52	.	.	.
18637	18765	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	18765	2	are	be	VBP
18637	18765	3	the	the	DT
18637	18765	4	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	18765	5	,	,	,
18637	18765	6	other	other	JJ
18637	18765	7	common	common	JJ
18637	18765	8	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	18765	9	and	and	CC
18637	18765	10	public	public	JJ
18637	18765	11	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	18765	12	.	.	.
18637	18766	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18766	2	2	2	LS
18637	18766	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18766	4	Certain	certain	JJ
18637	18766	5	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	18766	6	,	,	,
18637	18766	7	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	18766	8	as	as	IN
18637	18766	9	exceptional	exceptional	JJ
18637	18766	10	,	,	,
18637	18766	11	the	the	DT
18637	18766	12	public	public	JJ
18637	18766	13	interest	interest	NN
18637	18766	14	attaching	attach	VBG
18637	18766	15	to	to	IN
18637	18766	16	which	which	WDT
18637	18766	17	,	,	,
18637	18766	18	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	18766	19	from	from	IN
18637	18766	20	earliest	early	JJS
18637	18766	21	times	time	NNS
18637	18766	22	,	,	,
18637	18766	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	18766	24	survived	survive	VBN
18637	18766	25	the	the	DT
18637	18766	26	period	period	NN
18637	18766	27	of	of	IN
18637	18766	28	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18766	29	laws	law	NNS
18637	18766	30	by	by	IN
18637	18766	31	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
18637	18766	32	or	or	CC
18637	18766	33	Colonial	colonial	JJ
18637	18766	34	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	18766	35	for	for	IN
18637	18766	36	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	18766	37	all	all	DT
18637	18766	38	trades	trade	NNS
18637	18766	39	and	and	CC
18637	18766	40	callings	calling	NNS
18637	18766	41	.	.	.
18637	18767	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	18767	2	are	be	VBP
18637	18767	3	those	those	DT
18637	18767	4	of	of	IN
18637	18767	5	the	the	DT
18637	18767	6	keepers	keeper	NNS
18637	18767	7	of	of	IN
18637	18767	8	inns	inn	NNS
18637	18767	9	,	,	,
18637	18767	10	cabs	cab	NNS
18637	18767	11	and	and	CC
18637	18767	12	grist	grist	NN
18637	18767	13	mills	mill	NNS
18637	18767	14	.	.	.
18637	18768	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18768	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18768	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18768	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18768	5	3	3	LS
18637	18768	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18768	7	Businesses	business	NNS
18637	18768	8	which	which	WDT
18637	18768	9	though	though	IN
18637	18768	10	not	not	RB
18637	18768	11	public	public	JJ
18637	18768	12	at	at	IN
18637	18768	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18768	14	inception	inception	NN
18637	18768	15	may	may	MD
18637	18768	16	be	be	VB
18637	18768	17	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	18768	18	said	say	VBN
18637	18768	19	to	to	TO
18637	18768	20	have	have	VB
18637	18768	21	risen	rise	VBN
18637	18768	22	to	to	TO
18637	18768	23	be	be	VB
18637	18768	24	such	such	JJ
18637	18768	25	and	and	CC
18637	18768	26	have	have	VBP
18637	18768	27	become	become	VBN
18637	18768	28	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18768	29	in	in	IN
18637	18768	30	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	18768	31	to	to	IN
18637	18768	32	some	some	DT
18637	18768	33	government	government	NN
18637	18768	34	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18768	35	.	.	.
18637	18769	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18769	2	have	have	VBP
18637	18769	3	come	come	VBN
18637	18769	4	to	to	TO
18637	18769	5	hold	hold	VB
18637	18769	6	such	such	PDT
18637	18769	7	a	a	DT
18637	18769	8	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	18769	9	relation	relation	NN
18637	18769	10	to	to	IN
18637	18769	11	the	the	DT
18637	18769	12	public	public	NN
18637	18769	13	that	that	IN
18637	18769	14	this	this	DT
18637	18769	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	18769	16	superimposed	superimpose	VBN
18637	18769	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	18769	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18769	19	.	.	.
18637	18770	1	In	in	IN
18637	18770	2	the	the	DT
18637	18770	3	language	language	NN
18637	18770	4	of	of	IN
18637	18770	5	the	the	DT
18637	18770	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	18770	7	,	,	,
18637	18770	8	the	the	DT
18637	18770	9	owner	owner	NN
18637	18770	10	by	by	IN
18637	18770	11	devoting	devote	VBG
18637	18770	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18770	13	business	business	NN
18637	18770	14	to	to	IN
18637	18770	15	the	the	DT
18637	18770	16	public	public	JJ
18637	18770	17	use	use	NN
18637	18770	18	,	,	,
18637	18770	19	in	in	IN
18637	18770	20	effect	effect	NN
18637	18770	21	grants	grant	VBZ
18637	18770	22	the	the	DT
18637	18770	23	public	public	NN
18637	18770	24	an	an	DT
18637	18770	25	interest	interest	NN
18637	18770	26	in	in	IN
18637	18770	27	that	that	DT
18637	18770	28	use	use	NN
18637	18770	29	and	and	CC
18637	18770	30	subjects	subject	VBZ
18637	18770	31	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18770	32	to	to	IN
18637	18770	33	public	public	JJ
18637	18770	34	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18770	35	to	to	IN
18637	18770	36	the	the	DT
18637	18770	37	extent	extent	NN
18637	18770	38	of	of	IN
18637	18770	39	that	that	DT
18637	18770	40	interest	interest	NN
18637	18770	41	although	although	IN
18637	18770	42	the	the	DT
18637	18770	43	property	property	NN
18637	18770	44	continues	continue	VBZ
18637	18770	45	to	to	TO
18637	18770	46	belong	belong	VB
18637	18770	47	to	to	IN
18637	18770	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18770	49	private	private	JJ
18637	18770	50	owner	owner	NN
18637	18770	51	and	and	CC
18637	18770	52	to	to	TO
18637	18770	53	be	be	VB
18637	18770	54	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	18770	55	to	to	IN
18637	18770	56	protection	protection	NN
18637	18770	57	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	18770	58	.	.	.
18637	18770	59	"	"	''
18637	18771	1	Through	through	IN
18637	18771	2	application	application	NN
18637	18771	3	of	of	IN
18637	18771	4	this	this	DT
18637	18771	5	now	now	RB
18637	18771	6	outmoded	outmode	VBN
18637	18771	7	formula	formula	NN
18637	18771	8	the	the	DT
18637	18771	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18771	10	found	find	VBD
18637	18771	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18771	12	possible	possible	JJ
18637	18771	13	to	to	TO
18637	18771	14	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	18771	15	State	state	NN
18637	18771	16	laws	law	NNS
18637	18771	17	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	18771	18	charges	charge	NNS
18637	18771	19	made	make	VBN
18637	18771	20	by	by	IN
18637	18771	21	grain	grain	NN
18637	18771	22	elevators,[176	elevators,[176	NN
18637	18771	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18771	24	stockyards,[177	stockyards,[177	NN
18637	18771	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18771	26	and	and	CC
18637	18771	27	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	18771	28	warehouses,[178	warehouses,[178	NNS
18637	18771	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18771	30	and	and	CC
18637	18771	31	fire	fire	NN
18637	18771	32	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18771	33	rates[179	rates[179	NN
18637	18771	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18771	35	and	and	CC
18637	18771	36	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	18771	37	paid	pay	VBN
18637	18771	38	to	to	IN
18637	18771	39	fire	fire	NN
18637	18771	40	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18771	41	agents	agent	NNS
18637	18771	42	.	.	.
18637	18772	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18772	2	180	180	CD
18637	18772	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18772	4	Voided	voided	JJ
18637	18772	5	,	,	,
18637	18772	6	because	because	IN
18637	18772	7	the	the	DT
18637	18772	8	businesses	business	NNS
18637	18772	9	sought	seek	VBD
18637	18772	10	to	to	TO
18637	18772	11	be	be	VB
18637	18772	12	controlled	control	VBN
18637	18772	13	were	be	VBD
18637	18772	14	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	18772	15	to	to	TO
18637	18772	16	be	be	VB
18637	18772	17	not	not	RB
18637	18772	18	so	so	RB
18637	18772	19	affected	affected	JJ
18637	18772	20	,	,	,
18637	18772	21	were	be	VBD
18637	18772	22	State	state	NN
18637	18772	23	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18772	24	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	18772	25	the	the	DT
18637	18772	26	price	price	NN
18637	18772	27	at	at	IN
18637	18772	28	which	which	WDT
18637	18772	29	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	18772	30	may	may	MD
18637	18772	31	be	be	VB
18637	18772	32	sold,[181	sold,[181	NN
18637	18772	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18772	34	or	or	CC
18637	18772	35	at	at	IN
18637	18772	36	which	which	WDT
18637	18772	37	ticket	ticket	NN
18637	18772	38	brokers	broker	NNS
18637	18772	39	may	may	MD
18637	18772	40	resell	resell	VB
18637	18772	41	tickets	ticket	NNS
18637	18772	42	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	18772	43	from	from	IN
18637	18772	44	theatres,[182	theatres,[182	NN
18637	18772	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18772	46	and	and	CC
18637	18772	47	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	18772	48	competition	competition	NN
18637	18772	49	in	in	IN
18637	18772	50	the	the	DT
18637	18772	51	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	18772	52	and	and	CC
18637	18772	53	sale	sale	NN
18637	18772	54	of	of	IN
18637	18772	55	ice	ice	NN
18637	18772	56	through	through	IN
18637	18772	57	the	the	DT
18637	18772	58	withholding	withholding	NN
18637	18772	59	of	of	IN
18637	18772	60	licenses	license	NNS
18637	18772	61	to	to	TO
18637	18772	62	engage	engage	VB
18637	18772	63	therein	therein	RB
18637	18772	64	.	.	.
18637	18773	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18773	2	183	183	CD
18637	18773	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18773	4	Nebbia	Nebbia	NNP
18637	18773	5	_	_	NNP
18637	18773	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	18773	7	_	_	NNP
18637	18773	8	New	New	NNP
18637	18773	9	York	York	NNP
18637	18773	10	In	in	IN
18637	18773	11	upholding	upholding	NN
18637	18773	12	,	,	,
18637	18773	13	by	by	IN
18637	18773	14	a	a	DT
18637	18773	15	vote	vote	NN
18637	18773	16	of	of	IN
18637	18773	17	five	five	CD
18637	18773	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	18773	19	to	to	IN
18637	18773	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	18773	21	four	four	CD
18637	18773	22	,	,	,
18637	18773	23	a	a	DT
18637	18773	24	depression	depression	NN
18637	18773	25	induced	induce	VBN
18637	18773	26	New	New	NNP
18637	18773	27	York	York	NNP
18637	18773	28	statute	statute	NN
18637	18773	29	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	18773	30	prices	price	NNS
18637	18773	31	at	at	IN
18637	18773	32	which	which	WDT
18637	18773	33	fluid	fluid	JJ
18637	18773	34	milk	milk	NN
18637	18773	35	might	may	MD
18637	18773	36	be	be	VB
18637	18773	37	sold	sell	VBN
18637	18773	38	,	,	,
18637	18773	39	the	the	DT
18637	18773	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18773	41	,	,	,
18637	18773	42	in	in	IN
18637	18773	43	1934	1934	CD
18637	18773	44	,	,	,
18637	18773	45	finally	finally	RB
18637	18773	46	shelved	shelve	VBD
18637	18773	47	the	the	DT
18637	18773	48	concept	concept	NN
18637	18773	49	of	of	IN
18637	18773	50	"	"	``
18637	18773	51	a	a	DT
18637	18773	52	business	business	NN
18637	18773	53	affected	affect	VBN
18637	18773	54	with	with	IN
18637	18773	55	a	a	DT
18637	18773	56	public	public	JJ
18637	18773	57	interest	interest	NN
18637	18773	58	.	.	.
18637	18774	1	"	"	``
18637	18774	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18774	3	184	184	CD
18637	18774	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18774	5	Older	old	JJR
18637	18774	6	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	18774	7	,	,	,
18637	18774	8	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	18774	9	as	as	IN
18637	18774	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18774	11	negatived	negative	VBD
18637	18774	12	a	a	DT
18637	18774	13	power	power	NN
18637	18774	14	to	to	TO
18637	18774	15	control	control	VB
18637	18774	16	prices	price	NNS
18637	18774	17	in	in	IN
18637	18774	18	businesses	business	NNS
18637	18774	19	found	find	VBD
18637	18774	20	not	not	RB
18637	18774	21	"	"	``
18637	18774	22	to	to	TO
18637	18774	23	be	be	VB
18637	18774	24	clothed	clothe	VBN
18637	18774	25	with	with	IN
18637	18774	26	a	a	DT
18637	18774	27	public	public	JJ
18637	18774	28	use	use	NN
18637	18774	29	"	"	''
18637	18774	30	were	be	VBD
18637	18774	31	now	now	RB
18637	18774	32	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	18774	33	as	as	IN
18637	18774	34	resting	rest	VBG
18637	18774	35	,	,	,
18637	18774	36	"	"	``
18637	18774	37	finally	finally	RB
18637	18774	38	,	,	,
18637	18774	39	upon	upon	IN
18637	18774	40	the	the	DT
18637	18774	41	basis	basis	NN
18637	18774	42	that	that	WDT
18637	18774	43	the	the	DT
18637	18774	44	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	18774	45	of	of	IN
18637	18774	46	due	due	JJ
18637	18774	47	process	process	NN
18637	18774	48	were	be	VBD
18637	18774	49	not	not	RB
18637	18774	50	met	meet	VBN
18637	18774	51	because	because	IN
18637	18774	52	the	the	DT
18637	18774	53	laws	law	NNS
18637	18774	54	were	be	VBD
18637	18774	55	found	find	VBN
18637	18774	56	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18774	57	in	in	IN
18637	18774	58	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18774	59	operation	operation	NN
18637	18774	60	and	and	CC
18637	18774	61	effect	effect	NN
18637	18774	62	.	.	.
18637	18775	1	Price	price	NN
18637	18775	2	control	control	NN
18637	18775	3	,	,	,
18637	18775	4	like	like	IN
18637	18775	5	any	any	DT
18637	18775	6	other	other	JJ
18637	18775	7	form	form	NN
18637	18775	8	of	of	IN
18637	18775	9	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18775	10	,	,	,
18637	18775	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	18775	12	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18775	13	now	now	RB
18637	18775	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18775	15	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18775	16	only	only	RB
18637	18775	17	if	if	IN
18637	18775	18	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18775	19	,	,	,
18637	18775	20	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	18775	21	,	,	,
18637	18775	22	or	or	CC
18637	18775	23	demonstrably	demonstrably	RB
18637	18775	24	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
18637	18775	25	to	to	IN
18637	18775	26	the	the	DT
18637	18775	27	policy	policy	NN
18637	18775	28	the	the	DT
18637	18775	29	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18775	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	18775	31	free	free	JJ
18637	18775	32	to	to	TO
18637	18775	33	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	18775	34	,	,	,
18637	18775	35	and	and	CC
18637	18775	36	hence	hence	RB
18637	18775	37	an	an	DT
18637	18775	38	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	18775	39	and	and	CC
18637	18775	40	unwarranted	unwarranted	JJ
18637	18775	41	interference	interference	NN
18637	18775	42	with	with	IN
18637	18775	43	individual	individual	JJ
18637	18775	44	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18775	45	.	.	.
18637	18775	46	"	"	''
18637	18776	1	Conceding	concede	VBG
18637	18776	2	that	that	IN
18637	18776	3	"	"	``
18637	18776	4	the	the	DT
18637	18776	5	dairy	dairy	NN
18637	18776	6	industry	industry	NN
18637	18776	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	18776	8	not	not	RB
18637	18776	9	,	,	,
18637	18776	10	in	in	IN
18637	18776	11	the	the	DT
18637	18776	12	accepted	accepted	JJ
18637	18776	13	sense	sense	NN
18637	18776	14	of	of	IN
18637	18776	15	the	the	DT
18637	18776	16	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	18776	17	,	,	,
18637	18776	18	a	a	DT
18637	18776	19	public	public	JJ
18637	18776	20	utility	utility	NN
18637	18776	21	"	"	''
18637	18776	22	;	;	:
18637	18776	23	that	that	RB
18637	18776	24	is	is	RB
18637	18776	25	,	,	,
18637	18776	26	a	a	DT
18637	18776	27	"	"	``
18637	18776	28	business	business	NN
18637	18776	29	affected	affect	VBN
18637	18776	30	with	with	IN
18637	18776	31	a	a	DT
18637	18776	32	public	public	JJ
18637	18776	33	interest	interest	NN
18637	18776	34	,	,	,
18637	18776	35	"	"	''
18637	18776	36	the	the	DT
18637	18776	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18776	38	in	in	IN
18637	18776	39	effect	effect	NN
18637	18776	40	declared	declare	VBD
18637	18776	41	that	that	DT
18637	18776	42	price	price	NN
18637	18776	43	control	control	NN
18637	18776	44	henceforth	henceforth	RB
18637	18776	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	18776	46	to	to	TO
18637	18776	47	be	be	VB
18637	18776	48	viewed	view	VBN
18637	18776	49	merely	merely	RB
18637	18776	50	as	as	IN
18637	18776	51	an	an	DT
18637	18776	52	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18776	53	by	by	IN
18637	18776	54	the	the	DT
18637	18776	55	State	State	NNP
18637	18776	56	of	of	IN
18637	18776	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18776	58	police	police	NN
18637	18776	59	power	power	NN
18637	18776	60	,	,	,
18637	18776	61	and	and	CC
18637	18776	62	as	as	IN
18637	18776	63	such	such	JJ
18637	18776	64	is	be	VBZ
18637	18776	65	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18776	66	only	only	RB
18637	18776	67	to	to	IN
18637	18776	68	the	the	DT
18637	18776	69	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	18776	70	which	which	WDT
18637	18776	71	due	due	JJ
18637	18776	72	process	process	NN
18637	18776	73	of	of	IN
18637	18776	74	law	law	NN
18637	18776	75	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	18776	76	on	on	IN
18637	18776	77	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18776	78	interference	interference	NN
18637	18776	79	with	with	IN
18637	18776	80	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18776	81	and	and	CC
18637	18776	82	property	property	NN
18637	18776	83	.	.	.
18637	18777	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	18777	2	was	be	VBD
18637	18777	3	the	the	DT
18637	18777	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18777	5	disturbed	disturb	VBN
18637	18777	6	by	by	IN
18637	18777	7	the	the	DT
18637	18777	8	fact	fact	NN
18637	18777	9	that	that	IN
18637	18777	10	a	a	DT
18637	18777	11	"	"	``
18637	18777	12	scientific	scientific	JJ
18637	18777	13	validity	validity	NN
18637	18777	14	"	"	''
18637	18777	15	had	have	VBD
18637	18777	16	been	be	VBN
18637	18777	17	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	18777	18	for	for	IN
18637	18777	19	the	the	DT
18637	18777	20	theories	theory	NNS
18637	18777	21	of	of	IN
18637	18777	22	Adam	Adam	NNP
18637	18777	23	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	18777	24	relating	relate	VBG
18637	18777	25	to	to	IN
18637	18777	26	the	the	DT
18637	18777	27	"	"	``
18637	18777	28	price	price	NN
18637	18777	29	that	that	WDT
18637	18777	30	will	will	MD
18637	18777	31	clear	clear	VB
18637	18777	32	the	the	DT
18637	18777	33	market	market	NN
18637	18777	34	.	.	.
18637	18777	35	"	"	''
18637	18778	1	However	however	RB
18637	18778	2	much	much	JJ
18637	18778	3	the	the	DT
18637	18778	4	minority	minority	NN
18637	18778	5	might	may	MD
18637	18778	6	stress	stress	VB
18637	18778	7	the	the	DT
18637	18778	8	unreasonableness	unreasonableness	NN
18637	18778	9	of	of	IN
18637	18778	10	any	any	DT
18637	18778	11	artificial	artificial	JJ
18637	18778	12	State	State	NNP
18637	18778	13	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18778	14	interfering	interfere	VBG
18637	18778	15	with	with	IN
18637	18778	16	the	the	DT
18637	18778	17	determination	determination	NN
18637	18778	18	of	of	IN
18637	18778	19	prices	price	NNS
18637	18778	20	by	by	IN
18637	18778	21	"	"	``
18637	18778	22	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18778	23	forces,"[185	forces,"[185	NN
18637	18778	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18778	25	the	the	DT
18637	18778	26	majority	majority	NN
18637	18778	27	was	be	VBD
18637	18778	28	content	content	JJ
18637	18778	29	to	to	TO
18637	18778	30	note	note	VB
18637	18778	31	that	that	IN
18637	18778	32	the	the	DT
18637	18778	33	"	"	``
18637	18778	34	due	due	JJ
18637	18778	35	process	process	NN
18637	18778	36	clause	clause	NN
18637	18778	37	makes	make	VBZ
18637	18778	38	no	no	DT
18637	18778	39	mention	mention	NN
18637	18778	40	of	of	IN
18637	18778	41	prices	price	NNS
18637	18778	42	"	"	''
18637	18778	43	and	and	CC
18637	18778	44	that	that	IN
18637	18778	45	"	"	``
18637	18778	46	the	the	DT
18637	18778	47	courts	court	NNS
18637	18778	48	are	be	VBP
18637	18778	49	both	both	DT
18637	18778	50	incompetent	incompetent	JJ
18637	18778	51	and	and	CC
18637	18778	52	unauthorized	unauthorized	JJ
18637	18778	53	to	to	TO
18637	18778	54	deal	deal	VB
18637	18778	55	with	with	IN
18637	18778	56	the	the	DT
18637	18778	57	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	18778	58	of	of	IN
18637	18778	59	the	the	DT
18637	18778	60	policy	policy	NN
18637	18778	61	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	18778	62	or	or	CC
18637	18778	63	the	the	DT
18637	18778	64	practicability	practicability	NN
18637	18778	65	of	of	IN
18637	18778	66	the	the	DT
18637	18778	67	law	law	NN
18637	18778	68	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	18778	69	to	to	IN
18637	18778	70	forward	forward	VB
18637	18778	71	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18778	72	.	.	.
18637	18778	73	"	"	''
18637	18779	1	Having	have	VBG
18637	18779	2	thus	thus	RB
18637	18779	3	concluded	conclude	VBN
18637	18779	4	that	that	IN
18637	18779	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18779	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	18779	7	no	no	RB
18637	18779	8	longer	long	RBR
18637	18779	9	the	the	DT
18637	18779	10	nature	nature	NN
18637	18779	11	of	of	IN
18637	18779	12	the	the	DT
18637	18779	13	business	business	NN
18637	18779	14	which	which	WDT
18637	18779	15	determines	determine	VBZ
18637	18779	16	the	the	DT
18637	18779	17	validity	validity	NN
18637	18779	18	of	of	IN
18637	18779	19	a	a	DT
18637	18779	20	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18779	21	of	of	IN
18637	18779	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18779	23	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18779	24	or	or	CC
18637	18779	25	charges	charge	NNS
18637	18779	26	but	but	CC
18637	18779	27	solely	solely	RB
18637	18779	28	the	the	DT
18637	18779	29	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	18779	30	of	of	IN
18637	18779	31	the	the	DT
18637	18779	32	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18779	33	,	,	,
18637	18779	34	the	the	DT
18637	18779	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18779	36	had	have	VBD
18637	18779	37	little	little	JJ
18637	18779	38	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	18779	39	in	in	IN
18637	18779	40	upholding	upholding	NN
18637	18779	41	,	,	,
18637	18779	42	in	in	IN
18637	18779	43	Olsen	Olsen	NNP
18637	18779	44	_	_	NNP
18637	18779	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	18779	46	_	_	NNP
18637	18779	47	Nebraska,[186	Nebraska,[186	NNP
18637	18779	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18779	49	a	a	DT
18637	18779	50	State	State	NNP
18637	18779	51	law	law	NN
18637	18779	52	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	18779	53	the	the	DT
18637	18779	54	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	18779	55	commission	commission	NN
18637	18779	56	which	which	WDT
18637	18779	57	private	private	JJ
18637	18779	58	employment	employment	NN
18637	18779	59	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	18779	60	may	may	MD
18637	18779	61	charge	charge	VB
18637	18779	62	.	.	.
18637	18780	1	Rejecting	reject	VBG
18637	18780	2	the	the	DT
18637	18780	3	contentions	contention	NNS
18637	18780	4	of	of	IN
18637	18780	5	the	the	DT
18637	18780	6	employment	employment	NN
18637	18780	7	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	18780	8	that	that	IN
18637	18780	9	the	the	DT
18637	18780	10	need	need	NN
18637	18780	11	for	for	IN
18637	18780	12	such	such	JJ
18637	18780	13	protective	protective	JJ
18637	18780	14	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18780	15	had	have	VBD
18637	18780	16	not	not	RB
18637	18780	17	been	be	VBN
18637	18780	18	shown	show	VBN
18637	18780	19	,	,	,
18637	18780	20	the	the	DT
18637	18780	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18780	22	held	hold	VBD
18637	18780	23	that	that	IN
18637	18780	24	differences	difference	NNS
18637	18780	25	of	of	IN
18637	18780	26	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	18780	27	as	as	IN
18637	18780	28	to	to	IN
18637	18780	29	the	the	DT
18637	18780	30	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	18780	31	,	,	,
18637	18780	32	need	need	NN
18637	18780	33	,	,	,
18637	18780	34	or	or	CC
18637	18780	35	appropriateness	appropriateness	NN
18637	18780	36	of	of	IN
18637	18780	37	the	the	DT
18637	18780	38	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18780	39	"	"	``
18637	18780	40	suggest	suggest	VBP
18637	18780	41	a	a	DT
18637	18780	42	choice	choice	NN
18637	18780	43	which	which	WDT
18637	18780	44	should	should	MD
18637	18780	45	be	be	VB
18637	18780	46	left	leave	VBN
18637	18780	47	to	to	IN
18637	18780	48	the	the	DT
18637	18780	49	States	States	NNP
18637	18780	50	"	"	''
18637	18780	51	;	;	:
18637	18780	52	and	and	CC
18637	18780	53	that	that	IN
18637	18780	54	there	there	EX
18637	18780	55	was	be	VBD
18637	18780	56	"	"	``
18637	18780	57	no	no	DT
18637	18780	58	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	18780	59	for	for	IN
18637	18780	60	the	the	DT
18637	18780	61	State	State	NNP
18637	18780	62	to	to	TO
18637	18780	63	demonstrate	demonstrate	VB
18637	18780	64	before	before	IN
18637	18780	65	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18780	66	that	that	IN
18637	18780	67	evils	evil	NNS
18637	18780	68	persist	persist	VBP
18637	18780	69	despite	despite	IN
18637	18780	70	the	the	DT
18637	18780	71	competition	competition	NN
18637	18780	72	"	"	''
18637	18780	73	between	between	IN
18637	18780	74	public	public	JJ
18637	18780	75	,	,	,
18637	18780	76	charitable	charitable	JJ
18637	18780	77	,	,	,
18637	18780	78	and	and	CC
18637	18780	79	private	private	JJ
18637	18780	80	employment	employment	NN
18637	18780	81	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	18780	82	.	.	.
18637	18781	1	The	the	DT
18637	18781	2	older	old	JJR
18637	18781	3	case	case	NN
18637	18781	4	of	of	IN
18637	18781	5	Ribnik	Ribnik	NNP
18637	18781	6	_	_	NNP
18637	18781	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	18781	8	_	_	NNP
18637	18781	9	McBride,[187	McBride,[187	NNP
18637	18781	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18781	11	which	which	WDT
18637	18781	12	founded	found	VBD
18637	18781	13	the	the	DT
18637	18781	14	invalidation	invalidation	NN
18637	18781	15	of	of	IN
18637	18781	16	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18781	17	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18781	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	18781	19	the	the	DT
18637	18781	20	now	now	RB
18637	18781	21	obsolete	obsolete	JJ
18637	18781	22	concept	concept	NN
18637	18781	23	of	of	IN
18637	18781	24	a	a	DT
18637	18781	25	"	"	``
18637	18781	26	business	business	NN
18637	18781	27	affected	affect	VBN
18637	18781	28	with	with	IN
18637	18781	29	a	a	DT
18637	18781	30	public	public	JJ
18637	18781	31	interest	interest	NN
18637	18781	32	"	"	``
18637	18781	33	was	be	VBD
18637	18781	34	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	18781	35	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	18781	36	.	.	.
18637	18782	1	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
18637	18782	2	REVIEW	REVIEW	NNP
18637	18782	3	OF	of	IN
18637	18782	4	PUBLICLY	PUBLICLY	NNP
18637	18782	5	DETERMINED	determined	NN
18637	18782	6	RATES	rate	NNS
18637	18782	7	AND	and	CC
18637	18782	8	CHARGES	charge	VBD
18637	18782	9	Development	Development	NNP
18637	18782	10	In	in	IN
18637	18782	11	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	18782	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18782	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	18782	14	_	_	NNP
18637	18782	15	Illinois,[188	Illinois,[188	NNP
18637	18782	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18782	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18782	18	initial	initial	JJ
18637	18782	19	holding	holding	NN
18637	18782	20	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	18782	21	the	the	DT
18637	18782	22	applicability	applicability	NN
18637	18782	23	of	of	IN
18637	18782	24	the	the	DT
18637	18782	25	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18782	26	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18782	27	to	to	IN
18637	18782	28	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	18782	29	price	price	NN
18637	18782	30	fixing,[189	fixing,[189	NN
18637	18782	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18782	32	the	the	DT
18637	18782	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18782	34	,	,	,
18637	18782	35	not	not	RB
18637	18782	36	only	only	RB
18637	18782	37	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	18782	38	that	that	IN
18637	18782	39	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	18782	40	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18782	41	of	of	IN
18637	18782	42	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18782	43	charged	charge	VBN
18637	18782	44	by	by	IN
18637	18782	45	public	public	JJ
18637	18782	46	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	18782	47	and	and	CC
18637	18782	48	allied	ally	VBN
18637	18782	49	businesses	business	NNS
18637	18782	50	was	be	VBD
18637	18782	51	within	within	IN
18637	18782	52	the	the	DT
18637	18782	53	States	States	NNPS
18637	18782	54	'	'	POS
18637	18782	55	police	police	NN
18637	18782	56	power	power	NN
18637	18782	57	but	but	CC
18637	18782	58	added	add	VBD
18637	18782	59	that	that	IN
18637	18782	60	the	the	DT
18637	18782	61	determination	determination	NN
18637	18782	62	of	of	IN
18637	18782	63	such	such	JJ
18637	18782	64	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18782	65	by	by	IN
18637	18782	66	a	a	DT
18637	18782	67	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18782	68	was	be	VBD
18637	18782	69	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	18782	70	and	and	CC
18637	18782	71	not	not	RB
18637	18782	72	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18782	73	to	to	IN
18637	18782	74	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18782	75	review	review	NN
18637	18782	76	or	or	CC
18637	18782	77	revision	revision	NN
18637	18782	78	.	.	.
18637	18783	1	Expanding	expand	VBG
18637	18783	2	the	the	DT
18637	18783	3	range	range	NN
18637	18783	4	of	of	IN
18637	18783	5	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	18783	6	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	18783	7	fixing	fixing	NN
18637	18783	8	of	of	IN
18637	18783	9	prices	price	NNS
18637	18783	10	,	,	,
18637	18783	11	the	the	DT
18637	18783	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18783	13	,	,	,
18637	18783	14	in	in	IN
18637	18783	15	the	the	DT
18637	18783	16	Nebbia	Nebbia	NNP
18637	18783	17	Case,[190	Case,[190	NNP
18637	18783	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18783	19	more	more	RBR
18637	18783	20	recently	recently	RB
18637	18783	21	declared	declare	VBD
18637	18783	22	that	that	IN
18637	18783	23	prices	price	NNS
18637	18783	24	established	establish	VBN
18637	18783	25	for	for	IN
18637	18783	26	business	business	NN
18637	18783	27	in	in	IN
18637	18783	28	general	general	JJ
18637	18783	29	would	would	MD
18637	18783	30	invite	invite	VB
18637	18783	31	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18783	32	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	18783	33	only	only	RB
18637	18783	34	if	if	IN
18637	18783	35	"	"	``
18637	18783	36	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18783	37	,	,	,
18637	18783	38	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	18783	39	,	,	,
18637	18783	40	or	or	CC
18637	18783	41	demonstrably	demonstrably	RB
18637	18783	42	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
18637	18783	43	to	to	IN
18637	18783	44	the	the	DT
18637	18783	45	policy	policy	NN
18637	18783	46	the	the	DT
18637	18783	47	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18783	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	18783	49	free	free	JJ
18637	18783	50	to	to	TO
18637	18783	51	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	18783	52	.	.	.
18637	18783	53	"	"	''
18637	18784	1	The	the	DT
18637	18784	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18784	3	standard	standard	NN
18637	18784	4	of	of	IN
18637	18784	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18784	6	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	18784	7	,	,	,
18637	18784	8	as	as	IN
18637	18784	9	will	will	MD
18637	18784	10	be	be	VB
18637	18784	11	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	18784	12	noted	note	VBN
18637	18784	13	,	,	,
18637	18784	14	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	18784	15	less	less	JJR
18637	18784	16	of	of	IN
18637	18784	17	a	a	DT
18637	18784	18	departure	departure	NN
18637	18784	19	from	from	IN
18637	18784	20	the	the	DT
18637	18784	21	principle	principle	NN
18637	18784	22	enunciated	enunciate	VBN
18637	18784	23	in	in	IN
18637	18784	24	the	the	DT
18637	18784	25	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	18784	26	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18784	27	than	than	IN
18637	18784	28	that	that	DT
18637	18784	29	which	which	WDT
18637	18784	30	the	the	DT
18637	18784	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18784	32	evolved	evolve	VBD
18637	18784	33	,	,	,
18637	18784	34	in	in	IN
18637	18784	35	the	the	DT
18637	18784	36	years	year	NNS
18637	18784	37	following	follow	VBG
18637	18784	38	1877	1877	CD
18637	18784	39	,	,	,
18637	18784	40	to	to	TO
18637	18784	41	measure	measure	VB
18637	18784	42	the	the	DT
18637	18784	43	validity	validity	NN
18637	18784	44	of	of	IN
18637	18784	45	State	State	NNP
18637	18784	46	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	18784	47	public	public	JJ
18637	18784	48	utility	utility	NN
18637	18784	49	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18784	50	,	,	,
18637	18784	51	and	and	CC
18637	18784	52	this	this	DT
18637	18784	53	difference	difference	NN
18637	18784	54	in	in	IN
18637	18784	55	the	the	DT
18637	18784	56	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18784	57	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	18784	58	of	of	IN
18637	18784	59	prices	price	NNS
18637	18784	60	and	and	CC
18637	18784	61	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18784	62	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	18784	63	warrants	warrant	VBZ
18637	18784	64	an	an	DT
18637	18784	65	explanation	explanation	NN
18637	18784	66	at	at	IN
18637	18784	67	the	the	DT
18637	18784	68	outset	outset	NN
18637	18784	69	.	.	.
18637	18785	1	Unlike	unlike	IN
18637	18785	2	operators	operator	NNS
18637	18785	3	of	of	IN
18637	18785	4	public	public	JJ
18637	18785	5	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	18785	6	who	who	WP
18637	18785	7	,	,	,
18637	18785	8	in	in	IN
18637	18785	9	return	return	NN
18637	18785	10	for	for	IN
18637	18785	11	the	the	DT
18637	18785	12	grant	grant	NN
18637	18785	13	of	of	IN
18637	18785	14	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18785	15	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	18785	16	,	,	,
18637	18785	17	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	18785	18	monopolistic	monopolistic	JJ
18637	18785	19	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18785	20	by	by	IN
18637	18785	21	the	the	DT
18637	18785	22	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	18785	23	unit	unit	NN
18637	18785	24	enfranchising	enfranchise	VBG
18637	18785	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18785	26	,	,	,
18637	18785	27	must	must	MD
18637	18785	28	assume	assume	VB
18637	18785	29	an	an	DT
18637	18785	30	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	18785	31	to	to	TO
18637	18785	32	provide	provide	VB
18637	18785	33	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	18785	34	service	service	NN
18637	18785	35	,	,	,
18637	18785	36	proprietors	proprietor	NNS
18637	18785	37	of	of	IN
18637	18785	38	other	other	JJ
18637	18785	39	businesses	business	NNS
18637	18785	40	are	be	VBP
18637	18785	41	in	in	IN
18637	18785	42	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	18785	43	of	of	IN
18637	18785	44	no	no	DT
18637	18785	45	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18785	46	special	special	JJ
18637	18785	47	advantages	advantage	NNS
18637	18785	48	and	and	CC
18637	18785	49	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	18785	50	are	be	VBP
18637	18785	51	unrestricted	unrestricte	VBN
18637	18785	52	in	in	IN
18637	18785	53	the	the	DT
18637	18785	54	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18785	55	of	of	IN
18637	18785	56	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18785	57	right	right	NN
18637	18785	58	to	to	TO
18637	18785	59	liquidate	liquidate	VB
18637	18785	60	and	and	CC
18637	18785	61	close	close	VB
18637	18785	62	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18785	63	establishments	establishment	NNS
18637	18785	64	.	.	.
18637	18786	1	At	at	IN
18637	18786	2	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18786	3	,	,	,
18637	18786	4	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	18786	5	,	,	,
18637	18786	6	as	as	IN
18637	18786	7	public	public	JJ
18637	18786	8	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	18786	9	invariably	invariably	RB
18637	18786	10	are	be	VBP
18637	18786	11	not	not	RB
18637	18786	12	,	,	,
18637	18786	13	to	to	TO
18637	18786	14	escape	escape	VB
18637	18786	15	,	,	,
18637	18786	16	by	by	IN
18637	18786	17	dissolution	dissolution	NN
18637	18786	18	,	,	,
18637	18786	19	the	the	DT
18637	18786	20	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	18786	21	of	of	IN
18637	18786	22	publicly	publicly	RB
18637	18786	23	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18786	24	charges	charge	NNS
18637	18786	25	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	18786	26	to	to	TO
18637	18786	27	be	be	VB
18637	18786	28	oppressive	oppressive	JJ
18637	18786	29	,	,	,
18637	18786	30	owners	owner	NNS
18637	18786	31	of	of	IN
18637	18786	32	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	18786	33	business	business	NN
18637	18786	34	,	,	,
18637	18786	35	presumably	presumably	RB
18637	18786	36	for	for	IN
18637	18786	37	that	that	DT
18637	18786	38	reason	reason	NN
18637	18786	39	,	,	,
18637	18786	40	have	have	VBP
18637	18786	41	thus	thus	RB
18637	18786	42	far	far	RB
18637	18786	43	been	be	VBN
18637	18786	44	unable	unable	JJ
18637	18786	45	to	to	TO
18637	18786	46	convince	convince	VB
18637	18786	47	the	the	DT
18637	18786	48	courts	court	NNS
18637	18786	49	that	that	WDT
18637	18786	50	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18786	51	too	too	RB
18637	18786	52	,	,	,
18637	18786	53	no	no	DT
18637	18786	54	less	less	JJR
18637	18786	55	than	than	IN
18637	18786	56	public	public	JJ
18637	18786	57	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	18786	58	,	,	,
18637	18786	59	are	be	VBP
18637	18786	60	in	in	IN
18637	18786	61	need	need	NN
18637	18786	62	of	of	IN
18637	18786	63	that	that	DT
18637	18786	64	protection	protection	NN
18637	18786	65	which	which	WDT
18637	18786	66	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18786	67	review	review	NN
18637	18786	68	affords	afford	NNS
18637	18786	69	.	.	.
18637	18787	1	Consistently	consistently	RB
18637	18787	2	with	with	IN
18637	18787	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18787	4	initial	initial	JJ
18637	18787	5	pronouncement	pronouncement	NN
18637	18787	6	in	in	IN
18637	18787	7	the	the	DT
18637	18787	8	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	18787	9	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18787	10	,	,	,
18637	18787	11	that	that	IN
18637	18787	12	the	the	DT
18637	18787	13	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	18787	14	of	of	IN
18637	18787	15	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18787	16	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	18787	17	under	under	IN
18637	18787	18	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	18787	19	rate	rate	NN
18637	18787	20	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18787	21	presented	present	VBD
18637	18787	22	a	a	DT
18637	18787	23	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18787	24	rather	rather	RB
18637	18787	25	than	than	IN
18637	18787	26	a	a	DT
18637	18787	27	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18787	28	question	question	NN
18637	18787	29	,	,	,
18637	18787	30	the	the	DT
18637	18787	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18787	32	,	,	,
18637	18787	33	in	in	IN
18637	18787	34	Davidson	Davidson	NNP
18637	18787	35	_	_	NNP
18637	18787	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	18787	37	_	_	NNP
18637	18787	38	New	New	NNP
18637	18787	39	Orleans,[191	Orleans,[191	NNP
18637	18787	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18787	41	also	also	RB
18637	18787	42	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	18787	43	the	the	DT
18637	18787	44	contention	contention	NN
18637	18787	45	that	that	IN
18637	18787	46	,	,	,
18637	18787	47	by	by	IN
18637	18787	48	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	18787	49	of	of	IN
18637	18787	50	the	the	DT
18637	18787	51	due	due	JJ
18637	18787	52	process	process	NN
18637	18787	53	clause	clause	NN
18637	18787	54	,	,	,
18637	18787	55	businesses	business	NNS
18637	18787	56	,	,	,
18637	18787	57	even	even	RB
18637	18787	58	though	though	IN
18637	18787	59	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18787	60	to	to	IN
18637	18787	61	control	control	NN
18637	18787	62	of	of	IN
18637	18787	63	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18787	64	prices	price	NNS
18637	18787	65	or	or	CC
18637	18787	66	charges	charge	NNS
18637	18787	67	,	,	,
18637	18787	68	were	be	VBD
18637	18787	69	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	18787	70	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	18787	71	to	to	IN
18637	18787	72	"	"	``
18637	18787	73	just	just	RB
18637	18787	74	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18787	75	.	.	.
18637	18787	76	"	"	''
18637	18788	1	Less	Less	JJR
18637	18788	2	than	than	IN
18637	18788	3	a	a	DT
18637	18788	4	decade	decade	NN
18637	18788	5	was	be	VBD
18637	18788	6	to	to	TO
18637	18788	7	elapse	elapse	VB
18637	18788	8	,	,	,
18637	18788	9	however	however	RB
18637	18788	10	,	,	,
18637	18788	11	before	before	IN
18637	18788	12	the	the	DT
18637	18788	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18788	14	,	,	,
18637	18788	15	appalled	appal	VBD
18637	18788	16	perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	18788	17	by	by	IN
18637	18788	18	prospective	prospective	JJ
18637	18788	19	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	18788	20	of	of	IN
18637	18788	21	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	18788	22	business	business	NN
18637	18788	23	"	"	''
18637	18788	24	at	at	IN
18637	18788	25	the	the	DT
18637	18788	26	mercy	mercy	NN
18637	18788	27	of	of	IN
18637	18788	28	the	the	DT
18637	18788	29	majority	majority	NN
18637	18788	30	of	of	IN
18637	18788	31	the	the	DT
18637	18788	32	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18788	33	,	,	,
18637	18788	34	"	"	''
18637	18788	35	began	begin	VBD
18637	18788	36	to	to	TO
18637	18788	37	reverse	reverse	VB
18637	18788	38	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18788	39	.	.	.
18637	18789	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18789	2	,	,	,
18637	18789	3	in	in	IN
18637	18789	4	1886	1886	CD
18637	18789	5	,	,	,
18637	18789	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	18789	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	18789	8	Waite	Waite	NNP
18637	18789	9	,	,	,
18637	18789	10	in	in	IN
18637	18789	11	the	the	DT
18637	18789	12	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	18789	13	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18789	14	Cases,[192	Cases,[192	NNP
18637	18789	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18789	16	warned	warn	VBD
18637	18789	17	that	that	IN
18637	18789	18	"	"	``
18637	18789	19	this	this	DT
18637	18789	20	power	power	NN
18637	18789	21	to	to	TO
18637	18789	22	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	18789	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	18789	24	not	not	RB
18637	18789	25	a	a	DT
18637	18789	26	power	power	NN
18637	18789	27	to	to	TO
18637	18789	28	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	18789	29	;	;	:
18637	18789	30	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18789	31	and	and	CC
18637	18789	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18789	33	the	the	DT
18637	18789	34	State	state	NN
18637	18789	35	can	can	MD
18637	18789	36	not	not	RB
18637	18789	37	do	do	VB
18637	18789	38	that	that	DT
18637	18789	39	in	in	IN
18637	18789	40	law	law	NN
18637	18789	41	which	which	WDT
18637	18789	42	amounts	amount	VBZ
18637	18789	43	to	to	IN
18637	18789	44	a	a	DT
18637	18789	45	taking	taking	NN
18637	18789	46	of	of	IN
18637	18789	47	property	property	NN
18637	18789	48	for	for	IN
18637	18789	49	public	public	JJ
18637	18789	50	use	use	NN
18637	18789	51	without	without	IN
18637	18789	52	just	just	RB
18637	18789	53	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18789	54	or	or	CC
18637	18789	55	without	without	IN
18637	18789	56	due	due	JJ
18637	18789	57	process	process	NN
18637	18789	58	of	of	IN
18637	18789	59	law	law	NN
18637	18789	60	"	"	''
18637	18789	61	;	;	:
18637	18789	62	or	or	CC
18637	18789	63	,	,	,
18637	18789	64	in	in	IN
18637	18789	65	other	other	JJ
18637	18789	66	words	word	NNS
18637	18789	67	,	,	,
18637	18789	68	can	can	MD
18637	18789	69	not	not	RB
18637	18789	70	impose	impose	VB
18637	18789	71	a	a	DT
18637	18789	72	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	18789	73	rate	rate	NN
18637	18789	74	.	.	.
18637	18790	1	By	by	IN
18637	18790	2	treating	treat	VBG
18637	18790	3	"	"	``
18637	18790	4	due	due	JJ
18637	18790	5	process	process	NN
18637	18790	6	of	of	IN
18637	18790	7	law	law	NN
18637	18790	8	"	"	''
18637	18790	9	and	and	CC
18637	18790	10	"	"	``
18637	18790	11	just	just	RB
18637	18790	12	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18790	13	"	"	''
18637	18790	14	as	as	IN
18637	18790	15	equivalents	equivalent	NNS
18637	18790	16	,	,	,
18637	18790	17	the	the	DT
18637	18790	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18790	19	,	,	,
18637	18790	20	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	18790	21	to	to	IN
18637	18790	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18790	23	earlier	early	JJR
18637	18790	24	holding	holding	NN
18637	18790	25	in	in	IN
18637	18790	26	Davidson	Davidson	NNP
18637	18790	27	_	_	NNP
18637	18790	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	18790	29	_	_	NNP
18637	18790	30	New	New	NNP
18637	18790	31	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	18790	32	,	,	,
18637	18790	33	was	be	VBD
18637	18790	34	in	in	IN
18637	18790	35	effect	effect	NN
18637	18790	36	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	18790	37	that	that	IN
18637	18790	38	the	the	DT
18637	18790	39	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	18790	40	of	of	IN
18637	18790	41	a	a	DT
18637	18790	42	rate	rate	NN
18637	18790	43	so	so	RB
18637	18790	44	low	low	JJ
18637	18790	45	as	as	IN
18637	18790	46	to	to	TO
18637	18790	47	damage	damage	NN
18637	18790	48	or	or	CC
18637	18790	49	diminish	diminish	VB
18637	18790	50	private	private	JJ
18637	18790	51	property	property	NN
18637	18790	52	ceased	cease	VBD
18637	18790	53	to	to	TO
18637	18790	54	be	be	VB
18637	18790	55	an	an	DT
18637	18790	56	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18790	57	of	of	IN
18637	18790	58	a	a	DT
18637	18790	59	State	State	NNP
18637	18790	60	's	's	POS
18637	18790	61	police	police	NN
18637	18790	62	power	power	NN
18637	18790	63	and	and	CC
18637	18790	64	became	become	VBD
18637	18790	65	one	one	CD
18637	18790	66	of	of	IN
18637	18790	67	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	18790	68	domain	domain	NN
18637	18790	69	.	.	.
18637	18791	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	18791	2	,	,	,
18637	18791	3	even	even	RB
18637	18791	4	the	the	DT
18637	18791	5	added	add	VBN
18637	18791	6	measure	measure	NN
18637	18791	7	of	of	IN
18637	18791	8	protection	protection	NN
18637	18791	9	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	18791	10	by	by	IN
18637	18791	11	the	the	DT
18637	18791	12	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	18791	13	of	of	IN
18637	18791	14	the	the	DT
18637	18791	15	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	18791	16	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18791	17	Cases	case	NNS
18637	18791	18	proved	prove	VBD
18637	18791	19	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
18637	18791	20	to	to	TO
18637	18791	21	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	18791	22	public	public	JJ
18637	18791	23	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	18791	24	;	;	:
18637	18791	25	for	for	IN
18637	18791	26	through	through	IN
18637	18791	27	application	application	NN
18637	18791	28	of	of	IN
18637	18791	29	the	the	DT
18637	18791	30	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18791	31	the	the	DT
18637	18791	32	courts	court	NNS
18637	18791	33	were	be	VBD
18637	18791	34	competent	competent	JJ
18637	18791	35	to	to	TO
18637	18791	36	intervene	intervene	VB
18637	18791	37	only	only	RB
18637	18791	38	to	to	TO
18637	18791	39	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18791	40	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18791	41	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	18791	42	of	of	IN
18637	18791	43	a	a	DT
18637	18791	44	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	18791	45	rate	rate	NN
18637	18791	46	,	,	,
18637	18791	47	a	a	DT
18637	18791	48	rate	rate	NN
18637	18791	49	so	so	RB
18637	18791	50	low	low	JJ
18637	18791	51	as	as	IN
18637	18791	52	to	to	TO
18637	18791	53	be	be	VB
18637	18791	54	productive	productive	JJ
18637	18791	55	of	of	IN
18637	18791	56	a	a	DT
18637	18791	57	loss	loss	NN
18637	18791	58	and	and	CC
18637	18791	59	to	to	TO
18637	18791	60	amount	amount	VB
18637	18791	61	to	to	IN
18637	18791	62	a	a	DT
18637	18791	63	taking	taking	NN
18637	18791	64	of	of	IN
18637	18791	65	property	property	NN
18637	18791	66	without	without	IN
18637	18791	67	just	just	RB
18637	18791	68	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18791	69	.	.	.
18637	18792	1	Nothing	nothing	NN
18637	18792	2	less	less	JJR
18637	18792	3	than	than	IN
18637	18792	4	a	a	DT
18637	18792	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18792	6	acknowledgment	acknowledgment	NN
18637	18792	7	that	that	IN
18637	18792	8	when	when	WRB
18637	18792	9	the	the	DT
18637	18792	10	"	"	``
18637	18792	11	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	18792	12	"	"	''
18637	18792	13	of	of	IN
18637	18792	14	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18792	15	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18792	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	18792	17	questioned	question	VBN
18637	18792	18	,	,	,
18637	18792	19	the	the	DT
18637	18792	20	courts	court	NNS
18637	18792	21	should	should	MD
18637	18792	22	finally	finally	RB
18637	18792	23	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	18792	24	of	of	IN
18637	18792	25	the	the	DT
18637	18792	26	contention	contention	NN
18637	18792	27	was	be	VBD
18637	18792	28	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	18792	29	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	18792	30	by	by	IN
18637	18792	31	such	such	JJ
18637	18792	32	businesses	business	NNS
18637	18792	33	to	to	TO
18637	18792	34	afford	afford	VB
18637	18792	35	the	the	DT
18637	18792	36	relief	relief	NN
18637	18792	37	desired	desire	VBN
18637	18792	38	;	;	:
18637	18792	39	and	and	CC
18637	18792	40	although	although	IN
18637	18792	41	as	as	RB
18637	18792	42	late	late	JJ
18637	18792	43	as	as	IN
18637	18792	44	1888[193	1888[193	CD
18637	18792	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18792	46	the	the	DT
18637	18792	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18792	48	doubted	doubt	VBD
18637	18792	49	that	that	IN
18637	18792	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18792	51	possessed	possess	VBD
18637	18792	52	the	the	DT
18637	18792	53	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	18792	54	power	power	NN
18637	18792	55	,	,	,
18637	18792	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18792	57	finally	finally	RB
18637	18792	58	acceded	accede	VBD
18637	18792	59	to	to	IN
18637	18792	60	the	the	DT
18637	18792	61	wishes	wish	NNS
18637	18792	62	of	of	IN
18637	18792	63	the	the	DT
18637	18792	64	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	18792	65	in	in	IN
18637	18792	66	1890	1890	CD
18637	18792	67	,	,	,
18637	18792	68	and	and	CC
18637	18792	69	,	,	,
18637	18792	70	in	in	IN
18637	18792	71	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	18792	72	,	,	,
18637	18792	73	M.	M.	NNP
18637	18792	74	&	&	CC
18637	18792	75	St.	St.	NNP
18637	18792	76	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	18793	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18793	2	_	_	NNP
18637	18793	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	18793	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18793	5	Minnesota[194	Minnesota[194	NNP
18637	18793	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18793	7	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	18793	8	as	as	IN
18637	18793	9	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	18793	10	:	:	:
18637	18793	11	"	"	``
18637	18793	12	The	the	DT
18637	18793	13	question	question	NN
18637	18793	14	of	of	IN
18637	18793	15	the	the	DT
18637	18793	16	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	18793	17	of	of	IN
18637	18793	18	a	a	DT
18637	18793	19	rate	rate	NN
18637	18793	20	*	*	NFP
18637	18793	21	*	*	NFP
18637	18793	22	*	*	NFP
18637	18793	23	,	,	,
18637	18793	24	involving	involve	VBG
18637	18793	25	as	as	IN
18637	18793	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18793	27	does	do	VBZ
18637	18793	28	the	the	DT
18637	18793	29	element	element	NN
18637	18793	30	of	of	IN
18637	18793	31	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	18793	32	both	both	DT
18637	18793	33	as	as	IN
18637	18793	34	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	18793	35	the	the	DT
18637	18793	36	company	company	NN
18637	18793	37	and	and	CC
18637	18793	38	as	as	IN
18637	18793	39	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	18793	40	the	the	DT
18637	18793	41	public	public	NN
18637	18793	42	,	,	,
18637	18793	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	18793	44	eminently	eminently	RB
18637	18793	45	a	a	DT
18637	18793	46	question	question	NN
18637	18793	47	for	for	IN
18637	18793	48	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18793	49	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	18793	50	,	,	,
18637	18793	51	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18793	52	due	due	JJ
18637	18793	53	process	process	NN
18637	18793	54	of	of	IN
18637	18793	55	law	law	NN
18637	18793	56	for	for	IN
18637	18793	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18793	58	determination	determination	NN
18637	18793	59	.	.	.
18637	18794	1	If	if	IN
18637	18794	2	the	the	DT
18637	18794	3	company	company	NN
18637	18794	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	18794	5	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	18794	6	of	of	IN
18637	18794	7	the	the	DT
18637	18794	8	power	power	NN
18637	18794	9	of	of	IN
18637	18794	10	charging	charge	VBG
18637	18794	11	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18794	12	for	for	IN
18637	18794	13	the	the	DT
18637	18794	14	use	use	NN
18637	18794	15	of	of	IN
18637	18794	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18794	17	property	property	NN
18637	18794	18	,	,	,
18637	18794	19	and	and	CC
18637	18794	20	such	such	JJ
18637	18794	21	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18794	22	takes	take	VBZ
18637	18794	23	place	place	NN
18637	18794	24	in	in	IN
18637	18794	25	the	the	DT
18637	18794	26	absence	absence	NN
18637	18794	27	of	of	IN
18637	18794	28	an	an	DT
18637	18794	29	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	18794	30	by	by	IN
18637	18794	31	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18794	32	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	18794	33	,	,	,
18637	18794	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18794	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	18794	36	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	18794	37	of	of	IN
18637	18794	38	the	the	DT
18637	18794	39	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	18794	40	use	use	NN
18637	18794	41	of	of	IN
18637	18794	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18794	43	property	property	NN
18637	18794	44	,	,	,
18637	18794	45	and	and	CC
18637	18794	46	thus	thus	RB
18637	18794	47	,	,	,
18637	18794	48	in	in	IN
18637	18794	49	substance	substance	NN
18637	18794	50	and	and	CC
18637	18794	51	effect	effect	NN
18637	18794	52	,	,	,
18637	18794	53	of	of	IN
18637	18794	54	the	the	DT
18637	18794	55	property	property	NN
18637	18794	56	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18794	57	,	,	,
18637	18794	58	without	without	IN
18637	18794	59	due	due	JJ
18637	18794	60	process	process	NN
18637	18794	61	of	of	IN
18637	18794	62	law	law	NN
18637	18794	63	*	*	NFP
18637	18794	64	*	*	NFP
18637	18794	65	*	*	NFP
18637	18794	66	"	"	``
18637	18794	67	Despite	despite	IN
18637	18794	68	a	a	DT
18637	18794	69	last	last	JJ
18637	18794	70	hour	hour	NN
18637	18794	71	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	18794	72	,	,	,
18637	18794	73	in	in	IN
18637	18794	74	Budd	Budd	NNP
18637	18794	75	_	_	NNP
18637	18794	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	18794	77	_	_	NNP
18637	18794	78	New	New	NNP
18637	18794	79	York,[195	York,[195	NNP
18637	18794	80	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18794	81	to	to	TO
18637	18794	82	reconcile	reconcile	VB
18637	18794	83	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	18794	84	_	_	NNP
18637	18794	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	18794	86	_	_	NNP
18637	18794	87	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	18794	88	with	with	IN
18637	18794	89	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	18794	90	,	,	,
18637	18794	91	M.	M.	NNP
18637	18794	92	&	&	CC
18637	18794	93	St.	St.	NNP
18637	18794	94	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	18795	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18795	2	_	_	NNP
18637	18795	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	18795	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18795	5	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	18795	6	by	by	IN
18637	18795	7	confining	confine	VBG
18637	18795	8	application	application	NN
18637	18795	9	of	of	IN
18637	18795	10	the	the	DT
18637	18795	11	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18795	12	decision	decision	NN
18637	18795	13	to	to	IN
18637	18795	14	cases	case	NNS
18637	18795	15	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	18795	16	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18795	17	had	have	VBD
18637	18795	18	been	be	VBN
18637	18795	19	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	18795	20	by	by	IN
18637	18795	21	a	a	DT
18637	18795	22	commission	commission	NN
18637	18795	23	and	and	CC
18637	18795	24	denying	deny	VBG
18637	18795	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18795	26	pertinence	pertinence	NN
18637	18795	27	to	to	IN
18637	18795	28	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18795	29	directly	directly	RB
18637	18795	30	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18795	31	by	by	IN
18637	18795	32	a	a	DT
18637	18795	33	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18795	34	,	,	,
18637	18795	35	the	the	DT
18637	18795	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18795	37	,	,	,
18637	18795	38	in	in	IN
18637	18795	39	Reagan	Reagan	NNP
18637	18795	40	_	_	NNP
18637	18795	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	18795	42	_	_	NNP
18637	18795	43	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	18795	44	'	'	POS
18637	18795	45	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	18795	46	and	and	CC
18637	18795	47	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	18795	48	Co	Co	NNP
18637	18795	49	.	.	.
18637	18795	50	,[196	,[196	NFP
18637	18795	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18795	52	set	set	VBN
18637	18795	53	at	at	IN
18637	18795	54	rest	rest	NN
18637	18795	55	all	all	DT
18637	18795	56	lingering	linger	VBG
18637	18795	57	doubts	doubt	NNS
18637	18795	58	as	as	IN
18637	18795	59	to	to	IN
18637	18795	60	the	the	DT
18637	18795	61	scope	scope	NN
18637	18795	62	of	of	IN
18637	18795	63	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18795	64	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	18795	65	by	by	IN
18637	18795	66	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	18795	67	that	that	DT
18637	18795	68	,	,	,
18637	18795	69	"	"	``
18637	18795	70	if	if	IN
18637	18795	71	a	a	DT
18637	18795	72	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18795	73	,	,	,
18637	18795	74	"	"	''
18637	18795	75	in	in	IN
18637	18795	76	the	the	DT
18637	18795	77	absence	absence	NN
18637	18795	78	of	of	IN
18637	18795	79	a	a	DT
18637	18795	80	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18795	81	rate	rate	NN
18637	18795	82	,	,	,
18637	18795	83	"	"	''
18637	18795	84	attempted	attempt	VBD
18637	18795	85	to	to	TO
18637	18795	86	charge	charge	VB
18637	18795	87	a	a	DT
18637	18795	88	shipper	shipper	NN
18637	18795	89	an	an	DT
18637	18795	90	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18795	91	sum	sum	NN
18637	18795	92	,	,	,
18637	18795	93	"	"	''
18637	18795	94	the	the	DT
18637	18795	95	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18795	96	,	,	,
18637	18795	97	in	in	IN
18637	18795	98	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	18795	99	with	with	IN
18637	18795	100	common	common	JJ
18637	18795	101	law	law	NN
18637	18795	102	principles	principle	NNS
18637	18795	103	,	,	,
18637	18795	104	will	will	MD
18637	18795	105	pass	pass	VB
18637	18795	106	on	on	RP
18637	18795	107	the	the	DT
18637	18795	108	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	18795	109	of	of	IN
18637	18795	110	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18795	111	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18795	112	and	and	CC
18637	18795	113	has	have	VBZ
18637	18795	114	"	"	``
18637	18795	115	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	18795	116	*	*	NFP
18637	18795	117	*	*	NFP
18637	18795	118	*	*	NFP
18637	18795	119	to	to	TO
18637	18795	120	award	award	VB
18637	18795	121	to	to	IN
18637	18795	122	the	the	DT
18637	18795	123	shipper	shipper	NN
18637	18795	124	any	any	DT
18637	18795	125	amount	amount	NN
18637	18795	126	exacted	exact	VBN
18637	18795	127	*	*	NFP
18637	18795	128	*	*	NFP
18637	18795	129	*	*	NFP
18637	18795	130	in	in	IN
18637	18795	131	excess	excess	NN
18637	18795	132	of	of	IN
18637	18795	133	a	a	DT
18637	18795	134	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18795	135	rate	rate	NN
18637	18795	136	;	;	:
18637	18795	137	*	*	NFP
18637	18795	138	*	*	NFP
18637	18795	139	*	*	NFP
18637	18795	140	The	the	DT
18637	18795	141	province	province	NN
18637	18795	142	of	of	IN
18637	18795	143	the	the	DT
18637	18795	144	courts	court	NNS
18637	18795	145	is	be	VBZ
18637	18795	146	not	not	RB
18637	18795	147	changed	change	VBN
18637	18795	148	,	,	,
18637	18795	149	nor	nor	CC
18637	18795	150	the	the	DT
18637	18795	151	limit	limit	NN
18637	18795	152	of	of	IN
18637	18795	153	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18795	154	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	18795	155	altered	alter	VBD
18637	18795	156	,	,	,
18637	18795	157	because	because	IN
18637	18795	158	the	the	DT
18637	18795	159	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18795	160	instead	instead	RB
18637	18795	161	of	of	IN
18637	18795	162	a	a	DT
18637	18795	163	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18795	164	prescribes	prescribe	VBZ
18637	18795	165	the	the	DT
18637	18795	166	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18795	167	.	.	.
18637	18796	1	"	"	``
18637	18796	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18796	3	197	197	CD
18637	18796	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18796	5	Reiterating	reiterate	VBG
18637	18796	6	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	18796	7	the	the	DT
18637	18796	8	same	same	JJ
18637	18796	9	principle	principle	NN
18637	18796	10	in	in	IN
18637	18796	11	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
18637	18796	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18796	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	18796	14	_	_	NNP
18637	18796	15	Ames,[198	Ames,[198	NNP
18637	18796	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18796	17	the	the	DT
18637	18796	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18796	19	not	not	RB
18637	18796	20	only	only	RB
18637	18796	21	obliterated	obliterate	VBD
18637	18796	22	the	the	DT
18637	18796	23	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	18796	24	between	between	IN
18637	18796	25	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	18796	26	and	and	CC
18637	18796	27	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18796	28	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18796	29	,	,	,
18637	18796	30	but	but	CC
18637	18796	31	also	also	RB
18637	18796	32	contributed	contribute	VBD
18637	18796	33	the	the	DT
18637	18796	34	additional	additional	JJ
18637	18796	35	observation	observation	NN
18637	18796	36	that	that	IN
18637	18796	37	the	the	DT
18637	18796	38	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	18796	39	of	of	IN
18637	18796	40	due	due	JJ
18637	18796	41	process	process	NN
18637	18796	42	are	be	VBP
18637	18796	43	not	not	RB
18637	18796	44	met	meet	VBN
18637	18796	45	unless	unless	IN
18637	18796	46	a	a	DT
18637	18796	47	court	court	NN
18637	18796	48	reviews	review	VBZ
18637	18796	49	not	not	RB
18637	18796	50	merely	merely	RB
18637	18796	51	the	the	DT
18637	18796	52	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	18796	53	of	of	IN
18637	18796	54	a	a	DT
18637	18796	55	rate	rate	NN
18637	18796	56	but	but	CC
18637	18796	57	also	also	RB
18637	18796	58	determines	determine	VBZ
18637	18796	59	whether	whether	IN
18637	18796	60	the	the	DT
18637	18796	61	rate	rate	NN
18637	18796	62	permits	permit	VBZ
18637	18796	63	the	the	DT
18637	18796	64	utility	utility	NN
18637	18796	65	to	to	TO
18637	18796	66	earn	earn	VB
18637	18796	67	a	a	DT
18637	18796	68	fair	fair	JJ
18637	18796	69	return	return	NN
18637	18796	70	on	on	IN
18637	18796	71	a	a	DT
18637	18796	72	fair	fair	JJ
18637	18796	73	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	18796	74	of	of	IN
18637	18796	75	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18796	76	investment	investment	NN
18637	18796	77	.	.	.
18637	18797	1	Limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	18797	2	on	on	IN
18637	18797	3	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	18797	4	Review	Review	NNP
18637	18797	5	As	as	IN
18637	18797	6	to	to	IN
18637	18797	7	what	what	WDT
18637	18797	8	courts	court	NNS
18637	18797	9	will	will	MD
18637	18797	10	not	not	RB
18637	18797	11	do	do	VB
18637	18797	12	,	,	,
18637	18797	13	when	when	WRB
18637	18797	14	reviewing	review	VBG
18637	18797	15	rate	rate	NN
18637	18797	16	orders	order	NNS
18637	18797	17	of	of	IN
18637	18797	18	a	a	DT
18637	18797	19	State	State	NNP
18637	18797	20	commission	commission	NN
18637	18797	21	,	,	,
18637	18797	22	the	the	DT
18637	18797	23	following	follow	VBG
18637	18797	24	negative	negative	JJ
18637	18797	25	statements	statement	NNS
18637	18797	26	of	of	IN
18637	18797	27	the	the	DT
18637	18797	28	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	18797	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18797	30	appear	appear	VBP
18637	18797	31	to	to	TO
18637	18797	32	have	have	VB
18637	18797	33	enduring	endure	VBG
18637	18797	34	value	value	NN
18637	18797	35	.	.	.
18637	18798	1	As	as	RB
18637	18798	2	early	early	RB
18637	18798	3	as	as	IN
18637	18798	4	1894	1894	CD
18637	18798	5	,	,	,
18637	18798	6	the	the	DT
18637	18798	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18798	8	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	18798	9	:	:	:
18637	18798	10	"	"	``
18637	18798	11	The	the	DT
18637	18798	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	18798	13	are	be	VBP
18637	18798	14	not	not	RB
18637	18798	15	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	18798	16	to	to	TO
18637	18798	17	revise	revise	VB
18637	18798	18	or	or	CC
18637	18798	19	change	change	VB
18637	18798	20	the	the	DT
18637	18798	21	body	body	NN
18637	18798	22	of	of	IN
18637	18798	23	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18798	24	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18798	25	by	by	IN
18637	18798	26	a	a	DT
18637	18798	27	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18798	28	or	or	CC
18637	18798	29	a	a	DT
18637	18798	30	commission	commission	NN
18637	18798	31	;	;	:
18637	18798	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18798	33	do	do	VBP
18637	18798	34	not	not	RB
18637	18798	35	determine	determine	VB
18637	18798	36	whether	whether	IN
18637	18798	37	one	one	CD
18637	18798	38	rate	rate	NN
18637	18798	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	18798	40	preferable	preferable	JJ
18637	18798	41	to	to	IN
18637	18798	42	another	another	DT
18637	18798	43	,	,	,
18637	18798	44	or	or	CC
18637	18798	45	what	what	WP
18637	18798	46	under	under	IN
18637	18798	47	all	all	DT
18637	18798	48	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	18798	49	would	would	MD
18637	18798	50	be	be	VB
18637	18798	51	fair	fair	JJ
18637	18798	52	and	and	CC
18637	18798	53	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18798	54	as	as	IN
18637	18798	55	between	between	IN
18637	18798	56	the	the	DT
18637	18798	57	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	18798	58	and	and	CC
18637	18798	59	the	the	DT
18637	18798	60	shippers	shipper	NNS
18637	18798	61	;	;	:
18637	18798	62	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18798	63	do	do	VBP
18637	18798	64	not	not	RB
18637	18798	65	engage	engage	VB
18637	18798	66	in	in	IN
18637	18798	67	any	any	DT
18637	18798	68	mere	mere	JJ
18637	18798	69	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	18798	70	work	work	NN
18637	18798	71	;	;	:
18637	18798	72	*	*	NFP
18637	18798	73	*	*	NFP
18637	18798	74	*	*	NFP
18637	18798	75	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18798	76	however	however	RB
18637	18798	77	,	,	,
18637	18798	78	there	there	EX
18637	18798	79	can	can	MD
18637	18798	80	be	be	VB
18637	18798	81	no	no	DT
18637	18798	82	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	18798	83	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18798	84	of	of	IN
18637	18798	85	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18798	86	power	power	NN
18637	18798	87	and	and	CC
18637	18798	88	duty	duty	NN
18637	18798	89	to	to	TO
18637	18798	90	inquire	inquire	VB
18637	18798	91	whether	whether	IN
18637	18798	92	a	a	DT
18637	18798	93	body	body	NN
18637	18798	94	of	of	IN
18637	18798	95	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18798	96	*	*	NFP
18637	18798	97	*	*	NFP
18637	18798	98	*	*	NFP
18637	18798	99	is	be	VBZ
18637	18798	100	unjust	unjust	JJ
18637	18798	101	and	and	CC
18637	18798	102	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18798	103	,	,	,
18637	18798	104	*	*	NFP
18637	18798	105	*	*	NFP
18637	18798	106	*	*	NFP
18637	18798	107	,	,	,
18637	18798	108	and	and	CC
18637	18798	109	if	if	IN
18637	18798	110	found	find	VBN
18637	18798	111	so	so	RB
18637	18798	112	to	to	TO
18637	18798	113	be	be	VB
18637	18798	114	,	,	,
18637	18798	115	to	to	TO
18637	18798	116	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	18798	117	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18798	118	operation	operation	NN
18637	18798	119	.	.	.
18637	18799	1	"	"	``
18637	18799	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18799	3	199	199	CD
18637	18799	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18799	5	And	and	CC
18637	18799	6	later	later	RBR
18637	18799	7	,	,	,
18637	18799	8	in	in	IN
18637	18799	9	1910	1910	CD
18637	18799	10	,	,	,
18637	18799	11	although	although	IN
18637	18799	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18799	13	was	be	VBD
18637	18799	14	examining	examine	VBG
18637	18799	15	the	the	DT
18637	18799	16	order	order	NN
18637	18799	17	of	of	IN
18637	18799	18	a	a	DT
18637	18799	19	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18799	20	rate	rate	NN
18637	18799	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	18799	22	making	make	VBG
18637	18799	23	agency	agency	NN
18637	18799	24	,	,	,
18637	18799	25	the	the	DT
18637	18799	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18799	27	made	make	VBD
18637	18799	28	a	a	DT
18637	18799	29	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18799	30	observation	observation	NN
18637	18799	31	which	which	WDT
18637	18799	32	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	18799	33	to	to	TO
18637	18799	34	be	be	VB
18637	18799	35	equally	equally	RB
18637	18799	36	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	18799	37	to	to	IN
18637	18799	38	the	the	DT
18637	18799	39	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18799	40	review	review	NN
18637	18799	41	of	of	IN
18637	18799	42	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18799	43	of	of	IN
18637	18799	44	State	State	NNP
18637	18799	45	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	18799	46	.	.	.
18637	18800	1	The	the	DT
18637	18800	2	courts	court	NNS
18637	18800	3	can	can	MD
18637	18800	4	not	not	RB
18637	18800	5	,	,	,
18637	18800	6	"	"	``
18637	18800	7	under	under	IN
18637	18800	8	the	the	DT
18637	18800	9	guise	guise	NN
18637	18800	10	of	of	IN
18637	18800	11	exerting	exert	VBG
18637	18800	12	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18800	13	power	power	NN
18637	18800	14	,	,	,
18637	18800	15	usurp	usurp	VB
18637	18800	16	merely	merely	RB
18637	18800	17	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	18800	18	functions	function	NNS
18637	18800	19	by	by	IN
18637	18800	20	setting	set	VBG
18637	18800	21	aside	aside	RB
18637	18800	22	"	"	``
18637	18800	23	an	an	DT
18637	18800	24	order	order	NN
18637	18800	25	of	of	IN
18637	18800	26	the	the	DT
18637	18800	27	commission	commission	NN
18637	18800	28	within	within	IN
18637	18800	29	the	the	DT
18637	18800	30	scope	scope	NN
18637	18800	31	of	of	IN
18637	18800	32	the	the	DT
18637	18800	33	power	power	NN
18637	18800	34	delegated	delegate	VBN
18637	18800	35	to	to	IN
18637	18800	36	such	such	JJ
18637	18800	37	commission	commission	NN
18637	18800	38	,	,	,
18637	18800	39	upon	upon	IN
18637	18800	40	the	the	DT
18637	18800	41	ground	ground	NN
18637	18800	42	that	that	IN
18637	18800	43	such	such	JJ
18637	18800	44	power	power	NN
18637	18800	45	was	be	VBD
18637	18800	46	unwisely	unwisely	RB
18637	18800	47	or	or	CC
18637	18800	48	inexpediently	inexpediently	RB
18637	18800	49	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	18800	50	.	.	.
18637	18801	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18801	2	200	200	CD
18637	18801	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18801	4	Also	also	RB
18637	18801	5	inferable	inferable	JJ
18637	18801	6	from	from	IN
18637	18801	7	these	these	DT
18637	18801	8	early	early	JJ
18637	18801	9	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	18801	10	,	,	,
18637	18801	11	and	and	CC
18637	18801	12	effective	effective	JJ
18637	18801	13	to	to	TO
18637	18801	14	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	18801	15	the	the	DT
18637	18801	16	bounds	bound	NNS
18637	18801	17	of	of	IN
18637	18801	18	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18801	19	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	18801	20	,	,	,
18637	18801	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	18801	22	the	the	DT
18637	18801	23	notion	notion	NN
18637	18801	24	that	that	IN
18637	18801	25	a	a	DT
18637	18801	26	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	18801	27	can	can	MD
18637	18801	28	be	be	VB
18637	18801	29	made	make	VBN
18637	18801	30	between	between	IN
18637	18801	31	factual	factual	JJ
18637	18801	32	questions	question	NNS
18637	18801	33	which	which	WDT
18637	18801	34	give	give	VBP
18637	18801	35	rise	rise	NN
18637	18801	36	only	only	RB
18637	18801	37	to	to	IN
18637	18801	38	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	18801	39	as	as	IN
18637	18801	40	to	to	IN
18637	18801	41	the	the	DT
18637	18801	42	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	18801	43	or	or	CC
18637	18801	44	expediency	expediency	NN
18637	18801	45	of	of	IN
18637	18801	46	an	an	DT
18637	18801	47	order	order	NN
18637	18801	48	issued	issue	VBN
18637	18801	49	by	by	IN
18637	18801	50	a	a	DT
18637	18801	51	commission	commission	NN
18637	18801	52	and	and	CC
18637	18801	53	determinations	determination	NNS
18637	18801	54	of	of	IN
18637	18801	55	fact	fact	NN
18637	18801	56	which	which	WDT
18637	18801	57	bear	bear	VBP
18637	18801	58	on	on	IN
18637	18801	59	a	a	DT
18637	18801	60	commission	commission	NN
18637	18801	61	's	's	POS
18637	18801	62	power	power	NN
18637	18801	63	to	to	TO
18637	18801	64	act	act	VB
18637	18801	65	;	;	:
18637	18801	66	namely	namely	RB
18637	18801	67	those	those	DT
18637	18801	68	questions	question	NNS
18637	18801	69	which	which	WDT
18637	18801	70	are	be	VBP
18637	18801	71	inseparable	inseparable	JJ
18637	18801	72	from	from	IN
18637	18801	73	the	the	DT
18637	18801	74	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18801	75	issue	issue	NN
18637	18801	76	of	of	IN
18637	18801	77	confiscation	confiscation	NN
18637	18801	78	,	,	,
18637	18801	79	and	and	CC
18637	18801	80	that	that	DT
18637	18801	81	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18801	82	review	review	NN
18637	18801	83	does	do	VBZ
18637	18801	84	not	not	RB
18637	18801	85	extend	extend	VB
18637	18801	86	to	to	IN
18637	18801	87	the	the	DT
18637	18801	88	former	former	JJ
18637	18801	89	.	.	.
18637	18802	1	This	this	DT
18637	18802	2	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	18802	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	18802	4	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	18802	5	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	18802	6	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	18802	7	by	by	IN
18637	18802	8	the	the	DT
18637	18802	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18802	10	in	in	IN
18637	18802	11	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	18802	12	&	&	CC
18637	18802	13	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	18803	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18803	2	_	_	NNP
18637	18803	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	18803	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18803	5	Garrett,[201	Garrett,[201	NNP
18637	18803	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18803	7	in	in	IN
18637	18803	8	which	which	WDT
18637	18803	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18803	10	declared	declare	VBD
18637	18803	11	that	that	IN
18637	18803	12	"	"	``
18637	18803	13	the	the	DT
18637	18803	14	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	18803	15	question	question	NN
18637	18803	16	for	for	IN
18637	18803	17	the	the	DT
18637	18803	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	18803	19	"	"	``
18637	18803	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	18803	21	simply	simply	RB
18637	18803	22	whether	whether	IN
18637	18803	23	a	a	DT
18637	18803	24	"	"	``
18637	18803	25	commission	commission	NN
18637	18803	26	,	,	,
18637	18803	27	"	"	''
18637	18803	28	in	in	IN
18637	18803	29	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	18803	30	a	a	DT
18637	18803	31	rate	rate	NN
18637	18803	32	,	,	,
18637	18803	33	"	"	''
18637	18803	34	acted	act	VBD
18637	18803	35	within	within	IN
18637	18803	36	the	the	DT
18637	18803	37	scope	scope	NN
18637	18803	38	of	of	IN
18637	18803	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18803	40	power	power	NN
18637	18803	41	"	"	''
18637	18803	42	and	and	CC
18637	18803	43	did	do	VBD
18637	18803	44	not	not	RB
18637	18803	45	violate	violate	VB
18637	18803	46	"	"	``
18637	18803	47	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18803	48	rights	right	NNS
18637	18803	49	*	*	NFP
18637	18803	50	*	*	NFP
18637	18803	51	*	*	NFP
18637	18803	52	by	by	IN
18637	18803	53	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	18803	54	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	18803	55	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	18803	56	"	"	''
18637	18803	57	and	and	CC
18637	18803	58	that	that	IN
18637	18803	59	a	a	DT
18637	18803	60	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18803	61	,	,	,
18637	18803	62	contesting	contest	VBG
18637	18803	63	the	the	DT
18637	18803	64	rate	rate	NN
18637	18803	65	thus	thus	RB
18637	18803	66	established	establish	VBN
18637	18803	67	,	,	,
18637	18803	68	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	18803	69	was	be	VBD
18637	18803	70	not	not	RB
18637	18803	71	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	18803	72	to	to	TO
18637	18803	73	have	have	VB
18637	18803	74	a	a	DT
18637	18803	75	court	court	NN
18637	18803	76	also	also	RB
18637	18803	77	pass	pass	VB
18637	18803	78	upon	upon	RP
18637	18803	79	a	a	DT
18637	18803	80	question	question	NN
18637	18803	81	of	of	IN
18637	18803	82	fact	fact	NN
18637	18803	83	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	18803	84	the	the	DT
18637	18803	85	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	18803	86	of	of	IN
18637	18803	87	a	a	DT
18637	18803	88	higher	high	JJR
18637	18803	89	rate	rate	NN
18637	18803	90	charged	charge	VBN
18637	18803	91	by	by	IN
18637	18803	92	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18803	93	prior	prior	RB
18637	18803	94	to	to	IN
18637	18803	95	the	the	DT
18637	18803	96	order	order	NN
18637	18803	97	of	of	IN
18637	18803	98	the	the	DT
18637	18803	99	commission	commission	NN
18637	18803	100	.	.	.
18637	18804	1	All	all	DT
18637	18804	2	that	that	WDT
18637	18804	3	need	need	VBP
18637	18804	4	concern	concern	NN
18637	18804	5	a	a	DT
18637	18804	6	court	court	NN
18637	18804	7	,	,	,
18637	18804	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18804	9	said	say	VBD
18637	18804	10	,	,	,
18637	18804	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	18804	12	the	the	DT
18637	18804	13	fairness	fairness	NN
18637	18804	14	of	of	IN
18637	18804	15	the	the	DT
18637	18804	16	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	18804	17	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	18804	18	the	the	DT
18637	18804	19	commission	commission	NN
18637	18804	20	determined	determine	VBD
18637	18804	21	that	that	IN
18637	18804	22	the	the	DT
18637	18804	23	existing	exist	VBG
18637	18804	24	rate	rate	NN
18637	18804	25	was	be	VBD
18637	18804	26	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	18804	27	;	;	:
18637	18804	28	but	but	CC
18637	18804	29	not	not	RB
18637	18804	30	the	the	DT
18637	18804	31	expediency	expediency	NN
18637	18804	32	or	or	CC
18637	18804	33	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	18804	34	of	of	IN
18637	18804	35	the	the	DT
18637	18804	36	commission	commission	NN
18637	18804	37	's	's	POS
18637	18804	38	having	have	VBG
18637	18804	39	superseded	supersede	VBN
18637	18804	40	that	that	IN
18637	18804	41	rate	rate	NN
18637	18804	42	with	with	IN
18637	18804	43	a	a	DT
18637	18804	44	rate	rate	NN
18637	18804	45	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18804	46	of	of	IN
18637	18804	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18804	48	own	own	JJ
18637	18804	49	.	.	.
18637	18805	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	18805	2	,	,	,
18637	18805	3	with	with	IN
18637	18805	4	a	a	DT
18637	18805	5	view	view	NN
18637	18805	6	to	to	IN
18637	18805	7	diminishing	diminish	VBG
18637	18805	8	the	the	DT
18637	18805	9	number	number	NN
18637	18805	10	of	of	IN
18637	18805	11	opportunities	opportunity	NNS
18637	18805	12	which	which	WDT
18637	18805	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	18805	14	may	may	MD
18637	18805	15	enjoy	enjoy	VB
18637	18805	16	for	for	IN
18637	18805	17	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
18637	18805	18	rate	rate	NN
18637	18805	19	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18805	20	of	of	IN
18637	18805	21	State	state	NN
18637	18805	22	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	18805	23	,	,	,
18637	18805	24	the	the	DT
18637	18805	25	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	18805	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18805	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	18805	28	placed	place	VBN
18637	18805	29	various	various	JJ
18637	18805	30	obstacles	obstacle	NNS
18637	18805	31	in	in	IN
18637	18805	32	the	the	DT
18637	18805	33	path	path	NN
18637	18805	34	of	of	IN
18637	18805	35	the	the	DT
18637	18805	36	complaining	complaining	NN
18637	18805	37	litigant	litigant	NN
18637	18805	38	.	.	.
18637	18806	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18806	2	,	,	,
18637	18806	3	not	not	RB
18637	18806	4	only	only	RB
18637	18806	5	must	must	MD
18637	18806	6	a	a	DT
18637	18806	7	person	person	NN
18637	18806	8	challenging	challenge	VBG
18637	18806	9	a	a	DT
18637	18806	10	rate	rate	NN
18637	18806	11	assume	assume	VB
18637	18806	12	the	the	DT
18637	18806	13	burden	burden	NN
18637	18806	14	of	of	IN
18637	18806	15	proof,[202	proof,[202	NNP
18637	18806	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18806	17	but	but	CC
18637	18806	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18806	19	must	must	MD
18637	18806	20	present	present	VB
18637	18806	21	a	a	DT
18637	18806	22	case	case	NN
18637	18806	23	of	of	IN
18637	18806	24	"	"	``
18637	18806	25	manifest	manif	JJS
18637	18806	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18806	27	invalidity";[203	invalidity";[203	''
18637	18806	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18806	29	and	and	CC
18637	18806	30	if	if	IN
18637	18806	31	,	,	,
18637	18806	32	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	18806	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18806	34	effort	effort	NN
18637	18806	35	,	,	,
18637	18806	36	the	the	DT
18637	18806	37	question	question	NN
18637	18806	38	of	of	IN
18637	18806	39	confiscation	confiscation	NN
18637	18806	40	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	18806	41	in	in	IN
18637	18806	42	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	18806	43	,	,	,
18637	18806	44	no	no	DT
18637	18806	45	relief	relief	NN
18637	18806	46	will	will	MD
18637	18806	47	be	be	VB
18637	18806	48	granted	grant	VBN
18637	18806	49	.	.	.
18637	18807	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18807	2	204	204	CD
18637	18807	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18807	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	18807	5	,	,	,
18637	18807	6	even	even	RB
18637	18807	7	though	though	IN
18637	18807	8	a	a	DT
18637	18807	9	public	public	JJ
18637	18807	10	utility	utility	NN
18637	18807	11	,	,	,
18637	18807	12	which	which	WDT
18637	18807	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	18807	14	petitioned	petition	VBN
18637	18807	15	a	a	DT
18637	18807	16	commission	commission	NN
18637	18807	17	for	for	IN
18637	18807	18	relief	relief	NN
18637	18807	19	from	from	IN
18637	18807	20	allegedly	allegedly	RB
18637	18807	21	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	18807	22	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18807	23	,	,	,
18637	18807	24	need	nee	MD
18637	18807	25	not	not	RB
18637	18807	26	await	await	VB
18637	18807	27	indefinitely	indefinitely	RB
18637	18807	28	a	a	DT
18637	18807	29	decision	decision	NN
18637	18807	30	by	by	IN
18637	18807	31	the	the	DT
18637	18807	32	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18807	33	before	before	IN
18637	18807	34	applying	apply	VBG
18637	18807	35	to	to	IN
18637	18807	36	a	a	DT
18637	18807	37	court	court	NN
18637	18807	38	for	for	IN
18637	18807	39	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	18807	40	relief,[205	relief,[205	NNP
18637	18807	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18807	42	the	the	DT
18637	18807	43	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18807	44	ought	ought	MD
18637	18807	45	not	not	RB
18637	18807	46	to	to	TO
18637	18807	47	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	18807	48	in	in	IN
18637	18807	49	advance	advance	NN
18637	18807	50	of	of	IN
18637	18807	51	any	any	DT
18637	18807	52	experience	experience	NN
18637	18807	53	of	of	IN
18637	18807	54	the	the	DT
18637	18807	55	practical	practical	JJ
18637	18807	56	result	result	NN
18637	18807	57	of	of	IN
18637	18807	58	such	such	JJ
18637	18807	59	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18807	60	.	.	.
18637	18808	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18808	2	206	206	CD
18637	18808	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18808	4	In	in	IN
18637	18808	5	the	the	DT
18637	18808	6	course	course	NN
18637	18808	7	of	of	IN
18637	18808	8	time	time	NN
18637	18808	9	,	,	,
18637	18808	10	however	however	RB
18637	18808	11	,	,	,
18637	18808	12	a	a	DT
18637	18808	13	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	18808	14	emerged	emerge	VBD
18637	18808	15	between	between	IN
18637	18808	16	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	18808	17	factual	factual	JJ
18637	18808	18	determinations	determination	NNS
18637	18808	19	by	by	IN
18637	18808	20	State	state	NN
18637	18808	21	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	18808	22	and	and	CC
18637	18808	23	factual	factual	JJ
18637	18808	24	determinations	determination	NNS
18637	18808	25	which	which	WDT
18637	18808	26	were	be	VBD
18637	18808	27	found	find	VBN
18637	18808	28	to	to	TO
18637	18808	29	be	be	VB
18637	18808	30	inseparable	inseparable	JJ
18637	18808	31	from	from	IN
18637	18808	32	the	the	DT
18637	18808	33	legal	legal	JJ
18637	18808	34	and	and	CC
18637	18808	35	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18808	36	issue	issue	NN
18637	18808	37	of	of	IN
18637	18808	38	confiscation	confiscation	NN
18637	18808	39	.	.	.
18637	18809	1	In	in	IN
18637	18809	2	two	two	CD
18637	18809	3	older	old	JJR
18637	18809	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	18809	5	arising	arise	VBG
18637	18809	6	from	from	IN
18637	18809	7	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18809	8	begun	begin	VBN
18637	18809	9	in	in	IN
18637	18809	10	lower	low	JJR
18637	18809	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18809	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	18809	13	to	to	TO
18637	18809	14	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	18809	15	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18809	16	,	,	,
18637	18809	17	the	the	DT
18637	18809	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18809	19	initially	initially	RB
18637	18809	20	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	18809	21	the	the	DT
18637	18809	22	position	position	NN
18637	18809	23	that	that	IN
18637	18809	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18809	25	would	would	MD
18637	18809	26	not	not	RB
18637	18809	27	disturb	disturb	VB
18637	18809	28	such	such	JJ
18637	18809	29	findings	finding	NNS
18637	18809	30	of	of	IN
18637	18809	31	fact	fact	NN
18637	18809	32	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	18809	33	as	as	IN
18637	18809	34	these	these	DT
18637	18809	35	were	be	VBD
18637	18809	36	supported	support	VBN
18637	18809	37	by	by	IN
18637	18809	38	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	18809	39	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18809	40	.	.	.
18637	18810	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18810	2	,	,	,
18637	18810	3	in	in	IN
18637	18810	4	San	San	NNP
18637	18810	5	Diego	Diego	NNP
18637	18810	6	Land	Land	NNP
18637	18810	7	and	and	CC
18637	18810	8	Town	Town	NNP
18637	18810	9	Company	Company	NNP
18637	18810	10	_	_	NNP
18637	18810	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	18810	12	_	_	NNP
18637	18810	13	National	National	NNP
18637	18810	14	City,[207	City,[207	NNP
18637	18810	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18810	16	the	the	DT
18637	18810	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18810	18	declared	declare	VBD
18637	18810	19	that	that	DT
18637	18810	20	:	:	:
18637	18810	21	After	after	IN
18637	18810	22	a	a	DT
18637	18810	23	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18810	24	body	body	NN
18637	18810	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	18810	26	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	18810	27	and	and	CC
18637	18810	28	fully	fully	RB
18637	18810	29	investigated	investigate	VBN
18637	18810	30	and	and	CC
18637	18810	31	acted	act	VBD
18637	18810	32	,	,	,
18637	18810	33	by	by	IN
18637	18810	34	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	18810	35	what	what	WP
18637	18810	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18810	37	believes	believe	VBZ
18637	18810	38	to	to	TO
18637	18810	39	be	be	VB
18637	18810	40	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18810	41	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18810	42	,	,	,
18637	18810	43	the	the	DT
18637	18810	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	18810	45	can	can	MD
18637	18810	46	not	not	RB
18637	18810	47	step	step	VB
18637	18810	48	in	in	RB
18637	18810	49	and	and	CC
18637	18810	50	say	say	VB
18637	18810	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18810	52	action	action	NN
18637	18810	53	shall	shall	MD
18637	18810	54	be	be	VB
18637	18810	55	set	set	VBN
18637	18810	56	aside	aside	RB
18637	18810	57	because	because	IN
18637	18810	58	the	the	DT
18637	18810	59	courts	court	NNS
18637	18810	60	,	,	,
18637	18810	61	upon	upon	IN
18637	18810	62	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18810	63	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	18810	64	,	,	,
18637	18810	65	have	have	VBP
18637	18810	66	come	come	VBN
18637	18810	67	to	to	IN
18637	18810	68	a	a	DT
18637	18810	69	different	different	JJ
18637	18810	70	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	18810	71	as	as	IN
18637	18810	72	to	to	IN
18637	18810	73	the	the	DT
18637	18810	74	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	18810	75	of	of	IN
18637	18810	76	the	the	DT
18637	18810	77	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18810	78	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	18810	79	.	.	.
18637	18811	1	"	"	``
18637	18811	2	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18811	3	interference	interference	NN
18637	18811	4	should	should	MD
18637	18811	5	never	never	RB
18637	18811	6	occur	occur	VB
18637	18811	7	unless	unless	IN
18637	18811	8	the	the	DT
18637	18811	9	case	case	NN
18637	18811	10	presents	present	VBZ
18637	18811	11	,	,	,
18637	18811	12	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	18811	13	and	and	CC
18637	18811	14	beyond	beyond	RB
18637	18811	15	all	all	RB
18637	18811	16	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	18811	17	,	,	,
18637	18811	18	such	such	PDT
18637	18811	19	a	a	DT
18637	18811	20	flagrant	flagrant	JJ
18637	18811	21	attack	attack	NN
18637	18811	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	18811	23	the	the	DT
18637	18811	24	rights	right	NNS
18637	18811	25	of	of	IN
18637	18811	26	property	property	NN
18637	18811	27	under	under	IN
18637	18811	28	the	the	DT
18637	18811	29	guise	guise	NN
18637	18811	30	of	of	IN
18637	18811	31	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18811	32	as	as	IN
18637	18811	33	to	to	TO
18637	18811	34	compel	compel	VB
18637	18811	35	the	the	DT
18637	18811	36	court	court	NN
18637	18811	37	to	to	TO
18637	18811	38	say	say	VB
18637	18811	39	that	that	IN
18637	18811	40	the	the	DT
18637	18811	41	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18811	42	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	18811	43	will	will	MD
18637	18811	44	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	18811	45	have	have	VB
18637	18811	46	the	the	DT
18637	18811	47	effect	effect	NN
18637	18811	48	to	to	TO
18637	18811	49	deny	deny	VB
18637	18811	50	just	just	RB
18637	18811	51	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18811	52	for	for	IN
18637	18811	53	private	private	JJ
18637	18811	54	property	property	NN
18637	18811	55	taken	take	VBN
18637	18811	56	for	for	IN
18637	18811	57	the	the	DT
18637	18811	58	public	public	JJ
18637	18811	59	use	use	NN
18637	18811	60	.	.	.
18637	18811	61	"	"	''
18637	18812	1	And	and	CC
18637	18812	2	in	in	IN
18637	18812	3	a	a	DT
18637	18812	4	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18812	5	later	later	JJ
18637	18812	6	case[208	case[208	NN
18637	18812	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18812	8	the	the	DT
18637	18812	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18812	10	expressed	express	VBD
18637	18812	11	even	even	RB
18637	18812	12	more	more	RBR
18637	18812	13	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	18812	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18812	15	reluctance	reluctance	NN
18637	18812	16	to	to	TO
18637	18812	17	reexamine	reexamine	VB
18637	18812	18	factual	factual	JJ
18637	18812	19	determinations	determination	NNS
18637	18812	20	of	of	IN
18637	18812	21	the	the	DT
18637	18812	22	kind	kind	NN
18637	18812	23	just	just	RB
18637	18812	24	described	describe	VBN
18637	18812	25	.	.	.
18637	18813	1	The	the	DT
18637	18813	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18813	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	18813	4	not	not	RB
18637	18813	5	bound	bind	VBN
18637	18813	6	"	"	''
18637	18813	7	to	to	TO
18637	18813	8	reexamine	reexamine	VB
18637	18813	9	and	and	CC
18637	18813	10	weigh	weigh	VB
18637	18813	11	all	all	PDT
18637	18813	12	the	the	DT
18637	18813	13	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18813	14	,	,	,
18637	18813	15	*	*	NFP
18637	18813	16	*	*	NFP
18637	18813	17	*	*	NFP
18637	18813	18	,	,	,
18637	18813	19	or	or	CC
18637	18813	20	to	to	TO
18637	18813	21	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	18813	22	according	accord	VBG
18637	18813	23	to	to	IN
18637	18813	24	*	*	NFP
18637	18813	25	*	*	NFP
18637	18813	26	*	*	NFP
18637	18813	27	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18813	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18813	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18813	30	independent	independent	JJ
18637	18813	31	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	18813	32	as	as	IN
18637	18813	33	to	to	IN
18637	18813	34	what	what	WP
18637	18813	35	are	be	VBP
18637	18813	36	proper	proper	JJ
18637	18813	37	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18813	38	.	.	.
18637	18814	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18814	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	18814	3	enough	enough	JJ
18637	18814	4	if	if	IN
18637	18814	5	*	*	NFP
18637	18814	6	*	*	NFP
18637	18814	7	*	*	NFP
18637	18814	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18814	9	the	the	DT
18637	18814	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18814	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18814	12	can	can	MD
18637	18814	13	not	not	RB
18637	18814	14	say	say	VB
18637	18814	15	that	that	IN
18637	18814	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18814	17	was	be	VBD
18637	18814	18	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	18814	19	for	for	IN
18637	18814	20	a	a	DT
18637	18814	21	fair	fair	JJ
18637	18814	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	18814	23	minded	minded	JJ
18637	18814	24	board	board	NN
18637	18814	25	to	to	TO
18637	18814	26	come	come	VB
18637	18814	27	to	to	IN
18637	18814	28	the	the	DT
18637	18814	29	result	result	NN
18637	18814	30	which	which	WDT
18637	18814	31	was	be	VBD
18637	18814	32	reached	reach	VBN
18637	18814	33	.	.	.
18637	18814	34	"	"	''
18637	18815	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	18815	2	,	,	,
18637	18815	3	in	in	IN
18637	18815	4	reviewing	review	VBG
18637	18815	5	orders	order	NNS
18637	18815	6	of	of	IN
18637	18815	7	the	the	DT
18637	18815	8	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	18815	9	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	18815	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18815	11	,	,	,
18637	18815	12	the	the	DT
18637	18815	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18815	14	,	,	,
18637	18815	15	at	at	IN
18637	18815	16	least	least	JJS
18637	18815	17	in	in	IN
18637	18815	18	earlier	early	JJR
18637	18815	19	years,[209	years,[209	NNP
18637	18815	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18815	21	chose	choose	VBD
18637	18815	22	to	to	TO
18637	18815	23	be	be	VB
18637	18815	24	guided	guide	VBN
18637	18815	25	by	by	IN
18637	18815	26	approximately	approximately	RB
18637	18815	27	the	the	DT
18637	18815	28	same	same	JJ
18637	18815	29	standards	standard	NNS
18637	18815	30	of	of	IN
18637	18815	31	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	18815	32	as	as	IN
18637	18815	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18815	34	had	have	VBD
18637	18815	35	originally	originally	RB
18637	18815	36	formulated	formulate	VBN
18637	18815	37	for	for	IN
18637	18815	38	examining	examine	VBG
18637	18815	39	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18815	40	of	of	IN
18637	18815	41	State	state	NN
18637	18815	42	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	18815	43	;	;	:
18637	18815	44	and	and	CC
18637	18815	45	inasmuch	inasmuch	VB
18637	18815	46	as	as	IN
18637	18815	47	the	the	DT
18637	18815	48	following	follow	VBG
18637	18815	49	excerpt	excerpt	NN
18637	18815	50	from	from	IN
18637	18815	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18815	52	holding	holding	NN
18637	18815	53	in	in	IN
18637	18815	54	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	18815	55	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	18815	56	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18815	57	_	_	NNP
18637	18815	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	18815	59	_	_	NNP
18637	18815	60	Union	Union	NNP
18637	18815	61	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	18815	62	R.	R.	NNP
18637	18815	63	Co.[210	Co.[210	NNP
18637	18815	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18815	65	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	18815	66	an	an	DT
18637	18815	67	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	18815	68	summation	summation	NN
18637	18815	69	of	of	IN
18637	18815	70	the	the	DT
18637	18815	71	law	law	NN
18637	18815	72	as	as	IN
18637	18815	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18815	74	stood	stand	VBD
18637	18815	75	prior	prior	RB
18637	18815	76	to	to	IN
18637	18815	77	1920	1920	CD
18637	18815	78	,	,	,
18637	18815	79	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18815	80	is	be	VBZ
18637	18815	81	set	set	VBN
18637	18815	82	forth	forth	RP
18637	18815	83	below	below	RB
18637	18815	84	:	:	:
18637	18815	85	"	"	``
18637	18815	86	*	*	NFP
18637	18815	87	*	*	NFP
18637	18815	88	*	*	NFP
18637	18815	89	questions	question	NNS
18637	18815	90	of	of	IN
18637	18815	91	fact	fact	NN
18637	18815	92	may	may	MD
18637	18815	93	be	be	VB
18637	18815	94	involved	involve	VBN
18637	18815	95	in	in	IN
18637	18815	96	the	the	DT
18637	18815	97	determination	determination	NN
18637	18815	98	of	of	IN
18637	18815	99	questions	question	NNS
18637	18815	100	of	of	IN
18637	18815	101	law	law	NN
18637	18815	102	,	,	,
18637	18815	103	so	so	IN
18637	18815	104	that	that	IN
18637	18815	105	an	an	DT
18637	18815	106	order	order	NN
18637	18815	107	,	,	,
18637	18815	108	regular	regular	JJ
18637	18815	109	on	on	IN
18637	18815	110	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18815	111	face	face	NN
18637	18815	112	,	,	,
18637	18815	113	may	may	MD
18637	18815	114	be	be	VB
18637	18815	115	set	set	VBN
18637	18815	116	aside	aside	RB
18637	18815	117	if	if	IN
18637	18815	118	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18815	119	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	18815	120	that	that	IN
18637	18815	121	the	the	DT
18637	18815	122	rate	rate	NN
18637	18815	123	is	be	VBZ
18637	18815	124	so	so	RB
18637	18815	125	low	low	JJ
18637	18815	126	as	as	IN
18637	18815	127	to	to	TO
18637	18815	128	be	be	VB
18637	18815	129	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	18815	130	*	*	NFP
18637	18815	131	*	*	NFP
18637	18815	132	*	*	NFP
18637	18815	133	;	;	:
18637	18815	134	or	or	CC
18637	18815	135	if	if	IN
18637	18815	136	the	the	DT
18637	18815	137	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18815	138	acted	act	VBD
18637	18815	139	so	so	RB
18637	18815	140	arbitrarily	arbitrarily	RB
18637	18815	141	and	and	CC
18637	18815	142	unjustly	unjustly	RB
18637	18815	143	as	as	IN
18637	18815	144	to	to	TO
18637	18815	145	fix	fix	VB
18637	18815	146	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18815	147	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	18815	148	to	to	IN
18637	18815	149	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18815	150	,	,	,
18637	18815	151	or	or	CC
18637	18815	152	without	without	IN
18637	18815	153	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18815	154	to	to	TO
18637	18815	155	support	support	VB
18637	18815	156	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18815	157	;	;	:
18637	18815	158	or	or	CC
18637	18815	159	if	if	IN
18637	18815	160	the	the	DT
18637	18815	161	authority	authority	NN
18637	18815	162	therein	therein	RB
18637	18815	163	involved	involve	VBN
18637	18815	164	has	have	VBZ
18637	18815	165	been	be	VBN
18637	18815	166	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	18815	167	in	in	IN
18637	18815	168	such	such	PDT
18637	18815	169	an	an	DT
18637	18815	170	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18815	171	manner	manner	NN
18637	18815	172	as	as	IN
18637	18815	173	to	to	TO
18637	18815	174	cause	cause	VB
18637	18815	175	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18815	176	to	to	TO
18637	18815	177	be	be	VB
18637	18815	178	within	within	IN
18637	18815	179	the	the	DT
18637	18815	180	elementary	elementary	JJ
18637	18815	181	rule	rule	NN
18637	18815	182	that	that	IN
18637	18815	183	the	the	DT
18637	18815	184	substance	substance	NN
18637	18815	185	,	,	,
18637	18815	186	and	and	CC
18637	18815	187	not	not	RB
18637	18815	188	the	the	DT
18637	18815	189	shadow	shadow	NN
18637	18815	190	,	,	,
18637	18815	191	determines	determine	VBZ
18637	18815	192	the	the	DT
18637	18815	193	validity	validity	NN
18637	18815	194	of	of	IN
18637	18815	195	the	the	DT
18637	18815	196	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18815	197	of	of	IN
18637	18815	198	the	the	DT
18637	18815	199	power	power	NN
18637	18815	200	.	.	.
18637	18816	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18816	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18816	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18816	4	In	in	IN
18637	18816	5	determining	determine	VBG
18637	18816	6	these	these	DT
18637	18816	7	mixed	mix	VBN
18637	18816	8	questions	question	NNS
18637	18816	9	of	of	IN
18637	18816	10	law	law	NN
18637	18816	11	and	and	CC
18637	18816	12	fact	fact	NN
18637	18816	13	,	,	,
18637	18816	14	the	the	DT
18637	18816	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18816	16	confines	confine	VBZ
18637	18816	17	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18816	18	to	to	IN
18637	18816	19	the	the	DT
18637	18816	20	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	18816	21	question	question	NN
18637	18816	22	as	as	IN
18637	18816	23	to	to	IN
18637	18816	24	whether	whether	IN
18637	18816	25	the	the	DT
18637	18816	26	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18816	27	acted	act	VBD
18637	18816	28	within	within	IN
18637	18816	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18816	30	power	power	NN
18637	18816	31	.	.	.
18637	18817	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18817	2	will	will	MD
18637	18817	3	not	not	RB
18637	18817	4	consider	consider	VB
18637	18817	5	the	the	DT
18637	18817	6	expediency	expediency	NN
18637	18817	7	or	or	CC
18637	18817	8	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	18817	9	of	of	IN
18637	18817	10	the	the	DT
18637	18817	11	order	order	NN
18637	18817	12	,	,	,
18637	18817	13	or	or	CC
18637	18817	14	whether	whether	IN
18637	18817	15	,	,	,
18637	18817	16	on	on	IN
18637	18817	17	like	like	IN
18637	18817	18	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	18817	19	,	,	,
18637	18817	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18817	21	would	would	MD
18637	18817	22	have	have	VB
18637	18817	23	made	make	VBN
18637	18817	24	a	a	DT
18637	18817	25	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18817	26	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	18817	27	.	.	.
18637	18818	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18818	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18818	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18818	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18818	5	The	the	DT
18637	18818	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18818	7	's	's	POS
18637	18818	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18818	9	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	18818	10	,	,	,
18637	18818	11	of	of	IN
18637	18818	12	course	course	NN
18637	18818	13	,	,	,
18637	18818	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	18818	15	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18818	16	to	to	IN
18637	18818	17	review	review	NN
18637	18818	18	,	,	,
18637	18818	19	but	but	CC
18637	18818	20	when	when	WRB
18637	18818	21	supported	support	VBN
18637	18818	22	by	by	IN
18637	18818	23	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18818	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	18818	25	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	18818	26	as	as	IN
18637	18818	27	final	final	JJ
18637	18818	28	;	;	:
18637	18818	29	not	not	RB
18637	18818	30	that	that	IN
18637	18818	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18818	32	decision	decision	NN
18637	18818	33	,	,	,
18637	18818	34	*	*	NFP
18637	18818	35	*	*	NFP
18637	18818	36	*	*	NFP
18637	18818	37	,	,	,
18637	18818	38	can	can	MD
18637	18818	39	be	be	VB
18637	18818	40	supported	support	VBN
18637	18818	41	by	by	IN
18637	18818	42	a	a	DT
18637	18818	43	mere	mere	JJ
18637	18818	44	scintilla	scintilla	NN
18637	18818	45	of	of	IN
18637	18818	46	proof	proof	NN
18637	18818	47	--	--	:
18637	18818	48	but	but	CC
18637	18818	49	the	the	DT
18637	18818	50	courts	court	NNS
18637	18818	51	will	will	MD
18637	18818	52	not	not	RB
18637	18818	53	examine	examine	VB
18637	18818	54	the	the	DT
18637	18818	55	facts	fact	NNS
18637	18818	56	further	far	RBR
18637	18818	57	than	than	IN
18637	18818	58	to	to	TO
18637	18818	59	determine	determine	VB
18637	18818	60	whether	whether	IN
18637	18818	61	there	there	EX
18637	18818	62	was	be	VBD
18637	18818	63	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	18818	64	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18818	65	to	to	TO
18637	18818	66	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	18818	67	the	the	DT
18637	18818	68	order	order	NN
18637	18818	69	.	.	.
18637	18818	70	"	"	''
18637	18819	1	The	the	DT
18637	18819	2	Ben	Ben	NNP
18637	18819	3	Avon	Avon	NNP
18637	18819	4	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18819	5	These	these	DT
18637	18819	6	standards	standard	NNS
18637	18819	7	of	of	IN
18637	18819	8	review	review	NN
18637	18819	9	were	be	VBD
18637	18819	10	abruptly	abruptly	RB
18637	18819	11	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	18819	12	by	by	IN
18637	18819	13	the	the	DT
18637	18819	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18819	15	in	in	IN
18637	18819	16	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	18819	17	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	18819	18	Water	Water	NNP
18637	18819	19	Company	Company	NNP
18637	18819	20	_	_	NNP
18637	18819	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	18819	22	_	_	NNP
18637	18819	23	Ben	Ben	NNP
18637	18819	24	Avon	Avon	NNP
18637	18819	25	Borough,[211	Borough,[211	NNP
18637	18819	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18819	27	decided	decide	VBN
18637	18819	28	in	in	IN
18637	18819	29	1920	1920	CD
18637	18819	30	,	,	,
18637	18819	31	as	as	IN
18637	18819	32	being	be	VBG
18637	18819	33	no	no	RB
18637	18819	34	longer	longer	RB
18637	18819	35	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	18819	36	to	to	TO
18637	18819	37	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	18819	38	the	the	DT
18637	18819	39	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	18819	40	of	of	IN
18637	18819	41	due	due	JJ
18637	18819	42	process	process	NN
18637	18819	43	.	.	.
18637	18820	1	Unlike	unlike	IN
18637	18820	2	previous	previous	JJ
18637	18820	3	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	18820	4	involving	involve	VBG
18637	18820	5	allegedly	allegedly	RB
18637	18820	6	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	18820	7	rate	rate	NN
18637	18820	8	orders	order	NNS
18637	18820	9	of	of	IN
18637	18820	10	State	state	NN
18637	18820	11	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	18820	12	,	,	,
18637	18820	13	which	which	WDT
18637	18820	14	had	have	VBD
18637	18820	15	developed	develop	VBN
18637	18820	16	from	from	IN
18637	18820	17	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	18820	18	of	of	IN
18637	18820	19	lower	low	JJR
18637	18820	20	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18820	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	18820	22	in	in	IN
18637	18820	23	injunctive	injunctive	JJ
18637	18820	24	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	18820	25	,	,	,
18637	18820	26	this	this	DT
18637	18820	27	case	case	NN
18637	18820	28	reached	reach	VBD
18637	18820	29	the	the	DT
18637	18820	30	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	18820	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18820	32	by	by	IN
18637	18820	33	way	way	NN
18637	18820	34	of	of	IN
18637	18820	35	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	18820	36	from	from	IN
18637	18820	37	a	a	DT
18637	18820	38	State	State	NNP
18637	18820	39	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	18820	40	tribunal;[212	tribunal;[212	NNS
18637	18820	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18820	42	and	and	CC
18637	18820	43	although	although	IN
18637	18820	44	the	the	DT
18637	18820	45	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18820	46	did	do	VBD
18637	18820	47	in	in	IN
18637	18820	48	fact	fact	NN
18637	18820	49	review	review	VB
18637	18820	50	the	the	DT
18637	18820	51	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18820	52	and	and	CC
18637	18820	53	ascertained	ascertain	VBD
18637	18820	54	that	that	IN
18637	18820	55	the	the	DT
18637	18820	56	State	State	NNP
18637	18820	57	commission	commission	NN
18637	18820	58	's	's	POS
18637	18820	59	findings	finding	NNS
18637	18820	60	of	of	IN
18637	18820	61	fact	fact	NN
18637	18820	62	were	be	VBD
18637	18820	63	supported	support	VBN
18637	18820	64	by	by	IN
18637	18820	65	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	18820	66	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18820	67	,	,	,
18637	18820	68	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18820	69	also	also	RB
18637	18820	70	construed	construe	VBD
18637	18820	71	the	the	DT
18637	18820	72	statute	statute	NN
18637	18820	73	providing	provide	VBG
18637	18820	74	for	for	IN
18637	18820	75	review	review	NN
18637	18820	76	as	as	IN
18637	18820	77	denying	deny	VBG
18637	18820	78	to	to	IN
18637	18820	79	State	State	NNP
18637	18820	80	courts	court	NNS
18637	18820	81	"	"	``
18637	18820	82	the	the	DT
18637	18820	83	power	power	NN
18637	18820	84	to	to	TO
18637	18820	85	pass	pass	VB
18637	18820	86	upon	upon	IN
18637	18820	87	the	the	DT
18637	18820	88	weight	weight	NN
18637	18820	89	of	of	IN
18637	18820	90	such	such	JJ
18637	18820	91	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18820	92	.	.	.
18637	18820	93	"	"	''
18637	18821	1	Largely	largely	RB
18637	18821	2	on	on	IN
18637	18821	3	the	the	DT
18637	18821	4	strength	strength	NN
18637	18821	5	of	of	IN
18637	18821	6	this	this	DT
18637	18821	7	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	18821	8	of	of	IN
18637	18821	9	the	the	DT
18637	18821	10	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	18821	11	State	State	NNP
18637	18821	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	18821	13	,	,	,
18637	18821	14	the	the	DT
18637	18821	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	18821	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18821	17	held	hold	VBD
18637	18821	18	that	that	IN
18637	18821	19	when	when	WRB
18637	18821	20	the	the	DT
18637	18821	21	order	order	NN
18637	18821	22	of	of	IN
18637	18821	23	a	a	DT
18637	18821	24	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18821	25	,	,	,
18637	18821	26	or	or	CC
18637	18821	27	of	of	IN
18637	18821	28	a	a	DT
18637	18821	29	commission	commission	NN
18637	18821	30	,	,	,
18637	18821	31	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	18821	32	a	a	DT
18637	18821	33	schedule	schedule	NN
18637	18821	34	of	of	IN
18637	18821	35	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	18821	36	future	future	JJ
18637	18821	37	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18821	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	18821	39	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	18821	40	as	as	IN
18637	18821	41	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	18821	42	,	,	,
18637	18821	43	"	"	''
18637	18821	44	the	the	DT
18637	18821	45	State	State	NNP
18637	18821	46	must	must	MD
18637	18821	47	provide	provide	VB
18637	18821	48	a	a	DT
18637	18821	49	fair	fair	JJ
18637	18821	50	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	18821	51	for	for	IN
18637	18821	52	submitting	submit	VBG
18637	18821	53	that	that	DT
18637	18821	54	issue	issue	NN
18637	18821	55	to	to	IN
18637	18821	56	a	a	DT
18637	18821	57	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18821	58	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	18821	59	for	for	IN
18637	18821	60	determination	determination	NN
18637	18821	61	upon	upon	IN
18637	18821	62	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18821	63	own	own	JJ
18637	18821	64	independent	independent	JJ
18637	18821	65	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18821	66	as	as	IN
18637	18821	67	to	to	IN
18637	18821	68	both	both	DT
18637	18821	69	law	law	NN
18637	18821	70	and	and	CC
18637	18821	71	facts	fact	NNS
18637	18821	72	;	;	:
18637	18821	73	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	18821	74	the	the	DT
18637	18821	75	order	order	NN
18637	18821	76	is	be	VBZ
18637	18821	77	void	void	JJ
18637	18821	78	because	because	IN
18637	18821	79	in	in	IN
18637	18821	80	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	18821	81	with	with	IN
18637	18821	82	the	the	DT
18637	18821	83	due	due	JJ
18637	18821	84	process	process	NN
18637	18821	85	clause	clause	NN
18637	18821	86	,	,	,
18637	18821	87	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18821	88	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18821	89	.	.	.
18637	18821	90	"	"	''
18637	18822	1	Without	without	IN
18637	18822	2	departing	depart	VBG
18637	18822	3	from	from	IN
18637	18822	4	the	the	DT
18637	18822	5	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	18822	6	,	,	,
18637	18822	7	previously	previously	RB
18637	18822	8	enunciated	enunciate	VBN
18637	18822	9	in	in	IN
18637	18822	10	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	18822	11	&	&	CC
18637	18822	12	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	18823	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18823	2	_	_	NNP
18637	18823	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	18823	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18823	5	Garrett,[213	Garrett,[213	NNP
18637	18823	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18823	7	that	that	IN
18637	18823	8	the	the	DT
18637	18823	9	failure	failure	NN
18637	18823	10	of	of	IN
18637	18823	11	a	a	DT
18637	18823	12	State	State	NNP
18637	18823	13	to	to	TO
18637	18823	14	grant	grant	VB
18637	18823	15	a	a	DT
18637	18823	16	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	18823	17	right	right	NN
18637	18823	18	of	of	IN
18637	18823	19	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18823	20	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	18823	21	from	from	IN
18637	18823	22	a	a	DT
18637	18823	23	commission	commission	NN
18637	18823	24	's	's	POS
18637	18823	25	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18823	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	18823	27	not	not	RB
18637	18823	28	violative	violative	JJ
18637	18823	29	of	of	IN
18637	18823	30	due	due	JJ
18637	18823	31	process	process	NN
18637	18823	32	as	as	RB
18637	18823	33	long	long	RB
18637	18823	34	as	as	IN
18637	18823	35	relief	relief	NN
18637	18823	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	18823	37	obtainable	obtainable	JJ
18637	18823	38	by	by	IN
18637	18823	39	a	a	DT
18637	18823	40	bill	bill	NN
18637	18823	41	in	in	IN
18637	18823	42	equity	equity	NN
18637	18823	43	for	for	IN
18637	18823	44	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	18823	45	,	,	,
18637	18823	46	the	the	DT
18637	18823	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18823	48	also	also	RB
18637	18823	49	held	hold	VBD
18637	18823	50	that	that	IN
18637	18823	51	the	the	DT
18637	18823	52	alternative	alternative	JJ
18637	18823	53	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	18823	54	of	of	IN
18637	18823	55	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	18823	56	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	18823	57	provided	provide	VBN
18637	18823	58	by	by	IN
18637	18823	59	State	State	NNP
18637	18823	60	law	law	NN
18637	18823	61	did	do	VBD
18637	18823	62	not	not	RB
18637	18823	63	afford	afford	VB
18637	18823	64	an	an	DT
18637	18823	65	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	18823	66	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	18823	67	for	for	IN
18637	18823	68	testing	test	VBG
18637	18823	69	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	18823	70	a	a	DT
18637	18823	71	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	18823	72	rate	rate	NN
18637	18823	73	order	order	NN
18637	18823	74	.	.	.
18637	18824	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18824	2	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	18824	3	the	the	DT
18637	18824	4	principle	principle	NN
18637	18824	5	stressed	stress	VBN
18637	18824	6	by	by	IN
18637	18824	7	the	the	DT
18637	18824	8	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	18824	9	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	18824	10	that	that	IN
18637	18824	11	"	"	``
18637	18824	12	where	where	WRB
18637	18824	13	a	a	DT
18637	18824	14	State	state	NN
18637	18824	15	offers	offer	VBZ
18637	18824	16	a	a	DT
18637	18824	17	litigant	litigant	NN
18637	18824	18	the	the	DT
18637	18824	19	choice	choice	NN
18637	18824	20	of	of	IN
18637	18824	21	two	two	CD
18637	18824	22	methods	method	NNS
18637	18824	23	of	of	IN
18637	18824	24	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18824	25	review	review	NN
18637	18824	26	,	,	,
18637	18824	27	of	of	IN
18637	18824	28	which	which	WDT
18637	18824	29	one	one	NN
18637	18824	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	18824	31	both	both	CC
18637	18824	32	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	18824	33	and	and	CC
18637	18824	34	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
18637	18824	35	,	,	,
18637	18824	36	the	the	DT
18637	18824	37	mere	mere	JJ
18637	18824	38	fact	fact	NN
18637	18824	39	that	that	IN
18637	18824	40	the	the	DT
18637	18824	41	other	other	JJ
18637	18824	42	which	which	WDT
18637	18824	43	the	the	DT
18637	18824	44	litigant	litigant	NN
18637	18824	45	elects	elect	NNS
18637	18824	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	18824	47	limited	limited	JJ
18637	18824	48	,	,	,
18637	18824	49	does	do	VBZ
18637	18824	50	not	not	RB
18637	18824	51	amount	amount	VB
18637	18824	52	to	to	IN
18637	18824	53	a	a	DT
18637	18824	54	denial	denial	NN
18637	18824	55	of	of	IN
18637	18824	56	the	the	DT
18637	18824	57	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18824	58	right	right	NN
18637	18824	59	to	to	IN
18637	18824	60	a	a	DT
18637	18824	61	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18824	62	review	review	NN
18637	18824	63	.	.	.
18637	18825	1	"	"	``
18637	18825	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18825	3	214	214	CD
18637	18825	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18825	5	History	history	NN
18637	18825	6	of	of	IN
18637	18825	7	the	the	DT
18637	18825	8	Valuation	Valuation	NNP
18637	18825	9	Question	Question	NNP
18637	18825	10	For	for	IN
18637	18825	11	almost	almost	RB
18637	18825	12	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	18825	13	years	year	NNS
18637	18825	14	the	the	DT
18637	18825	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18825	16	was	be	VBD
18637	18825	17	to	to	TO
18637	18825	18	wander	wander	VB
18637	18825	19	through	through	IN
18637	18825	20	a	a	DT
18637	18825	21	maze	maze	NN
18637	18825	22	of	of	IN
18637	18825	23	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	18825	24	formulas	formula	NNS
18637	18825	25	for	for	IN
18637	18825	26	valuing	value	VBG
18637	18825	27	public	public	JJ
18637	18825	28	service	service	NNP
18637	18825	29	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18825	30	property	property	NN
18637	18825	31	only	only	RB
18637	18825	32	to	to	TO
18637	18825	33	emerge	emerge	VB
18637	18825	34	therefrom	therefrom	NNP
18637	18825	35	in	in	IN
18637	18825	36	1944	1944	CD
18637	18825	37	at	at	IN
18637	18825	38	a	a	DT
18637	18825	39	point	point	NN
18637	18825	40	not	not	RB
18637	18825	41	very	very	RB
18637	18825	42	far	far	RB
18637	18825	43	removed	remove	VBN
18637	18825	44	from	from	IN
18637	18825	45	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	18825	46	_	_	NNP
18637	18825	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	18825	48	_	_	NNP
18637	18825	49	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	18825	50	.	.	.
18637	18826	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18826	2	215	215	CD
18637	18826	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18826	4	By	by	IN
18637	18826	5	holding	hold	VBG
18637	18826	6	,	,	,
18637	18826	7	in	in	IN
18637	18826	8	1942	1942	CD
18637	18826	9	,	,	,
18637	18826	10	in	in	IN
18637	18826	11	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18826	12	Power	Power	NNP
18637	18826	13	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18826	14	_	_	NNP
18637	18826	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	18826	16	_	_	NNP
18637	18826	17	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	18826	18	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	18826	19	Pipeline	Pipeline	NNP
18637	18826	20	Co	Co	NNP
18637	18826	21	.	.	.
18637	18826	22	,[216	,[216	NFP
18637	18826	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18826	24	that	that	IN
18637	18826	25	the	the	DT
18637	18826	26	"	"	``
18637	18826	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18826	28	does	do	VBZ
18637	18826	29	not	not	RB
18637	18826	30	bind	bind	VB
18637	18826	31	rate	rate	NN
18637	18826	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	18826	33	making	make	VBG
18637	18826	34	bodies	body	NNS
18637	18826	35	to	to	IN
18637	18826	36	the	the	DT
18637	18826	37	service	service	NN
18637	18826	38	of	of	IN
18637	18826	39	any	any	DT
18637	18826	40	single	single	JJ
18637	18826	41	formula	formula	NN
18637	18826	42	or	or	CC
18637	18826	43	combination	combination	NN
18637	18826	44	of	of	IN
18637	18826	45	formulas	formula	NNS
18637	18826	46	,	,	,
18637	18826	47	"	"	''
18637	18826	48	and	and	CC
18637	18826	49	in	in	IN
18637	18826	50	1944	1944	CD
18637	18826	51	,	,	,
18637	18826	52	in	in	IN
18637	18826	53	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18826	54	Power	Power	NNP
18637	18826	55	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18826	56	_	_	NNP
18637	18826	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	18826	58	_	_	NNP
18637	18826	59	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	18826	60	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	18826	61	Co	Co	NNP
18637	18826	62	.	.	.
18637	18826	63	,[217	,[217	NFP
18637	18826	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18826	65	that	that	IN
18637	18826	66	"	"	``
18637	18826	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18826	68	is	be	VBZ
18637	18826	69	the	the	DT
18637	18826	70	result	result	NN
18637	18826	71	reached	reach	VBD
18637	18826	72	not	not	RB
18637	18826	73	the	the	DT
18637	18826	74	method	method	NN
18637	18826	75	employed	employ	VBN
18637	18826	76	which	which	WDT
18637	18826	77	is	be	VBZ
18637	18826	78	controlling	control	VBG
18637	18826	79	,	,	,
18637	18826	80	*	*	NFP
18637	18826	81	*	*	NFP
18637	18826	82	*	*	NFP
18637	18826	83	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18826	84	that	that	IN
18637	18826	85	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18826	86	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18826	87	is	be	VBZ
18637	18826	88	not	not	RB
18637	18826	89	the	the	DT
18637	18826	90	theory	theory	NN
18637	18826	91	but	but	CC
18637	18826	92	the	the	DT
18637	18826	93	impact	impact	NN
18637	18826	94	of	of	IN
18637	18826	95	the	the	DT
18637	18826	96	rate	rate	NN
18637	18826	97	order	order	NN
18637	18826	98	which	which	WDT
18637	18826	99	counts	count	VBZ
18637	18826	100	,	,	,
18637	18826	101	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18826	102	and	and	CC
18637	18826	103	that	that	IN
18637	18826	104	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18826	105	if	if	IN
18637	18826	106	the	the	DT
18637	18826	107	total	total	JJ
18637	18826	108	effect	effect	NN
18637	18826	109	of	of	IN
18637	18826	110	the	the	DT
18637	18826	111	rate	rate	NN
18637	18826	112	order	order	NN
18637	18826	113	can	can	MD
18637	18826	114	not	not	RB
18637	18826	115	be	be	VB
18637	18826	116	said	say	VBN
18637	18826	117	to	to	TO
18637	18826	118	be	be	VB
18637	18826	119	unjust	unjust	JJ
18637	18826	120	and	and	CC
18637	18826	121	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18826	122	,	,	,
18637	18826	123	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18826	124	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	18826	125	under	under	IN
18637	18826	126	the	the	DT
18637	18826	127	Act	Act	NNP
18637	18826	128	is	be	VBZ
18637	18826	129	at	at	IN
18637	18826	130	an	an	DT
18637	18826	131	end	end	NN
18637	18826	132	,	,	,
18637	18826	133	"	"	''
18637	18826	134	the	the	DT
18637	18826	135	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18826	136	,	,	,
18637	18826	137	in	in	IN
18637	18826	138	effect	effect	NN
18637	18826	139	,	,	,
18637	18826	140	abdicated	abdicate	VBN
18637	18826	141	from	from	IN
18637	18826	142	the	the	DT
18637	18826	143	position	position	NN
18637	18826	144	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	18826	145	in	in	IN
18637	18826	146	the	the	DT
18637	18826	147	Ben	Ben	NNP
18637	18826	148	Avon	Avon	NNP
18637	18826	149	Case	Case	NNP
18637	18826	150	.	.	.
18637	18827	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18827	2	218	218	CD
18637	18827	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18827	4	Without	without	IN
18637	18827	5	surrendering	surrender	VBG
18637	18827	6	the	the	DT
18637	18827	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18827	8	power	power	NN
18637	18827	9	to	to	TO
18637	18827	10	declare	declare	VB
18637	18827	11	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18827	12	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18827	13	on	on	IN
18637	18827	14	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	18827	15	of	of	IN
18637	18827	16	a	a	DT
18637	18827	17	substantive[219	substantive[219	NN
18637	18827	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18827	19	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18827	20	of	of	IN
18637	18827	21	due	due	JJ
18637	18827	22	process	process	NN
18637	18827	23	,	,	,
18637	18827	24	the	the	DT
18637	18827	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18827	26	announced	announce	VBD
18637	18827	27	that	that	IN
18637	18827	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18827	29	would	would	MD
18637	18827	30	not	not	RB
18637	18827	31	overturn	overturn	VB
18637	18827	32	a	a	DT
18637	18827	33	result	result	NN
18637	18827	34	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	18827	35	by	by	IN
18637	18827	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18827	37	to	to	TO
18637	18827	38	be	be	VB
18637	18827	39	just	just	RB
18637	18827	40	simply	simply	RB
18637	18827	41	because	because	IN
18637	18827	42	"	"	``
18637	18827	43	the	the	DT
18637	18827	44	method	method	NN
18637	18827	45	employed	employ	VBN
18637	18827	46	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18827	47	by	by	IN
18637	18827	48	a	a	DT
18637	18827	49	commission	commission	NN
18637	18827	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18827	51	to	to	TO
18637	18827	52	reach	reach	VB
18637	18827	53	that	that	DT
18637	18827	54	result	result	NN
18637	18827	55	may	may	MD
18637	18827	56	contain	contain	VB
18637	18827	57	infirmities	infirmity	NNS
18637	18827	58	.	.	.
18637	18828	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18828	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18828	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18828	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18828	5	A	a	NN
18637	18828	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18828	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18828	8	's	's	POS
18637	18828	9	order	order	NN
18637	18828	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	18828	11	not	not	RB
18637	18828	12	become	become	VB
18637	18828	13	suspect	suspect	NN
18637	18828	14	by	by	IN
18637	18828	15	reason	reason	NN
18637	18828	16	of	of	IN
18637	18828	17	the	the	DT
18637	18828	18	fact	fact	NN
18637	18828	19	that	that	IN
18637	18828	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18828	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	18828	22	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	18828	23	.	.	.
18637	18829	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18829	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	18829	3	the	the	DT
18637	18829	4	product	product	NN
18637	18829	5	of	of	IN
18637	18829	6	expert	expert	JJ
18637	18829	7	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18829	8	which	which	WDT
18637	18829	9	carries	carry	VBZ
18637	18829	10	a	a	DT
18637	18829	11	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	18829	12	of	of	IN
18637	18829	13	validity	validity	NN
18637	18829	14	.	.	.
18637	18830	1	And	and	CC
18637	18830	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18830	3	who	who	WP
18637	18830	4	would	would	MD
18637	18830	5	upset	upset	VB
18637	18830	6	the	the	DT
18637	18830	7	rate	rate	NN
18637	18830	8	order	order	NN
18637	18830	9	*	*	NFP
18637	18830	10	*	*	NFP
18637	18830	11	*	*	NFP
18637	18830	12	carries	carry	VBZ
18637	18830	13	the	the	DT
18637	18830	14	heavy	heavy	JJ
18637	18830	15	burden	burden	NN
18637	18830	16	of	of	IN
18637	18830	17	making	make	VBG
18637	18830	18	a	a	DT
18637	18830	19	convincing	convincing	JJ
18637	18830	20	showing	showing	NN
18637	18830	21	that	that	IN
18637	18830	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18830	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	18830	24	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	18830	25	because	because	IN
18637	18830	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18830	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	18830	28	unjust	unjust	JJ
18637	18830	29	and	and	CC
18637	18830	30	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18830	31	in	in	IN
18637	18830	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18830	33	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	18830	34	.	.	.
18637	18831	1	"	"	``
18637	18831	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18831	3	220	220	CD
18637	18831	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18831	5	In	in	IN
18637	18831	6	dispensing	dispense	VBG
18637	18831	7	with	with	IN
18637	18831	8	the	the	DT
18637	18831	9	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	18831	10	of	of	IN
18637	18831	11	observing	observe	VBG
18637	18831	12	any	any	DT
18637	18831	13	of	of	IN
18637	18831	14	the	the	DT
18637	18831	15	formulas	formula	NNS
18637	18831	16	for	for	IN
18637	18831	17	rate	rate	NN
18637	18831	18	computation	computation	NN
18637	18831	19	which	which	WDT
18637	18831	20	previously	previously	RB
18637	18831	21	had	have	VBD
18637	18831	22	currency	currency	NN
18637	18831	23	,	,	,
18637	18831	24	the	the	DT
18637	18831	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18831	26	did	do	VBD
18637	18831	27	not	not	RB
18637	18831	28	undertake	undertake	VB
18637	18831	29	to	to	TO
18637	18831	30	devise	devise	VB
18637	18831	31	,	,	,
18637	18831	32	by	by	IN
18637	18831	33	way	way	NN
18637	18831	34	of	of	IN
18637	18831	35	substitution	substitution	NN
18637	18831	36	,	,	,
18637	18831	37	any	any	DT
18637	18831	38	discernible	discernible	JJ
18637	18831	39	guide	guide	NN
18637	18831	40	to	to	TO
18637	18831	41	aid	aid	VB
18637	18831	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18831	43	in	in	IN
18637	18831	44	ascertaining	ascertain	VBG
18637	18831	45	whether	whether	IN
18637	18831	46	a	a	DT
18637	18831	47	so	so	RB
18637	18831	48	-	-	HYPH
18637	18831	49	called	call	VBN
18637	18831	50	end	end	NN
18637	18831	51	result	result	NN
18637	18831	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	18831	53	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18831	54	.	.	.
18637	18832	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18832	2	did	do	VBD
18637	18832	3	intimate	intimate	JJ
18637	18832	4	that	that	DT
18637	18832	5	rate	rate	NN
18637	18832	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	18832	7	making	make	VBG
18637	18832	8	"	"	''
18637	18832	9	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	18832	10	a	a	DT
18637	18832	11	balancing	balancing	NN
18637	18832	12	of	of	IN
18637	18832	13	the	the	DT
18637	18832	14	investor	investor	NN
18637	18832	15	and	and	CC
18637	18832	16	consumer	consumer	NN
18637	18832	17	interests	interest	NNS
18637	18832	18	,	,	,
18637	18832	19	"	"	''
18637	18832	20	which	which	WDT
18637	18832	21	does	do	VBZ
18637	18832	22	not	not	RB
18637	18832	23	,	,	,
18637	18832	24	however	however	RB
18637	18832	25	,	,	,
18637	18832	26	"	"	``
18637	18832	27	'	'	``
18637	18832	28	insure	insure	VBP
18637	18832	29	that	that	IN
18637	18832	30	the	the	DT
18637	18832	31	business	business	NN
18637	18832	32	shall	shall	MD
18637	18832	33	produce	produce	VB
18637	18832	34	net	net	JJ
18637	18832	35	revenues	revenue	NNS
18637	18832	36	,	,	,
18637	18832	37	'	'	''
18637	18832	38	*	*	NFP
18637	18832	39	*	*	NFP
18637	18832	40	*	*	NFP
18637	18832	41	From	from	IN
18637	18832	42	the	the	DT
18637	18832	43	investor	investor	NN
18637	18832	44	or	or	CC
18637	18832	45	company	company	NN
18637	18832	46	point	point	NN
18637	18832	47	of	of	IN
18637	18832	48	view	view	NN
18637	18832	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18832	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	18832	51	important	important	JJ
18637	18832	52	that	that	IN
18637	18832	53	there	there	EX
18637	18832	54	be	be	VB
18637	18832	55	enough	enough	JJ
18637	18832	56	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	18832	57	not	not	RB
18637	18832	58	only	only	RB
18637	18832	59	for	for	IN
18637	18832	60	operating	operating	NN
18637	18832	61	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	18832	62	but	but	CC
18637	18832	63	also	also	RB
18637	18832	64	for	for	IN
18637	18832	65	the	the	DT
18637	18832	66	capital	capital	NN
18637	18832	67	costs	cost	NNS
18637	18832	68	of	of	IN
18637	18832	69	the	the	DT
18637	18832	70	business	business	NN
18637	18832	71	.	.	.
18637	18833	1	These	these	DT
18637	18833	2	include	include	VBP
18637	18833	3	service	service	NN
18637	18833	4	on	on	IN
18637	18833	5	the	the	DT
18637	18833	6	debt	debt	NN
18637	18833	7	and	and	CC
18637	18833	8	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	18833	9	on	on	IN
18637	18833	10	the	the	DT
18637	18833	11	stock	stock	NN
18637	18833	12	.	.	.
18637	18834	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18834	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18834	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18834	4	By	by	IN
18637	18834	5	that	that	DT
18637	18834	6	standard	standard	NN
18637	18834	7	the	the	DT
18637	18834	8	return	return	NN
18637	18834	9	to	to	IN
18637	18834	10	the	the	DT
18637	18834	11	equity	equity	NN
18637	18834	12	owner	owner	NN
18637	18834	13	should	should	MD
18637	18834	14	be	be	VB
18637	18834	15	commensurate	commensurate	JJ
18637	18834	16	with	with	IN
18637	18834	17	returns	return	NNS
18637	18834	18	on	on	IN
18637	18834	19	investments	investment	NNS
18637	18834	20	in	in	IN
18637	18834	21	other	other	JJ
18637	18834	22	enterprises	enterprise	NNS
18637	18834	23	having	have	VBG
18637	18834	24	corresponding	correspond	VBG
18637	18834	25	risks	risk	NNS
18637	18834	26	.	.	.
18637	18835	1	That	that	DT
18637	18835	2	return	return	NN
18637	18835	3	,	,	,
18637	18835	4	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	18835	5	,	,	,
18637	18835	6	should	should	MD
18637	18835	7	be	be	VB
18637	18835	8	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	18835	9	to	to	TO
18637	18835	10	assure	assure	VB
18637	18835	11	confidence	confidence	NN
18637	18835	12	in	in	IN
18637	18835	13	the	the	DT
18637	18835	14	financial	financial	JJ
18637	18835	15	integrity	integrity	NN
18637	18835	16	of	of	IN
18637	18835	17	the	the	DT
18637	18835	18	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	18835	19	,	,	,
18637	18835	20	so	so	IN
18637	18835	21	as	as	IN
18637	18835	22	to	to	TO
18637	18835	23	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	18835	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18835	25	credit	credit	NN
18637	18835	26	and	and	CC
18637	18835	27	to	to	TO
18637	18835	28	attract	attract	VB
18637	18835	29	capital	capital	NN
18637	18835	30	.	.	.
18637	18836	1	"	"	``
18637	18836	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18836	3	221	221	CD
18637	18836	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18836	5	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	18836	6	,	,	,
18637	18836	7	in	in	IN
18637	18836	8	the	the	DT
18637	18836	9	light	light	NN
18637	18836	10	of	of	IN
18637	18836	11	the	the	DT
18637	18836	12	court	court	NN
18637	18836	13	's	's	POS
18637	18836	14	concentration	concentration	NN
18637	18836	15	on	on	IN
18637	18836	16	the	the	DT
18637	18836	17	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	18836	18	of	of	IN
18637	18836	19	the	the	DT
18637	18836	20	final	final	JJ
18637	18836	21	result	result	NN
18637	18836	22	rather	rather	RB
18637	18836	23	than	than	IN
18637	18836	24	on	on	IN
18637	18836	25	the	the	DT
18637	18836	26	correctness	correctness	NN
18637	18836	27	of	of	IN
18637	18836	28	the	the	DT
18637	18836	29	methods	method	NNS
18637	18836	30	employed	employ	VBN
18637	18836	31	to	to	TO
18637	18836	32	reach	reach	VB
18637	18836	33	that	that	DT
18637	18836	34	result	result	NN
18637	18836	35	,	,	,
18637	18836	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18836	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	18836	38	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
18637	18836	39	that	that	IN
18637	18836	40	methods	method	NNS
18637	18836	41	or	or	CC
18637	18836	42	formulas	formula	NNS
18637	18836	43	,	,	,
18637	18836	44	now	now	RB
18637	18836	45	discredited	discredit	VBN
18637	18836	46	in	in	IN
18637	18836	47	whole	whole	NN
18637	18836	48	or	or	CC
18637	18836	49	in	in	IN
18637	18836	50	part	part	NN
18637	18836	51	,	,	,
18637	18836	52	might	may	MD
18637	18836	53	continue	continue	VB
18637	18836	54	to	to	TO
18637	18836	55	be	be	VB
18637	18836	56	observed	observe	VBN
18637	18836	57	by	by	IN
18637	18836	58	State	state	NN
18637	18836	59	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	18836	60	in	in	IN
18637	18836	61	drafting	draft	VBG
18637	18836	62	rate	rate	NN
18637	18836	63	orders	order	NNS
18637	18836	64	that	that	WDT
18637	18836	65	will	will	MD
18637	18836	66	prove	prove	VB
18637	18836	67	to	to	TO
18637	18836	68	be	be	VB
18637	18836	69	justiciably	justiciably	RB
18637	18836	70	sustainable	sustainable	JJ
18637	18836	71	.	.	.
18637	18837	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18837	2	222	222	CD
18637	18837	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18837	4	REGULATION	regulation	NN
18637	18837	5	OF	of	IN
18637	18837	6	PUBLIC	public	NN
18637	18837	7	UTILITIES	utility	NNS
18637	18837	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18837	9	OTHER	other	JJ
18637	18837	10	THAN	than	IN
18637	18837	11	RATES	rate	NNS
18637	18837	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18837	13	In	in	IN
18637	18837	14	General	General	NNP
18637	18837	15	By	by	IN
18637	18837	16	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	18837	17	of	of	IN
18637	18837	18	the	the	DT
18637	18837	19	nature	nature	NN
18637	18837	20	of	of	IN
18637	18837	21	the	the	DT
18637	18837	22	business	business	NN
18637	18837	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18837	24	carry	carry	VBP
18637	18837	25	on	on	RP
18637	18837	26	and	and	CC
18637	18837	27	the	the	DT
18637	18837	28	public	public	NN
18637	18837	29	's	's	POS
18637	18837	30	interest	interest	NN
18637	18837	31	in	in	IN
18637	18837	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18837	33	,	,	,
18637	18837	34	public	public	JJ
18637	18837	35	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	18837	36	are	be	VBP
18637	18837	37	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18837	38	,	,	,
18637	18837	39	as	as	IN
18637	18837	40	to	to	IN
18637	18837	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18837	42	local	local	JJ
18637	18837	43	business	business	NN
18637	18837	44	,	,	,
18637	18837	45	to	to	IN
18637	18837	46	State	state	NN
18637	18837	47	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18837	48	exerted	exert	VBD
18637	18837	49	either	either	CC
18637	18837	50	directly	directly	RB
18637	18837	51	by	by	IN
18637	18837	52	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18837	53	or	or	CC
18637	18837	54	by	by	IN
18637	18837	55	duly	duly	RB
18637	18837	56	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	18837	57	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	18837	58	bodies	body	NNS
18637	18837	59	.	.	.
18637	18838	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18838	2	223	223	CD
18637	18838	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18838	4	But	but	CC
18637	18838	5	inasmuch	inasmuch	VB
18637	18838	6	as	as	IN
18637	18838	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18838	8	property	property	NN
18637	18838	9	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	18838	10	under	under	IN
18637	18838	11	the	the	DT
18637	18838	12	full	full	JJ
18637	18838	13	protection	protection	NN
18637	18838	14	of	of	IN
18637	18838	15	the	the	DT
18637	18838	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18838	17	,	,	,
18637	18838	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18838	19	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	18838	20	that	that	IN
18637	18838	21	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	18838	22	this	this	DT
18637	18838	23	power	power	NN
18637	18838	24	of	of	IN
18637	18838	25	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18838	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	18838	27	exerted	exert	VBN
18637	18838	28	in	in	IN
18637	18838	29	what	what	WP
18637	18838	30	the	the	DT
18637	18838	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18838	32	considers	consider	VBZ
18637	18838	33	to	to	TO
18637	18838	34	be	be	VB
18637	18838	35	an	an	DT
18637	18838	36	"	"	``
18637	18838	37	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18838	38	"	"	''
18637	18838	39	or	or	CC
18637	18838	40	"	"	``
18637	18838	41	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18838	42	"	"	''
18637	18838	43	way	way	NN
18637	18838	44	and	and	CC
18637	18838	45	to	to	TO
18637	18838	46	be	be	VB
18637	18838	47	in	in	IN
18637	18838	48	effect	effect	NN
18637	18838	49	an	an	DT
18637	18838	50	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	18838	51	upon	upon	IN
18637	18838	52	the	the	DT
18637	18838	53	right	right	NN
18637	18838	54	of	of	IN
18637	18838	55	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	18838	56	,	,	,
18637	18838	57	such	such	JJ
18637	18838	58	exertion	exertion	NN
18637	18838	59	of	of	IN
18637	18838	60	power	power	NN
18637	18838	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	18838	62	void	void	JJ
18637	18838	63	as	as	IN
18637	18838	64	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	18838	65	to	to	IN
18637	18838	66	the	the	DT
18637	18838	67	due	due	JJ
18637	18838	68	process	process	NN
18637	18838	69	clause	clause	NN
18637	18838	70	.	.	.
18637	18839	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18839	2	224	224	CD
18637	18839	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18839	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18839	5	,	,	,
18637	18839	6	a	a	DT
18637	18839	7	city	city	NN
18637	18839	8	can	can	MD
18637	18839	9	not	not	RB
18637	18839	10	take	take	VB
18637	18839	11	possession	possession	NN
18637	18839	12	of	of	IN
18637	18839	13	the	the	DT
18637	18839	14	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	18839	15	of	of	IN
18637	18839	16	a	a	DT
18637	18839	17	street	street	NN
18637	18839	18	railway	railway	NN
18637	18839	19	company	company	NN
18637	18839	20	,	,	,
18637	18839	21	the	the	DT
18637	18839	22	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	18839	23	of	of	IN
18637	18839	24	which	which	WDT
18637	18839	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	18839	26	expired,[225	expired,[225	JJ
18637	18839	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18839	28	although	although	IN
18637	18839	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18839	30	may	may	MD
18637	18839	31	subject	subject	VB
18637	18839	32	said	say	VBD
18637	18839	33	company	company	NN
18637	18839	34	to	to	IN
18637	18839	35	the	the	DT
18637	18839	36	alternative	alternative	NN
18637	18839	37	of	of	IN
18637	18839	38	accepting	accept	VBG
18637	18839	39	an	an	DT
18637	18839	40	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
18637	18839	41	price	price	NN
18637	18839	42	for	for	IN
18637	18839	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18839	44	property	property	NN
18637	18839	45	or	or	CC
18637	18839	46	of	of	IN
18637	18839	47	ceasing	cease	VBG
18637	18839	48	operations	operation	NNS
18637	18839	49	and	and	CC
18637	18839	50	removing	remove	VBG
18637	18839	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18839	52	property	property	NN
18637	18839	53	from	from	IN
18637	18839	54	the	the	DT
18637	18839	55	streets	street	NNS
18637	18839	56	.	.	.
18637	18840	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18840	2	226	226	CD
18637	18840	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18840	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	18840	5	,	,	,
18637	18840	6	a	a	DT
18637	18840	7	city	city	NN
18637	18840	8	,	,	,
18637	18840	9	which	which	WDT
18637	18840	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	18840	11	desirous	desirous	JJ
18637	18840	12	of	of	IN
18637	18840	13	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	18840	14	a	a	DT
18637	18840	15	lighting	lighting	NN
18637	18840	16	system	system	NN
18637	18840	17	of	of	IN
18637	18840	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18840	19	own	own	JJ
18637	18840	20	,	,	,
18637	18840	21	may	may	MD
18637	18840	22	not	not	RB
18637	18840	23	remove	remove	VB
18637	18840	24	,	,	,
18637	18840	25	without	without	IN
18637	18840	26	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18840	27	,	,	,
18637	18840	28	the	the	DT
18637	18840	29	fixtures	fixture	NNS
18637	18840	30	of	of	IN
18637	18840	31	a	a	DT
18637	18840	32	lighting	lighting	NN
18637	18840	33	company	company	NN
18637	18840	34	already	already	RB
18637	18840	35	occupying	occupy	VBG
18637	18840	36	the	the	DT
18637	18840	37	streets	street	NNS
18637	18840	38	under	under	IN
18637	18840	39	a	a	DT
18637	18840	40	franchise;[227	franchise;[227	CD
18637	18840	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18840	42	but	but	CC
18637	18840	43	in	in	IN
18637	18840	44	erecting	erect	VBG
18637	18840	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18840	46	own	own	JJ
18637	18840	47	waterworks	waterworks	NN
18637	18840	48	in	in	IN
18637	18840	49	competition	competition	NN
18637	18840	50	with	with	IN
18637	18840	51	that	that	DT
18637	18840	52	of	of	IN
18637	18840	53	a	a	DT
18637	18840	54	company	company	NN
18637	18840	55	which	which	WDT
18637	18840	56	has	have	VBZ
18637	18840	57	no	no	DT
18637	18840	58	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	18840	59	charter	charter	NN
18637	18840	60	,	,	,
18637	18840	61	a	a	DT
18637	18840	62	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	18840	63	inflicts	inflict	VBZ
18637	18840	64	no	no	DT
18637	18840	65	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18840	66	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18840	67	.	.	.
18637	18841	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18841	2	228	228	CD
18637	18841	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18841	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	18841	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	18841	6	the	the	DT
18637	18841	7	property	property	NN
18637	18841	8	of	of	IN
18637	18841	9	a	a	DT
18637	18841	10	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	18841	11	company	company	NN
18637	18841	12	illegally	illegally	RB
18637	18841	13	taken	take	VBN
18637	18841	14	by	by	IN
18637	18841	15	a	a	DT
18637	18841	16	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	18841	17	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	18841	18	which	which	WDT
18637	18841	19	demands	demand	VBZ
18637	18841	20	,	,	,
18637	18841	21	as	as	IN
18637	18841	22	a	a	DT
18637	18841	23	condition	condition	NN
18637	18841	24	of	of	IN
18637	18841	25	the	the	DT
18637	18841	26	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	18841	27	of	of	IN
18637	18841	28	poles	pole	NNS
18637	18841	29	and	and	CC
18637	18841	30	conduits	conduit	NNS
18637	18841	31	in	in	IN
18637	18841	32	the	the	DT
18637	18841	33	city	city	NN
18637	18841	34	streets	street	NNS
18637	18841	35	,	,	,
18637	18841	36	that	that	IN
18637	18841	37	positions	position	NNS
18637	18841	38	be	be	VB
18637	18841	39	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	18841	40	for	for	IN
18637	18841	41	the	the	DT
18637	18841	42	city	city	NN
18637	18841	43	's	's	POS
18637	18841	44	wires	wire	NNS
18637	18841	45	,	,	,
18637	18841	46	which	which	WDT
18637	18841	47	shall	shall	MD
18637	18841	48	be	be	VB
18637	18841	49	carried	carry	VBN
18637	18841	50	free	free	JJ
18637	18841	51	of	of	IN
18637	18841	52	charge	charge	NN
18637	18841	53	,	,	,
18637	18841	54	and	and	CC
18637	18841	55	which	which	WDT
18637	18841	56	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	18841	57	for	for	IN
18637	18841	58	the	the	DT
18637	18841	59	moving	moving	NN
18637	18841	60	of	of	IN
18637	18841	61	the	the	DT
18637	18841	62	conduits	conduit	NNS
18637	18841	63	,	,	,
18637	18841	64	when	when	WRB
18637	18841	65	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18841	66	,	,	,
18637	18841	67	at	at	IN
18637	18841	68	company	company	NN
18637	18841	69	expense	expense	NN
18637	18841	70	.	.	.
18637	18842	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18842	2	229	229	CD
18637	18842	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18842	4	And	and	CC
18637	18842	5	,	,	,
18637	18842	6	the	the	DT
18637	18842	7	fact	fact	NN
18637	18842	8	that	that	IN
18637	18842	9	a	a	DT
18637	18842	10	State	state	NN
18637	18842	11	,	,	,
18637	18842	12	by	by	IN
18637	18842	13	mere	mere	JJ
18637	18842	14	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18842	15	or	or	CC
18637	18842	16	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	18842	17	fiat	fiat	NN
18637	18842	18	,	,	,
18637	18842	19	can	can	MD
18637	18842	20	not	not	RB
18637	18842	21	convert	convert	VB
18637	18842	22	a	a	DT
18637	18842	23	private	private	JJ
18637	18842	24	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18842	25	into	into	IN
18637	18842	26	a	a	DT
18637	18842	27	common	common	JJ
18637	18842	28	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18842	29	will	will	MD
18637	18842	30	not	not	RB
18637	18842	31	protect	protect	VB
18637	18842	32	a	a	DT
18637	18842	33	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18842	34	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18842	35	which	which	WDT
18637	18842	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	18842	37	elected	elect	VBN
18637	18842	38	to	to	TO
18637	18842	39	enter	enter	VB
18637	18842	40	a	a	DT
18637	18842	41	State	state	NN
18637	18842	42	,	,	,
18637	18842	43	the	the	DT
18637	18842	44	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18842	45	and	and	CC
18637	18842	46	laws	law	NNS
18637	18842	47	of	of	IN
18637	18842	48	which	which	WDT
18637	18842	49	require	require	VBP
18637	18842	50	that	that	IN
18637	18842	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18842	52	operate	operate	VBP
18637	18842	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18842	54	local	local	JJ
18637	18842	55	private	private	JJ
18637	18842	56	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	18842	57	line	line	NN
18637	18842	58	as	as	IN
18637	18842	59	a	a	DT
18637	18842	60	common	common	JJ
18637	18842	61	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18842	62	.	.	.
18637	18843	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	18843	2	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18843	3	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18843	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	18843	5	viewed	view	VBN
18637	18843	6	as	as	IN
18637	18843	7	having	have	VBG
18637	18843	8	waived	waive	VBN
18637	18843	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18843	10	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18843	11	right	right	NN
18637	18843	12	to	to	TO
18637	18843	13	be	be	VB
18637	18843	14	secure	secure	JJ
18637	18843	15	against	against	IN
18637	18843	16	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	18843	17	of	of	IN
18637	18843	18	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	18843	19	which	which	WDT
18637	18843	20	amount	amount	VBP
18637	18843	21	to	to	IN
18637	18843	22	a	a	DT
18637	18843	23	taking	taking	NN
18637	18843	24	of	of	IN
18637	18843	25	property	property	NN
18637	18843	26	without	without	IN
18637	18843	27	due	due	JJ
18637	18843	28	process	process	NN
18637	18843	29	of	of	IN
18637	18843	30	law	law	NN
18637	18843	31	.	.	.
18637	18844	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18844	2	230	230	CD
18637	18844	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18844	4	Compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	18844	5	Expenditures	expenditure	NNS
18637	18844	6	The	the	DT
18637	18844	7	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18844	8	of	of	IN
18637	18844	9	uncompensated	uncompensated	JJ
18637	18844	10	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	18844	11	to	to	IN
18637	18844	12	a	a	DT
18637	18844	13	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18844	14	for	for	IN
18637	18844	15	the	the	DT
18637	18844	16	public	public	JJ
18637	18844	17	health	health	NN
18637	18844	18	and	and	CC
18637	18844	19	safety	safety	NN
18637	18844	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	18844	21	not	not	RB
18637	18844	22	an	an	DT
18637	18844	23	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18844	24	taking	taking	NN
18637	18844	25	of	of	IN
18637	18844	26	property	property	NN
18637	18844	27	without	without	IN
18637	18844	28	due	due	JJ
18637	18844	29	process	process	NN
18637	18844	30	of	of	IN
18637	18844	31	law	law	NN
18637	18844	32	.	.	.
18637	18845	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18845	2	231	231	CD
18637	18845	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18845	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18845	5	,	,	,
18637	18845	6	where	where	WRB
18637	18845	7	the	the	DT
18637	18845	8	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	18845	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	18845	10	so	so	RB
18637	18845	11	required	require	VBN
18637	18845	12	at	at	IN
18637	18845	13	the	the	DT
18637	18845	14	time	time	NN
18637	18845	15	of	of	IN
18637	18845	16	the	the	DT
18637	18845	17	granting	granting	NN
18637	18845	18	of	of	IN
18637	18845	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18845	20	charter	charter	NN
18637	18845	21	,	,	,
18637	18845	22	a	a	DT
18637	18845	23	water	water	NN
18637	18845	24	company	company	NN
18637	18845	25	may	may	MD
18637	18845	26	be	be	VB
18637	18845	27	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	18845	28	to	to	TO
18637	18845	29	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	18845	30	connections	connection	NNS
18637	18845	31	at	at	IN
18637	18845	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18845	33	own	own	JJ
18637	18845	34	expense	expense	NN
18637	18845	35	to	to	IN
18637	18845	36	one	one	CD
18637	18845	37	residing	reside	VBG
18637	18845	38	on	on	IN
18637	18845	39	an	an	DT
18637	18845	40	ungraded	ungraded	JJ
18637	18845	41	street	street	NN
18637	18845	42	in	in	IN
18637	18845	43	which	which	WDT
18637	18845	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18845	45	voluntarily	voluntarily	RB
18637	18845	46	laid	lay	VBD
18637	18845	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18845	48	lines	line	NNS
18637	18845	49	.	.	.
18637	18846	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18846	2	232	232	CD
18637	18846	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18846	4	However	however	RB
18637	18846	5	,	,	,
18637	18846	6	if	if	IN
18637	18846	7	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	18846	8	and	and	CC
18637	18846	9	telephone	telephone	NN
18637	18846	10	lines	line	NNS
18637	18846	11	are	be	VBP
18637	18846	12	located	locate	VBN
18637	18846	13	on	on	IN
18637	18846	14	a	a	DT
18637	18846	15	right	right	NN
18637	18846	16	of	of	IN
18637	18846	17	way	way	NN
18637	18846	18	owned	own	VBN
18637	18846	19	by	by	IN
18637	18846	20	a	a	DT
18637	18846	21	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	18846	22	line	line	NN
18637	18846	23	company	company	NN
18637	18846	24	,	,	,
18637	18846	25	the	the	DT
18637	18846	26	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18846	27	can	can	MD
18637	18846	28	not	not	RB
18637	18846	29	,	,	,
18637	18846	30	without	without	IN
18637	18846	31	a	a	DT
18637	18846	32	denial	denial	NN
18637	18846	33	of	of	IN
18637	18846	34	due	due	JJ
18637	18846	35	process	process	NN
18637	18846	36	,	,	,
18637	18846	37	be	be	VB
18637	18846	38	required	require	VBN
18637	18846	39	to	to	TO
18637	18846	40	relocate	relocate	VB
18637	18846	41	such	such	JJ
18637	18846	42	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	18846	43	at	at	IN
18637	18846	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18846	45	own	own	JJ
18637	18846	46	expense;[233	expense;[233	NNS
18637	18846	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18846	48	but	but	CC
18637	18846	49	if	if	IN
18637	18846	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18846	51	pipes	pipe	NNS
18637	18846	52	are	be	VBP
18637	18846	53	laid	lay	VBN
18637	18846	54	under	under	IN
18637	18846	55	city	city	NN
18637	18846	56	streets	street	NNS
18637	18846	57	,	,	,
18637	18846	58	a	a	DT
18637	18846	59	gas	gas	NN
18637	18846	60	company	company	NN
18637	18846	61	validly	validly	RB
18637	18846	62	may	may	MD
18637	18846	63	be	be	VB
18637	18846	64	obligated	obligate	VBN
18637	18846	65	to	to	TO
18637	18846	66	assume	assume	VB
18637	18846	67	the	the	DT
18637	18846	68	cost	cost	NN
18637	18846	69	of	of	IN
18637	18846	70	moving	move	VBG
18637	18846	71	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18846	72	to	to	TO
18637	18846	73	accommodate	accommodate	VB
18637	18846	74	a	a	DT
18637	18846	75	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	18846	76	drainage	drainage	NN
18637	18846	77	system	system	NN
18637	18846	78	.	.	.
18637	18847	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18847	2	234	234	CD
18637	18847	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18847	4	To	to	TO
18637	18847	5	require	require	VB
18637	18847	6	a	a	DT
18637	18847	7	turnpike	turnpike	JJ
18637	18847	8	company	company	NN
18637	18847	9	,	,	,
18637	18847	10	as	as	IN
18637	18847	11	a	a	DT
18637	18847	12	condition	condition	NN
18637	18847	13	of	of	IN
18637	18847	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18847	15	taking	take	VBG
18637	18847	16	tolls	toll	NNS
18637	18847	17	,	,	,
18637	18847	18	to	to	TO
18637	18847	19	keep	keep	VB
18637	18847	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18847	21	road	road	NN
18637	18847	22	in	in	IN
18637	18847	23	repair	repair	NN
18637	18847	24	and	and	CC
18637	18847	25	to	to	TO
18637	18847	26	suspend	suspend	VB
18637	18847	27	collection	collection	NN
18637	18847	28	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18847	29	,	,	,
18637	18847	30	conformably	conformably	RB
18637	18847	31	to	to	IN
18637	18847	32	a	a	DT
18637	18847	33	State	State	NNP
18637	18847	34	statute	statute	NN
18637	18847	35	,	,	,
18637	18847	36	until	until	IN
18637	18847	37	the	the	DT
18637	18847	38	road	road	NN
18637	18847	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	18847	40	put	put	VBN
18637	18847	41	in	in	IN
18637	18847	42	good	good	JJ
18637	18847	43	order	order	NN
18637	18847	44	,	,	,
18637	18847	45	does	do	VBZ
18637	18847	46	not	not	RB
18637	18847	47	take	take	VB
18637	18847	48	property	property	NN
18637	18847	49	without	without	IN
18637	18847	50	due	due	JJ
18637	18847	51	process	process	NN
18637	18847	52	of	of	IN
18637	18847	53	law	law	NN
18637	18847	54	,	,	,
18637	18847	55	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	18847	56	the	the	DT
18637	18847	57	fact	fact	NN
18637	18847	58	that	that	IN
18637	18847	59	present	present	JJ
18637	18847	60	patronage	patronage	NN
18637	18847	61	does	do	VBZ
18637	18847	62	not	not	RB
18637	18847	63	yield	yield	VB
18637	18847	64	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	18847	65	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	18847	66	to	to	TO
18637	18847	67	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	18847	68	the	the	DT
18637	18847	69	road	road	NN
18637	18847	70	in	in	IN
18637	18847	71	proper	proper	JJ
18637	18847	72	condition	condition	NN
18637	18847	73	.	.	.
18637	18848	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18848	2	235	235	CD
18637	18848	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18848	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	18848	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	18848	6	a	a	DT
18637	18848	7	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18848	8	bridge	bridge	NN
18637	18848	9	company	company	NN
18637	18848	10	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	RB
18637	18848	11	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	18848	12	of	of	IN
18637	18848	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18848	14	property	property	NN
18637	18848	15	when	when	WRB
18637	18848	16	,	,	,
18637	18848	17	in	in	IN
18637	18848	18	the	the	DT
18637	18848	19	absence	absence	NN
18637	18848	20	of	of	IN
18637	18848	21	proof	proof	NN
18637	18848	22	that	that	IN
18637	18848	23	the	the	DT
18637	18848	24	addition	addition	NN
18637	18848	25	will	will	MD
18637	18848	26	not	not	RB
18637	18848	27	yield	yield	VB
18637	18848	28	a	a	DT
18637	18848	29	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18848	30	return	return	NN
18637	18848	31	,	,	,
18637	18848	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18848	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	18848	34	ordered	order	VBN
18637	18848	35	to	to	TO
18637	18848	36	widen	widen	VB
18637	18848	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18848	38	bridge	bridge	NN
18637	18848	39	by	by	IN
18637	18848	40	inclusion	inclusion	NN
18637	18848	41	of	of	IN
18637	18848	42	a	a	DT
18637	18848	43	pathway	pathway	NN
18637	18848	44	for	for	IN
18637	18848	45	pedestrians	pedestrian	NNS
18637	18848	46	and	and	CC
18637	18848	47	a	a	DT
18637	18848	48	roadway	roadway	NN
18637	18848	49	for	for	IN
18637	18848	50	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	18848	51	.	.	.
18637	18849	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18849	2	236	236	CD
18637	18849	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18849	4	Grade	Grade	NNP
18637	18849	5	Crossings	Crossings	NNPS
18637	18849	6	and	and	CC
18637	18849	7	Other	other	JJ
18637	18849	8	Expenditures	Expenditures	NNPS
18637	18849	9	by	by	IN
18637	18849	10	Railroads.--When	Railroads.--When	NNS
18637	18849	11	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	18849	12	are	be	VBP
18637	18849	13	required	require	VBN
18637	18849	14	to	to	TO
18637	18849	15	repair	repair	VB
18637	18849	16	a	a	DT
18637	18849	17	viaduct	viaduct	NN
18637	18849	18	under	under	IN
18637	18849	19	which	which	WDT
18637	18849	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18849	21	operate,[237	operate,[237	VBP
18637	18849	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18849	23	or	or	CC
18637	18849	24	to	to	TO
18637	18849	25	reconstruct	reconstruct	VB
18637	18849	26	a	a	DT
18637	18849	27	bridge	bridge	NN
18637	18849	28	or	or	CC
18637	18849	29	provide	provide	VB
18637	18849	30	means	mean	NNS
18637	18849	31	for	for	IN
18637	18849	32	passing	pass	VBG
18637	18849	33	water	water	NN
18637	18849	34	for	for	IN
18637	18849	35	drainage	drainage	NN
18637	18849	36	through	through	IN
18637	18849	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18849	38	embankment,[238	embankment,[238	NN
18637	18849	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18849	40	or	or	CC
18637	18849	41	to	to	TO
18637	18849	42	sprinkle	sprinkle	VB
18637	18849	43	that	that	DT
18637	18849	44	part	part	NN
18637	18849	45	of	of	IN
18637	18849	46	the	the	DT
18637	18849	47	street	street	NN
18637	18849	48	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	18849	49	by	by	IN
18637	18849	50	them,[239	them,[239	NNP
18637	18849	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18849	52	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18849	53	property	property	NN
18637	18849	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	18849	55	not	not	RB
18637	18849	56	taken	take	VBN
18637	18849	57	without	without	IN
18637	18849	58	due	due	JJ
18637	18849	59	process	process	NN
18637	18849	60	of	of	IN
18637	18849	61	law	law	NN
18637	18849	62	.	.	.
18637	18850	1	But	but	CC
18637	18850	2	if	if	IN
18637	18850	3	an	an	DT
18637	18850	4	underground	underground	JJ
18637	18850	5	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	18850	6	-	-	:
18637	18850	7	pass	pass	NN
18637	18850	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	18850	9	to	to	TO
18637	18850	10	be	be	VB
18637	18850	11	constructed	construct	VBN
18637	18850	12	,	,	,
18637	18850	13	not	not	RB
18637	18850	14	as	as	IN
18637	18850	15	a	a	DT
18637	18850	16	safety	safety	NN
18637	18850	17	measure	measure	NN
18637	18850	18	but	but	CC
18637	18850	19	as	as	IN
18637	18850	20	a	a	DT
18637	18850	21	means	means	NN
18637	18850	22	of	of	IN
18637	18850	23	sparing	spare	VBG
18637	18850	24	the	the	DT
18637	18850	25	farmer	farmer	NN
18637	18850	26	the	the	DT
18637	18850	27	inconvenience	inconvenience	NN
18637	18850	28	attendant	attendant	JJ
18637	18850	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	18850	30	the	the	DT
18637	18850	31	use	use	NN
18637	18850	32	of	of	IN
18637	18850	33	an	an	DT
18637	18850	34	existing	exist	VBG
18637	18850	35	and	and	CC
18637	18850	36	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	18850	37	grade	grade	NN
18637	18850	38	crossing	crossing	NN
18637	18850	39	,	,	,
18637	18850	40	collection	collection	NN
18637	18850	41	of	of	IN
18637	18850	42	any	any	DT
18637	18850	43	part	part	NN
18637	18850	44	of	of	IN
18637	18850	45	the	the	DT
18637	18850	46	cost	cost	NN
18637	18850	47	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18850	48	from	from	IN
18637	18850	49	a	a	DT
18637	18850	50	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18850	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	18850	52	a	a	DT
18637	18850	53	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	18850	54	taking	taking	NN
18637	18850	55	for	for	IN
18637	18850	56	private	private	JJ
18637	18850	57	use	use	NN
18637	18850	58	.	.	.
18637	18851	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18851	2	240	240	CD
18637	18851	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18851	4	As	as	IN
18637	18851	5	to	to	TO
18637	18851	6	grade	grade	NN
18637	18851	7	crossing	crossing	NN
18637	18851	8	elimination	elimination	NN
18637	18851	9	,	,	,
18637	18851	10	the	the	DT
18637	18851	11	rule	rule	NN
18637	18851	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	18851	13	well	well	RB
18637	18851	14	established	establish	VBN
18637	18851	15	that	that	IN
18637	18851	16	the	the	DT
18637	18851	17	State	State	NNP
18637	18851	18	may	may	MD
18637	18851	19	exact	exact	VB
18637	18851	20	from	from	IN
18637	18851	21	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	18851	22	the	the	DT
18637	18851	23	whole	whole	NN
18637	18851	24	,	,	,
18637	18851	25	or	or	CC
18637	18851	26	such	such	JJ
18637	18851	27	part	part	NN
18637	18851	28	,	,	,
18637	18851	29	of	of	IN
18637	18851	30	the	the	DT
18637	18851	31	cost	cost	NN
18637	18851	32	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18851	33	as	as	IN
18637	18851	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18851	35	deems	deem	VBZ
18637	18851	36	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	18851	37	,	,	,
18637	18851	38	even	even	RB
18637	18851	39	though	though	IN
18637	18851	40	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	18851	41	highway	highway	NN
18637	18851	42	users	user	NNS
18637	18851	43	,	,	,
18637	18851	44	who	who	WP
18637	18851	45	make	make	VBP
18637	18851	46	no	no	DT
18637	18851	47	contribution	contribution	NN
18637	18851	48	whatsoever	whatsoever	RB
18637	18851	49	,	,	,
18637	18851	50	benefit	benefit	VBP
18637	18851	51	from	from	IN
18637	18851	52	such	such	JJ
18637	18851	53	improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	18851	54	.	.	.
18637	18852	1	But	but	CC
18637	18852	2	,	,	,
18637	18852	3	the	the	DT
18637	18852	4	power	power	NN
18637	18852	5	of	of	IN
18637	18852	6	the	the	DT
18637	18852	7	State	State	NNP
18637	18852	8	in	in	IN
18637	18852	9	this	this	DT
18637	18852	10	respect	respect	NN
18637	18852	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	18852	12	not	not	RB
18637	18852	13	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	18852	14	.	.	.
18637	18853	1	If	if	IN
18637	18853	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18853	3	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	18853	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	18853	5	"	"	``
18637	18853	6	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18853	7	"	"	''
18637	18853	8	and	and	CC
18637	18853	9	"	"	``
18637	18853	10	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18853	11	"	"	''
18637	18853	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18853	13	may	may	MD
18637	18853	14	be	be	VB
18637	18853	15	set	set	VBN
18637	18853	16	aside	aside	RB
18637	18853	17	;	;	:
18637	18853	18	but	but	CC
18637	18853	19	to	to	TO
18637	18853	20	reach	reach	VB
18637	18853	21	that	that	DT
18637	18853	22	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	18853	23	,	,	,
18637	18853	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18853	25	may	may	MD
18637	18853	26	become	become	VB
18637	18853	27	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18853	28	to	to	TO
18637	18853	29	consider	consider	VB
18637	18853	30	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18853	31	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	18853	32	facts	fact	NNS
18637	18853	33	;	;	:
18637	18853	34	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	18853	35	,	,	,
18637	18853	36	whether	whether	IN
18637	18853	37	a	a	DT
18637	18853	38	new	new	JJ
18637	18853	39	highway	highway	NN
18637	18853	40	on	on	IN
18637	18853	41	which	which	WDT
18637	18853	42	an	an	DT
18637	18853	43	underpass	underpass	NN
18637	18853	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	18853	45	to	to	TO
18637	18853	46	be	be	VB
18637	18853	47	constructed	construct	VBN
18637	18853	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	18853	49	essential	essential	JJ
18637	18853	50	to	to	IN
18637	18853	51	the	the	DT
18637	18853	52	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	18853	53	needs	need	NNS
18637	18853	54	of	of	IN
18637	18853	55	a	a	DT
18637	18853	56	community	community	NN
18637	18853	57	already	already	RB
18637	18853	58	well	well	RB
18637	18853	59	served	serve	VBN
18637	18853	60	by	by	IN
18637	18853	61	a	a	DT
18637	18853	62	crossing	crossing	NN
18637	18853	63	equipped	equip	VBN
18637	18853	64	with	with	IN
18637	18853	65	devices	device	NNS
18637	18853	66	which	which	WDT
18637	18853	67	are	be	VBP
18637	18853	68	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	18853	69	for	for	IN
18637	18853	70	safety	safety	NN
18637	18853	71	and	and	CC
18637	18853	72	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	18853	73	of	of	IN
18637	18853	74	a	a	DT
18637	18853	75	local	local	JJ
18637	18853	76	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	18853	77	;	;	:
18637	18853	78	whether	whether	IN
18637	18853	79	the	the	DT
18637	18853	80	underpass	underpass	NN
18637	18853	81	is	be	VBZ
18637	18853	82	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	18853	83	as	as	IN
18637	18853	84	part	part	NN
18637	18853	85	of	of	IN
18637	18853	86	a	a	DT
18637	18853	87	national	national	JJ
18637	18853	88	system	system	NN
18637	18853	89	of	of	IN
18637	18853	90	federal	federal	JJ
18637	18853	91	aid	aid	NN
18637	18853	92	highways	highway	NNS
18637	18853	93	for	for	IN
18637	18853	94	the	the	DT
18637	18853	95	furtherance	furtherance	NN
18637	18853	96	of	of	IN
18637	18853	97	motor	motor	NN
18637	18853	98	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	18853	99	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	18853	100	,	,	,
18637	18853	101	much	much	JJ
18637	18853	102	of	of	IN
18637	18853	103	which	which	WDT
18637	18853	104	is	be	VBZ
18637	18853	105	in	in	IN
18637	18853	106	direct	direct	JJ
18637	18853	107	competition	competition	NN
18637	18853	108	with	with	IN
18637	18853	109	the	the	DT
18637	18853	110	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18853	111	;	;	:
18637	18853	112	whether	whether	IN
18637	18853	113	the	the	DT
18637	18853	114	increase	increase	NN
18637	18853	115	in	in	IN
18637	18853	116	such	such	JJ
18637	18853	117	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	18853	118	will	will	MD
18637	18853	119	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	18853	120	decrease	decrease	VB
18637	18853	121	rail	rail	NN
18637	18853	122	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	18853	123	and	and	CC
18637	18853	124	hence	hence	RB
18637	18853	125	the	the	DT
18637	18853	126	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	18853	127	of	of	IN
18637	18853	128	the	the	DT
18637	18853	129	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18853	130	;	;	:
18637	18853	131	whether	whether	IN
18637	18853	132	the	the	DT
18637	18853	133	amount	amount	NN
18637	18853	134	of	of	IN
18637	18853	135	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	18853	136	paid	pay	VBN
18637	18853	137	by	by	IN
18637	18853	138	the	the	DT
18637	18853	139	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	18853	140	of	of	IN
18637	18853	141	the	the	DT
18637	18853	142	State	State	NNP
18637	18853	143	,	,	,
18637	18853	144	part	part	NN
18637	18853	145	of	of	IN
18637	18853	146	which	which	WDT
18637	18853	147	is	be	VBZ
18637	18853	148	devoted	devoted	JJ
18637	18853	149	to	to	IN
18637	18853	150	the	the	DT
18637	18853	151	upkeep	upkeep	NN
18637	18853	152	of	of	IN
18637	18853	153	public	public	JJ
18637	18853	154	highways	highway	NNS
18637	18853	155	used	use	VBN
18637	18853	156	by	by	IN
18637	18853	157	motor	motor	NN
18637	18853	158	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	18853	159	,	,	,
18637	18853	160	is	be	VBZ
18637	18853	161	disproportionately	disproportionately	RB
18637	18853	162	higher	high	JJR
18637	18853	163	than	than	IN
18637	18853	164	the	the	DT
18637	18853	165	amount	amount	NN
18637	18853	166	paid	pay	VBN
18637	18853	167	by	by	IN
18637	18853	168	motor	motor	NN
18637	18853	169	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	18853	170	.	.	.
18637	18854	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18854	2	241	241	CD
18637	18854	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18854	4	Compellable	compellable	JJ
18637	18854	5	Services	service	NNS
18637	18854	6	The	the	DT
18637	18854	7	primary	primary	JJ
18637	18854	8	duty	duty	NN
18637	18854	9	of	of	IN
18637	18854	10	a	a	DT
18637	18854	11	public	public	JJ
18637	18854	12	utility	utility	NN
18637	18854	13	being	be	VBG
18637	18854	14	to	to	TO
18637	18854	15	serve	serve	VB
18637	18854	16	on	on	IN
18637	18854	17	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18854	18	terms	term	NNS
18637	18854	19	all	all	PDT
18637	18854	20	those	those	DT
18637	18854	21	who	who	WP
18637	18854	22	desire	desire	VBP
18637	18854	23	the	the	DT
18637	18854	24	service	service	NN
18637	18854	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18854	26	renders	render	VBZ
18637	18854	27	,	,	,
18637	18854	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18854	29	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	18854	30	that	that	IN
18637	18854	31	a	a	DT
18637	18854	32	company	company	NN
18637	18854	33	can	can	MD
18637	18854	34	not	not	RB
18637	18854	35	pick	pick	VB
18637	18854	36	and	and	CC
18637	18854	37	choose	choose	VB
18637	18854	38	and	and	CC
18637	18854	39	elect	elect	VB
18637	18854	40	to	to	TO
18637	18854	41	serve	serve	VB
18637	18854	42	only	only	RB
18637	18854	43	those	those	DT
18637	18854	44	portions	portion	NNS
18637	18854	45	of	of	IN
18637	18854	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18854	47	territory	territory	NN
18637	18854	48	which	which	WDT
18637	18854	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18854	50	finds	find	VBZ
18637	18854	51	most	most	RBS
18637	18854	52	profitable	profitable	JJ
18637	18854	53	,	,	,
18637	18854	54	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	18854	55	the	the	DT
18637	18854	56	remainder	remainder	NN
18637	18854	57	to	to	TO
18637	18854	58	get	get	VB
18637	18854	59	along	along	RP
18637	18854	60	without	without	IN
18637	18854	61	the	the	DT
18637	18854	62	service	service	NN
18637	18854	63	which	which	WDT
18637	18854	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18854	65	alone	alone	RB
18637	18854	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	18854	67	in	in	IN
18637	18854	68	a	a	DT
18637	18854	69	position	position	NN
18637	18854	70	to	to	TO
18637	18854	71	give	give	VB
18637	18854	72	.	.	.
18637	18855	1	Compelling	compel	VBG
18637	18855	2	a	a	DT
18637	18855	3	gas	gas	NN
18637	18855	4	company	company	NN
18637	18855	5	to	to	TO
18637	18855	6	continue	continue	VB
18637	18855	7	serving	serve	VBG
18637	18855	8	specified	specify	VBN
18637	18855	9	cities	city	NNS
18637	18855	10	as	as	RB
18637	18855	11	long	long	RB
18637	18855	12	as	as	IN
18637	18855	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18855	14	continues	continue	VBZ
18637	18855	15	to	to	TO
18637	18855	16	do	do	VB
18637	18855	17	business	business	NN
18637	18855	18	in	in	IN
18637	18855	19	other	other	JJ
18637	18855	20	parts	part	NNS
18637	18855	21	of	of	IN
18637	18855	22	the	the	DT
18637	18855	23	State	state	NN
18637	18855	24	entails	entail	NNS
18637	18855	25	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	18855	26	no	no	DT
18637	18855	27	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18855	28	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18855	29	.	.	.
18637	18856	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18856	2	242	242	CD
18637	18856	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18856	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	18856	5	a	a	DT
18637	18856	6	railway	railway	NN
18637	18856	7	may	may	MD
18637	18856	8	be	be	VB
18637	18856	9	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	18856	10	to	to	TO
18637	18856	11	continue	continue	VB
18637	18856	12	the	the	DT
18637	18856	13	service	service	NN
18637	18856	14	of	of	IN
18637	18856	15	a	a	DT
18637	18856	16	branch	branch	NN
18637	18856	17	or	or	CC
18637	18856	18	part	part	NN
18637	18856	19	of	of	IN
18637	18856	20	a	a	DT
18637	18856	21	line	line	NN
18637	18856	22	although	although	IN
18637	18856	23	the	the	DT
18637	18856	24	operation	operation	NN
18637	18856	25	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	18856	26	a	a	DT
18637	18856	27	loss	loss	NN
18637	18856	28	.	.	.
18637	18857	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18857	2	243	243	CD
18637	18857	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18857	4	But	but	CC
18637	18857	5	even	even	RB
18637	18857	6	though	though	IN
18637	18857	7	a	a	DT
18637	18857	8	utility	utility	NN
18637	18857	9	,	,	,
18637	18857	10	as	as	IN
18637	18857	11	a	a	DT
18637	18857	12	condition	condition	NN
18637	18857	13	of	of	IN
18637	18857	14	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	18857	15	of	of	IN
18637	18857	16	powers	power	NNS
18637	18857	17	and	and	CC
18637	18857	18	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	18857	19	granted	grant	VBN
18637	18857	20	by	by	IN
18637	18857	21	the	the	DT
18637	18857	22	State	State	NNP
18637	18857	23	,	,	,
18637	18857	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	18857	25	under	under	IN
18637	18857	26	a	a	DT
18637	18857	27	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	18857	28	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	18857	29	to	to	TO
18637	18857	30	provide	provide	VB
18637	18857	31	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	18857	32	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	18857	33	service	service	NN
18637	18857	34	,	,	,
18637	18857	35	and	and	CC
18637	18857	36	even	even	RB
18637	18857	37	though	though	IN
18637	18857	38	that	that	DT
18637	18857	39	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	18857	40	can	can	MD
18637	18857	41	not	not	RB
18637	18857	42	be	be	VB
18637	18857	43	avoided	avoid	VBN
18637	18857	44	merely	merely	RB
18637	18857	45	because	because	IN
18637	18857	46	performance	performance	NN
18637	18857	47	occasions	occasion	NNS
18637	18857	48	financial	financial	JJ
18637	18857	49	loss	loss	NN
18637	18857	50	,	,	,
18637	18857	51	yet	yet	CC
18637	18857	52	if	if	IN
18637	18857	53	a	a	DT
18637	18857	54	company	company	NN
18637	18857	55	is	be	VBZ
18637	18857	56	at	at	IN
18637	18857	57	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18857	58	to	to	TO
18637	18857	59	surrender	surrender	VB
18637	18857	60	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18857	61	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	18857	62	and	and	CC
18637	18857	63	discontinue	discontinue	VB
18637	18857	64	operations	operation	NNS
18637	18857	65	,	,	,
18637	18857	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18857	67	can	can	MD
18637	18857	68	not	not	RB
18637	18857	69	be	be	VB
18637	18857	70	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	18857	71	to	to	TO
18637	18857	72	continue	continue	VB
18637	18857	73	at	at	IN
18637	18857	74	a	a	DT
18637	18857	75	loss	loss	NN
18637	18857	76	.	.	.
18637	18858	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18858	2	244	244	CD
18637	18858	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18858	4	Pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	18858	5	to	to	IN
18637	18858	6	the	the	DT
18637	18858	7	principle	principle	NN
18637	18858	8	that	that	IN
18637	18858	9	the	the	DT
18637	18858	10	State	State	NNP
18637	18858	11	may	may	MD
18637	18858	12	require	require	VB
18637	18858	13	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	18858	14	to	to	TO
18637	18858	15	provide	provide	VB
18637	18858	16	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	18858	17	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	18858	18	suitable	suitable	JJ
18637	18858	19	for	for	IN
18637	18858	20	the	the	DT
18637	18858	21	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	18858	22	of	of	IN
18637	18858	23	the	the	DT
18637	18858	24	communities	community	NNS
18637	18858	25	served	serve	VBN
18637	18858	26	by	by	IN
18637	18858	27	them,[245	them,[245	NNP
18637	18858	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18858	29	such	such	JJ
18637	18858	30	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	18858	31	have	have	VBP
18637	18858	32	been	be	VBN
18637	18858	33	obligated	obligate	VBN
18637	18858	34	to	to	TO
18637	18858	35	establish	establish	VB
18637	18858	36	stations	station	NNS
18637	18858	37	at	at	IN
18637	18858	38	proper	proper	JJ
18637	18858	39	places	place	NNS
18637	18858	40	for	for	IN
18637	18858	41	the	the	DT
18637	18858	42	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	18858	43	of	of	IN
18637	18858	44	patrons,[246	patrons,[246	NNP
18637	18858	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18858	46	to	to	TO
18637	18858	47	stop	stop	VB
18637	18858	48	all	all	PDT
18637	18858	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18858	50	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	18858	51	trains	train	NNS
18637	18858	52	at	at	IN
18637	18858	53	county	county	NN
18637	18858	54	seats,[247	seats,[247	NNP
18637	18858	55	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18858	56	to	to	TO
18637	18858	57	run	run	VB
18637	18858	58	a	a	DT
18637	18858	59	regular	regular	JJ
18637	18858	60	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	18858	61	train	train	NN
18637	18858	62	instead	instead	RB
18637	18858	63	of	of	IN
18637	18858	64	a	a	DT
18637	18858	65	mixed	mixed	JJ
18637	18858	66	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	18858	67	and	and	CC
18637	18858	68	freight	freight	NN
18637	18858	69	train,[248	train,[248	NNP
18637	18858	70	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18858	71	to	to	TO
18637	18858	72	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	18858	73	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	18858	74	service	service	NN
18637	18858	75	on	on	IN
18637	18858	76	a	a	DT
18637	18858	77	branch	branch	NN
18637	18858	78	line	line	NN
18637	18858	79	previously	previously	RB
18637	18858	80	devoted	devote	VBN
18637	18858	81	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	18858	82	to	to	IN
18637	18858	83	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	18858	84	freight,[249	freight,[249	NN
18637	18858	85	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18858	86	to	to	TO
18637	18858	87	restore	restore	VB
18637	18858	88	a	a	DT
18637	18858	89	siding	siding	NN
18637	18858	90	used	use	VBN
18637	18858	91	principally	principally	RB
18637	18858	92	by	by	IN
18637	18858	93	a	a	DT
18637	18858	94	particular	particular	JJ
18637	18858	95	plant	plant	NN
18637	18858	96	but	but	CC
18637	18858	97	available	available	JJ
18637	18858	98	generally	generally	RB
18637	18858	99	as	as	IN
18637	18858	100	a	a	DT
18637	18858	101	public	public	JJ
18637	18858	102	track	track	NN
18637	18858	103	,	,	,
18637	18858	104	and	and	CC
18637	18858	105	to	to	TO
18637	18858	106	continue	continue	VB
18637	18858	107	,	,	,
18637	18858	108	even	even	RB
18637	18858	109	though	though	IN
18637	18858	110	not	not	RB
18637	18858	111	profitable	profitable	JJ
18637	18858	112	by	by	IN
18637	18858	113	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18858	114	,	,	,
18637	18858	115	a	a	DT
18637	18858	116	sidetrack[250	sidetrack[250	NN
18637	18858	117	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18858	118	as	as	RB
18637	18858	119	well	well	RB
18637	18858	120	as	as	IN
18637	18858	121	the	the	DT
18637	18858	122	upkeep	upkeep	NN
18637	18858	123	of	of	IN
18637	18858	124	a	a	DT
18637	18858	125	switch	switch	NN
18637	18858	126	-	-	HYPH
18637	18858	127	track	track	NN
18637	18858	128	leading	lead	VBG
18637	18858	129	from	from	IN
18637	18858	130	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18858	131	main	main	JJ
18637	18858	132	line	line	NN
18637	18858	133	to	to	IN
18637	18858	134	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	18858	135	plants	plant	NNS
18637	18858	136	.	.	.
18637	18859	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18859	2	251	251	CD
18637	18859	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18859	4	However	however	RB
18637	18859	5	,	,	,
18637	18859	6	a	a	DT
18637	18859	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	18859	8	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18859	9	a	a	DT
18637	18859	10	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18859	11	without	without	IN
18637	18859	12	indemnification	indemnification	NN
18637	18859	13	to	to	TO
18637	18859	14	install	install	VB
18637	18859	15	switches	switch	NNS
18637	18859	16	on	on	IN
18637	18859	17	the	the	DT
18637	18859	18	application	application	NN
18637	18859	19	of	of	IN
18637	18859	20	owners	owner	NNS
18637	18859	21	of	of	IN
18637	18859	22	grain	grain	NN
18637	18859	23	elevators	elevator	NNS
18637	18859	24	erected	erect	VBN
18637	18859	25	on	on	IN
18637	18859	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18859	27	right	right	NN
18637	18859	28	of	of	IN
18637	18859	29	way	way	NN
18637	18859	30	was	be	VBD
18637	18859	31	held	hold	VBN
18637	18859	32	void	void	JJ
18637	18859	33	.	.	.
18637	18860	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18860	2	252	252	CD
18637	18860	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18860	4	Whether	whether	IN
18637	18860	5	a	a	DT
18637	18860	6	State	State	NNP
18637	18860	7	order	order	NN
18637	18860	8	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18860	9	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	18860	10	service	service	NN
18637	18860	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	18860	12	to	to	TO
18637	18860	13	be	be	VB
18637	18860	14	viewed	view	VBN
18637	18860	15	as	as	IN
18637	18860	16	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18860	17	may	may	MD
18637	18860	18	necessitate	necessitate	VB
18637	18860	19	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	18860	20	of	of	IN
18637	18860	21	such	such	JJ
18637	18860	22	facts	fact	NNS
18637	18860	23	as	as	IN
18637	18860	24	the	the	DT
18637	18860	25	likelihood	likelihood	NN
18637	18860	26	that	that	IN
18637	18860	27	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
18637	18860	28	loss	loss	NN
18637	18860	29	will	will	MD
18637	18860	30	result	result	VB
18637	18860	31	to	to	IN
18637	18860	32	the	the	DT
18637	18860	33	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18860	34	,	,	,
18637	18860	35	the	the	DT
18637	18860	36	nature	nature	NN
18637	18860	37	,	,	,
18637	18860	38	extent	extent	NN
18637	18860	39	and	and	CC
18637	18860	40	productiveness	productiveness	NN
18637	18860	41	of	of	IN
18637	18860	42	the	the	DT
18637	18860	43	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18860	44	's	's	POS
18637	18860	45	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	18860	46	business	business	NN
18637	18860	47	,	,	,
18637	18860	48	the	the	DT
18637	18860	49	character	character	NN
18637	18860	50	of	of	IN
18637	18860	51	the	the	DT
18637	18860	52	service	service	NN
18637	18860	53	required	require	VBN
18637	18860	54	,	,	,
18637	18860	55	the	the	DT
18637	18860	56	public	public	JJ
18637	18860	57	need	need	NN
18637	18860	58	for	for	IN
18637	18860	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18860	60	,	,	,
18637	18860	61	and	and	CC
18637	18860	62	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18860	63	effect	effect	NN
18637	18860	64	upon	upon	IN
18637	18860	65	service	service	NN
18637	18860	66	already	already	RB
18637	18860	67	being	be	VBG
18637	18860	68	rendered	render	VBN
18637	18860	69	.	.	.
18637	18861	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18861	2	253	253	CD
18637	18861	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18861	4	If	if	IN
18637	18861	5	the	the	DT
18637	18861	6	service	service	NN
18637	18861	7	required	require	VBN
18637	18861	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	18861	9	no	no	DT
18637	18861	10	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	18861	11	relation	relation	NN
18637	18861	12	to	to	IN
18637	18861	13	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	18861	14	,	,	,
18637	18861	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18861	16	will	will	MD
18637	18861	17	be	be	VB
18637	18861	18	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	18861	19	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18861	20	and	and	CC
18637	18861	21	void	void	JJ
18637	18861	22	,	,	,
18637	18861	23	as	as	IN
18637	18861	24	in	in	IN
18637	18861	25	the	the	DT
18637	18861	26	case	case	NN
18637	18861	27	of	of	IN
18637	18861	28	an	an	DT
18637	18861	29	order	order	NN
18637	18861	30	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18861	31	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	18861	32	to	to	TO
18637	18861	33	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	18861	34	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	18861	35	scales	scale	NNS
18637	18861	36	to	to	TO
18637	18861	37	facilitate	facilitate	VB
18637	18861	38	trading	trading	NN
18637	18861	39	in	in	IN
18637	18861	40	cattle,[254	cattle,[254	NNP
18637	18861	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18861	42	and	and	CC
18637	18861	43	of	of	IN
18637	18861	44	a	a	DT
18637	18861	45	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	18861	46	against	against	IN
18637	18861	47	letting	let	VBG
18637	18861	48	down	down	RP
18637	18861	49	an	an	DT
18637	18861	50	unengaged	unengaged	JJ
18637	18861	51	upper	upper	JJ
18637	18861	52	berth	berth	NN
18637	18861	53	while	while	IN
18637	18861	54	the	the	DT
18637	18861	55	lower	low	JJR
18637	18861	56	berth	berth	NN
18637	18861	57	was	be	VBD
18637	18861	58	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	18861	59	.	.	.
18637	18862	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18862	2	255	255	CD
18637	18862	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18862	4	Intercompany	Intercompany	NNP
18637	18862	5	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	18862	6	Service.--"Since	Service.--"Since	NNP
18637	18862	7	the	the	DT
18637	18862	8	decision	decision	NN
18637	18862	9	in	in	IN
18637	18862	10	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	18862	11	M.	M.	NNP
18637	18862	12	&	&	CC
18637	18862	13	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	18863	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	18863	2	_	_	NNP
18637	18863	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	18863	4	_	_	NNP
18637	18863	5	Jacobson	Jacobson	NNP
18637	18863	6	,	,	,
18637	18863	7	179	179	CD
18637	18863	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	18863	9	287	287	CD
18637	18863	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18863	11	1900	1900	CD
18637	18863	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18863	13	,	,	,
18637	18863	14	there	there	EX
18637	18863	15	can	can	MD
18637	18863	16	be	be	VB
18637	18863	17	no	no	DT
18637	18863	18	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	18863	19	of	of	IN
18637	18863	20	the	the	DT
18637	18863	21	power	power	NN
18637	18863	22	of	of	IN
18637	18863	23	a	a	DT
18637	18863	24	State	State	NNP
18637	18863	25	,	,	,
18637	18863	26	acting	act	VBG
18637	18863	27	through	through	IN
18637	18863	28	an	an	DT
18637	18863	29	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	18863	30	body	body	NN
18637	18863	31	,	,	,
18637	18863	32	to	to	TO
18637	18863	33	require	require	VB
18637	18863	34	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18863	35	companies	company	NNS
18637	18863	36	to	to	TO
18637	18863	37	make	make	VB
18637	18863	38	track	track	NN
18637	18863	39	connections	connection	NNS
18637	18863	40	.	.	.
18637	18864	1	But	but	CC
18637	18864	2	manifestly	manifestly	RB
18637	18864	3	that	that	DT
18637	18864	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	18864	5	not	not	RB
18637	18864	6	mean	mean	VB
18637	18864	7	that	that	IN
18637	18864	8	a	a	DT
18637	18864	9	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18864	10	may	may	MD
18637	18864	11	compel	compel	VB
18637	18864	12	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18864	13	to	to	TO
18637	18864	14	build	build	VB
18637	18864	15	branch	branch	NN
18637	18864	16	lines	line	NNS
18637	18864	17	,	,	,
18637	18864	18	so	so	IN
18637	18864	19	as	as	IN
18637	18864	20	to	to	TO
18637	18864	21	connect	connect	VB
18637	18864	22	roads	road	NNS
18637	18864	23	lying	lie	VBG
18637	18864	24	at	at	IN
18637	18864	25	a	a	DT
18637	18864	26	distance	distance	NN
18637	18864	27	from	from	IN
18637	18864	28	each	each	DT
18637	18864	29	other	other	JJ
18637	18864	30	;	;	:
18637	18864	31	nor	nor	CC
18637	18864	32	does	do	VBZ
18637	18864	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18864	34	mean	mean	VB
18637	18864	35	that	that	IN
18637	18864	36	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18864	37	may	may	MD
18637	18864	38	be	be	VB
18637	18864	39	required	require	VBN
18637	18864	40	to	to	TO
18637	18864	41	make	make	VB
18637	18864	42	connections	connection	NNS
18637	18864	43	at	at	IN
18637	18864	44	every	every	DT
18637	18864	45	point	point	NN
18637	18864	46	where	where	WRB
18637	18864	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18864	48	tracks	track	NNS
18637	18864	49	come	come	VBP
18637	18864	50	close	close	RB
18637	18864	51	together	together	RB
18637	18864	52	in	in	IN
18637	18864	53	city	city	NN
18637	18864	54	,	,	,
18637	18864	55	town	town	NN
18637	18864	56	and	and	CC
18637	18864	57	country	country	NN
18637	18864	58	,	,	,
18637	18864	59	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	18864	60	of	of	IN
18637	18864	61	the	the	DT
18637	18864	62	amount	amount	NN
18637	18864	63	of	of	IN
18637	18864	64	business	business	NN
18637	18864	65	to	to	TO
18637	18864	66	be	be	VB
18637	18864	67	done	do	VBN
18637	18864	68	,	,	,
18637	18864	69	or	or	CC
18637	18864	70	the	the	DT
18637	18864	71	number	number	NN
18637	18864	72	of	of	IN
18637	18864	73	persons	person	NNS
18637	18864	74	who	who	WP
18637	18864	75	may	may	MD
18637	18864	76	utilize	utilize	VB
18637	18864	77	the	the	DT
18637	18864	78	connection	connection	NN
18637	18864	79	if	if	IN
18637	18864	80	built	build	VBN
18637	18864	81	.	.	.
18637	18865	1	The	the	DT
18637	18865	2	question	question	NN
18637	18865	3	in	in	IN
18637	18865	4	each	each	DT
18637	18865	5	case	case	NN
18637	18865	6	must	must	MD
18637	18865	7	be	be	VB
18637	18865	8	determined	determine	VBN
18637	18865	9	in	in	IN
18637	18865	10	the	the	DT
18637	18865	11	light	light	NN
18637	18865	12	of	of	IN
18637	18865	13	all	all	PDT
18637	18865	14	the	the	DT
18637	18865	15	facts	fact	NNS
18637	18865	16	,	,	,
18637	18865	17	and	and	CC
18637	18865	18	with	with	IN
18637	18865	19	a	a	DT
18637	18865	20	just	just	JJ
18637	18865	21	regard	regard	NN
18637	18865	22	to	to	IN
18637	18865	23	the	the	DT
18637	18865	24	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	18865	25	to	to	TO
18637	18865	26	be	be	VB
18637	18865	27	derived	derive	VBN
18637	18865	28	by	by	IN
18637	18865	29	the	the	DT
18637	18865	30	public	public	NN
18637	18865	31	and	and	CC
18637	18865	32	the	the	DT
18637	18865	33	expense	expense	NN
18637	18865	34	to	to	TO
18637	18865	35	be	be	VB
18637	18865	36	incurred	incur	VBN
18637	18865	37	by	by	IN
18637	18865	38	the	the	DT
18637	18865	39	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18865	40	.	.	.
18637	18866	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18866	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18866	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18866	4	If	if	IN
18637	18866	5	the	the	DT
18637	18866	6	order	order	NN
18637	18866	7	involves	involve	VBZ
18637	18866	8	the	the	DT
18637	18866	9	use	use	NN
18637	18866	10	of	of	IN
18637	18866	11	property	property	NN
18637	18866	12	needed	need	VBN
18637	18866	13	in	in	IN
18637	18866	14	the	the	DT
18637	18866	15	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	18866	16	of	of	IN
18637	18866	17	those	those	DT
18637	18866	18	duties	duty	NNS
18637	18866	19	which	which	WDT
18637	18866	20	the	the	DT
18637	18866	21	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18866	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	18866	23	bound	bind	VBN
18637	18866	24	to	to	TO
18637	18866	25	perform	perform	VB
18637	18866	26	,	,	,
18637	18866	27	then	then	RB
18637	18866	28	,	,	,
18637	18866	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	18866	30	proof	proof	NN
18637	18866	31	of	of	IN
18637	18866	32	the	the	DT
18637	18866	33	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	18866	34	,	,	,
18637	18866	35	the	the	DT
18637	18866	36	order	order	NN
18637	18866	37	will	will	MD
18637	18866	38	be	be	VB
18637	18866	39	granted	grant	VBN
18637	18866	40	,	,	,
18637	18866	41	even	even	RB
18637	18866	42	though	though	IN
18637	18866	43	'	'	''
18637	18866	44	the	the	DT
18637	18866	45	furnishing	furnishing	NN
18637	18866	46	of	of	IN
18637	18866	47	such	such	JJ
18637	18866	48	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18866	49	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	18866	50	may	may	MD
18637	18866	51	occasion	occasion	VB
18637	18866	52	an	an	DT
18637	18866	53	incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	18866	54	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
18637	18866	55	loss	loss	NN
18637	18866	56	.	.	.
18637	18866	57	'	'	''
18637	18867	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18867	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18867	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18867	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	18867	5	,	,	,
18637	18867	6	however	however	RB
18637	18867	7	,	,	,
18637	18867	8	the	the	DT
18637	18867	9	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	18867	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	18867	11	brought	bring	VBN
18637	18867	12	to	to	TO
18637	18867	13	compel	compel	VB
18637	18867	14	a	a	DT
18637	18867	15	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18867	16	to	to	TO
18637	18867	17	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	18867	18	a	a	DT
18637	18867	19	facility	facility	NN
18637	18867	20	not	not	RB
18637	18867	21	included	include	VBN
18637	18867	22	within	within	IN
18637	18867	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18867	24	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	18867	25	duties	duty	NNS
18637	18867	26	,	,	,
18637	18867	27	the	the	DT
18637	18867	28	question	question	NN
18637	18867	29	of	of	IN
18637	18867	30	expense	expense	NN
18637	18867	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	18867	32	of	of	IN
18637	18867	33	more	more	RBR
18637	18867	34	controlling	controlling	JJ
18637	18867	35	importance	importance	NN
18637	18867	36	.	.	.
18637	18868	1	In	in	IN
18637	18868	2	determining	determine	VBG
18637	18868	3	the	the	DT
18637	18868	4	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	18868	5	of	of	IN
18637	18868	6	such	such	PDT
18637	18868	7	an	an	DT
18637	18868	8	order	order	NN
18637	18868	9	the	the	DT
18637	18868	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18868	11	must	must	MD
18637	18868	12	consider	consider	VB
18637	18868	13	all	all	PDT
18637	18868	14	the	the	DT
18637	18868	15	facts	fact	NNS
18637	18868	16	--	--	:
18637	18868	17	the	the	DT
18637	18868	18	places	place	NNS
18637	18868	19	and	and	CC
18637	18868	20	persons	person	NNS
18637	18868	21	interested	interested	JJ
18637	18868	22	,	,	,
18637	18868	23	the	the	DT
18637	18868	24	volume	volume	NN
18637	18868	25	of	of	IN
18637	18868	26	business	business	NN
18637	18868	27	to	to	TO
18637	18868	28	be	be	VB
18637	18868	29	affected	affect	VBN
18637	18868	30	,	,	,
18637	18868	31	the	the	DT
18637	18868	32	saving	saving	NN
18637	18868	33	in	in	IN
18637	18868	34	time	time	NN
18637	18868	35	and	and	CC
18637	18868	36	expense	expense	NN
18637	18868	37	to	to	IN
18637	18868	38	the	the	DT
18637	18868	39	shipper	shipper	NN
18637	18868	40	,	,	,
18637	18868	41	as	as	IN
18637	18868	42	against	against	IN
18637	18868	43	the	the	DT
18637	18868	44	cost	cost	NN
18637	18868	45	and	and	CC
18637	18868	46	loss	loss	NN
18637	18868	47	to	to	IN
18637	18868	48	the	the	DT
18637	18868	49	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18868	50	.	.	.
18637	18869	1	"	"	``
18637	18869	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18869	3	256	256	CD
18637	18869	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18869	5	Although	although	IN
18637	18869	6	a	a	DT
18637	18869	7	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18869	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	18869	9	under	under	IN
18637	18869	10	a	a	DT
18637	18869	11	duty	duty	NN
18637	18869	12	to	to	TO
18637	18869	13	accept	accept	VB
18637	18869	14	goods	good	NNS
18637	18869	15	tendered	tender	VBN
18637	18869	16	at	at	IN
18637	18869	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18869	18	station	station	NN
18637	18869	19	,	,	,
18637	18869	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18869	21	can	can	MD
18637	18869	22	not	not	RB
18637	18869	23	be	be	VB
18637	18869	24	required	require	VBN
18637	18869	25	,	,	,
18637	18869	26	upon	upon	IN
18637	18869	27	payment	payment	NN
18637	18869	28	simply	simply	RB
18637	18869	29	for	for	IN
18637	18869	30	the	the	DT
18637	18869	31	service	service	NN
18637	18869	32	of	of	IN
18637	18869	33	carriage	carriage	NN
18637	18869	34	,	,	,
18637	18869	35	to	to	TO
18637	18869	36	accept	accept	VB
18637	18869	37	cars	car	NNS
18637	18869	38	offered	offer	VBN
18637	18869	39	at	at	IN
18637	18869	40	an	an	DT
18637	18869	41	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18869	42	connection	connection	NN
18637	18869	43	point	point	NN
18637	18869	44	near	near	IN
18637	18869	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18869	46	terminus	terminus	NN
18637	18869	47	by	by	IN
18637	18869	48	a	a	DT
18637	18869	49	competing	compete	VBG
18637	18869	50	road	road	NN
18637	18869	51	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	18869	52	to	to	TO
18637	18869	53	reach	reach	VB
18637	18869	54	and	and	CC
18637	18869	55	use	use	VB
18637	18869	56	the	the	DT
18637	18869	57	former	former	JJ
18637	18869	58	's	's	POS
18637	18869	59	terminal	terminal	NN
18637	18869	60	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	18869	61	.	.	.
18637	18870	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	18870	2	may	may	MD
18637	18870	3	a	a	DT
18637	18870	4	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18870	5	be	be	VB
18637	18870	6	required	require	VBN
18637	18870	7	to	to	TO
18637	18870	8	deliver	deliver	VB
18637	18870	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18870	10	cars	car	NNS
18637	18870	11	to	to	IN
18637	18870	12	connecting	connect	VBG
18637	18870	13	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	18870	14	without	without	IN
18637	18870	15	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	18870	16	protection	protection	NN
18637	18870	17	from	from	IN
18637	18870	18	loss	loss	NN
18637	18870	19	or	or	CC
18637	18870	20	undue	undue	JJ
18637	18870	21	detention	detention	NN
18637	18870	22	or	or	CC
18637	18870	23	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18870	24	for	for	IN
18637	18870	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18870	26	use	use	NN
18637	18870	27	.	.	.
18637	18871	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18871	2	257	257	CD
18637	18871	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18871	4	But	but	CC
18637	18871	5	a	a	DT
18637	18871	6	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18871	7	may	may	MD
18637	18871	8	be	be	VB
18637	18871	9	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	18871	10	to	to	TO
18637	18871	11	interchange	interchange	VB
18637	18871	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18871	13	freight	freight	NN
18637	18871	14	cars	car	NNS
18637	18871	15	with	with	IN
18637	18871	16	other	other	JJ
18637	18871	17	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	18871	18	under	under	IN
18637	18871	19	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18871	20	terms,[258	terms,[258	NN
18637	18871	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18871	22	and	and	CC
18637	18871	23	to	to	TO
18637	18871	24	accept	accept	VB
18637	18871	25	,	,	,
18637	18871	26	for	for	IN
18637	18871	27	reshipment	reshipment	NN
18637	18871	28	over	over	IN
18637	18871	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18871	30	lines	line	NNS
18637	18871	31	to	to	IN
18637	18871	32	points	point	NNS
18637	18871	33	within	within	IN
18637	18871	34	the	the	DT
18637	18871	35	State	State	NNP
18637	18871	36	,	,	,
18637	18871	37	cars	car	NNS
18637	18871	38	already	already	RB
18637	18871	39	loaded	load	VBN
18637	18871	40	and	and	CC
18637	18871	41	in	in	IN
18637	18871	42	suitable	suitable	JJ
18637	18871	43	condition	condition	NN
18637	18871	44	.	.	.
18637	18872	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18872	2	259	259	CD
18637	18872	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18872	4	Intercompany	Intercompany	NNP
18637	18872	5	Discriminatory	Discriminatory	NNP
18637	18872	6	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	18872	7	Service	Service	NNP
18637	18872	8	Charges.--Due	Charges.--Due	NNP
18637	18872	9	process	process	NN
18637	18872	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	18872	11	not	not	RB
18637	18872	12	denied	deny	VBN
18637	18872	13	when	when	WRB
18637	18872	14	two	two	CD
18637	18872	15	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	18872	16	,	,	,
18637	18872	17	who	who	WP
18637	18872	18	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	18872	19	own	own	VBP
18637	18872	20	and	and	CC
18637	18872	21	dominate	dominate	VBP
18637	18872	22	a	a	DT
18637	18872	23	small	small	JJ
18637	18872	24	connecting	connect	VBG
18637	18872	25	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18872	26	,	,	,
18637	18872	27	are	be	VBP
18637	18872	28	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	18872	29	from	from	IN
18637	18872	30	exacting	exact	VBG
18637	18872	31	higher	high	JJR
18637	18872	32	charges	charge	NNS
18637	18872	33	from	from	IN
18637	18872	34	shippers	shipper	NNS
18637	18872	35	accepting	accept	VBG
18637	18872	36	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	18872	37	over	over	IN
18637	18872	38	said	say	VBD
18637	18872	39	connecting	connect	VBG
18637	18872	40	road	road	NN
18637	18872	41	than	than	IN
18637	18872	42	are	be	VBP
18637	18872	43	collected	collect	VBN
18637	18872	44	from	from	IN
18637	18872	45	shippers	shipper	NNS
18637	18872	46	taking	take	VBG
18637	18872	47	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	18872	48	at	at	IN
18637	18872	49	the	the	DT
18637	18872	50	terminals	terminal	NNS
18637	18872	51	of	of	IN
18637	18872	52	said	say	VBN
18637	18872	53	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	18872	54	.	.	.
18637	18873	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18873	2	260	260	CD
18637	18873	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18873	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	18873	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	18873	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18873	7	"	"	``
18637	18873	8	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18873	9	"	"	''
18637	18873	10	or	or	CC
18637	18873	11	"	"	``
18637	18873	12	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18873	13	"	"	''
18637	18873	14	to	to	TO
18637	18873	15	require	require	VB
18637	18873	16	a	a	DT
18637	18873	17	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18873	18	to	to	TO
18637	18873	19	desist	desist	VB
18637	18873	20	from	from	IN
18637	18873	21	demanding	demand	VBG
18637	18873	22	freight	freight	NN
18637	18873	23	in	in	IN
18637	18873	24	advance	advance	NN
18637	18873	25	on	on	IN
18637	18873	26	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	18873	27	received	receive	VBN
18637	18873	28	from	from	IN
18637	18873	29	one	one	CD
18637	18873	30	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18873	31	while	while	IN
18637	18873	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18873	33	accepts	accept	VBZ
18637	18873	34	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	18873	35	of	of	IN
18637	18873	36	the	the	DT
18637	18873	37	same	same	JJ
18637	18873	38	character	character	NN
18637	18873	39	at	at	IN
18637	18873	40	the	the	DT
18637	18873	41	same	same	JJ
18637	18873	42	point	point	NN
18637	18873	43	from	from	IN
18637	18873	44	another	another	DT
18637	18873	45	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18873	46	without	without	IN
18637	18873	47	such	such	JJ
18637	18873	48	prepayment	prepayment	NN
18637	18873	49	.	.	.
18637	18874	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18874	2	261	261	CD
18637	18874	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18874	4	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	18874	5	Regulations	Regulations	NNPS
18637	18874	6	Applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	18874	7	to	to	IN
18637	18874	8	Railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	18874	9	The	the	DT
18637	18874	10	following	follow	VBG
18637	18874	11	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18874	12	with	with	IN
18637	18874	13	reference	reference	NN
18637	18874	14	to	to	IN
18637	18874	15	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	18874	16	have	have	VBP
18637	18874	17	been	be	VBN
18637	18874	18	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	18874	19	:	:	:
18637	18874	20	a	a	DT
18637	18874	21	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	18874	22	against	against	IN
18637	18874	23	operation	operation	NN
18637	18874	24	on	on	IN
18637	18874	25	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18874	26	streets,[262	streets,[262	NNS
18637	18874	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18874	28	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	18874	29	on	on	IN
18637	18874	30	speed	speed	NN
18637	18874	31	,	,	,
18637	18874	32	operations	operation	NNS
18637	18874	33	,	,	,
18637	18874	34	etc	etc	FW
18637	18874	35	.	.	FW
18637	18874	36	,	,	,
18637	18874	37	in	in	IN
18637	18874	38	business	business	NN
18637	18874	39	sections,[263	sections,[263	NN
18637	18874	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18874	41	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	18874	42	of	of	IN
18637	18874	43	construction	construction	NN
18637	18874	44	of	of	IN
18637	18874	45	a	a	DT
18637	18874	46	sidewalk	sidewalk	NN
18637	18874	47	across	across	IN
18637	18874	48	a	a	DT
18637	18874	49	right	right	NN
18637	18874	50	of	of	IN
18637	18874	51	way,[264	way,[264	NN
18637	18874	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18874	53	or	or	CC
18637	18874	54	removal	removal	NN
18637	18874	55	of	of	IN
18637	18874	56	a	a	DT
18637	18874	57	track	track	NN
18637	18874	58	crossing	cross	VBG
18637	18874	59	a	a	DT
18637	18874	60	thoroughfare,[265	thoroughfare,[265	NN
18637	18874	61	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18874	62	compelling	compel	VBG
18637	18874	63	the	the	DT
18637	18874	64	presence	presence	NN
18637	18874	65	of	of	IN
18637	18874	66	a	a	DT
18637	18874	67	flagman	flagman	NN
18637	18874	68	at	at	IN
18637	18874	69	a	a	DT
18637	18874	70	crossing	crossing	NN
18637	18874	71	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	18874	72	that	that	DT
18637	18874	73	automatic	automatic	JJ
18637	18874	74	device	device	NN
18637	18874	75	might	may	MD
18637	18874	76	be	be	VB
18637	18874	77	cheaper	cheap	JJR
18637	18874	78	and	and	CC
18637	18874	79	better,[266	better,[266	NN
18637	18874	80	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18874	81	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	18874	82	examination	examination	NN
18637	18874	83	of	of	IN
18637	18874	84	employees	employee	NNS
18637	18874	85	for	for	IN
18637	18874	86	color	color	NN
18637	18874	87	blindness,[267	blindness,[267	NN
18637	18874	88	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18874	89	full	full	JJ
18637	18874	90	crews	crew	NNS
18637	18874	91	on	on	IN
18637	18874	92	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18874	93	trains,[268	trains,[268	NNP
18637	18874	94	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18874	95	specification	specification	NN
18637	18874	96	of	of	IN
18637	18874	97	a	a	DT
18637	18874	98	type	type	NN
18637	18874	99	of	of	IN
18637	18874	100	locomotive	locomotive	JJ
18637	18874	101	headlight,[269	headlight,[269	NNS
18637	18874	102	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18874	103	safety	safety	NN
18637	18874	104	appliance	appliance	NN
18637	18874	105	regulations,[270	regulations,[270	NNP
18637	18874	106	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18874	107	and	and	CC
18637	18874	108	a	a	DT
18637	18874	109	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	18874	110	on	on	IN
18637	18874	111	the	the	DT
18637	18874	112	heating	heating	NN
18637	18874	113	of	of	IN
18637	18874	114	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	18874	115	cars	car	NNS
18637	18874	116	from	from	IN
18637	18874	117	stoves	stove	NNS
18637	18874	118	or	or	CC
18637	18874	119	furnaces	furnace	NNS
18637	18874	120	inside	inside	RB
18637	18874	121	or	or	CC
18637	18874	122	suspended	suspend	VBN
18637	18874	123	from	from	IN
18637	18874	124	the	the	DT
18637	18874	125	cars	car	NNS
18637	18874	126	.	.	.
18637	18875	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18875	2	271	271	CD
18637	18875	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18875	4	Liabilities	Liabilities	NNPS
18637	18875	5	and	and	CC
18637	18875	6	Penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	18875	7	A	a	DT
18637	18875	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	18875	9	making	make	VBG
18637	18875	10	the	the	DT
18637	18875	11	initial	initial	JJ
18637	18875	12	carrier[272	carrier[272	NN
18637	18875	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18875	14	or	or	CC
18637	18875	15	the	the	DT
18637	18875	16	connecting	connect	VBG
18637	18875	17	or	or	CC
18637	18875	18	delivering	deliver	VBG
18637	18875	19	carrier,[273	carrier,[273	NN
18637	18875	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18875	21	liable	liable	JJ
18637	18875	22	to	to	IN
18637	18875	23	the	the	DT
18637	18875	24	shipper	shipper	NN
18637	18875	25	for	for	IN
18637	18875	26	the	the	DT
18637	18875	27	nondelivery	nondelivery	NN
18637	18875	28	of	of	IN
18637	18875	29	goods	good	NNS
18637	18875	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	18875	31	not	not	RB
18637	18875	32	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18875	33	;	;	:
18637	18875	34	nor	nor	CC
18637	18875	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	18875	36	a	a	DT
18637	18875	37	law	law	NN
18637	18875	38	which	which	WDT
18637	18875	39	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	18875	40	that	that	IN
18637	18875	41	a	a	DT
18637	18875	42	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18875	43	shall	shall	MD
18637	18875	44	be	be	VB
18637	18875	45	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	18875	46	in	in	IN
18637	18875	47	damages	damage	NNS
18637	18875	48	to	to	IN
18637	18875	49	the	the	DT
18637	18875	50	owner	owner	NN
18637	18875	51	of	of	IN
18637	18875	52	property	property	NN
18637	18875	53	injured	injure	VBN
18637	18875	54	by	by	IN
18637	18875	55	fire	fire	NN
18637	18875	56	communicated	communicate	VBN
18637	18875	57	by	by	IN
18637	18875	58	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18875	59	locomotive	locomotive	JJ
18637	18875	60	engines	engine	NNS
18637	18875	61	and	and	CC
18637	18875	62	which	which	WDT
18637	18875	63	grants	grant	VBZ
18637	18875	64	the	the	DT
18637	18875	65	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18875	66	an	an	DT
18637	18875	67	insurable	insurable	JJ
18637	18875	68	interest	interest	NN
18637	18875	69	in	in	IN
18637	18875	70	such	such	JJ
18637	18875	71	property	property	NN
18637	18875	72	along	along	IN
18637	18875	73	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18875	74	route	route	NN
18637	18875	75	and	and	CC
18637	18875	76	authority	authority	NN
18637	18875	77	to	to	TO
18637	18875	78	procure	procure	VB
18637	18875	79	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18875	80	against	against	IN
18637	18875	81	such	such	JJ
18637	18875	82	liability	liability	NN
18637	18875	83	.	.	.
18637	18876	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18876	2	274	274	CD
18637	18876	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18876	4	Equally	equally	RB
18637	18876	5	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	18876	6	with	with	IN
18637	18876	7	the	the	DT
18637	18876	8	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	18876	9	of	of	IN
18637	18876	10	due	due	JJ
18637	18876	11	process	process	NN
18637	18876	12	are	be	VBP
18637	18876	13	the	the	DT
18637	18876	14	following	follow	VBG
18637	18876	15	two	two	CD
18637	18876	16	enactments	enactment	NNS
18637	18876	17	;	;	:
18637	18876	18	the	the	DT
18637	18876	19	first	first	JJ
18637	18876	20	,	,	,
18637	18876	21	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	18876	22	on	on	IN
18637	18876	23	all	all	DT
18637	18876	24	common	common	JJ
18637	18876	25	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	18876	26	a	a	DT
18637	18876	27	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	18876	28	for	for	IN
18637	18876	29	failure	failure	NN
18637	18876	30	to	to	TO
18637	18876	31	settle	settle	VB
18637	18876	32	within	within	IN
18637	18876	33	a	a	DT
18637	18876	34	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18876	35	specified	specified	JJ
18637	18876	36	period	period	NN
18637	18876	37	claims	claim	NNS
18637	18876	38	for	for	IN
18637	18876	39	freight	freight	NN
18637	18876	40	lost	lose	VBN
18637	18876	41	or	or	CC
18637	18876	42	damaged	damage	VBN
18637	18876	43	in	in	IN
18637	18876	44	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	18876	45	and	and	CC
18637	18876	46	conditioning	conditioning	NN
18637	18876	47	payment	payment	NN
18637	18876	48	of	of	IN
18637	18876	49	that	that	DT
18637	18876	50	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	18876	51	upon	upon	IN
18637	18876	52	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	18876	53	by	by	IN
18637	18876	54	the	the	DT
18637	18876	55	claimant	claimant	NN
18637	18876	56	in	in	IN
18637	18876	57	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	18876	58	suit	suit	NN
18637	18876	59	of	of	IN
18637	18876	60	more	more	JJR
18637	18876	61	than	than	IN
18637	18876	62	the	the	DT
18637	18876	63	amount	amount	NN
18637	18876	64	tendered,[275	tendered,[275	NN
18637	18876	65	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18876	66	and	and	CC
18637	18876	67	the	the	DT
18637	18876	68	second	second	JJ
18637	18876	69	,	,	,
18637	18876	70	levying	levy	VBG
18637	18876	71	double	double	JJ
18637	18876	72	damages	damage	NNS
18637	18876	73	and	and	CC
18637	18876	74	an	an	DT
18637	18876	75	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	18876	76	's	's	POS
18637	18876	77	fee	fee	NN
18637	18876	78	upon	upon	IN
18637	18876	79	a	a	DT
18637	18876	80	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18876	81	for	for	IN
18637	18876	82	failure	failure	NN
18637	18876	83	to	to	TO
18637	18876	84	pay	pay	VB
18637	18876	85	within	within	IN
18637	18876	86	a	a	DT
18637	18876	87	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18876	88	time	time	NN
18637	18876	89	after	after	IN
18637	18876	90	demand	demand	NN
18637	18876	91	the	the	DT
18637	18876	92	amount	amount	NN
18637	18876	93	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	18876	94	by	by	IN
18637	18876	95	an	an	DT
18637	18876	96	owner	owner	NN
18637	18876	97	for	for	IN
18637	18876	98	stock	stock	NN
18637	18876	99	injured	injure	VBN
18637	18876	100	or	or	CC
18637	18876	101	killed	kill	VBN
18637	18876	102	.	.	.
18637	18877	1	However	however	RB
18637	18877	2	,	,	,
18637	18877	3	only	only	RB
18637	18877	4	in	in	IN
18637	18877	5	the	the	DT
18637	18877	6	event	event	NN
18637	18877	7	that	that	WDT
18637	18877	8	the	the	DT
18637	18877	9	application	application	NN
18637	18877	10	of	of	IN
18637	18877	11	the	the	DT
18637	18877	12	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18877	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	18877	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	18877	15	limited	limit	VBN
18637	18877	16	to	to	IN
18637	18877	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	18877	18	where	where	WRB
18637	18877	19	the	the	DT
18637	18877	20	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	18877	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	18877	22	not	not	RB
18637	18877	23	demanded	demand	VBN
18637	18877	24	more	more	JJR
18637	18877	25	than	than	IN
18637	18877	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18877	27	recovered	recover	VBD
18637	18877	28	in	in	IN
18637	18877	29	court	court	NN
18637	18877	30	will	will	MD
18637	18877	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18877	32	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	18877	33	be	be	VB
18637	18877	34	upheld;[276	upheld;[276	ADD
18637	18877	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18877	36	but	but	CC
18637	18877	37	when	when	WRB
18637	18877	38	the	the	DT
18637	18877	39	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	18877	40	allowed	allow	VBD
18637	18877	41	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	18877	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	18877	43	exacted	exact	VBN
18637	18877	44	in	in	IN
18637	18877	45	a	a	DT
18637	18877	46	case	case	NN
18637	18877	47	in	in	IN
18637	18877	48	which	which	WDT
18637	18877	49	the	the	DT
18637	18877	50	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	18877	51	demanded	demand	VBD
18637	18877	52	more	more	JJR
18637	18877	53	than	than	IN
18637	18877	54	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18877	55	sued	sue	VBD
18637	18877	56	for	for	IN
18637	18877	57	and	and	CC
18637	18877	58	recovered	recover	VBD
18637	18877	59	,	,	,
18637	18877	60	a	a	DT
18637	18877	61	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	18877	62	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18877	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	18877	64	arbitrarily	arbitrarily	RB
18637	18877	65	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	18877	66	of	of	IN
18637	18877	67	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18877	68	property	property	NN
18637	18877	69	without	without	IN
18637	18877	70	due	due	JJ
18637	18877	71	process	process	NN
18637	18877	72	.	.	.
18637	18878	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18878	2	277	277	CD
18637	18878	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18878	4	The	the	DT
18637	18878	5	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	18878	6	of	of	IN
18637	18878	7	fair	fair	JJ
18637	18878	8	play	play	NN
18637	18878	9	are	be	VBP
18637	18878	10	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18878	11	violated	violate	VBN
18637	18878	12	by	by	IN
18637	18878	13	a	a	DT
18637	18878	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	18878	15	which	which	WDT
18637	18878	16	,	,	,
18637	18878	17	by	by	IN
18637	18878	18	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	18878	19	double	double	JJ
18637	18878	20	liability	liability	NN
18637	18878	21	for	for	IN
18637	18878	22	failure	failure	NN
18637	18878	23	to	to	TO
18637	18878	24	pay	pay	VB
18637	18878	25	the	the	DT
18637	18878	26	full	full	JJ
18637	18878	27	amount	amount	NN
18637	18878	28	of	of	IN
18637	18878	29	damages	damage	NNS
18637	18878	30	within	within	IN
18637	18878	31	60	60	CD
18637	18878	32	days	day	NNS
18637	18878	33	after	after	IN
18637	18878	34	notice	notice	NN
18637	18878	35	,	,	,
18637	18878	36	unless	unless	IN
18637	18878	37	the	the	DT
18637	18878	38	claimant	claimant	JJ
18637	18878	39	recovers	recover	NNS
18637	18878	40	less	less	JJR
18637	18878	41	than	than	IN
18637	18878	42	the	the	DT
18637	18878	43	amount	amount	NN
18637	18878	44	offered	offer	VBN
18637	18878	45	in	in	IN
18637	18878	46	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	18878	47	,	,	,
18637	18878	48	in	in	IN
18637	18878	49	effect	effect	NN
18637	18878	50	penalizes	penalize	VBZ
18637	18878	51	a	a	DT
18637	18878	52	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18878	53	for	for	IN
18637	18878	54	guessing	guess	VBG
18637	18878	55	incorrectly	incorrectly	RB
18637	18878	56	what	what	WP
18637	18878	57	a	a	DT
18637	18878	58	jury	jury	NN
18637	18878	59	would	would	MD
18637	18878	60	award	award	VB
18637	18878	61	.	.	.
18637	18879	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18879	2	278	278	CD
18637	18879	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18879	4	To	to	TO
18637	18879	5	penalize	penalize	VB
18637	18879	6	a	a	DT
18637	18879	7	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18879	8	which	which	WDT
18637	18879	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	18879	10	collected	collect	VBN
18637	18879	11	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	18879	12	charges	charge	NNS
18637	18879	13	in	in	IN
18637	18879	14	excess	excess	NN
18637	18879	15	of	of	IN
18637	18879	16	established	establish	VBN
18637	18879	17	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	18879	18	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18879	19	by	by	IN
18637	18879	20	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	18879	21	a	a	DT
18637	18879	22	person	person	NN
18637	18879	23	wronged	wrong	VBN
18637	18879	24	to	to	TO
18637	18879	25	sue	sue	VB
18637	18879	26	for	for	IN
18637	18879	27	and	and	CC
18637	18879	28	collect	collect	VB
18637	18879	29	as	as	IN
18637	18879	30	liquidated	liquidate	VBN
18637	18879	31	damages	damage	NNS
18637	18879	32	$	$	$
18637	18879	33	500	500	CD
18637	18879	34	plus	plus	IN
18637	18879	35	a	a	DT
18637	18879	36	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18879	37	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	18879	38	's	's	POS
18637	18879	39	fee	fee	NN
18637	18879	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	18879	41	to	to	TO
18637	18879	42	subject	subject	VB
18637	18879	43	the	the	DT
18637	18879	44	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18879	45	to	to	IN
18637	18879	46	a	a	DT
18637	18879	47	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	18879	48	so	so	RB
18637	18879	49	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18879	50	as	as	IN
18637	18879	51	to	to	TO
18637	18879	52	be	be	VB
18637	18879	53	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	18879	54	to	to	IN
18637	18879	55	the	the	DT
18637	18879	56	due	due	JJ
18637	18879	57	process	process	NN
18637	18879	58	clause	clause	NN
18637	18879	59	;	;	:
18637	18879	60	for	for	IN
18637	18879	61	such	such	JJ
18637	18879	62	liability	liability	NN
18637	18879	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	18879	64	not	not	RB
18637	18879	65	only	only	RB
18637	18879	66	disproportionate	disproportionate	JJ
18637	18879	67	to	to	IN
18637	18879	68	actual	actual	JJ
18637	18879	69	damages	damage	NNS
18637	18879	70	,	,	,
18637	18879	71	but	but	CC
18637	18879	72	is	be	VBZ
18637	18879	73	being	be	VBG
18637	18879	74	exacted	exact	VBN
18637	18879	75	under	under	IN
18637	18879	76	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	18879	77	which	which	WDT
18637	18879	78	do	do	VBP
18637	18879	79	not	not	RB
18637	18879	80	afford	afford	VB
18637	18879	81	the	the	DT
18637	18879	82	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18879	83	an	an	DT
18637	18879	84	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	18879	85	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	18879	86	for	for	IN
18637	18879	87	safely	safely	RB
18637	18879	88	testing	test	VBG
18637	18879	89	the	the	DT
18637	18879	90	validity	validity	NN
18637	18879	91	of	of	IN
18637	18879	92	the	the	DT
18637	18879	93	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18879	94	before	before	IN
18637	18879	95	any	any	DT
18637	18879	96	liability	liability	NN
18637	18879	97	for	for	IN
18637	18879	98	the	the	DT
18637	18879	99	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	18879	100	attaches	attach	VBZ
18637	18879	101	.	.	.
18637	18880	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18880	2	279	279	CD
18637	18880	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18880	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	18880	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18880	6	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	18880	7	,	,	,
18637	18880	8	however	however	RB
18637	18880	9	,	,	,
18637	18880	10	that	that	IN
18637	18880	11	the	the	DT
18637	18880	12	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18880	13	had	have	VBD
18637	18880	14	an	an	DT
18637	18880	15	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	18880	16	to	to	TO
18637	18880	17	test	test	VB
18637	18880	18	the	the	DT
18637	18880	19	reasonableness	reasonableness	NN
18637	18880	20	of	of	IN
18637	18880	21	the	the	DT
18637	18880	22	rate	rate	NN
18637	18880	23	,	,	,
18637	18880	24	and	and	CC
18637	18880	25	that	that	IN
18637	18880	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18880	27	deviation	deviation	NN
18637	18880	28	therefrom	therefrom	NN
18637	18880	29	,	,	,
18637	18880	30	by	by	IN
18637	18880	31	collection	collection	NN
18637	18880	32	of	of	IN
18637	18880	33	an	an	DT
18637	18880	34	overcharge	overcharge	NN
18637	18880	35	,	,	,
18637	18880	36	did	do	VBD
18637	18880	37	not	not	RB
18637	18880	38	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	18880	39	from	from	IN
18637	18880	40	any	any	DT
18637	18880	41	belief	belief	NN
18637	18880	42	that	that	IN
18637	18880	43	the	the	DT
18637	18880	44	rate	rate	NN
18637	18880	45	was	be	VBD
18637	18880	46	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	18880	47	,	,	,
18637	18880	48	the	the	DT
18637	18880	49	validity	validity	NN
18637	18880	50	of	of	IN
18637	18880	51	the	the	DT
18637	18880	52	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	18880	53	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18880	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	18880	55	not	not	RB
18637	18880	56	to	to	TO
18637	18880	57	be	be	VB
18637	18880	58	tested	test	VBN
18637	18880	59	by	by	IN
18637	18880	60	comparison	comparison	NN
18637	18880	61	with	with	IN
18637	18880	62	the	the	DT
18637	18880	63	amount	amount	NN
18637	18880	64	of	of	IN
18637	18880	65	the	the	DT
18637	18880	66	overcharge	overcharge	NN
18637	18880	67	.	.	.
18637	18881	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	18881	2	as	as	IN
18637	18881	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18881	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	18881	5	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18881	6	as	as	IN
18637	18881	7	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	18881	8	for	for	IN
18637	18881	9	violation	violation	NN
18637	18881	10	of	of	IN
18637	18881	11	a	a	DT
18637	18881	12	law	law	NN
18637	18881	13	,	,	,
18637	18881	14	the	the	DT
18637	18881	15	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18881	16	may	may	MD
18637	18881	17	adjust	adjust	VB
18637	18881	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18881	19	amount	amount	NN
18637	18881	20	to	to	IN
18637	18881	21	the	the	DT
18637	18881	22	public	public	JJ
18637	18881	23	wrong	wrong	NN
18637	18881	24	rather	rather	RB
18637	18881	25	than	than	IN
18637	18881	26	the	the	DT
18637	18881	27	private	private	JJ
18637	18881	28	injury	injury	NN
18637	18881	29	,	,	,
18637	18881	30	and	and	CC
18637	18881	31	the	the	DT
18637	18881	32	only	only	JJ
18637	18881	33	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	18881	34	which	which	WDT
18637	18881	35	the	the	DT
18637	18881	36	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18881	37	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18881	38	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	18881	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	18881	40	that	that	IN
18637	18881	41	the	the	DT
18637	18881	42	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	18881	43	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	18881	44	shall	shall	MD
18637	18881	45	not	not	RB
18637	18881	46	be	be	VB
18637	18881	47	"	"	``
18637	18881	48	so	so	RB
18637	18881	49	severe	severe	JJ
18637	18881	50	and	and	CC
18637	18881	51	oppressive	oppressive	JJ
18637	18881	52	as	as	IN
18637	18881	53	to	to	TO
18637	18881	54	be	be	VB
18637	18881	55	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	18881	56	disproportioned	disproportione	VBN
18637	18881	57	to	to	IN
18637	18881	58	the	the	DT
18637	18881	59	offense	offense	NN
18637	18881	60	and	and	CC
18637	18881	61	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	18881	62	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18881	63	.	.	.
18637	18881	64	"	"	''
18637	18882	1	In	in	IN
18637	18882	2	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	18882	3	with	with	IN
18637	18882	4	the	the	DT
18637	18882	5	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18882	6	standard	standard	NN
18637	18882	7	,	,	,
18637	18882	8	a	a	DT
18637	18882	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	18882	10	granting	grant	VBG
18637	18882	11	an	an	DT
18637	18882	12	aggrieved	aggrieved	JJ
18637	18882	13	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	18882	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18882	15	who	who	WP
18637	18882	16	recovered	recover	VBD
18637	18882	17	$	$	$
18637	18882	18	100	100	CD
18637	18882	19	for	for	IN
18637	18882	20	an	an	DT
18637	18882	21	overcharge	overcharge	NN
18637	18882	22	of	of	IN
18637	18882	23	60	60	CD
18637	18882	24	cents	cent	NNS
18637	18882	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18882	26	the	the	DT
18637	18882	27	right	right	NN
18637	18882	28	to	to	TO
18637	18882	29	recover	recover	VB
18637	18882	30	in	in	IN
18637	18882	31	a	a	DT
18637	18882	32	civil	civil	JJ
18637	18882	33	suit	suit	NN
18637	18882	34	not	not	RB
18637	18882	35	less	less	JJR
18637	18882	36	than	than	IN
18637	18882	37	$	$	$
18637	18882	38	50	50	CD
18637	18882	39	nor	nor	CC
18637	18882	40	more	more	JJR
18637	18882	41	than	than	IN
18637	18882	42	$	$	$
18637	18882	43	300	300	CD
18637	18882	44	plus	plus	CC
18637	18882	45	costs	cost	NNS
18637	18882	46	and	and	CC
18637	18882	47	a	a	DT
18637	18882	48	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18882	49	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	18882	50	's	's	POS
18637	18882	51	fee	fee	NN
18637	18882	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	18882	53	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18882	54	.	.	.
18637	18883	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18883	2	280	280	CD
18637	18883	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18883	4	For	for	IN
18637	18883	5	like	like	JJ
18637	18883	6	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	18883	7	,	,	,
18637	18883	8	a	a	DT
18637	18883	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	18883	10	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18883	11	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	18883	12	to	to	TO
18637	18883	13	erect	erect	VB
18637	18883	14	and	and	CC
18637	18883	15	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	18883	16	fences	fence	NNS
18637	18883	17	and	and	CC
18637	18883	18	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	18883	19	guards	guard	NNS
18637	18883	20	,	,	,
18637	18883	21	and	and	CC
18637	18883	22	making	make	VBG
18637	18883	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18883	24	liable	liable	JJ
18637	18883	25	in	in	IN
18637	18883	26	double	double	JJ
18637	18883	27	amount	amount	NN
18637	18883	28	of	of	IN
18637	18883	29	damages	damage	NNS
18637	18883	30	for	for	IN
18637	18883	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18883	32	failure	failure	NN
18637	18883	33	to	to	TO
18637	18883	34	so	so	RB
18637	18883	35	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	18883	36	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18883	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	18883	38	not	not	RB
18637	18883	39	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18883	40	.	.	.
18637	18884	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18884	2	281	281	CD
18637	18884	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18884	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	18884	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	18884	6	a	a	DT
18637	18884	7	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	18884	8	law	law	NN
18637	18884	9	which	which	WDT
18637	18884	10	establishes	establish	VBZ
18637	18884	11	a	a	DT
18637	18884	12	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	18884	13	rate	rate	NN
18637	18884	14	of	of	IN
18637	18884	15	speed	speed	NN
18637	18884	16	for	for	IN
18637	18884	17	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	18884	18	of	of	IN
18637	18884	19	livestock	livestock	NN
18637	18884	20	and	and	CC
18637	18884	21	which	which	WDT
18637	18884	22	requires	require	VBZ
18637	18884	23	every	every	DT
18637	18884	24	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	18884	25	violating	violate	VBG
18637	18884	26	the	the	DT
18637	18884	27	same	same	JJ
18637	18884	28	to	to	TO
18637	18884	29	pay	pay	VB
18637	18884	30	the	the	DT
18637	18884	31	owner	owner	NN
18637	18884	32	of	of	IN
18637	18884	33	such	such	JJ
18637	18884	34	livestock	livestock	NN
18637	18884	35	the	the	DT
18637	18884	36	sum	sum	NN
18637	18884	37	of	of	IN
18637	18884	38	$	$	$
18637	18884	39	10	10	CD
18637	18884	40	per	per	IN
18637	18884	41	car	car	NN
18637	18884	42	per	per	IN
18637	18884	43	hour	hour	NN
18637	18884	44	.	.	.
18637	18885	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18885	2	282	282	CD
18637	18885	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18885	4	On	on	IN
18637	18885	5	the	the	DT
18637	18885	6	other	other	JJ
18637	18885	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	18885	8	,	,	,
18637	18885	9	when	when	WRB
18637	18885	10	a	a	DT
18637	18885	11	telephone	telephone	NN
18637	18885	12	company	company	NN
18637	18885	13	,	,	,
18637	18885	14	in	in	IN
18637	18885	15	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	18885	16	with	with	IN
18637	18885	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18885	18	established	establish	VBN
18637	18885	19	and	and	CC
18637	18885	20	uncontested	uncontested	JJ
18637	18885	21	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18885	22	,	,	,
18637	18885	23	suspends	suspend	VBZ
18637	18885	24	the	the	DT
18637	18885	25	service	service	NN
18637	18885	26	of	of	IN
18637	18885	27	a	a	DT
18637	18885	28	patron	patron	NN
18637	18885	29	in	in	IN
18637	18885	30	arrears	arrear	NNS
18637	18885	31	,	,	,
18637	18885	32	infliction	infliction	NN
18637	18885	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	18885	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18885	35	of	of	IN
18637	18885	36	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	18885	37	aggregating	aggregate	VBG
18637	18885	38	$	$	$
18637	18885	39	3,600	3,600	CD
18637	18885	40	,	,	,
18637	18885	41	levied	levy	VBN
18637	18885	42	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	18885	43	to	to	IN
18637	18885	44	a	a	DT
18637	18885	45	statute	statute	NN
18637	18885	46	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	18885	47	fines	fine	NNS
18637	18885	48	of	of	IN
18637	18885	49	$	$	$
18637	18885	50	100	100	CD
18637	18885	51	per	per	IN
18637	18885	52	day	day	NN
18637	18885	53	for	for	IN
18637	18885	54	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	18885	55	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	18885	56	,	,	,
18637	18885	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	18885	58	so	so	RB
18637	18885	59	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	18885	60	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18885	61	and	and	CC
18637	18885	62	oppressive	oppressive	JJ
18637	18885	63	as	as	IN
18637	18885	64	to	to	TO
18637	18885	65	take	take	VB
18637	18885	66	property	property	NN
18637	18885	67	without	without	IN
18637	18885	68	due	due	JJ
18637	18885	69	process	process	NN
18637	18885	70	.	.	.
18637	18886	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18886	2	283	283	CD
18637	18886	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18886	4	REGULATION	regulation	NN
18637	18886	5	OF	of	IN
18637	18886	6	CORPORATIONS	corporations	NN
18637	18886	7	,	,	,
18637	18886	8	BUSINESS	busines	NNS
18637	18886	9	,	,	,
18637	18886	10	PROFESSIONS	profession	NNS
18637	18886	11	,	,	,
18637	18886	12	AND	and	CC
18637	18886	13	TRADES	trades	XX
18637	18886	14	Domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	18886	15	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18886	16	Although	although	IN
18637	18886	17	a	a	DT
18637	18886	18	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18886	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	18886	20	the	the	DT
18637	18886	21	creation	creation	NN
18637	18886	22	of	of	IN
18637	18886	23	a	a	DT
18637	18886	24	State	state	NN
18637	18886	25	which	which	WDT
18637	18886	26	reserves	reserve	VBZ
18637	18886	27	the	the	DT
18637	18886	28	power	power	NN
18637	18886	29	to	to	TO
18637	18886	30	amend	amend	VB
18637	18886	31	or	or	CC
18637	18886	32	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	18886	33	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	18886	34	charters	charter	NNS
18637	18886	35	,	,	,
18637	18886	36	the	the	DT
18637	18886	37	retention	retention	NN
18637	18886	38	of	of	IN
18637	18886	39	such	such	JJ
18637	18886	40	power	power	NN
18637	18886	41	will	will	MD
18637	18886	42	not	not	RB
18637	18886	43	support	support	VB
18637	18886	44	the	the	DT
18637	18886	45	taking	taking	NN
18637	18886	46	of	of	IN
18637	18886	47	the	the	DT
18637	18886	48	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	18886	49	property	property	NN
18637	18886	50	without	without	IN
18637	18886	51	due	due	JJ
18637	18886	52	process	process	NN
18637	18886	53	of	of	IN
18637	18886	54	law	law	NN
18637	18886	55	.	.	.
18637	18887	1	To	to	TO
18637	18887	2	terminate	terminate	VB
18637	18887	3	the	the	DT
18637	18887	4	life	life	NN
18637	18887	5	of	of	IN
18637	18887	6	a	a	DT
18637	18887	7	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18887	8	by	by	IN
18637	18887	9	annulling	annul	VBG
18637	18887	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18887	11	charter	charter	NN
18637	18887	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	18887	13	not	not	RB
18637	18887	14	to	to	TO
18637	18887	15	confiscate	confiscate	VB
18637	18887	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18887	17	property	property	NN
18637	18887	18	but	but	CC
18637	18887	19	to	to	TO
18637	18887	20	turn	turn	VB
18637	18887	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18887	22	over	over	RP
18637	18887	23	to	to	IN
18637	18887	24	the	the	DT
18637	18887	25	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	18887	26	after	after	IN
18637	18887	27	liquidation	liquidation	NN
18637	18887	28	.	.	.
18637	18888	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18888	2	284	284	CD
18637	18888	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18888	4	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	18888	5	,	,	,
18637	18888	6	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18888	7	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18888	8	,	,	,
18637	18888	9	as	as	IN
18637	18888	10	by	by	IN
18637	18888	11	the	the	DT
18637	18888	12	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	18888	13	of	of	IN
18637	18888	14	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	18888	15	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18888	16	,	,	,
18637	18888	17	although	although	IN
18637	18888	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18888	19	ostensibly	ostensibly	RB
18637	18888	20	falls	fall	VBZ
18637	18888	21	short	short	RB
18637	18888	22	of	of	IN
18637	18888	23	termination	termination	NN
18637	18888	24	of	of	IN
18637	18888	25	the	the	DT
18637	18888	26	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	18888	27	existence	existence	NN
18637	18888	28	,	,	,
18637	18888	29	entails	entail	VBZ
18637	18888	30	an	an	DT
18637	18888	31	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	18888	32	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18888	33	.	.	.
18637	18889	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18889	2	285	285	CD
18637	18889	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18889	4	Foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18889	5	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18889	6	Foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18889	7	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18889	8	also	also	RB
18637	18889	9	enjoy	enjoy	VBP
18637	18889	10	the	the	DT
18637	18889	11	protection	protection	NN
18637	18889	12	which	which	WDT
18637	18889	13	the	the	DT
18637	18889	14	due	due	JJ
18637	18889	15	process	process	NN
18637	18889	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	18889	17	affords	afford	NNS
18637	18889	18	;	;	:
18637	18889	19	but	but	CC
18637	18889	20	such	such	JJ
18637	18889	21	protection	protection	NN
18637	18889	22	does	do	VBZ
18637	18889	23	not	not	RB
18637	18889	24	entitle	entitle	VB
18637	18889	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18889	26	to	to	TO
18637	18889	27	enter	enter	VB
18637	18889	28	another	another	DT
18637	18889	29	State	state	NN
18637	18889	30	or	or	CC
18637	18889	31	,	,	,
18637	18889	32	once	once	RB
18637	18889	33	having	have	VBG
18637	18889	34	been	be	VBN
18637	18889	35	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	18889	36	to	to	TO
18637	18889	37	enter	enter	VB
18637	18889	38	,	,	,
18637	18889	39	to	to	TO
18637	18889	40	continue	continue	VB
18637	18889	41	to	to	TO
18637	18889	42	do	do	VB
18637	18889	43	business	business	NN
18637	18889	44	therein	therein	RB
18637	18889	45	.	.	.
18637	18890	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18890	2	286	286	CD
18637	18890	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18890	4	The	the	DT
18637	18890	5	power	power	NN
18637	18890	6	of	of	IN
18637	18890	7	a	a	DT
18637	18890	8	State	State	NNP
18637	18890	9	to	to	TO
18637	18890	10	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	18890	11	or	or	CC
18637	18890	12	to	to	TO
18637	18890	13	expel	expel	VB
18637	18890	14	a	a	DT
18637	18890	15	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18890	16	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18890	17	being	be	VBG
18637	18890	18	almost	almost	RB
18637	18890	19	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	18890	20	as	as	RB
18637	18890	21	long	long	RB
18637	18890	22	as	as	IN
18637	18890	23	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	18890	24	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18890	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	18890	26	not	not	RB
18637	18890	27	directly	directly	RB
18637	18890	28	affected	affect	VBN
18637	18890	29	,	,	,
18637	18890	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18890	31	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	18890	32	that	that	IN
18637	18890	33	a	a	DT
18637	18890	34	State	state	NN
18637	18890	35	may	may	MD
18637	18890	36	subject	subject	VB
18637	18890	37	such	such	JJ
18637	18890	38	entry	entry	NN
18637	18890	39	or	or	CC
18637	18890	40	continued	continue	VBN
18637	18890	41	operation	operation	NN
18637	18890	42	to	to	IN
18637	18890	43	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	18890	44	.	.	.
18637	18891	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18891	2	,	,	,
18637	18891	3	a	a	DT
18637	18891	4	State	State	NNP
18637	18891	5	law	law	NN
18637	18891	6	which	which	WDT
18637	18891	7	requires	require	VBZ
18637	18891	8	the	the	DT
18637	18891	9	filing	filing	NN
18637	18891	10	of	of	IN
18637	18891	11	articles	article	NNS
18637	18891	12	with	with	IN
18637	18891	13	a	a	DT
18637	18891	14	local	local	JJ
18637	18891	15	official	official	NN
18637	18891	16	as	as	IN
18637	18891	17	a	a	DT
18637	18891	18	condition	condition	NN
18637	18891	19	prerequisite	prerequisite	JJ
18637	18891	20	to	to	IN
18637	18891	21	the	the	DT
18637	18891	22	validity	validity	NN
18637	18891	23	of	of	IN
18637	18891	24	conveyances	conveyance	NNS
18637	18891	25	of	of	IN
18637	18891	26	local	local	JJ
18637	18891	27	realty	realty	NN
18637	18891	28	to	to	IN
18637	18891	29	such	such	JJ
18637	18891	30	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18891	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	18891	32	not	not	RB
18637	18891	33	violative	violative	JJ
18637	18891	34	of	of	IN
18637	18891	35	due	due	JJ
18637	18891	36	process	process	NN
18637	18891	37	.	.	.
18637	18892	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18892	2	287	287	CD
18637	18892	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18892	4	Neither	neither	CC
18637	18892	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	18892	6	a	a	DT
18637	18892	7	State	State	NNP
18637	18892	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	18892	9	which	which	WDT
18637	18892	10	requires	require	VBZ
18637	18892	11	a	a	DT
18637	18892	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18892	13	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18892	14	company	company	NN
18637	18892	15	,	,	,
18637	18892	16	as	as	IN
18637	18892	17	part	part	NN
18637	18892	18	of	of	IN
18637	18892	19	the	the	DT
18637	18892	20	price	price	NN
18637	18892	21	of	of	IN
18637	18892	22	entry	entry	NN
18637	18892	23	,	,	,
18637	18892	24	to	to	TO
18637	18892	25	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	18892	26	reserves	reserve	NNS
18637	18892	27	computed	compute	VBN
18637	18892	28	by	by	IN
18637	18892	29	a	a	DT
18637	18892	30	specific	specific	JJ
18637	18892	31	percentage	percentage	NN
18637	18892	32	of	of	IN
18637	18892	33	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	18892	34	,	,	,
18637	18892	35	including	include	VBG
18637	18892	36	membership	membership	NN
18637	18892	37	fees	fee	NNS
18637	18892	38	,	,	,
18637	18892	39	received	receive	VBN
18637	18892	40	in	in	IN
18637	18892	41	all	all	DT
18637	18892	42	States	state	NNS
18637	18892	43	.	.	.
18637	18893	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18893	2	288	288	CD
18637	18893	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18893	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18893	5	a	a	DT
18637	18893	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	18893	7	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18893	8	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18893	9	to	to	TO
18637	18893	10	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	18893	11	of	of	IN
18637	18893	12	farm	farm	NN
18637	18893	13	land	land	NN
18637	18893	14	not	not	RB
18637	18893	15	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18893	16	to	to	IN
18637	18893	17	the	the	DT
18637	18893	18	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	18893	19	of	of	IN
18637	18893	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18893	21	business	business	NN
18637	18893	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	18893	23	not	not	RB
18637	18893	24	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	18893	25	as	as	IN
18637	18893	26	applied	apply	VBN
18637	18893	27	to	to	IN
18637	18893	28	a	a	DT
18637	18893	29	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18893	30	hospital	hospital	NN
18637	18893	31	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18893	32	,	,	,
18637	18893	33	even	even	RB
18637	18893	34	though	though	IN
18637	18893	35	the	the	DT
18637	18893	36	latter	latter	JJ
18637	18893	37	,	,	,
18637	18893	38	because	because	IN
18637	18893	39	of	of	IN
18637	18893	40	changed	change	VBN
18637	18893	41	economic	economic	JJ
18637	18893	42	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	18893	43	,	,	,
18637	18893	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	18893	45	unable	unable	JJ
18637	18893	46	to	to	TO
18637	18893	47	recoup	recoup	VB
18637	18893	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18893	49	original	original	JJ
18637	18893	50	investment	investment	NN
18637	18893	51	from	from	IN
18637	18893	52	the	the	DT
18637	18893	53	sale	sale	NN
18637	18893	54	which	which	WDT
18637	18893	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18893	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	18893	57	thus	thus	RB
18637	18893	58	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	18893	59	to	to	TO
18637	18893	60	make	make	VB
18637	18893	61	.	.	.
18637	18894	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18894	2	289	289	CD
18637	18894	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18894	4	Business	business	NN
18637	18894	5	:	:	:
18637	18894	6	In	in	IN
18637	18894	7	General	General	NNP
18637	18894	8	"	"	``
18637	18894	9	The	the	DT
18637	18894	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18894	11	does	do	VBZ
18637	18894	12	not	not	RB
18637	18894	13	guarantee	guarantee	VB
18637	18894	14	the	the	DT
18637	18894	15	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
18637	18894	16	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	18894	17	to	to	TO
18637	18894	18	engage	engage	VB
18637	18894	19	in	in	IN
18637	18894	20	a	a	DT
18637	18894	21	business	business	NN
18637	18894	22	or	or	CC
18637	18894	23	to	to	TO
18637	18894	24	conduct	conduct	VB
18637	18894	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18894	26	as	as	IN
18637	18894	27	one	one	CD
18637	18894	28	pleases	please	VBZ
18637	18894	29	.	.	.
18637	18895	1	Certain	certain	JJ
18637	18895	2	kinds	kind	NNS
18637	18895	3	of	of	IN
18637	18895	4	business	business	NN
18637	18895	5	may	may	MD
18637	18895	6	be	be	VB
18637	18895	7	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	18895	8	;	;	:
18637	18895	9	and	and	CC
18637	18895	10	the	the	DT
18637	18895	11	right	right	NN
18637	18895	12	to	to	TO
18637	18895	13	conduct	conduct	VB
18637	18895	14	a	a	DT
18637	18895	15	business	business	NN
18637	18895	16	,	,	,
18637	18895	17	or	or	CC
18637	18895	18	to	to	TO
18637	18895	19	pursue	pursue	VB
18637	18895	20	a	a	DT
18637	18895	21	calling	calling	NN
18637	18895	22	,	,	,
18637	18895	23	may	may	MD
18637	18895	24	be	be	VB
18637	18895	25	conditioned	condition	VBN
18637	18895	26	.	.	.
18637	18896	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18896	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18896	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18896	4	Statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18896	5	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	18896	6	the	the	DT
18637	18896	7	terms	term	NNS
18637	18896	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	18896	9	which	which	WDT
18637	18896	10	those	those	DT
18637	18896	11	conducting	conduct	VBG
18637	18896	12	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18896	13	businesses	business	NNS
18637	18896	14	may	may	MD
18637	18896	15	contract	contract	VB
18637	18896	16	,	,	,
18637	18896	17	or	or	CC
18637	18896	18	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	18896	19	terms	term	NNS
18637	18896	20	if	if	IN
18637	18896	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18896	22	do	do	VBP
18637	18896	23	enter	enter	VB
18637	18896	24	into	into	IN
18637	18896	25	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	18896	26	,	,	,
18637	18896	27	are	be	VBP
18637	18896	28	within	within	IN
18637	18896	29	the	the	DT
18637	18896	30	State	State	NNP
18637	18896	31	's	's	POS
18637	18896	32	competency	competency	NN
18637	18896	33	.	.	.
18637	18897	1	"	"	``
18637	18897	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18897	3	290	290	CD
18637	18897	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18897	5	Laws	law	NNS
18637	18897	6	Prohibiting	Prohibiting	NNP
18637	18897	7	Trusts	Trusts	NNPS
18637	18897	8	,	,	,
18637	18897	9	Discrimination	Discrimination	NNP
18637	18897	10	,	,	,
18637	18897	11	Restraint	Restraint	NNP
18637	18897	12	of	of	IN
18637	18897	13	Trade.--A	Trade.--A	NNP
18637	18897	14	State	State	NNP
18637	18897	15	act	act	NN
18637	18897	16	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	18897	17	trusts	trust	NNS
18637	18897	18	,	,	,
18637	18897	19	etc	etc	FW
18637	18897	20	.	.	FW
18637	18897	21	,	,	,
18637	18897	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	18897	23	not	not	RB
18637	18897	24	in	in	IN
18637	18897	25	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	18897	26	with	with	IN
18637	18897	27	the	the	DT
18637	18897	28	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18897	29	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18897	30	as	as	IN
18637	18897	31	to	to	IN
18637	18897	32	a	a	DT
18637	18897	33	person	person	NN
18637	18897	34	combining	combine	VBG
18637	18897	35	with	with	IN
18637	18897	36	others	other	NNS
18637	18897	37	to	to	IN
18637	18897	38	pool	pool	VB
18637	18897	39	and	and	CC
18637	18897	40	fix	fix	NN
18637	18897	41	prices	price	NNS
18637	18897	42	,	,	,
18637	18897	43	divide	divide	VB
18637	18897	44	net	net	JJ
18637	18897	45	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	18897	46	,	,	,
18637	18897	47	and	and	CC
18637	18897	48	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18897	49	competition	competition	NN
18637	18897	50	in	in	IN
18637	18897	51	the	the	DT
18637	18897	52	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	18897	53	and	and	CC
18637	18897	54	sale	sale	NN
18637	18897	55	of	of	IN
18637	18897	56	grain	grain	NN
18637	18897	57	.	.	.
18637	18898	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18898	2	291	291	CD
18637	18898	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18898	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	18898	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	18898	6	the	the	DT
18637	18898	7	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18898	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18898	9	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	18898	10	a	a	DT
18637	18898	11	State	state	NN
18637	18898	12	from	from	IN
18637	18898	13	adopting	adopt	VBG
18637	18898	14	a	a	DT
18637	18898	15	policy	policy	NN
18637	18898	16	against	against	IN
18637	18898	17	all	all	DT
18637	18898	18	combinations	combination	NNS
18637	18898	19	of	of	IN
18637	18898	20	competing	compete	VBG
18637	18898	21	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	18898	22	and	and	CC
18637	18898	23	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	18898	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18898	25	even	even	RB
18637	18898	26	against	against	IN
18637	18898	27	combinations	combination	NNS
18637	18898	28	which	which	WDT
18637	18898	29	may	may	MD
18637	18898	30	have	have	VB
18637	18898	31	been	be	VBN
18637	18898	32	induced	induce	VBN
18637	18898	33	by	by	IN
18637	18898	34	good	good	JJ
18637	18898	35	intentions	intention	NNS
18637	18898	36	and	and	CC
18637	18898	37	from	from	IN
18637	18898	38	which	which	WDT
18637	18898	39	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	18898	40	and	and	CC
18637	18898	41	not	not	RB
18637	18898	42	injury	injury	NN
18637	18898	43	may	may	MD
18637	18898	44	have	have	VB
18637	18898	45	resulted	result	VBN
18637	18898	46	.	.	.
18637	18899	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18899	2	292	292	CD
18637	18899	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18899	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	18899	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	18899	6	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18899	7	of	of	IN
18637	18899	8	contract	contract	NN
18637	18899	9	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	RB
18637	18899	10	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	18899	11	by	by	IN
18637	18899	12	a	a	DT
18637	18899	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	18899	14	which	which	WDT
18637	18899	15	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	18899	16	retail	retail	JJ
18637	18899	17	lumber	lumber	NN
18637	18899	18	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	18899	19	from	from	IN
18637	18899	20	uniting	unite	VBG
18637	18899	21	in	in	IN
18637	18899	22	an	an	DT
18637	18899	23	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	18899	24	not	not	RB
18637	18899	25	to	to	TO
18637	18899	26	purchase	purchase	VB
18637	18899	27	materials	material	NNS
18637	18899	28	from	from	IN
18637	18899	29	wholesalers	wholesaler	NNS
18637	18899	30	selling	sell	VBG
18637	18899	31	directly	directly	RB
18637	18899	32	to	to	IN
18637	18899	33	consumers	consumer	NNS
18637	18899	34	in	in	IN
18637	18899	35	the	the	DT
18637	18899	36	retailers	retailer	NNS
18637	18899	37	'	'	POS
18637	18899	38	localities,[293	localities,[293	NN
18637	18899	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18899	40	nor	nor	CC
18637	18899	41	by	by	IN
18637	18899	42	a	a	DT
18637	18899	43	law	law	NN
18637	18899	44	punishing	punish	VBG
18637	18899	45	combinations	combination	NNS
18637	18899	46	for	for	IN
18637	18899	47	"	"	``
18637	18899	48	maliciously	maliciously	RB
18637	18899	49	"	"	''
18637	18899	50	injuring	injure	VBG
18637	18899	51	a	a	DT
18637	18899	52	rival	rival	NN
18637	18899	53	in	in	IN
18637	18899	54	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18899	55	business	business	NN
18637	18899	56	profession	profession	NN
18637	18899	57	or	or	CC
18637	18899	58	trade	trade	NN
18637	18899	59	.	.	.
18637	18900	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18900	2	294	294	CD
18637	18900	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18900	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18900	5	,	,	,
18637	18900	6	a	a	DT
18637	18900	7	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	18900	8	of	of	IN
18637	18900	9	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	18900	10	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	18900	11	by	by	IN
18637	18900	12	any	any	DT
18637	18900	13	one	one	NN
18637	18900	14	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	18900	15	in	in	IN
18637	18900	16	the	the	DT
18637	18900	17	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	18900	18	or	or	CC
18637	18900	19	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	18900	20	of	of	IN
18637	18900	21	a	a	DT
18637	18900	22	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	18900	23	in	in	IN
18637	18900	24	general	general	JJ
18637	18900	25	use	use	NN
18637	18900	26	for	for	IN
18637	18900	27	the	the	DT
18637	18900	28	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18900	29	of	of	IN
18637	18900	30	intentionally	intentionally	RB
18637	18900	31	destroying	destroy	VBG
18637	18900	32	competition	competition	NN
18637	18900	33	of	of	IN
18637	18900	34	any	any	DT
18637	18900	35	regular	regular	JJ
18637	18900	36	dealer	dealer	NN
18637	18900	37	in	in	IN
18637	18900	38	such	such	JJ
18637	18900	39	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	18900	40	by	by	IN
18637	18900	41	making	make	VBG
18637	18900	42	sales	sale	NNS
18637	18900	43	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	18900	44	at	at	IN
18637	18900	45	a	a	DT
18637	18900	46	lower	low	JJR
18637	18900	47	rate	rate	NN
18637	18900	48	in	in	IN
18637	18900	49	one	one	CD
18637	18900	50	section	section	NN
18637	18900	51	of	of	IN
18637	18900	52	the	the	DT
18637	18900	53	State	State	NNP
18637	18900	54	than	than	IN
18637	18900	55	in	in	IN
18637	18900	56	another	another	DT
18637	18900	57	,	,	,
18637	18900	58	after	after	IN
18637	18900	59	equalization	equalization	NN
18637	18900	60	for	for	IN
18637	18900	61	distance	distance	NN
18637	18900	62	,	,	,
18637	18900	63	effects	effect	VBZ
18637	18900	64	no	no	DT
18637	18900	65	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	18900	66	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18900	67	of	of	IN
18637	18900	68	property	property	NN
18637	18900	69	or	or	CC
18637	18900	70	interference	interference	NN
18637	18900	71	with	with	IN
18637	18900	72	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	18900	73	of	of	IN
18637	18900	74	contract	contract	NN
18637	18900	75	.	.	.
18637	18901	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18901	2	295	295	CD
18637	18901	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18901	4	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	18901	5	of	of	IN
18637	18901	6	contract	contract	NN
18637	18901	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	18901	8	infringed	infringe	VBN
18637	18901	9	,	,	,
18637	18901	10	however	however	RB
18637	18901	11	,	,	,
18637	18901	12	by	by	IN
18637	18901	13	a	a	DT
18637	18901	14	law	law	NN
18637	18901	15	punishing	punish	VBG
18637	18901	16	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	18901	17	in	in	IN
18637	18901	18	cream	cream	NN
18637	18901	19	who	who	WP
18637	18901	20	pay	pay	VBP
18637	18901	21	higher	high	JJR
18637	18901	22	prices	price	NNS
18637	18901	23	in	in	IN
18637	18901	24	one	one	CD
18637	18901	25	locality	locality	NN
18637	18901	26	than	than	IN
18637	18901	27	in	in	IN
18637	18901	28	another	another	DT
18637	18901	29	.	.	.
18637	18902	1	Although	although	IN
18637	18902	2	high	high	JJ
18637	18902	3	bidding	bidding	NN
18637	18902	4	by	by	IN
18637	18902	5	strong	strong	JJ
18637	18902	6	buyers	buyer	NNS
18637	18902	7	tends	tend	VBZ
18637	18902	8	toward	toward	IN
18637	18902	9	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	18902	10	,	,	,
18637	18902	11	the	the	DT
18637	18902	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	18902	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	18902	14	no	no	DT
18637	18902	15	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18902	16	relation	relation	NN
18637	18902	17	to	to	IN
18637	18902	18	such	such	JJ
18637	18902	19	bidding	bidding	NN
18637	18902	20	,	,	,
18637	18902	21	but	but	CC
18637	18902	22	infringes	infringe	VBZ
18637	18902	23	private	private	JJ
18637	18902	24	rights	right	NNS
18637	18902	25	whose	whose	WP$
18637	18902	26	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18902	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	18902	28	not	not	RB
18637	18902	29	shown	show	VBN
18637	18902	30	to	to	TO
18637	18902	31	produce	produce	VB
18637	18902	32	evil	evil	JJ
18637	18902	33	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	18902	34	.	.	.
18637	18903	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18903	2	296	296	CD
18637	18903	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18903	4	A	a	DT
18637	18903	5	law	law	NN
18637	18903	6	sanctioning	sanctioning	NN
18637	18903	7	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	18903	8	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18903	9	that	that	IN
18637	18903	10	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	18903	11	identified	identify	VBN
18637	18903	12	by	by	IN
18637	18903	13	trade	trade	NN
18637	18903	14	mark	mark	NN
18637	18903	15	will	will	MD
18637	18903	16	not	not	RB
18637	18903	17	be	be	VB
18637	18903	18	sold	sell	VBN
18637	18903	19	by	by	IN
18637	18903	20	the	the	DT
18637	18903	21	vendee	vendee	JJ
18637	18903	22	or	or	CC
18637	18903	23	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	18903	24	vendees	vendee	NNS
18637	18903	25	except	except	IN
18637	18903	26	at	at	IN
18637	18903	27	prices	price	NNS
18637	18903	28	stipulated	stipulate	VBN
18637	18903	29	by	by	IN
18637	18903	30	the	the	DT
18637	18903	31	original	original	JJ
18637	18903	32	vendor	vendor	NN
18637	18903	33	does	do	VBZ
18637	18903	34	not	not	RB
18637	18903	35	violate	violate	VB
18637	18903	36	the	the	DT
18637	18903	37	due	due	JJ
18637	18903	38	process	process	NN
18637	18903	39	clause	clause	NN
18637	18903	40	.	.	.
18637	18904	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18904	2	297	297	CD
18637	18904	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18904	4	Statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18904	5	Preventing	Preventing	NNP
18637	18904	6	Fraud	fraud	NN
18637	18904	7	in	in	IN
18637	18904	8	Sale	sale	NN
18637	18904	9	of	of	IN
18637	18904	10	Goods.--Laws	goods.--law	NNS
18637	18904	11	and	and	CC
18637	18904	12	ordinances	ordinance	NNS
18637	18904	13	tending	tend	VBG
18637	18904	14	to	to	TO
18637	18904	15	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18904	16	frauds	fraud	NNS
18637	18904	17	and	and	CC
18637	18904	18	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18904	19	honest	honest	JJ
18637	18904	20	weights	weight	NNS
18637	18904	21	and	and	CC
18637	18904	22	measures	measure	NNS
18637	18904	23	in	in	IN
18637	18904	24	the	the	DT
18637	18904	25	sale	sale	NN
18637	18904	26	of	of	IN
18637	18904	27	articles	article	NNS
18637	18904	28	of	of	IN
18637	18904	29	general	general	JJ
18637	18904	30	consumption	consumption	NN
18637	18904	31	have	have	VBP
18637	18904	32	long	long	RB
18637	18904	33	been	be	VBN
18637	18904	34	considered	consider	VBN
18637	18904	35	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	18904	36	exertions	exertion	NNS
18637	18904	37	of	of	IN
18637	18904	38	the	the	DT
18637	18904	39	police	police	NN
18637	18904	40	power	power	NN
18637	18904	41	.	.	.
18637	18905	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18905	2	298	298	CD
18637	18905	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18905	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18905	5	,	,	,
18637	18905	6	a	a	DT
18637	18905	7	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	18905	8	on	on	IN
18637	18905	9	the	the	DT
18637	18905	10	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	18905	11	by	by	IN
18637	18905	12	other	other	JJ
18637	18905	13	than	than	IN
18637	18905	14	an	an	DT
18637	18905	15	authorized	authorized	JJ
18637	18905	16	weigher	weigher	NN
18637	18905	17	of	of	IN
18637	18905	18	any	any	DT
18637	18905	19	weight	weight	NN
18637	18905	20	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	18905	21	for	for	IN
18637	18905	22	grain	grain	NN
18637	18905	23	weighed	weigh	VBD
18637	18905	24	at	at	IN
18637	18905	25	any	any	DT
18637	18905	26	warehouse	warehouse	NN
18637	18905	27	or	or	CC
18637	18905	28	elevator	elevator	NN
18637	18905	29	where	where	WRB
18637	18905	30	State	state	NN
18637	18905	31	weighers	weigher	NNS
18637	18905	32	are	be	VBP
18637	18905	33	stationed	station	VBN
18637	18905	34	,	,	,
18637	18905	35	or	or	CC
18637	18905	36	to	to	TO
18637	18905	37	charge	charge	VB
18637	18905	38	for	for	IN
18637	18905	39	such	such	JJ
18637	18905	40	weighing	weighing	NN
18637	18905	41	,	,	,
18637	18905	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	18905	43	not	not	RB
18637	18905	44	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18905	45	.	.	.
18637	18906	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18906	2	299	299	CD
18637	18906	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18906	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	18906	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	18906	6	a	a	DT
18637	18906	7	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	18906	8	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	18906	9	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18906	10	that	that	IN
18637	18906	11	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	18906	12	sold	sell	VBN
18637	18906	13	in	in	IN
18637	18906	14	load	load	NN
18637	18906	15	lots	lot	NNS
18637	18906	16	by	by	IN
18637	18906	17	weight	weight	NN
18637	18906	18	be	be	VB
18637	18906	19	weighed	weigh	VBN
18637	18906	20	by	by	IN
18637	18906	21	a	a	DT
18637	18906	22	public	public	JJ
18637	18906	23	weigh	weigh	NN
18637	18906	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	18906	25	master	master	NN
18637	18906	26	within	within	IN
18637	18906	27	the	the	DT
18637	18906	28	city	city	NN
18637	18906	29	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	18906	30	as	as	IN
18637	18906	31	applied	apply	VBN
18637	18906	32	to	to	IN
18637	18906	33	one	one	CD
18637	18906	34	delivering	deliver	VBG
18637	18906	35	coal	coal	NN
18637	18906	36	from	from	IN
18637	18906	37	State	state	NN
18637	18906	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	18906	39	tested	test	VBN
18637	18906	40	scales	scale	NNS
18637	18906	41	at	at	IN
18637	18906	42	a	a	DT
18637	18906	43	mine	mine	NN
18637	18906	44	outside	outside	IN
18637	18906	45	the	the	DT
18637	18906	46	city	city	NN
18637	18906	47	.	.	.
18637	18907	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18907	2	300	300	CD
18637	18907	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18907	4	A	a	DT
18637	18907	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	18907	6	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18907	7	merchants	merchant	NNS
18637	18907	8	to	to	TO
18637	18907	9	record	record	VB
18637	18907	10	sales	sale	NNS
18637	18907	11	in	in	IN
18637	18907	12	bulk	bulk	NN
18637	18907	13	not	not	RB
18637	18907	14	made	make	VBN
18637	18907	15	in	in	IN
18637	18907	16	the	the	DT
18637	18907	17	regular	regular	JJ
18637	18907	18	course	course	NN
18637	18907	19	of	of	IN
18637	18907	20	business	business	NN
18637	18907	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	18907	22	also	also	RB
18637	18907	23	within	within	IN
18637	18907	24	the	the	DT
18637	18907	25	police	police	NN
18637	18907	26	power	power	NN
18637	18907	27	.	.	.
18637	18908	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18908	2	301	301	CD
18637	18908	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18908	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18908	5	,	,	,
18637	18908	6	the	the	DT
18637	18908	7	power	power	NN
18637	18908	8	of	of	IN
18637	18908	9	a	a	DT
18637	18908	10	State	State	NNP
18637	18908	11	to	to	TO
18637	18908	12	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	18908	13	standard	standard	JJ
18637	18908	14	containers	container	NNS
18637	18908	15	to	to	TO
18637	18908	16	protect	protect	VB
18637	18908	17	buyers	buyer	NNS
18637	18908	18	from	from	IN
18637	18908	19	deception	deception	NN
18637	18908	20	as	as	RB
18637	18908	21	well	well	RB
18637	18908	22	as	as	IN
18637	18908	23	to	to	TO
18637	18908	24	facilitate	facilitate	VB
18637	18908	25	trading	trading	NN
18637	18908	26	and	and	CC
18637	18908	27	to	to	TO
18637	18908	28	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	18908	29	the	the	DT
18637	18908	30	condition	condition	NN
18637	18908	31	of	of	IN
18637	18908	32	the	the	DT
18637	18908	33	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	18908	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	18908	35	not	not	RB
18637	18908	36	open	open	JJ
18637	18908	37	to	to	IN
18637	18908	38	question	question	NN
18637	18908	39	.	.	.
18637	18909	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	18909	2	,	,	,
18637	18909	3	an	an	DT
18637	18909	4	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	18909	5	order	order	NN
18637	18909	6	issued	issue	VBN
18637	18909	7	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	18909	8	to	to	IN
18637	18909	9	an	an	DT
18637	18909	10	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	18909	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	18909	12	and	and	CC
18637	18909	13	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	18909	14	the	the	DT
18637	18909	15	dimensions	dimension	NNS
18637	18909	16	,	,	,
18637	18909	17	form	form	NN
18637	18909	18	,	,	,
18637	18909	19	and	and	CC
18637	18909	20	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	18909	21	of	of	IN
18637	18909	22	containers	container	NNS
18637	18909	23	for	for	IN
18637	18909	24	strawberries	strawberry	NNS
18637	18909	25	and	and	CC
18637	18909	26	raspberries	raspberry	NNS
18637	18909	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	18909	28	not	not	RB
18637	18909	29	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18909	30	inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	18909	31	as	as	IN
18637	18909	32	the	the	DT
18637	18909	33	form	form	NN
18637	18909	34	and	and	CC
18637	18909	35	dimensions	dimension	NNS
18637	18909	36	bore	bear	VBD
18637	18909	37	a	a	DT
18637	18909	38	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18909	39	relation	relation	NN
18637	18909	40	to	to	IN
18637	18909	41	the	the	DT
18637	18909	42	protection	protection	NN
18637	18909	43	of	of	IN
18637	18909	44	the	the	DT
18637	18909	45	buyers	buyer	NNS
18637	18909	46	and	and	CC
18637	18909	47	the	the	DT
18637	18909	48	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	18909	49	in	in	IN
18637	18909	50	transit	transit	NN
18637	18909	51	of	of	IN
18637	18909	52	the	the	DT
18637	18909	53	fruit	fruit	NN
18637	18909	54	.	.	.
18637	18910	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18910	2	302	302	CD
18637	18910	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18910	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18910	5	,	,	,
18637	18910	6	an	an	DT
18637	18910	7	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	18910	8	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	18910	9	standard	standard	JJ
18637	18910	10	sizes	size	NNS
18637	18910	11	of	of	IN
18637	18910	12	bread	bread	NN
18637	18910	13	loaves	loaf	NNS
18637	18910	14	and	and	CC
18637	18910	15	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	18910	16	the	the	DT
18637	18910	17	sale	sale	NN
18637	18910	18	of	of	IN
18637	18910	19	other	other	JJ
18637	18910	20	sizes	size	NNS
18637	18910	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	18910	22	not	not	RB
18637	18910	23	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18910	24	.	.	.
18637	18911	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18911	2	303	303	CD
18637	18911	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18911	4	However	however	RB
18637	18911	5	,	,	,
18637	18911	6	by	by	IN
18637	18911	7	a	a	DT
18637	18911	8	case	case	NN
18637	18911	9	decided	decide	VBN
18637	18911	10	in	in	IN
18637	18911	11	1924	1924	CD
18637	18911	12	,	,	,
18637	18911	13	a	a	DT
18637	18911	14	"	"	``
18637	18911	15	tolerance	tolerance	NN
18637	18911	16	"	"	''
18637	18911	17	of	of	IN
18637	18911	18	only	only	RB
18637	18911	19	two	two	CD
18637	18911	20	ounces	ounce	NNS
18637	18911	21	in	in	IN
18637	18911	22	excess	excess	NN
18637	18911	23	of	of	IN
18637	18911	24	the	the	DT
18637	18911	25	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	18911	26	weight	weight	NN
18637	18911	27	of	of	IN
18637	18911	28	a	a	DT
18637	18911	29	loaf	loaf	NN
18637	18911	30	of	of	IN
18637	18911	31	bread	bread	NN
18637	18911	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	18911	33	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18911	34	when	when	WRB
18637	18911	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18911	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	18911	37	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	18911	38	to	to	TO
18637	18911	39	manufacture	manufacture	VB
18637	18911	40	good	good	JJ
18637	18911	41	bread	bread	NN
18637	18911	42	without	without	IN
18637	18911	43	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	18911	44	exceeding	exceed	VBG
18637	18911	45	the	the	DT
18637	18911	46	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	18911	47	tolerance	tolerance	NN
18637	18911	48	and	and	CC
18637	18911	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	18911	50	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	18911	51	unconstitutional;[304	unconstitutional;[304	ADD
18637	18911	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18911	53	but	but	CC
18637	18911	54	by	by	IN
18637	18911	55	one	one	CD
18637	18911	56	decided	decide	VBN
18637	18911	57	ten	ten	CD
18637	18911	58	years	year	NNS
18637	18911	59	later	later	RB
18637	18911	60	,	,	,
18637	18911	61	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18911	62	issued	issue	VBN
18637	18911	63	in	in	IN
18637	18911	64	furtherance	furtherance	NN
18637	18911	65	of	of	IN
18637	18911	66	a	a	DT
18637	18911	67	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	18911	68	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	18911	69	which	which	WDT
18637	18911	70	impose	impose	VBP
18637	18911	71	a	a	DT
18637	18911	72	rate	rate	NN
18637	18911	73	of	of	IN
18637	18911	74	tolerance	tolerance	NN
18637	18911	75	not	not	RB
18637	18911	76	to	to	TO
18637	18911	77	exceed	exceed	VB
18637	18911	78	three	three	CD
18637	18911	79	ounces	ounce	NNS
18637	18911	80	to	to	IN
18637	18911	81	a	a	DT
18637	18911	82	pound	pound	NN
18637	18911	83	of	of	IN
18637	18911	84	bread	bread	NN
18637	18911	85	and	and	CC
18637	18911	86	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18911	87	that	that	IN
18637	18911	88	the	the	DT
18637	18911	89	bread	bread	NN
18637	18911	90	maintain	maintain	VBP
18637	18911	91	the	the	DT
18637	18911	92	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	18911	93	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	18911	94	weight	weight	NN
18637	18911	95	for	for	IN
18637	18911	96	not	not	RB
18637	18911	97	less	less	JJR
18637	18911	98	than	than	IN
18637	18911	99	12	12	CD
18637	18911	100	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18911	101	after	after	IN
18637	18911	102	cooling	cool	VBG
18637	18911	103	are	be	VBP
18637	18911	104	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18911	105	.	.	.
18637	18912	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18912	2	305	305	CD
18637	18912	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18912	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	18912	5	a	a	DT
18637	18912	6	law	law	NN
18637	18912	7	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18912	8	that	that	DT
18637	18912	9	lard	lard	NN
18637	18912	10	not	not	RB
18637	18912	11	sold	sell	VBN
18637	18912	12	in	in	IN
18637	18912	13	bulk	bulk	NN
18637	18912	14	should	should	MD
18637	18912	15	be	be	VB
18637	18912	16	put	put	VBN
18637	18912	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	18912	18	in	in	IN
18637	18912	19	containers	container	NNS
18637	18912	20	holding	hold	VBG
18637	18912	21	one	one	CD
18637	18912	22	,	,	,
18637	18912	23	three	three	CD
18637	18912	24	,	,	,
18637	18912	25	or	or	CC
18637	18912	26	five	five	CD
18637	18912	27	pounds	pound	NNS
18637	18912	28	weight	weight	NN
18637	18912	29	,	,	,
18637	18912	30	or	or	CC
18637	18912	31	some	some	DT
18637	18912	32	whole	whole	JJ
18637	18912	33	multiple	multiple	NN
18637	18912	34	of	of	IN
18637	18912	35	these	these	DT
18637	18912	36	numbers	number	NNS
18637	18912	37	,	,	,
18637	18912	38	does	do	VBZ
18637	18912	39	not	not	RB
18637	18912	40	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	18912	41	sellers	seller	NNS
18637	18912	42	of	of	IN
18637	18912	43	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18912	44	property	property	NN
18637	18912	45	without	without	IN
18637	18912	46	the	the	DT
18637	18912	47	process	process	NN
18637	18912	48	of	of	IN
18637	18912	49	law	law	NN
18637	18912	50	.	.	.
18637	18913	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18913	2	306	306	CD
18637	18913	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18913	4	The	the	DT
18637	18913	5	right	right	NN
18637	18913	6	of	of	IN
18637	18913	7	a	a	DT
18637	18913	8	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
18637	18913	9	to	to	TO
18637	18913	10	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	18913	11	secrecy	secrecy	NN
18637	18913	12	as	as	IN
18637	18913	13	to	to	IN
18637	18913	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18913	15	compounds	compound	NNS
18637	18913	16	and	and	CC
18637	18913	17	processes	process	NNS
18637	18913	18	must	must	MD
18637	18913	19	be	be	VB
18637	18913	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	18913	21	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18913	22	to	to	IN
18637	18913	23	the	the	DT
18637	18913	24	right	right	NN
18637	18913	25	of	of	IN
18637	18913	26	the	the	DT
18637	18913	27	State	State	NNP
18637	18913	28	,	,	,
18637	18913	29	in	in	IN
18637	18913	30	the	the	DT
18637	18913	31	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18913	32	of	of	IN
18637	18913	33	the	the	DT
18637	18913	34	police	police	NN
18637	18913	35	power	power	NN
18637	18913	36	and	and	CC
18637	18913	37	in	in	IN
18637	18913	38	the	the	DT
18637	18913	39	promotion	promotion	NN
18637	18913	40	of	of	IN
18637	18913	41	fair	fair	JJ
18637	18913	42	dealing	dealing	NN
18637	18913	43	,	,	,
18637	18913	44	to	to	TO
18637	18913	45	require	require	VB
18637	18913	46	that	that	IN
18637	18913	47	the	the	DT
18637	18913	48	nature	nature	NN
18637	18913	49	of	of	IN
18637	18913	50	the	the	DT
18637	18913	51	product	product	NN
18637	18913	52	be	be	VB
18637	18913	53	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	18913	54	set	set	VBN
18637	18913	55	forth	forth	RP
18637	18913	56	.	.	.
18637	18914	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18914	2	307	307	CD
18637	18914	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18914	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	18914	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	18914	6	a	a	DT
18637	18914	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	18914	8	providing	provide	VBG
18637	18914	9	that	that	IN
18637	18914	10	the	the	DT
18637	18914	11	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	18914	12	of	of	IN
18637	18914	13	harvesting	harvesting	NN
18637	18914	14	or	or	CC
18637	18914	15	threshing	thresh	VBG
18637	18914	16	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	18914	17	for	for	IN
18637	18914	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18914	19	own	own	JJ
18637	18914	20	use	use	NN
18637	18914	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	18914	22	have	have	VB
18637	18914	23	a	a	DT
18637	18914	24	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18914	25	time	time	NN
18637	18914	26	after	after	IN
18637	18914	27	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	18914	28	for	for	IN
18637	18914	29	inspecting	inspect	VBG
18637	18914	30	and	and	CC
18637	18914	31	testing	test	VBG
18637	18914	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18914	33	,	,	,
18637	18914	34	and	and	CC
18637	18914	35	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	18914	36	recission	recission	NN
18637	18914	37	of	of	IN
18637	18914	38	the	the	DT
18637	18914	39	contract	contract	NN
18637	18914	40	if	if	IN
18637	18914	41	the	the	DT
18637	18914	42	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	18914	43	does	do	VBZ
18637	18914	44	not	not	RB
18637	18914	45	prove	prove	VB
18637	18914	46	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	18914	47	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	18914	48	,	,	,
18637	18914	49	and	and	CC
18637	18914	50	further	further	RB
18637	18914	51	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	18914	52	any	any	DT
18637	18914	53	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	18914	54	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	18914	55	to	to	IN
18637	18914	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18914	57	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	18914	58	to	to	TO
18637	18914	59	be	be	VB
18637	18914	60	against	against	IN
18637	18914	61	public	public	JJ
18637	18914	62	policy	policy	NN
18637	18914	63	and	and	CC
18637	18914	64	void	void	JJ
18637	18914	65	,	,	,
18637	18914	66	does	do	VBZ
18637	18914	67	not	not	RB
18637	18914	68	violate	violate	VB
18637	18914	69	the	the	DT
18637	18914	70	due	due	JJ
18637	18914	71	process	process	NN
18637	18914	72	clause	clause	NN
18637	18914	73	.	.	.
18637	18915	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18915	2	308	308	CD
18637	18915	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18915	4	Blue	Blue	NNP
18637	18915	5	Sky	Sky	NNP
18637	18915	6	Laws	law	NNS
18637	18915	7	;	;	:
18637	18915	8	Laws	law	NNS
18637	18915	9	Regulating	Regulating	NNP
18637	18915	10	Boards	Boards	NNPS
18637	18915	11	of	of	IN
18637	18915	12	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	18915	13	,	,	,
18637	18915	14	Etc.--In	etc.--in	VB
18637	18915	15	the	the	DT
18637	18915	16	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18915	17	of	of	IN
18637	18915	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18915	19	power	power	NN
18637	18915	20	to	to	TO
18637	18915	21	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18915	22	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	18915	23	and	and	CC
18637	18915	24	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	18915	25	,	,	,
18637	18915	26	a	a	DT
18637	18915	27	State	State	NNP
18637	18915	28	may	may	MD
18637	18915	29	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	18915	30	trading	trading	NN
18637	18915	31	in	in	IN
18637	18915	32	securities	security	NNS
18637	18915	33	within	within	IN
18637	18915	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18915	35	borders	border	NNS
18637	18915	36	,	,	,
18637	18915	37	require	require	VBP
18637	18915	38	a	a	DT
18637	18915	39	license	license	NN
18637	18915	40	of	of	IN
18637	18915	41	those	those	DT
18637	18915	42	engaging	engage	VBG
18637	18915	43	in	in	IN
18637	18915	44	such	such	JJ
18637	18915	45	dealing	dealing	NN
18637	18915	46	,	,	,
18637	18915	47	make	make	VB
18637	18915	48	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	18915	49	of	of	IN
18637	18915	50	a	a	DT
18637	18915	51	license	license	NN
18637	18915	52	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	18915	53	on	on	IN
18637	18915	54	a	a	DT
18637	18915	55	public	public	JJ
18637	18915	56	officer	officer	NN
18637	18915	57	's	's	POS
18637	18915	58	being	be	VBG
18637	18915	59	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	18915	60	of	of	IN
18637	18915	61	the	the	DT
18637	18915	62	good	good	JJ
18637	18915	63	repute	repute	NN
18637	18915	64	of	of	IN
18637	18915	65	the	the	DT
18637	18915	66	applicants	applicant	NNS
18637	18915	67	,	,	,
18637	18915	68	and	and	CC
18637	18915	69	permit	permit	VB
18637	18915	70	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18915	71	,	,	,
18637	18915	72	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18915	73	to	to	IN
18637	18915	74	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18915	75	review	review	NN
18637	18915	76	of	of	IN
18637	18915	77	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18915	78	findings	finding	NNS
18637	18915	79	,	,	,
18637	18915	80	to	to	TO
18637	18915	81	revoke	revoke	VB
18637	18915	82	the	the	DT
18637	18915	83	same	same	JJ
18637	18915	84	.	.	.
18637	18916	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18916	2	309	309	CD
18637	18916	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18916	4	A	a	DT
18637	18916	5	State	state	NN
18637	18916	6	may	may	MD
18637	18916	7	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	18916	8	the	the	DT
18637	18916	9	giving	giving	NN
18637	18916	10	of	of	IN
18637	18916	11	options	option	NNS
18637	18916	12	to	to	TO
18637	18916	13	sell	sell	VB
18637	18916	14	or	or	CC
18637	18916	15	buy	buy	VB
18637	18916	16	at	at	IN
18637	18916	17	a	a	DT
18637	18916	18	future	future	JJ
18637	18916	19	time	time	NN
18637	18916	20	any	any	DT
18637	18916	21	grain	grain	NN
18637	18916	22	or	or	CC
18637	18916	23	other	other	JJ
18637	18916	24	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	18916	25	.	.	.
18637	18917	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18917	2	310	310	CD
18637	18917	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18917	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18917	5	may	may	MD
18637	18917	6	also	also	RB
18637	18917	7	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	18917	8	sales	sale	NNS
18637	18917	9	on	on	IN
18637	18917	10	margin	margin	NN
18637	18917	11	for	for	IN
18637	18917	12	future	future	NN
18637	18917	13	delivery;[311	delivery;[311	NNPS
18637	18917	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18917	15	and	and	CC
18637	18917	16	may	may	MD
18637	18917	17	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	18917	18	the	the	DT
18637	18917	19	keeping	keeping	NN
18637	18917	20	of	of	IN
18637	18917	21	places	place	NNS
18637	18917	22	where	where	WRB
18637	18917	23	stocks	stock	NNS
18637	18917	24	,	,	,
18637	18917	25	grain	grain	NN
18637	18917	26	,	,	,
18637	18917	27	etc	etc	FW
18637	18917	28	.	.	.
18637	18917	29	,	,	,
18637	18917	30	are	be	VBP
18637	18917	31	sold	sell	VBN
18637	18917	32	but	but	CC
18637	18917	33	not	not	RB
18637	18917	34	paid	pay	VBN
18637	18917	35	for	for	IN
18637	18917	36	at	at	IN
18637	18917	37	the	the	DT
18637	18917	38	time	time	NN
18637	18917	39	,	,	,
18637	18917	40	unless	unless	IN
18637	18917	41	a	a	DT
18637	18917	42	record	record	NN
18637	18917	43	of	of	IN
18637	18917	44	the	the	DT
18637	18917	45	same	same	JJ
18637	18917	46	be	be	VB
18637	18917	47	made	make	VBN
18637	18917	48	and	and	CC
18637	18917	49	a	a	DT
18637	18917	50	stamp	stamp	NN
18637	18917	51	tax	tax	NN
18637	18917	52	paid	pay	VBN
18637	18917	53	.	.	.
18637	18918	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18918	2	312	312	CD
18637	18918	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18918	4	Making	make	VBG
18637	18918	5	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	18918	6	any	any	DT
18637	18918	7	deduction	deduction	NN
18637	18918	8	by	by	IN
18637	18918	9	the	the	DT
18637	18918	10	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	18918	11	from	from	IN
18637	18918	12	the	the	DT
18637	18918	13	actual	actual	JJ
18637	18918	14	weight	weight	NN
18637	18918	15	of	of	IN
18637	18918	16	grain	grain	NN
18637	18918	17	,	,	,
18637	18918	18	hay	hay	NN
18637	18918	19	,	,	,
18637	18918	20	seed	seed	NN
18637	18918	21	,	,	,
18637	18918	22	or	or	CC
18637	18918	23	coal	coal	NN
18637	18918	24	under	under	IN
18637	18918	25	a	a	DT
18637	18918	26	claim	claim	NN
18637	18918	27	of	of	IN
18637	18918	28	right	right	NN
18637	18918	29	by	by	IN
18637	18918	30	reason	reason	NN
18637	18918	31	of	of	IN
18637	18918	32	any	any	DT
18637	18918	33	custom	custom	NN
18637	18918	34	or	or	CC
18637	18918	35	rule	rule	NN
18637	18918	36	of	of	IN
18637	18918	37	a	a	DT
18637	18918	38	board	board	NN
18637	18918	39	of	of	IN
18637	18918	40	trade	trade	NNP
18637	18918	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	18918	42	a	a	DT
18637	18918	43	valid	valid	JJ
18637	18918	44	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18918	45	of	of	IN
18637	18918	46	the	the	DT
18637	18918	47	police	police	NN
18637	18918	48	power	power	NN
18637	18918	49	and	and	CC
18637	18918	50	does	do	VBZ
18637	18918	51	not	not	RB
18637	18918	52	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	18918	53	the	the	DT
18637	18918	54	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	18918	55	of	of	IN
18637	18918	56	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18918	57	property	property	NN
18637	18918	58	without	without	IN
18637	18918	59	due	due	JJ
18637	18918	60	process	process	NN
18637	18918	61	of	of	IN
18637	18918	62	law	law	NN
18637	18918	63	,	,	,
18637	18918	64	nor	nor	CC
18637	18918	65	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	18918	66	with	with	IN
18637	18918	67	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18918	68	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18918	69	of	of	IN
18637	18918	70	contract	contract	NN
18637	18918	71	.	.	.
18637	18919	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18919	2	313	313	CD
18637	18919	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18919	4	Trading	trading	NN
18637	18919	5	Stamps.--A	stamps.--a	NN
18637	18919	6	prohibitive	prohibitive	JJ
18637	18919	7	license	license	NN
18637	18919	8	fee	fee	NN
18637	18919	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	18919	10	the	the	DT
18637	18919	11	use	use	NN
18637	18919	12	of	of	IN
18637	18919	13	trading	trading	NN
18637	18919	14	stamps	stamp	NNS
18637	18919	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	18919	16	not	not	RB
18637	18919	17	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18919	18	.	.	.
18637	18920	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18920	2	314	314	CD
18637	18920	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18920	4	Banking	Banking	NNP
18637	18920	5	The	the	DT
18637	18920	6	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18920	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18920	8	does	do	VBZ
18637	18920	9	not	not	RB
18637	18920	10	deny	deny	VB
18637	18920	11	to	to	IN
18637	18920	12	States	States	NNP
18637	18920	13	the	the	DT
18637	18920	14	power	power	NN
18637	18920	15	to	to	TO
18637	18920	16	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	18920	17	a	a	DT
18637	18920	18	business	business	NN
18637	18920	19	simply	simply	RB
18637	18920	20	because	because	IN
18637	18920	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18920	22	was	be	VBD
18637	18920	23	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	18920	24	at	at	IN
18637	18920	25	common	common	JJ
18637	18920	26	law	law	NN
18637	18920	27	;	;	:
18637	18920	28	and	and	CC
18637	18920	29	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	18920	30	,	,	,
18637	18920	31	where	where	WRB
18637	18920	32	public	public	JJ
18637	18920	33	interests	interest	NNS
18637	18920	34	so	so	IN
18637	18920	35	demand	demand	VBP
18637	18920	36	,	,	,
18637	18920	37	a	a	DT
18637	18920	38	State	state	NN
18637	18920	39	may	may	MD
18637	18920	40	place	place	VB
18637	18920	41	the	the	DT
18637	18920	42	banking	banking	NN
18637	18920	43	business	business	NN
18637	18920	44	under	under	IN
18637	18920	45	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18920	46	control	control	NN
18637	18920	47	and	and	CC
18637	18920	48	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	18920	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18920	50	except	except	IN
18637	18920	51	under	under	IN
18637	18920	52	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	18920	53	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	18920	54	.	.	.
18637	18921	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	18921	2	,	,	,
18637	18921	3	a	a	DT
18637	18921	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	18921	5	subjecting	subject	VBG
18637	18921	6	State	state	NN
18637	18921	7	banks	bank	NNS
18637	18921	8	to	to	IN
18637	18921	9	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	18921	10	for	for	IN
18637	18921	11	a	a	DT
18637	18921	12	depositors	depositor	NNS
18637	18921	13	'	'	POS
18637	18921	14	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	18921	15	fund	fund	NN
18637	18921	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	18921	17	within	within	IN
18637	18921	18	the	the	DT
18637	18921	19	police	police	NN
18637	18921	20	power	power	NN
18637	18921	21	of	of	IN
18637	18921	22	the	the	DT
18637	18921	23	States	States	NNP
18637	18921	24	and	and	CC
18637	18921	25	does	do	VBZ
18637	18921	26	not	not	RB
18637	18921	27	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	18921	28	the	the	DT
18637	18921	29	banks	bank	NNS
18637	18921	30	of	of	IN
18637	18921	31	property	property	NN
18637	18921	32	without	without	IN
18637	18921	33	due	due	JJ
18637	18921	34	process	process	NN
18637	18921	35	of	of	IN
18637	18921	36	law	law	NN
18637	18921	37	.	.	.
18637	18922	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18922	2	315	315	CD
18637	18922	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18922	4	Also	also	RB
18637	18922	5	,	,	,
18637	18922	6	a	a	DT
18637	18922	7	law	law	NN
18637	18922	8	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18922	9	savings	saving	NNS
18637	18922	10	banks	bank	NNS
18637	18922	11	to	to	TO
18637	18922	12	turn	turn	VB
18637	18922	13	over	over	RP
18637	18922	14	to	to	IN
18637	18922	15	the	the	DT
18637	18922	16	State	state	NN
18637	18922	17	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	18922	18	inactive	inactive	JJ
18637	18922	19	for	for	IN
18637	18922	20	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	18922	21	years	year	NNS
18637	18922	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18922	23	when	when	WRB
18637	18922	24	the	the	DT
18637	18922	25	depositor	depositor	NN
18637	18922	26	can	can	MD
18637	18922	27	not	not	RB
18637	18922	28	be	be	VB
18637	18922	29	found	find	VBN
18637	18922	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18922	31	,	,	,
18637	18922	32	with	with	IN
18637	18922	33	provision	provision	NN
18637	18922	34	for	for	IN
18637	18922	35	payment	payment	NN
18637	18922	36	to	to	IN
18637	18922	37	the	the	DT
18637	18922	38	depositor	depositor	NN
18637	18922	39	or	or	CC
18637	18922	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18922	41	heirs	heir	NNS
18637	18922	42	on	on	IN
18637	18922	43	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	18922	44	of	of	IN
18637	18922	45	the	the	DT
18637	18922	46	right	right	NN
18637	18922	47	,	,	,
18637	18922	48	does	do	VBZ
18637	18922	49	not	not	RB
18637	18922	50	effect	effect	VB
18637	18922	51	an	an	DT
18637	18922	52	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	18922	53	taking	taking	NN
18637	18922	54	of	of	IN
18637	18922	55	the	the	DT
18637	18922	56	property	property	NN
18637	18922	57	of	of	IN
18637	18922	58	said	say	VBN
18637	18922	59	banks	bank	NNS
18637	18922	60	;	;	:
18637	18922	61	nor	nor	CC
18637	18922	62	does	do	VBZ
18637	18922	63	a	a	DT
18637	18922	64	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	18922	65	statute	statute	NN
18637	18922	66	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18922	67	banks	bank	NNS
18637	18922	68	to	to	TO
18637	18922	69	turn	turn	VB
18637	18922	70	over	over	RP
18637	18922	71	to	to	IN
18637	18922	72	the	the	DT
18637	18922	73	protective	protective	JJ
18637	18922	74	custody	custody	NN
18637	18922	75	of	of	IN
18637	18922	76	that	that	DT
18637	18922	77	State	state	NN
18637	18922	78	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	18922	79	that	that	WDT
18637	18922	80	have	have	VBP
18637	18922	81	been	be	VBN
18637	18922	82	inactive	inactive	JJ
18637	18922	83	ten	ten	CD
18637	18922	84	or	or	CC
18637	18922	85	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	18922	86	-	-	HYPH
18637	18922	87	five	five	CD
18637	18922	88	years	year	NNS
18637	18922	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	18922	90	depending	depend	VBG
18637	18922	91	on	on	IN
18637	18922	92	the	the	DT
18637	18922	93	nature	nature	NN
18637	18922	94	of	of	IN
18637	18922	95	the	the	DT
18637	18922	96	deposit	deposit	NN
18637	18922	97	)	)	-RRB-
18637	18922	98	.	.	.
18637	18923	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18923	2	316	316	CD
18637	18923	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18923	4	The	the	DT
18637	18923	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18923	6	rights	right	NNS
18637	18923	7	of	of	IN
18637	18923	8	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	18923	9	in	in	IN
18637	18923	10	an	an	DT
18637	18923	11	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
18637	18923	12	bank	bank	NN
18637	18923	13	in	in	IN
18637	18923	14	the	the	DT
18637	18923	15	hands	hand	NNS
18637	18923	16	of	of	IN
18637	18923	17	liquidators	liquidator	NNS
18637	18923	18	are	be	VBP
18637	18923	19	not	not	RB
18637	18923	20	violated	violate	VBN
18637	18923	21	by	by	IN
18637	18923	22	a	a	DT
18637	18923	23	later	later	JJ
18637	18923	24	statute	statute	NN
18637	18923	25	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	18923	26	reopening	reopen	VBG
18637	18923	27	under	under	IN
18637	18923	28	a	a	DT
18637	18923	29	reorganization	reorganization	NN
18637	18923	30	plan	plan	NN
18637	18923	31	approved	approve	VBN
18637	18923	32	by	by	IN
18637	18923	33	the	the	DT
18637	18923	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18923	35	,	,	,
18637	18923	36	the	the	DT
18637	18923	37	liquidating	liquidate	VBG
18637	18923	38	officer	officer	NN
18637	18923	39	,	,	,
18637	18923	40	and	and	CC
18637	18923	41	by	by	IN
18637	18923	42	three	three	CD
18637	18923	43	-	-	HYPH
18637	18923	44	fourths	fourth	NNS
18637	18923	45	of	of	IN
18637	18923	46	the	the	DT
18637	18923	47	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	18923	48	.	.	.
18637	18924	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18924	2	317	317	CD
18637	18924	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18924	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18924	5	,	,	,
18637	18924	6	a	a	DT
18637	18924	7	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18924	8	Reserve	Reserve	NNP
18637	18924	9	bank	bank	NN
18637	18924	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	18924	11	not	not	RB
18637	18924	12	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
18637	18924	13	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	18924	14	of	of	IN
18637	18924	15	business	business	NN
18637	18924	16	rights	right	NNS
18637	18924	17	of	of	IN
18637	18924	18	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18924	19	of	of	IN
18637	18924	20	contract	contract	NN
18637	18924	21	by	by	IN
18637	18924	22	a	a	DT
18637	18924	23	law	law	NN
18637	18924	24	which	which	WDT
18637	18924	25	allows	allow	VBZ
18637	18924	26	State	state	NN
18637	18924	27	banks	bank	NNS
18637	18924	28	to	to	TO
18637	18924	29	pay	pay	VB
18637	18924	30	checks	check	NNS
18637	18924	31	in	in	IN
18637	18924	32	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	18924	33	when	when	WRB
18637	18924	34	presented	present	VBN
18637	18924	35	by	by	IN
18637	18924	36	or	or	CC
18637	18924	37	through	through	IN
18637	18924	38	a	a	DT
18637	18924	39	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	18924	40	Reserve	Reserve	NNP
18637	18924	41	bank	bank	NN
18637	18924	42	,	,	,
18637	18924	43	post	post	NNP
18637	18924	44	office	office	NNP
18637	18924	45	,	,	,
18637	18924	46	or	or	CC
18637	18924	47	express	express	VB
18637	18924	48	company	company	NN
18637	18924	49	and	and	CC
18637	18924	50	when	when	WRB
18637	18924	51	not	not	RB
18637	18924	52	made	make	VBN
18637	18924	53	payable	payable	JJ
18637	18924	54	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	18924	55	by	by	IN
18637	18924	56	a	a	DT
18637	18924	57	maker	maker	NN
18637	18924	58	.	.	.
18637	18925	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18925	2	318	318	CD
18637	18925	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18925	4	Loans	Loans	NNP
18637	18925	5	,	,	,
18637	18925	6	Interest	interest	NN
18637	18925	7	,	,	,
18637	18925	8	Assignments	Assignments	NNPS
18637	18925	9	In	in	IN
18637	18925	10	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	18925	11	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	18925	12	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18925	13	of	of	IN
18637	18925	14	interest	interest	NN
18637	18925	15	on	on	IN
18637	18925	16	money	money	NN
18637	18925	17	loaned	loan	VBN
18637	18925	18	within	within	IN
18637	18925	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18925	20	borders	border	NNS
18637	18925	21	,	,	,
18637	18925	22	a	a	DT
18637	18925	23	State	state	NN
18637	18925	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	18925	25	acting	act	VBG
18637	18925	26	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	18925	27	within	within	IN
18637	18925	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18925	29	police	police	NN
18637	18925	30	power	power	NN
18637	18925	31	;	;	:
18637	18925	32	and	and	CC
18637	18925	33	the	the	DT
18637	18925	34	details	detail	NNS
18637	18925	35	are	be	VBP
18637	18925	36	within	within	IN
18637	18925	37	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	18925	38	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	18925	39	if	if	IN
18637	18925	40	not	not	RB
18637	18925	41	unreasonably	unreasonably	RB
18637	18925	42	or	or	CC
18637	18925	43	arbitrarily	arbitrarily	RB
18637	18925	44	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	18925	45	.	.	.
18637	18926	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18926	2	319	319	CD
18637	18926	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18926	4	Equally	equally	RB
18637	18926	5	valid	valid	JJ
18637	18926	6	as	as	IN
18637	18926	7	an	an	DT
18637	18926	8	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18926	9	of	of	IN
18637	18926	10	a	a	DT
18637	18926	11	State	State	NNP
18637	18926	12	's	's	POS
18637	18926	13	police	police	NN
18637	18926	14	power	power	NN
18637	18926	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	18926	16	a	a	DT
18637	18926	17	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	18926	18	that	that	IN
18637	18926	19	assignments	assignment	NNS
18637	18926	20	of	of	IN
18637	18926	21	future	future	JJ
18637	18926	22	wages	wage	NNS
18637	18926	23	as	as	IN
18637	18926	24	security	security	NN
18637	18926	25	for	for	IN
18637	18926	26	debts	debt	NNS
18637	18926	27	of	of	IN
18637	18926	28	less	less	JJR
18637	18926	29	than	than	IN
18637	18926	30	$	$	$
18637	18926	31	200	200	CD
18637	18926	32	,	,	,
18637	18926	33	to	to	TO
18637	18926	34	be	be	VB
18637	18926	35	valid	valid	JJ
18637	18926	36	,	,	,
18637	18926	37	must	must	MD
18637	18926	38	be	be	VB
18637	18926	39	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	18926	40	in	in	IN
18637	18926	41	writing	writing	NN
18637	18926	42	by	by	IN
18637	18926	43	the	the	DT
18637	18926	44	employer	employer	NN
18637	18926	45	,	,	,
18637	18926	46	consented	consent	VBD
18637	18926	47	to	to	IN
18637	18926	48	by	by	IN
18637	18926	49	the	the	DT
18637	18926	50	assignors	assignor	NNS
18637	18926	51	,	,	,
18637	18926	52	and	and	CC
18637	18926	53	filed	file	VBD
18637	18926	54	in	in	IN
18637	18926	55	a	a	DT
18637	18926	56	public	public	JJ
18637	18926	57	office	office	NN
18637	18926	58	.	.	.
18637	18927	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	18927	2	a	a	DT
18637	18927	3	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	18927	4	deprives	deprive	VBZ
18637	18927	5	neither	neither	CC
18637	18927	6	the	the	DT
18637	18927	7	borrower	borrower	NN
18637	18927	8	nor	nor	CC
18637	18927	9	the	the	DT
18637	18927	10	lender	lender	NN
18637	18927	11	of	of	IN
18637	18927	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18927	13	property	property	NN
18637	18927	14	without	without	IN
18637	18927	15	due	due	JJ
18637	18927	16	process	process	NN
18637	18927	17	of	of	IN
18637	18927	18	law	law	NN
18637	18927	19	.	.	.
18637	18928	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18928	2	320	320	CD
18637	18928	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18928	4	Insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18928	5	The	the	DT
18637	18928	6	relations	relation	NNS
18637	18928	7	generally	generally	RB
18637	18928	8	of	of	IN
18637	18928	9	those	those	DT
18637	18928	10	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	18928	11	in	in	IN
18637	18928	12	the	the	DT
18637	18928	13	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18928	14	business[321	business[321	NN
18637	18928	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18928	16	as	as	RB
18637	18928	17	well	well	RB
18637	18928	18	as	as	IN
18637	18928	19	the	the	DT
18637	18928	20	business	business	NN
18637	18928	21	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18928	22	have	have	VBP
18637	18928	23	been	be	VBN
18637	18928	24	peculiarly	peculiarly	RB
18637	18928	25	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18928	26	to	to	IN
18637	18928	27	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	18928	28	and	and	CC
18637	18928	29	control	control	NN
18637	18928	30	.	.	.
18637	18929	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18929	2	322	322	CD
18637	18929	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18929	4	The	the	DT
18637	18929	5	State	State	NNP
18637	18929	6	may	may	MD
18637	18929	7	fix	fix	VB
18637	18929	8	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18929	9	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18929	10	and	and	CC
18637	18929	11	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	18929	12	the	the	DT
18637	18929	13	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18929	14	of	of	IN
18637	18929	15	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18929	16	agents	agent	NNS
18637	18929	17	.	.	.
18637	18930	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18930	2	323	323	CD
18637	18930	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18930	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18930	5	may	may	MD
18637	18930	6	impose	impose	VB
18637	18930	7	a	a	DT
18637	18930	8	fine	fine	NN
18637	18930	9	on	on	IN
18637	18930	10	"	"	``
18637	18930	11	any	any	DT
18637	18930	12	person	person	NN
18637	18930	13	'	'	''
18637	18930	14	who	who	WP
18637	18930	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	18930	16	act	act	VB
18637	18930	17	in	in	IN
18637	18930	18	any	any	DT
18637	18930	19	manner	manner	NN
18637	18930	20	in	in	IN
18637	18930	21	the	the	DT
18637	18930	22	negotiation	negotiation	NN
18637	18930	23	or	or	CC
18637	18930	24	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	18930	25	of	of	IN
18637	18930	26	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	18930	27	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18930	28	*	*	NFP
18637	18930	29	*	*	NFP
18637	18930	30	*	*	NFP
18637	18930	31	with	with	IN
18637	18930	32	a	a	DT
18637	18930	33	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18930	34	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18930	35	company	company	NN
18637	18930	36	not	not	RB
18637	18930	37	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	18930	38	to	to	TO
18637	18930	39	do	do	VB
18637	18930	40	business	business	NN
18637	18930	41	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18930	42	within	within	IN
18637	18930	43	said	say	VBD
18637	18930	44	State	state	NN
18637	18930	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18930	46	.	.	.
18637	18931	1	'	'	``
18637	18931	2	"	"	``
18637	18931	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18931	4	324	324	CD
18637	18931	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18931	6	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18931	7	may	may	MD
18637	18931	8	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	18931	9	life	life	NN
18637	18931	10	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18931	11	companies	company	NNS
18637	18931	12	and	and	CC
18637	18931	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18931	14	agents	agent	NNS
18637	18931	15	to	to	TO
18637	18931	16	engage	engage	VB
18637	18931	17	in	in	IN
18637	18931	18	the	the	DT
18637	18931	19	undertaking	undertaking	NN
18637	18931	20	business	business	NN
18637	18931	21	and	and	CC
18637	18931	22	undertakers	undertaker	NNS
18637	18931	23	to	to	TO
18637	18931	24	serve	serve	VB
18637	18931	25	as	as	IN
18637	18931	26	life	life	NN
18637	18931	27	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18931	28	agents	agent	NNS
18637	18931	29	.	.	.
18637	18932	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18932	2	325	325	CD
18637	18932	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18932	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	18932	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	18932	6	a	a	DT
18637	18932	7	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	18932	8	law	law	NN
18637	18932	9	which	which	WDT
18637	18932	10	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	18932	11	the	the	DT
18637	18932	12	making	making	NN
18637	18932	13	of	of	IN
18637	18932	14	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	18932	15	of	of	IN
18637	18932	16	casualty	casualty	NN
18637	18932	17	or	or	CC
18637	18932	18	surety	surety	NN
18637	18932	19	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18932	20	,	,	,
18637	18932	21	by	by	IN
18637	18932	22	companies	company	NNS
18637	18932	23	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	18932	24	to	to	TO
18637	18932	25	do	do	VB
18637	18932	26	business	business	NN
18637	18932	27	therein	therein	RB
18637	18932	28	,	,	,
18637	18932	29	except	except	IN
18637	18932	30	through	through	IN
18637	18932	31	registered	register	VBN
18637	18932	32	agents	agent	NNS
18637	18932	33	,	,	,
18637	18932	34	which	which	WDT
18637	18932	35	requires	require	VBZ
18637	18932	36	that	that	IN
18637	18932	37	such	such	JJ
18637	18932	38	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	18932	39	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	18932	40	to	to	IN
18637	18932	41	persons	person	NNS
18637	18932	42	or	or	CC
18637	18932	43	property	property	NN
18637	18932	44	in	in	IN
18637	18932	45	the	the	DT
18637	18932	46	State	State	NNP
18637	18932	47	be	be	VB
18637	18932	48	countersigned	countersign	VBN
18637	18932	49	by	by	IN
18637	18932	50	a	a	DT
18637	18932	51	registered	registered	JJ
18637	18932	52	local	local	JJ
18637	18932	53	agent	agent	NN
18637	18932	54	,	,	,
18637	18932	55	and	and	CC
18637	18932	56	which	which	WDT
18637	18932	57	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	18932	58	such	such	JJ
18637	18932	59	agents	agent	NNS
18637	18932	60	from	from	IN
18637	18932	61	sharing	share	VBG
18637	18932	62	more	more	JJR
18637	18932	63	than	than	IN
18637	18932	64	50	50	CD
18637	18932	65	%	%	NN
18637	18932	66	of	of	IN
18637	18932	67	a	a	DT
18637	18932	68	commission	commission	NN
18637	18932	69	with	with	IN
18637	18932	70	a	a	DT
18637	18932	71	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	18932	72	broker	broker	NN
18637	18932	73	,	,	,
18637	18932	74	deprive	deprive	NNP
18637	18932	75	authorized	authorized	JJ
18637	18932	76	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18932	77	casualty	casualty	NN
18637	18932	78	and	and	CC
18637	18932	79	surety	surety	NN
18637	18932	80	insurers	insurer	NNS
18637	18932	81	of	of	IN
18637	18932	82	due	due	JJ
18637	18932	83	process	process	NN
18637	18932	84	.	.	.
18637	18933	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18933	2	326	326	CD
18637	18933	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18933	4	And	and	CC
18637	18933	5	just	just	RB
18637	18933	6	as	as	IN
18637	18933	7	all	all	DT
18637	18933	8	banks	bank	NNS
18637	18933	9	may	may	MD
18637	18933	10	be	be	VB
18637	18933	11	required	require	VBN
18637	18933	12	to	to	TO
18637	18933	13	contribute	contribute	VB
18637	18933	14	to	to	IN
18637	18933	15	a	a	DT
18637	18933	16	depositors	depositor	NNS
18637	18933	17	'	'	POS
18637	18933	18	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	18933	19	fund	fund	NN
18637	18933	20	,	,	,
18637	18933	21	so	so	RB
18637	18933	22	may	may	MD
18637	18933	23	all	all	DT
18637	18933	24	automobile	automobile	VB
18637	18933	25	liability	liability	NN
18637	18933	26	insurers	insurer	NNS
18637	18933	27	be	be	VB
18637	18933	28	required	require	VBN
18637	18933	29	to	to	TO
18637	18933	30	submit	submit	VB
18637	18933	31	to	to	IN
18637	18933	32	the	the	DT
18637	18933	33	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	18933	34	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	18933	35	among	among	IN
18637	18933	36	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18933	37	of	of	IN
18637	18933	38	applicants	applicant	NNS
18637	18933	39	who	who	WP
18637	18933	40	are	be	VBP
18637	18933	41	in	in	IN
18637	18933	42	good	good	JJ
18637	18933	43	faith	faith	NN
18637	18933	44	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	18933	45	to	to	IN
18637	18933	46	,	,	,
18637	18933	47	but	but	CC
18637	18933	48	are	be	VBP
18637	18933	49	financially	financially	RB
18637	18933	50	unable	unable	JJ
18637	18933	51	to	to	TO
18637	18933	52	,	,	,
18637	18933	53	procure	procure	VB
18637	18933	54	such	such	JJ
18637	18933	55	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18933	56	through	through	IN
18637	18933	57	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	18933	58	methods	method	NNS
18637	18933	59	.	.	.
18637	18934	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18934	2	327	327	CD
18637	18934	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18934	4	However	however	RB
18637	18934	5	,	,	,
18637	18934	6	a	a	DT
18637	18934	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	18934	8	which	which	WDT
18637	18934	9	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	18934	10	the	the	DT
18637	18934	11	assured	assure	VBN
18637	18934	12	from	from	IN
18637	18934	13	contracting	contract	VBG
18637	18934	14	directly	directly	RB
18637	18934	15	with	with	IN
18637	18934	16	a	a	DT
18637	18934	17	marine	marine	JJ
18637	18934	18	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18934	19	company	company	NN
18637	18934	20	outside	outside	IN
18637	18934	21	the	the	DT
18637	18934	22	State	State	NNP
18637	18934	23	for	for	IN
18637	18934	24	coverage	coverage	NN
18637	18934	25	of	of	IN
18637	18934	26	property	property	NN
18637	18934	27	within	within	IN
18637	18934	28	the	the	DT
18637	18934	29	State	State	NNP
18637	18934	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	18934	31	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	18934	32	as	as	IN
18637	18934	33	a	a	DT
18637	18934	34	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	18934	35	of	of	IN
18637	18934	36	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18934	37	without	without	IN
18637	18934	38	due	due	JJ
18637	18934	39	process	process	NN
18637	18934	40	of	of	IN
18637	18934	41	law	law	NN
18637	18934	42	.	.	.
18637	18935	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18935	2	328	328	CD
18637	18935	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18935	4	For	for	IN
18637	18935	5	the	the	DT
18637	18935	6	same	same	JJ
18637	18935	7	reason	reason	NN
18637	18935	8	,	,	,
18637	18935	9	a	a	DT
18637	18935	10	State	state	NN
18637	18935	11	may	may	MD
18637	18935	12	not	not	RB
18637	18935	13	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18935	14	a	a	DT
18637	18935	15	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	18935	16	from	from	IN
18637	18935	17	concluding	conclude	VBG
18637	18935	18	with	with	IN
18637	18935	19	a	a	DT
18637	18935	20	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18935	21	life	life	NN
18637	18935	22	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18935	23	company	company	NN
18637	18935	24	at	at	IN
18637	18935	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18935	26	home	home	NN
18637	18935	27	office	office	NN
18637	18935	28	a	a	DT
18637	18935	29	policy	policy	NN
18637	18935	30	loan	loan	NN
18637	18935	31	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	18935	32	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	18935	33	the	the	DT
18637	18935	34	policy	policy	NN
18637	18935	35	of	of	IN
18637	18935	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18935	37	life	life	NN
18637	18935	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	18935	39	pledged	pledge	VBN
18637	18935	40	as	as	IN
18637	18935	41	collateral	collateral	JJ
18637	18935	42	security	security	NN
18637	18935	43	for	for	IN
18637	18935	44	a	a	DT
18637	18935	45	cash	cash	NN
18637	18935	46	loan	loan	NN
18637	18935	47	to	to	TO
18637	18935	48	become	become	VB
18637	18935	49	due	due	JJ
18637	18935	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	18935	51	default	default	NN
18637	18935	52	in	in	IN
18637	18935	53	payment	payment	NN
18637	18935	54	of	of	IN
18637	18935	55	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	18935	56	,	,	,
18637	18935	57	in	in	IN
18637	18935	58	which	which	WDT
18637	18935	59	case	case	NN
18637	18935	60	the	the	DT
18637	18935	61	entire	entire	JJ
18637	18935	62	policy	policy	NN
18637	18935	63	reserve	reserve	NN
18637	18935	64	might	may	MD
18637	18935	65	be	be	VB
18637	18935	66	applied	apply	VBN
18637	18935	67	to	to	TO
18637	18935	68	discharge	discharge	VB
18637	18935	69	the	the	DT
18637	18935	70	indebtedness	indebtedness	NN
18637	18935	71	.	.	.
18637	18936	1	Authority	authority	NN
18637	18936	2	to	to	TO
18637	18936	3	subject	subject	VB
18637	18936	4	such	such	PDT
18637	18936	5	an	an	DT
18637	18936	6	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	18936	7	to	to	IN
18637	18936	8	the	the	DT
18637	18936	9	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	18936	10	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	18936	11	of	of	IN
18637	18936	12	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	18936	13	law	law	NN
18637	18936	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	18936	15	not	not	RB
18637	18936	16	deducible	deducible	JJ
18637	18936	17	from	from	IN
18637	18936	18	the	the	DT
18637	18936	19	power	power	NN
18637	18936	20	of	of	IN
18637	18936	21	a	a	DT
18637	18936	22	State	State	NNP
18637	18936	23	to	to	TO
18637	18936	24	license	license	VB
18637	18936	25	a	a	DT
18637	18936	26	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18936	27	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18936	28	company	company	NN
18637	18936	29	as	as	IN
18637	18936	30	a	a	DT
18637	18936	31	condition	condition	NN
18637	18936	32	of	of	IN
18637	18936	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18936	34	doing	do	VBG
18637	18936	35	business	business	NN
18637	18936	36	therein	therein	RB
18637	18936	37	.	.	.
18637	18937	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18937	2	329	329	CD
18637	18937	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18937	4	A	a	DT
18637	18937	5	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	18937	6	that	that	WDT
18637	18937	7	policies	policy	NNS
18637	18937	8	of	of	IN
18637	18937	9	hail	hail	NN
18637	18937	10	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18937	11	shall	shall	MD
18637	18937	12	take	take	VB
18637	18937	13	effect	effect	NN
18637	18937	14	and	and	CC
18637	18937	15	become	become	VB
18637	18937	16	binding	bind	VBG
18637	18937	17	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	18937	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	18937	19	four	four	CD
18637	18937	20	hours	hour	NNS
18637	18937	21	after	after	IN
18637	18937	22	the	the	DT
18637	18937	23	hour	hour	NN
18637	18937	24	in	in	IN
18637	18937	25	which	which	WDT
18637	18937	26	an	an	DT
18637	18937	27	application	application	NN
18637	18937	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	18937	29	taken	take	VBN
18637	18937	30	and	and	CC
18637	18937	31	further	further	RB
18637	18937	32	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18937	33	notice	notice	NN
18637	18937	34	by	by	IN
18637	18937	35	telegram	telegram	NN
18637	18937	36	of	of	IN
18637	18937	37	rejection	rejection	NN
18637	18937	38	of	of	IN
18637	18937	39	an	an	DT
18637	18937	40	application	application	NN
18637	18937	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	18937	42	not	not	RB
18637	18937	43	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	18937	44	.	.	.
18637	18938	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18938	2	330	330	CD
18637	18938	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18938	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	18938	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	18938	6	any	any	DT
18637	18938	7	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18938	8	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	18938	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	18938	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18938	11	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	18938	12	of	of	IN
18637	18938	13	contract	contract	NN
18637	18938	14	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	18938	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	18938	16	surety	surety	NN
18637	18938	17	companies	company	NNS
18637	18938	18	by	by	IN
18637	18938	19	a	a	DT
18637	18938	20	statute	statute	NN
18637	18938	21	providing	provide	VBG
18637	18938	22	that	that	IN
18637	18938	23	any	any	DT
18637	18938	24	bond	bond	NN
18637	18938	25	executed	execute	VBN
18637	18938	26	after	after	IN
18637	18938	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18938	28	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	18938	29	for	for	IN
18637	18938	30	the	the	DT
18637	18938	31	faithful	faithful	JJ
18637	18938	32	performance	performance	NN
18637	18938	33	of	of	IN
18637	18938	34	a	a	DT
18637	18938	35	building	building	NN
18637	18938	36	contract	contract	NN
18637	18938	37	shall	shall	MD
18637	18938	38	inure	inure	VB
18637	18938	39	to	to	IN
18637	18938	40	the	the	DT
18637	18938	41	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	18938	42	of	of	IN
18637	18938	43	materialmen	materialman	NNS
18637	18938	44	and	and	CC
18637	18938	45	laborers	laborer	NNS
18637	18938	46	,	,	,
18637	18938	47	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	18938	48	any	any	DT
18637	18938	49	provision	provision	NN
18637	18938	50	of	of	IN
18637	18938	51	the	the	DT
18637	18938	52	bond	bond	NN
18637	18938	53	to	to	IN
18637	18938	54	the	the	DT
18637	18938	55	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	18938	56	.	.	.
18637	18939	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18939	2	331	331	CD
18637	18939	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18939	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	18939	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18939	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	18939	7	a	a	DT
18637	18939	8	law	law	NN
18637	18939	9	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18939	10	that	that	IN
18637	18939	11	a	a	DT
18637	18939	12	policy	policy	NN
18637	18939	13	,	,	,
18637	18939	14	indemnifying	indemnify	VBG
18637	18939	15	a	a	DT
18637	18939	16	motor	motor	NN
18637	18939	17	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	18939	18	owner	owner	NN
18637	18939	19	against	against	IN
18637	18939	20	liability	liability	NN
18637	18939	21	to	to	IN
18637	18939	22	persons	person	NNS
18637	18939	23	injured	injure	VBN
18637	18939	24	through	through	IN
18637	18939	25	negligent	negligent	JJ
18637	18939	26	operation	operation	NN
18637	18939	27	,	,	,
18637	18939	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	18939	29	provide	provide	VB
18637	18939	30	that	that	DT
18637	18939	31	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	18939	32	of	of	IN
18637	18939	33	the	the	DT
18637	18939	34	insured	insure	VBN
18637	18939	35	shall	shall	MD
18637	18939	36	not	not	RB
18637	18939	37	release	release	VB
18637	18939	38	the	the	DT
18637	18939	39	insurer	insurer	NN
18637	18939	40	from	from	IN
18637	18939	41	liability	liability	NN
18637	18939	42	to	to	IN
18637	18939	43	an	an	DT
18637	18939	44	injured	injure	VBN
18637	18939	45	person	person	NN
18637	18939	46	.	.	.
18637	18940	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18940	2	332	332	CD
18637	18940	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18940	4	If	if	IN
18637	18940	5	fire	fire	NN
18637	18940	6	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18940	7	companies	company	NNS
18637	18940	8	,	,	,
18637	18940	9	in	in	IN
18637	18940	10	case	case	NN
18637	18940	11	of	of	IN
18637	18940	12	total	total	JJ
18637	18940	13	loss	loss	NN
18637	18940	14	,	,	,
18637	18940	15	are	be	VBP
18637	18940	16	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	18940	17	to	to	TO
18637	18940	18	pay	pay	VB
18637	18940	19	the	the	DT
18637	18940	20	amount	amount	NN
18637	18940	21	for	for	IN
18637	18940	22	which	which	WDT
18637	18940	23	the	the	DT
18637	18940	24	property	property	NN
18637	18940	25	was	be	VBD
18637	18940	26	insured	insure	VBN
18637	18940	27	,	,	,
18637	18940	28	less	less	JJR
18637	18940	29	depreciation	depreciation	NN
18637	18940	30	between	between	IN
18637	18940	31	the	the	DT
18637	18940	32	time	time	NN
18637	18940	33	of	of	IN
18637	18940	34	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	18940	35	the	the	DT
18637	18940	36	policy	policy	NN
18637	18940	37	and	and	CC
18637	18940	38	the	the	DT
18637	18940	39	time	time	NN
18637	18940	40	of	of	IN
18637	18940	41	the	the	DT
18637	18940	42	loss	loss	NN
18637	18940	43	,	,	,
18637	18940	44	such	such	JJ
18637	18940	45	insurers	insurer	NNS
18637	18940	46	are	be	VBP
18637	18940	47	not	not	RB
18637	18940	48	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	18940	49	of	of	IN
18637	18940	50	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18940	51	property	property	NN
18637	18940	52	without	without	IN
18637	18940	53	due	due	JJ
18637	18940	54	process	process	NN
18637	18940	55	of	of	IN
18637	18940	56	law	law	NN
18637	18940	57	.	.	.
18637	18941	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18941	2	333	333	CD
18637	18941	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18941	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	18941	5	,	,	,
18637	18941	6	even	even	RB
18637	18941	7	though	though	IN
18637	18941	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18941	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	18941	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18941	11	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	18941	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	18941	13	in	in	IN
18637	18941	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	18941	15	fact	fact	NN
18637	18941	16	located	locate	VBN
18637	18941	17	in	in	IN
18637	18941	18	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	18941	19	,	,	,
18637	18941	20	signs	sign	VBZ
18637	18941	21	all	all	PDT
18637	18941	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18941	23	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	18941	24	there	there	RB
18637	18941	25	,	,	,
18637	18941	26	and	and	CC
18637	18941	27	forwards	forwards	RB
18637	18941	28	therefrom	therefrom	JJ
18637	18941	29	all	all	DT
18637	18941	30	checks	check	NNS
18637	18941	31	in	in	IN
18637	18941	32	payment	payment	NN
18637	18941	33	of	of	IN
18637	18941	34	losses	loss	NNS
18637	18941	35	,	,	,
18637	18941	36	a	a	DT
18637	18941	37	reciprocal	reciprocal	JJ
18637	18941	38	insurance	insurance	NNP
18637	18941	39	association	association	NN
18637	18941	40	,	,	,
18637	18941	41	if	if	IN
18637	18941	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18941	43	covers	cover	VBZ
18637	18941	44	real	real	JJ
18637	18941	45	property	property	NN
18637	18941	46	located	locate	VBN
18637	18941	47	in	in	IN
18637	18941	48	New	New	NNP
18637	18941	49	York	York	NNP
18637	18941	50	,	,	,
18637	18941	51	may	may	MD
18637	18941	52	be	be	VB
18637	18941	53	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	18941	54	to	to	TO
18637	18941	55	comply	comply	VB
18637	18941	56	with	with	IN
18637	18941	57	New	New	NNP
18637	18941	58	York	York	NNP
18637	18941	59	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18941	60	which	which	WDT
18637	18941	61	require	require	VBP
18637	18941	62	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	18941	63	of	of	IN
18637	18941	64	an	an	DT
18637	18941	65	office	office	NN
18637	18941	66	in	in	IN
18637	18941	67	that	that	DT
18637	18941	68	State	State	NNP
18637	18941	69	and	and	CC
18637	18941	70	the	the	DT
18637	18941	71	countersigning	countersigning	NN
18637	18941	72	of	of	IN
18637	18941	73	policies	policy	NNS
18637	18941	74	by	by	IN
18637	18941	75	an	an	DT
18637	18941	76	agent	agent	NN
18637	18941	77	resident	resident	NN
18637	18941	78	therein	therein	RB
18637	18941	79	.	.	.
18637	18942	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18942	2	334	334	CD
18637	18942	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18942	4	Also	also	RB
18637	18942	5	,	,	,
18637	18942	6	to	to	TO
18637	18942	7	discourage	discourage	VB
18637	18942	8	monopolies	monopoly	NNS
18637	18942	9	and	and	CC
18637	18942	10	to	to	TO
18637	18942	11	encourage	encourage	VB
18637	18942	12	competition	competition	NN
18637	18942	13	in	in	IN
18637	18942	14	the	the	DT
18637	18942	15	matter	matter	NN
18637	18942	16	of	of	IN
18637	18942	17	rates	rate	NNS
18637	18942	18	,	,	,
18637	18942	19	a	a	DT
18637	18942	20	State	state	NN
18637	18942	21	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	18942	22	may	may	MD
18637	18942	23	impose	impose	VB
18637	18942	24	on	on	IN
18637	18942	25	all	all	DT
18637	18942	26	fire	fire	NN
18637	18942	27	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18942	28	companies	company	NNS
18637	18942	29	connected	connect	VBN
18637	18942	30	with	with	IN
18637	18942	31	a	a	DT
18637	18942	32	tariff	tariff	NN
18637	18942	33	association	association	NN
18637	18942	34	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	18942	35	rates	rate	VBZ
18637	18942	36	a	a	DT
18637	18942	37	liability	liability	NN
18637	18942	38	or	or	CC
18637	18942	39	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	18942	40	to	to	TO
18637	18942	41	be	be	VB
18637	18942	42	collected	collect	VBN
18637	18942	43	by	by	IN
18637	18942	44	the	the	DT
18637	18942	45	insured	insured	NN
18637	18942	46	of	of	IN
18637	18942	47	25	25	CD
18637	18942	48	%	%	NN
18637	18942	49	in	in	IN
18637	18942	50	excess	excess	NN
18637	18942	51	of	of	IN
18637	18942	52	actual	actual	JJ
18637	18942	53	loss	loss	NN
18637	18942	54	or	or	CC
18637	18942	55	damage	damage	NN
18637	18942	56	,	,	,
18637	18942	57	stipulations	stipulation	NNS
18637	18942	58	in	in	IN
18637	18942	59	the	the	DT
18637	18942	60	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18942	61	contract	contract	NN
18637	18942	62	to	to	IN
18637	18942	63	the	the	DT
18637	18942	64	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	18942	65	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	18942	66	.	.	.
18637	18943	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18943	2	335	335	CD
18637	18943	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18943	4	A	a	DT
18637	18943	5	State	State	NNP
18637	18943	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	18943	7	by	by	IN
18637	18943	8	which	which	WDT
18637	18943	9	a	a	DT
18637	18943	10	life	life	NN
18637	18943	11	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18943	12	company	company	NN
18637	18943	13	,	,	,
18637	18943	14	if	if	IN
18637	18943	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18943	16	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	18943	17	to	to	TO
18637	18943	18	pay	pay	VB
18637	18943	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	18943	20	demand	demand	NN
18637	18943	21	the	the	DT
18637	18943	22	amount	amount	NN
18637	18943	23	due	due	JJ
18637	18943	24	under	under	IN
18637	18943	25	a	a	DT
18637	18943	26	policy	policy	NN
18637	18943	27	after	after	IN
18637	18943	28	death	death	NN
18637	18943	29	of	of	IN
18637	18943	30	the	the	DT
18637	18943	31	insured	insure	VBN
18637	18943	32	,	,	,
18637	18943	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	18943	34	made	make	VBN
18637	18943	35	liable	liable	JJ
18637	18943	36	in	in	IN
18637	18943	37	addition	addition	NN
18637	18943	38	for	for	IN
18637	18943	39	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	18943	40	damages	damage	NNS
18637	18943	41	,	,	,
18637	18943	42	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18943	43	in	in	IN
18637	18943	44	amount	amount	NN
18637	18943	45	,	,	,
18637	18943	46	and	and	CC
18637	18943	47	for	for	IN
18637	18943	48	a	a	DT
18637	18943	49	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18943	50	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	18943	51	's	's	POS
18637	18943	52	fee	fee	NN
18637	18943	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	18943	54	not	not	RB
18637	18943	55	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18943	56	even	even	RB
18637	18943	57	though	though	IN
18637	18943	58	payment	payment	NN
18637	18943	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	18943	60	resisted	resist	VBN
18637	18943	61	in	in	IN
18637	18943	62	good	good	JJ
18637	18943	63	faith	faith	NN
18637	18943	64	and	and	CC
18637	18943	65	upon	upon	IN
18637	18943	66	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18943	67	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	18943	68	.	.	.
18637	18944	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18944	2	336	336	CD
18637	18944	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18944	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18944	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	18944	6	also	also	RB
18637	18944	7	proper	proper	JJ
18637	18944	8	by	by	IN
18637	18944	9	law	law	NN
18637	18944	10	to	to	TO
18637	18944	11	cut	cut	VB
18637	18944	12	off	off	RP
18637	18944	13	a	a	DT
18637	18944	14	defense	defense	NN
18637	18944	15	by	by	IN
18637	18944	16	a	a	DT
18637	18944	17	life	life	NN
18637	18944	18	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18944	19	company	company	NN
18637	18944	20	based	base	VBN
18637	18944	21	on	on	IN
18637	18944	22	false	false	JJ
18637	18944	23	and	and	CC
18637	18944	24	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	18944	25	statements	statement	NNS
18637	18944	26	in	in	IN
18637	18944	27	the	the	DT
18637	18944	28	application	application	NN
18637	18944	29	,	,	,
18637	18944	30	unless	unless	IN
18637	18944	31	the	the	DT
18637	18944	32	matter	matter	NN
18637	18944	33	misrepresented	misrepresent	VBN
18637	18944	34	actually	actually	RB
18637	18944	35	contributed	contribute	VBD
18637	18944	36	to	to	IN
18637	18944	37	the	the	DT
18637	18944	38	death	death	NN
18637	18944	39	of	of	IN
18637	18944	40	the	the	DT
18637	18944	41	insured	insure	VBN
18637	18944	42	.	.	.
18637	18945	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18945	2	337	337	CD
18637	18945	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18945	4	A	a	DT
18637	18945	5	provision	provision	NN
18637	18945	6	that	that	DT
18637	18945	7	suicide	suicide	NN
18637	18945	8	,	,	,
18637	18945	9	unless	unless	IN
18637	18945	10	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
18637	18945	11	when	when	WRB
18637	18945	12	the	the	DT
18637	18945	13	application	application	NN
18637	18945	14	for	for	IN
18637	18945	15	a	a	DT
18637	18945	16	policy	policy	NN
18637	18945	17	was	be	VBD
18637	18945	18	made	make	VBN
18637	18945	19	,	,	,
18637	18945	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	18945	21	be	be	VB
18637	18945	22	no	no	DT
18637	18945	23	defense	defense	NN
18637	18945	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	18945	25	equally	equally	RB
18637	18945	26	valid	valid	JJ
18637	18945	27	.	.	.
18637	18946	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18946	2	338	338	CD
18637	18946	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18946	4	When	when	WRB
18637	18946	5	a	a	DT
18637	18946	6	cooperative	cooperative	JJ
18637	18946	7	life	life	NN
18637	18946	8	insurance	insurance	NNP
18637	18946	9	association	association	NNP
18637	18946	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	18946	11	reorganized	reorganize	VBN
18637	18946	12	so	so	IN
18637	18946	13	as	as	IN
18637	18946	14	to	to	TO
18637	18946	15	permit	permit	VB
18637	18946	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18946	17	to	to	TO
18637	18946	18	do	do	VB
18637	18946	19	a	a	DT
18637	18946	20	life	life	NN
18637	18946	21	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18946	22	business	business	NN
18637	18946	23	of	of	IN
18637	18946	24	every	every	DT
18637	18946	25	kind	kind	NN
18637	18946	26	,	,	,
18637	18946	27	policyholders	policyholder	NNS
18637	18946	28	are	be	VBP
18637	18946	29	not	not	RB
18637	18946	30	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	18946	31	of	of	IN
18637	18946	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18946	33	property	property	NN
18637	18946	34	without	without	IN
18637	18946	35	due	due	JJ
18637	18946	36	process	process	NN
18637	18946	37	of	of	IN
18637	18946	38	law	law	NN
18637	18946	39	.	.	.
18637	18947	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18947	2	339	339	CD
18637	18947	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18947	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18947	5	,	,	,
18637	18947	6	when	when	WRB
18637	18947	7	the	the	DT
18637	18947	8	method	method	NN
18637	18947	9	of	of	IN
18637	18947	10	liquidation	liquidation	NN
18637	18947	11	provided	provide	VBN
18637	18947	12	by	by	IN
18637	18947	13	a	a	DT
18637	18947	14	plan	plan	NN
18637	18947	15	of	of	IN
18637	18947	16	rehabilitation	rehabilitation	NN
18637	18947	17	of	of	IN
18637	18947	18	a	a	DT
18637	18947	19	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	18947	20	life	life	NN
18637	18947	21	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	18947	22	company	company	NN
18637	18947	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	18947	24	as	as	RB
18637	18947	25	favorable	favorable	JJ
18637	18947	26	to	to	IN
18637	18947	27	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	18947	28	policyholders	policyholder	NNS
18637	18947	29	as	as	IN
18637	18947	30	would	would	MD
18637	18947	31	have	have	VB
18637	18947	32	been	be	VBN
18637	18947	33	the	the	DT
18637	18947	34	sale	sale	NN
18637	18947	35	of	of	IN
18637	18947	36	assets	asset	NNS
18637	18947	37	and	and	CC
18637	18947	38	pro	pro	JJ
18637	18947	39	rata	rata	JJ
18637	18947	40	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	18947	41	to	to	IN
18637	18947	42	all	all	DT
18637	18947	43	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	18947	44	,	,	,
18637	18947	45	the	the	DT
18637	18947	46	dissenters	dissenter	NNS
18637	18947	47	are	be	VBP
18637	18947	48	unable	unable	JJ
18637	18947	49	to	to	TO
18637	18947	50	show	show	VB
18637	18947	51	any	any	DT
18637	18947	52	taking	taking	NN
18637	18947	53	without	without	IN
18637	18947	54	due	due	JJ
18637	18947	55	process	process	NN
18637	18947	56	.	.	.
18637	18948	1	Dissenters	dissenter	NNS
18637	18948	2	have	have	VBP
18637	18948	3	no	no	DT
18637	18948	4	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18948	5	right	right	NN
18637	18948	6	to	to	IN
18637	18948	7	a	a	DT
18637	18948	8	particular	particular	JJ
18637	18948	9	form	form	NN
18637	18948	10	of	of	IN
18637	18948	11	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	18948	12	.	.	.
18637	18949	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18949	2	340	340	CD
18637	18949	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18949	4	Professions	Professions	NNPS
18637	18949	5	,	,	,
18637	18949	6	Trades	Trades	NNPS
18637	18949	7	,	,	,
18637	18949	8	Occupations	Occupations	NNP
18637	18949	9	Employment	Employment	NNP
18637	18949	10	Agencies.--An	Agencies.--An	NNP
18637	18949	11	act	act	NN
18637	18949	12	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	18949	13	license	license	NN
18637	18949	14	fees	fee	NNS
18637	18949	15	for	for	IN
18637	18949	16	operating	operate	VBG
18637	18949	17	such	such	JJ
18637	18949	18	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	18949	19	and	and	CC
18637	18949	20	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	18949	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18949	22	from	from	IN
18637	18949	23	sending	send	VBG
18637	18949	24	applicants	applicant	NNS
18637	18949	25	to	to	IN
18637	18949	26	an	an	DT
18637	18949	27	employer	employer	NN
18637	18949	28	who	who	WP
18637	18949	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	18949	30	not	not	RB
18637	18949	31	applied	apply	VBN
18637	18949	32	for	for	IN
18637	18949	33	labor	labor	NN
18637	18949	34	does	do	VBZ
18637	18949	35	not	not	RB
18637	18949	36	deny	deny	VB
18637	18949	37	due	due	JJ
18637	18949	38	process	process	NN
18637	18949	39	of	of	IN
18637	18949	40	law	law	NN
18637	18949	41	.	.	.
18637	18950	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18950	2	341	341	CD
18637	18950	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18950	4	Pharmacies.--A	pharmacies.--a	NN
18637	18950	5	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	18950	6	law	law	NN
18637	18950	7	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	18950	8	a	a	DT
18637	18950	9	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18950	10	to	to	TO
18637	18950	11	own	own	VB
18637	18950	12	therein	therein	RB
18637	18950	13	any	any	DT
18637	18950	14	drug	drug	NN
18637	18950	15	store	store	NN
18637	18950	16	,	,	,
18637	18950	17	excepting	except	VBG
18637	18950	18	those	those	DT
18637	18950	19	owned	own	VBN
18637	18950	20	and	and	CC
18637	18950	21	operated	operate	VBN
18637	18950	22	at	at	IN
18637	18950	23	the	the	DT
18637	18950	24	time	time	NN
18637	18950	25	of	of	IN
18637	18950	26	the	the	DT
18637	18950	27	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	18950	28	,	,	,
18637	18950	29	unless	unless	IN
18637	18950	30	all	all	DT
18637	18950	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18950	32	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	18950	33	are	be	VBP
18637	18950	34	licensed	license	VBN
18637	18950	35	pharmacists	pharmacist	NNS
18637	18950	36	,	,	,
18637	18950	37	violates	violate	VBZ
18637	18950	38	the	the	DT
18637	18950	39	due	due	JJ
18637	18950	40	process	process	NN
18637	18950	41	clause	clause	NN
18637	18950	42	as	as	IN
18637	18950	43	applied	apply	VBN
18637	18950	44	to	to	IN
18637	18950	45	a	a	DT
18637	18950	46	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	18950	47	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	18950	48	,	,	,
18637	18950	49	all	all	DT
18637	18950	50	of	of	IN
18637	18950	51	whose	whose	WP$
18637	18950	52	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	18950	53	are	be	VBP
18637	18950	54	not	not	RB
18637	18950	55	pharmacists	pharmacist	NNS
18637	18950	56	,	,	,
18637	18950	57	which	which	WDT
18637	18950	58	sought	seek	VBD
18637	18950	59	to	to	TO
18637	18950	60	extend	extend	VB
18637	18950	61	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18950	62	business	business	NN
18637	18950	63	in	in	IN
18637	18950	64	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	18950	65	by	by	IN
18637	18950	66	acquiring	acquire	VBG
18637	18950	67	and	and	CC
18637	18950	68	operating	operate	VBG
18637	18950	69	therein	therein	RB
18637	18950	70	two	two	CD
18637	18950	71	additional	additional	JJ
18637	18950	72	stores	store	NNS
18637	18950	73	.	.	.
18637	18951	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18951	2	342	342	CD
18637	18951	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18951	4	Miscellaneous	Miscellaneous	NNP
18637	18951	5	Business	Business	NNP
18637	18951	6	,	,	,
18637	18951	7	Professions	Professions	NNPS
18637	18951	8	,	,	,
18637	18951	9	Trades	Trades	NNPS
18637	18951	10	,	,	,
18637	18951	11	and	and	CC
18637	18951	12	Occupations.--The	occupations.--the	NN
18637	18951	13	practice	practice	NN
18637	18951	14	of	of	IN
18637	18951	15	medicine	medicine	NN
18637	18951	16	,	,	,
18637	18951	17	using	use	VBG
18637	18951	18	this	this	DT
18637	18951	19	word	word	NN
18637	18951	20	in	in	IN
18637	18951	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18951	22	most	most	RBS
18637	18951	23	general	general	JJ
18637	18951	24	sense	sense	NN
18637	18951	25	,	,	,
18637	18951	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	18951	27	long	long	RB
18637	18951	28	been	be	VBN
18637	18951	29	the	the	DT
18637	18951	30	subject	subject	NN
18637	18951	31	of	of	IN
18637	18951	32	regulation;[343	regulation;[343	NNPS
18637	18951	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18951	34	and	and	CC
18637	18951	35	in	in	IN
18637	18951	36	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	18951	37	of	of	IN
18637	18951	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18951	39	power	power	NN
18637	18951	40	a	a	DT
18637	18951	41	State	state	NN
18637	18951	42	may	may	MD
18637	18951	43	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	18951	44	osteopathic	osteopathic	JJ
18637	18951	45	physicians	physician	NNS
18637	18951	46	from	from	IN
18637	18951	47	hospitals	hospital	NNS
18637	18951	48	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	18951	49	by	by	IN
18637	18951	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18951	51	or	or	CC
18637	18951	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18951	53	municipalities;[344	municipalities;[344	ADD
18637	18951	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18951	55	and	and	CC
18637	18951	56	may	may	MD
18637	18951	57	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	18951	58	the	the	DT
18637	18951	59	practice	practice	NN
18637	18951	60	of	of	IN
18637	18951	61	dentistry	dentistry	NN
18637	18951	62	by	by	IN
18637	18951	63	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	18951	64	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	18951	65	that	that	WDT
18637	18951	66	are	be	VBP
18637	18951	67	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	18951	68	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18951	69	,	,	,
18637	18951	70	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18951	71	licenses	license	NNS
18637	18951	72	,	,	,
18637	18951	73	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	18951	74	a	a	DT
18637	18951	75	supervisory	supervisory	JJ
18637	18951	76	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	18951	77	board	board	NN
18637	18951	78	,	,	,
18637	18951	79	and	and	CC
18637	18951	80	by	by	IN
18637	18951	81	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	18951	82	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18951	83	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	18951	84	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	18951	85	of	of	IN
18637	18951	86	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18951	87	truthfulness	truthfulness	NN
18637	18951	88	.	.	.
18637	18952	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18952	2	345	345	CD
18637	18952	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18952	4	But	but	CC
18637	18952	5	while	while	IN
18637	18952	6	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18952	7	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18952	8	pilots	pilot	NNS
18637	18952	9	to	to	TO
18637	18952	10	be	be	VB
18637	18952	11	licensed[346	licensed[346	.
18637	18952	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18952	13	and	and	CC
18637	18952	14	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	18952	15	engineers	engineer	NNS
18637	18952	16	to	to	TO
18637	18952	17	pass	pass	VB
18637	18952	18	color	color	NN
18637	18952	19	blindness	blindness	NN
18637	18952	20	tests[347	tests[347	,
18637	18952	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18952	22	have	have	VBP
18637	18952	23	been	be	VBN
18637	18952	24	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18952	25	,	,	,
18637	18952	26	an	an	DT
18637	18952	27	act	act	NN
18637	18952	28	making	make	VBG
18637	18952	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18952	30	a	a	DT
18637	18952	31	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
18637	18952	32	for	for	IN
18637	18952	33	a	a	DT
18637	18952	34	person	person	NN
18637	18952	35	to	to	TO
18637	18952	36	act	act	VB
18637	18952	37	as	as	IN
18637	18952	38	a	a	DT
18637	18952	39	railway	railway	NN
18637	18952	40	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	18952	41	conductor	conductor	NN
18637	18952	42	without	without	IN
18637	18952	43	having	have	VBG
18637	18952	44	had	have	VBD
18637	18952	45	two	two	CD
18637	18952	46	years	year	NNS
18637	18952	47	'	'	POS
18637	18952	48	experience	experience	NN
18637	18952	49	as	as	IN
18637	18952	50	a	a	DT
18637	18952	51	freight	freight	NN
18637	18952	52	conductor	conductor	NN
18637	18952	53	or	or	CC
18637	18952	54	brakeman	brakeman	NN
18637	18952	55	is	be	VBZ
18637	18952	56	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	18952	57	.	.	.
18637	18953	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18953	2	348	348	CD
18637	18953	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18953	4	Legislation	legislation	NN
18637	18953	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	18953	6	been	be	VBN
18637	18953	7	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	18953	8	which	which	WDT
18637	18953	9	regulated	regulated	JJ
18637	18953	10	or	or	CC
18637	18953	11	required	require	VBN
18637	18953	12	licenses	license	NNS
18637	18953	13	for	for	IN
18637	18953	14	admissions	admission	NNS
18637	18953	15	to	to	IN
18637	18953	16	places	place	NNS
18637	18953	17	of	of	IN
18637	18953	18	amusement,[349	amusement,[349	NNP
18637	18953	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18953	20	grain	grain	NN
18637	18953	21	elevators,[350	elevators,[350	NNP
18637	18953	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18953	23	detective	detective	JJ
18637	18953	24	agencies,[351	agencies,[351	NNP
18637	18953	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18953	26	sale	sale	NN
18637	18953	27	of	of	IN
18637	18953	28	cigarettes,[352	cigarettes,[352	NN
18637	18953	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18953	30	or	or	CC
18637	18953	31	cosmetics,[353	cosmetics,[353	NN
18637	18953	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18953	33	and	and	CC
18637	18953	34	the	the	DT
18637	18953	35	resale	resale	NN
18637	18953	36	of	of	IN
18637	18953	37	theatre	theatre	NNP
18637	18953	38	tickets;[354	tickets;[354	NNP
18637	18953	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18953	40	or	or	CC
18637	18953	41	which	which	WDT
18637	18953	42	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	18953	43	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	18953	44	the	the	DT
18637	18953	45	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	18953	46	of	of	IN
18637	18953	47	cigarettes,[355	cigarettes,[355	NN
18637	18953	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18953	49	or	or	CC
18637	18953	50	the	the	DT
18637	18953	51	use	use	NN
18637	18953	52	of	of	IN
18637	18953	53	a	a	DT
18637	18953	54	representation	representation	NN
18637	18953	55	of	of	IN
18637	18953	56	the	the	DT
18637	18953	57	United	United	NNP
18637	18953	58	States	States	NNP
18637	18953	59	flag	flag	NN
18637	18953	60	on	on	IN
18637	18953	61	an	an	DT
18637	18953	62	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	18953	63	medium,[356	medium,[356	NN
18637	18953	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18953	65	the	the	DT
18637	18953	66	solicitation	solicitation	NN
18637	18953	67	by	by	IN
18637	18953	68	a	a	DT
18637	18953	69	layman	layman	NN
18637	18953	70	of	of	IN
18637	18953	71	business	business	NN
18637	18953	72	of	of	IN
18637	18953	73	collecting	collect	VBG
18637	18953	74	and	and	CC
18637	18953	75	adjusting	adjust	VBG
18637	18953	76	claims,[357	claims,[357	NN
18637	18953	77	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18953	78	the	the	DT
18637	18953	79	keeping	keeping	NN
18637	18953	80	of	of	IN
18637	18953	81	private	private	JJ
18637	18953	82	markets	market	NNS
18637	18953	83	within	within	IN
18637	18953	84	six	six	CD
18637	18953	85	squares	square	NNS
18637	18953	86	of	of	IN
18637	18953	87	a	a	DT
18637	18953	88	public	public	JJ
18637	18953	89	market,[358	market,[358	NN
18637	18953	90	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18953	91	the	the	DT
18637	18953	92	keeping	keeping	NN
18637	18953	93	of	of	IN
18637	18953	94	billiard	billiard	NN
18637	18953	95	halls	hall	NNS
18637	18953	96	except	except	IN
18637	18953	97	in	in	IN
18637	18953	98	hotels,[359	hotels,[359	NN
18637	18953	99	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18953	100	or	or	CC
18637	18953	101	the	the	DT
18637	18953	102	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	18953	103	by	by	IN
18637	18953	104	junk	junk	NN
18637	18953	105	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	18953	106	of	of	IN
18637	18953	107	wire	wire	NN
18637	18953	108	,	,	,
18637	18953	109	copper	copper	NN
18637	18953	110	,	,	,
18637	18953	111	etc	etc	FW
18637	18953	112	.	.	FW
18637	18953	113	,	,	,
18637	18953	114	without	without	IN
18637	18953	115	ascertaining	ascertain	VBG
18637	18953	116	the	the	DT
18637	18953	117	sellers	seller	NNS
18637	18953	118	'	'	POS
18637	18953	119	right	right	NN
18637	18953	120	to	to	TO
18637	18953	121	sell	sell	VB
18637	18953	122	.	.	.
18637	18954	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18954	2	360	360	CD
18637	18954	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18954	4	PROTECTION	PROTECTION	NNP
18637	18954	5	OF	of	IN
18637	18954	6	RESOURCES	resource	NNS
18637	18954	7	OF	of	IN
18637	18954	8	THE	the	DT
18637	18954	9	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	18954	10	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	18954	11	and	and	CC
18637	18954	12	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	18954	13	To	to	TO
18637	18954	14	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18954	15	waste	waste	NN
18637	18954	16	production	production	NN
18637	18954	17	may	may	MD
18637	18954	18	be	be	VB
18637	18954	19	prorated	prorate	VBN
18637	18954	20	;	;	:
18637	18954	21	the	the	DT
18637	18954	22	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	18954	23	of	of	IN
18637	18954	24	wasteful	wasteful	JJ
18637	18954	25	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	18954	26	,	,	,
18637	18954	27	whether	whether	IN
18637	18954	28	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	18954	29	in	in	IN
18637	18954	30	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	18954	31	of	of	IN
18637	18954	32	the	the	DT
18637	18954	33	owners	owner	NNS
18637	18954	34	of	of	IN
18637	18954	35	gas	gas	NN
18637	18954	36	in	in	IN
18637	18954	37	a	a	DT
18637	18954	38	common	common	JJ
18637	18954	39	reservoir	reservoir	NN
18637	18954	40	or	or	CC
18637	18954	41	because	because	IN
18637	18954	42	of	of	IN
18637	18954	43	the	the	DT
18637	18954	44	public	public	JJ
18637	18954	45	interests	interest	NNS
18637	18954	46	involved	involve	VBN
18637	18954	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	18954	48	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	18954	49	with	with	IN
18637	18954	50	the	the	DT
18637	18954	51	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18954	52	.	.	.
18637	18955	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18955	2	361	361	CD
18637	18955	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18955	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18955	5	a	a	DT
18637	18955	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	18955	7	which	which	WDT
18637	18955	8	defines	define	VBZ
18637	18955	9	waste	waste	NN
18637	18955	10	as	as	IN
18637	18955	11	including	include	VBG
18637	18955	12	,	,	,
18637	18955	13	in	in	IN
18637	18955	14	addition	addition	NN
18637	18955	15	to	to	IN
18637	18955	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18955	17	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	18955	18	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	18955	19	,	,	,
18637	18955	20	economic	economic	JJ
18637	18955	21	waste	waste	NN
18637	18955	22	,	,	,
18637	18955	23	surface	surface	NN
18637	18955	24	waste	waste	NN
18637	18955	25	,	,	,
18637	18955	26	and	and	CC
18637	18955	27	waste	waste	NN
18637	18955	28	incident	incident	NN
18637	18955	29	to	to	IN
18637	18955	30	production	production	NN
18637	18955	31	in	in	IN
18637	18955	32	excess	excess	NN
18637	18955	33	of	of	IN
18637	18955	34	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	18955	35	or	or	CC
18637	18955	36	marketing	marketing	NN
18637	18955	37	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	18955	38	or	or	CC
18637	18955	39	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18955	40	market	market	NN
18637	18955	41	demands	demand	NNS
18637	18955	42	,	,	,
18637	18955	43	and	and	CC
18637	18955	44	which	which	WDT
18637	18955	45	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	18955	46	that	that	IN
18637	18955	47	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	18955	48	full	full	JJ
18637	18955	49	production	production	NN
18637	18955	50	from	from	IN
18637	18955	51	a	a	DT
18637	18955	52	common	common	JJ
18637	18955	53	source	source	NN
18637	18955	54	of	of	IN
18637	18955	55	supply	supply	NN
18637	18955	56	can	can	MD
18637	18955	57	be	be	VB
18637	18955	58	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	18955	59	only	only	RB
18637	18955	60	under	under	IN
18637	18955	61	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	18955	62	constituting	constitute	VBG
18637	18955	63	waste	waste	NN
18637	18955	64	,	,	,
18637	18955	65	a	a	DT
18637	18955	66	producer	producer	NN
18637	18955	67	may	may	MD
18637	18955	68	take	take	VB
18637	18955	69	only	only	RB
18637	18955	70	such	such	JJ
18637	18955	71	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	18955	72	of	of	IN
18637	18955	73	all	all	DT
18637	18955	74	that	that	WDT
18637	18955	75	may	may	MD
18637	18955	76	be	be	VB
18637	18955	77	produced	produce	VBN
18637	18955	78	from	from	IN
18637	18955	79	such	such	JJ
18637	18955	80	common	common	JJ
18637	18955	81	source	source	NN
18637	18955	82	without	without	IN
18637	18955	83	waste	waste	NN
18637	18955	84	,	,	,
18637	18955	85	as	as	IN
18637	18955	86	the	the	DT
18637	18955	87	production	production	NN
18637	18955	88	of	of	IN
18637	18955	89	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18955	90	wells	well	NNS
18637	18955	91	bears	bear	VBZ
18637	18955	92	to	to	IN
18637	18955	93	the	the	DT
18637	18955	94	total	total	JJ
18637	18955	95	production	production	NN
18637	18955	96	of	of	IN
18637	18955	97	such	such	JJ
18637	18955	98	common	common	JJ
18637	18955	99	source	source	NN
18637	18955	100	,	,	,
18637	18955	101	is	be	VBZ
18637	18955	102	not	not	RB
18637	18955	103	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	18955	104	to	to	IN
18637	18955	105	the	the	DT
18637	18955	106	due	due	JJ
18637	18955	107	process	process	NN
18637	18955	108	clause	clause	NN
18637	18955	109	.	.	.
18637	18956	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18956	2	362	362	CD
18637	18956	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18956	4	But	but	CC
18637	18956	5	whether	whether	IN
18637	18956	6	a	a	DT
18637	18956	7	system	system	NN
18637	18956	8	of	of	IN
18637	18956	9	proration	proration	NN
18637	18956	10	based	base	VBN
18637	18956	11	on	on	IN
18637	18956	12	hourly	hourly	JJ
18637	18956	13	potential	potential	NN
18637	18956	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	18956	15	as	as	RB
18637	18956	16	fair	fair	JJ
18637	18956	17	as	as	IN
18637	18956	18	one	one	CD
18637	18956	19	based	base	VBN
18637	18956	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	18956	21	estimated	estimate	VBN
18637	18956	22	recoverable	recoverable	JJ
18637	18956	23	reserves	reserve	NNS
18637	18956	24	or	or	CC
18637	18956	25	some	some	DT
18637	18956	26	other	other	JJ
18637	18956	27	combination	combination	NN
18637	18956	28	of	of	IN
18637	18956	29	factors	factor	NNS
18637	18956	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	18956	31	a	a	DT
18637	18956	32	question	question	NN
18637	18956	33	for	for	IN
18637	18956	34	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	18956	35	and	and	CC
18637	18956	36	not	not	RB
18637	18956	37	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	18956	38	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18956	39	.	.	.
18637	18957	1	In	in	IN
18637	18957	2	a	a	DT
18637	18957	3	domain	domain	NN
18637	18957	4	of	of	IN
18637	18957	5	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	18957	6	still	still	RB
18637	18957	7	shifting	shift	VBG
18637	18957	8	and	and	CC
18637	18957	9	growing	grow	VBG
18637	18957	10	,	,	,
18637	18957	11	and	and	CC
18637	18957	12	in	in	IN
18637	18957	13	a	a	DT
18637	18957	14	field	field	NN
18637	18957	15	where	where	WRB
18637	18957	16	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18957	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	18957	18	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	18957	19	beset	beset	VBN
18637	18957	20	by	by	IN
18637	18957	21	the	the	DT
18637	18957	22	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	18957	23	of	of	IN
18637	18957	24	inferences	inference	NNS
18637	18957	25	bordering	border	VBG
18637	18957	26	on	on	IN
18637	18957	27	the	the	DT
18637	18957	28	conjecture	conjecture	NN
18637	18957	29	even	even	RB
18637	18957	30	for	for	IN
18637	18957	31	those	those	DT
18637	18957	32	learned	learn	VBN
18637	18957	33	in	in	IN
18637	18957	34	the	the	DT
18637	18957	35	art	art	NN
18637	18957	36	,	,	,
18637	18957	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18957	38	has	have	VBZ
18637	18957	39	been	be	VBN
18637	18957	40	held	hold	VBN
18637	18957	41	to	to	TO
18637	18957	42	be	be	VB
18637	18957	43	presumptuous	presumptuous	JJ
18637	18957	44	for	for	IN
18637	18957	45	courts	court	NNS
18637	18957	46	,	,	,
18637	18957	47	on	on	IN
18637	18957	48	the	the	DT
18637	18957	49	basis	basis	NN
18637	18957	50	of	of	IN
18637	18957	51	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	18957	52	expert	expert	NN
18637	18957	53	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	18957	54	,	,	,
18637	18957	55	to	to	TO
18637	18957	56	nullify	nullify	VB
18637	18957	57	an	an	DT
18637	18957	58	oil	oil	NN
18637	18957	59	proration	proration	NN
18637	18957	60	order	order	NN
18637	18957	61	,	,	,
18637	18957	62	promulgated	promulgate	VBN
18637	18957	63	by	by	IN
18637	18957	64	an	an	DT
18637	18957	65	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	18957	66	commission	commission	NN
18637	18957	67	in	in	IN
18637	18957	68	execution	execution	NN
18637	18957	69	of	of	IN
18637	18957	70	a	a	DT
18637	18957	71	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	18957	72	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	18957	73	intended	intend	VBN
18637	18957	74	to	to	TO
18637	18957	75	conserve	conserve	VB
18637	18957	76	a	a	DT
18637	18957	77	State	state	NN
18637	18957	78	's	's	POS
18637	18957	79	oil	oil	NN
18637	18957	80	resources	resource	NNS
18637	18957	81	,	,	,
18637	18957	82	as	as	IN
18637	18957	83	violative	violative	JJ
18637	18957	84	of	of	IN
18637	18957	85	due	due	JJ
18637	18957	86	process	process	NN
18637	18957	87	.	.	.
18637	18958	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18958	2	363	363	CD
18637	18958	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18958	4	On	on	IN
18637	18958	5	the	the	DT
18637	18958	6	other	other	JJ
18637	18958	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	18958	8	,	,	,
18637	18958	9	where	where	WRB
18637	18958	10	the	the	DT
18637	18958	11	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	18958	12	showed	show	VBD
18637	18958	13	that	that	IN
18637	18958	14	an	an	DT
18637	18958	15	order	order	NN
18637	18958	16	,	,	,
18637	18958	17	purporting	purport	VBG
18637	18958	18	to	to	TO
18637	18958	19	limit	limit	VB
18637	18958	20	daily	daily	JJ
18637	18958	21	total	total	JJ
18637	18958	22	production	production	NN
18637	18958	23	of	of	IN
18637	18958	24	a	a	DT
18637	18958	25	gas	gas	NN
18637	18958	26	field	field	NN
18637	18958	27	and	and	CC
18637	18958	28	to	to	TO
18637	18958	29	prorate	prorate	VB
18637	18958	30	the	the	DT
18637	18958	31	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	18958	32	production	production	NN
18637	18958	33	among	among	IN
18637	18958	34	several	several	JJ
18637	18958	35	wells	well	NNS
18637	18958	36	,	,	,
18637	18958	37	had	have	VBD
18637	18958	38	for	for	IN
18637	18958	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18958	40	real	real	JJ
18637	18958	41	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18958	42	,	,	,
18637	18958	43	not	not	RB
18637	18958	44	the	the	DT
18637	18958	45	prevention	prevention	NN
18637	18958	46	of	of	IN
18637	18958	47	waste	waste	NN
18637	18958	48	nor	nor	CC
18637	18958	49	the	the	DT
18637	18958	50	undue	undue	JJ
18637	18958	51	drainage	drainage	NN
18637	18958	52	from	from	IN
18637	18958	53	the	the	DT
18637	18958	54	reserves	reserve	NNS
18637	18958	55	of	of	IN
18637	18958	56	other	other	JJ
18637	18958	57	well	well	JJ
18637	18958	58	owners	owner	NNS
18637	18958	59	,	,	,
18637	18958	60	but	but	CC
18637	18958	61	rather	rather	RB
18637	18958	62	the	the	DT
18637	18958	63	compelling	compelling	NN
18637	18958	64	of	of	IN
18637	18958	65	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	18958	66	line	line	NN
18637	18958	67	owners	owner	NNS
18637	18958	68	to	to	TO
18637	18958	69	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	18958	70	a	a	DT
18637	18958	71	market	market	NN
18637	18958	72	to	to	IN
18637	18958	73	those	those	DT
18637	18958	74	who	who	WP
18637	18958	75	had	have	VBD
18637	18958	76	no	no	DT
18637	18958	77	pipe	pipe	NN
18637	18958	78	line	line	NN
18637	18958	79	connections	connection	NNS
18637	18958	80	,	,	,
18637	18958	81	the	the	DT
18637	18958	82	order	order	NN
18637	18958	83	was	be	VBD
18637	18958	84	held	hold	VBN
18637	18958	85	void	void	JJ
18637	18958	86	as	as	IN
18637	18958	87	a	a	DT
18637	18958	88	taking	taking	NN
18637	18958	89	of	of	IN
18637	18958	90	private	private	JJ
18637	18958	91	property	property	NN
18637	18958	92	for	for	IN
18637	18958	93	private	private	JJ
18637	18958	94	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	18958	95	.	.	.
18637	18959	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18959	2	364	364	CD
18637	18959	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18959	4	As	as	IN
18637	18959	5	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	18959	6	by	by	IN
18637	18959	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	18959	8	the	the	DT
18637	18959	9	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	18959	10	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	18959	11	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	18959	12	,	,	,
18637	18959	13	finding	find	VBG
18637	18959	14	that	that	IN
18637	18959	15	existing	exist	VBG
18637	18959	16	low	low	JJ
18637	18959	17	field	field	NN
18637	18959	18	prices	price	NNS
18637	18959	19	for	for	IN
18637	18959	20	gas	gas	NN
18637	18959	21	were	be	VBD
18637	18959	22	resulting	result	VBG
18637	18959	23	in	in	IN
18637	18959	24	economic	economic	JJ
18637	18959	25	and	and	CC
18637	18959	26	physical	physical	JJ
18637	18959	27	waste	waste	NN
18637	18959	28	,	,	,
18637	18959	29	issued	issue	VBN
18637	18959	30	orders	order	NNS
18637	18959	31	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	18959	32	a	a	DT
18637	18959	33	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	18959	34	price	price	NN
18637	18959	35	for	for	IN
18637	18959	36	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18959	37	gas	gas	NN
18637	18959	38	and	and	CC
18637	18959	39	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18959	40	the	the	DT
18637	18959	41	Cities	Cities	NNP
18637	18959	42	Service	Service	NNP
18637	18959	43	Company	Company	NNP
18637	18959	44	to	to	TO
18637	18959	45	take	take	VB
18637	18959	46	gas	gas	NN
18637	18959	47	ratably	ratably	RB
18637	18959	48	from	from	IN
18637	18959	49	another	another	DT
18637	18959	50	producer	producer	NN
18637	18959	51	in	in	IN
18637	18959	52	the	the	DT
18637	18959	53	same	same	JJ
18637	18959	54	field	field	NN
18637	18959	55	at	at	IN
18637	18959	56	the	the	DT
18637	18959	57	dictated	dictate	VBN
18637	18959	58	price	price	NN
18637	18959	59	.	.	.
18637	18960	1	The	the	DT
18637	18960	2	orders	order	NNS
18637	18960	3	were	be	VBD
18637	18960	4	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18960	5	by	by	IN
18637	18960	6	the	the	DT
18637	18960	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	18960	8	as	as	IN
18637	18960	9	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	18960	10	measures	measure	NNS
18637	18960	11	.	.	.
18637	18961	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18961	2	365	365	CD
18637	18961	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18961	4	Even	even	RB
18637	18961	5	though	though	IN
18637	18961	6	carbon	carbon	NN
18637	18961	7	black	black	NN
18637	18961	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	18961	9	more	more	RBR
18637	18961	10	valuable	valuable	JJ
18637	18961	11	than	than	IN
18637	18961	12	the	the	DT
18637	18961	13	gas	gas	NN
18637	18961	14	from	from	IN
18637	18961	15	which	which	WDT
18637	18961	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18961	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	18961	18	extracted	extract	VBN
18637	18961	19	,	,	,
18637	18961	20	and	and	CC
18637	18961	21	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	18961	22	a	a	DT
18637	18961	23	resulting	result	VBG
18637	18961	24	loss	loss	NN
18637	18961	25	of	of	IN
18637	18961	26	investment	investment	NN
18637	18961	27	in	in	IN
18637	18961	28	a	a	DT
18637	18961	29	plant	plant	NN
18637	18961	30	for	for	IN
18637	18961	31	the	the	DT
18637	18961	32	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	18961	33	of	of	IN
18637	18961	34	carbon	carbon	NN
18637	18961	35	black	black	NN
18637	18961	36	,	,	,
18637	18961	37	a	a	DT
18637	18961	38	State	State	NNP
18637	18961	39	,	,	,
18637	18961	40	in	in	IN
18637	18961	41	the	the	DT
18637	18961	42	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18961	43	of	of	IN
18637	18961	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18961	45	police	police	NN
18637	18961	46	power	power	NN
18637	18961	47	,	,	,
18637	18961	48	may	may	MD
18637	18961	49	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	18961	50	the	the	DT
18637	18961	51	use	use	NN
18637	18961	52	of	of	IN
18637	18961	53	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18961	54	gas	gas	NN
18637	18961	55	for	for	IN
18637	18961	56	products	product	NNS
18637	18961	57	,	,	,
18637	18961	58	such	such	JJ
18637	18961	59	as	as	IN
18637	18961	60	carbon	carbon	NN
18637	18961	61	black	black	NN
18637	18961	62	,	,	,
18637	18961	63	in	in	IN
18637	18961	64	the	the	DT
18637	18961	65	production	production	NN
18637	18961	66	of	of	IN
18637	18961	67	which	which	WDT
18637	18961	68	such	such	JJ
18637	18961	69	gas	gas	NN
18637	18961	70	is	be	VBZ
18637	18961	71	burned	burn	VBN
18637	18961	72	without	without	IN
18637	18961	73	fully	fully	RB
18637	18961	74	utilizing	utilize	VBG
18637	18961	75	for	for	IN
18637	18961	76	other	other	JJ
18637	18961	77	manufacturing	manufacturing	NN
18637	18961	78	or	or	CC
18637	18961	79	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	18961	80	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	18961	81	the	the	DT
18637	18961	82	heat	heat	NN
18637	18961	83	therein	therein	RB
18637	18961	84	contained	contain	VBD
18637	18961	85	.	.	.
18637	18962	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18962	2	366	366	CD
18637	18962	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18962	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	18962	5	,	,	,
18637	18962	6	for	for	IN
18637	18962	7	the	the	DT
18637	18962	8	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18962	9	of	of	IN
18637	18962	10	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	18962	11	and	and	CC
18637	18962	12	adjusting	adjust	VBG
18637	18962	13	coexisting	coexisting	NN
18637	18962	14	rights	right	NNS
18637	18962	15	of	of	IN
18637	18962	16	surface	surface	NN
18637	18962	17	owners	owner	NNS
18637	18962	18	to	to	IN
18637	18962	19	underlying	underlie	VBG
18637	18962	20	oil	oil	NN
18637	18962	21	and	and	CC
18637	18962	22	gas	gas	NN
18637	18962	23	,	,	,
18637	18962	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18962	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	18962	26	within	within	IN
18637	18962	27	the	the	DT
18637	18962	28	power	power	NN
18637	18962	29	of	of	IN
18637	18962	30	a	a	DT
18637	18962	31	State	State	NNP
18637	18962	32	to	to	TO
18637	18962	33	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	18962	34	the	the	DT
18637	18962	35	operators	operator	NNS
18637	18962	36	of	of	IN
18637	18962	37	wells	well	NNS
18637	18962	38	from	from	IN
18637	18962	39	allowing	allow	VBG
18637	18962	40	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18962	41	gas	gas	NN
18637	18962	42	,	,	,
18637	18962	43	not	not	RB
18637	18962	44	conveniently	conveniently	RB
18637	18962	45	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	18962	46	for	for	IN
18637	18962	47	other	other	JJ
18637	18962	48	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	18962	49	,	,	,
18637	18962	50	to	to	TO
18637	18962	51	come	come	VB
18637	18962	52	to	to	IN
18637	18962	53	the	the	DT
18637	18962	54	surface	surface	NN
18637	18962	55	without	without	IN
18637	18962	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18962	57	lifting	lift	VBG
18637	18962	58	power	power	NN
18637	18962	59	having	have	VBG
18637	18962	60	been	be	VBN
18637	18962	61	utilized	utilize	VBN
18637	18962	62	to	to	TO
18637	18962	63	produce	produce	VB
18637	18962	64	the	the	DT
18637	18962	65	greatest	great	JJS
18637	18962	66	quantity	quantity	NN
18637	18962	67	of	of	IN
18637	18962	68	oil	oil	NN
18637	18962	69	in	in	IN
18637	18962	70	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	18962	71	.	.	.
18637	18963	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18963	2	367	367	CD
18637	18963	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18963	4	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	18963	5	of	of	IN
18637	18963	6	Property	Property	NNP
18637	18963	7	Damaged	damage	VBN
18637	18963	8	by	by	IN
18637	18963	9	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	18963	10	or	or	CC
18637	18963	11	Drilling	Drilling	NNP
18637	18963	12	of	of	IN
18637	18963	13	Wells	Wells	NNP
18637	18963	14	An	an	DT
18637	18963	15	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	18963	16	conditioning	condition	VBG
18637	18963	17	the	the	DT
18637	18963	18	right	right	NN
18637	18963	19	to	to	TO
18637	18963	20	drill	drill	VB
18637	18963	21	for	for	IN
18637	18963	22	oil	oil	NN
18637	18963	23	and	and	CC
18637	18963	24	gas	gas	NN
18637	18963	25	within	within	IN
18637	18963	26	the	the	DT
18637	18963	27	city	city	NN
18637	18963	28	limits	limit	NNS
18637	18963	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	18963	30	the	the	DT
18637	18963	31	filing	filing	NN
18637	18963	32	of	of	IN
18637	18963	33	a	a	DT
18637	18963	34	bond	bond	NN
18637	18963	35	in	in	IN
18637	18963	36	the	the	DT
18637	18963	37	sum	sum	NN
18637	18963	38	of	of	IN
18637	18963	39	$	$	$
18637	18963	40	200,000	200,000	CD
18637	18963	41	for	for	IN
18637	18963	42	each	each	DT
18637	18963	43	well	well	RB
18637	18963	44	,	,	,
18637	18963	45	to	to	TO
18637	18963	46	secure	secure	VB
18637	18963	47	payment	payment	NN
18637	18963	48	of	of	IN
18637	18963	49	damages	damage	NNS
18637	18963	50	from	from	IN
18637	18963	51	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	18963	52	to	to	IN
18637	18963	53	any	any	DT
18637	18963	54	persons	person	NNS
18637	18963	55	or	or	CC
18637	18963	56	property	property	NN
18637	18963	57	resulting	result	VBG
18637	18963	58	from	from	IN
18637	18963	59	the	the	DT
18637	18963	60	drilling	drilling	NN
18637	18963	61	operation	operation	NN
18637	18963	62	,	,	,
18637	18963	63	or	or	CC
18637	18963	64	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	18963	65	of	of	IN
18637	18963	66	any	any	DT
18637	18963	67	well	well	RB
18637	18963	68	or	or	CC
18637	18963	69	structures	structure	VBZ
18637	18963	70	appurtenant	appurtenant	JJ
18637	18963	71	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	18963	72	,	,	,
18637	18963	73	is	be	VBZ
18637	18963	74	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	18963	75	with	with	IN
18637	18963	76	due	due	JJ
18637	18963	77	process	process	NN
18637	18963	78	of	of	IN
18637	18963	79	law	law	NN
18637	18963	80	,	,	,
18637	18963	81	and	and	CC
18637	18963	82	is	be	VBZ
18637	18963	83	not	not	RB
18637	18963	84	rendered	render	VBN
18637	18963	85	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18963	86	by	by	IN
18637	18963	87	the	the	DT
18637	18963	88	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	18963	89	that	that	IN
18637	18963	90	the	the	DT
18637	18963	91	bond	bond	NN
18637	18963	92	be	be	VB
18637	18963	93	executed	execute	VBN
18637	18963	94	,	,	,
18637	18963	95	not	not	RB
18637	18963	96	by	by	IN
18637	18963	97	personal	personal	JJ
18637	18963	98	sureties	surety	NNS
18637	18963	99	,	,	,
18637	18963	100	but	but	CC
18637	18963	101	by	by	IN
18637	18963	102	a	a	DT
18637	18963	103	bonding	bond	VBG
18637	18963	104	company	company	NN
18637	18963	105	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	18963	106	to	to	TO
18637	18963	107	do	do	VB
18637	18963	108	business	business	NN
18637	18963	109	in	in	IN
18637	18963	110	the	the	DT
18637	18963	111	State	State	NNP
18637	18963	112	.	.	.
18637	18964	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18964	2	368	368	CD
18637	18964	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18964	4	On	on	IN
18637	18964	5	the	the	DT
18637	18964	6	other	other	JJ
18637	18964	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	18964	8	,	,	,
18637	18964	9	a	a	DT
18637	18964	10	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	18964	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	18964	12	,	,	,
18637	18964	13	which	which	WDT
18637	18964	14	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	18964	15	the	the	DT
18637	18964	16	mining	mining	NN
18637	18964	17	of	of	IN
18637	18964	18	coal	coal	NN
18637	18964	19	under	under	IN
18637	18964	20	private	private	JJ
18637	18964	21	dwellings	dwelling	NNS
18637	18964	22	or	or	CC
18637	18964	23	streets	street	NNS
18637	18964	24	or	or	CC
18637	18964	25	cities	city	NNS
18637	18964	26	by	by	IN
18637	18964	27	a	a	DT
18637	18964	28	grantor	grantor	NN
18637	18964	29	that	that	WDT
18637	18964	30	had	have	VBD
18637	18964	31	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	18964	32	the	the	DT
18637	18964	33	right	right	NN
18637	18964	34	to	to	IN
18637	18964	35	mine	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18964	36	,	,	,
18637	18964	37	was	be	VBD
18637	18964	38	viewed	view	VBN
18637	18964	39	as	as	IN
18637	18964	40	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	18964	41	the	the	DT
18637	18964	42	use	use	NN
18637	18964	43	of	of	IN
18637	18964	44	private	private	JJ
18637	18964	45	property	property	NN
18637	18964	46	too	too	RB
18637	18964	47	much	much	RB
18637	18964	48	,	,	,
18637	18964	49	and	and	CC
18637	18964	50	hence	hence	RB
18637	18964	51	as	as	IN
18637	18964	52	a	a	DT
18637	18964	53	"	"	``
18637	18964	54	taking	taking	NN
18637	18964	55	"	"	''
18637	18964	56	without	without	IN
18637	18964	57	due	due	JJ
18637	18964	58	process	process	NN
18637	18964	59	of	of	IN
18637	18964	60	law	law	NN
18637	18964	61	.	.	.
18637	18965	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18965	2	369	369	CD
18637	18965	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18965	4	Water	Water	NNP
18637	18965	5	A	a	DT
18637	18965	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	18965	7	making	make	VBG
18637	18965	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18965	9	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	18965	10	for	for	IN
18637	18965	11	a	a	DT
18637	18965	12	riparian	riparian	JJ
18637	18965	13	owner	owner	NN
18637	18965	14	to	to	TO
18637	18965	15	divert	divert	VB
18637	18965	16	water	water	NN
18637	18965	17	into	into	IN
18637	18965	18	another	another	DT
18637	18965	19	State	state	NN
18637	18965	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	18965	21	not	not	RB
18637	18965	22	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	18965	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18965	24	of	of	IN
18637	18965	25	property	property	NN
18637	18965	26	without	without	IN
18637	18965	27	due	due	JJ
18637	18965	28	process	process	NN
18637	18965	29	of	of	IN
18637	18965	30	law	law	NN
18637	18965	31	.	.	.
18637	18966	1	"	"	``
18637	18966	2	The	the	DT
18637	18966	3	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18966	4	power	power	NN
18637	18966	5	of	of	IN
18637	18966	6	the	the	DT
18637	18966	7	State	State	NNP
18637	18966	8	to	to	TO
18637	18966	9	insist	insist	VB
18637	18966	10	that	that	IN
18637	18966	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18966	12	natural	natural	JJ
18637	18966	13	advantages	advantage	NNS
18637	18966	14	shall	shall	MD
18637	18966	15	remain	remain	VB
18637	18966	16	unimpaired	unimpaired	JJ
18637	18966	17	by	by	IN
18637	18966	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18966	19	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	18966	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	18966	21	not	not	RB
18637	18966	22	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	18966	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	18966	24	any	any	DT
18637	18966	25	nice	nice	JJ
18637	18966	26	estimate	estimate	NN
18637	18966	27	of	of	IN
18637	18966	28	the	the	DT
18637	18966	29	extent	extent	NN
18637	18966	30	of	of	IN
18637	18966	31	present	present	JJ
18637	18966	32	use	use	NN
18637	18966	33	or	or	CC
18637	18966	34	speculation	speculation	NN
18637	18966	35	as	as	IN
18637	18966	36	to	to	IN
18637	18966	37	future	future	JJ
18637	18966	38	needs	need	NNS
18637	18966	39	.	.	.
18637	18967	1	*	*	NFP
18637	18967	2	*	*	NFP
18637	18967	3	*	*	NFP
18637	18967	4	What	what	WP
18637	18967	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18967	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	18967	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18967	8	may	may	MD
18637	18967	9	keep	keep	VB
18637	18967	10	and	and	CC
18637	18967	11	give	give	VB
18637	18967	12	no	no	DT
18637	18967	13	one	one	NN
18637	18967	14	a	a	DT
18637	18967	15	reason	reason	NN
18637	18967	16	for	for	IN
18637	18967	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18967	18	will	will	NN
18637	18967	19	.	.	.
18637	18968	1	"	"	``
18637	18968	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18968	3	370	370	CD
18637	18968	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18968	5	Apple	Apple	NNP
18637	18968	6	and	and	CC
18637	18968	7	Citrus	Citrus	NNP
18637	18968	8	Fruit	Fruit	NNP
18637	18968	9	Industries	Industries	NNPS
18637	18968	10	A	a	DT
18637	18968	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	18968	12	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18968	13	the	the	DT
18637	18968	14	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	18968	15	of	of	IN
18637	18968	16	cedar	cedar	NN
18637	18968	17	trees	tree	NNS
18637	18968	18	to	to	TO
18637	18968	19	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	18968	20	the	the	DT
18637	18968	21	infecting	infecting	NN
18637	18968	22	with	with	IN
18637	18968	23	cedar	cedar	NN
18637	18968	24	rust	rust	NN
18637	18968	25	of	of	IN
18637	18968	26	apple	apple	NN
18637	18968	27	orchards	orchard	NNS
18637	18968	28	within	within	IN
18637	18968	29	the	the	DT
18637	18968	30	vicinity	vicinity	NN
18637	18968	31	of	of	IN
18637	18968	32	two	two	CD
18637	18968	33	miles	mile	NNS
18637	18968	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	18968	35	not	not	RB
18637	18968	36	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18968	37	,	,	,
18637	18968	38	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	18968	39	the	the	DT
18637	18968	40	absence	absence	NN
18637	18968	41	of	of	IN
18637	18968	42	provision	provision	NN
18637	18968	43	for	for	IN
18637	18968	44	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18968	45	for	for	IN
18637	18968	46	the	the	DT
18637	18968	47	trees	tree	NNS
18637	18968	48	thus	thus	RB
18637	18968	49	removed	remove	VBN
18637	18968	50	or	or	CC
18637	18968	51	the	the	DT
18637	18968	52	decrease	decrease	NN
18637	18968	53	in	in	IN
18637	18968	54	the	the	DT
18637	18968	55	market	market	NN
18637	18968	56	value	value	NN
18637	18968	57	of	of	IN
18637	18968	58	realty	realty	NN
18637	18968	59	caused	cause	VBN
18637	18968	60	by	by	IN
18637	18968	61	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18968	62	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	18968	63	.	.	.
18637	18969	1	Apple	Apple	NNP
18637	18969	2	growing	grow	VBG
18637	18969	3	being	be	VBG
18637	18969	4	one	one	CD
18637	18969	5	of	of	IN
18637	18969	6	the	the	DT
18637	18969	7	principal	principal	JJ
18637	18969	8	agricultural	agricultural	JJ
18637	18969	9	pursuits	pursuit	NNS
18637	18969	10	in	in	IN
18637	18969	11	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	18969	12	and	and	CC
18637	18969	13	the	the	DT
18637	18969	14	value	value	NN
18637	18969	15	of	of	IN
18637	18969	16	cedar	cedar	NN
18637	18969	17	trees	tree	NNS
18637	18969	18	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	18969	19	that	that	DT
18637	18969	20	State	state	NN
18637	18969	21	being	be	VBG
18637	18969	22	small	small	JJ
18637	18969	23	as	as	IN
18637	18969	24	compared	compare	VBN
18637	18969	25	with	with	IN
18637	18969	26	that	that	DT
18637	18969	27	of	of	IN
18637	18969	28	apple	apple	NN
18637	18969	29	orchards	orchard	NNS
18637	18969	30	,	,	,
18637	18969	31	the	the	DT
18637	18969	32	State	State	NNP
18637	18969	33	was	be	VBD
18637	18969	34	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	18969	35	competent	competent	JJ
18637	18969	36	to	to	TO
18637	18969	37	decide	decide	VB
18637	18969	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	18969	39	the	the	DT
18637	18969	40	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	18969	41	of	of	IN
18637	18969	42	one	one	CD
18637	18969	43	class	class	NN
18637	18969	44	of	of	IN
18637	18969	45	property	property	NN
18637	18969	46	in	in	IN
18637	18969	47	order	order	NN
18637	18969	48	to	to	TO
18637	18969	49	save	save	VB
18637	18969	50	another	another	DT
18637	18969	51	which	which	WDT
18637	18969	52	,	,	,
18637	18969	53	in	in	IN
18637	18969	54	the	the	DT
18637	18969	55	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	18969	56	of	of	IN
18637	18969	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18969	58	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	18969	59	,	,	,
18637	18969	60	is	be	VBZ
18637	18969	61	of	of	IN
18637	18969	62	greater	great	JJR
18637	18969	63	value	value	NN
18637	18969	64	to	to	IN
18637	18969	65	the	the	DT
18637	18969	66	public	public	NN
18637	18969	67	.	.	.
18637	18970	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18970	2	371	371	CD
18637	18970	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18970	4	With	with	IN
18637	18970	5	a	a	DT
18637	18970	6	similar	similar	JJ
18637	18970	7	object	object	NN
18637	18970	8	in	in	IN
18637	18970	9	view	view	NN
18637	18970	10	;	;	:
18637	18970	11	namely	namely	RB
18637	18970	12	,	,	,
18637	18970	13	to	to	TO
18637	18970	14	protect	protect	VB
18637	18970	15	the	the	DT
18637	18970	16	reputation	reputation	NN
18637	18970	17	of	of	IN
18637	18970	18	one	one	CD
18637	18970	19	of	of	IN
18637	18970	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18970	21	major	major	JJ
18637	18970	22	industries	industry	NNS
18637	18970	23	,	,	,
18637	18970	24	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	18970	25	was	be	VBD
18637	18970	26	held	hold	VBN
18637	18970	27	to	to	TO
18637	18970	28	possess	possess	VB
18637	18970	29	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18970	30	authority	authority	NN
18637	18970	31	to	to	TO
18637	18970	32	penalize	penalize	VB
18637	18970	33	the	the	DT
18637	18970	34	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	18970	35	for	for	IN
18637	18970	36	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	18970	37	in	in	IN
18637	18970	38	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	18970	39	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	18970	40	of	of	IN
18637	18970	41	citrus	citrus	NNP
18637	18970	42	fruits	fruit	NNS
18637	18970	43	so	so	RB
18637	18970	44	immature	immature	JJ
18637	18970	45	as	as	IN
18637	18970	46	to	to	TO
18637	18970	47	be	be	VB
18637	18970	48	unfit	unfit	JJ
18637	18970	49	for	for	IN
18637	18970	50	consumption	consumption	NN
18637	18970	51	.	.	.
18637	18971	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18971	2	372	372	CD
18637	18971	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18971	4	Fish	fish	NN
18637	18971	5	and	and	CC
18637	18971	6	Game	Game	NNP
18637	18971	7	Over	Over	NNP
18637	18971	8	fish	fish	NNS
18637	18971	9	found	find	VBN
18637	18971	10	within	within	IN
18637	18971	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18971	12	waters	water	NNS
18637	18971	13	,	,	,
18637	18971	14	and	and	CC
18637	18971	15	over	over	IN
18637	18971	16	wild	wild	JJ
18637	18971	17	game	game	NN
18637	18971	18	,	,	,
18637	18971	19	the	the	DT
18637	18971	20	State	State	NNP
18637	18971	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	18971	22	supreme	supreme	NNP
18637	18971	23	control	control	NN
18637	18971	24	.	.	.
18637	18972	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18972	2	373	373	CD
18637	18972	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18972	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18972	5	may	may	MD
18637	18972	6	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	18972	7	or	or	CC
18637	18972	8	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	18972	9	fishing	fishing	NN
18637	18972	10	and	and	CC
18637	18972	11	hunting	hunting	NN
18637	18972	12	within	within	IN
18637	18972	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18972	14	limits;[374	limits;[374	CD
18637	18972	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18972	16	and	and	CC
18637	18972	17	for	for	IN
18637	18972	18	the	the	DT
18637	18972	19	effective	effective	JJ
18637	18972	20	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	18972	21	of	of	IN
18637	18972	22	such	such	JJ
18637	18972	23	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	18972	24	,	,	,
18637	18972	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18972	26	may	may	MD
18637	18972	27	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	18972	28	the	the	DT
18637	18972	29	possession	possession	NN
18637	18972	30	within	within	IN
18637	18972	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18972	32	borders	border	NNS
18637	18972	33	of	of	IN
18637	18972	34	special	special	JJ
18637	18972	35	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	18972	36	of	of	IN
18637	18972	37	violations	violation	NNS
18637	18972	38	,	,	,
18637	18972	39	such	such	JJ
18637	18972	40	as	as	IN
18637	18972	41	nets	net	NNS
18637	18972	42	,	,	,
18637	18972	43	traps	trap	NNS
18637	18972	44	,	,	,
18637	18972	45	and	and	CC
18637	18972	46	seines	seine	NNS
18637	18972	47	,	,	,
18637	18972	48	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	18972	49	of	of	IN
18637	18972	50	the	the	DT
18637	18972	51	time	time	NN
18637	18972	52	of	of	IN
18637	18972	53	acquisition	acquisition	NN
18637	18972	54	or	or	CC
18637	18972	55	the	the	DT
18637	18972	56	protestations	protestation	NNS
18637	18972	57	of	of	IN
18637	18972	58	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	18972	59	intentions	intention	NNS
18637	18972	60	on	on	IN
18637	18972	61	the	the	DT
18637	18972	62	part	part	NN
18637	18972	63	of	of	IN
18637	18972	64	a	a	DT
18637	18972	65	particular	particular	JJ
18637	18972	66	possessor	possessor	NN
18637	18972	67	.	.	.
18637	18973	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18973	2	375	375	CD
18637	18973	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18973	4	To	to	TO
18637	18973	5	conserve	conserve	VB
18637	18973	6	for	for	IN
18637	18973	7	food	food	NN
18637	18973	8	fish	fish	NN
18637	18973	9	found	find	VBN
18637	18973	10	within	within	IN
18637	18973	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18973	12	waters	water	NNS
18637	18973	13	,	,	,
18637	18973	14	a	a	DT
18637	18973	15	State	state	NN
18637	18973	16	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	18973	17	may	may	MD
18637	18973	18	provide	provide	VB
18637	18973	19	that	that	IN
18637	18973	20	a	a	DT
18637	18973	21	reduction	reduction	NN
18637	18973	22	plant	plant	NN
18637	18973	23	,	,	,
18637	18973	24	processing	process	VBG
18637	18973	25	fish	fish	NN
18637	18973	26	for	for	IN
18637	18973	27	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	18973	28	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	18973	29	,	,	,
18637	18973	30	may	may	MD
18637	18973	31	not	not	RB
18637	18973	32	accept	accept	VB
18637	18973	33	more	more	JJR
18637	18973	34	fish	fish	NN
18637	18973	35	than	than	IN
18637	18973	36	can	can	MD
18637	18973	37	be	be	VB
18637	18973	38	used	use	VBN
18637	18973	39	without	without	IN
18637	18973	40	deterioration	deterioration	NN
18637	18973	41	,	,	,
18637	18973	42	waste	waste	NN
18637	18973	43	,	,	,
18637	18973	44	or	or	CC
18637	18973	45	spoilage	spoilage	NN
18637	18973	46	;	;	:
18637	18973	47	and	and	CC
18637	18973	48	,	,	,
18637	18973	49	as	as	IN
18637	18973	50	a	a	DT
18637	18973	51	shield	shield	NN
18637	18973	52	against	against	IN
18637	18973	53	the	the	DT
18637	18973	54	covert	covert	JJ
18637	18973	55	depletion	depletion	NN
18637	18973	56	of	of	IN
18637	18973	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18973	58	local	local	JJ
18637	18973	59	supply	supply	NN
18637	18973	60	,	,	,
18637	18973	61	may	may	MD
18637	18973	62	render	render	VB
18637	18973	63	such	such	JJ
18637	18973	64	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	18973	65	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	18973	66	to	to	TO
18637	18973	67	fish	fish	VB
18637	18973	68	brought	bring	VBN
18637	18973	69	into	into	IN
18637	18973	70	the	the	DT
18637	18973	71	State	state	NN
18637	18973	72	from	from	IN
18637	18973	73	the	the	DT
18637	18973	74	outside	outside	NN
18637	18973	75	.	.	.
18637	18974	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18974	2	376	376	CD
18637	18974	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18974	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	18974	5	,	,	,
18637	18974	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18974	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	18974	8	within	within	IN
18637	18974	9	the	the	DT
18637	18974	10	power	power	NN
18637	18974	11	of	of	IN
18637	18974	12	a	a	DT
18637	18974	13	State	State	NNP
18637	18974	14	to	to	TO
18637	18974	15	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	18974	16	the	the	DT
18637	18974	17	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	18974	18	outside	outside	IN
18637	18974	19	the	the	DT
18637	18974	20	State	State	NNP
18637	18974	21	of	of	IN
18637	18974	22	game	game	NN
18637	18974	23	killed	kill	VBN
18637	18974	24	therein;[377	therein;[377	CD
18637	18974	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18974	26	and	and	CC
18637	18974	27	to	to	TO
18637	18974	28	make	make	VB
18637	18974	29	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	18974	30	possession	possession	NN
18637	18974	31	during	during	IN
18637	18974	32	the	the	DT
18637	18974	33	closed	closed	JJ
18637	18974	34	season	season	NN
18637	18974	35	even	even	RB
18637	18974	36	of	of	IN
18637	18974	37	game	game	NN
18637	18974	38	imported	import	VBN
18637	18974	39	from	from	IN
18637	18974	40	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	18974	41	.	.	.
18637	18975	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18975	2	378	378	CD
18637	18975	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18975	4	LIMITATIONS	limitations	NN
18637	18975	5	ON	on	IN
18637	18975	6	OWNERSHIP	ownership	NN
18637	18975	7	Zoning	zoning	NN
18637	18975	8	,	,	,
18637	18975	9	Building	Building	NNP
18637	18975	10	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	18975	11	,	,	,
18637	18975	12	Etc	Etc	NNP
18637	18975	13	.	.	.
18637	18976	1	By	by	IN
18637	18976	2	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	18976	3	of	of	IN
18637	18976	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18976	5	possession	possession	NN
18637	18976	6	of	of	IN
18637	18976	7	the	the	DT
18637	18976	8	police	police	NN
18637	18976	9	power	power	NN
18637	18976	10	,	,	,
18637	18976	11	States	States	NNP
18637	18976	12	and	and	CC
18637	18976	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18976	14	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	18976	15	subdivisions	subdivision	NNS
18637	18976	16	may	may	MD
18637	18976	17	declare	declare	VB
18637	18976	18	that	that	IN
18637	18976	19	in	in	IN
18637	18976	20	particular	particular	JJ
18637	18976	21	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	18976	22	and	and	CC
18637	18976	23	in	in	IN
18637	18976	24	particular	particular	JJ
18637	18976	25	localities	locality	NNS
18637	18976	26	specific	specific	JJ
18637	18976	27	businesses	business	NNS
18637	18976	28	,	,	,
18637	18976	29	which	which	WDT
18637	18976	30	are	be	VBP
18637	18976	31	not	not	RB
18637	18976	32	nuisances	nuisance	NNS
18637	18976	33	_	_	NNP
18637	18976	34	per	per	FW
18637	18976	35	se	se	FW
18637	18976	36	_	_	NNP
18637	18976	37	are	be	VBP
18637	18976	38	to	to	TO
18637	18976	39	be	be	VB
18637	18976	40	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	18976	41	nuisances	nuisance	NNS
18637	18976	42	in	in	IN
18637	18976	43	fact	fact	NN
18637	18976	44	and	and	CC
18637	18976	45	in	in	IN
18637	18976	46	law	law	NN
18637	18976	47	.	.	.
18637	18977	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18977	2	379	379	CD
18637	18977	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18977	4	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	18977	5	when	when	WRB
18637	18977	6	,	,	,
18637	18977	7	by	by	IN
18637	18977	8	an	an	DT
18637	18977	9	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	18977	10	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	18977	11	in	in	IN
18637	18977	12	good	good	JJ
18637	18977	13	faith	faith	NN
18637	18977	14	,	,	,
18637	18977	15	a	a	DT
18637	18977	16	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	18977	17	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	18977	18	brickmaking	brickmaking	NN
18637	18977	19	in	in	IN
18637	18977	20	a	a	DT
18637	18977	21	designated	designate	VBN
18637	18977	22	area	area	NN
18637	18977	23	,	,	,
18637	18977	24	the	the	DT
18637	18977	25	land	land	NN
18637	18977	26	of	of	IN
18637	18977	27	a	a	DT
18637	18977	28	brickmaker	brickmaker	NN
18637	18977	29	in	in	IN
18637	18977	30	said	say	VBN
18637	18977	31	area	area	NN
18637	18977	32	was	be	VBD
18637	18977	33	not	not	RB
18637	18977	34	taken	take	VBN
18637	18977	35	without	without	IN
18637	18977	36	due	due	JJ
18637	18977	37	process	process	NN
18637	18977	38	of	of	IN
18637	18977	39	law	law	NN
18637	18977	40	,	,	,
18637	18977	41	although	although	IN
18637	18977	42	such	such	JJ
18637	18977	43	land	land	NN
18637	18977	44	contained	contain	VBD
18637	18977	45	valuable	valuable	JJ
18637	18977	46	clay	clay	NN
18637	18977	47	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	18977	48	which	which	WDT
18637	18977	49	could	could	MD
18637	18977	50	not	not	RB
18637	18977	51	profitably	profitably	RB
18637	18977	52	be	be	VB
18637	18977	53	removed	remove	VBN
18637	18977	54	for	for	IN
18637	18977	55	processing	process	VBG
18637	18977	56	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	18977	57	,	,	,
18637	18977	58	was	be	VBD
18637	18977	59	far	far	RB
18637	18977	60	more	more	RBR
18637	18977	61	valuable	valuable	JJ
18637	18977	62	for	for	IN
18637	18977	63	brickmaking	brickmake	VBG
18637	18977	64	than	than	IN
18637	18977	65	for	for	IN
18637	18977	66	any	any	DT
18637	18977	67	other	other	JJ
18637	18977	68	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	18977	69	,	,	,
18637	18977	70	and	and	CC
18637	18977	71	had	have	VBD
18637	18977	72	been	be	VBN
18637	18977	73	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	18977	74	by	by	IN
18637	18977	75	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18977	76	before	before	IN
18637	18977	77	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18977	78	was	be	VBD
18637	18977	79	annexed	annex	VBN
18637	18977	80	to	to	IN
18637	18977	81	the	the	DT
18637	18977	82	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	18977	83	,	,	,
18637	18977	84	and	and	CC
18637	18977	85	had	have	VBD
18637	18977	86	long	long	RB
18637	18977	87	been	be	VBN
18637	18977	88	used	use	VBN
18637	18977	89	as	as	IN
18637	18977	90	a	a	DT
18637	18977	91	brickyard	brickyard	NN
18637	18977	92	.	.	.
18637	18978	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18978	2	380	380	CD
18637	18978	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18978	4	On	on	IN
18637	18978	5	the	the	DT
18637	18978	6	same	same	JJ
18637	18978	7	basis	basis	NN
18637	18978	8	laws	law	NNS
18637	18978	9	have	have	VBP
18637	18978	10	been	be	VBN
18637	18978	11	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	18978	12	which	which	WDT
18637	18978	13	restricted	restrict	VBD
18637	18978	14	the	the	DT
18637	18978	15	location	location	NN
18637	18978	16	of	of	IN
18637	18978	17	dairy	dairy	NN
18637	18978	18	or	or	CC
18637	18978	19	cow	cow	NN
18637	18978	20	stables,[381	stables,[381	NN
18637	18978	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18978	22	of	of	IN
18637	18978	23	livery	livery	NN
18637	18978	24	stables,[382	stables,[382	NN
18637	18978	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18978	26	of	of	IN
18637	18978	27	the	the	DT
18637	18978	28	grazing	grazing	NN
18637	18978	29	of	of	IN
18637	18978	30	sheep	sheep	NN
18637	18978	31	near	near	IN
18637	18978	32	habitations	habitation	NNS
18637	18978	33	.	.	.
18637	18979	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18979	2	383	383	CD
18637	18979	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18979	4	Also	also	RB
18637	18979	5	a	a	DT
18637	18979	6	State	state	NN
18637	18979	7	may	may	MD
18637	18979	8	declare	declare	VB
18637	18979	9	the	the	DT
18637	18979	10	emission	emission	NN
18637	18979	11	of	of	IN
18637	18979	12	dense	dense	JJ
18637	18979	13	smoke	smoke	NN
18637	18979	14	in	in	IN
18637	18979	15	cities	city	NNS
18637	18979	16	or	or	CC
18637	18979	17	populous	populous	JJ
18637	18979	18	neighborhoods	neighborhood	NNS
18637	18979	19	a	a	DT
18637	18979	20	nuisance	nuisance	NN
18637	18979	21	and	and	CC
18637	18979	22	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	18979	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18979	24	;	;	:
18637	18979	25	and	and	CC
18637	18979	26	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18979	27	to	to	IN
18637	18979	28	that	that	DT
18637	18979	29	effect	effect	NN
18637	18979	30	are	be	VBP
18637	18979	31	not	not	RB
18637	18979	32	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	18979	33	even	even	RB
18637	18979	34	though	though	IN
18637	18979	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18979	36	affect	affect	VBP
18637	18979	37	the	the	DT
18637	18979	38	use	use	NN
18637	18979	39	of	of	IN
18637	18979	40	property	property	NN
18637	18979	41	or	or	CC
18637	18979	42	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18979	43	the	the	DT
18637	18979	44	owner	owner	NN
18637	18979	45	to	to	IN
18637	18979	46	the	the	DT
18637	18979	47	expense	expense	NN
18637	18979	48	of	of	IN
18637	18979	49	complying	comply	VBG
18637	18979	50	with	with	IN
18637	18979	51	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18979	52	terms	term	NNS
18637	18979	53	.	.	.
18637	18980	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18980	2	384	384	CD
18637	18980	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18980	4	Not	not	RB
18637	18980	5	only	only	RB
18637	18980	6	may	may	MD
18637	18980	7	the	the	DT
18637	18980	8	height	height	NN
18637	18980	9	of	of	IN
18637	18980	10	buildings	building	NNS
18637	18980	11	be	be	VB
18637	18980	12	regulated;[385	regulated;[385	ADD
18637	18980	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18980	14	but	but	CC
18637	18980	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18980	16	also	also	RB
18637	18980	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	18980	18	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	18980	19	to	to	TO
18637	18980	20	create	create	VB
18637	18980	21	a	a	DT
18637	18980	22	residential	residential	JJ
18637	18980	23	district	district	NN
18637	18980	24	in	in	IN
18637	18980	25	a	a	DT
18637	18980	26	village	village	NN
18637	18980	27	and	and	CC
18637	18980	28	to	to	TO
18637	18980	29	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	18980	30	therefrom	therefrom	JJ
18637	18980	31	apartment	apartment	NN
18637	18980	32	houses	house	NNS
18637	18980	33	,	,	,
18637	18980	34	retail	retail	JJ
18637	18980	35	stores	store	NNS
18637	18980	36	,	,	,
18637	18980	37	and	and	CC
18637	18980	38	billboards	billboard	NNS
18637	18980	39	.	.	.
18637	18981	1	Before	before	IN
18637	18981	2	holding	hold	VBG
18637	18981	3	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	18981	4	an	an	DT
18637	18981	5	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	18981	6	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	18981	7	such	such	PDT
18637	18981	8	a	a	DT
18637	18981	9	district	district	NN
18637	18981	10	,	,	,
18637	18981	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18981	12	must	must	MD
18637	18981	13	be	be	VB
18637	18981	14	shown	show	VBN
18637	18981	15	to	to	TO
18637	18981	16	be	be	VB
18637	18981	17	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	18981	18	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18981	19	and	and	CC
18637	18981	20	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18981	21	and	and	CC
18637	18981	22	to	to	TO
18637	18981	23	have	have	VB
18637	18981	24	no	no	DT
18637	18981	25	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	18981	26	relation	relation	NN
18637	18981	27	to	to	IN
18637	18981	28	the	the	DT
18637	18981	29	public	public	JJ
18637	18981	30	health	health	NN
18637	18981	31	,	,	,
18637	18981	32	safety	safety	NN
18637	18981	33	,	,	,
18637	18981	34	or	or	CC
18637	18981	35	general	general	JJ
18637	18981	36	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	18981	37	.	.	.
18637	18982	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18982	2	386	386	CD
18637	18982	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18982	4	On	on	IN
18637	18982	5	the	the	DT
18637	18982	6	other	other	JJ
18637	18982	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	18982	8	,	,	,
18637	18982	9	erection	erection	NN
18637	18982	10	of	of	IN
18637	18982	11	a	a	DT
18637	18982	12	home	home	NN
18637	18982	13	for	for	IN
18637	18982	14	the	the	DT
18637	18982	15	aged	age	VBN
18637	18982	16	within	within	IN
18637	18982	17	a	a	DT
18637	18982	18	residential	residential	JJ
18637	18982	19	district	district	NN
18637	18982	20	can	can	MD
18637	18982	21	not	not	RB
18637	18982	22	be	be	VB
18637	18982	23	made	make	VBN
18637	18982	24	to	to	TO
18637	18982	25	depend	depend	VB
18637	18982	26	upon	upon	IN
18637	18982	27	the	the	DT
18637	18982	28	consent	consent	NN
18637	18982	29	of	of	IN
18637	18982	30	owners	owner	NNS
18637	18982	31	of	of	IN
18637	18982	32	two	two	CD
18637	18982	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	18982	34	thirds	third	NNS
18637	18982	35	of	of	IN
18637	18982	36	the	the	DT
18637	18982	37	property	property	NN
18637	18982	38	within	within	IN
18637	18982	39	400	400	CD
18637	18982	40	feet	foot	NNS
18637	18982	41	of	of	IN
18637	18982	42	the	the	DT
18637	18982	43	site	site	NN
18637	18982	44	thereof;[387	thereof;[387	NFP
18637	18982	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18982	46	nor	nor	CC
18637	18982	47	may	may	MD
18637	18982	48	the	the	DT
18637	18982	49	interests	interest	NNS
18637	18982	50	of	of	IN
18637	18982	51	nonassenting	nonassente	VBG
18637	18982	52	property	property	NN
18637	18982	53	owners	owner	NNS
18637	18982	54	be	be	VB
18637	18982	55	ignored	ignore	VBN
18637	18982	56	by	by	IN
18637	18982	57	an	an	DT
18637	18982	58	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	18982	59	which	which	WDT
18637	18982	60	requires	require	VBZ
18637	18982	61	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	18982	62	officers	officer	NNS
18637	18982	63	to	to	TO
18637	18982	64	establish	establish	VB
18637	18982	65	building	building	NN
18637	18982	66	lines	line	NNS
18637	18982	67	in	in	IN
18637	18982	68	a	a	DT
18637	18982	69	block	block	NN
18637	18982	70	on	on	IN
18637	18982	71	request	request	NN
18637	18982	72	of	of	IN
18637	18982	73	owners	owner	NNS
18637	18982	74	of	of	IN
18637	18982	75	two	two	CD
18637	18982	76	-	-	HYPH
18637	18982	77	thirds	third	NNS
18637	18982	78	of	of	IN
18637	18982	79	the	the	DT
18637	18982	80	property	property	NN
18637	18982	81	therein	therein	RB
18637	18982	82	.	.	.
18637	18983	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18983	2	388	388	CD
18637	18983	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18983	4	But	but	CC
18637	18983	5	ordinances	ordinance	NNS
18637	18983	6	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18983	7	lot	lot	NN
18637	18983	8	owners	owner	NNS
18637	18983	9	,	,	,
18637	18983	10	when	when	WRB
18637	18983	11	constructing	construct	VBG
18637	18983	12	new	new	JJ
18637	18983	13	buildings	building	NNS
18637	18983	14	,	,	,
18637	18983	15	to	to	TO
18637	18983	16	set	set	VB
18637	18983	17	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18983	18	back	back	RP
18637	18983	19	a	a	DT
18637	18983	20	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18983	21	distance	distance	NN
18637	18983	22	from	from	IN
18637	18983	23	the	the	DT
18637	18983	24	street	street	NN
18637	18983	25	lines	line	NNS
18637	18983	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	18983	27	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18983	28	unless	unless	IN
18637	18983	29	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	18983	30	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	18983	31	or	or	CC
18637	18983	32	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	18983	33	.	.	.
18637	18984	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18984	2	389	389	CD
18637	18984	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18984	4	However	however	RB
18637	18984	5	,	,	,
18637	18984	6	colored	color	VBN
18637	18984	7	persons	person	NNS
18637	18984	8	can	can	MD
18637	18984	9	not	not	RB
18637	18984	10	be	be	VB
18637	18984	11	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	18984	12	to	to	TO
18637	18984	13	occupy	occupy	VB
18637	18984	14	houses	house	NNS
18637	18984	15	in	in	IN
18637	18984	16	blocks	block	NNS
18637	18984	17	where	where	WRB
18637	18984	18	the	the	DT
18637	18984	19	greater	great	JJR
18637	18984	20	number	number	NN
18637	18984	21	of	of	IN
18637	18984	22	houses	house	NNS
18637	18984	23	are	be	VBP
18637	18984	24	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	18984	25	by	by	IN
18637	18984	26	white	white	JJ
18637	18984	27	persons	person	NNS
18637	18984	28	,	,	,
18637	18984	29	and	and	CC
18637	18984	30	vice	vice	NN
18637	18984	31	versa	versa	RB
18637	18984	32	.	.	.
18637	18985	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	18985	2	a	a	DT
18637	18985	3	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	18985	4	,	,	,
18637	18985	5	the	the	DT
18637	18985	6	practical	practical	JJ
18637	18985	7	effect	effect	NN
18637	18985	8	of	of	IN
18637	18985	9	which	which	WDT
18637	18985	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	18985	11	to	to	TO
18637	18985	12	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18985	13	the	the	DT
18637	18985	14	sale	sale	NN
18637	18985	15	of	of	IN
18637	18985	16	lots	lot	NNS
18637	18985	17	in	in	IN
18637	18985	18	such	such	JJ
18637	18985	19	blocks	block	NNS
18637	18985	20	to	to	IN
18637	18985	21	colored	colored	JJ
18637	18985	22	persons	person	NNS
18637	18985	23	,	,	,
18637	18985	24	violates	violate	VBZ
18637	18985	25	the	the	DT
18637	18985	26	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	18985	27	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
18637	18985	28	against	against	IN
18637	18985	29	interference	interference	NN
18637	18985	30	with	with	IN
18637	18985	31	property	property	NN
18637	18985	32	rights	right	NNS
18637	18985	33	except	except	IN
18637	18985	34	by	by	IN
18637	18985	35	due	due	JJ
18637	18985	36	process	process	NN
18637	18985	37	of	of	IN
18637	18985	38	laws	law	NNS
18637	18985	39	;	;	:
18637	18985	40	and	and	CC
18637	18985	41	can	can	MD
18637	18985	42	not	not	RB
18637	18985	43	be	be	VB
18637	18985	44	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18985	45	on	on	IN
18637	18985	46	the	the	DT
18637	18985	47	ground	ground	NN
18637	18985	48	that	that	IN
18637	18985	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18985	50	will	will	MD
18637	18985	51	promote	promote	VB
18637	18985	52	public	public	JJ
18637	18985	53	peace	peace	NN
18637	18985	54	by	by	IN
18637	18985	55	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	18985	56	race	race	NN
18637	18985	57	conflicts	conflict	NNS
18637	18985	58	.	.	.
18637	18986	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18986	2	390	390	CD
18637	18986	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18986	4	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	18986	5	Regulations	Regulations	NNPS
18637	18986	6	As	as	IN
18637	18986	7	a	a	DT
18637	18986	8	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	18986	9	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18986	10	of	of	IN
18637	18986	11	the	the	DT
18637	18986	12	police	police	NN
18637	18986	13	power	power	NN
18637	18986	14	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	18986	15	to	to	TO
18637	18986	16	promote	promote	VB
18637	18986	17	public	public	JJ
18637	18986	18	safety	safety	NN
18637	18986	19	and	and	CC
18637	18986	20	diminish	diminish	JJ
18637	18986	21	fire	fire	NN
18637	18986	22	hazards	hazard	NNS
18637	18986	23	,	,	,
18637	18986	24	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	18986	25	ordinances	ordinance	NNS
18637	18986	26	have	have	VBP
18637	18986	27	been	be	VBN
18637	18986	28	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18986	29	which	which	WDT
18637	18986	30	prohibit	prohibit	NN
18637	18986	31	the	the	DT
18637	18986	32	storage	storage	NN
18637	18986	33	of	of	IN
18637	18986	34	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	18986	35	within	within	IN
18637	18986	36	300	300	CD
18637	18986	37	feet	foot	NNS
18637	18986	38	of	of	IN
18637	18986	39	any	any	DT
18637	18986	40	dwelling,[391	dwelling,[391	NN
18637	18986	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18986	42	or	or	CC
18637	18986	43	require	require	VB
18637	18986	44	that	that	IN
18637	18986	45	all	all	DT
18637	18986	46	tanks	tank	NNS
18637	18986	47	with	with	IN
18637	18986	48	a	a	DT
18637	18986	49	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	18986	50	of	of	IN
18637	18986	51	more	more	JJR
18637	18986	52	than	than	IN
18637	18986	53	ten	ten	CD
18637	18986	54	gallons	gallon	NNS
18637	18986	55	,	,	,
18637	18986	56	used	use	VBN
18637	18986	57	for	for	IN
18637	18986	58	the	the	DT
18637	18986	59	storage	storage	NN
18637	18986	60	of	of	IN
18637	18986	61	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	18986	62	,	,	,
18637	18986	63	be	be	VB
18637	18986	64	buried	bury	VBN
18637	18986	65	at	at	RB
18637	18986	66	least	least	RBS
18637	18986	67	three	three	CD
18637	18986	68	feet	foot	NNS
18637	18986	69	under	under	IN
18637	18986	70	ground,[392	ground,[392	NN
18637	18986	71	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18986	72	or	or	CC
18637	18986	73	which	which	WDT
18637	18986	74	prohibit	prohibit	VBP
18637	18986	75	washing	washing	NN
18637	18986	76	and	and	CC
18637	18986	77	ironing	iron	VBG
18637	18986	78	in	in	IN
18637	18986	79	public	public	JJ
18637	18986	80	laundries	laundry	NNS
18637	18986	81	and	and	CC
18637	18986	82	wash	wash	VB
18637	18986	83	houses	house	NNS
18637	18986	84	,	,	,
18637	18986	85	within	within	IN
18637	18986	86	defined	define	VBN
18637	18986	87	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	18986	88	limits	limit	NNS
18637	18986	89	,	,	,
18637	18986	90	from	from	IN
18637	18986	91	10	10	CD
18637	18986	92	p.m.	p.m.	NN
18637	18986	93	to	to	IN
18637	18986	94	6	6	CD
18637	18986	95	a.m.[393	a.m.[393	NNS
18637	18986	96	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18986	97	Equally	equally	RB
18637	18986	98	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
18637	18986	99	by	by	IN
18637	18986	100	the	the	DT
18637	18986	101	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	18986	102	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	18986	103	is	be	VBZ
18637	18986	104	the	the	DT
18637	18986	105	demolition	demolition	NN
18637	18986	106	and	and	CC
18637	18986	107	removal	removal	NN
18637	18986	108	by	by	IN
18637	18986	109	cities	city	NNS
18637	18986	110	of	of	IN
18637	18986	111	wooden	wooden	JJ
18637	18986	112	buildings	building	NNS
18637	18986	113	erected	erect	VBN
18637	18986	114	within	within	IN
18637	18986	115	defined	define	VBN
18637	18986	116	fire	fire	NN
18637	18986	117	limits	limit	NNS
18637	18986	118	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	18986	119	to	to	IN
18637	18986	120	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18986	121	in	in	IN
18637	18986	122	force	force	NN
18637	18986	123	at	at	IN
18637	18986	124	the	the	DT
18637	18986	125	time	time	NN
18637	18986	126	.	.	.
18637	18987	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18987	2	394	394	CD
18637	18987	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18987	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	18987	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	18987	6	construction	construction	NN
18637	18987	7	of	of	IN
18637	18987	8	property	property	NN
18637	18987	9	in	in	IN
18637	18987	10	full	full	JJ
18637	18987	11	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	18987	12	with	with	IN
18637	18987	13	existing	existing	JJ
18637	18987	14	laws	law	NNS
18637	18987	15	confer	confer	VBP
18637	18987	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	18987	17	the	the	DT
18637	18987	18	owner	owner	NN
18637	18987	19	an	an	DT
18637	18987	20	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	18987	21	against	against	IN
18637	18987	22	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18987	23	of	of	IN
18637	18987	24	the	the	DT
18637	18987	25	police	police	NN
18637	18987	26	power	power	NN
18637	18987	27	.	.	.
18637	18988	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	18988	2	,	,	,
18637	18988	3	a	a	DT
18637	18988	4	1944	1944	CD
18637	18988	5	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	18988	6	to	to	IN
18637	18988	7	a	a	DT
18637	18988	8	Multiple	Multiple	NNP
18637	18988	9	Dwelling	Dwelling	NNP
18637	18988	10	Law	Law	NNP
18637	18988	11	,	,	,
18637	18988	12	requiring	require	VBG
18637	18988	13	installation	installation	NN
18637	18988	14	of	of	IN
18637	18988	15	automatic	automatic	JJ
18637	18988	16	sprinklers	sprinkler	NNS
18637	18988	17	in	in	IN
18637	18988	18	lodginghouses	lodginghouse	NNS
18637	18988	19	of	of	IN
18637	18988	20	nonfireproof	nonfireproof	JJ
18637	18988	21	construction	construction	NN
18637	18988	22	erected	erect	VBN
18637	18988	23	prior	prior	RB
18637	18988	24	to	to	IN
18637	18988	25	said	say	VBD
18637	18988	26	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	18988	27	,	,	,
18637	18988	28	does	do	VBZ
18637	18988	29	not	not	RB
18637	18988	30	,	,	,
18637	18988	31	as	as	IN
18637	18988	32	applied	apply	VBN
18637	18988	33	to	to	IN
18637	18988	34	a	a	DT
18637	18988	35	lodginghouse	lodginghouse	NN
18637	18988	36	constructed	construct	VBN
18637	18988	37	in	in	IN
18637	18988	38	1940	1940	CD
18637	18988	39	in	in	IN
18637	18988	40	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	18988	41	with	with	IN
18637	18988	42	all	all	DT
18637	18988	43	laws	law	NNS
18637	18988	44	then	then	RB
18637	18988	45	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	18988	46	,	,	,
18637	18988	47	deprive	deprive	VBP
18637	18988	48	the	the	DT
18637	18988	49	owner	owner	NN
18637	18988	50	thereof	thereof	IN
18637	18988	51	of	of	IN
18637	18988	52	due	due	JJ
18637	18988	53	process	process	NN
18637	18988	54	,	,	,
18637	18988	55	even	even	RB
18637	18988	56	though	though	IN
18637	18988	57	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	18988	58	entails	entail	VBZ
18637	18988	59	an	an	DT
18637	18988	60	expenditure	expenditure	NN
18637	18988	61	of	of	IN
18637	18988	62	$	$	$
18637	18988	63	7,500	7,500	CD
18637	18988	64	on	on	IN
18637	18988	65	a	a	DT
18637	18988	66	property	property	NN
18637	18988	67	worth	worth	NN
18637	18988	68	only	only	RB
18637	18988	69	$	$	$
18637	18988	70	25,000	25,000	CD
18637	18988	71	.	.	.
18637	18989	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18989	2	395	395	CD
18637	18989	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18989	4	THE	THE	NNP
18637	18989	5	POLICE	police	NN
18637	18989	6	POWER	POWER	NNP
18637	18989	7	General	General	NNP
18637	18989	8	According	accord	VBG
18637	18989	9	to	to	IN
18637	18989	10	settled	settle	VBN
18637	18989	11	principles	principle	NNS
18637	18989	12	,	,	,
18637	18989	13	the	the	DT
18637	18989	14	police	police	NN
18637	18989	15	power	power	NN
18637	18989	16	of	of	IN
18637	18989	17	a	a	DT
18637	18989	18	State	State	NNP
18637	18989	19	must	must	MD
18637	18989	20	be	be	VB
18637	18989	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	18989	22	to	to	TO
18637	18989	23	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	18989	24	the	the	DT
18637	18989	25	authority	authority	NN
18637	18989	26	not	not	RB
18637	18989	27	only	only	RB
18637	18989	28	to	to	TO
18637	18989	29	enact	enact	VB
18637	18989	30	directly	directly	RB
18637	18989	31	quarantine[396	quarantine[396	VB
18637	18989	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18989	33	and	and	CC
18637	18989	34	health	health	NN
18637	18989	35	laws	law	NNS
18637	18989	36	of	of	IN
18637	18989	37	every	every	DT
18637	18989	38	description	description	NN
18637	18989	39	but	but	CC
18637	18989	40	also	also	RB
18637	18989	41	to	to	TO
18637	18989	42	vest	vest	VB
18637	18989	43	in	in	IN
18637	18989	44	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	18989	45	subdivisions	subdivision	NNS
18637	18989	46	a	a	DT
18637	18989	47	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	18989	48	to	to	TO
18637	18989	49	safeguard	safeguard	VB
18637	18989	50	by	by	IN
18637	18989	51	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	18989	52	means	mean	VBZ
18637	18989	53	public	public	JJ
18637	18989	54	health	health	NN
18637	18989	55	,	,	,
18637	18989	56	safety	safety	NN
18637	18989	57	and	and	CC
18637	18989	58	morals	moral	NNS
18637	18989	59	.	.	.
18637	18990	1	The	the	DT
18637	18990	2	manner	manner	NN
18637	18990	3	in	in	IN
18637	18990	4	which	which	WDT
18637	18990	5	this	this	DT
18637	18990	6	objective	objective	NN
18637	18990	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	18990	8	to	to	TO
18637	18990	9	be	be	VB
18637	18990	10	accomplished	accomplish	VBN
18637	18990	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	18990	12	within	within	IN
18637	18990	13	the	the	DT
18637	18990	14	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	18990	15	of	of	IN
18637	18990	16	the	the	DT
18637	18990	17	State	State	NNP
18637	18990	18	and	and	CC
18637	18990	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18990	20	localities	locality	NNS
18637	18990	21	,	,	,
18637	18990	22	subject	subject	JJ
18637	18990	23	only	only	RB
18637	18990	24	to	to	IN
18637	18990	25	the	the	DT
18637	18990	26	condition	condition	NN
18637	18990	27	that	that	IN
18637	18990	28	no	no	DT
18637	18990	29	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	18990	30	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	18990	31	by	by	IN
18637	18990	32	either	either	DT
18637	18990	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	18990	34	contravene	contravene	VB
18637	18990	35	the	the	DT
18637	18990	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	18990	37	or	or	CC
18637	18990	38	infringe	infringe	VB
18637	18990	39	any	any	RB
18637	18990	40	right	right	NN
18637	18990	41	granted	grant	VBN
18637	18990	42	or	or	CC
18637	18990	43	secured	secure	VBN
18637	18990	44	by	by	IN
18637	18990	45	that	that	DT
18637	18990	46	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	18990	47	.	.	.
18637	18991	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18991	2	397	397	CD
18637	18991	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18991	4	Health	Health	NNP
18637	18991	5	Measures	Measures	NNPS
18637	18991	6	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	18991	7	of	of	IN
18637	18991	8	Water	Water	NNP
18637	18991	9	Supply.--A	supply.--a	NN
18637	18991	10	State	State	NNP
18637	18991	11	may	may	MD
18637	18991	12	require	require	VB
18637	18991	13	the	the	DT
18637	18991	14	removal	removal	NN
18637	18991	15	of	of	IN
18637	18991	16	timber	timber	NN
18637	18991	17	refuse	refuse	NN
18637	18991	18	from	from	IN
18637	18991	19	the	the	DT
18637	18991	20	vicinity	vicinity	NN
18637	18991	21	of	of	IN
18637	18991	22	a	a	DT
18637	18991	23	watershed	watershed	NN
18637	18991	24	for	for	IN
18637	18991	25	a	a	DT
18637	18991	26	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	18991	27	water	water	NN
18637	18991	28	supply	supply	NN
18637	18991	29	to	to	TO
18637	18991	30	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18991	31	the	the	DT
18637	18991	32	spread	spread	NN
18637	18991	33	of	of	IN
18637	18991	34	fire	fire	NN
18637	18991	35	and	and	CC
18637	18991	36	consequent	consequent	JJ
18637	18991	37	damage	damage	NN
18637	18991	38	to	to	IN
18637	18991	39	such	such	JJ
18637	18991	40	watershed	watershed	NN
18637	18991	41	.	.	.
18637	18992	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18992	2	398	398	CD
18637	18992	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18992	4	Garbage.--An	Garbage.--An	VBG
18637	18992	5	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	18992	6	for	for	IN
18637	18992	7	cremation	cremation	NN
18637	18992	8	of	of	IN
18637	18992	9	garbage	garbage	NN
18637	18992	10	and	and	CC
18637	18992	11	refuse	refuse	VBP
18637	18992	12	at	at	IN
18637	18992	13	a	a	DT
18637	18992	14	designated	designate	VBN
18637	18992	15	place	place	NN
18637	18992	16	as	as	IN
18637	18992	17	a	a	DT
18637	18992	18	means	means	NN
18637	18992	19	for	for	IN
18637	18992	20	the	the	DT
18637	18992	21	protection	protection	NN
18637	18992	22	of	of	IN
18637	18992	23	the	the	DT
18637	18992	24	public	public	JJ
18637	18992	25	health	health	NN
18637	18992	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	18992	27	not	not	RB
18637	18992	28	a	a	DT
18637	18992	29	taking	taking	NN
18637	18992	30	of	of	IN
18637	18992	31	private	private	JJ
18637	18992	32	property	property	NN
18637	18992	33	without	without	IN
18637	18992	34	just	just	RB
18637	18992	35	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	18992	36	even	even	RB
18637	18992	37	though	though	IN
18637	18992	38	such	such	JJ
18637	18992	39	garbage	garbage	NN
18637	18992	40	and	and	CC
18637	18992	41	refuse	refuse	NN
18637	18992	42	may	may	MD
18637	18992	43	have	have	VB
18637	18992	44	some	some	DT
18637	18992	45	elements	element	NNS
18637	18992	46	of	of	IN
18637	18992	47	value	value	NN
18637	18992	48	for	for	IN
18637	18992	49	certain	certain	JJ
18637	18992	50	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	18992	51	.	.	.
18637	18993	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18993	2	399	399	CD
18637	18993	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18993	4	Sewers.--Compelling	sewers.--compelle	VBG
18637	18993	5	property	property	NN
18637	18993	6	owners	owner	NNS
18637	18993	7	to	to	TO
18637	18993	8	connect	connect	VB
18637	18993	9	with	with	IN
18637	18993	10	a	a	DT
18637	18993	11	publicly	publicly	RB
18637	18993	12	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	18993	13	system	system	NN
18637	18993	14	of	of	IN
18637	18993	15	sewers	sewer	NNS
18637	18993	16	and	and	CC
18637	18993	17	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	18993	18	that	that	DT
18637	18993	19	duty	duty	NN
18637	18993	20	by	by	IN
18637	18993	21	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	18993	22	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	18993	23	does	do	VBZ
18637	18993	24	not	not	RB
18637	18993	25	violate	violate	VB
18637	18993	26	the	the	DT
18637	18993	27	due	due	JJ
18637	18993	28	process	process	NN
18637	18993	29	clause	clause	NN
18637	18993	30	.	.	.
18637	18994	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18994	2	400	400	CD
18637	18994	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18994	4	Food	Food	NNP
18637	18994	5	and	and	CC
18637	18994	6	Drugs	Drugs	NNPS
18637	18994	7	,	,	,
18637	18994	8	Etc.--"The	etc.--"the	CD
18637	18994	9	power	power	NN
18637	18994	10	of	of	IN
18637	18994	11	the	the	DT
18637	18994	12	State	State	NNP
18637	18994	13	to	to	TO
18637	18994	14	*	*	NFP
18637	18994	15	*	*	NFP
18637	18994	16	*	*	NFP
18637	18994	17	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	18994	18	the	the	DT
18637	18994	19	production	production	NN
18637	18994	20	within	within	IN
18637	18994	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18994	22	borders	border	NNS
18637	18994	23	of	of	IN
18637	18994	24	impure	impure	NN
18637	18994	25	foods	food	NNS
18637	18994	26	,	,	,
18637	18994	27	unfit	unfit	JJ
18637	18994	28	for	for	IN
18637	18994	29	use	use	NN
18637	18994	30	,	,	,
18637	18994	31	and	and	CC
18637	18994	32	such	such	JJ
18637	18994	33	articles	article	NNS
18637	18994	34	as	as	IN
18637	18994	35	would	would	MD
18637	18994	36	spread	spread	VB
18637	18994	37	disease	disease	NN
18637	18994	38	and	and	CC
18637	18994	39	pestilence	pestilence	NN
18637	18994	40	,	,	,
18637	18994	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	18994	42	well	well	RB
18637	18994	43	established";[401	established";[401	.
18637	18994	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18994	45	and	and	CC
18637	18994	46	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18994	47	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	18994	48	or	or	CC
18637	18994	49	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	18994	50	the	the	DT
18637	18994	51	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	18994	52	of	of	IN
18637	18994	53	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
18637	18994	54	have	have	VBP
18637	18994	55	been	be	VBN
18637	18994	56	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	18994	57	as	as	IN
18637	18994	58	a	a	DT
18637	18994	59	valid	valid	JJ
18637	18994	60	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	18994	61	of	of	IN
18637	18994	62	such	such	JJ
18637	18994	63	power	power	NN
18637	18994	64	.	.	.
18637	18995	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18995	2	402	402	CD
18637	18995	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18995	4	For	for	IN
18637	18995	5	the	the	DT
18637	18995	6	same	same	JJ
18637	18995	7	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	18995	8	,	,	,
18637	18995	9	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	18995	10	ordering	order	VBG
18637	18995	11	the	the	DT
18637	18995	12	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	18995	13	of	of	IN
18637	18995	14	unsafe	unsafe	JJ
18637	18995	15	and	and	CC
18637	18995	16	unwholesome	unwholesome	JJ
18637	18995	17	food[403	food[403	NN
18637	18995	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18995	19	,	,	,
18637	18995	20	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	18995	21	the	the	DT
18637	18995	22	sale	sale	NN
18637	18995	23	and	and	CC
18637	18995	24	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	18995	25	confiscation	confiscation	NN
18637	18995	26	of	of	IN
18637	18995	27	impure	impure	NN
18637	18995	28	milk[404	milk[404	NN
18637	18995	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18995	30	have	have	VBP
18637	18995	31	been	be	VBN
18637	18995	32	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	18995	33	,	,	,
18637	18995	34	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	18995	35	that	that	IN
18637	18995	36	such	such	JJ
18637	18995	37	articles	article	NNS
18637	18995	38	had	have	VBD
18637	18995	39	a	a	DT
18637	18995	40	value	value	NN
18637	18995	41	for	for	IN
18637	18995	42	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	18995	43	other	other	JJ
18637	18995	44	than	than	IN
18637	18995	45	food	food	NN
18637	18995	46	.	.	.
18637	18996	1	There	there	EX
18637	18996	2	also	also	RB
18637	18996	3	can	can	MD
18637	18996	4	be	be	VB
18637	18996	5	no	no	DT
18637	18996	6	question	question	NN
18637	18996	7	of	of	IN
18637	18996	8	the	the	DT
18637	18996	9	authority	authority	NN
18637	18996	10	of	of	IN
18637	18996	11	the	the	DT
18637	18996	12	State	State	NNP
18637	18996	13	,	,	,
18637	18996	14	in	in	IN
18637	18996	15	the	the	DT
18637	18996	16	interest	interest	NN
18637	18996	17	of	of	IN
18637	18996	18	public	public	JJ
18637	18996	19	health	health	NN
18637	18996	20	and	and	CC
18637	18996	21	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	18996	22	,	,	,
18637	18996	23	to	to	TO
18637	18996	24	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	18996	25	the	the	DT
18637	18996	26	sale	sale	NN
18637	18996	27	of	of	IN
18637	18996	28	drugs	drug	NNS
18637	18996	29	by	by	IN
18637	18996	30	itinerant	itinerant	JJ
18637	18996	31	vendors,[405	vendors,[405	NNP
18637	18996	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18996	33	or	or	CC
18637	18996	34	the	the	DT
18637	18996	35	sale	sale	NN
18637	18996	36	of	of	IN
18637	18996	37	spectacles	spectacle	NNS
18637	18996	38	by	by	IN
18637	18996	39	an	an	DT
18637	18996	40	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	18996	41	not	not	RB
18637	18996	42	in	in	IN
18637	18996	43	charge	charge	NN
18637	18996	44	of	of	IN
18637	18996	45	a	a	DT
18637	18996	46	physician	physician	NN
18637	18996	47	or	or	CC
18637	18996	48	optometrist	optometrist	NN
18637	18996	49	.	.	.
18637	18997	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18997	2	406	406	CD
18637	18997	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18997	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	18997	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	18997	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	18997	7	any	any	RB
18637	18997	8	longer	long	RBR
18637	18997	9	possible	possible	JJ
18637	18997	10	to	to	TO
18637	18997	11	doubt	doubt	VB
18637	18997	12	the	the	DT
18637	18997	13	validity	validity	NN
18637	18997	14	of	of	IN
18637	18997	15	State	State	NNP
18637	18997	16	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18997	17	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	18997	18	to	to	IN
18637	18997	19	the	the	DT
18637	18997	20	administration	administration	NN
18637	18997	21	,	,	,
18637	18997	22	sale	sale	NN
18637	18997	23	,	,	,
18637	18997	24	prescription	prescription	NN
18637	18997	25	,	,	,
18637	18997	26	and	and	CC
18637	18997	27	use	use	NN
18637	18997	28	of	of	IN
18637	18997	29	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	18997	30	and	and	CC
18637	18997	31	habit	habit	NN
18637	18997	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	18997	33	forming	form	VBG
18637	18997	34	drugs	drug	NNS
18637	18997	35	.	.	.
18637	18998	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18998	2	407	407	CD
18637	18998	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18998	4	Milk.--Equally	milk.--equally	RB
18637	18998	5	valid	valid	JJ
18637	18998	6	as	as	IN
18637	18998	7	police	police	NN
18637	18998	8	power	power	NN
18637	18998	9	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	18998	10	are	be	VBP
18637	18998	11	laws	law	NNS
18637	18998	12	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	18998	13	the	the	DT
18637	18998	14	sale	sale	NN
18637	18998	15	of	of	IN
18637	18998	16	ice	ice	NN
18637	18998	17	cream	cream	NN
18637	18998	18	not	not	RB
18637	18998	19	containing	contain	VBG
18637	18998	20	a	a	DT
18637	18998	21	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	18998	22	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	18998	23	of	of	IN
18637	18998	24	butter	butter	NN
18637	18998	25	fat,[408	fat,[408	NNS
18637	18998	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18998	27	or	or	CC
18637	18998	28	of	of	IN
18637	18998	29	condensed	condense	VBN
18637	18998	30	milk	milk	NN
18637	18998	31	made	make	VBN
18637	18998	32	from	from	IN
18637	18998	33	skimmed	skim	VBN
18637	18998	34	milk	milk	NN
18637	18998	35	rather	rather	RB
18637	18998	36	than	than	IN
18637	18998	37	whole	whole	JJ
18637	18998	38	milk,[409	milk,[409	NN
18637	18998	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18998	40	or	or	CC
18637	18998	41	of	of	IN
18637	18998	42	food	food	NN
18637	18998	43	preservatives	preservative	NNS
18637	18998	44	containing	contain	VBG
18637	18998	45	boric	boric	NN
18637	18998	46	acid	acid	NN
18637	18998	47	.	.	.
18637	18999	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	18999	2	410	410	CD
18637	18999	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	18999	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	18999	5	,	,	,
18637	18999	6	a	a	DT
18637	18999	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	18999	8	which	which	WDT
18637	18999	9	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	18999	10	the	the	DT
18637	18999	11	sale	sale	NN
18637	18999	12	of	of	IN
18637	18999	13	milk	milk	NN
18637	18999	14	to	to	TO
18637	18999	15	which	which	WDT
18637	18999	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	18999	17	been	be	VBN
18637	18999	18	added	add	VBN
18637	18999	19	any	any	DT
18637	18999	20	fat	fat	NN
18637	18999	21	or	or	CC
18637	18999	22	oil	oil	NN
18637	18999	23	other	other	JJ
18637	18999	24	than	than	IN
18637	18999	25	milk	milk	NN
18637	18999	26	fat	fat	JJ
18637	18999	27	,	,	,
18637	18999	28	and	and	CC
18637	18999	29	which	which	WDT
18637	18999	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	18999	31	,	,	,
18637	18999	32	as	as	IN
18637	18999	33	one	one	CD
18637	18999	34	of	of	IN
18637	18999	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	18999	36	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	18999	37	,	,	,
18637	18999	38	the	the	DT
18637	18999	39	prevention	prevention	NN
18637	18999	40	of	of	IN
18637	18999	41	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	18999	42	and	and	CC
18637	18999	43	deception	deception	NN
18637	18999	44	in	in	IN
18637	18999	45	the	the	DT
18637	18999	46	sale	sale	NN
18637	18999	47	of	of	IN
18637	18999	48	milk	milk	NN
18637	18999	49	products	product	NNS
18637	18999	50	,	,	,
18637	18999	51	does	do	VBZ
18637	18999	52	not	not	RB
18637	18999	53	,	,	,
18637	18999	54	when	when	WRB
18637	18999	55	applied	apply	VBN
18637	18999	56	to	to	IN
18637	18999	57	"	"	``
18637	18999	58	filled	fill	VBN
18637	18999	59	milk	milk	NN
18637	18999	60	"	"	''
18637	18999	61	having	have	VBG
18637	18999	62	the	the	DT
18637	18999	63	taste	taste	NN
18637	18999	64	,	,	,
18637	18999	65	consistency	consistency	NN
18637	18999	66	,	,	,
18637	18999	67	and	and	CC
18637	18999	68	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	18999	69	of	of	IN
18637	18999	70	whole	whole	JJ
18637	18999	71	milk	milk	NN
18637	18999	72	products	product	NNS
18637	18999	73	,	,	,
18637	18999	74	violate	violate	VB
18637	18999	75	the	the	DT
18637	18999	76	due	due	JJ
18637	18999	77	process	process	NN
18637	18999	78	clause	clause	NN
18637	18999	79	.	.	.
18637	19000	1	Filled	fill	VBN
18637	19000	2	milk	milk	NN
18637	19000	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	19000	4	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	19000	5	to	to	IN
18637	19000	6	whole	whole	JJ
18637	19000	7	milk	milk	NN
18637	19000	8	in	in	IN
18637	19000	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19000	10	nutritional	nutritional	JJ
18637	19000	11	content	content	NN
18637	19000	12	;	;	:
18637	19000	13	and	and	CC
18637	19000	14	can	can	MD
18637	19000	15	not	not	RB
18637	19000	16	be	be	VB
18637	19000	17	served	serve	VBN
18637	19000	18	to	to	IN
18637	19000	19	children	child	NNS
18637	19000	20	as	as	IN
18637	19000	21	a	a	DT
18637	19000	22	substitute	substitute	NN
18637	19000	23	for	for	IN
18637	19000	24	whole	whole	JJ
18637	19000	25	milk	milk	NN
18637	19000	26	without	without	IN
18637	19000	27	producing	produce	VBG
18637	19000	28	a	a	DT
18637	19000	29	dietary	dietary	JJ
18637	19000	30	deficiency	deficiency	NN
18637	19000	31	.	.	.
18637	19001	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19001	2	411	411	CD
18637	19001	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19001	4	However	however	RB
18637	19001	5	,	,	,
18637	19001	6	a	a	DT
18637	19001	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	19001	8	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	19001	9	the	the	DT
18637	19001	10	use	use	NN
18637	19001	11	of	of	IN
18637	19001	12	shoddy	shoddy	JJ
18637	19001	13	,	,	,
18637	19001	14	even	even	RB
18637	19001	15	when	when	WRB
18637	19001	16	sterilized	sterilize	VBN
18637	19001	17	,	,	,
18637	19001	18	was	be	VBD
18637	19001	19	held	hold	VBN
18637	19001	20	to	to	TO
18637	19001	21	be	be	VB
18637	19001	22	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19001	23	and	and	CC
18637	19001	24	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	19001	25	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	19001	26	.	.	.
18637	19002	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19002	2	412	412	CD
18637	19002	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19002	4	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	19002	5	of	of	IN
18637	19002	6	the	the	DT
18637	19002	7	Public	Public	NNP
18637	19002	8	Morals	Morals	NNPS
18637	19002	9	Gambling	Gambling	NNP
18637	19002	10	and	and	CC
18637	19002	11	Lotteries.--Unless	lotteries.--unless	IN
18637	19002	12	effecting	effect	VBG
18637	19002	13	a	a	DT
18637	19002	14	clear	clear	JJ
18637	19002	15	,	,	,
18637	19002	16	unmistakable	unmistakable	JJ
18637	19002	17	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	19002	18	of	of	IN
18637	19002	19	rights	right	NNS
18637	19002	20	securely	securely	RB
18637	19002	21	by	by	IN
18637	19002	22	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19002	23	law	law	NN
18637	19002	24	,	,	,
18637	19002	25	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19002	26	suppressing	suppress	VBG
18637	19002	27	gambling	gambling	NN
18637	19002	28	will	will	MD
18637	19002	29	be	be	VB
18637	19002	30	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	19002	31	by	by	IN
18637	19002	32	the	the	DT
18637	19002	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19002	34	as	as	RB
18637	19002	35	concededly	concededly	RB
18637	19002	36	within	within	IN
18637	19002	37	the	the	DT
18637	19002	38	police	police	NN
18637	19002	39	power	power	NN
18637	19002	40	of	of	IN
18637	19002	41	a	a	DT
18637	19002	42	State	State	NNP
18637	19002	43	.	.	.
18637	19003	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19003	2	413	413	CD
18637	19003	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19003	4	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19003	5	,	,	,
18637	19003	6	a	a	DT
18637	19003	7	State	state	NN
18637	19003	8	may	may	MD
18637	19003	9	validly	validly	RB
18637	19003	10	make	make	VB
18637	19003	11	a	a	DT
18637	19003	12	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19003	13	against	against	IN
18637	19003	14	those	those	DT
18637	19003	15	winning	win	VBG
18637	19003	16	money	money	NN
18637	19003	17	a	a	DT
18637	19003	18	lien	lien	NN
18637	19003	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	19003	20	the	the	DT
18637	19003	21	property	property	NN
18637	19003	22	in	in	IN
18637	19003	23	which	which	WDT
18637	19003	24	gambling	gambling	NN
18637	19003	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	19003	26	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	19003	27	with	with	IN
18637	19003	28	the	the	DT
18637	19003	29	owner	owner	NN
18637	19003	30	's	's	POS
18637	19003	31	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	19003	32	and	and	CC
18637	19003	33	consent	consent	NN
18637	19003	34	.	.	.
18637	19004	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19004	2	414	414	CD
18637	19004	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19004	4	For	for	IN
18637	19004	5	the	the	DT
18637	19004	6	same	same	JJ
18637	19004	7	reason	reason	NN
18637	19004	8	,	,	,
18637	19004	9	lotteries	lottery	NNS
18637	19004	10	,	,	,
18637	19004	11	including	include	VBG
18637	19004	12	those	those	DT
18637	19004	13	operated	operate	VBN
18637	19004	14	under	under	IN
18637	19004	15	a	a	DT
18637	19004	16	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19004	17	grant	grant	NN
18637	19004	18	,	,	,
18637	19004	19	may	may	MD
18637	19004	20	be	be	VB
18637	19004	21	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	19004	22	,	,	,
18637	19004	23	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	19004	24	of	of	IN
18637	19004	25	any	any	DT
18637	19004	26	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19004	27	equities	equity	NNS
18637	19004	28	.	.	.
18637	19005	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19005	2	415	415	CD
18637	19005	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19005	4	Red	Red	NNP
18637	19005	5	Light	Light	NNP
18637	19005	6	Districts.--An	districts.--an	JJ
18637	19005	7	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	19005	8	prescribing	prescribing	NN
18637	19005	9	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19005	10	in	in	IN
18637	19005	11	a	a	DT
18637	19005	12	city	city	NN
18637	19005	13	outside	outside	IN
18637	19005	14	of	of	IN
18637	19005	15	which	which	WDT
18637	19005	16	no	no	DT
18637	19005	17	woman	woman	NN
18637	19005	18	of	of	IN
18637	19005	19	lewd	lewd	JJ
18637	19005	20	character	character	NN
18637	19005	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	19005	22	dwell	dwell	VB
18637	19005	23	does	do	VBZ
18637	19005	24	not	not	RB
18637	19005	25	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	19005	26	persons	person	NNS
18637	19005	27	owning	own	VBG
18637	19005	28	or	or	CC
18637	19005	29	occupying	occupy	VBG
18637	19005	30	property	property	NN
18637	19005	31	in	in	IN
18637	19005	32	or	or	CC
18637	19005	33	adjacent	adjacent	JJ
18637	19005	34	to	to	IN
18637	19005	35	said	say	VBD
18637	19005	36	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19005	37	of	of	IN
18637	19005	38	any	any	DT
18637	19005	39	rights	right	NNS
18637	19005	40	protected	protect	VBN
18637	19005	41	by	by	IN
18637	19005	42	the	the	DT
18637	19005	43	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19005	44	.	.	.
18637	19006	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19006	2	416	416	CD
18637	19006	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19006	4	Sunday	Sunday	NNP
18637	19006	5	Blue	Blue	NNP
18637	19006	6	Laws.--The	Laws.--The	NNP
18637	19006	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19006	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19006	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	19006	10	uniformly	uniformly	RB
18637	19006	11	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	19006	12	State	State	NNP
18637	19006	13	laws	law	NNS
18637	19006	14	relating	relate	VBG
18637	19006	15	to	to	IN
18637	19006	16	the	the	DT
18637	19006	17	observance	observance	NN
18637	19006	18	of	of	IN
18637	19006	19	Sunday	Sunday	NNP
18637	19006	20	as	as	IN
18637	19006	21	representing	represent	VBG
18637	19006	22	a	a	DT
18637	19006	23	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	19006	24	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19006	25	of	of	IN
18637	19006	26	the	the	DT
18637	19006	27	police	police	NN
18637	19006	28	power	power	NN
18637	19006	29	.	.	.
18637	19007	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19007	2	,	,	,
18637	19007	3	a	a	DT
18637	19007	4	law	law	NN
18637	19007	5	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	19007	6	the	the	DT
18637	19007	7	keeping	keeping	NN
18637	19007	8	open	open	JJ
18637	19007	9	of	of	IN
18637	19007	10	barber	barber	NN
18637	19007	11	shops	shop	NNS
18637	19007	12	on	on	IN
18637	19007	13	Sunday	Sunday	NNP
18637	19007	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19007	15	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19007	16	.	.	.
18637	19008	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19008	2	417	417	CD
18637	19008	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19008	4	Intoxicating	Intoxicating	NNP
18637	19008	5	Liquor.--	Liquor.--	NNP
18637	19008	6	"	"	''
18637	19008	7	*	*	NFP
18637	19008	8	*	*	NFP
18637	19008	9	*	*	NFP
18637	19008	10	on	on	IN
18637	19008	11	account	account	NN
18637	19008	12	of	of	IN
18637	19008	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19008	14	well	well	RB
18637	19008	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	19008	16	known	know	VBN
18637	19008	17	noxious	noxious	JJ
18637	19008	18	qualities	quality	NNS
18637	19008	19	and	and	CC
18637	19008	20	the	the	DT
18637	19008	21	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	19008	22	evils	evil	NNS
18637	19008	23	shown	show	VBN
18637	19008	24	by	by	IN
18637	19008	25	experience	experience	NN
18637	19008	26	to	to	TO
18637	19008	27	be	be	VB
18637	19008	28	consequent	consequent	JJ
18637	19008	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	19008	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19008	31	use	use	NN
18637	19008	32	,	,	,
18637	19008	33	a	a	DT
18637	19008	34	State	state	NN
18637	19008	35	*	*	NFP
18637	19008	36	*	*	NFP
18637	19008	37	*	*	NFP
18637	19008	38	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19008	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	19008	40	competent	competent	JJ
18637	19008	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19008	42	to	to	TO
18637	19008	43	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	19008	44	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19008	45	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	19008	46	the	the	DT
18637	19008	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19008	48	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	19008	49	,	,	,
18637	19008	50	gift	gift	NN
18637	19008	51	,	,	,
18637	19008	52	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	19008	53	,	,	,
18637	19008	54	sale	sale	NN
18637	19008	55	,	,	,
18637	19008	56	or	or	CC
18637	19008	57	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	19008	58	of	of	IN
18637	19008	59	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	19008	60	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	19008	61	within	within	IN
18637	19008	62	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19008	63	borders	border	NNS
18637	19008	64	*	*	NFP
18637	19008	65	*	*	NFP
18637	19008	66	*	*	NFP
18637	19008	67	.	.	.
18637	19009	1	"	"	``
18637	19009	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19009	3	418	418	CD
18637	19009	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19009	5	And	and	CC
18637	19009	6	to	to	TO
18637	19009	7	implement	implement	VB
18637	19009	8	such	such	JJ
18637	19009	9	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	19009	10	,	,	,
18637	19009	11	a	a	DT
18637	19009	12	State	state	NN
18637	19009	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	19009	14	the	the	DT
18637	19009	15	power	power	NN
18637	19009	16	to	to	TO
18637	19009	17	declare	declare	VB
18637	19009	18	that	that	IN
18637	19009	19	places	place	NNS
18637	19009	20	where	where	WRB
18637	19009	21	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	19009	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	19009	23	manufactured	manufacture	VBN
18637	19009	24	or	or	CC
18637	19009	25	kept	keep	VBN
18637	19009	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	19009	27	be	be	VB
18637	19009	28	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19009	29	common	common	JJ
18637	19009	30	nuisances;[419	nuisances;[419	NNS
18637	19009	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19009	32	and	and	CC
18637	19009	33	even	even	RB
18637	19009	34	to	to	TO
18637	19009	35	subject	subject	VB
18637	19009	36	an	an	DT
18637	19009	37	innocent	innocent	JJ
18637	19009	38	owner	owner	NN
18637	19009	39	to	to	IN
18637	19009	40	the	the	DT
18637	19009	41	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	19009	42	of	of	IN
18637	19009	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19009	44	property	property	NN
18637	19009	45	for	for	IN
18637	19009	46	the	the	DT
18637	19009	47	acts	act	NNS
18637	19009	48	of	of	IN
18637	19009	49	a	a	DT
18637	19009	50	wrongdoer	wrongdoer	NN
18637	19009	51	.	.	.
18637	19010	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19010	2	420	420	CD
18637	19010	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19010	4	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	19010	5	of	of	IN
18637	19010	6	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	19010	7	Vehicles	Vehicles	NNPS
18637	19010	8	and	and	CC
18637	19010	9	Carriers	Carriers	NNPS
18637	19010	10	The	the	DT
18637	19010	11	highways	highway	NNS
18637	19010	12	of	of	IN
18637	19010	13	a	a	DT
18637	19010	14	State	state	NN
18637	19010	15	are	be	VBP
18637	19010	16	public	public	JJ
18637	19010	17	property	property	NN
18637	19010	18	,	,	,
18637	19010	19	the	the	DT
18637	19010	20	primary	primary	JJ
18637	19010	21	and	and	CC
18637	19010	22	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	19010	23	use	use	NN
18637	19010	24	of	of	IN
18637	19010	25	which	which	WDT
18637	19010	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	19010	27	for	for	IN
18637	19010	28	private	private	JJ
18637	19010	29	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19010	30	;	;	:
18637	19010	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19010	32	uses	use	NNS
18637	19010	33	for	for	IN
18637	19010	34	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19010	35	of	of	IN
18637	19010	36	gain	gain	NN
18637	19010	37	may	may	MD
18637	19010	38	generally	generally	RB
18637	19010	39	be	be	VB
18637	19010	40	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	19010	41	by	by	IN
18637	19010	42	the	the	DT
18637	19010	43	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	19010	44	or	or	CC
18637	19010	45	conditioned	condition	VBD
18637	19010	46	as	as	IN
18637	19010	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19010	48	sees	see	VBZ
18637	19010	49	fit	fit	JJ
18637	19010	50	.	.	.
18637	19011	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19011	2	421	421	CD
18637	19011	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19011	4	In	in	IN
18637	19011	5	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	19011	6	the	the	DT
18637	19011	7	use	use	NN
18637	19011	8	of	of	IN
18637	19011	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19011	10	highways	highway	NNS
18637	19011	11	for	for	IN
18637	19011	12	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	19011	13	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	19011	14	for	for	IN
18637	19011	15	hire	hire	NN
18637	19011	16	,	,	,
18637	19011	17	a	a	DT
18637	19011	18	State	state	NN
18637	19011	19	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	19011	20	may	may	MD
18637	19011	21	provide	provide	VB
18637	19011	22	that	that	IN
18637	19011	23	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19011	24	who	who	WP
18637	19011	25	have	have	VBP
18637	19011	26	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	19011	27	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19011	28	,	,	,
18637	19011	29	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	19011	30	,	,	,
18637	19011	31	and	and	CC
18637	19011	32	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	19011	33	service	service	NN
18637	19011	34	over	over	IN
18637	19011	35	a	a	DT
18637	19011	36	given	give	VBN
18637	19011	37	route	route	NN
18637	19011	38	from	from	IN
18637	19011	39	a	a	DT
18637	19011	40	specified	specify	VBN
18637	19011	41	date	date	NN
18637	19011	42	in	in	IN
18637	19011	43	the	the	DT
18637	19011	44	past	past	NN
18637	19011	45	shall	shall	MD
18637	19011	46	be	be	VB
18637	19011	47	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19011	48	to	to	IN
18637	19011	49	licenses	license	NNS
18637	19011	50	as	as	IN
18637	19011	51	a	a	DT
18637	19011	52	matter	matter	NN
18637	19011	53	of	of	IN
18637	19011	54	right	right	JJ
18637	19011	55	,	,	,
18637	19011	56	but	but	CC
18637	19011	57	that	that	IN
18637	19011	58	the	the	DT
18637	19011	59	licensing	licensing	NN
18637	19011	60	of	of	IN
18637	19011	61	those	those	DT
18637	19011	62	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19011	63	service	service	NN
18637	19011	64	over	over	IN
18637	19011	65	the	the	DT
18637	19011	66	route	route	NN
18637	19011	67	began	begin	VBD
18637	19011	68	later	later	RBR
18637	19011	69	than	than	IN
18637	19011	70	the	the	DT
18637	19011	71	date	date	NN
18637	19011	72	specified	specify	VBN
18637	19011	73	shall	shall	MD
18637	19011	74	depend	depend	VB
18637	19011	75	upon	upon	IN
18637	19011	76	public	public	JJ
18637	19011	77	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	19011	78	and	and	CC
18637	19011	79	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19011	80	.	.	.
18637	19012	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19012	2	422	422	CD
18637	19012	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19012	4	To	to	TO
18637	19012	5	require	require	VB
18637	19012	6	private	private	JJ
18637	19012	7	contract	contract	NN
18637	19012	8	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19012	9	for	for	IN
18637	19012	10	hire	hire	NN
18637	19012	11	to	to	TO
18637	19012	12	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	19012	13	a	a	DT
18637	19012	14	certificate	certificate	NN
18637	19012	15	of	of	IN
18637	19012	16	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	19012	17	and	and	CC
18637	19012	18	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19012	19	,	,	,
18637	19012	20	which	which	WDT
18637	19012	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	19012	22	not	not	RB
18637	19012	23	granted	grant	VBN
18637	19012	24	if	if	IN
18637	19012	25	the	the	DT
18637	19012	26	service	service	NN
18637	19012	27	of	of	IN
18637	19012	28	common	common	JJ
18637	19012	29	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19012	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	19012	31	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	19012	32	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	19012	33	,	,	,
18637	19012	34	and	and	CC
18637	19012	35	to	to	TO
18637	19012	36	fix	fix	VB
18637	19012	37	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	19012	38	rates	rate	NNS
18637	19012	39	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	19012	40	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	19012	41	which	which	WDT
18637	19012	42	are	be	VBP
18637	19012	43	not	not	RB
18637	19012	44	less	less	JJR
18637	19012	45	than	than	IN
18637	19012	46	those	those	DT
18637	19012	47	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	19012	48	for	for	IN
18637	19012	49	common	common	JJ
18637	19012	50	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19012	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	19012	52	valid	valid	JJ
18637	19012	53	as	as	IN
18637	19012	54	a	a	DT
18637	19012	55	means	means	NN
18637	19012	56	of	of	IN
18637	19012	57	conserving	conserve	VBG
18637	19012	58	highways;[423	highways;[423	ADD
18637	19012	59	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19012	60	but	but	CC
18637	19012	61	any	any	DT
18637	19012	62	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	19012	63	to	to	TO
18637	19012	64	convert	convert	VB
18637	19012	65	private	private	JJ
18637	19012	66	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19012	67	into	into	IN
18637	19012	68	common	common	JJ
18637	19012	69	carriers,[424	carriers,[424	NN
18637	19012	70	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19012	71	or	or	CC
18637	19012	72	to	to	TO
18637	19012	73	subject	subject	VB
18637	19012	74	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19012	75	to	to	IN
18637	19012	76	the	the	DT
18637	19012	77	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	19012	78	and	and	CC
18637	19012	79	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	19012	80	of	of	IN
18637	19012	81	common	common	JJ
18637	19012	82	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19012	83	,	,	,
18637	19012	84	without	without	IN
18637	19012	85	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	19012	86	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	19012	87	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19012	88	to	to	TO
18637	19012	89	be	be	VB
18637	19012	90	common	common	JJ
18637	19012	91	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19012	92	,	,	,
18637	19012	93	is	be	VBZ
18637	19012	94	violative	violative	JJ
18637	19012	95	of	of	IN
18637	19012	96	due	due	JJ
18637	19012	97	process	process	NN
18637	19012	98	.	.	.
18637	19013	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19013	2	425	425	CD
18637	19013	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19013	4	In	in	IN
18637	19013	5	the	the	DT
18637	19013	6	absence	absence	NN
18637	19013	7	of	of	IN
18637	19013	8	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19013	9	by	by	IN
18637	19013	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	19013	11	a	a	DT
18637	19013	12	State	State	NNP
18637	19013	13	may	may	MD
18637	19013	14	,	,	,
18637	19013	15	in	in	IN
18637	19013	16	protection	protection	NN
18637	19013	17	of	of	IN
18637	19013	18	the	the	DT
18637	19013	19	public	public	JJ
18637	19013	20	safety	safety	NN
18637	19013	21	,	,	,
18637	19013	22	deny	deny	VB
18637	19013	23	an	an	DT
18637	19013	24	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	19013	25	motor	motor	NN
18637	19013	26	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	19013	27	the	the	DT
18637	19013	28	use	use	NN
18637	19013	29	of	of	IN
18637	19013	30	an	an	DT
18637	19013	31	already	already	RB
18637	19013	32	congested	congest	VBN
18637	19013	33	highway	highway	NN
18637	19013	34	.	.	.
18637	19014	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19014	2	426	426	CD
18637	19014	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19014	4	In	in	IN
18637	19014	5	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	19014	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19014	7	authority	authority	NN
18637	19014	8	over	over	IN
18637	19014	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19014	10	highways	highway	NNS
18637	19014	11	,	,	,
18637	19014	12	on	on	IN
18637	19014	13	the	the	DT
18637	19014	14	other	other	JJ
18637	19014	15	hand	hand	NN
18637	19014	16	,	,	,
18637	19014	17	a	a	DT
18637	19014	18	State	state	NN
18637	19014	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	19014	20	limited	limit	VBN
18637	19014	21	not	not	RB
18637	19014	22	merely	merely	RB
18637	19014	23	to	to	IN
18637	19014	24	the	the	DT
18637	19014	25	raising	raising	NN
18637	19014	26	of	of	IN
18637	19014	27	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	19014	28	for	for	IN
18637	19014	29	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	19014	30	and	and	CC
18637	19014	31	reconstruction	reconstruction	NN
18637	19014	32	,	,	,
18637	19014	33	or	or	CC
18637	19014	34	to	to	IN
18637	19014	35	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	19014	36	as	as	IN
18637	19014	37	to	to	IN
18637	19014	38	the	the	DT
18637	19014	39	manner	manner	NN
18637	19014	40	in	in	IN
18637	19014	41	which	which	WDT
18637	19014	42	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	19014	43	shall	shall	MD
18637	19014	44	be	be	VB
18637	19014	45	operated	operate	VBN
18637	19014	46	,	,	,
18637	19014	47	but	but	CC
18637	19014	48	may	may	MD
18637	19014	49	also	also	RB
18637	19014	50	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	19014	51	the	the	DT
18637	19014	52	wear	wear	NN
18637	19014	53	and	and	CC
18637	19014	54	hazards	hazard	NNS
18637	19014	55	due	due	JJ
18637	19014	56	to	to	IN
18637	19014	57	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	19014	58	size	size	NN
18637	19014	59	of	of	IN
18637	19014	60	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	19014	61	and	and	CC
18637	19014	62	weight	weight	NN
18637	19014	63	of	of	IN
18637	19014	64	load	load	NN
18637	19014	65	.	.	.
18637	19015	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19015	2	,	,	,
18637	19015	3	a	a	DT
18637	19015	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	19015	5	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	19015	6	to	to	IN
18637	19015	7	7,000	7,000	CD
18637	19015	8	pounds	pound	NNS
18637	19015	9	the	the	DT
18637	19015	10	net	net	JJ
18637	19015	11	load	load	NN
18637	19015	12	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	19015	13	for	for	IN
18637	19015	14	trucks	truck	NNS
18637	19015	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	19015	16	not	not	RB
18637	19015	17	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19015	18	.	.	.
18637	19016	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19016	2	427	427	CD
18637	19016	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19016	4	No	no	RB
18637	19016	5	less	less	RBR
18637	19016	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19016	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19016	8	a	a	DT
18637	19016	9	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	19016	10	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	19016	11	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	19016	12	which	which	WDT
18637	19016	13	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	19016	14	the	the	DT
18637	19016	15	operation	operation	NN
18637	19016	16	in	in	IN
18637	19016	17	the	the	DT
18637	19016	18	streets	street	NNS
18637	19016	19	of	of	IN
18637	19016	20	any	any	DT
18637	19016	21	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	19016	22	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	19016	23	,	,	,
18637	19016	24	excepting	excepting	JJ
18637	19016	25	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	19016	26	displaying	display	VBG
18637	19016	27	business	business	NN
18637	19016	28	notices	notice	NNS
18637	19016	29	or	or	CC
18637	19016	30	advertisements	advertisement	NNS
18637	19016	31	of	of	IN
18637	19016	32	the	the	DT
18637	19016	33	products	product	NNS
18637	19016	34	of	of	IN
18637	19016	35	the	the	DT
18637	19016	36	owner	owner	NN
18637	19016	37	and	and	CC
18637	19016	38	not	not	RB
18637	19016	39	used	use	VBN
18637	19016	40	mainly	mainly	RB
18637	19016	41	for	for	IN
18637	19016	42	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	19016	43	;	;	:
18637	19016	44	and	and	CC
18637	19016	45	such	such	JJ
18637	19016	46	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	19016	47	may	may	MD
18637	19016	48	be	be	VB
18637	19016	49	validly	validly	RB
18637	19016	50	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	19016	51	to	to	TO
18637	19016	52	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	19016	53	an	an	DT
18637	19016	54	express	express	JJ
18637	19016	55	company	company	NN
18637	19016	56	from	from	IN
18637	19016	57	selling	sell	VBG
18637	19016	58	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	19016	59	space	space	NN
18637	19016	60	on	on	IN
18637	19016	61	the	the	DT
18637	19016	62	outside	outside	NN
18637	19016	63	of	of	IN
18637	19016	64	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19016	65	trucks	truck	NNS
18637	19016	66	.	.	.
18637	19017	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	19017	2	as	as	IN
18637	19017	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19017	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	19017	5	the	the	DT
18637	19017	6	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19017	7	of	of	IN
18637	19017	8	local	local	JJ
18637	19017	9	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	19017	10	that	that	IN
18637	19017	11	such	such	JJ
18637	19017	12	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	19017	13	affects	affect	VBZ
18637	19017	14	public	public	JJ
18637	19017	15	safety	safety	NN
18637	19017	16	by	by	IN
18637	19017	17	distracting	distract	VBG
18637	19017	18	drivers	driver	NNS
18637	19017	19	and	and	CC
18637	19017	20	pedestrians	pedestrian	NNS
18637	19017	21	,	,	,
18637	19017	22	courts	court	NNS
18637	19017	23	are	be	VBP
18637	19017	24	unable	unable	JJ
18637	19017	25	to	to	TO
18637	19017	26	hold	hold	VB
18637	19017	27	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	19017	28	in	in	IN
18637	19017	29	the	the	DT
18637	19017	30	absence	absence	NN
18637	19017	31	of	of	IN
18637	19017	32	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19017	33	refuting	refute	VBG
18637	19017	34	that	that	DT
18637	19017	35	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	19017	36	.	.	.
18637	19018	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19018	2	428	428	CD
18637	19018	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19018	4	Any	any	DT
18637	19018	5	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	19018	6	means	mean	NNS
18637	19018	7	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	19018	8	to	to	TO
18637	19018	9	insure	insure	VB
18637	19018	10	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	19018	11	and	and	CC
18637	19018	12	care	care	VB
18637	19018	13	on	on	IN
18637	19018	14	the	the	DT
18637	19018	15	part	part	NN
18637	19018	16	of	of	IN
18637	19018	17	licensees	licensee	NNS
18637	19018	18	and	and	CC
18637	19018	19	to	to	TO
18637	19018	20	protect	protect	VB
18637	19018	21	other	other	JJ
18637	19018	22	highway	highway	NN
18637	19018	23	users	user	NNS
18637	19018	24	being	be	VBG
18637	19018	25	consonant	consonant	JJ
18637	19018	26	with	with	IN
18637	19018	27	due	due	JJ
18637	19018	28	process	process	NN
18637	19018	29	,	,	,
18637	19018	30	a	a	DT
18637	19018	31	State	state	NN
18637	19018	32	may	may	MD
18637	19018	33	also	also	RB
18637	19018	34	provide	provide	VB
18637	19018	35	that	that	IN
18637	19018	36	one	one	CD
18637	19018	37	,	,	,
18637	19018	38	against	against	IN
18637	19018	39	whom	whom	WP
18637	19018	40	a	a	DT
18637	19018	41	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19018	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	19018	43	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19018	44	for	for	IN
18637	19018	45	negligent	negligent	JJ
18637	19018	46	operation	operation	NN
18637	19018	47	and	and	CC
18637	19018	48	who	who	WP
18637	19018	49	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	19018	50	to	to	TO
18637	19018	51	pay	pay	VB
18637	19018	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19018	53	within	within	IN
18637	19018	54	a	a	DT
18637	19018	55	designated	designate	VBN
18637	19018	56	time	time	NN
18637	19018	57	,	,	,
18637	19018	58	shall	shall	MD
18637	19018	59	have	have	VB
18637	19018	60	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19018	61	license	license	NN
18637	19018	62	and	and	CC
18637	19018	63	registration	registration	NN
18637	19018	64	suspended	suspend	VBN
18637	19018	65	for	for	IN
18637	19018	66	three	three	CD
18637	19018	67	years	year	NNS
18637	19018	68	,	,	,
18637	19018	69	unless	unless	IN
18637	19018	70	,	,	,
18637	19018	71	in	in	IN
18637	19018	72	the	the	DT
18637	19018	73	meantime	meantime	NN
18637	19018	74	,	,	,
18637	19018	75	the	the	DT
18637	19018	76	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19018	77	is	be	VBZ
18637	19018	78	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	19018	79	or	or	CC
18637	19018	80	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	19018	81	.	.	.
18637	19019	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19019	2	429	429	CD
18637	19019	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19019	4	By	by	IN
18637	19019	5	the	the	DT
18637	19019	6	same	same	JJ
18637	19019	7	token	token	NN
18637	19019	8	a	a	DT
18637	19019	9	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19019	10	owner	owner	NN
18637	19019	11	who	who	WP
18637	19019	12	loaned	loan	VBD
18637	19019	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19019	14	automobile	automobile	NN
18637	19019	15	in	in	IN
18637	19019	16	another	another	DT
18637	19019	17	State	state	NN
18637	19019	18	,	,	,
18637	19019	19	by	by	IN
18637	19019	20	the	the	DT
18637	19019	21	law	law	NN
18637	19019	22	of	of	IN
18637	19019	23	which	which	WDT
18637	19019	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19019	25	was	be	VBD
18637	19019	26	immune	immune	JJ
18637	19019	27	from	from	IN
18637	19019	28	liability	liability	NN
18637	19019	29	for	for	IN
18637	19019	30	the	the	DT
18637	19019	31	borrower	borrower	NN
18637	19019	32	's	's	POS
18637	19019	33	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	19019	34	,	,	,
18637	19019	35	and	and	CC
18637	19019	36	who	who	WP
18637	19019	37	was	be	VBD
18637	19019	38	not	not	RB
18637	19019	39	in	in	IN
18637	19019	40	the	the	DT
18637	19019	41	State	State	NNP
18637	19019	42	at	at	IN
18637	19019	43	the	the	DT
18637	19019	44	time	time	NN
18637	19019	45	of	of	IN
18637	19019	46	an	an	DT
18637	19019	47	accident	accident	NN
18637	19019	48	,	,	,
18637	19019	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	19019	50	not	not	RB
18637	19019	51	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	19019	52	to	to	IN
18637	19019	53	any	any	DT
18637	19019	54	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19019	55	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19019	56	by	by	IN
18637	19019	57	a	a	DT
18637	19019	58	law	law	NN
18637	19019	59	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19019	60	,	,	,
18637	19019	61	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	19019	62	liability	liability	NN
18637	19019	63	on	on	IN
18637	19019	64	the	the	DT
18637	19019	65	owner	owner	NN
18637	19019	66	for	for	IN
18637	19019	67	the	the	DT
18637	19019	68	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	19019	69	of	of	IN
18637	19019	70	one	one	CD
18637	19019	71	driving	drive	VBG
18637	19019	72	the	the	DT
18637	19019	73	car	car	NN
18637	19019	74	with	with	IN
18637	19019	75	the	the	DT
18637	19019	76	owner	owner	NN
18637	19019	77	's	's	POS
18637	19019	78	permission	permission	NN
18637	19019	79	.	.	.
18637	19020	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19020	2	430	430	CD
18637	19020	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19020	4	Compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	19020	5	automobile	automobile	NN
18637	19020	6	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19020	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19020	8	so	so	RB
18637	19020	9	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	19020	10	valid	valid	JJ
18637	19020	11	as	as	IN
18637	19020	12	to	to	TO
18637	19020	13	present	present	VB
18637	19020	14	no	no	DT
18637	19020	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19020	16	question	question	NN
18637	19020	17	.	.	.
18637	19021	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19021	2	431	431	CD
18637	19021	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19021	4	Succession	succession	NN
18637	19021	5	to	to	IN
18637	19021	6	Property	Property	NNP
18637	19021	7	When	when	WRB
18637	19021	8	a	a	DT
18637	19021	9	New	New	NNP
18637	19021	10	York	York	NNP
18637	19021	11	Decedent	Decedent	NNP
18637	19021	12	Estate	Estate	NNP
18637	19021	13	Law	Law	NNP
18637	19021	14	,	,	,
18637	19021	15	effective	effective	JJ
18637	19021	16	after	after	IN
18637	19021	17	1930	1930	CD
18637	19021	18	,	,	,
18637	19021	19	grants	grant	NNS
18637	19021	20	for	for	IN
18637	19021	21	the	the	DT
18637	19021	22	first	first	JJ
18637	19021	23	time	time	NN
18637	19021	24	to	to	IN
18637	19021	25	a	a	DT
18637	19021	26	surviving	survive	VBG
18637	19021	27	spouse	spouse	NN
18637	19021	28	a	a	DT
18637	19021	29	right	right	NN
18637	19021	30	of	of	IN
18637	19021	31	election	election	NN
18637	19021	32	to	to	TO
18637	19021	33	take	take	VB
18637	19021	34	as	as	IN
18637	19021	35	in	in	IN
18637	19021	36	intestacy	intestacy	NN
18637	19021	37	,	,	,
18637	19021	38	and	and	CC
18637	19021	39	the	the	DT
18637	19021	40	husband	husband	NN
18637	19021	41	,	,	,
18637	19021	42	by	by	IN
18637	19021	43	executing	execute	VBG
18637	19021	44	in	in	IN
18637	19021	45	1934	1934	CD
18637	19021	46	a	a	DT
18637	19021	47	codicil	codicil	NN
18637	19021	48	to	to	IN
18637	19021	49	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19021	50	will	will	NN
18637	19021	51	drafted	draft	VBN
18637	19021	52	in	in	IN
18637	19021	53	1929	1929	CD
18637	19021	54	,	,	,
18637	19021	55	made	make	VBD
18637	19021	56	this	this	DT
18637	19021	57	provision	provision	NN
18637	19021	58	operative	operative	NN
18637	19021	59	,	,	,
18637	19021	60	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19021	61	widow	widow	NN
18637	19021	62	,	,	,
18637	19021	63	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19021	64	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19021	65	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	19021	66	in	in	IN
18637	19021	67	1922	1922	CD
18637	19021	68	of	of	IN
18637	19021	69	any	any	DT
18637	19021	70	right	right	NN
18637	19021	71	in	in	IN
18637	19021	72	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19021	73	husband	husband	NN
18637	19021	74	's	's	POS
18637	19021	75	estate	estate	NN
18637	19021	76	,	,	,
18637	19021	77	may	may	MD
18637	19021	78	avail	avail	VB
18637	19021	79	herself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19021	80	of	of	IN
18637	19021	81	such	such	JJ
18637	19021	82	right	right	NN
18637	19021	83	of	of	IN
18637	19021	84	election	election	NN
18637	19021	85	.	.	.
18637	19022	1	The	the	DT
18637	19022	2	deceased	deceased	JJ
18637	19022	3	husband	husband	NN
18637	19022	4	's	's	POS
18637	19022	5	heirs	heir	NNS
18637	19022	6	can	can	MD
18637	19022	7	not	not	RB
18637	19022	8	contend	contend	VB
18637	19022	9	that	that	IN
18637	19022	10	the	the	DT
18637	19022	11	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	19022	12	of	of	IN
18637	19022	13	the	the	DT
18637	19022	14	widow	widow	NN
18637	19022	15	's	's	POS
18637	19022	16	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	19022	17	by	by	IN
18637	19022	18	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	19022	19	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19022	20	deprived	deprive	VBD
18637	19022	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19022	22	estate	estate	NN
18637	19022	23	of	of	IN
18637	19022	24	property	property	NN
18637	19022	25	without	without	IN
18637	19022	26	due	due	JJ
18637	19022	27	process	process	NN
18637	19022	28	of	of	IN
18637	19022	29	law	law	NN
18637	19022	30	.	.	.
18637	19023	1	Rights	right	NNS
18637	19023	2	of	of	IN
18637	19023	3	succession	succession	NN
18637	19023	4	to	to	IN
18637	19023	5	property	property	NN
18637	19023	6	are	be	VBP
18637	19023	7	of	of	IN
18637	19023	8	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	19023	9	creation	creation	NN
18637	19023	10	.	.	.
18637	19024	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19024	2	,	,	,
18637	19024	3	New	New	NNP
18637	19024	4	York	York	NNP
18637	19024	5	could	could	MD
18637	19024	6	have	have	VB
18637	19024	7	conditioned	condition	VBN
18637	19024	8	any	any	DT
18637	19024	9	further	further	JJ
18637	19024	10	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19024	11	of	of	IN
18637	19024	12	testamentary	testamentary	JJ
18637	19024	13	power	power	NN
18637	19024	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	19024	15	the	the	DT
18637	19024	16	giving	giving	NN
18637	19024	17	of	of	IN
18637	19024	18	right	right	NN
18637	19024	19	of	of	IN
18637	19024	20	election	election	NN
18637	19024	21	to	to	IN
18637	19024	22	the	the	DT
18637	19024	23	surviving	survive	VBG
18637	19024	24	spouse	spouse	NN
18637	19024	25	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	19024	26	of	of	IN
18637	19024	27	any	any	DT
18637	19024	28	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	19024	29	however	however	RB
18637	19024	30	formally	formally	RB
18637	19024	31	executed	execute	VBN
18637	19024	32	.	.	.
18637	19025	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19025	2	432	432	CD
18637	19025	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19025	4	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	19025	5	of	of	IN
18637	19025	6	Estates.--Even	Estates.--Even	,
18637	19025	7	after	after	IN
18637	19025	8	the	the	DT
18637	19025	9	creation	creation	NN
18637	19025	10	of	of	IN
18637	19025	11	testamentary	testamentary	NN
18637	19025	12	trust	trust	NN
18637	19025	13	,	,	,
18637	19025	14	a	a	DT
18637	19025	15	State	state	NN
18637	19025	16	retains	retain	VBZ
18637	19025	17	the	the	DT
18637	19025	18	power	power	NN
18637	19025	19	to	to	TO
18637	19025	20	devise	devise	VB
18637	19025	21	new	new	JJ
18637	19025	22	and	and	CC
18637	19025	23	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19025	24	directions	direction	NNS
18637	19025	25	to	to	IN
18637	19025	26	the	the	DT
18637	19025	27	trustee	trustee	NN
18637	19025	28	to	to	TO
18637	19025	29	meet	meet	VB
18637	19025	30	new	new	JJ
18637	19025	31	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19025	32	arising	arise	VBG
18637	19025	33	during	during	IN
18637	19025	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19025	35	administration	administration	NN
18637	19025	36	,	,	,
18637	19025	37	especially	especially	RB
18637	19025	38	such	such	JJ
18637	19025	39	as	as	IN
18637	19025	40	the	the	DT
18637	19025	41	depression	depression	NN
18637	19025	42	presented	present	VBD
18637	19025	43	to	to	IN
18637	19025	44	trusts	trust	NNS
18637	19025	45	containing	contain	VBG
18637	19025	46	mortgages	mortgage	NNS
18637	19025	47	.	.	.
18637	19026	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19026	2	,	,	,
18637	19026	3	no	no	DT
18637	19026	4	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19026	5	right	right	NN
18637	19026	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19026	7	violated	violate	VBN
18637	19026	8	by	by	IN
18637	19026	9	the	the	DT
18637	19026	10	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	19026	11	application	application	NN
18637	19026	12	to	to	IN
18637	19026	13	an	an	DT
18637	19026	14	estate	estate	NN
18637	19026	15	on	on	IN
18637	19026	16	which	which	WDT
18637	19026	17	administration	administration	NN
18637	19026	18	had	have	VBD
18637	19026	19	already	already	RB
18637	19026	20	begun	begin	VBN
18637	19026	21	of	of	IN
18637	19026	22	a	a	DT
18637	19026	23	statute	statute	NN
18637	19026	24	which	which	WDT
18637	19026	25	had	have	VBD
18637	19026	26	the	the	DT
18637	19026	27	effect	effect	NN
18637	19026	28	of	of	IN
18637	19026	29	taking	take	VBG
18637	19026	30	away	away	RP
18637	19026	31	a	a	DT
18637	19026	32	remainderman	remainderman	NN
18637	19026	33	's	's	POS
18637	19026	34	right	right	NN
18637	19026	35	to	to	IN
18637	19026	36	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19026	37	examination	examination	NN
18637	19026	38	of	of	IN
18637	19026	39	the	the	DT
18637	19026	40	trustee	trustee	NN
18637	19026	41	's	's	POS
18637	19026	42	computation	computation	NN
18637	19026	43	of	of	IN
18637	19026	44	income	income	NN
18637	19026	45	.	.	.
18637	19027	1	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19027	2	rules	rule	NNS
18637	19027	3	,	,	,
18637	19027	4	promulgated	promulgate	VBD
18637	19027	5	prior	prior	RB
18637	19027	6	to	to	IN
18637	19027	7	such	such	JJ
18637	19027	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	19027	9	and	and	CC
18637	19027	10	which	which	WDT
18637	19027	11	were	be	VBD
18637	19027	12	more	more	RBR
18637	19027	13	favorable	favorable	JJ
18637	19027	14	to	to	IN
18637	19027	15	the	the	DT
18637	19027	16	interests	interest	NNS
18637	19027	17	of	of	IN
18637	19027	18	remaindermen	remainderman	NNS
18637	19027	19	,	,	,
18637	19027	20	can	can	MD
18637	19027	21	be	be	VB
18637	19027	22	relied	rely	VBN
18637	19027	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	19027	24	by	by	IN
18637	19027	25	the	the	DT
18637	19027	26	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19027	27	only	only	RB
18637	19027	28	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	19027	29	as	as	IN
18637	19027	30	said	say	VBN
18637	19027	31	rules	rule	NNS
18637	19027	32	were	be	VBD
18637	19027	33	intended	intend	VBN
18637	19027	34	to	to	TO
18637	19027	35	operate	operate	VB
18637	19027	36	retroactively	retroactively	RB
18637	19027	37	;	;	:
18637	19027	38	for	for	IN
18637	19027	39	the	the	DT
18637	19027	40	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19027	41	,	,	,
18637	19027	42	in	in	IN
18637	19027	43	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19027	44	estate	estate	NN
18637	19027	45	the	the	DT
18637	19027	46	remaindermen	remainderman	NNS
18637	19027	47	had	have	VBD
18637	19027	48	an	an	DT
18637	19027	49	interest	interest	NN
18637	19027	50	,	,	,
18637	19027	51	died	die	VBD
18637	19027	52	even	even	RB
18637	19027	53	before	before	IN
18637	19027	54	such	such	JJ
18637	19027	55	court	court	NN
18637	19027	56	rules	rule	NNS
18637	19027	57	were	be	VBD
18637	19027	58	established	establish	VBN
18637	19027	59	.	.	.
18637	19028	1	If	if	IN
18637	19028	2	a	a	DT
18637	19028	3	property	property	NN
18637	19028	4	right	right	NN
18637	19028	5	in	in	IN
18637	19028	6	a	a	DT
18637	19028	7	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19028	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	19028	9	of	of	IN
18637	19028	10	income	income	NN
18637	19028	11	allotment	allotment	NN
18637	19028	12	in	in	IN
18637	19028	13	salvage	salvage	NN
18637	19028	14	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19028	15	vested	vest	VBN
18637	19028	16	at	at	RB
18637	19028	17	all	all	RB
18637	19028	18	,	,	,
18637	19028	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19028	20	would	would	MD
18637	19028	21	seem	seem	VB
18637	19028	22	to	to	TO
18637	19028	23	have	have	VB
18637	19028	24	done	do	VBN
18637	19028	25	so	so	RB
18637	19028	26	at	at	IN
18637	19028	27	the	the	DT
18637	19028	28	death	death	NN
18637	19028	29	of	of	IN
18637	19028	30	the	the	DT
18637	19028	31	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19028	32	or	or	CC
18637	19028	33	testator	testator	NN
18637	19028	34	.	.	.
18637	19029	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19029	2	433	433	CD
18637	19029	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19029	4	Abandoned	abandon	VBN
18637	19029	5	Property.--As	Property.--As	NNP
18637	19029	6	applied	apply	VBD
18637	19029	7	to	to	IN
18637	19029	8	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19029	9	policies	policy	NNS
18637	19029	10	on	on	IN
18637	19029	11	the	the	DT
18637	19029	12	lives	life	NNS
18637	19029	13	of	of	IN
18637	19029	14	New	New	NNP
18637	19029	15	York	York	NNP
18637	19029	16	residents	resident	NNS
18637	19029	17	issued	issue	VBN
18637	19029	18	by	by	IN
18637	19029	19	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19029	20	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19029	21	for	for	IN
18637	19029	22	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	19029	23	in	in	IN
18637	19029	24	New	New	NNP
18637	19029	25	York	York	NNP
18637	19029	26	,	,	,
18637	19029	27	where	where	WRB
18637	19029	28	the	the	DT
18637	19029	29	insured	insured	JJ
18637	19029	30	persons	person	NNS
18637	19029	31	continued	continue	VBD
18637	19029	32	to	to	TO
18637	19029	33	be	be	VB
18637	19029	34	residents	resident	NNS
18637	19029	35	and	and	CC
18637	19029	36	the	the	DT
18637	19029	37	beneficiaries	beneficiary	NNS
18637	19029	38	were	be	VBD
18637	19029	39	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19029	40	at	at	IN
18637	19029	41	the	the	DT
18637	19029	42	maturity	maturity	NN
18637	19029	43	date	date	NN
18637	19029	44	of	of	IN
18637	19029	45	the	the	DT
18637	19029	46	policies	policy	NNS
18637	19029	47	,	,	,
18637	19029	48	a	a	DT
18637	19029	49	New	New	NNP
18637	19029	50	York	York	NNP
18637	19029	51	Abandoned	Abandoned	NNP
18637	19029	52	Property	Property	NNP
18637	19029	53	Law	Law	NNP
18637	19029	54	requiring	require	VBG
18637	19029	55	payment	payment	NN
18637	19029	56	to	to	IN
18637	19029	57	the	the	DT
18637	19029	58	State	State	NNP
18637	19029	59	of	of	IN
18637	19029	60	money	money	NN
18637	19029	61	owing	owe	VBG
18637	19029	62	by	by	IN
18637	19029	63	life	life	NN
18637	19029	64	insurers	insurer	NNS
18637	19029	65	and	and	CC
18637	19029	66	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	19029	67	unclaimed	unclaimed	JJ
18637	19029	68	for	for	IN
18637	19029	69	seven	seven	CD
18637	19029	70	years	year	NNS
18637	19029	71	does	do	VBZ
18637	19029	72	not	not	RB
18637	19029	73	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	19029	74	such	such	JJ
18637	19029	75	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19029	76	companies	company	NNS
18637	19029	77	of	of	IN
18637	19029	78	property	property	NN
18637	19029	79	without	without	IN
18637	19029	80	due	due	JJ
18637	19029	81	process	process	NN
18637	19029	82	.	.	.
18637	19030	1	The	the	DT
18637	19030	2	relationship	relationship	NN
18637	19030	3	between	between	IN
18637	19030	4	New	New	NNP
18637	19030	5	York	York	NNP
18637	19030	6	and	and	CC
18637	19030	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19030	8	residents	resident	NNS
18637	19030	9	who	who	WP
18637	19030	10	abandon	abandon	VBP
18637	19030	11	claims	claim	NNS
18637	19030	12	against	against	IN
18637	19030	13	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19030	14	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19030	15	companies	company	NNS
18637	19030	16	,	,	,
18637	19030	17	and	and	CC
18637	19030	18	between	between	IN
18637	19030	19	New	New	NNP
18637	19030	20	York	York	NNP
18637	19030	21	and	and	CC
18637	19030	22	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19030	23	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19030	24	companies	company	NNS
18637	19030	25	doing	do	VBG
18637	19030	26	business	business	NN
18637	19030	27	therein	therein	RB
18637	19030	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	19030	29	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	19030	30	close	close	JJ
18637	19030	31	to	to	TO
18637	19030	32	give	give	VB
18637	19030	33	New	New	NNP
18637	19030	34	York	York	NNP
18637	19030	35	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19030	36	.	.	.
18637	19031	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19031	2	434	434	CD
18637	19031	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19031	4	In	in	IN
18637	19031	5	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	19031	6	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	19031	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	19031	8	_	_	NNP
18637	19031	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	19031	10	_	_	NNP
18637	19031	11	New	New	NNP
18637	19031	12	Jersey,[435	Jersey,[435	NNP
18637	19031	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19031	14	a	a	DT
18637	19031	15	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	19031	16	divided	divide	VBN
18637	19031	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19031	18	held	hold	VBD
18637	19031	19	recently	recently	RB
18637	19031	20	that	that	DT
18637	19031	21	due	due	JJ
18637	19031	22	process	process	NN
18637	19031	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	19031	24	not	not	RB
18637	19031	25	violated	violate	VBN
18637	19031	26	by	by	IN
18637	19031	27	a	a	DT
18637	19031	28	statute	statute	NN
18637	19031	29	escheating	escheate	VBG
18637	19031	30	to	to	IN
18637	19031	31	the	the	DT
18637	19031	32	State	State	NNP
18637	19031	33	shares	share	NNS
18637	19031	34	of	of	IN
18637	19031	35	stock	stock	NN
18637	19031	36	in	in	IN
18637	19031	37	a	a	DT
18637	19031	38	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19031	39	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19031	40	and	and	CC
18637	19031	41	unpaid	unpaid	JJ
18637	19031	42	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	19031	43	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19031	44	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	19031	45	,	,	,
18637	19031	46	even	even	RB
18637	19031	47	though	though	IN
18637	19031	48	the	the	DT
18637	19031	49	last	last	RB
18637	19031	50	-	-	HYPH
18637	19031	51	known	know	VBN
18637	19031	52	owners	owner	NNS
18637	19031	53	were	be	VBD
18637	19031	54	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	19031	55	and	and	CC
18637	19031	56	the	the	DT
18637	19031	57	stock	stock	NN
18637	19031	58	was	be	VBD
18637	19031	59	issued	issue	VBN
18637	19031	60	and	and	CC
18637	19031	61	the	the	DT
18637	19031	62	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	19031	63	were	be	VBD
18637	19031	64	held	hold	VBN
18637	19031	65	in	in	IN
18637	19031	66	another	another	DT
18637	19031	67	State	state	NN
18637	19031	68	.	.	.
18637	19032	1	The	the	DT
18637	19032	2	State	State	NNP
18637	19032	3	's	's	POS
18637	19032	4	power	power	NN
18637	19032	5	over	over	IN
18637	19032	6	the	the	DT
18637	19032	7	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	19032	8	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19032	9	gives	give	VBZ
18637	19032	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19032	11	power	power	NN
18637	19032	12	to	to	TO
18637	19032	13	seize	seize	VB
18637	19032	14	the	the	DT
18637	19032	15	debts	debt	NNS
18637	19032	16	or	or	CC
18637	19032	17	demands	demand	NNS
18637	19032	18	represented	represent	VBN
18637	19032	19	by	by	IN
18637	19032	20	the	the	DT
18637	19032	21	stock	stock	NN
18637	19032	22	and	and	CC
18637	19032	23	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	19032	24	.	.	.
18637	19033	1	Vested	Vested	NNP
18637	19033	2	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	19033	3	,	,	,
18637	19033	4	Remedial	Remedial	NNP
18637	19033	5	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	19033	6	,	,	,
18637	19033	7	Political	Political	NNP
18637	19033	8	Candidacy	Candidacy	NNP
18637	19033	9	Inasmuch	Inasmuch	NNP
18637	19033	10	as	as	IN
18637	19033	11	the	the	DT
18637	19033	12	right	right	NN
18637	19033	13	to	to	TO
18637	19033	14	become	become	VB
18637	19033	15	a	a	DT
18637	19033	16	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	19033	17	for	for	IN
18637	19033	18	State	State	NNP
18637	19033	19	office	office	NN
18637	19033	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	19033	21	a	a	DT
18637	19033	22	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19033	23	only	only	RB
18637	19033	24	of	of	IN
18637	19033	25	State	State	NNP
18637	19033	26	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	19033	27	,	,	,
18637	19033	28	an	an	DT
18637	19033	29	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	19033	30	denial	denial	NN
18637	19033	31	of	of	IN
18637	19033	32	such	such	JJ
18637	19033	33	right	right	NN
18637	19033	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	19033	35	not	not	RB
18637	19033	36	a	a	DT
18637	19033	37	denial	denial	NN
18637	19033	38	of	of	IN
18637	19033	39	a	a	DT
18637	19033	40	right	right	NN
18637	19033	41	of	of	IN
18637	19033	42	"	"	``
18637	19033	43	property	property	NN
18637	19033	44	.	.	.
18637	19034	1	"	"	``
18637	19034	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19034	3	436	436	CD
18637	19034	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19034	5	However	however	RB
18637	19034	6	,	,	,
18637	19034	7	an	an	DT
18637	19034	8	existing	exist	VBG
18637	19034	9	right	right	NN
18637	19034	10	of	of	IN
18637	19034	11	action	action	NN
18637	19034	12	to	to	TO
18637	19034	13	recover	recover	VB
18637	19034	14	damages	damage	NNS
18637	19034	15	for	for	IN
18637	19034	16	an	an	DT
18637	19034	17	injury	injury	NN
18637	19034	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	19034	19	property	property	NN
18637	19034	20	,	,	,
18637	19034	21	which	which	WDT
18637	19034	22	a	a	DT
18637	19034	23	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	19034	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	19034	25	no	no	DT
18637	19034	26	power	power	NN
18637	19034	27	to	to	TO
18637	19034	28	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	19034	29	.	.	.
18637	19035	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19035	2	437	437	CD
18637	19035	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19035	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19035	5	,	,	,
18637	19035	6	the	the	DT
18637	19035	7	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	19035	8	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	19035	9	of	of	IN
18637	19035	10	a	a	DT
18637	19035	11	provision	provision	NN
18637	19035	12	which	which	WDT
18637	19035	13	made	make	VBD
18637	19035	14	directors	director	NNS
18637	19035	15	liable	liable	JJ
18637	19035	16	for	for	IN
18637	19035	17	moneys	money	NNS
18637	19035	18	embezzled	embezzle	VBN
18637	19035	19	by	by	IN
18637	19035	20	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	19035	21	officers	officer	NNS
18637	19035	22	,	,	,
18637	19035	23	by	by	IN
18637	19035	24	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	19035	25	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	19035	26	of	of	IN
18637	19035	27	a	a	DT
18637	19035	28	liability	liability	NN
18637	19035	29	which	which	WDT
18637	19035	30	already	already	RB
18637	19035	31	had	have	VBD
18637	19035	32	arisen	arise	VBN
18637	19035	33	,	,	,
18637	19035	34	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	19035	35	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19035	36	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	19035	37	of	of	IN
18637	19035	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19035	39	property	property	NN
18637	19035	40	without	without	IN
18637	19035	41	due	due	JJ
18637	19035	42	process	process	NN
18637	19035	43	of	of	IN
18637	19035	44	law	law	NN
18637	19035	45	.	.	.
18637	19036	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19036	2	438	438	CD
18637	19036	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19036	4	But	but	CC
18637	19036	5	while	while	IN
18637	19036	6	a	a	DT
18637	19036	7	vested	vested	JJ
18637	19036	8	cause	cause	NN
18637	19036	9	of	of	IN
18637	19036	10	action	action	NN
18637	19036	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	19036	12	property	property	NN
18637	19036	13	,	,	,
18637	19036	14	a	a	DT
18637	19036	15	person	person	NN
18637	19036	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	19036	17	no	no	DT
18637	19036	18	property	property	NN
18637	19036	19	,	,	,
18637	19036	20	in	in	IN
18637	19036	21	the	the	DT
18637	19036	22	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19036	23	sense	sense	NN
18637	19036	24	,	,	,
18637	19036	25	in	in	IN
18637	19036	26	any	any	DT
18637	19036	27	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19036	28	form	form	NN
18637	19036	29	of	of	IN
18637	19036	30	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	19036	31	;	;	:
18637	19036	32	and	and	CC
18637	19036	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	19036	34	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	19036	35	only	only	RB
18637	19036	36	the	the	DT
18637	19036	37	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	19036	38	of	of	IN
18637	19036	39	a	a	DT
18637	19036	40	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	19036	41	right	right	NN
18637	19036	42	to	to	TO
18637	19036	43	redress	redress	VB
18637	19036	44	by	by	IN
18637	19036	45	any	any	DT
18637	19036	46	effective	effective	JJ
18637	19036	47	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19036	48	.	.	.
18637	19037	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19037	2	439	439	CD
18637	19037	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19037	4	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19037	5	,	,	,
18637	19037	6	a	a	DT
18637	19037	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	19037	8	creating	create	VBG
18637	19037	9	an	an	DT
18637	19037	10	additional	additional	JJ
18637	19037	11	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	19037	12	for	for	IN
18637	19037	13	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	19037	14	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	19037	15	'	'	POS
18637	19037	16	liability	liability	NN
18637	19037	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	19037	18	not	not	RB
18637	19037	19	,	,	,
18637	19037	20	as	as	IN
18637	19037	21	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19037	22	to	to	IN
18637	19037	23	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	19037	24	then	then	RB
18637	19037	25	holding	hold	VBG
18637	19037	26	stock	stock	NN
18637	19037	27	,	,	,
18637	19037	28	violative	violative	JJ
18637	19037	29	of	of	IN
18637	19037	30	due	due	JJ
18637	19037	31	process	process	NN
18637	19037	32	.	.	.
18637	19038	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19038	2	440	440	CD
18637	19038	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19038	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19038	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19038	6	a	a	DT
18637	19038	7	law	law	NN
18637	19038	8	which	which	WDT
18637	19038	9	lifts	lift	VBZ
18637	19038	10	a	a	DT
18637	19038	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	19038	12	of	of	IN
18637	19038	13	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	19038	14	and	and	CC
18637	19038	15	make	make	VB
18637	19038	16	possible	possible	JJ
18637	19038	17	a	a	DT
18637	19038	18	suit	suit	NN
18637	19038	19	,	,	,
18637	19038	20	theretofore	theretofore	NNP
18637	19038	21	barred	bar	VBN
18637	19038	22	,	,	,
18637	19038	23	for	for	IN
18637	19038	24	the	the	DT
18637	19038	25	value	value	NN
18637	19038	26	of	of	IN
18637	19038	27	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19038	28	securities	security	NNS
18637	19038	29	.	.	.
18637	19039	1	"	"	``
18637	19039	2	The	the	DT
18637	19039	3	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19039	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19039	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	19039	6	not	not	RB
18637	19039	7	make	make	VB
18637	19039	8	an	an	DT
18637	19039	9	act	act	NN
18637	19039	10	of	of	IN
18637	19039	11	State	State	NNP
18637	19039	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19039	13	void	void	VB
18637	19039	14	merely	merely	RB
18637	19039	15	because	because	IN
18637	19039	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19039	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	19039	18	some	some	DT
18637	19039	19	retrospective	retrospective	JJ
18637	19039	20	operation	operation	NN
18637	19039	21	.	.	.
18637	19040	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19040	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19040	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19040	4	Some	some	DT
18637	19040	5	rules	rule	NNS
18637	19040	6	of	of	IN
18637	19040	7	law	law	NN
18637	19040	8	probably	probably	RB
18637	19040	9	could	could	MD
18637	19040	10	not	not	RB
18637	19040	11	be	be	VB
18637	19040	12	changed	change	VBN
18637	19040	13	retroactively	retroactively	RB
18637	19040	14	without	without	IN
18637	19040	15	hardship	hardship	NN
18637	19040	16	and	and	CC
18637	19040	17	oppression	oppression	NN
18637	19040	18	,	,	,
18637	19040	19	*	*	NFP
18637	19040	20	*	*	NFP
18637	19040	21	*	*	NFP
18637	19040	22	,	,	,
18637	19040	23	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	19040	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19040	25	can	can	MD
18637	19040	26	not	not	RB
18637	19040	27	be	be	VB
18637	19040	28	said	say	VBN
18637	19040	29	that	that	IN
18637	19040	30	lifting	lift	VBG
18637	19040	31	the	the	DT
18637	19040	32	bar	bar	NN
18637	19040	33	of	of	IN
18637	19040	34	a	a	DT
18637	19040	35	statute	statute	NN
18637	19040	36	of	of	IN
18637	19040	37	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	19040	38	so	so	IN
18637	19040	39	as	as	IN
18637	19040	40	to	to	TO
18637	19040	41	restore	restore	VB
18637	19040	42	a	a	DT
18637	19040	43	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	19040	44	lost	lose	VBN
18637	19040	45	through	through	IN
18637	19040	46	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19040	47	lapse	lapse	NN
18637	19040	48	of	of	IN
18637	19040	49	time	time	NN
18637	19040	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	19040	51	_	_	NNP
18637	19040	52	per	per	FW
18637	19040	53	se	se	FW
18637	19040	54	_	_	NNP
18637	19040	55	an	an	DT
18637	19040	56	offense	offense	NN
18637	19040	57	against	against	IN
18637	19040	58	the	the	DT
18637	19040	59	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19040	60	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19040	61	.	.	.
18637	19041	1	"	"	``
18637	19041	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19041	3	441	441	CD
18637	19041	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19041	5	Man	Man	NNP
18637	19041	6	's	's	POS
18637	19041	7	Best	good	JJS
18637	19041	8	Friend	Friend	NNP
18637	19041	9	A	a	DT
18637	19041	10	statute	statute	NN
18637	19041	11	providing	provide	VBG
18637	19041	12	that	that	IN
18637	19041	13	no	no	DT
18637	19041	14	dog	dog	NN
18637	19041	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	19041	16	be	be	VB
18637	19041	17	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19041	18	to	to	IN
18637	19041	19	the	the	DT
18637	19041	20	protection	protection	NN
18637	19041	21	of	of	IN
18637	19041	22	the	the	DT
18637	19041	23	law	law	NN
18637	19041	24	unless	unless	IN
18637	19041	25	placed	place	VBN
18637	19041	26	upon	upon	IN
18637	19041	27	the	the	DT
18637	19041	28	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19041	29	rolls	roll	NNS
18637	19041	30	,	,	,
18637	19041	31	and	and	CC
18637	19041	32	that	that	IN
18637	19041	33	in	in	IN
18637	19041	34	a	a	DT
18637	19041	35	civil	civil	JJ
18637	19041	36	action	action	NN
18637	19041	37	for	for	IN
18637	19041	38	killing	kill	VBG
18637	19041	39	a	a	DT
18637	19041	40	dog	dog	NN
18637	19041	41	the	the	DT
18637	19041	42	owner	owner	NN
18637	19041	43	can	can	MD
18637	19041	44	not	not	RB
18637	19041	45	recover	recover	VB
18637	19041	46	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19041	47	the	the	DT
18637	19041	48	value	value	NN
18637	19041	49	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	19041	50	by	by	IN
18637	19041	51	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19041	52	in	in	IN
18637	19041	53	the	the	DT
18637	19041	54	last	last	JJ
18637	19041	55	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19041	56	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	19041	57	the	the	DT
18637	19041	58	killing	killing	NN
18637	19041	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	19041	60	within	within	IN
18637	19041	61	the	the	DT
18637	19041	62	police	police	NN
18637	19041	63	power	power	NN
18637	19041	64	of	of	IN
18637	19041	65	the	the	DT
18637	19041	66	State	State	NNP
18637	19041	67	.	.	.
18637	19042	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19042	2	442	442	CD
18637	19042	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19042	4	Control	Control	NNP
18637	19042	5	of	of	IN
18637	19042	6	Local	Local	NNP
18637	19042	7	Units	Units	NNPS
18637	19042	8	of	of	IN
18637	19042	9	Government	Government	NNP
18637	19042	10	The	the	DT
18637	19042	11	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19042	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19042	13	does	do	VBZ
18637	19042	14	not	not	RB
18637	19042	15	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	19042	16	a	a	DT
18637	19042	17	State	state	NN
18637	19042	18	of	of	IN
18637	19042	19	the	the	DT
18637	19042	20	power	power	NN
18637	19042	21	to	to	TO
18637	19042	22	determine	determine	VB
18637	19042	23	what	what	WDT
18637	19042	24	duties	duty	NNS
18637	19042	25	may	may	MD
18637	19042	26	be	be	VB
18637	19042	27	performed	perform	VBN
18637	19042	28	by	by	IN
18637	19042	29	local	local	JJ
18637	19042	30	officers	officer	NNS
18637	19042	31	,	,	,
18637	19042	32	nor	nor	CC
18637	19042	33	whether	whether	IN
18637	19042	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19042	35	shall	shall	MD
18637	19042	36	be	be	VB
18637	19042	37	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	19042	38	or	or	CC
18637	19042	39	popularly	popularly	RB
18637	19042	40	elected	elect	VBN
18637	19042	41	.	.	.
18637	19043	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19043	2	443	443	CD
18637	19043	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19043	4	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19043	5	power	power	NN
18637	19043	6	over	over	IN
18637	19043	7	the	the	DT
18637	19043	8	rights	right	NNS
18637	19043	9	and	and	CC
18637	19043	10	property	property	NN
18637	19043	11	of	of	IN
18637	19043	12	cities	city	NNS
18637	19043	13	held	hold	VBN
18637	19043	14	and	and	CC
18637	19043	15	used	use	VBN
18637	19043	16	for	for	IN
18637	19043	17	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	19043	18	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19043	19	was	be	VBD
18637	19043	20	unaltered	unaltered	JJ
18637	19043	21	by	by	IN
18637	19043	22	the	the	DT
18637	19043	23	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	19043	24	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19043	25	.	.	.
18637	19044	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19044	2	444	444	CD
18637	19044	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19044	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19044	5	,	,	,
18637	19044	6	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19044	7	that	that	IN
18637	19044	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19044	9	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	19044	10	liability	liability	NN
18637	19044	11	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	19044	12	of	of	IN
18637	19044	13	the	the	DT
18637	19044	14	power	power	NN
18637	19044	15	of	of	IN
18637	19044	16	a	a	DT
18637	19044	17	city	city	NN
18637	19044	18	to	to	TO
18637	19044	19	have	have	VB
18637	19044	20	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	19044	21	the	the	DT
18637	19044	22	violence	violence	NN
18637	19044	23	,	,	,
18637	19044	24	a	a	DT
18637	19044	25	statute	statute	NN
18637	19044	26	requiring	require	VBG
18637	19044	27	cities	city	NNS
18637	19044	28	to	to	TO
18637	19044	29	indemnify	indemnify	VB
18637	19044	30	owners	owner	NNS
18637	19044	31	of	of	IN
18637	19044	32	property	property	NN
18637	19044	33	damaged	damage	VBN
18637	19044	34	by	by	IN
18637	19044	35	mobs	mob	NNS
18637	19044	36	or	or	CC
18637	19044	37	during	during	IN
18637	19044	38	riots	riot	NNS
18637	19044	39	effects	effect	NNS
18637	19044	40	no	no	DT
18637	19044	41	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19044	42	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19044	43	of	of	IN
18637	19044	44	the	the	DT
18637	19044	45	property	property	NN
18637	19044	46	of	of	IN
18637	19044	47	such	such	JJ
18637	19044	48	municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	19044	49	.	.	.
18637	19045	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19045	2	445	445	CD
18637	19045	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19045	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19045	5	,	,	,
18637	19045	6	a	a	DT
18637	19045	7	person	person	NN
18637	19045	8	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	19045	9	a	a	DT
18637	19045	10	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19045	11	against	against	IN
18637	19045	12	a	a	DT
18637	19045	13	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	19045	14	for	for	IN
18637	19045	15	damages	damage	NNS
18637	19045	16	resulting	result	VBG
18637	19045	17	from	from	IN
18637	19045	18	a	a	DT
18637	19045	19	riot	riot	NN
18637	19045	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	19045	21	not	not	RB
18637	19045	22	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	19045	23	of	of	IN
18637	19045	24	property	property	NN
18637	19045	25	without	without	IN
18637	19045	26	due	due	JJ
18637	19045	27	process	process	NN
18637	19045	28	of	of	IN
18637	19045	29	law	law	NN
18637	19045	30	by	by	IN
18637	19045	31	an	an	DT
18637	19045	32	act	act	NN
18637	19045	33	which	which	WDT
18637	19045	34	so	so	RB
18637	19045	35	limits	limit	VBZ
18637	19045	36	the	the	DT
18637	19045	37	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	19045	38	's	's	POS
18637	19045	39	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19045	40	power	power	NN
18637	19045	41	as	as	IN
18637	19045	42	to	to	TO
18637	19045	43	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	19045	44	collection	collection	NN
18637	19045	45	of	of	IN
18637	19045	46	funds	fund	NNS
18637	19045	47	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19045	48	to	to	TO
18637	19045	49	pay	pay	VB
18637	19045	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19045	51	.	.	.
18637	19046	1	As	as	RB
18637	19046	2	long	long	RB
18637	19046	3	as	as	IN
18637	19046	4	the	the	DT
18637	19046	5	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19046	6	continues	continue	VBZ
18637	19046	7	as	as	IN
18637	19046	8	an	an	DT
18637	19046	9	existing	exist	VBG
18637	19046	10	liability	liability	NN
18637	19046	11	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19046	12	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19046	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	19046	14	experienced	experience	VBN
18637	19046	15	.	.	.
18637	19047	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19047	2	446	446	CD
18637	19047	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19047	4	Local	local	JJ
18637	19047	5	units	unit	NNS
18637	19047	6	of	of	IN
18637	19047	7	government	government	NN
18637	19047	8	obliged	oblige	VBD
18637	19047	9	to	to	TO
18637	19047	10	surrender	surrender	VB
18637	19047	11	property	property	NN
18637	19047	12	to	to	IN
18637	19047	13	other	other	JJ
18637	19047	14	units	unit	NNS
18637	19047	15	newly	newly	RB
18637	19047	16	created	create	VBN
18637	19047	17	out	out	IN
18637	19047	18	of	of	IN
18637	19047	19	the	the	DT
18637	19047	20	territory	territory	NN
18637	19047	21	of	of	IN
18637	19047	22	the	the	DT
18637	19047	23	former	former	JJ
18637	19047	24	can	can	MD
18637	19047	25	not	not	RB
18637	19047	26	successfully	successfully	RB
18637	19047	27	invoke	invoke	VB
18637	19047	28	the	the	DT
18637	19047	29	due	due	JJ
18637	19047	30	process	process	NN
18637	19047	31	clause,[447	clause,[447	NN
18637	19047	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19047	33	nor	nor	CC
18637	19047	34	may	may	MD
18637	19047	35	taxpayers	taxpayer	NNS
18637	19047	36	allege	allege	VB
18637	19047	37	any	any	DT
18637	19047	38	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19047	39	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19047	40	as	as	IN
18637	19047	41	the	the	DT
18637	19047	42	result	result	NN
18637	19047	43	of	of	IN
18637	19047	44	changes	change	NNS
18637	19047	45	in	in	IN
18637	19047	46	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19047	47	tax	tax	NN
18637	19047	48	burden	burden	NN
18637	19047	49	attendant	attendant	NN
18637	19047	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	19047	51	the	the	DT
18637	19047	52	consolidation	consolidation	NN
18637	19047	53	of	of	IN
18637	19047	54	contiguous	contiguous	JJ
18637	19047	55	municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	19047	56	.	.	.
18637	19048	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19048	2	448	448	CD
18637	19048	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19048	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19048	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19048	6	a	a	DT
18637	19048	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	19048	8	requiring	require	VBG
18637	19048	9	counties	county	NNS
18637	19048	10	to	to	TO
18637	19048	11	reimburse	reimburse	VB
18637	19048	12	cities	city	NNS
18637	19048	13	of	of	IN
18637	19048	14	the	the	DT
18637	19048	15	first	first	JJ
18637	19048	16	class	class	NN
18637	19048	17	but	but	CC
18637	19048	18	not	not	RB
18637	19048	19	other	other	JJ
18637	19048	20	classes	class	NNS
18637	19048	21	for	for	IN
18637	19048	22	rebates	rebate	NNS
18637	19048	23	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	19048	24	for	for	IN
18637	19048	25	prompt	prompt	JJ
18637	19048	26	payment	payment	NN
18637	19048	27	of	of	IN
18637	19048	28	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19048	29	in	in	IN
18637	19048	30	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	19048	31	with	with	IN
18637	19048	32	the	the	DT
18637	19048	33	due	due	JJ
18637	19048	34	process	process	NN
18637	19048	35	clause	clause	NN
18637	19048	36	.	.	.
18637	19049	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19049	2	449	449	CD
18637	19049	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19049	4	TAXATION	TAXATION	NNP
18637	19049	5	In	in	IN
18637	19049	6	General	General	NNP
18637	19049	7	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19049	8	was	be	VBD
18637	19049	9	not	not	RB
18637	19049	10	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
18637	19049	11	that	that	IN
18637	19049	12	the	the	DT
18637	19049	13	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	19049	14	of	of	IN
18637	19049	15	the	the	DT
18637	19049	16	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19049	17	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19049	18	would	would	MD
18637	19049	19	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	19049	20	or	or	CC
18637	19049	21	cripple	cripple	VB
18637	19049	22	the	the	DT
18637	19049	23	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19049	24	power	power	NN
18637	19049	25	of	of	IN
18637	19049	26	the	the	DT
18637	19049	27	States	States	NNP
18637	19049	28	.	.	.
18637	19050	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19050	2	450	450	CD
18637	19050	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19050	4	Rather	rather	RB
18637	19050	5	,	,	,
18637	19050	6	the	the	DT
18637	19050	7	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	19050	8	of	of	IN
18637	19050	9	the	the	DT
18637	19050	10	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	19050	11	was	be	VBD
18637	19050	12	to	to	TO
18637	19050	13	extend	extend	VB
18637	19050	14	to	to	IN
18637	19050	15	the	the	DT
18637	19050	16	residents	resident	NNS
18637	19050	17	of	of	IN
18637	19050	18	the	the	DT
18637	19050	19	States	States	NNP
18637	19050	20	the	the	DT
18637	19050	21	same	same	JJ
18637	19050	22	protection	protection	NN
18637	19050	23	against	against	IN
18637	19050	24	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19050	25	State	State	NNP
18637	19050	26	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19050	27	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	19050	28	life	life	NN
18637	19050	29	,	,	,
18637	19050	30	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19050	31	,	,	,
18637	19050	32	and	and	CC
18637	19050	33	property	property	NN
18637	19050	34	as	as	IN
18637	19050	35	was	be	VBD
18637	19050	36	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	19050	37	against	against	IN
18637	19050	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	19050	39	by	by	IN
18637	19050	40	the	the	DT
18637	19050	41	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	19050	42	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19050	43	.	.	.
18637	19051	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19051	2	451	451	CD
18637	19051	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19051	4	Public	Public	NNP
18637	19051	5	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	19051	6	Inasmuch	Inasmuch	NNP
18637	19051	7	as	as	IN
18637	19051	8	public	public	JJ
18637	19051	9	moneys	money	NNS
18637	19051	10	can	can	MD
18637	19051	11	not	not	RB
18637	19051	12	be	be	VB
18637	19051	13	expended	expend	VBN
18637	19051	14	for	for	IN
18637	19051	15	other	other	JJ
18637	19051	16	than	than	IN
18637	19051	17	public	public	JJ
18637	19051	18	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19051	19	,	,	,
18637	19051	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19051	21	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	19051	22	that	that	IN
18637	19051	23	an	an	DT
18637	19051	24	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19051	25	of	of	IN
18637	19051	26	the	the	DT
18637	19051	27	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19051	28	power	power	NN
18637	19051	29	for	for	IN
18637	19051	30	merely	merely	RB
18637	19051	31	private	private	JJ
18637	19051	32	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19051	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	19051	34	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19051	35	the	the	DT
18637	19051	36	authority	authority	NN
18637	19051	37	of	of	IN
18637	19051	38	the	the	DT
18637	19051	39	States	States	NNP
18637	19051	40	.	.	.
18637	19052	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19052	2	452	452	CD
18637	19052	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19052	4	Whether	whether	IN
18637	19052	5	a	a	DT
18637	19052	6	use	use	NN
18637	19052	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19052	8	public	public	JJ
18637	19052	9	or	or	CC
18637	19052	10	private	private	JJ
18637	19052	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	19052	12	ultimately	ultimately	RB
18637	19052	13	a	a	DT
18637	19052	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19052	15	question	question	NN
18637	19052	16	,	,	,
18637	19052	17	however	however	RB
18637	19052	18	,	,	,
18637	19052	19	and	and	CC
18637	19052	20	in	in	IN
18637	19052	21	the	the	DT
18637	19052	22	determination	determination	NN
18637	19052	23	thereof	thereof	IN
18637	19052	24	the	the	DT
18637	19052	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19052	26	will	will	MD
18637	19052	27	be	be	VB
18637	19052	28	influenced	influence	VBN
18637	19052	29	by	by	IN
18637	19052	30	local	local	JJ
18637	19052	31	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19052	32	and	and	CC
18637	19052	33	by	by	IN
18637	19052	34	the	the	DT
18637	19052	35	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	19052	36	of	of	IN
18637	19052	37	State	State	NNP
18637	19052	38	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	19052	39	as	as	IN
18637	19052	40	to	to	IN
18637	19052	41	what	what	WP
18637	19052	42	are	be	VBP
18637	19052	43	to	to	TO
18637	19052	44	be	be	VB
18637	19052	45	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19052	46	public	public	JJ
18637	19052	47	uses	use	NNS
18637	19052	48	in	in	IN
18637	19052	49	any	any	DT
18637	19052	50	State	State	NNP
18637	19052	51	.	.	.
18637	19053	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19053	2	453	453	CD
18637	19053	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19053	4	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19053	5	levied	levy	VBN
18637	19053	6	for	for	IN
18637	19053	7	each	each	DT
18637	19053	8	of	of	IN
18637	19053	9	the	the	DT
18637	19053	10	following	following	JJ
18637	19053	11	listed	listed	JJ
18637	19053	12	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19053	13	have	have	VBP
18637	19053	14	been	be	VBN
18637	19053	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	19053	16	to	to	TO
18637	19053	17	be	be	VB
18637	19053	18	for	for	IN
18637	19053	19	a	a	DT
18637	19053	20	public	public	JJ
18637	19053	21	use	use	NN
18637	19053	22	:	:	:
18637	19053	23	city	city	NN
18637	19053	24	coal	coal	NN
18637	19053	25	and	and	CC
18637	19053	26	fuel	fuel	NN
18637	19053	27	yard,[454	yard,[454	NN
18637	19053	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19053	29	State	State	NNP
18637	19053	30	bank	bank	NN
18637	19053	31	,	,	,
18637	19053	32	warehouse	warehouse	NN
18637	19053	33	,	,	,
18637	19053	34	elevator	elevator	NN
18637	19053	35	,	,	,
18637	19053	36	flour	flour	NN
18637	19053	37	-	-	HYPH
18637	19053	38	mill	mill	NN
18637	19053	39	system	system	NN
18637	19053	40	,	,	,
18637	19053	41	and	and	CC
18637	19053	42	homebuilding	homebuilde	VBG
18637	19053	43	projects,[455	projects,[455	NN
18637	19053	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19053	45	society	society	NN
18637	19053	46	for	for	IN
18637	19053	47	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	19053	48	cruelty	cruelty	NN
18637	19053	49	to	to	IN
18637	19053	50	animals	animal	NNS
18637	19053	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19053	52	dog	dog	NN
18637	19053	53	license	license	NN
18637	19053	54	tax),[456	tax),[456	NNP
18637	19053	55	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19053	56	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19053	57	tunnel,[457	tunnel,[457	NNS
18637	19053	58	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19053	59	books	book	NNS
18637	19053	60	for	for	IN
18637	19053	61	school	school	NN
18637	19053	62	children	child	NNS
18637	19053	63	attending	attend	VBG
18637	19053	64	private	private	JJ
18637	19053	65	as	as	RB
18637	19053	66	well	well	RB
18637	19053	67	as	as	IN
18637	19053	68	public	public	JJ
18637	19053	69	schools,[458	schools,[458	NN
18637	19053	70	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19053	71	and	and	CC
18637	19053	72	relief	relief	NN
18637	19053	73	of	of	IN
18637	19053	74	unemployment	unemployment	NN
18637	19053	75	.	.	.
18637	19054	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19054	2	459	459	CD
18637	19054	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19054	4	Other	other	JJ
18637	19054	5	Considerations	Considerations	NNPS
18637	19054	6	Affecting	affect	VBG
18637	19054	7	Validity	Validity	NNP
18637	19054	8	:	:	:
18637	19054	9	Excessive	Excessive	NNP
18637	19054	10	Burden	Burden	NNP
18637	19054	11	;	;	:
18637	19054	12	Ratio	Ratio	NNP
18637	19054	13	of	of	IN
18637	19054	14	Amount	Amount	NNP
18637	19054	15	to	to	IN
18637	19054	16	Benefit	Benefit	NNP
18637	19054	17	Received	Received	NNP
18637	19054	18	When	when	WRB
18637	19054	19	the	the	DT
18637	19054	20	power	power	NN
18637	19054	21	to	to	TO
18637	19054	22	tax	tax	NN
18637	19054	23	exists	exist	NNS
18637	19054	24	,	,	,
18637	19054	25	the	the	DT
18637	19054	26	extent	extent	NN
18637	19054	27	of	of	IN
18637	19054	28	the	the	DT
18637	19054	29	burden	burden	NN
18637	19054	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	19054	31	a	a	DT
18637	19054	32	matter	matter	NN
18637	19054	33	for	for	IN
18637	19054	34	the	the	DT
18637	19054	35	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	19054	36	of	of	IN
18637	19054	37	the	the	DT
18637	19054	38	lawmakers;[460	lawmakers;[460	NNPS
18637	19054	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19054	40	and	and	CC
18637	19054	41	the	the	DT
18637	19054	42	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19054	43	will	will	MD
18637	19054	44	refrain	refrain	VB
18637	19054	45	from	from	IN
18637	19054	46	condemning	condemn	VBG
18637	19054	47	a	a	DT
18637	19054	48	tax	tax	NN
18637	19054	49	solely	solely	RB
18637	19054	50	on	on	IN
18637	19054	51	the	the	DT
18637	19054	52	ground	ground	NN
18637	19054	53	that	that	IN
18637	19054	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19054	55	is	be	VBZ
18637	19054	56	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	19054	57	.	.	.
18637	19055	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19055	2	461	461	CD
18637	19055	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19055	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19055	5	can	can	MD
18637	19055	6	the	the	DT
18637	19055	7	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	19055	8	of	of	IN
18637	19055	9	the	the	DT
18637	19055	10	power	power	NN
18637	19055	11	to	to	TO
18637	19055	12	levy	levy	VB
18637	19055	13	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19055	14	be	be	VB
18637	19055	15	made	make	VBN
18637	19055	16	to	to	TO
18637	19055	17	depend	depend	VB
18637	19055	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	19055	19	the	the	DT
18637	19055	20	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	19055	21	's	's	POS
18637	19055	22	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	19055	23	of	of	IN
18637	19055	24	any	any	DT
18637	19055	25	special	special	JJ
18637	19055	26	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19055	27	from	from	IN
18637	19055	28	use	use	NN
18637	19055	29	of	of	IN
18637	19055	30	the	the	DT
18637	19055	31	funds	fund	NNS
18637	19055	32	raised	raise	VBN
18637	19055	33	by	by	IN
18637	19055	34	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19055	35	.	.	.
18637	19056	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19056	2	462	462	CD
18637	19056	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19056	4	Estate	Estate	NNP
18637	19056	5	,	,	,
18637	19056	6	Gift	Gift	NNP
18637	19056	7	,	,	,
18637	19056	8	and	and	CC
18637	19056	9	Inheritance	Inheritance	NNP
18637	19056	10	Taxes	tax	VBZ
18637	19056	11	The	the	DT
18637	19056	12	power	power	NN
18637	19056	13	of	of	IN
18637	19056	14	testamentary	testamentary	NN
18637	19056	15	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	19056	16	and	and	CC
18637	19056	17	the	the	DT
18637	19056	18	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19056	19	of	of	IN
18637	19056	20	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	19056	21	being	be	VBG
18637	19056	22	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	19056	23	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	19056	24	of	of	IN
18637	19056	25	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19056	26	,	,	,
18637	19056	27	a	a	DT
18637	19056	28	State	state	NN
18637	19056	29	may	may	MD
18637	19056	30	apply	apply	VB
18637	19056	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19056	32	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	19056	33	tax	tax	NN
18637	19056	34	to	to	IN
18637	19056	35	either	either	CC
18637	19056	36	the	the	DT
18637	19056	37	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	19056	38	,	,	,
18637	19056	39	or	or	CC
18637	19056	40	the	the	DT
18637	19056	41	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19056	42	of	of	IN
18637	19056	43	the	the	DT
18637	19056	44	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19056	45	power	power	NN
18637	19056	46	of	of	IN
18637	19056	47	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	19056	48	,	,	,
18637	19056	49	of	of	IN
18637	19056	50	property	property	NN
18637	19056	51	by	by	IN
18637	19056	52	will	will	NN
18637	19056	53	or	or	CC
18637	19056	54	descent	descent	VB
18637	19056	55	,	,	,
18637	19056	56	or	or	CC
18637	19056	57	to	to	IN
18637	19056	58	the	the	DT
18637	19056	59	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19056	60	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19056	61	of	of	IN
18637	19056	62	taking	take	VBG
18637	19056	63	property	property	NN
18637	19056	64	by	by	IN
18637	19056	65	devise	devise	NN
18637	19056	66	or	or	CC
18637	19056	67	descent	descent	NN
18637	19056	68	.	.	.
18637	19057	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19057	2	463	463	CD
18637	19057	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19057	4	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19057	5	,	,	,
18637	19057	6	an	an	DT
18637	19057	7	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	19057	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	19057	9	law	law	NN
18637	19057	10	,	,	,
18637	19057	11	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	19057	12	after	after	IN
18637	19057	13	the	the	DT
18637	19057	14	death	death	NN
18637	19057	15	of	of	IN
18637	19057	16	a	a	DT
18637	19057	17	testator	testator	NN
18637	19057	18	,	,	,
18637	19057	19	but	but	CC
18637	19057	20	before	before	IN
18637	19057	21	the	the	DT
18637	19057	22	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	19057	23	of	of	IN
18637	19057	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19057	25	estate	estate	NN
18637	19057	26	,	,	,
18637	19057	27	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	19057	28	may	may	MD
18637	19057	29	be	be	VB
18637	19057	30	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19057	31	on	on	IN
18637	19057	32	the	the	DT
18637	19057	33	shares	share	NNS
18637	19057	34	of	of	IN
18637	19057	35	legatees	legatee	NNS
18637	19057	36	,	,	,
18637	19057	37	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19057	38	that	that	DT
18637	19057	39	under	under	IN
18637	19057	40	the	the	DT
18637	19057	41	law	law	NN
18637	19057	42	of	of	IN
18637	19057	43	the	the	DT
18637	19057	44	State	State	NNP
18637	19057	45	in	in	IN
18637	19057	46	effect	effect	NN
18637	19057	47	on	on	IN
18637	19057	48	the	the	DT
18637	19057	49	date	date	NN
18637	19057	50	of	of	IN
18637	19057	51	such	such	JJ
18637	19057	52	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	19057	53	,	,	,
18637	19057	54	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	19057	55	of	of	IN
18637	19057	56	the	the	DT
18637	19057	57	property	property	NN
18637	19057	58	passed	pass	VBD
18637	19057	59	to	to	IN
18637	19057	60	the	the	DT
18637	19057	61	legatees	legatee	NNS
18637	19057	62	upon	upon	IN
18637	19057	63	the	the	DT
18637	19057	64	testator	testator	NN
18637	19057	65	's	's	POS
18637	19057	66	death	death	NN
18637	19057	67	.	.	.
18637	19058	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19058	2	464	464	CD
18637	19058	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19058	4	Equally	equally	RB
18637	19058	5	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	19058	6	with	with	IN
18637	19058	7	due	due	JJ
18637	19058	8	process	process	NN
18637	19058	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19058	10	a	a	DT
18637	19058	11	tax	tax	NN
18637	19058	12	on	on	IN
18637	19058	13	an	an	DT
18637	19058	14	_	_	NNP
18637	19058	15	inter	inter	NN
18637	19058	16	vivos	vivos	NNP
18637	19058	17	_	_	NNP
18637	19058	18	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19058	19	of	of	IN
18637	19058	20	property	property	NN
18637	19058	21	by	by	IN
18637	19058	22	deed	deed	NN
18637	19058	23	intended	intend	VBN
18637	19058	24	to	to	TO
18637	19058	25	take	take	VB
18637	19058	26	effect	effect	NN
18637	19058	27	upon	upon	IN
18637	19058	28	the	the	DT
18637	19058	29	death	death	NN
18637	19058	30	of	of	IN
18637	19058	31	the	the	DT
18637	19058	32	grantor	grantor	NN
18637	19058	33	.	.	.
18637	19059	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19059	2	465	465	CD
18637	19059	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19059	4	The	the	DT
18637	19059	5	due	due	JJ
18637	19059	6	process	process	NN
18637	19059	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	19059	8	places	place	VBZ
18637	19059	9	no	no	DT
18637	19059	10	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	19059	11	on	on	IN
18637	19059	12	a	a	DT
18637	19059	13	State	state	NN
18637	19059	14	as	as	IN
18637	19059	15	to	to	IN
18637	19059	16	the	the	DT
18637	19059	17	time	time	NN
18637	19059	18	at	at	IN
18637	19059	19	which	which	WDT
18637	19059	20	an	an	DT
18637	19059	21	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	19059	22	tax	tax	NN
18637	19059	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	19059	24	be	be	VB
18637	19059	25	levied	levy	VBN
18637	19059	26	or	or	CC
18637	19059	27	the	the	DT
18637	19059	28	property	property	NN
18637	19059	29	valued	value	VBN
18637	19059	30	for	for	IN
18637	19059	31	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19059	32	of	of	IN
18637	19059	33	such	such	PDT
18637	19059	34	a	a	DT
18637	19059	35	tax	tax	NN
18637	19059	36	;	;	:
18637	19059	37	and	and	CC
18637	19059	38	for	for	IN
18637	19059	39	that	that	DT
18637	19059	40	reason	reason	NN
18637	19059	41	a	a	DT
18637	19059	42	graduated	graduate	VBN
18637	19059	43	tax	tax	NN
18637	19059	44	on	on	IN
18637	19059	45	the	the	DT
18637	19059	46	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19059	47	of	of	IN
18637	19059	48	contingent	contingent	JJ
18637	19059	49	remainders	remainder	NNS
18637	19059	50	,	,	,
18637	19059	51	undiminished	undiminishe	VBN
18637	19059	52	by	by	IN
18637	19059	53	the	the	DT
18637	19059	54	value	value	NN
18637	19059	55	of	of	IN
18637	19059	56	an	an	DT
18637	19059	57	intervening	intervene	VBG
18637	19059	58	life	life	NN
18637	19059	59	estate	estate	NN
18637	19059	60	but	but	CC
18637	19059	61	not	not	RB
18637	19059	62	payable	payable	JJ
18637	19059	63	until	until	IN
18637	19059	64	after	after	IN
18637	19059	65	the	the	DT
18637	19059	66	death	death	NN
18637	19059	67	of	of	IN
18637	19059	68	the	the	DT
18637	19059	69	life	life	NN
18637	19059	70	tenant	tenant	NN
18637	19059	71	,	,	,
18637	19059	72	is	be	VBZ
18637	19059	73	valid	valid	JJ
18637	19059	74	.	.	.
18637	19060	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19060	2	466	466	CD
18637	19060	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19060	4	Also	also	RB
18637	19060	5	,	,	,
18637	19060	6	when	when	WRB
18637	19060	7	a	a	DT
18637	19060	8	power	power	NN
18637	19060	9	of	of	IN
18637	19060	10	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	19060	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	19060	12	been	be	VBN
18637	19060	13	granted	grant	VBN
18637	19060	14	by	by	IN
18637	19060	15	deed	deed	NN
18637	19060	16	,	,	,
18637	19060	17	transfer	transfer	VB
18637	19060	18	tax	tax	NN
18637	19060	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	19060	20	the	the	DT
18637	19060	21	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19060	22	of	of	IN
18637	19060	23	the	the	DT
18637	19060	24	power	power	NN
18637	19060	25	by	by	IN
18637	19060	26	will	will	MD
18637	19060	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	19060	28	not	not	RB
18637	19060	29	a	a	DT
18637	19060	30	taking	taking	NN
18637	19060	31	of	of	IN
18637	19060	32	property	property	NN
18637	19060	33	without	without	IN
18637	19060	34	due	due	JJ
18637	19060	35	process	process	NN
18637	19060	36	of	of	IN
18637	19060	37	law	law	NN
18637	19060	38	,	,	,
18637	19060	39	even	even	RB
18637	19060	40	though	though	IN
18637	19060	41	the	the	DT
18637	19060	42	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	19060	43	creating	create	VBG
18637	19060	44	the	the	DT
18637	19060	45	power	power	NN
18637	19060	46	was	be	VBD
18637	19060	47	executed	execute	VBN
18637	19060	48	prior	prior	RB
18637	19060	49	to	to	IN
18637	19060	50	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	19060	51	of	of	IN
18637	19060	52	the	the	DT
18637	19060	53	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19060	54	statute	statute	NN
18637	19060	55	.	.	.
18637	19061	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19061	2	467	467	CD
18637	19061	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19061	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19061	5	when	when	WRB
18637	19061	6	a	a	DT
18637	19061	7	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19061	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	19061	9	law	law	NN
18637	19061	10	did	do	VBD
18637	19061	11	not	not	RB
18637	19061	12	become	become	VB
18637	19061	13	effective	effective	JJ
18637	19061	14	until	until	IN
18637	19061	15	after	after	IN
18637	19061	16	a	a	DT
18637	19061	17	deed	deed	NN
18637	19061	18	creating	create	VBG
18637	19061	19	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19061	20	remainders	remainder	NNS
18637	19061	21	had	have	VBD
18637	19061	22	been	be	VBN
18637	19061	23	executed	execute	VBN
18637	19061	24	,	,	,
18637	19061	25	but	but	CC
18637	19061	26	the	the	DT
18637	19061	27	State	State	NNP
18637	19061	28	court	court	NN
18637	19061	29	applied	apply	VBD
18637	19061	30	the	the	DT
18637	19061	31	tax	tax	NN
18637	19061	32	on	on	IN
18637	19061	33	the	the	DT
18637	19061	34	theory	theory	NN
18637	19061	35	that	that	IN
18637	19061	36	the	the	DT
18637	19061	37	vesting	vesting	NN
18637	19061	38	actually	actually	RB
18637	19061	39	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	19061	40	after	after	IN
18637	19061	41	the	the	DT
18637	19061	42	tax	tax	NN
18637	19061	43	law	law	NN
18637	19061	44	became	become	VBD
18637	19061	45	operative	operative	JJ
18637	19061	46	,	,	,
18637	19061	47	no	no	DT
18637	19061	48	denial	denial	NN
18637	19061	49	of	of	IN
18637	19061	50	due	due	JJ
18637	19061	51	process	process	NN
18637	19061	52	resulted	result	VBD
18637	19061	53	.	.	.
18637	19062	1	"	"	``
18637	19062	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19062	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19062	4	*	*	NFP
18637	19062	5	,	,	,
18637	19062	6	the	the	DT
18637	19062	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	19062	8	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
18637	19062	9	might	may	MD
18637	19062	10	have	have	VB
18637	19062	11	made	make	VBN
18637	19062	12	the	the	DT
18637	19062	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	19062	14	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	19062	15	to	to	IN
18637	19062	16	this	this	DT
18637	19062	17	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19062	18	,	,	,
18637	19062	19	*	*	NFP
18637	19062	20	*	*	NFP
18637	19062	21	*	*	NFP
18637	19062	22	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19062	23	and	and	CC
18637	19062	24	the	the	DT
18637	19062	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19062	26	need	need	NN
18637	19062	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19062	28	*	*	NFP
18637	19062	29	*	*	NFP
18637	19062	30	*	*	NFP
18637	19062	31	not	not	RB
18637	19062	32	inquire	inquire	RB
18637	19062	33	*	*	NFP
18637	19062	34	*	*	NFP
18637	19062	35	*	*	NFP
18637	19062	36	into	into	IN
18637	19062	37	the	the	DT
18637	19062	38	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	19062	39	by	by	IN
18637	19062	40	which	which	WDT
18637	19062	41	*	*	NFP
18637	19062	42	*	*	NFP
18637	19062	43	*	*	NFP
18637	19062	44	"	"	``
18637	19062	45	the	the	DT
18637	19062	46	State	State	NNP
18637	19062	47	held	hold	VBD
18637	19062	48	the	the	DT
18637	19062	49	statute	statute	NN
18637	19062	50	operative	operative	NN
18637	19062	51	.	.	.
18637	19063	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19063	2	468	468	CD
18637	19063	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19063	4	On	on	IN
18637	19063	5	the	the	DT
18637	19063	6	other	other	JJ
18637	19063	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	19063	8	,	,	,
18637	19063	9	when	when	WRB
18637	19063	10	remainders	remainder	NNS
18637	19063	11	indisputably	indisputably	RB
18637	19063	12	vest	vest	VBP
18637	19063	13	at	at	IN
18637	19063	14	the	the	DT
18637	19063	15	time	time	NN
18637	19063	16	of	of	IN
18637	19063	17	the	the	DT
18637	19063	18	creation	creation	NN
18637	19063	19	of	of	IN
18637	19063	20	a	a	DT
18637	19063	21	trust	trust	NN
18637	19063	22	and	and	CC
18637	19063	23	a	a	DT
18637	19063	24	succession	succession	NN
18637	19063	25	tax	tax	NN
18637	19063	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	19063	27	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	19063	28	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	19063	29	,	,	,
18637	19063	30	the	the	DT
18637	19063	31	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	19063	32	of	of	IN
18637	19063	33	said	say	VBN
18637	19063	34	tax	tax	NN
18637	19063	35	on	on	IN
18637	19063	36	the	the	DT
18637	19063	37	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19063	38	of	of	IN
18637	19063	39	such	such	JJ
18637	19063	40	remainder	remainder	NN
18637	19063	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	19063	42	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19063	43	.	.	.
18637	19064	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19064	2	469	469	CD
18637	19064	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19064	4	But	but	CC
18637	19064	5	where	where	WRB
18637	19064	6	the	the	DT
18637	19064	7	remaindermen	remainderman	NNS
18637	19064	8	's	's	POS
18637	19064	9	interests	interest	NNS
18637	19064	10	are	be	VBP
18637	19064	11	contingent	contingent	JJ
18637	19064	12	and	and	CC
18637	19064	13	do	do	VBP
18637	19064	14	not	not	RB
18637	19064	15	vest	vest	VB
18637	19064	16	until	until	IN
18637	19064	17	the	the	DT
18637	19064	18	donor	donor	NN
18637	19064	19	's	's	POS
18637	19064	20	death	death	NN
18637	19064	21	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	19064	22	to	to	IN
18637	19064	23	the	the	DT
18637	19064	24	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	19064	25	of	of	IN
18637	19064	26	the	the	DT
18637	19064	27	statute	statute	NN
18637	19064	28	,	,	,
18637	19064	29	the	the	DT
18637	19064	30	tax	tax	NN
18637	19064	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	19064	32	valid	valid	JJ
18637	19064	33	.	.	.
18637	19065	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19065	2	470	470	CD
18637	19065	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19065	4	Another	another	DT
18637	19065	5	example	example	NN
18637	19065	6	of	of	IN
18637	19065	7	valid	valid	JJ
18637	19065	8	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	19065	9	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19065	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	19065	11	to	to	TO
18637	19065	12	be	be	VB
18637	19065	13	found	find	VBN
18637	19065	14	in	in	IN
18637	19065	15	a	a	DT
18637	19065	16	New	New	NNP
18637	19065	17	York	York	NNP
18637	19065	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	19065	19	amending	amend	VBG
18637	19065	20	a	a	DT
18637	19065	21	1930	1930	CD
18637	19065	22	estate	estate	NN
18637	19065	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	19065	24	law	law	NN
18637	19065	25	.	.	.
18637	19066	1	The	the	DT
18637	19066	2	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	19066	3	required	require	VBN
18637	19066	4	inclusion	inclusion	NN
18637	19066	5	in	in	IN
18637	19066	6	the	the	DT
18637	19066	7	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19066	8	's	's	POS
18637	19066	9	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19066	10	estate	estate	NN
18637	19066	11	,	,	,
18637	19066	12	for	for	IN
18637	19066	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	19066	14	computation	computation	NN
18637	19066	15	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19066	16	,	,	,
18637	19066	17	of	of	IN
18637	19066	18	property	property	NN
18637	19066	19	in	in	IN
18637	19066	20	respect	respect	NN
18637	19066	21	of	of	IN
18637	19066	22	which	which	WDT
18637	19066	23	the	the	DT
18637	19066	24	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19066	25	exercised	exercise	VBD
18637	19066	26	after	after	IN
18637	19066	27	1930	1930	CD
18637	19066	28	,	,	,
18637	19066	29	by	by	IN
18637	19066	30	will	will	NN
18637	19066	31	,	,	,
18637	19066	32	a	a	DT
18637	19066	33	nongeneral	nongeneral	JJ
18637	19066	34	power	power	NN
18637	19066	35	of	of	IN
18637	19066	36	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	19066	37	created	create	VBD
18637	19066	38	prior	prior	RB
18637	19066	39	to	to	IN
18637	19066	40	that	that	DT
18637	19066	41	year	year	NN
18637	19066	42	.	.	.
18637	19067	1	The	the	DT
18637	19067	2	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	19067	3	reached	reach	VBD
18637	19067	4	such	such	JJ
18637	19067	5	transfers	transfer	NNS
18637	19067	6	under	under	IN
18637	19067	7	powers	power	NNS
18637	19067	8	of	of	IN
18637	19067	9	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	19067	10	as	as	IN
18637	19067	11	under	under	IN
18637	19067	12	the	the	DT
18637	19067	13	previous	previous	JJ
18637	19067	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	19067	15	escaped	escape	VBD
18637	19067	16	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19067	17	.	.	.
18637	19068	1	In	in	IN
18637	19068	2	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	19068	3	application	application	NN
18637	19068	4	of	of	IN
18637	19068	5	the	the	DT
18637	19068	6	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	19068	7	,	,	,
18637	19068	8	the	the	DT
18637	19068	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19068	10	held	hold	VBD
18637	19068	11	that	that	IN
18637	19068	12	the	the	DT
18637	19068	13	inclusion	inclusion	NN
18637	19068	14	in	in	IN
18637	19068	15	the	the	DT
18637	19068	16	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19068	17	estate	estate	NN
18637	19068	18	of	of	IN
18637	19068	19	property	property	NN
18637	19068	20	never	never	RB
18637	19068	21	owned	own	VBN
18637	19068	22	by	by	IN
18637	19068	23	the	the	DT
18637	19068	24	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19068	25	,	,	,
18637	19068	26	but	but	CC
18637	19068	27	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	19068	28	by	by	IN
18637	19068	29	her	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19068	30	will	will	NN
18637	19068	31	under	under	IN
18637	19068	32	a	a	DT
18637	19068	33	limited	limited	JJ
18637	19068	34	power	power	NN
18637	19068	35	which	which	WDT
18637	19068	36	could	could	MD
18637	19068	37	not	not	RB
18637	19068	38	be	be	VB
18637	19068	39	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	19068	40	in	in	IN
18637	19068	41	favor	favor	NN
18637	19068	42	of	of	IN
18637	19068	43	the	the	DT
18637	19068	44	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19068	45	,	,	,
18637	19068	46	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19068	47	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	19068	48	,	,	,
18637	19068	49	or	or	CC
18637	19068	50	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19068	51	estate	estate	NN
18637	19068	52	,	,	,
18637	19068	53	did	do	VBD
18637	19068	54	not	not	RB
18637	19068	55	deny	deny	VB
18637	19068	56	due	due	JJ
18637	19068	57	process	process	NN
18637	19068	58	to	to	IN
18637	19068	59	those	those	DT
18637	19068	60	who	who	WP
18637	19068	61	inherited	inherit	VBD
18637	19068	62	the	the	DT
18637	19068	63	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19068	64	's	's	POS
18637	19068	65	property	property	NN
18637	19068	66	,	,	,
18637	19068	67	even	even	RB
18637	19068	68	though	though	RB
18637	19068	69	,	,	,
18637	19068	70	because	because	IN
18637	19068	71	the	the	DT
18637	19068	72	tax	tax	NN
18637	19068	73	rate	rate	NN
18637	19068	74	was	be	VBD
18637	19068	75	progressive	progressive	JJ
18637	19068	76	,	,	,
18637	19068	77	the	the	DT
18637	19068	78	net	net	JJ
18637	19068	79	amount	amount	NN
18637	19068	80	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19068	81	inherited	inherit	VBD
18637	19068	82	was	be	VBD
18637	19068	83	less	less	JJR
18637	19068	84	than	than	IN
18637	19068	85	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19068	86	would	would	MD
18637	19068	87	have	have	VB
18637	19068	88	been	be	VBN
18637	19068	89	if	if	IN
18637	19068	90	the	the	DT
18637	19068	91	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	19068	92	property	property	NN
18637	19068	93	had	have	VBD
18637	19068	94	not	not	RB
18637	19068	95	been	be	VBN
18637	19068	96	included	include	VBN
18637	19068	97	in	in	IN
18637	19068	98	the	the	DT
18637	19068	99	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19068	100	estate	estate	NN
18637	19068	101	.	.	.
18637	19069	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19069	2	471	471	CD
18637	19069	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19069	4	In	in	IN
18637	19069	5	summation	summation	NN
18637	19069	6	,	,	,
18637	19069	7	the	the	DT
18637	19069	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19069	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	19069	10	noted	note	VBN
18637	19069	11	that	that	IN
18637	19069	12	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	19069	13	as	as	IN
18637	19069	14	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	19069	15	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19069	16	of	of	IN
18637	19069	17	vested	vest	VBN
18637	19069	18	gifts	gift	NNS
18637	19069	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	19069	20	been	be	VBN
18637	19069	21	voided	void	VBN
18637	19069	22	,	,	,
18637	19069	23	the	the	DT
18637	19069	24	justification	justification	NN
18637	19069	25	therefor	therefor	RB
18637	19069	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	19069	27	been	be	VBN
18637	19069	28	that	that	IN
18637	19069	29	"	"	``
18637	19069	30	the	the	DT
18637	19069	31	nature	nature	NN
18637	19069	32	or	or	CC
18637	19069	33	amount	amount	NN
18637	19069	34	of	of	IN
18637	19069	35	the	the	DT
18637	19069	36	tax	tax	NN
18637	19069	37	could	could	MD
18637	19069	38	not	not	RB
18637	19069	39	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	19069	40	have	have	VB
18637	19069	41	been	be	VBN
18637	19069	42	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
18637	19069	43	by	by	IN
18637	19069	44	the	the	DT
18637	19069	45	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	19069	46	at	at	IN
18637	19069	47	the	the	DT
18637	19069	48	time	time	NN
18637	19069	49	of	of	IN
18637	19069	50	the	the	DT
18637	19069	51	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19069	52	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	19069	53	act	act	NN
18637	19069	54	which	which	WDT
18637	19069	55	the	the	DT
18637	19069	56	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19069	57	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	19069	58	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19069	59	statute	statute	NN
18637	19069	60	later	later	RB
18637	19069	61	made	make	VBD
18637	19069	62	the	the	DT
18637	19069	63	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	19069	64	event	event	NN
18637	19069	65	*	*	NFP
18637	19069	66	*	*	NFP
18637	19069	67	*	*	NFP
18637	19069	68	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19069	69	,	,	,
18637	19069	70	*	*	NFP
18637	19069	71	*	*	NFP
18637	19069	72	*	*	NFP
18637	19069	73	,	,	,
18637	19069	74	of	of	IN
18637	19069	75	a	a	DT
18637	19069	76	gift	gift	NN
18637	19069	77	which	which	WDT
18637	19069	78	*	*	NFP
18637	19069	79	*	*	NFP
18637	19069	80	*	*	NFP
18637	19069	81	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19069	82	the	the	DT
18637	19069	83	donor	donor	NN
18637	19069	84	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19069	85	might	may	MD
18637	19069	86	well	well	RB
18637	19069	87	have	have	VB
18637	19069	88	refrained	refrain	VBN
18637	19069	89	from	from	IN
18637	19069	90	making	make	VBG
18637	19069	91	had	have	VBD
18637	19069	92	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19069	93	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
18637	19069	94	the	the	DT
18637	19069	95	tax	tax	NN
18637	19069	96	,	,	,
18637	19069	97	*	*	NFP
18637	19069	98	*	*	NFP
18637	19069	99	*	*	NFP
18637	19069	100	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19069	101	is	be	VBZ
18637	19069	102	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19069	103	thought	think	VBN
18637	19069	104	to	to	TO
18637	19069	105	be	be	VB
18637	19069	106	so	so	RB
18637	19069	107	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19069	108	*	*	NFP
18637	19069	109	*	*	NFP
18637	19069	110	*	*	NFP
18637	19069	111	as	as	IN
18637	19069	112	to	to	TO
18637	19069	113	be	be	VB
18637	19069	114	a	a	DT
18637	19069	115	denial	denial	NN
18637	19069	116	of	of	IN
18637	19069	117	due	due	JJ
18637	19069	118	process	process	NN
18637	19069	119	.	.	.
18637	19070	1	"	"	``
18637	19070	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19070	3	472	472	CD
18637	19070	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19070	5	Other	other	JJ
18637	19070	6	Types	type	NNS
18637	19070	7	of	of	IN
18637	19070	8	Taxes	Taxes	NNP
18637	19070	9	Income	Income	NNP
18637	19070	10	Taxes.--Any	Taxes.--Any	NNP
18637	19070	11	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	19070	12	by	by	IN
18637	19070	13	a	a	DT
18637	19070	14	State	State	NNP
18637	19070	15	to	to	TO
18637	19070	16	measure	measure	VB
18637	19070	17	a	a	DT
18637	19070	18	tax	tax	NN
18637	19070	19	on	on	IN
18637	19070	20	one	one	CD
18637	19070	21	person	person	NN
18637	19070	22	's	's	POS
18637	19070	23	income	income	NN
18637	19070	24	by	by	IN
18637	19070	25	reference	reference	NN
18637	19070	26	to	to	IN
18637	19070	27	the	the	DT
18637	19070	28	income	income	NN
18637	19070	29	of	of	IN
18637	19070	30	another	another	DT
18637	19070	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	19070	32	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	19070	33	to	to	IN
18637	19070	34	due	due	JJ
18637	19070	35	process	process	NN
18637	19070	36	as	as	IN
18637	19070	37	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	19070	38	by	by	IN
18637	19070	39	the	the	DT
18637	19070	40	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19070	41	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19070	42	.	.	.
18637	19071	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19071	2	a	a	DT
18637	19071	3	husband	husband	NN
18637	19071	4	can	can	MD
18637	19071	5	not	not	RB
18637	19071	6	be	be	VB
18637	19071	7	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19071	8	on	on	IN
18637	19071	9	the	the	DT
18637	19071	10	combined	combine	VBN
18637	19071	11	total	total	NN
18637	19071	12	of	of	IN
18637	19071	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19071	14	and	and	CC
18637	19071	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19071	16	wife	wife	NN
18637	19071	17	's	's	POS
18637	19071	18	incomes	income	NNS
18637	19071	19	as	as	IN
18637	19071	20	shown	show	VBN
18637	19071	21	by	by	IN
18637	19071	22	separate	separate	JJ
18637	19071	23	returns	return	NNS
18637	19071	24	,	,	,
18637	19071	25	where	where	WRB
18637	19071	26	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19071	27	income	income	NN
18637	19071	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	19071	29	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19071	30	separate	separate	JJ
18637	19071	31	property	property	NN
18637	19071	32	and	and	CC
18637	19071	33	where	where	WRB
18637	19071	34	,	,	,
18637	19071	35	by	by	IN
18637	19071	36	reason	reason	NN
18637	19071	37	of	of	IN
18637	19071	38	the	the	DT
18637	19071	39	tax	tax	NN
18637	19071	40	being	be	VBG
18637	19071	41	graduated	graduate	VBN
18637	19071	42	,	,	,
18637	19071	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19071	44	amount	amount	NN
18637	19071	45	exceeded	exceed	VBD
18637	19071	46	the	the	DT
18637	19071	47	sum	sum	NN
18637	19071	48	of	of	IN
18637	19071	49	the	the	DT
18637	19071	50	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19071	51	which	which	WDT
18637	19071	52	would	would	MD
18637	19071	53	have	have	VB
18637	19071	54	been	be	VBN
18637	19071	55	due	due	JJ
18637	19071	56	had	have	VBD
18637	19071	57	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19071	58	separate	separate	JJ
18637	19071	59	incomes	income	NNS
18637	19071	60	been	be	VBN
18637	19071	61	separately	separately	RB
18637	19071	62	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	19071	63	.	.	.
18637	19072	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19072	2	473	473	CD
18637	19072	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19072	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	19072	5	,	,	,
18637	19072	6	a	a	DT
18637	19072	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	19072	8	on	on	IN
18637	19072	9	income	income	NN
18637	19072	10	,	,	,
18637	19072	11	unlike	unlike	IN
18637	19072	12	a	a	DT
18637	19072	13	gift	gift	NN
18637	19072	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	19072	15	,	,	,
18637	19072	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	19072	17	not	not	RB
18637	19072	18	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	19072	19	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19072	20	,	,	,
18637	19072	21	because	because	IN
18637	19072	22	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	19072	23	.	.	.
18637	19073	1	Taxpayers	taxpayer	NNS
18637	19073	2	can	can	MD
18637	19073	3	not	not	RB
18637	19073	4	complain	complain	VB
18637	19073	5	of	of	IN
18637	19073	6	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19073	7	action	action	NN
18637	19073	8	or	or	CC
18637	19073	9	assert	assert	NN
18637	19073	10	surprise	surprise	NN
18637	19073	11	in	in	IN
18637	19073	12	the	the	DT
18637	19073	13	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	19073	14	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	19073	15	of	of	IN
18637	19073	16	tax	tax	NN
18637	19073	17	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	19073	18	to	to	TO
18637	19073	19	income	income	VB
18637	19073	20	when	when	WRB
18637	19073	21	that	that	DT
18637	19073	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	19073	23	done	do	VBN
18637	19073	24	by	by	IN
18637	19073	25	the	the	DT
18637	19073	26	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	19073	27	at	at	IN
18637	19073	28	the	the	DT
18637	19073	29	first	first	JJ
18637	19073	30	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19073	31	after	after	IN
18637	19073	32	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	19073	33	of	of	IN
18637	19073	34	the	the	DT
18637	19073	35	nature	nature	NN
18637	19073	36	and	and	CC
18637	19073	37	amount	amount	NN
18637	19073	38	of	of	IN
18637	19073	39	the	the	DT
18637	19073	40	income	income	NN
18637	19073	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	19073	42	available	available	JJ
18637	19073	43	.	.	.
18637	19074	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19074	2	474	474	CD
18637	19074	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19074	4	Franchise	Franchise	NNP
18637	19074	5	Taxes.--A	taxes.--a	CD
18637	19074	6	city	city	NN
18637	19074	7	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	19074	8	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	19074	9	annual	annual	JJ
18637	19074	10	license	license	NN
18637	19074	11	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19074	12	on	on	IN
18637	19074	13	light	light	NN
18637	19074	14	and	and	CC
18637	19074	15	power	power	NN
18637	19074	16	companies	company	NNS
18637	19074	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	19074	18	not	not	RB
18637	19074	19	violative	violative	JJ
18637	19074	20	of	of	IN
18637	19074	21	the	the	DT
18637	19074	22	due	due	JJ
18637	19074	23	process	process	NN
18637	19074	24	clause	clause	NN
18637	19074	25	merely	merely	RB
18637	19074	26	because	because	IN
18637	19074	27	the	the	DT
18637	19074	28	city	city	NN
18637	19074	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	19074	30	entered	enter	VBN
18637	19074	31	the	the	DT
18637	19074	32	power	power	NN
18637	19074	33	business	business	NN
18637	19074	34	in	in	IN
18637	19074	35	competition	competition	NN
18637	19074	36	with	with	IN
18637	19074	37	such	such	JJ
18637	19074	38	companies	company	NNS
18637	19074	39	.	.	.
18637	19075	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19075	2	475	475	CD
18637	19075	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19075	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19075	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	19075	6	a	a	DT
18637	19075	7	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	19075	8	charter	charter	NN
18637	19075	9	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	19075	10	the	the	DT
18637	19075	11	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	19075	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	19075	13	a	a	DT
18637	19075	14	local	local	JJ
18637	19075	15	telegraph	telegraph	NN
18637	19075	16	company	company	NN
18637	19075	17	of	of	IN
18637	19075	18	a	a	DT
18637	19075	19	tax	tax	NN
18637	19075	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	19075	21	the	the	DT
18637	19075	22	lines	line	NNS
18637	19075	23	of	of	IN
18637	19075	24	the	the	DT
18637	19075	25	company	company	NN
18637	19075	26	within	within	IN
18637	19075	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19075	28	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19075	29	at	at	IN
18637	19075	30	the	the	DT
18637	19075	31	rate	rate	NN
18637	19075	32	at	at	IN
18637	19075	33	which	which	WDT
18637	19075	34	other	other	JJ
18637	19075	35	property	property	NN
18637	19075	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	19075	37	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19075	38	,	,	,
18637	19075	39	but	but	CC
18637	19075	40	upon	upon	IN
18637	19075	41	an	an	DT
18637	19075	42	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19075	43	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	19075	44	per	per	IN
18637	19075	45	mile	mile	NN
18637	19075	46	,	,	,
18637	19075	47	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	19075	48	the	the	DT
18637	19075	49	company	company	NN
18637	19075	50	of	of	IN
18637	19075	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19075	52	property	property	NN
18637	19075	53	without	without	IN
18637	19075	54	due	due	JJ
18637	19075	55	process	process	NN
18637	19075	56	of	of	IN
18637	19075	57	law	law	NN
18637	19075	58	,	,	,
18637	19075	59	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	19075	60	as	as	IN
18637	19075	61	the	the	DT
18637	19075	62	tax	tax	NN
18637	19075	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	19075	64	a	a	DT
18637	19075	65	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19075	66	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	19075	67	or	or	CC
18637	19075	68	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19075	69	tax	tax	NN
18637	19075	70	.	.	.
18637	19076	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19076	2	476	476	CD
18637	19076	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19076	4	Severance	severance	NN
18637	19076	5	Taxes.--A	taxes.--a	CD
18637	19076	6	State	state	NN
18637	19076	7	excise	excise	NN
18637	19076	8	on	on	IN
18637	19076	9	the	the	DT
18637	19076	10	production	production	NN
18637	19076	11	of	of	IN
18637	19076	12	oil	oil	NN
18637	19076	13	which	which	WDT
18637	19076	14	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	19076	15	to	to	IN
18637	19076	16	the	the	DT
18637	19076	17	royalty	royalty	NN
18637	19076	18	interest	interest	NN
18637	19076	19	of	of	IN
18637	19076	20	the	the	DT
18637	19076	21	lessor	lessor	NN
18637	19076	22	in	in	IN
18637	19076	23	the	the	DT
18637	19076	24	oil	oil	NN
18637	19076	25	produced	produce	VBN
18637	19076	26	under	under	IN
18637	19076	27	an	an	DT
18637	19076	28	oil	oil	NN
18637	19076	29	lease	lease	NN
18637	19076	30	as	as	RB
18637	19076	31	well	well	RB
18637	19076	32	as	as	IN
18637	19076	33	to	to	IN
18637	19076	34	the	the	DT
18637	19076	35	interest	interest	NN
18637	19076	36	of	of	IN
18637	19076	37	the	the	DT
18637	19076	38	lessee	lessee	NN
18637	19076	39	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	19076	40	in	in	IN
18637	19076	41	the	the	DT
18637	19076	42	active	active	JJ
18637	19076	43	work	work	NN
18637	19076	44	of	of	IN
18637	19076	45	production	production	NN
18637	19076	46	,	,	,
18637	19076	47	the	the	DT
18637	19076	48	tax	tax	NN
18637	19076	49	being	be	VBG
18637	19076	50	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	19076	51	between	between	IN
18637	19076	52	these	these	DT
18637	19076	53	parties	party	NNS
18637	19076	54	according	accord	VBG
18637	19076	55	to	to	IN
18637	19076	56	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19076	57	respective	respective	JJ
18637	19076	58	interest	interest	NN
18637	19076	59	in	in	IN
18637	19076	60	the	the	DT
18637	19076	61	common	common	JJ
18637	19076	62	venture	venture	NN
18637	19076	63	,	,	,
18637	19076	64	is	be	VBZ
18637	19076	65	not	not	RB
18637	19076	66	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19076	67	as	as	IN
18637	19076	68	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	19076	69	the	the	DT
18637	19076	70	lessor	lessor	NN
18637	19076	71	,	,	,
18637	19076	72	but	but	CC
18637	19076	73	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	19076	74	with	with	IN
18637	19076	75	due	due	JJ
18637	19076	76	process	process	NN
18637	19076	77	.	.	.
18637	19077	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19077	2	477	477	CD
18637	19077	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19077	4	Real	real	JJ
18637	19077	5	Property	property	NN
18637	19077	6	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19077	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19077	8	Assessment).--The	assessment).--the	DT
18637	19077	9	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	19077	10	of	of	IN
18637	19077	11	a	a	DT
18637	19077	12	high	high	JJ
18637	19077	13	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19077	14	in	in	IN
18637	19077	15	the	the	DT
18637	19077	16	face	face	NN
18637	19077	17	of	of	IN
18637	19077	18	declining	decline	VBG
18637	19077	19	value	value	NN
18637	19077	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	19077	21	merely	merely	RB
18637	19077	22	another	another	DT
18637	19077	23	way	way	NN
18637	19077	24	of	of	IN
18637	19077	25	achieving	achieve	VBG
18637	19077	26	an	an	DT
18637	19077	27	increase	increase	NN
18637	19077	28	in	in	IN
18637	19077	29	the	the	DT
18637	19077	30	rate	rate	NN
18637	19077	31	of	of	IN
18637	19077	32	property	property	NN
18637	19077	33	tax	tax	NN
18637	19077	34	.	.	.
18637	19078	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	19078	2	,	,	,
18637	19078	3	an	an	DT
18637	19078	4	over	over	IN
18637	19078	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	19078	6	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19078	7	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	19078	8	no	no	DT
18637	19078	9	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19078	10	of	of	IN
18637	19078	11	property	property	NN
18637	19078	12	without	without	IN
18637	19078	13	due	due	JJ
18637	19078	14	process	process	NN
18637	19078	15	of	of	IN
18637	19078	16	law	law	NN
18637	19078	17	.	.	.
18637	19079	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19079	2	478	478	CD
18637	19079	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19079	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19079	5	,	,	,
18637	19079	6	land	land	NN
18637	19079	7	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19079	8	to	to	IN
18637	19079	9	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	19079	10	may	may	MD
18637	19079	11	be	be	VB
18637	19079	12	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19079	13	for	for	IN
18637	19079	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19079	15	full	full	JJ
18637	19079	16	value	value	NN
18637	19079	17	without	without	IN
18637	19079	18	deduction	deduction	NN
18637	19079	19	of	of	IN
18637	19079	20	the	the	DT
18637	19079	21	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	19079	22	debt	debt	NN
18637	19079	23	from	from	IN
18637	19079	24	the	the	DT
18637	19079	25	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	19079	26	.	.	.
18637	19080	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19080	2	479	479	CD
18637	19080	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19080	4	Real	real	JJ
18637	19080	5	Property	property	NN
18637	19080	6	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19080	7	:	:	:
18637	19080	8	Special	special	JJ
18637	19080	9	Assessments.--A	assessments.--a	NN
18637	19080	10	State	State	NNP
18637	19080	11	may	may	MD
18637	19080	12	defray	defray	VB
18637	19080	13	the	the	DT
18637	19080	14	entire	entire	JJ
18637	19080	15	expense	expense	NN
18637	19080	16	of	of	IN
18637	19080	17	creating	create	VBG
18637	19080	18	,	,	,
18637	19080	19	developing	develop	VBG
18637	19080	20	,	,	,
18637	19080	21	and	and	CC
18637	19080	22	improving	improve	VBG
18637	19080	23	a	a	DT
18637	19080	24	political	political	JJ
18637	19080	25	subdivision	subdivision	NN
18637	19080	26	either	either	CC
18637	19080	27	from	from	IN
18637	19080	28	funds	fund	NNS
18637	19080	29	raised	raise	VBN
18637	19080	30	by	by	IN
18637	19080	31	general	general	JJ
18637	19080	32	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19080	33	,	,	,
18637	19080	34	or	or	CC
18637	19080	35	by	by	IN
18637	19080	36	apportioning	apportion	VBG
18637	19080	37	the	the	DT
18637	19080	38	burden	burden	NN
18637	19080	39	among	among	IN
18637	19080	40	the	the	DT
18637	19080	41	municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	19080	42	in	in	IN
18637	19080	43	which	which	WDT
18637	19080	44	the	the	DT
18637	19080	45	improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	19080	46	are	be	VBP
18637	19080	47	made	make	VBN
18637	19080	48	,	,	,
18637	19080	49	or	or	CC
18637	19080	50	by	by	IN
18637	19080	51	creating	create	VBG
18637	19080	52	,	,	,
18637	19080	53	or	or	CC
18637	19080	54	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	19080	55	the	the	DT
18637	19080	56	creation	creation	NN
18637	19080	57	of	of	IN
18637	19080	58	,	,	,
18637	19080	59	tax	tax	NN
18637	19080	60	districts	district	NNS
18637	19080	61	to	to	TO
18637	19080	62	meet	meet	VB
18637	19080	63	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
18637	19080	64	outlays	outlay	NNS
18637	19080	65	.	.	.
18637	19081	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19081	2	480	480	CD
18637	19081	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19081	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	19081	5	a	a	DT
18637	19081	6	State	State	NNP
18637	19081	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	19081	8	authorizes	authorize	VBZ
18637	19081	9	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	19081	10	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	19081	11	to	to	TO
18637	19081	12	define	define	VB
18637	19081	13	the	the	DT
18637	19081	14	district	district	NN
18637	19081	15	to	to	TO
18637	19081	16	be	be	VB
18637	19081	17	benefited	benefit	VBN
18637	19081	18	by	by	IN
18637	19081	19	a	a	DT
18637	19081	20	street	street	NN
18637	19081	21	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	19081	22	and	and	CC
18637	19081	23	to	to	TO
18637	19081	24	assess	assess	VB
18637	19081	25	the	the	DT
18637	19081	26	cost	cost	NN
18637	19081	27	of	of	IN
18637	19081	28	the	the	DT
18637	19081	29	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	19081	30	upon	upon	IN
18637	19081	31	the	the	DT
18637	19081	32	property	property	NN
18637	19081	33	within	within	IN
18637	19081	34	the	the	DT
18637	19081	35	district	district	NN
18637	19081	36	in	in	IN
18637	19081	37	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	19081	38	to	to	IN
18637	19081	39	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	19081	40	,	,	,
18637	19081	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19081	42	action	action	NN
18637	19081	43	in	in	IN
18637	19081	44	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	19081	45	the	the	DT
18637	19081	46	district	district	NN
18637	19081	47	and	and	CC
18637	19081	48	in	in	IN
18637	19081	49	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	19081	50	the	the	DT
18637	19081	51	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	19081	52	on	on	IN
18637	19081	53	included	include	VBN
18637	19081	54	property	property	NN
18637	19081	55	,	,	,
18637	19081	56	after	after	IN
18637	19081	57	due	due	JJ
18637	19081	58	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19081	59	of	of	IN
18637	19081	60	the	the	DT
18637	19081	61	owners	owner	NNS
18637	19081	62	as	as	IN
18637	19081	63	required	require	VBN
18637	19081	64	by	by	IN
18637	19081	65	the	the	DT
18637	19081	66	statute	statute	NN
18637	19081	67	can	can	MD
18637	19081	68	not	not	RB
18637	19081	69	,	,	,
18637	19081	70	when	when	WRB
18637	19081	71	not	not	RB
18637	19081	72	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19081	73	or	or	CC
18637	19081	74	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	19081	75	,	,	,
18637	19081	76	be	be	VB
18637	19081	77	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	19081	78	under	under	IN
18637	19081	79	the	the	DT
18637	19081	80	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19081	81	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19081	82	upon	upon	IN
18637	19081	83	the	the	DT
18637	19081	84	ground	ground	NN
18637	19081	85	that	that	IN
18637	19081	86	other	other	JJ
18637	19081	87	property	property	NN
18637	19081	88	benefited	benefit	VBN
18637	19081	89	by	by	IN
18637	19081	90	the	the	DT
18637	19081	91	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	19081	92	was	be	VBD
18637	19081	93	not	not	RB
18637	19081	94	included	include	VBN
18637	19081	95	.	.	.
18637	19082	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19082	2	481	481	CD
18637	19082	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19082	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19082	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19082	6	also	also	RB
18637	19082	7	proper	proper	JJ
18637	19082	8	to	to	TO
18637	19082	9	impose	impose	VB
18637	19082	10	a	a	DT
18637	19082	11	special	special	JJ
18637	19082	12	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19082	13	for	for	IN
18637	19082	14	the	the	DT
18637	19082	15	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	19082	16	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	19082	17	of	of	IN
18637	19082	18	an	an	DT
18637	19082	19	abandoned	abandon	VBN
18637	19082	20	road	road	NN
18637	19082	21	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	19082	22	,	,	,
18637	19082	23	even	even	RB
18637	19082	24	though	though	IN
18637	19082	25	the	the	DT
18637	19082	26	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19082	27	exceeds	exceed	VBZ
18637	19082	28	the	the	DT
18637	19082	29	amount	amount	NN
18637	19082	30	of	of	IN
18637	19082	31	the	the	DT
18637	19082	32	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19082	33	which	which	WDT
18637	19082	34	the	the	DT
18637	19082	35	assessors	assessor	NNS
18637	19082	36	estimated	estimate	VBD
18637	19082	37	the	the	DT
18637	19082	38	property	property	NN
18637	19082	39	would	would	MD
18637	19082	40	receive	receive	VB
18637	19082	41	from	from	IN
18637	19082	42	the	the	DT
18637	19082	43	completed	complete	VBN
18637	19082	44	work	work	NN
18637	19082	45	.	.	.
18637	19083	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19083	2	482	482	CD
18637	19083	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19083	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19083	5	a	a	DT
18637	19083	6	levy	levy	NN
18637	19083	7	upon	upon	IN
18637	19083	8	all	all	DT
18637	19083	9	lands	land	NNS
18637	19083	10	within	within	IN
18637	19083	11	a	a	DT
18637	19083	12	drainage	drainage	NN
18637	19083	13	district	district	NN
18637	19083	14	of	of	IN
18637	19083	15	a	a	DT
18637	19083	16	tax	tax	NN
18637	19083	17	of	of	IN
18637	19083	18	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	19083	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	19083	20	five	five	CD
18637	19083	21	cents	cent	NNS
18637	19083	22	per	per	IN
18637	19083	23	acre	acre	NN
18637	19083	24	to	to	TO
18637	19083	25	defray	defray	VB
18637	19083	26	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	19083	27	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	19083	28	does	do	VBZ
18637	19083	29	not	not	RB
18637	19083	30	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	RB
18637	19083	31	take	take	VB
18637	19083	32	the	the	DT
18637	19083	33	property	property	NN
18637	19083	34	of	of	IN
18637	19083	35	landowners	landowner	NNS
18637	19083	36	within	within	IN
18637	19083	37	that	that	DT
18637	19083	38	district	district	NN
18637	19083	39	who	who	WP
18637	19083	40	may	may	MD
18637	19083	41	not	not	RB
18637	19083	42	be	be	VB
18637	19083	43	benefited	benefit	VBN
18637	19083	44	by	by	IN
18637	19083	45	the	the	DT
18637	19083	46	completed	complete	VBN
18637	19083	47	drainage	drainage	NN
18637	19083	48	plans	plan	NNS
18637	19083	49	.	.	.
18637	19084	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19084	2	483	483	CD
18637	19084	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19084	4	On	on	IN
18637	19084	5	the	the	DT
18637	19084	6	other	other	JJ
18637	19084	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	19084	8	,	,	,
18637	19084	9	when	when	WRB
18637	19084	10	the	the	DT
18637	19084	11	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19084	12	to	to	TO
18637	19084	13	be	be	VB
18637	19084	14	derived	derive	VBN
18637	19084	15	by	by	IN
18637	19084	16	a	a	DT
18637	19084	17	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19084	18	from	from	IN
18637	19084	19	the	the	DT
18637	19084	20	construction	construction	NN
18637	19084	21	of	of	IN
18637	19084	22	a	a	DT
18637	19084	23	highway	highway	NN
18637	19084	24	will	will	MD
18637	19084	25	be	be	VB
18637	19084	26	largely	largely	RB
18637	19084	27	offset	offset	VBN
18637	19084	28	by	by	IN
18637	19084	29	the	the	DT
18637	19084	30	loss	loss	NN
18637	19084	31	of	of	IN
18637	19084	32	local	local	JJ
18637	19084	33	freight	freight	NN
18637	19084	34	and	and	CC
18637	19084	35	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	19084	36	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	19084	37	,	,	,
18637	19084	38	an	an	DT
18637	19084	39	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19084	40	upon	upon	IN
18637	19084	41	such	such	JJ
18637	19084	42	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19084	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	19084	44	violative	violative	JJ
18637	19084	45	of	of	IN
18637	19084	46	due	due	JJ
18637	19084	47	process,[484	process,[484	NN
18637	19084	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19084	49	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	19084	50	any	any	DT
18637	19084	51	gains	gain	NNS
18637	19084	52	from	from	IN
18637	19084	53	increased	increase	VBN
18637	19084	54	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	19084	55	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	19084	56	expected	expect	VBN
18637	19084	57	to	to	TO
18637	19084	58	result	result	VB
18637	19084	59	from	from	IN
18637	19084	60	a	a	DT
18637	19084	61	road	road	NN
18637	19084	62	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	19084	63	will	will	MD
18637	19084	64	suffice	suffice	VB
18637	19084	65	to	to	TO
18637	19084	66	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	19084	67	an	an	DT
18637	19084	68	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19084	69	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	19084	70	.	.	.
18637	19085	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19085	2	485	485	CD
18637	19085	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19085	4	Also	also	RB
18637	19085	5	the	the	DT
18637	19085	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	19085	7	that	that	IN
18637	19085	8	the	the	DT
18637	19085	9	only	only	JJ
18637	19085	10	use	use	NN
18637	19085	11	made	make	VBN
18637	19085	12	of	of	IN
18637	19085	13	a	a	DT
18637	19085	14	lot	lot	NN
18637	19085	15	abutting	abut	VBG
18637	19085	16	on	on	IN
18637	19085	17	a	a	DT
18637	19085	18	street	street	NN
18637	19085	19	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	19085	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	19085	21	for	for	IN
18637	19085	22	a	a	DT
18637	19085	23	railway	railway	NN
18637	19085	24	right	right	NN
18637	19085	25	of	of	IN
18637	19085	26	way	way	NN
18637	19085	27	does	do	VBZ
18637	19085	28	not	not	RB
18637	19085	29	make	make	VB
18637	19085	30	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	19085	31	,	,	,
18637	19085	32	for	for	IN
18637	19085	33	lack	lack	NN
18637	19085	34	of	of	IN
18637	19085	35	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	19085	36	,	,	,
18637	19085	37	an	an	DT
18637	19085	38	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19085	39	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	19085	40	for	for	IN
18637	19085	41	grading	grading	NN
18637	19085	42	,	,	,
18637	19085	43	curbing	curbing	NN
18637	19085	44	,	,	,
18637	19085	45	and	and	CC
18637	19085	46	paving	pave	VBG
18637	19085	47	.	.	.
18637	19086	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19086	2	486	486	CD
18637	19086	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19086	4	However	however	RB
18637	19086	5	,	,	,
18637	19086	6	when	when	WRB
18637	19086	7	a	a	DT
18637	19086	8	high	high	JJ
18637	19086	9	and	and	CC
18637	19086	10	dry	dry	JJ
18637	19086	11	island	island	NN
18637	19086	12	was	be	VBD
18637	19086	13	included	include	VBN
18637	19086	14	within	within	IN
18637	19086	15	the	the	DT
18637	19086	16	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	19086	17	of	of	IN
18637	19086	18	a	a	DT
18637	19086	19	drainage	drainage	NN
18637	19086	20	district	district	NN
18637	19086	21	from	from	IN
18637	19086	22	which	which	WDT
18637	19086	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19086	24	could	could	MD
18637	19086	25	not	not	RB
18637	19086	26	be	be	VB
18637	19086	27	benefited	benefit	VBN
18637	19086	28	directly	directly	RB
18637	19086	29	or	or	CC
18637	19086	30	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	19086	31	,	,	,
18637	19086	32	a	a	DT
18637	19086	33	tax	tax	NN
18637	19086	34	on	on	IN
18637	19086	35	such	such	JJ
18637	19086	36	island	island	NN
18637	19086	37	was	be	VBD
18637	19086	38	held	hold	VBN
18637	19086	39	to	to	TO
18637	19086	40	be	be	VB
18637	19086	41	a	a	DT
18637	19086	42	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19086	43	of	of	IN
18637	19086	44	property	property	NN
18637	19086	45	without	without	IN
18637	19086	46	due	due	JJ
18637	19086	47	process	process	NN
18637	19086	48	of	of	IN
18637	19086	49	law	law	NN
18637	19086	50	.	.	.
18637	19087	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19087	2	487	487	CD
18637	19087	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19087	4	Finally	finally	RB
18637	19087	5	,	,	,
18637	19087	6	a	a	DT
18637	19087	7	State	state	NN
18637	19087	8	may	may	MD
18637	19087	9	levy	levy	VB
18637	19087	10	an	an	DT
18637	19087	11	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19087	12	for	for	IN
18637	19087	13	special	special	JJ
18637	19087	14	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	19087	15	resulting	result	VBG
18637	19087	16	from	from	IN
18637	19087	17	an	an	DT
18637	19087	18	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	19087	19	already	already	RB
18637	19087	20	made[488	made[488	XX
18637	19087	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19087	22	and	and	CC
18637	19087	23	may	may	MD
18637	19087	24	validate	validate	VB
18637	19087	25	an	an	DT
18637	19087	26	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19087	27	previously	previously	RB
18637	19087	28	held	hold	VBN
18637	19087	29	void	void	NN
18637	19087	30	for	for	IN
18637	19087	31	want	want	NN
18637	19087	32	of	of	IN
18637	19087	33	authority	authority	NN
18637	19087	34	.	.	.
18637	19088	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19088	2	489	489	CD
18637	19088	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19088	4	JURISDICTION	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19088	5	TO	to	IN
18637	19088	6	TAX	TAX	NNP
18637	19088	7	Land	Land	NNP
18637	19088	8	Prior	prior	RB
18637	19088	9	even	even	RB
18637	19088	10	to	to	IN
18637	19088	11	the	the	DT
18637	19088	12	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	19088	13	of	of	IN
18637	19088	14	the	the	DT
18637	19088	15	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19088	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19088	17	,	,	,
18637	19088	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19088	19	was	be	VBD
18637	19088	20	settled	settle	VBN
18637	19088	21	principle	principle	NN
18637	19088	22	that	that	IN
18637	19088	23	a	a	DT
18637	19088	24	State	state	NN
18637	19088	25	could	could	MD
18637	19088	26	not	not	RB
18637	19088	27	tax	tax	VB
18637	19088	28	land	land	NN
18637	19088	29	situated	situate	VBN
18637	19088	30	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19088	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19088	32	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19088	33	;	;	:
18637	19088	34	and	and	CC
18637	19088	35	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	19088	36	elaborating	elaborate	VBG
18637	19088	37	upon	upon	IN
18637	19088	38	that	that	DT
18637	19088	39	principle	principle	NN
18637	19088	40	the	the	DT
18637	19088	41	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19088	42	has	have	VBZ
18637	19088	43	said	say	VBN
18637	19088	44	that	that	IN
18637	19088	45	"	"	``
18637	19088	46	*	*	NFP
18637	19088	47	*	*	NFP
18637	19088	48	*	*	NFP
18637	19088	49	,	,	,
18637	19088	50	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19088	51	know	know	VBP
18637	19088	52	of	of	IN
18637	19088	53	no	no	DT
18637	19088	54	case	case	NN
18637	19088	55	where	where	WRB
18637	19088	56	a	a	DT
18637	19088	57	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	19088	58	has	have	VBZ
18637	19088	59	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	19088	60	to	to	TO
18637	19088	61	impose	impose	VB
18637	19088	62	a	a	DT
18637	19088	63	tax	tax	NN
18637	19088	64	upon	upon	IN
18637	19088	65	land	land	NN
18637	19088	66	within	within	IN
18637	19088	67	the	the	DT
18637	19088	68	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19088	69	of	of	IN
18637	19088	70	another	another	DT
18637	19088	71	State	State	NNP
18637	19088	72	,	,	,
18637	19088	73	much	much	RB
18637	19088	74	less	less	RBR
18637	19088	75	where	where	WRB
18637	19088	76	such	such	JJ
18637	19088	77	action	action	NN
18637	19088	78	has	have	VBZ
18637	19088	79	been	be	VBN
18637	19088	80	defended	defend	VBN
18637	19088	81	by	by	IN
18637	19088	82	a	a	DT
18637	19088	83	court	court	NN
18637	19088	84	.	.	.
18637	19089	1	"	"	``
18637	19089	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19089	3	490	490	CD
18637	19089	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19089	5	Insofar	insofar	RB
18637	19089	6	as	as	IN
18637	19089	7	a	a	DT
18637	19089	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	19089	9	payment	payment	NN
18637	19089	10	may	may	MD
18637	19089	11	be	be	VB
18637	19089	12	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19089	13	as	as	IN
18637	19089	14	an	an	DT
18637	19089	15	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	19089	16	for	for	IN
18637	19089	17	the	the	DT
18637	19089	18	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	19089	19	of	of	IN
18637	19089	20	government	government	NN
18637	19089	21	in	in	IN
18637	19089	22	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	19089	23	of	of	IN
18637	19089	24	protection	protection	NN
18637	19089	25	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	19089	26	,	,	,
18637	19089	27	the	the	DT
18637	19089	28	logic	logic	NN
18637	19089	29	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	19089	30	this	this	DT
18637	19089	31	rule	rule	NN
18637	19089	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	19089	33	self	self	NN
18637	19089	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	19089	35	evident	evident	JJ
18637	19089	36	.	.	.
18637	19090	1	Tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	19090	2	Personalty	Personalty	NNP
18637	19090	3	As	as	RB
18637	19090	4	long	long	RB
18637	19090	5	as	as	IN
18637	19090	6	tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	19090	7	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19090	8	property	property	NN
18637	19090	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	19090	10	a	a	DT
18637	19090	11	situs	situs	NN
18637	19090	12	within	within	IN
18637	19090	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19090	14	borders	border	NNS
18637	19090	15	,	,	,
18637	19090	16	a	a	DT
18637	19090	17	State	state	NN
18637	19090	18	validly	validly	RB
18637	19090	19	may	may	MD
18637	19090	20	tax	tax	VB
18637	19090	21	the	the	DT
18637	19090	22	same	same	JJ
18637	19090	23	,	,	,
18637	19090	24	whether	whether	IN
18637	19090	25	directly	directly	RB
18637	19090	26	through	through	IN
18637	19090	27	an	an	DT
18637	19090	28	_	_	NNP
18637	19090	29	ad	ad	NN
18637	19090	30	valorem	valorem	NN
18637	19090	31	_	_	NNP
18637	19090	32	tax	tax	NN
18637	19090	33	or	or	CC
18637	19090	34	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	19090	35	through	through	IN
18637	19090	36	death	death	NN
18637	19090	37	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19090	38	,	,	,
18637	19090	39	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	19090	40	of	of	IN
18637	19090	41	the	the	DT
18637	19090	42	residence	residence	NN
18637	19090	43	of	of	IN
18637	19090	44	the	the	DT
18637	19090	45	owner	owner	NN
18637	19090	46	.	.	.
18637	19091	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19091	2	491	491	CD
18637	19091	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19091	4	By	by	IN
18637	19091	5	the	the	DT
18637	19091	6	same	same	JJ
18637	19091	7	token	token	NN
18637	19091	8	,	,	,
18637	19091	9	if	if	IN
18637	19091	10	tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	19091	11	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19091	12	property	property	NN
18637	19091	13	makes	make	VBZ
18637	19091	14	only	only	RB
18637	19091	15	occasional	occasional	JJ
18637	19091	16	incursions	incursion	NNS
18637	19091	17	into	into	IN
18637	19091	18	other	other	JJ
18637	19091	19	States	States	NNP
18637	19091	20	,	,	,
18637	19091	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19091	22	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	19091	23	situs	situs	NN
18637	19091	24	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	19091	25	in	in	IN
18637	19091	26	the	the	DT
18637	19091	27	State	State	NNP
18637	19091	28	of	of	IN
18637	19091	29	origin	origin	NN
18637	19091	30	,	,	,
18637	19091	31	and	and	CC
18637	19091	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	19091	33	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	19091	34	only	only	RB
18637	19091	35	by	by	IN
18637	19091	36	the	the	DT
18637	19091	37	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19091	38	.	.	.
18637	19092	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19092	2	492	492	CD
18637	19092	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19092	4	The	the	DT
18637	19092	5	ancient	ancient	JJ
18637	19092	6	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	19092	7	,	,	,
18637	19092	8	_	_	NNP
18637	19092	9	mobilia	mobilia	NNP
18637	19092	10	sequuntur	sequuntur	NNP
18637	19092	11	personam	personam	NNP
18637	19092	12	_	_	NNP
18637	19092	13	,	,	,
18637	19092	14	which	which	WDT
18637	19092	15	had	have	VBD
18637	19092	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19092	17	origin	origin	NN
18637	19092	18	when	when	WRB
18637	19092	19	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19092	20	property	property	NN
18637	19092	21	consisted	consist	VBD
18637	19092	22	in	in	IN
18637	19092	23	the	the	DT
18637	19092	24	main	main	JJ
18637	19092	25	of	of	IN
18637	19092	26	articles	article	NNS
18637	19092	27	appertaining	appertain	VBG
18637	19092	28	to	to	IN
18637	19092	29	the	the	DT
18637	19092	30	person	person	NN
18637	19092	31	of	of	IN
18637	19092	32	the	the	DT
18637	19092	33	owner	owner	NN
18637	19092	34	,	,	,
18637	19092	35	yielded	yield	VBN
18637	19092	36	in	in	IN
18637	19092	37	modern	modern	JJ
18637	19092	38	times	time	NNS
18637	19092	39	to	to	IN
18637	19092	40	the	the	DT
18637	19092	41	"	"	``
18637	19092	42	law	law	NN
18637	19092	43	of	of	IN
18637	19092	44	the	the	DT
18637	19092	45	place	place	NN
18637	19092	46	where	where	WRB
18637	19092	47	the	the	DT
18637	19092	48	property	property	NN
18637	19092	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	19092	50	kept	keep	VBN
18637	19092	51	and	and	CC
18637	19092	52	used	use	VBN
18637	19092	53	.	.	.
18637	19092	54	"	"	''
18637	19093	1	In	in	IN
18637	19093	2	recent	recent	JJ
18637	19093	3	years	year	NNS
18637	19093	4	,	,	,
18637	19093	5	the	the	DT
18637	19093	6	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	19093	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	19093	8	been	be	VBN
18637	19093	9	to	to	TO
18637	19093	10	treat	treat	VB
18637	19093	11	tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	19093	12	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19093	13	property	property	NN
18637	19093	14	as	as	IN
18637	19093	15	"	"	``
18637	19093	16	having	have	VBG
18637	19093	17	a	a	DT
18637	19093	18	situs	situs	NN
18637	19093	19	of	of	IN
18637	19093	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19093	21	own	own	JJ
18637	19093	22	for	for	IN
18637	19093	23	the	the	DT
18637	19093	24	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	19093	25	of	of	IN
18637	19093	26	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19093	27	,	,	,
18637	19093	28	and	and	CC
18637	19093	29	correlatively	correlatively	RB
18637	19093	30	to	to	IN
18637	19093	31	*	*	NFP
18637	19093	32	*	*	NFP
18637	19093	33	*	*	NFP
18637	19093	34	exempt	exempt	VBP
18637	19093	35	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19093	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19093	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19093	38	at	at	IN
18637	19093	39	the	the	DT
18637	19093	40	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19093	41	of	of	IN
18637	19093	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19093	43	owner	owner	NN
18637	19093	44	.	.	.
18637	19094	1	"	"	``
18637	19094	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19094	3	493]The	493]the	CD
18637	19094	4	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19094	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	19094	6	protection	protection	NN
18637	19094	7	theory	theory	NN
18637	19094	8	of	of	IN
18637	19094	9	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19094	10	,	,	,
18637	19094	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	19094	12	which	which	WDT
18637	19094	13	the	the	DT
18637	19094	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19094	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	19094	16	in	in	IN
18637	19094	17	fact	fact	NN
18637	19094	18	relied	rely	VBN
18637	19094	19	to	to	TO
18637	19094	20	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	19094	21	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19094	22	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	19094	23	by	by	IN
18637	19094	24	the	the	DT
18637	19094	25	situs	situs	NN
18637	19094	26	State	State	NNP
18637	19094	27	,	,	,
18637	19094	28	logically	logically	RB
18637	19094	29	would	would	MD
18637	19094	30	seem	seem	VB
18637	19094	31	to	to	TO
18637	19094	32	permit	permit	VB
18637	19094	33	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19094	34	by	by	IN
18637	19094	35	the	the	DT
18637	19094	36	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	19094	37	State	State	NNP
18637	19094	38	as	as	RB
18637	19094	39	well	well	RB
18637	19094	40	as	as	IN
18637	19094	41	by	by	IN
18637	19094	42	the	the	DT
18637	19094	43	nondomiciliary	nondomiciliary	JJ
18637	19094	44	State	State	NNP
18637	19094	45	in	in	IN
18637	19094	46	which	which	WDT
18637	19094	47	the	the	DT
18637	19094	48	tangibles	tangible	NNS
18637	19094	49	are	be	VBP
18637	19094	50	situate	situate	JJ
18637	19094	51	,	,	,
18637	19094	52	especially	especially	RB
18637	19094	53	when	when	WRB
18637	19094	54	the	the	DT
18637	19094	55	former	former	JJ
18637	19094	56	levies	levy	VBZ
18637	19094	57	the	the	DT
18637	19094	58	tax	tax	NN
18637	19094	59	on	on	IN
18637	19094	60	the	the	DT
18637	19094	61	owner	owner	NN
18637	19094	62	in	in	IN
18637	19094	63	terms	term	NNS
18637	19094	64	of	of	IN
18637	19094	65	the	the	DT
18637	19094	66	value	value	NN
18637	19094	67	of	of	IN
18637	19094	68	the	the	DT
18637	19094	69	tangibles	tangible	NNS
18637	19094	70	.	.	.
18637	19095	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19095	2	far	far	RB
18637	19095	3	,	,	,
18637	19095	4	however	however	RB
18637	19095	5	,	,	,
18637	19095	6	the	the	DT
18637	19095	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19095	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	19095	9	taken	take	VBN
18637	19095	10	the	the	DT
18637	19095	11	position	position	NN
18637	19095	12	that	that	IN
18637	19095	13	when	when	WRB
18637	19095	14	the	the	DT
18637	19095	15	tangibles	tangible	NNS
18637	19095	16	have	have	VBP
18637	19095	17	a	a	DT
18637	19095	18	situs	situs	NN
18637	19095	19	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	19095	20	,	,	,
18637	19095	21	the	the	DT
18637	19095	22	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	19095	23	State	State	NNP
18637	19095	24	can	can	MD
18637	19095	25	neither	neither	CC
18637	19095	26	control	control	VB
18637	19095	27	such	such	JJ
18637	19095	28	property	property	NN
18637	19095	29	nor	nor	CC
18637	19095	30	extend	extend	VB
18637	19095	31	to	to	IN
18637	19095	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19095	33	or	or	CC
18637	19095	34	to	to	IN
18637	19095	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19095	36	owner	owner	NN
18637	19095	37	such	such	JJ
18637	19095	38	measure	measure	NN
18637	19095	39	of	of	IN
18637	19095	40	protection	protection	NN
18637	19095	41	as	as	IN
18637	19095	42	would	would	MD
18637	19095	43	be	be	VB
18637	19095	44	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19095	45	to	to	TO
18637	19095	46	meet	meet	VB
18637	19095	47	the	the	DT
18637	19095	48	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	19095	49	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	19095	50	of	of	IN
18637	19095	51	due	due	JJ
18637	19095	52	process	process	NN
18637	19095	53	.	.	.
18637	19096	1	Intangible	Intangible	NNP
18637	19096	2	Personalty	Personalty	NNP
18637	19096	3	General.--To	General.--To	NNS
18637	19096	4	determine	determine	VBP
18637	19096	5	whether	whether	IN
18637	19096	6	a	a	DT
18637	19096	7	State	state	NN
18637	19096	8	,	,	,
18637	19096	9	or	or	CC
18637	19096	10	States	States	NNP
18637	19096	11	,	,	,
18637	19096	12	may	may	MD
18637	19096	13	tax	tax	VB
18637	19096	14	intangible	intangible	JJ
18637	19096	15	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19096	16	property	property	NN
18637	19096	17	,	,	,
18637	19096	18	the	the	DT
18637	19096	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19096	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	19096	21	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19096	22	the	the	DT
18637	19096	23	fiction	fiction	NN
18637	19096	24	,	,	,
18637	19096	25	_	_	NNP
18637	19096	26	mobilia	mobilia	NNP
18637	19096	27	sequuntur	sequuntur	NNP
18637	19096	28	personam	personam	NNP
18637	19096	29	_	_	NNP
18637	19096	30	and	and	CC
18637	19096	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	19096	32	also	also	RB
18637	19096	33	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	19096	34	that	that	IN
18637	19096	35	such	such	JJ
18637	19096	36	property	property	NN
18637	19096	37	may	may	MD
18637	19096	38	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	19096	39	,	,	,
18637	19096	40	for	for	IN
18637	19096	41	tax	tax	NN
18637	19096	42	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19096	43	,	,	,
18637	19096	44	a	a	DT
18637	19096	45	business	business	NN
18637	19096	46	or	or	CC
18637	19096	47	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	19096	48	situs	situs	NN
18637	19096	49	where	where	WRB
18637	19096	50	permanently	permanently	RB
18637	19096	51	located	locate	VBN
18637	19096	52	;	;	:
18637	19096	53	but	but	CC
18637	19096	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19096	55	has	have	VBZ
18637	19096	56	never	never	RB
18637	19096	57	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	19096	58	disposed	dispose	VBN
18637	19096	59	of	of	IN
18637	19096	60	the	the	DT
18637	19096	61	issue	issue	NN
18637	19096	62	as	as	IN
18637	19096	63	to	to	IN
18637	19096	64	whether	whether	IN
18637	19096	65	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	19096	66	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19096	67	property	property	NN
18637	19096	68	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19096	69	of	of	IN
18637	19096	70	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19096	71	is	be	VBZ
18637	19096	72	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	19096	73	with	with	IN
18637	19096	74	due	due	JJ
18637	19096	75	process	process	NN
18637	19096	76	.	.	.
18637	19097	1	In	in	IN
18637	19097	2	the	the	DT
18637	19097	3	case	case	NN
18637	19097	4	of	of	IN
18637	19097	5	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	19097	6	stock	stock	NN
18637	19097	7	,	,	,
18637	19097	8	however	however	RB
18637	19097	9	,	,	,
18637	19097	10	the	the	DT
18637	19097	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19097	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	19097	13	obliquely	obliquely	RB
18637	19097	14	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	19097	15	that	that	IN
18637	19097	16	the	the	DT
18637	19097	17	owner	owner	NN
18637	19097	18	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19097	19	may	may	MD
18637	19097	20	be	be	VB
18637	19097	21	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19097	22	at	at	IN
18637	19097	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19097	24	own	own	JJ
18637	19097	25	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19097	26	,	,	,
18637	19097	27	at	at	IN
18637	19097	28	the	the	DT
18637	19097	29	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	19097	30	situs	situs	NN
18637	19097	31	of	of	IN
18637	19097	32	the	the	DT
18637	19097	33	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	19097	34	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19097	35	,	,	,
18637	19097	36	and	and	CC
18637	19097	37	at	at	IN
18637	19097	38	the	the	DT
18637	19097	39	latter	latter	NN
18637	19097	40	's	's	POS
18637	19097	41	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19097	42	;	;	:
18637	19097	43	but	but	CC
18637	19097	44	,	,	,
18637	19097	45	as	as	IN
18637	19097	46	of	of	IN
18637	19097	47	the	the	DT
18637	19097	48	present	present	JJ
18637	19097	49	date	date	NN
18637	19097	50	,	,	,
18637	19097	51	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19097	52	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
18637	19097	53	are	be	VBP
18637	19097	54	speculating	speculate	VBG
18637	19097	55	whether	whether	IN
18637	19097	56	the	the	DT
18637	19097	57	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19097	58	would	would	MD
18637	19097	59	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	19097	60	a	a	DT
18637	19097	61	tax	tax	NN
18637	19097	62	by	by	IN
18637	19097	63	all	all	DT
18637	19097	64	three	three	CD
18637	19097	65	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NNS
18637	19097	66	,	,	,
18637	19097	67	or	or	CC
18637	19097	68	by	by	IN
18637	19097	69	only	only	RB
18637	19097	70	two	two	CD
18637	19097	71	of	of	IN
18637	19097	72	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19097	73	,	,	,
18637	19097	74	and	and	CC
18637	19097	75	,	,	,
18637	19097	76	if	if	IN
18637	19097	77	the	the	DT
18637	19097	78	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19097	79	,	,	,
18637	19097	80	which	which	WDT
18637	19097	81	two	two	CD
18637	19097	82	,	,	,
18637	19097	83	the	the	DT
18637	19097	84	State	State	NNP
18637	19097	85	of	of	IN
18637	19097	86	the	the	DT
18637	19097	87	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	19097	88	situs	situs	NN
18637	19097	89	and	and	CC
18637	19097	90	of	of	IN
18637	19097	91	the	the	DT
18637	19097	92	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	19097	93	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19097	94	's	's	POS
18637	19097	95	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19097	96	,	,	,
18637	19097	97	or	or	CC
18637	19097	98	the	the	DT
18637	19097	99	State	State	NNP
18637	19097	100	of	of	IN
18637	19097	101	the	the	DT
18637	19097	102	owner	owner	NN
18637	19097	103	's	's	POS
18637	19097	104	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19097	105	and	and	CC
18637	19097	106	that	that	DT
18637	19097	107	of	of	IN
18637	19097	108	the	the	DT
18637	19097	109	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	19097	110	situs	situs	NN
18637	19097	111	.	.	.
18637	19098	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19098	2	494	494	CD
18637	19098	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19098	4	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19098	5	on	on	IN
18637	19098	6	Intangibles	Intangibles	NNP
18637	19098	7	Sustained.--Thus	sustained.--thu	NNS
18637	19098	8	far	far	RB
18637	19098	9	,	,	,
18637	19098	10	the	the	DT
18637	19098	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19098	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	19098	13	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	19098	14	the	the	DT
18637	19098	15	following	follow	VBG
18637	19098	16	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19098	17	property	property	NN
18637	19098	18	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19098	19	on	on	IN
18637	19098	20	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19098	21	:	:	:
18637	19098	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19098	23	1	1	LS
18637	19098	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19098	25	A	a	DT
18637	19098	26	debt	debt	NN
18637	19098	27	held	hold	VBN
18637	19098	28	by	by	IN
18637	19098	29	a	a	DT
18637	19098	30	resident	resident	NN
18637	19098	31	against	against	IN
18637	19098	32	a	a	DT
18637	19098	33	nonresidence	nonresidence	NN
18637	19098	34	,	,	,
18637	19098	35	evidenced	evidence	VBN
18637	19098	36	by	by	IN
18637	19098	37	a	a	DT
18637	19098	38	bond	bond	NN
18637	19098	39	of	of	IN
18637	19098	40	the	the	DT
18637	19098	41	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	19098	42	and	and	CC
18637	19098	43	secured	secure	VBN
18637	19098	44	by	by	IN
18637	19098	45	a	a	DT
18637	19098	46	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	19098	47	on	on	IN
18637	19098	48	real	real	JJ
18637	19098	49	estate	estate	NN
18637	19098	50	in	in	IN
18637	19098	51	the	the	DT
18637	19098	52	State	State	NNP
18637	19098	53	of	of	IN
18637	19098	54	the	the	DT
18637	19098	55	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	19098	56	's	's	POS
18637	19098	57	residence	residence	NN
18637	19098	58	.	.	.
18637	19099	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19099	2	495	495	CD
18637	19099	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19099	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19099	5	2	2	LS
18637	19099	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19099	7	A	a	DT
18637	19099	8	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	19099	9	owned	own	VBN
18637	19099	10	and	and	CC
18637	19099	11	kept	keep	VBD
18637	19099	12	outside	outside	IN
18637	19099	13	the	the	DT
18637	19099	14	State	state	NN
18637	19099	15	by	by	IN
18637	19099	16	a	a	DT
18637	19099	17	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19099	18	but	but	CC
18637	19099	19	on	on	IN
18637	19099	20	land	land	NN
18637	19099	21	within	within	IN
18637	19099	22	the	the	DT
18637	19099	23	State	State	NNP
18637	19099	24	.	.	.
18637	19100	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19100	2	496	496	CD
18637	19100	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19100	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19100	5	3	3	LS
18637	19100	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19100	7	Investments	Investments	NNPS
18637	19100	8	,	,	,
18637	19100	9	in	in	IN
18637	19100	10	the	the	DT
18637	19100	11	form	form	NN
18637	19100	12	of	of	IN
18637	19100	13	loans	loan	NNS
18637	19100	14	to	to	IN
18637	19100	15	residents	resident	NNS
18637	19100	16	,	,	,
18637	19100	17	made	make	VBN
18637	19100	18	by	by	IN
18637	19100	19	a	a	DT
18637	19100	20	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19100	21	agent	agent	NN
18637	19100	22	of	of	IN
18637	19100	23	a	a	DT
18637	19100	24	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19100	25	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	19100	26	,	,	,
18637	19100	27	are	be	VBP
18637	19100	28	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	19100	29	to	to	IN
18637	19100	30	the	the	DT
18637	19100	31	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19100	32	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	19100	33	.	.	.
18637	19101	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19101	2	497	497	CD
18637	19101	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19101	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19101	5	4	4	LS
18637	19101	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19101	7	Deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	19101	8	of	of	IN
18637	19101	9	a	a	DT
18637	19101	10	resident	resident	NN
18637	19101	11	in	in	IN
18637	19101	12	a	a	DT
18637	19101	13	bank	bank	NN
18637	19101	14	in	in	IN
18637	19101	15	another	another	DT
18637	19101	16	State	State	NNP
18637	19101	17	,	,	,
18637	19101	18	where	where	WRB
18637	19101	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19101	20	carries	carry	VBZ
18637	19101	21	on	on	IN
18637	19101	22	a	a	DT
18637	19101	23	business	business	NN
18637	19101	24	and	and	CC
18637	19101	25	from	from	IN
18637	19101	26	which	which	WDT
18637	19101	27	these	these	DT
18637	19101	28	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	19101	29	are	be	VBP
18637	19101	30	derived	derive	VBN
18637	19101	31	,	,	,
18637	19101	32	but	but	CC
18637	19101	33	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	19101	34	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	19101	35	to	to	IN
18637	19101	36	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19101	37	and	and	CC
18637	19101	38	not	not	RB
18637	19101	39	used	use	VBN
18637	19101	40	in	in	IN
18637	19101	41	the	the	DT
18637	19101	42	business	business	NN
18637	19101	43	,	,	,
18637	19101	44	are	be	VBP
18637	19101	45	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19101	46	to	to	IN
18637	19101	47	a	a	DT
18637	19101	48	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19101	49	property	property	NN
18637	19101	50	tax	tax	NN
18637	19101	51	in	in	IN
18637	19101	52	the	the	DT
18637	19101	53	city	city	NN
18637	19101	54	of	of	IN
18637	19101	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19101	56	residence	residence	NN
18637	19101	57	,	,	,
18637	19101	58	whether	whether	IN
18637	19101	59	or	or	CC
18637	19101	60	not	not	RB
18637	19101	61	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19101	62	are	be	VBP
18637	19101	63	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19101	64	to	to	IN
18637	19101	65	tax	tax	NN
18637	19101	66	in	in	IN
18637	19101	67	the	the	DT
18637	19101	68	State	State	NNP
18637	19101	69	where	where	WRB
18637	19101	70	the	the	DT
18637	19101	71	business	business	NN
18637	19101	72	is	be	VBZ
18637	19101	73	carried	carry	VBN
18637	19101	74	on	on	RP
18637	19101	75	.	.	.
18637	19102	1	The	the	DT
18637	19102	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	19102	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	19102	4	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19102	5	for	for	IN
18637	19102	6	the	the	DT
18637	19102	7	general	general	JJ
18637	19102	8	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	19102	9	of	of	IN
18637	19102	10	living	live	VBG
18637	19102	11	within	within	IN
18637	19102	12	the	the	DT
18637	19102	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19102	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19102	15	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19102	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	19102	17	protection	protection	NN
18637	19102	18	theory	theory	NN
18637	19102	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19102	20	,	,	,
18637	19102	21	and	and	CC
18637	19102	22	may	may	MD
18637	19102	23	be	be	VB
18637	19102	24	measured	measure	VBN
18637	19102	25	by	by	IN
18637	19102	26	reference	reference	NN
18637	19102	27	to	to	IN
18637	19102	28	the	the	DT
18637	19102	29	riches	rich	NNS
18637	19102	30	of	of	IN
18637	19102	31	the	the	DT
18637	19102	32	person	person	NN
18637	19102	33	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19102	34	.	.	.
18637	19103	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19103	2	498	498	CD
18637	19103	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19103	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19103	5	5	5	LS
18637	19103	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19103	7	Membership	membership	NN
18637	19103	8	owned	own	VBN
18637	19103	9	by	by	IN
18637	19103	10	a	a	DT
18637	19103	11	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19103	12	in	in	IN
18637	19103	13	a	a	DT
18637	19103	14	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19103	15	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	19103	16	,	,	,
18637	19103	17	known	know	VBN
18637	19103	18	as	as	IN
18637	19103	19	a	a	DT
18637	19103	20	chamber	chamber	NN
18637	19103	21	of	of	IN
18637	19103	22	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	19103	23	.	.	.
18637	19104	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19104	2	499	499	CD
18637	19104	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19104	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19104	5	6	6	CD
18637	19104	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19104	7	Membership	membership	NN
18637	19104	8	by	by	IN
18637	19104	9	a	a	DT
18637	19104	10	resident	resident	NN
18637	19104	11	in	in	IN
18637	19104	12	a	a	DT
18637	19104	13	stock	stock	NN
18637	19104	14	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	19104	15	located	locate	VBN
18637	19104	16	in	in	IN
18637	19104	17	another	another	DT
18637	19104	18	State	State	NNP
18637	19104	19	.	.	.
18637	19105	1	"	"	``
18637	19105	2	Double	double	JJ
18637	19105	3	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19105	4	"	"	''
18637	19105	5	the	the	DT
18637	19105	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19105	7	observed	observe	VBD
18637	19105	8	"	"	''
18637	19105	9	by	by	IN
18637	19105	10	one	one	CD
18637	19105	11	and	and	CC
18637	19105	12	the	the	DT
18637	19105	13	same	same	JJ
18637	19105	14	State	State	NNP
18637	19105	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	19105	16	not	not	RB
18637	19105	17	"	"	``
18637	19105	18	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	19105	19	"	"	''
18637	19105	20	by	by	IN
18637	19105	21	the	the	DT
18637	19105	22	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19105	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19105	24	;	;	:
18637	19105	25	much	much	RB
18637	19105	26	less	less	JJR
18637	19105	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	19105	28	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19105	29	by	by	IN
18637	19105	30	two	two	CD
18637	19105	31	States	state	NNS
18637	19105	32	upon	upon	IN
18637	19105	33	identical	identical	JJ
18637	19105	34	or	or	CC
18637	19105	35	closely	closely	RB
18637	19105	36	related	related	JJ
18637	19105	37	property	property	NN
18637	19105	38	interests	interest	NNS
18637	19105	39	falling	fall	VBG
18637	19105	40	within	within	IN
18637	19105	41	the	the	DT
18637	19105	42	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19105	43	of	of	IN
18637	19105	44	both	both	DT
18637	19105	45	,	,	,
18637	19105	46	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	19105	47	.	.	.
18637	19106	1	"	"	``
18637	19106	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19106	3	500	500	CD
18637	19106	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19106	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19106	6	7	7	LS
18637	19106	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19106	8	A	a	DT
18637	19106	9	resident	resident	NN
18637	19106	10	owner	owner	NN
18637	19106	11	may	may	MD
18637	19106	12	be	be	VB
18637	19106	13	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19106	14	on	on	IN
18637	19106	15	stock	stock	NN
18637	19106	16	held	hold	VBN
18637	19106	17	in	in	IN
18637	19106	18	a	a	DT
18637	19106	19	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19106	20	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19106	21	that	that	WDT
18637	19106	22	does	do	VBZ
18637	19106	23	no	no	DT
18637	19106	24	business	business	NN
18637	19106	25	and	and	CC
18637	19106	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	19106	27	no	no	DT
18637	19106	28	property	property	NN
18637	19106	29	within	within	IN
18637	19106	30	the	the	DT
18637	19106	31	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19106	32	State	state	NN
18637	19106	33	.	.	.
18637	19107	1	The	the	DT
18637	19107	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19107	3	also	also	RB
18637	19107	4	added	add	VBD
18637	19107	5	that	that	IN
18637	19107	6	"	"	``
18637	19107	7	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	19107	8	the	the	DT
18637	19107	9	State	State	NNP
18637	19107	10	in	in	IN
18637	19107	11	which	which	WDT
18637	19107	12	a	a	DT
18637	19107	13	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19107	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19107	15	organized	organize	VBN
18637	19107	16	may	may	MD
18637	19107	17	*	*	NFP
18637	19107	18	*	*	NFP
18637	19107	19	*	*	NFP
18637	19107	20	,	,	,
18637	19107	21	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19107	22	tax	tax	NN
18637	19107	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19107	24	of	of	IN
18637	19107	25	all	all	DT
18637	19107	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19107	27	shares	share	NNS
18637	19107	28	whether	whether	IN
18637	19107	29	owned	own	VBN
18637	19107	30	by	by	IN
18637	19107	31	residents	resident	NNS
18637	19107	32	or	or	CC
18637	19107	33	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	19107	34	.	.	.
18637	19108	1	"	"	``
18637	19108	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19108	3	501	501	CD
18637	19108	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19108	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19108	6	8)	8)	CD
18637	19108	7	Stock	stock	NN
18637	19108	8	in	in	IN
18637	19108	9	a	a	DT
18637	19108	10	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19108	11	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19108	12	owned	own	VBN
18637	19108	13	by	by	IN
18637	19108	14	another	another	DT
18637	19108	15	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19108	16	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19108	17	transacting	transact	VBG
18637	19108	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19108	19	business	business	NN
18637	19108	20	within	within	IN
18637	19108	21	the	the	DT
18637	19108	22	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19108	23	State	state	NN
18637	19108	24	.	.	.
18637	19109	1	The	the	DT
18637	19109	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19109	3	attached	attach	VBD
18637	19109	4	no	no	DT
18637	19109	5	importance	importance	NN
18637	19109	6	to	to	IN
18637	19109	7	the	the	DT
18637	19109	8	fact	fact	NN
18637	19109	9	that	that	IN
18637	19109	10	the	the	DT
18637	19109	11	shares	share	NNS
18637	19109	12	were	be	VBD
18637	19109	13	already	already	RB
18637	19109	14	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19109	15	by	by	IN
18637	19109	16	the	the	DT
18637	19109	17	State	State	NNP
18637	19109	18	in	in	IN
18637	19109	19	which	which	WDT
18637	19109	20	the	the	DT
18637	19109	21	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	19109	22	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19109	23	was	be	VBD
18637	19109	24	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	19109	25	and	and	CC
18637	19109	26	might	may	MD
18637	19109	27	also	also	RB
18637	19109	28	be	be	VB
18637	19109	29	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19109	30	by	by	IN
18637	19109	31	the	the	DT
18637	19109	32	State	State	NNP
18637	19109	33	in	in	IN
18637	19109	34	which	which	WDT
18637	19109	35	the	the	DT
18637	19109	36	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	19109	37	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19109	38	was	be	VBD
18637	19109	39	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	19109	40	and	and	CC
18637	19109	41	might	may	MD
18637	19109	42	also	also	RB
18637	19109	43	be	be	VB
18637	19109	44	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19109	45	by	by	IN
18637	19109	46	the	the	DT
18637	19109	47	State	State	NNP
18637	19109	48	in	in	IN
18637	19109	49	which	which	WDT
18637	19109	50	the	the	DT
18637	19109	51	stock	stock	NN
18637	19109	52	owner	owner	NN
18637	19109	53	was	be	VBD
18637	19109	54	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	19109	55	;	;	:
18637	19109	56	or	or	CC
18637	19109	57	at	at	IN
18637	19109	58	any	any	DT
18637	19109	59	rate	rate	NN
18637	19109	60	did	do	VBD
18637	19109	61	not	not	RB
18637	19109	62	find	find	VB
18637	19109	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19109	64	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19109	65	to	to	TO
18637	19109	66	pass	pass	VB
18637	19109	67	upon	upon	IN
18637	19109	68	the	the	DT
18637	19109	69	validity	validity	NN
18637	19109	70	of	of	IN
18637	19109	71	the	the	DT
18637	19109	72	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19109	73	two	two	CD
18637	19109	74	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19109	75	.	.	.
18637	19110	1	The	the	DT
18637	19110	2	present	present	JJ
18637	19110	3	levy	levy	NN
18637	19110	4	was	be	VBD
18637	19110	5	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19110	6	to	to	TO
18637	19110	7	be	be	VB
18637	19110	8	tenable	tenable	JJ
18637	19110	9	on	on	IN
18637	19110	10	the	the	DT
18637	19110	11	basis	basis	NN
18637	19110	12	of	of	IN
18637	19110	13	the	the	DT
18637	19110	14	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19110	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	19110	16	protection	protection	NN
18637	19110	17	theory	theory	NN
18637	19110	18	;	;	:
18637	19110	19	namely	namely	RB
18637	19110	20	,	,	,
18637	19110	21	"	"	''
18637	19110	22	the	the	DT
18637	19110	23	economic	economic	JJ
18637	19110	24	advantages	advantage	NNS
18637	19110	25	realized	realize	VBD
18637	19110	26	through	through	IN
18637	19110	27	the	the	DT
18637	19110	28	protection	protection	NN
18637	19110	29	,	,	,
18637	19110	30	at	at	IN
18637	19110	31	the	the	DT
18637	19110	32	place	place	NN
18637	19110	33	*	*	NFP
18637	19110	34	*	*	NFP
18637	19110	35	*	*	NFP
18637	19110	36	,	,	,
18637	19110	37	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19110	38	of	of	IN
18637	19110	39	business	business	NN
18637	19110	40	situs	situs	NN
18637	19110	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19110	42	of	of	IN
18637	19110	43	the	the	DT
18637	19110	44	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	19110	45	of	of	IN
18637	19110	46	rights	right	NNS
18637	19110	47	in	in	IN
18637	19110	48	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19110	49	*	*	NFP
18637	19110	50	*	*	NFP
18637	19110	51	*	*	NFP
18637	19110	52	"	"	''
18637	19110	53	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19110	54	502	502	CD
18637	19110	55	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19110	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19110	57	9	9	CD
18637	19110	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19110	59	Shares	share	NNS
18637	19110	60	owned	own	VBN
18637	19110	61	by	by	IN
18637	19110	62	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19110	63	shareholders	shareholder	NNS
18637	19110	64	in	in	IN
18637	19110	65	a	a	DT
18637	19110	66	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19110	67	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19110	68	,	,	,
18637	19110	69	the	the	DT
18637	19110	70	tax	tax	NN
18637	19110	71	being	be	VBG
18637	19110	72	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	19110	73	on	on	IN
18637	19110	74	the	the	DT
18637	19110	75	basis	basis	NN
18637	19110	76	of	of	IN
18637	19110	77	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	19110	78	assets	asset	NNS
18637	19110	79	and	and	CC
18637	19110	80	payable	payable	JJ
18637	19110	81	by	by	IN
18637	19110	82	the	the	DT
18637	19110	83	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19110	84	either	either	CC
18637	19110	85	out	out	IN
18637	19110	86	of	of	IN
18637	19110	87	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19110	88	general	general	JJ
18637	19110	89	fund	fund	NN
18637	19110	90	or	or	CC
18637	19110	91	by	by	IN
18637	19110	92	collection	collection	NN
18637	19110	93	from	from	IN
18637	19110	94	the	the	DT
18637	19110	95	shareholder	shareholder	NN
18637	19110	96	.	.	.
18637	19111	1	The	the	DT
18637	19111	2	shares	share	NNS
18637	19111	3	represent	represent	VBP
18637	19111	4	an	an	DT
18637	19111	5	aliquot	aliquot	NNS
18637	19111	6	portion	portion	NN
18637	19111	7	of	of	IN
18637	19111	8	the	the	DT
18637	19111	9	whole	whole	JJ
18637	19111	10	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	19111	11	assets	asset	NNS
18637	19111	12	,	,	,
18637	19111	13	and	and	CC
18637	19111	14	the	the	DT
18637	19111	15	property	property	NN
18637	19111	16	right	right	RB
18637	19111	17	so	so	RB
18637	19111	18	represented	represented	JJ
18637	19111	19	arises	arise	NNS
18637	19111	20	where	where	WRB
18637	19111	21	the	the	DT
18637	19111	22	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19111	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	19111	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19111	25	home	home	NN
18637	19111	26	,	,	,
18637	19111	27	and	and	CC
18637	19111	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	19111	29	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	19111	30	within	within	IN
18637	19111	31	the	the	DT
18637	19111	32	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19111	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19111	34	of	of	IN
18637	19111	35	the	the	DT
18637	19111	36	State	State	NNP
18637	19111	37	,	,	,
18637	19111	38	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19111	39	that	that	DT
18637	19111	40	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	19111	41	of	of	IN
18637	19111	42	the	the	DT
18637	19111	43	stock	stock	NN
18637	19111	44	may	may	MD
18637	19111	45	also	also	RB
18637	19111	46	be	be	VB
18637	19111	47	a	a	DT
18637	19111	48	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	19111	49	subject	subject	NN
18637	19111	50	in	in	IN
18637	19111	51	another	another	DT
18637	19111	52	State	state	NN
18637	19111	53	.	.	.
18637	19112	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19112	2	503	503	CD
18637	19112	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19112	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19112	5	10	10	CD
18637	19112	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19112	7	A	a	DT
18637	19112	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	19112	9	on	on	IN
18637	19112	10	the	the	DT
18637	19112	11	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	19112	12	of	of	IN
18637	19112	13	a	a	DT
18637	19112	14	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19112	15	may	may	MD
18637	19112	16	be	be	VB
18637	19112	17	distributed	distribute	VBN
18637	19112	18	ratably	ratably	RB
18637	19112	19	among	among	IN
18637	19112	20	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	19112	21	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	19112	22	of	of	IN
18637	19112	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19112	24	residence	residence	NN
18637	19112	25	outside	outside	IN
18637	19112	26	the	the	DT
18637	19112	27	State	State	NNP
18637	19112	28	,	,	,
18637	19112	29	the	the	DT
18637	19112	30	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	19112	31	being	be	VBG
18637	19112	32	the	the	DT
18637	19112	33	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	19112	34	beneficiaries	beneficiary	NNS
18637	19112	35	of	of	IN
18637	19112	36	the	the	DT
18637	19112	37	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19112	38	's	's	POS
18637	19112	39	activities	activity	NNS
18637	19112	40	within	within	IN
18637	19112	41	the	the	DT
18637	19112	42	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19112	43	State	state	NN
18637	19112	44	and	and	CC
18637	19112	45	protected	protect	VBN
18637	19112	46	by	by	IN
18637	19112	47	the	the	DT
18637	19112	48	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19112	49	and	and	CC
18637	19112	50	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19112	51	to	to	IN
18637	19112	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19112	53	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19112	54	.	.	.
18637	19113	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19113	2	504	504	CD
18637	19113	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19113	4	This	this	DT
18637	19113	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	19113	6	,	,	,
18637	19113	7	though	though	IN
18637	19113	8	collected	collect	VBN
18637	19113	9	by	by	IN
18637	19113	10	the	the	DT
18637	19113	11	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19113	12	,	,	,
18637	19113	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	19113	14	on	on	IN
18637	19113	15	the	the	DT
18637	19113	16	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19113	17	to	to	IN
18637	19113	18	a	a	DT
18637	19113	19	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	19113	20	of	of	IN
18637	19113	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19113	22	share	share	NN
18637	19113	23	of	of	IN
18637	19113	24	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	19113	25	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	19113	26	within	within	IN
18637	19113	27	the	the	DT
18637	19113	28	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19113	29	State	State	NNP
18637	19113	30	,	,	,
18637	19113	31	and	and	CC
18637	19113	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	19113	33	deducted	deduct	VBN
18637	19113	34	from	from	IN
18637	19113	35	said	say	VBN
18637	19113	36	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	19113	37	payments	payment	NNS
18637	19113	38	.	.	.
18637	19114	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19114	2	505	505	CD
18637	19114	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19114	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19114	5	11	11	CD
18637	19114	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19114	7	Stamp	stamp	NN
18637	19114	8	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19114	9	on	on	IN
18637	19114	10	the	the	DT
18637	19114	11	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19114	12	within	within	IN
18637	19114	13	the	the	DT
18637	19114	14	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19114	15	State	state	NN
18637	19114	16	by	by	IN
18637	19114	17	one	one	CD
18637	19114	18	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19114	19	to	to	IN
18637	19114	20	another	another	DT
18637	19114	21	of	of	IN
18637	19114	22	stock	stock	NN
18637	19114	23	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	19114	24	issued	issue	VBN
18637	19114	25	by	by	IN
18637	19114	26	a	a	DT
18637	19114	27	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19114	28	corporation;[506	corporation;[506	NNPS
18637	19114	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19114	30	and	and	CC
18637	19114	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	19114	32	promissory	promissory	JJ
18637	19114	33	notes	note	NNS
18637	19114	34	executed	execute	VBN
18637	19114	35	by	by	IN
18637	19114	36	a	a	DT
18637	19114	37	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19114	38	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19114	39	,	,	,
18637	19114	40	although	although	IN
18637	19114	41	payable	payable	JJ
18637	19114	42	to	to	IN
18637	19114	43	banks	bank	NNS
18637	19114	44	in	in	IN
18637	19114	45	other	other	JJ
18637	19114	46	States	States	NNPS
18637	19114	47	.	.	.
18637	19115	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19115	2	507	507	CD
18637	19115	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19115	4	These	these	DT
18637	19115	5	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19115	6	,	,	,
18637	19115	7	however	however	RB
18637	19115	8	,	,	,
18637	19115	9	were	be	VBD
18637	19115	10	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19115	11	to	to	TO
18637	19115	12	have	have	VB
18637	19115	13	been	be	VBN
18637	19115	14	laid	lay	VBN
18637	19115	15	,	,	,
18637	19115	16	not	not	RB
18637	19115	17	on	on	IN
18637	19115	18	the	the	DT
18637	19115	19	property	property	NN
18637	19115	20	,	,	,
18637	19115	21	but	but	CC
18637	19115	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	19115	23	an	an	DT
18637	19115	24	event	event	NN
18637	19115	25	,	,	,
18637	19115	26	the	the	DT
18637	19115	27	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19115	28	in	in	IN
18637	19115	29	one	one	CD
18637	19115	30	instance	instance	NN
18637	19115	31	,	,	,
18637	19115	32	and	and	CC
18637	19115	33	execution	execution	NN
18637	19115	34	,	,	,
18637	19115	35	in	in	IN
18637	19115	36	the	the	DT
18637	19115	37	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19115	38	,	,	,
18637	19115	39	which	which	WDT
18637	19115	40	took	take	VBD
18637	19115	41	place	place	NN
18637	19115	42	in	in	IN
18637	19115	43	the	the	DT
18637	19115	44	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19115	45	State	state	NN
18637	19115	46	.	.	.
18637	19116	1	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19116	2	on	on	IN
18637	19116	3	Intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19116	4	Invalidated.--The	Invalidated.--The	NNP
18637	19116	5	following	follow	VBG
18637	19116	6	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19116	7	property	property	NN
18637	19116	8	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19116	9	on	on	IN
18637	19116	10	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19116	11	have	have	VBP
18637	19116	12	not	not	RB
18637	19116	13	been	be	VBN
18637	19116	14	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	19116	15	:	:	:
18637	19116	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19116	17	1	1	LS
18637	19116	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19116	19	Debts	Debts	NNP
18637	19116	20	evidenced	evidence	VBN
18637	19116	21	by	by	IN
18637	19116	22	notes	note	NNS
18637	19116	23	in	in	IN
18637	19116	24	safekeeping	safekeeping	NN
18637	19116	25	within	within	IN
18637	19116	26	the	the	DT
18637	19116	27	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19116	28	State	state	NN
18637	19116	29	,	,	,
18637	19116	30	but	but	CC
18637	19116	31	made	made	JJ
18637	19116	32	and	and	CC
18637	19116	33	payable	payable	JJ
18637	19116	34	and	and	CC
18637	19116	35	secured	secure	VBN
18637	19116	36	by	by	IN
18637	19116	37	property	property	NN
18637	19116	38	in	in	IN
18637	19116	39	a	a	DT
18637	19116	40	second	second	JJ
18637	19116	41	State	state	NN
18637	19116	42	and	and	CC
18637	19116	43	owned	own	VBN
18637	19116	44	by	by	IN
18637	19116	45	a	a	DT
18637	19116	46	resident	resident	NN
18637	19116	47	of	of	IN
18637	19116	48	a	a	DT
18637	19116	49	third	third	JJ
18637	19116	50	State	State	NNP
18637	19116	51	.	.	.
18637	19117	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19117	2	508	508	CD
18637	19117	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19117	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19117	5	2	2	LS
18637	19117	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19117	7	A	a	DT
18637	19117	8	property	property	NN
18637	19117	9	tax	tax	NN
18637	19117	10	sought	seek	VBD
18637	19117	11	to	to	TO
18637	19117	12	be	be	VB
18637	19117	13	collected	collect	VBN
18637	19117	14	from	from	IN
18637	19117	15	a	a	DT
18637	19117	16	life	life	NN
18637	19117	17	beneficiary	beneficiary	NN
18637	19117	18	on	on	IN
18637	19117	19	the	the	DT
18637	19117	20	corpus	corpus	NN
18637	19117	21	of	of	IN
18637	19117	22	a	a	DT
18637	19117	23	trust	trust	NN
18637	19117	24	composed	compose	VBN
18637	19117	25	of	of	IN
18637	19117	26	property	property	NN
18637	19117	27	located	locate	VBN
18637	19117	28	in	in	IN
18637	19117	29	another	another	DT
18637	19117	30	State	State	NNP
18637	19117	31	and	and	CC
18637	19117	32	as	as	IN
18637	19117	33	to	to	TO
18637	19117	34	which	which	WDT
18637	19117	35	said	say	VBD
18637	19117	36	beneficiary	beneficiary	NN
18637	19117	37	had	have	VBD
18637	19117	38	neither	neither	CC
18637	19117	39	control	control	NN
18637	19117	40	nor	nor	CC
18637	19117	41	possession	possession	NN
18637	19117	42	,	,	,
18637	19117	43	apart	apart	RB
18637	19117	44	from	from	IN
18637	19117	45	the	the	DT
18637	19117	46	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	19117	47	of	of	IN
18637	19117	48	income	income	NN
18637	19117	49	therefrom	therefrom	NN
18637	19117	50	.	.	.
18637	19118	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19118	2	509	509	CD
18637	19118	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19118	4	However	however	RB
18637	19118	5	,	,	,
18637	19118	6	a	a	DT
18637	19118	7	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19118	8	property	property	NN
18637	19118	9	tax	tax	NN
18637	19118	10	may	may	MD
18637	19118	11	be	be	VB
18637	19118	12	collected	collect	VBN
18637	19118	13	on	on	IN
18637	19118	14	one	one	CD
18637	19118	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	19118	16	half	half	NN
18637	19118	17	of	of	IN
18637	19118	18	the	the	DT
18637	19118	19	value	value	NN
18637	19118	20	of	of	IN
18637	19118	21	the	the	DT
18637	19118	22	corpus	corpus	NN
18637	19118	23	of	of	IN
18637	19118	24	a	a	DT
18637	19118	25	trust	trust	NN
18637	19118	26	from	from	IN
18637	19118	27	a	a	DT
18637	19118	28	resident	resident	NN
18637	19118	29	who	who	WP
18637	19118	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	19118	31	one	one	CD
18637	19118	32	of	of	IN
18637	19118	33	the	the	DT
18637	19118	34	two	two	CD
18637	19118	35	trustees	trustee	NNS
18637	19118	36	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19118	37	,	,	,
18637	19118	38	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19118	39	that	that	IN
18637	19118	40	the	the	DT
18637	19118	41	trust	trust	NN
18637	19118	42	was	be	VBD
18637	19118	43	created	create	VBN
18637	19118	44	by	by	IN
18637	19118	45	the	the	DT
18637	19118	46	will	will	NN
18637	19118	47	of	of	IN
18637	19118	48	a	a	DT
18637	19118	49	resident	resident	NN
18637	19118	50	of	of	IN
18637	19118	51	another	another	DT
18637	19118	52	State	State	NNP
18637	19118	53	in	in	IN
18637	19118	54	respect	respect	NN
18637	19118	55	of	of	IN
18637	19118	56	intangible	intangible	JJ
18637	19118	57	property	property	NN
18637	19118	58	located	locate	VBN
18637	19118	59	in	in	IN
18637	19118	60	the	the	DT
18637	19118	61	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19118	62	State	State	NNP
18637	19118	63	,	,	,
18637	19118	64	at	at	IN
18637	19118	65	least	least	JJS
18637	19118	66	where	where	WRB
18637	19118	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19118	68	does	do	VBZ
18637	19118	69	not	not	RB
18637	19118	70	appear	appear	VB
18637	19118	71	that	that	IN
18637	19118	72	the	the	DT
18637	19118	73	trustee	trustee	NN
18637	19118	74	is	be	VBZ
18637	19118	75	exposed	expose	VBN
18637	19118	76	to	to	IN
18637	19118	77	the	the	DT
18637	19118	78	danger	danger	NN
18637	19118	79	of	of	IN
18637	19118	80	other	other	JJ
18637	19118	81	_	_	NNP
18637	19118	82	ad	ad	NN
18637	19118	83	valorem	valorem	NN
18637	19118	84	_	_	NNP
18637	19118	85	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19118	86	in	in	IN
18637	19118	87	another	another	DT
18637	19118	88	State	state	NN
18637	19118	89	.	.	.
18637	19119	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19119	2	510	510	CD
18637	19119	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19119	4	The	the	DT
18637	19119	5	first	first	JJ
18637	19119	6	case	case	NN
18637	19119	7	,	,	,
18637	19119	8	Brooke	Brooke	NNP
18637	19119	9	_	_	NNP
18637	19119	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	19119	11	_	_	NNP
18637	19119	12	Norfolk,[511	Norfolk,[511	NNP
18637	19119	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19119	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19119	15	distinguishable	distinguishable	JJ
18637	19119	16	by	by	IN
18637	19119	17	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	19119	18	of	of	IN
18637	19119	19	the	the	DT
18637	19119	20	fact	fact	NN
18637	19119	21	that	that	IN
18637	19119	22	the	the	DT
18637	19119	23	property	property	NN
18637	19119	24	tax	tax	NN
18637	19119	25	therein	therein	RB
18637	19119	26	voided	void	VBN
18637	19119	27	was	be	VBD
18637	19119	28	levied	levy	VBN
18637	19119	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	19119	30	a	a	DT
18637	19119	31	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19119	32	beneficiary	beneficiary	NN
18637	19119	33	rather	rather	RB
18637	19119	34	than	than	IN
18637	19119	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	19119	36	a	a	DT
18637	19119	37	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19119	38	trustee	trustee	NN
18637	19119	39	in	in	IN
18637	19119	40	control	control	NN
18637	19119	41	of	of	IN
18637	19119	42	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19119	43	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19119	44	.	.	.
18637	19120	1	Different	different	JJ
18637	19120	2	too	too	RB
18637	19120	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	19120	4	Safe	Safe	NNP
18637	19120	5	Deposit	Deposit	NNP
18637	19120	6	and	and	CC
18637	19120	7	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	19120	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	19120	9	_	_	NNP
18637	19120	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	19120	11	_	_	NNP
18637	19120	12	Virginia,[512	Virginia,[512	NNP
18637	19120	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19120	14	where	where	WRB
18637	19120	15	a	a	DT
18637	19120	16	property	property	NN
18637	19120	17	tax	tax	NN
18637	19120	18	was	be	VBD
18637	19120	19	unsuccessfully	unsuccessfully	RB
18637	19120	20	demanded	demand	VBN
18637	19120	21	of	of	IN
18637	19120	22	a	a	DT
18637	19120	23	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19120	24	trustee	trustee	NN
18637	19120	25	with	with	IN
18637	19120	26	respect	respect	NN
18637	19120	27	to	to	IN
18637	19120	28	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19120	29	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19120	30	under	under	IN
18637	19120	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19120	32	control	control	NN
18637	19120	33	.	.	.
18637	19121	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19121	2	3	3	LS
18637	19121	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19121	4	A	a	DT
18637	19121	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	19121	6	,	,	,
18637	19121	7	measured	measure	VBN
18637	19121	8	by	by	IN
18637	19121	9	income	income	NN
18637	19121	10	,	,	,
18637	19121	11	levied	levy	VBN
18637	19121	12	on	on	IN
18637	19121	13	trust	trust	NN
18637	19121	14	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	19121	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	19121	16	by	by	IN
18637	19121	17	a	a	DT
18637	19121	18	resident	resident	NN
18637	19121	19	,	,	,
18637	19121	20	representing	represent	VBG
18637	19121	21	interests	interest	NNS
18637	19121	22	in	in	IN
18637	19121	23	various	various	JJ
18637	19121	24	parcels	parcel	NNS
18637	19121	25	of	of	IN
18637	19121	26	land	land	NN
18637	19121	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19121	28	some	some	DT
18637	19121	29	inside	inside	IN
18637	19121	30	the	the	DT
18637	19121	31	State	State	NNP
18637	19121	32	and	and	CC
18637	19121	33	some	some	DT
18637	19121	34	outside	outside	NN
18637	19121	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19121	36	,	,	,
18637	19121	37	the	the	DT
18637	19121	38	holder	holder	NN
18637	19121	39	of	of	IN
18637	19121	40	the	the	DT
18637	19121	41	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	19121	42	,	,	,
18637	19121	43	though	though	IN
18637	19121	44	without	without	IN
18637	19121	45	a	a	DT
18637	19121	46	voice	voice	NN
18637	19121	47	in	in	IN
18637	19121	48	the	the	DT
18637	19121	49	management	management	NN
18637	19121	50	of	of	IN
18637	19121	51	the	the	DT
18637	19121	52	property	property	NN
18637	19121	53	,	,	,
18637	19121	54	being	be	VBG
18637	19121	55	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19121	56	to	to	IN
18637	19121	57	a	a	DT
18637	19121	58	share	share	NN
18637	19121	59	in	in	IN
18637	19121	60	the	the	DT
18637	19121	61	net	net	JJ
18637	19121	62	income	income	NN
18637	19121	63	and	and	CC
18637	19121	64	,	,	,
18637	19121	65	upon	upon	IN
18637	19121	66	sale	sale	NN
18637	19121	67	of	of	IN
18637	19121	68	the	the	DT
18637	19121	69	property	property	NN
18637	19121	70	,	,	,
18637	19121	71	to	to	IN
18637	19121	72	the	the	DT
18637	19121	73	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	19121	74	of	of	IN
18637	19121	75	the	the	DT
18637	19121	76	sale	sale	NN
18637	19121	77	.	.	.
18637	19122	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19122	2	513	513	CD
18637	19122	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19122	4	Transfer	Transfer	NNP
18637	19122	5	Taxes	Taxes	NNP
18637	19122	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19122	7	Inheritance	Inheritance	NNP
18637	19122	8	,	,	,
18637	19122	9	Estate	Estate	NNP
18637	19122	10	,	,	,
18637	19122	11	Gift	Gift	NNP
18637	19122	12	Taxes).--Being	Taxes).--Being	NNP
18637	19122	13	competent	competent	NN
18637	19122	14	to	to	TO
18637	19122	15	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	19122	16	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19122	17	of	of	IN
18637	19122	18	the	the	DT
18637	19122	19	power	power	NN
18637	19122	20	of	of	IN
18637	19122	21	testamentary	testamentary	NN
18637	19122	22	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	19122	23	and	and	CC
18637	19122	24	the	the	DT
18637	19122	25	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19122	26	of	of	IN
18637	19122	27	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	19122	28	,	,	,
18637	19122	29	a	a	DT
18637	19122	30	State	State	NNP
18637	19122	31	may	may	MD
18637	19122	32	base	base	VB
18637	19122	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19122	34	succession	succession	NN
18637	19122	35	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19122	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	19122	37	either	either	CC
18637	19122	38	the	the	DT
18637	19122	39	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	19122	40	,	,	,
18637	19122	41	or	or	CC
18637	19122	42	an	an	DT
18637	19122	43	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19122	44	of	of	IN
18637	19122	45	the	the	DT
18637	19122	46	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19122	47	power	power	NN
18637	19122	48	of	of	IN
18637	19122	49	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	19122	50	,	,	,
18637	19122	51	of	of	IN
18637	19122	52	property	property	NN
18637	19122	53	by	by	IN
18637	19122	54	will	will	NN
18637	19122	55	or	or	CC
18637	19122	56	by	by	IN
18637	19122	57	descent	descent	NN
18637	19122	58	,	,	,
18637	19122	59	or	or	CC
18637	19122	60	the	the	DT
18637	19122	61	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	19122	62	of	of	IN
18637	19122	63	the	the	DT
18637	19122	64	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19122	65	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19122	66	of	of	IN
18637	19122	67	taking	take	VBG
18637	19122	68	property	property	NN
18637	19122	69	by	by	IN
18637	19122	70	devise	devise	NN
18637	19122	71	or	or	CC
18637	19122	72	descent	descent	NN
18637	19122	73	.	.	.
18637	19123	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19123	2	514	514	LS
18637	19123	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19123	4	But	but	CC
18637	19123	5	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	19123	6	may	may	MD
18637	19123	7	be	be	VB
18637	19123	8	the	the	DT
18637	19123	9	justification	justification	NN
18637	19123	10	of	of	IN
18637	19123	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19123	12	power	power	NN
18637	19123	13	to	to	TO
18637	19123	14	levy	levy	VB
18637	19123	15	such	such	JJ
18637	19123	16	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19123	17	,	,	,
18637	19123	18	States	state	NNS
18637	19123	19	have	have	VBP
18637	19123	20	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	19123	21	found	find	VBN
18637	19123	22	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19123	23	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	19123	24	by	by	IN
18637	19123	25	the	the	DT
18637	19123	26	rule	rule	NN
18637	19123	27	,	,	,
18637	19123	28	established	establish	VBN
18637	19123	29	as	as	IN
18637	19123	30	to	to	IN
18637	19123	31	property	property	NN
18637	19123	32	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19123	33	in	in	IN
18637	19123	34	1905	1905	CD
18637	19123	35	in	in	IN
18637	19123	36	Union	Union	NNP
18637	19123	37	Refrigerator	Refrigerator	NNP
18637	19123	38	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	19123	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	19123	40	_	_	NNP
18637	19123	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	19123	42	_	_	NNP
18637	19123	43	Kentucky,[515	Kentucky,[515	NNP
18637	19123	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19123	45	and	and	CC
18637	19123	46	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	19123	47	reiterated	reiterate	VBN
18637	19123	48	in	in	IN
18637	19123	49	Frick	Frick	NNP
18637	19123	50	_	_	NNP
18637	19123	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	19123	52	_	_	NNP
18637	19123	53	Pennsylvania[516	Pennsylvania[516	NNP
18637	19123	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19123	55	in	in	IN
18637	19123	56	1925	1925	CD
18637	19123	57	,	,	,
18637	19123	58	which	which	WDT
18637	19123	59	precludes	preclude	VBZ
18637	19123	60	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	19123	61	of	of	IN
18637	19123	62	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19123	63	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19123	64	upon	upon	IN
18637	19123	65	tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	19123	66	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19123	67	property	property	NN
18637	19123	68	by	by	IN
18637	19123	69	any	any	DT
18637	19123	70	State	State	NNP
18637	19123	71	other	other	JJ
18637	19123	72	than	than	IN
18637	19123	73	the	the	DT
18637	19123	74	one	one	CD
18637	19123	75	in	in	IN
18637	19123	76	which	which	WDT
18637	19123	77	such	such	JJ
18637	19123	78	tangibles	tangible	NNS
18637	19123	79	are	be	VBP
18637	19123	80	permanently	permanently	RB
18637	19123	81	located	locate	VBN
18637	19123	82	or	or	CC
18637	19123	83	have	have	VBP
18637	19123	84	an	an	DT
18637	19123	85	actual	actual	JJ
18637	19123	86	situs	situs	NN
18637	19123	87	.	.	.
18637	19124	1	In	in	IN
18637	19124	2	the	the	DT
18637	19124	3	case	case	NN
18637	19124	4	of	of	IN
18637	19124	5	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19124	6	,	,	,
18637	19124	7	however	however	RB
18637	19124	8	,	,	,
18637	19124	9	the	the	DT
18637	19124	10	States	state	NNS
18637	19124	11	have	have	VBP
18637	19124	12	been	be	VBN
18637	19124	13	harassed	harass	VBN
18637	19124	14	by	by	IN
18637	19124	15	the	the	DT
18637	19124	16	indecision	indecision	NN
18637	19124	17	of	of	IN
18637	19124	18	the	the	DT
18637	19124	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19124	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19124	21	;	;	:
18637	19124	22	for	for	IN
18637	19124	23	to	to	IN
18637	19124	24	an	an	DT
18637	19124	25	even	even	RB
18637	19124	26	greater	great	JJR
18637	19124	27	extent	extent	NN
18637	19124	28	than	than	IN
18637	19124	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	19124	30	discernible	discernible	JJ
18637	19124	31	in	in	IN
18637	19124	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19124	33	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	19124	34	of	of	IN
18637	19124	35	property	property	NN
18637	19124	36	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19124	37	on	on	IN
18637	19124	38	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19124	39	,	,	,
18637	19124	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19124	41	has	have	VBZ
18637	19124	42	oscillated	oscillate	VBN
18637	19124	43	in	in	IN
18637	19124	44	upholding	upholding	NN
18637	19124	45	,	,	,
18637	19124	46	then	then	RB
18637	19124	47	rejecting	reject	VBG
18637	19124	48	,	,	,
18637	19124	49	and	and	CC
18637	19124	50	again	again	RB
18637	19124	51	currently	currently	RB
18637	19124	52	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	19124	53	the	the	DT
18637	19124	54	levy	levy	NN
18637	19124	55	by	by	IN
18637	19124	56	more	more	JJR
18637	19124	57	than	than	IN
18637	19124	58	one	one	CD
18637	19124	59	State	state	NN
18637	19124	60	of	of	IN
18637	19124	61	death	death	NN
18637	19124	62	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19124	63	upon	upon	IN
18637	19124	64	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19124	65	comprising	comprise	VBG
18637	19124	66	the	the	DT
18637	19124	67	estate	estate	NN
18637	19124	68	of	of	IN
18637	19124	69	a	a	DT
18637	19124	70	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19124	71	.	.	.
18637	19125	1	Until	until	IN
18637	19125	2	1930	1930	CD
18637	19125	3	,	,	,
18637	19125	4	transfer	transfer	VB
18637	19125	5	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19125	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	19125	7	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19125	8	levied	levy	VBN
18637	19125	9	by	by	IN
18637	19125	10	both	both	CC
18637	19125	11	the	the	DT
18637	19125	12	domiciliary	domiciliary	NN
18637	19125	13	as	as	RB
18637	19125	14	well	well	RB
18637	19125	15	as	as	IN
18637	19125	16	nondomiciliary	nondomiciliary	JJ
18637	19125	17	,	,	,
18637	19125	18	or	or	CC
18637	19125	19	situs	situs	NN
18637	19125	20	State	State	NNP
18637	19125	21	,	,	,
18637	19125	22	were	be	VBD
18637	19125	23	with	with	IN
18637	19125	24	rare	rare	JJ
18637	19125	25	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	19125	26	approved	approve	VBN
18637	19125	27	.	.	.
18637	19126	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19126	2	,	,	,
18637	19126	3	in	in	IN
18637	19126	4	Bullen	Bullen	NNP
18637	19126	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19126	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	19126	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19126	8	Wisconsin,[517	Wisconsin,[517	NNP
18637	19126	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19126	10	the	the	DT
18637	19126	11	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	19126	12	State	State	NNP
18637	19126	13	of	of	IN
18637	19126	14	the	the	DT
18637	19126	15	creator	creator	NN
18637	19126	16	of	of	IN
18637	19126	17	a	a	DT
18637	19126	18	trust	trust	NN
18637	19126	19	was	be	VBD
18637	19126	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	19126	21	competent	competent	JJ
18637	19126	22	to	to	TO
18637	19126	23	levy	levy	VB
18637	19126	24	an	an	DT
18637	19126	25	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	19126	26	tax	tax	NN
18637	19126	27	,	,	,
18637	19126	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	19126	29	the	the	DT
18637	19126	30	death	death	NN
18637	19126	31	of	of	IN
18637	19126	32	the	the	DT
18637	19126	33	settlor	settlor	NN
18637	19126	34	,	,	,
18637	19126	35	on	on	IN
18637	19126	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19126	37	trust	trust	NN
18637	19126	38	fund	fund	NN
18637	19126	39	consisting	consisting	NN
18637	19126	40	of	of	IN
18637	19126	41	stocks	stock	NNS
18637	19126	42	,	,	,
18637	19126	43	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	19126	44	,	,	,
18637	19126	45	and	and	CC
18637	19126	46	notes	note	NNS
18637	19126	47	kept	keep	VBD
18637	19126	48	and	and	CC
18637	19126	49	administered	administer	VBN
18637	19126	50	in	in	IN
18637	19126	51	another	another	DT
18637	19126	52	State	State	NNP
18637	19126	53	and	and	CC
18637	19126	54	as	as	IN
18637	19126	55	to	to	TO
18637	19126	56	which	which	WDT
18637	19126	57	the	the	DT
18637	19126	58	settlor	settlor	NN
18637	19126	59	reserved	reserve	VBD
18637	19126	60	the	the	DT
18637	19126	61	right	right	NN
18637	19126	62	to	to	TO
18637	19126	63	control	control	VB
18637	19126	64	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	19126	65	and	and	CC
18637	19126	66	to	to	TO
18637	19126	67	direct	direct	VB
18637	19126	68	payment	payment	NN
18637	19126	69	of	of	IN
18637	19126	70	income	income	NN
18637	19126	71	for	for	IN
18637	19126	72	life	life	NN
18637	19126	73	,	,	,
18637	19126	74	such	such	JJ
18637	19126	75	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	19126	76	powers	power	NNS
18637	19126	77	being	be	VBG
18637	19126	78	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
18637	19126	79	to	to	IN
18637	19126	80	a	a	DT
18637	19126	81	fee	fee	NN
18637	19126	82	.	.	.
18637	19127	1	Cognizance	Cognizance	NNP
18637	19127	2	was	be	VBD
18637	19127	3	taken	take	VBN
18637	19127	4	of	of	IN
18637	19127	5	the	the	DT
18637	19127	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	19127	7	that	that	IN
18637	19127	8	the	the	DT
18637	19127	9	State	State	NNP
18637	19127	10	in	in	IN
18637	19127	11	which	which	WDT
18637	19127	12	these	these	DT
18637	19127	13	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19127	14	had	have	VBD
18637	19127	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19127	16	situs	situs	NN
18637	19127	17	had	have	VBD
18637	19127	18	also	also	RB
18637	19127	19	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19127	20	the	the	DT
18637	19127	21	trust	trust	NN
18637	19127	22	.	.	.
18637	19128	1	Levy	levy	NN
18637	19128	2	of	of	IN
18637	19128	3	an	an	DT
18637	19128	4	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	19128	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	19128	6	by	by	IN
18637	19128	7	a	a	DT
18637	19128	8	nondomiciliary	nondomiciliary	JJ
18637	19128	9	State	state	NN
18637	19128	10	was	be	VBD
18637	19128	11	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	19128	12	on	on	IN
18637	19128	13	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19128	14	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	19128	15	in	in	IN
18637	19128	16	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	19128	17	_	_	NNP
18637	19128	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	19128	19	_	_	NNP
18637	19128	20	Sohmer	Sohmer	NNP
18637	19128	21	,	,	,
18637	19128	22	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	19128	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19128	24	was	be	VBD
18637	19128	25	held	hold	VBN
18637	19128	26	that	that	IN
18637	19128	27	the	the	DT
18637	19128	28	presence	presence	NN
18637	19128	29	of	of	IN
18637	19128	30	a	a	DT
18637	19128	31	negotiable	negotiable	JJ
18637	19128	32	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	19128	33	was	be	VBD
18637	19128	34	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19128	35	to	to	TO
18637	19128	36	confer	confer	VB
18637	19128	37	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19128	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	19128	39	the	the	DT
18637	19128	40	State	state	NN
18637	19128	41	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	19128	42	to	to	TO
18637	19128	43	tax	tax	VB
18637	19128	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19128	45	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19128	46	.	.	.
18637	19129	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19129	2	518	518	CD
18637	19129	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19129	4	On	on	IN
18637	19129	5	the	the	DT
18637	19129	6	other	other	JJ
18637	19129	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	19129	8	,	,	,
18637	19129	9	the	the	DT
18637	19129	10	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19129	11	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	19129	12	by	by	IN
18637	19129	13	a	a	DT
18637	19129	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19129	15	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19129	16	of	of	IN
18637	19129	17	property	property	NN
18637	19129	18	in	in	IN
18637	19129	19	a	a	DT
18637	19129	20	nondomiciliary	nondomiciliary	JJ
18637	19129	21	State	state	NN
18637	19129	22	was	be	VBD
18637	19129	23	held	hold	VBN
18637	19129	24	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	19129	25	to	to	TO
18637	19129	26	support	support	VB
18637	19129	27	a	a	DT
18637	19129	28	tax	tax	NN
18637	19129	29	by	by	IN
18637	19129	30	that	that	DT
18637	19129	31	State	state	NN
18637	19129	32	on	on	IN
18637	19129	33	the	the	DT
18637	19129	34	succession	succession	NN
18637	19129	35	to	to	IN
18637	19129	36	shares	share	NNS
18637	19129	37	of	of	IN
18637	19129	38	stock	stock	NN
18637	19129	39	in	in	IN
18637	19129	40	that	that	DT
18637	19129	41	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19129	42	owned	own	VBN
18637	19129	43	by	by	IN
18637	19129	44	a	a	DT
18637	19129	45	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19129	46	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19129	47	.	.	.
18637	19130	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19130	2	519	519	CD
18637	19130	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19130	4	Also	also	RB
18637	19130	5	against	against	IN
18637	19130	6	the	the	DT
18637	19130	7	trend	trend	NN
18637	19130	8	was	be	VBD
18637	19130	9	Blodgett	Blodgett	NNP
18637	19130	10	_	_	NNP
18637	19130	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	19130	12	_	_	NNP
18637	19130	13	Silberman[520	Silberman[520	NNP
18637	19130	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19130	15	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	19130	16	the	the	DT
18637	19130	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19130	18	defeated	defeat	VBD
18637	19130	19	collection	collection	NN
18637	19130	20	of	of	IN
18637	19130	21	a	a	DT
18637	19130	22	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19130	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	19130	24	by	by	IN
18637	19130	25	the	the	DT
18637	19130	26	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	19130	27	State	State	NNP
18637	19130	28	by	by	IN
18637	19130	29	treating	treat	VBG
18637	19130	30	coins	coin	NNS
18637	19130	31	and	and	CC
18637	19130	32	bank	bank	NN
18637	19130	33	notes	note	NNS
18637	19130	34	deposited	deposit	VBN
18637	19130	35	by	by	IN
18637	19130	36	a	a	DT
18637	19130	37	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19130	38	in	in	IN
18637	19130	39	a	a	DT
18637	19130	40	safe	safe	JJ
18637	19130	41	deposit	deposit	NN
18637	19130	42	box	box	NN
18637	19130	43	in	in	IN
18637	19130	44	another	another	DT
18637	19130	45	State	State	NNP
18637	19130	46	as	as	IN
18637	19130	47	tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	19130	48	property	property	NN
18637	19130	49	,	,	,
18637	19130	50	albeit	albeit	IN
18637	19130	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19130	52	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	19130	53	that	that	IN
18637	19130	54	the	the	DT
18637	19130	55	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	19130	56	State	State	NNP
18637	19130	57	could	could	MD
18637	19130	58	tax	tax	VB
18637	19130	59	the	the	DT
18637	19130	60	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19130	61	of	of	IN
18637	19130	62	books	book	NNS
18637	19130	63	and	and	CC
18637	19130	64	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	19130	65	of	of	IN
18637	19130	66	indebtedness	indebtedness	NN
18637	19130	67	found	find	VBN
18637	19130	68	in	in	IN
18637	19130	69	that	that	DT
18637	19130	70	safe	safe	JJ
18637	19130	71	deposit	deposit	NN
18637	19130	72	box	box	NN
18637	19130	73	as	as	RB
18637	19130	74	well	well	RB
18637	19130	75	as	as	IN
18637	19130	76	the	the	DT
18637	19130	77	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19130	78	's	's	POS
18637	19130	79	interest	interest	NN
18637	19130	80	in	in	IN
18637	19130	81	a	a	DT
18637	19130	82	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19130	83	partnership	partnership	NN
18637	19130	84	.	.	.
18637	19131	1	In	in	IN
18637	19131	2	the	the	DT
18637	19131	3	course	course	NN
18637	19131	4	of	of	IN
18637	19131	5	about	about	RB
18637	19131	6	two	two	CD
18637	19131	7	years	year	NNS
18637	19131	8	following	follow	VBG
18637	19131	9	the	the	DT
18637	19131	10	recent	recent	JJ
18637	19131	11	Depression	Depression	NNP
18637	19131	12	,	,	,
18637	19131	13	the	the	DT
18637	19131	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19131	15	handed	hand	VBD
18637	19131	16	down	down	RP
18637	19131	17	a	a	DT
18637	19131	18	group	group	NN
18637	19131	19	of	of	IN
18637	19131	20	four	four	CD
18637	19131	21	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19131	22	which	which	WDT
18637	19131	23	,	,	,
18637	19131	24	for	for	IN
18637	19131	25	the	the	DT
18637	19131	26	time	time	NN
18637	19131	27	being	be	VBG
18637	19131	28	at	at	IN
18637	19131	29	any	any	DT
18637	19131	30	rate	rate	NN
18637	19131	31	,	,	,
18637	19131	32	placed	place	VBD
18637	19131	33	the	the	DT
18637	19131	34	stamp	stamp	NN
18637	19131	35	of	of	IN
18637	19131	36	disapproval	disapproval	NN
18637	19131	37	upon	upon	IN
18637	19131	38	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	19131	39	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19131	40	and	and	CC
18637	19131	41	--	--	:
18637	19131	42	by	by	IN
18637	19131	43	inference	inference	NN
18637	19131	44	--	--	:
18637	19131	45	other	other	JJ
18637	19131	46	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	19131	47	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19131	48	of	of	IN
18637	19131	49	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19131	50	.	.	.
18637	19132	1	Asserting	asserting	NN
18637	19132	2	,	,	,
18637	19132	3	as	as	IN
18637	19132	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19132	5	did	do	VBD
18637	19132	6	in	in	IN
18637	19132	7	one	one	CD
18637	19132	8	of	of	IN
18637	19132	9	these	these	DT
18637	19132	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	19132	11	,	,	,
18637	19132	12	that	that	IN
18637	19132	13	"	"	``
18637	19132	14	practical	practical	JJ
18637	19132	15	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	19132	16	of	of	IN
18637	19132	17	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	19132	18	,	,	,
18637	19132	19	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	19132	20	and	and	CC
18637	19132	21	justice	justice	NN
18637	19132	22	alike	alike	RB
18637	19132	23	dictate	dictate	VBP
18637	19132	24	the	the	DT
18637	19132	25	desirability	desirability	NN
18637	19132	26	of	of	IN
18637	19132	27	a	a	DT
18637	19132	28	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	19132	29	general	general	JJ
18637	19132	30	rule	rule	NN
18637	19132	31	confining	confine	VBG
18637	19132	32	the	the	DT
18637	19132	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19132	34	to	to	TO
18637	19132	35	impose	impose	VB
18637	19132	36	death	death	NN
18637	19132	37	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19132	38	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19132	39	as	as	IN
18637	19132	40	to	to	IN
18637	19132	41	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19132	42	to	to	IN
18637	19132	43	the	the	DT
18637	19132	44	State	State	NNP
18637	19132	45	of	of	IN
18637	19132	46	the	the	DT
18637	19132	47	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19132	48	owner	owner	NN
18637	19132	49	's	's	POS
18637	19132	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19132	51	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19132	52	;	;	:
18637	19132	53	*	*	NFP
18637	19132	54	*	*	NFP
18637	19132	55	*	*	NFP
18637	19132	56	"	"	''
18637	19132	57	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19132	58	521	521	CD
18637	19132	59	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19132	60	the	the	DT
18637	19132	61	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19132	62	,	,	,
18637	19132	63	through	through	IN
18637	19132	64	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	19132	65	application	application	NN
18637	19132	66	of	of	IN
18637	19132	67	the	the	DT
18637	19132	68	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	19132	69	,	,	,
18637	19132	70	_	_	NNP
18637	19132	71	mobilia	mobilia	NNP
18637	19132	72	sequuntur	sequuntur	NNP
18637	19132	73	personam	personam	NNP
18637	19132	74	_	_	NNP
18637	19132	75	,	,	,
18637	19132	76	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	19132	77	to	to	TO
18637	19132	78	deny	deny	VB
18637	19132	79	the	the	DT
18637	19132	80	right	right	NN
18637	19132	81	of	of	IN
18637	19132	82	nondomiciliary	nondomiciliary	JJ
18637	19132	83	States	state	NNS
18637	19132	84	to	to	TO
18637	19132	85	tax	tax	VB
18637	19132	86	and	and	CC
18637	19132	87	to	to	TO
18637	19132	88	reject	reject	VB
18637	19132	89	as	as	IN
18637	19132	90	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
18637	19132	91	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	19132	92	claims	claim	NNS
18637	19132	93	of	of	IN
18637	19132	94	the	the	DT
18637	19132	95	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19132	96	founded	found	VBN
18637	19132	97	upon	upon	IN
18637	19132	98	such	such	JJ
18637	19132	99	bases	basis	NNS
18637	19132	100	as	as	IN
18637	19132	101	control	control	NN
18637	19132	102	,	,	,
18637	19132	103	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19132	104	,	,	,
18637	19132	105	and	and	CC
18637	19132	106	protection	protection	NN
18637	19132	107	or	or	CC
18637	19132	108	situs	situs	NN
18637	19132	109	.	.	.
18637	19133	1	During	during	IN
18637	19133	2	this	this	DT
18637	19133	3	interval	interval	NN
18637	19133	4	,	,	,
18637	19133	5	1930	1930	CD
18637	19133	6	-	-	SYM
18637	19133	7	1932	1932	CD
18637	19133	8	,	,	,
18637	19133	9	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	19133	10	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19133	11	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19133	12	of	of	IN
18637	19133	13	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19133	14	came	come	VBD
18637	19133	15	to	to	TO
18637	19133	16	be	be	VB
18637	19133	17	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19133	18	,	,	,
18637	19133	19	not	not	RB
18637	19133	20	merely	merely	RB
18637	19133	21	as	as	IN
18637	19133	22	undesirable	undesirable	JJ
18637	19133	23	,	,	,
18637	19133	24	but	but	CC
18637	19133	25	as	as	IN
18637	19133	26	so	so	RB
18637	19133	27	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19133	28	and	and	CC
18637	19133	29	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19133	30	as	as	IN
18637	19133	31	to	to	TO
18637	19133	32	be	be	VB
18637	19133	33	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	19133	34	by	by	IN
18637	19133	35	the	the	DT
18637	19133	36	due	due	JJ
18637	19133	37	process	process	NN
18637	19133	38	clause	clause	NN
18637	19133	39	.	.	.
18637	19134	1	Beginning	begin	VBG
18637	19134	2	,	,	,
18637	19134	3	in	in	IN
18637	19134	4	1930	1930	CD
18637	19134	5	,	,	,
18637	19134	6	with	with	IN
18637	19134	7	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	19134	8	'	'	POS
18637	19134	9	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	19134	10	and	and	CC
18637	19134	11	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	19134	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	19134	13	_	_	NNP
18637	19134	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	19134	15	_	_	NNP
18637	19134	16	Minnesota,[522	Minnesota,[522	NNP
18637	19134	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19134	18	the	the	DT
18637	19134	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19134	20	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	19134	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19134	22	former	former	JJ
18637	19134	23	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	19134	24	in	in	IN
18637	19134	25	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
18637	19134	26	_	_	NNP
18637	19134	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	19134	28	_	_	NNP
18637	19134	29	Miller,[523	Miller,[523	NNP
18637	19134	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19134	31	in	in	IN
18637	19134	32	which	which	WDT
18637	19134	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19134	34	had	have	VBD
18637	19134	35	held	hold	VBN
18637	19134	36	that	that	IN
18637	19134	37	the	the	DT
18637	19134	38	State	State	NNP
18637	19134	39	in	in	IN
18637	19134	40	which	which	WDT
18637	19134	41	a	a	DT
18637	19134	42	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	19134	43	was	be	VBD
18637	19134	44	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	19134	45	or	or	CC
18637	19134	46	a	a	DT
18637	19134	47	bank	bank	NN
18637	19134	48	located	locate	VBN
18637	19134	49	could	could	MD
18637	19134	50	levy	levy	VB
18637	19134	51	an	an	DT
18637	19134	52	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	19134	53	tax	tax	NN
18637	19134	54	on	on	IN
18637	19134	55	the	the	DT
18637	19134	56	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19134	57	of	of	IN
18637	19134	58	the	the	DT
18637	19134	59	debt	debt	NN
18637	19134	60	or	or	CC
18637	19134	61	the	the	DT
18637	19134	62	deposit	deposit	NN
18637	19134	63	,	,	,
18637	19134	64	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19134	65	that	that	IN
18637	19134	66	the	the	DT
18637	19134	67	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	19134	68	had	have	VBD
18637	19134	69	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19134	70	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19134	71	in	in	IN
18637	19134	72	a	a	DT
18637	19134	73	different	different	JJ
18637	19134	74	State	state	NN
18637	19134	75	.	.	.
18637	19135	1	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	19135	2	'	'	POS
18637	19135	3	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	19135	4	and	and	CC
18637	19135	5	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	19135	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	19135	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19135	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	19135	9	_	_	NNP
18637	19135	10	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	19135	11	,	,	,
18637	19135	12	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	19135	13	appraised	appraise	VBN
18637	19135	14	,	,	,
18637	19135	15	was	be	VBD
18637	19135	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	19135	17	simply	simply	RB
18637	19135	18	for	for	IN
18637	19135	19	the	the	DT
18637	19135	20	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	19135	21	that	that	IN
18637	19135	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19135	23	over	over	IN
18637	19135	24	a	a	DT
18637	19135	25	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	19135	26	,	,	,
18637	19135	27	in	in	IN
18637	19135	28	this	this	DT
18637	19135	29	instance	instance	NN
18637	19135	30	a	a	DT
18637	19135	31	State	state	NN
18637	19135	32	which	which	WDT
18637	19135	33	had	have	VBD
18637	19135	34	issued	issue	VBN
18637	19135	35	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	19135	36	held	hold	VBN
18637	19135	37	by	by	IN
18637	19135	38	a	a	DT
18637	19135	39	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19135	40	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	19135	41	,	,	,
18637	19135	42	was	be	VBD
18637	19135	43	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
18637	19135	44	to	to	TO
18637	19135	45	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	19135	46	a	a	DT
18637	19135	47	tax	tax	NN
18637	19135	48	by	by	IN
18637	19135	49	that	that	DT
18637	19135	50	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	19135	51	State	State	NNP
18637	19135	52	on	on	IN
18637	19135	53	the	the	DT
18637	19135	54	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19135	55	of	of	IN
18637	19135	56	such	such	JJ
18637	19135	57	securities	security	NNS
18637	19135	58	.	.	.
18637	19136	1	The	the	DT
18637	19136	2	securities	security	NNS
18637	19136	3	in	in	IN
18637	19136	4	question	question	NN
18637	19136	5	,	,	,
18637	19136	6	which	which	WDT
18637	19136	7	had	have	VBD
18637	19136	8	never	never	RB
18637	19136	9	been	be	VBN
18637	19136	10	used	use	VBN
18637	19136	11	by	by	IN
18637	19136	12	the	the	DT
18637	19136	13	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	19136	14	in	in	IN
18637	19136	15	any	any	DT
18637	19136	16	business	business	NN
18637	19136	17	in	in	IN
18637	19136	18	the	the	DT
18637	19136	19	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	19136	20	State	State	NNP
18637	19136	21	,	,	,
18637	19136	22	were	be	VBD
18637	19136	23	located	locate	VBN
18637	19136	24	in	in	IN
18637	19136	25	the	the	DT
18637	19136	26	State	State	NNP
18637	19136	27	in	in	IN
18637	19136	28	which	which	WDT
18637	19136	29	the	the	DT
18637	19136	30	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	19136	31	had	have	VBD
18637	19136	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19136	33	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19136	34	,	,	,
18637	19136	35	and	and	CC
18637	19136	36	were	be	VBD
18637	19136	37	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19136	38	to	to	TO
18637	19136	39	be	be	VB
18637	19136	40	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	19136	41	only	only	RB
18637	19136	42	in	in	IN
18637	19136	43	the	the	DT
18637	19136	44	latter	latter	NN
18637	19136	45	.	.	.
18637	19137	1	In	in	IN
18637	19137	2	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	19137	3	_	_	NNP
18637	19137	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	19137	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19137	6	Missouri,[524	Missouri,[524	NNP
18637	19137	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19137	8	a	a	DT
18637	19137	9	nondomiciliary	nondomiciliary	JJ
18637	19137	10	State	State	NNP
18637	19137	11	was	be	VBD
18637	19137	12	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	19137	13	from	from	IN
18637	19137	14	applying	apply	VBG
18637	19137	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19137	16	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	19137	17	tax	tax	NN
18637	19137	18	to	to	IN
18637	19137	19	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	19137	20	,	,	,
18637	19137	21	bank	bank	NN
18637	19137	22	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	19137	23	,	,	,
18637	19137	24	and	and	CC
18637	19137	25	promissory	promissory	JJ
18637	19137	26	notes	note	NNS
18637	19137	27	,	,	,
18637	19137	28	all	all	DT
18637	19137	29	physically	physically	RB
18637	19137	30	present	present	JJ
18637	19137	31	within	within	IN
18637	19137	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19137	33	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19137	34	and	and	CC
18637	19137	35	some	some	DT
18637	19137	36	of	of	IN
18637	19137	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19137	38	secured	secure	VBN
18637	19137	39	by	by	IN
18637	19137	40	lands	land	NNS
18637	19137	41	therein	therein	RB
18637	19137	42	,	,	,
18637	19137	43	when	when	WRB
18637	19137	44	the	the	DT
18637	19137	45	owner	owner	NN
18637	19137	46	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19137	47	was	be	VBD
18637	19137	48	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	19137	49	in	in	IN
18637	19137	50	another	another	DT
18637	19137	51	State	state	NN
18637	19137	52	.	.	.
18637	19138	1	A	a	DT
18637	19138	2	like	like	JJ
18637	19138	3	result	result	NN
18637	19138	4	,	,	,
18637	19138	5	although	although	IN
18637	19138	6	on	on	IN
18637	19138	7	this	this	DT
18637	19138	8	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	19138	9	on	on	IN
18637	19138	10	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	19138	11	of	of	IN
18637	19138	12	lack	lack	NN
18637	19138	13	of	of	IN
18637	19138	14	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19138	15	of	of	IN
18637	19138	16	any	any	DT
18637	19138	17	"	"	``
18637	19138	18	business	business	NN
18637	19138	19	situs	situs	NN
18637	19138	20	,	,	,
18637	19138	21	"	"	''
18637	19138	22	was	be	VBD
18637	19138	23	reached	reach	VBN
18637	19138	24	in	in	IN
18637	19138	25	Beidler	Beidler	NNP
18637	19138	26	_	_	NNP
18637	19138	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	19138	28	_	_	NNP
18637	19138	29	South	South	NNP
18637	19138	30	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	19138	31	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	19138	32	Commission,[525	Commission,[525	NNP
18637	19138	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19138	34	in	in	IN
18637	19138	35	which	which	WDT
18637	19138	36	the	the	DT
18637	19138	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19138	38	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	19138	39	that	that	IN
18637	19138	40	a	a	DT
18637	19138	41	State	state	NN
18637	19138	42	,	,	,
18637	19138	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	19138	44	the	the	DT
18637	19138	45	death	death	NN
18637	19138	46	of	of	IN
18637	19138	47	a	a	DT
18637	19138	48	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19138	49	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	19138	50	,	,	,
18637	19138	51	may	may	MD
18637	19138	52	not	not	RB
18637	19138	53	apply	apply	VB
18637	19138	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19138	55	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	19138	56	tax	tax	NN
18637	19138	57	to	to	IN
18637	19138	58	a	a	DT
18637	19138	59	debt	debt	NN
18637	19138	60	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19138	61	open	open	JJ
18637	19138	62	account	account	NN
18637	19138	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19138	64	owned	own	VBN
18637	19138	65	by	by	IN
18637	19138	66	one	one	CD
18637	19138	67	of	of	IN
18637	19138	68	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19138	69	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19138	70	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19138	71	.	.	.
18637	19139	1	Finally	finally	RB
18637	19139	2	,	,	,
18637	19139	3	in	in	IN
18637	19139	4	First	First	NNP
18637	19139	5	National	National	NNP
18637	19139	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	19139	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19139	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	19139	9	_	_	NNP
18637	19139	10	Maine,[526	Maine,[526	NNP
18637	19139	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19139	12	which	which	WDT
18637	19139	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	19139	14	since	since	RB
18637	19139	15	been	be	VBN
18637	19139	16	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	19139	17	in	in	IN
18637	19139	18	State	State	NNP
18637	19139	19	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	19139	20	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	19139	21	_	_	NNP
18637	19139	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	19139	23	_	_	NNP
18637	19139	24	Aldrich,[527	Aldrich,[527	NNP
18637	19139	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19139	26	the	the	DT
18637	19139	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19139	28	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19139	29	that	that	IN
18637	19139	30	only	only	RB
18637	19139	31	the	the	DT
18637	19139	32	State	State	NNP
18637	19139	33	in	in	IN
18637	19139	34	which	which	WDT
18637	19139	35	the	the	DT
18637	19139	36	owner	owner	NN
18637	19139	37	of	of	IN
18637	19139	38	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	19139	39	stock	stock	NN
18637	19139	40	died	die	VBD
18637	19139	41	domiciled	domicile	VBD
18637	19139	42	was	be	VBD
18637	19139	43	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	19139	44	to	to	TO
18637	19139	45	tax	tax	VB
18637	19139	46	the	the	DT
18637	19139	47	succession	succession	NN
18637	19139	48	to	to	IN
18637	19139	49	the	the	DT
18637	19139	50	shares	share	NNS
18637	19139	51	by	by	IN
18637	19139	52	will	will	NN
18637	19139	53	or	or	CC
18637	19139	54	inheritance	inheritance	VB
18637	19139	55	and	and	CC
18637	19139	56	that	that	IN
18637	19139	57	the	the	DT
18637	19139	58	State	State	NNP
18637	19139	59	in	in	IN
18637	19139	60	which	which	WDT
18637	19139	61	the	the	DT
18637	19139	62	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	19139	63	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19139	64	was	be	VBD
18637	19139	65	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	19139	66	could	could	MD
18637	19139	67	not	not	RB
18637	19139	68	do	do	VB
18637	19139	69	so	so	RB
18637	19139	70	.	.	.
18637	19140	1	Without	without	IN
18637	19140	2	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	19140	3	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	19140	4	more	more	JJR
18637	19140	5	than	than	IN
18637	19140	6	one	one	CD
18637	19140	7	of	of	IN
18637	19140	8	these	these	DT
18637	19140	9	four	four	CD
18637	19140	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	19140	11	condemning	condemn	VBG
18637	19140	12	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	19140	13	succession	succession	NN
18637	19140	14	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19140	15	of	of	IN
18637	19140	16	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19140	17	,	,	,
18637	19140	18	the	the	DT
18637	19140	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19140	20	,	,	,
18637	19140	21	beginning	begin	VBG
18637	19140	22	with	with	IN
18637	19140	23	Curry	Curry	NNP
18637	19140	24	_	_	NNP
18637	19140	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	19140	26	_	_	NNP
18637	19140	27	McCanless[528	McCanless[528	NNP
18637	19140	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19140	29	in	in	IN
18637	19140	30	1939	1939	CD
18637	19140	31	,	,	,
18637	19140	32	announced	announce	VBD
18637	19140	33	a	a	DT
18637	19140	34	departure	departure	NN
18637	19140	35	from	from	IN
18637	19140	36	the	the	DT
18637	19140	37	"	"	``
18637	19140	38	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	19140	39	,	,	,
18637	19140	40	of	of	IN
18637	19140	41	recent	recent	JJ
18637	19140	42	origin	origin	NN
18637	19140	43	,	,	,
18637	19140	44	that	that	IN
18637	19140	45	the	the	DT
18637	19140	46	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19140	47	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19140	48	precludes	preclude	VBZ
18637	19140	49	the	the	DT
18637	19140	50	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19140	51	of	of	IN
18637	19140	52	any	any	DT
18637	19140	53	interest	interest	NN
18637	19140	54	in	in	IN
18637	19140	55	the	the	DT
18637	19140	56	same	same	JJ
18637	19140	57	intangible	intangible	JJ
18637	19140	58	in	in	IN
18637	19140	59	more	more	JJR
18637	19140	60	than	than	IN
18637	19140	61	one	one	CD
18637	19140	62	State	state	NN
18637	19140	63	*	*	NFP
18637	19140	64	*	*	NFP
18637	19140	65	*	*	NFP
18637	19140	66	.	.	.
18637	19140	67	"	"	''
18637	19141	1	Taking	take	VBG
18637	19141	2	cognizance	cognizance	NN
18637	19141	3	of	of	IN
18637	19141	4	the	the	DT
18637	19141	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	19141	6	that	that	IN
18637	19141	7	this	this	DT
18637	19141	8	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	19141	9	had	have	VBD
18637	19141	10	never	never	RB
18637	19141	11	been	be	VBN
18637	19141	12	extended	extend	VBN
18637	19141	13	to	to	IN
18637	19141	14	the	the	DT
18637	19141	15	field	field	NN
18637	19141	16	of	of	IN
18637	19141	17	income	income	NN
18637	19141	18	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19141	19	or	or	CC
18637	19141	20	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	19141	21	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19141	22	in	in	IN
18637	19141	23	the	the	DT
18637	19141	24	field	field	NN
18637	19141	25	of	of	IN
18637	19141	26	property	property	NN
18637	19141	27	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19141	28	,	,	,
18637	19141	29	where	where	WRB
18637	19141	30	the	the	DT
18637	19141	31	concepts	concept	NNS
18637	19141	32	of	of	IN
18637	19141	33	business	business	NN
18637	19141	34	situs	situs	NN
18637	19141	35	as	as	RB
18637	19141	36	well	well	RB
18637	19141	37	as	as	IN
18637	19141	38	of	of	IN
18637	19141	39	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	19141	40	situs	situs	NN
18637	19141	41	had	have	VBD
18637	19141	42	been	be	VBN
18637	19141	43	utilized	utilize	VBN
18637	19141	44	to	to	TO
18637	19141	45	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	19141	46	double	double	JJ
18637	19141	47	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19141	48	,	,	,
18637	19141	49	especially	especially	RB
18637	19141	50	in	in	IN
18637	19141	51	connection	connection	NN
18637	19141	52	with	with	IN
18637	19141	53	shares	share	NNS
18637	19141	54	of	of	IN
18637	19141	55	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	19141	56	stock	stock	NN
18637	19141	57	,	,	,
18637	19141	58	the	the	DT
18637	19141	59	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19141	60	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19141	61	that	that	IN
18637	19141	62	a	a	DT
18637	19141	63	correct	correct	JJ
18637	19141	64	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	19141	65	of	of	IN
18637	19141	66	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19141	67	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	19141	68	would	would	MD
18637	19141	69	dictate	dictate	VB
18637	19141	70	the	the	DT
18637	19141	71	following	following	JJ
18637	19141	72	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
18637	19141	73	:	:	:
18637	19141	74	"	"	``
18637	19141	75	From	from	IN
18637	19141	76	the	the	DT
18637	19141	77	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	19141	78	of	of	IN
18637	19141	79	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19141	80	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19141	81	system	system	NN
18637	19141	82	control	control	NN
18637	19141	83	over	over	IN
18637	19141	84	the	the	DT
18637	19141	85	person	person	NN
18637	19141	86	at	at	IN
18637	19141	87	the	the	DT
18637	19141	88	place	place	NN
18637	19141	89	of	of	IN
18637	19141	90	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19141	91	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19141	92	and	and	CC
18637	19141	93	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19141	94	duty	duty	NN
18637	19141	95	there	there	RB
18637	19141	96	,	,	,
18637	19141	97	common	common	JJ
18637	19141	98	to	to	IN
18637	19141	99	all	all	DT
18637	19141	100	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	19141	101	,	,	,
18637	19141	102	to	to	TO
18637	19141	103	contribute	contribute	VB
18637	19141	104	to	to	IN
18637	19141	105	the	the	DT
18637	19141	106	support	support	NN
18637	19141	107	of	of	IN
18637	19141	108	government	government	NN
18637	19141	109	have	have	VBP
18637	19141	110	been	be	VBN
18637	19141	111	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19141	112	to	to	TO
18637	19141	113	afford	afford	VB
18637	19141	114	an	an	DT
18637	19141	115	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19141	116	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19141	117	basis	basis	NN
18637	19141	118	for	for	IN
18637	19141	119	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	19141	120	on	on	IN
18637	19141	121	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19141	122	a	a	DT
18637	19141	123	tax	tax	NN
18637	19141	124	on	on	IN
18637	19141	125	the	the	DT
18637	19141	126	use	use	NN
18637	19141	127	and	and	CC
18637	19141	128	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	19141	129	of	of	IN
18637	19141	130	rights	right	NNS
18637	19141	131	in	in	IN
18637	19141	132	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19141	133	measured	measure	VBN
18637	19141	134	by	by	IN
18637	19141	135	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19141	136	value	value	NN
18637	19141	137	.	.	.
18637	19142	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19142	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19142	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19142	4	But	but	CC
18637	19142	5	when	when	WRB
18637	19142	6	the	the	DT
18637	19142	7	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	19142	8	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	19142	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19142	10	activities	activity	NNS
18637	19142	11	with	with	IN
18637	19142	12	respect	respect	NN
18637	19142	13	to	to	IN
18637	19142	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19142	15	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19142	16	,	,	,
18637	19142	17	so	so	IN
18637	19142	18	as	as	IN
18637	19142	19	to	to	TO
18637	19142	20	avail	avail	VB
18637	19142	21	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19142	22	of	of	IN
18637	19142	23	the	the	DT
18637	19142	24	protection	protection	NN
18637	19142	25	and	and	CC
18637	19142	26	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19142	27	of	of	IN
18637	19142	28	the	the	DT
18637	19142	29	laws	law	NNS
18637	19142	30	of	of	IN
18637	19142	31	another	another	DT
18637	19142	32	State	State	NNP
18637	19142	33	,	,	,
18637	19142	34	in	in	IN
18637	19142	35	such	such	PDT
18637	19142	36	a	a	DT
18637	19142	37	way	way	NN
18637	19142	38	as	as	IN
18637	19142	39	to	to	TO
18637	19142	40	bring	bring	VB
18637	19142	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19142	42	person	person	NN
18637	19142	43	or	or	CC
18637	19142	44	*	*	NFP
18637	19142	45	*	*	NFP
18637	19142	46	*	*	NFP
18637	19142	47	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19142	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19142	49	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19142	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19142	51	within	within	IN
18637	19142	52	the	the	DT
18637	19142	53	reach	reach	NN
18637	19142	54	of	of	IN
18637	19142	55	the	the	DT
18637	19142	56	tax	tax	NN
18637	19142	57	gatherer	gatherer	NN
18637	19142	58	there	there	RB
18637	19142	59	,	,	,
18637	19142	60	the	the	DT
18637	19142	61	reason	reason	NN
18637	19142	62	for	for	IN
18637	19142	63	a	a	DT
18637	19142	64	single	single	JJ
18637	19142	65	place	place	NN
18637	19142	66	of	of	IN
18637	19142	67	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19142	68	no	no	RB
18637	19142	69	longer	long	RBR
18637	19142	70	obtains	obtain	NNS
18637	19142	71	,	,	,
18637	19142	72	*	*	NFP
18637	19142	73	*	*	NFP
18637	19142	74	*	*	NFP
18637	19142	75	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19142	76	However	however	RB
18637	19142	77	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19142	78	,	,	,
18637	19142	79	the	the	DT
18637	19142	80	State	State	NNP
18637	19142	81	of	of	IN
18637	19142	82	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19142	83	is	be	VBZ
18637	19142	84	not	not	RB
18637	19142	85	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	19142	86	,	,	,
18637	19142	87	by	by	IN
18637	19142	88	the	the	DT
18637	19142	89	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	19142	90	's	's	POS
18637	19142	91	activities	activity	NNS
18637	19142	92	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	19142	93	,	,	,
18637	19142	94	of	of	IN
18637	19142	95	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19142	96	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19142	97	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19142	98	to	to	TO
18637	19142	99	tax	tax	NN
18637	19142	100	.	.	.
18637	19142	101	"	"	''
18637	19143	1	In	in	IN
18637	19143	2	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	19143	3	with	with	IN
18637	19143	4	this	this	DT
18637	19143	5	line	line	NN
18637	19143	6	of	of	IN
18637	19143	7	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	19143	8	,	,	,
18637	19143	9	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	19143	10	,	,	,
18637	19143	11	where	where	WRB
18637	19143	12	a	a	DT
18637	19143	13	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19143	14	died	die	VBD
18637	19143	15	domiciled	domicile	VBD
18637	19143	16	,	,	,
18637	19143	17	and	and	CC
18637	19143	18	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	19143	19	,	,	,
18637	19143	20	where	where	WRB
18637	19143	21	a	a	DT
18637	19143	22	trustee	trustee	NN
18637	19143	23	,	,	,
18637	19143	24	by	by	IN
18637	19143	25	conveyance	conveyance	NN
18637	19143	26	from	from	IN
18637	19143	27	said	say	VBD
18637	19143	28	decedent	decedent	NNP
18637	19143	29	,	,	,
18637	19143	30	held	hold	VBD
18637	19143	31	securities	security	NNS
18637	19143	32	on	on	IN
18637	19143	33	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19143	34	trusts	trust	NNS
18637	19143	35	,	,	,
18637	19143	36	were	be	VBD
18637	19143	37	both	both	DT
18637	19143	38	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19143	39	competent	competent	JJ
18637	19143	40	to	to	TO
18637	19143	41	impose	impose	VB
18637	19143	42	a	a	DT
18637	19143	43	tax	tax	NN
18637	19143	44	on	on	IN
18637	19143	45	the	the	DT
18637	19143	46	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19143	47	of	of	IN
18637	19143	48	these	these	DT
18637	19143	49	securities	security	NNS
18637	19143	50	passing	pass	VBG
18637	19143	51	under	under	IN
18637	19143	52	the	the	DT
18637	19143	53	will	will	NN
18637	19143	54	of	of	IN
18637	19143	55	the	the	DT
18637	19143	56	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19143	57	.	.	.
18637	19144	1	"	"	``
18637	19144	2	In	in	IN
18637	19144	3	effecting	effect	VBG
18637	19144	4	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19144	5	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19144	6	,	,	,
18637	19144	7	"	"	''
18637	19144	8	the	the	DT
18637	19144	9	testatrix	testatrix	NN
18637	19144	10	was	be	VBD
18637	19144	11	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19144	12	as	as	IN
18637	19144	13	having	have	VBG
18637	19144	14	"	"	``
18637	19144	15	brought	bring	VBN
18637	19144	16	some	some	DT
18637	19144	17	of	of	IN
18637	19144	18	the	the	DT
18637	19144	19	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19144	20	interests	interest	NNS
18637	19144	21	which	which	WDT
18637	19144	22	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19144	23	created	create	VBD
18637	19144	24	within	within	IN
18637	19144	25	the	the	DT
18637	19144	26	control	control	NN
18637	19144	27	of	of	IN
18637	19144	28	one	one	CD
18637	19144	29	State	State	NNP
18637	19144	30	by	by	IN
18637	19144	31	selecting	select	VBG
18637	19144	32	a	a	DT
18637	19144	33	trustee	trustee	NN
18637	19144	34	there	there	RB
18637	19144	35	,	,	,
18637	19144	36	and	and	CC
18637	19144	37	others	other	NNS
18637	19144	38	within	within	IN
18637	19144	39	the	the	DT
18637	19144	40	control	control	NN
18637	19144	41	of	of	IN
18637	19144	42	the	the	DT
18637	19144	43	other	other	JJ
18637	19144	44	State	State	NNP
18637	19144	45	,	,	,
18637	19144	46	by	by	IN
18637	19144	47	making	make	VBG
18637	19144	48	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19144	49	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19144	50	there	there	RB
18637	19144	51	.	.	.
18637	19144	52	"	"	''
18637	19145	1	She	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19145	2	had	have	VBD
18637	19145	3	found	find	VBN
18637	19145	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19145	5	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19145	6	to	to	TO
18637	19145	7	invoke	invoke	VB
18637	19145	8	"	"	``
18637	19145	9	the	the	DT
18637	19145	10	aid	aid	NN
18637	19145	11	of	of	IN
18637	19145	12	the	the	DT
18637	19145	13	law	law	NN
18637	19145	14	of	of	IN
18637	19145	15	both	both	DT
18637	19145	16	States	States	NNP
18637	19145	17	,	,	,
18637	19145	18	and	and	CC
18637	19145	19	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19145	20	legatees	legatee	NNS
18637	19145	21	"	"	''
18637	19145	22	were	be	VBD
18637	19145	23	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19145	24	to	to	IN
18637	19145	25	the	the	DT
18637	19145	26	same	same	JJ
18637	19145	27	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19145	28	.	.	.
18637	19146	1	These	these	DT
18637	19146	2	statements	statement	NNS
18637	19146	3	represented	represent	VBD
18637	19146	4	a	a	DT
18637	19146	5	belated	belate	VBN
18637	19146	6	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	19146	7	of	of	IN
18637	19146	8	the	the	DT
18637	19146	9	views	view	NNS
18637	19146	10	advanced	advance	VBN
18637	19146	11	by	by	IN
18637	19146	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	19146	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19146	14	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	19146	15	in	in	IN
18637	19146	16	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	19146	17	or	or	CC
18637	19146	18	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	19146	19	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	19146	20	which	which	WDT
18637	19146	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19146	22	filed	file	VBD
18637	19146	23	in	in	IN
18637	19146	24	three	three	CD
18637	19146	25	of	of	IN
18637	19146	26	the	the	DT
18637	19146	27	four	four	CD
18637	19146	28	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19146	29	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19146	30	during	during	IN
18637	19146	31	1930	1930	CD
18637	19146	32	-	-	SYM
18637	19146	33	1932	1932	CD
18637	19146	34	.	.	.
18637	19147	1	By	by	IN
18637	19147	2	the	the	DT
18637	19147	3	line	line	NN
18637	19147	4	of	of	IN
18637	19147	5	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	19147	6	taken	take	VBN
18637	19147	7	in	in	IN
18637	19147	8	these	these	DT
18637	19147	9	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	19147	10	,	,	,
18637	19147	11	if	if	IN
18637	19147	12	protection	protection	NN
18637	19147	13	or	or	CC
18637	19147	14	control	control	NN
18637	19147	15	was	be	VBD
18637	19147	16	extended	extend	VBN
18637	19147	17	to	to	IN
18637	19147	18	,	,	,
18637	19147	19	or	or	CC
18637	19147	20	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	19147	21	over	over	IN
18637	19147	22	,	,	,
18637	19147	23	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19147	24	or	or	CC
18637	19147	25	the	the	DT
18637	19147	26	person	person	NN
18637	19147	27	of	of	IN
18637	19147	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19147	29	owner	owner	NN
18637	19147	30	,	,	,
18637	19147	31	then	then	RB
18637	19147	32	as	as	IN
18637	19147	33	many	many	JJ
18637	19147	34	States	States	NNP
18637	19147	35	as	as	IN
18637	19147	36	afforded	afford	VBD
18637	19147	37	such	such	JJ
18637	19147	38	protection	protection	NN
18637	19147	39	or	or	CC
18637	19147	40	were	be	VBD
18637	19147	41	capable	capable	JJ
18637	19147	42	of	of	IN
18637	19147	43	exerting	exert	VBG
18637	19147	44	such	such	JJ
18637	19147	45	dominion	dominion	NN
18637	19147	46	should	should	MD
18637	19147	47	be	be	VB
18637	19147	48	privileged	privilege	VBN
18637	19147	49	to	to	TO
18637	19147	50	tax	tax	VB
18637	19147	51	the	the	DT
18637	19147	52	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19147	53	of	of	IN
18637	19147	54	such	such	JJ
18637	19147	55	property	property	NN
18637	19147	56	.	.	.
18637	19148	1	On	on	IN
18637	19148	2	this	this	DT
18637	19148	3	basis	basis	NN
18637	19148	4	,	,	,
18637	19148	5	the	the	DT
18637	19148	6	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	19148	7	State	State	NNP
18637	19148	8	would	would	MD
18637	19148	9	invariably	invariably	RB
18637	19148	10	qualify	qualify	VB
18637	19148	11	as	as	IN
18637	19148	12	a	a	DT
18637	19148	13	State	state	NN
18637	19148	14	competent	competent	JJ
18637	19148	15	to	to	IN
18637	19148	16	tax	tax	NN
18637	19148	17	and	and	CC
18637	19148	18	a	a	DT
18637	19148	19	nondomiciliary	nondomiciliary	JJ
18637	19148	20	State	State	NNP
18637	19148	21	,	,	,
18637	19148	22	so	so	RB
18637	19148	23	far	far	RB
18637	19148	24	as	as	IN
18637	19148	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19148	26	could	could	MD
18637	19148	27	legitimately	legitimately	RB
18637	19148	28	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	19148	29	control	control	NN
18637	19148	30	or	or	CC
18637	19148	31	could	could	MD
18637	19148	32	be	be	VB
18637	19148	33	shown	show	VBN
18637	19148	34	to	to	TO
18637	19148	35	have	have	VB
18637	19148	36	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	19148	37	a	a	DT
18637	19148	38	measure	measure	NN
18637	19148	39	of	of	IN
18637	19148	40	protection	protection	NN
18637	19148	41	that	that	WDT
18637	19148	42	was	be	VBD
18637	19148	43	not	not	RB
18637	19148	44	trivial	trivial	JJ
18637	19148	45	or	or	CC
18637	19148	46	insubstantial	insubstantial	JJ
18637	19148	47	.	.	.
18637	19149	1	On	on	IN
18637	19149	2	the	the	DT
18637	19149	3	authority	authority	NN
18637	19149	4	of	of	IN
18637	19149	5	Curry	Curry	NNP
18637	19149	6	_	_	NNP
18637	19149	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	19149	8	_	_	NNP
18637	19149	9	McCanless	McCanless	NNP
18637	19149	10	,	,	,
18637	19149	11	the	the	DT
18637	19149	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19149	13	,	,	,
18637	19149	14	in	in	IN
18637	19149	15	Pearson	Pearson	NNP
18637	19149	16	_	_	NNP
18637	19149	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	19149	18	_	_	NNP
18637	19149	19	McGraw,[529	mcgraw,[529	NN
18637	19149	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19149	21	also	also	RB
18637	19149	22	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	19149	23	the	the	DT
18637	19149	24	application	application	NN
18637	19149	25	of	of	IN
18637	19149	26	an	an	DT
18637	19149	27	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	19149	28	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19149	29	tax	tax	NN
18637	19149	30	to	to	IN
18637	19149	31	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19149	32	handled	handle	VBN
18637	19149	33	by	by	IN
18637	19149	34	an	an	DT
18637	19149	35	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	19149	36	trust	trust	NN
18637	19149	37	company	company	NN
18637	19149	38	and	and	CC
18637	19149	39	never	never	RB
18637	19149	40	physically	physically	RB
18637	19149	41	present	present	JJ
18637	19149	42	in	in	IN
18637	19149	43	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	19149	44	,	,	,
18637	19149	45	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19149	46	to	to	TO
18637	19149	47	tax	tax	NN
18637	19149	48	being	be	VBG
18637	19149	49	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19149	50	as	as	IN
18637	19149	51	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	19149	52	,	,	,
18637	19149	53	not	not	RB
18637	19149	54	on	on	IN
18637	19149	55	the	the	DT
18637	19149	56	location	location	NN
18637	19149	57	of	of	IN
18637	19149	58	the	the	DT
18637	19149	59	property	property	NN
18637	19149	60	in	in	IN
18637	19149	61	the	the	DT
18637	19149	62	State	State	NNP
18637	19149	63	,	,	,
18637	19149	64	but	but	CC
18637	19149	65	on	on	IN
18637	19149	66	control	control	NN
18637	19149	67	over	over	IN
18637	19149	68	the	the	DT
18637	19149	69	owner	owner	NN
18637	19149	70	who	who	WP
18637	19149	71	was	be	VBD
18637	19149	72	a	a	DT
18637	19149	73	resident	resident	NN
18637	19149	74	of	of	IN
18637	19149	75	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	19149	76	.	.	.
18637	19150	1	In	in	IN
18637	19150	2	Graves	Graves	NNP
18637	19150	3	_	_	NNP
18637	19150	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	19150	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19150	6	Elliott,[530	Elliott,[530	NNP
18637	19150	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19150	8	decided	decide	VBD
18637	19150	9	in	in	IN
18637	19150	10	the	the	DT
18637	19150	11	same	same	JJ
18637	19150	12	year	year	NN
18637	19150	13	,	,	,
18637	19150	14	the	the	DT
18637	19150	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19150	16	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	19150	17	the	the	DT
18637	19150	18	power	power	NN
18637	19150	19	of	of	IN
18637	19150	20	New	New	NNP
18637	19150	21	York	York	NNP
18637	19150	22	,	,	,
18637	19150	23	in	in	IN
18637	19150	24	computing	compute	VBG
18637	19150	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19150	26	estate	estate	NN
18637	19150	27	tax	tax	NN
18637	19150	28	,	,	,
18637	19150	29	to	to	TO
18637	19150	30	include	include	VB
18637	19150	31	in	in	IN
18637	19150	32	the	the	DT
18637	19150	33	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19150	34	estate	estate	NN
18637	19150	35	of	of	IN
18637	19150	36	a	a	DT
18637	19150	37	domiciled	domiciled	JJ
18637	19150	38	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19150	39	the	the	DT
18637	19150	40	value	value	NN
18637	19150	41	of	of	IN
18637	19150	42	a	a	DT
18637	19150	43	trust	trust	NN
18637	19150	44	of	of	IN
18637	19150	45	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	19150	46	managed	manage	VBN
18637	19150	47	in	in	IN
18637	19150	48	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	19150	49	by	by	IN
18637	19150	50	a	a	DT
18637	19150	51	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	19150	52	trust	trust	NN
18637	19150	53	company	company	NN
18637	19150	54	and	and	CC
18637	19150	55	already	already	RB
18637	19150	56	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19150	57	on	on	IN
18637	19150	58	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19150	59	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19150	60	by	by	IN
18637	19150	61	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	19150	62	,	,	,
18637	19150	63	which	which	WDT
18637	19150	64	trust	trust	VBP
18637	19150	65	the	the	DT
18637	19150	66	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19150	67	had	have	VBD
18637	19150	68	established	establish	VBN
18637	19150	69	while	while	IN
18637	19150	70	in	in	IN
18637	19150	71	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	19150	72	and	and	CC
18637	19150	73	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	19150	74	which	which	WDT
18637	19150	75	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19150	76	had	have	VBD
18637	19150	77	never	never	RB
18637	19150	78	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	19150	79	any	any	DT
18637	19150	80	of	of	IN
18637	19150	81	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19150	82	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	19150	83	powers	power	NNS
18637	19150	84	of	of	IN
18637	19150	85	revocation	revocation	NN
18637	19150	86	or	or	CC
18637	19150	87	change	change	NN
18637	19150	88	of	of	IN
18637	19150	89	beneficiaries	beneficiary	NNS
18637	19150	90	.	.	.
18637	19151	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19151	2	was	be	VBD
18637	19151	3	observed	observe	VBN
18637	19151	4	that	that	IN
18637	19151	5	"	"	``
18637	19151	6	the	the	DT
18637	19151	7	power	power	NN
18637	19151	8	of	of	IN
18637	19151	9	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	19151	10	of	of	IN
18637	19151	11	property	property	NN
18637	19151	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	19151	13	the	the	DT
18637	19151	14	equivalent	equivalent	NN
18637	19151	15	of	of	IN
18637	19151	16	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	19151	17	,	,	,
18637	19151	18	*	*	NFP
18637	19151	19	*	*	NFP
18637	19151	20	*	*	NFP
18637	19151	21	and	and	CC
18637	19151	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19151	23	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19151	24	in	in	IN
18637	19151	25	the	the	DT
18637	19151	26	case	case	NN
18637	19151	27	of	of	IN
18637	19151	28	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19151	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	19151	30	*	*	NFP
18637	19151	31	*	*	NFP
18637	19151	32	*	*	NFP
18637	19151	33	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19151	34	an	an	DT
18637	19151	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19151	36	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	19151	37	subject	subject	NN
18637	19151	38	of	of	IN
18637	19151	39	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19151	40	at	at	IN
18637	19151	41	the	the	DT
18637	19151	42	place	place	NN
18637	19151	43	of	of	IN
18637	19151	44	the	the	DT
18637	19151	45	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19151	46	of	of	IN
18637	19151	47	the	the	DT
18637	19151	48	owner	owner	NN
18637	19151	49	of	of	IN
18637	19151	50	the	the	DT
18637	19151	51	power	power	NN
18637	19151	52	.	.	.
18637	19152	1	Relinquishment	relinquishment	NN
18637	19152	2	at	at	IN
18637	19152	3	death	death	NN
18637	19152	4	,	,	,
18637	19152	5	in	in	IN
18637	19152	6	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	19152	7	of	of	IN
18637	19152	8	the	the	DT
18637	19152	9	non	non	JJ
18637	19152	10	-	-	NN
18637	19152	11	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19152	12	in	in	IN
18637	19152	13	life	life	NN
18637	19152	14	,	,	,
18637	19152	15	of	of	IN
18637	19152	16	a	a	DT
18637	19152	17	power	power	NN
18637	19152	18	to	to	TO
18637	19152	19	revoke	revoke	VB
18637	19152	20	a	a	DT
18637	19152	21	trust	trust	NN
18637	19152	22	created	create	VBN
18637	19152	23	by	by	IN
18637	19152	24	a	a	DT
18637	19152	25	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19152	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	19152	27	likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19152	28	an	an	DT
18637	19152	29	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	19152	30	subject	subject	NN
18637	19152	31	of	of	IN
18637	19152	32	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19152	33	.	.	.
18637	19153	1	"	"	``
18637	19153	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19153	3	531	531	CD
18637	19153	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19153	5	Consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	19153	6	application	application	NN
18637	19153	7	of	of	IN
18637	19153	8	the	the	DT
18637	19153	9	principle	principle	NN
18637	19153	10	enunciated	enunciate	VBD
18637	19153	11	in	in	IN
18637	19153	12	Curry	Curry	NNP
18637	19153	13	_	_	NNP
18637	19153	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	19153	15	_	_	NNP
18637	19153	16	McCanless	McCanless	NNP
18637	19153	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	19153	18	also	also	RB
18637	19153	19	discernible	discernible	JJ
18637	19153	20	in	in	IN
18637	19153	21	two	two	CD
18637	19153	22	later	later	JJ
18637	19153	23	cases	case	NNS
18637	19153	24	in	in	IN
18637	19153	25	which	which	WDT
18637	19153	26	the	the	DT
18637	19153	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19153	28	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	19153	29	the	the	DT
18637	19153	30	right	right	NN
18637	19153	31	of	of	IN
18637	19153	32	a	a	DT
18637	19153	33	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	19153	34	State	State	NNP
18637	19153	35	to	to	TO
18637	19153	36	tax	tax	VB
18637	19153	37	the	the	DT
18637	19153	38	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19153	39	of	of	IN
18637	19153	40	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19153	41	kept	keep	VBN
18637	19153	42	outside	outside	IN
18637	19153	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19153	44	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	19153	45	,	,	,
18637	19153	46	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19153	47	that	that	IN
18637	19153	48	"	"	``
18637	19153	49	in	in	IN
18637	19153	50	some	some	DT
18637	19153	51	instances	instance	NNS
18637	19153	52	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19153	53	may	may	MD
18637	19153	54	be	be	VB
18637	19153	55	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19153	56	to	to	IN
18637	19153	57	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19153	58	in	in	IN
18637	19153	59	other	other	JJ
18637	19153	60	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NNS
18637	19153	61	,	,	,
18637	19153	62	to	to	IN
18637	19153	63	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19153	64	control	control	NN
18637	19153	65	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19153	66	are	be	VBP
18637	19153	67	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19153	68	and	and	CC
18637	19153	69	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19153	70	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19153	71	protection	protection	NN
18637	19153	72	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19153	73	enjoyed	enjoy	VBD
18637	19153	74	.	.	.
18637	19153	75	"	"	''
18637	19154	1	In	in	IN
18637	19154	2	Graves	Graves	NNP
18637	19154	3	_	_	NNP
18637	19154	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	19154	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19154	6	Schmidlapp[532	Schmidlapp[532	NNP
18637	19154	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19154	8	an	an	DT
18637	19154	9	estate	estate	NN
18637	19154	10	tax	tax	NN
18637	19154	11	was	be	VBD
18637	19154	12	levied	levy	VBN
18637	19154	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	19154	14	the	the	DT
18637	19154	15	value	value	NN
18637	19154	16	of	of	IN
18637	19154	17	the	the	DT
18637	19154	18	subject	subject	NN
18637	19154	19	of	of	IN
18637	19154	20	a	a	DT
18637	19154	21	general	general	JJ
18637	19154	22	testamentary	testamentary	NN
18637	19154	23	power	power	NN
18637	19154	24	of	of	IN
18637	19154	25	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	19154	26	effectively	effectively	RB
18637	19154	27	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	19154	28	by	by	IN
18637	19154	29	a	a	DT
18637	19154	30	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19154	31	donee	donee	NN
18637	19154	32	over	over	IN
18637	19154	33	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19154	34	held	hold	VBN
18637	19154	35	by	by	IN
18637	19154	36	trustees	trustee	NNS
18637	19154	37	under	under	IN
18637	19154	38	the	the	DT
18637	19154	39	will	will	NN
18637	19154	40	of	of	IN
18637	19154	41	a	a	DT
18637	19154	42	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19154	43	donor	donor	NN
18637	19154	44	of	of	IN
18637	19154	45	the	the	DT
18637	19154	46	power	power	NN
18637	19154	47	.	.	.
18637	19155	1	Viewing	view	VBG
18637	19155	2	the	the	DT
18637	19155	3	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19155	4	of	of	IN
18637	19155	5	interest	interest	NN
18637	19155	6	in	in	IN
18637	19155	7	said	say	VBN
18637	19155	8	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19155	9	by	by	IN
18637	19155	10	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19155	11	of	of	IN
18637	19155	12	the	the	DT
18637	19155	13	power	power	NN
18637	19155	14	of	of	IN
18637	19155	15	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	19155	16	as	as	IN
18637	19155	17	the	the	DT
18637	19155	18	equivalent	equivalent	NN
18637	19155	19	of	of	IN
18637	19155	20	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	19155	21	,	,	,
18637	19155	22	the	the	DT
18637	19155	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19155	24	quoted	quote	VBD
18637	19155	25	from	from	IN
18637	19155	26	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	19155	27	_	_	NNP
18637	19155	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	19155	29	_	_	NNP
18637	19155	30	Maryland[533	Maryland[533	NNP
18637	19155	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19155	32	to	to	IN
18637	19155	33	the	the	DT
18637	19155	34	effect	effect	NN
18637	19155	35	that	that	IN
18637	19155	36	the	the	DT
18637	19155	37	power	power	NN
18637	19155	38	to	to	TO
18637	19155	39	tax	tax	VB
18637	19155	40	"	"	``
18637	19155	41	'	'	``
18637	19155	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	19155	43	an	an	DT
18637	19155	44	incident	incident	NN
18637	19155	45	of	of	IN
18637	19155	46	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	19155	47	,	,	,
18637	19155	48	and	and	CC
18637	19155	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	19155	50	coextensive	coextensive	JJ
18637	19155	51	with	with	IN
18637	19155	52	that	that	DT
18637	19155	53	to	to	TO
18637	19155	54	which	which	WDT
18637	19155	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19155	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	19155	57	an	an	DT
18637	19155	58	incident	incident	NN
18637	19155	59	.	.	.
18637	19155	60	'	'	''
18637	19155	61	"	"	''
18637	19156	1	Again	again	RB
18637	19156	2	,	,	,
18637	19156	3	in	in	IN
18637	19156	4	Central	Central	NNP
18637	19156	5	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
18637	19156	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	19156	7	&	&	CC
18637	19156	8	T.	T.	NNP
18637	19156	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	19156	10	_	_	NNP
18637	19156	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	19156	12	_	_	NNP
18637	19156	13	Kelly,[534	Kelly,[534	NNP
18637	19156	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19156	15	the	the	DT
18637	19156	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19156	17	approved	approve	VBD
18637	19156	18	a	a	DT
18637	19156	19	New	New	NNP
18637	19156	20	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	19156	21	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19156	22	tax	tax	NN
18637	19156	23	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19156	24	on	on	IN
18637	19156	25	the	the	DT
18637	19156	26	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	19156	27	of	of	IN
18637	19156	28	the	the	DT
18637	19156	29	death	death	NN
18637	19156	30	of	of	IN
18637	19156	31	a	a	DT
18637	19156	32	New	New	NNP
18637	19156	33	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	19156	34	grantor	grantor	NN
18637	19156	35	of	of	IN
18637	19156	36	an	an	DT
18637	19156	37	irrevocable	irrevocable	JJ
18637	19156	38	trust	trust	NN
18637	19156	39	executed	execute	VBN
18637	19156	40	,	,	,
18637	19156	41	and	and	CC
18637	19156	42	consisting	consisting	NN
18637	19156	43	of	of	IN
18637	19156	44	securities	security	NNS
18637	19156	45	located	locate	VBN
18637	19156	46	,	,	,
18637	19156	47	in	in	IN
18637	19156	48	New	New	NNP
18637	19156	49	York	York	NNP
18637	19156	50	,	,	,
18637	19156	51	and	and	CC
18637	19156	52	providing	provide	VBG
18637	19156	53	for	for	IN
18637	19156	54	the	the	DT
18637	19156	55	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	19156	56	of	of	IN
18637	19156	57	the	the	DT
18637	19156	58	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	19156	59	to	to	IN
18637	19156	60	two	two	CD
18637	19156	61	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19156	62	sons	son	NNS
18637	19156	63	.	.	.
18637	19157	1	The	the	DT
18637	19157	2	costliness	costliness	NN
18637	19157	3	of	of	IN
18637	19157	4	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	19157	5	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19157	6	of	of	IN
18637	19157	7	estates	estate	NNS
18637	19157	8	comprising	comprise	VBG
18637	19157	9	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	19157	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	19157	11	appreciably	appreciably	RB
18637	19157	12	aggravated	aggravate	VBN
18637	19157	13	when	when	WRB
18637	19157	14	each	each	DT
18637	19157	15	of	of	IN
18637	19157	16	several	several	JJ
18637	19157	17	States	States	NNP
18637	19157	18	founds	found	VBZ
18637	19157	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19157	20	tax	tax	NN
18637	19157	21	not	not	RB
18637	19157	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	19157	23	different	different	JJ
18637	19157	24	events	event	NNS
18637	19157	25	or	or	CC
18637	19157	26	property	property	NN
18637	19157	27	rights	right	NNS
18637	19157	28	but	but	CC
18637	19157	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	19157	30	an	an	DT
18637	19157	31	identical	identical	JJ
18637	19157	32	basis	basis	NN
18637	19157	33	;	;	:
18637	19157	34	namely	namely	RB
18637	19157	35	that	that	IN
18637	19157	36	,	,	,
18637	19157	37	the	the	DT
18637	19157	38	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19157	39	died	die	VBD
18637	19157	40	domiciled	domicile	VBD
18637	19157	41	within	within	IN
18637	19157	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19157	43	borders	border	NNS
18637	19157	44	.	.	.
18637	19158	1	Not	not	RB
18637	19158	2	only	only	RB
18637	19158	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	19158	4	an	an	DT
18637	19158	5	estate	estate	NN
18637	19158	6	then	then	RB
18637	19158	7	threatened	threaten	VBD
18637	19158	8	with	with	IN
18637	19158	9	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	19158	10	contraction	contraction	NN
18637	19158	11	but	but	CC
18637	19158	12	the	the	DT
18637	19158	13	contesting	contest	VBG
18637	19158	14	States	States	NNPS
18637	19158	15	may	may	MD
18637	19158	16	discover	discover	VB
18637	19158	17	that	that	IN
18637	19158	18	the	the	DT
18637	19158	19	assets	asset	NNS
18637	19158	20	of	of	IN
18637	19158	21	the	the	DT
18637	19158	22	estate	estate	NN
18637	19158	23	are	be	VBP
18637	19158	24	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	19158	25	to	to	TO
18637	19158	26	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	19158	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19158	28	claims	claim	NNS
18637	19158	29	.	.	.
18637	19159	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19159	2	,	,	,
18637	19159	3	in	in	IN
18637	19159	4	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	19159	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19159	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	19159	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19159	8	Florida,[535	Florida,[535	NNP
18637	19159	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19159	10	the	the	DT
18637	19159	11	State	State	NNP
18637	19159	12	of	of	IN
18637	19159	13	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	19159	14	filed	file	VBD
18637	19159	15	an	an	DT
18637	19159	16	original	original	JJ
18637	19159	17	petition	petition	NN
18637	19159	18	in	in	IN
18637	19159	19	the	the	DT
18637	19159	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19159	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19159	22	,	,	,
18637	19159	23	in	in	IN
18637	19159	24	which	which	WDT
18637	19159	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19159	26	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	19159	27	that	that	IN
18637	19159	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19159	29	claim	claim	NN
18637	19159	30	,	,	,
18637	19159	31	together	together	RB
18637	19159	32	with	with	IN
18637	19159	33	those	those	DT
18637	19159	34	of	of	IN
18637	19159	35	three	three	CD
18637	19159	36	other	other	JJ
18637	19159	37	States	States	NNPS
18637	19159	38	,	,	,
18637	19159	39	exceeded	exceed	VBD
18637	19159	40	the	the	DT
18637	19159	41	value	value	NN
18637	19159	42	of	of	IN
18637	19159	43	the	the	DT
18637	19159	44	estate	estate	NN
18637	19159	45	,	,	,
18637	19159	46	that	that	IN
18637	19159	47	the	the	DT
18637	19159	48	portion	portion	NN
18637	19159	49	of	of	IN
18637	19159	50	the	the	DT
18637	19159	51	estate	estate	NN
18637	19159	52	within	within	IN
18637	19159	53	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	19159	54	alone	alone	RB
18637	19159	55	would	would	MD
18637	19159	56	not	not	RB
18637	19159	57	suffice	suffice	VB
18637	19159	58	to	to	TO
18637	19159	59	discharge	discharge	VB
18637	19159	60	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19159	61	own	own	JJ
18637	19159	62	tax	tax	NN
18637	19159	63	,	,	,
18637	19159	64	and	and	CC
18637	19159	65	that	that	IN
18637	19159	66	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19159	67	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	19159	68	to	to	TO
18637	19159	69	collect	collect	VB
18637	19159	70	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19159	71	tax	tax	NN
18637	19159	72	might	may	MD
18637	19159	73	be	be	VB
18637	19159	74	defeated	defeat	VBN
18637	19159	75	by	by	IN
18637	19159	76	adjudications	adjudication	NNS
18637	19159	77	of	of	IN
18637	19159	78	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19159	79	by	by	IN
18637	19159	80	the	the	DT
18637	19159	81	other	other	JJ
18637	19159	82	States	States	NNPS
18637	19159	83	.	.	.
18637	19160	1	The	the	DT
18637	19160	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19160	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19160	4	disposed	dispose	VBD
18637	19160	5	of	of	IN
18637	19160	6	this	this	DT
18637	19160	7	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	19160	8	by	by	IN
18637	19160	9	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	19160	10	a	a	DT
18637	19160	11	finding	finding	NN
18637	19160	12	that	that	IN
18637	19160	13	the	the	DT
18637	19160	14	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19160	15	had	have	VBD
18637	19160	16	been	be	VBN
18637	19160	17	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	19160	18	in	in	IN
18637	19160	19	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	19160	20	,	,	,
18637	19160	21	but	but	CC
18637	19160	22	intimated	intimate	VBD
18637	19160	23	that	that	IN
18637	19160	24	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	19160	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19160	26	would	would	MD
18637	19160	27	take	take	VB
18637	19160	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19160	29	in	in	IN
18637	19160	30	like	like	JJ
18637	19160	31	situations	situation	NNS
18637	19160	32	only	only	RB
18637	19160	33	in	in	IN
18637	19160	34	the	the	DT
18637	19160	35	event	event	NN
18637	19160	36	that	that	IN
18637	19160	37	an	an	DT
18637	19160	38	estate	estate	NN
18637	19160	39	did	do	VBD
18637	19160	40	not	not	RB
18637	19160	41	exceed	exceed	VB
18637	19160	42	in	in	IN
18637	19160	43	value	value	NN
18637	19160	44	the	the	DT
18637	19160	45	total	total	NN
18637	19160	46	of	of	IN
18637	19160	47	the	the	DT
18637	19160	48	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	19160	49	demands	demand	NNS
18637	19160	50	of	of	IN
18637	19160	51	several	several	JJ
18637	19160	52	States	States	NNPS
18637	19160	53	and	and	CC
18637	19160	54	that	that	IN
18637	19160	55	the	the	DT
18637	19160	56	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19160	57	were	be	VBD
18637	19160	58	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	19160	59	with	with	IN
18637	19160	60	a	a	DT
18637	19160	61	prospective	prospective	JJ
18637	19160	62	inability	inability	NN
18637	19160	63	to	to	TO
18637	19160	64	collect	collect	VB
18637	19160	65	.	.	.
18637	19161	1	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	19161	2	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19161	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19161	4	1	1	LS
18637	19161	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19161	6	Intangible	intangible	JJ
18637	19161	7	Personal	personal	JJ
18637	19161	8	Property.--A	property.--a	NN
18637	19161	9	State	State	NNP
18637	19161	10	in	in	IN
18637	19161	11	which	which	WDT
18637	19161	12	a	a	DT
18637	19161	13	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19161	14	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19161	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	19161	16	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	19161	17	a	a	DT
18637	19161	18	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	19161	19	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19161	20	and	and	CC
18637	19161	21	in	in	IN
18637	19161	22	which	which	WDT
18637	19161	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19161	24	maintains	maintain	VBZ
18637	19161	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19161	26	general	general	JJ
18637	19161	27	business	business	NN
18637	19161	28	offices	office	NNS
18637	19161	29	may	may	MD
18637	19161	30	tax	tax	VB
18637	19161	31	the	the	DT
18637	19161	32	latter	latter	NN
18637	19161	33	's	's	POS
18637	19161	34	bank	bank	NN
18637	19161	35	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	19161	36	and	and	CC
18637	19161	37	accounts	account	NNS
18637	19161	38	receivable	receivable	JJ
18637	19161	39	even	even	RB
18637	19161	40	though	though	IN
18637	19161	41	the	the	DT
18637	19161	42	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	19161	43	are	be	VBP
18637	19161	44	outside	outside	IN
18637	19161	45	the	the	DT
18637	19161	46	State	State	NNP
18637	19161	47	and	and	CC
18637	19161	48	the	the	DT
18637	19161	49	accounts	account	NNS
18637	19161	50	receivable	receivable	JJ
18637	19161	51	arise	arise	NN
18637	19161	52	from	from	IN
18637	19161	53	manufacturing	manufacture	VBG
18637	19161	54	activities	activity	NNS
18637	19161	55	in	in	IN
18637	19161	56	another	another	DT
18637	19161	57	State	state	NN
18637	19161	58	.	.	.
18637	19162	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19162	2	536	536	CD
18637	19162	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19162	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19162	5	,	,	,
18637	19162	6	a	a	DT
18637	19162	7	nondomiciliary	nondomiciliary	JJ
18637	19162	8	State	State	NNP
18637	19162	9	in	in	IN
18637	19162	10	which	which	WDT
18637	19162	11	a	a	DT
18637	19162	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19162	13	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19162	14	did	do	VBD
18637	19162	15	business	business	NN
18637	19162	16	can	can	MD
18637	19162	17	tax	tax	VB
18637	19162	18	the	the	DT
18637	19162	19	"	"	``
18637	19162	20	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	19162	21	excess	excess	NN
18637	19162	22	"	"	''
18637	19162	23	arising	arise	VBG
18637	19162	24	from	from	IN
18637	19162	25	property	property	NN
18637	19162	26	employed	employ	VBN
18637	19162	27	and	and	CC
18637	19162	28	business	business	NN
18637	19162	29	done	do	VBN
18637	19162	30	in	in	IN
18637	19162	31	the	the	DT
18637	19162	32	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19162	33	State	state	NN
18637	19162	34	.	.	.
18637	19163	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19163	2	537	537	CD
18637	19163	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19163	4	On	on	IN
18637	19163	5	the	the	DT
18637	19163	6	other	other	JJ
18637	19163	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	19163	8	,	,	,
18637	19163	9	when	when	WRB
18637	19163	10	the	the	DT
18637	19163	11	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19163	12	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19163	13	transacts	transact	VBZ
18637	19163	14	only	only	RB
18637	19163	15	interstate	interstate	VBP
18637	19163	16	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	19163	17	within	within	IN
18637	19163	18	a	a	DT
18637	19163	19	State	State	NNP
18637	19163	20	,	,	,
18637	19163	21	any	any	DT
18637	19163	22	excise	excise	NN
18637	19163	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	19163	24	on	on	IN
18637	19163	25	such	such	JJ
18637	19163	26	excess	excess	NN
18637	19163	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	19163	28	void	void	JJ
18637	19163	29	,	,	,
18637	19163	30	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	19163	31	of	of	IN
18637	19163	32	the	the	DT
18637	19163	33	amount	amount	NN
18637	19163	34	of	of	IN
18637	19163	35	the	the	DT
18637	19163	36	tax	tax	NN
18637	19163	37	.	.	.
18637	19164	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19164	2	538	538	CD
18637	19164	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19164	4	A	a	DT
18637	19164	5	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	19164	6	State	state	NN
18637	19164	7	,	,	,
18637	19164	8	however	however	RB
18637	19164	9	,	,	,
18637	19164	10	may	may	MD
18637	19164	11	tax	tax	VB
18637	19164	12	the	the	DT
18637	19164	13	excess	excess	NN
18637	19164	14	of	of	IN
18637	19164	15	market	market	NN
18637	19164	16	value	value	NN
18637	19164	17	of	of	IN
18637	19164	18	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	19164	19	capital	capital	NN
18637	19164	20	stock	stock	NN
18637	19164	21	over	over	IN
18637	19164	22	the	the	DT
18637	19164	23	value	value	NN
18637	19164	24	of	of	IN
18637	19164	25	real	real	JJ
18637	19164	26	and	and	CC
18637	19164	27	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19164	28	property	property	NN
18637	19164	29	and	and	CC
18637	19164	30	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19164	31	indebtedness	indebtedness	NN
18637	19164	32	of	of	IN
18637	19164	33	a	a	DT
18637	19164	34	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19164	35	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19164	36	even	even	RB
18637	19164	37	though	though	IN
18637	19164	38	this	this	DT
18637	19164	39	"	"	``
18637	19164	40	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	19164	41	excess	excess	NN
18637	19164	42	"	"	''
18637	19164	43	arose	arise	VBD
18637	19164	44	from	from	IN
18637	19164	45	property	property	NN
18637	19164	46	located	locate	VBN
18637	19164	47	and	and	CC
18637	19164	48	business	business	NN
18637	19164	49	done	do	VBN
18637	19164	50	in	in	IN
18637	19164	51	another	another	DT
18637	19164	52	State	State	NNP
18637	19164	53	and	and	CC
18637	19164	54	was	be	VBD
18637	19164	55	there	there	RB
18637	19164	56	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	19164	57	.	.	.
18637	19165	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	19165	2	,	,	,
18637	19165	3	this	this	DT
18637	19165	4	result	result	NN
18637	19165	5	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	19165	6	whether	whether	IN
18637	19165	7	the	the	DT
18637	19165	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	19165	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19165	10	considered	consider	VBN
18637	19165	11	as	as	IN
18637	19165	12	one	one	CD
18637	19165	13	on	on	IN
18637	19165	14	property	property	NN
18637	19165	15	or	or	CC
18637	19165	16	on	on	IN
18637	19165	17	the	the	DT
18637	19165	18	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	19165	19	.	.	.
18637	19166	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19166	2	539	539	CD
18637	19166	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19166	4	Also	also	RB
18637	19166	5	a	a	DT
18637	19166	6	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	19166	7	State	state	NN
18637	19166	8	,	,	,
18637	19166	9	which	which	WDT
18637	19166	10	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	19166	11	no	no	DT
18637	19166	12	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	19166	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	19166	14	on	on	IN
18637	19166	15	a	a	DT
18637	19166	16	stock	stock	NN
18637	19166	17	fire	fire	NN
18637	19166	18	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19166	19	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19166	20	,	,	,
18637	19166	21	validly	validly	RB
18637	19166	22	may	may	MD
18637	19166	23	assess	assess	VB
18637	19166	24	a	a	DT
18637	19166	25	tax	tax	NN
18637	19166	26	on	on	IN
18637	19166	27	the	the	DT
18637	19166	28	full	full	JJ
18637	19166	29	amount	amount	NN
18637	19166	30	of	of	IN
18637	19166	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19166	32	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19166	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	19166	34	in	in	RP
18637	19166	35	capital	capital	NN
18637	19166	36	stock	stock	NN
18637	19166	37	and	and	CC
18637	19166	38	surplus	surplus	NN
18637	19166	39	,	,	,
18637	19166	40	less	less	JJR
18637	19166	41	deductions	deduction	NNS
18637	19166	42	for	for	IN
18637	19166	43	liabilities	liability	NNS
18637	19166	44	,	,	,
18637	19166	45	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19166	46	that	that	IN
18637	19166	47	such	such	JJ
18637	19166	48	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19166	49	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19166	50	concentrates	concentrate	VBZ
18637	19166	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19166	52	executive	executive	NN
18637	19166	53	,	,	,
18637	19166	54	accounting	accounting	NN
18637	19166	55	,	,	,
18637	19166	56	and	and	CC
18637	19166	57	other	other	JJ
18637	19166	58	business	business	NN
18637	19166	59	offices	office	NNS
18637	19166	60	in	in	IN
18637	19166	61	New	New	NNP
18637	19166	62	York	York	NNP
18637	19166	63	,	,	,
18637	19166	64	and	and	CC
18637	19166	65	maintains	maintain	VBZ
18637	19166	66	in	in	IN
18637	19166	67	the	the	DT
18637	19166	68	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	19166	69	State	State	NNP
18637	19166	70	only	only	RB
18637	19166	71	a	a	DT
18637	19166	72	required	require	VBN
18637	19166	73	registered	registered	JJ
18637	19166	74	office	office	NN
18637	19166	75	at	at	IN
18637	19166	76	which	which	WDT
18637	19166	77	local	local	JJ
18637	19166	78	claims	claim	NNS
18637	19166	79	are	be	VBP
18637	19166	80	handled	handle	VBN
18637	19166	81	.	.	.
18637	19167	1	Despite	despite	IN
18637	19167	2	"	"	``
18637	19167	3	the	the	DT
18637	19167	4	vicissitudes	vicissitude	NNS
18637	19167	5	which	which	WDT
18637	19167	6	the	the	DT
18637	19167	7	so	so	RB
18637	19167	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	19167	9	called	call	VBN
18637	19167	10	'	'	``
18637	19167	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19167	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	19167	13	to	to	IN
18637	19167	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	19167	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	19167	16	'	'	''
18637	19167	17	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	19167	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	19167	19	encountered	encounter	VBN
18637	19167	20	*	*	NFP
18637	19167	21	*	*	NFP
18637	19167	22	*	*	NFP
18637	19167	23	,	,	,
18637	19167	24	"	"	''
18637	19167	25	the	the	DT
18637	19167	26	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	19167	27	persists	persist	VBZ
18637	19167	28	that	that	IN
18637	19167	29	intangible	intangible	JJ
18637	19167	30	property	property	NN
18637	19167	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	19167	32	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	19167	33	by	by	IN
18637	19167	34	the	the	DT
18637	19167	35	State	State	NNP
18637	19167	36	of	of	IN
18637	19167	37	origin	origin	NN
18637	19167	38	.	.	.
18637	19168	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19168	2	540	540	CD
18637	19168	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19168	4	But	but	CC
18637	19168	5	a	a	DT
18637	19168	6	property	property	NN
18637	19168	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	19168	8	on	on	IN
18637	19168	9	the	the	DT
18637	19168	10	capital	capital	NN
18637	19168	11	stock	stock	NN
18637	19168	12	of	of	IN
18637	19168	13	a	a	DT
18637	19168	14	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19168	15	company	company	NN
18637	19168	16	which	which	WDT
18637	19168	17	includes	include	VBZ
18637	19168	18	in	in	IN
18637	19168	19	the	the	DT
18637	19168	20	appraisement	appraisement	NN
18637	19168	21	thereof	thereof	IN
18637	19168	22	the	the	DT
18637	19168	23	value	value	NN
18637	19168	24	of	of	IN
18637	19168	25	coal	coal	NN
18637	19168	26	mined	mine	VBN
18637	19168	27	in	in	IN
18637	19168	28	the	the	DT
18637	19168	29	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19168	30	State	State	NNP
18637	19168	31	but	but	CC
18637	19168	32	located	locate	VBN
18637	19168	33	in	in	IN
18637	19168	34	another	another	DT
18637	19168	35	State	state	NN
18637	19168	36	awaiting	await	VBG
18637	19168	37	sale	sale	NN
18637	19168	38	deprives	deprive	VBZ
18637	19168	39	the	the	DT
18637	19168	40	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19168	41	of	of	IN
18637	19168	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19168	43	property	property	NN
18637	19168	44	without	without	IN
18637	19168	45	due	due	JJ
18637	19168	46	process	process	NN
18637	19168	47	of	of	IN
18637	19168	48	law	law	NN
18637	19168	49	.	.	.
18637	19169	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19169	2	541	541	CD
18637	19169	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19169	4	Also	also	RB
18637	19169	5	void	void	JJ
18637	19169	6	for	for	IN
18637	19169	7	the	the	DT
18637	19169	8	same	same	JJ
18637	19169	9	reason	reason	NN
18637	19169	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	19169	11	a	a	DT
18637	19169	12	State	State	NNP
18637	19169	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	19169	14	on	on	IN
18637	19169	15	the	the	DT
18637	19169	16	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	19169	17	of	of	IN
18637	19169	18	a	a	DT
18637	19169	19	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19169	20	ferry	ferry	NN
18637	19169	21	company	company	NN
18637	19169	22	which	which	WDT
18637	19169	23	includes	include	VBZ
18637	19169	24	in	in	IN
18637	19169	25	the	the	DT
18637	19169	26	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	19169	27	thereof	thereof	IN
18637	19169	28	the	the	DT
18637	19169	29	worth	worth	NN
18637	19169	30	of	of	IN
18637	19169	31	a	a	DT
18637	19169	32	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	19169	33	granted	grant	VBN
18637	19169	34	to	to	IN
18637	19169	35	the	the	DT
18637	19169	36	said	say	VBN
18637	19169	37	company	company	NN
18637	19169	38	by	by	IN
18637	19169	39	another	another	DT
18637	19169	40	State	State	NNP
18637	19169	41	.	.	.
18637	19170	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19170	2	542	542	CD
18637	19170	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19170	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19170	5	2	2	LS
18637	19170	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19170	7	Privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19170	8	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19170	9	Measured	measure	VBN
18637	19170	10	by	by	IN
18637	19170	11	Corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	19170	12	Stock.--Since	stock.--since	NN
18637	19170	13	the	the	DT
18637	19170	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	19170	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	19170	16	levied	levy	VBN
18637	19170	17	not	not	RB
18637	19170	18	on	on	IN
18637	19170	19	property	property	NN
18637	19170	20	but	but	CC
18637	19170	21	on	on	IN
18637	19170	22	the	the	DT
18637	19170	23	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19170	24	of	of	IN
18637	19170	25	doing	do	VBG
18637	19170	26	business	business	NN
18637	19170	27	in	in	IN
18637	19170	28	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	19170	29	form	form	NN
18637	19170	30	,	,	,
18637	19170	31	a	a	DT
18637	19170	32	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19170	33	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19170	34	may	may	MD
18637	19170	35	be	be	VB
18637	19170	36	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	19170	37	to	to	IN
18637	19170	38	a	a	DT
18637	19170	39	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19170	40	tax	tax	NN
18637	19170	41	graduated	graduate	VBN
18637	19170	42	according	accord	VBG
18637	19170	43	to	to	IN
18637	19170	44	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19170	45	up	up	RP
18637	19170	46	capital	capital	NN
18637	19170	47	stock	stock	NN
18637	19170	48	,	,	,
18637	19170	49	even	even	RB
18637	19170	50	though	though	IN
18637	19170	51	the	the	DT
18637	19170	52	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19170	53	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	19170	54	capital	capital	NN
18637	19170	55	not	not	RB
18637	19170	56	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19170	57	to	to	IN
18637	19170	58	the	the	DT
18637	19170	59	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19170	60	power	power	NN
18637	19170	61	of	of	IN
18637	19170	62	the	the	DT
18637	19170	63	State	State	NNP
18637	19170	64	.	.	.
18637	19171	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19171	2	543	543	CD
18637	19171	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19171	4	By	by	IN
18637	19171	5	the	the	DT
18637	19171	6	same	same	JJ
18637	19171	7	token	token	NN
18637	19171	8	,	,	,
18637	19171	9	the	the	DT
18637	19171	10	validity	validity	NN
18637	19171	11	of	of	IN
18637	19171	12	a	a	DT
18637	19171	13	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	19171	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	19171	15	,	,	,
18637	19171	16	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19171	17	on	on	IN
18637	19171	18	a	a	DT
18637	19171	19	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19171	20	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19171	21	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	19171	22	in	in	IN
18637	19171	23	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19171	24	maritime	maritime	NN
18637	19171	25	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	19171	26	and	and	CC
18637	19171	27	assessed	assess	VBD
18637	19171	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	19171	29	a	a	DT
18637	19171	30	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	19171	31	of	of	IN
18637	19171	32	the	the	DT
18637	19171	33	total	total	JJ
18637	19171	34	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	19171	35	value	value	NN
18637	19171	36	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19171	37	to	to	IN
18637	19171	38	the	the	DT
18637	19171	39	ratio	ratio	NN
18637	19171	40	of	of	IN
18637	19171	41	local	local	JJ
18637	19171	42	business	business	NN
18637	19171	43	done	do	VBN
18637	19171	44	to	to	IN
18637	19171	45	total	total	JJ
18637	19171	46	business	business	NN
18637	19171	47	,	,	,
18637	19171	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	19171	49	not	not	RB
18637	19171	50	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	19171	51	by	by	IN
18637	19171	52	the	the	DT
18637	19171	53	fact	fact	NN
18637	19171	54	that	that	IN
18637	19171	55	the	the	DT
18637	19171	56	total	total	JJ
18637	19171	57	value	value	NN
18637	19171	58	of	of	IN
18637	19171	59	the	the	DT
18637	19171	60	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	19171	61	was	be	VBD
18637	19171	62	enhanced	enhance	VBN
18637	19171	63	by	by	IN
18637	19171	64	property	property	NN
18637	19171	65	and	and	CC
18637	19171	66	operations	operation	NNS
18637	19171	67	carried	carry	VBD
18637	19171	68	on	on	RP
18637	19171	69	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19171	70	the	the	DT
18637	19171	71	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19171	72	of	of	IN
18637	19171	73	the	the	DT
18637	19171	74	State	State	NNP
18637	19171	75	.	.	.
18637	19172	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19172	2	544	544	CD
18637	19172	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19172	4	However	however	RB
18637	19172	5	,	,	,
18637	19172	6	a	a	DT
18637	19172	7	State	state	NN
18637	19172	8	,	,	,
18637	19172	9	under	under	IN
18637	19172	10	the	the	DT
18637	19172	11	guise	guise	NN
18637	19172	12	of	of	IN
18637	19172	13	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19172	14	the	the	DT
18637	19172	15	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19172	16	of	of	IN
18637	19172	17	doing	do	VBG
18637	19172	18	an	an	DT
18637	19172	19	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	19172	20	business	business	NN
18637	19172	21	,	,	,
18637	19172	22	can	can	MD
18637	19172	23	not	not	RB
18637	19172	24	levy	levy	VB
18637	19172	25	on	on	IN
18637	19172	26	property	property	NN
18637	19172	27	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19172	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19172	29	borders	border	NNS
18637	19172	30	;	;	:
18637	19172	31	and	and	CC
18637	19172	32	,	,	,
18637	19172	33	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	19172	34	,	,	,
18637	19172	35	as	as	IN
18637	19172	36	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19172	37	to	to	IN
18637	19172	38	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19172	39	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19172	40	,	,	,
18637	19172	41	a	a	DT
18637	19172	42	license	license	NN
18637	19172	43	tax	tax	NN
18637	19172	44	based	base	VBN
18637	19172	45	on	on	IN
18637	19172	46	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	19172	47	capital	capital	NN
18637	19172	48	stock	stock	NN
18637	19172	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	19172	50	void,[545	void,[545	NNP
18637	19172	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19172	52	even	even	RB
18637	19172	53	though	though	IN
18637	19172	54	there	there	EX
18637	19172	55	be	be	VB
18637	19172	56	a	a	DT
18637	19172	57	maximum	maximum	NN
18637	19172	58	to	to	IN
18637	19172	59	the	the	DT
18637	19172	60	fee,[546	fee,[546	CD
18637	19172	61	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19172	62	unless	unless	IN
18637	19172	63	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	19172	64	according	accord	VBG
18637	19172	65	to	to	IN
18637	19172	66	some	some	DT
18637	19172	67	method	method	NN
18637	19172	68	,	,	,
18637	19172	69	as	as	IN
18637	19172	70	,	,	,
18637	19172	71	for	for	IN
18637	19172	72	example	example	NN
18637	19172	73	,	,	,
18637	19172	74	a	a	DT
18637	19172	75	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	19172	76	tax	tax	NN
18637	19172	77	based	base	VBN
18637	19172	78	on	on	IN
18637	19172	79	such	such	JJ
18637	19172	80	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	19172	81	of	of	IN
18637	19172	82	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	19172	83	capital	capital	NN
18637	19172	84	stock	stock	NN
18637	19172	85	as	as	IN
18637	19172	86	is	be	VBZ
18637	19172	87	represented	represent	VBN
18637	19172	88	by	by	IN
18637	19172	89	property	property	NN
18637	19172	90	owned	own	VBN
18637	19172	91	and	and	CC
18637	19172	92	used	use	VBN
18637	19172	93	in	in	IN
18637	19172	94	business	business	NN
18637	19172	95	transacted	transact	VBN
18637	19172	96	in	in	IN
18637	19172	97	the	the	DT
18637	19172	98	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19172	99	State	state	NN
18637	19172	100	.	.	.
18637	19173	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19173	2	547	547	CD
18637	19173	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19173	4	An	an	DT
18637	19173	5	entrance	entrance	NN
18637	19173	6	fee	fee	NN
18637	19173	7	,	,	,
18637	19173	8	on	on	IN
18637	19173	9	the	the	DT
18637	19173	10	other	other	JJ
18637	19173	11	hand	hand	NN
18637	19173	12	,	,	,
18637	19173	13	collected	collect	VBD
18637	19173	14	only	only	RB
18637	19173	15	once	once	RB
18637	19173	16	as	as	IN
18637	19173	17	the	the	DT
18637	19173	18	price	price	NN
18637	19173	19	of	of	IN
18637	19173	20	admission	admission	NN
18637	19173	21	to	to	TO
18637	19173	22	do	do	VB
18637	19173	23	an	an	DT
18637	19173	24	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	19173	25	business	business	NN
18637	19173	26	,	,	,
18637	19173	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	19173	28	distinguishable	distinguishable	JJ
18637	19173	29	from	from	IN
18637	19173	30	a	a	DT
18637	19173	31	tax	tax	NN
18637	19173	32	and	and	CC
18637	19173	33	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19173	34	may	may	MD
18637	19173	35	be	be	VB
18637	19173	36	levied	levy	VBN
18637	19173	37	on	on	IN
18637	19173	38	a	a	DT
18637	19173	39	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19173	40	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19173	41	on	on	IN
18637	19173	42	the	the	DT
18637	19173	43	basis	basis	NN
18637	19173	44	of	of	IN
18637	19173	45	a	a	DT
18637	19173	46	sum	sum	NN
18637	19173	47	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	19173	48	in	in	IN
18637	19173	49	relation	relation	NN
18637	19173	50	to	to	IN
18637	19173	51	the	the	DT
18637	19173	52	amount	amount	NN
18637	19173	53	of	of	IN
18637	19173	54	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	19173	55	capital	capital	NN
18637	19173	56	stock	stock	NN
18637	19173	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19173	58	in	in	IN
18637	19173	59	this	this	DT
18637	19173	60	instance	instance	NN
18637	19173	61	,	,	,
18637	19173	62	a	a	DT
18637	19173	63	$	$	$
18637	19173	64	5,000	5,000	CD
18637	19173	65	fee	fee	NN
18637	19173	66	on	on	IN
18637	19173	67	an	an	DT
18637	19173	68	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	19173	69	capital	capital	NN
18637	19173	70	of	of	IN
18637	19173	71	$	$	$
18637	19173	72	100,000,000	100,000,000	CD
18637	19173	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19173	74	.	.	.
18637	19174	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19174	2	548	548	CD
18637	19174	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19174	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19174	5	3	3	LS
18637	19174	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19174	7	Privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19174	8	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19174	9	Measured	measure	VBN
18637	19174	10	by	by	IN
18637	19174	11	Gross	gross	JJ
18637	19174	12	Receipts.--A	receipts.--a	NN
18637	19174	13	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	19174	14	license	license	NN
18637	19174	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	19174	16	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19174	17	as	as	IN
18637	19174	18	a	a	DT
18637	19174	19	percentage	percentage	NN
18637	19174	20	of	of	IN
18637	19174	21	the	the	DT
18637	19174	22	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	19174	23	of	of	IN
18637	19174	24	a	a	DT
18637	19174	25	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19174	26	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19174	27	derived	derive	VBN
18637	19174	28	from	from	IN
18637	19174	29	the	the	DT
18637	19174	30	sales	sale	NNS
18637	19174	31	within	within	IN
18637	19174	32	and	and	CC
18637	19174	33	without	without	IN
18637	19174	34	the	the	DT
18637	19174	35	State	State	NNP
18637	19174	36	of	of	IN
18637	19174	37	goods	good	NNS
18637	19174	38	manufactured	manufacture	VBN
18637	19174	39	in	in	IN
18637	19174	40	the	the	DT
18637	19174	41	city	city	NN
18637	19174	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	19174	43	not	not	RB
18637	19174	44	a	a	DT
18637	19174	45	tax	tax	NN
18637	19174	46	on	on	IN
18637	19174	47	business	business	NN
18637	19174	48	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	19174	49	or	or	CC
18637	19174	50	property	property	NN
18637	19174	51	outside	outside	IN
18637	19174	52	the	the	DT
18637	19174	53	city	city	NN
18637	19174	54	and	and	CC
18637	19174	55	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	19174	56	does	do	VBZ
18637	19174	57	not	not	RB
18637	19174	58	violate	violate	VB
18637	19174	59	the	the	DT
18637	19174	60	due	due	JJ
18637	19174	61	process	process	NN
18637	19174	62	clause	clause	NN
18637	19174	63	.	.	.
18637	19175	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19175	2	549	549	CD
18637	19175	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19175	4	But	but	CC
18637	19175	5	a	a	DT
18637	19175	6	State	state	NN
18637	19175	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19175	8	wanting	want	VBG
18637	19175	9	in	in	IN
18637	19175	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19175	11	to	to	TO
18637	19175	12	extend	extend	VB
18637	19175	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19175	14	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19175	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	19175	16	to	to	IN
18637	19175	17	the	the	DT
18637	19175	18	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19175	19	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	19175	20	of	of	IN
18637	19175	21	a	a	DT
18637	19175	22	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19175	23	contracting	contract	VBG
18637	19175	24	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19175	25	for	for	IN
18637	19175	26	work	work	NN
18637	19175	27	done	do	VBN
18637	19175	28	outside	outside	IN
18637	19175	29	the	the	DT
18637	19175	30	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19175	31	State	state	NN
18637	19175	32	in	in	IN
18637	19175	33	fabricating	fabricate	VBG
18637	19175	34	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	19175	35	later	later	RB
18637	19175	36	installed	instal	VBN
18637	19175	37	in	in	IN
18637	19175	38	the	the	DT
18637	19175	39	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19175	40	State	state	NN
18637	19175	41	.	.	.
18637	19176	1	Unless	unless	IN
18637	19176	2	the	the	DT
18637	19176	3	activities	activity	NNS
18637	19176	4	which	which	WDT
18637	19176	5	are	be	VBP
18637	19176	6	the	the	DT
18637	19176	7	subject	subject	NN
18637	19176	8	of	of	IN
18637	19176	9	the	the	DT
18637	19176	10	tax	tax	NN
18637	19176	11	are	be	VBP
18637	19176	12	carried	carry	VBN
18637	19176	13	on	on	RP
18637	19176	14	within	within	IN
18637	19176	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19176	16	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	19176	17	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19176	18	,	,	,
18637	19176	19	a	a	DT
18637	19176	20	State	state	NN
18637	19176	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	19176	22	not	not	RB
18637	19176	23	competent	competent	JJ
18637	19176	24	to	to	TO
18637	19176	25	impose	impose	VB
18637	19176	26	such	such	PDT
18637	19176	27	a	a	DT
18637	19176	28	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19176	29	tax	tax	NN
18637	19176	30	.	.	.
18637	19177	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19177	2	550	550	CD
18637	19177	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19177	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19177	5	4	4	LS
18637	19177	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19177	7	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19177	8	on	on	IN
18637	19177	9	Tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	19177	10	Personal	personal	JJ
18637	19177	11	Property.--When	Property.--When	''
18637	19177	12	rolling	roll	VBG
18637	19177	13	stock	stock	NN
18637	19177	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19177	15	permanently	permanently	RB
18637	19177	16	located	locate	VBN
18637	19177	17	and	and	CC
18637	19177	18	employed	employ	VBN
18637	19177	19	in	in	IN
18637	19177	20	the	the	DT
18637	19177	21	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	19177	22	of	of	IN
18637	19177	23	a	a	DT
18637	19177	24	business	business	NN
18637	19177	25	outside	outside	IN
18637	19177	26	the	the	DT
18637	19177	27	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	19177	28	of	of	IN
18637	19177	29	a	a	DT
18637	19177	30	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	19177	31	State	State	NNP
18637	19177	32	,	,	,
18637	19177	33	the	the	DT
18637	19177	34	latter	latter	NN
18637	19177	35	has	have	VBZ
18637	19177	36	no	no	DT
18637	19177	37	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19177	38	to	to	TO
18637	19177	39	tax	tax	VB
18637	19177	40	the	the	DT
18637	19177	41	same	same	JJ
18637	19177	42	.	.	.
18637	19178	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19178	2	551	551	CD
18637	19178	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19178	4	Vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	19178	5	,	,	,
18637	19178	6	however	however	RB
18637	19178	7	,	,	,
18637	19178	8	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	19178	9	as	as	IN
18637	19178	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19178	11	merely	merely	RB
18637	19178	12	touch	touch	VBP
18637	19178	13	briefly	briefly	RB
18637	19178	14	at	at	IN
18637	19178	15	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	19178	16	ports	port	NNS
18637	19178	17	,	,	,
18637	19178	18	never	never	RB
18637	19178	19	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	19178	20	a	a	DT
18637	19178	21	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	19178	22	situs	situs	NN
18637	19178	23	at	at	IN
18637	19178	24	any	any	DT
18637	19178	25	one	one	CD
18637	19178	26	of	of	IN
18637	19178	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19178	28	,	,	,
18637	19178	29	and	and	CC
18637	19178	30	are	be	VBP
18637	19178	31	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	19178	32	by	by	IN
18637	19178	33	the	the	DT
18637	19178	34	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19178	35	of	of	IN
18637	19178	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19178	37	owners	owner	NNS
18637	19178	38	or	or	CC
18637	19178	39	not	not	RB
18637	19178	40	at	at	IN
18637	19178	41	all;[552	all;[552	NNP
18637	19178	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19178	43	unless	unless	IN
18637	19178	44	,	,	,
18637	19178	45	of	of	IN
18637	19178	46	course	course	NN
18637	19178	47	,	,	,
18637	19178	48	the	the	DT
18637	19178	49	ships	ship	NNS
18637	19178	50	operate	operate	VBP
18637	19178	51	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	19178	52	on	on	IN
18637	19178	53	the	the	DT
18637	19178	54	waters	water	NNS
18637	19178	55	within	within	IN
18637	19178	56	one	one	CD
18637	19178	57	State	State	NNP
18637	19178	58	,	,	,
18637	19178	59	in	in	IN
18637	19178	60	which	which	WDT
18637	19178	61	event	event	NN
18637	19178	62	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19178	63	are	be	VBP
18637	19178	64	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	19178	65	there	there	RB
18637	19178	66	and	and	CC
18637	19178	67	not	not	RB
18637	19178	68	at	at	IN
18637	19178	69	the	the	DT
18637	19178	70	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19178	71	of	of	IN
18637	19178	72	the	the	DT
18637	19178	73	owners	owner	NNS
18637	19178	74	.	.	.
18637	19179	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19179	2	553	553	CD
18637	19179	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19179	4	Only	only	RB
18637	19179	5	recently	recently	RB
18637	19179	6	airplanes	airplane	NNS
18637	19179	7	have	have	VBP
18637	19179	8	been	be	VBN
18637	19179	9	treated	treat	VBN
18637	19179	10	in	in	IN
18637	19179	11	a	a	DT
18637	19179	12	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19179	13	manner	manner	NN
18637	19179	14	for	for	IN
18637	19179	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	19179	16	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19179	17	.	.	.
18637	19180	1	Noting	note	VBG
18637	19180	2	that	that	IN
18637	19180	3	the	the	DT
18637	19180	4	entire	entire	JJ
18637	19180	5	fleet	fleet	NN
18637	19180	6	of	of	IN
18637	19180	7	airplanes	airplane	NNS
18637	19180	8	of	of	IN
18637	19180	9	an	an	DT
18637	19180	10	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	19180	11	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	19180	12	were	be	VBD
18637	19180	13	"	"	``
18637	19180	14	never	never	RB
18637	19180	15	continuously	continuously	RB
18637	19180	16	without	without	IN
18637	19180	17	the	the	DT
18637	19180	18	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19180	19	domiciliary	domiciliary	NNP
18637	19180	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19180	21	State	state	NN
18637	19180	22	during	during	IN
18637	19180	23	the	the	DT
18637	19180	24	whole	whole	JJ
18637	19180	25	tax	tax	NN
18637	19180	26	year	year	NN
18637	19180	27	,	,	,
18637	19180	28	"	"	''
18637	19180	29	that	that	IN
18637	19180	30	such	such	JJ
18637	19180	31	airplanes	airplane	NNS
18637	19180	32	also	also	RB
18637	19180	33	had	have	VBD
18637	19180	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19180	35	"	"	``
18637	19180	36	home	home	NN
18637	19180	37	port	port	NN
18637	19180	38	"	"	''
18637	19180	39	in	in	IN
18637	19180	40	the	the	DT
18637	19180	41	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	19180	42	State	State	NNP
18637	19180	43	,	,	,
18637	19180	44	and	and	CC
18637	19180	45	that	that	IN
18637	19180	46	the	the	DT
18637	19180	47	company	company	NN
18637	19180	48	maintained	maintain	VBD
18637	19180	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19180	50	principal	principal	JJ
18637	19180	51	office	office	NN
18637	19180	52	therein	therein	RB
18637	19180	53	,	,	,
18637	19180	54	the	the	DT
18637	19180	55	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19180	56	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	19180	57	a	a	DT
18637	19180	58	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19180	59	property	property	NN
18637	19180	60	tax	tax	NN
18637	19180	61	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19180	62	by	by	IN
18637	19180	63	the	the	DT
18637	19180	64	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	19180	65	State	State	NNP
18637	19180	66	to	to	IN
18637	19180	67	all	all	PDT
18637	19180	68	the	the	DT
18637	19180	69	airplanes	airplane	NNS
18637	19180	70	owned	own	VBN
18637	19180	71	by	by	IN
18637	19180	72	the	the	DT
18637	19180	73	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	19180	74	.	.	.
18637	19181	1	No	no	DT
18637	19181	2	other	other	JJ
18637	19181	3	State	State	NNP
18637	19181	4	was	be	VBD
18637	19181	5	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19181	6	able	able	JJ
18637	19181	7	to	to	TO
18637	19181	8	accord	accord	VB
18637	19181	9	the	the	DT
18637	19181	10	same	same	JJ
18637	19181	11	protection	protection	NN
18637	19181	12	and	and	CC
18637	19181	13	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	19181	14	as	as	IN
18637	19181	15	the	the	DT
18637	19181	16	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19181	17	State	State	NNP
18637	19181	18	in	in	IN
18637	19181	19	which	which	WDT
18637	19181	20	the	the	DT
18637	19181	21	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	19181	22	had	have	VBD
18637	19181	23	both	both	CC
18637	19181	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19181	25	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19181	26	and	and	CC
18637	19181	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19181	28	business	business	NN
18637	19181	29	situs	situs	NN
18637	19181	30	;	;	,
18637	19181	31	and	and	CC
18637	19181	32	the	the	DT
18637	19181	33	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	19181	34	of	of	IN
18637	19181	35	Union	Union	NNP
18637	19181	36	Refrigerator	Refrigerator	NNP
18637	19181	37	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	19181	38	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	19181	39	_	_	NNP
18637	19181	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	19181	41	_	_	NNP
18637	19181	42	Kentucky,[554	Kentucky,[554	NNP
18637	19181	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19181	44	as	as	IN
18637	19181	45	to	to	IN
18637	19181	46	the	the	DT
18637	19181	47	taxability	taxability	NN
18637	19181	48	of	of	IN
18637	19181	49	permanently	permanently	RB
18637	19181	50	located	locate	VBN
18637	19181	51	tangibles	tangible	NNS
18637	19181	52	,	,	,
18637	19181	53	and	and	CC
18637	19181	54	that	that	DT
18637	19181	55	of	of	IN
18637	19181	56	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	19181	57	,	,	,
18637	19181	58	for	for	IN
18637	19181	59	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	19181	60	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	19181	61	in	in	IN
18637	19181	62	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	19181	63	commerce[555	commerce[555	.
18637	19181	64	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19181	65	were	be	VBD
18637	19181	66	held	hold	VBN
18637	19181	67	to	to	TO
18637	19181	68	be	be	VB
18637	19181	69	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	19181	70	.	.	.
18637	19182	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19182	2	556	556	CD
18637	19182	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19182	4	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	19182	5	,	,	,
18637	19182	6	a	a	DT
18637	19182	7	nondomiciliary	nondomiciliary	JJ
18637	19182	8	State	State	NNP
18637	19182	9	,	,	,
18637	19182	10	although	although	IN
18637	19182	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19182	12	may	may	MD
18637	19182	13	not	not	RB
18637	19182	14	tax	tax	VB
18637	19182	15	property	property	NN
18637	19182	16	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	19182	17	to	to	IN
18637	19182	18	a	a	DT
18637	19182	19	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19182	20	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19182	21	which	which	WDT
18637	19182	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	19182	23	never	never	RB
18637	19182	24	come	come	VBN
18637	19182	25	within	within	IN
18637	19182	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19182	27	borders	border	NNS
18637	19182	28	,	,	,
18637	19182	29	may	may	MD
18637	19182	30	levy	levy	VB
18637	19182	31	on	on	IN
18637	19182	32	movables	movable	NNS
18637	19182	33	which	which	WDT
18637	19182	34	are	be	VBP
18637	19182	35	regularly	regularly	RB
18637	19182	36	and	and	CC
18637	19182	37	habitually	habitually	RB
18637	19182	38	used	use	VBN
18637	19182	39	and	and	CC
18637	19182	40	employed	employ	VBN
18637	19182	41	therein	therein	RB
18637	19182	42	.	.	.
18637	19183	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19183	2	,	,	,
18637	19183	3	while	while	IN
18637	19183	4	the	the	DT
18637	19183	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	19183	6	that	that	IN
18637	19183	7	cars	car	NNS
18637	19183	8	are	be	VBP
18637	19183	9	loaded	load	VBN
18637	19183	10	and	and	CC
18637	19183	11	reloaded	reload	VBN
18637	19183	12	at	at	IN
18637	19183	13	a	a	DT
18637	19183	14	refinery	refinery	NN
18637	19183	15	in	in	IN
18637	19183	16	a	a	DT
18637	19183	17	State	state	NN
18637	19183	18	outside	outside	IN
18637	19183	19	the	the	DT
18637	19183	20	owner	owner	NN
18637	19183	21	's	's	POS
18637	19183	22	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19183	23	does	do	VBZ
18637	19183	24	not	not	RB
18637	19183	25	fix	fix	VB
18637	19183	26	the	the	DT
18637	19183	27	situs	situs	NN
18637	19183	28	of	of	IN
18637	19183	29	the	the	DT
18637	19183	30	entire	entire	JJ
18637	19183	31	fleet	fleet	NN
18637	19183	32	in	in	IN
18637	19183	33	such	such	JJ
18637	19183	34	State	State	NNP
18637	19183	35	,	,	,
18637	19183	36	the	the	DT
18637	19183	37	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19183	38	may	may	MD
18637	19183	39	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	19183	40	tax	tax	VB
18637	19183	41	the	the	DT
18637	19183	42	number	number	NN
18637	19183	43	of	of	IN
18637	19183	44	cars	car	NNS
18637	19183	45	which	which	WDT
18637	19183	46	on	on	IN
18637	19183	47	the	the	DT
18637	19183	48	average	average	NN
18637	19183	49	are	be	VBP
18637	19183	50	found	find	VBN
18637	19183	51	to	to	TO
18637	19183	52	be	be	VB
18637	19183	53	present	present	JJ
18637	19183	54	within	within	IN
18637	19183	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19183	56	borders	border	NNS
18637	19183	57	.	.	.
18637	19184	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19184	2	557	557	CD
18637	19184	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19184	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	19184	5	,	,	,
18637	19184	6	in	in	IN
18637	19184	7	assessing	assess	VBG
18637	19184	8	that	that	DT
18637	19184	9	part	part	NN
18637	19184	10	of	of	IN
18637	19184	11	a	a	DT
18637	19184	12	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19184	13	within	within	IN
18637	19184	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19184	15	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19184	16	,	,	,
18637	19184	17	a	a	DT
18637	19184	18	State	state	NN
18637	19184	19	need	nee	MD
18637	19184	20	not	not	RB
18637	19184	21	treat	treat	VB
18637	19184	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19184	23	as	as	IN
18637	19184	24	an	an	DT
18637	19184	25	independent	independent	JJ
18637	19184	26	line	line	NN
18637	19184	27	,	,	,
18637	19184	28	disconnected	disconnect	VBN
18637	19184	29	from	from	IN
18637	19184	30	the	the	DT
18637	19184	31	part	part	NN
18637	19184	32	without	without	IN
18637	19184	33	,	,	,
18637	19184	34	and	and	CC
18637	19184	35	place	place	NN
18637	19184	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	19184	37	the	the	DT
18637	19184	38	property	property	NN
18637	19184	39	within	within	IN
18637	19184	40	the	the	DT
18637	19184	41	State	State	NNP
18637	19184	42	only	only	RB
18637	19184	43	a	a	DT
18637	19184	44	value	value	NN
18637	19184	45	which	which	WDT
18637	19184	46	could	could	MD
18637	19184	47	be	be	VB
18637	19184	48	given	give	VBN
18637	19184	49	to	to	IN
18637	19184	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19184	51	if	if	IN
18637	19184	52	operated	operate	VBN
18637	19184	53	separately	separately	RB
18637	19184	54	from	from	IN
18637	19184	55	the	the	DT
18637	19184	56	balance	balance	NN
18637	19184	57	of	of	IN
18637	19184	58	the	the	DT
18637	19184	59	road	road	NN
18637	19184	60	.	.	.
18637	19185	1	The	the	DT
18637	19185	2	State	State	NNP
18637	19185	3	may	may	MD
18637	19185	4	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	19185	5	the	the	DT
18637	19185	6	value	value	NN
18637	19185	7	of	of	IN
18637	19185	8	the	the	DT
18637	19185	9	whole	whole	JJ
18637	19185	10	line	line	NN
18637	19185	11	as	as	IN
18637	19185	12	a	a	DT
18637	19185	13	single	single	JJ
18637	19185	14	property	property	NN
18637	19185	15	and	and	CC
18637	19185	16	then	then	RB
18637	19185	17	determine	determine	VB
18637	19185	18	the	the	DT
18637	19185	19	value	value	NN
18637	19185	20	of	of	IN
18637	19185	21	the	the	DT
18637	19185	22	part	part	NN
18637	19185	23	within	within	IN
18637	19185	24	on	on	IN
18637	19185	25	a	a	DT
18637	19185	26	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	19185	27	basis	basis	NN
18637	19185	28	,	,	,
18637	19185	29	unless	unless	IN
18637	19185	30	there	there	EX
18637	19185	31	be	be	VB
18637	19185	32	special	special	JJ
18637	19185	33	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19185	34	which	which	WDT
18637	19185	35	distinguish	distinguish	VBP
18637	19185	36	between	between	IN
18637	19185	37	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19185	38	in	in	IN
18637	19185	39	the	the	DT
18637	19185	40	several	several	JJ
18637	19185	41	States	state	NNS
18637	19185	42	.	.	.
18637	19186	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19186	2	558	558	CD
18637	19186	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19186	4	But	but	CC
18637	19186	5	no	no	DT
18637	19186	6	property	property	NN
18637	19186	7	of	of	IN
18637	19186	8	an	an	DT
18637	19186	9	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	19186	10	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	19186	11	can	can	MD
18637	19186	12	be	be	VB
18637	19186	13	taken	take	VBN
18637	19186	14	into	into	IN
18637	19186	15	account	account	NN
18637	19186	16	unless	unless	IN
18637	19186	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19186	18	can	can	MD
18637	19186	19	be	be	VB
18637	19186	20	seen	see	VBN
18637	19186	21	in	in	IN
18637	19186	22	some	some	DT
18637	19186	23	plain	plain	JJ
18637	19186	24	and	and	CC
18637	19186	25	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	19186	26	intelligible	intelligible	JJ
18637	19186	27	way	way	NN
18637	19186	28	that	that	WDT
18637	19186	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19186	30	adds	add	VBZ
18637	19186	31	to	to	IN
18637	19186	32	the	the	DT
18637	19186	33	value	value	NN
18637	19186	34	of	of	IN
18637	19186	35	the	the	DT
18637	19186	36	road	road	NN
18637	19186	37	and	and	CC
18637	19186	38	the	the	DT
18637	19186	39	rights	right	NNS
18637	19186	40	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	19186	41	in	in	IN
18637	19186	42	the	the	DT
18637	19186	43	State	State	NNP
18637	19186	44	.	.	.
18637	19187	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19187	2	559	559	CD
18637	19187	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19187	4	Also	also	RB
18637	19187	5	,	,	,
18637	19187	6	a	a	DT
18637	19187	7	State	state	NN
18637	19187	8	property	property	NN
18637	19187	9	tax	tax	NN
18637	19187	10	on	on	IN
18637	19187	11	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	19187	12	,	,	,
18637	19187	13	which	which	WDT
18637	19187	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19187	15	measured	measure	VBN
18637	19187	16	by	by	IN
18637	19187	17	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19187	18	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	19187	19	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	19187	20	to	to	IN
18637	19187	21	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	19187	22	,	,	,
18637	19187	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	19187	24	not	not	RB
18637	19187	25	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19187	26	in	in	IN
18637	19187	27	the	the	DT
18637	19187	28	absence	absence	NN
18637	19187	29	of	of	IN
18637	19187	30	proof	proof	NN
18637	19187	31	that	that	IN
18637	19187	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19187	33	exceeds	exceed	VBZ
18637	19187	34	what	what	WP
18637	19187	35	would	would	MD
18637	19187	36	be	be	VB
18637	19187	37	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	19187	38	as	as	IN
18637	19187	39	an	an	DT
18637	19187	40	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	19187	41	tax	tax	NN
18637	19187	42	on	on	IN
18637	19187	43	the	the	DT
18637	19187	44	property	property	NN
18637	19187	45	valued	value	VBN
18637	19187	46	as	as	IN
18637	19187	47	part	part	NN
18637	19187	48	of	of	IN
18637	19187	49	a	a	DT
18637	19187	50	going	go	VBG
18637	19187	51	concern	concern	NN
18637	19187	52	or	or	CC
18637	19187	53	that	that	IN
18637	19187	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19187	55	is	be	VBZ
18637	19187	56	relatively	relatively	RB
18637	19187	57	higher	high	JJR
18637	19187	58	than	than	IN
18637	19187	59	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19187	60	on	on	IN
18637	19187	61	other	other	JJ
18637	19187	62	kinds	kind	NNS
18637	19187	63	of	of	IN
18637	19187	64	property	property	NN
18637	19187	65	.	.	.
18637	19188	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19188	2	560	560	CD
18637	19188	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19188	4	The	the	DT
18637	19188	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	19188	6	reaches	reach	VBZ
18637	19188	7	only	only	RB
18637	19188	8	revenues	revenue	NNS
18637	19188	9	derived	derive	VBN
18637	19188	10	from	from	IN
18637	19188	11	local	local	JJ
18637	19188	12	operations	operation	NNS
18637	19188	13	,	,	,
18637	19188	14	and	and	CC
18637	19188	15	the	the	DT
18637	19188	16	fact	fact	NN
18637	19188	17	that	that	IN
18637	19188	18	the	the	DT
18637	19188	19	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	19188	20	formula	formula	NN
18637	19188	21	does	do	VBZ
18637	19188	22	not	not	RB
18637	19188	23	result	result	VB
18637	19188	24	in	in	IN
18637	19188	25	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
18637	19188	26	exactitude	exactitude	NN
18637	19188	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	19188	28	not	not	RB
18637	19188	29	a	a	DT
18637	19188	30	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19188	31	defect	defect	NN
18637	19188	32	.	.	.
18637	19189	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19189	2	561	561	CD
18637	19189	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19189	4	Income	Income	NNP
18637	19189	5	and	and	CC
18637	19189	6	Other	other	JJ
18637	19189	7	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19189	8	Individual	individual	VBP
18637	19189	9	Incomes.--Consistently	incomes.--consistently	RB
18637	19189	10	with	with	IN
18637	19189	11	due	due	JJ
18637	19189	12	process	process	NN
18637	19189	13	of	of	IN
18637	19189	14	law	law	NN
18637	19189	15	,	,	,
18637	19189	16	a	a	DT
18637	19189	17	State	state	NN
18637	19189	18	annually	annually	RB
18637	19189	19	may	may	MD
18637	19189	20	tax	tax	VB
18637	19189	21	the	the	DT
18637	19189	22	entire	entire	JJ
18637	19189	23	net	net	JJ
18637	19189	24	income	income	NN
18637	19189	25	of	of	IN
18637	19189	26	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19189	27	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	19189	28	from	from	IN
18637	19189	29	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	19189	30	source	source	NN
18637	19189	31	received,[562	received,[562	NN
18637	19189	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19189	33	and	and	CC
18637	19189	34	that	that	DT
18637	19189	35	portion	portion	NN
18637	19189	36	of	of	IN
18637	19189	37	a	a	DT
18637	19189	38	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19189	39	's	's	POS
18637	19189	40	net	net	JJ
18637	19189	41	income	income	NN
18637	19189	42	derived	derive	VBN
18637	19189	43	from	from	IN
18637	19189	44	property	property	NN
18637	19189	45	owned	own	VBN
18637	19189	46	,	,	,
18637	19189	47	and	and	CC
18637	19189	48	from	from	IN
18637	19189	49	any	any	DT
18637	19189	50	business	business	NN
18637	19189	51	,	,	,
18637	19189	52	trade	trade	NN
18637	19189	53	,	,	,
18637	19189	54	or	or	CC
18637	19189	55	profession	profession	NN
18637	19189	56	carried	carry	VBN
18637	19189	57	on	on	RP
18637	19189	58	,	,	,
18637	19189	59	by	by	IN
18637	19189	60	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19189	61	within	within	IN
18637	19189	62	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19189	63	borders	border	NNS
18637	19189	64	.	.	.
18637	19190	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19190	2	563	563	CD
18637	19190	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19190	4	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	19190	5	,	,	,
18637	19190	6	in	in	IN
18637	19190	7	the	the	DT
18637	19190	8	case	case	NN
18637	19190	9	of	of	IN
18637	19190	10	residents	resident	NNS
18637	19190	11	,	,	,
18637	19190	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	19190	13	founded	found	VBN
18637	19190	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	19190	15	the	the	DT
18637	19190	16	rights	right	NNS
18637	19190	17	and	and	CC
18637	19190	18	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	19190	19	incident	incident	NN
18637	19190	20	to	to	TO
18637	19190	21	domicile	domicile	VB
18637	19190	22	;	;	:
18637	19190	23	that	that	RB
18637	19190	24	is	is	RB
18637	19190	25	,	,	,
18637	19190	26	the	the	DT
18637	19190	27	protection	protection	NN
18637	19190	28	afforded	afford	VBD
18637	19190	29	the	the	DT
18637	19190	30	recipient	recipient	NN
18637	19190	31	of	of	IN
18637	19190	32	income	income	NN
18637	19190	33	in	in	IN
18637	19190	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19190	35	person	person	NN
18637	19190	36	,	,	,
18637	19190	37	in	in	IN
18637	19190	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19190	39	right	right	NN
18637	19190	40	to	to	TO
18637	19190	41	receive	receive	VB
18637	19190	42	the	the	DT
18637	19190	43	income	income	NN
18637	19190	44	,	,	,
18637	19190	45	and	and	CC
18637	19190	46	in	in	IN
18637	19190	47	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19190	48	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	19190	49	of	of	IN
18637	19190	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19190	51	when	when	WRB
18637	19190	52	received	receive	VBN
18637	19190	53	,	,	,
18637	19190	54	and	and	CC
18637	19190	55	,	,	,
18637	19190	56	in	in	IN
18637	19190	57	the	the	DT
18637	19190	58	case	case	NN
18637	19190	59	of	of	IN
18637	19190	60	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	19190	61	,	,	,
18637	19190	62	upon	upon	IN
18637	19190	63	dominion	dominion	NN
18637	19190	64	over	over	IN
18637	19190	65	either	either	CC
18637	19190	66	the	the	DT
18637	19190	67	receiver	receiver	NN
18637	19190	68	of	of	IN
18637	19190	69	the	the	DT
18637	19190	70	income	income	NN
18637	19190	71	or	or	CC
18637	19190	72	the	the	DT
18637	19190	73	property	property	NN
18637	19190	74	or	or	CC
18637	19190	75	activity	activity	NN
18637	19190	76	from	from	IN
18637	19190	77	which	which	WDT
18637	19190	78	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19190	79	is	be	VBZ
18637	19190	80	derived	derive	VBN
18637	19190	81	,	,	,
18637	19190	82	and	and	CC
18637	19190	83	upon	upon	IN
18637	19190	84	the	the	DT
18637	19190	85	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	19190	86	to	to	TO
18637	19190	87	contribute	contribute	VB
18637	19190	88	to	to	IN
18637	19190	89	the	the	DT
18637	19190	90	support	support	NN
18637	19190	91	of	of	IN
18637	19190	92	a	a	DT
18637	19190	93	government	government	NN
18637	19190	94	which	which	WDT
18637	19190	95	renders	render	VBZ
18637	19190	96	secure	secure	VBP
18637	19190	97	the	the	DT
18637	19190	98	collection	collection	NN
18637	19190	99	of	of	IN
18637	19190	100	such	such	JJ
18637	19190	101	income	income	NN
18637	19190	102	.	.	.
18637	19191	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19191	2	,	,	,
18637	19191	3	a	a	DT
18637	19191	4	State	state	NN
18637	19191	5	may	may	MD
18637	19191	6	tax	tax	VB
18637	19191	7	residents	resident	NNS
18637	19191	8	on	on	IN
18637	19191	9	income	income	NN
18637	19191	10	from	from	IN
18637	19191	11	rents	rent	NNS
18637	19191	12	of	of	IN
18637	19191	13	land	land	NN
18637	19191	14	located	locate	VBN
18637	19191	15	outside	outside	IN
18637	19191	16	the	the	DT
18637	19191	17	State	State	NNP
18637	19191	18	and	and	CC
18637	19191	19	from	from	IN
18637	19191	20	interest	interest	NN
18637	19191	21	on	on	IN
18637	19191	22	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	19191	23	physically	physically	RB
18637	19191	24	without	without	IN
18637	19191	25	the	the	DT
18637	19191	26	State	state	NN
18637	19191	27	and	and	CC
18637	19191	28	secured	secure	VBN
18637	19191	29	by	by	IN
18637	19191	30	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	19191	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	19191	32	lands	land	VBZ
18637	19191	33	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19191	34	situated;[564	situated;[564	ADD
18637	19191	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19191	36	and	and	CC
18637	19191	37	the	the	DT
18637	19191	38	income	income	NN
18637	19191	39	received	receive	VBN
18637	19191	40	by	by	IN
18637	19191	41	a	a	DT
18637	19191	42	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19191	43	beneficiary	beneficiary	NN
18637	19191	44	from	from	IN
18637	19191	45	securities	security	NNS
18637	19191	46	held	hold	VBN
18637	19191	47	by	by	IN
18637	19191	48	a	a	DT
18637	19191	49	trustee	trustee	NN
18637	19191	50	in	in	IN
18637	19191	51	a	a	DT
18637	19191	52	trust	trust	NN
18637	19191	53	created	create	VBN
18637	19191	54	and	and	CC
18637	19191	55	administered	administer	VBN
18637	19191	56	in	in	IN
18637	19191	57	another	another	DT
18637	19191	58	State	state	NN
18637	19191	59	,	,	,
18637	19191	60	and	and	CC
18637	19191	61	not	not	RB
18637	19191	62	directly	directly	RB
18637	19191	63	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	19191	64	to	to	IN
18637	19191	65	the	the	DT
18637	19191	66	trustee	trustee	NN
18637	19191	67	.	.	.
18637	19192	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19192	2	565	565	CD
18637	19192	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19192	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19192	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	19192	6	the	the	DT
18637	19192	7	fact	fact	NN
18637	19192	8	that	that	IN
18637	19192	9	another	another	DT
18637	19192	10	State	state	NN
18637	19192	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	19192	12	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	19192	13	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19192	14	identical	identical	JJ
18637	19192	15	income	income	NN
18637	19192	16	in	in	IN
18637	19192	17	the	the	DT
18637	19192	18	hands	hand	NNS
18637	19192	19	of	of	IN
18637	19192	20	trustees	trustee	NNS
18637	19192	21	operating	operate	VBG
18637	19192	22	therein	therein	RB
18637	19192	23	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	19192	24	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	19192	25	a	a	DT
18637	19192	26	domiciliary	domiciliary	JJ
18637	19192	27	State	State	NNP
18637	19192	28	's	's	POS
18637	19192	29	right	right	NN
18637	19192	30	to	to	TO
18637	19192	31	tax	tax	VB
18637	19192	32	the	the	DT
18637	19192	33	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	19192	34	of	of	IN
18637	19192	35	said	said	JJ
18637	19192	36	income	income	NN
18637	19192	37	by	by	IN
18637	19192	38	a	a	DT
18637	19192	39	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19192	40	beneficiary	beneficiary	NN
18637	19192	41	.	.	.
18637	19193	1	"	"	``
18637	19193	2	The	the	DT
18637	19193	3	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19193	4	power	power	NN
18637	19193	5	of	of	IN
18637	19193	6	a	a	DT
18637	19193	7	State	State	NNP
18637	19193	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	19193	9	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	19193	10	to	to	IN
18637	19193	11	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19193	12	confines	confine	NNS
18637	19193	13	and	and	CC
18637	19193	14	may	may	MD
18637	19193	15	not	not	RB
18637	19193	16	be	be	VB
18637	19193	17	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	19193	18	in	in	IN
18637	19193	19	respect	respect	NN
18637	19193	20	of	of	IN
18637	19193	21	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	19193	22	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19193	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19193	24	.	.	.
18637	19194	1	"	"	``
18637	19194	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19194	3	566	566	CD
18637	19194	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19194	5	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19194	6	,	,	,
18637	19194	7	even	even	RB
18637	19194	8	though	though	IN
18637	19194	9	a	a	DT
18637	19194	10	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19194	11	does	do	VBZ
18637	19194	12	no	no	DT
18637	19194	13	business	business	NN
18637	19194	14	within	within	IN
18637	19194	15	a	a	DT
18637	19194	16	State	State	NNP
18637	19194	17	,	,	,
18637	19194	18	the	the	DT
18637	19194	19	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19194	20	may	may	MD
18637	19194	21	tax	tax	VB
18637	19194	22	the	the	DT
18637	19194	23	profits	profit	NNS
18637	19194	24	realized	realize	VBN
18637	19194	25	by	by	IN
18637	19194	26	the	the	DT
18637	19194	27	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19194	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	19194	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19194	30	sale	sale	NN
18637	19194	31	of	of	IN
18637	19194	32	a	a	DT
18637	19194	33	right	right	JJ
18637	19194	34	appurtenant	appurtenant	NN
18637	19194	35	to	to	IN
18637	19194	36	membership	membership	NN
18637	19194	37	in	in	IN
18637	19194	38	a	a	DT
18637	19194	39	stock	stock	NN
18637	19194	40	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	19194	41	within	within	IN
18637	19194	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19194	43	borders	border	NNS
18637	19194	44	.	.	.
18637	19195	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19195	2	567	567	CD
18637	19195	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19195	4	Incomes	Incomes	NNP
18637	19195	5	of	of	IN
18637	19195	6	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	19195	7	Corporations.--A	corporations.--a	NN
18637	19195	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	19195	9	based	base	VBN
18637	19195	10	on	on	IN
18637	19195	11	the	the	DT
18637	19195	12	income	income	NN
18637	19195	13	of	of	IN
18637	19195	14	a	a	DT
18637	19195	15	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19195	16	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19195	17	may	may	MD
18637	19195	18	be	be	VB
18637	19195	19	determined	determine	VBN
18637	19195	20	by	by	IN
18637	19195	21	allocating	allocate	VBG
18637	19195	22	to	to	IN
18637	19195	23	the	the	DT
18637	19195	24	State	State	NNP
18637	19195	25	a	a	DT
18637	19195	26	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	19195	27	of	of	IN
18637	19195	28	the	the	DT
18637	19195	29	total	total	JJ
18637	19195	30	income	income	NN
18637	19195	31	which	which	WDT
18637	19195	32	the	the	DT
18637	19195	33	tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	19195	34	property	property	NN
18637	19195	35	in	in	IN
18637	19195	36	the	the	DT
18637	19195	37	State	State	NNP
18637	19195	38	bears	bear	VBZ
18637	19195	39	to	to	IN
18637	19195	40	the	the	DT
18637	19195	41	total	total	NN
18637	19195	42	.	.	.
18637	19196	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19196	2	568	568	CD
18637	19196	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19196	4	However	however	RB
18637	19196	5	,	,	,
18637	19196	6	such	such	PDT
18637	19196	7	a	a	DT
18637	19196	8	basis	basis	NN
18637	19196	9	may	may	MD
18637	19196	10	work	work	VB
18637	19196	11	an	an	DT
18637	19196	12	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19196	13	result	result	NN
18637	19196	14	if	if	IN
18637	19196	15	the	the	DT
18637	19196	16	income	income	NN
18637	19196	17	thus	thus	RB
18637	19196	18	attributed	attribute	VBD
18637	19196	19	to	to	IN
18637	19196	20	the	the	DT
18637	19196	21	State	state	NN
18637	19196	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	19196	23	out	out	IN
18637	19196	24	of	of	IN
18637	19196	25	all	all	DT
18637	19196	26	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	19196	27	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	19196	28	to	to	IN
18637	19196	29	the	the	DT
18637	19196	30	business	business	NN
18637	19196	31	there	there	RB
18637	19196	32	transacted	transact	VBN
18637	19196	33	by	by	IN
18637	19196	34	the	the	DT
18637	19196	35	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19196	36	.	.	.
18637	19197	1	Evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19197	2	may	may	MD
18637	19197	3	always	always	RB
18637	19197	4	be	be	VB
18637	19197	5	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	19197	6	which	which	WDT
18637	19197	7	tends	tend	VBZ
18637	19197	8	to	to	TO
18637	19197	9	show	show	VB
18637	19197	10	that	that	IN
18637	19197	11	a	a	DT
18637	19197	12	State	state	NN
18637	19197	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	19197	14	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19197	15	a	a	DT
18637	19197	16	method	method	NN
18637	19197	17	which	which	WDT
18637	19197	18	,	,	,
18637	19197	19	albeit	albeit	IN
18637	19197	20	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19197	21	on	on	IN
18637	19197	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19197	23	face	face	NN
18637	19197	24	,	,	,
18637	19197	25	operates	operate	VBZ
18637	19197	26	so	so	IN
18637	19197	27	as	as	IN
18637	19197	28	to	to	TO
18637	19197	29	reach	reach	VB
18637	19197	30	profits	profit	NNS
18637	19197	31	which	which	WDT
18637	19197	32	are	be	VBP
18637	19197	33	in	in	IN
18637	19197	34	no	no	DT
18637	19197	35	sense	sense	NN
18637	19197	36	attributable	attributable	JJ
18637	19197	37	to	to	IN
18637	19197	38	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	19197	39	within	within	IN
18637	19197	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19197	41	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19197	42	.	.	.
18637	19198	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19198	2	569	569	CD
18637	19198	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19198	4	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	19198	5	,	,	,
18637	19198	6	a	a	DT
18637	19198	7	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19198	8	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19198	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19198	10	in	in	IN
18637	19198	11	error	error	NN
18637	19198	12	when	when	WRB
18637	19198	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19198	14	contends	contend	VBZ
18637	19198	15	that	that	IN
18637	19198	16	due	due	JJ
18637	19198	17	process	process	NN
18637	19198	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	19198	19	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19198	20	by	by	IN
18637	19198	21	a	a	DT
18637	19198	22	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	19198	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	19198	24	measured	measure	VBN
18637	19198	25	by	by	IN
18637	19198	26	income	income	NN
18637	19198	27	,	,	,
18637	19198	28	which	which	WDT
18637	19198	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	19198	30	levied	levy	VBN
18637	19198	31	,	,	,
18637	19198	32	not	not	RB
18637	19198	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	19198	34	net	net	JJ
18637	19198	35	income	income	NN
18637	19198	36	from	from	IN
18637	19198	37	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	19198	38	business	business	NN
18637	19198	39	alone	alone	RB
18637	19198	40	,	,	,
18637	19198	41	but	but	CC
18637	19198	42	on	on	IN
18637	19198	43	net	net	JJ
18637	19198	44	income	income	NN
18637	19198	45	justly	justly	RB
18637	19198	46	attributable	attributable	JJ
18637	19198	47	to	to	IN
18637	19198	48	all	all	DT
18637	19198	49	classes	class	NNS
18637	19198	50	of	of	IN
18637	19198	51	business	business	NN
18637	19198	52	done	do	VBN
18637	19198	53	within	within	IN
18637	19198	54	the	the	DT
18637	19198	55	State	State	NNP
18637	19198	56	,	,	,
18637	19198	57	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	19198	58	and	and	CC
18637	19198	59	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19198	60	,	,	,
18637	19198	61	as	as	RB
18637	19198	62	well	well	RB
18637	19198	63	as	as	IN
18637	19198	64	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	19198	65	business	business	NN
18637	19198	66	.	.	.
18637	19199	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19199	2	570	570	CD
18637	19199	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19199	4	Inasmuch	Inasmuch	NNP
18637	19199	5	as	as	IN
18637	19199	6	the	the	DT
18637	19199	7	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19199	8	granted	grant	VBN
18637	19199	9	by	by	IN
18637	19199	10	a	a	DT
18637	19199	11	State	state	NN
18637	19199	12	to	to	IN
18637	19199	13	a	a	DT
18637	19199	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19199	15	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19199	16	of	of	IN
18637	19199	17	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	19199	18	on	on	IN
18637	19199	19	local	local	JJ
18637	19199	20	business	business	NN
18637	19199	21	supports	support	VBZ
18637	19199	22	a	a	DT
18637	19199	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	19199	24	by	by	IN
18637	19199	25	that	that	DT
18637	19199	26	State	state	NN
18637	19199	27	on	on	IN
18637	19199	28	the	the	DT
18637	19199	29	income	income	NN
18637	19199	30	derived	derive	VBN
18637	19199	31	from	from	IN
18637	19199	32	that	that	DT
18637	19199	33	business	business	NN
18637	19199	34	,	,	,
18637	19199	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19199	36	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	19199	37	that	that	IN
18637	19199	38	the	the	DT
18637	19199	39	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	19199	40	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19199	41	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	19199	42	tax	tax	NN
18637	19199	43	,	,	,
18637	19199	44	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	19199	45	with	with	IN
18637	19199	46	the	the	DT
18637	19199	47	due	due	JJ
18637	19199	48	process	process	NN
18637	19199	49	clause	clause	NN
18637	19199	50	,	,	,
18637	19199	51	may	may	MD
18637	19199	52	be	be	VB
18637	19199	53	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19199	54	to	to	IN
18637	19199	55	a	a	DT
18637	19199	56	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	19199	57	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19199	58	,	,	,
18637	19199	59	having	have	VBG
18637	19199	60	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19199	61	principal	principal	JJ
18637	19199	62	offices	office	NNS
18637	19199	63	in	in	IN
18637	19199	64	New	New	NNP
18637	19199	65	York	York	NNP
18637	19199	66	,	,	,
18637	19199	67	holding	hold	VBG
18637	19199	68	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19199	69	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	19199	70	and	and	CC
18637	19199	71	voting	vote	VBG
18637	19199	72	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19199	73	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	19199	74	in	in	IN
18637	19199	75	New	New	NNP
18637	19199	76	York	York	NNP
18637	19199	77	,	,	,
18637	19199	78	and	and	CC
18637	19199	79	drawing	draw	VBG
18637	19199	80	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19199	81	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	19199	82	checks	check	NNS
18637	19199	83	on	on	IN
18637	19199	84	New	New	NNP
18637	19199	85	York	York	NNP
18637	19199	86	bank	bank	NN
18637	19199	87	accounts	account	NNS
18637	19199	88	.	.	.
18637	19200	1	The	the	DT
18637	19200	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	19200	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	19200	4	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19200	5	on	on	IN
18637	19200	6	the	the	DT
18637	19200	7	"	"	``
18637	19200	8	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19200	9	of	of	IN
18637	19200	10	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	19200	11	and	and	CC
18637	19200	12	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	19200	13	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	19200	14	"	"	''
18637	19200	15	out	out	IN
18637	19200	16	of	of	IN
18637	19200	17	income	income	NN
18637	19200	18	derived	derive	VBN
18637	19200	19	from	from	IN
18637	19200	20	property	property	NN
18637	19200	21	located	locate	VBN
18637	19200	22	and	and	CC
18637	19200	23	business	business	NN
18637	19200	24	transacted	transact	VBN
18637	19200	25	in	in	IN
18637	19200	26	the	the	DT
18637	19200	27	State	State	NNP
18637	19200	28	,	,	,
18637	19200	29	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19200	30	to	to	IN
18637	19200	31	a	a	DT
18637	19200	32	specified	specified	JJ
18637	19200	33	percentage	percentage	NN
18637	19200	34	of	of	IN
18637	19200	35	such	such	JJ
18637	19200	36	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	19200	37	,	,	,
18637	19200	38	the	the	DT
18637	19200	39	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19200	40	being	be	VBG
18637	19200	41	required	require	VBN
18637	19200	42	to	to	TO
18637	19200	43	deduct	deduct	VB
18637	19200	44	the	the	DT
18637	19200	45	tax	tax	NN
18637	19200	46	from	from	IN
18637	19200	47	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	19200	48	payable	payable	JJ
18637	19200	49	to	to	IN
18637	19200	50	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19200	51	and	and	CC
18637	19200	52	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19200	53	shareholders	shareholder	NNS
18637	19200	54	and	and	CC
18637	19200	55	pay	pay	VB
18637	19200	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19200	57	over	over	RP
18637	19200	58	to	to	IN
18637	19200	59	the	the	DT
18637	19200	60	State	State	NNP
18637	19200	61	.	.	.
18637	19201	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19201	2	571	571	CD
18637	19201	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19201	4	Chain	Chain	NNP
18637	19201	5	Store	Store	NNP
18637	19201	6	Taxes.--A	taxes.--a	CD
18637	19201	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	19201	8	on	on	IN
18637	19201	9	chain	chain	NN
18637	19201	10	stores	store	NNS
18637	19201	11	,	,	,
18637	19201	12	at	at	IN
18637	19201	13	a	a	DT
18637	19201	14	rate	rate	NN
18637	19201	15	per	per	IN
18637	19201	16	store	store	NN
18637	19201	17	determined	determine	VBN
18637	19201	18	by	by	IN
18637	19201	19	the	the	DT
18637	19201	20	number	number	NN
18637	19201	21	of	of	IN
18637	19201	22	stores	store	NNS
18637	19201	23	both	both	CC
18637	19201	24	within	within	IN
18637	19201	25	and	and	CC
18637	19201	26	without	without	IN
18637	19201	27	the	the	DT
18637	19201	28	State	State	NNP
18637	19201	29	,	,	,
18637	19201	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	19201	31	not	not	RB
18637	19201	32	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19201	33	as	as	IN
18637	19201	34	a	a	DT
18637	19201	35	tax	tax	NN
18637	19201	36	in	in	IN
18637	19201	37	part	part	NN
18637	19201	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	19201	39	things	thing	NNS
18637	19201	40	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19201	41	the	the	DT
18637	19201	42	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19201	43	of	of	IN
18637	19201	44	the	the	DT
18637	19201	45	State	State	NNP
18637	19201	46	.	.	.
18637	19202	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19202	2	572	572	CD
18637	19202	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19202	4	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	19202	5	Company	Company	NNP
18637	19202	6	Taxes.--A	taxes.--a	NN
18637	19202	7	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19202	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	19202	9	on	on	IN
18637	19202	10	the	the	DT
18637	19202	11	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19202	12	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	19202	13	received	receive	VBN
18637	19202	14	by	by	IN
18637	19202	15	a	a	DT
18637	19202	16	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19202	17	life	life	NN
18637	19202	18	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19202	19	company	company	NN
18637	19202	20	at	at	IN
18637	19202	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19202	22	home	home	NN
18637	19202	23	office	office	NN
18637	19202	24	for	for	IN
18637	19202	25	business	business	NN
18637	19202	26	written	write	VBN
18637	19202	27	in	in	IN
18637	19202	28	the	the	DT
18637	19202	29	State	state	NN
18637	19202	30	does	do	VBZ
18637	19202	31	not	not	RB
18637	19202	32	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	19202	33	the	the	DT
18637	19202	34	company	company	NN
18637	19202	35	of	of	IN
18637	19202	36	property	property	NN
18637	19202	37	without	without	IN
18637	19202	38	due	due	JJ
18637	19202	39	process;[573	process;[573	NNPS
18637	19202	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19202	41	but	but	CC
18637	19202	42	a	a	DT
18637	19202	43	tax	tax	NN
18637	19202	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	19202	45	bad	bad	JJ
18637	19202	46	when	when	WRB
18637	19202	47	the	the	DT
18637	19202	48	company	company	NN
18637	19202	49	has	have	VBZ
18637	19202	50	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	19202	51	all	all	PDT
18637	19202	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19202	53	agents	agent	NNS
18637	19202	54	from	from	IN
18637	19202	55	the	the	DT
18637	19202	56	State	State	NNP
18637	19202	57	and	and	CC
18637	19202	58	has	have	VBZ
18637	19202	59	ceased	cease	VBN
18637	19202	60	to	to	TO
18637	19202	61	do	do	VB
18637	19202	62	business	business	NN
18637	19202	63	,	,	,
18637	19202	64	merely	merely	RB
18637	19202	65	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	19202	66	to	to	TO
18637	19202	67	be	be	VB
18637	19202	68	bound	bind	VBN
18637	19202	69	to	to	IN
18637	19202	70	policyholders	policyholder	NNS
18637	19202	71	resident	resident	VB
18637	19202	72	therein	therein	RB
18637	19202	73	and	and	CC
18637	19202	74	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	19202	75	at	at	IN
18637	19202	76	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19202	77	home	home	NN
18637	19202	78	office	office	NN
18637	19202	79	the	the	DT
18637	19202	80	renewal	renewal	NN
18637	19202	81	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	19202	82	.	.	.
18637	19203	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19203	2	574	574	CD
18637	19203	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19203	4	Distinguishable	distinguishable	JJ
18637	19203	5	therefrom	therefrom	NN
18637	19203	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19203	7	the	the	DT
18637	19203	8	following	follow	VBG
18637	19203	9	tax	tax	NN
18637	19203	10	which	which	WDT
18637	19203	11	was	be	VBD
18637	19203	12	construed	construe	VBN
18637	19203	13	as	as	IN
18637	19203	14	having	have	VBG
18637	19203	15	been	be	VBN
18637	19203	16	levied	levy	VBN
18637	19203	17	,	,	,
18637	19203	18	not	not	RB
18637	19203	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	19203	20	annual	annual	JJ
18637	19203	21	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	19203	22	nor	nor	CC
18637	19203	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	19203	24	the	the	DT
18637	19203	25	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19203	26	merely	merely	RB
18637	19203	27	of	of	IN
18637	19203	28	doing	do	VBG
18637	19203	29	business	business	NN
18637	19203	30	during	during	IN
18637	19203	31	the	the	DT
18637	19203	32	period	period	NN
18637	19203	33	that	that	IN
18637	19203	34	the	the	DT
18637	19203	35	company	company	NN
18637	19203	36	actually	actually	RB
18637	19203	37	was	be	VBD
18637	19203	38	within	within	IN
18637	19203	39	the	the	DT
18637	19203	40	State	State	NNP
18637	19203	41	,	,	,
18637	19203	42	but	but	CC
18637	19203	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	19203	44	the	the	DT
18637	19203	45	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19203	46	of	of	IN
18637	19203	47	entering	enter	VBG
18637	19203	48	and	and	CC
18637	19203	49	engaging	engage	VBG
18637	19203	50	in	in	IN
18637	19203	51	business	business	NN
18637	19203	52	,	,	,
18637	19203	53	the	the	DT
18637	19203	54	percentage	percentage	NN
18637	19203	55	"	"	''
18637	19203	56	on	on	IN
18637	19203	57	the	the	DT
18637	19203	58	annual	annual	JJ
18637	19203	59	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	19203	60	_	_	NNP
18637	19203	61	to	to	TO
18637	19203	62	be	be	VB
18637	19203	63	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19203	64	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	19203	65	the	the	DT
18637	19203	66	life	life	NN
18637	19203	67	of	of	IN
18637	19203	68	the	the	DT
18637	19203	69	policies	policy	NNS
18637	19203	70	issued	issue	VBN
18637	19203	71	_	_	NNP
18637	19203	72	.	.	.
18637	19203	73	"	"	''
18637	19204	1	By	by	IN
18637	19204	2	reason	reason	NN
18637	19204	3	of	of	IN
18637	19204	4	this	this	DT
18637	19204	5	difference	difference	NN
18637	19204	6	a	a	DT
18637	19204	7	State	state	NN
18637	19204	8	may	may	MD
18637	19204	9	continue	continue	VB
18637	19204	10	to	to	TO
18637	19204	11	collect	collect	VB
18637	19204	12	such	such	JJ
18637	19204	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	19204	14	even	even	RB
18637	19204	15	after	after	IN
18637	19204	16	the	the	DT
18637	19204	17	company	company	NN
18637	19204	18	's	's	POS
18637	19204	19	withdrawal	withdrawal	NN
18637	19204	20	from	from	IN
18637	19204	21	the	the	DT
18637	19204	22	State	State	NNP
18637	19204	23	.	.	.
18637	19205	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19205	2	575	575	CD
18637	19205	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19205	4	A	a	DT
18637	19205	5	State	state	NN
18637	19205	6	which	which	WDT
18637	19205	7	taxes	tax	VBZ
18637	19205	8	the	the	DT
18637	19205	9	insuring	insuring	NN
18637	19205	10	of	of	IN
18637	19205	11	property	property	NN
18637	19205	12	within	within	IN
18637	19205	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19205	14	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19205	15	may	may	MD
18637	19205	16	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	19205	17	extend	extend	VB
18637	19205	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19205	19	tax	tax	NN
18637	19205	20	to	to	IN
18637	19205	21	a	a	DT
18637	19205	22	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19205	23	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19205	24	company	company	NN
18637	19205	25	which	which	WDT
18637	19205	26	contracts	contract	VBZ
18637	19205	27	with	with	IN
18637	19205	28	an	an	DT
18637	19205	29	automobile	automobile	NN
18637	19205	30	sales	sale	NNS
18637	19205	31	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19205	32	in	in	IN
18637	19205	33	a	a	DT
18637	19205	34	third	third	JJ
18637	19205	35	State	State	NNP
18637	19205	36	to	to	TO
18637	19205	37	insure	insure	VB
18637	19205	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19205	39	customers	customer	NNS
18637	19205	40	against	against	IN
18637	19205	41	loss	loss	NN
18637	19205	42	of	of	IN
18637	19205	43	cars	car	NNS
18637	19205	44	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	19205	45	through	through	IN
18637	19205	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19205	47	,	,	,
18637	19205	48	so	so	RB
18637	19205	49	far	far	RB
18637	19205	50	as	as	IN
18637	19205	51	the	the	DT
18637	19205	52	cars	car	NNS
18637	19205	53	go	go	VBP
18637	19205	54	into	into	IN
18637	19205	55	possession	possession	NN
18637	19205	56	of	of	IN
18637	19205	57	purchasers	purchaser	NNS
18637	19205	58	within	within	IN
18637	19205	59	the	the	DT
18637	19205	60	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19205	61	State	state	NN
18637	19205	62	.	.	.
18637	19206	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19206	2	576	576	CD
18637	19206	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19206	4	On	on	IN
18637	19206	5	the	the	DT
18637	19206	6	other	other	JJ
18637	19206	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	19206	8	,	,	,
18637	19206	9	a	a	DT
18637	19206	10	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19206	11	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19206	12	admitted	admit	VBD
18637	19206	13	to	to	TO
18637	19206	14	do	do	VB
18637	19206	15	a	a	DT
18637	19206	16	local	local	JJ
18637	19206	17	business	business	NN
18637	19206	18	,	,	,
18637	19206	19	which	which	WDT
18637	19206	20	insures	insure	VBZ
18637	19206	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19206	22	property	property	NN
18637	19206	23	with	with	IN
18637	19206	24	insurers	insurer	NNS
18637	19206	25	in	in	IN
18637	19206	26	other	other	JJ
18637	19206	27	States	state	NNS
18637	19206	28	who	who	WP
18637	19206	29	are	be	VBP
18637	19206	30	not	not	RB
18637	19206	31	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	19206	32	to	to	TO
18637	19206	33	do	do	VB
18637	19206	34	business	business	NN
18637	19206	35	in	in	IN
18637	19206	36	the	the	DT
18637	19206	37	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19206	38	State	state	NN
18637	19206	39	,	,	,
18637	19206	40	can	can	MD
18637	19206	41	not	not	RB
18637	19206	42	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	19206	43	be	be	VB
18637	19206	44	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	19206	45	to	to	IN
18637	19206	46	a	a	DT
18637	19206	47	5	5	CD
18637	19206	48	%	%	NN
18637	19206	49	tax	tax	NN
18637	19206	50	on	on	IN
18637	19206	51	the	the	DT
18637	19206	52	amount	amount	NN
18637	19206	53	of	of	IN
18637	19206	54	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	19206	55	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19206	56	for	for	IN
18637	19206	57	such	such	JJ
18637	19206	58	coverage	coverage	NN
18637	19206	59	.	.	.
18637	19207	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19207	2	577	577	CD
18637	19207	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19207	4	Likewise	Likewise	NNP
18637	19207	5	a	a	DT
18637	19207	6	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	19207	7	life	life	NN
18637	19207	8	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19207	9	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19207	10	,	,	,
18637	19207	11	licensed	license	VBN
18637	19207	12	to	to	TO
18637	19207	13	do	do	VB
18637	19207	14	business	business	NN
18637	19207	15	in	in	IN
18637	19207	16	California	California	NNP
18637	19207	17	,	,	,
18637	19207	18	which	which	WDT
18637	19207	19	negotiated	negotiate	VBD
18637	19207	20	reinsurance	reinsurance	NN
18637	19207	21	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	19207	22	in	in	IN
18637	19207	23	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	19207	24	,	,	,
18637	19207	25	received	receive	VBD
18637	19207	26	payment	payment	NN
18637	19207	27	of	of	IN
18637	19207	28	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	19207	29	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	19207	30	in	in	IN
18637	19207	31	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	19207	32	,	,	,
18637	19207	33	and	and	CC
18637	19207	34	was	be	VBD
18637	19207	35	there	there	RB
18637	19207	36	liable	liable	JJ
18637	19207	37	for	for	IN
18637	19207	38	payment	payment	NN
18637	19207	39	of	of	IN
18637	19207	40	losses	loss	NNS
18637	19207	41	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	19207	42	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	19207	43	,	,	,
18637	19207	44	can	can	MD
18637	19207	45	not	not	RB
18637	19207	46	be	be	VB
18637	19207	47	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	19207	48	by	by	IN
18637	19207	49	California	California	NNP
18637	19207	50	to	to	IN
18637	19207	51	a	a	DT
18637	19207	52	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19207	53	tax	tax	NN
18637	19207	54	measured	measure	VBN
18637	19207	55	by	by	IN
18637	19207	56	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19207	57	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	19207	58	derived	derive	VBN
18637	19207	59	from	from	IN
18637	19207	60	such	such	JJ
18637	19207	61	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	19207	62	,	,	,
18637	19207	63	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19207	64	that	that	IN
18637	19207	65	the	the	DT
18637	19207	66	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	19207	67	reinsured	reinsure	VBD
18637	19207	68	other	other	JJ
18637	19207	69	insurers	insurer	NNS
18637	19207	70	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	19207	71	to	to	TO
18637	19207	72	do	do	VB
18637	19207	73	business	business	NN
18637	19207	74	in	in	IN
18637	19207	75	California	California	NNP
18637	19207	76	and	and	CC
18637	19207	77	protected	protect	VBN
18637	19207	78	policies	policy	NNS
18637	19207	79	effected	effect	VBN
18637	19207	80	in	in	IN
18637	19207	81	California	California	NNP
18637	19207	82	on	on	IN
18637	19207	83	the	the	DT
18637	19207	84	lives	life	NNS
18637	19207	85	of	of	IN
18637	19207	86	residents	resident	NNS
18637	19207	87	therein	therein	RB
18637	19207	88	.	.	.
18637	19208	1	The	the	DT
18637	19208	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	19208	3	can	can	MD
18637	19208	4	not	not	RB
18637	19208	5	be	be	VB
18637	19208	6	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	19208	7	whether	whether	IN
18637	19208	8	as	as	RB
18637	19208	9	laid	lay	VBN
18637	19208	10	on	on	IN
18637	19208	11	property	property	NN
18637	19208	12	,	,	,
18637	19208	13	business	business	NN
18637	19208	14	done	do	VBN
18637	19208	15	,	,	,
18637	19208	16	or	or	CC
18637	19208	17	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	19208	18	carried	carry	VBN
18637	19208	19	on	on	RP
18637	19208	20	,	,	,
18637	19208	21	within	within	IN
18637	19208	22	California	California	NNP
18637	19208	23	,	,	,
18637	19208	24	or	or	CC
18637	19208	25	as	as	IN
18637	19208	26	a	a	DT
18637	19208	27	tax	tax	NN
18637	19208	28	on	on	IN
18637	19208	29	a	a	DT
18637	19208	30	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19208	31	granted	grant	VBN
18637	19208	32	by	by	IN
18637	19208	33	that	that	DT
18637	19208	34	State	State	NNP
18637	19208	35	.	.	.
18637	19209	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19209	2	578	578	CD
18637	19209	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19209	4	When	when	WRB
18637	19209	5	policy	policy	NN
18637	19209	6	loans	loan	NNS
18637	19209	7	to	to	IN
18637	19209	8	residents	resident	NNS
18637	19209	9	are	be	VBP
18637	19209	10	made	make	VBN
18637	19209	11	by	by	IN
18637	19209	12	a	a	DT
18637	19209	13	local	local	JJ
18637	19209	14	agent	agent	NN
18637	19209	15	of	of	IN
18637	19209	16	a	a	DT
18637	19209	17	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19209	18	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19209	19	company	company	NN
18637	19209	20	,	,	,
18637	19209	21	in	in	IN
18637	19209	22	the	the	DT
18637	19209	23	servicing	servicing	NN
18637	19209	24	of	of	IN
18637	19209	25	which	which	WDT
18637	19209	26	notes	note	NNS
18637	19209	27	are	be	VBP
18637	19209	28	signed	sign	VBN
18637	19209	29	,	,	,
18637	19209	30	security	security	NN
18637	19209	31	taken	take	VBN
18637	19209	32	,	,	,
18637	19209	33	interest	interest	NN
18637	19209	34	collected	collect	VBN
18637	19209	35	,	,	,
18637	19209	36	and	and	CC
18637	19209	37	debts	debt	NNS
18637	19209	38	are	be	VBP
18637	19209	39	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19209	40	within	within	IN
18637	19209	41	the	the	DT
18637	19209	42	State	State	NNP
18637	19209	43	,	,	,
18637	19209	44	such	such	JJ
18637	19209	45	credits	credit	NNS
18637	19209	46	are	be	VBP
18637	19209	47	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	19209	48	to	to	IN
18637	19209	49	the	the	DT
18637	19209	50	company	company	NN
18637	19209	51	,	,	,
18637	19209	52	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19209	53	that	that	IN
18637	19209	54	the	the	DT
18637	19209	55	promissory	promissory	JJ
18637	19209	56	notes	note	NNS
18637	19209	57	evidencing	evidence	VBG
18637	19209	58	such	such	JJ
18637	19209	59	credits	credit	NNS
18637	19209	60	are	be	VBP
18637	19209	61	kept	keep	VBN
18637	19209	62	at	at	IN
18637	19209	63	the	the	DT
18637	19209	64	home	home	NN
18637	19209	65	office	office	NN
18637	19209	66	of	of	IN
18637	19209	67	the	the	DT
18637	19209	68	insurer	insurer	NN
18637	19209	69	.	.	.
18637	19210	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19210	2	579	579	CD
18637	19210	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19210	4	But	but	CC
18637	19210	5	when	when	WRB
18637	19210	6	a	a	DT
18637	19210	7	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19210	8	policyholder	policyholder	NN
18637	19210	9	's	's	POS
18637	19210	10	loan	loan	NN
18637	19210	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	19210	12	merely	merely	RB
18637	19210	13	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19210	14	against	against	IN
18637	19210	15	the	the	DT
18637	19210	16	reserve	reserve	NN
18637	19210	17	value	value	NN
18637	19210	18	of	of	IN
18637	19210	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19210	20	policy	policy	NN
18637	19210	21	,	,	,
18637	19210	22	under	under	IN
18637	19210	23	an	an	DT
18637	19210	24	arrangement	arrangement	NN
18637	19210	25	for	for	IN
18637	19210	26	extinguishing	extinguish	VBG
18637	19210	27	the	the	DT
18637	19210	28	debt	debt	NN
18637	19210	29	and	and	CC
18637	19210	30	interest	interest	NN
18637	19210	31	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	19210	32	by	by	IN
18637	19210	33	deduction	deduction	NN
18637	19210	34	from	from	IN
18637	19210	35	any	any	DT
18637	19210	36	claim	claim	NN
18637	19210	37	under	under	IN
18637	19210	38	the	the	DT
18637	19210	39	policy	policy	NN
18637	19210	40	,	,	,
18637	19210	41	such	such	JJ
18637	19210	42	credit	credit	NN
18637	19210	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	19210	44	not	not	RB
18637	19210	45	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	19210	46	to	to	IN
18637	19210	47	the	the	DT
18637	19210	48	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19210	49	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19210	50	company	company	NN
18637	19210	51	.	.	.
18637	19211	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19211	2	580	580	CD
18637	19211	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19211	4	Premiums	premium	NNS
18637	19211	5	due	due	JJ
18637	19211	6	from	from	IN
18637	19211	7	residents	resident	NNS
18637	19211	8	on	on	IN
18637	19211	9	which	which	WDT
18637	19211	10	an	an	DT
18637	19211	11	extension	extension	NN
18637	19211	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	19211	13	been	be	VBN
18637	19211	14	granted	grant	VBN
18637	19211	15	by	by	IN
18637	19211	16	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19211	17	companies	company	NNS
18637	19211	18	also	also	RB
18637	19211	19	are	be	VBP
18637	19211	20	credits	credit	NNS
18637	19211	21	on	on	IN
18637	19211	22	which	which	WDT
18637	19211	23	the	the	DT
18637	19211	24	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19211	25	may	may	MD
18637	19211	26	be	be	VB
18637	19211	27	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19211	28	by	by	IN
18637	19211	29	the	the	DT
18637	19211	30	State	State	NNP
18637	19211	31	of	of	IN
18637	19211	32	the	the	DT
18637	19211	33	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	19211	34	's	's	POS
18637	19211	35	domicile;[581	domicile;[581	NN
18637	19211	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19211	37	and	and	CC
18637	19211	38	the	the	DT
18637	19211	39	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19211	40	fact	fact	NN
18637	19211	41	that	that	IN
18637	19211	42	the	the	DT
18637	19211	43	insurers	insurer	NNS
18637	19211	44	charge	charge	VBP
18637	19211	45	these	these	DT
18637	19211	46	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	19211	47	to	to	IN
18637	19211	48	local	local	JJ
18637	19211	49	agents	agent	NNS
18637	19211	50	and	and	CC
18637	19211	51	give	give	VB
18637	19211	52	no	no	DT
18637	19211	53	credit	credit	NN
18637	19211	54	directly	directly	RB
18637	19211	55	to	to	IN
18637	19211	56	policyholders	policyholder	NNS
18637	19211	57	does	do	VBZ
18637	19211	58	not	not	RB
18637	19211	59	enable	enable	VB
18637	19211	60	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19211	61	to	to	TO
18637	19211	62	escape	escape	VB
18637	19211	63	this	this	DT
18637	19211	64	tax	tax	NN
18637	19211	65	.	.	.
18637	19212	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19212	2	582	582	CD
18637	19212	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19212	4	PROCEDURE	PROCEDURE	NNP
18637	19212	5	IN	in	IN
18637	19212	6	TAXATION	TAXATION	NNP
18637	19212	7	In	in	IN
18637	19212	8	General	General	NNP
18637	19212	9	Exactly	exactly	RB
18637	19212	10	what	what	WP
18637	19212	11	due	due	JJ
18637	19212	12	process	process	NN
18637	19212	13	requires	require	VBZ
18637	19212	14	in	in	IN
18637	19212	15	the	the	DT
18637	19212	16	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19212	17	and	and	CC
18637	19212	18	collection	collection	NN
18637	19212	19	of	of	IN
18637	19212	20	general	general	JJ
18637	19212	21	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19212	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	19212	23	never	never	RB
18637	19212	24	been	be	VBN
18637	19212	25	decided	decide	VBN
18637	19212	26	by	by	IN
18637	19212	27	the	the	DT
18637	19212	28	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19212	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19212	30	.	.	.
18637	19213	1	While	while	IN
18637	19213	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19213	3	was	be	VBD
18637	19213	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	19213	5	that	that	IN
18637	19213	6	"	"	``
18637	19213	7	notice	notice	VB
18637	19213	8	to	to	IN
18637	19213	9	the	the	DT
18637	19213	10	owner	owner	NN
18637	19213	11	at	at	IN
18637	19213	12	some	some	DT
18637	19213	13	stage	stage	NN
18637	19213	14	of	of	IN
18637	19213	15	the	the	DT
18637	19213	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19213	17	,	,	,
18637	19213	18	as	as	RB
18637	19213	19	well	well	RB
18637	19213	20	as	as	IN
18637	19213	21	an	an	DT
18637	19213	22	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19213	23	to	to	TO
18637	19213	24	defend	defend	VB
18637	19213	25	,	,	,
18637	19213	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	19213	27	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19213	28	"	"	''
18637	19213	29	for	for	IN
18637	19213	30	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	19213	31	of	of	IN
18637	19213	32	special	special	JJ
18637	19213	33	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19213	34	,	,	,
18637	19213	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19213	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	19213	37	also	also	RB
18637	19213	38	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	19213	39	that	that	IN
18637	19213	40	laws	law	NNS
18637	19213	41	for	for	IN
18637	19213	42	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19213	43	and	and	CC
18637	19213	44	collection	collection	NN
18637	19213	45	of	of	IN
18637	19213	46	general	general	JJ
18637	19213	47	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19213	48	stand	stand	VBP
18637	19213	49	upon	upon	IN
18637	19213	50	a	a	DT
18637	19213	51	different	different	JJ
18637	19213	52	footing	footing	NN
18637	19213	53	and	and	CC
18637	19213	54	are	be	VBP
18637	19213	55	to	to	TO
18637	19213	56	be	be	VB
18637	19213	57	construed	construe	VBN
18637	19213	58	with	with	IN
18637	19213	59	the	the	DT
18637	19213	60	utmost	utmost	JJ
18637	19213	61	liberality	liberality	NN
18637	19213	62	,	,	,
18637	19213	63	even	even	RB
18637	19213	64	to	to	IN
18637	19213	65	the	the	DT
18637	19213	66	extent	extent	NN
18637	19213	67	of	of	IN
18637	19213	68	acknowledging	acknowledge	VBG
18637	19213	69	that	that	IN
18637	19213	70	no	no	DT
18637	19213	71	notice	notice	NN
18637	19213	72	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	19213	73	is	be	VBZ
18637	19213	74	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19213	75	.	.	.
18637	19214	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19214	2	583	583	CD
18637	19214	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19214	4	Due	due	JJ
18637	19214	5	process	process	NN
18637	19214	6	of	of	IN
18637	19214	7	law	law	NN
18637	19214	8	as	as	IN
18637	19214	9	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19214	10	to	to	IN
18637	19214	11	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19214	12	does	do	VBZ
18637	19214	13	not	not	RB
18637	19214	14	mean	mean	VB
18637	19214	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19214	16	process;[584	process;[584	NNS
18637	19214	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19214	18	neither	neither	CC
18637	19214	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	19214	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19214	21	require	require	VB
18637	19214	22	the	the	DT
18637	19214	23	same	same	JJ
18637	19214	24	kind	kind	NN
18637	19214	25	of	of	IN
18637	19214	26	notice	notice	NN
18637	19214	27	as	as	IN
18637	19214	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	19214	29	required	require	VBN
18637	19214	30	in	in	IN
18637	19214	31	a	a	DT
18637	19214	32	suit	suit	NN
18637	19214	33	at	at	IN
18637	19214	34	law	law	NN
18637	19214	35	,	,	,
18637	19214	36	or	or	CC
18637	19214	37	even	even	RB
18637	19214	38	in	in	IN
18637	19214	39	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19214	40	for	for	IN
18637	19214	41	taking	take	VBG
18637	19214	42	private	private	JJ
18637	19214	43	property	property	NN
18637	19214	44	under	under	IN
18637	19214	45	the	the	DT
18637	19214	46	power	power	NN
18637	19214	47	of	of	IN
18637	19214	48	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	19214	49	domain	domain	NN
18637	19214	50	.	.	.
18637	19215	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19215	2	585	585	CD
18637	19215	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19215	4	If	if	IN
18637	19215	5	a	a	DT
18637	19215	6	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	19215	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19215	8	given	give	VBN
18637	19215	9	an	an	DT
18637	19215	10	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19215	11	to	to	TO
18637	19215	12	test	test	VB
18637	19215	13	the	the	DT
18637	19215	14	validity	validity	NN
18637	19215	15	of	of	IN
18637	19215	16	a	a	DT
18637	19215	17	tax	tax	NN
18637	19215	18	at	at	IN
18637	19215	19	any	any	DT
18637	19215	20	time	time	NN
18637	19215	21	before	before	IN
18637	19215	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19215	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	19215	24	final	final	JJ
18637	19215	25	,	,	,
18637	19215	26	whether	whether	IN
18637	19215	27	the	the	DT
18637	19215	28	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19215	29	for	for	IN
18637	19215	30	review	review	NN
18637	19215	31	take	take	VB
18637	19215	32	place	place	NN
18637	19215	33	before	before	IN
18637	19215	34	a	a	DT
18637	19215	35	board	board	NN
18637	19215	36	having	have	VBG
18637	19215	37	a	a	DT
18637	19215	38	quasi	quasi	JJ
18637	19215	39	-	-	JJ
18637	19215	40	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19215	41	character	character	NN
18637	19215	42	,	,	,
18637	19215	43	or	or	CC
18637	19215	44	before	before	IN
18637	19215	45	a	a	DT
18637	19215	46	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	19215	47	provided	provide	VBN
18637	19215	48	by	by	IN
18637	19215	49	the	the	DT
18637	19215	50	State	State	NNP
18637	19215	51	for	for	IN
18637	19215	52	the	the	DT
18637	19215	53	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	19215	54	of	of	IN
18637	19215	55	determining	determine	VBG
18637	19215	56	such	such	JJ
18637	19215	57	questions	question	NNS
18637	19215	58	,	,	,
18637	19215	59	due	due	JJ
18637	19215	60	process	process	NN
18637	19215	61	of	of	IN
18637	19215	62	law	law	NN
18637	19215	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	19215	64	not	not	RB
18637	19215	65	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19215	66	.	.	.
18637	19216	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19216	2	586	586	CD
18637	19216	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19216	4	Notice	Notice	NNP
18637	19216	5	and	and	CC
18637	19216	6	Hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19216	7	in	in	IN
18637	19216	8	Relation	Relation	NNP
18637	19216	9	to	to	IN
18637	19216	10	General	General	NNP
18637	19216	11	Taxes	Taxes	NNP
18637	19216	12	"	"	''
18637	19216	13	Of	of	IN
18637	19216	14	the	the	DT
18637	19216	15	different	different	JJ
18637	19216	16	kinds	kind	NNS
18637	19216	17	of	of	IN
18637	19216	18	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19216	19	which	which	WDT
18637	19216	20	the	the	DT
18637	19216	21	State	State	NNP
18637	19216	22	may	may	MD
18637	19216	23	impose	impose	VB
18637	19216	24	,	,	,
18637	19216	25	there	there	EX
18637	19216	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	19216	27	a	a	DT
18637	19216	28	vast	vast	JJ
18637	19216	29	number	number	NN
18637	19216	30	of	of	IN
18637	19216	31	which	which	WDT
18637	19216	32	,	,	,
18637	19216	33	from	from	IN
18637	19216	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19216	35	nature	nature	NN
18637	19216	36	,	,	,
18637	19216	37	no	no	DT
18637	19216	38	notice	notice	NN
18637	19216	39	can	can	MD
18637	19216	40	be	be	VB
18637	19216	41	given	give	VBN
18637	19216	42	to	to	IN
18637	19216	43	the	the	DT
18637	19216	44	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	19216	45	,	,	,
18637	19216	46	nor	nor	CC
18637	19216	47	would	would	MD
18637	19216	48	notice	notice	VB
18637	19216	49	be	be	VB
18637	19216	50	of	of	IN
18637	19216	51	any	any	DT
18637	19216	52	possible	possible	JJ
18637	19216	53	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	19216	54	to	to	IN
18637	19216	55	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19216	56	,	,	,
18637	19216	57	such	such	JJ
18637	19216	58	as	as	IN
18637	19216	59	poll	poll	JJ
18637	19216	60	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19216	61	,	,	,
18637	19216	62	license	license	NN
18637	19216	63	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19216	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19216	65	not	not	RB
18637	19216	66	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	19216	67	upon	upon	IN
18637	19216	68	the	the	DT
18637	19216	69	extent	extent	NN
18637	19216	70	of	of	IN
18637	19216	71	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19216	72	business	business	NN
18637	19216	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19216	74	,	,	,
18637	19216	75	and	and	CC
18637	19216	76	generally	generally	RB
18637	19216	77	,	,	,
18637	19216	78	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19216	79	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19216	80	on	on	IN
18637	19216	81	things	thing	NNS
18637	19216	82	,	,	,
18637	19216	83	or	or	CC
18637	19216	84	persons	person	NNS
18637	19216	85	,	,	,
18637	19216	86	or	or	CC
18637	19216	87	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	19216	88	.	.	.
18637	19217	1	In	in	IN
18637	19217	2	such	such	JJ
18637	19217	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	19217	4	the	the	DT
18637	19217	5	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	19217	6	,	,	,
18637	19217	7	in	in	IN
18637	19217	8	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	19217	9	the	the	DT
18637	19217	10	tax	tax	NN
18637	19217	11	,	,	,
18637	19217	12	fixes	fix	VBZ
18637	19217	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19217	14	amount	amount	NN
18637	19217	15	,	,	,
18637	19217	16	and	and	CC
18637	19217	17	that	that	DT
18637	19217	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	19217	19	the	the	DT
18637	19217	20	end	end	NN
18637	19217	21	of	of	IN
18637	19217	22	the	the	DT
18637	19217	23	matter	matter	NN
18637	19217	24	.	.	.
18637	19218	1	If	if	IN
18637	19218	2	the	the	DT
18637	19218	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	19218	4	be	be	VBP
18637	19218	5	not	not	RB
18637	19218	6	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19218	7	,	,	,
18637	19218	8	the	the	DT
18637	19218	9	property	property	NN
18637	19218	10	of	of	IN
18637	19218	11	the	the	DT
18637	19218	12	delinquent	delinquent	NN
18637	19218	13	may	may	MD
18637	19218	14	be	be	VB
18637	19218	15	sold	sell	VBN
18637	19218	16	,	,	,
18637	19218	17	and	and	CC
18637	19218	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19218	19	be	be	VBP
18637	19218	20	thus	thus	RB
18637	19218	21	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	19218	22	of	of	IN
18637	19218	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19218	24	property	property	NN
18637	19218	25	.	.	.
18637	19219	1	Yet	yet	CC
18637	19219	2	there	there	EX
18637	19219	3	can	can	MD
18637	19219	4	be	be	VB
18637	19219	5	no	no	DT
18637	19219	6	question	question	NN
18637	19219	7	,	,	,
18637	19219	8	that	that	IN
18637	19219	9	the	the	DT
18637	19219	10	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19219	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	19219	12	due	due	JJ
18637	19219	13	process	process	NN
18637	19219	14	of	of	IN
18637	19219	15	law	law	NN
18637	19219	16	,	,	,
18637	19219	17	as	as	IN
18637	19219	18	there	there	EX
18637	19219	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	19219	20	no	no	DT
18637	19219	21	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	19219	22	into	into	IN
18637	19219	23	the	the	DT
18637	19219	24	weight	weight	NN
18637	19219	25	of	of	IN
18637	19219	26	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19219	27	,	,	,
18637	19219	28	or	or	CC
18637	19219	29	other	other	JJ
18637	19219	30	element	element	NN
18637	19219	31	of	of	IN
18637	19219	32	a	a	DT
18637	19219	33	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19219	34	nature	nature	NN
18637	19219	35	,	,	,
18637	19219	36	and	and	CC
18637	19219	37	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	19219	38	could	could	MD
18637	19219	39	be	be	VB
18637	19219	40	changed	change	VBN
18637	19219	41	by	by	IN
18637	19219	42	hearing	hear	VBG
18637	19219	43	the	the	DT
18637	19219	44	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	19219	45	.	.	.
18637	19220	1	No	no	UH
18637	19220	2	right	right	NN
18637	19220	3	of	of	IN
18637	19220	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19220	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19220	6	,	,	,
18637	19220	7	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	19220	8	,	,	,
18637	19220	9	invaded	invade	VBD
18637	19220	10	.	.	.
18637	19221	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19221	2	,	,	,
18637	19221	3	if	if	IN
18637	19221	4	the	the	DT
18637	19221	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	19221	6	on	on	IN
18637	19221	7	animals	animal	NNS
18637	19221	8	be	be	VB
18637	19221	9	a	a	DT
18637	19221	10	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	19221	11	sum	sum	NN
18637	19221	12	per	per	IN
18637	19221	13	head	head	NN
18637	19221	14	,	,	,
18637	19221	15	or	or	CC
18637	19221	16	on	on	IN
18637	19221	17	articles	article	NNS
18637	19221	18	a	a	DT
18637	19221	19	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	19221	20	sum	sum	NN
18637	19221	21	per	per	IN
18637	19221	22	yard	yard	NN
18637	19221	23	,	,	,
18637	19221	24	or	or	CC
18637	19221	25	bushel	bushel	NN
18637	19221	26	,	,	,
18637	19221	27	or	or	CC
18637	19221	28	gallon	gallon	NN
18637	19221	29	,	,	,
18637	19221	30	there	there	EX
18637	19221	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	19221	32	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	19221	33	the	the	DT
18637	19221	34	owner	owner	NN
18637	19221	35	can	can	MD
18637	19221	36	do	do	VB
18637	19221	37	which	which	WDT
18637	19221	38	can	can	MD
18637	19221	39	affect	affect	VB
18637	19221	40	the	the	DT
18637	19221	41	amount	amount	NN
18637	19221	42	to	to	TO
18637	19221	43	be	be	VB
18637	19221	44	collected	collect	VBN
18637	19221	45	from	from	IN
18637	19221	46	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19221	47	.	.	.
18637	19222	1	So	so	CC
18637	19222	2	,	,	,
18637	19222	3	if	if	IN
18637	19222	4	a	a	DT
18637	19222	5	person	person	NN
18637	19222	6	wishes	wish	VBZ
18637	19222	7	a	a	DT
18637	19222	8	license	license	NN
18637	19222	9	to	to	TO
18637	19222	10	do	do	VB
18637	19222	11	business	business	NN
18637	19222	12	of	of	IN
18637	19222	13	a	a	DT
18637	19222	14	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19222	15	kind	kind	NN
18637	19222	16	,	,	,
18637	19222	17	or	or	CC
18637	19222	18	at	at	IN
18637	19222	19	a	a	DT
18637	19222	20	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19222	21	place	place	NN
18637	19222	22	,	,	,
18637	19222	23	such	such	JJ
18637	19222	24	as	as	IN
18637	19222	25	keeping	keep	VBG
18637	19222	26	a	a	DT
18637	19222	27	hotel	hotel	NN
18637	19222	28	or	or	CC
18637	19222	29	a	a	DT
18637	19222	30	restaurant	restaurant	NN
18637	19222	31	,	,	,
18637	19222	32	or	or	CC
18637	19222	33	selling	sell	VBG
18637	19222	34	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	19222	35	,	,	,
18637	19222	36	or	or	CC
18637	19222	37	cigars	cigar	NNS
18637	19222	38	,	,	,
18637	19222	39	or	or	CC
18637	19222	40	clothes	clothe	NNS
18637	19222	41	,	,	,
18637	19222	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19222	43	has	have	VBZ
18637	19222	44	only	only	RB
18637	19222	45	to	to	TO
18637	19222	46	pay	pay	VB
18637	19222	47	the	the	DT
18637	19222	48	amount	amount	NN
18637	19222	49	required	require	VBN
18637	19222	50	by	by	IN
18637	19222	51	law	law	NN
18637	19222	52	and	and	CC
18637	19222	53	go	go	VB
18637	19222	54	into	into	IN
18637	19222	55	the	the	DT
18637	19222	56	business	business	NN
18637	19222	57	.	.	.
18637	19223	1	There	there	EX
18637	19223	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	19223	3	no	no	DT
18637	19223	4	need	need	NN
18637	19223	5	in	in	IN
18637	19223	6	such	such	JJ
18637	19223	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	19223	8	for	for	IN
18637	19223	9	notice	notice	NN
18637	19223	10	or	or	CC
18637	19223	11	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19223	12	.	.	.
18637	19224	1	So	so	RB
18637	19224	2	,	,	,
18637	19224	3	also	also	RB
18637	19224	4	,	,	,
18637	19224	5	if	if	IN
18637	19224	6	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19224	7	are	be	VBP
18637	19224	8	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19224	9	in	in	IN
18637	19224	10	the	the	DT
18637	19224	11	shape	shape	NN
18637	19224	12	of	of	IN
18637	19224	13	licenses	license	NNS
18637	19224	14	for	for	IN
18637	19224	15	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	19224	16	,	,	,
18637	19224	17	such	such	JJ
18637	19224	18	as	as	IN
18637	19224	19	those	those	DT
18637	19224	20	on	on	IN
18637	19224	21	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19224	22	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19224	23	for	for	IN
18637	19224	24	doing	do	VBG
18637	19224	25	business	business	NN
18637	19224	26	in	in	IN
18637	19224	27	the	the	DT
18637	19224	28	State	State	NNP
18637	19224	29	,	,	,
18637	19224	30	or	or	CC
18637	19224	31	on	on	IN
18637	19224	32	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19224	33	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19224	34	for	for	IN
18637	19224	35	franchises	franchise	NNS
18637	19224	36	,	,	,
18637	19224	37	if	if	IN
18637	19224	38	the	the	DT
18637	19224	39	parties	party	NNS
18637	19224	40	desire	desire	VBP
18637	19224	41	the	the	DT
18637	19224	42	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19224	43	,	,	,
18637	19224	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19224	45	have	have	VBP
18637	19224	46	only	only	RB
18637	19224	47	to	to	TO
18637	19224	48	pay	pay	VB
18637	19224	49	the	the	DT
18637	19224	50	amount	amount	NN
18637	19224	51	required	require	VBN
18637	19224	52	.	.	.
18637	19225	1	In	in	IN
18637	19225	2	such	such	JJ
18637	19225	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	19225	4	there	there	EX
18637	19225	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19225	6	no	no	DT
18637	19225	7	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19225	8	for	for	IN
18637	19225	9	notice	notice	NN
18637	19225	10	or	or	CC
18637	19225	11	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19225	12	.	.	.
18637	19226	1	The	the	DT
18637	19226	2	amount	amount	NN
18637	19226	3	of	of	IN
18637	19226	4	the	the	DT
18637	19226	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	19226	6	would	would	MD
18637	19226	7	not	not	RB
18637	19226	8	be	be	VB
18637	19226	9	changed	change	VBN
18637	19226	10	by	by	IN
18637	19226	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19226	12	.	.	.
18637	19227	1	"	"	``
18637	19227	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19227	3	587	587	CD
18637	19227	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19227	5	Notice	Notice	NNP
18637	19227	6	and	and	CC
18637	19227	7	Hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19227	8	in	in	IN
18637	19227	9	Relation	Relation	NNP
18637	19227	10	to	to	IN
18637	19227	11	Assessments	Assessments	NNPS
18637	19227	12	"	"	''
18637	19227	13	But	but	CC
18637	19227	14	where	where	WRB
18637	19227	15	a	a	DT
18637	19227	16	tax	tax	NN
18637	19227	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	19227	18	levied	levy	VBN
18637	19227	19	on	on	IN
18637	19227	20	property	property	NN
18637	19227	21	not	not	RB
18637	19227	22	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	19227	23	,	,	,
18637	19227	24	but	but	CC
18637	19227	25	according	accord	VBG
18637	19227	26	to	to	IN
18637	19227	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19227	28	value	value	NN
18637	19227	29	,	,	,
18637	19227	30	to	to	TO
18637	19227	31	be	be	VB
18637	19227	32	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	19227	33	by	by	IN
18637	19227	34	assessors	assessor	NNS
18637	19227	35	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	19227	36	for	for	IN
18637	19227	37	that	that	DT
18637	19227	38	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	19227	39	upon	upon	IN
18637	19227	40	such	such	JJ
18637	19227	41	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19227	42	as	as	IN
18637	19227	43	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19227	44	may	may	MD
18637	19227	45	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	19227	46	,	,	,
18637	19227	47	a	a	DT
18637	19227	48	different	different	JJ
18637	19227	49	principle	principle	NN
18637	19227	50	comes	come	VBZ
18637	19227	51	in	in	RB
18637	19227	52	.	.	.
18637	19228	1	The	the	DT
18637	19228	2	officers	officer	NNS
18637	19228	3	in	in	IN
18637	19228	4	estimating	estimate	VBG
18637	19228	5	the	the	DT
18637	19228	6	value	value	NN
18637	19228	7	act	act	NN
18637	19228	8	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	19228	9	;	;	:
18637	19228	10	and	and	CC
18637	19228	11	in	in	IN
18637	19228	12	most	most	JJS
18637	19228	13	of	of	IN
18637	19228	14	the	the	DT
18637	19228	15	States	States	NNP
18637	19228	16	provision	provision	NN
18637	19228	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	19228	18	made	make	VBN
18637	19228	19	for	for	IN
18637	19228	20	the	the	DT
18637	19228	21	correction	correction	NN
18637	19228	22	of	of	IN
18637	19228	23	errors	error	NNS
18637	19228	24	committed	commit	VBN
18637	19228	25	by	by	IN
18637	19228	26	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19228	27	,	,	,
18637	19228	28	through	through	IN
18637	19228	29	boards	board	NNS
18637	19228	30	of	of	IN
18637	19228	31	revision	revision	NN
18637	19228	32	or	or	CC
18637	19228	33	equalization	equalization	NN
18637	19228	34	,	,	,
18637	19228	35	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	19228	36	at	at	IN
18637	19228	37	designated	designate	VBN
18637	19228	38	periods	period	NNS
18637	19228	39	provided	provide	VBN
18637	19228	40	by	by	IN
18637	19228	41	law	law	NN
18637	19228	42	to	to	TO
18637	19228	43	hear	hear	VB
18637	19228	44	complaints	complaint	NNS
18637	19228	45	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	19228	46	the	the	DT
18637	19228	47	justice	justice	NN
18637	19228	48	of	of	IN
18637	19228	49	the	the	DT
18637	19228	50	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	19228	51	.	.	.
18637	19229	1	The	the	DT
18637	19229	2	law	law	NN
18637	19229	3	in	in	IN
18637	19229	4	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	19229	5	the	the	DT
18637	19229	6	time	time	NN
18637	19229	7	when	when	WRB
18637	19229	8	such	such	JJ
18637	19229	9	complaints	complaint	NNS
18637	19229	10	will	will	MD
18637	19229	11	be	be	VB
18637	19229	12	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19229	13	,	,	,
18637	19229	14	gives	give	VBZ
18637	19229	15	all	all	PDT
18637	19229	16	the	the	DT
18637	19229	17	notice	notice	NN
18637	19229	18	required	require	VBN
18637	19229	19	,	,	,
18637	19229	20	and	and	CC
18637	19229	21	the	the	DT
18637	19229	22	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19229	23	by	by	IN
18637	19229	24	which	which	WDT
18637	19229	25	the	the	DT
18637	19229	26	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	19229	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	19229	28	determined	determine	VBN
18637	19229	29	,	,	,
18637	19229	30	though	though	IN
18637	19229	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19229	32	may	may	MD
18637	19229	33	be	be	VB
18637	19229	34	followed	follow	VBN
18637	19229	35	,	,	,
18637	19229	36	if	if	IN
18637	19229	37	the	the	DT
18637	19229	38	tax	tax	NN
18637	19229	39	be	be	VBP
18637	19229	40	not	not	RB
18637	19229	41	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19229	42	,	,	,
18637	19229	43	by	by	IN
18637	19229	44	a	a	DT
18637	19229	45	sale	sale	NN
18637	19229	46	of	of	IN
18637	19229	47	the	the	DT
18637	19229	48	delinquent	delinquent	NN
18637	19229	49	's	's	POS
18637	19229	50	property	property	NN
18637	19229	51	,	,	,
18637	19229	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	19229	53	due	due	JJ
18637	19229	54	process	process	NN
18637	19229	55	of	of	IN
18637	19229	56	law	law	NN
18637	19229	57	.	.	.
18637	19230	1	"	"	``
18637	19230	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19230	3	588	588	CD
18637	19230	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19230	5	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	19230	6	,	,	,
18637	19230	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19230	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	19230	9	never	never	RB
18637	19230	10	been	be	VBN
18637	19230	11	considered	consider	VBN
18637	19230	12	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19230	13	to	to	IN
18637	19230	14	the	the	DT
18637	19230	15	validity	validity	NN
18637	19230	16	of	of	IN
18637	19230	17	a	a	DT
18637	19230	18	tax	tax	NN
18637	19230	19	that	that	WDT
18637	19230	20	the	the	DT
18637	19230	21	party	party	NN
18637	19230	22	charged	charge	VBD
18637	19230	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	19230	24	have	have	VB
18637	19230	25	been	be	VBN
18637	19230	26	present	present	JJ
18637	19230	27	,	,	,
18637	19230	28	or	or	CC
18637	19230	29	had	have	VBD
18637	19230	30	an	an	DT
18637	19230	31	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19230	32	to	to	TO
18637	19230	33	be	be	VB
18637	19230	34	present	present	JJ
18637	19230	35	,	,	,
18637	19230	36	in	in	IN
18637	19230	37	some	some	DT
18637	19230	38	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	19230	39	when	when	WRB
18637	19230	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19230	41	was	be	VBD
18637	19230	42	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	19230	43	.	.	.
18637	19231	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19231	2	589	589	CD
18637	19231	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19231	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	19231	5	a	a	DT
18637	19231	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	19231	7	board	board	NN
18637	19231	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	19231	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19231	10	time	time	NN
18637	19231	11	of	of	IN
18637	19231	12	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	19231	13	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	19231	14	by	by	IN
18637	19231	15	law	law	NN
18637	19231	16	and	and	CC
18637	19231	17	where	where	WRB
18637	19231	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19231	19	sessions	session	NNS
18637	19231	20	are	be	VBP
18637	19231	21	not	not	RB
18637	19231	22	secret	secret	JJ
18637	19231	23	,	,	,
18637	19231	24	no	no	DT
18637	19231	25	obstacle	obstacle	NN
18637	19231	26	prevents	prevent	VBZ
18637	19231	27	the	the	DT
18637	19231	28	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	19231	29	of	of	IN
18637	19231	30	any	any	DT
18637	19231	31	one	one	NN
18637	19231	32	before	before	IN
18637	19231	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19231	34	to	to	TO
18637	19231	35	assert	assert	VB
18637	19231	36	a	a	DT
18637	19231	37	right	right	NN
18637	19231	38	or	or	CC
18637	19231	39	redress	redress	VB
18637	19231	40	a	a	DT
18637	19231	41	wrong	wrong	NN
18637	19231	42	;	;	:
18637	19231	43	and	and	CC
18637	19231	44	in	in	IN
18637	19231	45	the	the	DT
18637	19231	46	business	business	NN
18637	19231	47	of	of	IN
18637	19231	48	assessing	assess	VBG
18637	19231	49	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19231	50	,	,	,
18637	19231	51	this	this	DT
18637	19231	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	19231	53	all	all	DT
18637	19231	54	that	that	WDT
18637	19231	55	can	can	MD
18637	19231	56	be	be	VB
18637	19231	57	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	19231	58	asked	ask	VBN
18637	19231	59	.	.	.
18637	19232	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19232	2	590	590	CD
18637	19232	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19232	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19232	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19232	6	there	there	EX
18637	19232	7	any	any	DT
18637	19232	8	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19232	9	command	command	NN
18637	19232	10	that	that	WDT
18637	19232	11	notice	notice	NN
18637	19232	12	of	of	IN
18637	19232	13	an	an	DT
18637	19232	14	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19232	15	as	as	RB
18637	19232	16	well	well	RB
18637	19232	17	as	as	IN
18637	19232	18	an	an	DT
18637	19232	19	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19232	20	to	to	TO
18637	19232	21	contest	contest	VB
18637	19232	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19232	23	be	be	VB
18637	19232	24	given	give	VBN
18637	19232	25	in	in	IN
18637	19232	26	advance	advance	NN
18637	19232	27	of	of	IN
18637	19232	28	the	the	DT
18637	19232	29	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19232	30	.	.	.
18637	19233	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19233	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	19233	3	enough	enough	JJ
18637	19233	4	that	that	IN
18637	19233	5	all	all	DT
18637	19233	6	available	available	JJ
18637	19233	7	defenses	defense	NNS
18637	19233	8	may	may	MD
18637	19233	9	be	be	VB
18637	19233	10	presented	present	VBN
18637	19233	11	to	to	IN
18637	19233	12	a	a	DT
18637	19233	13	competent	competent	JJ
18637	19233	14	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	19233	15	during	during	IN
18637	19233	16	a	a	DT
18637	19233	17	suit	suit	NN
18637	19233	18	to	to	TO
18637	19233	19	collect	collect	VB
18637	19233	20	the	the	DT
18637	19233	21	tax	tax	NN
18637	19233	22	and	and	CC
18637	19233	23	before	before	IN
18637	19233	24	the	the	DT
18637	19233	25	demand	demand	NN
18637	19233	26	of	of	IN
18637	19233	27	the	the	DT
18637	19233	28	State	State	NNP
18637	19233	29	for	for	IN
18637	19233	30	remittance	remittance	NN
18637	19233	31	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	19233	32	final	final	JJ
18637	19233	33	.	.	.
18637	19234	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19234	2	591	591	CD
18637	19234	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19234	4	A	a	DT
18637	19234	5	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19234	6	before	before	IN
18637	19234	7	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19234	8	,	,	,
18637	19234	9	with	with	IN
18637	19234	10	full	full	JJ
18637	19234	11	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19234	12	to	to	TO
18637	19234	13	submit	submit	VB
18637	19234	14	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19234	15	and	and	CC
18637	19234	16	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	19234	17	being	be	VBG
18637	19234	18	all	all	DT
18637	19234	19	that	that	WDT
18637	19234	20	can	can	MD
18637	19234	21	be	be	VB
18637	19234	22	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
18637	19234	23	vital	vital	JJ
18637	19234	24	,	,	,
18637	19234	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19234	26	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	19234	27	that	that	IN
18637	19234	28	rehearings	rehearing	NNS
18637	19234	29	and	and	CC
18637	19234	30	new	new	JJ
18637	19234	31	trials	trial	NNS
18637	19234	32	are	be	VBP
18637	19234	33	not	not	RB
18637	19234	34	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19234	35	to	to	TO
18637	19234	36	due	due	JJ
18637	19234	37	process	process	NN
18637	19234	38	of	of	IN
18637	19234	39	law	law	NN
18637	19234	40	.	.	.
18637	19235	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19235	2	592	592	CD
18637	19235	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19235	4	One	one	CD
18637	19235	5	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19235	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19235	7	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19235	8	to	to	TO
18637	19235	9	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	19235	10	due	due	JJ
18637	19235	11	process;[593	process;[593	NNS
18637	19235	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19235	13	and	and	CC
18637	19235	14	the	the	DT
18637	19235	15	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	19235	16	of	of	IN
18637	19235	17	due	due	JJ
18637	19235	18	process	process	NN
18637	19235	19	are	be	VBP
18637	19235	20	also	also	RB
18637	19235	21	met	meet	VBN
18637	19235	22	if	if	IN
18637	19235	23	a	a	DT
18637	19235	24	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	19235	25	,	,	,
18637	19235	26	who	who	WP
18637	19235	27	had	have	VBD
18637	19235	28	no	no	DT
18637	19235	29	notice	notice	NN
18637	19235	30	of	of	IN
18637	19235	31	a	a	DT
18637	19235	32	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19235	33	,	,	,
18637	19235	34	does	do	VBZ
18637	19235	35	receive	receive	VB
18637	19235	36	notice	notice	NN
18637	19235	37	of	of	IN
18637	19235	38	the	the	DT
18637	19235	39	decision	decision	NN
18637	19235	40	reached	reach	VBN
18637	19235	41	thereat	thereat	RB
18637	19235	42	,	,	,
18637	19235	43	and	and	CC
18637	19235	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	19235	45	privileged	privileged	JJ
18637	19235	46	to	to	TO
18637	19235	47	appeal	appeal	VB
18637	19235	48	the	the	DT
18637	19235	49	same	same	JJ
18637	19235	50	and	and	CC
18637	19235	51	,	,	,
18637	19235	52	on	on	IN
18637	19235	53	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	19235	54	,	,	,
18637	19235	55	to	to	TO
18637	19235	56	present	present	VB
18637	19235	57	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19235	58	and	and	CC
18637	19235	59	be	be	VB
18637	19235	60	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19235	61	on	on	IN
18637	19235	62	the	the	DT
18637	19235	63	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	19235	64	of	of	IN
18637	19235	65	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19235	66	property	property	NN
18637	19235	67	.	.	.
18637	19236	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19236	2	594	594	CD
18637	19236	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19236	4	Notice	Notice	NNP
18637	19236	5	and	and	CC
18637	19236	6	Hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19236	7	in	in	IN
18637	19236	8	Relation	Relation	NNP
18637	19236	9	to	to	IN
18637	19236	10	Special	Special	NNP
18637	19236	11	Assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	19236	12	However	however	RB
18637	19236	13	,	,	,
18637	19236	14	when	when	WRB
18637	19236	15	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	19236	16	are	be	VBP
18637	19236	17	made	make	VBN
18637	19236	18	by	by	IN
18637	19236	19	a	a	DT
18637	19236	20	political	political	JJ
18637	19236	21	subdivision	subdivision	NN
18637	19236	22	,	,	,
18637	19236	23	a	a	DT
18637	19236	24	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19236	25	board	board	NN
18637	19236	26	or	or	CC
18637	19236	27	court	court	NN
18637	19236	28	,	,	,
18637	19236	29	according	accord	VBG
18637	19236	30	to	to	IN
18637	19236	31	special	special	JJ
18637	19236	32	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	19236	33	,	,	,
18637	19236	34	the	the	DT
18637	19236	35	property	property	NN
18637	19236	36	owner	owner	NN
18637	19236	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	19236	38	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19236	39	to	to	TO
18637	19236	40	be	be	VB
18637	19236	41	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19236	42	as	as	IN
18637	19236	43	to	to	IN
18637	19236	44	the	the	DT
18637	19236	45	amount	amount	NN
18637	19236	46	of	of	IN
18637	19236	47	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19236	48	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	19236	49	and	and	CC
18637	19236	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	19236	51	all	all	DT
18637	19236	52	questions	question	NNS
18637	19236	53	properly	properly	RB
18637	19236	54	entering	enter	VBG
18637	19236	55	into	into	IN
18637	19236	56	that	that	DT
18637	19236	57	determination	determination	NN
18637	19236	58	.	.	.
18637	19237	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19237	2	595	595	CD
18637	19237	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19237	4	The	the	DT
18637	19237	5	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19237	6	need	nee	MD
18637	19237	7	not	not	RB
18637	19237	8	amount	amount	VB
18637	19237	9	to	to	IN
18637	19237	10	a	a	DT
18637	19237	11	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19237	12	inquiry,[596	inquiry,[596	NN
18637	19237	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19237	14	but	but	CC
18637	19237	15	a	a	DT
18637	19237	16	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19237	17	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19237	18	to	to	TO
18637	19237	19	submit	submit	VB
18637	19237	20	objections	objection	NNS
18637	19237	21	in	in	IN
18637	19237	22	writing	writing	NN
18637	19237	23	,	,	,
18637	19237	24	without	without	IN
18637	19237	25	the	the	DT
18637	19237	26	right	right	NN
18637	19237	27	of	of	IN
18637	19237	28	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19237	29	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	19237	30	,	,	,
18637	19237	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	19237	32	not	not	RB
18637	19237	33	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19237	34	.	.	.
18637	19238	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19238	2	597	597	CD
18637	19238	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19238	4	If	if	IN
18637	19238	5	an	an	DT
18637	19238	6	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19238	7	for	for	IN
18637	19238	8	a	a	DT
18637	19238	9	local	local	JJ
18637	19238	10	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	19238	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	19238	12	made	make	VBN
18637	19238	13	in	in	IN
18637	19238	14	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	19238	15	with	with	IN
18637	19238	16	a	a	DT
18637	19238	17	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	19238	18	rule	rule	NN
18637	19238	19	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	19238	20	by	by	IN
18637	19238	21	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19238	22	act	act	NNP
18637	19238	23	,	,	,
18637	19238	24	the	the	DT
18637	19238	25	property	property	NN
18637	19238	26	owner	owner	NN
18637	19238	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	19238	28	not	not	RB
18637	19238	29	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19238	30	to	to	TO
18637	19238	31	be	be	VB
18637	19238	32	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19238	33	in	in	IN
18637	19238	34	advance	advance	NN
18637	19238	35	on	on	IN
18637	19238	36	the	the	DT
18637	19238	37	question	question	NN
18637	19238	38	of	of	IN
18637	19238	39	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	19238	40	.	.	.
18637	19239	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19239	2	598	598	CD
18637	19239	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19239	4	On	on	IN
18637	19239	5	the	the	DT
18637	19239	6	other	other	JJ
18637	19239	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	19239	8	,	,	,
18637	19239	9	if	if	IN
18637	19239	10	the	the	DT
18637	19239	11	area	area	NN
18637	19239	12	of	of	IN
18637	19239	13	the	the	DT
18637	19239	14	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19239	15	district	district	NN
18637	19239	16	was	be	VBD
18637	19239	17	not	not	RB
18637	19239	18	determined	determine	VBN
18637	19239	19	by	by	IN
18637	19239	20	the	the	DT
18637	19239	21	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	19239	22	,	,	,
18637	19239	23	a	a	DT
18637	19239	24	landowner	landowner	NN
18637	19239	25	does	do	VBZ
18637	19239	26	have	have	VB
18637	19239	27	the	the	DT
18637	19239	28	right	right	NN
18637	19239	29	to	to	TO
18637	19239	30	be	be	VB
18637	19239	31	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19239	32	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	19239	33	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	19239	34	to	to	IN
18637	19239	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19239	36	property	property	NN
18637	19239	37	before	before	IN
18637	19239	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19239	39	can	can	MD
18637	19239	40	be	be	VB
18637	19239	41	included	include	VBN
18637	19239	42	in	in	IN
18637	19239	43	the	the	DT
18637	19239	44	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	19239	45	district	district	NN
18637	19239	46	and	and	CC
18637	19239	47	assessed	assess	VBD
18637	19239	48	;	;	:
18637	19239	49	but	but	CC
18637	19239	50	due	due	JJ
18637	19239	51	process	process	NN
18637	19239	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	19239	53	not	not	RB
18637	19239	54	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19239	55	if	if	IN
18637	19239	56	,	,	,
18637	19239	57	in	in	IN
18637	19239	58	the	the	DT
18637	19239	59	absence	absence	NN
18637	19239	60	of	of	IN
18637	19239	61	actual	actual	JJ
18637	19239	62	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	19239	63	or	or	CC
18637	19239	64	bad	bad	JJ
18637	19239	65	faith	faith	NN
18637	19239	66	,	,	,
18637	19239	67	the	the	DT
18637	19239	68	decision	decision	NN
18637	19239	69	of	of	IN
18637	19239	70	the	the	DT
18637	19239	71	agency	agency	NN
18637	19239	72	vested	vest	VBN
18637	19239	73	with	with	IN
18637	19239	74	the	the	DT
18637	19239	75	initial	initial	JJ
18637	19239	76	determination	determination	NN
18637	19239	77	of	of	IN
18637	19239	78	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	19239	79	is	be	VBZ
18637	19239	80	made	make	VBN
18637	19239	81	final	final	JJ
18637	19239	82	.	.	.
18637	19240	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19240	2	599	599	CD
18637	19240	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19240	4	The	the	DT
18637	19240	5	owner	owner	NN
18637	19240	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	19240	7	no	no	DT
18637	19240	8	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19240	9	right	right	NN
18637	19240	10	to	to	TO
18637	19240	11	be	be	VB
18637	19240	12	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19240	13	in	in	IN
18637	19240	14	opposition	opposition	NN
18637	19240	15	to	to	IN
18637	19240	16	the	the	DT
18637	19240	17	launching	launching	NN
18637	19240	18	of	of	IN
18637	19240	19	a	a	DT
18637	19240	20	project	project	NN
18637	19240	21	which	which	WDT
18637	19240	22	may	may	MD
18637	19240	23	end	end	VB
18637	19240	24	in	in	IN
18637	19240	25	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19240	26	;	;	:
18637	19240	27	and	and	CC
18637	19240	28	once	once	RB
18637	19240	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19240	30	land	land	NN
18637	19240	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	19240	32	been	be	VBN
18637	19240	33	duly	duly	RB
18637	19240	34	included	include	VBN
18637	19240	35	within	within	IN
18637	19240	36	a	a	DT
18637	19240	37	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19240	38	district	district	NN
18637	19240	39	,	,	,
18637	19240	40	the	the	DT
18637	19240	41	only	only	JJ
18637	19240	42	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19240	43	which	which	WDT
18637	19240	44	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19240	45	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	19240	46	enjoys	enjoy	VBZ
18637	19240	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	19240	48	to	to	IN
18637	19240	49	a	a	DT
18637	19240	50	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19240	51	upon	upon	IN
18637	19240	52	the	the	DT
18637	19240	53	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	19240	54	;	;	:
18637	19240	55	that	that	RB
18637	19240	56	is	is	RB
18637	19240	57	,	,	,
18637	19240	58	the	the	DT
18637	19240	59	amount	amount	NN
18637	19240	60	of	of	IN
18637	19240	61	the	the	DT
18637	19240	62	tax	tax	NN
18637	19240	63	which	which	WDT
18637	19240	64	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19240	65	has	have	VBZ
18637	19240	66	to	to	TO
18637	19240	67	pay	pay	VB
18637	19240	68	.	.	.
18637	19241	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19241	2	600	600	CD
18637	19241	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19241	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19241	5	can	can	MD
18637	19241	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19241	7	rightfully	rightfully	RB
18637	19241	8	complain	complain	VB
18637	19241	9	because	because	IN
18637	19241	10	the	the	DT
18637	19241	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	19241	12	renders	render	VBZ
18637	19241	13	conclusive	conclusive	VBP
18637	19241	14	,	,	,
18637	19241	15	after	after	IN
18637	19241	16	said	say	VBD
18637	19241	17	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19241	18	,	,	,
18637	19241	19	the	the	DT
18637	19241	20	determination	determination	NN
18637	19241	21	as	as	IN
18637	19241	22	to	to	IN
18637	19241	23	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	19241	24	by	by	IN
18637	19241	25	the	the	DT
18637	19241	26	same	same	JJ
18637	19241	27	body	body	NN
18637	19241	28	which	which	WDT
18637	19241	29	levied	levy	VBD
18637	19241	30	the	the	DT
18637	19241	31	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19241	32	.	.	.
18637	19242	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19242	2	601	601	CD
18637	19242	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19242	4	More	more	RBR
18637	19242	5	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	19242	6	,	,	,
18637	19242	7	where	where	WRB
18637	19242	8	the	the	DT
18637	19242	9	mode	mode	NN
18637	19242	10	of	of	IN
18637	19242	11	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19242	12	resolves	resolve	VBZ
18637	19242	13	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19242	14	into	into	IN
18637	19242	15	a	a	DT
18637	19242	16	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19242	17	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
18637	19242	18	calculation	calculation	NN
18637	19242	19	,	,	,
18637	19242	20	there	there	EX
18637	19242	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	19242	22	no	no	DT
18637	19242	23	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19242	24	for	for	IN
18637	19242	25	a	a	DT
18637	19242	26	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19242	27	.	.	.
18637	19243	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19243	2	602	602	CD
18637	19243	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19243	4	Statutes	statute	NNS
18637	19243	5	and	and	CC
18637	19243	6	ordinances	ordinance	NNS
18637	19243	7	providing	provide	VBG
18637	19243	8	for	for	IN
18637	19243	9	the	the	DT
18637	19243	10	paving	paving	NN
18637	19243	11	and	and	CC
18637	19243	12	grading	grading	NN
18637	19243	13	of	of	IN
18637	19243	14	streets	street	NNS
18637	19243	15	,	,	,
18637	19243	16	the	the	DT
18637	19243	17	cost	cost	NN
18637	19243	18	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19243	19	to	to	TO
18637	19243	20	be	be	VB
18637	19243	21	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	19243	22	on	on	IN
18637	19243	23	the	the	DT
18637	19243	24	front	front	JJ
18637	19243	25	foot	foot	NN
18637	19243	26	rule	rule	NN
18637	19243	27	,	,	,
18637	19243	28	do	do	VB
18637	19243	29	not	not	RB
18637	19243	30	,	,	,
18637	19243	31	by	by	IN
18637	19243	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19243	33	failure	failure	NN
18637	19243	34	to	to	TO
18637	19243	35	provide	provide	VB
18637	19243	36	for	for	IN
18637	19243	37	a	a	DT
18637	19243	38	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19243	39	or	or	CC
18637	19243	40	review	review	NN
18637	19243	41	of	of	IN
18637	19243	42	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	19243	43	,	,	,
18637	19243	44	generally	generally	RB
18637	19243	45	deprive	deprive	VBP
18637	19243	46	a	a	DT
18637	19243	47	complaining	complain	VBG
18637	19243	48	owner	owner	NN
18637	19243	49	of	of	IN
18637	19243	50	property	property	NN
18637	19243	51	without	without	IN
18637	19243	52	due	due	JJ
18637	19243	53	process	process	NN
18637	19243	54	of	of	IN
18637	19243	55	law	law	NN
18637	19243	56	.	.	.
18637	19244	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19244	2	603	603	CD
18637	19244	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19244	4	In	in	IN
18637	19244	5	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	19244	6	,	,	,
18637	19244	7	when	when	WRB
18637	19244	8	an	an	DT
18637	19244	9	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	19244	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	19244	11	made	make	VBN
18637	19244	12	to	to	TO
18637	19244	13	cast	cast	VB
18637	19244	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	19244	15	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19244	16	property	property	NN
18637	19244	17	a	a	DT
18637	19244	18	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19244	19	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	19244	20	of	of	IN
18637	19244	21	the	the	DT
18637	19244	22	construction	construction	NN
18637	19244	23	cost	cost	NN
18637	19244	24	of	of	IN
18637	19244	25	a	a	DT
18637	19244	26	sewer	sewer	NN
18637	19244	27	not	not	RB
18637	19244	28	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	19244	29	by	by	IN
18637	19244	30	any	any	DT
18637	19244	31	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
18637	19244	32	formula	formula	NN
18637	19244	33	,	,	,
18637	19244	34	the	the	DT
18637	19244	35	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	19244	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	19244	37	a	a	DT
18637	19244	38	right	right	NN
18637	19244	39	to	to	TO
18637	19244	40	be	be	VB
18637	19244	41	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19244	42	.	.	.
18637	19245	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19245	2	604	604	CD
18637	19245	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19245	4	Sufficiency	Sufficiency	NNP
18637	19245	5	and	and	CC
18637	19245	6	Manner	Manner	NNP
18637	19245	7	of	of	IN
18637	19245	8	Giving	Giving	NNP
18637	19245	9	Notice	Notice	NNP
18637	19245	10	Notice	Notice	NNP
18637	19245	11	,	,	,
18637	19245	12	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	19245	13	as	as	IN
18637	19245	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19245	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	19245	16	required	require	VBN
18637	19245	17	,	,	,
18637	19245	18	may	may	MD
18637	19245	19	be	be	VB
18637	19245	20	either	either	CC
18637	19245	21	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19245	22	,	,	,
18637	19245	23	or	or	CC
18637	19245	24	by	by	IN
18637	19245	25	publication	publication	NN
18637	19245	26	,	,	,
18637	19245	27	or	or	CC
18637	19245	28	by	by	IN
18637	19245	29	statute	statute	NN
18637	19245	30	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	19245	31	the	the	DT
18637	19245	32	time	time	NN
18637	19245	33	and	and	CC
18637	19245	34	place	place	NN
18637	19245	35	of	of	IN
18637	19245	36	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19245	37	.	.	.
18637	19246	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19246	2	605	605	CD
18637	19246	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19246	4	A	a	DT
18637	19246	5	State	state	NN
18637	19246	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	19246	7	,	,	,
18637	19246	8	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	19246	9	with	with	IN
18637	19246	10	due	due	JJ
18637	19246	11	process	process	NN
18637	19246	12	,	,	,
18637	19246	13	may	may	MD
18637	19246	14	designate	designate	VB
18637	19246	15	a	a	DT
18637	19246	16	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19246	17	as	as	IN
18637	19246	18	the	the	DT
18637	19246	19	agent	agent	NN
18637	19246	20	of	of	IN
18637	19246	21	a	a	DT
18637	19246	22	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19246	23	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	19246	24	to	to	TO
18637	19246	25	receive	receive	VB
18637	19246	26	notice	notice	NN
18637	19246	27	and	and	CC
18637	19246	28	to	to	TO
18637	19246	29	represent	represent	VB
18637	19246	30	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19246	31	in	in	IN
18637	19246	32	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19246	33	for	for	IN
18637	19246	34	correcting	correct	VBG
18637	19246	35	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	19246	36	.	.	.
18637	19247	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19247	2	606	606	CD
18637	19247	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19247	4	Also	also	RB
18637	19247	5	"	"	``
18637	19247	6	where	where	WRB
18637	19247	7	the	the	DT
18637	19247	8	State	state	NN
18637	19247	9	*	*	NFP
18637	19247	10	*	*	NFP
18637	19247	11	*	*	NFP
18637	19247	12	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19247	13	desires	desire	NNS
18637	19247	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19247	15	to	to	TO
18637	19247	16	sell	sell	VB
18637	19247	17	land	land	NN
18637	19247	18	for	for	IN
18637	19247	19	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19247	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	19247	21	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19247	22	to	to	TO
18637	19247	23	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	19247	24	a	a	DT
18637	19247	25	lien	lien	NN
18637	19247	26	for	for	IN
18637	19247	27	the	the	DT
18637	19247	28	payment	payment	NN
18637	19247	29	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19247	30	,	,	,
18637	19247	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19247	32	may	may	MD
18637	19247	33	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	19247	34	directly	directly	RB
18637	19247	35	against	against	IN
18637	19247	36	the	the	DT
18637	19247	37	land	land	NN
18637	19247	38	within	within	IN
18637	19247	39	the	the	DT
18637	19247	40	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19247	41	of	of	IN
18637	19247	42	the	the	DT
18637	19247	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19247	44	,	,	,
18637	19247	45	and	and	CC
18637	19247	46	a	a	DT
18637	19247	47	notice	notice	NN
18637	19247	48	which	which	WDT
18637	19247	49	permits	permit	VBZ
18637	19247	50	all	all	DT
18637	19247	51	interested	interested	JJ
18637	19247	52	,	,	,
18637	19247	53	who	who	WP
18637	19247	54	are	be	VBP
18637	19247	55	'	'	``
18637	19247	56	so	so	RB
18637	19247	57	minded	minded	JJ
18637	19247	58	,	,	,
18637	19247	59	'	'	''
18637	19247	60	to	to	TO
18637	19247	61	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	19247	62	that	that	IN
18637	19247	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19247	64	is	be	VBZ
18637	19247	65	to	to	TO
18637	19247	66	be	be	VB
18637	19247	67	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	19247	68	to	to	IN
18637	19247	69	sale	sale	NN
18637	19247	70	to	to	TO
18637	19247	71	answer	answer	VB
18637	19247	72	for	for	IN
18637	19247	73	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19247	74	,	,	,
18637	19247	75	and	and	CC
18637	19247	76	to	to	TO
18637	19247	77	appear	appear	VB
18637	19247	78	and	and	CC
18637	19247	79	be	be	VB
18637	19247	80	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19247	81	,	,	,
18637	19247	82	whether	whether	IN
18637	19247	83	to	to	TO
18637	19247	84	be	be	VB
18637	19247	85	found	find	VBN
18637	19247	86	within	within	IN
18637	19247	87	the	the	DT
18637	19247	88	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19247	89	or	or	CC
18637	19247	90	not	not	RB
18637	19247	91	,	,	,
18637	19247	92	is	be	VBZ
18637	19247	93	due	due	JJ
18637	19247	94	process	process	NN
18637	19247	95	of	of	IN
18637	19247	96	law	law	NN
18637	19247	97	within	within	IN
18637	19247	98	the	the	DT
18637	19247	99	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19247	100	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19247	101	*	*	NFP
18637	19247	102	*	*	NFP
18637	19247	103	*	*	NFP
18637	19247	104	.	.	.
18637	19248	1	"	"	``
18637	19248	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19248	3	607	607	CD
18637	19248	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19248	5	A	a	DT
18637	19248	6	description	description	NN
18637	19248	7	,	,	,
18637	19248	8	even	even	RB
18637	19248	9	though	though	IN
18637	19248	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19248	11	not	not	RB
18637	19248	12	be	be	VB
18637	19248	13	technically	technically	RB
18637	19248	14	correct	correct	JJ
18637	19248	15	,	,	,
18637	19248	16	which	which	WDT
18637	19248	17	identifies	identify	VBZ
18637	19248	18	the	the	DT
18637	19248	19	land	land	NN
18637	19248	20	will	will	MD
18637	19248	21	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	19248	22	an	an	DT
18637	19248	23	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19248	24	for	for	IN
18637	19248	25	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19248	26	and	and	CC
18637	19248	27	a	a	DT
18637	19248	28	notice	notice	NN
18637	19248	29	of	of	IN
18637	19248	30	sale	sale	NN
18637	19248	31	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	19248	32	when	when	WRB
18637	19248	33	delinquent	delinquent	JJ
18637	19248	34	.	.	.
18637	19249	1	If	if	IN
18637	19249	2	the	the	DT
18637	19249	3	owner	owner	NN
18637	19249	4	knows	know	VBZ
18637	19249	5	that	that	IN
18637	19249	6	the	the	DT
18637	19249	7	property	property	NN
18637	19249	8	so	so	RB
18637	19249	9	described	describe	VBN
18637	19249	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	19249	11	his	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19249	12	,	,	,
18637	19249	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19249	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19249	15	not	not	RB
18637	19249	16	,	,	,
18637	19249	17	by	by	IN
18637	19249	18	reason	reason	NN
18637	19249	19	of	of	IN
18637	19249	20	the	the	DT
18637	19249	21	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	19249	22	description	description	NN
18637	19249	23	,	,	,
18637	19249	24	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	19249	25	of	of	IN
18637	19249	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19249	27	property	property	NN
18637	19249	28	without	without	IN
18637	19249	29	due	due	JJ
18637	19249	30	process	process	NN
18637	19249	31	.	.	.
18637	19250	1	Where	where	WRB
18637	19250	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	19250	3	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19250	4	are	be	VBP
18637	19250	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19250	6	in	in	IN
18637	19250	7	rem	rem	NNP
18637	19250	8	_	_	NNP
18637	19250	9	,	,	,
18637	19250	10	owners	owner	NNS
18637	19250	11	are	be	VBP
18637	19250	12	bound	bind	VBN
18637	19250	13	to	to	TO
18637	19250	14	take	take	VB
18637	19250	15	notice	notice	NN
18637	19250	16	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19250	17	,	,	,
18637	19250	18	and	and	CC
18637	19250	19	to	to	TO
18637	19250	20	pay	pay	VB
18637	19250	21	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19250	22	on	on	IN
18637	19250	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19250	24	property	property	NN
18637	19250	25	,	,	,
18637	19250	26	even	even	RB
18637	19250	27	if	if	IN
18637	19250	28	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	19250	29	to	to	TO
18637	19250	30	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	19250	31	or	or	CC
18637	19250	32	other	other	JJ
18637	19250	33	persons	person	NNS
18637	19250	34	;	;	:
18637	19250	35	and	and	CC
18637	19250	36	if	if	IN
18637	19250	37	an	an	DT
18637	19250	38	owner	owner	NN
18637	19250	39	stands	stand	VBZ
18637	19250	40	by	by	RB
18637	19250	41	and	and	CC
18637	19250	42	sees	see	VBZ
18637	19250	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19250	44	property	property	NN
18637	19250	45	sold	sell	VBN
18637	19250	46	for	for	IN
18637	19250	47	delinquent	delinquent	JJ
18637	19250	48	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19250	49	,	,	,
18637	19250	50	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19250	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	19250	52	not	not	RB
18637	19250	53	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	19250	54	wrongfully	wrongfully	RB
18637	19250	55	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	19250	56	of	of	IN
18637	19250	57	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19250	58	property	property	NN
18637	19250	59	.	.	.
18637	19251	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19251	2	608	608	CD
18637	19251	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19251	4	Sufficiency	Sufficiency	NNP
18637	19251	5	of	of	IN
18637	19251	6	Remedy	Remedy	NNP
18637	19251	7	When	when	WRB
18637	19251	8	no	no	DT
18637	19251	9	other	other	JJ
18637	19251	10	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	19251	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	19251	12	available	available	JJ
18637	19251	13	,	,	,
18637	19251	14	due	due	JJ
18637	19251	15	process	process	NN
18637	19251	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	19251	17	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19251	18	by	by	IN
18637	19251	19	a	a	DT
18637	19251	20	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19251	21	of	of	IN
18637	19251	22	a	a	DT
18637	19251	23	State	State	NNP
18637	19251	24	court	court	NN
18637	19251	25	withholding	withhold	VBG
18637	19251	26	a	a	DT
18637	19251	27	decree	decree	NN
18637	19251	28	in	in	IN
18637	19251	29	equity	equity	NN
18637	19251	30	to	to	TO
18637	19251	31	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	19251	32	collection	collection	NN
18637	19251	33	of	of	IN
18637	19251	34	a	a	DT
18637	19251	35	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	19251	36	tax	tax	NN
18637	19251	37	.	.	.
18637	19252	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19252	2	609	609	CD
18637	19252	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19252	4	Requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	19252	5	of	of	IN
18637	19252	6	due	due	JJ
18637	19252	7	process	process	NN
18637	19252	8	are	be	VBP
18637	19252	9	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19252	10	violated	violate	VBN
18637	19252	11	by	by	IN
18637	19252	12	a	a	DT
18637	19252	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	19252	14	which	which	WDT
18637	19252	15	limits	limit	VBZ
18637	19252	16	a	a	DT
18637	19252	17	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	19252	18	's	's	POS
18637	19252	19	right	right	NN
18637	19252	20	to	to	TO
18637	19252	21	challenge	challenge	VB
18637	19252	22	an	an	DT
18637	19252	23	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19252	24	to	to	IN
18637	19252	25	cases	case	NNS
18637	19252	26	of	of	IN
18637	19252	27	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	19252	28	or	or	CC
18637	19252	29	corruption,[610	corruption,[610	NNP
18637	19252	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19252	31	and	and	CC
18637	19252	32	by	by	IN
18637	19252	33	a	a	DT
18637	19252	34	State	State	NNP
18637	19252	35	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	19252	36	which	which	WDT
18637	19252	37	prevents	prevent	VBZ
18637	19252	38	a	a	DT
18637	19252	39	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	19252	40	of	of	IN
18637	19252	41	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19252	42	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19252	43	in	in	IN
18637	19252	44	violation	violation	NN
18637	19252	45	of	of	IN
18637	19252	46	the	the	DT
18637	19252	47	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19252	48	and	and	CC
18637	19252	49	laws	law	NNS
18637	19252	50	of	of	IN
18637	19252	51	the	the	DT
18637	19252	52	United	United	NNP
18637	19252	53	States	States	NNP
18637	19252	54	by	by	IN
18637	19252	55	invoking	invoke	VBG
18637	19252	56	a	a	DT
18637	19252	57	State	State	NNP
18637	19252	58	law	law	NN
18637	19252	59	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	19252	60	suits	suit	NNS
18637	19252	61	to	to	TO
18637	19252	62	recover	recover	VB
18637	19252	63	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19252	64	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	19252	65	to	to	TO
18637	19252	66	have	have	VB
18637	19252	67	been	be	VBN
18637	19252	68	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	19252	69	illegally	illegally	RB
18637	19252	70	to	to	IN
18637	19252	71	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19252	72	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19252	73	at	at	IN
18637	19252	74	the	the	DT
18637	19252	75	time	time	NN
18637	19252	76	and	and	CC
18637	19252	77	in	in	IN
18637	19252	78	the	the	DT
18637	19252	79	manner	manner	NN
18637	19252	80	provided	provide	VBN
18637	19252	81	by	by	IN
18637	19252	82	said	said	NNP
18637	19252	83	law	law	NN
18637	19252	84	.	.	.
18637	19253	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19253	2	611	611	CD
18637	19253	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19253	4	Laches	Laches	NNP
18637	19253	5	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	19253	6	failing	fail	VBG
18637	19253	7	to	to	TO
18637	19253	8	avail	avail	VB
18637	19253	9	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19253	10	of	of	IN
18637	19253	11	an	an	DT
18637	19253	12	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19253	13	to	to	TO
18637	19253	14	object	object	VB
18637	19253	15	and	and	CC
18637	19253	16	be	be	VB
18637	19253	17	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19253	18	,	,	,
18637	19253	19	can	can	MD
18637	19253	20	not	not	RB
18637	19253	21	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	19253	22	complain	complain	VB
18637	19253	23	of	of	IN
18637	19253	24	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	19253	25	as	as	IN
18637	19253	26	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19253	27	and	and	CC
18637	19253	28	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19253	29	.	.	.
18637	19254	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19254	2	612	612	CD
18637	19254	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19254	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19254	5	a	a	DT
18637	19254	6	car	car	NN
18637	19254	7	company	company	NN
18637	19254	8	,	,	,
18637	19254	9	which	which	WDT
18637	19254	10	failed	fail	VBD
18637	19254	11	to	to	TO
18637	19254	12	report	report	VB
18637	19254	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19254	14	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19254	15	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	19254	16	as	as	IN
18637	19254	17	required	require	VBN
18637	19254	18	by	by	IN
18637	19254	19	statute	statute	NN
18637	19254	20	,	,	,
18637	19254	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	19254	22	no	no	DT
18637	19254	23	further	further	RB
18637	19254	24	right	right	NN
18637	19254	25	to	to	TO
18637	19254	26	contest	contest	VB
18637	19254	27	the	the	DT
18637	19254	28	State	State	NNP
18637	19254	29	comptroller	comptroller	NN
18637	19254	30	's	's	POS
18637	19254	31	estimate	estimate	NN
18637	19254	32	of	of	IN
18637	19254	33	those	those	DT
18637	19254	34	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	19254	35	and	and	CC
18637	19254	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19254	37	adding	add	VBG
18637	19254	38	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	19254	39	the	the	DT
18637	19254	40	10	10	CD
18637	19254	41	%	%	NN
18637	19254	42	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	19254	43	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	19254	44	by	by	IN
18637	19254	45	law	law	NN
18637	19254	46	.	.	.
18637	19255	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19255	2	613	613	CD
18637	19255	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19255	4	Collection	Collection	NNP
18637	19255	5	of	of	IN
18637	19255	6	Taxes	Taxes	NNPS
18637	19255	7	To	to	TO
18637	19255	8	reach	reach	VB
18637	19255	9	property	property	NN
18637	19255	10	which	which	WDT
18637	19255	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	19255	12	escaped	escape	VBN
18637	19255	13	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19255	14	,	,	,
18637	19255	15	a	a	DT
18637	19255	16	State	state	NN
18637	19255	17	may	may	MD
18637	19255	18	tax	tax	VB
18637	19255	19	the	the	DT
18637	19255	20	estates	estate	NNS
18637	19255	21	of	of	IN
18637	19255	22	decedents	decedent	NNS
18637	19255	23	for	for	IN
18637	19255	24	a	a	DT
18637	19255	25	period	period	NN
18637	19255	26	anterior	anterior	JJ
18637	19255	27	to	to	IN
18637	19255	28	death	death	NN
18637	19255	29	and	and	CC
18637	19255	30	grant	grant	VB
18637	19255	31	proportionate	proportionate	NN
18637	19255	32	deductions	deduction	NNS
18637	19255	33	for	for	IN
18637	19255	34	all	all	DT
18637	19255	35	prior	prior	JJ
18637	19255	36	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19255	37	which	which	WDT
18637	19255	38	the	the	DT
18637	19255	39	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19255	40	representative	representative	NN
18637	19255	41	can	can	MD
18637	19255	42	prove	prove	VB
18637	19255	43	to	to	TO
18637	19255	44	have	have	VB
18637	19255	45	been	be	VBN
18637	19255	46	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19255	47	.	.	.
18637	19256	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19256	2	614	614	CD
18637	19256	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19256	4	Collection	collection	NN
18637	19256	5	of	of	IN
18637	19256	6	an	an	DT
18637	19256	7	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	19256	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	19256	9	also	also	RB
18637	19256	10	may	may	MD
18637	19256	11	be	be	VB
18637	19256	12	expedited	expedite	VBN
18637	19256	13	by	by	IN
18637	19256	14	a	a	DT
18637	19256	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	19256	16	requiring	require	VBG
18637	19256	17	the	the	DT
18637	19256	18	sealing	sealing	NN
18637	19256	19	of	of	IN
18637	19256	20	safe	safe	JJ
18637	19256	21	deposit	deposit	NN
18637	19256	22	boxes	box	NNS
18637	19256	23	for	for	IN
18637	19256	24	at	at	RB
18637	19256	25	least	least	JJS
18637	19256	26	ten	ten	CD
18637	19256	27	days	day	NNS
18637	19256	28	after	after	IN
18637	19256	29	the	the	DT
18637	19256	30	death	death	NN
18637	19256	31	of	of	IN
18637	19256	32	the	the	DT
18637	19256	33	renter	renter	NN
18637	19256	34	and	and	CC
18637	19256	35	obliging	oblige	VBG
18637	19256	36	the	the	DT
18637	19256	37	lessor	lessor	NN
18637	19256	38	to	to	TO
18637	19256	39	retain	retain	VB
18637	19256	40	assets	asset	NNS
18637	19256	41	found	find	VBN
18637	19256	42	therein	therein	RB
18637	19256	43	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19256	44	to	to	TO
18637	19256	45	pay	pay	VB
18637	19256	46	the	the	DT
18637	19256	47	tax	tax	NN
18637	19256	48	that	that	WDT
18637	19256	49	may	may	MD
18637	19256	50	be	be	VB
18637	19256	51	due	due	JJ
18637	19256	52	the	the	DT
18637	19256	53	State	state	NN
18637	19256	54	.	.	.
18637	19257	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19257	2	615	615	CD
18637	19257	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19257	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	19257	5	,	,	,
18637	19257	6	with	with	IN
18637	19257	7	a	a	DT
18637	19257	8	view	view	NN
18637	19257	9	to	to	IN
18637	19257	10	achieving	achieve	VBG
18637	19257	11	a	a	DT
18637	19257	12	like	like	JJ
18637	19257	13	result	result	NN
18637	19257	14	in	in	IN
18637	19257	15	the	the	DT
18637	19257	16	case	case	NN
18637	19257	17	of	of	IN
18637	19257	18	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	19257	19	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19257	20	,	,	,
18637	19257	21	a	a	DT
18637	19257	22	State	state	NN
18637	19257	23	may	may	MD
18637	19257	24	compel	compel	VB
18637	19257	25	retailers	retailer	NNS
18637	19257	26	to	to	TO
18637	19257	27	collect	collect	VB
18637	19257	28	such	such	JJ
18637	19257	29	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19257	30	from	from	IN
18637	19257	31	consumers	consumer	NNS
18637	19257	32	and	and	CC
18637	19257	33	,	,	,
18637	19257	34	under	under	IN
18637	19257	35	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	19257	36	of	of	IN
18637	19257	37	a	a	DT
18637	19257	38	fine	fine	NN
18637	19257	39	for	for	IN
18637	19257	40	delinquency	delinquency	NN
18637	19257	41	,	,	,
18637	19257	42	to	to	TO
18637	19257	43	remit	remit	VB
18637	19257	44	monthly	monthly	RB
18637	19257	45	the	the	DT
18637	19257	46	amounts	amount	NNS
18637	19257	47	thus	thus	RB
18637	19257	48	collected	collect	VBN
18637	19257	49	.	.	.
18637	19258	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19258	2	616	616	CD
18637	19258	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19258	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19258	5	,	,	,
18637	19258	6	a	a	DT
18637	19258	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	19258	8	on	on	IN
18637	19258	9	the	the	DT
18637	19258	10	tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	19258	11	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19258	12	property	property	NN
18637	19258	13	of	of	IN
18637	19258	14	a	a	DT
18637	19258	15	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19258	16	owner	owner	NN
18637	19258	17	may	may	MD
18637	19258	18	be	be	VB
18637	19258	19	collected	collect	VBN
18637	19258	20	from	from	IN
18637	19258	21	the	the	DT
18637	19258	22	custodian	custodian	JJ
18637	19258	23	or	or	CC
18637	19258	24	possessor	possessor	NN
18637	19258	25	of	of	IN
18637	19258	26	such	such	JJ
18637	19258	27	property	property	NN
18637	19258	28	,	,	,
18637	19258	29	and	and	CC
18637	19258	30	the	the	DT
18637	19258	31	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19258	32	,	,	,
18637	19258	33	as	as	IN
18637	19258	34	an	an	DT
18637	19258	35	assurance	assurance	NN
18637	19258	36	of	of	IN
18637	19258	37	reimbursement	reimbursement	NN
18637	19258	38	,	,	,
18637	19258	39	may	may	MD
18637	19258	40	be	be	VB
18637	19258	41	granted	grant	VBN
18637	19258	42	a	a	DT
18637	19258	43	lien	lien	NN
18637	19258	44	on	on	IN
18637	19258	45	such	such	JJ
18637	19258	46	property	property	NN
18637	19258	47	.	.	.
18637	19259	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19259	2	617	617	CD
18637	19259	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19259	4	In	in	IN
18637	19259	5	collecting	collect	VBG
18637	19259	6	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19259	7	income	income	NN
18637	19259	8	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19259	9	,	,	,
18637	19259	10	however	however	RB
18637	19259	11	,	,	,
18637	19259	12	most	most	JJS
18637	19259	13	States	state	NNS
18637	19259	14	require	require	VBP
18637	19259	15	employers	employer	NNS
18637	19259	16	to	to	TO
18637	19259	17	deduct	deduct	VB
18637	19259	18	and	and	CC
18637	19259	19	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	19259	20	the	the	DT
18637	19259	21	tax	tax	NN
18637	19259	22	from	from	IN
18637	19259	23	the	the	DT
18637	19259	24	wages	wage	NNS
18637	19259	25	of	of	IN
18637	19259	26	only	only	JJ
18637	19259	27	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19259	28	employees	employee	NNS
18637	19259	29	;	;	:
18637	19259	30	but	but	CC
18637	19259	31	the	the	DT
18637	19259	32	duty	duty	NN
18637	19259	33	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	19259	34	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19259	35	on	on	IN
18637	19259	36	the	the	DT
18637	19259	37	employer	employer	NN
18637	19259	38	has	have	VBZ
18637	19259	39	never	never	RB
18637	19259	40	been	be	VBN
18637	19259	41	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19259	42	as	as	IN
18637	19259	43	depriving	deprive	VBG
18637	19259	44	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19259	45	of	of	IN
18637	19259	46	property	property	NN
18637	19259	47	without	without	IN
18637	19259	48	due	due	JJ
18637	19259	49	process	process	NN
18637	19259	50	of	of	IN
18637	19259	51	law	law	NN
18637	19259	52	,	,	,
18637	19259	53	nor	nor	CC
18637	19259	54	has	have	VBZ
18637	19259	55	the	the	DT
18637	19259	56	adjustment	adjustment	NN
18637	19259	57	of	of	IN
18637	19259	58	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19259	59	system	system	NN
18637	19259	60	of	of	IN
18637	19259	61	accounting	accounting	NN
18637	19259	62	and	and	CC
18637	19259	63	paying	pay	VBG
18637	19259	64	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	19259	65	which	which	WDT
18637	19259	66	withholding	withholding	NN
18637	19259	67	entails	entail	NNS
18637	19259	68	been	be	VBN
18637	19259	69	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19259	70	as	as	IN
18637	19259	71	an	an	DT
18637	19259	72	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19259	73	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	19259	74	of	of	IN
18637	19259	75	the	the	DT
18637	19259	76	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	19259	77	of	of	IN
18637	19259	78	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19259	79	business	business	NN
18637	19259	80	.	.	.
18637	19260	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19260	2	618	618	CD
18637	19260	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19260	4	As	as	IN
18637	19260	5	a	a	DT
18637	19260	6	State	state	NN
18637	19260	7	may	may	MD
18637	19260	8	provide	provide	VB
18637	19260	9	in	in	IN
18637	19260	10	advance	advance	NN
18637	19260	11	that	that	IN
18637	19260	12	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19260	13	shall	shall	MD
18637	19260	14	bear	bear	VB
18637	19260	15	interest	interest	NN
18637	19260	16	from	from	IN
18637	19260	17	the	the	DT
18637	19260	18	time	time	NN
18637	19260	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19260	20	become	become	VBP
18637	19260	21	due	due	JJ
18637	19260	22	,	,	,
18637	19260	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19260	24	may	may	MD
18637	19260	25	with	with	IN
18637	19260	26	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19260	27	validity	validity	NN
18637	19260	28	stipulate	stipulate	NN
18637	19260	29	that	that	IN
18637	19260	30	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19260	31	which	which	WDT
18637	19260	32	have	have	VBP
18637	19260	33	become	become	VBN
18637	19260	34	delinquent	delinquent	JJ
18637	19260	35	shall	shall	MD
18637	19260	36	bear	bear	VB
18637	19260	37	interest	interest	NN
18637	19260	38	from	from	IN
18637	19260	39	the	the	DT
18637	19260	40	time	time	NN
18637	19260	41	the	the	DT
18637	19260	42	delinquency	delinquency	NN
18637	19260	43	commenced	commence	VBD
18637	19260	44	.	.	.
18637	19261	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19261	2	,	,	,
18637	19261	3	a	a	DT
18637	19261	4	State	state	NN
18637	19261	5	may	may	MD
18637	19261	6	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	19261	7	new	new	JJ
18637	19261	8	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	19261	9	for	for	IN
18637	19261	10	the	the	DT
18637	19261	11	collection	collection	NN
18637	19261	12	of	of	IN
18637	19261	13	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19261	14	and	and	CC
18637	19261	15	apply	apply	VB
18637	19261	16	these	these	DT
18637	19261	17	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	19261	18	to	to	IN
18637	19261	19	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19261	20	already	already	RB
18637	19261	21	delinquent	delinquent	JJ
18637	19261	22	.	.	.
18637	19262	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19262	2	619	619	CD
18637	19262	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19262	4	After	after	IN
18637	19262	5	liability	liability	NN
18637	19262	6	of	of	IN
18637	19262	7	a	a	DT
18637	19262	8	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	19262	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	19262	10	been	be	VBN
18637	19262	11	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	19262	12	by	by	IN
18637	19262	13	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	19262	14	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19262	15	,	,	,
18637	19262	16	collection	collection	NN
18637	19262	17	of	of	IN
18637	19262	18	a	a	DT
18637	19262	19	tax	tax	NN
18637	19262	20	by	by	IN
18637	19262	21	distress	distress	NN
18637	19262	22	and	and	CC
18637	19262	23	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	19262	24	of	of	IN
18637	19262	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19262	26	person	person	NN
18637	19262	27	does	do	VBZ
18637	19262	28	not	not	RB
18637	19262	29	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	19262	30	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19262	31	of	of	IN
18637	19262	32	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19262	33	without	without	IN
18637	19262	34	due	due	JJ
18637	19262	35	process	process	NN
18637	19262	36	of	of	IN
18637	19262	37	law	law	NN
18637	19262	38	.	.	.
18637	19263	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19263	2	620	620	CD
18637	19263	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19263	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19263	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19263	6	a	a	DT
18637	19263	7	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19263	8	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19263	9	company	company	NN
18637	19263	10	denied	deny	VBD
18637	19263	11	due	due	JJ
18637	19263	12	process	process	NN
18637	19263	13	of	of	IN
18637	19263	14	law	law	NN
18637	19263	15	when	when	WRB
18637	19263	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19263	17	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19263	18	property	property	NN
18637	19263	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	19263	20	distrained	distrain	VBN
18637	19263	21	to	to	TO
18637	19263	22	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	19263	23	unpaid	unpaid	JJ
18637	19263	24	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19263	25	.	.	.
18637	19264	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19264	2	621	621	CD
18637	19264	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19264	4	The	the	DT
18637	19264	5	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	19264	6	of	of	IN
18637	19264	7	due	due	JJ
18637	19264	8	process	process	NN
18637	19264	9	are	be	VBP
18637	19264	10	fulfilled	fulfil	VBN
18637	19264	11	by	by	IN
18637	19264	12	a	a	DT
18637	19264	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	19264	14	which	which	WDT
18637	19264	15	,	,	,
18637	19264	16	in	in	IN
18637	19264	17	conjunction	conjunction	NN
18637	19264	18	with	with	IN
18637	19264	19	affording	afford	VBG
18637	19264	20	an	an	DT
18637	19264	21	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19264	22	to	to	TO
18637	19264	23	be	be	VB
18637	19264	24	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19264	25	,	,	,
18637	19264	26	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	19264	27	for	for	IN
18637	19264	28	the	the	DT
18637	19264	29	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	19264	30	of	of	IN
18637	19264	31	titles	title	NNS
18637	19264	32	to	to	TO
18637	19264	33	land	land	VB
18637	19264	34	for	for	IN
18637	19264	35	failure	failure	NN
18637	19264	36	to	to	TO
18637	19264	37	list	list	VB
18637	19264	38	and	and	CC
18637	19264	39	pay	pay	VB
18637	19264	40	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19264	41	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	19264	42	for	for	IN
18637	19264	43	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19264	44	specified	specified	JJ
18637	19264	45	years	year	NNS
18637	19264	46	.	.	.
18637	19265	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19265	2	622	622	CD
18637	19265	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19265	4	No	no	RB
18637	19265	5	less	less	RBR
18637	19265	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19265	7	,	,	,
18637	19265	8	as	as	IN
18637	19265	9	a	a	DT
18637	19265	10	means	means	NN
18637	19265	11	of	of	IN
18637	19265	12	facilitating	facilitate	VBG
18637	19265	13	collection	collection	NN
18637	19265	14	,	,	,
18637	19265	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	19265	16	an	an	DT
18637	19265	17	_	_	NNP
18637	19265	18	in	in	IN
18637	19265	19	rem	rem	NN
18637	19265	20	_	_	NNP
18637	19265	21	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19265	22	,	,	,
18637	19265	23	to	to	TO
18637	19265	24	which	which	WDT
18637	19265	25	the	the	DT
18637	19265	26	land	land	NN
18637	19265	27	alone	alone	RB
18637	19265	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	19265	29	made	make	VBN
18637	19265	30	a	a	DT
18637	19265	31	party	party	NN
18637	19265	32	,	,	,
18637	19265	33	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	19265	34	tax	tax	NN
18637	19265	35	liens	lien	NNS
18637	19265	36	on	on	IN
18637	19265	37	land	land	NN
18637	19265	38	are	be	VBP
18637	19265	39	foreclosed	foreclose	VBN
18637	19265	40	and	and	CC
18637	19265	41	all	all	DT
18637	19265	42	pre	pre	JJ
18637	19265	43	-	-	JJ
18637	19265	44	existing	existing	JJ
18637	19265	45	rights	right	NNS
18637	19265	46	or	or	CC
18637	19265	47	liens	lien	NNS
18637	19265	48	are	be	VBP
18637	19265	49	eliminated	eliminate	VBN
18637	19265	50	by	by	IN
18637	19265	51	a	a	DT
18637	19265	52	sale	sale	NN
18637	19265	53	under	under	IN
18637	19265	54	a	a	DT
18637	19265	55	decree	decree	NN
18637	19265	56	in	in	IN
18637	19265	57	said	say	VBD
18637	19265	58	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19265	59	.	.	.
18637	19266	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19266	2	623	623	CD
18637	19266	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19266	4	On	on	IN
18637	19266	5	the	the	DT
18637	19266	6	other	other	JJ
18637	19266	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	19266	8	,	,	,
18637	19266	9	while	while	IN
18637	19266	10	the	the	DT
18637	19266	11	conversion	conversion	NN
18637	19266	12	of	of	IN
18637	19266	13	an	an	DT
18637	19266	14	unpaid	unpaid	JJ
18637	19266	15	special	special	JJ
18637	19266	16	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19266	17	into	into	IN
18637	19266	18	both	both	CC
18637	19266	19	a	a	DT
18637	19266	20	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19266	21	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19266	22	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	19266	23	against	against	IN
18637	19266	24	the	the	DT
18637	19266	25	owner	owner	NN
18637	19266	26	as	as	RB
18637	19266	27	well	well	RB
18637	19266	28	as	as	IN
18637	19266	29	a	a	DT
18637	19266	30	charge	charge	NN
18637	19266	31	on	on	IN
18637	19266	32	the	the	DT
18637	19266	33	land	land	NN
18637	19266	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	19266	35	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	19266	36	with	with	IN
18637	19266	37	the	the	DT
18637	19266	38	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19266	39	Amendment,[624	Amendment,[624	NNP
18637	19266	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19266	41	a	a	DT
18637	19266	42	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19266	43	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	19266	44	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19266	45	liability	liability	NN
18637	19266	46	against	against	IN
18637	19266	47	a	a	DT
18637	19266	48	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19266	49	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	19266	50	over	over	IN
18637	19266	51	whom	whom	WP
18637	19266	52	the	the	DT
18637	19266	53	State	State	NNP
18637	19266	54	court	court	NN
18637	19266	55	acquired	acquire	VBD
18637	19266	56	no	no	DT
18637	19266	57	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19266	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	19266	59	void	void	JJ
18637	19266	60	.	.	.
18637	19267	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19267	2	625	625	CD
18637	19267	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19267	4	Apart	apart	RB
18637	19267	5	from	from	IN
18637	19267	6	such	such	JJ
18637	19267	7	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	19267	8	,	,	,
18637	19267	9	however	however	RB
18637	19267	10	,	,	,
18637	19267	11	a	a	DT
18637	19267	12	State	state	NN
18637	19267	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	19267	14	free	free	JJ
18637	19267	15	to	to	TO
18637	19267	16	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	19267	17	new	new	JJ
18637	19267	18	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	19267	19	for	for	IN
18637	19267	20	the	the	DT
18637	19267	21	collection	collection	NN
18637	19267	22	of	of	IN
18637	19267	23	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19267	24	and	and	CC
18637	19267	25	even	even	RB
18637	19267	26	to	to	TO
18637	19267	27	apply	apply	VB
18637	19267	28	new	new	JJ
18637	19267	29	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	19267	30	to	to	IN
18637	19267	31	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19267	32	already	already	RB
18637	19267	33	delinquent	delinquent	JJ
18637	19267	34	.	.	.
18637	19268	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19268	2	626	626	CD
18637	19268	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19268	4	EMINENT	EMINENT	NNP
18637	19268	5	DOMAIN	DOMAIN	NNP
18637	19268	6	Historical	Historical	NNP
18637	19268	7	Development	Development	NNP
18637	19268	8	"	"	''
18637	19268	9	Prior	prior	RB
18637	19268	10	to	to	IN
18637	19268	11	the	the	DT
18637	19268	12	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	19268	13	of	of	IN
18637	19268	14	the	the	DT
18637	19268	15	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19268	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19268	17	,	,	,
18637	19268	18	"	"	''
18637	19268	19	the	the	DT
18637	19268	20	power	power	NN
18637	19268	21	of	of	IN
18637	19268	22	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	19268	23	domain	domain	NN
18637	19268	24	,	,	,
18637	19268	25	which	which	WDT
18637	19268	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	19268	27	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19268	28	to	to	TO
18637	19268	29	inhere	inhere	VB
18637	19268	30	in	in	IN
18637	19268	31	every	every	DT
18637	19268	32	State	State	NNP
18637	19268	33	and	and	CC
18637	19268	34	to	to	TO
18637	19268	35	be	be	VB
18637	19268	36	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19268	37	to	to	IN
18637	19268	38	the	the	DT
18637	19268	39	performance	performance	NN
18637	19268	40	of	of	IN
18637	19268	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19268	42	functions,[627	functions,[627	NN
18637	19268	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19268	44	"	"	``
18637	19268	45	was	be	VBD
18637	19268	46	unrestrained	unrestrained	JJ
18637	19268	47	by	by	IN
18637	19268	48	any	any	DT
18637	19268	49	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19268	50	authority	authority	NN
18637	19268	51	.	.	.
18637	19269	1	"	"	``
18637	19269	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19269	3	628	628	CD
18637	19269	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19269	5	An	an	DT
18637	19269	6	express	express	JJ
18637	19269	7	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	19269	8	against	against	IN
18637	19269	9	the	the	DT
18637	19269	10	taking	taking	NN
18637	19269	11	of	of	IN
18637	19269	12	private	private	JJ
18637	19269	13	property	property	NN
18637	19269	14	for	for	IN
18637	19269	15	public	public	JJ
18637	19269	16	use	use	NN
18637	19269	17	without	without	IN
18637	19269	18	just	just	RB
18637	19269	19	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19269	20	was	be	VBD
18637	19269	21	contained	contain	VBN
18637	19269	22	in	in	IN
18637	19269	23	the	the	DT
18637	19269	24	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	19269	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19269	26	;	;	:
18637	19269	27	but	but	CC
18637	19269	28	an	an	DT
18637	19269	29	effort	effort	NN
18637	19269	30	to	to	TO
18637	19269	31	extend	extend	VB
18637	19269	32	the	the	DT
18637	19269	33	application	application	NN
18637	19269	34	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19269	35	to	to	IN
18637	19269	36	the	the	DT
18637	19269	37	States	States	NNP
18637	19269	38	had	have	VBD
18637	19269	39	been	be	VBN
18637	19269	40	defeated	defeat	VBN
18637	19269	41	by	by	IN
18637	19269	42	the	the	DT
18637	19269	43	decision	decision	NN
18637	19269	44	,	,	,
18637	19269	45	in	in	IN
18637	19269	46	1833	1833	CD
18637	19269	47	,	,	,
18637	19269	48	in	in	IN
18637	19269	49	Barron	Barron	NNP
18637	19269	50	_	_	NNP
18637	19269	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	19269	52	_	_	NNP
18637	19269	53	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	19269	54	.	.	.
18637	19270	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19270	2	629	629	CD
18637	19270	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19270	4	The	the	DT
18637	19270	5	most	most	RBS
18637	19270	6	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	19270	7	comparable	comparable	JJ
18637	19270	8	provision	provision	NN
18637	19270	9	included	include	VBN
18637	19270	10	in	in	IN
18637	19270	11	the	the	DT
18637	19270	12	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19270	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19270	14	,	,	,
18637	19270	15	was	be	VBD
18637	19270	16	the	the	DT
18637	19270	17	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	19270	18	against	against	IN
18637	19270	19	a	a	DT
18637	19270	20	State	state	NN
18637	19270	21	depriving	deprive	VBG
18637	19270	22	a	a	DT
18637	19270	23	person	person	NN
18637	19270	24	of	of	IN
18637	19270	25	property	property	NN
18637	19270	26	without	without	IN
18637	19270	27	due	due	JJ
18637	19270	28	process	process	NN
18637	19270	29	of	of	IN
18637	19270	30	law	law	NN
18637	19270	31	.	.	.
18637	19271	1	The	the	DT
18637	19271	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19271	3	was	be	VBD
18637	19271	4	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19271	5	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	19271	6	with	with	IN
18637	19271	7	the	the	DT
18637	19271	8	task	task	NN
18637	19271	9	of	of	IN
18637	19271	10	determining	determine	VBG
18637	19271	11	whether	whether	IN
18637	19271	12	this	this	DT
18637	19271	13	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	19271	14	on	on	IN
18637	19271	15	State	State	NNP
18637	19271	16	action	action	NN
18637	19271	17	,	,	,
18637	19271	18	minus	minus	CC
18637	19271	19	the	the	DT
18637	19271	20	explicit	explicit	JJ
18637	19271	21	provision	provision	NN
18637	19271	22	for	for	IN
18637	19271	23	just	just	RB
18637	19271	24	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19271	25	found	find	VBN
18637	19271	26	in	in	IN
18637	19271	27	the	the	DT
18637	19271	28	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	19271	29	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19271	30	,	,	,
18637	19271	31	afforded	afford	VBD
18637	19271	32	property	property	NN
18637	19271	33	owners	owner	NNS
18637	19271	34	the	the	DT
18637	19271	35	same	same	JJ
18637	19271	36	measure	measure	NN
18637	19271	37	of	of	IN
18637	19271	38	protection	protection	NN
18637	19271	39	as	as	IN
18637	19271	40	did	do	VBD
18637	19271	41	the	the	DT
18637	19271	42	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19271	43	in	in	IN
18637	19271	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19271	45	operation	operation	NN
18637	19271	46	as	as	IN
18637	19271	47	a	a	DT
18637	19271	48	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	19271	49	on	on	IN
18637	19271	50	the	the	DT
18637	19271	51	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	19271	52	Government	Government	NNP
18637	19271	53	.	.	.
18637	19272	1	The	the	DT
18637	19272	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19272	3	's	's	POS
18637	19272	4	initial	initial	JJ
18637	19272	5	answer	answer	NN
18637	19272	6	to	to	IN
18637	19272	7	this	this	DT
18637	19272	8	question	question	NN
18637	19272	9	,	,	,
18637	19272	10	as	as	IN
18637	19272	11	set	set	VBN
18637	19272	12	forth	forth	RP
18637	19272	13	in	in	IN
18637	19272	14	Davidson	Davidson	NNP
18637	19272	15	_	_	NNP
18637	19272	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	19272	17	_	_	NNP
18637	19272	18	New	New	NNP
18637	19272	19	Orleans,[630	Orleans,[630	NNP
18637	19272	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19272	21	decided	decide	VBD
18637	19272	22	in	in	IN
18637	19272	23	1878	1878	CD
18637	19272	24	,	,	,
18637	19272	25	was	be	VBD
18637	19272	26	in	in	IN
18637	19272	27	the	the	DT
18637	19272	28	negative	negative	JJ
18637	19272	29	;	;	:
18637	19272	30	and	and	CC
18637	19272	31	on	on	IN
18637	19272	32	the	the	DT
18637	19272	33	ground	ground	NN
18637	19272	34	of	of	IN
18637	19272	35	the	the	DT
18637	19272	36	omission	omission	NN
18637	19272	37	of	of	IN
18637	19272	38	the	the	DT
18637	19272	39	clause	clause	NN
18637	19272	40	found	find	VBN
18637	19272	41	in	in	IN
18637	19272	42	the	the	DT
18637	19272	43	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	19272	44	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19272	45	from	from	IN
18637	19272	46	the	the	DT
18637	19272	47	terms	term	NNS
18637	19272	48	of	of	IN
18637	19272	49	the	the	DT
18637	19272	50	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19272	51	,	,	,
18637	19272	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19272	53	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	19272	54	to	to	TO
18637	19272	55	equate	equate	VB
18637	19272	56	the	the	DT
18637	19272	57	just	just	JJ
18637	19272	58	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19272	59	with	with	IN
18637	19272	60	due	due	JJ
18637	19272	61	process	process	NN
18637	19272	62	.	.	.
18637	19273	1	Within	within	IN
18637	19273	2	less	less	JJR
18637	19273	3	than	than	IN
18637	19273	4	a	a	DT
18637	19273	5	decade	decade	NN
18637	19273	6	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	19273	7	,	,	,
18637	19273	8	however	however	RB
18637	19273	9	,	,	,
18637	19273	10	the	the	DT
18637	19273	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19273	12	modified	modify	VBD
18637	19273	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19273	14	position	position	NN
18637	19273	15	,	,	,
18637	19273	16	and	and	CC
18637	19273	17	in	in	IN
18637	19273	18	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	19273	19	,	,	,
18637	19273	20	B.	B.	NNP
18637	19274	1	&	&	CC
18637	19274	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	19275	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	19275	2	_	_	NNP
18637	19275	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	19275	4	_	_	NNP
18637	19275	5	Chicago,[631	Chicago,[631	NNP
18637	19275	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19275	7	seven	seven	CD
18637	19275	8	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	19275	9	unequivocally	unequivocally	RB
18637	19275	10	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	19275	11	the	the	DT
18637	19275	12	contention	contention	NN
18637	19275	13	,	,	,
18637	19275	14	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	19275	15	based	base	VBN
18637	19275	16	on	on	IN
18637	19275	17	the	the	DT
18637	19275	18	Davidson	Davidson	NNP
18637	19275	19	Case	Case	NNP
18637	19275	20	that	that	IN
18637	19275	21	"	"	``
18637	19275	22	the	the	DT
18637	19275	23	question	question	NN
18637	19275	24	as	as	IN
18637	19275	25	to	to	IN
18637	19275	26	the	the	DT
18637	19275	27	amount	amount	NN
18637	19275	28	of	of	IN
18637	19275	29	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19275	30	to	to	TO
18637	19275	31	be	be	VB
18637	19275	32	awarded	award	VBN
18637	19275	33	to	to	IN
18637	19275	34	the	the	DT
18637	19275	35	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19275	36	company	company	NN
18637	19275	37	was	be	VBD
18637	19275	38	one	one	CD
18637	19275	39	of	of	IN
18637	19275	40	local	local	JJ
18637	19275	41	law	law	NN
18637	19275	42	merely	merely	RB
18637	19275	43	,	,	,
18637	19275	44	and	and	CC
18637	19275	45	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19275	46	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	19275	47	as	as	IN
18637	19275	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19275	49	that	that	DT
18637	19275	50	question	question	NN
18637	19275	51	was	be	VBD
18637	19275	52	determined	determine	VBN
18637	19275	53	in	in	IN
18637	19275	54	the	the	DT
18637	19275	55	mode	mode	NN
18637	19275	56	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	19275	57	by	by	IN
18637	19275	58	the	the	DT
18637	19275	59	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19275	60	and	and	CC
18637	19275	61	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19275	62	State	state	NN
18637	19275	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19275	64	law	law	NN
18637	19275	65	,	,	,
18637	19275	66	the	the	DT
18637	19275	67	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19275	68	property	property	NN
18637	19275	69	owner	owner	NN
18637	19275	70	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19275	71	appearing	appear	VBG
18637	19275	72	and	and	CC
18637	19275	73	having	have	VBG
18637	19275	74	full	full	JJ
18637	19275	75	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19275	76	to	to	TO
18637	19275	77	be	be	VB
18637	19275	78	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19275	79	,	,	,
18637	19275	80	the	the	DT
18637	19275	81	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19275	82	of	of	IN
18637	19275	83	due	due	JJ
18637	19275	84	process	process	NN
18637	19275	85	of	of	IN
18637	19275	86	law	law	NN
18637	19275	87	was	be	VBD
18637	19275	88	observed	observe	VBN
18637	19275	89	.	.	.
18637	19275	90	"	"	''
18637	19276	1	On	on	IN
18637	19276	2	the	the	DT
18637	19276	3	contrary	contrary	NN
18637	19276	4	,	,	,
18637	19276	5	the	the	DT
18637	19276	6	seven	seven	CD
18637	19276	7	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19276	8	maintained	maintain	VBD
18637	19276	9	that	that	IN
18637	19276	10	although	although	IN
18637	19276	11	a	a	DT
18637	19276	12	State	State	NNP
18637	19276	13	"	"	''
18637	19276	14	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	19276	15	may	may	MD
18637	19276	16	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	19276	17	a	a	DT
18637	19276	18	form	form	NN
18637	19276	19	of	of	IN
18637	19276	20	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19276	21	to	to	TO
18637	19276	22	be	be	VB
18637	19276	23	observed	observe	VBN
18637	19276	24	in	in	IN
18637	19276	25	the	the	DT
18637	19276	26	taking	taking	NN
18637	19276	27	of	of	IN
18637	19276	28	private	private	JJ
18637	19276	29	property	property	NN
18637	19276	30	for	for	IN
18637	19276	31	public	public	JJ
18637	19276	32	use	use	NN
18637	19276	33	,	,	,
18637	19276	34	*	*	NFP
18637	19276	35	*	*	NFP
18637	19276	36	*	*	NFP
18637	19276	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19276	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	19276	39	not	not	RB
18637	19276	40	due	due	JJ
18637	19276	41	process	process	NN
18637	19276	42	of	of	IN
18637	19276	43	law	law	NN
18637	19276	44	if	if	IN
18637	19276	45	provision	provision	NN
18637	19276	46	be	be	VB
18637	19276	47	not	not	RB
18637	19276	48	made	make	VBN
18637	19276	49	for	for	IN
18637	19276	50	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19276	51	*	*	NFP
18637	19276	52	*	*	NFP
18637	19276	53	*	*	NFP
18637	19276	54	The	the	DT
18637	19276	55	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19276	56	form	form	NN
18637	19276	57	of	of	IN
18637	19276	58	the	the	DT
18637	19276	59	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19276	60	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	19276	61	against	against	IN
18637	19276	62	the	the	DT
18637	19276	63	owner	owner	NN
18637	19276	64	,	,	,
18637	19276	65	*	*	NFP
18637	19276	66	*	*	NFP
18637	19276	67	*	*	NFP
18637	19276	68	,	,	,
18637	19276	69	can	can	MD
18637	19276	70	not	not	RB
18637	19276	71	convert	convert	VB
18637	19276	72	the	the	DT
18637	19276	73	process	process	NN
18637	19276	74	used	use	VBN
18637	19276	75	into	into	IN
18637	19276	76	due	due	JJ
18637	19276	77	process	process	NN
18637	19276	78	of	of	IN
18637	19276	79	law	law	NN
18637	19276	80	,	,	,
18637	19276	81	if	if	IN
18637	19276	82	the	the	DT
18637	19276	83	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19276	84	result	result	NN
18637	19276	85	be	be	VB
18637	19276	86	to	to	TO
18637	19276	87	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	19276	88	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19276	89	of	of	IN
18637	19276	90	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19276	91	property	property	NN
18637	19276	92	without	without	IN
18637	19276	93	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19276	94	.	.	.
18637	19276	95	"	"	''
18637	19277	1	Public	Public	NNP
18637	19277	2	Use	Use	NNP
18637	19277	3	While	while	IN
18637	19277	4	acknowledging	acknowledge	VBG
18637	19277	5	that	that	DT
18637	19277	6	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	19277	7	was	be	VBD
18637	19277	8	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	19277	9	nonexistent	nonexistent	JJ
18637	19277	10	as	as	IN
18637	19277	11	to	to	IN
18637	19277	12	"	"	``
18637	19277	13	what	what	WP
18637	19277	14	are	be	VBP
18637	19277	15	public	public	JJ
18637	19277	16	uses	use	NNS
18637	19277	17	for	for	IN
18637	19277	18	which	which	WDT
18637	19277	19	the	the	DT
18637	19277	20	right	right	NN
18637	19277	21	of	of	IN
18637	19277	22	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	19277	23	taking	taking	NN
18637	19277	24	may	may	MD
18637	19277	25	be	be	VB
18637	19277	26	employed	employ	VBN
18637	19277	27	,	,	,
18637	19277	28	"	"	''
18637	19277	29	the	the	DT
18637	19277	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19277	31	,	,	,
18637	19277	32	until	until	IN
18637	19277	33	1946	1946	CD
18637	19277	34	,	,	,
18637	19277	35	continued	continue	VBD
18637	19277	36	to	to	TO
18637	19277	37	reiterate	reiterate	VB
18637	19277	38	"	"	``
18637	19277	39	the	the	DT
18637	19277	40	nature	nature	NN
18637	19277	41	of	of	IN
18637	19277	42	the	the	DT
18637	19277	43	uses	use	NNS
18637	19277	44	,	,	,
18637	19277	45	whether	whether	IN
18637	19277	46	public	public	JJ
18637	19277	47	or	or	CC
18637	19277	48	private	private	JJ
18637	19277	49	,	,	,
18637	19277	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	19277	51	ultimately	ultimately	RB
18637	19277	52	a	a	DT
18637	19277	53	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19277	54	question	question	NN
18637	19277	55	.	.	.
18637	19278	1	"	"	``
18637	19278	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19278	3	632	632	CD
18637	19278	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19278	5	But	but	CC
18637	19278	6	because	because	IN
18637	19278	7	of	of	IN
18637	19278	8	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
18637	19278	9	willingness	willingness	NN
18637	19278	10	to	to	TO
18637	19278	11	defer	defer	VB
18637	19278	12	to	to	IN
18637	19278	13	local	local	JJ
18637	19278	14	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	19278	15	,	,	,
18637	19278	16	especially	especially	RB
18637	19278	17	"	"	``
18637	19278	18	the	the	DT
18637	19278	19	highest	high	JJS
18637	19278	20	court	court	NN
18637	19278	21	of	of	IN
18637	19278	22	the	the	DT
18637	19278	23	State	State	NNP
18637	19278	24	"	"	''
18637	19278	25	in	in	IN
18637	19278	26	resolving	resolve	VBG
18637	19278	27	such	such	PDT
18637	19278	28	an	an	DT
18637	19278	29	issue,[633	issue,[633	NNP
18637	19278	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19278	31	the	the	DT
18637	19278	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19278	33	,	,	,
18637	19278	34	as	as	RB
18637	19278	35	early	early	RB
18637	19278	36	as	as	IN
18637	19278	37	1908	1908	CD
18637	19278	38	,	,	,
18637	19278	39	was	be	VBD
18637	19278	40	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	19278	41	to	to	TO
18637	19278	42	admit	admit	VB
18637	19278	43	that	that	IN
18637	19278	44	,	,	,
18637	19278	45	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19278	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19278	47	retention	retention	NN
18637	19278	48	of	of	IN
18637	19278	49	the	the	DT
18637	19278	50	power	power	NN
18637	19278	51	of	of	IN
18637	19278	52	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19278	53	review	review	NN
18637	19278	54	,	,	,
18637	19278	55	"	"	``
18637	19278	56	no	no	DT
18637	19278	57	case	case	NN
18637	19278	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	19278	59	recalled	recall	VBN
18637	19278	60	where	where	WRB
18637	19278	61	this	this	DT
18637	19278	62	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19278	63	has	have	VBZ
18637	19278	64	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	19278	65	as	as	IN
18637	19278	66	a	a	DT
18637	19278	67	violation	violation	NN
18637	19278	68	of	of	IN
18637	19278	69	the	the	DT
18637	19278	70	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19278	71	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19278	72	a	a	DT
18637	19278	73	taking	taking	NN
18637	19278	74	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	19278	75	by	by	IN
18637	19278	76	the	the	DT
18637	19278	77	State	State	NNP
18637	19278	78	court	court	NN
18637	19278	79	as	as	IN
18637	19278	80	a	a	DT
18637	19278	81	taking	taking	NN
18637	19278	82	for	for	IN
18637	19278	83	public	public	JJ
18637	19278	84	uses	use	NNS
18637	19278	85	*	*	NFP
18637	19278	86	*	*	NFP
18637	19278	87	*	*	NFP
18637	19278	88	"	"	''
18637	19278	89	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19278	90	634	634	CD
18637	19278	91	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19278	92	In	in	IN
18637	19278	93	1946	1946	CD
18637	19278	94	,	,	,
18637	19278	95	however	however	RB
18637	19278	96	,	,	,
18637	19278	97	without	without	IN
18637	19278	98	endeavoring	endeavor	VBG
18637	19278	99	to	to	TO
18637	19278	100	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	19278	101	whether	whether	IN
18637	19278	102	"	"	``
18637	19278	103	the	the	DT
18637	19278	104	scope	scope	NN
18637	19278	105	of	of	IN
18637	19278	106	the	the	DT
18637	19278	107	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19278	108	power	power	NN
18637	19278	109	to	to	TO
18637	19278	110	determine	determine	VB
18637	19278	111	what	what	WP
18637	19278	112	is	be	VBZ
18637	19278	113	a	a	DT
18637	19278	114	'	'	``
18637	19278	115	public	public	JJ
18637	19278	116	use	use	NN
18637	19278	117	'	'	''
18637	19278	118	in	in	IN
18637	19278	119	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19278	120	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19278	121	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	19278	122	,	,	,
18637	19278	123	*	*	NFP
18637	19278	124	*	*	NFP
18637	19278	125	*	*	NFP
18637	19278	126	"	"	``
18637	19278	127	is	be	VBZ
18637	19278	128	the	the	DT
18637	19278	129	same	same	JJ
18637	19278	130	as	as	IN
18637	19278	131	under	under	IN
18637	19278	132	the	the	DT
18637	19278	133	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	19278	134	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19278	135	,	,	,
18637	19278	136	a	a	DT
18637	19278	137	majority	majority	NN
18637	19278	138	of	of	IN
18637	19278	139	the	the	DT
18637	19278	140	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19278	141	,	,	,
18637	19278	142	in	in	IN
18637	19278	143	a	a	DT
18637	19278	144	decision	decision	NN
18637	19278	145	involving	involve	VBG
18637	19278	146	the	the	DT
18637	19278	147	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	19278	148	Government	Government	NNP
18637	19278	149	,	,	,
18637	19278	150	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19278	151	that	that	IN
18637	19278	152	"	"	``
18637	19278	153	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19278	154	is	be	VBZ
18637	19278	155	the	the	DT
18637	19278	156	function	function	NN
18637	19278	157	of	of	IN
18637	19278	158	*	*	NFP
18637	19278	159	*	*	NFP
18637	19278	160	*	*	NFP
18637	19278	161	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19278	162	the	the	DT
18637	19278	163	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19278	164	branch	branch	NN
18637	19278	165	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19278	166	to	to	TO
18637	19278	167	decide	decide	VB
18637	19278	168	what	what	WDT
18637	19278	169	type	type	NN
18637	19278	170	of	of	IN
18637	19278	171	taking	taking	NN
18637	19278	172	is	be	VBZ
18637	19278	173	for	for	IN
18637	19278	174	a	a	DT
18637	19278	175	public	public	JJ
18637	19278	176	use	use	NN
18637	19278	177	*	*	NFP
18637	19278	178	*	*	NFP
18637	19278	179	*	*	NFP
18637	19278	180	"	"	''
18637	19278	181	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19278	182	635	635	CD
18637	19278	183	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19278	184	Necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19278	185	for	for	IN
18637	19278	186	a	a	DT
18637	19278	187	Taking	taking	NN
18637	19278	188	"	"	``
18637	19278	189	Once	once	IN
18637	19278	190	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19278	191	is	be	VBZ
18637	19278	192	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	19278	193	or	or	CC
18637	19278	194	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	19278	195	determined	determine	VBN
18637	19278	196	that	that	IN
18637	19278	197	a	a	DT
18637	19278	198	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	19278	199	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	19278	200	is	be	VBZ
18637	19278	201	for	for	IN
18637	19278	202	a	a	DT
18637	19278	203	public	public	JJ
18637	19278	204	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	19278	205	and	and	CC
18637	19278	206	within	within	IN
18637	19278	207	the	the	DT
18637	19278	208	statutory	statutory	NNP
18637	19278	209	authority	authority	NNP
18637	19278	210	,	,	,
18637	19278	211	a	a	DT
18637	19278	212	political	political	JJ
18637	19278	213	or	or	CC
18637	19278	214	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	19278	215	nonreviewable	nonreviewable	JJ
18637	19278	216	question	question	NN
18637	19278	217	may	may	MD
18637	19278	218	emerge	emerge	VB
18637	19278	219	,	,	,
18637	19278	220	to	to	IN
18637	19278	221	wit	wit	NN
18637	19278	222	,	,	,
18637	19278	223	the	the	DT
18637	19278	224	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19278	225	or	or	CC
18637	19278	226	expediency	expediency	NN
18637	19278	227	of	of	IN
18637	19278	228	the	the	DT
18637	19278	229	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	19278	230	of	of	IN
18637	19278	231	the	the	DT
18637	19278	232	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19278	233	property	property	NN
18637	19278	234	.	.	.
18637	19279	1	"	"	``
18637	19279	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19279	3	636	636	CD
18637	19279	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19279	5	The	the	DT
18637	19279	6	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19279	7	and	and	CC
18637	19279	8	expediency	expediency	NN
18637	19279	9	of	of	IN
18637	19279	10	the	the	DT
18637	19279	11	taking	take	VBG
18637	19279	12	are	be	VBP
18637	19279	13	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19279	14	questions	question	NNS
18637	19279	15	to	to	TO
18637	19279	16	be	be	VB
18637	19279	17	determined	determine	VBN
18637	19279	18	by	by	IN
18637	19279	19	such	such	JJ
18637	19279	20	agency	agency	NN
18637	19279	21	and	and	CC
18637	19279	22	in	in	IN
18637	19279	23	such	such	JJ
18637	19279	24	mode	mode	NN
18637	19279	25	as	as	IN
18637	19279	26	the	the	DT
18637	19279	27	State	State	NNP
18637	19279	28	may	may	MD
18637	19279	29	designate	designate	VB
18637	19279	30	.	.	.
18637	19280	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19280	2	637	637	CD
18637	19280	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19280	4	What	what	WP
18637	19280	5	Constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	19280	6	a	a	DT
18637	19280	7	Taking	taking	NN
18637	19280	8	For	for	IN
18637	19280	9	a	a	DT
18637	19280	10	Public	public	JJ
18637	19280	11	Use	Use	NNP
18637	19280	12	To	to	TO
18637	19280	13	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	19280	14	a	a	DT
18637	19280	15	public	public	JJ
18637	19280	16	use	use	NN
18637	19280	17	within	within	IN
18637	19280	18	the	the	DT
18637	19280	19	law	law	NN
18637	19280	20	of	of	IN
18637	19280	21	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	19280	22	domain	domain	NN
18637	19280	23	,	,	,
18637	19280	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19280	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	19280	26	not	not	RB
18637	19280	27	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19280	28	that	that	IN
18637	19280	29	an	an	DT
18637	19280	30	entire	entire	JJ
18637	19280	31	community	community	NN
18637	19280	32	should	should	MD
18637	19280	33	directly	directly	RB
18637	19280	34	participate	participate	VB
18637	19280	35	in	in	IN
18637	19280	36	or	or	CC
18637	19280	37	enjoy	enjoy	VB
18637	19280	38	an	an	DT
18637	19280	39	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	19280	40	,	,	,
18637	19280	41	and	and	CC
18637	19280	42	,	,	,
18637	19280	43	in	in	IN
18637	19280	44	ascertaining	ascertain	VBG
18637	19280	45	whether	whether	IN
18637	19280	46	a	a	DT
18637	19280	47	use	use	NN
18637	19280	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	19280	49	public	public	JJ
18637	19280	50	,	,	,
18637	19280	51	not	not	RB
18637	19280	52	only	only	RB
18637	19280	53	present	present	JJ
18637	19280	54	demands	demand	NNS
18637	19280	55	of	of	IN
18637	19280	56	the	the	DT
18637	19280	57	public	public	NN
18637	19280	58	but	but	CC
18637	19280	59	those	those	DT
18637	19280	60	which	which	WDT
18637	19280	61	may	may	MD
18637	19280	62	be	be	VB
18637	19280	63	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	19280	64	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
18637	19280	65	in	in	IN
18637	19280	66	the	the	DT
18637	19280	67	future	future	NN
18637	19280	68	may	may	MD
18637	19280	69	be	be	VB
18637	19280	70	considered	consider	VBN
18637	19280	71	.	.	.
18637	19281	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19281	2	638	638	CD
18637	19281	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19281	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	19281	5	,	,	,
18637	19281	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19281	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19281	8	also	also	RB
18637	19281	9	not	not	RB
18637	19281	10	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19281	11	that	that	IN
18637	19281	12	property	property	NN
18637	19281	13	should	should	MD
18637	19281	14	be	be	VB
18637	19281	15	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	19281	16	taken	take	VBN
18637	19281	17	,	,	,
18637	19281	18	in	in	IN
18637	19281	19	the	the	DT
18637	19281	20	narrowest	narrow	JJS
18637	19281	21	sense	sense	NN
18637	19281	22	of	of	IN
18637	19281	23	the	the	DT
18637	19281	24	word	word	NN
18637	19281	25	,	,	,
18637	19281	26	to	to	TO
18637	19281	27	bring	bring	VB
18637	19281	28	the	the	DT
18637	19281	29	case	case	NN
18637	19281	30	within	within	IN
18637	19281	31	the	the	DT
18637	19281	32	protection	protection	NN
18637	19281	33	of	of	IN
18637	19281	34	this	this	DT
18637	19281	35	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19281	36	provision	provision	NN
18637	19281	37	,	,	,
18637	19281	38	but	but	CC
18637	19281	39	there	there	EX
18637	19281	40	may	may	MD
18637	19281	41	be	be	VB
18637	19281	42	such	such	JJ
18637	19281	43	serious	serious	JJ
18637	19281	44	interruption	interruption	NN
18637	19281	45	to	to	IN
18637	19281	46	the	the	DT
18637	19281	47	common	common	JJ
18637	19281	48	and	and	CC
18637	19281	49	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19281	50	use	use	NN
18637	19281	51	of	of	IN
18637	19281	52	property	property	NN
18637	19281	53	as	as	IN
18637	19281	54	will	will	MD
18637	19281	55	be	be	VB
18637	19281	56	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
18637	19281	57	to	to	IN
18637	19281	58	a	a	DT
18637	19281	59	taking	taking	NN
18637	19281	60	.	.	.
18637	19282	1	"	"	``
18637	19282	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19282	3	would	would	MD
18637	19282	4	be	be	VB
18637	19282	5	*	*	NFP
18637	19282	6	*	*	NFP
18637	19282	7	*	*	NFP
18637	19282	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19282	9	an	an	DT
18637	19282	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19282	11	unsatisfactory	unsatisfactory	JJ
18637	19282	12	result	result	NN
18637	19282	13	,	,	,
18637	19282	14	if	if	IN
18637	19282	15	*	*	NFP
18637	19282	16	*	*	NFP
18637	19282	17	*	*	NFP
18637	19282	18	,	,	,
18637	19282	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19282	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	19282	21	be	be	VB
18637	19282	22	held	hold	VBN
18637	19282	23	that	that	IN
18637	19282	24	if	if	IN
18637	19282	25	the	the	DT
18637	19282	26	government	government	NN
18637	19282	27	refrains	refrain	VBZ
18637	19282	28	from	from	IN
18637	19282	29	the	the	DT
18637	19282	30	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	19282	31	conversion	conversion	NN
18637	19282	32	of	of	IN
18637	19282	33	real	real	JJ
18637	19282	34	property	property	NN
18637	19282	35	to	to	IN
18637	19282	36	the	the	DT
18637	19282	37	uses	use	NNS
18637	19282	38	of	of	IN
18637	19282	39	the	the	DT
18637	19282	40	public	public	NN
18637	19282	41	,	,	,
18637	19282	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19282	43	can	can	MD
18637	19282	44	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	19282	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19282	46	value	value	NN
18637	19282	47	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	19282	48	,	,	,
18637	19282	49	can	can	MD
18637	19282	50	inflict	inflict	VB
18637	19282	51	irreparable	irreparable	JJ
18637	19282	52	and	and	CC
18637	19282	53	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	19282	54	injury	injury	NN
18637	19282	55	to	to	IN
18637	19282	56	any	any	DT
18637	19282	57	extent	extent	NN
18637	19282	58	,	,	,
18637	19282	59	can	can	MD
18637	19282	60	in	in	IN
18637	19282	61	effect	effect	NN
18637	19282	62	,	,	,
18637	19282	63	subject	subject	VB
18637	19282	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19282	65	to	to	IN
18637	19282	66	total	total	JJ
18637	19282	67	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	19282	68	without	without	IN
18637	19282	69	making	make	VBG
18637	19282	70	any	any	DT
18637	19282	71	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19282	72	,	,	,
18637	19282	73	because	because	IN
18637	19282	74	,	,	,
18637	19282	75	in	in	IN
18637	19282	76	the	the	DT
18637	19282	77	narrowest	narrow	JJS
18637	19282	78	sense	sense	NN
18637	19282	79	of	of	IN
18637	19282	80	that	that	DT
18637	19282	81	word	word	NN
18637	19282	82	,	,	,
18637	19282	83	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19282	84	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19282	85	has	have	VBZ
18637	19282	86	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19282	87	not	not	RB
18637	19282	88	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19282	89	been	be	VBN
18637	19282	90	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19282	91	taken	take	VBN
18637	19282	92	for	for	IN
18637	19282	93	the	the	DT
18637	19282	94	public	public	JJ
18637	19282	95	use	use	NN
18637	19282	96	.	.	.
18637	19283	1	"	"	``
18637	19283	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19283	3	639	639	CD
18637	19283	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19283	5	Takings	taking	NNS
18637	19283	6	for	for	IN
18637	19283	7	a	a	DT
18637	19283	8	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	19283	9	that	that	WDT
18637	19283	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	19283	11	public	public	JJ
18637	19283	12	hitherto	hitherto	NNP
18637	19283	13	have	have	VBP
18637	19283	14	been	be	VBN
18637	19283	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	19283	16	to	to	TO
18637	19283	17	comprise	comprise	VB
18637	19283	18	the	the	DT
18637	19283	19	following	follow	VBG
18637	19283	20	:	:	:
18637	19283	21	a	a	DT
18637	19283	22	privately	privately	RB
18637	19283	23	owned	own	VBN
18637	19283	24	water	water	NN
18637	19283	25	supply	supply	NN
18637	19283	26	system	system	NN
18637	19283	27	formerly	formerly	RB
18637	19283	28	operated	operate	VBN
18637	19283	29	under	under	IN
18637	19283	30	contract	contract	NN
18637	19283	31	with	with	IN
18637	19283	32	the	the	DT
18637	19283	33	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	19283	34	effecting	effect	VBG
18637	19283	35	the	the	DT
18637	19283	36	taking;[640	taking;[640	NNPS
18637	19283	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19283	38	a	a	DT
18637	19283	39	right	right	NN
18637	19283	40	of	of	IN
18637	19283	41	way	way	NN
18637	19283	42	across	across	IN
18637	19283	43	a	a	DT
18637	19283	44	neighbor	neighbor	NN
18637	19283	45	's	's	POS
18637	19283	46	land	land	NN
18637	19283	47	for	for	IN
18637	19283	48	the	the	DT
18637	19283	49	enlargement	enlargement	NN
18637	19283	50	of	of	IN
18637	19283	51	an	an	DT
18637	19283	52	irrigation	irrigation	NN
18637	19283	53	ditch	ditch	NN
18637	19283	54	therein	therein	RB
18637	19283	55	to	to	TO
18637	19283	56	enable	enable	VB
18637	19283	57	the	the	DT
18637	19283	58	taker	taker	NN
18637	19283	59	to	to	TO
18637	19283	60	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	19283	61	water	water	NN
18637	19283	62	for	for	IN
18637	19283	63	irrigating	irrigate	VBG
18637	19283	64	land	land	NN
18637	19283	65	that	that	WDT
18637	19283	66	would	would	MD
18637	19283	67	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	19283	68	remain	remain	VB
18637	19283	69	valueless;[641	valueless;[641	LS
18637	19283	70	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19283	71	a	a	DT
18637	19283	72	right	right	NN
18637	19283	73	of	of	IN
18637	19283	74	way	way	NN
18637	19283	75	across	across	IN
18637	19283	76	a	a	DT
18637	19283	77	placer	placer	NN
18637	19283	78	mining	mining	NN
18637	19283	79	claim	claim	NN
18637	19283	80	for	for	IN
18637	19283	81	the	the	DT
18637	19283	82	aerial	aerial	JJ
18637	19283	83	bucket	bucket	NN
18637	19283	84	line	line	NN
18637	19283	85	of	of	IN
18637	19283	86	a	a	DT
18637	19283	87	mining	mining	NN
18637	19283	88	corporation;[642	corporation;[642	.
18637	19283	89	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19283	90	land	land	NN
18637	19283	91	,	,	,
18637	19283	92	water	water	NN
18637	19283	93	,	,	,
18637	19283	94	and	and	CC
18637	19283	95	water	water	NN
18637	19283	96	rights	right	NNS
18637	19283	97	for	for	IN
18637	19283	98	the	the	DT
18637	19283	99	production	production	NN
18637	19283	100	of	of	IN
18637	19283	101	electric	electric	JJ
18637	19283	102	power	power	NN
18637	19283	103	by	by	IN
18637	19283	104	a	a	DT
18637	19283	105	public	public	JJ
18637	19283	106	utility;[643	utility;[643	JJ
18637	19283	107	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19283	108	water	water	NN
18637	19283	109	rights	right	NNS
18637	19283	110	by	by	IN
18637	19283	111	an	an	DT
18637	19283	112	interurban	interurban	JJ
18637	19283	113	railway	railway	NN
18637	19283	114	company	company	NN
18637	19283	115	for	for	IN
18637	19283	116	the	the	DT
18637	19283	117	production	production	NN
18637	19283	118	of	of	IN
18637	19283	119	power	power	NN
18637	19283	120	in	in	IN
18637	19283	121	excess	excess	NN
18637	19283	122	of	of	IN
18637	19283	123	current	current	JJ
18637	19283	124	needs;[644	needs;[644	NNPS
18637	19283	125	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19283	126	places	place	NNS
18637	19283	127	of	of	IN
18637	19283	128	historical	historical	JJ
18637	19283	129	interest;[645	interest;[645	NNS
18637	19283	130	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19283	131	land	land	NN
18637	19283	132	taken	take	VBN
18637	19283	133	for	for	IN
18637	19283	134	the	the	DT
18637	19283	135	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	19283	136	of	of	IN
18637	19283	137	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	19283	138	with	with	IN
18637	19283	139	a	a	DT
18637	19283	140	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19283	141	company	company	NN
18637	19283	142	for	for	IN
18637	19283	143	a	a	DT
18637	19283	144	portion	portion	NN
18637	19283	145	of	of	IN
18637	19283	146	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19283	147	right	right	NN
18637	19283	148	of	of	IN
18637	19283	149	way	way	NN
18637	19283	150	,	,	,
18637	19283	151	required	require	VBN
18637	19283	152	for	for	IN
18637	19283	153	widening	widen	VBG
18637	19283	154	a	a	DT
18637	19283	155	highway;[646	highway;[646	NNPS
18637	19283	156	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19283	157	land	land	NN
18637	19283	158	by	by	IN
18637	19283	159	a	a	DT
18637	19283	160	railway	railway	NN
18637	19283	161	for	for	IN
18637	19283	162	a	a	DT
18637	19283	163	spur	spur	NN
18637	19283	164	track;[647	track;[647	DT
18637	19283	165	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19283	166	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	19283	167	by	by	IN
18637	19283	168	a	a	DT
18637	19283	169	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	19283	170	of	of	IN
18637	19283	171	a	a	DT
18637	19283	172	public	public	JJ
18637	19283	173	hack	hack	NN
18637	19283	174	stand	stand	NN
18637	19283	175	upon	upon	IN
18637	19283	176	the	the	DT
18637	19283	177	driveway	driveway	NN
18637	19283	178	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	19283	179	by	by	IN
18637	19283	180	a	a	DT
18637	19283	181	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19283	182	upon	upon	IN
18637	19283	183	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19283	184	own	own	JJ
18637	19283	185	terminal	terminal	JJ
18637	19283	186	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	19283	187	to	to	TO
18637	19283	188	afford	afford	VB
18637	19283	189	ingress	ingress	NN
18637	19283	190	and	and	CC
18637	19283	191	egress	egress	NN
18637	19283	192	to	to	IN
18637	19283	193	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19283	194	patrons	patron	NNS
18637	19283	195	.	.	.
18637	19284	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19284	2	648	648	CD
18637	19284	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19284	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19284	5	,	,	,
18637	19284	6	damages	damage	NNS
18637	19284	7	for	for	IN
18637	19284	8	which	which	WDT
18637	19284	9	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19284	10	must	must	MD
18637	19284	11	be	be	VB
18637	19284	12	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19284	13	are	be	VBP
18637	19284	14	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	19284	15	by	by	IN
18637	19284	16	an	an	DT
18637	19284	17	upper	upper	JJ
18637	19284	18	riparian	riparian	JJ
18637	19284	19	proprietor	proprietor	NN
18637	19284	20	by	by	IN
18637	19284	21	reason	reason	NN
18637	19284	22	of	of	IN
18637	19284	23	the	the	DT
18637	19284	24	erection	erection	NN
18637	19284	25	of	of	IN
18637	19284	26	a	a	DT
18637	19284	27	dam	dam	NN
18637	19284	28	by	by	IN
18637	19284	29	a	a	DT
18637	19284	30	lower	low	JJR
18637	19284	31	mill	mill	NN
18637	19284	32	owner	owner	NN
18637	19284	33	under	under	IN
18637	19284	34	authority	authority	NN
18637	19284	35	of	of	IN
18637	19284	36	a	a	DT
18637	19284	37	"	"	``
18637	19284	38	mill	mill	NN
18637	19284	39	act	act	NN
18637	19284	40	.	.	.
18637	19285	1	"	"	``
18637	19285	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19285	3	649	649	CD
18637	19285	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19285	5	On	on	IN
18637	19285	6	the	the	DT
18637	19285	7	other	other	JJ
18637	19285	8	hand	hand	NN
18637	19285	9	,	,	,
18637	19285	10	even	even	RB
18637	19285	11	when	when	WRB
18637	19285	12	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19285	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	19285	14	tendered	tender	VBN
18637	19285	15	,	,	,
18637	19285	16	an	an	DT
18637	19285	17	owner	owner	NN
18637	19285	18	of	of	IN
18637	19285	19	property	property	NN
18637	19285	20	can	can	MD
18637	19285	21	not	not	RB
18637	19285	22	be	be	VB
18637	19285	23	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	19285	24	to	to	TO
18637	19285	25	assent	assent	VB
18637	19285	26	to	to	IN
18637	19285	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19285	28	taking	taking	NN
18637	19285	29	by	by	IN
18637	19285	30	the	the	DT
18637	19285	31	State	State	NNP
18637	19285	32	for	for	IN
18637	19285	33	the	the	DT
18637	19285	34	private	private	JJ
18637	19285	35	use	use	NN
18637	19285	36	of	of	IN
18637	19285	37	another	another	DT
18637	19285	38	.	.	.
18637	19286	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	19286	2	a	a	DT
18637	19286	3	taking	taking	NN
18637	19286	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	19286	5	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	19286	6	,	,	,
18637	19286	7	by	by	IN
18637	19286	8	the	the	DT
18637	19286	9	due	due	JJ
18637	19286	10	process	process	NN
18637	19286	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	19286	12	.	.	.
18637	19287	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19287	2	,	,	,
18637	19287	3	a	a	DT
18637	19287	4	State	state	NN
18637	19287	5	,	,	,
18637	19287	6	by	by	IN
18637	19287	7	law	law	NN
18637	19287	8	,	,	,
18637	19287	9	could	could	MD
18637	19287	10	not	not	RB
18637	19287	11	require	require	VB
18637	19287	12	a	a	DT
18637	19287	13	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19287	14	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19287	15	,	,	,
18637	19287	16	which	which	WDT
18637	19287	17	had	have	VBD
18637	19287	18	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	19287	19	the	the	DT
18637	19287	20	erection	erection	NN
18637	19287	21	of	of	IN
18637	19287	22	two	two	CD
18637	19287	23	grain	grain	NN
18637	19287	24	elevators	elevator	NNS
18637	19287	25	by	by	IN
18637	19287	26	private	private	JJ
18637	19287	27	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	19287	28	on	on	IN
18637	19287	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19287	30	right	right	NN
18637	19287	31	of	of	IN
18637	19287	32	way	way	NN
18637	19287	33	,	,	,
18637	19287	34	to	to	TO
18637	19287	35	grant	grant	VB
18637	19287	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	19287	37	like	like	IN
18637	19287	38	terms	term	NNS
18637	19287	39	,	,	,
18637	19287	40	a	a	DT
18637	19287	41	location	location	NN
18637	19287	42	to	to	IN
18637	19287	43	another	another	DT
18637	19287	44	group	group	NN
18637	19287	45	of	of	IN
18637	19287	46	farmers	farmer	NNS
18637	19287	47	desirous	desirous	JJ
18637	19287	48	of	of	IN
18637	19287	49	erecting	erect	VBG
18637	19287	50	a	a	DT
18637	19287	51	third	third	JJ
18637	19287	52	grain	grain	NN
18637	19287	53	elevator	elevator	NN
18637	19287	54	for	for	IN
18637	19287	55	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19287	56	own	own	JJ
18637	19287	57	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19287	58	.	.	.
18637	19288	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19288	2	650	650	CD
18637	19288	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19288	4	Just	just	RB
18637	19288	5	Compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19288	6	"	"	''
18637	19288	7	When	when	WRB
18637	19288	8	*	*	NFP
18637	19288	9	*	*	NFP
18637	19288	10	*	*	NFP
18637	19288	11	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19288	12	the	the	DT
18637	19288	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19288	14	power	power	NN
18637	19288	15	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19288	16	of	of	IN
18637	19288	17	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	19288	18	domain	domain	NN
18637	19288	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19288	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	19288	21	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	19288	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19288	23	can	can	MD
18637	19288	24	only	only	RB
18637	19288	25	be	be	VB
18637	19288	26	done	do	VBN
18637	19288	27	by	by	IN
18637	19288	28	giving	give	VBG
18637	19288	29	the	the	DT
18637	19288	30	party	party	NN
18637	19288	31	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19288	32	property	property	NN
18637	19288	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	19288	34	taken	take	VBN
18637	19288	35	or	or	CC
18637	19288	36	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19288	37	use	use	NN
18637	19288	38	and	and	CC
18637	19288	39	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	19288	40	of	of	IN
18637	19288	41	such	such	JJ
18637	19288	42	property	property	NN
18637	19288	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	19288	44	interfered	interfere	VBN
18637	19288	45	with	with	IN
18637	19288	46	,	,	,
18637	19288	47	full	full	JJ
18637	19288	48	and	and	CC
18637	19288	49	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19288	50	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19288	51	,	,	,
18637	19288	52	not	not	RB
18637	19288	53	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	19288	54	or	or	CC
18637	19288	55	exorbitant	exorbitant	JJ
18637	19288	56	,	,	,
18637	19288	57	but	but	CC
18637	19288	58	just	just	RB
18637	19288	59	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19288	60	.	.	.
18637	19289	1	"	"	``
18637	19289	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19289	3	651	651	CD
18637	19289	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19289	5	However	however	RB
18637	19289	6	,	,	,
18637	19289	7	"	"	``
18637	19289	8	there	there	EX
18637	19289	9	must	must	MD
18637	19289	10	be	be	VB
18637	19289	11	something	something	NN
18637	19289	12	more	more	JJR
18637	19289	13	than	than	IN
18637	19289	14	an	an	DT
18637	19289	15	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	19289	16	honest	honest	JJ
18637	19289	17	mistake	mistake	NN
18637	19289	18	of	of	IN
18637	19289	19	law	law	NN
18637	19289	20	in	in	IN
18637	19289	21	the	the	DT
18637	19289	22	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19289	23	for	for	IN
18637	19289	24	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19289	25	before	before	IN
18637	19289	26	a	a	DT
18637	19289	27	party	party	NN
18637	19289	28	can	can	MD
18637	19289	29	make	make	VB
18637	19289	30	out	out	RP
18637	19289	31	that	that	IN
18637	19289	32	the	the	DT
18637	19289	33	State	State	NNP
18637	19289	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	19289	35	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	19289	36	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19289	37	of	of	IN
18637	19289	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19289	39	property	property	NN
18637	19289	40	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	RB
18637	19289	41	.	.	.
18637	19290	1	"	"	``
18637	19290	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19290	3	652	652	CD
18637	19290	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19290	5	Unless	unless	IN
18637	19290	6	,	,	,
18637	19290	7	by	by	IN
18637	19290	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19290	9	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	19290	10	of	of	IN
18637	19290	11	law	law	NN
18637	19290	12	,	,	,
18637	19290	13	the	the	DT
18637	19290	14	State	State	NNP
18637	19290	15	court	court	NN
18637	19290	16	prevented	prevent	VBD
18637	19290	17	a	a	DT
18637	19290	18	complainant	complainant	NN
18637	19290	19	from	from	IN
18637	19290	20	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	19290	21	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	19290	22	any	any	DT
18637	19290	23	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19290	24	,	,	,
18637	19290	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19290	26	findings	finding	NNS
18637	19290	27	as	as	IN
18637	19290	28	to	to	IN
18637	19290	29	the	the	DT
18637	19290	30	amount	amount	NN
18637	19290	31	of	of	IN
18637	19290	32	damages	damage	NNS
18637	19290	33	will	will	MD
18637	19290	34	not	not	RB
18637	19290	35	be	be	VB
18637	19290	36	overturned	overturn	VBN
18637	19290	37	on	on	IN
18637	19290	38	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	19290	39	,	,	,
18637	19290	40	even	even	RB
18637	19290	41	though	though	IN
18637	19290	42	as	as	IN
18637	19290	43	a	a	DT
18637	19290	44	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	19290	45	of	of	IN
18637	19290	46	error	error	NN
18637	19290	47	therein	therein	RB
18637	19290	48	the	the	DT
18637	19290	49	property	property	NN
18637	19290	50	owner	owner	NN
18637	19290	51	received	receive	VBD
18637	19290	52	less	less	JJR
18637	19290	53	than	than	IN
18637	19290	54	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19290	55	ought	ought	MD
18637	19290	56	.	.	.
18637	19291	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19291	2	653	653	CD
18637	19291	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19291	4	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19291	5	,	,	,
18637	19291	6	when	when	WRB
18637	19291	7	a	a	DT
18637	19291	8	State	State	NNP
18637	19291	9	court	court	NN
18637	19291	10	,	,	,
18637	19291	11	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	19291	12	recognizing	recognize	VBG
18637	19291	13	a	a	DT
18637	19291	14	right	right	NN
18637	19291	15	of	of	IN
18637	19291	16	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	19291	17	for	for	IN
18637	19291	18	any	any	DT
18637	19291	19	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	19291	20	damage	damage	NN
18637	19291	21	,	,	,
18637	19291	22	found	find	VBD
18637	19291	23	that	that	IN
18637	19291	24	none	none	NN
18637	19291	25	had	have	VBD
18637	19291	26	been	be	VBN
18637	19291	27	shown	show	VBN
18637	19291	28	by	by	IN
18637	19291	29	the	the	DT
18637	19291	30	proof	proof	NN
18637	19291	31	,	,	,
18637	19291	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19291	33	award	award	NN
18637	19291	34	of	of	IN
18637	19291	35	only	only	RB
18637	19291	36	$	$	$
18637	19291	37	1	1	CD
18637	19291	38	as	as	IN
18637	19291	39	nominal	nominal	JJ
18637	19291	40	damages	damage	NNS
18637	19291	41	was	be	VBD
18637	19291	42	held	hold	VBN
18637	19291	43	to	to	TO
18637	19291	44	present	present	VB
18637	19291	45	no	no	DT
18637	19291	46	question	question	NN
18637	19291	47	for	for	IN
18637	19291	48	review	review	NN
18637	19291	49	.	.	.
18637	19292	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19292	2	654	654	CD
18637	19292	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19292	4	"	"	``
18637	19292	5	All	all	DT
18637	19292	6	that	that	WDT
18637	19292	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19292	8	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19292	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19292	10	that	that	IN
18637	19292	11	in	in	IN
18637	19292	12	some	some	DT
18637	19292	13	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	19292	14	way	way	NN
18637	19292	15	,	,	,
18637	19292	16	before	before	IN
18637	19292	17	some	some	DT
18637	19292	18	properly	properly	RB
18637	19292	19	constituted	constitute	VBN
18637	19292	20	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	19292	21	,	,	,
18637	19292	22	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	19292	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	19292	24	be	be	VB
18637	19292	25	made	make	VBN
18637	19292	26	as	as	IN
18637	19292	27	to	to	IN
18637	19292	28	the	the	DT
18637	19292	29	amount	amount	NN
18637	19292	30	of	of	IN
18637	19292	31	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19292	32	,	,	,
18637	19292	33	and	and	CC
18637	19292	34	when	when	WRB
18637	19292	35	this	this	DT
18637	19292	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	19292	37	been	be	VBN
18637	19292	38	provided	provide	VBN
18637	19292	39	there	there	RB
18637	19292	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	19292	41	that	that	DT
18637	19292	42	due	due	JJ
18637	19292	43	process	process	NN
18637	19292	44	of	of	IN
18637	19292	45	law	law	NN
18637	19292	46	which	which	WDT
18637	19292	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	19292	48	required	require	VBN
18637	19292	49	by	by	IN
18637	19292	50	the	the	DT
18637	19292	51	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	19292	52	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19292	53	.	.	.
18637	19293	1	"	"	``
18637	19293	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19293	3	655	655	CD
18637	19293	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19293	5	"	"	''
18637	19293	6	The	the	DT
18637	19293	7	general	general	JJ
18637	19293	8	rule	rule	NN
18637	19293	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19293	10	that	that	IN
18637	19293	11	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19293	12	'	'	''
18637	19293	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	19293	14	to	to	TO
18637	19293	15	be	be	VB
18637	19293	16	estimated	estimate	VBN
18637	19293	17	by	by	IN
18637	19293	18	reference	reference	NN
18637	19293	19	to	to	IN
18637	19293	20	the	the	DT
18637	19293	21	uses	use	NNS
18637	19293	22	for	for	IN
18637	19293	23	which	which	WDT
18637	19293	24	the	the	DT
18637	19293	25	property	property	NN
18637	19293	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	19293	27	suitable	suitable	JJ
18637	19293	28	,	,	,
18637	19293	29	having	have	VBG
18637	19293	30	regard	regard	NN
18637	19293	31	to	to	IN
18637	19293	32	the	the	DT
18637	19293	33	existing	exist	VBG
18637	19293	34	business	business	NN
18637	19293	35	and	and	CC
18637	19293	36	wants	want	VBZ
18637	19293	37	of	of	IN
18637	19293	38	the	the	DT
18637	19293	39	community	community	NN
18637	19293	40	,	,	,
18637	19293	41	or	or	CC
18637	19293	42	such	such	JJ
18637	19293	43	as	as	IN
18637	19293	44	may	may	MD
18637	19293	45	be	be	VB
18637	19293	46	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	19293	47	expected	expect	VBN
18637	19293	48	in	in	IN
18637	19293	49	the	the	DT
18637	19293	50	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	19293	51	future	future	NN
18637	19293	52	,	,	,
18637	19293	53	'	'	''
18637	19293	54	*	*	NFP
18637	19293	55	*	*	NFP
18637	19293	56	*	*	NFP
18637	19293	57	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19293	58	but	but	CC
18637	19293	59	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19293	60	'	'	``
18637	19293	61	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19293	62	possible	possible	JJ
18637	19293	63	or	or	CC
18637	19293	64	imaginary	imaginary	JJ
18637	19293	65	uses	use	NNS
18637	19293	66	,	,	,
18637	19293	67	or	or	CC
18637	19293	68	the	the	DT
18637	19293	69	speculative	speculative	JJ
18637	19293	70	schemes	scheme	NNS
18637	19293	71	of	of	IN
18637	19293	72	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19293	73	proprietor	proprietor	NN
18637	19293	74	,	,	,
18637	19293	75	are	be	VBP
18637	19293	76	to	to	TO
18637	19293	77	be	be	VB
18637	19293	78	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	19293	79	.	.	.
18637	19294	1	'	'	``
18637	19294	2	"	"	``
18637	19294	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19294	4	656	656	CD
18637	19294	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19294	6	Damages	damage	NNS
18637	19294	7	are	be	VBP
18637	19294	8	measured	measure	VBN
18637	19294	9	by	by	IN
18637	19294	10	the	the	DT
18637	19294	11	loss	loss	NN
18637	19294	12	to	to	IN
18637	19294	13	the	the	DT
18637	19294	14	owner	owner	NN
18637	19294	15	,	,	,
18637	19294	16	not	not	RB
18637	19294	17	by	by	IN
18637	19294	18	the	the	DT
18637	19294	19	gain	gain	NN
18637	19294	20	to	to	IN
18637	19294	21	the	the	DT
18637	19294	22	taker;[657	taker;[657	NNS
18637	19294	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19294	24	and	and	CC
18637	19294	25	attorneys	attorney	NNS
18637	19294	26	'	'	POS
18637	19294	27	fees	fee	NNS
18637	19294	28	and	and	CC
18637	19294	29	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	19294	30	are	be	VBP
18637	19294	31	not	not	RB
18637	19294	32	embraced	embrace	VBN
18637	19294	33	therein	therein	RB
18637	19294	34	.	.	.
18637	19295	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19295	2	658	658	CD
18637	19295	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19295	4	"	"	``
18637	19295	5	When	when	WRB
18637	19295	6	the	the	DT
18637	19295	7	public	public	JJ
18637	19295	8	faith	faith	NN
18637	19295	9	and	and	CC
18637	19295	10	credit	credit	NN
18637	19295	11	are	be	VBP
18637	19295	12	pledged	pledge	VBN
18637	19295	13	to	to	IN
18637	19295	14	a	a	DT
18637	19295	15	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	19295	16	prompt	prompt	JJ
18637	19295	17	ascertainment	ascertainment	NN
18637	19295	18	and	and	CC
18637	19295	19	payment	payment	NN
18637	19295	20	,	,	,
18637	19295	21	and	and	CC
18637	19295	22	there	there	EX
18637	19295	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	19295	24	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19295	25	provision	provision	NN
18637	19295	26	for	for	IN
18637	19295	27	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	19295	28	the	the	DT
18637	19295	29	pledge	pledge	NN
18637	19295	30	,	,	,
18637	19295	31	*	*	NFP
18637	19295	32	*	*	NFP
18637	19295	33	*	*	NFP
18637	19295	34	the	the	DT
18637	19295	35	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19295	36	of	of	IN
18637	19295	37	just	just	RB
18637	19295	38	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19295	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	19295	40	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	19295	41	.	.	.
18637	19296	1	"	"	``
18637	19296	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19296	3	659	659	CD
18637	19296	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19296	5	Uncompensated	Uncompensated	NNP
18637	19296	6	Takings	Takings	NNPS
18637	19296	7	"	"	''
18637	19296	8	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19296	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19296	10	well	well	RB
18637	19296	11	settled	settle	VBN
18637	19296	12	that	that	IN
18637	19296	13	'	'	''
18637	19296	14	neither	neither	CC
18637	19296	15	a	a	DT
18637	19296	16	natural	natural	JJ
18637	19296	17	person	person	NN
18637	19296	18	nor	nor	CC
18637	19296	19	a	a	DT
18637	19296	20	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19296	21	can	can	MD
18637	19296	22	claim	claim	VB
18637	19296	23	damages	damage	NNS
18637	19296	24	on	on	IN
18637	19296	25	account	account	NN
18637	19296	26	of	of	IN
18637	19296	27	being	be	VBG
18637	19296	28	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	19296	29	to	to	TO
18637	19296	30	render	render	VB
18637	19296	31	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	19296	32	to	to	IN
18637	19296	33	a	a	DT
18637	19296	34	police	police	NN
18637	19296	35	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	19296	36	designed	design	VBN
18637	19296	37	to	to	TO
18637	19296	38	secure	secure	VB
18637	19296	39	the	the	DT
18637	19296	40	common	common	JJ
18637	19296	41	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	19296	42	.	.	.
18637	19296	43	'	'	''
18637	19297	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19297	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19297	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19297	4	Uncompensated	uncompensated	JJ
18637	19297	5	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	19297	6	to	to	IN
18637	19297	7	a	a	DT
18637	19297	8	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	19297	9	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	19297	10	for	for	IN
18637	19297	11	the	the	DT
18637	19297	12	public	public	JJ
18637	19297	13	safety	safety	NN
18637	19297	14	under	under	IN
18637	19297	15	the	the	DT
18637	19297	16	police	police	NN
18637	19297	17	power	power	NN
18637	19297	18	of	of	IN
18637	19297	19	the	the	DT
18637	19297	20	State	State	NNP
18637	19297	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	19297	22	not	not	RB
18637	19297	23	a	a	DT
18637	19297	24	taking	take	VBG
18637	19297	25	or	or	CC
18637	19297	26	damaging	damaging	JJ
18637	19297	27	without	without	IN
18637	19297	28	just	just	RB
18637	19297	29	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19297	30	of	of	IN
18637	19297	31	private	private	JJ
18637	19297	32	property	property	NN
18637	19297	33	,	,	,
18637	19297	34	*	*	NFP
18637	19297	35	*	*	NFP
18637	19297	36	*	*	NFP
18637	19297	37	"	"	''
18637	19297	38	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19297	39	660	660	CD
18637	19297	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19297	41	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19297	42	,	,	,
18637	19297	43	the	the	DT
18637	19297	44	flooding	flooding	NN
18637	19297	45	of	of	IN
18637	19297	46	lands	land	NNS
18637	19297	47	consequent	consequent	JJ
18637	19297	48	upon	upon	IN
18637	19297	49	private	private	JJ
18637	19297	50	construction	construction	NN
18637	19297	51	of	of	IN
18637	19297	52	a	a	DT
18637	19297	53	dam	dam	NN
18637	19297	54	under	under	IN
18637	19297	55	authority	authority	NN
18637	19297	56	of	of	IN
18637	19297	57	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19297	58	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	19297	59	to	to	TO
18637	19297	60	subserve	subserve	VB
18637	19297	61	the	the	DT
18637	19297	62	drainage	drainage	NN
18637	19297	63	of	of	IN
18637	19297	64	lowlands	lowland	NNS
18637	19297	65	was	be	VBD
18637	19297	66	not	not	RB
18637	19297	67	a	a	DT
18637	19297	68	taking	taking	NN
18637	19297	69	which	which	WDT
18637	19297	70	required	require	VBD
18637	19297	71	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19297	72	to	to	TO
18637	19297	73	be	be	VB
18637	19297	74	made	make	VBN
18637	19297	75	,	,	,
18637	19297	76	especially	especially	RB
18637	19297	77	since	since	IN
18637	19297	78	such	such	JJ
18637	19297	79	flooding	flooding	NN
18637	19297	80	could	could	MD
18637	19297	81	have	have	VB
18637	19297	82	been	be	VBN
18637	19297	83	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	19297	84	by	by	IN
18637	19297	85	raising	raise	VBG
18637	19297	86	the	the	DT
18637	19297	87	height	height	NN
18637	19297	88	of	of	IN
18637	19297	89	dikes	dike	NNS
18637	19297	90	around	around	IN
18637	19297	91	the	the	DT
18637	19297	92	lands	land	NNS
18637	19297	93	.	.	.
18637	19298	1	"	"	``
18637	19298	2	The	the	DT
18637	19298	3	rule	rule	NN
18637	19298	4	to	to	TO
18637	19298	5	be	be	VB
18637	19298	6	gathered	gather	VBN
18637	19298	7	from	from	IN
18637	19298	8	these	these	DT
18637	19298	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	19298	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	19298	11	that	that	IN
18637	19298	12	where	where	WRB
18637	19298	13	there	there	EX
18637	19298	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19298	15	a	a	DT
18637	19298	16	practical	practical	JJ
18637	19298	17	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	19298	18	,	,	,
18637	19298	19	or	or	CC
18637	19298	20	material	material	NN
18637	19298	21	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	19298	22	of	of	IN
18637	19298	23	the	the	DT
18637	19298	24	value	value	NN
18637	19298	25	of	of	IN
18637	19298	26	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	19298	27	's	's	POS
18637	19298	28	lands	land	NNS
18637	19298	29	,	,	,
18637	19298	30	there	there	EX
18637	19298	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	19298	32	a	a	DT
18637	19298	33	taking	taking	NN
18637	19298	34	,	,	,
18637	19298	35	which	which	WDT
18637	19298	36	demands	demand	VBZ
18637	19298	37	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19298	38	,	,	,
18637	19298	39	but	but	CC
18637	19298	40	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	19298	41	where	where	WRB
18637	19298	42	,	,	,
18637	19298	43	as	as	IN
18637	19298	44	in	in	IN
18637	19298	45	this	this	DT
18637	19298	46	case	case	NN
18637	19298	47	,	,	,
18637	19298	48	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	19298	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	19298	50	merely	merely	RB
18637	19298	51	put	put	VBN
18637	19298	52	to	to	IN
18637	19298	53	some	some	DT
18637	19298	54	extra	extra	JJ
18637	19298	55	expense	expense	NN
18637	19298	56	in	in	IN
18637	19298	57	warding	ward	VBG
18637	19298	58	off	off	RP
18637	19298	59	the	the	DT
18637	19298	60	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	19298	61	of	of	IN
18637	19298	62	the	the	DT
18637	19298	63	overflow	overflow	NN
18637	19298	64	.	.	.
18637	19299	1	"	"	``
18637	19299	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19299	3	661	661	CD
18637	19299	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19299	5	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19299	6	,	,	,
18637	19299	7	when	when	WRB
18637	19299	8	a	a	DT
18637	19299	9	city	city	NN
18637	19299	10	,	,	,
18637	19299	11	by	by	IN
18637	19299	12	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	19299	13	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19299	14	,	,	,
18637	19299	15	sought	seek	VBD
18637	19299	16	to	to	TO
18637	19299	17	open	open	VB
18637	19299	18	a	a	DT
18637	19299	19	street	street	NN
18637	19299	20	across	across	IN
18637	19299	21	the	the	DT
18637	19299	22	tracks	track	NNS
18637	19299	23	of	of	IN
18637	19299	24	a	a	DT
18637	19299	25	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19299	26	,	,	,
18637	19299	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19299	28	was	be	VBD
18637	19299	29	not	not	RB
18637	19299	30	obligated	obligate	VBN
18637	19299	31	to	to	TO
18637	19299	32	pay	pay	VB
18637	19299	33	the	the	DT
18637	19299	34	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	19299	35	that	that	WDT
18637	19299	36	the	the	DT
18637	19299	37	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19299	38	would	would	MD
18637	19299	39	incur	incur	VB
18637	19299	40	in	in	IN
18637	19299	41	planking	plank	VBG
18637	19299	42	the	the	DT
18637	19299	43	crossing	crossing	NN
18637	19299	44	,	,	,
18637	19299	45	constructing	construct	VBG
18637	19299	46	gates	gate	NNS
18637	19299	47	,	,	,
18637	19299	48	and	and	CC
18637	19299	49	posting	post	VBG
18637	19299	50	gatemen	gateman	NNS
18637	19299	51	at	at	IN
18637	19299	52	the	the	DT
18637	19299	53	crossing	crossing	NN
18637	19299	54	.	.	.
18637	19300	1	The	the	DT
18637	19300	2	railway	railway	NN
18637	19300	3	was	be	VBD
18637	19300	4	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	19300	5	to	to	TO
18637	19300	6	have	have	VB
18637	19300	7	"	"	``
18637	19300	8	laid	lay	VBN
18637	19300	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19300	10	tracks	track	NNS
18637	19300	11	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19300	12	to	to	IN
18637	19300	13	the	the	DT
18637	19300	14	condition	condition	NN
18637	19300	15	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	19300	16	implied	imply	VBN
18637	19300	17	that	that	IN
18637	19300	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19300	19	use	use	NN
18637	19300	20	could	could	MD
18637	19300	21	be	be	VB
18637	19300	22	so	so	RB
18637	19300	23	regulated	regulated	JJ
18637	19300	24	by	by	IN
18637	19300	25	competent	competent	JJ
18637	19300	26	authority	authority	NN
18637	19300	27	as	as	IN
18637	19300	28	to	to	TO
18637	19300	29	insure	insure	VB
18637	19300	30	the	the	DT
18637	19300	31	public	public	JJ
18637	19300	32	safety	safety	NN
18637	19300	33	.	.	.
18637	19301	1	"	"	``
18637	19301	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19301	3	662	662	CD
18637	19301	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19301	5	Also	also	RB
18637	19301	6	,	,	,
18637	19301	7	one	one	CD
18637	19301	8	who	who	WP
18637	19301	9	leased	lease	VBD
18637	19301	10	oyster	oyster	JJ
18637	19301	11	beds	bed	NNS
18637	19301	12	in	in	IN
18637	19301	13	Hampton	Hampton	NNP
18637	19301	14	Roads	Roads	NNPS
18637	19301	15	from	from	IN
18637	19301	16	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	19301	17	for	for	IN
18637	19301	18	$	$	$
18637	19301	19	1	1	CD
18637	19301	20	per	per	IN
18637	19301	21	acre	acre	NN
18637	19301	22	under	under	IN
18637	19301	23	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	19301	24	of	of	IN
18637	19301	25	an	an	DT
18637	19301	26	"	"	``
18637	19301	27	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	19301	28	right	right	NN
18637	19301	29	"	"	''
18637	19301	30	to	to	TO
18637	19301	31	use	use	VB
18637	19301	32	and	and	CC
18637	19301	33	occupy	occupy	VB
18637	19301	34	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19301	35	was	be	VBD
18637	19301	36	held	hold	VBN
18637	19301	37	to	to	TO
18637	19301	38	have	have	VB
18637	19301	39	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	19301	40	such	such	JJ
18637	19301	41	rights	right	NNS
18637	19301	42	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19301	43	to	to	IN
18637	19301	44	the	the	DT
18637	19301	45	superior	superior	JJ
18637	19301	46	power	power	NN
18637	19301	47	of	of	IN
18637	19301	48	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	19301	49	to	to	TO
18637	19301	50	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	19301	51	Newport	Newport	NNP
18637	19301	52	News	News	NNP
18637	19301	53	to	to	TO
18637	19301	54	discharge	discharge	VB
18637	19301	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19301	56	sewage	sewage	NN
18637	19301	57	into	into	IN
18637	19301	58	the	the	DT
18637	19301	59	sea	sea	NN
18637	19301	60	;	;	:
18637	19301	61	and	and	CC
18637	19301	62	,	,	,
18637	19301	63	hence	hence	RB
18637	19301	64	could	could	MD
18637	19301	65	not	not	RB
18637	19301	66	successfully	successfully	RB
18637	19301	67	contend	contend	VB
18637	19301	68	that	that	IN
18637	19301	69	the	the	DT
18637	19301	70	resulting	result	VBG
18637	19301	71	pollution	pollution	NN
18637	19301	72	of	of	IN
18637	19301	73	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19301	74	oysters	oyster	NNS
18637	19301	75	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	19301	76	an	an	DT
18637	19301	77	uncompensated	uncompensated	JJ
18637	19301	78	taking	taking	NN
18637	19301	79	without	without	IN
18637	19301	80	due	due	JJ
18637	19301	81	process	process	NN
18637	19301	82	of	of	IN
18637	19301	83	law	law	NN
18637	19301	84	.	.	.
18637	19302	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19302	2	663	663	CD
18637	19302	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19302	4	Consequential	Consequential	NNP
18637	19302	5	Damages	damage	NNS
18637	19302	6	"	"	''
18637	19302	7	Acts	act	NNS
18637	19302	8	done	do	VBN
18637	19302	9	in	in	IN
18637	19302	10	the	the	DT
18637	19302	11	proper	proper	JJ
18637	19302	12	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19302	13	of	of	IN
18637	19302	14	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	19302	15	powers	power	NNS
18637	19302	16	,	,	,
18637	19302	17	and	and	CC
18637	19302	18	not	not	RB
18637	19302	19	directly	directly	RB
18637	19302	20	encroaching	encroach	VBG
18637	19302	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	19302	22	private	private	JJ
18637	19302	23	property	property	NN
18637	19302	24	,	,	,
18637	19302	25	though	though	IN
18637	19302	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19302	27	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	19302	28	may	may	MD
18637	19302	29	impair	impair	VB
18637	19302	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19302	31	use	use	NN
18637	19302	32	,	,	,
18637	19302	33	are	be	VBP
18637	19302	34	universally	universally	RB
18637	19302	35	held	hold	VBN
18637	19302	36	not	not	RB
18637	19302	37	to	to	TO
18637	19302	38	be	be	VB
18637	19302	39	a	a	DT
18637	19302	40	taking	taking	NN
18637	19302	41	within	within	IN
18637	19302	42	the	the	DT
18637	19302	43	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	19302	44	of	of	IN
18637	19302	45	the	the	DT
18637	19302	46	due	due	JJ
18637	19302	47	process	process	NN
18637	19302	48	clause	clause	NN
18637	19302	49	.	.	.
18637	19303	1	"	"	``
18637	19303	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19303	3	664	664	CD
18637	19303	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19303	5	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19303	6	,	,	,
18637	19303	7	consequential	consequential	JJ
18637	19303	8	damages	damage	NNS
18637	19303	9	to	to	IN
18637	19303	10	abutting	abut	VBG
18637	19303	11	property	property	NN
18637	19303	12	caused	cause	VBN
18637	19303	13	by	by	IN
18637	19303	14	an	an	DT
18637	19303	15	obstruction	obstruction	NN
18637	19303	16	in	in	IN
18637	19303	17	a	a	DT
18637	19303	18	street	street	NN
18637	19303	19	resulting	result	VBG
18637	19303	20	from	from	IN
18637	19303	21	the	the	DT
18637	19303	22	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	19303	23	of	of	IN
18637	19303	24	a	a	DT
18637	19303	25	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19303	26	to	to	TO
18637	19303	27	erect	erect	NN
18637	19303	28	tracks	track	NNS
18637	19303	29	,	,	,
18637	19303	30	sheds	shed	NNS
18637	19303	31	,	,	,
18637	19303	32	and	and	CC
18637	19303	33	fences	fence	NNS
18637	19303	34	over	over	IN
18637	19303	35	a	a	DT
18637	19303	36	portion	portion	NN
18637	19303	37	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19303	38	have	have	VBP
18637	19303	39	been	be	VBN
18637	19303	40	held	hold	VBN
18637	19303	41	to	to	TO
18637	19303	42	effect	effect	VB
18637	19303	43	no	no	DT
18637	19303	44	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19303	45	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19303	46	of	of	IN
18637	19303	47	property	property	NN
18637	19303	48	.	.	.
18637	19304	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19304	2	665	665	CD
18637	19304	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19304	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19304	5	,	,	,
18637	19304	6	the	the	DT
18637	19304	7	erection	erection	NN
18637	19304	8	over	over	IN
18637	19304	9	a	a	DT
18637	19304	10	street	street	NN
18637	19304	11	of	of	IN
18637	19304	12	an	an	DT
18637	19304	13	elevated	elevated	JJ
18637	19304	14	viaduct	viaduct	NN
18637	19304	15	,	,	,
18637	19304	16	intended	intend	VBN
18637	19304	17	for	for	IN
18637	19304	18	general	general	JJ
18637	19304	19	public	public	JJ
18637	19304	20	travel	travel	NN
18637	19304	21	and	and	CC
18637	19304	22	not	not	RB
18637	19304	23	devoted	devoted	JJ
18637	19304	24	to	to	IN
18637	19304	25	the	the	DT
18637	19304	26	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	19304	27	use	use	NN
18637	19304	28	of	of	IN
18637	19304	29	a	a	DT
18637	19304	30	private	private	JJ
18637	19304	31	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	19304	32	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19304	33	,	,	,
18637	19304	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	19304	35	been	be	VBN
18637	19304	36	declared	declare	VBN
18637	19304	37	to	to	TO
18637	19304	38	be	be	VB
18637	19304	39	a	a	DT
18637	19304	40	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	19304	41	street	street	NN
18637	19304	42	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	19304	43	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
18637	19304	44	to	to	IN
18637	19304	45	a	a	DT
18637	19304	46	change	change	NN
18637	19304	47	in	in	IN
18637	19304	48	grade	grade	NN
18637	19304	49	;	;	:
18637	19304	50	and	and	CC
18637	19304	51	,	,	,
18637	19304	52	as	as	IN
18637	19304	53	in	in	IN
18637	19304	54	the	the	DT
18637	19304	55	case	case	NN
18637	19304	56	of	of	IN
18637	19304	57	a	a	DT
18637	19304	58	change	change	NN
18637	19304	59	of	of	IN
18637	19304	60	grade	grade	NN
18637	19304	61	,	,	,
18637	19304	62	the	the	DT
18637	19304	63	owner	owner	NN
18637	19304	64	of	of	IN
18637	19304	65	land	land	NN
18637	19304	66	abutting	abut	VBG
18637	19304	67	on	on	IN
18637	19304	68	the	the	DT
18637	19304	69	street	street	NN
18637	19304	70	has	have	VBZ
18637	19304	71	been	be	VBN
18637	19304	72	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	19304	73	damages	damage	NNS
18637	19304	74	for	for	IN
18637	19304	75	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	19304	76	of	of	IN
18637	19304	77	access	access	NN
18637	19304	78	to	to	IN
18637	19304	79	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19304	80	land	land	NN
18637	19304	81	and	and	CC
18637	19304	82	the	the	DT
18637	19304	83	lessening	lessening	NN
18637	19304	84	of	of	IN
18637	19304	85	the	the	DT
18637	19304	86	circulation	circulation	NN
18637	19304	87	of	of	IN
18637	19304	88	light	light	NN
18637	19304	89	and	and	CC
18637	19304	90	air	air	NN
18637	19304	91	over	over	IN
18637	19304	92	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19304	93	.	.	.
18637	19305	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19305	2	666	666	CD
18637	19305	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19305	4	Limits	limit	NNS
18637	19305	5	to	to	IN
18637	19305	6	the	the	DT
18637	19305	7	Above	above	JJ
18637	19305	8	Rule.--There	rule.--there	RB
18637	19305	9	are	be	VBP
18637	19305	10	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19305	11	however	however	RB
18637	19305	12	,	,	,
18637	19305	13	to	to	IN
18637	19305	14	the	the	DT
18637	19305	15	amount	amount	NN
18637	19305	16	of	of	IN
18637	19305	17	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	19305	18	or	or	CC
18637	19305	19	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	19305	20	of	of	IN
18637	19305	21	the	the	DT
18637	19305	22	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	19305	23	or	or	CC
18637	19305	24	value	value	NN
18637	19305	25	of	of	IN
18637	19305	26	private	private	JJ
18637	19305	27	property	property	NN
18637	19305	28	which	which	WDT
18637	19305	29	public	public	JJ
18637	19305	30	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	19305	31	or	or	CC
18637	19305	32	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	19305	33	acting	act	VBG
18637	19305	34	in	in	IN
18637	19305	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19305	36	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	19305	37	may	may	MD
18637	19305	38	occasion	occasion	VB
18637	19305	39	without	without	IN
18637	19305	40	the	the	DT
18637	19305	41	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19305	42	of	of	IN
18637	19305	43	paying	pay	VBG
18637	19305	44	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19305	45	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	19305	46	.	.	.
18637	19306	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19306	2	,	,	,
18637	19306	3	in	in	IN
18637	19306	4	upholding	uphold	VBG
18637	19306	5	zoning	zoning	NN
18637	19306	6	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	19306	7	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	19306	8	the	the	DT
18637	19306	9	height	height	NN
18637	19306	10	of	of	IN
18637	19306	11	buildings	building	NNS
18637	19306	12	which	which	WDT
18637	19306	13	may	may	MD
18637	19306	14	be	be	VB
18637	19306	15	constructed	construct	VBN
18637	19306	16	in	in	IN
18637	19306	17	a	a	DT
18637	19306	18	designated	designate	VBN
18637	19306	19	zone	zone	NN
18637	19306	20	,	,	,
18637	19306	21	the	the	DT
18637	19306	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19306	23	has	have	VBZ
18637	19306	24	warned	warn	VBN
18637	19306	25	that	that	IN
18637	19306	26	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19306	27	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	19306	28	,	,	,
18637	19306	29	if	if	IN
18637	19306	30	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19306	31	,	,	,
18637	19306	32	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19306	33	,	,	,
18637	19306	34	and	and	CC
18637	19306	35	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	19306	36	,	,	,
18637	19306	37	may	may	MD
18637	19306	38	be	be	VB
18637	19306	39	held	hold	VBN
18637	19306	40	to	to	TO
18637	19306	41	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	19306	42	an	an	DT
18637	19306	43	owner	owner	NN
18637	19306	44	of	of	IN
18637	19306	45	the	the	DT
18637	19306	46	profitable	profitable	JJ
18637	19306	47	use	use	NN
18637	19306	48	of	of	IN
18637	19306	49	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19306	50	property	property	NN
18637	19306	51	and	and	CC
18637	19306	52	hence	hence	RB
18637	19306	53	to	to	TO
18637	19306	54	amount	amount	VB
18637	19306	55	to	to	IN
18637	19306	56	a	a	DT
18637	19306	57	taking	take	VBG
18637	19306	58	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19306	59	to	to	TO
18637	19306	60	require	require	VB
18637	19306	61	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19306	62	to	to	TO
18637	19306	63	be	be	VB
18637	19306	64	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19306	65	for	for	IN
18637	19306	66	such	such	JJ
18637	19306	67	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	19306	68	of	of	IN
18637	19306	69	property	property	NN
18637	19306	70	rights	right	NNS
18637	19306	71	.	.	.
18637	19307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19307	2	667	667	CD
18637	19307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19307	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19307	5	,	,	,
18637	19307	6	in	in	IN
18637	19307	7	voiding	void	VBG
18637	19307	8	a	a	DT
18637	19307	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	19307	10	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	19307	11	mining	mining	NN
18637	19307	12	of	of	IN
18637	19307	13	coal	coal	NN
18637	19307	14	under	under	IN
18637	19307	15	private	private	JJ
18637	19307	16	dwellings	dwelling	NNS
18637	19307	17	or	or	CC
18637	19307	18	streets	street	NNS
18637	19307	19	or	or	CC
18637	19307	20	cities	city	NNS
18637	19307	21	in	in	IN
18637	19307	22	places	place	NNS
18637	19307	23	where	where	WRB
18637	19307	24	such	such	JJ
18637	19307	25	right	right	NN
18637	19307	26	to	to	IN
18637	19307	27	mine	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19307	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	19307	29	been	be	VBN
18637	19307	30	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	19307	31	in	in	IN
18637	19307	32	a	a	DT
18637	19307	33	conveyance	conveyance	NN
18637	19307	34	,	,	,
18637	19307	35	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19307	36	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	19307	37	,	,	,
18637	19307	38	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	19307	39	for	for	IN
18637	19307	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19307	41	associates	associate	NNS
18637	19307	42	,	,	,
18637	19307	43	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19307	44	if	if	IN
18637	19307	45	a	a	DT
18637	19307	46	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	19307	47	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	19307	48	the	the	DT
18637	19307	49	use	use	NN
18637	19307	50	of	of	IN
18637	19307	51	private	private	JJ
18637	19307	52	property	property	NN
18637	19307	53	goes	go	VBZ
18637	19307	54	too	too	RB
18637	19307	55	far	far	RB
18637	19307	56	,	,	,
18637	19307	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19307	58	will	will	MD
18637	19307	59	be	be	VB
18637	19307	60	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	19307	61	as	as	IN
18637	19307	62	a	a	DT
18637	19307	63	taking	taking	NN
18637	19307	64	for	for	IN
18637	19307	65	which	which	WDT
18637	19307	66	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19307	67	must	must	MD
18637	19307	68	be	be	VB
18637	19307	69	made	make	VBN
18637	19307	70	.	.	.
18637	19308	1	"	"	``
18637	19308	2	Some	some	DT
18637	19308	3	values	value	NNS
18637	19308	4	are	be	VBP
18637	19308	5	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
18637	19308	6	under	under	IN
18637	19308	7	an	an	DT
18637	19308	8	implied	imply	VBN
18637	19308	9	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	19308	10	,	,	,
18637	19308	11	and	and	CC
18637	19308	12	must	must	MD
18637	19308	13	yield	yield	VB
18637	19308	14	to	to	IN
18637	19308	15	the	the	DT
18637	19308	16	police	police	NN
18637	19308	17	power	power	NN
18637	19308	18	.	.	.
18637	19309	1	But	but	CC
18637	19309	2	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	19309	3	the	the	DT
18637	19309	4	implied	implied	JJ
18637	19309	5	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	19309	6	must	must	MD
18637	19309	7	have	have	VB
18637	19309	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19309	9	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19309	10	,	,	,
18637	19309	11	*	*	NFP
18637	19309	12	*	*	NFP
18637	19309	13	*	*	NFP
18637	19309	14	One	one	CD
18637	19309	15	fact	fact	NN
18637	19309	16	for	for	IN
18637	19309	17	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	19309	18	in	in	IN
18637	19309	19	determining	determine	VBG
18637	19309	20	such	such	JJ
18637	19309	21	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19309	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	19309	23	the	the	DT
18637	19309	24	extent	extent	NN
18637	19309	25	of	of	IN
18637	19309	26	the	the	DT
18637	19309	27	diminution	diminution	NN
18637	19309	28	.	.	.
18637	19310	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19310	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19310	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19310	4	The	the	DT
18637	19310	5	damage	damage	NN
18637	19310	6	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19310	7	here	here	RB
18637	19310	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19310	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19310	10	not	not	RB
18637	19310	11	common	common	JJ
18637	19310	12	or	or	CC
18637	19310	13	public	public	JJ
18637	19310	14	.	.	.
18637	19311	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19311	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19311	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19311	4	The	the	DT
18637	19311	5	extent	extent	NN
18637	19311	6	of	of	IN
18637	19311	7	the	the	DT
18637	19311	8	taking	taking	NN
18637	19311	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19311	10	great	great	JJ
18637	19311	11	.	.	.
18637	19312	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19312	2	purports	purport	VBZ
18637	19312	3	to	to	TO
18637	19312	4	abolish	abolish	VB
18637	19312	5	what	what	WP
18637	19312	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19312	7	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	19312	8	in	in	IN
18637	19312	9	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	19312	10	as	as	IN
18637	19312	11	an	an	DT
18637	19312	12	estate	estate	NN
18637	19312	13	in	in	IN
18637	19312	14	land	land	NN
18637	19312	15	.	.	.
18637	19313	1	"	"	``
18637	19313	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19313	3	668	668	CD
18637	19313	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19313	5	Due	Due	NNP
18637	19313	6	Process	Process	NNP
18637	19313	7	in	in	IN
18637	19313	8	Eminent	Eminent	NNP
18637	19313	9	Domain	Domain	NNP
18637	19313	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19313	11	1	1	LS
18637	19313	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19313	13	Notice.--If	Notice.--If	NNP
18637	19313	14	the	the	DT
18637	19313	15	owner	owner	NN
18637	19313	16	of	of	IN
18637	19313	17	property	property	NN
18637	19313	18	sought	seek	VBN
18637	19313	19	to	to	TO
18637	19313	20	be	be	VB
18637	19313	21	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	19313	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	19313	23	a	a	DT
18637	19313	24	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19313	25	,	,	,
18637	19313	26	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19313	27	notice	notice	NN
18637	19313	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	19313	29	not	not	RB
18637	19313	30	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	19313	31	and	and	CC
18637	19313	32	service	service	NN
18637	19313	33	may	may	MD
18637	19313	34	be	be	VB
18637	19313	35	effected	effect	VBN
18637	19313	36	by	by	IN
18637	19313	37	publication	publication	NN
18637	19313	38	.	.	.
18637	19314	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19314	2	669	669	CD
18637	19314	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19314	4	In	in	IN
18637	19314	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	19314	6	,	,	,
18637	19314	7	"	"	``
18637	19314	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19314	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	19314	10	been	be	VBN
18637	19314	11	uniformly	uniformly	RB
18637	19314	12	held	hold	VBN
18637	19314	13	that	that	IN
18637	19314	14	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	19314	15	providing	provide	VBG
18637	19314	16	for	for	IN
18637	19314	17	*	*	NFP
18637	19314	18	*	*	NFP
18637	19314	19	*	*	NFP
18637	19314	20	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	19314	21	of	of	IN
18637	19314	22	land	land	NN
18637	19314	23	may	may	MD
18637	19314	24	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	19314	25	a	a	DT
18637	19314	26	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19314	27	summary	summary	NN
18637	19314	28	in	in	IN
18637	19314	29	character	character	NN
18637	19314	30	,	,	,
18637	19314	31	and	and	CC
18637	19314	32	that	that	DT
18637	19314	33	notice	notice	NN
18637	19314	34	of	of	IN
18637	19314	35	such	such	JJ
18637	19314	36	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19314	37	may	may	MD
18637	19314	38	be	be	VB
18637	19314	39	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	19314	40	,	,	,
18637	19314	41	provided	provide	VBN
18637	19314	42	only	only	RB
18637	19314	43	that	that	IN
18637	19314	44	the	the	DT
18637	19314	45	period	period	NN
18637	19314	46	of	of	IN
18637	19314	47	notice	notice	NN
18637	19314	48	of	of	IN
18637	19314	49	the	the	DT
18637	19314	50	initiation	initiation	NN
18637	19314	51	of	of	IN
18637	19314	52	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19314	53	and	and	CC
18637	19314	54	the	the	DT
18637	19314	55	method	method	NN
18637	19314	56	of	of	IN
18637	19314	57	giving	give	VBG
18637	19314	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19314	59	are	be	VBP
18637	19314	60	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	19314	61	adapted	adapt	VBN
18637	19314	62	to	to	IN
18637	19314	63	the	the	DT
18637	19314	64	nature	nature	NN
18637	19314	65	of	of	IN
18637	19314	66	the	the	DT
18637	19314	67	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19314	68	and	and	CC
18637	19314	69	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19314	70	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19314	71	matter	matter	NN
18637	19314	72	.	.	.
18637	19314	73	"	"	''
18637	19315	1	Insofar	insofar	RB
18637	19315	2	as	as	IN
18637	19315	3	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19315	4	notice	notice	NN
18637	19315	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19315	6	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19315	7	to	to	TO
18637	19315	8	be	be	VB
18637	19315	9	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19315	10	,	,	,
18637	19315	11	that	that	DT
18637	19315	12	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19315	13	was	be	VBD
18637	19315	14	declared	declare	VBN
18637	19315	15	to	to	TO
18637	19315	16	have	have	VB
18637	19315	17	been	be	VBN
18637	19315	18	satisfied	satisfy	VBN
18637	19315	19	by	by	IN
18637	19315	20	a	a	DT
18637	19315	21	statute	statute	NN
18637	19315	22	providing	provide	VBG
18637	19315	23	that	that	DT
18637	19315	24	notice	notice	NN
18637	19315	25	of	of	IN
18637	19315	26	initiation	initiation	NN
18637	19315	27	of	of	IN
18637	19315	28	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19315	29	for	for	IN
18637	19315	30	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	19315	31	of	of	IN
18637	19315	32	a	a	DT
18637	19315	33	county	county	NN
18637	19315	34	road	road	NN
18637	19315	35	be	be	VB
18637	19315	36	published	publish	VBN
18637	19315	37	on	on	IN
18637	19315	38	three	three	CD
18637	19315	39	successive	successive	JJ
18637	19315	40	weeks	week	NNS
18637	19315	41	in	in	IN
18637	19315	42	three	three	CD
18637	19315	43	successive	successive	JJ
18637	19315	44	issues	issue	NNS
18637	19315	45	of	of	IN
18637	19315	46	a	a	DT
18637	19315	47	paper	paper	NN
18637	19315	48	published	publish	VBN
18637	19315	49	in	in	IN
18637	19315	50	the	the	DT
18637	19315	51	county	county	NN
18637	19315	52	,	,	,
18637	19315	53	and	and	CC
18637	19315	54	that	that	IN
18637	19315	55	all	all	DT
18637	19315	56	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	19315	57	of	of	IN
18637	19315	58	the	the	DT
18637	19315	59	county	county	NN
18637	19315	60	condemning	condemn	VBG
18637	19315	61	agency	agency	NN
18637	19315	62	be	be	VB
18637	19315	63	public	public	JJ
18637	19315	64	and	and	CC
18637	19315	65	published	publish	VBN
18637	19315	66	in	in	IN
18637	19315	67	a	a	DT
18637	19315	68	county	county	NN
18637	19315	69	newspaper	newspaper	NN
18637	19315	70	.	.	.
18637	19316	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19316	2	670	670	CD
18637	19316	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19316	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19316	5	2	2	LS
18637	19316	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19316	7	Hearing.--The	hearing.--the	NN
18637	19316	8	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19316	9	and	and	CC
18637	19316	10	expediency	expediency	NN
18637	19316	11	of	of	IN
18637	19316	12	a	a	DT
18637	19316	13	taking	take	VBG
18637	19316	14	being	be	VBG
18637	19316	15	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19316	16	questions	question	NNS
18637	19316	17	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	19316	18	of	of	IN
18637	19316	19	who	who	WP
18637	19316	20	may	may	MD
18637	19316	21	be	be	VB
18637	19316	22	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19316	23	with	with	IN
18637	19316	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19316	25	decision	decision	NN
18637	19316	26	,	,	,
18637	19316	27	a	a	DT
18637	19316	28	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19316	29	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	19316	30	need	nee	MD
18637	19316	31	not	not	RB
18637	19316	32	be	be	VB
18637	19316	33	afforded;[671	afforded;[671	ADD
18637	19316	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19316	35	but	but	CC
18637	19316	36	the	the	DT
18637	19316	37	mode	mode	NN
18637	19316	38	of	of	IN
18637	19316	39	determining	determine	VBG
18637	19316	40	the	the	DT
18637	19316	41	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19316	42	payable	payable	JJ
18637	19316	43	to	to	IN
18637	19316	44	an	an	DT
18637	19316	45	owner	owner	NN
18637	19316	46	must	must	MD
18637	19316	47	be	be	VB
18637	19316	48	such	such	JJ
18637	19316	49	as	as	IN
18637	19316	50	to	to	TO
18637	19316	51	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	19316	52	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19316	53	with	with	IN
18637	19316	54	an	an	DT
18637	19316	55	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19316	56	to	to	TO
18637	19316	57	be	be	VB
18637	19316	58	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19316	59	.	.	.
18637	19317	1	Among	among	IN
18637	19317	2	several	several	JJ
18637	19317	3	admissible	admissible	JJ
18637	19317	4	modes	mode	NNS
18637	19317	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19317	6	that	that	DT
18637	19317	7	of	of	IN
18637	19317	8	causing	cause	VBG
18637	19317	9	the	the	DT
18637	19317	10	amount	amount	NN
18637	19317	11	to	to	TO
18637	19317	12	be	be	VB
18637	19317	13	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	19317	14	by	by	IN
18637	19317	15	viewers	viewer	NNS
18637	19317	16	,	,	,
18637	19317	17	or	or	CC
18637	19317	18	by	by	IN
18637	19317	19	a	a	DT
18637	19317	20	jury	jury	NN
18637	19317	21	,	,	,
18637	19317	22	generally	generally	RB
18637	19317	23	without	without	IN
18637	19317	24	a	a	DT
18637	19317	25	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19317	26	,	,	,
18637	19317	27	but	but	CC
18637	19317	28	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19317	29	to	to	IN
18637	19317	30	the	the	DT
18637	19317	31	right	right	NN
18637	19317	32	of	of	IN
18637	19317	33	the	the	DT
18637	19317	34	owner	owner	NN
18637	19317	35	to	to	TO
18637	19317	36	appeal	appeal	VB
18637	19317	37	for	for	IN
18637	19317	38	a	a	DT
18637	19317	39	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19317	40	review	review	NN
18637	19317	41	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19317	42	at	at	IN
18637	19317	43	which	which	WDT
18637	19317	44	a	a	DT
18637	19317	45	trial	trial	NN
18637	19317	46	on	on	IN
18637	19317	47	the	the	DT
18637	19317	48	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19317	49	may	may	MD
18637	19317	50	be	be	VB
18637	19317	51	had	have	VBN
18637	19317	52	.	.	.
18637	19318	1	Through	through	IN
18637	19318	2	such	such	PDT
18637	19318	3	an	an	DT
18637	19318	4	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	19318	5	the	the	DT
18637	19318	6	owner	owner	NN
18637	19318	7	obtains	obtain	VBZ
18637	19318	8	the	the	DT
18637	19318	9	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19318	10	to	to	TO
18637	19318	11	which	which	WDT
18637	19318	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19318	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	19318	14	entitled;[672	entitled;[672	LS
18637	19318	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19318	16	and	and	CC
18637	19318	17	the	the	DT
18637	19318	18	fact	fact	NN
18637	19318	19	that	that	IN
18637	19318	20	after	after	IN
18637	19318	21	having	have	VBG
18637	19318	22	been	be	VBN
18637	19318	23	adequately	adequately	RB
18637	19318	24	notified	notify	VBN
18637	19318	25	of	of	IN
18637	19318	26	the	the	DT
18637	19318	27	determination	determination	NN
18637	19318	28	by	by	IN
18637	19318	29	the	the	DT
18637	19318	30	condemning	condemn	VBG
18637	19318	31	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	19318	32	,	,	,
18637	19318	33	the	the	DT
18637	19318	34	former	former	JJ
18637	19318	35	must	must	MD
18637	19318	36	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	19318	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19318	38	right	right	NN
18637	19318	39	of	of	IN
18637	19318	40	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	19318	41	within	within	IN
18637	19318	42	a	a	DT
18637	19318	43	limited	limited	JJ
18637	19318	44	period	period	NN
18637	19318	45	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	19318	46	,	,	,
18637	19318	47	such	such	JJ
18637	19318	48	as	as	IN
18637	19318	49	30	30	CD
18637	19318	50	days	day	NNS
18637	19318	51	,	,	,
18637	19318	52	has	have	VBZ
18637	19318	53	been	be	VBN
18637	19318	54	held	hold	VBN
18637	19318	55	not	not	RB
18637	19318	56	so	so	RB
18637	19318	57	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19318	58	as	as	IN
18637	19318	59	to	to	TO
18637	19318	60	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	19318	61	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19318	62	of	of	IN
18637	19318	63	property	property	NN
18637	19318	64	without	without	IN
18637	19318	65	due	due	JJ
18637	19318	66	process	process	NN
18637	19318	67	of	of	IN
18637	19318	68	law	law	NN
18637	19318	69	.	.	.
18637	19319	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19319	2	673	673	CD
18637	19319	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19319	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19319	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19319	6	there	there	EX
18637	19319	7	any	any	DT
18637	19319	8	"	"	``
18637	19319	9	denial	denial	NN
18637	19319	10	of	of	IN
18637	19319	11	due	due	JJ
18637	19319	12	process	process	NN
18637	19319	13	in	in	IN
18637	19319	14	making	make	VBG
18637	19319	15	the	the	DT
18637	19319	16	findings	finding	NNS
18637	19319	17	of	of	IN
18637	19319	18	fact	fact	NN
18637	19319	19	by	by	IN
18637	19319	20	the	the	DT
18637	19319	21	triers	trier	NNS
18637	19319	22	of	of	IN
18637	19319	23	fact	fact	NN
18637	19319	24	,	,	,
18637	19319	25	whether	whether	IN
18637	19319	26	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	19319	27	or	or	CC
18637	19319	28	a	a	DT
18637	19319	29	jury	jury	NN
18637	19319	30	,	,	,
18637	19319	31	final	final	JJ
18637	19319	32	as	as	IN
18637	19319	33	to	to	IN
18637	19319	34	such	such	JJ
18637	19319	35	facts	fact	NNS
18637	19319	36	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19319	37	that	that	RB
18637	19319	38	is	is	RB
18637	19319	39	,	,	,
18637	19319	40	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	19319	41	as	as	IN
18637	19319	42	to	to	IN
18637	19319	43	the	the	DT
18637	19319	44	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19319	45	value	value	NN
18637	19319	46	of	of	IN
18637	19319	47	the	the	DT
18637	19319	48	property	property	NN
18637	19319	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19319	50	,	,	,
18637	19319	51	and	and	CC
18637	19319	52	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	19319	53	open	open	JJ
18637	19319	54	to	to	IN
18637	19319	55	the	the	DT
18637	19319	56	courts	court	NNS
18637	19319	57	simply	simply	RB
18637	19319	58	the	the	DT
18637	19319	59	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	19319	60	as	as	IN
18637	19319	61	to	to	IN
18637	19319	62	whether	whether	IN
18637	19319	63	there	there	EX
18637	19319	64	was	be	VBD
18637	19319	65	any	any	DT
18637	19319	66	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
18637	19319	67	basis	basis	NN
18637	19319	68	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	19319	69	by	by	IN
18637	19319	70	the	the	DT
18637	19319	71	triers	trier	NNS
18637	19319	72	in	in	IN
18637	19319	73	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19319	74	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	19319	75	,	,	,
18637	19319	76	*	*	NFP
18637	19319	77	*	*	NFP
18637	19319	78	*	*	NFP
18637	19319	79	"	"	''
18637	19319	80	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19319	81	674	674	CD
18637	19319	82	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19319	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19319	84	3	3	LS
18637	19319	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19319	86	Occupation	Occupation	NNP
18637	19319	87	in	in	IN
18637	19319	88	Advance	Advance	NNP
18637	19319	89	of	of	IN
18637	19319	90	Condemnation.--Due	Condemnation.--Due	NNP
18637	19319	91	process	process	NN
18637	19319	92	does	do	VBZ
18637	19319	93	require	require	VB
18637	19319	94	that	that	IN
18637	19319	95	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	19319	96	precede	precede	NN
18637	19319	97	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	19319	98	by	by	IN
18637	19319	99	the	the	DT
18637	19319	100	condemning	condemn	VBG
18637	19319	101	authority	authority	NN
18637	19319	102	so	so	RB
18637	19319	103	long	long	RB
18637	19319	104	as	as	IN
18637	19319	105	the	the	DT
18637	19319	106	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19319	107	for	for	IN
18637	19319	108	a	a	DT
18637	19319	109	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19319	110	as	as	IN
18637	19319	111	to	to	IN
18637	19319	112	the	the	DT
18637	19319	113	value	value	NN
18637	19319	114	of	of	IN
18637	19319	115	the	the	DT
18637	19319	116	land	land	NN
18637	19319	117	is	be	VBZ
18637	19319	118	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	19319	119	during	during	IN
18637	19319	120	the	the	DT
18637	19319	121	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	19319	122	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19319	123	.	.	.
18637	19320	1	Where	where	WRB
18637	19320	2	the	the	DT
18637	19320	3	statute	statute	NN
18637	19320	4	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	19320	5	an	an	DT
18637	19320	6	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19320	7	provision	provision	NN
18637	19320	8	for	for	IN
18637	19320	9	assured	assured	JJ
18637	19320	10	payment	payment	NN
18637	19320	11	of	of	IN
18637	19320	12	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19320	13	without	without	IN
18637	19320	14	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19320	15	delay	delay	NN
18637	19320	16	,	,	,
18637	19320	17	the	the	DT
18637	19320	18	taking	taking	NN
18637	19320	19	may	may	MD
18637	19320	20	precede	precede	VB
18637	19320	21	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19320	22	.	.	.
18637	19321	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19321	2	675	675	CD
18637	19321	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19321	4	DUE	DUE	NNP
18637	19321	5	PROCESS	PROCESS	NNP
18637	19321	6	OF	of	IN
18637	19321	7	LAW	law	NN
18637	19321	8	IN	in	IN
18637	19321	9	CIVIL	CIVIL	NNP
18637	19321	10	PROCEEDINGS	proceeding	NNS
18637	19321	11	Some	some	DT
18637	19321	12	General	General	NNP
18637	19321	13	Criteria	criterion	NNS
18637	19321	14	What	what	WP
18637	19321	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	19321	16	due	due	JJ
18637	19321	17	process	process	NN
18637	19321	18	of	of	IN
18637	19321	19	law	law	NN
18637	19321	20	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	19321	21	on	on	IN
18637	19321	22	the	the	DT
18637	19321	23	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19321	24	.	.	.
18637	19322	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19322	2	676	676	CD
18637	19322	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19322	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19322	5	varies	vary	VBZ
18637	19322	6	with	with	IN
18637	19322	7	the	the	DT
18637	19322	8	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19322	9	matter	matter	NN
18637	19322	10	and	and	CC
18637	19322	11	the	the	DT
18637	19322	12	necessities	necessity	NNS
18637	19322	13	of	of	IN
18637	19322	14	the	the	DT
18637	19322	15	situation	situation	NN
18637	19322	16	.	.	.
18637	19323	1	By	by	IN
18637	19323	2	due	due	JJ
18637	19323	3	process	process	NN
18637	19323	4	of	of	IN
18637	19323	5	law	law	NN
18637	19323	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19323	7	meant	mean	VBN
18637	19323	8	one	one	CD
18637	19323	9	which	which	WDT
18637	19323	10	,	,	,
18637	19323	11	following	follow	VBG
18637	19323	12	the	the	DT
18637	19323	13	forms	form	NNS
18637	19323	14	of	of	IN
18637	19323	15	law	law	NN
18637	19323	16	,	,	,
18637	19323	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	19323	18	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	19323	19	to	to	IN
18637	19323	20	the	the	DT
18637	19323	21	case	case	NN
18637	19323	22	,	,	,
18637	19323	23	and	and	CC
18637	19323	24	just	just	RB
18637	19323	25	to	to	IN
18637	19323	26	the	the	DT
18637	19323	27	parties	party	NNS
18637	19323	28	affected	affect	VBN
18637	19323	29	.	.	.
18637	19324	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19324	2	must	must	MD
18637	19324	3	be	be	VB
18637	19324	4	pursued	pursue	VBN
18637	19324	5	in	in	IN
18637	19324	6	the	the	DT
18637	19324	7	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	19324	8	mode	mode	NN
18637	19324	9	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	19324	10	by	by	IN
18637	19324	11	law	law	NN
18637	19324	12	;	;	:
18637	19324	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19324	14	must	must	MD
18637	19324	15	be	be	VB
18637	19324	16	adapted	adapt	VBN
18637	19324	17	to	to	IN
18637	19324	18	the	the	DT
18637	19324	19	end	end	NN
18637	19324	20	to	to	TO
18637	19324	21	be	be	VB
18637	19324	22	attained	attain	VBN
18637	19324	23	;	;	:
18637	19324	24	and	and	CC
18637	19324	25	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	19324	26	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19324	27	to	to	IN
18637	19324	28	the	the	DT
18637	19324	29	protection	protection	NN
18637	19324	30	of	of	IN
18637	19324	31	the	the	DT
18637	19324	32	parties	party	NNS
18637	19324	33	,	,	,
18637	19324	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19324	35	must	must	MD
18637	19324	36	give	give	VB
18637	19324	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19324	38	an	an	DT
18637	19324	39	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19324	40	to	to	TO
18637	19324	41	be	be	VB
18637	19324	42	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19324	43	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	19324	44	the	the	DT
18637	19324	45	justice	justice	NN
18637	19324	46	of	of	IN
18637	19324	47	the	the	DT
18637	19324	48	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19324	49	sought	seek	VBD
18637	19324	50	.	.	.
18637	19325	1	Any	any	DT
18637	19325	2	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19325	3	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19325	4	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	19325	5	by	by	IN
18637	19325	6	public	public	JJ
18637	19325	7	authority	authority	NN
18637	19325	8	,	,	,
18637	19325	9	whether	whether	IN
18637	19325	10	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
18637	19325	11	by	by	IN
18637	19325	12	age	age	NN
18637	19325	13	or	or	CC
18637	19325	14	custom	custom	NN
18637	19325	15	or	or	CC
18637	19325	16	newly	newly	RB
18637	19325	17	devised	devise	VBN
18637	19325	18	in	in	IN
18637	19325	19	the	the	DT
18637	19325	20	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	19325	21	of	of	IN
18637	19325	22	the	the	DT
18637	19325	23	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19325	24	power	power	NN
18637	19325	25	,	,	,
18637	19325	26	which	which	WDT
18637	19325	27	regards	regard	VBZ
18637	19325	28	and	and	CC
18637	19325	29	preserves	preserve	NNS
18637	19325	30	these	these	DT
18637	19325	31	principles	principle	NNS
18637	19325	32	of	of	IN
18637	19325	33	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19325	34	and	and	CC
18637	19325	35	justice	justice	NN
18637	19325	36	,	,	,
18637	19325	37	must	must	MD
18637	19325	38	be	be	VB
18637	19325	39	held	hold	VBN
18637	19325	40	to	to	TO
18637	19325	41	be	be	VB
18637	19325	42	due	due	JJ
18637	19325	43	process	process	NN
18637	19325	44	of	of	IN
18637	19325	45	law	law	NN
18637	19325	46	.	.	.
18637	19326	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19326	2	677	677	CD
18637	19326	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19326	4	Ancient	Ancient	NNP
18637	19326	5	Usage	Usage	NNP
18637	19326	6	and	and	CC
18637	19326	7	Uniformity.--What	Uniformity.--What	,
18637	19326	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	19326	9	due	due	JJ
18637	19326	10	process	process	NN
18637	19326	11	of	of	IN
18637	19326	12	law	law	NN
18637	19326	13	may	may	MD
18637	19326	14	be	be	VB
18637	19326	15	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	19326	16	in	in	IN
18637	19326	17	part	part	NN
18637	19326	18	by	by	IN
18637	19326	19	an	an	DT
18637	19326	20	examination	examination	NN
18637	19326	21	of	of	IN
18637	19326	22	those	those	DT
18637	19326	23	settled	settle	VBN
18637	19326	24	usages	usage	NNS
18637	19326	25	and	and	CC
18637	19326	26	modes	mode	NNS
18637	19326	27	of	of	IN
18637	19326	28	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19326	29	existing	exist	VBG
18637	19326	30	in	in	IN
18637	19326	31	the	the	DT
18637	19326	32	common	common	JJ
18637	19326	33	and	and	CC
18637	19326	34	statute	statute	NN
18637	19326	35	law	law	NN
18637	19326	36	of	of	IN
18637	19326	37	England	England	NNP
18637	19326	38	before	before	IN
18637	19326	39	the	the	DT
18637	19326	40	emigration	emigration	NN
18637	19326	41	of	of	IN
18637	19326	42	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19326	43	ancestors	ancestor	NNS
18637	19326	44	,	,	,
18637	19326	45	and	and	CC
18637	19326	46	shown	show	VBN
18637	19326	47	not	not	RB
18637	19326	48	to	to	TO
18637	19326	49	have	have	VB
18637	19326	50	been	be	VBN
18637	19326	51	unsuited	unsuited	JJ
18637	19326	52	to	to	IN
18637	19326	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19326	54	civil	civil	JJ
18637	19326	55	and	and	CC
18637	19326	56	political	political	JJ
18637	19326	57	condition	condition	NN
18637	19326	58	by	by	IN
18637	19326	59	having	have	VBG
18637	19326	60	been	be	VBN
18637	19326	61	acted	act	VBN
18637	19326	62	on	on	IN
18637	19326	63	by	by	IN
18637	19326	64	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19326	65	after	after	IN
18637	19326	66	the	the	DT
18637	19326	67	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	19326	68	of	of	IN
18637	19326	69	this	this	DT
18637	19326	70	country	country	NN
18637	19326	71	.	.	.
18637	19327	1	If	if	IN
18637	19327	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19327	3	can	can	MD
18637	19327	4	show	show	VB
18637	19327	5	the	the	DT
18637	19327	6	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	19327	7	of	of	IN
18637	19327	8	settled	settle	VBN
18637	19327	9	usage	usage	NN
18637	19327	10	both	both	DT
18637	19327	11	in	in	IN
18637	19327	12	England	England	NNP
18637	19327	13	and	and	CC
18637	19327	14	in	in	IN
18637	19327	15	this	this	DT
18637	19327	16	country	country	NN
18637	19327	17	,	,	,
18637	19327	18	a	a	DT
18637	19327	19	process	process	NN
18637	19327	20	of	of	IN
18637	19327	21	law	law	NN
18637	19327	22	which	which	WDT
18637	19327	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	19327	24	not	not	RB
18637	19327	25	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	19327	26	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	19327	27	may	may	MD
18637	19327	28	be	be	VB
18637	19327	29	taken	take	VBN
18637	19327	30	to	to	TO
18637	19327	31	be	be	VB
18637	19327	32	due	due	JJ
18637	19327	33	process	process	NN
18637	19327	34	of	of	IN
18637	19327	35	law	law	NN
18637	19327	36	.	.	.
18637	19328	1	In	in	IN
18637	19328	2	other	other	JJ
18637	19328	3	words	word	NNS
18637	19328	4	,	,	,
18637	19328	5	the	the	DT
18637	19328	6	antiquity	antiquity	NN
18637	19328	7	of	of	IN
18637	19328	8	a	a	DT
18637	19328	9	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19328	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	19328	11	a	a	DT
18637	19328	12	fact	fact	NN
18637	19328	13	of	of	IN
18637	19328	14	weight	weight	NN
18637	19328	15	in	in	IN
18637	19328	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19328	17	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	19328	18	.	.	.
18637	19329	1	However	however	RB
18637	19329	2	,	,	,
18637	19329	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19329	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	19329	5	not	not	RB
18637	19329	6	follow	follow	VB
18637	19329	7	that	that	IN
18637	19329	8	a	a	DT
18637	19329	9	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19329	10	settled	settle	VBN
18637	19329	11	in	in	IN
18637	19329	12	English	English	NNP
18637	19329	13	law	law	NN
18637	19329	14	at	at	IN
18637	19329	15	the	the	DT
18637	19329	16	time	time	NN
18637	19329	17	of	of	IN
18637	19329	18	the	the	DT
18637	19329	19	emigration	emigration	NN
18637	19329	20	and	and	CC
18637	19329	21	brought	bring	VBD
18637	19329	22	to	to	IN
18637	19329	23	this	this	DT
18637	19329	24	country	country	NN
18637	19329	25	and	and	CC
18637	19329	26	practiced	practice	VBN
18637	19329	27	by	by	IN
18637	19329	28	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19329	29	ancestors	ancestor	NNS
18637	19329	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	19329	31	,	,	,
18637	19329	32	or	or	CC
18637	19329	33	remains	remain	VBZ
18637	19329	34	,	,	,
18637	19329	35	an	an	DT
18637	19329	36	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19329	37	element	element	NN
18637	19329	38	of	of	IN
18637	19329	39	due	due	JJ
18637	19329	40	process	process	NN
18637	19329	41	of	of	IN
18637	19329	42	law	law	NN
18637	19329	43	.	.	.
18637	19330	1	If	if	IN
18637	19330	2	that	that	DT
18637	19330	3	were	be	VBD
18637	19330	4	so	so	RB
18637	19330	5	,	,	,
18637	19330	6	the	the	DT
18637	19330	7	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19330	8	of	of	IN
18637	19330	9	the	the	DT
18637	19330	10	first	first	JJ
18637	19330	11	half	half	NN
18637	19330	12	of	of	IN
18637	19330	13	the	the	DT
18637	19330	14	seventeenth	seventeenth	JJ
18637	19330	15	century	century	NN
18637	19330	16	would	would	MD
18637	19330	17	be	be	VB
18637	19330	18	fastened	fasten	VBN
18637	19330	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	19330	20	American	american	JJ
18637	19330	21	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
18637	19330	22	like	like	IN
18637	19330	23	a	a	DT
18637	19330	24	strait	strait	JJ
18637	19330	25	jacket	jacket	NN
18637	19330	26	,	,	,
18637	19330	27	only	only	RB
18637	19330	28	to	to	TO
18637	19330	29	be	be	VB
18637	19330	30	unloosed	unloose	VBN
18637	19330	31	by	by	IN
18637	19330	32	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19330	33	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	19330	34	.	.	.
18637	19331	1	Fortunately	fortunately	RB
18637	19331	2	,	,	,
18637	19331	3	the	the	DT
18637	19331	4	States	state	NNS
18637	19331	5	are	be	VBP
18637	19331	6	not	not	RB
18637	19331	7	tied	tie	VBN
18637	19331	8	down	down	RP
18637	19331	9	by	by	IN
18637	19331	10	any	any	DT
18637	19331	11	provision	provision	NN
18637	19331	12	of	of	IN
18637	19331	13	the	the	DT
18637	19331	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19331	15	to	to	IN
18637	19331	16	the	the	DT
18637	19331	17	practice	practice	NN
18637	19331	18	and	and	CC
18637	19331	19	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19331	20	which	which	WDT
18637	19331	21	existed	exist	VBD
18637	19331	22	at	at	IN
18637	19331	23	the	the	DT
18637	19331	24	common	common	JJ
18637	19331	25	law	law	NN
18637	19331	26	,	,	,
18637	19331	27	but	but	CC
18637	19331	28	may	may	MD
18637	19331	29	avail	avail	VB
18637	19331	30	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19331	31	of	of	IN
18637	19331	32	the	the	DT
18637	19331	33	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	19331	34	gathered	gather	VBN
18637	19331	35	by	by	IN
18637	19331	36	the	the	DT
18637	19331	37	experience	experience	NN
18637	19331	38	of	of	IN
18637	19331	39	the	the	DT
18637	19331	40	country	country	NN
18637	19331	41	to	to	TO
18637	19331	42	make	make	VB
18637	19331	43	changes	change	NNS
18637	19331	44	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19331	45	to	to	TO
18637	19331	46	be	be	VB
18637	19331	47	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19331	48	.	.	.
18637	19332	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19332	2	678	678	CD
18637	19332	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19332	4	Equality.--If	Equality.--If	NNP
18637	19332	5	due	due	JJ
18637	19332	6	process	process	NN
18637	19332	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19332	8	to	to	TO
18637	19332	9	be	be	VB
18637	19332	10	secured	secure	VBN
18637	19332	11	,	,	,
18637	19332	12	the	the	DT
18637	19332	13	laws	law	NNS
18637	19332	14	must	must	MD
18637	19332	15	operate	operate	VB
18637	19332	16	alike	alike	RB
18637	19332	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	19332	18	all	all	DT
18637	19332	19	,	,	,
18637	19332	20	and	and	CC
18637	19332	21	not	not	RB
18637	19332	22	subject	subject	VB
18637	19332	23	the	the	DT
18637	19332	24	individual	individual	NN
18637	19332	25	to	to	IN
18637	19332	26	the	the	DT
18637	19332	27	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19332	28	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19332	29	of	of	IN
18637	19332	30	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	19332	31	power	power	NN
18637	19332	32	unrestrained	unrestraine	VBN
18637	19332	33	by	by	IN
18637	19332	34	established	establish	VBN
18637	19332	35	principles	principle	NNS
18637	19332	36	of	of	IN
18637	19332	37	private	private	JJ
18637	19332	38	rights	right	NNS
18637	19332	39	and	and	CC
18637	19332	40	distributive	distributive	JJ
18637	19332	41	justice	justice	NN
18637	19332	42	.	.	.
18637	19333	1	Where	where	WRB
18637	19333	2	a	a	DT
18637	19333	3	litigant	litigant	NN
18637	19333	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	19333	5	the	the	DT
18637	19333	6	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19333	7	of	of	IN
18637	19333	8	a	a	DT
18637	19333	9	full	full	JJ
18637	19333	10	and	and	CC
18637	19333	11	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19333	12	trial	trial	NN
18637	19333	13	in	in	IN
18637	19333	14	the	the	DT
18637	19333	15	State	State	NNP
18637	19333	16	courts	court	NNS
18637	19333	17	,	,	,
18637	19333	18	and	and	CC
18637	19333	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19333	20	rights	right	NNS
18637	19333	21	are	be	VBP
18637	19333	22	measured	measure	VBN
18637	19333	23	,	,	,
18637	19333	24	not	not	RB
18637	19333	25	by	by	IN
18637	19333	26	laws	law	NNS
18637	19333	27	made	make	VBN
18637	19333	28	to	to	TO
18637	19333	29	affect	affect	VB
18637	19333	30	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19333	31	individually	individually	RB
18637	19333	32	,	,	,
18637	19333	33	but	but	CC
18637	19333	34	by	by	IN
18637	19333	35	general	general	JJ
18637	19333	36	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	19333	37	of	of	IN
18637	19333	38	law	law	NN
18637	19333	39	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	19333	40	to	to	IN
18637	19333	41	all	all	PDT
18637	19333	42	those	those	DT
18637	19333	43	in	in	IN
18637	19333	44	like	like	IN
18637	19333	45	condition	condition	NN
18637	19333	46	,	,	,
18637	19333	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19333	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	19333	49	not	not	RB
18637	19333	50	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	19333	51	of	of	IN
18637	19333	52	property	property	NN
18637	19333	53	without	without	IN
18637	19333	54	due	due	JJ
18637	19333	55	process	process	NN
18637	19333	56	of	of	IN
18637	19333	57	law	law	NN
18637	19333	58	,	,	,
18637	19333	59	even	even	RB
18637	19333	60	if	if	IN
18637	19333	61	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19333	62	can	can	MD
18637	19333	63	be	be	VB
18637	19333	64	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	19333	65	as	as	IN
18637	19333	66	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	19333	67	of	of	IN
18637	19333	68	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19333	69	property	property	NN
18637	19333	70	by	by	IN
18637	19333	71	an	an	DT
18637	19333	72	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	19333	73	result	result	NN
18637	19333	74	.	.	.
18637	19334	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19334	2	679	679	CD
18637	19334	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19334	4	Due	Due	NNP
18637	19334	5	Process	Process	NNP
18637	19334	6	and	and	CC
18637	19334	7	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	19334	8	Process.--Due	Process.--Due	NNP
18637	19334	9	process	process	NN
18637	19334	10	of	of	IN
18637	19334	11	law	law	NN
18637	19334	12	does	do	VBZ
18637	19334	13	not	not	RB
18637	19334	14	always	always	RB
18637	19334	15	mean	mean	VB
18637	19334	16	a	a	DT
18637	19334	17	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19334	18	in	in	IN
18637	19334	19	court	court	NN
18637	19334	20	.	.	.
18637	19335	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19335	2	680	680	CD
18637	19335	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19335	4	Proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19335	5	to	to	TO
18637	19335	6	raise	raise	VB
18637	19335	7	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	19335	8	by	by	IN
18637	19335	9	levying	levy	VBG
18637	19335	10	and	and	CC
18637	19335	11	collecting	collect	VBG
18637	19335	12	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19335	13	are	be	VBP
18637	19335	14	not	not	RB
18637	19335	15	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	19335	16	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19335	17	,	,	,
18637	19335	18	neither	neither	CC
18637	19335	19	are	be	VBP
18637	19335	20	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	19335	21	and	and	CC
18637	19335	22	executive	executive	JJ
18637	19335	23	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19335	24	,	,	,
18637	19335	25	yet	yet	CC
18637	19335	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19335	27	validity	validity	NN
18637	19335	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	19335	29	not	not	RB
18637	19335	30	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	19335	31	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	19335	32	.	.	.
18637	19336	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19336	2	681	681	CD
18637	19336	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19336	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	19336	5	,	,	,
18637	19336	6	the	the	DT
18637	19336	7	due	due	JJ
18637	19336	8	process	process	NN
18637	19336	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	19336	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	19336	11	been	be	VBN
18637	19336	12	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	19336	13	as	as	IN
18637	19336	14	not	not	RB
18637	19336	15	requiring	require	VBG
18637	19336	16	that	that	IN
18637	19336	17	the	the	DT
18637	19336	18	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19336	19	of	of	IN
18637	19336	20	an	an	DT
18637	19336	21	expert	expert	NN
18637	19336	22	commission	commission	NN
18637	19336	23	be	be	VB
18637	19336	24	supplanted	supplant	VBN
18637	19336	25	by	by	IN
18637	19336	26	the	the	DT
18637	19336	27	independent	independent	JJ
18637	19336	28	view	view	NN
18637	19336	29	of	of	IN
18637	19336	30	judges	judge	NNS
18637	19336	31	based	base	VBN
18637	19336	32	on	on	IN
18637	19336	33	the	the	DT
18637	19336	34	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	19336	35	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19336	36	,	,	,
18637	19336	37	prophecies	prophecy	NNS
18637	19336	38	,	,	,
18637	19336	39	and	and	CC
18637	19336	40	impressions	impression	NNS
18637	19336	41	of	of	IN
18637	19336	42	expert	expert	JJ
18637	19336	43	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	19336	44	when	when	WRB
18637	19336	45	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	19336	46	reviewing	review	VBG
18637	19336	47	a	a	DT
18637	19336	48	formula	formula	NN
18637	19336	49	of	of	IN
18637	19336	50	a	a	DT
18637	19336	51	State	State	NNP
18637	19336	52	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	19336	53	commission	commission	NN
18637	19336	54	for	for	IN
18637	19336	55	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	19336	56	daily	daily	JJ
18637	19336	57	production	production	NN
18637	19336	58	in	in	IN
18637	19336	59	an	an	DT
18637	19336	60	oil	oil	NN
18637	19336	61	field	field	NN
18637	19336	62	and	and	CC
18637	19336	63	for	for	IN
18637	19336	64	proration	proration	NN
18637	19336	65	among	among	IN
18637	19336	66	the	the	DT
18637	19336	67	several	several	JJ
18637	19336	68	well	well	UH
18637	19336	69	owners	owner	NNS
18637	19336	70	.	.	.
18637	19337	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19337	2	682	682	CD
18637	19337	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19337	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19337	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	19337	6	the	the	DT
18637	19337	7	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19337	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19337	9	prohibit	prohibit	NN
18637	19337	10	a	a	DT
18637	19337	11	State	state	NN
18637	19337	12	from	from	IN
18637	19337	13	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	19337	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	19337	15	nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	19337	16	bodies	body	NNS
18637	19337	17	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19337	18	functions	function	NNS
18637	19337	19	that	that	WDT
18637	19337	20	may	may	MD
18637	19337	21	be	be	VB
18637	19337	22	called	call	VBN
18637	19337	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19337	24	,	,	,
18637	19337	25	or	or	CC
18637	19337	26	from	from	IN
18637	19337	27	delegating	delegate	VBG
18637	19337	28	to	to	IN
18637	19337	29	a	a	DT
18637	19337	30	court	court	NN
18637	19337	31	powers	power	NNS
18637	19337	32	that	that	WDT
18637	19337	33	are	be	VBP
18637	19337	34	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19337	35	in	in	IN
18637	19337	36	nature	nature	NN
18637	19337	37	.	.	.
18637	19338	1	For	for	IN
18637	19338	2	example	example	NN
18637	19338	3	,	,	,
18637	19338	4	State	state	NN
18637	19338	5	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	19338	6	vesting	vest	VBG
18637	19338	7	in	in	IN
18637	19338	8	a	a	DT
18637	19338	9	parole	parole	NN
18637	19338	10	board	board	NN
18637	19338	11	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19338	12	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19338	13	functions,[683	functions,[683	NNP
18637	19338	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19338	15	or	or	CC
18637	19338	16	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	19338	17	discretionary	discretionary	JJ
18637	19338	18	power	power	NN
18637	19338	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	19338	20	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	19338	21	boards	board	NNS
18637	19338	22	to	to	TO
18637	19338	23	grant	grant	VB
18637	19338	24	or	or	CC
18637	19338	25	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	19338	26	permission	permission	NN
18637	19338	27	to	to	TO
18637	19338	28	carry	carry	VB
18637	19338	29	on	on	RP
18637	19338	30	a	a	DT
18637	19338	31	trade,[684	trade,[684	NN
18637	19338	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19338	33	or	or	CC
18637	19338	34	vesting	vest	VBG
18637	19338	35	in	in	IN
18637	19338	36	a	a	DT
18637	19338	37	probate	probate	JJ
18637	19338	38	court	court	NN
18637	19338	39	authority	authority	NN
18637	19338	40	to	to	TO
18637	19338	41	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	19338	42	park	park	NN
18637	19338	43	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	19338	44	and	and	CC
18637	19338	45	establish	establish	VB
18637	19338	46	park	park	NN
18637	19338	47	districts[685	districts[685	''
18637	19338	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19338	49	are	be	VBP
18637	19338	50	not	not	RB
18637	19338	51	in	in	IN
18637	19338	52	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	19338	53	with	with	IN
18637	19338	54	the	the	DT
18637	19338	55	due	due	JJ
18637	19338	56	process	process	NN
18637	19338	57	clause	clause	NN
18637	19338	58	and	and	CC
18637	19338	59	present	present	JJ
18637	19338	60	no	no	DT
18637	19338	61	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19338	62	question	question	NN
18637	19338	63	.	.	.
18637	19339	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	19339	2	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19339	3	,	,	,
18637	19339	4	executive	executive	JJ
18637	19339	5	,	,	,
18637	19339	6	and	and	CC
18637	19339	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19339	8	powers	power	NNS
18637	19339	9	of	of	IN
18637	19339	10	a	a	DT
18637	19339	11	State	state	NN
18637	19339	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	19339	13	be	be	VB
18637	19339	14	kept	keep	VBN
18637	19339	15	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	19339	16	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	19339	17	and	and	CC
18637	19339	18	separate	separate	JJ
18637	19339	19	,	,	,
18637	19339	20	or	or	CC
18637	19339	21	whether	whether	IN
18637	19339	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19339	23	should	should	MD
18637	19339	24	in	in	IN
18637	19339	25	some	some	DT
18637	19339	26	particulars	particular	NNS
18637	19339	27	be	be	VB
18637	19339	28	merged	merge	VBN
18637	19339	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	19339	30	for	for	IN
18637	19339	31	the	the	DT
18637	19339	32	determination	determination	NN
18637	19339	33	of	of	IN
18637	19339	34	the	the	DT
18637	19339	35	State	State	NNP
18637	19339	36	.	.	.
18637	19340	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19340	2	686	686	CD
18637	19340	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19340	4	Jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19340	5	In	in	IN
18637	19340	6	General.--Jurisdiction	general.--jurisdiction	NN
18637	19340	7	may	may	MD
18637	19340	8	be	be	VB
18637	19340	9	defined	define	VBN
18637	19340	10	as	as	IN
18637	19340	11	the	the	DT
18637	19340	12	power	power	NN
18637	19340	13	to	to	TO
18637	19340	14	create	create	VB
18637	19340	15	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19340	16	interests	interest	NNS
18637	19340	17	;	;	:
18637	19340	18	but	but	CC
18637	19340	19	if	if	IN
18637	19340	20	a	a	DT
18637	19340	21	State	state	NN
18637	19340	22	attempts	attempt	VBZ
18637	19340	23	to	to	TO
18637	19340	24	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	19340	25	such	such	JJ
18637	19340	26	power	power	NN
18637	19340	27	with	with	IN
18637	19340	28	respect	respect	NN
18637	19340	29	to	to	IN
18637	19340	30	persons	person	NNS
18637	19340	31	or	or	CC
18637	19340	32	things	thing	NNS
18637	19340	33	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19340	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19340	35	borders	border	NNS
18637	19340	36	,	,	,
18637	19340	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19340	38	action	action	NN
18637	19340	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	19340	40	in	in	IN
18637	19340	41	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	19340	42	with	with	IN
18637	19340	43	the	the	DT
18637	19340	44	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19340	45	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19340	46	and	and	CC
18637	19340	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	19340	48	void	void	JJ
18637	19340	49	within	within	IN
18637	19340	50	as	as	RB
18637	19340	51	well	well	RB
18637	19340	52	as	as	IN
18637	19340	53	without	without	IN
18637	19340	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19340	55	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	19340	56	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19340	57	.	.	.
18637	19341	1	The	the	DT
18637	19341	2	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	19341	3	of	of	IN
18637	19341	4	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19341	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19341	6	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	19341	7	physical	physical	JJ
18637	19341	8	power	power	NN
18637	19341	9	capable	capable	JJ
18637	19341	10	of	of	IN
18637	19341	11	being	be	VBG
18637	19341	12	exerted	exert	VBN
18637	19341	13	over	over	IN
18637	19341	14	persons	person	NNS
18637	19341	15	through	through	IN
18637	19341	16	_	_	NNP
18637	19341	17	in	in	IN
18637	19341	18	personam	personam	NNP
18637	19341	19	_	_	NNP
18637	19341	20	actions	action	NNS
18637	19341	21	and	and	CC
18637	19341	22	over	over	IN
18637	19341	23	things	thing	NNS
18637	19341	24	,	,	,
18637	19341	25	generally	generally	RB
18637	19341	26	through	through	IN
18637	19341	27	actions	action	NNS
18637	19341	28	_	_	NNP
18637	19341	29	in	in	IN
18637	19341	30	rem	rem	NNP
18637	19341	31	_	_	NNP
18637	19341	32	.	.	.
18637	19342	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19342	2	687	687	CD
18637	19342	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19342	4	In	in	IN
18637	19342	5	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19342	6	_	_	NNP
18637	19342	7	in	in	IN
18637	19342	8	personam	personam	NNP
18637	19342	9	_	_	NNP
18637	19342	10	to	to	TO
18637	19342	11	determine	determine	VB
18637	19342	12	liability	liability	NN
18637	19342	13	of	of	IN
18637	19342	14	a	a	DT
18637	19342	15	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19342	16	,	,	,
18637	19342	17	no	no	DT
18637	19342	18	property	property	NN
18637	19342	19	having	have	VBG
18637	19342	20	been	be	VBN
18637	19342	21	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	19342	22	by	by	IN
18637	19342	23	such	such	JJ
18637	19342	24	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	19342	25	to	to	IN
18637	19342	26	the	the	DT
18637	19342	27	control	control	NN
18637	19342	28	of	of	IN
18637	19342	29	the	the	DT
18637	19342	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19342	31	,	,	,
18637	19342	32	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19342	33	over	over	IN
18637	19342	34	the	the	DT
18637	19342	35	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19342	36	's	's	POS
18637	19342	37	person	person	NN
18637	19342	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	19342	39	a	a	DT
18637	19342	40	condition	condition	NN
18637	19342	41	prerequisite	prerequisite	JJ
18637	19342	42	to	to	IN
18637	19342	43	the	the	DT
18637	19342	44	rendering	rendering	NN
18637	19342	45	of	of	IN
18637	19342	46	any	any	DT
18637	19342	47	effective	effective	JJ
18637	19342	48	decree	decree	NN
18637	19342	49	.	.	.
18637	19343	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19343	2	688	688	CD
18637	19343	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19343	4	That	that	DT
18637	19343	5	condition	condition	NN
18637	19343	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19343	7	fulfilled	fulfil	VBN
18637	19343	8	;	;	:
18637	19343	9	that	that	RB
18637	19343	10	is	is	RB
18637	19343	11	,	,	,
18637	19343	12	a	a	DT
18637	19343	13	State	state	NN
18637	19343	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19343	15	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19343	16	capable	capable	JJ
18637	19343	17	of	of	IN
18637	19343	18	exerting	exert	VBG
18637	19343	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19343	20	over	over	IN
18637	19343	21	an	an	DT
18637	19343	22	individual	individual	NN
18637	19343	23	if	if	IN
18637	19343	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19343	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	19343	26	physically	physically	RB
18637	19343	27	present	present	JJ
18637	19343	28	within	within	IN
18637	19343	29	the	the	DT
18637	19343	30	territory	territory	NN
18637	19343	31	of	of	IN
18637	19343	32	the	the	DT
18637	19343	33	State	State	NNP
18637	19343	34	,	,	,
18637	19343	35	if	if	IN
18637	19343	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19343	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	19343	38	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	19343	39	in	in	IN
18637	19343	40	the	the	DT
18637	19343	41	State	State	NNP
18637	19343	42	although	although	IN
18637	19343	43	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	19343	44	absent	absent	JJ
18637	19343	45	therefrom	therefrom	NN
18637	19343	46	,	,	,
18637	19343	47	or	or	CC
18637	19343	48	if	if	IN
18637	19343	49	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19343	50	has	have	VBZ
18637	19343	51	consented	consent	VBN
18637	19343	52	to	to	IN
18637	19343	53	the	the	DT
18637	19343	54	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19343	55	of	of	IN
18637	19343	56	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19343	57	over	over	IN
18637	19343	58	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19343	59	.	.	.
18637	19344	1	In	in	IN
18637	19344	2	actions	action	NNS
18637	19344	3	_	_	NNP
18637	19344	4	in	in	IN
18637	19344	5	rem	rem	NNP
18637	19344	6	_	_	NNP
18637	19344	7	,	,	,
18637	19344	8	however	however	RB
18637	19344	9	,	,	,
18637	19344	10	a	a	DT
18637	19344	11	State	state	NN
18637	19344	12	validly	validly	RB
18637	19344	13	may	may	MD
18637	19344	14	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	19344	15	to	to	TO
18637	19344	16	settle	settle	VB
18637	19344	17	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	19344	18	with	with	IN
18637	19344	19	regard	regard	NN
18637	19344	20	to	to	IN
18637	19344	21	rights	right	NNS
18637	19344	22	or	or	CC
18637	19344	23	claims	claim	NNS
18637	19344	24	against	against	IN
18637	19344	25	property	property	NN
18637	19344	26	within	within	IN
18637	19344	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19344	28	borders	border	NNS
18637	19344	29	,	,	,
18637	19344	30	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19344	31	that	that	DT
18637	19344	32	control	control	NN
18637	19344	33	of	of	IN
18637	19344	34	the	the	DT
18637	19344	35	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19344	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	19344	37	never	never	RB
18637	19344	38	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19344	39	.	.	.
18637	19345	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19345	2	,	,	,
18637	19345	3	by	by	IN
18637	19345	4	reason	reason	NN
18637	19345	5	of	of	IN
18637	19345	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19345	7	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	19345	8	authority	authority	NN
18637	19345	9	over	over	IN
18637	19345	10	titles	title	NNS
18637	19345	11	to	to	TO
18637	19345	12	land	land	VB
18637	19345	13	within	within	IN
18637	19345	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19345	15	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	19345	16	confines	confine	NNS
18637	19345	17	,	,	,
18637	19345	18	a	a	DT
18637	19345	19	State	state	NN
18637	19345	20	may	may	MD
18637	19345	21	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	19345	22	through	through	IN
18637	19345	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19345	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	19345	25	to	to	IN
18637	19345	26	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19345	27	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	19345	28	the	the	DT
18637	19345	29	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	19345	30	of	of	IN
18637	19345	31	such	such	JJ
18637	19345	32	property	property	NN
18637	19345	33	,	,	,
18637	19345	34	even	even	RB
18637	19345	35	though	though	IN
18637	19345	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19345	37	lacks	lack	VBZ
18637	19345	38	the	the	DT
18637	19345	39	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19345	40	competence	competence	NN
18637	19345	41	to	to	TO
18637	19345	42	reach	reach	VB
18637	19345	43	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	19345	44	of	of	IN
18637	19345	45	title	title	NN
18637	19345	46	who	who	WP
18637	19345	47	reside	reside	VBP
18637	19345	48	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19345	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19345	50	borders	border	NNS
18637	19345	51	.	.	.
18637	19346	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19346	2	689	689	CD
18637	19346	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19346	4	By	by	IN
18637	19346	5	the	the	DT
18637	19346	6	same	same	JJ
18637	19346	7	token	token	NN
18637	19346	8	,	,	,
18637	19346	9	probate[690	probate[690	''
18637	19346	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19346	11	and	and	CC
18637	19346	12	garnishment	garnishment	JJ
18637	19346	13	or	or	CC
18637	19346	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19346	15	attachment[691	attachment[691	NN
18637	19346	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19346	17	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19346	18	,	,	,
18637	19346	19	being	be	VBG
18637	19346	20	in	in	IN
18637	19346	21	the	the	DT
18637	19346	22	nature	nature	NN
18637	19346	23	of	of	IN
18637	19346	24	_	_	NNP
18637	19346	25	in	in	IN
18637	19346	26	rem	rem	NNP
18637	19346	27	_	_	NNP
18637	19346	28	actions	action	NNS
18637	19346	29	for	for	IN
18637	19346	30	the	the	DT
18637	19346	31	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	19346	32	of	of	IN
18637	19346	33	property	property	NN
18637	19346	34	,	,	,
18637	19346	35	may	may	MD
18637	19346	36	be	be	VB
18637	19346	37	prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
18637	19346	38	to	to	IN
18637	19346	39	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	19346	40	without	without	IN
18637	19346	41	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19346	42	of	of	IN
18637	19346	43	the	the	DT
18637	19346	44	presence	presence	NN
18637	19346	45	of	of	IN
18637	19346	46	all	all	DT
18637	19346	47	parties	party	NNS
18637	19346	48	in	in	IN
18637	19346	49	interest	interest	NN
18637	19346	50	.	.	.
18637	19347	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19347	2	692	692	CD
18637	19347	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19347	4	How	how	WRB
18637	19347	5	Perfected	perfect	VBN
18637	19347	6	:	:	:
18637	19347	7	By	by	IN
18637	19347	8	Voluntary	Voluntary	NNP
18637	19347	9	Appearance	Appearance	NNP
18637	19347	10	or	or	CC
18637	19347	11	Service	Service	NNP
18637	19347	12	of	of	IN
18637	19347	13	Process.--It	Process.--It	NNP
18637	19347	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19347	15	not	not	RB
18637	19347	16	enough	enough	JJ
18637	19347	17	,	,	,
18637	19347	18	however	however	RB
18637	19347	19	,	,	,
18637	19347	20	that	that	IN
18637	19347	21	a	a	DT
18637	19347	22	State	state	NN
18637	19347	23	be	be	VB
18637	19347	24	potentially	potentially	RB
18637	19347	25	capable	capable	JJ
18637	19347	26	of	of	IN
18637	19347	27	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	19347	28	control	control	NN
18637	19347	29	over	over	IN
18637	19347	30	persons	person	NNS
18637	19347	31	and	and	CC
18637	19347	32	property	property	NN
18637	19347	33	.	.	.
18637	19348	1	Before	before	IN
18637	19348	2	a	a	DT
18637	19348	3	State	state	NN
18637	19348	4	legitimately	legitimately	RB
18637	19348	5	can	can	MD
18637	19348	6	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	19348	7	such	such	JJ
18637	19348	8	power	power	NN
18637	19348	9	to	to	TO
18637	19348	10	alter	alter	VB
18637	19348	11	private	private	JJ
18637	19348	12	interests	interest	NNS
18637	19348	13	,	,	,
18637	19348	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19348	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19348	16	must	must	MD
18637	19348	17	be	be	VB
18637	19348	18	perfected	perfect	VBN
18637	19348	19	by	by	IN
18637	19348	20	the	the	DT
18637	19348	21	employment	employment	NN
18637	19348	22	of	of	IN
18637	19348	23	an	an	DT
18637	19348	24	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	19348	25	mode	mode	NN
18637	19348	26	of	of	IN
18637	19348	27	serving	serve	VBG
18637	19348	28	process	process	NN
18637	19348	29	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19348	30	effective	effective	JJ
18637	19348	31	to	to	TO
18637	19348	32	acquaint	acquaint	VB
18637	19348	33	all	all	DT
18637	19348	34	parties	party	NNS
18637	19348	35	of	of	IN
18637	19348	36	the	the	DT
18637	19348	37	institution	institution	NN
18637	19348	38	of	of	IN
18637	19348	39	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19348	40	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	19348	41	to	to	TO
18637	19348	42	affect	affect	VB
18637	19348	43	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19348	44	rights	right	NNS
18637	19348	45	;	;	:
18637	19348	46	for	for	IN
18637	19348	47	the	the	DT
18637	19348	48	interest	interest	NN
18637	19348	49	of	of	IN
18637	19348	50	no	no	DT
18637	19348	51	one	one	NN
18637	19348	52	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	19348	53	may	may	MD
18637	19348	54	be	be	VB
18637	19348	55	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	19348	56	by	by	IN
18637	19348	57	a	a	DT
18637	19348	58	decree	decree	NN
18637	19348	59	resulting	result	VBG
18637	19348	60	from	from	IN
18637	19348	61	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	19348	62	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	19348	63	which	which	WDT
18637	19348	64	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19348	65	was	be	VBD
18637	19348	66	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	19348	67	neither	neither	CC
18637	19348	68	notice	notice	NN
18637	19348	69	nor	nor	CC
18637	19348	70	an	an	DT
18637	19348	71	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19348	72	to	to	TO
18637	19348	73	participate	participate	VB
18637	19348	74	.	.	.
18637	19349	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19349	2	693	693	CD
18637	19349	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19349	4	Voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	19349	5	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	19349	6	,	,	,
18637	19349	7	on	on	IN
18637	19349	8	the	the	DT
18637	19349	9	other	other	JJ
18637	19349	10	hand	hand	NN
18637	19349	11	,	,	,
18637	19349	12	may	may	MD
18637	19349	13	enable	enable	VB
18637	19349	14	a	a	DT
18637	19349	15	State	state	NN
18637	19349	16	not	not	RB
18637	19349	17	only	only	RB
18637	19349	18	to	to	TO
18637	19349	19	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	19349	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19349	21	over	over	IN
18637	19349	22	a	a	DT
18637	19349	23	person	person	NN
18637	19349	24	who	who	WP
18637	19349	25	was	be	VBD
18637	19349	26	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	19349	27	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19349	28	the	the	DT
18637	19349	29	reach	reach	NN
18637	19349	30	of	of	IN
18637	19349	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19349	32	process	process	NN
18637	19349	33	;	;	:
18637	19349	34	but	but	CC
18637	19349	35	also	also	RB
18637	19349	36	,	,	,
18637	19349	37	as	as	IN
18637	19349	38	in	in	IN
18637	19349	39	the	the	DT
18637	19349	40	case	case	NN
18637	19349	41	of	of	IN
18637	19349	42	a	a	DT
18637	19349	43	person	person	NN
18637	19349	44	who	who	WP
18637	19349	45	was	be	VBD
18637	19349	46	within	within	IN
18637	19349	47	the	the	DT
18637	19349	48	scope	scope	NN
18637	19349	49	of	of	IN
18637	19349	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19349	51	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19349	52	,	,	,
18637	19349	53	to	to	TO
18637	19349	54	dispense	dispense	VB
18637	19349	55	with	with	IN
18637	19349	56	the	the	DT
18637	19349	57	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19349	58	of	of	IN
18637	19349	59	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19349	60	service	service	NN
18637	19349	61	.	.	.
18637	19350	1	When	when	WRB
18637	19350	2	a	a	DT
18637	19350	3	party	party	NN
18637	19350	4	voluntarily	voluntarily	RB
18637	19350	5	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	19350	6	in	in	IN
18637	19350	7	a	a	DT
18637	19350	8	cause	cause	NN
18637	19350	9	and	and	CC
18637	19350	10	actively	actively	RB
18637	19350	11	conducts	conduct	VBZ
18637	19350	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19350	13	defense	defense	NN
18637	19350	14	,	,	,
18637	19350	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19350	16	can	can	MD
18637	19350	17	not	not	RB
18637	19350	18	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	19350	19	claim	claim	VB
18637	19350	20	that	that	IN
18637	19350	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19350	22	was	be	VBD
18637	19350	23	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19350	24	due	due	JJ
18637	19350	25	process	process	NN
18637	19350	26	merely	merely	RB
18637	19350	27	because	because	IN
18637	19350	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19350	29	was	be	VBD
18637	19350	30	not	not	RB
18637	19350	31	served	serve	VBN
18637	19350	32	with	with	IN
18637	19350	33	process	process	NN
18637	19350	34	when	when	WRB
18637	19350	35	the	the	DT
18637	19350	36	original	original	JJ
18637	19350	37	action	action	NN
18637	19350	38	was	be	VBD
18637	19350	39	commenced	commence	VBN
18637	19350	40	.	.	.
18637	19351	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19351	2	694	694	CD
18637	19351	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19351	4	Service	Service	NNP
18637	19351	5	of	of	IN
18637	19351	6	Process	Process	NNP
18637	19351	7	in	in	IN
18637	19351	8	Actions	Actions	NNPS
18637	19351	9	in	in	IN
18637	19351	10	Personam	Personam	NNP
18637	19351	11	:	:	:
18637	19351	12	Individuals	individual	NNS
18637	19351	13	,	,	,
18637	19351	14	Resident	Resident	NNP
18637	19351	15	and	and	CC
18637	19351	16	Nonresident.--The	Nonresident.--The	NNP
18637	19351	17	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	19351	18	being	be	VBG
18637	19351	19	well	well	RB
18637	19351	20	established	establish	VBN
18637	19351	21	that	that	IN
18637	19351	22	no	no	DT
18637	19351	23	person	person	NN
18637	19351	24	can	can	MD
18637	19351	25	be	be	VB
18637	19351	26	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	19351	27	of	of	IN
18637	19351	28	property	property	NN
18637	19351	29	rights	right	NNS
18637	19351	30	by	by	IN
18637	19351	31	a	a	DT
18637	19351	32	decree	decree	NN
18637	19351	33	in	in	IN
18637	19351	34	a	a	DT
18637	19351	35	case	case	NN
18637	19351	36	in	in	IN
18637	19351	37	which	which	WDT
18637	19351	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19351	39	neither	neither	CC
18637	19351	40	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	19351	41	,	,	,
18637	19351	42	nor	nor	CC
18637	19351	43	was	be	VBD
18637	19351	44	served	serve	VBN
18637	19351	45	or	or	CC
18637	19351	46	effectively	effectively	RB
18637	19351	47	made	make	VBD
18637	19351	48	a	a	DT
18637	19351	49	party	party	NN
18637	19351	50	,	,	,
18637	19351	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19351	52	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	19351	53	,	,	,
18637	19351	54	by	by	IN
18637	19351	55	way	way	NN
18637	19351	56	of	of	IN
18637	19351	57	illustration	illustration	NN
18637	19351	58	that	that	IN
18637	19351	59	to	to	TO
18637	19351	60	subject	subject	VB
18637	19351	61	property	property	NN
18637	19351	62	of	of	IN
18637	19351	63	individual	individual	JJ
18637	19351	64	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	19351	65	of	of	IN
18637	19351	66	a	a	DT
18637	19351	67	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	19351	68	,	,	,
18637	19351	69	by	by	IN
18637	19351	70	a	a	DT
18637	19351	71	summary	summary	NN
18637	19351	72	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19351	73	in	in	IN
18637	19351	74	equity	equity	NN
18637	19351	75	,	,	,
18637	19351	76	to	to	IN
18637	19351	77	the	the	DT
18637	19351	78	payment	payment	NN
18637	19351	79	of	of	IN
18637	19351	80	an	an	DT
18637	19351	81	unsatisfied	unsatisfied	JJ
18637	19351	82	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19351	83	against	against	IN
18637	19351	84	the	the	DT
18637	19351	85	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	19351	86	would	would	MD
18637	19351	87	be	be	VB
18637	19351	88	a	a	DT
18637	19351	89	denial	denial	NN
18637	19351	90	of	of	IN
18637	19351	91	due	due	JJ
18637	19351	92	process	process	NN
18637	19351	93	of	of	IN
18637	19351	94	law	law	NN
18637	19351	95	.	.	.
18637	19352	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19352	2	695	695	CD
18637	19352	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19352	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19352	5	,	,	,
18637	19352	6	in	in	IN
18637	19352	7	a	a	DT
18637	19352	8	suit	suit	NN
18637	19352	9	against	against	IN
18637	19352	10	a	a	DT
18637	19352	11	local	local	JJ
18637	19352	12	partnership	partnership	NN
18637	19352	13	,	,	,
18637	19352	14	in	in	IN
18637	19352	15	which	which	WDT
18637	19352	16	the	the	DT
18637	19352	17	resident	resident	NN
18637	19352	18	partner	partner	NN
18637	19352	19	was	be	VBD
18637	19352	20	duly	duly	RB
18637	19352	21	served	serve	VBN
18637	19352	22	with	with	IN
18637	19352	23	process	process	NN
18637	19352	24	and	and	CC
18637	19352	25	the	the	DT
18637	19352	26	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19352	27	partner	partner	NN
18637	19352	28	was	be	VBD
18637	19352	29	served	serve	VBN
18637	19352	30	only	only	RB
18637	19352	31	with	with	IN
18637	19352	32	notice	notice	NN
18637	19352	33	,	,	,
18637	19352	34	a	a	DT
18637	19352	35	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19352	36	thus	thus	RB
18637	19352	37	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19352	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	19352	39	binding	bind	VBG
18637	19352	40	upon	upon	IN
18637	19352	41	the	the	DT
18637	19352	42	firm	firm	NN
18637	19352	43	and	and	CC
18637	19352	44	the	the	DT
18637	19352	45	resident	resident	NN
18637	19352	46	partner	partner	NN
18637	19352	47	,	,	,
18637	19352	48	but	but	CC
18637	19352	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	19352	50	not	not	RB
18637	19352	51	a	a	DT
18637	19352	52	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19352	53	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19352	54	against	against	IN
18637	19352	55	the	the	DT
18637	19352	56	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19352	57	and	and	CC
18637	19352	58	can	can	MD
18637	19352	59	not	not	RB
18637	19352	60	be	be	VB
18637	19352	61	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	19352	62	by	by	IN
18637	19352	63	execution	execution	NN
18637	19352	64	against	against	IN
18637	19352	65	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19352	66	individual	individual	JJ
18637	19352	67	property	property	NN
18637	19352	68	.	.	.
18637	19353	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19353	2	696	696	CD
18637	19353	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19353	4	That	that	IN
18637	19353	5	the	the	DT
18637	19353	6	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19353	7	partner	partner	NN
18637	19353	8	should	should	MD
18637	19353	9	have	have	VB
18637	19353	10	been	be	VBN
18637	19353	11	so	so	RB
18637	19353	12	protected	protect	VBN
18637	19353	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	19353	14	attributable	attributable	JJ
18637	19353	15	to	to	IN
18637	19353	16	the	the	DT
18637	19353	17	fact	fact	NN
18637	19353	18	the	the	DT
18637	19353	19	process	process	NN
18637	19353	20	of	of	IN
18637	19353	21	a	a	DT
18637	19353	22	court	court	NN
18637	19353	23	of	of	IN
18637	19353	24	one	one	CD
18637	19353	25	State	State	NNP
18637	19353	26	can	can	MD
18637	19353	27	not	not	RB
18637	19353	28	run	run	VB
18637	19353	29	into	into	IN
18637	19353	30	another	another	DT
18637	19353	31	and	and	CC
18637	19353	32	summon	summon	NNP
18637	19353	33	a	a	DT
18637	19353	34	party	party	NN
18637	19353	35	there	there	RB
18637	19353	36	domiciled	domicile	VBD
18637	19353	37	to	to	TO
18637	19353	38	respond	respond	VB
18637	19353	39	to	to	IN
18637	19353	40	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19353	41	against	against	IN
18637	19353	42	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19353	43	,	,	,
18637	19353	44	when	when	WRB
18637	19353	45	neither	neither	CC
18637	19353	46	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19353	47	person	person	NN
18637	19353	48	nor	nor	CC
18637	19353	49	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19353	50	property	property	NN
18637	19353	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	19353	52	within	within	IN
18637	19353	53	the	the	DT
18637	19353	54	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19353	55	of	of	IN
18637	19353	56	the	the	DT
18637	19353	57	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19353	58	rendering	render	VBG
18637	19353	59	the	the	DT
18637	19353	60	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19353	61	.	.	.
18637	19354	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19354	2	697	697	CD
18637	19354	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19354	4	In	in	IN
18637	19354	5	the	the	DT
18637	19354	6	case	case	NN
18637	19354	7	of	of	IN
18637	19354	8	a	a	DT
18637	19354	9	resident	resident	NN
18637	19354	10	,	,	,
18637	19354	11	however	however	RB
18637	19354	12	,	,	,
18637	19354	13	absence	absence	NN
18637	19354	14	alone	alone	RB
18637	19354	15	will	will	MD
18637	19354	16	not	not	RB
18637	19354	17	defeat	defeat	VB
18637	19354	18	the	the	DT
18637	19354	19	processes	process	NNS
18637	19354	20	of	of	IN
18637	19354	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	19354	22	in	in	IN
18637	19354	23	the	the	DT
18637	19354	24	State	State	NNP
18637	19354	25	of	of	IN
18637	19354	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19354	27	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19354	28	;	;	:
18637	19354	29	for	for	IN
18637	19354	30	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19354	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	19354	32	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19354	33	to	to	TO
18637	19354	34	be	be	VB
18637	19354	35	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19354	36	to	to	TO
18637	19354	37	keep	keep	VB
18637	19354	38	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19354	39	within	within	IN
18637	19354	40	reach	reach	NN
18637	19354	41	of	of	IN
18637	19354	42	the	the	DT
18637	19354	43	State	State	NNP
18637	19354	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	19354	45	for	for	IN
18637	19354	46	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19354	47	of	of	IN
18637	19354	48	a	a	DT
18637	19354	49	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19354	50	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19354	51	,	,	,
18637	19354	52	whether	whether	IN
18637	19354	53	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19354	54	by	by	IN
18637	19354	55	means	mean	NNS
18637	19354	56	of	of	IN
18637	19354	57	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	19354	58	,	,	,
18637	19354	59	substituted	substituted	JJ
18637	19354	60	service	service	NN
18637	19354	61	,	,	,
18637	19354	62	or	or	CC
18637	19354	63	by	by	IN
18637	19354	64	actual	actual	JJ
18637	19354	65	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19354	66	service	service	NN
18637	19354	67	on	on	IN
18637	19354	68	the	the	DT
18637	19354	69	resident	resident	NN
18637	19354	70	at	at	IN
18637	19354	71	a	a	DT
18637	19354	72	point	point	NN
18637	19354	73	outside	outside	IN
18637	19354	74	the	the	DT
18637	19354	75	State	state	NN
18637	19354	76	.	.	.
18637	19355	1	Amenability	amenability	NN
18637	19355	2	to	to	IN
18637	19355	3	such	such	JJ
18637	19355	4	suit	suit	NN
18637	19355	5	even	even	RB
18637	19355	6	during	during	IN
18637	19355	7	sojourns	sojourn	NNS
18637	19355	8	outside	outside	RB
18637	19355	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19355	10	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19355	11	as	as	IN
18637	19355	12	an	an	DT
18637	19355	13	"	"	``
18637	19355	14	incident	incident	NN
18637	19355	15	of	of	IN
18637	19355	16	domicile	domicile	NN
18637	19355	17	.	.	.
18637	19356	1	"	"	``
18637	19356	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19356	3	698	698	CD
18637	19356	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19356	5	However	however	RB
18637	19356	6	,	,	,
18637	19356	7	if	if	IN
18637	19356	8	the	the	DT
18637	19356	9	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19356	10	,	,	,
18637	19356	11	although	although	IN
18637	19356	12	technically	technically	RB
18637	19356	13	domiciled	domicile	VBD
18637	19356	14	therein	therein	RB
18637	19356	15	,	,	,
18637	19356	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	19356	17	left	leave	VBN
18637	19356	18	the	the	DT
18637	19356	19	State	State	NNP
18637	19356	20	with	with	IN
18637	19356	21	no	no	DT
18637	19356	22	intention	intention	NN
18637	19356	23	to	to	TO
18637	19356	24	return	return	VB
18637	19356	25	,	,	,
18637	19356	26	service	service	NN
18637	19356	27	by	by	IN
18637	19356	28	publication	publication	NN
18637	19356	29	;	;	:
18637	19356	30	that	that	RB
18637	19356	31	is	is	RB
18637	19356	32	,	,	,
18637	19356	33	by	by	IN
18637	19356	34	advertisement	advertisement	NN
18637	19356	35	in	in	IN
18637	19356	36	a	a	DT
18637	19356	37	local	local	JJ
18637	19356	38	newspaper	newspaper	NN
18637	19356	39	,	,	,
18637	19356	40	as	as	IN
18637	19356	41	compared	compare	VBN
18637	19356	42	to	to	IN
18637	19356	43	a	a	DT
18637	19356	44	summons	summon	NNS
18637	19356	45	left	leave	VBN
18637	19356	46	at	at	IN
18637	19356	47	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19356	48	last	last	JJ
18637	19356	49	and	and	CC
18637	19356	50	usual	usual	JJ
18637	19356	51	place	place	NN
18637	19356	52	of	of	IN
18637	19356	53	abode	abode	NNP
18637	19356	54	where	where	WRB
18637	19356	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19356	56	family	family	NN
18637	19356	57	continued	continue	VBD
18637	19356	58	to	to	TO
18637	19356	59	reside	reside	VB
18637	19356	60	,	,	,
18637	19356	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	19356	62	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
18637	19356	63	inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	19356	64	as	as	IN
18637	19356	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19356	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	19356	67	not	not	RB
18637	19356	68	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	19356	69	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	19356	70	to	to	TO
18637	19356	71	give	give	VB
18637	19356	72	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19356	73	actual	actual	JJ
18637	19356	74	notice	notice	NN
18637	19356	75	of	of	IN
18637	19356	76	the	the	DT
18637	19356	77	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19356	78	and	and	CC
18637	19356	79	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19356	80	to	to	TO
18637	19356	81	be	be	VB
18637	19356	82	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19356	83	.	.	.
18637	19357	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19357	2	699	699	CD
18637	19357	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19357	4	In	in	IN
18637	19357	5	the	the	DT
18637	19357	6	case	case	NN
18637	19357	7	of	of	IN
18637	19357	8	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19357	9	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	19357	10	who	who	WP
18637	19357	11	are	be	VBP
18637	19357	12	domiciled	domicile	VBN
18637	19357	13	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	19357	14	,	,	,
18637	19357	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19357	16	in	in	IN
18637	19357	17	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19357	18	instances	instance	NNS
18637	19357	19	may	may	MD
18637	19357	20	be	be	VB
18637	19357	21	perfected	perfect	VBN
18637	19357	22	by	by	IN
18637	19357	23	requiring	require	VBG
18637	19357	24	such	such	JJ
18637	19357	25	persons	person	NNS
18637	19357	26	,	,	,
18637	19357	27	as	as	IN
18637	19357	28	a	a	DT
18637	19357	29	condition	condition	NN
18637	19357	30	to	to	IN
18637	19357	31	entering	enter	VBG
18637	19357	32	the	the	DT
18637	19357	33	State	State	NNP
18637	19357	34	,	,	,
18637	19357	35	to	to	TO
18637	19357	36	designate	designate	VB
18637	19357	37	local	local	JJ
18637	19357	38	agents	agent	NNS
18637	19357	39	to	to	TO
18637	19357	40	accept	accept	VB
18637	19357	41	service	service	NN
18637	19357	42	of	of	IN
18637	19357	43	process	process	NN
18637	19357	44	.	.	.
18637	19358	1	Although	although	IN
18637	19358	2	a	a	DT
18637	19358	3	State	state	NN
18637	19358	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	19358	5	not	not	RB
18637	19358	6	have	have	VB
18637	19358	7	the	the	DT
18637	19358	8	power	power	NN
18637	19358	9	to	to	TO
18637	19358	10	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	19358	11	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	19358	12	until	until	IN
18637	19358	13	such	such	JJ
18637	19358	14	formal	formal	JJ
18637	19358	15	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	19358	16	of	of	IN
18637	19358	17	an	an	DT
18637	19358	18	agent	agent	NN
18637	19358	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	19358	20	been	be	VBN
18637	19358	21	made,[700	made,[700	NN
18637	19358	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19358	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19358	24	may	may	MD
18637	19358	25	,	,	,
18637	19358	26	for	for	IN
18637	19358	27	example	example	NN
18637	19358	28	,	,	,
18637	19358	29	declare	declare	VBP
18637	19358	30	that	that	IN
18637	19358	31	the	the	DT
18637	19358	32	use	use	NN
18637	19358	33	of	of	IN
18637	19358	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19358	35	highways	highway	NNS
18637	19358	36	by	by	IN
18637	19358	37	a	a	DT
18637	19358	38	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19358	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	19358	40	the	the	DT
18637	19358	41	equivalent	equivalent	NN
18637	19358	42	of	of	IN
18637	19358	43	the	the	DT
18637	19358	44	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	19358	45	of	of	IN
18637	19358	46	the	the	DT
18637	19358	47	State	State	NNP
18637	19358	48	Registrar	Registrar	NNP
18637	19358	49	as	as	IN
18637	19358	50	agent	agent	NN
18637	19358	51	for	for	IN
18637	19358	52	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	19358	53	of	of	IN
18637	19358	54	process	process	NN
18637	19358	55	in	in	IN
18637	19358	56	suits	suit	NNS
18637	19358	57	growing	grow	VBG
18637	19358	58	out	out	IN
18637	19358	59	of	of	IN
18637	19358	60	motor	motor	NN
18637	19358	61	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	19358	62	accidents	accident	NNS
18637	19358	63	.	.	.
18637	19359	1	However	however	RB
18637	19359	2	,	,	,
18637	19359	3	a	a	DT
18637	19359	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	19359	5	designating	designate	VBG
18637	19359	6	a	a	DT
18637	19359	7	State	State	NNP
18637	19359	8	official	official	NN
18637	19359	9	as	as	IN
18637	19359	10	the	the	DT
18637	19359	11	proper	proper	JJ
18637	19359	12	person	person	NN
18637	19359	13	to	to	TO
18637	19359	14	receive	receive	VB
18637	19359	15	service	service	NN
18637	19359	16	of	of	IN
18637	19359	17	process	process	NN
18637	19359	18	in	in	IN
18637	19359	19	such	such	JJ
18637	19359	20	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	19359	21	must	must	MD
18637	19359	22	,	,	,
18637	19359	23	to	to	TO
18637	19359	24	be	be	VB
18637	19359	25	valid	valid	JJ
18637	19359	26	,	,	,
18637	19359	27	contain	contain	VBP
18637	19359	28	a	a	DT
18637	19359	29	provision	provision	NN
18637	19359	30	making	make	VBG
18637	19359	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19359	32	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	19359	33	probable	probable	JJ
18637	19359	34	that	that	IN
18637	19359	35	a	a	DT
18637	19359	36	notice	notice	NN
18637	19359	37	of	of	IN
18637	19359	38	such	such	JJ
18637	19359	39	service	service	NN
18637	19359	40	will	will	MD
18637	19359	41	be	be	VB
18637	19359	42	communicated	communicate	VBN
18637	19359	43	to	to	IN
18637	19359	44	the	the	DT
18637	19359	45	person	person	NN
18637	19359	46	sued	sue	VBN
18637	19359	47	.	.	.
18637	19360	1	If	if	IN
18637	19360	2	the	the	DT
18637	19360	3	statute	statute	NN
18637	19360	4	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	19360	5	"	"	``
18637	19360	6	either	either	CC
18637	19360	7	on	on	IN
18637	19360	8	the	the	DT
18637	19360	9	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	19360	10	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19360	11	,	,	,
18637	19360	12	or	or	CC
18637	19360	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	19360	14	the	the	DT
18637	19360	15	official	official	NN
18637	19360	16	"	"	``
18637	19360	17	designated	designate	VBN
18637	19360	18	to	to	TO
18637	19360	19	accept	accept	VB
18637	19360	20	process	process	NN
18637	19360	21	"	"	''
18637	19360	22	or	or	CC
18637	19360	23	some	some	DT
18637	19360	24	other	other	JJ
18637	19360	25	,	,	,
18637	19360	26	the	the	DT
18637	19360	27	duty	duty	NN
18637	19360	28	of	of	IN
18637	19360	29	communicating	communicate	VBG
18637	19360	30	by	by	IN
18637	19360	31	mail	mail	NN
18637	19360	32	or	or	CC
18637	19360	33	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	19360	34	with	with	IN
18637	19360	35	the	the	DT
18637	19360	36	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19360	37	"	"	``
18637	19360	38	this	this	DT
18637	19360	39	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19360	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	19360	41	met	meet	VBN
18637	19360	42	;	;	:
18637	19360	43	but	but	CC
18637	19360	44	if	if	IN
18637	19360	45	the	the	DT
18637	19360	46	act	act	NN
18637	19360	47	exacts	exact	VBZ
18637	19360	48	no	no	DT
18637	19360	49	more	more	JJR
18637	19360	50	than	than	IN
18637	19360	51	service	service	NN
18637	19360	52	of	of	IN
18637	19360	53	process	process	NN
18637	19360	54	on	on	IN
18637	19360	55	the	the	DT
18637	19360	56	local	local	JJ
18637	19360	57	agent	agent	NN
18637	19360	58	,	,	,
18637	19360	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19360	60	is	be	VBZ
18637	19360	61	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19360	62	,	,	,
18637	19360	63	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19360	64	that	that	IN
18637	19360	65	the	the	DT
18637	19360	66	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19360	67	may	may	MD
18637	19360	68	have	have	VB
18637	19360	69	been	be	VBN
18637	19360	70	personally	personally	RB
18637	19360	71	served	serve	VBN
18637	19360	72	in	in	IN
18637	19360	73	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19360	74	own	own	JJ
18637	19360	75	State	state	NN
18637	19360	76	.	.	.
18637	19361	1	Not	not	RB
18637	19361	2	having	have	VBG
18637	19361	3	been	be	VBN
18637	19361	4	directed	direct	VBN
18637	19361	5	by	by	IN
18637	19361	6	the	the	DT
18637	19361	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	19361	8	,	,	,
18637	19361	9	such	such	JJ
18637	19361	10	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19361	11	service	service	NN
18637	19361	12	can	can	MD
18637	19361	13	not	not	RB
18637	19361	14	supply	supply	VB
18637	19361	15	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19361	16	validity	validity	NN
18637	19361	17	to	to	IN
18637	19361	18	the	the	DT
18637	19361	19	act	act	NN
18637	19361	20	or	or	CC
18637	19361	21	to	to	IN
18637	19361	22	service	service	NN
18637	19361	23	under	under	IN
18637	19361	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19361	25	.	.	.
18637	19362	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19362	2	701	701	CD
18637	19362	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19362	4	Suits	Suits	NNP
18637	19362	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19362	6	in	in	IN
18637	19362	7	Personam_.--Restating	personam_.--restate	VBG
18637	19362	8	the	the	DT
18637	19362	9	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19362	10	principles	principle	NNS
18637	19362	11	currently	currently	RB
18637	19362	12	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	19362	13	for	for	IN
18637	19362	14	determining	determine	VBG
18637	19362	15	whether	whether	IN
18637	19362	16	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	19362	17	,	,	,
18637	19362	18	resident	resident	NN
18637	19362	19	and	and	CC
18637	19362	20	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19362	21	,	,	,
18637	19362	22	are	be	VBP
18637	19362	23	suable	suable	JJ
18637	19362	24	in	in	IN
18637	19362	25	_	_	NNP
18637	19362	26	in	in	IN
18637	19362	27	personam	personam	NNP
18637	19362	28	_	_	NNP
18637	19362	29	actions	action	NNS
18637	19362	30	,	,	,
18637	19362	31	the	the	DT
18637	19362	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19362	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19362	34	in	in	IN
18637	19362	35	International	International	NNP
18637	19362	36	Shoe	Shoe	NNP
18637	19362	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	19362	38	_	_	NNP
18637	19362	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	19362	40	_	_	NNP
18637	19362	41	Washington,[702	Washington,[702	NNP
18637	19362	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19362	43	recently	recently	RB
18637	19362	44	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19362	45	that	that	DT
18637	19362	46	:	:	:
18637	19362	47	"	"	``
18637	19362	48	Historically	historically	RB
18637	19362	49	the	the	DT
18637	19362	50	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19362	51	of	of	IN
18637	19362	52	courts	court	NNS
18637	19362	53	to	to	TO
18637	19362	54	render	render	VB
18637	19362	55	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	19362	56	_	_	NNP
18637	19362	57	in	in	IN
18637	19362	58	personam	personam	NNP
18637	19362	59	_	_	NNP
18637	19362	60	is	be	VBZ
18637	19362	61	grounded	ground	VBN
18637	19362	62	on	on	IN
18637	19362	63	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19362	64	de	de	FW
18637	19362	65	facto	facto	FW
18637	19362	66	power	power	NN
18637	19362	67	over	over	IN
18637	19362	68	the	the	DT
18637	19362	69	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19362	70	's	's	POS
18637	19362	71	person	person	NN
18637	19362	72	.	.	.
18637	19363	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	19363	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19363	3	presence	presence	NN
18637	19363	4	within	within	IN
18637	19363	5	the	the	DT
18637	19363	6	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	19363	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19363	8	of	of	IN
18637	19363	9	a	a	DT
18637	19363	10	court	court	NN
18637	19363	11	was	be	VBD
18637	19363	12	prerequisite	prerequisite	JJ
18637	19363	13	to	to	IN
18637	19363	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19363	15	rendition	rendition	NN
18637	19363	16	of	of	IN
18637	19363	17	a	a	DT
18637	19363	18	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19363	19	personally	personally	RB
18637	19363	20	binding	bind	VBG
18637	19363	21	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19363	22	.	.	.
18637	19364	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19364	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19364	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19364	4	But	but	CC
18637	19364	5	now	now	RB
18637	19364	6	*	*	NFP
18637	19364	7	*	*	NFP
18637	19364	8	*	*	NFP
18637	19364	9	,	,	,
18637	19364	10	due	due	JJ
18637	19364	11	process	process	NN
18637	19364	12	requires	require	VBZ
18637	19364	13	only	only	RB
18637	19364	14	that	that	DT
18637	19364	15	in	in	IN
18637	19364	16	order	order	NN
18637	19364	17	to	to	TO
18637	19364	18	subject	subject	VB
18637	19364	19	a	a	DT
18637	19364	20	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19364	21	to	to	IN
18637	19364	22	a	a	DT
18637	19364	23	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19364	24	_	_	NNP
18637	19364	25	in	in	IN
18637	19364	26	personam	personam	NNP
18637	19364	27	_	_	NNP
18637	19364	28	,	,	,
18637	19364	29	if	if	IN
18637	19364	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19364	31	be	be	VB
18637	19364	32	not	not	RB
18637	19364	33	present	present	JJ
18637	19364	34	within	within	IN
18637	19364	35	the	the	DT
18637	19364	36	territory	territory	NN
18637	19364	37	of	of	IN
18637	19364	38	the	the	DT
18637	19364	39	forum	forum	NN
18637	19364	40	,	,	,
18637	19364	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19364	42	have	have	VBP
18637	19364	43	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19364	44	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	19364	45	contacts	contact	NNS
18637	19364	46	with	with	IN
18637	19364	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19364	48	such	such	JJ
18637	19364	49	that	that	IN
18637	19364	50	the	the	DT
18637	19364	51	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	19364	52	of	of	IN
18637	19364	53	the	the	DT
18637	19364	54	suit	suit	NN
18637	19364	55	does	do	VBZ
18637	19364	56	not	not	RB
18637	19364	57	offend	offend	VB
18637	19364	58	'	'	``
18637	19364	59	traditional	traditional	JJ
18637	19364	60	notions	notion	NNS
18637	19364	61	of	of	IN
18637	19364	62	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19364	63	play	play	NN
18637	19364	64	and	and	CC
18637	19364	65	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	19364	66	justice	justice	NN
18637	19364	67	.	.	.
18637	19364	68	'	'	''
18637	19364	69	"	"	''
18637	19365	1	Suability	Suability	NNP
18637	19365	2	of	of	IN
18637	19365	3	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	19365	4	Corporations.--Until	Corporations.--Until	NNP
18637	19365	5	the	the	DT
18637	19365	6	enunciation	enunciation	NN
18637	19365	7	in	in	IN
18637	19365	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	19365	9	in	in	IN
18637	19365	10	International	International	NNP
18637	19365	11	Shoe	Shoe	NNP
18637	19365	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	19365	13	_	_	NNP
18637	19365	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	19365	15	_	_	NNP
18637	19365	16	Washington[703	Washington[703	NNP
18637	19365	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19365	18	of	of	IN
18637	19365	19	a	a	DT
18637	19365	20	"	"	``
18637	19365	21	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19365	22	play	play	NN
18637	19365	23	and	and	CC
18637	19365	24	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	19365	25	justice	justice	NN
18637	19365	26	"	"	''
18637	19365	27	doctrine	doctrine	NNP
18637	19365	28	,	,	,
18637	19365	29	the	the	DT
18637	19365	30	exact	exact	JJ
18637	19365	31	scope	scope	NN
18637	19365	32	of	of	IN
18637	19365	33	which	which	WDT
18637	19365	34	can	can	MD
18637	19365	35	not	not	RB
18637	19365	36	yet	yet	RB
18637	19365	37	be	be	VB
18637	19365	38	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	19365	39	,	,	,
18637	19365	40	the	the	DT
18637	19365	41	suability	suability	NN
18637	19365	42	of	of	IN
18637	19365	43	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19365	44	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19365	45	had	have	VBD
18637	19365	46	been	be	VBN
18637	19365	47	determined	determine	VBN
18637	19365	48	by	by	IN
18637	19365	49	utilization	utilization	NN
18637	19365	50	of	of	IN
18637	19365	51	the	the	DT
18637	19365	52	"	"	``
18637	19365	53	presence	presence	NN
18637	19365	54	"	"	''
18637	19365	55	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	19365	56	.	.	.
18637	19366	1	Defined	define	VBN
18637	19366	2	in	in	IN
18637	19366	3	terms	term	NNS
18637	19366	4	no	no	DT
18637	19366	5	less	less	RBR
18637	19366	6	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	19366	7	than	than	IN
18637	19366	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19366	9	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	19366	10	successor	successor	NN
18637	19366	11	and	and	CC
18637	19366	12	capable	capable	JJ
18637	19366	13	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	19366	14	of	of	IN
18637	19366	15	acquiring	acquire	VBG
18637	19366	16	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	19366	17	only	only	RB
18637	19366	18	in	in	IN
18637	19366	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	19366	20	of	of	IN
18637	19366	21	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19366	22	application	application	NN
18637	19366	23	,	,	,
18637	19366	24	the	the	DT
18637	19366	25	"	"	``
18637	19366	26	presence	presence	NN
18637	19366	27	"	"	''
18637	19366	28	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	19366	29	was	be	VBD
18637	19366	30	stated	state	VBN
18637	19366	31	by	by	IN
18637	19366	32	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19366	33	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	19366	34	as	as	IN
18637	19366	35	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	19366	36	:	:	:
18637	19366	37	"	"	``
18637	19366	38	In	in	IN
18637	19366	39	the	the	DT
18637	19366	40	absence	absence	NN
18637	19366	41	of	of	IN
18637	19366	42	consent	consent	NN
18637	19366	43	,	,	,
18637	19366	44	a	a	DT
18637	19366	45	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19366	46	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19366	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	19366	48	amenable	amenable	JJ
18637	19366	49	to	to	TO
18637	19366	50	process	process	VB
18637	19366	51	to	to	TO
18637	19366	52	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	19366	53	a	a	DT
18637	19366	54	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19366	55	liability	liability	NN
18637	19366	56	only	only	RB
18637	19366	57	if	if	IN
18637	19366	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19366	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	19366	60	doing	do	VBG
18637	19366	61	business	business	NN
18637	19366	62	within	within	IN
18637	19366	63	the	the	DT
18637	19366	64	State	State	NNP
18637	19366	65	in	in	IN
18637	19366	66	such	such	JJ
18637	19366	67	manner	manner	NN
18637	19366	68	and	and	CC
18637	19366	69	to	to	IN
18637	19366	70	such	such	JJ
18637	19366	71	extent	extent	NN
18637	19366	72	as	as	IN
18637	19366	73	to	to	TO
18637	19366	74	warrant	warrant	VB
18637	19366	75	the	the	DT
18637	19366	76	inference	inference	NN
18637	19366	77	that	that	IN
18637	19366	78	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19366	79	is	be	VBZ
18637	19366	80	present	present	JJ
18637	19366	81	there	there	RB
18637	19366	82	"	"	''
18637	19366	83	.	.	.
18637	19367	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19367	2	704	704	CD
18637	19367	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19367	4	In	in	IN
18637	19367	5	a	a	DT
18637	19367	6	variety	variety	NN
18637	19367	7	of	of	IN
18637	19367	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	19367	9	the	the	DT
18637	19367	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19367	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	19367	12	considered	consider	VBN
18637	19367	13	the	the	DT
18637	19367	14	measure	measure	NN
18637	19367	15	of	of	IN
18637	19367	16	"	"	``
18637	19367	17	presence	presence	NN
18637	19367	18	"	"	''
18637	19367	19	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19367	20	to	to	TO
18637	19367	21	confer	confer	VB
18637	19367	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19367	23	and	and	CC
18637	19367	24	a	a	DT
18637	19367	25	representative	representative	JJ
18637	19367	26	sample	sample	NN
18637	19367	27	of	of	IN
18637	19367	28	the	the	DT
18637	19367	29	classes	class	NNS
18637	19367	30	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19367	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	19367	32	set	set	VBN
18637	19367	33	forth	forth	RP
18637	19367	34	below	below	RB
18637	19367	35	.	.	.
18637	19368	1	With	with	IN
18637	19368	2	rare	rare	JJ
18637	19368	3	exceptions,[705	exceptions,[705	NNS
18637	19368	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19368	5	even	even	RB
18637	19368	6	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	19368	7	activity	activity	NN
18637	19368	8	of	of	IN
18637	19368	9	some	some	DT
18637	19368	10	sort	sort	NN
18637	19368	11	by	by	IN
18637	19368	12	a	a	DT
18637	19368	13	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19368	14	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19368	15	within	within	IN
18637	19368	16	a	a	DT
18637	19368	17	State	State	NNP
18637	19368	18	did	do	VBD
18637	19368	19	not	not	RB
18637	19368	20	in	in	IN
18637	19368	21	the	the	DT
18637	19368	22	past	past	JJ
18637	19368	23	suffice	suffice	NN
18637	19368	24	to	to	TO
18637	19368	25	render	render	VB
18637	19368	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19368	27	amenable	amenable	JJ
18637	19368	28	to	to	IN
18637	19368	29	suits	suit	NNS
18637	19368	30	therein	therein	RB
18637	19368	31	unrelated	unrelated	JJ
18637	19368	32	to	to	IN
18637	19368	33	that	that	DT
18637	19368	34	activity	activity	NN
18637	19368	35	.	.	.
18637	19369	1	Without	without	IN
18637	19369	2	the	the	DT
18637	19369	3	protection	protection	NN
18637	19369	4	of	of	IN
18637	19369	5	such	such	PDT
18637	19369	6	a	a	DT
18637	19369	7	rule	rule	NN
18637	19369	8	,	,	,
18637	19369	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19369	10	was	be	VBD
18637	19369	11	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	19369	12	,	,	,
18637	19369	13	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19369	14	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19369	15	would	would	MD
18637	19369	16	be	be	VB
18637	19369	17	exposed	expose	VBN
18637	19369	18	to	to	IN
18637	19369	19	the	the	DT
18637	19369	20	manifest	manif	JJS
18637	19369	21	hardship	hardship	NN
18637	19369	22	and	and	CC
18637	19369	23	inconvenience	inconvenience	NN
18637	19369	24	of	of	IN
18637	19369	25	defending	defend	VBG
18637	19369	26	in	in	IN
18637	19369	27	any	any	DT
18637	19369	28	State	State	NNP
18637	19369	29	in	in	IN
18637	19369	30	which	which	WDT
18637	19369	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19369	32	happen	happen	VBP
18637	19369	33	to	to	TO
18637	19369	34	be	be	VB
18637	19369	35	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	19369	36	on	on	IN
18637	19369	37	business	business	NN
18637	19369	38	suits	suit	NNS
18637	19369	39	for	for	IN
18637	19369	40	torts	tort	NNS
18637	19369	41	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	19369	42	committed	commit	VBN
18637	19369	43	and	and	CC
18637	19369	44	claims	claim	VBZ
18637	19369	45	on	on	IN
18637	19369	46	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	19369	47	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	19369	48	made	make	VBN
18637	19369	49	.	.	.
18637	19370	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19370	2	,	,	,
18637	19370	3	an	an	DT
18637	19370	4	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	19370	5	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19370	6	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19370	7	,	,	,
18637	19370	8	engaging	engage	VBG
18637	19370	9	,	,	,
18637	19370	10	without	without	IN
18637	19370	11	formal	formal	JJ
18637	19370	12	admission	admission	NN
18637	19370	13	,	,	,
18637	19370	14	in	in	IN
18637	19370	15	the	the	DT
18637	19370	16	business	business	NN
18637	19370	17	of	of	IN
18637	19370	18	selling	sell	VBG
18637	19370	19	life	life	NN
18637	19370	20	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19370	21	in	in	IN
18637	19370	22	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	19370	23	,	,	,
18637	19370	24	was	be	VBD
18637	19370	25	held	hold	VBN
18637	19370	26	not	not	RB
18637	19370	27	to	to	TO
18637	19370	28	be	be	VB
18637	19370	29	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19370	30	in	in	IN
18637	19370	31	the	the	DT
18637	19370	32	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19370	33	State	State	NNP
18637	19370	34	to	to	IN
18637	19370	35	a	a	DT
18637	19370	36	suit	suit	NN
18637	19370	37	filed	file	VBN
18637	19370	38	by	by	IN
18637	19370	39	a	a	DT
18637	19370	40	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	19370	41	resident	resident	NN
18637	19370	42	upon	upon	IN
18637	19370	43	an	an	DT
18637	19370	44	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19370	45	policy	policy	NN
18637	19370	46	executed	execute	VBN
18637	19370	47	and	and	CC
18637	19370	48	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	19370	49	in	in	IN
18637	19370	50	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	19370	51	.	.	.
18637	19371	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19371	2	706	706	CD
18637	19371	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19371	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19371	5	,	,	,
18637	19371	6	a	a	DT
18637	19371	7	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	19371	8	railway	railway	NN
18637	19371	9	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19371	10	,	,	,
18637	19371	11	doing	do	VBG
18637	19371	12	business	business	NN
18637	19371	13	in	in	IN
18637	19371	14	New	New	NNP
18637	19371	15	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	19371	16	,	,	,
18637	19371	17	was	be	VBD
18637	19371	18	declared	declare	VBN
18637	19371	19	not	not	RB
18637	19371	20	to	to	TO
18637	19371	21	be	be	VB
18637	19371	22	within	within	IN
18637	19371	23	the	the	DT
18637	19371	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19371	25	of	of	IN
18637	19371	26	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	19371	27	for	for	IN
18637	19371	28	the	the	DT
18637	19371	29	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19371	30	of	of	IN
18637	19371	31	a	a	DT
18637	19371	32	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	19371	33	action	action	NN
18637	19371	34	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	19371	35	against	against	IN
18637	19371	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19371	37	by	by	IN
18637	19371	38	a	a	DT
18637	19371	39	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	19371	40	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	19371	41	and	and	CC
18637	19371	42	based	base	VBN
18637	19371	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	19371	44	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	19371	45	suffered	suffer	VBN
18637	19371	46	in	in	IN
18637	19371	47	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	19371	48	.	.	.
18637	19372	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19372	2	707	707	CD
18637	19372	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19372	4	Also	also	RB
18637	19372	5	,	,	,
18637	19372	6	an	an	DT
18637	19372	7	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	19372	8	railway	railway	NN
18637	19372	9	company	company	NN
18637	19372	10	soliciting	solicit	VBG
18637	19372	11	freight	freight	NN
18637	19372	12	and	and	CC
18637	19372	13	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	19372	14	business	business	NN
18637	19372	15	in	in	IN
18637	19372	16	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	19372	17	through	through	IN
18637	19372	18	a	a	DT
18637	19372	19	local	local	JJ
18637	19372	20	agent	agent	NN
18637	19372	21	was	be	VBD
18637	19372	22	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19372	23	as	as	IN
18637	19372	24	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	19372	25	therein	therein	RB
18637	19372	26	from	from	IN
18637	19372	27	suit	suit	NN
18637	19372	28	brought	bring	VBN
18637	19372	29	by	by	IN
18637	19372	30	a	a	DT
18637	19372	31	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	19372	32	resident	resident	NN
18637	19372	33	to	to	TO
18637	19372	34	recover	recover	VB
18637	19372	35	damages	damage	NNS
18637	19372	36	for	for	IN
18637	19372	37	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19372	38	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	19372	39	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	19372	40	on	on	IN
18637	19372	41	one	one	CD
18637	19372	42	of	of	IN
18637	19372	43	the	the	DT
18637	19372	44	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	19372	45	's	's	POS
18637	19372	46	trains	train	NNS
18637	19372	47	in	in	IN
18637	19372	48	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	19372	49	.	.	.
18637	19373	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19373	2	708	708	CD
18637	19373	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19373	4	On	on	IN
18637	19373	5	the	the	DT
18637	19373	6	other	other	JJ
18637	19373	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	19373	8	,	,	,
18637	19373	9	when	when	WRB
18637	19373	10	a	a	DT
18637	19373	11	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	19373	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	19373	13	,	,	,
18637	19373	14	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	19373	15	by	by	IN
18637	19373	16	a	a	DT
18637	19373	17	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19373	18	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19373	19	company	company	NN
18637	19373	20	and	and	CC
18637	19373	21	requiring	require	VBG
18637	19373	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19373	23	to	to	TO
18637	19373	24	designate	designate	VB
18637	19373	25	the	the	DT
18637	19373	26	State	State	NNP
18637	19373	27	superintendent	superintendent	NN
18637	19373	28	of	of	IN
18637	19373	29	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19373	30	as	as	IN
18637	19373	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19373	32	agent	agent	NN
18637	19373	33	for	for	IN
18637	19373	34	service	service	NN
18637	19373	35	of	of	IN
18637	19373	36	process	process	NN
18637	19373	37	,	,	,
18637	19373	38	was	be	VBD
18637	19373	39	construed	construe	VBN
18637	19373	40	by	by	IN
18637	19373	41	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	19373	42	courts	court	NNS
18637	19373	43	to	to	TO
18637	19373	44	apply	apply	VB
18637	19373	45	to	to	IN
18637	19373	46	suits	suit	NNS
18637	19373	47	on	on	IN
18637	19373	48	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	19373	49	executed	execute	VBN
18637	19373	50	outside	outside	IN
18637	19373	51	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	19373	52	,	,	,
18637	19373	53	with	with	IN
18637	19373	54	the	the	DT
18637	19373	55	result	result	NN
18637	19373	56	that	that	IN
18637	19373	57	the	the	DT
18637	19373	58	company	company	NN
18637	19373	59	had	have	VBD
18637	19373	60	to	to	TO
18637	19373	61	defend	defend	VB
18637	19373	62	in	in	IN
18637	19373	63	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	19373	64	a	a	DT
18637	19373	65	suit	suit	NN
18637	19373	66	on	on	IN
18637	19373	67	a	a	DT
18637	19373	68	policy	policy	NN
18637	19373	69	issued	issue	VBN
18637	19373	70	in	in	IN
18637	19373	71	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	19373	72	and	and	CC
18637	19373	73	covering	cover	VBG
18637	19373	74	property	property	NN
18637	19373	75	therein	therein	RB
18637	19373	76	,	,	,
18637	19373	77	the	the	DT
18637	19373	78	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19373	79	was	be	VBD
18637	19373	80	unable	unable	JJ
18637	19373	81	to	to	TO
18637	19373	82	discern	discern	VB
18637	19373	83	any	any	DT
18637	19373	84	denial	denial	NN
18637	19373	85	of	of	IN
18637	19373	86	due	due	JJ
18637	19373	87	process	process	NN
18637	19373	88	.	.	.
18637	19374	1	The	the	DT
18637	19374	2	company	company	NN
18637	19374	3	was	be	VBD
18637	19374	4	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19374	5	to	to	TO
18637	19374	6	have	have	VB
18637	19374	7	consented	consent	VBN
18637	19374	8	to	to	IN
18637	19374	9	such	such	JJ
18637	19374	10	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	19374	11	when	when	WRB
18637	19374	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19374	13	complied	comply	VBD
18637	19374	14	with	with	IN
18637	19374	15	the	the	DT
18637	19374	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	19374	17	.	.	.
18637	19375	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19375	2	709	709	CD
18637	19375	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19375	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	19375	5	,	,	,
18637	19375	6	even	even	RB
18637	19375	7	when	when	WRB
18637	19375	8	the	the	DT
18637	19375	9	cause	cause	NN
18637	19375	10	of	of	IN
18637	19375	11	action	action	NN
18637	19375	12	arose	arise	VBD
18637	19375	13	in	in	IN
18637	19375	14	the	the	DT
18637	19375	15	forum	forum	NN
18637	19375	16	State	state	NN
18637	19375	17	and	and	CC
18637	19375	18	suit	suit	NN
18637	19375	19	was	be	VBD
18637	19375	20	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	19375	21	by	by	IN
18637	19375	22	a	a	DT
18637	19375	23	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19375	24	chartered	charter	VBD
18637	19375	25	therein	therein	RB
18637	19375	26	,	,	,
18637	19375	27	a	a	DT
18637	19375	28	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19375	29	company	company	NN
18637	19375	30	retailing	retail	VBG
18637	19375	31	clothing	clothing	NN
18637	19375	32	in	in	IN
18637	19375	33	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	19375	34	was	be	VBD
18637	19375	35	held	hold	VBN
18637	19375	36	immune	immune	JJ
18637	19375	37	from	from	IN
18637	19375	38	service	service	NN
18637	19375	39	of	of	IN
18637	19375	40	process	process	NN
18637	19375	41	on	on	IN
18637	19375	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19375	43	president	president	NN
18637	19375	44	when	when	WRB
18637	19375	45	the	the	DT
18637	19375	46	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19375	47	visited	visit	VBD
18637	19375	48	New	New	NNP
18637	19375	49	York	York	NNP
18637	19375	50	on	on	IN
18637	19375	51	one	one	CD
18637	19375	52	of	of	IN
18637	19375	53	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19375	54	periodic	periodic	JJ
18637	19375	55	trips	trip	NNS
18637	19375	56	there	there	RB
18637	19375	57	for	for	IN
18637	19375	58	the	the	DT
18637	19375	59	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	19375	60	of	of	IN
18637	19375	61	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	19375	62	.	.	.
18637	19376	1	Notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19376	2	that	that	IN
18637	19376	3	such	such	JJ
18637	19376	4	business	business	NN
18637	19376	5	trips	trip	NNS
18637	19376	6	were	be	VBD
18637	19376	7	made	make	VBN
18637	19376	8	at	at	IN
18637	19376	9	regular	regular	JJ
18637	19376	10	intervals	interval	NNS
18637	19376	11	,	,	,
18637	19376	12	the	the	DT
18637	19376	13	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	19376	14	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19376	15	was	be	VBD
18637	19376	16	considered	consider	VBN
18637	19376	17	not	not	RB
18637	19376	18	to	to	TO
18637	19376	19	be	be	VB
18637	19376	20	doing	do	VBG
18637	19376	21	business	business	NN
18637	19376	22	in	in	IN
18637	19376	23	New	New	NNP
18637	19376	24	York	York	NNP
18637	19376	25	"	"	''
18637	19376	26	in	in	IN
18637	19376	27	such	such	JJ
18637	19376	28	manner	manner	NN
18637	19376	29	and	and	CC
18637	19376	30	to	to	IN
18637	19376	31	such	such	JJ
18637	19376	32	extent	extent	NN
18637	19376	33	as	as	IN
18637	19376	34	to	to	TO
18637	19376	35	warrant	warrant	VB
18637	19376	36	the	the	DT
18637	19376	37	inference	inference	NN
18637	19376	38	that	that	IN
18637	19376	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19376	40	was	be	VBD
18637	19376	41	present	present	JJ
18637	19376	42	there	there	RB
18637	19376	43	,	,	,
18637	19376	44	"	"	``
18637	19376	45	especially	especially	RB
18637	19376	46	in	in	IN
18637	19376	47	view	view	NN
18637	19376	48	of	of	IN
18637	19376	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19376	50	having	have	VBG
18637	19376	51	never	never	RB
18637	19376	52	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19376	53	for	for	IN
18637	19376	54	a	a	DT
18637	19376	55	license	license	NN
18637	19376	56	to	to	TO
18637	19376	57	do	do	VB
18637	19376	58	business	business	NN
18637	19376	59	in	in	IN
18637	19376	60	New	New	NNP
18637	19376	61	York	York	NNP
18637	19376	62	or	or	CC
18637	19376	63	consented	consent	VBD
18637	19376	64	to	to	TO
18637	19376	65	suit	suit	VB
18637	19376	66	being	be	VBG
18637	19376	67	brought	bring	VBN
18637	19376	68	against	against	IN
18637	19376	69	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19376	70	there	there	RB
18637	19376	71	,	,	,
18637	19376	72	or	or	CC
18637	19376	73	established	establish	VBD
18637	19376	74	therein	therein	RB
18637	19376	75	an	an	DT
18637	19376	76	office	office	NN
18637	19376	77	or	or	CC
18637	19376	78	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	19376	79	a	a	DT
18637	19376	80	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19376	81	agent	agent	NN
18637	19376	82	.	.	.
18637	19377	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19377	2	710	710	CD
18637	19377	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19377	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19377	5	would	would	MD
18637	19377	6	the	the	DT
18637	19377	7	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19377	8	presence	presence	NN
18637	19377	9	within	within	IN
18637	19377	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19377	11	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	19377	12	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19377	13	of	of	IN
18637	19377	14	an	an	DT
18637	19377	15	agent	agent	NN
18637	19377	16	,	,	,
18637	19377	17	officer	officer	NN
18637	19377	18	,	,	,
18637	19377	19	or	or	CC
18637	19377	20	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	19377	21	,	,	,
18637	19377	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	19377	23	whom	whom	WP
18637	19377	24	service	service	NN
18637	19377	25	might	may	MD
18637	19377	26	readily	readily	RB
18637	19377	27	be	be	VB
18637	19377	28	had	have	VBN
18637	19377	29	,	,	,
18637	19377	30	be	be	VB
18637	19377	31	effective	effective	JJ
18637	19377	32	without	without	IN
18637	19377	33	more	more	JJR
18637	19377	34	to	to	TO
18637	19377	35	enable	enable	VB
18637	19377	36	a	a	DT
18637	19377	37	State	state	NN
18637	19377	38	to	to	TO
18637	19377	39	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	19377	40	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19377	41	over	over	IN
18637	19377	42	a	a	DT
18637	19377	43	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19377	44	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19377	45	.	.	.
18637	19378	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	19378	2	,	,	,
18637	19378	3	service	service	NN
18637	19378	4	of	of	IN
18637	19378	5	process	process	NN
18637	19378	6	on	on	IN
18637	19378	7	the	the	DT
18637	19378	8	president	president	NN
18637	19378	9	of	of	IN
18637	19378	10	a	a	DT
18637	19378	11	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19378	12	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19378	13	in	in	IN
18637	19378	14	a	a	DT
18637	19378	15	State	state	NN
18637	19378	16	where	where	WRB
18637	19378	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19378	18	was	be	VBD
18637	19378	19	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	19378	20	and	and	CC
18637	19378	21	casually	casually	RB
18637	19378	22	present	present	JJ
18637	19378	23	and	and	CC
18637	19378	24	where	where	WRB
18637	19378	25	the	the	DT
18637	19378	26	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19378	27	did	do	VBD
18637	19378	28	no	no	DT
18637	19378	29	business	business	NN
18637	19378	30	and	and	CC
18637	19378	31	had	have	VBD
18637	19378	32	no	no	DT
18637	19378	33	property	property	NN
18637	19378	34	was	be	VBD
18637	19378	35	fruitless	fruitless	JJ
18637	19378	36	.	.	.
18637	19379	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19379	2	711	711	CD
18637	19379	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19379	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19379	5	,	,	,
18637	19379	6	service	service	NN
18637	19379	7	on	on	IN
18637	19379	8	a	a	DT
18637	19379	9	New	New	NNP
18637	19379	10	York	York	NNP
18637	19379	11	director	director	NN
18637	19379	12	of	of	IN
18637	19379	13	a	a	DT
18637	19379	14	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	19379	15	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19379	16	was	be	VBD
18637	19379	17	not	not	RB
18637	19379	18	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19379	19	to	to	TO
18637	19379	20	bring	bring	VB
18637	19379	21	the	the	DT
18637	19379	22	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19379	23	into	into	IN
18637	19379	24	the	the	DT
18637	19379	25	New	New	NNP
18637	19379	26	York	York	NNP
18637	19379	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	19379	28	when	when	WRB
18637	19379	29	,	,	,
18637	19379	30	at	at	IN
18637	19379	31	the	the	DT
18637	19379	32	time	time	NN
18637	19379	33	of	of	IN
18637	19379	34	service	service	NN
18637	19379	35	,	,	,
18637	19379	36	the	the	DT
18637	19379	37	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19379	38	was	be	VBD
18637	19379	39	not	not	RB
18637	19379	40	doing	do	VBG
18637	19379	41	business	business	NN
18637	19379	42	in	in	IN
18637	19379	43	New	New	NNP
18637	19379	44	York	York	NNP
18637	19379	45	,	,	,
18637	19379	46	and	and	CC
18637	19379	47	the	the	DT
18637	19379	48	director	director	NN
18637	19379	49	was	be	VBD
18637	19379	50	not	not	RB
18637	19379	51	there	there	RB
18637	19379	52	officially	officially	RB
18637	19379	53	representing	represent	VBG
18637	19379	54	the	the	DT
18637	19379	55	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19379	56	in	in	IN
18637	19379	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19379	58	business	business	NN
18637	19379	59	.	.	.
18637	19380	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19380	2	712	712	CD
18637	19380	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19380	4	On	on	IN
18637	19380	5	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	19380	6	,	,	,
18637	19380	7	an	an	DT
18637	19380	8	officer	officer	NN
18637	19380	9	of	of	IN
18637	19380	10	a	a	DT
18637	19380	11	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19380	12	may	may	MD
18637	19380	13	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	19380	14	be	be	VB
18637	19380	15	in	in	IN
18637	19380	16	a	a	DT
18637	19380	17	State	state	NN
18637	19380	18	or	or	CC
18637	19380	19	even	even	RB
18637	19380	20	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	19380	21	reside	reside	VB
18637	19380	22	therein	therein	RB
18637	19380	23	;	;	:
18637	19380	24	but	but	CC
18637	19380	25	if	if	IN
18637	19380	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19380	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	19380	28	not	not	RB
18637	19380	29	there	there	RB
18637	19380	30	for	for	IN
18637	19380	31	the	the	DT
18637	19380	32	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	19380	33	of	of	IN
18637	19380	34	transacting	transact	VBG
18637	19380	35	business	business	NN
18637	19380	36	for	for	IN
18637	19380	37	the	the	DT
18637	19380	38	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19380	39	,	,	,
18637	19380	40	or	or	CC
18637	19380	41	vested	vest	VBN
18637	19380	42	with	with	IN
18637	19380	43	authority	authority	NN
18637	19380	44	by	by	IN
18637	19380	45	the	the	DT
18637	19380	46	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19380	47	to	to	TO
18637	19380	48	transact	transact	VB
18637	19380	49	business	business	NN
18637	19380	50	in	in	IN
18637	19380	51	such	such	JJ
18637	19380	52	State	State	NNP
18637	19380	53	,	,	,
18637	19380	54	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19380	55	presence	presence	NN
18637	19380	56	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	19380	57	no	no	DT
18637	19380	58	basis	basis	NN
18637	19380	59	for	for	IN
18637	19380	60	the	the	DT
18637	19380	61	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19380	62	of	of	IN
18637	19380	63	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19380	64	over	over	IN
18637	19380	65	such	such	JJ
18637	19380	66	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19380	67	employer	employer	NN
18637	19380	68	,	,	,
18637	19380	69	and	and	CC
18637	19380	70	any	any	DT
18637	19380	71	decree	decree	NN
18637	19380	72	resulting	result	VBG
18637	19380	73	from	from	IN
18637	19380	74	service	service	NN
18637	19380	75	upon	upon	IN
18637	19380	76	such	such	JJ
18637	19380	77	officer	officer	NN
18637	19380	78	is	be	VBZ
18637	19380	79	violative	violative	JJ
18637	19380	80	of	of	IN
18637	19380	81	due	due	JJ
18637	19380	82	process	process	NN
18637	19380	83	.	.	.
18637	19381	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19381	2	713	713	CD
18637	19381	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19381	4	However	however	RB
18637	19381	5	,	,	,
18637	19381	6	a	a	DT
18637	19381	7	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19381	8	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19381	9	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19381	10	which	which	WDT
18637	19381	11	had	have	VBD
18637	19381	12	ceased	cease	VBN
18637	19381	13	to	to	TO
18637	19381	14	sell	sell	VB
18637	19381	15	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19381	16	in	in	IN
18637	19381	17	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	19381	18	but	but	CC
18637	19381	19	which	which	WDT
18637	19381	20	had	have	VBD
18637	19381	21	sent	send	VBN
18637	19381	22	a	a	DT
18637	19381	23	special	special	JJ
18637	19381	24	agent	agent	NN
18637	19381	25	there	there	RB
18637	19381	26	to	to	TO
18637	19381	27	adjust	adjust	VB
18637	19381	28	a	a	DT
18637	19381	29	loss	loss	NN
18637	19381	30	under	under	IN
18637	19381	31	a	a	DT
18637	19381	32	policy	policy	NN
18637	19381	33	previously	previously	RB
18637	19381	34	issued	issue	VBN
18637	19381	35	in	in	IN
18637	19381	36	that	that	DT
18637	19381	37	State	State	NNP
18637	19381	38	could	could	MD
18637	19381	39	not	not	RB
18637	19381	40	,	,	,
18637	19381	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19381	42	was	be	VBD
18637	19381	43	held	hold	VBN
18637	19381	44	,	,	,
18637	19381	45	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	19381	46	object	object	VB
18637	19381	47	when	when	WRB
18637	19381	48	a	a	DT
18637	19381	49	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19381	50	on	on	IN
18637	19381	51	that	that	DT
18637	19381	52	claim	claim	NN
18637	19381	53	was	be	VBD
18637	19381	54	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19381	55	by	by	IN
18637	19381	56	service	service	NN
18637	19381	57	on	on	IN
18637	19381	58	that	that	DT
18637	19381	59	agent	agent	NN
18637	19381	60	.	.	.
18637	19382	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19382	2	714	714	CD
18637	19382	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19382	4	Inasmuch	Inasmuch	NNP
18637	19382	5	as	as	IN
18637	19382	6	a	a	DT
18637	19382	7	State	state	NN
18637	19382	8	need	nee	MD
18637	19382	9	not	not	RB
18637	19382	10	permit	permit	VB
18637	19382	11	a	a	DT
18637	19382	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19382	13	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19382	14	to	to	TO
18637	19382	15	do	do	VB
18637	19382	16	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19382	17	business	business	NN
18637	19382	18	within	within	IN
18637	19382	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19382	20	borders	border	NNS
18637	19382	21	,	,	,
18637	19382	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19382	23	may	may	MD
18637	19382	24	condition	condition	VB
18637	19382	25	entry	entry	NN
18637	19382	26	upon	upon	IN
18637	19382	27	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	19382	28	by	by	IN
18637	19382	29	the	the	DT
18637	19382	30	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19382	31	of	of	IN
18637	19382	32	service	service	NN
18637	19382	33	of	of	IN
18637	19382	34	process	process	NN
18637	19382	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	19382	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19382	37	agents	agent	NNS
18637	19382	38	or	or	CC
18637	19382	39	upon	upon	IN
18637	19382	40	a	a	DT
18637	19382	41	person	person	NN
18637	19382	42	to	to	TO
18637	19382	43	be	be	VB
18637	19382	44	designated	designate	VBN
18637	19382	45	by	by	IN
18637	19382	46	the	the	DT
18637	19382	47	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19382	48	or	or	CC
18637	19382	49	,	,	,
18637	19382	50	failing	fail	VBG
18637	19382	51	such	such	JJ
18637	19382	52	designation	designation	NN
18637	19382	53	,	,	,
18637	19382	54	upon	upon	IN
18637	19382	55	a	a	DT
18637	19382	56	State	State	NNP
18637	19382	57	officer	officer	NN
18637	19382	58	designated	designate	VBN
18637	19382	59	by	by	IN
18637	19382	60	law	law	NN
18637	19382	61	.	.	.
18637	19383	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19383	2	715	715	CD
18637	19383	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19383	4	Service	Service	NNP
18637	19383	5	on	on	IN
18637	19383	6	a	a	DT
18637	19383	7	State	state	NN
18637	19383	8	officer	officer	NN
18637	19383	9	,	,	,
18637	19383	10	however	however	RB
18637	19383	11	,	,	,
18637	19383	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	19383	13	no	no	DT
18637	19383	14	more	more	RBR
18637	19383	15	effective	effective	JJ
18637	19383	16	than	than	IN
18637	19383	17	service	service	NN
18637	19383	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	19383	19	an	an	DT
18637	19383	20	agent	agent	NN
18637	19383	21	in	in	IN
18637	19383	22	the	the	DT
18637	19383	23	employ	employ	NN
18637	19383	24	of	of	IN
18637	19383	25	a	a	DT
18637	19383	26	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19383	27	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19383	28	when	when	WRB
18637	19383	29	,	,	,
18637	19383	30	as	as	IN
18637	19383	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	19383	32	already	already	RB
18637	19383	33	been	be	VBN
18637	19383	34	noted	note	VBN
18637	19383	35	,	,	,
18637	19383	36	such	such	JJ
18637	19383	37	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19383	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	19383	39	not	not	RB
18637	19383	40	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19383	41	to	to	IN
18637	19383	42	the	the	DT
18637	19383	43	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19383	44	of	of	IN
18637	19383	45	the	the	DT
18637	19383	46	State	State	NNP
18637	19383	47	;	;	:
18637	19383	48	that	that	RB
18637	19383	49	is	is	RB
18637	19383	50	,	,	,
18637	19383	51	has	have	VBZ
18637	19383	52	not	not	RB
18637	19383	53	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	19383	54	in	in	IN
18637	19383	55	activities	activity	NNS
18637	19383	56	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19383	57	to	to	TO
18637	19383	58	render	render	VB
18637	19383	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19383	60	"	"	``
18637	19383	61	present	present	JJ
18637	19383	62	"	"	''
18637	19383	63	within	within	IN
18637	19383	64	the	the	DT
18637	19383	65	State	State	NNP
18637	19383	66	,	,	,
18637	19383	67	or	or	CC
18637	19383	68	is	be	VBZ
18637	19383	69	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	19383	70	to	to	IN
18637	19383	71	a	a	DT
18637	19383	72	cause	cause	NN
18637	19383	73	of	of	IN
18637	19383	74	action	action	NN
18637	19383	75	unrelated	unrelated	JJ
18637	19383	76	to	to	IN
18637	19383	77	such	such	JJ
18637	19383	78	activities	activity	NNS
18637	19383	79	and	and	CC
18637	19383	80	originating	originate	VBG
18637	19383	81	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19383	82	the	the	DT
18637	19383	83	forum	forum	NN
18637	19383	84	State	state	NN
18637	19383	85	.	.	.
18637	19384	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19384	2	,	,	,
18637	19384	3	a	a	DT
18637	19384	4	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19384	5	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19384	6	company	company	NN
18637	19384	7	which	which	WDT
18637	19384	8	,	,	,
18637	19384	9	after	after	IN
18637	19384	10	revocation	revocation	NN
18637	19384	11	of	of	IN
18637	19384	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19384	13	entry	entry	NN
18637	19384	14	license	license	NN
18637	19384	15	,	,	,
18637	19384	16	continued	continue	VBD
18637	19384	17	to	to	TO
18637	19384	18	collect	collect	VB
18637	19384	19	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	19384	20	on	on	IN
18637	19384	21	policies	policy	NNS
18637	19384	22	formerly	formerly	RB
18637	19384	23	issued	issue	VBN
18637	19384	24	to	to	IN
18637	19384	25	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	19384	26	of	of	IN
18637	19384	27	the	the	DT
18637	19384	28	forum	forum	NN
18637	19384	29	State	State	NNP
18637	19384	30	was	be	VBD
18637	19384	31	in	in	IN
18637	19384	32	fact	fact	NN
18637	19384	33	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	19384	34	to	to	TO
18637	19384	35	do	do	VB
18637	19384	36	business	business	NN
18637	19384	37	in	in	IN
18637	19384	38	that	that	DT
18637	19384	39	State	State	NNP
18637	19384	40	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	19384	41	to	to	TO
18637	19384	42	render	render	VB
18637	19384	43	service	service	NN
18637	19384	44	on	on	IN
18637	19384	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19384	46	through	through	IN
18637	19384	47	the	the	DT
18637	19384	48	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19384	49	commissioner	commissioner	NN
18637	19384	50	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19384	51	to	to	TO
18637	19384	52	bind	bind	VB
18637	19384	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19384	54	as	as	IN
18637	19384	55	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19384	56	in	in	IN
18637	19384	57	a	a	DT
18637	19384	58	suit	suit	NN
18637	19384	59	by	by	IN
18637	19384	60	a	a	DT
18637	19384	61	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	19384	62	of	of	IN
18637	19384	63	said	say	VBD
18637	19384	64	State	state	NN
18637	19384	65	on	on	IN
18637	19384	66	a	a	DT
18637	19384	67	policy	policy	NN
18637	19384	68	therein	therein	RB
18637	19384	69	issued	issue	VBN
18637	19384	70	to	to	IN
18637	19384	71	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19384	72	.	.	.
18637	19385	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19385	2	716	716	CD
18637	19385	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19385	4	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	19385	5	,	,	,
18637	19385	6	a	a	DT
18637	19385	7	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19385	8	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19385	9	which	which	WDT
18637	19385	10	,	,	,
18637	19385	11	after	after	IN
18637	19385	12	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	19385	13	a	a	DT
18637	19385	14	State	state	NN
18637	19385	15	and	and	CC
18637	19385	16	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	19385	17	dissolving	dissolve	VBG
18637	19385	18	,	,	,
18637	19385	19	failed	fail	VBD
18637	19385	20	to	to	TO
18637	19385	21	obey	obey	VB
18637	19385	22	a	a	DT
18637	19385	23	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	19385	24	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19385	25	of	of	IN
18637	19385	26	that	that	DT
18637	19385	27	State	State	NNP
18637	19385	28	that	that	IN
18637	19385	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19385	30	maintain	maintain	VBP
18637	19385	31	therein	therein	RB
18637	19385	32	a	a	DT
18637	19385	33	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19385	34	agent	agent	NN
18637	19385	35	until	until	IN
18637	19385	36	the	the	DT
18637	19385	37	period	period	NN
18637	19385	38	of	of	IN
18637	19385	39	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	19385	40	shall	shall	MD
18637	19385	41	have	have	VB
18637	19385	42	run	run	VBN
18637	19385	43	,	,	,
18637	19385	44	or	or	CC
18637	19385	45	,	,	,
18637	19385	46	in	in	IN
18637	19385	47	default	default	NN
18637	19385	48	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19385	49	,	,	,
18637	19385	50	that	that	IN
18637	19385	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19385	52	consent	consent	VBP
18637	19385	53	to	to	TO
18637	19385	54	service	service	VB
18637	19385	55	on	on	IN
18637	19385	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19385	57	through	through	IN
18637	19385	58	the	the	DT
18637	19385	59	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	19385	60	of	of	IN
18637	19385	61	State	State	NNP
18637	19385	62	,	,	,
18637	19385	63	could	could	MD
18637	19385	64	not	not	RB
18637	19385	65	complain	complain	VB
18637	19385	66	of	of	IN
18637	19385	67	any	any	DT
18637	19385	68	denial	denial	NN
18637	19385	69	of	of	IN
18637	19385	70	due	due	JJ
18637	19385	71	process	process	NN
18637	19385	72	because	because	IN
18637	19385	73	that	that	DT
18637	19385	74	statute	statute	NN
18637	19385	75	did	do	VBD
18637	19385	76	not	not	RB
18637	19385	77	oblige	oblige	VB
18637	19385	78	the	the	DT
18637	19385	79	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	19385	80	of	of	IN
18637	19385	81	State	State	NNP
18637	19385	82	to	to	TO
18637	19385	83	notify	notify	VB
18637	19385	84	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19385	85	of	of	IN
18637	19385	86	the	the	DT
18637	19385	87	pendency	pendency	NN
18637	19385	88	of	of	IN
18637	19385	89	an	an	DT
18637	19385	90	action	action	NN
18637	19385	91	.	.	.
18637	19386	1	The	the	DT
18637	19386	2	burden	burden	NN
18637	19386	3	was	be	VBD
18637	19386	4	on	on	IN
18637	19386	5	the	the	DT
18637	19386	6	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19386	7	to	to	TO
18637	19386	8	make	make	VB
18637	19386	9	such	such	JJ
18637	19386	10	arrangement	arrangement	NN
18637	19386	11	for	for	IN
18637	19386	12	notice	notice	NN
18637	19386	13	as	as	IN
18637	19386	14	was	be	VBD
18637	19386	15	thought	think	VBN
18637	19386	16	desirable	desirable	JJ
18637	19386	17	.	.	.
18637	19387	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19387	2	717	717	CD
18637	19387	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19387	4	To	to	IN
18637	19387	5	what	what	WDT
18637	19387	6	extent	extent	NN
18637	19387	7	these	these	DT
18637	19387	8	aforementioned	aforementioned	JJ
18637	19387	9	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	19387	10	have	have	VBP
18637	19387	11	been	be	VBN
18637	19387	12	undermined	undermine	VBN
18637	19387	13	by	by	IN
18637	19387	14	the	the	DT
18637	19387	15	recent	recent	JJ
18637	19387	16	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	19387	17	in	in	IN
18637	19387	18	International	International	NNP
18637	19387	19	Shoe	Shoe	NNP
18637	19387	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	19387	21	_	_	NNP
18637	19387	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	19387	23	_	_	NNP
18637	19387	24	Washington[718	Washington[718	NNP
18637	19387	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19387	26	can	can	MD
18637	19387	27	not	not	RB
18637	19387	28	yet	yet	RB
18637	19387	29	be	be	VB
18637	19387	30	determined	determine	VBN
18637	19387	31	.	.	.
18637	19388	1	In	in	IN
18637	19388	2	the	the	DT
18637	19388	3	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19388	4	case	case	NN
18637	19388	5	,	,	,
18637	19388	6	a	a	DT
18637	19388	7	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19388	8	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19388	9	,	,	,
18637	19388	10	which	which	WDT
18637	19388	11	had	have	VBD
18637	19388	12	not	not	RB
18637	19388	13	been	be	VBN
18637	19388	14	issued	issue	VBN
18637	19388	15	a	a	DT
18637	19388	16	license	license	NN
18637	19388	17	to	to	TO
18637	19388	18	do	do	VB
18637	19388	19	business	business	NN
18637	19388	20	in	in	IN
18637	19388	21	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	19388	22	,	,	,
18637	19388	23	but	but	CC
18637	19388	24	which	which	WDT
18637	19388	25	systematically	systematically	RB
18637	19388	26	and	and	CC
18637	19388	27	continuously	continuously	RB
18637	19388	28	employed	employ	VBD
18637	19388	29	a	a	DT
18637	19388	30	force	force	NN
18637	19388	31	of	of	IN
18637	19388	32	salesmen	salesman	NNS
18637	19388	33	,	,	,
18637	19388	34	residents	resident	NNS
18637	19388	35	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19388	36	,	,	,
18637	19388	37	to	to	TO
18637	19388	38	canvass	canvass	VB
18637	19388	39	for	for	IN
18637	19388	40	orders	order	NNS
18637	19388	41	therein	therein	RB
18637	19388	42	,	,	,
18637	19388	43	was	be	VBD
18637	19388	44	held	hold	VBN
18637	19388	45	suable	suable	JJ
18637	19388	46	in	in	IN
18637	19388	47	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	19388	48	for	for	IN
18637	19388	49	unpaid	unpaid	JJ
18637	19388	50	unemployment	unemployment	NN
18637	19388	51	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19388	52	contributions	contribution	NNS
18637	19388	53	in	in	IN
18637	19388	54	respect	respect	NN
18637	19388	55	to	to	IN
18637	19388	56	such	such	JJ
18637	19388	57	salesmen	salesman	NNS
18637	19388	58	.	.	.
18637	19389	1	Service	service	NN
18637	19389	2	of	of	IN
18637	19389	3	the	the	DT
18637	19389	4	notice	notice	NN
18637	19389	5	of	of	IN
18637	19389	6	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19389	7	personally	personally	RB
18637	19389	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	19389	9	one	one	CD
18637	19389	10	of	of	IN
18637	19389	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19389	12	local	local	JJ
18637	19389	13	sales	sale	NNS
18637	19389	14	solicitors	solicitor	NNS
18637	19389	15	plus	plus	CC
18637	19389	16	the	the	DT
18637	19389	17	forwarding	forwarding	NN
18637	19389	18	of	of	IN
18637	19389	19	a	a	DT
18637	19389	20	copy	copy	NN
18637	19389	21	thereof	thereof	VBN
18637	19389	22	by	by	IN
18637	19389	23	registered	register	VBN
18637	19389	24	mail	mail	NN
18637	19389	25	to	to	IN
18637	19389	26	the	the	DT
18637	19389	27	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19389	28	's	's	POS
18637	19389	29	principal	principal	JJ
18637	19389	30	office	office	NN
18637	19389	31	in	in	IN
18637	19389	32	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	19389	33	was	be	VBD
18637	19389	34	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19389	35	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19389	36	to	to	TO
18637	19389	37	apprize	apprize	VB
18637	19389	38	the	the	DT
18637	19389	39	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19389	40	of	of	IN
18637	19389	41	the	the	DT
18637	19389	42	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19389	43	.	.	.
18637	19390	1	To	to	TO
18637	19390	2	reach	reach	VB
18637	19390	3	this	this	DT
18637	19390	4	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	19390	5	the	the	DT
18637	19390	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19390	7	not	not	RB
18637	19390	8	only	only	RB
18637	19390	9	overturned	overturn	VBD
18637	19390	10	prior	prior	JJ
18637	19390	11	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	19390	12	to	to	IN
18637	19390	13	the	the	DT
18637	19390	14	effect	effect	NN
18637	19390	15	that	that	IN
18637	19390	16	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19390	17	solicitation	solicitation	NN
18637	19390	18	of	of	IN
18637	19390	19	patronage	patronage	NN
18637	19390	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	19390	21	not	not	RB
18637	19390	22	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	19390	23	doing	do	VBG
18637	19390	24	of	of	IN
18637	19390	25	business	business	NN
18637	19390	26	in	in	IN
18637	19390	27	a	a	DT
18637	19390	28	State	state	NN
18637	19390	29	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19390	30	to	to	TO
18637	19390	31	subject	subject	VB
18637	19390	32	a	a	DT
18637	19390	33	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19390	34	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19390	35	to	to	IN
18637	19390	36	the	the	DT
18637	19390	37	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19390	38	thereof,[719	thereof,[719	NNS
18637	19390	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19390	40	but	but	CC
18637	19390	41	also	also	RB
18637	19390	42	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	19390	43	the	the	DT
18637	19390	44	"	"	``
18637	19390	45	presence	presence	NN
18637	19390	46	"	"	''
18637	19390	47	test	test	NN
18637	19390	48	as	as	IN
18637	19390	49	begging	beg	VBG
18637	19390	50	"	"	``
18637	19390	51	the	the	DT
18637	19390	52	question	question	NN
18637	19390	53	to	to	TO
18637	19390	54	be	be	VB
18637	19390	55	decided	decide	VBN
18637	19390	56	.	.	.
18637	19391	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19391	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19391	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19391	4	The	the	DT
18637	19391	5	terms	term	NNS
18637	19391	6	'	'	POS
18637	19391	7	present	present	JJ
18637	19391	8	'	'	''
18637	19391	9	or	or	CC
18637	19391	10	'	'	``
18637	19391	11	presence	presence	NN
18637	19391	12	,	,	,
18637	19391	13	'	'	''
18637	19391	14	"	"	''
18637	19391	15	according	accord	VBG
18637	19391	16	to	to	IN
18637	19391	17	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	19391	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19391	19	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	19391	20	,	,	,
18637	19391	21	"	"	``
18637	19391	22	are	be	VBP
18637	19391	23	used	use	VBN
18637	19391	24	merely	merely	RB
18637	19391	25	to	to	TO
18637	19391	26	symbolize	symbolize	VB
18637	19391	27	those	those	DT
18637	19391	28	activities	activity	NNS
18637	19391	29	of	of	IN
18637	19391	30	the	the	DT
18637	19391	31	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19391	32	's	's	POS
18637	19391	33	agent	agent	NN
18637	19391	34	within	within	IN
18637	19391	35	the	the	DT
18637	19391	36	State	State	NNP
18637	19391	37	which	which	WDT
18637	19391	38	courts	court	NNS
18637	19391	39	will	will	MD
18637	19391	40	deem	deem	VB
18637	19391	41	to	to	TO
18637	19391	42	be	be	VB
18637	19391	43	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19391	44	to	to	TO
18637	19391	45	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	19391	46	the	the	DT
18637	19391	47	demands	demand	NNS
18637	19391	48	of	of	IN
18637	19391	49	due	due	JJ
18637	19391	50	process	process	NN
18637	19391	51	.	.	.
18637	19392	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19392	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19392	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19392	4	Those	those	DT
18637	19392	5	demands	demand	NNS
18637	19392	6	may	may	MD
18637	19392	7	be	be	VB
18637	19392	8	met	meet	VBN
18637	19392	9	by	by	IN
18637	19392	10	such	such	JJ
18637	19392	11	contacts	contact	NNS
18637	19392	12	of	of	IN
18637	19392	13	the	the	DT
18637	19392	14	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19392	15	with	with	IN
18637	19392	16	the	the	DT
18637	19392	17	State	State	NNP
18637	19392	18	of	of	IN
18637	19392	19	the	the	DT
18637	19392	20	forum	forum	NN
18637	19392	21	as	as	IN
18637	19392	22	make	make	VB
18637	19392	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19392	24	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19392	25	,	,	,
18637	19392	26	in	in	IN
18637	19392	27	the	the	DT
18637	19392	28	context	context	NN
18637	19392	29	of	of	IN
18637	19392	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19392	31	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19392	32	system	system	NN
18637	19392	33	*	*	NFP
18637	19392	34	*	*	NFP
18637	19392	35	*	*	NFP
18637	19392	36	,	,	,
18637	19392	37	to	to	TO
18637	19392	38	require	require	VB
18637	19392	39	the	the	DT
18637	19392	40	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19392	41	to	to	TO
18637	19392	42	defend	defend	VB
18637	19392	43	the	the	DT
18637	19392	44	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19392	45	suit	suit	NN
18637	19392	46	which	which	WDT
18637	19392	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	19392	48	brought	bring	VBN
18637	19392	49	there	there	RB
18637	19392	50	;	;	:
18637	19392	51	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19392	52	and	and	CC
18637	19392	53	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19392	54	*	*	NFP
18637	19392	55	*	*	NFP
18637	19392	56	*	*	NFP
18637	19392	57	that	that	IN
18637	19392	58	the	the	DT
18637	19392	59	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	19392	60	of	of	IN
18637	19392	61	the	the	DT
18637	19392	62	suit	suit	NN
18637	19392	63	does	do	VBZ
18637	19392	64	not	not	RB
18637	19392	65	offend	offend	VB
18637	19392	66	'	'	``
18637	19392	67	traditional	traditional	JJ
18637	19392	68	notices	notice	NNS
18637	19392	69	of	of	IN
18637	19392	70	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19392	71	play	play	NN
18637	19392	72	and	and	CC
18637	19392	73	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	19392	74	justice	justice	NN
18637	19392	75	'	'	''
18637	19392	76	*	*	NFP
18637	19392	77	*	*	NFP
18637	19392	78	*	*	NFP
18637	19392	79	An	an	NN
18637	19392	80	'	'	``
18637	19392	81	estimate	estimate	NN
18637	19392	82	of	of	IN
18637	19392	83	the	the	DT
18637	19392	84	inconveniences	inconvenience	NNS
18637	19392	85	'	'	POS
18637	19392	86	which	which	WDT
18637	19392	87	would	would	MD
18637	19392	88	result	result	VB
18637	19392	89	to	to	IN
18637	19392	90	the	the	DT
18637	19392	91	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19392	92	from	from	IN
18637	19392	93	a	a	DT
18637	19392	94	trial	trial	NN
18637	19392	95	away	away	RB
18637	19392	96	from	from	IN
18637	19392	97	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19392	98	'	'	``
18637	19392	99	home	home	NN
18637	19392	100	'	'	''
18637	19392	101	or	or	CC
18637	19392	102	principal	principal	JJ
18637	19392	103	place	place	NN
18637	19392	104	of	of	IN
18637	19392	105	business	business	NN
18637	19392	106	is	be	VBZ
18637	19392	107	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	19392	108	in	in	IN
18637	19392	109	this	this	DT
18637	19392	110	connection	connection	NN
18637	19392	111	.	.	.
18637	19393	1	"	"	``
18637	19393	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19393	3	720	720	CD
18637	19393	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19393	5	As	as	IN
18637	19393	6	to	to	IN
18637	19393	7	the	the	DT
18637	19393	8	scope	scope	NN
18637	19393	9	of	of	IN
18637	19393	10	application	application	NN
18637	19393	11	to	to	TO
18637	19393	12	be	be	VB
18637	19393	13	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	19393	14	this	this	DT
18637	19393	15	"	"	``
18637	19393	16	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19393	17	play	play	NN
18637	19393	18	and	and	CC
18637	19393	19	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	19393	20	justice	justice	NN
18637	19393	21	"	"	''
18637	19393	22	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	19393	23	,	,	,
18637	19393	24	the	the	DT
18637	19393	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19393	26	,	,	,
18637	19393	27	at	at	IN
18637	19393	28	least	least	JJS
18637	19393	29	verbally	verbally	RB
18637	19393	30	,	,	,
18637	19393	31	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	19393	32	that	that	IN
18637	19393	33	"	"	``
18637	19393	34	*	*	NFP
18637	19393	35	*	*	NFP
18637	19393	36	*	*	NFP
18637	19393	37	so	so	RB
18637	19393	38	far	far	RB
18637	19393	39	as	as	IN
18637	19393	40	*	*	NFP
18637	19393	41	*	*	NFP
18637	19393	42	*	*	NFP
18637	19393	43	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19393	44	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	19393	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19393	46	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	19393	47	arise	arise	VBP
18637	19393	48	out	out	IN
18637	19393	49	of	of	IN
18637	19393	50	or	or	CC
18637	19393	51	are	be	VBP
18637	19393	52	connected	connect	VBN
18637	19393	53	with	with	IN
18637	19393	54	activities	activity	NNS
18637	19393	55	within	within	IN
18637	19393	56	the	the	DT
18637	19393	57	State	State	NNP
18637	19393	58	,	,	,
18637	19393	59	a	a	DT
18637	19393	60	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19393	61	which	which	WDT
18637	19393	62	requires	require	VBZ
18637	19393	63	the	the	DT
18637	19393	64	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19393	65	to	to	TO
18637	19393	66	respond	respond	VB
18637	19393	67	to	to	IN
18637	19393	68	a	a	DT
18637	19393	69	suit	suit	NN
18637	19393	70	brought	bring	VBN
18637	19393	71	to	to	TO
18637	19393	72	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	19393	73	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19393	74	can	can	MD
18637	19393	75	,	,	,
18637	19393	76	in	in	IN
18637	19393	77	most	most	JJS
18637	19393	78	instances	instance	NNS
18637	19393	79	,	,	,
18637	19393	80	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	19393	81	be	be	VB
18637	19393	82	said	say	VBN
18637	19393	83	to	to	TO
18637	19393	84	be	be	VB
18637	19393	85	undue	undue	JJ
18637	19393	86	.	.	.
18637	19394	1	"	"	``
18637	19394	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19394	3	721	721	CD
18637	19394	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19394	5	Read	read	VB
18637	19394	6	literally	literally	RB
18637	19394	7	,	,	,
18637	19394	8	these	these	DT
18637	19394	9	statements	statement	NNS
18637	19394	10	coupled	couple	VBN
18637	19394	11	with	with	IN
18637	19394	12	the	the	DT
18637	19394	13	terms	term	NNS
18637	19394	14	of	of	IN
18637	19394	15	the	the	DT
18637	19394	16	new	new	JJ
18637	19394	17	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	19394	18	may	may	MD
18637	19394	19	conceivably	conceivably	RB
18637	19394	20	lead	lead	VB
18637	19394	21	to	to	IN
18637	19394	22	a	a	DT
18637	19394	23	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	19394	24	of	of	IN
18637	19394	25	former	former	JJ
18637	19394	26	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19394	27	which	which	WDT
18637	19394	28	:	:	:
18637	19394	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19394	30	1	1	LS
18637	19394	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19394	32	nullified	nullify	VBD
18637	19394	33	the	the	DT
18637	19394	34	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19394	35	of	of	IN
18637	19394	36	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19394	37	by	by	IN
18637	19394	38	the	the	DT
18637	19394	39	forum	forum	NN
18637	19394	40	State	State	NNP
18637	19394	41	over	over	IN
18637	19394	42	actions	action	NNS
18637	19394	43	arising	arise	VBG
18637	19394	44	outside	outside	RB
18637	19394	45	said	say	VBD
18637	19394	46	State	state	NN
18637	19394	47	and	and	CC
18637	19394	48	brought	bring	VBN
18637	19394	49	by	by	IN
18637	19394	50	a	a	DT
18637	19394	51	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19394	52	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	19394	53	against	against	IN
18637	19394	54	a	a	DT
18637	19394	55	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19394	56	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19394	57	doing	do	VBG
18637	19394	58	business	business	NN
18637	19394	59	therein	therein	RB
18637	19394	60	without	without	IN
18637	19394	61	having	have	VBG
18637	19394	62	been	be	VBN
18637	19394	63	legally	legally	RB
18637	19394	64	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	19394	65	and	and	CC
18637	19394	66	without	without	IN
18637	19394	67	having	have	VBG
18637	19394	68	consented	consent	VBN
18637	19394	69	to	to	IN
18637	19394	70	service	service	NN
18637	19394	71	of	of	IN
18637	19394	72	process	process	NN
18637	19394	73	on	on	IN
18637	19394	74	a	a	DT
18637	19394	75	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19394	76	agent	agent	NN
18637	19394	77	;	;	:
18637	19394	78	and	and	CC
18637	19394	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19394	80	2	2	LS
18637	19394	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19394	82	exempted	exempt	VBD
18637	19394	83	a	a	DT
18637	19394	84	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19394	85	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19394	86	,	,	,
18637	19394	87	which	which	WDT
18637	19394	88	has	have	VBZ
18637	19394	89	been	be	VBN
18637	19394	90	licensed	license	VBN
18637	19394	91	by	by	IN
18637	19394	92	the	the	DT
18637	19394	93	forum	forum	NN
18637	19394	94	State	State	NNP
18637	19394	95	to	to	TO
18637	19394	96	do	do	VB
18637	19394	97	business	business	NN
18637	19394	98	therein	therein	RB
18637	19394	99	and	and	CC
18637	19394	100	has	have	VBZ
18637	19394	101	consented	consent	VBN
18637	19394	102	to	to	IN
18637	19394	103	the	the	DT
18637	19394	104	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	19394	105	of	of	IN
18637	19394	106	a	a	DT
18637	19394	107	local	local	JJ
18637	19394	108	agent	agent	NN
18637	19394	109	to	to	TO
18637	19394	110	accept	accept	VB
18637	19394	111	process	process	NN
18637	19394	112	,	,	,
18637	19394	113	from	from	IN
18637	19394	114	suit	suit	NN
18637	19394	115	on	on	IN
18637	19394	116	an	an	DT
18637	19394	117	action	action	NN
18637	19394	118	not	not	RB
18637	19394	119	arising	arise	VBG
18637	19394	120	in	in	IN
18637	19394	121	the	the	DT
18637	19394	122	forum	forum	NN
18637	19394	123	State	State	NNP
18637	19394	124	and	and	CC
18637	19394	125	not	not	RB
18637	19394	126	related	relate	VBN
18637	19394	127	to	to	IN
18637	19394	128	activities	activity	NNS
18637	19394	129	pursued	pursue	VBN
18637	19394	130	therein	therein	RB
18637	19394	131	.	.	.
18637	19395	1	By	by	IN
18637	19395	2	an	an	DT
18637	19395	3	extended	extended	JJ
18637	19395	4	application	application	NN
18637	19395	5	of	of	IN
18637	19395	6	the	the	DT
18637	19395	7	logic	logic	NN
18637	19395	8	of	of	IN
18637	19395	9	the	the	DT
18637	19395	10	last	last	JJ
18637	19395	11	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	19395	12	case	case	NN
18637	19395	13	,	,	,
18637	19395	14	a	a	DT
18637	19395	15	majority	majority	NN
18637	19395	16	of	of	IN
18637	19395	17	the	the	DT
18637	19395	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19395	19	,	,	,
18637	19395	20	in	in	IN
18637	19395	21	Travelers	Travelers	NNP
18637	19395	22	Health	Health	NNP
18637	19395	23	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	19395	24	.	.	.
18637	19396	1	_	_	NNP
18637	19396	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	19396	3	_	_	NNP
18637	19396	4	Virginia[722	Virginia[722	NNP
18637	19396	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19396	6	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	19396	7	that	that	IN
18637	19396	8	,	,	,
18637	19396	9	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19396	10	that	that	IN
18637	19396	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19396	12	solicited	solicit	VBD
18637	19396	13	business	business	NN
18637	19396	14	in	in	IN
18637	19396	15	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	19396	16	solely	solely	RB
18637	19396	17	through	through	IN
18637	19396	18	recommendations	recommendation	NNS
18637	19396	19	of	of	IN
18637	19396	20	existing	exist	VBG
18637	19396	21	members	member	NNS
18637	19396	22	and	and	CC
18637	19396	23	was	be	VBD
18637	19396	24	represented	represent	VBN
18637	19396	25	therein	therein	RB
18637	19396	26	by	by	IN
18637	19396	27	no	no	DT
18637	19396	28	agents	agent	NNS
18637	19396	29	whatsoever	whatsoever	RB
18637	19396	30	,	,	,
18637	19396	31	a	a	DT
18637	19396	32	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19396	33	mail	mail	NN
18637	19396	34	order	order	NN
18637	19396	35	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19396	36	company	company	NN
18637	19396	37	had	have	VBD
18637	19396	38	through	through	IN
18637	19396	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19396	40	policies	policy	NNS
18637	19396	41	developed	develop	VBD
18637	19396	42	such	such	JJ
18637	19396	43	contacts	contact	NNS
18637	19396	44	and	and	CC
18637	19396	45	ties	tie	NNS
18637	19396	46	with	with	IN
18637	19396	47	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	19396	48	residents	resident	NNS
18637	19396	49	that	that	IN
18637	19396	50	the	the	DT
18637	19396	51	State	State	NNP
18637	19396	52	,	,	,
18637	19396	53	by	by	IN
18637	19396	54	forwarding	forward	VBG
18637	19396	55	notice	notice	NN
18637	19396	56	to	to	IN
18637	19396	57	the	the	DT
18637	19396	58	company	company	NN
18637	19396	59	by	by	IN
18637	19396	60	registered	register	VBN
18637	19396	61	mail	mail	NN
18637	19396	62	only	only	RB
18637	19396	63	,	,	,
18637	19396	64	could	could	MD
18637	19396	65	institute	institute	VB
18637	19396	66	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	19396	67	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19396	68	under	under	IN
18637	19396	69	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19396	70	Blue	Blue	NNP
18637	19396	71	Sky	Sky	NNP
18637	19396	72	Law	Law	NNP
18637	19396	73	leading	lead	VBG
18637	19396	74	to	to	IN
18637	19396	75	a	a	DT
18637	19396	76	decree	decree	NN
18637	19396	77	ordering	order	VBG
18637	19396	78	cessation	cessation	NN
18637	19396	79	of	of	IN
18637	19396	80	business	business	NN
18637	19396	81	pending	pende	VBG
18637	19396	82	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	19396	83	with	with	IN
18637	19396	84	that	that	DT
18637	19396	85	act	act	NN
18637	19396	86	.	.	.
18637	19397	1	The	the	DT
18637	19397	2	due	due	JJ
18637	19397	3	process	process	NN
18637	19397	4	clause	clause	NN
18637	19397	5	was	be	VBD
18637	19397	6	declared	declare	VBN
18637	19397	7	not	not	RB
18637	19397	8	to	to	TO
18637	19397	9	"	"	``
18637	19397	10	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	19397	11	a	a	DT
18637	19397	12	State	state	NN
18637	19397	13	to	to	TO
18637	19397	14	protect	protect	VB
18637	19397	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19397	16	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	19397	17	from	from	IN
18637	19397	18	such	such	JJ
18637	19397	19	injustice	injustice	NN
18637	19397	20	"	"	''
18637	19397	21	of	of	IN
18637	19397	22	having	have	VBG
18637	19397	23	to	to	TO
18637	19397	24	file	file	VB
18637	19397	25	suits	suit	NNS
18637	19397	26	on	on	IN
18637	19397	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19397	28	claims	claim	NNS
18637	19397	29	at	at	IN
18637	19397	30	a	a	DT
18637	19397	31	far	far	RB
18637	19397	32	distant	distant	JJ
18637	19397	33	home	home	NN
18637	19397	34	office	office	NN
18637	19397	35	of	of	IN
18637	19397	36	such	such	JJ
18637	19397	37	company	company	NN
18637	19397	38	,	,	,
18637	19397	39	especially	especially	RB
18637	19397	40	in	in	IN
18637	19397	41	view	view	NN
18637	19397	42	of	of	IN
18637	19397	43	the	the	DT
18637	19397	44	fact	fact	NN
18637	19397	45	that	that	IN
18637	19397	46	such	such	JJ
18637	19397	47	suits	suit	NNS
18637	19397	48	could	could	MD
18637	19397	49	be	be	VB
18637	19397	50	more	more	RBR
18637	19397	51	conveniently	conveniently	RB
18637	19397	52	tried	try	VBN
18637	19397	53	in	in	IN
18637	19397	54	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	19397	55	where	where	WRB
18637	19397	56	claims	claim	NNS
18637	19397	57	of	of	IN
18637	19397	58	loss	loss	NN
18637	19397	59	could	could	MD
18637	19397	60	be	be	VB
18637	19397	61	investigated	investigate	VBN
18637	19397	62	.	.	.
18637	19398	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19398	2	723	723	CD
18637	19398	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19398	4	Service	Service	NNP
18637	19398	5	of	of	IN
18637	19398	6	Process	Process	NNP
18637	19398	7	Actions	Actions	NNPS
18637	19398	8	in	in	IN
18637	19398	9	Rem	Rem	NNP
18637	19398	10	--	--	:
18637	19398	11	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNP
18637	19398	12	Against	against	IN
18637	19398	13	Land.--For	Land.--For	VBG
18637	19398	14	the	the	DT
18637	19398	15	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	19398	16	of	of	IN
18637	19398	17	determining	determine	VBG
18637	19398	18	the	the	DT
18637	19398	19	extent	extent	NN
18637	19398	20	of	of	IN
18637	19398	21	a	a	DT
18637	19398	22	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19398	23	's	's	POS
18637	19398	24	title	title	NN
18637	19398	25	to	to	IN
18637	19398	26	real	real	JJ
18637	19398	27	estate	estate	NN
18637	19398	28	within	within	IN
18637	19398	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19398	30	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19398	31	,	,	,
18637	19398	32	a	a	DT
18637	19398	33	State	state	NN
18637	19398	34	may	may	MD
18637	19398	35	provide	provide	VB
18637	19398	36	any	any	DT
18637	19398	37	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19398	38	means	mean	NNS
18637	19398	39	of	of	IN
18637	19398	40	imparting	imparting	JJ
18637	19398	41	notice	notice	NN
18637	19398	42	.	.	.
18637	19399	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19399	2	724	724	CD
18637	19399	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19399	4	Precluded	preclude	VBD
18637	19399	5	from	from	IN
18637	19399	6	going	go	VBG
18637	19399	7	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19399	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19399	9	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	19399	10	and	and	CC
18637	19399	11	serving	serve	VBG
18637	19399	12	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19399	13	owners	owner	NNS
18637	19399	14	personally	personally	RB
18637	19399	15	,	,	,
18637	19399	16	States	state	NNS
18637	19399	17	in	in	IN
18637	19399	18	such	such	JJ
18637	19399	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	19399	20	of	of	IN
18637	19399	21	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19399	22	have	have	VBP
18637	19399	23	had	have	VBN
18637	19399	24	recourse	recourse	VBN
18637	19399	25	to	to	IN
18637	19399	26	constructive	constructive	JJ
18637	19399	27	notice	notice	NN
18637	19399	28	or	or	CC
18637	19399	29	service	service	NN
18637	19399	30	by	by	IN
18637	19399	31	publications	publication	NNS
18637	19399	32	.	.	.
18637	19400	1	This	this	DT
18637	19400	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19400	3	have	have	VBP
18637	19400	4	been	be	VBN
18637	19400	5	able	able	JJ
18637	19400	6	to	to	TO
18637	19400	7	do	do	VB
18637	19400	8	because	because	IN
18637	19400	9	of	of	IN
18637	19400	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19400	11	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	19400	12	authority	authority	NN
18637	19400	13	over	over	IN
18637	19400	14	titles	title	NNS
18637	19400	15	to	to	IN
18637	19400	16	lands	land	NNS
18637	19400	17	within	within	IN
18637	19400	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19400	19	borders	border	NNS
18637	19400	20	.	.	.
18637	19401	1	Owners	owner	NNS
18637	19401	2	,	,	,
18637	19401	3	nonresident	nonresident	RB
18637	19401	4	as	as	RB
18637	19401	5	well	well	RB
18637	19401	6	as	as	IN
18637	19401	7	resident	resident	NN
18637	19401	8	,	,	,
18637	19401	9	are	be	VBP
18637	19401	10	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19401	11	with	with	IN
18637	19401	12	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	19401	13	of	of	IN
18637	19401	14	laws	law	NNS
18637	19401	15	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	19401	16	demands	demand	NNS
18637	19401	17	of	of	IN
18637	19401	18	the	the	DT
18637	19401	19	State	State	NNP
18637	19401	20	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	19401	21	to	to	IN
18637	19401	22	property	property	NN
18637	19401	23	and	and	CC
18637	19401	24	of	of	IN
18637	19401	25	the	the	DT
18637	19401	26	manner	manner	NN
18637	19401	27	in	in	IN
18637	19401	28	which	which	WDT
18637	19401	29	such	such	JJ
18637	19401	30	demands	demand	NNS
18637	19401	31	may	may	MD
18637	19401	32	be	be	VB
18637	19401	33	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	19401	34	.	.	.
18637	19402	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19402	2	725	725	CD
18637	19402	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19402	4	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19402	5	,	,	,
18637	19402	6	only	only	RB
18637	19402	7	so	so	RB
18637	19402	8	long	long	RB
18637	19402	9	as	as	IN
18637	19402	10	the	the	DT
18637	19402	11	property	property	NN
18637	19402	12	affected	affect	VBN
18637	19402	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	19402	14	been	be	VBN
18637	19402	15	brought	bring	VBN
18637	19402	16	under	under	IN
18637	19402	17	control	control	NN
18637	19402	18	of	of	IN
18637	19402	19	the	the	DT
18637	19402	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19402	21	,	,	,
18637	19402	22	will	will	MD
18637	19402	23	a	a	DT
18637	19402	24	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19402	25	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19402	26	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	19402	27	without	without	IN
18637	19402	28	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19402	29	notice	notice	NN
18637	19402	30	to	to	IN
18637	19402	31	a	a	DT
18637	19402	32	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19402	33	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19402	34	be	be	VB
18637	19402	35	effective	effective	JJ
18637	19402	36	.	.	.
18637	19403	1	Insofar	insofar	RB
18637	19403	2	as	as	IN
18637	19403	3	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19403	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	19403	5	thus	thus	RB
18637	19403	6	required	require	VBN
18637	19403	7	over	over	IN
18637	19403	8	a	a	DT
18637	19403	9	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19403	10	,	,	,
18637	19403	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19403	12	does	do	VBZ
18637	19403	13	not	not	RB
18637	19403	14	extend	extend	VB
18637	19403	15	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19403	16	the	the	DT
18637	19403	17	property	property	NN
18637	19403	18	involved	involve	VBN
18637	19403	19	.	.	.
18637	19404	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19404	2	726	726	CD
18637	19404	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19404	4	Consistently	consistently	RB
18637	19404	5	with	with	IN
18637	19404	6	such	such	JJ
18637	19404	7	principles	principle	NNS
18637	19404	8	,	,	,
18637	19404	9	San	San	NNP
18637	19404	10	Francisco	Francisco	NNP
18637	19404	11	,	,	,
18637	19404	12	after	after	IN
18637	19404	13	the	the	DT
18637	19404	14	earthquake	earthquake	NN
18637	19404	15	of	of	IN
18637	19404	16	1906	1906	CD
18637	19404	17	,	,	,
18637	19404	18	had	have	VBD
18637	19404	19	destroyed	destroy	VBN
18637	19404	20	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	19404	21	all	all	DT
18637	19404	22	records	record	NNS
18637	19404	23	,	,	,
18637	19404	24	permitted	permit	VBD
18637	19404	25	titles	title	NNS
18637	19404	26	to	to	TO
18637	19404	27	be	be	VB
18637	19404	28	reestablished	reestablish	VBN
18637	19404	29	by	by	IN
18637	19404	30	parties	party	NNS
18637	19404	31	in	in	IN
18637	19404	32	possession	possession	NN
18637	19404	33	by	by	IN
18637	19404	34	posting	post	VBG
18637	19404	35	summons	summon	NNS
18637	19404	36	on	on	IN
18637	19404	37	the	the	DT
18637	19404	38	property	property	NN
18637	19404	39	,	,	,
18637	19404	40	serving	serve	VBG
18637	19404	41	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19404	42	on	on	IN
18637	19404	43	known	known	JJ
18637	19404	44	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	19404	45	,	,	,
18637	19404	46	and	and	CC
18637	19404	47	publishing	publish	VBG
18637	19404	48	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19404	49	against	against	IN
18637	19404	50	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	19404	51	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	19404	52	in	in	IN
18637	19404	53	newspapers	newspaper	NNS
18637	19404	54	for	for	IN
18637	19404	55	two	two	CD
18637	19404	56	weeks	week	NNS
18637	19404	57	.	.	.
18637	19405	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19405	2	727	727	CD
18637	19405	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19405	4	Actions	Actions	NNPS
18637	19405	5	in	in	IN
18637	19405	6	Rem	Rem	NNP
18637	19405	7	--	--	:
18637	19405	8	Attachment	Attachment	NNP
18637	19405	9	Proceedings.--In	Proceedings.--In	NNP
18637	19405	10	fulfillment	fulfillment	NN
18637	19405	11	of	of	IN
18637	19405	12	the	the	DT
18637	19405	13	protection	protection	NN
18637	19405	14	which	which	WDT
18637	19405	15	a	a	DT
18637	19405	16	State	state	NN
18637	19405	17	owes	owe	VBZ
18637	19405	18	to	to	IN
18637	19405	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19405	20	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	19405	21	,	,	,
18637	19405	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19405	23	may	may	MD
18637	19405	24	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	19405	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19405	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19405	27	over	over	IN
18637	19405	28	real	real	JJ
18637	19405	29	and	and	CC
18637	19405	30	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19405	31	property	property	NN
18637	19405	32	situated	situate	VBN
18637	19405	33	within	within	IN
18637	19405	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19405	35	borders	border	NNS
18637	19405	36	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	19405	37	to	to	IN
18637	19405	38	a	a	DT
18637	19405	39	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19405	40	and	and	CC
18637	19405	41	permit	permit	VB
18637	19405	42	an	an	DT
18637	19405	43	appropriation	appropriation	NN
18637	19405	44	of	of	IN
18637	19405	45	the	the	DT
18637	19405	46	same	same	JJ
18637	19405	47	in	in	IN
18637	19405	48	attachment	attachment	JJ
18637	19405	49	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19405	50	to	to	TO
18637	19405	51	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	19405	52	a	a	DT
18637	19405	53	debt	debt	NN
18637	19405	54	owed	owe	VBN
18637	19405	55	by	by	IN
18637	19405	56	the	the	DT
18637	19405	57	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19405	58	to	to	IN
18637	19405	59	one	one	CD
18637	19405	60	of	of	IN
18637	19405	61	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19405	62	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	19405	63	or	or	CC
18637	19405	64	to	to	TO
18637	19405	65	settle	settle	VB
18637	19405	66	a	a	DT
18637	19405	67	claim	claim	NN
18637	19405	68	for	for	IN
18637	19405	69	damages	damage	NNS
18637	19405	70	founded	found	VBN
18637	19405	71	upon	upon	IN
18637	19405	72	a	a	DT
18637	19405	73	wrong	wrong	JJ
18637	19405	74	inflicted	inflict	VBN
18637	19405	75	on	on	IN
18637	19405	76	the	the	DT
18637	19405	77	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	19405	78	by	by	IN
18637	19405	79	the	the	DT
18637	19405	80	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19405	81	.	.	.
18637	19406	1	Being	be	VBG
18637	19406	2	neither	neither	CC
18637	19406	3	present	present	JJ
18637	19406	4	within	within	IN
18637	19406	5	the	the	DT
18637	19406	6	State	State	NNP
18637	19406	7	nor	nor	CC
18637	19406	8	domiciled	domicile	VBD
18637	19406	9	therein	therein	RB
18637	19406	10	,	,	,
18637	19406	11	the	the	DT
18637	19406	12	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19406	13	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19406	14	can	can	MD
18637	19406	15	not	not	RB
18637	19406	16	be	be	VB
18637	19406	17	served	serve	VBN
18637	19406	18	personally	personally	RB
18637	19406	19	;	;	:
18637	19406	20	and	and	CC
18637	19406	21	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	19406	22	any	any	DT
18637	19406	23	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19406	24	in	in	IN
18637	19406	25	money	money	NN
18637	19406	26	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19406	27	against	against	IN
18637	19406	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19406	29	would	would	MD
18637	19406	30	be	be	VB
18637	19406	31	void	void	JJ
18637	19406	32	and	and	CC
18637	19406	33	could	could	MD
18637	19406	34	not	not	RB
18637	19406	35	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	19406	36	be	be	VB
18637	19406	37	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	19406	38	either	either	CC
18637	19406	39	by	by	IN
18637	19406	40	execution	execution	NN
18637	19406	41	on	on	IN
18637	19406	42	the	the	DT
18637	19406	43	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19406	44	's	's	POS
18637	19406	45	property	property	NN
18637	19406	46	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	19406	47	found	find	VBN
18637	19406	48	within	within	IN
18637	19406	49	the	the	DT
18637	19406	50	State	state	NN
18637	19406	51	or	or	CC
18637	19406	52	by	by	IN
18637	19406	53	suit	suit	NN
18637	19406	54	and	and	CC
18637	19406	55	execution	execution	NN
18637	19406	56	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	19406	57	in	in	IN
18637	19406	58	another	another	DT
18637	19406	59	State	state	NN
18637	19406	60	.	.	.
18637	19407	1	In	in	IN
18637	19407	2	such	such	JJ
18637	19407	3	instances	instance	NNS
18637	19407	4	,	,	,
18637	19407	5	the	the	DT
18637	19407	6	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	19407	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	19407	8	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	19407	9	may	may	MD
18637	19407	10	recover	recover	VB
18637	19407	11	,	,	,
18637	19407	12	if	if	IN
18637	19407	13	at	at	RB
18637	19407	14	all	all	RB
18637	19407	15	,	,	,
18637	19407	16	only	only	RB
18637	19407	17	by	by	IN
18637	19407	18	an	an	DT
18637	19407	19	_	_	NNP
18637	19407	20	in	in	IN
18637	19407	21	rem	rem	NN
18637	19407	22	_	_	NNP
18637	19407	23	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19407	24	involving	involve	VBG
18637	19407	25	a	a	DT
18637	19407	26	levy	levy	NN
18637	19407	27	of	of	IN
18637	19407	28	a	a	DT
18637	19407	29	writ	writ	NN
18637	19407	30	of	of	IN
18637	19407	31	attachment	attachment	NN
18637	19407	32	on	on	IN
18637	19407	33	the	the	DT
18637	19407	34	local	local	JJ
18637	19407	35	property	property	NN
18637	19407	36	of	of	IN
18637	19407	37	the	the	DT
18637	19407	38	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19407	39	,	,	,
18637	19407	40	of	of	IN
18637	19407	41	which	which	WDT
18637	19407	42	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	19407	43	the	the	DT
18637	19407	44	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19407	45	need	need	NN
18637	19407	46	be	be	VB
18637	19407	47	notified	notify	VBN
18637	19407	48	merely	merely	RB
18637	19407	49	by	by	IN
18637	19407	50	publication	publication	NN
18637	19407	51	of	of	IN
18637	19407	52	a	a	DT
18637	19407	53	notice	notice	NN
18637	19407	54	within	within	IN
18637	19407	55	the	the	DT
18637	19407	56	forum	forum	NN
18637	19407	57	State	State	NNP
18637	19407	58	.	.	.
18637	19408	1	However	however	RB
18637	19408	2	,	,	,
18637	19408	3	any	any	DT
18637	19408	4	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19408	5	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19408	6	in	in	IN
18637	19408	7	such	such	JJ
18637	19408	8	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19408	9	can	can	MD
18637	19408	10	have	have	VB
18637	19408	11	no	no	DT
18637	19408	12	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	19408	13	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19408	14	the	the	DT
18637	19408	15	property	property	NN
18637	19408	16	attached	attach	VBN
18637	19408	17	.	.	.
18637	19409	1	If	if	IN
18637	19409	2	the	the	DT
18637	19409	3	attached	attach	VBN
18637	19409	4	property	property	NN
18637	19409	5	be	be	VB
18637	19409	6	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	19409	7	to	to	TO
18637	19409	8	pay	pay	VB
18637	19409	9	the	the	DT
18637	19409	10	claim	claim	NN
18637	19409	11	,	,	,
18637	19409	12	the	the	DT
18637	19409	13	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	19409	14	can	can	MD
18637	19409	15	not	not	RB
18637	19409	16	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	19409	17	sue	sue	VB
18637	19409	18	on	on	IN
18637	19409	19	such	such	JJ
18637	19409	20	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19409	21	to	to	TO
18637	19409	22	collect	collect	VB
18637	19409	23	an	an	DT
18637	19409	24	unpaid	unpaid	JJ
18637	19409	25	balance	balance	NN
18637	19409	26	;	;	:
18637	19409	27	and	and	CC
18637	19409	28	if	if	IN
18637	19409	29	property	property	NN
18637	19409	30	owned	own	VBN
18637	19409	31	by	by	IN
18637	19409	32	the	the	DT
18637	19409	33	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19409	34	can	can	MD
18637	19409	35	not	not	RB
18637	19409	36	be	be	VB
18637	19409	37	found	find	VBN
18637	19409	38	within	within	IN
18637	19409	39	the	the	DT
18637	19409	40	State	State	NNP
18637	19409	41	,	,	,
18637	19409	42	the	the	DT
18637	19409	43	attachment	attachment	NN
18637	19409	44	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19409	45	are	be	VBP
18637	19409	46	,	,	,
18637	19409	47	of	of	IN
18637	19409	48	course	course	NN
18637	19409	49	,	,	,
18637	19409	50	summarily	summarily	RB
18637	19409	51	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	19409	52	.	.	.
18637	19410	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19410	2	728	728	CD
18637	19410	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19410	4	Actions	Actions	NNPS
18637	19410	5	in	in	IN
18637	19410	6	Rem	Rem	NNP
18637	19410	7	--	--	:
18637	19410	8	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19410	9	,	,	,
18637	19410	10	Estates	Estates	NNPS
18637	19410	11	,	,	,
18637	19410	12	Trusts	Trusts	NNPS
18637	19410	13	,	,	,
18637	19410	14	Etc.--Probate	etc.--probate	VB
18637	19410	15	administration	administration	NN
18637	19410	16	,	,	,
18637	19410	17	being	be	VBG
18637	19410	18	in	in	IN
18637	19410	19	the	the	DT
18637	19410	20	nature	nature	NN
18637	19410	21	of	of	IN
18637	19410	22	a	a	DT
18637	19410	23	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19410	24	_	_	NNP
18637	19410	25	in	in	IN
18637	19410	26	rem	rem	NNP
18637	19410	27	_	_	NNP
18637	19410	28	,	,	,
18637	19410	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	19410	30	one	one	CD
18637	19410	31	to	to	TO
18637	19410	32	which	which	WDT
18637	19410	33	all	all	PDT
18637	19410	34	the	the	DT
18637	19410	35	world	world	NN
18637	19410	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	19410	37	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19410	38	with	with	IN
18637	19410	39	notice	notice	NN
18637	19410	40	.	.	.
18637	19411	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19411	2	729	729	CD
18637	19411	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19411	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19411	5	,	,	,
18637	19411	6	in	in	IN
18637	19411	7	a	a	DT
18637	19411	8	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19411	9	against	against	IN
18637	19411	10	an	an	DT
18637	19411	11	estate	estate	NN
18637	19411	12	involving	involve	VBG
18637	19411	13	a	a	DT
18637	19411	14	suit	suit	NN
18637	19411	15	against	against	IN
18637	19411	16	an	an	DT
18637	19411	17	administratrix	administratrix	NN
18637	19411	18	to	to	TO
18637	19411	19	foreclose	foreclose	VB
18637	19411	20	a	a	DT
18637	19411	21	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	19411	22	executed	execute	VBN
18637	19411	23	by	by	IN
18637	19411	24	the	the	DT
18637	19411	25	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19411	26	,	,	,
18637	19411	27	the	the	DT
18637	19411	28	heir	heir	NN
18637	19411	29	,	,	,
18637	19411	30	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19411	31	that	that	IN
18637	19411	32	the	the	DT
18637	19411	33	suit	suit	NN
18637	19411	34	presents	present	VBZ
18637	19411	35	an	an	DT
18637	19411	36	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	19411	37	claim	claim	NN
18637	19411	38	the	the	DT
18637	19411	39	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	19411	40	of	of	IN
18637	19411	41	which	which	WDT
18637	19411	42	may	may	MD
18637	19411	43	be	be	VB
18637	19411	44	destructive	destructive	JJ
18637	19411	45	of	of	IN
18637	19411	46	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19411	47	title	title	NN
18637	19411	48	to	to	TO
18637	19411	49	land	land	VB
18637	19411	50	deriving	derive	VBG
18637	19411	51	from	from	IN
18637	19411	52	the	the	DT
18637	19411	53	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19411	54	,	,	,
18637	19411	55	may	may	MD
18637	19411	56	properly	properly	RB
18637	19411	57	be	be	VB
18637	19411	58	represented	represent	VBN
18637	19411	59	by	by	IN
18637	19411	60	the	the	DT
18637	19411	61	administratrix	administratrix	NN
18637	19411	62	and	and	CC
18637	19411	63	is	be	VBZ
18637	19411	64	not	not	RB
18637	19411	65	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19411	66	to	to	IN
18637	19411	67	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19411	68	notification	notification	NN
18637	19411	69	or	or	CC
18637	19411	70	summons	summon	NNS
18637	19411	71	.	.	.
18637	19412	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19412	2	730	730	CD
18637	19412	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19412	4	For	for	IN
18637	19412	5	like	like	JJ
18637	19412	6	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	19412	7	,	,	,
18637	19412	8	a	a	DT
18637	19412	9	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	19412	10	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19412	11	whereunder	whereunder	NN
18637	19412	12	a	a	DT
18637	19412	13	special	special	JJ
18637	19412	14	administrator	administrator	NN
18637	19412	15	,	,	,
18637	19412	16	having	have	VBG
18637	19412	17	charge	charge	NN
18637	19412	18	of	of	IN
18637	19412	19	an	an	DT
18637	19412	20	estate	estate	NN
18637	19412	21	pending	pende	VBG
18637	19412	22	a	a	DT
18637	19412	23	contest	contest	NN
18637	19412	24	as	as	IN
18637	19412	25	to	to	IN
18637	19412	26	the	the	DT
18637	19412	27	validity	validity	NN
18637	19412	28	of	of	IN
18637	19412	29	the	the	DT
18637	19412	30	will	will	NN
18637	19412	31	,	,	,
18637	19412	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	19412	33	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	19412	34	to	to	TO
18637	19412	35	have	have	VB
18637	19412	36	a	a	DT
18637	19412	37	final	final	JJ
18637	19412	38	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	19412	39	of	of	IN
18637	19412	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19412	41	accounts	account	NNS
18637	19412	42	without	without	IN
18637	19412	43	notice	notice	NN
18637	19412	44	to	to	IN
18637	19412	45	the	the	DT
18637	19412	46	distributees	distributee	NNS
18637	19412	47	,	,	,
18637	19412	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	19412	49	not	not	RB
18637	19412	50	violative	violative	JJ
18637	19412	51	of	of	IN
18637	19412	52	due	due	JJ
18637	19412	53	process	process	NN
18637	19412	54	.	.	.
18637	19413	1	The	the	DT
18637	19413	2	executor	executor	NN
18637	19413	3	,	,	,
18637	19413	4	or	or	CC
18637	19413	5	administrator	administrator	NN
18637	19413	6	c.t.a	c.t.a	NNP
18637	19413	7	.	.	NNP
18637	19413	8	,	,	,
18637	19413	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	19413	10	an	an	DT
18637	19413	11	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19413	12	to	to	TO
18637	19413	13	contest	contest	VB
18637	19413	14	the	the	DT
18637	19413	15	final	final	JJ
18637	19413	16	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	19413	17	of	of	IN
18637	19413	18	the	the	DT
18637	19413	19	special	special	JJ
18637	19413	20	administrator	administrator	NN
18637	19413	21	before	before	IN
18637	19413	22	giving	give	VBG
18637	19413	23	the	the	DT
18637	19413	24	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19413	25	an	an	DT
18637	19413	26	acquittance	acquittance	NN
18637	19413	27	;	;	:
18637	19413	28	and	and	CC
18637	19413	29	since	since	IN
18637	19413	30	the	the	DT
18637	19413	31	former	former	JJ
18637	19413	32	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	19413	33	all	all	DT
18637	19413	34	claiming	claim	VBG
18637	19413	35	under	under	IN
18637	19413	36	the	the	DT
18637	19413	37	will	will	NN
18637	19413	38	,	,	,
18637	19413	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19413	40	can	can	MD
18637	19413	41	not	not	RB
18637	19413	42	be	be	VB
18637	19413	43	said	say	VBN
18637	19413	44	the	the	DT
18637	19413	45	absence	absence	NN
18637	19413	46	of	of	IN
18637	19413	47	notice	notice	NN
18637	19413	48	to	to	IN
18637	19413	49	the	the	DT
18637	19413	50	distributees	distributee	NNS
18637	19413	51	of	of	IN
18637	19413	52	the	the	DT
18637	19413	53	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	19413	54	deprives	deprive	VBZ
18637	19413	55	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19413	56	of	of	IN
18637	19413	57	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19413	58	rights	right	NNS
18637	19413	59	without	without	IN
18637	19413	60	due	due	JJ
18637	19413	61	process	process	NN
18637	19413	62	of	of	IN
18637	19413	63	law	law	NN
18637	19413	64	.	.	.
18637	19414	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19414	2	731	731	CD
18637	19414	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19414	4	In	in	IN
18637	19414	5	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	19414	6	to	to	TO
18637	19414	7	determine	determine	VB
18637	19414	8	succession	succession	NN
18637	19414	9	to	to	IN
18637	19414	10	property	property	NN
18637	19414	11	by	by	IN
18637	19414	12	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19414	13	in	in	IN
18637	19414	14	escheat	escheat	NN
18637	19414	15	,	,	,
18637	19414	16	due	due	JJ
18637	19414	17	process	process	NN
18637	19414	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	19414	19	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	19414	20	by	by	IN
18637	19414	21	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19414	22	service	service	NN
18637	19414	23	of	of	IN
18637	19414	24	summons	summon	NNS
18637	19414	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	19414	26	all	all	DT
18637	19414	27	known	know	VBN
18637	19414	28	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	19414	29	and	and	CC
18637	19414	30	constructive	constructive	JJ
18637	19414	31	notice	notice	NN
18637	19414	32	by	by	IN
18637	19414	33	publication	publication	NN
18637	19414	34	to	to	IN
18637	19414	35	all	all	DT
18637	19414	36	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	19414	37	who	who	WP
18637	19414	38	are	be	VBP
18637	19414	39	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	19414	40	.	.	.
18637	19415	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19415	2	732	732	CD
18637	19415	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19415	4	Whether	whether	IN
18637	19415	5	a	a	DT
18637	19415	6	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19415	7	by	by	IN
18637	19415	8	the	the	DT
18637	19415	9	State	State	NNP
18637	19415	10	to	to	TO
18637	19415	11	compel	compel	VB
18637	19415	12	a	a	DT
18637	19415	13	bank	bank	NN
18637	19415	14	to	to	TO
18637	19415	15	turn	turn	VB
18637	19415	16	over	over	RP
18637	19415	17	to	to	IN
18637	19415	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19415	19	unclaimed	unclaimed	JJ
18637	19415	20	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	19415	21	in	in	IN
18637	19415	22	_	_	NNP
18637	19415	23	quasi	quasi	NNP
18637	19415	24	in	in	IN
18637	19415	25	rem	rem	NNP
18637	19415	26	_	_	NNP
18637	19415	27	or	or	CC
18637	19415	28	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	19415	29	_	_	NNP
18637	19415	30	in	in	IN
18637	19415	31	rem	rem	NNP
18637	19415	32	_	_	NNP
18637	19415	33	,	,	,
18637	19415	34	the	the	DT
18637	19415	35	essentials	essential	NNS
18637	19415	36	of	of	IN
18637	19415	37	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19415	38	over	over	IN
18637	19415	39	the	the	DT
18637	19415	40	deposit	deposit	NN
18637	19415	41	are	be	VBP
18637	19415	42	that	that	IN
18637	19415	43	there	there	EX
18637	19415	44	be	be	VB
18637	19415	45	a	a	DT
18637	19415	46	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	19415	47	of	of	IN
18637	19415	48	the	the	DT
18637	19415	49	_	_	NNP
18637	19415	50	res	res	NNP
18637	19415	51	_	_	NNP
18637	19415	52	at	at	IN
18637	19415	53	the	the	DT
18637	19415	54	commencement	commencement	NN
18637	19415	55	of	of	IN
18637	19415	56	the	the	DT
18637	19415	57	suit	suit	NN
18637	19415	58	and	and	CC
18637	19415	59	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19415	60	notice	notice	NN
18637	19415	61	and	and	CC
18637	19415	62	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19415	63	to	to	TO
18637	19415	64	be	be	VB
18637	19415	65	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19415	66	.	.	.
18637	19416	1	These	these	DT
18637	19416	2	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	19416	3	are	be	VBP
18637	19416	4	met	meet	VBN
18637	19416	5	by	by	IN
18637	19416	6	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19416	7	service	service	NN
18637	19416	8	on	on	IN
18637	19416	9	the	the	DT
18637	19416	10	bank	bank	NN
18637	19416	11	and	and	CC
18637	19416	12	publication	publication	NN
18637	19416	13	of	of	IN
18637	19416	14	summons	summon	NNS
18637	19416	15	to	to	IN
18637	19416	16	depositors	depositor	NNS
18637	19416	17	and	and	CC
18637	19416	18	of	of	IN
18637	19416	19	notice	notice	NN
18637	19416	20	to	to	IN
18637	19416	21	all	all	DT
18637	19416	22	other	other	JJ
18637	19416	23	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	19416	24	.	.	.
18637	19417	1	The	the	DT
18637	19417	2	fact	fact	NN
18637	19417	3	that	that	IN
18637	19417	4	no	no	DT
18637	19417	5	affidavit	affidavit	NN
18637	19417	6	of	of	IN
18637	19417	7	impracticability	impracticability	NN
18637	19417	8	of	of	IN
18637	19417	9	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19417	10	service	service	NN
18637	19417	11	on	on	IN
18637	19417	12	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	19417	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	19417	14	required	require	VBN
18637	19417	15	before	before	IN
18637	19417	16	publication	publication	NN
18637	19417	17	of	of	IN
18637	19417	18	such	such	JJ
18637	19417	19	notices	notice	NNS
18637	19417	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	19417	21	not	not	RB
18637	19417	22	render	render	VB
18637	19417	23	the	the	DT
18637	19417	24	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19417	25	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19417	26	inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	19417	27	as	as	IN
18637	19417	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19417	29	are	be	VBP
18637	19417	30	used	use	VBN
18637	19417	31	only	only	RB
18637	19417	32	in	in	IN
18637	19417	33	cases	case	NNS
18637	19417	34	where	where	WRB
18637	19417	35	the	the	DT
18637	19417	36	depositor	depositor	NN
18637	19417	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	19417	38	not	not	RB
18637	19417	39	known	know	VBN
18637	19417	40	to	to	IN
18637	19417	41	the	the	DT
18637	19417	42	bank	bank	NN
18637	19417	43	officers	officer	NNS
18637	19417	44	to	to	TO
18637	19417	45	be	be	VB
18637	19417	46	alive	alive	JJ
18637	19417	47	.	.	.
18637	19418	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19418	2	733	733	CD
18637	19418	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19418	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19418	5	,	,	,
18637	19418	6	a	a	DT
18637	19418	7	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	19418	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	19418	9	requiring	require	VBG
18637	19418	10	banks	bank	NNS
18637	19418	11	to	to	TO
18637	19418	12	turn	turn	VB
18637	19418	13	over	over	RP
18637	19418	14	to	to	IN
18637	19418	15	the	the	DT
18637	19418	16	State	state	NN
18637	19418	17	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	19418	18	long	long	JJ
18637	19418	19	inactive	inactive	NN
18637	19418	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	19418	21	not	not	RB
18637	19418	22	violative	violative	JJ
18637	19418	23	of	of	IN
18637	19418	24	due	due	JJ
18637	19418	25	process	process	NN
18637	19418	26	where	where	WRB
18637	19418	27	,	,	,
18637	19418	28	although	although	IN
18637	19418	29	the	the	DT
18637	19418	30	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	19418	31	are	be	VBP
18637	19418	32	taken	take	VBN
18637	19418	33	over	over	RP
18637	19418	34	upon	upon	IN
18637	19418	35	published	publish	VBN
18637	19418	36	notice	notice	NN
18637	19418	37	only	only	RB
18637	19418	38	,	,	,
18637	19418	39	without	without	IN
18637	19418	40	any	any	DT
18637	19418	41	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19418	42	decree	decree	NN
18637	19418	43	of	of	IN
18637	19418	44	actual	actual	JJ
18637	19418	45	abandonment	abandonment	NN
18637	19418	46	,	,	,
18637	19418	47	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19418	48	are	be	VBP
18637	19418	49	to	to	TO
18637	19418	50	be	be	VB
18637	19418	51	held	hold	VBN
18637	19418	52	by	by	IN
18637	19418	53	the	the	DT
18637	19418	54	State	State	NNP
18637	19418	55	for	for	IN
18637	19418	56	the	the	DT
18637	19418	57	depositor	depositor	NN
18637	19418	58	until	until	IN
18637	19418	59	such	such	JJ
18637	19418	60	determination	determination	NN
18637	19418	61	and	and	CC
18637	19418	62	for	for	IN
18637	19418	63	five	five	CD
18637	19418	64	years	year	NNS
18637	19418	65	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	19418	66	.	.	.
18637	19419	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19419	2	734	734	CD
18637	19419	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19419	4	However	however	RB
18637	19419	5	,	,	,
18637	19419	6	a	a	DT
18637	19419	7	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19419	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	19419	9	at	at	IN
18637	19419	10	least	least	JJS
18637	19419	11	partly	partly	RB
18637	19419	12	defective	defective	JJ
18637	19419	13	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	19419	14	a	a	DT
18637	19419	15	bank	bank	NN
18637	19419	16	managing	manage	VBG
18637	19419	17	a	a	DT
18637	19419	18	common	common	JJ
18637	19419	19	trust	trust	NN
18637	19419	20	fund	fund	NN
18637	19419	21	in	in	IN
18637	19419	22	favor	favor	NN
18637	19419	23	of	of	IN
18637	19419	24	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19419	25	as	as	RB
18637	19419	26	well	well	RB
18637	19419	27	as	as	IN
18637	19419	28	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19419	29	beneficiaries	beneficiary	NNS
18637	19419	30	may	may	MD
18637	19419	31	,	,	,
18637	19419	32	by	by	IN
18637	19419	33	a	a	DT
18637	19419	34	petition	petition	NN
18637	19419	35	,	,	,
18637	19419	36	the	the	DT
18637	19419	37	only	only	JJ
18637	19419	38	notice	notice	NN
18637	19419	39	of	of	IN
18637	19419	40	which	which	WDT
18637	19419	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	19419	42	by	by	IN
18637	19419	43	publication	publication	NN
18637	19419	44	in	in	IN
18637	19419	45	a	a	DT
18637	19419	46	local	local	JJ
18637	19419	47	paper	paper	NN
18637	19419	48	,	,	,
18637	19419	49	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	19419	50	a	a	DT
18637	19419	51	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19419	52	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	19419	53	of	of	IN
18637	19419	54	accounts	account	NNS
18637	19419	55	which	which	WDT
18637	19419	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	19419	57	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	19419	58	on	on	IN
18637	19419	59	all	all	DT
18637	19419	60	having	have	VBG
18637	19419	61	an	an	DT
18637	19419	62	interest	interest	NN
18637	19419	63	in	in	IN
18637	19419	64	the	the	DT
18637	19419	65	common	common	JJ
18637	19419	66	fund	fund	NN
18637	19419	67	or	or	CC
18637	19419	68	in	in	IN
18637	19419	69	any	any	DT
18637	19419	70	participating	participate	VBG
18637	19419	71	trust	trust	NN
18637	19419	72	.	.	.
18637	19420	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	19420	2	notice	notice	NN
18637	19420	3	by	by	IN
18637	19420	4	publication	publication	NN
18637	19420	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19420	6	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19420	7	as	as	IN
18637	19420	8	to	to	IN
18637	19420	9	beneficiaries	beneficiary	NNS
18637	19420	10	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19420	11	interests	interest	NNS
18637	19420	12	or	or	CC
18637	19420	13	addresses	address	NNS
18637	19420	14	are	be	VBP
18637	19420	15	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	19420	16	to	to	IN
18637	19420	17	the	the	DT
18637	19420	18	bank	bank	NN
18637	19420	19	,	,	,
18637	19420	20	since	since	IN
18637	19420	21	there	there	EX
18637	19420	22	are	be	VBP
18637	19420	23	no	no	DT
18637	19420	24	other	other	JJ
18637	19420	25	more	more	RBR
18637	19420	26	practicable	practicable	JJ
18637	19420	27	means	mean	NNS
18637	19420	28	of	of	IN
18637	19420	29	giving	give	VBG
18637	19420	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19420	31	notice	notice	NN
18637	19420	32	;	;	:
18637	19420	33	but	but	CC
18637	19420	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	19420	35	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
18637	19420	36	as	as	IN
18637	19420	37	a	a	DT
18637	19420	38	basis	basis	NN
18637	19420	39	for	for	IN
18637	19420	40	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	19420	41	depriving	depriving	NN
18637	19420	42	of	of	IN
18637	19420	43	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	19420	44	rights	right	NNS
18637	19420	45	persons	person	NNS
18637	19420	46	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19420	47	whereabouts	whereabout	NNS
18637	19420	48	are	be	VBP
18637	19420	49	known	know	VBN
18637	19420	50	,	,	,
18637	19420	51	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	19420	52	as	as	IN
18637	19420	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19420	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	19420	55	feasible	feasible	JJ
18637	19420	56	to	to	TO
18637	19420	57	make	make	VB
18637	19420	58	serious	serious	JJ
18637	19420	59	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	19420	60	to	to	TO
18637	19420	61	notify	notify	VB
18637	19420	62	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19420	63	at	at	IN
18637	19420	64	least	least	RBS
18637	19420	65	by	by	IN
18637	19420	66	mail	mail	NN
18637	19420	67	to	to	IN
18637	19420	68	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19420	69	addresses	address	NNS
18637	19420	70	on	on	IN
18637	19420	71	record	record	NN
18637	19420	72	with	with	IN
18637	19420	73	said	say	VBD
18637	19420	74	bank	bank	NN
18637	19420	75	.	.	.
18637	19421	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19421	2	735	735	CD
18637	19421	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19421	4	On	on	IN
18637	19421	5	the	the	DT
18637	19421	6	other	other	JJ
18637	19421	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	19421	8	,	,	,
18637	19421	9	failure	failure	NN
18637	19421	10	to	to	TO
18637	19421	11	make	make	VB
18637	19421	12	any	any	DT
18637	19421	13	provision	provision	NN
18637	19421	14	for	for	IN
18637	19421	15	notice	notice	NN
18637	19421	16	to	to	IN
18637	19421	17	majority	majority	NN
18637	19421	18	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	19421	19	of	of	IN
18637	19421	20	a	a	DT
18637	19421	21	suit	suit	NN
18637	19421	22	by	by	IN
18637	19421	23	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	19421	24	shareholders	shareholder	NNS
18637	19421	25	,	,	,
18637	19421	26	under	under	IN
18637	19421	27	a	a	DT
18637	19421	28	statute	statute	NN
18637	19421	29	which	which	WDT
18637	19421	30	provided	provide	VBD
18637	19421	31	that	that	IN
18637	19421	32	,	,	,
18637	19421	33	on	on	IN
18637	19421	34	a	a	DT
18637	19421	35	sale	sale	NN
18637	19421	36	or	or	CC
18637	19421	37	other	other	JJ
18637	19421	38	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	19421	39	of	of	IN
18637	19421	40	all	all	DT
18637	19421	41	or	or	CC
18637	19421	42	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	19421	43	all	all	DT
18637	19421	44	of	of	IN
18637	19421	45	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	19421	46	assets	asset	NNS
18637	19421	47	,	,	,
18637	19421	48	a	a	DT
18637	19421	49	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	19421	50	shareholder	shareholder	NN
18637	19421	51	shall	shall	MD
18637	19421	52	have	have	VB
18637	19421	53	the	the	DT
18637	19421	54	right	right	NN
18637	19421	55	,	,	,
18637	19421	56	after	after	IN
18637	19421	57	six	six	CD
18637	19421	58	months	month	NNS
18637	19421	59	,	,	,
18637	19421	60	to	to	TO
18637	19421	61	be	be	VB
18637	19421	62	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19421	63	the	the	DT
18637	19421	64	amount	amount	NN
18637	19421	65	demanded	demand	VBN
18637	19421	66	,	,	,
18637	19421	67	if	if	IN
18637	19421	68	the	the	DT
18637	19421	69	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19421	70	makes	make	VBZ
18637	19421	71	no	no	DT
18637	19421	72	counter	counter	NN
18637	19421	73	offer	offer	VB
18637	19421	74	or	or	CC
18637	19421	75	does	do	VBZ
18637	19421	76	not	not	RB
18637	19421	77	abandon	abandon	VB
18637	19421	78	the	the	DT
18637	19421	79	sale	sale	NN
18637	19421	80	,	,	,
18637	19421	81	does	do	VBZ
18637	19421	82	not	not	RB
18637	19421	83	deny	deny	VB
18637	19421	84	due	due	JJ
18637	19421	85	process	process	NN
18637	19421	86	;	;	:
18637	19421	87	for	for	IN
18637	19421	88	the	the	DT
18637	19421	89	majority	majority	NN
18637	19421	90	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	19421	91	are	be	VBP
18637	19421	92	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	19421	93	represented	represent	VBN
18637	19421	94	by	by	IN
18637	19421	95	the	the	DT
18637	19421	96	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19421	97	.	.	.
18637	19422	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19422	2	736	736	CD
18637	19422	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19422	4	Actions	Actions	NNPS
18637	19422	5	in	in	IN
18637	19422	6	Rem	Rem	NNP
18637	19422	7	--	--	:
18637	19422	8	Divorce	divorce	NN
18637	19422	9	Proceedings.--The	Proceedings.--The	NNP
18637	19422	10	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	19422	11	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	19422	12	for	for	IN
18637	19422	13	rendering	render	VBG
18637	19422	14	a	a	DT
18637	19422	15	valid	valid	JJ
18637	19422	16	decree	decree	NN
18637	19422	17	in	in	IN
18637	19422	18	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	19422	19	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19422	20	are	be	VBP
18637	19422	21	considered	consider	VBN
18637	19422	22	under	under	IN
18637	19422	23	the	the	DT
18637	19422	24	full	full	JJ
18637	19422	25	faith	faith	NN
18637	19422	26	and	and	CC
18637	19422	27	credit	credit	NN
18637	19422	28	clause	clause	NN
18637	19422	29	.	.	.
18637	19423	1	_	_	NNP
18637	19423	2	See	See	NNP
18637	19423	3	_	_	NNP
18637	19423	4	pp	pp	NNP
18637	19423	5	.	.	.
18637	19424	1	662	662	CD
18637	19424	2	-	-	SYM
18637	19424	3	670	670	CD
18637	19424	4	.	.	.
18637	19425	1	Misnomer	Misnomer	NNP
18637	19425	2	of	of	IN
18637	19425	3	Defendant	Defendant	NNP
18637	19425	4	--	--	:
18637	19425	5	False	False	NNP
18637	19425	6	Return	Return	NNP
18637	19425	7	,	,	,
18637	19425	8	Etc.--An	etc.--an	VB
18637	19425	9	unattainable	unattainable	JJ
18637	19425	10	standard	standard	NN
18637	19425	11	of	of	IN
18637	19425	12	accuracy	accuracy	NN
18637	19425	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	19425	14	not	not	RB
18637	19425	15	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19425	16	by	by	IN
18637	19425	17	the	the	DT
18637	19425	18	due	due	JJ
18637	19425	19	process	process	NN
18637	19425	20	clause	clause	NN
18637	19425	21	.	.	.
18637	19426	1	If	if	IN
18637	19426	2	a	a	DT
18637	19426	3	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19426	4	within	within	IN
18637	19426	5	the	the	DT
18637	19426	6	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19426	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19426	8	served	serve	VBN
18637	19426	9	personally	personally	RB
18637	19426	10	with	with	IN
18637	19426	11	process	process	NN
18637	19426	12	in	in	IN
18637	19426	13	which	which	WDT
18637	19426	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19426	15	name	name	NN
18637	19426	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	19426	17	misspelled	misspelled	JJ
18637	19426	18	,	,	,
18637	19426	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19426	20	can	can	MD
18637	19426	21	not	not	RB
18637	19426	22	safely	safely	RB
18637	19426	23	ignore	ignore	VB
18637	19426	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19426	25	on	on	IN
18637	19426	26	account	account	NN
18637	19426	27	of	of	IN
18637	19426	28	the	the	DT
18637	19426	29	misnomer	misnomer	NN
18637	19426	30	.	.	.
18637	19427	1	If	if	IN
18637	19427	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19427	3	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	19427	4	to	to	TO
18637	19427	5	appear	appear	VB
18637	19427	6	and	and	CC
18637	19427	7	plead	plead	VB
18637	19427	8	the	the	DT
18637	19427	9	misnomer	misnomer	NN
18637	19427	10	in	in	IN
18637	19427	11	abatement	abatement	NN
18637	19427	12	,	,	,
18637	19427	13	the	the	DT
18637	19427	14	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19427	15	binds	bind	VBZ
18637	19427	16	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19427	17	.	.	.
18637	19428	1	In	in	IN
18637	19428	2	a	a	DT
18637	19428	3	published	publish	VBN
18637	19428	4	notice	notice	NN
18637	19428	5	intended	intend	VBN
18637	19428	6	to	to	TO
18637	19428	7	reach	reach	VB
18637	19428	8	absent	absent	JJ
18637	19428	9	or	or	CC
18637	19428	10	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19428	11	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	19428	12	,	,	,
18637	19428	13	where	where	WRB
18637	19428	14	the	the	DT
18637	19428	15	name	name	NN
18637	19428	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	19428	17	a	a	DT
18637	19428	18	principal	principal	JJ
18637	19428	19	means	mean	NNS
18637	19428	20	of	of	IN
18637	19428	21	identifying	identify	VBG
18637	19428	22	the	the	DT
18637	19428	23	person	person	NN
18637	19428	24	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	19428	25	,	,	,
18637	19428	26	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	19428	27	different	different	JJ
18637	19428	28	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	19428	29	obtain	obtain	VBP
18637	19428	30	.	.	.
18637	19429	1	The	the	DT
18637	19429	2	general	general	JJ
18637	19429	3	rule	rule	NN
18637	19429	4	,	,	,
18637	19429	5	in	in	IN
18637	19429	6	case	case	NN
18637	19429	7	of	of	IN
18637	19429	8	constructive	constructive	JJ
18637	19429	9	service	service	NN
18637	19429	10	of	of	IN
18637	19429	11	process	process	NN
18637	19429	12	by	by	IN
18637	19429	13	publication	publication	NN
18637	19429	14	,	,	,
18637	19429	15	tends	tend	VBZ
18637	19429	16	to	to	IN
18637	19429	17	strictness	strictness	NN
18637	19429	18	.	.	.
18637	19430	1	However	however	RB
18637	19430	2	,	,	,
18637	19430	3	published	publish	VBN
18637	19430	4	notice	notice	NN
18637	19430	5	to	to	IN
18637	19430	6	"	"	``
18637	19430	7	Albert	Albert	NNP
18637	19430	8	Guilfuss	Guilfuss	NNP
18637	19430	9	,	,	,
18637	19430	10	Assignee	Assignee	NNP
18637	19430	11	,	,	,
18637	19430	12	"	"	''
18637	19430	13	in	in	IN
18637	19430	14	a	a	DT
18637	19430	15	suit	suit	NN
18637	19430	16	to	to	IN
18637	19430	17	partition	partition	NN
18637	19430	18	land	land	NN
18637	19430	19	,	,	,
18637	19430	20	was	be	VBD
18637	19430	21	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19430	22	to	to	TO
18637	19430	23	render	render	VB
18637	19430	24	a	a	DT
18637	19430	25	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19430	26	binding	bind	VBG
18637	19430	27	on	on	IN
18637	19430	28	"	"	``
18637	19430	29	Albert	Albert	NNP
18637	19430	30	B.	B.	NNP
18637	19430	31	Geilfuss	Geilfuss	NNP
18637	19430	32	,	,	,
18637	19430	33	Assignee	Assignee	NNP
18637	19430	34	,	,	,
18637	19430	35	"	"	''
18637	19430	36	the	the	DT
18637	19430	37	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19430	38	not	not	RB
18637	19430	39	having	have	VBG
18637	19430	40	appeared	appear	VBN
18637	19430	41	.	.	.
18637	19431	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19431	2	737	737	CD
18637	19431	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19431	4	Foreclosure	foreclosure	NN
18637	19431	5	of	of	IN
18637	19431	6	a	a	DT
18637	19431	7	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	19431	8	made	make	VBN
18637	19431	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	19431	10	process	process	NN
18637	19431	11	duly	duly	RB
18637	19431	12	issued	issue	VBN
18637	19431	13	but	but	CC
18637	19431	14	which	which	WDT
18637	19431	15	the	the	DT
18637	19431	16	sheriff	sheriff	NN
18637	19431	17	falsely	falsely	RB
18637	19431	18	returned	return	VBD
18637	19431	19	as	as	IN
18637	19431	20	having	have	VBG
18637	19431	21	been	be	VBN
18637	19431	22	duly	duly	RB
18637	19431	23	served	serve	VBN
18637	19431	24	,	,	,
18637	19431	25	and	and	CC
18637	19431	26	of	of	IN
18637	19431	27	which	which	WDT
18637	19431	28	the	the	DT
18637	19431	29	owner	owner	NN
18637	19431	30	had	have	VBD
18637	19431	31	no	no	DT
18637	19431	32	notice	notice	NN
18637	19431	33	,	,	,
18637	19431	34	does	do	VBZ
18637	19431	35	not	not	RB
18637	19431	36	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	19431	37	said	say	VBD
18637	19431	38	owner	owner	NN
18637	19431	39	of	of	IN
18637	19431	40	property	property	NN
18637	19431	41	without	without	IN
18637	19431	42	due	due	JJ
18637	19431	43	process	process	NN
18637	19431	44	of	of	IN
18637	19431	45	law	law	NN
18637	19431	46	.	.	.
18637	19432	1	A	a	DT
18637	19432	2	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	19432	3	of	of	IN
18637	19432	4	the	the	DT
18637	19432	5	land	land	NN
18637	19432	6	at	at	IN
18637	19432	7	the	the	DT
18637	19432	8	sheriff	sheriff	NN
18637	19432	9	's	's	POS
18637	19432	10	sale	sale	NN
18637	19432	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	19432	12	a	a	DT
18637	19432	13	right	right	NN
18637	19432	14	to	to	TO
18637	19432	15	rely	rely	VB
18637	19432	16	on	on	IN
18637	19432	17	such	such	JJ
18637	19432	18	return	return	NN
18637	19432	19	;	;	:
18637	19432	20	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	19432	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19432	22	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19432	23	could	could	MD
18637	19432	24	never	never	RB
18637	19432	25	be	be	VB
18637	19432	26	relied	rely	VBN
18637	19432	27	upon	upon	IN
18637	19432	28	.	.	.
18637	19433	1	The	the	DT
18637	19433	2	mortgagor	mortgagor	NN
18637	19433	3	must	must	MD
18637	19433	4	seek	seek	VB
18637	19433	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19433	6	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	19433	7	against	against	IN
18637	19433	8	the	the	DT
18637	19433	9	sheriff	sheriff	NN
18637	19433	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	19433	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19433	12	bond	bond	NN
18637	19433	13	.	.	.
18637	19434	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19434	2	738	738	CD
18637	19434	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19434	4	Notice	notice	NN
18637	19434	5	and	and	CC
18637	19434	6	Hearing	Hearing	NNP
18637	19434	7	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	19434	8	Proceedings.--While	proceedings.--while	NN
18637	19434	9	due	due	JJ
18637	19434	10	notice	notice	NN
18637	19434	11	and	and	CC
18637	19434	12	a	a	DT
18637	19434	13	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19434	14	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19434	15	to	to	TO
18637	19434	16	be	be	VB
18637	19434	17	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19434	18	to	to	TO
18637	19434	19	present	present	VB
18637	19434	20	one	one	PRP
18637	19434	21	's	's	POS
18637	19434	22	claim	claim	NN
18637	19434	23	or	or	CC
18637	19434	24	defense	defense	NN
18637	19434	25	have	have	VBP
18637	19434	26	been	be	VBN
18637	19434	27	declared	declare	VBN
18637	19434	28	to	to	TO
18637	19434	29	be	be	VB
18637	19434	30	two	two	CD
18637	19434	31	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19434	32	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19434	33	almost	almost	RB
18637	19434	34	universally	universally	RB
18637	19434	35	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	19434	36	in	in	IN
18637	19434	37	all	all	DT
18637	19434	38	systems	system	NNS
18637	19434	39	of	of	IN
18637	19434	40	law	law	NN
18637	19434	41	established	establish	VBN
18637	19434	42	by	by	IN
18637	19434	43	civilized	civilized	JJ
18637	19434	44	countries,[739	countries,[739	NN
18637	19434	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19434	46	there	there	EX
18637	19434	47	are	be	VBP
18637	19434	48	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19434	49	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19434	50	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	19434	51	for	for	IN
18637	19434	52	the	the	DT
18637	19434	53	determination	determination	NN
18637	19434	54	of	of	IN
18637	19434	55	various	various	JJ
18637	19434	56	rights	right	NNS
18637	19434	57	in	in	IN
18637	19434	58	which	which	WDT
18637	19434	59	the	the	DT
18637	19434	60	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	19434	61	of	of	IN
18637	19434	62	these	these	DT
18637	19434	63	two	two	CD
18637	19434	64	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	19434	65	has	have	VBZ
18637	19434	66	not	not	RB
18637	19434	67	been	be	VBN
18637	19434	68	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19434	69	to	to	TO
18637	19434	70	be	be	VB
18637	19434	71	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	19434	72	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19434	73	.	.	.
18637	19435	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19435	2	the	the	DT
18637	19435	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19435	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	19435	5	not	not	RB
18637	19435	6	require	require	VB
18637	19435	7	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19435	8	assemblies	assembly	NNS
18637	19435	9	to	to	TO
18637	19435	10	discharge	discharge	VB
18637	19435	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19435	12	functions	function	NNS
18637	19435	13	in	in	IN
18637	19435	14	town	town	NN
18637	19435	15	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	19435	16	style	style	NN
18637	19435	17	;	;	:
18637	19435	18	and	and	CC
18637	19435	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19435	20	would	would	MD
18637	19435	21	be	be	VB
18637	19435	22	manifestly	manifestly	RB
18637	19435	23	impracticable	impracticable	JJ
18637	19435	24	to	to	TO
18637	19435	25	accord	accord	VB
18637	19435	26	every	every	DT
18637	19435	27	one	one	NN
18637	19435	28	affected	affect	VBN
18637	19435	29	by	by	IN
18637	19435	30	a	a	DT
18637	19435	31	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	19435	32	rule	rule	NN
18637	19435	33	of	of	IN
18637	19435	34	conduct	conduct	VB
18637	19435	35	a	a	DT
18637	19435	36	voice	voice	NN
18637	19435	37	in	in	IN
18637	19435	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19435	39	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	19435	40	.	.	.
18637	19436	1	Advanced	advanced	JJ
18637	19436	2	notice	notice	NN
18637	19436	3	of	of	IN
18637	19436	4	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19436	5	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19436	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19436	7	not	not	RB
18637	19436	8	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19436	9	to	to	TO
18637	19436	10	due	due	JJ
18637	19436	11	process	process	NN
18637	19436	12	of	of	IN
18637	19436	13	law	law	NN
18637	19436	14	;	;	:
18637	19436	15	nor	nor	CC
18637	19436	16	need	need	VBP
18637	19436	17	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19436	18	bodies	body	NNS
18637	19436	19	preface	preface	VBP
18637	19436	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19436	21	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	19436	22	of	of	IN
18637	19436	23	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19436	24	by	by	IN
18637	19436	25	first	first	NNP
18637	19436	26	holding	hold	VBG
18637	19436	27	committee	committee	NN
18637	19436	28	hearings	hearing	NNS
18637	19436	29	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	19436	30	.	.	.
18637	19437	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19437	2	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	19437	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	19437	4	that	that	IN
18637	19437	5	persons	person	NNS
18637	19437	6	adversely	adversely	RB
18637	19437	7	affected	affect	VBN
18637	19437	8	by	by	IN
18637	19437	9	a	a	DT
18637	19437	10	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19437	11	law	law	NN
18637	19437	12	can	can	MD
18637	19437	13	never	never	RB
18637	19437	14	challenge	challenge	VB
18637	19437	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19437	16	validity	validity	NN
18637	19437	17	on	on	IN
18637	19437	18	the	the	DT
18637	19437	19	ground	ground	NN
18637	19437	20	that	that	IN
18637	19437	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19437	22	were	be	VBD
18637	19437	23	never	never	RB
18637	19437	24	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19437	25	on	on	IN
18637	19437	26	the	the	DT
18637	19437	27	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	19437	28	or	or	CC
18637	19437	29	justice	justice	NN
18637	19437	30	of	of	IN
18637	19437	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19437	32	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	19437	33	.	.	.
18637	19438	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19438	2	740	740	CD
18637	19438	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19438	4	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	19438	5	Proceedings.--To	Proceedings.--To	NNS
18637	19438	6	what	what	WDT
18637	19438	7	extent	extent	NN
18637	19438	8	notice	notice	NN
18637	19438	9	and	and	CC
18637	19438	10	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19438	11	are	be	VBP
18637	19438	12	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19438	13	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19438	14	to	to	IN
18637	19438	15	due	due	JJ
18637	19438	16	process	process	NN
18637	19438	17	in	in	IN
18637	19438	18	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	19438	19	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19438	20	,	,	,
18637	19438	21	encompassing	encompass	VBG
18637	19438	22	as	as	IN
18637	19438	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19438	24	do	do	VBP
18637	19438	25	the	the	DT
18637	19438	26	formulation	formulation	NN
18637	19438	27	and	and	CC
18637	19438	28	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	19438	29	of	of	IN
18637	19438	30	general	general	JJ
18637	19438	31	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	19438	32	,	,	,
18637	19438	33	the	the	DT
18637	19438	34	determination	determination	NN
18637	19438	35	of	of	IN
18637	19438	36	the	the	DT
18637	19438	37	existence	existence	NN
18637	19438	38	of	of	IN
18637	19438	39	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19438	40	which	which	WDT
18637	19438	41	have	have	VBP
18637	19438	42	the	the	DT
18637	19438	43	effect	effect	NN
18637	19438	44	of	of	IN
18637	19438	45	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	19438	46	such	such	JJ
18637	19438	47	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	19438	48	into	into	IN
18637	19438	49	operation	operation	NN
18637	19438	50	,	,	,
18637	19438	51	and	and	CC
18637	19438	52	the	the	DT
18637	19438	53	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	19438	54	of	of	IN
18637	19438	55	orders	order	NNS
18637	19438	56	of	of	IN
18637	19438	57	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19438	58	,	,	,
18637	19438	59	limited	limited	JJ
18637	19438	60	application	application	NN
18637	19438	61	,	,	,
18637	19438	62	entails	entail	VBZ
18637	19438	63	a	a	DT
18637	19438	64	balancing	balancing	NN
18637	19438	65	of	of	IN
18637	19438	66	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	19438	67	as	as	IN
18637	19438	68	to	to	IN
18637	19438	69	the	the	DT
18637	19438	70	desirability	desirability	NN
18637	19438	71	of	of	IN
18637	19438	72	speed	speed	NN
18637	19438	73	in	in	IN
18637	19438	74	law	law	NN
18637	19438	75	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	19438	76	and	and	CC
18637	19438	77	protection	protection	NN
18637	19438	78	of	of	IN
18637	19438	79	individual	individual	JJ
18637	19438	80	interests	interest	NNS
18637	19438	81	.	.	.
18637	19439	1	When	when	WRB
18637	19439	2	an	an	DT
18637	19439	3	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	19439	4	agency	agency	NN
18637	19439	5	engages	engage	VBZ
18637	19439	6	in	in	IN
18637	19439	7	a	a	DT
18637	19439	8	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19439	9	function	function	NN
18637	19439	10	,	,	,
18637	19439	11	as	as	IN
18637	19439	12	,	,	,
18637	19439	13	for	for	IN
18637	19439	14	example	example	NN
18637	19439	15	,	,	,
18637	19439	16	when	when	WRB
18637	19439	17	,	,	,
18637	19439	18	in	in	IN
18637	19439	19	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	19439	20	of	of	IN
18637	19439	21	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	19439	22	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	19439	23	,	,	,
18637	19439	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19439	25	drafts	draft	VBZ
18637	19439	26	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	19439	27	of	of	IN
18637	19439	28	general	general	JJ
18637	19439	29	application	application	NN
18637	19439	30	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	19439	31	an	an	DT
18637	19439	32	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	19439	33	number	number	NN
18637	19439	34	of	of	IN
18637	19439	35	people	people	NNS
18637	19439	36	,	,	,
18637	19439	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19439	38	need	need	VBP
18637	19439	39	not	not	RB
18637	19439	40	,	,	,
18637	19439	41	any	any	DT
18637	19439	42	more	more	RBR
18637	19439	43	than	than	IN
18637	19439	44	does	do	VBZ
18637	19439	45	a	a	DT
18637	19439	46	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19439	47	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	19439	48	,	,	,
18637	19439	49	afford	afford	VB
18637	19439	50	a	a	DT
18637	19439	51	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19439	52	prior	prior	RB
18637	19439	53	to	to	IN
18637	19439	54	promulgation	promulgation	NN
18637	19439	55	.	.	.
18637	19440	1	On	on	IN
18637	19440	2	the	the	DT
18637	19440	3	other	other	JJ
18637	19440	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	19440	5	,	,	,
18637	19440	6	if	if	IN
18637	19440	7	a	a	DT
18637	19440	8	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	19440	9	,	,	,
18637	19440	10	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	19440	11	described	describe	VBN
18637	19440	12	as	as	IN
18637	19440	13	an	an	DT
18637	19440	14	order	order	NN
18637	19440	15	or	or	CC
18637	19440	16	action	action	NN
18637	19440	17	of	of	IN
18637	19440	18	an	an	DT
18637	19440	19	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	19440	20	body	body	NN
18637	19440	21	,	,	,
18637	19440	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	19440	23	of	of	IN
18637	19440	24	limited	limited	JJ
18637	19440	25	application	application	NN
18637	19440	26	;	;	:
18637	19440	27	that	that	RB
18637	19440	28	is	is	RB
18637	19440	29	,	,	,
18637	19440	30	affects	affect	VBZ
18637	19440	31	the	the	DT
18637	19440	32	property	property	NN
18637	19440	33	or	or	CC
18637	19440	34	interests	interest	NNS
18637	19440	35	of	of	IN
18637	19440	36	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19440	37	,	,	,
18637	19440	38	named	name	VBN
18637	19440	39	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	19440	40	,	,	,
18637	19440	41	or	or	CC
18637	19440	42	a	a	DT
18637	19440	43	relatively	relatively	RB
18637	19440	44	small	small	JJ
18637	19440	45	number	number	NN
18637	19440	46	of	of	IN
18637	19440	47	people	people	NNS
18637	19440	48	readily	readily	RB
18637	19440	49	identifiable	identifiable	JJ
18637	19440	50	by	by	IN
18637	19440	51	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19440	52	relation	relation	NN
18637	19440	53	to	to	IN
18637	19440	54	the	the	DT
18637	19440	55	property	property	NN
18637	19440	56	or	or	CC
18637	19440	57	interests	interest	NNS
18637	19440	58	affected	affect	VBN
18637	19440	59	,	,	,
18637	19440	60	the	the	DT
18637	19440	61	question	question	NN
18637	19440	62	whether	whether	IN
18637	19440	63	notice	notice	NN
18637	19440	64	and	and	CC
18637	19440	65	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19440	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	19440	67	prerequisite	prerequisite	JJ
18637	19440	68	and	and	CC
18637	19440	69	,	,	,
18637	19440	70	if	if	IN
18637	19440	71	so	so	RB
18637	19440	72	,	,	,
18637	19440	73	whether	whether	IN
18637	19440	74	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19440	75	must	must	MD
18637	19440	76	precede	precede	VB
18637	19440	77	such	such	JJ
18637	19440	78	action	action	NN
18637	19440	79	,	,	,
18637	19440	80	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	19440	81	a	a	DT
18637	19440	82	matter	matter	NN
18637	19440	83	of	of	IN
18637	19440	84	greater	great	JJR
18637	19440	85	urgency	urgency	NN
18637	19440	86	.	.	.
18637	19441	1	But	but	CC
18637	19441	2	while	while	IN
18637	19441	3	a	a	DT
18637	19441	4	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	19441	5	readily	readily	RB
18637	19441	6	may	may	MD
18637	19441	7	be	be	VB
18637	19441	8	made	make	VBN
18637	19441	9	,	,	,
18637	19441	10	for	for	IN
18637	19441	11	example	example	NN
18637	19441	12	,	,	,
18637	19441	13	between	between	IN
18637	19441	14	a	a	DT
18637	19441	15	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	19441	16	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	19441	17	a	a	DT
18637	19441	18	schedule	schedule	NN
18637	19441	19	of	of	IN
18637	19441	20	rates	rate	NNS
18637	19441	21	for	for	IN
18637	19441	22	all	all	DT
18637	19441	23	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19441	24	in	in	IN
18637	19441	25	a	a	DT
18637	19441	26	State	state	NN
18637	19441	27	,	,	,
18637	19441	28	and	and	CC
18637	19441	29	one	one	CD
18637	19441	30	designed	design	VBN
18637	19441	31	to	to	TO
18637	19441	32	control	control	VB
18637	19441	33	the	the	DT
18637	19441	34	charges	charge	NNS
18637	19441	35	of	of	IN
18637	19441	36	only	only	RB
18637	19441	37	one	one	CD
18637	19441	38	or	or	CC
18637	19441	39	two	two	CD
18637	19441	40	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	19441	41	named	name	VBN
18637	19441	42	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19441	43	,	,	,
18637	19441	44	the	the	DT
18637	19441	45	cases	case	NNS
18637	19441	46	do	do	VBP
18637	19441	47	not	not	RB
18637	19441	48	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	19441	49	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	19441	50	the	the	DT
18637	19441	51	withholding	withholding	NN
18637	19441	52	of	of	IN
18637	19441	53	advance	advance	NN
18637	19441	54	notice	notice	NN
18637	19441	55	and	and	CC
18637	19441	56	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19441	57	in	in	IN
18637	19441	58	the	the	DT
18637	19441	59	first	first	JJ
18637	19441	60	class	class	NN
18637	19441	61	of	of	IN
18637	19441	62	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	19441	63	and	and	CC
18637	19441	64	insist	insist	VB
18637	19441	65	upon	upon	IN
18637	19441	66	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19441	67	provision	provision	NN
18637	19441	68	in	in	IN
18637	19441	69	the	the	DT
18637	19441	70	latter	latter	NN
18637	19441	71	.	.	.
18637	19442	1	In	in	IN
18637	19442	2	fact	fact	NN
18637	19442	3	,	,	,
18637	19442	4	the	the	DT
18637	19442	5	observation	observation	NN
18637	19442	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	19442	7	been	be	VBN
18637	19442	8	made	make	VBN
18637	19442	9	that	that	IN
18637	19442	10	the	the	DT
18637	19442	11	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19442	12	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	19442	13	to	to	TO
18637	19442	14	exact	exact	VB
18637	19442	15	the	the	DT
18637	19442	16	protection	protection	NN
18637	19442	17	of	of	IN
18637	19442	18	notice	notice	NN
18637	19442	19	and	and	CC
18637	19442	20	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19442	21	rises	rise	NNS
18637	19442	22	in	in	IN
18637	19442	23	direct	direct	JJ
18637	19442	24	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	19442	25	to	to	IN
18637	19442	26	the	the	DT
18637	19442	27	extent	extent	NN
18637	19442	28	to	to	TO
18637	19442	29	which	which	WDT
18637	19442	30	a	a	DT
18637	19442	31	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	19442	32	affects	affect	VBZ
18637	19442	33	the	the	DT
18637	19442	34	finances	finance	NNS
18637	19442	35	of	of	IN
18637	19442	36	business	business	NN
18637	19442	37	establishments	establishment	NNS
18637	19442	38	covered	cover	VBD
18637	19442	39	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	19442	40	.	.	.
18637	19443	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19443	2	,	,	,
18637	19443	3	if	if	IN
18637	19443	4	a	a	DT
18637	19443	5	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	19443	6	bears	bear	VBZ
18637	19443	7	only	only	RB
18637	19443	8	indirectly	indirectly	RB
18637	19443	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	19443	10	income	income	NN
18637	19443	11	and	and	CC
18637	19443	12	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	19443	13	,	,	,
18637	19443	14	as	as	IN
18637	19443	15	for	for	IN
18637	19443	16	example	example	NN
18637	19443	17	,	,	,
18637	19443	18	a	a	DT
18637	19443	19	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	19443	20	altering	alter	VBG
18637	19443	21	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19443	22	policy	policy	NN
18637	19443	23	forms	form	NNS
18637	19443	24	,	,	,
18637	19443	25	less	less	JJR
18637	19443	26	concern	concern	NN
18637	19443	27	for	for	IN
18637	19443	28	such	such	JJ
18637	19443	29	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	19443	30	protection	protection	NN
18637	19443	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	19443	32	likely	likely	JJ
18637	19443	33	to	to	TO
18637	19443	34	be	be	VB
18637	19443	35	expressed	express	VBN
18637	19443	36	than	than	IN
18637	19443	37	in	in	IN
18637	19443	38	the	the	DT
18637	19443	39	case	case	NN
18637	19443	40	of	of	IN
18637	19443	41	the	the	DT
18637	19443	42	formulation	formulation	NN
18637	19443	43	of	of	IN
18637	19443	44	a	a	DT
18637	19443	45	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	19443	46	wage	wage	NN
18637	19443	47	schedule	schedule	NN
18637	19443	48	,	,	,
18637	19443	49	even	even	RB
18637	19443	50	though	though	IN
18637	19443	51	the	the	DT
18637	19443	52	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	19443	53	involved	involve	VBN
18637	19443	54	in	in	IN
18637	19443	55	both	both	DT
18637	19443	56	illustrations	illustration	NNS
18637	19443	57	are	be	VBP
18637	19443	58	general	general	JJ
18637	19443	59	and	and	CC
18637	19443	60	not	not	RB
18637	19443	61	limited	limit	VBN
18637	19443	62	in	in	IN
18637	19443	63	operation	operation	NN
18637	19443	64	.	.	.
18637	19444	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	19444	2	,	,	,
18637	19444	3	if	if	IN
18637	19444	4	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	19444	5	,	,	,
18637	19444	6	which	which	WDT
18637	19444	7	are	be	VBP
18637	19444	8	general	general	JJ
18637	19444	9	in	in	IN
18637	19444	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19444	11	application	application	NN
18637	19444	12	,	,	,
18637	19444	13	may	may	MD
18637	19444	14	be	be	VB
18637	19444	15	readily	readily	RB
18637	19444	16	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	19444	17	to	to	IN
18637	19444	18	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19444	19	challenge	challenge	NN
18637	19444	20	after	after	IN
18637	19444	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19444	22	promulgation	promulgation	NN
18637	19444	23	,	,	,
18637	19444	24	or	or	CC
18637	19444	25	if	if	IN
18637	19444	26	the	the	DT
18637	19444	27	parties	party	NNS
18637	19444	28	to	to	TO
18637	19444	29	which	which	WDT
18637	19444	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19444	31	apply	apply	VBP
18637	19444	32	are	be	VBP
18637	19444	33	affected	affect	VBN
18637	19444	34	only	only	RB
18637	19444	35	when	when	WRB
18637	19444	36	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19444	37	endeavor	endeavor	VBP
18637	19444	38	to	to	TO
18637	19444	39	comply	comply	VB
18637	19444	40	in	in	IN
18637	19444	41	the	the	DT
18637	19444	42	future	future	NN
18637	19444	43	,	,	,
18637	19444	44	advance	advance	NN
18637	19444	45	notice	notice	NN
18637	19444	46	and	and	CC
18637	19444	47	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19444	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	19444	49	less	less	RBR
18637	19444	50	likely	likely	JJ
18637	19444	51	to	to	TO
18637	19444	52	be	be	VB
18637	19444	53	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19444	54	as	as	IN
18637	19444	55	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19444	56	to	to	IN
18637	19444	57	due	due	JJ
18637	19444	58	process	process	NN
18637	19444	59	.	.	.
18637	19445	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19445	2	741	741	CD
18637	19445	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19445	4	As	as	IN
18637	19445	5	to	to	IN
18637	19445	6	that	that	DT
18637	19445	7	portion	portion	NN
18637	19445	8	of	of	IN
18637	19445	9	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	19445	10	activity	activity	NN
18637	19445	11	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	19445	12	to	to	IN
18637	19445	13	the	the	DT
18637	19445	14	making	making	NN
18637	19445	15	of	of	IN
18637	19445	16	determinations	determination	NNS
18637	19445	17	or	or	CC
18637	19445	18	the	the	DT
18637	19445	19	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	19445	20	of	of	IN
18637	19445	21	orders	order	NNS
18637	19445	22	of	of	IN
18637	19445	23	limited	limited	JJ
18637	19445	24	or	or	CC
18637	19445	25	individual	individual	JJ
18637	19445	26	application	application	NN
18637	19445	27	,	,	,
18637	19445	28	the	the	DT
18637	19445	29	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	19445	30	to	to	TO
18637	19445	31	afford	afford	VB
18637	19445	32	notice	notice	NN
18637	19445	33	and	and	CC
18637	19445	34	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19445	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	19445	36	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	19445	37	clear	clear	JJ
18637	19445	38	;	;	:
18637	19445	39	but	but	CC
18637	19445	40	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	19445	41	has	have	VBZ
18637	19445	42	been	be	VBN
18637	19445	43	protracted	protract	VBN
18637	19445	44	on	on	IN
18637	19445	45	the	the	DT
18637	19445	46	question	question	NN
18637	19445	47	whether	whether	IN
18637	19445	48	this	this	DT
18637	19445	49	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	19445	50	safeguard	safeguard	NN
18637	19445	51	,	,	,
18637	19445	52	in	in	IN
18637	19445	53	every	every	DT
18637	19445	54	instance	instance	NN
18637	19445	55	,	,	,
18637	19445	56	must	must	MD
18637	19445	57	be	be	VB
18637	19445	58	granted	grant	VBN
18637	19445	59	in	in	IN
18637	19445	60	advance	advance	NN
18637	19445	61	of	of	IN
18637	19445	62	such	such	JJ
18637	19445	63	activity	activity	NN
18637	19445	64	.	.	.
18637	19446	1	The	the	DT
18637	19446	2	most	most	RBS
18637	19446	3	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	19446	4	litigated	litigate	VBD
18637	19446	5	types	type	NNS
18637	19446	6	of	of	IN
18637	19446	7	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	19446	8	action	action	NN
18637	19446	9	embracing	embrace	VBG
18637	19446	10	the	the	DT
18637	19446	11	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19446	12	issue	issue	NN
18637	19446	13	have	have	VBP
18637	19446	14	been	be	VBN
18637	19446	15	determinations	determination	NNS
18637	19446	16	to	to	TO
18637	19446	17	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	19446	18	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	19446	19	of	of	IN
18637	19446	20	,	,	,
18637	19446	21	or	or	CC
18637	19446	22	to	to	TO
18637	19446	23	revoke	revoke	VB
18637	19446	24	,	,	,
18637	19446	25	an	an	DT
18637	19446	26	occupational	occupational	JJ
18637	19446	27	license	license	NN
18637	19446	28	,	,	,
18637	19446	29	or	or	CC
18637	19446	30	to	to	TO
18637	19446	31	impound	impound	VB
18637	19446	32	or	or	CC
18637	19446	33	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	19446	34	property	property	NN
18637	19446	35	believed	believe	VBN
18637	19446	36	to	to	TO
18637	19446	37	be	be	VB
18637	19446	38	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	19446	39	to	to	IN
18637	19446	40	public	public	JJ
18637	19446	41	health	health	NN
18637	19446	42	,	,	,
18637	19446	43	morals	moral	NNS
18637	19446	44	,	,	,
18637	19446	45	or	or	CC
18637	19446	46	safety	safety	NN
18637	19446	47	.	.	.
18637	19447	1	Apparently	apparently	RB
18637	19447	2	in	in	IN
18637	19447	3	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	19447	4	of	of	IN
18637	19447	5	the	the	DT
18637	19447	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	19447	7	that	that	IN
18637	19447	8	few	few	JJ
18637	19447	9	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	19447	10	today	today	NN
18637	19447	11	can	can	MD
18637	19447	12	be	be	VB
18637	19447	13	pursued	pursue	VBN
18637	19447	14	without	without	IN
18637	19447	15	a	a	DT
18637	19447	16	license	license	NN
18637	19447	17	,	,	,
18637	19447	18	the	the	DT
18637	19447	19	trend	trend	NN
18637	19447	20	of	of	IN
18637	19447	21	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19447	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	19447	23	toward	toward	IN
18637	19447	24	sustaining	sustain	VBG
18637	19447	25	a	a	DT
18637	19447	26	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19447	27	of	of	IN
18637	19447	28	a	a	DT
18637	19447	29	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19447	30	before	before	IN
18637	19447	31	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	19447	32	to	to	TO
18637	19447	33	issue	issue	VB
18637	19447	34	a	a	DT
18637	19447	35	license	license	NN
18637	19447	36	and	and	CC
18637	19447	37	away	away	RB
18637	19447	38	from	from	IN
18637	19447	39	the	the	DT
18637	19447	40	view	view	NN
18637	19447	41	that	that	DT
18637	19447	42	inasmuch	inasmuch	VBP
18637	19447	43	as	as	IN
18637	19447	44	no	no	DT
18637	19447	45	one	one	NN
18637	19447	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	19447	47	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19447	48	as	as	IN
18637	19447	49	of	of	IN
18637	19447	50	right	right	NN
18637	19447	51	to	to	TO
18637	19447	52	engage	engage	VB
18637	19447	53	in	in	IN
18637	19447	54	a	a	DT
18637	19447	55	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19447	56	profession	profession	NN
18637	19447	57	,	,	,
18637	19447	58	the	the	DT
18637	19447	59	issue	issue	NN
18637	19447	60	of	of	IN
18637	19447	61	a	a	DT
18637	19447	62	practitioner	practitioner	NN
18637	19447	63	's	's	POS
18637	19447	64	license	license	NN
18637	19447	65	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	19447	66	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	19447	67	is	be	VBZ
18637	19447	68	in	in	IN
18637	19447	69	the	the	DT
18637	19447	70	nature	nature	NN
18637	19447	71	of	of	IN
18637	19447	72	a	a	DT
18637	19447	73	gift	gift	NN
18637	19447	74	as	as	IN
18637	19447	75	to	to	IN
18637	19447	76	the	the	DT
18637	19447	77	granting	granting	NN
18637	19447	78	or	or	CC
18637	19447	79	withholding	withholding	NN
18637	19447	80	of	of	IN
18637	19447	81	which	which	WDT
18637	19447	82	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	19447	83	protection	protection	NN
18637	19447	84	is	be	VBZ
18637	19447	85	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	19447	86	.	.	.
18637	19448	1	Revocation	revocation	NN
18637	19448	2	,	,	,
18637	19448	3	or	or	CC
18637	19448	4	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	19448	5	to	to	TO
18637	19448	6	renew	renew	VB
18637	19448	7	a	a	DT
18637	19448	8	license	license	NN
18637	19448	9	,	,	,
18637	19448	10	however	however	RB
18637	19448	11	,	,	,
18637	19448	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	19448	13	been	be	VBN
18637	19448	14	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	19448	15	from	from	IN
18637	19448	16	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	19448	17	of	of	IN
18637	19448	18	a	a	DT
18637	19448	19	license	license	NN
18637	19448	20	;	;	:
18637	19448	21	and	and	CC
18637	19448	22	where	where	WRB
18637	19448	23	a	a	DT
18637	19448	24	license	license	NN
18637	19448	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	19448	26	construed	construe	VBN
18637	19448	27	to	to	TO
18637	19448	28	confer	confer	VB
18637	19448	29	something	something	NN
18637	19448	30	in	in	IN
18637	19448	31	the	the	DT
18637	19448	32	nature	nature	NN
18637	19448	33	of	of	IN
18637	19448	34	a	a	DT
18637	19448	35	property	property	NN
18637	19448	36	right	right	RB
18637	19448	37	rather	rather	RB
18637	19448	38	than	than	IN
18637	19448	39	a	a	DT
18637	19448	40	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19448	41	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19448	42	terminable	terminable	NN
18637	19448	43	at	at	IN
18637	19448	44	will	will	NN
18637	19448	45	,	,	,
18637	19448	46	such	such	JJ
18637	19448	47	property	property	NN
18637	19448	48	right	right	RB
18637	19448	49	,	,	,
18637	19448	50	the	the	DT
18637	19448	51	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	19448	52	have	have	VBP
18637	19448	53	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	19448	54	,	,	,
18637	19448	55	ought	ought	MD
18637	19448	56	not	not	RB
18637	19448	57	to	to	TO
18637	19448	58	be	be	VB
18637	19448	59	destroyed	destroy	VBN
18637	19448	60	summarily	summarily	RB
18637	19448	61	by	by	IN
18637	19448	62	revocation	revocation	NN
18637	19448	63	without	without	IN
18637	19448	64	prior	prior	JJ
18637	19448	65	notice	notice	NN
18637	19448	66	and	and	CC
18637	19448	67	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19448	68	.	.	.
18637	19449	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	19449	2	an	an	DT
18637	19449	3	occupational	occupational	JJ
18637	19449	4	license	license	NN
18637	19449	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19449	6	to	to	TO
18637	19449	7	be	be	VB
18637	19449	8	treated	treat	VBN
18637	19449	9	as	as	IN
18637	19449	10	a	a	DT
18637	19449	11	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19449	12	revocable	revocable	NN
18637	19449	13	without	without	IN
18637	19449	14	a	a	DT
18637	19449	15	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19449	16	,	,	,
18637	19449	17	or	or	CC
18637	19449	18	as	as	IN
18637	19449	19	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	19449	20	a	a	DT
18637	19449	21	property	property	NN
18637	19449	22	right	right	JJ
18637	19449	23	deserving	deserving	NN
18637	19449	24	of	of	IN
18637	19449	25	greater	great	JJR
18637	19449	26	protection	protection	NN
18637	19449	27	,	,	,
18637	19449	28	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	19449	29	very	very	RB
18637	19449	30	largely	largely	RB
18637	19449	31	on	on	IN
18637	19449	32	prevailing	prevail	VBG
18637	19449	33	estimates	estimate	NNS
18637	19449	34	of	of	IN
18637	19449	35	the	the	DT
18637	19449	36	social	social	JJ
18637	19449	37	desirability	desirability	NN
18637	19449	38	of	of	IN
18637	19449	39	a	a	DT
18637	19449	40	calling	calling	NN
18637	19449	41	.	.	.
18637	19450	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19450	2	,	,	,
18637	19450	3	if	if	IN
18637	19450	4	a	a	DT
18637	19450	5	business	business	NN
18637	19450	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19450	7	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
18637	19450	8	of	of	IN
18637	19450	9	being	be	VBG
18637	19450	10	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19450	11	as	as	RB
18637	19450	12	injurious	injurious	JJ
18637	19450	13	to	to	IN
18637	19450	14	public	public	JJ
18637	19450	15	health	health	NN
18637	19450	16	,	,	,
18637	19450	17	morals	moral	NNS
18637	19450	18	,	,	,
18637	19450	19	safety	safety	NN
18637	19450	20	,	,	,
18637	19450	21	and	and	CC
18637	19450	22	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	19450	23	,	,	,
18637	19450	24	as	as	IN
18637	19450	25	,	,	,
18637	19450	26	for	for	IN
18637	19450	27	example	example	NN
18637	19450	28	,	,	,
18637	19450	29	saloons	saloon	NNS
18637	19450	30	,	,	,
18637	19450	31	pool	pool	NN
18637	19450	32	rooms	room	NNS
18637	19450	33	,	,	,
18637	19450	34	and	and	CC
18637	19450	35	dance	dance	NN
18637	19450	36	halls	hall	NNS
18637	19450	37	,	,	,
18637	19450	38	the	the	DT
18637	19450	39	licensee	licensee	NN
18637	19450	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	19450	41	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19450	42	to	to	TO
18637	19450	43	have	have	VB
18637	19450	44	entered	enter	VBN
18637	19450	45	upon	upon	IN
18637	19450	46	such	such	JJ
18637	19450	47	line	line	NN
18637	19450	48	of	of	IN
18637	19450	49	endeavor	endeavor	NN
18637	19450	50	with	with	IN
18637	19450	51	advance	advance	JJ
18637	19450	52	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	19450	53	of	of	IN
18637	19450	54	the	the	DT
18637	19450	55	State	state	NN
18637	19450	56	's	's	POS
18637	19450	57	right	right	NN
18637	19450	58	to	to	TO
18637	19450	59	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	19450	60	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19450	61	license	license	NN
18637	19450	62	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	19450	63	summarily	summarily	RB
18637	19450	64	.	.	.
18637	19451	1	Prompt	prompt	JJ
18637	19451	2	protection	protection	NN
18637	19451	3	of	of	IN
18637	19451	4	the	the	DT
18637	19451	5	public	public	NN
18637	19451	6	in	in	IN
18637	19451	7	such	such	JJ
18637	19451	8	instances	instance	NNS
18637	19451	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19451	10	said	say	VBN
18637	19451	11	to	to	TO
18637	19451	12	outweigh	outweigh	VB
18637	19451	13	the	the	DT
18637	19451	14	advantages	advantage	NNS
18637	19451	15	of	of	IN
18637	19451	16	a	a	DT
18637	19451	17	slower	slow	JJR
18637	19451	18	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19451	19	,	,	,
18637	19451	20	retarded	retard	VBN
18637	19451	21	by	by	IN
18637	19451	22	previous	previous	JJ
18637	19451	23	notice	notice	NN
18637	19451	24	and	and	CC
18637	19451	25	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19451	26	,	,	,
18637	19451	27	and	and	CC
18637	19451	28	to	to	TO
18637	19451	29	require	require	VB
18637	19451	30	that	that	IN
18637	19451	31	the	the	DT
18637	19451	32	person	person	NN
18637	19451	33	adversely	adversely	RB
18637	19451	34	affected	affect	VBD
18637	19451	35	seek	seek	VB
18637	19451	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19451	37	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	19451	38	from	from	IN
18637	19451	39	the	the	DT
18637	19451	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19451	41	via	via	IN
18637	19451	42	a	a	DT
18637	19451	43	petition	petition	NN
18637	19451	44	to	to	TO
18637	19451	45	review	review	VB
18637	19451	46	or	or	CC
18637	19451	47	to	to	TO
18637	19451	48	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	19451	49	the	the	DT
18637	19451	50	decision	decision	NN
18637	19451	51	of	of	IN
18637	19451	52	the	the	DT
18637	19451	53	licensing	licensing	NN
18637	19451	54	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	19451	55	.	.	.
18637	19452	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19452	2	742	742	CD
18637	19452	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19452	4	For	for	IN
18637	19452	5	like	like	JJ
18637	19452	6	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	19452	7	,	,	,
18637	19452	8	the	the	DT
18637	19452	9	owner	owner	NN
18637	19452	10	of	of	IN
18637	19452	11	property	property	NN
18637	19452	12	about	about	IN
18637	19452	13	to	to	TO
18637	19452	14	be	be	VB
18637	19452	15	impounded	impound	VBN
18637	19452	16	or	or	CC
18637	19452	17	destroyed	destroy	VBN
18637	19452	18	by	by	IN
18637	19452	19	officers	officer	NNS
18637	19452	20	acting	act	VBG
18637	19452	21	in	in	IN
18637	19452	22	furtherance	furtherance	NN
18637	19452	23	of	of	IN
18637	19452	24	the	the	DT
18637	19452	25	police	police	NN
18637	19452	26	power	power	NN
18637	19452	27	may	may	MD
18637	19452	28	justifiably	justifiably	RB
18637	19452	29	be	be	VB
18637	19452	30	relegated	relegate	VBN
18637	19452	31	to	to	TO
18637	19452	32	post	post	VB
18637	19452	33	mortem	mortem	FW
18637	19452	34	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	19452	35	in	in	IN
18637	19452	36	the	the	DT
18637	19452	37	form	form	NN
18637	19452	38	of	of	IN
18637	19452	39	a	a	DT
18637	19452	40	suit	suit	NN
18637	19452	41	for	for	IN
18637	19452	42	damages	damage	NNS
18637	19452	43	against	against	IN
18637	19452	44	the	the	DT
18637	19452	45	officer	officer	NN
18637	19452	46	effecting	effect	VBG
18637	19452	47	the	the	DT
18637	19452	48	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	19452	49	or	or	CC
18637	19452	50	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	19452	51	,	,	,
18637	19452	52	or	or	CC
18637	19452	53	,	,	,
18637	19452	54	if	if	IN
18637	19452	55	time	time	NN
18637	19452	56	permits	permit	VBZ
18637	19452	57	,	,	,
18637	19452	58	a	a	DT
18637	19452	59	bill	bill	NN
18637	19452	60	in	in	IN
18637	19452	61	equity	equity	NN
18637	19452	62	for	for	IN
18637	19452	63	an	an	DT
18637	19452	64	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	19452	65	.	.	.
18637	19453	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19453	2	,	,	,
18637	19453	3	due	due	JJ
18637	19453	4	process	process	NN
18637	19453	5	of	of	IN
18637	19453	6	law	law	NN
18637	19453	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19453	8	not	not	RB
18637	19453	9	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19453	10	the	the	DT
18637	19453	11	custodian	custodian	NN
18637	19453	12	of	of	IN
18637	19453	13	food	food	NN
18637	19453	14	in	in	IN
18637	19453	15	cold	cold	JJ
18637	19453	16	storage	storage	NN
18637	19453	17	by	by	IN
18637	19453	18	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	19453	19	of	of	IN
18637	19453	20	a	a	DT
18637	19453	21	city	city	NN
18637	19453	22	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	19453	23	under	under	IN
18637	19453	24	which	which	WDT
18637	19453	25	such	such	JJ
18637	19453	26	food	food	NN
18637	19453	27	,	,	,
18637	19453	28	when	when	WRB
18637	19453	29	unfit	unfit	JJ
18637	19453	30	for	for	IN
18637	19453	31	human	human	JJ
18637	19453	32	consumption	consumption	NN
18637	19453	33	,	,	,
18637	19453	34	may	may	MD
18637	19453	35	summarily	summarily	RB
18637	19453	36	be	be	VB
18637	19453	37	seized	seize	VBN
18637	19453	38	,	,	,
18637	19453	39	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	19453	40	,	,	,
18637	19453	41	and	and	CC
18637	19453	42	destroyed	destroy	VBN
18637	19453	43	without	without	IN
18637	19453	44	a	a	DT
18637	19453	45	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	19453	46	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19453	47	.	.	.
18637	19454	1	"	"	``
18637	19454	2	If	if	IN
18637	19454	3	a	a	DT
18637	19454	4	party	party	NN
18637	19454	5	can	can	MD
18637	19454	6	not	not	RB
18637	19454	7	get	get	VB
18637	19454	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19454	9	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19454	10	in	in	IN
18637	19454	11	advance	advance	NN
18637	19454	12	of	of	IN
18637	19454	13	the	the	DT
18637	19454	14	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	19454	15	and	and	CC
18637	19454	16	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	19454	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19454	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	19454	19	the	the	DT
18637	19454	20	right	right	NN
18637	19454	21	to	to	TO
18637	19454	22	have	have	VB
18637	19454	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19454	24	afterward	afterward	RB
18637	19454	25	,	,	,
18637	19454	26	*	*	NFP
18637	19454	27	*	*	NFP
18637	19454	28	*	*	NFP
18637	19454	29	in	in	IN
18637	19454	30	an	an	DT
18637	19454	31	action	action	NN
18637	19454	32	brought	bring	VBN
18637	19454	33	for	for	IN
18637	19454	34	the	the	DT
18637	19454	35	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	19454	36	of	of	IN
18637	19454	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19454	38	property	property	NN
18637	19454	39	,	,	,
18637	19454	40	and	and	CC
18637	19454	41	in	in	IN
18637	19454	42	that	that	DT
18637	19454	43	action	action	NN
18637	19454	44	those	those	DT
18637	19454	45	who	who	WP
18637	19454	46	destroyed	destroy	VBD
18637	19454	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19454	48	can	can	MD
18637	19454	49	only	only	RB
18637	19454	50	successfully	successfully	RB
18637	19454	51	defend	defend	VB
18637	19454	52	if	if	IN
18637	19454	53	the	the	DT
18637	19454	54	jury	jury	NN
18637	19454	55	shall	shall	MD
18637	19454	56	find	find	VB
18637	19454	57	the	the	DT
18637	19454	58	fact	fact	NN
18637	19454	59	of	of	IN
18637	19454	60	unwholesomeness	unwholesomeness	NN
18637	19454	61	as	as	IN
18637	19454	62	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	19454	63	by	by	IN
18637	19454	64	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19454	65	.	.	.
18637	19455	1	"	"	``
18637	19455	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19455	3	743	743	CD
18637	19455	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19455	5	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19455	6	,	,	,
18637	19455	7	if	if	IN
18637	19455	8	the	the	DT
18637	19455	9	owner	owner	NN
18637	19455	10	of	of	IN
18637	19455	11	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	19455	12	,	,	,
18637	19455	13	possession	possession	NN
18637	19455	14	of	of	IN
18637	19455	15	which	which	WDT
18637	19455	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	19455	17	been	be	VBN
18637	19455	18	made	make	VBN
18637	19455	19	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	19455	20	,	,	,
18637	19455	21	can	can	MD
18637	19455	22	secure	secure	VB
18637	19455	23	a	a	DT
18637	19455	24	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19455	25	by	by	IN
18637	19455	26	instituting	institute	VBG
18637	19455	27	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	19455	28	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19455	29	,	,	,
18637	19455	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19455	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	19455	32	not	not	RB
18637	19455	33	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19455	34	due	due	JJ
18637	19455	35	process	process	NN
18637	19455	36	by	by	IN
18637	19455	37	the	the	DT
18637	19455	38	failure	failure	NN
18637	19455	39	to	to	TO
18637	19455	40	grant	grant	VB
18637	19455	41	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19455	42	a	a	DT
18637	19455	43	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19455	44	before	before	IN
18637	19455	45	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	19455	46	and	and	CC
18637	19455	47	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	19455	48	of	of	IN
18637	19455	49	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19455	50	property	property	NN
18637	19455	51	.	.	.
18637	19456	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19456	2	744	744	CD
18637	19456	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19456	4	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	19456	5	,	,	,
18637	19456	6	even	even	RB
18637	19456	7	when	when	WRB
18637	19456	8	no	no	DT
18637	19456	9	emergency	emergency	NN
18637	19456	10	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	19456	11	,	,	,
18637	19456	12	such	such	JJ
18637	19456	13	as	as	IN
18637	19456	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19456	15	provided	provide	VBN
18637	19456	16	by	by	IN
18637	19456	17	a	a	DT
18637	19456	18	conflagration	conflagration	NN
18637	19456	19	or	or	CC
18637	19456	20	threatened	threaten	VBN
18637	19456	21	epidemic	epidemic	NN
18637	19456	22	,	,	,
18637	19456	23	and	and	CC
18637	19456	24	the	the	DT
18637	19456	25	property	property	NN
18637	19456	26	in	in	IN
18637	19456	27	question	question	NN
18637	19456	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	19456	29	not	not	RB
18637	19456	30	intrinsically	intrinsically	RB
18637	19456	31	harmful	harmful	JJ
18637	19456	32	,	,	,
18637	19456	33	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19456	34	use	use	NN
18637	19456	35	in	in	IN
18637	19456	36	violation	violation	NN
18637	19456	37	of	of	IN
18637	19456	38	a	a	DT
18637	19456	39	valid	valid	JJ
18637	19456	40	police	police	NN
18637	19456	41	power	power	NN
18637	19456	42	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	19456	43	has	have	VBZ
18637	19456	44	been	be	VBN
18637	19456	45	held	hold	VBN
18637	19456	46	to	to	TO
18637	19456	47	justify	justify	VB
18637	19456	48	summary	summary	NN
18637	19456	49	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	19456	50	.	.	.
18637	19457	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19457	2	,	,	,
18637	19457	3	in	in	IN
18637	19457	4	the	the	DT
18637	19457	5	much	much	RB
18637	19457	6	criticized	criticize	VBN
18637	19457	7	case	case	NN
18637	19457	8	of	of	IN
18637	19457	9	Lawton	Lawton	NNP
18637	19457	10	_	_	NNP
18637	19457	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	19457	12	_	_	NNP
18637	19457	13	Steele,[745	Steele,[745	NNP
18637	19457	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19457	15	the	the	DT
18637	19457	16	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	19457	17	,	,	,
18637	19457	18	without	without	IN
18637	19457	19	prior	prior	JJ
18637	19457	20	notice	notice	NN
18637	19457	21	and	and	CC
18637	19457	22	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19457	23	,	,	,
18637	19457	24	of	of	IN
18637	19457	25	fishing	fishing	NN
18637	19457	26	nets	net	NNS
18637	19457	27	set	set	VBN
18637	19457	28	in	in	IN
18637	19457	29	violation	violation	NN
18637	19457	30	of	of	IN
18637	19457	31	a	a	DT
18637	19457	32	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	19457	33	law	law	NN
18637	19457	34	defining	define	VBG
18637	19457	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19457	36	to	to	TO
18637	19457	37	be	be	VB
18637	19457	38	a	a	DT
18637	19457	39	nuisance	nuisance	NN
18637	19457	40	was	be	VBD
18637	19457	41	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	19457	42	on	on	IN
18637	19457	43	the	the	DT
18637	19457	44	ground	ground	NN
18637	19457	45	that	that	IN
18637	19457	46	the	the	DT
18637	19457	47	property	property	NN
18637	19457	48	was	be	VBD
18637	19457	49	not	not	RB
18637	19457	50	"	"	``
18637	19457	51	of	of	IN
18637	19457	52	great	great	JJ
18637	19457	53	value	value	NN
18637	19457	54	.	.	.
18637	19457	55	"	"	''
18637	19458	1	Conceding	concede	VBG
18637	19458	2	that	that	IN
18637	19458	3	"	"	``
18637	19458	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19458	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19458	6	not	not	RB
18637	19458	7	easy	easy	JJ
18637	19458	8	to	to	TO
18637	19458	9	draw	draw	VB
18637	19458	10	the	the	DT
18637	19458	11	line	line	NN
18637	19458	12	between	between	IN
18637	19458	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	19458	14	where	where	WRB
18637	19458	15	property	property	NN
18637	19458	16	illegally	illegally	RB
18637	19458	17	used	use	VBN
18637	19458	18	may	may	MD
18637	19458	19	be	be	VB
18637	19458	20	destroyed	destroy	VBN
18637	19458	21	summarily	summarily	RB
18637	19458	22	and	and	CC
18637	19458	23	where	where	WRB
18637	19458	24	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19458	25	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19458	26	are	be	VBP
18637	19458	27	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19458	28	for	for	IN
18637	19458	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19458	30	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	19458	31	,	,	,
18637	19458	32	"	"	''
18637	19458	33	the	the	DT
18637	19458	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19458	35	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBD
18637	19458	36	that	that	IN
18637	19458	37	"	"	``
18637	19458	38	if	if	IN
18637	19458	39	the	the	DT
18637	19458	40	property	property	NN
18637	19458	41	were	be	VBD
18637	19458	42	of	of	IN
18637	19458	43	great	great	JJ
18637	19458	44	value	value	NN
18637	19458	45	,	,	,
18637	19458	46	as	as	IN
18637	19458	47	,	,	,
18637	19458	48	for	for	IN
18637	19458	49	instance	instance	NN
18637	19458	50	,	,	,
18637	19458	51	if	if	IN
18637	19458	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19458	53	were	be	VBD
18637	19458	54	a	a	DT
18637	19458	55	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	19458	56	employed	employ	VBN
18637	19458	57	for	for	IN
18637	19458	58	smuggling	smuggling	NN
18637	19458	59	or	or	CC
18637	19458	60	other	other	JJ
18637	19458	61	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	19458	62	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19458	63	,	,	,
18637	19458	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19458	65	would	would	MD
18637	19458	66	be	be	VB
18637	19458	67	*	*	NFP
18637	19458	68	*	*	NFP
18637	19458	69	*	*	NFP
18637	19458	70	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	19458	71	*	*	NFP
18637	19458	72	*	*	NFP
18637	19458	73	*	*	NFP
18637	19458	74	to	to	TO
18637	19458	75	permit	permit	VB
18637	19458	76	*	*	NFP
18637	19458	77	*	*	NFP
18637	19458	78	*	*	NFP
18637	19458	79	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19458	80	an	an	DT
18637	19458	81	officer	officer	NN
18637	19458	82	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19458	83	to	to	TO
18637	19458	84	sell	sell	VB
18637	19458	85	or	or	CC
18637	19458	86	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	19458	87	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19458	88	as	as	IN
18637	19458	89	a	a	DT
18637	19458	90	public	public	JJ
18637	19458	91	nuisance	nuisance	NN
18637	19458	92	,	,	,
18637	19458	93	*	*	NFP
18637	19458	94	*	*	NFP
18637	19458	95	*	*	NFP
18637	19458	96	But	but	CC
18637	19458	97	where	where	WRB
18637	19458	98	the	the	DT
18637	19458	99	property	property	NN
18637	19458	100	is	be	VBZ
18637	19458	101	of	of	IN
18637	19458	102	trifling	trifle	VBG
18637	19458	103	value	value	NN
18637	19458	104	,	,	,
18637	19458	105	*	*	NFP
18637	19458	106	*	*	NFP
18637	19458	107	*	*	NFP
18637	19458	108	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19458	109	think	think	VBP
18637	19458	110	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19458	111	is	be	VBZ
18637	19458	112	within	within	IN
18637	19458	113	the	the	DT
18637	19458	114	power	power	NN
18637	19458	115	of	of	IN
18637	19458	116	the	the	DT
18637	19458	117	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	19458	118	to	to	TO
18637	19458	119	order	order	VB
18637	19458	120	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19458	121	summary	summary	NN
18637	19458	122	abatement	abatement	NN
18637	19458	123	.	.	.
18637	19459	1	"	"	``
18637	19459	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19459	3	746	746	CD
18637	19459	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19459	5	Statutory	Statutory	NNP
18637	19459	6	Proceedings.--"It	Proceedings.--"It	NNP
18637	19459	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19459	8	not	not	RB
18637	19459	9	an	an	DT
18637	19459	10	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
18637	19459	11	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19459	12	of	of	IN
18637	19459	13	due	due	JJ
18637	19459	14	process	process	NN
18637	19459	15	that	that	WDT
18637	19459	16	every	every	DT
18637	19459	17	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19459	18	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	19459	19	the	the	DT
18637	19459	20	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	19459	21	or	or	CC
18637	19459	22	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	19459	23	of	of	IN
18637	19459	24	property	property	NN
18637	19459	25	be	be	VB
18637	19459	26	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	19459	27	by	by	IN
18637	19459	28	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19459	29	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19459	30	.	.	.
18637	19460	1	Statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	19460	2	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19460	3	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	19460	4	property	property	NN
18637	19460	5	rights	right	NNS
18637	19460	6	,	,	,
18637	19460	7	which	which	WDT
18637	19460	8	,	,	,
18637	19460	9	by	by	IN
18637	19460	10	later	later	RB
18637	19460	11	resort	resort	NN
18637	19460	12	to	to	IN
18637	19460	13	the	the	DT
18637	19460	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	19460	15	,	,	,
18637	19460	16	secure	secure	JJ
18637	19460	17	to	to	IN
18637	19460	18	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	19460	19	parties	party	NNS
18637	19460	20	an	an	DT
18637	19460	21	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19460	22	to	to	TO
18637	19460	23	be	be	VB
18637	19460	24	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19460	25	,	,	,
18637	19460	26	suitable	suitable	JJ
18637	19460	27	to	to	IN
18637	19460	28	the	the	DT
18637	19460	29	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	19460	30	,	,	,
18637	19460	31	do	do	VB
18637	19460	32	not	not	RB
18637	19460	33	deny	deny	VB
18637	19460	34	due	due	JJ
18637	19460	35	process	process	NN
18637	19460	36	.	.	.
18637	19461	1	"	"	``
18637	19461	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19461	3	747	747	CD
18637	19461	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19461	5	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19461	6	,	,	,
18637	19461	7	a	a	DT
18637	19461	8	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19461	9	under	under	IN
18637	19461	10	which	which	WDT
18637	19461	11	a	a	DT
18637	19461	12	State	State	NNP
18637	19461	13	banking	banking	NN
18637	19461	14	superintendent	superintendent	NN
18637	19461	15	,	,	,
18637	19461	16	after	after	IN
18637	19461	17	having	have	VBG
18637	19461	18	taken	take	VBN
18637	19461	19	over	over	RP
18637	19461	20	a	a	DT
18637	19461	21	closed	close	VBN
18637	19461	22	bank	bank	NN
18637	19461	23	and	and	CC
18637	19461	24	issued	issue	VBD
18637	19461	25	notices	notice	NNS
18637	19461	26	to	to	IN
18637	19461	27	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	19461	28	of	of	IN
18637	19461	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19461	30	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19461	31	,	,	,
18637	19461	32	may	may	MD
18637	19461	33	issue	issue	VB
18637	19461	34	execution	execution	NN
18637	19461	35	for	for	IN
18637	19461	36	the	the	DT
18637	19461	37	amounts	amount	NNS
18637	19461	38	due	due	JJ
18637	19461	39	,	,	,
18637	19461	40	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19461	41	to	to	IN
18637	19461	42	the	the	DT
18637	19461	43	right	right	NN
18637	19461	44	of	of	IN
18637	19461	45	each	each	DT
18637	19461	46	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	19461	47	,	,	,
18637	19461	48	by	by	IN
18637	19461	49	affidavit	affidavit	NN
18637	19461	50	of	of	IN
18637	19461	51	illegality	illegality	NN
18637	19461	52	,	,	,
18637	19461	53	to	to	TO
18637	19461	54	contest	contest	VB
18637	19461	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19461	56	liability	liability	NN
18637	19461	57	for	for	IN
18637	19461	58	such	such	PDT
18637	19461	59	an	an	DT
18637	19461	60	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19461	61	,	,	,
18637	19461	62	does	do	VBZ
18637	19461	63	not	not	RB
18637	19461	64	in	in	IN
18637	19461	65	effect	effect	NN
18637	19461	66	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	19461	67	an	an	DT
18637	19461	68	execution	execution	NN
18637	19461	69	and	and	CC
18637	19461	70	creation	creation	NN
18637	19461	71	of	of	IN
18637	19461	72	a	a	DT
18637	19461	73	lien	lien	NN
18637	19461	74	before	before	RB
18637	19461	75	and	and	CC
18637	19461	76	without	without	IN
18637	19461	77	any	any	DT
18637	19461	78	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19461	79	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19461	80	.	.	.
18637	19462	1	The	the	DT
18637	19462	2	fact	fact	NN
18637	19462	3	that	that	IN
18637	19462	4	the	the	DT
18637	19462	5	execution	execution	NN
18637	19462	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19462	7	issued	issue	VBN
18637	19462	8	in	in	IN
18637	19462	9	the	the	DT
18637	19462	10	first	first	JJ
18637	19462	11	instance	instance	NN
18637	19462	12	by	by	IN
18637	19462	13	an	an	DT
18637	19462	14	agent	agent	NN
18637	19462	15	of	of	IN
18637	19462	16	the	the	DT
18637	19462	17	State	State	NNP
18637	19462	18	and	and	CC
18637	19462	19	not	not	RB
18637	19462	20	from	from	IN
18637	19462	21	a	a	DT
18637	19462	22	court	court	NN
18637	19462	23	,	,	,
18637	19462	24	followed	follow	VBN
18637	19462	25	by	by	IN
18637	19462	26	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19462	27	notice	notice	NN
18637	19462	28	and	and	CC
18637	19462	29	a	a	DT
18637	19462	30	right	right	NN
18637	19462	31	to	to	TO
18637	19462	32	take	take	VB
18637	19462	33	the	the	DT
18637	19462	34	case	case	NN
18637	19462	35	into	into	IN
18637	19462	36	court	court	NN
18637	19462	37	,	,	,
18637	19462	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	19462	39	open	open	JJ
18637	19462	40	to	to	IN
18637	19462	41	no	no	DT
18637	19462	42	objection	objection	NN
18637	19462	43	.	.	.
18637	19463	1	The	the	DT
18637	19463	2	statute	statute	NN
18637	19463	3	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	19463	4	this	this	DT
18637	19463	5	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19463	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19463	7	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19463	8	notice	notice	NN
18637	19463	9	to	to	IN
18637	19463	10	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	19463	11	that	that	IN
18637	19463	12	on	on	IN
18637	19463	13	becoming	become	VBG
18637	19463	14	such	such	JJ
18637	19463	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19463	16	assumed	assume	VBD
18637	19463	17	the	the	DT
18637	19463	18	liability	liability	NN
18637	19463	19	on	on	IN
18637	19463	20	which	which	WDT
18637	19463	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19463	22	are	be	VBP
18637	19463	23	to	to	TO
18637	19463	24	be	be	VB
18637	19463	25	held	hold	VBN
18637	19463	26	.	.	.
18637	19464	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19464	2	748	748	CD
18637	19464	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19464	4	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	19464	5	Proceedings.--Consistently	proceedings.--consistently	RB
18637	19464	6	with	with	IN
18637	19464	7	the	the	DT
18637	19464	8	due	due	JJ
18637	19464	9	process	process	NN
18637	19464	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	19464	11	,	,	,
18637	19464	12	a	a	DT
18637	19464	13	State	state	NN
18637	19464	14	may	may	MD
18637	19464	15	not	not	RB
18637	19464	16	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	19464	17	a	a	DT
18637	19464	18	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19464	19	against	against	IN
18637	19464	20	a	a	DT
18637	19464	21	party	party	NN
18637	19464	22	named	name	VBN
18637	19464	23	in	in	IN
18637	19464	24	the	the	DT
18637	19464	25	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19464	26	without	without	IN
18637	19464	27	an	an	DT
18637	19464	28	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19464	29	to	to	TO
18637	19464	30	be	be	VB
18637	19464	31	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19464	32	at	at	IN
18637	19464	33	sometime	sometime	RB
18637	19464	34	before	before	IN
18637	19464	35	final	final	JJ
18637	19464	36	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19464	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	19464	38	entered	enter	VBN
18637	19464	39	.	.	.
18637	19465	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19465	2	749	749	CD
18637	19465	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19465	4	As	as	IN
18637	19465	5	to	to	IN
18637	19465	6	the	the	DT
18637	19465	7	presentation	presentation	NN
18637	19465	8	of	of	IN
18637	19465	9	every	every	DT
18637	19465	10	available	available	JJ
18637	19465	11	defense	defense	NN
18637	19465	12	,	,	,
18637	19465	13	however	however	RB
18637	19465	14	,	,	,
18637	19465	15	the	the	DT
18637	19465	16	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	19465	17	of	of	IN
18637	19465	18	due	due	JJ
18637	19465	19	process	process	NN
18637	19465	20	do	do	VBP
18637	19465	21	not	not	RB
18637	19465	22	entail	entail	VB
18637	19465	23	affording	afford	VBG
18637	19465	24	an	an	DT
18637	19465	25	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19465	26	to	to	TO
18637	19465	27	do	do	VB
18637	19465	28	so	so	RB
18637	19465	29	before	before	IN
18637	19465	30	entry	entry	NN
18637	19465	31	of	of	IN
18637	19465	32	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19465	33	.	.	.
18637	19466	1	A	a	DT
18637	19466	2	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19466	3	by	by	IN
18637	19466	4	an	an	DT
18637	19466	5	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	19466	6	may	may	MD
18637	19466	7	suffice	suffice	VB
18637	19466	8	.	.	.
18637	19467	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19467	2	,	,	,
18637	19467	3	a	a	DT
18637	19467	4	surety	surety	NN
18637	19467	5	company	company	NN
18637	19467	6	,	,	,
18637	19467	7	objecting	object	VBG
18637	19467	8	to	to	IN
18637	19467	9	the	the	DT
18637	19467	10	entry	entry	NN
18637	19467	11	of	of	IN
18637	19467	12	a	a	DT
18637	19467	13	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19467	14	against	against	IN
18637	19467	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19467	16	on	on	IN
18637	19467	17	a	a	DT
18637	19467	18	supersedeas	supersedeas	JJ
18637	19467	19	bond	bond	NN
18637	19467	20	,	,	,
18637	19467	21	without	without	IN
18637	19467	22	notice	notice	NN
18637	19467	23	and	and	CC
18637	19467	24	an	an	DT
18637	19467	25	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19467	26	of	of	IN
18637	19467	27	a	a	DT
18637	19467	28	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19467	29	on	on	IN
18637	19467	30	the	the	DT
18637	19467	31	issue	issue	NN
18637	19467	32	of	of	IN
18637	19467	33	liability	liability	NN
18637	19467	34	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	19467	35	,	,	,
18637	19467	36	was	be	VBD
18637	19467	37	not	not	RB
18637	19467	38	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19467	39	due	due	JJ
18637	19467	40	process	process	NN
18637	19467	41	where	where	WRB
18637	19467	42	the	the	DT
18637	19467	43	State	State	NNP
18637	19467	44	practice	practice	NN
18637	19467	45	provided	provide	VBD
18637	19467	46	the	the	DT
18637	19467	47	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19467	48	for	for	IN
18637	19467	49	such	such	JJ
18637	19467	50	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19467	51	by	by	IN
18637	19467	52	an	an	DT
18637	19467	53	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	19467	54	from	from	IN
18637	19467	55	the	the	DT
18637	19467	56	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19467	57	so	so	RB
18637	19467	58	entered	enter	VBD
18637	19467	59	.	.	.
18637	19468	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19468	2	could	could	MD
18637	19468	3	the	the	DT
18637	19468	4	company	company	NN
18637	19468	5	found	find	VBD
18637	19468	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19468	7	claim	claim	NN
18637	19468	8	of	of	IN
18637	19468	9	denial	denial	NN
18637	19468	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	19468	11	the	the	DT
18637	19468	12	fact	fact	NN
18637	19468	13	that	that	IN
18637	19468	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19468	15	lost	lose	VBD
18637	19468	16	this	this	DT
18637	19468	17	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19468	18	for	for	IN
18637	19468	19	a	a	DT
18637	19468	20	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19468	21	by	by	IN
18637	19468	22	inadvertently	inadvertently	RB
18637	19468	23	pursuing	pursue	VBG
18637	19468	24	the	the	DT
18637	19468	25	wrong	wrong	JJ
18637	19468	26	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19468	27	in	in	IN
18637	19468	28	the	the	DT
18637	19468	29	State	State	NNP
18637	19468	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	19468	31	.	.	.
18637	19469	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19469	2	750	750	CD
18637	19469	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19469	4	On	on	IN
18637	19469	5	the	the	DT
18637	19469	6	other	other	JJ
18637	19469	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	19469	8	,	,	,
18637	19469	9	where	where	WRB
18637	19469	10	a	a	DT
18637	19469	11	State	State	NNP
18637	19469	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19469	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19469	14	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	19469	15	a	a	DT
18637	19469	16	trial	trial	NN
18637	19469	17	court	court	NN
18637	19469	18	and	and	CC
18637	19469	19	entered	enter	VBD
18637	19469	20	a	a	DT
18637	19469	21	final	final	JJ
18637	19469	22	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19469	23	for	for	IN
18637	19469	24	the	the	DT
18637	19469	25	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19469	26	,	,	,
18637	19469	27	a	a	DT
18637	19469	28	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	19469	29	who	who	WP
18637	19469	30	had	have	VBD
18637	19469	31	never	never	RB
18637	19469	32	had	have	VBN
18637	19469	33	an	an	DT
18637	19469	34	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19469	35	to	to	TO
18637	19469	36	introduce	introduce	VB
18637	19469	37	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19469	38	in	in	IN
18637	19469	39	rebuttal	rebuttal	NNP
18637	19469	40	to	to	IN
18637	19469	41	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19469	42	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19469	43	which	which	WDT
18637	19469	44	the	the	DT
18637	19469	45	trial	trial	NN
18637	19469	46	court	court	NN
18637	19469	47	deemed	deem	VBD
18637	19469	48	immaterial	immaterial	NNP
18637	19469	49	but	but	CC
18637	19469	50	which	which	WDT
18637	19469	51	the	the	DT
18637	19469	52	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19469	53	court	court	NN
18637	19469	54	considered	consider	VBD
18637	19469	55	material	material	NN
18637	19469	56	,	,	,
18637	19469	57	was	be	VBD
18637	19469	58	held	hold	VBN
18637	19469	59	to	to	TO
18637	19469	60	have	have	VB
18637	19469	61	been	be	VBN
18637	19469	62	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	19469	63	of	of	IN
18637	19469	64	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19469	65	rights	right	NNS
18637	19469	66	without	without	IN
18637	19469	67	due	due	JJ
18637	19469	68	process	process	NN
18637	19469	69	of	of	IN
18637	19469	70	law	law	NN
18637	19469	71	.	.	.
18637	19470	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19470	2	751	751	CD
18637	19470	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19470	4	Sufficiency	Sufficiency	NNP
18637	19470	5	of	of	IN
18637	19470	6	Notice	Notice	NNP
18637	19470	7	and	and	CC
18637	19470	8	Hearing.--Although	hearing.--although	VB
18637	19470	9	the	the	DT
18637	19470	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19470	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19470	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	19470	13	wavered	waver	VBN
18637	19470	14	on	on	IN
18637	19470	15	the	the	DT
18637	19470	16	question	question	NN
18637	19470	17	whether	whether	IN
18637	19470	18	the	the	DT
18637	19470	19	granting	granting	NN
18637	19470	20	of	of	IN
18637	19470	21	notice	notice	NN
18637	19470	22	in	in	IN
18637	19470	23	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	19470	24	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19470	25	,	,	,
18637	19470	26	in	in	IN
18637	19470	27	cases	case	NNS
18637	19470	28	in	in	IN
18637	19470	29	which	which	WDT
18637	19470	30	the	the	DT
18637	19470	31	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	19470	32	statute	statute	NN
18637	19470	33	does	do	VBZ
18637	19470	34	not	not	RB
18637	19470	35	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	19470	36	provide	provide	VB
18637	19470	37	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	19470	38	,	,	,
18637	19470	39	will	will	MD
18637	19470	40	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	19470	41	the	the	DT
18637	19470	42	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	19470	43	of	of	IN
18637	19470	44	due	due	JJ
18637	19470	45	process,[752	process,[752	NNS
18637	19470	46	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19470	47	in	in	IN
18637	19470	48	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19470	49	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19470	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19470	51	has	have	VBZ
18637	19470	52	almost	almost	RB
18637	19470	53	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	19470	54	declared	declare	VBN
18637	19470	55	that	that	IN
18637	19470	56	notice	notice	NN
18637	19470	57	must	must	MD
18637	19470	58	be	be	VB
18637	19470	59	provided	provide	VBN
18637	19470	60	as	as	IN
18637	19470	61	an	an	DT
18637	19470	62	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19470	63	part	part	NN
18637	19470	64	of	of	IN
18637	19470	65	the	the	DT
18637	19470	66	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	19470	67	provision	provision	NN
18637	19470	68	and	and	CC
18637	19470	69	not	not	RB
18637	19470	70	as	as	IN
18637	19470	71	a	a	DT
18637	19470	72	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19470	73	matter	matter	NN
18637	19470	74	of	of	IN
18637	19470	75	favor	favor	NN
18637	19470	76	or	or	CC
18637	19470	77	grace	grace	NN
18637	19470	78	.	.	.
18637	19471	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19471	2	753	753	CD
18637	19471	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19471	4	Also	also	RB
18637	19471	5	,	,	,
18637	19471	6	the	the	DT
18637	19471	7	notice	notice	NN
18637	19471	8	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	19471	9	must	must	MD
18637	19471	10	be	be	VB
18637	19471	11	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19471	12	for	for	IN
18637	19471	13	the	the	DT
18637	19471	14	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	19471	15	.	.	.
18637	19472	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19472	2	,	,	,
18637	19472	3	a	a	DT
18637	19472	4	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	19472	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	19472	6	providing	provide	VBG
18637	19472	7	for	for	IN
18637	19472	8	service	service	NN
18637	19472	9	of	of	IN
18637	19472	10	process	process	NN
18637	19472	11	by	by	IN
18637	19472	12	giving	give	VBG
18637	19472	13	five	five	CD
18637	19472	14	days	day	NNS
18637	19472	15	'	'	POS
18637	19472	16	notice	notice	NN
18637	19472	17	was	be	VBD
18637	19472	18	held	hold	VBN
18637	19472	19	to	to	TO
18637	19472	20	be	be	VB
18637	19472	21	an	an	DT
18637	19472	22	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	19472	23	notice	notice	NN
18637	19472	24	to	to	IN
18637	19472	25	a	a	DT
18637	19472	26	Virginian	Virginian	NNP
18637	19472	27	who	who	WP
18637	19472	28	would	would	MD
18637	19472	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19472	30	at	at	IN
18637	19472	31	that	that	DT
18637	19472	32	time	time	NN
18637	19472	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19472	34	have	have	VBP
18637	19472	35	required	require	VBN
18637	19472	36	four	four	CD
18637	19472	37	days	day	NNS
18637	19472	38	'	'	''
18637	19472	39	traveling	travel	VBG
18637	19472	40	to	to	TO
18637	19472	41	reach	reach	VB
18637	19472	42	the	the	DT
18637	19472	43	place	place	NN
18637	19472	44	where	where	WRB
18637	19472	45	the	the	DT
18637	19472	46	court	court	NN
18637	19472	47	was	be	VBD
18637	19472	48	held	hold	VBN
18637	19472	49	.	.	.
18637	19473	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19473	2	would	would	MD
18637	19473	3	this	this	DT
18637	19473	4	insufficiency	insufficiency	NN
18637	19473	5	of	of	IN
18637	19473	6	notice	notice	NN
18637	19473	7	on	on	IN
18637	19473	8	a	a	DT
18637	19473	9	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19473	10	be	be	VB
18637	19473	11	cured	cure	VBN
18637	19473	12	by	by	IN
18637	19473	13	the	the	DT
18637	19473	14	fact	fact	NN
18637	19473	15	that	that	IN
18637	19473	16	under	under	IN
18637	19473	17	local	local	JJ
18637	19473	18	practice	practice	NN
18637	19473	19	there	there	EX
18637	19473	20	would	would	MD
18637	19473	21	be	be	VB
18637	19473	22	several	several	JJ
18637	19473	23	additional	additional	JJ
18637	19473	24	days	day	NNS
18637	19473	25	before	before	IN
18637	19473	26	the	the	DT
18637	19473	27	case	case	NN
18637	19473	28	would	would	MD
18637	19473	29	be	be	VB
18637	19473	30	called	call	VBN
18637	19473	31	for	for	IN
18637	19473	32	trial	trial	NN
18637	19473	33	or	or	CC
18637	19473	34	that	that	IN
18637	19473	35	the	the	DT
18637	19473	36	court	court	NN
18637	19473	37	would	would	MD
18637	19473	38	probably	probably	RB
18637	19473	39	set	set	VB
18637	19473	40	aside	aside	RP
18637	19473	41	a	a	DT
18637	19473	42	default	default	NN
18637	19473	43	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19473	44	and	and	CC
18637	19473	45	permit	permit	VB
18637	19473	46	a	a	DT
18637	19473	47	defense	defense	NN
18637	19473	48	when	when	WRB
18637	19473	49	the	the	DT
18637	19473	50	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19473	51	arrived	arrive	VBD
18637	19473	52	.	.	.
18637	19474	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19474	2	754	754	CD
18637	19474	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19474	4	On	on	IN
18637	19474	5	the	the	DT
18637	19474	6	other	other	JJ
18637	19474	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	19474	8	,	,	,
18637	19474	9	a	a	DT
18637	19474	10	statute	statute	NN
18637	19474	11	affording	afford	VBG
18637	19474	12	ten	ten	CD
18637	19474	13	days	day	NNS
18637	19474	14	'	'	''
18637	19474	15	notice	notice	NN
18637	19474	16	of	of	IN
18637	19474	17	the	the	DT
18637	19474	18	time	time	NN
18637	19474	19	for	for	IN
18637	19474	20	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	19474	21	of	of	IN
18637	19474	22	the	the	DT
18637	19474	23	account	account	NN
18637	19474	24	of	of	IN
18637	19474	25	a	a	DT
18637	19474	26	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19474	27	representative	representative	NN
18637	19474	28	in	in	IN
18637	19474	29	probate	probate	NN
18637	19474	30	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19474	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	19474	32	not	not	RB
18637	19474	33	wanting	want	VBG
18637	19474	34	in	in	IN
18637	19474	35	due	due	JJ
18637	19474	36	process	process	NN
18637	19474	37	of	of	IN
18637	19474	38	law	law	NN
18637	19474	39	as	as	IN
18637	19474	40	to	to	IN
18637	19474	41	a	a	DT
18637	19474	42	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19474	43	.	.	.
18637	19475	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19475	2	755	755	CD
18637	19475	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19475	4	Adequacy	adequacy	NN
18637	19475	5	,	,	,
18637	19475	6	moreover	moreover	RB
18637	19475	7	,	,	,
18637	19475	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	19475	9	no	no	DT
18637	19475	10	less	less	JJR
18637	19475	11	an	an	DT
18637	19475	12	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19475	13	attribute	attribute	NN
18637	19475	14	of	of	IN
18637	19475	15	a	a	DT
18637	19475	16	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19475	17	than	than	IN
18637	19475	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19475	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	19475	20	of	of	IN
18637	19475	21	notice	notice	NN
18637	19475	22	;	;	:
18637	19475	23	and	and	CC
18637	19475	24	,	,	,
18637	19475	25	as	as	IN
18637	19475	26	the	the	DT
18637	19475	27	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	19475	28	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	19475	29	has	have	VBZ
18637	19475	30	shown	show	VBN
18637	19475	31	,	,	,
18637	19475	32	unless	unless	IN
18637	19475	33	a	a	DT
18637	19475	34	person	person	NN
18637	19475	35	involved	involve	VBN
18637	19475	36	in	in	IN
18637	19475	37	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	19475	38	as	as	RB
18637	19475	39	well	well	RB
18637	19475	40	as	as	IN
18637	19475	41	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19475	42	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19475	43	has	have	VBZ
18637	19475	44	received	receive	VBN
18637	19475	45	a	a	DT
18637	19475	46	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19475	47	that	that	WDT
18637	19475	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	19475	49	both	both	CC
18637	19475	50	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19475	51	and	and	CC
18637	19475	52	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19475	53	and	and	CC
18637	19475	54	has	have	VBZ
18637	19475	55	been	be	VBN
18637	19475	56	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	19475	57	to	to	IN
18637	19475	58	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	19475	59	amply	amply	RB
18637	19475	60	supported	support	VBN
18637	19475	61	by	by	IN
18637	19475	62	the	the	DT
18637	19475	63	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19475	64	introduced	introduce	VBN
18637	19475	65	thereat	thereat	IN
18637	19475	66	,	,	,
18637	19475	67	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19475	68	will	will	MD
18637	19475	69	not	not	RB
18637	19475	70	be	be	VB
18637	19475	71	considered	consider	VBN
18637	19475	72	to	to	TO
18637	19475	73	have	have	VB
18637	19475	74	been	be	VBN
18637	19475	75	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	19475	76	due	due	JJ
18637	19475	77	process	process	NN
18637	19475	78	.	.	.
18637	19476	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19476	2	756	756	CD
18637	19476	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19476	4	POWER	power	NN
18637	19476	5	OF	of	IN
18637	19476	6	STATES	state	NNS
18637	19476	7	TO	to	TO
18637	19476	8	REGULATE	REGULATE	NNP
18637	19476	9	PROCEDURE	PROCEDURE	NNP
18637	19476	10	Generally	generally	RB
18637	19476	11	The	the	DT
18637	19476	12	due	due	JJ
18637	19476	13	process	process	NN
18637	19476	14	clause	clause	NN
18637	19476	15	of	of	IN
18637	19476	16	the	the	DT
18637	19476	17	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19476	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19476	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	19476	20	not	not	RB
18637	19476	21	control	control	VB
18637	19476	22	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19476	23	forms	form	NNS
18637	19476	24	of	of	IN
18637	19476	25	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19476	26	in	in	IN
18637	19476	27	State	state	NN
18637	19476	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	19476	29	or	or	CC
18637	19476	30	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	19476	31	practice	practice	NN
18637	19476	32	therein	therein	RB
18637	19476	33	.	.	.
18637	19477	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19477	2	757	757	CD
18637	19477	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19477	4	A	a	DT
18637	19477	5	State	state	NN
18637	19477	6	"	"	''
18637	19477	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19477	8	free	free	JJ
18637	19477	9	to	to	TO
18637	19477	10	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	19477	11	the	the	DT
18637	19477	12	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19477	13	of	of	IN
18637	19477	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19477	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	19477	16	in	in	IN
18637	19477	17	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	19477	18	with	with	IN
18637	19477	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19477	20	own	own	JJ
18637	19477	21	conception	conception	NN
18637	19477	22	of	of	IN
18637	19477	23	policy	policy	NN
18637	19477	24	and	and	CC
18637	19477	25	fairness	fairness	NN
18637	19477	26	unless	unless	IN
18637	19477	27	in	in	IN
18637	19477	28	so	so	RB
18637	19477	29	doing	do	VBG
18637	19477	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19477	31	offends	offend	VBZ
18637	19477	32	some	some	DT
18637	19477	33	principle	principle	NN
18637	19477	34	of	of	IN
18637	19477	35	justice	justice	NN
18637	19477	36	so	so	RB
18637	19477	37	rooted	root	VBN
18637	19477	38	in	in	IN
18637	19477	39	the	the	DT
18637	19477	40	traditions	tradition	NNS
18637	19477	41	and	and	CC
18637	19477	42	conscience	conscience	NN
18637	19477	43	of	of	IN
18637	19477	44	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19477	45	people	people	NNS
18637	19477	46	as	as	IN
18637	19477	47	to	to	TO
18637	19477	48	be	be	VB
18637	19477	49	ranked	rank	VBN
18637	19477	50	as	as	IN
18637	19477	51	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19477	52	.	.	.
18637	19478	1	"	"	``
18637	19478	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19478	3	758	758	CD
18637	19478	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19478	5	Pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	19478	6	to	to	IN
18637	19478	7	such	such	JJ
18637	19478	8	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	19478	9	power	power	NN
18637	19478	10	,	,	,
18637	19478	11	States	state	NNS
18637	19478	12	have	have	VBP
18637	19478	13	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	19478	14	the	the	DT
18637	19478	15	manner	manner	NN
18637	19478	16	in	in	IN
18637	19478	17	which	which	WDT
18637	19478	18	rights	right	NNS
18637	19478	19	may	may	MD
18637	19478	20	be	be	VB
18637	19478	21	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	19478	22	and	and	CC
18637	19478	23	wrongs	wrong	NNS
18637	19478	24	remedied,[759	remedied,[759	NNP
18637	19478	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19478	26	and	and	CC
18637	19478	27	,	,	,
18637	19478	28	in	in	IN
18637	19478	29	connection	connection	NN
18637	19478	30	therewith	therewith	NN
18637	19478	31	,	,	,
18637	19478	32	have	have	VBP
18637	19478	33	created	create	VBN
18637	19478	34	courts	court	NNS
18637	19478	35	and	and	CC
18637	19478	36	endowed	endow	VBD
18637	19478	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19478	38	with	with	IN
18637	19478	39	such	such	JJ
18637	19478	40	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19478	41	as	as	IN
18637	19478	42	,	,	,
18637	19478	43	in	in	IN
18637	19478	44	the	the	DT
18637	19478	45	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19478	46	of	of	IN
18637	19478	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19478	48	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	19478	49	,	,	,
18637	19478	50	seemed	seem	VBD
18637	19478	51	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	19478	52	.	.	.
18637	19479	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19479	2	760	760	CD
18637	19479	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19479	4	Whether	whether	IN
18637	19479	5	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19479	6	action	action	NN
18637	19479	7	in	in	IN
18637	19479	8	such	such	JJ
18637	19479	9	matters	matter	NNS
18637	19479	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	19479	11	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19479	12	to	to	TO
18637	19479	13	be	be	VB
18637	19479	14	wise	wise	JJ
18637	19479	15	or	or	CC
18637	19479	16	proves	prove	VBZ
18637	19479	17	efficient	efficient	JJ
18637	19479	18	,	,	,
18637	19479	19	whether	whether	IN
18637	19479	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19479	21	works	work	VBZ
18637	19479	22	a	a	DT
18637	19479	23	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19479	24	hardship	hardship	NN
18637	19479	25	on	on	IN
18637	19479	26	a	a	DT
18637	19479	27	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19479	28	litigant	litigant	NN
18637	19479	29	,	,	,
18637	19479	30	or	or	CC
18637	19479	31	perpetuates	perpetuate	NNS
18637	19479	32	or	or	CC
18637	19479	33	supplants	supplant	NNS
18637	19479	34	ancient	ancient	JJ
18637	19479	35	forms	form	NNS
18637	19479	36	of	of	IN
18637	19479	37	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19479	38	are	be	VBP
18637	19479	39	issues	issue	NNS
18637	19479	40	which	which	WDT
18637	19479	41	can	can	MD
18637	19479	42	give	give	VB
18637	19479	43	rise	rise	NN
18637	19479	44	to	to	IN
18637	19479	45	no	no	DT
18637	19479	46	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	19479	47	with	with	IN
18637	19479	48	the	the	DT
18637	19479	49	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19479	50	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19479	51	;	;	:
18637	19479	52	for	for	IN
18637	19479	53	the	the	DT
18637	19479	54	latter	latter	NN
18637	19479	55	's	's	POS
18637	19479	56	function	function	NN
18637	19479	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	19479	58	negative	negative	JJ
18637	19479	59	rather	rather	RB
18637	19479	60	than	than	IN
18637	19479	61	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	19479	62	and	and	CC
18637	19479	63	in	in	IN
18637	19479	64	no	no	DT
18637	19479	65	way	way	NN
18637	19479	66	obligates	obligate	VBZ
18637	19479	67	the	the	DT
18637	19479	68	States	States	NNPS
18637	19479	69	to	to	TO
18637	19479	70	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	19479	71	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19479	72	measures	measure	NNS
18637	19479	73	of	of	IN
18637	19479	74	reform	reform	NN
18637	19479	75	.	.	.
18637	19480	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19480	2	761	761	CD
18637	19480	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19480	4	Pleading	pleading	NN
18637	19480	5	and	and	CC
18637	19480	6	Practice	Practice	NNP
18637	19480	7	Commencement	Commencement	NNP
18637	19480	8	Of	of	IN
18637	19480	9	Actions.--A	actions.--a	XX
18637	19480	10	State	state	NN
18637	19480	11	may	may	MD
18637	19480	12	impose	impose	VB
18637	19480	13	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19480	14	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19480	15	on	on	IN
18637	19480	16	the	the	DT
18637	19480	17	right	right	NN
18637	19480	18	to	to	IN
18637	19480	19	institute	institute	VB
18637	19480	20	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	19480	21	.	.	.
18637	19481	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19481	2	,	,	,
18637	19481	3	access	access	NN
18637	19481	4	to	to	IN
18637	19481	5	the	the	DT
18637	19481	6	courts	court	NNS
18637	19481	7	may	may	MD
18637	19481	8	be	be	VB
18637	19481	9	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19481	10	to	to	IN
18637	19481	11	persons	person	NNS
18637	19481	12	instituting	instituting	NN
18637	19481	13	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	19481	14	'	'	POS
18637	19481	15	derivative	derivative	JJ
18637	19481	16	actions	action	NNS
18637	19481	17	unless	unless	IN
18637	19481	18	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19481	19	security	security	NN
18637	19481	20	for	for	IN
18637	19481	21	the	the	DT
18637	19481	22	costs	cost	NNS
18637	19481	23	,	,	,
18637	19481	24	and	and	CC
18637	19481	25	fees	fee	NNS
18637	19481	26	incurred	incur	VBN
18637	19481	27	by	by	IN
18637	19481	28	the	the	DT
18637	19481	29	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19481	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	19481	31	first	first	RB
18637	19481	32	tendered	tender	VBN
18637	19481	33	.	.	.
18637	19482	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19482	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	19482	3	the	the	DT
18637	19482	4	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	19482	5	application	application	NN
18637	19482	6	of	of	IN
18637	19482	7	this	this	DT
18637	19482	8	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	19482	9	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19482	10	to	to	IN
18637	19482	11	actions	action	NNS
18637	19482	12	pending	pende	VBG
18637	19482	13	at	at	IN
18637	19482	14	the	the	DT
18637	19482	15	time	time	NN
18637	19482	16	of	of	IN
18637	19482	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19482	18	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	19482	19	violative	violative	NN
18637	19482	20	of	of	IN
18637	19482	21	due	due	JJ
18637	19482	22	process	process	NN
18637	19482	23	as	as	RB
18637	19482	24	long	long	RB
18637	19482	25	as	as	IN
18637	19482	26	no	no	DT
18637	19482	27	new	new	JJ
18637	19482	28	liability	liability	NN
18637	19482	29	for	for	IN
18637	19482	30	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	19482	31	incurred	incur	VBN
18637	19482	32	before	before	IN
18637	19482	33	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	19482	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	19482	35	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19482	36	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	19482	37	,	,	,
18637	19482	38	and	and	CC
18637	19482	39	the	the	DT
18637	19482	40	only	only	JJ
18637	19482	41	effect	effect	NN
18637	19482	42	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19482	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	19482	44	to	to	TO
18637	19482	45	stay	stay	VB
18637	19482	46	such	such	JJ
18637	19482	47	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19482	48	until	until	IN
18637	19482	49	the	the	DT
18637	19482	50	security	security	NN
18637	19482	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	19482	52	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	19482	53	.	.	.
18637	19483	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19483	2	762	762	CD
18637	19483	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19483	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	19483	5	,	,	,
18637	19483	6	when	when	WRB
18637	19483	7	a	a	DT
18637	19483	8	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19483	9	files	file	NNS
18637	19483	10	suit	suit	NN
18637	19483	11	in	in	IN
18637	19483	12	a	a	DT
18637	19483	13	local	local	JJ
18637	19483	14	court	court	NN
18637	19483	15	,	,	,
18637	19483	16	the	the	DT
18637	19483	17	State	State	NNP
18637	19483	18	,	,	,
18637	19483	19	as	as	IN
18637	19483	20	the	the	DT
18637	19483	21	price	price	NN
18637	19483	22	of	of	IN
18637	19483	23	opening	open	VBG
18637	19483	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19483	25	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	19483	26	to	to	IN
18637	19483	27	such	such	JJ
18637	19483	28	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	19483	29	,	,	,
18637	19483	30	may	may	MD
18637	19483	31	exact	exact	VB
18637	19483	32	the	the	DT
18637	19483	33	condition	condition	NN
18637	19483	34	that	that	IN
18637	19483	35	the	the	DT
18637	19483	36	former	former	JJ
18637	19483	37	stand	stand	NN
18637	19483	38	ready	ready	JJ
18637	19483	39	to	to	TO
18637	19483	40	answer	answer	VB
18637	19483	41	all	all	DT
18637	19483	42	cross	cross	NN
18637	19483	43	-	-	NNS
18637	19483	44	actions	action	NNS
18637	19483	45	filed	file	VBD
18637	19483	46	and	and	CC
18637	19483	47	accept	accept	VBP
18637	19483	48	any	any	DT
18637	19483	49	_	_	NNP
18637	19483	50	in	in	IN
18637	19483	51	personam	personam	NNP
18637	19483	52	_	_	NNP
18637	19483	53	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	19483	54	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19483	55	by	by	IN
18637	19483	56	a	a	DT
18637	19483	57	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19483	58	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19483	59	through	through	IN
18637	19483	60	service	service	NN
18637	19483	61	of	of	IN
18637	19483	62	process	process	NN
18637	19483	63	or	or	CC
18637	19483	64	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	19483	65	pleading	pleading	NN
18637	19483	66	upon	upon	IN
18637	19483	67	the	the	DT
18637	19483	68	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	19483	69	's	's	POS
18637	19483	70	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	19483	71	of	of	IN
18637	19483	72	record	record	NN
18637	19483	73	.	.	.
18637	19484	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19484	2	763	763	CD
18637	19484	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19484	4	For	for	IN
18637	19484	5	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19484	6	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	19484	7	,	,	,
18637	19484	8	the	the	DT
18637	19484	9	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	19484	10	,	,	,
18637	19484	11	without	without	IN
18637	19484	12	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	19484	13	other	other	JJ
18637	19484	14	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19484	15	,	,	,
18637	19484	16	of	of	IN
18637	19484	17	a	a	DT
18637	19484	18	chemical	chemical	NN
18637	19484	19	analysis	analysis	NN
18637	19484	20	as	as	IN
18637	19484	21	a	a	DT
18637	19484	22	condition	condition	NN
18637	19484	23	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	19484	24	to	to	IN
18637	19484	25	a	a	DT
18637	19484	26	suit	suit	NN
18637	19484	27	to	to	TO
18637	19484	28	recover	recover	VB
18637	19484	29	damages	damage	NNS
18637	19484	30	resulting	result	VBG
18637	19484	31	to	to	IN
18637	19484	32	crops	crop	NNS
18637	19484	33	from	from	IN
18637	19484	34	allegedly	allegedly	RB
18637	19484	35	deficient	deficient	JJ
18637	19484	36	fertilizers	fertilizer	NNS
18637	19484	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	19484	38	not	not	RB
18637	19484	39	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19484	40	to	to	TO
18637	19484	41	be	be	VB
18637	19484	42	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19484	43	or	or	CC
18637	19484	44	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19484	45	.	.	.
18637	19485	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19485	2	764	764	CD
18637	19485	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19485	4	Pleas	pleas	NN
18637	19485	5	in	in	IN
18637	19485	6	Abatement.--State	Abatement.--State	NNP
18637	19485	7	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19485	8	which	which	WDT
18637	19485	9	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	19485	10	a	a	DT
18637	19485	11	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19485	12	to	to	TO
18637	19485	13	come	come	VB
18637	19485	14	into	into	IN
18637	19485	15	court	court	NN
18637	19485	16	and	and	CC
18637	19485	17	challenge	challenge	VB
18637	19485	18	the	the	DT
18637	19485	19	validity	validity	NN
18637	19485	20	of	of	IN
18637	19485	21	service	service	NN
18637	19485	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	19485	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19485	24	in	in	IN
18637	19485	25	a	a	DT
18637	19485	26	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19485	27	action	action	NN
18637	19485	28	without	without	IN
18637	19485	29	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	19485	30	surrendering	surrender	VBG
18637	19485	31	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19485	32	to	to	IN
18637	19485	33	the	the	DT
18637	19485	34	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19485	35	of	of	IN
18637	19485	36	the	the	DT
18637	19485	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19485	38	,	,	,
18637	19485	39	but	but	CC
18637	19485	40	which	which	WDT
18637	19485	41	does	do	VBZ
18637	19485	42	not	not	RB
18637	19485	43	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	19485	44	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19485	45	from	from	IN
18637	19485	46	protecting	protect	VBG
18637	19485	47	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19485	48	substantive	substantive	JJ
18637	19485	49	rights	right	NNS
18637	19485	50	against	against	IN
18637	19485	51	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	19485	52	of	of	IN
18637	19485	53	a	a	DT
18637	19485	54	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19485	55	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19485	56	without	without	IN
18637	19485	57	service	service	NN
18637	19485	58	of	of	IN
18637	19485	59	process	process	NN
18637	19485	60	,	,	,
18637	19485	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	19485	62	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19485	63	and	and	CC
18637	19485	64	does	do	VBZ
18637	19485	65	not	not	RB
18637	19485	66	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	19485	67	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19485	68	of	of	IN
18637	19485	69	property	property	NN
18637	19485	70	without	without	IN
18637	19485	71	due	due	JJ
18637	19485	72	process	process	NN
18637	19485	73	of	of	IN
18637	19485	74	law	law	NN
18637	19485	75	.	.	.
18637	19486	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	19486	2	a	a	DT
18637	19486	3	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19486	4	,	,	,
18637	19486	5	if	if	IN
18637	19486	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19486	7	please	please	UH
18637	19486	8	,	,	,
18637	19486	9	may	may	MD
18637	19486	10	ignore	ignore	VB
18637	19486	11	the	the	DT
18637	19486	12	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19486	13	as	as	IN
18637	19486	14	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	19486	15	ineffective	ineffective	JJ
18637	19486	16	,	,	,
18637	19486	17	and	and	CC
18637	19486	18	set	set	VB
18637	19486	19	up	up	RP
18637	19486	20	the	the	DT
18637	19486	21	invalidity	invalidity	NN
18637	19486	22	of	of	IN
18637	19486	23	the	the	DT
18637	19486	24	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19486	25	if	if	IN
18637	19486	26	and	and	CC
18637	19486	27	when	when	WRB
18637	19486	28	an	an	DT
18637	19486	29	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	19486	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	19486	31	made	make	VBN
18637	19486	32	to	to	TO
18637	19486	33	take	take	VB
18637	19486	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19486	35	property	property	NN
18637	19486	36	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	19486	37	.	.	.
18637	19487	1	However	however	RB
18637	19487	2	,	,	,
18637	19487	3	if	if	IN
18637	19487	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19487	5	desires	desire	VBZ
18637	19487	6	to	to	TO
18637	19487	7	contest	contest	VB
18637	19487	8	the	the	DT
18637	19487	9	validity	validity	NN
18637	19487	10	of	of	IN
18637	19487	11	the	the	DT
18637	19487	12	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19487	13	in	in	IN
18637	19487	14	the	the	DT
18637	19487	15	court	court	NN
18637	19487	16	in	in	IN
18637	19487	17	which	which	WDT
18637	19487	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19487	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	19487	20	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	19487	21	,	,	,
18637	19487	22	so	so	IN
18637	19487	23	as	as	IN
18637	19487	24	to	to	TO
18637	19487	25	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	19487	26	even	even	RB
18637	19487	27	semblance	semblance	NN
18637	19487	28	of	of	IN
18637	19487	29	a	a	DT
18637	19487	30	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19487	31	against	against	IN
18637	19487	32	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19487	33	,	,	,
18637	19487	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19487	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	19487	36	within	within	IN
18637	19487	37	the	the	DT
18637	19487	38	power	power	NN
18637	19487	39	of	of	IN
18637	19487	40	a	a	DT
18637	19487	41	State	State	NNP
18637	19487	42	to	to	TO
18637	19487	43	declare	declare	VB
18637	19487	44	that	that	IN
18637	19487	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19487	46	shall	shall	MD
18637	19487	47	do	do	VB
18637	19487	48	this	this	DT
18637	19487	49	subject	subject	NN
18637	19487	50	to	to	IN
18637	19487	51	the	the	DT
18637	19487	52	risk	risk	NN
18637	19487	53	of	of	IN
18637	19487	54	being	be	VBG
18637	19487	55	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	19487	56	to	to	TO
18637	19487	57	submit	submit	VB
18637	19487	58	to	to	IN
18637	19487	59	the	the	DT
18637	19487	60	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19487	61	of	of	IN
18637	19487	62	the	the	DT
18637	19487	63	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19487	64	to	to	TO
18637	19487	65	hear	hear	VB
18637	19487	66	and	and	CC
18637	19487	67	determine	determine	VB
18637	19487	68	the	the	DT
18637	19487	69	merits	merit	NNS
18637	19487	70	,	,	,
18637	19487	71	if	if	IN
18637	19487	72	the	the	DT
18637	19487	73	objection	objection	NN
18637	19487	74	raised	raise	VBD
18637	19487	75	by	by	IN
18637	19487	76	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19487	77	as	as	IN
18637	19487	78	to	to	IN
18637	19487	79	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19487	80	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19487	81	over	over	IN
18637	19487	82	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19487	83	person	person	NN
18637	19487	84	shall	shall	MD
18637	19487	85	be	be	VB
18637	19487	86	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	19487	87	.	.	.
18637	19488	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19488	2	765	765	CD
18637	19488	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19488	4	Defenses.--Just	Defenses.--Just	,
18637	19488	5	as	as	IN
18637	19488	6	the	the	DT
18637	19488	7	State	State	NNP
18637	19488	8	may	may	MD
18637	19488	9	condition	condition	VB
18637	19488	10	the	the	DT
18637	19488	11	right	right	NN
18637	19488	12	to	to	IN
18637	19488	13	institute	institute	VB
18637	19488	14	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	19488	15	,	,	,
18637	19488	16	so	so	CC
18637	19488	17	may	may	MD
18637	19488	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19488	19	establish	establish	VB
18637	19488	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19488	21	terms	term	NNS
18637	19488	22	for	for	IN
18637	19488	23	the	the	DT
18637	19488	24	interposition	interposition	NN
18637	19488	25	of	of	IN
18637	19488	26	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19488	27	defenses	defense	NNS
18637	19488	28	.	.	.
18637	19489	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19489	2	,	,	,
18637	19489	3	by	by	IN
18637	19489	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	19489	5	a	a	DT
18637	19489	6	State	state	NN
18637	19489	7	validly	validly	RB
18637	19489	8	may	may	MD
18637	19489	9	provide	provide	VB
18637	19489	10	that	that	IN
18637	19489	11	one	one	CD
18637	19489	12	sued	sue	VBD
18637	19489	13	in	in	IN
18637	19489	14	a	a	DT
18637	19489	15	possessory	possessory	JJ
18637	19489	16	action	action	NN
18637	19489	17	can	can	MD
18637	19489	18	not	not	RB
18637	19489	19	bring	bring	VB
18637	19489	20	an	an	DT
18637	19489	21	action	action	NN
18637	19489	22	to	to	TO
18637	19489	23	try	try	VB
18637	19489	24	title	title	NN
18637	19489	25	until	until	IN
18637	19489	26	after	after	IN
18637	19489	27	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19489	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	19489	29	have	have	VB
18637	19489	30	been	be	VBN
18637	19489	31	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19489	32	in	in	IN
18637	19489	33	the	the	DT
18637	19489	34	possessory	possessory	JJ
18637	19489	35	action	action	NN
18637	19489	36	,	,	,
18637	19489	37	and	and	CC
18637	19489	38	until	until	IN
18637	19489	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19489	40	shall	shall	MD
18637	19489	41	have	have	VB
18637	19489	42	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19489	43	the	the	DT
18637	19489	44	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19489	45	,	,	,
18637	19489	46	if	if	IN
18637	19489	47	the	the	DT
18637	19489	48	decision	decision	NN
18637	19489	49	shall	shall	MD
18637	19489	50	have	have	VB
18637	19489	51	so	so	RB
18637	19489	52	awarded	award	VBN
18637	19489	53	.	.	.
18637	19490	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19490	2	766	766	CD
18637	19490	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19490	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19490	5	,	,	,
18637	19490	6	a	a	DT
18637	19490	7	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19490	8	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19490	9	in	in	IN
18637	19490	10	a	a	DT
18637	19490	11	suit	suit	NN
18637	19490	12	begun	begin	VBN
18637	19490	13	by	by	IN
18637	19490	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19490	15	attachment	attachment	NN
18637	19490	16	,	,	,
18637	19490	17	even	even	RB
18637	19490	18	though	though	IN
18637	19490	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19490	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	19490	21	no	no	DT
18637	19490	22	resources	resource	NNS
18637	19490	23	or	or	CC
18637	19490	24	credit	credit	NN
18637	19490	25	other	other	JJ
18637	19490	26	than	than	IN
18637	19490	27	the	the	DT
18637	19490	28	property	property	NN
18637	19490	29	attached	attach	VBN
18637	19490	30	,	,	,
18637	19490	31	can	can	MD
18637	19490	32	not	not	RB
18637	19490	33	successfully	successfully	RB
18637	19490	34	challenge	challenge	VB
18637	19490	35	the	the	DT
18637	19490	36	validity	validity	NN
18637	19490	37	of	of	IN
18637	19490	38	a	a	DT
18637	19490	39	statute	statute	NN
18637	19490	40	which	which	WDT
18637	19490	41	requires	require	VBZ
18637	19490	42	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19490	43	to	to	TO
18637	19490	44	give	give	VB
18637	19490	45	bail	bail	NN
18637	19490	46	or	or	CC
18637	19490	47	security	security	NN
18637	19490	48	for	for	IN
18637	19490	49	the	the	DT
18637	19490	50	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	19490	51	of	of	IN
18637	19490	52	the	the	DT
18637	19490	53	seized	seize	VBN
18637	19490	54	property	property	NN
18637	19490	55	before	before	IN
18637	19490	56	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	19490	57	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19490	58	an	an	DT
18637	19490	59	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19490	60	to	to	TO
18637	19490	61	appear	appear	VB
18637	19490	62	and	and	CC
18637	19490	63	defend	defend	VB
18637	19490	64	.	.	.
18637	19491	1	"	"	``
18637	19491	2	The	the	DT
18637	19491	3	condition	condition	NN
18637	19491	4	imposed	impose	VBD
18637	19491	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	19491	6	a	a	DT
18637	19491	7	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19491	8	relation	relation	NN
18637	19491	9	to	to	IN
18637	19491	10	the	the	DT
18637	19491	11	conversion	conversion	NN
18637	19491	12	of	of	IN
18637	19491	13	a	a	DT
18637	19491	14	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19491	15	_	_	NNP
18637	19491	16	quasi	quasi	NNP
18637	19491	17	in	in	IN
18637	19491	18	rem	rem	NNP
18637	19491	19	_	_	NNP
18637	19491	20	into	into	IN
18637	19491	21	an	an	DT
18637	19491	22	action	action	NN
18637	19491	23	_	_	NNP
18637	19491	24	in	in	IN
18637	19491	25	personam	personam	NNP
18637	19491	26	_	_	NNP
18637	19491	27	;	;	:
18637	19491	28	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19491	29	and	and	CC
18637	19491	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19491	31	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
18637	19491	32	*	*	NFP
18637	19491	33	*	*	NFP
18637	19491	34	*	*	NFP
18637	19491	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	19491	36	not	not	RB
18637	19491	37	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	19491	38	to	to	TO
18637	19491	39	comply	comply	VB
18637	19491	40	with--	with--	CD
18637	19491	41	*	*	NFP
18637	19491	42	*	*	NFP
18637	19491	43	*	*	NFP
18637	19491	44	"	"	''
18637	19491	45	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19491	46	767	767	CD
18637	19491	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19491	48	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	19491	49	and	and	CC
18637	19491	50	Continuances.--Amendment	continuances.--amendment	NN
18637	19491	51	of	of	IN
18637	19491	52	pleadings	pleading	NNS
18637	19491	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	19491	54	largely	largely	RB
18637	19491	55	within	within	IN
18637	19491	56	the	the	DT
18637	19491	57	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	19491	58	of	of	IN
18637	19491	59	the	the	DT
18637	19491	60	trial	trial	NN
18637	19491	61	court	court	NN
18637	19491	62	,	,	,
18637	19491	63	and	and	CC
18637	19491	64	unless	unless	IN
18637	19491	65	a	a	DT
18637	19491	66	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19491	67	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	19491	68	of	of	IN
18637	19491	69	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	19491	70	is	be	VBZ
18637	19491	71	shown	show	VBN
18637	19491	72	,	,	,
18637	19491	73	there	there	EX
18637	19491	74	is	be	VBZ
18637	19491	75	no	no	DT
18637	19491	76	ground	ground	NN
18637	19491	77	for	for	IN
18637	19491	78	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	19491	79	;	;	,
18637	19491	80	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19491	81	,	,	,
18637	19491	82	where	where	WRB
18637	19491	83	the	the	DT
18637	19491	84	defense	defense	NN
18637	19491	85	sought	seek	VBD
18637	19491	86	to	to	TO
18637	19491	87	be	be	VB
18637	19491	88	interposed	interpose	VBN
18637	19491	89	is	be	VBZ
18637	19491	90	without	without	IN
18637	19491	91	merit	merit	NN
18637	19491	92	,	,	,
18637	19491	93	a	a	DT
18637	19491	94	claim	claim	NN
18637	19491	95	that	that	IN
18637	19491	96	due	due	JJ
18637	19491	97	process	process	NN
18637	19491	98	would	would	MD
18637	19491	99	be	be	VB
18637	19491	100	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19491	101	by	by	IN
18637	19491	102	rendition	rendition	NN
18637	19491	103	of	of	IN
18637	19491	104	a	a	DT
18637	19491	105	foreclosure	foreclosure	NN
18637	19491	106	decree	decree	NN
18637	19491	107	without	without	IN
18637	19491	108	leave	leave	NN
18637	19491	109	to	to	TO
18637	19491	110	file	file	VB
18637	19491	111	a	a	DT
18637	19491	112	supplementary	supplementary	JJ
18637	19491	113	answer	answer	NN
18637	19491	114	is	be	VBZ
18637	19491	115	utterly	utterly	RB
18637	19491	116	without	without	IN
18637	19491	117	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	19491	118	.	.	.
18637	19492	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19492	2	768	768	CD
18637	19492	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19492	4	Costs	cost	NNS
18637	19492	5	,	,	,
18637	19492	6	Damages	damage	NNS
18637	19492	7	,	,	,
18637	19492	8	and	and	CC
18637	19492	9	Penalties.--What	penalties.--what	JJ
18637	19492	10	costs	cost	NNS
18637	19492	11	are	be	VBP
18637	19492	12	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	19492	13	by	by	IN
18637	19492	14	law	law	NN
18637	19492	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	19492	16	for	for	IN
18637	19492	17	the	the	DT
18637	19492	18	court	court	NN
18637	19492	19	to	to	TO
18637	19492	20	determine	determine	VB
18637	19492	21	;	;	,
18637	19492	22	and	and	CC
18637	19492	23	an	an	DT
18637	19492	24	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
18637	19492	25	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19492	26	of	of	IN
18637	19492	27	what	what	WP
18637	19492	28	the	the	DT
18637	19492	29	law	law	NN
18637	19492	30	allows	allow	VBZ
18637	19492	31	does	do	VBZ
18637	19492	32	not	not	RB
18637	19492	33	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	19492	34	a	a	DT
18637	19492	35	party	party	NN
18637	19492	36	of	of	IN
18637	19492	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19492	38	property	property	NN
18637	19492	39	without	without	IN
18637	19492	40	due	due	JJ
18637	19492	41	process	process	NN
18637	19492	42	of	of	IN
18637	19492	43	law	law	NN
18637	19492	44	.	.	.
18637	19493	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19493	2	769	769	CD
18637	19493	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19493	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19493	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	19493	6	a	a	DT
18637	19493	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	19493	8	providing	provide	VBG
18637	19493	9	for	for	IN
18637	19493	10	the	the	DT
18637	19493	11	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	19493	12	of	of	IN
18637	19493	13	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19493	14	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	19493	15	's	's	POS
18637	19493	16	fees	fee	NNS
18637	19493	17	in	in	IN
18637	19493	18	actions	action	NNS
18637	19493	19	on	on	IN
18637	19493	20	small	small	JJ
18637	19493	21	claims	claim	NNS
18637	19493	22	subject	subject	VBP
18637	19493	23	unsuccessful	unsuccessful	JJ
18637	19493	24	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	19493	25	to	to	IN
18637	19493	26	any	any	DT
18637	19493	27	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19493	28	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19493	29	.	.	.
18637	19494	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19494	2	770	770	CD
18637	19494	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19494	4	Equally	equally	RB
18637	19494	5	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	19494	6	with	with	IN
18637	19494	7	the	the	DT
18637	19494	8	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	19494	9	of	of	IN
18637	19494	10	due	due	JJ
18637	19494	11	process	process	NN
18637	19494	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	19494	13	a	a	DT
18637	19494	14	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	19494	15	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19494	16	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	19494	17	a	a	DT
18637	19494	18	prosecutor	prosecutor	NN
18637	19494	19	of	of	IN
18637	19494	20	a	a	DT
18637	19494	21	case	case	NN
18637	19494	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	19494	23	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
18637	19494	24	liable	liable	JJ
18637	19494	25	for	for	IN
18637	19494	26	costs	cost	NNS
18637	19494	27	,	,	,
18637	19494	28	and	and	CC
18637	19494	29	committed	commit	VBN
18637	19494	30	to	to	IN
18637	19494	31	jail	jail	NN
18637	19494	32	in	in	IN
18637	19494	33	default	default	NN
18637	19494	34	of	of	IN
18637	19494	35	payment	payment	NN
18637	19494	36	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19494	37	,	,	,
18637	19494	38	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	19494	39	the	the	DT
18637	19494	40	court	court	NN
18637	19494	41	or	or	CC
18637	19494	42	jury	jury	NN
18637	19494	43	,	,	,
18637	19494	44	after	after	IN
18637	19494	45	according	accord	VBG
18637	19494	46	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19494	47	an	an	DT
18637	19494	48	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19494	49	to	to	TO
18637	19494	50	present	present	VB
18637	19494	51	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19494	52	of	of	IN
18637	19494	53	good	good	JJ
18637	19494	54	faith	faith	NN
18637	19494	55	,	,	,
18637	19494	56	finds	find	VBZ
18637	19494	57	that	that	IN
18637	19494	58	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19494	59	instituted	institute	VBD
18637	19494	60	the	the	DT
18637	19494	61	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	19494	62	without	without	IN
18637	19494	63	probable	probable	JJ
18637	19494	64	cause	cause	NN
18637	19494	65	and	and	CC
18637	19494	66	from	from	IN
18637	19494	67	malicious	malicious	JJ
18637	19494	68	motives	motive	NNS
18637	19494	69	.	.	.
18637	19495	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19495	2	771	771	CD
18637	19495	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19495	4	Also	also	RB
18637	19495	5	,	,	,
18637	19495	6	as	as	IN
18637	19495	7	a	a	DT
18637	19495	8	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19495	9	incentive	incentive	NN
18637	19495	10	for	for	IN
18637	19495	11	prompt	prompt	JJ
18637	19495	12	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	19495	13	without	without	IN
18637	19495	14	suit	suit	NN
18637	19495	15	of	of	IN
18637	19495	16	just	just	RB
18637	19495	17	demands	demand	NNS
18637	19495	18	of	of	IN
18637	19495	19	a	a	DT
18637	19495	20	class	class	NN
18637	19495	21	admitting	admitting	NN
18637	19495	22	of	of	IN
18637	19495	23	special	special	JJ
18637	19495	24	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19495	25	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	19495	26	,	,	,
18637	19495	27	such	such	JJ
18637	19495	28	as	as	IN
18637	19495	29	common	common	JJ
18637	19495	30	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19495	31	and	and	CC
18637	19495	32	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19495	33	companies	company	NNS
18637	19495	34	together	together	RB
18637	19495	35	with	with	IN
18637	19495	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19495	37	patrons	patron	NNS
18637	19495	38	,	,	,
18637	19495	39	a	a	DT
18637	19495	40	State	state	NN
18637	19495	41	through	through	IN
18637	19495	42	the	the	DT
18637	19495	43	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19495	44	of	of	IN
18637	19495	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19495	46	police	police	NN
18637	19495	47	power	power	NN
18637	19495	48	may	may	MD
18637	19495	49	permit	permit	VB
18637	19495	50	harassed	harass	VBN
18637	19495	51	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	19495	52	to	to	TO
18637	19495	53	recover	recover	VB
18637	19495	54	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	19495	55	in	in	IN
18637	19495	56	the	the	DT
18637	19495	57	form	form	NN
18637	19495	58	of	of	IN
18637	19495	59	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	19495	60	's	's	POS
18637	19495	61	fees	fee	NNS
18637	19495	62	or	or	CC
18637	19495	63	damages	damage	NNS
18637	19495	64	.	.	.
18637	19496	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19496	2	772	772	CD
18637	19496	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19496	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19496	5	,	,	,
18637	19496	6	to	to	TO
18637	19496	7	deter	deter	VB
18637	19496	8	careless	careless	JJ
18637	19496	9	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	19496	10	of	of	IN
18637	19496	11	human	human	JJ
18637	19496	12	life	life	NN
18637	19496	13	,	,	,
18637	19496	14	a	a	DT
18637	19496	15	State	state	NN
18637	19496	16	by	by	IN
18637	19496	17	law	law	NN
18637	19496	18	may	may	MD
18637	19496	19	allow	allow	VB
18637	19496	20	punitive	punitive	JJ
18637	19496	21	damages	damage	NNS
18637	19496	22	to	to	TO
18637	19496	23	be	be	VB
18637	19496	24	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	19496	25	in	in	IN
18637	19496	26	actions	action	NNS
18637	19496	27	against	against	IN
18637	19496	28	employers	employer	NNS
18637	19496	29	for	for	IN
18637	19496	30	deaths	death	NNS
18637	19496	31	caused	cause	VBN
18637	19496	32	by	by	IN
18637	19496	33	the	the	DT
18637	19496	34	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	19496	35	of	of	IN
18637	19496	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19496	37	employees	employee	NNS
18637	19496	38	.	.	.
18637	19497	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19497	2	773	773	CD
18637	19497	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19497	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19497	5	,	,	,
18637	19497	6	by	by	IN
18637	19497	7	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	19497	8	of	of	IN
18637	19497	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19497	10	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	19497	11	power	power	NN
18637	19497	12	to	to	TO
18637	19497	13	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	19497	14	the	the	DT
18637	19497	15	character	character	NN
18637	19497	16	of	of	IN
18637	19497	17	the	the	DT
18637	19497	18	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19497	19	which	which	WDT
18637	19497	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	19497	21	be	be	VB
18637	19497	22	awarded	award	VBN
18637	19497	23	against	against	IN
18637	19497	24	those	those	DT
18637	19497	25	found	find	VBN
18637	19497	26	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19497	27	of	of	IN
18637	19497	28	crime	crime	NN
18637	19497	29	,	,	,
18637	19497	30	a	a	DT
18637	19497	31	State	state	NN
18637	19497	32	may	may	MD
18637	19497	33	provide	provide	VB
18637	19497	34	that	that	IN
18637	19497	35	a	a	DT
18637	19497	36	public	public	JJ
18637	19497	37	officer	officer	NN
18637	19497	38	embezzling	embezzle	VBG
18637	19497	39	public	public	JJ
18637	19497	40	money	money	NN
18637	19497	41	shall	shall	MD
18637	19497	42	,	,	,
18637	19497	43	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19497	44	that	that	IN
18637	19497	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19497	46	has	have	VBZ
18637	19497	47	made	make	VBN
18637	19497	48	restitution	restitution	NN
18637	19497	49	,	,	,
18637	19497	50	suffer	suffer	VB
18637	19497	51	not	not	RB
18637	19497	52	only	only	RB
18637	19497	53	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	19497	54	but	but	CC
18637	19497	55	also	also	RB
18637	19497	56	pay	pay	VB
18637	19497	57	a	a	DT
18637	19497	58	fine	fine	JJ
18637	19497	59	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19497	60	to	to	TO
18637	19497	61	double	double	VB
18637	19497	62	the	the	DT
18637	19497	63	amount	amount	NN
18637	19497	64	embezzled	embezzle	VBN
18637	19497	65	,	,	,
18637	19497	66	which	which	WDT
18637	19497	67	shall	shall	MD
18637	19497	68	operate	operate	VB
18637	19497	69	as	as	IN
18637	19497	70	a	a	DT
18637	19497	71	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19497	72	for	for	IN
18637	19497	73	the	the	DT
18637	19497	74	use	use	NN
18637	19497	75	of	of	IN
18637	19497	76	persons	person	NNS
18637	19497	77	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19497	78	money	money	NN
18637	19497	79	was	be	VBD
18637	19497	80	embezzled	embezzle	VBN
18637	19497	81	.	.	.
18637	19498	1	Whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	19498	2	this	this	DT
18637	19498	3	fine	fine	NN
18637	19498	4	be	be	VB
18637	19498	5	called	call	VBN
18637	19498	6	,	,	,
18637	19498	7	whether	whether	IN
18637	19498	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19498	9	be	be	VB
18637	19498	10	a	a	DT
18637	19498	11	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	19498	12	,	,	,
18637	19498	13	or	or	CC
18637	19498	14	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	19498	15	,	,	,
18637	19498	16	or	or	CC
18637	19498	17	civil	civil	JJ
18637	19498	18	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19498	19	,	,	,
18637	19498	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19498	21	comes	come	VBZ
18637	19498	22	to	to	IN
18637	19498	23	the	the	DT
18637	19498	24	convict	convict	NN
18637	19498	25	as	as	IN
18637	19498	26	the	the	DT
18637	19498	27	result	result	NN
18637	19498	28	of	of	IN
18637	19498	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19498	30	crime	crime	NN
18637	19498	31	.	.	.
18637	19499	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19499	2	774	774	CD
18637	19499	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19499	4	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	19499	5	of	of	IN
18637	19499	6	Limitation	limitation	NN
18637	19499	7	A	a	DT
18637	19499	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	19499	9	of	of	IN
18637	19499	10	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	19499	11	does	do	VBZ
18637	19499	12	not	not	RB
18637	19499	13	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	19499	14	one	one	CD
18637	19499	15	of	of	IN
18637	19499	16	property	property	NN
18637	19499	17	without	without	IN
18637	19499	18	due	due	JJ
18637	19499	19	process	process	NN
18637	19499	20	of	of	IN
18637	19499	21	law	law	NN
18637	19499	22	,	,	,
18637	19499	23	unless	unless	IN
18637	19499	24	,	,	,
18637	19499	25	in	in	IN
18637	19499	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19499	27	application	application	NN
18637	19499	28	to	to	IN
18637	19499	29	an	an	DT
18637	19499	30	existing	exist	VBG
18637	19499	31	right	right	NN
18637	19499	32	of	of	IN
18637	19499	33	action	action	NN
18637	19499	34	,	,	,
18637	19499	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19499	36	unreasonably	unreasonably	RB
18637	19499	37	limits	limit	VBZ
18637	19499	38	the	the	DT
18637	19499	39	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19499	40	to	to	TO
18637	19499	41	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	19499	42	that	that	DT
18637	19499	43	right	right	RB
18637	19499	44	by	by	IN
18637	19499	45	suit	suit	NN
18637	19499	46	.	.	.
18637	19500	1	By	by	IN
18637	19500	2	the	the	DT
18637	19500	3	same	same	JJ
18637	19500	4	token	token	NN
18637	19500	5	,	,	,
18637	19500	6	a	a	DT
18637	19500	7	State	state	NN
18637	19500	8	may	may	MD
18637	19500	9	shorten	shorten	VB
18637	19500	10	an	an	DT
18637	19500	11	existing	exist	VBG
18637	19500	12	period	period	NN
18637	19500	13	of	of	IN
18637	19500	14	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	19500	15	,	,	,
18637	19500	16	provided	provide	VBD
18637	19500	17	a	a	DT
18637	19500	18	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19500	19	time	time	NN
18637	19500	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	19500	21	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	19500	22	for	for	IN
18637	19500	23	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	19500	24	an	an	DT
18637	19500	25	action	action	NN
18637	19500	26	after	after	IN
18637	19500	27	the	the	DT
18637	19500	28	passage	passage	NN
18637	19500	29	of	of	IN
18637	19500	30	the	the	DT
18637	19500	31	statute	statute	NN
18637	19500	32	and	and	CC
18637	19500	33	before	before	IN
18637	19500	34	the	the	DT
18637	19500	35	bar	bar	NN
18637	19500	36	takes	take	VBZ
18637	19500	37	effect	effect	NN
18637	19500	38	.	.	.
18637	19501	1	What	what	WP
18637	19501	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	19501	3	a	a	DT
18637	19501	4	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19501	5	period	period	NN
18637	19501	6	,	,	,
18637	19501	7	however	however	RB
18637	19501	8	,	,	,
18637	19501	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19501	10	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	19501	11	on	on	IN
18637	19501	12	the	the	DT
18637	19501	13	nature	nature	NN
18637	19501	14	of	of	IN
18637	19501	15	the	the	DT
18637	19501	16	right	right	JJ
18637	19501	17	and	and	CC
18637	19501	18	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19501	19	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19501	20	.	.	.
18637	19502	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19502	2	775	775	CD
18637	19502	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19502	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19502	5	,	,	,
18637	19502	6	an	an	DT
18637	19502	7	interval	interval	NN
18637	19502	8	of	of	IN
18637	19502	9	only	only	RB
18637	19502	10	one	one	CD
18637	19502	11	year	year	NN
18637	19502	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	19502	13	not	not	RB
18637	19502	14	so	so	RB
18637	19502	15	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19502	16	as	as	IN
18637	19502	17	to	to	TO
18637	19502	18	be	be	VB
18637	19502	19	wanting	want	VBG
18637	19502	20	in	in	IN
18637	19502	21	due	due	JJ
18637	19502	22	process	process	NN
18637	19502	23	when	when	WRB
18637	19502	24	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19502	25	to	to	IN
18637	19502	26	bar	bar	NN
18637	19502	27	actions	action	NNS
18637	19502	28	relative	relative	JJ
18637	19502	29	to	to	IN
18637	19502	30	the	the	DT
18637	19502	31	property	property	NN
18637	19502	32	of	of	IN
18637	19502	33	an	an	DT
18637	19502	34	absentee	absentee	NN
18637	19502	35	in	in	IN
18637	19502	36	instances	instance	NNS
18637	19502	37	when	when	WRB
18637	19502	38	the	the	DT
18637	19502	39	receiver	receiver	NN
18637	19502	40	for	for	IN
18637	19502	41	such	such	JJ
18637	19502	42	property	property	NN
18637	19502	43	has	have	VBZ
18637	19502	44	not	not	RB
18637	19502	45	been	be	VBN
18637	19502	46	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	19502	47	until	until	IN
18637	19502	48	13	13	CD
18637	19502	49	years	year	NNS
18637	19502	50	after	after	IN
18637	19502	51	the	the	DT
18637	19502	52	former	former	JJ
18637	19502	53	's	's	POS
18637	19502	54	disappearance	disappearance	NN
18637	19502	55	.	.	.
18637	19503	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19503	2	776	776	CD
18637	19503	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19503	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19503	5	,	,	,
18637	19503	6	when	when	WRB
18637	19503	7	a	a	DT
18637	19503	8	State	state	NN
18637	19503	9	,	,	,
18637	19503	10	by	by	IN
18637	19503	11	law	law	NN
18637	19503	12	,	,	,
18637	19503	13	suddenly	suddenly	RB
18637	19503	14	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	19503	15	,	,	,
18637	19503	16	unless	unless	IN
18637	19503	17	brought	bring	VBN
18637	19503	18	within	within	RB
18637	19503	19	six	six	CD
18637	19503	20	months	month	NNS
18637	19503	21	after	after	IN
18637	19503	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19503	23	passage	passage	NN
18637	19503	24	,	,	,
18637	19503	25	all	all	DT
18637	19503	26	actions	action	NNS
18637	19503	27	to	to	TO
18637	19503	28	contest	contest	VB
18637	19503	29	tax	tax	NN
18637	19503	30	deeds	deed	NNS
18637	19503	31	which	which	WDT
18637	19503	32	have	have	VBP
18637	19503	33	been	be	VBN
18637	19503	34	of	of	IN
18637	19503	35	record	record	NN
18637	19503	36	for	for	IN
18637	19503	37	two	two	CD
18637	19503	38	years	year	NNS
18637	19503	39	,	,	,
18637	19503	40	no	no	DT
18637	19503	41	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19503	42	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19503	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	19503	44	effected	effect	VBN
18637	19503	45	.	.	.
18637	19504	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19504	2	777	777	CD
18637	19504	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19504	4	No	no	DT
18637	19504	5	less	less	RBR
18637	19504	6	valid	valid	JJ
18637	19504	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19504	8	a	a	DT
18637	19504	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	19504	10	,	,	,
18637	19504	11	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	19504	12	to	to	IN
18637	19504	13	wild	wild	JJ
18637	19504	14	lands	land	NNS
18637	19504	15	,	,	,
18637	19504	16	which	which	WDT
18637	19504	17	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	19504	18	that	that	IN
18637	19504	19	when	when	WRB
18637	19504	20	a	a	DT
18637	19504	21	person	person	NN
18637	19504	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	19504	23	been	be	VBN
18637	19504	24	in	in	IN
18637	19504	25	possession	possession	NN
18637	19504	26	under	under	IN
18637	19504	27	a	a	DT
18637	19504	28	recorded	record	VBN
18637	19504	29	deed	deed	NN
18637	19504	30	continuously	continuously	RB
18637	19504	31	for	for	IN
18637	19504	32	20	20	CD
18637	19504	33	years	year	NNS
18637	19504	34	,	,	,
18637	19504	35	and	and	CC
18637	19504	36	had	have	VBD
18637	19504	37	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19504	38	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19504	39	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	19504	40	during	during	IN
18637	19504	41	the	the	DT
18637	19504	42	same	same	JJ
18637	19504	43	,	,	,
18637	19504	44	the	the	DT
18637	19504	45	former	former	JJ
18637	19504	46	owner	owner	NN
18637	19504	47	in	in	IN
18637	19504	48	that	that	DT
18637	19504	49	interval	interval	NN
18637	19504	50	paying	pay	VBG
18637	19504	51	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	19504	52	,	,	,
18637	19504	53	no	no	DT
18637	19504	54	action	action	NN
18637	19504	55	to	to	TO
18637	19504	56	recover	recover	VB
18637	19504	57	such	such	JJ
18637	19504	58	land	land	NN
18637	19504	59	shall	shall	MD
18637	19504	60	be	be	VB
18637	19504	61	entertained	entertain	VBN
18637	19504	62	unless	unless	IN
18637	19504	63	commenced	commence	VBN
18637	19504	64	within	within	IN
18637	19504	65	20	20	CD
18637	19504	66	years	year	NNS
18637	19504	67	,	,	,
18637	19504	68	or	or	CC
18637	19504	69	before	before	IN
18637	19504	70	the	the	DT
18637	19504	71	expiration	expiration	NN
18637	19504	72	of	of	IN
18637	19504	73	five	five	CD
18637	19504	74	years	year	NNS
18637	19504	75	following	follow	VBG
18637	19504	76	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	19504	77	of	of	IN
18637	19504	78	said	said	NNP
18637	19504	79	provision	provision	NN
18637	19504	80	.	.	.
18637	19505	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19505	2	778	778	CD
18637	19505	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19505	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19505	5	,	,	,
18637	19505	6	an	an	DT
18637	19505	7	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	19505	8	to	to	IN
18637	19505	9	a	a	DT
18637	19505	10	workmen	workmen	NN
18637	19505	11	's	's	POS
18637	19505	12	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19505	13	act	act	NN
18637	19505	14	,	,	,
18637	19505	15	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	19505	16	to	to	IN
18637	19505	17	three	three	CD
18637	19505	18	years	year	NNS
18637	19505	19	the	the	DT
18637	19505	20	time	time	NN
18637	19505	21	within	within	IN
18637	19505	22	which	which	WDT
18637	19505	23	a	a	DT
18637	19505	24	case	case	NN
18637	19505	25	may	may	MD
18637	19505	26	be	be	VB
18637	19505	27	reopened	reopen	VBN
18637	19505	28	for	for	IN
18637	19505	29	readjustment	readjustment	NN
18637	19505	30	of	of	IN
18637	19505	31	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19505	32	on	on	IN
18637	19505	33	account	account	NN
18637	19505	34	of	of	IN
18637	19505	35	aggravation	aggravation	NN
18637	19505	36	of	of	IN
18637	19505	37	a	a	DT
18637	19505	38	disability	disability	NN
18637	19505	39	,	,	,
18637	19505	40	does	do	VBZ
18637	19505	41	not	not	RB
18637	19505	42	deny	deny	VB
18637	19505	43	due	due	JJ
18637	19505	44	process	process	NN
18637	19505	45	to	to	IN
18637	19505	46	one	one	CD
18637	19505	47	who	who	WP
18637	19505	48	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	19505	49	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19505	50	injury	injury	NN
18637	19505	51	at	at	IN
18637	19505	52	a	a	DT
18637	19505	53	time	time	NN
18637	19505	54	when	when	WRB
18637	19505	55	the	the	DT
18637	19505	56	statute	statute	NN
18637	19505	57	contained	contain	VBD
18637	19505	58	no	no	DT
18637	19505	59	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	19505	60	.	.	.
18637	19506	1	A	a	DT
18637	19506	2	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	19506	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	19506	4	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19506	5	to	to	TO
18637	19506	6	affect	affect	VB
18637	19506	7	the	the	DT
18637	19506	8	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	19506	9	only	only	RB
18637	19506	10	,	,	,
18637	19506	11	and	and	CC
18637	19506	12	the	the	DT
18637	19506	13	period	period	NN
18637	19506	14	of	of	IN
18637	19506	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19506	16	operation	operation	NN
18637	19506	17	in	in	IN
18637	19506	18	this	this	DT
18637	19506	19	instance	instance	NN
18637	19506	20	was	be	VBD
18637	19506	21	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19506	22	as	as	IN
18637	19506	23	neither	neither	CC
18637	19506	24	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19506	25	nor	nor	CC
18637	19506	26	oppressive	oppressive	JJ
18637	19506	27	.	.	.
18637	19507	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19507	2	779	779	CD
18637	19507	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19507	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	19507	5	,	,	,
18637	19507	6	as	as	RB
18637	19507	7	long	long	RB
18637	19507	8	as	as	IN
18637	19507	9	no	no	DT
18637	19507	10	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	19507	11	of	of	IN
18637	19507	12	the	the	DT
18637	19507	13	parties	party	NNS
18637	19507	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19507	15	violated	violate	VBN
18637	19507	16	,	,	,
18637	19507	17	a	a	DT
18637	19507	18	State	state	NN
18637	19507	19	may	may	MD
18637	19507	20	extend	extend	VB
18637	19507	21	as	as	RB
18637	19507	22	well	well	RB
18637	19507	23	as	as	IN
18637	19507	24	shorten	shorten	VB
18637	19507	25	the	the	DT
18637	19507	26	time	time	NN
18637	19507	27	in	in	IN
18637	19507	28	which	which	WDT
18637	19507	29	suits	suit	NNS
18637	19507	30	may	may	MD
18637	19507	31	be	be	VB
18637	19507	32	brought	bring	VBN
18637	19507	33	in	in	IN
18637	19507	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19507	35	courts	court	NNS
18637	19507	36	and	and	CC
18637	19507	37	may	may	MD
18637	19507	38	even	even	RB
18637	19507	39	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	19507	40	remove	remove	VB
18637	19507	41	a	a	DT
18637	19507	42	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	19507	43	bar	bar	NN
18637	19507	44	to	to	IN
18637	19507	45	the	the	DT
18637	19507	46	commencement	commencement	NN
18637	19507	47	of	of	IN
18637	19507	48	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	19507	49	.	.	.
18637	19508	1	As	as	IN
18637	19508	2	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19508	3	to	to	IN
18637	19508	4	actions	action	NNS
18637	19508	5	for	for	IN
18637	19508	6	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19508	7	debts	debt	NNS
18637	19508	8	,	,	,
18637	19508	9	a	a	DT
18637	19508	10	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	19508	11	or	or	CC
18637	19508	12	extension	extension	NN
18637	19508	13	of	of	IN
18637	19508	14	a	a	DT
18637	19508	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	19508	16	of	of	IN
18637	19508	17	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	19508	18	effects	effect	NNS
18637	19508	19	no	no	DT
18637	19508	20	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19508	21	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19508	22	of	of	IN
18637	19508	23	property	property	NN
18637	19508	24	of	of	IN
18637	19508	25	a	a	DT
18637	19508	26	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	19508	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	19508	28	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19508	29	in	in	IN
18637	19508	30	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19508	31	favor	favor	NN
18637	19508	32	such	such	JJ
18637	19508	33	statute	statute	NN
18637	19508	34	had	have	VBD
18637	19508	35	already	already	RB
18637	19508	36	become	become	VBN
18637	19508	37	a	a	DT
18637	19508	38	defense	defense	NN
18637	19508	39	.	.	.
18637	19509	1	"	"	``
18637	19509	2	A	a	DT
18637	19509	3	right	right	NN
18637	19509	4	to	to	TO
18637	19509	5	defeat	defeat	VB
18637	19509	6	a	a	DT
18637	19509	7	just	just	JJ
18637	19509	8	debt	debt	NN
18637	19509	9	by	by	IN
18637	19509	10	the	the	DT
18637	19509	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	19509	12	of	of	IN
18637	19509	13	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	19509	14	*	*	NFP
18637	19509	15	*	*	NFP
18637	19509	16	*	*	NFP
18637	19509	17	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19509	18	not	not	RB
18637	19509	19	being	be	VBG
18637	19509	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19509	21	a	a	DT
18637	19509	22	vested	vested	JJ
18637	19509	23	right	right	NN
18637	19509	24	,	,	,
18637	19509	25	"	"	''
18637	19509	26	such	such	JJ
18637	19509	27	as	as	IN
18637	19509	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	19509	29	protected	protect	VBN
18637	19509	30	by	by	IN
18637	19509	31	the	the	DT
18637	19509	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19509	33	,	,	,
18637	19509	34	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19509	35	no	no	DT
18637	19509	36	offense	offense	NN
18637	19509	37	against	against	IN
18637	19509	38	the	the	DT
18637	19509	39	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19509	40	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19509	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	19509	42	committed	commit	VBN
18637	19509	43	by	by	IN
18637	19509	44	revival	revival	NN
18637	19509	45	,	,	,
18637	19509	46	through	through	IN
18637	19509	47	an	an	DT
18637	19509	48	extension	extension	NN
18637	19509	49	or	or	CC
18637	19509	50	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	19509	51	,	,	,
18637	19509	52	of	of	IN
18637	19509	53	an	an	DT
18637	19509	54	action	action	NN
18637	19509	55	on	on	IN
18637	19509	56	an	an	DT
18637	19509	57	implied	imply	VBN
18637	19509	58	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	19509	59	to	to	TO
18637	19509	60	pay	pay	VB
18637	19509	61	a	a	DT
18637	19509	62	child	child	NN
18637	19509	63	for	for	IN
18637	19509	64	the	the	DT
18637	19509	65	use	use	NN
18637	19509	66	of	of	IN
18637	19509	67	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19509	68	property,[780	property,[780	NN
18637	19509	69	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19509	70	or	or	CC
18637	19509	71	a	a	DT
18637	19509	72	suit	suit	NN
18637	19509	73	to	to	TO
18637	19509	74	recover	recover	VB
18637	19509	75	the	the	DT
18637	19509	76	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	19509	77	price	price	NN
18637	19509	78	of	of	IN
18637	19509	79	securities	security	NNS
18637	19509	80	sold	sell	VBN
18637	19509	81	in	in	IN
18637	19509	82	violation	violation	NN
18637	19509	83	of	of	IN
18637	19509	84	a	a	DT
18637	19509	85	Blue	Blue	NNP
18637	19509	86	Sky	Sky	NNP
18637	19509	87	Law,[781	Law,[781	NNP
18637	19509	88	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19509	89	or	or	CC
18637	19509	90	a	a	DT
18637	19509	91	right	right	NN
18637	19509	92	of	of	IN
18637	19509	93	an	an	DT
18637	19509	94	employee	employee	NN
18637	19509	95	to	to	TO
18637	19509	96	seek	seek	VB
18637	19509	97	,	,	,
18637	19509	98	on	on	IN
18637	19509	99	account	account	NN
18637	19509	100	of	of	IN
18637	19509	101	the	the	DT
18637	19509	102	aggravation	aggravation	NN
18637	19509	103	of	of	IN
18637	19509	104	a	a	DT
18637	19509	105	former	former	JJ
18637	19509	106	injury	injury	NN
18637	19509	107	,	,	,
18637	19509	108	an	an	DT
18637	19509	109	additional	additional	JJ
18637	19509	110	award	award	NN
18637	19509	111	out	out	IN
18637	19509	112	of	of	IN
18637	19509	113	a	a	DT
18637	19509	114	State	State	NNP
18637	19509	115	administered	administer	VBN
18637	19509	116	fund	fund	NN
18637	19509	117	.	.	.
18637	19510	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19510	2	782	782	CD
18637	19510	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19510	4	However	however	RB
18637	19510	5	,	,	,
18637	19510	6	as	as	IN
18637	19510	7	respects	respect	NNS
18637	19510	8	suits	suit	NNS
18637	19510	9	to	to	TO
18637	19510	10	recover	recover	VB
18637	19510	11	real	real	JJ
18637	19510	12	and	and	CC
18637	19510	13	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19510	14	property	property	NN
18637	19510	15	,	,	,
18637	19510	16	when	when	WRB
18637	19510	17	the	the	DT
18637	19510	18	right	right	NN
18637	19510	19	of	of	IN
18637	19510	20	action	action	NN
18637	19510	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	19510	22	been	be	VBN
18637	19510	23	barred	bar	VBN
18637	19510	24	by	by	IN
18637	19510	25	a	a	DT
18637	19510	26	statute	statute	NN
18637	19510	27	of	of	IN
18637	19510	28	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	19510	29	and	and	CC
18637	19510	30	title	title	NN
18637	19510	31	as	as	RB
18637	19510	32	well	well	RB
18637	19510	33	as	as	IN
18637	19510	34	real	real	JJ
18637	19510	35	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	19510	36	have	have	VBP
18637	19510	37	become	become	VBN
18637	19510	38	vested	vest	VBN
18637	19510	39	in	in	IN
18637	19510	40	the	the	DT
18637	19510	41	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19510	42	,	,	,
18637	19510	43	any	any	DT
18637	19510	44	later	later	JJ
18637	19510	45	act	act	NN
18637	19510	46	removing	remove	VBG
18637	19510	47	or	or	CC
18637	19510	48	repealing	repeal	VBG
18637	19510	49	the	the	DT
18637	19510	50	bar	bar	NN
18637	19510	51	would	would	MD
18637	19510	52	be	be	VB
18637	19510	53	void	void	JJ
18637	19510	54	as	as	IN
18637	19510	55	attempting	attempt	VBG
18637	19510	56	an	an	DT
18637	19510	57	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19510	58	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19510	59	of	of	IN
18637	19510	60	title	title	NN
18637	19510	61	.	.	.
18637	19511	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19511	2	783	783	CD
18637	19511	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19511	4	Also	also	RB
18637	19511	5	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19511	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19511	7	the	the	DT
18637	19511	8	application	application	NN
18637	19511	9	of	of	IN
18637	19511	10	a	a	DT
18637	19511	11	local	local	JJ
18637	19511	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	19511	13	of	of	IN
18637	19511	14	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	19511	15	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	19511	16	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	19511	17	any	any	DT
18637	19511	18	contractual	contractual	JJ
18637	19511	19	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	19511	20	of	of	IN
18637	19511	21	the	the	DT
18637	19511	22	right	right	NN
18637	19511	23	to	to	TO
18637	19511	24	sue	sue	VB
18637	19511	25	to	to	IN
18637	19511	26	a	a	DT
18637	19511	27	period	period	NN
18637	19511	28	shorter	short	JJR
18637	19511	29	than	than	IN
18637	19511	30	two	two	CD
18637	19511	31	years	year	NNS
18637	19511	32	to	to	IN
18637	19511	33	an	an	DT
18637	19511	34	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19511	35	contract	contract	NN
18637	19511	36	made	make	VBN
18637	19511	37	and	and	CC
18637	19511	38	to	to	TO
18637	19511	39	be	be	VB
18637	19511	40	performed	perform	VBN
18637	19511	41	outside	outside	IN
18637	19511	42	the	the	DT
18637	19511	43	forum	forum	NN
18637	19511	44	State	State	NNP
18637	19511	45	and	and	CC
18637	19511	46	containing	contain	VBG
18637	19511	47	a	a	DT
18637	19511	48	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	19511	49	that	that	WDT
18637	19511	50	suit	suit	NN
18637	19511	51	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	19511	52	must	must	MD
18637	19511	53	be	be	VB
18637	19511	54	brought	bring	VBN
18637	19511	55	within	within	IN
18637	19511	56	one	one	CD
18637	19511	57	year	year	NN
18637	19511	58	from	from	IN
18637	19511	59	the	the	DT
18637	19511	60	date	date	NN
18637	19511	61	of	of	IN
18637	19511	62	loss	loss	NN
18637	19511	63	.	.	.
18637	19512	1	"	"	``
18637	19512	2	When	when	WRB
18637	19512	3	the	the	DT
18637	19512	4	parties	party	NNS
18637	19512	5	to	to	IN
18637	19512	6	a	a	DT
18637	19512	7	contract	contract	NN
18637	19512	8	have	have	VBP
18637	19512	9	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	19512	10	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	19512	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	19512	12	a	a	DT
18637	19512	13	time	time	NN
18637	19512	14	limit	limit	NN
18637	19512	15	on	on	IN
18637	19512	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19512	17	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	19512	18	,	,	,
18637	19512	19	a	a	DT
18637	19512	20	statute	statute	NN
18637	19512	21	which	which	WDT
18637	19512	22	invalidates	invalidate	VBZ
18637	19512	23	*	*	NFP
18637	19512	24	*	*	NFP
18637	19512	25	*	*	NFP
18637	19512	26	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19512	27	said	say	VBD
18637	19512	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19512	29	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	19512	30	and	and	CC
18637	19512	31	directs	direct	VBZ
18637	19512	32	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	19512	33	of	of	IN
18637	19512	34	the	the	DT
18637	19512	35	contract	contract	NN
18637	19512	36	after	after	IN
18637	19512	37	*	*	NFP
18637	19512	38	*	*	NFP
18637	19512	39	*	*	NFP
18637	19512	40	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19512	41	the	the	DT
18637	19512	42	agreed	agree	VBN
18637	19512	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19512	44	time	time	NN
18637	19512	45	has	have	VBZ
18637	19512	46	expired	expire	VBN
18637	19512	47	*	*	NFP
18637	19512	48	*	*	NFP
18637	19512	49	*	*	NFP
18637	19512	50	"	"	``
18637	19512	51	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	RB
18637	19512	52	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	19512	53	a	a	DT
18637	19512	54	burden	burden	NN
18637	19512	55	in	in	IN
18637	19512	56	excess	excess	NN
18637	19512	57	of	of	IN
18637	19512	58	that	that	DT
18637	19512	59	contracted	contract	VBD
18637	19512	60	.	.	.
18637	19513	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19513	2	784	784	CD
18637	19513	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19513	4	Evidence	Evidence	NNP
18637	19513	5	and	and	CC
18637	19513	6	Presumptions	presumption	NNS
18637	19513	7	The	the	DT
18637	19513	8	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	19513	9	of	of	IN
18637	19513	10	presumptions	presumption	NNS
18637	19513	11	and	and	CC
18637	19513	12	rules	rule	NNS
18637	19513	13	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	19513	14	the	the	DT
18637	19513	15	burden	burden	NN
18637	19513	16	of	of	IN
18637	19513	17	proof	proof	NN
18637	19513	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	19513	19	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	19513	20	within	within	IN
18637	19513	21	the	the	DT
18637	19513	22	domain	domain	NN
18637	19513	23	of	of	IN
18637	19513	24	State	state	NN
18637	19513	25	governments	government	NNS
18637	19513	26	.	.	.
18637	19514	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19514	2	785	785	CD
18637	19514	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19514	4	As	as	RB
18637	19514	5	long	long	RB
18637	19514	6	as	as	IN
18637	19514	7	a	a	DT
18637	19514	8	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	19514	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19514	10	not	not	RB
18637	19514	11	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19514	12	and	and	CC
18637	19514	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	19514	14	not	not	RB
18637	19514	15	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	19514	16	of	of	IN
18637	19514	17	the	the	DT
18637	19514	18	rights	right	NNS
18637	19514	19	of	of	IN
18637	19514	20	the	the	DT
18637	19514	21	person	person	NN
18637	19514	22	against	against	IN
18637	19514	23	whom	whom	WP
18637	19514	24	raised	raise	VBD
18637	19514	25	,	,	,
18637	19514	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19514	27	does	do	VBZ
18637	19514	28	not	not	RB
18637	19514	29	violate	violate	VB
18637	19514	30	the	the	DT
18637	19514	31	due	due	JJ
18637	19514	32	process	process	NN
18637	19514	33	clause	clause	NN
18637	19514	34	.	.	.
18637	19515	1	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19515	2	fiat	fiat	NN
18637	19515	3	may	may	MD
18637	19515	4	not	not	RB
18637	19515	5	take	take	VB
18637	19515	6	the	the	DT
18637	19515	7	place	place	NN
18637	19515	8	of	of	IN
18637	19515	9	fact	fact	NN
18637	19515	10	,	,	,
18637	19515	11	however	however	RB
18637	19515	12	,	,	,
18637	19515	13	in	in	IN
18637	19515	14	the	the	DT
18637	19515	15	determination	determination	NN
18637	19515	16	of	of	IN
18637	19515	17	issues	issue	NNS
18637	19515	18	involving	involve	VBG
18637	19515	19	life	life	NN
18637	19515	20	,	,	,
18637	19515	21	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19515	22	,	,	,
18637	19515	23	or	or	CC
18637	19515	24	property	property	NN
18637	19515	25	,	,	,
18637	19515	26	and	and	CC
18637	19515	27	a	a	DT
18637	19515	28	statute	statute	NN
18637	19515	29	creating	create	VBG
18637	19515	30	a	a	DT
18637	19515	31	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	19515	32	which	which	WDT
18637	19515	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	19515	34	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	19515	35	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19515	36	and	and	CC
18637	19515	37	which	which	WDT
18637	19515	38	operates	operate	VBZ
18637	19515	39	to	to	TO
18637	19515	40	deny	deny	VB
18637	19515	41	a	a	DT
18637	19515	42	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19515	43	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19515	44	to	to	TO
18637	19515	45	repel	repel	VB
18637	19515	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19515	47	or	or	CC
18637	19515	48	to	to	TO
18637	19515	49	present	present	VB
18637	19515	50	facts	fact	NNS
18637	19515	51	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	19515	52	to	to	IN
18637	19515	53	one	one	PRP
18637	19515	54	's	's	POS
18637	19515	55	defense	defense	NN
18637	19515	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	19515	57	void	void	JJ
18637	19515	58	.	.	.
18637	19516	1	On	on	IN
18637	19516	2	the	the	DT
18637	19516	3	other	other	JJ
18637	19516	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	19516	5	,	,	,
18637	19516	6	if	if	IN
18637	19516	7	there	there	EX
18637	19516	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	19516	9	a	a	DT
18637	19516	10	rational	rational	JJ
18637	19516	11	connection	connection	NN
18637	19516	12	between	between	IN
18637	19516	13	what	what	WP
18637	19516	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19516	15	proved	prove	VBN
18637	19516	16	and	and	CC
18637	19516	17	what	what	WP
18637	19516	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	19516	19	to	to	TO
18637	19516	20	be	be	VB
18637	19516	21	inferred	infer	VBN
18637	19516	22	,	,	,
18637	19516	23	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19516	24	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	19516	25	that	that	IN
18637	19516	26	the	the	DT
18637	19516	27	proof	proof	NN
18637	19516	28	of	of	IN
18637	19516	29	one	one	CD
18637	19516	30	fact	fact	NN
18637	19516	31	or	or	CC
18637	19516	32	group	group	NN
18637	19516	33	of	of	IN
18637	19516	34	facts	fact	NNS
18637	19516	35	shall	shall	MD
18637	19516	36	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	19516	37	_	_	NNP
18637	19516	38	prima	prima	NN
18637	19516	39	facie	facie	VBN
18637	19516	40	_	_	NNP
18637	19516	41	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19516	42	of	of	IN
18637	19516	43	a	a	DT
18637	19516	44	main	main	JJ
18637	19516	45	or	or	CC
18637	19516	46	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	19516	47	fact	fact	NN
18637	19516	48	will	will	MD
18637	19516	49	be	be	VB
18637	19516	50	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	19516	51	.	.	.
18637	19517	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19517	2	786	786	CD
18637	19517	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19517	4	On	on	IN
18637	19517	5	the	the	DT
18637	19517	6	ground	ground	NN
18637	19517	7	that	that	IN
18637	19517	8	the	the	DT
18637	19517	9	connection	connection	NN
18637	19517	10	between	between	IN
18637	19517	11	the	the	DT
18637	19517	12	fact	fact	NN
18637	19517	13	proven	prove	VBN
18637	19517	14	and	and	CC
18637	19517	15	that	that	IN
18637	19517	16	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	19517	17	was	be	VBD
18637	19517	18	not	not	RB
18637	19517	19	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19517	20	and	and	CC
18637	19517	21	that	that	IN
18637	19517	22	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	19517	23	did	do	VBD
18637	19517	24	not	not	RB
18637	19517	25	lead	lead	VB
18637	19517	26	from	from	IN
18637	19517	27	one	one	CD
18637	19517	28	to	to	IN
18637	19517	29	the	the	DT
18637	19517	30	other	other	JJ
18637	19517	31	,	,	,
18637	19517	32	the	the	DT
18637	19517	33	following	follow	VBG
18637	19517	34	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	19517	35	presumptions	presumption	NNS
18637	19517	36	have	have	VBP
18637	19517	37	been	be	VBN
18637	19517	38	voided	void	VBN
18637	19517	39	.	.	.
18637	19518	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19518	2	,	,	,
18637	19518	3	a	a	DT
18637	19518	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	19518	5	which	which	WDT
18637	19518	6	treated	treat	VBD
18637	19518	7	a	a	DT
18637	19518	8	breach	breach	NN
18637	19518	9	of	of	IN
18637	19518	10	a	a	DT
18637	19518	11	contract	contract	NN
18637	19518	12	to	to	IN
18637	19518	13	labor	labor	NN
18637	19518	14	as	as	IN
18637	19518	15	_	_	NNP
18637	19518	16	prima	prima	NN
18637	19518	17	facie	facie	VBD
18637	19518	18	_	_	NNP
18637	19518	19	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19518	20	of	of	IN
18637	19518	21	an	an	DT
18637	19518	22	intent	intent	NN
18637	19518	23	to	to	TO
18637	19518	24	defraud	defraud	VB
18637	19518	25	an	an	DT
18637	19518	26	employer	employer	NN
18637	19518	27	of	of	IN
18637	19518	28	money	money	NN
18637	19518	29	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19518	30	by	by	IN
18637	19518	31	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19518	32	in	in	IN
18637	19518	33	advance	advance	NN
18637	19518	34	was	be	VBD
18637	19518	35	found	find	VBN
18637	19518	36	to	to	TO
18637	19518	37	be	be	VB
18637	19518	38	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	19518	39	defective	defective	JJ
18637	19518	40	because	because	IN
18637	19518	41	the	the	DT
18637	19518	42	trial	trial	NN
18637	19518	43	court	court	NN
18637	19518	44	was	be	VBD
18637	19518	45	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	19518	46	to	to	TO
18637	19518	47	disregard	disregard	VB
18637	19518	48	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19518	49	rationally	rationally	RB
18637	19518	50	bearing	bear	VBG
18637	19518	51	upon	upon	IN
18637	19518	52	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	19518	53	and	and	CC
18637	19518	54	to	to	TO
18637	19518	55	decide	decide	VB
18637	19518	56	upon	upon	IN
18637	19518	57	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19518	58	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	19518	59	to	to	IN
18637	19518	60	an	an	DT
18637	19518	61	unrelated	unrelated	JJ
18637	19518	62	breach	breach	NN
18637	19518	63	of	of	IN
18637	19518	64	contract	contract	NN
18637	19518	65	,	,	,
18637	19518	66	with	with	IN
18637	19518	67	the	the	DT
18637	19518	68	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	19518	69	that	that	IN
18637	19518	70	an	an	DT
18637	19518	71	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19518	72	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19518	73	upon	upon	IN
18637	19518	74	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	19518	75	was	be	VBD
18637	19518	76	not	not	RB
18637	19518	77	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	19518	78	.	.	.
18637	19519	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19519	2	787	787	CD
18637	19519	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19519	4	Also	also	RB
18637	19519	5	,	,	,
18637	19519	6	since	since	IN
18637	19519	7	"	"	``
18637	19519	8	inference	inference	NN
18637	19519	9	of	of	IN
18637	19519	10	crime	crime	NN
18637	19519	11	and	and	CC
18637	19519	12	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	19519	13	may	may	MD
18637	19519	14	not	not	RB
18637	19519	15	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	19519	16	be	be	VB
18637	19519	17	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	19519	18	from	from	IN
18637	19519	19	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19519	20	inability	inability	NN
18637	19519	21	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19519	22	of	of	IN
18637	19519	23	a	a	DT
18637	19519	24	bank	bank	NN
18637	19519	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19519	26	to	to	TO
18637	19519	27	pay	pay	VB
18637	19519	28	demand	demand	NN
18637	19519	29	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	19519	30	and	and	CC
18637	19519	31	other	other	JJ
18637	19519	32	debts	debt	NNS
18637	19519	33	as	as	IN
18637	19519	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19519	35	mature	mature	VBP
18637	19519	36	,	,	,
18637	19519	37	"	"	''
18637	19519	38	a	a	DT
18637	19519	39	statute	statute	NN
18637	19519	40	making	make	VBG
18637	19519	41	proof	proof	NN
18637	19519	42	of	of	IN
18637	19519	43	insolvency	insolvency	NN
18637	19519	44	_	_	NNP
18637	19519	45	prima	prima	NN
18637	19519	46	facie	facie	VBN
18637	19519	47	_	_	NNP
18637	19519	48	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19519	49	of	of	IN
18637	19519	50	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	19519	51	on	on	IN
18637	19519	52	the	the	DT
18637	19519	53	part	part	NN
18637	19519	54	of	of	IN
18637	19519	55	bank	bank	NN
18637	19519	56	directors	director	NNS
18637	19519	57	was	be	VBD
18637	19519	58	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19519	59	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	19519	60	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19519	61	.	.	.
18637	19520	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19520	2	788	788	CD
18637	19520	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19520	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19520	5	,	,	,
18637	19520	6	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	19520	7	by	by	IN
18637	19520	8	one	one	CD
18637	19520	9	or	or	CC
18637	19520	10	all	all	PDT
18637	19520	11	the	the	DT
18637	19520	12	participants	participant	NNS
18637	19520	13	in	in	IN
18637	19520	14	a	a	DT
18637	19520	15	grade	grade	NN
18637	19520	16	crossing	cross	VBG
18637	19520	17	collision	collision	NN
18637	19520	18	not	not	RB
18637	19520	19	being	be	VBG
18637	19520	20	inferable	inferable	JJ
18637	19520	21	from	from	IN
18637	19520	22	the	the	DT
18637	19520	23	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19520	24	occurrence	occurrence	NN
18637	19520	25	,	,	,
18637	19520	26	the	the	DT
18637	19520	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19520	28	voided	void	VBD
18637	19520	29	a	a	DT
18637	19520	30	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	19520	31	statute	statute	NN
18637	19520	32	which	which	WDT
18637	19520	33	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19520	34	that	that	IN
18637	19520	35	a	a	DT
18637	19520	36	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19520	37	shall	shall	MD
18637	19520	38	be	be	VB
18637	19520	39	liable	liable	JJ
18637	19520	40	in	in	IN
18637	19520	41	damages	damage	NNS
18637	19520	42	to	to	IN
18637	19520	43	person	person	NN
18637	19520	44	or	or	CC
18637	19520	45	property	property	NN
18637	19520	46	by	by	IN
18637	19520	47	the	the	DT
18637	19520	48	running	running	NN
18637	19520	49	of	of	IN
18637	19520	50	trains	train	NNS
18637	19520	51	unless	unless	IN
18637	19520	52	the	the	DT
18637	19520	53	company	company	NN
18637	19520	54	shall	shall	MD
18637	19520	55	make	make	VB
18637	19520	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19520	57	appear	appear	VB
18637	19520	58	that	that	IN
18637	19520	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19520	60	agents	agent	NNS
18637	19520	61	exercised	exercise	VBD
18637	19520	62	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	19520	63	diligence	diligence	NN
18637	19520	64	,	,	,
18637	19520	65	the	the	DT
18637	19520	66	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	19520	67	in	in	IN
18637	19520	68	all	all	DT
18637	19520	69	cases	case	NNS
18637	19520	70	being	be	VBG
18637	19520	71	against	against	IN
18637	19520	72	the	the	DT
18637	19520	73	company	company	NN
18637	19520	74	,	,	,
18637	19520	75	and	and	CC
18637	19520	76	which	which	WDT
18637	19520	77	was	be	VBD
18637	19520	78	construed	construe	VBN
18637	19520	79	by	by	IN
18637	19520	80	State	State	NNP
18637	19520	81	courts	court	NNS
18637	19520	82	as	as	IN
18637	19520	83	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	19520	84	said	say	VBD
18637	19520	85	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	19520	86	of	of	IN
18637	19520	87	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19520	88	to	to	TO
18637	19520	89	be	be	VB
18637	19520	90	weighed	weigh	VBN
18637	19520	91	against	against	IN
18637	19520	92	opposing	oppose	VBG
18637	19520	93	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19520	94	and	and	CC
18637	19520	95	to	to	TO
18637	19520	96	prevail	prevail	VB
18637	19520	97	unless	unless	IN
18637	19520	98	such	such	JJ
18637	19520	99	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19520	100	is	be	VBZ
18637	19520	101	found	find	VBN
18637	19520	102	by	by	IN
18637	19520	103	a	a	DT
18637	19520	104	jury	jury	NN
18637	19520	105	to	to	TO
18637	19520	106	be	be	VB
18637	19520	107	preponderant	preponderant	JJ
18637	19520	108	.	.	.
18637	19521	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19521	2	789	789	CD
18637	19521	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19521	4	On	on	IN
18637	19521	5	the	the	DT
18637	19521	6	other	other	JJ
18637	19521	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	19521	8	,	,	,
18637	19521	9	a	a	DT
18637	19521	10	South	South	NNP
18637	19521	11	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	19521	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	19521	13	which	which	WDT
18637	19521	14	raised	raise	VBD
18637	19521	15	a	a	DT
18637	19521	16	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	19521	17	of	of	IN
18637	19521	18	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	19521	19	against	against	IN
18637	19521	20	a	a	DT
18637	19521	21	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19521	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	19521	23	proof	proof	NN
18637	19521	24	of	of	IN
18637	19521	25	failure	failure	NN
18637	19521	26	to	to	TO
18637	19521	27	give	give	VB
18637	19521	28	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	19521	29	warning	warning	NN
18637	19521	30	signals	signal	NNS
18637	19521	31	was	be	VBD
18637	19521	32	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	19521	33	because	because	IN
18637	19521	34	the	the	DT
18637	19521	35	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	19521	36	therein	therein	RB
18637	19521	37	established	establish	VBN
18637	19521	38	gave	give	VBD
18637	19521	39	rise	rise	NN
18637	19521	40	merely	merely	RB
18637	19521	41	to	to	IN
18637	19521	42	a	a	DT
18637	19521	43	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	19521	44	inference	inference	NN
18637	19521	45	which	which	WDT
18637	19521	46	might	may	MD
18637	19521	47	be	be	VB
18637	19521	48	rebutted	rebut	VBN
18637	19521	49	by	by	IN
18637	19521	50	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	19521	51	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19521	52	and	and	CC
18637	19521	53	which	which	WDT
18637	19521	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	19521	55	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	19521	56	to	to	TO
18637	19521	57	be	be	VB
18637	19521	58	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	19521	59	in	in	IN
18637	19521	60	determining	determine	VBG
18637	19521	61	proximate	proximate	NN
18637	19521	62	cause	cause	NN
18637	19521	63	.	.	.
18637	19522	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19522	2	790	790	CD
18637	19522	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19522	4	Presumptions	presumption	NNS
18637	19522	5	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	19522	6	as	as	IN
18637	19522	7	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	19522	8	tenable	tenable	JJ
18637	19522	9	include	include	VBP
18637	19522	10	those	those	DT
18637	19522	11	set	set	VBN
18637	19522	12	out	out	RP
18637	19522	13	in	in	IN
18637	19522	14	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	19522	15	providing	provide	VBG
18637	19522	16	that	that	IN
18637	19522	17	when	when	WRB
18637	19522	18	distillery	distillery	NN
18637	19522	19	apparatus	apparatus	NN
18637	19522	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	19522	21	found	find	VBN
18637	19522	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	19522	23	the	the	DT
18637	19522	24	premises	premise	NNS
18637	19522	25	of	of	IN
18637	19522	26	an	an	DT
18637	19522	27	individual	individual	JJ
18637	19522	28	,	,	,
18637	19522	29	such	such	JJ
18637	19522	30	discovery	discovery	NN
18637	19522	31	shall	shall	MD
18637	19522	32	be	be	VB
18637	19522	33	_	_	NNP
18637	19522	34	prima	prima	NN
18637	19522	35	facie	facie	VBN
18637	19522	36	_	_	NNP
18637	19522	37	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19522	38	of	of	IN
18637	19522	39	actual	actual	JJ
18637	19522	40	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	19522	41	of	of	IN
18637	19522	42	the	the	DT
18637	19522	43	presence	presence	NN
18637	19522	44	of	of	IN
18637	19522	45	the	the	DT
18637	19522	46	same;[791	same;[791	NNS
18637	19522	47	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19522	48	that	that	IN
18637	19522	49	the	the	DT
18637	19522	50	flowing	flowing	JJ
18637	19522	51	,	,	,
18637	19522	52	release	release	NN
18637	19522	53	,	,	,
18637	19522	54	or	or	CC
18637	19522	55	escape	escape	NN
18637	19522	56	of	of	IN
18637	19522	57	natural	natural	JJ
18637	19522	58	gas	gas	NN
18637	19522	59	into	into	IN
18637	19522	60	the	the	DT
18637	19522	61	air	air	NN
18637	19522	62	shall	shall	MD
18637	19522	63	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	19522	64	_	_	NNP
18637	19522	65	prima	prima	NN
18637	19522	66	facie	facie	VBN
18637	19522	67	_	_	NNP
18637	19522	68	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19522	69	of	of	IN
18637	19522	70	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	19522	71	waste,[792	waste,[792	NN
18637	19522	72	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19522	73	and	and	CC
18637	19522	74	that	that	IN
18637	19522	75	prior	prior	JJ
18637	19522	76	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19522	77	of	of	IN
18637	19522	78	a	a	DT
18637	19522	79	felony	felony	NN
18637	19522	80	shall	shall	MD
18637	19522	81	be	be	VB
18637	19522	82	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	19522	83	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19522	84	of	of	IN
18637	19522	85	bad	bad	JJ
18637	19522	86	character	character	NN
18637	19522	87	justifying	justify	VBG
18637	19522	88	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	19522	89	to	to	TO
18637	19522	90	issue	issue	VB
18637	19522	91	a	a	DT
18637	19522	92	license	license	NN
18637	19522	93	to	to	TO
18637	19522	94	practice	practice	VB
18637	19522	95	medicine	medicine	NN
18637	19522	96	.	.	.
18637	19523	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19523	2	793	793	CD
18637	19523	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19523	4	Upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	19523	5	,	,	,
18637	19523	6	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	19523	7	with	with	IN
18637	19523	8	the	the	DT
18637	19523	9	former	former	JJ
18637	19523	10	,	,	,
18637	19523	11	were	be	VBD
18637	19523	12	two	two	CD
18637	19523	13	sections	section	NNS
18637	19523	14	of	of	IN
18637	19523	15	the	the	DT
18637	19523	16	California	California	NNP
18637	19523	17	alien	alien	JJ
18637	19523	18	land	land	NN
18637	19523	19	law	law	NN
18637	19523	20	;	;	:
18637	19523	21	one	one	CD
18637	19523	22	,	,	,
18637	19523	23	which	which	WDT
18637	19523	24	specified	specify	VBD
18637	19523	25	that	that	IN
18637	19523	26	the	the	DT
18637	19523	27	taking	taking	NN
18637	19523	28	of	of	IN
18637	19523	29	title	title	NN
18637	19523	30	in	in	IN
18637	19523	31	the	the	DT
18637	19523	32	name	name	NN
18637	19523	33	of	of	IN
18637	19523	34	a	a	DT
18637	19523	35	person	person	NN
18637	19523	36	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	19523	37	to	to	TO
18637	19523	38	hold	hold	VB
18637	19523	39	land	land	NN
18637	19523	40	,	,	,
18637	19523	41	where	where	WRB
18637	19523	42	the	the	DT
18637	19523	43	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	19523	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	19523	45	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	19523	46	by	by	IN
18637	19523	47	one	one	CD
18637	19523	48	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	19523	49	to	to	TO
18637	19523	50	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	19523	51	agricultural	agricultural	JJ
18637	19523	52	land	land	NN
18637	19523	53	,	,	,
18637	19523	54	shall	shall	MD
18637	19523	55	raise	raise	VB
18637	19523	56	a	a	DT
18637	19523	57	_	_	NNP
18637	19523	58	prima	prima	NN
18637	19523	59	facie	facie	NN
18637	19523	60	_	_	NNP
18637	19523	61	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	19523	62	that	that	IN
18637	19523	63	the	the	DT
18637	19523	64	conveyance	conveyance	NN
18637	19523	65	is	be	VBZ
18637	19523	66	made	make	VBN
18637	19523	67	to	to	TO
18637	19523	68	evade	evade	VB
18637	19523	69	the	the	DT
18637	19523	70	law;[794	law;[794	NNP
18637	19523	71	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19523	72	and	and	CC
18637	19523	73	a	a	DT
18637	19523	74	second	second	NN
18637	19523	75	,	,	,
18637	19523	76	which	which	WDT
18637	19523	77	cast	cast	VBD
18637	19523	78	upon	upon	IN
18637	19523	79	a	a	DT
18637	19523	80	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	19523	81	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19523	82	the	the	DT
18637	19523	83	burden	burden	NN
18637	19523	84	of	of	IN
18637	19523	85	proving	prove	VBG
18637	19523	86	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	19523	87	by	by	IN
18637	19523	88	birth	birth	NN
18637	19523	89	after	after	IN
18637	19523	90	the	the	DT
18637	19523	91	State	State	NNP
18637	19523	92	endeavored	endeavor	VBD
18637	19523	93	to	to	TO
18637	19523	94	prove	prove	VB
18637	19523	95	that	that	IN
18637	19523	96	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19523	97	belonged	belong	VBD
18637	19523	98	to	to	IN
18637	19523	99	a	a	DT
18637	19523	100	race	race	NN
18637	19523	101	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	19523	102	for	for	IN
18637	19523	103	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	19523	104	.	.	.
18637	19524	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19524	2	795	795	CD
18637	19524	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19524	4	In	in	IN
18637	19524	5	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	19524	6	with	with	IN
18637	19524	7	the	the	DT
18637	19524	8	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19524	9	result	result	NN
18637	19524	10	,	,	,
18637	19524	11	however	however	RB
18637	19524	12	,	,	,
18637	19524	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	19524	14	a	a	DT
18637	19524	15	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	19524	16	decision	decision	NN
18637	19524	17	of	of	IN
18637	19524	18	the	the	DT
18637	19524	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19524	20	holding	holding	NN
18637	19524	21	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	VBD
18637	19524	22	another	another	DT
18637	19524	23	section	section	NN
18637	19524	24	of	of	IN
18637	19524	25	the	the	DT
18637	19524	26	same	same	JJ
18637	19524	27	California	California	NNP
18637	19524	28	law	law	NN
18637	19524	29	providing	provide	VBG
18637	19524	30	that	that	IN
18637	19524	31	when	when	WRB
18637	19524	32	an	an	DT
18637	19524	33	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	19524	34	alleges	allege	VBZ
18637	19524	35	alienage	alienage	NN
18637	19524	36	and	and	CC
18637	19524	37	ineligibility	ineligibility	NN
18637	19524	38	to	to	IN
18637	19524	39	United	United	NNP
18637	19524	40	States	States	NNP
18637	19524	41	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	19524	42	of	of	IN
18637	19524	43	a	a	DT
18637	19524	44	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19524	45	,	,	,
18637	19524	46	the	the	DT
18637	19524	47	burden	burden	NN
18637	19524	48	of	of	IN
18637	19524	49	proving	prove	VBG
18637	19524	50	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	19524	51	or	or	CC
18637	19524	52	eligibility	eligibility	NN
18637	19524	53	thereto	thereto	NNP
18637	19524	54	shall	shall	MD
18637	19524	55	devolve	devolve	VB
18637	19524	56	upon	upon	IN
18637	19524	57	the	the	DT
18637	19524	58	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19524	59	.	.	.
18637	19525	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19525	2	796	796	CD
18637	19525	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19525	4	As	as	IN
18637	19525	5	a	a	DT
18637	19525	6	basis	basis	NN
18637	19525	7	for	for	IN
18637	19525	8	distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
18637	19525	9	these	these	DT
18637	19525	10	last	last	JJ
18637	19525	11	two	two	CD
18637	19525	12	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19525	13	the	the	DT
18637	19525	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19525	15	observed	observe	VBD
18637	19525	16	that	that	IN
18637	19525	17	while	while	IN
18637	19525	18	"	"	``
18637	19525	19	the	the	DT
18637	19525	20	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19525	21	are	be	VBP
18637	19525	22	manifold	manifold	JJ
18637	19525	23	that	that	IN
18637	19525	24	within	within	IN
18637	19525	25	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19525	26	the	the	DT
18637	19525	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19525	28	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19525	29	"	"	''
18637	19525	30	of	of	IN
18637	19525	31	fairness[797	fairness[797	NN
18637	19525	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19525	33	and	and	CC
18637	19525	34	reason	reason	VB
18637	19525	35	the	the	DT
18637	19525	36	burden	burden	NN
18637	19525	37	of	of	IN
18637	19525	38	proof	proof	NN
18637	19525	39	may	may	MD
18637	19525	40	be	be	VB
18637	19525	41	shifted	shift	VBN
18637	19525	42	to	to	IN
18637	19525	43	the	the	DT
18637	19525	44	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19525	45	even	even	RB
18637	19525	46	in	in	IN
18637	19525	47	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19525	48	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	19525	49	,	,	,
18637	19525	50	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	19525	51	,	,	,
18637	19525	52	to	to	TO
18637	19525	53	be	be	VB
18637	19525	54	justified	justify	VBN
18637	19525	55	,	,	,
18637	19525	56	"	"	''
18637	19525	57	the	the	DT
18637	19525	58	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19525	59	held	hold	VBN
18637	19525	60	to	to	TO
18637	19525	61	be	be	VB
18637	19525	62	inculpatory	inculpatory	NN
18637	19525	63	*	*	NFP
18637	19525	64	*	*	NFP
18637	19525	65	*	*	NFP
18637	19525	66	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19525	67	must	must	MD
18637	19525	68	have	have	VB
18637	19525	69	had	have	VBD
18637	19525	70	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19525	71	at	at	IN
18637	19525	72	least	least	JJS
18637	19525	73	a	a	DT
18637	19525	74	sinister	sinister	JJ
18637	19525	75	significance	significance	NN
18637	19525	76	*	*	NFP
18637	19525	77	*	*	NFP
18637	19525	78	*	*	NFP
18637	19525	79	,	,	,
18637	19525	80	or	or	CC
18637	19525	81	if	if	IN
18637	19525	82	this	this	DT
18637	19525	83	at	at	IN
18637	19525	84	times	time	NNS
18637	19525	85	be	be	VBP
18637	19525	86	lacking	lack	VBG
18637	19525	87	,	,	,
18637	19525	88	there	there	EX
18637	19525	89	must	must	MD
18637	19525	90	be	be	VB
18637	19525	91	in	in	IN
18637	19525	92	any	any	DT
18637	19525	93	event	event	NN
18637	19525	94	a	a	DT
18637	19525	95	manifest	manif	JJS
18637	19525	96	disparity	disparity	NN
18637	19525	97	in	in	IN
18637	19525	98	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	19525	99	of	of	IN
18637	19525	100	proof	proof	NN
18637	19525	101	and	and	CC
18637	19525	102	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19525	103	for	for	IN
18637	19525	104	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	19525	105	,	,	,
18637	19525	106	*	*	NFP
18637	19525	107	*	*	NFP
18637	19525	108	*	*	NFP
18637	19525	109	"	"	``
18637	19525	110	Whereas	whereas	IN
18637	19525	111	,	,	,
18637	19525	112	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19525	113	,	,	,
18637	19525	114	under	under	IN
18637	19525	115	the	the	DT
18637	19525	116	terms	term	NNS
18637	19525	117	of	of	IN
18637	19525	118	the	the	DT
18637	19525	119	section	section	NN
18637	19525	120	previously	previously	RB
18637	19525	121	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	19525	122	,	,	,
18637	19525	123	the	the	DT
18637	19525	124	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19525	125	could	could	MD
18637	19525	126	prove	prove	VB
18637	19525	127	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19525	128	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	19525	129	without	without	IN
18637	19525	130	trouble	trouble	NN
18637	19525	131	,	,	,
18637	19525	132	and	and	CC
18637	19525	133	the	the	DT
18637	19525	134	State	State	NNP
18637	19525	135	,	,	,
18637	19525	136	if	if	IN
18637	19525	137	forced	force	VBN
18637	19525	138	to	to	TO
18637	19525	139	disprove	disprove	VB
18637	19525	140	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19525	141	claim	claim	NN
18637	19525	142	,	,	,
18637	19525	143	could	could	MD
18637	19525	144	be	be	VB
18637	19525	145	relatively	relatively	RB
18637	19525	146	helpless	helpless	JJ
18637	19525	147	,	,	,
18637	19525	148	the	the	DT
18637	19525	149	background	background	NN
18637	19525	150	of	of	IN
18637	19525	151	the	the	DT
18637	19525	152	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19525	153	party	party	NN
18637	19525	154	being	be	VBG
18637	19525	155	known	know	VBN
18637	19525	156	probably	probably	RB
18637	19525	157	only	only	RB
18637	19525	158	to	to	IN
18637	19525	159	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19525	160	and	and	CC
18637	19525	161	close	close	VB
18637	19525	162	relatives	relative	NNS
18637	19525	163	,	,	,
18637	19525	164	the	the	DT
18637	19525	165	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	19525	166	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	19525	167	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19525	168	,	,	,
18637	19525	169	in	in	IN
18637	19525	170	the	the	DT
18637	19525	171	last	last	JJ
18637	19525	172	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	19525	173	case	case	NN
18637	19525	174	,	,	,
18637	19525	175	would	would	MD
18637	19525	176	have	have	VB
18637	19525	177	suffered	suffer	VBN
18637	19525	178	hardship	hardship	NN
18637	19525	179	and	and	CC
18637	19525	180	injustice	injustice	NN
18637	19525	181	if	if	IN
18637	19525	182	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	19525	183	to	to	TO
18637	19525	184	prove	prove	VB
18637	19525	185	non	non	JJ
18637	19525	186	-	-	JJ
18637	19525	187	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	19525	188	origin	origin	NN
18637	19525	189	,	,	,
18637	19525	190	especially	especially	RB
18637	19525	191	since	since	IN
18637	19525	192	ineligibility	ineligibility	NN
18637	19525	193	renders	render	VBZ
18637	19525	194	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19525	195	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	19525	196	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	19525	197	lacking	lack	VBG
18637	19525	198	in	in	IN
18637	19525	199	"	"	``
18637	19525	200	sinister	sinister	JJ
18637	19525	201	significance	significance	NN
18637	19525	202	"	"	''
18637	19525	203	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19525	204	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	19525	205	of	of	IN
18637	19525	206	land	land	NN
18637	19525	207	under	under	IN
18637	19525	208	lease	lease	NN
18637	19525	209	from	from	IN
18637	19525	210	an	an	DT
18637	19525	211	American	american	JJ
18637	19525	212	codefendant	codefendant	NN
18637	19525	213	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19525	214	.	.	.
18637	19526	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19526	2	798	798	CD
18637	19526	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19526	4	On	on	IN
18637	19526	5	the	the	DT
18637	19526	6	other	other	JJ
18637	19526	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	19526	8	,	,	,
18637	19526	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19526	10	was	be	VBD
18637	19526	11	held	hold	VBN
18637	19526	12	in	in	IN
18637	19526	13	a	a	DT
18637	19526	14	recent	recent	JJ
18637	19526	15	case	case	NN
18637	19526	16	,	,	,
18637	19526	17	that	that	IN
18637	19526	18	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	19526	19	was	be	VBD
18637	19526	20	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19526	21	to	to	TO
18637	19526	22	require	require	VB
18637	19526	23	that	that	IN
18637	19526	24	one	one	CD
18637	19526	25	pleading	plead	VBG
18637	19526	26	insanity	insanity	NN
18637	19526	27	as	as	IN
18637	19526	28	a	a	DT
18637	19526	29	defense	defense	NN
18637	19526	30	against	against	IN
18637	19526	31	a	a	DT
18637	19526	32	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19526	33	charge	charge	NN
18637	19526	34	should	should	MD
18637	19526	35	prove	prove	VB
18637	19526	36	same	same	JJ
18637	19526	37	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19526	38	a	a	DT
18637	19526	39	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19526	40	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	19526	41	,	,	,
18637	19526	42	and	and	CC
18637	19526	43	to	to	TO
18637	19526	44	make	make	VB
18637	19526	45	"	"	``
18637	19526	46	morbid	morbid	NN
18637	19526	47	propensity	propensity	NN
18637	19526	48	"	"	''
18637	19526	49	no	no	DT
18637	19526	50	defense	defense	NN
18637	19526	51	.	.	.
18637	19527	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19527	2	799	799	CD
18637	19527	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19527	4	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	19527	5	Trials	Trials	NNPS
18637	19527	6	:	:	:
18637	19527	7	Dispensing	dispense	VBG
18637	19527	8	With	with	IN
18637	19527	9	Jury	jury	NN
18637	19527	10	Trials	Trials	NNPS
18637	19527	11	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	19527	12	by	by	IN
18637	19527	13	jury	jury	NN
18637	19527	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	19527	15	not	not	RB
18637	19527	16	been	be	VBN
18637	19527	17	considered	consider	VBN
18637	19527	18	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19527	19	to	to	IN
18637	19527	20	due	due	JJ
18637	19527	21	process	process	NN
18637	19527	22	,	,	,
18637	19527	23	and	and	CC
18637	19527	24	since	since	IN
18637	19527	25	the	the	DT
18637	19527	26	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19527	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19527	28	guarantees	guarantee	VBZ
18637	19527	29	no	no	DT
18637	19527	30	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19527	31	form	form	NN
18637	19527	32	or	or	CC
18637	19527	33	method	method	NN
18637	19527	34	of	of	IN
18637	19527	35	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19527	36	,	,	,
18637	19527	37	States	state	NNS
18637	19527	38	have	have	VBP
18637	19527	39	been	be	VBN
18637	19527	40	free	free	JJ
18637	19527	41	to	to	TO
18637	19527	42	retain	retain	VB
18637	19527	43	or	or	CC
18637	19527	44	abolish	abolish	VB
18637	19527	45	juries	jury	NNS
18637	19527	46	.	.	.
18637	19528	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19528	2	800	800	CD
18637	19528	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19528	4	Conformably	conformably	RB
18637	19528	5	to	to	IN
18637	19528	6	the	the	DT
18637	19528	7	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19528	8	,	,	,
18637	19528	9	States	States	NNP
18637	19528	10	,	,	,
18637	19528	11	in	in	IN
18637	19528	12	devising	devise	VBG
18637	19528	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19528	14	own	own	JJ
18637	19528	15	procedures	procedure	NNS
18637	19528	16	,	,	,
18637	19528	17	eliminated	eliminate	VBN
18637	19528	18	juries	jury	NNS
18637	19528	19	in	in	IN
18637	19528	20	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19528	21	to	to	TO
18637	19528	22	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	19528	23	liens,[801	liens,[801	NN
18637	19528	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19528	25	inquiries	inquiry	NNS
18637	19528	26	for	for	IN
18637	19528	27	contempt,[802	contempt,[802	NN
18637	19528	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19528	29	mandamus[803	mandamus[803	NN
18637	19528	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19528	31	and	and	CC
18637	19528	32	quo	quo	VB
18637	19528	33	warranto	warranto	NN
18637	19528	34	actions,[804	actions,[804	NNP
18637	19528	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19528	36	and	and	CC
18637	19528	37	in	in	IN
18637	19528	38	eminent	eminent	NNP
18637	19528	39	domain[805	domain[805	NNP
18637	19528	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19528	41	and	and	CC
18637	19528	42	equity	equity	NN
18637	19528	43	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19528	44	.	.	.
18637	19529	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19529	2	806	806	CD
18637	19529	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19529	4	States	state	NNS
18637	19529	5	are	be	VBP
18637	19529	6	equally	equally	RB
18637	19529	7	free	free	JJ
18637	19529	8	to	to	TO
18637	19529	9	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	19529	10	innovations	innovation	NNS
18637	19529	11	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	19529	12	the	the	DT
18637	19529	13	selection	selection	NN
18637	19529	14	and	and	CC
18637	19529	15	number	number	NN
18637	19529	16	of	of	IN
18637	19529	17	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	19529	18	.	.	.
18637	19530	1	Verdicts	verdict	NNS
18637	19530	2	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19530	3	by	by	IN
18637	19530	4	ten	ten	CD
18637	19530	5	out	out	IN
18637	19530	6	of	of	IN
18637	19530	7	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	19530	8	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	19530	9	may	may	MD
18637	19530	10	be	be	VB
18637	19530	11	substituted	substitute	VBN
18637	19530	12	for	for	IN
18637	19530	13	the	the	DT
18637	19530	14	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19530	15	of	of	IN
18637	19530	16	a	a	DT
18637	19530	17	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	19530	18	verdict,[807	verdict,[807	NN
18637	19530	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19530	20	and	and	CC
18637	19530	21	petit	petit	NN
18637	19530	22	juries	jury	NNS
18637	19530	23	containing	contain	VBG
18637	19530	24	eight	eight	CD
18637	19530	25	rather	rather	RB
18637	19530	26	than	than	IN
18637	19530	27	the	the	DT
18637	19530	28	conventional	conventional	JJ
18637	19530	29	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	19530	30	members	member	NNS
18637	19530	31	may	may	MD
18637	19530	32	be	be	VB
18637	19530	33	established	establish	VBN
18637	19530	34	.	.	.
18637	19531	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19531	2	808	808	CD
18637	19531	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19531	4	DUE	DUE	NNP
18637	19531	5	PROCESS	PROCESS	NNP
18637	19531	6	IN	in	IN
18637	19531	7	CRIMINAL	criminal	JJ
18637	19531	8	PROCEEDINGS	proceeding	NNS
18637	19531	9	General	General	NNP
18637	19531	10	In	in	IN
18637	19531	11	the	the	DT
18637	19531	12	following	follow	VBG
18637	19531	13	pages	page	NNS
18637	19531	14	the	the	DT
18637	19531	15	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	19531	16	of	of	IN
18637	19531	17	the	the	DT
18637	19531	18	due	due	JJ
18637	19531	19	process	process	NN
18637	19531	20	clause	clause	NN
18637	19531	21	of	of	IN
18637	19531	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19531	23	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	19531	24	in	in	IN
18637	19531	25	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19531	26	cases	case	NNS
18637	19531	27	will	will	MD
18637	19531	28	be	be	VB
18637	19531	29	dealt	deal	VBN
18637	19531	30	with	with	IN
18637	19531	31	in	in	IN
18637	19531	32	approximately	approximately	RB
18637	19531	33	the	the	DT
18637	19531	34	order	order	NN
18637	19531	35	in	in	IN
18637	19531	36	which	which	WDT
18637	19531	37	questions	question	NNS
18637	19531	38	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	19531	39	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19531	40	arise	arise	VBP
18637	19531	41	in	in	IN
18637	19531	42	the	the	DT
18637	19531	43	course	course	NN
18637	19531	44	of	of	IN
18637	19531	45	a	a	DT
18637	19531	46	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	19531	47	.	.	.
18637	19532	1	Indefinite	Indefinite	NNP
18637	19532	2	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	19532	3	:	:	:
18637	19532	4	Right	right	RB
18637	19532	5	of	of	IN
18637	19532	6	Accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19532	7	to	to	IN
18637	19532	8	Knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	19532	9	of	of	IN
18637	19532	10	Offense	Offense	NNP
18637	19532	11	"	"	''
18637	19532	12	A	a	DT
18637	19532	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	19532	14	so	so	RB
18637	19532	15	vague	vague	JJ
18637	19532	16	and	and	CC
18637	19532	17	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	19532	18	,	,	,
18637	19532	19	in	in	IN
18637	19532	20	form	form	NN
18637	19532	21	and	and	CC
18637	19532	22	as	as	IN
18637	19532	23	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	19532	24	,	,	,
18637	19532	25	*	*	NFP
18637	19532	26	*	*	NFP
18637	19532	27	*	*	NFP
18637	19532	28	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19532	29	as	as	IN
18637	19532	30	to	to	TO
18637	19532	31	fail	fail	VB
18637	19532	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19532	33	to	to	TO
18637	19532	34	give	give	VB
18637	19532	35	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19532	36	notice	notice	NN
18637	19532	37	of	of	IN
18637	19532	38	what	what	WDT
18637	19532	39	acts	act	NNS
18637	19532	40	will	will	MD
18637	19532	41	be	be	VB
18637	19532	42	punished	punish	VBN
18637	19532	43	,	,	,
18637	19532	44	*	*	NFP
18637	19532	45	*	*	NFP
18637	19532	46	*	*	NFP
18637	19532	47	,	,	,
18637	19532	48	violates	violate	VBZ
18637	19532	49	an	an	DT
18637	19532	50	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19532	51	's	's	POS
18637	19532	52	rights	right	NNS
18637	19532	53	under	under	IN
18637	19532	54	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	19532	55	due	due	JJ
18637	19532	56	process	process	NN
18637	19532	57	*	*	NFP
18637	19532	58	*	*	NFP
18637	19532	59	*	*	NFP
18637	19532	60	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19532	61	A	a	DT
18637	19532	62	penal	penal	JJ
18637	19532	63	statute	statute	NN
18637	19532	64	must	must	MD
18637	19532	65	set	set	VB
18637	19532	66	up	up	RP
18637	19532	67	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19532	68	ascertainable	ascertainable	JJ
18637	19532	69	standards	standard	NNS
18637	19532	70	of	of	IN
18637	19532	71	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	19532	72	.	.	.
18637	19533	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19533	2	So	so	IN
18637	19533	3	that	that	IN
18637	19533	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19533	5	men	man	NNS
18637	19533	6	of	of	IN
18637	19533	7	common	common	JJ
18637	19533	8	intelligence	intelligence	NN
18637	19533	9	*	*	NFP
18637	19533	10	*	*	NFP
18637	19533	11	*	*	NFP
18637	19533	12	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19533	13	are	be	VBP
18637	19533	14	not	not	RB
18637	19533	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19533	16	required	require	VBN
18637	19533	17	to	to	TO
18637	19533	18	guess	guess	VB
18637	19533	19	at	at	IN
18637	19533	20	*	*	NFP
18637	19533	21	*	*	NFP
18637	19533	22	*	*	NFP
18637	19533	23	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19533	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19533	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19533	26	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	19533	27	,	,	,
18637	19533	28	"	"	''
18637	19533	29	either	either	CC
18637	19533	30	as	as	IN
18637	19533	31	to	to	IN
18637	19533	32	persons	person	NNS
18637	19533	33	within	within	IN
18637	19533	34	the	the	DT
18637	19533	35	scope	scope	NN
18637	19533	36	of	of	IN
18637	19533	37	the	the	DT
18637	19533	38	act	act	NN
18637	19533	39	or	or	CC
18637	19533	40	as	as	IN
18637	19533	41	to	to	TO
18637	19533	42	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	19533	43	tests	test	NNS
18637	19533	44	to	to	TO
18637	19533	45	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	19533	46	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	19533	47	.	.	.
18637	19534	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19534	2	809	809	CD
18637	19534	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19534	4	Defective	Defective	NNP
18637	19534	5	by	by	IN
18637	19534	6	these	these	DT
18637	19534	7	tests	test	NNS
18637	19534	8	and	and	CC
18637	19534	9	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	19534	10	violative	violative	JJ
18637	19534	11	of	of	IN
18637	19534	12	due	due	JJ
18637	19534	13	process	process	NN
18637	19534	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19534	15	a	a	DT
18637	19534	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	19534	17	providing	provide	VBG
18637	19534	18	that	that	IN
18637	19534	19	any	any	DT
18637	19534	20	person	person	NN
18637	19534	21	not	not	RB
18637	19534	22	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	19534	23	in	in	IN
18637	19534	24	any	any	DT
18637	19534	25	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	19534	26	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	19534	27	,	,	,
18637	19534	28	known	know	VBN
18637	19534	29	to	to	TO
18637	19534	30	be	be	VB
18637	19534	31	a	a	DT
18637	19534	32	member	member	NN
18637	19534	33	of	of	IN
18637	19534	34	any	any	DT
18637	19534	35	gang	gang	NN
18637	19534	36	consisting	consist	VBG
18637	19534	37	of	of	IN
18637	19534	38	two	two	CD
18637	19534	39	or	or	CC
18637	19534	40	more	more	JJR
18637	19534	41	persons	person	NNS
18637	19534	42	,	,	,
18637	19534	43	who	who	WP
18637	19534	44	has	have	VBZ
18637	19534	45	been	be	VBN
18637	19534	46	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	19534	47	at	at	RB
18637	19534	48	least	least	RBS
18637	19534	49	three	three	CD
18637	19534	50	times	time	NNS
18637	19534	51	of	of	IN
18637	19534	52	being	be	VBG
18637	19534	53	a	a	DT
18637	19534	54	disorderly	disorderly	JJ
18637	19534	55	person	person	NN
18637	19534	56	,	,	,
18637	19534	57	or	or	CC
18637	19534	58	who	who	WP
18637	19534	59	has	have	VBZ
18637	19534	60	been	be	VBN
18637	19534	61	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	19534	62	of	of	IN
18637	19534	63	any	any	DT
18637	19534	64	crime	crime	NN
18637	19534	65	in	in	IN
18637	19534	66	this	this	DT
18637	19534	67	or	or	CC
18637	19534	68	any	any	DT
18637	19534	69	other	other	JJ
18637	19534	70	State	State	NNP
18637	19534	71	,	,	,
18637	19534	72	is	be	VBZ
18637	19534	73	a	a	DT
18637	19534	74	gangster	gangster	NN
18637	19534	75	and	and	CC
18637	19534	76	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19534	77	to	to	IN
18637	19534	78	fine	fine	JJ
18637	19534	79	or	or	CC
18637	19534	80	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	19534	81	.	.	.
18637	19535	1	Pointing	point	VBG
18637	19535	2	to	to	IN
18637	19535	3	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19535	4	shortcomings	shortcoming	NNS
18637	19535	5	of	of	IN
18637	19535	6	this	this	DT
18637	19535	7	act	act	NN
18637	19535	8	,	,	,
18637	19535	9	the	the	DT
18637	19535	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19535	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19535	12	observed	observe	VBD
18637	19535	13	that	that	IN
18637	19535	14	"	"	``
18637	19535	15	*	*	NFP
18637	19535	16	*	*	NFP
18637	19535	17	*	*	NFP
18637	19535	18	neither	neither	CC
18637	19535	19	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19535	20	at	at	IN
18637	19535	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19535	22	common	common	JJ
18637	19535	23	law	law	NN
18637	19535	24	,	,	,
18637	19535	25	*	*	NFP
18637	19535	26	*	*	NFP
18637	19535	27	*	*	NFP
18637	19535	28	nor	nor	CC
18637	19535	29	anywhere	anywhere	RB
18637	19535	30	in	in	IN
18637	19535	31	the	the	DT
18637	19535	32	language	language	NN
18637	19535	33	of	of	IN
18637	19535	34	the	the	DT
18637	19535	35	law	law	NN
18637	19535	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	19535	37	there	there	RB
18637	19535	38	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19535	39	to	to	TO
18637	19535	40	be	be	VB
18637	19535	41	found	find	VBN
18637	19535	42	any	any	DT
18637	19535	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19535	44	definition	definition	NN
18637	19535	45	of	of	IN
18637	19535	46	the	the	DT
18637	19535	47	word	word	NN
18637	19535	48	,	,	,
18637	19535	49	*	*	NFP
18637	19535	50	*	*	NFP
18637	19535	51	*	*	NFP
18637	19535	52	'	'	``
18637	19535	53	gang	gang	NN
18637	19535	54	'	'	''
18637	19535	55	.	.	.
18637	19535	56	"	"	''
18637	19536	1	The	the	DT
18637	19536	2	State	State	NNP
18637	19536	3	courts	court	NNS
18637	19536	4	,	,	,
18637	19536	5	in	in	IN
18637	19536	6	adopting	adopt	VBG
18637	19536	7	dictionary	dictionary	JJ
18637	19536	8	definitions	definition	NNS
18637	19536	9	of	of	IN
18637	19536	10	that	that	DT
18637	19536	11	term	term	NN
18637	19536	12	,	,	,
18637	19536	13	were	be	VBD
18637	19536	14	not	not	RB
18637	19536	15	to	to	TO
18637	19536	16	be	be	VB
18637	19536	17	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19536	18	as	as	IN
18637	19536	19	having	have	VBG
18637	19536	20	intended	intend	VBN
18637	19536	21	to	to	TO
18637	19536	22	give	give	VB
18637	19536	23	"	"	``
18637	19536	24	gangster	gangster	NN
18637	19536	25	"	"	''
18637	19536	26	a	a	DT
18637	19536	27	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	19536	28	broad	broad	RB
18637	19536	29	enough	enough	RB
18637	19536	30	to	to	TO
18637	19536	31	include	include	VB
18637	19536	32	anyone	anyone	NN
18637	19536	33	who	who	WP
18637	19536	34	had	have	VBD
18637	19536	35	not	not	RB
18637	19536	36	been	be	VBN
18637	19536	37	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	19536	38	of	of	IN
18637	19536	39	a	a	DT
18637	19536	40	specified	specify	VBN
18637	19536	41	crime	crime	NN
18637	19536	42	or	or	CC
18637	19536	43	of	of	IN
18637	19536	44	disorderly	disorderly	JJ
18637	19536	45	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	19536	46	as	as	IN
18637	19536	47	set	set	VBN
18637	19536	48	out	out	RP
18637	19536	49	in	in	IN
18637	19536	50	the	the	DT
18637	19536	51	statute	statute	NN
18637	19536	52	,	,	,
18637	19536	53	or	or	CC
18637	19536	54	to	to	TO
18637	19536	55	limit	limit	VB
18637	19536	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19536	57	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	19536	58	to	to	IN
18637	19536	59	the	the	DT
18637	19536	60	field	field	NN
18637	19536	61	covered	cover	VBN
18637	19536	62	by	by	IN
18637	19536	63	the	the	DT
18637	19536	64	words	word	NNS
18637	19536	65	that	that	WDT
18637	19536	66	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19536	67	found	find	VBD
18637	19536	68	in	in	IN
18637	19536	69	a	a	DT
18637	19536	70	dictionary	dictionary	NN
18637	19536	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19536	72	"	"	``
18637	19536	73	roughs	rough	NNS
18637	19536	74	,	,	,
18637	19536	75	thieves	thief	NNS
18637	19536	76	,	,	,
18637	19536	77	criminals	criminal	NNS
18637	19536	78	"	"	''
18637	19536	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19536	80	.	.	.
18637	19537	1	Application	application	NN
18637	19537	2	of	of	IN
18637	19537	3	the	the	DT
18637	19537	4	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19537	5	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	19537	6	would	would	MD
18637	19537	7	include	include	VB
18637	19537	8	some	some	DT
18637	19537	9	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	19537	10	not	not	RB
18637	19537	11	within	within	IN
18637	19537	12	the	the	DT
18637	19537	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	19537	14	and	and	CC
18637	19537	15	would	would	MD
18637	19537	16	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	19537	17	some	some	DT
18637	19537	18	plainly	plainly	RB
18637	19537	19	covered	cover	VBN
18637	19537	20	by	by	IN
18637	19537	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19537	22	.	.	.
18637	19538	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	19538	2	,	,	,
18637	19538	3	the	the	DT
18637	19538	4	expression	expression	NN
18637	19538	5	,	,	,
18637	19538	6	"	"	``
18637	19538	7	known	know	VBN
18637	19538	8	to	to	TO
18637	19538	9	be	be	VB
18637	19538	10	a	a	DT
18637	19538	11	member	member	NN
18637	19538	12	,	,	,
18637	19538	13	"	"	``
18637	19538	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19538	15	ambiguous	ambiguous	JJ
18637	19538	16	;	;	:
18637	19538	17	and	and	CC
18637	19538	18	not	not	RB
18637	19538	19	only	only	RB
18637	19538	20	permits	permit	VBZ
18637	19538	21	a	a	DT
18637	19538	22	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	19538	23	as	as	IN
18637	19538	24	to	to	IN
18637	19538	25	whether	whether	IN
18637	19538	26	actual	actual	JJ
18637	19538	27	or	or	CC
18637	19538	28	putative	putative	JJ
18637	19538	29	association	association	NN
18637	19538	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	19538	31	meant	mean	VBN
18637	19538	32	,	,	,
18637	19538	33	but	but	CC
18637	19538	34	also	also	RB
18637	19538	35	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	19538	36	to	to	TO
18637	19538	37	indicate	indicate	VB
18637	19538	38	what	what	WP
18637	19538	39	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	19538	40	membership	membership	NN
18637	19538	41	or	or	CC
18637	19538	42	how	how	WRB
18637	19538	43	one	one	PRP
18637	19538	44	may	may	MD
18637	19538	45	join	join	VB
18637	19538	46	a	a	DT
18637	19538	47	gang	gang	NN
18637	19538	48	.	.	.
18637	19539	1	In	in	IN
18637	19539	2	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	19539	3	,	,	,
18637	19539	4	the	the	DT
18637	19539	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19539	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19539	7	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19539	8	that	that	IN
18637	19539	9	if	if	IN
18637	19539	10	on	on	IN
18637	19539	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19539	12	face	face	NN
18637	19539	13	a	a	DT
18637	19539	14	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	19539	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	19539	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	19539	17	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	19539	18	to	to	IN
18637	19539	19	the	the	DT
18637	19539	20	due	due	JJ
18637	19539	21	process	process	NN
18637	19539	22	clause	clause	NN
18637	19539	23	,	,	,
18637	19539	24	specification	specification	NN
18637	19539	25	of	of	IN
18637	19539	26	details	detail	NNS
18637	19539	27	of	of	IN
18637	19539	28	the	the	DT
18637	19539	29	offense	offense	NN
18637	19539	30	intended	intend	VBD
18637	19539	31	to	to	TO
18637	19539	32	be	be	VB
18637	19539	33	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19539	34	would	would	MD
18637	19539	35	not	not	RB
18637	19539	36	serve	serve	VB
18637	19539	37	to	to	TO
18637	19539	38	validate	validate	VB
18637	19539	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19539	40	;	;	:
18637	19539	41	for	for	IN
18637	19539	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19539	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	19539	44	the	the	DT
18637	19539	45	statute	statute	NN
18637	19539	46	,	,	,
18637	19539	47	not	not	RB
18637	19539	48	the	the	DT
18637	19539	49	accusation	accusation	NN
18637	19539	50	under	under	IN
18637	19539	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19539	52	,	,	,
18637	19539	53	that	that	WDT
18637	19539	54	prescribes	prescribe	VBZ
18637	19539	55	the	the	DT
18637	19539	56	rule	rule	NN
18637	19539	57	to	to	TO
18637	19539	58	govern	govern	VB
18637	19539	59	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	19539	60	and	and	CC
18637	19539	61	warns	warn	VBZ
18637	19539	62	against	against	IN
18637	19539	63	transgression	transgression	NN
18637	19539	64	.	.	.
18637	19540	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19540	2	810	810	CD
18637	19540	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19540	4	In	in	IN
18637	19540	5	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	19540	6	,	,	,
18637	19540	7	the	the	DT
18637	19540	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19540	9	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	19540	10	as	as	IN
18637	19540	11	neither	neither	CC
18637	19540	12	too	too	RB
18637	19540	13	vague	vague	JJ
18637	19540	14	nor	nor	CC
18637	19540	15	indefinite	indefinite	IN
18637	19540	16	a	a	DT
18637	19540	17	State	State	NNP
18637	19540	18	law	law	NN
18637	19540	19	which	which	WDT
18637	19540	20	provided	provide	VBD
18637	19540	21	for	for	IN
18637	19540	22	commitment	commitment	NN
18637	19540	23	of	of	IN
18637	19540	24	a	a	DT
18637	19540	25	psychopathic	psychopathic	JJ
18637	19540	26	personality	personality	NN
18637	19540	27	by	by	IN
18637	19540	28	probate	probate	NN
18637	19540	29	action	action	NN
18637	19540	30	akin	akin	JJ
18637	19540	31	to	to	IN
18637	19540	32	a	a	DT
18637	19540	33	lunacy	lunacy	NN
18637	19540	34	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19540	35	,	,	,
18637	19540	36	and	and	CC
18637	19540	37	which	which	WDT
18637	19540	38	was	be	VBD
18637	19540	39	construed	construe	VBN
18637	19540	40	by	by	IN
18637	19540	41	the	the	DT
18637	19540	42	State	State	NNP
18637	19540	43	court	court	NN
18637	19540	44	as	as	IN
18637	19540	45	including	include	VBG
18637	19540	46	those	those	DT
18637	19540	47	persons	person	NNS
18637	19540	48	who	who	WP
18637	19540	49	,	,	,
18637	19540	50	by	by	IN
18637	19540	51	habitual	habitual	JJ
18637	19540	52	course	course	NN
18637	19540	53	of	of	IN
18637	19540	54	misconduct	misconduct	NN
18637	19540	55	in	in	IN
18637	19540	56	sexual	sexual	JJ
18637	19540	57	matters	matter	NNS
18637	19540	58	,	,	,
18637	19540	59	have	have	VBP
18637	19540	60	evidenced	evidence	VBN
18637	19540	61	utter	utter	JJ
18637	19540	62	lack	lack	NN
18637	19540	63	of	of	IN
18637	19540	64	power	power	NN
18637	19540	65	to	to	TO
18637	19540	66	control	control	VB
18637	19540	67	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19540	68	sexual	sexual	JJ
18637	19540	69	impulses	impulse	NNS
18637	19540	70	and	and	CC
18637	19540	71	are	be	VBP
18637	19540	72	likely	likely	JJ
18637	19540	73	to	to	TO
18637	19540	74	inflict	inflict	VB
18637	19540	75	injury	injury	NN
18637	19540	76	.	.	.
18637	19541	1	The	the	DT
18637	19541	2	underlying	underlie	VBG
18637	19541	3	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19541	4	,	,	,
18637	19541	5	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	19541	6	,	,	,
18637	19541	7	habitual	habitual	JJ
18637	19541	8	course	course	NN
18637	19541	9	of	of	IN
18637	19541	10	misconduct	misconduct	NN
18637	19541	11	in	in	IN
18637	19541	12	sex	sex	NN
18637	19541	13	matters	matter	NNS
18637	19541	14	and	and	CC
18637	19541	15	lack	lack	NN
18637	19541	16	of	of	IN
18637	19541	17	power	power	NN
18637	19541	18	to	to	TO
18637	19541	19	control	control	VB
18637	19541	20	impulses	impulse	NNS
18637	19541	21	,	,	,
18637	19541	22	and	and	CC
18637	19541	23	likelihood	likelihood	NN
18637	19541	24	of	of	IN
18637	19541	25	attack	attack	NN
18637	19541	26	on	on	IN
18637	19541	27	others	other	NNS
18637	19541	28	,	,	,
18637	19541	29	were	be	VBD
18637	19541	30	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19541	31	as	as	IN
18637	19541	32	calling	call	VBG
18637	19541	33	for	for	IN
18637	19541	34	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19541	35	of	of	IN
18637	19541	36	past	past	JJ
18637	19541	37	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	19541	38	pointing	point	VBG
18637	19541	39	to	to	IN
18637	19541	40	probable	probable	JJ
18637	19541	41	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	19541	42	and	and	CC
18637	19541	43	as	as	IN
18637	19541	44	being	be	VBG
18637	19541	45	as	as	RB
18637	19541	46	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
18637	19541	47	of	of	IN
18637	19541	48	proof	proof	NN
18637	19541	49	as	as	IN
18637	19541	50	many	many	JJ
18637	19541	51	of	of	IN
18637	19541	52	the	the	DT
18637	19541	53	criteria	criterion	NNS
18637	19541	54	constantly	constantly	RB
18637	19541	55	applied	apply	VBD
18637	19541	56	in	in	IN
18637	19541	57	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19541	58	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	19541	59	.	.	.
18637	19542	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19542	2	811	811	CD
18637	19542	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19542	4	Abolition	abolition	NN
18637	19542	5	of	of	IN
18637	19542	6	the	the	DT
18637	19542	7	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	19542	8	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	19542	9	An	an	DT
18637	19542	10	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	19542	11	or	or	CC
18637	19542	12	presentment	presentment	NN
18637	19542	13	by	by	IN
18637	19542	14	a	a	DT
18637	19542	15	grand	grand	JJ
18637	19542	16	jury	jury	NN
18637	19542	17	,	,	,
18637	19542	18	as	as	IN
18637	19542	19	known	know	VBN
18637	19542	20	to	to	IN
18637	19542	21	the	the	DT
18637	19542	22	common	common	JJ
18637	19542	23	law	law	NN
18637	19542	24	of	of	IN
18637	19542	25	England	England	NNP
18637	19542	26	,	,	,
18637	19542	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	19542	28	not	not	RB
18637	19542	29	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19542	30	to	to	TO
18637	19542	31	due	due	JJ
18637	19542	32	process	process	NN
18637	19542	33	of	of	IN
18637	19542	34	law	law	NN
18637	19542	35	even	even	RB
18637	19542	36	when	when	WRB
18637	19542	37	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19542	38	to	to	IN
18637	19542	39	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	19542	40	for	for	IN
18637	19542	41	felonies	felony	NNS
18637	19542	42	.	.	.
18637	19543	1	Substitution	substitution	NN
18637	19543	2	for	for	IN
18637	19543	3	a	a	DT
18637	19543	4	presentment	presentment	NN
18637	19543	5	or	or	CC
18637	19543	6	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	19543	7	by	by	IN
18637	19543	8	a	a	DT
18637	19543	9	grand	grand	JJ
18637	19543	10	jury	jury	NN
18637	19543	11	of	of	IN
18637	19543	12	the	the	DT
18637	19543	13	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19543	14	by	by	IN
18637	19543	15	information	information	NN
18637	19543	16	,	,	,
18637	19543	17	after	after	IN
18637	19543	18	examination	examination	NN
18637	19543	19	and	and	CC
18637	19543	20	commitment	commitment	NN
18637	19543	21	by	by	IN
18637	19543	22	a	a	DT
18637	19543	23	magistrate	magistrate	NN
18637	19543	24	,	,	,
18637	19543	25	certifying	certify	VBG
18637	19543	26	to	to	IN
18637	19543	27	the	the	DT
18637	19543	28	probable	probable	JJ
18637	19543	29	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	19543	30	of	of	IN
18637	19543	31	the	the	DT
18637	19543	32	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19543	33	,	,	,
18637	19543	34	with	with	IN
18637	19543	35	the	the	DT
18637	19543	36	right	right	NN
18637	19543	37	on	on	IN
18637	19543	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19543	39	part	part	NN
18637	19543	40	to	to	IN
18637	19543	41	the	the	DT
18637	19543	42	aid	aid	NN
18637	19543	43	of	of	IN
18637	19543	44	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19543	45	,	,	,
18637	19543	46	and	and	CC
18637	19543	47	to	to	IN
18637	19543	48	the	the	DT
18637	19543	49	cross	cross	NN
18637	19543	50	-	-	NN
18637	19543	51	examination	examination	NN
18637	19543	52	of	of	IN
18637	19543	53	the	the	DT
18637	19543	54	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	19543	55	produced	produce	VBN
18637	19543	56	for	for	IN
18637	19543	57	the	the	DT
18637	19543	58	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	19543	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	19543	60	due	due	JJ
18637	19543	61	process	process	NN
18637	19543	62	of	of	IN
18637	19543	63	law	law	NN
18637	19543	64	.	.	.
18637	19544	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19544	2	812	812	CD
18637	19544	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19544	4	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
18637	19544	5	,	,	,
18637	19544	6	due	due	JJ
18637	19544	7	process	process	NN
18637	19544	8	does	do	VBZ
18637	19544	9	not	not	RB
18637	19544	10	require	require	VB
18637	19544	11	that	that	IN
18637	19544	12	the	the	DT
18637	19544	13	information	information	NN
18637	19544	14	filed	file	VBN
18637	19544	15	by	by	IN
18637	19544	16	the	the	DT
18637	19544	17	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
18637	19544	18	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	19544	19	should	should	MD
18637	19544	20	have	have	VB
18637	19544	21	been	be	VBN
18637	19544	22	preceded	precede	VBN
18637	19544	23	by	by	IN
18637	19544	24	the	the	DT
18637	19544	25	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	19544	26	or	or	CC
18637	19544	27	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	19544	28	examination	examination	NN
18637	19544	29	of	of	IN
18637	19544	30	the	the	DT
18637	19544	31	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19544	32	.	.	.
18637	19545	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19545	2	813	813	CD
18637	19545	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19545	4	Even	even	RB
18637	19545	5	when	when	WRB
18637	19545	6	an	an	DT
18637	19545	7	information	information	NN
18637	19545	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	19545	9	filed	file	VBN
18637	19545	10	pending	pende	VBG
18637	19545	11	an	an	DT
18637	19545	12	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	19545	13	by	by	IN
18637	19545	14	the	the	DT
18637	19545	15	coroner	coroner	NN
18637	19545	16	,	,	,
18637	19545	17	due	due	JJ
18637	19545	18	process	process	NN
18637	19545	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	19545	20	not	not	RB
18637	19545	21	been	be	VBN
18637	19545	22	violated	violate	VBN
18637	19545	23	.	.	.
18637	19546	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19546	2	814	814	CD
18637	19546	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19546	4	But	but	CC
18637	19546	5	when	when	WRB
18637	19546	6	the	the	DT
18637	19546	7	grand	grand	JJ
18637	19546	8	jury	jury	NN
18637	19546	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19546	10	retained	retain	VBN
18637	19546	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19546	12	must	must	MD
18637	19546	13	be	be	VB
18637	19546	14	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	19546	15	constituted	constitute	VBN
18637	19546	16	.	.	.
18637	19547	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19547	2	,	,	,
18637	19547	3	in	in	IN
18637	19547	4	the	the	DT
18637	19547	5	leading	leading	JJ
18637	19547	6	case	case	NN
18637	19547	7	,	,	,
18637	19547	8	an	an	DT
18637	19547	9	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	19547	10	by	by	IN
18637	19547	11	a	a	DT
18637	19547	12	grand	grand	JJ
18637	19547	13	jury	jury	NN
18637	19547	14	in	in	IN
18637	19547	15	a	a	DT
18637	19547	16	county	county	NN
18637	19547	17	of	of	IN
18637	19547	18	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	19547	19	in	in	IN
18637	19547	20	which	which	WDT
18637	19547	21	no	no	DT
18637	19547	22	member	member	NN
18637	19547	23	of	of	IN
18637	19547	24	a	a	DT
18637	19547	25	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	19547	26	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	19547	27	population	population	NN
18637	19547	28	had	have	VBD
18637	19547	29	ever	ever	RB
18637	19547	30	been	be	VBN
18637	19547	31	called	call	VBN
18637	19547	32	for	for	IN
18637	19547	33	jury	jury	NN
18637	19547	34	service	service	NN
18637	19547	35	,	,	,
18637	19547	36	was	be	VBD
18637	19547	37	held	hold	VBN
18637	19547	38	void	void	JJ
18637	19547	39	,	,	,
18637	19547	40	although	although	IN
18637	19547	41	the	the	DT
18637	19547	42	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	19547	43	statute	statute	NN
18637	19547	44	governing	govern	VBG
18637	19547	45	the	the	DT
18637	19547	46	matter	matter	NN
18637	19547	47	did	do	VBD
18637	19547	48	not	not	RB
18637	19547	49	discriminate	discriminate	VB
18637	19547	50	between	between	IN
18637	19547	51	the	the	DT
18637	19547	52	two	two	CD
18637	19547	53	races	race	NNS
18637	19547	54	.	.	.
18637	19548	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19548	2	815	815	CD
18637	19548	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19548	4	The	the	DT
18637	19548	5	Right	right	NN
18637	19548	6	to	to	IN
18637	19548	7	Counsel	Counsel	NNP
18637	19548	8	Whatever	Whatever	NNP
18637	19548	9	previously	previously	RB
18637	19548	10	may	may	MD
18637	19548	11	have	have	VB
18637	19548	12	been	be	VBN
18637	19548	13	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	19548	14	as	as	IN
18637	19548	15	constituting	constitute	VBG
18637	19548	16	the	the	DT
18637	19548	17	elements	element	NNS
18637	19548	18	of	of	IN
18637	19548	19	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	19548	20	due	due	JJ
18637	19548	21	process	process	NN
18637	19548	22	in	in	IN
18637	19548	23	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19548	24	cases	case	NNS
18637	19548	25	,	,	,
18637	19548	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19548	27	was	be	VBD
18637	19548	28	not	not	RB
18637	19548	29	until	until	IN
18637	19548	30	1932[816	1932[816	CD
18637	19548	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19548	32	that	that	IN
18637	19548	33	the	the	DT
18637	19548	34	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19548	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19548	36	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBD
18637	19548	37	that	that	IN
18637	19548	38	the	the	DT
18637	19548	39	right	right	NN
18637	19548	40	"	"	''
18637	19548	41	to	to	TO
18637	19548	42	have	have	VB
18637	19548	43	the	the	DT
18637	19548	44	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	19548	45	of	of	IN
18637	19548	46	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19548	47	for	for	IN
18637	19548	48	*	*	NFP
18637	19548	49	*	*	NFP
18637	19548	50	*	*	NFP
18637	19548	51	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19548	52	one	one	CD
18637	19548	53	's	's	POS
18637	19548	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19548	55	defense	defense	NN
18637	19548	56	,	,	,
18637	19548	57	"	"	''
18637	19548	58	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	19548	59	as	as	IN
18637	19548	60	against	against	IN
18637	19548	61	the	the	DT
18637	19548	62	National	National	NNP
18637	19548	63	Government	Government	NNP
18637	19548	64	by	by	IN
18637	19548	65	the	the	DT
18637	19548	66	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	19548	67	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19548	68	,	,	,
18637	19548	69	was	be	VBD
18637	19548	70	of	of	IN
18637	19548	71	such	such	JJ
18637	19548	72	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19548	73	character	character	NN
18637	19548	74	as	as	IN
18637	19548	75	to	to	TO
18637	19548	76	be	be	VB
18637	19548	77	embodied	embody	VBN
18637	19548	78	in	in	IN
18637	19548	79	the	the	DT
18637	19548	80	concept	concept	NN
18637	19548	81	of	of	IN
18637	19548	82	due	due	JJ
18637	19548	83	process	process	NN
18637	19548	84	of	of	IN
18637	19548	85	law	law	NN
18637	19548	86	as	as	IN
18637	19548	87	set	set	VBN
18637	19548	88	forth	forth	RP
18637	19548	89	in	in	IN
18637	19548	90	the	the	DT
18637	19548	91	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19548	92	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19548	93	.	.	.
18637	19549	1	Later	later	RB
18637	19549	2	in	in	IN
18637	19549	3	1937	1937	CD
18637	19549	4	,	,	,
18637	19549	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19549	6	effected	effect	VBD
18637	19549	7	this	this	DT
18637	19549	8	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	19549	9	by	by	IN
18637	19549	10	way	way	NN
18637	19549	11	of	of	IN
18637	19549	12	expansion	expansion	NN
18637	19549	13	of	of	IN
18637	19549	14	the	the	DT
18637	19549	15	term	term	NN
18637	19549	16	,	,	,
18637	19549	17	"	"	``
18637	19549	18	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19549	19	,	,	,
18637	19549	20	"	"	''
18637	19549	21	rather	rather	RB
18637	19549	22	than	than	IN
18637	19549	23	,	,	,
18637	19549	24	"	"	``
18637	19549	25	due	due	JJ
18637	19549	26	process	process	NN
18637	19549	27	,	,	,
18637	19549	28	"	"	''
18637	19549	29	and	and	CC
18637	19549	30	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	19549	31	that	that	IN
18637	19549	32	the	the	DT
18637	19549	33	right	right	NN
18637	19549	34	to	to	IN
18637	19549	35	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19549	36	was	be	VBD
18637	19549	37	"	"	``
18637	19549	38	implicit	implicit	JJ
18637	19549	39	in	in	IN
18637	19549	40	the	the	DT
18637	19549	41	concept	concept	NN
18637	19549	42	of	of	IN
18637	19549	43	ordered	order	VBN
18637	19549	44	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19549	45	.	.	.
18637	19550	1	"	"	``
18637	19550	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19550	3	817	817	CD
18637	19550	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19550	5	For	for	IN
18637	19550	6	want	want	NN
18637	19550	7	of	of	IN
18637	19550	8	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19550	9	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	19550	10	of	of	IN
18637	19550	11	the	the	DT
18637	19550	12	right	right	NN
18637	19550	13	to	to	TO
18637	19550	14	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	19550	15	,	,	,
18637	19550	16	the	the	DT
18637	19550	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19550	18	,	,	,
18637	19550	19	in	in	IN
18637	19550	20	Powell	Powell	NNP
18637	19550	21	_	_	NNP
18637	19550	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	19550	23	_	_	NNP
18637	19550	24	Alabama,[818	Alabama,[818	NNP
18637	19550	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19550	26	overturned	overturn	VBD
18637	19550	27	the	the	DT
18637	19550	28	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19550	29	of	of	IN
18637	19550	30	Negroes	negro	NNS
18637	19550	31	who	who	WP
18637	19550	32	had	have	VBD
18637	19550	33	received	receive	VBN
18637	19550	34	sentences	sentence	NNS
18637	19550	35	of	of	IN
18637	19550	36	death	death	NN
18637	19550	37	for	for	IN
18637	19550	38	rape	rape	NN
18637	19550	39	,	,	,
18637	19550	40	and	and	CC
18637	19550	41	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	19550	42	that	that	IN
18637	19550	43	,	,	,
18637	19550	44	at	at	IN
18637	19550	45	least	least	JJS
18637	19550	46	in	in	IN
18637	19550	47	capital	capital	NN
18637	19550	48	cases	case	NNS
18637	19550	49	,	,	,
18637	19550	50	where	where	WRB
18637	19550	51	the	the	DT
18637	19550	52	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19550	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	19550	54	unable	unable	JJ
18637	19550	55	to	to	TO
18637	19550	56	employ	employ	VB
18637	19550	57	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19550	58	and	and	CC
18637	19550	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	19550	60	incapable	incapable	JJ
18637	19550	61	adequately	adequately	RB
18637	19550	62	of	of	IN
18637	19550	63	making	make	VBG
18637	19550	64	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19550	65	own	own	JJ
18637	19550	66	defense	defense	NN
18637	19550	67	because	because	IN
18637	19550	68	of	of	IN
18637	19550	69	ignorance	ignorance	NN
18637	19550	70	,	,	,
18637	19550	71	illiteracy	illiteracy	NN
18637	19550	72	,	,	,
18637	19550	73	or	or	CC
18637	19550	74	the	the	DT
18637	19550	75	like	like	JJ
18637	19550	76	,	,	,
18637	19550	77	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19550	78	is	be	VBZ
18637	19550	79	the	the	DT
18637	19550	80	duty	duty	NN
18637	19550	81	of	of	IN
18637	19550	82	the	the	DT
18637	19550	83	court	court	NN
18637	19550	84	,	,	,
18637	19550	85	whether	whether	IN
18637	19550	86	requested	request	VBD
18637	19550	87	or	or	CC
18637	19550	88	not	not	RB
18637	19550	89	,	,	,
18637	19550	90	to	to	TO
18637	19550	91	assign	assign	VB
18637	19550	92	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19550	93	for	for	IN
18637	19550	94	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19550	95	as	as	IN
18637	19550	96	a	a	DT
18637	19550	97	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19550	98	requisite	requisite	NN
18637	19550	99	of	of	IN
18637	19550	100	due	due	JJ
18637	19550	101	process	process	NN
18637	19550	102	of	of	IN
18637	19550	103	Law	Law	NNP
18637	19550	104	.	.	.
18637	19551	1	The	the	DT
18637	19551	2	duty	duty	NN
18637	19551	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	19551	4	not	not	RB
18637	19551	5	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	19551	6	by	by	IN
18637	19551	7	an	an	DT
18637	19551	8	assignment	assignment	NN
18637	19551	9	at	at	IN
18637	19551	10	such	such	JJ
18637	19551	11	time	time	NN
18637	19551	12	or	or	CC
18637	19551	13	under	under	IN
18637	19551	14	such	such	JJ
18637	19551	15	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19551	16	as	as	IN
18637	19551	17	to	to	TO
18637	19551	18	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	19551	19	the	the	DT
18637	19551	20	giving	giving	NN
18637	19551	21	of	of	IN
18637	19551	22	effective	effective	JJ
18637	19551	23	aid	aid	NN
18637	19551	24	in	in	IN
18637	19551	25	preparation	preparation	NN
18637	19551	26	and	and	CC
18637	19551	27	trial	trial	NN
18637	19551	28	of	of	IN
18637	19551	29	the	the	DT
18637	19551	30	case	case	NN
18637	19551	31	.	.	.
18637	19552	1	Under	under	IN
18637	19552	2	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19552	3	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19552	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19552	5	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	19552	6	,	,	,
18637	19552	7	ignorance	ignorance	NN
18637	19552	8	and	and	CC
18637	19552	9	illiteracy	illiteracy	NN
18637	19552	10	of	of	IN
18637	19552	11	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	19552	12	,	,	,
18637	19552	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19552	14	youth	youth	NN
18637	19552	15	,	,	,
18637	19552	16	public	public	JJ
18637	19552	17	hostility	hostility	NN
18637	19552	18	,	,	,
18637	19552	19	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	19552	20	and	and	CC
18637	19552	21	close	close	JJ
18637	19552	22	surveillance	surveillance	NN
18637	19552	23	by	by	IN
18637	19552	24	military	military	JJ
18637	19552	25	forces	force	NNS
18637	19552	26	,	,	,
18637	19552	27	fact	fact	NN
18637	19552	28	that	that	IN
18637	19552	29	friends	friend	NNS
18637	19552	30	and	and	CC
18637	19552	31	families	family	NNS
18637	19552	32	are	be	VBP
18637	19552	33	in	in	IN
18637	19552	34	other	other	JJ
18637	19552	35	States	States	NNPS
18637	19552	36	,	,	,
18637	19552	37	and	and	CC
18637	19552	38	that	that	IN
18637	19552	39	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19552	40	stand	stand	VBP
18637	19552	41	in	in	IN
18637	19552	42	deadly	deadly	JJ
18637	19552	43	peril	peril	NN
18637	19552	44	of	of	IN
18637	19552	45	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19552	46	lives	life	NNS
18637	19552	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19552	48	,	,	,
18637	19552	49	the	the	DT
18637	19552	50	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19552	51	of	of	IN
18637	19552	52	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19552	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	19552	54	so	so	RB
18637	19552	55	vital	vital	JJ
18637	19552	56	and	and	CC
18637	19552	57	imperative	imperative	JJ
18637	19552	58	that	that	WDT
18637	19552	59	the	the	DT
18637	19552	60	failure	failure	NN
18637	19552	61	of	of	IN
18637	19552	62	a	a	DT
18637	19552	63	trial	trial	NN
18637	19552	64	court	court	NN
18637	19552	65	to	to	TO
18637	19552	66	make	make	VB
18637	19552	67	an	an	DT
18637	19552	68	effective	effective	JJ
18637	19552	69	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	19552	70	of	of	IN
18637	19552	71	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19552	72	is	be	VBZ
18637	19552	73	a	a	DT
18637	19552	74	denial	denial	NN
18637	19552	75	of	of	IN
18637	19552	76	due	due	JJ
18637	19552	77	process	process	NN
18637	19552	78	of	of	IN
18637	19552	79	law	law	NN
18637	19552	80	.	.	.
18637	19553	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19553	2	819	819	CD
18637	19553	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19553	4	By	by	IN
18637	19553	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19553	6	explicit	explicit	JJ
18637	19553	7	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	19553	8	in	in	IN
18637	19553	9	Powell	Powell	NNP
18637	19553	10	_	_	NNP
18637	19553	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	19553	12	_	_	NNP
18637	19553	13	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	19553	14	to	to	TO
18637	19553	15	consider	consider	VB
18637	19553	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	19553	17	denial	denial	NN
18637	19553	18	of	of	IN
18637	19553	19	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19553	20	in	in	IN
18637	19553	21	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19553	22	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	19553	23	for	for	IN
18637	19553	24	less	less	JJR
18637	19553	25	than	than	IN
18637	19553	26	capital	capital	NN
18637	19553	27	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	19553	28	or	or	CC
18637	19553	29	under	under	IN
18637	19553	30	other	other	JJ
18637	19553	31	circumstances[820	circumstances[820	NN
18637	19553	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19553	33	was	be	VBD
18637	19553	34	equally	equally	RB
18637	19553	35	violative	violative	JJ
18637	19553	36	of	of	IN
18637	19553	37	the	the	DT
18637	19553	38	due	due	JJ
18637	19553	39	process	process	NN
18637	19553	40	clause	clause	NN
18637	19553	41	,	,	,
18637	19553	42	the	the	DT
18637	19553	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19553	44	left	leave	VBD
18637	19553	45	undefined	undefined	JJ
18637	19553	46	the	the	DT
18637	19553	47	measure	measure	NN
18637	19553	48	of	of	IN
18637	19553	49	the	the	DT
18637	19553	50	protection	protection	NN
18637	19553	51	available	available	JJ
18637	19553	52	to	to	IN
18637	19553	53	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	19553	54	;	;	:
18637	19553	55	and	and	CC
18637	19553	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19553	57	first	first	JJ
18637	19553	58	two	two	CD
18637	19553	59	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	19553	60	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19553	61	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19553	62	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	19553	63	,	,	,
18637	19553	64	contributed	contribute	VBD
18637	19553	65	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	19553	66	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	19553	67	to	to	TO
18637	19553	68	correct	correct	VB
18637	19553	69	that	that	DT
18637	19553	70	deficiency	deficiency	NN
18637	19553	71	.	.	.
18637	19554	1	In	in	IN
18637	19554	2	Avery	Avery	NNP
18637	19554	3	_	_	NNP
18637	19554	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	19554	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19554	6	Alabama,[821	Alabama,[821	NNP
18637	19554	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19554	8	a	a	DT
18637	19554	9	State	State	NNP
18637	19554	10	trial	trial	NN
18637	19554	11	court	court	NN
18637	19554	12	was	be	VBD
18637	19554	13	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	19554	14	in	in	IN
18637	19554	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19554	16	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	19554	17	to	to	TO
18637	19554	18	continue	continue	VB
18637	19554	19	a	a	DT
18637	19554	20	murder	murder	NN
18637	19554	21	case	case	NN
18637	19554	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	19554	23	request	request	NN
18637	19554	24	of	of	IN
18637	19554	25	defense	defense	NN
18637	19554	26	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19554	27	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	19554	28	by	by	IN
18637	19554	29	said	say	VBD
18637	19554	30	court	court	NN
18637	19554	31	only	only	RB
18637	19554	32	three	three	CD
18637	19554	33	days	day	NNS
18637	19554	34	before	before	IN
18637	19554	35	the	the	DT
18637	19554	36	trial	trial	NN
18637	19554	37	,	,	,
18637	19554	38	who	who	WP
18637	19554	39	contended	contend	VBD
18637	19554	40	that	that	IN
18637	19554	41	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19554	42	had	have	VBD
18637	19554	43	not	not	RB
18637	19554	44	had	have	VBN
18637	19554	45	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19554	46	time	time	NN
18637	19554	47	to	to	TO
18637	19554	48	prepare	prepare	VB
18637	19554	49	a	a	DT
18637	19554	50	defense	defense	NN
18637	19554	51	,	,	,
18637	19554	52	and	and	CC
18637	19554	53	in	in	IN
18637	19554	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19554	55	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	19554	56	rejection	rejection	NN
18637	19554	57	of	of	IN
18637	19554	58	a	a	DT
18637	19554	59	motion	motion	NN
18637	19554	60	for	for	IN
18637	19554	61	a	a	DT
18637	19554	62	new	new	JJ
18637	19554	63	trial	trial	NN
18637	19554	64	which	which	WDT
18637	19554	65	was	be	VBD
18637	19554	66	grounded	ground	VBN
18637	19554	67	in	in	IN
18637	19554	68	part	part	NN
18637	19554	69	on	on	IN
18637	19554	70	the	the	DT
18637	19554	71	contention	contention	NN
18637	19554	72	that	that	IN
18637	19554	73	the	the	DT
18637	19554	74	denial	denial	NN
18637	19554	75	of	of	IN
18637	19554	76	the	the	DT
18637	19554	77	continuance	continuance	NN
18637	19554	78	was	be	VBD
18637	19554	79	a	a	DT
18637	19554	80	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19554	81	of	of	IN
18637	19554	82	the	the	DT
18637	19554	83	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	19554	84	's	's	POS
18637	19554	85	rights	right	NNS
18637	19554	86	under	under	IN
18637	19554	87	the	the	DT
18637	19554	88	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19554	89	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19554	90	.	.	.
18637	19555	1	Apart	apart	RB
18637	19555	2	from	from	IN
18637	19555	3	an	an	DT
18637	19555	4	admission	admission	NN
18637	19555	5	that	that	IN
18637	19555	6	"	"	``
18637	19555	7	where	where	WRB
18637	19555	8	denial	denial	NN
18637	19555	9	of	of	IN
18637	19555	10	the	the	DT
18637	19555	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19555	12	right	right	NN
18637	19555	13	to	to	IN
18637	19555	14	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	19555	15	of	of	IN
18637	19555	16	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19555	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	19555	18	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	19555	19	,	,	,
18637	19555	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19555	21	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
18637	19555	22	sacredness	sacredness	NN
18637	19555	23	demands	demand	VBZ
18637	19555	24	that	that	IN
18637	19555	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19555	26	scrupulously	scrupulously	RB
18637	19555	27	review	review	VBP
18637	19555	28	the	the	DT
18637	19555	29	record	record	NN
18637	19555	30	,	,	,
18637	19555	31	"	"	''
18637	19555	32	a	a	DT
18637	19555	33	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	19555	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19555	35	proffered	proffer	VBN
18637	19555	36	only	only	RB
18637	19555	37	the	the	DT
18637	19555	38	following	follow	VBG
18637	19555	39	vague	vague	JJ
18637	19555	40	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	19555	41	of	of	IN
18637	19555	42	the	the	DT
18637	19555	43	application	application	NN
18637	19555	44	of	of	IN
18637	19555	45	the	the	DT
18637	19555	46	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19555	47	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19555	48	:	:	:
18637	19555	49	"	"	``
18637	19555	50	In	in	IN
18637	19555	51	determining	determine	VBG
18637	19555	52	whether	whether	IN
18637	19555	53	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	19555	54	has	have	VBZ
18637	19555	55	been	be	VBN
18637	19555	56	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19555	57	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19555	58	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19555	59	right	right	NN
18637	19555	60	*	*	NFP
18637	19555	61	*	*	NFP
18637	19555	62	*	*	NFP
18637	19555	63	,	,	,
18637	19555	64	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19555	65	must	must	MD
18637	19555	66	remember	remember	VB
18637	19555	67	that	that	IN
18637	19555	68	the	the	DT
18637	19555	69	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19555	70	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19555	71	does	do	VBZ
18637	19555	72	not	not	RB
18637	19555	73	limit	limit	VB
18637	19555	74	the	the	DT
18637	19555	75	power	power	NN
18637	19555	76	of	of	IN
18637	19555	77	the	the	DT
18637	19555	78	States	States	NNPS
18637	19555	79	to	to	TO
18637	19555	80	try	try	VB
18637	19555	81	and	and	CC
18637	19555	82	deal	deal	VB
18637	19555	83	with	with	IN
18637	19555	84	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	19555	85	committed	commit	VBN
18637	19555	86	within	within	IN
18637	19555	87	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19555	88	borders	border	NNS
18637	19555	89	,	,	,
18637	19555	90	and	and	CC
18637	19555	91	was	be	VBD
18637	19555	92	not	not	RB
18637	19555	93	intended	intend	VBN
18637	19555	94	to	to	TO
18637	19555	95	bring	bring	VB
18637	19555	96	to	to	IN
18637	19555	97	the	the	DT
18637	19555	98	test	test	NN
18637	19555	99	of	of	IN
18637	19555	100	a	a	DT
18637	19555	101	decision	decision	NN
18637	19555	102	of	of	IN
18637	19555	103	this	this	DT
18637	19555	104	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19555	105	every	every	DT
18637	19555	106	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	19555	107	made	make	VBN
18637	19555	108	in	in	IN
18637	19555	109	the	the	DT
18637	19555	110	course	course	NN
18637	19555	111	of	of	IN
18637	19555	112	a	a	DT
18637	19555	113	State	State	NNP
18637	19555	114	trial	trial	NN
18637	19555	115	.	.	.
18637	19556	1	Consistently	consistently	RB
18637	19556	2	with	with	IN
18637	19556	3	the	the	DT
18637	19556	4	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	19556	5	of	of	IN
18637	19556	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19556	7	balance	balance	NN
18637	19556	8	between	between	IN
18637	19556	9	State	State	NNP
18637	19556	10	and	and	CC
18637	19556	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19556	12	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	19556	13	,	,	,
18637	19556	14	this	this	DT
18637	19556	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19556	16	must	must	MD
18637	19556	17	respect	respect	VB
18637	19556	18	and	and	CC
18637	19556	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	19556	20	reluctant	reluctant	JJ
18637	19556	21	to	to	TO
18637	19556	22	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	19556	23	with	with	IN
18637	19556	24	the	the	DT
18637	19556	25	States	state	NNS
18637	19556	26	'	'	POS
18637	19556	27	determination	determination	NN
18637	19556	28	of	of	IN
18637	19556	29	local	local	JJ
18637	19556	30	social	social	JJ
18637	19556	31	policy	policy	NN
18637	19556	32	.	.	.
18637	19557	1	"	"	``
18637	19557	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19557	3	822	822	CD
18637	19557	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19557	5	One	one	CD
18637	19557	6	year	year	NN
18637	19557	7	later	later	RB
18637	19557	8	,	,	,
18637	19557	9	the	the	DT
18637	19557	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19557	11	made	make	VBD
18637	19557	12	another	another	DT
18637	19557	13	inconclusive	inconclusive	JJ
18637	19557	14	observation	observation	NN
18637	19557	15	in	in	IN
18637	19557	16	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	19557	17	_	_	NNP
18637	19557	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	19557	19	_	_	NNP
18637	19557	20	O'Grady,[823	O'Grady,[823	NNP
18637	19557	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19557	22	in	in	IN
18637	19557	23	which	which	WDT
18637	19557	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19557	25	stated	state	VBD
18637	19557	26	that	that	IN
18637	19557	27	if	if	IN
18637	19557	28	true	true	JJ
18637	19557	29	,	,	,
18637	19557	30	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	19557	31	in	in	IN
18637	19557	32	a	a	DT
18637	19557	33	petition	petition	NN
18637	19557	34	for	for	IN
18637	19557	35	_	_	NNP
18637	19557	36	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	19557	37	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	19557	38	_	_	NNP
18637	19557	39	showing	show	VBG
18637	19557	40	that	that	IN
18637	19557	41	the	the	DT
18637	19557	42	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	19557	43	,	,	,
18637	19557	44	although	although	IN
18637	19557	45	an	an	DT
18637	19557	46	uneducated	uneducated	JJ
18637	19557	47	man	man	NN
18637	19557	48	and	and	CC
18637	19557	49	without	without	IN
18637	19557	50	prior	prior	JJ
18637	19557	51	experience	experience	NN
18637	19557	52	in	in	IN
18637	19557	53	court	court	NN
18637	19557	54	,	,	,
18637	19557	55	was	be	VBD
18637	19557	56	tricked	trick	VBN
18637	19557	57	into	into	IN
18637	19557	58	pleading	plead	VBG
18637	19557	59	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19557	60	to	to	IN
18637	19557	61	a	a	DT
18637	19557	62	serious	serious	JJ
18637	19557	63	crime	crime	NN
18637	19557	64	of	of	IN
18637	19557	65	burglary	burglary	NN
18637	19557	66	,	,	,
18637	19557	67	and	and	CC
18637	19557	68	was	be	VBD
18637	19557	69	tried	try	VBN
18637	19557	70	without	without	IN
18637	19557	71	the	the	DT
18637	19557	72	requested	request	VBN
18637	19557	73	aid	aid	NN
18637	19557	74	of	of	IN
18637	19557	75	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19557	76	would	would	MD
18637	19557	77	void	void	VB
18637	19557	78	the	the	DT
18637	19557	79	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19557	80	under	under	IN
18637	19557	81	which	which	WDT
18637	19557	82	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19557	83	was	be	VBD
18637	19557	84	imprisoned	imprison	VBN
18637	19557	85	.	.	.
18637	19558	1	Conceding	concede	VBG
18637	19558	2	that	that	IN
18637	19558	3	the	the	DT
18637	19558	4	above	above	RB
18637	19558	5	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	19558	6	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	19558	7	"	"	``
18637	19558	8	lend	lend	VBP
18637	19558	9	color	color	NN
18637	19558	10	to	to	IN
18637	19558	11	the	the	DT
18637	19558	12	argument	argument	NN
18637	19558	13	,	,	,
18637	19558	14	"	"	``
18637	19558	15	though	though	IN
18637	19558	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19558	17	did	do	VBD
18637	19558	18	not	not	RB
18637	19558	19	actually	actually	RB
18637	19558	20	so	so	RB
18637	19558	21	rule	rule	VB
18637	19558	22	,	,	,
18637	19558	23	that	that	IN
18637	19558	24	"	"	``
18637	19558	25	in	in	IN
18637	19558	26	every	every	DT
18637	19558	27	case	case	NN
18637	19558	28	,	,	,
18637	19558	29	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	19558	30	the	the	DT
18637	19558	31	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19558	32	,	,	,
18637	19558	33	one	one	CD
18637	19558	34	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19558	35	with	with	IN
18637	19558	36	crime	crime	NN
18637	19558	37	,	,	,
18637	19558	38	who	who	WP
18637	19558	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	19558	40	unable	unable	JJ
18637	19558	41	to	to	TO
18637	19558	42	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	19558	43	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19558	44	,	,	,
18637	19558	45	must	must	MD
18637	19558	46	be	be	VB
18637	19558	47	furnished	furnish	VBN
18637	19558	48	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19558	49	by	by	IN
18637	19558	50	the	the	DT
18637	19558	51	State	State	NNP
18637	19558	52	,	,	,
18637	19558	53	"	"	''
18637	19558	54	the	the	DT
18637	19558	55	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19558	56	,	,	,
18637	19558	57	in	in	IN
18637	19558	58	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	19558	59	_	_	NNP
18637	19558	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	19558	61	_	_	NNP
18637	19558	62	Brady,[824	Brady,[824	NNP
18637	19558	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19558	64	decided	decide	VBD
18637	19558	65	in	in	IN
18637	19558	66	1942	1942	CD
18637	19558	67	,	,	,
18637	19558	68	not	not	RB
18637	19558	69	only	only	RB
18637	19558	70	narrowed	narrow	VBD
18637	19558	71	the	the	DT
18637	19558	72	scope	scope	NN
18637	19558	73	of	of	IN
18637	19558	74	the	the	DT
18637	19558	75	right	right	NN
18637	19558	76	of	of	IN
18637	19558	77	the	the	DT
18637	19558	78	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19558	79	to	to	IN
18637	19558	80	the	the	DT
18637	19558	81	"	"	``
18637	19558	82	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	19558	83	of	of	IN
18637	19558	84	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19558	85	,	,	,
18637	19558	86	"	"	''
18637	19558	87	but	but	CC
18637	19558	88	also	also	RB
18637	19558	89	set	set	VBN
18637	19558	90	at	at	IN
18637	19558	91	rest	rest	NN
18637	19558	92	any	any	DT
18637	19558	93	question	question	NN
18637	19558	94	as	as	IN
18637	19558	95	to	to	IN
18637	19558	96	the	the	DT
18637	19558	97	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19558	98	source	source	NN
18637	19558	99	from	from	IN
18637	19558	100	which	which	WDT
18637	19558	101	the	the	DT
18637	19558	102	right	right	NN
18637	19558	103	was	be	VBD
18637	19558	104	derived	derive	VBN
18637	19558	105	.	.	.
18637	19559	1	Offering	offer	VBG
18637	19559	2	State	State	NNP
18637	19559	3	courts	court	NNS
18637	19559	4	the	the	DT
18637	19559	5	following	follow	VBG
18637	19559	6	vague	vague	JJ
18637	19559	7	guide	guide	NN
18637	19559	8	for	for	IN
18637	19559	9	determining	determine	VBG
18637	19559	10	when	when	WRB
18637	19559	11	provision	provision	NN
18637	19559	12	of	of	IN
18637	19559	13	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19559	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19559	15	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	19559	16	required	require	VBN
18637	19559	17	,	,	,
18637	19559	18	the	the	DT
18637	19559	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19559	20	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19559	21	that	that	IN
18637	19559	22	"	"	``
18637	19559	23	the	the	DT
18637	19559	24	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19559	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19559	26	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	19559	27	the	the	DT
18637	19559	28	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19559	29	and	and	CC
18637	19559	30	incarceration	incarceration	NN
18637	19559	31	of	of	IN
18637	19559	32	one	one	CD
18637	19559	33	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19559	34	trial	trial	NN
18637	19559	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	19559	36	offensive	offensive	JJ
18637	19559	37	to	to	IN
18637	19559	38	the	the	DT
18637	19559	39	common	common	JJ
18637	19559	40	and	and	CC
18637	19559	41	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19559	42	ideas	idea	NNS
18637	19559	43	of	of	IN
18637	19559	44	fairness	fairness	NN
18637	19559	45	and	and	CC
18637	19559	46	right	right	NN
18637	19559	47	,	,	,
18637	19559	48	and	and	CC
18637	19559	49	while	while	IN
18637	19559	50	want	want	NN
18637	19559	51	of	of	IN
18637	19559	52	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19559	53	in	in	IN
18637	19559	54	a	a	DT
18637	19559	55	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19559	56	case	case	NN
18637	19559	57	may	may	MD
18637	19559	58	result	result	VB
18637	19559	59	in	in	IN
18637	19559	60	a	a	DT
18637	19559	61	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19559	62	lacking	lack	VBG
18637	19559	63	in	in	IN
18637	19559	64	such	such	JJ
18637	19559	65	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19559	66	fairness	fairness	NN
18637	19559	67	,	,	,
18637	19559	68	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19559	69	can	can	MD
18637	19559	70	not	not	RB
18637	19559	71	say	say	VB
18637	19559	72	that	that	IN
18637	19559	73	the	the	DT
18637	19559	74	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	19559	75	embodies	embody	VBZ
18637	19559	76	an	an	DT
18637	19559	77	inexorable	inexorable	JJ
18637	19559	78	command	command	NN
18637	19559	79	that	that	IN
18637	19559	80	no	no	DT
18637	19559	81	trial	trial	NN
18637	19559	82	for	for	IN
18637	19559	83	any	any	DT
18637	19559	84	offense	offense	NN
18637	19559	85	,	,	,
18637	19559	86	or	or	CC
18637	19559	87	in	in	IN
18637	19559	88	any	any	DT
18637	19559	89	court	court	NN
18637	19559	90	,	,	,
18637	19559	91	can	can	MD
18637	19559	92	be	be	VB
18637	19559	93	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	19559	94	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	19559	95	and	and	CC
18637	19559	96	justice	justice	NN
18637	19559	97	accorded	accord	VBD
18637	19559	98	a	a	DT
18637	19559	99	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19559	100	who	who	WP
18637	19559	101	is	be	VBZ
18637	19559	102	not	not	RB
18637	19559	103	represented	represent	VBN
18637	19559	104	by	by	IN
18637	19559	105	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19559	106	*	*	NFP
18637	19559	107	*	*	NFP
18637	19559	108	*	*	NFP
18637	19559	109	Asserted	assert	VBN
18637	19559	110	denial	denial	NN
18637	19559	111	of	of	IN
18637	19559	112	due	due	JJ
18637	19559	113	process	process	NN
18637	19559	114	is	be	VBZ
18637	19559	115	to	to	TO
18637	19559	116	be	be	VB
18637	19559	117	tested	test	VBN
18637	19559	118	by	by	IN
18637	19559	119	an	an	DT
18637	19559	120	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	19559	121	of	of	IN
18637	19559	122	the	the	DT
18637	19559	123	totality	totality	NN
18637	19559	124	of	of	IN
18637	19559	125	facts	fact	NNS
18637	19559	126	in	in	IN
18637	19559	127	a	a	DT
18637	19559	128	given	give	VBN
18637	19559	129	case	case	NN
18637	19559	130	.	.	.
18637	19560	1	That	that	DT
18637	19560	2	which	which	WDT
18637	19560	3	may	may	MD
18637	19560	4	,	,	,
18637	19560	5	in	in	IN
18637	19560	6	one	one	CD
18637	19560	7	setting	setting	NN
18637	19560	8	,	,	,
18637	19560	9	constitute	constitute	VBP
18637	19560	10	a	a	DT
18637	19560	11	denial	denial	NN
18637	19560	12	of	of	IN
18637	19560	13	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19560	14	fairness	fairness	NN
18637	19560	15	,	,	,
18637	19560	16	shocking	shocking	JJ
18637	19560	17	to	to	IN
18637	19560	18	the	the	DT
18637	19560	19	universal	universal	JJ
18637	19560	20	sense	sense	NN
18637	19560	21	of	of	IN
18637	19560	22	justice	justice	NN
18637	19560	23	,	,	,
18637	19560	24	may	may	MD
18637	19560	25	,	,	,
18637	19560	26	in	in	IN
18637	19560	27	other	other	JJ
18637	19560	28	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19560	29	,	,	,
18637	19560	30	and	and	CC
18637	19560	31	in	in	IN
18637	19560	32	the	the	DT
18637	19560	33	light	light	NN
18637	19560	34	of	of	IN
18637	19560	35	other	other	JJ
18637	19560	36	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	19560	37	,	,	,
18637	19560	38	fall	fall	VB
18637	19560	39	short	short	RB
18637	19560	40	of	of	IN
18637	19560	41	such	such	JJ
18637	19560	42	denial	denial	NN
18637	19560	43	.	.	.
18637	19561	1	"	"	``
18637	19561	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19561	3	825	825	CD
18637	19561	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19561	5	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19561	6	,	,	,
18637	19561	7	an	an	DT
18637	19561	8	indigent	indigent	JJ
18637	19561	9	farm	farm	NN
18637	19561	10	laborer	laborer	NN
18637	19561	11	was	be	VBD
18637	19561	12	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19561	13	not	not	RB
18637	19561	14	to	to	TO
18637	19561	15	have	have	VB
18637	19561	16	been	be	VBN
18637	19561	17	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19561	18	due	due	JJ
18637	19561	19	process	process	NN
18637	19561	20	of	of	IN
18637	19561	21	law	law	NN
18637	19561	22	when	when	WRB
18637	19561	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19561	24	was	be	VBD
18637	19561	25	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	19561	26	of	of	IN
18637	19561	27	robbery	robbery	NN
18637	19561	28	by	by	IN
18637	19561	29	a	a	DT
18637	19561	30	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	19561	31	county	county	NN
18637	19561	32	court	court	NN
18637	19561	33	,	,	,
18637	19561	34	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	19561	35	without	without	IN
18637	19561	36	a	a	DT
18637	19561	37	jury	jury	NN
18637	19561	38	,	,	,
18637	19561	39	which	which	WDT
18637	19561	40	was	be	VBD
18637	19561	41	not	not	RB
18637	19561	42	required	require	VBN
18637	19561	43	by	by	IN
18637	19561	44	statute[826	statute[826	NN
18637	19561	45	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19561	46	to	to	TO
18637	19561	47	honor	honor	VB
18637	19561	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19561	49	request	request	NN
18637	19561	50	for	for	IN
18637	19561	51	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19561	52	and	and	CC
18637	19561	53	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19561	54	"	"	``
18637	19561	55	practice	practice	NN
18637	19561	56	,	,	,
18637	19561	57	"	"	''
18637	19561	58	in	in	IN
18637	19561	59	fact	fact	NN
18637	19561	60	was	be	VBD
18637	19561	61	to	to	TO
18637	19561	62	afford	afford	VB
18637	19561	63	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19561	64	only	only	RB
18637	19561	65	in	in	IN
18637	19561	66	murder	murder	NN
18637	19561	67	and	and	CC
18637	19561	68	rape	rape	NN
18637	19561	69	cases	case	NNS
18637	19561	70	.	.	.
18637	19562	1	Finally	finally	RB
18637	19562	2	,	,	,
18637	19562	3	the	the	DT
18637	19562	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19562	5	emphatically	emphatically	RB
18637	19562	6	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	19562	7	the	the	DT
18637	19562	8	notion	notion	NN
18637	19562	9	,	,	,
18637	19562	10	suggested	suggest	VBN
18637	19562	11	,	,	,
18637	19562	12	however	however	RB
18637	19562	13	faintly	faintly	RB
18637	19562	14	by	by	IN
18637	19562	15	the	the	DT
18637	19562	16	older	old	JJR
18637	19562	17	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19562	18	,	,	,
18637	19562	19	that	that	IN
18637	19562	20	the	the	DT
18637	19562	21	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19562	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19562	23	"	"	''
18637	19562	24	incorporates	incorporate	VBZ
18637	19562	25	the	the	DT
18637	19562	26	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19562	27	guarantees	guarantee	NNS
18637	19562	28	found	find	VBN
18637	19562	29	in	in	IN
18637	19562	30	the	the	DT
18637	19562	31	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	19562	32	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19562	33	,	,	,
18637	19562	34	although	although	IN
18637	19562	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19562	36	recognized	recognize	VBD
18637	19562	37	that	that	IN
18637	19562	38	a	a	DT
18637	19562	39	denial	denial	NN
18637	19562	40	of	of	IN
18637	19562	41	the	the	DT
18637	19562	42	rights	right	NNS
18637	19562	43	stipulated	stipulate	VBN
18637	19562	44	in	in	IN
18637	19562	45	the	the	DT
18637	19562	46	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19562	47	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19562	48	may	may	MD
18637	19562	49	in	in	IN
18637	19562	50	a	a	DT
18637	19562	51	given	give	VBN
18637	19562	52	case	case	NN
18637	19562	53	amount	amount	NN
18637	19562	54	to	to	IN
18637	19562	55	a	a	DT
18637	19562	56	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19562	57	of	of	IN
18637	19562	58	due	due	JJ
18637	19562	59	process	process	NN
18637	19562	60	.	.	.
18637	19563	1	"	"	``
18637	19563	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19563	3	827	827	CD
18637	19563	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19563	5	Having	have	VBG
18637	19563	6	thus	thus	RB
18637	19563	7	construed	construe	VBN
18637	19563	8	the	the	DT
18637	19563	9	due	due	JJ
18637	19563	10	process	process	NN
18637	19563	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	19563	12	of	of	IN
18637	19563	13	the	the	DT
18637	19563	14	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19563	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19563	16	as	as	IN
18637	19563	17	not	not	RB
18637	19563	18	inclusive	inclusive	JJ
18637	19563	19	of	of	IN
18637	19563	20	the	the	DT
18637	19563	21	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	19563	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19563	23	and	and	CC
18637	19563	24	as	as	IN
18637	19563	25	requiring	require	VBG
18637	19563	26	no	no	DT
18637	19563	27	more	more	JJR
18637	19563	28	than	than	IN
18637	19563	29	a	a	DT
18637	19563	30	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19563	31	trial	trial	NN
18637	19563	32	which	which	WDT
18637	19563	33	,	,	,
18637	19563	34	on	on	IN
18637	19563	35	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	19563	36	,	,	,
18637	19563	37	may	may	MD
18637	19563	38	necessitate	necessitate	VB
18637	19563	39	the	the	DT
18637	19563	40	protection	protection	NN
18637	19563	41	of	of	IN
18637	19563	42	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19563	43	,	,	,
18637	19563	44	the	the	DT
18637	19563	45	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19563	46	,	,	,
18637	19563	47	in	in	IN
18637	19563	48	succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	19563	49	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19563	50	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19563	51	during	during	IN
18637	19563	52	the	the	DT
18637	19563	53	interval	interval	NN
18637	19563	54	,	,	,
18637	19563	55	1942	1942	CD
18637	19563	56	-	-	SYM
18637	19563	57	1946	1946	CD
18637	19563	58	,	,	,
18637	19563	59	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	19563	60	to	to	TO
18637	19563	61	subject	subject	VB
18637	19563	62	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	19563	63	_	_	NNP
18637	19563	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	19563	65	_	_	NNP
18637	19563	66	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	19563	67	to	to	IN
18637	19563	68	the	the	DT
18637	19563	69	"	"	``
18637	19563	70	silent	silent	JJ
18637	19563	71	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	19563	72	.	.	.
18637	19563	73	"	"	''
18637	19564	1	In	in	IN
18637	19564	2	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	19564	3	_	_	NNP
18637	19564	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	19564	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19564	6	Kaiser[828	Kaiser[828	NNP
18637	19564	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19564	8	and	and	CC
18637	19564	9	Tomkins	Tomkins	NNP
18637	19564	10	_	_	NNP
18637	19564	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	19564	12	_	_	NNP
18637	19564	13	Missouri[829	Missouri[829	NNP
18637	19564	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19564	15	two	two	CD
18637	19564	16	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	19564	17	pleaded	plead	VBD
18637	19564	18	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19564	19	without	without	IN
18637	19564	20	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19564	21	to	to	IN
18637	19564	22	the	the	DT
18637	19564	23	commission	commission	NN
18637	19564	24	in	in	IN
18637	19564	25	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	19564	26	of	of	IN
18637	19564	27	capital	capital	NN
18637	19564	28	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	19564	29	,	,	,
18637	19564	30	one	one	CD
18637	19564	31	,	,	,
18637	19564	32	to	to	TO
18637	19564	33	robbery	robbery	VB
18637	19564	34	with	with	IN
18637	19564	35	a	a	DT
18637	19564	36	deadly	deadly	JJ
18637	19564	37	weapon	weapon	NN
18637	19564	38	,	,	,
18637	19564	39	and	and	CC
18637	19564	40	the	the	DT
18637	19564	41	second	second	JJ
18637	19564	42	,	,	,
18637	19564	43	to	to	TO
18637	19564	44	murder	murder	VB
18637	19564	45	.	.	.
18637	19565	1	Defendant	Defendant	NNP
18637	19565	2	,	,	,
18637	19565	3	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	19565	4	contended	contend	VBD
18637	19565	5	that	that	IN
18637	19565	6	,	,	,
18637	19565	7	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19565	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19565	9	request	request	NN
18637	19565	10	,	,	,
18637	19565	11	the	the	DT
18637	19565	12	trial	trial	NN
18637	19565	13	court	court	NN
18637	19565	14	did	do	VBD
18637	19565	15	not	not	RB
18637	19565	16	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	19565	17	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19565	18	,	,	,
18637	19565	19	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	19565	20	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19565	21	,	,	,
18637	19565	22	Tomkins	Tomkins	NNP
18637	19565	23	alleged	allege	VBD
18637	19565	24	that	that	IN
18637	19565	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19565	26	was	be	VBD
18637	19565	27	ignorant	ignorant	JJ
18637	19565	28	of	of	IN
18637	19565	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19565	30	right	right	NN
18637	19565	31	to	to	TO
18637	19565	32	demand	demand	VB
18637	19565	33	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19565	34	under	under	IN
18637	19565	35	the	the	DT
18637	19565	36	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	19565	37	statute	statute	NN
18637	19565	38	.	.	.
18637	19566	1	In	in	IN
18637	19566	2	ruling	rule	VBG
18637	19566	3	that	that	IN
18637	19566	4	the	the	DT
18637	19566	5	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	19566	6	'	'	POS
18637	19566	7	petitions	petition	NNS
18637	19566	8	for	for	IN
18637	19566	9	_	_	NNP
18637	19566	10	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	19566	11	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	19566	12	_	_	NNP
18637	19566	13	should	should	MD
18637	19566	14	not	not	RB
18637	19566	15	have	have	VB
18637	19566	16	been	be	VBN
18637	19566	17	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	19566	18	by	by	IN
18637	19566	19	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	19566	20	courts	court	NNS
18637	19566	21	without	without	IN
18637	19566	22	a	a	DT
18637	19566	23	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19566	24	,	,	,
18637	19566	25	the	the	DT
18637	19566	26	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19566	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19566	28	relied	rely	VBD
18637	19566	29	almost	almost	RB
18637	19566	30	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	19566	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	19566	32	the	the	DT
18637	19566	33	quotations	quotation	NNS
18637	19566	34	from	from	IN
18637	19566	35	Powell	Powell	NNP
18637	19566	36	_	_	NNP
18637	19566	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	19566	38	_	_	NNP
18637	19566	39	Alabama[830	Alabama[830	NNP
18637	19566	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19566	41	previously	previously	RB
18637	19566	42	set	set	VBN
18637	19566	43	forth	forth	RP
18637	19566	44	herein	herein	NNP
18637	19566	45	;	;	:
18637	19566	46	and	and	CC
18637	19566	47	reiterated	reiterate	VBD
18637	19566	48	that	that	IN
18637	19566	49	the	the	DT
18637	19566	50	right	right	NN
18637	19566	51	to	to	TO
18637	19566	52	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	19566	53	in	in	IN
18637	19566	54	felony	felony	NN
18637	19566	55	cases	case	NNS
18637	19566	56	being	be	VBG
18637	19566	57	protected	protect	VBN
18637	19566	58	by	by	IN
18637	19566	59	the	the	DT
18637	19566	60	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19566	61	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19566	62	,	,	,
18637	19566	63	the	the	DT
18637	19566	64	failure	failure	NN
18637	19566	65	of	of	IN
18637	19566	66	a	a	DT
18637	19566	67	State	State	NNP
18637	19566	68	court	court	NN
18637	19566	69	to	to	TO
18637	19566	70	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	19566	71	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19566	72	is	be	VBZ
18637	19566	73	a	a	DT
18637	19566	74	denial	denial	NN
18637	19566	75	of	of	IN
18637	19566	76	due	due	JJ
18637	19566	77	process	process	NN
18637	19566	78	.	.	.
18637	19567	1	"	"	``
18637	19567	2	A	a	DT
18637	19567	3	layman	layman	NN
18637	19567	4	,	,	,
18637	19567	5	"	"	''
18637	19567	6	the	the	DT
18637	19567	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19567	8	added	add	VBD
18637	19567	9	,	,	,
18637	19567	10	"	"	``
18637	19567	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	19567	12	usually	usually	RB
18637	19567	13	no	no	DT
18637	19567	14	match	match	NN
18637	19567	15	for	for	IN
18637	19567	16	the	the	DT
18637	19567	17	skilled	skilled	JJ
18637	19567	18	prosecutor	prosecutor	NN
18637	19567	19	whom	whom	WP
18637	19567	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19567	21	confronts	confront	VBZ
18637	19567	22	in	in	IN
18637	19567	23	the	the	DT
18637	19567	24	court	court	NN
18637	19567	25	room	room	NN
18637	19567	26	.	.	.
18637	19568	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19568	2	needs	need	VBZ
18637	19568	3	the	the	DT
18637	19568	4	aid	aid	NN
18637	19568	5	of	of	IN
18637	19568	6	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19568	7	lest	lest	IN
18637	19568	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19568	9	be	be	VB
18637	19568	10	the	the	DT
18637	19568	11	victim	victim	NN
18637	19568	12	of	of	IN
18637	19568	13	overzealous	overzealous	JJ
18637	19568	14	prosecutors	prosecutor	NNS
18637	19568	15	,	,	,
18637	19568	16	of	of	IN
18637	19568	17	the	the	DT
18637	19568	18	law	law	NN
18637	19568	19	's	's	POS
18637	19568	20	complexity	complexity	NN
18637	19568	21	,	,	,
18637	19568	22	or	or	CC
18637	19568	23	of	of	IN
18637	19568	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19568	25	own	own	JJ
18637	19568	26	ignorance	ignorance	NN
18637	19568	27	or	or	CC
18637	19568	28	bewilderment	bewilderment	NN
18637	19568	29	.	.	.
18637	19569	1	"	"	``
18637	19569	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19569	3	831	831	CD
18637	19569	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19569	5	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19569	6	was	be	VBD
18637	19569	7	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	19569	8	_	_	NNP
18637	19569	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	19569	10	_	_	NNP
18637	19569	11	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	19569	12	mentioned	mention	VBD
18637	19569	13	in	in	IN
18637	19569	14	the	the	DT
18637	19569	15	following	following	JJ
18637	19569	16	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	19569	17	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19569	18	.	.	.
18637	19570	1	In	in	IN
18637	19570	2	House	House	NNP
18637	19570	3	_	_	NNP
18637	19570	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	19570	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19570	6	Mayo,[832	Mayo,[832	NNP
18637	19570	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19570	8	the	the	DT
18637	19570	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19570	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19570	11	held	hold	VBD
18637	19570	12	that	that	IN
18637	19570	13	the	the	DT
18637	19570	14	action	action	NN
18637	19570	15	of	of	IN
18637	19570	16	a	a	DT
18637	19570	17	trial	trial	NN
18637	19570	18	court	court	NN
18637	19570	19	in	in	IN
18637	19570	20	compelling	compel	VBG
18637	19570	21	a	a	DT
18637	19570	22	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19570	23	to	to	TO
18637	19570	24	plead	plead	VB
18637	19570	25	to	to	IN
18637	19570	26	an	an	DT
18637	19570	27	information	information	NN
18637	19570	28	charging	charge	VBG
18637	19570	29	burglary	burglary	NN
18637	19570	30	without	without	IN
18637	19570	31	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19570	32	to	to	TO
18637	19570	33	consult	consult	VB
18637	19570	34	with	with	IN
18637	19570	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19570	36	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19570	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	19570	38	a	a	DT
18637	19570	39	denial	denial	NN
18637	19570	40	of	of	IN
18637	19570	41	the	the	DT
18637	19570	42	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19570	43	right	right	NN
18637	19570	44	to	to	IN
18637	19570	45	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	19570	46	;	;	:
18637	19570	47	and	and	CC
18637	19570	48	in	in	IN
18637	19570	49	Hawk	Hawk	NNP
18637	19570	50	_	_	NNP
18637	19570	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	19570	52	_	_	NNP
18637	19570	53	Olson[833	Olson[833	NNP
18637	19570	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19570	55	the	the	DT
18637	19570	56	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19570	57	repeated	repeat	VBD
18637	19570	58	this	this	DT
18637	19570	59	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	19570	60	,	,	,
18637	19570	61	in	in	IN
18637	19570	62	connection	connection	NN
18637	19570	63	with	with	IN
18637	19570	64	the	the	DT
18637	19570	65	denial	denial	NN
18637	19570	66	to	to	IN
18637	19570	67	a	a	DT
18637	19570	68	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19570	69	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19570	70	of	of	IN
18637	19570	71	a	a	DT
18637	19570	72	murder	murder	NN
18637	19570	73	of	of	IN
18637	19570	74	the	the	DT
18637	19570	75	same	same	JJ
18637	19570	76	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19570	77	during	during	IN
18637	19570	78	the	the	DT
18637	19570	79	critical	critical	JJ
18637	19570	80	period	period	NN
18637	19570	81	between	between	IN
18637	19570	82	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19570	83	arraignment	arraignment	NN
18637	19570	84	and	and	CC
18637	19570	85	the	the	DT
18637	19570	86	impaneling	impaneling	NN
18637	19570	87	of	of	IN
18637	19570	88	the	the	DT
18637	19570	89	jury	jury	NN
18637	19570	90	.	.	.
18637	19571	1	Both	both	CC
18637	19571	2	these	these	DT
18637	19571	3	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	19571	4	cited	cite	VBD
18637	19571	5	with	with	IN
18637	19571	6	approval	approval	NN
18637	19571	7	the	the	DT
18637	19571	8	two	two	CD
18637	19571	9	previously	previously	RB
18637	19571	10	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	19571	11	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	19571	12	and	and	CC
18637	19571	13	Tomkins	Tomkins	NNP
18637	19571	14	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	19571	15	;	;	:
18637	19571	16	and	and	CC
18637	19571	17	in	in	IN
18637	19571	18	House	House	NNP
18637	19571	19	_	_	NNP
18637	19571	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	19571	21	_	_	NNP
18637	19571	22	Mayo	Mayo	NNP
18637	19571	23	the	the	DT
18637	19571	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19571	25	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19571	26	without	without	IN
18637	19571	27	any	any	DT
18637	19571	28	explanation	explanation	NN
18637	19571	29	:	:	:
18637	19571	30	"	"	``
18637	19571	31	Compare	compare	VB
18637	19571	32	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	19571	33	_	_	NNP
18637	19571	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	19571	35	_	_	NNP
18637	19571	36	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	19571	37	with	with	IN
18637	19571	38	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	19571	39	_	_	NNP
18637	19571	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	19571	41	_	_	NNP
18637	19571	42	Kaiser	Kaiser	NNP
18637	19571	43	and	and	CC
18637	19571	44	Tomkins	Tomkins	NNP
18637	19571	45	_	_	NNP
18637	19571	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	19571	47	_	_	NNP
18637	19571	48	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	19571	49	.	.	.
18637	19572	1	"	"	``
18637	19572	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19572	3	834	834	CD
18637	19572	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19572	5	A	a	DT
18637	19572	6	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19572	7	performance	performance	NN
18637	19572	8	by	by	IN
18637	19572	9	the	the	DT
18637	19572	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19572	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	19572	12	also	also	RB
18637	19572	13	discernible	discernible	JJ
18637	19572	14	in	in	IN
18637	19572	15	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	19572	16	_	_	NNP
18637	19572	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	19572	18	_	_	NNP
18637	19572	19	Olson,[835	Olson,[835	NNP
18637	19572	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19572	21	in	in	IN
18637	19572	22	which	which	WDT
18637	19572	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19572	24	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	19572	25	that	that	IN
18637	19572	26	a	a	DT
18637	19572	27	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19572	28	,	,	,
18637	19572	29	who	who	WP
18637	19572	30	pleads	plead	VBZ
18637	19572	31	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19572	32	to	to	IN
18637	19572	33	a	a	DT
18637	19572	34	charge	charge	NN
18637	19572	35	of	of	IN
18637	19572	36	burglary	burglary	NN
18637	19572	37	,	,	,
18637	19572	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	19572	39	incapable	incapable	JJ
18637	19572	40	adequately	adequately	RB
18637	19572	41	of	of	IN
18637	19572	42	making	make	VBG
18637	19572	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19572	44	own	own	JJ
18637	19572	45	defense	defense	NN
18637	19572	46	,	,	,
18637	19572	47	and	and	CC
18637	19572	48	does	do	VBZ
18637	19572	49	not	not	RB
18637	19572	50	understandingly	understandingly	RB
18637	19572	51	waive	waive	JJ
18637	19572	52	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19572	53	;	;	:
18637	19572	54	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19572	55	is	be	VBZ
18637	19572	56	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19572	57	to	to	IN
18637	19572	58	the	the	DT
18637	19572	59	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19572	60	of	of	IN
18637	19572	61	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19572	62	aid	aid	NN
18637	19572	63	,	,	,
18637	19572	64	and	and	CC
18637	19572	65	a	a	DT
18637	19572	66	request	request	NN
18637	19572	67	therefor	therefor	RB
18637	19572	68	is	be	VBZ
18637	19572	69	not	not	RB
18637	19572	70	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19572	71	.	.	.
18637	19573	1	Also	also	RB
18637	19573	2	,	,	,
18637	19573	3	on	on	IN
18637	19573	4	the	the	DT
18637	19573	5	basis	basis	NN
18637	19573	6	of	of	IN
18637	19573	7	unchallenged	unchallenged	JJ
18637	19573	8	facts	fact	NNS
18637	19573	9	contradicting	contradict	VBG
18637	19573	10	a	a	DT
18637	19573	11	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	19573	12	's	's	POS
18637	19573	13	allegation	allegation	NN
18637	19573	14	that	that	IN
18637	19573	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19573	16	had	have	VBD
18637	19573	17	been	be	VBN
18637	19573	18	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19573	19	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19573	20	;	;	:
18637	19573	21	namely	namely	RB
18637	19573	22	,	,	,
18637	19573	23	that	that	IN
18637	19573	24	after	after	IN
18637	19573	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19573	26	arraignment	arraignment	NN
18637	19573	27	and	and	CC
18637	19573	28	plea	plea	NN
18637	19573	29	of	of	IN
18637	19573	30	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19573	31	to	to	IN
18637	19573	32	a	a	DT
18637	19573	33	charge	charge	NN
18637	19573	34	of	of	IN
18637	19573	35	robbery	robbery	NN
18637	19573	36	,	,	,
18637	19573	37	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19573	38	had	have	VBD
18637	19573	39	noted	note	VBN
18637	19573	40	an	an	DT
18637	19573	41	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	19573	42	for	for	IN
18637	19573	43	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19573	44	two	two	CD
18637	19573	45	days	day	NNS
18637	19573	46	before	before	IN
18637	19573	47	the	the	DT
18637	19573	48	date	date	NN
18637	19573	49	of	of	IN
18637	19573	50	sentencing	sentencing	NN
18637	19573	51	and	and	CC
18637	19573	52	had	have	VBD
18637	19573	53	actively	actively	RB
18637	19573	54	intervened	intervene	VBN
18637	19573	55	in	in	IN
18637	19573	56	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19573	57	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	19573	58	on	on	IN
18637	19573	59	the	the	DT
18637	19573	60	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19573	61	date	date	NN
18637	19573	62	,	,	,
18637	19573	63	a	a	DT
18637	19573	64	majority	majority	NN
18637	19573	65	of	of	IN
18637	19573	66	the	the	DT
18637	19573	67	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19573	68	,	,	,
18637	19573	69	in	in	IN
18637	19573	70	Canizio	Canizio	NNP
18637	19573	71	_	_	NNP
18637	19573	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	19573	73	_	_	NNP
18637	19573	74	New	New	NNP
18637	19573	75	York,[836	York,[836	NNP
18637	19573	76	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19573	77	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	19573	78	that	that	IN
18637	19573	79	the	the	DT
18637	19573	80	right	right	NN
18637	19573	81	to	to	TO
18637	19573	82	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	19573	83	had	have	VBD
18637	19573	84	not	not	RB
18637	19573	85	been	be	VBN
18637	19573	86	withheld	withhold	VBN
18637	19573	87	.	.	.
18637	19574	1	Without	without	IN
18637	19574	2	mentioning	mention	VBG
18637	19574	3	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	19574	4	_	_	NNP
18637	19574	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	19574	6	_	_	NNP
18637	19574	7	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	19574	8	by	by	IN
18637	19574	9	name	name	NN
18637	19574	10	,	,	,
18637	19574	11	the	the	DT
18637	19574	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19574	13	,	,	,
18637	19574	14	in	in	IN
18637	19574	15	1946	1946	CD
18637	19574	16	,	,	,
18637	19574	17	returned	return	VBD
18637	19574	18	to	to	IN
18637	19574	19	the	the	DT
18637	19574	20	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19574	21	trial	trial	NN
18637	19574	22	principle	principle	NN
18637	19574	23	enunciated	enunciate	VBD
18637	19574	24	therein	therein	RB
18637	19574	25	when	when	WRB
18637	19574	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19574	27	held	hold	VBD
18637	19574	28	that	that	IN
18637	19574	29	no	no	DT
18637	19574	30	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19574	31	of	of	IN
18637	19574	32	the	the	DT
18637	19574	33	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19574	34	right	right	NN
18637	19574	35	to	to	IN
18637	19574	36	the	the	DT
18637	19574	37	aid	aid	NN
18637	19574	38	of	of	IN
18637	19574	39	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19574	40	was	be	VBD
18637	19574	41	disclosed	disclose	VBN
18637	19574	42	by	by	IN
18637	19574	43	the	the	DT
18637	19574	44	record	record	NN
18637	19574	45	in	in	IN
18637	19574	46	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	19574	47	_	_	NNP
18637	19574	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	19574	49	_	_	NNP
18637	19574	50	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	19574	51	.	.	.
18637	19575	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19575	2	837	837	CD
18637	19575	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19575	4	That	that	DT
18637	19575	5	record	record	NN
18637	19575	6	included	include	VBD
18637	19575	7	only	only	RB
18637	19575	8	the	the	DT
18637	19575	9	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	19575	10	,	,	,
18637	19575	11	the	the	DT
18637	19575	12	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19575	13	on	on	IN
18637	19575	14	the	the	DT
18637	19575	15	plea	plea	NN
18637	19575	16	of	of	IN
18637	19575	17	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19575	18	to	to	IN
18637	19575	19	a	a	DT
18637	19575	20	charge	charge	NN
18637	19575	21	of	of	IN
18637	19575	22	murder	murder	NN
18637	19575	23	,	,	,
18637	19575	24	the	the	DT
18637	19575	25	minute	minute	NN
18637	19575	26	entry	entry	NN
18637	19575	27	bearing	bear	VBG
18637	19575	28	on	on	IN
18637	19575	29	the	the	DT
18637	19575	30	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19575	31	,	,	,
18637	19575	32	and	and	CC
18637	19575	33	the	the	DT
18637	19575	34	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19575	35	,	,	,
18637	19575	36	together	together	RB
18637	19575	37	with	with	IN
18637	19575	38	a	a	DT
18637	19575	39	lengthy	lengthy	JJ
18637	19575	40	recital	recital	NN
18637	19575	41	in	in	IN
18637	19575	42	the	the	DT
18637	19575	43	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19575	44	to	to	IN
18637	19575	45	the	the	DT
18637	19575	46	effect	effect	NN
18637	19575	47	that	that	IN
18637	19575	48	when	when	WRB
18637	19575	49	the	the	DT
18637	19575	50	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19575	51	expressed	express	VBD
18637	19575	52	a	a	DT
18637	19575	53	desire	desire	NN
18637	19575	54	to	to	TO
18637	19575	55	plead	plead	VB
18637	19575	56	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19575	57	the	the	DT
18637	19575	58	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19575	59	explained	explain	VBD
18637	19575	60	to	to	IN
18637	19575	61	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19575	62	the	the	DT
18637	19575	63	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	19575	64	of	of	IN
18637	19575	65	such	such	JJ
18637	19575	66	plea	plea	NN
18637	19575	67	,	,	,
18637	19575	68	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19575	69	rights	right	NNS
18637	19575	70	in	in	IN
18637	19575	71	the	the	DT
18637	19575	72	premises	premise	NNS
18637	19575	73	,	,	,
18637	19575	74	especially	especially	RB
18637	19575	75	,	,	,
18637	19575	76	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19575	77	rights	right	NNS
18637	19575	78	to	to	TO
18637	19575	79	have	have	VB
18637	19575	80	a	a	DT
18637	19575	81	lawyer	lawyer	NN
18637	19575	82	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	19575	83	to	to	TO
18637	19575	84	defend	defend	VB
18637	19575	85	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19575	86	and	and	CC
18637	19575	87	to	to	TO
18637	19575	88	be	be	VB
18637	19575	89	tried	try	VBN
18637	19575	90	before	before	IN
18637	19575	91	a	a	DT
18637	19575	92	jury	jury	NN
18637	19575	93	,	,	,
18637	19575	94	and	and	CC
18637	19575	95	the	the	DT
18637	19575	96	degree	degree	NN
18637	19575	97	of	of	IN
18637	19575	98	proof	proof	NN
18637	19575	99	required	require	VBN
18637	19575	100	for	for	IN
18637	19575	101	an	an	DT
18637	19575	102	acquittal	acquittal	NN
18637	19575	103	under	under	IN
18637	19575	104	a	a	DT
18637	19575	105	not	not	RB
18637	19575	106	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19575	107	plea	plea	NN
18637	19575	108	,	,	,
18637	19575	109	but	but	CC
18637	19575	110	that	that	IN
18637	19575	111	the	the	DT
18637	19575	112	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19575	113	persisted	persist	VBD
18637	19575	114	in	in	IN
18637	19575	115	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19575	116	plea	plea	NN
18637	19575	117	of	of	IN
18637	19575	118	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19575	119	.	.	.
18637	19576	1	Emphasizing	emphasize	VBG
18637	19576	2	that	that	IN
18637	19576	3	this	this	DT
18637	19576	4	record	record	NN
18637	19576	5	was	be	VBD
18637	19576	6	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	19576	7	wanting	want	VBG
18637	19576	8	in	in	IN
18637	19576	9	facts	fact	NNS
18637	19576	10	bearing	bear	VBG
18637	19576	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	19576	12	the	the	DT
18637	19576	13	maturity	maturity	NN
18637	19576	14	or	or	CC
18637	19576	15	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	19576	16	of	of	IN
18637	19576	17	comprehension	comprehension	NN
18637	19576	18	of	of	IN
18637	19576	19	the	the	DT
18637	19576	20	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	19576	21	,	,	,
18637	19576	22	or	or	CC
18637	19576	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	19576	24	the	the	DT
18637	19576	25	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19576	26	under	under	IN
18637	19576	27	which	which	WDT
18637	19576	28	the	the	DT
18637	19576	29	plea	plea	NN
18637	19576	30	of	of	IN
18637	19576	31	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19576	32	was	be	VBD
18637	19576	33	tendered	tender	VBN
18637	19576	34	and	and	CC
18637	19576	35	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	19576	36	,	,	,
18637	19576	37	the	the	DT
18637	19576	38	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19576	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19576	40	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	19576	41	that	that	IN
18637	19576	42	no	no	DT
18637	19576	43	inference	inference	NN
18637	19576	44	of	of	IN
18637	19576	45	lack	lack	NN
18637	19576	46	of	of	IN
18637	19576	47	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	19576	48	,	,	,
18637	19576	49	or	or	CC
18637	19576	50	ability	ability	NN
18637	19576	51	to	to	TO
18637	19576	52	make	make	VB
18637	19576	53	an	an	DT
18637	19576	54	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
18637	19576	55	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	19576	56	of	of	IN
18637	19576	57	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19576	58	,	,	,
18637	19576	59	could	could	MD
18637	19576	60	be	be	VB
18637	19576	61	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	19576	62	from	from	IN
18637	19576	63	the	the	DT
18637	19576	64	fact	fact	NN
18637	19576	65	that	that	IN
18637	19576	66	the	the	DT
18637	19576	67	trial	trial	NN
18637	19576	68	court	court	NN
18637	19576	69	did	do	VBD
18637	19576	70	assign	assign	JJ
18637	19576	71	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19576	72	when	when	WRB
18637	19576	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19576	74	came	come	VBD
18637	19576	75	to	to	IN
18637	19576	76	sentencing	sentencing	NN
18637	19576	77	.	.	.
18637	19577	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19577	2	838	838	CD
18637	19577	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19577	4	Applying	apply	VBG
18637	19577	5	the	the	DT
18637	19577	6	same	same	JJ
18637	19577	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	19577	8	,	,	,
18637	19577	9	and	and	CC
18637	19577	10	on	on	IN
18637	19577	11	this	this	DT
18637	19577	12	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	19577	13	at	at	IN
18637	19577	14	least	least	JJS
18637	19577	15	citing	cite	VBG
18637	19577	16	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	19577	17	_	_	NNP
18637	19577	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	19577	19	_	_	NNP
18637	19577	20	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	19577	21	,	,	,
18637	19577	22	the	the	DT
18637	19577	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19577	24	,	,	,
18637	19577	25	in	in	IN
18637	19577	26	De	De	NNP
18637	19577	27	Meerleer	Meerleer	NNP
18637	19577	28	_	_	NNP
18637	19577	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	19577	30	_	_	NNP
18637	19577	31	Michigan,[839	Michigan,[839	NNP
18637	19577	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19577	33	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	19577	34	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19577	35	that	that	IN
18637	19577	36	the	the	DT
18637	19577	37	arraignment	arraignment	NN
18637	19577	38	,	,	,
18637	19577	39	trial	trial	NN
18637	19577	40	,	,	,
18637	19577	41	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19577	42	of	of	IN
18637	19577	43	murder	murder	NN
18637	19577	44	,	,	,
18637	19577	45	and	and	CC
18637	19577	46	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19577	47	to	to	IN
18637	19577	48	life	life	NN
18637	19577	49	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	19577	50	,	,	,
18637	19577	51	all	all	RB
18637	19577	52	on	on	IN
18637	19577	53	the	the	DT
18637	19577	54	same	same	JJ
18637	19577	55	day	day	NN
18637	19577	56	,	,	,
18637	19577	57	of	of	IN
18637	19577	58	a	a	DT
18637	19577	59	seventeen	seventeen	CD
18637	19577	60	-	-	HYPH
18637	19577	61	year	year	NN
18637	19577	62	old	old	JJ
18637	19577	63	boy	boy	NN
18637	19577	64	who	who	WP
18637	19577	65	was	be	VBD
18637	19577	66	without	without	IN
18637	19577	67	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19577	68	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	19577	69	,	,	,
18637	19577	70	and	and	CC
18637	19577	71	was	be	VBD
18637	19577	72	never	never	RB
18637	19577	73	advised	advise	VBN
18637	19577	74	of	of	IN
18637	19577	75	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19577	76	right	right	NN
18637	19577	77	to	to	IN
18637	19577	78	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	19577	79	,	,	,
18637	19577	80	who	who	WP
18637	19577	81	received	receive	VBD
18637	19577	82	from	from	IN
18637	19577	83	the	the	DT
18637	19577	84	trial	trial	NN
18637	19577	85	court	court	NN
18637	19577	86	no	no	DT
18637	19577	87	explanation	explanation	NN
18637	19577	88	of	of	IN
18637	19577	89	the	the	DT
18637	19577	90	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	19577	91	of	of	IN
18637	19577	92	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19577	93	plea	plea	NN
18637	19577	94	of	of	IN
18637	19577	95	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19577	96	,	,	,
18637	19577	97	and	and	CC
18637	19577	98	who	who	WP
18637	19577	99	never	never	RB
18637	19577	100	subjected	subject	VBD
18637	19577	101	the	the	DT
18637	19577	102	State	State	NNP
18637	19577	103	's	's	POS
18637	19577	104	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	19577	105	to	to	IN
18637	19577	106	cross	cross	NN
18637	19577	107	-	-	NN
18637	19577	108	examination	examination	NN
18637	19577	109	,	,	,
18637	19577	110	effected	effect	VBD
18637	19577	111	a	a	DT
18637	19577	112	denial	denial	NN
18637	19577	113	of	of	IN
18637	19577	114	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19577	115	"	"	''
18637	19577	116	rights	right	NNS
18637	19577	117	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19577	118	to	to	IN
18637	19577	119	a	a	DT
18637	19577	120	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19577	121	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19577	122	.	.	.
18637	19577	123	"	"	''
18637	19578	1	Even	even	RB
18637	19578	2	more	more	RBR
18637	19578	3	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	19578	4	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19578	5	of	of	IN
18637	19578	6	the	the	DT
18637	19578	7	revival	revival	NN
18637	19578	8	of	of	IN
18637	19578	9	the	the	DT
18637	19578	10	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19578	11	trial	trial	NN
18637	19578	12	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	19578	13	of	of	IN
18637	19578	14	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	19578	15	_	_	NNP
18637	19578	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	19578	17	_	_	NNP
18637	19578	18	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	19578	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	19578	20	to	to	TO
18637	19578	21	be	be	VB
18637	19578	22	found	find	VBN
18637	19578	23	in	in	IN
18637	19578	24	the	the	DT
18637	19578	25	majority	majority	NN
18637	19578	26	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	19578	27	contained	contain	VBN
18637	19578	28	in	in	IN
18637	19578	29	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	19578	30	_	_	NNP
18637	19578	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	19578	32	_	_	NNP
18637	19578	33	Illinois[840	Illinois[840	NNP
18637	19578	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19578	35	and	and	CC
18637	19578	36	Gayes	Gayes	NNP
18637	19578	37	_	_	NNP
18637	19578	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	19578	39	_	_	NNP
18637	19578	40	New	New	NNP
18637	19578	41	York	York	NNP
18637	19578	42	.	.	.
18637	19579	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19579	2	841	841	CD
18637	19579	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19579	4	In	in	IN
18637	19579	5	the	the	DT
18637	19579	6	former	former	JJ
18637	19579	7	the	the	DT
18637	19579	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19579	9	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	19579	10	that	that	IN
18637	19579	11	where	where	WRB
18637	19579	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19579	13	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	19579	14	that	that	IN
18637	19579	15	the	the	DT
18637	19579	16	trial	trial	NN
18637	19579	17	court	court	NN
18637	19579	18	,	,	,
18637	19579	19	before	before	IN
18637	19579	20	accepting	accept	VBG
18637	19579	21	pleas	plea	NNS
18637	19579	22	of	of	IN
18637	19579	23	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19579	24	to	to	IN
18637	19579	25	charges	charge	NNS
18637	19579	26	of	of	IN
18637	19579	27	burglary	burglary	NN
18637	19579	28	and	and	CC
18637	19579	29	larceny	larceny	NN
18637	19579	30	by	by	IN
18637	19579	31	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	19579	32	,	,	,
18637	19579	33	aged	age	VBN
18637	19579	34	34	34	CD
18637	19579	35	and	and	CC
18637	19579	36	58	58	CD
18637	19579	37	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	19579	38	,	,	,
18637	19579	39	advised	advise	VBD
18637	19579	40	each	each	DT
18637	19579	41	of	of	IN
18637	19579	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19579	43	rights	right	NNS
18637	19579	44	of	of	IN
18637	19579	45	trial	trial	NN
18637	19579	46	and	and	CC
18637	19579	47	of	of	IN
18637	19579	48	the	the	DT
18637	19579	49	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	19579	50	of	of	IN
18637	19579	51	such	such	PDT
18637	19579	52	a	a	DT
18637	19579	53	plea	plea	NN
18637	19579	54	,	,	,
18637	19579	55	the	the	DT
18637	19579	56	fact	fact	NN
18637	19579	57	that	that	IN
18637	19579	58	the	the	DT
18637	19579	59	record	record	NN
18637	19579	60	reveals	reveal	VBZ
18637	19579	61	no	no	DT
18637	19579	62	express	express	JJ
18637	19579	63	offer	offer	NN
18637	19579	64	of	of	IN
18637	19579	65	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19579	66	would	would	MD
18637	19579	67	not	not	RB
18637	19579	68	suffice	suffice	VB
18637	19579	69	to	to	TO
18637	19579	70	show	show	VB
18637	19579	71	that	that	IN
18637	19579	72	the	the	DT
18637	19579	73	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19579	74	were	be	VBD
18637	19579	75	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	19579	76	of	of	IN
18637	19579	77	rights	right	NNS
18637	19579	78	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19579	79	to	to	IN
18637	19579	80	the	the	DT
18637	19579	81	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19579	82	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19579	83	required	require	VBN
18637	19579	84	by	by	IN
18637	19579	85	the	the	DT
18637	19579	86	due	due	JJ
18637	19579	87	process	process	NN
18637	19579	88	clause	clause	NN
18637	19579	89	.	.	.
18637	19580	1	Reiterating	reiterate	VBG
18637	19580	2	that	that	IN
18637	19580	3	the	the	DT
18637	19580	4	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	19580	5	right	right	NN
18637	19580	6	to	to	TO
18637	19580	7	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	19580	8	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	19580	9	by	by	IN
18637	19580	10	the	the	DT
18637	19580	11	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	19580	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19580	13	does	do	VBZ
18637	19580	14	not	not	RB
18637	19580	15	apply	apply	VB
18637	19580	16	in	in	IN
18637	19580	17	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	19580	18	in	in	IN
18637	19580	19	State	State	NNP
18637	19580	20	courts	court	NNS
18637	19580	21	,	,	,
18637	19580	22	five	five	CD
18637	19580	23	of	of	IN
18637	19580	24	the	the	DT
18637	19580	25	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19580	26	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19580	27	that	that	IN
18637	19580	28	all	all	PDT
18637	19580	29	the	the	DT
18637	19580	30	due	due	JJ
18637	19580	31	process	process	NN
18637	19580	32	clause	clause	NN
18637	19580	33	of	of	IN
18637	19580	34	the	the	DT
18637	19580	35	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19580	36	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19580	37	"	"	''
18637	19580	38	exacts	exact	VBZ
18637	19580	39	from	from	IN
18637	19580	40	the	the	DT
18637	19580	41	States	States	NNP
18637	19580	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	19580	43	a	a	DT
18637	19580	44	conception	conception	NN
18637	19580	45	of	of	IN
18637	19580	46	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19580	47	justice	justice	NN
18637	19580	48	"	"	''
18637	19580	49	which	which	WDT
18637	19580	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	19580	51	neither	neither	CC
18637	19580	52	"	"	``
18637	19580	53	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	19580	54	by	by	IN
18637	19580	55	merely	merely	RB
18637	19580	56	formal	formal	JJ
18637	19580	57	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	19580	58	correctness	correctness	NN
18637	19580	59	,	,	,
18637	19580	60	nor	nor	CC
18637	19580	61	*	*	NFP
18637	19580	62	*	*	NFP
18637	19580	63	*	*	NFP
18637	19580	64	confined	confine	VBN
18637	19580	65	by	by	IN
18637	19580	66	any	any	DT
18637	19580	67	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	19580	68	rule	rule	NN
18637	19580	69	such	such	JJ
18637	19580	70	as	as	IN
18637	19580	71	that	that	DT
18637	19580	72	which	which	WDT
18637	19580	73	the	the	DT
18637	19580	74	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	19580	75	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19580	76	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	19580	77	in	in	IN
18637	19580	78	securing	secure	VBG
18637	19580	79	to	to	IN
18637	19580	80	an	an	DT
18637	19580	81	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19580	82	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19580	83	in	in	IN
18637	19580	84	the	the	DT
18637	19580	85	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19580	86	courts	court	NNS
18637	19580	87	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19580	88	'	'	``
18637	19580	89	the	the	DT
18637	19580	90	Assistance	assistance	NN
18637	19580	91	of	of	IN
18637	19580	92	Counsel	Counsel	NNP
18637	19580	93	for	for	IN
18637	19580	94	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19580	95	defense	defense	NN
18637	19580	96	.	.	.
18637	19581	1	'	'	``
18637	19581	2	"	"	``
18637	19581	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19581	4	842	842	CD
18637	19581	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19581	6	On	on	IN
18637	19581	7	the	the	DT
18637	19581	8	same	same	JJ
18637	19581	9	day	day	NN
18637	19581	10	,	,	,
18637	19581	11	four	four	CD
18637	19581	12	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19581	13	,	,	,
18637	19581	14	with	with	IN
18637	19581	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19581	16	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	19581	17	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	19581	18	only	only	RB
18637	19581	19	in	in	IN
18637	19581	20	the	the	DT
18637	19581	21	result	result	NN
18637	19581	22	,	,	,
18637	19581	23	held	hold	VBN
18637	19581	24	in	in	IN
18637	19581	25	Gayes	Gayes	NNP
18637	19581	26	_	_	NNP
18637	19581	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	19581	28	_	_	NNP
18637	19581	29	New	New	NNP
18637	19581	30	York,[843	York,[843	NNP
18637	19581	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19581	32	that	that	IN
18637	19581	33	one	one	CD
18637	19581	34	sentenced	sentence	VBN
18637	19581	35	in	in	IN
18637	19581	36	1941	1941	CD
18637	19581	37	as	as	IN
18637	19581	38	a	a	DT
18637	19581	39	second	second	JJ
18637	19581	40	offender	offender	NN
18637	19581	41	under	under	IN
18637	19581	42	a	a	DT
18637	19581	43	charge	charge	NN
18637	19581	44	of	of	IN
18637	19581	45	burglary	burglary	NN
18637	19581	46	was	be	VBD
18637	19581	47	not	not	RB
18637	19581	48	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19581	49	to	to	IN
18637	19581	50	vacation	vacation	NN
18637	19581	51	of	of	IN
18637	19581	52	a	a	DT
18637	19581	53	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19581	54	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19581	55	against	against	IN
18637	19581	56	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19581	57	in	in	IN
18637	19581	58	1938	1938	CD
18637	19581	59	,	,	,
18637	19581	60	when	when	WRB
18637	19581	61	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19581	62	with	with	IN
18637	19581	63	the	the	DT
18637	19581	64	first	first	JJ
18637	19581	65	offense	offense	NN
18637	19581	66	,	,	,
18637	19581	67	on	on	IN
18637	19581	68	the	the	DT
18637	19581	69	ground	ground	NN
18637	19581	70	that	that	IN
18637	19581	71	when	when	WRB
18637	19581	72	answering	answer	VBG
18637	19581	73	in	in	IN
18637	19581	74	the	the	DT
18637	19581	75	negative	negative	JJ
18637	19581	76	the	the	DT
18637	19581	77	trial	trial	NN
18637	19581	78	court	court	NN
18637	19581	79	's	's	POS
18637	19581	80	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	19581	81	as	as	IN
18637	19581	82	to	to	IN
18637	19581	83	whether	whether	IN
18637	19581	84	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19581	85	desired	desire	VBD
18637	19581	86	the	the	DT
18637	19581	87	aid	aid	NN
18637	19581	88	of	of	IN
18637	19581	89	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19581	90	,	,	,
18637	19581	91	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19581	92	did	do	VBD
18637	19581	93	not	not	RB
18637	19581	94	understand	understand	VB
18637	19581	95	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19581	96	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19581	97	rights	right	NNS
18637	19581	98	.	.	.
18637	19582	1	On	on	IN
18637	19582	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19582	3	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	19582	4	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19582	5	in	in	IN
18637	19582	6	1941	1941	CD
18637	19582	7	,	,	,
18637	19582	8	which	which	WDT
18637	19582	9	took	take	VBD
18637	19582	10	into	into	IN
18637	19582	11	account	account	NN
18637	19582	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19582	13	earlier	early	JJR
18637	19582	14	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19582	15	of	of	IN
18637	19582	16	1938	1938	CD
18637	19582	17	,	,	,
18637	19582	18	the	the	DT
18637	19582	19	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19582	20	was	be	VBD
18637	19582	21	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19582	22	to	to	TO
18637	19582	23	have	have	VB
18637	19582	24	had	have	VBN
18637	19582	25	full	full	JJ
18637	19582	26	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19582	27	to	to	TO
18637	19582	28	contest	contest	VB
18637	19582	29	the	the	DT
18637	19582	30	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	19582	31	of	of	IN
18637	19582	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19582	33	earlier	early	JJR
18637	19582	34	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19582	35	.	.	.
18637	19583	1	Consistently	consistently	RB
18637	19583	2	with	with	IN
18637	19583	3	these	these	DT
18637	19583	4	two	two	CD
18637	19583	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	19583	6	,	,	,
18637	19583	7	the	the	DT
18637	19583	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19583	9	in	in	IN
18637	19583	10	Marino	Marino	NNP
18637	19583	11	_	_	NNP
18637	19583	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	19583	13	_	_	NNP
18637	19583	14	Ragen,[844	Ragen,[844	NNP
18637	19583	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19583	16	decided	decide	VBN
18637	19583	17	later	later	RB
18637	19583	18	in	in	IN
18637	19583	19	the	the	DT
18637	19583	20	same	same	JJ
18637	19583	21	year	year	NN
18637	19583	22	,	,	,
18637	19583	23	held	hold	VBD
18637	19583	24	that	that	IN
18637	19583	25	the	the	DT
18637	19583	26	absence	absence	NN
18637	19583	27	of	of	IN
18637	19583	28	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19583	29	,	,	,
18637	19583	30	in	in	IN
18637	19583	31	conjunction	conjunction	NN
18637	19583	32	with	with	IN
18637	19583	33	the	the	DT
18637	19583	34	following	follow	VBG
18637	19583	35	set	set	NN
18637	19583	36	of	of	IN
18637	19583	37	facts	fact	NNS
18637	19583	38	,	,	,
18637	19583	39	operated	operate	VBN
18637	19583	40	to	to	TO
18637	19583	41	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	19583	42	a	a	DT
18637	19583	43	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19583	44	of	of	IN
18637	19583	45	due	due	JJ
18637	19583	46	process	process	NN
18637	19583	47	.	.	.
18637	19584	1	In	in	IN
18637	19584	2	this	this	DT
18637	19584	3	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19584	4	decision	decision	NN
18637	19584	5	,	,	,
18637	19584	6	the	the	DT
18637	19584	7	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19584	8	,	,	,
18637	19584	9	an	an	DT
18637	19584	10	18-year	18-year	CD
18637	19584	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	19584	12	old	old	JJ
18637	19584	13	Italian	italian	JJ
18637	19584	14	immigrant	immigrant	NN
18637	19584	15	,	,	,
18637	19584	16	unable	unable	JJ
18637	19584	17	to	to	TO
18637	19584	18	understand	understand	VB
18637	19584	19	the	the	DT
18637	19584	20	English	english	JJ
18637	19584	21	language	language	NN
18637	19584	22	,	,	,
18637	19584	23	was	be	VBD
18637	19584	24	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	19584	25	of	of	IN
18637	19584	26	murder	murder	NN
18637	19584	27	and	and	CC
18637	19584	28	sentenced	sentence	VBN
18637	19584	29	to	to	IN
18637	19584	30	life	life	NN
18637	19584	31	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	19584	32	on	on	IN
18637	19584	33	a	a	DT
18637	19584	34	plea	plea	NN
18637	19584	35	of	of	IN
18637	19584	36	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19584	37	when	when	WRB
18637	19584	38	,	,	,
18637	19584	39	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19584	40	a	a	DT
18637	19584	41	recital	recital	NN
18637	19584	42	in	in	IN
18637	19584	43	the	the	DT
18637	19584	44	record	record	NN
18637	19584	45	that	that	IN
18637	19584	46	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19584	47	was	be	VBD
18637	19584	48	arraigned	arraign	VBN
18637	19584	49	in	in	IN
18637	19584	50	open	open	JJ
18637	19584	51	court	court	NN
18637	19584	52	and	and	CC
18637	19584	53	advised	advise	VBD
18637	19584	54	through	through	IN
18637	19584	55	interpreters	interpreter	NNS
18637	19584	56	,	,	,
18637	19584	57	one	one	CD
18637	19584	58	of	of	IN
18637	19584	59	whom	whom	WP
18637	19584	60	was	be	VBD
18637	19584	61	the	the	DT
18637	19584	62	arresting	arrest	VBG
18637	19584	63	officer	officer	NN
18637	19584	64	,	,	,
18637	19584	65	of	of	IN
18637	19584	66	the	the	DT
18637	19584	67	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	19584	68	and	and	CC
18637	19584	69	effect	effect	NN
18637	19584	70	of	of	IN
18637	19584	71	a	a	DT
18637	19584	72	"	"	``
18637	19584	73	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19584	74	"	"	''
18637	19584	75	plea	plea	NN
18637	19584	76	,	,	,
18637	19584	77	and	and	CC
18637	19584	78	that	that	IN
18637	19584	79	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19584	80	signed	sign	VBD
18637	19584	81	a	a	DT
18637	19584	82	statement	statement	NN
18637	19584	83	waiving	waive	VBG
18637	19584	84	a	a	DT
18637	19584	85	jury	jury	NN
18637	19584	86	trial	trial	NN
18637	19584	87	and	and	CC
18637	19584	88	pleading	plead	VBG
18637	19584	89	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19584	90	,	,	,
18637	19584	91	the	the	DT
18637	19584	92	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	19584	93	was	be	VBD
18637	19584	94	not	not	RB
18637	19584	95	in	in	IN
18637	19584	96	fact	fact	NN
18637	19584	97	signed	sign	VBN
18637	19584	98	by	by	IN
18637	19584	99	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19584	100	and	and	CC
18637	19584	101	no	no	DT
18637	19584	102	plea	plea	NN
18637	19584	103	of	of	IN
18637	19584	104	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19584	105	actually	actually	RB
18637	19584	106	had	have	VBD
18637	19584	107	been	be	VBN
18637	19584	108	entered	enter	VBN
18637	19584	109	.	.	.
18637	19585	1	In	in	IN
18637	19585	2	disposing	dispose	VBG
18637	19585	3	of	of	IN
18637	19585	4	more	more	JJR
18637	19585	5	recent	recent	JJ
18637	19585	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	19585	7	embracing	embrace	VBG
18637	19585	8	right	right	NN
18637	19585	9	to	to	IN
18637	19585	10	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	19585	11	as	as	IN
18637	19585	12	an	an	DT
18637	19585	13	issue	issue	NN
18637	19585	14	,	,	,
18637	19585	15	the	the	DT
18637	19585	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19585	17	,	,	,
18637	19585	18	either	either	CC
18637	19585	19	with	with	IN
18637	19585	20	or	or	CC
18637	19585	21	without	without	IN
18637	19585	22	citation	citation	NN
18637	19585	23	of	of	IN
18637	19585	24	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	19585	25	_	_	NNP
18637	19585	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	19585	27	_	_	NNP
18637	19585	28	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	19585	29	,	,	,
18637	19585	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	19585	31	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	19585	32	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19585	33	the	the	DT
18637	19585	34	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19585	35	trial	trial	NN
18637	19585	36	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	19585	37	.	.	.
18637	19586	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19586	2	,	,	,
18637	19586	3	the	the	DT
18637	19586	4	absence	absence	NN
18637	19586	5	of	of	IN
18637	19586	6	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19586	7	competent	competent	JJ
18637	19586	8	to	to	TO
18637	19586	9	advise	advise	VB
18637	19586	10	a	a	DT
18637	19586	11	15-year	15-year	CD
18637	19586	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	19586	13	old	old	JJ
18637	19586	14	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	19586	15	boy	boy	NN
18637	19586	16	of	of	IN
18637	19586	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19586	18	rights	right	NNS
18637	19586	19	was	be	VBD
18637	19586	20	one	one	CD
18637	19586	21	of	of	IN
18637	19586	22	several	several	JJ
18637	19586	23	factors	factor	NNS
18637	19586	24	operating	operate	VBG
18637	19586	25	in	in	IN
18637	19586	26	Haley	Haley	NNP
18637	19586	27	_	_	NNP
18637	19586	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	19586	29	_	_	NNP
18637	19586	30	Ohio[845	ohio[845	CD
18637	19586	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19586	32	to	to	TO
18637	19586	33	negative	negative	JJ
18637	19586	34	the	the	DT
18637	19586	35	propriety	propriety	NN
18637	19586	36	of	of	IN
18637	19586	37	admitting	admit	VBG
18637	19586	38	in	in	IN
18637	19586	39	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19586	40	a	a	DT
18637	19586	41	confession	confession	NN
18637	19586	42	to	to	IN
18637	19586	43	murder	murder	NN
18637	19586	44	and	and	CC
18637	19586	45	contributing	contribute	VBG
18637	19586	46	to	to	IN
18637	19586	47	the	the	DT
18637	19586	48	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	19586	49	that	that	IN
18637	19586	50	the	the	DT
18637	19586	51	boy	boy	NN
18637	19586	52	's	's	POS
18637	19586	53	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19586	54	had	have	VBD
18637	19586	55	resulted	result	VBN
18637	19586	56	from	from	IN
18637	19586	57	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19586	58	that	that	WDT
18637	19586	59	were	be	VBD
18637	19586	60	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	19586	61	.	.	.
18637	19587	1	Dividing	divide	VBG
18637	19587	2	again	again	RB
18637	19587	3	on	on	IN
18637	19587	4	the	the	DT
18637	19587	5	same	same	JJ
18637	19587	6	issues	issue	NNS
18637	19587	7	in	in	IN
18637	19587	8	which	which	WDT
18637	19587	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19587	10	were	be	VBD
18637	19587	11	in	in	IN
18637	19587	12	disagreement	disagreement	NN
18637	19587	13	in	in	IN
18637	19587	14	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	19587	15	_	_	NNP
18637	19587	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	19587	17	_	_	NNP
18637	19587	18	Illinois;[846	illinois;[846	NN
18637	19587	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19587	20	namely	namely	RB
18637	19587	21	,	,	,
18637	19587	22	the	the	DT
18637	19587	23	applicability	applicability	NN
18637	19587	24	of	of	IN
18637	19587	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19587	26	Six	six	CD
18637	19587	27	to	to	IN
18637	19587	28	State	state	NN
18637	19587	29	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19587	30	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	19587	31	and	and	CC
18637	19587	32	the	the	DT
18637	19587	33	merits	merit	NNS
18637	19587	34	of	of	IN
18637	19587	35	the	the	DT
18637	19587	36	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19587	37	trial	trial	NN
18637	19587	38	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	19587	39	as	as	IN
18637	19587	40	expounded	expound	VBN
18637	19587	41	in	in	IN
18637	19587	42	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	19587	43	_	_	NNP
18637	19587	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	19587	45	_	_	NNP
18637	19587	46	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	19587	47	,	,	,
18637	19587	48	five	five	CD
18637	19587	49	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	19587	50	in	in	IN
18637	19587	51	Bute	Bute	NNP
18637	19587	52	_	_	NNP
18637	19587	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	19587	54	_	_	NNP
18637	19587	55	Illinois[847	Illinois[847	NNP
18637	19587	56	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19587	57	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	19587	58	that	that	IN
18637	19587	59	the	the	DT
18637	19587	60	due	due	JJ
18637	19587	61	process	process	NN
18637	19587	62	clause	clause	NN
18637	19587	63	of	of	IN
18637	19587	64	the	the	DT
18637	19587	65	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19587	66	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19587	67	does	do	VBZ
18637	19587	68	not	not	RB
18637	19587	69	require	require	VB
18637	19587	70	a	a	DT
18637	19587	71	State	State	NNP
18637	19587	72	court	court	NN
18637	19587	73	to	to	TO
18637	19587	74	tender	tender	VB
18637	19587	75	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	19587	76	of	of	IN
18637	19587	77	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19587	78	,	,	,
18637	19587	79	before	before	IN
18637	19587	80	accepting	accept	VBG
18637	19587	81	a	a	DT
18637	19587	82	plea	plea	NN
18637	19587	83	of	of	IN
18637	19587	84	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19587	85	to	to	IN
18637	19587	86	a	a	DT
18637	19587	87	charge	charge	NN
18637	19587	88	of	of	IN
18637	19587	89	indecent	indecent	JJ
18637	19587	90	liberties	liberty	NNS
18637	19587	91	with	with	IN
18637	19587	92	female	female	JJ
18637	19587	93	children	child	NNS
18637	19587	94	,	,	,
18637	19587	95	the	the	DT
18637	19587	96	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	19587	97	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	19587	98	for	for	IN
18637	19587	99	which	which	WDT
18637	19587	100	is	be	VBZ
18637	19587	101	20	20	CD
18637	19587	102	years	year	NNS
18637	19587	103	,	,	,
18637	19587	104	from	from	IN
18637	19587	105	a	a	DT
18637	19587	106	57-year	57-year	CD
18637	19587	107	-	-	HYPH
18637	19587	108	old	old	JJ
18637	19587	109	man	man	NN
18637	19587	110	who	who	WP
18637	19587	111	was	be	VBD
18637	19587	112	not	not	RB
18637	19587	113	a	a	DT
18637	19587	114	lawyer	lawyer	NN
18637	19587	115	and	and	CC
18637	19587	116	who	who	WP
18637	19587	117	received	receive	VBD
18637	19587	118	from	from	IN
18637	19587	119	the	the	DT
18637	19587	120	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19587	121	an	an	DT
18637	19587	122	explanation	explanation	NN
18637	19587	123	of	of	IN
18637	19587	124	the	the	DT
18637	19587	125	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	19587	126	and	and	CC
18637	19587	127	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	19587	128	resulting	result	VBG
18637	19587	129	from	from	IN
18637	19587	130	such	such	JJ
18637	19587	131	plea	plea	NN
18637	19587	132	.	.	.
18637	19588	1	Unanimity	Unanimity	NNP
18637	19588	2	was	be	VBD
18637	19588	3	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	19588	4	regained	regain	VBN
18637	19588	5	in	in	IN
18637	19588	6	Wade	Wade	NNP
18637	19588	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19588	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	19588	9	_	_	NNP
18637	19588	10	Mayo[848	Mayo[848	NNP
18637	19588	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19588	12	in	in	IN
18637	19588	13	which	which	WDT
18637	19588	14	the	the	DT
18637	19588	15	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19588	16	had	have	VBD
18637	19588	17	before	before	IN
18637	19588	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19588	19	the	the	DT
18637	19588	20	plight	plight	NN
18637	19588	21	of	of	IN
18637	19588	22	an	an	DT
18637	19588	23	18-year	18-year	CD
18637	19588	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	19588	25	old	old	JJ
18637	19588	26	boy	boy	NN
18637	19588	27	,	,	,
18637	19588	28	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	19588	29	on	on	IN
18637	19588	30	the	the	DT
18637	19588	31	charge	charge	NN
18637	19588	32	of	of	IN
18637	19588	33	breaking	break	VBG
18637	19588	34	and	and	CC
18637	19588	35	entering	enter	VBG
18637	19588	36	,	,	,
18637	19588	37	who	who	WP
18637	19588	38	was	be	VBD
18637	19588	39	described	describe	VBN
18637	19588	40	by	by	IN
18637	19588	41	a	a	DT
18637	19588	42	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19588	43	district	district	NN
18637	19588	44	court	court	NN
18637	19588	45	as	as	IN
18637	19588	46	not	not	RB
18637	19588	47	a	a	DT
18637	19588	48	stranger	stranger	NN
18637	19588	49	in	in	IN
18637	19588	50	court	court	NN
18637	19588	51	,	,	,
18637	19588	52	having	have	VBG
18637	19588	53	been	be	VBN
18637	19588	54	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	19588	55	of	of	IN
18637	19588	56	prior	prior	JJ
18637	19588	57	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	19588	58	,	,	,
18637	19588	59	but	but	CC
18637	19588	60	as	as	IN
18637	19588	61	still	still	RB
18637	19588	62	unfamiliar	unfamiliar	JJ
18637	19588	63	with	with	IN
18637	19588	64	court	court	NN
18637	19588	65	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19588	66	and	and	CC
18637	19588	67	not	not	RB
18637	19588	68	capable	capable	JJ
18637	19588	69	of	of	IN
18637	19588	70	representing	represent	VBG
18637	19588	71	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19588	72	adequately	adequately	RB
18637	19588	73	.	.	.
18637	19589	1	On	on	IN
18637	19589	2	the	the	DT
18637	19589	3	strength	strength	NN
18637	19589	4	of	of	IN
18637	19589	5	these	these	DT
18637	19589	6	and	and	CC
18637	19589	7	other	other	JJ
18637	19589	8	findings	finding	NNS
18637	19589	9	,	,	,
18637	19589	10	the	the	DT
18637	19589	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19589	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19589	13	held	hold	VBD
18637	19589	14	that	that	IN
18637	19589	15	where	where	WRB
18637	19589	16	one	one	NN
18637	19589	17	charged	charge	VBD
18637	19589	18	with	with	IN
18637	19589	19	crime	crime	NN
18637	19589	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	19589	21	by	by	IN
18637	19589	22	reason	reason	NN
18637	19589	23	of	of	IN
18637	19589	24	age	age	NN
18637	19589	25	,	,	,
18637	19589	26	ignorance	ignorance	NN
18637	19589	27	,	,	,
18637	19589	28	or	or	CC
18637	19589	29	mental	mental	JJ
18637	19589	30	incapacity	incapacity	NN
18637	19589	31	incapable	incapable	JJ
18637	19589	32	of	of	IN
18637	19589	33	defending	defend	VBG
18637	19589	34	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19589	35	,	,	,
18637	19589	36	even	even	RB
18637	19589	37	in	in	IN
18637	19589	38	a	a	DT
18637	19589	39	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	19589	40	of	of	IN
18637	19589	41	a	a	DT
18637	19589	42	relatively	relatively	RB
18637	19589	43	simple	simple	JJ
18637	19589	44	nature	nature	NN
18637	19589	45	,	,	,
18637	19589	46	the	the	DT
18637	19589	47	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	19589	48	of	of	IN
18637	19589	49	a	a	DT
18637	19589	50	State	State	NNP
18637	19589	51	trial	trial	NN
18637	19589	52	court	court	NN
18637	19589	53	to	to	TO
18637	19589	54	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	19589	55	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19589	56	at	at	IN
18637	19589	57	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19589	58	request	request	NN
18637	19589	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	19589	60	a	a	DT
18637	19589	61	denial	denial	NN
18637	19589	62	of	of	IN
18637	19589	63	due	due	JJ
18637	19589	64	process	process	NN
18637	19589	65	,	,	,
18637	19589	66	even	even	RB
18637	19589	67	though	though	IN
18637	19589	68	the	the	DT
18637	19589	69	law	law	NN
18637	19589	70	of	of	IN
18637	19589	71	the	the	DT
18637	19589	72	State	State	NNP
18637	19589	73	does	do	VBZ
18637	19589	74	not	not	RB
18637	19589	75	require	require	VB
18637	19589	76	such	such	JJ
18637	19589	77	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	19589	78	.	.	.
18637	19590	1	Dissents	dissent	NNS
18637	19590	2	were	be	VBD
18637	19590	3	again	again	RB
18637	19590	4	registered	register	VBN
18637	19590	5	in	in	IN
18637	19590	6	the	the	DT
18637	19590	7	following	follow	VBG
18637	19590	8	brace	brace	NN
18637	19590	9	of	of	IN
18637	19590	10	decision	decision	NN
18637	19590	11	which	which	WDT
18637	19590	12	a	a	DT
18637	19590	13	minority	minority	NN
18637	19590	14	of	of	IN
18637	19590	15	the	the	DT
18637	19590	16	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19590	17	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19590	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19590	19	inability	inability	NN
18637	19590	20	to	to	TO
18637	19590	21	reconcile	reconcile	VB
18637	19590	22	.	.	.
18637	19591	1	In	in	IN
18637	19591	2	the	the	DT
18637	19591	3	first	first	JJ
18637	19591	4	,	,	,
18637	19591	5	Gryger	Gryger	NNP
18637	19591	6	_	_	NNP
18637	19591	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	19591	8	_	_	NNP
18637	19591	9	Burke,[849	Burke,[849	NNP
18637	19591	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19591	11	the	the	DT
18637	19591	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19591	13	held	hold	VBD
18637	19591	14	that	that	IN
18637	19591	15	when	when	WRB
18637	19591	16	one	one	CD
18637	19591	17	,	,	,
18637	19591	18	sentenced	sentence	VBN
18637	19591	19	to	to	IN
18637	19591	20	life	life	NN
18637	19591	21	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	19591	22	as	as	IN
18637	19591	23	a	a	DT
18637	19591	24	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	19591	25	offender	offender	NN
18637	19591	26	under	under	IN
18637	19591	27	a	a	DT
18637	19591	28	State	State	NNP
18637	19591	29	habitual	habitual	JJ
18637	19591	30	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19591	31	act	act	NN
18637	19591	32	,	,	,
18637	19591	33	had	have	VBD
18637	19591	34	been	be	VBN
18637	19591	35	arrested	arrest	VBN
18637	19591	36	eight	eight	CD
18637	19591	37	times	time	NNS
18637	19591	38	for	for	IN
18637	19591	39	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	19591	40	of	of	IN
18637	19591	41	violence	violence	NN
18637	19591	42	,	,	,
18637	19591	43	followed	follow	VBN
18637	19591	44	by	by	IN
18637	19591	45	pleas	plea	NNS
18637	19591	46	of	of	IN
18637	19591	47	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19591	48	or	or	CC
18637	19591	49	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19591	50	,	,	,
18637	19591	51	and	and	CC
18637	19591	52	in	in	IN
18637	19591	53	two	two	CD
18637	19591	54	of	of	IN
18637	19591	55	such	such	JJ
18637	19591	56	former	former	JJ
18637	19591	57	trials	trial	NNS
18637	19591	58	had	have	VBD
18637	19591	59	been	be	VBN
18637	19591	60	represented	represent	VBN
18637	19591	61	by	by	IN
18637	19591	62	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19591	63	,	,	,
18637	19591	64	the	the	DT
18637	19591	65	State	State	NNP
18637	19591	66	's	's	POS
18637	19591	67	failure	failure	NN
18637	19591	68	to	to	TO
18637	19591	69	offer	offer	VB
18637	19591	70	or	or	CC
18637	19591	71	to	to	TO
18637	19591	72	provide	provide	VB
18637	19591	73	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19591	74	for	for	IN
18637	19591	75	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19591	76	on	on	IN
18637	19591	77	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19591	78	plea	plea	NN
18637	19591	79	to	to	IN
18637	19591	80	a	a	DT
18637	19591	81	charge	charge	NN
18637	19591	82	of	of	IN
18637	19591	83	being	be	VBG
18637	19591	84	a	a	DT
18637	19591	85	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	19591	86	offender	offender	NN
18637	19591	87	does	do	VBZ
18637	19591	88	not	not	RB
18637	19591	89	render	render	VB
18637	19591	90	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19591	91	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19591	92	and	and	CC
18637	19591	93	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19591	94	as	as	IN
18637	19591	95	such	such	JJ
18637	19591	96	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	19591	97	,	,	,
18637	19591	98	even	even	RB
18637	19591	99	though	though	IN
18637	19591	100	the	the	DT
18637	19591	101	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19591	102	may	may	MD
18637	19591	103	have	have	VB
18637	19591	104	misconstrued	misconstrue	VBN
18637	19591	105	the	the	DT
18637	19591	106	statute	statute	NN
18637	19591	107	as	as	IN
18637	19591	108	making	make	VBG
18637	19591	109	a	a	DT
18637	19591	110	life	life	NN
18637	19591	111	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19591	112	mandatory	mandatory	JJ
18637	19591	113	rather	rather	RB
18637	19591	114	than	than	IN
18637	19591	115	discretionary	discretionary	JJ
18637	19591	116	.	.	.
18637	19592	1	Emphasizing	emphasize	VBG
18637	19592	2	that	that	IN
18637	19592	3	there	there	EX
18637	19592	4	were	be	VBD
18637	19592	5	"	"	``
18637	19592	6	no	no	DT
18637	19592	7	exceptional	exceptional	JJ
18637	19592	8	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19592	9	*	*	NFP
18637	19592	10	*	*	NFP
18637	19592	11	*	*	NFP
18637	19592	12	present	present	NN
18637	19592	13	,	,	,
18637	19592	14	"	"	''
18637	19592	15	the	the	DT
18637	19592	16	majority	majority	NN
18637	19592	17	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	19592	18	that	that	IN
18637	19592	19	"	"	``
18637	19592	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19592	21	rather	rather	RB
18637	19592	22	overstrains	overstrain	VBZ
18637	19592	23	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19592	24	credulity	credulity	NN
18637	19592	25	to	to	TO
18637	19592	26	believe	believe	VB
18637	19592	27	that	that	IN
18637	19592	28	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19592	29	such	such	PDT
18637	19592	30	a	a	DT
18637	19592	31	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19592	32	would	would	MD
18637	19592	33	be	be	VB
18637	19592	34	ignorant	ignorant	JJ
18637	19592	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19592	36	of	of	IN
18637	19592	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19592	38	right	right	JJ
18637	19592	39	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19592	40	to	to	TO
18637	19592	41	request	request	VB
18637	19592	42	and	and	CC
18637	19592	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19592	44	to	to	TO
18637	19592	45	engage	engage	VB
18637	19592	46	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19592	47	.	.	.
18637	19592	48	"	"	''
18637	19593	1	In	in	IN
18637	19593	2	the	the	DT
18637	19593	3	second	second	JJ
18637	19593	4	,	,	,
18637	19593	5	Townsend	Townsend	NNP
18637	19593	6	_	_	NNP
18637	19593	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	19593	8	_	_	NNP
18637	19593	9	Burke,[850	Burke,[850	NNP
18637	19593	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19593	11	the	the	DT
18637	19593	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19593	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19593	14	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19593	15	that	that	IN
18637	19593	16	although	although	IN
18637	19593	17	failure	failure	NN
18637	19593	18	of	of	IN
18637	19593	19	a	a	DT
18637	19593	20	State	State	NNP
18637	19593	21	court	court	NN
18637	19593	22	to	to	TO
18637	19593	23	offer	offer	VB
18637	19593	24	or	or	CC
18637	19593	25	to	to	TO
18637	19593	26	assign	assign	VB
18637	19593	27	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19593	28	to	to	IN
18637	19593	29	one	one	CD
18637	19593	30	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19593	31	with	with	IN
18637	19593	32	the	the	DT
18637	19593	33	noncapital	noncapital	JJ
18637	19593	34	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	19593	35	of	of	IN
18637	19593	36	burglary	burglary	NN
18637	19593	37	and	and	CC
18637	19593	38	robbery	robbery	NN
18637	19593	39	,	,	,
18637	19593	40	or	or	CC
18637	19593	41	to	to	TO
18637	19593	42	advise	advise	VB
18637	19593	43	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19593	44	of	of	IN
18637	19593	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19593	46	right	right	NN
18637	19593	47	to	to	TO
18637	19593	48	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	19593	49	before	before	IN
18637	19593	50	accepting	accept	VBG
18637	19593	51	a	a	DT
18637	19593	52	plea	plea	NN
18637	19593	53	of	of	IN
18637	19593	54	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19593	55	may	may	MD
18637	19593	56	not	not	RB
18637	19593	57	render	render	VB
18637	19593	58	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19593	59	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19593	60	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	19593	61	for	for	IN
18637	19593	62	lack	lack	NN
18637	19593	63	of	of	IN
18637	19593	64	due	due	JJ
18637	19593	65	process	process	NN
18637	19593	66	,	,	,
18637	19593	67	the	the	DT
18637	19593	68	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19593	69	is	be	VBZ
18637	19593	70	violated	violate	VBN
18637	19593	71	when	when	WRB
18637	19593	72	,	,	,
18637	19593	73	while	while	IN
18637	19593	74	disadvantaged	disadvantage	VBN
18637	19593	75	by	by	IN
18637	19593	76	lack	lack	NN
18637	19593	77	of	of	IN
18637	19593	78	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19593	79	who	who	WP
18637	19593	80	might	may	MD
18637	19593	81	have	have	VB
18637	19593	82	corrected	correct	VBN
18637	19593	83	the	the	DT
18637	19593	84	court	court	NN
18637	19593	85	's	's	POS
18637	19593	86	errors	error	NNS
18637	19593	87	,	,	,
18637	19593	88	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19593	89	is	be	VBZ
18637	19593	90	sentenced	sentence	VBN
18637	19593	91	on	on	IN
18637	19593	92	the	the	DT
18637	19593	93	basis	basis	NN
18637	19593	94	of	of	IN
18637	19593	95	materially	materially	RB
18637	19593	96	untrue	untrue	JJ
18637	19593	97	assumptions	assumption	NNS
18637	19593	98	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	19593	99	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19593	100	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19593	101	record	record	NN
18637	19593	102	.	.	.
18637	19594	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19594	2	851	851	CD
18637	19594	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19594	4	Concordant	Concordant	NNP
18637	19594	5	as	as	IN
18637	19594	6	to	to	IN
18637	19594	7	the	the	DT
18637	19594	8	results	result	NNS
18637	19594	9	reached	reach	VBN
18637	19594	10	,	,	,
18637	19594	11	if	if	IN
18637	19594	12	not	not	RB
18637	19594	13	always	always	RB
18637	19594	14	as	as	IN
18637	19594	15	to	to	IN
18637	19594	16	the	the	DT
18637	19594	17	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	19594	18	supporting	support	VBG
18637	19594	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19594	20	,	,	,
18637	19594	21	are	be	VBP
18637	19594	22	the	the	DT
18637	19594	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19594	24	's	's	POS
18637	19594	25	latest	late	JJS
18637	19594	26	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	19594	27	.	.	.
18637	19595	1	In	in	IN
18637	19595	2	Uveges	Uveges	NNP
18637	19595	3	_	_	NNP
18637	19595	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	19595	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19595	6	Pennsylvania,[852	Pennsylvania,[852	NNP
18637	19595	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19595	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19595	9	was	be	VBD
18637	19595	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	19595	11	that	that	DT
18637	19595	12	inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	19595	13	as	as	IN
18637	19595	14	the	the	DT
18637	19595	15	record	record	NN
18637	19595	16	showed	show	VBD
18637	19595	17	that	that	IN
18637	19595	18	a	a	DT
18637	19595	19	State	State	NNP
18637	19595	20	court	court	NN
18637	19595	21	did	do	VBD
18637	19595	22	not	not	RB
18637	19595	23	attempt	attempt	VB
18637	19595	24	to	to	TO
18637	19595	25	make	make	VB
18637	19595	26	a	a	DT
18637	19595	27	17-year	17-year	CD
18637	19595	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	19595	29	old	old	JJ
18637	19595	30	youth	youth	NN
18637	19595	31	understand	understand	VBP
18637	19595	32	the	the	DT
18637	19595	33	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	19595	34	of	of	IN
18637	19595	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19595	36	plea	plea	NN
18637	19595	37	of	of	IN
18637	19595	38	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19595	39	to	to	IN
18637	19595	40	four	four	CD
18637	19595	41	separate	separate	JJ
18637	19595	42	indictments	indictment	NNS
18637	19595	43	charging	charge	VBG
18637	19595	44	burglary	burglary	NN
18637	19595	45	,	,	,
18637	19595	46	for	for	IN
18637	19595	47	which	which	WDT
18637	19595	48	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19595	49	could	could	MD
18637	19595	50	be	be	VB
18637	19595	51	given	give	VBN
18637	19595	52	sentences	sentence	NNS
18637	19595	53	aggregating	aggregate	VBG
18637	19595	54	80	80	CD
18637	19595	55	years	year	NNS
18637	19595	56	,	,	,
18637	19595	57	and	and	CC
18637	19595	58	that	that	IN
18637	19595	59	the	the	DT
18637	19595	60	youth	youth	NN
18637	19595	61	was	be	VBD
18637	19595	62	neither	neither	CC
18637	19595	63	advised	advise	VBN
18637	19595	64	of	of	IN
18637	19595	65	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19595	66	right	right	NN
18637	19595	67	to	to	TO
18637	19595	68	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	19595	69	nor	nor	CC
18637	19595	70	offered	offer	VBN
18637	19595	71	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19595	72	at	at	IN
18637	19595	73	any	any	DT
18637	19595	74	time	time	NN
18637	19595	75	between	between	IN
18637	19595	76	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	19595	77	and	and	CC
18637	19595	78	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19595	79	,	,	,
18637	19595	80	due	due	JJ
18637	19595	81	process	process	NN
18637	19595	82	was	be	VBD
18637	19595	83	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19595	84	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19595	85	.	.	.
18637	19596	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19596	2	,	,	,
18637	19596	3	in	in	IN
18637	19596	4	Gibbs	Gibbs	NNP
18637	19596	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19596	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	19596	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19596	8	Burke[853	Burke[853	NNP
18637	19596	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19596	10	was	be	VBD
18637	19596	11	overturned	overturn	VBN
18637	19596	12	,	,	,
18637	19596	13	as	as	RB
18637	19596	14	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	19596	15	to	to	IN
18637	19596	16	due	due	JJ
18637	19596	17	process	process	NN
18637	19596	18	,	,	,
18637	19596	19	the	the	DT
18637	19596	20	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19596	21	for	for	IN
18637	19596	22	larceny	larceny	NN
18637	19596	23	of	of	IN
18637	19596	24	a	a	DT
18637	19596	25	man	man	NN
18637	19596	26	in	in	IN
18637	19596	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19596	28	thirties	thirty	NNS
18637	19596	29	who	who	WP
18637	19596	30	conducted	conduct	VBD
18637	19596	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19596	32	own	own	JJ
18637	19596	33	defense	defense	NN
18637	19596	34	,	,	,
18637	19596	35	having	have	VBG
18637	19596	36	neither	neither	CC
18637	19596	37	requested	request	VBN
18637	19596	38	,	,	,
18637	19596	39	nor	nor	CC
18637	19596	40	having	have	VBG
18637	19596	41	been	be	VBN
18637	19596	42	offered	offer	VBN
18637	19596	43	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19596	44	.	.	.
18637	19597	1	On	on	IN
18637	19597	2	the	the	DT
18637	19597	3	authority	authority	NN
18637	19597	4	of	of	IN
18637	19597	5	the	the	DT
18637	19597	6	Uveges	Uveges	NNPS
18637	19597	7	Case	Case	NNP
18637	19597	8	,	,	,
18637	19597	9	accused	accuse	VBD
18637	19597	10	's	's	POS
18637	19597	11	failure	failure	NN
18637	19597	12	to	to	IN
18637	19597	13	request	request	NN
18637	19597	14	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19597	15	,	,	,
18637	19597	16	since	since	IN
18637	19597	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19597	18	could	could	MD
18637	19597	19	be	be	VB
18637	19597	20	attributed	attribute	VBN
18637	19597	21	to	to	IN
18637	19597	22	ignorance	ignorance	NN
18637	19597	23	of	of	IN
18637	19597	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19597	25	right	right	JJ
18637	19597	26	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	19597	27	,	,	,
18637	19597	28	was	be	VBD
18637	19597	29	held	hold	VBN
18637	19597	30	not	not	RB
18637	19597	31	to	to	TO
18637	19597	32	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	19597	33	a	a	DT
18637	19597	34	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	19597	35	.	.	.
18637	19598	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	19598	2	,	,	,
18637	19598	3	had	have	VBD
18637	19598	4	the	the	DT
18637	19598	5	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19598	6	been	be	VBN
18637	19598	7	granted	grant	VBN
18637	19598	8	the	the	DT
18637	19598	9	protection	protection	NN
18637	19598	10	of	of	IN
18637	19598	11	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19598	12	,	,	,
18637	19598	13	the	the	DT
18637	19598	14	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19598	15	might	may	MD
18637	19598	16	have	have	VB
18637	19598	17	been	be	VBN
18637	19598	18	able	able	JJ
18637	19598	19	to	to	TO
18637	19598	20	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	19598	21	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19598	22	prejudicial	prejudicial	JJ
18637	19598	23	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	19598	24	;	;	:
18637	19598	25	namely	namely	RB
18637	19598	26	,	,	,
18637	19598	27	the	the	DT
18637	19598	28	introduction	introduction	NN
18637	19598	29	without	without	IN
18637	19598	30	objection	objection	NN
18637	19598	31	of	of	IN
18637	19598	32	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	19598	33	hearsay	hearsay	NN
18637	19598	34	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19598	35	,	,	,
18637	19598	36	the	the	DT
18637	19598	37	error	error	NN
18637	19598	38	of	of	IN
18637	19598	39	the	the	DT
18637	19598	40	trial	trial	NN
18637	19598	41	judge	judge	NN
18637	19598	42	in	in	IN
18637	19598	43	converting	convert	VBG
18637	19598	44	a	a	DT
18637	19598	45	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	19598	46	witness	witness	NN
18637	19598	47	into	into	IN
18637	19598	48	a	a	DT
18637	19598	49	defense	defense	NN
18637	19598	50	witness	witness	NN
18637	19598	51	,	,	,
18637	19598	52	and	and	CC
18637	19598	53	finally	finally	RB
18637	19598	54	,	,	,
18637	19598	55	the	the	DT
18637	19598	56	injection	injection	NN
18637	19598	57	of	of	IN
18637	19598	58	biased	biased	JJ
18637	19598	59	statements	statement	NNS
18637	19598	60	into	into	IN
18637	19598	61	the	the	DT
18637	19598	62	judge	judge	NN
18637	19598	63	's	's	POS
18637	19598	64	comments	comment	NNS
18637	19598	65	to	to	IN
18637	19598	66	the	the	DT
18637	19598	67	jury	jury	NN
18637	19598	68	.	.	.
18637	19599	1	And	and	CC
18637	19599	2	of	of	IN
18637	19599	3	the	the	DT
18637	19599	4	same	same	JJ
18637	19599	5	general	general	JJ
18637	19599	6	pattern	pattern	NN
18637	19599	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19599	8	the	the	DT
18637	19599	9	holding	holding	NN
18637	19599	10	in	in	IN
18637	19599	11	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	19599	12	_	_	NNP
18637	19599	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	19599	14	_	_	NNP
18637	19599	15	Ashe,[854	Ashe,[854	NNP
18637	19599	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19599	17	another	another	DT
18637	19599	18	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	19599	19	case	case	NN
18637	19599	20	,	,	,
18637	19599	21	involving	involve	VBG
18637	19599	22	a	a	DT
18637	19599	23	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	19599	24	who	who	WP
18637	19599	25	alleged	allege	VBD
18637	19599	26	that	that	IN
18637	19599	27	,	,	,
18637	19599	28	as	as	IN
18637	19599	29	a	a	DT
18637	19599	30	youth	youth	NN
18637	19599	31	and	and	CC
18637	19599	32	former	former	JJ
18637	19599	33	inmate	inmate	NN
18637	19599	34	at	at	IN
18637	19599	35	a	a	DT
18637	19599	36	mental	mental	JJ
18637	19599	37	institution	institution	NN
18637	19599	38	,	,	,
18637	19599	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19599	40	was	be	VBD
18637	19599	41	railroaded	railroad	VBN
18637	19599	42	into	into	IN
18637	19599	43	prison	prison	NN
18637	19599	44	for	for	IN
18637	19599	45	armed	armed	JJ
18637	19599	46	robbery	robbery	NN
18637	19599	47	without	without	IN
18637	19599	48	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19599	49	of	of	IN
18637	19599	50	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19599	51	,	,	,
18637	19599	52	on	on	IN
18637	19599	53	the	the	DT
18637	19599	54	representation	representation	NN
18637	19599	55	that	that	IN
18637	19599	56	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19599	57	was	be	VBD
18637	19599	58	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19599	59	only	only	RB
18637	19599	60	with	with	IN
18637	19599	61	breaking	break	VBG
18637	19599	62	and	and	CC
18637	19599	63	entering	enter	VBG
18637	19599	64	.	.	.
18637	19600	1	Reversing	reverse	VBG
18637	19600	2	the	the	DT
18637	19600	3	State	State	NNP
18637	19600	4	court	court	NN
18637	19600	5	's	's	POS
18637	19600	6	denial	denial	NN
18637	19600	7	of	of	IN
18637	19600	8	petitioner	petitioner	NNP
18637	19600	9	's	's	POS
18637	19600	10	application	application	NN
18637	19600	11	for	for	IN
18637	19600	12	a	a	DT
18637	19600	13	writ	writ	NN
18637	19600	14	of	of	IN
18637	19600	15	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	19600	16	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	19600	17	,	,	,
18637	19600	18	the	the	DT
18637	19600	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19600	20	remanded	remand	VBD
18637	19600	21	the	the	DT
18637	19600	22	case	case	NN
18637	19600	23	,	,	,
18637	19600	24	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	19600	25	that	that	IN
18637	19600	26	if	if	IN
18637	19600	27	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	19600	28	's	's	POS
18637	19600	29	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	19600	30	were	be	VBD
18637	19600	31	proven	prove	VBN
18637	19600	32	,	,	,
18637	19600	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19600	34	was	be	VBD
18637	19600	35	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19600	36	to	to	IN
18637	19600	37	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19600	38	.	.	.
18637	19601	1	On	on	IN
18637	19601	2	the	the	DT
18637	19601	3	other	other	JJ
18637	19601	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	19601	5	,	,	,
18637	19601	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19601	7	was	be	VBD
18637	19601	8	held	hold	VBN
18637	19601	9	in	in	IN
18637	19601	10	Quicksall	Quicksall	NNP
18637	19601	11	_	_	NNP
18637	19601	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	19601	13	_	_	NNP
18637	19601	14	Michigan,[855	Michigan,[855	NNP
18637	19601	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19601	16	a	a	DT
18637	19601	17	State	state	NN
18637	19601	18	in	in	IN
18637	19601	19	which	which	WDT
18637	19601	20	capital	capital	NN
18637	19601	21	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	19601	22	does	do	VBZ
18637	19601	23	not	not	RB
18637	19601	24	exist	exist	VB
18637	19601	25	,	,	,
18637	19601	26	that	that	IN
18637	19601	27	a	a	DT
18637	19601	28	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19601	29	who	who	WP
18637	19601	30	had	have	VBD
18637	19601	31	received	receive	VBN
18637	19601	32	a	a	DT
18637	19601	33	life	life	NN
18637	19601	34	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19601	35	on	on	IN
18637	19601	36	a	a	DT
18637	19601	37	plea	plea	NN
18637	19601	38	of	of	IN
18637	19601	39	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19601	40	entered	enter	VBN
18637	19601	41	without	without	IN
18637	19601	42	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19601	43	of	of	IN
18637	19601	44	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19601	45	,	,	,
18637	19601	46	had	have	VBD
18637	19601	47	"	"	``
18637	19601	48	failed	fail	VBN
18637	19601	49	to	to	TO
18637	19601	50	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	19601	51	the	the	DT
18637	19601	52	burden	burden	NN
18637	19601	53	of	of	IN
18637	19601	54	proving	prove	VBG
18637	19601	55	such	such	JJ
18637	19601	56	disregard	disregard	NN
18637	19601	57	of	of	IN
18637	19601	58	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19601	59	fairness	fairness	NN
18637	19601	60	*	*	NFP
18637	19601	61	*	*	NFP
18637	19601	62	*	*	NFP
18637	19601	63	as	as	IN
18637	19601	64	alone	alone	RB
18637	19601	65	would	would	MD
18637	19601	66	*	*	NFP
18637	19601	67	*	*	NFP
18637	19601	68	*	*	NFP
18637	19601	69	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	19601	70	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19601	71	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19601	72	,	,	,
18637	19601	73	"	"	``
18637	19601	74	not	not	RB
18637	19601	75	having	have	VBG
18637	19601	76	convinced	convince	VBN
18637	19601	77	the	the	DT
18637	19601	78	State	State	NNP
18637	19601	79	court	court	NN
18637	19601	80	that	that	IN
18637	19601	81	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19601	82	was	be	VBD
18637	19601	83	ignorant	ignorant	JJ
18637	19601	84	of	of	IN
18637	19601	85	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19601	86	right	right	NN
18637	19601	87	to	to	IN
18637	19601	88	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	19601	89	,	,	,
18637	19601	90	or	or	CC
18637	19601	91	that	that	IN
18637	19601	92	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19601	93	had	have	VBD
18637	19601	94	requested	request	VBN
18637	19601	95	same	same	JJ
18637	19601	96	,	,	,
18637	19601	97	or	or	CC
18637	19601	98	that	that	IN
18637	19601	99	the	the	DT
18637	19601	100	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	19601	101	of	of	IN
18637	19601	102	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19601	103	plea	plea	NN
18637	19601	104	had	have	VBD
18637	19601	105	been	be	VBN
18637	19601	106	misrepresented	misrepresent	VBN
18637	19601	107	to	to	IN
18637	19601	108	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19601	109	.	.	.
18637	19602	1	Also	also	RB
18637	19602	2	,	,	,
18637	19602	3	in	in	IN
18637	19602	4	Gallegos	Gallegos	NNP
18637	19602	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19602	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	19602	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19602	8	Nebraska,[856	Nebraska,[856	NNP
18637	19602	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19602	10	in	in	IN
18637	19602	11	which	which	WDT
18637	19602	12	the	the	DT
18637	19602	13	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	19602	14	had	have	VBD
18637	19602	15	been	be	VBN
18637	19602	16	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	19602	17	of	of	IN
18637	19602	18	manslaughter	manslaughter	NN
18637	19602	19	on	on	IN
18637	19602	20	a	a	DT
18637	19602	21	homicide	homicide	NN
18637	19602	22	charge	charge	NN
18637	19602	23	,	,	,
18637	19602	24	a	a	DT
18637	19602	25	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19602	26	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	19602	27	was	be	VBD
18637	19602	28	reached	reach	VBN
18637	19602	29	in	in	IN
18637	19602	30	the	the	DT
18637	19602	31	face	face	NN
18637	19602	32	of	of	IN
18637	19602	33	the	the	DT
18637	19602	34	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	19602	35	's	's	POS
18637	19602	36	claim	claim	NN
18637	19602	37	that	that	IN
18637	19602	38	the	the	DT
18637	19602	39	confession	confession	NN
18637	19602	40	on	on	IN
18637	19602	41	the	the	DT
18637	19602	42	strength	strength	NN
18637	19602	43	of	of	IN
18637	19602	44	which	which	WDT
18637	19602	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19602	46	was	be	VBD
18637	19602	47	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	19602	48	had	have	VBD
18637	19602	49	been	be	VBN
18637	19602	50	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19602	51	from	from	IN
18637	19602	52	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19602	53	by	by	IN
18637	19602	54	mistreatment	mistreatment	NN
18637	19602	55	,	,	,
18637	19602	56	prior	prior	RB
18637	19602	57	to	to	IN
18637	19602	58	the	the	DT
18637	19602	59	assignment	assignment	NN
18637	19602	60	of	of	IN
18637	19602	61	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19602	62	to	to	IN
18637	19602	63	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19602	64	.	.	.
18637	19603	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	19603	2	the	the	DT
18637	19603	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19603	4	:	:	:
18637	19603	5	"	"	``
18637	19603	6	The	the	DT
18637	19603	7	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	19603	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19603	9	does	do	VBZ
18637	19603	10	not	not	RB
18637	19603	11	command	command	VB
18637	19603	12	a	a	DT
18637	19603	13	State	state	NN
18637	19603	14	to	to	TO
18637	19603	15	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	19603	16	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	19603	17	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19603	18	as	as	IN
18637	19603	19	a	a	DT
18637	19603	20	matter	matter	NN
18637	19603	21	of	of	IN
18637	19603	22	course	course	NN
18637	19603	23	.	.	.
18637	19604	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19604	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19604	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19604	4	Lack	lack	NN
18637	19604	5	of	of	IN
18637	19604	6	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19604	7	at	at	IN
18637	19604	8	State	state	NN
18637	19604	9	noncapital	noncapital	JJ
18637	19604	10	trials	trial	NNS
18637	19604	11	denies	deny	VBZ
18637	19604	12	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19604	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19604	14	protection	protection	NN
18637	19604	15	only	only	RB
18637	19604	16	when	when	WRB
18637	19604	17	the	the	DT
18637	19604	18	absence	absence	NN
18637	19604	19	results	result	VBZ
18637	19604	20	in	in	IN
18637	19604	21	a	a	DT
18637	19604	22	denial	denial	NN
18637	19604	23	to	to	IN
18637	19604	24	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19604	25	of	of	IN
18637	19604	26	the	the	DT
18637	19604	27	essentials	essential	NNS
18637	19604	28	of	of	IN
18637	19604	29	justice	justice	NN
18637	19604	30	.	.	.
18637	19605	1	"	"	``
18637	19605	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19605	3	857	857	CD
18637	19605	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19605	5	By	by	IN
18637	19605	6	way	way	NN
18637	19605	7	of	of	IN
18637	19605	8	summation	summation	NN
18637	19605	9	,	,	,
18637	19605	10	the	the	DT
18637	19605	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19605	12	in	in	IN
18637	19605	13	Uveges	Uveges	NNPS
18637	19605	14	_	_	NNP
18637	19605	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	19605	16	_	_	NNP
18637	19605	17	Pennsylvania[858	Pennsylvania[858	NNP
18637	19605	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19605	19	offered	offer	VBD
18637	19605	20	the	the	DT
18637	19605	21	following	follow	VBG
18637	19605	22	comment	comment	NN
18637	19605	23	on	on	IN
18637	19605	24	the	the	DT
18637	19605	25	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	19605	26	views	view	NNS
18637	19605	27	advanced	advance	VBN
18637	19605	28	by	by	IN
18637	19605	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19605	30	members	member	NNS
18637	19605	31	on	on	IN
18637	19605	32	this	this	DT
18637	19605	33	issue	issue	NN
18637	19605	34	of	of	IN
18637	19605	35	right	right	NN
18637	19605	36	to	to	IN
18637	19605	37	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	19605	38	.	.	.
18637	19606	1	"	"	``
18637	19606	2	Some	some	DT
18637	19606	3	members	member	NNS
18637	19606	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19606	5	minority	minority	NN
18637	19606	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19606	7	of	of	IN
18637	19606	8	the	the	DT
18637	19606	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19606	10	think	think	VBP
18637	19606	11	that	that	IN
18637	19606	12	where	where	WRB
18637	19606	13	serious	serious	JJ
18637	19606	14	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	19606	15	are	be	VBP
18637	19606	16	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19606	17	,	,	,
18637	19606	18	failure	failure	NN
18637	19606	19	of	of	IN
18637	19606	20	a	a	DT
18637	19606	21	court	court	NN
18637	19606	22	to	to	TO
18637	19606	23	offer	offer	VB
18637	19606	24	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19606	25	in	in	IN
18637	19606	26	State	State	NNP
18637	19606	27	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19606	28	trials	trial	NNS
18637	19606	29	deprives	deprive	VBZ
18637	19606	30	an	an	DT
18637	19606	31	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19606	32	of	of	IN
18637	19606	33	rights	right	NNS
18637	19606	34	under	under	IN
18637	19606	35	the	the	DT
18637	19606	36	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19606	37	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19606	38	.	.	.
18637	19607	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19607	2	are	be	VBP
18637	19607	3	convinced	convinced	JJ
18637	19607	4	that	that	IN
18637	19607	5	the	the	DT
18637	19607	6	services	service	NNS
18637	19607	7	of	of	IN
18637	19607	8	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19607	9	to	to	TO
18637	19607	10	protect	protect	VB
18637	19607	11	the	the	DT
18637	19607	12	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19607	13	are	be	VBP
18637	19607	14	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	19607	15	by	by	IN
18637	19607	16	the	the	DT
18637	19607	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19607	18	in	in	IN
18637	19607	19	every	every	DT
18637	19607	20	such	such	JJ
18637	19607	21	instance	instance	NN
18637	19607	22	.	.	.
18637	19608	1	_	_	NNP
18637	19608	2	See	See	NNP
18637	19608	3	_	_	NNP
18637	19608	4	Bute	Bute	NNP
18637	19608	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19608	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	19608	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19608	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	19608	9	,	,	,
18637	19608	10	333	333	CD
18637	19608	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	19608	12	640	640	CD
18637	19608	13	,	,	,
18637	19608	14	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	19608	15	,	,	,
18637	19608	16	677	677	CD
18637	19608	17	-	-	SYM
18637	19608	18	679	679	CD
18637	19608	19	.	.	.
18637	19609	1	Only	only	RB
18637	19609	2	when	when	WRB
18637	19609	3	the	the	DT
18637	19609	4	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19609	5	refuses	refuse	VBZ
18637	19609	6	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19609	7	with	with	IN
18637	19609	8	an	an	DT
18637	19609	9	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	19609	10	of	of	IN
18637	19609	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19609	12	rights	right	NNS
18637	19609	13	can	can	MD
18637	19609	14	the	the	DT
18637	19609	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19609	16	dispense	dispense	NN
18637	19609	17	with	with	IN
18637	19609	18	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19609	19	.	.	.
18637	19610	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19610	2	859	859	CD
18637	19610	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19610	4	Others	other	NNS
18637	19610	5	of	of	IN
18637	19610	6	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19610	7	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19610	8	majority	majority	NN
18637	19610	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19610	10	think	think	VBP
18637	19610	11	that	that	IN
18637	19610	12	when	when	WRB
18637	19610	13	a	a	DT
18637	19610	14	crime	crime	NN
18637	19610	15	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19610	16	to	to	IN
18637	19610	17	capital	capital	JJ
18637	19610	18	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	19610	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	19610	20	not	not	RB
18637	19610	21	involved	involve	VBN
18637	19610	22	,	,	,
18637	19610	23	each	each	DT
18637	19610	24	case	case	NN
18637	19610	25	depends	depend	VBZ
18637	19610	26	on	on	IN
18637	19610	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19610	28	own	own	JJ
18637	19610	29	facts	fact	NNS
18637	19610	30	.	.	.
18637	19611	1	_	_	NNP
18637	19611	2	See	See	NNP
18637	19611	3	_	_	NNP
18637	19611	4	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	19611	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19611	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	19611	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19611	8	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	19611	9	,	,	,
18637	19611	10	316	316	CD
18637	19611	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	19611	12	455	455	CD
18637	19611	13	,	,	,
18637	19611	14	462	462	CD
18637	19611	15	.	.	.
18637	19612	1	Where	where	WRB
18637	19612	2	the	the	DT
18637	19612	3	gravity	gravity	NN
18637	19612	4	of	of	IN
18637	19612	5	the	the	DT
18637	19612	6	crime	crime	NN
18637	19612	7	and	and	CC
18637	19612	8	other	other	JJ
18637	19612	9	factors	factor	NNS
18637	19612	10	--	--	:
18637	19612	11	such	such	JJ
18637	19612	12	as	as	IN
18637	19612	13	the	the	DT
18637	19612	14	age	age	NN
18637	19612	15	and	and	CC
18637	19612	16	education	education	NN
18637	19612	17	of	of	IN
18637	19612	18	the	the	DT
18637	19612	19	defendant,[860	defendant,[860	NNP
18637	19612	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19612	21	the	the	DT
18637	19612	22	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	19612	23	of	of	IN
18637	19612	24	the	the	DT
18637	19612	25	court	court	NN
18637	19612	26	or	or	CC
18637	19612	27	the	the	DT
18637	19612	28	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
18637	19612	29	officials,[861	officials,[861	NNP
18637	19612	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19612	31	and	and	CC
18637	19612	32	the	the	DT
18637	19612	33	complicated	complicated	JJ
18637	19612	34	nature	nature	NN
18637	19612	35	of	of	IN
18637	19612	36	the	the	DT
18637	19612	37	offense	offense	NN
18637	19612	38	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19612	39	and	and	CC
18637	19612	40	the	the	DT
18637	19612	41	possible	possible	JJ
18637	19612	42	defenses	defense	VBZ
18637	19612	43	thereto[862]--render	thereto[862]--render	JJ
18637	19612	44	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19612	45	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19612	46	without	without	IN
18637	19612	47	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19612	48	so	so	RB
18637	19612	49	apt	apt	JJ
18637	19612	50	to	to	TO
18637	19612	51	result	result	VB
18637	19612	52	in	in	IN
18637	19612	53	injustice	injustice	NN
18637	19612	54	as	as	IN
18637	19612	55	to	to	TO
18637	19612	56	be	be	VB
18637	19612	57	fundamentally	fundamentally	RB
18637	19612	58	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	19612	59	,	,	,
18637	19612	60	the	the	DT
18637	19612	61	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19612	62	group	group	NN
18637	19612	63	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19612	64	majority	majority	NN
18637	19612	65	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19612	66	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	19612	67	that	that	IN
18637	19612	68	the	the	DT
18637	19612	69	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19612	70	must	must	MD
18637	19612	71	have	have	VB
18637	19612	72	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19612	73	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	19612	74	under	under	IN
18637	19612	75	the	the	DT
18637	19612	76	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	19612	77	whether	whether	IN
18637	19612	78	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19612	79	pleads	plead	VBZ
18637	19612	80	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19612	81	or	or	CC
18637	19612	82	elects	elect	VBZ
18637	19612	83	to	to	TO
18637	19612	84	stand	stand	VB
18637	19612	85	trial	trial	NN
18637	19612	86	,	,	,
18637	19612	87	whether	whether	IN
18637	19612	88	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19612	89	requests	request	VBZ
18637	19612	90	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19612	91	or	or	CC
18637	19612	92	not	not	RB
18637	19612	93	.	.	.
18637	19613	1	Only	only	RB
18637	19613	2	a	a	DT
18637	19613	3	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	19613	4	of	of	IN
18637	19613	5	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19613	6	,	,	,
18637	19613	7	understandingly	understandingly	RB
18637	19613	8	made	make	VBN
18637	19613	9	,	,	,
18637	19613	10	justifies	justifie	NNS
18637	19613	11	trial	trial	NN
18637	19613	12	without	without	IN
18637	19613	13	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19613	14	.	.	.
18637	19614	1	The	the	DT
18637	19614	2	philosophy	philosophy	NN
18637	19614	3	behind	behind	IN
18637	19614	4	both	both	DT
18637	19614	5	of	of	IN
18637	19614	6	these	these	DT
18637	19614	7	views	view	NNS
18637	19614	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	19614	9	that	that	IN
18637	19614	10	the	the	DT
18637	19614	11	due	due	JJ
18637	19614	12	process	process	NN
18637	19614	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	19614	14	of	of	IN
18637	19614	15	the	the	DT
18637	19614	16	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19614	17	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19614	18	*	*	NFP
18637	19614	19	*	*	NFP
18637	19614	20	*	*	NFP
18637	19614	21	requires	require	VBZ
18637	19614	22	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19614	23	for	for	IN
18637	19614	24	all	all	DT
18637	19614	25	persons	person	NNS
18637	19614	26	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19614	27	with	with	IN
18637	19614	28	serious	serious	JJ
18637	19614	29	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	19614	30	,	,	,
18637	19614	31	when	when	WRB
18637	19614	32	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19614	33	for	for	IN
18637	19614	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19614	35	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19614	36	defense	defense	NN
18637	19614	37	,	,	,
18637	19614	38	in	in	IN
18637	19614	39	order	order	NN
18637	19614	40	that	that	IN
18637	19614	41	such	such	JJ
18637	19614	42	persons	person	NNS
18637	19614	43	may	may	MD
18637	19614	44	be	be	VB
18637	19614	45	advised	advise	VBN
18637	19614	46	how	how	WRB
18637	19614	47	to	to	TO
18637	19614	48	conduct	conduct	VB
18637	19614	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19614	50	trials	trial	NNS
18637	19614	51	.	.	.
18637	19615	1	The	the	DT
18637	19615	2	application	application	NN
18637	19615	3	of	of	IN
18637	19615	4	the	the	DT
18637	19615	5	rule	rule	NN
18637	19615	6	varies	vary	VBZ
18637	19615	7	*	*	NFP
18637	19615	8	*	*	NFP
18637	19615	9	*	*	NFP
18637	19615	10	"	"	``
18637	19615	11	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19615	12	would	would	MD
18637	19615	13	appear	appear	VB
18637	19615	14	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	19615	15	that	that	IN
18637	19615	16	the	the	DT
18637	19615	17	statement	statement	NN
18637	19615	18	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	19615	19	in	in	IN
18637	19615	20	the	the	DT
18637	19615	21	previous	previous	JJ
18637	19615	22	paragraph	paragraph	NN
18637	19615	23	from	from	IN
18637	19615	24	the	the	DT
18637	19615	25	Gallegos	Gallegos	NNP
18637	19615	26	Case	Case	NNP
18637	19615	27	weakens	weaken	VBZ
18637	19615	28	this	this	DT
18637	19615	29	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	19615	30	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	19615	31	.	.	.
18637	19616	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19616	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	19616	3	the	the	DT
18637	19616	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19616	5	's	's	POS
18637	19616	6	reply	reply	NN
18637	19616	7	to	to	IN
18637	19616	8	the	the	DT
18637	19616	9	contention	contention	NN
18637	19616	10	that	that	IN
18637	19616	11	such	such	JJ
18637	19616	12	variation	variation	NN
18637	19616	13	in	in	IN
18637	19616	14	application	application	NN
18637	19616	15	"	"	``
18637	19616	16	leaves	leave	VBZ
18637	19616	17	the	the	DT
18637	19616	18	State	state	NN
18637	19616	19	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
18637	19616	20	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	19616	21	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
18637	19616	22	as	as	IN
18637	19616	23	to	to	IN
18637	19616	24	whether	whether	IN
18637	19616	25	to	to	TO
18637	19616	26	offer	offer	VB
18637	19616	27	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19616	28	to	to	IN
18637	19616	29	all	all	DT
18637	19616	30	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19616	31	who	who	WP
18637	19616	32	are	be	VBP
18637	19616	33	without	without	IN
18637	19616	34	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19616	35	funds	fund	NNS
18637	19616	36	and	and	CC
18637	19616	37	under	under	IN
18637	19616	38	serious	serious	JJ
18637	19616	39	charges	charge	NNS
18637	19616	40	,	,	,
18637	19616	41	"	"	``
18637	19616	42	very	very	RB
18637	19616	43	reassuring	reassuring	JJ
18637	19616	44	:	:	:
18637	19616	45	"	"	``
18637	19616	46	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19616	47	can	can	MD
18637	19616	48	not	not	RB
18637	19616	49	offer	offer	VB
18637	19616	50	a	a	DT
18637	19616	51	panacea	panacea	NN
18637	19616	52	for	for	IN
18637	19616	53	the	the	DT
18637	19616	54	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	19616	55	.	.	.
18637	19617	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19617	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19617	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19617	4	The	the	DT
18637	19617	5	due	due	JJ
18637	19617	6	process	process	NN
18637	19617	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	19617	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	19617	9	not	not	RB
18637	19617	10	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
18637	19617	11	of	of	IN
18637	19617	12	reduction	reduction	NN
18637	19617	13	to	to	IN
18637	19617	14	a	a	DT
18637	19617	15	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
18637	19617	16	formula	formula	NN
18637	19617	17	.	.	.
18637	19618	1	"	"	``
18637	19618	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19618	3	863	863	CD
18637	19618	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19618	5	Right	right	UH
18637	19618	6	to	to	IN
18637	19618	7	Trial	trial	NN
18637	19618	8	by	by	IN
18637	19618	9	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	19618	10	The	the	DT
18637	19618	11	contention	contention	NN
18637	19618	12	that	that	IN
18637	19618	13	a	a	DT
18637	19618	14	right	right	NN
18637	19618	15	to	to	IN
18637	19618	16	trial	trial	NN
18637	19618	17	by	by	IN
18637	19618	18	a	a	DT
18637	19618	19	common	common	JJ
18637	19618	20	law	law	NN
18637	19618	21	jury	jury	NN
18637	19618	22	of	of	IN
18637	19618	23	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	19618	24	men	man	NNS
18637	19618	25	in	in	IN
18637	19618	26	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19618	27	cases	case	NNS
18637	19618	28	was	be	VBD
18637	19618	29	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	19618	30	by	by	IN
18637	19618	31	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19618	32	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	19618	33	was	be	VBD
18637	19618	34	first	first	RB
18637	19618	35	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	19618	36	in	in	IN
18637	19618	37	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	19618	38	_	_	NNP
18637	19618	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	19618	40	_	_	NNP
18637	19618	41	Dow[864	Dow[864	NNP
18637	19618	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19618	43	on	on	IN
18637	19618	44	the	the	DT
18637	19618	45	basis	basis	NN
18637	19618	46	of	of	IN
18637	19618	47	Hurtado	Hurtado	NNP
18637	19618	48	_	_	NNP
18637	19618	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	19618	50	_	_	NNP
18637	19618	51	California,[865	California,[865	NNP
18637	19618	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19618	53	where	where	WRB
18637	19618	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19618	55	was	be	VBD
18637	19618	56	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19618	57	that	that	IN
18637	19618	58	the	the	DT
18637	19618	59	due	due	JJ
18637	19618	60	process	process	NN
18637	19618	61	clause	clause	NN
18637	19618	62	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19618	63	incorporated	incorporate	VBD
18637	19618	64	all	all	PDT
18637	19618	65	the	the	DT
18637	19618	66	rules	rule	NNS
18637	19618	67	of	of	IN
18637	19618	68	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	19618	69	protection	protection	NN
18637	19618	70	having	have	VBG
18637	19618	71	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19618	72	origin	origin	NN
18637	19618	73	in	in	IN
18637	19618	74	English	english	JJ
18637	19618	75	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19618	76	history	history	NN
18637	19618	77	.	.	.
18637	19619	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19619	2	,	,	,
18637	19619	3	so	so	RB
18637	19619	4	long	long	RB
18637	19619	5	as	as	IN
18637	19619	6	all	all	DT
18637	19619	7	persons	person	NNS
18637	19619	8	are	be	VBP
18637	19619	9	made	make	VBN
18637	19619	10	liable	liable	JJ
18637	19619	11	to	to	TO
18637	19619	12	be	be	VB
18637	19619	13	proceeded	proceed	VBN
18637	19619	14	against	against	IN
18637	19619	15	in	in	IN
18637	19619	16	the	the	DT
18637	19619	17	same	same	JJ
18637	19619	18	manner	manner	NN
18637	19619	19	,	,	,
18637	19619	20	a	a	DT
18637	19619	21	state	state	NN
18637	19619	22	statute	statute	NN
18637	19619	23	dispensing	dispense	VBG
18637	19619	24	with	with	IN
18637	19619	25	unanimity,[866	unanimity,[866	NNP
18637	19619	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19619	27	or	or	CC
18637	19619	28	providing	provide	VBG
18637	19619	29	for	for	IN
18637	19619	30	a	a	DT
18637	19619	31	jury	jury	NN
18637	19619	32	of	of	IN
18637	19619	33	eight	eight	CD
18637	19619	34	instead	instead	RB
18637	19619	35	of	of	IN
18637	19619	36	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	19619	37	,	,	,
18637	19619	38	in	in	IN
18637	19619	39	noncapital	noncapital	JJ
18637	19619	40	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19619	41	cases[867	cases[867	NN
18637	19619	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19619	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	19619	44	not	not	RB
18637	19619	45	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19619	46	;	;	:
18637	19619	47	nor	nor	CC
18637	19619	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	19619	49	one	one	CD
18637	19619	50	eliminating	eliminate	VBG
18637	19619	51	employment	employment	NN
18637	19619	52	of	of	IN
18637	19619	53	a	a	DT
18637	19619	54	jury	jury	NN
18637	19619	55	when	when	WRB
18637	19619	56	the	the	DT
18637	19619	57	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19619	58	pleads	plead	VBZ
18637	19619	59	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19619	60	to	to	IN
18637	19619	61	no	no	DT
18637	19619	62	less	less	JJR
18637	19619	63	than	than	IN
18637	19619	64	a	a	DT
18637	19619	65	capital	capital	NN
18637	19619	66	offense;[868	offense;[868	CD
18637	19619	67	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19619	68	or	or	CC
18637	19619	69	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	19619	70	a	a	DT
18637	19619	71	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19619	72	generally	generally	RB
18637	19619	73	to	to	TO
18637	19619	74	waive	waive	VB
18637	19619	75	trial	trial	NN
18637	19619	76	by	by	IN
18637	19619	77	jury	jury	NN
18637	19619	78	.	.	.
18637	19620	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19620	2	869	869	CD
18637	19620	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19620	4	In	in	IN
18637	19620	5	short	short	JJ
18637	19620	6	,	,	,
18637	19620	7	jury	jury	NN
18637	19620	8	trials	trial	NNS
18637	19620	9	are	be	VBP
18637	19620	10	no	no	RB
18637	19620	11	longer	long	RBR
18637	19620	12	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19620	13	as	as	IN
18637	19620	14	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19620	15	to	to	IN
18637	19620	16	due	due	JJ
18637	19620	17	process	process	NN
18637	19620	18	,	,	,
18637	19620	19	even	even	RB
18637	19620	20	in	in	IN
18637	19620	21	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19620	22	cases	case	NNS
18637	19620	23	,	,	,
18637	19620	24	and	and	CC
18637	19620	25	may	may	MD
18637	19620	26	be	be	VB
18637	19620	27	abolished	abolish	VBN
18637	19620	28	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	19620	29	.	.	.
18637	19621	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19621	2	870	870	CD
18637	19621	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19621	4	Inasmuch	inasmuch	VB
18637	19621	5	as	as	IN
18637	19621	6	"	"	``
18637	19621	7	the	the	DT
18637	19621	8	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	19621	9	of	of	IN
18637	19621	10	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19621	11	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19621	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	19621	13	not	not	RB
18637	19621	14	to	to	TO
18637	19621	15	enable	enable	VB
18637	19621	16	the	the	DT
18637	19621	17	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19621	18	to	to	TO
18637	19621	19	select	select	VB
18637	19621	20	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	19621	21	,	,	,
18637	19621	22	but	but	CC
18637	19621	23	to	to	TO
18637	19621	24	secure	secure	VB
18637	19621	25	an	an	DT
18637	19621	26	impartial	impartial	JJ
18637	19621	27	jury	jury	NN
18637	19621	28	,	,	,
18637	19621	29	"	"	''
18637	19621	30	a	a	DT
18637	19621	31	trial	trial	NN
18637	19621	32	of	of	IN
18637	19621	33	a	a	DT
18637	19621	34	murder	murder	NN
18637	19621	35	charge	charge	NN
18637	19621	36	by	by	IN
18637	19621	37	a	a	DT
18637	19621	38	"	"	``
18637	19621	39	struck	struck	JJ
18637	19621	40	"	"	''
18637	19621	41	jury	jury	NN
18637	19621	42	,	,	,
18637	19621	43	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	19621	44	in	in	IN
18637	19621	45	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	19621	46	with	with	IN
18637	19621	47	a	a	DT
18637	19621	48	statute	statute	NN
18637	19621	49	providing	provide	VBG
18637	19621	50	that	that	IN
18637	19621	51	the	the	DT
18637	19621	52	court	court	NN
18637	19621	53	may	may	MD
18637	19621	54	select	select	VB
18637	19621	55	from	from	IN
18637	19621	56	the	the	DT
18637	19621	57	persons	person	NNS
18637	19621	58	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	19621	59	to	to	TO
18637	19621	60	serve	serve	VB
18637	19621	61	as	as	IN
18637	19621	62	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	19621	63	96	96	CD
18637	19621	64	names	name	NNS
18637	19621	65	,	,	,
18637	19621	66	from	from	IN
18637	19621	67	which	which	WDT
18637	19621	68	the	the	DT
18637	19621	69	prosecutor	prosecutor	NN
18637	19621	70	and	and	CC
18637	19621	71	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19621	72	may	may	MD
18637	19621	73	each	each	DT
18637	19621	74	strike	strike	NN
18637	19621	75	24	24	CD
18637	19621	76	,	,	,
18637	19621	77	and	and	CC
18637	19621	78	that	that	IN
18637	19621	79	the	the	DT
18637	19621	80	remainder	remainder	NN
18637	19621	81	of	of	IN
18637	19621	82	which	which	WDT
18637	19621	83	shall	shall	MD
18637	19621	84	be	be	VB
18637	19621	85	put	put	VBN
18637	19621	86	in	in	IN
18637	19621	87	the	the	DT
18637	19621	88	jury	jury	NN
18637	19621	89	box	box	NN
18637	19621	90	,	,	,
18637	19621	91	out	out	IN
18637	19621	92	of	of	IN
18637	19621	93	which	which	WDT
18637	19621	94	the	the	DT
18637	19621	95	trial	trial	NN
18637	19621	96	jury	jury	NN
18637	19621	97	shall	shall	MD
18637	19621	98	be	be	VB
18637	19621	99	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	19621	100	in	in	IN
18637	19621	101	the	the	DT
18637	19621	102	usual	usual	JJ
18637	19621	103	way	way	NN
18637	19621	104	,	,	,
18637	19621	105	is	be	VBZ
18637	19621	106	not	not	RB
18637	19621	107	violative	violative	JJ
18637	19621	108	of	of	IN
18637	19621	109	due	due	JJ
18637	19621	110	process	process	NN
18637	19621	111	.	.	.
18637	19622	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	19622	2	a	a	DT
18637	19622	3	method	method	NN
18637	19622	4	"	"	``
18637	19622	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19622	6	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	19622	7	a	a	DT
18637	19622	8	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19622	9	and	and	CC
18637	19622	10	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19622	11	way	way	NN
18637	19622	12	of	of	IN
18637	19622	13	securing	secure	VBG
18637	19622	14	an	an	DT
18637	19622	15	impartial	impartial	JJ
18637	19622	16	jury	jury	NN
18637	19622	17	,	,	,
18637	19622	18	"	"	''
18637	19622	19	which	which	WDT
18637	19622	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	19622	21	all	all	DT
18637	19622	22	that	that	WDT
18637	19622	23	the	the	DT
18637	19622	24	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19622	25	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	19622	26	may	may	MD
18637	19622	27	demand	demand	VB
18637	19622	28	.	.	.
18637	19623	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19623	2	871	871	CD
18637	19623	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19623	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19623	5	,	,	,
18637	19623	6	the	the	DT
18637	19623	7	right	right	NN
18637	19623	8	to	to	TO
18637	19623	9	challenge	challenge	VB
18637	19623	10	being	be	VBG
18637	19623	11	the	the	DT
18637	19623	12	right	right	NN
18637	19623	13	to	to	TO
18637	19623	14	reject	reject	VB
18637	19623	15	,	,	,
18637	19623	16	not	not	RB
18637	19623	17	to	to	TO
18637	19623	18	select	select	VB
18637	19623	19	,	,	,
18637	19623	20	a	a	DT
18637	19623	21	juror	juror	NN
18637	19623	22	,	,	,
18637	19623	23	a	a	DT
18637	19623	24	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19623	25	who	who	WP
18637	19623	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	19623	27	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	19623	28	at	at	IN
18637	19623	29	a	a	DT
18637	19623	30	single	single	JJ
18637	19623	31	trial	trial	NN
18637	19623	32	to	to	IN
18637	19623	33	two	two	CD
18637	19623	34	indictments	indictment	NNS
18637	19623	35	,	,	,
18637	19623	36	each	each	DT
18637	19623	37	charging	charge	VBG
18637	19623	38	murder	murder	NN
18637	19623	39	,	,	,
18637	19623	40	can	can	MD
18637	19623	41	not	not	RB
18637	19623	42	complain	complain	VB
18637	19623	43	when	when	WRB
18637	19623	44	the	the	DT
18637	19623	45	State	state	NN
18637	19623	46	limits	limit	VBZ
18637	19623	47	the	the	DT
18637	19623	48	number	number	NN
18637	19623	49	of	of	IN
18637	19623	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19623	51	peremptory	peremptory	JJ
18637	19623	52	challenges	challenge	NNS
18637	19623	53	to	to	IN
18637	19623	54	ten	ten	CD
18637	19623	55	on	on	IN
18637	19623	56	each	each	DT
18637	19623	57	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	19623	58	instead	instead	RB
18637	19623	59	of	of	IN
18637	19623	60	the	the	DT
18637	19623	61	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	19623	62	customarily	customarily	RB
18637	19623	63	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	19623	64	at	at	IN
18637	19623	65	a	a	DT
18637	19623	66	trial	trial	NN
18637	19623	67	founded	found	VBN
18637	19623	68	upon	upon	IN
18637	19623	69	a	a	DT
18637	19623	70	single	single	JJ
18637	19623	71	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	19623	72	.	.	.
18637	19624	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19624	2	872	872	CD
18637	19624	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19624	4	Also	also	RB
18637	19624	5	,	,	,
18637	19624	6	a	a	DT
18637	19624	7	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19624	8	who	who	WP
18637	19624	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	19624	10	been	be	VBN
18637	19624	11	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	19624	12	by	by	IN
18637	19624	13	a	a	DT
18637	19624	14	special	special	JJ
18637	19624	15	,	,	,
18637	19624	16	or	or	CC
18637	19624	17	"	"	``
18637	19624	18	blue	blue	JJ
18637	19624	19	ribbon	ribbon	NN
18637	19624	20	,	,	,
18637	19624	21	"	"	``
18637	19624	22	jury	jury	NN
18637	19624	23	can	can	MD
18637	19624	24	not	not	RB
18637	19624	25	validly	validly	RB
18637	19624	26	contend	contend	VB
18637	19624	27	that	that	IN
18637	19624	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19624	29	was	be	VBD
18637	19624	30	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	19624	31	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19624	32	due	due	JJ
18637	19624	33	process	process	NN
18637	19624	34	of	of	IN
18637	19624	35	law	law	NN
18637	19624	36	.	.	.
18637	19625	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19625	2	873	873	CD
18637	19625	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19625	4	In	in	IN
18637	19625	5	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	19625	6	that	that	IN
18637	19625	7	the	the	DT
18637	19625	8	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19625	9	had	have	VBD
18637	19625	10	failed	fail	VBN
18637	19625	11	to	to	TO
18637	19625	12	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	19625	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19625	14	contention	contention	NN
18637	19625	15	that	that	IN
18637	19625	16	such	such	PDT
18637	19625	17	a	a	DT
18637	19625	18	jury	jury	NN
18637	19625	19	was	be	VBD
18637	19625	20	defective	defective	JJ
18637	19625	21	as	as	IN
18637	19625	22	to	to	IN
18637	19625	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19625	24	composition	composition	NN
18637	19625	25	,	,	,
18637	19625	26	the	the	DT
18637	19625	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19625	28	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	19625	29	that	that	IN
18637	19625	30	"	"	``
18637	19625	31	a	a	DT
18637	19625	32	system	system	NN
18637	19625	33	of	of	IN
18637	19625	34	exclusions	exclusion	NNS
18637	19625	35	could	could	MD
18637	19625	36	be	be	VB
18637	19625	37	so	so	RB
18637	19625	38	manipulated	manipulate	VBN
18637	19625	39	as	as	IN
18637	19625	40	to	to	TO
18637	19625	41	call	call	VB
18637	19625	42	a	a	DT
18637	19625	43	jury	jury	NN
18637	19625	44	before	before	IN
18637	19625	45	which	which	WDT
18637	19625	46	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	19625	47	would	would	MD
18637	19625	48	have	have	VB
18637	19625	49	so	so	RB
18637	19625	50	little	little	JJ
18637	19625	51	chance	chance	NN
18637	19625	52	of	of	IN
18637	19625	53	a	a	DT
18637	19625	54	decision	decision	NN
18637	19625	55	on	on	IN
18637	19625	56	the	the	DT
18637	19625	57	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19625	58	that	that	IN
18637	19625	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19625	60	would	would	MD
18637	19625	61	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	19625	62	a	a	DT
18637	19625	63	denial	denial	NN
18637	19625	64	of	of	IN
18637	19625	65	due	due	JJ
18637	19625	66	process	process	NN
18637	19625	67	"	"	''
18637	19625	68	and	and	CC
18637	19625	69	would	would	MD
18637	19625	70	result	result	VB
18637	19625	71	in	in	IN
18637	19625	72	a	a	DT
18637	19625	73	trial	trial	NN
18637	19625	74	which	which	WDT
18637	19625	75	was	be	VBD
18637	19625	76	a	a	DT
18637	19625	77	"	"	``
18637	19625	78	sham	sham	NN
18637	19625	79	or	or	CC
18637	19625	80	pretense	pretense	JJ
18637	19625	81	.	.	.
18637	19625	82	"	"	''
18637	19626	1	A	a	DT
18637	19626	2	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19626	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	19626	4	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19626	5	entitled	entitled	JJ
18637	19626	6	,	,	,
18637	19626	7	however	however	RB
18637	19626	8	,	,	,
18637	19626	9	to	to	IN
18637	19626	10	no	no	DT
18637	19626	11	more	more	JJR
18637	19626	12	than	than	IN
18637	19626	13	"	"	``
18637	19626	14	a	a	DT
18637	19626	15	neutral	neutral	JJ
18637	19626	16	jury	jury	NN
18637	19626	17	"	"	''
18637	19626	18	and	and	CC
18637	19626	19	"	"	``
18637	19626	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	19626	21	no	no	DT
18637	19626	22	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19626	23	right	right	NN
18637	19626	24	to	to	IN
18637	19626	25	friends	friend	NNS
18637	19626	26	on	on	IN
18637	19626	27	the	the	DT
18637	19626	28	jury	jury	NN
18637	19626	29	.	.	.
18637	19627	1	"	"	``
18637	19627	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19627	3	874	874	CD
18637	19627	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19627	5	In	in	IN
18637	19627	6	fact	fact	NN
18637	19627	7	,	,	,
18637	19627	8	the	the	DT
18637	19627	9	due	due	JJ
18637	19627	10	process	process	NN
18637	19627	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	19627	12	does	do	VBZ
18637	19627	13	not	not	RB
18637	19627	14	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	19627	15	a	a	DT
18637	19627	16	State	state	NN
18637	19627	17	from	from	IN
18637	19627	18	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	19627	19	from	from	IN
18637	19627	20	the	the	DT
18637	19627	21	jury	jury	NN
18637	19627	22	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19627	23	occupational	occupational	JJ
18637	19627	24	groups	group	NNS
18637	19627	25	such	such	JJ
18637	19627	26	as	as	IN
18637	19627	27	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
18637	19627	28	,	,	,
18637	19627	29	preachers	preacher	NNS
18637	19627	30	,	,	,
18637	19627	31	doctors	doctor	NNS
18637	19627	32	,	,	,
18637	19627	33	dentists	dentist	NNS
18637	19627	34	,	,	,
18637	19627	35	and	and	CC
18637	19627	36	enginemen	engineman	NNS
18637	19627	37	and	and	CC
18637	19627	38	firemen	fireman	NNS
18637	19627	39	of	of	IN
18637	19627	40	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19627	41	trains	train	NNS
18637	19627	42	.	.	.
18637	19628	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	19628	2	exclusions	exclusion	NNS
18637	19628	3	may	may	MD
18637	19628	4	be	be	VB
18637	19628	5	justified	justify	VBN
18637	19628	6	on	on	IN
18637	19628	7	the	the	DT
18637	19628	8	ground	ground	NN
18637	19628	9	that	that	IN
18637	19628	10	the	the	DT
18637	19628	11	continued	continue	VBN
18637	19628	12	attention	attention	NN
18637	19628	13	to	to	IN
18637	19628	14	duty	duty	NN
18637	19628	15	by	by	IN
18637	19628	16	members	member	NNS
18637	19628	17	of	of	IN
18637	19628	18	such	such	JJ
18637	19628	19	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	19628	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	19628	21	beneficial	beneficial	JJ
18637	19628	22	to	to	IN
18637	19628	23	the	the	DT
18637	19628	24	community	community	NN
18637	19628	25	.	.	.
18637	19629	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19629	2	875	875	CD
18637	19629	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19629	4	Self	Self	NNP
18637	19629	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	19629	6	Incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	19629	7	--	--	:
18637	19629	8	Forced	force	VBD
18637	19629	9	Confessions	Confessions	NNPS
18637	19629	10	In	in	IN
18637	19629	11	1908	1908	CD
18637	19629	12	,	,	,
18637	19629	13	in	in	IN
18637	19629	14	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	19629	15	_	_	NNP
18637	19629	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	19629	17	_	_	NNP
18637	19629	18	New	New	NNP
18637	19629	19	Jersey,[876	Jersey,[876	NNP
18637	19629	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19629	21	the	the	DT
18637	19629	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19629	23	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	19629	24	that	that	IN
18637	19629	25	neither	neither	CC
18637	19629	26	the	the	DT
18637	19629	27	historical	historical	JJ
18637	19629	28	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	19629	29	nor	nor	CC
18637	19629	30	the	the	DT
18637	19629	31	current	current	JJ
18637	19629	32	definition	definition	NN
18637	19629	33	of	of	IN
18637	19629	34	the	the	DT
18637	19629	35	due	due	JJ
18637	19629	36	process	process	NN
18637	19629	37	clause	clause	NN
18637	19629	38	of	of	IN
18637	19629	39	the	the	DT
18637	19629	40	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19629	41	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19629	42	included	include	VBD
18637	19629	43	protection	protection	NN
18637	19629	44	against	against	IN
18637	19629	45	self	self	NN
18637	19629	46	-	-	HYPH
18637	19629	47	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	19629	48	,	,	,
18637	19629	49	which	which	WDT
18637	19629	50	was	be	VBD
18637	19629	51	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19629	52	as	as	IN
18637	19629	53	unworthy	unworthy	JJ
18637	19629	54	of	of	IN
18637	19629	55	being	be	VBG
18637	19629	56	rated	rate	VBN
18637	19629	57	"	"	''
18637	19629	58	an	an	DT
18637	19629	59	immutable	immutable	JJ
18637	19629	60	principle	principle	NN
18637	19629	61	of	of	IN
18637	19629	62	justice	justice	NN
18637	19629	63	"	"	''
18637	19629	64	or	or	CC
18637	19629	65	as	as	IN
18637	19629	66	a	a	DT
18637	19629	67	"	"	``
18637	19629	68	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19629	69	right	right	NN
18637	19629	70	.	.	.
18637	19629	71	"	"	''
18637	19630	1	The	the	DT
18637	19630	2	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	19630	3	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19630	4	embodying	embody	VBG
18637	19630	5	this	this	DT
18637	19630	6	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19630	7	was	be	VBD
18637	19630	8	held	hold	VBN
18637	19630	9	to	to	TO
18637	19630	10	operate	operate	VB
18637	19630	11	to	to	TO
18637	19630	12	restrain	restrain	VB
18637	19630	13	only	only	RB
18637	19630	14	the	the	DT
18637	19630	15	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	19630	16	Government	Government	NNP
18637	19630	17	;	;	:
18637	19630	18	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	19630	19	the	the	DT
18637	19630	20	due	due	JJ
18637	19630	21	process	process	NN
18637	19630	22	clause	clause	NN
18637	19630	23	of	of	IN
18637	19630	24	the	the	DT
18637	19630	25	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19630	26	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19630	27	was	be	VBD
18637	19630	28	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19630	29	to	to	TO
18637	19630	30	permit	permit	VB
18637	19630	31	a	a	DT
18637	19630	32	State	state	NN
18637	19630	33	even	even	RB
18637	19630	34	to	to	TO
18637	19630	35	go	go	VB
18637	19630	36	so	so	RB
18637	19630	37	far	far	RB
18637	19630	38	as	as	IN
18637	19630	39	to	to	TO
18637	19630	40	substitute	substitute	VB
18637	19630	41	the	the	DT
18637	19630	42	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19630	43	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19630	44	of	of	IN
18637	19630	45	the	the	DT
18637	19630	46	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	19630	47	Law	Law	NNP
18637	19630	48	,	,	,
18637	19630	49	in	in	IN
18637	19630	50	which	which	WDT
18637	19630	51	the	the	DT
18637	19630	52	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19630	53	against	against	IN
18637	19630	54	self	self	NN
18637	19630	55	-	-	HYPH
18637	19630	56	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	19630	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	19630	58	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	19630	59	,	,	,
18637	19630	60	for	for	IN
18637	19630	61	that	that	DT
18637	19630	62	of	of	IN
18637	19630	63	the	the	DT
18637	19630	64	Common	Common	NNP
18637	19630	65	Law	Law	NNP
18637	19630	66	.	.	.
18637	19631	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19631	2	,	,	,
18637	19631	3	New	New	NNP
18637	19631	4	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	19631	5	was	be	VBD
18637	19631	6	within	within	IN
18637	19631	7	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19631	8	rights	right	NNS
18637	19631	9	in	in	IN
18637	19631	10	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	19631	11	a	a	DT
18637	19631	12	trial	trial	NN
18637	19631	13	judge	judge	NN
18637	19631	14	,	,	,
18637	19631	15	in	in	IN
18637	19631	16	a	a	DT
18637	19631	17	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19631	18	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19631	19	,	,	,
18637	19631	20	to	to	TO
18637	19631	21	instruct	instruct	VB
18637	19631	22	a	a	DT
18637	19631	23	jury	jury	NN
18637	19631	24	that	that	IN
18637	19631	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19631	26	might	may	MD
18637	19631	27	draw	draw	VB
18637	19631	28	an	an	DT
18637	19631	29	unfavorable	unfavorable	JJ
18637	19631	30	inference	inference	NN
18637	19631	31	from	from	IN
18637	19631	32	the	the	DT
18637	19631	33	failure	failure	NN
18637	19631	34	of	of	IN
18637	19631	35	a	a	DT
18637	19631	36	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19631	37	to	to	TO
18637	19631	38	comment	comment	VB
18637	19631	39	on	on	IN
18637	19631	40	the	the	DT
18637	19631	41	prosecutor	prosecutor	NN
18637	19631	42	's	's	POS
18637	19631	43	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19631	44	.	.	.
18637	19632	1	Apart	apart	RB
18637	19632	2	from	from	IN
18637	19632	3	a	a	DT
18637	19632	4	recent	recent	JJ
18637	19632	5	ineffectual	ineffectual	JJ
18637	19632	6	effort	effort	NN
18637	19632	7	of	of	IN
18637	19632	8	a	a	DT
18637	19632	9	minority	minority	NN
18637	19632	10	of	of	IN
18637	19632	11	the	the	DT
18637	19632	12	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19632	13	to	to	TO
18637	19632	14	challenge	challenge	VB
18637	19632	15	the	the	DT
18637	19632	16	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	19632	17	thus	thus	RB
18637	19632	18	placed	place	VBN
18637	19632	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	19632	20	the	the	DT
18637	19632	21	due	due	JJ
18637	19632	22	process	process	NN
18637	19632	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	19632	24	of	of	IN
18637	19632	25	the	the	DT
18637	19632	26	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19632	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19632	28	,	,	,
18637	19632	29	the	the	DT
18637	19632	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19632	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	19632	32	yet	yet	RB
18637	19632	33	to	to	TO
18637	19632	34	register	register	VB
18637	19632	35	any	any	DT
18637	19632	36	departure	departure	NN
18637	19632	37	from	from	IN
18637	19632	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19632	39	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	19632	40	in	in	IN
18637	19632	41	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	19632	42	_	_	NNP
18637	19632	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	19632	44	_	_	NNP
18637	19632	45	New	New	NNP
18637	19632	46	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	19632	47	.	.	.
18637	19633	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19633	2	877	877	CD
18637	19633	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19633	4	In	in	IN
18637	19633	5	two	two	CD
18637	19633	6	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	19633	7	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	19633	8	the	the	DT
18637	19633	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19633	10	reasserted	reassert	VBD
18637	19633	11	_	_	NNP
18637	19633	12	obiter	obiter	NN
18637	19633	13	_	_	NNP
18637	19633	14	that	that	IN
18637	19633	15	"	"	``
18637	19633	16	the	the	DT
18637	19633	17	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19633	18	against	against	IN
18637	19633	19	self	self	NN
18637	19633	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	19633	21	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	19633	22	may	may	MD
18637	19633	23	be	be	VB
18637	19633	24	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	19633	25	and	and	CC
18637	19633	26	the	the	DT
18637	19633	27	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19633	28	put	put	VBN
18637	19633	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	19633	30	the	the	DT
18637	19633	31	stand	stand	NN
18637	19633	32	as	as	IN
18637	19633	33	a	a	DT
18637	19633	34	witness	witness	NN
18637	19633	35	for	for	IN
18637	19633	36	the	the	DT
18637	19633	37	State	State	NNP
18637	19633	38	.	.	.
18637	19633	39	"	"	''
18637	19634	1	No	no	DT
18637	19634	2	"	"	``
18637	19634	3	principle	principle	NN
18637	19634	4	of	of	IN
18637	19634	5	justice	justice	NN
18637	19634	6	so	so	RB
18637	19634	7	rooted	root	VBN
18637	19634	8	in	in	IN
18637	19634	9	the	the	DT
18637	19634	10	traditions	tradition	NNS
18637	19634	11	and	and	CC
18637	19634	12	conscience	conscience	NN
18637	19634	13	of	of	IN
18637	19634	14	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19634	15	people	people	NNS
18637	19634	16	as	as	IN
18637	19634	17	to	to	TO
18637	19634	18	be	be	VB
18637	19634	19	ranked	rank	VBN
18637	19634	20	as	as	IN
18637	19634	21	fundamental"[878	fundamental"[878	NN
18637	19634	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19634	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	19634	24	violated	violate	VBN
18637	19634	25	by	by	IN
18637	19634	26	abolition	abolition	NN
18637	19634	27	of	of	IN
18637	19634	28	such	such	JJ
18637	19634	29	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19634	30	;	;	:
18637	19634	31	nor	nor	CC
18637	19634	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	19634	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19634	34	complete	complete	JJ
18637	19634	35	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	19634	36	likely	likely	JJ
18637	19634	37	to	to	TO
18637	19634	38	outrage	outrage	VB
18637	19634	39	students	student	NNS
18637	19634	40	of	of	IN
18637	19634	41	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19634	42	penal	penal	JJ
18637	19634	43	system	system	NN
18637	19634	44	,	,	,
18637	19634	45	many	many	DT
18637	19634	46	of	of	IN
18637	19634	47	whom	whom	WP
18637	19634	48	"	"	``
18637	19634	49	look	look	VBP
18637	19634	50	upon	upon	IN
18637	19634	51	*	*	NFP
18637	19634	52	*	*	NFP
18637	19634	53	*	*	NFP
18637	19634	54	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19634	55	this	this	DT
18637	19634	56	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19634	57	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	19634	58	as	as	IN
18637	19634	59	a	a	DT
18637	19634	60	mischief	mischief	NN
18637	19634	61	rather	rather	RB
18637	19634	62	than	than	IN
18637	19634	63	a	a	DT
18637	19634	64	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19634	65	,	,	,
18637	19634	66	*	*	NFP
18637	19634	67	*	*	NFP
18637	19634	68	*	*	NFP
18637	19634	69	"	"	''
18637	19634	70	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19634	71	879	879	CD
18637	19634	72	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19634	73	In	in	IN
18637	19634	74	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	19634	75	disposing	dispose	VBG
18637	19634	76	of	of	IN
18637	19634	77	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19634	78	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	19634	79	State	State	NNP
18637	19634	80	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19634	81	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19634	82	,	,	,
18637	19634	83	the	the	DT
18637	19634	84	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19634	85	has	have	VBZ
18637	19634	86	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19634	87	almost	almost	RB
18637	19634	88	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	19634	89	the	the	DT
18637	19634	90	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	19634	91	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	19634	92	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	19634	93	.	.	.
18637	19635	1	With	with	IN
18637	19635	2	only	only	JJ
18637	19635	3	casual	casual	JJ
18637	19635	4	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	19635	5	of	of	IN
18637	19635	6	the	the	DT
18637	19635	7	intention	intention	NN
18637	19635	8	of	of	IN
18637	19635	9	the	the	DT
18637	19635	10	framers	framer	NNS
18637	19635	11	of	of	IN
18637	19635	12	the	the	DT
18637	19635	13	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19635	14	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19635	15	,	,	,
18637	19635	16	or	or	CC
18637	19635	17	of	of	IN
18637	19635	18	the	the	DT
18637	19635	19	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	19635	20	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	19635	21	that	that	IN
18637	19635	22	the	the	DT
18637	19635	23	due	due	JJ
18637	19635	24	process	process	NN
18637	19635	25	clause	clause	NN
18637	19635	26	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	19635	27	had	have	VBD
18637	19635	28	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19635	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	19635	30	the	the	DT
18637	19635	31	States	States	NNP
18637	19635	32	all	all	PDT
18637	19635	33	the	the	DT
18637	19635	34	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	19635	35	which	which	WDT
18637	19635	36	the	the	DT
18637	19635	37	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	19635	38	of	of	IN
18637	19635	39	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	19635	40	had	have	VBD
18637	19635	41	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19635	42	upon	upon	IN
18637	19635	43	the	the	DT
18637	19635	44	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	19635	45	Government	Government	NNP
18637	19635	46	,	,	,
18637	19635	47	the	the	DT
18637	19635	48	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19635	49	has	have	VBZ
18637	19635	50	simply	simply	RB
18637	19635	51	endeavored	endeavor	VBN
18637	19635	52	to	to	TO
18637	19635	53	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	19635	54	whether	whether	IN
18637	19635	55	the	the	DT
18637	19635	56	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19635	57	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
18637	19635	58	all	all	PDT
18637	19635	59	the	the	DT
18637	19635	60	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	19635	61	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19635	62	to	to	IN
18637	19635	63	a	a	DT
18637	19635	64	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19635	65	trial	trial	NN
18637	19635	66	.	.	.
18637	19636	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19636	2	,	,	,
18637	19636	3	without	without	IN
18637	19636	4	even	even	RB
18637	19636	5	admitting	admit	VBG
18637	19636	6	that	that	IN
18637	19636	7	the	the	DT
18637	19636	8	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19636	9	against	against	IN
18637	19636	10	self	self	NN
18637	19636	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	19636	12	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	19636	13	was	be	VBD
18637	19636	14	involved	involve	VBN
18637	19636	15	,	,	,
18637	19636	16	all	all	PDT
18637	19636	17	the	the	DT
18637	19636	18	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19636	19	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	19636	20	,	,	,
18637	19636	21	in	in	IN
18637	19636	22	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	19636	23	_	_	NNP
18637	19636	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	19636	25	_	_	NNP
18637	19636	26	Mississippi,[880	Mississippi,[880	NNP
18637	19636	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19636	28	that	that	IN
18637	19636	29	the	the	DT
18637	19636	30	use	use	NN
18637	19636	31	of	of	IN
18637	19636	32	a	a	DT
18637	19636	33	confession	confession	NN
18637	19636	34	extorted	extort	VBN
18637	19636	35	by	by	IN
18637	19636	36	brutality	brutality	NN
18637	19636	37	and	and	CC
18637	19636	38	violence	violence	NN
18637	19636	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19636	40	undenied	undenie	VBN
18637	19636	41	strangulation	strangulation	NN
18637	19636	42	and	and	CC
18637	19636	43	whipping	whipping	NN
18637	19636	44	by	by	IN
18637	19636	45	the	the	DT
18637	19636	46	sheriff	sheriff	NN
18637	19636	47	aided	aid	VBN
18637	19636	48	by	by	IN
18637	19636	49	a	a	DT
18637	19636	50	mob	mob	NN
18637	19636	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19636	52	was	be	VBD
18637	19636	53	a	a	DT
18637	19636	54	denial	denial	NN
18637	19636	55	of	of	IN
18637	19636	56	due	due	JJ
18637	19636	57	process	process	NN
18637	19636	58	,	,	,
18637	19636	59	even	even	RB
18637	19636	60	though	though	IN
18637	19636	61	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	19636	62	was	be	VBD
18637	19636	63	not	not	RB
18637	19636	64	established	establish	VBN
18637	19636	65	until	until	IN
18637	19636	66	after	after	IN
18637	19636	67	the	the	DT
18637	19636	68	confession	confession	NN
18637	19636	69	had	have	VBD
18637	19636	70	been	be	VBN
18637	19636	71	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	19636	72	in	in	IN
18637	19636	73	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19636	74	and	and	CC
18637	19636	75	defense	defense	NN
18637	19636	76	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19636	77	did	do	VBD
18637	19636	78	not	not	RB
18637	19636	79	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	19636	80	move	move	VB
18637	19636	81	for	for	IN
18637	19636	82	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19636	83	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	19636	84	.	.	.
18637	19637	1	Although	although	IN
18637	19637	2	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	19637	3	processes	process	NNS
18637	19637	4	of	of	IN
18637	19637	5	justice	justice	NN
18637	19637	6	may	may	MD
18637	19637	7	be	be	VB
18637	19637	8	used	use	VBN
18637	19637	9	to	to	TO
18637	19637	10	call	call	VB
18637	19637	11	the	the	DT
18637	19637	12	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19637	13	as	as	IN
18637	19637	14	a	a	DT
18637	19637	15	witness	witness	NN
18637	19637	16	and	and	CC
18637	19637	17	to	to	TO
18637	19637	18	require	require	VB
18637	19637	19	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19637	20	to	to	TO
18637	19637	21	testify	testify	VB
18637	19637	22	,	,	,
18637	19637	23	"	"	``
18637	19637	24	compulsion	compulsion	NN
18637	19637	25	by	by	IN
18637	19637	26	torture	torture	NN
18637	19637	27	to	to	TO
18637	19637	28	extort	extort	VB
18637	19637	29	a	a	DT
18637	19637	30	confession	confession	NN
18637	19637	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	19637	32	a	a	DT
18637	19637	33	different	different	JJ
18637	19637	34	matter	matter	NN
18637	19637	35	.	.	.
18637	19638	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19638	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19638	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19638	4	The	the	DT
18637	19638	5	rack	rack	NN
18637	19638	6	and	and	CC
18637	19638	7	torture	torture	NN
18637	19638	8	chamber	chamber	NN
18637	19638	9	may	may	MD
18637	19638	10	not	not	RB
18637	19638	11	be	be	VB
18637	19638	12	substituted	substitute	VBN
18637	19638	13	for	for	IN
18637	19638	14	the	the	DT
18637	19638	15	witness	witness	NN
18637	19638	16	stand	stand	NN
18637	19638	17	.	.	.
18637	19639	1	"	"	``
18637	19639	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19639	3	881	881	CD
18637	19639	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19639	5	Again	again	RB
18637	19639	6	,	,	,
18637	19639	7	in	in	IN
18637	19639	8	Chambers	Chambers	NNP
18637	19639	9	_	_	NNP
18637	19639	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	19639	11	_	_	NNP
18637	19639	12	Florida[882	Florida[882	NNP
18637	19639	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19639	14	the	the	DT
18637	19639	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19639	16	,	,	,
18637	19639	17	with	with	IN
18637	19639	18	no	no	DT
18637	19639	19	mention	mention	NN
18637	19639	20	of	of	IN
18637	19639	21	the	the	DT
18637	19639	22	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19639	23	against	against	IN
18637	19639	24	self	self	NN
18637	19639	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	19639	26	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	19639	27	,	,	,
18637	19639	28	proclaimed	proclaim	VBD
18637	19639	29	that	that	IN
18637	19639	30	due	due	JJ
18637	19639	31	process	process	NN
18637	19639	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	19639	33	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19639	34	when	when	WRB
18637	19639	35	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	19639	36	of	of	IN
18637	19639	37	murder	murder	NN
18637	19639	38	are	be	VBP
18637	19639	39	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19639	40	in	in	IN
18637	19639	41	State	State	NNP
18637	19639	42	courts	court	NNS
18637	19639	43	by	by	IN
18637	19639	44	the	the	DT
18637	19639	45	use	use	NN
18637	19639	46	of	of	IN
18637	19639	47	confessions	confession	NNS
18637	19639	48	extorted	extort	VBN
18637	19639	49	under	under	IN
18637	19639	50	the	the	DT
18637	19639	51	following	following	JJ
18637	19639	52	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19639	53	:	:	:
18637	19639	54	dragnet	dragnet	NN
18637	19639	55	methods	method	NNS
18637	19639	56	of	of	IN
18637	19639	57	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	19639	58	on	on	IN
18637	19639	59	suspicion	suspicion	NN
18637	19639	60	without	without	IN
18637	19639	61	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	19639	62	and	and	CC
18637	19639	63	protracted	protracted	JJ
18637	19639	64	questioning	questioning	NN
18637	19639	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19639	66	on	on	IN
18637	19639	67	the	the	DT
18637	19639	68	last	last	JJ
18637	19639	69	day	day	NN
18637	19639	70	,	,	,
18637	19639	71	from	from	IN
18637	19639	72	noon	noon	NN
18637	19639	73	until	until	IN
18637	19639	74	sunset	sunset	NN
18637	19639	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19639	76	in	in	IN
18637	19639	77	a	a	DT
18637	19639	78	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	19639	79	floor	floor	NN
18637	19639	80	jail	jail	NN
18637	19639	81	where	where	WRB
18637	19639	82	the	the	DT
18637	19639	83	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
18637	19639	84	were	be	VBD
18637	19639	85	without	without	IN
18637	19639	86	friends	friend	NNS
18637	19639	87	or	or	CC
18637	19639	88	counselors	counselor	NNS
18637	19639	89	,	,	,
18637	19639	90	and	and	CC
18637	19639	91	under	under	IN
18637	19639	92	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19639	93	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	19639	94	to	to	TO
18637	19639	95	break	break	VB
18637	19639	96	the	the	DT
18637	19639	97	strongest	strong	JJS
18637	19639	98	nerves	nerve	NNS
18637	19639	99	and	and	CC
18637	19639	100	stoutest	stout	JJS
18637	19639	101	resistance	resistance	NN
18637	19639	102	.	.	.
18637	19640	1	Affirming	affirm	VBG
18637	19640	2	that	that	IN
18637	19640	3	the	the	DT
18637	19640	4	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19640	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19640	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19640	7	not	not	RB
18637	19640	8	concluded	conclude	VBN
18637	19640	9	by	by	IN
18637	19640	10	the	the	DT
18637	19640	11	finding	finding	NN
18637	19640	12	of	of	IN
18637	19640	13	a	a	DT
18637	19640	14	jury	jury	NN
18637	19640	15	in	in	IN
18637	19640	16	a	a	DT
18637	19640	17	State	State	NNP
18637	19640	18	court	court	NN
18637	19640	19	that	that	IN
18637	19640	20	a	a	DT
18637	19640	21	confession	confession	NN
18637	19640	22	in	in	IN
18637	19640	23	a	a	DT
18637	19640	24	murder	murder	NN
18637	19640	25	trial	trial	NN
18637	19640	26	was	be	VBD
18637	19640	27	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	19640	28	,	,	,
18637	19640	29	but	but	CC
18637	19640	30	determines	determine	VBZ
18637	19640	31	that	that	IN
18637	19640	32	question	question	VBP
18637	19640	33	for	for	IN
18637	19640	34	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19640	35	from	from	IN
18637	19640	36	the	the	DT
18637	19640	37	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19640	38	,	,	,
18637	19640	39	the	the	DT
18637	19640	40	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19640	41	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	19640	42	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19640	43	that	that	IN
18637	19640	44	the	the	DT
18637	19640	45	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19640	46	proscribes	proscribe	VBZ
18637	19640	47	lawless	lawless	JJ
18637	19640	48	means	mean	NNS
18637	19640	49	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	19640	50	of	of	IN
18637	19640	51	the	the	DT
18637	19640	52	end	end	NN
18637	19640	53	,	,	,
18637	19640	54	and	and	CC
18637	19640	55	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	19640	56	the	the	DT
18637	19640	57	argument	argument	NN
18637	19640	58	that	that	IN
18637	19640	59	the	the	DT
18637	19640	60	thumbscrew	thumbscrew	NN
18637	19640	61	,	,	,
18637	19640	62	the	the	DT
18637	19640	63	wheel	wheel	NN
18637	19640	64	,	,	,
18637	19640	65	solitary	solitary	JJ
18637	19640	66	confinement	confinement	NN
18637	19640	67	,	,	,
18637	19640	68	protracted	protract	VBN
18637	19640	69	questioning	questioning	NN
18637	19640	70	,	,	,
18637	19640	71	and	and	CC
18637	19640	72	other	other	JJ
18637	19640	73	ingenious	ingenious	JJ
18637	19640	74	means	mean	NNS
18637	19640	75	of	of	IN
18637	19640	76	entrapment	entrapment	NN
18637	19640	77	are	be	VBP
18637	19640	78	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19640	79	to	to	TO
18637	19640	80	uphold	uphold	VB
18637	19640	81	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19640	82	laws	law	NNS
18637	19640	83	.	.	.
18637	19641	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19641	2	883	883	CD
18637	19641	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19641	4	Procuring	procure	VBG
18637	19641	5	a	a	DT
18637	19641	6	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19641	7	for	for	IN
18637	19641	8	a	a	DT
18637	19641	9	capital	capital	NN
18637	19641	10	crime	crime	NN
18637	19641	11	by	by	IN
18637	19641	12	use	use	NN
18637	19641	13	of	of	IN
18637	19641	14	a	a	DT
18637	19641	15	confession	confession	NN
18637	19641	16	extracted	extract	VBN
18637	19641	17	by	by	IN
18637	19641	18	protracted	protracted	JJ
18637	19641	19	interrogation	interrogation	NN
18637	19641	20	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	19641	21	in	in	IN
18637	19641	22	a	a	DT
18637	19641	23	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19641	24	manner	manner	NN
18637	19641	25	was	be	VBD
18637	19641	26	,	,	,
18637	19641	27	on	on	IN
18637	19641	28	the	the	DT
18637	19641	29	authority	authority	NN
18637	19641	30	of	of	IN
18637	19641	31	Chambers	Chambers	NNP
18637	19641	32	_	_	NNP
18637	19641	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	19641	34	_	_	NNP
18637	19641	35	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	19641	36	,	,	,
18637	19641	37	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	19641	38	in	in	IN
18637	19641	39	White	White	NNP
18637	19641	40	_	_	NNP
18637	19641	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	19641	42	_	_	NNP
18637	19641	43	Texas;[884	Texas;[884	NNP
18637	19641	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19641	45	and	and	CC
18637	19641	46	in	in	IN
18637	19641	47	Lisenba	Lisenba	NNP
18637	19641	48	_	_	NNP
18637	19641	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	19641	50	_	_	NNP
18637	19641	51	California,[885	California,[885	NNP
18637	19641	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19641	53	a	a	DT
18637	19641	54	case	case	NN
18637	19641	55	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19641	56	inconclusive	inconclusive	JJ
18637	19641	57	by	by	IN
18637	19641	58	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	19641	59	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19641	60	,	,	,
18637	19641	61	the	the	DT
18637	19641	62	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19641	63	remarked	remark	VBD
18637	19641	64	,	,	,
18637	19641	65	by	by	IN
18637	19641	66	way	way	NN
18637	19641	67	of	of	IN
18637	19641	68	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	19641	69	,	,	,
18637	19641	70	that	that	IN
18637	19641	71	"	"	``
18637	19641	72	the	the	DT
18637	19641	73	concept	concept	NN
18637	19641	74	of	of	IN
18637	19641	75	due	due	JJ
18637	19641	76	process	process	NN
18637	19641	77	would	would	MD
18637	19641	78	void	void	VB
18637	19641	79	a	a	DT
18637	19641	80	trial	trial	NN
18637	19641	81	in	in	IN
18637	19641	82	which	which	WDT
18637	19641	83	,	,	,
18637	19641	84	by	by	IN
18637	19641	85	threats	threat	NNS
18637	19641	86	or	or	CC
18637	19641	87	promises	promise	NNS
18637	19641	88	in	in	IN
18637	19641	89	the	the	DT
18637	19641	90	presence	presence	NN
18637	19641	91	of	of	IN
18637	19641	92	court	court	NN
18637	19641	93	and	and	CC
18637	19641	94	jury	jury	NN
18637	19641	95	,	,	,
18637	19641	96	a	a	DT
18637	19641	97	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19641	98	was	be	VBD
18637	19641	99	induced	induce	VBN
18637	19641	100	to	to	TO
18637	19641	101	testify	testify	VB
18637	19641	102	against	against	IN
18637	19641	103	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19641	104	,	,	,
18637	19641	105	"	"	''
18637	19641	106	or	or	CC
18637	19641	107	in	in	IN
18637	19641	108	which	which	WDT
18637	19641	109	a	a	DT
18637	19641	110	confession	confession	NN
18637	19641	111	is	be	VBZ
18637	19641	112	used	use	VBN
18637	19641	113	which	which	WDT
18637	19641	114	is	be	VBZ
18637	19641	115	"	"	``
18637	19641	116	procured	procured	JJ
18637	19641	117	*	*	NFP
18637	19641	118	*	*	NFP
18637	19641	119	*	*	NFP
18637	19641	120	by	by	IN
18637	19641	121	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	19641	122	,	,	,
18637	19641	123	collusion	collusion	NN
18637	19641	124	,	,	,
18637	19641	125	trickery	trickery	NN
18637	19641	126	and	and	CC
18637	19641	127	subornation	subornation	NN
18637	19641	128	or	or	CC
18637	19641	129	perjury	perjury	NN
18637	19641	130	.	.	.
18637	19641	131	"	"	''
18637	19642	1	In	in	IN
18637	19642	2	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	19642	3	with	with	IN
18637	19642	4	these	these	DT
18637	19642	5	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	19642	6	,	,	,
18637	19642	7	the	the	DT
18637	19642	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19642	9	,	,	,
18637	19642	10	in	in	IN
18637	19642	11	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	19642	12	_	_	NNP
18637	19642	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	19642	14	_	_	NNP
18637	19642	15	Texas,[886	Texas,[886	NNP
18637	19642	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19642	17	set	set	VBN
18637	19642	18	aside	aside	RP
18637	19642	19	a	a	DT
18637	19642	20	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19642	21	based	base	VBN
18637	19642	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	19642	23	a	a	DT
18637	19642	24	confession	confession	NN
18637	19642	25	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19642	26	,	,	,
18637	19642	27	by	by	IN
18637	19642	28	methods	method	NNS
18637	19642	29	of	of	IN
18637	19642	30	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	19642	31	and	and	CC
18637	19642	32	duress	duress	NN
18637	19642	33	,	,	,
18637	19642	34	from	from	IN
18637	19642	35	a	a	DT
18637	19642	36	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19642	37	who	who	WP
18637	19642	38	had	have	VBD
18637	19642	39	been	be	VBN
18637	19642	40	arrested	arrest	VBN
18637	19642	41	illegally	illegally	RB
18637	19642	42	,	,	,
18637	19642	43	without	without	IN
18637	19642	44	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	19642	45	,	,	,
18637	19642	46	by	by	IN
18637	19642	47	the	the	DT
18637	19642	48	sheriff	sheriff	NN
18637	19642	49	of	of	IN
18637	19642	50	another	another	DT
18637	19642	51	county	county	NN
18637	19642	52	,	,	,
18637	19642	53	and	and	CC
18637	19642	54	removed	remove	VBD
18637	19642	55	to	to	IN
18637	19642	56	a	a	DT
18637	19642	57	county	county	NN
18637	19642	58	more	more	JJR
18637	19642	59	than	than	IN
18637	19642	60	a	a	DT
18637	19642	61	hundred	hundred	CD
18637	19642	62	miles	mile	NNS
18637	19642	63	away	away	RB
18637	19642	64	,	,	,
18637	19642	65	and	and	CC
18637	19642	66	who	who	WP
18637	19642	67	for	for	IN
18637	19642	68	three	three	CD
18637	19642	69	days	day	NNS
18637	19642	70	,	,	,
18637	19642	71	while	while	IN
18637	19642	72	being	be	VBG
18637	19642	73	driven	drive	VBN
18637	19642	74	from	from	IN
18637	19642	75	county	county	NN
18637	19642	76	to	to	IN
18637	19642	77	county	county	NNP
18637	19642	78	,	,	,
18637	19642	79	was	be	VBD
18637	19642	80	questioned	question	VBN
18637	19642	81	continuously	continuously	RB
18637	19642	82	by	by	IN
18637	19642	83	various	various	JJ
18637	19642	84	officers	officer	NNS
18637	19642	85	and	and	CC
18637	19642	86	falsely	falsely	RB
18637	19642	87	informed	inform	VBN
18637	19642	88	by	by	IN
18637	19642	89	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19642	90	of	of	IN
18637	19642	91	threats	threat	NNS
18637	19642	92	of	of	IN
18637	19642	93	mob	mob	NN
18637	19642	94	violence	violence	NN
18637	19642	95	.	.	.
18637	19643	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19643	2	,	,	,
18637	19643	3	in	in	IN
18637	19643	4	Ashcraft	Ashcraft	NNP
18637	19643	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19643	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	19643	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19643	8	Tennessee,[887	Tennessee,[887	NNP
18637	19643	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19643	10	the	the	DT
18637	19643	11	use	use	NN
18637	19643	12	in	in	IN
18637	19643	13	a	a	DT
18637	19643	14	State	State	NNP
18637	19643	15	court	court	NN
18637	19643	16	of	of	IN
18637	19643	17	a	a	DT
18637	19643	18	confession	confession	NN
18637	19643	19	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19643	20	near	near	IN
18637	19643	21	the	the	DT
18637	19643	22	end	end	NN
18637	19643	23	of	of	IN
18637	19643	24	a	a	DT
18637	19643	25	36-hour	36-hour	CD
18637	19643	26	period	period	NN
18637	19643	27	of	of	IN
18637	19643	28	practically	practically	RB
18637	19643	29	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	19643	30	questioning	questioning	NN
18637	19643	31	,	,	,
18637	19643	32	under	under	IN
18637	19643	33	powerful	powerful	JJ
18637	19643	34	electric	electric	JJ
18637	19643	35	lights	light	NNS
18637	19643	36	,	,	,
18637	19643	37	by	by	IN
18637	19643	38	relays	relay	NNS
18637	19643	39	of	of	IN
18637	19643	40	officers	officer	NNS
18637	19643	41	,	,	,
18637	19643	42	experienced	experienced	JJ
18637	19643	43	investigators	investigator	NNS
18637	19643	44	,	,	,
18637	19643	45	and	and	CC
18637	19643	46	highly	highly	RB
18637	19643	47	trained	train	VBN
18637	19643	48	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
18637	19643	49	was	be	VBD
18637	19643	50	held	hold	VBN
18637	19643	51	to	to	TO
18637	19643	52	be	be	VB
18637	19643	53	violative	violative	JJ
18637	19643	54	of	of	IN
18637	19643	55	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19643	56	right	right	NN
18637	19643	57	by	by	IN
18637	19643	58	reason	reason	NN
18637	19643	59	of	of	IN
18637	19643	60	the	the	DT
18637	19643	61	inherently	inherently	RB
18637	19643	62	coercive	coercive	JJ
18637	19643	63	character	character	NN
18637	19643	64	of	of	IN
18637	19643	65	such	such	JJ
18637	19643	66	interrogation	interrogation	NN
18637	19643	67	.	.	.
18637	19644	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19644	2	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	19644	3	,	,	,
18637	19644	4	joined	join	VBN
18637	19644	5	by	by	IN
18637	19644	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19644	7	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	19644	8	and	and	CC
18637	19644	9	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	19644	10	,	,	,
18637	19644	11	dissented	dissent	VBN
18637	19644	12	on	on	IN
18637	19644	13	the	the	DT
18637	19644	14	ground	ground	NN
18637	19644	15	that	that	IN
18637	19644	16	the	the	DT
18637	19644	17	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19644	18	not	not	RB
18637	19644	19	only	only	RB
18637	19644	20	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19644	21	that	that	IN
18637	19644	22	the	the	DT
18637	19644	23	protracted	protract	VBN
18637	19644	24	questioning	questioning	NN
18637	19644	25	"	"	''
18637	19644	26	had	have	VBD
18637	19644	27	the	the	DT
18637	19644	28	effect	effect	NN
18637	19644	29	of	of	IN
18637	19644	30	forcing	force	VBG
18637	19644	31	an	an	DT
18637	19644	32	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	19644	33	confession	confession	NN
18637	19644	34	from	from	IN
18637	19644	35	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19644	36	"	"	''
18637	19644	37	but	but	CC
18637	19644	38	that	that	IN
18637	19644	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19644	40	had	have	VBD
18637	19644	41	ever	ever	RB
18637	19644	42	confessed	confess	VBN
18637	19644	43	at	at	RB
18637	19644	44	all	all	RB
18637	19644	45	,	,	,
18637	19644	46	a	a	DT
18637	19644	47	contention	contention	NN
18637	19644	48	which	which	WDT
18637	19644	49	reputable	reputable	JJ
18637	19644	50	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	19644	51	contradicted	contradict	VBN
18637	19644	52	.	.	.
18637	19645	1	Referring	refer	VBG
18637	19645	2	to	to	IN
18637	19645	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19645	4	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	19645	5	's	's	POS
18637	19645	6	warning	warning	NN
18637	19645	7	against	against	IN
18637	19645	8	"	"	``
18637	19645	9	the	the	DT
18637	19645	10	ever	ever	RB
18637	19645	11	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	19645	12	scope	scope	NN
18637	19645	13	given	give	VBN
18637	19645	14	to	to	IN
18637	19645	15	the	the	DT
18637	19645	16	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19645	17	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19645	18	in	in	IN
18637	19645	19	cutting	cut	VBG
18637	19645	20	down	down	RP
18637	19645	21	*	*	NFP
18637	19645	22	*	*	NFP
18637	19645	23	*	*	NFP
18637	19645	24	the	the	DT
18637	19645	25	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19645	26	rights	right	NNS
18637	19645	27	of	of	IN
18637	19645	28	the	the	DT
18637	19645	29	States	States	NNP
18637	19645	30	.	.	.
18637	19646	1	"	"	``
18637	19646	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19646	3	888	888	CD
18637	19646	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19646	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19646	6	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	19646	7	protested	protest	VBD
18637	19646	8	that	that	IN
18637	19646	9	"	"	``
18637	19646	10	interrogation	interrogation	NN
18637	19646	11	_	_	NNP
18637	19646	12	per	per	FW
18637	19646	13	se	se	FW
18637	19646	14	_	_	NNP
18637	19646	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	19646	16	not	not	RB
18637	19646	17	,	,	,
18637	19646	18	*	*	NFP
18637	19646	19	*	*	NFP
18637	19646	20	*	*	NFP
18637	19646	21	,	,	,
18637	19646	22	an	an	DT
18637	19646	23	outlaw	outlaw	NN
18637	19646	24	"	"	''
18637	19646	25	;	;	:
18637	19646	26	and	and	CC
18637	19646	27	that	that	DT
18637	19646	28	inasmuch	inasmuch	VBP
18637	19646	29	as	as	IN
18637	19646	30	all	all	DT
18637	19646	31	questioning	questioning	NN
18637	19646	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	19646	33	"	"	``
18637	19646	34	'	'	``
18637	19646	35	inherently	inherently	RB
18637	19646	36	coercive	coercive	JJ
18637	19646	37	'	'	''
18637	19646	38	*	*	NFP
18637	19646	39	*	*	NFP
18637	19646	40	*	*	NFP
18637	19646	41	,	,	,
18637	19646	42	the	the	DT
18637	19646	43	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	19646	44	question	question	NN
18637	19646	45	*	*	NFP
18637	19646	46	*	*	NFP
18637	19646	47	*	*	NFP
18637	19646	48	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19646	49	must	must	MD
18637	19646	50	be	be	VB
18637	19646	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19646	52	whether	whether	IN
18637	19646	53	the	the	DT
18637	19646	54	confessor	confessor	NN
18637	19646	55	was	be	VBD
18637	19646	56	in	in	IN
18637	19646	57	possession	possession	NN
18637	19646	58	of	of	IN
18637	19646	59	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19646	60	own	own	JJ
18637	19646	61	will	will	NN
18637	19646	62	and	and	CC
18637	19646	63	self	self	NN
18637	19646	64	-	-	HYPH
18637	19646	65	control	control	NN
18637	19646	66	at	at	IN
18637	19646	67	the	the	DT
18637	19646	68	time	time	NN
18637	19646	69	of	of	IN
18637	19646	70	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19646	71	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19646	72	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19646	73	confession	confession	NN
18637	19646	74	.	.	.
18637	19647	1	"	"	``
18637	19647	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19647	3	889	889	CD
18637	19647	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19647	5	This	this	DT
18637	19647	6	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	19647	7	was	be	VBD
18637	19647	8	not	not	RB
18637	19647	9	without	without	IN
18637	19647	10	effect	effect	NN
18637	19647	11	.	.	.
18637	19648	1	In	in	IN
18637	19648	2	June	June	NNP
18637	19648	3	1944	1944	CD
18637	19648	4	,	,	,
18637	19648	5	in	in	IN
18637	19648	6	Lyons	Lyons	NNP
18637	19648	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19648	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	19648	9	_	_	NNP
18637	19648	10	Oklahoma,[890	Oklahoma,[890	NNP
18637	19648	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19648	12	the	the	DT
18637	19648	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19648	14	finally	finally	RB
18637	19648	15	handed	hand	VBD
18637	19648	16	down	down	RP
18637	19648	17	a	a	DT
18637	19648	18	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	19648	19	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	19648	20	definitely	definitely	RB
18637	19648	21	to	to	TO
18637	19648	22	arrest	arrest	VB
18637	19648	23	the	the	DT
18637	19648	24	suspicion	suspicion	NN
18637	19648	25	that	that	WDT
18637	19648	26	had	have	VBD
18637	19648	27	been	be	VBN
18637	19648	28	developing	develop	VBG
18637	19648	29	that	that	IN
18637	19648	30	the	the	DT
18637	19648	31	use	use	NN
18637	19648	32	of	of	IN
18637	19648	33	any	any	DT
18637	19648	34	confession	confession	NN
18637	19648	35	made	make	VBN
18637	19648	36	after	after	IN
18637	19648	37	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	19648	38	would	would	MD
18637	19648	39	render	render	VB
18637	19648	40	a	a	DT
18637	19648	41	trial	trial	NN
18637	19648	42	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	19648	43	defective	defective	JJ
18637	19648	44	.	.	.
18637	19649	1	Here	here	RB
18637	19649	2	,	,	,
18637	19649	3	six	six	CD
18637	19649	4	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	19649	5	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	19649	6	to	to	TO
18637	19649	7	overturn	overturn	VB
18637	19649	8	a	a	DT
18637	19649	9	holding	holding	NN
18637	19649	10	of	of	IN
18637	19649	11	the	the	DT
18637	19649	12	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	19649	13	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
18637	19649	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19649	15	of	of	IN
18637	19649	16	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	19649	17	which	which	WDT
18637	19649	18	labelled	label	VBD
18637	19649	19	as	as	IN
18637	19649	20	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	19649	21	and	and	CC
18637	19649	22	usable	usable	JJ
18637	19649	23	a	a	DT
18637	19649	24	second	second	JJ
18637	19649	25	confession	confession	NN
18637	19649	26	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19649	27	by	by	IN
18637	19649	28	other	other	JJ
18637	19649	29	than	than	IN
18637	19649	30	coercive	coercive	JJ
18637	19649	31	means	mean	NNS
18637	19649	32	within	within	IN
18637	19649	33	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	19649	34	hours	hour	NNS
18637	19649	35	after	after	IN
18637	19649	36	the	the	DT
18637	19649	37	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19649	38	had	have	VBD
18637	19649	39	made	make	VBN
18637	19649	40	a	a	DT
18637	19649	41	confession	confession	NN
18637	19649	42	admittedly	admittedly	RB
18637	19649	43	under	under	IN
18637	19649	44	duress	duress	NN
18637	19649	45	.	.	.
18637	19650	1	The	the	DT
18637	19650	2	vice	vice	NN
18637	19650	3	of	of	IN
18637	19650	4	coerced	coerced	JJ
18637	19650	5	confessions	confession	NNS
18637	19650	6	,	,	,
18637	19650	7	these	these	DT
18637	19650	8	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	19650	9	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	19650	10	,	,	,
18637	19650	11	was	be	VBD
18637	19650	12	that	that	IN
18637	19650	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19650	14	offended	offend	VBD
18637	19650	15	"	"	``
18637	19650	16	basic	basic	JJ
18637	19650	17	standards	standard	NNS
18637	19650	18	of	of	IN
18637	19650	19	justice	justice	NN
18637	19650	20	,	,	,
18637	19650	21	not	not	RB
18637	19650	22	because	because	IN
18637	19650	23	the	the	DT
18637	19650	24	victim	victim	NN
18637	19650	25	had	have	VBD
18637	19650	26	a	a	DT
18637	19650	27	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19650	28	grievance	grievance	NN
18637	19650	29	against	against	IN
18637	19650	30	the	the	DT
18637	19650	31	police	police	NN
18637	19650	32	,	,	,
18637	19650	33	but	but	CC
18637	19650	34	because	because	IN
18637	19650	35	declarations	declaration	NNS
18637	19650	36	procured	procure	VBN
18637	19650	37	by	by	IN
18637	19650	38	torture	torture	NN
18637	19650	39	are	be	VBP
18637	19650	40	not	not	RB
18637	19650	41	premises	premise	NNS
18637	19650	42	from	from	IN
18637	19650	43	which	which	WDT
18637	19650	44	a	a	DT
18637	19650	45	civilized	civilized	JJ
18637	19650	46	forum	forum	NN
18637	19650	47	will	will	MD
18637	19650	48	infer	infer	VB
18637	19650	49	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	19650	50	.	.	.
18637	19651	1	"	"	``
18637	19651	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19651	3	891	891	CD
18637	19651	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19651	5	In	in	IN
18637	19651	6	Malinski	Malinski	NNP
18637	19651	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19651	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	19651	9	_	_	NNP
18637	19651	10	New	New	NNP
18637	19651	11	York,[892	York,[892	NNP
18637	19651	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19651	13	however	however	RB
18637	19651	14	,	,	,
18637	19651	15	although	although	IN
18637	19651	16	in	in	IN
18637	19651	17	the	the	DT
18637	19651	18	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	19651	19	of	of	IN
18637	19651	20	four	four	CD
18637	19651	21	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19651	22	there	there	EX
18637	19651	23	was	be	VBD
18637	19651	24	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	19651	25	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19651	26	as	as	IN
18637	19651	27	to	to	IN
18637	19651	28	the	the	DT
18637	19651	29	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	19651	30	character	character	NN
18637	19651	31	of	of	IN
18637	19651	32	the	the	DT
18637	19651	33	confessions	confession	NNS
18637	19651	34	used	use	VBN
18637	19651	35	,	,	,
18637	19651	36	the	the	DT
18637	19651	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19651	38	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	19651	39	overturned	overturn	VBD
18637	19651	40	a	a	DT
18637	19651	41	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19651	42	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	19651	43	by	by	IN
18637	19651	44	New	New	NNP
18637	19651	45	York	York	NNP
18637	19651	46	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	19651	47	.	.	.
18637	19652	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19652	2	893	893	CD
18637	19652	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19652	4	Without	without	IN
18637	19652	5	finding	find	VBG
18637	19652	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19652	7	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19652	8	to	to	TO
18637	19652	9	determine	determine	VB
18637	19652	10	whether	whether	IN
18637	19652	11	succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	19652	12	oral	oral	JJ
18637	19652	13	and	and	CC
18637	19652	14	written	write	VBN
18637	19652	15	confessions	confession	NNS
18637	19652	16	were	be	VBD
18637	19652	17	the	the	DT
18637	19652	18	product	product	NN
18637	19652	19	of	of	IN
18637	19652	20	the	the	DT
18637	19652	21	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	19652	22	"	"	``
18637	19652	23	admittedly	admittedly	RB
18637	19652	24	"	"	''
18637	19652	25	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19652	26	in	in	IN
18637	19652	27	extracting	extract	VBG
18637	19652	28	an	an	DT
18637	19652	29	initial	initial	JJ
18637	19652	30	oral	oral	JJ
18637	19652	31	confession,[894	confession,[894	NN
18637	19652	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19652	33	the	the	DT
18637	19652	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19652	35	held	hold	VBD
18637	19652	36	that	that	IN
18637	19652	37	,	,	,
18637	19652	38	even	even	RB
18637	19652	39	though	though	IN
18637	19652	40	other	other	JJ
18637	19652	41	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19652	42	might	may	MD
18637	19652	43	have	have	VB
18637	19652	44	sufficed	suffice	VBN
18637	19652	45	to	to	TO
18637	19652	46	convict	convict	VB
18637	19652	47	the	the	DT
18637	19652	48	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19652	49	and	and	CC
18637	19652	50	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19652	51	the	the	DT
18637	19652	52	fact	fact	NN
18637	19652	53	that	that	IN
18637	19652	54	the	the	DT
18637	19652	55	initial	initial	JJ
18637	19652	56	oral	oral	JJ
18637	19652	57	confession	confession	NN
18637	19652	58	was	be	VBD
18637	19652	59	never	never	RB
18637	19652	60	put	put	VBN
18637	19652	61	in	in	IN
18637	19652	62	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19652	63	,	,	,
18637	19652	64	the	the	DT
18637	19652	65	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	19652	66	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	19652	67	reference	reference	NN
18637	19652	68	to	to	IN
18637	19652	69	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19652	70	content	content	NN
18637	19652	71	at	at	IN
18637	19652	72	the	the	DT
18637	19652	73	trial	trial	NN
18637	19652	74	plus	plus	CC
18637	19652	75	the	the	DT
18637	19652	76	failure	failure	NN
18637	19652	77	to	to	TO
18637	19652	78	warn	warn	VB
18637	19652	79	the	the	DT
18637	19652	80	jury	jury	NN
18637	19652	81	not	not	RB
18637	19652	82	to	to	TO
18637	19652	83	consider	consider	VB
18637	19652	84	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19652	85	as	as	IN
18637	19652	86	evidence[895	evidence[895	JJ
18637	19652	87	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19652	88	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
18637	19652	89	the	the	DT
18637	19652	90	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19652	91	giving	give	VBG
18637	19652	92	rise	rise	NN
18637	19652	93	to	to	IN
18637	19652	94	the	the	DT
18637	19652	95	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	19652	96	.	.	.
18637	19653	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19653	2	896	896	CD
18637	19653	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19653	4	Of	of	IN
18637	19653	5	the	the	DT
18637	19653	6	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	19653	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	19653	8	involving	involve	VBG
18637	19653	9	the	the	DT
18637	19653	10	issue	issue	NN
18637	19653	11	of	of	IN
18637	19653	12	self	self	NN
18637	19653	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	19653	14	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	19653	15	,	,	,
18637	19653	16	Adamson	Adamson	NNP
18637	19653	17	_	_	NNP
18637	19653	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	19653	19	_	_	NNP
18637	19653	20	California[897	California[897	NNP
18637	19653	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19653	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	19653	23	especially	especially	RB
18637	19653	24	significant	significant	JJ
18637	19653	25	because	because	IN
18637	19653	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19653	27	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	19653	28	the	the	DT
18637	19653	29	high	high	JJ
18637	19653	30	water	water	NN
18637	19653	31	mark	mark	NN
18637	19653	32	of	of	IN
18637	19653	33	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	19653	34	in	in	IN
18637	19653	35	support	support	NN
18637	19653	36	of	of	IN
18637	19653	37	the	the	DT
18637	19653	38	contention	contention	NN
18637	19653	39	that	that	IN
18637	19653	40	the	the	DT
18637	19653	41	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	19653	42	of	of	IN
18637	19653	43	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	19653	44	,	,	,
18637	19653	45	originally	originally	RB
18637	19653	46	operative	operative	VBP
18637	19653	47	only	only	RB
18637	19653	48	against	against	IN
18637	19653	49	the	the	DT
18637	19653	50	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	19653	51	Government	Government	NNP
18637	19653	52	,	,	,
18637	19653	53	became	become	VBD
18637	19653	54	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	19653	55	on	on	IN
18637	19653	56	State	state	NN
18637	19653	57	action	action	NN
18637	19653	58	by	by	IN
18637	19653	59	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	19653	60	of	of	IN
18637	19653	61	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19653	62	inclusion	inclusion	NN
18637	19653	63	within	within	IN
18637	19653	64	the	the	DT
18637	19653	65	due	due	JJ
18637	19653	66	process	process	NN
18637	19653	67	clause	clause	NN
18637	19653	68	of	of	IN
18637	19653	69	the	the	DT
18637	19653	70	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19653	71	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19653	72	.	.	.
18637	19654	1	Here	here	RB
18637	19654	2	,	,	,
18637	19654	3	the	the	DT
18637	19654	4	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19654	5	,	,	,
18637	19654	6	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	19654	7	through	through	IN
18637	19654	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19654	9	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	19654	10	,	,	,
18637	19654	11	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19654	12	that	that	IN
18637	19654	13	the	the	DT
18637	19654	14	California	California	NNP
18637	19654	15	law	law	NN
18637	19654	16	which	which	WDT
18637	19654	17	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	19654	18	that	that	IN
18637	19654	19	if	if	IN
18637	19654	20	an	an	DT
18637	19654	21	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19654	22	elects	elect	NNS
18637	19654	23	to	to	TO
18637	19654	24	take	take	VB
18637	19654	25	the	the	DT
18637	19654	26	witness	witness	NN
18637	19654	27	stand	stand	VB
18637	19654	28	and	and	CC
18637	19654	29	testify	testify	VB
18637	19654	30	,	,	,
18637	19654	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19654	32	must	must	MD
18637	19654	33	then	then	RB
18637	19654	34	be	be	VB
18637	19654	35	prepared	prepare	VBN
18637	19654	36	to	to	TO
18637	19654	37	undergo	undergo	VB
18637	19654	38	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	19654	39	of	of	IN
18637	19654	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19654	41	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19654	42	,	,	,
18637	19654	43	through	through	IN
18637	19654	44	disclosure	disclosure	NN
18637	19654	45	of	of	IN
18637	19654	46	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19654	47	previous	previous	JJ
18637	19654	48	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	19654	49	,	,	,
18637	19654	50	and	and	CC
18637	19654	51	which	which	WDT
18637	19654	52	also	also	RB
18637	19654	53	permits	permit	VBZ
18637	19654	54	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19654	55	to	to	TO
18637	19654	56	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	19654	57	such	such	JJ
18637	19654	58	disclosure	disclosure	NN
18637	19654	59	by	by	IN
18637	19654	60	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	19654	61	silent	silent	JJ
18637	19654	62	,	,	,
18637	19654	63	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19654	64	to	to	IN
18637	19654	65	comment	comment	NN
18637	19654	66	on	on	IN
18637	19654	67	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19654	68	failure	failure	NN
18637	19654	69	to	to	TO
18637	19654	70	testify	testify	VB
18637	19654	71	by	by	IN
18637	19654	72	the	the	DT
18637	19654	73	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19654	74	and	and	CC
18637	19654	75	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
18637	19654	76	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19654	77	,	,	,
18637	19654	78	does	do	VBZ
18637	19654	79	not	not	RB
18637	19654	80	involve	involve	VB
18637	19654	81	such	such	PDT
18637	19654	82	a	a	DT
18637	19654	83	denial	denial	NN
18637	19654	84	of	of	IN
18637	19654	85	due	due	JJ
18637	19654	86	process	process	NN
18637	19654	87	as	as	IN
18637	19654	88	to	to	TO
18637	19654	89	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	19654	90	a	a	DT
18637	19654	91	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19654	92	in	in	IN
18637	19654	93	a	a	DT
18637	19654	94	State	State	NNP
18637	19654	95	court	court	NN
18637	19654	96	.	.	.
18637	19655	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	19655	2	as	as	IN
18637	19655	3	California	California	NNP
18637	19655	4	law	law	NN
18637	19655	5	"	"	``
18637	19655	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	19655	7	not	not	RB
18637	19655	8	involve	involve	VB
18637	19655	9	any	any	DT
18637	19655	10	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	19655	11	,	,	,
18637	19655	12	rebuttable	rebuttable	JJ
18637	19655	13	or	or	CC
18637	19655	14	irrebuttable	irrebuttable	JJ
18637	19655	15	,	,	,
18637	19655	16	either	either	CC
18637	19655	17	of	of	IN
18637	19655	18	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	19655	19	or	or	CC
18637	19655	20	of	of	IN
18637	19655	21	the	the	DT
18637	19655	22	truth	truth	NN
18637	19655	23	of	of	IN
18637	19655	24	any	any	DT
18637	19655	25	fact	fact	NN
18637	19655	26	,	,	,
18637	19655	27	"	"	''
18637	19655	28	and	and	CC
18637	19655	29	does	do	VBZ
18637	19655	30	not	not	RB
18637	19655	31	alter	alter	VB
18637	19655	32	the	the	DT
18637	19655	33	burden	burden	NN
18637	19655	34	of	of	IN
18637	19655	35	proof	proof	NN
18637	19655	36	,	,	,
18637	19655	37	which	which	WDT
18637	19655	38	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	19655	39	upon	upon	IN
18637	19655	40	the	the	DT
18637	19655	41	State	State	NNP
18637	19655	42	,	,	,
18637	19655	43	nor	nor	CC
18637	19655	44	the	the	DT
18637	19655	45	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	19655	46	of	of	IN
18637	19655	47	innocence	innocence	NN
18637	19655	48	in	in	IN
18637	19655	49	favor	favor	NN
18637	19655	50	of	of	IN
18637	19655	51	the	the	DT
18637	19655	52	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19655	53	,	,	,
18637	19655	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19655	55	does	do	VBZ
18637	19655	56	not	not	RB
18637	19655	57	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	19655	58	the	the	DT
18637	19655	59	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19655	60	from	from	IN
18637	19655	61	enjoying	enjoy	VBG
18637	19655	62	a	a	DT
18637	19655	63	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19655	64	trial	trial	NN
18637	19655	65	,	,	,
18637	19655	66	which	which	WDT
18637	19655	67	is	be	VBZ
18637	19655	68	all	all	DT
18637	19655	69	that	that	WDT
18637	19655	70	the	the	DT
18637	19655	71	due	due	JJ
18637	19655	72	process	process	NN
18637	19655	73	clause	clause	NN
18637	19655	74	of	of	IN
18637	19655	75	the	the	DT
18637	19655	76	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19655	77	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19655	78	guarantees	guarantee	VBZ
18637	19655	79	.	.	.
18637	19656	1	Relying	rely	VBG
18637	19656	2	upon	upon	IN
18637	19656	3	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	19656	4	_	_	NNP
18637	19656	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	19656	6	_	_	NNP
18637	19656	7	New	New	NNP
18637	19656	8	Jersey[898	Jersey[898	NNP
18637	19656	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19656	10	and	and	CC
18637	19656	11	Palko	Palko	NNP
18637	19656	12	_	_	NNP
18637	19656	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	19656	14	_	_	NNP
18637	19656	15	Connecticut,[899	Connecticut,[899	NNP
18637	19656	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19656	17	the	the	DT
18637	19656	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19656	19	reiterated	reiterate	VBD
18637	19656	20	that	that	IN
18637	19656	21	the	the	DT
18637	19656	22	"	"	``
18637	19656	23	due	due	JJ
18637	19656	24	process	process	NN
18637	19656	25	clause	clause	NN
18637	19656	26	of	of	IN
18637	19656	27	the	the	DT
18637	19656	28	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19656	29	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19656	30	,	,	,
18637	19656	31	however	however	RB
18637	19656	32	,	,	,
18637	19656	33	does	do	VBZ
18637	19656	34	not	not	RB
18637	19656	35	draw	draw	VB
18637	19656	36	all	all	PDT
18637	19656	37	the	the	DT
18637	19656	38	rights	right	NNS
18637	19656	39	of	of	IN
18637	19656	40	the	the	DT
18637	19656	41	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19656	42	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	19656	43	of	of	IN
18637	19656	44	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	19656	45	under	under	IN
18637	19656	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19656	47	protection	protection	NN
18637	19656	48	.	.	.
18637	19657	1	"	"	``
18637	19657	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19657	3	900	900	CD
18637	19657	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19657	5	In	in	IN
18637	19657	6	a	a	DT
18637	19657	7	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	19657	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	19657	9	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	19657	10	the	the	DT
18637	19657	11	scope	scope	NN
18637	19657	12	of	of	IN
18637	19657	13	the	the	DT
18637	19657	14	protection	protection	NN
18637	19657	15	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	19657	16	by	by	IN
18637	19657	17	this	this	DT
18637	19657	18	clause	clause	NN
18637	19657	19	of	of	IN
18637	19657	20	the	the	DT
18637	19657	21	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19657	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19657	23	,	,	,
18637	19657	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19657	25	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	19657	26	contended	contend	VBD
18637	19657	27	that	that	IN
18637	19657	28	further	further	JJ
18637	19657	29	argument	argument	NN
18637	19657	30	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	19657	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	19657	32	foreclosed	foreclose	VBN
18637	19657	33	by	by	IN
18637	19657	34	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	19657	35	_	_	NNP
18637	19657	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	19657	37	_	_	NNP
18637	19657	38	New	New	NNP
18637	19657	39	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	19657	40	,	,	,
18637	19657	41	a	a	DT
18637	19657	42	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	19657	43	,	,	,
18637	19657	44	on	on	IN
18637	19657	45	which	which	WDT
18637	19657	46	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19657	47	commented	comment	VBD
18637	19657	48	as	as	IN
18637	19657	49	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	19657	50	:	:	:
18637	19657	51	"	"	``
18637	19657	52	Decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19657	53	of	of	IN
18637	19657	54	this	this	DT
18637	19657	55	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19657	56	do	do	VBP
18637	19657	57	not	not	RB
18637	19657	58	have	have	VB
18637	19657	59	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19657	60	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
18637	19657	61	authority	authority	NN
18637	19657	62	.	.	.
18637	19658	1	The	the	DT
18637	19658	2	_	_	NNP
18637	19658	3	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	19658	4	_	_	NNP
18637	19658	5	Case	Case	NNP
18637	19658	6	shows	show	VBZ
18637	19658	7	the	the	DT
18637	19658	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19658	9	process	process	NN
18637	19658	10	at	at	IN
18637	19658	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19658	12	best	good	JJS
18637	19658	13	--	--	:
18637	19658	14	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
18637	19658	15	briefs	brief	NNS
18637	19658	16	and	and	CC
18637	19658	17	powerful	powerful	JJ
18637	19658	18	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	19658	19	on	on	IN
18637	19658	20	both	both	DT
18637	19658	21	sides	side	NNS
18637	19658	22	,	,	,
18637	19658	23	followed	follow	VBN
18637	19658	24	by	by	IN
18637	19658	25	long	long	JJ
18637	19658	26	deliberation	deliberation	NN
18637	19658	27	,	,	,
18637	19658	28	resulting	result	VBG
18637	19658	29	in	in	IN
18637	19658	30	an	an	DT
18637	19658	31	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	19658	32	by	by	IN
18637	19658	33	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
18637	19658	34	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19658	35	Moody	Moody	NNP
18637	19658	36	which	which	WDT
18637	19658	37	at	at	IN
18637	19658	38	once	once	RB
18637	19658	39	gained	gain	VBN
18637	19658	40	and	and	CC
18637	19658	41	has	have	VBZ
18637	19658	42	ever	ever	RB
18637	19658	43	since	since	IN
18637	19658	44	retained	retained	JJ
18637	19658	45	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	19658	46	as	as	IN
18637	19658	47	one	one	CD
18637	19658	48	of	of	IN
18637	19658	49	the	the	DT
18637	19658	50	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	19658	51	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	19658	52	in	in	IN
18637	19658	53	the	the	DT
18637	19658	54	history	history	NN
18637	19658	55	of	of	IN
18637	19658	56	the	the	DT
18637	19658	57	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19658	58	.	.	.
18637	19659	1	After	after	IN
18637	19659	2	enjoying	enjoy	VBG
18637	19659	3	unquestioned	unquestioned	JJ
18637	19659	4	prestige	prestige	NN
18637	19659	5	for	for	IN
18637	19659	6	forty	forty	CD
18637	19659	7	years	year	NNS
18637	19659	8	,	,	,
18637	19659	9	the	the	DT
18637	19659	10	_	_	NNP
18637	19659	11	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	19659	12	_	_	NNP
18637	19659	13	Case	Case	NNP
18637	19659	14	should	should	MD
18637	19659	15	not	not	RB
18637	19659	16	now	now	RB
18637	19659	17	be	be	VB
18637	19659	18	diluted	dilute	VBN
18637	19659	19	,	,	,
18637	19659	20	even	even	RB
18637	19659	21	unwittingly	unwittingly	RB
18637	19659	22	,	,	,
18637	19659	23	either	either	CC
18637	19659	24	in	in	IN
18637	19659	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19659	26	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19659	27	philosophy	philosophy	NN
18637	19659	28	or	or	CC
18637	19659	29	in	in	IN
18637	19659	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19659	31	particulars	particular	NNS
18637	19659	32	.	.	.
18637	19660	1	As	as	IN
18637	19660	2	the	the	DT
18637	19660	3	surest	sure	JJS
18637	19660	4	way	way	NN
18637	19660	5	of	of	IN
18637	19660	6	keeping	keep	VBG
18637	19660	7	the	the	DT
18637	19660	8	_	_	NNP
18637	19660	9	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	19660	10	_	_	NNP
18637	19660	11	Case	Case	NNP
18637	19660	12	intact	intact	JJ
18637	19660	13	,	,	,
18637	19660	14	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19660	15	would	would	MD
18637	19660	16	affirm	affirm	VB
18637	19660	17	this	this	DT
18637	19660	18	case	case	NN
18637	19660	19	on	on	IN
18637	19660	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19660	21	authority	authority	NN
18637	19660	22	.	.	.
18637	19660	23	"	"	''
18637	19661	1	In	in	IN
18637	19661	2	dismissing	dismissing	NN
18637	19661	3	as	as	RB
18637	19661	4	historically	historically	RB
18637	19661	5	untenable	untenable	JJ
18637	19661	6	the	the	DT
18637	19661	7	position	position	NN
18637	19661	8	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	19661	9	by	by	IN
18637	19661	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19661	11	Black	Black	NNP
18637	19661	12	,	,	,
18637	19661	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19661	14	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	19661	15	further	further	RB
18637	19661	16	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19661	17	that	that	DT
18637	19661	18	:	:	:
18637	19661	19	"	"	``
18637	19661	20	The	the	DT
18637	19661	21	notion	notion	NN
18637	19661	22	that	that	IN
18637	19661	23	the	the	DT
18637	19661	24	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19661	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19661	26	was	be	VBD
18637	19661	27	a	a	DT
18637	19661	28	covert	covert	JJ
18637	19661	29	way	way	NN
18637	19661	30	of	of	IN
18637	19661	31	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	19661	32	upon	upon	IN
18637	19661	33	the	the	DT
18637	19661	34	States	States	NNP
18637	19661	35	all	all	PDT
18637	19661	36	the	the	DT
18637	19661	37	rules	rule	NNS
18637	19661	38	which	which	WDT
18637	19661	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19661	40	seemed	seem	VBD
18637	19661	41	important	important	JJ
18637	19661	42	to	to	IN
18637	19661	43	Eighteenth	Eighteenth	NNP
18637	19661	44	Century	Century	NNP
18637	19661	45	statesmen	statesman	NNS
18637	19661	46	to	to	TO
18637	19661	47	write	write	VB
18637	19661	48	into	into	IN
18637	19661	49	the	the	DT
18637	19661	50	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	19661	51	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	19661	52	,	,	,
18637	19661	53	was	be	VBD
18637	19661	54	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	19661	55	by	by	IN
18637	19661	56	judges	judge	NNS
18637	19661	57	who	who	WP
18637	19661	58	were	be	VBD
18637	19661	59	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19661	60	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	19661	61	of	of	IN
18637	19661	62	the	the	DT
18637	19661	63	process	process	NN
18637	19661	64	by	by	IN
18637	19661	65	which	which	WDT
18637	19661	66	the	the	DT
18637	19661	67	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19661	68	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19661	69	became	become	VBD
18637	19661	70	part	part	NN
18637	19661	71	of	of	IN
18637	19661	72	the	the	DT
18637	19661	73	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19661	74	.	.	.
18637	19662	1	Arguments	argument	NNS
18637	19662	2	that	that	WDT
18637	19662	3	may	may	MD
18637	19662	4	now	now	RB
18637	19662	5	be	be	VB
18637	19662	6	adduced	adduce	VBN
18637	19662	7	to	to	TO
18637	19662	8	prove	prove	VB
18637	19662	9	that	that	IN
18637	19662	10	the	the	DT
18637	19662	11	first	first	JJ
18637	19662	12	eight	eight	CD
18637	19662	13	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	19662	14	were	be	VBD
18637	19662	15	concealed	conceal	VBN
18637	19662	16	within	within	IN
18637	19662	17	the	the	DT
18637	19662	18	historic	historic	JJ
18637	19662	19	phrasing	phrasing	NN
18637	19662	20	of	of	IN
18637	19662	21	the	the	DT
18637	19662	22	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19662	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19662	24	were	be	VBD
18637	19662	25	not	not	RB
18637	19662	26	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	19662	27	at	at	IN
18637	19662	28	the	the	DT
18637	19662	29	time	time	NN
18637	19662	30	of	of	IN
18637	19662	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19662	32	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	19662	33	.	.	.
18637	19663	1	A	a	DT
18637	19663	2	surer	sure	JJR
18637	19663	3	estimate	estimate	NN
18637	19663	4	of	of	IN
18637	19663	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19663	6	bearing	bearing	NN
18637	19663	7	was	be	VBD
18637	19663	8	possible	possible	JJ
18637	19663	9	for	for	IN
18637	19663	10	judges	judge	NNS
18637	19663	11	at	at	IN
18637	19663	12	the	the	DT
18637	19663	13	time	time	NN
18637	19663	14	than	than	IN
18637	19663	15	distorting	distort	VBG
18637	19663	16	distance	distance	NN
18637	19663	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	19663	18	likely	likely	JJ
18637	19663	19	to	to	TO
18637	19663	20	vouchsafe	vouchsafe	VB
18637	19663	21	.	.	.
18637	19664	1	Any	any	DT
18637	19664	2	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19664	3	of	of	IN
18637	19664	4	design	design	NN
18637	19664	5	or	or	CC
18637	19664	6	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	19664	7	not	not	RB
18637	19664	8	contemporaneously	contemporaneously	RB
18637	19664	9	known	know	VBN
18637	19664	10	could	could	MD
18637	19664	11	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	19664	12	have	have	VB
18637	19664	13	influenced	influence	VBN
18637	19664	14	those	those	DT
18637	19664	15	who	who	WP
18637	19664	16	ratified	ratify	VBD
18637	19664	17	the	the	DT
18637	19664	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19664	19	.	.	.
18637	19665	1	Remarks	remark	NNS
18637	19665	2	of	of	IN
18637	19665	3	a	a	DT
18637	19665	4	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19665	5	proponent	proponent	NN
18637	19665	6	of	of	IN
18637	19665	7	the	the	DT
18637	19665	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19665	9	,	,	,
18637	19665	10	no	no	RB
18637	19665	11	matter	matter	RB
18637	19665	12	how	how	WRB
18637	19665	13	influential	influential	JJ
18637	19665	14	,	,	,
18637	19665	15	are	be	VBP
18637	19665	16	not	not	RB
18637	19665	17	to	to	TO
18637	19665	18	be	be	VB
18637	19665	19	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19665	20	part	part	NN
18637	19665	21	of	of	IN
18637	19665	22	the	the	DT
18637	19665	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19665	24	.	.	.
18637	19666	1	What	what	WP
18637	19666	2	was	be	VBD
18637	19666	3	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	19666	4	for	for	IN
18637	19666	5	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	19666	6	was	be	VBD
18637	19666	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19666	8	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	19666	9	,	,	,
18637	19666	10	not	not	RB
18637	19666	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19666	12	speech	speech	NN
18637	19666	13	.	.	.
18637	19667	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19667	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19667	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19667	4	The	the	DT
18637	19667	5	Due	Due	NNP
18637	19667	6	Process	Process	NNP
18637	19667	7	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	19667	8	of	of	IN
18637	19667	9	the	the	DT
18637	19667	10	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19667	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19667	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	19667	13	an	an	DT
18637	19667	14	independent	independent	JJ
18637	19667	15	potency	potency	NN
18637	19667	16	,	,	,
18637	19667	17	precisely	precisely	RB
18637	19667	18	as	as	IN
18637	19667	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	19667	20	the	the	DT
18637	19667	21	Due	Due	NNP
18637	19667	22	Process	Process	NNP
18637	19667	23	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	19667	24	of	of	IN
18637	19667	25	the	the	DT
18637	19667	26	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	19667	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19667	28	in	in	IN
18637	19667	29	relation	relation	NN
18637	19667	30	to	to	IN
18637	19667	31	the	the	DT
18637	19667	32	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	19667	33	Government	Government	NNP
18637	19667	34	.	.	.
18637	19668	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19668	2	ought	ought	MD
18637	19668	3	not	not	RB
18637	19668	4	to	to	TO
18637	19668	5	require	require	VB
18637	19668	6	argument	argument	NN
18637	19668	7	to	to	TO
18637	19668	8	reject	reject	VB
18637	19668	9	the	the	DT
18637	19668	10	notion	notion	NN
18637	19668	11	that	that	IN
18637	19668	12	due	due	JJ
18637	19668	13	process	process	NN
18637	19668	14	of	of	IN
18637	19668	15	law	law	NN
18637	19668	16	meant	mean	VBD
18637	19668	17	one	one	CD
18637	19668	18	thing	thing	NN
18637	19668	19	in	in	IN
18637	19668	20	the	the	DT
18637	19668	21	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	19668	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19668	23	and	and	CC
18637	19668	24	another	another	DT
18637	19668	25	in	in	IN
18637	19668	26	the	the	DT
18637	19668	27	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19668	28	.	.	.
18637	19669	1	The	the	DT
18637	19669	2	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	19669	3	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19669	4	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	19669	5	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	19669	6	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	19669	7	of	of	IN
18637	19669	8	an	an	DT
18637	19669	9	'	'	``
18637	19669	10	infamous	infamous	JJ
18637	19669	11	crime	crime	NN
18637	19669	12	'	'	''
18637	19669	13	except	except	IN
18637	19669	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	19669	15	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	19669	16	;	;	:
18637	19669	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19669	18	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	19669	19	double	double	JJ
18637	19669	20	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	19669	21	;	;	:
18637	19669	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19669	23	bars	bar	VBZ
18637	19669	24	compelling	compel	VBG
18637	19669	25	a	a	DT
18637	19669	26	person	person	NN
18637	19669	27	to	to	TO
18637	19669	28	be	be	VB
18637	19669	29	a	a	DT
18637	19669	30	witness	witness	NN
18637	19669	31	against	against	IN
18637	19669	32	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19669	33	in	in	IN
18637	19669	34	any	any	DT
18637	19669	35	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19669	36	case	case	NN
18637	19669	37	;	;	:
18637	19669	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19669	39	precludes	preclude	VBZ
18637	19669	40	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19669	41	of	of	IN
18637	19669	42	'	'	``
18637	19669	43	life	life	NN
18637	19669	44	,	,	,
18637	19669	45	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19669	46	,	,	,
18637	19669	47	or	or	CC
18637	19669	48	property	property	NN
18637	19669	49	,	,	,
18637	19669	50	without	without	IN
18637	19669	51	due	due	JJ
18637	19669	52	process	process	NN
18637	19669	53	of	of	IN
18637	19669	54	law	law	NN
18637	19669	55	*	*	NFP
18637	19669	56	*	*	NFP
18637	19669	57	*	*	NFP
18637	19669	58	'	'	''
18637	19669	59	Are	be	VBP
18637	19669	60	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	19669	61	and	and	CC
18637	19669	62	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19669	63	contemporaries	contemporary	NNS
18637	19669	64	in	in	IN
18637	19669	65	the	the	DT
18637	19669	66	framing	framing	NN
18637	19669	67	of	of	IN
18637	19669	68	the	the	DT
18637	19669	69	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	19669	70	of	of	IN
18637	19669	71	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	19669	72	to	to	TO
18637	19669	73	be	be	VB
18637	19669	74	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19669	75	with	with	IN
18637	19669	76	writing	writing	NN
18637	19669	77	into	into	IN
18637	19669	78	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19669	79	a	a	DT
18637	19669	80	meaningless	meaningless	JJ
18637	19669	81	clause	clause	NN
18637	19669	82	?	?	.
18637	19670	1	To	to	TO
18637	19670	2	consider	consider	VB
18637	19670	3	'	'	``
18637	19670	4	due	due	JJ
18637	19670	5	process	process	NN
18637	19670	6	of	of	IN
18637	19670	7	law	law	NN
18637	19670	8	'	'	''
18637	19670	9	as	as	IN
18637	19670	10	merely	merely	RB
18637	19670	11	a	a	DT
18637	19670	12	shorthand	shorthand	JJ
18637	19670	13	statement	statement	NN
18637	19670	14	of	of	IN
18637	19670	15	other	other	JJ
18637	19670	16	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19670	17	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	19670	18	in	in	IN
18637	19670	19	the	the	DT
18637	19670	20	same	same	JJ
18637	19670	21	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	19670	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	19670	23	to	to	TO
18637	19670	24	attribute	attribute	VB
18637	19670	25	to	to	IN
18637	19670	26	the	the	DT
18637	19670	27	authors	author	NNS
18637	19670	28	and	and	CC
18637	19670	29	proponents	proponent	NNS
18637	19670	30	of	of	IN
18637	19670	31	this	this	DT
18637	19670	32	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19670	33	ignorance	ignorance	NN
18637	19670	34	of	of	IN
18637	19670	35	,	,	,
18637	19670	36	or	or	CC
18637	19670	37	indifference	indifference	NN
18637	19670	38	to	to	IN
18637	19670	39	,	,	,
18637	19670	40	a	a	DT
18637	19670	41	historic	historic	JJ
18637	19670	42	conception	conception	NN
18637	19670	43	which	which	WDT
18637	19670	44	was	be	VBD
18637	19670	45	one	one	CD
18637	19670	46	of	of	IN
18637	19670	47	the	the	DT
18637	19670	48	great	great	JJ
18637	19670	49	instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	19670	50	in	in	IN
18637	19670	51	the	the	DT
18637	19670	52	arsenal	arsenal	NN
18637	19670	53	of	of	IN
18637	19670	54	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19670	55	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	19670	56	which	which	WDT
18637	19670	57	the	the	DT
18637	19670	58	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	19670	59	of	of	IN
18637	19670	60	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	19670	61	was	be	VBD
18637	19670	62	to	to	TO
18637	19670	63	protect	protect	VB
18637	19670	64	and	and	CC
18637	19670	65	strengthen	strengthen	VB
18637	19670	66	.	.	.
18637	19670	67	"	"	''
18637	19671	1	Warning	warning	NN
18637	19671	2	that	that	IN
18637	19671	3	"	"	``
18637	19671	4	a	a	DT
18637	19671	5	construction	construction	NN
18637	19671	6	which	which	WDT
18637	19671	7	*	*	NFP
18637	19671	8	*	*	NFP
18637	19671	9	*	*	NFP
18637	19671	10	makes	make	NNS
18637	19671	11	of	of	IN
18637	19671	12	"	"	``
18637	19671	13	the	the	DT
18637	19671	14	due	due	JJ
18637	19671	15	process	process	NN
18637	19671	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	19671	17	of	of	IN
18637	19671	18	the	the	DT
18637	19671	19	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19671	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19671	21	"	"	``
18637	19671	22	a	a	DT
18637	19671	23	summary	summary	NN
18637	19671	24	of	of	IN
18637	19671	25	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19671	26	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	19671	27	of	of	IN
18637	19671	28	the	the	DT
18637	19671	29	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	19671	30	of	of	IN
18637	19671	31	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	19671	32	would	would	MD
18637	19671	33	,	,	,
18637	19671	34	*	*	NFP
18637	19671	35	*	*	NFP
18637	19671	36	*	*	NFP
18637	19671	37	,	,	,
18637	19671	38	tear	tear	VB
18637	19671	39	up	up	RP
18637	19671	40	by	by	IN
18637	19671	41	the	the	DT
18637	19671	42	roots	root	NNS
18637	19671	43	much	much	JJ
18637	19671	44	of	of	IN
18637	19671	45	the	the	DT
18637	19671	46	fabric	fabric	NN
18637	19671	47	of	of	IN
18637	19671	48	the	the	DT
18637	19671	49	law	law	NN
18637	19671	50	in	in	IN
18637	19671	51	the	the	DT
18637	19671	52	several	several	JJ
18637	19671	53	States	state	NNS
18637	19671	54	,	,	,
18637	19671	55	"	"	''
18637	19671	56	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19671	57	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	19671	58	,	,	,
18637	19671	59	in	in	IN
18637	19671	60	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	19671	61	,	,	,
18637	19671	62	offers	offer	VBZ
18637	19671	63	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19671	64	own	own	JJ
18637	19671	65	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	19671	66	of	of	IN
18637	19671	67	this	this	DT
18637	19671	68	clause	clause	NN
18637	19671	69	.	.	.
18637	19672	1	To	to	IN
18637	19672	2	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19672	3	,	,	,
18637	19672	4	the	the	DT
18637	19672	5	due	due	JJ
18637	19672	6	process	process	NN
18637	19672	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	19672	8	"	"	''
18637	19672	9	expresses	express	VBZ
18637	19672	10	a	a	DT
18637	19672	11	demand	demand	NN
18637	19672	12	for	for	IN
18637	19672	13	civilized	civilized	JJ
18637	19672	14	standards	standard	NNS
18637	19672	15	of	of	IN
18637	19672	16	law	law	NN
18637	19672	17	,	,	,
18637	19672	18	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19672	19	and	and	CC
18637	19672	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19672	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19672	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	19672	23	thus	thus	RB
18637	19672	24	not	not	RB
18637	19672	25	a	a	DT
18637	19672	26	stagnant	stagnant	JJ
18637	19672	27	formulation	formulation	NN
18637	19672	28	of	of	IN
18637	19672	29	what	what	WP
18637	19672	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	19672	31	been	be	VBN
18637	19672	32	achieved	achieve	VBN
18637	19672	33	in	in	IN
18637	19672	34	the	the	DT
18637	19672	35	past	past	NN
18637	19672	36	but	but	CC
18637	19672	37	a	a	DT
18637	19672	38	standard	standard	NN
18637	19672	39	for	for	IN
18637	19672	40	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19672	41	in	in	IN
18637	19672	42	the	the	DT
18637	19672	43	progressive	progressive	JJ
18637	19672	44	evolution	evolution	NN
18637	19672	45	of	of	IN
18637	19672	46	the	the	DT
18637	19672	47	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	19672	48	of	of	IN
18637	19672	49	a	a	DT
18637	19672	50	free	free	JJ
18637	19672	51	society	society	NN
18637	19672	52	.	.	.
18637	19672	53	"	"	''
18637	19673	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19673	2	"	"	``
18637	19673	3	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19673	4	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19673	5	in	in	IN
18637	19673	6	applying	apply	VBG
18637	19673	7	the	the	DT
18637	19673	8	Due	Due	NNP
18637	19673	9	Process	Process	NNP
18637	19673	10	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	19673	11	must	must	MD
18637	19673	12	move	move	VB
18637	19673	13	within	within	IN
18637	19673	14	the	the	DT
18637	19673	15	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19673	16	of	of	IN
18637	19673	17	accepted	accepted	JJ
18637	19673	18	notions	notion	NNS
18637	19673	19	of	of	IN
18637	19673	20	justice	justice	NN
18637	19673	21	and	and	CC
18637	19673	22	*	*	NFP
18637	19673	23	*	*	NFP
18637	19673	24	*	*	NFP
18637	19673	25	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19673	26	should	should	MD
18637	19673	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19673	28	not	not	RB
18637	19673	29	be	be	VB
18637	19673	30	based	base	VBN
18637	19673	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	19673	32	the	the	DT
18637	19673	33	idiosyncrasies	idiosyncrasy	NNS
18637	19673	34	of	of	IN
18637	19673	35	a	a	DT
18637	19673	36	merely	merely	RB
18637	19673	37	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19673	38	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19673	39	.	.	.
18637	19674	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19674	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19674	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19674	4	An	an	DT
18637	19674	5	important	important	JJ
18637	19674	6	safeguard	safeguard	NN
18637	19674	7	against	against	IN
18637	19674	8	such	such	JJ
18637	19674	9	merely	merely	RB
18637	19674	10	individual	individual	JJ
18637	19674	11	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19674	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	19674	13	an	an	DT
18637	19674	14	alert	alert	JJ
18637	19674	15	deference	deference	NN
18637	19674	16	to	to	IN
18637	19674	17	the	the	DT
18637	19674	18	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19674	19	of	of	IN
18637	19674	20	the	the	DT
18637	19674	21	State	State	NNP
18637	19674	22	court	court	NN
18637	19674	23	under	under	IN
18637	19674	24	review	review	NN
18637	19674	25	.	.	.
18637	19675	1	"	"	``
18637	19675	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19675	3	901	901	CD
18637	19675	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19675	5	In	in	IN
18637	19675	6	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	19675	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19675	8	Black	Black	NNP
18637	19675	9	,	,	,
18637	19675	10	who	who	WP
18637	19675	11	was	be	VBD
18637	19675	12	supported	support	VBN
18637	19675	13	by	by	IN
18637	19675	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19675	15	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	19675	16	,	,	,
18637	19675	17	attached	attach	VBN
18637	19675	18	to	to	IN
18637	19675	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19675	20	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	19675	21	"	"	``
18637	19675	22	an	an	DT
18637	19675	23	appendix	appendix	NNP
18637	19675	24	which	which	WDT
18637	19675	25	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	19675	26	*	*	NFP
18637	19675	27	*	*	NFP
18637	19675	28	*	*	NFP
18637	19675	29	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19675	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19675	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19675	32	resume	resume	NN
18637	19675	33	,	,	,
18637	19675	34	*	*	NFP
18637	19675	35	*	*	NFP
18637	19675	36	*	*	NFP
18637	19675	37	,	,	,
18637	19675	38	of	of	IN
18637	19675	39	the	the	DT
18637	19675	40	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19675	41	's	's	POS
18637	19675	42	history	history	NN
18637	19675	43	.	.	.
18637	19675	44	"	"	''
18637	19676	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19676	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	19676	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19676	4	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19676	5	"	"	``
18637	19676	6	that	that	WDT
18637	19676	7	history	history	NN
18637	19676	8	conclusively	conclusively	RB
18637	19676	9	demonstrates	demonstrate	VBZ
18637	19676	10	that	that	IN
18637	19676	11	the	the	DT
18637	19676	12	language	language	NN
18637	19676	13	of	of	IN
18637	19676	14	the	the	DT
18637	19676	15	first	first	JJ
18637	19676	16	section	section	NN
18637	19676	17	of	of	IN
18637	19676	18	the	the	DT
18637	19676	19	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19676	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19676	21	,	,	,
18637	19676	22	taken	take	VBN
18637	19676	23	as	as	IN
18637	19676	24	a	a	DT
18637	19676	25	whole	whole	NN
18637	19676	26	,	,	,
18637	19676	27	was	be	VBD
18637	19676	28	thought	think	VBN
18637	19676	29	by	by	IN
18637	19676	30	those	those	DT
18637	19676	31	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	19676	32	for	for	IN
18637	19676	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19676	34	submission	submission	NN
18637	19676	35	to	to	IN
18637	19676	36	the	the	DT
18637	19676	37	people	people	NNS
18637	19676	38	,	,	,
18637	19676	39	and	and	CC
18637	19676	40	by	by	IN
18637	19676	41	those	those	DT
18637	19676	42	who	who	WP
18637	19676	43	opposed	oppose	VBD
18637	19676	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19676	45	submission	submission	NN
18637	19676	46	,	,	,
18637	19676	47	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
18637	19676	48	explicit	explicit	JJ
18637	19676	49	to	to	TO
18637	19676	50	guarantee	guarantee	VB
18637	19676	51	that	that	IN
18637	19676	52	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	19676	53	no	no	DT
18637	19676	54	State	state	NN
18637	19676	55	could	could	MD
18637	19676	56	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	19676	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19676	58	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	19676	59	of	of	IN
18637	19676	60	the	the	DT
18637	19676	61	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	19676	62	and	and	CC
18637	19676	63	protections	protection	NNS
18637	19676	64	of	of	IN
18637	19676	65	the	the	DT
18637	19676	66	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	19676	67	of	of	IN
18637	19676	68	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	19676	69	.	.	.
18637	19676	70	"	"	''
18637	19677	1	A	a	DT
18637	19677	2	majority	majority	NN
18637	19677	3	of	of	IN
18637	19677	4	the	the	DT
18637	19677	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19677	6	,	,	,
18637	19677	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19677	8	acknowledges	acknowledge	VBZ
18637	19677	9	resignedly	resignedly	RB
18637	19677	10	,	,	,
18637	19677	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	19677	12	declined	decline	VBN
18637	19677	13	,	,	,
18637	19677	14	however	however	RB
18637	19677	15	,	,	,
18637	19677	16	"	"	``
18637	19677	17	to	to	TO
18637	19677	18	appraise	appraise	VB
18637	19677	19	the	the	DT
18637	19677	20	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	19677	21	historical	historical	JJ
18637	19677	22	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19677	23	of	of	IN
18637	19677	24	the	the	DT
18637	19677	25	intended	intended	JJ
18637	19677	26	scope	scope	NN
18637	19677	27	of	of	IN
18637	19677	28	the	the	DT
18637	19677	29	first	first	JJ
18637	19677	30	section	section	NN
18637	19677	31	of	of	IN
18637	19677	32	the	the	DT
18637	19677	33	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19677	34	.	.	.
18637	19677	35	"	"	''
18637	19678	1	In	in	IN
18637	19678	2	the	the	DT
18637	19678	3	instant	instant	JJ
18637	19678	4	case	case	NN
18637	19678	5	,	,	,
18637	19678	6	the	the	DT
18637	19678	7	majority	majority	NN
18637	19678	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	19678	9	,	,	,
18637	19678	10	according	accord	VBG
18637	19678	11	to	to	IN
18637	19678	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19678	13	Black	Black	NNP
18637	19678	14	,	,	,
18637	19678	15	"	"	``
18637	19678	16	reasserts	reassert	VBZ
18637	19678	17	a	a	DT
18637	19678	18	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19678	19	theory	theory	NN
18637	19678	20	spelled	spell	VBN
18637	19678	21	out	out	RP
18637	19678	22	in	in	IN
18637	19678	23	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	19678	24	_	_	NNP
18637	19678	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	19678	26	_	_	NNP
18637	19678	27	New	New	NNP
18637	19678	28	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	19678	29	,	,	,
18637	19678	30	*	*	NFP
18637	19678	31	*	*	NFP
18637	19678	32	*	*	NFP
18637	19678	33	that	that	IN
18637	19678	34	this	this	DT
18637	19678	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19678	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	19678	37	endowed	endow	VBN
18637	19678	38	by	by	IN
18637	19678	39	the	the	DT
18637	19678	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19678	41	with	with	IN
18637	19678	42	boundless	boundless	JJ
18637	19678	43	power	power	NN
18637	19678	44	under	under	IN
18637	19678	45	'	'	``
18637	19678	46	natural	natural	JJ
18637	19678	47	law	law	NN
18637	19678	48	'	'	''
18637	19678	49	periodically	periodically	RB
18637	19678	50	to	to	TO
18637	19678	51	expand	expand	VB
18637	19678	52	and	and	CC
18637	19678	53	contract	contract	VB
18637	19678	54	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19678	55	standards	standard	NNS
18637	19678	56	to	to	TO
18637	19678	57	conform	conform	VB
18637	19678	58	to	to	IN
18637	19678	59	the	the	DT
18637	19678	60	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19678	61	's	's	POS
18637	19678	62	conception	conception	NN
18637	19678	63	of	of	IN
18637	19678	64	what	what	WP
18637	19678	65	at	at	IN
18637	19678	66	a	a	DT
18637	19678	67	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19678	68	time	time	NN
18637	19678	69	constitutes	constitute	NNS
18637	19678	70	'	'	POS
18637	19678	71	civilized	civilized	JJ
18637	19678	72	decency	decency	NN
18637	19678	73	'	'	''
18637	19678	74	and	and	CC
18637	19678	75	'	'	``
18637	19678	76	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19678	77	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19678	78	and	and	CC
18637	19678	79	justice	justice	NN
18637	19678	80	.	.	.
18637	19678	81	'	'	''
18637	19679	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19679	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19679	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19679	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19679	5	This	this	NN
18637	19679	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19679	7	'	'	POS
18637	19679	8	natural	natural	JJ
18637	19679	9	law	law	NN
18637	19679	10	'	'	''
18637	19679	11	formula	formula	NN
18637	19679	12	,	,	,
18637	19679	13	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19679	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19679	15	further	further	RB
18637	19679	16	contends	contend	VBZ
18637	19679	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19679	18	*	*	NFP
18637	19679	19	*	*	NFP
18637	19679	20	*	*	NFP
18637	19679	21	should	should	MD
18637	19679	22	be	be	VB
18637	19679	23	abandoned	abandon	VBN
18637	19679	24	as	as	IN
18637	19679	25	an	an	DT
18637	19679	26	incongruous	incongruous	JJ
18637	19679	27	excrescence	excrescence	NN
18637	19679	28	on	on	IN
18637	19679	29	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19679	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19679	31	.	.	.
18637	19680	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19680	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19680	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19680	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19680	5	The	the	DT
18637	19680	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19680	7	formula	formula	NN
18637	19680	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19680	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19680	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19680	11	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19680	12	a	a	DT
18637	19680	13	violation	violation	NN
18637	19680	14	of	of	IN
18637	19680	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19680	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19680	17	,	,	,
18637	19680	18	in	in	IN
18637	19680	19	that	that	IN
18637	19680	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19680	21	subtly	subtly	RB
18637	19680	22	conveys	convey	VBZ
18637	19680	23	to	to	IN
18637	19680	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	19680	25	,	,	,
18637	19680	26	at	at	IN
18637	19680	27	the	the	DT
18637	19680	28	expense	expense	NN
18637	19680	29	of	of	IN
18637	19680	30	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	19680	31	,	,	,
18637	19680	32	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	19680	33	power	power	NN
18637	19680	34	over	over	IN
18637	19680	35	public	public	JJ
18637	19680	36	policies	policy	NNS
18637	19680	37	in	in	IN
18637	19680	38	fields	field	NNS
18637	19680	39	where	where	WRB
18637	19680	40	no	no	DT
18637	19680	41	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19680	42	provision	provision	NN
18637	19680	43	of	of	IN
18637	19680	44	the	the	DT
18637	19680	45	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19680	46	limits	limit	VBZ
18637	19680	47	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19680	48	power	power	NN
18637	19680	49	.	.	.
18637	19680	50	"	"	''
18637	19681	1	In	in	IN
18637	19681	2	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	19681	3	,	,	,
18637	19681	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19681	5	Black	Black	NNP
18637	19681	6	expresses	express	VBZ
18637	19681	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19681	8	fears	fear	NNS
18637	19681	9	as	as	IN
18637	19681	10	to	to	IN
18637	19681	11	"	"	``
18637	19681	12	the	the	DT
18637	19681	13	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	19681	14	of	of	IN
18637	19681	15	the	the	DT
18637	19681	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19681	17	's	's	POS
18637	19681	18	practice	practice	NN
18637	19681	19	of	of	IN
18637	19681	20	substituting	substitute	VBG
18637	19681	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19681	22	own	own	JJ
18637	19681	23	concepts	concept	NNS
18637	19681	24	of	of	IN
18637	19681	25	decency	decency	NN
18637	19681	26	and	and	CC
18637	19681	27	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19681	28	justice	justice	NN
18637	19681	29	for	for	IN
18637	19681	30	the	the	DT
18637	19681	31	language	language	NN
18637	19681	32	of	of	IN
18637	19681	33	the	the	DT
18637	19681	34	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	19681	35	of	of	IN
18637	19681	36	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	19681	37	*	*	NFP
18637	19681	38	*	*	NFP
18637	19681	39	*	*	NFP
18637	19681	40	"	"	''
18637	19681	41	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19681	42	902	902	CD
18637	19681	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19681	44	In	in	IN
18637	19681	45	all	all	DT
18637	19681	46	but	but	IN
18637	19681	47	one	one	CD
18637	19681	48	of	of	IN
18637	19681	49	the	the	DT
18637	19681	50	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	19681	51	cases	case	NNS
18637	19681	52	,	,	,
18637	19681	53	the	the	DT
18637	19681	54	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19681	55	sided	side	VBD
18637	19681	56	with	with	IN
18637	19681	57	the	the	DT
18637	19681	58	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19681	59	and	and	CC
18637	19681	60	supported	support	VBD
18637	19681	61	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19681	62	contention	contention	NN
18637	19681	63	that	that	IN
18637	19681	64	the	the	DT
18637	19681	65	confession	confession	NN
18637	19681	66	on	on	IN
18637	19681	67	which	which	WDT
18637	19681	68	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19681	69	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19681	70	was	be	VBD
18637	19681	71	based	base	VBN
18637	19681	72	had	have	VBD
18637	19681	73	been	be	VBN
18637	19681	74	procured	procure	VBN
18637	19681	75	by	by	IN
18637	19681	76	methods	method	NNS
18637	19681	77	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	19681	78	to	to	IN
18637	19681	79	the	the	DT
18637	19681	80	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	19681	81	of	of	IN
18637	19681	82	due	due	JJ
18637	19681	83	process	process	NN
18637	19681	84	.	.	.
18637	19682	1	The	the	DT
18637	19682	2	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19682	3	of	of	IN
18637	19682	4	murder	murder	NN
18637	19682	5	of	of	IN
18637	19682	6	a	a	DT
18637	19682	7	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	19682	8	boy	boy	NN
18637	19682	9	of	of	IN
18637	19682	10	fifteen	fifteen	CD
18637	19682	11	was	be	VBD
18637	19682	12	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	19682	13	by	by	IN
18637	19682	14	five	five	CD
18637	19682	15	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19682	16	in	in	IN
18637	19682	17	Haley	Haley	NNP
18637	19682	18	_	_	NNP
18637	19682	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	19682	20	_	_	NNP
18637	19682	21	Ohio[903	Ohio[903	NNP
18637	19682	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19682	23	on	on	IN
18637	19682	24	the	the	DT
18637	19682	25	ground	ground	NN
18637	19682	26	that	that	IN
18637	19682	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19682	28	confession	confession	NN
18637	19682	29	,	,	,
18637	19682	30	which	which	WDT
18637	19682	31	contributed	contribute	VBD
18637	19682	32	to	to	IN
18637	19682	33	the	the	DT
18637	19682	34	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	19682	35	,	,	,
18637	19682	36	was	be	VBD
18637	19682	37	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	19682	38	,	,	,
18637	19682	39	having	have	VBG
18637	19682	40	been	be	VBN
18637	19682	41	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19682	42	by	by	IN
18637	19682	43	the	the	DT
18637	19682	44	police	police	NN
18637	19682	45	after	after	IN
18637	19682	46	several	several	JJ
18637	19682	47	hours	hour	NNS
18637	19682	48	of	of	IN
18637	19682	49	questioning	question	VBG
18637	19682	50	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	19682	51	after	after	IN
18637	19682	52	the	the	DT
18637	19682	53	boy	boy	NN
18637	19682	54	was	be	VBD
18637	19682	55	arrested	arrest	VBN
18637	19682	56	,	,	,
18637	19682	57	during	during	IN
18637	19682	58	which	which	WDT
18637	19682	59	interval	interval	NN
18637	19682	60	the	the	DT
18637	19682	61	youth	youth	NN
18637	19682	62	was	be	VBD
18637	19682	63	without	without	IN
18637	19682	64	friends	friend	NNS
18637	19682	65	or	or	CC
18637	19682	66	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19682	67	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19682	68	.	.	.
18637	19683	1	After	after	IN
18637	19683	2	having	have	VBG
18637	19683	3	had	have	VBD
18637	19683	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19683	5	confession	confession	NN
18637	19683	6	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	19683	7	to	to	IN
18637	19683	8	writing	writing	NN
18637	19683	9	,	,	,
18637	19683	10	the	the	DT
18637	19683	11	boy	boy	NN
18637	19683	12	continued	continue	VBD
18637	19683	13	to	to	TO
18637	19683	14	be	be	VB
18637	19683	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	19683	16	_	_	NNP
18637	19683	17	incommunicado	incommunicado	NNP
18637	19683	18	_	_	NNP
18637	19683	19	for	for	IN
18637	19683	20	three	three	CD
18637	19683	21	days	day	NNS
18637	19683	22	before	before	IN
18637	19683	23	being	be	VBG
18637	19683	24	arraigned	arraign	VBN
18637	19683	25	.	.	.
18637	19684	1	"	"	``
18637	19684	2	The	the	DT
18637	19684	3	age	age	NN
18637	19684	4	of	of	IN
18637	19684	5	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	19684	6	,	,	,
18637	19684	7	the	the	DT
18637	19684	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19684	9	midnight	midnight	NN
18637	19684	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19684	11	hours	hour	NNS
18637	19684	12	when	when	WRB
18637	19684	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19684	14	was	be	VBD
18637	19684	15	grilled	grill	VBN
18637	19684	16	,	,	,
18637	19684	17	the	the	DT
18637	19684	18	duration	duration	NN
18637	19684	19	of	of	IN
18637	19684	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19684	21	quizzing	quizzing	NN
18637	19684	22	,	,	,
18637	19684	23	the	the	DT
18637	19684	24	fact	fact	NN
18637	19684	25	that	that	IN
18637	19684	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19684	27	had	have	VBD
18637	19684	28	no	no	DT
18637	19684	29	friend	friend	NN
18637	19684	30	or	or	CC
18637	19684	31	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19684	32	to	to	TO
18637	19684	33	advise	advise	VB
18637	19684	34	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19684	35	,	,	,
18637	19684	36	the	the	DT
18637	19684	37	callous	callous	JJ
18637	19684	38	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	19684	39	of	of	IN
18637	19684	40	the	the	DT
18637	19684	41	police	police	NN
18637	19684	42	towards	towards	IN
18637	19684	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19684	44	rights	right	NNS
18637	19684	45	combine	combine	VBP
18637	19684	46	to	to	TO
18637	19684	47	convince	convince	VB
18637	19684	48	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19684	49	,	,	,
18637	19684	50	"	"	''
18637	19684	51	the	the	DT
18637	19684	52	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19684	53	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19684	54	,	,	,
18637	19684	55	"	"	``
18637	19684	56	that	that	IN
18637	19684	57	this	this	DT
18637	19684	58	was	be	VBD
18637	19684	59	a	a	DT
18637	19684	60	confession	confession	NN
18637	19684	61	wrung	wrung	NN
18637	19684	62	from	from	IN
18637	19684	63	a	a	DT
18637	19684	64	child	child	NN
18637	19684	65	by	by	IN
18637	19684	66	means	mean	NNS
18637	19684	67	which	which	WDT
18637	19684	68	the	the	DT
18637	19684	69	law	law	NN
18637	19684	70	should	should	MD
18637	19684	71	not	not	RB
18637	19684	72	sanction	sanction	VB
18637	19684	73	.	.	.
18637	19685	1	"	"	``
18637	19685	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19685	3	904	904	CD
18637	19685	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19685	5	The	the	DT
18637	19685	6	application	application	NN
18637	19685	7	of	of	IN
18637	19685	8	duress	duress	NN
18637	19685	9	being	be	VBG
18637	19685	10	indisputed	indispute	VBN
18637	19685	11	,	,	,
18637	19685	12	a	a	DT
18637	19685	13	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	19685	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19685	15	,	,	,
18637	19685	16	in	in	IN
18637	19685	17	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	19685	18	_	_	NNP
18637	19685	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	19685	20	_	_	NNP
18637	19685	21	Mississippi,[905	Mississippi,[905	NNP
18637	19685	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19685	23	citing	cite	VBG
18637	19685	24	as	as	IN
18637	19685	25	authority	authority	NN
18637	19685	26	all	all	PDT
18637	19685	27	the	the	DT
18637	19685	28	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	19685	29	cases	case	NNS
18637	19685	30	beginning	begin	VBG
18637	19685	31	with	with	IN
18637	19685	32	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	19685	33	_	_	NNP
18637	19685	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	19685	35	_	_	NNP
18637	19685	36	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	19685	37	,	,	,
18637	19685	38	held	hold	VBD
18637	19685	39	that	that	IN
18637	19685	40	"	"	``
18637	19685	41	a	a	DT
18637	19685	42	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19685	43	resulting	result	VBG
18637	19685	44	from	from	IN
18637	19685	45	such	such	JJ
18637	19685	46	use	use	NN
18637	19685	47	of	of	IN
18637	19685	48	a	a	DT
18637	19685	49	coerced	coerced	JJ
18637	19685	50	confession	confession	NN
18637	19685	51	,	,	,
18637	19685	52	however	however	RB
18637	19685	53	,	,	,
18637	19685	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	19685	55	no	no	DT
18637	19685	56	less	less	RBR
18637	19685	57	void	void	JJ
18637	19685	58	because	because	IN
18637	19685	59	the	the	DT
18637	19685	60	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19685	61	testified	testify	VBD
18637	19685	62	at	at	IN
18637	19685	63	some	some	DT
18637	19685	64	point	point	NN
18637	19685	65	in	in	IN
18637	19685	66	the	the	DT
18637	19685	67	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19685	68	that	that	IN
18637	19685	69	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19685	70	had	have	VBD
18637	19685	71	never	never	RB
18637	19685	72	in	in	IN
18637	19685	73	fact	fact	NN
18637	19685	74	confessed	confess	VBN
18637	19685	75	,	,	,
18637	19685	76	voluntarily	voluntarily	RB
18637	19685	77	or	or	CC
18637	19685	78	involuntarily	involuntarily	RB
18637	19685	79	.	.	.
18637	19686	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	4	,	,	,
18637	19686	5	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	19686	6	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19686	7	as	as	IN
18637	19686	8	to	to	IN
18637	19686	9	the	the	DT
18637	19686	10	confession	confession	NN
18637	19686	11	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	12	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	13	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	14	can	can	MD
18637	19686	15	not	not	RB
18637	19686	16	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	19686	17	the	the	DT
18637	19686	18	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19686	19	from	from	IN
18637	19686	20	raising	raise	VBG
18637	19686	21	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	22	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	23	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	24	the	the	DT
18637	19686	25	issue	issue	NN
18637	19686	26	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	27	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	28	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	29	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19686	30	that	that	IN
18637	19686	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19686	32	the	the	DT
18637	19686	33	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19686	34	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19686	35	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	36	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	37	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	38	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19686	39	voids	void	NNS
18637	19686	40	a	a	DT
18637	19686	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19686	42	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19686	43	grounded	ground	VBN
18637	19686	44	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	45	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	46	*	*	NFP
18637	19686	47	upon	upon	IN
18637	19686	48	a	a	DT
18637	19686	49	confession	confession	NN
18637	19686	50	which	which	WDT
18637	19686	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	19686	52	the	the	DT
18637	19686	53	product	product	NN
18637	19686	54	of	of	IN
18637	19686	55	other	other	JJ
18637	19686	56	than	than	IN
18637	19686	57	reasoned	reason	VBN
18637	19686	58	and	and	CC
18637	19686	59	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	19686	60	choice	choice	NN
18637	19686	61	.	.	.
18637	19686	62	"	"	''
18637	19687	1	In	in	IN
18637	19687	2	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	19687	3	_	_	NNP
18637	19687	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	19687	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19687	6	Alabama,[906	Alabama,[906	NNP
18637	19687	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19687	8	however	however	RB
18637	19687	9	,	,	,
18637	19687	10	a	a	DT
18637	19687	11	majority	majority	NN
18637	19687	12	of	of	IN
18637	19687	13	the	the	DT
18637	19687	14	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19687	15	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	19687	16	the	the	DT
18637	19687	17	denial	denial	NN
18637	19687	18	by	by	IN
18637	19687	19	a	a	DT
18637	19687	20	State	State	NNP
18637	19687	21	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19687	22	court	court	NN
18637	19687	23	,	,	,
18637	19687	24	in	in	IN
18637	19687	25	which	which	WDT
18637	19687	26	a	a	DT
18637	19687	27	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19687	28	had	have	VBD
18637	19687	29	been	be	VBN
18637	19687	30	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	19687	31	,	,	,
18637	19687	32	of	of	IN
18637	19687	33	leave	leave	NN
18637	19687	34	to	to	TO
18637	19687	35	file	file	VB
18637	19687	36	in	in	IN
18637	19687	37	a	a	DT
18637	19687	38	trial	trial	NN
18637	19687	39	court	court	NN
18637	19687	40	a	a	DT
18637	19687	41	petition	petition	NN
18637	19687	42	for	for	IN
18637	19687	43	a	a	DT
18637	19687	44	writ	writ	NN
18637	19687	45	of	of	IN
18637	19687	46	error	error	NN
18637	19687	47	_	_	NNP
18637	19687	48	coram	coram	NNP
18637	19687	49	nobis	nobis	NNP
18637	19687	50	_	_	NNP
18637	19687	51	grounded	ground	VBN
18637	19687	52	upon	upon	IN
18637	19687	53	the	the	DT
18637	19687	54	contention	contention	NN
18637	19687	55	that	that	IN
18637	19687	56	confessions	confession	NNS
18637	19687	57	and	and	CC
18637	19687	58	admissions	admission	NNS
18637	19687	59	introduced	introduce	VBN
18637	19687	60	into	into	IN
18637	19687	61	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19687	62	at	at	IN
18637	19687	63	the	the	DT
18637	19687	64	trial	trial	NN
18637	19687	65	had	have	VBD
18637	19687	66	been	be	VBN
18637	19687	67	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19687	68	by	by	IN
18637	19687	69	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	19687	70	.	.	.
18637	19688	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19688	2	907	907	CD
18637	19688	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19688	4	Five	five	CD
18637	19688	5	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	19688	6	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19688	7	that	that	IN
18637	19688	8	such	such	JJ
18637	19688	9	denial	denial	NN
18637	19688	10	was	be	VBD
18637	19688	11	not	not	RB
18637	19688	12	such	such	JJ
18637	19688	13	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19688	14	action	action	NN
18637	19688	15	as	as	IN
18637	19688	16	in	in	IN
18637	19688	17	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19688	18	to	to	TO
18637	19688	19	amount	amount	VB
18637	19688	20	to	to	IN
18637	19688	21	a	a	DT
18637	19688	22	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19688	23	of	of	IN
18637	19688	24	due	due	JJ
18637	19688	25	process	process	NN
18637	19688	26	of	of	IN
18637	19688	27	law	law	NN
18637	19688	28	where	where	WRB
18637	19688	29	the	the	DT
18637	19688	30	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19688	31	tended	tend	VBD
18637	19688	32	to	to	TO
18637	19688	33	show	show	VB
18637	19688	34	that	that	IN
18637	19688	35	the	the	DT
18637	19688	36	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	19688	37	's	's	POS
18637	19688	38	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	19688	39	of	of	IN
18637	19688	40	mistreatment	mistreatment	NN
18637	19688	41	,	,	,
18637	19688	42	none	none	NN
18637	19688	43	of	of	IN
18637	19688	44	which	which	WDT
18637	19688	45	were	be	VBD
18637	19688	46	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	19688	47	during	during	IN
18637	19688	48	the	the	DT
18637	19688	49	trial	trial	NN
18637	19688	50	or	or	CC
18637	19688	51	the	the	DT
18637	19688	52	appeal,[908	appeal,[908	NN
18637	19688	53	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19688	54	were	be	VBD
18637	19688	55	highly	highly	RB
18637	19688	56	improbable	improbable	JJ
18637	19688	57	.	.	.
18637	19689	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19689	2	909	909	CD
18637	19689	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19689	4	Finally	finally	RB
18637	19689	5	,	,	,
18637	19689	6	in	in	IN
18637	19689	7	three	three	CD
18637	19689	8	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19689	9	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19689	10	on	on	IN
18637	19689	11	June	June	NNP
18637	19689	12	27	27	CD
18637	19689	13	,	,	,
18637	19689	14	1949	1949	CD
18637	19689	15	,	,	,
18637	19689	16	the	the	DT
18637	19689	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19689	18	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	19689	19	three	three	CD
18637	19689	20	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	19689	21	of	of	IN
18637	19689	22	murder	murder	NN
18637	19689	23	on	on	IN
18637	19689	24	the	the	DT
18637	19689	25	ground	ground	NN
18637	19689	26	that	that	IN
18637	19689	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19689	28	had	have	VBD
18637	19689	29	been	be	VBN
18637	19689	30	founded	found	VBN
18637	19689	31	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	19689	32	upon	upon	IN
18637	19689	33	coerced	coerced	JJ
18637	19689	34	confessions	confession	NNS
18637	19689	35	.	.	.
18637	19690	1	The	the	DT
18637	19690	2	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19690	3	in	in	IN
18637	19690	4	the	the	DT
18637	19690	5	first	first	JJ
18637	19690	6	case	case	NN
18637	19690	7	,	,	,
18637	19690	8	Watts	Watts	NNP
18637	19690	9	_	_	NNP
18637	19690	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	19690	11	_	_	NNP
18637	19690	12	Indiana,[910	Indiana,[910	NNP
18637	19690	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19690	14	was	be	VBD
18637	19690	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	19690	16	without	without	IN
18637	19690	17	arraignment	arraignment	NN
18637	19690	18	,	,	,
18637	19690	19	without	without	IN
18637	19690	20	the	the	DT
18637	19690	21	aid	aid	NN
18637	19690	22	of	of	IN
18637	19690	23	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19690	24	or	or	CC
18637	19690	25	friends	friend	NNS
18637	19690	26	,	,	,
18637	19690	27	and	and	CC
18637	19690	28	without	without	IN
18637	19690	29	advice	advice	NN
18637	19690	30	as	as	IN
18637	19690	31	to	to	IN
18637	19690	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19690	33	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19690	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	19690	35	from	from	IN
18637	19690	36	Wednesday	Wednesday	NNP
18637	19690	37	until	until	IN
18637	19690	38	the	the	DT
18637	19690	39	following	follow	VBG
18637	19690	40	Friday	Friday	NNP
18637	19690	41	,	,	,
18637	19690	42	when	when	WRB
18637	19690	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19690	44	confessed	confess	VBD
18637	19690	45	.	.	.
18637	19691	1	During	during	IN
18637	19691	2	this	this	DT
18637	19691	3	interval	interval	NN
18637	19691	4	,	,	,
18637	19691	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19691	6	was	be	VBD
18637	19691	7	held	hold	VBN
18637	19691	8	much	much	JJ
18637	19691	9	of	of	IN
18637	19691	10	the	the	DT
18637	19691	11	time	time	NN
18637	19691	12	in	in	IN
18637	19691	13	solitary	solitary	JJ
18637	19691	14	confinement	confinement	NN
18637	19691	15	in	in	IN
18637	19691	16	a	a	DT
18637	19691	17	cell	cell	NN
18637	19691	18	with	with	IN
18637	19691	19	no	no	DT
18637	19691	20	place	place	NN
18637	19691	21	to	to	TO
18637	19691	22	sit	sit	VB
18637	19691	23	or	or	CC
18637	19691	24	sleep	sleep	VB
18637	19691	25	except	except	IN
18637	19691	26	the	the	DT
18637	19691	27	floor	floor	NN
18637	19691	28	,	,	,
18637	19691	29	and	and	CC
18637	19691	30	was	be	VBD
18637	19691	31	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	19691	32	to	to	IN
18637	19691	33	interrogation	interrogation	NN
18637	19691	34	daily	daily	RB
18637	19691	35	,	,	,
18637	19691	36	Sunday	Sunday	NNP
18637	19691	37	excepted	except	VBD
18637	19691	38	,	,	,
18637	19691	39	by	by	IN
18637	19691	40	relays	relay	NNS
18637	19691	41	of	of	IN
18637	19691	42	police	police	NN
18637	19691	43	officers	officer	NNS
18637	19691	44	for	for	IN
18637	19691	45	periods	period	NNS
18637	19691	46	ranging	range	VBG
18637	19691	47	in	in	IN
18637	19691	48	duration	duration	NN
18637	19691	49	from	from	IN
18637	19691	50	three	three	CD
18637	19691	51	to	to	IN
18637	19691	52	nine	nine	CD
18637	19691	53	and	and	CC
18637	19691	54	one	one	CD
18637	19691	55	-	-	HYPH
18637	19691	56	half	half	NN
18637	19691	57	hours	hour	NNS
18637	19691	58	.	.	.
18637	19692	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19692	2	incarceration	incarceration	NN
18637	19692	3	without	without	IN
18637	19692	4	a	a	DT
18637	19692	5	prompt	prompt	JJ
18637	19692	6	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	19692	7	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19692	8	also	also	RB
18637	19692	9	was	be	VBD
18637	19692	10	a	a	DT
18637	19692	11	violation	violation	NN
18637	19692	12	of	of	IN
18637	19692	13	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	19692	14	law	law	NN
18637	19692	15	.	.	.
18637	19693	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19693	2	in	in	IN
18637	19693	3	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	19693	4	with	with	IN
18637	19693	5	State	State	NNP
18637	19693	6	law	law	NN
18637	19693	7	was	be	VBD
18637	19693	8	the	the	DT
18637	19693	9	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	19693	10	without	without	IN
18637	19693	11	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	19693	12	and	and	CC
18637	19693	13	detention	detention	NN
18637	19693	14	without	without	IN
18637	19693	15	arraignment	arraignment	NN
18637	19693	16	for	for	IN
18637	19693	17	five	five	CD
18637	19693	18	days	day	NNS
18637	19693	19	of	of	IN
18637	19693	20	the	the	DT
18637	19693	21	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19693	22	in	in	IN
18637	19693	23	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	19693	24	_	_	NNP
18637	19693	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	19693	26	_	_	NNP
18637	19693	27	Pennsylvania,[911	Pennsylvania,[911	NNP
18637	19693	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19693	29	the	the	DT
18637	19693	30	second	second	JJ
18637	19693	31	case	case	NN
18637	19693	32	.	.	.
18637	19694	1	During	during	IN
18637	19694	2	this	this	DT
18637	19694	3	period	period	NN
18637	19694	4	,	,	,
18637	19694	5	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	19694	6	was	be	VBD
18637	19694	7	not	not	RB
18637	19694	8	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	19694	9	to	to	TO
18637	19694	10	see	see	VB
18637	19694	11	friends	friend	NNS
18637	19694	12	,	,	,
18637	19694	13	relatives	relative	NNS
18637	19694	14	,	,	,
18637	19694	15	or	or	CC
18637	19694	16	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19694	17	,	,	,
18637	19694	18	was	be	VBD
18637	19694	19	never	never	RB
18637	19694	20	informed	inform	VBN
18637	19694	21	of	of	IN
18637	19694	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19694	23	right	right	NN
18637	19694	24	to	to	TO
18637	19694	25	remain	remain	VB
18637	19694	26	silent	silent	JJ
18637	19694	27	,	,	,
18637	19694	28	and	and	CC
18637	19694	29	was	be	VBD
18637	19694	30	interrogated	interrogate	VBN
18637	19694	31	daily	daily	RB
18637	19694	32	,	,	,
18637	19694	33	though	though	IN
18637	19694	34	for	for	IN
18637	19694	35	briefer	briefer	NN
18637	19694	36	intervals	interval	NNS
18637	19694	37	than	than	IN
18637	19694	38	in	in	IN
18637	19694	39	the	the	DT
18637	19694	40	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	19694	41	case	case	NN
18637	19694	42	.	.	.
18637	19695	1	At	at	IN
18637	19695	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19695	3	trial	trial	NN
18637	19695	4	,	,	,
18637	19695	5	the	the	DT
18637	19695	6	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
18637	19695	7	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	19695	8	"	"	``
18637	19695	9	admitted	admit	VBD
18637	19695	10	that	that	IN
18637	19695	11	a	a	DT
18637	19695	12	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19695	13	was	be	VBD
18637	19695	14	withheld	withhold	VBN
18637	19695	15	until	until	IN
18637	19695	16	interrogation	interrogation	NN
18637	19695	17	had	have	VBD
18637	19695	18	produced	produce	VBN
18637	19695	19	a	a	DT
18637	19695	20	confession	confession	NN
18637	19695	21	.	.	.
18637	19695	22	"	"	''
18637	19696	1	In	in	IN
18637	19696	2	the	the	DT
18637	19696	3	third	third	JJ
18637	19696	4	and	and	CC
18637	19696	5	last	last	JJ
18637	19696	6	case	case	NN
18637	19696	7	of	of	IN
18637	19696	8	this	this	DT
18637	19696	9	group	group	NN
18637	19696	10	,	,	,
18637	19696	11	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	19696	12	_	_	NNP
18637	19696	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	19696	14	_	_	NNP
18637	19696	15	South	South	NNP
18637	19696	16	Carolina,[912	Carolina,[912	NNP
18637	19696	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19696	18	the	the	DT
18637	19696	19	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19696	20	,	,	,
18637	19696	21	an	an	DT
18637	19696	22	illiterate	illiterate	JJ
18637	19696	23	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	19696	24	,	,	,
18637	19696	25	was	be	VBD
18637	19696	26	apprehended	apprehend	VBN
18637	19696	27	in	in	IN
18637	19696	28	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	19696	29	on	on	IN
18637	19696	30	a	a	DT
18637	19696	31	Friday	Friday	NNP
18637	19696	32	on	on	IN
18637	19696	33	a	a	DT
18637	19696	34	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	19696	35	alleging	allege	VBG
18637	19696	36	no	no	RB
18637	19696	37	more	more	JJR
18637	19696	38	than	than	IN
18637	19696	39	a	a	DT
18637	19696	40	theft	theft	NN
18637	19696	41	of	of	IN
18637	19696	42	a	a	DT
18637	19696	43	pistol	pistol	NN
18637	19696	44	,	,	,
18637	19696	45	and	and	CC
18637	19696	46	taken	take	VBN
18637	19696	47	to	to	IN
18637	19696	48	South	South	NNP
18637	19696	49	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	19696	50	on	on	IN
18637	19696	51	a	a	DT
18637	19696	52	Sunday	Sunday	NNP
18637	19696	53	.	.	.
18637	19697	1	Without	without	IN
18637	19697	2	being	be	VBG
18637	19697	3	informed	inform	VBN
18637	19697	4	of	of	IN
18637	19697	5	the	the	DT
18637	19697	6	contents	content	NNS
18637	19697	7	of	of	IN
18637	19697	8	the	the	DT
18637	19697	9	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	19697	10	or	or	CC
18637	19697	11	of	of	IN
18637	19697	12	the	the	DT
18637	19697	13	charge	charge	NN
18637	19697	14	of	of	IN
18637	19697	15	murder	murder	NN
18637	19697	16	on	on	IN
18637	19697	17	which	which	WDT
18637	19697	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19697	19	was	be	VBD
18637	19697	20	being	be	VBG
18637	19697	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	19697	22	,	,	,
18637	19697	23	without	without	IN
18637	19697	24	arraignment	arraignment	NN
18637	19697	25	or	or	CC
18637	19697	26	advice	advice	NN
18637	19697	27	as	as	IN
18637	19697	28	to	to	IN
18637	19697	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19697	30	rights	right	NNS
18637	19697	31	and	and	CC
18637	19697	32	without	without	IN
18637	19697	33	access	access	NN
18637	19697	34	to	to	IN
18637	19697	35	family	family	NN
18637	19697	36	or	or	CC
18637	19697	37	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19697	38	,	,	,
18637	19697	39	the	the	DT
18637	19697	40	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19697	41	was	be	VBD
18637	19697	42	questioned	question	VBN
18637	19697	43	daily	daily	RB
18637	19697	44	by	by	IN
18637	19697	45	officers	officer	NNS
18637	19697	46	for	for	IN
18637	19697	47	periods	period	NNS
18637	19697	48	as	as	RB
18637	19697	49	long	long	JJ
18637	19697	50	as	as	IN
18637	19697	51	12	12	CD
18637	19697	52	hours	hour	NNS
18637	19697	53	.	.	.
18637	19698	1	In	in	IN
18637	19698	2	addition	addition	NN
18637	19698	3	,	,	,
18637	19698	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19698	5	was	be	VBD
18637	19698	6	warned	warn	VBN
18637	19698	7	that	that	IN
18637	19698	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19698	9	mother	mother	NN
18637	19698	10	also	also	RB
18637	19698	11	might	may	MD
18637	19698	12	be	be	VB
18637	19698	13	arrested	arrest	VBN
18637	19698	14	for	for	IN
18637	19698	15	handling	handle	VBG
18637	19698	16	stolen	steal	VBN
18637	19698	17	property	property	NN
18637	19698	18	.	.	.
18637	19699	1	In	in	IN
18637	19699	2	each	each	DT
18637	19699	3	of	of	IN
18637	19699	4	these	these	DT
18637	19699	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	19699	6	there	there	EX
18637	19699	7	was	be	VBD
18637	19699	8	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	19699	9	,	,	,
18637	19699	10	and	and	CC
18637	19699	11	in	in	IN
18637	19699	12	none	none	NN
18637	19699	13	was	be	VBD
18637	19699	14	the	the	DT
18637	19699	15	majority	majority	NN
18637	19699	16	able	able	JJ
18637	19699	17	to	to	TO
18637	19699	18	record	record	VB
18637	19699	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19699	20	views	view	NNS
18637	19699	21	in	in	IN
18637	19699	22	a	a	DT
18637	19699	23	single	single	JJ
18637	19699	24	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	19699	25	.	.	.
18637	19700	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19700	2	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	19700	3	and	and	CC
18637	19700	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19700	5	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	19700	6	joined	join	VBD
18637	19700	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19700	8	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	19700	9	,	,	,
18637	19700	10	who	who	WP
18637	19700	11	filed	file	VBD
18637	19700	12	a	a	DT
18637	19700	13	separate	separate	JJ
18637	19700	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	19700	15	in	in	IN
18637	19700	16	all	all	DT
18637	19700	17	three	three	CD
18637	19700	18	cases	case	NNS
18637	19700	19	,	,	,
18637	19700	20	in	in	IN
18637	19700	21	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	19700	22	that	that	IN
18637	19700	23	"	"	``
18637	19700	24	a	a	DT
18637	19700	25	confession	confession	NN
18637	19700	26	by	by	IN
18637	19700	27	which	which	WDT
18637	19700	28	life	life	NN
18637	19700	29	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	19700	30	forfeit	forfeit	NN
18637	19700	31	must	must	MD
18637	19700	32	be	be	VB
18637	19700	33	the	the	DT
18637	19700	34	expression	expression	NN
18637	19700	35	of	of	IN
18637	19700	36	free	free	JJ
18637	19700	37	choice	choice	NN
18637	19700	38	.	.	.
18637	19701	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19701	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19701	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19701	4	When	when	WRB
18637	19701	5	a	a	DT
18637	19701	6	suspect	suspect	NN
18637	19701	7	speaks	speak	VBZ
18637	19701	8	because	because	IN
18637	19701	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19701	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	19701	11	overborne	overborne	JJ
18637	19701	12	,	,	,
18637	19701	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19701	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19701	15	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
18637	19701	16	whether	whether	IN
18637	19701	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19701	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	19701	19	been	be	VBN
18637	19701	20	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	19701	21	to	to	IN
18637	19701	22	a	a	DT
18637	19701	23	physical	physical	NN
18637	19701	24	or	or	CC
18637	19701	25	a	a	DT
18637	19701	26	mental	mental	JJ
18637	19701	27	ordeal	ordeal	NN
18637	19701	28	.	.	.
18637	19702	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19702	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19702	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19702	4	if	if	IN
18637	19702	5	*	*	NFP
18637	19702	6	*	*	NFP
18637	19702	7	*	*	NFP
18637	19702	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19702	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19702	10	confession	confession	NN
18637	19702	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19702	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	19702	13	the	the	DT
18637	19702	14	product	product	NN
18637	19702	15	of	of	IN
18637	19702	16	sustained	sustained	JJ
18637	19702	17	pressure	pressure	NN
18637	19702	18	by	by	IN
18637	19702	19	the	the	DT
18637	19702	20	police	police	NN
18637	19702	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19702	22	does	do	VBZ
18637	19702	23	not	not	RB
18637	19702	24	issue	issue	VB
18637	19702	25	from	from	IN
18637	19702	26	a	a	DT
18637	19702	27	free	free	JJ
18637	19702	28	choice	choice	NN
18637	19702	29	.	.	.
18637	19703	1	"	"	``
18637	19703	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19703	3	913	913	CD
18637	19703	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19703	5	On	on	IN
18637	19703	6	the	the	DT
18637	19703	7	authority	authority	NN
18637	19703	8	of	of	IN
18637	19703	9	Chambers	Chambers	NNP
18637	19703	10	_	_	NNP
18637	19703	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	19703	12	_	_	NNP
18637	19703	13	Florida[914	Florida[914	NNP
18637	19703	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19703	15	and	and	CC
18637	19703	16	Ashcraft	Ashcraft	NNP
18637	19703	17	_	_	NNP
18637	19703	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	19703	19	_	_	NNP
18637	19703	20	Tennessee,[915	Tennessee,[915	NNP
18637	19703	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19703	22	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19703	23	Black	Black	NNP
18637	19703	24	supported	support	VBD
18637	19703	25	the	the	DT
18637	19703	26	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	19703	27	reached	reach	VBN
18637	19703	28	in	in	IN
18637	19703	29	all	all	DT
18637	19703	30	three	three	CD
18637	19703	31	cases	case	NNS
18637	19703	32	;	;	:
18637	19703	33	but	but	CC
18637	19703	34	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19703	35	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	19703	36	,	,	,
18637	19703	37	in	in	IN
18637	19703	38	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	19703	39	,	,	,
18637	19703	40	advocated	advocate	VBD
18637	19703	41	the	the	DT
18637	19703	42	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	19703	43	of	of	IN
18637	19703	44	these	these	DT
18637	19703	45	cases	case	NNS
18637	19703	46	in	in	IN
18637	19703	47	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	19703	48	with	with	IN
18637	19703	49	a	a	DT
18637	19703	50	broader	broad	JJR
18637	19703	51	rule	rule	NN
18637	19703	52	;	;	:
18637	19703	53	namely	namely	RB
18637	19703	54	that	that	IN
18637	19703	55	,	,	,
18637	19703	56	"	"	''
18637	19703	57	any	any	DT
18637	19703	58	confession	confession	NN
18637	19703	59	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19703	60	during	during	IN
18637	19703	61	*	*	NFP
18637	19703	62	*	*	NFP
18637	19703	63	*	*	NFP
18637	19703	64	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19703	65	a	a	DT
18637	19703	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19703	67	period	period	NN
18637	19703	68	of	of	IN
18637	19703	69	*	*	NFP
18637	19703	70	*	*	NFP
18637	19703	71	*	*	NFP
18637	19703	72	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	19703	73	detention	detention	NN
18637	19703	74	"	"	''
18637	19703	75	;	;	:
18637	19703	76	that	that	DT
18637	19703	77	is	be	VBZ
18637	19703	78	during	during	IN
18637	19703	79	a	a	DT
18637	19703	80	period	period	NN
18637	19703	81	of	of	IN
18637	19703	82	custody	custody	NN
18637	19703	83	between	between	IN
18637	19703	84	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	19703	85	and	and	CC
18637	19703	86	arraignment	arraignment	NN
18637	19703	87	,	,	,
18637	19703	88	should	should	MD
18637	19703	89	be	be	VB
18637	19703	90	outlawed	outlaw	VBN
18637	19703	91	.	.	.
18637	19704	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19704	2	916	916	CD
18637	19704	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19704	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19704	5	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	19704	6	,	,	,
18637	19704	7	who	who	WP
18637	19704	8	wrote	write	VBD
18637	19704	9	an	an	DT
18637	19704	10	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	19704	11	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	19704	12	to	to	IN
18637	19704	13	all	all	DT
18637	19704	14	three	three	CD
18637	19704	15	cases	case	NNS
18637	19704	16	,	,	,
18637	19704	17	concurred	concur	VBN
18637	19704	18	in	in	IN
18637	19704	19	the	the	DT
18637	19704	20	result	result	NN
18637	19704	21	in	in	IN
18637	19704	22	Watts	Watts	NNP
18637	19704	23	_	_	NNP
18637	19704	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	19704	25	_	_	NNP
18637	19704	26	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	19704	27	,	,	,
18637	19704	28	presumably	presumably	RB
18637	19704	29	on	on	IN
18637	19704	30	the	the	DT
18637	19704	31	basis	basis	NN
18637	19704	32	of	of	IN
18637	19704	33	that	that	DT
18637	19704	34	part	part	NN
18637	19704	35	of	of	IN
18637	19704	36	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19704	37	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	19704	38	's	's	POS
18637	19704	39	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	19704	40	therein	therein	RB
18637	19704	41	which	which	WDT
18637	19704	42	was	be	VBD
18637	19704	43	founded	found	VBN
18637	19704	44	"	"	''
18637	19704	45	on	on	IN
18637	19704	46	the	the	DT
18637	19704	47	State	state	NN
18637	19704	48	's	's	POS
18637	19704	49	admissions	admission	NNS
18637	19704	50	as	as	IN
18637	19704	51	to	to	IN
18637	19704	52	the	the	DT
18637	19704	53	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	19704	54	of	of	IN
18637	19704	55	Watts	Watts	NNP
18637	19704	56	.	.	.
18637	19705	1	"	"	``
18637	19705	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19705	3	917	917	CD
18637	19705	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19705	5	Emphasizing	emphasize	VBG
18637	19705	6	the	the	DT
18637	19705	7	merit	merit	NN
18637	19705	8	of	of	IN
18637	19705	9	deferring	defer	VBG
18637	19705	10	to	to	IN
18637	19705	11	the	the	DT
18637	19705	12	findings	finding	NNS
18637	19705	13	of	of	IN
18637	19705	14	trial	trial	NN
18637	19705	15	court	court	NN
18637	19705	16	and	and	CC
18637	19705	17	jury	jury	NN
18637	19705	18	on	on	IN
18637	19705	19	the	the	DT
18637	19705	20	issue	issue	NN
18637	19705	21	of	of	IN
18637	19705	22	the	the	DT
18637	19705	23	"	"	``
18637	19705	24	voluntariness	voluntariness	JJ
18637	19705	25	"	"	''
18637	19705	26	of	of	IN
18637	19705	27	confessions	confession	NNS
18637	19705	28	on	on	IN
18637	19705	29	the	the	DT
18637	19705	30	ground	ground	NN
18637	19705	31	that	that	IN
18637	19705	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19705	33	have	have	VBP
18637	19705	34	"	"	``
18637	19705	35	the	the	DT
18637	19705	36	great	great	JJ
18637	19705	37	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	19705	38	of	of	IN
18637	19705	39	hearing	hear	VBG
18637	19705	40	and	and	CC
18637	19705	41	seeing	see	VBG
18637	19705	42	the	the	DT
18637	19705	43	confessor	confessor	NN
18637	19705	44	and	and	CC
18637	19705	45	also	also	RB
18637	19705	46	the	the	DT
18637	19705	47	officers	officer	NNS
18637	19705	48	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19705	49	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	19705	50	and	and	CC
18637	19705	51	bearing	bear	VBG
18637	19705	52	toward	toward	IN
18637	19705	53	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19705	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	19705	55	in	in	IN
18637	19705	56	question	question	NN
18637	19705	57	,	,	,
18637	19705	58	"	"	''
18637	19705	59	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19705	60	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	19705	61	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	19705	62	in	in	IN
18637	19705	63	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	19705	64	_	_	NNP
18637	19705	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	19705	66	_	_	NNP
18637	19705	67	Pennsylvania[918	Pennsylvania[918	NNP
18637	19705	68	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19705	69	and	and	CC
18637	19705	70	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	19705	71	_	_	NNP
18637	19705	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	19705	73	_	_	NNP
18637	19705	74	South	South	NNP
18637	19705	75	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	19705	76	.	.	.
18637	19706	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19706	2	919	919	CD
18637	19706	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19706	4	"	"	``
18637	19706	5	If	if	IN
18637	19706	6	the	the	DT
18637	19706	7	right	right	NN
18637	19706	8	of	of	IN
18637	19706	9	interrogation	interrogation	NN
18637	19706	10	be	be	VB
18637	19706	11	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	19706	12	,	,	,
18637	19706	13	"	"	''
18637	19706	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19706	15	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19706	16	,	,	,
18637	19706	17	"	"	``
18637	19706	18	then	then	RB
18637	19706	19	*	*	NFP
18637	19706	20	*	*	NFP
18637	19706	21	*	*	NFP
18637	19706	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19706	23	must	must	MD
18637	19706	24	leave	leave	VB
18637	19706	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19706	26	to	to	IN
18637	19706	27	trial	trial	NN
18637	19706	28	judges	judge	NNS
18637	19706	29	and	and	CC
18637	19706	30	juries	jury	NNS
18637	19706	31	and	and	CC
18637	19706	32	State	state	NN
18637	19706	33	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19706	34	courts	court	NNS
18637	19706	35	to	to	TO
18637	19706	36	decide	decide	VB
18637	19706	37	individual	individual	JJ
18637	19706	38	cases	case	NNS
18637	19706	39	,	,	,
18637	19706	40	unless	unless	IN
18637	19706	41	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19706	42	show	show	VBP
18637	19706	43	some	some	DT
18637	19706	44	want	want	NN
18637	19706	45	of	of	IN
18637	19706	46	proper	proper	JJ
18637	19706	47	standards	standard	NNS
18637	19706	48	of	of	IN
18637	19706	49	decision	decision	NN
18637	19706	50	.	.	.
18637	19707	1	"	"	``
18637	19707	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19707	3	920	920	CD
18637	19707	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19707	5	Without	without	IN
18637	19707	6	explanatory	explanatory	JJ
18637	19707	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	19707	8	,	,	,
18637	19707	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	19707	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19707	11	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	19707	12	and	and	CC
18637	19707	13	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19707	14	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	19707	15	and	and	CC
18637	19707	16	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	19707	17	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	19707	18	in	in	IN
18637	19707	19	all	all	DT
18637	19707	20	three	three	CD
18637	19707	21	cases	case	NNS
18637	19707	22	.	.	.
18637	19708	1	Unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19708	2	Searches	Searches	NNPS
18637	19708	3	and	and	CC
18637	19708	4	Seizures	Seizures	NNPS
18637	19708	5	In	in	IN
18637	19708	6	National	National	NNP
18637	19708	7	Safe	Safe	NNP
18637	19708	8	Deposit	Deposit	NNP
18637	19708	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	19708	10	_	_	NNP
18637	19708	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	19708	12	_	_	NNP
18637	19708	13	Stead,[921	Stead,[921	NNP
18637	19708	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19708	15	decided	decide	VBD
18637	19708	16	in	in	IN
18637	19708	17	1914	1914	CD
18637	19708	18	,	,	,
18637	19708	19	the	the	DT
18637	19708	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19708	21	unequivocally	unequivocally	RB
18637	19708	22	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19708	23	that	that	IN
18637	19708	24	an	an	DT
18637	19708	25	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19708	26	search	search	NN
18637	19708	27	and	and	CC
18637	19708	28	seizure	seizure	VB
18637	19708	29	committed	commit	VBN
18637	19708	30	by	by	IN
18637	19708	31	State	state	NN
18637	19708	32	and	and	CC
18637	19708	33	local	local	JJ
18637	19708	34	officers	officer	NNS
18637	19708	35	presented	present	VBD
18637	19708	36	no	no	DT
18637	19708	37	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19708	38	question	question	NN
18637	19708	39	,	,	,
18637	19708	40	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	19708	41	as	as	IN
18637	19708	42	the	the	DT
18637	19708	43	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	19708	44	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19708	45	does	do	VBZ
18637	19708	46	not	not	RB
18637	19708	47	apply	apply	VB
18637	19708	48	to	to	IN
18637	19708	49	the	the	DT
18637	19708	50	States	States	NNP
18637	19708	51	.	.	.
18637	19709	1	Prior	prior	RB
18637	19709	2	to	to	IN
18637	19709	3	that	that	DT
18637	19709	4	date	date	NN
18637	19709	5	,	,	,
18637	19709	6	the	the	DT
18637	19709	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19709	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	19709	9	passed	pass	VBN
18637	19709	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	19709	11	this	this	DT
18637	19709	12	question	question	NN
18637	19709	13	obliquely	obliquely	RB
18637	19709	14	in	in	IN
18637	19709	15	only	only	RB
18637	19709	16	a	a	DT
18637	19709	17	few	few	JJ
18637	19709	18	decisions,[922	decisions,[922	NN
18637	19709	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19709	20	in	in	IN
18637	19709	21	one	one	CD
18637	19709	22	of	of	IN
18637	19709	23	which	which	WDT
18637	19709	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19709	25	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	19709	26	for	for	IN
18637	19709	27	the	the	DT
18637	19709	28	sake	sake	NN
18637	19709	29	of	of	IN
18637	19709	30	argument	argument	NN
18637	19709	31	,	,	,
18637	19709	32	but	but	CC
18637	19709	33	without	without	IN
18637	19709	34	so	so	RB
18637	19709	35	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	19709	36	,	,	,
18637	19709	37	that	that	IN
18637	19709	38	the	the	DT
18637	19709	39	due	due	JJ
18637	19709	40	process	process	NN
18637	19709	41	clause	clause	NN
18637	19709	42	of	of	IN
18637	19709	43	the	the	DT
18637	19709	44	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19709	45	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19709	46	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	19709	47	in	in	IN
18637	19709	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19709	49	generic	generic	JJ
18637	19709	50	terms	term	NNS
18637	19709	51	a	a	DT
18637	19709	52	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	19709	53	against	against	IN
18637	19709	54	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19709	55	searches	search	NNS
18637	19709	56	.	.	.
18637	19710	1	In	in	IN
18637	19710	2	two	two	CD
18637	19710	3	of	of	IN
18637	19710	4	these	these	DT
18637	19710	5	earlier	early	JJR
18637	19710	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	19710	7	the	the	DT
18637	19710	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19710	9	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	19710	10	as	as	IN
18637	19710	11	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	19710	12	with	with	IN
18637	19710	13	due	due	JJ
18637	19710	14	process	process	NN
18637	19710	15	the	the	DT
18637	19710	16	power	power	NN
18637	19710	17	of	of	IN
18637	19710	18	a	a	DT
18637	19710	19	State	State	NNP
18637	19710	20	,	,	,
18637	19710	21	in	in	IN
18637	19710	22	investigating	investigate	VBG
18637	19710	23	the	the	DT
18637	19710	24	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	19710	25	of	of	IN
18637	19710	26	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19710	27	doing	do	VBG
18637	19710	28	business	business	NN
18637	19710	29	within	within	IN
18637	19710	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19710	31	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19710	32	,	,	,
18637	19710	33	to	to	TO
18637	19710	34	demand	demand	VB
18637	19710	35	the	the	DT
18637	19710	36	production	production	NN
18637	19710	37	of	of	IN
18637	19710	38	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	19710	39	books	book	NNS
18637	19710	40	and	and	CC
18637	19710	41	papers	paper	NNS
18637	19710	42	.	.	.
18637	19711	1	The	the	DT
18637	19711	2	call	call	NN
18637	19711	3	for	for	IN
18637	19711	4	such	such	JJ
18637	19711	5	papers	paper	NNS
18637	19711	6	was	be	VBD
18637	19711	7	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19711	8	not	not	RB
18637	19711	9	to	to	TO
18637	19711	10	have	have	VB
18637	19711	11	been	be	VBN
18637	19711	12	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19711	13	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19711	14	because	because	IN
18637	19711	15	,	,	,
18637	19711	16	at	at	IN
18637	19711	17	the	the	DT
18637	19711	18	time	time	NN
18637	19711	19	of	of	IN
18637	19711	20	the	the	DT
18637	19711	21	demand	demand	NN
18637	19711	22	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	19711	23	,	,	,
18637	19711	24	the	the	DT
18637	19711	25	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19711	26	affected	affect	VBD
18637	19711	27	either	either	CC
18637	19711	28	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	19711	29	or	or	CC
18637	19711	30	permanently	permanently	RB
18637	19711	31	kept	keep	VBN
18637	19711	32	such	such	JJ
18637	19711	33	documents	document	NNS
18637	19711	34	in	in	IN
18637	19711	35	another	another	DT
18637	19711	36	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19711	37	.	.	.
18637	19712	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	19712	2	was	be	VBD
18637	19712	3	the	the	DT
18637	19712	4	validity	validity	NN
18637	19712	5	of	of	IN
18637	19712	6	the	the	DT
18637	19712	7	order	order	NN
18637	19712	8	to	to	TO
18637	19712	9	produce	produce	VB
18637	19712	10	such	such	JJ
18637	19712	11	materials	material	NNS
18637	19712	12	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19712	13	as	as	IN
18637	19712	14	having	have	VBG
18637	19712	15	been	be	VBN
18637	19712	16	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	19712	17	by	by	IN
18637	19712	18	the	the	DT
18637	19712	19	fact	fact	NN
18637	19712	20	that	that	IN
18637	19712	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19712	22	sought	seek	VBD
18637	19712	23	to	to	IN
18637	19712	24	elicit	elicit	VB
18637	19712	25	proof	proof	NN
18637	19712	26	not	not	RB
18637	19712	27	only	only	RB
18637	19712	28	as	as	IN
18637	19712	29	to	to	IN
18637	19712	30	the	the	DT
18637	19712	31	liability	liability	NN
18637	19712	32	of	of	IN
18637	19712	33	the	the	DT
18637	19712	34	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19712	35	but	but	CC
18637	19712	36	also	also	RB
18637	19712	37	,	,	,
18637	19712	38	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19712	39	in	in	IN
18637	19712	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19712	41	possession	possession	NN
18637	19712	42	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	19712	43	to	to	IN
18637	19712	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19712	45	defense	defense	NN
18637	19712	46	.	.	.
18637	19713	1	In	in	IN
18637	19713	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19713	3	most	most	RBS
18637	19713	4	recent	recent	JJ
18637	19713	5	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19713	6	to	to	TO
18637	19713	7	review	review	VB
18637	19713	8	the	the	DT
18637	19713	9	question	question	NN
18637	19713	10	whether	whether	IN
18637	19713	11	the	the	DT
18637	19713	12	due	due	JJ
18637	19713	13	process	process	NN
18637	19713	14	clause	clause	NN
18637	19713	15	of	of	IN
18637	19713	16	the	the	DT
18637	19713	17	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19713	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19713	19	precludes	preclude	VBZ
18637	19713	20	admission	admission	NN
18637	19713	21	in	in	IN
18637	19713	22	a	a	DT
18637	19713	23	State	State	NNP
18637	19713	24	court	court	NN
18637	19713	25	of	of	IN
18637	19713	26	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	19713	27	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19713	28	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19713	29	by	by	IN
18637	19713	30	an	an	DT
18637	19713	31	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19713	32	search	search	NN
18637	19713	33	and	and	CC
18637	19713	34	seizure,[923	seizure,[923	NN
18637	19713	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19713	36	the	the	DT
18637	19713	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19713	38	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	19713	39	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	19713	40	in	in	IN
18637	19713	41	the	the	DT
18637	19713	42	negative	negative	JJ
18637	19713	43	;	;	:
18637	19713	44	but	but	CC
18637	19713	45	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19713	46	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	19713	47	,	,	,
18637	19713	48	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	19713	49	for	for	IN
18637	19713	50	the	the	DT
18637	19713	51	majority	majority	NN
18637	19713	52	,	,	,
18637	19713	53	did	do	VBD
18637	19713	54	not	not	RB
18637	19713	55	limit	limit	VB
18637	19713	56	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19713	57	to	to	IN
18637	19713	58	a	a	DT
18637	19713	59	repetition	repetition	NN
18637	19713	60	of	of	IN
18637	19713	61	the	the	DT
18637	19713	62	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
18637	19713	63	stated	state	VBN
18637	19713	64	by	by	IN
18637	19713	65	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19713	66	in	in	IN
18637	19713	67	Adamson	Adamson	NNP
18637	19713	68	_	_	NNP
18637	19713	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	19713	70	_	_	NNP
18637	19713	71	California;[924	California;[924	NNP
18637	19713	72	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19713	73	namely	namely	RB
18637	19713	74	,	,	,
18637	19713	75	that	that	IN
18637	19713	76	the	the	DT
18637	19713	77	due	due	JJ
18637	19713	78	process	process	NN
18637	19713	79	clause	clause	NN
18637	19713	80	of	of	IN
18637	19713	81	the	the	DT
18637	19713	82	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19713	83	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19713	84	did	do	VBD
18637	19713	85	not	not	RB
18637	19713	86	incorporate	incorporate	VB
18637	19713	87	the	the	DT
18637	19713	88	first	first	JJ
18637	19713	89	eight	eight	CD
18637	19713	90	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	19713	91	of	of	IN
18637	19713	92	the	the	DT
18637	19713	93	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19713	94	,	,	,
18637	19713	95	and	and	CC
18637	19713	96	,	,	,
18637	19713	97	conformably	conformably	RB
18637	19713	98	to	to	IN
18637	19713	99	Palko	Palko	NNP
18637	19713	100	_	_	NNP
18637	19713	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	19713	102	_	_	NNP
18637	19713	103	Connecticut,[925	Connecticut,[925	NNP
18637	19713	104	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19713	105	exacts	exact	VBZ
18637	19713	106	no	no	DT
18637	19713	107	more	more	JJR
18637	19713	108	from	from	IN
18637	19713	109	a	a	DT
18637	19713	110	State	state	NN
18637	19713	111	than	than	IN
18637	19713	112	is	be	VBZ
18637	19713	113	"	"	``
18637	19713	114	implicit	implicit	JJ
18637	19713	115	in	in	IN
18637	19713	116	'	'	''
18637	19713	117	the	the	DT
18637	19713	118	concept	concept	NN
18637	19713	119	of	of	IN
18637	19713	120	ordered	order	VBN
18637	19713	121	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19713	122	.	.	.
18637	19713	123	'	'	''
18637	19713	124	"	"	''
18637	19714	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19714	2	also	also	RB
18637	19714	3	proclaimed	proclaim	VBD
18637	19714	4	that	that	DT
18637	19714	5	:	:	:
18637	19714	6	"	"	``
18637	19714	7	The	the	DT
18637	19714	8	security	security	NN
18637	19714	9	of	of	IN
18637	19714	10	one	one	NN
18637	19714	11	's	's	POS
18637	19714	12	privacy	privacy	NN
18637	19714	13	against	against	IN
18637	19714	14	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19714	15	intrusion	intrusion	NN
18637	19714	16	by	by	IN
18637	19714	17	the	the	DT
18637	19714	18	police	police	NN
18637	19714	19	--	--	:
18637	19714	20	which	which	WDT
18637	19714	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	19714	22	at	at	IN
18637	19714	23	the	the	DT
18637	19714	24	core	core	NN
18637	19714	25	of	of	IN
18637	19714	26	the	the	DT
18637	19714	27	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	19714	28	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19714	29	--	--	:
18637	19714	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	19714	31	basic	basic	JJ
18637	19714	32	to	to	IN
18637	19714	33	a	a	DT
18637	19714	34	free	free	JJ
18637	19714	35	society	society	NN
18637	19714	36	.	.	.
18637	19715	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19715	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	19715	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	19715	4	implicit	implicit	JJ
18637	19715	5	in	in	IN
18637	19715	6	'	'	''
18637	19715	7	the	the	DT
18637	19715	8	concept	concept	NN
18637	19715	9	of	of	IN
18637	19715	10	ordered	order	VBN
18637	19715	11	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19715	12	'	'	''
18637	19715	13	and	and	CC
18637	19715	14	as	as	IN
18637	19715	15	such	such	JJ
18637	19715	16	enforceable	enforceable	JJ
18637	19715	17	against	against	IN
18637	19715	18	the	the	DT
18637	19715	19	States	States	NNP
18637	19715	20	through	through	IN
18637	19715	21	the	the	DT
18637	19715	22	due	due	JJ
18637	19715	23	process	process	NN
18637	19715	24	clause	clause	NN
18637	19715	25	.	.	.
18637	19716	1	"	"	``
18637	19716	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19716	3	926	926	CD
18637	19716	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19716	5	Such	such	JJ
18637	19716	6	language	language	NN
18637	19716	7	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	19716	8	to	to	TO
18637	19716	9	effect	effect	VB
18637	19716	10	the	the	DT
18637	19716	11	very	very	JJ
18637	19716	12	absorption	absorption	NN
18637	19716	13	into	into	IN
18637	19716	14	the	the	DT
18637	19716	15	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19716	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19716	17	which	which	WDT
18637	19716	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19716	19	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	19716	20	rejects	reject	VBZ
18637	19716	21	in	in	IN
18637	19716	22	the	the	DT
18637	19716	23	Adamson	Adamson	NNP
18637	19716	24	case	case	NN
18637	19716	25	;	;	:
18637	19716	26	but	but	CC
18637	19716	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19716	28	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	19716	29	by	by	IN
18637	19716	30	adding	add	VBG
18637	19716	31	that	that	IN
18637	19716	32	as	as	RB
18637	19716	33	long	long	RB
18637	19716	34	as	as	IN
18637	19716	35	"	"	``
18637	19716	36	a	a	DT
18637	19716	37	State	state	NN
18637	19716	38	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19716	39	does	do	VBZ
18637	19716	40	not	not	RB
18637	19716	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19716	42	affirmatively	affirmatively	RB
18637	19716	43	*	*	NFP
18637	19716	44	*	*	NFP
18637	19716	45	*	*	NFP
18637	19716	46	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	19716	47	*	*	NFP
18637	19716	48	*	*	NFP
18637	19716	49	*	*	NFP
18637	19716	50	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19716	51	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19716	52	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19716	53	police	police	NN
18637	19716	54	incursion	incursion	NN
18637	19716	55	into	into	IN
18637	19716	56	privacy	privacy	NN
18637	19716	57	"	"	''
18637	19716	58	;	;	:
18637	19716	59	that	that	RB
18637	19716	60	is	is	RB
18637	19716	61	,	,	,
18637	19716	62	as	as	RB
18637	19716	63	long	long	RB
18637	19716	64	as	as	IN
18637	19716	65	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19716	66	police	police	NN
18637	19716	67	are	be	VBP
18637	19716	68	deterred	deter	VBN
18637	19716	69	from	from	IN
18637	19716	70	making	make	VBG
18637	19716	71	searches	search	NNS
18637	19716	72	without	without	IN
18637	19716	73	authority	authority	NN
18637	19716	74	of	of	IN
18637	19716	75	law	law	NN
18637	19716	76	by	by	IN
18637	19716	77	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	19716	78	of	of	IN
18637	19716	79	such	such	JJ
18637	19716	80	internal	internal	JJ
18637	19716	81	discipline	discipline	NN
18637	19716	82	as	as	IN
18637	19716	83	an	an	DT
18637	19716	84	alert	alert	JJ
18637	19716	85	public	public	JJ
18637	19716	86	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	19716	87	may	may	MD
18637	19716	88	induce	induce	VB
18637	19716	89	and	and	CC
18637	19716	90	by	by	IN
18637	19716	91	reason	reason	NN
18637	19716	92	of	of	IN
18637	19716	93	the	the	DT
18637	19716	94	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	19716	95	or	or	CC
18637	19716	96	common	common	JJ
18637	19716	97	law	law	NN
18637	19716	98	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	19716	99	which	which	WDT
18637	19716	100	the	the	DT
18637	19716	101	victims	victim	NNS
18637	19716	102	of	of	IN
18637	19716	103	such	such	JJ
18637	19716	104	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	19716	105	searches	search	NNS
18637	19716	106	may	may	MD
18637	19716	107	invoke	invoke	VB
18637	19716	108	,	,	,
18637	19716	109	a	a	DT
18637	19716	110	State	State	NNP
18637	19716	111	,	,	,
18637	19716	112	without	without	IN
18637	19716	113	running	run	VBG
18637	19716	114	counter	counter	RB
18637	19716	115	to	to	IN
18637	19716	116	the	the	DT
18637	19716	117	due	due	JJ
18637	19716	118	process	process	NN
18637	19716	119	clause	clause	NN
18637	19716	120	,	,	,
18637	19716	121	may	may	MD
18637	19716	122	employ	employ	VB
18637	19716	123	at	at	IN
18637	19716	124	a	a	DT
18637	19716	125	trial	trial	NN
18637	19716	126	incriminating	incriminate	VBG
18637	19716	127	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19716	128	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19716	129	by	by	IN
18637	19716	130	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	19716	131	search	search	NN
18637	19716	132	and	and	CC
18637	19716	133	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	19716	134	.	.	.
18637	19717	1	The	the	DT
18637	19717	2	fact	fact	NN
18637	19717	3	that	that	IN
18637	19717	4	most	most	JJS
18637	19717	5	of	of	IN
18637	19717	6	the	the	DT
18637	19717	7	English	English	NNP
18637	19717	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	19717	9	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	19717	10	world	world	NN
18637	19717	11	,	,	,
18637	19717	12	including	include	VBG
18637	19717	13	30	30	CD
18637	19717	14	States	States	NNPS
18637	19717	15	and	and	CC
18637	19717	16	the	the	DT
18637	19717	17	British	British	NNP
18637	19717	18	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
18637	19717	19	of	of	IN
18637	19717	20	Nations	Nations	NNPS
18637	19717	21	,	,	,
18637	19717	22	does	do	VBZ
18637	19717	23	not	not	RB
18637	19717	24	regard	regard	VB
18637	19717	25	the	the	DT
18637	19717	26	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	19717	27	of	of	IN
18637	19717	28	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19717	29	thus	thus	RB
18637	19717	30	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19717	31	,	,	,
18637	19717	32	as	as	IN
18637	19717	33	vital	vital	JJ
18637	19717	34	to	to	IN
18637	19717	35	the	the	DT
18637	19717	36	protection	protection	NN
18637	19717	37	of	of	IN
18637	19717	38	the	the	DT
18637	19717	39	right	right	NN
18637	19717	40	of	of	IN
18637	19717	41	privacy	privacy	NN
18637	19717	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	19717	43	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	19717	44	by	by	IN
18637	19717	45	the	the	DT
18637	19717	46	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19717	47	as	as	IN
18637	19717	48	lending	lend	VBG
18637	19717	49	abundant	abundant	JJ
18637	19717	50	support	support	NN
18637	19717	51	to	to	IN
18637	19717	52	the	the	DT
18637	19717	53	merit	merit	NN
18637	19717	54	of	of	IN
18637	19717	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19717	56	position	position	NN
18637	19717	57	.	.	.
18637	19718	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19718	2	927	927	CD
18637	19718	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19718	4	Without	without	IN
18637	19718	5	departing	depart	VBG
18637	19718	6	from	from	IN
18637	19718	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19718	8	previously	previously	RB
18637	19718	9	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	19718	10	position	position	NN
18637	19718	11	which	which	WDT
18637	19718	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19718	13	restated	restate	VBD
18637	19718	14	in	in	IN
18637	19718	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19718	16	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	19718	17	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	19718	18	in	in	IN
18637	19718	19	Adamson	Adamson	NNP
18637	19718	20	_	_	NNP
18637	19718	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	19718	22	_	_	NNP
18637	19718	23	California;[928	California;[928	NNP
18637	19718	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19718	25	namely	namely	RB
18637	19718	26	,	,	,
18637	19718	27	that	that	IN
18637	19718	28	the	the	DT
18637	19718	29	due	due	JJ
18637	19718	30	process	process	NN
18637	19718	31	clause	clause	NN
18637	19718	32	of	of	IN
18637	19718	33	the	the	DT
18637	19718	34	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19718	35	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19718	36	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	19718	37	the	the	DT
18637	19718	38	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	19718	39	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19718	40	's	's	POS
18637	19718	41	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	19718	42	of	of	IN
18637	19718	43	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19718	44	searches	search	NNS
18637	19718	45	and	and	CC
18637	19718	46	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	19718	47	,	,	,
18637	19718	48	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19718	49	Black	Black	NNP
18637	19718	50	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	19718	51	in	in	IN
18637	19718	52	the	the	DT
18637	19718	53	result	result	NN
18637	19718	54	on	on	IN
18637	19718	55	the	the	DT
18637	19718	56	ground	ground	NN
18637	19718	57	that	that	IN
18637	19718	58	the	the	DT
18637	19718	59	exclusionary	exclusionary	JJ
18637	19718	60	rule	rule	NN
18637	19718	61	,	,	,
18637	19718	62	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	19718	63	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19718	64	procured	procure	VBD
18637	19718	65	in	in	IN
18637	19718	66	an	an	DT
18637	19718	67	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	19718	68	search	search	NN
18637	19718	69	and	and	CC
18637	19718	70	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	19718	71	is	be	VBZ
18637	19718	72	not	not	RB
18637	19718	73	admissible	admissible	JJ
18637	19718	74	in	in	IN
18637	19718	75	a	a	DT
18637	19718	76	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19718	77	court	court	NN
18637	19718	78	,	,	,
18637	19718	79	is	be	VBZ
18637	19718	80	"	"	``
18637	19718	81	not	not	RB
18637	19718	82	a	a	DT
18637	19718	83	command	command	NN
18637	19718	84	of	of	IN
18637	19718	85	the	the	DT
18637	19718	86	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	19718	87	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19718	88	but	but	CC
18637	19718	89	is	be	VBZ
18637	19718	90	a	a	DT
18637	19718	91	judicially	judicially	RB
18637	19718	92	created	create	VBN
18637	19718	93	rule	rule	NN
18637	19718	94	of	of	IN
18637	19718	95	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19718	96	which	which	WDT
18637	19718	97	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	19718	98	might	may	MD
18637	19718	99	negate	negate	VB
18637	19718	100	.	.	.
18637	19719	1	"	"	``
18637	19719	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19719	3	929	929	CD
18637	19719	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19719	5	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19719	6	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	19719	7	,	,	,
18637	19719	8	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	19719	9	,	,	,
18637	19719	10	and	and	CC
18637	19719	11	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	19719	12	,	,	,
18637	19719	13	in	in	IN
18637	19719	14	separate	separate	JJ
18637	19719	15	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	19719	16	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	19719	17	,	,	,
18637	19719	18	all	all	DT
18637	19719	19	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19719	20	that	that	IN
18637	19719	21	the	the	DT
18637	19719	22	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	19719	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19719	24	was	be	VBD
18637	19719	25	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	19719	26	to	to	IN
18637	19719	27	the	the	DT
18637	19719	28	States	States	NNPS
18637	19719	29	and	and	CC
18637	19719	30	that	that	IN
18637	19719	31	"	"	``
18637	19719	32	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19719	33	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19719	34	in	in	IN
18637	19719	35	violation	violation	NN
18637	19719	36	of	of	IN
18637	19719	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19719	38	must	must	MD
18637	19719	39	be	be	VB
18637	19719	40	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	19719	41	in	in	IN
18637	19719	42	State	state	NN
18637	19719	43	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	19719	44	as	as	RB
18637	19719	45	well	well	RB
18637	19719	46	as	as	IN
18637	19719	47	in	in	IN
18637	19719	48	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19719	49	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	19719	50	,	,	,
18637	19719	51	*	*	NFP
18637	19719	52	*	*	NFP
18637	19719	53	*	*	NFP
18637	19719	54	.	.	.
18637	19720	1	"	"	``
18637	19720	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19720	3	930	930	CD
18637	19720	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19720	5	Attacking	Attacking	NNP
18637	19720	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19720	7	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	19720	8	's	's	POS
18637	19720	9	method	method	NN
18637	19720	10	of	of	IN
18637	19720	11	approach	approach	NN
18637	19720	12	,	,	,
18637	19720	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19720	14	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	19720	15	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19720	16	that	that	IN
18637	19720	17	the	the	DT
18637	19720	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19720	19	should	should	MD
18637	19720	20	not	not	RB
18637	19720	21	"	"	``
18637	19720	22	decide	decide	VB
18637	19720	23	due	due	JJ
18637	19720	24	process	process	NN
18637	19720	25	questions	question	NNS
18637	19720	26	by	by	IN
18637	19720	27	simply	simply	RB
18637	19720	28	taking	take	VBG
18637	19720	29	a	a	DT
18637	19720	30	poll	poll	NN
18637	19720	31	of	of	IN
18637	19720	32	the	the	DT
18637	19720	33	rules	rule	NNS
18637	19720	34	in	in	IN
18637	19720	35	various	various	JJ
18637	19720	36	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NNS
18637	19720	37	,	,	,
18637	19720	38	*	*	NFP
18637	19720	39	*	*	NFP
18637	19720	40	*	*	NFP
18637	19720	41	"	"	''
18637	19720	42	and	and	CC
18637	19720	43	agreed	agree	VBD
18637	19720	44	with	with	IN
18637	19720	45	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19720	46	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	19720	47	that	that	IN
18637	19720	48	unless	unless	IN
18637	19720	49	illegally	illegally	RB
18637	19720	50	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19720	51	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19720	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	19720	53	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	19720	54	,	,	,
18637	19720	55	no	no	DT
18637	19720	56	effective	effective	JJ
18637	19720	57	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	19720	58	"	"	''
18637	19720	59	exists	exist	VBZ
18637	19720	60	to	to	TO
18637	19720	61	deter	deter	VB
18637	19720	62	violations	violation	NNS
18637	19720	63	of	of	IN
18637	19720	64	the	the	DT
18637	19720	65	search	search	NN
18637	19720	66	and	and	CC
18637	19720	67	seizure	seizure	VB
18637	19720	68	clause	clause	NN
18637	19720	69	.	.	.
18637	19720	70	"	"	''
18637	19721	1	In	in	IN
18637	19721	2	two	two	CD
18637	19721	3	recent	recent	JJ
18637	19721	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	19721	5	,	,	,
18637	19721	6	both	both	DT
18637	19721	7	argued	argue	VBD
18637	19721	8	the	the	DT
18637	19721	9	same	same	JJ
18637	19721	10	day	day	NN
18637	19721	11	,	,	,
18637	19721	12	a	a	DT
18637	19721	13	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	19721	14	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	19721	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19721	16	reached	reach	VBD
18637	19721	17	opposite	opposite	JJ
18637	19721	18	results	result	NNS
18637	19721	19	.	.	.
18637	19722	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19722	2	931	931	CD
18637	19722	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19722	4	In	in	IN
18637	19722	5	the	the	DT
18637	19722	6	first	first	JJ
18637	19722	7	the	the	DT
18637	19722	8	outcome	outcome	NN
18637	19722	9	of	of	IN
18637	19722	10	the	the	DT
18637	19722	11	Wolf	Wolf	NNP
18637	19722	12	case	case	NN
18637	19722	13	was	be	VBD
18637	19722	14	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	19722	15	.	.	.
18637	19723	1	The	the	DT
18637	19723	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19723	3	,	,	,
18637	19723	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	19723	5	by	by	IN
18637	19723	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19723	7	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	19723	8	,	,	,
18637	19723	9	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	19723	10	to	to	TO
18637	19723	11	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	19723	12	the	the	DT
18637	19723	13	use	use	NN
18637	19723	14	,	,	,
18637	19723	15	in	in	IN
18637	19723	16	State	State	NNP
18637	19723	17	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19723	18	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19723	19	against	against	IN
18637	19723	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19723	21	in	in	IN
18637	19723	22	New	New	NNP
18637	19723	23	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	19723	24	of	of	IN
18637	19723	25	evidences	evidence	NNS
18637	19723	26	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	19723	27	to	to	TO
18637	19723	28	have	have	VB
18637	19723	29	been	be	VBN
18637	19723	30	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19723	31	by	by	IN
18637	19723	32	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	19723	33	search	search	NN
18637	19723	34	by	by	IN
18637	19723	35	State	state	NN
18637	19723	36	police	police	NNS
18637	19723	37	.	.	.
18637	19724	1	Said	say	VBD
18637	19724	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19724	3	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	19724	4	,	,	,
18637	19724	5	"	"	``
18637	19724	6	If	if	IN
18637	19724	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19724	8	were	be	VBD
18637	19724	9	to	to	TO
18637	19724	10	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	19724	11	this	this	DT
18637	19724	12	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	19724	13	,	,	,
18637	19724	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19724	15	would	would	MD
18637	19724	16	expose	expose	VB
18637	19724	17	every	every	DT
18637	19724	18	State	state	NN
18637	19724	19	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19724	20	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	19724	21	to	to	IN
18637	19724	22	insupportable	insupportable	JJ
18637	19724	23	disruption	disruption	NN
18637	19724	24	.	.	.
18637	19725	1	Every	every	DT
18637	19725	2	question	question	NN
18637	19725	3	of	of	IN
18637	19725	4	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	19725	5	due	due	JJ
18637	19725	6	process	process	NN
18637	19725	7	of	of	IN
18637	19725	8	law	law	NN
18637	19725	9	--	--	:
18637	19725	10	with	with	IN
18637	19725	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19725	12	far	far	RB
18637	19725	13	flung	flung	JJ
18637	19725	14	and	and	CC
18637	19725	15	undefined	undefined	JJ
18637	19725	16	range	range	NN
18637	19725	17	--	--	:
18637	19725	18	would	would	MD
18637	19725	19	invite	invite	VB
18637	19725	20	a	a	DT
18637	19725	21	flanking	flanking	JJ
18637	19725	22	movement	movement	NN
18637	19725	23	against	against	IN
18637	19725	24	the	the	DT
18637	19725	25	system	system	NN
18637	19725	26	of	of	IN
18637	19725	27	State	State	NNP
18637	19725	28	courts	court	NNS
18637	19725	29	by	by	IN
18637	19725	30	resort	resort	NN
18637	19725	31	to	to	IN
18637	19725	32	the	the	DT
18637	19725	33	federal	federal	NNP
18637	19725	34	forum	forum	NNP
18637	19725	35	*	*	NFP
18637	19725	36	*	*	NFP
18637	19725	37	*	*	NFP
18637	19725	38	"	"	''
18637	19725	39	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19725	40	932	932	CD
18637	19725	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19725	42	The	the	DT
18637	19725	43	facts	fact	NNS
18637	19725	44	in	in	IN
18637	19725	45	the	the	DT
18637	19725	46	second	second	JJ
18637	19725	47	case	case	NN
18637	19725	48	were	be	VBD
18637	19725	49	as	as	IN
18637	19725	50	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	19725	51	:	:	:
18637	19725	52	state	state	NN
18637	19725	53	officers	officer	NNS
18637	19725	54	,	,	,
18637	19725	55	on	on	IN
18637	19725	56	the	the	DT
18637	19725	57	basis	basis	NN
18637	19725	58	of	of	IN
18637	19725	59	"	"	``
18637	19725	60	some	some	DT
18637	19725	61	information	information	NN
18637	19725	62	"	"	''
18637	19725	63	that	that	WDT
18637	19725	64	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	19725	65	was	be	VBD
18637	19725	66	selling	sell	VBG
18637	19725	67	narcotics	narcotic	NNS
18637	19725	68	,	,	,
18637	19725	69	entered	enter	VBD
18637	19725	70	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19725	71	home	home	NN
18637	19725	72	and	and	CC
18637	19725	73	forced	force	VBD
18637	19725	74	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19725	75	way	way	NN
18637	19725	76	into	into	IN
18637	19725	77	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19725	78	wife	wife	NN
18637	19725	79	's	's	POS
18637	19725	80	bedroom	bedroom	NN
18637	19725	81	.	.	.
18637	19726	1	When	when	WRB
18637	19726	2	asked	ask	VBN
18637	19726	3	about	about	RB
18637	19726	4	two	two	CD
18637	19726	5	capsules	capsule	NNS
18637	19726	6	lying	lie	VBG
18637	19726	7	on	on	IN
18637	19726	8	a	a	DT
18637	19726	9	bedroom	bedroom	NN
18637	19726	10	table	table	NN
18637	19726	11	,	,	,
18637	19726	12	petitioner	petitioner	NNP
18637	19726	13	put	put	VBD
18637	19726	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19726	15	into	into	IN
18637	19726	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19726	17	mouth	mouth	NN
18637	19726	18	and	and	CC
18637	19726	19	swallowed	swallow	VBD
18637	19726	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19726	21	.	.	.
18637	19727	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19727	2	was	be	VBD
18637	19727	3	then	then	RB
18637	19727	4	taken	take	VBN
18637	19727	5	to	to	IN
18637	19727	6	a	a	DT
18637	19727	7	hospital	hospital	NN
18637	19727	8	,	,	,
18637	19727	9	where	where	WRB
18637	19727	10	an	an	DT
18637	19727	11	emetic	emetic	NN
18637	19727	12	was	be	VBD
18637	19727	13	forced	force	VBN
18637	19727	14	into	into	IN
18637	19727	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19727	16	stomach	stomach	NN
18637	19727	17	with	with	IN
18637	19727	18	the	the	DT
18637	19727	19	result	result	NN
18637	19727	20	that	that	IN
18637	19727	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19727	22	vomited	vomit	VBD
18637	19727	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19727	24	up	up	RP
18637	19727	25	.	.	.
18637	19728	1	Later	later	RB
18637	19728	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19728	3	were	be	VBD
18637	19728	4	offered	offer	VBN
18637	19728	5	in	in	IN
18637	19728	6	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19728	7	against	against	IN
18637	19728	8	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19728	9	.	.	.
18637	19729	1	Again	again	RB
18637	19729	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19729	3	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	19729	4	spoke	speak	VBD
18637	19729	5	for	for	IN
18637	19729	6	the	the	DT
18637	19729	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19729	8	,	,	,
18637	19729	9	while	while	IN
18637	19729	10	reiterating	reiterate	VBG
18637	19729	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19729	12	preachments	preachment	NNS
18637	19729	13	regarding	regard	VBG
18637	19729	14	the	the	DT
18637	19729	15	tolerance	tolerance	NN
18637	19729	16	claimable	claimable	JJ
18637	19729	17	by	by	IN
18637	19729	18	the	the	DT
18637	19729	19	States	States	NNPS
18637	19729	20	under	under	IN
18637	19729	21	the	the	DT
18637	19729	22	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19729	23	Amendment[933	Amendment[933	NNP
18637	19729	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19729	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19729	26	held	hold	VBD
18637	19729	27	that	that	IN
18637	19729	28	methods	method	NNS
18637	19729	29	offensive	offensive	JJ
18637	19729	30	to	to	IN
18637	19729	31	human	human	JJ
18637	19729	32	dignity	dignity	NN
18637	19729	33	were	be	VBD
18637	19729	34	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	19729	35	out	out	RP
18637	19729	36	by	by	IN
18637	19729	37	the	the	DT
18637	19729	38	due	due	JJ
18637	19729	39	process	process	NN
18637	19729	40	clause	clause	NN
18637	19729	41	.	.	.
18637	19730	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19730	2	934	934	CD
18637	19730	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19730	4	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19730	5	Black	Black	NNP
18637	19730	6	and	and	CC
18637	19730	7	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	19730	8	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	19730	9	in	in	IN
18637	19730	10	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	19730	11	in	in	IN
18637	19730	12	which	which	WDT
18637	19730	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19730	14	seized	seize	VBD
18637	19730	15	the	the	DT
18637	19730	16	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19730	17	to	to	TO
18637	19730	18	reiterate	reiterate	VB
18637	19730	19	once	once	RB
18637	19730	20	more	more	JJR
18637	19730	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19730	22	position	position	NN
18637	19730	23	in	in	IN
18637	19730	24	Adamson	Adamson	NNP
18637	19730	25	_	_	NNP
18637	19730	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	19730	27	_	_	NNP
18637	19730	28	California	California	NNP
18637	19730	29	.	.	.
18637	19731	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19731	2	935	935	CD
18637	19731	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19731	4	Conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19731	5	Based	base	VBN
18637	19731	6	on	on	IN
18637	19731	7	Perjured	Perjured	NNP
18637	19731	8	Testimony	Testimony	NNP
18637	19731	9	When	when	WRB
18637	19731	10	a	a	DT
18637	19731	11	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19731	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	19731	13	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19731	14	by	by	IN
18637	19731	15	the	the	DT
18637	19731	16	presentation	presentation	NN
18637	19731	17	of	of	IN
18637	19731	18	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19731	19	known	know	VBN
18637	19731	20	to	to	IN
18637	19731	21	the	the	DT
18637	19731	22	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
18637	19731	23	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	19731	24	to	to	TO
18637	19731	25	have	have	VB
18637	19731	26	been	be	VBN
18637	19731	27	perjured	perjure	VBN
18637	19731	28	,	,	,
18637	19731	29	the	the	DT
18637	19731	30	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19731	31	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19731	32	of	of	IN
18637	19731	33	due	due	JJ
18637	19731	34	process	process	NN
18637	19731	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	19731	36	not	not	RB
18637	19731	37	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	19731	38	.	.	.
18637	19732	1	That	that	DT
18637	19732	2	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19732	3	"	"	``
18637	19732	4	can	can	MD
18637	19732	5	not	not	RB
18637	19732	6	be	be	VB
18637	19732	7	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19732	8	to	to	TO
18637	19732	9	be	be	VB
18637	19732	10	satisfied	satisfy	VBN
18637	19732	11	by	by	IN
18637	19732	12	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19732	13	notice	notice	NN
18637	19732	14	and	and	CC
18637	19732	15	hearing	hear	VBG
18637	19732	16	if	if	IN
18637	19732	17	a	a	DT
18637	19732	18	State	State	NNP
18637	19732	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	19732	20	contrived	contrive	VBN
18637	19732	21	a	a	DT
18637	19732	22	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19732	23	through	through	IN
18637	19732	24	the	the	DT
18637	19732	25	pretense	pretense	NN
18637	19732	26	of	of	IN
18637	19732	27	a	a	DT
18637	19732	28	trial	trial	NN
18637	19732	29	which	which	WDT
18637	19732	30	in	in	IN
18637	19732	31	truth	truth	NN
18637	19732	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	19732	33	but	but	CC
18637	19732	34	used	use	VBN
18637	19732	35	as	as	IN
18637	19732	36	a	a	DT
18637	19732	37	means	means	NN
18637	19732	38	of	of	IN
18637	19732	39	depriving	deprive	VBG
18637	19732	40	a	a	DT
18637	19732	41	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19732	42	of	of	IN
18637	19732	43	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19732	44	through	through	IN
18637	19732	45	a	a	DT
18637	19732	46	deliberate	deliberate	JJ
18637	19732	47	deception	deception	NN
18637	19732	48	of	of	IN
18637	19732	49	court	court	NN
18637	19732	50	and	and	CC
18637	19732	51	jury	jury	NN
18637	19732	52	by	by	IN
18637	19732	53	the	the	DT
18637	19732	54	presentation	presentation	NN
18637	19732	55	of	of	IN
18637	19732	56	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19732	57	known	know	VBN
18637	19732	58	to	to	TO
18637	19732	59	be	be	VB
18637	19732	60	perjured	perjure	VBN
18637	19732	61	.	.	.
18637	19733	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	19733	2	a	a	DT
18637	19733	3	contrivance	contrivance	NN
18637	19733	4	*	*	NFP
18637	19733	5	*	*	NFP
18637	19733	6	*	*	NFP
18637	19733	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19733	8	as	as	RB
18637	19733	9	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	19733	10	with	with	IN
18637	19733	11	the	the	DT
18637	19733	12	rudimentary	rudimentary	JJ
18637	19733	13	demands	demand	NNS
18637	19733	14	of	of	IN
18637	19733	15	justice	justice	NN
18637	19733	16	as	as	IN
18637	19733	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	19733	18	the	the	DT
18637	19733	19	obtaining	obtaining	NN
18637	19733	20	of	of	IN
18637	19733	21	a	a	DT
18637	19733	22	like	like	JJ
18637	19733	23	result	result	NN
18637	19733	24	by	by	IN
18637	19733	25	intimidation	intimidation	NN
18637	19733	26	.	.	.
18637	19734	1	"	"	``
18637	19734	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19734	3	936	936	CD
18637	19734	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19734	5	This	this	DT
18637	19734	6	principle	principle	NN
18637	19734	7	,	,	,
18637	19734	8	as	as	RB
18637	19734	9	originally	originally	RB
18637	19734	10	announced	announce	VBN
18637	19734	11	,	,	,
18637	19734	12	was	be	VBD
18637	19734	13	no	no	DT
18637	19734	14	more	more	JJR
18637	19734	15	than	than	IN
18637	19734	16	a	a	DT
18637	19734	17	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	19734	18	uttered	utter	VBN
18637	19734	19	by	by	IN
18637	19734	20	the	the	DT
18637	19734	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19734	22	in	in	IN
18637	19734	23	disposing	dispose	VBG
18637	19734	24	of	of	IN
18637	19734	25	Tom	Tom	NNP
18637	19734	26	Mooney	Mooney	NNP
18637	19734	27	's	's	POS
18637	19734	28	application	application	NN
18637	19734	29	for	for	IN
18637	19734	30	a	a	DT
18637	19734	31	writ	writ	NN
18637	19734	32	of	of	IN
18637	19734	33	_	_	NNP
18637	19734	34	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	19734	35	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	19734	36	_	_	NNP
18637	19734	37	,	,	,
18637	19734	38	filed	file	VBD
18637	19734	39	almost	almost	RB
18637	19734	40	eighteen	eighteen	CD
18637	19734	41	years	year	NNS
18637	19734	42	after	after	IN
18637	19734	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19734	44	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19734	45	,	,	,
18637	19734	46	and	and	CC
18637	19734	47	founded	found	VBN
18637	19734	48	upon	upon	IN
18637	19734	49	the	the	DT
18637	19734	50	contention	contention	NN
18637	19734	51	that	that	IN
18637	19734	52	the	the	DT
18637	19734	53	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	19734	54	of	of	IN
18637	19734	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19734	56	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	19734	57	was	be	VBD
18637	19734	58	made	make	VBN
18637	19734	59	possible	possible	JJ
18637	19734	60	solely	solely	RB
18637	19734	61	by	by	IN
18637	19734	62	perjured	perjured	JJ
18637	19734	63	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19734	64	knowingly	knowingly	RB
18637	19734	65	employed	employ	VBN
18637	19734	66	by	by	IN
18637	19734	67	the	the	DT
18637	19734	68	prosecutor	prosecutor	NN
18637	19734	69	who	who	WP
18637	19734	70	"	"	``
18637	19734	71	deliberately	deliberately	RB
18637	19734	72	suppressed	suppress	VBD
18637	19734	73	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19734	74	which	which	WDT
18637	19734	75	would	would	MD
18637	19734	76	have	have	VB
18637	19734	77	impeached	impeach	VBN
18637	19734	78	and	and	CC
18637	19734	79	refuted	refute	VBN
18637	19734	80	the	the	DT
18637	19734	81	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19734	82	thus	thus	RB
18637	19734	83	given	give	VBN
18637	19734	84	against	against	IN
18637	19734	85	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19734	86	.	.	.
18637	19735	1	"	"	``
18637	19735	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19735	3	937	937	CD
18637	19735	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19735	5	On	on	IN
18637	19735	6	the	the	DT
18637	19735	7	authority	authority	NN
18637	19735	8	of	of	IN
18637	19735	9	the	the	DT
18637	19735	10	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	19735	11	case	case	NN
18637	19735	12	,	,	,
18637	19735	13	and	and	CC
18637	19735	14	without	without	IN
18637	19735	15	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	19735	16	,	,	,
18637	19735	17	the	the	DT
18637	19735	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19735	19	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	19735	20	applied	apply	VBD
18637	19735	21	this	this	DT
18637	19735	22	principle	principle	NN
18637	19735	23	in	in	IN
18637	19735	24	Hysler	Hysler	NNP
18637	19735	25	_	_	NNP
18637	19735	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	19735	27	_	_	NNP
18637	19735	28	Florida,[938	Florida,[938	NNP
18637	19735	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19735	30	Pyle	Pyle	NNP
18637	19735	31	_	_	NNP
18637	19735	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	19735	33	_	_	NNP
18637	19735	34	Kansas[939	kansas[939	CD
18637	19735	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19735	36	and	and	CC
18637	19735	37	White	White	NNP
18637	19735	38	_	_	NNP
18637	19735	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	19735	40	_	_	NNP
18637	19735	41	Ragen	Ragen	NNP
18637	19735	42	.	.	.
18637	19736	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19736	2	940	940	CD
18637	19736	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19736	4	In	in	IN
18637	19736	5	the	the	DT
18637	19736	6	first	first	JJ
18637	19736	7	case	case	NN
18637	19736	8	,	,	,
18637	19736	9	the	the	DT
18637	19736	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19736	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19736	12	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	19736	13	in	in	IN
18637	19736	14	the	the	DT
18637	19736	15	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19736	16	of	of	IN
18637	19736	17	the	the	DT
18637	19736	18	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	19736	19	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19736	20	court	court	NN
18637	19736	21	denying	deny	VBG
18637	19736	22	a	a	DT
18637	19736	23	petition	petition	NN
18637	19736	24	for	for	IN
18637	19736	25	leave	leave	NN
18637	19736	26	to	to	TO
18637	19736	27	apply	apply	VB
18637	19736	28	to	to	IN
18637	19736	29	a	a	DT
18637	19736	30	trial	trial	NN
18637	19736	31	court	court	NN
18637	19736	32	for	for	IN
18637	19736	33	a	a	DT
18637	19736	34	writ	writ	NNP
18637	19736	35	of	of	IN
18637	19736	36	_	_	NNP
18637	19736	37	coram	coram	NNP
18637	19736	38	nobis	nobis	NNP
18637	19736	39	_	_	NNP
18637	19736	40	.	.	.
18637	19737	1	Supporting	support	VBG
18637	19737	2	the	the	DT
18637	19737	3	petition	petition	NN
18637	19737	4	filed	file	VBN
18637	19737	5	by	by	IN
18637	19737	6	Hysler	Hysler	NNP
18637	19737	7	,	,	,
18637	19737	8	the	the	DT
18637	19737	9	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19737	10	,	,	,
18637	19737	11	were	be	VBD
18637	19737	12	affidavits	affidavit	NNS
18637	19737	13	signed	sign	VBN
18637	19737	14	by	by	IN
18637	19737	15	one	one	CD
18637	19737	16	of	of	IN
18637	19737	17	two	two	CD
18637	19737	18	codefendants	codefendant	NNS
18637	19737	19	on	on	IN
18637	19737	20	the	the	DT
18637	19737	21	eve	eve	NN
18637	19737	22	of	of	IN
18637	19737	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19737	24	execution	execution	NN
18637	19737	25	for	for	IN
18637	19737	26	participation	participation	NN
18637	19737	27	in	in	IN
18637	19737	28	the	the	DT
18637	19737	29	same	same	JJ
18637	19737	30	crime	crime	NN
18637	19737	31	and	and	CC
18637	19737	32	stating	state	VBG
18637	19737	33	that	that	IN
18637	19737	34	the	the	DT
18637	19737	35	two	two	CD
18637	19737	36	codefendants	codefendant	NNS
18637	19737	37	had	have	VBD
18637	19737	38	testified	testify	VBN
18637	19737	39	falsely	falsely	RB
18637	19737	40	against	against	IN
18637	19737	41	Hysler	Hysler	NNP
18637	19737	42	because	because	IN
18637	19737	43	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19737	44	had	have	VBD
18637	19737	45	been	be	VBN
18637	19737	46	"	"	``
18637	19737	47	'	'	``
18637	19737	48	coerced	coerce	VBN
18637	19737	49	,	,	,
18637	19737	50	intimidated	intimidate	VBN
18637	19737	51	,	,	,
18637	19737	52	beaten	beat	VBN
18637	19737	53	,	,	,
18637	19737	54	threatened	threaten	VBD
18637	19737	55	with	with	IN
18637	19737	56	violence	violence	NN
18637	19737	57	and	and	CC
18637	19737	58	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	19737	59	abused	abuse	VBN
18637	19737	60	and	and	CC
18637	19737	61	mistreated	mistreat	VBN
18637	19737	62	'	'	''
18637	19737	63	by	by	IN
18637	19737	64	the	the	DT
18637	19737	65	police	police	NN
18637	19737	66	and	and	CC
18637	19737	67	were	be	VBD
18637	19737	68	'	'	``
18637	19737	69	promised	promise	VBN
18637	19737	70	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	19737	71	from	from	IN
18637	19737	72	the	the	DT
18637	19737	73	electric	electric	JJ
18637	19737	74	chair	chair	NN
18637	19737	75	'	'	''
18637	19737	76	by	by	IN
18637	19737	77	the	the	DT
18637	19737	78	district	district	NN
18637	19737	79	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	19737	80	.	.	.
18637	19737	81	"	"	''
18637	19738	1	Having	have	VBG
18637	19738	2	made	make	VBN
18637	19738	3	"	"	``
18637	19738	4	an	an	DT
18637	19738	5	independent	independent	JJ
18637	19738	6	examination	examination	NN
18637	19738	7	of	of	IN
18637	19738	8	the	the	DT
18637	19738	9	affidavits	affidavit	NNS
18637	19738	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	19738	11	which	which	WDT
18637	19738	12	*	*	NFP
18637	19738	13	*	*	NFP
18637	19738	14	*	*	NFP
18637	19738	15	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19738	16	Hysler	Hysler	NNP
18637	19738	17	's	's	POS
18637	19738	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19738	19	claim	claim	NN
18637	19738	20	was	be	VBD
18637	19738	21	based	base	VBN
18637	19738	22	,	,	,
18637	19738	23	"	"	''
18637	19738	24	a	a	DT
18637	19738	25	majority	majority	NN
18637	19738	26	of	of	IN
18637	19738	27	the	the	DT
18637	19738	28	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19738	29	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	19738	30	that	that	IN
18637	19738	31	the	the	DT
18637	19738	32	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	19738	33	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19738	34	court	court	NN
18637	19738	35	's	's	POS
18637	19738	36	finding	finding	NN
18637	19738	37	that	that	IN
18637	19738	38	Hysler	Hysler	NNP
18637	19738	39	's	's	POS
18637	19738	40	proof	proof	NN
18637	19738	41	was	be	VBD
18637	19738	42	insubstantial	insubstantial	JJ
18637	19738	43	and	and	CC
18637	19738	44	did	do	VBD
18637	19738	45	not	not	RB
18637	19738	46	make	make	VB
18637	19738	47	out	out	RP
18637	19738	48	a	a	DT
18637	19738	49	_	_	NNP
18637	19738	50	prima	prima	NN
18637	19738	51	facie	facie	NNP
18637	19738	52	_	_	NNP
18637	19738	53	case	case	NN
18637	19738	54	was	be	VBD
18637	19738	55	justified	justify	VBN
18637	19738	56	.	.	.
18637	19739	1	"	"	``
18637	19739	2	That	that	IN
18637	19739	3	in	in	IN
18637	19739	4	the	the	DT
18637	19739	5	course	course	NN
18637	19739	6	of	of	IN
18637	19739	7	*	*	NFP
18637	19739	8	*	*	NFP
18637	19739	9	*	*	NFP
18637	19739	10	years	year	NNS
18637	19739	11	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	19739	12	die	die	VBP
18637	19739	13	or	or	CC
18637	19739	14	disappear	disappear	VBP
18637	19739	15	,	,	,
18637	19739	16	that	that	IN
18637	19739	17	memories	memory	NNS
18637	19739	18	fade	fade	NNP
18637	19739	19	,	,	,
18637	19739	20	that	that	IN
18637	19739	21	a	a	DT
18637	19739	22	sense	sense	NN
18637	19739	23	of	of	IN
18637	19739	24	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	19739	25	may	may	MD
18637	19739	26	become	become	VB
18637	19739	27	attenuated	attenuate	VBN
18637	19739	28	,	,	,
18637	19739	29	that	that	IN
18637	19739	30	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19739	31	recantation	recantation	NN
18637	19739	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19739	33	*	*	NFP
18637	19739	34	*	*	NFP
18637	19739	35	*	*	NFP
18637	19739	36	on	on	IN
18637	19739	37	the	the	DT
18637	19739	38	eve	eve	NN
18637	19739	39	of	of	IN
18637	19739	40	execution	execution	NN
18637	19739	41	*	*	NFP
18637	19739	42	*	*	NFP
18637	19739	43	*	*	NFP
18637	19739	44	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19739	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	19739	46	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19739	47	not	not	RB
18637	19739	48	unfamiliar	unfamiliar	JJ
18637	19739	49	as	as	IN
18637	19739	50	a	a	DT
18637	19739	51	means	means	NN
18637	19739	52	of	of	IN
18637	19739	53	relieving	relieve	VBG
18637	19739	54	others	other	NNS
18637	19739	55	or	or	CC
18637	19739	56	as	as	IN
18637	19739	57	an	an	DT
18637	19739	58	irrational	irrational	JJ
18637	19739	59	hope	hope	NN
18637	19739	60	for	for	IN
18637	19739	61	self	self	NN
18637	19739	62	*	*	NFP
18637	19739	63	*	*	NFP
18637	19739	64	*	*	NFP
18637	19739	65	are	be	VBP
18637	19739	66	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	19739	67	"	"	''
18637	19739	68	to	to	IN
18637	19739	69	the	the	DT
18637	19739	70	determination	determination	NN
18637	19739	71	by	by	IN
18637	19739	72	the	the	DT
18637	19739	73	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	19739	74	court	court	NN
18637	19739	75	that	that	IN
18637	19739	76	"	"	``
18637	19739	77	such	such	PDT
18637	19739	78	a	a	DT
18637	19739	79	belated	belate	VBN
18637	19739	80	disclosure	disclosure	NN
18637	19739	81	"	"	``
18637	19739	82	did	do	VBD
18637	19739	83	not	not	RB
18637	19739	84	spring	spring	VB
18637	19739	85	"	"	''
18637	19739	86	from	from	IN
18637	19739	87	the	the	DT
18637	19739	88	impulse	impulse	NN
18637	19739	89	for	for	IN
18637	19739	90	truth	truth	NN
18637	19739	91	-	-	HYPH
18637	19739	92	telling	telling	NN
18637	19739	93	"	"	''
18637	19739	94	and	and	CC
18637	19739	95	was	be	VBD
18637	19739	96	"	"	``
18637	19739	97	the	the	DT
18637	19739	98	product	product	NN
18637	19739	99	of	of	IN
18637	19739	100	self	self	NN
18637	19739	101	-	-	HYPH
18637	19739	102	delusion	delusion	NN
18637	19739	103	*	*	NFP
18637	19739	104	*	*	NFP
18637	19739	105	*	*	NFP
18637	19739	106	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19739	107	and	and	CC
18637	19739	108	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19739	109	artifice	artifice	NN
18637	19739	110	prompted	prompt	VBN
18637	19739	111	by	by	IN
18637	19739	112	the	the	DT
18637	19739	113	instinct	instinct	NN
18637	19739	114	of	of	IN
18637	19739	115	self	self	NN
18637	19739	116	-	-	HYPH
18637	19739	117	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	19739	118	.	.	.
18637	19740	1	"	"	``
18637	19740	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19740	3	941	941	CD
18637	19740	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19740	5	Relying	rely	VBG
18637	19740	6	largely	largely	RB
18637	19740	7	on	on	IN
18637	19740	8	the	the	DT
18637	19740	9	failure	failure	NN
18637	19740	10	of	of	IN
18637	19740	11	the	the	DT
18637	19740	12	State	State	NNP
18637	19740	13	to	to	TO
18637	19740	14	answer	answer	VB
18637	19740	15	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	19740	16	in	in	IN
18637	19740	17	a	a	DT
18637	19740	18	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	19740	19	's	's	POS
18637	19740	20	application	application	NN
18637	19740	21	for	for	IN
18637	19740	22	a	a	DT
18637	19740	23	write	write	NN
18637	19740	24	of	of	IN
18637	19740	25	_	_	NNP
18637	19740	26	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	19740	27	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	19740	28	_	_	NNP
18637	19740	29	,	,	,
18637	19740	30	which	which	WDT
18637	19740	31	application	application	NN
18637	19740	32	recited	recite	VBD
18637	19740	33	that	that	IN
18637	19740	34	persons	person	NNS
18637	19740	35	named	name	VBN
18637	19740	36	in	in	IN
18637	19740	37	supporting	support	VBG
18637	19740	38	affidavits	affidavit	NNS
18637	19740	39	and	and	CC
18637	19740	40	documents	document	NNS
18637	19740	41	were	be	VBD
18637	19740	42	coerced	coerce	VBN
18637	19740	43	to	to	TO
18637	19740	44	testify	testify	VB
18637	19740	45	falsely	falsely	RB
18637	19740	46	,	,	,
18637	19740	47	and	and	CC
18637	19740	48	that	that	IN
18637	19740	49	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19740	50	of	of	IN
18637	19740	51	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19740	52	other	other	JJ
18637	19740	53	persons	person	NNS
18637	19740	54	material	material	NN
18637	19740	55	to	to	IN
18637	19740	56	the	the	DT
18637	19740	57	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	19740	58	's	's	POS
18637	19740	59	defense	defense	NN
18637	19740	60	was	be	VBD
18637	19740	61	suppressed	suppress	VBN
18637	19740	62	under	under	IN
18637	19740	63	threat	threat	NN
18637	19740	64	and	and	CC
18637	19740	65	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	19740	66	by	by	IN
18637	19740	67	the	the	DT
18637	19740	68	State	State	NNP
18637	19740	69	,	,	,
18637	19740	70	the	the	DT
18637	19740	71	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19740	72	,	,	,
18637	19740	73	in	in	IN
18637	19740	74	Pyle	Pyle	NNP
18637	19740	75	_	_	NNP
18637	19740	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	19740	77	_	_	NNP
18637	19740	78	Kansas[942	Kansas[942	NNP
18637	19740	79	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19740	80	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	19740	81	the	the	DT
18637	19740	82	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	19740	83	court	court	NN
18637	19740	84	's	's	POS
18637	19740	85	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	19740	86	to	to	TO
18637	19740	87	issue	issue	VB
18637	19740	88	the	the	DT
18637	19740	89	writ	writ	NN
18637	19740	90	.	.	.
18637	19741	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	19741	2	as	as	IN
18637	19741	3	the	the	DT
18637	19741	4	record	record	NN
18637	19741	5	of	of	IN
18637	19741	6	the	the	DT
18637	19741	7	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	19741	8	's	's	POS
18637	19741	9	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19741	10	did	do	VBD
18637	19741	11	"	"	``
18637	19741	12	not	not	RB
18637	19741	13	controvert	controvert	VB
18637	19741	14	the	the	DT
18637	19741	15	charges	charge	NNS
18637	19741	16	that	that	WDT
18637	19741	17	perjured	perjure	VBD
18637	19741	18	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19741	19	was	be	VBD
18637	19741	20	used	use	VBN
18637	19741	21	,	,	,
18637	19741	22	and	and	CC
18637	19741	23	that	that	IN
18637	19741	24	favorable	favorable	JJ
18637	19741	25	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19741	26	was	be	VBD
18637	19741	27	suppressed	suppress	VBN
18637	19741	28	with	with	IN
18637	19741	29	the	the	DT
18637	19741	30	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	19741	31	"	"	''
18637	19741	32	of	of	IN
18637	19741	33	the	the	DT
18637	19741	34	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	19741	35	,	,	,
18637	19741	36	the	the	DT
18637	19741	37	case	case	NN
18637	19741	38	was	be	VBD
18637	19741	39	remanded	remand	VBN
18637	19741	40	in	in	IN
18637	19741	41	order	order	NN
18637	19741	42	that	that	IN
18637	19741	43	the	the	DT
18637	19741	44	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	19741	45	might	may	MD
18637	19741	46	enjoy	enjoy	VB
18637	19741	47	that	that	DT
18637	19741	48	to	to	TO
18637	19741	49	which	which	WDT
18637	19741	50	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19741	51	was	be	VBD
18637	19741	52	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19741	53	;	;	:
18637	19741	54	namely	namely	RB
18637	19741	55	,	,	,
18637	19741	56	a	a	DT
18637	19741	57	determination	determination	NN
18637	19741	58	of	of	IN
18637	19741	59	the	the	DT
18637	19741	60	verity	verity	NN
18637	19741	61	of	of	IN
18637	19741	62	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19741	63	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	19741	64	.	.	.
18637	19742	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19742	2	,	,	,
18637	19742	3	in	in	IN
18637	19742	4	White	White	NNP
18637	19742	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19742	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	19742	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19742	8	Ragen,[943	Ragen,[943	NNP
18637	19742	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19742	10	the	the	DT
18637	19742	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19742	12	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19742	13	that	that	IN
18637	19742	14	since	since	IN
18637	19742	15	a	a	DT
18637	19742	16	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	19742	17	's	's	POS
18637	19742	18	petition	petition	NN
18637	19742	19	to	to	IN
18637	19742	20	a	a	DT
18637	19742	21	State	State	NNP
18637	19742	22	court	court	NN
18637	19742	23	for	for	IN
18637	19742	24	release	release	NN
18637	19742	25	on	on	IN
18637	19742	26	_	_	NNP
18637	19742	27	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	19742	28	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	19742	29	_	_	NNP
18637	19742	30	had	have	VBD
18637	19742	31	been	be	VBN
18637	19742	32	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
18637	19742	33	without	without	IN
18637	19742	34	requiring	require	VBG
18637	19742	35	the	the	DT
18637	19742	36	State	State	NNP
18637	19742	37	to	to	TO
18637	19742	38	answer	answer	VB
18637	19742	39	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	19742	40	supporting	support	VBG
18637	19742	41	the	the	DT
18637	19742	42	petition	petition	NN
18637	19742	43	;	;	:
18637	19742	44	namely	namely	RB
18637	19742	45	,	,	,
18637	19742	46	that	that	IN
18637	19742	47	the	the	DT
18637	19742	48	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19742	49	was	be	VBD
18637	19742	50	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19742	51	by	by	IN
18637	19742	52	the	the	DT
18637	19742	53	use	use	NN
18637	19742	54	of	of	IN
18637	19742	55	false	false	JJ
18637	19742	56	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19742	57	procured	procure	VBN
18637	19742	58	by	by	IN
18637	19742	59	bribery	bribery	NN
18637	19742	60	of	of	IN
18637	19742	61	two	two	CD
18637	19742	62	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	19742	63	by	by	IN
18637	19742	64	the	the	DT
18637	19742	65	prosecutor	prosecutor	NN
18637	19742	66	,	,	,
18637	19742	67	must	must	MD
18637	19742	68	be	be	VB
18637	19742	69	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	19742	70	to	to	TO
18637	19742	71	be	be	VB
18637	19742	72	true	true	JJ
18637	19742	73	.	.	.
18637	19743	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19743	2	,	,	,
18637	19743	3	the	the	DT
18637	19743	4	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	19743	5	's	's	POS
18637	19743	6	contentions	contention	NNS
18637	19743	7	were	be	VBD
18637	19743	8	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19743	9	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19743	10	to	to	TO
18637	19743	11	make	make	VB
18637	19743	12	out	out	RP
18637	19743	13	a	a	DT
18637	19743	14	_	_	NNP
18637	19743	15	prima	prima	NN
18637	19743	16	facie	facie	NNP
18637	19743	17	_	_	NNP
18637	19743	18	case	case	NN
18637	19743	19	of	of	IN
18637	19743	20	violation	violation	NN
18637	19743	21	of	of	IN
18637	19743	22	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19743	23	rights	right	NNS
18637	19743	24	and	and	CC
18637	19743	25	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19743	26	to	to	TO
18637	19743	27	entitle	entitle	VB
18637	19743	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19743	29	to	to	TO
18637	19743	30	invoke	invoke	VB
18637	19743	31	corrective	corrective	JJ
18637	19743	32	process	process	NN
18637	19743	33	in	in	IN
18637	19743	34	a	a	DT
18637	19743	35	State	State	NNP
18637	19743	36	court	court	NN
18637	19743	37	.	.	.
18637	19744	1	Confrontation	confrontation	NN
18637	19744	2	;	;	:
18637	19744	3	Presence	Presence	NNP
18637	19744	4	of	of	IN
18637	19744	5	the	the	DT
18637	19744	6	Accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19744	7	;	;	:
18637	19744	8	Public	Public	NNP
18637	19744	9	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	19744	10	On	on	IN
18637	19744	11	the	the	DT
18637	19744	12	issue	issue	NN
18637	19744	13	whether	whether	IN
18637	19744	14	the	the	DT
18637	19744	15	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	19744	16	of	of	IN
18637	19744	17	presence	presence	NN
18637	19744	18	,	,	,
18637	19744	19	confrontation	confrontation	NN
18637	19744	20	and	and	CC
18637	19744	21	cross	cross	NN
18637	19744	22	-	-	NN
18637	19744	23	examination	examination	JJ
18637	19744	24	face	face	NN
18637	19744	25	to	to	IN
18637	19744	26	face	face	NN
18637	19744	27	,	,	,
18637	19744	28	assured	assure	VBN
18637	19744	29	to	to	IN
18637	19744	30	a	a	DT
18637	19744	31	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19744	32	in	in	IN
18637	19744	33	a	a	DT
18637	19744	34	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19744	35	trial	trial	NN
18637	19744	36	by	by	IN
18637	19744	37	the	the	DT
18637	19744	38	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	19744	39	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19744	40	,	,	,
18637	19744	41	are	be	VBP
18637	19744	42	also	also	RB
18637	19744	43	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	19744	44	in	in	IN
18637	19744	45	State	State	NNP
18637	19744	46	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19744	47	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19744	48	,	,	,
18637	19744	49	the	the	DT
18637	19744	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19744	51	thus	thus	RB
18637	19744	52	far	far	RB
18637	19744	53	has	have	VBZ
18637	19744	54	been	be	VBN
18637	19744	55	unable	unable	JJ
18637	19744	56	to	to	TO
18637	19744	57	formulate	formulate	VB
18637	19744	58	an	an	DT
18637	19744	59	enduring	enduring	JJ
18637	19744	60	and	and	CC
18637	19744	61	unequivocal	unequivocal	JJ
18637	19744	62	answer	answer	NN
18637	19744	63	.	.	.
18637	19745	1	At	at	IN
18637	19745	2	times	time	NNS
18637	19745	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19745	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	19745	5	intimated	intimate	VBN
18637	19745	6	,	,	,
18637	19745	7	as	as	IN
18637	19745	8	in	in	IN
18637	19745	9	the	the	DT
18637	19745	10	following	follow	VBG
18637	19745	11	utterance	utterance	NN
18637	19745	12	,	,	,
18637	19745	13	that	that	IN
18637	19745	14	the	the	DT
18637	19745	15	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	19745	16	of	of	IN
18637	19745	17	all	all	PDT
18637	19745	18	these	these	DT
18637	19745	19	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	19745	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	19745	21	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19745	22	to	to	IN
18637	19745	23	due	due	JJ
18637	19745	24	process	process	NN
18637	19745	25	.	.	.
18637	19746	1	"	"	``
18637	19746	2	The	the	DT
18637	19746	3	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19746	4	presence	presence	NN
18637	19746	5	of	of	IN
18637	19746	6	the	the	DT
18637	19746	7	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19746	8	,	,	,
18637	19746	9	from	from	IN
18637	19746	10	the	the	DT
18637	19746	11	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	19746	12	to	to	IN
18637	19746	13	the	the	DT
18637	19746	14	end	end	NN
18637	19746	15	of	of	IN
18637	19746	16	a	a	DT
18637	19746	17	trial	trial	NN
18637	19746	18	for	for	IN
18637	19746	19	felony	felony	NN
18637	19746	20	,	,	,
18637	19746	21	involving	involve	VBG
18637	19746	22	life	life	NN
18637	19746	23	or	or	CC
18637	19746	24	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19746	25	,	,	,
18637	19746	26	as	as	RB
18637	19746	27	well	well	RB
18637	19746	28	as	as	IN
18637	19746	29	at	at	IN
18637	19746	30	the	the	DT
18637	19746	31	time	time	NN
18637	19746	32	final	final	JJ
18637	19746	33	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19746	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	19746	35	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19746	36	against	against	IN
18637	19746	37	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19746	38	,	,	,
18637	19746	39	may	may	MD
18637	19746	40	be	be	VB
18637	19746	41	,	,	,
18637	19746	42	and	and	CC
18637	19746	43	must	must	MD
18637	19746	44	be	be	VB
18637	19746	45	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	19746	46	to	to	TO
18637	19746	47	be	be	VB
18637	19746	48	,	,	,
18637	19746	49	vital	vital	JJ
18637	19746	50	to	to	IN
18637	19746	51	the	the	DT
18637	19746	52	proper	proper	JJ
18637	19746	53	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	19746	54	of	of	IN
18637	19746	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19746	56	defence	defence	NN
18637	19746	57	,	,	,
18637	19746	58	and	and	CC
18637	19746	59	can	can	MD
18637	19746	60	not	not	RB
18637	19746	61	be	be	VB
18637	19746	62	dispensed	dispense	VBN
18637	19746	63	with	with	IN
18637	19746	64	.	.	.
18637	19747	1	"	"	``
18637	19747	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19747	3	944	944	CD
18637	19747	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19747	5	Notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19747	6	this	this	DT
18637	19747	7	early	early	JJ
18637	19747	8	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	19747	9	,	,	,
18637	19747	10	the	the	DT
18637	19747	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19747	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19747	13	,	,	,
18637	19747	14	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	19747	15	years	year	NNS
18637	19747	16	later	later	RB
18637	19747	17	,	,	,
18637	19747	18	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	19747	19	a	a	DT
18637	19747	20	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	19747	21	court	court	NN
18637	19747	22	which	which	WDT
18637	19747	23	approved	approve	VBD
18637	19747	24	the	the	DT
18637	19747	25	questioning	questioning	NN
18637	19747	26	,	,	,
18637	19747	27	in	in	IN
18637	19747	28	the	the	DT
18637	19747	29	absence	absence	NN
18637	19747	30	of	of	IN
18637	19747	31	the	the	DT
18637	19747	32	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19747	33	and	and	CC
18637	19747	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19747	35	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19747	36	,	,	,
18637	19747	37	of	of	IN
18637	19747	38	a	a	DT
18637	19747	39	juror	juror	NN
18637	19747	40	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19747	41	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	19747	42	before	before	IN
18637	19747	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19747	44	was	be	VBD
18637	19747	45	sworn	swear	VBN
18637	19747	46	had	have	VBD
18637	19747	47	been	be	VBN
18637	19747	48	demanded	demand	VBN
18637	19747	49	.	.	.
18637	19748	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19748	2	945	945	CD
18637	19748	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19748	4	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	19748	5	as	as	IN
18637	19748	6	no	no	DT
18637	19748	7	injury	injury	NN
18637	19748	8	to	to	IN
18637	19748	9	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	19748	10	rights	right	NNS
18637	19748	11	of	of	IN
18637	19748	12	the	the	DT
18637	19748	13	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19748	14	was	be	VBD
18637	19748	15	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19748	16	to	to	TO
18637	19748	17	have	have	VB
18637	19748	18	been	be	VBN
18637	19748	19	inflicted	inflict	VBN
18637	19748	20	by	by	IN
18637	19748	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19748	22	occasional	occasional	JJ
18637	19748	23	absence	absence	NN
18637	19748	24	during	during	IN
18637	19748	25	a	a	DT
18637	19748	26	trial	trial	NN
18637	19748	27	,	,	,
18637	19748	28	no	no	DT
18637	19748	29	denial	denial	NN
18637	19748	30	of	of	IN
18637	19748	31	due	due	JJ
18637	19748	32	process	process	NN
18637	19748	33	was	be	VBD
18637	19748	34	declared	declare	VBN
18637	19748	35	to	to	TO
18637	19748	36	have	have	VB
18637	19748	37	resulted	result	VBN
18637	19748	38	from	from	IN
18637	19748	39	the	the	DT
18637	19748	40	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	19748	41	by	by	IN
18637	19748	42	the	the	DT
18637	19748	43	State	State	NNP
18637	19748	44	court	court	NN
18637	19748	45	of	of	IN
18637	19748	46	the	the	DT
18637	19748	47	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19748	48	's	's	POS
18637	19748	49	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	19748	50	of	of	IN
18637	19748	51	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19748	52	right	right	NN
18637	19748	53	to	to	TO
18637	19748	54	be	be	VB
18637	19748	55	present	present	JJ
18637	19748	56	.	.	.
18637	19749	1	In	in	IN
18637	19749	2	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	19749	3	with	with	IN
18637	19749	4	the	the	DT
18637	19749	5	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19749	6	case	case	NN
18637	19749	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19749	8	Felts	Felts	NNP
18637	19749	9	_	_	NNP
18637	19749	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	19749	11	_	_	NNP
18637	19749	12	Murphy,[946	Murphy,[946	NNP
18637	19749	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19749	14	which	which	WDT
18637	19749	15	contains	contain	VBZ
18637	19749	16	additional	additional	JJ
18637	19749	17	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19749	18	of	of	IN
18637	19749	19	an	an	DT
18637	19749	20	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	19749	21	inclination	inclination	NN
18637	19749	22	on	on	IN
18637	19749	23	the	the	DT
18637	19749	24	part	part	NN
18637	19749	25	of	of	IN
18637	19749	26	the	the	DT
18637	19749	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19749	28	to	to	TO
18637	19749	29	treat	treat	VB
18637	19749	30	as	as	IN
18637	19749	31	not	not	RB
18637	19749	32	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19749	33	the	the	DT
18637	19749	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	19749	35	of	of	IN
18637	19749	36	presence	presence	NN
18637	19749	37	,	,	,
18637	19749	38	confrontation	confrontation	NN
18637	19749	39	,	,	,
18637	19749	40	and	and	CC
18637	19749	41	cross	cross	NN
18637	19749	42	-	-	NN
18637	19749	43	examination	examination	JJ
18637	19749	44	face	face	NN
18637	19749	45	to	to	IN
18637	19749	46	face	face	NN
18637	19749	47	.	.	.
18637	19750	1	The	the	DT
18637	19750	2	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19750	3	in	in	IN
18637	19750	4	Felts	Felts	NNP
18637	19750	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19750	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	19750	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19750	8	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	19750	9	proved	prove	VBD
18637	19750	10	to	to	TO
18637	19750	11	be	be	VB
18637	19750	12	so	so	RB
18637	19750	13	deaf	deaf	JJ
18637	19750	14	that	that	IN
18637	19750	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19750	16	was	be	VBD
18637	19750	17	unable	unable	JJ
18637	19750	18	to	to	TO
18637	19750	19	hear	hear	VB
18637	19750	20	any	any	DT
18637	19750	21	of	of	IN
18637	19750	22	the	the	DT
18637	19750	23	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19750	24	of	of	IN
18637	19750	25	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	19750	26	,	,	,
18637	19750	27	and	and	CC
18637	19750	28	had	have	VBD
18637	19750	29	never	never	RB
18637	19750	30	had	have	VBN
18637	19750	31	the	the	DT
18637	19750	32	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19750	33	repeated	repeat	VBN
18637	19750	34	to	to	IN
18637	19750	35	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19750	36	.	.	.
18637	19751	1	While	while	IN
18637	19751	2	regretting	regret	VBG
18637	19751	3	that	that	IN
18637	19751	4	the	the	DT
18637	19751	5	trial	trial	NN
18637	19751	6	court	court	NN
18637	19751	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	19751	8	not	not	RB
18637	19751	9	had	have	VBN
18637	19751	10	the	the	DT
18637	19751	11	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19751	12	read	read	VB
18637	19751	13	or	or	CC
18637	19751	14	repeated	repeat	VBD
18637	19751	15	to	to	IN
18637	19751	16	the	the	DT
18637	19751	17	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19751	18	,	,	,
18637	19751	19	the	the	DT
18637	19751	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19751	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19751	22	held	hold	VBD
18637	19751	23	that	that	IN
18637	19751	24	a	a	DT
18637	19751	25	deaf	deaf	JJ
18637	19751	26	person	person	NN
18637	19751	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	19751	28	not	not	RB
18637	19751	29	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	19751	30	of	of	IN
18637	19751	31	due	due	JJ
18637	19751	32	process	process	NN
18637	19751	33	of	of	IN
18637	19751	34	law	law	NN
18637	19751	35	because	because	IN
18637	19751	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19751	37	had	have	VBD
18637	19751	38	not	not	RB
18637	19751	39	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19751	40	a	a	DT
18637	19751	41	word	word	NN
18637	19751	42	of	of	IN
18637	19751	43	the	the	DT
18637	19751	44	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19751	45	.	.	.
18637	19752	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19752	2	also	also	RB
18637	19752	3	did	do	VBD
18637	19752	4	not	not	RB
18637	19752	5	overlook	overlook	VB
18637	19752	6	the	the	DT
18637	19752	7	fact	fact	NN
18637	19752	8	the	the	DT
18637	19752	9	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19752	10	"	"	``
18637	19752	11	made	make	VBD
18637	19752	12	no	no	DT
18637	19752	13	objection	objection	NN
18637	19752	14	,	,	,
18637	19752	15	asked	ask	VBD
18637	19752	16	for	for	IN
18637	19752	17	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	19752	18	,	,	,
18637	19752	19	and	and	CC
18637	19752	20	permitted	permit	VBD
18637	19752	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19752	22	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19752	23	to	to	TO
18637	19752	24	take	take	VB
18637	19752	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19752	26	own	own	JJ
18637	19752	27	course	course	NN
18637	19752	28	.	.	.
18637	19752	29	"	"	''
18637	19753	1	That	that	IN
18637	19753	2	the	the	DT
18637	19753	3	presence	presence	NN
18637	19753	4	of	of	IN
18637	19753	5	the	the	DT
18637	19753	6	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19753	7	may	may	MD
18637	19753	8	be	be	VB
18637	19753	9	dispensed	dispense	VBN
18637	19753	10	with	with	IN
18637	19753	11	at	at	IN
18637	19753	12	various	various	JJ
18637	19753	13	stages	stage	NNS
18637	19753	14	of	of	IN
18637	19753	15	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19753	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19753	17	was	be	VBD
18637	19753	18	further	further	RB
18637	19753	19	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	19753	20	by	by	IN
18637	19753	21	the	the	DT
18637	19753	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19753	23	in	in	IN
18637	19753	24	Frank	Frank	NNP
18637	19753	25	_	_	NNP
18637	19753	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	19753	27	_	_	NNP
18637	19753	28	Mangum,[947	Mangum,[947	NNP
18637	19753	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19753	30	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	19753	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19753	32	held	hold	VBD
18637	19753	33	that	that	IN
18637	19753	34	the	the	DT
18637	19753	35	presence	presence	NN
18637	19753	36	of	of	IN
18637	19753	37	the	the	DT
18637	19753	38	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19753	39	when	when	WRB
18637	19753	40	the	the	DT
18637	19753	41	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	19753	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	19753	43	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19753	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	19753	45	not	not	RB
18637	19753	46	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19753	47	,	,	,
18637	19753	48	and	and	CC
18637	19753	49	,	,	,
18637	19753	50	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19753	51	,	,	,
18637	19753	52	that	that	IN
18637	19753	53	a	a	DT
18637	19753	54	rule	rule	NN
18637	19753	55	of	of	IN
18637	19753	56	practice	practice	NN
18637	19753	57	allowing	allow	VBG
18637	19753	58	the	the	DT
18637	19753	59	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19753	60	to	to	TO
18637	19753	61	waive	waive	VB
18637	19753	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19753	63	and	and	CC
18637	19753	64	which	which	WDT
18637	19753	65	bound	bind	VBD
18637	19753	66	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19753	67	by	by	IN
18637	19753	68	that	that	DT
18637	19753	69	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	19753	70	did	do	VBD
18637	19753	71	not	not	RB
18637	19753	72	effect	effect	VB
18637	19753	73	any	any	DT
18637	19753	74	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19753	75	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19753	76	.	.	.
18637	19754	1	Enumerating	enumerate	VBG
18637	19754	2	many	many	JJ
18637	19754	3	departures	departure	NNS
18637	19754	4	from	from	IN
18637	19754	5	common	common	JJ
18637	19754	6	law	law	NN
18637	19754	7	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19754	8	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	19754	9	jury	jury	NN
18637	19754	10	trials	trial	NNS
18637	19754	11	,	,	,
18637	19754	12	including	include	VBG
18637	19754	13	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	19754	14	waiving	waive	VBG
18637	19754	15	the	the	DT
18637	19754	16	presence	presence	NN
18637	19754	17	of	of	IN
18637	19754	18	an	an	DT
18637	19754	19	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19754	20	during	during	IN
18637	19754	21	portions	portion	NNS
18637	19754	22	of	of	IN
18637	19754	23	a	a	DT
18637	19754	24	trial	trial	NN
18637	19754	25	,	,	,
18637	19754	26	the	the	DT
18637	19754	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19754	28	emphasized	emphasize	VBD
18637	19754	29	that	that	IN
18637	19754	30	none	none	NN
18637	19754	31	of	of	IN
18637	19754	32	these	these	DT
18637	19754	33	changes	change	NNS
18637	19754	34	had	have	VBD
18637	19754	35	been	be	VBN
18637	19754	36	construed	construe	VBN
18637	19754	37	as	as	IN
18637	19754	38	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	19754	39	with	with	IN
18637	19754	40	the	the	DT
18637	19754	41	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19754	42	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19754	43	.	.	.
18637	19755	1	More	more	RBR
18637	19755	2	recently	recently	RB
18637	19755	3	,	,	,
18637	19755	4	the	the	DT
18637	19755	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19755	6	,	,	,
18637	19755	7	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	19755	8	,	,	,
18637	19755	9	by	by	IN
18637	19755	10	only	only	RB
18637	19755	11	a	a	DT
18637	19755	12	five	five	CD
18637	19755	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	19755	14	to	to	IN
18637	19755	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	19755	16	four	four	CD
18637	19755	17	vote	vote	NN
18637	19755	18	,	,	,
18637	19755	19	however	however	RB
18637	19755	20	,	,	,
18637	19755	21	a	a	DT
18637	19755	22	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19755	23	for	for	IN
18637	19755	24	murder	murder	NN
18637	19755	25	where	where	WRB
18637	19755	26	the	the	DT
18637	19755	27	trial	trial	NN
18637	19755	28	court	court	NN
18637	19755	29	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	19755	30	the	the	DT
18637	19755	31	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19755	32	's	's	POS
18637	19755	33	request	request	NN
18637	19755	34	that	that	IN
18637	19755	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19755	36	be	be	VB
18637	19755	37	present	present	JJ
18637	19755	38	at	at	IN
18637	19755	39	a	a	DT
18637	19755	40	view	view	NN
18637	19755	41	of	of	IN
18637	19755	42	the	the	DT
18637	19755	43	scene	scene	NN
18637	19755	44	of	of	IN
18637	19755	45	the	the	DT
18637	19755	46	murder	murder	NN
18637	19755	47	to	to	TO
18637	19755	48	which	which	WDT
18637	19755	49	the	the	DT
18637	19755	50	jury	jury	NN
18637	19755	51	had	have	VBD
18637	19755	52	been	be	VBN
18637	19755	53	taken	take	VBN
18637	19755	54	.	.	.
18637	19756	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19756	2	948	948	CD
18637	19756	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19756	4	Acknowledging	acknowledge	VBG
18637	19756	5	that	that	IN
18637	19756	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19756	7	had	have	VBD
18637	19756	8	never	never	RB
18637	19756	9	squarely	squarely	RB
18637	19756	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	19756	11	,	,	,
18637	19756	12	though	though	IN
18637	19756	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19756	14	now	now	RB
18637	19756	15	assumed	assume	VBD
18637	19756	16	,	,	,
18637	19756	17	that	that	IN
18637	19756	18	"	"	``
18637	19756	19	the	the	DT
18637	19756	20	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19756	21	to	to	TO
18637	19756	22	confront	confront	VB
18637	19756	23	one	one	PRP
18637	19756	24	's	's	POS
18637	19756	25	accusers	accuser	NNS
18637	19756	26	and	and	CC
18637	19756	27	cross	cross	NN
18637	19756	28	-	-	NN
18637	19756	29	examine	examine	VB
18637	19756	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19756	31	face	face	NN
18637	19756	32	to	to	IN
18637	19756	33	face	face	NN
18637	19756	34	"	"	''
18637	19756	35	in	in	IN
18637	19756	36	State	State	NNP
18637	19756	37	court	court	NN
18637	19756	38	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	19756	39	"	"	''
18637	19756	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	19756	41	reinforced	reinforce	VBN
18637	19756	42	by	by	IN
18637	19756	43	the	the	DT
18637	19756	44	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19756	45	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19756	46	,	,	,
18637	19756	47	"	"	''
18637	19756	48	the	the	DT
18637	19756	49	majority	majority	NN
18637	19756	50	devised	devise	VBD
18637	19756	51	the	the	DT
18637	19756	52	following	following	JJ
18637	19756	53	standard	standard	NN
18637	19756	54	for	for	IN
18637	19756	55	disposing	dispose	VBG
18637	19756	56	of	of	IN
18637	19756	57	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19756	58	cases	case	NNS
18637	19756	59	in	in	IN
18637	19756	60	the	the	DT
18637	19756	61	future	future	NN
18637	19756	62	.	.	.
18637	19757	1	"	"	``
18637	19757	2	In	in	IN
18637	19757	3	a	a	DT
18637	19757	4	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	19757	5	for	for	IN
18637	19757	6	a	a	DT
18637	19757	7	felony	felony	NN
18637	19757	8	,	,	,
18637	19757	9	"	"	''
18637	19757	10	five	five	CD
18637	19757	11	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	19757	12	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19757	13	,	,	,
18637	19757	14	"	"	``
18637	19757	15	the	the	DT
18637	19757	16	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19757	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	19757	18	the	the	DT
18637	19757	19	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19757	20	under	under	IN
18637	19757	21	the	the	DT
18637	19757	22	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19757	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19757	24	to	to	TO
18637	19757	25	be	be	VB
18637	19757	26	present	present	JJ
18637	19757	27	in	in	IN
18637	19757	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19757	29	own	own	JJ
18637	19757	30	person	person	NN
18637	19757	31	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	19757	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19757	33	presence	presence	NN
18637	19757	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	19757	35	a	a	DT
18637	19757	36	relation	relation	NN
18637	19757	37	,	,	,
18637	19757	38	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	19757	39	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	19757	40	,	,	,
18637	19757	41	to	to	IN
18637	19757	42	the	the	DT
18637	19757	43	fulness	fulness	NN
18637	19757	44	of	of	IN
18637	19757	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19757	46	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19757	47	to	to	TO
18637	19757	48	defend	defend	VB
18637	19757	49	against	against	IN
18637	19757	50	the	the	DT
18637	19757	51	charge	charge	NN
18637	19757	52	.	.	.
18637	19758	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19758	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19758	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19758	4	The	the	DT
18637	19758	5	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19758	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19758	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	19758	8	not	not	RB
18637	19758	9	assume	assume	VB
18637	19758	10	to	to	IN
18637	19758	11	a	a	DT
18637	19758	12	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19758	13	the	the	DT
18637	19758	14	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19758	15	to	to	TO
18637	19758	16	be	be	VB
18637	19758	17	present	present	JJ
18637	19758	18	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19758	19	when	when	WRB
18637	19758	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19758	21	*	*	NFP
18637	19758	22	*	*	NFP
18637	19758	23	*	*	NFP
18637	19758	24	presence	presence	NN
18637	19758	25	would	would	MD
18637	19758	26	be	be	VB
18637	19758	27	useless	useless	JJ
18637	19758	28	,	,	,
18637	19758	29	or	or	CC
18637	19758	30	the	the	DT
18637	19758	31	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19758	32	but	but	CC
18637	19758	33	a	a	DT
18637	19758	34	shadow	shadow	NN
18637	19758	35	.	.	.
18637	19759	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19759	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19759	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19759	4	The	the	DT
18637	19759	5	presence	presence	NN
18637	19759	6	of	of	IN
18637	19759	7	a	a	DT
18637	19759	8	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19759	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19759	10	a	a	DT
18637	19759	11	condition	condition	NN
18637	19759	12	of	of	IN
18637	19759	13	due	due	JJ
18637	19759	14	process	process	NN
18637	19759	15	to	to	IN
18637	19759	16	the	the	DT
18637	19759	17	extent	extent	NN
18637	19759	18	that	that	IN
18637	19759	19	a	a	DT
18637	19759	20	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19759	21	and	and	CC
18637	19759	22	just	just	RB
18637	19759	23	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19759	24	would	would	MD
18637	19759	25	be	be	VB
18637	19759	26	thwarted	thwart	VBN
18637	19759	27	by	by	IN
18637	19759	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19759	29	absence	absence	NN
18637	19759	30	,	,	,
18637	19759	31	and	and	CC
18637	19759	32	to	to	IN
18637	19759	33	that	that	DT
18637	19759	34	extent	extent	NN
18637	19759	35	only	only	RB
18637	19759	36	.	.	.
18637	19759	37	"	"	''
18637	19760	1	Employing	employ	VBG
18637	19760	2	this	this	DT
18637	19760	3	standard	standard	NN
18637	19760	4	of	of	IN
18637	19760	5	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	19760	6	,	,	,
18637	19760	7	the	the	DT
18637	19760	8	majority	majority	NN
18637	19760	9	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	19760	10	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	19760	11	that	that	IN
18637	19760	12	no	no	DT
18637	19760	13	harm	harm	NN
18637	19760	14	or	or	CC
18637	19760	15	damage	damage	NN
18637	19760	16	had	have	VBD
18637	19760	17	been	be	VBN
18637	19760	18	done	do	VBN
18637	19760	19	to	to	IN
18637	19760	20	the	the	DT
18637	19760	21	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19760	22	by	by	IN
18637	19760	23	reason	reason	NN
18637	19760	24	of	of	IN
18637	19760	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19760	26	failure	failure	NN
18637	19760	27	to	to	TO
18637	19760	28	be	be	VB
18637	19760	29	present	present	JJ
18637	19760	30	when	when	WRB
18637	19760	31	the	the	DT
18637	19760	32	jury	jury	NN
18637	19760	33	viewed	view	VBD
18637	19760	34	the	the	DT
18637	19760	35	site	site	NN
18637	19760	36	of	of	IN
18637	19760	37	the	the	DT
18637	19760	38	murder	murder	NN
18637	19760	39	.	.	.
18637	19761	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19761	2	949	949	CD
18637	19761	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19761	4	To	to	IN
18637	19761	5	what	what	WDT
18637	19761	6	extent	extent	NN
18637	19761	7	,	,	,
18637	19761	8	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	19761	9	with	with	IN
18637	19761	10	due	due	JJ
18637	19761	11	process	process	NN
18637	19761	12	,	,	,
18637	19761	13	States	States	NNP
18637	19761	14	may	may	MD
18637	19761	15	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	19761	16	the	the	DT
18637	19761	17	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	19761	18	,	,	,
18637	19761	19	after	after	IN
18637	19761	20	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19761	21	and	and	CC
18637	19761	22	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19761	23	,	,	,
18637	19761	24	of	of	IN
18637	19761	25	nonadversary	nonadversary	JJ
18637	19761	26	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19761	27	from	from	IN
18637	19761	28	which	which	WDT
18637	19761	29	the	the	DT
18637	19761	30	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19761	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	19761	32	been	be	VBN
18637	19761	33	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	19761	34	and	and	CC
18637	19761	35	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19761	36	the	the	DT
18637	19761	37	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19761	38	of	of	IN
18637	19761	39	confrontation	confrontation	NN
18637	19761	40	and	and	CC
18637	19761	41	cross	cross	NN
18637	19761	42	-	-	NN
18637	19761	43	examination	examination	NN
18637	19761	44	,	,	,
18637	19761	45	has	have	VBZ
18637	19761	46	been	be	VBN
18637	19761	47	examined	examine	VBN
18637	19761	48	by	by	IN
18637	19761	49	the	the	DT
18637	19761	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19761	51	in	in	IN
18637	19761	52	two	two	CD
18637	19761	53	recent	recent	JJ
18637	19761	54	cases	case	NNS
18637	19761	55	.	.	.
18637	19762	1	In	in	IN
18637	19762	2	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	19762	3	_	_	NNP
18637	19762	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	19762	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19762	6	New	New	NNP
18637	19762	7	York,[950	York,[950	NNP
18637	19762	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19762	9	the	the	DT
18637	19762	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19762	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19762	12	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	19762	13	the	the	DT
18637	19762	14	contention	contention	NN
18637	19762	15	that	that	IN
18637	19762	16	the	the	DT
18637	19762	17	due	due	JJ
18637	19762	18	process	process	NN
18637	19762	19	clause	clause	NN
18637	19762	20	requires	require	VBZ
18637	19762	21	that	that	IN
18637	19762	22	a	a	DT
18637	19762	23	person	person	NN
18637	19762	24	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	19762	25	of	of	IN
18637	19762	26	murder	murder	NN
18637	19762	27	be	be	VB
18637	19762	28	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	19762	29	to	to	IN
18637	19762	30	cross	cross	VB
18637	19762	31	-	-	JJ
18637	19762	32	examine	examine	JJ
18637	19762	33	probation	probation	NN
18637	19762	34	officers	officer	NNS
18637	19762	35	as	as	IN
18637	19762	36	to	to	IN
18637	19762	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19762	38	prior	prior	JJ
18637	19762	39	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19762	40	record	record	NN
18637	19762	41	when	when	WRB
18637	19762	42	the	the	DT
18637	19762	43	trial	trial	NN
18637	19762	44	judge	judge	NN
18637	19762	45	,	,	,
18637	19762	46	in	in	IN
18637	19762	47	the	the	DT
18637	19762	48	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19762	49	of	of	IN
18637	19762	50	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	19762	51	vested	vest	VBN
18637	19762	52	in	in	IN
18637	19762	53	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19762	54	by	by	IN
18637	19762	55	law	law	NN
18637	19762	56	,	,	,
18637	19762	57	considers	consider	VBZ
18637	19762	58	such	such	JJ
18637	19762	59	information	information	NN
18637	19762	60	,	,	,
18637	19762	61	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19762	62	outside	outside	IN
18637	19762	63	the	the	DT
18637	19762	64	courtroom	courtroom	NN
18637	19762	65	,	,	,
18637	19762	66	in	in	IN
18637	19762	67	determining	determine	VBG
18637	19762	68	whether	whether	IN
18637	19762	69	to	to	TO
18637	19762	70	abide	abide	VB
18637	19762	71	by	by	IN
18637	19762	72	a	a	DT
18637	19762	73	jury	jury	NN
18637	19762	74	's	's	POS
18637	19762	75	recommendation	recommendation	NN
18637	19762	76	of	of	IN
18637	19762	77	life	life	NN
18637	19762	78	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	19762	79	or	or	CC
18637	19762	80	to	to	TO
18637	19762	81	impose	impose	VB
18637	19762	82	a	a	DT
18637	19762	83	death	death	NN
18637	19762	84	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19762	85	.	.	.
18637	19763	1	Emphasizing	emphasize	VBG
18637	19763	2	the	the	DT
18637	19763	3	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	19763	4	between	between	IN
18637	19763	5	evidentiary	evidentiary	JJ
18637	19763	6	rules	rule	NNS
18637	19763	7	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	19763	8	to	to	IN
18637	19763	9	the	the	DT
18637	19763	10	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	19763	11	of	of	IN
18637	19763	12	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19763	13	trials	trial	NNS
18637	19763	14	,	,	,
18637	19763	15	which	which	WDT
18637	19763	16	are	be	VBP
18637	19763	17	confined	confine	VBN
18637	19763	18	to	to	IN
18637	19763	19	the	the	DT
18637	19763	20	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	19763	21	issue	issue	NN
18637	19763	22	of	of	IN
18637	19763	23	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	19763	24	,	,	,
18637	19763	25	and	and	CC
18637	19763	26	sentencing	sentencing	NN
18637	19763	27	procedures	procedure	NNS
18637	19763	28	which	which	WDT
18637	19763	29	pertain	pertain	VBP
18637	19763	30	to	to	IN
18637	19763	31	the	the	DT
18637	19763	32	determination	determination	NN
18637	19763	33	of	of	IN
18637	19763	34	the	the	DT
18637	19763	35	type	type	NN
18637	19763	36	and	and	CC
18637	19763	37	extent	extent	NN
18637	19763	38	of	of	IN
18637	19763	39	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	19763	40	after	after	IN
18637	19763	41	the	the	DT
18637	19763	42	issue	issue	NN
18637	19763	43	of	of	IN
18637	19763	44	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	19763	45	has	have	VBZ
18637	19763	46	been	be	VBN
18637	19763	47	decided	decide	VBN
18637	19763	48	,	,	,
18637	19763	49	the	the	DT
18637	19763	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19763	51	disposed	dispose	VBD
18637	19763	52	of	of	IN
18637	19763	53	the	the	DT
18637	19763	54	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	19763	55	's	's	POS
18637	19763	56	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	19763	57	by	by	IN
18637	19763	58	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	19763	59	that	that	DT
18637	19763	60	,	,	,
18637	19763	61	"	"	``
18637	19763	62	modern	modern	JJ
18637	19763	63	concepts	concept	NNS
18637	19763	64	individualizing	individualize	VBG
18637	19763	65	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	19763	66	have	have	VBP
18637	19763	67	made	make	VBN
18637	19763	68	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19763	69	all	all	PDT
18637	19763	70	the	the	DT
18637	19763	71	more	more	RBR
18637	19763	72	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19763	73	that	that	IN
18637	19763	74	a	a	DT
18637	19763	75	sentencing	sentencing	NN
18637	19763	76	judge	judge	NN
18637	19763	77	not	not	RB
18637	19763	78	be	be	VB
18637	19763	79	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19763	80	an	an	DT
18637	19763	81	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19763	82	to	to	TO
18637	19763	83	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	19763	84	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	19763	85	information	information	NN
18637	19763	86	by	by	IN
18637	19763	87	a	a	DT
18637	19763	88	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19763	89	of	of	IN
18637	19763	90	rigid	rigid	JJ
18637	19763	91	adherence	adherence	NN
18637	19763	92	to	to	IN
18637	19763	93	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	19763	94	rules	rule	NNS
18637	19763	95	of	of	IN
18637	19763	96	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19763	97	properly	properly	RB
18637	19763	98	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	19763	99	to	to	IN
18637	19763	100	the	the	DT
18637	19763	101	trial	trial	NN
18637	19763	102	.	.	.
18637	19764	1	"	"	``
18637	19764	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19764	3	951	951	CD
18637	19764	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19764	5	By	by	IN
18637	19764	6	a	a	DT
18637	19764	7	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19764	8	process	process	NN
18637	19764	9	of	of	IN
18637	19764	10	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	19764	11	,	,	,
18637	19764	12	in	in	IN
18637	19764	13	Solesbee	Solesbee	NNP
18637	19764	14	_	_	NNP
18637	19764	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	19764	16	_	_	NNP
18637	19764	17	Balkcom,[952	Balkcom,[952	NNP
18637	19764	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19764	19	the	the	DT
18637	19764	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19764	21	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	19764	22	a	a	DT
18637	19764	23	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	19764	24	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	19764	25	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19764	26	granting	grant	VBG
18637	19764	27	the	the	DT
18637	19764	28	governor	governor	NN
18637	19764	29	discretionary	discretionary	NNP
18637	19764	30	authority	authority	NNP
18637	19764	31	,	,	,
18637	19764	32	with	with	IN
18637	19764	33	the	the	DT
18637	19764	34	aid	aid	NN
18637	19764	35	of	of	IN
18637	19764	36	physicians	physician	NNS
18637	19764	37	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	19764	38	by	by	IN
18637	19764	39	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19764	40	,	,	,
18637	19764	41	to	to	TO
18637	19764	42	determine	determine	VB
18637	19764	43	,	,	,
18637	19764	44	without	without	IN
18637	19764	45	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19764	46	for	for	IN
18637	19764	47	an	an	DT
18637	19764	48	adversary	adversary	NN
18637	19764	49	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19764	50	or	or	CC
18637	19764	51	for	for	IN
18637	19764	52	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19764	53	review	review	NN
18637	19764	54	,	,	,
18637	19764	55	whether	whether	IN
18637	19764	56	a	a	DT
18637	19764	57	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	19764	58	convict	convict	NN
18637	19764	59	has	have	VBZ
18637	19764	60	become	become	VBN
18637	19764	61	insane	insane	JJ
18637	19764	62	and	and	CC
18637	19764	63	,	,	,
18637	19764	64	if	if	IN
18637	19764	65	so	so	RB
18637	19764	66	,	,	,
18637	19764	67	whether	whether	IN
18637	19764	68	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19764	69	should	should	MD
18637	19764	70	be	be	VB
18637	19764	71	committed	commit	VBN
18637	19764	72	to	to	IN
18637	19764	73	an	an	DT
18637	19764	74	insane	insane	JJ
18637	19764	75	asylum	asylum	NN
18637	19764	76	.	.	.
18637	19765	1	Likening	liken	VBG
18637	19765	2	the	the	DT
18637	19765	3	function	function	NN
18637	19765	4	thus	thus	RB
18637	19765	5	vested	vest	VBN
18637	19765	6	in	in	IN
18637	19765	7	the	the	DT
18637	19765	8	governor	governor	NN
18637	19765	9	to	to	IN
18637	19765	10	the	the	DT
18637	19765	11	power	power	NN
18637	19765	12	of	of	IN
18637	19765	13	executive	executive	JJ
18637	19765	14	clemency	clemency	NN
18637	19765	15	,	,	,
18637	19765	16	the	the	DT
18637	19765	17	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19765	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19765	19	reiterated	reiterate	VBD
18637	19765	20	that	that	IN
18637	19765	21	"	"	``
18637	19765	22	trial	trial	NN
18637	19765	23	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19765	24	safeguards	safeguard	NNS
18637	19765	25	are	be	VBP
18637	19765	26	not	not	RB
18637	19765	27	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	19765	28	to	to	IN
18637	19765	29	the	the	DT
18637	19765	30	process	process	NN
18637	19765	31	of	of	IN
18637	19765	32	sentencing	sentencing	NN
18637	19765	33	,	,	,
18637	19765	34	"	"	''
18637	19765	35	and	and	CC
18637	19765	36	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	19765	37	with	with	IN
18637	19765	38	the	the	DT
18637	19765	39	observation	observation	NN
18637	19765	40	that	that	IN
18637	19765	41	the	the	DT
18637	19765	42	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	19765	43	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19765	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	19765	45	amply	amply	RB
18637	19765	46	supported	support	VBN
18637	19765	47	by	by	IN
18637	19765	48	"	"	``
18637	19765	49	the	the	DT
18637	19765	50	universal	universal	JJ
18637	19765	51	common	common	JJ
18637	19765	52	-	-	HYPH
18637	19765	53	law	law	NN
18637	19765	54	principle	principle	NN
18637	19765	55	that	that	IN
18637	19765	56	upon	upon	IN
18637	19765	57	a	a	DT
18637	19765	58	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	19765	59	of	of	IN
18637	19765	60	insanity	insanity	NN
18637	19765	61	after	after	IN
18637	19765	62	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19765	63	,	,	,
18637	19765	64	the	the	DT
18637	19765	65	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	19765	66	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19765	67	with	with	IN
18637	19765	68	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	19765	69	must	must	MD
18637	19765	70	be	be	VB
18637	19765	71	vested	vest	VBN
18637	19765	72	with	with	IN
18637	19765	73	broad	broad	JJ
18637	19765	74	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	19765	75	in	in	IN
18637	19765	76	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	19765	77	whether	whether	IN
18637	19765	78	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19765	79	shall	shall	MD
18637	19765	80	be	be	VB
18637	19765	81	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19765	82	.	.	.
18637	19766	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19766	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19766	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19766	4	The	the	DT
18637	19766	5	heart	heart	NN
18637	19766	6	of	of	IN
18637	19766	7	the	the	DT
18637	19766	8	common	common	JJ
18637	19766	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	19766	10	law	law	NN
18637	19766	11	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	19766	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	19766	13	been	be	VBN
18637	19766	14	that	that	IN
18637	19766	15	a	a	DT
18637	19766	16	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	19766	17	of	of	IN
18637	19766	18	insanity	insanity	NN
18637	19766	19	after	after	IN
18637	19766	20	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19766	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	19766	22	an	an	DT
18637	19766	23	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	19766	24	to	to	IN
18637	19766	25	the	the	DT
18637	19766	26	conscience	conscience	NN
18637	19766	27	and	and	CC
18637	19766	28	sound	sound	VB
18637	19766	29	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	19766	30	of	of	IN
18637	19766	31	the	the	DT
18637	19766	32	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19766	33	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	19766	34	which	which	WDT
18637	19766	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	19766	36	asked	ask	VBN
18637	19766	37	to	to	TO
18637	19766	38	postpone	postpone	VB
18637	19766	39	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19766	40	.	.	.
18637	19767	1	"	"	``
18637	19767	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19767	3	953	953	CD
18637	19767	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19767	5	When	when	WRB
18637	19767	6	employed	employ	VBN
18637	19767	7	in	in	IN
18637	19767	8	the	the	DT
18637	19767	9	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	19767	10	of	of	IN
18637	19767	11	the	the	DT
18637	19767	12	trial	trial	NN
18637	19767	13	,	,	,
18637	19767	14	however	however	RB
18637	19767	15	,	,	,
18637	19767	16	summary	summary	NN
18637	19767	17	procedures	procedure	NNS
18637	19767	18	such	such	JJ
18637	19767	19	as	as	IN
18637	19767	20	those	those	DT
18637	19767	21	examined	examine	VBN
18637	19767	22	in	in	IN
18637	19767	23	the	the	DT
18637	19767	24	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	19767	25	two	two	CD
18637	19767	26	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19767	27	invariably	invariably	RB
18637	19767	28	elicit	elicit	VBZ
18637	19767	29	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19767	30	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	19767	31	.	.	.
18637	19768	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19768	2	,	,	,
18637	19768	3	when	when	WRB
18637	19768	4	a	a	DT
18637	19768	5	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	19768	6	judge	judge	NN
18637	19768	7	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	19768	8	as	as	IN
18637	19768	9	a	a	DT
18637	19768	10	one	one	CD
18637	19768	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	19768	12	man	man	NN
18637	19768	13	grand	grand	JJ
18637	19768	14	jury	jury	NN
18637	19768	15	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	19768	16	that	that	IN
18637	19768	17	a	a	DT
18637	19768	18	witness	witness	NN
18637	19768	19	had	have	VBD
18637	19768	20	given	give	VBN
18637	19768	21	false	false	JJ
18637	19768	22	and	and	CC
18637	19768	23	evasive	evasive	JJ
18637	19768	24	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19768	25	,	,	,
18637	19768	26	not	not	RB
18637	19768	27	on	on	IN
18637	19768	28	the	the	DT
18637	19768	29	basis	basis	NN
18637	19768	30	of	of	IN
18637	19768	31	anything	anything	NN
18637	19768	32	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	19768	33	in	in	IN
18637	19768	34	the	the	DT
18637	19768	35	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19768	36	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19768	37	,	,	,
18637	19768	38	but	but	CC
18637	19768	39	at	at	IN
18637	19768	40	least	least	JJS
18637	19768	41	in	in	IN
18637	19768	42	part	part	NN
18637	19768	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	19768	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19768	45	inconsistency	inconsistency	NN
18637	19768	46	with	with	IN
18637	19768	47	other	other	JJ
18637	19768	48	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19768	49	given	give	VBN
18637	19768	50	by	by	IN
18637	19768	51	a	a	DT
18637	19768	52	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	19768	53	witness	witness	NN
18637	19768	54	,	,	,
18637	19768	55	and	and	CC
18637	19768	56	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	19768	57	thereupon	thereupon	RB
18637	19768	58	suspended	suspend	VBD
18637	19768	59	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19768	60	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	19768	61	,	,	,
18637	19768	62	and	and	CC
18637	19768	63	committed	commit	VBD
18637	19768	64	the	the	DT
18637	19768	65	witness	witness	NN
18637	19768	66	to	to	IN
18637	19768	67	jail	jail	NN
18637	19768	68	for	for	IN
18637	19768	69	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	19768	70	,	,	,
18637	19768	71	such	such	JJ
18637	19768	72	summary	summary	NN
18637	19768	73	commitment	commitment	NN
18637	19768	74	,	,	,
18637	19768	75	in	in	IN
18637	19768	76	the	the	DT
18637	19768	77	absence	absence	NN
18637	19768	78	of	of	IN
18637	19768	79	a	a	DT
18637	19768	80	showing	showing	NN
18637	19768	81	that	that	IN
18637	19768	82	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19768	83	was	be	VBD
18637	19768	84	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19768	85	to	to	TO
18637	19768	86	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	19768	87	demoralization	demoralization	NN
18637	19768	88	of	of	IN
18637	19768	89	the	the	DT
18637	19768	90	judge	judge	NN
18637	19768	91	's	's	POS
18637	19768	92	authority	authority	NN
18637	19768	93	,	,	,
18637	19768	94	was	be	VBD
18637	19768	95	held	hold	VBN
18637	19768	96	to	to	TO
18637	19768	97	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	19768	98	a	a	DT
18637	19768	99	denial	denial	NN
18637	19768	100	of	of	IN
18637	19768	101	due	due	JJ
18637	19768	102	process	process	NN
18637	19768	103	.	.	.
18637	19769	1	The	the	DT
18637	19769	2	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	19769	3	of	of	IN
18637	19769	4	that	that	DT
18637	19769	5	clause	clause	NN
18637	19769	6	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	19769	7	the	the	DT
18637	19769	8	sentencing	sentencing	NN
18637	19769	9	of	of	IN
18637	19769	10	an	an	DT
18637	19769	11	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19769	12	person	person	NN
18637	19769	13	to	to	IN
18637	19769	14	prison	prison	NN
18637	19769	15	without	without	IN
18637	19769	16	a	a	DT
18637	19769	17	public	public	JJ
18637	19769	18	trial	trial	NN
18637	19769	19	;	;	:
18637	19769	20	that	that	RB
18637	19769	21	is	is	RB
18637	19769	22	,	,	,
18637	19769	23	without	without	IN
18637	19769	24	a	a	DT
18637	19769	25	day	day	NN
18637	19769	26	in	in	IN
18637	19769	27	court	court	NN
18637	19769	28	,	,	,
18637	19769	29	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19769	30	notice	notice	NN
18637	19769	31	of	of	IN
18637	19769	32	the	the	DT
18637	19769	33	charges	charge	NNS
18637	19769	34	,	,	,
18637	19769	35	and	and	CC
18637	19769	36	an	an	DT
18637	19769	37	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19769	38	to	to	TO
18637	19769	39	be	be	VB
18637	19769	40	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19769	41	in	in	IN
18637	19769	42	one	one	NN
18637	19769	43	's	's	POS
18637	19769	44	defense	defense	NN
18637	19769	45	by	by	IN
18637	19769	46	cross	cross	NN
18637	19769	47	-	-	JJ
18637	19769	48	examining	examine	VBG
18637	19769	49	other	other	JJ
18637	19769	50	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	19769	51	,	,	,
18637	19769	52	or	or	CC
18637	19769	53	by	by	IN
18637	19769	54	summoning	summon	VBG
18637	19769	55	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	19769	56	to	to	TO
18637	19769	57	refute	refute	VB
18637	19769	58	the	the	DT
18637	19769	59	charges	charge	NNS
18637	19769	60	against	against	IN
18637	19769	61	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19769	62	.	.	.
18637	19770	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19770	2	954	954	CD
18637	19770	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19770	4	On	on	IN
18637	19770	5	the	the	DT
18637	19770	6	other	other	JJ
18637	19770	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	19770	8	,	,	,
18637	19770	9	when	when	WRB
18637	19770	10	the	the	DT
18637	19770	11	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	19770	12	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	19770	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	19770	14	committed	committed	JJ
18637	19770	15	,	,	,
18637	19770	16	not	not	RB
18637	19770	17	within	within	IN
18637	19770	18	the	the	DT
18637	19770	19	confines	confine	NNS
18637	19770	20	of	of	IN
18637	19770	21	a	a	DT
18637	19770	22	secret	secret	JJ
18637	19770	23	grand	grand	JJ
18637	19770	24	jury	jury	NN
18637	19770	25	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19770	26	,	,	,
18637	19770	27	but	but	CC
18637	19770	28	in	in	IN
18637	19770	29	open	open	JJ
18637	19770	30	court	court	NN
18637	19770	31	,	,	,
18637	19770	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	19770	33	readily	readily	RB
18637	19770	34	observable	observable	JJ
18637	19770	35	by	by	IN
18637	19770	36	the	the	DT
18637	19770	37	presiding	preside	VBG
18637	19770	38	judge	judge	NN
18637	19770	39	,	,	,
18637	19770	40	and	and	CC
18637	19770	41	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	19770	42	an	an	DT
18637	19770	43	open	open	JJ
18637	19770	44	and	and	CC
18637	19770	45	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	19770	46	threat	threat	NN
18637	19770	47	to	to	IN
18637	19770	48	orderly	orderly	JJ
18637	19770	49	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19770	50	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19770	51	and	and	CC
18637	19770	52	to	to	IN
18637	19770	53	the	the	DT
18637	19770	54	court	court	NN
18637	19770	55	's	's	POS
18637	19770	56	authority	authority	NN
18637	19770	57	,	,	,
18637	19770	58	the	the	DT
18637	19770	59	offended	offend	VBN
18637	19770	60	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	19770	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	19770	62	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	19770	63	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	19770	64	summarily	summarily	RB
18637	19770	65	to	to	TO
18637	19770	66	punish	punish	VB
18637	19770	67	without	without	IN
18637	19770	68	notice	notice	NN
18637	19770	69	,	,	,
18637	19770	70	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	19770	71	,	,	,
18637	19770	72	or	or	CC
18637	19770	73	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19770	74	.	.	.
18637	19771	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19771	2	in	in	IN
18637	19771	3	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	19771	4	_	_	NNP
18637	19771	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	19771	6	_	_	NNP
18637	19771	7	Pace,[955	Pace,[955	NNP
18637	19771	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19771	9	albeit	albeit	IN
18637	19771	10	with	with	IN
18637	19771	11	the	the	DT
18637	19771	12	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	19771	13	of	of	IN
18637	19771	14	only	only	RB
18637	19771	15	five	five	CD
18637	19771	16	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	19771	17	,	,	,
18637	19771	18	the	the	DT
18637	19771	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19771	20	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	19771	21	a	a	DT
18637	19771	22	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	19771	23	court	court	NN
18637	19771	24	's	's	POS
18637	19771	25	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19771	26	for	for	IN
18637	19771	27	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	19771	28	,	,	,
18637	19771	29	with	with	IN
18637	19771	30	progressive	progressive	JJ
18637	19771	31	increase	increase	NN
18637	19771	32	of	of	IN
18637	19771	33	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	19771	34	from	from	IN
18637	19771	35	a	a	DT
18637	19771	36	$	$	$
18637	19771	37	25	25	CD
18637	19771	38	to	to	TO
18637	19771	39	$	$	$
18637	19771	40	50	50	CD
18637	19771	41	to	to	TO
18637	19771	42	$	$	$
18637	19771	43	100	100	CD
18637	19771	44	fine	fine	JJ
18637	19771	45	plus	plus	CC
18637	19771	46	three	three	CD
18637	19771	47	days	day	NNS
18637	19771	48	in	in	IN
18637	19771	49	jail	jail	NN
18637	19771	50	,	,	,
18637	19771	51	of	of	IN
18637	19771	52	a	a	DT
18637	19771	53	trial	trial	NN
18637	19771	54	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	19771	55	who	who	WP
18637	19771	56	,	,	,
18637	19771	57	despite	despite	IN
18637	19771	58	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19771	59	admonition	admonition	NN
18637	19771	60	,	,	,
18637	19771	61	persisted	persist	VBD
18637	19771	62	in	in	IN
18637	19771	63	conveying	convey	VBG
18637	19771	64	to	to	IN
18637	19771	65	the	the	DT
18637	19771	66	jury	jury	NN
18637	19771	67	,	,	,
18637	19771	68	in	in	IN
18637	19771	69	a	a	DT
18637	19771	70	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	19771	71	's	's	POS
18637	19771	72	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19771	73	case	case	NN
18637	19771	74	,	,	,
18637	19771	75	information	information	NN
18637	19771	76	not	not	RB
18637	19771	77	for	for	IN
18637	19771	78	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19771	79	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	19771	80	.	.	.
18637	19772	1	Conceding	concede	VBG
18637	19772	2	that	that	IN
18637	19772	3	"	"	``
18637	19772	4	there	there	EX
18637	19772	5	must	must	MD
18637	19772	6	be	be	VB
18637	19772	7	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19772	8	facts	fact	NNS
18637	19772	9	to	to	TO
18637	19772	10	support	support	VB
18637	19772	11	an	an	DT
18637	19772	12	order	order	NN
18637	19772	13	for	for	IN
18637	19772	14	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	19772	15	,	,	,
18637	19772	16	"	"	''
18637	19772	17	the	the	DT
18637	19772	18	majority	majority	NN
18637	19772	19	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19772	20	that	that	IN
18637	19772	21	the	the	DT
18637	19772	22	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	19772	23	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19772	24	court	court	NN
18637	19772	25	's	's	POS
18637	19772	26	finding	finding	NN
18637	19772	27	in	in	IN
18637	19772	28	the	the	DT
18637	19772	29	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	19772	30	,	,	,
18637	19772	31	after	after	IN
18637	19772	32	evaluation	evaluation	NN
18637	19772	33	of	of	IN
18637	19772	34	the	the	DT
18637	19772	35	facts	fact	NNS
18637	19772	36	,	,	,
18637	19772	37	should	should	MD
18637	19772	38	not	not	RB
18637	19772	39	be	be	VB
18637	19772	40	overturned	overturn	VBN
18637	19772	41	inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	19772	42	as	as	IN
18637	19772	43	the	the	DT
18637	19772	44	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19772	45	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19772	46	,	,	,
18637	19772	47	in	in	IN
18637	19772	48	examining	examine	VBG
18637	19772	49	the	the	DT
18637	19772	50	transcript	transcript	NN
18637	19772	51	of	of	IN
18637	19772	52	the	the	DT
18637	19772	53	record	record	NN
18637	19772	54	,	,	,
18637	19772	55	could	could	MD
18637	19772	56	not	not	RB
18637	19772	57	derive	derive	VB
18637	19772	58	therefrom	therefrom	IN
18637	19772	59	an	an	DT
18637	19772	60	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19772	61	picture	picture	NN
18637	19772	62	of	of	IN
18637	19772	63	the	the	DT
18637	19772	64	courtroom	courtroom	NN
18637	19772	65	scene	scene	NN
18637	19772	66	nor	nor	CC
18637	19772	67	discern	discern	NN
18637	19772	68	therein	therein	RB
18637	19772	69	"	"	``
18637	19772	70	such	such	JJ
18637	19772	71	elements	element	NNS
18637	19772	72	of	of	IN
18637	19772	73	misbehavior	misbehavior	NN
18637	19772	74	as	as	IN
18637	19772	75	expression	expression	NN
18637	19772	76	,	,	,
18637	19772	77	manner	manner	NN
18637	19772	78	of	of	IN
18637	19772	79	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	19772	80	,	,	,
18637	19772	81	bearing	bearing	NN
18637	19772	82	,	,	,
18637	19772	83	and	and	CC
18637	19772	84	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	19772	85	of	of	IN
18637	19772	86	*	*	NFP
18637	19772	87	*	*	NFP
18637	19772	88	*	*	NFP
18637	19772	89	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19772	90	the	the	DT
18637	19772	91	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	19772	92	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19772	93	.	.	.
18637	19772	94	"	"	''
18637	19773	1	The	the	DT
18637	19773	2	fact	fact	NN
18637	19773	3	that	that	IN
18637	19773	4	the	the	DT
18637	19773	5	bench	bench	NN
18637	19773	6	was	be	VBD
18637	19773	7	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19773	8	of	of	IN
18637	19773	9	"	"	``
18637	19773	10	mildly	mildly	RB
18637	19773	11	provocative	provocative	JJ
18637	19773	12	language	language	NN
18637	19773	13	"	"	''
18637	19773	14	was	be	VBD
18637	19773	15	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19773	16	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	19773	17	to	to	TO
18637	19773	18	excuse	excuse	VB
18637	19773	19	the	the	DT
18637	19773	20	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	19773	21	of	of	IN
18637	19773	22	the	the	DT
18637	19773	23	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	19773	24	.	.	.
18637	19774	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19774	2	956	956	CD
18637	19774	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19774	4	Trial	trial	NN
18637	19774	5	by	by	IN
18637	19774	6	Impartial	Impartial	NNP
18637	19774	7	Tribunal	Tribunal	NNP
18637	19774	8	Inasmuch	Inasmuch	NNP
18637	19774	9	as	as	IN
18637	19774	10	due	due	JJ
18637	19774	11	process	process	NN
18637	19774	12	implies	imply	VBZ
18637	19774	13	a	a	DT
18637	19774	14	tribunal	tribunal	JJ
18637	19774	15	both	both	CC
18637	19774	16	impartial	impartial	JJ
18637	19774	17	and	and	CC
18637	19774	18	mentally	mentally	RB
18637	19774	19	competent	competent	JJ
18637	19774	20	to	to	TO
18637	19774	21	afford	afford	VB
18637	19774	22	a	a	DT
18637	19774	23	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19774	24	,	,	,
18637	19774	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19774	26	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	19774	27	that	that	IN
18637	19774	28	the	the	DT
18637	19774	29	subjection	subjection	NN
18637	19774	30	of	of	IN
18637	19774	31	a	a	DT
18637	19774	32	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19774	33	's	's	POS
18637	19774	34	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19774	35	or	or	CC
18637	19774	36	property	property	NN
18637	19774	37	to	to	IN
18637	19774	38	the	the	DT
18637	19774	39	decision	decision	NN
18637	19774	40	of	of	IN
18637	19774	41	a	a	DT
18637	19774	42	court	court	NN
18637	19774	43	,	,	,
18637	19774	44	the	the	DT
18637	19774	45	judge	judge	NN
18637	19774	46	of	of	IN
18637	19774	47	which	which	WDT
18637	19774	48	has	have	VBZ
18637	19774	49	a	a	DT
18637	19774	50	direct	direct	JJ
18637	19774	51	,	,	,
18637	19774	52	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19774	53	,	,	,
18637	19774	54	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	19774	55	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
18637	19774	56	interest	interest	NN
18637	19774	57	in	in	IN
18637	19774	58	rendering	render	VBG
18637	19774	59	a	a	DT
18637	19774	60	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	19774	61	against	against	IN
18637	19774	62	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19774	63	,	,	,
18637	19774	64	is	be	VBZ
18637	19774	65	violative	violative	JJ
18637	19774	66	of	of	IN
18637	19774	67	the	the	DT
18637	19774	68	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19774	69	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19774	70	.	.	.
18637	19775	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19775	2	957	957	CD
18637	19775	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19775	4	Compensating	compensate	VBG
18637	19775	5	an	an	DT
18637	19775	6	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	19775	7	judge	judge	NN
18637	19775	8	for	for	IN
18637	19775	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19775	10	services	service	NNS
18637	19775	11	only	only	RB
18637	19775	12	when	when	WRB
18637	19775	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19775	14	convicts	convict	VBZ
18637	19775	15	a	a	DT
18637	19775	16	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19775	17	may	may	MD
18637	19775	18	have	have	VB
18637	19775	19	been	be	VBN
18637	19775	20	a	a	DT
18637	19775	21	practice	practice	NN
18637	19775	22	of	of	IN
18637	19775	23	long	long	RB
18637	19775	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	19775	25	standing	stand	VBG
18637	19775	26	,	,	,
18637	19775	27	but	but	CC
18637	19775	28	such	such	PDT
18637	19775	29	a	a	DT
18637	19775	30	system	system	NN
18637	19775	31	of	of	IN
18637	19775	32	remuneration	remuneration	NN
18637	19775	33	,	,	,
18637	19775	34	the	the	DT
18637	19775	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19775	36	declared	declare	VBD
18637	19775	37	,	,	,
18637	19775	38	never	never	RB
18637	19775	39	became	become	VBD
18637	19775	40	"	"	``
18637	19775	41	so	so	RB
18637	19775	42	embedded	embed	VBN
18637	19775	43	by	by	IN
18637	19775	44	custom	custom	NN
18637	19775	45	in	in	IN
18637	19775	46	the	the	DT
18637	19775	47	general	general	JJ
18637	19775	48	practice	practice	NN
18637	19775	49	either	either	CC
18637	19775	50	at	at	IN
18637	19775	51	common	common	JJ
18637	19775	52	law	law	NN
18637	19775	53	or	or	CC
18637	19775	54	in	in	IN
18637	19775	55	this	this	DT
18637	19775	56	country	country	NN
18637	19775	57	that	that	WDT
18637	19775	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19775	59	can	can	MD
18637	19775	60	be	be	VB
18637	19775	61	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	19775	62	as	as	IN
18637	19775	63	due	due	JJ
18637	19775	64	process	process	NN
18637	19775	65	of	of	IN
18637	19775	66	law	law	NN
18637	19775	67	.	.	.
18637	19776	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19776	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19776	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19776	4	"	"	''
18637	19776	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19776	6	958	958	CD
18637	19776	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19776	8	However	however	RB
18637	19776	9	,	,	,
18637	19776	10	a	a	DT
18637	19776	11	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19776	12	before	before	IN
18637	19776	13	a	a	DT
18637	19776	14	mayor	mayor	NN
18637	19776	15	's	's	POS
18637	19776	16	court	court	NN
18637	19776	17	does	do	VBZ
18637	19776	18	not	not	RB
18637	19776	19	become	become	VB
18637	19776	20	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	19776	21	defective	defective	JJ
18637	19776	22	by	by	IN
18637	19776	23	reason	reason	NN
18637	19776	24	of	of	IN
18637	19776	25	the	the	DT
18637	19776	26	fact	fact	NN
18637	19776	27	that	that	IN
18637	19776	28	the	the	DT
18637	19776	29	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	19776	30	salary	salary	NN
18637	19776	31	of	of	IN
18637	19776	32	the	the	DT
18637	19776	33	mayor	mayor	NN
18637	19776	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	19776	35	paid	pay	VBN
18637	19776	36	out	out	IN
18637	19776	37	of	of	IN
18637	19776	38	the	the	DT
18637	19776	39	fund	fund	NN
18637	19776	40	to	to	TO
18637	19776	41	which	which	WDT
18637	19776	42	the	the	DT
18637	19776	43	fines	fine	NNS
18637	19776	44	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19776	45	by	by	IN
18637	19776	46	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19776	47	contribute	contribute	VBP
18637	19776	48	.	.	.
18637	19777	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19777	2	959	959	CD
18637	19777	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19777	4	Obviously	obviously	RB
18637	19777	5	,	,	,
18637	19777	6	the	the	DT
18637	19777	7	attribute	attribute	NN
18637	19777	8	of	of	IN
18637	19777	9	impartiality	impartiality	NN
18637	19777	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	19777	11	lacking	lack	VBG
18637	19777	12	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	19777	13	the	the	DT
18637	19777	14	judge	judge	NN
18637	19777	15	and	and	CC
18637	19777	16	jury	jury	NN
18637	19777	17	are	be	VBP
18637	19777	18	dominated	dominate	VBN
18637	19777	19	by	by	IN
18637	19777	20	a	a	DT
18637	19777	21	mob	mob	NN
18637	19777	22	.	.	.
18637	19778	1	"	"	``
18637	19778	2	If	if	IN
18637	19778	3	the	the	DT
18637	19778	4	jury	jury	NN
18637	19778	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19778	6	intimidated	intimidate	VBN
18637	19778	7	and	and	CC
18637	19778	8	the	the	DT
18637	19778	9	trial	trial	NN
18637	19778	10	judge	judge	NN
18637	19778	11	yields	yield	NNS
18637	19778	12	,	,	,
18637	19778	13	and	and	CC
18637	19778	14	so	so	IN
18637	19778	15	that	that	IN
18637	19778	16	there	there	EX
18637	19778	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	19778	18	an	an	DT
18637	19778	19	actual	actual	JJ
18637	19778	20	interference	interference	NN
18637	19778	21	with	with	IN
18637	19778	22	the	the	DT
18637	19778	23	course	course	NN
18637	19778	24	of	of	IN
18637	19778	25	justice	justice	NN
18637	19778	26	,	,	,
18637	19778	27	there	there	EX
18637	19778	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	19778	29	,	,	,
18637	19778	30	in	in	IN
18637	19778	31	that	that	DT
18637	19778	32	court	court	NN
18637	19778	33	,	,	,
18637	19778	34	a	a	DT
18637	19778	35	departure	departure	NN
18637	19778	36	from	from	IN
18637	19778	37	due	due	JJ
18637	19778	38	process	process	NN
18637	19778	39	of	of	IN
18637	19778	40	law	law	NN
18637	19778	41	.	.	.
18637	19779	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19779	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19779	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19779	4	"	"	''
18637	19779	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19779	6	960	960	CD
18637	19779	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19779	8	But	but	CC
18637	19779	9	"	"	``
18637	19779	10	if	if	IN
18637	19779	11	*	*	NFP
18637	19779	12	*	*	NFP
18637	19779	13	*	*	NFP
18637	19779	14	the	the	DT
18637	19779	15	whole	whole	JJ
18637	19779	16	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19779	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	19779	18	a	a	DT
18637	19779	19	mask--	mask--	JJ
18637	19779	20	*	*	NFP
18637	19779	21	*	*	NFP
18637	19779	22	*	*	NFP
18637	19779	23	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19779	24	if	if	IN
18637	19779	25	the	the	DT
18637	19779	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19779	27	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19779	28	,	,	,
18637	19779	29	jury	jury	NN
18637	19779	30	and	and	CC
18637	19779	31	judge	judge	NN
18637	19779	32	*	*	NFP
18637	19779	33	*	*	NFP
18637	19779	34	*	*	NFP
18637	19779	35	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19779	36	are	be	VBP
18637	19779	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19779	38	swept	sweep	VBN
18637	19779	39	to	to	IN
18637	19779	40	the	the	DT
18637	19779	41	fatal	fatal	JJ
18637	19779	42	end	end	NN
18637	19779	43	by	by	IN
18637	19779	44	an	an	DT
18637	19779	45	irresistible	irresistible	JJ
18637	19779	46	wave	wave	NN
18637	19779	47	of	of	IN
18637	19779	48	public	public	JJ
18637	19779	49	passion	passion	NN
18637	19779	50	,	,	,
18637	19779	51	and	and	CC
18637	19779	52	*	*	NFP
18637	19779	53	*	*	NFP
18637	19779	54	*	*	NFP
18637	19779	55	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19779	56	if	if	IN
18637	19779	57	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19779	58	the	the	DT
18637	19779	59	State	State	NNP
18637	19779	60	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	19779	61	failed	fail	VBD
18637	19779	62	to	to	TO
18637	19779	63	correct	correct	VB
18637	19779	64	the	the	DT
18637	19779	65	wrong	wrong	NN
18637	19779	66	,	,	,
18637	19779	67	neither	neither	DT
18637	19779	68	perfection	perfection	NN
18637	19779	69	in	in	IN
18637	19779	70	the	the	DT
18637	19779	71	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	19779	72	for	for	IN
18637	19779	73	correction	correction	NN
18637	19779	74	nor	nor	CC
18637	19779	75	the	the	DT
18637	19779	76	possibility	possibility	NN
18637	19779	77	that	that	IN
18637	19779	78	the	the	DT
18637	19779	79	trial	trial	NN
18637	19779	80	court	court	NN
18637	19779	81	and	and	CC
18637	19779	82	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19779	83	saw	see	VBD
18637	19779	84	no	no	DT
18637	19779	85	other	other	JJ
18637	19779	86	way	way	NN
18637	19779	87	of	of	IN
18637	19779	88	avoiding	avoid	VBG
18637	19779	89	an	an	DT
18637	19779	90	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	19779	91	outbreak	outbreak	NN
18637	19779	92	of	of	IN
18637	19779	93	the	the	DT
18637	19779	94	mob	mob	NN
18637	19779	95	can	can	MD
18637	19779	96	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	19779	97	"	"	''
18637	19779	98	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	19779	99	by	by	IN
18637	19779	100	the	the	DT
18637	19779	101	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19779	102	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19779	103	to	to	TO
18637	19779	104	secure	secure	VB
18637	19779	105	the	the	DT
18637	19779	106	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19779	107	rights	right	NNS
18637	19779	108	of	of	IN
18637	19779	109	the	the	DT
18637	19779	110	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19779	111	.	.	.
18637	19780	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19780	2	961	961	CD
18637	19780	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19780	4	Insofar	insofar	RB
18637	19780	5	as	as	IN
18637	19780	6	a	a	DT
18637	19780	7	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19780	8	trial	trial	NN
18637	19780	9	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	19780	10	with	with	IN
18637	19780	11	a	a	DT
18637	19780	12	jury	jury	NN
18637	19780	13	,	,	,
18637	19780	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19780	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	19780	16	part	part	NN
18637	19780	17	of	of	IN
18637	19780	18	the	the	DT
18637	19780	19	American	american	JJ
18637	19780	20	tradition	tradition	NN
18637	19780	21	to	to	TO
18637	19780	22	contemplate	contemplate	VB
18637	19780	23	not	not	RB
18637	19780	24	only	only	RB
18637	19780	25	an	an	DT
18637	19780	26	impartial	impartial	JJ
18637	19780	27	jury	jury	NN
18637	19780	28	but	but	CC
18637	19780	29	one	one	CD
18637	19780	30	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	19780	31	from	from	IN
18637	19780	32	a	a	DT
18637	19780	33	cross	cross	NN
18637	19780	34	-	-	NN
18637	19780	35	section	section	NN
18637	19780	36	of	of	IN
18637	19780	37	the	the	DT
18637	19780	38	community	community	NN
18637	19780	39	.	.	.
18637	19781	1	This	this	DT
18637	19781	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	19781	3	been	be	VBN
18637	19781	4	construed	construe	VBN
18637	19781	5	as	as	IN
18637	19781	6	requiring	require	VBG
18637	19781	7	that	that	IN
18637	19781	8	prospective	prospective	JJ
18637	19781	9	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	19781	10	be	be	VB
18637	19781	11	selected	select	VBN
18637	19781	12	by	by	IN
18637	19781	13	court	court	NN
18637	19781	14	officials	official	NNS
18637	19781	15	without	without	IN
18637	19781	16	systematic	systematic	JJ
18637	19781	17	and	and	CC
18637	19781	18	intentional	intentional	JJ
18637	19781	19	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	19781	20	of	of	IN
18637	19781	21	any	any	DT
18637	19781	22	group	group	NN
18637	19781	23	,	,	,
18637	19781	24	even	even	RB
18637	19781	25	though	though	IN
18637	19781	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19781	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	19781	28	not	not	RB
18637	19781	29	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	19781	30	that	that	IN
18637	19781	31	every	every	DT
18637	19781	32	jury	jury	NN
18637	19781	33	contain	contain	VB
18637	19781	34	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	19781	35	of	of	IN
18637	19781	36	all	all	PDT
18637	19781	37	the	the	DT
18637	19781	38	economic	economic	JJ
18637	19781	39	,	,	,
18637	19781	40	social	social	JJ
18637	19781	41	,	,	,
18637	19781	42	religious	religious	JJ
18637	19781	43	,	,	,
18637	19781	44	racial	racial	JJ
18637	19781	45	,	,	,
18637	19781	46	political	political	JJ
18637	19781	47	,	,	,
18637	19781	48	and	and	CC
18637	19781	49	geographical	geographical	JJ
18637	19781	50	groups	group	NNS
18637	19781	51	of	of	IN
18637	19781	52	the	the	DT
18637	19781	53	community	community	NN
18637	19781	54	.	.	.
18637	19782	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19782	2	962	962	CD
18637	19782	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19782	4	Other	other	JJ
18637	19782	5	Attributes	Attributes	NNPS
18637	19782	6	of	of	IN
18637	19782	7	a	a	DT
18637	19782	8	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	19782	9	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	19782	10	"	"	''
18637	19782	11	Due	due	JJ
18637	19782	12	process	process	NN
18637	19782	13	of	of	IN
18637	19782	14	law	law	NN
18637	19782	15	,	,	,
18637	19782	16	"	"	''
18637	19782	17	the	the	DT
18637	19782	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19782	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19782	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	19782	21	observed	observe	VBN
18637	19782	22	,	,	,
18637	19782	23	"	"	''
18637	19782	24	requires	require	VBZ
18637	19782	25	that	that	IN
18637	19782	26	the	the	DT
18637	19782	27	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19782	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	19782	29	be	be	VB
18637	19782	30	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19782	31	,	,	,
18637	19782	32	but	but	CC
18637	19782	33	fairness	fairness	NN
18637	19782	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	19782	35	a	a	DT
18637	19782	36	relative	relative	JJ
18637	19782	37	,	,	,
18637	19782	38	not	not	RB
18637	19782	39	an	an	DT
18637	19782	40	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	19782	41	concept	concept	NN
18637	19782	42	.	.	.
18637	19783	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19783	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19783	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19783	4	What	what	WP
18637	19783	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19783	6	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19783	7	in	in	IN
18637	19783	8	one	one	CD
18637	19783	9	set	set	NN
18637	19783	10	of	of	IN
18637	19783	11	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19783	12	may	may	MD
18637	19783	13	be	be	VB
18637	19783	14	an	an	DT
18637	19783	15	act	act	NN
18637	19783	16	of	of	IN
18637	19783	17	tyranny	tyranny	NN
18637	19783	18	in	in	IN
18637	19783	19	others	other	NNS
18637	19783	20	.	.	.
18637	19784	1	"	"	``
18637	19784	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19784	3	963	963	CD
18637	19784	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19784	5	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	19784	6	,	,	,
18637	19784	7	"	"	''
18637	19784	8	as	as	IN
18637	19784	9	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19784	10	to	to	IN
18637	19784	11	a	a	DT
18637	19784	12	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19784	13	trial	trial	NN
18637	19784	14	,	,	,
18637	19784	15	denial	denial	NN
18637	19784	16	of	of	IN
18637	19784	17	due	due	JJ
18637	19784	18	process	process	NN
18637	19784	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	19784	20	the	the	DT
18637	19784	21	failure	failure	NN
18637	19784	22	to	to	TO
18637	19784	23	observe	observe	VB
18637	19784	24	that	that	IN
18637	19784	25	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19784	26	fairness	fairness	NN
18637	19784	27	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19784	28	to	to	IN
18637	19784	29	the	the	DT
18637	19784	30	very	very	JJ
18637	19784	31	concept	concept	NN
18637	19784	32	of	of	IN
18637	19784	33	justice	justice	NN
18637	19784	34	.	.	.
18637	19785	1	In	in	IN
18637	19785	2	order	order	NN
18637	19785	3	to	to	TO
18637	19785	4	declare	declare	VB
18637	19785	5	a	a	DT
18637	19785	6	denial	denial	NN
18637	19785	7	of	of	IN
18637	19785	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19785	9	*	*	NFP
18637	19785	10	*	*	NFP
18637	19785	11	*	*	NFP
18637	19785	12	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19785	13	the	the	DT
18637	19785	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19785	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19785	16	must	must	MD
18637	19785	17	find	find	VB
18637	19785	18	that	that	IN
18637	19785	19	the	the	DT
18637	19785	20	absence	absence	NN
18637	19785	21	of	of	IN
18637	19785	22	that	that	DT
18637	19785	23	fairness	fairness	NN
18637	19785	24	fatally	fatally	RB
18637	19785	25	infected	infect	VBD
18637	19785	26	the	the	DT
18637	19785	27	trial	trial	NN
18637	19785	28	;	;	:
18637	19785	29	the	the	DT
18637	19785	30	acts	act	NNS
18637	19785	31	complained	complain	VBD
18637	19785	32	of	of	IN
18637	19785	33	must	must	MD
18637	19785	34	be	be	VB
18637	19785	35	of	of	IN
18637	19785	36	such	such	JJ
18637	19785	37	quality	quality	NN
18637	19785	38	as	as	IN
18637	19785	39	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	19785	40	prevents	prevent	VBZ
18637	19785	41	a	a	DT
18637	19785	42	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19785	43	trial	trial	NN
18637	19785	44	.	.	.
18637	19786	1	"	"	``
18637	19786	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19786	3	964	964	CD
18637	19786	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19786	5	And	and	CC
18637	19786	6	on	on	IN
18637	19786	7	another	another	DT
18637	19786	8	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	19786	9	the	the	DT
18637	19786	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19786	11	remarked	remark	VBD
18637	19786	12	that	that	IN
18637	19786	13	"	"	``
18637	19786	14	the	the	DT
18637	19786	15	due	due	JJ
18637	19786	16	process	process	NN
18637	19786	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	19786	18	,	,	,
18637	19786	19	"	"	''
18637	19786	20	as	as	IN
18637	19786	21	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19786	22	in	in	IN
18637	19786	23	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19786	24	trials	trial	NNS
18637	19786	25	"	"	''
18637	19786	26	requires	require	VBZ
18637	19786	27	that	that	IN
18637	19786	28	action	action	NN
18637	19786	29	by	by	IN
18637	19786	30	a	a	DT
18637	19786	31	State	State	NNP
18637	19786	32	through	through	IN
18637	19786	33	any	any	DT
18637	19786	34	of	of	IN
18637	19786	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19786	36	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	19786	37	must	must	MD
18637	19786	38	be	be	VB
18637	19786	39	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	19786	40	with	with	IN
18637	19786	41	the	the	DT
18637	19786	42	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19786	43	principles	principle	NNS
18637	19786	44	of	of	IN
18637	19786	45	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19786	46	and	and	CC
18637	19786	47	justice	justice	NN
18637	19786	48	which	which	WDT
18637	19786	49	lie	lie	VBP
18637	19786	50	at	at	IN
18637	19786	51	the	the	DT
18637	19786	52	base	base	NN
18637	19786	53	of	of	IN
18637	19786	54	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19786	55	civil	civil	JJ
18637	19786	56	and	and	CC
18637	19786	57	political	political	JJ
18637	19786	58	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	19786	59	,	,	,
18637	19786	60	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19786	61	and	and	CC
18637	19786	62	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19786	63	which	which	WDT
18637	19786	64	not	not	RB
18637	19786	65	infrequently	infrequently	RB
18637	19786	66	are	be	VBP
18637	19786	67	designated	designate	VBN
18637	19786	68	as	as	IN
18637	19786	69	'	'	``
18637	19786	70	the	the	DT
18637	19786	71	law	law	NN
18637	19786	72	of	of	IN
18637	19786	73	the	the	DT
18637	19786	74	land	land	NN
18637	19786	75	.	.	.
18637	19787	1	'	'	``
18637	19787	2	"	"	``
18637	19787	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19787	4	965	965	CD
18637	19787	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19787	6	Basic	basic	JJ
18637	19787	7	to	to	IN
18637	19787	8	the	the	DT
18637	19787	9	very	very	JJ
18637	19787	10	idea	idea	NN
18637	19787	11	of	of	IN
18637	19787	12	free	free	JJ
18637	19787	13	government	government	NN
18637	19787	14	and	and	CC
18637	19787	15	among	among	IN
18637	19787	16	the	the	DT
18637	19787	17	immutable	immutable	JJ
18637	19787	18	principles	principle	NNS
18637	19787	19	of	of	IN
18637	19787	20	justice	justice	NN
18637	19787	21	which	which	WDT
18637	19787	22	no	no	DT
18637	19787	23	State	State	NNP
18637	19787	24	of	of	IN
18637	19787	25	the	the	DT
18637	19787	26	Union	Union	NNP
18637	19787	27	may	may	MD
18637	19787	28	disregard	disregard	VB
18637	19787	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	19787	30	the	the	DT
18637	19787	31	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19787	32	of	of	IN
18637	19787	33	due	due	JJ
18637	19787	34	"	"	''
18637	19787	35	notice	notice	NN
18637	19787	36	of	of	IN
18637	19787	37	the	the	DT
18637	19787	38	charge	charge	NN
18637	19787	39	and	and	CC
18637	19787	40	an	an	DT
18637	19787	41	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19787	42	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19787	43	to	to	TO
18637	19787	44	be	be	VB
18637	19787	45	heard	hear	VBN
18637	19787	46	in	in	IN
18637	19787	47	defense	defense	NN
18637	19787	48	of	of	IN
18637	19787	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19787	50	.	.	.
18637	19788	1	"	"	``
18637	19788	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19788	3	966	966	CD
18637	19788	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19788	5	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	19788	6	,	,	,
18637	19788	7	when	when	WRB
18637	19788	8	a	a	DT
18637	19788	9	State	state	NN
18637	19788	10	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19788	11	court	court	NN
18637	19788	12	affirms	affirm	VBZ
18637	19788	13	a	a	DT
18637	19788	14	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19788	15	on	on	IN
18637	19788	16	the	the	DT
18637	19788	17	ground	ground	NN
18637	19788	18	that	that	IN
18637	19788	19	the	the	DT
18637	19788	20	information	information	NN
18637	19788	21	charged	charge	VBD
18637	19788	22	,	,	,
18637	19788	23	and	and	CC
18637	19788	24	the	the	DT
18637	19788	25	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19788	26	showed	show	VBD
18637	19788	27	a	a	DT
18637	19788	28	violation	violation	NN
18637	19788	29	of	of	IN
18637	19788	30	Sec	Sec	NNP
18637	19788	31	.	.	.
18637	19789	1	1	1	CD
18637	19789	2	of	of	IN
18637	19789	3	a	a	DT
18637	19789	4	penal	penal	JJ
18637	19789	5	law	law	NN
18637	19789	6	of	of	IN
18637	19789	7	the	the	DT
18637	19789	8	State	State	NNP
18637	19789	9	,	,	,
18637	19789	10	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19789	11	that	that	IN
18637	19789	12	the	the	DT
18637	19789	13	language	language	NN
18637	19789	14	of	of	IN
18637	19789	15	the	the	DT
18637	19789	16	information	information	NN
18637	19789	17	and	and	CC
18637	19789	18	the	the	DT
18637	19789	19	construction	construction	NN
18637	19789	20	placed	place	VBN
18637	19789	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	19789	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19789	23	at	at	IN
18637	19789	24	the	the	DT
18637	19789	25	trial	trial	NN
18637	19789	26	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	19789	27	show	show	VBP
18637	19789	28	that	that	IN
18637	19789	29	an	an	DT
18637	19789	30	offense	offense	NN
18637	19789	31	under	under	IN
18637	19789	32	Sec	Sec	NNP
18637	19789	33	.	.	.
18637	19790	1	2	2	CD
18637	19790	2	of	of	IN
18637	19790	3	such	such	JJ
18637	19790	4	law	law	NN
18637	19790	5	was	be	VBD
18637	19790	6	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19790	7	,	,	,
18637	19790	8	that	that	IN
18637	19790	9	the	the	DT
18637	19790	10	trial	trial	NN
18637	19790	11	judge	judge	NN
18637	19790	12	's	's	POS
18637	19790	13	instructions	instruction	NNS
18637	19790	14	to	to	IN
18637	19790	15	the	the	DT
18637	19790	16	jury	jury	NN
18637	19790	17	were	be	VBD
18637	19790	18	based	base	VBN
18637	19790	19	on	on	IN
18637	19790	20	Sec	Sec	NNP
18637	19790	21	.	.	.
18637	19791	1	2	2	CD
18637	19791	2	,	,	,
18637	19791	3	and	and	CC
18637	19791	4	that	that	IN
18637	19791	5	on	on	IN
18637	19791	6	the	the	DT
18637	19791	7	whole	whole	JJ
18637	19791	8	case	case	NN
18637	19791	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19791	10	was	be	VBD
18637	19791	11	clear	clear	JJ
18637	19791	12	that	that	IN
18637	19791	13	the	the	DT
18637	19791	14	trial	trial	NN
18637	19791	15	and	and	CC
18637	19791	16	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19791	17	in	in	IN
18637	19791	18	the	the	DT
18637	19791	19	lower	low	JJR
18637	19791	20	court	court	NN
18637	19791	21	were	be	VBD
18637	19791	22	for	for	IN
18637	19791	23	the	the	DT
18637	19791	24	violation	violation	NN
18637	19791	25	of	of	IN
18637	19791	26	Sec	Sec	NNP
18637	19791	27	.	.	.
18637	19792	1	2	2	LS
18637	19792	2	,	,	,
18637	19792	3	not	not	RB
18637	19792	4	Sec	Sec	NNP
18637	19792	5	.	.	.
18637	19793	1	1	1	CD
18637	19793	2	,	,	,
18637	19793	3	such	such	JJ
18637	19793	4	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19793	5	court	court	NN
18637	19793	6	in	in	IN
18637	19793	7	effect	effect	NN
18637	19793	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	19793	9	convicting	convict	VBG
18637	19793	10	the	the	DT
18637	19793	11	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19793	12	of	of	IN
18637	19793	13	a	a	DT
18637	19793	14	charge	charge	NN
18637	19793	15	on	on	IN
18637	19793	16	which	which	WDT
18637	19793	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19793	18	was	be	VBD
18637	19793	19	never	never	RB
18637	19793	20	tried	try	VBN
18637	19793	21	,	,	,
18637	19793	22	which	which	WDT
18637	19793	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	19793	24	as	as	RB
18637	19793	25	much	much	JJ
18637	19793	26	a	a	DT
18637	19793	27	violation	violation	NN
18637	19793	28	of	of	IN
18637	19793	29	due	due	JJ
18637	19793	30	process	process	NN
18637	19793	31	as	as	IN
18637	19793	32	a	a	DT
18637	19793	33	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19793	34	upon	upon	IN
18637	19793	35	a	a	DT
18637	19793	36	charge	charge	NN
18637	19793	37	that	that	WDT
18637	19793	38	was	be	VBD
18637	19793	39	never	never	RB
18637	19793	40	made	make	VBN
18637	19793	41	.	.	.
18637	19794	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19794	2	967	967	CD
18637	19794	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19794	4	On	on	IN
18637	19794	5	the	the	DT
18637	19794	6	other	other	JJ
18637	19794	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	19794	8	,	,	,
18637	19794	9	a	a	DT
18637	19794	10	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	19794	11	who	who	WP
18637	19794	12	,	,	,
18637	19794	13	after	after	IN
18637	19794	14	having	have	VBG
18637	19794	15	been	be	VBN
18637	19794	16	indicted	indict	VBN
18637	19794	17	on	on	IN
18637	19794	18	a	a	DT
18637	19794	19	charge	charge	NN
18637	19794	20	of	of	IN
18637	19794	21	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	19794	22	stolen	steal	VBN
18637	19794	23	goods	good	NNS
18637	19794	24	,	,	,
18637	19794	25	abides	abide	NNS
18637	19794	26	by	by	IN
18637	19794	27	the	the	DT
18637	19794	28	prosecutor	prosecutor	NN
18637	19794	29	's	's	POS
18637	19794	30	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	19794	31	and	and	CC
18637	19794	32	pleads	plead	VBZ
18637	19794	33	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19794	34	to	to	IN
18637	19794	35	the	the	DT
18637	19794	36	lesser	less	JJR
18637	19794	37	offense	offense	NN
18637	19794	38	of	of	IN
18637	19794	39	attempted	attempt	VBN
18637	19794	40	second	second	JJ
18637	19794	41	degree	degree	NN
18637	19794	42	grand	grand	NNP
18637	19794	43	larceny	larceny	NNP
18637	19794	44	,	,	,
18637	19794	45	can	can	MD
18637	19794	46	not	not	RB
18637	19794	47	later	later	RB
18637	19794	48	contend	contend	VB
18637	19794	49	that	that	IN
18637	19794	50	a	a	DT
18637	19794	51	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19794	52	of	of	IN
18637	19794	53	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	19794	54	of	of	IN
18637	19794	55	the	the	DT
18637	19794	56	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19794	57	offense	offense	NN
18637	19794	58	was	be	VBD
18637	19794	59	lacking	lack	VBG
18637	19794	60	in	in	IN
18637	19794	61	due	due	JJ
18637	19794	62	process	process	NN
18637	19794	63	in	in	IN
18637	19794	64	that	that	IN
18637	19794	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19794	66	amounted	amount	VBD
18637	19794	67	to	to	IN
18637	19794	68	a	a	DT
18637	19794	69	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19794	70	of	of	IN
18637	19794	71	a	a	DT
18637	19794	72	crime	crime	NN
18637	19794	73	for	for	IN
18637	19794	74	which	which	WDT
18637	19794	75	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19794	76	had	have	VBD
18637	19794	77	never	never	RB
18637	19794	78	been	be	VBN
18637	19794	79	indicted	indict	VBN
18637	19794	80	.	.	.
18637	19795	1	In	in	IN
18637	19795	2	view	view	NN
18637	19795	3	of	of	IN
18637	19795	4	the	the	DT
18637	19795	5	"	"	``
18637	19795	6	close	close	JJ
18637	19795	7	kinship	kinship	NN
18637	19795	8	between	between	IN
18637	19795	9	the	the	DT
18637	19795	10	offense	offense	NN
18637	19795	11	of	of	IN
18637	19795	12	larceny	larceny	NN
18637	19795	13	and	and	CC
18637	19795	14	that	that	IN
18637	19795	15	of	of	IN
18637	19795	16	receiving	receive	VBG
18637	19795	17	stolen	steal	VBN
18637	19795	18	property	property	NN
18637	19795	19	*	*	NFP
18637	19795	20	*	*	NFP
18637	19795	21	*	*	NFP
18637	19795	22	,	,	,
18637	19795	23	when	when	WRB
18637	19795	24	related	relate	VBN
18637	19795	25	to	to	IN
18637	19795	26	the	the	DT
18637	19795	27	same	same	JJ
18637	19795	28	stolen	steal	VBN
18637	19795	29	goods	good	NNS
18637	19795	30	,	,	,
18637	19795	31	the	the	DT
18637	19795	32	two	two	CD
18637	19795	33	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	19795	34	may	may	MD
18637	19795	35	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	19795	36	be	be	VB
18637	19795	37	said	say	VBN
18637	19795	38	'	'	''
18637	19795	39	to	to	TO
18637	19795	40	be	be	VB
18637	19795	41	connected	connect	VBN
18637	19795	42	with	with	IN
18637	19795	43	the	the	DT
18637	19795	44	same	same	JJ
18637	19795	45	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	19795	46	.	.	.
18637	19795	47	'	'	''
18637	19795	48	"	"	''
18637	19796	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19796	2	would	would	MD
18637	19796	3	be	be	VB
18637	19796	4	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	19796	5	,	,	,
18637	19796	6	the	the	DT
18637	19796	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19796	8	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	19796	9	,	,	,
18637	19796	10	"	"	''
18637	19796	11	an	an	DT
18637	19796	12	exaltation	exaltation	NN
18637	19796	13	of	of	IN
18637	19796	14	technical	technical	JJ
18637	19796	15	precision	precision	NN
18637	19796	16	to	to	IN
18637	19796	17	an	an	DT
18637	19796	18	unwarranted	unwarranted	JJ
18637	19796	19	degree	degree	NN
18637	19796	20	to	to	TO
18637	19796	21	say	say	VB
18637	19796	22	that	that	IN
18637	19796	23	the	the	DT
18637	19796	24	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	19796	25	here	here	RB
18637	19796	26	did	do	VBD
18637	19796	27	not	not	RB
18637	19796	28	inform	inform	VB
18637	19796	29	the	the	DT
18637	19796	30	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	19796	31	that	that	IN
18637	19796	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19796	33	was	be	VBD
18637	19796	34	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19796	35	with	with	IN
18637	19796	36	the	the	DT
18637	19796	37	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	19796	38	elements	element	NNS
18637	19796	39	of	of	IN
18637	19796	40	the	the	DT
18637	19796	41	crime	crime	NN
18637	19796	42	of	of	IN
18637	19796	43	larceny	larceny	NN
18637	19796	44	.	.	.
18637	19796	45	"	"	''
18637	19797	1	Under	under	IN
18637	19797	2	these	these	DT
18637	19797	3	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19797	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19797	5	must	must	MD
18637	19797	6	be	be	VB
18637	19797	7	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19797	8	to	to	TO
18637	19797	9	have	have	VB
18637	19797	10	been	be	VBN
18637	19797	11	given	give	VBN
18637	19797	12	"	"	``
18637	19797	13	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19797	14	notice	notice	NN
18637	19797	15	and	and	CC
18637	19797	16	information	information	NN
18637	19797	17	of	of	IN
18637	19797	18	the	the	DT
18637	19797	19	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19797	20	charge	charge	NN
18637	19797	21	against	against	IN
18637	19797	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19797	23	and	and	CC
18637	19797	24	a	a	DT
18637	19797	25	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19797	26	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	19797	27	in	in	IN
18637	19797	28	open	open	JJ
18637	19797	29	court	court	NN
18637	19797	30	.	.	.
18637	19798	1	"	"	``
18637	19798	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19798	3	968	968	CD
18637	19798	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19798	5	Excessive	Excessive	NNP
18637	19798	6	Bail	Bail	NNP
18637	19798	7	,	,	,
18637	19798	8	Cruel	Cruel	NNP
18637	19798	9	and	and	CC
18637	19798	10	Unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	19798	11	Punishment	Punishment	NNP
18637	19798	12	,	,	,
18637	19798	13	Sentence	Sentence	NNP
18637	19798	14	The	the	DT
18637	19798	15	commitment	commitment	NN
18637	19798	16	to	to	IN
18637	19798	17	prison	prison	NN
18637	19798	18	of	of	IN
18637	19798	19	a	a	DT
18637	19798	20	person	person	NN
18637	19798	21	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	19798	22	of	of	IN
18637	19798	23	crime	crime	NN
18637	19798	24	,	,	,
18637	19798	25	without	without	IN
18637	19798	26	giving	give	VBG
18637	19798	27	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19798	28	an	an	DT
18637	19798	29	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19798	30	pending	pende	VBG
18637	19798	31	an	an	DT
18637	19798	32	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	19798	33	,	,	,
18637	19798	34	to	to	TO
18637	19798	35	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	19798	36	bail	bail	NN
18637	19798	37	,	,	,
18637	19798	38	does	do	VBZ
18637	19798	39	not	not	RB
18637	19798	40	violate	violate	VB
18637	19798	41	the	the	DT
18637	19798	42	due	due	JJ
18637	19798	43	process	process	NN
18637	19798	44	clause	clause	NN
18637	19798	45	of	of	IN
18637	19798	46	the	the	DT
18637	19798	47	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19798	48	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19798	49	.	.	.
18637	19799	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19799	2	969	969	CD
18637	19799	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19799	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19799	5	,	,	,
18637	19799	6	a	a	DT
18637	19799	7	State	state	NN
18637	19799	8	,	,	,
18637	19799	9	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19799	10	the	the	DT
18637	19799	11	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	19799	12	of	of	IN
18637	19799	13	that	that	DT
18637	19799	14	clause	clause	NN
18637	19799	15	,	,	,
18637	19799	16	retains	retain	VBZ
18637	19799	17	a	a	DT
18637	19799	18	wide	wide	JJ
18637	19799	19	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	19799	20	in	in	IN
18637	19799	21	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	19799	22	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	19799	23	for	for	IN
18637	19799	24	violation	violation	NN
18637	19799	25	of	of	IN
18637	19799	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19799	27	laws	law	NNS
18637	19799	28	.	.	.
18637	19800	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19800	2	,	,	,
18637	19800	3	a	a	DT
18637	19800	4	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19800	5	of	of	IN
18637	19800	6	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	19800	7	years	year	NNS
18637	19800	8	'	'	POS
18637	19800	9	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	19800	10	for	for	IN
18637	19800	11	the	the	DT
18637	19800	12	crime	crime	NN
18637	19800	13	of	of	IN
18637	19800	14	perjury	perjury	NN
18637	19800	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	19800	16	not	not	RB
18637	19800	17	been	be	VBN
18637	19800	18	viewed	view	VBN
18637	19800	19	as	as	IN
18637	19800	20	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	19800	21	nor	nor	CC
18637	19800	22	as	as	IN
18637	19800	23	effecting	effect	VBG
18637	19800	24	any	any	DT
18637	19800	25	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19800	26	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19800	27	of	of	IN
18637	19800	28	the	the	DT
18637	19800	29	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19800	30	's	's	POS
18637	19800	31	liberty;[970	liberty;[970	RBS
18637	19800	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19800	33	nor	nor	CC
18637	19800	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	19800	35	the	the	DT
18637	19800	36	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	19800	37	of	of	IN
18637	19800	38	successively	successively	RB
18637	19800	39	heavier	heavy	JJR
18637	19800	40	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	19800	41	upon	upon	IN
18637	19800	42	"	"	``
18637	19800	43	repeaters	repeater	NNS
18637	19800	44	"	"	''
18637	19800	45	been	be	VBN
18637	19800	46	considered	consider	VBN
18637	19800	47	as	as	IN
18637	19800	48	partaking	partaking	NN
18637	19800	49	of	of	IN
18637	19800	50	a	a	DT
18637	19800	51	"	"	``
18637	19800	52	cruel	cruel	JJ
18637	19800	53	and	and	CC
18637	19800	54	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	19800	55	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	19800	56	.	.	.
18637	19801	1	"	"	``
18637	19801	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19801	3	971	971	CD
18637	19801	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19801	5	In	in	IN
18637	19801	6	an	an	DT
18637	19801	7	older	old	JJR
18637	19801	8	decision	decision	NN
18637	19801	9	,	,	,
18637	19801	10	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	19801	11	parte	parte	VBZ
18637	19801	12	Kemmler,[972	kemmler,[972	NN
18637	19801	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19801	14	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19801	15	in	in	IN
18637	19801	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	19801	17	,	,	,
18637	19801	18	the	the	DT
18637	19801	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19801	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19801	21	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	19801	22	the	the	DT
18637	19801	23	suggestion	suggestion	NN
18637	19801	24	that	that	IN
18637	19801	25	the	the	DT
18637	19801	26	substance	substance	NN
18637	19801	27	of	of	IN
18637	19801	28	the	the	DT
18637	19801	29	Eighth	Eighth	NNP
18637	19801	30	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19801	31	had	have	VBD
18637	19801	32	been	be	VBN
18637	19801	33	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
18637	19801	34	into	into	IN
18637	19801	35	the	the	DT
18637	19801	36	due	due	JJ
18637	19801	37	process	process	NN
18637	19801	38	clause	clause	NN
18637	19801	39	of	of	IN
18637	19801	40	the	the	DT
18637	19801	41	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19801	42	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19801	43	,	,	,
18637	19801	44	but	but	CC
18637	19801	45	did	do	VBD
18637	19801	46	intimate	intimate	JJ
18637	19801	47	that	that	IN
18637	19801	48	the	the	DT
18637	19801	49	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19801	50	clause	clause	NN
18637	19801	51	would	would	MD
18637	19801	52	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	19801	53	punishments	punishment	NNS
18637	19801	54	which	which	WDT
18637	19801	55	would	would	MD
18637	19801	56	involve	involve	VB
18637	19801	57	"	"	``
18637	19801	58	torture	torture	NN
18637	19801	59	or	or	CC
18637	19801	60	a	a	DT
18637	19801	61	lingering	linger	VBG
18637	19801	62	death	death	NN
18637	19801	63	,	,	,
18637	19801	64	"	"	''
18637	19801	65	such	such	JJ
18637	19801	66	"	"	''
18637	19801	67	as	as	IN
18637	19801	68	burning	burn	VBG
18637	19801	69	at	at	IN
18637	19801	70	the	the	DT
18637	19801	71	stake	stake	NN
18637	19801	72	,	,	,
18637	19801	73	crucifixion	crucifixion	NN
18637	19801	74	,	,	,
18637	19801	75	breaking	break	VBG
18637	19801	76	on	on	IN
18637	19801	77	the	the	DT
18637	19801	78	wheel	wheel	NN
18637	19801	79	,	,	,
18637	19801	80	and	and	CC
18637	19801	81	the	the	DT
18637	19801	82	like	like	JJ
18637	19801	83	.	.	.
18637	19801	84	"	"	''
18637	19802	1	Holding	hold	VBG
18637	19802	2	that	that	IN
18637	19802	3	the	the	DT
18637	19802	4	infliction	infliction	NN
18637	19802	5	of	of	IN
18637	19802	6	the	the	DT
18637	19802	7	death	death	NN
18637	19802	8	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	19802	9	by	by	IN
18637	19802	10	electrocution	electrocution	NN
18637	19802	11	was	be	VBD
18637	19802	12	comparable	comparable	JJ
18637	19802	13	to	to	IN
18637	19802	14	none	none	NN
18637	19802	15	of	of	IN
18637	19802	16	the	the	DT
18637	19802	17	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19802	18	,	,	,
18637	19802	19	the	the	DT
18637	19802	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19802	21	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	19802	22	to	to	TO
18637	19802	23	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	19802	24	with	with	IN
18637	19802	25	the	the	DT
18637	19802	26	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19802	27	of	of	IN
18637	19802	28	the	the	DT
18637	19802	29	State	State	NNP
18637	19802	30	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	19802	31	that	that	IN
18637	19802	32	such	such	PDT
18637	19802	33	a	a	DT
18637	19802	34	method	method	NN
18637	19802	35	of	of	IN
18637	19802	36	executing	execute	VBG
18637	19802	37	the	the	DT
18637	19802	38	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19802	39	of	of	IN
18637	19802	40	a	a	DT
18637	19802	41	court	court	NN
18637	19802	42	was	be	VBD
18637	19802	43	humane	humane	JJ
18637	19802	44	.	.	.
18637	19803	1	More	more	RBR
18637	19803	2	recently	recently	RB
18637	19803	3	,	,	,
18637	19803	4	in	in	IN
18637	19803	5	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	19803	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	19803	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	19803	8	.	.	.
18637	19804	1	Francis	Francis	NNP
18637	19804	2	_	_	NNP
18637	19804	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	19804	4	_	_	NNP
18637	19804	5	Resweber,[973	Resweber,[973	NNP
18637	19804	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19804	7	five	five	CD
18637	19804	8	members	member	NNS
18637	19804	9	of	of	IN
18637	19804	10	the	the	DT
18637	19804	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19804	12	reached	reach	VBD
18637	19804	13	a	a	DT
18637	19804	14	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19804	15	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	19804	16	as	as	IN
18637	19804	17	to	to	IN
18637	19804	18	the	the	DT
18637	19804	19	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	19804	20	effect	effect	NN
18637	19804	21	of	of	IN
18637	19804	22	the	the	DT
18637	19804	23	due	due	JJ
18637	19804	24	process	process	NN
18637	19804	25	clause	clause	NN
18637	19804	26	of	of	IN
18637	19804	27	the	the	DT
18637	19804	28	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19804	29	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19804	30	when	when	WRB
18637	19804	31	,	,	,
18637	19804	32	assuming	assume	VBG
18637	19804	33	,	,	,
18637	19804	34	"	"	``
18637	19804	35	but	but	CC
18637	19804	36	without	without	IN
18637	19804	37	so	so	RB
18637	19804	38	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	19804	39	"	"	``
18637	19804	40	that	that	IN
18637	19804	41	violations	violation	NNS
18637	19804	42	of	of	IN
18637	19804	43	the	the	DT
18637	19804	44	Eighth	Eighth	NNP
18637	19804	45	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19804	46	as	as	IN
18637	19804	47	to	to	IN
18637	19804	48	cruel	cruel	JJ
18637	19804	49	and	and	CC
18637	19804	50	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	19804	51	punishments	punishment	NNS
18637	19804	52	would	would	MD
18637	19804	53	also	also	RB
18637	19804	54	be	be	VB
18637	19804	55	violative	violative	JJ
18637	19804	56	of	of	IN
18637	19804	57	that	that	DT
18637	19804	58	clause	clause	NN
18637	19804	59	,	,	,
18637	19804	60	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19804	61	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	19804	62	a	a	DT
18637	19804	63	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	19804	64	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	19804	65	to	to	TO
18637	19804	66	execute	execute	VB
18637	19804	67	a	a	DT
18637	19804	68	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19804	69	of	of	IN
18637	19804	70	death	death	NN
18637	19804	71	by	by	IN
18637	19804	72	electrocution	electrocution	NN
18637	19804	73	after	after	IN
18637	19804	74	an	an	DT
18637	19804	75	accidental	accidental	JJ
18637	19804	76	failure	failure	NN
18637	19804	77	of	of	IN
18637	19804	78	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	19804	79	had	have	VBD
18637	19804	80	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19804	81	an	an	DT
18637	19804	82	initial	initial	JJ
18637	19804	83	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	19804	84	unsuccessful	unsuccessful	JJ
18637	19804	85	.	.	.
18637	19805	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19805	2	974	974	CD
18637	19805	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19805	4	Double	double	JJ
18637	19805	5	Jeopardy	Jeopardy	NNP
18637	19805	6	In	in	IN
18637	19805	7	none	none	NN
18637	19805	8	of	of	IN
18637	19805	9	the	the	DT
18637	19805	10	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	19805	11	cases	case	NNS
18637	19805	12	considered	consider	VBN
18637	19805	13	prior	prior	RB
18637	19805	14	to	to	IN
18637	19805	15	1937	1937	CD
18637	19805	16	was	be	VBD
18637	19805	17	the	the	DT
18637	19805	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19805	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19805	20	able	able	JJ
18637	19805	21	to	to	TO
18637	19805	22	discern	discern	VB
18637	19805	23	the	the	DT
18637	19805	24	existence	existence	NN
18637	19805	25	of	of	IN
18637	19805	26	any	any	DT
18637	19805	27	factual	factual	JJ
18637	19805	28	situation	situation	NN
18637	19805	29	amounting	amount	VBG
18637	19805	30	to	to	TO
18637	19805	31	double	double	JJ
18637	19805	32	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	19805	33	,	,	,
18637	19805	34	and	and	CC
18637	19805	35	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19805	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19805	37	was	be	VBD
18637	19805	38	never	never	RB
18637	19805	39	confronted	confront	VBN
18637	19805	40	with	with	IN
18637	19805	41	the	the	DT
18637	19805	42	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19805	43	of	of	IN
18637	19805	44	determining	determine	VBG
18637	19805	45	whether	whether	IN
18637	19805	46	the	the	DT
18637	19805	47	guarantee	guarantee	NN
18637	19805	48	that	that	IN
18637	19805	49	no	no	DT
18637	19805	50	person	person	NN
18637	19805	51	be	be	VB
18637	19805	52	put	put	VBN
18637	19805	53	twice	twice	RB
18637	19805	54	in	in	IN
18637	19805	55	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	19805	56	of	of	IN
18637	19805	57	life	life	NN
18637	19805	58	or	or	CC
18637	19805	59	limb	limb	NN
18637	19805	60	,	,	,
18637	19805	61	expressed	express	VBN
18637	19805	62	in	in	IN
18637	19805	63	the	the	DT
18637	19805	64	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	19805	65	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19805	66	as	as	IN
18637	19805	67	a	a	DT
18637	19805	68	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	19805	69	against	against	IN
18637	19805	70	the	the	DT
18637	19805	71	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	19805	72	Government	Government	NNP
18637	19805	73	,	,	,
18637	19805	74	had	have	VBD
18637	19805	75	been	be	VBN
18637	19805	76	absorbed	absorb	VBN
18637	19805	77	in	in	IN
18637	19805	78	the	the	DT
18637	19805	79	due	due	JJ
18637	19805	80	process	process	NN
18637	19805	81	clause	clause	NN
18637	19805	82	of	of	IN
18637	19805	83	the	the	DT
18637	19805	84	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19805	85	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19805	86	.	.	.
18637	19806	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19806	2	,	,	,
18637	19806	3	in	in	IN
18637	19806	4	Dreyer	Dreyer	NNP
18637	19806	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19806	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	19806	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19806	8	Illinois,[975	Illinois,[975	NNP
18637	19806	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19806	10	after	after	IN
18637	19806	11	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	19806	12	that	that	IN
18637	19806	13	a	a	DT
18637	19806	14	retrial	retrial	NN
18637	19806	15	after	after	IN
18637	19806	16	discharge	discharge	NN
18637	19806	17	of	of	IN
18637	19806	18	a	a	DT
18637	19806	19	hung	hung	JJ
18637	19806	20	jury	jury	NN
18637	19806	21	did	do	VBD
18637	19806	22	not	not	RB
18637	19806	23	subject	subject	VB
18637	19806	24	a	a	DT
18637	19806	25	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19806	26	to	to	TO
18637	19806	27	double	double	VB
18637	19806	28	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	19806	29	,	,	,
18637	19806	30	the	the	DT
18637	19806	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19806	32	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	19806	33	as	as	IN
18637	19806	34	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	19806	35	:	:	:
18637	19806	36	If	if	IN
18637	19806	37	"	"	``
18637	19806	38	*	*	NFP
18637	19806	39	*	*	NFP
18637	19806	40	*	*	NFP
18637	19806	41	what	what	WP
18637	19806	42	was	be	VBD
18637	19806	43	said	say	VBN
18637	19806	44	in	in	IN
18637	19806	45	United	United	NNP
18637	19806	46	States	States	NNP
18637	19806	47	_	_	NNP
18637	19806	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	19806	49	_	_	NNP
18637	19806	50	Perez	Perez	NNP
18637	19806	51	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19806	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19806	53	9	9	CD
18637	19806	54	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	19806	55	.	.	.
18637	19807	1	579	579	CD
18637	19807	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19807	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	19807	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19807	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19807	6	embracing	embrace	VBG
18637	19807	7	a	a	DT
18637	19807	8	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19807	9	set	set	NN
18637	19807	10	of	of	IN
18637	19807	11	facts	fact	NNS
18637	19807	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19807	13	,	,	,
18637	19807	14	*	*	NFP
18637	19807	15	*	*	NFP
18637	19807	16	*	*	NFP
18637	19807	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	19807	18	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	19807	19	to	to	IN
18637	19807	20	the	the	DT
18637	19807	21	contention	contention	NN
18637	19807	22	of	of	IN
18637	19807	23	the	the	DT
18637	19807	24	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19807	25	that	that	IN
18637	19807	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19807	27	was	be	VBD
18637	19807	28	put	put	VBN
18637	19807	29	twice	twice	RB
18637	19807	30	in	in	IN
18637	19807	31	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	19807	32	,	,	,
18637	19807	33	"	"	``
18637	19807	34	then	then	RB
18637	19807	35	"	"	``
18637	19807	36	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19807	37	need	need	VBP
18637	19807	38	not	not	RB
18637	19807	39	now	now	RB
18637	19807	40	express	express	VB
18637	19807	41	an	an	DT
18637	19807	42	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	19807	43	"	"	``
18637	19807	44	as	as	IN
18637	19807	45	to	to	IN
18637	19807	46	whether	whether	IN
18637	19807	47	the	the	DT
18637	19807	48	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19807	49	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19807	50	embraces	embrace	VBZ
18637	19807	51	the	the	DT
18637	19807	52	guarantee	guarantee	NN
18637	19807	53	against	against	IN
18637	19807	54	double	double	JJ
18637	19807	55	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	19807	56	.	.	.
18637	19808	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19808	2	,	,	,
18637	19808	3	in	in	IN
18637	19808	4	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	19808	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19808	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	19808	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19808	8	Massachusetts[976	Massachusetts[976	NNP
18637	19808	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19808	10	and	and	CC
18637	19808	11	Shoener	Shoener	NNP
18637	19808	12	_	_	NNP
18637	19808	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	19808	14	_	_	NNP
18637	19808	15	Pennsylvania[977	Pennsylvania[977	NNP
18637	19808	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19808	17	the	the	DT
18637	19808	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19808	19	held	hold	VBD
18637	19808	20	that	that	IN
18637	19808	21	where	where	WRB
18637	19808	22	the	the	DT
18637	19808	23	original	original	JJ
18637	19808	24	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19808	25	of	of	IN
18637	19808	26	the	the	DT
18637	19808	27	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	19808	28	was	be	VBD
18637	19808	29	,	,	,
18637	19808	30	on	on	IN
18637	19808	31	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	19808	32	,	,	,
18637	19808	33	construed	construe	VBN
18637	19808	34	by	by	IN
18637	19808	35	the	the	DT
18637	19808	36	State	State	NNP
18637	19808	37	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	19808	38	to	to	TO
18637	19808	39	be	be	VB
18637	19808	40	legally	legally	RB
18637	19808	41	defective	defective	JJ
18637	19808	42	and	and	CC
18637	19808	43	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	19808	44	a	a	DT
18637	19808	45	nullity	nullity	NN
18637	19808	46	,	,	,
18637	19808	47	a	a	DT
18637	19808	48	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	19808	49	trial	trial	NN
18637	19808	50	,	,	,
18637	19808	51	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19808	52	,	,	,
18637	19808	53	and	and	CC
18637	19808	54	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19808	55	of	of	IN
18637	19808	56	the	the	DT
18637	19808	57	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19808	58	deprived	deprive	VBD
18637	19808	59	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19808	60	of	of	IN
18637	19808	61	no	no	DT
18637	19808	62	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19808	63	right	right	NN
18637	19808	64	,	,	,
18637	19808	65	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19808	66	the	the	DT
18637	19808	67	fact	fact	NN
18637	19808	68	that	that	IN
18637	19808	69	under	under	IN
18637	19808	70	the	the	DT
18637	19808	71	invalidated	invalidated	JJ
18637	19808	72	original	original	JJ
18637	19808	73	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19808	74	,	,	,
18637	19808	75	the	the	DT
18637	19808	76	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19808	77	had	have	VBD
18637	19808	78	spent	spend	VBN
18637	19808	79	time	time	NN
18637	19808	80	in	in	IN
18637	19808	81	prison	prison	NN
18637	19808	82	.	.	.
18637	19809	1	In	in	IN
18637	19809	2	both	both	DT
18637	19809	3	instances	instance	NNS
18637	19809	4	the	the	DT
18637	19809	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19809	6	found	find	VBD
18637	19809	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19809	8	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	19809	9	to	to	TO
18637	19809	10	discuss	discuss	VB
18637	19809	11	"	"	``
18637	19809	12	any	any	DT
18637	19809	13	question	question	NN
18637	19809	14	of	of	IN
18637	19809	15	a	a	DT
18637	19809	16	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19809	17	nature	nature	NN
18637	19809	18	.	.	.
18637	19809	19	"	"	''
18637	19810	1	With	with	IN
18637	19810	2	like	like	IN
18637	19810	3	dispatch	dispatch	NN
18637	19810	4	,	,	,
18637	19810	5	"	"	''
18637	19810	6	the	the	DT
18637	19810	7	propriety	propriety	NN
18637	19810	8	of	of	IN
18637	19810	9	inflicting	inflict	VBG
18637	19810	10	severer	severer	NN
18637	19810	11	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	19810	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	19810	13	old	old	JJ
18637	19810	14	offenders	offender	NNS
18637	19810	15	"	"	''
18637	19810	16	was	be	VBD
18637	19810	17	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	19810	18	on	on	IN
18637	19810	19	the	the	DT
18637	19810	20	ground	ground	NN
18637	19810	21	that	that	IN
18637	19810	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19810	23	were	be	VBD
18637	19810	24	not	not	RB
18637	19810	25	being	be	VBG
18637	19810	26	"	"	``
18637	19810	27	punished	punish	VBN
18637	19810	28	*	*	NFP
18637	19810	29	*	*	NFP
18637	19810	30	*	*	NFP
18637	19810	31	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19810	32	a	a	DT
18637	19810	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19810	34	second	second	JJ
18637	19810	35	time	time	NN
18637	19810	36	for	for	IN
18637	19810	37	the	the	DT
18637	19810	38	earlier	early	JJR
18637	19810	39	offense	offense	NN
18637	19810	40	,	,	,
18637	19810	41	but	but	CC
18637	19810	42	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19810	43	that	that	IN
18637	19810	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19810	45	the	the	DT
18637	19810	46	repetition	repetition	NN
18637	19810	47	of	of	IN
18637	19810	48	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19810	49	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	19810	50	aggravates	aggravate	VBZ
18637	19810	51	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19810	52	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	19810	53	and	and	CC
18637	19810	54	justifies	justify	VBZ
18637	19810	55	heavier	heavy	JJR
18637	19810	56	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	19810	57	when	when	WRB
18637	19810	58	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19810	59	are	be	VBP
18637	19810	60	again	again	RB
18637	19810	61	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	19810	62	.	.	.
18637	19811	1	"	"	``
18637	19811	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19811	3	978	978	CD
18637	19811	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19811	5	In	in	IN
18637	19811	6	Palko	Palko	NNP
18637	19811	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19811	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	19811	9	_	_	NNP
18637	19811	10	Connecticut,[979	Connecticut,[979	NNP
18637	19811	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19811	12	however	however	RB
18637	19811	13	,	,	,
18637	19811	14	the	the	DT
18637	19811	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19811	16	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	19811	17	to	to	TO
18637	19811	18	have	have	VB
18637	19811	19	been	be	VBN
18637	19811	20	presented	present	VBN
18637	19811	21	with	with	IN
18637	19811	22	issues	issue	NNS
18637	19811	23	,	,	,
18637	19811	24	the	the	DT
18637	19811	25	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	19811	26	of	of	IN
18637	19811	27	which	which	WDT
18637	19811	28	would	would	MD
18637	19811	29	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	19811	30	further	further	JJ
18637	19811	31	avoidance	avoidance	NN
18637	19811	32	of	of	IN
18637	19811	33	a	a	DT
18637	19811	34	decision	decision	NN
18637	19811	35	as	as	IN
18637	19811	36	to	to	IN
18637	19811	37	whether	whether	IN
18637	19811	38	the	the	DT
18637	19811	39	double	double	JJ
18637	19811	40	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	19811	41	provision	provision	NN
18637	19811	42	of	of	IN
18637	19811	43	the	the	DT
18637	19811	44	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	19811	45	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19811	46	had	have	VBD
18637	19811	47	become	become	VBN
18637	19811	48	operable	operable	JJ
18637	19811	49	as	as	IN
18637	19811	50	a	a	DT
18637	19811	51	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	19811	52	upon	upon	IN
18637	19811	53	the	the	DT
18637	19811	54	States	States	NNP
18637	19811	55	by	by	IN
18637	19811	56	reason	reason	NN
18637	19811	57	of	of	IN
18637	19811	58	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19811	59	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	19811	60	into	into	IN
18637	19811	61	the	the	DT
18637	19811	62	due	due	JJ
18637	19811	63	process	process	NN
18637	19811	64	clause	clause	NN
18637	19811	65	of	of	IN
18637	19811	66	the	the	DT
18637	19811	67	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19811	68	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19811	69	.	.	.
18637	19812	1	By	by	IN
18637	19812	2	the	the	DT
18637	19812	3	terms	term	NNS
18637	19812	4	of	of	IN
18637	19812	5	the	the	DT
18637	19812	6	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	19812	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	19812	8	at	at	IN
18637	19812	9	issue	issue	NN
18637	19812	10	,	,	,
18637	19812	11	the	the	DT
18637	19812	12	State	State	NNP
18637	19812	13	was	be	VBD
18637	19812	14	privileged	privileged	JJ
18637	19812	15	to	to	TO
18637	19812	16	appeal	appeal	VB
18637	19812	17	any	any	DT
18637	19812	18	question	question	NN
18637	19812	19	of	of	IN
18637	19812	20	law	law	NN
18637	19812	21	arising	arise	VBG
18637	19812	22	out	out	IN
18637	19812	23	of	of	IN
18637	19812	24	a	a	DT
18637	19812	25	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19812	26	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	19812	27	,	,	,
18637	19812	28	and	and	CC
18637	19812	29	did	do	VBD
18637	19812	30	appeal	appeal	VB
18637	19812	31	a	a	DT
18637	19812	32	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19812	33	of	of	IN
18637	19812	34	second	second	JJ
18637	19812	35	degree	degree	NN
18637	19812	36	murder	murder	NN
18637	19812	37	and	and	CC
18637	19812	38	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19812	39	to	to	IN
18637	19812	40	life	life	NN
18637	19812	41	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	19812	42	of	of	IN
18637	19812	43	one	one	CD
18637	19812	44	Palko	Palko	NNP
18637	19812	45	,	,	,
18637	19812	46	who	who	WP
18637	19812	47	had	have	VBD
18637	19812	48	been	be	VBN
18637	19812	49	charged	charge	VBN
18637	19812	50	with	with	IN
18637	19812	51	first	first	JJ
18637	19812	52	degree	degree	NN
18637	19812	53	murder	murder	NN
18637	19812	54	.	.	.
18637	19813	1	Obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	19813	2	a	a	DT
18637	19813	3	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	19813	4	,	,	,
18637	19813	5	the	the	DT
18637	19813	6	State	State	NNP
18637	19813	7	prosecuted	prosecute	VBD
18637	19813	8	Palko	Palko	NNP
18637	19813	9	a	a	DT
18637	19813	10	second	second	JJ
18637	19813	11	time	time	NN
18637	19813	12	and	and	CC
18637	19813	13	won	win	VBD
18637	19813	14	a	a	DT
18637	19813	15	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19813	16	of	of	IN
18637	19813	17	first	first	JJ
18637	19813	18	degree	degree	NN
18637	19813	19	murder	murder	NN
18637	19813	20	and	and	CC
18637	19813	21	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19813	22	to	to	IN
18637	19813	23	death	death	NN
18637	19813	24	.	.	.
18637	19814	1	In	in	IN
18637	19814	2	response	response	NN
18637	19814	3	to	to	IN
18637	19814	4	the	the	DT
18637	19814	5	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	19814	6	's	's	POS
18637	19814	7	contentions	contention	NNS
18637	19814	8	that	that	IN
18637	19814	9	a	a	DT
18637	19814	10	retrial	retrial	NN
18637	19814	11	under	under	IN
18637	19814	12	one	one	CD
18637	19814	13	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	19814	14	would	would	MD
18637	19814	15	subject	subject	VB
18637	19814	16	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19814	17	to	to	TO
18637	19814	18	double	double	VB
18637	19814	19	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	19814	20	in	in	IN
18637	19814	21	violation	violation	NN
18637	19814	22	of	of	IN
18637	19814	23	the	the	DT
18637	19814	24	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	19814	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19814	26	,	,	,
18637	19814	27	if	if	IN
18637	19814	28	the	the	DT
18637	19814	29	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	19814	30	were	be	VBD
18637	19814	31	one	one	CD
18637	19814	32	on	on	IN
18637	19814	33	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	19814	34	of	of	IN
18637	19814	35	the	the	DT
18637	19814	36	United	United	NNP
18637	19814	37	States	States	NNP
18637	19814	38	and	and	CC
18637	19814	39	"	"	``
18637	19814	40	that	that	IN
18637	19814	41	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	19814	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	19814	43	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	19814	44	by	by	IN
18637	19814	45	the	the	DT
18637	19814	46	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	19814	47	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19814	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	19814	49	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	19814	50	by	by	IN
18637	19814	51	the	the	DT
18637	19814	52	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19814	53	also,"[980	also,"[980	NN
18637	19814	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19814	55	eight	eight	CD
18637	19814	56	Justices[981	justices[981	NN
18637	19814	57	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19814	58	replied	reply	VBD
18637	19814	59	that	that	IN
18637	19814	60	the	the	DT
18637	19814	61	State	State	NNP
18637	19814	62	statute	statute	NN
18637	19814	63	did	do	VBD
18637	19814	64	not	not	RB
18637	19814	65	subject	subject	VB
18637	19814	66	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19814	67	to	to	TO
18637	19814	68	double	double	JJ
18637	19814	69	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	19814	70	"	"	''
18637	19814	71	so	so	RB
18637	19814	72	acute	acute	JJ
18637	19814	73	and	and	CC
18637	19814	74	shocking	shocking	JJ
18637	19814	75	that	that	IN
18637	19814	76	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19814	77	polity	polity	NN
18637	19814	78	will	will	MD
18637	19814	79	not	not	RB
18637	19814	80	endure	endure	VB
18637	19814	81	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19814	82	"	"	''
18637	19814	83	;	;	:
18637	19814	84	nor	nor	CC
18637	19814	85	did	do	VBD
18637	19814	86	"	"	``
18637	19814	87	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19814	88	violate	violate	VBP
18637	19814	89	those	those	DT
18637	19814	90	'	'	``
18637	19814	91	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19814	92	principles	principle	NNS
18637	19814	93	of	of	IN
18637	19814	94	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19814	95	and	and	CC
18637	19814	96	justice	justice	NN
18637	19814	97	which	which	WDT
18637	19814	98	lie	lie	VBP
18637	19814	99	at	at	IN
18637	19814	100	the	the	DT
18637	19814	101	base	base	NN
18637	19814	102	of	of	IN
18637	19814	103	all	all	PDT
18637	19814	104	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19814	105	civil	civil	JJ
18637	19814	106	and	and	CC
18637	19814	107	political	political	JJ
18637	19814	108	'	'	''
18637	19814	109	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	19814	110	.	.	.
18637	19814	111	'	'	''
18637	19814	112	"	"	''
18637	19815	1	Consistently	consistently	RB
18637	19815	2	with	with	IN
18637	19815	3	past	past	JJ
18637	19815	4	behavior	behavior	NN
18637	19815	5	,	,	,
18637	19815	6	the	the	DT
18637	19815	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19815	8	thus	thus	RB
18637	19815	9	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	19815	10	to	to	TO
18637	19815	11	assert	assert	VB
18637	19815	12	that	that	IN
18637	19815	13	the	the	DT
18637	19815	14	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19815	15	had	have	VBD
18637	19815	16	been	be	VBN
18637	19815	17	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	19815	18	to	to	IN
18637	19815	19	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	19815	20	of	of	IN
18637	19815	21	the	the	DT
18637	19815	22	type	type	NN
18637	19815	23	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	19815	24	by	by	IN
18637	19815	25	the	the	DT
18637	19815	26	double	double	JJ
18637	19815	27	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	19815	28	clause	clause	NN
18637	19815	29	of	of	IN
18637	19815	30	the	the	DT
18637	19815	31	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	19815	32	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19815	33	;	;	:
18637	19815	34	nor	nor	CC
18637	19815	35	did	do	VBD
18637	19815	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19815	37	,	,	,
18637	19815	38	on	on	IN
18637	19815	39	the	the	DT
18637	19815	40	other	other	JJ
18637	19815	41	hand	hand	NN
18637	19815	42	,	,	,
18637	19815	43	repudiate	repudiate	VBP
18637	19815	44	the	the	DT
18637	19815	45	possibility	possibility	NN
18637	19815	46	of	of	IN
18637	19815	47	situations	situation	NNS
18637	19815	48	in	in	IN
18637	19815	49	which	which	WDT
18637	19815	50	the	the	DT
18637	19815	51	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19815	52	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19815	53	would	would	MD
18637	19815	54	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	19815	55	the	the	DT
18637	19815	56	States	States	NNP
18637	19815	57	from	from	IN
18637	19815	58	inflicting	inflict	VBG
18637	19815	59	double	double	JJ
18637	19815	60	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	19815	61	.	.	.
18637	19816	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	19816	2	a	a	DT
18637	19816	3	State	state	NN
18637	19816	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	19816	5	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	19816	6	by	by	IN
18637	19816	7	the	the	DT
18637	19816	8	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19816	9	amendment	amendment	NNP
18637	19816	10	,	,	,
18637	19816	11	after	after	IN
18637	19816	12	a	a	DT
18637	19816	13	trial	trial	NN
18637	19816	14	free	free	JJ
18637	19816	15	from	from	IN
18637	19816	16	error	error	NN
18637	19816	17	,	,	,
18637	19816	18	from	from	IN
18637	19816	19	trying	try	VBG
18637	19816	20	the	the	DT
18637	19816	21	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19816	22	over	over	RB
18637	19816	23	again	again	RB
18637	19816	24	or	or	CC
18637	19816	25	from	from	IN
18637	19816	26	wearing	wear	VBG
18637	19816	27	out	out	RP
18637	19816	28	the	the	DT
18637	19816	29	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19816	30	"	"	''
18637	19816	31	by	by	IN
18637	19816	32	a	a	DT
18637	19816	33	multitude	multitude	NN
18637	19816	34	of	of	IN
18637	19816	35	cases	case	NNS
18637	19816	36	with	with	IN
18637	19816	37	accumulated	accumulate	VBN
18637	19816	38	trials	trial	NNS
18637	19816	39	"	"	''
18637	19816	40	were	be	VBD
18637	19816	41	questions	question	NNS
18637	19816	42	which	which	WDT
18637	19816	43	the	the	DT
18637	19816	44	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19816	45	reserved	reserve	VBD
18637	19816	46	for	for	IN
18637	19816	47	future	future	JJ
18637	19816	48	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	19816	49	.	.	.
18637	19817	1	Subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	19817	2	,	,	,
18637	19817	3	in	in	IN
18637	19817	4	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	19817	5	ex	ex	NNP
18637	19817	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	19817	7	.	.	.
18637	19818	1	Francis	Francis	NNP
18637	19818	2	_	_	NNP
18637	19818	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	19818	4	_	_	NNP
18637	19818	5	Resweber,[982	Resweber,[982	NNP
18637	19818	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19818	7	a	a	DT
18637	19818	8	majority	majority	NN
18637	19818	9	of	of	IN
18637	19818	10	the	the	DT
18637	19818	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19818	12	assumed	assume	VBD
18637	19818	13	,	,	,
18637	19818	14	"	"	``
18637	19818	15	but	but	CC
18637	19818	16	without	without	IN
18637	19818	17	so	so	RB
18637	19818	18	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	19818	19	,	,	,
18637	19818	20	that	that	IN
18637	19818	21	violation	violation	NN
18637	19818	22	of	of	IN
18637	19818	23	the	the	DT
18637	19818	24	principles	principle	NNS
18637	19818	25	of	of	IN
18637	19818	26	the	the	DT
18637	19818	27	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	19818	28	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19818	29	*	*	NFP
18637	19818	30	*	*	NFP
18637	19818	31	*	*	NFP
18637	19818	32	,	,	,
18637	19818	33	as	as	IN
18637	19818	34	to	to	TO
18637	19818	35	double	double	JJ
18637	19818	36	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	19818	37	*	*	NFP
18637	19818	38	*	*	NFP
18637	19818	39	*	*	NFP
18637	19818	40	,	,	,
18637	19818	41	would	would	MD
18637	19818	42	be	be	VB
18637	19818	43	violative	violative	JJ
18637	19818	44	of	of	IN
18637	19818	45	the	the	DT
18637	19818	46	due	due	JJ
18637	19818	47	process	process	NN
18637	19818	48	clause	clause	NN
18637	19818	49	of	of	IN
18637	19818	50	the	the	DT
18637	19818	51	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19818	52	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19818	53	,	,	,
18637	19818	54	"	"	''
18637	19818	55	and	and	CC
18637	19818	56	then	then	RB
18637	19818	57	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	19818	58	that	that	IN
18637	19818	59	the	the	DT
18637	19818	60	Palko	Palko	NNP
18637	19818	61	case	case	NN
18637	19818	62	was	be	VBD
18637	19818	63	decisive	decisive	JJ
18637	19818	64	,	,	,
18637	19818	65	there	there	EX
18637	19818	66	being	be	VBG
18637	19818	67	"	"	``
18637	19818	68	no	no	DT
18637	19818	69	difference	difference	NN
18637	19818	70	from	from	IN
18637	19818	71	a	a	DT
18637	19818	72	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19818	73	point	point	NN
18637	19818	74	of	of	IN
18637	19818	75	view	view	NN
18637	19818	76	between	between	IN
18637	19818	77	a	a	DT
18637	19818	78	new	new	JJ
18637	19818	79	trial	trial	NN
18637	19818	80	for	for	IN
18637	19818	81	error	error	NN
18637	19818	82	of	of	IN
18637	19818	83	law	law	NN
18637	19818	84	at	at	IN
18637	19818	85	the	the	DT
18637	19818	86	instance	instance	NN
18637	19818	87	of	of	IN
18637	19818	88	the	the	DT
18637	19818	89	State	State	NNP
18637	19818	90	that	that	WDT
18637	19818	91	results	result	VBZ
18637	19818	92	in	in	IN
18637	19818	93	a	a	DT
18637	19818	94	death	death	NN
18637	19818	95	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19818	96	instead	instead	RB
18637	19818	97	of	of	IN
18637	19818	98	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	19818	99	for	for	IN
18637	19818	100	life	life	NN
18637	19818	101	and	and	CC
18637	19818	102	an	an	DT
18637	19818	103	execution	execution	NN
18637	19818	104	"	"	''
18637	19818	105	by	by	IN
18637	19818	106	electrocution	electrocution	NN
18637	19818	107	that	that	WDT
18637	19818	108	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	19818	109	after	after	IN
18637	19818	110	"	"	``
18637	19818	111	an	an	DT
18637	19818	112	accidental	accidental	JJ
18637	19818	113	failure	failure	NN
18637	19818	114	in	in	IN
18637	19818	115	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	19818	116	had	have	VBD
18637	19818	117	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19818	118	a	a	DT
18637	19818	119	previous	previous	JJ
18637	19818	120	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	19818	121	at	at	IN
18637	19818	122	execution	execution	NN
18637	19818	123	ineffectual	ineffectual	JJ
18637	19818	124	.	.	.
18637	19818	125	"	"	''
18637	19819	1	Rights	right	NNS
18637	19819	2	of	of	IN
18637	19819	3	Prisoners	Prisoners	NNPS
18637	19819	4	Access	Access	NNP
18637	19819	5	to	to	IN
18637	19819	6	the	the	DT
18637	19819	7	Courts.--A	Courts.--A	NNP
18637	19819	8	State	State	NNP
18637	19819	9	prison	prison	NN
18637	19819	10	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	19819	11	requiring	require	VBG
18637	19819	12	that	that	IN
18637	19819	13	all	all	DT
18637	19819	14	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19819	15	papers	paper	NNS
18637	19819	16	sought	seek	VBD
18637	19819	17	to	to	TO
18637	19819	18	be	be	VB
18637	19819	19	filed	file	VBN
18637	19819	20	in	in	IN
18637	19819	21	court	court	NN
18637	19819	22	by	by	IN
18637	19819	23	inmates	inmate	NNS
18637	19819	24	must	must	MD
18637	19819	25	first	first	RB
18637	19819	26	be	be	VB
18637	19819	27	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	19819	28	to	to	IN
18637	19819	29	the	the	DT
18637	19819	30	institution	institution	NN
18637	19819	31	for	for	IN
18637	19819	32	approval	approval	NN
18637	19819	33	and	and	CC
18637	19819	34	which	which	WDT
18637	19819	35	was	be	VBD
18637	19819	36	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19819	37	so	so	IN
18637	19819	38	as	as	IN
18637	19819	39	to	to	TO
18637	19819	40	obstruct	obstruct	VB
18637	19819	41	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	19819	42	of	of	IN
18637	19819	43	a	a	DT
18637	19819	44	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	19819	45	to	to	TO
18637	19819	46	petition	petition	VB
18637	19819	47	a	a	DT
18637	19819	48	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19819	49	court	court	NN
18637	19819	50	for	for	IN
18637	19819	51	a	a	DT
18637	19819	52	writ	writ	NNP
18637	19819	53	of	of	IN
18637	19819	54	_	_	NNP
18637	19819	55	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	19819	56	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	19819	57	_	_	NNP
18637	19819	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	19819	59	void	void	JJ
18637	19819	60	.	.	.
18637	19820	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	19820	2	a	a	DT
18637	19820	3	petition	petition	NN
18637	19820	4	for	for	IN
18637	19820	5	such	such	JJ
18637	19820	6	writ	writ	VBN
18637	19820	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	19820	8	properly	properly	RB
18637	19820	9	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	19820	10	and	and	CC
18637	19820	11	what	what	WP
18637	19820	12	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	19820	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19820	14	must	must	MD
18637	19820	15	contain	contain	VB
18637	19820	16	are	be	VBP
18637	19820	17	questions	question	NNS
18637	19820	18	which	which	WDT
18637	19820	19	a	a	DT
18637	19820	20	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19820	21	court	court	NN
18637	19820	22	alone	alone	RB
18637	19820	23	determines	determine	VBZ
18637	19820	24	.	.	.
18637	19821	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19821	2	983	983	CD
18637	19821	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19821	4	Equally	equally	RB
18637	19821	5	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19821	6	to	to	IN
18637	19821	7	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	19821	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	19821	9	the	the	DT
18637	19821	10	practice	practice	NN
18637	19821	11	of	of	IN
18637	19821	12	the	the	DT
18637	19821	13	warden	warden	NN
18637	19821	14	of	of	IN
18637	19821	15	a	a	DT
18637	19821	16	State	State	NNP
18637	19821	17	penitentiary	penitentiary	NN
18637	19821	18	who	who	WP
18637	19821	19	denied	deny	VBD
18637	19821	20	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
18637	19821	21	access	access	VBP
18637	19821	22	to	to	IN
18637	19821	23	the	the	DT
18637	19821	24	courts	court	NNS
18637	19821	25	unless	unless	IN
18637	19821	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19821	27	procured	procure	VBD
18637	19821	28	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19821	29	to	to	TO
18637	19821	30	represent	represent	VB
18637	19821	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19821	32	.	.	.
18637	19822	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19822	2	984	984	CD
18637	19822	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19822	4	Appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	19822	5	;	;	:
18637	19822	6	Corrective	Corrective	NNP
18637	19822	7	Process.--Rehearing	Process.--Rehearing	NNP
18637	19822	8	,	,	,
18637	19822	9	new	new	JJ
18637	19822	10	trials	trial	NNS
18637	19822	11	,	,	,
18637	19822	12	and	and	CC
18637	19822	13	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	19822	14	are	be	VBP
18637	19822	15	not	not	RB
18637	19822	16	considered	consider	VBN
18637	19822	17	to	to	TO
18637	19822	18	be	be	VB
18637	19822	19	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19822	20	to	to	IN
18637	19822	21	due	due	JJ
18637	19822	22	process	process	NN
18637	19822	23	;	;	:
18637	19822	24	and	and	CC
18637	19822	25	a	a	DT
18637	19822	26	State	state	NN
18637	19822	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	19822	28	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	19822	29	by	by	IN
18637	19822	30	no	no	DT
18637	19822	31	provision	provision	NN
18637	19822	32	of	of	IN
18637	19822	33	the	the	DT
18637	19822	34	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19822	35	from	from	IN
18637	19822	36	vesting	vest	VBG
18637	19822	37	in	in	IN
18637	19822	38	one	one	CD
18637	19822	39	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	19822	40	the	the	DT
18637	19822	41	final	final	JJ
18637	19822	42	determination	determination	NN
18637	19822	43	of	of	IN
18637	19822	44	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19822	45	questions	question	NNS
18637	19822	46	.	.	.
18637	19823	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	19823	2	,	,	,
18637	19823	3	a	a	DT
18637	19823	4	review	review	NN
18637	19823	5	by	by	IN
18637	19823	6	an	an	DT
18637	19823	7	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19823	8	court	court	NN
18637	19823	9	of	of	IN
18637	19823	10	a	a	DT
18637	19823	11	final	final	JJ
18637	19823	12	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19823	13	in	in	IN
18637	19823	14	a	a	DT
18637	19823	15	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19823	16	case	case	NN
18637	19823	17	,	,	,
18637	19823	18	irrespective	irrespective	RB
18637	19823	19	of	of	IN
18637	19823	20	the	the	DT
18637	19823	21	gravity	gravity	NN
18637	19823	22	of	of	IN
18637	19823	23	the	the	DT
18637	19823	24	offense	offense	NN
18637	19823	25	,	,	,
18637	19823	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	19823	27	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	19823	28	within	within	IN
18637	19823	29	the	the	DT
18637	19823	30	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	19823	31	of	of	IN
18637	19823	32	the	the	DT
18637	19823	33	State	State	NNP
18637	19823	34	to	to	TO
18637	19823	35	allow	allow	VB
18637	19823	36	or	or	CC
18637	19823	37	not	not	RB
18637	19823	38	to	to	IN
18637	19823	39	allow;[985	allow;[985	ADD
18637	19823	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19823	41	and	and	CC
18637	19823	42	,	,	,
18637	19823	43	if	if	IN
18637	19823	44	granted	grant	VBN
18637	19823	45	,	,	,
18637	19823	46	may	may	MD
18637	19823	47	be	be	VB
18637	19823	48	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	19823	49	by	by	IN
18637	19823	50	the	the	DT
18637	19823	51	State	State	NNP
18637	19823	52	upon	upon	IN
18637	19823	53	such	such	JJ
18637	19823	54	terms	term	NNS
18637	19823	55	as	as	IN
18637	19823	56	in	in	IN
18637	19823	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19823	58	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	19823	59	may	may	MD
18637	19823	60	be	be	VB
18637	19823	61	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19823	62	proper	proper	JJ
18637	19823	63	.	.	.
18637	19824	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19824	2	986	986	CD
18637	19824	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19824	4	"	"	``
18637	19824	5	Wide	wide	JJ
18637	19824	6	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	19824	7	must	must	MD
18637	19824	8	be	be	VB
18637	19824	9	left	leave	VBN
18637	19824	10	to	to	IN
18637	19824	11	the	the	DT
18637	19824	12	States	States	NNP
18637	19824	13	for	for	IN
18637	19824	14	the	the	DT
18637	19824	15	manner	manner	NN
18637	19824	16	of	of	IN
18637	19824	17	adjudicating	adjudicate	VBG
18637	19824	18	a	a	DT
18637	19824	19	claim	claim	NN
18637	19824	20	that	that	IN
18637	19824	21	a	a	DT
18637	19824	22	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19824	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	19824	24	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19824	25	;	;	:
18637	19824	26	*	*	NFP
18637	19824	27	*	*	NFP
18637	19824	28	*	*	NFP
18637	19824	29	and	and	CC
18637	19824	30	so	so	RB
18637	19824	31	long	long	RB
18637	19824	32	as	as	IN
18637	19824	33	the	the	DT
18637	19824	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	19824	35	under	under	IN
18637	19824	36	the	the	DT
18637	19824	37	*	*	NN
18637	19824	38	*	*	NFP
18637	19824	39	*	*	NFP
18637	19824	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19824	41	may	may	MD
18637	19824	42	be	be	VB
18637	19824	43	pursued	pursue	VBN
18637	19824	44	,	,	,
18637	19824	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19824	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	19824	47	for	for	IN
18637	19824	48	a	a	DT
18637	19824	49	State	state	NN
18637	19824	50	and	and	CC
18637	19824	51	not	not	RB
18637	19824	52	for	for	IN
18637	19824	53	*	*	NFP
18637	19824	54	*	*	NFP
18637	19824	55	*	*	NFP
18637	19824	56	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19824	57	the	the	DT
18637	19824	58	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19824	59	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19824	60	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19824	61	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19824	62	of	of	IN
18637	19824	63	the	the	DT
18637	19824	64	United	United	NNP
18637	19824	65	States	States	NNP
18637	19824	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19824	67	to	to	TO
18637	19824	68	define	define	VB
18637	19824	69	the	the	DT
18637	19824	70	mode	mode	NN
18637	19824	71	by	by	IN
18637	19824	72	which	which	WDT
18637	19824	73	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19824	74	may	may	MD
18637	19824	75	be	be	VB
18637	19824	76	vindicated	vindicate	VBN
18637	19824	77	.	.	.
18637	19825	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19825	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19825	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19825	4	A	a	DT
18637	19825	5	State	state	NN
18637	19825	6	may	may	MD
18637	19825	7	decide	decide	VB
18637	19825	8	whether	whether	IN
18637	19825	9	to	to	TO
18637	19825	10	have	have	VB
18637	19825	11	direct	direct	JJ
18637	19825	12	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	19825	13	*	*	NFP
18637	19825	14	*	*	NFP
18637	19825	15	*	*	NFP
18637	19825	16	,	,	,
18637	19825	17	and	and	CC
18637	19825	18	if	if	IN
18637	19825	19	so	so	RB
18637	19825	20	under	under	IN
18637	19825	21	what	what	WDT
18637	19825	22	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19825	23	*	*	NFP
18637	19825	24	*	*	NFP
18637	19825	25	*	*	NFP
18637	19825	26	may	may	MD
18637	19825	27	provide	provide	VB
18637	19825	28	that	that	IN
18637	19825	29	the	the	DT
18637	19825	30	protection	protection	NN
18637	19825	31	of	of	IN
18637	19825	32	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19825	33	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19825	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19825	35	rights	right	NNS
18637	19825	36	*	*	NFP
18637	19825	37	*	*	NFP
18637	19825	38	*	*	NFP
18637	19825	39	be	be	VB
18637	19825	40	sought	seek	VBN
18637	19825	41	through	through	IN
18637	19825	42	the	the	DT
18637	19825	43	writ	writ	NNP
18637	19825	44	of	of	IN
18637	19825	45	_	_	NNP
18637	19825	46	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	19825	47	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	19825	48	_	_	NNP
18637	19825	49	or	or	CC
18637	19825	50	_	_	NNP
18637	19825	51	coram	coram	NNP
18637	19825	52	nobis	nobis	NNP
18637	19825	53	_	_	NNP
18637	19825	54	,	,	,
18637	19825	55	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19825	56	or	or	CC
18637	19825	57	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19825	58	*	*	NFP
18637	19825	59	*	*	NFP
18637	19825	60	*	*	NFP
18637	19825	61	may	may	MD
18637	19825	62	afford	afford	VB
18637	19825	63	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	19825	64	by	by	IN
18637	19825	65	a	a	DT
18637	19825	66	simple	simple	JJ
18637	19825	67	motion	motion	NN
18637	19825	68	brought	bring	VBN
18637	19825	69	either	either	CC
18637	19825	70	in	in	IN
18637	19825	71	the	the	DT
18637	19825	72	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19825	73	of	of	IN
18637	19825	74	original	original	JJ
18637	19825	75	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19825	76	or	or	CC
18637	19825	77	at	at	IN
18637	19825	78	the	the	DT
18637	19825	79	place	place	NN
18637	19825	80	of	of	IN
18637	19825	81	detention	detention	NN
18637	19825	82	.	.	.
18637	19826	1	"	"	``
18637	19826	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19826	3	987	987	CD
18637	19826	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19826	5	However	however	RB
18637	19826	6	,	,	,
18637	19826	7	if	if	IN
18637	19826	8	the	the	DT
18637	19826	9	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	19826	10	of	of	IN
18637	19826	11	first	first	JJ
18637	19826	12	instance	instance	NN
18637	19826	13	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	19826	14	to	to	TO
18637	19826	15	accord	accord	VB
18637	19826	16	due	due	JJ
18637	19826	17	process	process	NN
18637	19826	18	such	such	JJ
18637	19826	19	as	as	IN
18637	19826	20	occurs	occur	VBZ
18637	19826	21	when	when	WRB
18637	19826	22	the	the	DT
18637	19826	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19826	24	in	in	IN
18637	19826	25	which	which	WDT
18637	19826	26	a	a	DT
18637	19826	27	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	19826	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	19826	29	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	19826	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	19826	31	dominated	dominate	VBN
18637	19826	32	by	by	IN
18637	19826	33	a	a	DT
18637	19826	34	mob	mob	NN
18637	19826	35	,	,	,
18637	19826	36	the	the	DT
18637	19826	37	State	State	NNP
18637	19826	38	must	must	MD
18637	19826	39	supply	supply	VB
18637	19826	40	corrective	corrective	JJ
18637	19826	41	process	process	NN
18637	19826	42	.	.	.
18637	19827	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	19827	2	,	,	,
18637	19827	3	when	when	WRB
18637	19827	4	such	such	JJ
18637	19827	5	process	process	NN
18637	19827	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19827	7	made	make	VBN
18637	19827	8	available	available	JJ
18637	19827	9	,	,	,
18637	19827	10	the	the	DT
18637	19827	11	corrective	corrective	JJ
18637	19827	12	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19827	13	in	in	IN
18637	19827	14	the	the	DT
18637	19827	15	reviewing	reviewing	NN
18637	19827	16	or	or	CC
18637	19827	17	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19827	18	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	19827	19	being	be	VBG
18637	19827	20	no	no	RB
18637	19827	21	less	less	JJR
18637	19827	22	a	a	DT
18637	19827	23	part	part	NN
18637	19827	24	of	of	IN
18637	19827	25	the	the	DT
18637	19827	26	process	process	NN
18637	19827	27	of	of	IN
18637	19827	28	law	law	NN
18637	19827	29	under	under	IN
18637	19827	30	which	which	WDT
18637	19827	31	a	a	DT
18637	19827	32	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	19827	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	19827	34	held	hold	VBN
18637	19827	35	in	in	IN
18637	19827	36	custody	custody	NN
18637	19827	37	,	,	,
18637	19827	38	become	become	VB
18637	19827	39	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19827	40	to	to	IN
18637	19827	41	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
18637	19827	42	on	on	IN
18637	19827	43	the	the	DT
18637	19827	44	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	19827	45	of	of	IN
18637	19827	46	any	any	DT
18637	19827	47	determination	determination	NN
18637	19827	48	of	of	IN
18637	19827	49	an	an	DT
18637	19827	50	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	19827	51	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19827	52	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	19827	53	of	of	IN
18637	19827	54	life	life	NN
18637	19827	55	or	or	CC
18637	19827	56	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19827	57	.	.	.
18637	19828	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19828	2	988	988	CD
18637	19828	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19828	4	Such	such	JJ
18637	19828	5	examination	examination	NN
18637	19828	6	may	may	MD
18637	19828	7	lead	lead	VB
18637	19828	8	unavoidably	unavoidably	RB
18637	19828	9	to	to	IN
18637	19828	10	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	19828	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19828	12	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	19828	13	in	in	IN
18637	19828	14	State	State	NNP
18637	19828	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19828	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19828	17	,	,	,
18637	19828	18	and	and	CC
18637	19828	19	sensitive	sensitive	JJ
18637	19828	20	,	,	,
18637	19828	21	no	no	RB
18637	19828	22	doubt	doubt	RB
18637	19828	23	,	,	,
18637	19828	24	to	to	IN
18637	19828	25	the	the	DT
18637	19828	26	propriety	propriety	NN
18637	19828	27	thereof,[989	thereof,[989	RB
18637	19828	28	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19828	29	the	the	DT
18637	19828	30	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19828	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19828	32	,	,	,
18637	19828	33	almost	almost	RB
18637	19828	34	until	until	IN
18637	19828	35	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	19828	36	_	_	NNP
18637	19828	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	19828	38	_	_	NNP
18637	19828	39	Mississippi,[990	Mississippi,[990	NNP
18637	19828	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19828	41	decided	decide	VBD
18637	19828	42	in	in	IN
18637	19828	43	1936	1936	CD
18637	19828	44	,	,	,
18637	19828	45	manifested	manifest	VBD
18637	19828	46	an	an	DT
18637	19828	47	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	19828	48	reluctance	reluctance	NN
18637	19828	49	to	to	TO
18637	19828	50	indulge	indulge	VB
18637	19828	51	in	in	IN
18637	19828	52	an	an	DT
18637	19828	53	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	19828	54	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	19828	55	of	of	IN
18637	19828	56	the	the	DT
18637	19828	57	adequacy	adequacy	NN
18637	19828	58	of	of	IN
18637	19828	59	a	a	DT
18637	19828	60	State	State	NNP
18637	19828	61	's	's	POS
18637	19828	62	corrective	corrective	JJ
18637	19828	63	process	process	NN
18637	19828	64	.	.	.
18637	19829	1	Prior	prior	RB
18637	19829	2	to	to	IN
18637	19829	3	the	the	DT
18637	19829	4	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19829	5	date	date	NN
18637	19829	6	,	,	,
18637	19829	7	the	the	DT
18637	19829	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19829	9	was	be	VBD
18637	19829	10	content	content	JJ
18637	19829	11	to	to	TO
18637	19829	12	assume	assume	VB
18637	19829	13	as	as	IN
18637	19829	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19829	15	did	do	VBD
18637	19829	16	in	in	IN
18637	19829	17	Frank	Frank	NNP
18637	19829	18	_	_	NNP
18637	19829	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	19829	20	_	_	NNP
18637	19829	21	Mangum,[991	Mangum,[991	NNP
18637	19829	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19829	23	decided	decide	VBD
18637	19829	24	in	in	IN
18637	19829	25	1915	1915	CD
18637	19829	26	,	,	,
18637	19829	27	that	that	DT
18637	19829	28	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	19829	29	as	as	IN
18637	19829	30	the	the	DT
18637	19829	31	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19829	32	in	in	IN
18637	19829	33	the	the	DT
18637	19829	34	State	State	NNP
18637	19829	35	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19829	36	court	court	NN
18637	19829	37	formally	formally	RB
18637	19829	38	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	19829	39	to	to	TO
18637	19829	40	be	be	VB
18637	19829	41	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19829	42	to	to	TO
18637	19829	43	correct	correct	VB
18637	19829	44	errors	error	NNS
18637	19829	45	committed	commit	VBN
18637	19829	46	by	by	IN
18637	19829	47	a	a	DT
18637	19829	48	trial	trial	NN
18637	19829	49	court	court	NN
18637	19829	50	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	19829	51	to	to	TO
18637	19829	52	have	have	VB
18637	19829	53	been	be	VBN
18637	19829	54	intimidated	intimidate	VBN
18637	19829	55	by	by	IN
18637	19829	56	a	a	DT
18637	19829	57	mob	mob	NN
18637	19829	58	,	,	,
18637	19829	59	the	the	DT
18637	19829	60	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	19829	61	by	by	IN
18637	19829	62	that	that	DT
18637	19829	63	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19829	64	court	court	NN
18637	19829	65	that	that	IN
18637	19829	66	the	the	DT
18637	19829	67	trial	trial	NN
18637	19829	68	court	court	NN
18637	19829	69	's	's	POS
18637	19829	70	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	19829	71	of	of	IN
18637	19829	72	execution	execution	NN
18637	19829	73	should	should	MD
18637	19829	74	be	be	VB
18637	19829	75	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	19829	76	was	be	VBD
18637	19829	77	ample	ample	JJ
18637	19829	78	assurance	assurance	NN
18637	19829	79	that	that	IN
18637	19829	80	life	life	NN
18637	19829	81	would	would	MD
18637	19829	82	not	not	RB
18637	19829	83	be	be	VB
18637	19829	84	forfeited	forfeit	VBN
18637	19829	85	without	without	IN
18637	19829	86	due	due	JJ
18637	19829	87	process	process	NN
18637	19829	88	of	of	IN
18637	19829	89	law	law	NN
18637	19829	90	.	.	.
18637	19830	1	Apparently	apparently	RB
18637	19830	2	in	in	IN
18637	19830	3	observance	observance	NN
18637	19830	4	of	of	IN
18637	19830	5	a	a	DT
18637	19830	6	principle	principle	NN
18637	19830	7	of	of	IN
18637	19830	8	comity	comity	NN
18637	19830	9	,	,	,
18637	19830	10	whereunder	whereunder	VB
18637	19830	11	a	a	DT
18637	19830	12	State	State	NNP
18637	19830	13	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19830	14	court	court	NN
18637	19830	15	's	's	POS
18637	19830	16	holding	holding	NN
18637	19830	17	,	,	,
18637	19830	18	though	though	IN
18637	19830	19	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	19830	20	as	as	IN
18637	19830	21	not	not	RB
18637	19830	22	binding	bind	VBG
18637	19830	23	,	,	,
18637	19830	24	was	be	VBD
18637	19830	25	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19830	26	entitled	entitled	JJ
18637	19830	27	to	to	IN
18637	19830	28	utmost	utmost	JJ
18637	19830	29	respect	respect	NN
18637	19830	30	,	,	,
18637	19830	31	the	the	DT
18637	19830	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19830	33	persisted	persist	VBD
18637	19830	34	in	in	IN
18637	19830	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19830	36	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	19830	37	to	to	TO
18637	19830	38	make	make	VB
18637	19830	39	an	an	DT
18637	19830	40	independent	independent	JJ
18637	19830	41	examination	examination	NN
18637	19830	42	of	of	IN
18637	19830	43	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	19830	44	of	of	IN
18637	19830	45	a	a	DT
18637	19830	46	denial	denial	NN
18637	19830	47	of	of	IN
18637	19830	48	due	due	JJ
18637	19830	49	process	process	NN
18637	19830	50	.	.	.
18637	19831	1	Eight	eight	CD
18637	19831	2	years	year	NNS
18637	19831	3	later	later	RB
18637	19831	4	,	,	,
18637	19831	5	in	in	IN
18637	19831	6	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	19831	7	_	_	NNP
18637	19831	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	19831	9	_	_	NNP
18637	19831	10	Dempsey,[992	Dempsey,[992	NNP
18637	19831	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19831	12	a	a	DT
18637	19831	13	case	case	NN
18637	19831	14	involving	involve	VBG
18637	19831	15	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19831	16	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	19831	17	of	of	IN
18637	19831	18	mob	mob	NN
18637	19831	19	domination	domination	NN
18637	19831	20	,	,	,
18637	19831	21	the	the	DT
18637	19831	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19831	23	,	,	,
18637	19831	24	on	on	IN
18637	19831	25	this	this	DT
18637	19831	26	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	19831	27	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	19831	28	through	through	IN
18637	19831	29	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19831	30	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	19831	31	who	who	WP
18637	19831	32	had	have	VBD
18637	19831	33	dissented	dissent	VBN
18637	19831	34	in	in	IN
18637	19831	35	the	the	DT
18637	19831	36	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	19831	37	decision	decision	NN
18637	19831	38	,	,	,
18637	19831	39	ordered	order	VBD
18637	19831	40	the	the	DT
18637	19831	41	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19831	42	district	district	NN
18637	19831	43	court	court	NNP
18637	19831	44	,	,	,
18637	19831	45	in	in	IN
18637	19831	46	which	which	WDT
18637	19831	47	the	the	DT
18637	19831	48	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	19831	49	had	have	VBD
18637	19831	50	petitioned	petition	VBN
18637	19831	51	for	for	IN
18637	19831	52	a	a	DT
18637	19831	53	writ	writ	NN
18637	19831	54	of	of	IN
18637	19831	55	_	_	NNP
18637	19831	56	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	19831	57	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	19831	58	_	_	NNP
18637	19831	59	and	and	CC
18637	19831	60	which	which	WDT
18637	19831	61	had	have	VBD
18637	19831	62	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	19831	63	the	the	DT
18637	19831	64	State	State	NNP
18637	19831	65	of	of	IN
18637	19831	66	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	19831	67	's	's	POS
18637	19831	68	demurrer	demurrer	NN
18637	19831	69	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	19831	70	,	,	,
18637	19831	71	to	to	TO
18637	19831	72	make	make	VB
18637	19831	73	an	an	DT
18637	19831	74	independent	independent	JJ
18637	19831	75	investigation	investigation	NN
18637	19831	76	of	of	IN
18637	19831	77	the	the	DT
18637	19831	78	facts	fact	NNS
18637	19831	79	,	,	,
18637	19831	80	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	19831	81	that	that	IN
18637	19831	82	the	the	DT
18637	19831	83	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	19831	84	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19831	85	court	court	NN
18637	19831	86	had	have	VBD
18637	19831	87	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	19831	88	that	that	IN
18637	19831	89	,	,	,
18637	19831	90	in	in	IN
18637	19831	91	view	view	NN
18637	19831	92	of	of	IN
18637	19831	93	the	the	DT
18637	19831	94	legally	legally	RB
18637	19831	95	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19831	96	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19831	97	on	on	IN
18637	19831	98	which	which	WDT
18637	19831	99	the	the	DT
18637	19831	100	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	19831	101	was	be	VBD
18637	19831	102	based	base	VBN
18637	19831	103	and	and	CC
18637	19831	104	the	the	DT
18637	19831	105	competent	competent	JJ
18637	19831	106	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	19831	107	defending	defend	VBG
18637	19831	108	the	the	DT
18637	19831	109	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	19831	110	,	,	,
18637	19831	111	the	the	DT
18637	19831	112	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	19831	113	of	of	IN
18637	19831	114	mob	mob	NN
18637	19831	115	domination	domination	NN
18637	19831	116	did	do	VBD
18637	19831	117	not	not	RB
18637	19831	118	suffice	suffice	VB
18637	19831	119	to	to	TO
18637	19831	120	void	void	VB
18637	19831	121	the	the	DT
18637	19831	122	trial	trial	NN
18637	19831	123	.	.	.
18637	19832	1	Indubitably	indubitably	RB
18637	19832	2	,	,	,
18637	19832	3	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	19832	4	_	_	NNP
18637	19832	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	19832	6	_	_	NNP
18637	19832	7	Dempsey	Dempsey	NNP
18637	19832	8	marked	mark	VBD
18637	19832	9	the	the	DT
18637	19832	10	abandonment	abandonment	NN
18637	19832	11	of	of	IN
18637	19832	12	the	the	DT
18637	19832	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19832	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19832	15	's	's	POS
18637	19832	16	deference	deference	NN
18637	19832	17	,	,	,
18637	19832	18	founded	found	VBN
18637	19832	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	19832	20	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	19832	21	of	of	IN
18637	19832	22	comity	comity	NN
18637	19832	23	,	,	,
18637	19832	24	to	to	IN
18637	19832	25	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19832	26	of	of	IN
18637	19832	27	State	State	NNP
18637	19832	28	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19832	29	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	19832	30	on	on	IN
18637	19832	31	issues	issue	NNS
18637	19832	32	of	of	IN
18637	19832	33	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	19832	34	and	and	CC
18637	19832	35	the	the	DT
18637	19832	36	proclamation	proclamation	NN
18637	19832	37	of	of	IN
18637	19832	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19832	39	intention	intention	NN
18637	19832	40	no	no	RB
18637	19832	41	longer	longer	RB
18637	19832	42	to	to	TO
18637	19832	43	treat	treat	VB
18637	19832	44	as	as	IN
18637	19832	45	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	19832	46	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	19832	47	pronouncements	pronouncement	NNS
18637	19832	48	by	by	IN
18637	19832	49	the	the	DT
18637	19832	50	latter	latter	JJ
18637	19832	51	that	that	IN
18637	19832	52	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19832	53	in	in	IN
18637	19832	54	a	a	DT
18637	19832	55	trial	trial	NN
18637	19832	56	court	court	NN
18637	19832	57	were	be	VBD
18637	19832	58	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19832	59	.	.	.
18637	19833	1	However	however	RB
18637	19833	2	,	,	,
18637	19833	3	the	the	DT
18637	19833	4	enduring	endure	VBG
18637	19833	5	character	character	NN
18637	19833	6	of	of	IN
18637	19833	7	this	this	DT
18637	19833	8	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	19833	9	was	be	VBD
18637	19833	10	depreciated	depreciate	VBN
18637	19833	11	by	by	IN
18637	19833	12	the	the	DT
18637	19833	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19833	14	's	's	POS
18637	19833	15	insistence	insistence	NN
18637	19833	16	that	that	IN
18637	19833	17	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	19833	18	_	_	NNP
18637	19833	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	19833	20	_	_	NNP
18637	19833	21	Dempsey	Dempsey	NNP
18637	19833	22	was	be	VBD
18637	19833	23	decided	decide	VBN
18637	19833	24	consistently[993	consistently[993	NNP
18637	19833	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19833	26	with	with	IN
18637	19833	27	Frank	Frank	NNP
18637	19833	28	_	_	NNP
18637	19833	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	19833	30	_	_	NNP
18637	19833	31	Mangum	Mangum	NNP
18637	19833	32	;	;	:
18637	19833	33	and	and	CC
18637	19833	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19833	35	was	be	VBD
18637	19833	36	not	not	RB
18637	19833	37	until	until	IN
18637	19833	38	the	the	DT
18637	19833	39	later	later	JJ
18637	19833	40	holding	holding	NN
18637	19833	41	in	in	IN
18637	19833	42	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	19833	43	_	_	NNP
18637	19833	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	19833	45	_	_	NNP
18637	19833	46	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	19833	47	in	in	IN
18637	19833	48	1936	1936	CD
18637	19833	49	and	and	CC
18637	19833	50	the	the	DT
18637	19833	51	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	19833	52	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19833	53	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19833	54	conformably	conformably	RB
18637	19833	55	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	19833	56	in	in	IN
18637	19833	57	the	the	DT
18637	19833	58	decade	decade	NN
18637	19833	59	following	follow	VBG
18637	19833	60	that	that	IN
18637	19833	61	all	all	DT
18637	19833	62	uncertainty	uncertainty	NN
18637	19833	63	was	be	VBD
18637	19833	64	dispelled	dispel	VBN
18637	19833	65	as	as	IN
18637	19833	66	to	to	IN
18637	19833	67	the	the	DT
18637	19833	68	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19833	69	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19833	70	's	's	POS
18637	19833	71	willingness	willingness	NN
18637	19833	72	to	to	TO
18637	19833	73	engage	engage	VB
18637	19833	74	in	in	IN
18637	19833	75	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19833	76	own	own	JJ
18637	19833	77	independent	independent	JJ
18637	19833	78	examination	examination	NN
18637	19833	79	of	of	IN
18637	19833	80	the	the	DT
18637	19833	81	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19833	82	adequacy	adequacy	NN
18637	19833	83	of	of	IN
18637	19833	84	trial	trial	NN
18637	19833	85	court	court	NN
18637	19833	86	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19833	87	.	.	.
18637	19834	1	DUE	DUE	NNP
18637	19834	2	PROCESS	PROCESS	NNP
18637	19834	3	:	:	:
18637	19834	4	MISCELLANEOUS	MISCELLANEOUS	NNP
18637	19834	5	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	19834	6	In	in	IN
18637	19834	7	every	every	DT
18637	19834	8	case	case	NN
18637	19834	9	a	a	DT
18637	19834	10	point	point	NN
18637	19834	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	19834	12	reached	reach	VBN
18637	19834	13	where	where	WRB
18637	19834	14	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	19834	15	must	must	MD
18637	19834	16	cease	cease	VB
18637	19834	17	;	;	:
18637	19834	18	and	and	CC
18637	19834	19	what	what	WP
18637	19834	20	that	that	DT
18637	19834	21	point	point	NN
18637	19834	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	19834	23	can	can	MD
18637	19834	24	best	well	RBS
18637	19834	25	be	be	VB
18637	19834	26	determined	determine	VBN
18637	19834	27	by	by	IN
18637	19834	28	the	the	DT
18637	19834	29	State	State	NNP
18637	19834	30	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	19834	31	.	.	.
18637	19835	1	The	the	DT
18637	19835	2	power	power	NN
18637	19835	3	to	to	TO
18637	19835	4	render	render	VB
18637	19835	5	a	a	DT
18637	19835	6	final	final	JJ
18637	19835	7	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19835	8	must	must	MD
18637	19835	9	be	be	VB
18637	19835	10	lodged	lodge	VBN
18637	19835	11	somewhere	somewhere	RB
18637	19835	12	;	;	:
18637	19835	13	and	and	CC
18637	19835	14	there	there	EX
18637	19835	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	19835	16	no	no	DT
18637	19835	17	provision	provision	NN
18637	19835	18	in	in	IN
18637	19835	19	the	the	DT
18637	19835	20	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	19835	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19835	22	which	which	WDT
18637	19835	23	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	19835	24	a	a	DT
18637	19835	25	State	state	NN
18637	19835	26	from	from	IN
18637	19835	27	granting	grant	VBG
18637	19835	28	to	to	IN
18637	19835	29	a	a	DT
18637	19835	30	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	19835	31	,	,	,
18637	19835	32	whether	whether	IN
18637	19835	33	called	call	VBD
18637	19835	34	a	a	DT
18637	19835	35	court	court	NN
18637	19835	36	or	or	CC
18637	19835	37	an	an	DT
18637	19835	38	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	19835	39	board	board	NN
18637	19835	40	,	,	,
18637	19835	41	the	the	DT
18637	19835	42	final	final	JJ
18637	19835	43	determination	determination	NN
18637	19835	44	of	of	IN
18637	19835	45	a	a	DT
18637	19835	46	legal	legal	JJ
18637	19835	47	question	question	NN
18637	19835	48	.	.	.
18637	19836	1	Neither	neither	CC
18637	19836	2	in	in	IN
18637	19836	3	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	19836	4	nor	nor	CC
18637	19836	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19836	6	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	19836	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	19836	8	the	the	DT
18637	19836	9	due	due	JJ
18637	19836	10	process	process	NN
18637	19836	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	19836	12	require	require	VBP
18637	19836	13	that	that	IN
18637	19836	14	the	the	DT
18637	19836	15	participants	participant	NNS
18637	19836	16	be	be	VB
18637	19836	17	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19836	18	as	as	IN
18637	19836	19	of	of	IN
18637	19836	20	right	right	NN
18637	19836	21	to	to	IN
18637	19836	22	rehearings	rehearing	NNS
18637	19836	23	,	,	,
18637	19836	24	new	new	JJ
18637	19836	25	trials	trial	NNS
18637	19836	26	,	,	,
18637	19836	27	or	or	CC
18637	19836	28	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	19836	29	.	.	.
18637	19837	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19837	2	994	994	CD
18637	19837	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19837	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	19837	5	Review	Review	NNP
18637	19837	6	of	of	IN
18637	19837	7	State	State	NNP
18637	19837	8	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	19837	9	The	the	DT
18637	19837	10	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19837	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19837	12	does	do	VBZ
18637	19837	13	not	not	RB
18637	19837	14	impair	impair	VB
18637	19837	15	the	the	DT
18637	19837	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	19837	17	of	of	IN
18637	19837	18	the	the	DT
18637	19837	19	States	States	NNPS
18637	19837	20	to	to	TO
18637	19837	21	determine	determine	VB
18637	19837	22	finally	finally	RB
18637	19837	23	,	,	,
18637	19837	24	according	accord	VBG
18637	19837	25	to	to	IN
18637	19837	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19837	27	settled	settle	VBN
18637	19837	28	usages	usage	NNS
18637	19837	29	and	and	CC
18637	19837	30	established	establish	VBD
18637	19837	31	modes	mode	NNS
18637	19837	32	of	of	IN
18637	19837	33	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19837	34	,	,	,
18637	19837	35	issues	issue	NNS
18637	19837	36	which	which	WDT
18637	19837	37	do	do	VBP
18637	19837	38	not	not	RB
18637	19837	39	involve	involve	VB
18637	19837	40	any	any	DT
18637	19837	41	right	right	JJ
18637	19837	42	secured	secure	VBN
18637	19837	43	by	by	IN
18637	19837	44	the	the	DT
18637	19837	45	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19837	46	,	,	,
18637	19837	47	an	an	DT
18637	19837	48	act	act	NN
18637	19837	49	of	of	IN
18637	19837	50	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	19837	51	,	,	,
18637	19837	52	or	or	CC
18637	19837	53	a	a	DT
18637	19837	54	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	19837	55	.	.	.
18637	19838	1	As	as	RB
18637	19838	2	long	long	RB
18637	19838	3	as	as	IN
18637	19838	4	a	a	DT
18637	19838	5	local	local	JJ
18637	19838	6	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	19838	7	acts	act	NNS
18637	19838	8	in	in	IN
18637	19838	9	consonance	consonance	NN
18637	19838	10	with	with	IN
18637	19838	11	the	the	DT
18637	19838	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19838	13	,	,	,
18637	19838	14	laws	law	NNS
18637	19838	15	and	and	CC
18637	19838	16	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19838	17	of	of	IN
18637	19838	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19838	19	own	own	JJ
18637	19838	20	State	state	NN
18637	19838	21	and	and	CC
18637	19838	22	as	as	RB
18637	19838	23	long	long	RB
18637	19838	24	as	as	IN
18637	19838	25	said	say	VBD
18637	19838	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19838	27	and	and	CC
18637	19838	28	laws	law	NNS
18637	19838	29	are	be	VBP
18637	19838	30	so	so	RB
18637	19838	31	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	19838	32	as	as	IN
18637	19838	33	not	not	RB
18637	19838	34	to	to	TO
18637	19838	35	violate	violate	VB
18637	19838	36	due	due	JJ
18637	19838	37	process	process	NN
18637	19838	38	,	,	,
18637	19838	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19838	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	19838	41	only	only	RB
18637	19838	42	in	in	IN
18637	19838	43	exceptional	exceptional	JJ
18637	19838	44	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19838	45	that	that	WDT
18637	19838	46	the	the	DT
18637	19838	47	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19838	48	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19838	49	would	would	MD
18637	19838	50	feel	feel	VB
18637	19838	51	justified	justified	JJ
18637	19838	52	in	in	IN
18637	19838	53	intervening	intervene	VBG
18637	19838	54	.	.	.
18637	19839	1	Neither	neither	CC
18637	19839	2	by	by	IN
18637	19839	3	intention	intention	NN
18637	19839	4	nor	nor	CC
18637	19839	5	by	by	IN
18637	19839	6	result	result	NN
18637	19839	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	19839	8	the	the	DT
18637	19839	9	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19839	10	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19839	11	transformed	transform	VBD
18637	19839	12	the	the	DT
18637	19839	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19839	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19839	15	into	into	IN
18637	19839	16	a	a	DT
18637	19839	17	court	court	NN
18637	19839	18	of	of	IN
18637	19839	19	general	general	JJ
18637	19839	20	review	review	NN
18637	19839	21	to	to	TO
18637	19839	22	which	which	WDT
18637	19839	23	questions	question	NNS
18637	19839	24	of	of	IN
18637	19839	25	general	general	JJ
18637	19839	26	justice	justice	NN
18637	19839	27	or	or	CC
18637	19839	28	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	19839	29	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	19839	30	arising	arise	VBG
18637	19839	31	out	out	IN
18637	19839	32	of	of	IN
18637	19839	33	the	the	DT
18637	19839	34	taking	taking	NN
18637	19839	35	of	of	IN
18637	19839	36	property	property	NN
18637	19839	37	may	may	MD
18637	19839	38	be	be	VB
18637	19839	39	brought	bring	VBN
18637	19839	40	for	for	IN
18637	19839	41	final	final	JJ
18637	19839	42	determination	determination	NN
18637	19839	43	.	.	.
18637	19840	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19840	2	995	995	CD
18637	19840	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19840	4	Insofar	insofar	RB
18637	19840	5	as	as	IN
18637	19840	6	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19840	7	irregularities	irregularity	NNS
18637	19840	8	or	or	CC
18637	19840	9	errors	error	NNS
18637	19840	10	in	in	IN
18637	19840	11	matters	matter	NNS
18637	19840	12	of	of	IN
18637	19840	13	practice	practice	NN
18637	19840	14	under	under	IN
18637	19840	15	State	state	NN
18637	19840	16	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	19840	17	do	do	VBP
18637	19840	18	not	not	RB
18637	19840	19	affect	affect	VB
18637	19840	20	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19840	21	right,[996	right,[996	NN
18637	19840	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19840	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19840	24	are	be	VBP
18637	19840	25	matters	matter	NNS
18637	19840	26	solely	solely	RB
18637	19840	27	for	for	IN
18637	19840	28	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	19840	29	by	by	IN
18637	19840	30	the	the	DT
18637	19840	31	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	19840	32	State	State	NNP
18637	19840	33	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	19840	34	.	.	.
18637	19841	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19841	2	997	997	CD
18637	19841	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19841	4	The	the	DT
18637	19841	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19841	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	19841	7	not	not	RB
18637	19841	8	guarantee	guarantee	VB
18637	19841	9	that	that	IN
18637	19841	10	the	the	DT
18637	19841	11	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19841	12	of	of	IN
18637	19841	13	State	State	NNP
18637	19841	14	courts	court	NNS
18637	19841	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	19841	16	be	be	VB
18637	19841	17	free	free	JJ
18637	19841	18	from	from	IN
18637	19841	19	error;[998	error;[998	NNPS
18637	19841	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19841	21	nor	nor	CC
18637	19841	22	does	do	VBZ
18637	19841	23	the	the	DT
18637	19841	24	due	due	JJ
18637	19841	25	process	process	NN
18637	19841	26	clause	clause	NN
18637	19841	27	give	give	VBP
18637	19841	28	the	the	DT
18637	19841	29	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19841	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19841	31	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19841	32	to	to	TO
18637	19841	33	review	review	VB
18637	19841	34	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19841	35	mistakes	mistake	NNS
18637	19841	36	of	of	IN
18637	19841	37	law	law	NN
18637	19841	38	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	19841	39	nonfederal	nonfederal	JJ
18637	19841	40	matters	matter	NNS
18637	19841	41	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	19841	42	to	to	TO
18637	19841	43	have	have	VB
18637	19841	44	been	be	VBN
18637	19841	45	committed	commit	VBN
18637	19841	46	by	by	IN
18637	19841	47	a	a	DT
18637	19841	48	State	State	NNP
18637	19841	49	court	court	NN
18637	19841	50	.	.	.
18637	19842	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19842	2	999	999	CD
18637	19842	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19842	4	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	19842	5	,	,	,
18637	19842	6	when	when	WRB
18637	19842	7	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	19842	8	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	19842	9	the	the	DT
18637	19842	10	form	form	NN
18637	19842	11	of	of	IN
18637	19842	12	the	the	DT
18637	19842	13	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	19842	14	used	use	VBN
18637	19842	15	are	be	VBP
18637	19842	16	not	not	RB
18637	19842	17	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	19842	18	violative	violative	JJ
18637	19842	19	of	of	IN
18637	19842	20	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	19842	21	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19842	22	principles	principle	NNS
18637	19842	23	,	,	,
18637	19842	24	any	any	DT
18637	19842	25	question	question	NN
18637	19842	26	as	as	IN
18637	19842	27	to	to	IN
18637	19842	28	the	the	DT
18637	19842	29	sufficiency	sufficiency	NN
18637	19842	30	of	of	IN
18637	19842	31	the	the	DT
18637	19842	32	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	19842	33	employed	employ	VBN
18637	19842	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	19842	35	for	for	IN
18637	19842	36	a	a	DT
18637	19842	37	State	State	NNP
18637	19842	38	court	court	NN
18637	19842	39	to	to	TO
18637	19842	40	determine	determine	VB
18637	19842	41	.	.	.
18637	19843	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19843	2	1000	1000	CD
18637	19843	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19843	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19843	5	,	,	,
18637	19843	6	the	the	DT
18637	19843	7	failure	failure	NN
18637	19843	8	of	of	IN
18637	19843	9	a	a	DT
18637	19843	10	State	State	NNP
18637	19843	11	to	to	TO
18637	19843	12	establish	establish	VB
18637	19843	13	a	a	DT
18637	19843	14	county	county	NN
18637	19843	15	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	19843	16	court	court	NN
18637	19843	17	as	as	IN
18637	19843	18	required	require	VBN
18637	19843	19	by	by	IN
18637	19843	20	the	the	DT
18637	19843	21	State	State	NNP
18637	19843	22	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	19843	23	can	can	MD
18637	19843	24	not	not	RB
18637	19843	25	support	support	VB
18637	19843	26	any	any	DT
18637	19843	27	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	19843	28	founded	found	VBN
18637	19843	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	19843	30	a	a	DT
18637	19843	31	denial	denial	NN
18637	19843	32	of	of	IN
18637	19843	33	due	due	JJ
18637	19843	34	process	process	NN
18637	19843	35	.	.	.
18637	19844	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19844	2	1001	1001	CD
18637	19844	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19844	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	19844	5	,	,	,
18637	19844	6	if	if	IN
18637	19844	7	a	a	DT
18637	19844	8	State	State	NNP
18637	19844	9	court	court	NN
18637	19844	10	errs	err	VBZ
18637	19844	11	in	in	IN
18637	19844	12	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	19844	13	what	what	WP
18637	19844	14	the	the	DT
18637	19844	15	common	common	JJ
18637	19844	16	law	law	NN
18637	19844	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	19844	18	,	,	,
18637	19844	19	without	without	IN
18637	19844	20	,	,	,
18637	19844	21	however	however	RB
18637	19844	22	,	,	,
18637	19844	23	denying	deny	VBG
18637	19844	24	any	any	DT
18637	19844	25	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19844	26	right	right	NN
18637	19844	27	,	,	,
18637	19844	28	the	the	DT
18637	19844	29	litigant	litigant	NN
18637	19844	30	adversely	adversely	RB
18637	19844	31	affected	affect	VBN
18637	19844	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	19844	33	not	not	RB
18637	19844	34	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	19844	35	of	of	IN
18637	19844	36	any	any	DT
18637	19844	37	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19844	38	or	or	CC
18637	19844	39	property	property	NN
18637	19844	40	without	without	IN
18637	19844	41	due	due	JJ
18637	19844	42	process	process	NN
18637	19844	43	of	of	IN
18637	19844	44	law	law	NN
18637	19844	45	.	.	.
18637	19845	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19845	2	1002	1002	CD
18637	19845	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19845	4	Also	also	RB
18637	19845	5	,	,	,
18637	19845	6	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	19845	7	a	a	DT
18637	19845	8	wrong	wrong	JJ
18637	19845	9	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19845	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	19845	11	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19845	12	,	,	,
18637	19845	13	property	property	NN
18637	19845	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19845	15	taken	take	VBN
18637	19845	16	when	when	WRB
18637	19845	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19845	18	should	should	MD
18637	19845	19	not	not	RB
18637	19845	20	have	have	VB
18637	19845	21	been	be	VBN
18637	19845	22	;	;	:
18637	19845	23	yet	yet	CC
18637	19845	24	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	19845	25	the	the	DT
18637	19845	26	ground	ground	NN
18637	19845	27	may	may	MD
18637	19845	28	be	be	VB
18637	19845	29	,	,	,
18637	19845	30	if	if	IN
18637	19845	31	the	the	DT
18637	19845	32	mistake	mistake	NN
18637	19845	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	19845	34	not	not	RB
18637	19845	35	so	so	RB
18637	19845	36	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19845	37	as	as	IN
18637	19845	38	to	to	TO
18637	19845	39	be	be	VB
18637	19845	40	impossible	impossible	JJ
18637	19845	41	in	in	IN
18637	19845	42	a	a	DT
18637	19845	43	rational	rational	JJ
18637	19845	44	administration	administration	NN
18637	19845	45	of	of	IN
18637	19845	46	justice	justice	NN
18637	19845	47	,	,	,
18637	19845	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19845	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	19845	50	no	no	DT
18637	19845	51	more	more	JJR
18637	19845	52	than	than	IN
18637	19845	53	the	the	DT
18637	19845	54	imperfection	imperfection	NN
18637	19845	55	of	of	IN
18637	19845	56	man	man	NN
18637	19845	57	,	,	,
18637	19845	58	not	not	RB
18637	19845	59	a	a	DT
18637	19845	60	denial	denial	NN
18637	19845	61	of	of	IN
18637	19845	62	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19845	63	rights	right	NNS
18637	19845	64	.	.	.
18637	19846	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19846	2	1003	1003	CD
18637	19846	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19846	4	In	in	IN
18637	19846	5	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	19846	6	,	,	,
18637	19846	7	the	the	DT
18637	19846	8	decision	decision	NN
18637	19846	9	of	of	IN
18637	19846	10	a	a	DT
18637	19846	11	State	State	NNP
18637	19846	12	court	court	NN
18637	19846	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	19846	14	a	a	DT
18637	19846	15	question	question	NN
18637	19846	16	of	of	IN
18637	19846	17	local	local	JJ
18637	19846	18	law	law	NN
18637	19846	19	,	,	,
18637	19846	20	however	however	RB
18637	19846	21	wrong	wrong	JJ
18637	19846	22	,	,	,
18637	19846	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	19846	24	not	not	RB
18637	19846	25	an	an	DT
18637	19846	26	infraction	infraction	NN
18637	19846	27	of	of	IN
18637	19846	28	the	the	DT
18637	19846	29	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19846	30	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19846	31	merely	merely	RB
18637	19846	32	because	because	IN
18637	19846	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19846	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	19846	35	wrong	wrong	JJ
18637	19846	36	.	.	.
18637	19847	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19847	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	19847	3	not	not	RB
18637	19847	4	for	for	IN
18637	19847	5	the	the	DT
18637	19847	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19847	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19847	8	to	to	TO
18637	19847	9	determine	determine	VB
18637	19847	10	whether	whether	IN
18637	19847	11	there	there	EX
18637	19847	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	19847	13	been	be	VBN
18637	19847	14	an	an	DT
18637	19847	15	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
18637	19847	16	construction	construction	NN
18637	19847	17	of	of	IN
18637	19847	18	a	a	DT
18637	19847	19	State	State	NNP
18637	19847	20	statute	statute	NN
18637	19847	21	or	or	CC
18637	19847	22	the	the	DT
18637	19847	23	common	common	JJ
18637	19847	24	law	law	NN
18637	19847	25	;	;	:
18637	19847	26	nor	nor	CC
18637	19847	27	does	do	VBZ
18637	19847	28	the	the	DT
18637	19847	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19847	30	impose	impose	VB
18637	19847	31	any	any	DT
18637	19847	32	impediment	impediment	NN
18637	19847	33	to	to	IN
18637	19847	34	the	the	DT
18637	19847	35	correction	correction	NN
18637	19847	36	or	or	CC
18637	19847	37	modification	modification	NN
18637	19847	38	by	by	IN
18637	19847	39	a	a	DT
18637	19847	40	State	State	NNP
18637	19847	41	court	court	NN
18637	19847	42	of	of	IN
18637	19847	43	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
18637	19847	44	or	or	CC
18637	19847	45	older	old	JJR
18637	19847	46	constructions	construction	NNS
18637	19847	47	of	of	IN
18637	19847	48	local	local	JJ
18637	19847	49	law	law	NN
18637	19847	50	embraced	embrace	VBN
18637	19847	51	in	in	IN
18637	19847	52	previous	previous	JJ
18637	19847	53	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19847	54	.	.	.
18637	19848	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19848	2	1004	1004	CD
18637	19848	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19848	4	Equal	Equal	NNP
18637	19848	5	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	19848	6	of	of	IN
18637	19848	7	the	the	DT
18637	19848	8	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	19848	9	DEFINITIONS	definition	NNS
18637	19848	10	OF	of	IN
18637	19848	11	TERMS	term	NNS
18637	19848	12	What	what	WP
18637	19848	13	Constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	19848	14	State	State	NNP
18637	19848	15	Action	Action	NNP
18637	19848	16	The	the	DT
18637	19848	17	inhibition	inhibition	NN
18637	19848	18	against	against	IN
18637	19848	19	denial	denial	NN
18637	19848	20	of	of	IN
18637	19848	21	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19848	22	protection	protection	NN
18637	19848	23	of	of	IN
18637	19848	24	the	the	DT
18637	19848	25	laws	law	NNS
18637	19848	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	19848	27	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	19848	28	reference	reference	NN
18637	19848	29	to	to	IN
18637	19848	30	State	state	NN
18637	19848	31	action	action	NN
18637	19848	32	.	.	.
18637	19849	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19849	2	means	mean	VBZ
18637	19849	3	that	that	IN
18637	19849	4	no	no	DT
18637	19849	5	agency	agency	NN
18637	19849	6	of	of	IN
18637	19849	7	the	the	DT
18637	19849	8	State	State	NNP
18637	19849	9	,	,	,
18637	19849	10	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	19849	11	,	,	,
18637	19849	12	executive	executive	JJ
18637	19849	13	or	or	CC
18637	19849	14	judicial,[1005	judicial,[1005	NNP
18637	19849	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19849	16	no	no	DT
18637	19849	17	instrumentality	instrumentality	NN
18637	19849	18	of	of	IN
18637	19849	19	the	the	DT
18637	19849	20	State	State	NNP
18637	19849	21	,	,	,
18637	19849	22	and	and	CC
18637	19849	23	no	no	DT
18637	19849	24	person	person	NN
18637	19849	25	,	,	,
18637	19849	26	officer	officer	NN
18637	19849	27	or	or	CC
18637	19849	28	agent	agent	NN
18637	19849	29	exerting	exert	VBG
18637	19849	30	the	the	DT
18637	19849	31	power	power	NN
18637	19849	32	of	of	IN
18637	19849	33	the	the	DT
18637	19849	34	State	State	NNP
18637	19849	35	shall	shall	MD
18637	19849	36	deny	deny	VB
18637	19849	37	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19849	38	protection	protection	NN
18637	19849	39	to	to	IN
18637	19849	40	any	any	DT
18637	19849	41	person	person	NN
18637	19849	42	within	within	IN
18637	19849	43	the	the	DT
18637	19849	44	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19849	45	of	of	IN
18637	19849	46	the	the	DT
18637	19849	47	State	State	NNP
18637	19849	48	.	.	.
18637	19850	1	The	the	DT
18637	19850	2	clause	clause	NN
18637	19850	3	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	19850	4	"	"	``
18637	19850	5	discriminating	discriminating	JJ
18637	19850	6	and	and	CC
18637	19850	7	partial	partial	JJ
18637	19850	8	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19850	9	*	*	NFP
18637	19850	10	*	*	NFP
18637	19850	11	*	*	NFP
18637	19850	12	in	in	IN
18637	19850	13	favor	favor	NN
18637	19850	14	of	of	IN
18637	19850	15	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19850	16	persons	person	NNS
18637	19850	17	as	as	IN
18637	19850	18	against	against	IN
18637	19850	19	others	other	NNS
18637	19850	20	in	in	IN
18637	19850	21	like	like	IN
18637	19850	22	condition	condition	NN
18637	19850	23	.	.	.
18637	19851	1	"	"	``
18637	19851	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19851	3	1006	1006	CD
18637	19851	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19851	5	But	but	CC
18637	19851	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19851	7	also	also	RB
18637	19851	8	has	have	VBZ
18637	19851	9	reference	reference	NN
18637	19851	10	to	to	IN
18637	19851	11	the	the	DT
18637	19851	12	way	way	NN
18637	19851	13	the	the	DT
18637	19851	14	law	law	NN
18637	19851	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	19851	16	administered	administer	VBN
18637	19851	17	.	.	.
18637	19852	1	"	"	``
18637	19852	2	Though	though	IN
18637	19852	3	the	the	DT
18637	19852	4	law	law	NN
18637	19852	5	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19852	6	be	be	VB
18637	19852	7	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19852	8	on	on	IN
18637	19852	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19852	10	face	face	NN
18637	19852	11	and	and	CC
18637	19852	12	impartial	impartial	JJ
18637	19852	13	in	in	IN
18637	19852	14	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	19852	15	,	,	,
18637	19852	16	yet	yet	RB
18637	19852	17	,	,	,
18637	19852	18	if	if	IN
18637	19852	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19852	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	19852	21	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19852	22	and	and	CC
18637	19852	23	administered	administer	VBN
18637	19852	24	by	by	IN
18637	19852	25	public	public	JJ
18637	19852	26	authority	authority	NN
18637	19852	27	with	with	IN
18637	19852	28	an	an	DT
18637	19852	29	evil	evil	JJ
18637	19852	30	eye	eye	NN
18637	19852	31	and	and	CC
18637	19852	32	an	an	DT
18637	19852	33	unequal	unequal	JJ
18637	19852	34	hand	hand	NN
18637	19852	35	,	,	,
18637	19852	36	so	so	IN
18637	19852	37	as	as	IN
18637	19852	38	practically	practically	RB
18637	19852	39	to	to	TO
18637	19852	40	make	make	VB
18637	19852	41	unjust	unjust	JJ
18637	19852	42	and	and	CC
18637	19852	43	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	19852	44	discriminations	discrimination	NNS
18637	19852	45	between	between	IN
18637	19852	46	persons	person	NNS
18637	19852	47	in	in	IN
18637	19852	48	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19852	49	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19852	50	,	,	,
18637	19852	51	material	material	NN
18637	19852	52	to	to	IN
18637	19852	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19852	54	rights	right	NNS
18637	19852	55	,	,	,
18637	19852	56	the	the	DT
18637	19852	57	denial	denial	NN
18637	19852	58	of	of	IN
18637	19852	59	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19852	60	justice	justice	NN
18637	19852	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	19852	62	still	still	RB
18637	19852	63	within	within	IN
18637	19852	64	the	the	DT
18637	19852	65	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	19852	66	of	of	IN
18637	19852	67	the	the	DT
18637	19852	68	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19852	69	.	.	.
18637	19853	1	"	"	``
18637	19853	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19853	3	1007	1007	CD
18637	19853	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19853	5	This	this	DT
18637	19853	6	was	be	VBD
18637	19853	7	said	say	VBN
18637	19853	8	in	in	IN
18637	19853	9	a	a	DT
18637	19853	10	case	case	NN
18637	19853	11	where	where	WRB
18637	19853	12	a	a	DT
18637	19853	13	Chinese	chinese	JJ
18637	19853	14	subject	subject	NN
18637	19853	15	had	have	VBD
18637	19853	16	been	be	VBN
18637	19853	17	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	19853	18	of	of	IN
18637	19853	19	operating	operate	VBG
18637	19853	20	a	a	DT
18637	19853	21	laundry	laundry	NN
18637	19853	22	in	in	IN
18637	19853	23	violation	violation	NN
18637	19853	24	of	of	IN
18637	19853	25	a	a	DT
18637	19853	26	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	19853	27	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	19853	28	which	which	WDT
18637	19853	29	made	make	VBD
18637	19853	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19853	31	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	19853	32	to	to	TO
18637	19853	33	engage	engage	VB
18637	19853	34	in	in	IN
18637	19853	35	such	such	JJ
18637	19853	36	business	business	NN
18637	19853	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19853	38	except	except	IN
18637	19853	39	in	in	IN
18637	19853	40	a	a	DT
18637	19853	41	building	building	NN
18637	19853	42	constructed	construct	VBN
18637	19853	43	of	of	IN
18637	19853	44	brick	brick	NN
18637	19853	45	or	or	CC
18637	19853	46	stone	stone	NN
18637	19853	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19853	48	without	without	IN
18637	19853	49	the	the	DT
18637	19853	50	consent	consent	NN
18637	19853	51	of	of	IN
18637	19853	52	the	the	DT
18637	19853	53	board	board	NN
18637	19853	54	of	of	IN
18637	19853	55	supervisors	supervisors	NNPS
18637	19853	56	.	.	.
18637	19854	1	Permission	permission	NN
18637	19854	2	had	have	VBD
18637	19854	3	been	be	VBN
18637	19854	4	withheld	withhold	VBN
18637	19854	5	from	from	IN
18637	19854	6	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	19854	7	and	and	CC
18637	19854	8	200	200	CD
18637	19854	9	other	other	JJ
18637	19854	10	Chinese	chinese	JJ
18637	19854	11	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	19854	12	but	but	CC
18637	19854	13	had	have	VBD
18637	19854	14	been	be	VBN
18637	19854	15	granted	grant	VBN
18637	19854	16	to	to	IN
18637	19854	17	80	80	CD
18637	19854	18	others	other	NNS
18637	19854	19	to	to	TO
18637	19854	20	carry	carry	VB
18637	19854	21	on	on	RP
18637	19854	22	the	the	DT
18637	19854	23	same	same	JJ
18637	19854	24	business	business	NN
18637	19854	25	under	under	IN
18637	19854	26	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19854	27	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19854	28	.	.	.
18637	19855	1	This	this	DT
18637	19855	2	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19855	3	solely	solely	RB
18637	19855	4	on	on	IN
18637	19855	5	the	the	DT
18637	19855	6	basis	basis	NN
18637	19855	7	of	of	IN
18637	19855	8	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	19855	9	was	be	VBD
18637	19855	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	19855	11	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	19855	12	.	.	.
18637	19856	1	For	for	IN
18637	19856	2	an	an	DT
18637	19856	3	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	19856	4	administration	administration	NN
18637	19856	5	of	of	IN
18637	19856	6	a	a	DT
18637	19856	7	valid	valid	JJ
18637	19856	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	19856	9	to	to	TO
18637	19856	10	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	19856	11	a	a	DT
18637	19856	12	violation	violation	NN
18637	19856	13	of	of	IN
18637	19856	14	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19856	15	rights	right	NNS
18637	19856	16	,	,	,
18637	19856	17	purposeful	purposeful	JJ
18637	19856	18	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19856	19	must	must	MD
18637	19856	20	be	be	VB
18637	19856	21	shown	show	VBN
18637	19856	22	.	.	.
18637	19857	1	An	an	DT
18637	19857	2	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
18637	19857	3	performance	performance	NN
18637	19857	4	of	of	IN
18637	19857	5	a	a	DT
18637	19857	6	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	19857	7	duty	duty	NN
18637	19857	8	,	,	,
18637	19857	9	although	although	IN
18637	19857	10	a	a	DT
18637	19857	11	violation	violation	NN
18637	19857	12	of	of	IN
18637	19857	13	the	the	DT
18637	19857	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	19857	15	,	,	,
18637	19857	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	19857	17	not	not	RB
18637	19857	18	without	without	IN
18637	19857	19	more	more	JJR
18637	19857	20	a	a	DT
18637	19857	21	denial	denial	NN
18637	19857	22	of	of	IN
18637	19857	23	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19857	24	protection	protection	NN
18637	19857	25	of	of	IN
18637	19857	26	the	the	DT
18637	19857	27	laws	law	NNS
18637	19857	28	.	.	.
18637	19858	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19858	2	1008	1008	CD
18637	19858	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19858	4	This	this	DT
18637	19858	5	clause	clause	NN
18637	19858	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19858	7	also	also	RB
18637	19858	8	violated	violate	VBN
18637	19858	9	by	by	IN
18637	19858	10	the	the	DT
18637	19858	11	withholding	withholding	NN
18637	19858	12	of	of	IN
18637	19858	13	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19858	14	access	access	NN
18637	19858	15	to	to	IN
18637	19858	16	the	the	DT
18637	19858	17	courts,[1009	courts,[1009	NNP
18637	19858	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19858	19	or	or	CC
18637	19858	20	by	by	IN
18637	19858	21	inequality	inequality	NN
18637	19858	22	of	of	IN
18637	19858	23	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	19858	24	in	in	IN
18637	19858	25	the	the	DT
18637	19858	26	courts	court	NNS
18637	19858	27	.	.	.
18637	19859	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19859	2	1010	1010	CD
18637	19859	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19859	4	In	in	IN
18637	19859	5	Shelley	Shelley	NNP
18637	19859	6	_	_	NNP
18637	19859	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	19859	8	_	_	NNP
18637	19859	9	Kraemer[1011	Kraemer[1011	NNP
18637	19859	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19859	11	the	the	DT
18637	19859	12	use	use	NN
18637	19859	13	of	of	IN
18637	19859	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19859	15	power	power	NN
18637	19859	16	to	to	TO
18637	19859	17	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	19859	18	private	private	JJ
18637	19859	19	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	19859	20	of	of	IN
18637	19859	21	a	a	DT
18637	19859	22	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	19859	23	character	character	NN
18637	19859	24	was	be	VBD
18637	19859	25	held	hold	VBN
18637	19859	26	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19859	27	.	.	.
18637	19860	1	Holding	hold	VBG
18637	19860	2	that	that	IN
18637	19860	3	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	19860	4	covenants	covenant	NNS
18637	19860	5	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	19860	6	the	the	DT
18637	19860	7	sale	sale	NN
18637	19860	8	of	of	IN
18637	19860	9	homes	home	NNS
18637	19860	10	to	to	IN
18637	19860	11	Negroes	negro	NNS
18637	19860	12	could	could	MD
18637	19860	13	not	not	RB
18637	19860	14	be	be	VB
18637	19860	15	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	19860	16	in	in	IN
18637	19860	17	the	the	DT
18637	19860	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	19860	19	,	,	,
18637	19860	20	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	19860	21	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19860	22	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	19860	23	said	say	VBD
18637	19860	24	:	:	:
18637	19860	25	"	"	``
18637	19860	26	These	these	DT
18637	19860	27	are	be	VBP
18637	19860	28	not	not	RB
18637	19860	29	cases	case	NNS
18637	19860	30	,	,	,
18637	19860	31	as	as	IN
18637	19860	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	19860	33	been	be	VBN
18637	19860	34	suggested	suggest	VBN
18637	19860	35	,	,	,
18637	19860	36	in	in	IN
18637	19860	37	which	which	WDT
18637	19860	38	the	the	DT
18637	19860	39	States	States	NNPS
18637	19860	40	have	have	VBP
18637	19860	41	merely	merely	RB
18637	19860	42	abstained	abstain	VBN
18637	19860	43	from	from	IN
18637	19860	44	action	action	NN
18637	19860	45	,	,	,
18637	19860	46	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	19860	47	private	private	JJ
18637	19860	48	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	19860	49	free	free	JJ
18637	19860	50	to	to	TO
18637	19860	51	impose	impose	VB
18637	19860	52	such	such	JJ
18637	19860	53	discriminations	discrimination	NNS
18637	19860	54	as	as	IN
18637	19860	55	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19860	56	see	see	VBP
18637	19860	57	fit	fit	JJ
18637	19860	58	.	.	.
18637	19861	1	Rather	rather	RB
18637	19861	2	,	,	,
18637	19861	3	these	these	DT
18637	19861	4	are	be	VBP
18637	19861	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	19861	6	in	in	IN
18637	19861	7	which	which	WDT
18637	19861	8	the	the	DT
18637	19861	9	States	state	NNS
18637	19861	10	have	have	VBP
18637	19861	11	made	make	VBN
18637	19861	12	available	available	JJ
18637	19861	13	to	to	IN
18637	19861	14	such	such	JJ
18637	19861	15	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	19861	16	the	the	DT
18637	19861	17	full	full	JJ
18637	19861	18	coercive	coercive	JJ
18637	19861	19	power	power	NN
18637	19861	20	of	of	IN
18637	19861	21	government	government	NN
18637	19861	22	to	to	TO
18637	19861	23	deny	deny	VB
18637	19861	24	to	to	IN
18637	19861	25	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	19861	26	,	,	,
18637	19861	27	on	on	IN
18637	19861	28	the	the	DT
18637	19861	29	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	19861	30	of	of	IN
18637	19861	31	race	race	NN
18637	19861	32	or	or	CC
18637	19861	33	color	color	NN
18637	19861	34	,	,	,
18637	19861	35	the	the	DT
18637	19861	36	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	19861	37	of	of	IN
18637	19861	38	property	property	NN
18637	19861	39	rights	right	NNS
18637	19861	40	in	in	IN
18637	19861	41	premises	premise	NNS
18637	19861	42	which	which	WDT
18637	19861	43	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	19861	44	are	be	VBP
18637	19861	45	willing	willing	JJ
18637	19861	46	and	and	CC
18637	19861	47	financially	financially	RB
18637	19861	48	able	able	JJ
18637	19861	49	to	to	TO
18637	19861	50	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	19861	51	and	and	CC
18637	19861	52	which	which	WDT
18637	19861	53	the	the	DT
18637	19861	54	grantors	grantor	NNS
18637	19861	55	are	be	VBP
18637	19861	56	willing	willing	JJ
18637	19861	57	to	to	TO
18637	19861	58	sell	sell	VB
18637	19861	59	.	.	.
18637	19862	1	The	the	DT
18637	19862	2	difference	difference	NN
18637	19862	3	between	between	IN
18637	19862	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	19862	5	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	19862	6	and	and	CC
18637	19862	7	nonenforcement	nonenforcement	NN
18637	19862	8	of	of	IN
18637	19862	9	the	the	DT
18637	19862	10	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	19862	11	covenants	covenant	NNS
18637	19862	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	19862	13	the	the	DT
18637	19862	14	difference	difference	NN
18637	19862	15	to	to	IN
18637	19862	16	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
18637	19862	17	between	between	IN
18637	19862	18	being	be	VBG
18637	19862	19	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19862	20	rights	right	NNS
18637	19862	21	of	of	IN
18637	19862	22	property	property	NN
18637	19862	23	available	available	JJ
18637	19862	24	to	to	IN
18637	19862	25	other	other	JJ
18637	19862	26	members	member	NNS
18637	19862	27	of	of	IN
18637	19862	28	the	the	DT
18637	19862	29	community	community	NN
18637	19862	30	and	and	CC
18637	19862	31	being	be	VBG
18637	19862	32	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	19862	33	full	full	JJ
18637	19862	34	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	19862	35	of	of	IN
18637	19862	36	those	those	DT
18637	19862	37	rights	right	NNS
18637	19862	38	on	on	IN
18637	19862	39	an	an	DT
18637	19862	40	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19862	41	footing	footing	NN
18637	19862	42	.	.	.
18637	19863	1	"	"	``
18637	19863	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19863	3	1012	1012	CD
18637	19863	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19863	5	The	the	DT
18637	19863	6	action	action	NN
18637	19863	7	of	of	IN
18637	19863	8	the	the	DT
18637	19863	9	curators	curator	NNS
18637	19863	10	of	of	IN
18637	19863	11	a	a	DT
18637	19863	12	state	state	NN
18637	19863	13	university	university	NN
18637	19863	14	in	in	IN
18637	19863	15	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	19863	16	admission	admission	NN
18637	19863	17	to	to	IN
18637	19863	18	an	an	DT
18637	19863	19	applicant	applicant	NN
18637	19863	20	on	on	IN
18637	19863	21	account	account	NN
18637	19863	22	of	of	IN
18637	19863	23	race	race	NN
18637	19863	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	19863	25	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	19863	26	as	as	IN
18637	19863	27	State	State	NNP
18637	19863	28	action	action	NN
18637	19863	29	.	.	.
18637	19864	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19864	2	1013	1013	CD
18637	19864	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19864	4	A	a	DT
18637	19864	5	State	state	NN
18637	19864	6	can	can	MD
18637	19864	7	not	not	RB
18637	19864	8	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	19864	9	the	the	DT
18637	19864	10	impact	impact	NN
18637	19864	11	of	of	IN
18637	19864	12	the	the	DT
18637	19864	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	19864	14	by	by	IN
18637	19864	15	the	the	DT
18637	19864	16	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	19864	17	of	of	IN
18637	19864	18	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	19864	19	to	to	IN
18637	19864	20	a	a	DT
18637	19864	21	private	private	JJ
18637	19864	22	body	body	NN
18637	19864	23	.	.	.
18637	19865	1	After	after	IN
18637	19865	2	a	a	DT
18637	19865	3	period	period	NN
18637	19865	4	of	of	IN
18637	19865	5	vacillation	vacillation	NN
18637	19865	6	,	,	,
18637	19865	7	the	the	DT
18637	19865	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19865	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19865	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	19865	11	determined	determine	VBN
18637	19865	12	that	that	IN
18637	19865	13	the	the	DT
18637	19865	14	action	action	NN
18637	19865	15	of	of	IN
18637	19865	16	a	a	DT
18637	19865	17	political	political	JJ
18637	19865	18	party	party	NN
18637	19865	19	in	in	IN
18637	19865	20	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	19865	21	Negroes	Negroes	NNP
18637	19865	22	from	from	IN
18637	19865	23	membership	membership	NN
18637	19865	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	19865	25	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	19865	26	when	when	WRB
18637	19865	27	such	such	JJ
18637	19865	28	membership	membership	NN
18637	19865	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	19865	30	an	an	DT
18637	19865	31	essential	essential	JJ
18637	19865	32	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	19865	33	for	for	IN
18637	19865	34	voting	voting	NN
18637	19865	35	in	in	IN
18637	19865	36	a	a	DT
18637	19865	37	primary	primary	NN
18637	19865	38	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	19865	39	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	19865	40	to	to	IN
18637	19865	41	State	State	NNP
18637	19865	42	law	law	NN
18637	19865	43	.	.	.
18637	19866	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19866	2	1014	1014	CD
18637	19866	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19866	4	"	"	``
18637	19866	5	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	19866	6	"	"	''
18637	19866	7	In	in	IN
18637	19866	8	the	the	DT
18637	19866	9	case	case	NN
18637	19866	10	in	in	IN
18637	19866	11	which	which	WDT
18637	19866	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19866	13	was	be	VBD
18637	19866	14	first	first	RB
18637	19866	15	called	call	VBN
18637	19866	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	19866	17	to	to	TO
18637	19866	18	interpret	interpret	VB
18637	19866	19	this	this	DT
18637	19866	20	clause	clause	NN
18637	19866	21	the	the	DT
18637	19866	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19866	23	expressed	express	VBD
18637	19866	24	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	19866	25	whether	whether	IN
18637	19866	26	"	"	``
18637	19866	27	any	any	DT
18637	19866	28	action	action	NN
18637	19866	29	of	of	IN
18637	19866	30	a	a	DT
18637	19866	31	State	State	NNP
18637	19866	32	not	not	RB
18637	19866	33	directed	direct	VBN
18637	19866	34	by	by	IN
18637	19866	35	way	way	NN
18637	19866	36	of	of	IN
18637	19866	37	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19866	38	against	against	IN
18637	19866	39	the	the	DT
18637	19866	40	Negroes	Negroes	NNPS
18637	19866	41	as	as	IN
18637	19866	42	a	a	DT
18637	19866	43	class	class	NN
18637	19866	44	,	,	,
18637	19866	45	or	or	CC
18637	19866	46	on	on	IN
18637	19866	47	account	account	NN
18637	19866	48	of	of	IN
18637	19866	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19866	50	race	race	NN
18637	19866	51	,	,	,
18637	19866	52	will	will	MD
18637	19866	53	ever	ever	RB
18637	19866	54	be	be	VB
18637	19866	55	held	hold	VBN
18637	19866	56	to	to	TO
18637	19866	57	come	come	VB
18637	19866	58	within	within	IN
18637	19866	59	the	the	DT
18637	19866	60	purview	purview	NN
18637	19866	61	of	of	IN
18637	19866	62	this	this	DT
18637	19866	63	provision	provision	NN
18637	19866	64	.	.	.
18637	19867	1	"	"	``
18637	19867	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19867	3	1015	1015	CD
18637	19867	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19867	5	That	that	DT
18637	19867	6	view	view	NN
18637	19867	7	was	be	VBD
18637	19867	8	soon	soon	RB
18637	19867	9	abandoned	abandon	VBN
18637	19867	10	.	.	.
18637	19868	1	In	in	IN
18637	19868	2	1877	1877	CD
18637	19868	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19868	4	took	take	VBD
18637	19868	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19868	6	of	of	IN
18637	19868	7	a	a	DT
18637	19868	8	series	series	NN
18637	19868	9	of	of	IN
18637	19868	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	19868	11	,	,	,
18637	19868	12	popularly	popularly	RB
18637	19868	13	known	know	VBN
18637	19868	14	as	as	IN
18637	19868	15	the	the	DT
18637	19868	16	Granger	Granger	NNP
18637	19868	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	19868	18	,	,	,
18637	19868	19	in	in	IN
18637	19868	20	which	which	WDT
18637	19868	21	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19868	22	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19868	23	sought	seek	VBD
18637	19868	24	protection	protection	NN
18637	19868	25	under	under	IN
18637	19868	26	the	the	DT
18637	19868	27	due	due	JJ
18637	19868	28	process	process	NN
18637	19868	29	and	and	CC
18637	19868	30	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19868	31	protection	protection	NN
18637	19868	32	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	19868	33	.	.	.
18637	19869	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19869	2	1016	1016	CD
18637	19869	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19869	4	Although	although	IN
18637	19869	5	every	every	DT
18637	19869	6	case	case	NN
18637	19869	7	was	be	VBD
18637	19869	8	decided	decide	VBN
18637	19869	9	against	against	IN
18637	19869	10	the	the	DT
18637	19869	11	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19869	12	on	on	IN
18637	19869	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19869	14	merits	merit	NNS
18637	19869	15	,	,	,
18637	19869	16	there	there	EX
18637	19869	17	was	be	VBD
18637	19869	18	no	no	DT
18637	19869	19	expression	expression	NN
18637	19869	20	of	of	IN
18637	19869	21	any	any	DT
18637	19869	22	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	19869	23	that	that	IN
18637	19869	24	the	the	DT
18637	19869	25	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19869	26	were	be	VBD
18637	19869	27	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19869	28	to	to	TO
18637	19869	29	invoke	invoke	VB
18637	19869	30	the	the	DT
18637	19869	31	protection	protection	NN
18637	19869	32	of	of	IN
18637	19869	33	the	the	DT
18637	19869	34	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	19869	35	.	.	.
18637	19870	1	Nine	nine	CD
18637	19870	2	years	year	NNS
18637	19870	3	later	later	RB
18637	19870	4	the	the	DT
18637	19870	5	issue	issue	NN
18637	19870	6	was	be	VBD
18637	19870	7	settled	settle	VBN
18637	19870	8	definitely	definitely	RB
18637	19870	9	by	by	IN
18637	19870	10	an	an	DT
18637	19870	11	announcement	announcement	NN
18637	19870	12	from	from	IN
18637	19870	13	the	the	DT
18637	19870	14	bench	bench	NN
18637	19870	15	by	by	IN
18637	19870	16	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	19870	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19870	18	Waite	Waite	NNP
18637	19870	19	that	that	IN
18637	19870	20	the	the	DT
18637	19870	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19870	22	would	would	MD
18637	19870	23	not	not	RB
18637	19870	24	hear	hear	VB
18637	19870	25	argument	argument	NN
18637	19870	26	on	on	IN
18637	19870	27	the	the	DT
18637	19870	28	question	question	NN
18637	19870	29	whether	whether	IN
18637	19870	30	the	the	DT
18637	19870	31	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19870	32	protection	protection	NN
18637	19870	33	clause	clause	NN
18637	19870	34	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	19870	35	to	to	IN
18637	19870	36	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19870	37	,	,	,
18637	19870	38	adding	add	VBG
18637	19870	39	:	:	:
18637	19870	40	"	"	``
18637	19870	41	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19870	42	are	be	VBP
18637	19870	43	all	all	DT
18637	19870	44	of	of	IN
18637	19870	45	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	19870	46	that	that	IN
18637	19870	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19870	48	does	do	VBZ
18637	19870	49	.	.	.
18637	19871	1	"	"	``
18637	19871	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19871	3	1017	1017	CD
18637	19871	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19871	5	At	at	IN
18637	19871	6	the	the	DT
18637	19871	7	same	same	JJ
18637	19871	8	term	term	NN
18637	19871	9	the	the	DT
18637	19871	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19871	11	gave	give	VBD
18637	19871	12	the	the	DT
18637	19871	13	broadest	broad	JJS
18637	19871	14	possible	possible	JJ
18637	19871	15	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	19871	16	to	to	IN
18637	19871	17	the	the	DT
18637	19871	18	word	word	NN
18637	19871	19	"	"	``
18637	19871	20	person	person	NN
18637	19871	21	"	"	''
18637	19871	22	;	;	:
18637	19871	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19871	24	held	hold	VBD
18637	19871	25	that	that	DT
18637	19871	26	:	:	:
18637	19871	27	"	"	``
18637	19871	28	These	these	DT
18637	19871	29	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	19871	30	are	be	VBP
18637	19871	31	universal	universal	JJ
18637	19871	32	in	in	IN
18637	19871	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19871	34	application	application	NN
18637	19871	35	,	,	,
18637	19871	36	to	to	IN
18637	19871	37	all	all	DT
18637	19871	38	persons	person	NNS
18637	19871	39	within	within	IN
18637	19871	40	the	the	DT
18637	19871	41	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	19871	42	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19871	43	,	,	,
18637	19871	44	without	without	IN
18637	19871	45	regard	regard	NN
18637	19871	46	to	to	IN
18637	19871	47	any	any	DT
18637	19871	48	differences	difference	NNS
18637	19871	49	of	of	IN
18637	19871	50	race	race	NN
18637	19871	51	,	,	,
18637	19871	52	of	of	IN
18637	19871	53	color	color	NN
18637	19871	54	,	,	,
18637	19871	55	or	or	CC
18637	19871	56	of	of	IN
18637	19871	57	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	19871	58	;	;	,
18637	19871	59	*	*	NFP
18637	19871	60	*	*	NFP
18637	19871	61	*	*	NFP
18637	19871	62	"	"	''
18637	19871	63	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19871	64	1018	1018	CD
18637	19871	65	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19871	66	The	the	DT
18637	19871	67	only	only	JJ
18637	19871	68	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	19871	69	of	of	IN
18637	19871	70	the	the	DT
18637	19871	71	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	19871	72	of	of	IN
18637	19871	73	"	"	``
18637	19871	74	person	person	NN
18637	19871	75	"	"	''
18637	19871	76	is	be	VBZ
18637	19871	77	that	that	DT
18637	19871	78	introduced	introduce	VBN
18637	19871	79	by	by	IN
18637	19871	80	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	19871	81	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19871	82	holding	hold	VBG
18637	19871	83	that	that	IN
18637	19871	84	a	a	DT
18637	19871	85	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	19871	86	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19871	87	can	can	MD
18637	19871	88	not	not	RB
18637	19871	89	invoke	invoke	VB
18637	19871	90	the	the	DT
18637	19871	91	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	19871	92	against	against	IN
18637	19871	93	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19871	94	State	State	NNP
18637	19871	95	.	.	.
18637	19872	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19872	2	1019	1019	CD
18637	19872	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19872	4	"	"	``
18637	19872	5	Within	within	IN
18637	19872	6	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19872	7	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	19872	8	"	"	``
18637	19872	9	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19872	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	19872	11	persons	person	NNS
18637	19872	12	"	"	''
18637	19872	13	within	within	IN
18637	19872	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19872	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19872	16	"	"	''
18637	19872	17	that	that	WDT
18637	19872	18	are	be	VBP
18637	19872	19	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19872	20	to	to	TO
18637	19872	21	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19872	22	protection	protection	NN
18637	19872	23	from	from	IN
18637	19872	24	a	a	DT
18637	19872	25	State	state	NN
18637	19872	26	.	.	.
18637	19873	1	Largely	largely	RB
18637	19873	2	because	because	IN
18637	19873	3	article	article	NN
18637	19873	4	IV	IV	NNP
18637	19873	5	,	,	,
18637	19873	6	section	section	NN
18637	19873	7	2	2	CD
18637	19873	8	,	,	,
18637	19873	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	19873	10	from	from	IN
18637	19873	11	the	the	DT
18637	19873	12	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	19873	13	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19873	14	"	"	``
18637	19873	15	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	19873	16	of	of	IN
18637	19873	17	each	each	DT
18637	19873	18	State	state	NN
18637	19873	19	"	"	''
18637	19873	20	to	to	IN
18637	19873	21	the	the	DT
18637	19873	22	"	"	``
18637	19873	23	Privileges	Privileges	NNPS
18637	19873	24	and	and	CC
18637	19873	25	Immunities	Immunities	NNPS
18637	19873	26	of	of	IN
18637	19873	27	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	19873	28	in	in	IN
18637	19873	29	the	the	DT
18637	19873	30	several	several	JJ
18637	19873	31	States	state	NNS
18637	19873	32	,	,	,
18637	19873	33	"	"	''
18637	19873	34	the	the	DT
18637	19873	35	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19873	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	19873	37	never	never	RB
18637	19873	38	construed	construe	VBN
18637	19873	39	the	the	DT
18637	19873	40	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	19873	41	,	,	,
18637	19873	42	"	"	``
18637	19873	43	within	within	IN
18637	19873	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19873	45	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19873	46	,	,	,
18637	19873	47	"	"	''
18637	19873	48	in	in	IN
18637	19873	49	relation	relation	NN
18637	19873	50	to	to	IN
18637	19873	51	natural	natural	JJ
18637	19873	52	persons	person	NNS
18637	19873	53	.	.	.
18637	19874	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19874	2	1020	1020	CD
18637	19874	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19874	4	The	the	DT
18637	19874	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	19874	6	interpretive	interpretive	JJ
18637	19874	7	of	of	IN
18637	19874	8	this	this	DT
18637	19874	9	expression	expression	NN
18637	19874	10	consequently	consequently	RB
18637	19874	11	all	all	DT
18637	19874	12	concern	concern	NN
18637	19874	13	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19874	14	.	.	.
18637	19875	1	In	in	IN
18637	19875	2	1898	1898	CD
18637	19875	3	,	,	,
18637	19875	4	the	the	DT
18637	19875	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19875	6	laid	lay	VBD
18637	19875	7	down	down	RP
18637	19875	8	the	the	DT
18637	19875	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	19875	10	that	that	IN
18637	19875	11	a	a	DT
18637	19875	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19875	13	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19875	14	not	not	RB
18637	19875	15	doing	do	VBG
18637	19875	16	business	business	NN
18637	19875	17	in	in	IN
18637	19875	18	a	a	DT
18637	19875	19	State	State	NNP
18637	19875	20	under	under	IN
18637	19875	21	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19875	22	that	that	WDT
18637	19875	23	subjected	subject	VBD
18637	19875	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19875	25	to	to	TO
18637	19875	26	process	process	VB
18637	19875	27	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	19875	28	from	from	IN
18637	19875	29	the	the	DT
18637	19875	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	19875	31	of	of	IN
18637	19875	32	the	the	DT
18637	19875	33	State	State	NNP
18637	19875	34	at	at	IN
18637	19875	35	the	the	DT
18637	19875	36	instance	instance	NN
18637	19875	37	of	of	IN
18637	19875	38	suitors	suitor	NNS
18637	19875	39	was	be	VBD
18637	19875	40	not	not	RB
18637	19875	41	"	"	``
18637	19875	42	within	within	IN
18637	19875	43	the	the	DT
18637	19875	44	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19875	45	,	,	,
18637	19875	46	"	"	''
18637	19875	47	and	and	CC
18637	19875	48	could	could	MD
18637	19875	49	not	not	RB
18637	19875	50	complain	complain	VB
18637	19875	51	of	of	IN
18637	19875	52	the	the	DT
18637	19875	53	preference	preference	NN
18637	19875	54	granted	grant	VBD
18637	19875	55	resident	resident	JJ
18637	19875	56	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	19875	57	in	in	IN
18637	19875	58	the	the	DT
18637	19875	59	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	19875	60	of	of	IN
18637	19875	61	the	the	DT
18637	19875	62	assets	asset	NNS
18637	19875	63	of	of	IN
18637	19875	64	an	an	DT
18637	19875	65	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
18637	19875	66	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19875	67	.	.	.
18637	19876	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19876	2	1021	1021	CD
18637	19876	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19876	4	That	that	DT
18637	19876	5	principle	principle	NN
18637	19876	6	was	be	VBD
18637	19876	7	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	19876	8	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	19876	9	,	,	,
18637	19876	10	over	over	IN
18637	19876	11	the	the	DT
18637	19876	12	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	19876	13	of	of	IN
18637	19876	14	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19876	15	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	19876	16	and	and	CC
18637	19876	17	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	19876	18	,	,	,
18637	19876	19	by	by	IN
18637	19876	20	a	a	DT
18637	19876	21	holding	holding	NN
18637	19876	22	that	that	IN
18637	19876	23	a	a	DT
18637	19876	24	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19876	25	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19876	26	which	which	WDT
18637	19876	27	sued	sue	VBD
18637	19876	28	in	in	IN
18637	19876	29	a	a	DT
18637	19876	30	court	court	NN
18637	19876	31	of	of	IN
18637	19876	32	a	a	DT
18637	19876	33	State	State	NNP
18637	19876	34	in	in	IN
18637	19876	35	which	which	WDT
18637	19876	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19876	37	was	be	VBD
18637	19876	38	not	not	RB
18637	19876	39	licensed	license	VBN
18637	19876	40	to	to	TO
18637	19876	41	do	do	VB
18637	19876	42	business	business	NN
18637	19876	43	to	to	TO
18637	19876	44	recover	recover	VB
18637	19876	45	possession	possession	NN
18637	19876	46	of	of	IN
18637	19876	47	property	property	NN
18637	19876	48	wrongfully	wrongfully	RB
18637	19876	49	taken	take	VBN
18637	19876	50	from	from	IN
18637	19876	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19876	52	in	in	IN
18637	19876	53	another	another	DT
18637	19876	54	State	state	NN
18637	19876	55	was	be	VBD
18637	19876	56	"	"	``
18637	19876	57	within	within	IN
18637	19876	58	the	the	DT
18637	19876	59	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19876	60	"	"	''
18637	19876	61	and	and	CC
18637	19876	62	could	could	MD
18637	19876	63	not	not	RB
18637	19876	64	be	be	VB
18637	19876	65	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	19876	66	to	to	IN
18637	19876	67	unequal	unequal	JJ
18637	19876	68	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	19876	69	in	in	IN
18637	19876	70	the	the	DT
18637	19876	71	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	19876	72	of	of	IN
18637	19876	73	the	the	DT
18637	19876	74	suit	suit	NN
18637	19876	75	.	.	.
18637	19877	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19877	2	1022	1022	CD
18637	19877	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19877	4	The	the	DT
18637	19877	5	test	test	NN
18637	19877	6	of	of	IN
18637	19877	7	amenability	amenability	NN
18637	19877	8	to	to	IN
18637	19877	9	service	service	NN
18637	19877	10	of	of	IN
18637	19877	11	process	process	NN
18637	19877	12	within	within	IN
18637	19877	13	the	the	DT
18637	19877	14	State	state	NN
18637	19877	15	was	be	VBD
18637	19877	16	ignored	ignore	VBN
18637	19877	17	in	in	IN
18637	19877	18	a	a	DT
18637	19877	19	recent	recent	JJ
18637	19877	20	case	case	NN
18637	19877	21	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	19877	22	with	with	IN
18637	19877	23	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	19877	24	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19877	25	of	of	IN
18637	19877	26	property	property	NN
18637	19877	27	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	19877	28	to	to	IN
18637	19877	29	a	a	DT
18637	19877	30	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19877	31	individual	individual	NN
18637	19877	32	.	.	.
18637	19878	1	In	in	IN
18637	19878	2	holding	hold	VBG
18637	19878	3	that	that	IN
18637	19878	4	a	a	DT
18637	19878	5	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19878	6	court	court	NN
18637	19878	7	had	have	VBD
18637	19878	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19878	9	to	to	TO
18637	19878	10	entertain	entertain	VB
18637	19878	11	a	a	DT
18637	19878	12	suit	suit	NN
18637	19878	13	for	for	IN
18637	19878	14	a	a	DT
18637	19878	15	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	19878	16	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19878	17	to	to	TO
18637	19878	18	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	19878	19	the	the	DT
18637	19878	20	tax	tax	NN
18637	19878	21	,	,	,
18637	19878	22	the	the	DT
18637	19878	23	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19878	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19878	25	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	19878	26	mentioned	mention	VBD
18637	19878	27	the	the	DT
18637	19878	28	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19878	29	protection	protection	NN
18637	19878	30	clause	clause	NN
18637	19878	31	as	as	IN
18637	19878	32	the	the	DT
18637	19878	33	source	source	NN
18637	19878	34	of	of	IN
18637	19878	35	the	the	DT
18637	19878	36	federal	federal	JJ
18637	19878	37	right	right	NN
18637	19878	38	,	,	,
18637	19878	39	but	but	CC
18637	19878	40	took	take	VBD
18637	19878	41	no	no	DT
18637	19878	42	account	account	NN
18637	19878	43	of	of	IN
18637	19878	44	the	the	DT
18637	19878	45	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	19878	46	's	's	POS
18637	19878	47	status	status	NN
18637	19878	48	as	as	IN
18637	19878	49	a	a	DT
18637	19878	50	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19878	51	,	,	,
18637	19878	52	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	19878	53	a	a	DT
18637	19878	54	passing	pass	VBG
18637	19878	55	reference	reference	NN
18637	19878	56	to	to	IN
18637	19878	57	the	the	DT
18637	19878	58	existence	existence	NN
18637	19878	59	of	of	IN
18637	19878	60	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	19878	61	of	of	IN
18637	19878	62	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	19878	63	.	.	.
18637	19879	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19879	2	1023	1023	CD
18637	19879	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19879	4	When	when	WRB
18637	19879	5	a	a	DT
18637	19879	6	State	state	NN
18637	19879	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	19879	8	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	19879	9	a	a	DT
18637	19879	10	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19879	11	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19879	12	to	to	TO
18637	19879	13	do	do	VB
18637	19879	14	business	business	NN
18637	19879	15	within	within	IN
18637	19879	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19879	17	borders	border	NNS
18637	19879	18	,	,	,
18637	19879	19	that	that	IN
18637	19879	20	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19879	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	19879	22	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19879	23	to	to	TO
18637	19879	24	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19879	25	protection	protection	NN
18637	19879	26	of	of	IN
18637	19879	27	the	the	DT
18637	19879	28	laws	law	NNS
18637	19879	29	,	,	,
18637	19879	30	but	but	CC
18637	19879	31	not	not	RB
18637	19879	32	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	19879	33	to	to	IN
18637	19879	34	identical	identical	JJ
18637	19879	35	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	19879	36	with	with	IN
18637	19879	37	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19879	38	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19879	39	.	.	.
18637	19880	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19880	2	1024	1024	CD
18637	19880	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19880	4	A	a	DT
18637	19880	5	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19880	6	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19880	7	licensed	license	VBN
18637	19880	8	to	to	TO
18637	19880	9	do	do	VB
18637	19880	10	business	business	NN
18637	19880	11	within	within	IN
18637	19880	12	a	a	DT
18637	19880	13	State	state	NN
18637	19880	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	19880	15	payment	payment	NN
18637	19880	16	of	of	IN
18637	19880	17	an	an	DT
18637	19880	18	annual	annual	JJ
18637	19880	19	license	license	NN
18637	19880	20	tax	tax	NN
18637	19880	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	19880	22	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19880	23	to	to	IN
18637	19880	24	the	the	DT
18637	19880	25	power	power	NN
18637	19880	26	of	of	IN
18637	19880	27	the	the	DT
18637	19880	28	State	State	NNP
18637	19880	29	to	to	TO
18637	19880	30	change	change	VB
18637	19880	31	at	at	IN
18637	19880	32	any	any	DT
18637	19880	33	time	time	NN
18637	19880	34	the	the	DT
18637	19880	35	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19880	36	of	of	IN
18637	19880	37	admission	admission	NN
18637	19880	38	for	for	IN
18637	19880	39	the	the	DT
18637	19880	40	future	future	NN
18637	19880	41	.	.	.
18637	19881	1	If	if	IN
18637	19881	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19881	3	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	19881	4	to	to	TO
18637	19881	5	pay	pay	VB
18637	19881	6	an	an	DT
18637	19881	7	increased	increase	VBN
18637	19881	8	license	license	NN
18637	19881	9	tax	tax	NN
18637	19881	10	as	as	IN
18637	19881	11	a	a	DT
18637	19881	12	prerequisite	prerequisite	NN
18637	19881	13	to	to	IN
18637	19881	14	doing	do	VBG
18637	19881	15	business	business	NN
18637	19881	16	,	,	,
18637	19881	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19881	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	19881	19	not	not	RB
18637	19881	20	"	"	``
18637	19881	21	within	within	IN
18637	19881	22	the	the	DT
18637	19881	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19881	24	"	"	''
18637	19881	25	and	and	CC
18637	19881	26	unequal	unequal	JJ
18637	19881	27	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	19881	28	may	may	MD
18637	19881	29	be	be	VB
18637	19881	30	laid	lay	VBN
18637	19881	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	19881	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19881	33	as	as	IN
18637	19881	34	compared	compare	VBN
18637	19881	35	with	with	IN
18637	19881	36	other	other	JJ
18637	19881	37	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19881	38	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19881	39	.	.	.
18637	19882	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19882	2	1025	1025	CD
18637	19882	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19882	4	"	"	``
18637	19882	5	Equal	Equal	NNP
18637	19882	6	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	19882	7	of	of	IN
18637	19882	8	the	the	DT
18637	19882	9	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	19882	10	"	"	''
18637	19882	11	Equal	equal	JJ
18637	19882	12	protection	protection	NN
18637	19882	13	of	of	IN
18637	19882	14	the	the	DT
18637	19882	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	19882	16	means	mean	VBZ
18637	19882	17	the	the	DT
18637	19882	18	protection	protection	NN
18637	19882	19	of	of	IN
18637	19882	20	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19882	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	19882	22	.	.	.
18637	19883	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19883	2	1026	1026	CD
18637	19883	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19883	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19883	5	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	19883	6	all	all	DT
18637	19883	7	invidious	invidious	JJ
18637	19883	8	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19883	9	but	but	CC
18637	19883	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	19883	11	not	not	RB
18637	19883	12	require	require	VB
18637	19883	13	identical	identical	JJ
18637	19883	14	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	19883	15	for	for	IN
18637	19883	16	all	all	DT
18637	19883	17	persons	person	NNS
18637	19883	18	without	without	IN
18637	19883	19	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	19883	20	of	of	IN
18637	19883	21	differences	difference	NNS
18637	19883	22	in	in	IN
18637	19883	23	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	19883	24	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19883	25	.	.	.
18637	19884	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19884	2	requires	require	VBZ
18637	19884	3	"	"	``
18637	19884	4	that	that	IN
18637	19884	5	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19884	6	protection	protection	NN
18637	19884	7	and	and	CC
18637	19884	8	security	security	NN
18637	19884	9	should	should	MD
18637	19884	10	be	be	VB
18637	19884	11	given	give	VBN
18637	19884	12	to	to	IN
18637	19884	13	all	all	DT
18637	19884	14	under	under	IN
18637	19884	15	like	like	JJ
18637	19884	16	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19884	17	in	in	IN
18637	19884	18	the	the	DT
18637	19884	19	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	19884	20	of	of	IN
18637	19884	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19884	22	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19884	23	and	and	CC
18637	19884	24	civil	civil	JJ
18637	19884	25	rights	right	NNS
18637	19884	26	;	;	:
18637	19884	27	that	that	IN
18637	19884	28	all	all	DT
18637	19884	29	persons	person	NNS
18637	19884	30	should	should	MD
18637	19884	31	be	be	VB
18637	19884	32	equally	equally	RB
18637	19884	33	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19884	34	to	to	TO
18637	19884	35	pursue	pursue	VB
18637	19884	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19884	37	happiness	happiness	NN
18637	19884	38	and	and	CC
18637	19884	39	acquire	acquire	VB
18637	19884	40	and	and	CC
18637	19884	41	enjoy	enjoy	VB
18637	19884	42	property	property	NN
18637	19884	43	;	;	:
18637	19884	44	that	that	IN
18637	19884	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19884	46	should	should	MD
18637	19884	47	have	have	VB
18637	19884	48	like	like	UH
18637	19884	49	access	access	NN
18637	19884	50	to	to	IN
18637	19884	51	the	the	DT
18637	19884	52	courts	court	NNS
18637	19884	53	of	of	IN
18637	19884	54	the	the	DT
18637	19884	55	country	country	NN
18637	19884	56	for	for	IN
18637	19884	57	the	the	DT
18637	19884	58	protection	protection	NN
18637	19884	59	of	of	IN
18637	19884	60	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19884	61	persons	person	NNS
18637	19884	62	and	and	CC
18637	19884	63	property	property	NN
18637	19884	64	,	,	,
18637	19884	65	the	the	DT
18637	19884	66	prevention	prevention	NN
18637	19884	67	and	and	CC
18637	19884	68	redress	redress	NN
18637	19884	69	of	of	IN
18637	19884	70	wrongs	wrong	NNS
18637	19884	71	,	,	,
18637	19884	72	and	and	CC
18637	19884	73	the	the	DT
18637	19884	74	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	19884	75	of	of	IN
18637	19884	76	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	19884	77	;	;	:
18637	19884	78	that	that	IN
18637	19884	79	no	no	DT
18637	19884	80	impediment	impediment	NN
18637	19884	81	should	should	MD
18637	19884	82	be	be	VB
18637	19884	83	interposed	interpose	VBN
18637	19884	84	to	to	IN
18637	19884	85	the	the	DT
18637	19884	86	pursuits	pursuit	NNS
18637	19884	87	of	of	IN
18637	19884	88	anyone	anyone	NN
18637	19884	89	except	except	IN
18637	19884	90	as	as	IN
18637	19884	91	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19884	92	to	to	IN
18637	19884	93	the	the	DT
18637	19884	94	same	same	JJ
18637	19884	95	pursuits	pursuit	NNS
18637	19884	96	by	by	IN
18637	19884	97	others	other	NNS
18637	19884	98	under	under	IN
18637	19884	99	like	like	JJ
18637	19884	100	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19884	101	;	;	:
18637	19884	102	that	that	IN
18637	19884	103	no	no	DT
18637	19884	104	greater	great	JJR
18637	19884	105	burdens	burden	NNS
18637	19884	106	should	should	MD
18637	19884	107	be	be	VB
18637	19884	108	laid	lay	VBN
18637	19884	109	upon	upon	IN
18637	19884	110	one	one	CD
18637	19884	111	than	than	IN
18637	19884	112	are	be	VBP
18637	19884	113	laid	lay	VBN
18637	19884	114	upon	upon	IN
18637	19884	115	others	other	NNS
18637	19884	116	in	in	IN
18637	19884	117	the	the	DT
18637	19884	118	same	same	JJ
18637	19884	119	calling	calling	NN
18637	19884	120	and	and	CC
18637	19884	121	condition	condition	NN
18637	19884	122	,	,	,
18637	19884	123	and	and	CC
18637	19884	124	that	that	IN
18637	19884	125	in	in	IN
18637	19884	126	the	the	DT
18637	19884	127	administration	administration	NN
18637	19884	128	of	of	IN
18637	19884	129	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	19884	130	justice	justice	NN
18637	19884	131	no	no	RB
18637	19884	132	different	different	JJ
18637	19884	133	or	or	CC
18637	19884	134	higher	high	JJR
18637	19884	135	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	19884	136	should	should	MD
18637	19884	137	be	be	VB
18637	19884	138	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19884	139	upon	upon	IN
18637	19884	140	one	one	CD
18637	19884	141	than	than	IN
18637	19884	142	such	such	JJ
18637	19884	143	as	as	IN
18637	19884	144	is	be	VBZ
18637	19884	145	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	19884	146	to	to	IN
18637	19884	147	all	all	DT
18637	19884	148	for	for	IN
18637	19884	149	like	like	JJ
18637	19884	150	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	19884	151	.	.	.
18637	19885	1	"	"	``
18637	19885	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19885	3	1027	1027	CD
18637	19885	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19885	5	The	the	DT
18637	19885	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19885	7	was	be	VBD
18637	19885	8	not	not	RB
18637	19885	9	"	"	``
18637	19885	10	designed	design	VBN
18637	19885	11	to	to	TO
18637	19885	12	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	19885	13	with	with	IN
18637	19885	14	the	the	DT
18637	19885	15	power	power	NN
18637	19885	16	of	of	IN
18637	19885	17	the	the	DT
18637	19885	18	State	State	NNP
18637	19885	19	,	,	,
18637	19885	20	sometimes	sometimes	RB
18637	19885	21	termed	term	VBD
18637	19885	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19885	23	'	'	``
18637	19885	24	police	police	NN
18637	19885	25	power	power	NN
18637	19885	26	,	,	,
18637	19885	27	'	'	''
18637	19885	28	to	to	TO
18637	19885	29	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	19885	30	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	19885	31	to	to	TO
18637	19885	32	promote	promote	VB
18637	19885	33	the	the	DT
18637	19885	34	health	health	NN
18637	19885	35	,	,	,
18637	19885	36	peace	peace	NN
18637	19885	37	,	,	,
18637	19885	38	morals	moral	NNS
18637	19885	39	,	,	,
18637	19885	40	education	education	NN
18637	19885	41	,	,	,
18637	19885	42	and	and	CC
18637	19885	43	good	good	JJ
18637	19885	44	order	order	NN
18637	19885	45	of	of	IN
18637	19885	46	the	the	DT
18637	19885	47	people	people	NNS
18637	19885	48	,	,	,
18637	19885	49	and	and	CC
18637	19885	50	to	to	TO
18637	19885	51	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	19885	52	so	so	IN
18637	19885	53	as	as	IN
18637	19885	54	to	to	TO
18637	19885	55	increase	increase	VB
18637	19885	56	the	the	DT
18637	19885	57	industries	industry	NNS
18637	19885	58	of	of	IN
18637	19885	59	the	the	DT
18637	19885	60	State	State	NNP
18637	19885	61	,	,	,
18637	19885	62	develop	develop	VB
18637	19885	63	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19885	64	resources	resource	NNS
18637	19885	65	,	,	,
18637	19885	66	and	and	CC
18637	19885	67	add	add	VB
18637	19885	68	to	to	IN
18637	19885	69	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19885	70	wealth	wealth	NN
18637	19885	71	and	and	CC
18637	19885	72	prosperity	prosperity	NN
18637	19885	73	*	*	NFP
18637	19885	74	*	*	NFP
18637	19885	75	*	*	NFP
18637	19885	76	Regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	19885	77	for	for	IN
18637	19885	78	these	these	DT
18637	19885	79	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19885	80	may	may	MD
18637	19885	81	press	press	VB
18637	19885	82	with	with	IN
18637	19885	83	more	more	JJR
18637	19885	84	or	or	CC
18637	19885	85	less	less	JJR
18637	19885	86	weight	weight	NN
18637	19885	87	upon	upon	IN
18637	19885	88	one	one	CD
18637	19885	89	than	than	IN
18637	19885	90	upon	upon	IN
18637	19885	91	another	another	DT
18637	19885	92	,	,	,
18637	19885	93	but	but	CC
18637	19885	94	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19885	95	are	be	VBP
18637	19885	96	designed	design	VBN
18637	19885	97	,	,	,
18637	19885	98	not	not	RB
18637	19885	99	to	to	TO
18637	19885	100	impose	impose	VB
18637	19885	101	unequal	unequal	JJ
18637	19885	102	or	or	CC
18637	19885	103	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	19885	104	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	19885	105	upon	upon	IN
18637	19885	106	anyone	anyone	NN
18637	19885	107	,	,	,
18637	19885	108	but	but	CC
18637	19885	109	to	to	TO
18637	19885	110	promote	promote	VB
18637	19885	111	,	,	,
18637	19885	112	with	with	IN
18637	19885	113	as	as	RB
18637	19885	114	little	little	JJ
18637	19885	115	individual	individual	JJ
18637	19885	116	inconvenience	inconvenience	NN
18637	19885	117	as	as	IN
18637	19885	118	possible	possible	JJ
18637	19885	119	,	,	,
18637	19885	120	the	the	DT
18637	19885	121	general	general	JJ
18637	19885	122	good	good	NN
18637	19885	123	.	.	.
18637	19886	1	Though	though	IN
18637	19886	2	,	,	,
18637	19886	3	in	in	IN
18637	19886	4	many	many	JJ
18637	19886	5	respects	respect	NNS
18637	19886	6	,	,	,
18637	19886	7	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	19886	8	special	special	JJ
18637	19886	9	in	in	IN
18637	19886	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19886	11	character	character	NN
18637	19886	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19886	13	do	do	VBP
18637	19886	14	not	not	RB
18637	19886	15	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	19886	16	just	just	RB
18637	19886	17	ground	ground	NN
18637	19886	18	of	of	IN
18637	19886	19	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	19886	20	if	if	IN
18637	19886	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19886	22	operate	operate	VBP
18637	19886	23	alike	alike	RB
18637	19886	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	19886	25	all	all	DT
18637	19886	26	persons	person	NNS
18637	19886	27	and	and	CC
18637	19886	28	property	property	NN
18637	19886	29	under	under	IN
18637	19886	30	the	the	DT
18637	19886	31	same	same	JJ
18637	19886	32	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19886	33	and	and	CC
18637	19886	34	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19886	35	.	.	.
18637	19887	1	"	"	``
18637	19887	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19887	3	1028	1028	CD
18637	19887	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19887	5	The	the	DT
18637	19887	6	due	due	JJ
18637	19887	7	process	process	NN
18637	19887	8	and	and	CC
18637	19887	9	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19887	10	protection	protection	NN
18637	19887	11	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	19887	12	overlap	overlap	VBP
18637	19887	13	but	but	CC
18637	19887	14	the	the	DT
18637	19887	15	spheres	sphere	NNS
18637	19887	16	of	of	IN
18637	19887	17	protection	protection	NN
18637	19887	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19887	19	offer	offer	VBP
18637	19887	20	are	be	VBP
18637	19887	21	not	not	RB
18637	19887	22	coterminous	coterminous	JJ
18637	19887	23	.	.	.
18637	19888	1	The	the	DT
18637	19888	2	due	due	JJ
18637	19888	3	process	process	NN
18637	19888	4	clause	clause	NN
18637	19888	5	"	"	''
18637	19888	6	tends	tend	VBZ
18637	19888	7	to	to	TO
18637	19888	8	secure	secure	VB
18637	19888	9	equality	equality	NN
18637	19888	10	of	of	IN
18637	19888	11	law	law	NN
18637	19888	12	in	in	IN
18637	19888	13	the	the	DT
18637	19888	14	sense	sense	NN
18637	19888	15	that	that	IN
18637	19888	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19888	17	makes	make	VBZ
18637	19888	18	a	a	DT
18637	19888	19	required	require	VBN
18637	19888	20	minimum	minimum	NN
18637	19888	21	of	of	IN
18637	19888	22	protection	protection	NN
18637	19888	23	for	for	IN
18637	19888	24	everyone	everyone	NN
18637	19888	25	's	's	POS
18637	19888	26	right	right	NN
18637	19888	27	of	of	IN
18637	19888	28	life	life	NN
18637	19888	29	,	,	,
18637	19888	30	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	19888	31	,	,	,
18637	19888	32	and	and	CC
18637	19888	33	property	property	NN
18637	19888	34	,	,	,
18637	19888	35	which	which	WDT
18637	19888	36	the	the	DT
18637	19888	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	19888	38	or	or	CC
18637	19888	39	the	the	DT
18637	19888	40	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	19888	41	may	may	MD
18637	19888	42	not	not	RB
18637	19888	43	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	19888	44	.	.	.
18637	19889	1	*	*	NFP
18637	19889	2	*	*	NFP
18637	19889	3	*	*	NFP
18637	19889	4	The	the	DT
18637	19889	5	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	19889	6	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19889	7	of	of	IN
18637	19889	8	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19889	9	protection	protection	NN
18637	19889	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19889	11	was	be	VBD
18637	19889	12	aimed	aim	VBN
18637	19889	13	at	at	IN
18637	19889	14	undue	undue	JJ
18637	19889	15	favor	favor	NN
18637	19889	16	and	and	CC
18637	19889	17	individual	individual	JJ
18637	19889	18	or	or	CC
18637	19889	19	class	class	NN
18637	19889	20	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19889	21	,	,	,
18637	19889	22	on	on	IN
18637	19889	23	the	the	DT
18637	19889	24	other	other	JJ
18637	19889	25	hand	hand	NN
18637	19889	26	,	,	,
18637	19889	27	and	and	CC
18637	19889	28	at	at	IN
18637	19889	29	hostile	hostile	JJ
18637	19889	30	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19889	31	or	or	CC
18637	19889	32	the	the	DT
18637	19889	33	oppression	oppression	NN
18637	19889	34	of	of	IN
18637	19889	35	inequality	inequality	NN
18637	19889	36	,	,	,
18637	19889	37	on	on	IN
18637	19889	38	the	the	DT
18637	19889	39	other	other	JJ
18637	19889	40	.	.	.
18637	19890	1	"	"	``
18637	19890	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19890	3	1029	1029	CD
18637	19890	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19890	5	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	19890	6	Classifications	Classifications	NNP
18637	19890	7	Although	although	IN
18637	19890	8	the	the	DT
18637	19890	9	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19890	10	protection	protection	NN
18637	19890	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	19890	12	requires	require	VBZ
18637	19890	13	laws	law	NNS
18637	19890	14	of	of	IN
18637	19890	15	like	like	IN
18637	19890	16	application	application	NN
18637	19890	17	to	to	IN
18637	19890	18	all	all	DT
18637	19890	19	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	19890	20	situated	situate	VBN
18637	19890	21	,	,	,
18637	19890	22	the	the	DT
18637	19890	23	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	19890	24	is	be	VBZ
18637	19890	25	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	19890	26	wide	wide	JJ
18637	19890	27	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	19890	28	in	in	IN
18637	19890	29	the	the	DT
18637	19890	30	selection	selection	NN
18637	19890	31	of	of	IN
18637	19890	32	classes	class	NNS
18637	19890	33	.	.	.
18637	19891	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19891	2	1030	1030	CD
18637	19891	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19891	4	Classification	classification	NN
18637	19891	5	will	will	MD
18637	19891	6	not	not	RB
18637	19891	7	render	render	VB
18637	19891	8	a	a	DT
18637	19891	9	State	State	NNP
18637	19891	10	police	police	NN
18637	19891	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	19891	12	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19891	13	so	so	RB
18637	19891	14	long	long	RB
18637	19891	15	as	as	IN
18637	19891	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19891	17	has	have	VBZ
18637	19891	18	a	a	DT
18637	19891	19	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19891	20	basis;[1031	basis;[1031	NNPS
18637	19891	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19891	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19891	23	validity	validity	NN
18637	19891	24	does	do	VBZ
18637	19891	25	not	not	RB
18637	19891	26	depend	depend	VB
18637	19891	27	on	on	IN
18637	19891	28	scientific	scientific	JJ
18637	19891	29	or	or	CC
18637	19891	30	marked	marked	JJ
18637	19891	31	differences	difference	NNS
18637	19891	32	in	in	IN
18637	19891	33	things	thing	NNS
18637	19891	34	or	or	CC
18637	19891	35	persons	person	NNS
18637	19891	36	or	or	CC
18637	19891	37	in	in	IN
18637	19891	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19891	39	relations	relation	NNS
18637	19891	40	.	.	.
18637	19892	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19892	2	suffices	suffice	VBZ
18637	19892	3	if	if	IN
18637	19892	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19892	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19892	6	practical	practical	JJ
18637	19892	7	.	.	.
18637	19893	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19893	2	1032	1032	CD
18637	19893	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19893	4	While	while	IN
18637	19893	5	a	a	DT
18637	19893	6	State	State	NNP
18637	19893	7	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	19893	8	may	may	MD
18637	19893	9	not	not	RB
18637	19893	10	arbitrarily	arbitrarily	RB
18637	19893	11	select	select	VB
18637	19893	12	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19893	13	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	19893	14	for	for	IN
18637	19893	15	the	the	DT
18637	19893	16	operation	operation	NN
18637	19893	17	of	of	IN
18637	19893	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19893	19	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	19893	20	,	,	,
18637	19893	21	a	a	DT
18637	19893	22	selection	selection	NN
18637	19893	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	19893	24	obnoxious	obnoxious	JJ
18637	19893	25	to	to	IN
18637	19893	26	the	the	DT
18637	19893	27	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19893	28	protection	protection	NN
18637	19893	29	clause	clause	NN
18637	19893	30	only	only	RB
18637	19893	31	if	if	IN
18637	19893	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19893	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	19893	34	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	19893	35	and	and	CC
18637	19893	36	actually	actually	RB
18637	19893	37	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19893	38	and	and	CC
18637	19893	39	not	not	RB
18637	19893	40	merely	merely	RB
18637	19893	41	possibly	possibly	RB
18637	19893	42	so	so	RB
18637	19893	43	.	.	.
18637	19894	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19894	2	1033	1033	CD
18637	19894	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19894	4	A	a	DT
18637	19894	5	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	19894	6	difference	difference	NN
18637	19894	7	,	,	,
18637	19894	8	in	in	IN
18637	19894	9	point	point	NN
18637	19894	10	of	of	IN
18637	19894	11	harmful	harmful	JJ
18637	19894	12	results	result	NNS
18637	19894	13	,	,	,
18637	19894	14	between	between	IN
18637	19894	15	two	two	CD
18637	19894	16	methods	method	NNS
18637	19894	17	of	of	IN
18637	19894	18	operation	operation	NN
18637	19894	19	,	,	,
18637	19894	20	justifies	justify	VBZ
18637	19894	21	a	a	DT
18637	19894	22	classification	classification	NN
18637	19894	23	and	and	CC
18637	19894	24	the	the	DT
18637	19894	25	burden	burden	NN
18637	19894	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	19894	27	on	on	IN
18637	19894	28	the	the	DT
18637	19894	29	attacking	attack	VBG
18637	19894	30	party	party	NN
18637	19894	31	to	to	TO
18637	19894	32	prove	prove	VB
18637	19894	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19894	34	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19894	35	.	.	.
18637	19895	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19895	2	1034	1034	CD
18637	19895	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19895	4	There	there	EX
18637	19895	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19895	6	a	a	DT
18637	19895	7	strong	strong	JJ
18637	19895	8	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	19895	9	that	that	WDT
18637	19895	10	discriminations	discrimination	NNS
18637	19895	11	in	in	IN
18637	19895	12	State	State	NNP
18637	19895	13	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19895	14	are	be	VBP
18637	19895	15	based	base	VBN
18637	19895	16	on	on	IN
18637	19895	17	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	19895	18	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	19895	19	.	.	.
18637	19896	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19896	2	1035	1035	CD
18637	19896	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19896	4	Every	every	DT
18637	19896	5	state	state	NN
18637	19896	6	of	of	IN
18637	19896	7	facts	fact	NNS
18637	19896	8	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	19896	9	to	to	TO
18637	19896	10	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	19896	11	a	a	DT
18637	19896	12	classification	classification	NN
18637	19896	13	which	which	WDT
18637	19896	14	can	can	MD
18637	19896	15	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	19896	16	be	be	VB
18637	19896	17	conceived	conceive	VBN
18637	19896	18	of	of	IN
18637	19896	19	as	as	IN
18637	19896	20	having	have	VBG
18637	19896	21	existed	exist	VBN
18637	19896	22	when	when	WRB
18637	19896	23	the	the	DT
18637	19896	24	law	law	NN
18637	19896	25	was	be	VBD
18637	19896	26	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	19896	27	will	will	MD
18637	19896	28	be	be	VB
18637	19896	29	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	19896	30	.	.	.
18637	19897	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19897	2	1036	1036	CD
18637	19897	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19897	4	There	there	EX
18637	19897	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	19897	6	no	no	DT
18637	19897	7	doctrinaire	doctrinaire	JJ
18637	19897	8	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19897	9	that	that	IN
18637	19897	10	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19897	11	should	should	MD
18637	19897	12	be	be	VB
18637	19897	13	couched	couch	VBN
18637	19897	14	in	in	IN
18637	19897	15	all	all	RB
18637	19897	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	19897	17	embracing	embrace	VBG
18637	19897	18	terms	term	NNS
18637	19897	19	.	.	.
18637	19898	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19898	2	1037	1037	CD
18637	19898	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19898	4	A	a	DT
18637	19898	5	police	police	NN
18637	19898	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	19898	7	may	may	MD
18637	19898	8	be	be	VB
18637	19898	9	confined	confine	VBN
18637	19898	10	to	to	IN
18637	19898	11	the	the	DT
18637	19898	12	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	19898	13	for	for	IN
18637	19898	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19898	15	existence	existence	NN
18637	19898	16	.	.	.
18637	19899	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19899	2	1038	1038	CD
18637	19899	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19899	4	The	the	DT
18637	19899	5	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19899	6	protection	protection	NN
18637	19899	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	19899	8	does	do	VBZ
18637	19899	9	not	not	RB
18637	19899	10	mean	mean	VB
18637	19899	11	that	that	IN
18637	19899	12	all	all	DT
18637	19899	13	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	19899	14	that	that	WDT
18637	19899	15	are	be	VBP
18637	19899	16	called	call	VBN
18637	19899	17	by	by	IN
18637	19899	18	the	the	DT
18637	19899	19	same	same	JJ
18637	19899	20	name	name	NN
18637	19899	21	must	must	MD
18637	19899	22	be	be	VB
18637	19899	23	treated	treat	VBN
18637	19899	24	in	in	IN
18637	19899	25	the	the	DT
18637	19899	26	same	same	JJ
18637	19899	27	way	way	NN
18637	19899	28	.	.	.
18637	19900	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19900	2	1039	1039	CD
18637	19900	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19900	4	The	the	DT
18637	19900	5	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	19900	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19900	7	free	free	JJ
18637	19900	8	to	to	TO
18637	19900	9	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	19900	10	degrees	degree	NNS
18637	19900	11	of	of	IN
18637	19900	12	harm	harm	NN
18637	19900	13	;	;	:
18637	19900	14	a	a	DT
18637	19900	15	law	law	NN
18637	19900	16	which	which	WDT
18637	19900	17	hits	hit	VBZ
18637	19900	18	the	the	DT
18637	19900	19	evil	evil	NN
18637	19900	20	where	where	WRB
18637	19900	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19900	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	19900	23	most	most	RBS
18637	19900	24	felt	feel	VBN
18637	19900	25	will	will	MD
18637	19900	26	not	not	RB
18637	19900	27	be	be	VB
18637	19900	28	overthrown	overthrow	VBN
18637	19900	29	because	because	IN
18637	19900	30	there	there	EX
18637	19900	31	are	be	VBP
18637	19900	32	other	other	JJ
18637	19900	33	instances	instance	NNS
18637	19900	34	to	to	TO
18637	19900	35	which	which	WDT
18637	19900	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19900	37	might	may	MD
18637	19900	38	have	have	VB
18637	19900	39	been	be	VBN
18637	19900	40	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19900	41	.	.	.
18637	19901	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19901	2	1040	1040	CD
18637	19901	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19901	4	The	the	DT
18637	19901	5	State	State	NNP
18637	19901	6	may	may	MD
18637	19901	7	do	do	VB
18637	19901	8	what	what	WP
18637	19901	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19901	10	can	can	MD
18637	19901	11	to	to	TO
18637	19901	12	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	19901	13	what	what	WP
18637	19901	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19901	15	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	19901	16	an	an	DT
18637	19901	17	evil	evil	NN
18637	19901	18	and	and	CC
18637	19901	19	stop	stop	VB
18637	19901	20	short	short	RB
18637	19901	21	of	of	IN
18637	19901	22	those	those	DT
18637	19901	23	cases	case	NNS
18637	19901	24	in	in	IN
18637	19901	25	which	which	WDT
18637	19901	26	the	the	DT
18637	19901	27	harm	harm	NN
18637	19901	28	to	to	IN
18637	19901	29	the	the	DT
18637	19901	30	few	few	JJ
18637	19901	31	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	19901	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	19901	33	thought	think	VBN
18637	19901	34	less	less	RBR
18637	19901	35	important	important	JJ
18637	19901	36	than	than	IN
18637	19901	37	the	the	DT
18637	19901	38	harm	harm	NN
18637	19901	39	to	to	IN
18637	19901	40	the	the	DT
18637	19901	41	public	public	NN
18637	19901	42	that	that	WDT
18637	19901	43	would	would	MD
18637	19901	44	ensue	ensue	VB
18637	19901	45	if	if	IN
18637	19901	46	the	the	DT
18637	19901	47	rules	rule	NNS
18637	19901	48	laid	lay	VBD
18637	19901	49	down	down	RP
18637	19901	50	were	be	VBD
18637	19901	51	made	make	VBN
18637	19901	52	mathematically	mathematically	RB
18637	19901	53	exact	exact	JJ
18637	19901	54	.	.	.
18637	19902	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19902	2	1041	1041	CD
18637	19902	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19902	4	Exceptions	Exceptions	NNPS
18637	19902	5	of	of	IN
18637	19902	6	specified	specify	VBN
18637	19902	7	classes	class	NNS
18637	19902	8	will	will	MD
18637	19902	9	not	not	RB
18637	19902	10	render	render	VB
18637	19902	11	the	the	DT
18637	19902	12	law	law	NN
18637	19902	13	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19902	14	unless	unless	IN
18637	19902	15	there	there	EX
18637	19902	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	19902	17	no	no	DT
18637	19902	18	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19902	19	reason	reason	NN
18637	19902	20	for	for	IN
18637	19902	21	the	the	DT
18637	19902	22	law	law	NN
18637	19902	23	that	that	WDT
18637	19902	24	would	would	MD
18637	19902	25	not	not	RB
18637	19902	26	equally	equally	RB
18637	19902	27	require	require	VB
18637	19902	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19902	29	extension	extension	NN
18637	19902	30	to	to	IN
18637	19902	31	the	the	DT
18637	19902	32	excepted	except	VBN
18637	19902	33	classes	class	NNS
18637	19902	34	.	.	.
18637	19903	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19903	2	1042	1042	CD
18637	19903	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19903	4	Incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	19903	5	individual	individual	JJ
18637	19903	6	inequality	inequality	NN
18637	19903	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	19903	8	not	not	RB
18637	19903	9	violate	violate	VB
18637	19903	10	the	the	DT
18637	19903	11	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19903	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19903	13	.	.	.
18637	19904	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19904	2	1043	1043	CD
18637	19904	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19904	4	One	one	CD
18637	19904	5	who	who	WP
18637	19904	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19904	7	not	not	RB
18637	19904	8	discriminated	discriminate	VBN
18637	19904	9	against	against	IN
18637	19904	10	can	can	MD
18637	19904	11	not	not	RB
18637	19904	12	attack	attack	VB
18637	19904	13	a	a	DT
18637	19904	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	19904	15	because	because	IN
18637	19904	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19904	17	does	do	VBZ
18637	19904	18	not	not	RB
18637	19904	19	go	go	VB
18637	19904	20	further	further	RB
18637	19904	21	;	;	:
18637	19904	22	and	and	CC
18637	19904	23	if	if	IN
18637	19904	24	what	what	WP
18637	19904	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19904	26	commands	command	VBZ
18637	19904	27	of	of	IN
18637	19904	28	one	one	CD
18637	19904	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19904	30	commands	command	VBZ
18637	19904	31	of	of	IN
18637	19904	32	all	all	DT
18637	19904	33	others	other	NNS
18637	19904	34	in	in	IN
18637	19904	35	the	the	DT
18637	19904	36	same	same	JJ
18637	19904	37	class	class	NN
18637	19904	38	,	,	,
18637	19904	39	that	that	DT
18637	19904	40	person	person	NN
18637	19904	41	can	can	MD
18637	19904	42	not	not	RB
18637	19904	43	complain	complain	VB
18637	19904	44	of	of	IN
18637	19904	45	matter	matter	NN
18637	19904	46	which	which	WDT
18637	19904	47	the	the	DT
18637	19904	48	statute	statute	NN
18637	19904	49	does	do	VBZ
18637	19904	50	not	not	RB
18637	19904	51	cover	cover	VB
18637	19904	52	.	.	.
18637	19905	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19905	2	1044	1044	CD
18637	19905	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19905	4	TAXATION	TAXATION	NNP
18637	19905	5	At	at	IN
18637	19905	6	the	the	DT
18637	19905	7	outset	outset	NN
18637	19905	8	,	,	,
18637	19905	9	the	the	DT
18637	19905	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19905	11	did	do	VBD
18637	19905	12	not	not	RB
18637	19905	13	regard	regard	VB
18637	19905	14	the	the	DT
18637	19905	15	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19905	16	protection	protection	NN
18637	19905	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	19905	18	as	as	IN
18637	19905	19	having	have	VBG
18637	19905	20	any	any	DT
18637	19905	21	bearing	bearing	NN
18637	19905	22	on	on	IN
18637	19905	23	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19905	24	.	.	.
18637	19906	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19906	2	1045	1045	CD
18637	19906	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19906	4	Before	before	IN
18637	19906	5	long	long	RB
18637	19906	6	,	,	,
18637	19906	7	however	however	RB
18637	19906	8	,	,	,
18637	19906	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19906	10	took	take	VBD
18637	19906	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	19906	12	of	of	IN
18637	19906	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	19906	14	assailing	assail	VBG
18637	19906	15	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19906	16	tax	tax	NN
18637	19906	17	laws	law	NNS
18637	19906	18	under	under	IN
18637	19906	19	this	this	DT
18637	19906	20	provision	provision	NN
18637	19906	21	.	.	.
18637	19907	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19907	2	1046	1046	CD
18637	19907	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19907	4	In	in	IN
18637	19907	5	1890	1890	CD
18637	19907	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19907	7	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	19907	8	cautiously	cautiously	RB
18637	19907	9	that	that	IN
18637	19907	10	"	"	``
18637	19907	11	clear	clear	JJ
18637	19907	12	and	and	CC
18637	19907	13	hostile	hostile	JJ
18637	19907	14	discriminations	discrimination	NNS
18637	19907	15	against	against	IN
18637	19907	16	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19907	17	persons	person	NNS
18637	19907	18	and	and	CC
18637	19907	19	classes	class	NNS
18637	19907	20	,	,	,
18637	19907	21	especially	especially	RB
18637	19907	22	such	such	JJ
18637	19907	23	as	as	IN
18637	19907	24	are	be	VBP
18637	19907	25	of	of	IN
18637	19907	26	an	an	DT
18637	19907	27	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	19907	28	character	character	NN
18637	19907	29	,	,	,
18637	19907	30	unknown	unknown	JJ
18637	19907	31	to	to	IN
18637	19907	32	the	the	DT
18637	19907	33	practice	practice	NN
18637	19907	34	of	of	IN
18637	19907	35	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19907	36	governments	government	NNS
18637	19907	37	,	,	,
18637	19907	38	_	_	NNP
18637	19907	39	might	may	MD
18637	19907	40	_	_	NNP
18637	19907	41	be	be	VB
18637	19907	42	obnoxious	obnoxious	JJ
18637	19907	43	to	to	IN
18637	19907	44	the	the	DT
18637	19907	45	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19907	46	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	19907	47	.	.	.
18637	19908	1	"	"	``
18637	19908	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19908	3	1047	1047	CD
18637	19908	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19908	5	In	in	IN
18637	19908	6	succeeding	succeed	VBG
18637	19908	7	years	year	NNS
18637	19908	8	the	the	DT
18637	19908	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	19908	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	19908	11	been	be	VBN
18637	19908	12	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	19908	13	but	but	CC
18637	19908	14	sparingly	sparingly	RB
18637	19908	15	to	to	TO
18637	19908	16	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	19908	17	State	State	NNP
18637	19908	18	levies	levy	NNS
18637	19908	19	.	.	.
18637	19909	1	In	in	IN
18637	19909	2	the	the	DT
18637	19909	3	field	field	NN
18637	19909	4	of	of	IN
18637	19909	5	property	property	NN
18637	19909	6	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19909	7	,	,	,
18637	19909	8	inequality	inequality	NN
18637	19909	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	19909	10	been	be	VBN
18637	19909	11	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	19909	12	only	only	RB
18637	19909	13	in	in	IN
18637	19909	14	two	two	CD
18637	19909	15	classes	class	NNS
18637	19909	16	of	of	IN
18637	19909	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	19909	18	:	:	:
18637	19909	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19909	20	1	1	LS
18637	19909	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19909	22	intentional	intentional	JJ
18637	19909	23	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19909	24	in	in	IN
18637	19909	25	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	19909	26	;	;	:
18637	19909	27	and	and	CC
18637	19909	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	19909	29	2	2	LS
18637	19909	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	19909	31	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19909	32	against	against	IN
18637	19909	33	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19909	34	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19909	35	.	.	.
18637	19910	1	In	in	IN
18637	19910	2	addition	addition	NN
18637	19910	3	,	,	,
18637	19910	4	there	there	EX
18637	19910	5	are	be	VBP
18637	19910	6	a	a	DT
18637	19910	7	handful	handful	NN
18637	19910	8	of	of	IN
18637	19910	9	cases	case	NNS
18637	19910	10	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
18637	19910	11	,	,	,
18637	19910	12	because	because	IN
18637	19910	13	of	of	IN
18637	19910	14	inequality	inequality	NN
18637	19910	15	,	,	,
18637	19910	16	State	state	NN
18637	19910	17	laws	law	NNS
18637	19910	18	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	19910	19	income	income	NN
18637	19910	20	,	,	,
18637	19910	21	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19910	22	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	19910	23	,	,	,
18637	19910	24	sales	sale	NNS
18637	19910	25	and	and	CC
18637	19910	26	license	license	NN
18637	19910	27	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19910	28	.	.	.
18637	19911	1	Classifications	classification	NNS
18637	19911	2	for	for	IN
18637	19911	3	the	the	DT
18637	19911	4	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	19911	5	of	of	IN
18637	19911	6	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	19911	7	The	the	DT
18637	19911	8	power	power	NN
18637	19911	9	of	of	IN
18637	19911	10	the	the	DT
18637	19911	11	State	State	NNP
18637	19911	12	to	to	TO
18637	19911	13	classify	classify	VB
18637	19911	14	for	for	IN
18637	19911	15	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19911	16	of	of	IN
18637	19911	17	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19911	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	19911	19	"	"	``
18637	19911	20	of	of	IN
18637	19911	21	wide	wide	JJ
18637	19911	22	range	range	NN
18637	19911	23	and	and	CC
18637	19911	24	flexibility	flexibility	NN
18637	19911	25	.	.	.
18637	19912	1	"	"	``
18637	19912	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19912	3	1048	1048	CD
18637	19912	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19912	5	The	the	DT
18637	19912	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	19912	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	19912	8	not	not	RB
18637	19912	9	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	19912	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19912	11	"	"	''
18637	19912	12	from	from	IN
18637	19912	13	adjusting	adjust	VBG
18637	19912	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19912	15	system	system	NN
18637	19912	16	of	of	IN
18637	19912	17	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19912	18	in	in	IN
18637	19912	19	all	all	DT
18637	19912	20	proper	proper	JJ
18637	19912	21	and	and	CC
18637	19912	22	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19912	23	ways	way	NNS
18637	19912	24	.	.	.
18637	19913	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19913	2	may	may	MD
18637	19913	3	,	,	,
18637	19913	4	if	if	IN
18637	19913	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19913	6	chooses	choose	VBZ
18637	19913	7	,	,	,
18637	19913	8	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	19913	9	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19913	10	classes	class	NNS
18637	19913	11	of	of	IN
18637	19913	12	property	property	NN
18637	19913	13	from	from	IN
18637	19913	14	any	any	DT
18637	19913	15	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19913	16	at	at	RB
18637	19913	17	all	all	RB
18637	19913	18	,	,	,
18637	19913	19	such	such	JJ
18637	19913	20	as	as	IN
18637	19913	21	churches	church	NNS
18637	19913	22	,	,	,
18637	19913	23	libraries	library	NNS
18637	19913	24	,	,	,
18637	19913	25	and	and	CC
18637	19913	26	the	the	DT
18637	19913	27	property	property	NN
18637	19913	28	of	of	IN
18637	19913	29	charitable	charitable	JJ
18637	19913	30	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	19913	31	.	.	.
18637	19914	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19914	2	may	may	MD
18637	19914	3	impose	impose	VB
18637	19914	4	different	different	JJ
18637	19914	5	specific	specific	JJ
18637	19914	6	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19914	7	upon	upon	IN
18637	19914	8	different	different	JJ
18637	19914	9	trades	trade	NNS
18637	19914	10	and	and	CC
18637	19914	11	professions	profession	NNS
18637	19914	12	,	,	,
18637	19914	13	and	and	CC
18637	19914	14	may	may	MD
18637	19914	15	vary	vary	VB
18637	19914	16	the	the	DT
18637	19914	17	rates	rate	NNS
18637	19914	18	of	of	IN
18637	19914	19	excise	excise	NN
18637	19914	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	19914	21	various	various	JJ
18637	19914	22	products	product	NNS
18637	19914	23	;	;	:
18637	19914	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19914	25	may	may	MD
18637	19914	26	tax	tax	VB
18637	19914	27	real	real	JJ
18637	19914	28	estate	estate	NN
18637	19914	29	and	and	CC
18637	19914	30	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19914	31	property	property	NN
18637	19914	32	in	in	IN
18637	19914	33	a	a	DT
18637	19914	34	different	different	JJ
18637	19914	35	manner	manner	NN
18637	19914	36	;	;	:
18637	19914	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19914	38	may	may	MD
18637	19914	39	tax	tax	VB
18637	19914	40	visible	visible	JJ
18637	19914	41	property	property	NN
18637	19914	42	only	only	RB
18637	19914	43	,	,	,
18637	19914	44	and	and	CC
18637	19914	45	not	not	RB
18637	19914	46	tax	tax	VB
18637	19914	47	securities	security	NNS
18637	19914	48	for	for	IN
18637	19914	49	payment	payment	NN
18637	19914	50	of	of	IN
18637	19914	51	money	money	NN
18637	19914	52	;	;	:
18637	19914	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19914	54	may	may	MD
18637	19914	55	allow	allow	VB
18637	19914	56	deductions	deduction	NNS
18637	19914	57	for	for	IN
18637	19914	58	indebtedness	indebtedness	NN
18637	19914	59	,	,	,
18637	19914	60	or	or	CC
18637	19914	61	not	not	RB
18637	19914	62	allow	allow	VB
18637	19914	63	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19914	64	.	.	.
18637	19915	1	All	all	DT
18637	19915	2	such	such	JJ
18637	19915	3	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	19915	4	,	,	,
18637	19915	5	and	and	CC
18637	19915	6	those	those	DT
18637	19915	7	of	of	IN
18637	19915	8	like	like	IN
18637	19915	9	character	character	NN
18637	19915	10	,	,	,
18637	19915	11	so	so	RB
18637	19915	12	long	long	RB
18637	19915	13	as	as	IN
18637	19915	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19915	15	proceed	proceed	VBP
18637	19915	16	within	within	IN
18637	19915	17	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19915	18	limits	limit	NNS
18637	19915	19	and	and	CC
18637	19915	20	general	general	JJ
18637	19915	21	usage	usage	NN
18637	19915	22	,	,	,
18637	19915	23	are	be	VBP
18637	19915	24	within	within	IN
18637	19915	25	the	the	DT
18637	19915	26	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	19915	27	of	of	IN
18637	19915	28	the	the	DT
18637	19915	29	State	State	NNP
18637	19915	30	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	19915	31	,	,	,
18637	19915	32	*	*	NFP
18637	19915	33	*	*	NFP
18637	19915	34	*	*	NFP
18637	19915	35	"	"	''
18637	19915	36	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19915	37	1049	1049	CD
18637	19915	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19915	39	A	a	DT
18637	19915	40	State	state	NN
18637	19915	41	may	may	MD
18637	19915	42	adjust	adjust	VB
18637	19915	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19915	44	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19915	45	system	system	NN
18637	19915	46	in	in	IN
18637	19915	47	such	such	PDT
18637	19915	48	a	a	DT
18637	19915	49	way	way	NN
18637	19915	50	as	as	IN
18637	19915	51	to	to	TO
18637	19915	52	favor	favor	VB
18637	19915	53	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19915	54	industries	industry	NNS
18637	19915	55	or	or	CC
18637	19915	56	forms	form	NNS
18637	19915	57	of	of	IN
18637	19915	58	industry,[1050	industry,[1050	NNP
18637	19915	59	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19915	60	and	and	CC
18637	19915	61	may	may	MD
18637	19915	62	tax	tax	VB
18637	19915	63	different	different	JJ
18637	19915	64	types	type	NNS
18637	19915	65	of	of	IN
18637	19915	66	taxpayers	taxpayer	NNS
18637	19915	67	differently	differently	RB
18637	19915	68	,	,	,
18637	19915	69	despite	despite	IN
18637	19915	70	the	the	DT
18637	19915	71	fact	fact	NN
18637	19915	72	that	that	IN
18637	19915	73	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19915	74	compete	compete	VBP
18637	19915	75	.	.	.
18637	19916	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19916	2	1051	1051	CD
18637	19916	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19916	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19916	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	19916	6	not	not	RB
18637	19916	7	follow	follow	VB
18637	19916	8	that	that	DT
18637	19916	9	because	because	IN
18637	19916	10	"	"	``
18637	19916	11	some	some	DT
18637	19916	12	degree	degree	NN
18637	19916	13	of	of	IN
18637	19916	14	inequality	inequality	NN
18637	19916	15	from	from	IN
18637	19916	16	the	the	DT
18637	19916	17	nature	nature	NN
18637	19916	18	of	of	IN
18637	19916	19	things	thing	NNS
18637	19916	20	must	must	MD
18637	19916	21	be	be	VB
18637	19916	22	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	19916	23	,	,	,
18637	19916	24	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19916	25	inequality	inequality	NN
18637	19916	26	must	must	MD
18637	19916	27	also	also	RB
18637	19916	28	be	be	VB
18637	19916	29	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	19916	30	.	.	.
18637	19917	1	"	"	``
18637	19917	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19917	3	1052	1052	CD
18637	19917	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19917	5	Classification	classification	NN
18637	19917	6	may	may	MD
18637	19917	7	not	not	RB
18637	19917	8	be	be	VB
18637	19917	9	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19917	10	;	;	:
18637	19917	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19917	12	must	must	MD
18637	19917	13	be	be	VB
18637	19917	14	based	base	VBN
18637	19917	15	on	on	IN
18637	19917	16	a	a	DT
18637	19917	17	real	real	JJ
18637	19917	18	and	and	CC
18637	19917	19	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	19917	20	difference,[1053	difference,[1053	NN
18637	19917	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19917	22	but	but	CC
18637	19917	23	the	the	DT
18637	19917	24	difference	difference	NN
18637	19917	25	need	nee	MD
18637	19917	26	not	not	RB
18637	19917	27	be	be	VB
18637	19917	28	great	great	JJ
18637	19917	29	or	or	CC
18637	19917	30	conspicuous;[1054	conspicuous;[1054	JJ
18637	19917	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19917	32	but	but	CC
18637	19917	33	there	there	EX
18637	19917	34	must	must	MD
18637	19917	35	be	be	VB
18637	19917	36	no	no	DT
18637	19917	37	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19917	38	in	in	IN
18637	19917	39	favor	favor	NN
18637	19917	40	of	of	IN
18637	19917	41	one	one	CD
18637	19917	42	as	as	IN
18637	19917	43	against	against	IN
18637	19917	44	another	another	DT
18637	19917	45	of	of	IN
18637	19917	46	the	the	DT
18637	19917	47	same	same	JJ
18637	19917	48	class	class	NN
18637	19917	49	.	.	.
18637	19918	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19918	2	1055	1055	CD
18637	19918	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19918	4	Also	also	RB
18637	19918	5	,	,	,
18637	19918	6	discriminations	discrimination	NNS
18637	19918	7	of	of	IN
18637	19918	8	an	an	DT
18637	19918	9	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	19918	10	character	character	NN
18637	19918	11	are	be	VBP
18637	19918	12	scrutinized	scrutinize	VBN
18637	19918	13	with	with	IN
18637	19918	14	especial	especial	JJ
18637	19918	15	care	care	NN
18637	19918	16	.	.	.
18637	19919	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19919	2	1056	1056	CD
18637	19919	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19919	4	A	a	DT
18637	19919	5	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19919	6	sales	sale	NNS
18637	19919	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	19919	8	graduated	graduate	VBN
18637	19919	9	at	at	IN
18637	19919	10	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	19919	11	rates	rate	NNS
18637	19919	12	with	with	IN
18637	19919	13	the	the	DT
18637	19919	14	volume	volume	NN
18637	19919	15	of	of	IN
18637	19919	16	sales,[1057	sales,[1057	NNP
18637	19919	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19919	18	a	a	DT
18637	19919	19	heavier	heavy	JJR
18637	19919	20	license	license	NN
18637	19919	21	tax	tax	NN
18637	19919	22	on	on	IN
18637	19919	23	each	each	DT
18637	19919	24	unit	unit	NN
18637	19919	25	in	in	IN
18637	19919	26	a	a	DT
18637	19919	27	chain	chain	NN
18637	19919	28	of	of	IN
18637	19919	29	stores	store	NNS
18637	19919	30	where	where	WRB
18637	19919	31	the	the	DT
18637	19919	32	owner	owner	NN
18637	19919	33	has	have	VBZ
18637	19919	34	stores	store	NNS
18637	19919	35	located	locate	VBN
18637	19919	36	in	in	IN
18637	19919	37	more	more	JJR
18637	19919	38	than	than	IN
18637	19919	39	one	one	CD
18637	19919	40	county,[1058	county,[1058	NNP
18637	19919	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19919	42	and	and	CC
18637	19919	43	a	a	DT
18637	19919	44	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19919	45	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	19919	46	tax	tax	NN
18637	19919	47	levied	levy	VBN
18637	19919	48	on	on	IN
18637	19919	49	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19919	50	operating	operate	VBG
18637	19919	51	taxicabs	taxicab	NNS
18637	19919	52	,	,	,
18637	19919	53	but	but	CC
18637	19919	54	not	not	RB
18637	19919	55	on	on	IN
18637	19919	56	individuals,[1059	individuals,[1059	NNP
18637	19919	57	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19919	58	have	have	VBP
18637	19919	59	been	be	VBN
18637	19919	60	held	hold	VBN
18637	19919	61	to	to	TO
18637	19919	62	be	be	VB
18637	19919	63	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	19919	64	to	to	IN
18637	19919	65	the	the	DT
18637	19919	66	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19919	67	protection	protection	NN
18637	19919	68	clause	clause	NN
18637	19919	69	.	.	.
18637	19920	1	But	but	CC
18637	19920	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19920	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	19920	4	not	not	RB
18637	19920	5	the	the	DT
18637	19920	6	function	function	NN
18637	19920	7	of	of	IN
18637	19920	8	the	the	DT
18637	19920	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19920	10	to	to	TO
18637	19920	11	consider	consider	VB
18637	19920	12	the	the	DT
18637	19920	13	propriety	propriety	NN
18637	19920	14	or	or	CC
18637	19920	15	justness	justness	NN
18637	19920	16	of	of	IN
18637	19920	17	the	the	DT
18637	19920	18	tax	tax	NN
18637	19920	19	,	,	,
18637	19920	20	to	to	TO
18637	19920	21	seek	seek	VB
18637	19920	22	for	for	IN
18637	19920	23	the	the	DT
18637	19920	24	motives	motive	NNS
18637	19920	25	and	and	CC
18637	19920	26	criticize	criticize	VB
18637	19920	27	the	the	DT
18637	19920	28	public	public	JJ
18637	19920	29	policy	policy	NN
18637	19920	30	which	which	WDT
18637	19920	31	prompted	prompt	VBD
18637	19920	32	the	the	DT
18637	19920	33	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	19920	34	of	of	IN
18637	19920	35	the	the	DT
18637	19920	36	statute	statute	NN
18637	19920	37	.	.	.
18637	19921	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19921	2	1060	1060	CD
18637	19921	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19921	4	If	if	IN
18637	19921	5	the	the	DT
18637	19921	6	evident	evident	JJ
18637	19921	7	intent	intent	NN
18637	19921	8	and	and	CC
18637	19921	9	general	general	JJ
18637	19921	10	operation	operation	NN
18637	19921	11	of	of	IN
18637	19921	12	the	the	DT
18637	19921	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	19921	14	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19921	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	19921	16	to	to	TO
18637	19921	17	adjust	adjust	VB
18637	19921	18	the	the	DT
18637	19921	19	burden	burden	NN
18637	19921	20	with	with	IN
18637	19921	21	a	a	DT
18637	19921	22	fair	fair	JJ
18637	19921	23	and	and	CC
18637	19921	24	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19921	25	degree	degree	NN
18637	19921	26	of	of	IN
18637	19921	27	equality	equality	NN
18637	19921	28	,	,	,
18637	19921	29	the	the	DT
18637	19921	30	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19921	31	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	19921	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	19921	33	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	19921	34	.	.	.
18637	19922	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19922	2	1061	1061	CD
18637	19922	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19922	4	One	one	CD
18637	19922	5	not	not	RB
18637	19922	6	within	within	IN
18637	19922	7	the	the	DT
18637	19922	8	class	class	NN
18637	19922	9	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	19922	10	to	to	TO
18637	19922	11	be	be	VB
18637	19922	12	discriminated	discriminate	VBN
18637	19922	13	against	against	IN
18637	19922	14	can	can	MD
18637	19922	15	not	not	RB
18637	19922	16	raise	raise	VB
18637	19922	17	the	the	DT
18637	19922	18	question	question	NN
18637	19922	19	of	of	IN
18637	19922	20	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	19922	21	of	of	IN
18637	19922	22	a	a	DT
18637	19922	23	statute	statute	NN
18637	19922	24	on	on	IN
18637	19922	25	the	the	DT
18637	19922	26	ground	ground	NN
18637	19922	27	that	that	IN
18637	19922	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19922	29	denies	deny	VBZ
18637	19922	30	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19922	31	protection	protection	NN
18637	19922	32	of	of	IN
18637	19922	33	the	the	DT
18637	19922	34	law	law	NN
18637	19922	35	.	.	.
18637	19923	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19923	2	1062	1062	CD
18637	19923	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19923	4	If	if	IN
18637	19923	5	a	a	DT
18637	19923	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	19923	7	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	19923	8	to	to	IN
18637	19923	9	a	a	DT
18637	19923	10	class	class	NN
18637	19923	11	which	which	WDT
18637	19923	12	may	may	MD
18637	19923	13	be	be	VB
18637	19923	14	separately	separately	RB
18637	19923	15	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19923	16	,	,	,
18637	19923	17	those	those	DT
18637	19923	18	within	within	IN
18637	19923	19	the	the	DT
18637	19923	20	class	class	NN
18637	19923	21	may	may	MD
18637	19923	22	not	not	RB
18637	19923	23	complain	complain	VB
18637	19923	24	because	because	IN
18637	19923	25	the	the	DT
18637	19923	26	class	class	NN
18637	19923	27	might	may	MD
18637	19923	28	have	have	VB
18637	19923	29	been	be	VBN
18637	19923	30	more	more	RBR
18637	19923	31	aptly	aptly	RB
18637	19923	32	defined	define	VBN
18637	19923	33	,	,	,
18637	19923	34	nor	nor	CC
18637	19923	35	because	because	IN
18637	19923	36	others	other	NNS
18637	19923	37	,	,	,
18637	19923	38	not	not	RB
18637	19923	39	of	of	IN
18637	19923	40	the	the	DT
18637	19923	41	class	class	NN
18637	19923	42	,	,	,
18637	19923	43	are	be	VBP
18637	19923	44	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19923	45	improperly	improperly	RB
18637	19923	46	.	.	.
18637	19924	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19924	2	1063	1063	CD
18637	19924	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19924	4	Foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19924	5	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19924	6	The	the	DT
18637	19924	7	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19924	8	protection	protection	NN
18637	19924	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	19924	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	19924	11	not	not	RB
18637	19924	12	require	require	VB
18637	19924	13	identical	identical	JJ
18637	19924	14	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19924	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	19924	16	all	all	DT
18637	19924	17	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19924	18	and	and	CC
18637	19924	19	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19924	20	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19924	21	in	in	IN
18637	19924	22	every	every	DT
18637	19924	23	case	case	NN
18637	19924	24	.	.	.
18637	19925	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19925	2	1064	1064	CD
18637	19925	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19925	4	In	in	IN
18637	19925	5	1886	1886	CD
18637	19925	6	,	,	,
18637	19925	7	a	a	DT
18637	19925	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	19925	9	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19925	10	previously	previously	RB
18637	19925	11	licensed	license	VBD
18637	19925	12	to	to	TO
18637	19925	13	do	do	VB
18637	19925	14	business	business	NN
18637	19925	15	in	in	IN
18637	19925	16	New	New	NNP
18637	19925	17	York	York	NNP
18637	19925	18	challenged	challenge	VBD
18637	19925	19	an	an	DT
18637	19925	20	increased	increase	VBN
18637	19925	21	annual	annual	JJ
18637	19925	22	license	license	NN
18637	19925	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	19925	24	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19925	25	by	by	IN
18637	19925	26	that	that	DT
18637	19925	27	State	State	NNP
18637	19925	28	in	in	IN
18637	19925	29	retaliation	retaliation	NN
18637	19925	30	for	for	IN
18637	19925	31	a	a	DT
18637	19925	32	like	like	JJ
18637	19925	33	tax	tax	NN
18637	19925	34	levied	levy	VBN
18637	19925	35	by	by	IN
18637	19925	36	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	19925	37	against	against	IN
18637	19925	38	New	New	NNP
18637	19925	39	York	York	NNP
18637	19925	40	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19925	41	.	.	.
18637	19926	1	This	this	DT
18637	19926	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	19926	3	was	be	VBD
18637	19926	4	held	hold	VBN
18637	19926	5	valid	valid	JJ
18637	19926	6	on	on	IN
18637	19926	7	the	the	DT
18637	19926	8	ground	ground	NN
18637	19926	9	that	that	IN
18637	19926	10	the	the	DT
18637	19926	11	State	State	NNP
18637	19926	12	,	,	,
18637	19926	13	having	have	VBG
18637	19926	14	power	power	NN
18637	19926	15	to	to	TO
18637	19926	16	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	19926	17	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	19926	18	,	,	,
18637	19926	19	could	could	MD
18637	19926	20	change	change	VB
18637	19926	21	the	the	DT
18637	19926	22	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19926	23	of	of	IN
18637	19926	24	admission	admission	NN
18637	19926	25	for	for	IN
18637	19926	26	the	the	DT
18637	19926	27	future	future	NN
18637	19926	28	,	,	,
18637	19926	29	and	and	CC
18637	19926	30	could	could	MD
18637	19926	31	demand	demand	VB
18637	19926	32	the	the	DT
18637	19926	33	payment	payment	NN
18637	19926	34	of	of	IN
18637	19926	35	a	a	DT
18637	19926	36	new	new	JJ
18637	19926	37	or	or	CC
18637	19926	38	further	further	JJ
18637	19926	39	tax	tax	NN
18637	19926	40	,	,	,
18637	19926	41	as	as	IN
18637	19926	42	a	a	DT
18637	19926	43	license	license	NN
18637	19926	44	fee	fee	NN
18637	19926	45	.	.	.
18637	19927	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19927	2	1065	1065	CD
18637	19927	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19927	4	Later	late	JJR
18637	19927	5	cases	case	NNS
18637	19927	6	whittled	whittle	VBD
18637	19927	7	down	down	RP
18637	19927	8	this	this	DT
18637	19927	9	rule	rule	NN
18637	19927	10	considerably	considerably	RB
18637	19927	11	.	.	.
18637	19928	1	The	the	DT
18637	19928	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19928	3	decided	decide	VBD
18637	19928	4	that	that	IN
18637	19928	5	"	"	``
18637	19928	6	after	after	IN
18637	19928	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19928	8	admission	admission	NN
18637	19928	9	,	,	,
18637	19928	10	the	the	DT
18637	19928	11	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19928	12	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19928	13	stands	stand	VBZ
18637	19928	14	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19928	15	and	and	CC
18637	19928	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	19928	17	to	to	TO
18637	19928	18	be	be	VB
18637	19928	19	classified	classify	VBN
18637	19928	20	with	with	IN
18637	19928	21	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19928	22	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19928	23	of	of	IN
18637	19928	24	the	the	DT
18637	19928	25	same	same	JJ
18637	19928	26	kind,"[1066	kind,"[1066	NNP
18637	19928	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19928	28	and	and	CC
18637	19928	29	that	that	IN
18637	19928	30	where	where	WRB
18637	19928	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19928	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	19928	33	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	19928	34	property	property	NN
18637	19928	35	of	of	IN
18637	19928	36	a	a	DT
18637	19928	37	fixed	fixed	JJ
18637	19928	38	and	and	CC
18637	19928	39	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	19928	40	nature	nature	NN
18637	19928	41	in	in	IN
18637	19928	42	a	a	DT
18637	19928	43	State	state	NN
18637	19928	44	,	,	,
18637	19928	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19928	46	can	can	MD
18637	19928	47	not	not	RB
18637	19928	48	be	be	VB
18637	19928	49	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	19928	50	to	to	IN
18637	19928	51	a	a	DT
18637	19928	52	more	more	RBR
18637	19928	53	onerous	onerous	JJ
18637	19928	54	tax	tax	NN
18637	19928	55	for	for	IN
18637	19928	56	the	the	DT
18637	19928	57	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19928	58	of	of	IN
18637	19928	59	doing	do	VBG
18637	19928	60	business	business	NN
18637	19928	61	than	than	IN
18637	19928	62	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19928	63	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19928	64	.	.	.
18637	19929	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19929	2	1067	1067	CD
18637	19929	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19929	4	A	a	DT
18637	19929	5	State	State	NNP
18637	19929	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	19929	7	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19929	8	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19929	9	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19929	10	writing	write	VBG
18637	19929	11	fire	fire	NN
18637	19929	12	,	,	,
18637	19929	13	marine	marine	NNP
18637	19929	14	,	,	,
18637	19929	15	inland	inland	NNP
18637	19929	16	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	19929	17	and	and	CC
18637	19929	18	casualty	casualty	NN
18637	19929	19	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19929	20	on	on	IN
18637	19929	21	net	net	JJ
18637	19929	22	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	19929	23	,	,	,
18637	19929	24	including	include	VBG
18637	19929	25	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	19929	26	from	from	IN
18637	19929	27	casualty	casualty	NN
18637	19929	28	business	business	NN
18637	19929	29	was	be	VBD
18637	19929	30	held	hold	VBN
18637	19929	31	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	19929	32	under	under	IN
18637	19929	33	the	the	DT
18637	19929	34	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19929	35	protection	protection	NN
18637	19929	36	clause	clause	NN
18637	19929	37	where	where	WRB
18637	19929	38	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19929	39	companies	company	NNS
18637	19929	40	writing	write	VBG
18637	19929	41	only	only	JJ
18637	19929	42	casualty	casualty	NN
18637	19929	43	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19929	44	were	be	VBD
18637	19929	45	not	not	RB
18637	19929	46	subject	subject	JJ
18637	19929	47	to	to	IN
18637	19929	48	a	a	DT
18637	19929	49	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19929	50	tax	tax	NN
18637	19929	51	.	.	.
18637	19930	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19930	2	1068	1068	CD
18637	19930	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19930	4	Recently	recently	RB
18637	19930	5	,	,	,
18637	19930	6	the	the	DT
18637	19930	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	19930	8	of	of	IN
18637	19930	9	Fire	Fire	NNP
18637	19930	10	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	19930	11	.	.	.
18637	19931	1	of	of	IN
18637	19931	2	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	19931	3	_	_	NNP
18637	19931	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	19931	5	_	_	NNP
18637	19931	6	New	New	NNP
18637	19931	7	York	York	NNP
18637	19931	8	was	be	VBD
18637	19931	9	revived	revive	VBN
18637	19931	10	to	to	TO
18637	19931	11	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	19931	12	an	an	DT
18637	19931	13	increased	increase	VBN
18637	19931	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	19931	15	on	on	IN
18637	19931	16	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19931	17	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	19931	18	which	which	WDT
18637	19931	19	was	be	VBD
18637	19931	20	exacted	exact	VBN
18637	19931	21	as	as	IN
18637	19931	22	an	an	DT
18637	19931	23	annual	annual	JJ
18637	19931	24	license	license	NN
18637	19931	25	fee	fee	NN
18637	19931	26	from	from	IN
18637	19931	27	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19931	28	but	but	CC
18637	19931	29	not	not	RB
18637	19931	30	from	from	IN
18637	19931	31	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19931	32	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19931	33	.	.	.
18637	19932	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19932	2	1069	1069	CD
18637	19932	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19932	4	Even	even	RB
18637	19932	5	though	though	IN
18637	19932	6	the	the	DT
18637	19932	7	right	right	NN
18637	19932	8	of	of	IN
18637	19932	9	a	a	DT
18637	19932	10	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	19932	11	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19932	12	to	to	TO
18637	19932	13	do	do	VB
18637	19932	14	business	business	NN
18637	19932	15	in	in	IN
18637	19932	16	a	a	DT
18637	19932	17	State	state	NN
18637	19932	18	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	19932	19	on	on	IN
18637	19932	20	a	a	DT
18637	19932	21	license	license	NN
18637	19932	22	,	,	,
18637	19932	23	yet	yet	CC
18637	19932	24	the	the	DT
18637	19932	25	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19932	26	protection	protection	NN
18637	19932	27	clause	clause	NN
18637	19932	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	19932	29	held	hold	VBN
18637	19932	30	to	to	TO
18637	19932	31	insure	insure	VB
18637	19932	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19932	33	equality	equality	NN
18637	19932	34	of	of	IN
18637	19932	35	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	19932	36	,	,	,
18637	19932	37	at	at	IN
18637	19932	38	least	least	JJS
18637	19932	39	so	so	RB
18637	19932	40	far	far	RB
18637	19932	41	as	as	IN
18637	19932	42	_	_	NNP
18637	19932	43	ad	ad	NN
18637	19932	44	valorem	valorem	NN
18637	19932	45	_	_	NNP
18637	19932	46	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19932	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	19932	48	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	19932	49	.	.	.
18637	19933	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19933	2	1070	1070	CD
18637	19933	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19933	4	Income	income	NN
18637	19933	5	Taxes	Taxes	NNP
18637	19933	6	A	a	DT
18637	19933	7	State	State	NNP
18637	19933	8	law	law	NN
18637	19933	9	which	which	WDT
18637	19933	10	taxes	tax	VBZ
18637	19933	11	the	the	DT
18637	19933	12	entire	entire	JJ
18637	19933	13	income	income	NN
18637	19933	14	,	,	,
18637	19933	15	including	include	VBG
18637	19933	16	that	that	DT
18637	19933	17	derived	derive	VBN
18637	19933	18	without	without	IN
18637	19933	19	the	the	DT
18637	19933	20	State	State	NNP
18637	19933	21	,	,	,
18637	19933	22	of	of	IN
18637	19933	23	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19933	24	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19933	25	which	which	WDT
18637	19933	26	do	do	VBP
18637	19933	27	business	business	NN
18637	19933	28	in	in	IN
18637	19933	29	the	the	DT
18637	19933	30	State	State	NNP
18637	19933	31	,	,	,
18637	19933	32	while	while	IN
18637	19933	33	exempting	exempt	VBG
18637	19933	34	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	19933	35	the	the	DT
18637	19933	36	income	income	NN
18637	19933	37	received	receive	VBD
18637	19933	38	outside	outside	IN
18637	19933	39	the	the	DT
18637	19933	40	State	State	NNP
18637	19933	41	by	by	IN
18637	19933	42	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19933	43	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	19933	44	which	which	WDT
18637	19933	45	do	do	VBP
18637	19933	46	no	no	DT
18637	19933	47	local	local	JJ
18637	19933	48	business	business	NN
18637	19933	49	,	,	,
18637	19933	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	19933	51	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19933	52	and	and	CC
18637	19933	53	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	19933	54	.	.	.
18637	19934	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19934	2	1071	1071	CD
18637	19934	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19934	4	In	in	IN
18637	19934	5	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19934	6	the	the	DT
18637	19934	7	income	income	NN
18637	19934	8	of	of	IN
18637	19934	9	a	a	DT
18637	19934	10	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	19934	11	,	,	,
18637	19934	12	there	there	EX
18637	19934	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	19934	14	no	no	DT
18637	19934	15	denial	denial	NN
18637	19934	16	of	of	IN
18637	19934	17	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19934	18	protection	protection	NN
18637	19934	19	in	in	IN
18637	19934	20	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	19934	21	the	the	DT
18637	19934	22	deduction	deduction	NN
18637	19934	23	of	of	IN
18637	19934	24	losses	loss	NNS
18637	19934	25	to	to	IN
18637	19934	26	those	those	DT
18637	19934	27	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	19934	28	within	within	IN
18637	19934	29	the	the	DT
18637	19934	30	State	State	NNP
18637	19934	31	,	,	,
18637	19934	32	although	although	IN
18637	19934	33	residents	resident	NNS
18637	19934	34	are	be	VBP
18637	19934	35	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	19934	36	to	to	TO
18637	19934	37	deduct	deduct	VB
18637	19934	38	all	all	DT
18637	19934	39	losses	loss	NNS
18637	19934	40	,	,	,
18637	19934	41	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	19934	42	incurred	incur	VBN
18637	19934	43	.	.	.
18637	19935	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19935	2	1072	1072	CD
18637	19935	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19935	4	A	a	DT
18637	19935	5	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	19935	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	19935	7	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	19935	8	a	a	DT
18637	19935	9	graduated	graduate	VBN
18637	19935	10	tax	tax	NN
18637	19935	11	at	at	IN
18637	19935	12	rates	rate	NNS
18637	19935	13	different	different	JJ
18637	19935	14	from	from	IN
18637	19935	15	those	those	DT
18637	19935	16	in	in	IN
18637	19935	17	the	the	DT
18637	19935	18	general	general	JJ
18637	19935	19	income	income	NN
18637	19935	20	tax	tax	NN
18637	19935	21	law	law	NN
18637	19935	22	,	,	,
18637	19935	23	on	on	IN
18637	19935	24	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	19935	25	received	receive	VBN
18637	19935	26	in	in	IN
18637	19935	27	a	a	DT
18637	19935	28	prior	prior	JJ
18637	19935	29	year	year	NN
18637	19935	30	which	which	WDT
18637	19935	31	were	be	VBD
18637	19935	32	deductible	deductible	JJ
18637	19935	33	from	from	IN
18637	19935	34	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19935	35	income	income	NN
18637	19935	36	under	under	IN
18637	19935	37	the	the	DT
18637	19935	38	law	law	NN
18637	19935	39	in	in	IN
18637	19935	40	effect	effect	NN
18637	19935	41	when	when	WRB
18637	19935	42	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19935	43	were	be	VBD
18637	19935	44	received	receive	VBN
18637	19935	45	,	,	,
18637	19935	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	19935	47	not	not	RB
18637	19935	48	obnoxious	obnoxious	JJ
18637	19935	49	to	to	IN
18637	19935	50	the	the	DT
18637	19935	51	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19935	52	protection	protection	NN
18637	19935	53	clause	clause	NN
18637	19935	54	.	.	.
18637	19936	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19936	2	1073	1073	CD
18637	19936	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19936	4	Inheritance	Inheritance	NNP
18637	19936	5	Taxes	Taxes	NNP
18637	19936	6	In	in	IN
18637	19936	7	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	19936	8	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19936	9	,	,	,
18637	19936	10	there	there	EX
18637	19936	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	19936	12	no	no	DT
18637	19936	13	denial	denial	NN
18637	19936	14	of	of	IN
18637	19936	15	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19936	16	protection	protection	NN
18637	19936	17	in	in	IN
18637	19936	18	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	19936	19	different	different	JJ
18637	19936	20	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	19936	21	for	for	IN
18637	19936	22	lineal	lineal	NN
18637	19936	23	relations	relation	NNS
18637	19936	24	,	,	,
18637	19936	25	collateral	collateral	NN
18637	19936	26	kindred	kindred	NNP
18637	19936	27	and	and	CC
18637	19936	28	strangers	stranger	NNS
18637	19936	29	of	of	IN
18637	19936	30	the	the	DT
18637	19936	31	blood	blood	NN
18637	19936	32	,	,	,
18637	19936	33	or	or	CC
18637	19936	34	in	in	IN
18637	19936	35	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	19936	36	the	the	DT
18637	19936	37	proportionate	proportionate	NN
18637	19936	38	burden	burden	NN
18637	19936	39	of	of	IN
18637	19936	40	the	the	DT
18637	19936	41	tax	tax	NN
18637	19936	42	progressively	progressively	RB
18637	19936	43	as	as	IN
18637	19936	44	the	the	DT
18637	19936	45	amount	amount	NN
18637	19936	46	of	of	IN
18637	19936	47	the	the	DT
18637	19936	48	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19936	49	increases	increase	NNS
18637	19936	50	.	.	.
18637	19937	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19937	2	1074	1074	CD
18637	19937	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19937	4	A	a	DT
18637	19937	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	19937	6	on	on	IN
18637	19937	7	life	life	NN
18637	19937	8	estates	estate	NNS
18637	19937	9	where	where	WRB
18637	19937	10	the	the	DT
18637	19937	11	remainder	remainder	NN
18637	19937	12	passes	pass	VBZ
18637	19937	13	to	to	TO
18637	19937	14	lineal	lineal	VB
18637	19937	15	heirs	heir	NNS
18637	19937	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	19937	17	valid	valid	JJ
18637	19937	18	despite	despite	IN
18637	19937	19	the	the	DT
18637	19937	20	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	19937	21	of	of	IN
18637	19937	22	life	life	NN
18637	19937	23	estates	estate	NNS
18637	19937	24	where	where	WRB
18637	19937	25	the	the	DT
18637	19937	26	remainder	remainder	NN
18637	19937	27	passes	pass	VBZ
18637	19937	28	to	to	IN
18637	19937	29	collateral	collateral	NN
18637	19937	30	heirs;[1075	heirs;[1075	LS
18637	19937	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19937	32	there	there	EX
18637	19937	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	19937	34	no	no	DT
18637	19937	35	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19937	36	classification	classification	NN
18637	19937	37	in	in	IN
18637	19937	38	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19937	39	the	the	DT
18637	19937	40	transmission	transmission	NN
18637	19937	41	of	of	IN
18637	19937	42	property	property	NN
18637	19937	43	to	to	IN
18637	19937	44	a	a	DT
18637	19937	45	brother	brother	NN
18637	19937	46	or	or	CC
18637	19937	47	sister	sister	NN
18637	19937	48	,	,	,
18637	19937	49	while	while	IN
18637	19937	50	exempting	exempt	VBG
18637	19937	51	that	that	DT
18637	19937	52	to	to	IN
18637	19937	53	a	a	DT
18637	19937	54	son	son	NN
18637	19937	55	-	-	HYPH
18637	19937	56	in	in	IN
18637	19937	57	-	-	HYPH
18637	19937	58	law	law	NN
18637	19937	59	or	or	CC
18637	19937	60	a	a	DT
18637	19937	61	daughter	daughter	NN
18637	19937	62	-	-	HYPH
18637	19937	63	in	in	IN
18637	19937	64	-	-	HYPH
18637	19937	65	law	law	NN
18637	19937	66	.	.	.
18637	19938	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19938	2	1076	1076	CD
18637	19938	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19938	4	Vested	vest	VBN
18637	19938	5	and	and	CC
18637	19938	6	contingent	contingent	JJ
18637	19938	7	remainders	remainder	NNS
18637	19938	8	may	may	MD
18637	19938	9	be	be	VB
18637	19938	10	treated	treat	VBN
18637	19938	11	differently	differently	RB
18637	19938	12	.	.	.
18637	19939	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19939	2	1077	1077	CD
18637	19939	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19939	4	The	the	DT
18637	19939	5	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	19939	6	of	of	IN
18637	19939	7	property	property	NN
18637	19939	8	bequeathed	bequeath	VBD
18637	19939	9	to	to	TO
18637	19939	10	charitable	charitable	JJ
18637	19939	11	or	or	CC
18637	19939	12	educational	educational	JJ
18637	19939	13	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	19939	14	may	may	MD
18637	19939	15	be	be	VB
18637	19939	16	limited	limited	JJ
18637	19939	17	to	to	IN
18637	19939	18	those	those	DT
18637	19939	19	within	within	IN
18637	19939	20	the	the	DT
18637	19939	21	State	State	NNP
18637	19939	22	.	.	.
18637	19940	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19940	2	1078	1078	CD
18637	19940	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19940	4	In	in	IN
18637	19940	5	computing	compute	VBG
18637	19940	6	the	the	DT
18637	19940	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	19940	8	collectible	collectible	JJ
18637	19940	9	from	from	IN
18637	19940	10	a	a	DT
18637	19940	11	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	19940	12	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	19940	13	's	's	POS
18637	19940	14	property	property	NN
18637	19940	15	within	within	IN
18637	19940	16	the	the	DT
18637	19940	17	State	State	NNP
18637	19940	18	,	,	,
18637	19940	19	a	a	DT
18637	19940	20	State	state	NN
18637	19940	21	may	may	MD
18637	19940	22	apply	apply	VB
18637	19940	23	the	the	DT
18637	19940	24	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	19940	25	rates	rate	NNS
18637	19940	26	to	to	IN
18637	19940	27	the	the	DT
18637	19940	28	whole	whole	JJ
18637	19940	29	estate	estate	NN
18637	19940	30	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	19940	31	located	locate	VBN
18637	19940	32	,	,	,
18637	19940	33	and	and	CC
18637	19940	34	take	take	VB
18637	19940	35	that	that	DT
18637	19940	36	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	19940	37	thereof	thereof	IN
18637	19940	38	which	which	WDT
18637	19940	39	the	the	DT
18637	19940	40	property	property	NN
18637	19940	41	within	within	IN
18637	19940	42	the	the	DT
18637	19940	43	State	state	NN
18637	19940	44	bears	bear	VBZ
18637	19940	45	to	to	IN
18637	19940	46	the	the	DT
18637	19940	47	total	total	NN
18637	19940	48	;	;	:
18637	19940	49	the	the	DT
18637	19940	50	fact	fact	NN
18637	19940	51	that	that	IN
18637	19940	52	a	a	DT
18637	19940	53	greater	great	JJR
18637	19940	54	tax	tax	NN
18637	19940	55	may	may	MD
18637	19940	56	result	result	VB
18637	19940	57	than	than	IN
18637	19940	58	would	would	MD
18637	19940	59	be	be	VB
18637	19940	60	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	19940	61	on	on	IN
18637	19940	62	an	an	DT
18637	19940	63	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19940	64	amount	amount	NN
18637	19940	65	of	of	IN
18637	19940	66	property	property	NN
18637	19940	67	if	if	IN
18637	19940	68	owned	own	VBN
18637	19940	69	by	by	IN
18637	19940	70	a	a	DT
18637	19940	71	resident,[1079	resident,[1079	NNP
18637	19940	72	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19940	73	does	do	VBZ
18637	19940	74	not	not	RB
18637	19940	75	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	19940	76	the	the	DT
18637	19940	77	result	result	NN
18637	19940	78	.	.	.
18637	19941	1	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	19941	2	Vehicle	Vehicle	NNP
18637	19941	3	Taxes	Taxes	NNP
18637	19941	4	In	in	IN
18637	19941	5	demanding	demand	VBG
18637	19941	6	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19941	7	for	for	IN
18637	19941	8	the	the	DT
18637	19941	9	use	use	NN
18637	19941	10	of	of	IN
18637	19941	11	highways	highway	NNS
18637	19941	12	,	,	,
18637	19941	13	a	a	DT
18637	19941	14	State	state	NN
18637	19941	15	may	may	MD
18637	19941	16	exempt	exempt	VB
18637	19941	17	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19941	18	types	type	NNS
18637	19941	19	of	of	IN
18637	19941	20	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	19941	21	,	,	,
18637	19941	22	according	accord	VBG
18637	19941	23	to	to	IN
18637	19941	24	the	the	DT
18637	19941	25	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	19941	26	for	for	IN
18637	19941	27	which	which	WDT
18637	19941	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19941	29	are	be	VBP
18637	19941	30	used	use	VBN
18637	19941	31	,	,	,
18637	19941	32	from	from	IN
18637	19941	33	a	a	DT
18637	19941	34	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	19941	35	tax	tax	NN
18637	19941	36	on	on	IN
18637	19941	37	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19941	38	.	.	.
18637	19942	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19942	2	1080	1080	CD
18637	19942	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19942	4	A	a	DT
18637	19942	5	State	State	NNP
18637	19942	6	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	19942	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	19942	8	act	act	NN
18637	19942	9	,	,	,
18637	19942	10	which	which	WDT
18637	19942	11	taxes	tax	VBZ
18637	19942	12	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	19942	13	property	property	NN
18637	19942	14	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19942	15	for	for	IN
18637	19942	16	hire	hire	NN
18637	19942	17	at	at	IN
18637	19942	18	greater	great	JJR
18637	19942	19	rates	rate	NNS
18637	19942	20	than	than	IN
18637	19942	21	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19942	22	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	19942	23	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	19942	24	property	property	NN
18637	19942	25	not	not	RB
18637	19942	26	for	for	IN
18637	19942	27	hire	hire	NN
18637	19942	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	19942	29	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19942	30	,	,	,
18637	19942	31	since	since	IN
18637	19942	32	the	the	DT
18637	19942	33	use	use	NN
18637	19942	34	of	of	IN
18637	19942	35	roads	road	NNS
18637	19942	36	by	by	IN
18637	19942	37	one	one	CD
18637	19942	38	hauling	haul	VBG
18637	19942	39	not	not	RB
18637	19942	40	for	for	IN
18637	19942	41	hire	hire	NN
18637	19942	42	generally	generally	RB
18637	19942	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	19942	44	limited	limit	VBN
18637	19942	45	to	to	IN
18637	19942	46	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	19942	47	of	of	IN
18637	19942	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19942	49	own	own	JJ
18637	19942	50	property	property	NN
18637	19942	51	as	as	IN
18637	19942	52	an	an	DT
18637	19942	53	incident	incident	NN
18637	19942	54	to	to	IN
18637	19942	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19942	56	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	19942	57	and	and	CC
18637	19942	58	is	be	VBZ
18637	19942	59	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	19942	60	less	less	JJR
18637	19942	61	than	than	IN
18637	19942	62	that	that	DT
18637	19942	63	of	of	IN
18637	19942	64	one	one	NN
18637	19942	65	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	19942	66	in	in	IN
18637	19942	67	business	business	NN
18637	19942	68	as	as	IN
18637	19942	69	a	a	DT
18637	19942	70	common	common	JJ
18637	19942	71	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	19942	72	.	.	.
18637	19943	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19943	2	1081	1081	CD
18637	19943	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19943	4	A	a	DT
18637	19943	5	property	property	NN
18637	19943	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	19943	7	on	on	IN
18637	19943	8	motor	motor	NN
18637	19943	9	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	19943	10	used	use	VBN
18637	19943	11	in	in	IN
18637	19943	12	operating	operate	VBG
18637	19943	13	a	a	DT
18637	19943	14	stage	stage	NN
18637	19943	15	line	line	NN
18637	19943	16	that	that	WDT
18637	19943	17	makes	make	VBZ
18637	19943	18	constant	constant	JJ
18637	19943	19	and	and	CC
18637	19943	20	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	19943	21	use	use	NN
18637	19943	22	of	of	IN
18637	19943	23	the	the	DT
18637	19943	24	highways	highway	NNS
18637	19943	25	may	may	MD
18637	19943	26	be	be	VB
18637	19943	27	measured	measure	VBN
18637	19943	28	by	by	IN
18637	19943	29	gross	gross	JJ
18637	19943	30	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	19943	31	and	and	CC
18637	19943	32	be	be	VB
18637	19943	33	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	19943	34	at	at	IN
18637	19943	35	a	a	DT
18637	19943	36	higher	high	JJR
18637	19943	37	rate	rate	NN
18637	19943	38	than	than	IN
18637	19943	39	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19943	40	on	on	IN
18637	19943	41	property	property	NN
18637	19943	42	not	not	RB
18637	19943	43	so	so	RB
18637	19943	44	employed	employ	VBN
18637	19943	45	.	.	.
18637	19944	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19944	2	1082	1082	CD
18637	19944	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19944	4	Common	common	JJ
18637	19944	5	motor	motor	NN
18637	19944	6	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19944	7	of	of	IN
18637	19944	8	freight	freight	NN
18637	19944	9	operating	operate	VBG
18637	19944	10	over	over	IN
18637	19944	11	regular	regular	JJ
18637	19944	12	routes	route	NNS
18637	19944	13	between	between	IN
18637	19944	14	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	19944	15	termini	termini	NN
18637	19944	16	may	may	MD
18637	19944	17	be	be	VB
18637	19944	18	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19944	19	at	at	IN
18637	19944	20	higher	high	JJR
18637	19944	21	rates	rate	NNS
18637	19944	22	than	than	IN
18637	19944	23	other	other	JJ
18637	19944	24	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19944	25	,	,	,
18637	19944	26	common	common	JJ
18637	19944	27	and	and	CC
18637	19944	28	private	private	JJ
18637	19944	29	.	.	.
18637	19945	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19945	2	1083	1083	CD
18637	19945	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19945	4	A	a	DT
18637	19945	5	fee	fee	NN
18637	19945	6	for	for	IN
18637	19945	7	the	the	DT
18637	19945	8	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	19945	9	of	of	IN
18637	19945	10	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	19945	11	motor	motor	NN
18637	19945	12	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	19945	13	on	on	IN
18637	19945	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19945	15	own	own	JJ
18637	19945	16	wheels	wheel	NNS
18637	19945	17	over	over	IN
18637	19945	18	the	the	DT
18637	19945	19	highways	highway	NNS
18637	19945	20	of	of	IN
18637	19945	21	the	the	DT
18637	19945	22	State	State	NNP
18637	19945	23	for	for	IN
18637	19945	24	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	19945	25	of	of	IN
18637	19945	26	sale	sale	NN
18637	19945	27	,	,	,
18637	19945	28	does	do	VBZ
18637	19945	29	not	not	RB
18637	19945	30	violate	violate	VB
18637	19945	31	the	the	DT
18637	19945	32	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19945	33	protection	protection	NN
18637	19945	34	clause	clause	NN
18637	19945	35	as	as	IN
18637	19945	36	applied	apply	VBN
18637	19945	37	to	to	IN
18637	19945	38	cars	car	NNS
18637	19945	39	moving	move	VBG
18637	19945	40	in	in	IN
18637	19945	41	caravans	caravan	NNS
18637	19945	42	.	.	.
18637	19946	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19946	2	1084	1084	CD
18637	19946	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19946	4	The	the	DT
18637	19946	5	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	19946	6	from	from	IN
18637	19946	7	a	a	DT
18637	19946	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	19946	9	for	for	IN
18637	19946	10	a	a	DT
18637	19946	11	permit	permit	NN
18637	19946	12	to	to	TO
18637	19946	13	bring	bring	VB
18637	19946	14	cars	car	NNS
18637	19946	15	into	into	IN
18637	19946	16	the	the	DT
18637	19946	17	State	State	NNP
18637	19946	18	in	in	IN
18637	19946	19	caravans	caravan	NNS
18637	19946	20	of	of	IN
18637	19946	21	cars	car	NNS
18637	19946	22	moved	move	VBN
18637	19946	23	for	for	IN
18637	19946	24	sale	sale	NN
18637	19946	25	between	between	IN
18637	19946	26	zones	zone	NNS
18637	19946	27	in	in	IN
18637	19946	28	the	the	DT
18637	19946	29	State	State	NNP
18637	19946	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	19946	31	not	not	RB
18637	19946	32	an	an	DT
18637	19946	33	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19946	34	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19946	35	where	where	WRB
18637	19946	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19946	37	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	19946	38	that	that	IN
18637	19946	39	the	the	DT
18637	19946	40	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	19946	41	subject	subject	NN
18637	19946	42	to	to	IN
18637	19946	43	the	the	DT
18637	19946	44	tax	tax	NN
18637	19946	45	places	place	NNS
18637	19946	46	a	a	DT
18637	19946	47	much	much	RB
18637	19946	48	more	more	RBR
18637	19946	49	serious	serious	JJ
18637	19946	50	burden	burden	NN
18637	19946	51	on	on	IN
18637	19946	52	the	the	DT
18637	19946	53	highways	highway	NNS
18637	19946	54	than	than	IN
18637	19946	55	that	that	DT
18637	19946	56	which	which	WDT
18637	19946	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	19946	58	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	19946	59	.	.	.
18637	19947	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19947	2	1085	1085	CD
18637	19947	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19947	4	The	the	DT
18637	19947	5	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	19947	6	of	of	IN
18637	19947	7	small	small	JJ
18637	19947	8	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	19947	9	from	from	IN
18637	19947	10	graduated	graduated	JJ
18637	19947	11	registration	registration	NN
18637	19947	12	fees	fee	NNS
18637	19947	13	on	on	IN
18637	19947	14	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19947	15	for	for	IN
18637	19947	16	hire,[1086	hire,[1086	NNP
18637	19947	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19947	18	and	and	CC
18637	19947	19	of	of	IN
18637	19947	20	persons	person	NNS
18637	19947	21	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19947	22	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	19947	23	haul	haul	VBP
18637	19947	24	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	19947	25	and	and	CC
18637	19947	26	farm	farm	NN
18637	19947	27	products	product	NNS
18637	19947	28	between	between	IN
18637	19947	29	points	point	NNS
18637	19947	30	not	not	RB
18637	19947	31	having	have	VBG
18637	19947	32	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19947	33	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	19947	34	or	or	CC
18637	19947	35	hauling	haul	VBG
18637	19947	36	farm	farm	NN
18637	19947	37	and	and	CC
18637	19947	38	dairy	dairy	NN
18637	19947	39	products	product	NNS
18637	19947	40	for	for	IN
18637	19947	41	a	a	DT
18637	19947	42	producer	producer	NN
18637	19947	43	from	from	IN
18637	19947	44	a	a	DT
18637	19947	45	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	19947	46	license	license	NN
18637	19947	47	tax	tax	NN
18637	19947	48	on	on	IN
18637	19947	49	private	private	JJ
18637	19947	50	motor	motor	NN
18637	19947	51	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19947	52	,	,	,
18637	19947	53	has	have	VBZ
18637	19947	54	been	be	VBN
18637	19947	55	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	19947	56	.	.	.
18637	19948	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19948	2	1087	1087	CD
18637	19948	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19948	4	Poll	Poll	NNP
18637	19948	5	Taxes	Taxes	NNP
18637	19948	6	A	a	DT
18637	19948	7	poll	poll	NN
18637	19948	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	19948	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	19948	10	exempting	exempt	VBG
18637	19948	11	women	woman	NNS
18637	19948	12	,	,	,
18637	19948	13	the	the	DT
18637	19948	14	aged	aged	JJ
18637	19948	15	and	and	CC
18637	19948	16	minors	minor	NNS
18637	19948	17	,	,	,
18637	19948	18	does	do	VBZ
18637	19948	19	not	not	RB
18637	19948	20	make	make	VB
18637	19948	21	an	an	DT
18637	19948	22	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19948	23	classification[1088	classification[1088	NNP
18637	19948	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19948	25	.	.	.
18637	19949	1	Property	property	NN
18637	19949	2	Taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19949	3	The	the	DT
18637	19949	4	State	State	NNP
18637	19949	5	's	's	POS
18637	19949	6	latitude	latitude	NN
18637	19949	7	of	of	IN
18637	19949	8	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	19949	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19949	10	notably	notably	RB
18637	19949	11	wide	wide	JJ
18637	19949	12	in	in	IN
18637	19949	13	the	the	DT
18637	19949	14	classification	classification	NN
18637	19949	15	of	of	IN
18637	19949	16	property	property	NN
18637	19949	17	for	for	IN
18637	19949	18	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19949	19	of	of	IN
18637	19949	20	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19949	21	and	and	CC
18637	19949	22	the	the	DT
18637	19949	23	granting	granting	NN
18637	19949	24	of	of	IN
18637	19949	25	partial	partial	JJ
18637	19949	26	or	or	CC
18637	19949	27	total	total	JJ
18637	19949	28	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	19949	29	on	on	IN
18637	19949	30	the	the	DT
18637	19949	31	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	19949	32	of	of	IN
18637	19949	33	policy,[1089	policy,[1089	NNP
18637	19949	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19949	35	whether	whether	IN
18637	19949	36	the	the	DT
18637	19949	37	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	19949	38	results	result	VBZ
18637	19949	39	from	from	IN
18637	19949	40	the	the	DT
18637	19949	41	terms	term	NNS
18637	19949	42	of	of	IN
18637	19949	43	the	the	DT
18637	19949	44	statute	statute	NN
18637	19949	45	or	or	CC
18637	19949	46	the	the	DT
18637	19949	47	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	19949	48	of	of	IN
18637	19949	49	a	a	DT
18637	19949	50	State	State	NNP
18637	19949	51	official	official	NN
18637	19949	52	under	under	IN
18637	19949	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19949	54	.	.	.
18637	19950	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19950	2	1090	1090	CD
18637	19950	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19950	4	A	a	DT
18637	19950	5	provision	provision	NN
18637	19950	6	for	for	IN
18637	19950	7	the	the	DT
18637	19950	8	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	19950	9	of	of	IN
18637	19950	10	land	land	NN
18637	19950	11	for	for	IN
18637	19950	12	nonpayment	nonpayment	NN
18637	19950	13	of	of	IN
18637	19950	14	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	19950	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	19950	16	not	not	RB
18637	19950	17	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	19950	18	because	because	IN
18637	19950	19	the	the	DT
18637	19950	20	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19950	21	to	to	TO
18637	19950	22	which	which	WDT
18637	19950	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19950	24	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	19950	25	exist	exist	VBP
18637	19950	26	only	only	RB
18637	19950	27	in	in	IN
18637	19950	28	a	a	DT
18637	19950	29	part	part	NN
18637	19950	30	of	of	IN
18637	19950	31	the	the	DT
18637	19950	32	State	State	NNP
18637	19950	33	.	.	.
18637	19951	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19951	2	1091	1091	CD
18637	19951	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19951	4	Intentional	intentional	JJ
18637	19951	5	and	and	CC
18637	19951	6	systematic	systematic	JJ
18637	19951	7	undervaluation	undervaluation	NN
18637	19951	8	by	by	IN
18637	19951	9	State	State	NNP
18637	19951	10	officials	official	NNS
18637	19951	11	of	of	IN
18637	19951	12	other	other	JJ
18637	19951	13	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	19951	14	property	property	NN
18637	19951	15	in	in	IN
18637	19951	16	the	the	DT
18637	19951	17	same	same	JJ
18637	19951	18	class	class	NN
18637	19951	19	contravenes	contravene	NNS
18637	19951	20	the	the	DT
18637	19951	21	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19951	22	right	right	NN
18637	19951	23	of	of	IN
18637	19951	24	one	one	CD
18637	19951	25	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19951	26	upon	upon	IN
18637	19951	27	the	the	DT
18637	19951	28	full	full	JJ
18637	19951	29	value	value	NN
18637	19951	30	of	of	IN
18637	19951	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19951	32	property;[1092	property;[1092	-RRB-
18637	19951	33	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19951	34	but	but	CC
18637	19951	35	mere	mere	JJ
18637	19951	36	errors	error	NNS
18637	19951	37	in	in	IN
18637	19951	38	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	19951	39	resulting	result	VBG
18637	19951	40	in	in	IN
18637	19951	41	unequal	unequal	JJ
18637	19951	42	overvaluation	overvaluation	NN
18637	19951	43	or	or	CC
18637	19951	44	undervaluation	undervaluation	NN
18637	19951	45	,	,	,
18637	19951	46	not	not	RB
18637	19951	47	intentional	intentional	JJ
18637	19951	48	or	or	CC
18637	19951	49	systematic	systematic	JJ
18637	19951	50	,	,	,
18637	19951	51	will	will	MD
18637	19951	52	not	not	RB
18637	19951	53	support	support	VB
18637	19951	54	a	a	DT
18637	19951	55	claim	claim	NN
18637	19951	56	of	of	IN
18637	19951	57	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19951	58	.	.	.
18637	19952	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19952	2	1093	1093	CD
18637	19952	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19952	4	Differences	difference	NNS
18637	19952	5	in	in	IN
18637	19952	6	the	the	DT
18637	19952	7	basis	basis	NN
18637	19952	8	of	of	IN
18637	19952	9	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19952	10	are	be	VBP
18637	19952	11	not	not	RB
18637	19952	12	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	19952	13	where	where	WRB
18637	19952	14	the	the	DT
18637	19952	15	person	person	NN
18637	19952	16	or	or	CC
18637	19952	17	property	property	NN
18637	19952	18	affected	affect	VBN
18637	19952	19	might	may	MD
18637	19952	20	properly	properly	RB
18637	19952	21	be	be	VB
18637	19952	22	placed	place	VBN
18637	19952	23	in	in	IN
18637	19952	24	a	a	DT
18637	19952	25	separate	separate	JJ
18637	19952	26	class	class	NN
18637	19952	27	for	for	IN
18637	19952	28	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	19952	29	of	of	IN
18637	19952	30	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	19952	31	.	.	.
18637	19953	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19953	2	1094	1094	CD
18637	19953	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19953	4	An	an	DT
18637	19953	5	owner	owner	NN
18637	19953	6	aggrieved	aggrieve	VBN
18637	19953	7	by	by	IN
18637	19953	8	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19953	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19953	10	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	19953	11	to	to	TO
18637	19953	12	have	have	VB
18637	19953	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19953	14	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19953	15	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	19953	16	to	to	IN
18637	19953	17	the	the	DT
18637	19953	18	common	common	JJ
18637	19953	19	level	level	NN
18637	19953	20	.	.	.
18637	19954	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19954	2	1095	1095	CD
18637	19954	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19954	4	Equal	equal	JJ
18637	19954	5	protection	protection	NN
18637	19954	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	19954	7	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19954	8	if	if	IN
18637	19954	9	a	a	DT
18637	19954	10	State	state	NN
18637	19954	11	does	do	VBZ
18637	19954	12	not	not	RB
18637	19954	13	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19954	14	remove	remove	VB
18637	19954	15	the	the	DT
18637	19954	16	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19954	17	;	;	:
18637	19954	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19954	19	can	can	MD
18637	19954	20	not	not	RB
18637	19954	21	impose	impose	VB
18637	19954	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	19954	23	the	the	DT
18637	19954	24	person	person	NN
18637	19954	25	against	against	IN
18637	19954	26	whom	whom	WP
18637	19954	27	the	the	DT
18637	19954	28	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19954	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	19954	30	directed	direct	VBN
18637	19954	31	the	the	DT
18637	19954	32	burden	burden	NN
18637	19954	33	of	of	IN
18637	19954	34	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	19954	35	an	an	DT
18637	19954	36	upward	upward	JJ
18637	19954	37	revision	revision	NN
18637	19954	38	of	of	IN
18637	19954	39	the	the	DT
18637	19954	40	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19954	41	of	of	IN
18637	19954	42	other	other	JJ
18637	19954	43	members	member	NNS
18637	19954	44	of	of	IN
18637	19954	45	the	the	DT
18637	19954	46	class	class	NN
18637	19954	47	.	.	.
18637	19955	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19955	2	1096	1096	CD
18637	19955	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19955	4	A	a	DT
18637	19955	5	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	19955	6	whose	whose	WP$
18637	19955	7	valuations	valuation	NNS
18637	19955	8	were	be	VBD
18637	19955	9	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	19955	10	by	by	IN
18637	19955	11	the	the	DT
18637	19955	12	assessing	assess	VBG
18637	19955	13	commission	commission	NN
18637	19955	14	can	can	MD
18637	19955	15	not	not	RB
18637	19955	16	complain	complain	VB
18637	19955	17	that	that	IN
18637	19955	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19955	19	was	be	VBD
18637	19955	20	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	19955	21	disproportionately	disproportionately	RB
18637	19955	22	,	,	,
18637	19955	23	as	as	IN
18637	19955	24	compared	compare	VBN
18637	19955	25	with	with	IN
18637	19955	26	others	other	NNS
18637	19955	27	,	,	,
18637	19955	28	if	if	IN
18637	19955	29	the	the	DT
18637	19955	30	commission	commission	NN
18637	19955	31	did	do	VBD
18637	19955	32	not	not	RB
18637	19955	33	act	act	VB
18637	19955	34	fraudulently	fraudulently	RB
18637	19955	35	.	.	.
18637	19956	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19956	2	1097	1097	CD
18637	19956	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19956	4	Special	Special	NNP
18637	19956	5	Assessment	Assessment	NNP
18637	19956	6	A	a	DT
18637	19956	7	special	special	JJ
18637	19956	8	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19956	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	19956	10	not	not	RB
18637	19956	11	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	19956	12	because	because	IN
18637	19956	13	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	19956	14	on	on	IN
18637	19956	15	an	an	DT
18637	19956	16	_	_	NNP
18637	19956	17	ad	ad	NN
18637	19956	18	valorem	valorem	NN
18637	19956	19	_	_	NNP
18637	19956	20	basis	basis	NN
18637	19956	21	,	,	,
18637	19956	22	nor	nor	CC
18637	19956	23	does	do	VBZ
18637	19956	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19956	25	validity	validity	NN
18637	19956	26	depend	depend	VB
18637	19956	27	upon	upon	IN
18637	19956	28	the	the	DT
18637	19956	29	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	19956	30	of	of	IN
18637	19956	31	some	some	DT
18637	19956	32	special	special	JJ
18637	19956	33	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19956	34	as	as	IN
18637	19956	35	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	19956	36	from	from	IN
18637	19956	37	the	the	DT
18637	19956	38	general	general	JJ
18637	19956	39	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19956	40	to	to	IN
18637	19956	41	the	the	DT
18637	19956	42	community	community	NN
18637	19956	43	.	.	.
18637	19957	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19957	2	1098	1098	CD
18637	19957	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19957	4	Railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19957	5	property	property	NN
18637	19957	6	may	may	MD
18637	19957	7	not	not	RB
18637	19957	8	be	be	VB
18637	19957	9	burdened	burden	VBN
18637	19957	10	for	for	IN
18637	19957	11	local	local	JJ
18637	19957	12	improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	19957	13	upon	upon	IN
18637	19957	14	a	a	DT
18637	19957	15	basis	basis	NN
18637	19957	16	so	so	RB
18637	19957	17	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	19957	18	different	different	JJ
18637	19957	19	from	from	IN
18637	19957	20	that	that	DT
18637	19957	21	used	use	VBN
18637	19957	22	for	for	IN
18637	19957	23	ascertaining	ascertain	VBG
18637	19957	24	the	the	DT
18637	19957	25	contribution	contribution	NN
18637	19957	26	demanded	demand	VBN
18637	19957	27	of	of	IN
18637	19957	28	individual	individual	JJ
18637	19957	29	owners	owner	NNS
18637	19957	30	as	as	IN
18637	19957	31	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	19957	32	to	to	TO
18637	19957	33	produce	produce	VB
18637	19957	34	manifest	manifest	NN
18637	19957	35	inequality	inequality	NN
18637	19957	36	.	.	.
18637	19958	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19958	2	1099	1099	CD
18637	19958	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19958	4	A	a	DT
18637	19958	5	special	special	JJ
18637	19958	6	highway	highway	NN
18637	19958	7	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19958	8	against	against	IN
18637	19958	9	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	19958	10	based	base	VBN
18637	19958	11	on	on	IN
18637	19958	12	real	real	JJ
18637	19958	13	property	property	NN
18637	19958	14	,	,	,
18637	19958	15	rolling	roll	VBG
18637	19958	16	stock	stock	NN
18637	19958	17	and	and	CC
18637	19958	18	other	other	JJ
18637	19958	19	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19958	20	property	property	NN
18637	19958	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	19958	22	unjustly	unjustly	RB
18637	19958	23	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	19958	24	when	when	WRB
18637	19958	25	other	other	JJ
18637	19958	26	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	19958	27	for	for	IN
18637	19958	28	the	the	DT
18637	19958	29	same	same	JJ
18637	19958	30	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	19958	31	are	be	VBP
18637	19958	32	based	base	VBN
18637	19958	33	on	on	IN
18637	19958	34	real	real	JJ
18637	19958	35	property	property	NN
18637	19958	36	alone	alone	RB
18637	19958	37	.	.	.
18637	19959	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19959	2	1100	1100	CD
18637	19959	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19959	4	A	a	DT
18637	19959	5	law	law	NN
18637	19959	6	requiring	require	VBG
18637	19959	7	the	the	DT
18637	19959	8	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	19959	9	of	of	IN
18637	19959	10	a	a	DT
18637	19959	11	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19959	12	to	to	TO
18637	19959	13	be	be	VB
18637	19959	14	considered	consider	VBN
18637	19959	15	in	in	IN
18637	19959	16	valuing	value	VBG
18637	19959	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19959	18	property	property	NN
18637	19959	19	for	for	IN
18637	19959	20	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	19959	21	of	of	IN
18637	19959	22	a	a	DT
18637	19959	23	special	special	JJ
18637	19959	24	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19959	25	,	,	,
18637	19959	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	19959	27	not	not	RB
18637	19959	28	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	19959	29	where	where	WRB
18637	19959	30	the	the	DT
18637	19959	31	franchises	franchise	NNS
18637	19959	32	were	be	VBD
18637	19959	33	not	not	RB
18637	19959	34	added	add	VBN
18637	19959	35	as	as	IN
18637	19959	36	a	a	DT
18637	19959	37	separate	separate	JJ
18637	19959	38	personal	personal	JJ
18637	19959	39	property	property	NN
18637	19959	40	value	value	NN
18637	19959	41	to	to	IN
18637	19959	42	the	the	DT
18637	19959	43	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	19959	44	of	of	IN
18637	19959	45	the	the	DT
18637	19959	46	real	real	JJ
18637	19959	47	property	property	NN
18637	19959	48	.	.	.
18637	19960	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19960	2	1101	1101	CD
18637	19960	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19960	4	In	in	IN
18637	19960	5	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	19960	6	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	19960	7	within	within	IN
18637	19960	8	a	a	DT
18637	19960	9	levee	levee	JJ
18637	19960	10	district	district	NN
18637	19960	11	on	on	IN
18637	19960	12	a	a	DT
18637	19960	13	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	19960	14	basis	basis	NN
18637	19960	15	,	,	,
18637	19960	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19960	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	19960	18	not	not	RB
18637	19960	19	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	19960	20	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19960	21	to	to	TO
18637	19960	22	fix	fix	VB
18637	19960	23	a	a	DT
18637	19960	24	lower	low	JJR
18637	19960	25	rate	rate	NN
18637	19960	26	per	per	IN
18637	19960	27	mile	mile	NN
18637	19960	28	for	for	IN
18637	19960	29	those	those	DT
18637	19960	30	having	have	VBG
18637	19960	31	less	less	JJR
18637	19960	32	than	than	IN
18637	19960	33	25	25	CD
18637	19960	34	miles	mile	NNS
18637	19960	35	of	of	IN
18637	19960	36	main	main	JJ
18637	19960	37	line	line	NN
18637	19960	38	within	within	IN
18637	19960	39	the	the	DT
18637	19960	40	district	district	NN
18637	19960	41	than	than	IN
18637	19960	42	for	for	IN
18637	19960	43	those	those	DT
18637	19960	44	having	have	VBG
18637	19960	45	more	more	JJR
18637	19960	46	.	.	.
18637	19961	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19961	2	1102	1102	CD
18637	19961	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19961	4	POLICE	police	NN
18637	19961	5	POWER	POWER	NNP
18637	19961	6	Classification	Classification	NNP
18637	19961	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	19961	8	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	19961	9	once	once	RB
18637	19961	10	called	call	VBD
18637	19961	11	the	the	DT
18637	19961	12	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19961	13	protection	protection	NN
18637	19961	14	clause	clause	NN
18637	19961	15	the	the	DT
18637	19961	16	"	"	``
18637	19961	17	usual	usual	JJ
18637	19961	18	last	last	JJ
18637	19961	19	refuge	refuge	NN
18637	19961	20	of	of	IN
18637	19961	21	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	19961	22	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	19961	23	.	.	.
18637	19962	1	"	"	``
18637	19962	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19962	3	1103	1103	CD
18637	19962	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19962	5	When	when	WRB
18637	19962	6	State	state	NN
18637	19962	7	action	action	NN
18637	19962	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	19962	9	attacked	attack	VBN
18637	19962	10	under	under	IN
18637	19962	11	the	the	DT
18637	19962	12	due	due	JJ
18637	19962	13	process	process	NN
18637	19962	14	clause	clause	NN
18637	19962	15	,	,	,
18637	19962	16	the	the	DT
18637	19962	17	assailant	assailant	NN
18637	19962	18	usually	usually	RB
18637	19962	19	charges	charge	VBZ
18637	19962	20	also	also	RB
18637	19962	21	that	that	IN
18637	19962	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19962	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	19962	24	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19962	25	the	the	DT
18637	19962	26	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19962	27	protection	protection	NN
18637	19962	28	of	of	IN
18637	19962	29	the	the	DT
18637	19962	30	laws	law	NNS
18637	19962	31	.	.	.
18637	19963	1	Except	except	IN
18637	19963	2	where	where	WRB
18637	19963	3	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19963	4	on	on	IN
18637	19963	5	the	the	DT
18637	19963	6	basis	basis	NN
18637	19963	7	of	of	IN
18637	19963	8	race	race	NN
18637	19963	9	or	or	CC
18637	19963	10	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	19963	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	19963	12	shown	show	VBN
18637	19963	13	,	,	,
18637	19963	14	few	few	JJ
18637	19963	15	police	police	NN
18637	19963	16	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	19963	17	have	have	VBP
18637	19963	18	been	be	VBN
18637	19963	19	found	find	VBN
18637	19963	20	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19963	21	on	on	IN
18637	19963	22	this	this	DT
18637	19963	23	ground	ground	NN
18637	19963	24	.	.	.
18637	19964	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19964	2	1104	1104	CD
18637	19964	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19964	4	The	the	DT
18637	19964	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19964	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	19964	7	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	19964	8	a	a	DT
18637	19964	9	statute	statute	NN
18637	19964	10	which	which	WDT
18637	19964	11	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	19964	12	stock	stock	NN
18637	19964	13	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	19964	14	companies	company	NNS
18637	19964	15	to	to	TO
18637	19964	16	act	act	VB
18637	19964	17	through	through	IN
18637	19964	18	agents	agent	NNS
18637	19964	19	who	who	WP
18637	19964	20	were	be	VBD
18637	19964	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19964	22	salaried	salary	VBN
18637	19964	23	employees	employee	NNS
18637	19964	24	,	,	,
18637	19964	25	but	but	CC
18637	19964	26	permitted	permit	VBD
18637	19964	27	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	19964	28	companies	company	NNS
18637	19964	29	to	to	TO
18637	19964	30	operate	operate	VB
18637	19964	31	in	in	IN
18637	19964	32	this	this	DT
18637	19964	33	manner	manner	NN
18637	19964	34	.	.	.
18637	19965	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19965	2	1105	1105	CD
18637	19965	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19965	4	A	a	DT
18637	19965	5	law	law	NN
18637	19965	6	which	which	WDT
18637	19965	7	required	require	VBD
18637	19965	8	private	private	JJ
18637	19965	9	motor	motor	NN
18637	19965	10	vehicle	vehicle	NN
18637	19965	11	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19965	12	to	to	TO
18637	19965	13	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	19965	14	certificates	certificate	NNS
18637	19965	15	of	of	IN
18637	19965	16	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	19965	17	and	and	CC
18637	19965	18	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	19965	19	and	and	CC
18637	19965	20	to	to	TO
18637	19965	21	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	19965	22	security	security	NN
18637	19965	23	for	for	IN
18637	19965	24	the	the	DT
18637	19965	25	protection	protection	NN
18637	19965	26	of	of	IN
18637	19965	27	the	the	DT
18637	19965	28	public	public	NN
18637	19965	29	was	be	VBD
18637	19965	30	held	hold	VBN
18637	19965	31	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	19965	32	by	by	IN
18637	19965	33	reason	reason	NN
18637	19965	34	of	of	IN
18637	19965	35	the	the	DT
18637	19965	36	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	19965	37	of	of	IN
18637	19965	38	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	19965	39	of	of	IN
18637	19965	40	fish	fish	NN
18637	19965	41	,	,	,
18637	19965	42	farm	farm	NN
18637	19965	43	and	and	CC
18637	19965	44	dairy	dairy	NN
18637	19965	45	products	product	NNS
18637	19965	46	.	.	.
18637	19966	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19966	2	1106	1106	CD
18637	19966	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19966	4	Discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19966	5	among	among	IN
18637	19966	6	milk	milk	NN
18637	19966	7	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	19966	8	without	without	IN
18637	19966	9	well	well	RB
18637	19966	10	advertised	advertise	VBN
18637	19966	11	trade	trade	NN
18637	19966	12	names	name	NNS
18637	19966	13	,	,	,
18637	19966	14	giving	give	VBG
18637	19966	15	those	those	DT
18637	19966	16	who	who	WP
18637	19966	17	entered	enter	VBD
18637	19966	18	business	business	NN
18637	19966	19	before	before	IN
18637	19966	20	a	a	DT
18637	19966	21	specified	specify	VBN
18637	19966	22	date	date	NN
18637	19966	23	the	the	DT
18637	19966	24	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	19966	25	of	of	IN
18637	19966	26	a	a	DT
18637	19966	27	price	price	NN
18637	19966	28	differential	differential	NN
18637	19966	29	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19966	30	to	to	IN
18637	19966	31	those	those	DT
18637	19966	32	who	who	WP
18637	19966	33	commenced	commence	VBD
18637	19966	34	operations	operation	NNS
18637	19966	35	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	19966	36	,	,	,
18637	19966	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	19966	38	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19966	39	and	and	CC
18637	19966	40	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	19966	41	.	.	.
18637	19967	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19967	2	1107	1107	CD
18637	19967	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19967	4	A	a	DT
18637	19967	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	19967	6	providing	provide	VBG
18637	19967	7	for	for	IN
18637	19967	8	the	the	DT
18637	19967	9	sterilization	sterilization	NN
18637	19967	10	of	of	IN
18637	19967	11	defectives	defective	NNS
18637	19967	12	in	in	IN
18637	19967	13	State	State	NNP
18637	19967	14	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	19967	15	was	be	VBD
18637	19967	16	sustained;[1108	sustained;[1108	ADD
18637	19967	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19967	18	but	but	CC
18637	19967	19	a	a	DT
18637	19967	20	similar	similar	JJ
18637	19967	21	act	act	NN
18637	19967	22	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	19967	23	to	to	IN
18637	19967	24	triple	triple	JJ
18637	19967	25	offenders	offender	NNS
18637	19967	26	was	be	VBD
18637	19967	27	held	hold	VBN
18637	19967	28	void	void	JJ
18637	19967	29	.	.	.
18637	19968	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19968	2	1109	1109	CD
18637	19968	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19968	4	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	19968	5	Discretion	Discretion	NNP
18637	19968	6	A	a	DT
18637	19968	7	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	19968	8	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	19968	9	which	which	WDT
18637	19968	10	vests	vest	VBZ
18637	19968	11	in	in	IN
18637	19968	12	supervisory	supervisory	JJ
18637	19968	13	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	19968	14	a	a	DT
18637	19968	15	naked	naked	JJ
18637	19968	16	and	and	CC
18637	19968	17	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19968	18	power	power	NN
18637	19968	19	to	to	TO
18637	19968	20	grant	grant	VB
18637	19968	21	or	or	CC
18637	19968	22	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	19968	23	consent	consent	NN
18637	19968	24	to	to	IN
18637	19968	25	the	the	DT
18637	19968	26	operation	operation	NN
18637	19968	27	of	of	IN
18637	19968	28	laundries	laundry	NNS
18637	19968	29	in	in	IN
18637	19968	30	wooden	wooden	JJ
18637	19968	31	buildings	building	NNS
18637	19968	32	,	,	,
18637	19968	33	without	without	IN
18637	19968	34	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	19968	35	of	of	IN
18637	19968	36	the	the	DT
18637	19968	37	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	19968	38	of	of	IN
18637	19968	39	individual	individual	JJ
18637	19968	40	cases	case	NNS
18637	19968	41	,	,	,
18637	19968	42	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	19968	43	a	a	DT
18637	19968	44	denial	denial	NN
18637	19968	45	of	of	IN
18637	19968	46	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19968	47	protection	protection	NN
18637	19968	48	of	of	IN
18637	19968	49	the	the	DT
18637	19968	50	law	law	NN
18637	19968	51	when	when	WRB
18637	19968	52	consent	consent	NN
18637	19968	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	19968	54	withheld	withhold	VBN
18637	19968	55	from	from	IN
18637	19968	56	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19968	57	persons	person	NNS
18637	19968	58	solely	solely	RB
18637	19968	59	on	on	IN
18637	19968	60	the	the	DT
18637	19968	61	basis	basis	NN
18637	19968	62	of	of	IN
18637	19968	63	nationality	nationality	NN
18637	19968	64	.	.	.
18637	19969	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19969	2	1110	1110	CD
18637	19969	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19969	4	But	but	CC
18637	19969	5	a	a	DT
18637	19969	6	city	city	NN
18637	19969	7	council	council	NN
18637	19969	8	may	may	MD
18637	19969	9	reserve	reserve	VB
18637	19969	10	to	to	IN
18637	19969	11	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19969	12	the	the	DT
18637	19969	13	power	power	NN
18637	19969	14	to	to	TO
18637	19969	15	make	make	VB
18637	19969	16	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	19969	17	from	from	IN
18637	19969	18	a	a	DT
18637	19969	19	ban	ban	NN
18637	19969	20	on	on	IN
18637	19969	21	the	the	DT
18637	19969	22	operation	operation	NN
18637	19969	23	of	of	IN
18637	19969	24	a	a	DT
18637	19969	25	dairy	dairy	NN
18637	19969	26	within	within	IN
18637	19969	27	the	the	DT
18637	19969	28	city,[1111	city,[1111	NNP
18637	19969	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19969	30	or	or	CC
18637	19969	31	from	from	IN
18637	19969	32	building	build	VBG
18637	19969	33	line	line	NN
18637	19969	34	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	19969	35	.	.	.
18637	19970	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19970	2	1112	1112	CD
18637	19970	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19970	4	Written	write	VBN
18637	19970	5	permission	permission	NN
18637	19970	6	of	of	IN
18637	19970	7	the	the	DT
18637	19970	8	mayor	mayor	NN
18637	19970	9	or	or	CC
18637	19970	10	president	president	NN
18637	19970	11	of	of	IN
18637	19970	12	the	the	DT
18637	19970	13	city	city	NNP
18637	19970	14	council	council	NNP
18637	19970	15	may	may	MD
18637	19970	16	be	be	VB
18637	19970	17	required	require	VBN
18637	19970	18	before	before	IN
18637	19970	19	any	any	DT
18637	19970	20	person	person	NN
18637	19970	21	shall	shall	MD
18637	19970	22	move	move	VB
18637	19970	23	a	a	DT
18637	19970	24	building	building	NN
18637	19970	25	on	on	IN
18637	19970	26	a	a	DT
18637	19970	27	street	street	NN
18637	19970	28	.	.	.
18637	19971	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19971	2	1113	1113	CD
18637	19971	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19971	4	The	the	DT
18637	19971	5	Mayor	Mayor	NNP
18637	19971	6	may	may	MD
18637	19971	7	be	be	VB
18637	19971	8	empowered	empower	VBN
18637	19971	9	to	to	TO
18637	19971	10	determine	determine	VB
18637	19971	11	whether	whether	IN
18637	19971	12	an	an	DT
18637	19971	13	applicant	applicant	NN
18637	19971	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	19971	15	a	a	DT
18637	19971	16	good	good	JJ
18637	19971	17	character	character	NN
18637	19971	18	and	and	CC
18637	19971	19	reputation	reputation	NN
18637	19971	20	and	and	CC
18637	19971	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	19971	22	a	a	DT
18637	19971	23	suitable	suitable	JJ
18637	19971	24	person	person	NN
18637	19971	25	to	to	TO
18637	19971	26	receive	receive	VB
18637	19971	27	a	a	DT
18637	19971	28	license	license	NN
18637	19971	29	for	for	IN
18637	19971	30	the	the	DT
18637	19971	31	sale	sale	NN
18637	19971	32	of	of	IN
18637	19971	33	cigarettes	cigarette	NNS
18637	19971	34	.	.	.
18637	19972	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19972	2	1114	1114	CD
18637	19972	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19972	4	In	in	IN
18637	19972	5	a	a	DT
18637	19972	6	recent	recent	JJ
18637	19972	7	case[1115	case[1115	NNP
18637	19972	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19972	9	the	the	DT
18637	19972	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19972	11	held	hold	VBD
18637	19972	12	that	that	IN
18637	19972	13	the	the	DT
18637	19972	14	unfettered	unfettered	JJ
18637	19972	15	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	19972	16	of	of	IN
18637	19972	17	officer	officer	NN
18637	19972	18	river	river	NNP
18637	19972	19	pilots	pilot	NNS
18637	19972	20	to	to	TO
18637	19972	21	select	select	VB
18637	19972	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19972	23	apprentices	apprentice	NNS
18637	19972	24	,	,	,
18637	19972	25	which	which	WDT
18637	19972	26	was	be	VBD
18637	19972	27	almost	almost	RB
18637	19972	28	invariably	invariably	RB
18637	19972	29	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	19972	30	in	in	IN
18637	19972	31	favor	favor	NN
18637	19972	32	of	of	IN
18637	19972	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19972	34	relatives	relative	NNS
18637	19972	35	and	and	CC
18637	19972	36	friends	friend	NNS
18637	19972	37	,	,	,
18637	19972	38	was	be	VBD
18637	19972	39	not	not	RB
18637	19972	40	a	a	DT
18637	19972	41	denial	denial	NN
18637	19972	42	of	of	IN
18637	19972	43	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19972	44	protection	protection	NN
18637	19972	45	to	to	IN
18637	19972	46	persons	person	NNS
18637	19972	47	not	not	RB
18637	19972	48	selected	select	VBN
18637	19972	49	despite	despite	IN
18637	19972	50	the	the	DT
18637	19972	51	fact	fact	NN
18637	19972	52	that	that	IN
18637	19972	53	such	such	JJ
18637	19972	54	apprenticeship	apprenticeship	NN
18637	19972	55	was	be	VBD
18637	19972	56	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	19972	57	for	for	IN
18637	19972	58	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	19972	59	as	as	IN
18637	19972	60	a	a	DT
18637	19972	61	pilot	pilot	NN
18637	19972	62	.	.	.
18637	19973	1	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	19973	2	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	19973	3	The	the	DT
18637	19973	4	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19973	5	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19973	6	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	19973	7	purely	purely	RB
18637	19973	8	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	19973	9	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19973	10	against	against	IN
18637	19973	11	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	19973	12	.	.	.
18637	19974	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19974	2	1116	1116	CD
18637	19974	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19974	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	19974	5	alien	alien	JJ
18637	19974	6	race	race	NN
18637	19974	7	and	and	CC
18637	19974	8	allegiance	allegiance	NN
18637	19974	9	bear	bear	VBP
18637	19974	10	a	a	DT
18637	19974	11	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	19974	12	relation	relation	NN
18637	19974	13	to	to	IN
18637	19974	14	a	a	DT
18637	19974	15	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	19974	16	object	object	NN
18637	19974	17	of	of	IN
18637	19974	18	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19974	19	,	,	,
18637	19974	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19974	21	may	may	MD
18637	19974	22	be	be	VB
18637	19974	23	made	make	VBN
18637	19974	24	the	the	DT
18637	19974	25	basis	basis	NN
18637	19974	26	of	of	IN
18637	19974	27	classification	classification	NN
18637	19974	28	.	.	.
18637	19975	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	19975	2	,	,	,
18637	19975	3	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19975	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	19975	5	been	be	VBN
18637	19975	6	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	19975	7	under	under	IN
18637	19975	8	which	which	WDT
18637	19975	9	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	19975	10	were	be	VBD
18637	19975	11	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	19975	12	to	to	TO
18637	19975	13	conduct	conduct	VB
18637	19975	14	pool	pool	NN
18637	19975	15	rooms[1117	rooms[1117	NNP
18637	19975	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19975	17	or	or	CC
18637	19975	18	to	to	TO
18637	19975	19	take	take	VB
18637	19975	20	game	game	NN
18637	19975	21	or	or	CC
18637	19975	22	possess	possess	VB
18637	19975	23	shotguns	shotgun	NNS
18637	19975	24	.	.	.
18637	19976	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19976	2	1118	1118	CD
18637	19976	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19976	4	A	a	DT
18637	19976	5	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19976	6	between	between	IN
18637	19976	7	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	19976	8	and	and	CC
18637	19976	9	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	19976	10	in	in	IN
18637	19976	11	the	the	DT
18637	19976	12	matter	matter	NN
18637	19976	13	of	of	IN
18637	19976	14	employment	employment	NN
18637	19976	15	on	on	IN
18637	19976	16	public	public	JJ
18637	19976	17	works	work	NNS
18637	19976	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	19976	19	not	not	RB
18637	19976	20	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19976	21	.	.	.
18637	19977	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19977	2	1119	1119	CD
18637	19977	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19977	4	A	a	DT
18637	19977	5	State	state	NN
18637	19977	6	can	can	MD
18637	19977	7	not	not	RB
18637	19977	8	,	,	,
18637	19977	9	however	however	RB
18637	19977	10	,	,	,
18637	19977	11	deny	deny	VB
18637	19977	12	to	to	IN
18637	19977	13	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	19977	14	the	the	DT
18637	19977	15	right	right	NN
18637	19977	16	to	to	TO
18637	19977	17	earn	earn	VB
18637	19977	18	a	a	DT
18637	19977	19	living	living	NN
18637	19977	20	in	in	IN
18637	19977	21	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	19977	22	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	19977	23	.	.	.
18637	19978	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	19978	2	,	,	,
18637	19978	3	a	a	DT
18637	19978	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	19978	5	requiring	require	VBG
18637	19978	6	that	that	IN
18637	19978	7	employers	employer	NNS
18637	19978	8	of	of	IN
18637	19978	9	more	more	JJR
18637	19978	10	than	than	IN
18637	19978	11	five	five	CD
18637	19978	12	workers	worker	NNS
18637	19978	13	employ	employ	VBP
18637	19978	14	not	not	RB
18637	19978	15	less	less	JJR
18637	19978	16	than	than	IN
18637	19978	17	eighty	eighty	CD
18637	19978	18	percent	percent	NN
18637	19978	19	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	19978	20	electors	elector	NNS
18637	19978	21	or	or	CC
18637	19978	22	natural	natural	JJ
18637	19978	23	born	bear	VBN
18637	19978	24	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	19978	25	denies	deny	VBZ
18637	19978	26	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19978	27	protection	protection	NN
18637	19978	28	of	of	IN
18637	19978	29	the	the	DT
18637	19978	30	law	law	NN
18637	19978	31	.	.	.
18637	19979	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19979	2	1120	1120	CD
18637	19979	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19979	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	19979	5	a	a	DT
18637	19979	6	State	State	NNP
18637	19979	7	law	law	NN
18637	19979	8	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	19979	9	the	the	DT
18637	19979	10	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	19979	11	of	of	IN
18637	19979	12	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	19979	13	fishing	fishing	NN
18637	19979	14	licenses	license	NNS
18637	19979	15	to	to	IN
18637	19979	16	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	19979	17	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	19979	18	for	for	IN
18637	19979	19	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	19979	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	19979	21	been	be	VBN
18637	19979	22	held	hold	VBN
18637	19979	23	void	void	JJ
18637	19979	24	.	.	.
18637	19980	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19980	2	1121	1121	CD
18637	19980	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19980	4	State	state	NN
18637	19980	5	laws	law	NNS
18637	19980	6	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	19980	7	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	19980	8	to	to	TO
18637	19980	9	own	own	VB
18637	19980	10	real	real	JJ
18637	19980	11	estate	estate	NN
18637	19980	12	,	,	,
18637	19980	13	have	have	VBP
18637	19980	14	been	be	VBN
18637	19980	15	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	19980	16	in	in	IN
18637	19980	17	the	the	DT
18637	19980	18	past	past	NN
18637	19980	19	.	.	.
18637	19981	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19981	2	1122	1122	CD
18637	19981	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19981	4	A	a	DT
18637	19981	5	less	less	RBR
18637	19981	6	sympathetic	sympathetic	JJ
18637	19981	7	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	19981	8	toward	toward	IN
18637	19981	9	such	such	JJ
18637	19981	10	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19981	11	was	be	VBD
18637	19981	12	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	19981	13	in	in	IN
18637	19981	14	Oyama	Oyama	NNP
18637	19981	15	_	_	NNP
18637	19981	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	19981	17	_	_	NNP
18637	19981	18	California	California	NNP
18637	19981	19	,	,	,
18637	19981	20	in	in	IN
18637	19981	21	1948	1948	CD
18637	19981	22	.	.	.
18637	19982	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19982	2	1123	1123	CD
18637	19982	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19982	4	There	there	RB
18637	19982	5	the	the	DT
18637	19982	6	State	State	NNP
18637	19982	7	of	of	IN
18637	19982	8	California	California	NNP
18637	19982	9	sought	seek	VBD
18637	19982	10	to	to	TO
18637	19982	11	escheat	escheat	VB
18637	19982	12	land	land	NN
18637	19982	13	owned	own	VBN
18637	19982	14	by	by	IN
18637	19982	15	an	an	DT
18637	19982	16	American	American	NNP
18637	19982	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	19982	18	born	bear	VBN
18637	19982	19	son	son	NN
18637	19982	20	of	of	IN
18637	19982	21	a	a	DT
18637	19982	22	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	19982	23	father	father	NN
18637	19982	24	under	under	IN
18637	19982	25	a	a	DT
18637	19982	26	provision	provision	NN
18637	19982	27	of	of	IN
18637	19982	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19982	29	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	19982	30	Land	Land	NNP
18637	19982	31	Law	Law	NNP
18637	19982	32	which	which	WDT
18637	19982	33	made	make	VBD
18637	19982	34	payment	payment	NN
18637	19982	35	by	by	IN
18637	19982	36	an	an	DT
18637	19982	37	alien	alien	NN
18637	19982	38	of	of	IN
18637	19982	39	the	the	DT
18637	19982	40	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	19982	41	for	for	IN
18637	19982	42	a	a	DT
18637	19982	43	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	19982	44	of	of	IN
18637	19982	45	land	land	NN
18637	19982	46	to	to	IN
18637	19982	47	a	a	DT
18637	19982	48	third	third	JJ
18637	19982	49	person	person	NN
18637	19982	50	_	_	NNP
18637	19982	51	prima	prima	NN
18637	19982	52	facie	facie	NNP
18637	19982	53	_	_	NNP
18637	19982	54	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	19982	55	of	of	IN
18637	19982	56	intent	intent	NN
18637	19982	57	to	to	TO
18637	19982	58	evade	evade	VB
18637	19982	59	the	the	DT
18637	19982	60	statute	statute	NN
18637	19982	61	.	.	.
18637	19983	1	The	the	DT
18637	19983	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19983	3	held	hold	VBD
18637	19983	4	that	that	IN
18637	19983	5	the	the	DT
18637	19983	6	burden	burden	NN
18637	19983	7	of	of	IN
18637	19983	8	proof	proof	NN
18637	19983	9	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	19983	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	19983	11	the	the	DT
18637	19983	12	son	son	NN
18637	19983	13	,	,	,
18637	19983	14	an	an	DT
18637	19983	15	American	american	JJ
18637	19983	16	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	19983	17	,	,	,
18637	19983	18	by	by	IN
18637	19983	19	reason	reason	NN
18637	19983	20	of	of	IN
18637	19983	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19983	22	parent	parent	NN
18637	19983	23	's	's	POS
18637	19983	24	country	country	NN
18637	19983	25	of	of	IN
18637	19983	26	origin	origin	NN
18637	19983	27	,	,	,
18637	19983	28	was	be	VBD
18637	19983	29	an	an	DT
18637	19983	30	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	19983	31	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	19983	32	,	,	,
18637	19983	33	but	but	CC
18637	19983	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19983	35	did	do	VBD
18637	19983	36	not	not	RB
18637	19983	37	pass	pass	VB
18637	19983	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	19983	39	the	the	DT
18637	19983	40	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	19983	41	of	of	IN
18637	19983	42	the	the	DT
18637	19983	43	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	19983	44	Land	Land	NNP
18637	19983	45	Law	Law	NNP
18637	19983	46	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19983	47	.	.	.
18637	19984	1	In	in	IN
18637	19984	2	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	19984	3	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	19984	4	four	four	CD
18637	19984	5	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	19984	6	took	take	VBD
18637	19984	7	the	the	DT
18637	19984	8	position	position	NN
18637	19984	9	that	that	IN
18637	19984	10	the	the	DT
18637	19984	11	law	law	NN
18637	19984	12	was	be	VBD
18637	19984	13	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
18637	19984	14	with	with	IN
18637	19984	15	the	the	DT
18637	19984	16	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19984	17	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19984	18	.	.	.
18637	19985	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19985	2	1124	1124	CD
18637	19985	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19985	4	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	19985	5	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	19985	6	Objections	Objections	NNPS
18637	19985	7	to	to	IN
18637	19985	8	labor	labor	NN
18637	19985	9	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19985	10	on	on	IN
18637	19985	11	the	the	DT
18637	19985	12	ground	ground	NN
18637	19985	13	that	that	IN
18637	19985	14	the	the	DT
18637	19985	15	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	19985	16	of	of	IN
18637	19985	17	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19985	18	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	19985	19	to	to	IN
18637	19985	20	specified	specify	VBN
18637	19985	21	industries	industry	NNS
18637	19985	22	was	be	VBD
18637	19985	23	obnoxious	obnoxious	JJ
18637	19985	24	to	to	IN
18637	19985	25	the	the	DT
18637	19985	26	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19985	27	protection	protection	NN
18637	19985	28	clause	clause	NN
18637	19985	29	,	,	,
18637	19985	30	have	have	VBP
18637	19985	31	been	be	VBN
18637	19985	32	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	19985	33	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	19985	34	.	.	.
18637	19986	1	Statutes	statute	NNS
18637	19986	2	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	19986	3	hours	hour	NNS
18637	19986	4	of	of	IN
18637	19986	5	labor	labor	NN
18637	19986	6	for	for	IN
18637	19986	7	employees	employee	NNS
18637	19986	8	in	in	IN
18637	19986	9	mines	mine	NNS
18637	19986	10	,	,	,
18637	19986	11	smelters,[1125	smelters,[1125	NNP
18637	19986	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19986	13	mills	mill	NNS
18637	19986	14	,	,	,
18637	19986	15	factories,[1126	factories,[1126	NNP
18637	19986	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19986	17	or	or	CC
18637	19986	18	on	on	IN
18637	19986	19	public	public	JJ
18637	19986	20	works[1127	works[1127	NNP
18637	19986	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19986	22	have	have	VBP
18637	19986	23	been	be	VBN
18637	19986	24	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	19986	25	.	.	.
18637	19987	1	So	so	RB
18637	19987	2	also	also	RB
18637	19987	3	was	be	VBD
18637	19987	4	a	a	DT
18637	19987	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	19987	6	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	19987	7	persons	person	NNS
18637	19987	8	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	19987	9	in	in	IN
18637	19987	10	mining	mining	NN
18637	19987	11	and	and	CC
18637	19987	12	manufacturing	manufacturing	NN
18637	19987	13	to	to	TO
18637	19987	14	issue	issue	VB
18637	19987	15	orders	order	NNS
18637	19987	16	for	for	IN
18637	19987	17	payment	payment	NN
18637	19987	18	of	of	IN
18637	19987	19	labor	labor	NN
18637	19987	20	unless	unless	IN
18637	19987	21	redeemable	redeemable	JJ
18637	19987	22	at	at	IN
18637	19987	23	face	face	NN
18637	19987	24	value	value	NN
18637	19987	25	in	in	IN
18637	19987	26	cash	cash	NN
18637	19987	27	.	.	.
18637	19988	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19988	2	1128	1128	CD
18637	19988	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19988	4	The	the	DT
18637	19988	5	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	19988	6	of	of	IN
18637	19988	7	mines	mine	NNS
18637	19988	8	employing	employ	VBG
18637	19988	9	less	less	JJR
18637	19988	10	than	than	IN
18637	19988	11	ten	ten	CD
18637	19988	12	persons	person	NNS
18637	19988	13	from	from	IN
18637	19988	14	a	a	DT
18637	19988	15	law	law	NN
18637	19988	16	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	19988	17	to	to	IN
18637	19988	18	measurement	measurement	NN
18637	19988	19	of	of	IN
18637	19988	20	coal	coal	NNP
18637	19988	21	to	to	TO
18637	19988	22	determine	determine	VB
18637	19988	23	a	a	DT
18637	19988	24	miner	miner	NN
18637	19988	25	's	's	POS
18637	19988	26	wages	wage	NNS
18637	19988	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	19988	28	not	not	RB
18637	19988	29	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	19988	30	.	.	.
18637	19989	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19989	2	1129	1129	CD
18637	19989	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19989	4	All	all	DT
18637	19989	5	corporations,[1130	corporations,[1130	NNP
18637	19989	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19989	7	or	or	CC
18637	19989	8	public	public	JJ
18637	19989	9	service	service	NN
18637	19989	10	corporations,[1131	corporations,[1131	NNP
18637	19989	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19989	12	may	may	MD
18637	19989	13	be	be	VB
18637	19989	14	required	require	VBN
18637	19989	15	to	to	TO
18637	19989	16	issue	issue	VB
18637	19989	17	to	to	IN
18637	19989	18	employees	employee	NNS
18637	19989	19	who	who	WP
18637	19989	20	leave	leave	VBP
18637	19989	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19989	22	service	service	NN
18637	19989	23	letters	letter	NNS
18637	19989	24	stating	state	VBG
18637	19989	25	the	the	DT
18637	19989	26	nature	nature	NN
18637	19989	27	of	of	IN
18637	19989	28	the	the	DT
18637	19989	29	service	service	NN
18637	19989	30	and	and	CC
18637	19989	31	the	the	DT
18637	19989	32	cause	cause	NN
18637	19989	33	of	of	IN
18637	19989	34	leaving	leave	VBG
18637	19989	35	even	even	RB
18637	19989	36	though	though	IN
18637	19989	37	other	other	JJ
18637	19989	38	employers	employer	NNS
18637	19989	39	are	be	VBP
18637	19989	40	not	not	RB
18637	19989	41	.	.	.
18637	19990	1	Industries	industry	NNS
18637	19990	2	may	may	MD
18637	19990	3	be	be	VB
18637	19990	4	classified	classify	VBN
18637	19990	5	in	in	IN
18637	19990	6	a	a	DT
18637	19990	7	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	19990	8	's	's	POS
18637	19990	9	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	19990	10	act	act	NN
18637	19990	11	according	accord	VBG
18637	19990	12	to	to	IN
18637	19990	13	the	the	DT
18637	19990	14	respective	respective	JJ
18637	19990	15	hazards	hazard	NNS
18637	19990	16	of	of	IN
18637	19990	17	each;[1132	each;[1132	NNP
18637	19990	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19990	19	the	the	DT
18637	19990	20	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	19990	21	of	of	IN
18637	19990	22	farm	farm	NN
18637	19990	23	laborers	laborer	NNS
18637	19990	24	and	and	CC
18637	19990	25	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	19990	26	servants	servant	NNS
18637	19990	27	does	do	VBZ
18637	19990	28	not	not	RB
18637	19990	29	render	render	VB
18637	19990	30	such	such	PDT
18637	19990	31	an	an	DT
18637	19990	32	act	act	NN
18637	19990	33	invalid	invalid	NN
18637	19990	34	.	.	.
18637	19991	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19991	2	1133	1133	CD
18637	19991	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19991	4	A	a	DT
18637	19991	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	19991	6	providing	provide	VBG
18637	19991	7	that	that	IN
18637	19991	8	no	no	DT
18637	19991	9	person	person	NN
18637	19991	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	19991	11	be	be	VB
18637	19991	12	denied	deny	VBN
18637	19991	13	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	19991	14	for	for	IN
18637	19991	15	employment	employment	NN
18637	19991	16	because	because	IN
18637	19991	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19991	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	19991	19	not	not	RB
18637	19991	20	a	a	DT
18637	19991	21	member	member	NN
18637	19991	22	of	of	IN
18637	19991	23	a	a	DT
18637	19991	24	union	union	NN
18637	19991	25	does	do	VBZ
18637	19991	26	not	not	RB
18637	19991	27	offend	offend	VB
18637	19991	28	the	the	DT
18637	19991	29	equal	equal	JJ
18637	19991	30	protection	protection	NN
18637	19991	31	clause	clause	NN
18637	19991	32	.	.	.
18637	19992	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19992	2	1134	1134	CD
18637	19992	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19992	4	Women	woman	NNS
18637	19992	5	,	,	,
18637	19992	6	or	or	CC
18637	19992	7	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19992	8	classes	class	NNS
18637	19992	9	of	of	IN
18637	19992	10	women	woman	NNS
18637	19992	11	,	,	,
18637	19992	12	may	may	MD
18637	19992	13	be	be	VB
18637	19992	14	singled	single	VBN
18637	19992	15	out	out	RP
18637	19992	16	for	for	IN
18637	19992	17	special	special	JJ
18637	19992	18	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	19992	19	,	,	,
18637	19992	20	in	in	IN
18637	19992	21	the	the	DT
18637	19992	22	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	19992	23	of	of	IN
18637	19992	24	the	the	DT
18637	19992	25	State	State	NNP
18637	19992	26	's	's	POS
18637	19992	27	protective	protective	JJ
18637	19992	28	power	power	NN
18637	19992	29	,	,	,
18637	19992	30	without	without	IN
18637	19992	31	violation	violation	NN
18637	19992	32	of	of	IN
18637	19992	33	the	the	DT
18637	19992	34	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	19992	35	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	19992	36	.	.	.
18637	19993	1	Classification	classification	NN
18637	19993	2	may	may	MD
18637	19993	3	be	be	VB
18637	19993	4	based	base	VBN
18637	19993	5	on	on	IN
18637	19993	6	differences	difference	NNS
18637	19993	7	either	either	CC
18637	19993	8	in	in	IN
18637	19993	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19993	10	physical	physical	JJ
18637	19993	11	characteristics	characteristic	NNS
18637	19993	12	or	or	CC
18637	19993	13	in	in	IN
18637	19993	14	the	the	DT
18637	19993	15	social	social	JJ
18637	19993	16	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19993	17	which	which	WDT
18637	19993	18	surround	surround	VBP
18637	19993	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19993	20	employment	employment	NN
18637	19993	21	.	.	.
18637	19994	1	Restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	19994	2	on	on	IN
18637	19994	3	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	19994	4	of	of	IN
18637	19994	5	employment	employment	NN
18637	19994	6	in	in	IN
18637	19994	7	particular	particular	JJ
18637	19994	8	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	19994	9	are	be	VBP
18637	19994	10	not	not	RB
18637	19994	11	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	19994	12	because	because	IN
18637	19994	13	the	the	DT
18637	19994	14	law	law	NN
18637	19994	15	might	may	MD
18637	19994	16	have	have	VB
18637	19994	17	been	be	VBN
18637	19994	18	made	make	VBN
18637	19994	19	broader	broad	JJR
18637	19994	20	.	.	.
18637	19995	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19995	2	1135	1135	CD
18637	19995	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19995	4	One	one	CD
18637	19995	5	of	of	IN
18637	19995	6	the	the	DT
18637	19995	7	earliest	early	JJS
18637	19995	8	pieces	piece	NNS
18637	19995	9	of	of	IN
18637	19995	10	social	social	JJ
18637	19995	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	19995	12	to	to	TO
18637	19995	13	be	be	VB
18637	19995	14	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	19995	15	was	be	VBD
18637	19995	16	a	a	DT
18637	19995	17	ten	ten	CD
18637	19995	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	19995	19	hour	hour	NN
18637	19995	20	law	law	NN
18637	19995	21	for	for	IN
18637	19995	22	women	woman	NNS
18637	19995	23	employed	employ	VBN
18637	19995	24	in	in	IN
18637	19995	25	laundries	laundry	NNS
18637	19995	26	.	.	.
18637	19996	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19996	2	1136	1136	CD
18637	19996	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19996	4	A	a	DT
18637	19996	5	law	law	NN
18637	19996	6	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	19996	7	hours	hour	NNS
18637	19996	8	of	of	IN
18637	19996	9	labor	labor	NN
18637	19996	10	for	for	IN
18637	19996	11	women	woman	NNS
18637	19996	12	in	in	IN
18637	19996	13	hotels	hotel	NNS
18637	19996	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	19996	15	not	not	RB
18637	19996	16	rendered	render	VBN
18637	19996	17	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	19996	18	by	by	IN
18637	19996	19	reason	reason	NN
18637	19996	20	of	of	IN
18637	19996	21	the	the	DT
18637	19996	22	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	19996	23	of	of	IN
18637	19996	24	certain	certain	JJ
18637	19996	25	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	19996	26	restaurants	restaurant	NNS
18637	19996	27	.	.	.
18637	19997	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19997	2	1137	1137	CD
18637	19997	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19997	4	Night	night	NN
18637	19997	5	work	work	NN
18637	19997	6	by	by	IN
18637	19997	7	women	woman	NNS
18637	19997	8	in	in	IN
18637	19997	9	restaurants	restaurant	NNS
18637	19997	10	may	may	MD
18637	19997	11	be	be	VB
18637	19997	12	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	19997	13	.	.	.
18637	19998	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19998	2	1138	1138	CD
18637	19998	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19998	4	Reversing	reverse	VBG
18637	19998	5	earlier	early	JJR
18637	19998	6	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	19998	7	,	,	,
18637	19998	8	the	the	DT
18637	19998	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	19998	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	19998	11	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	19998	12	a	a	DT
18637	19998	13	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	19998	14	wage	wage	NN
18637	19998	15	law	law	NN
18637	19998	16	for	for	IN
18637	19998	17	women	woman	NNS
18637	19998	18	in	in	IN
18637	19998	19	1937	1937	CD
18637	19998	20	,	,	,
18637	19998	21	saying	say	VBG
18637	19998	22	that	that	IN
18637	19998	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19998	24	unequal	unequal	JJ
18637	19998	25	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	19998	26	position	position	NN
18637	19998	27	justified	justify	VBD
18637	19998	28	a	a	DT
18637	19998	29	law	law	NN
18637	19998	30	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	19998	31	only	only	RB
18637	19998	32	to	to	IN
18637	19998	33	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	19998	34	.	.	.
18637	19999	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	19999	2	1139	1139	CD
18637	19999	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	19999	4	Women	woman	NNS
18637	19999	5	may	may	MD
18637	19999	6	be	be	VB
18637	19999	7	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	19999	8	to	to	TO
18637	19999	9	engage	engage	VB
18637	19999	10	in	in	IN
18637	19999	11	an	an	DT
18637	19999	12	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	19999	13	where	where	WRB
18637	19999	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	19999	15	employment	employment	NN
18637	19999	16	may	may	MD
18637	19999	17	create	create	VB
18637	19999	18	special	special	JJ
18637	19999	19	moral	moral	JJ
18637	19999	20	and	and	CC
18637	19999	21	social	social	JJ
18637	19999	22	problems	problem	NNS
18637	19999	23	.	.	.
18637	20000	1	A	a	DT
18637	20000	2	State	state	NN
18637	20000	3	statute	statute	NN
18637	20000	4	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	20000	5	women	woman	NNS
18637	20000	6	to	to	TO
18637	20000	7	act	act	VB
18637	20000	8	as	as	IN
18637	20000	9	bartenders	bartender	NNS
18637	20000	10	,	,	,
18637	20000	11	but	but	CC
18637	20000	12	making	make	VBG
18637	20000	13	an	an	DT
18637	20000	14	exception	exception	NN
18637	20000	15	in	in	IN
18637	20000	16	favor	favor	NN
18637	20000	17	of	of	IN
18637	20000	18	wives	wife	NNS
18637	20000	19	and	and	CC
18637	20000	20	daughters	daughter	NNS
18637	20000	21	of	of	IN
18637	20000	22	the	the	DT
18637	20000	23	male	male	JJ
18637	20000	24	owners	owner	NNS
18637	20000	25	of	of	IN
18637	20000	26	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	20000	27	establishments	establishment	NNS
18637	20000	28	was	be	VBD
18637	20000	29	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	20000	30	over	over	IN
18637	20000	31	the	the	DT
18637	20000	32	objection	objection	NN
18637	20000	33	,	,	,
18637	20000	34	which	which	WDT
18637	20000	35	three	three	CD
18637	20000	36	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	20000	37	found	find	VBD
18637	20000	38	persuasive	persuasive	JJ
18637	20000	39	,	,	,
18637	20000	40	that	that	IN
18637	20000	41	the	the	DT
18637	20000	42	act	act	NN
18637	20000	43	denied	deny	VBD
18637	20000	44	the	the	DT
18637	20000	45	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20000	46	protection	protection	NN
18637	20000	47	of	of	IN
18637	20000	48	the	the	DT
18637	20000	49	law	law	NN
18637	20000	50	to	to	IN
18637	20000	51	female	female	JJ
18637	20000	52	owners	owner	NNS
18637	20000	53	of	of	IN
18637	20000	54	such	such	JJ
18637	20000	55	establishments	establishment	NNS
18637	20000	56	.	.	.
18637	20001	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20001	2	1140	1140	CD
18637	20001	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20001	4	Said	Said	NNP
18637	20001	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20001	6	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	20001	7	for	for	IN
18637	20001	8	the	the	DT
18637	20001	9	majority	majority	NN
18637	20001	10	:	:	:
18637	20001	11	"	"	``
18637	20001	12	The	the	DT
18637	20001	13	fact	fact	NN
18637	20001	14	that	that	IN
18637	20001	15	women	woman	NNS
18637	20001	16	may	may	MD
18637	20001	17	now	now	RB
18637	20001	18	have	have	VB
18637	20001	19	achieved	achieve	VBN
18637	20001	20	the	the	DT
18637	20001	21	virtues	virtue	NNS
18637	20001	22	that	that	WDT
18637	20001	23	men	man	NNS
18637	20001	24	have	have	VBP
18637	20001	25	long	long	RB
18637	20001	26	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	20001	27	as	as	IN
18637	20001	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20001	29	prerogatives	prerogative	NNS
18637	20001	30	and	and	CC
18637	20001	31	now	now	RB
18637	20001	32	indulge	indulge	VBP
18637	20001	33	in	in	IN
18637	20001	34	vices	vice	NNS
18637	20001	35	that	that	IN
18637	20001	36	men	man	NNS
18637	20001	37	have	have	VBP
18637	20001	38	long	long	RB
18637	20001	39	practiced	practice	VBN
18637	20001	40	,	,	,
18637	20001	41	does	do	VBZ
18637	20001	42	not	not	RB
18637	20001	43	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	20001	44	the	the	DT
18637	20001	45	States	States	NNP
18637	20001	46	from	from	IN
18637	20001	47	drawing	draw	VBG
18637	20001	48	a	a	DT
18637	20001	49	sharp	sharp	JJ
18637	20001	50	line	line	NN
18637	20001	51	between	between	IN
18637	20001	52	the	the	DT
18637	20001	53	sexes	sex	NNS
18637	20001	54	,	,	,
18637	20001	55	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	20001	56	in	in	IN
18637	20001	57	such	such	JJ
18637	20001	58	matters	matter	NNS
18637	20001	59	as	as	IN
18637	20001	60	the	the	DT
18637	20001	61	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	20001	62	of	of	IN
18637	20001	63	the	the	DT
18637	20001	64	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	20001	65	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	20001	66	.	.	.
18637	20002	1	*	*	NFP
18637	20002	2	*	*	NFP
18637	20002	3	*	*	NFP
18637	20002	4	The	the	DT
18637	20002	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	20002	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	20002	7	not	not	RB
18637	20002	8	require	require	VB
18637	20002	9	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	20002	10	to	to	TO
18637	20002	11	reflect	reflect	VB
18637	20002	12	sociological	sociological	JJ
18637	20002	13	insight	insight	NN
18637	20002	14	,	,	,
18637	20002	15	or	or	CC
18637	20002	16	shifting	shift	VBG
18637	20002	17	social	social	JJ
18637	20002	18	standards	standard	NNS
18637	20002	19	,	,	,
18637	20002	20	any	any	DT
18637	20002	21	more	more	RBR
18637	20002	22	than	than	IN
18637	20002	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20002	24	requires	require	VBZ
18637	20002	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20002	26	to	to	TO
18637	20002	27	keep	keep	VB
18637	20002	28	abreast	abreast	RB
18637	20002	29	of	of	IN
18637	20002	30	the	the	DT
18637	20002	31	latest	late	JJS
18637	20002	32	scientific	scientific	JJ
18637	20002	33	standards	standard	NNS
18637	20002	34	.	.	.
18637	20003	1	"	"	``
18637	20003	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20003	3	1141	1141	CD
18637	20003	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20003	5	Monopolies	Monopolies	NNPS
18637	20003	6	On	on	IN
18637	20003	7	the	the	DT
18637	20003	8	principle	principle	NN
18637	20003	9	that	that	IN
18637	20003	10	the	the	DT
18637	20003	11	law	law	NN
18637	20003	12	may	may	MD
18637	20003	13	hit	hit	VB
18637	20003	14	the	the	DT
18637	20003	15	evil	evil	NN
18637	20003	16	where	where	WRB
18637	20003	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20003	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	20003	19	most	most	RBS
18637	20003	20	felt	feel	VBN
18637	20003	21	,	,	,
18637	20003	22	State	State	NNP
18637	20003	23	Antitrust	Antitrust	NNP
18637	20003	24	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	20003	25	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	20003	26	to	to	IN
18637	20003	27	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	20003	28	but	but	CC
18637	20003	29	not	not	RB
18637	20003	30	to	to	TO
18637	20003	31	individuals,[1142	individuals,[1142	NNP
18637	20003	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20003	33	or	or	CC
18637	20003	34	to	to	IN
18637	20003	35	vendors	vendor	NNS
18637	20003	36	of	of	IN
18637	20003	37	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	20003	38	but	but	CC
18637	20003	39	not	not	RB
18637	20003	40	to	to	IN
18637	20003	41	vendors	vendor	NNS
18637	20003	42	of	of	IN
18637	20003	43	labor,[1143	labor,[1143	NNP
18637	20003	44	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20003	45	have	have	VBP
18637	20003	46	been	be	VBN
18637	20003	47	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	20003	48	.	.	.
18637	20004	1	Contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	20004	2	to	to	IN
18637	20004	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20004	4	earlier	early	JJR
18637	20004	5	view	view	NN
18637	20004	6	,	,	,
18637	20004	7	the	the	DT
18637	20004	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20004	9	now	now	RB
18637	20004	10	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	20004	11	that	that	IN
18637	20004	12	an	an	DT
18637	20004	13	Antitrust	Antitrust	NNP
18637	20004	14	Act	Act	NNP
18637	20004	15	which	which	WDT
18637	20004	16	exempts	exempt	VBZ
18637	20004	17	agricultural	agricultural	JJ
18637	20004	18	products	product	NNS
18637	20004	19	in	in	IN
18637	20004	20	the	the	DT
18637	20004	21	hands	hand	NNS
18637	20004	22	of	of	IN
18637	20004	23	the	the	DT
18637	20004	24	producer	producer	NN
18637	20004	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	20004	26	valid	valid	JJ
18637	20004	27	.	.	.
18637	20005	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20005	2	1144	1144	CD
18637	20005	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20005	4	Diversity	diversity	NN
18637	20005	5	with	with	IN
18637	20005	6	respect	respect	NN
18637	20005	7	to	to	IN
18637	20005	8	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	20005	9	also	also	RB
18637	20005	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	20005	11	been	be	VBN
18637	20005	12	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	20005	13	.	.	.
18637	20006	1	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	20006	2	violating	violate	VBG
18637	20006	3	the	the	DT
18637	20006	4	law	law	NN
18637	20006	5	may	may	MD
18637	20006	6	be	be	VB
18637	20006	7	proceeded	proceed	VBN
18637	20006	8	against	against	IN
18637	20006	9	by	by	IN
18637	20006	10	bill	bill	NN
18637	20006	11	in	in	IN
18637	20006	12	equity	equity	NN
18637	20006	13	,	,	,
18637	20006	14	while	while	IN
18637	20006	15	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	20006	16	are	be	VBP
18637	20006	17	indicted	indict	VBN
18637	20006	18	and	and	CC
18637	20006	19	tried	try	VBN
18637	20006	20	.	.	.
18637	20007	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20007	2	1145	1145	CD
18637	20007	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20007	4	A	a	DT
18637	20007	5	provision	provision	NN
18637	20007	6	,	,	,
18637	20007	7	superimposed	superimpose	VBN
18637	20007	8	upon	upon	IN
18637	20007	9	the	the	DT
18637	20007	10	general	general	JJ
18637	20007	11	Antitrust	Antitrust	NNP
18637	20007	12	Law	Law	NNP
18637	20007	13	,	,	,
18637	20007	14	for	for	IN
18637	20007	15	revocation	revocation	NN
18637	20007	16	of	of	IN
18637	20007	17	the	the	DT
18637	20007	18	licenses	license	NNS
18637	20007	19	of	of	IN
18637	20007	20	fire	fire	NN
18637	20007	21	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	20007	22	companies	company	NNS
18637	20007	23	which	which	WDT
18637	20007	24	enter	enter	VBP
18637	20007	25	into	into	IN
18637	20007	26	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	20007	27	combinations	combination	NNS
18637	20007	28	,	,	,
18637	20007	29	does	do	VBZ
18637	20007	30	not	not	RB
18637	20007	31	violate	violate	VB
18637	20007	32	the	the	DT
18637	20007	33	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20007	34	protection	protection	NN
18637	20007	35	clause	clause	NN
18637	20007	36	.	.	.
18637	20008	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20008	2	1146	1146	CD
18637	20008	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20008	4	A	a	DT
18637	20008	5	grant	grant	NN
18637	20008	6	of	of	IN
18637	20008	7	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	20008	8	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	20008	9	,	,	,
18637	20008	10	if	if	IN
18637	20008	11	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	20008	12	an	an	DT
18637	20008	13	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	20008	14	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	20008	15	of	of	IN
18637	20008	16	the	the	DT
18637	20008	17	police	police	NN
18637	20008	18	power	power	NN
18637	20008	19	,	,	,
18637	20008	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	20008	21	immune	immune	JJ
18637	20008	22	to	to	TO
18637	20008	23	attack	attack	VB
18637	20008	24	under	under	IN
18637	20008	25	that	that	DT
18637	20008	26	clause	clause	NN
18637	20008	27	.	.	.
18637	20009	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20009	2	1147	1147	CD
18637	20009	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20009	4	Punishment	punishment	NN
18637	20009	5	for	for	IN
18637	20009	6	Crime	Crime	NNP
18637	20009	7	Equality	equality	NN
18637	20009	8	of	of	IN
18637	20009	9	protection	protection	NN
18637	20009	10	under	under	IN
18637	20009	11	the	the	DT
18637	20009	12	law	law	NN
18637	20009	13	implies	imply	VBZ
18637	20009	14	that	that	IN
18637	20009	15	in	in	IN
18637	20009	16	the	the	DT
18637	20009	17	administration	administration	NN
18637	20009	18	of	of	IN
18637	20009	19	criminal	criminal	NNP
18637	20009	20	justice	justice	NN
18637	20009	21	no	no	DT
18637	20009	22	person	person	NN
18637	20009	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	20009	24	be	be	VB
18637	20009	25	subject	subject	JJ
18637	20009	26	to	to	IN
18637	20009	27	any	any	DT
18637	20009	28	greater	great	JJR
18637	20009	29	or	or	CC
18637	20009	30	different	different	JJ
18637	20009	31	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	20009	32	than	than	IN
18637	20009	33	another	another	DT
18637	20009	34	in	in	IN
18637	20009	35	similar	similar	JJ
18637	20009	36	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	20009	37	.	.	.
18637	20010	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20010	2	1148	1148	CD
18637	20010	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20010	4	Comparative	comparative	JJ
18637	20010	5	gravity	gravity	NN
18637	20010	6	of	of	IN
18637	20010	7	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	20010	8	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	20010	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	20010	10	a	a	DT
18637	20010	11	matter	matter	NN
18637	20010	12	for	for	IN
18637	20010	13	the	the	DT
18637	20010	14	State	State	NNP
18637	20010	15	to	to	TO
18637	20010	16	determine	determine	VB
18637	20010	17	,	,	,
18637	20010	18	and	and	CC
18637	20010	19	the	the	DT
18637	20010	20	fact	fact	NN
18637	20010	21	that	that	IN
18637	20010	22	some	some	DT
18637	20010	23	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	20010	24	are	be	VBP
18637	20010	25	punished	punish	VBN
18637	20010	26	with	with	IN
18637	20010	27	less	less	JJR
18637	20010	28	severity	severity	NN
18637	20010	29	than	than	IN
18637	20010	30	others	other	NNS
18637	20010	31	does	do	VBZ
18637	20010	32	not	not	RB
18637	20010	33	deny	deny	VB
18637	20010	34	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20010	35	protection	protection	NN
18637	20010	36	.	.	.
18637	20011	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20011	2	1149	1149	CD
18637	20011	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20011	4	Heavier	heavy	JJR
18637	20011	5	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	20011	6	may	may	MD
18637	20011	7	be	be	VB
18637	20011	8	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	20011	9	upon	upon	IN
18637	20011	10	habitual	habitual	JJ
18637	20011	11	criminals	criminal	NNS
18637	20011	12	for	for	IN
18637	20011	13	like	like	IN
18637	20011	14	offenses,[1150	offenses,[1150	NNP
18637	20011	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20011	16	even	even	RB
18637	20011	17	after	after	IN
18637	20011	18	a	a	DT
18637	20011	19	pardon	pardon	NN
18637	20011	20	for	for	IN
18637	20011	21	an	an	DT
18637	20011	22	earlier	early	JJR
18637	20011	23	offense,[1151	offense,[1151	NN
18637	20011	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20011	25	and	and	CC
18637	20011	26	such	such	JJ
18637	20011	27	persons	person	NNS
18637	20011	28	may	may	MD
18637	20011	29	be	be	VB
18637	20011	30	made	make	VBN
18637	20011	31	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	20011	32	for	for	IN
18637	20011	33	parole	parole	NN
18637	20011	34	.	.	.
18637	20012	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20012	2	1152	1152	CD
18637	20012	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20012	4	A	a	DT
18637	20012	5	State	State	NNP
18637	20012	6	law	law	NN
18637	20012	7	doubling	double	VBG
18637	20012	8	the	the	DT
18637	20012	9	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	20012	10	on	on	IN
18637	20012	11	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
18637	20012	12	attempting	attempt	VBG
18637	20012	13	to	to	TO
18637	20012	14	escape	escape	VB
18637	20012	15	does	do	VBZ
18637	20012	16	not	not	RB
18637	20012	17	deny	deny	VB
18637	20012	18	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20012	19	protection	protection	NN
18637	20012	20	in	in	IN
18637	20012	21	subjecting	subject	VBG
18637	20012	22	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
18637	20012	23	who	who	WP
18637	20012	24	attempt	attempt	VBP
18637	20012	25	to	to	TO
18637	20012	26	escape	escape	VB
18637	20012	27	together	together	RB
18637	20012	28	to	to	IN
18637	20012	29	different	different	JJ
18637	20012	30	sentences	sentence	NNS
18637	20012	31	depending	depend	VBG
18637	20012	32	on	on	IN
18637	20012	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20012	34	original	original	JJ
18637	20012	35	sentences	sentence	NNS
18637	20012	36	.	.	.
18637	20013	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20013	2	1153	1153	CD
18637	20013	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20013	4	Infliction	infliction	NN
18637	20013	5	of	of	IN
18637	20013	6	the	the	DT
18637	20013	7	death	death	NN
18637	20013	8	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	20013	9	for	for	IN
18637	20013	10	assaults	assault	NNS
18637	20013	11	with	with	IN
18637	20013	12	intent	intent	NN
18637	20013	13	to	to	TO
18637	20013	14	kill	kill	VB
18637	20013	15	by	by	IN
18637	20013	16	life	life	NN
18637	20013	17	term	term	NN
18637	20013	18	convicts	convict	NNS
18637	20013	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	20013	20	not	not	RB
18637	20013	21	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	20013	22	because	because	IN
18637	20013	23	not	not	RB
18637	20013	24	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	20013	25	to	to	IN
18637	20013	26	convicts	convict	NNS
18637	20013	27	serving	serve	VBG
18637	20013	28	lesser	less	JJR
18637	20013	29	terms	term	NNS
18637	20013	30	.	.	.
18637	20014	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20014	2	1154	1154	CD
18637	20014	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20014	4	The	the	DT
18637	20014	5	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	20014	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20014	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	20014	8	not	not	RB
18637	20014	9	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	20014	10	the	the	DT
18637	20014	11	commitment	commitment	NN
18637	20014	12	of	of	IN
18637	20014	13	persons	person	NNS
18637	20014	14	who	who	WP
18637	20014	15	,	,	,
18637	20014	16	by	by	IN
18637	20014	17	an	an	DT
18637	20014	18	habitual	habitual	JJ
18637	20014	19	course	course	NN
18637	20014	20	of	of	IN
18637	20014	21	misconduct	misconduct	NN
18637	20014	22	,	,	,
18637	20014	23	have	have	VBP
18637	20014	24	evidenced	evidence	VBN
18637	20014	25	utter	utter	JJ
18637	20014	26	lack	lack	NN
18637	20014	27	of	of	IN
18637	20014	28	power	power	NN
18637	20014	29	to	to	TO
18637	20014	30	control	control	VB
18637	20014	31	sexual	sexual	JJ
18637	20014	32	impulses	impulse	NNS
18637	20014	33	,	,	,
18637	20014	34	and	and	CC
18637	20014	35	are	be	VBP
18637	20014	36	likely	likely	JJ
18637	20014	37	to	to	TO
18637	20014	38	inflict	inflict	VB
18637	20014	39	injury	injury	NN
18637	20014	40	.	.	.
18637	20015	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20015	2	1155	1155	CD
18637	20015	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20015	4	A	a	DT
18637	20015	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	20015	6	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	20015	7	a	a	DT
18637	20015	8	white	white	JJ
18637	20015	9	person	person	NN
18637	20015	10	and	and	CC
18637	20015	11	a	a	DT
18637	20015	12	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	20015	13	from	from	IN
18637	20015	14	living	live	VBG
18637	20015	15	together	together	RB
18637	20015	16	in	in	IN
18637	20015	17	adultery	adultery	NN
18637	20015	18	or	or	CC
18637	20015	19	fornication	fornication	NN
18637	20015	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	20015	21	not	not	RB
18637	20015	22	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	20015	23	because	because	IN
18637	20015	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20015	25	prescribes	prescribe	VBZ
18637	20015	26	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	20015	27	more	more	RBR
18637	20015	28	severe	severe	JJ
18637	20015	29	than	than	IN
18637	20015	30	those	those	DT
18637	20015	31	to	to	TO
18637	20015	32	which	which	WDT
18637	20015	33	the	the	DT
18637	20015	34	parties	party	NNS
18637	20015	35	would	would	MD
18637	20015	36	be	be	VB
18637	20015	37	subject	subject	JJ
18637	20015	38	were	be	VBD
18637	20015	39	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20015	40	both	both	DT
18637	20015	41	of	of	IN
18637	20015	42	the	the	DT
18637	20015	43	same	same	JJ
18637	20015	44	race	race	NN
18637	20015	45	.	.	.
18637	20016	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20016	2	1156	1156	CD
18637	20016	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20016	4	The	the	DT
18637	20016	5	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20016	6	protection	protection	NN
18637	20016	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	20016	8	does	do	VBZ
18637	20016	9	not	not	RB
18637	20016	10	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	20016	11	the	the	DT
18637	20016	12	execution	execution	NN
18637	20016	13	of	of	IN
18637	20016	14	a	a	DT
18637	20016	15	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	20016	16	after	after	IN
18637	20016	17	the	the	DT
18637	20016	18	accidental	accidental	JJ
18637	20016	19	failure	failure	NN
18637	20016	20	of	of	IN
18637	20016	21	the	the	DT
18637	20016	22	first	first	JJ
18637	20016	23	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	20016	24	.	.	.
18637	20017	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20017	2	1157	1157	CD
18637	20017	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20017	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20017	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	20017	6	,	,	,
18637	20017	7	however	however	RB
18637	20017	8	,	,	,
18637	20017	9	render	render	VBP
18637	20017	10	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	20017	11	a	a	DT
18637	20017	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	20017	13	requiring	require	VBG
18637	20017	14	sterilization	sterilization	NN
18637	20017	15	of	of	IN
18637	20017	16	persons	person	NNS
18637	20017	17	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	20017	18	of	of	IN
18637	20017	19	various	various	JJ
18637	20017	20	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	20017	21	,	,	,
18637	20017	22	including	include	VBG
18637	20017	23	larceny	larceny	NN
18637	20017	24	by	by	IN
18637	20017	25	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	20017	26	,	,	,
18637	20017	27	but	but	CC
18637	20017	28	exempting	exempt	VBG
18637	20017	29	embezzlers	embezzler	NNS
18637	20017	30	.	.	.
18637	20018	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20018	2	1158	1158	CD
18637	20018	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20018	4	Segregation	Segregation	NNP
18637	20018	5	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	20018	6	designed	design	VBN
18637	20018	7	to	to	TO
18637	20018	8	segregate	segregate	VB
18637	20018	9	persons	person	NNS
18637	20018	10	of	of	IN
18637	20018	11	different	different	JJ
18637	20018	12	races	race	NNS
18637	20018	13	in	in	IN
18637	20018	14	the	the	DT
18637	20018	15	location	location	NN
18637	20018	16	of	of	IN
18637	20018	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20018	18	homes	home	NNS
18637	20018	19	,	,	,
18637	20018	20	in	in	IN
18637	20018	21	the	the	DT
18637	20018	22	public	public	JJ
18637	20018	23	schools	school	NNS
18637	20018	24	and	and	CC
18637	20018	25	on	on	IN
18637	20018	26	public	public	JJ
18637	20018	27	conveyances	conveyance	NNS
18637	20018	28	have	have	VBP
18637	20018	29	been	be	VBN
18637	20018	30	a	a	DT
18637	20018	31	prolific	prolific	JJ
18637	20018	32	source	source	NN
18637	20018	33	of	of	IN
18637	20018	34	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	20018	35	under	under	IN
18637	20018	36	the	the	DT
18637	20018	37	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20018	38	protection	protection	NN
18637	20018	39	clause	clause	NN
18637	20018	40	.	.	.
18637	20019	1	An	an	DT
18637	20019	2	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	20019	3	intended	intend	VBN
18637	20019	4	to	to	TO
18637	20019	5	segregate	segregate	VB
18637	20019	6	the	the	DT
18637	20019	7	homes	home	NNS
18637	20019	8	of	of	IN
18637	20019	9	white	white	JJ
18637	20019	10	and	and	CC
18637	20019	11	colored	colored	JJ
18637	20019	12	races	race	NNS
18637	20019	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	20019	14	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	20019	15	.	.	.
18637	20020	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20020	2	1159	1159	CD
18637	20020	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20020	4	Private	private	JJ
18637	20020	5	covenants	covenant	NNS
18637	20020	6	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	20020	7	the	the	DT
18637	20020	8	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	20020	9	of	of	IN
18637	20020	10	real	real	JJ
18637	20020	11	property	property	NN
18637	20020	12	to	to	IN
18637	20020	13	persons	person	NNS
18637	20020	14	of	of	IN
18637	20020	15	a	a	DT
18637	20020	16	certain	certain	JJ
18637	20020	17	race	race	NN
18637	20020	18	or	or	CC
18637	20020	19	color	color	NN
18637	20020	20	have	have	VBP
18637	20020	21	been	be	VBN
18637	20020	22	held	hold	VBN
18637	20020	23	lawful,[1160	lawful,[1160	NNP
18637	20020	24	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20020	25	but	but	CC
18637	20020	26	the	the	DT
18637	20020	27	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	20020	28	of	of	IN
18637	20020	29	such	such	JJ
18637	20020	30	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	20020	31	by	by	IN
18637	20020	32	a	a	DT
18637	20020	33	State	state	NN
18637	20020	34	through	through	IN
18637	20020	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20020	36	courts	court	NNS
18637	20020	37	would	would	MD
18637	20020	38	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	20020	39	a	a	DT
18637	20020	40	denial	denial	NN
18637	20020	41	of	of	IN
18637	20020	42	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20020	43	protection	protection	NN
18637	20020	44	of	of	IN
18637	20020	45	the	the	DT
18637	20020	46	laws	law	NNS
18637	20020	47	.	.	.
18637	20021	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20021	2	1161	1161	CD
18637	20021	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20021	4	A	a	DT
18637	20021	5	statute	statute	NN
18637	20021	6	providing	provide	VBG
18637	20021	7	for	for	IN
18637	20021	8	separate	separate	JJ
18637	20021	9	but	but	CC
18637	20021	10	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20021	11	accommodations	accommodation	NNS
18637	20021	12	on	on	IN
18637	20021	13	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	20021	14	for	for	IN
18637	20021	15	white	white	JJ
18637	20021	16	and	and	CC
18637	20021	17	colored	colored	JJ
18637	20021	18	persons	person	NNS
18637	20021	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	20021	20	been	be	VBN
18637	20021	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	20021	22	not	not	RB
18637	20021	23	to	to	TO
18637	20021	24	deny	deny	VB
18637	20021	25	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20021	26	protection	protection	NN
18637	20021	27	of	of	IN
18637	20021	28	the	the	DT
18637	20021	29	law,[1162	law,[1162	NNS
18637	20021	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20021	31	but	but	CC
18637	20021	32	a	a	DT
18637	20021	33	separate	separate	JJ
18637	20021	34	coach	coach	NN
18637	20021	35	law	law	NN
18637	20021	36	which	which	WDT
18637	20021	37	permits	permit	VBZ
18637	20021	38	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	20021	39	to	to	TO
18637	20021	40	provide	provide	VB
18637	20021	41	sleeping	sleep	VBG
18637	20021	42	and	and	CC
18637	20021	43	dining	dining	NN
18637	20021	44	cars	car	NNS
18637	20021	45	only	only	RB
18637	20021	46	for	for	IN
18637	20021	47	white	white	JJ
18637	20021	48	persons	person	NNS
18637	20021	49	,	,	,
18637	20021	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	20021	51	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	20021	52	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	20021	53	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	20021	54	by	by	IN
18637	20021	55	the	the	DT
18637	20021	56	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	20021	57	that	that	IN
18637	20021	58	there	there	EX
18637	20021	59	would	would	MD
18637	20021	60	be	be	VB
18637	20021	61	little	little	JJ
18637	20021	62	demand	demand	NN
18637	20021	63	for	for	IN
18637	20021	64	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20021	65	by	by	IN
18637	20021	66	colored	colored	JJ
18637	20021	67	persons	person	NNS
18637	20021	68	.	.	.
18637	20022	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20022	2	1163	1163	CD
18637	20022	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20022	4	Fifty	fifty	CD
18637	20022	5	years	year	NNS
18637	20022	6	ago	ago	RB
18637	20022	7	the	the	DT
18637	20022	8	action	action	NN
18637	20022	9	of	of	IN
18637	20022	10	a	a	DT
18637	20022	11	local	local	JJ
18637	20022	12	board	board	NN
18637	20022	13	of	of	IN
18637	20022	14	education	education	NN
18637	20022	15	in	in	IN
18637	20022	16	suspending	suspend	VBG
18637	20022	17	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	20022	18	for	for	IN
18637	20022	19	economic	economic	JJ
18637	20022	20	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	20022	21	a	a	DT
18637	20022	22	high	high	JJ
18637	20022	23	school	school	NN
18637	20022	24	for	for	IN
18637	20022	25	colored	colored	JJ
18637	20022	26	children	child	NNS
18637	20022	27	was	be	VBD
18637	20022	28	held	hold	VBN
18637	20022	29	not	not	RB
18637	20022	30	to	to	TO
18637	20022	31	be	be	VB
18637	20022	32	a	a	DT
18637	20022	33	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	20022	34	reason	reason	NN
18637	20022	35	for	for	IN
18637	20022	36	restraining	restrain	VBG
18637	20022	37	the	the	DT
18637	20022	38	board	board	NN
18637	20022	39	from	from	IN
18637	20022	40	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	20022	41	an	an	DT
18637	20022	42	existing	exist	VBG
18637	20022	43	high	high	JJ
18637	20022	44	school	school	NN
18637	20022	45	for	for	IN
18637	20022	46	white	white	JJ
18637	20022	47	children	child	NNS
18637	20022	48	,	,	,
18637	20022	49	when	when	WRB
18637	20022	50	the	the	DT
18637	20022	51	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	20022	52	did	do	VBD
18637	20022	53	not	not	RB
18637	20022	54	indicate	indicate	VB
18637	20022	55	that	that	IN
18637	20022	56	the	the	DT
18637	20022	57	board	board	NN
18637	20022	58	had	have	VBD
18637	20022	59	proceeded	proceed	VBN
18637	20022	60	in	in	IN
18637	20022	61	bad	bad	JJ
18637	20022	62	faith	faith	NN
18637	20022	63	or	or	CC
18637	20022	64	had	have	VBD
18637	20022	65	acted	act	VBN
18637	20022	66	in	in	IN
18637	20022	67	hostility	hostility	NN
18637	20022	68	to	to	IN
18637	20022	69	the	the	DT
18637	20022	70	colored	colored	JJ
18637	20022	71	race	race	NN
18637	20022	72	.	.	.
18637	20023	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20023	2	1164	1164	CD
18637	20023	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20023	4	A	a	DT
18637	20023	5	child	child	NN
18637	20023	6	of	of	IN
18637	20023	7	Chinese	chinese	JJ
18637	20023	8	ancestry	ancestry	NN
18637	20023	9	,	,	,
18637	20023	10	who	who	WP
18637	20023	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	20023	12	a	a	DT
18637	20023	13	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	20023	14	of	of	IN
18637	20023	15	the	the	DT
18637	20023	16	United	United	NNP
18637	20023	17	States	States	NNP
18637	20023	18	,	,	,
18637	20023	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	20023	20	not	not	RB
18637	20023	21	denied	deny	VBN
18637	20023	22	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20023	23	protection	protection	NN
18637	20023	24	of	of	IN
18637	20023	25	law	law	NN
18637	20023	26	by	by	IN
18637	20023	27	being	be	VBG
18637	20023	28	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	20023	29	to	to	IN
18637	20023	30	a	a	DT
18637	20023	31	public	public	JJ
18637	20023	32	school	school	NN
18637	20023	33	provided	provide	VBN
18637	20023	34	for	for	IN
18637	20023	35	colored	colored	JJ
18637	20023	36	children	child	NNS
18637	20023	37	,	,	,
18637	20023	38	when	when	WRB
18637	20023	39	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20023	40	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	20023	41	for	for	IN
18637	20023	42	education	education	NN
18637	20023	43	are	be	VBP
18637	20023	44	offered	offer	VBN
18637	20023	45	to	to	IN
18637	20023	46	both	both	DT
18637	20023	47	races	race	NNS
18637	20023	48	.	.	.
18637	20024	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20024	2	1165	1165	CD
18637	20024	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20024	4	Although	although	IN
18637	20024	5	the	the	DT
18637	20024	6	principle	principle	NN
18637	20024	7	that	that	WDT
18637	20024	8	separate	separate	VBP
18637	20024	9	but	but	CC
18637	20024	10	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20024	11	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	20024	12	satisfy	satisfy	VBP
18637	20024	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	20024	14	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	20024	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	20024	16	not	not	RB
18637	20024	17	been	be	VBN
18637	20024	18	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	20024	19	,	,	,
18637	20024	20	the	the	DT
18637	20024	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20024	22	in	in	IN
18637	20024	23	recent	recent	JJ
18637	20024	24	years	year	NNS
18637	20024	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	20024	26	been	be	VBN
18637	20024	27	inclined	incline	VBN
18637	20024	28	to	to	TO
18637	20024	29	review	review	VB
18637	20024	30	more	more	RBR
18637	20024	31	critically	critically	RB
18637	20024	32	the	the	DT
18637	20024	33	facts	fact	NNS
18637	20024	34	of	of	IN
18637	20024	35	cases	case	NNS
18637	20024	36	brought	bring	VBN
18637	20024	37	before	before	IN
18637	20024	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20024	39	to	to	TO
18637	20024	40	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	20024	41	whether	whether	IN
18637	20024	42	equality	equality	NN
18637	20024	43	has	have	VBZ
18637	20024	44	,	,	,
18637	20024	45	in	in	IN
18637	20024	46	fact	fact	NN
18637	20024	47	,	,	,
18637	20024	48	been	be	VBN
18637	20024	49	offered	offer	VBN
18637	20024	50	.	.	.
18637	20025	1	In	in	IN
18637	20025	2	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20025	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20025	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	20025	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20025	6	Canada[1166	Canada[1166	NNP
18637	20025	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20025	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20025	9	held	hold	VBD
18637	20025	10	that	that	IN
18637	20025	11	the	the	DT
18637	20025	12	State	State	NNP
18637	20025	13	was	be	VBD
18637	20025	14	denying	deny	VBG
18637	20025	15	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20025	16	protection	protection	NN
18637	20025	17	of	of	IN
18637	20025	18	the	the	DT
18637	20025	19	law	law	NN
18637	20025	20	in	in	IN
18637	20025	21	failing	fail	VBG
18637	20025	22	to	to	TO
18637	20025	23	provide	provide	VB
18637	20025	24	a	a	DT
18637	20025	25	legal	legal	JJ
18637	20025	26	education	education	NN
18637	20025	27	within	within	IN
18637	20025	28	the	the	DT
18637	20025	29	State	State	NNP
18637	20025	30	for	for	IN
18637	20025	31	Negroes	Negroes	NNPS
18637	20025	32	comparable	comparable	JJ
18637	20025	33	to	to	IN
18637	20025	34	that	that	DT
18637	20025	35	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	20025	36	white	white	JJ
18637	20025	37	students	student	NNS
18637	20025	38	.	.	.
18637	20026	1	Pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	20026	2	to	to	IN
18637	20026	3	a	a	DT
18637	20026	4	policy	policy	NN
18637	20026	5	of	of	IN
18637	20026	6	segregating	segregate	VBG
18637	20026	7	Negro	negro	JJ
18637	20026	8	and	and	CC
18637	20026	9	white	white	JJ
18637	20026	10	students	student	NNS
18637	20026	11	,	,	,
18637	20026	12	the	the	DT
18637	20026	13	State	State	NNP
18637	20026	14	had	have	VBD
18637	20026	15	established	establish	VBN
18637	20026	16	a	a	DT
18637	20026	17	law	law	NN
18637	20026	18	school	school	NN
18637	20026	19	at	at	IN
18637	20026	20	the	the	DT
18637	20026	21	State	State	NNP
18637	20026	22	university	university	NN
18637	20026	23	for	for	IN
18637	20026	24	white	white	JJ
18637	20026	25	applicants	applicant	NNS
18637	20026	26	.	.	.
18637	20027	1	In	in	IN
18637	20027	2	lieu	lieu	NN
18637	20027	3	of	of	IN
18637	20027	4	setting	set	VBG
18637	20027	5	up	up	RP
18637	20027	6	one	one	CD
18637	20027	7	at	at	IN
18637	20027	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20027	9	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	20027	10	university	university	NN
18637	20027	11	,	,	,
18637	20027	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20027	13	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	20027	14	the	the	DT
18637	20027	15	curators	curator	NNS
18637	20027	16	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	20027	17	to	to	TO
18637	20027	18	establish	establish	VB
18637	20027	19	such	such	PDT
18637	20027	20	a	a	DT
18637	20027	21	school	school	NN
18637	20027	22	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	20027	23	in	in	IN
18637	20027	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20027	25	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	20027	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20027	27	should	should	MD
18637	20027	28	be	be	VB
18637	20027	29	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	20027	30	and	and	CC
18637	20027	31	practicable	practicable	JJ
18637	20027	32	to	to	TO
18637	20027	33	do	do	VB
18637	20027	34	so	so	RB
18637	20027	35	,	,	,
18637	20027	36	and	and	CC
18637	20027	37	pending	pende	VBG
18637	20027	38	such	such	JJ
18637	20027	39	development	development	NN
18637	20027	40	,	,	,
18637	20027	41	to	to	TO
18637	20027	42	arrange	arrange	VB
18637	20027	43	and	and	CC
18637	20027	44	pay	pay	VB
18637	20027	45	for	for	IN
18637	20027	46	the	the	DT
18637	20027	47	legal	legal	JJ
18637	20027	48	education	education	NN
18637	20027	49	of	of	IN
18637	20027	50	the	the	DT
18637	20027	51	State	State	NNP
18637	20027	52	's	's	POS
18637	20027	53	Negroes	Negroes	NNPS
18637	20027	54	at	at	IN
18637	20027	55	schools	school	NNS
18637	20027	56	in	in	IN
18637	20027	57	other	other	JJ
18637	20027	58	States	States	NNPS
18637	20027	59	.	.	.
18637	20028	1	This	this	DT
18637	20028	2	was	be	VBD
18637	20028	3	found	find	VBN
18637	20028	4	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
18637	20028	5	;	;	:
18637	20028	6	the	the	DT
18637	20028	7	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	20028	8	of	of	IN
18637	20028	9	the	the	DT
18637	20028	10	State	State	NNP
18637	20028	11	to	to	TO
18637	20028	12	afford	afford	VB
18637	20028	13	the	the	DT
18637	20028	14	protection	protection	NN
18637	20028	15	of	of	IN
18637	20028	16	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20028	17	law	law	NN
18637	20028	18	can	can	MD
18637	20028	19	be	be	VB
18637	20028	20	performed	perform	VBN
18637	20028	21	only	only	RB
18637	20028	22	where	where	WRB
18637	20028	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20028	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	20028	25	operate	operate	VBP
18637	20028	26	,	,	,
18637	20028	27	that	that	DT
18637	20028	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	20028	29	to	to	TO
18637	20028	30	say	say	VB
18637	20028	31	,	,	,
18637	20028	32	within	within	IN
18637	20028	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20028	34	own	own	JJ
18637	20028	35	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	20028	36	.	.	.
18637	20029	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20029	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	20029	3	there	there	RB
18637	20029	4	that	that	DT
18637	20029	5	equality	equality	NN
18637	20029	6	of	of	IN
18637	20029	7	rights	right	NNS
18637	20029	8	must	must	MD
18637	20029	9	be	be	VB
18637	20029	10	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	20029	11	.	.	.
18637	20030	1	In	in	IN
18637	20030	2	a	a	DT
18637	20030	3	later	later	JJ
18637	20030	4	case	case	NN
18637	20030	5	the	the	DT
18637	20030	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20030	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	20030	8	that	that	IN
18637	20030	9	the	the	DT
18637	20030	10	State	State	NNP
18637	20030	11	of	of	IN
18637	20030	12	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	20030	13	was	be	VBD
18637	20030	14	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	20030	15	to	to	TO
18637	20030	16	provide	provide	VB
18637	20030	17	legal	legal	JJ
18637	20030	18	education	education	NN
18637	20030	19	for	for	IN
18637	20030	20	a	a	DT
18637	20030	21	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	20030	22	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	20030	23	applicant	applicant	NN
18637	20030	24	as	as	RB
18637	20030	25	soon	soon	RB
18637	20030	26	as	as	IN
18637	20030	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20030	28	did	do	VBD
18637	20030	29	for	for	IN
18637	20030	30	applicants	applicant	NNS
18637	20030	31	of	of	IN
18637	20030	32	any	any	DT
18637	20030	33	other	other	JJ
18637	20030	34	group	group	NN
18637	20030	35	.	.	.
18637	20031	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20031	2	1167	1167	CD
18637	20031	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20031	4	To	to	TO
18637	20031	5	comply	comply	VB
18637	20031	6	with	with	IN
18637	20031	7	this	this	DT
18637	20031	8	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	20031	9	a	a	DT
18637	20031	10	State	State	NNP
18637	20031	11	court	court	NN
18637	20031	12	entered	enter	VBD
18637	20031	13	an	an	DT
18637	20031	14	order	order	NN
18637	20031	15	requiring	require	VBG
18637	20031	16	in	in	IN
18637	20031	17	the	the	DT
18637	20031	18	alternative	alternative	NN
18637	20031	19	the	the	DT
18637	20031	20	admission	admission	NN
18637	20031	21	of	of	IN
18637	20031	22	a	a	DT
18637	20031	23	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	20031	24	to	to	IN
18637	20031	25	the	the	DT
18637	20031	26	state	state	NN
18637	20031	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	20031	28	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	20031	29	law	law	NN
18637	20031	30	school	school	NN
18637	20031	31	or	or	CC
18637	20031	32	non	non	JJ
18637	20031	33	-	-	JJ
18637	20031	34	enrollment	enrollment	NN
18637	20031	35	of	of	IN
18637	20031	36	any	any	DT
18637	20031	37	other	other	JJ
18637	20031	38	applicant	applicant	NN
18637	20031	39	until	until	IN
18637	20031	40	a	a	DT
18637	20031	41	separate	separate	JJ
18637	20031	42	school	school	NN
18637	20031	43	with	with	IN
18637	20031	44	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20031	45	educational	educational	JJ
18637	20031	46	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	20031	47	should	should	MD
18637	20031	48	be	be	VB
18637	20031	49	provided	provide	VBN
18637	20031	50	for	for	IN
18637	20031	51	Negroes	negro	NNS
18637	20031	52	.	.	.
18637	20032	1	Over	over	IN
18637	20032	2	the	the	DT
18637	20032	3	objection	objection	NN
18637	20032	4	of	of	IN
18637	20032	5	two	two	CD
18637	20032	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	20032	7	the	the	DT
18637	20032	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	20032	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20032	10	held	hold	VBD
18637	20032	11	this	this	DT
18637	20032	12	order	order	NN
18637	20032	13	did	do	VBD
18637	20032	14	not	not	RB
18637	20032	15	depart	depart	VB
18637	20032	16	from	from	IN
18637	20032	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20032	18	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	20032	19	.	.	.
18637	20033	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20033	2	1168	1168	CD
18637	20033	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20033	4	After	after	IN
18637	20033	5	a	a	DT
18637	20033	6	close	close	JJ
18637	20033	7	examination	examination	NN
18637	20033	8	of	of	IN
18637	20033	9	the	the	DT
18637	20033	10	facts	fact	NNS
18637	20033	11	,	,	,
18637	20033	12	the	the	DT
18637	20033	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20033	14	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	20033	15	,	,	,
18637	20033	16	in	in	IN
18637	20033	17	Sweatt	Sweatt	NNP
18637	20033	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20033	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	20033	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20033	21	Painter,[1169	Painter,[1169	NNP
18637	20033	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20033	23	that	that	IN
18637	20033	24	the	the	DT
18637	20033	25	legal	legal	JJ
18637	20033	26	education	education	NN
18637	20033	27	offered	offer	VBD
18637	20033	28	in	in	IN
18637	20033	29	a	a	DT
18637	20033	30	separate	separate	JJ
18637	20033	31	law	law	NN
18637	20033	32	school	school	NN
18637	20033	33	for	for	IN
18637	20033	34	Negroes	Negroes	NNP
18637	20033	35	was	be	VBD
18637	20033	36	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	20033	37	to	to	IN
18637	20033	38	that	that	DT
18637	20033	39	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	20033	40	by	by	IN
18637	20033	41	the	the	DT
18637	20033	42	University	University	NNP
18637	20033	43	of	of	IN
18637	20033	44	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	20033	45	Law	Law	NNP
18637	20033	46	School	School	NNP
18637	20033	47	and	and	CC
18637	20033	48	hence	hence	RB
18637	20033	49	that	that	IN
18637	20033	50	the	the	DT
18637	20033	51	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20033	52	protection	protection	NN
18637	20033	53	clause	clause	NN
18637	20033	54	required	require	VBN
18637	20033	55	that	that	IN
18637	20033	56	a	a	DT
18637	20033	57	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	20033	58	applicant	applicant	NN
18637	20033	59	be	be	VB
18637	20033	60	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	20033	61	to	to	IN
18637	20033	62	the	the	DT
18637	20033	63	latter	latter	JJ
18637	20033	64	.	.	.
18637	20034	1	In	in	IN
18637	20034	2	McLaurin	McLaurin	NNP
18637	20034	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20034	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	20034	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20034	6	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	20034	7	State	State	NNP
18637	20034	8	Regents[1170	Regents[1170	NNP
18637	20034	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20034	10	the	the	DT
18637	20034	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20034	12	held	hold	VBD
18637	20034	13	that	that	IN
18637	20034	14	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	20034	15	segregation	segregation	NN
18637	20034	16	of	of	IN
18637	20034	17	a	a	DT
18637	20034	18	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	20034	19	student	student	NN
18637	20034	20	admitted	admit	VBD
18637	20034	21	to	to	IN
18637	20034	22	a	a	DT
18637	20034	23	State	State	NNP
18637	20034	24	university	university	NN
18637	20034	25	was	be	VBD
18637	20034	26	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	20034	27	because	because	IN
18637	20034	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20034	29	handicapped	handicap	VBD
18637	20034	30	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20034	31	in	in	IN
18637	20034	32	the	the	DT
18637	20034	33	pursuit	pursuit	NN
18637	20034	34	of	of	IN
18637	20034	35	effective	effective	JJ
18637	20034	36	graduate	graduate	NN
18637	20034	37	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	20034	38	.	.	.
18637	20035	1	POLITICAL	political	JJ
18637	20035	2	RIGHTS	right	NNS
18637	20035	3	In	in	IN
18637	20035	4	conjunction	conjunction	NN
18637	20035	5	with	with	IN
18637	20035	6	the	the	DT
18637	20035	7	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	20035	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20035	9	the	the	DT
18637	20035	10	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20035	11	protection	protection	NN
18637	20035	12	clause	clause	NN
18637	20035	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	20035	14	played	play	VBN
18637	20035	15	an	an	DT
18637	20035	16	important	important	JJ
18637	20035	17	role	role	NN
18637	20035	18	in	in	IN
18637	20035	19	cases	case	NNS
18637	20035	20	involving	involve	VBG
18637	20035	21	various	various	JJ
18637	20035	22	expedients	expedient	NNS
18637	20035	23	devised	devise	VBN
18637	20035	24	to	to	TO
18637	20035	25	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	20035	26	Negro	negro	JJ
18637	20035	27	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20035	28	of	of	IN
18637	20035	29	the	the	DT
18637	20035	30	right	right	NN
18637	20035	31	of	of	IN
18637	20035	32	suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	20035	33	.	.	.
18637	20036	1	Attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	20036	2	have	have	VBP
18637	20036	3	also	also	RB
18637	20036	4	been	be	VBN
18637	20036	5	made	make	VBN
18637	20036	6	,	,	,
18637	20036	7	but	but	CC
18637	20036	8	thus	thus	RB
18637	20036	9	far	far	RB
18637	20036	10	without	without	IN
18637	20036	11	success	success	NN
18637	20036	12	,	,	,
18637	20036	13	to	to	TO
18637	20036	14	invoke	invoke	VB
18637	20036	15	this	this	DT
18637	20036	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	20036	17	against	against	IN
18637	20036	18	other	other	JJ
18637	20036	19	forms	form	NNS
18637	20036	20	of	of	IN
18637	20036	21	political	political	JJ
18637	20036	22	inequality	inequality	NN
18637	20036	23	.	.	.
18637	20037	1	The	the	DT
18637	20037	2	principal	principal	JJ
18637	20037	3	devices	device	NNS
18637	20037	4	employed	employ	VBN
18637	20037	5	to	to	TO
18637	20037	6	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	20037	7	voting	voting	NN
18637	20037	8	by	by	IN
18637	20037	9	Negroes	negro	NNS
18637	20037	10	have	have	VBP
18637	20037	11	been	be	VBN
18637	20037	12	grandfather	grandfather	NN
18637	20037	13	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	20037	14	,	,	,
18637	20037	15	educational	educational	JJ
18637	20037	16	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	20037	17	,	,	,
18637	20037	18	registration	registration	NN
18637	20037	19	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	20037	20	and	and	CC
18637	20037	21	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	20037	22	on	on	IN
18637	20037	23	membership	membership	NN
18637	20037	24	in	in	IN
18637	20037	25	a	a	DT
18637	20037	26	political	political	JJ
18637	20037	27	party	party	NN
18637	20037	28	.	.	.
18637	20038	1	Grandfather	grandfather	NN
18637	20038	2	clauses	clause	VBZ
18637	20038	3	exempting	exempt	VBG
18637	20038	4	persons	person	NNS
18637	20038	5	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	20038	6	as	as	IN
18637	20038	7	electors	elector	NNS
18637	20038	8	before	before	IN
18637	20038	9	1866	1866	CD
18637	20038	10	and	and	CC
18637	20038	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20038	12	descendants	descendant	NNS
18637	20038	13	from	from	IN
18637	20038	14	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	20038	15	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	20038	16	to	to	IN
18637	20038	17	other	other	JJ
18637	20038	18	voters	voter	NNS
18637	20038	19	,	,	,
18637	20038	20	were	be	VBD
18637	20038	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	20038	22	to	to	TO
18637	20038	23	violate	violate	VB
18637	20038	24	the	the	DT
18637	20038	25	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	20038	26	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20038	27	.	.	.
18637	20039	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20039	2	1171	1171	CD
18637	20039	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20039	4	Educational	educational	JJ
18637	20039	5	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	20039	6	which	which	WDT
18637	20039	7	did	do	VBD
18637	20039	8	not	not	RB
18637	20039	9	on	on	IN
18637	20039	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20039	11	face	face	NN
18637	20039	12	discriminate	discriminate	NN
18637	20039	13	between	between	IN
18637	20039	14	white	white	JJ
18637	20039	15	and	and	CC
18637	20039	16	Negro	negro	JJ
18637	20039	17	voters	voter	NNS
18637	20039	18	were	be	VBD
18637	20039	19	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	20039	20	in	in	IN
18637	20039	21	the	the	DT
18637	20039	22	absence	absence	NN
18637	20039	23	of	of	IN
18637	20039	24	a	a	DT
18637	20039	25	showing	showing	NN
18637	20039	26	that	that	IN
18637	20039	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20039	28	actual	actual	JJ
18637	20039	29	administration	administration	NN
18637	20039	30	was	be	VBD
18637	20039	31	evil	evil	JJ
18637	20039	32	.	.	.
18637	20040	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20040	2	1172	1172	CD
18637	20040	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20040	4	In	in	IN
18637	20040	5	1903	1903	CD
18637	20040	6	in	in	IN
18637	20040	7	a	a	DT
18637	20040	8	suit	suit	NN
18637	20040	9	charging	charge	VBG
18637	20040	10	that	that	IN
18637	20040	11	the	the	DT
18637	20040	12	registration	registration	NN
18637	20040	13	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	20040	14	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	20040	15	by	by	IN
18637	20040	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	20040	17	was	be	VBD
18637	20040	18	fraudulently	fraudulently	RB
18637	20040	19	designed	design	VBN
18637	20040	20	to	to	TO
18637	20040	21	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	20040	22	Negroes	negro	NNS
18637	20040	23	from	from	IN
18637	20040	24	voting	voting	NN
18637	20040	25	,	,	,
18637	20040	26	the	the	DT
18637	20040	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20040	28	,	,	,
18637	20040	29	in	in	IN
18637	20040	30	an	an	DT
18637	20040	31	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	20040	32	written	write	VBN
18637	20040	33	by	by	IN
18637	20040	34	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20040	35	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	20040	36	,	,	,
18637	20040	37	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	20040	38	to	to	TO
18637	20040	39	order	order	VB
18637	20040	40	the	the	DT
18637	20040	41	registration	registration	NN
18637	20040	42	of	of	IN
18637	20040	43	an	an	DT
18637	20040	44	allegedly	allegedly	RB
18637	20040	45	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	20040	46	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	20040	47	,	,	,
18637	20040	48	on	on	IN
18637	20040	49	the	the	DT
18637	20040	50	whimsical	whimsical	JJ
18637	20040	51	ground	ground	NN
18637	20040	52	that	that	WDT
18637	20040	53	to	to	TO
18637	20040	54	do	do	VB
18637	20040	55	so	so	RB
18637	20040	56	would	would	MD
18637	20040	57	make	make	VB
18637	20040	58	the	the	DT
18637	20040	59	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20040	60	a	a	DT
18637	20040	61	party	party	NN
18637	20040	62	to	to	IN
18637	20040	63	the	the	DT
18637	20040	64	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	20040	65	plan	plan	NN
18637	20040	66	.	.	.
18637	20041	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20041	2	1173	1173	CD
18637	20041	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20041	4	The	the	DT
18637	20041	5	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	20041	6	was	be	VBD
18637	20041	7	careful	careful	JJ
18637	20041	8	to	to	TO
18637	20041	9	state	state	VB
18637	20041	10	that	that	IN
18637	20041	11	"	"	``
18637	20041	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20041	13	are	be	VBP
18637	20041	14	not	not	RB
18637	20041	15	prepared	prepared	JJ
18637	20041	16	to	to	TO
18637	20041	17	say	say	VB
18637	20041	18	that	that	IN
18637	20041	19	an	an	DT
18637	20041	20	action	action	NN
18637	20041	21	at	at	IN
18637	20041	22	law	law	NN
18637	20041	23	could	could	MD
18637	20041	24	not	not	RB
18637	20041	25	be	be	VB
18637	20041	26	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	20041	27	on	on	IN
18637	20041	28	the	the	DT
18637	20041	29	facts	fact	NNS
18637	20041	30	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	20041	31	in	in	IN
18637	20041	32	the	the	DT
18637	20041	33	bill	bill	NN
18637	20041	34	.	.	.
18637	20041	35	"	"	''
18637	20042	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	20042	2	an	an	DT
18637	20042	3	action	action	NN
18637	20042	4	was	be	VBD
18637	20042	5	brought	bring	VBN
18637	20042	6	some	some	DT
18637	20042	7	years	year	NNS
18637	20042	8	later	later	RB
18637	20042	9	in	in	IN
18637	20042	10	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	20042	11	under	under	IN
18637	20042	12	a	a	DT
18637	20042	13	registration	registration	NN
18637	20042	14	law	law	NN
18637	20042	15	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	20042	16	after	after	IN
18637	20042	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20042	18	"	"	``
18637	20042	19	grandfather	grandfather	NN
18637	20042	20	"	"	''
18637	20042	21	statute	statute	NN
18637	20042	22	had	have	VBD
18637	20042	23	been	be	VBN
18637	20042	24	held	hold	VBN
18637	20042	25	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	20042	26	.	.	.
18637	20043	1	Registration	registration	NN
18637	20043	2	was	be	VBD
18637	20043	3	not	not	RB
18637	20043	4	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	20043	5	for	for	IN
18637	20043	6	persons	person	NNS
18637	20043	7	who	who	WP
18637	20043	8	had	have	VBD
18637	20043	9	voted	vote	VBN
18637	20043	10	at	at	IN
18637	20043	11	the	the	DT
18637	20043	12	previous	previous	JJ
18637	20043	13	election	election	NN
18637	20043	14	under	under	IN
18637	20043	15	the	the	DT
18637	20043	16	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	20043	17	statute	statute	NN
18637	20043	18	.	.	.
18637	20044	1	Other	other	JJ
18637	20044	2	persons	person	NNS
18637	20044	3	were	be	VBD
18637	20044	4	required	require	VBN
18637	20044	5	to	to	TO
18637	20044	6	register	register	VB
18637	20044	7	during	during	IN
18637	20044	8	a	a	DT
18637	20044	9	twelve	twelve	CD
18637	20044	10	day	day	NN
18637	20044	11	period	period	NN
18637	20044	12	or	or	CC
18637	20044	13	be	be	VB
18637	20044	14	forever	forever	RB
18637	20044	15	disfranchised	disfranchise	VBN
18637	20044	16	.	.	.
18637	20045	1	A	a	DT
18637	20045	2	colored	colored	JJ
18637	20045	3	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	20045	4	who	who	WP
18637	20045	5	was	be	VBD
18637	20045	6	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	20045	7	the	the	DT
18637	20045	8	right	right	NN
18637	20045	9	to	to	TO
18637	20045	10	vote	vote	VB
18637	20045	11	in	in	IN
18637	20045	12	1934	1934	CD
18637	20045	13	because	because	IN
18637	20045	14	of	of	IN
18637	20045	15	failure	failure	NN
18637	20045	16	to	to	TO
18637	20045	17	register	register	VB
18637	20045	18	during	during	IN
18637	20045	19	the	the	DT
18637	20045	20	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	20045	21	period	period	NN
18637	20045	22	in	in	IN
18637	20045	23	1916	1916	CD
18637	20045	24	,	,	,
18637	20045	25	was	be	VBD
18637	20045	26	held	hold	VBN
18637	20045	27	to	to	TO
18637	20045	28	have	have	VB
18637	20045	29	a	a	DT
18637	20045	30	cause	cause	NN
18637	20045	31	of	of	IN
18637	20045	32	action	action	NN
18637	20045	33	for	for	IN
18637	20045	34	damages	damage	NNS
18637	20045	35	against	against	IN
18637	20045	36	the	the	DT
18637	20045	37	election	election	NN
18637	20045	38	officials	official	NNS
18637	20045	39	under	under	IN
18637	20045	40	the	the	DT
18637	20045	41	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	20045	42	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	20045	43	Act	Act	NNP
18637	20045	44	of	of	IN
18637	20045	45	1871	1871	CD
18637	20045	46	.	.	.
18637	20046	1	In	in	IN
18637	20046	2	the	the	DT
18637	20046	3	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	20046	4	of	of	IN
18637	20046	5	the	the	DT
18637	20046	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20046	7	reversing	reverse	VBG
18637	20046	8	a	a	DT
18637	20046	9	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	20046	10	for	for	IN
18637	20046	11	the	the	DT
18637	20046	12	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	20046	13	,	,	,
18637	20046	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20046	15	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	20046	16	said:[1174	said:[1174	VBP
18637	20046	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20046	18	"	"	``
18637	20046	19	The	the	DT
18637	20046	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20046	21	nullifies	nullifie	NNS
18637	20046	22	sophisticated	sophisticate	VBD
18637	20046	23	as	as	RB
18637	20046	24	well	well	RB
18637	20046	25	as	as	IN
18637	20046	26	simple	simple	JJ
18637	20046	27	minded	minded	JJ
18637	20046	28	modes	mode	NNS
18637	20046	29	of	of	IN
18637	20046	30	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	20046	31	.	.	.
18637	20047	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20047	2	hits	hit	VBZ
18637	20047	3	onerous	onerous	JJ
18637	20047	4	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	20047	5	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	20047	6	which	which	WDT
18637	20047	7	effectively	effectively	RB
18637	20047	8	handicap	handicap	VBP
18637	20047	9	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	20047	10	of	of	IN
18637	20047	11	the	the	DT
18637	20047	12	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	20047	13	by	by	IN
18637	20047	14	the	the	DT
18637	20047	15	colored	colored	JJ
18637	20047	16	race	race	NN
18637	20047	17	although	although	IN
18637	20047	18	the	the	DT
18637	20047	19	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	20047	20	right	right	NN
18637	20047	21	to	to	TO
18637	20047	22	vote	vote	VB
18637	20047	23	may	may	MD
18637	20047	24	remain	remain	VB
18637	20047	25	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
18637	20047	26	as	as	IN
18637	20047	27	to	to	IN
18637	20047	28	race	race	NN
18637	20047	29	.	.	.
18637	20047	30	"	"	''
18637	20048	1	As	as	IN
18637	20048	2	the	the	DT
18637	20048	3	selection	selection	NN
18637	20048	4	of	of	IN
18637	20048	5	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	20048	6	by	by	IN
18637	20048	7	primary	primary	JJ
18637	20048	8	elections	election	NNS
18637	20048	9	became	become	VBD
18637	20048	10	general	general	JJ
18637	20048	11	,	,	,
18637	20048	12	the	the	DT
18637	20048	13	denial	denial	NN
18637	20048	14	of	of	IN
18637	20048	15	the	the	DT
18637	20048	16	right	right	NN
18637	20048	17	to	to	TO
18637	20048	18	vote	vote	VB
18637	20048	19	in	in	IN
18637	20048	20	the	the	DT
18637	20048	21	primary	primary	JJ
18637	20048	22	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	20048	23	dominant	dominant	JJ
18637	20048	24	importance	importance	NN
18637	20048	25	.	.	.
18637	20049	1	For	for	IN
18637	20049	2	many	many	JJ
18637	20049	3	years	year	NNS
18637	20049	4	the	the	DT
18637	20049	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20049	6	hesitated	hesitate	VBD
18637	20049	7	to	to	TO
18637	20049	8	hold	hold	VB
18637	20049	9	that	that	IN
18637	20049	10	party	party	NN
18637	20049	11	primaries	primary	NNS
18637	20049	12	were	be	VBD
18637	20049	13	elections	election	NNS
18637	20049	14	within	within	IN
18637	20049	15	the	the	DT
18637	20049	16	purview	purview	NN
18637	20049	17	of	of	IN
18637	20049	18	the	the	DT
18637	20049	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	20049	20	.	.	.
18637	20050	1	During	during	IN
18637	20050	2	that	that	DT
18637	20050	3	period	period	NN
18637	20050	4	the	the	DT
18637	20050	5	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20050	6	protection	protection	NN
18637	20050	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	20050	8	was	be	VBD
18637	20050	9	relied	rely	VBN
18637	20050	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	20050	11	to	to	TO
18637	20050	12	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	20050	13	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	20050	14	against	against	IN
18637	20050	15	Negroes	Negroes	NNP
18637	20050	16	.	.	.
18637	20051	1	Under	under	IN
18637	20051	2	the	the	DT
18637	20051	3	clause	clause	NN
18637	20051	4	,	,	,
18637	20051	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20051	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	20051	7	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	20051	8	to	to	TO
18637	20051	9	find	find	VB
18637	20051	10	that	that	IN
18637	20051	11	inequality	inequality	NN
18637	20051	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	20051	13	perpetrated	perpetrate	VBN
18637	20051	14	by	by	IN
18637	20051	15	the	the	DT
18637	20051	16	State	State	NNP
18637	20051	17	.	.	.
18637	20052	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20052	2	1175	1175	CD
18637	20052	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20052	4	The	the	DT
18637	20052	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20052	6	had	have	VBD
18637	20052	7	no	no	DT
18637	20052	8	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	20052	9	in	in	IN
18637	20052	10	holding	hold	VBG
18637	20052	11	that	that	IN
18637	20052	12	a	a	DT
18637	20052	13	State	State	NNP
18637	20052	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	20052	15	which	which	WDT
18637	20052	16	forbade	forbid	VBD
18637	20052	17	voting	voting	NN
18637	20052	18	by	by	IN
18637	20052	19	Negroes	Negroes	NNPS
18637	20052	20	in	in	IN
18637	20052	21	a	a	DT
18637	20052	22	party	party	NN
18637	20052	23	primary	primary	NN
18637	20052	24	was	be	VBD
18637	20052	25	obnoxious	obnoxious	JJ
18637	20052	26	to	to	IN
18637	20052	27	the	the	DT
18637	20052	28	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	20052	29	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20052	30	.	.	.
18637	20053	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20053	2	1176	1176	CD
18637	20053	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20053	4	The	the	DT
18637	20053	5	same	same	JJ
18637	20053	6	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	20053	7	was	be	VBD
18637	20053	8	reached	reach	VBN
18637	20053	9	with	with	IN
18637	20053	10	respect	respect	NN
18637	20053	11	to	to	IN
18637	20053	12	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	20053	13	by	by	IN
18637	20053	14	action	action	NN
18637	20053	15	of	of	IN
18637	20053	16	a	a	DT
18637	20053	17	party	party	NN
18637	20053	18	executive	executive	JJ
18637	20053	19	committee	committee	NN
18637	20053	20	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	20053	21	to	to	IN
18637	20053	22	authority	authority	NN
18637	20053	23	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	20053	24	by	by	IN
18637	20053	25	statute	statute	NN
18637	20053	26	.	.	.
18637	20054	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20054	2	1177	1177	CD
18637	20054	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20054	4	But	but	CC
18637	20054	5	at	at	IN
18637	20054	6	first	first	RB
18637	20054	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20054	8	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	20054	9	to	to	TO
18637	20054	10	extend	extend	VB
18637	20054	11	this	this	DT
18637	20054	12	rule	rule	NN
18637	20054	13	to	to	IN
18637	20054	14	a	a	DT
18637	20054	15	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	20054	16	on	on	IN
18637	20054	17	membership	membership	NN
18637	20054	18	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	20054	19	without	without	IN
18637	20054	20	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	20054	21	authority	authority	NN
18637	20054	22	by	by	IN
18637	20054	23	the	the	DT
18637	20054	24	State	State	NNP
18637	20054	25	convention	convention	NN
18637	20054	26	of	of	IN
18637	20054	27	a	a	DT
18637	20054	28	party	party	NN
18637	20054	29	.	.	.
18637	20055	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20055	2	1178	1178	CD
18637	20055	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20055	4	The	the	DT
18637	20055	5	latter	latter	JJ
18637	20055	6	case	case	NN
18637	20055	7	was	be	VBD
18637	20055	8	soon	soon	RB
18637	20055	9	overruled	overruled	JJ
18637	20055	10	;	;	:
18637	20055	11	having	have	VBG
18637	20055	12	,	,	,
18637	20055	13	in	in	IN
18637	20055	14	the	the	DT
18637	20055	15	meanwhile	meanwhile	NN
18637	20055	16	,	,	,
18637	20055	17	decided	decide	VBD
18637	20055	18	that	that	IN
18637	20055	19	a	a	DT
18637	20055	20	primary	primary	NN
18637	20055	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	20055	22	an	an	DT
18637	20055	23	integral	integral	JJ
18637	20055	24	part	part	NN
18637	20055	25	of	of	IN
18637	20055	26	the	the	DT
18637	20055	27	electoral	electoral	JJ
18637	20055	28	machinery,[1179	machinery,[1179	NNP
18637	20055	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20055	30	the	the	DT
18637	20055	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20055	32	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	20055	33	in	in	IN
18637	20055	34	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	20055	35	_	_	NNP
18637	20055	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	20055	37	_	_	NNP
18637	20055	38	Allwright,[1180	Allwright,[1180	NNP
18637	20055	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20055	40	that	that	IN
18637	20055	41	a	a	DT
18637	20055	42	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	20055	43	on	on	IN
18637	20055	44	party	party	NN
18637	20055	45	membership	membership	NN
18637	20055	46	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	20055	47	by	by	IN
18637	20055	48	a	a	DT
18637	20055	49	State	State	NNP
18637	20055	50	convention	convention	NN
18637	20055	51	was	be	VBD
18637	20055	52	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	20055	53	under	under	IN
18637	20055	54	the	the	DT
18637	20055	55	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	20055	56	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20055	57	,	,	,
18637	20055	58	where	where	WRB
18637	20055	59	such	such	JJ
18637	20055	60	membership	membership	NN
18637	20055	61	was	be	VBD
18637	20055	62	a	a	DT
18637	20055	63	prerequisite	prerequisite	NN
18637	20055	64	for	for	IN
18637	20055	65	voting	voting	NN
18637	20055	66	in	in	IN
18637	20055	67	the	the	DT
18637	20055	68	primary	primary	NN
18637	20055	69	.	.	.
18637	20056	1	Failure	failure	NN
18637	20056	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	20056	3	attended	attend	VBN
18637	20056	4	the	the	DT
18637	20056	5	few	few	JJ
18637	20056	6	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	20056	7	which	which	WDT
18637	20056	8	have	have	VBP
18637	20056	9	been	be	VBN
18637	20056	10	made	make	VBN
18637	20056	11	to	to	TO
18637	20056	12	strike	strike	VB
18637	20056	13	down	down	RP
18637	20056	14	other	other	JJ
18637	20056	15	alleged	alleged	JJ
18637	20056	16	discriminations	discrimination	NNS
18637	20056	17	in	in	IN
18637	20056	18	election	election	NN
18637	20056	19	laws	law	NNS
18637	20056	20	or	or	CC
18637	20056	21	in	in	IN
18637	20056	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20056	23	administration	administration	NN
18637	20056	24	.	.	.
18637	20057	1	Nearly	nearly	RB
18637	20057	2	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	20057	3	years	year	NNS
18637	20057	4	ago	ago	RB
18637	20057	5	the	the	DT
18637	20057	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20057	7	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	20057	8	a	a	DT
18637	20057	9	claim	claim	NN
18637	20057	10	that	that	IN
18637	20057	11	an	an	DT
18637	20057	12	act	act	NN
18637	20057	13	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	20057	14	the	the	DT
18637	20057	15	registration	registration	NN
18637	20057	16	of	of	IN
18637	20057	17	a	a	DT
18637	20057	18	voter	voter	NN
18637	20057	19	until	until	IN
18637	20057	20	one	one	CD
18637	20057	21	year	year	NN
18637	20057	22	after	after	IN
18637	20057	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20057	24	intent	intent	NN
18637	20057	25	to	to	TO
18637	20057	26	become	become	VB
18637	20057	27	a	a	DT
18637	20057	28	legal	legal	JJ
18637	20057	29	voter	voter	NN
18637	20057	30	shall	shall	MD
18637	20057	31	have	have	VB
18637	20057	32	been	be	VBN
18637	20057	33	recorded	record	VBN
18637	20057	34	was	be	VBD
18637	20057	35	a	a	DT
18637	20057	36	denial	denial	NN
18637	20057	37	of	of	IN
18637	20057	38	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20057	39	protection	protection	NN
18637	20057	40	.	.	.
18637	20058	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20058	2	1181	1181	CD
18637	20058	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20058	4	In	in	IN
18637	20058	5	Snowden	Snowden	NNP
18637	20058	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20058	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20058	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20058	9	Hughes,[1182	hughes,[1182	CD
18637	20058	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20058	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20058	12	held	hold	VBD
18637	20058	13	that	that	IN
18637	20058	14	an	an	DT
18637	20058	15	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	20058	16	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
18637	20058	17	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	20058	18	of	of	IN
18637	20058	19	a	a	DT
18637	20058	20	State	State	NNP
18637	20058	21	Primary	Primary	NNP
18637	20058	22	Canvassing	Canvassing	NNP
18637	20058	23	Board	Board	NNP
18637	20058	24	to	to	TO
18637	20058	25	certify	certify	VB
18637	20058	26	a	a	DT
18637	20058	27	person	person	NN
18637	20058	28	as	as	IN
18637	20058	29	a	a	DT
18637	20058	30	successful	successful	JJ
18637	20058	31	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	20058	32	in	in	IN
18637	20058	33	a	a	DT
18637	20058	34	party	party	NN
18637	20058	35	primary	primary	NN
18637	20058	36	was	be	VBD
18637	20058	37	not	not	RB
18637	20058	38	,	,	,
18637	20058	39	in	in	IN
18637	20058	40	the	the	DT
18637	20058	41	absence	absence	NN
18637	20058	42	of	of	IN
18637	20058	43	a	a	DT
18637	20058	44	showing	showing	NN
18637	20058	45	of	of	IN
18637	20058	46	purposeful	purposeful	JJ
18637	20058	47	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	20058	48	,	,	,
18637	20058	49	a	a	DT
18637	20058	50	denial	denial	NN
18637	20058	51	of	of	IN
18637	20058	52	a	a	DT
18637	20058	53	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	20058	54	right	right	NN
18637	20058	55	which	which	WDT
18637	20058	56	would	would	MD
18637	20058	57	justify	justify	VB
18637	20058	58	a	a	DT
18637	20058	59	suit	suit	NN
18637	20058	60	for	for	IN
18637	20058	61	damages	damage	NNS
18637	20058	62	against	against	IN
18637	20058	63	members	member	NNS
18637	20058	64	of	of	IN
18637	20058	65	the	the	DT
18637	20058	66	Board	Board	NNP
18637	20058	67	.	.	.
18637	20059	1	Three	three	CD
18637	20059	2	recent	recent	JJ
18637	20059	3	attacks	attack	NNS
18637	20059	4	on	on	IN
18637	20059	5	inequalities	inequality	NNS
18637	20059	6	in	in	IN
18637	20059	7	the	the	DT
18637	20059	8	effective	effective	JJ
18637	20059	9	voting	voting	NN
18637	20059	10	power	power	NN
18637	20059	11	of	of	IN
18637	20059	12	persons	person	NNS
18637	20059	13	residing	reside	VBG
18637	20059	14	in	in	IN
18637	20059	15	different	different	JJ
18637	20059	16	geographical	geographical	JJ
18637	20059	17	areas	area	NNS
18637	20059	18	were	be	VBD
18637	20059	19	likewise	likewise	RB
18637	20059	20	unsuccessful	unsuccessful	JJ
18637	20059	21	.	.	.
18637	20060	1	The	the	DT
18637	20060	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20060	3	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	20060	4	,	,	,
18637	20060	5	in	in	IN
18637	20060	6	Colegrove	Colegrove	NNP
18637	20060	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20060	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20060	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20060	10	Green,[1183	Green,[1183	NNP
18637	20060	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20060	12	to	to	TO
18637	20060	13	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	20060	14	to	to	TO
18637	20060	15	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	20060	16	the	the	DT
18637	20060	17	election	election	NN
18637	20060	18	of	of	IN
18637	20060	19	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	20060	20	in	in	IN
18637	20060	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20060	22	by	by	IN
18637	20060	23	districts	district	NNS
18637	20060	24	in	in	IN
18637	20060	25	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	20060	26	,	,	,
18637	20060	27	because	because	IN
18637	20060	28	of	of	IN
18637	20060	29	unequal	unequal	JJ
18637	20060	30	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	20060	31	.	.	.
18637	20061	1	Two	two	CD
18637	20061	2	years	year	NNS
18637	20061	3	later	later	RB
18637	20061	4	,	,	,
18637	20061	5	in	in	IN
18637	20061	6	MacDougall	MacDougall	NNP
18637	20061	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20061	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20061	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20061	10	Green[1184	Green[1184	NNP
18637	20061	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20061	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20061	13	held	hold	VBD
18637	20061	14	that	that	IN
18637	20061	15	a	a	DT
18637	20061	16	State	State	NNP
18637	20061	17	law	law	NN
18637	20061	18	requiring	require	VBG
18637	20061	19	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	20061	20	of	of	IN
18637	20061	21	a	a	DT
18637	20061	22	new	new	JJ
18637	20061	23	political	political	JJ
18637	20061	24	party	party	NN
18637	20061	25	to	to	TO
18637	20061	26	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	20061	27	a	a	DT
18637	20061	28	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	20061	29	number	number	NN
18637	20061	30	of	of	IN
18637	20061	31	signatures	signature	NNS
18637	20061	32	on	on	IN
18637	20061	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20061	34	nominating	nominating	JJ
18637	20061	35	petitions	petition	NNS
18637	20061	36	in	in	IN
18637	20061	37	each	each	DT
18637	20061	38	of	of	IN
18637	20061	39	50	50	CD
18637	20061	40	counties	county	NNS
18637	20061	41	did	do	VBD
18637	20061	42	not	not	RB
18637	20061	43	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	20061	44	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20061	45	justice	justice	NN
18637	20061	46	from	from	IN
18637	20061	47	the	the	DT
18637	20061	48	overwhelming	overwhelming	JJ
18637	20061	49	majority	majority	NN
18637	20061	50	of	of	IN
18637	20061	51	the	the	DT
18637	20061	52	voters	voter	NNS
18637	20061	53	who	who	WP
18637	20061	54	resided	reside	VBD
18637	20061	55	in	in	IN
18637	20061	56	the	the	DT
18637	20061	57	49	49	CD
18637	20061	58	most	most	RBS
18637	20061	59	populous	populous	JJ
18637	20061	60	counties	county	NNS
18637	20061	61	.	.	.
18637	20062	1	Over	over	IN
18637	20062	2	the	the	DT
18637	20062	3	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	20062	4	of	of	IN
18637	20062	5	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	20062	6	Black	Black	NNP
18637	20062	7	and	and	CC
18637	20062	8	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	20062	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20062	10	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	20062	11	the	the	DT
18637	20062	12	action	action	NN
18637	20062	13	of	of	IN
18637	20062	14	a	a	DT
18637	20062	15	federal	federal	JJ
18637	20062	16	district	district	NN
18637	20062	17	court	court	NN
18637	20062	18	in	in	IN
18637	20062	19	dismissing	dismiss	VBG
18637	20062	20	a	a	DT
18637	20062	21	complaint	complaint	NN
18637	20062	22	challenging	challenge	VBG
18637	20062	23	the	the	DT
18637	20062	24	validity	validity	NN
18637	20062	25	of	of	IN
18637	20062	26	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	20062	27	's	's	POS
18637	20062	28	county	county	NN
18637	20062	29	unit	unit	NN
18637	20062	30	election	election	NN
18637	20062	31	system	system	NN
18637	20062	32	,	,	,
18637	20062	33	under	under	IN
18637	20062	34	which	which	WDT
18637	20062	35	the	the	DT
18637	20062	36	votes	vote	NNS
18637	20062	37	of	of	IN
18637	20062	38	residents	resident	NNS
18637	20062	39	of	of	IN
18637	20062	40	the	the	DT
18637	20062	41	most	most	RBS
18637	20062	42	populous	populous	JJ
18637	20062	43	county	county	NN
18637	20062	44	have	have	VBP
18637	20062	45	on	on	IN
18637	20062	46	the	the	DT
18637	20062	47	average	average	NN
18637	20062	48	but	but	CC
18637	20062	49	one	one	CD
18637	20062	50	-	-	HYPH
18637	20062	51	tenth	tenth	NN
18637	20062	52	the	the	DT
18637	20062	53	weight	weight	NN
18637	20062	54	of	of	IN
18637	20062	55	those	those	DT
18637	20062	56	in	in	IN
18637	20062	57	other	other	JJ
18637	20062	58	counties	county	NNS
18637	20062	59	.	.	.
18637	20063	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20063	2	1185	1185	CD
18637	20063	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20063	4	PROCEDURE	PROCEDURE	NNP
18637	20063	5	General	General	NNP
18637	20063	6	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	20063	7	The	the	DT
18637	20063	8	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20063	9	protection	protection	NN
18637	20063	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	20063	11	does	do	VBZ
18637	20063	12	not	not	RB
18637	20063	13	exact	exact	VB
18637	20063	14	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	20063	15	of	of	IN
18637	20063	16	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	20063	17	.	.	.
18637	20064	1	State	state	NN
18637	20064	2	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	20064	3	may	may	MD
18637	20064	4	classify	classify	VB
18637	20064	5	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	20064	6	and	and	CC
18637	20064	7	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	20064	8	one	one	CD
18637	20064	9	type	type	NN
18637	20064	10	of	of	IN
18637	20064	11	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	20064	12	for	for	IN
18637	20064	13	one	one	CD
18637	20064	14	class	class	NN
18637	20064	15	and	and	CC
18637	20064	16	a	a	DT
18637	20064	17	different	different	JJ
18637	20064	18	type	type	NN
18637	20064	19	for	for	IN
18637	20064	20	another	another	DT
18637	20064	21	.	.	.
18637	20065	1	The	the	DT
18637	20065	2	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	20065	3	followed	follow	VBD
18637	20065	4	in	in	IN
18637	20065	5	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	20065	6	suits	suit	NNS
18637	20065	7	brought	bring	VBN
18637	20065	8	by	by	IN
18637	20065	9	a	a	DT
18637	20065	10	State	state	NN
18637	20065	11	need	nee	MD
18637	20065	12	not	not	RB
18637	20065	13	be	be	VB
18637	20065	14	the	the	DT
18637	20065	15	same	same	JJ
18637	20065	16	as	as	IN
18637	20065	17	in	in	IN
18637	20065	18	a	a	DT
18637	20065	19	suit	suit	NN
18637	20065	20	started	start	VBN
18637	20065	21	by	by	IN
18637	20065	22	a	a	DT
18637	20065	23	private	private	JJ
18637	20065	24	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	20065	25	.	.	.
18637	20066	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20066	2	1186	1186	CD
18637	20066	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20066	4	Procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	20066	5	rules	rule	NNS
18637	20066	6	may	may	MD
18637	20066	7	vary	vary	VB
18637	20066	8	in	in	IN
18637	20066	9	different	different	JJ
18637	20066	10	geographic	geographic	JJ
18637	20066	11	subdivisions	subdivision	NNS
18637	20066	12	of	of	IN
18637	20066	13	the	the	DT
18637	20066	14	State	State	NNP
18637	20066	15	;	;	:
18637	20066	16	the	the	DT
18637	20066	17	State	state	NN
18637	20066	18	may	may	MD
18637	20066	19	be	be	VB
18637	20066	20	given	give	VBN
18637	20066	21	a	a	DT
18637	20066	22	larger	large	JJR
18637	20066	23	number	number	NN
18637	20066	24	of	of	IN
18637	20066	25	peremptory	peremptory	JJ
18637	20066	26	challenges	challenge	NNS
18637	20066	27	to	to	IN
18637	20066	28	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	20066	29	in	in	IN
18637	20066	30	capital	capital	NN
18637	20066	31	cases	case	NNS
18637	20066	32	in	in	IN
18637	20066	33	cities	city	NNS
18637	20066	34	having	have	VBG
18637	20066	35	more	more	JJR
18637	20066	36	than	than	IN
18637	20066	37	100,000	100,000	CD
18637	20066	38	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	20066	39	than	than	IN
18637	20066	40	in	in	IN
18637	20066	41	other	other	JJ
18637	20066	42	areas	area	NNS
18637	20066	43	.	.	.
18637	20067	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20067	2	1187	1187	CD
18637	20067	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20067	4	A	a	DT
18637	20067	5	State	state	NN
18637	20067	6	may	may	MD
18637	20067	7	require	require	VB
18637	20067	8	that	that	IN
18637	20067	9	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	20067	10	on	on	IN
18637	20067	11	the	the	DT
18637	20067	12	amount	amount	NN
18637	20067	13	of	of	IN
18637	20067	14	loss	loss	NN
18637	20067	15	under	under	IN
18637	20067	16	fire	fire	NN
18637	20067	17	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	20067	18	policies	policy	NNS
18637	20067	19	be	be	VB
18637	20067	20	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	20067	21	to	to	IN
18637	20067	22	arbitration	arbitration	NN
18637	20067	23	.	.	.
18637	20068	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20068	2	1188	1188	CD
18637	20068	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20068	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20068	5	may	may	MD
18637	20068	6	prescribe	prescribe	VB
18637	20068	7	the	the	DT
18637	20068	8	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	20068	9	which	which	WDT
18637	20068	10	shall	shall	MD
18637	20068	11	be	be	VB
18637	20068	12	received	receive	VBN
18637	20068	13	and	and	CC
18637	20068	14	the	the	DT
18637	20068	15	effect	effect	NN
18637	20068	16	which	which	WDT
18637	20068	17	shall	shall	MD
18637	20068	18	be	be	VB
18637	20068	19	given	give	VBN
18637	20068	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20068	21	;	;	:
18637	20068	22	proof	proof	NN
18637	20068	23	of	of	IN
18637	20068	24	one	one	CD
18637	20068	25	fact	fact	NN
18637	20068	26	,	,	,
18637	20068	27	or	or	CC
18637	20068	28	of	of	IN
18637	20068	29	several	several	JJ
18637	20068	30	facts	fact	NNS
18637	20068	31	taken	take	VBN
18637	20068	32	collectively	collectively	RB
18637	20068	33	,	,	,
18637	20068	34	may	may	MD
18637	20068	35	be	be	VB
18637	20068	36	made	make	VBN
18637	20068	37	_	_	NNP
18637	20068	38	prima	prima	NN
18637	20068	39	facie	facie	VB
18637	20068	40	_	_	NNP
18637	20068	41	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	20068	42	of	of	IN
18637	20068	43	another	another	DT
18637	20068	44	fact	fact	NN
18637	20068	45	,	,	,
18637	20068	46	so	so	RB
18637	20068	47	long	long	RB
18637	20068	48	as	as	IN
18637	20068	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20068	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	20068	51	not	not	RB
18637	20068	52	a	a	DT
18637	20068	53	mere	mere	JJ
18637	20068	54	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	20068	55	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	20068	56	and	and	CC
18637	20068	57	does	do	VBZ
18637	20068	58	not	not	RB
18637	20068	59	discriminate	discriminate	VB
18637	20068	60	invidiously	invidiously	RB
18637	20068	61	between	between	IN
18637	20068	62	different	different	JJ
18637	20068	63	persons	person	NNS
18637	20068	64	in	in	IN
18637	20068	65	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	20068	66	the	the	DT
18637	20068	67	same	same	JJ
18637	20068	68	situations	situation	NNS
18637	20068	69	.	.	.
18637	20069	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20069	2	1189	1189	CD
18637	20069	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20069	4	A	a	DT
18637	20069	5	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	20069	6	in	in	IN
18637	20069	7	a	a	DT
18637	20069	8	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	20069	9	's	's	POS
18637	20069	10	derivative	derivative	JJ
18637	20069	11	suit	suit	NN
18637	20069	12	may	may	MD
18637	20069	13	be	be	VB
18637	20069	14	required	require	VBN
18637	20069	15	to	to	TO
18637	20069	16	give	give	VB
18637	20069	17	security	security	NN
18637	20069	18	if	if	IN
18637	20069	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20069	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	20069	21	not	not	RB
18637	20069	22	own	own	VB
18637	20069	23	a	a	DT
18637	20069	24	specified	specify	VBN
18637	20069	25	amount	amount	NN
18637	20069	26	of	of	IN
18637	20069	27	stock	stock	NN
18637	20069	28	;	;	:
18637	20069	29	the	the	DT
18637	20069	30	size	size	NN
18637	20069	31	of	of	IN
18637	20069	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20069	33	financial	financial	JJ
18637	20069	34	interest	interest	NN
18637	20069	35	may	may	MD
18637	20069	36	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	20069	37	be	be	VB
18637	20069	38	considered	consider	VBN
18637	20069	39	as	as	IN
18637	20069	40	some	some	DT
18637	20069	41	measure	measure	NN
18637	20069	42	of	of	IN
18637	20069	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20069	44	good	good	JJ
18637	20069	45	faith	faith	NN
18637	20069	46	and	and	CC
18637	20069	47	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	20069	48	in	in	IN
18637	20069	49	bringing	bring	VBG
18637	20069	50	the	the	DT
18637	20069	51	suit	suit	NN
18637	20069	52	.	.	.
18637	20070	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20070	2	1190	1190	CD
18637	20070	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20070	4	Access	access	NN
18637	20070	5	to	to	IN
18637	20070	6	Courts	court	NNS
18637	20070	7	The	the	DT
18637	20070	8	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	20070	9	may	may	MD
18637	20070	10	provide	provide	VB
18637	20070	11	for	for	IN
18637	20070	12	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	20070	13	in	in	IN
18637	20070	14	the	the	DT
18637	20070	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	20070	16	of	of	IN
18637	20070	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20070	18	several	several	JJ
18637	20070	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	20070	20	,	,	,
18637	20070	21	both	both	CC
18637	20070	22	as	as	IN
18637	20070	23	to	to	TO
18637	20070	24	subject	subject	JJ
18637	20070	25	matter	matter	NN
18637	20070	26	and	and	CC
18637	20070	27	finality	finality	NN
18637	20070	28	of	of	IN
18637	20070	29	decision	decision	NN
18637	20070	30	,	,	,
18637	20070	31	if	if	IN
18637	20070	32	all	all	DT
18637	20070	33	persons	person	NNS
18637	20070	34	within	within	IN
18637	20070	35	the	the	DT
18637	20070	36	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	20070	37	limits	limit	NNS
18637	20070	38	of	of	IN
18637	20070	39	the	the	DT
18637	20070	40	respective	respective	JJ
18637	20070	41	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	20070	42	have	have	VBP
18637	20070	43	an	an	DT
18637	20070	44	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20070	45	right	right	NN
18637	20070	46	in	in	IN
18637	20070	47	like	like	JJ
18637	20070	48	cases	case	NNS
18637	20070	49	to	to	TO
18637	20070	50	resort	resort	VB
18637	20070	51	to	to	IN
18637	20070	52	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20070	53	for	for	IN
18637	20070	54	redress	redress	NN
18637	20070	55	.	.	.
18637	20071	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20071	2	1191	1191	CD
18637	20071	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20071	4	There	there	EX
18637	20071	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	20071	6	no	no	DT
18637	20071	7	denial	denial	NN
18637	20071	8	of	of	IN
18637	20071	9	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20071	10	protection	protection	NN
18637	20071	11	of	of	IN
18637	20071	12	the	the	DT
18637	20071	13	law	law	NN
18637	20071	14	by	by	IN
18637	20071	15	reason	reason	NN
18637	20071	16	of	of	IN
18637	20071	17	the	the	DT
18637	20071	18	fact	fact	NN
18637	20071	19	that	that	IN
18637	20071	20	in	in	IN
18637	20071	21	one	one	CD
18637	20071	22	district	district	NN
18637	20071	23	the	the	DT
18637	20071	24	State	State	NNP
18637	20071	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	20071	26	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	20071	27	an	an	DT
18637	20071	28	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	20071	29	and	and	CC
18637	20071	30	in	in	IN
18637	20071	31	another	another	DT
18637	20071	32	district	district	NN
18637	20071	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20071	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	20071	35	not	not	RB
18637	20071	36	.	.	.
18637	20072	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20072	2	1192	1192	CD
18637	20072	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20072	4	The	the	DT
18637	20072	5	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	20072	6	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	20072	7	to	to	TO
18637	20072	8	grant	grant	VB
18637	20072	9	or	or	CC
18637	20072	10	withhold	withhold	VB
18637	20072	11	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	20072	12	relief	relief	NN
18637	20072	13	in	in	IN
18637	20072	14	any	any	DT
18637	20072	15	class	class	NN
18637	20072	16	of	of	IN
18637	20072	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	20072	18	must	must	MD
18637	20072	19	,	,	,
18637	20072	20	under	under	IN
18637	20072	21	the	the	DT
18637	20072	22	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20072	23	protection	protection	NN
18637	20072	24	clause	clause	NN
18637	20072	25	,	,	,
18637	20072	26	be	be	VB
18637	20072	27	so	so	RB
18637	20072	28	exercised	exercised	JJ
18637	20072	29	as	as	IN
18637	20072	30	not	not	RB
18637	20072	31	to	to	TO
18637	20072	32	grant	grant	VB
18637	20072	33	equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	20072	34	relief	relief	NN
18637	20072	35	to	to	IN
18637	20072	36	one	one	CD
18637	20072	37	,	,	,
18637	20072	38	and	and	CC
18637	20072	39	to	to	TO
18637	20072	40	deny	deny	VB
18637	20072	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20072	42	to	to	IN
18637	20072	43	another	another	DT
18637	20072	44	under	under	IN
18637	20072	45	like	like	JJ
18637	20072	46	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	20072	47	and	and	CC
18637	20072	48	in	in	IN
18637	20072	49	the	the	DT
18637	20072	50	same	same	JJ
18637	20072	51	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	20072	52	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	20072	53	.	.	.
18637	20073	1	A	a	DT
18637	20073	2	State	State	NNP
18637	20073	3	law	law	NN
18637	20073	4	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	20073	5	injunctions	injunction	NNS
18637	20073	6	in	in	IN
18637	20073	7	labor	labor	NN
18637	20073	8	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	20073	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	20073	10	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	20073	11	where	where	WRB
18637	20073	12	injunctive	injunctive	JJ
18637	20073	13	relief	relief	NN
18637	20073	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	20073	15	available	available	JJ
18637	20073	16	in	in	IN
18637	20073	17	other	other	JJ
18637	20073	18	similar	similar	JJ
18637	20073	19	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	20073	20	.	.	.
18637	20074	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20074	2	1193	1193	CD
18637	20074	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20074	4	The	the	DT
18637	20074	5	action	action	NN
18637	20074	6	of	of	IN
18637	20074	7	prison	prison	NN
18637	20074	8	officials	official	NNS
18637	20074	9	in	in	IN
18637	20074	10	suppressing	suppress	VBG
18637	20074	11	a	a	DT
18637	20074	12	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	20074	13	's	's	POS
18637	20074	14	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	20074	15	documents	document	NNS
18637	20074	16	during	during	IN
18637	20074	17	the	the	DT
18637	20074	18	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	20074	19	period	period	NN
18637	20074	20	for	for	IN
18637	20074	21	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	20074	22	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	20074	23	a	a	DT
18637	20074	24	denial	denial	NN
18637	20074	25	of	of	IN
18637	20074	26	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20074	27	protection	protection	NN
18637	20074	28	by	by	IN
18637	20074	29	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	20074	30	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20074	31	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	20074	32	of	of	IN
18637	20074	33	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	20074	34	that	that	WDT
18637	20074	35	were	be	VBD
18637	20074	36	available	available	JJ
18637	20074	37	to	to	IN
18637	20074	38	others	other	NNS
18637	20074	39	.	.	.
18637	20075	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20075	2	1194	1194	CD
18637	20075	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20075	4	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	20075	5	A	a	DT
18637	20075	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	20075	7	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	20075	8	suits	suit	NNS
18637	20075	9	against	against	IN
18637	20075	10	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	20075	11	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	20075	12	to	to	TO
18637	20075	13	be	be	VB
18637	20075	14	brought	bring	VBN
18637	20075	15	in	in	RP
18637	20075	16	any	any	DT
18637	20075	17	county	county	NN
18637	20075	18	in	in	IN
18637	20075	19	which	which	WDT
18637	20075	20	the	the	DT
18637	20075	21	cause	cause	NN
18637	20075	22	of	of	IN
18637	20075	23	action	action	NN
18637	20075	24	arose	arise	VBD
18637	20075	25	,	,	,
18637	20075	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	20075	27	not	not	RB
18637	20075	28	void	void	JJ
18637	20075	29	as	as	IN
18637	20075	30	denying	deny	VBG
18637	20075	31	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20075	32	protection	protection	NN
18637	20075	33	.	.	.
18637	20076	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20076	2	1195	1195	CD
18637	20076	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20076	4	Neither	neither	CC
18637	20076	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	20076	6	a	a	DT
18637	20076	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	20076	8	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	20076	9	only	only	RB
18637	20076	10	to	to	IN
18637	20076	11	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	20076	12	requiring	require	VBG
18637	20076	13	the	the	DT
18637	20076	14	production	production	NN
18637	20076	15	of	of	IN
18637	20076	16	books	book	NNS
18637	20076	17	and	and	CC
18637	20076	18	papers	paper	NNS
18637	20076	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	20076	20	notice	notice	NN
18637	20076	21	,	,	,
18637	20076	22	with	with	IN
18637	20076	23	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	20076	24	for	for	IN
18637	20076	25	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	20076	26	upon	upon	IN
18637	20076	27	neglect	neglect	NN
18637	20076	28	or	or	CC
18637	20076	29	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	20076	30	to	to	TO
18637	20076	31	comply	comply	VB
18637	20076	32	.	.	.
18637	20077	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20077	2	1196	1196	CD
18637	20077	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20077	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	20077	5	,	,	,
18637	20077	6	however	however	RB
18637	20077	7	,	,	,
18637	20077	8	actions	action	NNS
18637	20077	9	against	against	IN
18637	20077	10	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	20077	11	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	20077	12	may	may	MD
18637	20077	13	be	be	VB
18637	20077	14	brought	bring	VBN
18637	20077	15	only	only	RB
18637	20077	16	in	in	IN
18637	20077	17	counties	county	NNS
18637	20077	18	where	where	WRB
18637	20077	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20077	20	may	may	MD
18637	20077	21	have	have	VB
18637	20077	22	places	place	NNS
18637	20077	23	of	of	IN
18637	20077	24	business	business	NN
18637	20077	25	or	or	CC
18637	20077	26	where	where	WRB
18637	20077	27	a	a	DT
18637	20077	28	chief	chief	JJ
18637	20077	29	officer	officer	NN
18637	20077	30	resides	reside	VBZ
18637	20077	31	,	,	,
18637	20077	32	a	a	DT
18637	20077	33	statute	statute	NN
18637	20077	34	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	20077	35	action	action	NN
18637	20077	36	against	against	IN
18637	20077	37	a	a	DT
18637	20077	38	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	20077	39	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	20077	40	in	in	IN
18637	20077	41	any	any	DT
18637	20077	42	county	county	NN
18637	20077	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	20077	44	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	20077	45	and	and	CC
18637	20077	46	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	20077	47	.	.	.
18637	20078	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20078	2	1197	1197	CD
18637	20078	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20078	4	So	so	RB
18637	20078	5	also	also	RB
18637	20078	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	20078	7	a	a	DT
18637	20078	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	20078	9	,	,	,
18637	20078	10	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	20078	11	only	only	RB
18637	20078	12	to	to	IN
18637	20078	13	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	20078	14	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	20078	15	,	,	,
18637	20078	16	which	which	WDT
18637	20078	17	requires	require	VBZ
18637	20078	18	the	the	DT
18637	20078	19	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	20078	20	,	,	,
18637	20078	21	as	as	IN
18637	20078	22	a	a	DT
18637	20078	23	condition	condition	NN
18637	20078	24	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	20078	25	to	to	IN
18637	20078	26	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	20078	27	of	of	IN
18637	20078	28	an	an	DT
18637	20078	29	action	action	NN
18637	20078	30	,	,	,
18637	20078	31	to	to	TO
18637	20078	32	send	send	VB
18637	20078	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20078	34	officer	officer	NN
18637	20078	35	into	into	IN
18637	20078	36	the	the	DT
18637	20078	37	State	State	NNP
18637	20078	38	,	,	,
18637	20078	39	with	with	IN
18637	20078	40	papers	paper	NNS
18637	20078	41	and	and	CC
18637	20078	42	books	book	NNS
18637	20078	43	bearing	bear	VBG
18637	20078	44	on	on	IN
18637	20078	45	the	the	DT
18637	20078	46	matter	matter	NN
18637	20078	47	in	in	IN
18637	20078	48	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	20078	49	,	,	,
18637	20078	50	for	for	IN
18637	20078	51	examination	examination	NN
18637	20078	52	before	before	IN
18637	20078	53	trial	trial	NN
18637	20078	54	,	,	,
18637	20078	55	where	where	WRB
18637	20078	56	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	20078	57	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	20078	58	,	,	,
18637	20078	59	as	as	RB
18637	20078	60	well	well	RB
18637	20078	61	as	as	IN
18637	20078	62	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	20078	63	and	and	CC
18637	20078	64	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	20078	65	within	within	IN
18637	20078	66	the	the	DT
18637	20078	67	State	State	NNP
18637	20078	68	,	,	,
18637	20078	69	were	be	VBD
18637	20078	70	subject	subject	JJ
18637	20078	71	to	to	IN
18637	20078	72	less	less	RBR
18637	20078	73	onerous	onerous	JJ
18637	20078	74	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	20078	75	.	.	.
18637	20079	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20079	2	1198	1198	CD
18637	20079	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20079	4	Expenses	Expenses	NNPS
18637	20079	5	of	of	IN
18637	20079	6	Litigation	Litigation	NNP
18637	20079	7	A	a	DT
18637	20079	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	20079	9	which	which	WDT
18637	20079	10	directs	direct	VBZ
18637	20079	11	that	that	IN
18637	20079	12	life	life	NN
18637	20079	13	and	and	CC
18637	20079	14	health	health	NN
18637	20079	15	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	20079	16	companies	company	NNS
18637	20079	17	who	who	WP
18637	20079	18	default	default	VBP
18637	20079	19	in	in	IN
18637	20079	20	payments	payment	NNS
18637	20079	21	of	of	IN
18637	20079	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20079	23	policies	policy	NNS
18637	20079	24	shall	shall	MD
18637	20079	25	pay	pay	VB
18637	20079	26	12	12	CD
18637	20079	27	per	per	NN
18637	20079	28	cent	cent	NN
18637	20079	29	damages	damage	NNS
18637	20079	30	,	,	,
18637	20079	31	together	together	RB
18637	20079	32	with	with	IN
18637	20079	33	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	20079	34	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	20079	35	's	's	POS
18637	20079	36	fees	fee	NNS
18637	20079	37	,	,	,
18637	20079	38	does	do	VBZ
18637	20079	39	not	not	RB
18637	20079	40	deny	deny	VB
18637	20079	41	the	the	DT
18637	20079	42	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20079	43	protection	protection	NN
18637	20079	44	of	of	IN
18637	20079	45	the	the	DT
18637	20079	46	law	law	NN
18637	20079	47	in	in	IN
18637	20079	48	failing	fail	VBG
18637	20079	49	to	to	TO
18637	20079	50	impose	impose	VB
18637	20079	51	the	the	DT
18637	20079	52	same	same	JJ
18637	20079	53	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	20079	54	on	on	IN
18637	20079	55	fire	fire	NN
18637	20079	56	,	,	,
18637	20079	57	marine	marine	NNP
18637	20079	58	,	,	,
18637	20079	59	and	and	CC
18637	20079	60	inland	inland	NN
18637	20079	61	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	20079	62	companies	company	NNS
18637	20079	63	,	,	,
18637	20079	64	and	and	CC
18637	20079	65	on	on	IN
18637	20079	66	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	20079	67	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	20079	68	and	and	CC
18637	20079	69	relief	relief	NN
18637	20079	70	associations	association	NNS
18637	20079	71	.	.	.
18637	20080	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20080	2	1199	1199	CD
18637	20080	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20080	4	Costs	cost	NNS
18637	20080	5	may	may	MD
18637	20080	6	be	be	VB
18637	20080	7	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	20080	8	to	to	IN
18637	20080	9	a	a	DT
18637	20080	10	person	person	NN
18637	20080	11	who	who	WP
18637	20080	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	20080	13	been	be	VBN
18637	20080	14	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	20080	15	to	to	IN
18637	20080	16	malicious	malicious	JJ
18637	20080	17	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	20080	18	,	,	,
18637	20080	19	with	with	IN
18637	20080	20	provision	provision	NN
18637	20080	21	for	for	IN
18637	20080	22	commitment	commitment	NN
18637	20080	23	of	of	IN
18637	20080	24	the	the	DT
18637	20080	25	prosecutor	prosecutor	NN
18637	20080	26	until	until	IN
18637	20080	27	paid	pay	VBN
18637	20080	28	.	.	.
18637	20081	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20081	2	1200	1200	CD
18637	20081	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20081	4	Statutes	statute	NNS
18637	20081	5	providing	provide	VBG
18637	20081	6	for	for	IN
18637	20081	7	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	20081	8	of	of	IN
18637	20081	9	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	20081	10	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	20081	11	's	's	POS
18637	20081	12	fees	fee	NNS
18637	20081	13	in	in	IN
18637	20081	14	action	action	NN
18637	20081	15	on	on	IN
18637	20081	16	small	small	JJ
18637	20081	17	claims	claim	NNS
18637	20081	18	against	against	IN
18637	20081	19	all	all	DT
18637	20081	20	classes	class	NNS
18637	20081	21	of	of	IN
18637	20081	22	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	20081	23	,	,	,
18637	20081	24	individual	individual	NN
18637	20081	25	and	and	CC
18637	20081	26	corporate,[1201	corporate,[1201	NNP
18637	20081	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20081	28	in	in	IN
18637	20081	29	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	20081	30	proceedings,[1202	proceedings,[1202	NNP
18637	20081	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20081	32	or	or	CC
18637	20081	33	in	in	IN
18637	20081	34	actions	action	NNS
18637	20081	35	against	against	IN
18637	20081	36	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	20081	37	for	for	IN
18637	20081	38	damages	damage	NNS
18637	20081	39	caused	cause	VBN
18637	20081	40	by	by	IN
18637	20081	41	fires[1203	fires[1203	NNP
18637	20081	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20081	43	have	have	VBP
18637	20081	44	been	be	VBN
18637	20081	45	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	20081	46	.	.	.
18637	20082	1	But	but	CC
18637	20082	2	a	a	DT
18637	20082	3	statute	statute	NN
18637	20082	4	,	,	,
18637	20082	5	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	20082	6	only	only	RB
18637	20082	7	to	to	TO
18637	20082	8	railway	railway	VB
18637	20082	9	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	20082	10	,	,	,
18637	20082	11	providing	provide	VBG
18637	20082	12	for	for	IN
18637	20082	13	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	20082	14	of	of	IN
18637	20082	15	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	20082	16	's	's	POS
18637	20082	17	fees	fee	NNS
18637	20082	18	and	and	CC
18637	20082	19	costs	cost	NNS
18637	20082	20	in	in	IN
18637	20082	21	actions	action	NNS
18637	20082	22	for	for	IN
18637	20082	23	certain	certain	JJ
18637	20082	24	small	small	JJ
18637	20082	25	claims	claim	NNS
18637	20082	26	was	be	VBD
18637	20082	27	found	find	VBN
18637	20082	28	to	to	TO
18637	20082	29	be	be	VB
18637	20082	30	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	20082	31	to	to	IN
18637	20082	32	the	the	DT
18637	20082	33	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20082	34	protection	protection	NN
18637	20082	35	clause	clause	NN
18637	20082	36	.	.	.
18637	20083	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20083	2	1204	1204	CD
18637	20083	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20083	4	Selection	Selection	NNP
18637	20083	5	of	of	IN
18637	20083	6	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	20083	7	Exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	20083	8	the	the	DT
18637	20083	9	authority	authority	NN
18637	20083	10	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	20083	11	by	by	IN
18637	20083	12	section	section	NN
18637	20083	13	5	5	CD
18637	20083	14	of	of	IN
18637	20083	15	the	the	DT
18637	20083	16	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	20083	17	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20083	18	,	,	,
18637	20083	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20083	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	20083	21	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	20083	22	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	20083	23	the	the	DT
18637	20083	24	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	20083	25	of	of	IN
18637	20083	26	any	any	DT
18637	20083	27	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	20083	28	from	from	IN
18637	20083	29	service	service	NN
18637	20083	30	as	as	IN
18637	20083	31	a	a	DT
18637	20083	32	grand	grand	JJ
18637	20083	33	or	or	CC
18637	20083	34	petit	petit	NN
18637	20083	35	juror	juror	NN
18637	20083	36	in	in	IN
18637	20083	37	any	any	DT
18637	20083	38	federal	federal	JJ
18637	20083	39	or	or	CC
18637	20083	40	State	State	NNP
18637	20083	41	court	court	NN
18637	20083	42	,	,	,
18637	20083	43	on	on	IN
18637	20083	44	the	the	DT
18637	20083	45	ground	ground	NN
18637	20083	46	of	of	IN
18637	20083	47	race	race	NN
18637	20083	48	or	or	CC
18637	20083	49	color	color	NN
18637	20083	50	.	.	.
18637	20084	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20084	2	1205	1205	CD
18637	20084	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20084	4	Jury	jury	NN
18637	20084	5	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
18637	20084	6	are	be	VBP
18637	20084	7	under	under	IN
18637	20084	8	the	the	DT
18637	20084	9	duty	duty	NN
18637	20084	10	"	"	``
18637	20084	11	not	not	RB
18637	20084	12	to	to	TO
18637	20084	13	pursue	pursue	VB
18637	20084	14	a	a	DT
18637	20084	15	course	course	NN
18637	20084	16	of	of	IN
18637	20084	17	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	20084	18	in	in	IN
18637	20084	19	the	the	DT
18637	20084	20	administration	administration	NN
18637	20084	21	of	of	IN
18637	20084	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20084	23	office	office	NN
18637	20084	24	which	which	WDT
18637	20084	25	would	would	MD
18637	20084	26	operate	operate	VB
18637	20084	27	to	to	TO
18637	20084	28	discriminate	discriminate	VB
18637	20084	29	in	in	IN
18637	20084	30	the	the	DT
18637	20084	31	selection	selection	NN
18637	20084	32	of	of	IN
18637	20084	33	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	20084	34	on	on	IN
18637	20084	35	racial	racial	JJ
18637	20084	36	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	20084	37	.	.	.
18637	20085	1	"	"	``
18637	20085	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20085	3	1206	1206	CD
18637	20085	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20085	5	An	an	DT
18637	20085	6	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	20085	7	does	do	VBZ
18637	20085	8	not	not	RB
18637	20085	9	,	,	,
18637	20085	10	however	however	RB
18637	20085	11	,	,	,
18637	20085	12	have	have	VBP
18637	20085	13	a	a	DT
18637	20085	14	legal	legal	JJ
18637	20085	15	right	right	NN
18637	20085	16	to	to	IN
18637	20085	17	a	a	DT
18637	20085	18	jury	jury	NN
18637	20085	19	composed	compose	VBN
18637	20085	20	in	in	IN
18637	20085	21	whole	whole	NN
18637	20085	22	or	or	CC
18637	20085	23	in	in	IN
18637	20085	24	part	part	NN
18637	20085	25	of	of	IN
18637	20085	26	members	member	NNS
18637	20085	27	of	of	IN
18637	20085	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20085	29	own	own	JJ
18637	20085	30	race	race	NN
18637	20085	31	.	.	.
18637	20086	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20086	2	1207	1207	CD
18637	20086	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20086	4	Mere	mere	JJ
18637	20086	5	inequality	inequality	NN
18637	20086	6	in	in	IN
18637	20086	7	the	the	DT
18637	20086	8	numbers	number	NNS
18637	20086	9	of	of	IN
18637	20086	10	persons	person	NNS
18637	20086	11	selected	select	VBN
18637	20086	12	from	from	IN
18637	20086	13	different	different	JJ
18637	20086	14	races	race	NNS
18637	20086	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	20086	16	not	not	RB
18637	20086	17	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	20086	18	;	;	:
18637	20086	19	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	20086	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	20086	21	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	20086	22	only	only	RB
18637	20086	23	if	if	IN
18637	20086	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20086	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	20086	26	purposeful	purposeful	JJ
18637	20086	27	and	and	CC
18637	20086	28	systematic	systematic	JJ
18637	20086	29	.	.	.
18637	20087	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20087	2	1208	1208	CD
18637	20087	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20087	4	But	but	CC
18637	20087	5	where	where	WRB
18637	20087	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20087	7	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	20087	8	that	that	IN
18637	20087	9	no	no	DT
18637	20087	10	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	20087	11	had	have	VBD
18637	20087	12	served	serve	VBN
18637	20087	13	on	on	IN
18637	20087	14	a	a	DT
18637	20087	15	grand	grand	JJ
18637	20087	16	or	or	CC
18637	20087	17	petit	petit	JJ
18637	20087	18	jury	jury	NN
18637	20087	19	for	for	IN
18637	20087	20	thirty	thirty	CD
18637	20087	21	years	year	NNS
18637	20087	22	in	in	IN
18637	20087	23	a	a	DT
18637	20087	24	county	county	NN
18637	20087	25	in	in	IN
18637	20087	26	which	which	WDT
18637	20087	27	35	35	CD
18637	20087	28	per	per	IN
18637	20087	29	cent	cent	NN
18637	20087	30	of	of	IN
18637	20087	31	the	the	DT
18637	20087	32	adult	adult	NN
18637	20087	33	population	population	NN
18637	20087	34	was	be	VBD
18637	20087	35	colored	color	VBN
18637	20087	36	,	,	,
18637	20087	37	the	the	DT
18637	20087	38	inference	inference	NN
18637	20087	39	of	of	IN
18637	20087	40	systematic	systematic	JJ
18637	20087	41	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	20087	42	was	be	VBD
18637	20087	43	not	not	RB
18637	20087	44	repelled	repel	VBN
18637	20087	45	by	by	IN
18637	20087	46	a	a	DT
18637	20087	47	showing	showing	NN
18637	20087	48	that	that	IN
18637	20087	49	few	few	JJ
18637	20087	50	Negroes	Negroes	NNPS
18637	20087	51	fulfilled	fulfil	VBD
18637	20087	52	the	the	DT
18637	20087	53	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	20087	54	that	that	IN
18637	20087	55	a	a	DT
18637	20087	56	juror	juror	NN
18637	20087	57	must	must	MD
18637	20087	58	be	be	VB
18637	20087	59	a	a	DT
18637	20087	60	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	20087	61	elector	elector	NN
18637	20087	62	.	.	.
18637	20088	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20088	2	1209	1209	CD
18637	20088	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20088	4	To	to	IN
18637	20088	5	what	what	WDT
18637	20088	6	extent	extent	NN
18637	20088	7	,	,	,
18637	20088	8	if	if	IN
18637	20088	9	at	at	RB
18637	20088	10	all	all	RB
18637	20088	11	,	,	,
18637	20088	12	the	the	DT
18637	20088	13	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20088	14	protection	protection	NN
18637	20088	15	clause	clause	NN
18637	20088	16	prevents	prevent	VBZ
18637	20088	17	the	the	DT
18637	20088	18	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	20088	19	from	from	IN
18637	20088	20	jury	jury	NN
18637	20088	21	service	service	NN
18637	20088	22	of	of	IN
18637	20088	23	any	any	DT
18637	20088	24	class	class	NN
18637	20088	25	of	of	IN
18637	20088	26	persons	person	NNS
18637	20088	27	on	on	IN
18637	20088	28	any	any	DT
18637	20088	29	basis	basis	NN
18637	20088	30	other	other	JJ
18637	20088	31	than	than	IN
18637	20088	32	race	race	NN
18637	20088	33	or	or	CC
18637	20088	34	color	color	NN
18637	20088	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	20088	36	a	a	DT
18637	20088	37	still	still	RB
18637	20088	38	unsettled	unsettled	JJ
18637	20088	39	problem	problem	NN
18637	20088	40	of	of	IN
18637	20088	41	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	20088	42	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	20088	43	.	.	.
18637	20089	1	The	the	DT
18637	20089	2	selection	selection	NN
18637	20089	3	of	of	IN
18637	20089	4	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	20089	5	may	may	MD
18637	20089	6	be	be	VB
18637	20089	7	confined	confine	VBN
18637	20089	8	to	to	IN
18637	20089	9	males	male	NNS
18637	20089	10	,	,	,
18637	20089	11	to	to	IN
18637	20089	12	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20089	13	,	,	,
18637	20089	14	to	to	IN
18637	20089	15	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	20089	16	electors	elector	NNS
18637	20089	17	,	,	,
18637	20089	18	to	to	IN
18637	20089	19	persons	person	NNS
18637	20089	20	within	within	IN
18637	20089	21	certain	certain	JJ
18637	20089	22	ages	age	NNS
18637	20089	23	,	,	,
18637	20089	24	or	or	CC
18637	20089	25	to	to	IN
18637	20089	26	persons	person	NNS
18637	20089	27	having	have	VBG
18637	20089	28	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	20089	29	educational	educational	JJ
18637	20089	30	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	20089	31	.	.	.
18637	20090	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20090	2	1210	1210	CD
18637	20090	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20090	4	Certain	certain	JJ
18637	20090	5	occupational	occupational	JJ
18637	20090	6	groups	group	NNS
18637	20090	7	,	,	,
18637	20090	8	such	such	JJ
18637	20090	9	as	as	IN
18637	20090	10	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
18637	20090	11	,	,	,
18637	20090	12	preachers	preacher	NNS
18637	20090	13	,	,	,
18637	20090	14	ministers	minister	NNS
18637	20090	15	,	,	,
18637	20090	16	doctors	doctor	NNS
18637	20090	17	,	,	,
18637	20090	18	dentists	dentist	NNS
18637	20090	19	,	,	,
18637	20090	20	and	and	CC
18637	20090	21	engineers	engineer	NNS
18637	20090	22	and	and	CC
18637	20090	23	firemen	fireman	NNS
18637	20090	24	of	of	IN
18637	20090	25	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	20090	26	trains	train	NNS
18637	20090	27	may	may	MD
18637	20090	28	be	be	VB
18637	20090	29	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	20090	30	from	from	IN
18637	20090	31	jury	jury	NN
18637	20090	32	service	service	NN
18637	20090	33	.	.	.
18637	20091	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20091	2	1211	1211	CD
18637	20091	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20091	4	An	an	DT
18637	20091	5	issue	issue	NN
18637	20091	6	of	of	IN
18637	20091	7	even	even	RB
18637	20091	8	greater	great	JJR
18637	20091	9	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	20091	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	20091	11	raised	raise	VBN
18637	20091	12	by	by	IN
18637	20091	13	differentiation	differentiation	NN
18637	20091	14	in	in	IN
18637	20091	15	the	the	DT
18637	20091	16	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	20091	17	of	of	IN
18637	20091	18	persons	person	NNS
18637	20091	19	selected	select	VBN
18637	20091	20	to	to	TO
18637	20091	21	try	try	VB
18637	20091	22	different	different	JJ
18637	20091	23	kinds	kind	NNS
18637	20091	24	of	of	IN
18637	20091	25	cases	case	NNS
18637	20091	26	.	.	.
18637	20092	1	This	this	DT
18637	20092	2	was	be	VBD
18637	20092	3	the	the	DT
18637	20092	4	question	question	NN
18637	20092	5	on	on	IN
18637	20092	6	which	which	WDT
18637	20092	7	the	the	DT
18637	20092	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	20092	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20092	10	divided	divide	VBD
18637	20092	11	five	five	CD
18637	20092	12	to	to	TO
18637	20092	13	four	four	CD
18637	20092	14	in	in	IN
18637	20092	15	Fay	Fay	NNP
18637	20092	16	_	_	NNP
18637	20092	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	20092	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20092	19	New	New	NNP
18637	20092	20	York[1212	York[1212	NNP
18637	20092	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20092	22	where	where	WRB
18637	20092	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20092	24	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	20092	25	a	a	DT
18637	20092	26	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	20092	27	by	by	IN
18637	20092	28	a	a	DT
18637	20092	29	"	"	``
18637	20092	30	blue	blue	JJ
18637	20092	31	ribbon	ribbon	NN
18637	20092	32	"	"	''
18637	20092	33	jury	jury	NN
18637	20092	34	.	.	.
18637	20093	1	In	in	IN
18637	20093	2	that	that	DT
18637	20093	3	case	case	NN
18637	20093	4	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	20093	5	,	,	,
18637	20093	6	officials	official	NNS
18637	20093	7	of	of	IN
18637	20093	8	certain	certain	JJ
18637	20093	9	labor	labor	NN
18637	20093	10	unions	union	NNS
18637	20093	11	,	,	,
18637	20093	12	were	be	VBD
18637	20093	13	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	20093	14	of	of	IN
18637	20093	15	extortion	extortion	NN
18637	20093	16	,	,	,
18637	20093	17	by	by	IN
18637	20093	18	collecting	collect	VBG
18637	20093	19	large	large	JJ
18637	20093	20	sums	sum	NNS
18637	20093	21	from	from	IN
18637	20093	22	contractors	contractor	NNS
18637	20093	23	for	for	IN
18637	20093	24	assisting	assist	VBG
18637	20093	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20093	26	in	in	IN
18637	20093	27	avoiding	avoid	VBG
18637	20093	28	labor	labor	NN
18637	20093	29	troubles	trouble	NNS
18637	20093	30	.	.	.
18637	20094	1	From	from	IN
18637	20094	2	a	a	DT
18637	20094	3	"	"	``
18637	20094	4	blue	blue	JJ
18637	20094	5	ribbon	ribbon	NN
18637	20094	6	"	"	''
18637	20094	7	jury	jury	NN
18637	20094	8	certain	certain	JJ
18637	20094	9	categories	category	NNS
18637	20094	10	of	of	IN
18637	20094	11	persons	person	NNS
18637	20094	12	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	20094	13	for	for	IN
18637	20094	14	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	20094	15	jury	jury	NN
18637	20094	16	duty	duty	NN
18637	20094	17	are	be	VBP
18637	20094	18	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	20094	19	;	;	:
18637	20094	20	and	and	CC
18637	20094	21	on	on	IN
18637	20094	22	this	this	DT
18637	20094	23	ground	ground	NN
18637	20094	24	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	20094	25	claimed	claim	VBD
18637	20094	26	that	that	IN
18637	20094	27	in	in	IN
18637	20094	28	being	be	VBG
18637	20094	29	tried	try	VBN
18637	20094	30	by	by	IN
18637	20094	31	such	such	PDT
18637	20094	32	a	a	DT
18637	20094	33	jury	jury	NN
18637	20094	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20094	35	had	have	VBD
18637	20094	36	been	be	VBN
18637	20094	37	denied	deny	VBN
18637	20094	38	"	"	``
18637	20094	39	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20094	40	protection	protection	NN
18637	20094	41	of	of	IN
18637	20094	42	the	the	DT
18637	20094	43	law	law	NN
18637	20094	44	"	"	''
18637	20094	45	and	and	CC
18637	20094	46	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	20094	47	of	of	IN
18637	20094	48	"	"	``
18637	20094	49	due	due	JJ
18637	20094	50	process	process	NN
18637	20094	51	of	of	IN
18637	20094	52	law	law	NN
18637	20094	53	,	,	,
18637	20094	54	"	"	''
18637	20094	55	but	but	CC
18637	20094	56	especially	especially	RB
18637	20094	57	the	the	DT
18637	20094	58	former	former	JJ
18637	20094	59	,	,	,
18637	20094	60	alleging	allege	VBG
18637	20094	61	that	that	IN
18637	20094	62	such	such	JJ
18637	20094	63	juries	jury	NNS
18637	20094	64	had	have	VBD
18637	20094	65	a	a	DT
18637	20094	66	higher	high	JJR
18637	20094	67	record	record	NN
18637	20094	68	of	of	IN
18637	20094	69	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	20094	70	than	than	IN
18637	20094	71	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	20094	72	juries	jury	NNS
18637	20094	73	and	and	CC
18637	20094	74	that	that	IN
18637	20094	75	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20094	76	sympathies	sympathy	NNS
18637	20094	77	were	be	VBD
18637	20094	78	"	"	``
18637	20094	79	conservative	conservative	JJ
18637	20094	80	.	.	.
18637	20094	81	"	"	''
18637	20095	1	The	the	DT
18637	20095	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20095	3	,	,	,
18637	20095	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	20095	5	by	by	IN
18637	20095	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20095	7	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	20095	8	,	,	,
18637	20095	9	answered	answer	VBD
18637	20095	10	that	that	IN
18637	20095	11	"	"	``
18637	20095	12	a	a	DT
18637	20095	13	state	state	NN
18637	20095	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	20095	15	not	not	RB
18637	20095	16	required	require	VBN
18637	20095	17	to	to	TO
18637	20095	18	try	try	VB
18637	20095	19	all	all	DT
18637	20095	20	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	20095	21	to	to	IN
18637	20095	22	the	the	DT
18637	20095	23	same	same	JJ
18637	20095	24	forum	forum	NN
18637	20095	25	,	,	,
18637	20095	26	"	"	''
18637	20095	27	but	but	CC
18637	20095	28	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	20095	29	that	that	IN
18637	20095	30	"	"	``
18637	20095	31	a	a	DT
18637	20095	32	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	20095	33	,	,	,
18637	20095	34	even	even	RB
18637	20095	35	if	if	IN
18637	20095	36	vested	vest	VBN
18637	20095	37	in	in	IN
18637	20095	38	the	the	DT
18637	20095	39	court	court	NN
18637	20095	40	,	,	,
18637	20095	41	to	to	TO
18637	20095	42	shunt	shunt	VB
18637	20095	43	a	a	DT
18637	20095	44	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	20095	45	before	before	IN
18637	20095	46	a	a	DT
18637	20095	47	jury	jury	NN
18637	20095	48	so	so	RB
18637	20095	49	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	20095	50	as	as	RB
18637	20095	51	greatly	greatly	RB
18637	20095	52	to	to	TO
18637	20095	53	lessen	lessen	VB
18637	20095	54	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20095	55	chances	chance	NNS
18637	20095	56	while	while	IN
18637	20095	57	others	other	NNS
18637	20095	58	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	20095	59	of	of	IN
18637	20095	60	a	a	DT
18637	20095	61	like	like	JJ
18637	20095	62	offense	offense	NN
18637	20095	63	are	be	VBP
18637	20095	64	tried	try	VBN
18637	20095	65	by	by	IN
18637	20095	66	a	a	DT
18637	20095	67	jury	jury	NN
18637	20095	68	so	so	RB
18637	20095	69	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	20095	70	as	as	IN
18637	20095	71	to	to	TO
18637	20095	72	be	be	VB
18637	20095	73	more	more	RBR
18637	20095	74	favorable	favorable	JJ
18637	20095	75	to	to	IN
18637	20095	76	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20095	77	,	,	,
18637	20095	78	would	would	MD
18637	20095	79	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	20095	80	be	be	VB
18637	20095	81	'	'	``
18637	20095	82	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20095	83	protection	protection	NN
18637	20095	84	of	of	IN
18637	20095	85	the	the	DT
18637	20095	86	laws	law	NNS
18637	20095	87	.	.	.
18637	20096	1	'	'	``
18637	20096	2	"	"	``
18637	20096	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20096	4	1213	1213	CD
18637	20096	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20096	6	However	however	RB
18637	20096	7	,	,	,
18637	20096	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20096	9	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	20096	10	that	that	IN
18637	20096	11	the	the	DT
18637	20096	12	New	New	NNP
18637	20096	13	York	York	NNP
18637	20096	14	statute	statute	NN
18637	20096	15	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	20096	16	"	"	``
18637	20096	17	blue	blue	JJ
18637	20096	18	ribbon	ribbon	NN
18637	20096	19	"	"	''
18637	20096	20	juries	jury	NNS
18637	20096	21	"	"	''
18637	20096	22	does	do	VBZ
18637	20096	23	not	not	RB
18637	20096	24	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	20096	25	,	,	,
18637	20096	26	or	or	CC
18637	20096	27	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	20096	28	the	the	DT
18637	20096	29	clerk	clerk	NN
18637	20096	30	to	to	TO
18637	20096	31	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	20096	32	,	,	,
18637	20096	33	any	any	DT
18637	20096	34	person	person	NN
18637	20096	35	or	or	CC
18637	20096	36	class	class	NN
18637	20096	37	because	because	IN
18637	20096	38	of	of	IN
18637	20096	39	race	race	NN
18637	20096	40	,	,	,
18637	20096	41	creed	creed	NN
18637	20096	42	,	,	,
18637	20096	43	color	color	NN
18637	20096	44	or	or	CC
18637	20096	45	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	20096	46	.	.	.
18637	20097	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20097	2	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	20097	3	no	no	DT
18637	20097	4	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	20097	5	of	of	IN
18637	20097	6	an	an	DT
18637	20097	7	economic	economic	JJ
18637	20097	8	nature	nature	NN
18637	20097	9	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	20097	10	that	that	DT
18637	20097	11	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	20097	12	by	by	IN
18637	20097	13	the	the	DT
18637	20097	14	concededly	concededly	RB
18637	20097	15	valid	valid	JJ
18637	20097	16	general	general	JJ
18637	20097	17	panel	panel	NN
18637	20097	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	20097	19	.	.	.
18637	20098	1	Each	each	DT
18637	20098	2	of	of	IN
18637	20098	3	the	the	DT
18637	20098	4	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	20098	5	of	of	IN
18637	20098	6	elimination	elimination	NN
18637	20098	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	20098	8	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	20098	9	and	and	CC
18637	20098	10	closely	closely	RB
18637	20098	11	related	related	JJ
18637	20098	12	to	to	IN
18637	20098	13	the	the	DT
18637	20098	14	juror	juror	NN
18637	20098	15	's	's	POS
18637	20098	16	suitability	suitability	NN
18637	20098	17	for	for	IN
18637	20098	18	the	the	DT
18637	20098	19	kind	kind	NN
18637	20098	20	of	of	IN
18637	20098	21	service	service	NN
18637	20098	22	the	the	DT
18637	20098	23	special	special	JJ
18637	20098	24	panel	panel	NN
18637	20098	25	requires	require	VBZ
18637	20098	26	or	or	CC
18637	20098	27	to	to	IN
18637	20098	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20098	29	fitness	fitness	NN
18637	20098	30	to	to	TO
18637	20098	31	judge	judge	VB
18637	20098	32	the	the	DT
18637	20098	33	kind	kind	NN
18637	20098	34	of	of	IN
18637	20098	35	cases	case	NNS
18637	20098	36	for	for	IN
18637	20098	37	which	which	WDT
18637	20098	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20098	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	20098	40	most	most	RBS
18637	20098	41	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	20098	42	utilized	utilize	VBN
18637	20098	43	.	.	.
18637	20099	1	Not	not	RB
18637	20099	2	all	all	DT
18637	20099	3	of	of	IN
18637	20099	4	the	the	DT
18637	20099	5	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	20099	6	of	of	IN
18637	20099	7	elimination	elimination	NN
18637	20099	8	would	would	MD
18637	20099	9	appear	appear	VB
18637	20099	10	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	20099	11	to	to	IN
18637	20099	12	the	the	DT
18637	20099	13	issues	issue	NNS
18637	20099	14	of	of	IN
18637	20099	15	the	the	DT
18637	20099	16	present	present	JJ
18637	20099	17	case	case	NN
18637	20099	18	.	.	.
18637	20100	1	But	but	CC
18637	20100	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20100	3	know	know	VBP
18637	20100	4	of	of	IN
18637	20100	5	no	no	DT
18637	20100	6	right	right	NN
18637	20100	7	of	of	IN
18637	20100	8	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	20100	9	to	to	TO
18637	20100	10	have	have	VB
18637	20100	11	a	a	DT
18637	20100	12	specially	specially	RB
18637	20100	13	constituted	constitute	VBN
18637	20100	14	panel	panel	NN
18637	20100	15	which	which	WDT
18637	20100	16	would	would	MD
18637	20100	17	include	include	VB
18637	20100	18	all	all	DT
18637	20100	19	persons	person	NNS
18637	20100	20	who	who	WP
18637	20100	21	might	may	MD
18637	20100	22	be	be	VB
18637	20100	23	fitted	fit	VBN
18637	20100	24	to	to	TO
18637	20100	25	hear	hear	VB
18637	20100	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20100	27	particular	particular	JJ
18637	20100	28	and	and	CC
18637	20100	29	unique	unique	JJ
18637	20100	30	case	case	NN
18637	20100	31	.	.	.
18637	20101	1	"	"	``
18637	20101	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20101	3	1214	1214	CD
18637	20101	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20101	5	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20101	6	held	hold	VBD
18637	20101	7	further	further	RB
18637	20101	8	that	that	IN
18637	20101	9	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	20101	10	had	have	VBD
18637	20101	11	failed	fail	VBN
18637	20101	12	to	to	TO
18637	20101	13	shoulder	shoulder	VB
18637	20101	14	the	the	DT
18637	20101	15	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	20101	16	burden	burden	NN
18637	20101	17	of	of	IN
18637	20101	18	proof	proof	NN
18637	20101	19	in	in	IN
18637	20101	20	support	support	NN
18637	20101	21	of	of	IN
18637	20101	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20101	23	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	20101	24	of	of	IN
18637	20101	25	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	20101	26	,	,	,
18637	20101	27	and	and	CC
18637	20101	28	added	add	VBD
18637	20101	29	:	:	:
18637	20101	30	"	"	``
18637	20101	31	At	at	IN
18637	20101	32	most	most	RBS
18637	20101	33	,	,	,
18637	20101	34	the	the	DT
18637	20101	35	proof	proof	NN
18637	20101	36	shows	show	VBZ
18637	20101	37	lack	lack	NN
18637	20101	38	of	of	IN
18637	20101	39	proportional	proportional	JJ
18637	20101	40	representation	representation	NN
18637	20101	41	and	and	CC
18637	20101	42	there	there	EX
18637	20101	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	20101	44	an	an	DT
18637	20101	45	utter	utter	JJ
18637	20101	46	deficiency	deficiency	NN
18637	20101	47	of	of	IN
18637	20101	48	proof	proof	NN
18637	20101	49	that	that	IN
18637	20101	50	this	this	DT
18637	20101	51	was	be	VBD
18637	20101	52	the	the	DT
18637	20101	53	result	result	NN
18637	20101	54	of	of	IN
18637	20101	55	a	a	DT
18637	20101	56	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	20101	57	to	to	TO
18637	20101	58	discriminate	discriminate	VB
18637	20101	59	against	against	IN
18637	20101	60	this	this	DT
18637	20101	61	group	group	NN
18637	20101	62	as	as	IN
18637	20101	63	such	such	JJ
18637	20101	64	.	.	.
18637	20102	1	The	the	DT
18637	20102	2	uncontradicted	uncontradicted	JJ
18637	20102	3	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	20102	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	20102	5	that	that	IN
18637	20102	6	no	no	DT
18637	20102	7	person	person	NN
18637	20102	8	was	be	VBD
18637	20102	9	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	20102	10	because	because	IN
18637	20102	11	of	of	IN
18637	20102	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20102	13	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	20102	14	or	or	CC
18637	20102	15	economic	economic	JJ
18637	20102	16	status	status	NN
18637	20102	17	.	.	.
18637	20103	1	All	all	DT
18637	20103	2	were	be	VBD
18637	20103	3	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	20103	4	to	to	IN
18637	20103	5	the	the	DT
18637	20103	6	same	same	JJ
18637	20103	7	tests	test	NNS
18637	20103	8	of	of	IN
18637	20103	9	intelligence	intelligence	NN
18637	20103	10	,	,	,
18637	20103	11	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	20103	12	and	and	CC
18637	20103	13	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	20103	14	of	of	IN
18637	20103	15	English	English	NNP
18637	20103	16	.	.	.
18637	20104	1	The	the	DT
18637	20104	2	state	state	NN
18637	20104	3	's	's	POS
18637	20104	4	right	right	NN
18637	20104	5	to	to	TO
18637	20104	6	apply	apply	VB
18637	20104	7	these	these	DT
18637	20104	8	tests	test	NNS
18637	20104	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	20104	10	not	not	RB
18637	20104	11	open	open	JJ
18637	20104	12	to	to	TO
18637	20104	13	doubt	doubt	VB
18637	20104	14	even	even	RB
18637	20104	15	though	though	IN
18637	20104	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20104	17	disqualify	disqualify	VBP
18637	20104	18	,	,	,
18637	20104	19	especially	especially	RB
18637	20104	20	in	in	IN
18637	20104	21	the	the	DT
18637	20104	22	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	20104	23	that	that	WDT
18637	20104	24	prevail	prevail	VBP
18637	20104	25	in	in	IN
18637	20104	26	New	New	NNP
18637	20104	27	York	York	NNP
18637	20104	28	,	,	,
18637	20104	29	a	a	DT
18637	20104	30	disproportionate	disproportionate	JJ
18637	20104	31	number	number	NN
18637	20104	32	of	of	IN
18637	20104	33	manual	manual	JJ
18637	20104	34	workers	worker	NNS
18637	20104	35	.	.	.
18637	20105	1	A	a	DT
18637	20105	2	fair	fair	JJ
18637	20105	3	application	application	NN
18637	20105	4	of	of	IN
18637	20105	5	literacy	literacy	NN
18637	20105	6	,	,	,
18637	20105	7	intelligence	intelligence	NN
18637	20105	8	and	and	CC
18637	20105	9	other	other	JJ
18637	20105	10	tests	test	NNS
18637	20105	11	would	would	MD
18637	20105	12	hardly	hardly	RB
18637	20105	13	act	act	VB
18637	20105	14	with	with	IN
18637	20105	15	proportional	proportional	JJ
18637	20105	16	equality	equality	NN
18637	20105	17	on	on	IN
18637	20105	18	all	all	DT
18637	20105	19	levels	level	NNS
18637	20105	20	of	of	IN
18637	20105	21	life	life	NN
18637	20105	22	.	.	.
18637	20106	1	The	the	DT
18637	20106	2	most	most	JJS
18637	20106	3	that	that	WDT
18637	20106	4	the	the	DT
18637	20106	5	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	20106	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	20106	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	20106	8	to	to	TO
18637	20106	9	raise	raise	VB
18637	20106	10	,	,	,
18637	20106	11	rather	rather	RB
18637	20106	12	than	than	IN
18637	20106	13	answer	answer	VB
18637	20106	14	,	,	,
18637	20106	15	the	the	DT
18637	20106	16	question	question	NN
18637	20106	17	whether	whether	IN
18637	20106	18	there	there	EX
18637	20106	19	was	be	VBD
18637	20106	20	an	an	DT
18637	20106	21	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	20106	22	disproportionate	disproportionate	JJ
18637	20106	23	representation	representation	NN
18637	20106	24	of	of	IN
18637	20106	25	lower	low	JJR
18637	20106	26	income	income	NN
18637	20106	27	groups	group	NNS
18637	20106	28	on	on	IN
18637	20106	29	the	the	DT
18637	20106	30	special	special	JJ
18637	20106	31	jury	jury	NN
18637	20106	32	.	.	.
18637	20107	1	"	"	``
18637	20107	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20107	3	1215	1215	CD
18637	20107	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20107	5	Then	then	RB
18637	20107	6	,	,	,
18637	20107	7	as	as	IN
18637	20107	8	to	to	IN
18637	20107	9	the	the	DT
18637	20107	10	due	due	JJ
18637	20107	11	process	process	NN
18637	20107	12	clause	clause	NN
18637	20107	13	,	,	,
18637	20107	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20107	15	pointed	point	VBD
18637	20107	16	out	out	RP
18637	20107	17	that	that	IN
18637	20107	18	the	the	DT
18637	20107	19	jury	jury	NN
18637	20107	20	had	have	VBD
18637	20107	21	had	have	VBN
18637	20107	22	a	a	DT
18637	20107	23	long	long	JJ
18637	20107	24	and	and	CC
18637	20107	25	varied	varied	JJ
18637	20107	26	history	history	NN
18637	20107	27	in	in	IN
18637	20107	28	the	the	DT
18637	20107	29	course	course	NN
18637	20107	30	of	of	IN
18637	20107	31	which	which	WDT
18637	20107	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20107	33	has	have	VBZ
18637	20107	34	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	20107	35	many	many	JJ
18637	20107	36	forms	form	NNS
18637	20107	37	,	,	,
18637	20107	38	and	and	CC
18637	20107	39	that	that	IN
18637	20107	40	for	for	IN
18637	20107	41	that	that	DT
18637	20107	42	matter	matter	NN
18637	20107	43	the	the	DT
18637	20107	44	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20107	45	"	"	''
18637	20107	46	*	*	NFP
18637	20107	47	*	*	NFP
18637	20107	48	*	*	NFP
18637	20107	49	has	have	VBZ
18637	20107	50	construed	construe	VBN
18637	20107	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20107	52	to	to	TO
18637	20107	53	be	be	VB
18637	20107	54	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	20107	55	in	in	IN
18637	20107	56	the	the	DT
18637	20107	57	independent	independent	JJ
18637	20107	58	concept	concept	NN
18637	20107	59	of	of	IN
18637	20107	60	due	due	JJ
18637	20107	61	process	process	NN
18637	20107	62	that	that	DT
18637	20107	63	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	20107	64	shall	shall	MD
18637	20107	65	be	be	VB
18637	20107	66	rendered	render	VBN
18637	20107	67	only	only	RB
18637	20107	68	after	after	IN
18637	20107	69	a	a	DT
18637	20107	70	trial	trial	NN
18637	20107	71	,	,	,
18637	20107	72	in	in	IN
18637	20107	73	which	which	WDT
18637	20107	74	the	the	DT
18637	20107	75	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	20107	76	is	be	VBZ
18637	20107	77	a	a	DT
18637	20107	78	real	real	JJ
18637	20107	79	one	one	CD
18637	20107	80	,	,	,
18637	20107	81	not	not	RB
18637	20107	82	a	a	DT
18637	20107	83	sham	sham	NN
18637	20107	84	or	or	CC
18637	20107	85	pretense	pretense	NN
18637	20107	86	.	.	.
18637	20108	1	*	*	NFP
18637	20108	2	*	*	NFP
18637	20108	3	*	*	NFP
18637	20108	4	Trial	trial	NN
18637	20108	5	must	must	MD
18637	20108	6	be	be	VB
18637	20108	7	held	hold	VBN
18637	20108	8	before	before	IN
18637	20108	9	a	a	DT
18637	20108	10	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	20108	11	not	not	RB
18637	20108	12	biased	bias	VBN
18637	20108	13	by	by	IN
18637	20108	14	interest	interest	NN
18637	20108	15	in	in	IN
18637	20108	16	the	the	DT
18637	20108	17	event	event	NN
18637	20108	18	.	.	.
18637	20109	1	*	*	NFP
18637	20109	2	*	*	NFP
18637	20109	3	*	*	NFP
18637	20109	4	Undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	20109	5	a	a	DT
18637	20109	6	system	system	NN
18637	20109	7	of	of	IN
18637	20109	8	exclusions	exclusion	NNS
18637	20109	9	could	could	MD
18637	20109	10	be	be	VB
18637	20109	11	so	so	RB
18637	20109	12	manipulated	manipulate	VBN
18637	20109	13	as	as	IN
18637	20109	14	to	to	TO
18637	20109	15	call	call	VB
18637	20109	16	a	a	DT
18637	20109	17	jury	jury	NN
18637	20109	18	before	before	IN
18637	20109	19	which	which	WDT
18637	20109	20	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	20109	21	would	would	MD
18637	20109	22	have	have	VB
18637	20109	23	so	so	RB
18637	20109	24	little	little	JJ
18637	20109	25	chance	chance	NN
18637	20109	26	of	of	IN
18637	20109	27	a	a	DT
18637	20109	28	decision	decision	NN
18637	20109	29	on	on	IN
18637	20109	30	the	the	DT
18637	20109	31	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	20109	32	that	that	IN
18637	20109	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20109	34	would	would	MD
18637	20109	35	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	20109	36	a	a	DT
18637	20109	37	denial	denial	NN
18637	20109	38	of	of	IN
18637	20109	39	due	due	JJ
18637	20109	40	process	process	NN
18637	20109	41	.	.	.
18637	20110	1	A	a	DT
18637	20110	2	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	20110	3	on	on	IN
18637	20110	4	the	the	DT
18637	20110	5	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	20110	6	,	,	,
18637	20110	7	however	however	RB
18637	20110	8	,	,	,
18637	20110	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	20110	10	all	all	PDT
18637	20110	11	an	an	DT
18637	20110	12	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	20110	13	can	can	MD
18637	20110	14	claim	claim	VB
18637	20110	15	;	;	:
18637	20110	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20110	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	20110	18	not	not	RB
18637	20110	19	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	20110	20	to	to	IN
18637	20110	21	a	a	DT
18637	20110	22	set	set	NN
18637	20110	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	20110	24	up	up	RP
18637	20110	25	that	that	WDT
18637	20110	26	will	will	MD
18637	20110	27	give	give	VB
18637	20110	28	a	a	DT
18637	20110	29	chance	chance	NN
18637	20110	30	of	of	IN
18637	20110	31	escape	escape	NN
18637	20110	32	after	after	IN
18637	20110	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20110	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	20110	35	properly	properly	RB
18637	20110	36	proven	prove	VBN
18637	20110	37	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	20110	38	.	.	.
18637	20111	1	Society	society	NN
18637	20111	2	also	also	RB
18637	20111	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	20111	4	a	a	DT
18637	20111	5	right	right	NN
18637	20111	6	to	to	IN
18637	20111	7	a	a	DT
18637	20111	8	fair	fair	JJ
18637	20111	9	trial	trial	NN
18637	20111	10	.	.	.
18637	20112	1	The	the	DT
18637	20112	2	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	20112	3	's	's	POS
18637	20112	4	right	right	NN
18637	20112	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	20112	6	a	a	DT
18637	20112	7	neutral	neutral	JJ
18637	20112	8	jury	jury	NN
18637	20112	9	.	.	.
18637	20113	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20113	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	20113	3	no	no	DT
18637	20113	4	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	20113	5	right	right	NN
18637	20113	6	to	to	IN
18637	20113	7	friends	friend	NNS
18637	20113	8	on	on	IN
18637	20113	9	the	the	DT
18637	20113	10	jury	jury	NN
18637	20113	11	.	.	.
18637	20114	1	"	"	``
18637	20114	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20114	3	1216	1216	CD
18637	20114	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20114	5	APPORTIONMENT	APPORTIONMENT	NNP
18637	20114	6	OF	of	IN
18637	20114	7	REPRESENTATION	REPRESENTATION	NNP
18637	20114	8	Section	section	NN
18637	20114	9	2	2	CD
18637	20114	10	.	.	.
18637	20115	1	Representatives	representative	NNS
18637	20115	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	20115	3	be	be	VB
18637	20115	4	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	20115	5	among	among	IN
18637	20115	6	the	the	DT
18637	20115	7	several	several	JJ
18637	20115	8	States	state	NNS
18637	20115	9	according	accord	VBG
18637	20115	10	to	to	IN
18637	20115	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20115	12	respective	respective	JJ
18637	20115	13	numbers	number	NNS
18637	20115	14	,	,	,
18637	20115	15	counting	count	VBG
18637	20115	16	the	the	DT
18637	20115	17	whole	whole	JJ
18637	20115	18	number	number	NN
18637	20115	19	of	of	IN
18637	20115	20	persons	person	NNS
18637	20115	21	in	in	IN
18637	20115	22	each	each	DT
18637	20115	23	State	state	NN
18637	20115	24	,	,	,
18637	20115	25	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	20115	26	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	20115	27	not	not	RB
18637	20115	28	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	20115	29	.	.	.
18637	20116	1	But	but	CC
18637	20116	2	when	when	WRB
18637	20116	3	the	the	DT
18637	20116	4	right	right	NN
18637	20116	5	to	to	TO
18637	20116	6	vote	vote	VB
18637	20116	7	at	at	IN
18637	20116	8	any	any	DT
18637	20116	9	election	election	NN
18637	20116	10	for	for	IN
18637	20116	11	the	the	DT
18637	20116	12	choice	choice	NN
18637	20116	13	of	of	IN
18637	20116	14	electors	elector	NNS
18637	20116	15	for	for	IN
18637	20116	16	President	President	NNP
18637	20116	17	and	and	CC
18637	20116	18	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	20116	19	President	President	NNP
18637	20116	20	of	of	IN
18637	20116	21	the	the	DT
18637	20116	22	United	United	NNP
18637	20116	23	States	States	NNP
18637	20116	24	,	,	,
18637	20116	25	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	20116	26	in	in	IN
18637	20116	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20116	28	,	,	,
18637	20116	29	the	the	DT
18637	20116	30	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	20116	31	and	and	CC
18637	20116	32	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	20116	33	officers	officer	NNS
18637	20116	34	of	of	IN
18637	20116	35	a	a	DT
18637	20116	36	State	state	NN
18637	20116	37	,	,	,
18637	20116	38	or	or	CC
18637	20116	39	the	the	DT
18637	20116	40	members	member	NNS
18637	20116	41	of	of	IN
18637	20116	42	the	the	DT
18637	20116	43	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	20116	44	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	20116	45	,	,	,
18637	20116	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	20116	47	denied	deny	VBN
18637	20116	48	to	to	IN
18637	20116	49	any	any	DT
18637	20116	50	of	of	IN
18637	20116	51	the	the	DT
18637	20116	52	male	male	JJ
18637	20116	53	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	20116	54	of	of	IN
18637	20116	55	such	such	JJ
18637	20116	56	State	State	NNP
18637	20116	57	,	,	,
18637	20116	58	being	be	VBG
18637	20116	59	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	20116	60	-	-	HYPH
18637	20116	61	one	one	CD
18637	20116	62	years	year	NNS
18637	20116	63	of	of	IN
18637	20116	64	age	age	NN
18637	20116	65	,	,	,
18637	20116	66	and	and	CC
18637	20116	67	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20116	68	of	of	IN
18637	20116	69	the	the	DT
18637	20116	70	United	United	NNP
18637	20116	71	States	States	NNP
18637	20116	72	,	,	,
18637	20116	73	or	or	CC
18637	20116	74	in	in	IN
18637	20116	75	any	any	DT
18637	20116	76	way	way	NN
18637	20116	77	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	20116	78	,	,	,
18637	20116	79	except	except	IN
18637	20116	80	for	for	IN
18637	20116	81	participation	participation	NN
18637	20116	82	in	in	IN
18637	20116	83	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	20116	84	,	,	,
18637	20116	85	or	or	CC
18637	20116	86	other	other	JJ
18637	20116	87	crime	crime	NN
18637	20116	88	,	,	,
18637	20116	89	the	the	DT
18637	20116	90	basis	basis	NN
18637	20116	91	of	of	IN
18637	20116	92	representation	representation	NN
18637	20116	93	therein	therein	RB
18637	20116	94	shall	shall	MD
18637	20116	95	be	be	VB
18637	20116	96	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	20116	97	in	in	IN
18637	20116	98	the	the	DT
18637	20116	99	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	20116	100	which	which	WDT
18637	20116	101	the	the	DT
18637	20116	102	number	number	NN
18637	20116	103	of	of	IN
18637	20116	104	such	such	JJ
18637	20116	105	male	male	JJ
18637	20116	106	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20116	107	shall	shall	MD
18637	20116	108	bear	bear	VB
18637	20116	109	to	to	IN
18637	20116	110	the	the	DT
18637	20116	111	whole	whole	JJ
18637	20116	112	number	number	NN
18637	20116	113	of	of	IN
18637	20116	114	male	male	JJ
18637	20116	115	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20116	116	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	20116	117	-	-	HYPH
18637	20116	118	one	one	CD
18637	20116	119	years	year	NNS
18637	20116	120	of	of	IN
18637	20116	121	age	age	NN
18637	20116	122	in	in	IN
18637	20116	123	such	such	JJ
18637	20116	124	State	state	NN
18637	20116	125	.	.	.
18637	20117	1	In	in	IN
18637	20117	2	General	General	NNP
18637	20117	3	The	the	DT
18637	20117	4	effect	effect	NN
18637	20117	5	of	of	IN
18637	20117	6	this	this	DT
18637	20117	7	section	section	NN
18637	20117	8	in	in	IN
18637	20117	9	relation	relation	NN
18637	20117	10	to	to	IN
18637	20117	11	Negroes	Negroes	NNP
18637	20117	12	was	be	VBD
18637	20117	13	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	20117	14	in	in	IN
18637	20117	15	Elk	Elk	NNP
18637	20117	16	_	_	NNP
18637	20117	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	20117	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20117	19	Wilkins	Wilkins	NNP
18637	20117	20	.	.	.
18637	20118	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20118	2	1217	1217	CD
18637	20118	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20118	4	"	"	``
18637	20118	5	Slavery	slavery	NN
18637	20118	6	having	have	VBG
18637	20118	7	been	be	VBN
18637	20118	8	abolished	abolish	VBN
18637	20118	9	,	,	,
18637	20118	10	and	and	CC
18637	20118	11	the	the	DT
18637	20118	12	persons	person	NNS
18637	20118	13	formerly	formerly	RB
18637	20118	14	held	hold	VBN
18637	20118	15	as	as	IN
18637	20118	16	slaves	slave	NNS
18637	20118	17	made	make	VBD
18637	20118	18	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20118	19	,	,	,
18637	20118	20	this	this	DT
18637	20118	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	20118	22	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	20118	23	the	the	DT
18637	20118	24	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	20118	25	of	of	IN
18637	20118	26	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	20118	27	has	have	VBZ
18637	20118	28	abrogated	abrogate	VBN
18637	20118	29	so	so	RB
18637	20118	30	much	much	JJ
18637	20118	31	of	of	IN
18637	20118	32	*	*	NFP
18637	20118	33	*	*	NFP
18637	20118	34	*	*	NFP
18637	20118	35	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20118	36	Article	article	NN
18637	20118	37	I	i	NN
18637	20118	38	,	,	,
18637	20118	39	§	§	NNP
18637	20118	40	2	2	CD
18637	20118	41	,	,	,
18637	20118	42	cl	cl	UH
18637	20118	43	.	.	.
18637	20119	1	3	3	LS
18637	20119	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20119	3	of	of	IN
18637	20119	4	the	the	DT
18637	20119	5	*	*	NFP
18637	20119	6	*	*	NFP
18637	20119	7	*	*	NFP
18637	20119	8	original	original	JJ
18637	20119	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	20119	10	as	as	IN
18637	20119	11	counted	count	VBN
18637	20119	12	only	only	RB
18637	20119	13	three	three	CD
18637	20119	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	20119	15	fifths	fifth	NNS
18637	20119	16	of	of	IN
18637	20119	17	such	such	JJ
18637	20119	18	persons	person	NNS
18637	20119	19	.	.	.
18637	20119	20	"	"	''
18637	20120	1	"	"	``
18637	20120	2	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	20120	3	Not	not	RB
18637	20120	4	Taxed	tax	VBN
18637	20120	5	"	"	''
18637	20120	6	Although	although	IN
18637	20120	7	one	one	CD
18637	20120	8	authority	authority	NN
18637	20120	9	on	on	IN
18637	20120	10	the	the	DT
18637	20120	11	legal	legal	JJ
18637	20120	12	status	status	NN
18637	20120	13	of	of	IN
18637	20120	14	the	the	DT
18637	20120	15	American	American	NNP
18637	20120	16	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	20120	17	observed	observe	VBD
18637	20120	18	that	that	IN
18637	20120	19	this	this	DT
18637	20120	20	"	"	``
18637	20120	21	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	22	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	23	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	24	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	20120	25	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20120	26	was	be	VBD
18637	20120	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20120	28	never	never	RB
18637	20120	29	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	30	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	31	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	32	more	more	RBR
18637	20120	33	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	20120	34	defined	define	VBN
18637	20120	35	,	,	,
18637	20120	36	but	but	CC
18637	20120	37	probably	probably	RB
18637	20120	38	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	39	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	40	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	41	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20120	42	meant	mean	VBN
18637	20120	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20120	44	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	45	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	46	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	47	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	20120	48	resident	resident	NN
18637	20120	49	on	on	IN
18637	20120	50	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	20120	51	,	,	,
18637	20120	52	that	that	RB
18637	20120	53	is	is	RB
18637	20120	54	,	,	,
18637	20120	55	on	on	IN
18637	20120	56	land	land	NN
18637	20120	57	not	not	RB
18637	20120	58	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	20120	59	by	by	IN
18637	20120	60	the	the	DT
18637	20120	61	States,"[1218	states,"[1218	XX
18637	20120	62	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20120	63	the	the	DT
18637	20120	64	United	United	NNP
18637	20120	65	States	States	NNP
18637	20120	66	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	20120	67	General	General	NNP
18637	20120	68	,	,	,
18637	20120	69	in	in	IN
18637	20120	70	1940	1940	CD
18637	20120	71	,	,	,
18637	20120	72	commented	comment	VBD
18637	20120	73	as	as	IN
18637	20120	74	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	20120	75	upon	upon	IN
18637	20120	76	the	the	DT
18637	20120	77	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	20120	78	of	of	IN
18637	20120	79	arriving	arrive	VBG
18637	20120	80	at	at	IN
18637	20120	81	any	any	DT
18637	20120	82	satisfactory	satisfactory	JJ
18637	20120	83	construction	construction	NN
18637	20120	84	of	of	IN
18637	20120	85	these	these	DT
18637	20120	86	words	word	NNS
18637	20120	87	:	:	:
18637	20120	88	"	"	``
18637	20120	89	Whether	whether	IN
18637	20120	90	the	the	DT
18637	20120	91	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	20120	92	'	'	``
18637	20120	93	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	20120	94	not	not	RB
18637	20120	95	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	20120	96	'	'	POS
18637	20120	97	refers	refer	NNS
18637	20120	98	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20120	99	1	1	CD
18637	20120	100	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20120	101	to	to	IN
18637	20120	102	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	20120	103	not	not	RB
18637	20120	104	actually	actually	RB
18637	20120	105	paying	pay	VBG
18637	20120	106	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	20120	107	or	or	CC
18637	20120	108	only	only	RB
18637	20120	109	to	to	IN
18637	20120	110	those	those	DT
18637	20120	111	who	who	WP
18637	20120	112	are	be	VBP
18637	20120	113	not	not	RB
18637	20120	114	subject	subject	JJ
18637	20120	115	to	to	IN
18637	20120	116	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	20120	117	and	and	CC
18637	20120	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20120	119	2	2	LS
18637	20120	120	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20120	121	to	to	IN
18637	20120	122	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	20120	123	not	not	RB
18637	20120	124	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	20120	125	or	or	CC
18637	20120	126	subject	subject	JJ
18637	20120	127	to	to	IN
18637	20120	128	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	20120	129	by	by	IN
18637	20120	130	any	any	DT
18637	20120	131	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	20120	132	authority	authority	NN
18637	20120	133	or	or	CC
18637	20120	134	only	only	RB
18637	20120	135	to	to	IN
18637	20120	136	those	those	DT
18637	20120	137	not	not	RB
18637	20120	138	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	20120	139	or	or	CC
18637	20120	140	subject	subject	JJ
18637	20120	141	to	to	IN
18637	20120	142	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	20120	143	by	by	IN
18637	20120	144	the	the	DT
18637	20120	145	States	States	NNP
18637	20120	146	in	in	IN
18637	20120	147	which	which	WDT
18637	20120	148	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20120	149	reside	reside	VBP
18637	20120	150	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	151	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	152	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	153	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20120	154	presents	present	NNS
18637	20120	155	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20120	156	questions	question	NNS
18637	20120	157	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	158	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	159	*	*	NFP
18637	20120	160	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20120	161	which	which	WDT
18637	20120	162	have	have	VBP
18637	20120	163	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20120	164	been	be	VBN
18637	20120	165	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	20120	166	in	in	IN
18637	20120	167	a	a	DT
18637	20120	168	number	number	NN
18637	20120	169	of	of	IN
18637	20120	170	court	court	NN
18637	20120	171	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	20120	172	but	but	CC
18637	20120	173	the	the	DT
18637	20120	174	issue	issue	NN
18637	20120	175	has	have	VBZ
18637	20120	176	never	never	RB
18637	20120	177	been	be	VBN
18637	20120	178	squarely	squarely	RB
18637	20120	179	raised	raise	VBN
18637	20120	180	in	in	IN
18637	20120	181	any	any	DT
18637	20120	182	of	of	IN
18637	20120	183	the	the	DT
18637	20120	184	decided	decide	VBN
18637	20120	185	cases	case	NNS
18637	20120	186	.	.	.
18637	20121	1	Some	some	DT
18637	20121	2	of	of	IN
18637	20121	3	the	the	DT
18637	20121	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	20121	5	and	and	CC
18637	20121	6	some	some	DT
18637	20121	7	statements	statement	NNS
18637	20121	8	appearing	appear	VBG
18637	20121	9	in	in	IN
18637	20121	10	the	the	DT
18637	20121	11	debates	debate	NNS
18637	20121	12	in	in	IN
18637	20121	13	the	the	DT
18637	20121	14	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	20121	15	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	20121	16	lend	lend	VB
18637	20121	17	support	support	NN
18637	20121	18	to	to	IN
18637	20121	19	the	the	DT
18637	20121	20	view	view	NN
18637	20121	21	that	that	IN
18637	20121	22	since	since	IN
18637	20121	23	all	all	DT
18637	20121	24	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	20121	25	are	be	VBP
18637	20121	26	now	now	RB
18637	20121	27	subject	subject	JJ
18637	20121	28	to	to	IN
18637	20121	29	the	the	DT
18637	20121	30	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	20121	31	income	income	NN
18637	20121	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	20121	33	tax	tax	NN
18637	20121	34	laws	law	NNS
18637	20121	35	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20121	36	Superintendent	Superintendent	NNP
18637	20121	37	_	_	NNP
18637	20121	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	20121	39	_	_	NNP
18637	20121	40	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	20121	41	,	,	,
18637	20121	42	295	295	CD
18637	20121	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20121	44	418	418	CD
18637	20121	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20121	46	1935	1935	CD
18637	20121	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20121	48	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20121	49	there	there	EX
18637	20121	50	are	be	VBP
18637	20121	51	no	no	RB
18637	20121	52	longer	long	RBR
18637	20121	53	any	any	DT
18637	20121	54	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	20121	55	not	not	RB
18637	20121	56	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	20121	57	within	within	IN
18637	20121	58	the	the	DT
18637	20121	59	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	20121	60	of	of	IN
18637	20121	61	the	the	DT
18637	20121	62	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	20121	63	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	20121	64	.	.	.
18637	20122	1	On	on	IN
18637	20122	2	the	the	DT
18637	20122	3	other	other	JJ
18637	20122	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	20122	5	,	,	,
18637	20122	6	other	other	JJ
18637	20122	7	decided	decide	VBN
18637	20122	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	20122	9	and	and	CC
18637	20122	10	other	other	JJ
18637	20122	11	statements	statement	NNS
18637	20122	12	appearing	appear	VBG
18637	20122	13	in	in	IN
18637	20122	14	the	the	DT
18637	20122	15	debates	debate	NNS
18637	20122	16	in	in	IN
18637	20122	17	the	the	DT
18637	20122	18	Convention	Convention	NNP
18637	20122	19	equally	equally	RB
18637	20122	20	support	support	VBP
18637	20122	21	the	the	DT
18637	20122	22	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	20122	23	view	view	NN
18637	20122	24	.	.	.
18637	20123	1	*	*	NFP
18637	20123	2	*	*	NFP
18637	20123	3	*	*	NFP
18637	20123	4	,	,	,
18637	20123	5	the	the	DT
18637	20123	6	answer	answer	NN
18637	20123	7	to	to	IN
18637	20123	8	*	*	NFP
18637	20123	9	*	*	NFP
18637	20123	10	*	*	NFP
18637	20123	11	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20123	12	these	these	DT
18637	20123	13	questions	question	NNS
18637	20123	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20123	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	20123	16	not	not	RB
18637	20123	17	free	free	JJ
18637	20123	18	from	from	IN
18637	20123	19	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	20123	20	.	.	.
18637	20124	1	"	"	``
18637	20124	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20124	3	1219	1219	CD
18637	20124	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20124	5	As	as	IN
18637	20124	6	to	to	IN
18637	20124	7	the	the	DT
18637	20124	8	latest	late	JJS
18637	20124	9	construction	construction	NN
18637	20124	10	which	which	WDT
18637	20124	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20124	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	20124	13	given	give	VBN
18637	20124	14	to	to	IN
18637	20124	15	this	this	DT
18637	20124	16	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	20124	17	in	in	IN
18637	20124	18	apportioning	apportion	VBG
18637	20124	19	seats	seat	NNS
18637	20124	20	in	in	IN
18637	20124	21	the	the	DT
18637	20124	22	House	House	NNP
18637	20124	23	of	of	IN
18637	20124	24	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	20124	25	,	,	,
18637	20124	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20124	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	20124	28	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
18637	20124	29	to	to	TO
18637	20124	30	note	note	VB
18637	20124	31	that	that	IN
18637	20124	32	the	the	DT
18637	20124	33	Apportionment	Apportionment	NNP
18637	20124	34	Act	Act	NNP
18637	20124	35	of	of	IN
18637	20124	36	1929	1929	CD
18637	20124	37	,	,	,
18637	20124	38	at	at	IN
18637	20124	39	last	last	JJ
18637	20124	40	amended	amend	VBN
18637	20124	41	in	in	IN
18637	20124	42	1941,[1220	1941,[1220	CD
18637	20124	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20124	44	excludes	exclude	NNS
18637	20124	45	"	"	``
18637	20124	46	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	20124	47	not	not	RB
18637	20124	48	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	20124	49	"	"	''
18637	20124	50	from	from	IN
18637	20124	51	the	the	DT
18637	20124	52	computation	computation	NN
18637	20124	53	of	of	IN
18637	20124	54	the	the	DT
18637	20124	55	total	total	JJ
18637	20124	56	population	population	NN
18637	20124	57	of	of	IN
18637	20124	58	each	each	DT
18637	20124	59	State	State	NNP
18637	20124	60	.	.	.
18637	20125	1	However	however	RB
18637	20125	2	,	,	,
18637	20125	3	in	in	IN
18637	20125	4	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	20125	5	on	on	IN
18637	20125	6	the	the	DT
18637	20125	7	above	above	RB
18637	20125	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	20125	9	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	20125	10	decision	decision	NN
18637	20125	11	that	that	IN
18637	20125	12	all	all	DT
18637	20125	13	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	20125	14	are	be	VBP
18637	20125	15	now	now	RB
18637	20125	16	subject	subject	JJ
18637	20125	17	to	to	IN
18637	20125	18	federal	federal	JJ
18637	20125	19	income	income	NN
18637	20125	20	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	20125	21	,	,	,
18637	20125	22	the	the	DT
18637	20125	23	Director	Director	NNP
18637	20125	24	of	of	IN
18637	20125	25	the	the	DT
18637	20125	26	Census	Census	NNP
18637	20125	27	included	include	VBD
18637	20125	28	all	all	DT
18637	20125	29	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	20125	30	in	in	IN
18637	20125	31	the	the	DT
18637	20125	32	1940	1940	CD
18637	20125	33	tabulation	tabulation	NN
18637	20125	34	of	of	IN
18637	20125	35	total	total	JJ
18637	20125	36	population	population	NN
18637	20125	37	in	in	IN
18637	20125	38	each	each	DT
18637	20125	39	State	State	NNP
18637	20125	40	,	,	,
18637	20125	41	and	and	CC
18637	20125	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20125	43	took	take	VBD
18637	20125	44	no	no	DT
18637	20125	45	action	action	NN
18637	20125	46	to	to	TO
18637	20125	47	alter	alter	VB
18637	20125	48	the	the	DT
18637	20125	49	effects	effect	NNS
18637	20125	50	which	which	WDT
18637	20125	51	such	such	JJ
18637	20125	52	inclusion	inclusion	NN
18637	20125	53	had	have	VBD
18637	20125	54	upon	upon	IN
18637	20125	55	the	the	DT
18637	20125	56	number	number	NN
18637	20125	57	of	of	IN
18637	20125	58	seats	seat	NNS
18637	20125	59	distributed	distribute	VBN
18637	20125	60	to	to	IN
18637	20125	61	the	the	DT
18637	20125	62	several	several	JJ
18637	20125	63	States	state	NNS
18637	20125	64	.	.	.
18637	20126	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20126	2	1221	1221	CD
18637	20126	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20126	4	Right	right	UH
18637	20126	5	to	to	TO
18637	20126	6	Vote	vote	VB
18637	20126	7	The	the	DT
18637	20126	8	right	right	NN
18637	20126	9	to	to	TO
18637	20126	10	vote	vote	VB
18637	20126	11	intended	intend	VBN
18637	20126	12	to	to	TO
18637	20126	13	be	be	VB
18637	20126	14	protected	protect	VBN
18637	20126	15	refers	refer	NNS
18637	20126	16	to	to	IN
18637	20126	17	the	the	DT
18637	20126	18	right	right	NN
18637	20126	19	to	to	TO
18637	20126	20	vote	vote	VB
18637	20126	21	as	as	IN
18637	20126	22	established	establish	VBN
18637	20126	23	by	by	IN
18637	20126	24	the	the	DT
18637	20126	25	laws	law	NNS
18637	20126	26	and	and	CC
18637	20126	27	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	20126	28	of	of	IN
18637	20126	29	the	the	DT
18637	20126	30	State	State	NNP
18637	20126	31	;	;	:
18637	20126	32	subject	subject	JJ
18637	20126	33	,	,	,
18637	20126	34	however	however	RB
18637	20126	35	,	,	,
18637	20126	36	to	to	IN
18637	20126	37	the	the	DT
18637	20126	38	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	20126	39	that	that	IN
18637	20126	40	the	the	DT
18637	20126	41	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	20126	42	,	,	,
18637	20126	43	in	in	IN
18637	20126	44	article	article	NN
18637	20126	45	I	i	NN
18637	20126	46	,	,	,
18637	20126	47	section	section	NN
18637	20126	48	2	2	CD
18637	20126	49	,	,	,
18637	20126	50	adopts	adopt	VBZ
18637	20126	51	as	as	IN
18637	20126	52	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	20126	53	for	for	IN
18637	20126	54	voting	vote	VBG
18637	20126	55	for	for	IN
18637	20126	56	members	member	NNS
18637	20126	57	of	of	IN
18637	20126	58	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20126	59	those	those	DT
18637	20126	60	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	20126	61	established	establish	VBN
18637	20126	62	by	by	IN
18637	20126	63	the	the	DT
18637	20126	64	States	States	NNP
18637	20126	65	for	for	IN
18637	20126	66	voting	vote	VBG
18637	20126	67	for	for	IN
18637	20126	68	the	the	DT
18637	20126	69	most	most	RBS
18637	20126	70	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	20126	71	branch	branch	NN
18637	20126	72	of	of	IN
18637	20126	73	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20126	74	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	20126	75	.	.	.
18637	20127	1	To	to	IN
18637	20127	2	the	the	DT
18637	20127	3	latter	latter	JJ
18637	20127	4	extent	extent	NN
18637	20127	5	the	the	DT
18637	20127	6	right	right	NN
18637	20127	7	to	to	TO
18637	20127	8	vote	vote	VB
18637	20127	9	for	for	IN
18637	20127	10	members	member	NNS
18637	20127	11	of	of	IN
18637	20127	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20127	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	20127	14	been	be	VBN
18637	20127	15	declared	declare	VBN
18637	20127	16	to	to	TO
18637	20127	17	be	be	VB
18637	20127	18	fundamentally	fundamentally	RB
18637	20127	19	based	base	VBN
18637	20127	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	20127	21	the	the	DT
18637	20127	22	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	20127	23	and	and	CC
18637	20127	24	as	as	IN
18637	20127	25	never	never	RB
18637	20127	26	having	have	VBG
18637	20127	27	been	be	VBN
18637	20127	28	intended	intend	VBN
18637	20127	29	to	to	TO
18637	20127	30	be	be	VB
18637	20127	31	left	leave	VBN
18637	20127	32	within	within	IN
18637	20127	33	the	the	DT
18637	20127	34	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	20127	35	control	control	NN
18637	20127	36	of	of	IN
18637	20127	37	the	the	DT
18637	20127	38	States	States	NNP
18637	20127	39	.	.	.
18637	20128	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20128	2	1222	1222	CD
18637	20128	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20128	4	Reduction	Reduction	NNP
18637	20128	5	of	of	IN
18637	20128	6	State	State	NNP
18637	20128	7	's	's	POS
18637	20128	8	Representation	Representation	NNP
18637	20128	9	"	"	''
18637	20128	10	Questions	Questions	NNPS
18637	20128	11	relating	relate	VBG
18637	20128	12	to	to	IN
18637	20128	13	the	the	DT
18637	20128	14	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	20128	15	of	of	IN
18637	20128	16	representatives	representative	NNS
18637	20128	17	among	among	IN
18637	20128	18	the	the	DT
18637	20128	19	several	several	JJ
18637	20128	20	States	state	NNS
18637	20128	21	are	be	VBP
18637	20128	22	political	political	JJ
18637	20128	23	in	in	IN
18637	20128	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20128	25	nature	nature	NN
18637	20128	26	and	and	CC
18637	20128	27	reside	reside	VB
18637	20128	28	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	20128	29	within	within	IN
18637	20128	30	the	the	DT
18637	20128	31	determination	determination	NN
18637	20128	32	of	of	IN
18637	20128	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20128	34	*	*	NFP
18637	20128	35	*	*	NFP
18637	20128	36	*	*	NFP
18637	20128	37	"	"	``
18637	20128	38	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	20128	39	,	,	,
18637	20128	40	a	a	DT
18637	20128	41	United	United	NNP
18637	20128	42	States	States	NNP
18637	20128	43	District	District	NNP
18637	20128	44	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20128	45	was	be	VBD
18637	20128	46	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	20128	47	to	to	TO
18637	20128	48	dismiss	dismiss	VB
18637	20128	49	an	an	DT
18637	20128	50	action	action	NN
18637	20128	51	for	for	IN
18637	20128	52	damages	damage	NNS
18637	20128	53	against	against	IN
18637	20128	54	the	the	DT
18637	20128	55	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	20128	56	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	20128	57	of	of	IN
18637	20128	58	State	State	NNP
18637	20128	59	for	for	IN
18637	20128	60	the	the	DT
18637	20128	61	latter	latter	NN
18637	20128	62	's	's	POS
18637	20128	63	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	20128	64	to	to	TO
18637	20128	65	certify	certify	VB
18637	20128	66	the	the	DT
18637	20128	67	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	20128	68	as	as	IN
18637	20128	69	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	20128	70	for	for	IN
18637	20128	71	the	the	DT
18637	20128	72	office	office	NN
18637	20128	73	of	of	IN
18637	20128	74	Congressman	Congressman	NNP
18637	20128	75	at	at	IN
18637	20128	76	large	large	JJ
18637	20128	77	,	,	,
18637	20128	78	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	20128	79	as	as	IN
18637	20128	80	the	the	DT
18637	20128	81	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	20128	82	's	's	POS
18637	20128	83	case	case	NN
18637	20128	84	rested	rest	VBN
18637	20128	85	on	on	IN
18637	20128	86	the	the	DT
18637	20128	87	theory	theory	NN
18637	20128	88	that	that	IN
18637	20128	89	the	the	DT
18637	20128	90	apportionment	apportionment	JJ
18637	20128	91	act	act	NN
18637	20128	92	of	of	IN
18637	20128	93	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20128	94	and	and	CC
18637	20128	95	the	the	DT
18637	20128	96	Redistricting	Redistricting	NNP
18637	20128	97	Act	Act	NNP
18637	20128	98	of	of	IN
18637	20128	99	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	20128	100	,	,	,
18637	20128	101	by	by	IN
18637	20128	102	failing	fail	VBG
18637	20128	103	to	to	TO
18637	20128	104	take	take	VB
18637	20128	105	into	into	IN
18637	20128	106	account	account	NN
18637	20128	107	the	the	DT
18637	20128	108	disenfranchisement	disenfranchisement	NN
18637	20128	109	of	of	IN
18637	20128	110	60	60	CD
18637	20128	111	%	%	NN
18637	20128	112	of	of	IN
18637	20128	113	the	the	DT
18637	20128	114	voters	voter	NNS
18637	20128	115	occasioned	occasion	VBN
18637	20128	116	by	by	IN
18637	20128	117	the	the	DT
18637	20128	118	poll	poll	NN
18637	20128	119	tax	tax	NN
18637	20128	120	,	,	,
18637	20128	121	were	be	VBD
18637	20128	122	both	both	CC
18637	20128	123	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	20128	124	,	,	,
18637	20128	125	and	and	CC
18637	20128	126	that	that	IN
18637	20128	127	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	20128	128	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	20128	129	was	be	VBD
18637	20128	130	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	20128	131	to	to	IN
18637	20128	132	only	only	RB
18637	20128	133	four	four	CD
18637	20128	134	instead	instead	RB
18637	20128	135	of	of	IN
18637	20128	136	nine	nine	CD
18637	20128	137	Congressmen	Congressmen	NNPS
18637	20128	138	,	,	,
18637	20128	139	which	which	WDT
18637	20128	140	four	four	CD
18637	20128	141	were	be	VBD
18637	20128	142	to	to	TO
18637	20128	143	be	be	VB
18637	20128	144	elected	elect	VBN
18637	20128	145	at	at	IN
18637	20128	146	large	large	JJ
18637	20128	147	.	.	.
18637	20129	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20129	2	1223	1223	CD
18637	20129	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20129	4	"	"	``
18637	20129	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20129	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	20129	7	well	well	RB
18637	20129	8	known	know	VBN
18637	20129	9	that	that	IN
18637	20129	10	the	the	DT
18637	20129	11	elective	elective	JJ
18637	20129	12	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	20129	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	20129	14	been	be	VBN
18637	20129	15	limited	limit	VBN
18637	20129	16	or	or	CC
18637	20129	17	denied	deny	VBN
18637	20129	18	to	to	IN
18637	20129	19	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20129	20	in	in	IN
18637	20129	21	various	various	JJ
18637	20129	22	States	state	NNS
18637	20129	23	of	of	IN
18637	20129	24	the	the	DT
18637	20129	25	union	union	NN
18637	20129	26	in	in	IN
18637	20129	27	past	past	JJ
18637	20129	28	years	year	NNS
18637	20129	29	,	,	,
18637	20129	30	but	but	CC
18637	20129	31	no	no	DT
18637	20129	32	serious	serious	JJ
18637	20129	33	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	20129	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	20129	35	been	be	VBN
18637	20129	36	made	make	VBN
18637	20129	37	by	by	IN
18637	20129	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20129	39	to	to	TO
18637	20129	40	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	20129	41	the	the	DT
18637	20129	42	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	20129	43	of	of	IN
18637	20129	44	the	the	DT
18637	20129	45	second	second	JJ
18637	20129	46	section	section	NN
18637	20129	47	of	of	IN
18637	20129	48	the	the	DT
18637	20129	49	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	20129	50	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20129	51	,	,	,
18637	20129	52	and	and	CC
18637	20129	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20129	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	20129	55	noteworthy	noteworthy	JJ
18637	20129	56	that	that	IN
18637	20129	57	there	there	EX
18637	20129	58	are	be	VBP
18637	20129	59	no	no	DT
18637	20129	60	instances	instance	NNS
18637	20129	61	in	in	IN
18637	20129	62	which	which	WDT
18637	20129	63	the	the	DT
18637	20129	64	courts	court	NNS
18637	20129	65	have	have	VBP
18637	20129	66	attempted	attempt	VBN
18637	20129	67	to	to	TO
18637	20129	68	revise	revise	VB
18637	20129	69	the	the	DT
18637	20129	70	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	20129	71	of	of	IN
18637	20129	72	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	20129	73	by	by	IN
18637	20129	74	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20129	75	.	.	.
18637	20130	1	"	"	``
18637	20130	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20130	3	1224	1224	CD
18637	20130	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20130	5	DISQUALIFICATION	disqualification	NN
18637	20130	6	OF	of	IN
18637	20130	7	OFFICERS	OFFICERS	NNP
18637	20130	8	Section	Section	NNP
18637	20130	9	3	3	CD
18637	20130	10	.	.	.
18637	20131	1	No	no	DT
18637	20131	2	Person	person	NN
18637	20131	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	20131	4	be	be	VB
18637	20131	5	a	a	DT
18637	20131	6	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	20131	7	or	or	CC
18637	20131	8	Representative	Representative	NNP
18637	20131	9	in	in	IN
18637	20131	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20131	11	,	,	,
18637	20131	12	or	or	CC
18637	20131	13	elector	elector	NN
18637	20131	14	of	of	IN
18637	20131	15	President	President	NNP
18637	20131	16	and	and	CC
18637	20131	17	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	20131	18	President	President	NNP
18637	20131	19	,	,	,
18637	20131	20	or	or	CC
18637	20131	21	hold	hold	VB
18637	20131	22	any	any	DT
18637	20131	23	office	office	NN
18637	20131	24	,	,	,
18637	20131	25	civil	civil	JJ
18637	20131	26	or	or	CC
18637	20131	27	military	military	JJ
18637	20131	28	,	,	,
18637	20131	29	under	under	IN
18637	20131	30	the	the	DT
18637	20131	31	United	United	NNP
18637	20131	32	States	States	NNP
18637	20131	33	,	,	,
18637	20131	34	or	or	CC
18637	20131	35	under	under	IN
18637	20131	36	any	any	DT
18637	20131	37	State	State	NNP
18637	20131	38	,	,	,
18637	20131	39	who	who	WP
18637	20131	40	,	,	,
18637	20131	41	having	have	VBG
18637	20131	42	previously	previously	RB
18637	20131	43	taken	take	VBN
18637	20131	44	an	an	DT
18637	20131	45	oath	oath	NN
18637	20131	46	,	,	,
18637	20131	47	as	as	IN
18637	20131	48	a	a	DT
18637	20131	49	member	member	NN
18637	20131	50	of	of	IN
18637	20131	51	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20131	52	,	,	,
18637	20131	53	or	or	CC
18637	20131	54	as	as	IN
18637	20131	55	an	an	DT
18637	20131	56	officer	officer	NN
18637	20131	57	of	of	IN
18637	20131	58	the	the	DT
18637	20131	59	United	United	NNP
18637	20131	60	States	States	NNP
18637	20131	61	,	,	,
18637	20131	62	or	or	CC
18637	20131	63	as	as	IN
18637	20131	64	a	a	DT
18637	20131	65	member	member	NN
18637	20131	66	of	of	IN
18637	20131	67	any	any	DT
18637	20131	68	State	State	NNP
18637	20131	69	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	20131	70	,	,	,
18637	20131	71	or	or	CC
18637	20131	72	as	as	IN
18637	20131	73	an	an	DT
18637	20131	74	executive	executive	JJ
18637	20131	75	or	or	CC
18637	20131	76	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	20131	77	officer	officer	NN
18637	20131	78	of	of	IN
18637	20131	79	any	any	DT
18637	20131	80	State	State	NNP
18637	20131	81	,	,	,
18637	20131	82	to	to	TO
18637	20131	83	support	support	VB
18637	20131	84	the	the	DT
18637	20131	85	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	20131	86	of	of	IN
18637	20131	87	the	the	DT
18637	20131	88	United	United	NNP
18637	20131	89	States	States	NNP
18637	20131	90	,	,	,
18637	20131	91	shall	shall	MD
18637	20131	92	have	have	VB
18637	20131	93	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	20131	94	in	in	IN
18637	20131	95	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	20131	96	or	or	CC
18637	20131	97	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	20131	98	against	against	IN
18637	20131	99	the	the	DT
18637	20131	100	same	same	JJ
18637	20131	101	,	,	,
18637	20131	102	or	or	CC
18637	20131	103	given	give	VBN
18637	20131	104	aid	aid	NN
18637	20131	105	or	or	CC
18637	20131	106	comfort	comfort	NN
18637	20131	107	to	to	IN
18637	20131	108	the	the	DT
18637	20131	109	enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	20131	110	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	20131	111	.	.	.
18637	20132	1	But	but	CC
18637	20132	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20132	3	may	may	MD
18637	20132	4	by	by	IN
18637	20132	5	a	a	DT
18637	20132	6	vote	vote	NN
18637	20132	7	of	of	IN
18637	20132	8	two	two	CD
18637	20132	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	20132	10	thirds	third	NNS
18637	20132	11	of	of	IN
18637	20132	12	each	each	DT
18637	20132	13	House	House	NNP
18637	20132	14	,	,	,
18637	20132	15	remove	remove	VB
18637	20132	16	such	such	JJ
18637	20132	17	disability	disability	NN
18637	20132	18	.	.	.
18637	20133	1	In	in	IN
18637	20133	2	General	General	NNP
18637	20133	3	The	the	DT
18637	20133	4	right	right	NN
18637	20133	5	to	to	TO
18637	20133	6	remove	remove	VB
18637	20133	7	disabilities	disability	NNS
18637	20133	8	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	20133	9	by	by	IN
18637	20133	10	this	this	DT
18637	20133	11	section	section	NN
18637	20133	12	was	be	VBD
18637	20133	13	exercised	exercise	VBN
18637	20133	14	by	by	IN
18637	20133	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20133	16	at	at	IN
18637	20133	17	different	different	JJ
18637	20133	18	times	time	NNS
18637	20133	19	on	on	IN
18637	20133	20	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	20133	21	of	of	IN
18637	20133	22	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	20133	23	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	20133	24	--	--	:
18637	20133	25	notably	notably	RB
18637	20133	26	by	by	IN
18637	20133	27	act	act	NN
18637	20133	28	of	of	IN
18637	20133	29	December	December	NNP
18637	20133	30	14	14	CD
18637	20133	31	,	,	,
18637	20133	32	1869	1869	CD
18637	20133	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20133	34	16	16	CD
18637	20133	35	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	20133	36	.	.	.
18637	20134	1	607	607	CD
18637	20134	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20134	3	.	.	.
18637	20135	1	In	in	IN
18637	20135	2	1872	1872	CD
18637	20135	3	,	,	,
18637	20135	4	the	the	DT
18637	20135	5	disabilities	disability	NNS
18637	20135	6	were	be	VBD
18637	20135	7	removed	remove	VBN
18637	20135	8	,	,	,
18637	20135	9	by	by	IN
18637	20135	10	a	a	DT
18637	20135	11	blanket	blanket	NN
18637	20135	12	act	act	NN
18637	20135	13	,	,	,
18637	20135	14	from	from	IN
18637	20135	15	all	all	DT
18637	20135	16	persons	person	NNS
18637	20135	17	"	"	''
18637	20135	18	except	except	IN
18637	20135	19	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	20135	20	and	and	CC
18637	20135	21	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	20135	22	of	of	IN
18637	20135	23	the	the	DT
18637	20135	24	Thirty	thirty	CD
18637	20135	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	20135	26	sixth	sixth	JJ
18637	20135	27	and	and	CC
18637	20135	28	Thirty	thirty	CD
18637	20135	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	20135	30	seventh	seventh	JJ
18637	20135	31	Congresses	Congresses	NNPS
18637	20135	32	,	,	,
18637	20135	33	officers	officer	NNS
18637	20135	34	in	in	IN
18637	20135	35	the	the	DT
18637	20135	36	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	20135	37	military	military	NN
18637	20135	38	,	,	,
18637	20135	39	and	and	CC
18637	20135	40	naval	naval	JJ
18637	20135	41	service	service	NN
18637	20135	42	of	of	IN
18637	20135	43	the	the	DT
18637	20135	44	United	United	NNP
18637	20135	45	States	States	NNP
18637	20135	46	,	,	,
18637	20135	47	heads	head	NNS
18637	20135	48	of	of	IN
18637	20135	49	departments	department	NNS
18637	20135	50	,	,	,
18637	20135	51	and	and	CC
18637	20135	52	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	20135	53	ministers	minister	NNS
18637	20135	54	of	of	IN
18637	20135	55	the	the	DT
18637	20135	56	United	United	NNP
18637	20135	57	States	States	NNP
18637	20135	58	"	"	''
18637	20135	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20135	60	17	17	CD
18637	20135	61	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	20135	62	.	.	.
18637	20136	1	142	142	CD
18637	20136	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20136	3	.	.	.
18637	20137	1	Twenty	twenty	CD
18637	20137	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	20137	3	six	six	CD
18637	20137	4	years	year	NNS
18637	20137	5	later	later	RB
18637	20137	6	,	,	,
18637	20137	7	on	on	IN
18637	20137	8	June	June	NNP
18637	20137	9	6	6	CD
18637	20137	10	,	,	,
18637	20137	11	1898	1898	CD
18637	20137	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20137	13	30	30	CD
18637	20137	14	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	20137	15	.	.	.
18637	20138	1	432	432	CD
18637	20138	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20138	3	,	,	,
18637	20138	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20138	5	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	20138	6	briefly	briefly	RB
18637	20138	7	that	that	IN
18637	20138	8	"	"	``
18637	20138	9	the	the	DT
18637	20138	10	disability	disability	NN
18637	20138	11	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	20138	12	by	by	IN
18637	20138	13	section	section	NN
18637	20138	14	3	3	CD
18637	20138	15	*	*	NFP
18637	20138	16	*	*	NFP
18637	20138	17	*	*	NFP
18637	20138	18	incurred	incur	VBN
18637	20138	19	heretofore	heretofore	RB
18637	20138	20	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20138	21	prior	prior	RB
18637	20138	22	to	to	IN
18637	20138	23	June	June	NNP
18637	20138	24	6	6	CD
18637	20138	25	,	,	,
18637	20138	26	1898	1898	CD
18637	20138	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20138	28	,	,	,
18637	20138	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	20138	30	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	20138	31	removed	remove	VBN
18637	20138	32	.	.	.
18637	20139	1	"	"	``
18637	20139	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20139	3	1225	1225	CD
18637	20139	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20139	5	PUBLIC	public	NN
18637	20139	6	DEBT	debt	NN
18637	20139	7	,	,	,
18637	20139	8	ETC	ETC	NNP
18637	20139	9	.	.	.
18637	20140	1	Section	section	NN
18637	20140	2	4	4	CD
18637	20140	3	.	.	.
18637	20141	1	The	the	DT
18637	20141	2	validity	validity	NN
18637	20141	3	of	of	IN
18637	20141	4	the	the	DT
18637	20141	5	public	public	JJ
18637	20141	6	debt	debt	NN
18637	20141	7	of	of	IN
18637	20141	8	the	the	DT
18637	20141	9	United	United	NNP
18637	20141	10	States	States	NNP
18637	20141	11	,	,	,
18637	20141	12	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	20141	13	by	by	IN
18637	20141	14	law	law	NN
18637	20141	15	,	,	,
18637	20141	16	including	include	VBG
18637	20141	17	debts	debt	NNS
18637	20141	18	incurred	incur	VBN
18637	20141	19	for	for	IN
18637	20141	20	payment	payment	NN
18637	20141	21	of	of	IN
18637	20141	22	pensions	pension	NNS
18637	20141	23	and	and	CC
18637	20141	24	bounties	bounty	NNS
18637	20141	25	for	for	IN
18637	20141	26	services	service	NNS
18637	20141	27	in	in	IN
18637	20141	28	suppressing	suppress	VBG
18637	20141	29	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	20141	30	or	or	CC
18637	20141	31	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	20141	32	,	,	,
18637	20141	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	20141	34	not	not	RB
18637	20141	35	be	be	VB
18637	20141	36	questioned	question	VBN
18637	20141	37	.	.	.
18637	20142	1	But	but	CC
18637	20142	2	neither	neither	CC
18637	20142	3	the	the	DT
18637	20142	4	United	United	NNP
18637	20142	5	States	States	NNP
18637	20142	6	nor	nor	CC
18637	20142	7	any	any	DT
18637	20142	8	State	State	NNP
18637	20142	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	20142	10	assume	assume	VB
18637	20142	11	or	or	CC
18637	20142	12	pay	pay	VB
18637	20142	13	any	any	DT
18637	20142	14	debt	debt	NN
18637	20142	15	or	or	CC
18637	20142	16	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	20142	17	incurred	incur	VBN
18637	20142	18	in	in	IN
18637	20142	19	aid	aid	NN
18637	20142	20	of	of	IN
18637	20142	21	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	20142	22	or	or	CC
18637	20142	23	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	20142	24	against	against	IN
18637	20142	25	the	the	DT
18637	20142	26	United	United	NNP
18637	20142	27	States	States	NNP
18637	20142	28	,	,	,
18637	20142	29	or	or	CC
18637	20142	30	any	any	DT
18637	20142	31	claim	claim	NN
18637	20142	32	for	for	IN
18637	20142	33	the	the	DT
18637	20142	34	loss	loss	NN
18637	20142	35	or	or	CC
18637	20142	36	emancipation	emancipation	NN
18637	20142	37	of	of	IN
18637	20142	38	any	any	DT
18637	20142	39	slave	slave	NN
18637	20142	40	;	;	:
18637	20142	41	but	but	CC
18637	20142	42	all	all	DT
18637	20142	43	such	such	JJ
18637	20142	44	debts	debt	NNS
18637	20142	45	,	,	,
18637	20142	46	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	20142	47	and	and	CC
18637	20142	48	claims	claim	NNS
18637	20142	49	shall	shall	MD
18637	20142	50	be	be	VB
18637	20142	51	held	hold	VBN
18637	20142	52	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	20142	53	and	and	CC
18637	20142	54	void	void	JJ
18637	20142	55	.	.	.
18637	20143	1	Although	although	IN
18637	20143	2	section	section	NN
18637	20143	3	four	four	CD
18637	20143	4	"	"	''
18637	20143	5	was	be	VBD
18637	20143	6	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
18637	20143	7	inspired	inspire	VBN
18637	20143	8	by	by	IN
18637	20143	9	the	the	DT
18637	20143	10	desire	desire	NN
18637	20143	11	to	to	TO
18637	20143	12	put	put	VB
18637	20143	13	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	20143	14	question	question	NN
18637	20143	15	the	the	DT
18637	20143	16	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	20143	17	of	of	IN
18637	20143	18	the	the	DT
18637	20143	19	Government	Government	NNP
18637	20143	20	issued	issue	VBN
18637	20143	21	during	during	IN
18637	20143	22	the	the	DT
18637	20143	23	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	20143	24	War	War	NNP
18637	20143	25	,	,	,
18637	20143	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20143	27	language	language	NN
18637	20143	28	indicates	indicate	VBZ
18637	20143	29	a	a	DT
18637	20143	30	broader	broad	JJR
18637	20143	31	connotation	connotation	NN
18637	20143	32	.	.	.
18637	20144	1	*	*	NFP
18637	20144	2	*	*	NFP
18637	20144	3	*	*	NFP
18637	20144	4	'	'	''
18637	20144	5	the	the	DT
18637	20144	6	validity	validity	NN
18637	20144	7	of	of	IN
18637	20144	8	the	the	DT
18637	20144	9	public	public	JJ
18637	20144	10	debt	debt	NN
18637	20144	11	'	'	''
18637	20144	12	*	*	NFP
18637	20144	13	*	*	NFP
18637	20144	14	*	*	NFP
18637	20144	15	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20144	16	embraces	embrace	NNS
18637	20144	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20144	18	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	20144	19	concerns	concern	VBZ
18637	20144	20	the	the	DT
18637	20144	21	integrity	integrity	NN
18637	20144	22	of	of	IN
18637	20144	23	the	the	DT
18637	20144	24	public	public	JJ
18637	20144	25	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	20144	26	,	,	,
18637	20144	27	"	"	''
18637	20144	28	and	and	CC
18637	20144	29	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	20144	30	to	to	IN
18637	20144	31	government	government	NN
18637	20144	32	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	20144	33	issued	issue	VBN
18637	20144	34	after	after	IN
18637	20144	35	as	as	RB
18637	20144	36	well	well	RB
18637	20144	37	as	as	IN
18637	20144	38	before	before	IN
18637	20144	39	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	20144	40	of	of	IN
18637	20144	41	the	the	DT
18637	20144	42	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20144	43	.	.	.
18637	20145	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20145	2	1226	1226	CD
18637	20145	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20145	4	ENFORCEMENT	ENFORCEMENT	NNP
18637	20145	5	Section	section	NN
18637	20145	6	5	5	CD
18637	20145	7	.	.	.
18637	20146	1	The	the	DT
18637	20146	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20146	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	20146	4	have	have	VB
18637	20146	5	power	power	NN
18637	20146	6	to	to	TO
18637	20146	7	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	20146	8	,	,	,
18637	20146	9	by	by	IN
18637	20146	10	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	20146	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	20146	12	,	,	,
18637	20146	13	the	the	DT
18637	20146	14	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	20146	15	of	of	IN
18637	20146	16	this	this	DT
18637	20146	17	article	article	NN
18637	20146	18	.	.	.
18637	20147	1	Scope	scope	NN
18637	20147	2	of	of	IN
18637	20147	3	the	the	DT
18637	20147	4	Provision	Provision	NNP
18637	20147	5	"	"	''
18637	20147	6	*	*	NFP
18637	20147	7	*	*	NFP
18637	20147	8	*	*	NFP
18637	20147	9	until	until	IN
18637	20147	10	some	some	DT
18637	20147	11	State	State	NNP
18637	20147	12	law	law	NN
18637	20147	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	20147	14	been	be	VBN
18637	20147	15	passed	pass	VBN
18637	20147	16	,	,	,
18637	20147	17	or	or	CC
18637	20147	18	some	some	DT
18637	20147	19	State	State	NNP
18637	20147	20	action	action	NN
18637	20147	21	through	through	IN
18637	20147	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20147	23	officers	officer	NNS
18637	20147	24	or	or	CC
18637	20147	25	agents	agent	NNS
18637	20147	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	20147	27	been	be	VBN
18637	20147	28	taken	take	VBN
18637	20147	29	,	,	,
18637	20147	30	adverse	adverse	RB
18637	20147	31	to	to	IN
18637	20147	32	the	the	DT
18637	20147	33	rights	right	NNS
18637	20147	34	of	of	IN
18637	20147	35	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20147	36	sought	seek	VBD
18637	20147	37	to	to	TO
18637	20147	38	be	be	VB
18637	20147	39	protected	protect	VBN
18637	20147	40	by	by	IN
18637	20147	41	the	the	DT
18637	20147	42	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	20147	43	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20147	44	,	,	,
18637	20147	45	no	no	DT
18637	20147	46	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	20147	47	of	of	IN
18637	20147	48	the	the	DT
18637	20147	49	United	United	NNP
18637	20147	50	States	States	NNP
18637	20147	51	under	under	IN
18637	20147	52	said	say	VBD
18637	20147	53	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	20147	54	,	,	,
18637	20147	55	nor	nor	CC
18637	20147	56	any	any	DT
18637	20147	57	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	20147	58	under	under	IN
18637	20147	59	such	such	JJ
18637	20147	60	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	20147	61	,	,	,
18637	20147	62	can	can	MD
18637	20147	63	be	be	VB
18637	20147	64	called	call	VBN
18637	20147	65	into	into	IN
18637	20147	66	activity	activity	NN
18637	20147	67	:	:	:
18637	20147	68	*	*	NFP
18637	20147	69	*	*	NFP
18637	20147	70	*	*	NFP
18637	20147	71	The	the	DT
18637	20147	72	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	20147	73	which	which	WDT
18637	20147	74	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20147	75	is	be	VBZ
18637	20147	76	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	20147	77	to	to	TO
18637	20147	78	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	20147	79	in	in	IN
18637	20147	80	this	this	DT
18637	20147	81	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	20147	82	is	be	VBZ
18637	20147	83	not	not	RB
18637	20147	84	general	general	JJ
18637	20147	85	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	20147	86	upon	upon	IN
18637	20147	87	the	the	DT
18637	20147	88	rights	right	NNS
18637	20147	89	of	of	IN
18637	20147	90	the	the	DT
18637	20147	91	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	20147	92	,	,	,
18637	20147	93	but	but	CC
18637	20147	94	corrective	corrective	JJ
18637	20147	95	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	20147	96	,	,	,
18637	20147	97	that	that	RB
18637	20147	98	is	is	RB
18637	20147	99	,	,	,
18637	20147	100	such	such	JJ
18637	20147	101	as	as	IN
18637	20147	102	may	may	MD
18637	20147	103	be	be	VB
18637	20147	104	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	20147	105	and	and	CC
18637	20147	106	proper	proper	JJ
18637	20147	107	for	for	IN
18637	20147	108	counteracting	counteract	VBG
18637	20147	109	such	such	JJ
18637	20147	110	laws	law	NNS
18637	20147	111	as	as	IN
18637	20147	112	the	the	DT
18637	20147	113	States	States	NNPS
18637	20147	114	may	may	MD
18637	20147	115	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	20147	116	or	or	CC
18637	20147	117	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	20147	118	,	,	,
18637	20147	119	and	and	CC
18637	20147	120	which	which	WDT
18637	20147	121	,	,	,
18637	20147	122	by	by	IN
18637	20147	123	the	the	DT
18637	20147	124	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	20147	125	,	,	,
18637	20147	126	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20147	127	are	be	VBP
18637	20147	128	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	20147	129	from	from	IN
18637	20147	130	making	make	VBG
18637	20147	131	or	or	CC
18637	20147	132	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	20147	133	,	,	,
18637	20147	134	or	or	CC
18637	20147	135	such	such	JJ
18637	20147	136	acts	act	NNS
18637	20147	137	and	and	CC
18637	20147	138	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	20147	139	as	as	IN
18637	20147	140	the	the	DT
18637	20147	141	States	States	NNP
18637	20147	142	may	may	MD
18637	20147	143	commit	commit	VB
18637	20147	144	or	or	CC
18637	20147	145	take	take	VB
18637	20147	146	,	,	,
18637	20147	147	and	and	CC
18637	20147	148	which	which	WDT
18637	20147	149	,	,	,
18637	20147	150	by	by	IN
18637	20147	151	the	the	DT
18637	20147	152	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	20147	153	,	,	,
18637	20147	154	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20147	155	are	be	VBP
18637	20147	156	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	20147	157	from	from	IN
18637	20147	158	committing	commit	VBG
18637	20147	159	or	or	CC
18637	20147	160	taking	take	VBG
18637	20147	161	.	.	.
18637	20148	1	"	"	``
18637	20148	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20148	3	1227	1227	CD
18637	20148	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20148	5	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	20148	6	,	,	,
18637	20148	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20148	8	may	may	MD
18637	20148	9	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	20148	10	the	the	DT
18637	20148	11	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	20148	12	of	of	IN
18637	20148	13	the	the	DT
18637	20148	14	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	20148	15	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	20148	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20148	17	are	be	VBP
18637	20148	18	disregarded	disregard	VBN
18637	20148	19	by	by	IN
18637	20148	20	either	either	CC
18637	20148	21	the	the	DT
18637	20148	22	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	20148	23	,	,	,
18637	20148	24	the	the	DT
18637	20148	25	executive	executive	NN
18637	20148	26	,	,	,
18637	20148	27	or	or	CC
18637	20148	28	the	the	DT
18637	20148	29	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	20148	30	department	department	NN
18637	20148	31	of	of	IN
18637	20148	32	the	the	DT
18637	20148	33	State	State	NNP
18637	20148	34	.	.	.
18637	20149	1	The	the	DT
18637	20149	2	mode	mode	NN
18637	20149	3	of	of	IN
18637	20149	4	the	the	DT
18637	20149	5	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	20149	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	20149	7	left	leave	VBN
18637	20149	8	to	to	IN
18637	20149	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20149	10	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	20149	11	.	.	.
18637	20150	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20150	2	may	may	MD
18637	20150	3	secure	secure	VB
18637	20150	4	the	the	DT
18637	20150	5	right	right	NN
18637	20150	6	,	,	,
18637	20150	7	that	that	RB
18637	20150	8	is	is	RB
18637	20150	9	,	,	,
18637	20150	10	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	20150	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20150	12	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	20150	13	,	,	,
18637	20150	14	by	by	IN
18637	20150	15	removing	remove	VBG
18637	20150	16	the	the	DT
18637	20150	17	case	case	NN
18637	20150	18	from	from	IN
18637	20150	19	a	a	DT
18637	20150	20	State	State	NNP
18637	20150	21	court	court	NN
18637	20150	22	,	,	,
18637	20150	23	in	in	IN
18637	20150	24	which	which	WDT
18637	20150	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20150	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	20150	27	denied	deny	VBN
18637	20150	28	,	,	,
18637	20150	29	into	into	IN
18637	20150	30	a	a	DT
18637	20150	31	federal	federal	JJ
18637	20150	32	court	court	NN
18637	20150	33	where	where	WRB
18637	20150	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20150	35	will	will	MD
18637	20150	36	be	be	VB
18637	20150	37	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	20150	38	.	.	.
18637	20151	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20151	2	1228	1228	CD
18637	20151	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20151	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	20151	5	,	,	,
18637	20151	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20151	7	may	may	MD
18637	20151	8	provide	provide	VB
18637	20151	9	that	that	IN
18637	20151	10	"	"	``
18637	20151	11	no	no	DT
18637	20151	12	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	20151	13	,	,	,
18637	20151	14	possessing	possess	VBG
18637	20151	15	all	all	DT
18637	20151	16	other	other	JJ
18637	20151	17	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	20151	18	which	which	WDT
18637	20151	19	are	be	VBP
18637	20151	20	or	or	CC
18637	20151	21	may	may	MD
18637	20151	22	be	be	VB
18637	20151	23	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	20151	24	by	by	IN
18637	20151	25	law	law	NN
18637	20151	26	shall	shall	MD
18637	20151	27	be	be	VB
18637	20151	28	disqualified	disqualify	VBN
18637	20151	29	for	for	IN
18637	20151	30	service	service	NN
18637	20151	31	as	as	IN
18637	20151	32	grand	grand	NNP
18637	20151	33	or	or	CC
18637	20151	34	petit	petit	NNP
18637	20151	35	juror	juror	NN
18637	20151	36	in	in	IN
18637	20151	37	any	any	DT
18637	20151	38	court	court	NN
18637	20151	39	of	of	IN
18637	20151	40	the	the	DT
18637	20151	41	United	United	NNP
18637	20151	42	States	States	NNP
18637	20151	43	,	,	,
18637	20151	44	or	or	CC
18637	20151	45	of	of	IN
18637	20151	46	any	any	DT
18637	20151	47	State	State	NNP
18637	20151	48	,	,	,
18637	20151	49	on	on	IN
18637	20151	50	account	account	NN
18637	20151	51	of	of	IN
18637	20151	52	race	race	NN
18637	20151	53	,	,	,
18637	20151	54	color	color	NN
18637	20151	55	,	,	,
18637	20151	56	or	or	CC
18637	20151	57	previous	previous	JJ
18637	20151	58	condition	condition	NN
18637	20151	59	of	of	IN
18637	20151	60	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	20151	61	;	;	:
18637	20151	62	and	and	CC
18637	20151	63	any	any	DT
18637	20151	64	officer	officer	NN
18637	20151	65	or	or	CC
18637	20151	66	other	other	JJ
18637	20151	67	person	person	NN
18637	20151	68	charged	charge	VBN
18637	20151	69	with	with	IN
18637	20151	70	any	any	DT
18637	20151	71	duty	duty	NN
18637	20151	72	in	in	IN
18637	20151	73	the	the	DT
18637	20151	74	selection	selection	NN
18637	20151	75	or	or	CC
18637	20151	76	summoning	summoning	NN
18637	20151	77	of	of	IN
18637	20151	78	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	20151	79	who	who	WP
18637	20151	80	shall	shall	MD
18637	20151	81	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	20151	82	or	or	CC
18637	20151	83	fail	fail	VB
18637	20151	84	to	to	TO
18637	20151	85	summon	summon	VB
18637	20151	86	any	any	DT
18637	20151	87	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	20151	88	for	for	IN
18637	20151	89	the	the	DT
18637	20151	90	cause	cause	NN
18637	20151	91	aforesaid	aforesaid	NNP
18637	20151	92	shall	shall	NNP
18637	20151	93	,	,	,
18637	20151	94	on	on	IN
18637	20151	95	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	20151	96	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	20151	97	,	,	,
18637	20151	98	be	be	VB
18637	20151	99	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	20151	100	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	20151	101	of	of	IN
18637	20151	102	a	a	DT
18637	20151	103	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
18637	20151	104	,	,	,
18637	20151	105	*	*	NFP
18637	20151	106	*	*	NFP
18637	20151	107	*	*	NFP
18637	20151	108	"	"	''
18637	20151	109	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20151	110	1229	1229	CD
18637	20151	111	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20151	112	However	however	RB
18637	20151	113	,	,	,
18637	20151	114	the	the	DT
18637	20151	115	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	20151	116	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20151	117	declined	decline	VBD
18637	20151	118	to	to	TO
18637	20151	119	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	20151	120	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20151	121	when	when	WRB
18637	20151	122	,	,	,
18637	20151	123	under	under	IN
18637	20151	124	the	the	DT
18637	20151	125	guise	guise	NN
18637	20151	126	of	of	IN
18637	20151	127	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	20151	128	the	the	DT
18637	20151	129	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	20151	130	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20151	131	by	by	IN
18637	20151	132	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	20151	133	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	20151	134	,	,	,
18637	20151	135	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20151	136	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	20151	137	a	a	DT
18637	20151	138	statute	statute	NN
18637	20151	139	which	which	WDT
18637	20151	140	was	be	VBD
18637	20151	141	not	not	RB
18637	20151	142	limited	limit	VBN
18637	20151	143	to	to	TO
18637	20151	144	take	take	VB
18637	20151	145	effect	effect	NN
18637	20151	146	only	only	RB
18637	20151	147	in	in	IN
18637	20151	148	case	case	NN
18637	20151	149	a	a	DT
18637	20151	150	State	state	NN
18637	20151	151	should	should	MD
18637	20151	152	abridge	abridge	VB
18637	20151	153	the	the	DT
18637	20151	154	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	20151	155	of	of	IN
18637	20151	156	United	United	NNP
18637	20151	157	States	States	NNP
18637	20151	158	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20151	159	,	,	,
18637	20151	160	but	but	CC
18637	20151	161	applied	apply	VBD
18637	20151	162	no	no	RB
18637	20151	163	matter	matter	RB
18637	20151	164	how	how	WRB
18637	20151	165	well	well	RB
18637	20151	166	the	the	DT
18637	20151	167	State	state	NN
18637	20151	168	might	may	MD
18637	20151	169	have	have	VB
18637	20151	170	performed	perform	VBN
18637	20151	171	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20151	172	duty	duty	NN
18637	20151	173	,	,	,
18637	20151	174	and	and	CC
18637	20151	175	would	would	MD
18637	20151	176	subject	subject	VB
18637	20151	177	to	to	IN
18637	20151	178	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	20151	179	private	private	JJ
18637	20151	180	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	20151	181	who	who	WP
18637	20151	182	conspired	conspire	VBD
18637	20151	183	to	to	TO
18637	20151	184	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	20151	185	anyone	anyone	NN
18637	20151	186	of	of	IN
18637	20151	187	the	the	DT
18637	20151	188	equal	equal	JJ
18637	20151	189	protection	protection	NN
18637	20151	190	of	of	IN
18637	20151	191	the	the	DT
18637	20151	192	laws	law	NNS
18637	20151	193	.	.	.
18637	20152	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20152	2	1230	1230	CD
18637	20152	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20152	4	Whether	whether	IN
18637	20152	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20152	6	powers	power	NNS
18637	20152	7	of	of	IN
18637	20152	8	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	20152	9	enable	enable	VBP
18637	20152	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	20152	11	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	20152	12	to	to	TO
18637	20152	13	punish	punish	VB
18637	20152	14	State	state	NN
18637	20152	15	officers	officer	NNS
18637	20152	16	who	who	WP
18637	20152	17	abuse	abuse	VBP
18637	20152	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20152	19	authority	authority	NN
18637	20152	20	and	and	CC
18637	20152	21	act	act	VB
18637	20152	22	in	in	IN
18637	20152	23	violation	violation	NN
18637	20152	24	of	of	IN
18637	20152	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20152	26	State	State	NNP
18637	20152	27	's	's	POS
18637	20152	28	laws	law	NNS
18637	20152	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	20152	30	a	a	DT
18637	20152	31	question	question	NN
18637	20152	32	on	on	IN
18637	20152	33	which	which	WDT
18637	20152	34	the	the	DT
18637	20152	35	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	20152	36	only	only	RB
18637	20152	37	recently	recently	RB
18637	20152	38	have	have	VBP
18637	20152	39	divided	divide	VBN
18637	20152	40	.	.	.
18637	20153	1	Five	five	CD
18637	20153	2	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	20153	3	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	20153	4	in	in	IN
18637	20153	5	Screws	Screws	NNP
18637	20153	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20153	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20153	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20153	9	United	United	NNP
18637	20153	10	States[1231	States[1231	NNP
18637	20153	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20153	12	that	that	IN
18637	20153	13	section	section	NN
18637	20153	14	20	20	CD
18637	20153	15	of	of	IN
18637	20153	16	the	the	DT
18637	20153	17	Criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	20153	18	Code[1232	code[1232	NN
18637	20153	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20153	20	which	which	WDT
18637	20153	21	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	20153	22	"	"	``
18637	20153	23	whoever	whoever	WP
18637	20153	24	,	,	,
18637	20153	25	under	under	IN
18637	20153	26	the	the	DT
18637	20153	27	color	color	NN
18637	20153	28	of	of	IN
18637	20153	29	any	any	DT
18637	20153	30	law	law	NN
18637	20153	31	,	,	,
18637	20153	32	statute	statute	NN
18637	20153	33	,	,	,
18637	20153	34	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	20153	35	,	,	,
18637	20153	36	*	*	NFP
18637	20153	37	*	*	NFP
18637	20153	38	*	*	NFP
18637	20153	39	,	,	,
18637	20153	40	willfully	willfully	RB
18637	20153	41	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	20153	42	,	,	,
18637	20153	43	*	*	NFP
18637	20153	44	*	*	NFP
18637	20153	45	*	*	NFP
18637	20153	46	,	,	,
18637	20153	47	any	any	DT
18637	20153	48	inhabitant	inhabitant	NN
18637	20153	49	of	of	IN
18637	20153	50	any	any	DT
18637	20153	51	State	State	NNP
18637	20153	52	,	,	,
18637	20153	53	*	*	NFP
18637	20153	54	*	*	NFP
18637	20153	55	*	*	NFP
18637	20153	56	to	to	IN
18637	20153	57	the	the	DT
18637	20153	58	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	20153	59	of	of	IN
18637	20153	60	any	any	DT
18637	20153	61	rights	right	NNS
18637	20153	62	,	,	,
18637	20153	63	*	*	NFP
18637	20153	64	*	*	NFP
18637	20153	65	*	*	NFP
18637	20153	66	protected	protect	VBN
18637	20153	67	by	by	IN
18637	20153	68	the	the	DT
18637	20153	69	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	20153	70	and	and	CC
18637	20153	71	laws	law	NNS
18637	20153	72	of	of	IN
18637	20153	73	the	the	DT
18637	20153	74	United	United	NNP
18637	20153	75	States	States	NNP
18637	20153	76	,	,	,
18637	20153	77	*	*	NFP
18637	20153	78	*	*	NFP
18637	20153	79	*	*	NFP
18637	20153	80	"	"	``
18637	20153	81	could	could	MD
18637	20153	82	be	be	VB
18637	20153	83	the	the	DT
18637	20153	84	basis	basis	NN
18637	20153	85	of	of	IN
18637	20153	86	a	a	DT
18637	20153	87	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	20153	88	of	of	IN
18637	20153	89	Screws	Screws	NNP
18637	20153	90	,	,	,
18637	20153	91	a	a	DT
18637	20153	92	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	20153	93	sheriff	sheriff	NN
18637	20153	94	,	,	,
18637	20153	95	and	and	CC
18637	20153	96	others	other	NNS
18637	20153	97	,	,	,
18637	20153	98	on	on	IN
18637	20153	99	charges	charge	NNS
18637	20153	100	of	of	IN
18637	20153	101	having	have	VBG
18637	20153	102	,	,	,
18637	20153	103	in	in	IN
18637	20153	104	the	the	DT
18637	20153	105	course	course	NN
18637	20153	106	of	of	IN
18637	20153	107	arresting	arrest	VBG
18637	20153	108	a	a	DT
18637	20153	109	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	20153	110	,	,	,
18637	20153	111	brutally	brutally	RB
18637	20153	112	beaten	beat	VBD
18637	20153	113	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20153	114	to	to	IN
18637	20153	115	death	death	NN
18637	20153	116	and	and	CC
18637	20153	117	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	20153	118	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20153	119	of	of	IN
18637	20153	120	"	"	``
18637	20153	121	the	the	DT
18637	20153	122	right	right	RB
18637	20153	123	not	not	RB
18637	20153	124	to	to	TO
18637	20153	125	be	be	VB
18637	20153	126	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	20153	127	of	of	IN
18637	20153	128	life	life	NN
18637	20153	129	without	without	IN
18637	20153	130	due	due	JJ
18637	20153	131	process	process	NN
18637	20153	132	of	of	IN
18637	20153	133	law	law	NN
18637	20153	134	.	.	.
18637	20154	1	"	"	``
18637	20154	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20154	3	1233	1233	CD
18637	20154	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20154	5	Holding	hold	VBG
18637	20154	6	that	that	IN
18637	20154	7	,	,	,
18637	20154	8	"	"	''
18637	20154	9	abuse	abuse	NN
18637	20154	10	of	of	IN
18637	20154	11	State	State	NNP
18637	20154	12	power	power	NN
18637	20154	13	"	"	``
18637	20154	14	does	do	VBZ
18637	20154	15	not	not	RB
18637	20154	16	create	create	VB
18637	20154	17	"	"	''
18637	20154	18	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	20154	19	to	to	IN
18637	20154	20	federal	federal	JJ
18637	20154	21	power	power	NN
18637	20154	22	"	"	''
18637	20154	23	these	these	DT
18637	20154	24	five	five	CD
18637	20154	25	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	20154	26	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	20154	27	that	that	IN
18637	20154	28	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	20154	29	parte	parte	VBZ
18637	20154	30	Virginia[1234	Virginia[1234	NNP
18637	20154	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20154	32	and	and	CC
18637	20154	33	United	United	NNP
18637	20154	34	States	States	NNP
18637	20154	35	_	_	NNP
18637	20154	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	20154	37	_	_	NNP
18637	20154	38	Classic[1235	Classic[1235	NNP
18637	20154	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20154	40	had	have	VBD
18637	20154	41	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	20154	42	for	for	IN
18637	20154	43	all	all	DT
18637	20154	44	time	time	NN
18637	20154	45	the	the	DT
18637	20154	46	defense	defense	NN
18637	20154	47	that	that	IN
18637	20154	48	action	action	NN
18637	20154	49	by	by	IN
18637	20154	50	state	state	NN
18637	20154	51	officers	officer	NNS
18637	20154	52	in	in	IN
18637	20154	53	excess	excess	NN
18637	20154	54	of	of	IN
18637	20154	55	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20154	56	powers	power	NNS
18637	20154	57	did	do	VBD
18637	20154	58	not	not	RB
18637	20154	59	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	20154	60	state	state	NN
18637	20154	61	action	action	NN
18637	20154	62	"	"	''
18637	20154	63	under	under	IN
18637	20154	64	color	color	NN
18637	20154	65	of	of	IN
18637	20154	66	law	law	NN
18637	20154	67	"	"	''
18637	20154	68	and	and	CC
18637	20154	69	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	20154	70	was	be	VBD
18637	20154	71	punishable	punishable	JJ
18637	20154	72	,	,	,
18637	20154	73	if	if	IN
18637	20154	74	at	at	RB
18637	20154	75	all	all	RB
18637	20154	76	,	,	,
18637	20154	77	only	only	RB
18637	20154	78	as	as	IN
18637	20154	79	a	a	DT
18637	20154	80	crime	crime	NN
18637	20154	81	against	against	IN
18637	20154	82	the	the	DT
18637	20154	83	State	State	NNP
18637	20154	84	.	.	.
18637	20155	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20155	2	1236	1236	CD
18637	20155	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20155	4	The	the	DT
18637	20155	5	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	20155	6	of	of	IN
18637	20155	7	Screws	Screws	NNPS
18637	20155	8	was	be	VBD
18637	20155	9	,	,	,
18637	20155	10	however	however	RB
18637	20155	11	,	,	,
18637	20155	12	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	20155	13	on	on	IN
18637	20155	14	the	the	DT
18637	20155	15	ground	ground	NN
18637	20155	16	that	that	IN
18637	20155	17	the	the	DT
18637	20155	18	jury	jury	NN
18637	20155	19	should	should	MD
18637	20155	20	have	have	VB
18637	20155	21	been	be	VBN
18637	20155	22	instructed	instruct	VBN
18637	20155	23	to	to	TO
18637	20155	24	say	say	VB
18637	20155	25	whether	whether	IN
18637	20155	26	the	the	DT
18637	20155	27	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	20155	28	had	have	VBD
18637	20155	29	had	have	VBN
18637	20155	30	the	the	DT
18637	20155	31	"	"	``
18637	20155	32	specific	specific	JJ
18637	20155	33	intent	intent	NN
18637	20155	34	"	"	''
18637	20155	35	to	to	TO
18637	20155	36	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	20155	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20155	38	victim	victim	NN
18637	20155	39	of	of	IN
18637	20155	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20155	41	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	20155	42	rights	right	NNS
18637	20155	43	,	,	,
18637	20155	44	since	since	IN
18637	20155	45	in	in	IN
18637	20155	46	the	the	DT
18637	20155	47	absence	absence	NN
18637	20155	48	of	of	IN
18637	20155	49	such	such	PDT
18637	20155	50	a	a	DT
18637	20155	51	finding	find	VBG
18637	20155	52	§	§	NNP
18637	20155	53	20	20	CD
18637	20155	54	failed	fail	VBD
18637	20155	55	for	for	IN
18637	20155	56	indefiniteness	indefiniteness	NN
18637	20155	57	.	.	.
18637	20156	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20156	2	1237	1237	CD
18637	20156	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20156	4	But	but	CC
18637	20156	5	this	this	DT
18637	20156	6	construction	construction	NN
18637	20156	7	of	of	IN
18637	20156	8	the	the	DT
18637	20156	9	word	word	NN
18637	20156	10	"	"	``
18637	20156	11	willfully	willfully	RB
18637	20156	12	"	"	``
18637	20156	13	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	20156	14	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	20156	15	to	to	TO
18637	20156	16	have	have	VB
18637	20156	17	been	be	VBN
18637	20156	18	abandoned	abandon	VBN
18637	20156	19	,	,	,
18637	20156	20	or	or	CC
18637	20156	21	at	at	IN
18637	20156	22	least	least	JJS
18637	20156	23	considerably	considerably	RB
18637	20156	24	watered	water	VBN
18637	20156	25	down	down	RP
18637	20156	26	.	.	.
18637	20157	1	In	in	IN
18637	20157	2	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	20157	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20157	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	20157	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20157	6	United	United	NNP
18637	20157	7	States,[1238	States,[1238	NNP
18637	20157	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20157	9	decided	decide	VBN
18637	20157	10	in	in	IN
18637	20157	11	April	April	NNP
18637	20157	12	1951	1951	CD
18637	20157	13	,	,	,
18637	20157	14	the	the	DT
18637	20157	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20157	16	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	20157	17	,	,	,
18637	20157	18	by	by	IN
18637	20157	19	a	a	DT
18637	20157	20	bare	bare	JJ
18637	20157	21	majority	majority	NN
18637	20157	22	,	,	,
18637	20157	23	that	that	IN
18637	20157	24	a	a	DT
18637	20157	25	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	20157	26	under	under	IN
18637	20157	27	§	§	NNP
18637	20157	28	20	20	CD
18637	20157	29	was	be	VBD
18637	20157	30	not	not	RB
18637	20157	31	subject	subject	JJ
18637	20157	32	to	to	IN
18637	20157	33	objection	objection	NN
18637	20157	34	on	on	IN
18637	20157	35	the	the	DT
18637	20157	36	ground	ground	NN
18637	20157	37	of	of	IN
18637	20157	38	the	the	DT
18637	20157	39	vagueness	vagueness	NN
18637	20157	40	of	of	IN
18637	20157	41	the	the	DT
18637	20157	42	statute	statute	NN
18637	20157	43	where	where	WRB
18637	20157	44	the	the	DT
18637	20157	45	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	20157	46	made	make	VBD
18637	20157	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20157	48	clear	clear	JJ
18637	20157	49	that	that	IN
18637	20157	50	the	the	DT
18637	20157	51	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	20157	52	right	right	NN
18637	20157	53	violated	violate	VBN
18637	20157	54	by	by	IN
18637	20157	55	the	the	DT
18637	20157	56	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	20157	57	was	be	VBD
18637	20157	58	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	20157	59	from	from	IN
18637	20157	60	the	the	DT
18637	20157	61	use	use	NN
18637	20157	62	of	of	IN
18637	20157	63	force	force	NN
18637	20157	64	and	and	CC
18637	20157	65	violence	violence	NN
18637	20157	66	to	to	TO
18637	20157	67	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	20157	68	a	a	DT
18637	20157	69	confession	confession	NN
18637	20157	70	,	,	,
18637	20157	71	and	and	CC
18637	20157	72	this	this	DT
18637	20157	73	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	20157	74	was	be	VBD
18637	20157	75	also	also	RB
18637	20157	76	made	make	VBN
18637	20157	77	clear	clear	JJ
18637	20157	78	by	by	IN
18637	20157	79	the	the	DT
18637	20157	80	trial	trial	NN
18637	20157	81	judge	judge	NN
18637	20157	82	's	's	POS
18637	20157	83	charge	charge	NN
18637	20157	84	to	to	IN
18637	20157	85	the	the	DT
18637	20157	86	jury	jury	NN
18637	20157	87	.	.	.
18637	20158	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20158	2	1239	1239	CD
18637	20158	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20158	4	To	to	IN
18637	20158	5	the	the	DT
18637	20158	6	same	same	JJ
18637	20158	7	effect	effect	NN
18637	20158	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	20158	9	the	the	DT
18637	20158	10	later	later	JJ
18637	20158	11	case	case	NN
18637	20158	12	of	of	IN
18637	20158	13	Koehler	Koehler	NNP
18637	20158	14	_	_	NNP
18637	20158	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	20158	16	_	_	NNP
18637	20158	17	United	United	NNP
18637	20158	18	States[1240	States[1240	NNP
18637	20158	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20158	20	in	in	IN
18637	20158	21	which	which	WDT
18637	20158	22	the	the	DT
18637	20158	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20158	24	denied	deny	VBD
18637	20158	25	certiorari	certiorari	NN
18637	20158	26	in	in	IN
18637	20158	27	a	a	DT
18637	20158	28	case	case	NN
18637	20158	29	closely	closely	RB
18637	20158	30	resembling	resemble	VBG
18637	20158	31	that	that	DT
18637	20158	32	of	of	IN
18637	20158	33	Screws	Screws	NNPS
18637	20158	34	,	,	,
18637	20158	35	although	although	IN
18637	20158	36	the	the	DT
18637	20158	37	trial	trial	NN
18637	20158	38	judge	judge	NN
18637	20158	39	,	,	,
18637	20158	40	while	while	IN
18637	20158	41	charging	charge	VBG
18637	20158	42	the	the	DT
18637	20158	43	jury	jury	NN
18637	20158	44	that	that	IN
18637	20158	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20158	46	must	must	MD
18637	20158	47	find	find	VB
18637	20158	48	specific	specific	JJ
18637	20158	49	intent	intent	NN
18637	20158	50	,	,	,
18637	20158	51	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	20158	52	went	go	VBD
18637	20158	53	on	on	RP
18637	20158	54	to	to	IN
18637	20158	55	say:"'The	say:"'the	CD
18637	20158	56	color	color	NN
18637	20158	57	of	of	IN
18637	20158	58	the	the	DT
18637	20158	59	act	act	NN
18637	20158	60	determines	determine	VBZ
18637	20158	61	the	the	DT
18637	20158	62	complexion	complexion	NN
18637	20158	63	of	of	IN
18637	20158	64	the	the	DT
18637	20158	65	intent	intent	NN
18637	20158	66	.	.	.
18637	20159	1	The	the	DT
18637	20159	2	intent	intent	NN
18637	20159	3	to	to	TO
18637	20159	4	injure	injure	VB
18637	20159	5	or	or	CC
18637	20159	6	defraud	defraud	VB
18637	20159	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	20159	8	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	20159	9	when	when	WRB
18637	20159	10	the	the	DT
18637	20159	11	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	20159	12	act	act	NN
18637	20159	13	,	,	,
18637	20159	14	which	which	WDT
18637	20159	15	results	result	VBZ
18637	20159	16	in	in	IN
18637	20159	17	loss	loss	NN
18637	20159	18	or	or	CC
18637	20159	19	injury	injury	NN
18637	20159	20	,	,	,
18637	20159	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	20159	22	proved	prove	VBN
18637	20159	23	to	to	TO
18637	20159	24	have	have	VB
18637	20159	25	been	be	VBN
18637	20159	26	knowingly	knowingly	RB
18637	20159	27	committed	commit	VBN
18637	20159	28	.	.	.
18637	20160	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20160	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	20160	3	a	a	DT
18637	20160	4	well	well	RB
18637	20160	5	settled	settle	VBN
18637	20160	6	rule	rule	NN
18637	20160	7	,	,	,
18637	20160	8	which	which	WDT
18637	20160	9	the	the	DT
18637	20160	10	law	law	NN
18637	20160	11	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	20160	12	to	to	IN
18637	20160	13	both	both	CC
18637	20160	14	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	20160	15	and	and	CC
18637	20160	16	civil	civil	JJ
18637	20160	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	20160	18	,	,	,
18637	20160	19	that	that	IN
18637	20160	20	the	the	DT
18637	20160	21	intent	intent	NN
18637	20160	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	20160	23	presumed	presume	VBN
18637	20160	24	and	and	CC
18637	20160	25	inferred	infer	VBN
18637	20160	26	from	from	IN
18637	20160	27	the	the	DT
18637	20160	28	result	result	NN
18637	20160	29	of	of	IN
18637	20160	30	the	the	DT
18637	20160	31	action	action	NN
18637	20160	32	.	.	.
18637	20161	1	'	'	``
18637	20161	2	"	"	''
18637	20161	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20161	4	1241	1241	CD
18637	20161	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20161	6	Notes	note	NNS
18637	20161	7	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20161	8	1	1	CD
18637	20161	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20161	10	As	as	IN
18637	20161	11	to	to	IN
18637	20161	12	the	the	DT
18637	20161	13	other	other	JJ
18637	20161	14	categories	category	NNS
18637	20161	15	,	,	,
18637	20161	16	see	see	VB
18637	20161	17	Art	art	NN
18637	20161	18	.	.	.
18637	20162	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20162	2	,	,	,
18637	20162	3	§	§	NNP
18637	20162	4	8	8	CD
18637	20162	5	,	,	,
18637	20162	6	cl	cl	IN
18637	20162	7	.	.	.
18637	20163	1	4	4	LS
18637	20163	2	,	,	,
18637	20163	3	Naturalization	Naturalization	NNP
18637	20163	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20163	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20163	6	see	see	VBP
18637	20163	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20163	8	pp	pp	NNP
18637	20163	9	.	.	.
18637	20164	1	254	254	CD
18637	20164	2	-	-	SYM
18637	20164	3	256	256	CD
18637	20164	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20164	5	.	.	.
18637	20165	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20165	2	2	2	LS
18637	20165	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20165	4	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	20165	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20165	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20165	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20165	8	Sandford	Sandford	NNP
18637	20165	9	,	,	,
18637	20165	10	19	19	CD
18637	20165	11	How	how	WRB
18637	20165	12	.	.	.
18637	20166	1	393	393	CD
18637	20166	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20166	3	1897	1897	CD
18637	20166	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20166	5	.	.	.
18637	20167	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20167	2	3	3	LS
18637	20167	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20167	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20167	5	.	.	.
18637	20168	1	404	404	CD
18637	20168	2	-	-	SYM
18637	20168	3	406	406	CD
18637	20168	4	,	,	,
18637	20168	5	417	417	CD
18637	20168	6	-	-	SYM
18637	20168	7	418	418	CD
18637	20168	8	,	,	,
18637	20168	9	419	419	CD
18637	20168	10	-	-	SYM
18637	20168	11	420	420	CD
18637	20168	12	.	.	.
18637	20169	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20169	2	4	4	CD
18637	20169	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20169	4	By	by	IN
18637	20169	5	the	the	DT
18637	20169	6	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	20169	7	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	20169	8	Act	Act	NNP
18637	20169	9	of	of	IN
18637	20169	10	April	April	NNP
18637	20169	11	9	9	CD
18637	20169	12	,	,	,
18637	20169	13	1866	1866	CD
18637	20169	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20169	15	14	14	CD
18637	20169	16	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	20169	17	.	.	.
18637	20170	1	27	27	CD
18637	20170	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20170	3	,	,	,
18637	20170	4	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	20170	5	two	two	CD
18637	20170	6	years	year	NNS
18637	20170	7	prior	prior	RB
18637	20170	8	to	to	IN
18637	20170	9	the	the	DT
18637	20170	10	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	20170	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20170	12	,	,	,
18637	20170	13	"	"	''
18637	20170	14	All	all	DT
18637	20170	15	persons	person	NNS
18637	20170	16	born	bear	VBN
18637	20170	17	in	in	IN
18637	20170	18	the	the	DT
18637	20170	19	United	United	NNP
18637	20170	20	States	States	NNP
18637	20170	21	and	and	CC
18637	20170	22	not	not	RB
18637	20170	23	subject	subject	JJ
18637	20170	24	to	to	IN
18637	20170	25	any	any	DT
18637	20170	26	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	20170	27	power	power	NN
18637	20170	28	,	,	,
18637	20170	29	excluding	exclude	VBG
18637	20170	30	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	20170	31	not	not	RB
18637	20170	32	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	20170	33	,	,	,
18637	20170	34	are	be	VBP
18637	20170	35	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	20170	36	declared	declare	VBN
18637	20170	37	to	to	TO
18637	20170	38	be	be	VB
18637	20170	39	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20170	40	of	of	IN
18637	20170	41	the	the	DT
18637	20170	42	United	United	NNP
18637	20170	43	States	States	NNP
18637	20170	44	;	;	:
18637	20170	45	*	*	NFP
18637	20170	46	*	*	NFP
18637	20170	47	*	*	NFP
18637	20170	48	"	"	''
18637	20170	49	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20170	50	5	5	CD
18637	20170	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20170	52	169	169	CD
18637	20170	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20170	54	649	649	CD
18637	20170	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20170	56	1898).--Thus	1898).--thu	NNS
18637	20170	57	,	,	,
18637	20170	58	a	a	DT
18637	20170	59	person	person	NN
18637	20170	60	who	who	WP
18637	20170	61	was	be	VBD
18637	20170	62	born	bear	VBN
18637	20170	63	in	in	IN
18637	20170	64	the	the	DT
18637	20170	65	United	United	NNP
18637	20170	66	States	States	NNP
18637	20170	67	of	of	IN
18637	20170	68	Swedish	swedish	JJ
18637	20170	69	parents	parent	NNS
18637	20170	70	then	then	RB
18637	20170	71	naturalized	naturalize	VBD
18637	20170	72	here	here	RB
18637	20170	73	did	do	VBD
18637	20170	74	not	not	RB
18637	20170	75	lose	lose	VB
18637	20170	76	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20170	77	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	20170	78	and	and	CC
18637	20170	79	was	be	VBD
18637	20170	80	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	20170	81	not	not	RB
18637	20170	82	subject	subject	JJ
18637	20170	83	to	to	IN
18637	20170	84	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	20170	85	because	because	IN
18637	20170	86	of	of	IN
18637	20170	87	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20170	88	removal	removal	NN
18637	20170	89	to	to	IN
18637	20170	90	Sweden	Sweden	NNP
18637	20170	91	during	during	IN
18637	20170	92	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20170	93	minority	minority	NN
18637	20170	94	,	,	,
18637	20170	95	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20170	96	appearing	appear	VBG
18637	20170	97	that	that	IN
18637	20170	98	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20170	99	parents	parent	NNS
18637	20170	100	resumed	resume	VBD
18637	20170	101	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20170	102	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	20170	103	in	in	IN
18637	20170	104	that	that	DT
18637	20170	105	country	country	NN
18637	20170	106	,	,	,
18637	20170	107	but	but	CC
18637	20170	108	that	that	IN
18637	20170	109	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20170	110	returned	return	VBD
18637	20170	111	here	here	RB
18637	20170	112	on	on	IN
18637	20170	113	attaining	attain	VBG
18637	20170	114	majority	majority	NN
18637	20170	115	with	with	IN
18637	20170	116	intention	intention	NN
18637	20170	117	to	to	TO
18637	20170	118	retain	retain	VB
18637	20170	119	and	and	CC
18637	20170	120	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	20170	121	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20170	122	citizenship.--Perkins	citizenship.--perkins	CD
18637	20170	123	_	_	NNP
18637	20170	124	v.	v.	IN
18637	20170	125	_	_	NNP
18637	20170	126	Elg	Elg	NNP
18637	20170	127	,	,	,
18637	20170	128	307	307	CD
18637	20170	129	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20170	130	325	325	CD
18637	20170	131	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20170	132	1939	1939	CD
18637	20170	133	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20170	134	.	.	.
18637	20171	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20171	2	6	6	CD
18637	20171	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20171	4	169	169	CD
18637	20171	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20171	6	682	682	CD
18637	20171	7	.	.	.
18637	20172	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20172	2	7	7	LS
18637	20172	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20172	4	In	in	IN
18637	20172	5	re	re	NN
18637	20172	6	Look	look	VB
18637	20172	7	Tin	Tin	NNP
18637	20172	8	Sing	Sing	NNP
18637	20172	9	,	,	,
18637	20172	10	21	21	CD
18637	20172	11	F.	F.	NNP
18637	20172	12	905	905	CD
18637	20172	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20172	14	1884	1884	CD
18637	20172	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20172	16	.	.	.
18637	20173	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20173	2	8	8	CD
18637	20173	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20173	4	Lam	Lam	NNP
18637	20173	5	Mow	Mow	NNP
18637	20173	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20173	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20173	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20173	9	Nagle	Nagle	NNP
18637	20173	10	,	,	,
18637	20173	11	24	24	CD
18637	20173	12	F.	F.	NNP
18637	20173	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20173	14	2d	2d	CD
18637	20173	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20173	16	316	316	CD
18637	20173	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20173	18	1928	1928	CD
18637	20173	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20173	20	.	.	.
18637	20174	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20174	2	9	9	CD
18637	20174	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20174	4	United	United	NNP
18637	20174	5	States	States	NNP
18637	20174	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20174	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20174	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20174	9	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	20174	10	,	,	,
18637	20174	11	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	20174	12	.	.	.
18637	20175	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	20175	2	.	.	.
18637	20176	1	No	no	UH
18637	20176	2	.	.	.
18637	20177	1	15,231	15,231	CD
18637	20177	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20177	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	20177	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20177	5	.	.	.
18637	20178	1	The	the	DT
18637	20178	2	term	term	NN
18637	20178	3	,	,	,
18637	20178	4	United	United	NNP
18637	20178	5	States	States	NNP
18637	20178	6	,	,	,
18637	20178	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	20178	8	defined	define	VBN
18637	20178	9	in	in	IN
18637	20178	10	the	the	DT
18637	20178	11	recently	recently	RB
18637	20178	12	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	20178	13	Immigration	Immigration	NNP
18637	20178	14	and	and	CC
18637	20178	15	Nationality	Nationality	NNP
18637	20178	16	Act	Act	NNP
18637	20178	17	as	as	IN
18637	20178	18	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	20178	19	:	:	:
18637	20178	20	"	"	``
18637	20178	21	The	the	DT
18637	20178	22	term	term	NN
18637	20178	23	,	,	,
18637	20178	24	'	'	''
18637	20178	25	United	United	NNP
18637	20178	26	States	States	NNP
18637	20178	27	'	'	POS
18637	20178	28	,	,	,
18637	20178	29	except	except	IN
18637	20178	30	as	as	IN
18637	20178	31	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	20178	32	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	20178	33	herein	herein	NNP
18637	20178	34	provided	provide	VBN
18637	20178	35	,	,	,
18637	20178	36	when	when	WRB
18637	20178	37	used	use	VBN
18637	20178	38	in	in	IN
18637	20178	39	a	a	DT
18637	20178	40	geographical	geographical	JJ
18637	20178	41	sense	sense	NN
18637	20178	42	,	,	,
18637	20178	43	means	mean	VBZ
18637	20178	44	the	the	DT
18637	20178	45	continental	continental	JJ
18637	20178	46	United	United	NNP
18637	20178	47	States	States	NNP
18637	20178	48	,	,	,
18637	20178	49	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	20178	50	,	,	,
18637	20178	51	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	20178	52	,	,	,
18637	20178	53	Puerto	Puerto	NNP
18637	20178	54	Rico	Rico	NNP
18637	20178	55	,	,	,
18637	20178	56	Guam	Guam	NNP
18637	20178	57	,	,	,
18637	20178	58	and	and	CC
18637	20178	59	the	the	DT
18637	20178	60	Virgin	Virgin	NNP
18637	20178	61	Islands	Islands	NNP
18637	20178	62	of	of	IN
18637	20178	63	the	the	DT
18637	20178	64	United	United	NNP
18637	20178	65	States	States	NNP
18637	20178	66	.	.	.
18637	20178	67	"	"	''
18637	20179	1	66	66	CD
18637	20179	2	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	20179	3	.	.	.
18637	20180	1	165	165	CD
18637	20180	2	,	,	,
18637	20180	3	§	§	NNP
18637	20180	4	101	101	CD
18637	20180	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20180	6	38	38	CD
18637	20180	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20180	8	.	.	.
18637	20181	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	20181	2	the	the	DT
18637	20181	3	expression	expression	NN
18637	20181	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	20181	5	used	use	VBN
18637	20181	6	in	in	IN
18637	20181	7	the	the	DT
18637	20181	8	same	same	JJ
18637	20181	9	sense	sense	NN
18637	20181	10	in	in	IN
18637	20181	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20181	12	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	20181	13	may	may	MD
18637	20181	14	be	be	VB
18637	20181	15	questionable	questionable	JJ
18637	20181	16	.	.	.
18637	20182	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20182	2	10	10	CD
18637	20182	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20182	4	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	20182	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	20182	6	House	House	NNP
18637	20182	7	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	20182	8	,	,	,
18637	20182	9	16	16	CD
18637	20182	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	20182	11	.	.	.
18637	20183	1	36	36	CD
18637	20183	2	,	,	,
18637	20183	3	74	74	CD
18637	20183	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20183	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	20183	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20183	7	.	.	.
18637	20184	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20184	2	11	11	CD
18637	20184	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20184	4	Arver	Arver	NNP
18637	20184	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20184	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20184	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20184	8	United	United	NNP
18637	20184	9	States	States	NNP
18637	20184	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20184	11	Selective	Selective	NNP
18637	20184	12	Draft	Draft	NNP
18637	20184	13	Law	Law	NNP
18637	20184	14	Cases	case	NNS
18637	20184	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20184	16	,	,	,
18637	20184	17	245	245	CD
18637	20184	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20184	19	366	366	CD
18637	20184	20	,	,	,
18637	20184	21	377	377	CD
18637	20184	22	,	,	,
18637	20184	23	388	388	CD
18637	20184	24	-	-	SYM
18637	20184	25	389	389	CD
18637	20184	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20184	27	1918	1918	CD
18637	20184	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20184	29	.	.	.
18637	20185	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20185	2	12	12	CD
18637	20185	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20185	4	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	20185	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20185	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20185	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20185	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20185	9	New	New	NNP
18637	20185	10	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	20185	11	,	,	,
18637	20185	12	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	20185	13	.	.	.
18637	20186	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	20186	2	.	.	.
18637	20187	1	No	no	UH
18637	20187	2	.	.	.
18637	20188	1	7,052	7,052	CD
18637	20188	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20188	3	1870).--Not	1870).--not	CD
18637	20188	4	being	be	VBG
18637	20188	5	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20188	6	of	of	IN
18637	20188	7	the	the	DT
18637	20188	8	United	United	NNP
18637	20188	9	States	States	NNP
18637	20188	10	,	,	,
18637	20188	11	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	20188	12	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	20188	13	have	have	VBP
18637	20188	14	been	be	VBN
18637	20188	15	declared	declare	VBN
18637	20188	16	unable	unable	JJ
18637	20188	17	"	"	''
18637	20188	18	to	to	TO
18637	20188	19	claim	claim	VB
18637	20188	20	the	the	DT
18637	20188	21	protection	protection	NN
18637	20188	22	of	of	IN
18637	20188	23	that	that	DT
18637	20188	24	clause	clause	NN
18637	20188	25	of	of	IN
18637	20188	26	the	the	DT
18637	20188	27	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	20188	28	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20188	29	which	which	WDT
18637	20188	30	secures	secure	VBZ
18637	20188	31	the	the	DT
18637	20188	32	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	20188	33	and	and	CC
18637	20188	34	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	20188	35	of	of	IN
18637	20188	36	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20188	37	of	of	IN
18637	20188	38	the	the	DT
18637	20188	39	United	United	NNP
18637	20188	40	States	States	NNP
18637	20188	41	against	against	IN
18637	20188	42	abridgment	abridgment	NN
18637	20188	43	or	or	CC
18637	20188	44	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	20188	45	by	by	IN
18637	20188	46	the	the	DT
18637	20188	47	law	law	NN
18637	20188	48	of	of	IN
18637	20188	49	a	a	DT
18637	20188	50	State	State	NNP
18637	20188	51	.	.	.
18637	20188	52	"	"	''
18637	20189	1	--Orient	--Orient	:
18637	20189	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20189	3	.	.	.
18637	20190	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20190	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20190	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20190	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20190	5	Daggs	Daggs	NNP
18637	20190	6	,	,	,
18637	20190	7	172	172	CD
18637	20190	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20190	9	557	557	CD
18637	20190	10	,	,	,
18637	20190	11	561	561	CD
18637	20190	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20190	13	1899	1899	CD
18637	20190	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20190	15	.	.	.
18637	20191	1	This	this	DT
18637	20191	2	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	20191	3	was	be	VBD
18637	20191	4	in	in	IN
18637	20191	5	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	20191	6	with	with	IN
18637	20191	7	the	the	DT
18637	20191	8	earlier	early	JJR
18637	20191	9	holding	holding	NN
18637	20191	10	in	in	IN
18637	20191	11	Paul	Paul	NNP
18637	20191	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20191	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	20191	14	_	_	NNP
18637	20191	15	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	20191	16	,	,	,
18637	20191	17	8	8	CD
18637	20191	18	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	20191	19	.	.	.
18637	20192	1	168	168	CD
18637	20192	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20192	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	20192	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20192	5	to	to	IN
18637	20192	6	the	the	DT
18637	20192	7	effect	effect	NN
18637	20192	8	that	that	WDT
18637	20192	9	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	20192	10	were	be	VBD
18637	20192	11	not	not	RB
18637	20192	12	within	within	IN
18637	20192	13	the	the	DT
18637	20192	14	scope	scope	NN
18637	20192	15	of	of	IN
18637	20192	16	the	the	DT
18637	20192	17	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	20192	18	and	and	CC
18637	20192	19	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	20192	20	clause	clause	NN
18637	20192	21	of	of	IN
18637	20192	22	state	state	NN
18637	20192	23	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	20192	24	set	set	VBD
18637	20192	25	out	out	RP
18637	20192	26	in	in	IN
18637	20192	27	article	article	NN
18637	20192	28	4	4	CD
18637	20192	29	,	,	,
18637	20192	30	section	section	NN
18637	20192	31	2	2	CD
18637	20192	32	.	.	.
18637	20193	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20193	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20193	3	also	also	RB
18637	20193	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20193	5	Selover	Selover	NNP
18637	20193	6	,	,	,
18637	20193	7	Bates	Bates	NNP
18637	20193	8	&	&	CC
18637	20193	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20193	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20193	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	20193	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20193	13	Walsh	Walsh	NNP
18637	20193	14	,	,	,
18637	20193	15	226	226	CD
18637	20193	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20193	17	112	112	CD
18637	20193	18	,	,	,
18637	20193	19	126	126	CD
18637	20193	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20193	21	1912	1912	CD
18637	20193	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20193	23	;	;	:
18637	20193	24	Berea	Berea	NNP
18637	20193	25	College	College	NNP
18637	20193	26	_	_	NNP
18637	20193	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	20193	28	_	_	NNP
18637	20193	29	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	20193	30	,	,	,
18637	20193	31	211	211	CD
18637	20193	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20193	33	45	45	CD
18637	20193	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20193	35	1908	1908	CD
18637	20193	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20193	37	;	;	:
18637	20193	38	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	20193	39	Warehouse	Warehouse	NNP
18637	20193	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20193	41	_	_	NNP
18637	20193	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	20193	43	_	_	NNP
18637	20193	44	Burley	Burley	NNP
18637	20193	45	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	20193	46	Growers	Growers	NNPS
18637	20193	47	'	'	POS
18637	20193	48	Co	co	NN
18637	20193	49	-	-	NN
18637	20193	50	op	op	NN
18637	20193	51	.	.	.
18637	20194	1	Marketing	Marketing	NNP
18637	20194	2	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	20194	3	.	.	.
18637	20194	4	,	,	,
18637	20194	5	276	276	CD
18637	20194	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20194	7	71	71	CD
18637	20194	8	,	,	,
18637	20194	9	89	89	CD
18637	20194	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20194	11	1928	1928	CD
18637	20194	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20194	13	;	;	:
18637	20194	14	Grosjean	Grosjean	NNP
18637	20194	15	_	_	NNP
18637	20194	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	20194	17	_	_	NNP
18637	20194	18	American	American	NNP
18637	20194	19	Press	Press	NNP
18637	20194	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20194	21	,	,	,
18637	20194	22	297	297	CD
18637	20194	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20194	24	233	233	CD
18637	20194	25	,	,	,
18637	20194	26	244	244	CD
18637	20194	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20194	28	1936	1936	CD
18637	20194	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20194	30	.	.	.
18637	20195	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20195	2	13	13	CD
18637	20195	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20195	4	16	16	CD
18637	20195	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	20195	6	.	.	.
18637	20196	1	36	36	CD
18637	20196	2	,	,	,
18637	20196	3	71	71	CD
18637	20196	4	,	,	,
18637	20196	5	77	77	CD
18637	20196	6	-	-	SYM
18637	20196	7	79	79	CD
18637	20196	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20196	9	1873	1873	CD
18637	20196	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20196	11	.	.	.
18637	20197	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20197	2	14	14	CD
18637	20197	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20197	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20197	5	.	.	.
18637	20198	1	78	78	CD
18637	20198	2	-	-	SYM
18637	20198	3	79	79	CD
18637	20198	4	.	.	.
18637	20199	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20199	2	15	15	CD
18637	20199	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20199	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20199	5	.	.	.
18637	20200	1	79	79	CD
18637	20200	2	,	,	,
18637	20200	3	citing	cite	VBG
18637	20200	4	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	20200	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20200	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20200	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20200	8	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	20200	9	,	,	,
18637	20200	10	6	6	CD
18637	20200	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	20200	12	.	.	.
18637	20201	1	35	35	CD
18637	20201	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20201	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	20201	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20201	5	.	.	.
18637	20202	1	Decided	decide	VBN
18637	20202	2	before	before	IN
18637	20202	3	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	20202	4	of	of	IN
18637	20202	5	the	the	DT
18637	20202	6	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	20202	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20202	8	.	.	.
18637	20203	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20203	2	16	16	CD
18637	20203	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20203	4	211	211	CD
18637	20203	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20203	6	78	78	CD
18637	20203	7	,	,	,
18637	20203	8	97	97	CD
18637	20203	9	.	.	.
18637	20204	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20204	2	17	17	CD
18637	20204	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20204	4	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	20204	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20204	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20204	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20204	8	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	20204	9	,	,	,
18637	20204	10	6	6	CD
18637	20204	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	20204	12	.	.	.
18637	20205	1	35	35	CD
18637	20205	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20205	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	20205	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20205	5	.	.	.
18637	20206	1	This	this	DT
18637	20206	2	case	case	NN
18637	20206	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	20206	4	been	be	VBN
18637	20206	5	cited	cite	VBN
18637	20206	6	as	as	IN
18637	20206	7	supporting	support	VBG
18637	20206	8	the	the	DT
18637	20206	9	claim	claim	NN
18637	20206	10	that	that	IN
18637	20206	11	"	"	``
18637	20206	12	the	the	DT
18637	20206	13	right	right	NN
18637	20206	14	to	to	TO
18637	20206	15	pass	pass	VB
18637	20206	16	freely	freely	RB
18637	20206	17	from	from	IN
18637	20206	18	State	State	NNP
18637	20206	19	to	to	IN
18637	20206	20	State	State	NNP
18637	20206	21	"	"	``
18637	20206	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	20206	23	"	"	``
18637	20206	24	among	among	IN
18637	20206	25	the	the	DT
18637	20206	26	rights	right	NNS
18637	20206	27	and	and	CC
18637	20206	28	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	20206	29	of	of	IN
18637	20206	30	National	national	JJ
18637	20206	31	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	20206	32	"	"	''
18637	20206	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20206	34	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	20206	35	_	_	NNP
18637	20206	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	20206	37	_	_	NNP
18637	20206	38	New	New	NNP
18637	20206	39	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	20206	40	,	,	,
18637	20206	41	211	211	CD
18637	20206	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20206	43	78	78	CD
18637	20206	44	,	,	,
18637	20206	45	97	97	CD
18637	20206	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20206	47	1908	1908	CD
18637	20206	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20206	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20206	50	;	;	:
18637	20206	51	but	but	CC
18637	20206	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20206	53	was	be	VBD
18637	20206	54	pointed	point	VBN
18637	20206	55	out	out	RP
18637	20206	56	in	in	IN
18637	20206	57	United	United	NNP
18637	20206	58	States	States	NNP
18637	20206	59	_	_	NNP
18637	20206	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	20206	61	_	_	NNP
18637	20206	62	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	20206	63	,	,	,
18637	20206	64	254	254	CD
18637	20206	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20206	66	281	281	CD
18637	20206	67	,	,	,
18637	20206	68	299	299	CD
18637	20206	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20206	70	1920	1920	CD
18637	20206	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20206	72	,	,	,
18637	20206	73	that	that	IN
18637	20206	74	the	the	DT
18637	20206	75	statute	statute	NN
18637	20206	76	involved	involve	VBN
18637	20206	77	in	in	IN
18637	20206	78	the	the	DT
18637	20206	79	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	20206	80	Case	Case	NNP
18637	20206	81	was	be	VBD
18637	20206	82	held	hold	VBN
18637	20206	83	to	to	IN
18637	20206	84	burden	burden	NN
18637	20206	85	directly	directly	RB
18637	20206	86	the	the	DT
18637	20206	87	performance	performance	NN
18637	20206	88	by	by	IN
18637	20206	89	the	the	DT
18637	20206	90	United	United	NNP
18637	20206	91	States	States	NNP
18637	20206	92	of	of	IN
18637	20206	93	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20206	94	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	20206	95	functions	function	NNS
18637	20206	96	.	.	.
18637	20207	1	In	in	IN
18637	20207	2	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	20207	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20207	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	20207	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20207	6	Fears	Fears	NNP
18637	20207	7	,	,	,
18637	20207	8	179	179	CD
18637	20207	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20207	10	270	270	CD
18637	20207	11	,	,	,
18637	20207	12	274	274	CD
18637	20207	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20207	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	20207	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20207	16	,	,	,
18637	20207	17	a	a	DT
18637	20207	18	law	law	NN
18637	20207	19	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	20207	20	the	the	DT
18637	20207	21	business	business	NN
18637	20207	22	of	of	IN
18637	20207	23	hiring	hire	VBG
18637	20207	24	persons	person	NNS
18637	20207	25	to	to	IN
18637	20207	26	labor	labor	NN
18637	20207	27	outside	outside	IN
18637	20207	28	the	the	DT
18637	20207	29	State	state	NN
18637	20207	30	was	be	VBD
18637	20207	31	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	20207	32	on	on	IN
18637	20207	33	the	the	DT
18637	20207	34	ground	ground	NN
18637	20207	35	that	that	IN
18637	20207	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20207	37	affected	affect	VBD
18637	20207	38	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	20207	39	of	of	IN
18637	20207	40	egress	egress	NN
18637	20207	41	from	from	IN
18637	20207	42	the	the	DT
18637	20207	43	State	State	NNP
18637	20207	44	"	"	''
18637	20207	45	only	only	RB
18637	20207	46	incidentally	incidentally	RB
18637	20207	47	and	and	CC
18637	20207	48	remotely	remotely	RB
18637	20207	49	.	.	.
18637	20207	50	"	"	''
18637	20208	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20208	2	18	18	CD
18637	20208	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20208	4	United	United	NNP
18637	20208	5	States	States	NNP
18637	20208	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20208	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20208	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20208	9	Cruikshank	Cruikshank	NNP
18637	20208	10	,	,	,
18637	20208	11	92	92	CD
18637	20208	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20208	13	542	542	CD
18637	20208	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20208	15	1876	1876	CD
18637	20208	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20208	17	.	.	.
18637	20209	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20209	2	19	19	CD
18637	20209	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20209	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	20209	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	20209	6	Yarbrough	Yarbrough	NNP
18637	20209	7	,	,	,
18637	20209	8	110	110	CD
18637	20209	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20209	10	651	651	CD
18637	20209	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20209	12	1884	1884	CD
18637	20209	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20209	14	;	;	:
18637	20209	15	Wiley	Wiley	NNP
18637	20209	16	_	_	NNP
18637	20209	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	20209	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20209	19	Sinkler	Sinkler	NNP
18637	20209	20	,	,	,
18637	20209	21	179	179	CD
18637	20209	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20209	23	58	58	CD
18637	20209	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20209	25	1900	1900	CD
18637	20209	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20209	27	.	.	.
18637	20210	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20210	2	20	20	CD
18637	20210	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20210	4	United	United	NNP
18637	20210	5	States	States	NNP
18637	20210	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20210	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20210	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20210	9	Waddell	Waddell	NNP
18637	20210	10	,	,	,
18637	20210	11	112	112	CD
18637	20210	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20210	13	76	76	CD
18637	20210	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20210	15	1884	1884	CD
18637	20210	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20210	17	.	.	.
18637	20211	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20211	2	21	21	CD
18637	20211	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20211	4	Logan	Logan	NNP
18637	20211	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20211	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20211	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20211	8	United	United	NNP
18637	20211	9	States	States	NNP
18637	20211	10	,	,	,
18637	20211	11	144	144	CD
18637	20211	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20211	13	263	263	CD
18637	20211	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20211	15	1892	1892	CD
18637	20211	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20211	17	.	.	.
18637	20212	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20212	2	22	22	CD
18637	20212	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20212	4	Re	Re	NNP
18637	20212	5	Quarles	Quarles	NNP
18637	20212	6	,	,	,
18637	20212	7	158	158	CD
18637	20212	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20212	9	532	532	CD
18637	20212	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20212	11	1895	1895	CD
18637	20212	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20212	13	.	.	.
18637	20213	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20213	2	23	23	CD
18637	20213	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20213	4	Crutcher	Crutcher	NNP
18637	20213	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20213	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20213	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20213	8	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	20213	9	,	,	,
18637	20213	10	141	141	CD
18637	20213	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20213	12	47	47	CD
18637	20213	13	,	,	,
18637	20213	14	57	57	CD
18637	20213	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20213	16	1891	1891	CD
18637	20213	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20213	18	.	.	.
18637	20214	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20214	2	24	24	CD
18637	20214	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20214	4	307	307	CD
18637	20214	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20214	6	496	496	CD
18637	20214	7	.	.	.
18637	20215	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20215	2	25	25	CD
18637	20215	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20215	4	Concurring	concur	VBG
18637	20215	5	in	in	IN
18637	20215	6	the	the	DT
18637	20215	7	result	result	NN
18637	20215	8	,	,	,
18637	20215	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20215	10	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	20215	11	contended	contend	VBD
18637	20215	12	that	that	IN
18637	20215	13	the	the	DT
18637	20215	14	case	case	NN
18637	20215	15	should	should	MD
18637	20215	16	have	have	VB
18637	20215	17	been	be	VBN
18637	20215	18	disposed	dispose	VBN
18637	20215	19	of	of	IN
18637	20215	20	by	by	IN
18637	20215	21	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	20215	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	20215	23	the	the	DT
18637	20215	24	due	due	JJ
18637	20215	25	process	process	NN
18637	20215	26	,	,	,
18637	20215	27	rather	rather	RB
18637	20215	28	than	than	IN
18637	20215	29	the	the	DT
18637	20215	30	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	20215	31	and	and	CC
18637	20215	32	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	20215	33	,	,	,
18637	20215	34	clause	clause	NN
18637	20215	35	,	,	,
18637	20215	36	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	20215	37	as	as	IN
18637	20215	38	the	the	DT
18637	20215	39	record	record	NN
18637	20215	40	disclosed	disclose	VBD
18637	20215	41	that	that	IN
18637	20215	42	the	the	DT
18637	20215	43	complainants	complainant	NNS
18637	20215	44	had	have	VBD
18637	20215	45	not	not	RB
18637	20215	46	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	20215	47	the	the	DT
18637	20215	48	latter	latter	JJ
18637	20215	49	clause	clause	NN
18637	20215	50	and	and	CC
18637	20215	51	the	the	DT
18637	20215	52	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	20215	53	failed	fail	VBD
18637	20215	54	to	to	TO
18637	20215	55	indicate	indicate	VB
18637	20215	56	that	that	IN
18637	20215	57	any	any	DT
18637	20215	58	of	of	IN
18637	20215	59	the	the	DT
18637	20215	60	complainants	complainant	NNS
18637	20215	61	were	be	VBD
18637	20215	62	in	in	IN
18637	20215	63	fact	fact	NN
18637	20215	64	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20215	65	or	or	CC
18637	20215	66	that	that	IN
18637	20215	67	any	any	DT
18637	20215	68	relation	relation	NN
18637	20215	69	between	between	IN
18637	20215	70	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20215	71	and	and	CC
18637	20215	72	the	the	DT
18637	20215	73	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	20215	74	Government	Government	NNP
18637	20215	75	was	be	VBD
18637	20215	76	involved.--Ibid	involved.--ibid	CD
18637	20215	77	.	.	.
18637	20216	1	525	525	CD
18637	20216	2	-	-	SYM
18637	20216	3	527	527	CD
18637	20216	4	.	.	.
18637	20217	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20217	2	26	26	CD
18637	20217	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20217	4	314	314	CD
18637	20217	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20217	6	160	160	CD
18637	20217	7	,	,	,
18637	20217	8	177	177	CD
18637	20217	9	-	-	SYM
18637	20217	10	183	183	CD
18637	20217	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20217	12	1941	1941	CD
18637	20217	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20217	14	.	.	.
18637	20218	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20218	2	27	27	CD
18637	20218	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20218	4	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	20218	5	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	20218	6	,	,	,
18637	20218	7	Black	Black	NNP
18637	20218	8	,	,	,
18637	20218	9	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	20218	10	and	and	CC
18637	20218	11	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	20218	12	.	.	.
18637	20219	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20219	2	28	28	CD
18637	20219	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20219	4	6	6	CD
18637	20219	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	20219	6	.	.	.
18637	20220	1	35	35	CD
18637	20220	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20220	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	20220	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20220	5	.	.	.
18637	20221	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20221	2	29	29	CD
18637	20221	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20221	4	279	279	CD
18637	20221	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20221	6	245	245	CD
18637	20221	7	,	,	,
18637	20221	8	251	251	CD
18637	20221	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20221	10	1929	1929	CD
18637	20221	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20221	12	.	.	.
18637	20222	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20222	2	30	30	CD
18637	20222	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20222	4	296	296	CD
18637	20222	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20222	6	404	404	CD
18637	20222	7	.	.	.
18637	20223	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20223	2	31	31	CD
18637	20223	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20223	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20223	5	See	See	NNP
18637	20223	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20223	7	Madden	Madden	NNP
18637	20223	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20223	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20223	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20223	11	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	20223	12	,	,	,
18637	20223	13	309	309	CD
18637	20223	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20223	15	83	83	CD
18637	20223	16	,	,	,
18637	20223	17	93	93	CD
18637	20223	18	.	.	.
18637	20224	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20224	2	32	32	CD
18637	20224	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20224	4	296	296	CD
18637	20224	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20224	6	404	404	CD
18637	20224	7	,	,	,
18637	20224	8	444	444	CD
18637	20224	9	,	,	,
18637	20224	10	445	445	CD
18637	20224	11	-	-	SYM
18637	20224	12	446	446	CD
18637	20224	13	.	.	.
18637	20225	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20225	2	33	33	CD
18637	20225	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20225	4	332	332	CD
18637	20225	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20225	6	633	633	CD
18637	20225	7	,	,	,
18637	20225	8	645	645	CD
18637	20225	9	,	,	,
18637	20225	10	640	640	CD
18637	20225	11	.	.	.
18637	20226	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20226	2	34	34	CD
18637	20226	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20226	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20226	5	.	.	.
18637	20227	1	640	640	CD
18637	20227	2	.	.	.
18637	20228	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20228	2	35	35	CD
18637	20228	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20228	4	Holden	Holden	NNP
18637	20228	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20228	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20228	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20228	8	Hardy	Hardy	NNP
18637	20228	9	,	,	,
18637	20228	10	169	169	CD
18637	20228	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20228	12	366	366	CD
18637	20228	13	,	,	,
18637	20228	14	380	380	CD
18637	20228	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20228	16	1898	1898	CD
18637	20228	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20228	18	.	.	.
18637	20229	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20229	2	36	36	CD
18637	20229	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20229	4	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	20229	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20229	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20229	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20229	8	Fears	Fears	NNP
18637	20229	9	,	,	,
18637	20229	10	179	179	CD
18637	20229	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20229	12	270	270	CD
18637	20229	13	,	,	,
18637	20229	14	274	274	CD
18637	20229	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20229	16	1900	1900	CD
18637	20229	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20229	18	.	.	.
18637	20230	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20230	2	37	37	CD
18637	20230	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20230	4	Wilmington	Wilmington	NNP
18637	20230	5	Star	Star	NNP
18637	20230	6	Min	Min	NNP
18637	20230	7	.	.	.
18637	20231	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20231	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20231	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20231	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20231	5	Fulton	Fulton	NNP
18637	20231	6	,	,	,
18637	20231	7	205	205	CD
18637	20231	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20231	9	60	60	CD
18637	20231	10	,	,	,
18637	20231	11	74	74	CD
18637	20231	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20231	13	1907	1907	CD
18637	20231	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20231	15	.	.	.
18637	20232	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20232	2	38	38	CD
18637	20232	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20232	4	Heim	Heim	NNP
18637	20232	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20232	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20232	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20232	8	McCall	McCall	NNP
18637	20232	9	,	,	,
18637	20232	10	239	239	CD
18637	20232	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20232	12	175	175	CD
18637	20232	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20232	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	20232	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20232	16	;	;	:
18637	20232	17	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	20232	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20232	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	20232	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20232	21	New	New	NNP
18637	20232	22	York	York	NNP
18637	20232	23	,	,	,
18637	20232	24	239	239	CD
18637	20232	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20232	26	195	195	CD
18637	20232	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20232	28	1915	1915	CD
18637	20232	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20232	30	.	.	.
18637	20233	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20233	2	39	39	CD
18637	20233	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20233	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20233	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20234	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20234	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20234	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20234	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20234	5	Castle	Castle	NNP
18637	20234	6	,	,	,
18637	20234	7	224	224	CD
18637	20234	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20234	9	541	541	CD
18637	20234	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20234	11	1912	1912	CD
18637	20234	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20234	13	.	.	.
18637	20235	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20235	2	40	40	CD
18637	20235	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20235	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	20235	5	U.	U.	NNP
18637	20235	6	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	20235	7	.	.	.
18637	20236	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20236	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20236	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20236	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20236	5	Commercial	Commercial	NNP
18637	20236	6	Milling	Milling	NNP
18637	20236	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20236	8	,	,	,
18637	20236	9	218	218	CD
18637	20236	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20236	11	406	406	CD
18637	20236	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20236	13	1910	1910	CD
18637	20236	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20236	15	.	.	.
18637	20237	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20237	2	41	41	CD
18637	20237	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20237	4	Bradwell	Bradwell	NNP
18637	20237	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20237	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20237	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20237	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	20237	9	,	,	,
18637	20237	10	16	16	CD
18637	20237	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	20237	12	.	.	.
18637	20238	1	130	130	CD
18637	20238	2	,	,	,
18637	20238	3	139	139	CD
18637	20238	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20238	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	20238	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20238	7	;	;	:
18637	20238	8	Re	Re	NNP
18637	20238	9	Lockwood	Lockwood	NNP
18637	20238	10	,	,	,
18637	20238	11	154	154	CD
18637	20238	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20238	13	116	116	CD
18637	20238	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20238	15	1894	1894	CD
18637	20238	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20238	17	.	.	.
18637	20239	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20239	2	42	42	CD
18637	20239	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20239	4	Kirtland	Kirtland	NNP
18637	20239	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20239	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20239	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20239	8	Hotchkiss	Hotchkiss	NNP
18637	20239	9	,	,	,
18637	20239	10	100	100	CD
18637	20239	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20239	12	491	491	CD
18637	20239	13	,	,	,
18637	20239	14	499	499	CD
18637	20239	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20239	16	1879	1879	CD
18637	20239	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20239	18	.	.	.
18637	20240	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20240	2	43	43	CD
18637	20240	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20240	4	Bartemeyer	Bartemeyer	NNP
18637	20240	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20240	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20240	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20240	8	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	20240	9	,	,	,
18637	20240	10	18	18	CD
18637	20240	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	20240	12	.	.	.
18637	20241	1	129	129	CD
18637	20241	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20241	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	20241	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20241	5	;	;	:
18637	20241	6	Mugler	Mugler	NNP
18637	20241	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20241	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20241	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20241	10	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20241	11	,	,	,
18637	20241	12	123	123	CD
18637	20241	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20241	14	623	623	CD
18637	20241	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20241	16	1887	1887	CD
18637	20241	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20241	18	;	;	:
18637	20241	19	Crowley	Crowley	NNP
18637	20241	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20241	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	20241	22	_	_	NNP
18637	20241	23	Christensen	Christensen	NNP
18637	20241	24	,	,	,
18637	20241	25	137	137	CD
18637	20241	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20241	27	86	86	CD
18637	20241	28	,	,	,
18637	20241	29	91	91	CD
18637	20241	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20241	31	1890	1890	CD
18637	20241	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20241	33	;	;	:
18637	20241	34	Giozza	Giozza	NNP
18637	20241	35	_	_	NNP
18637	20241	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	20241	37	_	_	NNP
18637	20241	38	Tiernan	Tiernan	NNP
18637	20241	39	,	,	,
18637	20241	40	148	148	CD
18637	20241	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20241	42	657	657	CD
18637	20241	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20241	44	1893	1893	CD
18637	20241	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20241	46	.	.	.
18637	20242	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20242	2	44	44	CD
18637	20242	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20242	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	20242	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	20242	6	Kemmler	Kemmler	NNP
18637	20242	7	,	,	,
18637	20242	8	136	136	CD
18637	20242	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20242	10	436	436	CD
18637	20242	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20242	12	1890	1890	CD
18637	20242	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20242	14	.	.	.
18637	20243	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20243	2	45	45	CD
18637	20243	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20243	4	Minor	Minor	NNP
18637	20243	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20243	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20243	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20243	8	Happersett	Happersett	NNP
18637	20243	9	,	,	,
18637	20243	10	21	21	CD
18637	20243	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	20243	12	.	.	.
18637	20244	1	162	162	CD
18637	20244	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20244	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	20244	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20244	5	.	.	.
18637	20245	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20245	2	46	46	CD
18637	20245	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20245	4	Pope	Pope	NNP
18637	20245	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20245	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20245	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20245	8	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	20245	9	,	,	,
18637	20245	10	193	193	CD
18637	20245	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20245	12	621	621	CD
18637	20245	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20245	14	1904	1904	CD
18637	20245	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20245	16	.	.	.
18637	20246	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20246	2	47	47	CD
18637	20246	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20246	4	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	20246	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20246	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20246	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20246	8	Spokane	Spokane	NNP
18637	20246	9	,	,	,
18637	20246	10	P.	P.	NNP
18637	20246	11	&	&	CC
18637	20246	12	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	20247	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20247	2	,	,	,
18637	20247	3	258	258	CD
18637	20247	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20247	5	314	314	CD
18637	20247	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20247	7	1922	1922	CD
18637	20247	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20247	9	.	.	.
18637	20248	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20248	2	48	48	CD
18637	20248	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20248	4	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	20248	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20248	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20248	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20248	8	Sauvinet	Sauvinet	NNP
18637	20248	9	,	,	,
18637	20248	10	92	92	CD
18637	20248	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20248	12	90	90	CD
18637	20248	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20248	14	1876	1876	CD
18637	20248	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20248	16	.	.	.
18637	20249	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20249	2	49	49	CD
18637	20249	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20249	4	Presser	Presser	NNP
18637	20249	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20249	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20249	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20249	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	20249	9	,	,	,
18637	20249	10	116	116	CD
18637	20249	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20249	12	252	252	CD
18637	20249	13	,	,	,
18637	20249	14	267	267	CD
18637	20249	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20249	16	1886	1886	CD
18637	20249	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20249	18	.	.	.
18637	20250	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20250	2	50	50	CD
18637	20250	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20250	4	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	20250	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20250	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20250	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20250	8	Dow	Dow	NNP
18637	20250	9	,	,	,
18637	20250	10	176	176	CD
18637	20250	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20250	12	581	581	CD
18637	20250	13	,	,	,
18637	20250	14	596	596	CD
18637	20250	15	,	,	,
18637	20250	16	597	597	CD
18637	20250	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	20250	18	598	598	CD
18637	20250	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20250	20	1900	1900	CD
18637	20250	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20250	22	.	.	.
18637	20251	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20251	2	51	51	CD
18637	20251	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20251	4	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	20251	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20251	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20251	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20251	8	New	New	NNP
18637	20251	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	20251	10	,	,	,
18637	20251	11	211	211	CD
18637	20251	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20251	13	78	78	CD
18637	20251	14	,	,	,
18637	20251	15	91	91	CD
18637	20251	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	20251	17	98	98	CD
18637	20251	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20251	19	1908	1908	CD
18637	20251	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20251	21	.	.	.
18637	20252	1	Reaffirmed	Reaffirmed	NNP
18637	20252	2	in	in	IN
18637	20252	3	Adamson	Adamson	NNP
18637	20252	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20252	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	20252	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20252	7	California	California	NNP
18637	20252	8	,	,	,
18637	20252	9	332	332	CD
18637	20252	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20252	11	46	46	CD
18637	20252	12	,	,	,
18637	20252	13	51	51	CD
18637	20252	14	-	-	SYM
18637	20252	15	53	53	CD
18637	20252	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20252	17	1947	1947	CD
18637	20252	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20252	19	.	.	.
18637	20253	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20253	2	52	52	CD
18637	20253	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20253	4	New	New	NNP
18637	20253	5	York	York	NNP
18637	20253	6	ex	ex	NN
18637	20253	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	20253	8	.	.	.
18637	20254	1	Bryant	Bryant	NNP
18637	20254	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20254	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20254	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20254	5	Zimmerman	Zimmerman	NNP
18637	20254	6	,	,	,
18637	20254	7	278	278	CD
18637	20254	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20254	9	63	63	CD
18637	20254	10	,	,	,
18637	20254	11	71	71	CD
18637	20254	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20254	13	1928	1928	CD
18637	20254	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20254	15	.	.	.
18637	20255	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20255	2	53	53	CD
18637	20255	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20255	4	Palko	Palko	NNP
18637	20255	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20255	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20255	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20255	8	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	20255	9	,	,	,
18637	20255	10	302	302	CD
18637	20255	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20255	12	319	319	CD
18637	20255	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20255	14	1937	1937	CD
18637	20255	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20255	16	.	.	.
18637	20256	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20256	2	54	54	CD
18637	20256	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20256	4	Breedlove	Breedlove	NNP
18637	20256	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20256	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20256	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20256	8	Suttles	Suttles	NNP
18637	20256	9	,	,	,
18637	20256	10	302	302	CD
18637	20256	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20256	12	277	277	CD
18637	20256	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20256	14	1937	1937	CD
18637	20256	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20256	16	.	.	.
18637	20257	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20257	2	55	55	CD
18637	20257	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20257	4	Madden	Madden	NNP
18637	20257	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20257	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20257	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20257	8	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	20257	9	,	,	,
18637	20257	10	309	309	CD
18637	20257	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20257	12	83	83	CD
18637	20257	13	,	,	,
18637	20257	14	92	92	CD
18637	20257	15	-	-	SYM
18637	20257	16	93	93	CD
18637	20257	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20257	18	1940	1940	CD
18637	20257	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20257	20	;	;	:
18637	20257	21	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	20257	22	Colgate	Colgate	NNP
18637	20257	23	_	_	NNP
18637	20257	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	20257	25	_	_	NNP
18637	20257	26	Harvey	Harvey	NNP
18637	20257	27	,	,	,
18637	20257	28	296	296	CD
18637	20257	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20257	30	404	404	CD
18637	20257	31	,	,	,
18637	20257	32	430	430	CD
18637	20257	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20257	34	1935	1935	CD
18637	20257	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20257	36	.	.	.
18637	20258	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20258	2	56	56	CD
18637	20258	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20258	4	Snowden	Snowden	NNP
18637	20258	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20258	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20258	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20258	8	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	20258	9	,	,	,
18637	20258	10	321	321	CD
18637	20258	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20258	12	1	1	CD
18637	20258	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20258	14	1944	1944	CD
18637	20258	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20258	16	.	.	.
18637	20259	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20259	2	57	57	CD
18637	20259	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20259	4	MacDougall	MacDougall	NNP
18637	20259	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20259	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20259	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20259	8	Green	Green	NNP
18637	20259	9	,	,	,
18637	20259	10	335	335	CD
18637	20259	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20259	12	281	281	CD
18637	20259	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20259	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	20259	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20259	16	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20259	17	58	58	CD
18637	20259	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20259	19	Hibben	Hibben	NNP
18637	20259	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20259	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	20259	22	_	_	NNP
18637	20259	23	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	20259	24	,	,	,
18637	20259	25	191	191	CD
18637	20259	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20259	27	310	310	CD
18637	20259	28	,	,	,
18637	20259	29	325	325	CD
18637	20259	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20259	31	1903	1903	CD
18637	20259	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20259	33	.	.	.
18637	20260	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20260	2	59	59	CD
18637	20260	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20260	4	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	20260	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20260	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20260	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20260	8	Greenwich	Greenwich	NNP
18637	20260	9	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20260	10	.	.	.
18637	20261	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20261	2	,	,	,
18637	20261	3	199	199	CD
18637	20261	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20261	5	401	401	CD
18637	20261	6	,	,	,
18637	20261	7	410	410	CD
18637	20261	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20261	9	1905	1905	CD
18637	20261	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20261	11	.	.	.
18637	20262	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20262	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20262	3	also	also	RB
18637	20262	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20262	5	French	French	NNP
18637	20262	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20262	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20262	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20262	9	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	20262	10	Asphalt	Asphalt	NNP
18637	20262	11	Paving	Paving	NNP
18637	20262	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20262	13	,	,	,
18637	20262	14	181	181	CD
18637	20262	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20262	16	324	324	CD
18637	20262	17	,	,	,
18637	20262	18	328	328	CD
18637	20262	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20262	20	1901	1901	CD
18637	20262	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20262	22	.	.	.
18637	20263	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20263	2	60	60	CD
18637	20263	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20263	4	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	20263	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20263	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20263	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20263	8	Sandford	Sandford	NNP
18637	20263	9	,	,	,
18637	20263	10	19	19	CD
18637	20263	11	How	how	WRB
18637	20263	12	.	.	.
18637	20264	1	393	393	CD
18637	20264	2	,	,	,
18637	20264	3	450	450	CD
18637	20264	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20264	5	1857	1857	CD
18637	20264	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20264	7	,	,	,
18637	20264	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	20264	9	the	the	DT
18637	20264	10	exception	exception	NN
18637	20264	11	.	.	.
18637	20265	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20265	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20265	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20265	4	pp	pp	NNP
18637	20265	5	.	.	.
18637	20266	1	963	963	CD
18637	20266	2	-	-	SYM
18637	20266	3	964	964	CD
18637	20266	4	.	.	.
18637	20267	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20267	2	61	61	CD
18637	20267	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20267	4	16	16	CD
18637	20267	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	20267	6	.	.	.
18637	20268	1	36	36	CD
18637	20268	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20268	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	20268	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20268	5	.	.	.
18637	20269	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20269	2	62	62	CD
18637	20269	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20269	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20269	5	.	.	.
18637	20270	1	80	80	CD
18637	20270	2	-	-	SYM
18637	20270	3	81	81	CD
18637	20270	4	.	.	.
18637	20271	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20271	2	63	63	CD
18637	20271	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20271	4	94	94	CD
18637	20271	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20271	6	113	113	CD
18637	20271	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20271	8	1877	1877	CD
18637	20271	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20271	10	.	.	.
18637	20272	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20272	2	64	64	CD
18637	20272	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20272	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20272	5	.	.	.
18637	20273	1	134	134	CD
18637	20273	2	.	.	.
18637	20274	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20274	2	65	65	CD
18637	20274	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20274	4	96	96	CD
18637	20274	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20274	6	97	97	CD
18637	20274	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20274	8	1878	1878	CD
18637	20274	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20274	10	.	.	.
18637	20275	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20275	2	66	66	CD
18637	20275	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20275	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20275	5	.	.	.
18637	20276	1	103	103	CD
18637	20276	2	-	-	SYM
18637	20276	3	104	104	CD
18637	20276	4	.	.	.
18637	20277	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20277	2	67	67	CD
18637	20277	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20277	4	110	110	CD
18637	20277	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20277	6	516	516	CD
18637	20277	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20277	8	1884	1884	CD
18637	20277	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20277	10	.	.	.
18637	20278	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20278	2	68	68	CD
18637	20278	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20278	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20278	5	.	.	.
18637	20279	1	528	528	CD
18637	20279	2	,	,	,
18637	20279	3	532	532	CD
18637	20279	4	,	,	,
18637	20279	5	536	536	CD
18637	20279	6	.	.	.
18637	20280	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20280	2	69	69	CD
18637	20280	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20280	4	94	94	CD
18637	20280	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20280	6	113	113	CD
18637	20280	7	,	,	,
18637	20280	8	141	141	CD
18637	20280	9	-	-	SYM
18637	20280	10	148	148	CD
18637	20280	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20280	12	1877	1877	CD
18637	20280	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20280	14	.	.	.
18637	20281	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20281	2	70	70	CD
18637	20281	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20281	4	123	123	CD
18637	20281	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20281	6	623	623	CD
18637	20281	7	,	,	,
18637	20281	8	661	661	CD
18637	20281	9	.	.	.
18637	20282	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20282	2	71	71	CD
18637	20282	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20282	4	16	16	CD
18637	20282	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	20282	6	.	.	.
18637	20283	1	36	36	CD
18637	20283	2	,	,	,
18637	20283	3	113	113	CD
18637	20283	4	-	-	SYM
18637	20283	5	114	114	CD
18637	20283	6	,	,	,
18637	20283	7	116	116	CD
18637	20283	8	,	,	,
18637	20283	9	122	122	CD
18637	20283	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20283	11	1873	1873	CD
18637	20283	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20283	13	.	.	.
18637	20284	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20284	2	72	72	CD
18637	20284	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20284	4	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	20284	5	&	&	CC
18637	20284	6	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	20284	7	Association	Association	NNP
18637	20284	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20284	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20284	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20284	11	Topeka	Topeka	NNP
18637	20284	12	,	,	,
18637	20284	13	20	20	CD
18637	20284	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	20284	15	.	.	.
18637	20285	1	655	655	CD
18637	20285	2	,	,	,
18637	20285	3	663	663	CD
18637	20285	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20285	5	1875).--"There	1875).--"There	NNP
18637	20285	6	are	be	VBP
18637	20285	7	*	*	NFP
18637	20285	8	*	*	NFP
18637	20285	9	*	*	NFP
18637	20285	10	rights	right	NNS
18637	20285	11	in	in	IN
18637	20285	12	every	every	DT
18637	20285	13	free	free	JJ
18637	20285	14	government	government	NN
18637	20285	15	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	20285	16	the	the	DT
18637	20285	17	control	control	NN
18637	20285	18	of	of	IN
18637	20285	19	the	the	DT
18637	20285	20	State	State	NNP
18637	20285	21	.	.	.
18637	20286	1	*	*	NFP
18637	20286	2	*	*	NFP
18637	20286	3	*	*	NFP
18637	20286	4	There	there	EX
18637	20286	5	are	be	VBP
18637	20286	6	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	20286	7	on	on	IN
18637	20286	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20286	9	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	20286	10	power	power	NN
18637	20286	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20286	12	which	which	WDT
18637	20286	13	grow	grow	VBP
18637	20286	14	out	out	IN
18637	20286	15	of	of	IN
18637	20286	16	the	the	DT
18637	20286	17	essential	essential	JJ
18637	20286	18	nature	nature	NN
18637	20286	19	of	of	IN
18637	20286	20	all	all	DT
18637	20286	21	free	free	JJ
18637	20286	22	governments	government	NNS
18637	20286	23	.	.	.
18637	20287	1	Implied	implied	JJ
18637	20287	2	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	20287	3	of	of	IN
18637	20287	4	individual	individual	JJ
18637	20287	5	rights	right	NNS
18637	20287	6	,	,	,
18637	20287	7	without	without	IN
18637	20287	8	which	which	WDT
18637	20287	9	the	the	DT
18637	20287	10	social	social	JJ
18637	20287	11	compact	compact	NN
18637	20287	12	could	could	MD
18637	20287	13	not	not	RB
18637	20287	14	exist	exist	VB
18637	20287	15	,	,	,
18637	20287	16	*	*	NFP
18637	20287	17	*	*	NFP
18637	20287	18	*	*	NFP
18637	20287	19	"	"	''
18637	20287	20	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20287	21	73	73	CD
18637	20287	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20287	23	"	"	``
18637	20287	24	Rights	right	NNS
18637	20287	25	to	to	IN
18637	20287	26	life	life	NN
18637	20287	27	,	,	,
18637	20287	28	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	20287	29	,	,	,
18637	20287	30	and	and	CC
18637	20287	31	the	the	DT
18637	20287	32	pursuit	pursuit	NN
18637	20287	33	of	of	IN
18637	20287	34	happiness	happiness	NN
18637	20287	35	are	be	VBP
18637	20287	36	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
18637	20287	37	to	to	IN
18637	20287	38	the	the	DT
18637	20287	39	rights	right	NNS
18637	20287	40	of	of	IN
18637	20287	41	life	life	NN
18637	20287	42	,	,	,
18637	20287	43	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	20287	44	,	,	,
18637	20287	45	and	and	CC
18637	20287	46	property	property	NN
18637	20287	47	.	.	.
18637	20288	1	These	these	DT
18637	20288	2	are	be	VBP
18637	20288	3	the	the	DT
18637	20288	4	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	20288	5	rights	right	NNS
18637	20288	6	which	which	WDT
18637	20288	7	can	can	MD
18637	20288	8	only	only	RB
18637	20288	9	be	be	VB
18637	20288	10	taken	take	VBN
18637	20288	11	away	away	RP
18637	20288	12	by	by	IN
18637	20288	13	due	due	JJ
18637	20288	14	process	process	NN
18637	20288	15	of	of	IN
18637	20288	16	law	law	NN
18637	20288	17	,	,	,
18637	20288	18	and	and	CC
18637	20288	19	which	which	WDT
18637	20288	20	can	can	MD
18637	20288	21	only	only	RB
18637	20288	22	be	be	VB
18637	20288	23	interfered	interfere	VBN
18637	20288	24	with	with	IN
18637	20288	25	,	,	,
18637	20288	26	or	or	CC
18637	20288	27	the	the	DT
18637	20288	28	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	20288	29	of	of	IN
18637	20288	30	which	which	WDT
18637	20288	31	can	can	MD
18637	20288	32	only	only	RB
18637	20288	33	be	be	VB
18637	20288	34	modified	modify	VBN
18637	20288	35	,	,	,
18637	20288	36	by	by	IN
18637	20288	37	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	20288	38	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	20288	39	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	20288	40	or	or	CC
18637	20288	41	proper	proper	JJ
18637	20288	42	for	for	IN
18637	20288	43	the	the	DT
18637	20288	44	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	20288	45	good	good	NN
18637	20288	46	of	of	IN
18637	20288	47	all	all	DT
18637	20288	48	;	;	:
18637	20288	49	*	*	NFP
18637	20288	50	*	*	NFP
18637	20288	51	*	*	NFP
18637	20288	52	This	this	DT
18637	20288	53	right	right	NN
18637	20288	54	to	to	TO
18637	20288	55	choose	choose	VB
18637	20288	56	one	one	NN
18637	20288	57	's	's	POS
18637	20288	58	calling	calling	NN
18637	20288	59	is	be	VBZ
18637	20288	60	an	an	DT
18637	20288	61	essential	essential	JJ
18637	20288	62	part	part	NN
18637	20288	63	of	of	IN
18637	20288	64	that	that	DT
18637	20288	65	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	20288	66	which	which	WDT
18637	20288	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20288	68	is	be	VBZ
18637	20288	69	the	the	DT
18637	20288	70	object	object	NN
18637	20288	71	of	of	IN
18637	20288	72	government	government	NN
18637	20288	73	to	to	TO
18637	20288	74	protect	protect	VB
18637	20288	75	;	;	:
18637	20288	76	and	and	CC
18637	20288	77	a	a	DT
18637	20288	78	calling	calling	NN
18637	20288	79	,	,	,
18637	20288	80	when	when	WRB
18637	20288	81	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	20288	82	,	,	,
18637	20288	83	is	be	VBZ
18637	20288	84	a	a	DT
18637	20288	85	man	man	NN
18637	20288	86	's	's	POS
18637	20288	87	property	property	NN
18637	20288	88	and	and	CC
18637	20288	89	right	right	JJ
18637	20288	90	.	.	.
18637	20289	1	*	*	NFP
18637	20289	2	*	*	NFP
18637	20289	3	*	*	NFP
18637	20289	4	A	a	DT
18637	20289	5	law	law	NN
18637	20289	6	which	which	WDT
18637	20289	7	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	20289	8	a	a	DT
18637	20289	9	large	large	JJ
18637	20289	10	class	class	NN
18637	20289	11	of	of	IN
18637	20289	12	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20289	13	from	from	IN
18637	20289	14	adopting	adopt	VBG
18637	20289	15	a	a	DT
18637	20289	16	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	20289	17	employment	employment	NN
18637	20289	18	,	,	,
18637	20289	19	or	or	CC
18637	20289	20	from	from	IN
18637	20289	21	following	follow	VBG
18637	20289	22	a	a	DT
18637	20289	23	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	20289	24	employment	employment	NN
18637	20289	25	previously	previously	RB
18637	20289	26	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	20289	27	,	,	,
18637	20289	28	does	do	VBZ
18637	20289	29	deprive	deprive	VB
18637	20289	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20289	31	of	of	IN
18637	20289	32	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	20289	33	as	as	RB
18637	20289	34	well	well	RB
18637	20289	35	as	as	IN
18637	20289	36	property	property	NN
18637	20289	37	,	,	,
18637	20289	38	without	without	IN
18637	20289	39	due	due	JJ
18637	20289	40	process	process	NN
18637	20289	41	of	of	IN
18637	20289	42	law	law	NN
18637	20289	43	.	.	.
18637	20289	44	"	"	''
18637	20290	1	--Slaughter	--Slaughter	:
18637	20290	2	-	-	:
18637	20290	3	House	House	NNP
18637	20290	4	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	20290	5	,	,	,
18637	20290	6	16	16	CD
18637	20290	7	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	20290	8	.	.	.
18637	20291	1	36	36	CD
18637	20291	2	,	,	,
18637	20291	3	116	116	CD
18637	20291	4	,	,	,
18637	20291	5	122	122	CD
18637	20291	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20291	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20291	8	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	20291	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20291	10	.	.	.
18637	20292	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20292	2	74	74	CD
18637	20292	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20292	4	143	143	CD
18637	20292	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20292	6	517	517	CD
18637	20292	7	,	,	,
18637	20292	8	551	551	CD
18637	20292	9	.	.	.
18637	20293	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20293	2	75	75	CD
18637	20293	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20293	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20293	5	See	See	NNP
18637	20293	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20293	7	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	20293	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20293	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20293	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20293	11	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	20293	12	,	,	,
18637	20293	13	6	6	CD
18637	20293	14	Cr	cr	NN
18637	20293	15	.	.	.
18637	20294	1	87	87	CD
18637	20294	2	,	,	,
18637	20294	3	128	128	CD
18637	20294	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20294	5	1810	1810	CD
18637	20294	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20294	7	.	.	.
18637	20295	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20295	2	76	76	CD
18637	20295	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20295	4	94	94	CD
18637	20295	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20295	6	113	113	CD
18637	20295	7	,	,	,
18637	20295	8	123	123	CD
18637	20295	9	,	,	,
18637	20295	10	132	132	CD
18637	20295	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20295	12	1877	1877	CD
18637	20295	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20295	14	.	.	.
18637	20296	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20296	2	77	77	CD
18637	20296	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20296	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20296	5	.	.	.
18637	20297	1	132	132	CD
18637	20297	2	.	.	.
18637	20298	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20298	2	78	78	CD
18637	20298	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20298	4	123	123	CD
18637	20298	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20298	6	623	623	CD
18637	20298	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20298	8	1887	1887	CD
18637	20298	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20298	10	.	.	.
18637	20299	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20299	2	79	79	CD
18637	20299	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20299	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20299	5	.	.	.
18637	20300	1	662.--"We	662.--"we	CD
18637	20300	2	can	can	MD
18637	20300	3	not	not	RB
18637	20300	4	shut	shut	VB
18637	20300	5	out	out	IN
18637	20300	6	of	of	IN
18637	20300	7	view	view	NN
18637	20300	8	the	the	DT
18637	20300	9	fact	fact	NN
18637	20300	10	,	,	,
18637	20300	11	within	within	IN
18637	20300	12	the	the	DT
18637	20300	13	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	20300	14	of	of	IN
18637	20300	15	all	all	DT
18637	20300	16	,	,	,
18637	20300	17	that	that	IN
18637	20300	18	the	the	DT
18637	20300	19	public	public	JJ
18637	20300	20	health	health	NN
18637	20300	21	,	,	,
18637	20300	22	the	the	DT
18637	20300	23	public	public	JJ
18637	20300	24	morals	moral	NNS
18637	20300	25	,	,	,
18637	20300	26	and	and	CC
18637	20300	27	the	the	DT
18637	20300	28	public	public	JJ
18637	20300	29	safety	safety	NN
18637	20300	30	,	,	,
18637	20300	31	may	may	MD
18637	20300	32	be	be	VB
18637	20300	33	endangered	endanger	VBN
18637	20300	34	by	by	IN
18637	20300	35	the	the	DT
18637	20300	36	general	general	JJ
18637	20300	37	use	use	NN
18637	20300	38	of	of	IN
18637	20300	39	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	20300	40	drinks	drink	NNS
18637	20300	41	;	;	:
18637	20300	42	nor	nor	CC
18637	20300	43	the	the	DT
18637	20300	44	fact	fact	NN
18637	20300	45	,	,	,
18637	20300	46	*	*	NFP
18637	20300	47	*	*	NFP
18637	20300	48	*	*	NFP
18637	20300	49	,	,	,
18637	20300	50	that	that	IN
18637	20300	51	*	*	NFP
18637	20300	52	*	*	NFP
18637	20300	53	*	*	NFP
18637	20300	54	pauperism	pauperism	NN
18637	20300	55	,	,	,
18637	20300	56	and	and	CC
18637	20300	57	crime	crime	NN
18637	20300	58	*	*	NFP
18637	20300	59	*	*	NFP
18637	20300	60	*	*	NFP
18637	20300	61	are	be	VBP
18637	20300	62	,	,	,
18637	20300	63	in	in	IN
18637	20300	64	some	some	DT
18637	20300	65	degree	degree	NN
18637	20300	66	,	,	,
18637	20300	67	at	at	IN
18637	20300	68	least	least	JJS
18637	20300	69	,	,	,
18637	20300	70	traceable	traceable	JJ
18637	20300	71	to	to	IN
18637	20300	72	this	this	DT
18637	20300	73	evil	evil	NN
18637	20300	74	.	.	.
18637	20300	75	"	"	''
18637	20301	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20301	2	80	80	CD
18637	20301	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20301	4	127	127	CD
18637	20301	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20301	6	678	678	CD
18637	20301	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20301	8	1888	1888	CD
18637	20301	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20301	10	.	.	.
18637	20302	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20302	2	81	81	CD
18637	20302	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20302	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20302	5	.	.	.
18637	20303	1	685	685	CD
18637	20303	2	.	.	.
18637	20304	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20304	2	82	82	CD
18637	20304	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20304	4	169	169	CD
18637	20304	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20304	6	366	366	CD
18637	20304	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20304	8	1898	1898	CD
18637	20304	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20304	10	.	.	.
18637	20305	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20305	2	83	83	CD
18637	20305	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20305	4	198	198	CD
18637	20305	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20305	6	45	45	CD
18637	20305	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20305	8	1905	1905	CD
18637	20305	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20305	10	.	.	.
18637	20306	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20306	2	84	84	CD
18637	20306	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20306	4	127	127	CD
18637	20306	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20306	6	678	678	CD
18637	20306	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20306	8	1888	1888	CD
18637	20306	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20306	10	.	.	.
18637	20307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20307	2	85	85	CD
18637	20307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20307	4	123	123	CD
18637	20307	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20307	6	623	623	CD
18637	20307	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20307	8	1887	1887	CD
18637	20307	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20307	10	.	.	.
18637	20308	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20308	2	86	86	CD
18637	20308	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20308	4	169	169	CD
18637	20308	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20308	6	366	366	CD
18637	20308	7	,	,	,
18637	20308	8	398	398	CD
18637	20308	9	.	.	.
18637	20309	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20309	2	87	87	CD
18637	20309	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20309	4	198	198	CD
18637	20309	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20309	6	45	45	CD
18637	20309	7	,	,	,
18637	20309	8	58	58	CD
18637	20309	9	-	-	SYM
18637	20309	10	59	59	CD
18637	20309	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20309	12	1905	1905	CD
18637	20309	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20309	14	.	.	.
18637	20310	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20310	2	88	88	CD
18637	20310	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20310	4	198	198	CD
18637	20310	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20310	6	45	45	CD
18637	20310	7	,	,	,
18637	20310	8	71	71	CD
18637	20310	9	-	-	SYM
18637	20310	10	74	74	CD
18637	20310	11	.	.	.
18637	20311	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20311	2	89	89	CD
18637	20311	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20311	4	198	198	CD
18637	20311	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20311	6	45	45	CD
18637	20311	7	,	,	,
18637	20311	8	75	75	CD
18637	20311	9	-	-	SYM
18637	20311	10	76	76	CD
18637	20311	11	.	.	.
18637	20312	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20312	2	90	90	CD
18637	20312	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20312	4	243	243	CD
18637	20312	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20312	6	426	426	CD
18637	20312	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20312	8	1917	1917	CD
18637	20312	9	.	.	.
18637	20312	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20313	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20313	2	91	91	CD
18637	20313	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20313	4	208	208	CD
18637	20313	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20313	6	412	412	CD
18637	20313	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20313	8	1908	1908	CD
18637	20313	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20313	10	.	.	.
18637	20314	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20314	2	92	92	CD
18637	20314	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20314	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20314	5	.	.	.
18637	20315	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20315	2	93	93	CD
18637	20315	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20315	4	Adkins	Adkins	NNPS
18637	20315	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20315	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20315	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20315	8	Children	Children	NNP
18637	20315	9	's	's	POS
18637	20315	10	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	20315	11	,	,	,
18637	20315	12	261	261	CD
18637	20315	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20315	14	525	525	CD
18637	20315	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20315	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	20315	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20315	18	;	;	:
18637	20315	19	Stettler	Stettler	NNP
18637	20315	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20315	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	20315	22	_	_	NNP
18637	20315	23	O'Hara	O'Hara	NNP
18637	20315	24	,	,	,
18637	20315	25	243	243	CD
18637	20315	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20315	27	629	629	CD
18637	20315	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20315	29	1917	1917	CD
18637	20315	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20315	31	;	;	:
18637	20315	32	Morehead	Morehead	NNP
18637	20315	33	_	_	NNP
18637	20315	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	20315	35	_	_	NNP
18637	20315	36	New	New	NNP
18637	20315	37	York	York	NNP
18637	20315	38	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20315	39	rel	rel	NN
18637	20315	40	.	.	.
18637	20316	1	Tipaldo	Tipaldo	NNP
18637	20316	2	,	,	,
18637	20316	3	298	298	CD
18637	20316	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20316	5	587	587	CD
18637	20316	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20316	7	1936	1936	CD
18637	20316	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20316	9	;	;	,
18637	20316	10	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	20316	11	by	by	IN
18637	20316	12	West	West	NNP
18637	20316	13	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	20316	14	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	20316	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20316	16	_	_	NNP
18637	20316	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	20316	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20316	19	Parrish	Parrish	NNP
18637	20316	20	,	,	,
18637	20316	21	300	300	CD
18637	20316	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20316	23	379	379	CD
18637	20316	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20316	25	1937	1937	CD
18637	20316	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20316	27	.	.	.
18637	20317	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20317	2	94	94	CD
18637	20317	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20317	4	West	West	NNP
18637	20317	5	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	20317	6	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	20317	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20317	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20317	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20317	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20317	11	Parrish	Parrish	NNP
18637	20317	12	,	,	,
18637	20317	13	300	300	CD
18637	20317	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20317	15	379	379	CD
18637	20317	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20317	17	1937	1937	CD
18637	20317	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20317	19	.	.	.
18637	20318	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	20318	2	the	the	DT
18637	20318	3	National	National	NNP
18637	20318	4	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	20318	5	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	20318	6	Act	Act	NNP
18637	20318	7	was	be	VBD
18637	20318	8	declared	declare	VBN
18637	20318	9	not	not	RB
18637	20318	10	to	to	TO
18637	20318	11	"	"	``
18637	20318	12	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	20318	13	with	with	IN
18637	20318	14	the	the	DT
18637	20318	15	normal	normal	JJ
18637	20318	16	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	20318	17	of	of	IN
18637	20318	18	the	the	DT
18637	20318	19	right	right	NN
18637	20318	20	of	of	IN
18637	20318	21	the	the	DT
18637	20318	22	employer	employer	NN
18637	20318	23	to	to	TO
18637	20318	24	select	select	VB
18637	20318	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20318	26	employees	employee	NNS
18637	20318	27	or	or	CC
18637	20318	28	to	to	TO
18637	20318	29	discharge	discharge	VB
18637	20318	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20318	31	.	.	.
18637	20318	32	"	"	''
18637	20319	1	However	however	RB
18637	20319	2	,	,	,
18637	20319	3	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	20319	4	of	of	IN
18637	20319	5	the	the	DT
18637	20319	6	employer	employer	NN
18637	20319	7	for	for	IN
18637	20319	8	the	the	DT
18637	20319	9	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	20319	10	of	of	IN
18637	20319	11	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	20319	12	an	an	DT
18637	20319	13	unjust	unjust	JJ
18637	20319	14	interference	interference	NN
18637	20319	15	with	with	IN
18637	20319	16	the	the	DT
18637	20319	17	correlative	correlative	JJ
18637	20319	18	right	right	NN
18637	20319	19	of	of	IN
18637	20319	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20319	21	employees	employee	NNS
18637	20319	22	to	to	TO
18637	20319	23	organize	organize	VB
18637	20319	24	was	be	VBD
18637	20319	25	declared	declare	VBN
18637	20319	26	not	not	RB
18637	20319	27	to	to	TO
18637	20319	28	be	be	VB
18637	20319	29	arbitrary.--National	arbitrary.--national	CD
18637	20319	30	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	20319	31	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	20319	32	Board	Board	NNP
18637	20319	33	_	_	NNP
18637	20319	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	20319	35	_	_	NNP
18637	20319	36	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	20319	37	&	&	CC
18637	20319	38	Laughlin	Laughlin	NNP
18637	20319	39	,	,	,
18637	20319	40	301	301	CD
18637	20319	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20319	42	1	1	CD
18637	20319	43	,	,	,
18637	20319	44	44	44	CD
18637	20319	45	,	,	,
18637	20319	46	45	45	CD
18637	20319	47	-	-	SYM
18637	20319	48	46	46	CD
18637	20319	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20319	50	1937	1937	CD
18637	20319	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20319	52	.	.	.
18637	20320	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20320	2	95	95	CD
18637	20320	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20320	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20320	5	See	See	NNP
18637	20320	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20320	7	especially	especially	RB
18637	20320	8	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	20320	9	Jay	Jay	NNP
18637	20320	10	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	20320	11	,	,	,
18637	20320	12	"	"	``
18637	20320	13	The	the	DT
18637	20320	14	'	'	``
18637	20320	15	Conspiracy	Conspiracy	NNP
18637	20320	16	Theory	Theory	NNP
18637	20320	17	'	'	''
18637	20320	18	of	of	IN
18637	20320	19	the	the	DT
18637	20320	20	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	20320	21	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20320	22	"	"	''
18637	20320	23	,	,	,
18637	20320	24	_	_	NNP
18637	20320	25	Selected	Selected	NNP
18637	20320	26	Essays	Essays	NNPS
18637	20320	27	on	on	IN
18637	20320	28	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
18637	20320	29	Law	Law	NNP
18637	20320	30	_	_	NNP
18637	20320	31	,	,	,
18637	20320	32	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20320	33	,	,	,
18637	20320	34	236	236	CD
18637	20320	35	-	-	SYM
18637	20320	36	267	267	CD
18637	20320	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20320	38	1938	1938	CD
18637	20320	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20320	40	.	.	.
18637	20321	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20321	2	96	96	CD
18637	20321	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20321	4	94	94	CD
18637	20321	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20322	1	113.--In	113.--in	LS
18637	20322	2	a	a	DT
18637	20322	3	case	case	NN
18637	20322	4	arising	arise	VBG
18637	20322	5	under	under	IN
18637	20322	6	the	the	DT
18637	20322	7	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	20322	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20322	9	,	,	,
18637	20322	10	decided	decide	VBD
18637	20322	11	almost	almost	RB
18637	20322	12	at	at	IN
18637	20322	13	the	the	DT
18637	20322	14	same	same	JJ
18637	20322	15	time	time	NN
18637	20322	16	,	,	,
18637	20322	17	the	the	DT
18637	20322	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20322	19	explicitly	explicitly	RB
18637	20322	20	declared	declare	VBD
18637	20322	21	the	the	DT
18637	20322	22	United	United	NNP
18637	20322	23	States	States	NNP
18637	20322	24	"	"	''
18637	20322	25	equally	equally	RB
18637	20322	26	with	with	IN
18637	20322	27	the	the	DT
18637	20322	28	States	States	NNP
18637	20322	29	*	*	NFP
18637	20322	30	*	*	NFP
18637	20322	31	*	*	NFP
18637	20322	32	are	be	VBP
18637	20322	33	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	20322	34	from	from	IN
18637	20322	35	depriving	deprive	VBG
18637	20322	36	persons	person	NNS
18637	20322	37	or	or	CC
18637	20322	38	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	20322	39	of	of	IN
18637	20322	40	property	property	NN
18637	20322	41	without	without	IN
18637	20322	42	due	due	JJ
18637	20322	43	process	process	NN
18637	20322	44	of	of	IN
18637	20322	45	law	law	NN
18637	20322	46	.	.	.
18637	20322	47	"	"	''
18637	20323	1	Sinking	Sinking	NNP
18637	20323	2	Fund	Fund	NNP
18637	20323	3	Cases	case	NNS
18637	20323	4	,	,	,
18637	20323	5	99	99	CD
18637	20323	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20323	7	700	700	CD
18637	20323	8	,	,	,
18637	20323	9	718	718	CD
18637	20323	10	-	-	SYM
18637	20323	11	719	719	CD
18637	20323	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20323	13	1878	1878	CD
18637	20323	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20323	15	.	.	.
18637	20324	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20324	2	97	97	CD
18637	20324	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20324	4	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
18637	20324	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20324	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20324	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20324	8	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	20324	9	,	,	,
18637	20324	10	169	169	CD
18637	20324	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20324	12	466	466	CD
18637	20324	13	,	,	,
18637	20324	14	522	522	CD
18637	20324	15	,	,	,
18637	20324	16	526	526	CD
18637	20324	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20324	18	1898	1898	CD
18637	20324	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20324	20	;	;	:
18637	20324	21	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	20324	22	Finance	Finance	NNP
18637	20324	23	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	20324	24	_	_	NNP
18637	20324	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	20324	26	_	_	NNP
18637	20324	27	Paramount	Paramount	NNP
18637	20324	28	Auto	Auto	NNP
18637	20324	29	Exch	Exch	NNP
18637	20324	30	.	.	.
18637	20325	1	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	20325	2	,	,	,
18637	20325	3	262	262	CD
18637	20325	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20325	5	544	544	CD
18637	20325	6	,	,	,
18637	20325	7	550	550	CD
18637	20325	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20325	9	1923	1923	CD
18637	20325	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20325	11	;	;	:
18637	20325	12	Liggett	Liggett	NNP
18637	20325	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20325	14	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	20325	15	K.	K.	NNP
18637	20325	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20325	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20325	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20325	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	20325	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20325	21	Baldridge	Baldridge	NNP
18637	20325	22	,	,	,
18637	20325	23	278	278	CD
18637	20325	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20325	25	105	105	CD
18637	20325	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20325	27	1928	1928	CD
18637	20325	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20325	29	.	.	.
18637	20326	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20326	2	98	98	CD
18637	20326	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20326	4	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	20326	5	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	20326	6	.	.	.
18637	20327	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	20327	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20327	3	.	.	.
18637	20328	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20328	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20328	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20328	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20328	5	Riggs	Riggs	NNP
18637	20328	6	,	,	,
18637	20328	7	203	203	CD
18637	20328	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20328	9	243	243	CD
18637	20328	10	,	,	,
18637	20328	11	255	255	CD
18637	20328	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20328	13	1906	1906	CD
18637	20328	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20328	15	;	;	:
18637	20328	16	Western	western	JJ
18637	20328	17	Turf	Turf	NNP
18637	20328	18	Assoc	Assoc	NNP
18637	20328	19	.	.	.
18637	20329	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20329	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20329	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20329	4	Greenberg	Greenberg	NNP
18637	20329	5	,	,	,
18637	20329	6	204	204	CD
18637	20329	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20329	8	359	359	CD
18637	20329	9	,	,	,
18637	20329	10	363	363	CD
18637	20329	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20329	12	1907	1907	CD
18637	20329	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20329	14	;	;	:
18637	20329	15	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	20329	16	_	_	NNP
18637	20329	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	20329	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20329	19	Society	Society	NNP
18637	20329	20	of	of	IN
18637	20329	21	the	the	DT
18637	20329	22	Sisters	Sisters	NNPS
18637	20329	23	,	,	,
18637	20329	24	268	268	CD
18637	20329	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20329	26	510	510	CD
18637	20329	27	,	,	,
18637	20329	28	535	535	CD
18637	20329	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20329	30	1925	1925	CD
18637	20329	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20329	32	.	.	.
18637	20330	1	Earlier	early	RBR
18637	20330	2	,	,	,
18637	20330	3	in	in	IN
18637	20330	4	1904	1904	CD
18637	20330	5	,	,	,
18637	20330	6	in	in	IN
18637	20330	7	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	20330	8	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	20330	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20330	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20330	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	20330	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20330	13	United	United	NNP
18637	20330	14	States	States	NNP
18637	20330	15	,	,	,
18637	20330	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20330	17	193	193	CD
18637	20330	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20330	19	197	197	CD
18637	20330	20	,	,	,
18637	20330	21	362	362	CD
18637	20330	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20330	23	,	,	,
18637	20330	24	a	a	DT
18637	20330	25	case	case	NN
18637	20330	26	interpreting	interpret	VBG
18637	20330	27	the	the	DT
18637	20330	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	20330	29	antitrust	antitrust	JJ
18637	20330	30	law	law	NN
18637	20330	31	,	,	,
18637	20330	32	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20330	33	Brewer	Brewer	NNP
18637	20330	34	,	,	,
18637	20330	35	in	in	IN
18637	20330	36	a	a	DT
18637	20330	37	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	20330	38	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	20330	39	,	,	,
18637	20330	40	had	have	VBD
18637	20330	41	declared	declare	VBN
18637	20330	42	that	that	IN
18637	20330	43	"	"	``
18637	20330	44	a	a	DT
18637	20330	45	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	20330	46	,	,	,
18637	20330	47	*	*	NFP
18637	20330	48	*	*	NFP
18637	20330	49	*	*	NFP
18637	20330	50	,	,	,
18637	20330	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	20330	52	not	not	RB
18637	20330	53	endowed	endow	VBN
18637	20330	54	with	with	IN
18637	20330	55	the	the	DT
18637	20330	56	inalienable	inalienable	JJ
18637	20330	57	rights	right	NNS
18637	20330	58	of	of	IN
18637	20330	59	a	a	DT
18637	20330	60	natural	natural	JJ
18637	20330	61	person	person	NN
18637	20330	62	.	.	.
18637	20330	63	"	"	''
18637	20331	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20331	2	99	99	CD
18637	20331	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20331	4	Grosjean	Grosjean	NNP
18637	20331	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20331	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20331	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20331	8	American	American	NNP
18637	20331	9	Press	Press	NNP
18637	20331	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20331	11	,	,	,
18637	20331	12	297	297	CD
18637	20331	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20331	14	233	233	CD
18637	20331	15	,	,	,
18637	20331	16	244	244	CD
18637	20331	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20331	18	1936	1936	CD
18637	20331	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20331	20	.	.	.
18637	20332	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20332	2	100	100	CD
18637	20332	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20332	4	Yick	Yick	NNP
18637	20332	5	Wo	Wo	NNP
18637	20332	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20332	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20332	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20332	9	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	20332	10	,	,	,
18637	20332	11	118	118	CD
18637	20332	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20332	13	356	356	CD
18637	20332	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20332	15	1886	1886	CD
18637	20332	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20332	17	;	;	:
18637	20332	18	Terrace	Terrace	NNP
18637	20332	19	_	_	NNP
18637	20332	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	20332	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20332	22	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	20332	23	,	,	,
18637	20332	24	263	263	CD
18637	20332	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20332	26	197	197	CD
18637	20332	27	,	,	,
18637	20332	28	216	216	CD
18637	20332	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20332	30	1923	1923	CD
18637	20332	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20332	32	.	.	.
18637	20333	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20333	2	101	101	CD
18637	20333	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20333	4	Columbus	Columbus	NNP
18637	20333	5	&	&	CC
18637	20333	6	G.R.	G.R.	NNP
18637	20334	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20334	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20334	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20334	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20334	5	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	20334	6	,	,	,
18637	20334	7	283	283	CD
18637	20334	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20334	9	96	96	CD
18637	20334	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20334	11	1931	1931	CD
18637	20334	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20334	13	;	;	:
18637	20334	14	Pennie	Pennie	NNP
18637	20334	15	_	_	NNP
18637	20334	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	20334	17	_	_	NNP
18637	20334	18	Reis	Reis	NNP
18637	20334	19	,	,	,
18637	20334	20	132	132	CD
18637	20334	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20334	22	464	464	CD
18637	20334	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20334	24	1889	1889	CD
18637	20334	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20334	26	;	;	:
18637	20334	27	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	20334	28	_	_	NNP
18637	20334	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	20334	30	_	_	NNP
18637	20334	31	Beckham	Beckham	NNP
18637	20334	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20334	33	No	no	UH
18637	20334	34	.	.	.
18637	20335	1	1	1	LS
18637	20335	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20335	3	,	,	,
18637	20335	4	178	178	CD
18637	20335	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20335	6	548	548	CD
18637	20335	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20335	8	1900	1900	CD
18637	20335	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20335	10	;	;	:
18637	20335	11	Straus	Straus	NNP
18637	20335	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20335	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	20335	14	_	_	NNP
18637	20335	15	Foxworth	Foxworth	NNP
18637	20335	16	,	,	,
18637	20335	17	231	231	CD
18637	20335	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20335	19	162	162	CD
18637	20335	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20335	21	1913	1913	CD
18637	20335	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20335	23	;	;	:
18637	20335	24	Tyler	Tyler	NNP
18637	20335	25	_	_	NNP
18637	20335	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	20335	27	_	_	NNP
18637	20335	28	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	20335	29	of	of	IN
18637	20335	30	the	the	DT
18637	20335	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20335	32	of	of	IN
18637	20335	33	Registration	Registration	NNP
18637	20335	34	,	,	,
18637	20335	35	179	179	CD
18637	20335	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20335	37	405	405	CD
18637	20335	38	,	,	,
18637	20335	39	410	410	CD
18637	20335	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20335	41	1900	1900	CD
18637	20335	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20335	43	.	.	.
18637	20336	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20336	2	102	102	CD
18637	20336	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20336	4	Pawhuska	Pawhuska	NNP
18637	20336	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20336	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20336	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20336	8	Pawhuska	Pawhuska	NNP
18637	20336	9	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	20336	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20336	11	,	,	,
18637	20336	12	250	250	CD
18637	20336	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20336	14	394	394	CD
18637	20336	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20336	16	1919	1919	CD
18637	20336	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20336	18	;	;	:
18637	20336	19	Trenton	Trenton	NNP
18637	20336	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20336	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	20336	22	_	_	NNP
18637	20336	23	New	New	NNP
18637	20336	24	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	20336	25	,	,	,
18637	20336	26	262	262	CD
18637	20336	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20336	28	182	182	CD
18637	20336	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20336	30	1923	1923	CD
18637	20336	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20336	32	;	;	:
18637	20336	33	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	20336	34	_	_	NNP
18637	20336	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	20336	36	_	_	NNP
18637	20336	37	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	20336	38	,	,	,
18637	20336	39	289	289	CD
18637	20336	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20336	41	36	36	CD
18637	20336	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20336	43	1933	1933	CD
18637	20336	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20336	45	.	.	.
18637	20337	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20337	2	103	103	CD
18637	20337	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20337	4	Boynton	Boynton	NNP
18637	20337	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20337	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20337	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20337	8	Hutchinson	Hutchinson	NNP
18637	20337	9	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20337	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20337	11	,	,	,
18637	20337	12	291	291	CD
18637	20337	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20337	14	656	656	CD
18637	20337	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20337	16	1934	1934	CD
18637	20337	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20337	18	;	;	:
18637	20337	19	South	South	NNP
18637	20337	20	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	20337	21	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	20337	22	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	20337	23	.	.	.
18637	20338	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20338	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20338	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20338	4	Barnwell	Barnwell	NNP
18637	20338	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	20338	6	,	,	,
18637	20338	7	303	303	CD
18637	20338	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20338	9	177	177	CD
18637	20338	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20338	11	1938	1938	CD
18637	20338	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20338	13	.	.	.
18637	20339	1	The	the	DT
18637	20339	2	converse	converse	NN
18637	20339	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	20339	4	not	not	RB
18637	20339	5	true	true	JJ
18637	20339	6	,	,	,
18637	20339	7	however	however	RB
18637	20339	8	;	;	:
18637	20339	9	and	and	CC
18637	20339	10	"	"	``
18637	20339	11	the	the	DT
18637	20339	12	interest	interest	NN
18637	20339	13	of	of	IN
18637	20339	14	a	a	DT
18637	20339	15	State	State	NNP
18637	20339	16	official	official	NN
18637	20339	17	in	in	IN
18637	20339	18	vindicating	vindicate	VBG
18637	20339	19	the	the	DT
18637	20339	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	20339	21	*	*	NFP
18637	20339	22	*	*	NFP
18637	20339	23	*	*	NFP
18637	20339	24	gives	give	VBZ
18637	20339	25	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20339	26	no	no	DT
18637	20339	27	legal	legal	JJ
18637	20339	28	standing	standing	NN
18637	20339	29	to	to	TO
18637	20339	30	attack	attack	VB
18637	20339	31	the	the	DT
18637	20339	32	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	20339	33	of	of	IN
18637	20339	34	a	a	DT
18637	20339	35	State	State	NNP
18637	20339	36	statute	statute	NN
18637	20339	37	in	in	IN
18637	20339	38	order	order	NN
18637	20339	39	to	to	TO
18637	20339	40	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	20339	41	compliance	compliance	NN
18637	20339	42	with	with	IN
18637	20339	43	it.--Smith	it.--Smith	NNP
18637	20339	44	_	_	NNP
18637	20339	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	20339	46	_	_	NNP
18637	20339	47	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	20339	48	,	,	,
18637	20339	49	191	191	CD
18637	20339	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20339	51	138	138	CD
18637	20339	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20339	53	1903	1903	CD
18637	20339	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20339	55	;	;	:
18637	20339	56	Braxton	Braxton	NNP
18637	20339	57	County	County	NNP
18637	20339	58	Ct	Ct	NNP
18637	20339	59	.	.	.
18637	20339	60	_	_	NNP
18637	20339	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	20339	62	_	_	NNP
18637	20339	63	West	West	NNP
18637	20339	64	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	20339	65	,	,	,
18637	20339	66	208	208	CD
18637	20339	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20339	68	192	192	CD
18637	20339	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20339	70	1908	1908	CD
18637	20339	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20339	72	;	;	:
18637	20339	73	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	20339	74	_	_	NNP
18637	20339	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	20339	76	_	_	NNP
18637	20339	77	Dye	Dye	NNP
18637	20339	78	,	,	,
18637	20339	79	231	231	CD
18637	20339	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20339	81	250	250	CD
18637	20339	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20339	83	1913	1913	CD
18637	20339	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20339	85	;	;	:
18637	20339	86	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	20339	87	_	_	NNP
18637	20339	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	20339	89	_	_	NNP
18637	20339	90	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20339	91	City	City	NNP
18637	20339	92	,	,	,
18637	20339	93	239	239	CD
18637	20339	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20339	95	14	14	CD
18637	20339	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20339	97	1915	1915	CD
18637	20339	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20339	99	.	.	.
18637	20340	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20340	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20340	3	also	also	RB
18637	20340	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20340	5	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	20340	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20340	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20340	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20340	9	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	20340	10	,	,	,
18637	20340	11	307	307	CD
18637	20340	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20340	13	433	433	CD
18637	20340	14	,	,	,
18637	20340	15	437	437	CD
18637	20340	16	-	-	SYM
18637	20340	17	446	446	CD
18637	20340	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20340	19	1939	1939	CD
18637	20340	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20340	21	.	.	.
18637	20340	22	"	"	''
18637	20341	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20341	2	104	104	CD
18637	20341	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20341	4	Bacon	Bacon	NNP
18637	20341	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20341	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20341	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20341	8	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	20341	9	,	,	,
18637	20341	10	204	204	CD
18637	20341	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20341	12	311	311	CD
18637	20341	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20341	14	1907	1907	CD
18637	20341	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20341	16	;	;	:
18637	20341	17	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20341	18	,	,	,
18637	20341	19	B.	B.	NNP
18637	20342	1	&	&	CC
18637	20342	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	20343	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20343	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20343	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20343	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20343	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	20343	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20343	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	20343	8	.	.	.
18637	20344	1	Grimwood	Grimwood	NNP
18637	20344	2	,	,	,
18637	20344	3	200	200	CD
18637	20344	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20344	5	561	561	CD
18637	20344	6	,	,	,
18637	20344	7	592	592	CD
18637	20344	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20344	9	1906	1906	CD
18637	20344	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20344	11	;	;	:
18637	20344	12	California	California	NNP
18637	20344	13	Reduction	Reduction	NNP
18637	20344	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20344	15	_	_	NNP
18637	20344	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	20344	17	_	_	NNP
18637	20344	18	Sanitary	Sanitary	NNP
18637	20344	19	Reduction	Reduction	NNP
18637	20344	20	Works	Works	NNP
18637	20344	21	,	,	,
18637	20344	22	199	199	CD
18637	20344	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20344	24	306	306	CD
18637	20344	25	,	,	,
18637	20344	26	318	318	CD
18637	20344	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20344	28	1905	1905	CD
18637	20344	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20344	30	;	;	:
18637	20344	31	Eubank	Eubank	NNP
18637	20344	32	_	_	NNP
18637	20344	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	20344	34	_	_	NNP
18637	20344	35	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	20344	36	,	,	,
18637	20344	37	226	226	CD
18637	20344	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20344	39	137	137	CD
18637	20344	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20344	41	1912	1912	CD
18637	20344	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20344	43	;	;	:
18637	20344	44	Schmidinger	Schmidinger	NNP
18637	20344	45	_	_	NNP
18637	20344	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	20344	47	_	_	NNP
18637	20344	48	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20344	49	,	,	,
18637	20344	50	226	226	CD
18637	20344	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20344	52	578	578	CD
18637	20344	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20344	54	1913	1913	CD
18637	20344	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20344	56	;	;	:
18637	20344	57	Sligh	Sligh	NNP
18637	20344	58	_	_	NNP
18637	20344	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	20344	60	_	_	NNP
18637	20344	61	Kirkwood	Kirkwood	NNP
18637	20344	62	,	,	,
18637	20344	63	237	237	CD
18637	20344	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20344	65	52	52	CD
18637	20344	66	,	,	,
18637	20344	67	58	58	CD
18637	20344	68	-	-	SYM
18637	20344	69	59	59	CD
18637	20344	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20344	71	1915	1915	CD
18637	20344	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20344	73	;	;	:
18637	20344	74	Nebbia	Nebbia	NNP
18637	20344	75	_	_	NNP
18637	20344	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	20344	77	_	_	NNP
18637	20344	78	New	New	NNP
18637	20344	79	York	York	NNP
18637	20344	80	,	,	,
18637	20344	81	291	291	CD
18637	20344	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20344	83	502	502	CD
18637	20344	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20344	85	1934	1934	CD
18637	20344	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20344	87	;	;	:
18637	20344	88	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	20344	89	C.	C.	NNP
18637	20344	90	&	&	CC
18637	20344	91	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20344	92	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	20345	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20345	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20345	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20345	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20345	5	Walters	Walters	NNP
18637	20345	6	,	,	,
18637	20345	7	294	294	CD
18637	20345	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20345	9	405	405	CD
18637	20345	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20345	11	1935	1935	CD
18637	20345	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20345	13	.	.	.
18637	20346	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20346	2	105	105	CD
18637	20346	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20346	4	Hadacheck	Hadacheck	NNP
18637	20346	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20346	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20346	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20346	8	Sebastian	Sebastian	NNP
18637	20346	9	,	,	,
18637	20346	10	239	239	CD
18637	20346	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20346	12	394	394	CD
18637	20346	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20346	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	20346	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20346	16	;	;	:
18637	20346	17	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	20346	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20346	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	20346	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20346	21	Geiger	Geiger	NNP
18637	20346	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	20346	23	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	20346	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20346	25	,	,	,
18637	20346	26	242	242	CD
18637	20346	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20346	28	539	539	CD
18637	20346	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20346	30	1917	1917	CD
18637	20346	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20346	32	;	;	:
18637	20346	33	Sligh	Sligh	NNP
18637	20346	34	_	_	NNP
18637	20346	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	20346	36	_	_	NNP
18637	20346	37	Kirkwood	Kirkwood	NNP
18637	20346	38	,	,	,
18637	20346	39	237	237	CD
18637	20346	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20346	41	52	52	CD
18637	20346	42	,	,	,
18637	20346	43	58	58	CD
18637	20346	44	-	-	SYM
18637	20346	45	59	59	CD
18637	20346	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20346	47	1915	1915	CD
18637	20346	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20346	49	;	;	:
18637	20346	50	Eubank	Eubank	NNP
18637	20346	51	_	_	NNP
18637	20346	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	20346	53	_	_	NNP
18637	20346	54	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	20346	55	,	,	,
18637	20346	56	226	226	CD
18637	20346	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20346	58	137	137	CD
18637	20346	59	,	,	,
18637	20346	60	142	142	CD
18637	20346	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20346	62	1912	1912	CD
18637	20346	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20346	64	;	;	:
18637	20346	65	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	20346	66	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20346	67	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20346	68	_	_	NNP
18637	20346	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	20346	70	_	_	NNP
18637	20346	71	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	20346	72	,	,	,
18637	20346	73	233	233	CD
18637	20346	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20346	75	685	685	CD
18637	20346	76	,	,	,
18637	20346	77	699	699	CD
18637	20346	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20346	79	1914	1914	CD
18637	20346	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20346	81	;	;	:
18637	20346	82	Panhandle	Panhandle	NNP
18637	20346	83	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	20346	84	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	20346	85	Line	Line	NNP
18637	20346	86	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20346	87	_	_	NNP
18637	20346	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	20346	89	_	_	NNP
18637	20346	90	State	State	NNP
18637	20346	91	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	20346	92	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20346	93	,	,	,
18637	20346	94	294	294	CD
18637	20346	95	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20346	96	613	613	CD
18637	20346	97	,	,	,
18637	20346	98	622	622	CD
18637	20346	99	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20346	100	1935	1935	CD
18637	20346	101	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20346	102	;	;	:
18637	20346	103	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	20346	104	County	County	NNP
18637	20346	105	Water	Water	NNP
18637	20346	106	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20346	107	_	_	NNP
18637	20346	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	20346	109	_	_	NNP
18637	20346	110	McCarter	McCarter	NNP
18637	20346	111	,	,	,
18637	20346	112	209	209	CD
18637	20346	113	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20346	114	349	349	CD
18637	20346	115	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20346	116	1908	1908	CD
18637	20346	117	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20346	118	.	.	.
18637	20347	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20347	2	106	106	CD
18637	20347	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20347	4	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	20347	5	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	20347	6	Line	Line	NNP
18637	20347	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20347	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20347	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20347	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20347	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20347	12	Goldsboro	Goldsboro	NNP
18637	20347	13	,	,	,
18637	20347	14	232	232	CD
18637	20347	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20347	16	548	548	CD
18637	20347	17	,	,	,
18637	20347	18	558	558	CD
18637	20347	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20347	20	1914	1914	CD
18637	20347	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20347	22	.	.	.
18637	20348	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20348	2	107	107	CD
18637	20348	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20348	4	Treigle	Treigle	NNP
18637	20348	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20348	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20348	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20348	8	Acme	Acme	NNP
18637	20348	9	Homestead	Homestead	NNP
18637	20348	10	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	20348	11	.	.	.
18637	20348	12	,	,	,
18637	20348	13	297	297	CD
18637	20348	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20348	15	189	189	CD
18637	20348	16	,	,	,
18637	20348	17	197	197	CD
18637	20348	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20348	19	1933	1933	CD
18637	20348	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20348	21	;	;	:
18637	20348	22	Liggett	Liggett	NNP
18637	20348	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20348	24	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	20348	25	K.	K.	NNP
18637	20348	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20348	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20348	28	_	_	NNP
18637	20348	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	20348	30	_	_	NNP
18637	20348	31	Baldridge	Baldridge	NNP
18637	20348	32	,	,	,
18637	20348	33	278	278	CD
18637	20348	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20348	35	105	105	CD
18637	20348	36	,	,	,
18637	20348	37	111	111	CD
18637	20348	38	-	-	SYM
18637	20348	39	112	112	CD
18637	20348	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20348	41	1928	1928	CD
18637	20348	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20348	43	.	.	.
18637	20349	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20349	2	108	108	CD
18637	20349	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20349	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	20349	5	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	20349	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20349	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20349	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20349	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20349	10	Mahon	Mahon	NNP
18637	20349	11	,	,	,
18637	20349	12	260	260	CD
18637	20349	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20349	14	393	393	CD
18637	20349	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20349	16	1922	1922	CD
18637	20349	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20349	18	.	.	.
18637	20350	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20350	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20350	3	also	also	RB
18637	20350	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20350	5	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	20350	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20350	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20350	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20350	9	Swasey	Swasey	NNP
18637	20350	10	,	,	,
18637	20350	11	214	214	CD
18637	20350	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20350	13	91	91	CD
18637	20350	14	,	,	,
18637	20350	15	107	107	CD
18637	20350	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20350	17	1909	1909	CD
18637	20350	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20350	19	.	.	.
18637	20351	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20351	2	109	109	CD
18637	20351	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20351	4	Noble	Noble	NNP
18637	20351	5	State	State	NNP
18637	20351	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	20351	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20351	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20351	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20351	10	Haskell	Haskell	NNP
18637	20351	11	,	,	,
18637	20351	12	219	219	CD
18637	20351	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20351	14	104	104	CD
18637	20351	15	,	,	,
18637	20351	16	110	110	CD
18637	20351	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20351	18	1911	1911	CD
18637	20351	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20351	20	.	.	.
18637	20352	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20352	2	110	110	CD
18637	20352	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20352	4	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	20352	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20352	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20352	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20352	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20352	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20352	10	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	20352	11	,	,	,
18637	20352	12	233	233	CD
18637	20352	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20352	14	685	685	CD
18637	20352	15	,	,	,
18637	20352	16	700	700	CD
18637	20352	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20352	18	1914	1914	CD
18637	20352	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20352	20	.	.	.
18637	20353	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20353	2	111	111	CD
18637	20353	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20353	4	New	New	NNP
18637	20353	5	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	20353	6	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20353	7	Service	Service	NNP
18637	20353	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20353	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20353	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20353	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20353	12	New	New	NNP
18637	20353	13	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	20353	14	,	,	,
18637	20353	15	281	281	CD
18637	20353	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20353	17	682	682	CD
18637	20353	18	,	,	,
18637	20353	19	687	687	CD
18637	20353	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20353	21	1930	1930	CD
18637	20353	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20353	23	.	.	.
18637	20354	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20354	2	112	112	CD
18637	20354	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20354	4	Abie	Abie	NNP
18637	20354	5	State	State	NNP
18637	20354	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	20354	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20354	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20354	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20354	10	Bryan	Bryan	NNP
18637	20354	11	,	,	,
18637	20354	12	282	282	CD
18637	20354	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20354	14	765	765	CD
18637	20354	15	,	,	,
18637	20354	16	770	770	CD
18637	20354	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20354	18	1931	1931	CD
18637	20354	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20354	20	.	.	.
18637	20355	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20355	2	113	113	CD
18637	20355	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20355	4	Meyer	Meyer	NNP
18637	20355	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20355	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20355	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20355	8	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	20355	9	,	,	,
18637	20355	10	262	262	CD
18637	20355	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20355	12	300	300	CD
18637	20355	13	,	,	,
18637	20355	14	399	399	CD
18637	20355	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20355	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	20355	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20355	18	.	.	.
18637	20356	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20356	2	114	114	CD
18637	20356	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20356	4	Jacobson	Jacobson	NNP
18637	20356	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20356	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20356	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20356	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	20356	9	,	,	,
18637	20356	10	197	197	CD
18637	20356	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20356	12	11	11	CD
18637	20356	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20356	14	1905	1905	CD
18637	20356	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20356	16	;	;	:
18637	20356	17	Zucht	Zucht	NNP
18637	20356	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20356	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	20356	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20356	21	King	King	NNP
18637	20356	22	,	,	,
18637	20356	23	260	260	CD
18637	20356	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20356	25	174	174	CD
18637	20356	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20356	27	1922	1922	CD
18637	20356	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20356	29	.	.	.
18637	20357	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20357	2	115	115	CD
18637	20357	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20357	4	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	20357	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20357	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20357	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20357	8	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	20357	9	,	,	,
18637	20357	10	274	274	CD
18637	20357	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20357	12	200	200	CD
18637	20357	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20357	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	20357	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20357	16	.	.	.
18637	20358	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20358	2	116	116	CD
18637	20358	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20358	4	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	20358	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20358	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20358	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20358	8	Probate	Probate	NNP
18637	20358	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20358	10	,	,	,
18637	20358	11	309	309	CD
18637	20358	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20358	13	270	270	CD
18637	20358	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20358	15	1940	1940	CD
18637	20358	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20358	17	.	.	.
18637	20359	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20359	2	117	117	CD
18637	20359	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20359	4	Lanzetta	Lanzetta	NNP
18637	20359	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20359	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20359	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20359	8	New	New	NNP
18637	20359	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	20359	10	,	,	,
18637	20359	11	306	306	CD
18637	20359	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20359	13	451	451	CD
18637	20359	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20359	15	1939	1939	CD
18637	20359	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20359	17	.	.	.
18637	20360	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20360	2	118	118	CD
18637	20360	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20360	4	262	262	CD
18637	20360	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20360	6	390	390	CD
18637	20360	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20360	8	1923	1923	CD
18637	20360	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20360	10	.	.	.
18637	20361	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20361	2	119	119	CD
18637	20361	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20361	4	268	268	CD
18637	20361	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20361	6	510	510	CD
18637	20361	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20361	8	1925	1925	CD
18637	20361	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20361	10	.	.	.
18637	20362	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20362	2	120	120	CD
18637	20362	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20362	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20362	5	.	.	.
18637	20363	1	534	534	CD
18637	20363	2	.	.	.
18637	20364	1	Even	even	RB
18637	20364	2	this	this	DT
18637	20364	3	statement	statement	NN
18637	20364	4	was	be	VBD
18637	20364	5	a	a	DT
18637	20364	6	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	20364	7	.	.	.
18637	20365	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	20365	2	as	as	IN
18637	20365	3	only	only	JJ
18637	20365	4	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	20365	5	and	and	CC
18637	20365	6	no	no	DT
18637	20365	7	parents	parent	NNS
18637	20365	8	were	be	VBD
18637	20365	9	party	party	NN
18637	20365	10	litigants	litigant	NNS
18637	20365	11	,	,	,
18637	20365	12	the	the	DT
18637	20365	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20365	14	in	in	IN
18637	20365	15	fact	fact	NN
18637	20365	16	disposed	dispose	VBN
18637	20365	17	of	of	IN
18637	20365	18	the	the	DT
18637	20365	19	case	case	NN
18637	20365	20	on	on	IN
18637	20365	21	the	the	DT
18637	20365	22	ground	ground	NN
18637	20365	23	that	that	IN
18637	20365	24	the	the	DT
18637	20365	25	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	20365	26	were	be	VBD
18637	20365	27	being	be	VBG
18637	20365	28	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	20365	29	of	of	IN
18637	20365	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20365	31	"	"	``
18637	20365	32	property	property	NN
18637	20365	33	"	"	''
18637	20365	34	without	without	IN
18637	20365	35	due	due	JJ
18637	20365	36	process	process	NN
18637	20365	37	of	of	IN
18637	20365	38	law	law	NN
18637	20365	39	.	.	.
18637	20366	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20366	2	121	121	CD
18637	20366	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20366	4	Waugh	Waugh	NNP
18637	20366	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20366	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20366	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20366	8	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	20366	9	University	University	NNP
18637	20366	10	,	,	,
18637	20366	11	237	237	CD
18637	20366	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20366	13	589	589	CD
18637	20366	14	,	,	,
18637	20366	15	596	596	CD
18637	20366	16	-	-	SYM
18637	20366	17	597	597	CD
18637	20366	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20366	19	1915	1915	CD
18637	20366	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20366	21	.	.	.
18637	20367	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20367	2	122	122	CD
18637	20367	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20367	4	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	20367	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20367	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20367	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20367	8	University	University	NNP
18637	20367	9	of	of	IN
18637	20367	10	California	California	NNP
18637	20367	11	,	,	,
18637	20367	12	293	293	CD
18637	20367	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20367	14	245	245	CD
18637	20367	15	,	,	,
18637	20367	16	262	262	CD
18637	20367	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20367	18	1934	1934	CD
18637	20367	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20367	20	.	.	.
18637	20368	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20368	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20368	3	also	also	RB
18637	20368	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20368	5	p.	p.	NN
18637	20368	6	768	768	CD
18637	20368	7	.	.	.
18637	20369	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20369	2	123	123	CD
18637	20369	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20369	4	16	16	CD
18637	20369	5	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	20369	6	.	.	.
18637	20370	1	36	36	CD
18637	20370	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20370	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	20370	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20370	5	.	.	.
18637	20371	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20371	2	124	124	CD
18637	20371	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20371	4	165	165	CD
18637	20371	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20371	6	578	578	CD
18637	20371	7	,	,	,
18637	20371	8	589.--Herein	589.--herein	CD
18637	20371	9	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	20371	10	of	of	IN
18637	20371	11	contract	contract	NN
18637	20371	12	was	be	VBD
18637	20371	13	defined	define	VBN
18637	20371	14	as	as	IN
18637	20371	15	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	20371	16	:	:	:
18637	20371	17	"	"	``
18637	20371	18	The	the	DT
18637	20371	19	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	20371	20	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	20371	21	in	in	IN
18637	20371	22	that	that	DT
18637	20371	23	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20371	24	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	20371	25	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20371	26	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20371	27	means	mean	VBZ
18637	20371	28	not	not	RB
18637	20371	29	only	only	RB
18637	20371	30	the	the	DT
18637	20371	31	right	right	NN
18637	20371	32	of	of	IN
18637	20371	33	the	the	DT
18637	20371	34	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	20371	35	to	to	TO
18637	20371	36	be	be	VB
18637	20371	37	free	free	JJ
18637	20371	38	from	from	IN
18637	20371	39	the	the	DT
18637	20371	40	mere	mere	JJ
18637	20371	41	physical	physical	JJ
18637	20371	42	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	20371	43	of	of	IN
18637	20371	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20371	45	person	person	NN
18637	20371	46	,	,	,
18637	20371	47	as	as	IN
18637	20371	48	by	by	IN
18637	20371	49	incarceration	incarceration	NN
18637	20371	50	,	,	,
18637	20371	51	but	but	CC
18637	20371	52	the	the	DT
18637	20371	53	term	term	NN
18637	20371	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	20371	55	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	20371	56	to	to	TO
18637	20371	57	embrace	embrace	VB
18637	20371	58	the	the	DT
18637	20371	59	right	right	NN
18637	20371	60	of	of	IN
18637	20371	61	the	the	DT
18637	20371	62	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	20371	63	to	to	TO
18637	20371	64	be	be	VB
18637	20371	65	free	free	JJ
18637	20371	66	in	in	IN
18637	20371	67	the	the	DT
18637	20371	68	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	20371	69	of	of	IN
18637	20371	70	all	all	PDT
18637	20371	71	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20371	72	faculties	faculty	NNS
18637	20371	73	;	;	:
18637	20371	74	to	to	TO
18637	20371	75	be	be	VB
18637	20371	76	free	free	JJ
18637	20371	77	to	to	TO
18637	20371	78	use	use	VB
18637	20371	79	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20371	80	in	in	IN
18637	20371	81	all	all	DT
18637	20371	82	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	20371	83	ways	way	NNS
18637	20371	84	;	;	,
18637	20371	85	to	to	TO
18637	20371	86	live	live	VB
18637	20371	87	and	and	CC
18637	20371	88	work	work	VB
18637	20371	89	where	where	WRB
18637	20371	90	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20371	91	will	will	MD
18637	20371	92	;	;	:
18637	20371	93	to	to	TO
18637	20371	94	earn	earn	VB
18637	20371	95	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20371	96	livelihood	livelihood	NN
18637	20371	97	by	by	IN
18637	20371	98	any	any	DT
18637	20371	99	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	20371	100	calling	calling	NN
18637	20371	101	;	;	:
18637	20371	102	to	to	TO
18637	20371	103	pursue	pursue	VB
18637	20371	104	any	any	DT
18637	20371	105	livelihood	livelihood	NN
18637	20371	106	or	or	CC
18637	20371	107	avocation	avocation	NN
18637	20371	108	,	,	,
18637	20371	109	and	and	CC
18637	20371	110	for	for	IN
18637	20371	111	that	that	DT
18637	20371	112	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	20371	113	to	to	TO
18637	20371	114	enter	enter	VB
18637	20371	115	into	into	IN
18637	20371	116	all	all	DT
18637	20371	117	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	20371	118	which	which	WDT
18637	20371	119	may	may	MD
18637	20371	120	be	be	VB
18637	20371	121	proper	proper	JJ
18637	20371	122	,	,	,
18637	20371	123	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	20371	124	and	and	CC
18637	20371	125	essential	essential	JJ
18637	20371	126	to	to	IN
18637	20371	127	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20371	128	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	20371	129	out	out	RP
18637	20371	130	to	to	IN
18637	20371	131	a	a	DT
18637	20371	132	successful	successful	JJ
18637	20371	133	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	20371	134	the	the	DT
18637	20371	135	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	20371	136	above	above	IN
18637	20371	137	mentioned	mention	VBD
18637	20371	138	.	.	.
18637	20371	139	"	"	''
18637	20372	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20372	2	125	125	CD
18637	20372	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20372	4	236	236	CD
18637	20372	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20372	6	1	1	CD
18637	20372	7	,	,	,
18637	20372	8	14	14	CD
18637	20372	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20372	10	1915	1915	CD
18637	20372	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20372	12	.	.	.
18637	20373	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20373	2	126	126	CD
18637	20373	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20373	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20373	5	,	,	,
18637	20373	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	20374	1	&	&	CC
18637	20374	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	20375	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20375	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20375	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20375	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20375	5	McGuire	McGuire	NNP
18637	20375	6	,	,	,
18637	20375	7	219	219	CD
18637	20375	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20375	9	549	549	CD
18637	20375	10	,	,	,
18637	20375	11	567	567	CD
18637	20375	12	,	,	,
18637	20375	13	570	570	CD
18637	20375	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20375	15	1911	1911	CD
18637	20375	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20375	17	;	;	:
18637	20375	18	Wolff	Wolff	NNP
18637	20375	19	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	20375	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20375	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20375	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	20375	23	_	_	NNP
18637	20375	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20375	25	of	of	IN
18637	20375	26	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	20375	27	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	20375	28	,	,	,
18637	20375	29	262	262	CD
18637	20375	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20375	31	522	522	CD
18637	20375	32	,	,	,
18637	20375	33	534	534	CD
18637	20375	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20375	35	1923	1923	CD
18637	20375	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20375	37	.	.	.
18637	20376	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20376	2	127	127	CD
18637	20376	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20376	4	Holden	Holden	NNP
18637	20376	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20376	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20376	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20376	8	Hardy	Hardy	NNP
18637	20376	9	,	,	,
18637	20376	10	169	169	CD
18637	20376	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20376	12	366	366	CD
18637	20376	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20376	14	1898	1898	CD
18637	20376	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20376	16	.	.	.
18637	20377	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20377	2	128	128	CD
18637	20377	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20377	4	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	20377	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20377	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20377	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20377	8	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	20377	9	,	,	,
18637	20377	10	236	236	CD
18637	20377	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20377	12	373	373	CD
18637	20377	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20377	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	20377	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20377	16	;	;	:
18637	20377	17	Bosley	Bosley	NNP
18637	20377	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20377	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	20377	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20377	21	McLaughlin	McLaughlin	NNP
18637	20377	22	,	,	,
18637	20377	23	236	236	CD
18637	20377	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20377	25	385	385	CD
18637	20377	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20377	27	1915	1915	CD
18637	20377	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20377	29	.	.	.
18637	20378	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20378	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20378	3	also	also	RB
18637	20378	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20378	5	Muller	Muller	NNP
18637	20378	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20378	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20378	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20378	9	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	20378	10	,	,	,
18637	20378	11	208	208	CD
18637	20378	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20378	13	412	412	CD
18637	20378	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20378	15	1908	1908	CD
18637	20378	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20378	17	;	;	:
18637	20378	18	Riley	Riley	NNP
18637	20378	19	_	_	NNP
18637	20378	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	20378	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20378	22	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	20378	23	,	,	,
18637	20378	24	232	232	CD
18637	20378	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20378	26	671	671	CD
18637	20378	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20378	28	1914	1914	CD
18637	20378	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20378	30	;	;	:
18637	20378	31	Hawley	Hawley	NNP
18637	20378	32	_	_	NNP
18637	20378	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	20378	34	_	_	NNP
18637	20378	35	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	20378	36	,	,	,
18637	20378	37	232	232	CD
18637	20378	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20378	39	718	718	CD
18637	20378	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20378	41	1914	1914	CD
18637	20378	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20378	43	.	.	.
18637	20379	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20379	2	129	129	CD
18637	20379	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20379	4	Bunting	Bunting	NNP
18637	20379	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20379	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20379	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20379	8	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	20379	9	,	,	,
18637	20379	10	243	243	CD
18637	20379	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20379	12	426	426	CD
18637	20379	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20379	14	1917	1917	CD
18637	20379	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20379	16	.	.	.
18637	20380	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20380	2	130	130	CD
18637	20380	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20380	4	Atkin	Atkin	NNP
18637	20380	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20380	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20380	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20380	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20380	9	,	,	,
18637	20380	10	191	191	CD
18637	20380	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20380	12	207	207	CD
18637	20380	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20380	14	1903	1903	CD
18637	20380	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20380	16	.	.	.
18637	20381	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20381	2	131	131	CD
18637	20381	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20381	4	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	20381	5	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	20381	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20381	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20381	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20381	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20381	10	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	20381	11	,	,	,
18637	20381	12	185	185	CD
18637	20381	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20381	14	203	203	CD
18637	20381	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20381	16	1902	1902	CD
18637	20381	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20381	18	.	.	.
18637	20382	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20382	2	132	132	CD
18637	20382	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20382	4	Wilmington	Wilmington	NNP
18637	20382	5	Star	Star	NNP
18637	20382	6	Min	Min	NNP
18637	20382	7	.	.	.
18637	20383	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20383	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20383	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20383	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20383	5	Fulton	Fulton	NNP
18637	20383	6	,	,	,
18637	20383	7	205	205	CD
18637	20383	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20383	9	60	60	CD
18637	20383	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20383	11	1907	1907	CD
18637	20383	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20383	13	.	.	.
18637	20384	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20384	2	133	133	CD
18637	20384	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20384	4	Barrett	Barrett	NNP
18637	20384	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20384	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20384	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20384	8	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	20384	9	,	,	,
18637	20384	10	299	299	CD
18637	20384	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20384	12	26	26	CD
18637	20384	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20384	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	20384	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20384	16	.	.	.
18637	20385	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20385	2	134	134	CD
18637	20385	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20385	4	Plymouth	Plymouth	NNP
18637	20385	5	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	20385	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20385	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20385	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20385	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20385	10	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	20385	11	,	,	,
18637	20385	12	232	232	CD
18637	20385	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20385	14	531	531	CD
18637	20385	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20385	16	1914	1914	CD
18637	20385	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20385	18	.	.	.
18637	20386	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20386	2	135	135	CD
18637	20386	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20386	4	Booth	Booth	NNP
18637	20386	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20386	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20386	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20386	8	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	20386	9	,	,	,
18637	20386	10	237	237	CD
18637	20386	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20386	12	391	391	CD
18637	20386	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20386	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	20386	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20386	16	.	.	.
18637	20387	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20387	2	136	136	CD
18637	20387	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20387	4	Sturges	Sturges	NNP
18637	20387	5	&	&	CC
18637	20387	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	20387	7	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	20387	8	.	.	.
18637	20388	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20388	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20388	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20388	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20388	5	Beauchamp	Beauchamp	NNP
18637	20388	6	,	,	,
18637	20388	7	231	231	CD
18637	20388	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20388	9	320	320	CD
18637	20388	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20388	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	20388	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20388	13	.	.	.
18637	20389	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20389	2	137	137	CD
18637	20389	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20389	4	Knoxville	Knoxville	NNP
18637	20389	5	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	20389	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20389	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20389	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20389	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20389	10	Harbison	Harbison	NNP
18637	20389	11	,	,	,
18637	20389	12	183	183	CD
18637	20389	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20389	14	13	13	CD
18637	20389	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20389	16	1901	1901	CD
18637	20389	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20389	18	;	;	:
18637	20389	19	Dayton	Dayton	NNP
18637	20389	20	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	20389	21	&	&	CC
18637	20389	22	I.	I.	NNP
18637	20389	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20389	24	_	_	NNP
18637	20389	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	20389	26	_	_	NNP
18637	20389	27	Barton	Barton	NNP
18637	20389	28	,	,	,
18637	20389	29	183	183	CD
18637	20389	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20389	31	23	23	CD
18637	20389	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20389	33	1901	1901	CD
18637	20389	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20389	35	;	;	:
18637	20389	36	Keokee	Keokee	NNP
18637	20389	37	Consol	Consol	NNP
18637	20389	38	.	.	.
18637	20390	1	Coke	Coke	NNP
18637	20390	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20390	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20390	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	20390	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20390	6	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	20390	7	,	,	,
18637	20390	8	234	234	CD
18637	20390	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20390	10	224	224	CD
18637	20390	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20390	12	1914	1914	CD
18637	20390	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20390	14	.	.	.
18637	20391	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20391	2	138	138	CD
18637	20391	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20391	4	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	20391	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20391	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20391	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20391	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20391	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20391	10	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	20391	11	,	,	,
18637	20391	12	233	233	CD
18637	20391	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20391	14	685	685	CD
18637	20391	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20391	16	1914	1914	CD
18637	20391	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20391	18	.	.	.
18637	20392	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20392	2	139	139	CD
18637	20392	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20392	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20392	5	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	20392	6	,	,	,
18637	20392	7	I.M.	I.M.	NNP
18637	20393	1	&	&	CC
18637	20393	2	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	20394	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20394	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20394	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20394	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20394	5	Paul	Paul	NNP
18637	20394	6	,	,	,
18637	20394	7	173	173	CD
18637	20394	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20394	9	404	404	CD
18637	20394	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20394	11	1899	1899	CD
18637	20394	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20394	13	.	.	.
18637	20395	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20395	2	140	140	CD
18637	20395	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20395	4	Rail	Rail	NNP
18637	20395	5	&	&	CC
18637	20395	6	River	River	NNP
18637	20395	7	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	20395	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20395	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20395	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20395	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20395	12	Yaple	Yaple	NNP
18637	20395	13	,	,	,
18637	20395	14	236	236	CD
18637	20395	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20395	16	338	338	CD
18637	20395	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20395	18	1915	1915	CD
18637	20395	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20395	20	.	.	.
18637	20396	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20396	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20396	3	also	also	RB
18637	20396	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20396	5	McClean	McClean	NNP
18637	20396	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20396	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20396	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20396	9	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	20396	10	,	,	,
18637	20396	11	211	211	CD
18637	20396	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20396	13	539	539	CD
18637	20396	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20396	15	1909	1909	CD
18637	20396	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20396	17	.	.	.
18637	20397	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20397	2	141	141	CD
18637	20397	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20397	4	West	West	NNP
18637	20397	5	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	20397	6	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	20397	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20397	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20397	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20397	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20397	11	Parrish	Parrish	NNP
18637	20397	12	,	,	,
18637	20397	13	300	300	CD
18637	20397	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20397	15	379	379	CD
18637	20397	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20397	17	1937	1937	CD
18637	20397	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20397	19	,	,	,
18637	20397	20	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	20397	21	Adkins	Adkins	NNP
18637	20397	22	_	_	NNP
18637	20397	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	20397	24	_	_	NNP
18637	20397	25	Children	Children	NNP
18637	20397	26	's	's	POS
18637	20397	27	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	20397	28	,	,	,
18637	20397	29	261	261	CD
18637	20397	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20397	31	255	255	CD
18637	20397	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20397	33	1923	1923	CD
18637	20397	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20397	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20397	36	a	a	DT
18637	20397	37	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	20397	38	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20397	39	case	case	NN
18637	20397	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20397	41	;	;	:
18637	20397	42	Morehead	Morehead	NNP
18637	20397	43	_	_	NNP
18637	20397	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	20397	45	_	_	NNP
18637	20397	46	New	New	NNP
18637	20397	47	York	York	NNP
18637	20397	48	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20397	49	rel	rel	NN
18637	20397	50	.	.	.
18637	20398	1	Tipaldo	Tipaldo	NNP
18637	20398	2	,	,	,
18637	20398	3	298	298	CD
18637	20398	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20398	5	587	587	CD
18637	20398	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20398	7	1936	1936	CD
18637	20398	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20398	9	.	.	.
18637	20399	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20399	2	142	142	CD
18637	20399	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20399	4	Day	Day	NNP
18637	20399	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	20399	6	Brite	Brite	NNP
18637	20399	7	Lighting	Lighting	NNP
18637	20399	8	,	,	,
18637	20399	9	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	20399	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20399	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	20399	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20399	13	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20399	14	,	,	,
18637	20399	15	342	342	CD
18637	20399	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20399	17	421	421	CD
18637	20399	18	,	,	,
18637	20399	19	423	423	CD
18637	20399	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20399	21	1952	1952	CD
18637	20399	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20399	23	.	.	.
18637	20400	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20400	2	143	143	CD
18637	20400	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20400	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20400	5	.	.	.
18637	20400	6	,	,	,
18637	20400	7	424	424	CD
18637	20400	8	-	-	SYM
18637	20400	9	425	425	CD
18637	20400	10	.	.	.
18637	20401	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20401	2	144	144	CD
18637	20401	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20401	4	New	New	NNP
18637	20401	5	York	York	NNP
18637	20401	6	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	20402	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20402	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20402	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20402	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20402	5	White	White	NNP
18637	20402	6	,	,	,
18637	20402	7	243	243	CD
18637	20402	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20402	9	188	188	CD
18637	20402	10	,	,	,
18637	20402	11	200	200	CD
18637	20402	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20402	13	1917	1917	CD
18637	20402	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20402	15	.	.	.
18637	20403	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20403	2	145	145	CD
18637	20403	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20403	4	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	20403	5	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	20403	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20403	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20403	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20403	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20403	10	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	20403	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20403	12	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	20403	13	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	20403	14	'	'	POS
18637	20403	15	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	20403	16	Cases	case	NNS
18637	20403	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20403	18	,	,	,
18637	20403	19	250	250	CD
18637	20403	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20403	21	400	400	CD
18637	20403	22	,	,	,
18637	20403	23	419	419	CD
18637	20403	24	-	-	SYM
18637	20403	25	420	420	CD
18637	20403	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20403	27	1919	1919	CD
18637	20403	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20403	29	.	.	.
18637	20404	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20404	2	146	146	CD
18637	20404	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20404	4	In	in	IN
18637	20404	5	determining	determine	VBG
18637	20404	6	what	what	WP
18637	20404	7	occupations	occupation	NNS
18637	20404	8	may	may	MD
18637	20404	9	be	be	VB
18637	20404	10	brought	bring	VBN
18637	20404	11	under	under	IN
18637	20404	12	the	the	DT
18637	20404	13	designation	designation	NN
18637	20404	14	of	of	IN
18637	20404	15	"	"	``
18637	20404	16	hazardous	hazardous	JJ
18637	20404	17	,	,	,
18637	20404	18	"	"	''
18637	20404	19	the	the	DT
18637	20404	20	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	20404	21	may	may	MD
18637	20404	22	carry	carry	VB
18637	20404	23	the	the	DT
18637	20404	24	idea	idea	NN
18637	20404	25	to	to	IN
18637	20404	26	the	the	DT
18637	20404	27	"	"	``
18637	20404	28	vanishing	vanishing	JJ
18637	20404	29	point	point	NN
18637	20404	30	.	.	.
18637	20404	31	"	"	''
18637	20405	1	--Ward	--Ward	NNP
18637	20405	2	&	&	CC
18637	20405	3	Gow	Gow	NNP
18637	20405	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20405	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	20405	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20405	7	Krinsky	Krinsky	NNP
18637	20405	8	,	,	,
18637	20405	9	259	259	CD
18637	20405	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20405	11	503	503	CD
18637	20405	12	,	,	,
18637	20405	13	520	520	CD
18637	20405	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20405	15	1922	1922	CD
18637	20405	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20405	17	.	.	.
18637	20406	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20406	2	147	147	CD
18637	20406	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20406	4	New	New	NNP
18637	20406	5	York	York	NNP
18637	20406	6	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	20407	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20407	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20407	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20407	4	White	White	NNP
18637	20407	5	,	,	,
18637	20407	6	243	243	CD
18637	20407	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20407	8	188	188	CD
18637	20407	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20407	10	1917	1917	CD
18637	20407	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20407	12	;	;	:
18637	20407	13	Mountain	Mountain	NNP
18637	20407	14	Timber	Timber	NNP
18637	20407	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20407	16	_	_	NNP
18637	20407	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	20407	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20407	19	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	20407	20	,	,	,
18637	20407	21	243	243	CD
18637	20407	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20407	23	219	219	CD
18637	20407	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20407	25	1917	1917	CD
18637	20407	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20407	27	.	.	.
18637	20408	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20408	2	148	148	CD
18637	20408	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20408	4	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	20408	5	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	20408	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20408	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20408	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20408	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20408	10	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	20408	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20408	12	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	20408	13	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	20408	14	'	'	POS
18637	20408	15	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	20408	16	Cases	case	NNS
18637	20408	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20408	18	,	,	,
18637	20408	19	250	250	CD
18637	20408	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20408	21	400	400	CD
18637	20408	22	,	,	,
18637	20408	23	419	419	CD
18637	20408	24	-	-	SYM
18637	20408	25	420	420	CD
18637	20408	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20408	27	1919	1919	CD
18637	20408	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20408	29	.	.	.
18637	20409	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20409	2	149	149	CD
18637	20409	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20409	4	Hawkins	Hawkins	NNP
18637	20409	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20409	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20409	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20409	8	Bleakly	Bleakly	NNP
18637	20409	9	,	,	,
18637	20409	10	243	243	CD
18637	20409	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20409	12	210	210	CD
18637	20409	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20409	14	1917	1917	CD
18637	20409	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20409	16	.	.	.
18637	20410	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20410	2	150	150	CD
18637	20410	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20410	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20410	5	,	,	,
18637	20410	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	20411	1	&	&	CC
18637	20411	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	20412	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20412	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20412	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20412	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20412	5	McGuire	McGuire	NNP
18637	20412	6	,	,	,
18637	20412	7	219	219	CD
18637	20412	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20412	9	549	549	CD
18637	20412	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20412	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	20412	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20412	13	.	.	.
18637	20413	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20413	2	151	151	CD
18637	20413	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20413	4	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	20413	5	Packers	Packers	NNP
18637	20413	6	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	20413	7	.	.	.
18637	20414	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20414	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20414	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20414	4	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	20414	5	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20414	6	,	,	,
18637	20414	7	294	294	CD
18637	20414	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20414	9	532	532	CD
18637	20414	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20414	11	1935	1935	CD
18637	20414	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20414	13	.	.	.
18637	20415	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20415	2	152	152	CD
18637	20415	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20415	4	Thornton	Thornton	NNP
18637	20415	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20415	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20415	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20415	8	Duffy	Duffy	NNP
18637	20415	9	,	,	,
18637	20415	10	254	254	CD
18637	20415	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20415	12	361	361	CD
18637	20415	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20415	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	20415	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20415	16	.	.	.
18637	20416	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20416	2	153	153	CD
18637	20416	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20416	4	Booth	Booth	NNP
18637	20416	5	Fisheries	Fisheries	NNPS
18637	20416	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20416	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20416	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20416	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20416	10	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	20416	11	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20416	12	,	,	,
18637	20416	13	271	271	CD
18637	20416	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20416	15	208	208	CD
18637	20416	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20416	17	1920	1920	CD
18637	20416	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20416	19	.	.	.
18637	20417	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20417	2	154	154	CD
18637	20417	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20417	4	Staten	Staten	NNP
18637	20417	5	Island	Island	NNP
18637	20417	6	R.T.R.	R.T.R.	NNP
18637	20418	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20418	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20418	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20418	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20418	5	Phoenix	Phoenix	NNP
18637	20418	6	Indemnity	Indemnity	NNP
18637	20418	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20418	8	,	,	,
18637	20418	9	281	281	CD
18637	20418	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20418	11	98	98	CD
18637	20418	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20418	13	1930	1930	CD
18637	20418	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20418	15	.	.	.
18637	20419	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20419	2	155	155	CD
18637	20419	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20419	4	Sheehan	Sheehan	NNP
18637	20419	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20419	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20419	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20419	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20419	9	Shuler	Shuler	NNP
18637	20419	10	,	,	,
18637	20419	11	265	265	CD
18637	20419	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20419	13	371	371	CD
18637	20419	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20419	15	1924	1924	CD
18637	20419	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20419	17	;	;	:
18637	20419	18	New	New	NNP
18637	20419	19	York	York	NNP
18637	20419	20	State	State	NNP
18637	20419	21	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20419	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20419	23	_	_	NNP
18637	20419	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	20419	25	_	_	NNP
18637	20419	26	Shuler	Shuler	NNP
18637	20419	27	,	,	,
18637	20419	28	265	265	CD
18637	20419	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20419	30	379	379	CD
18637	20419	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20419	32	1924	1924	CD
18637	20419	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20419	34	.	.	.
18637	20420	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20420	2	156	156	CD
18637	20420	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20420	4	New	New	NNP
18637	20420	5	York	York	NNP
18637	20420	6	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	20421	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20421	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20421	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20421	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20421	5	Bianc	Bianc	NNP
18637	20421	6	,	,	,
18637	20421	7	250	250	CD
18637	20421	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20421	9	596	596	CD
18637	20421	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20421	11	1919).--Attorneys	1919).--attorney	NNS
18637	20421	12	are	be	VBP
18637	20421	13	not	not	RB
18637	20421	14	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	20421	15	of	of	IN
18637	20421	16	property	property	NN
18637	20421	17	or	or	CC
18637	20421	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20421	19	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	20421	20	of	of	IN
18637	20421	21	contract	contract	NN
18637	20421	22	by	by	IN
18637	20421	23	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	20421	24	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	20421	25	by	by	IN
18637	20421	26	the	the	DT
18637	20421	27	State	State	NNP
18637	20421	28	on	on	IN
18637	20421	29	the	the	DT
18637	20421	30	fees	fee	NNS
18637	20421	31	which	which	WDT
18637	20421	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20421	33	may	may	MD
18637	20421	34	charge	charge	VB
18637	20421	35	in	in	IN
18637	20421	36	cases	case	NNS
18637	20421	37	arising	arise	VBG
18637	20421	38	under	under	IN
18637	20421	39	the	the	DT
18637	20421	40	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	20421	41	's	's	POS
18637	20421	42	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	20421	43	law.--Yeiser	law.--Yeiser	NNP
18637	20421	44	_	_	NNP
18637	20421	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	20421	46	_	_	NNP
18637	20421	47	Dysart	Dysart	NNP
18637	20421	48	,	,	,
18637	20421	49	267	267	CD
18637	20421	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20421	51	540	540	CD
18637	20421	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20421	53	1925	1925	CD
18637	20421	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20421	55	.	.	.
18637	20422	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20422	2	157	157	CD
18637	20422	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20422	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20422	5	Black	Black	NNP
18637	20422	6	in	in	IN
18637	20422	7	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	20422	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	20422	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20422	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20422	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20422	12	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	20422	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20422	14	,	,	,
18637	20422	15	335	335	CD
18637	20422	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20422	17	525	525	CD
18637	20422	18	,	,	,
18637	20422	19	535	535	CD
18637	20422	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20422	21	1949	1949	CD
18637	20422	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20422	23	.	.	.
18637	20423	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20423	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20423	3	also	also	RB
18637	20423	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20423	5	pp	pp	NNP
18637	20423	6	.	.	.
18637	20424	1	141	141	CD
18637	20424	2	,	,	,
18637	20424	3	977	977	CD
18637	20424	4	-	-	SYM
18637	20424	5	979	979	CD
18637	20424	6	,	,	,
18637	20424	7	985	985	CD
18637	20424	8	.	.	.
18637	20425	1	In	in	IN
18637	20425	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20425	3	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	20425	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	20425	5	,	,	,
18637	20425	6	contained	contain	VBN
18637	20425	7	in	in	IN
18637	20425	8	the	the	DT
18637	20425	9	companion	companion	NN
18637	20425	10	case	case	NN
18637	20425	11	of	of	IN
18637	20425	12	American	American	NNP
18637	20425	13	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	20425	14	of	of	IN
18637	20425	15	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	20425	16	_	_	NNP
18637	20425	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	20425	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20425	19	American	American	NNP
18637	20425	20	Sash	Sash	NNP
18637	20425	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20425	22	,	,	,
18637	20425	23	335	335	CD
18637	20425	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20425	25	538	538	CD
18637	20425	26	,	,	,
18637	20425	27	543	543	CD
18637	20425	28	-	-	SYM
18637	20425	29	544	544	CD
18637	20425	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20425	31	1949	1949	CD
18637	20425	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20425	33	,	,	,
18637	20425	34	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20425	35	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	20425	36	summarized	summarize	VBD
18637	20425	37	as	as	IN
18637	20425	38	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	20425	39	the	the	DT
18637	20425	40	now	now	RB
18637	20425	41	obsolete	obsolete	JJ
18637	20425	42	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	20425	43	employed	employ	VBN
18637	20425	44	by	by	IN
18637	20425	45	the	the	DT
18637	20425	46	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20425	47	to	to	TO
18637	20425	48	strike	strike	VB
18637	20425	49	down	down	RP
18637	20425	50	State	state	NN
18637	20425	51	laws	law	NNS
18637	20425	52	fostering	foster	VBG
18637	20425	53	unionization	unionization	NN
18637	20425	54	.	.	.
18637	20426	1	"	"	``
18637	20426	2	*	*	NFP
18637	20426	3	*	*	NFP
18637	20426	4	*	*	NFP
18637	20426	5	unionization	unionization	NN
18637	20426	6	encountered	encounter	VBD
18637	20426	7	the	the	DT
18637	20426	8	shibboleths	shibboleth	NNS
18637	20426	9	of	of	IN
18637	20426	10	a	a	DT
18637	20426	11	premachine	premachine	NN
18637	20426	12	age	age	NN
18637	20426	13	and	and	CC
18637	20426	14	these	these	DT
18637	20426	15	were	be	VBD
18637	20426	16	reflected	reflect	VBN
18637	20426	17	in	in	IN
18637	20426	18	juridical	juridical	JJ
18637	20426	19	assumptions	assumption	NNS
18637	20426	20	that	that	WDT
18637	20426	21	survived	survive	VBD
18637	20426	22	the	the	DT
18637	20426	23	facts	fact	NNS
18637	20426	24	on	on	IN
18637	20426	25	which	which	WDT
18637	20426	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20426	27	were	be	VBD
18637	20426	28	based	base	VBN
18637	20426	29	.	.	.
18637	20427	1	Adam	Adam	NNP
18637	20427	2	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	20427	3	was	be	VBD
18637	20427	4	treated	treat	VBN
18637	20427	5	as	as	IN
18637	20427	6	though	though	IN
18637	20427	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20427	8	generalizations	generalization	NNS
18637	20427	9	had	have	VBD
18637	20427	10	been	be	VBN
18637	20427	11	imparted	impart	VBN
18637	20427	12	to	to	IN
18637	20427	13	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20427	14	on	on	IN
18637	20427	15	Sinai	Sinai	NNP
18637	20427	16	and	and	CC
18637	20427	17	not	not	RB
18637	20427	18	as	as	IN
18637	20427	19	a	a	DT
18637	20427	20	thinker	thinker	NN
18637	20427	21	who	who	WP
18637	20427	22	addressed	address	VBD
18637	20427	23	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20427	24	to	to	IN
18637	20427	25	the	the	DT
18637	20427	26	elimination	elimination	NN
18637	20427	27	of	of	IN
18637	20427	28	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	20427	29	which	which	WDT
18637	20427	30	had	have	VBD
18637	20427	31	become	become	VBN
18637	20427	32	fetters	fetter	NNS
18637	20427	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	20427	34	initiative	initiative	NN
18637	20427	35	and	and	CC
18637	20427	36	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	20427	37	in	in	IN
18637	20427	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20427	39	day	day	NN
18637	20427	40	.	.	.
18637	20428	1	Basic	basic	JJ
18637	20428	2	human	human	JJ
18637	20428	3	rights	right	NNS
18637	20428	4	expressed	express	VBN
18637	20428	5	by	by	IN
18637	20428	6	the	the	DT
18637	20428	7	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	20428	8	conception	conception	NN
18637	20428	9	of	of	IN
18637	20428	10	'	'	``
18637	20428	11	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	20428	12	'	'	''
18637	20428	13	were	be	VBD
18637	20428	14	equated	equate	VBN
18637	20428	15	with	with	IN
18637	20428	16	theories	theory	NNS
18637	20428	17	of	of	IN
18637	20428	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20428	19	laissez	laissez	NNP
18637	20428	20	faire	faire	NN
18637	20428	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20428	22	.	.	.
18637	20429	1	The	the	DT
18637	20429	2	result	result	NN
18637	20429	3	was	be	VBD
18637	20429	4	that	that	IN
18637	20429	5	economic	economic	JJ
18637	20429	6	views	view	NNS
18637	20429	7	of	of	IN
18637	20429	8	confined	confine	VBN
18637	20429	9	validity	validity	NN
18637	20429	10	were	be	VBD
18637	20429	11	treated	treat	VBN
18637	20429	12	by	by	IN
18637	20429	13	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
18637	20429	14	and	and	CC
18637	20429	15	judges	judge	NNS
18637	20429	16	as	as	IN
18637	20429	17	though	though	IN
18637	20429	18	the	the	DT
18637	20429	19	Framers	Framers	NNPS
18637	20429	20	had	have	VBD
18637	20429	21	enshrined	enshrine	VBN
18637	20429	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20429	23	in	in	IN
18637	20429	24	the	the	DT
18637	20429	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	20429	26	.	.	.
18637	20430	1	*	*	NFP
18637	20430	2	*	*	NFP
18637	20430	3	*	*	NFP
18637	20430	4	The	the	DT
18637	20430	5	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	20430	6	which	which	WDT
18637	20430	7	regarded	regard	VBD
18637	20430	8	any	any	DT
18637	20430	9	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	20430	10	encroachment	encroachment	NN
18637	20430	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	20430	12	the	the	DT
18637	20430	13	existing	exist	VBG
18637	20430	14	economic	economic	JJ
18637	20430	15	order	order	NN
18637	20430	16	as	as	IN
18637	20430	17	infected	infect	VBN
18637	20430	18	with	with	IN
18637	20430	19	unconstitutionality	unconstitutionality	NN
18637	20430	20	led	lead	VBN
18637	20430	21	to	to	TO
18637	20430	22	disrespect	disrespect	VB
18637	20430	23	for	for	IN
18637	20430	24	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	20430	25	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	20430	26	to	to	TO
18637	20430	27	strengthen	strengthen	VB
18637	20430	28	the	the	DT
18637	20430	29	wage	wage	NN
18637	20430	30	-	-	HYPH
18637	20430	31	earners	earner	NNS
18637	20430	32	'	'	POS
18637	20430	33	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	20430	34	power	power	NN
18637	20430	35	.	.	.
18637	20431	1	With	with	IN
18637	20431	2	that	that	DT
18637	20431	3	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	20431	4	as	as	IN
18637	20431	5	a	a	DT
18637	20431	6	premise	premise	NN
18637	20431	7	,	,	,
18637	20431	8	Adair	Adair	NNP
18637	20431	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20431	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20431	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20431	12	United	United	NNP
18637	20431	13	States	States	NNP
18637	20431	14	,	,	,
18637	20431	15	208	208	CD
18637	20431	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20431	17	161	161	CD
18637	20431	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20431	19	1908	1908	CD
18637	20431	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20431	21	,	,	,
18637	20431	22	and	and	CC
18637	20431	23	Coppage	Coppage	NNP
18637	20431	24	_	_	NNP
18637	20431	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	20431	26	_	_	NNP
18637	20431	27	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20431	28	,	,	,
18637	20431	29	236	236	CD
18637	20431	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20431	31	1	1	CD
18637	20431	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20431	33	1915	1915	CD
18637	20431	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20431	35	,	,	,
18637	20431	36	followed	follow	VBD
18637	20431	37	logically	logically	RB
18637	20431	38	enough	enough	RB
18637	20431	39	;	;	:
18637	20431	40	not	not	RB
18637	20431	41	even	even	RB
18637	20431	42	Truax	Truax	NNP
18637	20431	43	_	_	NNP
18637	20431	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	20431	45	_	_	NNP
18637	20431	46	Corrigan	Corrigan	NNP
18637	20431	47	,	,	,
18637	20431	48	257	257	CD
18637	20431	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20431	50	312	312	CD
18637	20431	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20431	52	1921	1921	CD
18637	20431	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20431	54	,	,	,
18637	20431	55	could	could	MD
18637	20431	56	be	be	VB
18637	20431	57	considered	consider	VBN
18637	20431	58	unexpected	unexpected	JJ
18637	20431	59	.	.	.
18637	20431	60	"	"	''
18637	20432	1	On	on	IN
18637	20432	2	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	20432	3	of	of	IN
18637	20432	4	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	20432	5	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	20432	6	of	of	IN
18637	20432	7	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	20432	8	of	of	IN
18637	20432	9	contract	contract	NN
18637	20432	10	,	,	,
18637	20432	11	or	or	CC
18637	20432	12	more	more	RBR
18637	20432	13	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	20432	14	,	,	,
18637	20432	15	of	of	IN
18637	20432	16	the	the	DT
18637	20432	17	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
18637	20432	18	right	right	NN
18637	20432	19	of	of	IN
18637	20432	20	the	the	DT
18637	20432	21	employer	employer	NN
18637	20432	22	to	to	TO
18637	20432	23	hire	hire	VB
18637	20432	24	and	and	CC
18637	20432	25	fire	fire	VB
18637	20432	26	,	,	,
18637	20432	27	a	a	DT
18637	20432	28	federal	federal	JJ
18637	20432	29	and	and	CC
18637	20432	30	a	a	DT
18637	20432	31	State	State	NNP
18637	20432	32	statute	statute	NN
18637	20432	33	attempting	attempt	VBG
18637	20432	34	to	to	TO
18637	20432	35	outlaw	outlaw	VB
18637	20432	36	"	"	``
18637	20432	37	yellow	yellow	JJ
18637	20432	38	dog	dog	NN
18637	20432	39	"	"	''
18637	20432	40	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	20432	41	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	20432	42	,	,	,
18637	20432	43	as	as	IN
18637	20432	44	a	a	DT
18637	20432	45	condition	condition	NN
18637	20432	46	of	of	IN
18637	20432	47	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	20432	48	employment	employment	NN
18637	20432	49	,	,	,
18637	20432	50	a	a	DT
18637	20432	51	worker	worker	NN
18637	20432	52	had	have	VBD
18637	20432	53	to	to	TO
18637	20432	54	agree	agree	VB
18637	20432	55	not	not	RB
18637	20432	56	to	to	TO
18637	20432	57	join	join	VB
18637	20432	58	or	or	CC
18637	20432	59	to	to	TO
18637	20432	60	remain	remain	VB
18637	20432	61	a	a	DT
18637	20432	62	member	member	NN
18637	20432	63	of	of	IN
18637	20432	64	a	a	DT
18637	20432	65	union	union	NN
18637	20432	66	,	,	,
18637	20432	67	were	be	VBD
18637	20432	68	voided	void	VBN
18637	20432	69	in	in	IN
18637	20432	70	Adair	Adair	NNP
18637	20432	71	_	_	NNP
18637	20432	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	20432	73	_	_	NNP
18637	20432	74	United	United	NNP
18637	20432	75	States	States	NNP
18637	20432	76	and	and	CC
18637	20432	77	Coppage	Coppage	NNP
18637	20432	78	_	_	NNP
18637	20432	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	20432	80	_	_	NNP
18637	20432	81	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20432	82	,	,	,
18637	20432	83	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	20432	84	.	.	.
18637	20433	1	In	in	IN
18637	20433	2	Truax	Truax	NNP
18637	20433	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20433	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	20433	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20433	6	Corrigan	Corrigan	NNP
18637	20433	7	,	,	,
18637	20433	8	a	a	DT
18637	20433	9	majority	majority	NN
18637	20433	10	of	of	IN
18637	20433	11	the	the	DT
18637	20433	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20433	13	held	hold	VBD
18637	20433	14	that	that	IN
18637	20433	15	an	an	DT
18637	20433	16	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	20433	17	statute	statute	NN
18637	20433	18	which	which	WDT
18637	20433	19	operated	operate	VBD
18637	20433	20	,	,	,
18637	20433	21	in	in	IN
18637	20433	22	effect	effect	NN
18637	20433	23	,	,	,
18637	20433	24	to	to	TO
18637	20433	25	make	make	VB
18637	20433	26	remediless	remediless	NN
18637	20433	27	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20433	28	by	by	IN
18637	20433	29	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	20433	30	the	the	DT
18637	20433	31	use	use	NN
18637	20433	32	of	of	IN
18637	20433	33	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	20433	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20433	35	injury	injury	NN
18637	20433	36	to	to	IN
18637	20433	37	an	an	DT
18637	20433	38	employer	employer	NN
18637	20433	39	's	's	POS
18637	20433	40	business	business	NN
18637	20433	41	by	by	IN
18637	20433	42	striking	strike	VBG
18637	20433	43	employees	employee	NNS
18637	20433	44	and	and	CC
18637	20433	45	others	other	NNS
18637	20433	46	,	,	,
18637	20433	47	through	through	IN
18637	20433	48	concerted	concert	VBN
18637	20433	49	action	action	NN
18637	20433	50	in	in	IN
18637	20433	51	picketing	picket	VBG
18637	20433	52	,	,	,
18637	20433	53	displaying	display	VBG
18637	20433	54	banners	banner	NNS
18637	20433	55	advertising	advertise	VBG
18637	20433	56	the	the	DT
18637	20433	57	strike	strike	NN
18637	20433	58	,	,	,
18637	20433	59	denouncing	denounce	VBG
18637	20433	60	the	the	DT
18637	20433	61	employer	employer	NN
18637	20433	62	as	as	IN
18637	20433	63	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	20433	64	to	to	IN
18637	20433	65	union	union	NN
18637	20433	66	labor	labor	NN
18637	20433	67	,	,	,
18637	20433	68	appealing	appeal	VBG
18637	20433	69	to	to	IN
18637	20433	70	customers	customer	NNS
18637	20433	71	to	to	TO
18637	20433	72	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	20433	73	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20433	74	patronage	patronage	NN
18637	20433	75	,	,	,
18637	20433	76	and	and	CC
18637	20433	77	circulating	circulate	VBG
18637	20433	78	handbills	handbill	NNS
18637	20433	79	containing	contain	VBG
18637	20433	80	abusive	abusive	JJ
18637	20433	81	and	and	CC
18637	20433	82	libelous	libelous	JJ
18637	20433	83	charges	charge	NNS
18637	20433	84	against	against	IN
18637	20433	85	employers	employer	NNS
18637	20433	86	,	,	,
18637	20433	87	employees	employee	NNS
18637	20433	88	,	,	,
18637	20433	89	and	and	CC
18637	20433	90	patrons	patron	NNS
18637	20433	91	,	,	,
18637	20433	92	and	and	CC
18637	20433	93	intimidations	intimidation	NNS
18637	20433	94	of	of	IN
18637	20433	95	injury	injury	NN
18637	20433	96	to	to	IN
18637	20433	97	future	future	JJ
18637	20433	98	patrons	patron	NNS
18637	20433	99	,	,	,
18637	20433	100	deprives	deprive	VBZ
18637	20433	101	the	the	DT
18637	20433	102	owner	owner	NN
18637	20433	103	of	of	IN
18637	20433	104	the	the	DT
18637	20433	105	business	business	NN
18637	20433	106	and	and	CC
18637	20433	107	the	the	DT
18637	20433	108	premises	premise	NNS
18637	20433	109	of	of	IN
18637	20433	110	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20433	111	property	property	NN
18637	20433	112	without	without	IN
18637	20433	113	due	due	JJ
18637	20433	114	process	process	NN
18637	20433	115	of	of	IN
18637	20433	116	law	law	NN
18637	20433	117	.	.	.
18637	20434	1	In	in	IN
18637	20434	2	Wolff	Wolff	NNP
18637	20434	3	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	20434	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20434	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20434	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20434	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20434	8	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	20434	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20434	10	,	,	,
18637	20434	11	262	262	CD
18637	20434	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20434	13	522	522	CD
18637	20434	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20434	15	1923	1923	CD
18637	20434	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20434	17	;	;	:
18637	20434	18	267	267	CD
18637	20434	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20434	20	552	552	CD
18637	20434	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20434	22	1925	1925	CD
18637	20434	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20434	24	and	and	CC
18637	20434	25	in	in	IN
18637	20434	26	Dorchy	Dorchy	NNP
18637	20434	27	_	_	NNP
18637	20434	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	20434	29	_	_	NNP
18637	20434	30	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20434	31	,	,	,
18637	20434	32	264	264	CD
18637	20434	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20434	34	286	286	CD
18637	20434	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20434	36	1924	1924	CD
18637	20434	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20434	38	,	,	,
18637	20434	39	the	the	DT
18637	20434	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20434	41	had	have	VBD
18637	20434	42	also	also	RB
18637	20434	43	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	20434	44	that	that	IN
18637	20434	45	a	a	DT
18637	20434	46	statute	statute	NN
18637	20434	47	compelling	compel	VBG
18637	20434	48	employers	employer	NNS
18637	20434	49	and	and	CC
18637	20434	50	employees	employee	NNS
18637	20434	51	to	to	TO
18637	20434	52	submit	submit	VB
18637	20434	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20434	54	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	20434	55	over	over	IN
18637	20434	56	wages	wage	NNS
18637	20434	57	and	and	CC
18637	20434	58	hours	hour	NNS
18637	20434	59	of	of	IN
18637	20434	60	labor	labor	NN
18637	20434	61	to	to	IN
18637	20434	62	State	state	NN
18637	20434	63	arbitration	arbitration	NN
18637	20434	64	was	be	VBD
18637	20434	65	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	20434	66	as	as	IN
18637	20434	67	part	part	NN
18637	20434	68	of	of	IN
18637	20434	69	a	a	DT
18637	20434	70	system	system	NN
18637	20434	71	compelling	compel	VBG
18637	20434	72	employers	employer	NNS
18637	20434	73	and	and	CC
18637	20434	74	employees	employee	NNS
18637	20434	75	to	to	TO
18637	20434	76	continue	continue	VB
18637	20434	77	in	in	IN
18637	20434	78	business	business	NN
18637	20434	79	on	on	IN
18637	20434	80	terms	term	NNS
18637	20434	81	not	not	RB
18637	20434	82	of	of	IN
18637	20434	83	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20434	84	own	own	JJ
18637	20434	85	making	making	NN
18637	20434	86	.	.	.
18637	20435	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20435	2	158	158	CD
18637	20435	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20435	4	301	301	CD
18637	20435	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20435	6	468	468	CD
18637	20435	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20435	8	1937	1937	CD
18637	20435	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20435	10	.	.	.
18637	20436	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20436	2	159	159	CD
18637	20436	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20436	4	Prudential	Prudential	NNP
18637	20436	5	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20436	6	.	.	.
18637	20437	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20437	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20437	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20437	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20437	5	Cheek	Cheek	NNP
18637	20437	6	,	,	,
18637	20437	7	259	259	CD
18637	20437	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20437	9	530	530	CD
18637	20437	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20437	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	20437	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20437	13	.	.	.
18637	20438	1	In	in	IN
18637	20438	2	conjunction	conjunction	NN
18637	20438	3	with	with	IN
18637	20438	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20438	5	approval	approval	NN
18637	20438	6	of	of	IN
18637	20438	7	this	this	DT
18637	20438	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	20438	9	,	,	,
18637	20438	10	the	the	DT
18637	20438	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20438	12	also	also	RB
18637	20438	13	sanctioned	sanction	VBD
18637	20438	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	20438	15	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	20438	16	by	by	IN
18637	20438	17	a	a	DT
18637	20438	18	State	State	NNP
18637	20438	19	court	court	NN
18637	20438	20	of	of	IN
18637	20438	21	a	a	DT
18637	20438	22	local	local	JJ
18637	20438	23	rule	rule	NN
18637	20438	24	of	of	IN
18637	20438	25	policy	policy	NN
18637	20438	26	which	which	WDT
18637	20438	27	rendered	render	VBD
18637	20438	28	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	20438	29	an	an	DT
18637	20438	30	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	20438	31	of	of	IN
18637	20438	32	several	several	JJ
18637	20438	33	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	20438	34	companies	company	NNS
18637	20438	35	having	have	VBG
18637	20438	36	a	a	DT
18637	20438	37	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	20438	38	of	of	IN
18637	20438	39	a	a	DT
18637	20438	40	line	line	NN
18637	20438	41	of	of	IN
18637	20438	42	business	business	NN
18637	20438	43	in	in	IN
18637	20438	44	a	a	DT
18637	20438	45	city	city	NN
18637	20438	46	that	that	WDT
18637	20438	47	none	none	NN
18637	20438	48	would	would	MD
18637	20438	49	employ	employ	VB
18637	20438	50	within	within	IN
18637	20438	51	two	two	CD
18637	20438	52	years	year	NNS
18637	20438	53	any	any	DT
18637	20438	54	man	man	NN
18637	20438	55	who	who	WP
18637	20438	56	had	have	VBD
18637	20438	57	been	be	VBN
18637	20438	58	discharged	discharge	VBN
18637	20438	59	from	from	IN
18637	20438	60	,	,	,
18637	20438	61	or	or	CC
18637	20438	62	left	leave	VBN
18637	20438	63	,	,	,
18637	20438	64	the	the	DT
18637	20438	65	service	service	NN
18637	20438	66	of	of	IN
18637	20438	67	any	any	DT
18637	20438	68	of	of	IN
18637	20438	69	the	the	DT
18637	20438	70	others	other	NNS
18637	20438	71	.	.	.
18637	20439	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20439	2	160	160	CD
18637	20439	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20439	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20439	5	,	,	,
18637	20439	6	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	20439	7	&	&	CC
18637	20439	8	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20440	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20440	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20440	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20440	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20440	5	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	20440	6	,	,	,
18637	20440	7	259	259	CD
18637	20440	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20440	9	548	548	CD
18637	20440	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20440	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	20440	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20440	13	.	.	.
18637	20441	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20441	2	161	161	CD
18637	20441	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20441	4	Dorchy	Dorchy	NNP
18637	20441	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20441	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20441	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20441	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20441	9	,	,	,
18637	20441	10	272	272	CD
18637	20441	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20441	12	306	306	CD
18637	20441	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20441	14	1926	1926	CD
18637	20441	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20441	16	.	.	.
18637	20442	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20442	2	162	162	CD
18637	20442	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20442	4	301	301	CD
18637	20442	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20442	6	468	468	CD
18637	20442	7	,	,	,
18637	20442	8	479	479	CD
18637	20442	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20442	10	1937	1937	CD
18637	20442	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20442	12	.	.	.
18637	20443	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20443	2	163	163	CD
18637	20443	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20443	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20443	5	See	See	NNP
18637	20443	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20443	7	p.	p.	NN
18637	20443	8	1141	1141	CD
18637	20443	9	.	.	.
18637	20444	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20444	2	164	164	CD
18637	20444	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20444	4	Cases	case	NNS
18637	20444	5	disposing	dispose	VBG
18637	20444	6	of	of	IN
18637	20444	7	the	the	DT
18637	20444	8	contention	contention	NN
18637	20444	9	that	that	IN
18637	20444	10	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	20444	11	on	on	IN
18637	20444	12	picketing	picket	VBG
18637	20444	13	amount	amount	NN
18637	20444	14	to	to	IN
18637	20444	15	a	a	DT
18637	20444	16	denial	denial	NN
18637	20444	17	of	of	IN
18637	20444	18	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	20444	19	of	of	IN
18637	20444	20	speech	speech	NN
18637	20444	21	and	and	CC
18637	20444	22	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	20444	23	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	20444	24	a	a	DT
18637	20444	25	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	20444	26	of	of	IN
18637	20444	27	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	20444	28	without	without	IN
18637	20444	29	due	due	JJ
18637	20444	30	process	process	NN
18637	20444	31	of	of	IN
18637	20444	32	law	law	NN
18637	20444	33	have	have	VBP
18637	20444	34	been	be	VBN
18637	20444	35	set	set	VBN
18637	20444	36	forth	forth	RP
18637	20444	37	under	under	IN
18637	20444	38	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20444	39	I.	I.	NNP
18637	20445	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20445	2	165	165	CD
18637	20445	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20445	4	326	326	CD
18637	20445	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20445	6	88	88	CD
18637	20445	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20445	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	20445	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20445	10	.	.	.
18637	20446	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20446	2	166	166	CD
18637	20446	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20446	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20446	5	.	.	.
18637	20447	1	94	94	CD
18637	20447	2	.	.	.
18637	20448	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20448	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	20448	3	,	,	,
18637	20448	4	concurring	concurring	NN
18637	20448	5	,	,	,
18637	20448	6	declared	declare	VBD
18637	20448	7	that	that	IN
18637	20448	8	"	"	``
18637	20448	9	the	the	DT
18637	20448	10	insistence	insistence	NN
18637	20448	11	by	by	IN
18637	20448	12	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	20448	13	on	on	IN
18637	20448	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20448	15	private	private	JJ
18637	20448	16	prejudices	prejudice	NNS
18637	20448	17	*	*	NFP
18637	20448	18	*	*	NFP
18637	20448	19	*	*	NFP
18637	20448	20	,	,	,
18637	20448	21	in	in	IN
18637	20448	22	relations	relation	NNS
18637	20448	23	like	like	IN
18637	20448	24	those	those	DT
18637	20448	25	now	now	RB
18637	20448	26	before	before	IN
18637	20448	27	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20448	28	,	,	,
18637	20448	29	ought	ought	MD
18637	20448	30	not	not	RB
18637	20448	31	to	to	TO
18637	20448	32	have	have	VB
18637	20448	33	a	a	DT
18637	20448	34	higher	high	JJR
18637	20448	35	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	20448	36	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	20448	37	than	than	IN
18637	20448	38	the	the	DT
18637	20448	39	determination	determination	NN
18637	20448	40	of	of	IN
18637	20448	41	a	a	DT
18637	20448	42	State	State	NNP
18637	20448	43	to	to	TO
18637	20448	44	extend	extend	VB
18637	20448	45	the	the	DT
18637	20448	46	area	area	NN
18637	20448	47	of	of	IN
18637	20448	48	nondiscrimination	nondiscrimination	NN
18637	20448	49	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	20448	50	that	that	DT
18637	20448	51	which	which	WDT
18637	20448	52	the	the	DT
18637	20448	53	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	20448	54	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20448	55	exacts	exact	VBZ
18637	20448	56	.	.	.
18637	20448	57	"	"	''
18637	20449	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	20449	2	.	.	.
18637	20450	1	98	98	CD
18637	20450	2	.	.	.
18637	20451	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20451	2	167	167	CD
18637	20451	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20451	4	335	335	CD
18637	20451	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20451	6	525	525	CD
18637	20451	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20451	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	20451	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20451	10	.	.	.
18637	20452	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20452	2	168	168	CD
18637	20452	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20452	4	335	335	CD
18637	20452	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20452	6	538	538	CD
18637	20452	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20452	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	20452	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20452	10	.	.	.
18637	20453	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20453	2	169	169	CD
18637	20453	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20453	4	335	335	CD
18637	20453	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20453	6	525	525	CD
18637	20453	7	,	,	,
18637	20453	8	534	534	CD
18637	20453	9	,	,	,
18637	20453	10	537	537	CD
18637	20453	11	.	.	.
18637	20454	1	In	in	IN
18637	20454	2	a	a	DT
18637	20454	3	lengthy	lengthy	JJ
18637	20454	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	20454	5	,	,	,
18637	20454	6	in	in	IN
18637	20454	7	which	which	WDT
18637	20454	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20454	9	registered	register	VBD
18637	20454	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20454	11	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	20454	12	with	with	IN
18637	20454	13	both	both	DT
18637	20454	14	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	20454	15	,	,	,
18637	20454	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20454	17	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	20454	18	set	set	VBD
18637	20454	19	forth	forth	RP
18637	20454	20	extensive	extensive	JJ
18637	20454	21	statistical	statistical	JJ
18637	20454	22	data	datum	NNS
18637	20454	23	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	20454	24	to	to	TO
18637	20454	25	prove	prove	VB
18637	20454	26	that	that	IN
18637	20454	27	labor	labor	NN
18637	20454	28	unions	union	NNS
18637	20454	29	not	not	RB
18637	20454	30	only	only	RB
18637	20454	31	were	be	VBD
18637	20454	32	possessed	possess	VBN
18637	20454	33	of	of	IN
18637	20454	34	considerable	considerable	JJ
18637	20454	35	economic	economic	JJ
18637	20454	36	power	power	NN
18637	20454	37	but	but	CC
18637	20454	38	by	by	IN
18637	20454	39	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	20454	40	of	of	IN
18637	20454	41	such	such	JJ
18637	20454	42	power	power	NN
18637	20454	43	were	be	VBD
18637	20454	44	no	no	RB
18637	20454	45	longer	longer	RB
18637	20454	46	dependent	dependent	JJ
18637	20454	47	on	on	IN
18637	20454	48	the	the	DT
18637	20454	49	closed	closed	JJ
18637	20454	50	shop	shop	NN
18637	20454	51	for	for	IN
18637	20454	52	survival	survival	NN
18637	20454	53	.	.	.
18637	20455	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20455	2	would	would	MD
18637	20455	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	20455	4	leave	leave	VB
18637	20455	5	to	to	IN
18637	20455	6	the	the	DT
18637	20455	7	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	20455	8	the	the	DT
18637	20455	9	determination	determination	NN
18637	20455	10	"	"	``
18637	20455	11	whether	whether	IN
18637	20455	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20455	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	20455	14	preferable	preferable	JJ
18637	20455	15	in	in	IN
18637	20455	16	the	the	DT
18637	20455	17	public	public	JJ
18637	20455	18	interest	interest	NN
18637	20455	19	that	that	WDT
18637	20455	20	trade	trade	NN
18637	20455	21	unions	union	NNS
18637	20455	22	should	should	MD
18637	20455	23	be	be	VB
18637	20455	24	subjected	subject	VBN
18637	20455	25	to	to	IN
18637	20455	26	State	state	NN
18637	20455	27	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	20455	28	or	or	CC
18637	20455	29	left	leave	VBD
18637	20455	30	to	to	IN
18637	20455	31	the	the	DT
18637	20455	32	free	free	JJ
18637	20455	33	play	play	NN
18637	20455	34	of	of	IN
18637	20455	35	social	social	JJ
18637	20455	36	forces	force	NNS
18637	20455	37	,	,	,
18637	20455	38	whether	whether	IN
18637	20455	39	experience	experience	NN
18637	20455	40	has	have	VBZ
18637	20455	41	disclosed	disclose	VBN
18637	20455	42	'	'	``
18637	20455	43	union	union	NNP
18637	20455	44	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	20455	45	labor	labor	NN
18637	20455	46	practices	practice	NNS
18637	20455	47	,	,	,
18637	20455	48	'	'	''
18637	20455	49	and	and	CC
18637	20455	50	,	,	,
18637	20455	51	if	if	IN
18637	20455	52	so	so	RB
18637	20455	53	,	,	,
18637	20455	54	whether	whether	IN
18637	20455	55	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	20455	56	correction	correction	NN
18637	20455	57	is	be	VBZ
18637	20455	58	more	more	RBR
18637	20455	59	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	20455	60	than	than	IN
18637	20455	61	self	self	NN
18637	20455	62	-	-	HYPH
18637	20455	63	discipline	discipline	NN
18637	20455	64	and	and	CC
18637	20455	65	pressure	pressure	NN
18637	20455	66	of	of	IN
18637	20455	67	public	public	JJ
18637	20455	68	opinion--	opinion--	NNP
18637	20455	69	*	*	NFP
18637	20455	70	*	*	NFP
18637	20455	71	*	*	NFP
18637	20455	72	.	.	.
18637	20455	73	"	"	''
18637	20456	1	335	335	CD
18637	20456	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20456	3	538	538	CD
18637	20456	4	,	,	,
18637	20456	5	549	549	CD
18637	20456	6	-	-	SYM
18637	20456	7	550	550	CD
18637	20456	8	.	.	.
18637	20457	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20457	2	170	170	CD
18637	20457	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20457	4	336	336	CD
18637	20457	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20457	6	245	245	CD
18637	20457	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20457	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	20457	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20457	10	.	.	.
18637	20458	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20458	2	171	171	CD
18637	20458	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20458	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20458	5	.	.	.
18637	20459	1	253	253	CD
18637	20459	2	.	.	.
18637	20460	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20460	2	172	172	CD
18637	20460	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20460	4	336	336	CD
18637	20460	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20460	6	490	490	CD
18637	20460	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20460	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	20460	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20460	10	.	.	.
18637	20461	1	Other	other	JJ
18637	20461	2	recent	recent	JJ
18637	20461	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	20461	4	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	20461	5	picketing	picket	VBG
18637	20461	6	are	be	VBP
18637	20461	7	treated	treat	VBN
18637	20461	8	under	under	IN
18637	20461	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	20461	10	I	I	NNP
18637	20461	11	,	,	,
18637	20461	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20461	13	see	see	VBP
18637	20461	14	_	_	NNP
18637	20461	15	p.	p.	NN
18637	20461	16	781	781	CD
18637	20461	17	.	.	.
18637	20462	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20462	2	173	173	CD
18637	20462	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20462	4	94	94	CD
18637	20462	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20462	6	113	113	CD
18637	20462	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20462	8	1877	1877	CD
18637	20462	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20462	10	.	.	.
18637	20463	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20463	2	174	174	CD
18637	20463	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20463	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20463	5	,	,	,
18637	20463	6	M.	M.	NNP
18637	20463	7	&	&	CC
18637	20463	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20463	9	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20464	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20464	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20464	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20464	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20464	5	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	20464	6	,	,	,
18637	20464	7	134	134	CD
18637	20464	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20464	9	418	418	CD
18637	20464	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20464	11	1890	1890	CD
18637	20464	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20464	13	.	.	.
18637	20465	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20465	2	175	175	CD
18637	20465	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20465	4	Wolff	Wolff	NNP
18637	20465	5	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	20465	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20465	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20465	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20465	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20465	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20465	11	of	of	IN
18637	20465	12	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	20465	13	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	20465	14	,	,	,
18637	20465	15	262	262	CD
18637	20465	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20465	17	522	522	CD
18637	20465	18	,	,	,
18637	20465	19	535	535	CD
18637	20465	20	-	-	SYM
18637	20465	21	536	536	CD
18637	20465	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20465	23	1923	1923	CD
18637	20465	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20465	25	.	.	.
18637	20466	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20466	2	176	176	CD
18637	20466	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20466	4	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	20466	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20466	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20466	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20466	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	20466	9	,	,	,
18637	20466	10	94	94	CD
18637	20466	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20466	12	113	113	CD
18637	20466	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20466	14	1877	1877	CD
18637	20466	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20466	16	;	;	:
18637	20466	17	Budd	Budd	NNP
18637	20466	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20466	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	20466	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20466	21	New	New	NNP
18637	20466	22	York	York	NNP
18637	20466	23	,	,	,
18637	20466	24	143	143	CD
18637	20466	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20466	26	517	517	CD
18637	20466	27	,	,	,
18637	20466	28	546	546	CD
18637	20466	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20466	30	1802	1802	CD
18637	20466	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20466	32	;	;	:
18637	20466	33	Brass	Brass	NNP
18637	20466	34	_	_	NNP
18637	20466	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	20466	36	_	_	NNP
18637	20466	37	North	North	NNP
18637	20466	38	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	20466	39	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20466	40	rel	rel	NN
18637	20466	41	.	.	.
18637	20467	1	Stoeser	Stoeser	NNP
18637	20467	2	,	,	,
18637	20467	3	153	153	CD
18637	20467	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20467	5	391	391	CD
18637	20467	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20467	7	1894	1894	CD
18637	20467	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20467	9	.	.	.
18637	20468	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20468	2	177	177	CD
18637	20468	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20468	4	Cotting	Cotting	NNP
18637	20468	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20468	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20468	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20468	8	Godard	Godard	NNP
18637	20468	9	,	,	,
18637	20468	10	183	183	CD
18637	20468	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20468	12	79	79	CD
18637	20468	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20468	14	1901	1901	CD
18637	20468	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20468	16	.	.	.
18637	20469	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20469	2	178	178	CD
18637	20469	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20469	4	Townsend	Townsend	NNP
18637	20469	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20469	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20469	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20469	8	Yeomans	Yeomans	NNPS
18637	20469	9	,	,	,
18637	20469	10	301	301	CD
18637	20469	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20469	12	441	441	CD
18637	20469	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20469	14	1937	1937	CD
18637	20469	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20469	16	.	.	.
18637	20470	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20470	2	179	179	CD
18637	20470	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20470	4	German	German	NNP
18637	20470	5	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	20470	6	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20470	7	.	.	.
18637	20471	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20471	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20471	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20471	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20471	5	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	20471	6	,	,	,
18637	20471	7	233	233	CD
18637	20471	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20471	9	389	389	CD
18637	20471	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20471	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	20471	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20471	13	;	;	:
18637	20471	14	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	20471	15	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20471	16	.	.	.
18637	20472	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20472	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20472	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20472	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20472	5	Hyde	Hyde	NNP
18637	20472	6	,	,	,
18637	20472	7	275	275	CD
18637	20472	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20472	9	440	440	CD
18637	20472	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20472	11	1928	1928	CD
18637	20472	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20472	13	.	.	.
18637	20473	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20473	2	180	180	CD
18637	20473	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20473	4	O'Gorman	O'Gorman	NNP
18637	20473	5	&	&	CC
18637	20473	6	Young	Young	NNP
18637	20473	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20473	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20473	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20473	10	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	20473	11	F.	F.	NNP
18637	20473	12	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20473	13	.	.	.
18637	20474	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20474	2	,	,	,
18637	20474	3	282	282	CD
18637	20474	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20474	5	251	251	CD
18637	20474	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20474	7	1931	1931	CD
18637	20474	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20474	9	.	.	.
18637	20475	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20475	2	181	181	CD
18637	20475	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20475	4	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	20475	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20475	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20475	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20475	8	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	20475	9	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	20475	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20475	11	,	,	,
18637	20475	12	278	278	CD
18637	20475	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20475	14	235	235	CD
18637	20475	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20475	16	1929	1929	CD
18637	20475	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20475	18	.	.	.
18637	20476	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20476	2	182	182	CD
18637	20476	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20476	4	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	20476	5	&	&	CC
18637	20476	6	Bros.--United	bros.--unite	VBD
18637	20476	7	Theatre	Theatre	NNP
18637	20476	8	Ticket	Ticket	NNP
18637	20476	9	Offices	Offices	NNPS
18637	20476	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20476	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	20476	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20476	13	Banton	Banton	NNP
18637	20476	14	,	,	,
18637	20476	15	273	273	CD
18637	20476	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20476	17	418	418	CD
18637	20476	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20476	19	1927	1927	CD
18637	20476	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20476	21	.	.	.
18637	20477	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20477	2	183	183	CD
18637	20477	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20477	4	New	New	NNP
18637	20477	5	State	State	NNP
18637	20477	6	Ice	Ice	NNP
18637	20477	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20477	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20477	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20477	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20477	11	Liebmann	Liebmann	NNP
18637	20477	12	,	,	,
18637	20477	13	285	285	CD
18637	20477	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20477	15	262	262	CD
18637	20477	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20477	17	1932	1932	CD
18637	20477	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20477	19	.	.	.
18637	20478	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20478	2	184	184	CD
18637	20478	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20478	4	Nebbia	Nebbia	NNP
18637	20478	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20478	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20478	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20478	8	New	New	NNP
18637	20478	9	York	York	NNP
18637	20478	10	,	,	,
18637	20478	11	291	291	CD
18637	20478	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20478	13	502	502	CD
18637	20478	14	,	,	,
18637	20478	15	531	531	CD
18637	20478	16	-	-	SYM
18637	20478	17	532	532	CD
18637	20478	18	,	,	,
18637	20478	19	535	535	CD
18637	20478	20	-	-	SYM
18637	20478	21	537	537	CD
18637	20478	22	,	,	,
18637	20478	23	539	539	CD
18637	20478	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20478	25	1934	1934	CD
18637	20478	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20478	27	.	.	.
18637	20479	1	In	in	IN
18637	20479	2	reaching	reach	VBG
18637	20479	3	this	this	DT
18637	20479	4	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	20479	5	the	the	DT
18637	20479	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20479	7	might	may	MD
18637	20479	8	be	be	VB
18637	20479	9	said	say	VBN
18637	20479	10	to	to	TO
18637	20479	11	have	have	VB
18637	20479	12	elevated	elevate	VBN
18637	20479	13	to	to	IN
18637	20479	14	the	the	DT
18637	20479	15	status	status	NN
18637	20479	16	of	of	IN
18637	20479	17	prevailing	prevail	VBG
18637	20479	18	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	20479	19	the	the	DT
18637	20479	20	views	view	NNS
18637	20479	21	advanced	advance	VBN
18637	20479	22	in	in	IN
18637	20479	23	previous	previous	JJ
18637	20479	24	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	20479	25	by	by	IN
18637	20479	26	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	20479	27	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	20479	28	.	.	.
18637	20480	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	20480	2	,	,	,
18637	20480	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20480	4	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	20480	5	,	,	,
18637	20480	6	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	20480	7	in	in	IN
18637	20480	8	Ribnik	Ribnik	NNP
18637	20480	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20480	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20480	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20480	12	McBride	McBride	NNP
18637	20480	13	,	,	,
18637	20480	14	277	277	CD
18637	20480	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20480	16	350	350	CD
18637	20480	17	,	,	,
18637	20480	18	350	350	CD
18637	20480	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	20480	20	360	360	CD
18637	20480	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20480	22	1928	1928	CD
18637	20480	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20480	24	had	have	VBD
18637	20480	25	declared	declare	VBN
18637	20480	26	:	:	:
18637	20480	27	"	"	``
18637	20480	28	Price	price	NN
18637	20480	29	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	20480	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	20480	31	within	within	IN
18637	20480	32	the	the	DT
18637	20480	33	State	State	NNP
18637	20480	34	's	's	POS
18637	20480	35	power	power	NN
18637	20480	36	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	20480	37	any	any	DT
18637	20480	38	combination	combination	NN
18637	20480	39	of	of	IN
18637	20480	40	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	20480	41	seriously	seriously	RB
18637	20480	42	curtails	curtail	VBZ
18637	20480	43	the	the	DT
18637	20480	44	regulative	regulative	JJ
18637	20480	45	force	force	NN
18637	20480	46	of	of	IN
18637	20480	47	competition	competition	NN
18637	20480	48	so	so	IN
18637	20480	49	that	that	IN
18637	20480	50	buyers	buyer	NNS
18637	20480	51	or	or	CC
18637	20480	52	sellers	seller	NNS
18637	20480	53	are	be	VBP
18637	20480	54	placed	place	VBN
18637	20480	55	at	at	IN
18637	20480	56	such	such	PDT
18637	20480	57	a	a	DT
18637	20480	58	disadvantage	disadvantage	NN
18637	20480	59	in	in	IN
18637	20480	60	the	the	DT
18637	20480	61	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	20480	62	struggle	struggle	NN
18637	20480	63	that	that	IN
18637	20480	64	a	a	DT
18637	20480	65	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	20480	66	might	may	MD
18637	20480	67	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	20480	68	anticipate	anticipate	VB
18637	20480	69	serious	serious	JJ
18637	20480	70	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	20480	71	to	to	IN
18637	20480	72	the	the	DT
18637	20480	73	community	community	NN
18637	20480	74	as	as	IN
18637	20480	75	a	a	DT
18637	20480	76	whole	whole	NN
18637	20480	77	.	.	.
18637	20480	78	"	"	''
18637	20481	1	In	in	IN
18637	20481	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20481	3	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	20481	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	20481	5	in	in	IN
18637	20481	6	New	New	NNP
18637	20481	7	State	State	NNP
18637	20481	8	Ice	Ice	NNP
18637	20481	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20481	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20481	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	20481	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20481	13	Liebmann	Liebmann	NNP
18637	20481	14	,	,	,
18637	20481	15	285	285	CD
18637	20481	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20481	17	202	202	CD
18637	20481	18	,	,	,
18637	20481	19	302	302	CD
18637	20481	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	20481	21	303	303	CD
18637	20481	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20481	23	1932	1932	CD
18637	20481	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20481	25	,	,	,
18637	20481	26	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20481	27	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	20481	28	had	have	VBD
18637	20481	29	also	also	RB
18637	20481	30	observed	observe	VBN
18637	20481	31	that	that	DT
18637	20481	32	:	:	:
18637	20481	33	"	"	``
18637	20481	34	The	the	DT
18637	20481	35	notion	notion	NN
18637	20481	36	of	of	IN
18637	20481	37	a	a	DT
18637	20481	38	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	20481	39	category	category	NN
18637	20481	40	of	of	IN
18637	20481	41	business	business	NN
18637	20481	42	'	'	''
18637	20481	43	affected	affect	VBN
18637	20481	44	with	with	IN
18637	20481	45	a	a	DT
18637	20481	46	public	public	JJ
18637	20481	47	interest	interest	NN
18637	20481	48	'	'	POS
18637	20481	49	employing	employ	VBG
18637	20481	50	property	property	NN
18637	20481	51	'	'	''
18637	20481	52	devoted	devote	VBN
18637	20481	53	to	to	IN
18637	20481	54	a	a	DT
18637	20481	55	public	public	JJ
18637	20481	56	use	use	NN
18637	20481	57	'	'	''
18637	20481	58	rests	rest	NNS
18637	20481	59	upon	upon	IN
18637	20481	60	historical	historical	JJ
18637	20481	61	error	error	NN
18637	20481	62	.	.	.
18637	20482	1	In	in	IN
18637	20482	2	my	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20482	3	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	20482	4	the	the	DT
18637	20482	5	true	true	JJ
18637	20482	6	principle	principle	NN
18637	20482	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	20482	8	that	that	IN
18637	20482	9	the	the	DT
18637	20482	10	State	State	NNP
18637	20482	11	's	's	POS
18637	20482	12	power	power	NN
18637	20482	13	extends	extend	VBZ
18637	20482	14	to	to	IN
18637	20482	15	every	every	DT
18637	20482	16	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	20482	17	of	of	IN
18637	20482	18	any	any	DT
18637	20482	19	business	business	NN
18637	20482	20	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	20482	21	required	require	VBN
18637	20482	22	and	and	CC
18637	20482	23	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	20482	24	for	for	IN
18637	20482	25	the	the	DT
18637	20482	26	public	public	JJ
18637	20482	27	protection	protection	NN
18637	20482	28	.	.	.
18637	20483	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20483	2	find	find	VBP
18637	20483	3	in	in	IN
18637	20483	4	the	the	DT
18637	20483	5	due	due	JJ
18637	20483	6	process	process	NN
18637	20483	7	clause	clause	NN
18637	20483	8	no	no	DT
18637	20483	9	other	other	JJ
18637	20483	10	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	20483	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	20483	12	the	the	DT
18637	20483	13	character	character	NN
18637	20483	14	or	or	CC
18637	20483	15	the	the	DT
18637	20483	16	scope	scope	NN
18637	20483	17	of	of	IN
18637	20483	18	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	20483	19	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	20483	20	.	.	.
18637	20483	21	"	"	''
18637	20484	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20484	2	185	185	CD
18637	20484	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20484	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20484	5	McReynolds	McReynolds	NNP
18637	20484	6	,	,	,
18637	20484	7	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	20484	8	for	for	IN
18637	20484	9	the	the	DT
18637	20484	10	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	20484	11	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	20484	12	,	,	,
18637	20484	13	labelled	label	VBD
18637	20484	14	the	the	DT
18637	20484	15	controls	control	NNS
18637	20484	16	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	20484	17	by	by	IN
18637	20484	18	the	the	DT
18637	20484	19	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	20484	20	statute	statute	NN
18637	20484	21	as	as	IN
18637	20484	22	a	a	DT
18637	20484	23	"	"	``
18637	20484	24	fanciful	fanciful	JJ
18637	20484	25	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	20484	26	to	to	TO
18637	20484	27	protect	protect	VB
18637	20484	28	the	the	DT
18637	20484	29	farmer	farmer	NN
18637	20484	30	against	against	IN
18637	20484	31	undue	undue	JJ
18637	20484	32	exactions	exaction	NNS
18637	20484	33	by	by	IN
18637	20484	34	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	20484	35	the	the	DT
18637	20484	36	price	price	NN
18637	20484	37	at	at	IN
18637	20484	38	which	which	WDT
18637	20484	39	milk	milk	NN
18637	20484	40	disposed	dispose	VBN
18637	20484	41	of	of	IN
18637	20484	42	by	by	IN
18637	20484	43	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20484	44	at	at	IN
18637	20484	45	will	will	MD
18637	20484	46	may	may	MD
18637	20484	47	be	be	VB
18637	20484	48	resold	resold	VBN
18637	20484	49	.	.	.
18637	20484	50	"	"	''
18637	20485	1	Intimating	intimate	VBG
18637	20485	2	that	that	IN
18637	20485	3	the	the	DT
18637	20485	4	New	New	NNP
18637	20485	5	York	York	NNP
18637	20485	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	20485	7	was	be	VBD
18637	20485	8	as	as	RB
18637	20485	9	efficacious	efficacious	JJ
18637	20485	10	as	as	IN
18637	20485	11	a	a	DT
18637	20485	12	safety	safety	NN
18637	20485	13	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	20485	14	which	which	WDT
18637	20485	15	required	require	VBD
18637	20485	16	"	"	``
18637	20485	17	householders	householder	NNS
18637	20485	18	to	to	TO
18637	20485	19	pour	pour	VB
18637	20485	20	oil	oil	NN
18637	20485	21	on	on	IN
18637	20485	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20485	23	roofs	roof	NNS
18637	20485	24	as	as	IN
18637	20485	25	a	a	DT
18637	20485	26	means	means	NN
18637	20485	27	of	of	IN
18637	20485	28	curbing	curb	VBG
18637	20485	29	the	the	DT
18637	20485	30	spread	spread	NN
18637	20485	31	of	of	IN
18637	20485	32	a	a	DT
18637	20485	33	neighborhood	neighborhood	NN
18637	20485	34	fire	fire	NN
18637	20485	35	,	,	,
18637	20485	36	"	"	''
18637	20485	37	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20485	38	McReynolds	McReynolds	NNP
18637	20485	39	insisted	insist	VBD
18637	20485	40	that	that	IN
18637	20485	41	"	"	``
18637	20485	42	this	this	DT
18637	20485	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20485	44	must	must	MD
18637	20485	45	have	have	VB
18637	20485	46	regard	regard	NN
18637	20485	47	to	to	IN
18637	20485	48	the	the	DT
18637	20485	49	wisdom	wisdom	NN
18637	20485	50	of	of	IN
18637	20485	51	the	the	DT
18637	20485	52	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	20485	53	,	,	,
18637	20485	54	"	"	''
18637	20485	55	and	and	CC
18637	20485	56	must	must	MD
18637	20485	57	determine	determine	VB
18637	20485	58	"	"	''
18637	20485	59	whether	whether	IN
18637	20485	60	the	the	DT
18637	20485	61	means	mean	NNS
18637	20485	62	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	20485	63	have	have	VBP
18637	20485	64	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	20485	65	relation	relation	NN
18637	20485	66	to	to	IN
18637	20485	67	something	something	NN
18637	20485	68	within	within	IN
18637	20485	69	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	20485	70	power	power	NN
18637	20485	71	.	.	.
18637	20485	72	"	"	''
18637	20486	1	--291	--291	NNP
18637	20486	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20486	3	502	502	CD
18637	20486	4	,	,	,
18637	20486	5	556	556	CD
18637	20486	6	,	,	,
18637	20486	7	558	558	CD
18637	20486	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20486	9	1934	1934	CD
18637	20486	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20486	11	.	.	.
18637	20487	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20487	2	186	186	CD
18637	20487	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20487	4	313	313	CD
18637	20487	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20487	6	236	236	CD
18637	20487	7	,	,	,
18637	20487	8	246	246	CD
18637	20487	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20487	10	1941	1941	CD
18637	20487	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20487	12	.	.	.
18637	20488	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20488	2	187	187	CD
18637	20488	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20488	4	277	277	CD
18637	20488	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20488	6	350	350	CD
18637	20488	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20488	8	1928	1928	CD
18637	20488	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20488	10	.	.	.
18637	20489	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20489	2	188	188	CD
18637	20489	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20489	4	94	94	CD
18637	20489	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20489	6	113	113	CD
18637	20489	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20489	8	1877	1877	CD
18637	20489	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20489	10	.	.	.
18637	20490	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20490	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20490	3	also	also	RB
18637	20490	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20490	5	Peik	Peik	NNP
18637	20490	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20490	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20490	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20490	9	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20490	10	&	&	CC
18637	20490	11	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	20491	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20491	2	,	,	,
18637	20491	3	94	94	CD
18637	20491	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20491	5	164	164	CD
18637	20491	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20491	7	1877	1877	CD
18637	20491	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20491	9	.	.	.
18637	20492	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20492	2	189	189	CD
18637	20492	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20492	4	Rate	rate	NN
18637	20492	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	20492	6	making	making	NN
18637	20492	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	20492	8	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	20492	9	to	to	TO
18637	20492	10	be	be	VB
18637	20492	11	one	one	CD
18637	20492	12	species	specie	NNS
18637	20492	13	of	of	IN
18637	20492	14	price	price	NN
18637	20492	15	fixing	fixing	NN
18637	20492	16	.	.	.
18637	20493	1	Power	power	NN
18637	20493	2	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	20493	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20493	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	20493	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20493	6	Pipeline	Pipeline	NNP
18637	20493	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20493	8	,	,	,
18637	20493	9	315	315	CD
18637	20493	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20493	11	575	575	CD
18637	20493	12	,	,	,
18637	20493	13	603	603	CD
18637	20493	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20493	15	1942	1942	CD
18637	20493	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20493	17	.	.	.
18637	20494	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20494	2	190	190	CD
18637	20494	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20494	4	Nebbia	Nebbia	NNP
18637	20494	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20494	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20494	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20494	8	New	New	NNP
18637	20494	9	York	York	NNP
18637	20494	10	,	,	,
18637	20494	11	291	291	CD
18637	20494	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20494	13	502	502	CD
18637	20494	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20494	15	1934	1934	CD
18637	20494	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20494	17	.	.	.
18637	20495	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20495	2	191	191	CD
18637	20495	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20495	4	96	96	CD
18637	20495	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20495	6	97	97	CD
18637	20495	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20495	8	1878	1878	CD
18637	20495	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20495	10	.	.	.
18637	20496	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20496	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20496	3	also	also	RB
18637	20496	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20496	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20496	6	,	,	,
18637	20496	7	B.	B.	NNP
18637	20497	1	&	&	CC
18637	20497	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	20498	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20498	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20498	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20498	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20498	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20498	6	,	,	,
18637	20498	7	166	166	CD
18637	20498	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20498	9	226	226	CD
18637	20498	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20498	11	1897	1897	CD
18637	20498	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20498	13	.	.	.
18637	20499	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20499	2	192	192	CD
18637	20499	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20499	4	116	116	CD
18637	20499	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20499	6	307	307	CD
18637	20499	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20499	8	1886	1886	CD
18637	20499	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20499	10	.	.	.
18637	20500	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20500	2	193	193	CD
18637	20500	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20500	4	Dow	Dow	NNP
18637	20500	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20500	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20500	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20500	8	Beidelman	Beidelman	NNP
18637	20500	9	,	,	,
18637	20500	10	125	125	CD
18637	20500	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20500	12	680	680	CD
18637	20500	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20500	14	1888	1888	CD
18637	20500	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20500	16	.	.	.
18637	20501	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20501	2	194	194	CD
18637	20501	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20501	4	134	134	CD
18637	20501	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20501	6	418	418	CD
18637	20501	7	,	,	,
18637	20501	8	458	458	CD
18637	20501	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20501	10	1890	1890	CD
18637	20501	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20501	12	.	.	.
18637	20502	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20502	2	195	195	CD
18637	20502	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20502	4	143	143	CD
18637	20502	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20502	6	517	517	CD
18637	20502	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20502	8	1892	1892	CD
18637	20502	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20502	10	.	.	.
18637	20503	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20503	2	196	196	CD
18637	20503	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20503	4	154	154	CD
18637	20503	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20503	6	362	362	CD
18637	20503	7	,	,	,
18637	20503	8	397	397	CD
18637	20503	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20503	10	1894	1894	CD
18637	20503	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20503	12	.	.	.
18637	20504	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20504	2	197	197	CD
18637	20504	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20504	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20504	5	397	397	CD
18637	20504	6	.	.	.
18637	20505	1	Insofar	insofar	RB
18637	20505	2	as	as	IN
18637	20505	3	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	20505	4	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	20505	5	resulting	result	VBG
18637	20505	6	in	in	IN
18637	20505	7	the	the	DT
18637	20505	8	invalidation	invalidation	NN
18637	20505	9	of	of	IN
18637	20505	10	legislatively	legislatively	RB
18637	20505	11	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	20505	12	rates	rate	NNS
18637	20505	13	has	have	VBZ
18637	20505	14	involved	involve	VBN
18637	20505	15	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	20505	16	,	,	,
18637	20505	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20505	18	should	should	MD
18637	20505	19	be	be	VB
18637	20505	20	noted	note	VBN
18637	20505	21	that	that	IN
18637	20505	22	the	the	DT
18637	20505	23	successful	successful	JJ
18637	20505	24	complainant	complainant	NN
18637	20505	25	invariably	invariably	RB
18637	20505	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	20505	27	been	be	VBN
18637	20505	28	the	the	DT
18637	20505	29	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	20505	30	,	,	,
18637	20505	31	not	not	RB
18637	20505	32	the	the	DT
18637	20505	33	shipper	shipper	NN
18637	20505	34	.	.	.
18637	20506	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20506	2	198	198	CD
18637	20506	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20506	4	169	169	CD
18637	20506	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20506	6	466	466	CD
18637	20506	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20506	8	1898).--Of	1898).--of	CD
18637	20506	9	course	course	NN
18637	20506	10	the	the	DT
18637	20506	11	validity	validity	NN
18637	20506	12	of	of	IN
18637	20506	13	rates	rate	NNS
18637	20506	14	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	20506	15	by	by	IN
18637	20506	16	a	a	DT
18637	20506	17	State	State	NNP
18637	20506	18	for	for	IN
18637	20506	19	services	service	NNS
18637	20506	20	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	20506	21	within	within	IN
18637	20506	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20506	23	limits	limit	NNS
18637	20506	24	,	,	,
18637	20506	25	must	must	MD
18637	20506	26	be	be	VB
18637	20506	27	determined	determine	VBN
18637	20506	28	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	20506	29	without	without	IN
18637	20506	30	reference	reference	NN
18637	20506	31	to	to	IN
18637	20506	32	the	the	DT
18637	20506	33	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	20506	34	business	business	NN
18637	20506	35	done	do	VBN
18637	20506	36	by	by	IN
18637	20506	37	a	a	DT
18637	20506	38	public	public	JJ
18637	20506	39	utility	utility	NN
18637	20506	40	.	.	.
18637	20507	1	Domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	20507	2	business	business	NN
18637	20507	3	should	should	MD
18637	20507	4	not	not	RB
18637	20507	5	be	be	VB
18637	20507	6	made	make	VBN
18637	20507	7	to	to	TO
18637	20507	8	bear	bear	VB
18637	20507	9	the	the	DT
18637	20507	10	losses	loss	NNS
18637	20507	11	on	on	IN
18637	20507	12	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	20507	13	business	business	NN
18637	20507	14	,	,	,
18637	20507	15	and	and	CC
18637	20507	16	vice	vice	NN
18637	20507	17	versa	versa	RB
18637	20507	18	.	.	.
18637	20508	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	20508	2	a	a	DT
18637	20508	3	State	state	NN
18637	20508	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	20508	5	no	no	DT
18637	20508	6	power	power	NN
18637	20508	7	to	to	TO
18637	20508	8	require	require	VB
18637	20508	9	the	the	DT
18637	20508	10	hauling	hauling	NN
18637	20508	11	of	of	IN
18637	20508	12	logs	log	NNS
18637	20508	13	at	at	IN
18637	20508	14	a	a	DT
18637	20508	15	loss	loss	NN
18637	20508	16	or	or	CC
18637	20508	17	at	at	IN
18637	20508	18	rates	rate	NNS
18637	20508	19	that	that	WDT
18637	20508	20	are	be	VBP
18637	20508	21	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	20508	22	,	,	,
18637	20508	23	even	even	RB
18637	20508	24	if	if	IN
18637	20508	25	a	a	DT
18637	20508	26	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	20508	27	receives	receive	VBZ
18637	20508	28	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	20508	29	revenues	revenue	NNS
18637	20508	30	from	from	IN
18637	20508	31	the	the	DT
18637	20508	32	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	20508	33	long	long	JJ
18637	20508	34	haul	haul	NN
18637	20508	35	and	and	CC
18637	20508	36	the	the	DT
18637	20508	37	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	20508	38	lumber	lumber	NN
18637	20508	39	haul	haul	NNP
18637	20508	40	taken	take	VBN
18637	20508	41	together	together	RB
18637	20508	42	.	.	.
18637	20509	1	On	on	IN
18637	20509	2	the	the	DT
18637	20509	3	other	other	JJ
18637	20509	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	20509	5	,	,	,
18637	20509	6	in	in	IN
18637	20509	7	determining	determine	VBG
18637	20509	8	whether	whether	IN
18637	20509	9	intrastate	intrastate	JJ
18637	20509	10	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	20509	11	railway	railway	NN
18637	20509	12	rates	rate	NNS
18637	20509	13	are	be	VBP
18637	20509	14	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	20509	15	,	,	,
18637	20509	16	all	all	DT
18637	20509	17	parts	part	NNS
18637	20509	18	of	of	IN
18637	20509	19	the	the	DT
18637	20509	20	system	system	NN
18637	20509	21	within	within	IN
18637	20509	22	the	the	DT
18637	20509	23	State	State	NNP
18637	20509	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20509	25	including	include	VBG
18637	20509	26	sleeping	sleeping	NN
18637	20509	27	,	,	,
18637	20509	28	parlor	parlor	NN
18637	20509	29	,	,	,
18637	20509	30	and	and	CC
18637	20509	31	dining	dining	NN
18637	20509	32	cars	car	NNS
18637	20509	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20509	34	should	should	MD
18637	20509	35	be	be	VB
18637	20509	36	embraced	embrace	VBN
18637	20509	37	in	in	IN
18637	20509	38	the	the	DT
18637	20509	39	computation	computation	NN
18637	20509	40	;	;	,
18637	20509	41	and	and	CC
18637	20509	42	the	the	DT
18637	20509	43	unremunerative	unremunerative	JJ
18637	20509	44	parts	part	NNS
18637	20509	45	should	should	MD
18637	20509	46	not	not	RB
18637	20509	47	be	be	VB
18637	20509	48	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	20509	49	because	because	IN
18637	20509	50	built	build	VBN
18637	20509	51	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	20509	52	for	for	IN
18637	20509	53	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	20509	54	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	20509	55	or	or	CC
18637	20509	56	not	not	RB
18637	20509	57	required	require	VBN
18637	20509	58	to	to	TO
18637	20509	59	supply	supply	VB
18637	20509	60	local	local	JJ
18637	20509	61	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	20509	62	needs.--_See	needs.--_see	NN
18637	20509	63	:	:	:
18637	20509	64	_	_	NNP
18637	20509	65	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	20509	66	Rate	Rate	NNP
18637	20509	67	Cases	Cases	NNP
18637	20509	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20509	69	Simpson	Simpson	NNP
18637	20509	70	_	_	NNP
18637	20509	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	20509	72	_	_	NNP
18637	20509	73	Shepard	shepard	RB
18637	20509	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20509	75	,	,	,
18637	20509	76	230	230	CD
18637	20509	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20509	78	352	352	CD
18637	20509	79	,	,	,
18637	20509	80	434	434	CD
18637	20509	81	-	-	HYPH
18637	20509	82	435	435	CD
18637	20509	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20509	84	1913	1913	CD
18637	20509	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20509	86	;	;	:
18637	20509	87	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20509	88	,	,	,
18637	20509	89	M.	M.	NNP
18637	20509	90	&	&	CC
18637	20509	91	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20509	92	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20510	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20510	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20510	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20510	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20510	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20510	6	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	20510	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20510	8	,	,	,
18637	20510	9	274	274	CD
18637	20510	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20510	11	344	344	CD
18637	20510	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20510	13	1927	1927	CD
18637	20510	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20510	15	;	;	:
18637	20510	16	Groesbeck	Groesbeck	NNP
18637	20510	17	_	_	NNP
18637	20510	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	20510	19	_	_	NNP
18637	20510	20	Duluth	Duluth	NNP
18637	20510	21	,	,	,
18637	20510	22	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	20510	23	&	&	CC
18637	20510	24	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	20511	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20511	2	,	,	,
18637	20511	3	250	250	CD
18637	20511	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20511	5	607	607	CD
18637	20511	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20511	7	1919	1919	CD
18637	20511	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20511	9	.	.	.
18637	20512	1	The	the	DT
18637	20512	2	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	20512	3	that	that	IN
18637	20512	4	a	a	DT
18637	20512	5	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	20512	6	can	can	MD
18637	20512	7	not	not	RB
18637	20512	8	delegate	delegate	VB
18637	20512	9	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	20512	10	power	power	NN
18637	20512	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	20512	12	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	20512	13	to	to	TO
18637	20512	14	permit	permit	VB
18637	20512	15	creation	creation	NN
18637	20512	16	of	of	IN
18637	20512	17	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	20512	18	boards	board	NNS
18637	20512	19	to	to	TO
18637	20512	20	apply	apply	VB
18637	20512	21	to	to	IN
18637	20512	22	the	the	DT
18637	20512	23	myriad	myriad	JJ
18637	20512	24	details	detail	NNS
18637	20512	25	of	of	IN
18637	20512	26	rate	rate	NN
18637	20512	27	schedules	schedule	NNS
18637	20512	28	the	the	DT
18637	20512	29	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	20512	30	police	police	NN
18637	20512	31	power	power	NN
18637	20512	32	of	of	IN
18637	20512	33	the	the	DT
18637	20512	34	State	State	NNP
18637	20512	35	.	.	.
18637	20513	1	To	to	TO
18637	20513	2	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	20513	3	the	the	DT
18637	20513	4	conferring	confer	VBG
18637	20513	5	upon	upon	IN
18637	20513	6	an	an	DT
18637	20513	7	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	20513	8	agency	agency	NN
18637	20513	9	of	of	IN
18637	20513	10	authority	authority	NN
18637	20513	11	to	to	TO
18637	20513	12	fix	fix	VB
18637	20513	13	rates	rate	NNS
18637	20513	14	for	for	IN
18637	20513	15	public	public	JJ
18637	20513	16	service	service	NN
18637	20513	17	from	from	IN
18637	20513	18	being	be	VBG
18637	20513	19	a	a	DT
18637	20513	20	mere	mere	JJ
18637	20513	21	delegation	delegation	NN
18637	20513	22	of	of	IN
18637	20513	23	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	20513	24	power	power	NN
18637	20513	25	,	,	,
18637	20513	26	and	and	CC
18637	20513	27	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	20513	28	void	void	JJ
18637	20513	29	,	,	,
18637	20513	30	the	the	DT
18637	20513	31	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	20513	32	must	must	MD
18637	20513	33	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	20513	34	upon	upon	IN
18637	20513	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20513	36	a	a	DT
18637	20513	37	certain	certain	JJ
18637	20513	38	course	course	NN
18637	20513	39	of	of	IN
18637	20513	40	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	20513	41	and	and	CC
18637	20513	42	certain	certain	JJ
18637	20513	43	rules	rule	NNS
18637	20513	44	of	of	IN
18637	20513	45	decision	decision	NN
18637	20513	46	in	in	IN
18637	20513	47	the	the	DT
18637	20513	48	performance	performance	NN
18637	20513	49	of	of	IN
18637	20513	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20513	51	functions	function	NNS
18637	20513	52	,	,	,
18637	20513	53	with	with	IN
18637	20513	54	which	which	WDT
18637	20513	55	the	the	DT
18637	20513	56	agency	agency	NN
18637	20513	57	must	must	MD
18637	20513	58	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	20513	59	comply	comply	VB
18637	20513	60	to	to	TO
18637	20513	61	validate	validate	VB
18637	20513	62	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20513	63	action	action	NN
18637	20513	64	.	.	.
18637	20514	1	Wichita	Wichita	NNP
18637	20514	2	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	20514	3	&	&	CC
18637	20514	4	L.	L.	NNP
18637	20514	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20514	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20514	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20514	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20514	9	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20514	10	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	20514	11	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20514	12	,	,	,
18637	20514	13	260	260	CD
18637	20514	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20514	15	48	48	CD
18637	20514	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20514	17	1922	1922	CD
18637	20514	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20514	19	.	.	.
18637	20515	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20515	2	199	199	CD
18637	20515	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20515	4	Reagan	Reagan	NNP
18637	20515	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20515	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20515	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20515	8	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	20515	9	'	'	POS
18637	20515	10	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	20515	11	&	&	CC
18637	20515	12	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	20515	13	Company	Company	NNP
18637	20515	14	,	,	,
18637	20515	15	154	154	CD
18637	20515	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20515	17	362	362	CD
18637	20515	18	,	,	,
18637	20515	19	397	397	CD
18637	20515	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20515	21	1894	1894	CD
18637	20515	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20515	23	.	.	.
18637	20516	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20516	2	200	200	CD
18637	20516	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20516	4	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	20516	5	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	20516	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20516	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20516	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20516	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20516	10	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	20516	11	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	20517	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20517	2	,	,	,
18637	20517	3	215	215	CD
18637	20517	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20517	5	452	452	CD
18637	20517	6	,	,	,
18637	20517	7	470	470	CD
18637	20517	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20517	9	1910	1910	CD
18637	20517	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20517	11	.	.	.
18637	20518	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20518	2	201	201	CD
18637	20518	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20518	4	231	231	CD
18637	20518	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20518	6	298	298	CD
18637	20518	7	,	,	,
18637	20518	8	310	310	CD
18637	20518	9	-	-	SYM
18637	20518	10	313	313	CD
18637	20518	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20518	12	1913	1913	CD
18637	20518	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20518	14	.	.	.
18637	20519	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20519	2	202	202	CD
18637	20519	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20519	4	Des	Des	NNP
18637	20519	5	Moines	Moines	NNP
18637	20519	6	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20519	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20519	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20519	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20519	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20519	11	Des	Des	NNP
18637	20519	12	Moines	Moines	NNP
18637	20519	13	,	,	,
18637	20519	14	238	238	CD
18637	20519	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20519	16	153	153	CD
18637	20519	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20519	18	1915	1915	CD
18637	20519	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20519	20	.	.	.
18637	20520	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20520	2	203	203	CD
18637	20520	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20520	4	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	20520	5	Rate	Rate	NNP
18637	20520	6	Cases	case	NNS
18637	20520	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20520	8	Simpson	Simpson	NNP
18637	20520	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20520	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20520	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20520	12	Shepard	shepard	RB
18637	20520	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20520	14	,	,	,
18637	20520	15	230	230	CD
18637	20520	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20520	17	352	352	CD
18637	20520	18	,	,	,
18637	20520	19	452	452	CD
18637	20520	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20520	21	1913	1913	CD
18637	20520	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20520	23	.	.	.
18637	20521	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20521	2	204	204	CD
18637	20521	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20521	4	Knoxville	Knoxville	NNP
18637	20521	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20521	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20521	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20521	8	Water	Water	NNP
18637	20521	9	Company	Company	NNP
18637	20521	10	,	,	,
18637	20521	11	212	212	CD
18637	20521	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20521	13	1	1	CD
18637	20521	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20521	15	1909	1909	CD
18637	20521	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20521	17	.	.	.
18637	20522	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20522	2	205	205	CD
18637	20522	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20522	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	20522	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20522	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20522	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20522	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	20522	9	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	20522	10	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	20522	11	.	.	.
18637	20523	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20523	2	,	,	,
18637	20523	3	270	270	CD
18637	20523	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20523	5	587	587	CD
18637	20523	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20523	7	1926	1926	CD
18637	20523	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20523	9	.	.	.
18637	20524	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20524	2	206	206	CD
18637	20524	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20524	4	Willcox	Willcox	NNP
18637	20524	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20524	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20524	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20524	8	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	20524	9	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20524	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20524	11	,	,	,
18637	20524	12	212	212	CD
18637	20524	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20524	14	19	19	CD
18637	20524	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20524	16	1909	1909	CD
18637	20524	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20524	18	.	.	.
18637	20525	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20525	2	207	207	CD
18637	20525	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20525	4	174	174	CD
18637	20525	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20525	6	739	739	CD
18637	20525	7	,	,	,
18637	20525	8	750	750	CD
18637	20525	9	,	,	,
18637	20525	10	754	754	CD
18637	20525	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20525	12	1899	1899	CD
18637	20525	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20525	14	.	.	.
18637	20526	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20526	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20526	3	also	also	RB
18637	20526	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20526	5	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	20526	6	Rate	Rate	NNP
18637	20526	7	Cases	Cases	NNP
18637	20526	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20526	9	Simpson	Simpson	NNP
18637	20526	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20526	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	20526	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20526	13	Shepard	shepard	RB
18637	20526	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20526	15	,	,	,
18637	20526	16	230	230	CD
18637	20526	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20526	18	352	352	CD
18637	20526	19	,	,	,
18637	20526	20	433	433	CD
18637	20526	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20526	22	1913	1913	CD
18637	20526	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20526	24	.	.	.
18637	20527	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20527	2	208	208	CD
18637	20527	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20527	4	San	San	NNP
18637	20527	5	Diego	Diego	NNP
18637	20527	6	Land	Land	NNP
18637	20527	7	&	&	CC
18637	20527	8	Town	Town	NNP
18637	20527	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20527	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20527	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	20527	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20527	13	Jasper	Jasper	NNP
18637	20527	14	,	,	,
18637	20527	15	189	189	CD
18637	20527	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20527	17	439	439	CD
18637	20527	18	,	,	,
18637	20527	19	441	441	CD
18637	20527	20	,	,	,
18637	20527	21	442	442	CD
18637	20527	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20527	23	1903	1903	CD
18637	20527	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20527	25	.	.	.
18637	20528	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20528	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20528	3	also	also	RB
18637	20528	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20528	5	Van	Van	NNP
18637	20528	6	Dyke	Dyke	NNP
18637	20528	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20528	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20528	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20528	10	Geary	Geary	NNP
18637	20528	11	,	,	,
18637	20528	12	244	244	CD
18637	20528	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20528	14	39	39	CD
18637	20528	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20528	16	1917	1917	CD
18637	20528	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20528	18	;	;	:
18637	20528	19	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	20528	20	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	20528	21	.	.	.
18637	20529	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20529	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20529	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20529	4	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	20530	1	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	20530	2	.	.	NNP
18637	20530	3	,	,	,
18637	20530	4	262	262	CD
18637	20530	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20530	6	625	625	CD
18637	20530	7	,	,	,
18637	20530	8	634	634	CD
18637	20530	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20530	10	1923	1923	CD
18637	20530	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20530	12	.	.	.
18637	20531	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20531	2	209	209	CD
18637	20531	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20531	4	For	for	IN
18637	20531	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20531	6	current	current	JJ
18637	20531	7	position	position	NN
18637	20531	8	,	,	,
18637	20531	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20531	10	see	see	VBP
18637	20531	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20531	12	Crowell	Crowell	NNP
18637	20531	13	_	_	NNP
18637	20531	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	20531	15	_	_	NNP
18637	20531	16	Benson	Benson	NNP
18637	20531	17	,	,	,
18637	20531	18	285	285	CD
18637	20531	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20531	20	22	22	CD
18637	20531	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20531	22	1932	1932	CD
18637	20531	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20531	24	.	.	.
18637	20532	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20532	2	210	210	CD
18637	20532	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20532	4	222	222	CD
18637	20532	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20532	6	541	541	CD
18637	20532	7	,	,	,
18637	20532	8	547	547	CD
18637	20532	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	20532	10	548	548	CD
18637	20532	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20532	12	1912	1912	CD
18637	20532	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20532	14	.	.	.
18637	20533	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20533	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20533	3	also	also	RB
18637	20533	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20533	5	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	20533	6	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	20533	7	.	.	.
18637	20534	1	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	20534	2	.	.	.
18637	20535	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20535	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20535	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20535	4	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	20535	5	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	20535	6	,	,	,
18637	20535	7	215	215	CD
18637	20535	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20535	9	452	452	CD
18637	20535	10	,	,	,
18637	20535	11	470	470	CD
18637	20535	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20535	13	1910	1910	CD
18637	20535	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20535	15	.	.	.
18637	20536	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20536	2	211	211	CD
18637	20536	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20536	4	253	253	CD
18637	20536	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20536	6	287	287	CD
18637	20536	7	,	,	,
18637	20536	8	293	293	CD
18637	20536	9	-	-	SYM
18637	20536	10	294	294	CD
18637	20536	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20536	12	1920	1920	CD
18637	20536	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20536	14	.	.	.
18637	20537	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20537	2	212	212	CD
18637	20537	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20537	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	20537	5	.	.	.
18637	20538	1	289	289	CD
18637	20538	2	.	.	.
18637	20539	1	In	in	IN
18637	20539	2	injunctive	injunctive	JJ
18637	20539	3	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	20539	4	,	,	,
18637	20539	5	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	20539	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	20539	7	freshly	freshly	RB
18637	20539	8	introduced	introduce	VBN
18637	20539	9	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	20539	10	in	in	IN
18637	20539	11	the	the	DT
18637	20539	12	cases	case	NNS
18637	20539	13	received	receive	VBN
18637	20539	14	on	on	IN
18637	20539	15	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	20539	16	from	from	IN
18637	20539	17	State	State	NNP
18637	20539	18	courts	court	NNS
18637	20539	19	,	,	,
18637	20539	20	the	the	DT
18637	20539	21	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	20539	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	20539	23	found	find	VBN
18637	20539	24	within	within	IN
18637	20539	25	the	the	DT
18637	20539	26	record	record	NN
18637	20539	27	.	.	.
18637	20540	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20540	2	213	213	CD
18637	20540	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20540	4	231	231	CD
18637	20540	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20540	6	298	298	CD
18637	20540	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20540	8	1913	1913	CD
18637	20540	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20540	10	.	.	.
18637	20541	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20541	2	214	214	CD
18637	20541	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20541	4	253	253	CD
18637	20541	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20541	6	287	287	CD
18637	20541	7	,	,	,
18637	20541	8	291	291	CD
18637	20541	9	,	,	,
18637	20541	10	295	295	CD
18637	20541	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20541	12	1920	1920	CD
18637	20541	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20541	14	.	.	.
18637	20542	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20542	2	215	215	CD
18637	20542	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20542	4	94	94	CD
18637	20542	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20542	6	113	113	CD
18637	20542	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20542	8	1877	1877	CD
18637	20542	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20542	10	.	.	.
18637	20543	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20543	2	216	216	CD
18637	20543	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20543	4	315	315	CD
18637	20543	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20543	6	575	575	CD
18637	20543	7	,	,	,
18637	20543	8	586	586	CD
18637	20543	9	.	.	.
18637	20544	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20544	2	217	217	CD
18637	20544	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20544	4	320	320	CD
18637	20544	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20544	6	591	591	CD
18637	20544	7	,	,	,
18637	20544	8	602.--Although	602.--although	CD
18637	20544	9	this	this	DT
18637	20544	10	and	and	CC
18637	20544	11	the	the	DT
18637	20544	12	previously	previously	RB
18637	20544	13	cited	cite	VBN
18637	20544	14	decision	decision	NN
18637	20544	15	arose	arise	VBD
18637	20544	16	out	out	IN
18637	20544	17	of	of	IN
18637	20544	18	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	20544	19	involving	involve	VBG
18637	20544	20	the	the	DT
18637	20544	21	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	20544	22	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20544	23	Act	Act	NNP
18637	20544	24	of	of	IN
18637	20544	25	1938	1938	CD
18637	20544	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20544	27	52	52	CD
18637	20544	28	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	20544	29	.	.	.
18637	20545	1	821	821	CD
18637	20545	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20545	3	,	,	,
18637	20545	4	the	the	DT
18637	20545	5	principles	principle	NNS
18637	20545	6	laid	lay	VBD
18637	20545	7	down	down	RP
18637	20545	8	therein	therein	RB
18637	20545	9	are	be	VBP
18637	20545	10	believed	believe	VBN
18637	20545	11	to	to	TO
18637	20545	12	be	be	VB
18637	20545	13	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	20545	14	to	to	IN
18637	20545	15	the	the	DT
18637	20545	16	review	review	NN
18637	20545	17	of	of	IN
18637	20545	18	rate	rate	NN
18637	20545	19	orders	order	NNS
18637	20545	20	of	of	IN
18637	20545	21	State	state	NN
18637	20545	22	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	20545	23	,	,	,
18637	20545	24	except	except	IN
18637	20545	25	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	20545	26	as	as	IN
18637	20545	27	the	the	DT
18637	20545	28	latter	latter	JJ
18637	20545	29	operate	operate	NN
18637	20545	30	in	in	IN
18637	20545	31	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	20545	32	to	to	IN
18637	20545	33	laws	law	NNS
18637	20545	34	containing	contain	VBG
18637	20545	35	unique	unique	JJ
18637	20545	36	standards	standard	NNS
18637	20545	37	or	or	CC
18637	20545	38	procedures	procedure	NNS
18637	20545	39	.	.	.
18637	20546	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20546	2	218	218	CD
18637	20546	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20546	4	253	253	CD
18637	20546	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20546	6	287	287	CD
18637	20546	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20546	8	1920	1920	CD
18637	20546	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20546	10	.	.	.
18637	20547	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20547	2	219	219	CD
18637	20547	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20547	4	In	in	IN
18637	20547	5	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	20547	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	20547	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20547	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20547	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20547	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20547	11	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	20547	12	.	.	.
18637	20548	1	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20548	2	Pipeline	Pipeline	NNP
18637	20548	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20548	4	,	,	,
18637	20548	5	315	315	CD
18637	20548	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20548	7	575	575	CD
18637	20548	8	,	,	,
18637	20548	9	599	599	CD
18637	20548	10	,	,	,
18637	20548	11	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	20548	12	Black	Black	NNP
18637	20548	13	,	,	,
18637	20548	14	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	20548	15	,	,	,
18637	20548	16	and	and	CC
18637	20548	17	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	20548	18	,	,	,
18637	20548	19	in	in	IN
18637	20548	20	a	a	DT
18637	20548	21	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	20548	22	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	20548	23	,	,	,
18637	20548	24	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	20548	25	to	to	TO
18637	20548	26	travel	travel	VB
18637	20548	27	the	the	DT
18637	20548	28	road	road	NN
18637	20548	29	all	all	PDT
18637	20548	30	the	the	DT
18637	20548	31	way	way	NN
18637	20548	32	back	back	RB
18637	20548	33	to	to	IN
18637	20548	34	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	20548	35	_	_	NNP
18637	20548	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	20548	37	_	_	NNP
18637	20548	38	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	20548	39	,	,	,
18637	20548	40	and	and	CC
18637	20548	41	deprive	deprive	JJ
18637	20548	42	courts	court	NNS
18637	20548	43	of	of	IN
18637	20548	44	the	the	DT
18637	20548	45	power	power	NN
18637	20548	46	to	to	TO
18637	20548	47	void	void	VB
18637	20548	48	rates	rate	NNS
18637	20548	49	simply	simply	RB
18637	20548	50	because	because	IN
18637	20548	51	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20548	52	deem	deem	VBP
18637	20548	53	the	the	DT
18637	20548	54	latter	latter	JJ
18637	20548	55	to	to	TO
18637	20548	56	be	be	VB
18637	20548	57	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	20548	58	.	.	.
18637	20549	1	In	in	IN
18637	20549	2	a	a	DT
18637	20549	3	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	20549	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	20549	5	,	,	,
18637	20549	6	written	write	VBN
18637	20549	7	earlier	early	RBR
18637	20549	8	in	in	IN
18637	20549	9	1939	1939	CD
18637	20549	10	in	in	IN
18637	20549	11	Driscoll	Driscoll	NNP
18637	20549	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20549	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	20549	14	_	_	NNP
18637	20549	15	Edison	Edison	NNP
18637	20549	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20549	17	,	,	,
18637	20549	18	307	307	CD
18637	20549	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20549	20	104	104	CD
18637	20549	21	,	,	,
18637	20549	22	122	122	CD
18637	20549	23	,	,	,
18637	20549	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20549	25	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	20549	26	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	20549	27	adopted	adopt	VBD
18637	20549	28	a	a	DT
18637	20549	29	similar	similar	JJ
18637	20549	30	position	position	NN
18637	20549	31	;	;	:
18637	20549	32	for	for	IN
18637	20549	33	therein	therein	RB
18637	20549	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20549	35	declared	declare	VBD
18637	20549	36	that	that	IN
18637	20549	37	"	"	``
18637	20549	38	the	the	DT
18637	20549	39	only	only	JJ
18637	20549	40	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	20549	41	function	function	NN
18637	20549	42	of	of	IN
18637	20549	43	law	law	NN
18637	20549	44	*	*	NFP
18637	20549	45	*	*	NFP
18637	20549	46	*	*	NFP
18637	20549	47	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20549	48	in	in	IN
18637	20549	49	rate	rate	NN
18637	20549	50	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	20549	51	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20549	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	20549	53	to	to	TO
18637	20549	54	secure	secure	VB
18637	20549	55	observance	observance	NN
18637	20549	56	of	of	IN
18637	20549	57	those	those	DT
18637	20549	58	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	20549	59	safeguards	safeguard	NNS
18637	20549	60	in	in	IN
18637	20549	61	the	the	DT
18637	20549	62	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	20549	63	of	of	IN
18637	20549	64	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	20549	65	powers	power	NNS
18637	20549	66	,	,	,
18637	20549	67	which	which	WDT
18637	20549	68	are	be	VBP
18637	20549	69	the	the	DT
18637	20549	70	historic	historic	JJ
18637	20549	71	foundations	foundation	NNS
18637	20549	72	of	of	IN
18637	20549	73	due	due	JJ
18637	20549	74	process	process	NN
18637	20549	75	.	.	.
18637	20549	76	"	"	''
18637	20550	1	However	however	RB
18637	20550	2	,	,	,
18637	20550	3	in	in	IN
18637	20550	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20550	5	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	20550	6	in	in	IN
18637	20550	7	the	the	DT
18637	20550	8	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	20550	9	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20550	10	Case	Case	NNP
18637	20550	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20550	12	320	320	CD
18637	20550	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20550	14	591	591	CD
18637	20550	15	,	,	,
18637	20550	16	625	625	CD
18637	20550	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20550	18	,	,	,
18637	20550	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20550	20	disassociated	disassociate	VBD
18637	20550	21	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20550	22	from	from	IN
18637	20550	23	this	this	DT
18637	20550	24	proposal	proposal	NN
18637	20550	25	,	,	,
18637	20550	26	and	and	CC
18637	20550	27	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	20550	28	that	that	IN
18637	20550	29	"	"	``
18637	20550	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20550	31	was	be	VBD
18637	20550	32	decided	decide	VBN
18637	20550	33	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20550	34	more	more	JJR
18637	20550	35	than	than	IN
18637	20550	36	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	20550	37	years	year	NNS
18637	20550	38	ago	ago	RB
18637	20550	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20550	40	that	that	IN
18637	20550	41	the	the	DT
18637	20550	42	final	final	JJ
18637	20550	43	say	say	NN
18637	20550	44	under	under	IN
18637	20550	45	the	the	DT
18637	20550	46	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	20550	47	lies	lie	VBZ
18637	20550	48	with	with	IN
18637	20550	49	the	the	DT
18637	20550	50	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	20550	51	.	.	.
18637	20550	52	"	"	''
18637	20551	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20551	2	220	220	CD
18637	20551	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20551	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	20551	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	20551	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20551	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20551	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20551	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20551	10	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	20551	11	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20551	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20551	13	,	,	,
18637	20551	14	320	320	CD
18637	20551	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20551	16	591	591	CD
18637	20551	17	,	,	,
18637	20551	18	602	602	CD
18637	20551	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20551	20	1944	1944	CD
18637	20551	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20551	22	.	.	.
18637	20552	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20552	2	221	221	CD
18637	20552	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20552	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	20552	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	20552	6	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	20552	7	.	.	.
18637	20553	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20553	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20553	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20553	4	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	20553	5	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20553	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20553	7	,	,	,
18637	20553	8	320	320	CD
18637	20553	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20553	10	591	591	CD
18637	20553	11	,	,	,
18637	20553	12	603	603	CD
18637	20553	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20553	14	1944	1944	CD
18637	20553	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20553	16	,	,	,
18637	20553	17	citing	cite	VBG
18637	20553	18	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20553	19	&	&	CC
18637	20553	20	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	20553	21	Trunk	Trunk	NNP
18637	20553	22	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	20553	23	.	.	.
18637	20554	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20554	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20554	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20554	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20554	5	Wellman	Wellman	NNP
18637	20554	6	,	,	,
18637	20554	7	143	143	CD
18637	20554	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20554	9	339	339	CD
18637	20554	10	,	,	,
18637	20554	11	345	345	CD
18637	20554	12	-	-	SYM
18637	20554	13	346	346	CD
18637	20554	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20554	15	1892	1892	CD
18637	20554	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20554	17	;	;	:
18637	20554	18	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20554	19	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20554	20	rel	rel	NN
18637	20554	21	.	.	.
18637	20555	1	Southwestern	Southwestern	NNP
18637	20555	2	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	20555	3	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	20555	4	.	.	.
18637	20556	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20556	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20556	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20556	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20556	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20556	6	Service	Service	NNP
18637	20556	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20556	8	,	,	,
18637	20556	9	262	262	CD
18637	20556	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20556	11	276	276	CD
18637	20556	12	,	,	,
18637	20556	13	291	291	CD
18637	20556	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20556	15	1923	1923	CD
18637	20556	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20556	17	.	.	.
18637	20557	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20557	2	222	222	CD
18637	20557	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20557	4	For	for	IN
18637	20557	5	this	this	DT
18637	20557	6	reason	reason	NN
18637	20557	7	there	there	EX
18637	20557	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	20557	9	presented	present	VBN
18637	20557	10	below	below	IN
18637	20557	11	a	a	DT
18637	20557	12	survey	survey	NN
18637	20557	13	of	of	IN
18637	20557	14	the	the	DT
18637	20557	15	formulas	formula	NNS
18637	20557	16	,	,	,
18637	20557	17	utilization	utilization	NN
18637	20557	18	of	of	IN
18637	20557	19	which	which	WDT
18637	20557	20	was	be	VBD
18637	20557	21	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
18637	20557	22	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	20557	23	essential	essential	JJ
18637	20557	24	if	if	IN
18637	20557	25	due	due	JJ
18637	20557	26	process	process	NN
18637	20557	27	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	20557	28	were	be	VBD
18637	20557	29	to	to	TO
18637	20557	30	be	be	VB
18637	20557	31	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	20557	32	.	.	.
18637	20558	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20558	2	1	1	LS
18637	20558	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20558	4	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	20558	5	Value.--On	Value.--On	VBZ
18637	20558	6	the	the	DT
18637	20558	7	premise	premise	NN
18637	20558	8	that	that	IN
18637	20558	9	a	a	DT
18637	20558	10	utility	utility	NN
18637	20558	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	20558	12	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	20558	13	to	to	TO
18637	20558	14	demand	demand	VB
18637	20558	15	a	a	DT
18637	20558	16	rate	rate	NN
18637	20558	17	schedule	schedule	NN
18637	20558	18	that	that	WDT
18637	20558	19	will	will	MD
18637	20558	20	yield	yield	VB
18637	20558	21	a	a	DT
18637	20558	22	"	"	``
18637	20558	23	fair	fair	JJ
18637	20558	24	return	return	NN
18637	20558	25	upon	upon	IN
18637	20558	26	the	the	DT
18637	20558	27	value	value	NN
18637	20558	28	"	"	''
18637	20558	29	of	of	IN
18637	20558	30	the	the	DT
18637	20558	31	property	property	NN
18637	20558	32	which	which	WDT
18637	20558	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20558	34	employs	employ	VBZ
18637	20558	35	for	for	IN
18637	20558	36	public	public	JJ
18637	20558	37	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	20558	38	,	,	,
18637	20558	39	the	the	DT
18637	20558	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20558	41	in	in	IN
18637	20558	42	1898	1898	CD
18637	20558	43	,	,	,
18637	20558	44	in	in	IN
18637	20558	45	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
18637	20558	46	_	_	NNP
18637	20558	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	20558	48	_	_	NNP
18637	20558	49	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	20558	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20558	51	169	169	CD
18637	20558	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20558	53	466	466	CD
18637	20558	54	,	,	,
18637	20558	55	546	546	CD
18637	20558	56	-	-	SYM
18637	20558	57	547	547	CD
18637	20558	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20558	59	,	,	,
18637	20558	60	held	hold	VBD
18637	20558	61	that	that	IN
18637	20558	62	determination	determination	NN
18637	20558	63	of	of	IN
18637	20558	64	such	such	JJ
18637	20558	65	value	value	NN
18637	20558	66	necessitated	necessitate	VBD
18637	20558	67	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	20558	68	of	of	IN
18637	20558	69	at	at	IN
18637	20558	70	least	least	JJS
18637	20558	71	such	such	JJ
18637	20558	72	factors	factor	NNS
18637	20558	73	as	as	IN
18637	20558	74	"	"	``
18637	20558	75	the	the	DT
18637	20558	76	original	original	JJ
18637	20558	77	cost	cost	NN
18637	20558	78	of	of	IN
18637	20558	79	construction	construction	NN
18637	20558	80	,	,	,
18637	20558	81	the	the	DT
18637	20558	82	amount	amount	NN
18637	20558	83	expended	expend	VBN
18637	20558	84	in	in	IN
18637	20558	85	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	20558	86	improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	20558	87	,	,	,
18637	20558	88	the	the	DT
18637	20558	89	amount	amount	NN
18637	20558	90	and	and	CC
18637	20558	91	market	market	NN
18637	20558	92	value	value	NN
18637	20558	93	of	of	IN
18637	20558	94	*	*	NFP
18637	20558	95	*	*	NFP
18637	20558	96	*	*	NFP
18637	20558	97	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20558	98	the	the	DT
18637	20558	99	utility	utility	NN
18637	20558	100	's	's	POS
18637	20558	101	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20558	102	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	20558	103	and	and	CC
18637	20558	104	stock	stock	NN
18637	20558	105	,	,	,
18637	20558	106	the	the	DT
18637	20558	107	present	present	JJ
18637	20558	108	as	as	IN
18637	20558	109	compared	compare	VBN
18637	20558	110	with	with	IN
18637	20558	111	the	the	DT
18637	20558	112	original	original	JJ
18637	20558	113	cost	cost	NN
18637	20558	114	of	of	IN
18637	20558	115	construction	construction	NN
18637	20558	116	,	,	,
18637	20558	117	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20558	118	replacement	replacement	NN
18637	20558	119	cost	cost	NN
18637	20558	120	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20558	121	,	,	,
18637	20558	122	the	the	DT
18637	20558	123	probable	probable	JJ
18637	20558	124	earning	earning	NN
18637	20558	125	capacity	capacity	NN
18637	20558	126	of	of	IN
18637	20558	127	the	the	DT
18637	20558	128	property	property	NN
18637	20558	129	under	under	IN
18637	20558	130	particular	particular	JJ
18637	20558	131	rates	rate	NNS
18637	20558	132	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	20558	133	by	by	IN
18637	20558	134	statute	statute	NN
18637	20558	135	,	,	,
18637	20558	136	and	and	CC
18637	20558	137	the	the	DT
18637	20558	138	sum	sum	NN
18637	20558	139	required	require	VBN
18637	20558	140	to	to	TO
18637	20558	141	meet	meet	VB
18637	20558	142	operating	operating	NN
18637	20558	143	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	20558	144	.	.	.
18637	20558	145	"	"	''
18637	20559	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20559	2	2	2	LS
18637	20559	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20559	4	Reproduction	reproduction	NN
18637	20559	5	Cost.--Prior	cost.--prior	NN
18637	20559	6	to	to	IN
18637	20559	7	the	the	DT
18637	20559	8	demise	demise	NN
18637	20559	9	in	in	IN
18637	20559	10	1944	1944	CD
18637	20559	11	of	of	IN
18637	20559	12	the	the	DT
18637	20559	13	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
18637	20559	14	_	_	NNP
18637	20559	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	20559	16	_	_	NNP
18637	20559	17	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	20559	18	fair	fair	JJ
18637	20559	19	value	value	NN
18637	20559	20	formula	formula	NN
18637	20559	21	,	,	,
18637	20559	22	two	two	CD
18637	20559	23	of	of	IN
18637	20559	24	the	the	DT
18637	20559	25	components	component	NNS
18637	20559	26	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	20559	27	were	be	VBD
18637	20559	28	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	20559	29	special	special	JJ
18637	20559	30	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	20559	31	,	,	,
18637	20559	32	with	with	IN
18637	20559	33	the	the	DT
18637	20559	34	second	second	NN
18637	20559	35	quickly	quickly	RB
18637	20559	36	surpassing	surpass	VBG
18637	20559	37	the	the	DT
18637	20559	38	first	first	JJ
18637	20559	39	in	in	IN
18637	20559	40	terms	term	NNS
18637	20559	41	of	of	IN
18637	20559	42	the	the	DT
18637	20559	43	measure	measure	NN
18637	20559	44	of	of	IN
18637	20559	45	importance	importance	NN
18637	20559	46	attributed	attribute	VBN
18637	20559	47	to	to	IN
18637	20559	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20559	49	.	.	.
18637	20560	1	These	these	DT
18637	20560	2	were	be	VBD
18637	20560	3	:	:	:
18637	20560	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20560	5	1	1	LS
18637	20560	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20560	7	the	the	DT
18637	20560	8	actual	actual	JJ
18637	20560	9	cost	cost	NN
18637	20560	10	of	of	IN
18637	20560	11	the	the	DT
18637	20560	12	property	property	NN
18637	20560	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20560	14	"	"	``
18637	20560	15	the	the	DT
18637	20560	16	original	original	JJ
18637	20560	17	cost	cost	NN
18637	20560	18	of	of	IN
18637	20560	19	construction	construction	NN
18637	20560	20	together	together	RB
18637	20560	21	with	with	IN
18637	20560	22	the	the	DT
18637	20560	23	amount	amount	NN
18637	20560	24	expended	expend	VBN
18637	20560	25	in	in	IN
18637	20560	26	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	20560	27	improvements	improvement	NNS
18637	20560	28	"	"	''
18637	20560	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20560	30	and	and	CC
18637	20560	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20560	32	2	2	LS
18637	20560	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20560	34	reproduction	reproduction	NN
18637	20560	35	cost	cost	NN
18637	20560	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20560	37	"	"	``
18637	20560	38	the	the	DT
18637	20560	39	present	present	NN
18637	20560	40	as	as	IN
18637	20560	41	compared	compare	VBN
18637	20560	42	with	with	IN
18637	20560	43	the	the	DT
18637	20560	44	original	original	JJ
18637	20560	45	cost	cost	NN
18637	20560	46	of	of	IN
18637	20560	47	construction	construction	NN
18637	20560	48	"	"	''
18637	20560	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20560	50	.	.	.
18637	20561	1	If	if	IN
18637	20561	2	prices	price	NNS
18637	20561	3	did	do	VBD
18637	20561	4	not	not	RB
18637	20561	5	fluctuate	fluctuate	VB
18637	20561	6	through	through	IN
18637	20561	7	the	the	DT
18637	20561	8	years	year	NNS
18637	20561	9	,	,	,
18637	20561	10	the	the	DT
18637	20561	11	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	20561	12	which	which	WDT
18637	20561	13	arose	arise	VBD
18637	20561	14	over	over	IN
18637	20561	15	the	the	DT
18637	20561	16	application	application	NN
18637	20561	17	of	of	IN
18637	20561	18	reproduction	reproduction	NN
18637	20561	19	cost	cost	NN
18637	20561	20	in	in	IN
18637	20561	21	preference	preference	NN
18637	20561	22	to	to	IN
18637	20561	23	original	original	JJ
18637	20561	24	cost	cost	NN
18637	20561	25	would	would	MD
18637	20561	26	have	have	VB
18637	20561	27	been	be	VBN
18637	20561	28	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	20561	29	to	to	IN
18637	20561	30	a	a	DT
18637	20561	31	war	war	NN
18637	20561	32	of	of	IN
18637	20561	33	words	word	NNS
18637	20561	34	;	;	:
18637	20561	35	for	for	IN
18637	20561	36	results	result	NNS
18637	20561	37	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	20561	38	by	by	IN
18637	20561	39	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	20561	40	upon	upon	IN
18637	20561	41	either	either	RB
18637	20561	42	would	would	MD
18637	20561	43	have	have	VB
18637	20561	44	been	be	VBN
18637	20561	45	identical	identical	JJ
18637	20561	46	.	.	.
18637	20562	1	The	the	DT
18637	20562	2	instability	instability	NN
18637	20562	3	in	in	IN
18637	20562	4	the	the	DT
18637	20562	5	price	price	NN
18637	20562	6	structure	structure	NN
18637	20562	7	,	,	,
18637	20562	8	however	however	RB
18637	20562	9	,	,	,
18637	20562	10	presented	present	VBD
18637	20562	11	the	the	DT
18637	20562	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	20562	13	with	with	IN
18637	20562	14	a	a	DT
18637	20562	15	dilemma	dilemma	NN
18637	20562	16	.	.	.
18637	20563	1	If	if	IN
18637	20563	2	rate	rate	NN
18637	20563	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	20563	4	making	making	NN
18637	20563	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	20563	6	attempted	attempt	VBN
18637	20563	7	at	at	IN
18637	20563	8	a	a	DT
18637	20563	9	time	time	NN
18637	20563	10	of	of	IN
18637	20563	11	declining	decline	VBG
18637	20563	12	prices	price	NNS
18637	20563	13	,	,	,
18637	20563	14	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	20563	15	on	on	IN
18637	20563	16	the	the	DT
18637	20563	17	basis	basis	NN
18637	20563	18	of	of	IN
18637	20563	19	present	present	NN
18637	20563	20	or	or	CC
18637	20563	21	reproduction	reproduction	NN
18637	20563	22	cost	cost	NN
18637	20563	23	will	will	MD
18637	20563	24	advantage	advantage	VB
18637	20563	25	the	the	DT
18637	20563	26	consumer	consumer	NN
18637	20563	27	or	or	CC
18637	20563	28	user	user	NN
18637	20563	29	,	,	,
18637	20563	30	and	and	CC
18637	20563	31	disadvantage	disadvantage	VB
18637	20563	32	the	the	DT
18637	20563	33	utility	utility	NN
18637	20563	34	.	.	.
18637	20564	1	On	on	IN
18637	20564	2	the	the	DT
18637	20564	3	other	other	JJ
18637	20564	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	20564	5	,	,	,
18637	20564	6	if	if	IN
18637	20564	7	the	the	DT
18637	20564	8	original	original	JJ
18637	20564	9	cost	cost	NN
18637	20564	10	of	of	IN
18637	20564	11	construction	construction	NN
18637	20564	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	20564	13	employed	employ	VBN
18637	20564	14	,	,	,
18637	20564	15	the	the	DT
18637	20564	16	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	20564	17	are	be	VBP
18637	20564	18	redistributed	redistribute	VBN
18637	20564	19	,	,	,
18637	20564	20	with	with	IN
18637	20564	21	the	the	DT
18637	20564	22	consumer	consumer	NN
18637	20564	23	becoming	become	VBG
18637	20564	24	the	the	DT
18637	20564	25	loser	loser	NN
18637	20564	26	.	.	.
18637	20565	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	20565	2	,	,	,
18637	20565	3	when	when	WRB
18637	20565	4	rates	rate	NNS
18637	20565	5	are	be	VBP
18637	20565	6	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	20565	7	at	at	IN
18637	20565	8	a	a	DT
18637	20565	9	time	time	NN
18637	20565	10	of	of	IN
18637	20565	11	rising	rise	VBG
18637	20565	12	prices	price	NNS
18637	20565	13	,	,	,
18637	20565	14	reliance	reliance	NN
18637	20565	15	upon	upon	IN
18637	20565	16	reproduction	reproduction	NN
18637	20565	17	cost	cost	NN
18637	20565	18	to	to	IN
18637	20565	19	the	the	DT
18637	20565	20	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	20565	21	of	of	IN
18637	20565	22	original	original	JJ
18637	20565	23	cost	cost	NN
18637	20565	24	will	will	MD
18637	20565	25	produce	produce	VB
18637	20565	26	results	result	NNS
18637	20565	27	satisfactory	satisfactory	JJ
18637	20565	28	to	to	IN
18637	20565	29	the	the	DT
18637	20565	30	utility	utility	NN
18637	20565	31	and	and	CC
18637	20565	32	undesirable	undesirable	JJ
18637	20565	33	to	to	IN
18637	20565	34	the	the	DT
18637	20565	35	public	public	NN
18637	20565	36	,	,	,
18637	20565	37	and	and	CC
18637	20565	38	vice	vice	NN
18637	20565	39	versa	versa	RB
18637	20565	40	.	.	.
18637	20566	1	Notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	20566	2	the	the	DT
18637	20566	3	admonition	admonition	NN
18637	20566	4	of	of	IN
18637	20566	5	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
18637	20566	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20566	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20566	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20566	9	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	20566	10	that	that	IN
18637	20566	11	original	original	JJ
18637	20566	12	cost	cost	NN
18637	20566	13	,	,	,
18637	20566	14	no	no	DT
18637	20566	15	less	less	JJR
18637	20566	16	than	than	IN
18637	20566	17	reproduction	reproduction	NN
18637	20566	18	cost	cost	NN
18637	20566	19	,	,	,
18637	20566	20	was	be	VBD
18637	20566	21	to	to	TO
18637	20566	22	be	be	VB
18637	20566	23	considered	consider	VBN
18637	20566	24	in	in	IN
18637	20566	25	determining	determine	VBG
18637	20566	26	value	value	NN
18637	20566	27	,	,	,
18637	20566	28	the	the	DT
18637	20566	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20566	30	,	,	,
18637	20566	31	in	in	IN
18637	20566	32	the	the	DT
18637	20566	33	years	year	NNS
18637	20566	34	which	which	WDT
18637	20566	35	intervened	intervene	VBD
18637	20566	36	between	between	IN
18637	20566	37	1898	1898	CD
18637	20566	38	and	and	CC
18637	20566	39	1944	1944	CD
18637	20566	40	,	,	,
18637	20566	41	wavered	waver	VBD
18637	20566	42	only	only	RB
18637	20566	43	slightly	slightly	RB
18637	20566	44	in	in	IN
18637	20566	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20566	46	preference	preference	NN
18637	20566	47	for	for	IN
18637	20566	48	the	the	DT
18637	20566	49	reproduction	reproduction	NN
18637	20566	50	cost	cost	NN
18637	20566	51	formula	formula	NN
18637	20566	52	,	,	,
18637	20566	53	and	and	CC
18637	20566	54	moderated	moderate	VBD
18637	20566	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20566	56	application	application	NN
18637	20566	57	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	20566	58	only	only	RB
18637	20566	59	in	in	IN
18637	20566	60	part	part	NN
18637	20566	61	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	20566	62	periods	period	NNS
18637	20566	63	of	of	IN
18637	20566	64	rising	rise	VBG
18637	20566	65	or	or	CC
18637	20566	66	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	20566	67	high	high	JJ
18637	20566	68	prices	price	NNS
18637	20566	69	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	20566	70	to	to	TO
18637	20566	71	require	require	VB
18637	20566	72	such	such	JJ
18637	20566	73	deviation	deviation	NN
18637	20566	74	in	in	IN
18637	20566	75	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	20566	76	of	of	IN
18637	20566	77	consumer	consumer	NN
18637	20566	78	interests	interest	NNS
18637	20566	79	.	.	.
18637	20567	1	As	as	IN
18637	20567	2	examples	example	NNS
18637	20567	3	of	of	IN
18637	20567	4	the	the	DT
18637	20567	5	varied	varied	JJ
18637	20567	6	application	application	NN
18637	20567	7	by	by	IN
18637	20567	8	the	the	DT
18637	20567	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20567	10	of	of	IN
18637	20567	11	the	the	DT
18637	20567	12	reproduction	reproduction	NN
18637	20567	13	cost	cost	VBD
18637	20567	14	formula	formula	NN
18637	20567	15	,	,	,
18637	20567	16	the	the	DT
18637	20567	17	following	follow	VBG
18637	20567	18	cases	case	NNS
18637	20567	19	are	be	VBP
18637	20567	20	significant	significant	JJ
18637	20567	21	:	:	:
18637	20567	22	San	San	NNP
18637	20567	23	Diego	Diego	NNP
18637	20567	24	Land	Land	NNP
18637	20567	25	and	and	CC
18637	20567	26	Town	Town	NNP
18637	20567	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20567	28	_	_	NNP
18637	20567	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	20567	30	_	_	NNP
18637	20567	31	National	National	NNP
18637	20567	32	City	City	NNP
18637	20567	33	,	,	,
18637	20567	34	174	174	CD
18637	20567	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20567	36	739	739	CD
18637	20567	37	,	,	,
18637	20567	38	757	757	CD
18637	20567	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20567	40	1899	1899	CD
18637	20567	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20567	42	;	;	:
18637	20567	43	San	San	NNP
18637	20567	44	Diego	Diego	NNP
18637	20567	45	Land	Land	NNP
18637	20567	46	&	&	CC
18637	20567	47	Town	Town	NNP
18637	20567	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20567	49	_	_	NNP
18637	20567	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	20567	51	_	_	NNP
18637	20567	52	Jasper	Jasper	NNP
18637	20567	53	,	,	,
18637	20567	54	189	189	CD
18637	20567	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20567	56	439	439	CD
18637	20567	57	,	,	,
18637	20567	58	443	443	CD
18637	20567	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20567	60	1903	1903	CD
18637	20567	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20567	62	;	;	:
18637	20567	63	Willcox	Willcox	NNP
18637	20567	64	_	_	NNP
18637	20567	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	20567	66	_	_	NNP
18637	20567	67	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	20567	68	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20567	69	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20567	70	,	,	,
18637	20567	71	212	212	CD
18637	20567	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20567	73	19	19	CD
18637	20567	74	,	,	,
18637	20567	75	52	52	CD
18637	20567	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20567	77	1909	1909	CD
18637	20567	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20567	79	;	;	:
18637	20567	80	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	20567	81	Rate	Rate	NNP
18637	20567	82	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	20567	83	,	,	,
18637	20567	84	230	230	CD
18637	20567	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20567	86	352	352	CD
18637	20567	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20567	88	1913	1913	CD
18637	20567	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20567	90	;	;	:
18637	20567	91	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	20567	92	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	20567	93	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20567	94	_	_	NNP
18637	20567	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	20567	96	_	_	NNP
18637	20567	97	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	20567	98	,	,	,
18637	20567	99	258	258	CD
18637	20567	100	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20567	101	388	388	CD
18637	20567	102	,	,	,
18637	20567	103	392	392	CD
18637	20567	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20567	105	1922	1922	CD
18637	20567	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20567	107	;	;	:
18637	20567	108	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20567	109	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20567	110	rel	rel	NN
18637	20567	111	.	.	.
18637	20568	1	Southwestern	Southwestern	NNP
18637	20568	2	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	20568	3	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	20568	4	.	.	.
18637	20569	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20569	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20569	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20569	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20569	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20569	6	Service	Service	NNP
18637	20569	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20569	8	,	,	,
18637	20569	9	262	262	CD
18637	20569	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20569	11	276	276	CD
18637	20569	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20569	13	1923	1923	CD
18637	20569	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20569	15	;	;	:
18637	20569	16	Bluefield	Bluefield	NNP
18637	20569	17	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	20569	18	&	&	CC
18637	20569	19	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	20569	20	.	.	.
18637	20570	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20570	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20570	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20570	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20570	5	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	20570	6	.	.	.
18637	20571	1	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	20571	2	.	.	.
18637	20572	1	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	20572	2	.	.	NNP
18637	20572	3	,	,	,
18637	20572	4	262	262	CD
18637	20572	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20572	6	679	679	CD
18637	20572	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20572	8	1923	1923	CD
18637	20572	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20572	10	;	;	:
18637	20572	11	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	20572	12	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20572	13	&	&	CC
18637	20572	14	Power	Power	NNP
18637	20572	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20572	16	_	_	NNP
18637	20572	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	20572	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20572	19	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	20572	20	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	20572	21	.	.	NNP
18637	20572	22	,	,	,
18637	20572	23	262	262	CD
18637	20572	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20572	25	625	625	CD
18637	20572	26	,	,	,
18637	20572	27	630	630	CD
18637	20572	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20572	29	1923	1923	CD
18637	20572	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20572	31	;	;	:
18637	20572	32	McCardle	McCardle	NNP
18637	20572	33	_	_	NNP
18637	20572	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	20572	35	_	_	NNP
18637	20572	36	Indianapolis	Indianapolis	NNP
18637	20572	37	Water	Water	NNP
18637	20572	38	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20572	39	,	,	,
18637	20572	40	272	272	CD
18637	20572	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20572	42	400	400	CD
18637	20572	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20572	44	1926	1926	CD
18637	20572	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20572	46	;	;	:
18637	20572	47	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20572	48	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	20572	49	&	&	CC
18637	20572	50	O'Fallon	O'Fallon	NNP
18637	20572	51	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	20572	52	.	.	.
18637	20573	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20573	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20573	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20573	4	United	United	NNP
18637	20573	5	States	States	NNP
18637	20573	6	,	,	,
18637	20573	7	279	279	CD
18637	20573	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20573	9	461	461	CD
18637	20573	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20573	11	1929	1929	CD
18637	20573	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20573	13	.	.	.
18637	20574	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20574	2	3	3	LS
18637	20574	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20574	4	Prudent	Prudent	NNP
18637	20574	5	Investment	Investment	NNP
18637	20574	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20574	7	versus	versus	IN
18637	20574	8	Reproduction	Reproduction	NNP
18637	20574	9	Cost).--This	Cost).--This	NNP
18637	20574	10	method	method	NN
18637	20574	11	of	of	IN
18637	20574	12	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	20574	13	,	,	,
18637	20574	14	which	which	WDT
18637	20574	15	was	be	VBD
18637	20574	16	championed	champion	VBN
18637	20574	17	by	by	IN
18637	20574	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20574	19	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	20574	20	in	in	IN
18637	20574	21	a	a	DT
18637	20574	22	separate	separate	JJ
18637	20574	23	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	20574	24	filed	file	VBN
18637	20574	25	in	in	IN
18637	20574	26	Southwestern	Southwestern	NNP
18637	20574	27	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	20574	28	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	20574	29	.	.	.
18637	20575	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20575	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20575	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20575	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20575	5	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	20575	6	.	.	.
18637	20576	1	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	20576	2	.	.	.
18637	20577	1	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	20577	2	.	.	.
18637	20578	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20578	2	262	262	CD
18637	20578	3	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20578	4	276	276	CD
18637	20578	5	,	,	,
18637	20578	6	291	291	CD
18637	20578	7	-	-	SYM
18637	20578	8	292	292	CD
18637	20578	9	,	,	,
18637	20578	10	302	302	CD
18637	20578	11	,	,	,
18637	20578	12	306	306	CD
18637	20578	13	-	-	SYM
18637	20578	14	307	307	CD
18637	20578	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20578	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	20578	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20578	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20578	19	,	,	,
18637	20578	20	was	be	VBD
18637	20578	21	defined	define	VBN
18637	20578	22	by	by	IN
18637	20578	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20578	24	as	as	IN
18637	20578	25	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	20578	26	:	:	:
18637	20578	27	"	"	``
18637	20578	28	The	the	DT
18637	20578	29	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	20578	30	which	which	WDT
18637	20578	31	the	the	DT
18637	20578	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	20578	33	guarantees	guarantee	VBZ
18637	20578	34	an	an	DT
18637	20578	35	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	20578	36	to	to	TO
18637	20578	37	earn	earn	VB
18637	20578	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	20578	39	the	the	DT
18637	20578	40	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	20578	41	cost	cost	NN
18637	20578	42	of	of	IN
18637	20578	43	conducting	conduct	VBG
18637	20578	44	the	the	DT
18637	20578	45	business	business	NN
18637	20578	46	.	.	.
18637	20579	1	Cost	cost	NN
18637	20579	2	includes	include	VBZ
18637	20579	3	not	not	RB
18637	20579	4	only	only	RB
18637	20579	5	operating	operating	NN
18637	20579	6	expenses	expense	NNS
18637	20579	7	,	,	,
18637	20579	8	but	but	CC
18637	20579	9	also	also	RB
18637	20579	10	capital	capital	NN
18637	20579	11	charges	charge	NNS
18637	20579	12	.	.	.
18637	20580	1	Capital	capital	NN
18637	20580	2	charges	charge	NNS
18637	20580	3	cover	cover	VBP
18637	20580	4	the	the	DT
18637	20580	5	allowance	allowance	NN
18637	20580	6	,	,	,
18637	20580	7	by	by	IN
18637	20580	8	way	way	NN
18637	20580	9	of	of	IN
18637	20580	10	interest	interest	NN
18637	20580	11	,	,	,
18637	20580	12	for	for	IN
18637	20580	13	the	the	DT
18637	20580	14	use	use	NN
18637	20580	15	of	of	IN
18637	20580	16	the	the	DT
18637	20580	17	capital	capital	NN
18637	20580	18	,	,	,
18637	20580	19	*	*	NFP
18637	20580	20	*	*	NFP
18637	20580	21	*	*	NFP
18637	20580	22	;	;	:
18637	20580	23	the	the	DT
18637	20580	24	allowance	allowance	NN
18637	20580	25	for	for	IN
18637	20580	26	the	the	DT
18637	20580	27	risk	risk	NN
18637	20580	28	incurred	incur	VBD
18637	20580	29	;	;	:
18637	20580	30	and	and	CC
18637	20580	31	enough	enough	RB
18637	20580	32	more	more	JJR
18637	20580	33	to	to	TO
18637	20580	34	attract	attract	VB
18637	20580	35	capital	capital	NN
18637	20580	36	.	.	.
18637	20581	1	*	*	NFP
18637	20581	2	*	*	NFP
18637	20581	3	*	*	NFP
18637	20581	4	Where	where	WRB
18637	20581	5	the	the	DT
18637	20581	6	financing	financing	NN
18637	20581	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	20581	8	been	be	VBN
18637	20581	9	proper	proper	JJ
18637	20581	10	,	,	,
18637	20581	11	the	the	DT
18637	20581	12	cost	cost	NN
18637	20581	13	to	to	IN
18637	20581	14	the	the	DT
18637	20581	15	utility	utility	NN
18637	20581	16	of	of	IN
18637	20581	17	the	the	DT
18637	20581	18	capital	capital	NN
18637	20581	19	,	,	,
18637	20581	20	required	require	VBN
18637	20581	21	to	to	TO
18637	20581	22	construct	construct	VB
18637	20581	23	,	,	,
18637	20581	24	equip	equip	VB
18637	20581	25	and	and	CC
18637	20581	26	operate	operate	VB
18637	20581	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20581	28	plant	plant	NN
18637	20581	29	,	,	,
18637	20581	30	should	should	MD
18637	20581	31	measure	measure	VB
18637	20581	32	the	the	DT
18637	20581	33	rate	rate	NN
18637	20581	34	of	of	IN
18637	20581	35	return	return	NN
18637	20581	36	which	which	WDT
18637	20581	37	the	the	DT
18637	20581	38	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	20581	39	guarantees	guarantee	VBZ
18637	20581	40	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	20581	41	to	to	TO
18637	20581	42	earn	earn	VB
18637	20581	43	.	.	.
18637	20581	44	"	"	''
18637	20582	1	Advantages	advantage	NNS
18637	20582	2	to	to	TO
18637	20582	3	be	be	VB
18637	20582	4	derived	derive	VBN
18637	20582	5	from	from	IN
18637	20582	6	"	"	``
18637	20582	7	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	20582	8	of	of	IN
18637	20582	9	the	the	DT
18637	20582	10	amount	amount	NN
18637	20582	11	prudently	prudently	RB
18637	20582	12	invested	invest	VBN
18637	20582	13	as	as	IN
18637	20582	14	the	the	DT
18637	20582	15	rate	rate	NN
18637	20582	16	base	base	NN
18637	20582	17	and	and	CC
18637	20582	18	the	the	DT
18637	20582	19	amount	amount	NN
18637	20582	20	of	of	IN
18637	20582	21	the	the	DT
18637	20582	22	capital	capital	NN
18637	20582	23	charge	charge	NN
18637	20582	24	as	as	IN
18637	20582	25	the	the	DT
18637	20582	26	measure	measure	NN
18637	20582	27	of	of	IN
18637	20582	28	the	the	DT
18637	20582	29	rate	rate	NN
18637	20582	30	of	of	IN
18637	20582	31	return	return	NN
18637	20582	32	"	"	''
18637	20582	33	would	would	MD
18637	20582	34	,	,	,
18637	20582	35	according	accord	VBG
18637	20582	36	to	to	IN
18637	20582	37	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20582	38	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	20582	39	,	,	,
18637	20582	40	be	be	VB
18637	20582	41	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	20582	42	less	less	JJR
18637	20582	43	than	than	IN
18637	20582	44	the	the	DT
18637	20582	45	attainment	attainment	NN
18637	20582	46	of	of	IN
18637	20582	47	a	a	DT
18637	20582	48	"	"	``
18637	20582	49	basis	basis	NN
18637	20582	50	for	for	IN
18637	20582	51	decision	decision	NN
18637	20582	52	which	which	WDT
18637	20582	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	20582	54	certain	certain	JJ
18637	20582	55	and	and	CC
18637	20582	56	stable	stable	JJ
18637	20582	57	.	.	.
18637	20583	1	The	the	DT
18637	20583	2	rate	rate	NN
18637	20583	3	base	base	NN
18637	20583	4	would	would	MD
18637	20583	5	be	be	VB
18637	20583	6	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	20583	7	as	as	IN
18637	20583	8	a	a	DT
18637	20583	9	fact	fact	NN
18637	20583	10	,	,	,
18637	20583	11	not	not	RB
18637	20583	12	determined	determine	VBN
18637	20583	13	as	as	IN
18637	20583	14	a	a	DT
18637	20583	15	matter	matter	NN
18637	20583	16	of	of	IN
18637	20583	17	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	20583	18	.	.	.
18637	20584	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20584	2	would	would	MD
18637	20584	3	not	not	RB
18637	20584	4	fluctuate	fluctuate	VB
18637	20584	5	with	with	IN
18637	20584	6	the	the	DT
18637	20584	7	market	market	NN
18637	20584	8	price	price	NN
18637	20584	9	of	of	IN
18637	20584	10	labor	labor	NN
18637	20584	11	,	,	,
18637	20584	12	or	or	CC
18637	20584	13	materials	material	NNS
18637	20584	14	,	,	,
18637	20584	15	or	or	CC
18637	20584	16	money	money	NN
18637	20584	17	.	.	.
18637	20585	1	*	*	NFP
18637	20585	2	*	*	NFP
18637	20585	3	*	*	NFP
18637	20585	4	"	"	``
18637	20585	5	As	as	IN
18637	20585	6	a	a	DT
18637	20585	7	method	method	NN
18637	20585	8	of	of	IN
18637	20585	9	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	20585	10	,	,	,
18637	20585	11	the	the	DT
18637	20585	12	prudent	prudent	JJ
18637	20585	13	investment	investment	NN
18637	20585	14	theory	theory	NN
18637	20585	15	was	be	VBD
18637	20585	16	not	not	RB
18637	20585	17	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	20585	18	any	any	DT
18637	20585	19	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	20585	20	until	until	IN
18637	20585	21	the	the	DT
18637	20585	22	depression	depression	NN
18637	20585	23	of	of	IN
18637	20585	24	the	the	DT
18637	20585	25	1930	1930	CD
18637	20585	26	's	's	POS
18637	20585	27	.	.	.
18637	20586	1	The	the	DT
18637	20586	2	sharp	sharp	JJ
18637	20586	3	decline	decline	NN
18637	20586	4	in	in	IN
18637	20586	5	prices	price	NNS
18637	20586	6	which	which	WDT
18637	20586	7	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	20586	8	during	during	IN
18637	20586	9	this	this	DT
18637	20586	10	period	period	NN
18637	20586	11	doubtless	doubtless	RB
18637	20586	12	contributed	contribute	VBD
18637	20586	13	to	to	IN
18637	20586	14	the	the	DT
18637	20586	15	loss	loss	NN
18637	20586	16	of	of	IN
18637	20586	17	affection	affection	NN
18637	20586	18	for	for	IN
18637	20586	19	reproduction	reproduction	NN
18637	20586	20	cost	cost	NN
18637	20586	21	;	;	,
18637	20586	22	and	and	CC
18637	20586	23	in	in	IN
18637	20586	24	Los	Los	NNP
18637	20586	25	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	20586	26	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20586	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20586	28	_	_	NNP
18637	20586	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	20586	30	_	_	NNP
18637	20586	31	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	20587	1	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	20587	2	.	.	.
18637	20587	3	,	,	,
18637	20587	4	289	289	CD
18637	20587	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20587	6	287	287	CD
18637	20587	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20587	8	1933	1933	CD
18637	20587	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20587	10	and	and	CC
18637	20587	11	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	20588	1	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
18637	20588	2	.	.	.
18637	20589	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20589	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20589	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20589	4	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	20589	5	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20589	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20589	7	,	,	,
18637	20589	8	302	302	CD
18637	20589	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20589	10	388	388	CD
18637	20589	11	,	,	,
18637	20589	12	399	399	CD
18637	20589	13	,	,	,
18637	20589	14	405	405	CD
18637	20589	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20589	16	1938	1938	CD
18637	20589	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20589	18	the	the	DT
18637	20589	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20589	20	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	20589	21	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	20589	22	a	a	DT
18637	20589	23	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	20589	24	from	from	IN
18637	20589	25	which	which	WDT
18637	20589	26	reproduction	reproduction	NN
18637	20589	27	cost	cost	NN
18637	20589	28	had	have	VBD
18637	20589	29	been	be	VBN
18637	20589	30	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	20589	31	and	and	CC
18637	20589	32	another	another	DT
18637	20589	33	in	in	IN
18637	20589	34	which	which	WDT
18637	20589	35	historical	historical	JJ
18637	20589	36	cost	cost	NN
18637	20589	37	served	serve	VBD
18637	20589	38	as	as	IN
18637	20589	39	the	the	DT
18637	20589	40	rate	rate	NN
18637	20589	41	base	base	NN
18637	20589	42	.	.	.
18637	20590	1	Later	later	RB
18637	20590	2	,	,	,
18637	20590	3	in	in	IN
18637	20590	4	1942	1942	CD
18637	20590	5	,	,	,
18637	20590	6	when	when	WRB
18637	20590	7	in	in	IN
18637	20590	8	Power	Power	NNP
18637	20590	9	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	20590	10	.	.	.
18637	20591	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20591	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20591	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20591	4	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	20591	5	.	.	.
18637	20592	1	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20592	2	Pipeline	Pipeline	NNP
18637	20592	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20592	4	,	,	,
18637	20592	5	315	315	CD
18637	20592	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20592	7	575	575	CD
18637	20592	8	,	,	,
18637	20592	9	the	the	DT
18637	20592	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20592	11	further	further	RB
18637	20592	12	emphasized	emphasize	VBD
18637	20592	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20592	14	abandonment	abandonment	NN
18637	20592	15	of	of	IN
18637	20592	16	the	the	DT
18637	20592	17	reproduction	reproduction	NN
18637	20592	18	cost	cost	NN
18637	20592	19	factor	factor	NN
18637	20592	20	,	,	,
18637	20592	21	there	there	RB
18637	20592	22	developed	develop	VBD
18637	20592	23	momentarily	momentarily	RB
18637	20592	24	the	the	DT
18637	20592	25	prospect	prospect	NN
18637	20592	26	that	that	IN
18637	20592	27	prudent	prudent	JJ
18637	20592	28	investment	investment	NN
18637	20592	29	might	may	MD
18637	20592	30	be	be	VB
18637	20592	31	substituted	substitute	VBN
18637	20592	32	.	.	.
18637	20593	1	This	this	DT
18637	20593	2	possibility	possibility	NN
18637	20593	3	was	be	VBD
18637	20593	4	quickly	quickly	RB
18637	20593	5	negatived	negative	VBN
18637	20593	6	,	,	,
18637	20593	7	however	however	RB
18637	20593	8	,	,	,
18637	20593	9	by	by	IN
18637	20593	10	the	the	DT
18637	20593	11	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	20593	12	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20593	13	Case	Case	NNP
18637	20593	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20593	15	320	320	CD
18637	20593	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20593	17	591	591	CD
18637	20593	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20593	19	1944	1944	CD
18637	20593	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20593	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20593	22	which	which	WDT
18637	20593	23	dispensed	dispense	VBD
18637	20593	24	with	with	IN
18637	20593	25	the	the	DT
18637	20593	26	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	20593	27	of	of	IN
18637	20593	28	relying	rely	VBG
18637	20593	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	20593	30	any	any	DT
18637	20593	31	formula	formula	NN
18637	20593	32	for	for	IN
18637	20593	33	the	the	DT
18637	20593	34	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	20593	35	of	of	IN
18637	20593	36	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	20593	37	valid	valid	JJ
18637	20593	38	rates	rate	NNS
18637	20593	39	.	.	.
18637	20594	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20594	2	4	4	LS
18637	20594	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20594	4	Depreciation.--No	depreciation.--no	NN
18637	20594	5	less	less	RBR
18637	20594	6	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
18637	20594	7	to	to	IN
18637	20594	8	the	the	DT
18637	20594	9	determination	determination	NN
18637	20594	10	of	of	IN
18637	20594	11	the	the	DT
18637	20594	12	fair	fair	JJ
18637	20594	13	value	value	NN
18637	20594	14	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	20594	15	in	in	IN
18637	20594	16	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
18637	20594	17	_	_	NNP
18637	20594	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	20594	19	_	_	NNP
18637	20594	20	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	20594	21	was	be	VBD
18637	20594	22	the	the	DT
18637	20594	23	amount	amount	NN
18637	20594	24	of	of	IN
18637	20594	25	depreciation	depreciation	NN
18637	20594	26	to	to	TO
18637	20594	27	be	be	VB
18637	20594	28	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	20594	29	as	as	IN
18637	20594	30	a	a	DT
18637	20594	31	deduction	deduction	NN
18637	20594	32	from	from	IN
18637	20594	33	the	the	DT
18637	20594	34	measure	measure	NN
18637	20594	35	of	of	IN
18637	20594	36	cost	cost	NN
18637	20594	37	employed	employ	VBN
18637	20594	38	,	,	,
18637	20594	39	whether	whether	IN
18637	20594	40	the	the	DT
18637	20594	41	latter	latter	JJ
18637	20594	42	be	be	VB
18637	20594	43	actual	actual	JJ
18637	20594	44	cost	cost	NN
18637	20594	45	,	,	,
18637	20594	46	reproduction	reproduction	NN
18637	20594	47	cost	cost	NN
18637	20594	48	,	,	,
18637	20594	49	or	or	CC
18637	20594	50	any	any	DT
18637	20594	51	other	other	JJ
18637	20594	52	form	form	NN
18637	20594	53	of	of	IN
18637	20594	54	cost	cost	NN
18637	20594	55	determination	determination	NN
18637	20594	56	.	.	.
18637	20595	1	Although	although	IN
18637	20595	2	not	not	RB
18637	20595	3	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	20595	4	in	in	IN
18637	20595	5	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
18637	20595	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20595	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20595	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20595	9	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	20595	10	,	,	,
18637	20595	11	the	the	DT
18637	20595	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20595	13	gave	give	VBD
18637	20595	14	this	this	DT
18637	20595	15	item	item	NN
18637	20595	16	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	20595	17	in	in	IN
18637	20595	18	Knoxville	Knoxville	NNP
18637	20595	19	_	_	NNP
18637	20595	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	20595	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20595	22	Knoxville	Knoxville	NNP
18637	20595	23	Water	Water	NNP
18637	20595	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20595	25	,	,	,
18637	20595	26	212	212	CD
18637	20595	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20595	28	1	1	CD
18637	20595	29	,	,	,
18637	20595	30	9	9	CD
18637	20595	31	-	-	SYM
18637	20595	32	10	10	CD
18637	20595	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20595	34	1909	1909	CD
18637	20595	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20595	36	;	;	:
18637	20595	37	but	but	CC
18637	20595	38	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	20595	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20595	40	early	early	JJ
18637	20595	41	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	20595	42	as	as	IN
18637	20595	43	an	an	DT
18637	20595	44	allowable	allowable	JJ
18637	20595	45	item	item	NN
18637	20595	46	of	of	IN
18637	20595	47	deduction	deduction	NN
18637	20595	48	in	in	IN
18637	20595	49	determining	determine	VBG
18637	20595	50	value	value	NN
18637	20595	51	,	,	,
18637	20595	52	depreciation	depreciation	NN
18637	20595	53	continued	continue	VBD
18637	20595	54	to	to	TO
18637	20595	55	be	be	VB
18637	20595	56	the	the	DT
18637	20595	57	subject	subject	NN
18637	20595	58	of	of	IN
18637	20595	59	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	20595	60	arising	arise	VBG
18637	20595	61	out	out	IN
18637	20595	62	of	of	IN
18637	20595	63	the	the	DT
18637	20595	64	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	20595	65	of	of	IN
18637	20595	66	ascertaining	ascertain	VBG
18637	20595	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20595	68	and	and	CC
18637	20595	69	of	of	IN
18637	20595	70	computing	compute	VBG
18637	20595	71	annual	annual	JJ
18637	20595	72	allowances	allowance	NNS
18637	20595	73	to	to	TO
18637	20595	74	cover	cover	VB
18637	20595	75	the	the	DT
18637	20595	76	same	same	JJ
18637	20595	77	.	.	.
18637	20596	1	Indicative	indicative	JJ
18637	20596	2	of	of	IN
18637	20596	3	such	such	JJ
18637	20596	4	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	20596	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	20596	6	been	be	VBN
18637	20596	7	the	the	DT
18637	20596	8	disagreement	disagreement	NN
18637	20596	9	as	as	IN
18637	20596	10	to	to	IN
18637	20596	11	whether	whether	IN
18637	20596	12	annual	annual	JJ
18637	20596	13	allowances	allowance	NNS
18637	20596	14	granted	grant	VBN
18637	20596	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	20596	16	be	be	VB
18637	20596	17	in	in	IN
18637	20596	18	such	such	JJ
18637	20596	19	amount	amount	NN
18637	20596	20	as	as	IN
18637	20596	21	will	will	MD
18637	20596	22	permit	permit	VB
18637	20596	23	the	the	DT
18637	20596	24	replacement	replacement	NN
18637	20596	25	of	of	IN
18637	20596	26	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	20596	27	at	at	IN
18637	20596	28	current	current	JJ
18637	20596	29	costs	cost	NNS
18637	20596	30	;	;	:
18637	20596	31	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	20596	32	,	,	,
18637	20596	33	present	present	JJ
18637	20596	34	value	value	NN
18637	20596	35	,	,	,
18637	20596	36	or	or	CC
18637	20596	37	at	at	IN
18637	20596	38	original	original	JJ
18637	20596	39	cost	cost	NN
18637	20596	40	.	.	.
18637	20597	1	In	in	IN
18637	20597	2	the	the	DT
18637	20597	3	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	20597	4	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20597	5	Case	Case	NNP
18637	20597	6	,	,	,
18637	20597	7	320	320	CD
18637	20597	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20597	9	591	591	CD
18637	20597	10	,	,	,
18637	20597	11	606	606	CD
18637	20597	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20597	13	1944	1944	CD
18637	20597	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20597	15	,	,	,
18637	20597	16	the	the	DT
18637	20597	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20597	18	reversed	reverse	VBD
18637	20597	19	United	United	NNP
18637	20597	20	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20597	21	&	&	CC
18637	20597	22	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	20597	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20597	24	_	_	NNP
18637	20597	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	20597	26	_	_	NNP
18637	20597	27	West	West	NNP
18637	20597	28	,	,	,
18637	20597	29	280	280	CD
18637	20597	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20597	31	234	234	CD
18637	20597	32	,	,	,
18637	20597	33	253	253	CD
18637	20597	34	-	-	SYM
18637	20597	35	254	254	CD
18637	20597	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20597	37	1930	1930	CD
18637	20597	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20597	39	,	,	,
18637	20597	40	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	20597	41	as	as	IN
18637	20597	42	the	the	DT
18637	20597	43	latter	latter	JJ
18637	20597	44	holding	holding	NN
18637	20597	45	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	20597	46	original	original	JJ
18637	20597	47	cost	cost	NN
18637	20597	48	as	as	IN
18637	20597	49	the	the	DT
18637	20597	50	basis	basis	NN
18637	20597	51	of	of	IN
18637	20597	52	annual	annual	JJ
18637	20597	53	depreciation	depreciation	NN
18637	20597	54	allowances	allowance	NNS
18637	20597	55	.	.	.
18637	20598	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20598	2	5	5	LS
18637	20598	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20598	4	Going	go	VBG
18637	20598	5	Concern	concern	NN
18637	20598	6	Value	value	NN
18637	20598	7	and	and	CC
18637	20598	8	Good	good	JJ
18637	20598	9	Will.--Whether	will.--whether	NN
18637	20598	10	or	or	CC
18637	20598	11	not	not	RB
18637	20598	12	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	20598	13	were	be	VBD
18637	20598	14	to	to	TO
18637	20598	15	be	be	VB
18637	20598	16	included	include	VBN
18637	20598	17	in	in	IN
18637	20598	18	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	20598	19	was	be	VBD
18637	20598	20	not	not	RB
18637	20598	21	passed	pass	VBN
18637	20598	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	20598	23	in	in	IN
18637	20598	24	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
18637	20598	25	_	_	NNP
18637	20598	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	20598	27	_	_	NNP
18637	20598	28	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	20598	29	;	;	:
18637	20598	30	but	but	CC
18637	20598	31	shortly	shortly	RB
18637	20598	32	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	20598	33	,	,	,
18637	20598	34	in	in	IN
18637	20598	35	Des	Des	NNP
18637	20598	36	Moines	Moines	NNP
18637	20598	37	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20598	38	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20598	39	_	_	NNP
18637	20598	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	20598	41	_	_	NNP
18637	20598	42	Des	Des	NNP
18637	20598	43	Moines	Moines	NNP
18637	20598	44	,	,	,
18637	20598	45	238	238	CD
18637	20598	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20598	47	153	153	CD
18637	20598	48	,	,	,
18637	20598	49	165	165	CD
18637	20598	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20598	51	1915	1915	CD
18637	20598	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20598	53	,	,	,
18637	20598	54	the	the	DT
18637	20598	55	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20598	56	declared	declare	VBD
18637	20598	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20598	58	to	to	TO
18637	20598	59	be	be	VB
18637	20598	60	self	self	NN
18637	20598	61	-	-	HYPH
18637	20598	62	evident	evident	JJ
18637	20598	63	"	"	''
18637	20598	64	that	that	IN
18637	20598	65	there	there	EX
18637	20598	66	is	be	VBZ
18637	20598	67	an	an	DT
18637	20598	68	element	element	NN
18637	20598	69	of	of	IN
18637	20598	70	value	value	NN
18637	20598	71	in	in	IN
18637	20598	72	an	an	DT
18637	20598	73	assembled	assemble	VBN
18637	20598	74	and	and	CC
18637	20598	75	established	establish	VBN
18637	20598	76	plant	plant	NN
18637	20598	77	,	,	,
18637	20598	78	doing	do	VBG
18637	20598	79	business	business	NN
18637	20598	80	and	and	CC
18637	20598	81	earning	earn	VBG
18637	20598	82	money	money	NN
18637	20598	83	,	,	,
18637	20598	84	over	over	IN
18637	20598	85	one	one	CD
18637	20598	86	not	not	RB
18637	20598	87	thus	thus	RB
18637	20598	88	advanced	advance	VBN
18637	20598	89	,	,	,
18637	20598	90	*	*	NFP
18637	20598	91	*	*	NFP
18637	20598	92	*	*	NFP
18637	20598	93	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20598	94	and	and	CC
18637	20598	95	that	that	IN
18637	20598	96	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20598	97	this	this	DT
18637	20598	98	element	element	NN
18637	20598	99	of	of	IN
18637	20598	100	value	value	NN
18637	20598	101	is	be	VBZ
18637	20598	102	a	a	DT
18637	20598	103	property	property	NN
18637	20598	104	right	right	NN
18637	20598	105	,	,	,
18637	20598	106	and	and	CC
18637	20598	107	should	should	MD
18637	20598	108	be	be	VB
18637	20598	109	considered	consider	VBN
18637	20598	110	in	in	IN
18637	20598	111	determining	determine	VBG
18637	20598	112	the	the	DT
18637	20598	113	value	value	NN
18637	20598	114	of	of	IN
18637	20598	115	the	the	DT
18637	20598	116	property	property	NN
18637	20598	117	,	,	,
18637	20598	118	upon	upon	IN
18637	20598	119	which	which	WDT
18637	20598	120	the	the	DT
18637	20598	121	owner	owner	NN
18637	20598	122	has	have	VBZ
18637	20598	123	a	a	DT
18637	20598	124	right	right	NN
18637	20598	125	to	to	TO
18637	20598	126	make	make	VB
18637	20598	127	a	a	DT
18637	20598	128	fair	fair	JJ
18637	20598	129	return	return	NN
18637	20598	130	*	*	NFP
18637	20598	131	*	*	NFP
18637	20598	132	*	*	NFP
18637	20598	133	.	.	.
18637	20598	134	"	"	''
18637	20599	1	Generally	generally	RB
18637	20599	2	described	describe	VBN
18637	20599	3	as	as	IN
18637	20599	4	going	go	VBG
18637	20599	5	concern	concern	NN
18637	20599	6	value	value	NN
18637	20599	7	,	,	,
18637	20599	8	this	this	DT
18637	20599	9	element	element	NN
18637	20599	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	20599	11	never	never	RB
18637	20599	12	been	be	VBN
18637	20599	13	precisely	precisely	RB
18637	20599	14	defined	define	VBN
18637	20599	15	by	by	IN
18637	20599	16	the	the	DT
18637	20599	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20599	18	,	,	,
18637	20599	19	and	and	CC
18637	20599	20	the	the	DT
18637	20599	21	latter	latter	JJ
18637	20599	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	20599	23	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	20599	24	been	be	VBN
18637	20599	25	plagued	plague	VBN
18637	20599	26	by	by	IN
18637	20599	27	the	the	DT
18637	20599	28	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	20599	29	of	of	IN
18637	20599	30	determining	determine	VBG
18637	20599	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20599	32	worth	worth	NN
18637	20599	33	.	.	.
18637	20600	1	In	in	IN
18637	20600	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20600	3	latest	late	JJS
18637	20600	4	pronouncement	pronouncement	NN
18637	20600	5	on	on	IN
18637	20600	6	the	the	DT
18637	20600	7	subject	subject	NN
18637	20600	8	,	,	,
18637	20600	9	uttered	utter	VBN
18637	20600	10	in	in	IN
18637	20600	11	Power	Power	NNP
18637	20600	12	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	20600	13	.	.	.
18637	20601	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20601	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20601	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20601	4	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	20601	5	.	.	.
18637	20602	1	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20602	2	Pipeline	Pipeline	NNP
18637	20602	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20602	4	,	,	,
18637	20602	5	315	315	CD
18637	20602	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20602	7	575	575	CD
18637	20602	8	,	,	,
18637	20602	9	589	589	CD
18637	20602	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20602	11	1942	1942	CD
18637	20602	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20602	13	,	,	,
18637	20602	14	the	the	DT
18637	20602	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20602	16	denied	deny	VBD
18637	20602	17	that	that	IN
18637	20602	18	there	there	EX
18637	20602	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	20602	20	any	any	DT
18637	20602	21	"	"	``
18637	20602	22	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	20602	23	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	20602	24	that	that	IN
18637	20602	25	going	go	VBG
18637	20602	26	concern	concern	NN
18637	20602	27	value	value	NN
18637	20602	28	,	,	,
18637	20602	29	even	even	RB
18637	20602	30	when	when	WRB
18637	20602	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20602	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	20602	33	an	an	DT
18637	20602	34	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	20602	35	element	element	NN
18637	20602	36	to	to	TO
18637	20602	37	be	be	VB
18637	20602	38	included	include	VBN
18637	20602	39	in	in	IN
18637	20602	40	a	a	DT
18637	20602	41	rate	rate	NN
18637	20602	42	base	base	NN
18637	20602	43	,	,	,
18637	20602	44	must	must	MD
18637	20602	45	be	be	VB
18637	20602	46	separately	separately	RB
18637	20602	47	stated	state	VBN
18637	20602	48	and	and	CC
18637	20602	49	appraised	appraise	VBN
18637	20602	50	as	as	IN
18637	20602	51	such	such	JJ
18637	20602	52	*	*	NFP
18637	20602	53	*	*	NFP
18637	20602	54	*	*	NFP
18637	20602	55	valuations	valuation	NNS
18637	20602	56	for	for	IN
18637	20602	57	rate	rate	NN
18637	20602	58	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	20602	59	of	of	IN
18637	20602	60	a	a	DT
18637	20602	61	business	business	NN
18637	20602	62	assembled	assemble	VBN
18637	20602	63	as	as	IN
18637	20602	64	a	a	DT
18637	20602	65	whole	whole	JJ
18637	20602	66	*	*	NFP
18637	20602	67	*	*	NFP
18637	20602	68	*	*	NFP
18637	20602	69	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20602	70	have	have	VBP
18637	20602	71	often	often	RB
18637	20602	72	been	be	VBN
18637	20602	73	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20602	74	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	20602	75	without	without	IN
18637	20602	76	separate	separate	JJ
18637	20602	77	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	20602	78	of	of	IN
18637	20602	79	the	the	DT
18637	20602	80	going	go	VBG
18637	20602	81	concern	concern	NN
18637	20602	82	element	element	NN
18637	20602	83	.	.	.
18637	20603	1	*	*	NFP
18637	20603	2	*	*	NFP
18637	20603	3	*	*	NFP
18637	20603	4	When	when	WRB
18637	20603	5	that	that	DT
18637	20603	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	20603	7	been	be	VBN
18637	20603	8	done	do	VBN
18637	20603	9	,	,	,
18637	20603	10	the	the	DT
18637	20603	11	burden	burden	NN
18637	20603	12	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	20603	13	on	on	IN
18637	20603	14	the	the	DT
18637	20603	15	regulated	regulated	JJ
18637	20603	16	company	company	NN
18637	20603	17	to	to	TO
18637	20603	18	show	show	VB
18637	20603	19	that	that	IN
18637	20603	20	this	this	DT
18637	20603	21	item	item	NN
18637	20603	22	has	have	VBZ
18637	20603	23	neither	neither	RB
18637	20603	24	been	be	VBN
18637	20603	25	adequately	adequately	RB
18637	20603	26	covered	cover	VBN
18637	20603	27	in	in	IN
18637	20603	28	the	the	DT
18637	20603	29	rate	rate	NN
18637	20603	30	base	base	NN
18637	20603	31	nor	nor	CC
18637	20603	32	recouped	recoup	VBN
18637	20603	33	from	from	IN
18637	20603	34	prior	prior	JJ
18637	20603	35	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	20603	36	of	of	IN
18637	20603	37	the	the	DT
18637	20603	38	business	business	NN
18637	20603	39	.	.	.
18637	20603	40	"	"	''
18637	20604	1	Franchise	franchise	NN
18637	20604	2	value	value	NN
18637	20604	3	and	and	CC
18637	20604	4	good	good	NN
18637	20604	5	will	will	NN
18637	20604	6	,	,	,
18637	20604	7	on	on	IN
18637	20604	8	the	the	DT
18637	20604	9	other	other	JJ
18637	20604	10	hand	hand	NN
18637	20604	11	,	,	,
18637	20604	12	have	have	VBP
18637	20604	13	been	be	VBN
18637	20604	14	consistently	consistently	RB
18637	20604	15	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	20604	16	from	from	IN
18637	20604	17	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	20604	18	;	;	:
18637	20604	19	the	the	DT
18637	20604	20	latter	latter	JJ
18637	20604	21	presumably	presumably	RB
18637	20604	22	because	because	IN
18637	20604	23	a	a	DT
18637	20604	24	utility	utility	NN
18637	20604	25	invariably	invariably	RB
18637	20604	26	enjoys	enjoy	VBZ
18637	20604	27	a	a	DT
18637	20604	28	monopoly	monopoly	NN
18637	20604	29	and	and	CC
18637	20604	30	consumers	consumer	NNS
18637	20604	31	have	have	VBP
18637	20604	32	no	no	DT
18637	20604	33	choice	choice	NN
18637	20604	34	in	in	IN
18637	20604	35	the	the	DT
18637	20604	36	matter	matter	NN
18637	20604	37	of	of	IN
18637	20604	38	patronizing	patronize	VBG
18637	20604	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20604	40	.	.	.
18637	20605	1	The	the	DT
18637	20605	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	20605	3	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	20605	4	has	have	VBZ
18637	20605	5	been	be	VBN
18637	20605	6	developed	develop	VBN
18637	20605	7	in	in	IN
18637	20605	8	the	the	DT
18637	20605	9	following	follow	VBG
18637	20605	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	20605	11	:	:	:
18637	20605	12	Willcox	Willcox	NNP
18637	20605	13	_	_	NNP
18637	20605	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	20605	15	_	_	NNP
18637	20605	16	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	20605	17	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20605	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20605	19	,	,	,
18637	20605	20	212	212	CD
18637	20605	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20605	22	19	19	CD
18637	20605	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20605	24	1909	1909	CD
18637	20605	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20605	26	;	;	:
18637	20605	27	Des	Des	NNP
18637	20605	28	Moines	Moines	NNP
18637	20605	29	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20605	30	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20605	31	_	_	NNP
18637	20605	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	20605	33	_	_	NNP
18637	20605	34	Des	Des	NNP
18637	20605	35	Moines	Moines	NNP
18637	20605	36	,	,	,
18637	20605	37	238	238	CD
18637	20605	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20605	39	153	153	CD
18637	20605	40	,	,	,
18637	20605	41	163	163	CD
18637	20605	42	-	-	SYM
18637	20605	43	164	164	CD
18637	20605	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20605	45	1915	1915	CD
18637	20605	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20605	47	;	;	:
18637	20605	48	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	20605	49	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	20605	50	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20605	51	_	_	NNP
18637	20605	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	20605	53	_	_	NNP
18637	20605	54	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	20605	55	,	,	,
18637	20605	56	258	258	CD
18637	20605	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20605	58	388	388	CD
18637	20605	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20605	60	1922	1922	CD
18637	20605	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20605	62	;	;	:
18637	20605	63	Los	Los	NNP
18637	20605	64	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	20605	65	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20605	66	&	&	CC
18637	20605	67	E.	E.	NNP
18637	20605	68	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	20605	69	_	_	NNP
18637	20605	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	20605	71	_	_	NNP
18637	20605	72	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	20605	73	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20605	74	,	,	,
18637	20605	75	289	289	CD
18637	20605	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20605	77	287	287	CD
18637	20605	78	,	,	,
18637	20605	79	313	313	CD
18637	20605	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20605	81	1933	1933	CD
18637	20605	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20605	83	.	.	.
18637	20606	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20606	2	6	6	CD
18637	20606	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20606	4	Salvage	Salvage	NNP
18637	20606	5	Value.--It	Value.--It	NNP
18637	20606	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	20606	7	not	not	RB
18637	20606	8	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	20606	9	error	error	NN
18637	20606	10	to	to	TO
18637	20606	11	disregard	disregard	VB
18637	20606	12	theoretical	theoretical	JJ
18637	20606	13	reproduction	reproduction	NN
18637	20606	14	cost	cost	NN
18637	20606	15	for	for	IN
18637	20606	16	a	a	DT
18637	20606	17	plant	plant	NN
18637	20606	18	which	which	WDT
18637	20606	19	"	"	``
18637	20606	20	no	no	DT
18637	20606	21	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	20606	22	person	person	NN
18637	20606	23	would	would	MD
18637	20606	24	think	think	VB
18637	20606	25	of	of	IN
18637	20606	26	reproducing	reproduce	VBG
18637	20606	27	.	.	.
18637	20606	28	"	"	''
18637	20607	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	20607	2	,	,	,
18637	20607	3	where	where	WRB
18637	20607	4	,	,	,
18637	20607	5	due	due	IN
18637	20607	6	to	to	IN
18637	20607	7	adverse	adverse	JJ
18637	20607	8	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	20607	9	,	,	,
18637	20607	10	a	a	DT
18637	20607	11	street	street	NN
18637	20607	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	20607	13	surface	surface	NN
18637	20607	14	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	20607	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	20607	16	lost	lose	VBN
18637	20607	17	all	all	DT
18637	20607	18	value	value	NN
18637	20607	19	except	except	IN
18637	20607	20	for	for	IN
18637	20607	21	scrap	scrap	NN
18637	20607	22	or	or	CC
18637	20607	23	salvage	salvage	NN
18637	20607	24	,	,	,
18637	20607	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20607	26	was	be	VBD
18637	20607	27	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	20607	28	for	for	IN
18637	20607	29	a	a	DT
18637	20607	30	commission	commission	NN
18637	20607	31	,	,	,
18637	20607	32	as	as	IN
18637	20607	33	the	the	DT
18637	20607	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20607	35	held	hold	VBD
18637	20607	36	in	in	IN
18637	20607	37	Market	Market	NNP
18637	20607	38	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20607	39	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20607	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20607	41	_	_	NNP
18637	20607	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	20607	43	_	_	NNP
18637	20607	44	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	20607	45	.	.	NNP
18637	20607	46	,	,	,
18637	20607	47	324	324	CD
18637	20607	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20607	49	548	548	CD
18637	20607	50	,	,	,
18637	20607	51	562	562	CD
18637	20607	52	,	,	,
18637	20607	53	564	564	CD
18637	20607	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20607	55	1945	1945	CD
18637	20607	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20607	57	,	,	,
18637	20607	58	to	to	TO
18637	20607	59	use	use	VB
18637	20607	60	as	as	IN
18637	20607	61	a	a	DT
18637	20607	62	rate	rate	NN
18637	20607	63	base	base	NN
18637	20607	64	the	the	DT
18637	20607	65	price	price	NN
18637	20607	66	at	at	IN
18637	20607	67	which	which	WDT
18637	20607	68	the	the	DT
18637	20607	69	utility	utility	NN
18637	20607	70	offered	offer	VBD
18637	20607	71	to	to	TO
18637	20607	72	sell	sell	VB
18637	20607	73	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20607	74	property	property	NN
18637	20607	75	to	to	IN
18637	20607	76	a	a	DT
18637	20607	77	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	20607	78	.	.	.
18637	20608	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	20608	2	,	,	,
18637	20608	3	the	the	DT
18637	20608	4	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20608	5	's	's	POS
18637	20608	6	order	order	NN
18637	20608	7	was	be	VBD
18637	20608	8	not	not	RB
18637	20608	9	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	20608	10	even	even	RB
18637	20608	11	though	though	IN
18637	20608	12	under	under	IN
18637	20608	13	the	the	DT
18637	20608	14	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	20608	15	rate	rate	NN
18637	20608	16	the	the	DT
18637	20608	17	utility	utility	NN
18637	20608	18	would	would	MD
18637	20608	19	operate	operate	VB
18637	20608	20	at	at	IN
18637	20608	21	a	a	DT
18637	20608	22	loss	loss	NN
18637	20608	23	;	;	:
18637	20608	24	for	for	IN
18637	20608	25	the	the	DT
18637	20608	26	due	due	JJ
18637	20608	27	process	process	NN
18637	20608	28	can	can	MD
18637	20608	29	not	not	RB
18637	20608	30	be	be	VB
18637	20608	31	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	20608	32	to	to	TO
18637	20608	33	protect	protect	VB
18637	20608	34	a	a	DT
18637	20608	35	public	public	JJ
18637	20608	36	utility	utility	NN
18637	20608	37	against	against	IN
18637	20608	38	business	business	NN
18637	20608	39	hazards	hazard	NNS
18637	20608	40	,	,	,
18637	20608	41	such	such	JJ
18637	20608	42	as	as	IN
18637	20608	43	the	the	DT
18637	20608	44	loss	loss	NN
18637	20608	45	of	of	IN
18637	20608	46	,	,	,
18637	20608	47	or	or	CC
18637	20608	48	failure	failure	NN
18637	20608	49	to	to	TO
18637	20608	50	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	20608	51	,	,	,
18637	20608	52	patronage	patronage	NN
18637	20608	53	.	.	.
18637	20609	1	On	on	IN
18637	20609	2	the	the	DT
18637	20609	3	other	other	JJ
18637	20609	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	20609	5	,	,	,
18637	20609	6	in	in	IN
18637	20609	7	the	the	DT
18637	20609	8	case	case	NN
18637	20609	9	of	of	IN
18637	20609	10	a	a	DT
18637	20609	11	water	water	NN
18637	20609	12	company	company	NN
18637	20609	13	whose	whose	WP$
18637	20609	14	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	20609	15	has	have	VBZ
18637	20609	16	expired	expire	VBN
18637	20609	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20609	18	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	20609	19	_	_	NNP
18637	20609	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	20609	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20609	22	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	20609	23	Union	Union	NNP
18637	20609	24	Water	Water	NNP
18637	20609	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20609	26	,	,	,
18637	20609	27	246	246	CD
18637	20609	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20609	29	178	178	CD
18637	20609	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20609	31	1918	1918	CD
18637	20609	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20609	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20609	34	,	,	,
18637	20609	35	but	but	CC
18637	20609	36	where	where	WRB
18637	20609	37	there	there	EX
18637	20609	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	20609	39	no	no	DT
18637	20609	40	other	other	JJ
18637	20609	41	source	source	NN
18637	20609	42	of	of	IN
18637	20609	43	supply	supply	NN
18637	20609	44	,	,	,
18637	20609	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20609	46	plant	plant	NN
18637	20609	47	should	should	MD
18637	20609	48	be	be	VB
18637	20609	49	valued	value	VBN
18637	20609	50	as	as	RB
18637	20609	51	actually	actually	RB
18637	20609	52	in	in	IN
18637	20609	53	use	use	NN
18637	20609	54	rather	rather	RB
18637	20609	55	than	than	IN
18637	20609	56	at	at	IN
18637	20609	57	what	what	WP
18637	20609	58	the	the	DT
18637	20609	59	property	property	NN
18637	20609	60	would	would	MD
18637	20609	61	bring	bring	VB
18637	20609	62	for	for	IN
18637	20609	63	some	some	DT
18637	20609	64	other	other	JJ
18637	20609	65	use	use	NN
18637	20609	66	in	in	IN
18637	20609	67	case	case	NN
18637	20609	68	the	the	DT
18637	20609	69	city	city	NN
18637	20609	70	should	should	MD
18637	20609	71	build	build	VB
18637	20609	72	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20609	73	own	own	JJ
18637	20609	74	plant	plant	NN
18637	20609	75	.	.	.
18637	20610	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20610	2	7	7	LS
18637	20610	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20610	4	Past	Past	NNP
18637	20610	5	Losses	Losses	NNPS
18637	20610	6	And	and	CC
18637	20610	7	Gains.--"The	Gains.--"The	NNP
18637	20610	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	20610	9	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20610	10	does	do	VBZ
18637	20610	11	not	not	RB
18637	20610	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20610	13	require	require	VB
18637	20610	14	that	that	IN
18637	20610	15	the	the	DT
18637	20610	16	losses	loss	NNS
18637	20610	17	of	of	IN
18637	20610	18	*	*	NFP
18637	20610	19	*	*	NFP
18637	20610	20	*	*	NFP
18637	20610	21	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20610	22	a	a	DT
18637	20610	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20610	24	business	business	NN
18637	20610	25	in	in	IN
18637	20610	26	one	one	CD
18637	20610	27	year	year	NN
18637	20610	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	20610	29	be	be	VB
18637	20610	30	restored	restore	VBN
18637	20610	31	from	from	IN
18637	20610	32	future	future	JJ
18637	20610	33	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	20610	34	by	by	IN
18637	20610	35	the	the	DT
18637	20610	36	device	device	NN
18637	20610	37	of	of	IN
18637	20610	38	capitalizing	capitalize	VBG
18637	20610	39	the	the	DT
18637	20610	40	losses	loss	NNS
18637	20610	41	and	and	CC
18637	20610	42	adding	add	VBG
18637	20610	43	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20610	44	to	to	IN
18637	20610	45	the	the	DT
18637	20610	46	rate	rate	NN
18637	20610	47	base	base	NN
18637	20610	48	on	on	IN
18637	20610	49	which	which	WDT
18637	20610	50	a	a	DT
18637	20610	51	fair	fair	JJ
18637	20610	52	return	return	NN
18637	20610	53	and	and	CC
18637	20610	54	depreciation	depreciation	NN
18637	20610	55	allowance	allowance	NN
18637	20610	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	20610	57	to	to	TO
18637	20610	58	be	be	VB
18637	20610	59	earned	earn	VBN
18637	20610	60	.	.	.
18637	20610	61	"	"	''
18637	20611	1	Power	Power	NNP
18637	20611	2	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
18637	20611	3	.	.	.
18637	20612	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20612	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20612	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20612	4	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	20612	5	.	.	.
18637	20613	1	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20613	2	Pipeline	Pipeline	NNP
18637	20613	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20613	4	,	,	,
18637	20613	5	315	315	CD
18637	20613	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20613	7	575	575	CD
18637	20613	8	,	,	,
18637	20613	9	590	590	CD
18637	20613	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20613	11	1942	1942	CD
18637	20613	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20613	13	.	.	.
18637	20614	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	20614	2	can	can	MD
18637	20614	3	past	past	VB
18637	20614	4	losses	loss	NNS
18637	20614	5	be	be	VB
18637	20614	6	used	use	VBN
18637	20614	7	to	to	TO
18637	20614	8	enhance	enhance	VB
18637	20614	9	the	the	DT
18637	20614	10	value	value	NN
18637	20614	11	of	of	IN
18637	20614	12	the	the	DT
18637	20614	13	property	property	NN
18637	20614	14	to	to	TO
18637	20614	15	support	support	VB
18637	20614	16	a	a	DT
18637	20614	17	claim	claim	NN
18637	20614	18	that	that	IN
18637	20614	19	rates	rate	NNS
18637	20614	20	for	for	IN
18637	20614	21	the	the	DT
18637	20614	22	future	future	NN
18637	20614	23	are	be	VBP
18637	20614	24	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	20614	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20614	26	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	20614	27	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	20614	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20614	29	_	_	NNP
18637	20614	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	20614	31	_	_	NNP
18637	20614	32	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	20614	33	,	,	,
18637	20614	34	258	258	CD
18637	20614	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20614	36	388	388	CD
18637	20614	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20614	38	1922	1922	CD
18637	20614	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20614	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20614	41	,	,	,
18637	20614	42	any	any	DT
18637	20614	43	more	more	RBR
18637	20614	44	than	than	IN
18637	20614	45	profits	profit	NNS
18637	20614	46	of	of	IN
18637	20614	47	the	the	DT
18637	20614	48	past	past	NN
18637	20614	49	can	can	MD
18637	20614	50	be	be	VB
18637	20614	51	used	use	VBN
18637	20614	52	to	to	TO
18637	20614	53	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	20614	54	confiscatory	confiscatory	JJ
18637	20614	55	rates	rate	NNS
18637	20614	56	for	for	IN
18637	20614	57	the	the	DT
18637	20614	58	future	future	NN
18637	20614	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20614	60	Newton	Newton	NNP
18637	20614	61	_	_	NNP
18637	20614	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	20614	63	_	_	NNP
18637	20614	64	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	20614	65	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20614	66	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20614	67	,	,	,
18637	20614	68	258	258	CD
18637	20614	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20614	70	165	165	CD
18637	20614	71	,	,	,
18637	20614	72	175	175	CD
18637	20614	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20614	74	1922	1922	CD
18637	20614	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20614	76	;	;	:
18637	20614	77	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20614	78	Utility	Utility	NNP
18637	20614	79	Commissioners	Commissioners	NNPS
18637	20614	80	_	_	NNP
18637	20614	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	20614	82	_	_	NNP
18637	20614	83	New	New	NNP
18637	20614	84	York	York	NNP
18637	20614	85	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	20614	86	.	.	.
18637	20615	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20615	2	,	,	,
18637	20615	3	271	271	CD
18637	20615	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20615	5	23	23	CD
18637	20615	6	,	,	,
18637	20615	7	31	31	CD
18637	20615	8	-	-	SYM
18637	20615	9	32	32	CD
18637	20615	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20615	11	1926	1926	CD
18637	20615	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20615	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20615	14	.	.	.
18637	20616	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20616	2	223	223	CD
18637	20616	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20616	4	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	20616	5	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	20616	6	Line	Line	NNP
18637	20616	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20616	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20616	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20616	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20616	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20616	12	North	North	NNP
18637	20616	13	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	20616	14	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	20616	15	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20616	16	,	,	,
18637	20616	17	206	206	CD
18637	20616	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20616	19	1	1	CD
18637	20616	20	,	,	,
18637	20616	21	19	19	CD
18637	20616	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20616	23	1907	1907	CD
18637	20616	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20616	25	,	,	,
18637	20616	26	citing	cite	VBG
18637	20616	27	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20616	28	,	,	,
18637	20616	29	B.	B.	NNP
18637	20616	30	&	&	CC
18637	20616	31	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	20617	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20617	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20617	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20617	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20617	5	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	20617	6	,	,	,
18637	20617	7	94	94	CD
18637	20617	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20617	9	155	155	CD
18637	20617	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20617	11	1877	1877	CD
18637	20617	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20617	13	.	.	.
18637	20618	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20618	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20618	3	also	also	RB
18637	20618	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20618	5	Prentis	Prentis	NNP
18637	20618	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20618	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20618	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20618	9	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	20618	10	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	20618	11	Line	Line	NNP
18637	20618	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20618	13	,	,	,
18637	20618	14	211	211	CD
18637	20618	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20618	16	210	210	CD
18637	20618	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20618	18	1908	1908	CD
18637	20618	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20618	20	;	;	:
18637	20618	21	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	20618	22	&	&	CC
18637	20618	23	R.G.R.	R.G.R.	NNP
18637	20619	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20619	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20619	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20619	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20619	5	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	20619	6	,	,	,
18637	20619	7	250	250	CD
18637	20619	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20619	9	241	241	CD
18637	20619	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20619	11	1919	1919	CD
18637	20619	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20619	13	.	.	.
18637	20620	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20620	2	224	224	CD
18637	20620	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20620	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20620	5	&	&	CC
18637	20620	6	G.T.R.	G.T.R.	NNP
18637	20621	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20621	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20621	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20621	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20621	5	Wellman	Wellman	NNP
18637	20621	6	,	,	,
18637	20621	7	143	143	CD
18637	20621	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20621	9	339	339	CD
18637	20621	10	,	,	,
18637	20621	11	344	344	CD
18637	20621	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20621	13	1892	1892	CD
18637	20621	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20621	15	;	;	:
18637	20621	16	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	20621	17	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20621	18	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20621	19	_	_	NNP
18637	20621	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	20621	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20621	22	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	20621	23	&	&	CC
18637	20621	24	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	20622	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20622	2	,	,	,
18637	20622	3	244	244	CD
18637	20622	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20622	5	388	388	CD
18637	20622	6	,	,	,
18637	20622	7	391	391	CD
18637	20622	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20622	9	1917	1917	CD
18637	20622	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20622	11	.	.	.
18637	20623	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20623	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20623	3	also	also	RB
18637	20623	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20623	5	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20623	6	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20624	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20624	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20624	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20624	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20624	5	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	20624	6	,	,	,
18637	20624	7	217	217	CD
18637	20624	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20624	9	196	196	CD
18637	20624	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20624	11	1910	1910	CD
18637	20624	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20624	13	;	;	:
18637	20624	14	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	20624	15	,	,	,
18637	20624	16	C.	C.	NNP
18637	20624	17	&	&	CC
18637	20624	18	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20624	19	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	20625	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20625	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20625	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20625	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20625	5	Walters	Walters	NNP
18637	20625	6	,	,	,
18637	20625	7	294	294	CD
18637	20625	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20625	9	405	405	CD
18637	20625	10	,	,	,
18637	20625	11	415	415	CD
18637	20625	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20625	13	1935	1935	CD
18637	20625	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20625	15	.	.	.
18637	20626	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20626	2	225	225	CD
18637	20626	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20626	4	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
18637	20626	5	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	20626	6	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	20626	7	.	.	.
18637	20627	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20627	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20627	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20627	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20627	5	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
18637	20627	6	,	,	,
18637	20627	7	204	204	CD
18637	20627	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20627	9	116	116	CD
18637	20627	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20627	11	1907	1907	CD
18637	20627	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20627	13	.	.	.
18637	20628	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20628	2	226	226	CD
18637	20628	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20628	4	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	20628	5	United	United	NNP
18637	20628	6	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	20628	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20628	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20628	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20628	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20628	11	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	20628	12	,	,	,
18637	20628	13	255	255	CD
18637	20628	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20628	15	171	171	CD
18637	20628	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20628	17	1921	1921	CD
18637	20628	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20628	19	.	.	.
18637	20629	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20629	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20629	3	also	also	RB
18637	20629	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20629	5	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	20629	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20629	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20629	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20629	9	New	New	NNP
18637	20629	10	York	York	NNP
18637	20629	11	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	20629	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20629	13	,	,	,
18637	20629	14	229	229	CD
18637	20629	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20629	16	123	123	CD
18637	20629	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20629	18	1913	1913	CD
18637	20629	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20629	20	.	.	.
18637	20630	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20630	2	227	227	CD
18637	20630	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20630	4	Los	Los	NNP
18637	20630	5	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	20630	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20630	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20630	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20630	9	Los	Los	NNP
18637	20630	10	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	20630	11	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20630	12	&	&	CC
18637	20630	13	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	20630	14	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	20630	15	,	,	,
18637	20630	16	251	251	CD
18637	20630	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20630	18	32	32	CD
18637	20630	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20630	20	1919	1919	CD
18637	20630	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20630	22	.	.	.
18637	20631	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20631	2	228	228	CD
18637	20631	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20631	4	Newburyport	Newburyport	NNP
18637	20631	5	Water	Water	NNP
18637	20631	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20631	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20631	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20631	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20631	10	Newburyport	Newburyport	NNP
18637	20631	11	,	,	,
18637	20631	12	193	193	CD
18637	20631	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20631	14	561	561	CD
18637	20631	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20631	16	1904	1904	CD
18637	20631	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20631	18	.	.	.
18637	20632	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20632	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20632	3	also	also	RB
18637	20632	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20632	5	Skaneateles	Skaneateles	NNP
18637	20632	6	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	20632	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20632	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20632	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20632	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20632	11	Skaneateles	Skaneateles	NNP
18637	20632	12	,	,	,
18637	20632	13	184	184	CD
18637	20632	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20632	15	354	354	CD
18637	20632	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20632	17	1902	1902	CD
18637	20632	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20632	19	;	;	:
18637	20632	20	Helena	Helena	NNP
18637	20632	21	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	20632	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20632	23	_	_	NNP
18637	20632	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	20632	25	_	_	NNP
18637	20632	26	Helena	Helena	NNP
18637	20632	27	,	,	,
18637	20632	28	195	195	CD
18637	20632	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20632	30	383	383	CD
18637	20632	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20632	32	1904	1904	CD
18637	20632	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20632	34	;	;	:
18637	20632	35	Madera	Madera	NNP
18637	20632	36	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	20632	37	_	_	NNP
18637	20632	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	20632	39	_	_	NNP
18637	20632	40	Madera	Madera	NNP
18637	20632	41	,	,	,
18637	20632	42	228	228	CD
18637	20632	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20632	44	454	454	CD
18637	20632	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20632	46	1913	1913	CD
18637	20632	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20632	48	.	.	.
18637	20633	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20633	2	229	229	CD
18637	20633	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20633	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	20633	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	20633	6	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	20633	7	.	.	.
18637	20634	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20634	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20634	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20634	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20634	5	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	20634	6	,	,	,
18637	20634	7	224	224	CD
18637	20634	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20634	9	160	160	CD
18637	20634	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20634	11	1912	1912	CD
18637	20634	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20634	13	.	.	.
18637	20635	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20635	2	230	230	CD
18637	20635	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20635	4	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	20635	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	20635	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	20635	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20635	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20635	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20635	10	Phoenix	Phoenix	NNP
18637	20635	11	Ref	Ref	NNP
18637	20635	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20635	13	,	,	,
18637	20635	14	259	259	CD
18637	20635	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20635	16	125	125	CD
18637	20635	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20635	18	1922	1922	CD
18637	20635	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20635	20	.	.	.
18637	20636	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20636	2	231	231	CD
18637	20636	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20636	4	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	20636	5	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	20636	6	Line	Line	NNP
18637	20636	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20636	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20636	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20636	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20636	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20636	12	Goldsboro	Goldsboro	NNP
18637	20636	13	,	,	,
18637	20636	14	232	232	CD
18637	20636	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20636	16	548	548	CD
18637	20636	17	,	,	,
18637	20636	18	558	558	CD
18637	20636	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20636	20	1914	1914	CD
18637	20636	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20636	22	.	.	.
18637	20637	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20637	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20637	3	also	also	RB
18637	20637	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20637	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20637	6	,	,	,
18637	20637	7	B.	B.	NNP
18637	20638	1	&	&	CC
18637	20638	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	20639	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20639	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20639	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20639	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20639	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20639	6	,	,	,
18637	20639	7	166	166	CD
18637	20639	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20639	9	226	226	CD
18637	20639	10	,	,	,
18637	20639	11	255	255	CD
18637	20639	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20639	13	1897	1897	CD
18637	20639	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20639	15	;	;	:
18637	20639	16	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20639	17	,	,	,
18637	20639	18	B.	B.	NNP
18637	20640	1	&	&	CC
18637	20640	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	20641	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20641	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20641	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20641	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20641	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	20641	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20641	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	20641	8	.	.	.
18637	20642	1	Grimwood	Grimwood	NNP
18637	20642	2	,	,	,
18637	20642	3	200	200	CD
18637	20642	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20642	5	561	561	CD
18637	20642	6	,	,	,
18637	20642	7	591	591	CD
18637	20642	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	20642	9	592	592	CD
18637	20642	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20642	11	1906	1906	CD
18637	20642	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20642	13	;	;	:
18637	20642	14	New	New	NNP
18637	20642	15	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	20642	16	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20642	17	Service	Service	NNP
18637	20642	18	,	,	,
18637	20642	19	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	20642	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20642	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	20642	22	_	_	NNP
18637	20642	23	New	New	NNP
18637	20642	24	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	20642	25	,	,	,
18637	20642	26	281	281	CD
18637	20642	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20642	28	682	682	CD
18637	20642	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20642	30	1930	1930	CD
18637	20642	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20642	32	.	.	.
18637	20643	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20643	2	232	232	CD
18637	20643	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20643	4	Consumers	Consumers	NNPS
18637	20643	5	'	'	POS
18637	20643	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20643	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20643	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20643	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20643	10	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	20643	11	,	,	,
18637	20643	12	224	224	CD
18637	20643	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20643	14	148	148	CD
18637	20643	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20643	16	1912	1912	CD
18637	20643	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20643	18	.	.	.
18637	20644	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20644	2	233	233	CD
18637	20644	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20644	4	Panhandle	Panhandle	NNP
18637	20644	5	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	20644	6	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	20644	7	Line	Line	NNP
18637	20644	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20644	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20644	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20644	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20644	12	State	State	NNP
18637	20644	13	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	20644	14	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20644	15	,	,	,
18637	20644	16	294	294	CD
18637	20644	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20644	18	613	613	CD
18637	20644	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20644	20	1935	1935	CD
18637	20644	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20644	22	.	.	.
18637	20645	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20645	2	234	234	CD
18637	20645	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20645	4	New	New	NNP
18637	20645	5	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	20645	6	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20645	7	Light	Light	NNP
18637	20645	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20645	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20645	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20645	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20645	12	Drainage	Drainage	NNP
18637	20645	13	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20645	14	,	,	,
18637	20645	15	197	197	CD
18637	20645	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20645	17	453	453	CD
18637	20645	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20645	19	1905	1905	CD
18637	20645	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20645	21	.	.	.
18637	20646	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20646	2	235	235	CD
18637	20646	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20646	4	Norfolk	Norfolk	NNP
18637	20646	5	&	&	CC
18637	20646	6	S.	S.	NNP
18637	20646	7	Turnpike	Turnpike	NNP
18637	20646	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20646	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20646	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20646	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20646	12	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	20646	13	,	,	,
18637	20646	14	225	225	CD
18637	20646	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20646	16	264	264	CD
18637	20646	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20646	18	1912	1912	CD
18637	20646	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20646	20	.	.	.
18637	20647	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20647	2	236	236	CD
18637	20647	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20647	4	International	International	NNP
18637	20647	5	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	20647	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20647	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20647	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20647	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20647	10	New	New	NNP
18637	20647	11	York	York	NNP
18637	20647	12	,	,	,
18637	20647	13	254	254	CD
18637	20647	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20647	15	126	126	CD
18637	20647	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20647	17	1920	1920	CD
18637	20647	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20647	19	.	.	.
18637	20648	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20648	2	237	237	CD
18637	20648	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20648	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20648	5	,	,	,
18637	20648	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	20649	1	&	&	CC
18637	20649	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	20650	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20650	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20650	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20650	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20650	5	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	20650	6	,	,	,
18637	20650	7	170	170	CD
18637	20650	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20650	9	57	57	CD
18637	20650	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20650	11	1898	1898	CD
18637	20650	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20650	13	.	.	.
18637	20651	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20651	2	238	238	CD
18637	20651	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20651	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20651	5	,	,	,
18637	20651	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	20652	1	&	&	CC
18637	20652	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	20653	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20653	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20653	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20653	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20653	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	20653	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20653	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	20653	8	.	.	.
18637	20654	1	Grimwood	Grimwood	NNP
18637	20654	2	,	,	,
18637	20654	3	200	200	CD
18637	20654	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20654	5	561	561	CD
18637	20654	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20654	7	1906	1906	CD
18637	20654	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20654	9	;	;	:
18637	20654	10	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20654	11	&	&	CC
18637	20654	12	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	20655	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20655	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20655	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20655	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20655	5	Tranbarger	Tranbarger	NNP
18637	20655	6	,	,	,
18637	20655	7	238	238	CD
18637	20655	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20655	9	67	67	CD
18637	20655	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20655	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	20655	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20655	13	;	;	:
18637	20655	14	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	20655	15	Shore	Shore	NNP
18637	20655	16	&	&	CC
18637	20655	17	M.S.R.	M.S.R.	NNP
18637	20656	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20656	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20656	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20656	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20656	5	Clough	Clough	NNP
18637	20656	6	,	,	,
18637	20656	7	242	242	CD
18637	20656	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20656	9	375	375	CD
18637	20656	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20656	11	1917	1917	CD
18637	20656	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20656	13	.	.	.
18637	20657	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20657	2	239	239	CD
18637	20657	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20657	4	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	20657	5	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20657	6	&	&	CC
18637	20657	7	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	20657	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20657	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20657	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20657	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20657	12	Police	Police	NNP
18637	20657	13	Ct	Ct	NNP
18637	20657	14	.	.	NNP
18637	20657	15	,	,	,
18637	20657	16	251	251	CD
18637	20657	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20657	18	22	22	CD
18637	20657	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20657	20	1919	1919	CD
18637	20657	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20657	22	.	.	.
18637	20658	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20658	2	240	240	CD
18637	20658	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20658	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20658	5	,	,	,
18637	20658	6	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20658	7	P.	P.	NNP
18637	20658	8	,	,	,
18637	20658	9	M.	M.	NNP
18637	20658	10	&	&	CC
18637	20658	11	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	20659	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20659	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20659	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20659	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20659	5	Holmberg	Holmberg	NNP
18637	20659	6	,	,	,
18637	20659	7	282	282	CD
18637	20659	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20659	9	162	162	CD
18637	20659	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20659	11	1930	1930	CD
18637	20659	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20659	13	.	.	.
18637	20660	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20660	2	241	241	CD
18637	20660	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20660	4	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	20660	5	,	,	,
18637	20660	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	20660	7	&	&	CC
18637	20660	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20660	9	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	20661	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20661	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20661	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20661	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20661	5	Walters	Walters	NNP
18637	20661	6	,	,	,
18637	20661	7	294	294	CD
18637	20661	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20661	9	405	405	CD
18637	20661	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20661	11	1935	1935	CD
18637	20661	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20661	13	.	.	.
18637	20662	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20662	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20662	3	also	also	RB
18637	20662	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20662	5	Lehigh	Lehigh	NNP
18637	20662	6	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	20662	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20662	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20662	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20662	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20662	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20662	12	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20662	13	Utility	Utility	NNP
18637	20662	14	Comrs	Comrs	NNP
18637	20662	15	.	.	.
18637	20662	16	,	,	,
18637	20662	17	278	278	CD
18637	20662	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20662	19	24	24	CD
18637	20662	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20662	21	1928	1928	CD
18637	20662	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20662	23	.	.	.
18637	20663	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20663	2	242	242	CD
18637	20663	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20663	4	United	United	NNP
18637	20663	5	Fuel	Fuel	NNP
18637	20663	6	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20663	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20663	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20663	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20663	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20663	11	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	20663	12	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20663	13	,	,	,
18637	20663	14	278	278	CD
18637	20663	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20663	16	300	300	CD
18637	20663	17	,	,	,
18637	20663	18	308	308	CD
18637	20663	19	-	-	SYM
18637	20663	20	309	309	CD
18637	20663	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20663	22	1929	1929	CD
18637	20663	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20663	24	.	.	.
18637	20664	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20664	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20664	3	also	also	RB
18637	20664	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20664	5	New	New	NNP
18637	20664	6	York	York	NNP
18637	20664	7	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20664	8	rel	rel	NN
18637	20664	9	.	.	.
18637	20665	1	Woodhaven	Woodhaven	NNP
18637	20665	2	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20665	3	Light	Light	NNP
18637	20665	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20665	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20665	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20665	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20665	8	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20665	9	Service	Service	NNP
18637	20665	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20665	11	,	,	,
18637	20665	12	269	269	CD
18637	20665	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20665	14	244	244	CD
18637	20665	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20665	16	1925	1925	CD
18637	20665	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20665	18	;	;	:
18637	20665	19	New	New	NNP
18637	20665	20	York	York	NNP
18637	20665	21	ex	ex	NN
18637	20665	22	rel	rel	NN
18637	20665	23	.	.	.
18637	20666	1	New	New	NNP
18637	20666	2	York	York	NNP
18637	20666	3	&	&	CC
18637	20666	4	O.	O.	NNP
18637	20667	1	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20667	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20667	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20667	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	20667	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20667	6	McCall	McCall	NNP
18637	20667	7	,	,	,
18637	20667	8	245	245	CD
18637	20667	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20667	10	345	345	CD
18637	20667	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20667	12	1917	1917	CD
18637	20667	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20667	14	.	.	.
18637	20668	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20668	2	243	243	CD
18637	20668	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20668	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20668	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20669	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20669	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20669	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20669	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20669	5	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20669	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20669	7	rel	rel	NNP
18637	20669	8	.	.	.
18637	20670	1	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	20670	2	,	,	,
18637	20670	3	216	216	CD
18637	20670	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20670	5	262	262	CD
18637	20670	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20670	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	20670	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20670	9	;	;	:
18637	20670	10	Chesapeake	Chesapeake	NNP
18637	20670	11	&	&	CC
18637	20670	12	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	20671	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20671	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20671	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20671	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20671	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20671	6	Service	Service	NNP
18637	20671	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20671	8	,	,	,
18637	20671	9	242	242	CD
18637	20671	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20671	11	603	603	CD
18637	20671	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20671	13	1917	1917	CD
18637	20671	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20671	15	;	;	:
18637	20671	16	Ft	Ft	NNP
18637	20671	17	.	.	.
18637	20671	18	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	20671	19	Light	Light	NNP
18637	20671	20	&	&	CC
18637	20671	21	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	20671	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20671	23	_	_	NNP
18637	20671	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	20671	25	_	_	NNP
18637	20671	26	Bourland	Bourland	NNP
18637	20671	27	,	,	,
18637	20671	28	267	267	CD
18637	20671	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20671	30	330	330	CD
18637	20671	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20671	32	1925	1925	CD
18637	20671	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20671	34	.	.	.
18637	20672	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20672	2	244	244	CD
18637	20672	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20672	4	Chesapeake	Chesapeake	NNP
18637	20672	5	&	&	CC
18637	20672	6	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	20673	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20673	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20673	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20673	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20673	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20673	6	Service	Service	NNP
18637	20673	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20673	8	,	,	,
18637	20673	9	242	242	CD
18637	20673	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20673	11	603	603	CD
18637	20673	12	,	,	,
18637	20673	13	607	607	CD
18637	20673	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20673	15	1917	1917	CD
18637	20673	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20673	17	;	;	:
18637	20673	18	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
18637	20673	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	20673	20	Scanlon	Scanlon	NNP
18637	20673	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20673	22	_	_	NNP
18637	20673	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	20673	24	_	_	NNP
18637	20673	25	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	20673	26	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20673	27	,	,	,
18637	20673	28	251	251	CD
18637	20673	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20673	30	396	396	CD
18637	20673	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20673	32	1920	1920	CD
18637	20673	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20673	34	;	;	:
18637	20673	35	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	20673	36	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20673	37	_	_	NNP
18637	20673	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	20673	39	_	_	NNP
18637	20673	40	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	20673	41	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	20673	42	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20673	43	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20673	44	,	,	,
18637	20673	45	264	264	CD
18637	20673	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20673	47	79	79	CD
18637	20673	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20673	49	1924	1924	CD
18637	20673	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20673	51	;	;	:
18637	20673	52	Broad	Broad	NNP
18637	20673	53	River	River	NNP
18637	20673	54	Power	Power	NNP
18637	20673	55	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20673	56	_	_	NNP
18637	20673	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	20673	58	_	_	NNP
18637	20673	59	South	South	NNP
18637	20673	60	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	20673	61	ex	ex	NN
18637	20673	62	rel	rel	NN
18637	20673	63	.	.	.
18637	20674	1	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	20674	2	,	,	,
18637	20674	3	281	281	CD
18637	20674	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20674	5	537	537	CD
18637	20674	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20674	7	1930	1930	CD
18637	20674	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20674	9	.	.	.
18637	20675	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20675	2	245	245	CD
18637	20675	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20675	4	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	20675	5	,	,	,
18637	20675	6	T.	T.	NNP
18637	20675	7	&	&	CC
18637	20675	8	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	20676	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20676	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20676	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20676	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20676	5	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	20676	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20676	7	,	,	,
18637	20676	8	283	283	CD
18637	20676	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20676	10	380	380	CD
18637	20676	11	,	,	,
18637	20676	12	394	394	CD
18637	20676	13	-	-	SYM
18637	20676	14	395	395	CD
18637	20676	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20676	16	1931	1931	CD
18637	20676	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20676	18	.	.	.
18637	20677	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20677	2	246	246	CD
18637	20677	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20677	4	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
18637	20677	5	&	&	CC
18637	20677	6	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20677	7	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	20678	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20678	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20678	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20678	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20678	5	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	20678	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20678	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	20678	8	.	.	.
18637	20679	1	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	20679	2	&	&	CC
18637	20679	3	W.	W.	NNP
18637	20679	4	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20679	5	,	,	,
18637	20679	6	193	193	CD
18637	20679	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20679	8	53	53	CD
18637	20679	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20679	10	1904	1904	CD
18637	20679	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20679	12	.	.	.
18637	20680	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20680	2	247	247	CD
18637	20680	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20680	4	Gladson	Gladson	NNP
18637	20680	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20680	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20680	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20680	8	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	20680	9	,	,	,
18637	20680	10	166	166	CD
18637	20680	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20680	12	427	427	CD
18637	20680	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20680	14	1897	1897	CD
18637	20680	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20680	16	.	.	.
18637	20681	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20681	2	248	248	CD
18637	20681	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20681	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20681	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20682	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20682	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20682	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20682	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20682	5	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20682	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20682	7	rel	rel	NNP
18637	20682	8	.	.	.
18637	20683	1	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	20683	2	,	,	,
18637	20683	3	216	216	CD
18637	20683	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20683	5	262	262	CD
18637	20683	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20683	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	20683	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20683	9	.	.	.
18637	20684	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20684	2	249	249	CD
18637	20684	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20684	4	Chesapeake	Chesapeake	NNP
18637	20684	5	&	&	CC
18637	20684	6	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	20685	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20685	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20685	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20685	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20685	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20685	6	Service	Service	NNP
18637	20685	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20685	8	,	,	,
18637	20685	9	242	242	CD
18637	20685	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20685	11	603	603	CD
18637	20685	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20685	13	1917	1917	CD
18637	20685	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20685	15	.	.	.
18637	20686	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20686	2	250	250	CD
18637	20686	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20686	4	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	20686	5	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	20686	6	&	&	CC
18637	20686	7	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	20686	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20686	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20686	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20686	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20686	12	State	State	NNP
18637	20686	13	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20686	14	Utilities	Utilities	NNPS
18637	20686	15	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20686	16	ex	ex	NN
18637	20686	17	rel	rel	NN
18637	20686	18	.	.	.
18637	20687	1	Cameron	Cameron	NNP
18637	20687	2	,	,	,
18637	20687	3	249	249	CD
18637	20687	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20687	5	422	422	CD
18637	20687	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20687	7	1919	1919	CD
18637	20687	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20687	9	;	;	:
18637	20687	10	Western	Western	NNP
18637	20687	11	&	&	CC
18637	20687	12	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	20688	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20688	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20688	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20688	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20688	5	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	20688	6	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20688	7	Service	Service	NNP
18637	20688	8	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20688	9	,	,	,
18637	20688	10	267	267	CD
18637	20688	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20688	12	493	493	CD
18637	20688	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20688	14	1925	1925	CD
18637	20688	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20688	16	.	.	.
18637	20689	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20689	2	251	251	CD
18637	20689	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20689	4	Alton	Alton	NNP
18637	20689	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20689	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20689	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20689	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20689	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20689	10	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	20689	11	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	20689	12	,	,	,
18637	20689	13	305	305	CD
18637	20689	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20689	15	548	548	CD
18637	20689	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20689	17	1939	1939	CD
18637	20689	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20689	19	.	.	.
18637	20690	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20690	2	252	252	CD
18637	20690	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20690	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20690	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20691	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20691	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20691	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20691	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20691	5	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	20691	6	,	,	,
18637	20691	7	217	217	CD
18637	20691	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20691	9	196	196	CD
18637	20691	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20691	11	1910	1910	CD
18637	20691	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20691	13	.	.	.
18637	20692	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20692	2	253	253	CD
18637	20692	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20692	4	Chesapeake	Chesapeake	NNP
18637	20692	5	&	&	CC
18637	20692	6	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	20693	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20693	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20693	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20693	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20693	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20693	6	Service	Service	NNP
18637	20693	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20693	8	,	,	,
18637	20693	9	242	242	CD
18637	20693	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20693	11	603	603	CD
18637	20693	12	,	,	,
18637	20693	13	607	607	CD
18637	20693	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20693	15	1917	1917	CD
18637	20693	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20693	17	.	.	.
18637	20694	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20694	2	254	254	CD
18637	20694	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20694	4	Great	Great	NNP
18637	20694	5	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	20694	6	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20694	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20694	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20694	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20694	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20694	11	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	20694	12	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20694	13	rel	rel	NN
18637	20694	14	.	.	.
18637	20695	1	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	20695	2	&	&	CC
18637	20695	3	Warehouse	Warehouse	NNP
18637	20695	4	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20695	5	,	,	,
18637	20695	6	238	238	CD
18637	20695	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20695	8	340	340	CD
18637	20695	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20695	10	1915	1915	CD
18637	20695	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20695	12	;	;	:
18637	20695	13	Great	Great	NNP
18637	20695	14	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	20695	15	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20695	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20695	17	_	_	NNP
18637	20695	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	20695	19	_	_	NNP
18637	20695	20	Cahill	Cahill	NNP
18637	20695	21	,	,	,
18637	20695	22	253	253	CD
18637	20695	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20695	24	71	71	CD
18637	20695	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20695	26	1920	1920	CD
18637	20695	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20695	28	.	.	.
18637	20696	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20696	2	255	255	CD
18637	20696	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20696	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20696	5	,	,	,
18637	20696	6	M.	M.	NNP
18637	20696	7	&	&	CC
18637	20696	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20696	9	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20697	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20697	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20697	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20697	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20697	5	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	20697	6	,	,	,
18637	20697	7	238	238	CD
18637	20697	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20697	9	491	491	CD
18637	20697	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20697	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	20697	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20697	13	.	.	.
18637	20698	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20698	2	256	256	CD
18637	20698	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20698	4	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	20698	5	ex	ex	FW
18637	20698	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	20698	7	.	.	.
18637	20699	1	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	20699	2	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20699	3	&	&	CC
18637	20699	4	N.	N.	NNP
18637	20699	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20699	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20699	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20699	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20699	9	Fairchild	Fairchild	NNP
18637	20699	10	,	,	,
18637	20699	11	224	224	CD
18637	20699	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20699	13	510	510	CD
18637	20699	14	,	,	,
18637	20699	15	528	528	CD
18637	20699	16	-	-	SYM
18637	20699	17	529	529	CD
18637	20699	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20699	19	1912	1912	CD
18637	20699	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20699	21	.	.	.
18637	20700	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20700	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20700	3	also	also	RB
18637	20700	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20700	5	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	20700	6	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	20701	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20701	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20701	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20701	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20701	5	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	20701	6	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	20701	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20701	8	,	,	,
18637	20701	9	236	236	CD
18637	20701	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20701	11	615	615	CD
18637	20701	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20701	13	1915	1915	CD
18637	20701	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20701	15	;	;	:
18637	20701	16	Seaboard	Seaboard	NNP
18637	20701	17	Air	Air	NNP
18637	20701	18	Line	Line	NNP
18637	20701	19	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20701	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20701	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20701	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	20701	23	_	_	NNP
18637	20701	24	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	20701	25	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20701	26	,	,	,
18637	20701	27	240	240	CD
18637	20701	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20701	29	324	324	CD
18637	20701	30	,	,	,
18637	20701	31	327	327	CD
18637	20701	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20701	33	1916	1916	CD
18637	20701	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20701	35	.	.	.
18637	20702	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20702	2	257	257	CD
18637	20702	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20702	4	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	20702	5	&	&	CC
18637	20702	6	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	20703	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20703	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20703	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20703	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20703	5	Central	Central	NNP
18637	20703	6	Stockyards	Stockyards	NNPS
18637	20703	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20703	8	,	,	,
18637	20703	9	212	212	CD
18637	20703	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20703	11	132	132	CD
18637	20703	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20703	13	1909	1909	CD
18637	20703	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20703	15	.	.	.
18637	20704	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20704	2	258	258	CD
18637	20704	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20704	4	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	20704	5	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	20705	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20705	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20705	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20705	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20705	5	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	20705	6	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	20705	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20705	8	,	,	,
18637	20705	9	236	236	CD
18637	20705	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20705	11	615	615	CD
18637	20705	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20705	13	1915	1915	CD
18637	20705	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20705	15	.	.	.
18637	20706	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20706	2	259	259	CD
18637	20706	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20706	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20706	5	,	,	,
18637	20706	6	M.	M.	NNP
18637	20706	7	&	&	CC
18637	20706	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20706	9	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20707	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20707	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20707	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20707	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20707	5	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	20707	6	,	,	,
18637	20707	7	233	233	CD
18637	20707	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20707	9	334	334	CD
18637	20707	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20707	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	20707	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20707	13	.	.	.
18637	20708	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20708	2	260	260	CD
18637	20708	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20708	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20708	5	,	,	,
18637	20708	6	M.	M.	NNP
18637	20708	7	&	&	CC
18637	20708	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20708	9	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20709	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20709	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20709	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20709	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20709	5	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
18637	20709	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	20709	7	&	&	CC
18637	20709	8	C.	C.	NNP
18637	20710	1	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	20710	2	.	.	.
18637	20710	3	,	,	,
18637	20710	4	247	247	CD
18637	20710	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20710	6	490	490	CD
18637	20710	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20710	8	1918	1918	CD
18637	20710	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20710	10	.	.	.
18637	20711	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	20711	2	are	be	VBP
18637	20711	3	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	20711	4	denied	deny	VBN
18637	20711	5	due	due	JJ
18637	20711	6	process	process	NN
18637	20711	7	when	when	WRB
18637	20711	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20711	9	are	be	VBP
18637	20711	10	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	20711	11	to	to	TO
18637	20711	12	exact	exact	VB
18637	20711	13	a	a	DT
18637	20711	14	greater	great	JJR
18637	20711	15	charge	charge	NN
18637	20711	16	for	for	IN
18637	20711	17	a	a	DT
18637	20711	18	shorter	short	JJR
18637	20711	19	distance	distance	NN
18637	20711	20	than	than	IN
18637	20711	21	for	for	IN
18637	20711	22	a	a	DT
18637	20711	23	longer	long	JJR
18637	20711	24	distance	distance	NN
18637	20711	25	.	.	.
18637	20712	1	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	20712	2	&	&	CC
18637	20712	3	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	20713	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20713	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20713	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20713	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20713	5	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	20713	6	,	,	,
18637	20713	7	183	183	CD
18637	20713	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20713	9	503	503	CD
18637	20713	10	,	,	,
18637	20713	11	512	512	CD
18637	20713	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20713	13	1902	1902	CD
18637	20713	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20713	15	;	;	:
18637	20713	16	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20713	17	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20714	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20714	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20714	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20714	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20714	5	McGrew	McGrew	NNP
18637	20714	6	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	20714	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20714	8	,	,	,
18637	20714	9	244	244	CD
18637	20714	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20714	11	191	191	CD
18637	20714	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20714	13	1917	1917	CD
18637	20714	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20714	15	.	.	.
18637	20715	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20715	2	261	261	CD
18637	20715	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20715	4	Wadley	Wadley	NNP
18637	20715	5	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	20715	6	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20715	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20715	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20715	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20715	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20715	11	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	20715	12	,	,	,
18637	20715	13	235	235	CD
18637	20715	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20715	15	651	651	CD
18637	20715	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20715	17	1915	1915	CD
18637	20715	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20715	19	.	.	.
18637	20716	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20716	2	262	262	CD
18637	20716	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20716	4	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	20716	5	,	,	,
18637	20716	6	F.	F.	NNP
18637	20716	7	&	&	CC
18637	20716	8	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20717	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20717	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20717	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20717	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20717	5	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	20717	6	,	,	,
18637	20717	7	96	96	CD
18637	20717	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20717	9	521	521	CD
18637	20717	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20717	11	1878	1878	CD
18637	20717	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20717	13	.	.	.
18637	20718	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20718	2	263	263	CD
18637	20718	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20718	4	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	20718	5	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	20718	6	Line	Line	NNP
18637	20718	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20718	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20718	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20718	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20718	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20718	12	Goldsboro	Goldsboro	NNP
18637	20718	13	,	,	,
18637	20718	14	232	232	CD
18637	20718	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20718	16	548	548	CD
18637	20718	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20718	18	1914	1914	CD
18637	20718	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20718	20	.	.	.
18637	20719	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20719	2	264	264	CD
18637	20719	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20719	4	Great	Great	NNP
18637	20719	5	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	20719	6	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20719	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20719	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20719	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20719	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20719	11	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	20719	12	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20719	13	rel	rel	NN
18637	20719	14	.	.	.
18637	20720	1	Clara	Clara	NNP
18637	20720	2	City	City	NNP
18637	20720	3	,	,	,
18637	20720	4	246	246	CD
18637	20720	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20720	6	434	434	CD
18637	20720	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20720	8	1918	1918	CD
18637	20720	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20720	10	.	.	.
18637	20721	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20721	2	265	265	CD
18637	20721	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20721	4	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	20721	5	&	&	CC
18637	20721	6	R.G.R.	R.G.R.	NNP
18637	20722	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20722	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20722	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20722	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20722	5	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	20722	6	,	,	,
18637	20722	7	250	250	CD
18637	20722	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20722	9	241	241	CD
18637	20722	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20722	11	1919	1919	CD
18637	20722	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20722	13	.	.	.
18637	20723	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20723	2	266	266	CD
18637	20723	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20723	4	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	20723	5	,	,	,
18637	20723	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	20723	7	&	&	CC
18637	20723	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20723	9	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	20724	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20724	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20724	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20724	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20724	5	White	White	NNP
18637	20724	6	,	,	,
18637	20724	7	278	278	CD
18637	20724	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20724	9	456	456	CD
18637	20724	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20724	11	1929	1929	CD
18637	20724	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20724	13	.	.	.
18637	20725	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20725	2	267	267	CD
18637	20725	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20725	4	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	20725	5	,	,	,
18637	20725	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	20725	7	&	&	CC
18637	20725	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20725	9	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	20726	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20726	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20726	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20726	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20726	5	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	20726	6	,	,	,
18637	20726	7	128	128	CD
18637	20726	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20726	9	96	96	CD
18637	20726	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20726	11	1888	1888	CD
18637	20726	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20726	13	.	.	.
18637	20727	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20727	2	268	268	CD
18637	20727	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20727	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20727	5	,	,	,
18637	20727	6	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	20727	7	&	&	CC
18637	20727	8	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20728	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20728	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20728	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20728	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20728	5	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	20728	6	,	,	,
18637	20728	7	219	219	CD
18637	20728	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20728	9	453	453	CD
18637	20728	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20728	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	20728	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20728	13	;	;	:
18637	20728	14	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20728	15	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	20728	16	,	,	,
18637	20728	17	I.M.	I.M.	NNP
18637	20729	1	&	&	CC
18637	20729	2	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	20730	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20730	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20730	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20730	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20730	5	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	20730	6	,	,	,
18637	20730	7	240	240	CD
18637	20730	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20730	9	518	518	CD
18637	20730	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20730	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	20730	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20730	13	;	;	:
18637	20730	14	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20730	15	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20731	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20731	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20731	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20731	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20731	5	Norwood	Norwood	NNP
18637	20731	6	,	,	,
18637	20731	7	283	283	CD
18637	20731	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20731	9	249	249	CD
18637	20731	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20731	11	1931	1931	CD
18637	20731	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20731	13	.	.	.
18637	20732	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20732	2	269	269	CD
18637	20732	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20732	4	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	20732	5	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	20732	6	Line	Line	NNP
18637	20732	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20732	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20732	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20732	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20732	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20732	12	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	20732	13	,	,	,
18637	20732	14	234	234	CD
18637	20732	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20732	16	280	280	CD
18637	20732	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20732	18	1914	1914	CD
18637	20732	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20732	20	.	.	.
18637	20733	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20733	2	270	270	CD
18637	20733	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20733	4	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	20733	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20733	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20733	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20733	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20733	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20733	10	Solomon	Solomon	NNP
18637	20733	11	,	,	,
18637	20733	12	237	237	CD
18637	20733	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20733	14	427	427	CD
18637	20733	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20733	16	1915	1915	CD
18637	20733	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20733	18	.	.	.
18637	20734	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20734	2	271	271	CD
18637	20734	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20734	4	New	New	NNP
18637	20734	5	York	York	NNP
18637	20734	6	,	,	,
18637	20734	7	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	20734	8	&	&	CC
18637	20734	9	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	20735	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20735	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20735	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20735	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20735	5	New	New	NNP
18637	20735	6	York	York	NNP
18637	20735	7	,	,	,
18637	20735	8	165	165	CD
18637	20735	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20735	10	628	628	CD
18637	20735	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20735	12	1897	1897	CD
18637	20735	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20735	14	.	.	.
18637	20736	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20736	2	272	272	CD
18637	20736	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20736	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20736	5	&	&	CC
18637	20736	6	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	20737	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20737	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20737	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20737	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20737	5	Nye	Nye	NNP
18637	20737	6	Schneider	Schneider	NNP
18637	20737	7	Fowler	Fowler	NNP
18637	20737	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20737	9	,	,	,
18637	20737	10	260	260	CD
18637	20737	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20737	12	35	35	CD
18637	20737	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20737	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	20737	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20737	16	.	.	.
18637	20738	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20738	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20738	3	also	also	RB
18637	20738	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20738	5	Yazoo	Yazoo	NNP
18637	20738	6	&	&	CC
18637	20738	7	M.V.R.	M.V.R.	NNP
18637	20739	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20739	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20739	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20739	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20739	5	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	20739	6	Vinegar	Vinegar	NNP
18637	20739	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20739	8	,	,	,
18637	20739	9	226	226	CD
18637	20739	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20739	11	217	217	CD
18637	20739	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20739	13	1912	1912	CD
18637	20739	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20739	15	;	;	:
18637	20739	16	_	_	NNP
18637	20739	17	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	20739	18	.	.	.
18637	20739	19	_	_	NNP
18637	20739	20	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	20739	21	Express	Express	NNP
18637	20739	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20739	23	_	_	NNP
18637	20739	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	20739	25	_	_	NNP
18637	20739	26	Croninger	Croninger	NNP
18637	20739	27	,	,	,
18637	20739	28	226	226	CD
18637	20739	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20739	30	491	491	CD
18637	20739	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20739	32	1913	1913	CD
18637	20739	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20739	34	.	.	.
18637	20740	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20740	2	273	273	CD
18637	20740	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20740	4	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	20740	5	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	20740	6	Line	Line	NNP
18637	20740	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20740	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20740	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20740	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20740	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20740	12	Glenn	Glenn	NNP
18637	20740	13	,	,	,
18637	20740	14	239	239	CD
18637	20740	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20740	16	388	388	CD
18637	20740	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20740	18	1915	1915	CD
18637	20740	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20740	20	.	.	.
18637	20741	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20741	2	274	274	CD
18637	20741	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20741	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20741	5	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	20741	6	&	&	CC
18637	20741	7	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	20742	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20742	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20742	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20742	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20742	5	Mathews	Mathews	NNP
18637	20742	6	,	,	,
18637	20742	7	165	165	CD
18637	20742	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20742	9	1	1	CD
18637	20742	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20742	11	1897	1897	CD
18637	20742	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20742	13	.	.	.
18637	20743	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20743	2	275	275	CD
18637	20743	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20743	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20743	5	&	&	CC
18637	20743	6	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	20744	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20744	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20744	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20744	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20744	5	Nye	Nye	NNP
18637	20744	6	Schneider	Schneider	NNP
18637	20744	7	Fowler	Fowler	NNP
18637	20744	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20744	9	,	,	,
18637	20744	10	260	260	CD
18637	20744	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20744	12	35	35	CD
18637	20744	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20744	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	20744	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20744	16	.	.	.
18637	20745	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20745	2	276	276	CD
18637	20745	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20745	4	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20745	5	City	City	NNP
18637	20745	6	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	20745	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20745	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20745	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20745	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20745	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20745	12	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	20745	13	,	,	,
18637	20745	14	233	233	CD
18637	20745	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20745	16	325	325	CD
18637	20745	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20745	18	1914	1914	CD
18637	20745	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20745	20	.	.	.
18637	20746	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20746	2	277	277	CD
18637	20746	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20746	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20746	5	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	20746	6	,	,	,
18637	20746	7	I.M.	I.M.	NNP
18637	20747	1	&	&	CC
18637	20747	2	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	20748	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20748	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20748	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20748	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20748	5	Wynne	Wynne	NNP
18637	20748	6	,	,	,
18637	20748	7	224	224	CD
18637	20748	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20748	9	354	354	CD
18637	20748	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20748	11	1912	1912	CD
18637	20748	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20748	13	.	.	.
18637	20749	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20749	2	278	278	CD
18637	20749	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20749	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20749	5	,	,	,
18637	20749	6	M.	M.	NNP
18637	20749	7	&	&	CC
18637	20749	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20749	9	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20750	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20750	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20750	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20750	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20750	5	Polt	Polt	NNP
18637	20750	6	,	,	,
18637	20750	7	232	232	CD
18637	20750	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20750	9	165	165	CD
18637	20750	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20750	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	20750	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20750	13	.	.	.
18637	20751	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20751	2	279	279	CD
18637	20751	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20751	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20751	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20752	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20752	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20752	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20752	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20752	5	Tucker	Tucker	NNP
18637	20752	6	,	,	,
18637	20752	7	230	230	CD
18637	20752	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20752	9	340	340	CD
18637	20752	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20752	11	1913	1913	CD
18637	20752	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20752	13	.	.	.
18637	20753	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20753	2	280	280	CD
18637	20753	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20753	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20753	5	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	20753	6	,	,	,
18637	20753	7	I.M.	I.M.	NNP
18637	20754	1	&	&	CC
18637	20754	2	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	20755	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20755	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20755	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20755	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20755	5	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	20755	6	,	,	,
18637	20755	7	251	251	CD
18637	20755	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20755	9	63	63	CD
18637	20755	10	,	,	,
18637	20755	11	67	67	CD
18637	20755	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20755	13	1919	1919	CD
18637	20755	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20755	15	.	.	.
18637	20756	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20756	2	281	281	CD
18637	20756	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20756	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20756	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	20757	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20757	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20757	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20757	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20757	5	Humes	Humes	NNP
18637	20757	6	,	,	,
18637	20757	7	115	115	CD
18637	20757	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20757	9	512	512	CD
18637	20757	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20757	11	1885	1885	CD
18637	20757	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20757	13	;	;	:
18637	20757	14	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
18637	20757	15	&	&	CC
18637	20757	16	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20757	17	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	20758	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20758	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20758	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20758	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20758	5	Beckwith	Beckwith	NNP
18637	20758	6	,	,	,
18637	20758	7	129	129	CD
18637	20758	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20758	9	26	26	CD
18637	20758	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20758	11	1889	1889	CD
18637	20758	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20758	13	.	.	.
18637	20759	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20759	2	282	282	CD
18637	20759	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20759	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20759	5	,	,	,
18637	20759	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	20760	1	&	&	CC
18637	20760	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	20761	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20761	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20761	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20761	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20761	5	Cram	Cram	NNP
18637	20761	6	,	,	,
18637	20761	7	228	228	CD
18637	20761	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20761	9	70	70	CD
18637	20761	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20761	11	1913	1913	CD
18637	20761	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20761	13	.	.	.
18637	20762	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20762	2	283	283	CD
18637	20762	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20762	4	Southwestern	Southwestern	NNP
18637	20762	5	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	20762	6	.	.	.
18637	20763	1	&	&	CC
18637	20763	2	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	20763	3	.	.	.
18637	20764	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20764	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20764	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20764	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20764	5	Danaher	Danaher	NNP
18637	20764	6	,	,	,
18637	20764	7	238	238	CD
18637	20764	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20764	9	482	482	CD
18637	20764	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20764	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	20764	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20764	13	.	.	.
18637	20765	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20765	2	284	284	CD
18637	20765	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20765	4	New	New	NNP
18637	20765	5	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	20765	6	Debenture	Debenture	NNP
18637	20765	7	Redemption	Redemption	NNP
18637	20765	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20765	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20765	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20765	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20765	12	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	20765	13	,	,	,
18637	20765	14	180	180	CD
18637	20765	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20765	16	320	320	CD
18637	20765	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20765	18	1901	1901	CD
18637	20765	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20765	20	.	.	.
18637	20766	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20766	2	285	285	CD
18637	20766	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20766	4	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	20766	5	Shore	Shore	NNP
18637	20766	6	&	&	CC
18637	20766	7	M.S.R.	M.S.R.	NNP
18637	20767	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20767	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20767	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20767	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20767	5	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	20767	6	,	,	,
18637	20767	7	173	173	CD
18637	20767	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20767	9	684	684	CD
18637	20767	10	,	,	,
18637	20767	11	698	698	CD
18637	20767	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20767	13	1899	1899	CD
18637	20767	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20767	15	.	.	.
18637	20768	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20768	2	286	286	CD
18637	20768	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20768	4	National	National	NNP
18637	20768	5	Council	Council	NNP
18637	20768	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20768	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20768	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20768	9	State	State	NNP
18637	20768	10	Council	Council	NNP
18637	20768	11	,	,	,
18637	20768	12	203	203	CD
18637	20768	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20768	14	151	151	CD
18637	20768	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20768	16	1906	1906	CD
18637	20768	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20768	18	.	.	.
18637	20769	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20769	2	287	287	CD
18637	20769	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20769	4	Munday	Munday	NNP
18637	20769	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20769	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20769	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20769	8	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	20769	9	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	20769	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20769	11	,	,	,
18637	20769	12	252	252	CD
18637	20769	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20769	14	499	499	CD
18637	20769	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20769	16	1920	1920	CD
18637	20769	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20769	18	.	.	.
18637	20770	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20770	2	288	288	CD
18637	20770	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20770	4	State	State	NNP
18637	20770	5	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	20770	6	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20770	7	.	.	.
18637	20771	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20771	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20771	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20771	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20771	5	Duel	Duel	NNP
18637	20771	6	,	,	,
18637	20771	7	324	324	CD
18637	20771	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20771	9	154	154	CD
18637	20771	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20771	11	1945	1945	CD
18637	20771	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20771	13	.	.	.
18637	20772	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20772	2	289	289	CD
18637	20772	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20772	4	Asbury	Asbury	NNP
18637	20772	5	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	20772	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20772	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20772	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20772	9	Cass	Cass	NNP
18637	20772	10	County	County	NNP
18637	20772	11	,	,	,
18637	20772	12	326	326	CD
18637	20772	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20772	14	207	207	CD
18637	20772	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20772	16	1945	1945	CD
18637	20772	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20772	18	.	.	.
18637	20773	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20773	2	290	290	CD
18637	20773	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20773	4	Nebbia	Nebbia	NNP
18637	20773	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20773	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20773	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20773	8	New	New	NNP
18637	20773	9	York	York	NNP
18637	20773	10	,	,	,
18637	20773	11	291	291	CD
18637	20773	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20773	13	502	502	CD
18637	20773	14	,	,	,
18637	20773	15	527	527	CD
18637	20773	16	-	-	SYM
18637	20773	17	528	528	CD
18637	20773	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20773	19	1934	1934	CD
18637	20773	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20773	21	.	.	.
18637	20774	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20774	2	291	291	CD
18637	20774	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20774	4	Smiley	Smiley	NNP
18637	20774	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20774	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20774	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20774	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20774	9	,	,	,
18637	20774	10	196	196	CD
18637	20774	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20774	12	447	447	CD
18637	20774	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20774	14	1905	1905	CD
18637	20774	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20774	16	.	.	.
18637	20775	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20775	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20775	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20775	4	Waters	Waters	NNP
18637	20775	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	20775	6	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	20775	7	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	20775	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20775	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20775	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20775	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20775	12	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	20775	13	,	,	,
18637	20775	14	212	212	CD
18637	20775	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20775	16	86	86	CD
18637	20775	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20775	18	1909	1909	CD
18637	20775	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20775	20	;	;	:
18637	20775	21	National	National	NNP
18637	20775	22	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	20775	23	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	20775	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20775	25	_	_	NNP
18637	20775	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	20775	27	_	_	NNP
18637	20775	28	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	20775	29	,	,	,
18637	20775	30	197	197	CD
18637	20775	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20775	32	115	115	CD
18637	20775	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20775	34	1905	1905	CD
18637	20775	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20775	36	,	,	,
18637	20775	37	also	also	RB
18637	20775	38	upholding	uphold	VBG
18637	20775	39	antitrust	antitrust	JJ
18637	20775	40	laws	law	NNS
18637	20775	41	.	.	.
18637	20776	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20776	2	292	292	CD
18637	20776	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20776	4	International	International	NNP
18637	20776	5	Harvester	Harvester	NNP
18637	20776	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20776	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20776	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20776	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20776	10	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20776	11	,	,	,
18637	20776	12	234	234	CD
18637	20776	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20776	14	199	199	CD
18637	20776	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20776	16	1914	1914	CD
18637	20776	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20776	18	.	.	.
18637	20777	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20777	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20777	3	also	also	RB
18637	20777	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20777	5	American	American	NNP
18637	20777	6	Seeding	Seeding	NNP
18637	20777	7	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	20777	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20777	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20777	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20777	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20777	12	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	20777	13	,	,	,
18637	20777	14	236	236	CD
18637	20777	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20777	16	660	660	CD
18637	20777	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20777	18	1915	1915	CD
18637	20777	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20777	20	.	.	.
18637	20778	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20778	2	293	293	CD
18637	20778	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20778	4	Grenada	Grenada	NNP
18637	20778	5	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	20778	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20778	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20778	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20778	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20778	10	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	20778	11	,	,	,
18637	20778	12	217	217	CD
18637	20778	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20778	14	433	433	CD
18637	20778	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20778	16	1910	1910	CD
18637	20778	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20778	18	.	.	.
18637	20779	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20779	2	294	294	CD
18637	20779	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20779	4	Aikens	Aikens	NNPS
18637	20779	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20779	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20779	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20779	8	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	20779	9	,	,	,
18637	20779	10	195	195	CD
18637	20779	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20779	12	194	194	CD
18637	20779	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20779	14	1904	1904	CD
18637	20779	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20779	16	.	.	.
18637	20780	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20780	2	295	295	CD
18637	20780	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20780	4	Central	Central	NNP
18637	20780	5	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	20780	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20780	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20780	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20780	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20780	10	South	South	NNP
18637	20780	11	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	20780	12	,	,	,
18637	20780	13	226	226	CD
18637	20780	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20780	15	157	157	CD
18637	20780	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20780	17	1912	1912	CD
18637	20780	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20780	19	.	.	.
18637	20781	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20781	2	296	296	CD
18637	20781	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20781	4	Fairmont	Fairmont	NNP
18637	20781	5	Creamery	Creamery	NNP
18637	20781	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20781	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20781	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20781	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20781	10	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	20781	11	,	,	,
18637	20781	12	274	274	CD
18637	20781	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20781	14	1	1	CD
18637	20781	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20781	16	1927	1927	CD
18637	20781	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20781	18	.	.	.
18637	20782	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20782	2	297	297	CD
18637	20782	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20782	4	Old	Old	NNP
18637	20782	5	Dearborn	Dearborn	NNP
18637	20782	6	Distributing	Distributing	NNP
18637	20782	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20782	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20782	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20782	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20782	11	Seagram	Seagram	NNP
18637	20782	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	20782	13	Distillers	Distillers	NNP
18637	20782	14	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	20782	15	,	,	,
18637	20782	16	299	299	CD
18637	20782	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20782	18	183	183	CD
18637	20782	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20782	20	1936	1936	CD
18637	20782	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20782	22	;	;	:
18637	20782	23	The	the	DT
18637	20782	24	Pep	Pep	NNP
18637	20782	25	Boys	Boys	NNPS
18637	20782	26	_	_	NNP
18637	20782	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	20782	28	_	_	NNP
18637	20782	29	Pyroil	Pyroil	NNP
18637	20782	30	Sales	Sales	NNP
18637	20782	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20782	32	,	,	,
18637	20782	33	299	299	CD
18637	20782	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20782	35	198	198	CD
18637	20782	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20782	37	1936	1936	CD
18637	20782	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20782	39	.	.	.
18637	20783	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20783	2	298	298	CD
18637	20783	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20783	4	Schmidinger	Schmidinger	NNP
18637	20783	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20783	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20783	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20783	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20783	9	,	,	,
18637	20783	10	226	226	CD
18637	20783	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20783	12	578	578	CD
18637	20783	13	,	,	,
18637	20783	14	588	588	CD
18637	20783	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20783	16	1913	1913	CD
18637	20783	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20783	18	,	,	,
18637	20783	19	citing	cite	VBG
18637	20783	20	McLean	McLean	NNP
18637	20783	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20783	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	20783	23	_	_	NNP
18637	20783	24	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	20783	25	,	,	,
18637	20783	26	211	211	CD
18637	20783	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20783	28	539	539	CD
18637	20783	29	,	,	,
18637	20783	30	550	550	CD
18637	20783	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20783	32	1909	1909	CD
18637	20783	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20783	34	.	.	.
18637	20784	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20784	2	299	299	CD
18637	20784	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20784	4	Merchants	Merchants	NNPS
18637	20784	5	Exch	Exch	NNP
18637	20784	6	.	.	.
18637	20785	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20785	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20785	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20785	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20785	5	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20785	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	20785	7	.	.	.
18637	20786	1	Barker	Barker	NNP
18637	20786	2	,	,	,
18637	20786	3	248	248	CD
18637	20786	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20786	5	365	365	CD
18637	20786	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20786	7	1919	1919	CD
18637	20786	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20786	9	.	.	.
18637	20787	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20787	2	300	300	CD
18637	20787	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20787	4	Hauge	Hauge	NNP
18637	20787	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20787	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20787	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20787	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20787	9	,	,	,
18637	20787	10	299	299	CD
18637	20787	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20787	12	387	387	CD
18637	20787	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20787	14	1937	1937	CD
18637	20787	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20787	16	.	.	.
18637	20788	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20788	2	301	301	CD
18637	20788	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20788	4	Lemieux	Lemieux	NNP
18637	20788	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20788	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20788	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20788	8	Young	Young	NNP
18637	20788	9	,	,	,
18637	20788	10	211	211	CD
18637	20788	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20788	12	489	489	CD
18637	20788	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20788	14	1909	1909	CD
18637	20788	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20788	16	;	;	:
18637	20788	17	Kidd	Kidd	NNP
18637	20788	18	,	,	,
18637	20788	19	D.	D.	NNP
18637	20788	20	&	&	CC
18637	20788	21	P.	P.	NNP
18637	20788	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20788	23	_	_	NNP
18637	20788	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	20788	25	_	_	NNP
18637	20788	26	Musselman	Musselman	NNP
18637	20788	27	Grocer	Grocer	NNP
18637	20788	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20788	29	,	,	,
18637	20788	30	217	217	CD
18637	20788	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20788	32	461	461	CD
18637	20788	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20788	34	1910	1910	CD
18637	20788	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20788	36	.	.	.
18637	20789	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20789	2	302	302	CD
18637	20789	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20789	4	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	20789	5	States	States	NNPS
18637	20789	6	Box	Box	NNP
18637	20789	7	&	&	CC
18637	20789	8	Basket	Basket	NNP
18637	20789	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20789	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20789	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	20789	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20789	13	White	White	NNP
18637	20789	14	,	,	,
18637	20789	15	296	296	CD
18637	20789	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20789	17	176	176	CD
18637	20789	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20789	19	1935	1935	CD
18637	20789	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20789	21	.	.	.
18637	20790	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20790	2	303	303	CD
18637	20790	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20790	4	Schmidinger	Schmidinger	NNP
18637	20790	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20790	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20790	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20790	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20790	9	,	,	,
18637	20790	10	226	226	CD
18637	20790	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20790	12	578	578	CD
18637	20790	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20790	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	20790	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20790	16	.	.	.
18637	20791	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20791	2	304	304	CD
18637	20791	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20791	4	Burns	Burns	NNP
18637	20791	5	Baking	Baking	NNP
18637	20791	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20791	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20791	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20791	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20791	10	Bryan	Bryan	NNP
18637	20791	11	,	,	,
18637	20791	12	264	264	CD
18637	20791	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20791	14	504	504	CD
18637	20791	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20791	16	1924	1924	CD
18637	20791	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20791	18	.	.	.
18637	20792	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20792	2	305	305	CD
18637	20792	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20792	4	Petersen	Petersen	NNP
18637	20792	5	Baking	Baking	NNP
18637	20792	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20792	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20792	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20792	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20792	10	Bryan	Bryan	NNP
18637	20792	11	,	,	,
18637	20792	12	290	290	CD
18637	20792	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20792	14	570	570	CD
18637	20792	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20792	16	1934	1934	CD
18637	20792	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20792	18	.	.	.
18637	20793	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20793	2	306	306	CD
18637	20793	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20793	4	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	20793	5	&	&	CC
18637	20793	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20793	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20793	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20793	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20793	10	North	North	NNP
18637	20793	11	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	20793	12	,	,	,
18637	20793	13	240	240	CD
18637	20793	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20793	15	510	510	CD
18637	20793	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20793	17	1916	1916	CD
18637	20793	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20793	19	.	.	.
18637	20794	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20794	2	307	307	CD
18637	20794	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20794	4	Heath	Heath	NNP
18637	20794	5	&	&	CC
18637	20794	6	M.	M.	NNP
18637	20794	7	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	20794	8	.	.	.
18637	20795	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20795	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20795	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20795	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20795	5	Worst	Worst	NNP
18637	20795	6	,	,	,
18637	20795	7	207	207	CD
18637	20795	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20795	9	338	338	CD
18637	20795	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20795	11	1907	1907	CD
18637	20795	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20795	13	;	;	:
18637	20795	14	Corn	Corn	NNP
18637	20795	15	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	20795	16	Ref	Ref	NNP
18637	20795	17	.	.	.
18637	20796	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20796	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20796	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20796	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20796	5	Eddy	Eddy	NNP
18637	20796	6	,	,	,
18637	20796	7	249	249	CD
18637	20796	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20796	9	427	427	CD
18637	20796	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20796	11	1919	1919	CD
18637	20796	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20796	13	;	;	:
18637	20796	14	National	National	NNP
18637	20796	15	Fertilizer	Fertilizer	NNP
18637	20796	16	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	20796	17	.	.	.
18637	20797	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20797	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20797	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20797	4	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	20797	5	,	,	,
18637	20797	6	301	301	CD
18637	20797	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20797	8	178	178	CD
18637	20797	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20797	10	1937	1937	CD
18637	20797	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20797	12	.	.	.
18637	20798	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20798	2	308	308	CD
18637	20798	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20798	4	Advance	advance	NN
18637	20798	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	20798	6	Rumely	Rumely	NNP
18637	20798	7	Thresher	Thresher	NNP
18637	20798	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20798	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20798	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20798	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20798	12	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	20798	13	,	,	,
18637	20798	14	287	287	CD
18637	20798	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20798	16	283	283	CD
18637	20798	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20798	18	1932	1932	CD
18637	20798	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20798	20	.	.	.
18637	20799	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20799	2	309	309	CD
18637	20799	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20799	4	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	20799	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20799	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20799	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20799	8	Geiger	Geiger	NNP
18637	20799	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	20799	10	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	20799	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20799	12	,	,	,
18637	20799	13	242	242	CD
18637	20799	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20799	15	539	539	CD
18637	20799	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20799	17	1917	1917	CD
18637	20799	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20799	19	;	;	:
18637	20799	20	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	20799	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20799	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	20799	23	_	_	NNP
18637	20799	24	Sioux	Sioux	NNP
18637	20799	25	Falls	Falls	NNP
18637	20799	26	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	20799	27	Yards	Yards	NNP
18637	20799	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20799	29	,	,	,
18637	20799	30	242	242	CD
18637	20799	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20799	32	559	559	CD
18637	20799	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20799	34	1917	1917	CD
18637	20799	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20799	36	;	;	:
18637	20799	37	Merrick	Merrick	NNP
18637	20799	38	_	_	NNP
18637	20799	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	20799	40	_	_	NNP
18637	20799	41	Halsey	Halsey	NNP
18637	20799	42	&	&	CC
18637	20799	43	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20799	44	,	,	,
18637	20799	45	242	242	CD
18637	20799	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20799	47	568	568	CD
18637	20799	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20799	49	1917	1917	CD
18637	20799	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20799	51	.	.	.
18637	20800	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20800	2	310	310	CD
18637	20800	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20800	4	Booth	Booth	NNP
18637	20800	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20800	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20800	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20800	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	20800	9	,	,	,
18637	20800	10	184	184	CD
18637	20800	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20800	12	425	425	CD
18637	20800	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20800	14	1902	1902	CD
18637	20800	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20800	16	.	.	.
18637	20801	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20801	2	311	311	CD
18637	20801	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20801	4	Otis	Otis	NNP
18637	20801	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20801	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20801	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20801	8	Parker	Parker	NNP
18637	20801	9	,	,	,
18637	20801	10	187	187	CD
18637	20801	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20801	12	606	606	CD
18637	20801	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20801	14	1903	1903	CD
18637	20801	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20801	16	.	.	.
18637	20802	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20802	2	312	312	CD
18637	20802	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20802	4	Brodnax	Brodnax	NNP
18637	20802	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20802	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20802	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20802	8	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	20802	9	,	,	,
18637	20802	10	219	219	CD
18637	20802	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20802	12	285	285	CD
18637	20802	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20802	14	1911	1911	CD
18637	20802	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20802	16	.	.	.
18637	20803	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20803	2	313	313	CD
18637	20803	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20803	4	House	House	NNP
18637	20803	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20803	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20803	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20803	8	Mayes	Mayes	NNP
18637	20803	9	,	,	,
18637	20803	10	219	219	CD
18637	20803	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20803	12	270	270	CD
18637	20803	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20803	14	1911	1911	CD
18637	20803	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20803	16	.	.	.
18637	20804	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20804	2	314	314	CD
18637	20804	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20804	4	Rast	Rast	NNP
18637	20804	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20804	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20804	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20804	8	Van	Van	NNP
18637	20804	9	Deman	Deman	NNP
18637	20804	10	&	&	CC
18637	20804	11	L.	L.	NNP
18637	20804	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20804	13	,	,	,
18637	20804	14	240	240	CD
18637	20804	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20804	16	342	342	CD
18637	20804	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20804	18	1916	1916	CD
18637	20804	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20804	20	;	;	:
18637	20804	21	Tanner	Tanner	NNP
18637	20804	22	_	_	NNP
18637	20804	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	20804	24	_	_	NNP
18637	20804	25	Little	Little	NNP
18637	20804	26	,	,	,
18637	20804	27	240	240	CD
18637	20804	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20804	29	369	369	CD
18637	20804	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20804	31	1916	1916	CD
18637	20804	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20804	33	;	;	:
18637	20804	34	Pitney	Pitney	NNP
18637	20804	35	_	_	NNP
18637	20804	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	20804	37	_	_	NNP
18637	20804	38	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	20804	39	,	,	,
18637	20804	40	240	240	CD
18637	20804	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20804	42	387	387	CD
18637	20804	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20804	44	1916	1916	CD
18637	20804	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20804	46	.	.	.
18637	20805	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20805	2	315	315	CD
18637	20805	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20805	4	Noble	Noble	NNP
18637	20805	5	State	State	NNP
18637	20805	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	20805	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20805	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20805	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20805	10	Haskell	Haskell	NNP
18637	20805	11	,	,	,
18637	20805	12	219	219	CD
18637	20805	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20805	14	104	104	CD
18637	20805	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20805	16	1911	1911	CD
18637	20805	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20805	18	;	;	:
18637	20805	19	Shallenberger	Shallenberger	NNP
18637	20805	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20805	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	20805	22	_	_	NNP
18637	20805	23	First	First	NNP
18637	20805	24	State	State	NNP
18637	20805	25	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	20805	26	,	,	,
18637	20805	27	219	219	CD
18637	20805	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20805	29	114	114	CD
18637	20805	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20805	31	1911	1911	CD
18637	20805	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20805	33	;	;	:
18637	20805	34	Assaria	Assaria	NNP
18637	20805	35	State	State	NNP
18637	20805	36	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	20805	37	_	_	NNP
18637	20805	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	20805	39	_	_	NNP
18637	20805	40	Dolley	Dolley	NNP
18637	20805	41	,	,	,
18637	20805	42	219	219	CD
18637	20805	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20805	44	121	121	CD
18637	20805	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20805	46	1911	1911	CD
18637	20805	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20805	48	;	;	:
18637	20805	49	Abie	Abie	NNP
18637	20805	50	State	State	NNP
18637	20805	51	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	20805	52	_	_	NNP
18637	20805	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	20805	54	_	_	NNP
18637	20805	55	Bryan	Bryan	NNP
18637	20805	56	,	,	,
18637	20805	57	282	282	CD
18637	20805	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20805	59	765	765	CD
18637	20805	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20805	61	1931	1931	CD
18637	20805	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20805	63	.	.	.
18637	20806	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20806	2	316	316	CD
18637	20806	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20806	4	Provident	Provident	NNP
18637	20806	5	Inst	Inst	NNP
18637	20806	6	.	.	.
18637	20807	1	for	for	IN
18637	20807	2	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	20807	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20807	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	20807	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20807	6	Malone	Malone	NNP
18637	20807	7	,	,	,
18637	20807	8	221	221	CD
18637	20807	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20807	10	660	660	CD
18637	20807	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20807	12	1911	1911	CD
18637	20807	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20807	14	;	;	:
18637	20807	15	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	20807	16	National	National	NNP
18637	20807	17	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	20807	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20807	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	20807	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20807	21	Luckett	Luckett	NNP
18637	20807	22	,	,	,
18637	20807	23	321	321	CD
18637	20807	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20807	25	233	233	CD
18637	20807	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20807	27	1944	1944	CD
18637	20807	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20807	29	.	.	.
18637	20808	1	When	when	WRB
18637	20808	2	a	a	DT
18637	20808	3	bank	bank	NN
18637	20808	4	conservator	conservator	NN
18637	20808	5	appointed	appoint	VBD
18637	20808	6	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	20808	7	to	to	IN
18637	20808	8	a	a	DT
18637	20808	9	new	new	JJ
18637	20808	10	statute	statute	NN
18637	20808	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	20808	12	all	all	PDT
18637	20808	13	the	the	DT
18637	20808	14	functions	function	NNS
18637	20808	15	of	of	IN
18637	20808	16	a	a	DT
18637	20808	17	receiver	receiver	NN
18637	20808	18	under	under	IN
18637	20808	19	the	the	DT
18637	20808	20	old	old	JJ
18637	20808	21	law	law	NN
18637	20808	22	,	,	,
18637	20808	23	one	one	CD
18637	20808	24	of	of	IN
18637	20808	25	which	which	WDT
18637	20808	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	20808	27	the	the	DT
18637	20808	28	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	20808	29	on	on	IN
18637	20808	30	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	20808	31	of	of	IN
18637	20808	32	depositors	depositor	NNS
18637	20808	33	of	of	IN
18637	20808	34	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	20808	35	'	'	POS
18637	20808	36	liability	liability	NN
18637	20808	37	,	,	,
18637	20808	38	which	which	WDT
18637	20808	39	liability	liability	NN
18637	20808	40	the	the	DT
18637	20808	41	conservator	conservator	NN
18637	20808	42	can	can	MD
18637	20808	43	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	20808	44	as	as	RB
18637	20808	45	cheaply	cheaply	RB
18637	20808	46	as	as	IN
18637	20808	47	could	could	MD
18637	20808	48	a	a	DT
18637	20808	49	receiver	receiver	NN
18637	20808	50	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	20808	51	under	under	IN
18637	20808	52	the	the	DT
18637	20808	53	pre	pre	JJ
18637	20808	54	-	-	JJ
18637	20808	55	existing	exist	VBG
18637	20808	56	statute	statute	NN
18637	20808	57	,	,	,
18637	20808	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20808	59	can	can	MD
18637	20808	60	not	not	RB
18637	20808	61	be	be	VB
18637	20808	62	said	say	VBN
18637	20808	63	that	that	IN
18637	20808	64	the	the	DT
18637	20808	65	new	new	JJ
18637	20808	66	statute	statute	NN
18637	20808	67	,	,	,
18637	20808	68	in	in	IN
18637	20808	69	suspending	suspend	VBG
18637	20808	70	the	the	DT
18637	20808	71	right	right	NN
18637	20808	72	of	of	IN
18637	20808	73	a	a	DT
18637	20808	74	depositor	depositor	NN
18637	20808	75	to	to	TO
18637	20808	76	have	have	VB
18637	20808	77	a	a	DT
18637	20808	78	receiver	receiver	NN
18637	20808	79	appointed	appoint	VBN
18637	20808	80	,	,	,
18637	20808	81	arbitrarily	arbitrarily	RB
18637	20808	82	deprives	deprive	VBZ
18637	20808	83	a	a	DT
18637	20808	84	depositor	depositor	NN
18637	20808	85	of	of	IN
18637	20808	86	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20808	87	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	20808	88	or	or	CC
18637	20808	89	destroys	destroy	VBZ
18637	20808	90	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	20808	91	property	property	NN
18637	20808	92	without	without	IN
18637	20808	93	due	due	JJ
18637	20808	94	process	process	NN
18637	20808	95	of	of	IN
18637	20808	96	law	law	NN
18637	20808	97	.	.	.
18637	20809	1	The	the	DT
18637	20809	2	depositor	depositor	NN
18637	20809	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	20809	4	no	no	DT
18637	20809	5	property	property	NN
18637	20809	6	right	right	RB
18637	20809	7	in	in	IN
18637	20809	8	any	any	DT
18637	20809	9	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	20809	10	form	form	NN
18637	20809	11	of	of	IN
18637	20809	12	remedy.--Gibbes	remedy.--gibbes	CD
18637	20809	13	_	_	NNP
18637	20809	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	20809	15	_	_	NNP
18637	20809	16	Zimmerman	Zimmerman	NNP
18637	20809	17	,	,	,
18637	20809	18	290	290	CD
18637	20809	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20809	20	326	326	CD
18637	20809	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20809	22	1933	1933	CD
18637	20809	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20809	24	.	.	.
18637	20810	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20810	2	317	317	CD
18637	20810	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20810	4	Doty	Doty	NNP
18637	20810	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20810	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20810	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20810	8	Love	Love	NNP
18637	20810	9	,	,	,
18637	20810	10	295	295	CD
18637	20810	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20810	12	64	64	CD
18637	20810	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20810	14	1935	1935	CD
18637	20810	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20810	16	.	.	.
18637	20811	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20811	2	318	318	CD
18637	20811	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20811	4	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	20811	5	&	&	CC
18637	20811	6	M.	M.	NNP
18637	20811	7	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	20811	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20811	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20811	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20811	11	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	20811	12	Reserve	Reserve	NNP
18637	20811	13	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	20811	14	,	,	,
18637	20811	15	262	262	CD
18637	20811	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20811	17	649	649	CD
18637	20811	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20811	19	1923	1923	CD
18637	20811	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20811	21	.	.	.
18637	20812	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20812	2	319	319	CD
18637	20812	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20812	4	Griffith	Griffith	NNP
18637	20812	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20812	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20812	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20812	8	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	20812	9	,	,	,
18637	20812	10	218	218	CD
18637	20812	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20812	12	563	563	CD
18637	20812	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20812	14	1910	1910	CD
18637	20812	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20812	16	.	.	.
18637	20813	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20813	2	320	320	CD
18637	20813	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20813	4	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	20813	5	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	20813	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20813	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20813	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20813	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20813	10	Martell	Martell	NNP
18637	20813	11	,	,	,
18637	20813	12	222	222	CD
18637	20813	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20813	14	225	225	CD
18637	20813	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20813	16	1911	1911	CD
18637	20813	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20813	18	.	.	.
18637	20814	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20814	2	321	321	CD
18637	20814	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20814	4	La	La	NNP
18637	20814	5	Tourette	Tourette	NNP
18637	20814	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20814	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20814	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20814	9	McMaster	McMaster	NNP
18637	20814	10	,	,	,
18637	20814	11	248	248	CD
18637	20814	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20814	13	465	465	CD
18637	20814	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20814	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	20814	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20814	17	;	;	:
18637	20814	18	Stipcich	Stipcich	NNP
18637	20814	19	_	_	NNP
18637	20814	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	20814	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20814	22	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
18637	20814	23	L.	L.	NNP
18637	20814	24	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20814	25	.	.	.
18637	20815	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20815	2	,	,	,
18637	20815	3	277	277	CD
18637	20815	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20815	5	311	311	CD
18637	20815	6	,	,	,
18637	20815	7	320	320	CD
18637	20815	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20815	9	1928	1928	CD
18637	20815	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20815	11	.	.	.
18637	20816	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20816	2	322	322	CD
18637	20816	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20816	4	German	German	NNP
18637	20816	5	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	20816	6	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20816	7	.	.	.
18637	20817	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20817	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20817	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20817	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20817	5	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	20817	6	,	,	,
18637	20817	7	233	233	CD
18637	20817	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20817	9	389	389	CD
18637	20817	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20817	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	20817	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20817	13	.	.	.
18637	20818	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20818	2	323	323	CD
18637	20818	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20818	4	O'Gorman	O'Gorman	NNP
18637	20818	5	and	and	CC
18637	20818	6	Young	Young	NNP
18637	20818	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20818	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20818	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20818	10	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	20818	11	Insur	Insur	NNP
18637	20818	12	.	.	.
18637	20819	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20819	2	,	,	,
18637	20819	3	282	282	CD
18637	20819	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20819	5	251	251	CD
18637	20819	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20819	7	1931	1931	CD
18637	20819	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20819	9	.	.	.
18637	20820	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20820	2	324	324	CD
18637	20820	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20820	4	Nutting	Nutting	NNP
18637	20820	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20820	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20820	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20820	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	20820	9	,	,	,
18637	20820	10	185	185	CD
18637	20820	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20820	12	553	553	CD
18637	20820	13	,	,	,
18637	20820	14	556	556	CD
18637	20820	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20820	16	1902	1902	CD
18637	20820	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20820	18	,	,	,
18637	20820	19	distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
18637	20820	20	Allgeyer	Allgeyer	NNP
18637	20820	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20820	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	20820	23	_	_	NNP
18637	20820	24	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	20820	25	,	,	,
18637	20820	26	165	165	CD
18637	20820	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20820	28	578	578	CD
18637	20820	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20820	30	1897	1897	CD
18637	20820	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20820	32	.	.	.
18637	20821	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20821	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20821	3	also	also	RB
18637	20821	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20821	5	Hooper	Hooper	NNP
18637	20821	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20821	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20821	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20821	9	California	California	NNP
18637	20821	10	,	,	,
18637	20821	11	155	155	CD
18637	20821	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20821	13	648	648	CD
18637	20821	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20821	15	1895	1895	CD
18637	20821	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20821	17	.	.	.
18637	20822	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20822	2	325	325	CD
18637	20822	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20822	4	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	20822	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20822	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20822	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20822	8	Family	Family	NNP
18637	20822	9	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20822	10	.	.	.
18637	20823	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20823	2	,	,	,
18637	20823	3	336	336	CD
18637	20823	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20823	5	220	220	CD
18637	20823	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20823	7	1949	1949	CD
18637	20823	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20823	9	.	.	.
18637	20824	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20824	2	326	326	CD
18637	20824	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20824	4	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	20824	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20824	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20824	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20824	8	Ozlin	Ozlin	NNP
18637	20824	9	,	,	,
18637	20824	10	310	310	CD
18637	20824	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20824	12	53	53	CD
18637	20824	13	,	,	,
18637	20824	14	68	68	CD
18637	20824	15	-	-	SYM
18637	20824	16	69	69	CD
18637	20824	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20824	18	1940	1940	CD
18637	20824	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20824	20	.	.	.
18637	20825	1	Dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	20825	2	from	from	IN
18637	20825	3	the	the	DT
18637	20825	4	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	20825	5	,	,	,
18637	20825	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20825	7	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	20825	8	declared	declare	VBD
18637	20825	9	that	that	IN
18637	20825	10	the	the	DT
18637	20825	11	plain	plain	JJ
18637	20825	12	effect	effect	NN
18637	20825	13	of	of	IN
18637	20825	14	the	the	DT
18637	20825	15	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	20825	16	law	law	NN
18637	20825	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	20825	18	to	to	TO
18637	20825	19	compel	compel	VB
18637	20825	20	a	a	DT
18637	20825	21	nonresident	nonresident	NN
18637	20825	22	to	to	TO
18637	20825	23	pay	pay	VB
18637	20825	24	a	a	DT
18637	20825	25	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	20825	26	resident	resident	NN
18637	20825	27	for	for	IN
18637	20825	28	services	service	NNS
18637	20825	29	which	which	WDT
18637	20825	30	the	the	DT
18637	20825	31	latter	latter	JJ
18637	20825	32	does	do	VBZ
18637	20825	33	not	not	RB
18637	20825	34	in	in	IN
18637	20825	35	fact	fact	NN
18637	20825	36	render	render	NN
18637	20825	37	.	.	.
18637	20826	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20826	2	327	327	CD
18637	20826	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20826	4	California	California	NNP
18637	20826	5	Auto	Auto	NNP
18637	20826	6	.	.	.
18637	20827	1	Assn	assn	UH
18637	20827	2	.	.	.
18637	20828	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20828	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20828	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20828	4	Maloney	Maloney	NNP
18637	20828	5	,	,	,
18637	20828	6	341	341	CD
18637	20828	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20828	8	105	105	CD
18637	20828	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20828	10	1951	1951	CD
18637	20828	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20828	12	.	.	.
18637	20829	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20829	2	328	328	CD
18637	20829	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20829	4	Allgeyer	Allgeyer	NNP
18637	20829	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20829	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20829	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20829	8	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	20829	9	,	,	,
18637	20829	10	165	165	CD
18637	20829	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20829	12	578	578	CD
18637	20829	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20829	14	1897	1897	CD
18637	20829	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20829	16	.	.	.
18637	20830	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20830	2	329	329	CD
18637	20830	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20830	4	New	New	NNP
18637	20830	5	York	York	NNP
18637	20830	6	L.	L.	NNP
18637	20830	7	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20830	8	.	.	.
18637	20831	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20831	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20831	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20831	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20831	5	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	20831	6	,	,	,
18637	20831	7	246	246	CD
18637	20831	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20831	9	357	357	CD
18637	20831	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20831	11	1918	1918	CD
18637	20831	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20831	13	.	.	.
18637	20832	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20832	2	330	330	CD
18637	20832	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20832	4	National	National	NNP
18637	20832	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	20832	6	F.	F.	NNP
18637	20832	7	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20832	8	.	.	.
18637	20833	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20833	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20833	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20833	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20833	5	Wanberg	Wanberg	NNP
18637	20833	6	,	,	,
18637	20833	7	260	260	CD
18637	20833	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20833	9	71	71	CD
18637	20833	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20833	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	20833	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20833	13	.	.	.
18637	20834	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20834	2	331	331	CD
18637	20834	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20834	4	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	20834	5	Acci	Acci	NNP
18637	20834	6	.	.	.
18637	20835	1	&	&	CC
18637	20835	2	Indem	Indem	NNP
18637	20835	3	.	.	.
18637	20836	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20836	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20836	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20836	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20836	5	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	20836	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20836	7	N.O.	N.O.	NNP
18637	20836	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20837	1	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	20837	2	.	.	.
18637	20838	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20838	2	,	,	,
18637	20838	3	291	291	CD
18637	20838	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20838	5	352	352	CD
18637	20838	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20838	7	1934	1934	CD
18637	20838	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20838	9	.	.	.
18637	20839	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20839	2	332	332	CD
18637	20839	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20839	4	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	20839	5	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	20839	6	.	.	.
18637	20840	1	Auto	Auto	NNP
18637	20840	2	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	20840	3	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20840	4	.	.	.
18637	20841	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20841	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20841	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20841	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20841	5	Smart	Smart	NNP
18637	20841	6	,	,	,
18637	20841	7	267	267	CD
18637	20841	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20841	9	126	126	CD
18637	20841	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20841	11	1925	1925	CD
18637	20841	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20841	13	.	.	.
18637	20842	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20842	2	333	333	CD
18637	20842	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20842	4	Orient	Orient	NNP
18637	20842	5	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20842	6	.	.	.
18637	20843	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20843	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20843	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20843	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20843	5	Daggs	Daggs	NNP
18637	20843	6	,	,	,
18637	20843	7	172	172	CD
18637	20843	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20843	9	557	557	CD
18637	20843	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20843	11	1899	1899	CD
18637	20843	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20843	13	.	.	.
18637	20844	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20844	2	334	334	CD
18637	20844	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20844	4	Hoopeston	Hoopeston	NNP
18637	20844	5	Canning	Canning	NNP
18637	20844	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20844	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20844	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20844	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20844	10	Cullen	Cullen	NNP
18637	20844	11	,	,	,
18637	20844	12	318	318	CD
18637	20844	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20844	14	313	313	CD
18637	20844	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20844	16	1943	1943	CD
18637	20844	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20844	18	.	.	.
18637	20845	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20845	2	335	335	CD
18637	20845	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20845	4	German	German	NNP
18637	20845	5	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	20845	6	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20845	7	.	.	.
18637	20846	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20846	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20846	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20846	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20846	5	Hale	Hale	NNP
18637	20846	6	,	,	,
18637	20846	7	219	219	CD
18637	20846	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20846	9	307	307	CD
18637	20846	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20846	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	20846	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20846	13	.	.	.
18637	20847	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20847	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20847	3	also	also	RB
18637	20847	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20847	5	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	20847	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20847	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20847	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20847	9	Greenwich	Greenwich	NNP
18637	20847	10	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20847	11	.	.	.
18637	20848	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20848	2	,	,	,
18637	20848	3	199	199	CD
18637	20848	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20848	5	401	401	CD
18637	20848	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20848	7	1905	1905	CD
18637	20848	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20848	9	.	.	.
18637	20849	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20849	2	336	336	CD
18637	20849	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20849	4	Life	Life	NNP
18637	20849	5	&	&	CC
18637	20849	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	20849	7	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20849	8	.	.	.
18637	20850	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20850	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20850	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20850	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20850	5	McCray	McCray	NNP
18637	20850	6	,	,	,
18637	20850	7	291	291	CD
18637	20850	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20850	9	566	566	CD
18637	20850	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20850	11	1934	1934	CD
18637	20850	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20850	13	.	.	.
18637	20851	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20851	2	337	337	CD
18637	20851	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20851	4	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	20851	5	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	20851	6	.	.	.
18637	20852	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	20852	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20852	3	.	.	.
18637	20853	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20853	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20853	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20853	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20853	5	Riggs	Riggs	NNP
18637	20853	6	,	,	,
18637	20853	7	203	203	CD
18637	20853	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20853	9	243	243	CD
18637	20853	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20853	11	1906	1906	CD
18637	20853	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20853	13	.	.	.
18637	20854	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20854	2	338	338	CD
18637	20854	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20854	4	Whitfield	Whitfield	NNP
18637	20854	5	ex	ex	NN
18637	20854	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	20854	7	.	.	.
18637	20855	1	Hadley	Hadley	NNP
18637	20855	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20855	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20855	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20855	5	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	20855	6	L.	L.	NNP
18637	20855	7	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20855	8	.	.	.
18637	20856	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20856	2	,	,	,
18637	20856	3	205	205	CD
18637	20856	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20856	5	489	489	CD
18637	20856	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20856	7	1907	1907	CD
18637	20856	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20856	9	.	.	.
18637	20857	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20857	2	339	339	CD
18637	20857	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20857	4	Polk	Polk	NNP
18637	20857	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20857	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20857	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20857	8	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	20857	9	Reserve	Reserve	NNP
18637	20857	10	Fund	Fund	NNP
18637	20857	11	Life	Life	NNP
18637	20857	12	Association	Association	NNP
18637	20857	13	,	,	,
18637	20857	14	207	207	CD
18637	20857	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20857	16	310	310	CD
18637	20857	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20857	18	1907	1907	CD
18637	20857	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20857	20	.	.	.
18637	20858	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20858	2	340	340	CD
18637	20858	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20858	4	Neblett	Neblett	NNP
18637	20858	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20858	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20858	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20858	8	Carpenter	Carpenter	NNP
18637	20858	9	,	,	,
18637	20858	10	305	305	CD
18637	20858	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20858	12	297	297	CD
18637	20858	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20858	14	1938	1938	CD
18637	20858	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20858	16	.	.	.
18637	20859	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20859	2	341	341	CD
18637	20859	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20859	4	Brazee	Brazee	NNP
18637	20859	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20859	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20859	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20859	8	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	20859	9	,	,	,
18637	20859	10	241	241	CD
18637	20859	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20859	12	340	340	CD
18637	20859	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20859	14	1916).--With	1916).--with	CD
18637	20859	15	four	four	CD
18637	20859	16	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	20859	17	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	20859	18	,	,	,
18637	20859	19	the	the	DT
18637	20859	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	20859	21	,	,	,
18637	20859	22	in	in	IN
18637	20859	23	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	20859	24	_	_	NNP
18637	20859	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	20859	26	_	_	NNP
18637	20859	27	Tanner	Tanner	NNP
18637	20859	28	,	,	,
18637	20859	29	244	244	CD
18637	20859	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20859	31	590	590	CD
18637	20859	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20859	33	1917	1917	CD
18637	20859	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20859	35	,	,	,
18637	20859	36	"	"	''
18637	20859	37	struck	strike	VBD
18637	20859	38	down	down	RP
18637	20859	39	a	a	DT
18637	20859	40	State	State	NNP
18637	20859	41	law	law	NN
18637	20859	42	absolutely	absolutely	RB
18637	20859	43	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	20859	44	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	20859	45	of	of	IN
18637	20859	46	private	private	JJ
18637	20859	47	employment	employment	NN
18637	20859	48	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	20859	49	.	.	.
18637	20859	50	"	"	''
18637	20860	1	Commenting	comment	VBG
18637	20860	2	on	on	IN
18637	20860	3	the	the	DT
18637	20860	4	"	"	``
18637	20860	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	20860	6	philosophy	philosophy	NN
18637	20860	7	"	"	''
18637	20860	8	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	20860	9	in	in	IN
18637	20860	10	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	20860	11	Union	Union	NNP
18637	20860	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20860	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	20860	14	_	_	NNP
18637	20860	15	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	20860	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20860	17	,	,	,
18637	20860	18	335	335	CD
18637	20860	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20860	20	525	525	CD
18637	20860	21	,	,	,
18637	20860	22	535	535	CD
18637	20860	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20860	24	1949	1949	CD
18637	20860	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20860	26	,	,	,
18637	20860	27	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20860	28	Black	Black	NNP
18637	20860	29	stated	state	VBD
18637	20860	30	that	that	IN
18637	20860	31	Olsen	Olsen	NNP
18637	20860	32	_	_	NNP
18637	20860	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	20860	34	_	_	NNP
18637	20860	35	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	20860	36	,	,	,
18637	20860	37	313	313	CD
18637	20860	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20860	39	236	236	CD
18637	20860	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20860	41	1941	1941	CD
18637	20860	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20860	43	,	,	,
18637	20860	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20860	45	_	_	NNP
18637	20860	46	see	see	VBP
18637	20860	47	_	_	NNP
18637	20860	48	p.	p.	NN
18637	20860	49	997	997	CD
18637	20860	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20860	51	"	"	''
18637	20860	52	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	20860	53	undermined	undermine	VBN
18637	20860	54	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	20860	55	_	_	NNP
18637	20860	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	20860	57	_	_	NNP
18637	20860	58	Tanner	Tanner	NNP
18637	20860	59	.	.	.
18637	20860	60	"	"	''
18637	20861	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20861	2	342	342	CD
18637	20861	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20861	4	Liggett	Liggett	NNP
18637	20861	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20861	6	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	20861	7	K.	K.	NNP
18637	20861	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20861	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20861	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20861	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	20861	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20861	13	Baldridge	Baldridge	NNP
18637	20861	14	,	,	,
18637	20861	15	278	278	CD
18637	20861	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20861	17	105	105	CD
18637	20861	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20861	19	1928	1928	CD
18637	20861	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20861	21	.	.	.
18637	20862	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20862	2	343	343	CD
18637	20862	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20862	4	McNaughton	McNaughton	NNP
18637	20862	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20862	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20862	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20862	8	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	20862	9	,	,	,
18637	20862	10	242	242	CD
18637	20862	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20862	12	344	344	CD
18637	20862	13	,	,	,
18637	20862	14	349	349	CD
18637	20862	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20862	16	1917	1917	CD
18637	20862	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20862	18	.	.	.
18637	20863	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20863	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20863	3	also	also	RB
18637	20863	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20863	5	Dent	Dent	NNP
18637	20863	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20863	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20863	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20863	9	West	West	NNP
18637	20863	10	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	20863	11	,	,	,
18637	20863	12	129	129	CD
18637	20863	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20863	14	114	114	CD
18637	20863	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20863	16	1889	1889	CD
18637	20863	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20863	18	;	;	:
18637	20863	19	Hawker	Hawker	NNP
18637	20863	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20863	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	20863	22	_	_	NNP
18637	20863	23	New	New	NNP
18637	20863	24	York	York	NNP
18637	20863	25	,	,	,
18637	20863	26	170	170	CD
18637	20863	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20863	28	189	189	CD
18637	20863	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20863	30	1898	1898	CD
18637	20863	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20863	32	;	;	:
18637	20863	33	Reetz	Reetz	NNP
18637	20863	34	_	_	NNP
18637	20863	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	20863	36	_	_	NNP
18637	20863	37	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	20863	38	,	,	,
18637	20863	39	188	188	CD
18637	20863	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20863	41	505	505	CD
18637	20863	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20863	43	1903	1903	CD
18637	20863	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20863	45	;	;	:
18637	20863	46	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	20863	47	_	_	NNP
18637	20863	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	20863	49	_	_	NNP
18637	20863	50	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	20863	51	,	,	,
18637	20863	52	218	218	CD
18637	20863	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20863	54	173	173	CD
18637	20863	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20863	56	1910	1910	CD
18637	20863	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20863	58	.	.	.
18637	20864	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20864	2	344	344	CD
18637	20864	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20864	4	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	20864	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20864	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20864	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20864	8	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	20864	9	,	,	,
18637	20864	10	223	223	CD
18637	20864	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20864	12	288	288	CD
18637	20864	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20864	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	20864	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20864	16	;	;	:
18637	20864	17	Hayman	Hayman	NNP
18637	20864	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20864	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	20864	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20864	21	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	20864	22	,	,	,
18637	20864	23	273	273	CD
18637	20864	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20864	25	414	414	CD
18637	20864	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20864	27	1927	1927	CD
18637	20864	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20864	29	.	.	.
18637	20865	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20865	2	345	345	CD
18637	20865	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20865	4	Semler	Semler	NNP
18637	20865	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20865	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20865	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20865	8	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	20865	9	State	State	NNP
18637	20865	10	Dental	Dental	NNP
18637	20865	11	Examiners	Examiners	NNPS
18637	20865	12	,	,	,
18637	20865	13	294	294	CD
18637	20865	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20865	15	608	608	CD
18637	20865	16	,	,	,
18637	20865	17	611	611	CD
18637	20865	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20865	19	1935	1935	CD
18637	20865	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20865	21	.	.	.
18637	20866	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20866	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20866	3	also	also	RB
18637	20866	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20866	5	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	20866	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20866	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20866	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20866	9	Noble	Noble	NNP
18637	20866	10	,	,	,
18637	20866	11	261	261	CD
18637	20866	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20866	13	165	165	CD
18637	20866	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20866	15	1923	1923	CD
18637	20866	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20866	17	;	;	:
18637	20866	18	Graves	Graves	NNPS
18637	20866	19	_	_	NNP
18637	20866	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	20866	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20866	22	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	20866	23	,	,	,
18637	20866	24	272	272	CD
18637	20866	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20866	26	425	425	CD
18637	20866	27	,	,	,
18637	20866	28	427	427	CD
18637	20866	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20866	30	1926	1926	CD
18637	20866	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20866	32	.	.	.
18637	20867	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20867	2	346	346	CD
18637	20867	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20867	4	Olsen	Olsen	NNP
18637	20867	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20867	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20867	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20867	8	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	20867	9	,	,	,
18637	20867	10	195	195	CD
18637	20867	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20867	12	332	332	CD
18637	20867	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20867	14	1904	1904	CD
18637	20867	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20867	16	.	.	.
18637	20868	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20868	2	347	347	CD
18637	20868	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20868	4	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	20868	5	,	,	,
18637	20868	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	20868	7	&	&	CC
18637	20868	8	.	.	.
18637	20869	1	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20869	2	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	20870	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20870	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20870	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20870	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20870	5	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	20870	6	,	,	,
18637	20870	7	128	128	CD
18637	20870	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20870	9	96	96	CD
18637	20870	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20870	11	1888	1888	CD
18637	20870	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20870	13	.	.	.
18637	20871	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20871	2	348	348	CD
18637	20871	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20871	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	20871	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20871	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20871	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20871	8	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	20871	9	,	,	,
18637	20871	10	233	233	CD
18637	20871	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20871	12	630	630	CD
18637	20871	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20871	14	1914	1914	CD
18637	20871	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20871	16	.	.	.
18637	20872	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20872	2	349	349	CD
18637	20872	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20872	4	Western	western	JJ
18637	20872	5	Turf	Turf	NNP
18637	20872	6	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	20872	7	.	.	.
18637	20873	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20873	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	20873	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20873	4	Greenberg	Greenberg	NNP
18637	20873	5	,	,	,
18637	20873	6	204	204	CD
18637	20873	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20873	8	359	359	CD
18637	20873	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20873	10	1907	1907	CD
18637	20873	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20873	12	.	.	.
18637	20874	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20874	2	350	350	CD
18637	20874	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20874	4	Cargill	Cargill	NNP
18637	20874	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20874	6	W.W.	W.W.	NNP
18637	20874	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20874	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20874	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20874	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20874	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20874	12	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	20874	13	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20874	14	rel	rel	NN
18637	20874	15	.	.	.
18637	20875	1	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	20875	2	&	&	CC
18637	20875	3	W.	W.	NNP
18637	20875	4	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20875	5	,	,	,
18637	20875	6	180	180	CD
18637	20875	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20875	8	452	452	CD
18637	20875	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20875	10	1901	1901	CD
18637	20875	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20875	12	.	.	.
18637	20876	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20876	2	351	351	CD
18637	20876	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20876	4	Lehon	Lehon	NNP
18637	20876	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20876	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20876	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20876	8	Atlanta	Atlanta	NNP
18637	20876	9	,	,	,
18637	20876	10	242	242	CD
18637	20876	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20876	12	53	53	CD
18637	20876	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20876	14	1916	1916	CD
18637	20876	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20876	16	.	.	.
18637	20877	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20877	2	352	352	CD
18637	20877	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20877	4	Gundling	Gundling	NNP
18637	20877	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20877	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20877	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20877	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20877	9	,	,	,
18637	20877	10	177	177	CD
18637	20877	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20877	12	183	183	CD
18637	20877	13	,	,	,
18637	20877	14	185	185	CD
18637	20877	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20877	16	1900	1900	CD
18637	20877	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20877	18	.	.	.
18637	20878	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20878	2	353	353	CD
18637	20878	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20878	4	Bourjois	Bourjois	NNP
18637	20878	5	,	,	,
18637	20878	6	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	20878	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20878	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20878	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20878	10	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	20878	11	,	,	,
18637	20878	12	301	301	CD
18637	20878	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20878	14	183	183	CD
18637	20878	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20878	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	20878	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20878	18	.	.	.
18637	20879	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20879	2	354	354	CD
18637	20879	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20879	4	Weller	Weller	NNP
18637	20879	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20879	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20879	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20879	8	New	New	NNP
18637	20879	9	York	York	NNP
18637	20879	10	,	,	,
18637	20879	11	268	268	CD
18637	20879	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20879	13	319	319	CD
18637	20879	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20879	15	1925	1925	CD
18637	20879	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20879	17	.	.	.
18637	20880	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20880	2	355	355	LS
18637	20880	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20880	4	Packer	Packer	NNP
18637	20880	5	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	20880	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20880	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20880	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20880	9	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	20880	10	,	,	,
18637	20880	11	285	285	CD
18637	20880	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20880	13	105	105	CD
18637	20880	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20880	15	1932	1932	CD
18637	20880	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20880	17	.	.	.
18637	20881	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20881	2	356	356	CD
18637	20881	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20881	4	Halter	Halter	NNP
18637	20881	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20881	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20881	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20881	8	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	20881	9	,	,	,
18637	20881	10	205	205	CD
18637	20881	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20881	12	34	34	CD
18637	20881	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20881	14	1907	1907	CD
18637	20881	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20881	16	.	.	.
18637	20882	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20882	2	357	357	CD
18637	20882	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20882	4	McCloskey	McCloskey	NNP
18637	20882	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20882	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20882	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20882	8	Tobin	Tobin	NNP
18637	20882	9	,	,	,
18637	20882	10	252	252	CD
18637	20882	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20882	12	107	107	CD
18637	20882	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20882	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	20882	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20882	16	.	.	.
18637	20883	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20883	2	358	358	CD
18637	20883	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20883	4	Natal	Natal	NNP
18637	20883	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20883	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20883	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20883	8	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	20883	9	,	,	,
18637	20883	10	139	139	CD
18637	20883	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20883	12	621	621	CD
18637	20883	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20883	14	1891	1891	CD
18637	20883	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20883	16	.	.	.
18637	20884	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20884	2	359	359	CD
18637	20884	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20884	4	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	20884	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20884	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20884	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20884	8	California	California	NNP
18637	20884	9	,	,	,
18637	20884	10	225	225	CD
18637	20884	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20884	12	623	623	CD
18637	20884	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20884	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	20884	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20884	16	.	.	.
18637	20885	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20885	2	360	360	CD
18637	20885	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20885	4	Rosenthal	Rosenthal	NNP
18637	20885	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20885	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20885	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20885	8	New	New	NNP
18637	20885	9	York	York	NNP
18637	20885	10	,	,	,
18637	20885	11	226	226	CD
18637	20885	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20885	13	260	260	CD
18637	20885	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20885	15	1912	1912	CD
18637	20885	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20885	17	.	.	.
18637	20886	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20886	2	361	361	CD
18637	20886	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20886	4	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	20886	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20886	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20886	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20886	8	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	20886	9	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20886	10	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	20886	11	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	20886	12	,	,	,
18637	20886	13	300	300	CD
18637	20886	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20886	15	55	55	CD
18637	20886	16	,	,	,
18637	20886	17	76	76	CD
18637	20886	18	-	-	SYM
18637	20886	19	77	77	CD
18637	20886	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20886	21	1937	1937	CD
18637	20886	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20886	23	,	,	,
18637	20886	24	citing	cite	VBG
18637	20886	25	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	20886	26	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	20886	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20886	28	_	_	NNP
18637	20886	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	20886	30	_	_	NNP
18637	20886	31	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	20886	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20886	33	No	no	UH
18637	20886	34	.	.	.
18637	20887	1	1	1	LS
18637	20887	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20887	3	,	,	,
18637	20887	4	177	177	CD
18637	20887	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20887	6	100	100	CD
18637	20887	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20887	8	1900	1900	CD
18637	20887	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20887	10	;	;	:
18637	20887	11	Lindsley	Lindsley	NNP
18637	20887	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20887	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	20887	14	_	_	NNP
18637	20887	15	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	20887	16	Carbonic	Carbonic	NNP
18637	20887	17	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20887	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20887	19	,	,	,
18637	20887	20	220	220	CD
18637	20887	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20887	22	61	61	CD
18637	20887	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20887	24	1911	1911	CD
18637	20887	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20887	26	;	;	:
18637	20887	27	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	20887	28	_	_	NNP
18637	20887	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	20887	30	_	_	NNP
18637	20887	31	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20887	32	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	20887	33	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20887	34	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20887	35	,	,	,
18637	20887	36	221	221	CD
18637	20887	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20887	38	229	229	CD
18637	20887	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20887	40	1911	1911	CD
18637	20887	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20887	42	.	.	.
18637	20888	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20888	2	362	362	CD
18637	20888	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20888	4	Champlin	Champlin	NNP
18637	20888	5	Ref	Ref	NNP
18637	20888	6	.	.	.
18637	20889	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20889	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20889	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20889	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20889	5	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	20889	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20889	7	,	,	,
18637	20889	8	286	286	CD
18637	20889	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20889	10	210	210	CD
18637	20889	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20889	12	1932	1932	CD
18637	20889	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20889	14	.	.	.
18637	20890	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20890	2	363	363	CD
18637	20890	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20890	4	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	20890	5	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20890	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20890	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20890	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20890	9	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	20890	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20890	11	,	,	,
18637	20890	12	310	310	CD
18637	20890	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20890	14	573	573	CD
18637	20890	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20890	16	1940	1940	CD
18637	20890	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20890	18	.	.	.
18637	20891	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20891	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20891	3	also	also	RB
18637	20891	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20891	5	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	20892	1	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20892	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20892	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20892	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20892	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	20892	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20892	7	,	,	,
18637	20892	8	311	311	CD
18637	20892	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20892	10	570	570	CD
18637	20892	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20892	12	1941	1941	CD
18637	20892	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20892	14	;	;	:
18637	20892	15	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	20893	1	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20893	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20893	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20893	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20893	5	Humble	Humble	NNP
18637	20893	6	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	20893	7	&	&	CC
18637	20893	8	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	20893	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20893	10	,	,	,
18637	20893	11	311	311	CD
18637	20893	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20893	13	578	578	CD
18637	20893	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20893	15	1941	1941	CD
18637	20893	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20893	17	.	.	.
18637	20894	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20894	2	364	364	CD
18637	20894	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20894	4	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	20894	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20894	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20894	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20894	8	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	20894	9	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	20894	10	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	20894	11	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	20894	12	,	,	,
18637	20894	13	300	300	CD
18637	20894	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20894	15	55	55	CD
18637	20894	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20894	17	1937	1937	CD
18637	20894	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20894	19	.	.	.
18637	20895	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20895	2	365	365	CD
18637	20895	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20895	4	Cities	Cities	NNP
18637	20895	5	Service	Service	NNP
18637	20895	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20895	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20895	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20895	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20895	10	Peerless	Peerless	NNP
18637	20895	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20895	12	,	,	,
18637	20895	13	340	340	CD
18637	20895	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20895	15	179	179	CD
18637	20895	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20895	17	1950	1950	CD
18637	20895	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20895	19	;	;	:
18637	20895	20	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	20895	21	Petroleum	Petroleum	NNP
18637	20895	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20895	23	_	_	NNP
18637	20895	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	20895	25	_	_	NNP
18637	20895	26	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	20895	27	,	,	,
18637	20895	28	ibid	ibid	NNP
18637	20895	29	.	.	.
18637	20895	30	,	,	,
18637	20895	31	190	190	CD
18637	20895	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20895	33	1950	1950	CD
18637	20895	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20895	35	.	.	.
18637	20896	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20896	2	366	366	CD
18637	20896	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20896	4	Walls	Walls	NNP
18637	20896	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20896	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20896	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20896	8	Midland	Midland	NNP
18637	20896	9	Carbon	Carbon	NNP
18637	20896	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20896	11	,	,	,
18637	20896	12	254	254	CD
18637	20896	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20896	14	300	300	CD
18637	20896	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20896	16	1920	1920	CD
18637	20896	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20896	18	.	.	.
18637	20897	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20897	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20897	3	also	also	RB
18637	20897	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20897	5	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	20897	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20897	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20897	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20897	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20897	10	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	20897	11	,	,	,
18637	20897	12	300	300	CD
18637	20897	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20897	14	258	258	CD
18637	20897	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20897	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	20897	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20897	18	.	.	.
18637	20898	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20898	2	367	367	CD
18637	20898	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20898	4	Bandini	Bandini	NNP
18637	20898	5	Petroleum	Petroleum	NNP
18637	20898	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20898	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20898	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20898	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20898	10	Superior	Superior	NNP
18637	20898	11	Ct	Ct	NNP
18637	20898	12	.	.	NNP
18637	20898	13	,	,	,
18637	20898	14	284	284	CD
18637	20898	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20898	16	8	8	CD
18637	20898	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20898	18	1931	1931	CD
18637	20898	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20898	20	.	.	.
18637	20899	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20899	2	368	368	CD
18637	20899	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20899	4	Gant	Gant	NNP
18637	20899	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20899	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20899	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20899	8	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	20899	9	City	City	NNP
18637	20899	10	,	,	,
18637	20899	11	289	289	CD
18637	20899	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20899	13	98	98	CD
18637	20899	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20899	15	1933	1933	CD
18637	20899	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20899	17	.	.	.
18637	20900	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20900	2	369	369	CD
18637	20900	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20900	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	20900	5	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	20900	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20900	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20900	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20900	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20900	10	Mahon	Mahon	NNP
18637	20900	11	,	,	,
18637	20900	12	260	260	CD
18637	20900	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20900	14	393	393	CD
18637	20900	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20900	16	1922	1922	CD
18637	20900	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20900	18	.	.	.
18637	20901	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20901	2	370	370	CD
18637	20901	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20901	4	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	20901	5	County	County	NNP
18637	20901	6	Water	Water	NNP
18637	20901	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20901	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20901	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20901	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20901	11	McCarter	McCarter	NNP
18637	20901	12	,	,	,
18637	20901	13	209	209	CD
18637	20901	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20901	15	349	349	CD
18637	20901	16	,	,	,
18637	20901	17	356	356	CD
18637	20901	18	-	-	SYM
18637	20901	19	357	357	CD
18637	20901	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20901	21	1908	1908	CD
18637	20901	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20901	23	.	.	.
18637	20902	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20902	2	371	371	CD
18637	20902	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20902	4	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	20902	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20902	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20902	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20902	8	Schoene	Schoene	NNP
18637	20902	9	,	,	,
18637	20902	10	276	276	CD
18637	20902	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20902	12	272	272	CD
18637	20902	13	,	,	,
18637	20902	14	277	277	CD
18637	20902	15	,	,	,
18637	20902	16	279	279	CD
18637	20902	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20902	18	1928	1928	CD
18637	20902	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20902	20	.	.	.
18637	20903	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20903	2	372	372	CD
18637	20903	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20903	4	Sligh	Sligh	NNP
18637	20903	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20903	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20903	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20903	8	Kirkwood	Kirkwood	NNP
18637	20903	9	,	,	,
18637	20903	10	237	237	CD
18637	20903	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20903	12	52	52	CD
18637	20903	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20903	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	20903	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20903	16	.	.	.
18637	20904	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20904	2	373	373	CD
18637	20904	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20904	4	Bayside	Bayside	NNP
18637	20904	5	Fish	Fish	NNP
18637	20904	6	Flour	Flour	NNP
18637	20904	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20904	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20904	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20904	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20904	11	Gentry	Gentry	NNP
18637	20904	12	,	,	,
18637	20904	13	297	297	CD
18637	20904	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20904	15	422	422	CD
18637	20904	16	,	,	,
18637	20904	17	426	426	CD
18637	20904	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20904	19	1936	1936	CD
18637	20904	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20904	21	.	.	.
18637	20905	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20905	2	374	374	CD
18637	20905	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20905	4	Manchester	Manchester	NNP
18637	20905	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20905	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20905	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20905	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	20905	9	,	,	,
18637	20905	10	139	139	CD
18637	20905	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20905	12	240	240	CD
18637	20905	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20905	14	1891	1891	CD
18637	20905	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20905	16	;	;	:
18637	20905	17	Geer	Geer	NNP
18637	20905	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20905	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	20905	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20905	21	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	20905	22	,	,	,
18637	20905	23	161	161	CD
18637	20905	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20905	25	519	519	CD
18637	20905	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20905	27	1896	1896	CD
18637	20905	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20905	29	.	.	.
18637	20906	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20906	2	375	375	CD
18637	20906	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20906	4	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	20906	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20906	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20906	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20906	8	McLaughlin	McLaughlin	NNP
18637	20906	9	,	,	,
18637	20906	10	281	281	CD
18637	20906	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20906	12	261	261	CD
18637	20906	13	,	,	,
18637	20906	14	264	264	CD
18637	20906	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20906	16	1930	1930	CD
18637	20906	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20906	18	.	.	.
18637	20907	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20907	2	376	376	CD
18637	20907	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20907	4	Bayside	Bayside	NNP
18637	20907	5	Fish	Fish	NNP
18637	20907	6	Flour	Flour	NNP
18637	20907	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20907	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20907	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20907	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20907	11	Gentry	Gentry	NNP
18637	20907	12	,	,	,
18637	20907	13	297	297	CD
18637	20907	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20907	15	422	422	CD
18637	20907	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20907	17	1936	1936	CD
18637	20907	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20907	19	.	.	.
18637	20908	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20908	2	377	377	CD
18637	20908	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20908	4	Geer	Geer	NNP
18637	20908	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20908	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20908	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20908	8	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	20908	9	,	,	,
18637	20908	10	161	161	CD
18637	20908	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20908	12	519	519	CD
18637	20908	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20908	14	1896	1896	CD
18637	20908	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20908	16	.	.	.
18637	20909	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20909	2	378	378	CD
18637	20909	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20909	4	Silz	Silz	NNP
18637	20909	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20909	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20909	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20909	8	Hesterberg	Hesterberg	NNP
18637	20909	9	,	,	,
18637	20909	10	211	211	CD
18637	20909	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20909	12	31	31	CD
18637	20909	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20909	14	1908	1908	CD
18637	20909	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20909	16	.	.	.
18637	20910	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20910	2	379	379	CD
18637	20910	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20910	4	Reinman	Reinman	NNP
18637	20910	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20910	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20910	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20910	8	Little	Little	NNP
18637	20910	9	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	20910	10	,	,	,
18637	20910	11	237	237	CD
18637	20910	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20910	13	171	171	CD
18637	20910	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20910	15	1915	1915	CD
18637	20910	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20910	17	.	.	.
18637	20911	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20911	2	380	380	CD
18637	20911	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20911	4	Hadacheck	Hadacheck	NNP
18637	20911	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20911	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20911	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20911	8	Sebastian	Sebastian	NNP
18637	20911	9	,	,	,
18637	20911	10	239	239	CD
18637	20911	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20911	12	394	394	CD
18637	20911	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20911	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	20911	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20911	16	.	.	.
18637	20912	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20912	2	381	381	CD
18637	20912	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20912	4	Fischer	Fischer	NNP
18637	20912	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20912	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20912	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20912	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20912	9	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	20912	10	,	,	,
18637	20912	11	194	194	CD
18637	20912	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20912	13	361	361	CD
18637	20912	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20912	15	1904	1904	CD
18637	20912	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20912	17	.	.	.
18637	20913	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20913	2	382	382	CD
18637	20913	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20913	4	Reinman	Reinman	NNP
18637	20913	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20913	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20913	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20913	8	Little	Little	NNP
18637	20913	9	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	20913	10	,	,	,
18637	20913	11	237	237	CD
18637	20913	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20913	13	171	171	CD
18637	20913	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20913	15	1915	1915	CD
18637	20913	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20913	17	.	.	.
18637	20914	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20914	2	383	383	CD
18637	20914	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20914	4	Bacon	Bacon	NNP
18637	20914	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20914	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20914	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20914	8	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	20914	9	,	,	,
18637	20914	10	204	204	CD
18637	20914	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20914	12	311	311	CD
18637	20914	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20914	14	1907	1907	CD
18637	20914	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20914	16	.	.	.
18637	20915	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20915	2	384	384	CD
18637	20915	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20915	4	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	20915	5	Laundry	Laundry	NNP
18637	20915	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20915	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20915	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20915	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20915	10	Des	Des	NNP
18637	20915	11	Moines	Moines	NNP
18637	20915	12	,	,	,
18637	20915	13	239	239	CD
18637	20915	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20915	15	486	486	CD
18637	20915	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20915	17	1916	1916	CD
18637	20915	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20915	19	.	.	.
18637	20916	1	For	for	IN
18637	20916	2	a	a	DT
18637	20916	3	case	case	NN
18637	20916	4	embracing	embrace	VBG
18637	20916	5	a	a	DT
18637	20916	6	rather	rather	RB
18637	20916	7	special	special	JJ
18637	20916	8	set	set	NN
18637	20916	9	of	of	IN
18637	20916	10	facts	fact	NNS
18637	20916	11	,	,	,
18637	20916	12	_	_	NNP
18637	20916	13	see	see	VBP
18637	20916	14	_	_	NNP
18637	20916	15	Dobbins	Dobbins	NNP
18637	20916	16	_	_	NNP
18637	20916	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	20916	18	_	_	NNP
18637	20916	19	Los	Los	NNP
18637	20916	20	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	20916	21	,	,	,
18637	20916	22	195	195	CD
18637	20916	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20916	24	223	223	CD
18637	20916	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20916	26	1904	1904	CD
18637	20916	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20916	28	.	.	.
18637	20917	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20917	2	385	385	CD
18637	20917	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20917	4	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	20917	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20917	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20917	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20917	8	Swasey	Swasey	NNP
18637	20917	9	,	,	,
18637	20917	10	214	214	CD
18637	20917	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20917	12	91	91	CD
18637	20917	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20917	14	1909	1909	CD
18637	20917	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20917	16	.	.	.
18637	20918	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20918	2	386	386	CD
18637	20918	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20918	4	Euclid	Euclid	NNP
18637	20918	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20918	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20918	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20918	8	Ambler	Ambler	NNP
18637	20918	9	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	20918	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20918	11	,	,	,
18637	20918	12	272	272	CD
18637	20918	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20918	14	365	365	CD
18637	20918	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20918	16	1926	1926	CD
18637	20918	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20918	18	;	;	:
18637	20918	19	Zahn	Zahn	NNP
18637	20918	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20918	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	20918	22	_	_	NNP
18637	20918	23	Board	Board	NNP
18637	20918	24	of	of	IN
18637	20918	25	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20918	26	Works	Works	NNP
18637	20918	27	,	,	,
18637	20918	28	274	274	CD
18637	20918	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20918	30	325	325	CD
18637	20918	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20918	32	1927	1927	CD
18637	20918	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20918	34	;	;	:
18637	20918	35	Nectaw	Nectaw	NNP
18637	20918	36	_	_	NNP
18637	20918	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	20918	38	_	_	NNP
18637	20918	39	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
18637	20918	40	,	,	,
18637	20918	41	277	277	CD
18637	20918	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20918	43	183	183	CD
18637	20918	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20918	45	1928	1928	CD
18637	20918	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20918	47	;	;	:
18637	20918	48	Cusack	Cusack	NNP
18637	20918	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20918	50	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	20918	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20918	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20918	53	_	_	NNP
18637	20918	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	20918	55	_	_	NNP
18637	20918	56	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20918	57	,	,	,
18637	20918	58	242	242	CD
18637	20918	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20918	60	526	526	CD
18637	20918	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20918	62	1917	1917	CD
18637	20918	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20918	64	;	;	:
18637	20918	65	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20918	66	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	20918	67	Poster	Poster	NNP
18637	20918	68	Advertising	Advertising	NNP
18637	20918	69	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20918	70	_	_	NNP
18637	20918	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	20918	72	_	_	NNP
18637	20918	73	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20918	74	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	20918	75	,	,	,
18637	20918	76	249	249	CD
18637	20918	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20918	78	269	269	CD
18637	20918	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20918	80	1919	1919	CD
18637	20918	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20918	82	.	.	.
18637	20919	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20919	2	387	387	CD
18637	20919	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20919	4	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	20919	5	ex	ex	NN
18637	20919	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	20919	7	.	.	.
18637	20920	1	Seattle	Seattle	NNP
18637	20920	2	Title	Title	NNP
18637	20920	3	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	20920	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20920	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20920	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20920	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20920	8	Roberage	Roberage	NNP
18637	20920	9	,	,	,
18637	20920	10	278	278	CD
18637	20920	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20920	12	116	116	CD
18637	20920	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20920	14	1928	1928	CD
18637	20920	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20920	16	.	.	.
18637	20921	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20921	2	388	388	CD
18637	20921	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20921	4	Eubank	Eubank	NNP
18637	20921	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20921	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20921	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20921	8	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	20921	9	,	,	,
18637	20921	10	226	226	CD
18637	20921	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20921	12	137	137	CD
18637	20921	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20921	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	20921	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20921	16	.	.	.
18637	20922	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20922	2	389	389	CD
18637	20922	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20922	4	Gorieb	Gorieb	NNP
18637	20922	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20922	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20922	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20922	8	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	20922	9	,	,	,
18637	20922	10	274	274	CD
18637	20922	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20922	12	603	603	CD
18637	20922	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20922	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	20922	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20922	16	.	.	.
18637	20923	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20923	2	390	390	CD
18637	20923	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20923	4	Buchanan	Buchanan	NNP
18637	20923	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20923	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20923	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20923	8	Warley	Warley	NNP
18637	20923	9	,	,	,
18637	20923	10	245	245	CD
18637	20923	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20923	12	60	60	CD
18637	20923	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20923	14	1917	1917	CD
18637	20923	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20923	16	.	.	.
18637	20924	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20924	2	391	391	CD
18637	20924	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20924	4	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	20924	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	20924	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	20924	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20924	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20924	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20924	10	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	20924	11	,	,	,
18637	20924	12	248	248	CD
18637	20924	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20924	14	498	498	CD
18637	20924	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20924	16	1919	1919	CD
18637	20924	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20924	18	.	.	.
18637	20925	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20925	2	392	392	CD
18637	20925	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20925	4	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	20925	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	20925	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20925	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20925	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20925	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20925	10	Marysville	Marysville	NNP
18637	20925	11	,	,	,
18637	20925	12	279	279	CD
18637	20925	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20925	14	582	582	CD
18637	20925	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20925	16	1929	1929	CD
18637	20925	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20925	18	.	.	.
18637	20926	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20926	2	393	393	CD
18637	20926	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20926	4	Barbier	Barbier	NNP
18637	20926	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20926	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20926	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20926	8	Connolly	Connolly	NNP
18637	20926	9	,	,	,
18637	20926	10	113	113	CD
18637	20926	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20926	12	27	27	CD
18637	20926	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20926	14	1885	1885	CD
18637	20926	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20926	16	;	;	:
18637	20926	17	Soon	soon	RB
18637	20926	18	Hing	Hing	NNP
18637	20926	19	_	_	NNP
18637	20926	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	20926	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20926	22	Crowley	Crowley	NNP
18637	20926	23	,	,	,
18637	20926	24	113	113	CD
18637	20926	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20926	26	703	703	CD
18637	20926	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20926	28	1885	1885	CD
18637	20926	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20926	30	.	.	.
18637	20927	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20927	2	394	394	CD
18637	20927	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20927	4	Maguire	Maguire	NNP
18637	20927	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20927	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20927	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20927	8	Reardon	Reardon	NNP
18637	20927	9	,	,	,
18637	20927	10	255	255	CD
18637	20927	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20927	12	271	271	CD
18637	20927	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20927	14	1921	1921	CD
18637	20927	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20927	16	.	.	.
18637	20928	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20928	2	395	395	CD
18637	20928	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20928	4	Queenside	Queenside	NNP
18637	20928	5	Hills	Hills	NNP
18637	20928	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20928	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20928	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20928	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20928	10	Saxl	Saxl	NNP
18637	20928	11	,	,	,
18637	20928	12	328	328	CD
18637	20928	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20928	14	80	80	CD
18637	20928	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20928	16	1946	1946	CD
18637	20928	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20928	18	.	.	.
18637	20929	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20929	2	396	396	CD
18637	20929	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20929	4	Compagnie	Compagnie	NNP
18637	20929	5	Francaise	Francaise	NNP
18637	20929	6	de	de	NNP
18637	20929	7	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	20929	8	Ã	Ã	NNP
18637	20929	9	  	  	_SP
18637	20929	10	Vapeur	Vapeur	NNP
18637	20929	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20929	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	20929	13	_	_	NNP
18637	20929	14	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	20929	15	State	State	NNP
18637	20929	16	Board	Board	NNP
18637	20929	17	of	of	IN
18637	20929	18	Health	Health	NNP
18637	20929	19	,	,	,
18637	20929	20	186	186	CD
18637	20929	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20929	22	380	380	CD
18637	20929	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20929	24	1902	1902	CD
18637	20929	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20929	26	.	.	.
18637	20930	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20930	2	397	397	CD
18637	20930	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20930	4	Jacobson	Jacobson	NNP
18637	20930	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20930	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20930	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20930	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	20930	9	,	,	,
18637	20930	10	197	197	CD
18637	20930	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20930	12	11	11	CD
18637	20930	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20930	14	1905	1905	CD
18637	20930	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20930	16	;	;	:
18637	20930	17	New	New	NNP
18637	20930	18	York	York	NNP
18637	20930	19	ex	ex	NN
18637	20930	20	rel	rel	NN
18637	20930	21	.	.	.
18637	20931	1	Lieberman	Lieberman	NNP
18637	20931	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20931	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20931	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20931	5	Van	Van	NNP
18637	20931	6	De	De	NNP
18637	20931	7	Carr	Carr	NNP
18637	20931	8	,	,	,
18637	20931	9	199	199	CD
18637	20931	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20931	11	552	552	CD
18637	20931	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20931	13	1905	1905	CD
18637	20931	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20931	15	.	.	.
18637	20932	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20932	2	398	398	CD
18637	20932	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20932	4	Perley	Perley	NNP
18637	20932	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20932	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20932	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20932	8	North	North	NNP
18637	20932	9	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	20932	10	,	,	,
18637	20932	11	249	249	CD
18637	20932	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20932	13	510	510	CD
18637	20932	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20932	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	20932	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20932	17	.	.	.
18637	20933	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20933	2	399	399	CD
18637	20933	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20933	4	California	California	NNP
18637	20933	5	Reduction	Reduction	NNP
18637	20933	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20933	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20933	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20933	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20933	10	Sanitary	Sanitary	NNP
18637	20933	11	Reduction	Reduction	NNP
18637	20933	12	Works	Works	NNP
18637	20933	13	,	,	,
18637	20933	14	199	199	CD
18637	20933	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20933	16	306	306	CD
18637	20933	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20933	18	1905	1905	CD
18637	20933	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20933	20	.	.	.
18637	20934	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20934	2	400	400	CD
18637	20934	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20934	4	Hutchinson	Hutchinson	NNP
18637	20934	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20934	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20934	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20934	8	Valdosta	Valdosta	NNP
18637	20934	9	,	,	,
18637	20934	10	227	227	CD
18637	20934	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20934	12	303	303	CD
18637	20934	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20934	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	20934	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20934	16	.	.	.
18637	20935	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20935	2	401	401	CD
18637	20935	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20935	4	Sligh	Sligh	NNP
18637	20935	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20935	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20935	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20935	8	Kirkwood	Kirkwood	NNP
18637	20935	9	,	,	,
18637	20935	10	237	237	CD
18637	20935	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20935	12	52	52	CD
18637	20935	13	,	,	,
18637	20935	14	59	59	CD
18637	20935	15	-	-	SYM
18637	20935	16	60	60	CD
18637	20935	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20935	18	1915	1915	CD
18637	20935	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20935	20	.	.	.
18637	20936	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20936	2	402	402	CD
18637	20936	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20936	4	Powell	Powell	NNP
18637	20936	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20936	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20936	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20936	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	20936	9	,	,	,
18637	20936	10	127	127	CD
18637	20936	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20936	12	678	678	CD
18637	20936	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20936	14	1888	1888	CD
18637	20936	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20936	16	;	;	:
18637	20936	17	Magnano	Magnano	NNP
18637	20936	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20936	19	A.	a.	NN
18637	20936	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20937	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20937	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20937	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20937	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20937	5	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	20937	6	,	,	,
18637	20937	7	292	292	CD
18637	20937	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20937	9	40	40	CD
18637	20937	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20937	11	1934	1934	CD
18637	20937	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20937	13	.	.	.
18637	20938	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20938	2	403	403	CD
18637	20938	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20938	4	North	North	NNP
18637	20938	5	American	American	NNP
18637	20938	6	Cold	Cold	NNP
18637	20938	7	Storage	Storage	NNP
18637	20938	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20938	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20938	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	20938	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20938	12	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20938	13	,	,	,
18637	20938	14	211	211	CD
18637	20938	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20938	16	306	306	CD
18637	20938	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20938	18	1908	1908	CD
18637	20938	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20938	20	.	.	.
18637	20939	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20939	2	404	404	CD
18637	20939	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20939	4	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	20939	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20939	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20939	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20939	8	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	20939	9	,	,	,
18637	20939	10	228	228	CD
18637	20939	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20939	12	572	572	CD
18637	20939	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20939	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	20939	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20939	16	.	.	.
18637	20940	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20940	2	405	405	CD
18637	20940	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20940	4	Baccus	Baccus	NNP
18637	20940	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20940	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20940	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20940	8	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	20940	9	,	,	,
18637	20940	10	232	232	CD
18637	20940	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20940	12	334	334	CD
18637	20940	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20940	14	1914	1914	CD
18637	20940	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20940	16	.	.	.
18637	20941	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20941	2	406	406	CD
18637	20941	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20941	4	Roschen	Roschen	NNP
18637	20941	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20941	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20941	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20941	8	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	20941	9	,	,	,
18637	20941	10	279	279	CD
18637	20941	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20941	12	337	337	CD
18637	20941	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20941	14	1929	1929	CD
18637	20941	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20941	16	.	.	.
18637	20942	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20942	2	407	407	CD
18637	20942	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20942	4	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	20942	5	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20942	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	20942	7	.	.	.
18637	20943	1	Whipple	Whipple	NNP
18637	20943	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20943	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20943	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20943	5	Martinson	Martinson	NNP
18637	20943	6	,	,	,
18637	20943	7	256	256	CD
18637	20943	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20943	9	41	41	CD
18637	20943	10	,	,	,
18637	20943	11	45	45	CD
18637	20943	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20943	13	1921	1921	CD
18637	20943	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20943	15	.	.	.
18637	20944	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20944	2	408	408	CD
18637	20944	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20944	4	Hutchinson	Hutchinson	NNP
18637	20944	5	Ice	Ice	NNP
18637	20944	6	Cream	Cream	NNP
18637	20944	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20944	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20944	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20944	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20944	11	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	20944	12	,	,	,
18637	20944	13	242	242	CD
18637	20944	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20944	15	153	153	CD
18637	20944	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20944	17	1916	1916	CD
18637	20944	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20944	19	.	.	.
18637	20945	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20945	2	409	409	CD
18637	20945	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20945	4	Hebe	Hebe	NNP
18637	20945	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20945	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20945	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20945	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20945	9	Shaw	Shaw	NNP
18637	20945	10	,	,	,
18637	20945	11	248	248	CD
18637	20945	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20945	13	297	297	CD
18637	20945	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20945	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	20945	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20945	17	.	.	.
18637	20946	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20946	2	410	410	CD
18637	20946	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20946	4	Price	Price	NNP
18637	20946	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20946	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20946	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20946	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	20946	9	,	,	,
18637	20946	10	238	238	CD
18637	20946	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20946	12	446	446	CD
18637	20946	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20946	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	20946	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20946	16	.	.	.
18637	20947	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20947	2	411	411	CD
18637	20947	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20947	4	Sage	Sage	NNP
18637	20947	5	Stores	Stores	NNPS
18637	20947	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20947	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20947	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20947	9	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20947	10	,	,	,
18637	20947	11	323	323	CD
18637	20947	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20947	13	32	32	CD
18637	20947	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20947	15	1944	1944	CD
18637	20947	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20947	17	.	.	.
18637	20948	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20948	2	412	412	CD
18637	20948	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20948	4	Weaver	Weaver	NNP
18637	20948	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20948	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20948	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20948	8	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	20948	9	Bros	Bros	NNP
18637	20948	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20948	11	,	,	,
18637	20948	12	270	270	CD
18637	20948	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20948	14	402	402	CD
18637	20948	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20948	16	1926	1926	CD
18637	20948	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20948	18	.	.	.
18637	20949	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20949	2	413	413	CD
18637	20949	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20949	4	Ah	Ah	NNP
18637	20949	5	Sin	Sin	NNP
18637	20949	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20949	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20949	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20949	9	Wittman	Wittman	NNP
18637	20949	10	,	,	,
18637	20949	11	198	198	CD
18637	20949	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20949	13	500	500	CD
18637	20949	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20949	15	1905	1905	CD
18637	20949	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20949	17	.	.	.
18637	20950	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20950	2	414	414	CD
18637	20950	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20950	4	Marvin	Marvin	NNP
18637	20950	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20950	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20950	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20950	8	Trout	Trout	NNP
18637	20950	9	,	,	,
18637	20950	10	199	199	CD
18637	20950	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20950	12	212	212	CD
18637	20950	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20950	14	1905	1905	CD
18637	20950	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20950	16	.	.	.
18637	20951	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20951	2	415	415	CD
18637	20951	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20951	4	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	20951	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20951	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20951	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20951	8	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	20951	9	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20951	10	rel	rel	NN
18637	20951	11	.	.	.
18637	20952	1	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	20952	2	,	,	,
18637	20952	3	101	101	CD
18637	20952	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20952	5	814	814	CD
18637	20952	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20952	7	1880	1880	CD
18637	20952	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20952	9	;	;	:
18637	20952	10	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	20952	11	_	_	NNP
18637	20952	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	20952	13	_	_	NNP
18637	20952	14	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	20952	15	,	,	,
18637	20952	16	168	168	CD
18637	20952	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20952	18	488	488	CD
18637	20952	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20952	20	1897	1897	CD
18637	20952	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20952	22	.	.	.
18637	20953	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20953	2	416	416	CD
18637	20953	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20953	4	L'Hote	L'Hote	NNP
18637	20953	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20953	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20953	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20953	8	New	New	NNP
18637	20953	9	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	20953	10	,	,	,
18637	20953	11	177	177	CD
18637	20953	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20953	13	587	587	CD
18637	20953	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20953	15	1900	1900	CD
18637	20953	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20953	17	.	.	.
18637	20954	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20954	2	417	417	CD
18637	20954	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20954	4	Petit	Petit	NNP
18637	20954	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20954	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20954	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20954	8	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	20954	9	,	,	,
18637	20954	10	177	177	CD
18637	20954	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20954	12	164	164	CD
18637	20954	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20954	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	20954	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20954	16	.	.	.
18637	20955	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20955	2	418	418	CD
18637	20955	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20955	4	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	20955	5	Beer	Beer	NNP
18637	20955	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20955	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20955	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20955	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20955	10	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	20955	11	,	,	,
18637	20955	12	97	97	CD
18637	20955	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20955	14	25	25	CD
18637	20955	15	,	,	,
18637	20955	16	33	33	CD
18637	20955	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20955	18	1878	1878	CD
18637	20955	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20955	20	;	;	:
18637	20955	21	Mugler	Mugler	NNP
18637	20955	22	_	_	NNP
18637	20955	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	20955	24	_	_	NNP
18637	20955	25	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20955	26	,	,	,
18637	20955	27	123	123	CD
18637	20955	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20955	29	623	623	CD
18637	20955	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20955	31	1887	1887	CD
18637	20955	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20955	33	;	;	:
18637	20955	34	Kidd	Kidd	NNP
18637	20955	35	_	_	NNP
18637	20955	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	20955	37	_	_	NNP
18637	20955	38	Pearson	Pearson	NNP
18637	20955	39	,	,	,
18637	20955	40	128	128	CD
18637	20955	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20955	42	1	1	CD
18637	20955	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20955	44	1888	1888	CD
18637	20955	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20955	46	;	;	:
18637	20955	47	Purity	Purity	NNP
18637	20955	48	Extract	Extract	NNP
18637	20955	49	&	&	CC
18637	20955	50	Tonic	Tonic	NNP
18637	20955	51	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20955	52	_	_	NNP
18637	20955	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	20955	54	_	_	NNP
18637	20955	55	Lynch	Lynch	NNP
18637	20955	56	,	,	,
18637	20955	57	226	226	CD
18637	20955	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20955	59	192	192	CD
18637	20955	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20955	61	1912	1912	CD
18637	20955	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20955	63	;	;	:
18637	20955	64	James	James	NNP
18637	20955	65	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	20955	66	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	20955	67	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20955	68	_	_	NNP
18637	20955	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	20955	70	_	_	NNP
18637	20955	71	Western	Western	NNP
18637	20955	72	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	20955	73	R.	R.	NNP
18637	20955	74	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20955	75	,	,	,
18637	20955	76	242	242	CD
18637	20955	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20955	78	311	311	CD
18637	20955	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20955	80	1917	1917	CD
18637	20955	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20955	82	;	;	:
18637	20955	83	Barbour	Barbour	NNP
18637	20955	84	_	_	NNP
18637	20955	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	20955	86	_	_	NNP
18637	20955	87	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	20955	88	,	,	,
18637	20955	89	249	249	CD
18637	20955	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20955	91	454	454	CD
18637	20955	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20955	93	1919	1919	CD
18637	20955	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20955	95	.	.	.
18637	20956	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20956	2	419	419	CD
18637	20956	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20956	4	Mugler	Mugler	NNP
18637	20956	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20956	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20956	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20956	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20956	9	,	,	,
18637	20956	10	123	123	CD
18637	20956	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20956	12	623	623	CD
18637	20956	13	,	,	,
18637	20956	14	671	671	CD
18637	20956	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20956	16	1887	1887	CD
18637	20956	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20956	18	.	.	.
18637	20957	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20957	2	420	420	CD
18637	20957	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20957	4	Hawes	Hawes	NNP
18637	20957	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20957	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20957	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20957	8	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	20957	9	,	,	,
18637	20957	10	258	258	CD
18637	20957	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20957	12	1	1	CD
18637	20957	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20957	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	20957	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20957	16	;	;	:
18637	20957	17	Van	Van	NNP
18637	20957	18	Oster	Oster	NNP
18637	20957	19	_	_	NNP
18637	20957	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	20957	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20957	22	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20957	23	,	,	,
18637	20957	24	272	272	CD
18637	20957	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20957	26	465	465	CD
18637	20957	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20957	28	1926	1926	CD
18637	20957	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20957	30	.	.	.
18637	20958	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20958	2	421	421	CD
18637	20958	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20958	4	Stephenson	Stephenson	NNP
18637	20958	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20958	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20958	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20958	8	Binford	Binford	NNP
18637	20958	9	,	,	,
18637	20958	10	287	287	CD
18637	20958	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20958	12	251	251	CD
18637	20958	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20958	14	1932	1932	CD
18637	20958	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20958	16	.	.	.
18637	20959	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20959	2	422	422	CD
18637	20959	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20959	4	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
18637	20959	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20959	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20959	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20959	8	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20959	9	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	20959	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20959	11	,	,	,
18637	20959	12	295	295	CD
18637	20959	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20959	14	76	76	CD
18637	20959	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20959	16	1935	1935	CD
18637	20959	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20959	18	.	.	.
18637	20960	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20960	2	423	423	CD
18637	20960	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20960	4	Stephenson	Stephenson	NNP
18637	20960	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20960	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20960	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20960	8	Binford	Binford	NNP
18637	20960	9	,	,	,
18637	20960	10	287	287	CD
18637	20960	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20960	12	251	251	CD
18637	20960	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20960	14	1932	1932	CD
18637	20960	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20960	16	.	.	.
18637	20961	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20961	2	424	424	CD
18637	20961	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20961	4	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	20961	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	20961	6	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	20961	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20961	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20961	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	20961	10	_	_	NNP
18637	20961	11	Duke	Duke	NNP
18637	20961	12	,	,	,
18637	20961	13	266	266	CD
18637	20961	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20961	15	570	570	CD
18637	20961	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20961	17	1925	1925	CD
18637	20961	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20961	19	.	.	.
18637	20962	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20962	2	425	425	CD
18637	20962	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20962	4	Frost	Frost	NNP
18637	20962	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20962	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20962	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20962	8	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	20962	9	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	20962	10	,	,	,
18637	20962	11	271	271	CD
18637	20962	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20962	13	583	583	CD
18637	20962	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20962	15	1926	1926	CD
18637	20962	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20962	17	;	;	:
18637	20962	18	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	20962	19	_	_	NNP
18637	20962	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	20962	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20962	22	Cahoon	Cahoon	NNP
18637	20962	23	,	,	,
18637	20962	24	283	283	CD
18637	20962	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20962	26	553	553	CD
18637	20962	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20962	28	1931	1931	CD
18637	20962	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20962	30	.	.	.
18637	20963	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20963	2	426	426	CD
18637	20963	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20963	4	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	20963	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20963	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20963	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20963	8	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	20963	9	.	.	.
18637	20964	1	Util	util	IN
18637	20964	2	.	.	.
18637	20965	1	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	20965	2	.	.	.
18637	20965	3	,	,	,
18637	20965	4	289	289	CD
18637	20965	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20965	6	92	92	CD
18637	20965	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20965	8	1933	1933	CD
18637	20965	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20965	10	.	.	.
18637	20966	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20966	2	427	427	CD
18637	20966	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20966	4	Sproles	Sproles	NNP
18637	20966	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20966	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20966	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20966	8	Binford	Binford	NNP
18637	20966	9	,	,	,
18637	20966	10	286	286	CD
18637	20966	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20966	12	374	374	CD
18637	20966	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20966	14	1932	1932	CD
18637	20966	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20966	16	.	.	.
18637	20967	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20967	2	428	428	CD
18637	20967	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20967	4	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	20967	5	Express	Express	NNP
18637	20967	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20967	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20967	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20967	9	New	New	NNP
18637	20967	10	York	York	NNP
18637	20967	11	,	,	,
18637	20967	12	336	336	CD
18637	20967	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20967	14	106	106	CD
18637	20967	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20967	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	20967	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20967	18	.	.	.
18637	20968	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20968	2	429	429	CD
18637	20968	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20968	4	Reitz	Reitz	NNP
18637	20968	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20968	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20968	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20968	8	Mealey	Mealey	NNP
18637	20968	9	,	,	,
18637	20968	10	314	314	CD
18637	20968	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20968	12	33	33	CD
18637	20968	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20968	14	1941	1941	CD
18637	20968	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20968	16	.	.	.
18637	20969	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20969	2	430	430	CD
18637	20969	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20969	4	Young	Young	NNP
18637	20969	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20969	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20969	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20969	8	Masci	Masci	NNP
18637	20969	9	,	,	,
18637	20969	10	289	289	CD
18637	20969	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20969	12	253	253	CD
18637	20969	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20969	14	1933	1933	CD
18637	20969	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20969	16	.	.	.
18637	20970	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20970	2	431	431	CD
18637	20970	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20970	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	20970	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	20970	6	Poresky	Poresky	NNP
18637	20970	7	,	,	,
18637	20970	8	290	290	CD
18637	20970	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20970	10	30	30	CD
18637	20970	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20970	12	1933	1933	CD
18637	20970	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20970	14	.	.	.
18637	20971	1	_	_	NNP
18637	20971	2	See	See	NNP
18637	20971	3	also	also	RB
18637	20971	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20971	5	Packard	Packard	NNP
18637	20971	6	_	_	NNP
18637	20971	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	20971	8	_	_	NNP
18637	20971	9	Banton	Banton	NNP
18637	20971	10	,	,	,
18637	20971	11	264	264	CD
18637	20971	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20971	13	140	140	CD
18637	20971	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20971	15	1924	1924	CD
18637	20971	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20971	17	;	;	:
18637	20971	18	Sprout	Sprout	NNP
18637	20971	19	_	_	NNP
18637	20971	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	20971	21	_	_	NNP
18637	20971	22	South	South	NNP
18637	20971	23	Bend	Bend	NNP
18637	20971	24	,	,	,
18637	20971	25	277	277	CD
18637	20971	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20971	27	163	163	CD
18637	20971	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20971	29	1928	1928	CD
18637	20971	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20971	31	;	;	:
18637	20971	32	Hodge	Hodge	NNP
18637	20971	33	Drive	Drive	NNP
18637	20971	34	-	-	:
18637	20971	35	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	20971	36	-	-	HYPH
18637	20971	37	Yourself	Yourself	NNP
18637	20971	38	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20971	39	_	_	NNP
18637	20971	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	20971	41	_	_	NNP
18637	20971	42	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	20971	43	,	,	,
18637	20971	44	284	284	CD
18637	20971	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20971	46	335	335	CD
18637	20971	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20971	48	1932	1932	CD
18637	20971	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20971	50	;	;	:
18637	20971	51	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	20971	52	Baking	Baking	NNP
18637	20971	53	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20971	54	_	_	NNP
18637	20971	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	20971	56	_	_	NNP
18637	20971	57	Woodring	Woodring	NNP
18637	20971	58	,	,	,
18637	20971	59	286	286	CD
18637	20971	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20971	61	352	352	CD
18637	20971	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20971	63	1932	1932	CD
18637	20971	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20971	65	.	.	.
18637	20972	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20972	2	432	432	CD
18637	20972	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20972	4	Irving	Irving	NNP
18637	20972	5	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	20972	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20972	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20972	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20972	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20972	10	Day	Day	NNP
18637	20972	11	,	,	,
18637	20972	12	314	314	CD
18637	20972	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20972	14	556	556	CD
18637	20972	15	,	,	,
18637	20972	16	564	564	CD
18637	20972	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20972	18	1942	1942	CD
18637	20972	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20972	20	.	.	.
18637	20973	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20973	2	433	433	CD
18637	20973	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20973	4	Demorest	Demorest	NNP
18637	20973	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20973	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20973	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20973	8	City	City	NNP
18637	20973	9	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	20973	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20973	11	,	,	,
18637	20973	12	321	321	CD
18637	20973	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20973	14	36	36	CD
18637	20973	15	,	,	,
18637	20973	16	47	47	CD
18637	20973	17	-	-	SYM
18637	20973	18	48	48	CD
18637	20973	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20973	20	1944	1944	CD
18637	20973	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20973	22	.	.	.
18637	20974	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20974	2	434	434	CD
18637	20974	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20974	4	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	20974	5	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	20974	6	.	.	.
18637	20975	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20975	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20975	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20975	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20975	5	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	20975	6	,	,	,
18637	20975	7	333	333	CD
18637	20975	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20975	9	541	541	CD
18637	20975	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20975	11	1948	1948	CD
18637	20975	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20975	13	.	.	.
18637	20976	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	20976	2	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	20976	3	and	and	CC
18637	20976	4	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	20976	5	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	20976	6	on	on	IN
18637	20976	7	the	the	DT
18637	20976	8	ground	ground	NN
18637	20976	9	that	that	IN
18637	20976	10	New	New	NNP
18637	20976	11	York	York	NNP
18637	20976	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	20976	13	attempting	attempt	VBG
18637	20976	14	to	to	TO
18637	20976	15	escheat	escheat	VB
18637	20976	16	unclaimed	unclaimed	JJ
18637	20976	17	funds	fund	NNS
18637	20976	18	not	not	RB
18637	20976	19	located	locate	VBN
18637	20976	20	either	either	CC
18637	20976	21	actually	actually	RB
18637	20976	22	or	or	CC
18637	20976	23	constructively	constructively	RB
18637	20976	24	in	in	IN
18637	20976	25	New	New	NNP
18637	20976	26	York	York	NNP
18637	20976	27	and	and	CC
18637	20976	28	which	which	WDT
18637	20976	29	are	be	VBP
18637	20976	30	the	the	DT
18637	20976	31	property	property	NN
18637	20976	32	of	of	IN
18637	20976	33	beneficiaries	beneficiary	NNS
18637	20976	34	who	who	WP
18637	20976	35	may	may	MD
18637	20976	36	never	never	RB
18637	20976	37	have	have	VB
18637	20976	38	been	be	VBN
18637	20976	39	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	20976	40	or	or	CC
18637	20976	41	residents	resident	NNS
18637	20976	42	of	of	IN
18637	20976	43	New	New	NNP
18637	20976	44	York	York	NNP
18637	20976	45	.	.	.
18637	20977	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20977	2	435	435	CD
18637	20977	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20977	4	341	341	CD
18637	20977	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20977	6	428	428	CD
18637	20977	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20977	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	20977	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20977	10	.	.	.
18637	20978	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20978	2	436	436	CD
18637	20978	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20978	4	Snowden	Snowden	NNP
18637	20978	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20978	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20978	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20978	8	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	20978	9	,	,	,
18637	20978	10	321	321	CD
18637	20978	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20978	12	1	1	CD
18637	20978	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20978	14	1944	1944	CD
18637	20978	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20978	16	.	.	.
18637	20979	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20979	2	437	437	CD
18637	20979	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20979	4	Angle	Angle	NNP
18637	20979	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20979	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20979	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20979	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20979	9	,	,	,
18637	20979	10	St.	St.	NNP
18637	20980	1	P.M.	P.M.	NNP
18637	20980	2	&	&	CC
18637	20980	3	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	20981	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20981	2	,	,	,
18637	20981	3	151	151	CD
18637	20981	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20981	5	1	1	CD
18637	20981	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20981	7	1894	1894	CD
18637	20981	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20981	9	.	.	.
18637	20982	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20982	2	438	438	CD
18637	20982	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20982	4	Coombes	Coombes	NNP
18637	20982	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20982	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20982	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20982	8	Getz	Getz	NNP
18637	20982	9	,	,	,
18637	20982	10	285	285	CD
18637	20982	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20982	12	434	434	CD
18637	20982	13	,	,	,
18637	20982	14	442	442	CD
18637	20982	15	,	,	,
18637	20982	16	448	448	CD
18637	20982	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20982	18	1932	1932	CD
18637	20982	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20982	20	.	.	.
18637	20983	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20983	2	439	439	CD
18637	20983	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20983	4	Gibbes	Gibbes	NNP
18637	20983	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20983	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20983	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20983	8	Zimmerman	Zimmerman	NNP
18637	20983	9	,	,	,
18637	20983	10	290	290	CD
18637	20983	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20983	12	326	326	CD
18637	20983	13	,	,	,
18637	20983	14	332	332	CD
18637	20983	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20983	16	1933	1933	CD
18637	20983	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20983	18	.	.	.
18637	20984	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20984	2	440	440	CD
18637	20984	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20984	4	Shriver	Shriver	NNP
18637	20984	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20984	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20984	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20984	8	Woodbine	Woodbine	NNP
18637	20984	9	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	20984	10	.	.	.
18637	20985	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	20985	2	,	,	,
18637	20985	3	285	285	CD
18637	20985	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20985	5	467	467	CD
18637	20985	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20985	7	1932	1932	CD
18637	20985	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20985	9	.	.	.
18637	20986	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20986	2	441	441	CD
18637	20986	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20986	4	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	20986	5	Securities	Securities	NNP
18637	20986	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	20986	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20986	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20986	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20986	10	Donaldson	Donaldson	NNP
18637	20986	11	,	,	,
18637	20986	12	325	325	CD
18637	20986	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20986	14	304	304	CD
18637	20986	15	,	,	,
18637	20986	16	315	315	CD
18637	20986	17	-	-	SYM
18637	20986	18	316	316	CD
18637	20986	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20986	20	1945	1945	CD
18637	20986	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20986	22	.	.	.
18637	20987	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20987	2	442	442	CD
18637	20987	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20987	4	Sentell	Sentell	NNP
18637	20987	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20987	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20987	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20987	8	New	New	NNP
18637	20987	9	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	20987	10	&	&	CC
18637	20987	11	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	20988	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20988	2	,	,	,
18637	20988	3	166	166	CD
18637	20988	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20988	5	698	698	CD
18637	20988	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20988	7	1897	1897	CD
18637	20988	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20988	9	.	.	.
18637	20989	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20989	2	443	443	CD
18637	20989	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20989	4	Soliah	Soliah	NNP
18637	20989	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20989	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20989	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20989	8	Heskin	Heskin	NNP
18637	20989	9	,	,	,
18637	20989	10	222	222	CD
18637	20989	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20989	12	522	522	CD
18637	20989	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20989	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	20989	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20989	16	.	.	.
18637	20990	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20990	2	444	444	CD
18637	20990	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20990	4	Trenton	Trenton	NNP
18637	20990	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20990	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20990	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20990	8	New	New	NNP
18637	20990	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	20990	10	,	,	,
18637	20990	11	262	262	CD
18637	20990	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20990	13	182	182	CD
18637	20990	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20990	15	1923	1923	CD
18637	20990	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20990	17	.	.	.
18637	20991	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20991	2	445	445	CD
18637	20991	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20991	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	20991	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20991	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20991	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20991	8	Sturges	Sturges	NNP
18637	20991	9	,	,	,
18637	20991	10	222	222	CD
18637	20991	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20991	12	313	313	CD
18637	20991	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20991	14	1911	1911	CD
18637	20991	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20991	16	.	.	.
18637	20992	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20992	2	446	446	CD
18637	20992	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20992	4	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	20992	5	ex	ex	NN
18637	20992	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	20992	7	.	.	.
18637	20993	1	Folsom	Folsom	NNP
18637	20993	2	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	20993	3	_	_	NNP
18637	20993	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	20993	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20993	6	New	New	NNP
18637	20993	7	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	20993	8	,	,	,
18637	20993	9	109	109	CD
18637	20993	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20993	11	285	285	CD
18637	20993	12	,	,	,
18637	20993	13	289	289	CD
18637	20993	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20993	15	1883	1883	CD
18637	20993	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20993	17	.	.	.
18637	20994	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20994	2	447	447	CD
18637	20994	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20994	4	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	20994	5	General	General	NNP
18637	20994	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	20994	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	20994	8	.	.	.
18637	20995	1	Kies	Kies	NNPS
18637	20995	2	_	_	NNP
18637	20995	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	20995	4	_	_	NNP
18637	20995	5	Lowrey	Lowrey	NNP
18637	20995	6	,	,	,
18637	20995	7	199	199	CD
18637	20995	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20995	9	233	233	CD
18637	20995	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20995	11	1905	1905	CD
18637	20995	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20995	13	.	.	.
18637	20996	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20996	2	448	448	CD
18637	20996	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20996	4	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	20996	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20996	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20996	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20996	8	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	20996	9	,	,	,
18637	20996	10	207	207	CD
18637	20996	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20996	12	161	161	CD
18637	20996	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20996	14	1907	1907	CD
18637	20996	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20996	16	.	.	.
18637	20997	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20997	2	449	449	CD
18637	20997	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20997	4	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	20997	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20997	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20997	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20997	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	20997	9	City	City	NNP
18637	20997	10	,	,	,
18637	20997	11	239	239	CD
18637	20997	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20997	13	14	14	CD
18637	20997	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20997	15	1915	1915	CD
18637	20997	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20997	17	.	.	.
18637	20998	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20998	2	450	450	CD
18637	20998	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20998	4	Tonawanda	Tonawanda	NNP
18637	20998	5	_	_	NNP
18637	20998	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	20998	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20998	8	Lyon	Lyon	NNP
18637	20998	9	,	,	,
18637	20998	10	181	181	CD
18637	20998	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20998	12	389	389	CD
18637	20998	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20998	14	1901	1901	CD
18637	20998	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20998	16	;	;	:
18637	20998	17	Cass	Cass	NNP
18637	20998	18	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	20998	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20998	20	_	_	NNP
18637	20998	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	20998	22	_	_	NNP
18637	20998	23	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	20998	24	,	,	,
18637	20998	25	181	181	CD
18637	20998	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20998	27	396	396	CD
18637	20998	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20998	29	1901	1901	CD
18637	20998	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20998	31	.	.	.
18637	20999	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	20999	2	451	451	CD
18637	20999	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	20999	4	Southwestern	Southwestern	NNP
18637	20999	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	20999	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	20999	7	_	_	NNP
18637	20999	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	20999	9	_	_	NNP
18637	20999	10	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	20999	11	,	,	,
18637	20999	12	217	217	CD
18637	20999	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	20999	14	114	114	CD
18637	20999	15	,	,	,
18637	20999	16	119	119	CD
18637	20999	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	20999	18	1910	1910	CD
18637	20999	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	20999	20	.	.	.
18637	21000	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21000	2	452	452	CD
18637	21000	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21000	4	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	21000	5	'	'	POS
18637	21000	6	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	21000	7	.	.	.
18637	21001	1	&	&	CC
18637	21001	2	L.	L.	NNP
18637	21001	3	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	21001	4	.	.	.
18637	21002	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21002	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	21002	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21002	4	Topeka	Topeka	NNP
18637	21002	5	,	,	,
18637	21002	6	20	20	CD
18637	21002	7	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	21002	8	.	.	.
18637	21003	1	655	655	CD
18637	21003	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21003	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	21003	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21003	5	;	;	:
18637	21003	6	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	21003	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21003	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21003	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21003	10	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	21003	11	,	,	,
18637	21003	12	245	245	CD
18637	21003	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21003	14	217	217	CD
18637	21003	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21003	16	1917	1917	CD
18637	21003	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21003	18	;	;	:
18637	21003	19	Green	Green	NNP
18637	21003	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21003	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21003	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21003	23	Frazier	Frazier	NNP
18637	21003	24	,	,	,
18637	21003	25	253	253	CD
18637	21003	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21003	27	233	233	CD
18637	21003	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21003	29	1920	1920	CD
18637	21003	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21003	31	;	;	:
18637	21003	32	Carmichael	Carmichael	NNP
18637	21003	33	_	_	NNP
18637	21003	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	21003	35	_	_	NNP
18637	21003	36	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	21003	37	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	21003	38	&	&	CC
18637	21003	39	Coke	Coke	NNP
18637	21003	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21003	41	,	,	,
18637	21003	42	300	300	CD
18637	21003	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21003	44	644	644	CD
18637	21003	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21003	46	1937	1937	CD
18637	21003	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21003	48	.	.	.
18637	21004	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21004	2	453	453	CD
18637	21004	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21004	4	Milheim	Milheim	NNP
18637	21004	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21004	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21004	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21004	8	Moffat	Moffat	NNP
18637	21004	9	Tunnel	Tunnel	NNP
18637	21004	10	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	21004	11	.	.	.
18637	21005	1	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	21005	2	.	.	.
18637	21005	3	,	,	,
18637	21005	4	262	262	CD
18637	21005	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21005	6	710	710	CD
18637	21005	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21005	8	1923	1923	CD
18637	21005	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21005	10	.	.	.
18637	21006	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21006	2	454	454	CD
18637	21006	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21006	4	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	21006	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21006	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21006	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21006	8	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	21006	9	,	,	,
18637	21006	10	245	245	CD
18637	21006	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21006	12	217	217	CD
18637	21006	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21006	14	1917	1917	CD
18637	21006	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21006	16	.	.	.
18637	21007	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21007	2	455	455	CD
18637	21007	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21007	4	Green	Green	NNP
18637	21007	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21007	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21007	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21007	8	Frazier	Frazier	NNP
18637	21007	9	,	,	,
18637	21007	10	253	253	CD
18637	21007	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21007	12	233	233	CD
18637	21007	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21007	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	21007	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21007	16	.	.	.
18637	21008	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21008	2	456	456	CD
18637	21008	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21008	4	Nicchia	Nicchia	NNP
18637	21008	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21008	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21008	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21008	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21008	9	York	York	NNP
18637	21008	10	,	,	,
18637	21008	11	254	254	CD
18637	21008	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21008	13	228	228	CD
18637	21008	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21008	15	1920	1920	CD
18637	21008	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21008	17	.	.	.
18637	21009	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21009	2	457	457	CD
18637	21009	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21009	4	Milheim	Milheim	NNP
18637	21009	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21009	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21009	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21009	8	Moffat	Moffat	NNP
18637	21009	9	Tunnel	Tunnel	NNP
18637	21009	10	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	21009	11	.	.	.
18637	21010	1	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	21010	2	,	,	,
18637	21010	3	262	262	CD
18637	21010	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21010	5	710	710	CD
18637	21010	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21010	7	1923	1923	CD
18637	21010	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21010	9	.	.	.
18637	21011	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21011	2	458	458	CD
18637	21011	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21011	4	Cochran	Cochran	NNP
18637	21011	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21011	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21011	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21011	8	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	21011	9	State	State	NNP
18637	21011	10	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	21011	11	.	.	.
18637	21012	1	of	of	IN
18637	21012	2	Ed	Ed	NNP
18637	21012	3	.	.	NNP
18637	21012	4	,	,	,
18637	21012	5	281	281	CD
18637	21012	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21012	7	370	370	CD
18637	21012	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21012	9	1930	1930	CD
18637	21012	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21012	11	.	.	.
18637	21013	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21013	2	459	459	CD
18637	21013	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21013	4	Carmichael	Carmichael	NNP
18637	21013	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21013	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21013	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21013	8	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	21013	9	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	21013	10	&	&	CC
18637	21013	11	Coke	Coke	NNP
18637	21013	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21013	13	,	,	,
18637	21013	14	300	300	CD
18637	21013	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21013	16	644	644	CD
18637	21013	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21013	18	1937	1937	CD
18637	21013	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21013	20	.	.	.
18637	21014	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21014	2	460	460	CD
18637	21014	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21014	4	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	21014	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21014	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21014	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21014	8	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	21014	9	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	21014	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21014	11	,	,	,
18637	21014	12	294	294	CD
18637	21014	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21014	14	87	87	CD
18637	21014	15	,	,	,
18637	21014	16	99	99	CD
18637	21014	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21014	18	1935	1935	CD
18637	21014	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21014	20	.	.	.
18637	21015	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21015	2	461	461	CD
18637	21015	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21015	4	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	21015	5	Dry	Dry	NNP
18637	21015	6	Goods	Goods	NNP
18637	21015	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21015	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21015	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21015	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21015	11	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	21015	12	,	,	,
18637	21015	13	294	294	CD
18637	21015	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21015	15	550	550	CD
18637	21015	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21015	17	1935	1935	CD
18637	21015	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21015	19	.	.	.
18637	21016	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21016	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21016	3	also	also	RB
18637	21016	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21016	5	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	21016	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21016	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21016	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21016	9	Zobelein	Zobelein	NNP
18637	21016	10	,	,	,
18637	21016	11	237	237	CD
18637	21016	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21016	13	135	135	CD
18637	21016	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21016	15	1915	1915	CD
18637	21016	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21016	17	;	;	:
18637	21016	18	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
18637	21016	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21016	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	21016	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21016	22	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	21016	23	,	,	,
18637	21016	24	104	104	CD
18637	21016	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21016	26	78	78	CD
18637	21016	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21016	28	1881	1881	CD
18637	21016	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21016	30	.	.	.
18637	21017	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21017	2	462	462	CD
18637	21017	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21017	4	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	21017	5	,	,	,
18637	21017	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	21017	7	&	&	CC
18637	21017	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21017	9	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	21018	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21018	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21018	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21018	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21018	5	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	21018	6	,	,	,
18637	21018	7	288	288	CD
18637	21018	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21018	9	249	249	CD
18637	21018	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21018	11	1933	1933	CD
18637	21018	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21018	13	;	;	:
18637	21018	14	Carmichael	Carmichael	NNP
18637	21018	15	_	_	NNP
18637	21018	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	21018	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21018	18	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	21018	19	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	21018	20	&	&	CC
18637	21018	21	Coke	Coke	NNP
18637	21018	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21018	23	,	,	,
18637	21018	24	300	300	CD
18637	21018	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21018	26	644	644	CD
18637	21018	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21018	28	1937	1937	CD
18637	21018	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21018	30	.	.	.
18637	21019	1	A	a	DT
18637	21019	2	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	21019	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	21019	4	can	can	MD
18637	21019	5	not	not	RB
18637	21019	6	contest	contest	VB
18637	21019	7	the	the	DT
18637	21019	8	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	21019	9	of	of	IN
18637	21019	10	an	an	DT
18637	21019	11	income	income	NN
18637	21019	12	tax	tax	NN
18637	21019	13	on	on	IN
18637	21019	14	the	the	DT
18637	21019	15	ground	ground	NN
18637	21019	16	that	that	IN
18637	21019	17	,	,	,
18637	21019	18	in	in	IN
18637	21019	19	operation	operation	NN
18637	21019	20	,	,	,
18637	21019	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21019	22	returns	return	VBZ
18637	21019	23	to	to	IN
18637	21019	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21019	25	town	town	NN
18637	21019	26	less	less	JJR
18637	21019	27	income	income	NN
18637	21019	28	tax	tax	NN
18637	21019	29	than	than	IN
18637	21019	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21019	31	and	and	CC
18637	21019	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21019	33	other	other	JJ
18637	21019	34	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	21019	35	pay.--Dane	pay.--Dane	:
18637	21019	36	_	_	NNP
18637	21019	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	21019	38	_	_	NNP
18637	21019	39	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	21019	40	,	,	,
18637	21019	41	256	256	CD
18637	21019	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21019	43	589	589	CD
18637	21019	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21019	45	1921	1921	CD
18637	21019	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21019	47	.	.	.
18637	21020	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21020	2	463	463	CD
18637	21020	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21020	4	Stebbins	Stebbins	NNPS
18637	21020	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21020	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21020	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21020	8	Riley	Riley	NNP
18637	21020	9	,	,	,
18637	21020	10	268	268	CD
18637	21020	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21020	12	137	137	CD
18637	21020	13	,	,	,
18637	21020	14	140	140	CD
18637	21020	15	,	,	,
18637	21020	16	141	141	CD
18637	21020	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21020	18	1925	1925	CD
18637	21020	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21020	20	.	.	.
18637	21021	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21021	2	464	464	CD
18637	21021	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21021	4	Cahen	Cahen	NNP
18637	21021	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21021	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21021	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21021	8	Brewster	Brewster	NNP
18637	21021	9	,	,	,
18637	21021	10	203	203	CD
18637	21021	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21021	12	543	543	CD
18637	21021	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21021	14	1906	1906	CD
18637	21021	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21021	16	.	.	.
18637	21022	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21022	2	465	465	CD
18637	21022	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21022	4	Keeney	Keeney	NNP
18637	21022	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21022	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21022	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21022	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21022	9	York	York	NNP
18637	21022	10	,	,	,
18637	21022	11	222	222	CD
18637	21022	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21022	13	525	525	CD
18637	21022	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21022	15	1912	1912	CD
18637	21022	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21022	17	.	.	.
18637	21023	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21023	2	466	466	CD
18637	21023	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21023	4	Salomon	Salomon	NNP
18637	21023	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21023	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21023	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21023	8	State	State	NNP
18637	21023	9	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	21023	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	21023	11	,	,	,
18637	21023	12	278	278	CD
18637	21023	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21023	14	484	484	CD
18637	21023	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21023	16	1929	1929	CD
18637	21023	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21023	18	.	.	.
18637	21024	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21024	2	467	467	CD
18637	21024	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21024	4	Orr	Orr	NNP
18637	21024	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21024	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21024	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21024	8	Gilman	Gilman	NNP
18637	21024	9	,	,	,
18637	21024	10	183	183	CD
18637	21024	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21024	12	278	278	CD
18637	21024	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21024	14	1902	1902	CD
18637	21024	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21024	16	;	;	:
18637	21024	17	Chanler	Chanler	NNP
18637	21024	18	_	_	NNP
18637	21024	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	21024	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21024	21	Kelsey	Kelsey	NNP
18637	21024	22	,	,	,
18637	21024	23	205	205	CD
18637	21024	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21024	25	466	466	CD
18637	21024	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21024	27	1907	1907	CD
18637	21024	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21024	29	.	.	.
18637	21025	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21025	2	468	468	CD
18637	21025	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21025	4	Nickel	Nickel	NNP
18637	21025	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21025	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21025	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21025	8	Cole	Cole	NNP
18637	21025	9	,	,	,
18637	21025	10	256	256	CD
18637	21025	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21025	12	222	222	CD
18637	21025	13	,	,	,
18637	21025	14	226	226	CD
18637	21025	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21025	16	1921	1921	CD
18637	21025	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21025	18	.	.	.
18637	21026	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21026	2	469	469	CD
18637	21026	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21026	4	Coolidge	Coolidge	NNP
18637	21026	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21026	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21026	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21026	8	Long	Long	NNP
18637	21026	9	,	,	,
18637	21026	10	282	282	CD
18637	21026	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21026	12	582	582	CD
18637	21026	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21026	14	1931	1931	CD
18637	21026	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21026	16	.	.	.
18637	21027	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21027	2	470	470	CD
18637	21027	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21027	4	Binney	Binney	NNP
18637	21027	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21027	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21027	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21027	8	Long	Long	NNP
18637	21027	9	,	,	,
18637	21027	10	299	299	CD
18637	21027	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21027	12	280	280	CD
18637	21027	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21027	14	1936	1936	CD
18637	21027	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21027	16	.	.	.
18637	21028	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21028	2	471	471	CD
18637	21028	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21028	4	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	21028	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21028	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21028	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21028	8	State	State	NNP
18637	21028	9	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	21028	10	Com	Com	NNP
18637	21028	11	.	.	NNP
18637	21028	12	,	,	,
18637	21028	13	309	309	CD
18637	21028	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21028	15	530	530	CD
18637	21028	16	,	,	,
18637	21028	17	540(1940	540(1940	NNP
18637	21028	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21028	19	.	.	.
18637	21029	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21029	2	472	472	CD
18637	21029	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21029	4	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	21029	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21029	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21029	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21029	8	Henry	Henry	NNP
18637	21029	9	,	,	,
18637	21029	10	305	305	CD
18637	21029	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21029	12	134	134	CD
18637	21029	13	,	,	,
18637	21029	14	147	147	CD
18637	21029	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21029	16	1938	1938	CD
18637	21029	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21029	18	.	.	.
18637	21030	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21030	2	473	473	CD
18637	21030	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21030	4	Hoeper	Hoeper	NNP
18637	21030	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21030	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21030	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21030	8	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	21030	9	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	21030	10	,	,	,
18637	21030	11	284	284	CD
18637	21030	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21030	13	206	206	CD
18637	21030	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21030	15	1931	1931	CD
18637	21030	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21030	17	.	.	.
18637	21031	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21031	2	474	474	CD
18637	21031	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21031	4	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	21031	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21031	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21031	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21031	8	Henry	Henry	NNP
18637	21031	9	,	,	,
18637	21031	10	305	305	CD
18637	21031	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21031	12	134	134	CD
18637	21031	13	,	,	,
18637	21031	14	147	147	CD
18637	21031	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21031	16	150	150	CD
18637	21031	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21031	18	1938	1938	CD
18637	21031	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21031	20	.	.	.
18637	21032	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21032	2	475	475	CD
18637	21032	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21032	4	Puget	Puget	NNP
18637	21032	5	Sound	Sound	NNP
18637	21032	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	21032	7	&	&	CC
18637	21032	8	Light	Light	NNP
18637	21032	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21032	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21032	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	21032	12	_	_	NNP
18637	21032	13	Seattle	Seattle	NNP
18637	21032	14	,	,	,
18637	21032	15	291	291	CD
18637	21032	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21032	17	619	619	CD
18637	21032	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21032	19	1934	1934	CD
18637	21032	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21032	21	.	.	.
18637	21033	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21033	2	476	476	CD
18637	21033	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21033	4	New	New	NNP
18637	21033	5	York	York	NNP
18637	21033	6	,	,	,
18637	21033	7	P.	P.	NNP
18637	21033	8	&	&	CC
18637	21033	9	N.	N.	NNP
18637	21033	10	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	21033	11	.	.	.
18637	21034	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21034	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21034	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21034	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21034	5	Dolan	Dolan	NNP
18637	21034	6	,	,	,
18637	21034	7	265	265	CD
18637	21034	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21034	9	96	96	CD
18637	21034	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21034	11	1924	1924	CD
18637	21034	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21034	13	.	.	.
18637	21035	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21035	2	477	477	CD
18637	21035	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21035	4	Barwise	Barwise	NNP
18637	21035	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21035	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21035	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21035	8	Sheppard	Sheppard	NNP
18637	21035	9	,	,	,
18637	21035	10	299	299	CD
18637	21035	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21035	12	33	33	CD
18637	21035	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21035	14	1936	1936	CD
18637	21035	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21035	16	.	.	.
18637	21036	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21036	2	478	478	CD
18637	21036	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21036	4	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	21036	5	,	,	,
18637	21036	6	O.	O.	NNP
18637	21037	1	&	&	CC
18637	21037	2	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21037	3	L.	L.	NNP
18637	21037	4	Ky.	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21037	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21037	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21037	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21037	8	Browning	Browning	NNP
18637	21037	9	,	,	,
18637	21037	10	310	310	CD
18637	21037	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21037	12	362	362	CD
18637	21037	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21037	14	1940	1940	CD
18637	21037	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21037	16	.	.	.
18637	21038	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21038	2	479	479	CD
18637	21038	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21038	4	Paddell	Paddell	NNP
18637	21038	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21038	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21038	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21038	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21038	9	York	York	NNP
18637	21038	10	,	,	,
18637	21038	11	211	211	CD
18637	21038	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21038	13	446	446	CD
18637	21038	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21038	15	1908	1908	CD
18637	21038	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21038	17	.	.	.
18637	21039	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21039	2	480	480	CD
18637	21039	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21039	4	Hagar	Hagar	NNP
18637	21039	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21039	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21039	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21039	8	Reclamation	Reclamation	NNP
18637	21039	9	District	District	NNP
18637	21039	10	,	,	,
18637	21039	11	111	111	CD
18637	21039	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21039	13	701	701	CD
18637	21039	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21039	15	1884	1884	CD
18637	21039	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21039	17	.	.	.
18637	21040	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21040	2	481	481	CD
18637	21040	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21040	4	Butters	Butters	NNPS
18637	21040	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21040	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21040	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21040	8	Oakland	Oakland	NNP
18637	21040	9	,	,	,
18637	21040	10	263	263	CD
18637	21040	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21040	12	162	162	CD
18637	21040	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21040	14	1923	1923	CD
18637	21040	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21040	16	.	.	.
18637	21041	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21041	2	482	482	CD
18637	21041	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21041	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	21041	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	21042	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21042	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21042	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21042	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21042	5	Western	Western	NNP
18637	21042	6	Crawford	Crawford	NNP
18637	21042	7	Road	Road	NNP
18637	21042	8	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	21042	9	.	.	.
18637	21043	1	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	21043	2	.	.	.
18637	21043	3	,	,	,
18637	21043	4	266	266	CD
18637	21043	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21043	6	187	187	CD
18637	21043	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21043	8	1924	1924	CD
18637	21043	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21043	10	.	.	.
18637	21044	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21044	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21044	3	also	also	RB
18637	21044	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21044	5	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	21044	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21044	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21044	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21044	9	Richland	Richland	NNP
18637	21044	10	Irrig	Irrig	NNP
18637	21044	11	.	.	.
18637	21045	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21045	2	,	,	,
18637	21045	3	289	289	CD
18637	21045	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21045	5	71	71	CD
18637	21045	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21045	7	1933	1933	CD
18637	21045	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21045	9	in	in	IN
18637	21045	10	which	which	WDT
18637	21045	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21045	12	was	be	VBD
18637	21045	13	also	also	RB
18637	21045	14	stated	state	VBN
18637	21045	15	that	that	IN
18637	21045	16	an	an	DT
18637	21045	17	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	21045	18	to	to	TO
18637	21045	19	pay	pay	VB
18637	21045	20	the	the	DT
18637	21045	21	general	general	JJ
18637	21045	22	indebtedness	indebtedness	NN
18637	21045	23	of	of	IN
18637	21045	24	an	an	DT
18637	21045	25	irrigation	irrigation	NN
18637	21045	26	district	district	NN
18637	21045	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	21045	28	valid	valid	JJ
18637	21045	29	,	,	,
18637	21045	30	even	even	RB
18637	21045	31	though	though	IN
18637	21045	32	in	in	IN
18637	21045	33	excess	excess	NN
18637	21045	34	of	of	IN
18637	21045	35	the	the	DT
18637	21045	36	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	21045	37	received	receive	VBN
18637	21045	38	.	.	.
18637	21046	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21046	2	483	483	CD
18637	21046	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21046	4	Houck	Houck	NNP
18637	21046	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21046	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21046	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21046	8	Little	Little	NNP
18637	21046	9	River	River	NNP
18637	21046	10	Drainage	Drainage	NNP
18637	21046	11	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	21046	12	,	,	,
18637	21046	13	239	239	CD
18637	21046	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21046	15	254	254	CD
18637	21046	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21046	17	1915	1915	CD
18637	21046	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21046	19	.	.	.
18637	21047	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21047	2	484	484	CD
18637	21047	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21047	4	Road	Road	NNP
18637	21047	5	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	21047	6	.	.	.
18637	21048	1	Dist	dist	VB
18637	21048	2	.	.	.
18637	21049	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21049	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	21049	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21049	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	21049	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	21050	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21050	2	,	,	,
18637	21050	3	274	274	CD
18637	21050	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21050	5	188	188	CD
18637	21050	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21050	7	1927	1927	CD
18637	21050	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21050	9	.	.	.
18637	21051	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21051	2	485	485	CD
18637	21051	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21051	4	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	21051	5	City	City	NNP
18637	21051	6	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	21051	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	21051	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21051	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21051	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	21051	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21051	12	Road	Road	NNP
18637	21051	13	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	21051	14	.	.	.
18637	21052	1	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	21052	2	.	.	.
18637	21052	3	,	,	,
18637	21052	4	266	266	CD
18637	21052	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21052	6	379	379	CD
18637	21052	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21052	8	1924	1924	CD
18637	21052	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21052	10	.	.	.
18637	21053	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21053	2	486	486	CD
18637	21053	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21053	4	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	21053	5	&	&	CC
18637	21053	6	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	21054	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21054	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21054	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21054	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21054	5	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	21054	6	Asphalt	Asphalt	NNP
18637	21054	7	Pav	Pav	NNP
18637	21054	8	.	.	.
18637	21055	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21055	2	,	,	,
18637	21055	3	197	197	CD
18637	21055	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21055	5	430	430	CD
18637	21055	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21055	7	1905	1905	CD
18637	21055	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21055	9	.	.	.
18637	21056	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21056	2	487	487	CD
18637	21056	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21056	4	Myles	Myles	NNP
18637	21056	5	Salt	Salt	NNP
18637	21056	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21056	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21056	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21056	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21056	10	Iberia	Iberia	NNP
18637	21056	11	&	&	CC
18637	21056	12	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21056	13	M.	M.	NNP
18637	21056	14	Drainage	Drainage	NNP
18637	21056	15	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	21056	16	.	.	.
18637	21056	17	,	,	,
18637	21056	18	239	239	CD
18637	21056	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21056	20	478	478	CD
18637	21056	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21056	22	1916	1916	CD
18637	21056	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21056	24	.	.	.
18637	21057	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21057	2	488	488	CD
18637	21057	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21057	4	Wagner	Wagner	NNP
18637	21057	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21057	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21057	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21057	8	Leser	Leser	NNP
18637	21057	9	,	,	,
18637	21057	10	239	239	CD
18637	21057	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21057	12	207	207	CD
18637	21057	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21057	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	21057	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21057	16	.	.	.
18637	21058	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21058	2	489	489	CD
18637	21058	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21058	4	Charlotte	Charlotte	NNP
18637	21058	5	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	21058	6	&	&	CC
18637	21058	7	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	21059	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21059	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21059	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21059	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21059	5	Welles	Welles	NNP
18637	21059	6	,	,	,
18637	21059	7	260	260	CD
18637	21059	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21059	9	8	8	CD
18637	21059	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21059	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	21059	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21059	13	.	.	.
18637	21060	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21060	2	490	490	CD
18637	21060	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21060	4	Union	Union	NNP
18637	21060	5	Refrigerator	Refrigerator	NNP
18637	21060	6	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	21060	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21060	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21060	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21060	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21060	11	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21060	12	,	,	,
18637	21060	13	199	199	CD
18637	21060	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21060	15	194	194	CD
18637	21060	16	,	,	,
18637	21060	17	204	204	CD
18637	21060	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21060	19	1905	1905	CD
18637	21060	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21060	21	.	.	.
18637	21061	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21061	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21061	3	also	also	RB
18637	21061	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21061	5	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	21061	6	&	&	CC
18637	21061	7	J.	J.	NNP
18637	21062	1	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	21062	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21062	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21062	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	21062	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21062	6	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21062	7	,	,	,
18637	21062	8	188	188	CD
18637	21062	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21062	10	385	385	CD
18637	21062	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21062	12	1903	1903	CD
18637	21062	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21062	14	.	.	.
18637	21063	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21063	2	491	491	CD
18637	21063	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21063	4	Carstairs	Carstairs	NNP
18637	21063	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21063	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21063	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21063	8	Cochran	Cochran	NNP
18637	21063	9	,	,	,
18637	21063	10	193	193	CD
18637	21063	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21063	12	10	10	CD
18637	21063	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21063	14	1904	1904	CD
18637	21063	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21063	16	;	;	:
18637	21063	17	Hannis	Hannis	NNP
18637	21063	18	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	21063	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21063	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21063	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21063	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21063	23	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	21063	24	,	,	,
18637	21063	25	216	216	CD
18637	21063	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21063	27	285	285	CD
18637	21063	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21063	29	1910	1910	CD
18637	21063	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21063	31	;	;	:
18637	21063	32	Frick	Frick	NNP
18637	21063	33	_	_	NNP
18637	21063	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	21063	35	_	_	NNP
18637	21063	36	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21063	37	,	,	,
18637	21063	38	268	268	CD
18637	21063	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21063	40	473	473	CD
18637	21063	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21063	42	1925	1925	CD
18637	21063	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21063	44	;	;	:
18637	21063	45	Blodgett	Blodgett	NNP
18637	21063	46	_	_	NNP
18637	21063	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	21063	48	_	_	NNP
18637	21063	49	Silberman	Silberman	NNP
18637	21063	50	,	,	,
18637	21063	51	277	277	CD
18637	21063	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21063	53	1	1	CD
18637	21063	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21063	55	1928	1928	CD
18637	21063	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21063	57	.	.	.
18637	21064	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21064	2	492	492	CD
18637	21064	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21064	4	New	New	NNP
18637	21064	5	York	York	NNP
18637	21064	6	ex	ex	NN
18637	21064	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	21064	8	.	.	.
18637	21065	1	New	New	NNP
18637	21065	2	York	York	NNP
18637	21065	3	,	,	,
18637	21065	4	C.	C.	NNP
18637	21065	5	&	&	CC
18637	21065	6	H.R.R.	H.R.R.	NNP
18637	21066	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21066	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21066	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21066	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21066	5	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	21066	6	,	,	,
18637	21066	7	202	202	CD
18637	21066	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21066	9	584	584	CD
18637	21066	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21066	11	1906	1906	CD
18637	21066	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21066	13	.	.	.
18637	21067	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21067	2	493	493	CD
18637	21067	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21067	4	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	21067	5	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	21067	6	Corp	Corp	NNP
18637	21067	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21067	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21067	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21067	10	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	21067	11	,	,	,
18637	21067	12	298	298	CD
18637	21067	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21067	14	193	193	CD
18637	21067	15	,	,	,
18637	21067	16	209	209	CD
18637	21067	17	-	-	SYM
18637	21067	18	210	210	CD
18637	21067	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21067	20	1936	1936	CD
18637	21067	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21067	22	;	;	:
18637	21067	23	Union	Union	NNP
18637	21067	24	Refrigerator	Refrigerator	NNP
18637	21067	25	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	21067	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21067	27	_	_	NNP
18637	21067	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	21067	29	_	_	NNP
18637	21067	30	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21067	31	,	,	,
18637	21067	32	199	199	CD
18637	21067	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21067	34	194	194	CD
18637	21067	35	,	,	,
18637	21067	36	207	207	CD
18637	21067	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21067	38	1905	1905	CD
18637	21067	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21067	40	;	;	:
18637	21067	41	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	21067	42	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	21067	43	Ref	Ref	NNP
18637	21067	44	.	.	.
18637	21068	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21068	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21068	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21068	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21068	5	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	21068	6	ex	ex	NN
18637	21068	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	21068	8	.	.	.
18637	21069	1	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	21069	2	,	,	,
18637	21069	3	290	290	CD
18637	21069	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21069	5	158	158	CD
18637	21069	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21069	7	1933	1933	CD
18637	21069	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21069	9	.	.	.
18637	21070	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21070	2	494	494	CD
18637	21070	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21070	4	Robert	Robert	NNP
18637	21070	5	L.	L.	NNP
18637	21070	6	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	21070	7	,	,	,
18637	21070	8	State	State	NNP
18637	21070	9	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	21070	10	to	to	IN
18637	21070	11	Tax	tax	NN
18637	21070	12	Intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	21070	13	:	:	:
18637	21070	14	A	a	DT
18637	21070	15	Twelve	Twelve	NNP
18637	21070	16	Year	Year	NNP
18637	21070	17	Cycle	cycle	NN
18637	21070	18	,	,	,
18637	21070	19	8	8	CD
18637	21070	20	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	21070	21	Law	Law	NNP
18637	21070	22	Review	Review	NNP
18637	21070	23	155	155	CD
18637	21070	24	,	,	,
18637	21070	25	160	160	CD
18637	21070	26	-	-	SYM
18637	21070	27	162	162	CD
18637	21070	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21070	29	1943	1943	CD
18637	21070	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21070	31	;	;	:
18637	21070	32	Ralph	Ralph	NNP
18637	21070	33	T.	T.	NNP
18637	21070	34	Rawlins	Rawlins	NNPS
18637	21070	35	,	,	,
18637	21070	36	State	State	NNP
18637	21070	37	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	21070	38	to	to	IN
18637	21070	39	Tax	tax	NN
18637	21070	40	Intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	21070	41	:	:	:
18637	21070	42	Some	some	DT
18637	21070	43	Modern	Modern	NNP
18637	21070	44	Aspects	Aspects	NNPS
18637	21070	45	,	,	,
18637	21070	46	18	18	CD
18637	21070	47	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	21070	48	Law	Law	NNP
18637	21070	49	Review	Review	NNP
18637	21070	50	296	296	CD
18637	21070	51	,	,	,
18637	21070	52	314	314	CD
18637	21070	53	-	-	HYPH
18637	21070	54	315	315	CD
18637	21070	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21070	56	1940	1940	CD
18637	21070	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21070	58	.	.	.
18637	21071	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21071	2	495	495	CD
18637	21071	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21071	4	Kirtland	Kirtland	NNP
18637	21071	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21071	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21071	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21071	8	Hotchkiss	Hotchkiss	NNP
18637	21071	9	,	,	,
18637	21071	10	100	100	CD
18637	21071	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21071	12	491	491	CD
18637	21071	13	,	,	,
18637	21071	14	498	498	CD
18637	21071	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21071	16	1879	1879	CD
18637	21071	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21071	18	.	.	.
18637	21072	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21072	2	496	496	CD
18637	21072	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21072	4	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	21072	5	&	&	CC
18637	21072	6	L.	L.	NNP
18637	21072	7	Soc	Soc	NNP
18637	21072	8	.	.	.
18637	21073	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21073	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	21073	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21073	4	Multnomah	Multnomah	NNP
18637	21073	5	County	County	NNP
18637	21073	6	,	,	,
18637	21073	7	169	169	CD
18637	21073	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21073	9	421	421	CD
18637	21073	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21073	11	1898	1898	CD
18637	21073	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21073	13	.	.	.
18637	21074	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21074	2	497	497	CD
18637	21074	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21074	4	Bristol	Bristol	NNP
18637	21074	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21074	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21074	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21074	8	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	21074	9	County	County	NNP
18637	21074	10	,	,	,
18637	21074	11	177	177	CD
18637	21074	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21074	13	133	133	CD
18637	21074	14	,	,	,
18637	21074	15	141	141	CD
18637	21074	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21074	17	1900	1900	CD
18637	21074	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21074	19	.	.	.
18637	21075	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21075	2	498	498	CD
18637	21075	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21075	4	Fidelity	Fidelity	NNP
18637	21075	5	&	&	CC
18637	21075	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	21075	7	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	21075	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21075	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21075	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	21075	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21075	12	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	21075	13	,	,	,
18637	21075	14	245	245	CD
18637	21075	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21075	16	54	54	CD
18637	21075	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21075	18	1917	1917	CD
18637	21075	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21075	20	.	.	.
18637	21076	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21076	2	499	499	CD
18637	21076	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21076	4	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	21076	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21076	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21076	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21076	8	Hennepin	Hennepin	NNP
18637	21076	9	County	County	NNP
18637	21076	10	,	,	,
18637	21076	11	240	240	CD
18637	21076	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21076	13	184	184	CD
18637	21076	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21076	15	1916	1916	CD
18637	21076	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21076	17	.	.	.
18637	21077	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21077	2	500	500	CD
18637	21077	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21077	4	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	21077	5	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	21077	6	.	.	.
18637	21078	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21078	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21078	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21078	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21078	5	Durr	Durr	NNP
18637	21078	6	,	,	,
18637	21078	7	257	257	CD
18637	21078	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21078	9	99	99	CD
18637	21078	10	,	,	,
18637	21078	11	109	109	CD
18637	21078	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21078	13	1921	1921	CD
18637	21078	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21078	15	.	.	.
18637	21079	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21079	2	501	501	CD
18637	21079	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21079	4	Hawley	Hawley	NNP
18637	21079	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21079	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21079	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21079	8	Maiden	Maiden	NNP
18637	21079	9	,	,	,
18637	21079	10	232	232	CD
18637	21079	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21079	12	1	1	CD
18637	21079	13	,	,	,
18637	21079	14	12	12	CD
18637	21079	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21079	16	1914	1914	CD
18637	21079	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21079	18	.	.	.
18637	21080	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21080	2	502	502	CD
18637	21080	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21080	4	First	First	NNP
18637	21080	5	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21080	6	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	21080	7	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	21080	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21080	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21080	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21080	11	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	21080	12	,	,	,
18637	21080	13	301	301	CD
18637	21080	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21080	15	234	234	CD
18637	21080	16	,	,	,
18637	21080	17	241	241	CD
18637	21080	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21080	19	1937	1937	CD
18637	21080	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21080	21	.	.	.
18637	21081	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21081	2	503	503	CD
18637	21081	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21081	4	Schuylkill	Schuylkill	NNP
18637	21081	5	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	21081	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21081	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21081	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21081	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21081	10	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21081	11	,	,	,
18637	21081	12	302	302	CD
18637	21081	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21081	14	506	506	CD
18637	21081	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21081	16	1938	1938	CD
18637	21081	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21081	18	.	.	.
18637	21082	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21082	2	504	504	CD
18637	21082	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21082	4	Harvester	Harvester	NNP
18637	21082	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21082	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21082	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21082	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21082	9	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	21082	10	.	.	.
18637	21083	1	of	of	IN
18637	21083	2	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	21083	3	,	,	,
18637	21083	4	322	322	CD
18637	21083	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21083	6	435	435	CD
18637	21083	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21083	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	21083	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21083	10	.	.	.
18637	21084	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21084	2	505	505	CD
18637	21084	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21084	4	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	21084	5	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	21084	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21084	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21084	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21084	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21084	10	United	United	NNP
18637	21084	11	States	States	NNP
18637	21084	12	,	,	,
18637	21084	13	322	322	CD
18637	21084	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21084	15	526	526	CD
18637	21084	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21084	17	1944	1944	CD
18637	21084	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21084	19	.	.	.
18637	21085	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21085	2	506	506	CD
18637	21085	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21085	4	New	New	NNP
18637	21085	5	York	York	NNP
18637	21085	6	ex	ex	NN
18637	21085	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	21085	8	.	.	.
18637	21086	1	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	21086	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21086	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21086	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21086	5	Reardon	Reardon	NNP
18637	21086	6	,	,	,
18637	21086	7	204	204	CD
18637	21086	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21086	9	152	152	CD
18637	21086	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21086	11	1907	1907	CD
18637	21086	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21086	13	.	.	.
18637	21087	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21087	2	507	507	CD
18637	21087	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21087	4	Graniteville	Graniteville	NNP
18637	21087	5	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	21087	6	.	.	.
18637	21088	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21088	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21088	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21088	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21088	5	Query	Query	NNP
18637	21088	6	,	,	,
18637	21088	7	283	283	CD
18637	21088	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21088	9	376	376	CD
18637	21088	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21088	11	1931	1931	CD
18637	21088	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21088	13	.	.	.
18637	21089	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21089	2	508	508	CD
18637	21089	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21089	4	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	21089	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21089	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21089	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21089	8	Beach	Beach	NNP
18637	21089	9	,	,	,
18637	21089	10	206	206	CD
18637	21089	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21089	12	392	392	CD
18637	21089	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21089	14	1907	1907	CD
18637	21089	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21089	16	.	.	.
18637	21090	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21090	2	509	509	CD
18637	21090	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21090	4	Brooke	Brooke	NNP
18637	21090	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21090	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21090	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21090	8	Norfolk	Norfolk	NNP
18637	21090	9	,	,	,
18637	21090	10	277	277	CD
18637	21090	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21090	12	27	27	CD
18637	21090	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21090	14	1928	1928	CD
18637	21090	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21090	16	.	.	.
18637	21091	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21091	2	510	510	CD
18637	21091	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21091	4	Greenough	Greenough	NNP
18637	21091	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21091	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21091	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21091	8	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	21091	9	Assessors	Assessors	NNPS
18637	21091	10	,	,	,
18637	21091	11	331	331	CD
18637	21091	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21091	13	486	486	CD
18637	21091	14	,	,	,
18637	21091	15	496	496	CD
18637	21091	16	-	-	SYM
18637	21091	17	497	497	CD
18637	21091	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21091	19	1947	1947	CD
18637	21091	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21091	21	.	.	.
18637	21092	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21092	2	511	511	CD
18637	21092	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21092	4	277	277	CD
18637	21092	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21092	6	27	27	CD
18637	21092	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21092	8	1928	1928	CD
18637	21092	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21092	10	.	.	.
18637	21093	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21093	2	512	512	CD
18637	21093	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21093	4	280	280	CD
18637	21093	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21093	6	83	83	CD
18637	21093	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21093	8	1929	1929	CD
18637	21093	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21093	10	.	.	.
18637	21094	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21094	2	513	513	CD
18637	21094	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21094	4	Senior	Senior	NNP
18637	21094	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21094	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21094	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21094	8	Braden	Braden	NNP
18637	21094	9	,	,	,
18637	21094	10	295	295	CD
18637	21094	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21094	12	422	422	CD
18637	21094	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21094	14	1985	1985	CD
18637	21094	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21094	16	.	.	.
18637	21095	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21095	2	514	514	LS
18637	21095	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21095	4	Stebbins	Stebbins	NNP
18637	21095	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21095	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21095	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21095	8	Riley	Riley	NNP
18637	21095	9	,	,	,
18637	21095	10	268	268	CD
18637	21095	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21095	12	137	137	CD
18637	21095	13	,	,	,
18637	21095	14	140	140	CD
18637	21095	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21095	16	141	141	CD
18637	21095	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21095	18	1925	1925	CD
18637	21095	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21095	20	.	.	.
18637	21096	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21096	2	515	515	CD
18637	21096	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21096	4	199	199	CD
18637	21096	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21096	6	194	194	CD
18637	21096	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21096	8	1905).--In	1905).--in	CD
18637	21096	9	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	21096	10	in	in	IN
18637	21096	11	State	State	NNP
18637	21096	12	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	21096	13	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	21096	14	_	_	NNP
18637	21096	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	21096	16	_	_	NNP
18637	21096	17	Aldrich	Aldrich	NNP
18637	21096	18	,	,	,
18637	21096	19	316	316	CD
18637	21096	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21096	21	174	174	CD
18637	21096	22	,	,	,
18637	21096	23	185	185	CD
18637	21096	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21096	25	1942	1942	CD
18637	21096	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21096	27	,	,	,
18637	21096	28	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21096	29	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	21096	30	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	21096	31	that	that	IN
18637	21096	32	a	a	DT
18637	21096	33	reconsideration	reconsideration	NN
18637	21096	34	of	of	IN
18637	21096	35	this	this	DT
18637	21096	36	principle	principle	NN
18637	21096	37	had	have	VBD
18637	21096	38	become	become	VBN
18637	21096	39	timely	timely	JJ
18637	21096	40	.	.	.
18637	21097	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21097	2	516	516	CD
18637	21097	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21097	4	268	268	CD
18637	21097	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21097	6	473	473	CD
18637	21097	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21097	8	1925	1925	CD
18637	21097	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21097	10	.	.	.
18637	21098	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21098	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21098	3	also	also	RB
18637	21098	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21098	5	Treichler	Treichler	NNP
18637	21098	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21098	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21098	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21098	9	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	21098	10	,	,	,
18637	21098	11	338	338	CD
18637	21098	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21098	13	251	251	CD
18637	21098	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21098	15	1949	1949	CD
18637	21098	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21098	17	;	;	:
18637	21098	18	City	City	NNP
18637	21098	19	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21098	20	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	21098	21	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	21098	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21098	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21098	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	21098	25	_	_	NNP
18637	21098	26	Schnader	Schnader	NNP
18637	21098	27	,	,	,
18637	21098	28	293	293	CD
18637	21098	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21098	30	112	112	CD
18637	21098	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21098	32	1934	1934	CD
18637	21098	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21098	34	.	.	.
18637	21099	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21099	2	517	517	CD
18637	21099	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21099	4	240	240	CD
18637	21099	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21099	6	625	625	CD
18637	21099	7	,	,	,
18637	21099	8	631	631	CD
18637	21099	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21099	10	1916).--A	1916).--a	CD
18637	21099	11	decision	decision	NN
18637	21099	12	rendered	render	VBN
18637	21099	13	in	in	IN
18637	21099	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	21099	15	which	which	WDT
18637	21099	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	21099	17	seemingly	seemingly	RB
18637	21099	18	in	in	IN
18637	21099	19	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	21099	20	was	be	VBD
18637	21099	21	Wachovia	Wachovia	NNP
18637	21099	22	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21099	23	&	&	CC
18637	21099	24	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	21099	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21099	26	_	_	NNP
18637	21099	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	21099	28	_	_	NNP
18637	21099	29	Doughton	Doughton	NNP
18637	21099	30	,	,	,
18637	21099	31	272	272	CD
18637	21099	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21099	33	567	567	CD
18637	21099	34	,	,	,
18637	21099	35	in	in	IN
18637	21099	36	which	which	WDT
18637	21099	37	North	North	NNP
18637	21099	38	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	21099	39	was	be	VBD
18637	21099	40	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	21099	41	from	from	IN
18637	21099	42	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	21099	43	the	the	DT
18637	21099	44	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	21099	45	of	of	IN
18637	21099	46	a	a	DT
18637	21099	47	power	power	NN
18637	21099	48	of	of	IN
18637	21099	49	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	21099	50	through	through	IN
18637	21099	51	a	a	DT
18637	21099	52	will	will	NN
18637	21099	53	executed	execute	VBN
18637	21099	54	therein	therein	RB
18637	21099	55	by	by	IN
18637	21099	56	a	a	DT
18637	21099	57	resident	resident	NN
18637	21099	58	,	,	,
18637	21099	59	when	when	WRB
18637	21099	60	the	the	DT
18637	21099	61	property	property	NN
18637	21099	62	was	be	VBD
18637	21099	63	a	a	DT
18637	21099	64	trust	trust	NN
18637	21099	65	fund	fund	NN
18637	21099	66	in	in	IN
18637	21099	67	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21099	68	created	create	VBN
18637	21099	69	by	by	IN
18637	21099	70	the	the	DT
18637	21099	71	will	will	NN
18637	21099	72	of	of	IN
18637	21099	73	a	a	DT
18637	21099	74	resident	resident	NN
18637	21099	75	of	of	IN
18637	21099	76	the	the	DT
18637	21099	77	latter	latter	JJ
18637	21099	78	State	State	NNP
18637	21099	79	.	.	.
18637	21100	1	One	one	CD
18637	21100	2	of	of	IN
18637	21100	3	the	the	DT
18637	21100	4	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	21100	5	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	21100	6	for	for	IN
18637	21100	7	this	this	DT
18637	21100	8	result	result	NN
18637	21100	9	was	be	VBD
18637	21100	10	that	that	IN
18637	21100	11	by	by	IN
18637	21100	12	the	the	DT
18637	21100	13	law	law	NN
18637	21100	14	of	of	IN
18637	21100	15	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21100	16	the	the	DT
18637	21100	17	property	property	NN
18637	21100	18	involved	involve	VBN
18637	21100	19	was	be	VBD
18637	21100	20	treated	treat	VBN
18637	21100	21	as	as	IN
18637	21100	22	passing	pass	VBG
18637	21100	23	from	from	IN
18637	21100	24	the	the	DT
18637	21100	25	original	original	JJ
18637	21100	26	donor	donor	NN
18637	21100	27	to	to	IN
18637	21100	28	the	the	DT
18637	21100	29	appointee	appointee	NN
18637	21100	30	.	.	.
18637	21101	1	However	however	RB
18637	21101	2	,	,	,
18637	21101	3	this	this	DT
18637	21101	4	holding	holding	NN
18637	21101	5	was	be	VBD
18637	21101	6	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	21101	7	in	in	IN
18637	21101	8	Graves	Graves	NNP
18637	21101	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21101	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	21101	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21101	12	Schmidlapp	Schmidlapp	NNP
18637	21101	13	,	,	,
18637	21101	14	315	315	CD
18637	21101	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21101	16	657	657	CD
18637	21101	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21101	18	1942	1942	CD
18637	21101	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21101	20	.	.	.
18637	21102	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21102	2	518	518	CD
18637	21102	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21102	4	233	233	CD
18637	21102	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21102	6	434	434	CD
18637	21102	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21102	8	1914	1914	CD
18637	21102	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21102	10	.	.	.
18637	21103	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21103	2	519	519	CD
18637	21103	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21103	4	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	21103	5	Island	Island	NNP
18637	21103	6	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	21103	7	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	21103	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21103	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21103	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	21103	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21103	12	Doughton	Doughton	NNP
18637	21103	13	,	,	,
18637	21103	14	270	270	CD
18637	21103	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21103	16	69	69	CD
18637	21103	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21103	18	1926	1926	CD
18637	21103	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21103	20	.	.	.
18637	21104	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21104	2	520	520	CD
18637	21104	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21104	4	277	277	CD
18637	21104	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21104	6	1	1	CD
18637	21104	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21104	8	1928	1928	CD
18637	21104	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21104	10	.	.	.
18637	21105	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21105	2	521	521	CD
18637	21105	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21105	4	First	First	NNP
18637	21105	5	National	National	NNP
18637	21105	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21105	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21105	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21105	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21105	10	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	21105	11	,	,	,
18637	21105	12	284	284	CD
18637	21105	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21105	14	312	312	CD
18637	21105	15	,	,	,
18637	21105	16	330	330	CD
18637	21105	17	-	-	SYM
18637	21105	18	331	331	CD
18637	21105	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21105	20	1932	1932	CD
18637	21105	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21105	22	.	.	.
18637	21106	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21106	2	522	522	CD
18637	21106	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21106	4	280	280	CD
18637	21106	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21106	6	204	204	CD
18637	21106	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21106	8	1930	1930	CD
18637	21106	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21106	10	.	.	.
18637	21107	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21107	2	523	523	CD
18637	21107	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21107	4	188	188	CD
18637	21107	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21107	6	189	189	CD
18637	21107	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21107	8	1903	1903	CD
18637	21107	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21107	10	.	.	.
18637	21108	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21108	2	524	524	CD
18637	21108	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21108	4	281	281	CD
18637	21108	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21108	6	586	586	CD
18637	21108	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21108	8	1930).--In	1930).--in	CD
18637	21108	9	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	21108	10	,	,	,
18637	21108	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21108	12	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	21108	13	observed	observe	VBD
18637	21108	14	that	that	IN
18637	21108	15	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	21108	16	_	_	NNP
18637	21108	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	21108	18	_	_	NNP
18637	21108	19	Sohmer	Sohmer	NNP
18637	21108	20	,	,	,
18637	21108	21	233	233	CD
18637	21108	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21108	23	434	434	CD
18637	21108	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21108	25	1914	1914	CD
18637	21108	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21108	27	,	,	,
18637	21108	28	previously	previously	RB
18637	21108	29	mentioned	mention	VBN
18637	21108	30	,	,	,
18637	21108	31	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	21108	32	joined	join	VBD
18637	21108	33	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
18637	21108	34	_	_	NNP
18637	21108	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	21108	36	_	_	NNP
18637	21108	37	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	21108	38	on	on	IN
18637	21108	39	the	the	DT
18637	21108	40	"	"	``
18637	21108	41	Index	Index	NNP
18637	21108	42	Expurgatorius	Expurgatorius	NNP
18637	21108	43	.	.	.
18637	21108	44	"	"	''
18637	21109	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21109	2	525	525	CD
18637	21109	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21109	4	282	282	CD
18637	21109	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21109	6	1	1	CD
18637	21109	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21109	8	1930	1930	CD
18637	21109	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21109	10	.	.	.
18637	21110	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21110	2	526	526	CD
18637	21110	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21110	4	284	284	CD
18637	21110	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21110	6	312	312	CD
18637	21110	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21110	8	1932	1932	CD
18637	21110	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21110	10	.	.	.
18637	21111	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21111	2	527	527	CD
18637	21111	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21111	4	316	316	CD
18637	21111	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21111	6	174	174	CD
18637	21111	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21111	8	1942	1942	CD
18637	21111	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21111	10	.	.	.
18637	21112	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21112	2	528	528	CD
18637	21112	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21112	4	307	307	CD
18637	21112	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21112	6	357	357	CD
18637	21112	7	,	,	,
18637	21112	8	363	363	CD
18637	21112	9	,	,	,
18637	21112	10	366	366	CD
18637	21112	11	-	-	SYM
18637	21112	12	368	368	CD
18637	21112	13	,	,	,
18637	21112	14	372	372	CD
18637	21112	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21112	16	1939	1939	CD
18637	21112	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21112	18	.	.	.
18637	21113	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21113	2	529	529	CD
18637	21113	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21113	4	308	308	CD
18637	21113	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21113	6	313	313	CD
18637	21113	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21113	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	21113	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21113	10	.	.	.
18637	21114	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21114	2	530	530	CD
18637	21114	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21114	4	307	307	CD
18637	21114	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21114	6	383	383	CD
18637	21114	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21114	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	21114	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21114	10	.	.	.
18637	21115	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21115	2	531	531	CD
18637	21115	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21115	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21115	5	.	.	.
18637	21116	1	386	386	CD
18637	21116	2	.	.	.
18637	21117	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21117	2	532	532	CD
18637	21117	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21117	4	315	315	CD
18637	21117	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21117	6	657	657	CD
18637	21117	7	,	,	,
18637	21117	8	660	660	CD
18637	21117	9	,	,	,
18637	21117	10	661	661	CD
18637	21117	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21117	12	1942	1942	CD
18637	21117	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21117	14	.	.	.
18637	21118	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21118	2	533	533	CD
18637	21118	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21118	4	4	4	CD
18637	21118	5	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	21118	6	.	.	.
18637	21119	1	316	316	CD
18637	21119	2	,	,	,
18637	21119	3	429	429	CD
18637	21119	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21119	5	1819	1819	CD
18637	21119	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21119	7	.	.	.
18637	21120	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21120	2	534	534	CD
18637	21120	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21120	4	319	319	CD
18637	21120	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21120	6	94	94	CD
18637	21120	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21120	8	1943	1943	CD
18637	21120	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21120	10	.	.	.
18637	21121	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21121	2	535	535	CD
18637	21121	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21121	4	306	306	CD
18637	21121	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21121	6	398	398	CD
18637	21121	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21121	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	21121	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21121	10	.	.	.
18637	21122	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21122	2	536	536	CD
18637	21122	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21122	4	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	21122	5	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	21122	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	21122	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21122	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21122	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21122	10	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	21122	11	,	,	,
18637	21122	12	298	298	CD
18637	21122	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21122	14	193	193	CD
18637	21122	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21122	16	1936	1936	CD
18637	21122	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21122	18	.	.	.
18637	21123	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21123	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21123	3	also	also	RB
18637	21123	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21123	5	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	21123	6	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	21123	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21123	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21123	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21123	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21123	11	Beeler	Beeler	NNP
18637	21123	12	,	,	,
18637	21123	13	315	315	CD
18637	21123	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21123	15	649	649	CD
18637	21123	16	,	,	,
18637	21123	17	652	652	CD
18637	21123	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21123	19	1942	1942	CD
18637	21123	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21123	21	.	.	.
18637	21124	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21124	2	537	537	CD
18637	21124	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21124	4	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	21124	5	Express	Express	NNP
18637	21124	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21124	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21124	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21124	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21124	10	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	21124	11	State	State	NNP
18637	21124	12	Auditor	Auditor	NNP
18637	21124	13	,	,	,
18637	21124	14	165	165	CD
18637	21124	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21124	16	194	194	CD
18637	21124	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21124	18	1897	1897	CD
18637	21124	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21124	20	.	.	.
18637	21125	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21125	2	538	538	CD
18637	21125	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21125	4	Alpha	Alpha	NNP
18637	21125	5	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	21125	6	Cement	Cement	NNP
18637	21125	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21125	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21125	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21125	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21125	11	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21125	12	,	,	,
18637	21125	13	268	268	CD
18637	21125	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21125	15	203	203	CD
18637	21125	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21125	17	1925	1925	CD
18637	21125	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21125	19	.	.	.
18637	21126	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21126	2	539	539	CD
18637	21126	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21126	4	Cream	Cream	NNP
18637	21126	5	of	of	IN
18637	21126	6	Wheat	Wheat	NNP
18637	21126	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21126	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21126	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21126	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21126	11	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	21126	12	Forks	Forks	NNP
18637	21126	13	County	County	NNP
18637	21126	14	,	,	,
18637	21126	15	253	253	CD
18637	21126	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21126	17	325	325	CD
18637	21126	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21126	19	1920	1920	CD
18637	21126	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21126	21	.	.	.
18637	21127	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21127	2	540	540	CD
18637	21127	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21127	4	Newark	Newark	NNP
18637	21127	5	Fire	Fire	NNP
18637	21127	6	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	21127	7	.	.	.
18637	21128	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21128	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21128	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21128	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21128	5	State	State	NNP
18637	21128	6	Board	Board	NNP
18637	21128	7	,	,	,
18637	21128	8	307	307	CD
18637	21128	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21128	10	313	313	CD
18637	21128	11	,	,	,
18637	21128	12	318	318	CD
18637	21128	13	,	,	,
18637	21128	14	324	324	CD
18637	21128	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21128	16	1939	1939	CD
18637	21128	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21128	18	.	.	.
18637	21129	1	Although	although	IN
18637	21129	2	the	the	DT
18637	21129	3	eight	eight	CD
18637	21129	4	judges	judge	NNS
18637	21129	5	affirming	affirm	VBG
18637	21129	6	this	this	DT
18637	21129	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	21129	8	were	be	VBD
18637	21129	9	not	not	RB
18637	21129	10	in	in	IN
18637	21129	11	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	21129	12	as	as	IN
18637	21129	13	to	to	IN
18637	21129	14	the	the	DT
18637	21129	15	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	21129	16	to	to	TO
18637	21129	17	be	be	VB
18637	21129	18	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	21129	19	in	in	IN
18637	21129	20	justification	justification	NN
18637	21129	21	of	of	IN
18637	21129	22	this	this	DT
18637	21129	23	result	result	NN
18637	21129	24	,	,	,
18637	21129	25	the	the	DT
18637	21129	26	holding	holding	NN
18637	21129	27	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	21129	28	to	to	TO
18637	21129	29	be	be	VB
18637	21129	30	in	in	IN
18637	21129	31	line	line	NN
18637	21129	32	with	with	IN
18637	21129	33	the	the	DT
18637	21129	34	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	21129	35	uttered	utter	VBN
18637	21129	36	by	by	IN
18637	21129	37	the	the	DT
18637	21129	38	late	late	JJ
18637	21129	39	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	21129	40	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21129	41	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	21129	42	in	in	IN
18637	21129	43	Curry	Curry	NNP
18637	21129	44	_	_	NNP
18637	21129	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	21129	46	_	_	NNP
18637	21129	47	McCanless	McCanless	NNP
18637	21129	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21129	49	307	307	CD
18637	21129	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21129	51	at	at	IN
18637	21129	52	368	368	CD
18637	21129	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21129	54	to	to	IN
18637	21129	55	the	the	DT
18637	21129	56	effect	effect	NN
18637	21129	57	that	that	IN
18637	21129	58	the	the	DT
18637	21129	59	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	21129	60	of	of	IN
18637	21129	61	a	a	DT
18637	21129	62	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	21129	63	by	by	IN
18637	21129	64	a	a	DT
18637	21129	65	State	state	NN
18637	21129	66	where	where	WRB
18637	21129	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21129	68	does	do	VBZ
18637	21129	69	business	business	NN
18637	21129	70	,	,	,
18637	21129	71	measured	measure	VBN
18637	21129	72	by	by	IN
18637	21129	73	the	the	DT
18637	21129	74	value	value	NN
18637	21129	75	of	of	IN
18637	21129	76	the	the	DT
18637	21129	77	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	21129	78	used	use	VBN
18637	21129	79	in	in	IN
18637	21129	80	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21129	81	business	business	NN
18637	21129	82	there	there	RB
18637	21129	83	,	,	,
18637	21129	84	does	do	VBZ
18637	21129	85	not	not	RB
18637	21129	86	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	21129	87	the	the	DT
18637	21129	88	State	state	NN
18637	21129	89	of	of	IN
18637	21129	90	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	21129	91	from	from	IN
18637	21129	92	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	21129	93	a	a	DT
18637	21129	94	tax	tax	NN
18637	21129	95	measured	measure	VBN
18637	21129	96	by	by	IN
18637	21129	97	all	all	DT
18637	21129	98	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21129	99	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	21129	100	.	.	.
18637	21130	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21130	2	541	541	CD
18637	21130	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21130	4	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	21130	5	L.	L.	NNP
18637	21130	6	&	&	CC
18637	21130	7	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	21130	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21130	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21130	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	21130	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21130	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21130	13	,	,	,
18637	21130	14	198	198	CD
18637	21130	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21130	16	341	341	CD
18637	21130	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21130	18	1905	1905	CD
18637	21130	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21130	20	.	.	.
18637	21131	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21131	2	542	542	CD
18637	21131	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21131	4	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	21131	5	&	&	CC
18637	21131	6	J.	J.	NNP
18637	21132	1	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	21132	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21132	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21132	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	21132	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21132	6	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21132	7	,	,	,
18637	21132	8	188	188	CD
18637	21132	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21132	10	385	385	CD
18637	21132	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21132	12	1903	1903	CD
18637	21132	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21132	14	.	.	.
18637	21133	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21133	2	543	543	CD
18637	21133	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21133	4	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	21133	5	City	City	NNP
18637	21133	6	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	21133	7	.	.	.
18637	21134	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21134	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	21134	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21134	4	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	21134	5	,	,	,
18637	21134	6	240	240	CD
18637	21134	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21134	8	227	227	CD
18637	21134	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21134	10	1916	1916	CD
18637	21134	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21134	12	;	;	:
18637	21134	13	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	21134	14	City	City	NNP
18637	21134	15	,	,	,
18637	21134	16	M.	M.	NNP
18637	21134	17	&	&	CC
18637	21134	18	B.R.	B.R.	NNP
18637	21135	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21135	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21135	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21135	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21135	5	Stiles	Stiles	NNP
18637	21135	6	,	,	,
18637	21135	7	242	242	CD
18637	21135	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21135	9	111	111	CD
18637	21135	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21135	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	21135	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21135	13	.	.	.
18637	21136	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21136	2	544	544	CD
18637	21136	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21136	4	Schwab	Schwab	NNP
18637	21136	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21136	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21136	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21136	8	Richardson	Richardson	NNP
18637	21136	9	,	,	,
18637	21136	10	263	263	CD
18637	21136	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21136	12	88	88	CD
18637	21136	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21136	14	1923	1923	CD
18637	21136	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21136	16	.	.	.
18637	21137	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21137	2	545	545	CD
18637	21137	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21137	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	21137	5	U.	U.	NNP
18637	21137	6	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	21137	7	.	.	.
18637	21138	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21138	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21138	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21138	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21138	5	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	21138	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	21138	7	rel	rel	NNP
18637	21138	8	.	.	.
18637	21139	1	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	21139	2	,	,	,
18637	21139	3	216	216	CD
18637	21139	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21139	5	1	1	CD
18637	21139	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21139	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	21139	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21139	9	;	;	:
18637	21139	10	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	21139	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21139	12	_	_	NNP
18637	21139	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	21139	14	_	_	NNP
18637	21139	15	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	21139	16	ex	ex	NNP
18637	21139	17	rel	rel	NNP
18637	21139	18	.	.	.
18637	21140	1	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	21140	2	,	,	,
18637	21140	3	216	216	CD
18637	21140	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21140	5	56	56	CD
18637	21140	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21140	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	21140	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21140	9	;	;	:
18637	21140	10	Looney	Looney	NNP
18637	21140	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21140	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	21140	13	_	_	NNP
18637	21140	14	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	21140	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21140	16	,	,	,
18637	21140	17	245	245	CD
18637	21140	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21140	19	178	178	CD
18637	21140	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21140	21	1917	1917	CD
18637	21140	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21140	23	;	;	:
18637	21140	24	International	International	NNP
18637	21140	25	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	21140	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21140	27	_	_	NNP
18637	21140	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	21140	29	_	_	NNP
18637	21140	30	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21140	31	,	,	,
18637	21140	32	246	246	CD
18637	21140	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21140	34	135	135	CD
18637	21140	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21140	36	1918	1918	CD
18637	21140	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21140	38	.	.	.
18637	21141	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21141	2	546	546	CD
18637	21141	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21141	4	Cudahy	Cudahy	NNP
18637	21141	5	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	21141	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21141	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21141	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21141	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21141	10	Hinkle	Hinkle	NNP
18637	21141	11	,	,	,
18637	21141	12	278	278	CD
18637	21141	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21141	14	460	460	CD
18637	21141	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21141	16	1929	1929	CD
18637	21141	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21141	18	.	.	.
18637	21142	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21142	2	547	547	CD
18637	21142	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21142	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21142	5	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	21142	6	S.W.R.	S.W.R.	NNP
18637	21143	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21143	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21143	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21143	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21143	5	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	21143	6	ex	ex	VBD
18637	21143	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	21143	8	.	.	.
18637	21144	1	Norwood	Norwood	NNP
18637	21144	2	,	,	,
18637	21144	3	235	235	CD
18637	21144	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21144	5	350	350	CD
18637	21144	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21144	7	1914	1914	CD
18637	21144	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21144	9	.	.	.
18637	21145	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21145	2	548	548	CD
18637	21145	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21145	4	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	21145	5	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	21145	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21145	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21145	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21145	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21145	10	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	21145	11	,	,	,
18637	21145	12	302	302	CD
18637	21145	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21145	14	22	22	CD
18637	21145	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21145	16	1937	1937	CD
18637	21145	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21145	18	.	.	.
18637	21146	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21146	2	549	549	CD
18637	21146	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21146	4	American	American	NNP
18637	21146	5	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	21146	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21146	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21146	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21146	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21146	10	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21146	11	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	21146	12	,	,	,
18637	21146	13	250	250	CD
18637	21146	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21146	15	459	459	CD
18637	21146	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21146	17	1919	1919	CD
18637	21146	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21146	19	.	.	.
18637	21147	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	21147	2	does	do	VBZ
18637	21147	3	a	a	DT
18637	21147	4	State	state	NN
18637	21147	5	license	license	NN
18637	21147	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	21147	7	on	on	IN
18637	21147	8	the	the	DT
18637	21147	9	production	production	NN
18637	21147	10	of	of	IN
18637	21147	11	electricity	electricity	NN
18637	21147	12	violate	violate	VBP
18637	21147	13	the	the	DT
18637	21147	14	due	due	JJ
18637	21147	15	process	process	NN
18637	21147	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	21147	17	because	because	IN
18637	21147	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21147	19	may	may	MD
18637	21147	20	be	be	VB
18637	21147	21	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	21147	22	,	,	,
18637	21147	23	to	to	TO
18637	21147	24	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	21147	25	,	,	,
18637	21147	26	as	as	IN
18637	21147	27	an	an	DT
18637	21147	28	element	element	NN
18637	21147	29	in	in	IN
18637	21147	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21147	31	computation	computation	NN
18637	21147	32	,	,	,
18637	21147	33	the	the	DT
18637	21147	34	amounts	amount	NNS
18637	21147	35	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	21147	36	in	in	IN
18637	21147	37	another	another	DT
18637	21147	38	jurisdiction.--Utah	jurisdiction.--Utah	NNP
18637	21147	39	Power	Power	NNP
18637	21147	40	&	&	CC
18637	21147	41	Light	Light	NNP
18637	21147	42	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21147	43	_	_	NNP
18637	21147	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	21147	45	_	_	NNP
18637	21147	46	Pfost	Pfost	NNP
18637	21147	47	,	,	,
18637	21147	48	286	286	CD
18637	21147	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21147	50	165	165	CD
18637	21147	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21147	52	1932	1932	CD
18637	21147	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21147	54	.	.	.
18637	21148	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21148	2	550	550	CD
18637	21148	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21148	4	James	James	NNP
18637	21148	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21148	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21148	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21148	8	Dravo	Dravo	NNP
18637	21148	9	Contracting	Contracting	NNP
18637	21148	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21148	11	302	302	CD
18637	21148	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21148	13	134	134	CD
18637	21148	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21148	15	1937	1937	CD
18637	21148	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21148	17	.	.	.
18637	21149	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21149	2	551	551	CD
18637	21149	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21149	4	Union	Union	NNP
18637	21149	5	Refrigerator	Refrigerator	NNP
18637	21149	6	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	21149	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21149	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21149	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21149	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21149	11	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21149	12	,	,	,
18637	21149	13	199	199	CD
18637	21149	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21149	15	194	194	CD
18637	21149	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21149	17	1905	1905	CD
18637	21149	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21149	19	.	.	.
18637	21150	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21150	2	552	552	CD
18637	21150	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21150	4	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	21150	5	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	21150	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21150	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21150	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21150	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21150	10	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21150	11	,	,	,
18637	21150	12	222	222	CD
18637	21150	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21150	14	63	63	CD
18637	21150	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21150	16	1911	1911	CD
18637	21150	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21150	18	.	.	.
18637	21151	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21151	2	553	553	CD
18637	21151	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21151	4	Old	Old	NNP
18637	21151	5	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	21151	6	Steamship	Steamship	NNP
18637	21151	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21151	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21151	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21151	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21151	11	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	21151	12	,	,	,
18637	21151	13	198	198	CD
18637	21151	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21151	15	299	299	CD
18637	21151	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21151	17	1905	1905	CD
18637	21151	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21151	19	.	.	.
18637	21152	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21152	2	554	554	CD
18637	21152	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21152	4	199	199	CD
18637	21152	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21152	6	194	194	CD
18637	21152	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21152	8	1905	1905	CD
18637	21152	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21152	10	.	.	.
18637	21153	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21153	2	555	555	CD
18637	21153	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21153	4	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	21153	5	's	's	POS
18637	21153	6	Palace	Palace	NNP
18637	21153	7	Car	Car	NNP
18637	21153	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21153	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21153	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	21153	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21153	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21153	13	,	,	,
18637	21153	14	141	141	CD
18637	21153	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21153	16	18	18	CD
18637	21153	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21153	18	1891	1891	CD
18637	21153	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21153	20	.	.	.
18637	21154	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21154	2	556	556	CD
18637	21154	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21154	4	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	21154	5	Airlines	Airlines	NNPS
18637	21154	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21154	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21154	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21154	9	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	21154	10	,	,	,
18637	21154	11	322	322	CD
18637	21154	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21154	13	292	292	CD
18637	21154	14	,	,	,
18637	21154	15	294	294	CD
18637	21154	16	-	-	SYM
18637	21154	17	297	297	CD
18637	21154	18	,	,	,
18637	21154	19	307	307	CD
18637	21154	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21154	21	1944).--The	1944).--the	CD
18637	21154	22	case	case	NN
18637	21154	23	was	be	VBD
18637	21154	24	said	say	VBN
18637	21154	25	to	to	TO
18637	21154	26	be	be	VB
18637	21154	27	governed	govern	VBN
18637	21154	28	by	by	IN
18637	21154	29	New	New	NNP
18637	21154	30	York	York	NNP
18637	21154	31	Central	Central	NNP
18637	21154	32	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	21154	33	_	_	NNP
18637	21154	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	21154	35	_	_	NNP
18637	21154	36	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	21154	37	,	,	,
18637	21154	38	202	202	CD
18637	21154	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21154	40	584	584	CD
18637	21154	41	,	,	,
18637	21154	42	596	596	CD
18637	21154	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21154	44	1906	1906	CD
18637	21154	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21154	46	.	.	.
18637	21155	1	As	as	IN
18637	21155	2	to	to	IN
18637	21155	3	the	the	DT
18637	21155	4	problem	problem	NN
18637	21155	5	of	of	IN
18637	21155	6	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	21155	7	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	21155	8	of	of	IN
18637	21155	9	such	such	JJ
18637	21155	10	airplanes	airplane	NNS
18637	21155	11	,	,	,
18637	21155	12	which	which	WDT
18637	21155	13	had	have	VBD
18637	21155	14	in	in	IN
18637	21155	15	fact	fact	NN
18637	21155	16	been	be	VBN
18637	21155	17	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	21155	18	proportionately	proportionately	RB
18637	21155	19	by	by	IN
18637	21155	20	other	other	JJ
18637	21155	21	States	States	NNPS
18637	21155	22	,	,	,
18637	21155	23	the	the	DT
18637	21155	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21155	25	declared	declare	VBD
18637	21155	26	that	that	IN
18637	21155	27	the	the	DT
18637	21155	28	"	"	``
18637	21155	29	taxability	taxability	NN
18637	21155	30	of	of	IN
18637	21155	31	any	any	DT
18637	21155	32	part	part	NN
18637	21155	33	of	of	IN
18637	21155	34	this	this	DT
18637	21155	35	fleet	fleet	NN
18637	21155	36	by	by	IN
18637	21155	37	any	any	DT
18637	21155	38	other	other	JJ
18637	21155	39	State	State	NNP
18637	21155	40	than	than	IN
18637	21155	41	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	21155	42	,	,	,
18637	21155	43	in	in	IN
18637	21155	44	view	view	NN
18637	21155	45	of	of	IN
18637	21155	46	the	the	DT
18637	21155	47	taxability	taxability	NN
18637	21155	48	of	of	IN
18637	21155	49	the	the	DT
18637	21155	50	entire	entire	JJ
18637	21155	51	fleet	fleet	NN
18637	21155	52	by	by	IN
18637	21155	53	that	that	DT
18637	21155	54	State	State	NNP
18637	21155	55	,	,	,
18637	21155	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	21155	57	not	not	RB
18637	21155	58	now	now	RB
18637	21155	59	before	before	IN
18637	21155	60	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21155	61	.	.	.
18637	21155	62	"	"	''
18637	21156	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21156	2	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	21156	3	,	,	,
18637	21156	4	in	in	IN
18637	21156	5	a	a	DT
18637	21156	6	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	21156	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21156	8	,	,	,
18637	21156	9	would	would	MD
18637	21156	10	treat	treat	VB
18637	21156	11	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	21156	12	's	's	POS
18637	21156	13	right	right	NN
18637	21156	14	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21156	15	to	to	TO
18637	21156	16	tax	tax	NN
18637	21156	17	as	as	IN
18637	21156	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21156	19	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	21156	20	of	of	IN
18637	21156	21	any	any	DT
18637	21156	22	similar	similar	JJ
18637	21156	23	right	right	RB
18637	21156	24	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
18637	21156	25	.	.	.
18637	21157	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21157	2	557	557	CD
18637	21157	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21157	4	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	21157	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	21157	6	Ref	Ref	NNP
18637	21157	7	.	.	.
18637	21158	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21158	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21158	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21158	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21158	5	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	21158	6	ex	ex	NN
18637	21158	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	21158	8	.	.	.
18637	21159	1	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	21159	2	,	,	,
18637	21159	3	290	290	CD
18637	21159	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21159	5	158	158	CD
18637	21159	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21159	7	1933	1933	CD
18637	21159	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21159	9	.	.	.
18637	21160	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21160	2	558	558	CD
18637	21160	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21160	4	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	21160	5	,	,	,
18637	21160	6	C.C.	C.C.	NNP
18637	21161	1	&	&	CC
18637	21161	2	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21161	3	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	21162	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21162	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21162	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21162	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21162	5	Backus	Backus	NNP
18637	21162	6	,	,	,
18637	21162	7	154	154	CD
18637	21162	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21162	9	421	421	CD
18637	21162	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21162	11	1894	1894	CD
18637	21162	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21162	13	.	.	.
18637	21163	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21163	2	559	559	CD
18637	21163	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21163	4	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	21163	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21163	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21163	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21163	8	Hines	Hines	NNP
18637	21163	9	,	,	,
18637	21163	10	253	253	CD
18637	21163	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21163	12	66	66	CD
18637	21163	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21163	14	1920).--For	1920).--for	CD
18637	21163	15	example	example	NN
18637	21163	16	,	,	,
18637	21163	17	the	the	DT
18637	21163	18	ratio	ratio	NN
18637	21163	19	of	of	IN
18637	21163	20	track	track	NN
18637	21163	21	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	21163	22	within	within	IN
18637	21163	23	the	the	DT
18637	21163	24	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	21163	25	State	state	NN
18637	21163	26	to	to	TO
18637	21163	27	total	total	JJ
18637	21163	28	track	track	NN
18637	21163	29	mileage	mileage	NN
18637	21163	30	can	can	MD
18637	21163	31	not	not	RB
18637	21163	32	be	be	VB
18637	21163	33	employed	employ	VBN
18637	21163	34	in	in	IN
18637	21163	35	evaluating	evaluate	VBG
18637	21163	36	that	that	DT
18637	21163	37	portion	portion	NN
18637	21163	38	of	of	IN
18637	21163	39	total	total	JJ
18637	21163	40	railway	railway	NN
18637	21163	41	property	property	NN
18637	21163	42	found	find	VBN
18637	21163	43	in	in	IN
18637	21163	44	said	say	VBD
18637	21163	45	State	state	NN
18637	21163	46	when	when	WRB
18637	21163	47	the	the	DT
18637	21163	48	cost	cost	NN
18637	21163	49	of	of	IN
18637	21163	50	the	the	DT
18637	21163	51	lines	line	NNS
18637	21163	52	in	in	IN
18637	21163	53	the	the	DT
18637	21163	54	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	21163	55	State	state	NN
18637	21163	56	was	be	VBD
18637	21163	57	much	much	RB
18637	21163	58	less	less	JJR
18637	21163	59	than	than	IN
18637	21163	60	in	in	IN
18637	21163	61	other	other	JJ
18637	21163	62	States	States	NNPS
18637	21163	63	and	and	CC
18637	21163	64	the	the	DT
18637	21163	65	most	most	RBS
18637	21163	66	valuable	valuable	JJ
18637	21163	67	terminals	terminal	NNS
18637	21163	68	of	of	IN
18637	21163	69	the	the	DT
18637	21163	70	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	21163	71	were	be	VBD
18637	21163	72	located	locate	VBN
18637	21163	73	in	in	IN
18637	21163	74	other	other	JJ
18637	21163	75	States	States	NNPS
18637	21163	76	.	.	.
18637	21164	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21164	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21164	3	also	also	RB
18637	21164	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21164	5	Fargo	Fargo	NNP
18637	21164	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21164	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21164	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21164	9	Hart	Hart	NNP
18637	21164	10	,	,	,
18637	21164	11	193	193	CD
18637	21164	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21164	13	490	490	CD
18637	21164	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21164	15	1904	1904	CD
18637	21164	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21164	17	;	;	:
18637	21164	18	Union	Union	NNP
18637	21164	19	Tank	Tank	NNP
18637	21164	20	Line	Line	NNP
18637	21164	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21164	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	21164	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21164	24	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	21164	25	,	,	,
18637	21164	26	249	249	CD
18637	21164	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21164	28	275	275	CD
18637	21164	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21164	30	1919	1919	CD
18637	21164	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21164	32	.	.	.
18637	21165	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21165	2	560	560	CD
18637	21165	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21165	4	Great	Great	NNP
18637	21165	5	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	21165	6	R.	R.	NNP
18637	21165	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21165	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21165	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21165	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21165	11	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	21165	12	,	,	,
18637	21165	13	278	278	CD
18637	21165	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21165	15	503	503	CD
18637	21165	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21165	17	1929	1929	CD
18637	21165	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21165	19	.	.	.
18637	21166	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21166	2	561	561	CD
18637	21166	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21166	4	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	21166	5	Cent	Cent	NNP
18637	21166	6	.	.	.
18637	21167	1	R.	R.	NNP
18637	21167	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21167	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21167	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	21167	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21167	6	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	21167	7	,	,	,
18637	21167	8	309	309	CD
18637	21167	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21167	10	157	157	CD
18637	21167	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21167	12	1940	1940	CD
18637	21167	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21167	14	.	.	.
18637	21168	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21168	2	562	562	CD
18637	21168	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21168	4	Lawrence	Lawrence	NNP
18637	21168	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21168	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21168	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21168	8	State	State	NNP
18637	21168	9	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	21168	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	21168	11	,	,	,
18637	21168	12	286	286	CD
18637	21168	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21168	14	276	276	CD
18637	21168	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21168	16	1932	1932	CD
18637	21168	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21168	18	.	.	.
18637	21169	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21169	2	563	563	CD
18637	21169	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21169	4	Shaffer	Shaffer	NNP
18637	21169	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21169	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21169	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21169	8	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	21169	9	,	,	,
18637	21169	10	252	252	CD
18637	21169	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21169	12	37	37	CD
18637	21169	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21169	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	21169	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21169	16	;	;	:
18637	21169	17	Travis	Travis	NNP
18637	21169	18	_	_	NNP
18637	21169	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	21169	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21169	21	Yale	Yale	NNP
18637	21169	22	&	&	CC
18637	21169	23	T.	T.	NNP
18637	21169	24	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	21169	25	.	.	.
18637	21170	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21170	2	,	,	,
18637	21170	3	252	252	CD
18637	21170	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21170	5	60	60	CD
18637	21170	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21170	7	1920	1920	CD
18637	21170	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21170	9	.	.	.
18637	21171	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21171	2	564	564	CD
18637	21171	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21171	4	New	New	NNP
18637	21171	5	York	York	NNP
18637	21171	6	ex	ex	NN
18637	21171	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	21171	8	.	.	.
18637	21172	1	Cohn	Cohn	NNP
18637	21172	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21172	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21172	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21172	5	Graves	Graves	NNP
18637	21172	6	,	,	,
18637	21172	7	300	300	CD
18637	21172	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21172	9	308	308	CD
18637	21172	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21172	11	1937	1937	CD
18637	21172	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21172	13	.	.	.
18637	21173	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21173	2	565	565	CD
18637	21173	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21173	4	Maguire	Maguire	NNP
18637	21173	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21173	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21173	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21173	8	Trefry	Trefry	NNP
18637	21173	9	,	,	,
18637	21173	10	253	253	CD
18637	21173	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21173	12	12	12	CD
18637	21173	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21173	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	21173	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21173	16	.	.	.
18637	21174	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21174	2	566	566	CD
18637	21174	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21174	4	Guaranty	Guaranty	NNP
18637	21174	5	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	21174	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21174	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21174	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21174	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21174	10	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	21174	11	,	,	,
18637	21174	12	305	305	CD
18637	21174	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21174	14	19	19	CD
18637	21174	15	,	,	,
18637	21174	16	23	23	CD
18637	21174	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21174	18	1938	1938	CD
18637	21174	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21174	20	.	.	.
18637	21175	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21175	2	567	567	CD
18637	21175	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21175	4	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	21175	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21175	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21175	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21175	8	Graves	Graves	NNP
18637	21175	9	,	,	,
18637	21175	10	299	299	CD
18637	21175	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21175	12	366	366	CD
18637	21175	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21175	14	1937	1937	CD
18637	21175	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21175	16	.	.	.
18637	21176	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21176	2	568	568	CD
18637	21176	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21176	4	Underwood	Underwood	NNP
18637	21176	5	Typewriter	Typewriter	NNP
18637	21176	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21176	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21176	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21176	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21176	10	Chamberlain	Chamberlain	NNP
18637	21176	11	,	,	,
18637	21176	12	254	254	CD
18637	21176	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21176	14	113	113	CD
18637	21176	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21176	16	1920	1920	CD
18637	21176	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21176	18	;	;	:
18637	21176	19	Bass	Bass	NNP
18637	21176	20	,	,	,
18637	21176	21	Ratcliff	Ratcliff	NNP
18637	21176	22	&	&	CC
18637	21176	23	Gretton	Gretton	NNP
18637	21176	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21176	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	21176	26	_	_	NNP
18637	21176	27	State	State	NNP
18637	21176	28	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	21176	29	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	21176	30	,	,	,
18637	21176	31	266	266	CD
18637	21176	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21176	33	271	271	CD
18637	21176	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21176	35	1924	1924	CD
18637	21176	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21176	37	.	.	.
18637	21177	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21177	2	569	569	CD
18637	21177	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21177	4	Hans	Hans	NNP
18637	21177	5	Rees	Rees	NNPS
18637	21177	6	'	'	POS
18637	21177	7	Sons	Sons	NNPS
18637	21177	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21177	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21177	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21177	11	North	North	NNP
18637	21177	12	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	21177	13	,	,	,
18637	21177	14	283	283	CD
18637	21177	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21177	16	123	123	CD
18637	21177	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21177	18	1931	1931	CD
18637	21177	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21177	20	.	.	.
18637	21178	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21178	2	570	570	CD
18637	21178	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21178	4	Matson	Matson	NNP
18637	21178	5	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	21178	6	.	.	.
18637	21179	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21179	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21179	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21179	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21179	5	State	State	NNP
18637	21179	6	Board	Board	NNP
18637	21179	7	,	,	,
18637	21179	8	297	297	CD
18637	21179	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21179	10	441	441	CD
18637	21179	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21179	12	1936	1936	CD
18637	21179	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21179	14	.	.	.
18637	21180	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21180	2	571	571	CD
18637	21180	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21180	4	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	21180	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21180	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21180	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21180	8	J.C.	J.C.	NNP
18637	21180	9	Penney	Penney	NNP
18637	21180	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21180	11	,	,	,
18637	21180	12	311	311	CD
18637	21180	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21180	14	435	435	CD
18637	21180	15	,	,	,
18637	21180	16	448	448	CD
18637	21180	17	-	-	SYM
18637	21180	18	449	449	CD
18637	21180	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21180	20	1940	1940	CD
18637	21180	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21180	22	.	.	.
18637	21181	1	Dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	21181	2	,	,	,
18637	21181	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21181	4	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	21181	5	,	,	,
18637	21181	6	along	along	IN
18637	21181	7	with	with	IN
18637	21181	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	21181	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21181	10	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	21181	11	and	and	CC
18637	21181	12	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21181	13	McReynolds	McReynolds	NNP
18637	21181	14	and	and	CC
18637	21181	15	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	21181	16	,	,	,
18637	21181	17	stressed	stress	VBD
18637	21181	18	the	the	DT
18637	21181	19	fact	fact	NN
18637	21181	20	that	that	IN
18637	21181	21	the	the	DT
18637	21181	22	use	use	NN
18637	21181	23	and	and	CC
18637	21181	24	disbursement	disbursement	NN
18637	21181	25	by	by	IN
18637	21181	26	the	the	DT
18637	21181	27	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	21181	28	at	at	IN
18637	21181	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21181	30	home	home	NN
18637	21181	31	office	office	NN
18637	21181	32	of	of	IN
18637	21181	33	income	income	NN
18637	21181	34	derived	derive	VBN
18637	21181	35	from	from	IN
18637	21181	36	operations	operation	NNS
18637	21181	37	in	in	IN
18637	21181	38	many	many	JJ
18637	21181	39	States	States	NNPS
18637	21181	40	does	do	VBZ
18637	21181	41	not	not	RB
18637	21181	42	depend	depend	VB
18637	21181	43	on	on	IN
18637	21181	44	,	,	,
18637	21181	45	and	and	CC
18637	21181	46	can	can	MD
18637	21181	47	not	not	RB
18637	21181	48	be	be	VB
18637	21181	49	controlled	control	VBN
18637	21181	50	by	by	IN
18637	21181	51	,	,	,
18637	21181	52	any	any	DT
18637	21181	53	law	law	NN
18637	21181	54	of	of	IN
18637	21181	55	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	21181	56	.	.	.
18637	21182	1	The	the	DT
18637	21182	2	act	act	NN
18637	21182	3	of	of	IN
18637	21182	4	disbursing	disburse	VBG
18637	21182	5	such	such	JJ
18637	21182	6	income	income	NN
18637	21182	7	as	as	IN
18637	21182	8	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	21182	9	,	,	,
18637	21182	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21182	11	contended	contend	VBD
18637	21182	12	,	,	,
18637	21182	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	21182	14	"	"	``
18637	21182	15	one	one	CD
18637	21182	16	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	21182	17	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	21182	18	the	the	DT
18637	21182	19	reach	reach	NN
18637	21182	20	of	of	IN
18637	21182	21	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	21182	22	's	's	POS
18637	21182	23	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	21182	24	power	power	NN
18637	21182	25	,	,	,
18637	21182	26	one	one	CD
18637	21182	27	which	which	WDT
18637	21182	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21182	29	can	can	MD
18637	21182	30	not	not	RB
18637	21182	31	effectively	effectively	RB
18637	21182	32	command	command	VB
18637	21182	33	,	,	,
18637	21182	34	or	or	CC
18637	21182	35	prohibit	prohibit	NN
18637	21182	36	or	or	CC
18637	21182	37	condition	condition	NN
18637	21182	38	.	.	.
18637	21182	39	"	"	''
18637	21183	1	The	the	DT
18637	21183	2	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	21183	3	that	that	IN
18637	21183	4	a	a	DT
18637	21183	5	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	21183	6	of	of	IN
18637	21183	7	the	the	DT
18637	21183	8	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	21183	9	distributed	distribute	VBN
18637	21183	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	21183	11	paid	pay	VBN
18637	21183	12	out	out	IN
18637	21183	13	of	of	IN
18637	21183	14	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	21183	15	in	in	IN
18637	21183	16	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	21183	17	for	for	IN
18637	21183	18	the	the	DT
18637	21183	19	year	year	NN
18637	21183	20	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	21183	21	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	21183	22	payment	payment	NN
18637	21183	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	21183	24	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	21183	25	and	and	CC
18637	21183	26	not	not	RB
18637	21183	27	borne	bear	VBN
18637	21183	28	out	out	RP
18637	21183	29	by	by	IN
18637	21183	30	the	the	DT
18637	21183	31	facts	fact	NNS
18637	21183	32	.	.	.
18637	21184	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	21184	2	,	,	,
18637	21184	3	"	"	``
18637	21184	4	if	if	IN
18637	21184	5	the	the	DT
18637	21184	6	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	21184	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	21184	8	an	an	DT
18637	21184	9	income	income	NN
18637	21184	10	tax	tax	NN
18637	21184	11	in	in	IN
18637	21184	12	any	any	DT
18637	21184	13	sense	sense	NN
18637	21184	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21184	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	21184	16	such	such	JJ
18637	21184	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	21184	18	the	the	DT
18637	21184	19	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	21184	20	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21184	21	many	many	JJ
18637	21184	22	of	of	IN
18637	21184	23	whom	whom	WP
18637	21184	24	are	be	VBP
18637	21184	25	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	21184	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21184	27	and	and	CC
18637	21184	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	21184	29	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	21184	30	bad	bad	JJ
18637	21184	31	.	.	.
18637	21184	32	"	"	''
18637	21185	1	--_See	--_See	:
18637	21185	2	also	also	RB
18637	21185	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21185	4	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	21185	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21185	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21185	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21185	8	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	21185	9	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	21185	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21185	11	,	,	,
18637	21185	12	311	311	CD
18637	21185	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21185	14	452	452	CD
18637	21185	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21185	16	1940	1940	CD
18637	21185	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21185	18	.	.	.
18637	21186	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21186	2	572	572	CD
18637	21186	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21186	4	Great	great	JJ
18637	21186	5	A.	a.	NN
18637	21187	1	&	&	CC
18637	21187	2	P.	P.	NNP
18637	21187	3	Tea	Tea	NNP
18637	21187	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21187	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21187	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21187	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21187	8	Grosjean	Grosjean	NNP
18637	21187	9	,	,	,
18637	21187	10	301	301	CD
18637	21187	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21187	12	412	412	CD
18637	21187	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21187	14	1937	1937	CD
18637	21187	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21187	16	.	.	.
18637	21188	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21188	2	573	573	CD
18637	21188	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21188	4	Equitable	Equitable	NNP
18637	21188	5	L.	L.	NNP
18637	21188	6	Assur	Assur	NNP
18637	21188	7	.	.	.
18637	21189	1	Soc	Soc	NNP
18637	21189	2	.	.	.
18637	21190	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21190	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	21190	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21190	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21190	5	,	,	,
18637	21190	6	238	238	CD
18637	21190	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21190	8	143	143	CD
18637	21190	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21190	10	1915	1915	CD
18637	21190	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21190	12	.	.	.
18637	21191	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21191	2	574	574	CD
18637	21191	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21191	4	Provident	Provident	NNP
18637	21191	5	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	21191	6	.	.	.
18637	21192	1	Life	Life	NNP
18637	21192	2	Assur	Assur	NNP
18637	21192	3	.	.	.
18637	21193	1	Soc	Soc	NNP
18637	21193	2	.	.	.
18637	21194	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21194	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	21194	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21194	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21194	5	,	,	,
18637	21194	6	239	239	CD
18637	21194	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21194	8	103	103	CD
18637	21194	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21194	10	1915	1915	CD
18637	21194	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21194	12	.	.	.
18637	21195	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21195	2	575	575	CD
18637	21195	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21195	4	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	21195	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21195	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21195	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21195	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21195	9	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	21195	10	,	,	,
18637	21195	11	311	311	CD
18637	21195	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21195	13	5	5	CD
18637	21195	14	,	,	,
18637	21195	15	6	6	CD
18637	21195	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21195	17	1940	1940	CD
18637	21195	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21195	19	,	,	,
18637	21195	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21195	21	Emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	21195	22	supplied	supply	VBN
18637	21195	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21195	24	.	.	.
18637	21196	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21196	2	576	576	CD
18637	21196	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21196	4	Palmetto	Palmetto	NNP
18637	21196	5	F.	F.	NNP
18637	21196	6	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	21196	7	.	.	.
18637	21197	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21197	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21197	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21197	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21197	5	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	21197	6	,	,	,
18637	21197	7	272	272	CD
18637	21197	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21197	9	295	295	CD
18637	21197	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21197	11	1926	1926	CD
18637	21197	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21197	13	.	.	.
18637	21198	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21198	2	577	577	CD
18637	21198	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21198	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21198	5	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	21198	6	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	21198	7	Compress	Compress	NNP
18637	21198	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21198	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21198	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	21198	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21198	12	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	21198	13	,	,	,
18637	21198	14	260	260	CD
18637	21198	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21198	16	346	346	CD
18637	21198	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21198	18	1922	1922	CD
18637	21198	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21198	20	.	.	.
18637	21199	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21199	2	578	578	CD
18637	21199	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21199	4	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	21199	5	General	General	NNP
18637	21199	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21199	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21199	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21199	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21199	10	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	21199	11	,	,	,
18637	21199	12	303	303	CD
18637	21199	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21199	14	77	77	CD
18637	21199	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21199	16	1938	1938	CD
18637	21199	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21199	18	.	.	.
18637	21200	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21200	2	579	579	CD
18637	21200	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21200	4	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
18637	21200	5	L.	L.	NNP
18637	21200	6	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	21200	7	.	.	.
18637	21201	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21201	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21201	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21201	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21201	5	New	New	NNP
18637	21201	6	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	21201	7	,	,	,
18637	21201	8	205	205	CD
18637	21201	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21201	10	395	395	CD
18637	21201	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21201	12	1907	1907	CD
18637	21201	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21201	14	.	.	.
18637	21202	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21202	2	580	580	CD
18637	21202	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21202	4	Board	Board	NNP
18637	21202	5	of	of	IN
18637	21202	6	Assessors	Assessors	NNPS
18637	21202	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21202	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21202	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21202	10	New	New	NNP
18637	21202	11	York	York	NNP
18637	21202	12	L.	L.	NNP
18637	21202	13	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	21202	14	.	.	.
18637	21203	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21203	2	,	,	,
18637	21203	3	216	216	CD
18637	21203	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21203	5	517	517	CD
18637	21203	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21203	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	21203	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21203	9	.	.	.
18637	21204	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21204	2	581	581	CD
18637	21204	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21204	4	Liverpool	Liverpool	NNP
18637	21204	5	&	&	CC
18637	21204	6	L.	L.	NNP
18637	21204	7	&	&	CC
18637	21204	8	G.	G.	NNP
18637	21204	9	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	21204	10	.	.	.
18637	21205	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21205	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21205	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21205	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21205	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	21205	6	of	of	IN
18637	21205	7	Assessors	Assessors	NNPS
18637	21205	8	,	,	,
18637	21205	9	221	221	CD
18637	21205	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21205	11	346	346	CD
18637	21205	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21205	13	1911	1911	CD
18637	21205	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21205	15	.	.	.
18637	21206	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21206	2	582	582	CD
18637	21206	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21206	4	Orient	Orient	NNP
18637	21206	5	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	21206	6	.	.	.
18637	21207	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21207	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21207	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21207	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21207	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	21207	6	of	of	IN
18637	21207	7	Assessors	Assessors	NNPS
18637	21207	8	,	,	,
18637	21207	9	221	221	CD
18637	21207	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21207	11	358	358	CD
18637	21207	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21207	13	1911	1911	CD
18637	21207	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21207	15	.	.	.
18637	21208	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21208	2	583	583	CD
18637	21208	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21208	4	Turpin	Turpin	NNP
18637	21208	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21208	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21208	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21208	8	Lemon	Lemon	NNP
18637	21208	9	,	,	,
18637	21208	10	187	187	CD
18637	21208	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21208	12	51	51	CD
18637	21208	13	,	,	,
18637	21208	14	58	58	CD
18637	21208	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21208	16	1902	1902	CD
18637	21208	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21208	18	;	;	:
18637	21208	19	Glidden	Glidden	NNP
18637	21208	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21208	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21208	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21208	23	Harrington	Harrington	NNP
18637	21208	24	,	,	,
18637	21208	25	189	189	CD
18637	21208	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21208	27	255	255	CD
18637	21208	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21208	29	1903	1903	CD
18637	21208	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21208	31	.	.	.
18637	21209	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21209	2	584	584	CD
18637	21209	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21209	4	McMillen	McMillen	NNP
18637	21209	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21209	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21209	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21209	8	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	21209	9	,	,	,
18637	21209	10	95	95	CD
18637	21209	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21209	12	37	37	CD
18637	21209	13	,	,	,
18637	21209	14	42	42	CD
18637	21209	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21209	16	1877	1877	CD
18637	21209	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21209	18	.	.	.
18637	21210	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21210	2	585	585	CD
18637	21210	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21210	4	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	21210	5	's	's	POS
18637	21210	6	Gap	Gap	NNP
18637	21210	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	21210	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21210	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21210	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	21210	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21210	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21210	13	,	,	,
18637	21210	14	134	134	CD
18637	21210	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21210	16	232	232	CD
18637	21210	17	,	,	,
18637	21210	18	239	239	CD
18637	21210	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21210	20	1890	1890	CD
18637	21210	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21210	22	.	.	.
18637	21211	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21211	2	586	586	CD
18637	21211	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21211	4	Hodge	Hodge	NNP
18637	21211	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21211	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21211	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21211	8	Muscatine	Muscatine	NNP
18637	21211	9	County	County	NNP
18637	21211	10	,	,	,
18637	21211	11	196	196	CD
18637	21211	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21211	13	276	276	CD
18637	21211	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21211	15	1905	1905	CD
18637	21211	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21211	17	.	.	.
18637	21212	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21212	2	587	587	CD
18637	21212	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21212	4	Hagar	Hagar	NNP
18637	21212	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21212	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21212	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21212	8	Reclamation	Reclamation	NNP
18637	21212	9	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	21212	10	.	.	.
18637	21213	1	No	no	UH
18637	21213	2	.	.	.
18637	21214	1	108	108	CD
18637	21214	2	,	,	,
18637	21214	3	111	111	CD
18637	21214	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21214	5	701	701	CD
18637	21214	6	,	,	,
18637	21214	7	709	709	CD
18637	21214	8	-	-	SYM
18637	21214	9	710	710	CD
18637	21214	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21214	11	1884	1884	CD
18637	21214	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21214	13	.	.	.
18637	21215	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21215	2	588	588	CD
18637	21215	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21215	4	Hagar	Hagar	NNP
18637	21215	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21215	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21215	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21215	8	Reclamation	Reclamation	NNP
18637	21215	9	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	21215	10	.	.	.
18637	21216	1	No	no	UH
18637	21216	2	.	.	.
18637	21217	1	108	108	CD
18637	21217	2	,	,	,
18637	21217	3	111	111	CD
18637	21217	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21217	5	701	701	CD
18637	21217	6	,	,	,
18637	21217	7	710	710	CD
18637	21217	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21217	9	1884	1884	CD
18637	21217	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21217	11	.	.	.
18637	21218	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21218	2	589	589	CD
18637	21218	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21218	4	McMillen	McMillen	NNP
18637	21218	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21218	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21218	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21218	8	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	21218	9	,	,	,
18637	21218	10	95	95	CD
18637	21218	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21218	12	37	37	CD
18637	21218	13	,	,	,
18637	21218	14	42	42	CD
18637	21218	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21218	16	1877	1877	CD
18637	21218	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21218	18	.	.	.
18637	21219	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21219	2	590	590	CD
18637	21219	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21219	4	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	21219	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21219	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21219	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21219	8	Secor	Secor	NNP
18637	21219	9	,	,	,
18637	21219	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21219	11	State	State	NNP
18637	21219	12	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	21219	13	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	21219	14	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	21219	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21219	16	,	,	,
18637	21219	17	92	92	CD
18637	21219	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21219	19	575	575	CD
18637	21219	20	,	,	,
18637	21219	21	610	610	CD
18637	21219	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21219	23	1876	1876	CD
18637	21219	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21219	25	.	.	.
18637	21220	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21220	2	591	591	CD
18637	21220	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21220	4	Nickey	Nickey	NNP
18637	21220	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21220	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21220	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21220	8	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	21220	9	,	,	,
18637	21220	10	292	292	CD
18637	21220	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21220	12	393	393	CD
18637	21220	13	,	,	,
18637	21220	14	396	396	CD
18637	21220	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21220	16	1934	1934	CD
18637	21220	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21220	18	.	.	.
18637	21221	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21221	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21221	3	also	also	RB
18637	21221	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21221	5	Clement	Clement	NNP
18637	21221	6	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	21221	7	.	.	.
18637	21222	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21222	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21222	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21222	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21222	5	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	21222	6	,	,	,
18637	21222	7	231	231	CD
18637	21222	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21222	9	120	120	CD
18637	21222	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21222	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	21222	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21222	13	.	.	.
18637	21223	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21223	2	592	592	CD
18637	21223	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21223	4	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	21223	5	,	,	,
18637	21223	6	C.C.	C.C.	NNP
18637	21224	1	&	&	CC
18637	21224	2	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21224	3	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	21225	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21225	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21225	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21225	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21225	5	Backus	Backus	NNP
18637	21225	6	,	,	,
18637	21225	7	154	154	CD
18637	21225	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21225	9	421	421	CD
18637	21225	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21225	11	1894	1894	CD
18637	21225	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21225	13	.	.	.
18637	21226	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21226	2	593	593	CD
18637	21226	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21226	4	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	21226	5	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	21227	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21227	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21227	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21227	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21227	5	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	21227	6	,	,	,
18637	21227	7	201	201	CD
18637	21227	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21227	9	245	245	CD
18637	21227	10	,	,	,
18637	21227	11	302	302	CD
18637	21227	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21227	13	1906	1906	CD
18637	21227	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21227	15	.	.	.
18637	21228	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21228	2	594	594	CD
18637	21228	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21228	4	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	21228	5	,	,	,
18637	21228	6	C.C.	C.C.	NNP
18637	21229	1	&	&	CC
18637	21229	2	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21229	3	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	21230	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21230	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21230	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21230	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21230	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	21230	6	of	of	IN
18637	21230	7	Public	Public	NNP
18637	21230	8	Works	Works	NNP
18637	21230	9	,	,	,
18637	21230	10	172	172	CD
18637	21230	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21230	12	32	32	CD
18637	21230	13	,	,	,
18637	21230	14	45	45	CD
18637	21230	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21230	16	1898	1898	CD
18637	21230	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21230	18	.	.	.
18637	21231	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21231	2	595	595	CD
18637	21231	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21231	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21231	5	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	21231	6	&	&	CC
18637	21231	7	K.C.	K.C.	NNP
18637	21232	1	Land	Land	NNP
18637	21232	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21232	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21232	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	21232	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21232	6	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	21232	7	City	City	NNP
18637	21232	8	,	,	,
18637	21232	9	241	241	CD
18637	21232	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21232	11	419	419	CD
18637	21232	12	,	,	,
18637	21232	13	430	430	CD
18637	21232	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21232	15	1916	1916	CD
18637	21232	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21232	17	;	;	:
18637	21232	18	Paulson	Paulson	NNP
18637	21232	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21232	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	21232	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21232	22	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	21232	23	,	,	,
18637	21232	24	149	149	CD
18637	21232	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21232	26	30	30	CD
18637	21232	27	,	,	,
18637	21232	28	41	41	CD
18637	21232	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21232	30	1893	1893	CD
18637	21232	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21232	32	;	;	:
18637	21232	33	Bauman	Bauman	NNP
18637	21232	34	_	_	NNP
18637	21232	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	21232	36	_	_	NNP
18637	21232	37	Ross	Ross	NNP
18637	21232	38	,	,	,
18637	21232	39	167	167	CD
18637	21232	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21232	41	548	548	CD
18637	21232	42	,	,	,
18637	21232	43	590	590	CD
18637	21232	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21232	45	1897	1897	CD
18637	21232	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21232	47	.	.	.
18637	21233	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21233	2	596	596	CD
18637	21233	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21233	4	Tonawanda	Tonawanda	NNP
18637	21233	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21233	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21233	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21233	8	Lyon	Lyon	NNP
18637	21233	9	,	,	,
18637	21233	10	161	161	CD
18637	21233	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21233	12	389	389	CD
18637	21233	13	,	,	,
18637	21233	14	391	391	CD
18637	21233	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21233	16	1901	1901	CD
18637	21233	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21233	18	.	.	.
18637	21234	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21234	2	597	597	CD
18637	21234	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21234	4	Londoner	Londoner	NNP
18637	21234	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21234	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21234	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21234	8	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	21234	9	,	,	,
18637	21234	10	210	210	CD
18637	21234	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21234	12	373	373	CD
18637	21234	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21234	14	1908	1908	CD
18637	21234	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21234	16	.	.	.
18637	21235	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21235	2	598	598	CD
18637	21235	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21235	4	Withnell	Withnell	NNP
18637	21235	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21235	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21235	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21235	8	Ruecking	Ruecking	NNP
18637	21235	9	Constr	Constr	NNP
18637	21235	10	.	.	.
18637	21236	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21236	2	,	,	,
18637	21236	3	249	249	CD
18637	21236	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21236	5	63	63	CD
18637	21236	6	,	,	,
18637	21236	7	68	68	CD
18637	21236	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21236	9	1919	1919	CD
18637	21236	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21236	11	;	;	:
18637	21236	12	Browning	Browning	NNP
18637	21236	13	_	_	NNP
18637	21236	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	21236	15	_	_	NNP
18637	21236	16	Hooper	Hooper	NNP
18637	21236	17	,	,	,
18637	21236	18	269	269	CD
18637	21236	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21236	20	396	396	CD
18637	21236	21	,	,	,
18637	21236	22	405	405	CD
18637	21236	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21236	24	1926	1926	CD
18637	21236	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21236	26	.	.	.
18637	21237	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	21237	2	,	,	,
18637	21237	3	the	the	DT
18637	21237	4	committing	commit	VBG
18637	21237	5	to	to	IN
18637	21237	6	a	a	DT
18637	21237	7	board	board	NN
18637	21237	8	of	of	IN
18637	21237	9	county	county	NN
18637	21237	10	supervisors	supervisor	NNS
18637	21237	11	of	of	IN
18637	21237	12	authority	authority	NN
18637	21237	13	to	to	TO
18637	21237	14	determine	determine	VB
18637	21237	15	,	,	,
18637	21237	16	without	without	IN
18637	21237	17	notice	notice	NN
18637	21237	18	or	or	CC
18637	21237	19	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	21237	20	,	,	,
18637	21237	21	when	when	WRB
18637	21237	22	repairs	repair	NNS
18637	21237	23	to	to	IN
18637	21237	24	an	an	DT
18637	21237	25	existing	exist	VBG
18637	21237	26	drainage	drainage	NN
18637	21237	27	system	system	NN
18637	21237	28	are	be	VBP
18637	21237	29	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	21237	30	can	can	MD
18637	21237	31	not	not	RB
18637	21237	32	be	be	VB
18637	21237	33	said	say	VBN
18637	21237	34	to	to	TO
18637	21237	35	deny	deny	VB
18637	21237	36	due	due	JJ
18637	21237	37	process	process	NN
18637	21237	38	of	of	IN
18637	21237	39	law	law	NN
18637	21237	40	to	to	IN
18637	21237	41	landowners	landowner	NNS
18637	21237	42	in	in	IN
18637	21237	43	the	the	DT
18637	21237	44	district	district	NN
18637	21237	45	,	,	,
18637	21237	46	who	who	WP
18637	21237	47	,	,	,
18637	21237	48	by	by	IN
18637	21237	49	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	21237	50	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	21237	51	,	,	,
18637	21237	52	are	be	VBP
18637	21237	53	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	21237	54	for	for	IN
18637	21237	55	the	the	DT
18637	21237	56	cost	cost	NN
18637	21237	57	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	21237	58	in	in	IN
18637	21237	59	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	21237	60	to	to	IN
18637	21237	61	the	the	DT
18637	21237	62	original	original	JJ
18637	21237	63	assessments.--Breiholz	assessments.--breiholz	CD
18637	21237	64	_	_	NNP
18637	21237	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	21237	66	_	_	NNP
18637	21237	67	Pocahontas	Pocahontas	NNP
18637	21237	68	County	County	NNP
18637	21237	69	,	,	,
18637	21237	70	257	257	CD
18637	21237	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21237	72	118	118	CD
18637	21237	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21237	74	1921	1921	CD
18637	21237	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21237	76	.	.	.
18637	21238	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21238	2	599	599	CD
18637	21238	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21238	4	Fallbrook	Fallbrook	NNP
18637	21238	5	Irrig	Irrig	NNP
18637	21238	6	.	.	.
18637	21239	1	District	District	NNP
18637	21239	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21239	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21239	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21239	5	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	21239	6	,	,	,
18637	21239	7	164	164	CD
18637	21239	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21239	9	112	112	CD
18637	21239	10	,	,	,
18637	21239	11	168	168	CD
18637	21239	12	,	,	,
18637	21239	13	175	175	CD
18637	21239	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21239	15	1896	1896	CD
18637	21239	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21239	17	;	;	:
18637	21239	18	Browning	Browning	NNP
18637	21239	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21239	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	21239	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21239	22	Hooper	Hooper	NNP
18637	21239	23	,	,	,
18637	21239	24	269	269	CD
18637	21239	25	U	u	NN
18637	21239	26	S.	S.	NNP
18637	21239	27	396	396	CD
18637	21239	28	,	,	,
18637	21239	29	405	405	CD
18637	21239	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21239	31	1926	1926	CD
18637	21239	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21239	33	.	.	.
18637	21240	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21240	2	600	600	CD
18637	21240	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21240	4	Utley	Utley	NNP
18637	21240	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21240	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21240	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21240	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21240	9	Petersburg	Petersburg	NNP
18637	21240	10	,	,	,
18637	21240	11	292	292	CD
18637	21240	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21240	13	106	106	CD
18637	21240	14	,	,	,
18637	21240	15	109	109	CD
18637	21240	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21240	17	1934	1934	CD
18637	21240	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21240	19	;	;	:
18637	21240	20	French	French	NNP
18637	21240	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21240	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	21240	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21240	24	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	21240	25	Asphalt	Asphalt	NNP
18637	21240	26	Paving	Paving	NNP
18637	21240	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21240	28	,	,	,
18637	21240	29	181	181	CD
18637	21240	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21240	31	324	324	CD
18637	21240	32	,	,	,
18637	21240	33	341	341	CD
18637	21240	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21240	35	1901	1901	CD
18637	21240	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21240	37	.	.	.
18637	21241	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21241	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21241	3	also	also	RB
18637	21241	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21241	5	Soliah	Soliah	NNP
18637	21241	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21241	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21241	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21241	9	Heskin	Heskin	NNP
18637	21241	10	,	,	,
18637	21241	11	222	222	CD
18637	21241	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21241	13	522	522	CD
18637	21241	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21241	15	1912	1912	CD
18637	21241	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21241	17	.	.	.
18637	21242	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21242	2	601	601	CD
18637	21242	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21242	4	Hibben	Hibben	NNP
18637	21242	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21242	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21242	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21242	8	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	21242	9	,	,	,
18637	21242	10	191	191	CD
18637	21242	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21242	12	310	310	CD
18637	21242	13	,	,	,
18637	21242	14	321	321	CD
18637	21242	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21242	16	1903	1903	CD
18637	21242	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21242	18	.	.	.
18637	21243	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21243	2	602	602	CD
18637	21243	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21243	4	Hancock	Hancock	NNP
18637	21243	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21243	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21243	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21243	8	Muskogee	Muskogee	NNP
18637	21243	9	,	,	,
18637	21243	10	250	250	CD
18637	21243	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21243	12	454	454	CD
18637	21243	13	,	,	,
18637	21243	14	488	488	CD
18637	21243	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21243	16	1919).--Likewise	1919).--Likewise	NNP
18637	21243	17	,	,	,
18637	21243	18	a	a	DT
18637	21243	19	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	21243	20	does	do	VBZ
18637	21243	21	not	not	RB
18637	21243	22	have	have	VB
18637	21243	23	a	a	DT
18637	21243	24	right	right	NN
18637	21243	25	to	to	IN
18637	21243	26	a	a	DT
18637	21243	27	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	21243	28	before	before	IN
18637	21243	29	a	a	DT
18637	21243	30	State	State	NNP
18637	21243	31	board	board	NN
18637	21243	32	of	of	IN
18637	21243	33	equalization	equalization	NN
18637	21243	34	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
18637	21243	35	to	to	TO
18637	21243	36	issuance	issuance	VB
18637	21243	37	by	by	IN
18637	21243	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21243	39	of	of	IN
18637	21243	40	an	an	DT
18637	21243	41	order	order	NN
18637	21243	42	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	21243	43	the	the	DT
18637	21243	44	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	21243	45	of	of	IN
18637	21243	46	all	all	DT
18637	21243	47	property	property	NN
18637	21243	48	in	in	IN
18637	21243	49	a	a	DT
18637	21243	50	city	city	NN
18637	21243	51	by	by	IN
18637	21243	52	40%.--Bi	40%.--Bi	NNP
18637	21243	53	-	-	HYPH
18637	21243	54	Metallic	Metallic	NNP
18637	21243	55	Invest	Invest	NNP
18637	21243	56	.	.	.
18637	21244	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21244	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21244	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21244	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21244	5	State	State	NNP
18637	21244	6	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	21244	7	.	.	.
18637	21245	1	of	of	IN
18637	21245	2	Equalization	Equalization	NNP
18637	21245	3	,	,	,
18637	21245	4	239	239	CD
18637	21245	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21245	6	441	441	CD
18637	21245	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21245	8	1915	1915	CD
18637	21245	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21245	10	.	.	.
18637	21246	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21246	2	603	603	CD
18637	21246	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21246	4	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	21246	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21246	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21246	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21246	8	Parker	Parker	NNP
18637	21246	9	,	,	,
18637	21246	10	181	181	CD
18637	21246	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21246	12	399	399	CD
18637	21246	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21246	14	1901	1901	CD
18637	21246	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21246	16	.	.	.
18637	21247	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21247	2	604	604	CD
18637	21247	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21247	4	Paulsen	Paulsen	NNP
18637	21247	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21247	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21247	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21247	8	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	21247	9	,	,	,
18637	21247	10	149	149	CD
18637	21247	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21247	12	30	30	CD
18637	21247	13	,	,	,
18637	21247	14	38	38	CD
18637	21247	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21247	16	1893	1893	CD
18637	21247	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21247	18	.	.	.
18637	21248	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21248	2	605	605	CD
18637	21248	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21248	4	Londoner	Londoner	NNP
18637	21248	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21248	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21248	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21248	8	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	21248	9	,	,	,
18637	21248	10	210	210	CD
18637	21248	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21248	12	373	373	CD
18637	21248	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21248	14	1908	1908	CD
18637	21248	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21248	16	.	.	.
18637	21249	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21249	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21249	3	also	also	RB
18637	21249	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21249	5	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	21249	6	,	,	,
18637	21249	7	N.O.	N.O.	NNP
18637	21250	1	&	&	CC
18637	21250	2	T.P.R.	T.P.R.	NNP
18637	21251	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21251	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21251	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21251	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21251	5	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21251	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21251	7	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21251	8	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	21251	9	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	21251	10	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	21251	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21251	12	,	,	,
18637	21251	13	115	115	CD
18637	21251	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21251	15	321	321	CD
18637	21251	16	,	,	,
18637	21251	17	331	331	CD
18637	21251	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21251	19	1885	1885	CD
18637	21251	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21251	21	;	;	:
18637	21251	22	Winona	Winona	NNP
18637	21251	23	&	&	CC
18637	21251	24	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21251	25	P.	P.	NNP
18637	21251	26	Land	Land	NNP
18637	21251	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21251	28	_	_	NNP
18637	21251	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	21251	30	_	_	NNP
18637	21251	31	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	21251	32	,	,	,
18637	21251	33	159	159	CD
18637	21251	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21251	35	526	526	CD
18637	21251	36	,	,	,
18637	21251	37	537	537	CD
18637	21251	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21251	39	1895	1895	CD
18637	21251	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21251	41	;	;	:
18637	21251	42	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	21251	43	'	'	POS
18637	21251	44	&	&	CC
18637	21251	45	Mfgrs	Mfgrs	NNP
18637	21251	46	.	.	.
18637	21252	1	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	21252	2	.	.	.
18637	21253	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21253	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21253	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21253	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21253	5	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21253	6	,	,	,
18637	21253	7	167	167	CD
18637	21253	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21253	9	461	461	CD
18637	21253	10	,	,	,
18637	21253	11	466	466	CD
18637	21253	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21253	13	1897	1897	CD
18637	21253	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21253	15	;	;	:
18637	21253	16	Glidden	Glidden	NNP
18637	21253	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21253	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	21253	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21253	20	Harrington	Harrington	NNP
18637	21253	21	,	,	,
18637	21253	22	189	189	CD
18637	21253	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21253	24	255	255	CD
18637	21253	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21253	26	1903	1903	CD
18637	21253	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21253	28	.	.	.
18637	21254	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21254	2	606	606	CD
18637	21254	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21254	4	Corry	Corry	NNP
18637	21254	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21254	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21254	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21254	8	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	21254	9	,	,	,
18637	21254	10	196	196	CD
18637	21254	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21254	12	466	466	CD
18637	21254	13	,	,	,
18637	21254	14	478	478	CD
18637	21254	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21254	16	1905	1905	CD
18637	21254	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21254	18	.	.	.
18637	21255	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21255	2	607	607	CD
18637	21255	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21255	4	Leigh	Leigh	NNP
18637	21255	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21255	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21255	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21255	8	Green	Green	NNP
18637	21255	9	,	,	,
18637	21255	10	193	193	CD
18637	21255	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21255	12	79	79	CD
18637	21255	13	,	,	,
18637	21255	14	92	92	CD
18637	21255	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21255	16	93	93	CD
18637	21255	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21255	18	1904	1904	CD
18637	21255	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21255	20	.	.	.
18637	21256	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21256	2	608	608	CD
18637	21256	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21256	4	Ontario	Ontario	NNP
18637	21256	5	Land	Land	NNP
18637	21256	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21256	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21256	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21256	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21256	10	Yordy	Yordy	NNP
18637	21256	11	,	,	,
18637	21256	12	212	212	CD
18637	21256	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21256	14	152	152	CD
18637	21256	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21256	16	1909	1909	CD
18637	21256	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21256	18	.	.	.
18637	21257	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21257	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21257	3	also	also	RB
18637	21257	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21257	5	Longyear	Longyear	NNP
18637	21257	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21257	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21257	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21257	9	Toolan	Toolan	NNP
18637	21257	10	,	,	,
18637	21257	11	209	209	CD
18637	21257	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21257	13	414	414	CD
18637	21257	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21257	15	1908	1908	CD
18637	21257	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21257	17	.	.	.
18637	21258	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21258	2	609	609	CD
18637	21258	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21258	4	Brinkerhoff	Brinkerhoff	NNP
18637	21258	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	21258	6	Faris	Faris	NNP
18637	21258	7	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	21258	8	&	&	CC
18637	21258	9	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	21258	10	.	.	.
18637	21259	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21259	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21259	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21259	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21259	5	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	21259	6	,	,	,
18637	21259	7	281	281	CD
18637	21259	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21259	9	673	673	CD
18637	21259	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21259	11	1930	1930	CD
18637	21259	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21259	13	.	.	.
18637	21260	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21260	2	610	610	CD
18637	21260	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21260	4	Central	Central	NNP
18637	21260	5	of	of	IN
18637	21260	6	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	21260	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	21260	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21260	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21260	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	21260	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21260	12	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	21260	13	,	,	,
18637	21260	14	207	207	CD
18637	21260	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21260	16	127	127	CD
18637	21260	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21260	18	1907	1907	CD
18637	21260	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21260	20	.	.	.
18637	21261	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21261	2	611	611	CD
18637	21261	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21261	4	Carpenter	Carpenter	NNP
18637	21261	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21261	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21261	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21261	8	Shaw	Shaw	NNP
18637	21261	9	,	,	,
18637	21261	10	280	280	CD
18637	21261	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21261	12	363	363	CD
18637	21261	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21261	14	1930	1930	CD
18637	21261	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21261	16	.	.	.
18637	21262	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21262	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21262	3	also	also	RB
18637	21262	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21262	5	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	21262	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21262	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21262	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21262	9	Love	Love	NNP
18637	21262	10	County	County	NNP
18637	21262	11	,	,	,
18637	21262	12	253	253	CD
18637	21262	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21262	14	17	17	CD
18637	21262	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21262	16	1920	1920	CD
18637	21262	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21262	18	.	.	.
18637	21263	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21263	2	612	612	CD
18637	21263	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21263	4	Farncomb	Farncomb	NNP
18637	21263	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21263	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21263	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21263	8	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	21263	9	,	,	,
18637	21263	10	252	252	CD
18637	21263	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21263	12	7	7	CD
18637	21263	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21263	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	21263	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21263	16	.	.	.
18637	21264	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21264	2	613	613	CD
18637	21264	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21264	4	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	21264	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21264	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21264	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21264	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21264	9	Knott	Knott	NNP
18637	21264	10	,	,	,
18637	21264	11	235	235	CD
18637	21264	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21264	13	23	23	CD
18637	21264	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21264	15	1914	1914	CD
18637	21264	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21264	17	.	.	.
18637	21265	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21265	2	614	614	CD
18637	21265	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21265	4	Bankers	Bankers	NNPS
18637	21265	5	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	21265	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21265	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21265	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21265	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21265	10	Blodgett	Blodgett	NNP
18637	21265	11	,	,	,
18637	21265	12	260	260	CD
18637	21265	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21265	14	647	647	CD
18637	21265	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21265	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	21265	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21265	18	.	.	.
18637	21266	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21266	2	615	615	CD
18637	21266	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21266	4	National	National	NNP
18637	21266	5	Safe	Safe	NNP
18637	21266	6	Deposit	Deposit	NNP
18637	21266	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21266	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21266	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21266	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21266	11	Stead	Stead	NNP
18637	21266	12	,	,	,
18637	21266	13	232	232	CD
18637	21266	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21266	15	58	58	CD
18637	21266	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21266	17	1914	1914	CD
18637	21266	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21266	19	.	.	.
18637	21267	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21267	2	616	616	CD
18637	21267	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21267	4	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	21267	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	21267	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	21267	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21267	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21267	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21267	10	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	21267	11	,	,	,
18637	21267	12	264	264	CD
18637	21267	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21267	14	137	137	CD
18637	21267	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21267	16	1924	1924	CD
18637	21267	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21267	18	.	.	.
18637	21268	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21268	2	617	617	CD
18637	21268	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21268	4	Carstairs	Carstairs	NNP
18637	21268	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21268	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21268	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21268	8	Cochran	Cochran	NNP
18637	21268	9	,	,	,
18637	21268	10	193	193	CD
18637	21268	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21268	12	10	10	CD
18637	21268	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21268	14	1904	1904	CD
18637	21268	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21268	16	;	;	:
18637	21268	17	Hannis	Hannis	NNP
18637	21268	18	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	21268	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21268	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21268	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21268	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21268	23	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	21268	24	,	,	,
18637	21268	25	216	216	CD
18637	21268	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21268	27	285	285	CD
18637	21268	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21268	29	1910	1910	CD
18637	21268	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21268	31	.	.	.
18637	21269	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21269	2	618	618	CD
18637	21269	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21269	4	Travis	Travis	NNP
18637	21269	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21269	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21269	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21269	8	Yale	Yale	NNP
18637	21269	9	&	&	CC
18637	21269	10	T.	T.	NNP
18637	21269	11	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	21269	12	.	.	.
18637	21270	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21270	2	,	,	,
18637	21270	3	252	252	CD
18637	21270	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21270	5	60	60	CD
18637	21270	6	,	,	,
18637	21270	7	75	75	CD
18637	21270	8	-	-	SYM
18637	21270	9	76	76	CD
18637	21270	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21270	11	1920	1920	CD
18637	21270	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21270	13	.	.	.
18637	21271	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21271	2	619	619	CD
18637	21271	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21271	4	League	League	NNP
18637	21271	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21271	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21271	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21271	8	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	21271	9	,	,	,
18637	21271	10	184	184	CD
18637	21271	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21271	12	156	156	CD
18637	21271	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21271	14	1902	1902	CD
18637	21271	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21271	16	.	.	.
18637	21272	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21272	2	620	620	CD
18637	21272	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21272	4	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	21272	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21272	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21272	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21272	8	McMahon	McMahon	NNP
18637	21272	9	,	,	,
18637	21272	10	133	133	CD
18637	21272	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21272	12	660	660	CD
18637	21272	13	,	,	,
18637	21272	14	669	669	CD
18637	21272	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21272	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	21272	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21272	18	.	.	.
18637	21273	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21273	2	621	621	CD
18637	21273	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21273	4	Scottish	Scottish	NNP
18637	21273	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	21273	6	&	&	CC
18637	21273	7	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	21273	8	.	.	.
18637	21274	1	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	21274	2	.	.	.
18637	21275	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21275	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21275	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21275	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21275	5	Bowland	Bowland	NNP
18637	21275	6	,	,	,
18637	21275	7	196	196	CD
18637	21275	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21275	9	611	611	CD
18637	21275	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21275	11	1905	1905	CD
18637	21275	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21275	13	.	.	.
18637	21276	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21276	2	622	622	CD
18637	21276	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21276	4	King	King	NNP
18637	21276	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21276	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21276	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21276	8	Mullins	Mullins	NNP
18637	21276	9	,	,	,
18637	21276	10	171	171	CD
18637	21276	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21276	12	404	404	CD
18637	21276	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21276	14	1898	1898	CD
18637	21276	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21276	16	;	;	:
18637	21276	17	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	21276	18	_	_	NNP
18637	21276	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	21276	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21276	21	Zobelein	Zobelein	NNP
18637	21276	22	,	,	,
18637	21276	23	237	237	CD
18637	21276	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21276	25	135	135	CD
18637	21276	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21276	27	1915	1915	CD
18637	21276	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21276	29	.	.	.
18637	21277	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21277	2	623	623	CD
18637	21277	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21277	4	Leigh	Leigh	NNP
18637	21277	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21277	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21277	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21277	8	Green	Green	NNP
18637	21277	9	,	,	,
18637	21277	10	193	193	CD
18637	21277	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21277	12	79	79	CD
18637	21277	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21277	14	1904	1904	CD
18637	21277	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21277	16	.	.	.
18637	21278	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21278	2	624	624	CD
18637	21278	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21278	4	Davidson	Davidson	NNP
18637	21278	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21278	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21278	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21278	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21278	9	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	21278	10	,	,	,
18637	21278	11	96	96	CD
18637	21278	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21278	13	97	97	CD
18637	21278	14	,	,	,
18637	21278	15	107	107	CD
18637	21278	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21278	17	1878	1878	CD
18637	21278	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21278	19	.	.	.
18637	21279	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21279	2	625	625	CD
18637	21279	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21279	4	Dewey	Dewey	NNP
18637	21279	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21279	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21279	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21279	8	Des	Des	NNP
18637	21279	9	Moines	Moines	NNP
18637	21279	10	,	,	,
18637	21279	11	173	173	CD
18637	21279	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21279	13	193	193	CD
18637	21279	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21279	15	1899	1899	CD
18637	21279	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21279	17	.	.	.
18637	21280	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21280	2	626	626	CD
18637	21280	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21280	4	League	League	NNP
18637	21280	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21280	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21280	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21280	8	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	21280	9	,	,	,
18637	21280	10	184	184	CD
18637	21280	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21280	12	156	156	CD
18637	21280	13	,	,	,
18637	21280	14	158	158	CD
18637	21280	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21280	16	1902	1902	CD
18637	21280	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21280	18	.	.	.
18637	21281	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21281	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21281	3	also	also	RB
18637	21281	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21281	5	Straus	Straus	NNP
18637	21281	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21281	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21281	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21281	9	Foxworth	Foxworth	NNP
18637	21281	10	,	,	,
18637	21281	11	231	231	CD
18637	21281	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21281	13	162	162	CD
18637	21281	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21281	15	1913	1913	CD
18637	21281	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21281	17	.	.	.
18637	21282	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21282	2	627	627	CD
18637	21282	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21282	4	Exercisable	exercisable	JJ
18637	21282	5	as	as	IN
18637	21282	6	to	to	IN
18637	21282	7	every	every	DT
18637	21282	8	description	description	NN
18637	21282	9	of	of	IN
18637	21282	10	property	property	NN
18637	21282	11	,	,	,
18637	21282	12	tangibles	tangible	NNS
18637	21282	13	and	and	CC
18637	21282	14	intangibles	intangible	NNS
18637	21282	15	including	include	VBG
18637	21282	16	choses	chose	NNS
18637	21282	17	in	in	IN
18637	21282	18	action	action	NN
18637	21282	19	,	,	,
18637	21282	20	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	21282	21	,	,	,
18637	21282	22	and	and	CC
18637	21282	23	charters	charter	NNS
18637	21282	24	,	,	,
18637	21282	25	but	but	CC
18637	21282	26	only	only	RB
18637	21282	27	for	for	IN
18637	21282	28	a	a	DT
18637	21282	29	public	public	JJ
18637	21282	30	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	21282	31	,	,	,
18637	21282	32	the	the	DT
18637	21282	33	power	power	NN
18637	21282	34	of	of	IN
18637	21282	35	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	21282	36	domain	domain	NN
18637	21282	37	may	may	MD
18637	21282	38	also	also	RB
18637	21282	39	be	be	VB
18637	21282	40	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	21282	41	by	by	IN
18637	21282	42	the	the	DT
18637	21282	43	State	State	NNP
18637	21282	44	upon	upon	IN
18637	21282	45	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	21282	46	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	21282	47	,	,	,
18637	21282	48	public	public	JJ
18637	21282	49	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	21282	50	,	,	,
18637	21282	51	and	and	CC
18637	21282	52	even	even	RB
18637	21282	53	upon	upon	IN
18637	21282	54	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	21282	55	.	.	.
18637	21283	1	Like	like	IN
18637	21283	2	every	every	DT
18637	21283	3	other	other	JJ
18637	21283	4	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	21283	5	power	power	NN
18637	21283	6	,	,	,
18637	21283	7	the	the	DT
18637	21283	8	power	power	NN
18637	21283	9	of	of	IN
18637	21283	10	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	21283	11	domain	domain	NN
18637	21283	12	can	can	MD
18637	21283	13	not	not	RB
18637	21283	14	be	be	VB
18637	21283	15	surrendered	surrender	VBN
18637	21283	16	by	by	IN
18637	21283	17	the	the	DT
18637	21283	18	State	State	NNP
18637	21283	19	or	or	CC
18637	21283	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21283	21	subdivisions	subdivision	NNS
18637	21283	22	either	either	CC
18637	21283	23	by	by	IN
18637	21283	24	contract	contract	NN
18637	21283	25	or	or	CC
18637	21283	26	by	by	IN
18637	21283	27	any	any	DT
18637	21283	28	other	other	JJ
18637	21283	29	means.--Long	means.--long	CD
18637	21283	30	Island	Island	NNP
18637	21283	31	Water	Water	NNP
18637	21283	32	Supply	Supply	NNP
18637	21283	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21283	34	_	_	NNP
18637	21283	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	21283	36	_	_	NNP
18637	21283	37	Brooklyn	Brooklyn	NNP
18637	21283	38	,	,	,
18637	21283	39	166	166	CD
18637	21283	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21283	41	685	685	CD
18637	21283	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21283	43	1897	1897	CD
18637	21283	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21283	45	;	;	:
18637	21283	46	Offield	Offield	NNP
18637	21283	47	_	_	NNP
18637	21283	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	21283	49	_	_	NNP
18637	21283	50	New	New	NNP
18637	21283	51	York	York	NNP
18637	21283	52	,	,	,
18637	21283	53	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	21283	54	&	&	CC
18637	21283	55	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	21284	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21284	2	,	,	,
18637	21284	3	203	203	CD
18637	21284	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21284	5	372	372	CD
18637	21284	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21284	7	1906	1906	CD
18637	21284	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21284	9	;	;	:
18637	21284	10	Sweet	Sweet	NNP
18637	21284	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21284	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	21284	13	_	_	NNP
18637	21284	14	Rechel	Rechel	NNP
18637	21284	15	,	,	,
18637	21284	16	159	159	CD
18637	21284	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21284	18	380	380	CD
18637	21284	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21284	20	1895	1895	CD
18637	21284	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21284	22	;	;	:
18637	21284	23	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	21284	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21284	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	21284	26	_	_	NNP
18637	21284	27	Nash	Nash	NNP
18637	21284	28	,	,	,
18637	21284	29	198	198	CD
18637	21284	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21284	31	361	361	CD
18637	21284	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21284	33	1905	1905	CD
18637	21284	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21284	35	;	;	:
18637	21284	36	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21284	37	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	21284	38	_	_	NNP
18637	21284	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	21284	40	_	_	NNP
18637	21284	41	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	21284	42	,	,	,
18637	21284	43	245	245	CD
18637	21284	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21284	45	20	20	CD
18637	21284	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21284	47	1917	1917	CD
18637	21284	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21284	49	;	;	:
18637	21284	50	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	21284	51	Wharf	Wharf	NNP
18637	21284	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21284	53	_	_	NNP
18637	21284	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	21284	55	_	_	NNP
18637	21284	56	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	21284	57	,	,	,
18637	21284	58	260	260	CD
18637	21284	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21284	60	473	473	CD
18637	21284	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21284	62	1923	1923	CD
18637	21284	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21284	64	.	.	.
18637	21285	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21285	2	628	628	CD
18637	21285	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21285	4	Green	Green	NNP
18637	21285	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21285	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21285	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21285	8	Frazier	Frazier	NNP
18637	21285	9	,	,	,
18637	21285	10	253	253	CD
18637	21285	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21285	12	233	233	CD
18637	21285	13	,	,	,
18637	21285	14	238	238	CD
18637	21285	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21285	16	1920	1920	CD
18637	21285	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21285	18	.	.	.
18637	21286	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21286	2	629	629	CD
18637	21286	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21286	4	7	7	CD
18637	21286	5	Pet	pet	NN
18637	21286	6	.	.	.
18637	21287	1	243	243	CD
18637	21287	2	.	.	.
18637	21288	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21288	2	630	630	CD
18637	21288	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21288	4	96	96	CD
18637	21288	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21288	6	97	97	CD
18637	21288	7	,	,	,
18637	21288	8	105	105	CD
18637	21288	9	.	.	.
18637	21289	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21289	2	631	631	CD
18637	21289	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21289	4	166	166	CD
18637	21289	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21289	6	226	226	CD
18637	21289	7	,	,	,
18637	21289	8	233	233	CD
18637	21289	9	,	,	,
18637	21289	10	236	236	CD
18637	21289	11	-	-	SYM
18637	21289	12	237	237	CD
18637	21289	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21289	14	1897	1897	CD
18637	21289	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21289	16	;	;	:
18637	21289	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21289	18	see	see	VB
18637	21289	19	also	also	RB
18637	21289	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21289	21	Sweet	Sweet	NNP
18637	21289	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21289	23	v	v	NNP
18637	21289	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21289	25	:	:	:
18637	21289	26	Rechel	Rechel	NNP
18637	21289	27	,	,	,
18637	21289	28	159	159	CD
18637	21289	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21289	30	380	380	CD
18637	21289	31	,	,	,
18637	21289	32	398	398	CD
18637	21289	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21289	34	1895	1895	CD
18637	21289	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21289	36	.	.	.
18637	21290	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21290	2	632	632	CD
18637	21290	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21290	4	Hairston	Hairston	NNP
18637	21290	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21290	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21290	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21290	8	Danville	Danville	NNP
18637	21290	9	&	&	CC
18637	21290	10	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	21290	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21290	12	,	,	,
18637	21290	13	208	208	CD
18637	21290	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21290	15	598	598	CD
18637	21290	16	,	,	,
18637	21290	17	606	606	CD
18637	21290	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21290	19	1908	1908	CD
18637	21290	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21290	21	.	.	.
18637	21291	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21291	2	633	633	CD
18637	21291	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21291	4	Green	Green	NNP
18637	21291	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21291	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21291	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21291	8	Frazier	Frazier	NNP
18637	21291	9	,	,	,
18637	21291	10	253	253	CD
18637	21291	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21291	12	233	233	CD
18637	21291	13	,	,	,
18637	21291	14	240	240	CD
18637	21291	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21291	16	1920	1920	CD
18637	21291	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21291	18	;	;	:
18637	21291	19	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	21291	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21291	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21291	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21291	23	Vester	Vester	NNP
18637	21291	24	,	,	,
18637	21291	25	281	281	CD
18637	21291	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21291	27	439	439	CD
18637	21291	28	,	,	,
18637	21291	29	446	446	CD
18637	21291	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21291	31	1930	1930	CD
18637	21291	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21291	33	.	.	.
18637	21292	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21292	2	634	634	CD
18637	21292	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21292	4	Hairston	Hairston	NNP
18637	21292	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21292	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21292	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21292	8	Danville	Danville	NNP
18637	21292	9	&	&	CC
18637	21292	10	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	21292	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21292	12	,	,	,
18637	21292	13	208	208	CD
18637	21292	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21292	15	598	598	CD
18637	21292	16	,	,	,
18637	21292	17	607	607	CD
18637	21292	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21292	19	1908	1908	CD
18637	21292	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21292	21	.	.	.
18637	21293	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21293	2	635	635	CD
18637	21293	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21293	4	United	United	NNP
18637	21293	5	States	States	NNP
18637	21293	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	21293	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	21293	8	.	.	.
18637	21294	1	T.V.A.	T.V.A.	NNP
18637	21295	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21295	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	21295	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21295	4	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	21295	5	,	,	,
18637	21295	6	327	327	CD
18637	21295	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21295	8	546	546	CD
18637	21295	9	,	,	,
18637	21295	10	551	551	CD
18637	21295	11	-	-	SYM
18637	21295	12	552	552	CD
18637	21295	13	,	,	,
18637	21295	14	556	556	CD
18637	21295	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21295	16	558	558	CD
18637	21295	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21295	18	1946	1946	CD
18637	21295	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21295	20	,	,	,
18637	21295	21	citing	cite	VBG
18637	21295	22	Case	Case	NNP
18637	21295	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21295	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	21295	25	_	_	NNP
18637	21295	26	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	21295	27	,	,	,
18637	21295	28	327	327	CD
18637	21295	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21295	30	92	92	CD
18637	21295	31	,	,	,
18637	21295	32	101	101	CD
18637	21295	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21295	34	1946	1946	CD
18637	21295	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21295	36	,	,	,
18637	21295	37	and	and	CC
18637	21295	38	New	New	NNP
18637	21295	39	York	York	NNP
18637	21295	40	_	_	NNP
18637	21295	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	21295	42	_	_	NNP
18637	21295	43	United	United	NNP
18637	21295	44	States	States	NNP
18637	21295	45	,	,	,
18637	21295	46	326	326	CD
18637	21295	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21295	48	572	572	CD
18637	21295	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21295	50	1946)--Concurring	1946)--concurring	CD
18637	21295	51	in	in	IN
18637	21295	52	the	the	DT
18637	21295	53	result	result	NN
18637	21295	54	,	,	,
18637	21295	55	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21295	56	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	21295	57	insisted	insist	VBD
18637	21295	58	that	that	IN
18637	21295	59	"	"	``
18637	21295	60	the	the	DT
18637	21295	61	fact	fact	NN
18637	21295	62	that	that	IN
18637	21295	63	the	the	DT
18637	21295	64	nature	nature	NN
18637	21295	65	of	of	IN
18637	21295	66	the	the	DT
18637	21295	67	subject	subject	JJ
18637	21295	68	matter	matter	NN
18637	21295	69	gives	give	VBZ
18637	21295	70	the	the	DT
18637	21295	71	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	21295	72	determination	determination	NN
18637	21295	73	nearly	nearly	RB
18637	21295	74	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	21295	75	from	from	IN
18637	21295	76	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	21295	77	review	review	NN
18637	21295	78	does	do	VBZ
18637	21295	79	not	not	RB
18637	21295	80	mean	mean	VB
18637	21295	81	that	that	IN
18637	21295	82	the	the	DT
18637	21295	83	power	power	NN
18637	21295	84	to	to	TO
18637	21295	85	review	review	VB
18637	21295	86	is	be	VBZ
18637	21295	87	wanting	want	VBG
18637	21295	88	.	.	.
18637	21295	89	"	"	''
18637	21296	1	Also	also	RB
18637	21296	2	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	21296	3	in	in	IN
18637	21296	4	the	the	DT
18637	21296	5	result	result	NN
18637	21296	6	,	,	,
18637	21296	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21296	8	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	21296	9	,	,	,
18637	21296	10	for	for	IN
18637	21296	11	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21296	12	and	and	CC
18637	21296	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	21296	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21296	15	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	21296	16	,	,	,
18637	21296	17	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	21296	18	from	from	IN
18637	21296	19	that	that	DT
18637	21296	20	portion	portion	NN
18637	21296	21	of	of	IN
18637	21296	22	the	the	DT
18637	21296	23	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21296	24	which	which	WDT
18637	21296	25	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	21296	26	that	that	IN
18637	21296	27	"	"	``
18637	21296	28	there	there	EX
18637	21296	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	21296	30	no	no	DT
18637	21296	31	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	21296	32	review	review	NN
18637	21296	33	"	"	''
18637	21296	34	of	of	IN
18637	21296	35	the	the	DT
18637	21296	36	question	question	NN
18637	21296	37	whether	whether	IN
18637	21296	38	a	a	DT
18637	21296	39	"	"	``
18637	21296	40	taking	taking	NN
18637	21296	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	21296	42	for	for	IN
18637	21296	43	a	a	DT
18637	21296	44	public	public	JJ
18637	21296	45	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	21296	46	.	.	.
18637	21296	47	"	"	''
18637	21297	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21297	2	636	636	CD
18637	21297	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21297	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21297	5	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	21297	6	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	21297	7	in	in	IN
18637	21297	8	United	United	NNP
18637	21297	9	States	States	NNP
18637	21297	10	ex	ex	NNP
18637	21297	11	rel	rel	NN
18637	21297	12	.	.	.
18637	21298	1	T.V.A.	T.V.A.	NNP
18637	21299	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21299	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	21299	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21299	4	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	21299	5	,	,	,
18637	21299	6	327	327	CD
18637	21299	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21299	8	546	546	CD
18637	21299	9	,	,	,
18637	21299	10	557	557	CD
18637	21299	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21299	12	1946	1946	CD
18637	21299	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21299	14	.	.	.
18637	21300	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21300	2	637	637	CD
18637	21300	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21300	4	Bragg	Bragg	NNP
18637	21300	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21300	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21300	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21300	8	Weaver	Weaver	NNP
18637	21300	9	,	,	,
18637	21300	10	251	251	CD
18637	21300	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21300	12	57	57	CD
18637	21300	13	-	-	SYM
18637	21300	14	59	59	CD
18637	21300	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21300	16	1919).--It	1919).--it	CD
18637	21300	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	21300	18	no	no	RB
18637	21300	19	longer	longer	RB
18637	21300	20	open	open	JJ
18637	21300	21	to	to	IN
18637	21300	22	question	question	VB
18637	21300	23	that	that	IN
18637	21300	24	the	the	DT
18637	21300	25	State	State	NNP
18637	21300	26	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	21300	27	may	may	MD
18637	21300	28	confer	confer	VB
18637	21300	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	21300	30	a	a	DT
18637	21300	31	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	21300	32	the	the	DT
18637	21300	33	authority	authority	NN
18637	21300	34	to	to	TO
18637	21300	35	determine	determine	VB
18637	21300	36	such	such	JJ
18637	21300	37	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	21300	38	for	for	IN
18637	21300	39	itself.--Joslin	itself.--Joslin	NNP
18637	21300	40	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	21300	41	.	.	.
18637	21301	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21301	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21301	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21301	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21301	5	Providence	Providence	NNP
18637	21301	6	,	,	,
18637	21301	7	262	262	CD
18637	21301	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21301	9	668	668	CD
18637	21301	10	,	,	,
18637	21301	11	678	678	CD
18637	21301	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21301	13	1923	1923	CD
18637	21301	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21301	15	.	.	.
18637	21302	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21302	2	638	638	CD
18637	21302	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21302	4	Rindge	Rindge	NNP
18637	21302	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21302	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21302	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21302	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21302	9	Los	Los	NNP
18637	21302	10	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	21302	11	County	County	NNP
18637	21302	12	,	,	,
18637	21302	13	262	262	CD
18637	21302	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21302	15	700	700	CD
18637	21302	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21302	17	1923	1923	CD
18637	21302	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21302	19	.	.	.
18637	21303	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21303	2	639	639	CD
18637	21303	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21303	4	Pumpelly	Pumpelly	NNP
18637	21303	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21303	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21303	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21303	8	Green	Green	NNP
18637	21303	9	Bay	Bay	NNP
18637	21303	10	Company	Company	NNP
18637	21303	11	,	,	,
18637	21303	12	13	13	CD
18637	21303	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	21303	14	.	.	.
18637	21304	1	166	166	CD
18637	21304	2	,	,	,
18637	21304	3	177	177	CD
18637	21304	4	-	-	SYM
18637	21304	5	178	178	CD
18637	21304	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21304	7	1872	1872	CD
18637	21304	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21304	9	;	;	:
18637	21304	10	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	21304	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21304	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	21304	13	_	_	NNP
18637	21304	14	Swasey	Swasey	NNP
18637	21304	15	,	,	,
18637	21304	16	214	214	CD
18637	21304	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21304	18	91	91	CD
18637	21304	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21304	20	1909	1909	CD
18637	21304	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21304	22	;	;	:
18637	21304	23	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21304	24	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	21304	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21304	26	_	_	NNP
18637	21304	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	21304	28	_	_	NNP
18637	21304	29	Mahon	Mahon	NNP
18637	21304	30	,	,	,
18637	21304	31	260	260	CD
18637	21304	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21304	33	393	393	CD
18637	21304	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21304	35	1922	1922	CD
18637	21304	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21304	37	.	.	.
18637	21305	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21305	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21305	3	also	also	RB
18637	21305	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21305	5	comparable	comparable	JJ
18637	21305	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	21305	7	involving	involve	VBG
18637	21305	8	the	the	DT
18637	21305	9	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	21305	10	Government	Government	NNP
18637	21305	11	and	and	CC
18637	21305	12	discussed	discuss	VBD
18637	21305	13	under	under	IN
18637	21305	14	the	the	DT
18637	21305	15	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	21305	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21305	17	,	,	,
18637	21305	18	United	United	NNP
18637	21305	19	States	States	NNP
18637	21305	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21305	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21305	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21305	23	Lynah	Lynah	NNP
18637	21305	24	,	,	,
18637	21305	25	188	188	CD
18637	21305	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21305	27	445	445	CD
18637	21305	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21305	29	1903	1903	CD
18637	21305	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21305	31	;	;	:
18637	21305	32	United	United	NNP
18637	21305	33	States	States	NNP
18637	21305	34	_	_	NNP
18637	21305	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	21305	36	_	_	NNP
18637	21305	37	Cress	Cress	NNP
18637	21305	38	,	,	,
18637	21305	39	243	243	CD
18637	21305	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21305	41	316	316	CD
18637	21305	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21305	43	1917	1917	CD
18637	21305	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21305	45	;	;	:
18637	21305	46	Portsmouth	Portsmouth	NNP
18637	21305	47	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	21305	48	L.	L.	NNP
18637	21305	49	&	&	CC
18637	21305	50	H.	H.	NNP
18637	21305	51	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21305	52	_	_	NNP
18637	21305	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	21305	54	_	_	NNP
18637	21305	55	United	United	NNP
18637	21305	56	States	States	NNP
18637	21305	57	,	,	,
18637	21305	58	260	260	CD
18637	21305	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21305	60	327	327	CD
18637	21305	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21305	62	1922	1922	CD
18637	21305	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21305	64	;	;	:
18637	21305	65	United	United	NNP
18637	21305	66	States	States	NNP
18637	21305	67	_	_	NNP
18637	21305	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	21305	69	_	_	NNP
18637	21305	70	Causby	Causby	NNP
18637	21305	71	,	,	,
18637	21305	72	328	328	CD
18637	21305	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21305	74	256	256	CD
18637	21305	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21305	76	1946	1946	CD
18637	21305	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21305	78	.	.	.
18637	21306	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21306	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21306	3	also	also	RB
18637	21306	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21306	5	the	the	DT
18637	21306	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	21306	7	hereinafter	hereinafter	NN
18637	21306	8	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	21306	9	on	on	IN
18637	21306	10	the	the	DT
18637	21306	11	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	21306	12	on	on	IN
18637	21306	13	"	"	``
18637	21306	14	uncompensated	uncompensated	JJ
18637	21306	15	takings	taking	NNS
18637	21306	16	.	.	.
18637	21306	17	"	"	''
18637	21307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21307	2	640	640	CD
18637	21307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21307	4	Long	Long	NNP
18637	21307	5	Island	Island	NNP
18637	21307	6	Water	Water	NNP
18637	21307	7	Supply	Supply	NNP
18637	21307	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21307	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21307	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	21307	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21307	12	Brooklyn	Brooklyn	NNP
18637	21307	13	,	,	,
18637	21307	14	166	166	CD
18637	21307	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21307	16	685	685	CD
18637	21307	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21307	18	1897	1897	CD
18637	21307	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21307	20	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21307	21	641	641	CD
18637	21307	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21307	23	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	21307	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21307	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	21307	26	_	_	NNP
18637	21307	27	Nash	Nash	NNP
18637	21307	28	,	,	,
18637	21307	29	198	198	CD
18637	21307	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21307	31	361	361	CD
18637	21307	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21307	33	1905	1905	CD
18637	21307	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21307	35	.	.	.
18637	21308	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21308	2	642	642	CD
18637	21308	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21308	4	Strickley	Strickley	NNP
18637	21308	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21308	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21308	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21308	8	Highland	Highland	NNP
18637	21308	9	Boy	Boy	NNP
18637	21308	10	Gold	Gold	NNP
18637	21308	11	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	21308	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21308	13	,	,	,
18637	21308	14	200	200	CD
18637	21308	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21308	16	527	527	CD
18637	21308	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21308	18	1906	1906	CD
18637	21308	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21308	20	.	.	.
18637	21309	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21309	2	643	643	CD
18637	21309	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21309	4	Mt.	Mount	NNP
18637	21310	1	Vernon	Vernon	NNP
18637	21310	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	21310	3	Woodberry	Woodberry	NNP
18637	21310	4	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	21310	5	Duck	Duck	NNP
18637	21310	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21310	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21310	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21310	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21310	10	.	.	.
18637	21311	1	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	21311	2	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	21311	3	Power	Power	NNP
18637	21311	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21311	5	,	,	,
18637	21311	6	240	240	CD
18637	21311	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21311	8	30	30	CD
18637	21311	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21311	10	1916	1916	CD
18637	21311	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21311	12	.	.	.
18637	21312	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21312	2	644	644	CD
18637	21312	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21312	4	Hendersonville	Hendersonville	NNP
18637	21312	5	Light	Light	NNP
18637	21312	6	&	&	CC
18637	21312	7	Power	Power	NNP
18637	21312	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21312	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21312	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	21312	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21312	12	.	.	.
18637	21313	1	Blue	Blue	NNP
18637	21313	2	Ridge	Ridge	NNP
18637	21313	3	Interurban	Interurban	NNP
18637	21313	4	R.	R.	NNP
18637	21313	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21313	6	,	,	,
18637	21313	7	243	243	CD
18637	21313	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21313	9	563	563	CD
18637	21313	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21313	11	1917	1917	CD
18637	21313	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21313	13	.	.	.
18637	21314	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21314	2	645	645	CD
18637	21314	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21314	4	Roe	Roe	NNP
18637	21314	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21314	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21314	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21314	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	21314	9	ex	ex	NNP
18637	21314	10	rel	rel	NNP
18637	21314	11	.	.	.
18637	21315	1	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	21315	2	,	,	,
18637	21315	3	278	278	CD
18637	21315	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21315	5	191	191	CD
18637	21315	6	,	,	,
18637	21315	7	193	193	CD
18637	21315	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21315	9	1929	1929	CD
18637	21315	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21315	11	.	.	.
18637	21316	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21316	2	646	646	CD
18637	21316	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21316	4	Dohany	Dohany	NNP
18637	21316	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21316	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21316	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21316	8	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	21316	9	,	,	,
18637	21316	10	281	281	CD
18637	21316	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21316	12	362	362	CD
18637	21316	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21316	14	1930	1930	CD
18637	21316	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21316	16	.	.	.
18637	21317	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21317	2	647	647	CD
18637	21317	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21317	4	Hairston	Hairston	NNP
18637	21317	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21317	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21317	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21317	8	Danville	Danville	NNP
18637	21317	9	&	&	CC
18637	21317	10	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	21317	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21317	12	,	,	,
18637	21317	13	208	208	CD
18637	21317	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21317	15	598	598	CD
18637	21317	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21317	17	1908	1908	CD
18637	21317	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21317	19	.	.	.
18637	21318	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21318	2	648	648	CD
18637	21318	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21318	4	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	21318	5	,	,	,
18637	21318	6	L.	L.	NNP
18637	21318	7	&	&	CC
18637	21318	8	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	21318	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21318	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21318	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	21318	12	_	_	NNP
18637	21318	13	Morristown	Morristown	NNP
18637	21318	14	,	,	,
18637	21318	15	276	276	CD
18637	21318	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21318	17	182	182	CD
18637	21318	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21318	19	1928	1928	CD
18637	21318	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21318	21	.	.	.
18637	21319	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21319	2	649	649	CD
18637	21319	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21319	4	Otis	Otis	NNP
18637	21319	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21319	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21319	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21319	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21319	9	Ludlow	Ludlow	NNP
18637	21319	10	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	21319	11	.	.	.
18637	21320	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21320	2	,	,	,
18637	21320	3	201	201	CD
18637	21320	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21320	5	140	140	CD
18637	21320	6	,	,	,
18637	21320	7	151	151	CD
18637	21320	8	,	,	,
18637	21320	9	153	153	CD
18637	21320	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21320	11	1906	1906	CD
18637	21320	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21320	13	.	.	.
18637	21321	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21321	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21321	3	also	also	RB
18637	21321	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21321	5	Head	Head	NNP
18637	21321	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21321	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21321	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21321	9	Amoskeag	Amoskeag	NNP
18637	21321	10	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	21321	11	.	.	.
18637	21322	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21322	2	,	,	,
18637	21322	3	113	113	CD
18637	21322	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21322	5	9	9	CD
18637	21322	6	,	,	,
18637	21322	7	20	20	CD
18637	21322	8	-	-	SYM
18637	21322	9	21	21	CD
18637	21322	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21322	11	1885	1885	CD
18637	21322	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21322	13	.	.	.
18637	21323	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21323	2	650	650	CD
18637	21323	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21323	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	21323	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	21324	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21324	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21324	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21324	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21324	5	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	21324	6	ex	ex	NN
18637	21324	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	21324	8	.	.	.
18637	21325	1	Board	Board	NNP
18637	21325	2	of	of	IN
18637	21325	3	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	21325	4	,	,	,
18637	21325	5	164	164	CD
18637	21325	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21325	7	403	403	CD
18637	21325	8	,	,	,
18637	21325	9	416	416	CD
18637	21325	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21325	11	1896	1896	CD
18637	21325	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21325	13	.	.	.
18637	21326	1	The	the	DT
18637	21326	2	State	State	NNP
18637	21326	3	court	court	NN
18637	21326	4	in	in	IN
18637	21326	5	this	this	DT
18637	21326	6	case	case	NN
18637	21326	7	was	be	VBD
18637	21326	8	declared	declare	VBN
18637	21326	9	to	to	TO
18637	21326	10	have	have	VB
18637	21326	11	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	21326	12	that	that	IN
18637	21326	13	the	the	DT
18637	21326	14	taking	taking	NN
18637	21326	15	was	be	VBD
18637	21326	16	not	not	RB
18637	21326	17	for	for	IN
18637	21326	18	a	a	DT
18637	21326	19	public	public	JJ
18637	21326	20	use	use	NN
18637	21326	21	.	.	.
18637	21327	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	21327	2	,	,	,
18637	21327	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21327	4	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	21327	5	by	by	IN
18637	21327	6	the	the	DT
18637	21327	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21327	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21327	9	did	do	VBD
18637	21327	10	not	not	RB
18637	21327	11	conflict	conflict	VB
18637	21327	12	with	with	IN
18637	21327	13	the	the	DT
18637	21327	14	later	later	JJ
18637	21327	15	observation	observation	NN
18637	21327	16	by	by	IN
18637	21327	17	the	the	DT
18637	21327	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21327	19	that	that	IN
18637	21327	20	"	"	``
18637	21327	21	no	no	DT
18637	21327	22	case	case	NN
18637	21327	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	21327	24	recalled	recall	VBN
18637	21327	25	where	where	WRB
18637	21327	26	this	this	DT
18637	21327	27	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21327	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	21327	29	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	21327	30	*	*	NFP
18637	21327	31	*	*	NFP
18637	21327	32	*	*	NFP
18637	21327	33	a	a	DT
18637	21327	34	taking	taking	NN
18637	21327	35	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	21327	36	by	by	IN
18637	21327	37	the	the	DT
18637	21327	38	State	State	NNP
18637	21327	39	court	court	NN
18637	21327	40	as	as	IN
18637	21327	41	a	a	DT
18637	21327	42	taking	taking	NN
18637	21327	43	for	for	IN
18637	21327	44	public	public	JJ
18637	21327	45	uses	use	NNS
18637	21327	46	in	in	IN
18637	21327	47	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	21327	48	with	with	IN
18637	21327	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21327	50	laws	law	NNS
18637	21327	51	.	.	.
18637	21327	52	"	"	''
18637	21328	1	--_See	--_See	:
18637	21328	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21328	3	Hairston	Hairston	NNP
18637	21328	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21328	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	21328	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21328	7	Danville	Danville	NNP
18637	21328	8	&	&	CC
18637	21328	9	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	21328	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21328	11	,	,	,
18637	21328	12	208	208	CD
18637	21328	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21328	14	598	598	CD
18637	21328	15	,	,	,
18637	21328	16	607	607	CD
18637	21328	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21328	18	1908	1908	CD
18637	21328	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21328	20	.	.	.
18637	21329	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21329	2	651	651	CD
18637	21329	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21329	4	Backus	Backus	NNP
18637	21329	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21329	6	A.	a.	NN
18637	21329	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21330	1	Jr.	Jr.	NNP
18637	21330	2	and	and	CC
18637	21330	3	Sons	Sons	NNPS
18637	21330	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21330	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	21330	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21330	7	Port	Port	NNP
18637	21330	8	Street	Street	NNP
18637	21330	9	Union	Union	NNP
18637	21330	10	Depot	Depot	NNP
18637	21330	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21330	12	,	,	,
18637	21330	13	169	169	CD
18637	21330	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21330	15	557	557	CD
18637	21330	16	,	,	,
18637	21330	17	573	573	CD
18637	21330	18	,	,	,
18637	21330	19	575	575	CD
18637	21330	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21330	21	1898	1898	CD
18637	21330	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21330	23	.	.	.
18637	21331	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21331	2	652	652	CD
18637	21331	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21331	4	McGovern	McGovern	NNP
18637	21331	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21331	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21331	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21331	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21331	9	York	York	NNP
18637	21331	10	,	,	,
18637	21331	11	229	229	CD
18637	21331	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21331	13	363	363	CD
18637	21331	14	,	,	,
18637	21331	15	370	370	CD
18637	21331	16	-	-	SYM
18637	21331	17	371	371	CD
18637	21331	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21331	19	1913	1913	CD
18637	21331	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21331	21	.	.	.
18637	21332	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21332	2	653	653	CD
18637	21332	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21332	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21332	5	.	.	.
18637	21333	1	371	371	CD
18637	21333	2	.	.	.
18637	21334	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21334	2	654	654	CD
18637	21334	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21334	4	Provo	Provo	NNP
18637	21334	5	Bench	Bench	NNP
18637	21334	6	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	21334	7	and	and	CC
18637	21334	8	Irrig	Irrig	NNP
18637	21334	9	.	.	.
18637	21335	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21335	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21335	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21335	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21335	5	Tanner	Tanner	NNP
18637	21335	6	,	,	,
18637	21335	7	239	239	CD
18637	21335	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21335	9	323	323	CD
18637	21335	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21335	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	21335	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21335	13	;	;	:
18637	21335	14	Appleby	Appleby	NNP
18637	21335	15	_	_	NNP
18637	21335	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	21335	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21335	18	Buffalo	Buffalo	NNP
18637	21335	19	,	,	,
18637	21335	20	221	221	CD
18637	21335	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21335	22	524	524	CD
18637	21335	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21335	24	1911	1911	CD
18637	21335	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21335	26	.	.	.
18637	21336	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21336	2	655	655	CD
18637	21336	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21336	4	Backus	Backus	NNP
18637	21336	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21336	6	A.	a.	NN
18637	21336	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21337	1	Jr.	Jr.	NNP
18637	21337	2	and	and	CC
18637	21337	3	Sons	Sons	NNPS
18637	21337	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21337	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	21337	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21337	7	Port	Port	NNP
18637	21337	8	Street	Street	NNP
18637	21337	9	Union	Union	NNP
18637	21337	10	Depot	Depot	NNP
18637	21337	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21337	12	,	,	,
18637	21337	13	169	169	CD
18637	21337	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21337	15	557	557	CD
18637	21337	16	,	,	,
18637	21337	17	569	569	CD
18637	21337	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21337	19	1898	1898	CD
18637	21337	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21337	21	.	.	.
18637	21338	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21338	2	656	656	CD
18637	21338	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21338	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21338	5	,	,	,
18637	21338	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	21339	1	&	&	CC
18637	21339	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	21340	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21340	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21340	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21340	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21340	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21340	6	,	,	,
18637	21340	7	166	166	CD
18637	21340	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21340	9	226	226	CD
18637	21340	10	,	,	,
18637	21340	11	250	250	CD
18637	21340	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21340	13	1897	1897	CD
18637	21340	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21340	15	;	;	:
18637	21340	16	McGovern	McGovern	NNP
18637	21340	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21340	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	21340	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21340	20	New	New	NNP
18637	21340	21	York	York	NNP
18637	21340	22	,	,	,
18637	21340	23	229	229	CD
18637	21340	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21340	25	363	363	CD
18637	21340	26	,	,	,
18637	21340	27	372	372	CD
18637	21340	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21340	29	1913	1913	CD
18637	21340	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21340	31	.	.	.
18637	21341	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21341	2	657	657	CD
18637	21341	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21341	4	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	21341	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21341	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21341	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21341	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21341	9	York	York	NNP
18637	21341	10	,	,	,
18637	21341	11	295	295	CD
18637	21341	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21341	13	264	264	CD
18637	21341	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21341	15	1935	1935	CD
18637	21341	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21341	17	.	.	.
18637	21342	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21342	2	658	658	CD
18637	21342	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21342	4	Dohany	Dohany	NNP
18637	21342	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21342	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21342	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21342	8	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	21342	9	,	,	,
18637	21342	10	281	281	CD
18637	21342	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21342	12	362	362	CD
18637	21342	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21342	14	1930	1930	CD
18637	21342	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21342	16	.	.	.
18637	21343	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21343	2	659	659	CD
18637	21343	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21343	4	Joslin	Joslin	NNP
18637	21343	5	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	21343	6	.	.	.
18637	21344	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21344	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21344	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21344	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21344	5	Providence	Providence	NNP
18637	21344	6	,	,	,
18637	21344	7	262	262	CD
18637	21344	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21344	9	668	668	CD
18637	21344	10	,	,	,
18637	21344	11	677	677	CD
18637	21344	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21344	13	1923	1923	CD
18637	21344	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21344	15	.	.	.
18637	21345	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21345	2	660	660	CD
18637	21345	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21345	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21345	5	,	,	,
18637	21345	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	21346	1	&	&	CC
18637	21346	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	21347	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21347	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21347	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21347	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21347	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21347	6	,	,	,
18637	21347	7	166	166	CD
18637	21347	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21347	9	226	226	CD
18637	21347	10	,	,	,
18637	21347	11	255	255	CD
18637	21347	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21347	13	1897	1897	CD
18637	21347	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21347	15	.	.	.
18637	21348	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21348	2	661	661	CD
18637	21348	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21348	4	Manigault	Manigault	NNP
18637	21348	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21348	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21348	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21348	8	Springs	Springs	NNP
18637	21348	9	,	,	,
18637	21348	10	199	199	CD
18637	21348	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21348	12	473	473	CD
18637	21348	13	,	,	,
18637	21348	14	484	484	CD
18637	21348	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	21348	16	485	485	CD
18637	21348	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21348	18	1905	1905	CD
18637	21348	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21348	20	.	.	.
18637	21349	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21349	2	662	662	CD
18637	21349	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21349	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21349	5	,	,	,
18637	21349	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	21350	1	&	&	CC
18637	21350	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	21351	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21351	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21351	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21351	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21351	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21351	6	,	,	,
18637	21351	7	166	166	CD
18637	21351	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21351	9	226	226	CD
18637	21351	10	,	,	,
18637	21351	11	252	252	CD
18637	21351	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21351	13	1897	1897	CD
18637	21351	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21351	15	.	.	.
18637	21352	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21352	2	663	663	CD
18637	21352	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21352	4	Darling	Darling	NNP
18637	21352	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21352	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21352	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21352	8	Newport	Newport	NNP
18637	21352	9	News	News	NNP
18637	21352	10	,	,	,
18637	21352	11	249	249	CD
18637	21352	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21352	13	540	540	CD
18637	21352	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21352	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	21352	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21352	17	.	.	.
18637	21353	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21353	2	664	664	CD
18637	21353	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21353	4	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	21353	5	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	21353	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21353	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21353	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21353	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21353	10	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21353	11	,	,	,
18637	21353	12	99	99	CD
18637	21353	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21353	14	635	635	CD
18637	21353	15	,	,	,
18637	21353	16	642	642	CD
18637	21353	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21353	18	1879	1879	CD
18637	21353	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21353	20	.	.	.
18637	21354	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21354	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21354	3	also	also	RB
18637	21354	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21354	5	Marchant	Marchant	NNP
18637	21354	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21354	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21354	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21354	9	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21354	10	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	21354	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21354	12	,	,	,
18637	21354	13	153	153	CD
18637	21354	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21354	15	380	380	CD
18637	21354	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21354	17	1894	1894	CD
18637	21354	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21354	19	.	.	.
18637	21355	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21355	2	665	665	CD
18637	21355	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21355	4	Meyer	Meyer	NNP
18637	21355	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21355	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21355	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21355	8	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	21355	9	,	,	,
18637	21355	10	172	172	CD
18637	21355	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21355	12	82	82	CD
18637	21355	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21355	14	1898	1898	CD
18637	21355	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21355	16	.	.	.
18637	21356	1	For	for	IN
18637	21356	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	21356	3	illustrative	illustrative	JJ
18637	21356	4	of	of	IN
18637	21356	5	the	the	DT
18637	21356	6	types	type	NNS
18637	21356	7	of	of	IN
18637	21356	8	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	21356	9	or	or	CC
18637	21356	10	flooding	flooding	NN
18637	21356	11	consequent	consequent	NN
18637	21356	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	21356	13	erection	erection	NN
18637	21356	14	of	of	IN
18637	21356	15	dams	dam	NNS
18637	21356	16	or	or	CC
18637	21356	17	aids	aids	NNP
18637	21356	18	to	to	IN
18637	21356	19	navigation	navigation	NN
18637	21356	20	which	which	WDT
18637	21356	21	have	have	VBP
18637	21356	22	been	be	VBN
18637	21356	23	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	21356	24	to	to	TO
18637	21356	25	amount	amount	VB
18637	21356	26	to	to	IN
18637	21356	27	a	a	DT
18637	21356	28	taking	taking	NN
18637	21356	29	for	for	IN
18637	21356	30	which	which	WDT
18637	21356	31	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	21356	32	must	must	MD
18637	21356	33	be	be	VB
18637	21356	34	paid	pay	VBN
18637	21356	35	,	,	,
18637	21356	36	_	_	NNP
18637	21356	37	see	see	VBP
18637	21356	38	_	_	NNP
18637	21356	39	Pumpelly	Pumpelly	NNP
18637	21356	40	_	_	NNP
18637	21356	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	21356	42	_	_	NNP
18637	21356	43	Green	Green	NNP
18637	21356	44	Bay	Bay	NNP
18637	21356	45	Company	Company	NNP
18637	21356	46	,	,	,
18637	21356	47	13	13	CD
18637	21356	48	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	21356	49	.	.	.
18637	21357	1	166	166	CD
18637	21357	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21357	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	21357	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21357	5	;	;	:
18637	21357	6	United	United	NNP
18637	21357	7	States	States	NNP
18637	21357	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21357	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21357	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21357	11	Lynah	Lynah	NNP
18637	21357	12	,	,	,
18637	21357	13	188	188	CD
18637	21357	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21357	15	445	445	CD
18637	21357	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21357	17	1903	1903	CD
18637	21357	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21357	19	;	;	:
18637	21357	20	United	United	NNP
18637	21357	21	States	States	NNP
18637	21357	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21357	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	21357	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21357	25	Cress	Cress	NNP
18637	21357	26	,	,	,
18637	21357	27	243	243	CD
18637	21357	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21357	29	316	316	CD
18637	21357	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21357	31	1917	1917	CD
18637	21357	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21357	33	.	.	.
18637	21358	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21358	2	666	666	CD
18637	21358	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21358	4	Sauer	Sauer	NNP
18637	21358	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21358	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21358	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21358	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21358	9	York	York	NNP
18637	21358	10	,	,	,
18637	21358	11	206	206	CD
18637	21358	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21358	13	536	536	CD
18637	21358	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21358	15	1907	1907	CD
18637	21358	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21358	17	.	.	.
18637	21359	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21359	2	667	667	CD
18637	21359	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21359	4	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	21359	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21359	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21359	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21359	8	Swasey	Swasey	NNP
18637	21359	9	,	,	,
18637	21359	10	214	214	CD
18637	21359	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21359	12	91	91	CD
18637	21359	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21359	14	1909	1909	CD
18637	21359	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21359	16	.	.	.
18637	21360	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21360	2	668	668	CD
18637	21360	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21360	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21360	5	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	21360	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21360	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21360	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21360	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21360	10	Mahon	Mahon	NNP
18637	21360	11	,	,	,
18637	21360	12	260	260	CD
18637	21360	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21360	14	393	393	CD
18637	21360	15	,	,	,
18637	21360	16	413	413	CD
18637	21360	17	-	-	SYM
18637	21360	18	414	414	CD
18637	21360	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21360	20	1922	1922	CD
18637	21360	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21360	22	.	.	.
18637	21361	1	For	for	IN
18637	21361	2	comparable	comparable	JJ
18637	21361	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	21361	4	involving	involve	VBG
18637	21361	5	the	the	DT
18637	21361	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	21361	7	Government	Government	NNP
18637	21361	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21361	9	see	see	VB
18637	21361	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21361	11	Portsmouth	Portsmouth	NNP
18637	21361	12	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	21361	13	L.	L.	NNP
18637	21361	14	&	&	CC
18637	21361	15	H.	H.	NNP
18637	21361	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21361	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21361	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	21361	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21361	20	United	United	NNP
18637	21361	21	States	States	NNP
18637	21361	22	,	,	,
18637	21361	23	260	260	CD
18637	21361	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21361	25	327	327	CD
18637	21361	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21361	27	1922	1922	CD
18637	21361	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21361	29	and	and	CC
18637	21361	30	United	United	NNP
18637	21361	31	States	States	NNP
18637	21361	32	_	_	NNP
18637	21361	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	21361	34	_	_	NNP
18637	21361	35	Causby	Causby	NNP
18637	21361	36	,	,	,
18637	21361	37	328	328	CD
18637	21361	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21361	39	256	256	CD
18637	21361	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21361	41	1946	1946	CD
18637	21361	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21361	43	.	.	.
18637	21362	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21362	2	669	669	CD
18637	21362	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21362	4	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	21362	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21362	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21362	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21362	8	Chattanooga	Chattanooga	NNP
18637	21362	9	,	,	,
18637	21362	10	264	264	CD
18637	21362	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21362	12	472	472	CD
18637	21362	13	,	,	,
18637	21362	14	483	483	CD
18637	21362	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21362	16	1924	1924	CD
18637	21362	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21362	18	.	.	.
18637	21363	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21363	2	670	670	CD
18637	21363	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21363	4	North	North	NNP
18637	21363	5	Laramie	Laramie	NNP
18637	21363	6	Land	Land	NNP
18637	21363	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21363	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21363	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21363	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21363	11	Hoffman	Hoffman	NNP
18637	21363	12	,	,	,
18637	21363	13	268	268	CD
18637	21363	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21363	15	276	276	CD
18637	21363	16	,	,	,
18637	21363	17	283	283	CD
18637	21363	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21363	19	1925	1925	CD
18637	21363	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21363	21	.	.	.
18637	21364	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21364	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21364	3	also	also	RB
18637	21364	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21364	5	Bragg	Bragg	NNP
18637	21364	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21364	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21364	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21364	9	Weaver	Weaver	NNP
18637	21364	10	,	,	,
18637	21364	11	251	251	CD
18637	21364	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21364	13	57	57	CD
18637	21364	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21364	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	21364	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21364	17	.	.	.
18637	21365	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21365	2	671	671	CD
18637	21365	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21365	4	Bragg	Bragg	NNP
18637	21365	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21365	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21365	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21365	8	Weaver	Weaver	NNP
18637	21365	9	,	,	,
18637	21365	10	251	251	CD
18637	21365	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21365	12	57	57	CD
18637	21365	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21365	14	1919	1919	CD
18637	21365	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21365	16	;	;	:
18637	21365	17	Joslin	Joslin	NNP
18637	21365	18	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	21365	19	.	.	.
18637	21366	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21366	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21366	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21366	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21366	5	Providence	Providence	NNP
18637	21366	6	,	,	,
18637	21366	7	262	262	CD
18637	21366	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21366	9	668	668	CD
18637	21366	10	,	,	,
18637	21366	11	678	678	CD
18637	21366	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21366	13	1923	1923	CD
18637	21366	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21366	15	.	.	.
18637	21367	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21367	2	672	672	CD
18637	21367	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21367	4	Bragg	Bragg	NNP
18637	21367	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21367	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21367	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21367	8	Weaver	Weaver	NNP
18637	21367	9	,	,	,
18637	21367	10	251	251	CD
18637	21367	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21367	12	57	57	CD
18637	21367	13	,	,	,
18637	21367	14	59	59	CD
18637	21367	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21367	16	1919	1919	CD
18637	21367	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21367	18	;	;	:
18637	21367	19	North	North	NNP
18637	21367	20	Laramie	Laramie	NNP
18637	21367	21	Land	Land	NNP
18637	21367	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21367	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21367	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	21367	25	_	_	NNP
18637	21367	26	Hoffman	Hoffman	NNP
18637	21367	27	,	,	,
18637	21367	28	268	268	CD
18637	21367	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21367	30	276	276	CD
18637	21367	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21367	32	1925	1925	CD
18637	21367	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21367	34	.	.	.
18637	21368	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21368	2	673	673	CD
18637	21368	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21368	4	Bragg	Bragg	NNP
18637	21368	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21368	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21368	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21368	8	Weaver	Weaver	NNP
18637	21368	9	,	,	,
18637	21368	10	251	251	CD
18637	21368	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21368	12	57	57	CD
18637	21368	13	,	,	,
18637	21368	14	59	59	CD
18637	21368	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21368	16	1919	1919	CD
18637	21368	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21368	18	.	.	.
18637	21369	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21369	2	674	674	CD
18637	21369	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21369	4	Long	Long	NNP
18637	21369	5	Island	Island	NNP
18637	21369	6	Water	Water	NNP
18637	21369	7	Supply	Supply	NNP
18637	21369	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21369	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21369	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	21369	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21369	12	Brooklyn	Brooklyn	NNP
18637	21369	13	,	,	,
18637	21369	14	166	166	CD
18637	21369	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21369	16	685	685	CD
18637	21369	17	,	,	,
18637	21369	18	695	695	CD
18637	21369	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21369	20	1897	1897	CD
18637	21369	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21369	22	.	.	.
18637	21370	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21370	2	675	675	CD
18637	21370	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21370	4	Hays	Hays	NNP
18637	21370	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21370	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21370	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21370	8	Seattle	Seattle	NNP
18637	21370	9	,	,	,
18637	21370	10	251	251	CD
18637	21370	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21370	12	233	233	CD
18637	21370	13	,	,	,
18637	21370	14	238	238	CD
18637	21370	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21370	16	1920	1920	CD
18637	21370	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21370	18	;	;	:
18637	21370	19	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	21370	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21370	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21370	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21370	23	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	21370	24	,	,	,
18637	21370	25	326	326	CD
18637	21370	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21370	27	203	203	CD
18637	21370	28	,	,	,
18637	21370	29	205	205	CD
18637	21370	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21370	31	1945	1945	CD
18637	21370	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21370	33	.	.	.
18637	21371	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21371	2	676	676	CD
18637	21371	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21371	4	The	the	DT
18637	21371	5	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	21371	6	of	of	IN
18637	21371	7	due	due	JJ
18637	21371	8	process	process	NN
18637	21371	9	in	in	IN
18637	21371	10	tax	tax	NN
18637	21371	11	and	and	CC
18637	21371	12	eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	21371	13	domain	domain	NN
18637	21371	14	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	21371	15	are	be	VBP
18637	21371	16	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	21371	17	in	in	IN
18637	21371	18	conjunction	conjunction	NN
18637	21371	19	with	with	IN
18637	21371	20	the	the	DT
18637	21371	21	coverage	coverage	NN
18637	21371	22	of	of	IN
18637	21371	23	these	these	DT
18637	21371	24	topics	topic	NNS
18637	21371	25	.	.	.
18637	21372	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21372	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21372	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21372	4	pp	pp	NNP
18637	21372	5	.	.	.
18637	21373	1	1056	1056	CD
18637	21373	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21373	3	1062	1062	CD
18637	21373	4	,	,	,
18637	21373	5	1069	1069	CD
18637	21373	6	.	.	.
18637	21374	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21374	2	677	677	CD
18637	21374	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21374	4	Hagar	Hagar	NNP
18637	21374	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21374	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21374	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21374	8	Reclamation	Reclamation	NNP
18637	21374	9	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	21374	10	.	.	NNP
18637	21374	11	,	,	,
18637	21374	12	111	111	CD
18637	21374	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21374	14	701	701	CD
18637	21374	15	,	,	,
18637	21374	16	708	708	CD
18637	21374	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21374	18	1884	1884	CD
18637	21374	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21374	20	;	;	:
18637	21374	21	Hurtado	Hurtado	NNP
18637	21374	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21374	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	21374	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21374	25	California	California	NNP
18637	21374	26	,	,	,
18637	21374	27	110	110	CD
18637	21374	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21374	29	516	516	CD
18637	21374	30	,	,	,
18637	21374	31	537	537	CD
18637	21374	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21374	33	1884	1884	CD
18637	21374	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21374	35	.	.	.
18637	21375	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21375	2	678	678	CD
18637	21375	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21375	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	21375	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21375	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21375	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21375	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21375	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	21375	10	,	,	,
18637	21375	11	175	175	CD
18637	21375	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21375	13	172	172	CD
18637	21375	14	,	,	,
18637	21375	15	175	175	CD
18637	21375	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21375	17	1899	1899	CD
18637	21375	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21375	19	;	;	:
18637	21375	20	Hurtado	Hurtado	NNP
18637	21375	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21375	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	21375	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21375	24	California	California	NNP
18637	21375	25	,	,	,
18637	21375	26	110	110	CD
18637	21375	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21375	28	516	516	CD
18637	21375	29	,	,	,
18637	21375	30	529	529	CD
18637	21375	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21375	32	1884	1884	CD
18637	21375	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21375	34	;	;	:
18637	21375	35	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	21375	36	_	_	NNP
18637	21375	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	21375	38	_	_	NNP
18637	21375	39	New	New	NNP
18637	21375	40	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	21375	41	,	,	,
18637	21375	42	211	211	CD
18637	21375	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21375	44	78	78	CD
18637	21375	45	,	,	,
18637	21375	46	101	101	CD
18637	21375	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21375	48	1908	1908	CD
18637	21375	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21375	50	;	;	:
18637	21375	51	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	21375	52	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	21375	53	.	.	.
18637	21376	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21376	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21376	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21376	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21376	5	Luckett	Luckett	NNP
18637	21376	6	,	,	,
18637	21376	7	321	321	CD
18637	21376	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21376	9	233	233	CD
18637	21376	10	,	,	,
18637	21376	11	244	244	CD
18637	21376	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21376	13	1944	1944	CD
18637	21376	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21376	15	.	.	.
18637	21377	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21377	2	679	679	CD
18637	21377	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21377	4	Marchant	Marchant	NNP
18637	21377	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21377	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21377	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21377	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21377	9	R.	R.	NNP
18637	21377	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21377	11	,	,	,
18637	21377	12	153	153	CD
18637	21377	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21377	14	380	380	CD
18637	21377	15	,	,	,
18637	21377	16	386	386	CD
18637	21377	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21377	18	1894	1894	CD
18637	21377	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21377	20	.	.	.
18637	21378	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21378	2	680	680	CD
18637	21378	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21378	4	Ballard	Ballard	NNP
18637	21378	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21378	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21378	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21378	8	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	21378	9	,	,	,
18637	21378	10	204	204	CD
18637	21378	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21378	12	241	241	CD
18637	21378	13	,	,	,
18637	21378	14	255	255	CD
18637	21378	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21378	16	1907	1907	CD
18637	21378	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21378	18	;	;	:
18637	21378	19	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	21378	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	21378	21	McMahon	McMahon	NNP
18637	21378	22	,	,	,
18637	21378	23	133	133	CD
18637	21378	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21378	25	660	660	CD
18637	21378	26	,	,	,
18637	21378	27	668	668	CD
18637	21378	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21378	29	1890	1890	CD
18637	21378	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21378	31	.	.	.
18637	21379	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21379	2	681	681	CD
18637	21379	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21379	4	McMillen	McMillen	NNP
18637	21379	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21379	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21379	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21379	8	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	21379	9	,	,	,
18637	21379	10	95	95	CD
18637	21379	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21379	12	37	37	CD
18637	21379	13	,	,	,
18637	21379	14	41	41	CD
18637	21379	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21379	16	1877	1877	CD
18637	21379	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21379	18	.	.	.
18637	21380	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21380	2	682	682	CD
18637	21380	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21380	4	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	21381	1	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	21381	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21381	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21381	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21381	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	21381	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21381	7	,	,	,
18637	21381	8	311	311	CD
18637	21381	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21381	10	570	570	CD
18637	21381	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21381	12	1941	1941	CD
18637	21381	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21381	14	.	.	.
18637	21382	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21382	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21382	3	also	also	RB
18637	21382	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21382	5	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	21382	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	21382	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21382	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21382	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21382	10	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	21382	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21382	12	,	,	,
18637	21382	13	310	310	CD
18637	21382	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21382	15	573	573	CD
18637	21382	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21382	17	1940	1940	CD
18637	21382	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21382	19	.	.	.
18637	21383	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21383	2	683	683	CD
18637	21383	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21383	4	Dreyer	Dreyer	NNP
18637	21383	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21383	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21383	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21383	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	21383	9	,	,	,
18637	21383	10	187	187	CD
18637	21383	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21383	12	71	71	CD
18637	21383	13	,	,	,
18637	21383	14	83	83	CD
18637	21383	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21383	16	84	84	CD
18637	21383	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21383	18	1902	1902	CD
18637	21383	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21383	20	.	.	.
18637	21384	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21384	2	684	684	CD
18637	21384	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21384	4	New	New	NNP
18637	21384	5	York	York	NNP
18637	21384	6	ex	ex	NN
18637	21384	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	21384	8	.	.	.
18637	21385	1	Lieberman	Lieberman	NNP
18637	21385	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21385	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21385	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21385	5	Van	Van	NNP
18637	21385	6	De	De	NNP
18637	21385	7	Carr	Carr	NNP
18637	21385	8	,	,	,
18637	21385	9	199	199	CD
18637	21385	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21385	11	552	552	CD
18637	21385	12	,	,	,
18637	21385	13	562	562	CD
18637	21385	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21385	15	1905	1905	CD
18637	21385	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21385	17	.	.	.
18637	21386	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21386	2	685	685	CD
18637	21386	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21386	4	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	21386	5	ex	ex	NNP
18637	21386	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	21386	7	.	.	.
18637	21387	1	Bryant	Bryant	NNP
18637	21387	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21387	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21387	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21387	5	Akron	Akron	NNP
18637	21387	6	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
18637	21387	7	Park	Park	NNP
18637	21387	8	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	21387	9	,	,	,
18637	21387	10	281	281	CD
18637	21387	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21387	12	74	74	CD
18637	21387	13	,	,	,
18637	21387	14	79	79	CD
18637	21387	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21387	16	1930	1930	CD
18637	21387	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21387	18	.	.	.
18637	21388	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21388	2	686	686	CD
18637	21388	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21388	4	Carfer	Carfer	NNP
18637	21388	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21388	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21388	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21388	8	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	21388	9	,	,	,
18637	21388	10	200	200	CD
18637	21388	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21388	12	293	293	CD
18637	21388	13	,	,	,
18637	21388	14	297	297	CD
18637	21388	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21388	16	1906	1906	CD
18637	21388	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21388	18	.	.	.
18637	21389	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21389	2	687	687	CD
18637	21389	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21389	4	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	21389	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21389	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21389	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21389	8	McNeal	McNeal	NNP
18637	21389	9	,	,	,
18637	21389	10	154	154	CD
18637	21389	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21389	12	34	34	CD
18637	21389	13	,	,	,
18637	21389	14	46	46	CD
18637	21389	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21389	16	1894	1894	CD
18637	21389	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21389	18	;	;	:
18637	21389	19	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
18637	21389	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21389	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21389	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21389	23	Neff	Neff	NNP
18637	21389	24	,	,	,
18637	21389	25	95	95	CD
18637	21389	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21389	27	714	714	CD
18637	21389	28	,	,	,
18637	21389	29	733	733	CD
18637	21389	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21389	31	1878	1878	CD
18637	21389	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21389	33	.	.	.
18637	21390	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21390	2	688	688	CD
18637	21390	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21390	4	National	National	NNP
18637	21390	5	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	21390	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21390	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21390	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21390	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21390	10	Wiley	Wiley	NNP
18637	21390	11	,	,	,
18637	21390	12	195	195	CD
18637	21390	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21390	14	257	257	CD
18637	21390	15	,	,	,
18637	21390	16	270	270	CD
18637	21390	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21390	18	1904	1904	CD
18637	21390	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21390	20	;	;	:
18637	21390	21	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	21390	22	Cliffs	Cliffs	NNP
18637	21390	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21390	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21390	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	21390	26	_	_	NNP
18637	21390	27	Negaunee	Negaunee	NNP
18637	21390	28	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	21390	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21390	30	,	,	,
18637	21390	31	197	197	CD
18637	21390	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21390	33	463	463	CD
18637	21390	34	,	,	,
18637	21390	35	471	471	CD
18637	21390	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21390	37	1905	1905	CD
18637	21390	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21390	39	.	.	.
18637	21391	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21391	2	689	689	CD
18637	21391	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21391	4	Arndt	Arndt	NNP
18637	21391	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21391	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21391	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21391	8	Griggs	Griggs	NNP
18637	21391	9	,	,	,
18637	21391	10	134	134	CD
18637	21391	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21391	12	316	316	CD
18637	21391	13	,	,	,
18637	21391	14	321	321	CD
18637	21391	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21391	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	21391	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21391	18	;	;	:
18637	21391	19	Grannis	Grannis	NNP
18637	21391	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21391	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21391	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21391	23	Ordean	Ordean	NNP
18637	21391	24	,	,	,
18637	21391	25	234	234	CD
18637	21391	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21391	27	385	385	CD
18637	21391	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21391	29	1914	1914	CD
18637	21391	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21391	31	;	;	:
18637	21391	32	Pennington	Pennington	NNP
18637	21391	33	_	_	NNP
18637	21391	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	21391	35	_	_	NNP
18637	21391	36	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	21391	37	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	21391	38	.	.	.
18637	21392	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21392	2	,	,	,
18637	21392	3	243	243	CD
18637	21392	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21392	5	269	269	CD
18637	21392	6	,	,	,
18637	21392	7	271	271	CD
18637	21392	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21392	9	1917	1917	CD
18637	21392	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21392	11	.	.	.
18637	21393	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21393	2	690	690	CD
18637	21393	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21393	4	Goodrich	Goodrich	NNP
18637	21393	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21393	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21393	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21393	8	Ferris	Ferris	NNP
18637	21393	9	,	,	,
18637	21393	10	214	214	CD
18637	21393	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21393	12	71	71	CD
18637	21393	13	,	,	,
18637	21393	14	80	80	CD
18637	21393	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21393	16	1909	1909	CD
18637	21393	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21393	18	.	.	.
18637	21394	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21394	2	691	691	CD
18637	21394	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21394	4	Pennington	Pennington	NNP
18637	21394	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21394	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21394	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21394	8	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	21394	9	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	21394	10	.	.	.
18637	21395	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21395	2	,	,	,
18637	21395	3	243	243	CD
18637	21395	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21395	5	269	269	CD
18637	21395	6	,	,	,
18637	21395	7	271	271	CD
18637	21395	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21395	9	1917	1917	CD
18637	21395	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21395	11	.	.	.
18637	21396	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21396	2	692	692	CD
18637	21396	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21396	4	The	the	DT
18637	21396	5	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	21396	6	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	21396	7	for	for	IN
18637	21396	8	rendering	render	VBG
18637	21396	9	a	a	DT
18637	21396	10	valid	valid	JJ
18637	21396	11	decree	decree	NN
18637	21396	12	in	in	IN
18637	21396	13	divorce	divorce	NN
18637	21396	14	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	21396	15	are	be	VBP
18637	21396	16	considered	consider	VBN
18637	21396	17	under	under	IN
18637	21396	18	the	the	DT
18637	21396	19	full	full	JJ
18637	21396	20	faith	faith	NN
18637	21396	21	and	and	CC
18637	21396	22	credit	credit	NN
18637	21396	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	21396	24	,	,	,
18637	21396	25	_	_	NNP
18637	21396	26	supra	supra	NNP
18637	21396	27	_	_	NNP
18637	21396	28	,	,	,
18637	21396	29	pp	pp	NNP
18637	21396	30	.	.	.
18637	21397	1	662	662	CD
18637	21397	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21397	3	670	670	CD
18637	21397	4	.	.	.
18637	21398	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21398	2	693	693	CD
18637	21398	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21398	4	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
18637	21398	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21398	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21398	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21398	8	Neff	Neff	NNP
18637	21398	9	,	,	,
18637	21398	10	95	95	CD
18637	21398	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21398	12	714	714	CD
18637	21398	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21398	14	1878	1878	CD
18637	21398	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21398	16	;	;	:
18637	21398	17	Simon	Simon	NNP
18637	21398	18	_	_	NNP
18637	21398	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	21398	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21398	21	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	21398	22	R.	R.	NNP
18637	21398	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21398	24	,	,	,
18637	21398	25	236	236	CD
18637	21398	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21398	27	115	115	CD
18637	21398	28	,	,	,
18637	21398	29	122	122	CD
18637	21398	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21398	31	1915	1915	CD
18637	21398	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21398	33	;	;	:
18637	21398	34	Grannis	Grannis	NNP
18637	21398	35	_	_	NNP
18637	21398	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	21398	37	_	_	NNP
18637	21398	38	Ordean	Ordean	NNP
18637	21398	39	,	,	,
18637	21398	40	234	234	CD
18637	21398	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21398	42	385	385	CD
18637	21398	43	,	,	,
18637	21398	44	392	392	CD
18637	21398	45	,	,	,
18637	21398	46	394	394	CD
18637	21398	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21398	48	1914	1914	CD
18637	21398	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21398	50	.	.	.
18637	21399	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21399	2	694	694	CD
18637	21399	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21399	4	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	21399	5	&	&	CC
18637	21399	6	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	21400	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21400	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21400	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21400	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21400	5	Schmidt	Schmidt	NNP
18637	21400	6	,	,	,
18637	21400	7	177	177	CD
18637	21400	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21400	9	230	230	CD
18637	21400	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21400	11	1900	1900	CD
18637	21400	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21400	13	;	;	:
18637	21400	14	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	21400	15	_	_	NNP
18637	21400	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	21400	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21400	18	Mabee	Mabee	NNP
18637	21400	19	,	,	,
18637	21400	20	243	243	CD
18637	21400	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21400	22	90	90	CD
18637	21400	23	,	,	,
18637	21400	24	91	91	CD
18637	21400	25	,	,	,
18637	21400	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21400	27	1917	1917	CD
18637	21400	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21400	29	.	.	.
18637	21401	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21401	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21401	3	also	also	RB
18637	21401	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21401	5	Adam	Adam	NNP
18637	21401	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21401	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21401	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21401	9	Saenger	Saenger	NNP
18637	21401	10	,	,	,
18637	21401	11	303	303	CD
18637	21401	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21401	13	59	59	CD
18637	21401	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21401	15	1938	1938	CD
18637	21401	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21401	17	.	.	.
18637	21402	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21402	2	695	695	CD
18637	21402	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21402	4	Rees	Rees	NNPS
18637	21402	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21402	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21402	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21402	8	Watertown	Watertown	NNP
18637	21402	9	,	,	,
18637	21402	10	19	19	CD
18637	21402	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	21402	12	.	.	.
18637	21403	1	107	107	CD
18637	21403	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21403	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	21403	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21403	5	;	;	:
18637	21403	6	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	21403	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21403	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21403	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21403	10	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	21403	11	Fertilizer	Fertilizer	NNP
18637	21403	12	Works	Works	NNP
18637	21403	13	,	,	,
18637	21403	14	237	237	CD
18637	21403	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21403	16	413	413	CD
18637	21403	17	,	,	,
18637	21403	18	423	423	CD
18637	21403	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21403	20	1915	1915	CD
18637	21403	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21403	22	;	;	:
18637	21403	23	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	21403	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21403	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	21403	26	_	_	NNP
18637	21403	27	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	21403	28	,	,	,
18637	21403	29	327	327	CD
18637	21403	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21403	31	220	220	CD
18637	21403	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21403	33	1946	1946	CD
18637	21403	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21403	35	.	.	.
18637	21404	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21404	2	696	696	CD
18637	21404	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21404	4	Sugg	Sugg	NNP
18637	21404	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21404	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21404	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21404	8	Thornton	Thornton	NNP
18637	21404	9	,	,	,
18637	21404	10	132	132	CD
18637	21404	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21404	12	524	524	CD
18637	21404	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21404	14	1889	1889	CD
18637	21404	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21404	16	.	.	.
18637	21405	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21405	2	697	697	CD
18637	21405	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21405	4	Riverside	Riverside	NNP
18637	21405	5	&	&	CC
18637	21405	6	Dan	Dan	NNP
18637	21405	7	River	River	NNP
18637	21405	8	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	21405	9	Mills	Mills	NNPS
18637	21405	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21405	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	21405	12	_	_	NNP
18637	21405	13	Menefee	Menefee	NNP
18637	21405	14	,	,	,
18637	21405	15	237	237	CD
18637	21405	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21405	17	189	189	CD
18637	21405	18	,	,	,
18637	21405	19	193	193	CD
18637	21405	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21405	21	1915	1915	CD
18637	21405	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21405	23	;	;	:
18637	21405	24	Hess	Hess	NNP
18637	21405	25	_	_	NNP
18637	21405	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	21405	27	_	_	NNP
18637	21405	28	Pawloski	Pawloski	NNP
18637	21405	29	,	,	,
18637	21405	30	274	274	CD
18637	21405	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21405	32	352	352	CD
18637	21405	33	,	,	,
18637	21405	34	355	355	CD
18637	21405	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21405	36	1927	1927	CD
18637	21405	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21405	38	.	.	.
18637	21406	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21406	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21406	3	also	also	RB
18637	21406	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21406	5	Harkness	Harkness	NNP
18637	21406	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21406	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21406	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21406	9	Hyde	Hyde	NNP
18637	21406	10	,	,	,
18637	21406	11	98	98	CD
18637	21406	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21406	13	476	476	CD
18637	21406	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21406	15	1879	1879	CD
18637	21406	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21406	17	;	;	:
18637	21406	18	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	21406	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21406	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	21406	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21406	22	Seligman	Seligman	NNP
18637	21406	23	,	,	,
18637	21406	24	144	144	CD
18637	21406	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21406	26	41	41	CD
18637	21406	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21406	28	1892	1892	CD
18637	21406	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21406	30	.	.	.
18637	21407	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21407	2	698	698	CD
18637	21407	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21407	4	Milliken	Milliken	NNP
18637	21407	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21407	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21407	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21407	8	Meyer	Meyer	NNP
18637	21407	9	,	,	,
18637	21407	10	311	311	CD
18637	21407	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21407	12	457	457	CD
18637	21407	13	,	,	,
18637	21407	14	462	462	CD
18637	21407	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21407	16	464	464	CD
18637	21407	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21407	18	1940	1940	CD
18637	21407	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21407	20	.	.	.
18637	21408	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21408	2	699	699	CD
18637	21408	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21408	4	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	21408	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21408	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21408	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21408	8	Mabee	Mabee	NNP
18637	21408	9	,	,	,
18637	21408	10	243	243	CD
18637	21408	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21408	12	90	90	CD
18637	21408	13	,	,	,
18637	21408	14	92	92	CD
18637	21408	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21408	16	1917	1917	CD
18637	21408	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21408	18	.	.	.
18637	21409	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21409	2	700	700	CD
18637	21409	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21409	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	21409	5	,	,	,
18637	21409	6	in	in	IN
18637	21409	7	an	an	DT
18637	21409	8	older	old	JJR
18637	21409	9	decision	decision	NN
18637	21409	10	rendered	render	VBN
18637	21409	11	in	in	IN
18637	21409	12	1919	1919	CD
18637	21409	13	,	,	,
18637	21409	14	the	the	DT
18637	21409	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21409	16	held	hold	VBD
18637	21409	17	that	that	IN
18637	21409	18	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	21409	19	"	"	``
18637	21409	20	States	state	NNS
18637	21409	21	could	could	MD
18637	21409	22	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	21409	23	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	21409	24	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	21409	25	*	*	NFP
18637	21409	26	*	*	NFP
18637	21409	27	*	*	NFP
18637	21409	28	,	,	,
18637	21409	29	and	and	CC
18637	21409	30	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	21409	31	establish	establish	VB
18637	21409	32	*	*	NFP
18637	21409	33	*	*	NFP
18637	21409	34	*	*	NFP
18637	21409	35	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21409	36	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	21409	37	of	of	IN
18637	21409	38	such	such	PDT
18637	21409	39	an	an	DT
18637	21409	40	agent	agent	NN
18637	21409	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21409	42	as	as	IN
18637	21409	43	a	a	DT
18637	21409	44	condition	condition	NN
18637	21409	45	to	to	TO
18637	21409	46	letting	let	VBG
18637	21409	47	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21409	48	in	in	RP
18637	21409	49	,	,	,
18637	21409	50	"	"	``
18637	21409	51	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21409	52	had	have	VBD
18637	21409	53	no	no	DT
18637	21409	54	power	power	NN
18637	21409	55	to	to	TO
18637	21409	56	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	21409	57	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	21409	58	;	;	:
18637	21409	59	and	and	CC
18637	21409	60	as	as	IN
18637	21409	61	a	a	DT
18637	21409	62	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	21409	63	,	,	,
18637	21409	64	a	a	DT
18637	21409	65	statute	statute	NN
18637	21409	66	was	be	VBD
18637	21409	67	ineffective	ineffective	JJ
18637	21409	68	which	which	WDT
18637	21409	69	treated	treat	VBD
18637	21409	70	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	21409	71	partners	partner	NNS
18637	21409	72	,	,	,
18637	21409	73	by	by	IN
18637	21409	74	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	21409	75	of	of	IN
18637	21409	76	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21409	77	having	have	VBG
18637	21409	78	done	do	VBN
18637	21409	79	business	business	NN
18637	21409	80	therein	therein	RB
18637	21409	81	,	,	,
18637	21409	82	as	as	IN
18637	21409	83	having	have	VBG
18637	21409	84	consented	consent	VBD
18637	21409	85	to	to	TO
18637	21409	86	be	be	VB
18637	21409	87	bound	bind	VBN
18637	21409	88	by	by	IN
18637	21409	89	service	service	NN
18637	21409	90	of	of	IN
18637	21409	91	process	process	NN
18637	21409	92	on	on	IN
18637	21409	93	a	a	DT
18637	21409	94	person	person	NN
18637	21409	95	who	who	WP
18637	21409	96	was	be	VBD
18637	21409	97	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21409	98	employee	employee	NN
18637	21409	99	when	when	WRB
18637	21409	100	the	the	DT
18637	21409	101	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	21409	102	sued	sue	VBD
18637	21409	103	on	on	IN
18637	21409	104	arose	arose	NN
18637	21409	105	but	but	CC
18637	21409	106	was	be	VBD
18637	21409	107	not	not	RB
18637	21409	108	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21409	109	agent	agent	NN
18637	21409	110	at	at	IN
18637	21409	111	the	the	DT
18637	21409	112	time	time	NN
18637	21409	113	of	of	IN
18637	21409	114	service.--Flexner	service.--Flexner	NNP
18637	21409	115	_	_	NNP
18637	21409	116	v.	v.	IN
18637	21409	117	_	_	NNP
18637	21409	118	Farson	Farson	NNP
18637	21409	119	,	,	,
18637	21409	120	248	248	CD
18637	21409	121	.	.	.
18637	21410	1	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21410	2	289	289	CD
18637	21410	3	,	,	,
18637	21410	4	293	293	CD
18637	21410	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21410	6	1919	1919	CD
18637	21410	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21410	8	.	.	.
18637	21411	1	Because	because	IN
18637	21411	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21411	3	might	may	MD
18637	21411	4	be	be	VB
18637	21411	5	construed	construe	VBN
18637	21411	6	to	to	IN
18637	21411	7	negative	negative	JJ
18637	21411	8	extension	extension	NN
18637	21411	9	to	to	IN
18637	21411	10	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	21411	11	,	,	,
18637	21411	12	other	other	JJ
18637	21411	13	than	than	IN
18637	21411	14	motorists	motorist	NNS
18637	21411	15	,	,	,
18637	21411	16	of	of	IN
18637	21411	17	the	the	DT
18637	21411	18	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	21411	19	device	device	NN
18637	21411	20	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	21411	21	in	in	IN
18637	21411	22	Hess	Hess	NNP
18637	21411	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21411	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	21411	25	_	_	NNP
18637	21411	26	Pawloski	Pawloski	NNP
18637	21411	27	,	,	,
18637	21411	28	the	the	DT
18637	21411	29	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	21411	30	of	of	IN
18637	21411	31	Flexner	Flexner	NNP
18637	21411	32	_	_	NNP
18637	21411	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	21411	34	_	_	NNP
18637	21411	35	Farson	Farson	NNP
18637	21411	36	,	,	,
18637	21411	37	"	"	``
18637	21411	38	that	that	IN
18637	21411	39	the	the	DT
18637	21411	40	mere	mere	JJ
18637	21411	41	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	21411	42	of	of	IN
18637	21411	43	business	business	NN
18637	21411	44	in	in	IN
18637	21411	45	a	a	DT
18637	21411	46	State	state	NN
18637	21411	47	by	by	IN
18637	21411	48	a	a	DT
18637	21411	49	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	21411	50	natural	natural	JJ
18637	21411	51	person	person	NN
18637	21411	52	does	do	VBZ
18637	21411	53	not	not	RB
18637	21411	54	imply	imply	VB
18637	21411	55	consent	consent	NN
18637	21411	56	to	to	TO
18637	21411	57	be	be	VB
18637	21411	58	bound	bind	VBN
18637	21411	59	by	by	IN
18637	21411	60	the	the	DT
18637	21411	61	process	process	NN
18637	21411	62	of	of	IN
18637	21411	63	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21411	64	courts	court	NNS
18637	21411	65	,	,	,
18637	21411	66	"	"	''
18637	21411	67	was	be	VBD
18637	21411	68	recently	recently	RB
18637	21411	69	condemned	condemn	VBN
18637	21411	70	as	as	IN
18637	21411	71	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
18637	21411	72	"	"	''
18637	21411	73	to	to	TO
18637	21411	74	cope	cope	VB
18637	21411	75	with	with	IN
18637	21411	76	the	the	DT
18637	21411	77	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	21411	78	problem	problem	NN
18637	21411	79	of	of	IN
18637	21411	80	practical	practical	JJ
18637	21411	81	responsibility	responsibility	NN
18637	21411	82	of	of	IN
18637	21411	83	hazardous	hazardous	JJ
18637	21411	84	business	business	NN
18637	21411	85	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	21411	86	in	in	IN
18637	21411	87	absentia	absentia	NN
18637	21411	88	*	*	NFP
18637	21411	89	*	*	NFP
18637	21411	90	*	*	NFP
18637	21411	91	"	"	''
18637	21411	92	--Sugg	--sugg	NN
18637	21411	93	_	_	NNP
18637	21411	94	v.	v.	IN
18637	21411	95	_	_	NNP
18637	21411	96	Hendrix	Hendrix	NNP
18637	21411	97	,	,	,
18637	21411	98	142	142	CD
18637	21411	99	F.	F.	NNP
18637	21411	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21411	101	2d	2d	NNP
18637	21411	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21411	103	740	740	CD
18637	21411	104	,	,	,
18637	21411	105	742	742	CD
18637	21411	106	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21411	107	1944	1944	CD
18637	21411	108	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21411	109	.	.	.
18637	21412	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21412	2	701	701	CD
18637	21412	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21412	4	Hess	Hess	NNP
18637	21412	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21412	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21412	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21412	8	Pawloski	Pawloski	NNP
18637	21412	9	,	,	,
18637	21412	10	274	274	CD
18637	21412	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21412	12	352	352	CD
18637	21412	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21412	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	21412	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21412	16	;	;	:
18637	21412	17	Wuchter	Wuchter	NNP
18637	21412	18	_	_	NNP
18637	21412	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	21412	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21412	21	Pizzutti	Pizzutti	NNP
18637	21412	22	,	,	,
18637	21412	23	276	276	CD
18637	21412	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21412	25	13	13	CD
18637	21412	26	,	,	,
18637	21412	27	20	20	CD
18637	21412	28	,	,	,
18637	21412	29	24	24	CD
18637	21412	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21412	31	1928	1928	CD
18637	21412	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21412	33	.	.	.
18637	21413	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21413	2	702	702	CD
18637	21413	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21413	4	326	326	CD
18637	21413	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21413	6	310	310	CD
18637	21413	7	,	,	,
18637	21413	8	316	316	CD
18637	21413	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21413	10	1945	1945	CD
18637	21413	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21413	12	.	.	.
18637	21414	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21414	2	703	703	CD
18637	21414	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21414	4	326	326	CD
18637	21414	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21414	6	310	310	CD
18637	21414	7	.	.	.
18637	21415	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21415	2	704	704	CD
18637	21415	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21415	4	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	21415	5	&	&	CC
18637	21415	6	Reading	Reading	NNP
18637	21415	7	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	21415	8	.	.	.
18637	21416	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21416	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21416	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21416	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21416	5	McKibbin	McKibbin	NNP
18637	21416	6	,	,	,
18637	21416	7	243	243	CD
18637	21416	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21416	9	264	264	CD
18637	21416	10	,	,	,
18637	21416	11	265	265	CD
18637	21416	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21416	13	1917	1917	CD
18637	21416	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21416	15	.	.	.
18637	21417	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21417	2	705	705	CD
18637	21417	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21417	4	In	in	IN
18637	21417	5	a	a	DT
18637	21417	6	very	very	RB
18637	21417	7	few	few	JJ
18637	21417	8	cases	case	NNS
18637	21417	9	,	,	,
18637	21417	10	"	"	``
18637	21417	11	continuous	continuous	JJ
18637	21417	12	operations	operation	NNS
18637	21417	13	within	within	IN
18637	21417	14	a	a	DT
18637	21417	15	State	state	NN
18637	21417	16	were	be	VBD
18637	21417	17	thought	think	VBN
18637	21417	18	to	to	TO
18637	21417	19	be	be	VB
18637	21417	20	so	so	RB
18637	21417	21	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	21417	22	and	and	CC
18637	21417	23	of	of	IN
18637	21417	24	such	such	PDT
18637	21417	25	a	a	DT
18637	21417	26	nature	nature	NN
18637	21417	27	as	as	IN
18637	21417	28	to	to	TO
18637	21417	29	justify	justify	VB
18637	21417	30	suits	suit	NNS
18637	21417	31	against	against	IN
18637	21417	32	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21417	33	a	a	DT
18637	21417	34	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	21417	35	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	21417	36	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21417	37	on	on	IN
18637	21417	38	causes	cause	NNS
18637	21417	39	of	of	IN
18637	21417	40	action	action	NN
18637	21417	41	arising	arise	VBG
18637	21417	42	from	from	IN
18637	21417	43	dealings	dealing	NNS
18637	21417	44	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	21417	45	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	21417	46	from	from	IN
18637	21417	47	those	those	DT
18637	21417	48	"	"	``
18637	21417	49	operations.--_See	operations.--_See	``
18637	21417	50	_	_	NNP
18637	21417	51	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21417	52	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	21417	53	S.W.R.	S.W.R.	NNP
18637	21418	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21418	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21418	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21418	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21418	5	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	21418	6	,	,	,
18637	21418	7	227	227	CD
18637	21418	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21418	9	218	218	CD
18637	21418	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21418	11	1913	1913	CD
18637	21418	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21418	13	;	;	:
18637	21418	14	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	21418	15	,	,	,
18637	21418	16	K.	K.	NNP
18637	21418	17	&	&	CC
18637	21418	18	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	21419	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21419	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21419	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21419	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21419	5	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	21419	6	,	,	,
18637	21419	7	255	255	CD
18637	21419	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21419	9	565	565	CD
18637	21419	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21419	11	1921	1921	CD
18637	21419	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21419	13	.	.	.
18637	21420	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21420	2	706	706	CD
18637	21420	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21420	4	Old	Old	NNP
18637	21420	5	Wayne	Wayne	NNP
18637	21420	6	Life	Life	NNP
18637	21420	7	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	21420	8	.	.	.
18637	21421	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21421	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	21421	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21421	4	McDonough	McDonough	NNP
18637	21421	5	,	,	,
18637	21421	6	204	204	CD
18637	21421	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21421	8	8	8	CD
18637	21421	9	,	,	,
18637	21421	10	21	21	CD
18637	21421	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21421	12	1907	1907	CD
18637	21421	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21421	14	.	.	.
18637	21422	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21422	2	707	707	CD
18637	21422	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21422	4	Simon	Simon	NNP
18637	21422	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21422	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21422	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21422	8	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	21422	9	R.	R.	NNP
18637	21422	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21422	11	,	,	,
18637	21422	12	236	236	CD
18637	21422	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21422	14	115	115	CD
18637	21422	15	,	,	,
18637	21422	16	129	129	CD
18637	21422	17	-	-	SYM
18637	21422	18	130	130	CD
18637	21422	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21422	20	1915).--In	1915).--in	CD
18637	21422	21	neither	neither	CC
18637	21422	22	this	this	DT
18637	21422	23	case	case	NN
18637	21422	24	,	,	,
18637	21422	25	nor	nor	CC
18637	21422	26	the	the	DT
18637	21422	27	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	21422	28	decision	decision	NN
18637	21422	29	were	be	VBD
18637	21422	30	the	the	DT
18637	21422	31	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	21422	32	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	21422	33	notified	notify	VBN
18637	21422	34	of	of	IN
18637	21422	35	the	the	DT
18637	21422	36	pendency	pendency	NN
18637	21422	37	of	of	IN
18637	21422	38	the	the	DT
18637	21422	39	action	action	NN
18637	21422	40	,	,	,
18637	21422	41	service	service	NN
18637	21422	42	having	have	VBG
18637	21422	43	been	be	VBN
18637	21422	44	made	make	VBN
18637	21422	45	only	only	RB
18637	21422	46	on	on	IN
18637	21422	47	the	the	DT
18637	21422	48	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	21422	49	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	21422	50	or	or	CC
18637	21422	51	the	the	DT
18637	21422	52	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	21422	53	of	of	IN
18637	21422	54	State	State	NNP
18637	21422	55	.	.	.
18637	21423	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21423	2	708	708	CD
18637	21423	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21423	4	Green	Green	NNP
18637	21423	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21423	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21423	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21423	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21423	9	,	,	,
18637	21423	10	B.	B.	NNP
18637	21424	1	&	&	CC
18637	21424	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	21425	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21425	2	,	,	,
18637	21425	3	205	205	CD
18637	21425	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21425	5	530	530	CD
18637	21425	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21425	7	1907	1907	CD
18637	21425	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21425	9	.	.	.
18637	21426	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21426	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21426	3	also	also	RB
18637	21426	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21426	5	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	21426	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21426	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21426	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21426	9	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	21426	10	Co	Co	NNP
18637	21426	11	-	-	NNP
18637	21426	12	operative	operative	JJ
18637	21426	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21426	14	,	,	,
18637	21426	15	262	262	CD
18637	21426	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21426	17	312	312	CD
18637	21426	18	,	,	,
18637	21426	19	317	317	CD
18637	21426	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21426	21	1923	1923	CD
18637	21426	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21426	23	.	.	.
18637	21427	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21427	2	709	709	CD
18637	21427	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21427	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21427	5	F.	F.	NNP
18637	21427	6	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	21427	7	.	.	.
18637	21428	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21428	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21428	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21428	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21428	5	Gold	Gold	NNP
18637	21428	6	Issue	Issue	NNP
18637	21428	7	Min	Min	NNP
18637	21428	8	.	.	.
18637	21429	1	&	&	CC
18637	21429	2	M.	M.	NNP
18637	21429	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21429	4	,	,	,
18637	21429	5	243	243	CD
18637	21429	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21429	7	93	93	CD
18637	21429	8	,	,	,
18637	21429	9	95	95	CD
18637	21429	10	-	-	SYM
18637	21429	11	96	96	CD
18637	21429	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21429	13	1917	1917	CD
18637	21429	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21429	15	.	.	.
18637	21430	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21430	2	710	710	CD
18637	21430	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21430	4	Rosenberg	Rosenberg	NNP
18637	21430	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	21430	6	&	&	CC
18637	21430	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21430	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21430	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21430	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21430	11	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	21430	12	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	21430	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21430	14	,	,	,
18637	21430	15	260	260	CD
18637	21430	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21430	17	516	516	CD
18637	21430	18	,	,	,
18637	21430	19	517	517	CD
18637	21430	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21430	21	1923	1923	CD
18637	21430	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21430	23	.	.	.
18637	21431	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21431	2	711	711	CD
18637	21431	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21431	4	Goldey	Goldey	NNP
18637	21431	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21431	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21431	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21431	8	Morning	Morning	NNP
18637	21431	9	News	News	NNP
18637	21431	10	,	,	,
18637	21431	11	156	156	CD
18637	21431	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21431	13	518	518	CD
18637	21431	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21431	15	1895	1895	CD
18637	21431	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21431	17	.	.	.
18637	21432	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21432	2	712	712	CD
18637	21432	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21432	4	Conley	Conley	NNP
18637	21432	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21432	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21432	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21432	8	Mathieson	Mathieson	NNP
18637	21432	9	Alkali	Alkali	NNP
18637	21432	10	Works	Works	NNP
18637	21432	11	,	,	,
18637	21432	12	190	190	CD
18637	21432	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21432	14	406	406	CD
18637	21432	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21432	16	1903	1903	CD
18637	21432	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21432	18	.	.	.
18637	21433	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21433	2	713	713	CD
18637	21433	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21433	4	Riverside	Riverside	NNP
18637	21433	5	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	21433	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21433	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21433	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21433	9	Menefee	Menefee	NNP
18637	21433	10	,	,	,
18637	21433	11	237	237	CD
18637	21433	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21433	13	189	189	CD
18637	21433	14	,	,	,
18637	21433	15	195	195	CD
18637	21433	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21433	17	1915	1915	CD
18637	21433	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21433	19	.	.	.
18637	21434	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21434	2	714	714	CD
18637	21434	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21434	4	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	21434	5	Life	Life	NNP
18637	21434	6	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	21434	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21434	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21434	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21434	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21434	11	Spratley	Spratley	NNP
18637	21434	12	,	,	,
18637	21434	13	172	172	CD
18637	21434	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21434	15	602	602	CD
18637	21434	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21434	17	1899	1899	CD
18637	21434	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21434	19	.	.	.
18637	21435	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21435	2	715	715	CD
18637	21435	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21435	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21435	5	Clair	Clair	NNP
18637	21435	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21435	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21435	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21435	9	Cox	Cox	NNP
18637	21435	10	,	,	,
18637	21435	11	106	106	CD
18637	21435	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21435	13	350	350	CD
18637	21435	14	,	,	,
18637	21435	15	356	356	CD
18637	21435	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21435	17	1882	1882	CD
18637	21435	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21435	19	.	.	.
18637	21436	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21436	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21436	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21436	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21436	5	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	21436	6	S.W.R.	S.W.R.	NNP
18637	21437	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21437	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21437	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21437	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21437	5	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	21437	6	,	,	,
18637	21437	7	227	227	CD
18637	21437	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21437	9	218	218	CD
18637	21437	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21437	11	1913	1913	CD
18637	21437	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21437	13	.	.	.
18637	21438	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21438	2	716	716	CD
18637	21438	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21438	4	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	21438	5	Reserve	Reserve	NNP
18637	21438	6	&	&	CC
18637	21438	7	c.	c.	NNP
18637	21438	8	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	21438	9	.	.	.
18637	21439	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21439	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	21439	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21439	4	Phelps	Phelps	NNP
18637	21439	5	,	,	,
18637	21439	6	190	190	CD
18637	21439	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21439	8	147	147	CD
18637	21439	9	,	,	,
18637	21439	10	156	156	CD
18637	21439	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21439	12	1903	1903	CD
18637	21439	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21439	14	.	.	.
18637	21440	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21440	2	717	717	CD
18637	21440	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21440	4	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	21440	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21440	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21440	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21440	8	Superior	Superior	NNP
18637	21440	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21440	10	,	,	,
18637	21440	11	289	289	CD
18637	21440	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21440	13	361	361	CD
18637	21440	14	,	,	,
18637	21440	15	365	365	CD
18637	21440	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21440	17	1933	1933	CD
18637	21440	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21440	19	.	.	.
18637	21441	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21441	2	718	718	CD
18637	21441	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21441	4	326	326	CD
18637	21441	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21441	6	310	310	CD
18637	21441	7	,	,	,
18637	21441	8	317	317	CD
18637	21441	9	-	-	SYM
18637	21441	10	320	320	CD
18637	21441	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21441	12	1945	1945	CD
18637	21441	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21441	14	.	.	.
18637	21442	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21442	2	719	719	LS
18637	21442	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21442	4	This	this	DT
18637	21442	5	departure	departure	NN
18637	21442	6	was	be	VBD
18637	21442	7	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	21442	8	by	by	IN
18637	21442	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21442	10	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21442	11	in	in	IN
18637	21442	12	a	a	DT
18637	21442	13	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	21442	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21442	15	in	in	IN
18637	21442	16	Nippert	Nippert	NNP
18637	21442	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21442	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	21442	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21442	20	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	21442	21	,	,	,
18637	21442	22	327	327	CD
18637	21442	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21442	24	416	416	CD
18637	21442	25	,	,	,
18637	21442	26	422	422	CD
18637	21442	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21442	28	1946	1946	CD
18637	21442	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21442	30	.	.	.
18637	21443	1	The	the	DT
18637	21443	2	principle	principle	NN
18637	21443	3	that	that	DT
18637	21443	4	solicitation	solicitation	NN
18637	21443	5	of	of	IN
18637	21443	6	business	business	NN
18637	21443	7	alone	alone	RB
18637	21443	8	is	be	VBZ
18637	21443	9	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
18637	21443	10	to	to	TO
18637	21443	11	confer	confer	VB
18637	21443	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	21443	13	for	for	IN
18637	21443	14	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	21443	15	of	of	IN
18637	21443	16	subjecting	subject	VBG
18637	21443	17	a	a	DT
18637	21443	18	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	21443	19	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	21443	20	to	to	IN
18637	21443	21	a	a	DT
18637	21443	22	suit	suit	NN
18637	21443	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21443	24	in	in	IN
18637	21443	25	personam	personam	NNP
18637	21443	26	_	_	NNP
18637	21443	27	was	be	VBD
18637	21443	28	established	establish	VBN
18637	21443	29	in	in	IN
18637	21443	30	Green	Green	NNP
18637	21443	31	_	_	NNP
18637	21443	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	21443	33	_	_	NNP
18637	21443	34	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21443	35	,	,	,
18637	21443	36	B.	B.	NNP
18637	21444	1	&	&	CC
18637	21444	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	21445	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21445	2	,	,	,
18637	21445	3	205	205	CD
18637	21445	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21445	5	530	530	CD
18637	21445	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21445	7	1907	1907	CD
18637	21445	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21445	9	;	;	:
18637	21445	10	but	but	CC
18637	21445	11	was	be	VBD
18637	21445	12	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	21445	13	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	21445	14	by	by	IN
18637	21445	15	the	the	DT
18637	21445	16	later	later	JJ
18637	21445	17	holding	holding	NN
18637	21445	18	in	in	IN
18637	21445	19	International	International	NNP
18637	21445	20	Harvester	Harvester	NNP
18637	21445	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21445	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21445	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	21445	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21445	25	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21445	26	,	,	,
18637	21445	27	234	234	CD
18637	21445	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21445	29	579	579	CD
18637	21445	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21445	31	1914	1914	CD
18637	21445	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21445	33	to	to	IN
18637	21445	34	the	the	DT
18637	21445	35	effect	effect	NN
18637	21445	36	that	that	IN
18637	21445	37	when	when	WRB
18637	21445	38	solicitation	solicitation	NN
18637	21445	39	was	be	VBD
18637	21445	40	connected	connect	VBN
18637	21445	41	with	with	IN
18637	21445	42	other	other	JJ
18637	21445	43	activities	activity	NNS
18637	21445	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21445	45	in	in	IN
18637	21445	46	the	the	DT
18637	21445	47	latter	latter	JJ
18637	21445	48	case	case	NN
18637	21445	49	,	,	,
18637	21445	50	the	the	DT
18637	21445	51	local	local	JJ
18637	21445	52	agents	agent	NNS
18637	21445	53	collected	collect	VBN
18637	21445	54	from	from	IN
18637	21445	55	the	the	DT
18637	21445	56	customers	customer	NNS
18637	21445	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21445	58	,	,	,
18637	21445	59	a	a	DT
18637	21445	60	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	21445	61	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	21445	62	was	be	VBD
18637	21445	63	then	then	RB
18637	21445	64	doing	do	VBG
18637	21445	65	business	business	NN
18637	21445	66	within	within	IN
18637	21445	67	the	the	DT
18637	21445	68	forum	forum	NN
18637	21445	69	State	state	NN
18637	21445	70	.	.	.
18637	21446	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	21446	2	as	as	IN
18637	21446	3	the	the	DT
18637	21446	4	International	International	NNP
18637	21446	5	Shoe	Shoe	NNP
18637	21446	6	Company	Company	NNP
18637	21446	7	,	,	,
18637	21446	8	in	in	IN
18637	21446	9	addition	addition	NN
18637	21446	10	to	to	IN
18637	21446	11	having	have	VBG
18637	21446	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21446	13	agents	agent	NNS
18637	21446	14	solicit	solicit	NN
18637	21446	15	orders	order	NNS
18637	21446	16	,	,	,
18637	21446	17	also	also	RB
18637	21446	18	permitted	permit	VBD
18637	21446	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21446	20	to	to	TO
18637	21446	21	rent	rent	VB
18637	21446	22	quarters	quarter	NNS
18637	21446	23	for	for	IN
18637	21446	24	the	the	DT
18637	21446	25	display	display	NN
18637	21446	26	of	of	IN
18637	21446	27	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	21446	28	,	,	,
18637	21446	29	the	the	DT
18637	21446	30	observation	observation	NN
18637	21446	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	21446	32	been	be	VBN
18637	21446	33	made	make	VBN
18637	21446	34	that	that	IN
18637	21446	35	the	the	DT
18637	21446	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21446	37	,	,	,
18637	21446	38	by	by	IN
18637	21446	39	applying	apply	VBG
18637	21446	40	the	the	DT
18637	21446	41	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	21446	42	of	of	IN
18637	21446	43	the	the	DT
18637	21446	44	International	International	NNP
18637	21446	45	Harvester	Harvester	NNP
18637	21446	46	Case	Case	NNP
18637	21446	47	,	,	,
18637	21446	48	could	could	MD
18637	21446	49	have	have	VB
18637	21446	50	decided	decide	VBN
18637	21446	51	International	International	NNP
18637	21446	52	Shoe	Shoe	NNP
18637	21446	53	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21446	54	_	_	NNP
18637	21446	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	21446	56	_	_	NNP
18637	21446	57	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	21446	58	,	,	,
18637	21446	59	326	326	CD
18637	21446	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21446	61	310	310	CD
18637	21446	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21446	63	1945	1945	CD
18637	21446	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21446	65	as	as	IN
18637	21446	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21446	67	did	do	VBD
18637	21446	68	without	without	IN
18637	21446	69	abandoning	abandon	VBG
18637	21446	70	the	the	DT
18637	21446	71	"	"	``
18637	21446	72	presence	presence	NN
18637	21446	73	"	"	''
18637	21446	74	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	21446	75	.	.	.
18637	21447	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21447	2	720	720	CD
18637	21447	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21447	4	326	326	CD
18637	21447	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21447	6	310	310	CD
18637	21447	7	,	,	,
18637	21447	8	316	316	CD
18637	21447	9	-	-	SYM
18637	21447	10	317	317	CD
18637	21447	11	.	.	.
18637	21448	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21448	2	721	721	CD
18637	21448	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21448	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21448	5	.	.	.
18637	21449	1	319	319	CD
18637	21449	2	.	.	.
18637	21450	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21450	2	722	722	CD
18637	21450	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21450	4	339	339	CD
18637	21450	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21450	6	643	643	CD
18637	21450	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21450	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	21450	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21450	10	.	.	.
18637	21451	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21451	2	723	723	CD
18637	21451	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21451	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21451	5	.	.	.
18637	21452	1	647	647	CD
18637	21452	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21452	3	649.--Concerning	649.--concerning	CD
18637	21452	4	the	the	DT
18637	21452	5	holding	holding	NN
18637	21452	6	in	in	IN
18637	21452	7	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	21452	8	Ass'n	Ass'n	NNP
18637	21452	9	.	.	.
18637	21453	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21453	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	21453	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21453	4	Benn	Benn	NNP
18637	21453	5	,	,	,
18637	21453	6	261	261	CD
18637	21453	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21453	8	140	140	CD
18637	21453	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21453	10	1923	1923	CD
18637	21453	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21453	12	,	,	,
18637	21453	13	that	that	IN
18637	21453	14	a	a	DT
18637	21453	15	similar	similar	JJ
18637	21453	16	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	21453	17	mail	mail	NN
18637	21453	18	order	order	NN
18637	21453	19	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	21453	20	company	company	NN
18637	21453	21	could	could	MD
18637	21453	22	not	not	RB
18637	21453	23	be	be	VB
18637	21453	24	viewed	view	VBN
18637	21453	25	as	as	IN
18637	21453	26	doing	do	VBG
18637	21453	27	business	business	NN
18637	21453	28	in	in	IN
18637	21453	29	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	21453	30	where	where	WRB
18637	21453	31	the	the	DT
18637	21453	32	claimant	claimant	JJ
18637	21453	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	21453	34	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	21453	35	lived	live	VBD
18637	21453	36	,	,	,
18637	21453	37	and	and	CC
18637	21453	38	that	that	IN
18637	21453	39	the	the	DT
18637	21453	40	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	21453	41	under	under	IN
18637	21453	42	which	which	WDT
18637	21453	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21453	44	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	21453	45	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	21453	46	,	,	,
18637	21453	47	executed	execute	VBN
18637	21453	48	and	and	CC
18637	21453	49	to	to	TO
18637	21453	50	be	be	VB
18637	21453	51	performed	perform	VBN
18637	21453	52	in	in	IN
18637	21453	53	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	21453	54	,	,	,
18637	21453	55	were	be	VBD
18637	21453	56	consummated	consummate	VBN
18637	21453	57	could	could	MD
18637	21453	58	not	not	RB
18637	21453	59	support	support	VB
18637	21453	60	in	in	IN
18637	21453	61	implication	implication	NN
18637	21453	62	that	that	IN
18637	21453	63	the	the	DT
18637	21453	64	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	21453	65	insurer	insurer	NN
18637	21453	66	had	have	VBD
18637	21453	67	consented	consent	VBN
18637	21453	68	to	to	TO
18637	21453	69	be	be	VB
18637	21453	70	sued	sue	VBN
18637	21453	71	in	in	IN
18637	21453	72	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	21453	73	,	,	,
18637	21453	74	the	the	DT
18637	21453	75	majority	majority	NN
18637	21453	76	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	21453	77	that	that	IN
18637	21453	78	the	the	DT
18637	21453	79	"	"	``
18637	21453	80	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	21453	81	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	21453	82	relied	rely	VBN
18637	21453	83	on	on	RP
18637	21453	84	by	by	IN
18637	21453	85	the	the	DT
18637	21453	86	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21453	87	in	in	IN
18637	21453	88	the	the	DT
18637	21453	89	Benn	Benn	NNP
18637	21453	90	Case	Case	NNP
18637	21453	91	can	can	MD
18637	21453	92	not	not	RB
18637	21453	93	be	be	VB
18637	21453	94	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	21453	95	controlling	control	VBG
18637	21453	96	.	.	.
18637	21453	97	"	"	''
18637	21454	1	Declaring	declare	VBG
18637	21454	2	that	that	IN
18637	21454	3	what	what	WP
18637	21454	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	21454	5	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	21454	6	to	to	TO
18637	21454	7	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	21454	8	a	a	DT
18637	21454	9	suit	suit	NN
18637	21454	10	by	by	IN
18637	21454	11	a	a	DT
18637	21454	12	policyholder	policyholder	NN
18637	21454	13	in	in	IN
18637	21454	14	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	21454	15	against	against	IN
18637	21454	16	a	a	DT
18637	21454	17	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	21454	18	insurer	insurer	NN
18637	21454	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	21454	20	not	not	RB
18637	21454	21	determinative	determinative	JJ
18637	21454	22	when	when	WRB
18637	21454	23	the	the	DT
18637	21454	24	State	state	NN
18637	21454	25	seeks	seek	VBZ
18637	21454	26	to	to	TO
18637	21454	27	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	21454	28	solicitation	solicitation	NN
18637	21454	29	within	within	IN
18637	21454	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21454	31	borders	border	NNS
18637	21454	32	,	,	,
18637	21454	33	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21454	34	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	21454	35	,	,	,
18637	21454	36	in	in	IN
18637	21454	37	a	a	DT
18637	21454	38	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	21454	39	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21454	40	,	,	,
18637	21454	41	emphasized	emphasize	VBD
18637	21454	42	that	that	IN
18637	21454	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21454	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	21454	45	the	the	DT
18637	21454	46	nature	nature	NN
18637	21454	47	of	of	IN
18637	21454	48	the	the	DT
18637	21454	49	State	State	NNP
18637	21454	50	's	's	POS
18637	21454	51	action	action	NN
18637	21454	52	that	that	WDT
18637	21454	53	determines	determine	VBZ
18637	21454	54	the	the	DT
18637	21454	55	degree	degree	NN
18637	21454	56	of	of	IN
18637	21454	57	activity	activity	NN
18637	21454	58	in	in	IN
18637	21454	59	a	a	DT
18637	21454	60	State	State	NNP
18637	21454	61	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	21454	62	for	for	IN
18637	21454	63	satisfying	satisfy	VBG
18637	21454	64	the	the	DT
18637	21454	65	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	21454	66	of	of	IN
18637	21454	67	due	due	JJ
18637	21454	68	process	process	NN
18637	21454	69	,	,	,
18637	21454	70	and	and	CC
18637	21454	71	that	that	DT
18637	21454	72	solicitation	solicitation	NN
18637	21454	73	by	by	IN
18637	21454	74	existing	exist	VBG
18637	21454	75	members	member	NNS
18637	21454	76	operates	operate	VBZ
18637	21454	77	as	as	IN
18637	21454	78	though	though	IN
18637	21454	79	the	the	DT
18637	21454	80	insurer	insurer	NN
18637	21454	81	"	"	``
18637	21454	82	had	have	VBD
18637	21454	83	formally	formally	RB
18637	21454	84	designated	designate	VBN
18637	21454	85	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	21454	86	members	member	NNS
18637	21454	87	as	as	IN
18637	21454	88	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21454	89	agents	agent	NNS
18637	21454	90	.	.	.
18637	21454	91	"	"	''
18637	21455	1	Insisting	insist	VBG
18637	21455	2	that	that	IN
18637	21455	3	"	"	``
18637	21455	4	an	an	DT
18637	21455	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21455	6	in	in	IN
18637	21455	7	personam	personam	NNP
18637	21455	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21455	9	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	21455	10	can	can	MD
18637	21455	11	not	not	RB
18637	21455	12	be	be	VB
18637	21455	13	based	base	VBN
18637	21455	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	21455	15	service	service	NN
18637	21455	16	by	by	IN
18637	21455	17	registered	register	VBN
18637	21455	18	letter	letter	NN
18637	21455	19	on	on	IN
18637	21455	20	a	a	DT
18637	21455	21	nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	21455	22	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	21455	23	or	or	CC
18637	21455	24	a	a	DT
18637	21455	25	natural	natural	JJ
18637	21455	26	person	person	NN
18637	21455	27	,	,	,
18637	21455	28	neither	neither	DT
18637	21455	29	of	of	IN
18637	21455	30	whom	whom	WP
18637	21455	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	21455	32	ever	ever	RB
18637	21455	33	been	be	VBN
18637	21455	34	"	"	''
18637	21455	35	in	in	IN
18637	21455	36	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	21455	37	,	,	,
18637	21455	38	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21455	39	Minton	Minton	NNP
18637	21455	40	,	,	,
18637	21455	41	with	with	IN
18637	21455	42	whom	whom	WP
18637	21455	43	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21455	44	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	21455	45	was	be	VBD
18637	21455	46	associated	associate	VBN
18637	21455	47	in	in	IN
18637	21455	48	a	a	DT
18637	21455	49	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	21455	50	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21455	51	,	,	,
18637	21455	52	would	would	MD
18637	21455	53	have	have	VB
18637	21455	54	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
18637	21455	55	the	the	DT
18637	21455	56	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	21455	57	on	on	IN
18637	21455	58	the	the	DT
18637	21455	59	ground	ground	NN
18637	21455	60	that	that	IN
18637	21455	61	"	"	``
18637	21455	62	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	21455	63	has	have	VBZ
18637	21455	64	not	not	RB
18637	21455	65	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	21455	66	the	the	DT
18637	21455	67	power	power	NN
18637	21455	68	to	to	TO
18637	21455	69	require	require	VB
18637	21455	70	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21455	71	the	the	DT
18637	21455	72	insurer	insurer	NN
18637	21455	73	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21455	74	*	*	NFP
18637	21455	75	*	*	NFP
18637	21455	76	*	*	NFP
18637	21455	77	to	to	TO
18637	21455	78	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	21455	79	the	the	DT
18637	21455	80	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	21455	81	of	of	IN
18637	21455	82	State	State	NNP
18637	21455	83	as	as	IN
18637	21455	84	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21455	85	agent	agent	NN
18637	21455	86	for	for	IN
18637	21455	87	service	service	NN
18637	21455	88	of	of	IN
18637	21455	89	process	process	NN
18637	21455	90	,	,	,
18637	21455	91	nor	nor	CC
18637	21455	92	have	have	VBP
18637	21455	93	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21455	94	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21455	95	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21455	96	courts	court	NNS
18637	21455	97	rendered	render	VBN
18637	21455	98	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	21455	99	in	in	IN
18637	21455	100	a	a	DT
18637	21455	101	suit	suit	NN
18637	21455	102	where	where	WRB
18637	21455	103	service	service	NN
18637	21455	104	was	be	VBD
18637	21455	105	made	make	VBN
18637	21455	106	in	in	IN
18637	21455	107	that	that	DT
18637	21455	108	manner	manner	NN
18637	21455	109	.	.	.
18637	21455	110	"	"	''
18637	21456	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21456	2	would	would	MD
18637	21456	3	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	21456	4	let	let	VB
18637	21456	5	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	21456	6	"	"	``
18637	21456	7	go	go	VB
18637	21456	8	through	through	IN
18637	21456	9	this	this	DT
18637	21456	10	shadow	shadow	NN
18637	21456	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	21456	12	boxing	box	VBG
18637	21456	13	performance	performance	NN
18637	21456	14	in	in	IN
18637	21456	15	order	order	NN
18637	21456	16	to	to	TO
18637	21456	17	publicize	publicize	VB
18637	21456	18	the	the	DT
18637	21456	19	activities	activity	NNS
18637	21456	20	of	of	IN
18637	21456	21	"	"	``
18637	21456	22	the	the	DT
18637	21456	23	insurer.--Justices	insurer.--Justices	NNP
18637	21456	24	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	21456	25	and	and	CC
18637	21456	26	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	21456	27	joined	join	VBD
18637	21456	28	this	this	DT
18637	21456	29	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	21456	30	on	on	IN
18637	21456	31	the	the	DT
18637	21456	32	merits.--Ibid	merits.--ibid	NN
18637	21456	33	.	.	.
18637	21457	1	655	655	CD
18637	21457	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21457	3	656	656	CD
18637	21457	4	,	,	,
18637	21457	5	658	658	CD
18637	21457	6	,	,	,
18637	21457	7	659	659	CD
18637	21457	8	.	.	.
18637	21458	1	In	in	IN
18637	21458	2	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
18637	21458	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21458	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	21458	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21458	6	Benguet	Benguet	NNP
18637	21458	7	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	21458	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21458	9	,	,	,
18637	21458	10	342	342	CD
18637	21458	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21458	12	437	437	CD
18637	21458	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21458	14	1952	1952	CD
18637	21458	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21458	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21458	17	was	be	VBD
18637	21458	18	held	hold	VBN
18637	21458	19	,	,	,
18637	21458	20	that	that	IN
18637	21458	21	the	the	DT
18637	21458	22	State	State	NNP
18637	21458	23	of	of	IN
18637	21458	24	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	21458	25	was	be	VBD
18637	21458	26	free	free	JJ
18637	21458	27	either	either	CC
18637	21458	28	to	to	TO
18637	21458	29	open	open	VB
18637	21458	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21458	31	courts	court	NNS
18637	21458	32	,	,	,
18637	21458	33	or	or	CC
18637	21458	34	to	to	TO
18637	21458	35	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	21458	36	to	to	TO
18637	21458	37	do	do	VB
18637	21458	38	so	so	RB
18637	21458	39	,	,	,
18637	21458	40	to	to	IN
18637	21458	41	a	a	DT
18637	21458	42	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	21458	43	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	21458	44	owning	own	VBG
18637	21458	45	gold	gold	NN
18637	21458	46	and	and	CC
18637	21458	47	silver	silver	NN
18637	21458	48	mines	mine	NNS
18637	21458	49	in	in	IN
18637	21458	50	the	the	DT
18637	21458	51	Philippine	Philippine	NNP
18637	21458	52	Islands	Islands	NNPS
18637	21458	53	,	,	,
18637	21458	54	but	but	CC
18637	21458	55	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	21458	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21458	57	during	during	IN
18637	21458	58	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	21458	59	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	21458	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21458	61	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	21458	62	on	on	IN
18637	21458	63	a	a	DT
18637	21458	64	part	part	NN
18637	21458	65	of	of	IN
18637	21458	66	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21458	67	general	general	JJ
18637	21458	68	business	business	NN
18637	21458	69	in	in	IN
18637	21458	70	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	21458	71	,	,	,
18637	21458	72	including	include	VBG
18637	21458	73	directors	director	NNS
18637	21458	74	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	21458	75	,	,	,
18637	21458	76	business	business	NN
18637	21458	77	correspondence	correspondence	NN
18637	21458	78	,	,	,
18637	21458	79	banking	banking	NN
18637	21458	80	,	,	,
18637	21458	81	etc	etc	FW
18637	21458	82	.	.	.
18637	21459	1	Two	two	CD
18637	21459	2	members	member	NNS
18637	21459	3	of	of	IN
18637	21459	4	the	the	DT
18637	21459	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21459	6	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	21459	7	,	,	,
18637	21459	8	contending	contend	VBG
18637	21459	9	that	that	IN
18637	21459	10	what	what	WP
18637	21459	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21459	12	was	be	VBD
18637	21459	13	doing	do	VBG
18637	21459	14	was	be	VBD
18637	21459	15	"	"	``
18637	21459	16	giving	give	VBG
18637	21459	17	gratuitously	gratuitously	RB
18637	21459	18	an	an	DT
18637	21459	19	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	21459	20	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21459	21	to	to	IN
18637	21459	22	the	the	DT
18637	21459	23	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	21459	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21459	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21459	26	.	.	.
18637	21460	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21460	2	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21460	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21460	4	would	would	MD
18637	21460	5	dismiss	dismiss	VB
18637	21460	6	the	the	DT
18637	21460	7	writ	writ	VBN
18637	21460	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21460	9	of	of	IN
18637	21460	10	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	21460	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21460	12	as	as	IN
18637	21460	13	improvidently	improvidently	RB
18637	21460	14	granted	grant	VBN
18637	21460	15	.	.	.
18637	21460	16	"	"	''
18637	21461	1	The	the	DT
18637	21461	2	case	case	NN
18637	21461	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	21461	4	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	21461	5	too	too	RB
18637	21461	6	atypical	atypical	JJ
18637	21461	7	to	to	TO
18637	21461	8	offer	offer	VB
18637	21461	9	much	much	JJ
18637	21461	10	promise	promise	NN
18637	21461	11	of	of	IN
18637	21461	12	importance	importance	NN
18637	21461	13	as	as	IN
18637	21461	14	a	a	DT
18637	21461	15	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	21461	16	.	.	.
18637	21462	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21462	2	724	724	CD
18637	21462	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21462	4	Arndt	Arndt	NNP
18637	21462	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21462	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21462	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21462	8	Griggs	Griggs	NNP
18637	21462	9	,	,	,
18637	21462	10	134	134	CD
18637	21462	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21462	12	316	316	CD
18637	21462	13	,	,	,
18637	21462	14	321	321	CD
18637	21462	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21462	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	21462	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21462	18	.	.	.
18637	21463	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21463	2	725	725	CD
18637	21463	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21463	4	Ballard	Ballard	NNP
18637	21463	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21463	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21463	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21463	8	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	21463	9	,	,	,
18637	21463	10	204	204	CD
18637	21463	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21463	12	241	241	CD
18637	21463	13	,	,	,
18637	21463	14	254	254	CD
18637	21463	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21463	16	1907	1907	CD
18637	21463	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21463	18	;	;	:
18637	21463	19	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
18637	21463	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21463	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21463	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21463	23	Neff	Neff	NNP
18637	21463	24	,	,	,
18637	21463	25	95	95	CD
18637	21463	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21463	27	714	714	CD
18637	21463	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21463	29	1878	1878	CD
18637	21463	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21463	31	.	.	.
18637	21464	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21464	2	726	726	CD
18637	21464	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21464	4	Dewey	Dewey	NNP
18637	21464	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21464	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21464	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21464	8	Des	Des	NNP
18637	21464	9	Moines	Moines	NNP
18637	21464	10	,	,	,
18637	21464	11	173	173	CD
18637	21464	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21464	13	193	193	CD
18637	21464	14	,	,	,
18637	21464	15	203	203	CD
18637	21464	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21464	17	1899	1899	CD
18637	21464	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21464	19	;	;	:
18637	21464	20	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
18637	21464	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21464	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	21464	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21464	24	Neff	Neff	NNP
18637	21464	25	,	,	,
18637	21464	26	95	95	CD
18637	21464	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21464	28	714	714	CD
18637	21464	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21464	30	1878	1878	CD
18637	21464	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21464	32	.	.	.
18637	21465	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21465	2	727	727	CD
18637	21465	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21465	4	American	American	NNP
18637	21465	5	Land	Land	NNP
18637	21465	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21465	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21465	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21465	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21465	10	Zeiss	Zeiss	NNP
18637	21465	11	,	,	,
18637	21465	12	219	219	CD
18637	21465	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21465	14	47	47	CD
18637	21465	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21465	16	1911	1911	CD
18637	21465	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21465	18	.	.	.
18637	21466	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21466	2	728	728	CD
18637	21466	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21466	4	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
18637	21466	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21466	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21466	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21466	8	Neff	Neff	NNP
18637	21466	9	,	,	,
18637	21466	10	95	95	CD
18637	21466	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21466	12	714	714	CD
18637	21466	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21466	14	1878	1878	CD
18637	21466	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21466	16	;	;	:
18637	21466	17	citing	cite	VBG
18637	21466	18	Boswell	Boswell	NNP
18637	21466	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21466	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	21466	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21466	22	Otis	Otis	NNP
18637	21466	23	,	,	,
18637	21466	24	9	9	CD
18637	21466	25	How	how	WRB
18637	21466	26	.	.	.
18637	21467	1	336	336	CD
18637	21467	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21467	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	21467	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21467	5	;	;	:
18637	21467	6	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	21467	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21467	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21467	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21467	10	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	21467	11	,	,	,
18637	21467	12	10	10	CD
18637	21467	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	21467	14	.	.	.
18637	21468	1	308	308	CD
18637	21468	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21468	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	21468	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21468	5	.	.	.
18637	21469	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	21469	2	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	21469	3	,	,	,
18637	21469	4	by	by	IN
18637	21469	5	way	way	NN
18637	21469	6	of	of	IN
18637	21469	7	example	example	NN
18637	21469	8	,	,	,
18637	21469	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	21469	10	also	also	RB
18637	21469	11	available	available	JJ
18637	21469	12	to	to	IN
18637	21469	13	a	a	DT
18637	21469	14	wife	wife	NN
18637	21469	15	who	who	WP
18637	21469	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	21469	17	enabled	enable	VBN
18637	21469	18	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	21469	19	to	to	TO
18637	21469	20	impound	impound	VB
18637	21469	21	local	local	JJ
18637	21469	22	bank	bank	NN
18637	21469	23	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	21469	24	of	of	IN
18637	21469	25	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21469	26	absent	absent	JJ
18637	21469	27	husband	husband	NN
18637	21469	28	for	for	IN
18637	21469	29	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	21469	30	of	of	IN
18637	21469	31	collecting	collect	VBG
18637	21469	32	unpaid	unpaid	JJ
18637	21469	33	instalments	instalment	NNS
18637	21469	34	by	by	IN
18637	21469	35	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21469	36	.	.	.
18637	21470	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	21470	2	,	,	,
18637	21470	3	because	because	IN
18637	21470	4	of	of	IN
18637	21470	5	the	the	DT
18637	21470	6	antiquity	antiquity	NN
18637	21470	7	of	of	IN
18637	21470	8	the	the	DT
18637	21470	9	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	21470	10	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	21470	11	,	,	,
18637	21470	12	a	a	DT
18637	21470	13	statute	statute	NN
18637	21470	14	permitting	permit	VBG
18637	21470	15	the	the	DT
18637	21470	16	impounding	impounding	NN
18637	21470	17	of	of	IN
18637	21470	18	property	property	NN
18637	21470	19	of	of	IN
18637	21470	20	an	an	DT
18637	21470	21	absconding	abscond	VBG
18637	21470	22	father	father	NN
18637	21470	23	for	for	IN
18637	21470	24	the	the	DT
18637	21470	25	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	21470	26	of	of	IN
18637	21470	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21470	28	children	child	NNS
18637	21470	29	is	be	VBZ
18637	21470	30	not	not	RB
18637	21470	31	in	in	IN
18637	21470	32	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	21470	33	with	with	IN
18637	21470	34	due	due	JJ
18637	21470	35	process	process	NN
18637	21470	36	because	because	IN
18637	21470	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21470	38	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	21470	39	to	to	TO
18637	21470	40	provide	provide	VB
18637	21470	41	for	for	IN
18637	21470	42	notice	notice	NN
18637	21470	43	,	,	,
18637	21470	44	actual	actual	JJ
18637	21470	45	or	or	CC
18637	21470	46	constructive	constructive	JJ
18637	21470	47	,	,	,
18637	21470	48	to	to	IN
18637	21470	49	the	the	DT
18637	21470	50	absconder.--Pennington	absconder.--pennington	CD
18637	21470	51	_	_	NNP
18637	21470	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	21470	53	_	_	NNP
18637	21470	54	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	21470	55	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	21470	56	.	.	.
18637	21471	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21471	2	,	,	,
18637	21471	3	243	243	CD
18637	21471	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21471	5	269	269	CD
18637	21471	6	,	,	,
18637	21471	7	271	271	CD
18637	21471	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21471	9	1917	1917	CD
18637	21471	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21471	11	;	;	:
18637	21471	12	Corn	corn	NN
18637	21471	13	Exch	Exch	NNS
18637	21471	14	.	.	.
18637	21472	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21472	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21472	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21472	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21472	5	Coler	Coler	NNP
18637	21472	6	,	,	,
18637	21472	7	280	280	CD
18637	21472	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21472	9	218	218	CD
18637	21472	10	,	,	,
18637	21472	11	222	222	CD
18637	21472	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21472	13	1930	1930	CD
18637	21472	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21472	15	.	.	.
18637	21473	1	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	21473	2	,	,	,
18637	21473	3	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	21473	4	to	to	TO
18637	21473	5	attach	attach	VB
18637	21473	6	wages	wage	NNS
18637	21473	7	in	in	IN
18637	21473	8	execution	execution	NN
18637	21473	9	of	of	IN
18637	21473	10	a	a	DT
18637	21473	11	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	21473	12	for	for	IN
18637	21473	13	debt	debt	NN
18637	21473	14	may	may	MD
18637	21473	15	be	be	VB
18637	21473	16	instituted	institute	VBN
18637	21473	17	without	without	IN
18637	21473	18	any	any	DT
18637	21473	19	notice	notice	NN
18637	21473	20	or	or	CC
18637	21473	21	service	service	NN
18637	21473	22	on	on	IN
18637	21473	23	the	the	DT
18637	21473	24	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	21473	25	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	21473	26	.	.	.
18637	21474	1	The	the	DT
18637	21474	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	21474	3	,	,	,
18637	21474	4	having	have	VBG
18637	21474	5	had	have	VBD
18637	21474	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21474	7	day	day	NN
18637	21474	8	in	in	IN
18637	21474	9	court	court	NN
18637	21474	10	when	when	WRB
18637	21474	11	the	the	DT
18637	21474	12	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	21474	13	was	be	VBD
18637	21474	14	rendered	render	VBN
18637	21474	15	,	,	,
18637	21474	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	21474	17	not	not	RB
18637	21474	18	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	21474	19	to	to	TO
18637	21474	20	be	be	VB
18637	21474	21	apprized	apprize	VBN
18637	21474	22	of	of	IN
18637	21474	23	what	what	WP
18637	21474	24	action	action	NN
18637	21474	25	the	the	DT
18637	21474	26	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	21474	27	creditor	creditor	NN
18637	21474	28	may	may	MD
18637	21474	29	elect	elect	VB
18637	21474	30	to	to	TO
18637	21474	31	take	take	VB
18637	21474	32	to	to	TO
18637	21474	33	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	21474	34	collection.--Endicott	collection.--Endicott	NNP
18637	21474	35	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21474	36	_	_	NNP
18637	21474	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	21474	38	_	_	NNP
18637	21474	39	Encyclopedia	Encyclopedia	NNP
18637	21474	40	Press	Press	NNP
18637	21474	41	,	,	,
18637	21474	42	266	266	CD
18637	21474	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21474	44	285	285	CD
18637	21474	45	,	,	,
18637	21474	46	288	288	CD
18637	21474	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21474	48	1924	1924	CD
18637	21474	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21474	50	.	.	.
18637	21475	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21475	2	729	729	CD
18637	21475	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21475	4	Goodrich	Goodrich	NNP
18637	21475	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21475	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21475	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21475	8	Ferris	Ferris	NNP
18637	21475	9	,	,	,
18637	21475	10	214	214	CD
18637	21475	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21475	12	71	71	CD
18637	21475	13	,	,	,
18637	21475	14	80	80	CD
18637	21475	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21475	16	1909	1909	CD
18637	21475	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21475	18	.	.	.
18637	21476	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21476	2	730	730	CD
18637	21476	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21476	4	McCaughey	McCaughey	NNP
18637	21476	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21476	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21476	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21476	8	Lyall	Lyall	NNP
18637	21476	9	,	,	,
18637	21476	10	224	224	CD
18637	21476	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21476	12	558	558	CD
18637	21476	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21476	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	21476	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21476	16	.	.	.
18637	21477	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21477	2	731	731	CD
18637	21477	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21477	4	RoBards	RoBards	NNP
18637	21477	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21477	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21477	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21477	8	Lamb	Lamb	NNP
18637	21477	9	,	,	,
18637	21477	10	127	127	CD
18637	21477	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21477	12	58	58	CD
18637	21477	13	,	,	,
18637	21477	14	61	61	CD
18637	21477	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21477	16	1888	1888	CD
18637	21477	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21477	18	.	.	.
18637	21478	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
18637	21478	2	as	as	IN
18637	21478	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21478	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	21478	5	within	within	IN
18637	21478	6	the	the	DT
18637	21478	7	power	power	NN
18637	21478	8	of	of	IN
18637	21478	9	a	a	DT
18637	21478	10	State	State	NNP
18637	21478	11	to	to	TO
18637	21478	12	provide	provide	VB
18637	21478	13	that	that	IN
18637	21478	14	one	one	NN
18637	21478	15	who	who	WP
18637	21478	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	21478	17	undertaken	undertake	VBN
18637	21478	18	administration	administration	NN
18637	21478	19	of	of	IN
18637	21478	20	an	an	DT
18637	21478	21	estate	estate	NN
18637	21478	22	shall	shall	MD
18637	21478	23	remain	remain	VB
18637	21478	24	subject	subject	JJ
18637	21478	25	to	to	IN
18637	21478	26	the	the	DT
18637	21478	27	order	order	NN
18637	21478	28	of	of	IN
18637	21478	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21478	30	courts	court	NNS
18637	21478	31	until	until	IN
18637	21478	32	said	say	VBD
18637	21478	33	administration	administration	NN
18637	21478	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	21478	35	closed	closed	JJ
18637	21478	36	,	,	,
18637	21478	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21478	38	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	21478	39	that	that	IN
18637	21478	40	there	there	EX
18637	21478	41	can	can	MD
18637	21478	42	be	be	VB
18637	21478	43	no	no	DT
18637	21478	44	question	question	NN
18637	21478	45	as	as	IN
18637	21478	46	to	to	IN
18637	21478	47	the	the	DT
18637	21478	48	validity	validity	NN
18637	21478	49	of	of	IN
18637	21478	50	a	a	DT
18637	21478	51	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	21478	52	for	for	IN
18637	21478	53	unadministered	unadministered	JJ
18637	21478	54	assets	asset	NNS
18637	21478	55	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	21478	56	on	on	IN
18637	21478	57	service	service	NN
18637	21478	58	of	of	IN
18637	21478	59	publication	publication	NN
18637	21478	60	plus	plus	CC
18637	21478	61	service	service	NN
18637	21478	62	personally	personally	RB
18637	21478	63	upon	upon	IN
18637	21478	64	an	an	DT
18637	21478	65	executor	executor	NN
18637	21478	66	in	in	IN
18637	21478	67	the	the	DT
18637	21478	68	State	State	NNP
18637	21478	69	in	in	IN
18637	21478	70	which	which	WDT
18637	21478	71	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21478	72	had	have	VBD
18637	21478	73	taken	take	VBN
18637	21478	74	refuge	refuge	NN
18637	21478	75	and	and	CC
18637	21478	76	in	in	IN
18637	21478	77	which	which	WDT
18637	21478	78	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21478	79	had	have	VBD
18637	21478	80	been	be	VBN
18637	21478	81	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
18637	21478	82	incompetent.--Michigan	incompetent.--Michigan	NNP
18637	21478	83	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	21478	84	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21478	85	_	_	NNP
18637	21478	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	21478	87	_	_	NNP
18637	21478	88	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	21478	89	,	,	,
18637	21478	90	228	228	CD
18637	21478	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21478	92	346	346	CD
18637	21478	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21478	94	1913	1913	CD
18637	21478	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21478	96	.	.	.
18637	21479	1	Also	also	RB
18637	21479	2	,	,	,
18637	21479	3	when	when	WRB
18637	21479	4	a	a	DT
18637	21479	5	mother	mother	NN
18637	21479	6	petitions	petition	VBZ
18637	21479	7	for	for	IN
18637	21479	8	her	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21479	9	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	21479	10	as	as	IN
18637	21479	11	guardian	guardian	NN
18637	21479	12	,	,	,
18637	21479	13	and	and	CC
18637	21479	14	no	no	DT
18637	21479	15	one	one	NN
18637	21479	16	but	but	IN
18637	21479	17	the	the	DT
18637	21479	18	mother	mother	NN
18637	21479	19	and	and	CC
18637	21479	20	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21479	21	infant	infant	NN
18637	21479	22	son	son	NN
18637	21479	23	of	of	IN
18637	21479	24	tender	tender	NNP
18637	21479	25	years	year	NNS
18637	21479	26	,	,	,
18637	21479	27	are	be	VBP
18637	21479	28	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	21479	29	,	,	,
18637	21479	30	failure	failure	NN
18637	21479	31	to	to	TO
18637	21479	32	serve	serve	VB
18637	21479	33	notice	notice	NN
18637	21479	34	of	of	IN
18637	21479	35	the	the	DT
18637	21479	36	petition	petition	NN
18637	21479	37	upon	upon	IN
18637	21479	38	the	the	DT
18637	21479	39	infant	infant	NN
18637	21479	40	does	do	VBZ
18637	21479	41	not	not	RB
18637	21479	42	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	21479	43	the	the	DT
18637	21479	44	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	21479	45	resulting	result	VBG
18637	21479	46	in	in	IN
18637	21479	47	her	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21479	48	appointment.--Jones	appointment.--jones	CD
18637	21479	49	_	_	NNP
18637	21479	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	21479	51	_	_	NNP
18637	21479	52	Prairie	Prairie	NNP
18637	21479	53	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	21479	54	&	&	CC
18637	21479	55	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	21479	56	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21479	57	,	,	,
18637	21479	58	273	273	CD
18637	21479	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21479	60	195	195	CD
18637	21479	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21479	62	1927	1927	CD
18637	21479	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21479	64	.	.	.
18637	21480	1	Also	also	RB
18637	21480	2	a	a	DT
18637	21480	3	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21480	4	statute	statute	NN
18637	21480	5	which	which	WDT
18637	21480	6	establishes	establish	VBZ
18637	21480	7	a	a	DT
18637	21480	8	special	special	JJ
18637	21480	9	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	21480	10	for	for	IN
18637	21480	11	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	21480	12	of	of	IN
18637	21480	13	one	one	CD
18637	21480	14	to	to	TO
18637	21480	15	administer	administer	VB
18637	21480	16	the	the	DT
18637	21480	17	estate	estate	NN
18637	21480	18	of	of	IN
18637	21480	19	absentees	absentee	NNS
18637	21480	20	,	,	,
18637	21480	21	which	which	WDT
18637	21480	22	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	21480	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	21480	24	distinct	distinct	JJ
18637	21480	25	from	from	IN
18637	21480	26	that	that	DT
18637	21480	27	contained	contain	VBN
18637	21480	28	in	in	IN
18637	21480	29	the	the	DT
18637	21480	30	general	general	JJ
18637	21480	31	law	law	NN
18637	21480	32	governing	governing	NN
18637	21480	33	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	21480	34	of	of	IN
18637	21480	35	decedents	decedent	NNS
18637	21480	36	'	'	POS
18637	21480	37	estates	estate	NNS
18637	21480	38	and	and	CC
18637	21480	39	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	21480	40	special	special	JJ
18637	21480	41	safeguards	safeguard	NNS
18637	21480	42	to	to	TO
18637	21480	43	protect	protect	VB
18637	21480	44	the	the	DT
18637	21480	45	rights	right	NNS
18637	21480	46	of	of	IN
18637	21480	47	absentees	absentee	NNS
18637	21480	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	21480	49	not	not	RB
18637	21480	50	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	21480	51	to	to	IN
18637	21480	52	the	the	DT
18637	21480	53	due	due	JJ
18637	21480	54	process	process	NN
18637	21480	55	clause	clause	NN
18637	21480	56	because	because	IN
18637	21480	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21480	58	authorizes	authorize	VBZ
18637	21480	59	notice	notice	NN
18637	21480	60	by	by	IN
18637	21480	61	publication	publication	NN
18637	21480	62	after	after	IN
18637	21480	63	an	an	DT
18637	21480	64	absence	absence	NN
18637	21480	65	of	of	IN
18637	21480	66	seven	seven	CD
18637	21480	67	years.--Cunnius	years.--cunnius	NN
18637	21480	68	_	_	NNP
18637	21480	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	21480	70	_	_	NNP
18637	21480	71	Reading	Reading	NNP
18637	21480	72	School	School	NNP
18637	21480	73	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	21480	74	.	.	NNP
18637	21480	75	,	,	,
18637	21480	76	198	198	CD
18637	21480	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21480	78	458	458	CD
18637	21480	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21480	80	1905	1905	CD
18637	21480	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21480	82	.	.	.
18637	21481	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21481	2	732	732	CD
18637	21481	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21481	4	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	21481	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21481	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21481	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21481	8	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	21481	9	,	,	,
18637	21481	10	161	161	CD
18637	21481	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21481	12	256	256	CD
18637	21481	13	,	,	,
18637	21481	14	275	275	CD
18637	21481	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21481	16	1896	1896	CD
18637	21481	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21481	18	.	.	.
18637	21482	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21482	2	733	733	CD
18637	21482	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21482	4	Security	Security	NNP
18637	21482	5	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	21482	6	.	.	.
18637	21483	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21483	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21483	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21483	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21483	5	California	California	NNP
18637	21483	6	,	,	,
18637	21483	7	263	263	CD
18637	21483	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21483	9	282	282	CD
18637	21483	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21483	11	1923	1923	CD
18637	21483	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21483	13	.	.	.
18637	21484	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21484	2	734	734	CD
18637	21484	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21484	4	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	21484	5	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	21484	6	.	.	.
18637	21485	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21485	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21485	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21485	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21485	5	Luckett	Luckett	NNP
18637	21485	6	,	,	,
18637	21485	7	321	321	CD
18637	21485	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21485	9	233	233	CD
18637	21485	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21485	11	1944	1944	CD
18637	21485	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21485	13	.	.	.
18637	21486	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21486	2	735	735	CD
18637	21486	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21486	4	Mullane	Mullane	NNP
18637	21486	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21486	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21486	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21486	8	Central	Central	NNP
18637	21486	9	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
18637	21486	10	Tr	Tr	NNP
18637	21486	11	.	.	.
18637	21487	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21487	2	,	,	,
18637	21487	3	339	339	CD
18637	21487	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21487	5	306	306	CD
18637	21487	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21487	7	1950	1950	CD
18637	21487	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21487	9	.	.	.
18637	21488	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21488	2	736	736	CD
18637	21488	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21488	4	Voeller	Voeller	NNP
18637	21488	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21488	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21488	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21488	8	Neilston	Neilston	NNP
18637	21488	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21488	10	,	,	,
18637	21488	11	311	311	CD
18637	21488	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21488	13	531	531	CD
18637	21488	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21488	15	1941	1941	CD
18637	21488	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21488	17	.	.	.
18637	21489	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21489	2	737	737	CD
18637	21489	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21489	4	Grannis	Grannis	NNP
18637	21489	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21489	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21489	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21489	8	Ordean	Ordean	NNP
18637	21489	9	,	,	,
18637	21489	10	234	234	CD
18637	21489	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21489	12	385	385	CD
18637	21489	13	,	,	,
18637	21489	14	395	395	CD
18637	21489	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21489	16	396	396	CD
18637	21489	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21489	18	1914	1914	CD
18637	21489	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21489	20	.	.	.
18637	21490	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21490	2	738	738	CD
18637	21490	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21490	4	Miedreich	Miedreich	NNP
18637	21490	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21490	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21490	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21490	8	Lauenstein	Lauenstein	NNP
18637	21490	9	,	,	,
18637	21490	10	232	232	CD
18637	21490	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21490	12	236	236	CD
18637	21490	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21490	14	1914	1914	CD
18637	21490	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21490	16	.	.	.
18637	21491	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21491	2	739	739	CD
18637	21491	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21491	4	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	21491	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21491	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21491	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21491	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21491	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	21491	10	,	,	,
18637	21491	11	211	211	CD
18637	21491	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21491	13	78	78	CD
18637	21491	14	,	,	,
18637	21491	15	110	110	CD
18637	21491	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21491	17	1908	1908	CD
18637	21491	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21491	19	;	;	:
18637	21491	20	Jacob	Jacob	NNP
18637	21491	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21491	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	21491	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21491	24	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	21491	25	,	,	,
18637	21491	26	223	223	CD
18637	21491	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21491	28	261	261	CD
18637	21491	29	,	,	,
18637	21491	30	265	265	CD
18637	21491	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21491	32	1912	1912	CD
18637	21491	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21491	34	.	.	.
18637	21492	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21492	2	740	740	CD
18637	21492	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21492	4	Bi	Bi	NNP
18637	21492	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	21492	6	Metallic	Metallic	NNP
18637	21492	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21492	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21492	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21492	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21492	11	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	21492	12	,	,	,
18637	21492	13	239	239	CD
18637	21492	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21492	15	441	441	CD
18637	21492	16	,	,	,
18637	21492	17	445	445	CD
18637	21492	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21492	19	1915	1915	CD
18637	21492	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21492	21	;	;	:
18637	21492	22	Bragg	Bragg	NNP
18637	21492	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21492	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	21492	25	_	_	NNP
18637	21492	26	Weaver	Weaver	NNP
18637	21492	27	,	,	,
18637	21492	28	251	251	CD
18637	21492	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21492	30	57	57	CD
18637	21492	31	,	,	,
18637	21492	32	58	58	CD
18637	21492	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21492	34	1919	1919	CD
18637	21492	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21492	36	.	.	.
18637	21493	1	For	for	IN
18637	21493	2	the	the	DT
18637	21493	3	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	21493	4	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	21493	5	that	that	WDT
18637	21493	6	must	must	MD
18637	21493	7	be	be	VB
18637	21493	8	observed	observe	VBN
18637	21493	9	in	in	IN
18637	21493	10	the	the	DT
18637	21493	11	passage	passage	NN
18637	21493	12	of	of	IN
18637	21493	13	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	21493	14	levying	levy	VBG
18637	21493	15	special	special	JJ
18637	21493	16	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	21493	17	or	or	CC
18637	21493	18	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	21493	19	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	21493	20	districts	district	NNS
18637	21493	21	,	,	,
18637	21493	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21493	23	see	see	VBP
18637	21493	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21493	25	pp	pp	NNP
18637	21493	26	.	.	.
18637	21494	1	1058	1058	CD
18637	21494	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21494	3	1059	1059	CD
18637	21494	4	.	.	.
18637	21495	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21495	2	741	741	CD
18637	21495	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21495	4	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	21495	5	States	States	NNPS
18637	21495	6	Box	Box	NNP
18637	21495	7	&	&	CC
18637	21495	8	Basket	Basket	NNP
18637	21495	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21495	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21495	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	21495	12	_	_	NNP
18637	21495	13	White	White	NNP
18637	21495	14	,	,	,
18637	21495	15	296	296	CD
18637	21495	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21495	17	176	176	CD
18637	21495	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21495	19	1935	1935	CD
18637	21495	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21495	21	;	;	:
18637	21495	22	Western	Western	NNP
18637	21495	23	Union	Union	NNP
18637	21495	24	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	21495	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21495	26	_	_	NNP
18637	21495	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	21495	28	_	_	NNP
18637	21495	29	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	21495	30	Com'n	Com'n	NNP
18637	21495	31	.	.	.
18637	21495	32	,	,	,
18637	21495	33	24	24	CD
18637	21495	34	F.	F.	NNP
18637	21495	35	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	21495	36	.	.	.
18637	21496	1	370	370	CD
18637	21496	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21496	3	1938	1938	CD
18637	21496	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21496	5	;	;	:
18637	21496	6	Ralph	Ralph	NNP
18637	21496	7	F.	F.	NNP
18637	21496	8	Fuchs	Fuchs	NNP
18637	21496	9	,	,	,
18637	21496	10	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	21496	11	in	in	IN
18637	21496	12	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	21496	13	Rule	Rule	NNP
18637	21496	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	21496	15	Making	Making	NNP
18637	21496	16	,	,	,
18637	21496	17	52	52	CD
18637	21496	18	Harvard	Harvard	NNP
18637	21496	19	Law	Law	NNP
18637	21496	20	Review	Review	NNP
18637	21496	21	,	,	,
18637	21496	22	259	259	CD
18637	21496	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21496	24	1938	1938	CD
18637	21496	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21496	26	.	.	.
18637	21497	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	21497	2	action	action	NN
18637	21497	3	of	of	IN
18637	21497	4	an	an	DT
18637	21497	5	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	21497	6	agency	agency	NN
18637	21497	7	,	,	,
18637	21497	8	which	which	WDT
18637	21497	9	voluntarily	voluntarily	RB
18637	21497	10	affords	afford	VBZ
18637	21497	11	notice	notice	NN
18637	21497	12	and	and	CC
18637	21497	13	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	21497	14	in	in	IN
18637	21497	15	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	21497	16	in	in	IN
18637	21497	17	which	which	WDT
18637	21497	18	due	due	JJ
18637	21497	19	process	process	NN
18637	21497	20	would	would	MD
18637	21497	21	require	require	VB
18637	21497	22	the	the	DT
18637	21497	23	same	same	JJ
18637	21497	24	,	,	,
18637	21497	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	21497	26	voided	void	VBN
18637	21497	27	by	by	IN
18637	21497	28	the	the	DT
18637	21497	29	fact	fact	NN
18637	21497	30	that	that	IN
18637	21497	31	the	the	DT
18637	21497	32	statute	statute	NN
18637	21497	33	in	in	IN
18637	21497	34	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	21497	35	of	of	IN
18637	21497	36	which	which	WDT
18637	21497	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21497	38	operates	operate	VBZ
18637	21497	39	does	do	VBZ
18637	21497	40	not	not	RB
18637	21497	41	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	21497	42	provide	provide	VB
18637	21497	43	such	such	JJ
18637	21497	44	protection	protection	NN
18637	21497	45	,	,	,
18637	21497	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	21497	47	a	a	DT
18637	21497	48	question	question	NN
18637	21497	49	as	as	IN
18637	21497	50	to	to	IN
18637	21497	51	which	which	WDT
18637	21497	52	the	the	DT
18637	21497	53	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21497	54	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21497	55	has	have	VBZ
18637	21497	56	developed	develop	VBN
18637	21497	57	no	no	DT
18637	21497	58	definitive	definitive	JJ
18637	21497	59	answer	answer	NN
18637	21497	60	.	.	.
18637	21498	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21498	2	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	21498	3	to	to	TO
18637	21498	4	favor	favor	VB
18637	21498	5	the	the	DT
18637	21498	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	21498	7	enunciated	enunciate	VBN
18637	21498	8	by	by	IN
18637	21498	9	State	State	NNP
18637	21498	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	21498	11	to	to	IN
18637	21498	12	the	the	DT
18637	21498	13	effect	effect	NN
18637	21498	14	that	that	IN
18637	21498	15	such	such	JJ
18637	21498	16	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	21498	17	are	be	VBP
18637	21498	18	to	to	TO
18637	21498	19	be	be	VB
18637	21498	20	construed	construe	VBN
18637	21498	21	as	as	IN
18637	21498	22	impliedly	impliedly	RB
18637	21498	23	requiring	require	VBG
18637	21498	24	notice	notice	NN
18637	21498	25	and	and	CC
18637	21498	26	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	21498	27	,	,	,
18637	21498	28	although	although	IN
18637	21498	29	,	,	,
18637	21498	30	in	in	IN
18637	21498	31	a	a	DT
18637	21498	32	few	few	JJ
18637	21498	33	instances	instance	NNS
18637	21498	34	,	,	,
18637	21498	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21498	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	21498	37	uttered	uttered	JJ
18637	21498	38	comments	comment	NNS
18637	21498	39	rejecting	reject	VBG
18637	21498	40	this	this	DT
18637	21498	41	notice	notice	NN
18637	21498	42	-	-	HYPH
18637	21498	43	by	by	IN
18637	21498	44	-	-	HYPH
18637	21498	45	implication	implication	NN
18637	21498	46	theory.--_See	theory.--_See	''
18637	21498	47	_	_	NNP
18637	21498	48	Toombs	Toombs	NNP
18637	21498	49	_	_	NNP
18637	21498	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	21498	51	_	_	NNP
18637	21498	52	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	21498	53	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21498	54	,	,	,
18637	21498	55	281	281	CD
18637	21498	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21498	57	643	643	CD
18637	21498	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21498	59	1930	1930	CD
18637	21498	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21498	61	;	;	:
18637	21498	62	Paulsen	Paulsen	NNP
18637	21498	63	_	_	NNP
18637	21498	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	21498	65	_	_	NNP
18637	21498	66	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	21498	67	,	,	,
18637	21498	68	149	149	CD
18637	21498	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21498	70	30	30	CD
18637	21498	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21498	72	1893	1893	CD
18637	21498	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21498	74	;	;	:
18637	21498	75	Bratton	Bratton	NNP
18637	21498	76	_	_	NNP
18637	21498	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	21498	78	_	_	NNP
18637	21498	79	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	21498	80	,	,	,
18637	21498	81	260	260	CD
18637	21498	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21498	83	110	110	CD
18637	21498	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21498	85	1922	1922	CD
18637	21498	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21498	87	;	;	:
18637	21498	88	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	21498	89	,	,	,
18637	21498	90	N.O.	N.O.	NNP
18637	21499	1	&	&	CC
18637	21499	2	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	21500	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21500	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21500	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21500	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21500	5	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21500	6	,	,	,
18637	21500	7	115	115	CD
18637	21500	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21500	9	321	321	CD
18637	21500	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21500	11	1885	1885	CD
18637	21500	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21500	13	.	.	.
18637	21501	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21501	2	Contra	Contra	NNP
18637	21501	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21501	4	:	:	:
18637	21501	5	Central	Central	NNP
18637	21501	6	of	of	IN
18637	21501	7	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	21501	8	R.	R.	NNP
18637	21501	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21501	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21501	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	21501	12	_	_	NNP
18637	21501	13	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	21501	14	,	,	,
18637	21501	15	207	207	CD
18637	21501	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21501	17	127	127	CD
18637	21501	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21501	19	1907	1907	CD
18637	21501	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21501	21	;	;	:
18637	21501	22	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	21501	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21501	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	21501	25	_	_	NNP
18637	21501	26	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	21501	27	Fertilizer	Fertilizer	NNP
18637	21501	28	Works	Works	NNP
18637	21501	29	,	,	,
18637	21501	30	237	237	CD
18637	21501	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21501	32	413	413	CD
18637	21501	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21501	34	1915	1915	CD
18637	21501	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21501	36	;	;	:
18637	21501	37	Wuchter	Wuchter	NNP
18637	21501	38	_	_	NNP
18637	21501	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	21501	40	_	_	NNP
18637	21501	41	Pizzutti	Pizzutti	NNP
18637	21501	42	,	,	,
18637	21501	43	276	276	CD
18637	21501	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21501	45	13	13	CD
18637	21501	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21501	47	1928	1928	CD
18637	21501	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21501	49	.	.	.
18637	21502	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21502	2	742	742	CD
18637	21502	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21502	4	Bratton	Bratton	NNP
18637	21502	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21502	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21502	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21502	8	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	21502	9	,	,	,
18637	21502	10	260	260	CD
18637	21502	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21502	12	110	110	CD
18637	21502	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21502	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	21502	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21502	16	;	;	:
18637	21502	17	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	21502	18	ex	ex	NNP
18637	21502	19	rel	rel	NN
18637	21502	20	.	.	.
18637	21503	1	Hurwitz	Hurwitz	NNP
18637	21503	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21503	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21503	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21503	5	North	North	NNP
18637	21503	6	,	,	,
18637	21503	7	271	271	CD
18637	21503	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21503	9	40	40	CD
18637	21503	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21503	11	1926	1926	CD
18637	21503	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21503	13	.	.	.
18637	21504	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21504	2	743	743	CD
18637	21504	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21504	4	North	North	NNP
18637	21504	5	American	American	NNP
18637	21504	6	Cold	Cold	NNP
18637	21504	7	Storage	Storage	NNP
18637	21504	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21504	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21504	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	21504	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21504	12	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21504	13	,	,	,
18637	21504	14	211	211	CD
18637	21504	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21504	16	306	306	CD
18637	21504	17	,	,	,
18637	21504	18	315	315	CD
18637	21504	19	-	-	SYM
18637	21504	20	316	316	CD
18637	21504	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21504	22	1908	1908	CD
18637	21504	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21504	24	.	.	.
18637	21505	1	For	for	IN
18637	21505	2	an	an	DT
18637	21505	3	exposition	exposition	NN
18637	21505	4	of	of	IN
18637	21505	5	the	the	DT
18637	21505	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	21505	7	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	21505	8	for	for	IN
18637	21505	9	determining	determine	VBG
18637	21505	10	the	the	DT
18637	21505	11	tort	tort	NN
18637	21505	12	liability	liability	NN
18637	21505	13	of	of	IN
18637	21505	14	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	21505	15	officers	officer	NNS
18637	21505	16	,	,	,
18637	21505	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21505	18	see	see	VBP
18637	21505	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21505	20	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	21505	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21505	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	21505	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21505	24	Horton	Horton	NNP
18637	21505	25	,	,	,
18637	21505	26	152	152	CD
18637	21505	27	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21506	1	540	540	CD
18637	21506	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21506	3	1891	1891	CD
18637	21506	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21506	5	.	.	.
18637	21507	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21507	2	744	744	CD
18637	21507	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21507	4	Samuels	Samuels	NNPS
18637	21507	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21507	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21507	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21507	8	McCurdy	McCurdy	NNP
18637	21507	9	,	,	,
18637	21507	10	267	267	CD
18637	21507	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21507	12	188	188	CD
18637	21507	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21507	14	1925	1925	CD
18637	21507	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21507	16	.	.	.
18637	21508	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21508	2	745	745	CD
18637	21508	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21508	4	152	152	CD
18637	21508	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21508	6	133	133	CD
18637	21508	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21508	8	1894	1894	CD
18637	21508	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21508	10	.	.	.
18637	21509	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21509	2	746	746	CD
18637	21509	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21509	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21509	5	.	.	.
18637	21510	1	140	140	CD
18637	21510	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21510	3	141	141	CD
18637	21510	4	.	.	.
18637	21511	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21511	2	747	747	CD
18637	21511	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21511	4	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	21511	5	National	National	NNP
18637	21511	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	21511	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21511	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21511	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21511	10	Luckett	Luckett	NNP
18637	21511	11	,	,	,
18637	21511	12	321	321	CD
18637	21511	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21511	14	233	233	CD
18637	21511	15	,	,	,
18637	21511	16	246	246	CD
18637	21511	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	21511	18	247	247	CD
18637	21511	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21511	20	1944	1944	CD
18637	21511	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21511	22	.	.	.
18637	21512	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21512	2	748	748	CD
18637	21512	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21512	4	Coffin	Coffin	NNP
18637	21512	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	21512	6	&	&	CC
18637	21512	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21512	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21512	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21512	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21512	11	Bennett	Bennett	NNP
18637	21512	12	,	,	,
18637	21512	13	277	277	CD
18637	21512	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21512	15	29	29	CD
18637	21512	16	,	,	,
18637	21512	17	31	31	CD
18637	21512	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21512	19	1928	1928	CD
18637	21512	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21512	21	.	.	.
18637	21513	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21513	2	749	749	CD
18637	21513	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21513	4	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	21513	5	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	21513	6	.	.	.
18637	21514	1	Cable	Cable	NNP
18637	21514	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21514	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21514	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	21514	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21514	6	Newport	Newport	NNP
18637	21514	7	,	,	,
18637	21514	8	247	247	CD
18637	21514	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21514	10	464	464	CD
18637	21514	11	,	,	,
18637	21514	12	476	476	CD
18637	21514	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21514	14	1918	1918	CD
18637	21514	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21514	16	;	;	:
18637	21514	17	Baker	Baker	NNP
18637	21514	18	_	_	NNP
18637	21514	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	21514	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21514	21	Baker	Baker	NNP
18637	21514	22	,	,	,
18637	21514	23	E.	E.	NNP
18637	21514	24	&	&	CC
18637	21514	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21514	26	,	,	,
18637	21514	27	242	242	CD
18637	21514	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21514	29	394	394	CD
18637	21514	30	,	,	,
18637	21514	31	403	403	CD
18637	21514	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21514	33	1917	1917	CD
18637	21514	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21514	35	;	;	:
18637	21514	36	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	21514	37	&	&	CC
18637	21514	38	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	21515	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21515	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21515	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21515	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21515	5	Schmidt	Schmidt	NNP
18637	21515	6	,	,	,
18637	21515	7	177	177	CD
18637	21515	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21515	9	230	230	CD
18637	21515	10	,	,	,
18637	21515	11	236	236	CD
18637	21515	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21515	13	1900	1900	CD
18637	21515	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21515	15	.	.	.
18637	21516	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21516	2	750	750	CD
18637	21516	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21516	4	American	American	NNP
18637	21516	5	Surety	Surety	NNP
18637	21516	6	Co	Co	NNP
18637	21516	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21516	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21516	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21516	10	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	21516	11	,	,	,
18637	21516	12	287	287	CD
18637	21516	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21516	14	156	156	CD
18637	21516	15	,	,	,
18637	21516	16	168	168	CD
18637	21516	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21516	18	1932	1932	CD
18637	21516	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21516	20	.	.	.
18637	21517	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21517	2	751	751	CD
18637	21517	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21517	4	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
18637	21517	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21517	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21517	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21517	8	Shaw	Shaw	NNP
18637	21517	9	,	,	,
18637	21517	10	244	244	CD
18637	21517	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21517	12	317	317	CD
18637	21517	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21517	14	1917	1917	CD
18637	21517	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21517	16	.	.	.
18637	21518	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21518	2	752	752	CD
18637	21518	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21518	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21518	5	See	See	NNP
18637	21518	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21518	7	footnote	footnote	NN
18637	21518	8	1	1	CD
18637	21518	9	,	,	,
18637	21518	10	p.	p.	NN
18637	21518	11	1085	1085	CD
18637	21518	12	.	.	.
18637	21519	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21519	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	21519	3	's	's	POS
18637	21519	4	Note	note	NN
18637	21519	5	:	:	:
18637	21519	6	Reference	reference	NN
18637	21519	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	21519	8	to	to	IN
18637	21519	9	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	21519	10	741	741	CD
18637	21519	11	,	,	,
18637	21519	12	above	above	RB
18637	21519	13	.	.	.
18637	21519	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21520	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21520	2	753	753	CD
18637	21520	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21520	4	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	21520	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21520	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21520	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21520	8	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	21520	9	Fertilizer	Fertilizer	NNP
18637	21520	10	Works	Works	NNP
18637	21520	11	,	,	,
18637	21520	12	237	237	CD
18637	21520	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21520	14	413	413	CD
18637	21520	15	,	,	,
18637	21520	16	424	424	CD
18637	21520	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21520	18	1915	1915	CD
18637	21520	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21520	20	;	;	:
18637	21520	21	Wuchter	Wuchter	NNP
18637	21520	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21520	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	21520	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21520	25	Pizzutti	Pizzutti	NNP
18637	21520	26	,	,	,
18637	21520	27	276	276	CD
18637	21520	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21520	29	13	13	CD
18637	21520	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21520	31	1928	1928	CD
18637	21520	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21520	33	.	.	.
18637	21521	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21521	2	754	754	CD
18637	21521	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21521	4	Roller	Roller	NNP
18637	21521	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21521	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21521	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21521	8	Holly	Holly	NNP
18637	21521	9	,	,	,
18637	21521	10	176	176	CD
18637	21521	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21521	12	398	398	CD
18637	21521	13	,	,	,
18637	21521	14	407	407	CD
18637	21521	15	,	,	,
18637	21521	16	409	409	CD
18637	21521	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21521	18	1900	1900	CD
18637	21521	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21521	20	.	.	.
18637	21522	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21522	2	755	755	CD
18637	21522	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21522	4	Goodrich	Goodrich	NNP
18637	21522	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21522	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21522	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21522	8	Ferris	Ferris	NNP
18637	21522	9	,	,	,
18637	21522	10	214	214	CD
18637	21522	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21522	12	71	71	CD
18637	21522	13	,	,	,
18637	21522	14	80	80	CD
18637	21522	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21522	16	1909	1909	CD
18637	21522	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21522	18	.	.	.
18637	21523	1	One	one	CD
18637	21523	2	may	may	MD
18637	21523	3	,	,	,
18637	21523	4	of	of	IN
18637	21523	5	course	course	NN
18637	21523	6	,	,	,
18637	21523	7	waive	waive	VB
18637	21523	8	a	a	DT
18637	21523	9	right	right	NN
18637	21523	10	to	to	TO
18637	21523	11	notice	notice	VB
18637	21523	12	and	and	CC
18637	21523	13	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	21523	14	,	,	,
18637	21523	15	as	as	IN
18637	21523	16	in	in	IN
18637	21523	17	the	the	DT
18637	21523	18	case	case	NN
18637	21523	19	of	of	IN
18637	21523	20	a	a	DT
18637	21523	21	debtor	debtor	NN
18637	21523	22	or	or	CC
18637	21523	23	surety	surety	NN
18637	21523	24	who	who	WP
18637	21523	25	consents	consent	VBZ
18637	21523	26	to	to	IN
18637	21523	27	the	the	DT
18637	21523	28	entry	entry	NN
18637	21523	29	of	of	IN
18637	21523	30	a	a	DT
18637	21523	31	confessed	confessed	JJ
18637	21523	32	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	21523	33	on	on	IN
18637	21523	34	the	the	DT
18637	21523	35	happening	happening	NN
18637	21523	36	of	of	IN
18637	21523	37	certain	certain	JJ
18637	21523	38	conditions.--Johnson	conditions.--johnson	CD
18637	21523	39	_	_	NNP
18637	21523	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	21523	41	_	_	NNP
18637	21523	42	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21523	43	&	&	CC
18637	21523	44	P.	P.	NNP
18637	21523	45	Elevator	Elevator	NNP
18637	21523	46	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21523	47	,	,	,
18637	21523	48	119	119	CD
18637	21523	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21523	50	388	388	CD
18637	21523	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21523	52	1886	1886	CD
18637	21523	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21523	54	;	;	:
18637	21523	55	American	American	NNP
18637	21523	56	Surety	Surety	NNP
18637	21523	57	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21523	58	_	_	NNP
18637	21523	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	21523	60	_	_	NNP
18637	21523	61	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	21523	62	,	,	,
18637	21523	63	287	287	CD
18637	21523	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21523	65	156	156	CD
18637	21523	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21523	67	1932	1932	CD
18637	21523	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21523	69	.	.	.
18637	21524	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21524	2	756	756	CD
18637	21524	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21524	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21524	5	See	See	NNP
18637	21524	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21524	7	pp	pp	NNP
18637	21524	8	.	.	.
18637	21525	1	1084	1084	CD
18637	21525	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21525	3	1088	1088	CD
18637	21525	4	.	.	.
18637	21526	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21526	2	757	757	CD
18637	21526	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21526	4	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	21526	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21526	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21526	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21526	8	Conway	Conway	NNP
18637	21526	9	,	,	,
18637	21526	10	241	241	CD
18637	21526	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21526	12	624	624	CD
18637	21526	13	,	,	,
18637	21526	14	631	631	CD
18637	21526	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21526	16	1916	1916	CD
18637	21526	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21526	18	;	;	:
18637	21526	19	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	21526	20	&	&	CC
18637	21526	21	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	21527	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21527	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21527	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21527	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21527	5	Schmidt	Schmidt	NNP
18637	21527	6	,	,	,
18637	21527	7	177	177	CD
18637	21527	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21527	9	230	230	CD
18637	21527	10	,	,	,
18637	21527	11	236	236	CD
18637	21527	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21527	13	1900	1900	CD
18637	21527	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21527	15	.	.	.
18637	21528	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21528	2	758	758	CD
18637	21528	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21528	4	Snyder	Snyder	NNP
18637	21528	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21528	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21528	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21528	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21528	9	,	,	,
18637	21528	10	291	291	CD
18637	21528	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21528	12	97	97	CD
18637	21528	13	,	,	,
18637	21528	14	105	105	CD
18637	21528	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21528	16	1934	1934	CD
18637	21528	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21528	18	;	;	:
18637	21528	19	West	West	NNP
18637	21528	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21528	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21528	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21528	23	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	21528	24	,	,	,
18637	21528	25	194	194	CD
18637	21528	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21528	27	258	258	CD
18637	21528	28	,	,	,
18637	21528	29	263	263	CD
18637	21528	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21528	31	1904	1904	CD
18637	21528	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21528	33	;	;	:
18637	21528	34	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21528	35	,	,	,
18637	21528	36	B.	B.	NNP
18637	21529	1	&	&	CC
18637	21529	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	21530	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21530	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21530	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21530	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21530	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21530	6	,	,	,
18637	21530	7	166	166	CD
18637	21530	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21530	9	226	226	CD
18637	21530	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21530	11	1897	1897	CD
18637	21530	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21530	13	;	;	:
18637	21530	14	Jordan	Jordan	NNP
18637	21530	15	_	_	NNP
18637	21530	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	21530	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21530	18	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21530	19	,	,	,
18637	21530	20	225	225	CD
18637	21530	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21530	22	167	167	CD
18637	21530	23	,	,	,
18637	21530	24	176	176	CD
18637	21530	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21530	26	1912	1912	CD
18637	21530	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21530	28	.	.	.
18637	21531	1	The	the	DT
18637	21531	2	power	power	NN
18637	21531	3	of	of	IN
18637	21531	4	a	a	DT
18637	21531	5	State	State	NNP
18637	21531	6	to	to	TO
18637	21531	7	determine	determine	VB
18637	21531	8	the	the	DT
18637	21531	9	limits	limit	NNS
18637	21531	10	of	of	IN
18637	21531	11	the	the	DT
18637	21531	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	21531	13	of	of	IN
18637	21531	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21531	15	courts	court	NNS
18637	21531	16	and	and	CC
18637	21531	17	the	the	DT
18637	21531	18	character	character	NN
18637	21531	19	of	of	IN
18637	21531	20	the	the	DT
18637	21531	21	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	21531	22	which	which	WDT
18637	21531	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	21531	24	be	be	VB
18637	21531	25	heard	hear	VBN
18637	21531	26	in	in	IN
18637	21531	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21531	28	and	and	CC
18637	21531	29	to	to	TO
18637	21531	30	deny	deny	VB
18637	21531	31	access	access	NN
18637	21531	32	to	to	IN
18637	21531	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21531	34	courts	court	NNS
18637	21531	35	,	,	,
18637	21531	36	in	in	IN
18637	21531	37	the	the	DT
18637	21531	38	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	21531	39	of	of	IN
18637	21531	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21531	41	right	right	NN
18637	21531	42	to	to	TO
18637	21531	43	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	21531	44	practice	practice	NN
18637	21531	45	and	and	CC
18637	21531	46	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	21531	47	;	;	:
18637	21531	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	21531	49	also	also	RB
18637	21531	50	subject	subject	JJ
18637	21531	51	to	to	IN
18637	21531	52	the	the	DT
18637	21531	53	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	21531	54	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	21531	55	by	by	IN
18637	21531	56	the	the	DT
18637	21531	57	contract	contract	NN
18637	21531	58	,	,	,
18637	21531	59	full	full	JJ
18637	21531	60	faith	faith	NN
18637	21531	61	and	and	CC
18637	21531	62	credit	credit	NN
18637	21531	63	,	,	,
18637	21531	64	and	and	CC
18637	21531	65	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	21531	66	and	and	CC
18637	21531	67	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	21531	68	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	21531	69	of	of	IN
18637	21531	70	the	the	DT
18637	21531	71	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	21531	72	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	21531	73	.	.	.
18637	21532	1	Angel	Angel	NNP
18637	21532	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21532	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21532	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21532	5	Bullington	Bullington	NNP
18637	21532	6	,	,	,
18637	21532	7	330	330	CD
18637	21532	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21532	9	183	183	CD
18637	21532	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21532	11	1947	1947	CD
18637	21532	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21532	13	.	.	.
18637	21533	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21533	2	759	759	CD
18637	21533	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21533	4	Hardware	Hardware	NNP
18637	21533	5	Dealers	Dealers	NNPS
18637	21533	6	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	21533	7	.	.	.
18637	21534	1	F.	F.	NNP
18637	21534	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	21534	3	.	.	.
18637	21535	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21535	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21535	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21535	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21535	5	Glidden	Glidden	NNP
18637	21535	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21535	7	,	,	,
18637	21535	8	284	284	CD
18637	21535	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21535	10	151	151	CD
18637	21535	11	,	,	,
18637	21535	12	158	158	CD
18637	21535	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21535	14	1931	1931	CD
18637	21535	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21535	16	;	;	:
18637	21535	17	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	21535	18	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	21536	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21536	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21536	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21536	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21536	5	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	21536	6	,	,	,
18637	21536	7	160	160	CD
18637	21536	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21536	9	389	389	CD
18637	21536	10	,	,	,
18637	21536	11	393	393	CD
18637	21536	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21536	13	1896	1896	CD
18637	21536	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21536	15	;	;	:
18637	21536	16	Honeyman	Honeyman	NNP
18637	21536	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21536	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	21536	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21536	20	Hanan	Hanan	NNP
18637	21536	21	,	,	,
18637	21536	22	302	302	CD
18637	21536	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21536	24	375	375	CD
18637	21536	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21536	26	1937	1937	CD
18637	21536	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21536	28	.	.	.
18637	21537	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21537	2	760	760	CD
18637	21537	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21537	4	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	21537	5	Street	Street	NNP
18637	21537	6	R.	R.	NNP
18637	21537	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21537	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21537	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21537	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21537	11	Snell	Snell	NNP
18637	21537	12	,	,	,
18637	21537	13	193	193	CD
18637	21537	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21537	15	30	30	CD
18637	21537	16	,	,	,
18637	21537	17	36	36	CD
18637	21537	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21537	19	1904	1904	CD
18637	21537	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21537	21	.	.	.
18637	21538	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21538	2	761	761	CD
18637	21538	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21538	4	Ownbey	Ownbey	NNP
18637	21538	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21538	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21538	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21538	8	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	21538	9	,	,	,
18637	21538	10	256	256	CD
18637	21538	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21538	12	94	94	CD
18637	21538	13	,	,	,
18637	21538	14	112	112	CD
18637	21538	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21538	16	1921	1921	CD
18637	21538	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21538	18	.	.	.
18637	21539	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	21539	2	,	,	,
18637	21539	3	the	the	DT
18637	21539	4	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21539	5	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21539	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	21539	7	not	not	RB
18637	21539	8	constrain	constrain	VB
18637	21539	9	the	the	DT
18637	21539	10	States	States	NNPS
18637	21539	11	to	to	TO
18637	21539	12	accept	accept	VB
18637	21539	13	modern	modern	JJ
18637	21539	14	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	21539	15	of	of	IN
18637	21539	16	equity	equity	NN
18637	21539	17	,	,	,
18637	21539	18	or	or	CC
18637	21539	19	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	21539	20	a	a	DT
18637	21539	21	combined	combined	JJ
18637	21539	22	system	system	NN
18637	21539	23	of	of	IN
18637	21539	24	law	law	NN
18637	21539	25	and	and	CC
18637	21539	26	equity	equity	NN
18637	21539	27	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	21539	28	,	,	,
18637	21539	29	or	or	CC
18637	21539	30	dispense	dispense	NN
18637	21539	31	with	with	IN
18637	21539	32	all	all	DT
18637	21539	33	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	21539	34	for	for	IN
18637	21539	35	form	form	NN
18637	21539	36	and	and	CC
18637	21539	37	method	method	NN
18637	21539	38	in	in	IN
18637	21539	39	pleading	plead	VBG
18637	21539	40	,	,	,
18637	21539	41	or	or	CC
18637	21539	42	give	give	VB
18637	21539	43	untrammeled	untrammeled	JJ
18637	21539	44	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	21539	45	to	to	TO
18637	21539	46	make	make	VB
18637	21539	47	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	21539	48	.	.	.
18637	21540	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21540	2	762	762	CD
18637	21540	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21540	4	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
18637	21540	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21540	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21540	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21540	8	Beneficial	Beneficial	NNP
18637	21540	9	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	21540	10	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	21540	11	,	,	,
18637	21540	12	337	337	CD
18637	21540	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21540	14	541	541	CD
18637	21540	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21540	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	21540	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21540	18	.	.	.
18637	21541	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21541	2	763	763	CD
18637	21541	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21541	4	Young	Young	NNP
18637	21541	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21541	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21541	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21541	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21541	9	McNeal	McNeal	NNP
18637	21541	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	21541	11	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	21541	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21541	13	,	,	,
18637	21541	14	283	283	CD
18637	21541	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21541	16	398	398	CD
18637	21541	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21541	18	1931	1931	CD
18637	21541	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21541	20	;	;	:
18637	21541	21	Adam	Adam	NNP
18637	21541	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21541	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	21541	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21541	25	Saenger	Saenger	NNP
18637	21541	26	,	,	,
18637	21541	27	303	303	CD
18637	21541	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21541	29	59	59	CD
18637	21541	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21541	31	1938	1938	CD
18637	21541	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21541	33	.	.	.
18637	21542	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21542	2	764	764	CD
18637	21542	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21542	4	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	21542	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21542	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21542	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21542	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	21542	9	Guano	Guano	NNP
18637	21542	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21542	11	,	,	,
18637	21542	12	264	264	CD
18637	21542	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21542	14	171	171	CD
18637	21542	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21542	16	1924	1924	CD
18637	21542	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21542	18	.	.	.
18637	21543	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21543	2	765	765	CD
18637	21543	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21543	4	York	York	NNP
18637	21543	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21543	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21543	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21543	8	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	21543	9	,	,	,
18637	21543	10	137	137	CD
18637	21543	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21543	12	15	15	CD
18637	21543	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21543	14	1890	1890	CD
18637	21543	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21543	16	;	;	:
18637	21543	17	Kauffman	Kauffman	NNP
18637	21543	18	_	_	NNP
18637	21543	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	21543	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21543	21	Wooters	Wooters	NNP
18637	21543	22	,	,	,
18637	21543	23	138	138	CD
18637	21543	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21543	25	285	285	CD
18637	21543	26	,	,	,
18637	21543	27	287	287	CD
18637	21543	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21543	29	1891	1891	CD
18637	21543	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21543	31	.	.	.
18637	21544	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21544	2	766	766	CD
18637	21544	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21544	4	Grant	Grant	NNP
18637	21544	5	Timber	Timber	NNP
18637	21544	6	&	&	CC
18637	21544	7	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	21544	8	.	.	.
18637	21545	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21545	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21545	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21545	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21545	5	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	21545	6	,	,	,
18637	21545	7	236	236	CD
18637	21545	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21545	9	133	133	CD
18637	21545	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21545	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	21545	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21545	13	.	.	.
18637	21546	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21546	2	767	767	CD
18637	21546	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21546	4	Ownbey	Ownbey	NNP
18637	21546	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21546	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21546	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21546	8	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	21546	9	,	,	,
18637	21546	10	256	256	CD
18637	21546	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21546	12	94	94	CD
18637	21546	13	,	,	,
18637	21546	14	111	111	CD
18637	21546	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21546	16	1921).--Consistently	1921).--consistently	RB
18637	21546	17	,	,	,
18637	21546	18	with	with	IN
18637	21546	19	due	due	JJ
18637	21546	20	process	process	NN
18637	21546	21	,	,	,
18637	21546	22	a	a	DT
18637	21546	23	State	state	NN
18637	21546	24	may	may	MD
18637	21546	25	provide	provide	VB
18637	21546	26	that	that	IN
18637	21546	27	the	the	DT
18637	21546	28	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	21546	29	of	of	IN
18637	21546	30	contributory	contributory	JJ
18637	21546	31	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	21546	32	,	,	,
18637	21546	33	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	21546	34	of	of	IN
18637	21546	35	risk	risk	NN
18637	21546	36	,	,	,
18637	21546	37	and	and	CC
18637	21546	38	fellow	fellow	JJ
18637	21546	39	servant	servant	NN
18637	21546	40	shall	shall	MD
18637	21546	41	not	not	RB
18637	21546	42	bar	bar	VB
18637	21546	43	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	21546	44	in	in	IN
18637	21546	45	actions	action	NNS
18637	21546	46	brought	bring	VBN
18637	21546	47	against	against	IN
18637	21546	48	an	an	DT
18637	21546	49	employer	employer	NN
18637	21546	50	for	for	IN
18637	21546	51	death	death	NN
18637	21546	52	or	or	CC
18637	21546	53	injury	injury	NN
18637	21546	54	resulting	result	VBG
18637	21546	55	from	from	IN
18637	21546	56	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	21546	57	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	21546	58	improperly	improperly	RB
18637	21546	59	safeguarded	safeguard	VBN
18637	21546	60	.	.	.
18637	21547	1	A	a	DT
18637	21547	2	person	person	NN
18637	21547	3	having	have	VBG
18637	21547	4	no	no	DT
18637	21547	5	vested	vest	VBN
18637	21547	6	right	right	RB
18637	21547	7	to	to	IN
18637	21547	8	the	the	DT
18637	21547	9	defense	defense	NN
18637	21547	10	of	of	IN
18637	21547	11	contributory	contributory	JJ
18637	21547	12	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	21547	13	,	,	,
18637	21547	14	a	a	DT
18637	21547	15	State	State	NNP
18637	21547	16	may	may	MD
18637	21547	17	take	take	VB
18637	21547	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21547	19	away	away	RB
18637	21547	20	altogether	altogether	RB
18637	21547	21	,	,	,
18637	21547	22	or	or	CC
18637	21547	23	may	may	MD
18637	21547	24	provide	provide	VB
18637	21547	25	that	that	DT
18637	21547	26	said	say	VBD
18637	21547	27	defense	defense	NN
18637	21547	28	,	,	,
18637	21547	29	as	as	RB
18637	21547	30	well	well	RB
18637	21547	31	as	as	IN
18637	21547	32	that	that	DT
18637	21547	33	of	of	IN
18637	21547	34	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	21547	35	of	of	IN
18637	21547	36	risk	risk	NN
18637	21547	37	,	,	,
18637	21547	38	are	be	VBP
18637	21547	39	questions	question	NNS
18637	21547	40	of	of	IN
18637	21547	41	fact	fact	NN
18637	21547	42	to	to	TO
18637	21547	43	be	be	VB
18637	21547	44	left	leave	VBN
18637	21547	45	to	to	IN
18637	21547	46	the	the	DT
18637	21547	47	jury.--Bowersock	jury.--bowersock	NN
18637	21547	48	_	_	NNP
18637	21547	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	21547	50	_	_	NNP
18637	21547	51	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	21547	52	,	,	,
18637	21547	53	243	243	CD
18637	21547	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21547	55	29	29	CD
18637	21547	56	,	,	,
18637	21547	57	34	34	CD
18637	21547	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21547	59	1917	1917	CD
18637	21547	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21547	61	;	;	:
18637	21547	62	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21547	63	,	,	,
18637	21547	64	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	21547	65	&	&	CC
18637	21547	66	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	21548	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21548	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21548	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21548	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21548	5	Cole	Cole	NNP
18637	21548	6	,	,	,
18637	21548	7	251	251	CD
18637	21548	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21548	9	54	54	CD
18637	21548	10	,	,	,
18637	21548	11	55	55	CD
18637	21548	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21548	13	1919	1919	CD
18637	21548	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21548	15	;	;	:
18637	21548	16	Herron	Herron	NNP
18637	21548	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21548	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	21548	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21548	20	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	21548	21	P.	P.	NNP
18637	21548	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21548	23	,	,	,
18637	21548	24	283	283	CD
18637	21548	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21548	26	91	91	CD
18637	21548	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21548	28	1931	1931	CD
18637	21548	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21548	30	.	.	.
18637	21549	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21549	2	768	768	CD
18637	21549	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21549	4	Sawyer	Sawyer	NNP
18637	21549	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21549	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21549	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21549	8	Piper	Piper	NNP
18637	21549	9	,	,	,
18637	21549	10	189	189	CD
18637	21549	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21549	12	154	154	CD
18637	21549	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21549	14	1903	1903	CD
18637	21549	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21549	16	.	.	.
18637	21550	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21550	2	769	769	CD
18637	21550	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21550	4	Ballard	Ballard	NNP
18637	21550	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21550	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21550	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21550	8	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	21550	9	,	,	,
18637	21550	10	204	204	CD
18637	21550	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21550	12	241	241	CD
18637	21550	13	,	,	,
18637	21550	14	259	259	CD
18637	21550	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21550	16	1907	1907	CD
18637	21550	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21550	18	.	.	.
18637	21551	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21551	2	770	770	CD
18637	21551	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21551	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	21551	5	K.	K.	NNP
18637	21551	6	&	&	CC
18637	21551	7	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	21552	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21552	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21552	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21552	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21552	5	Cade	Cade	NNP
18637	21552	6	,	,	,
18637	21552	7	233	233	CD
18637	21552	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21552	9	642	642	CD
18637	21552	10	,	,	,
18637	21552	11	650	650	CD
18637	21552	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21552	13	1914	1914	CD
18637	21552	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21552	15	.	.	.
18637	21553	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21553	2	771	771	CD
18637	21553	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21553	4	Lowe	Lowe	NNP
18637	21553	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21553	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21553	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21553	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	21553	9	,	,	,
18637	21553	10	163	163	CD
18637	21553	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21553	12	81	81	CD
18637	21553	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21553	14	1896	1896	CD
18637	21553	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21553	16	.	.	.
18637	21554	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21554	2	772	772	CD
18637	21554	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21554	4	Yazoo	Yazoo	NNP
18637	21554	5	&	&	CC
18637	21554	6	M.V.R.	M.V.R.	NNP
18637	21555	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21555	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21555	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21555	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21555	5	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	21555	6	Vinegar	Vinegar	NNP
18637	21555	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21555	8	,	,	,
18637	21555	9	226	226	CD
18637	21555	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21555	11	217	217	CD
18637	21555	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21555	13	1912	1912	CD
18637	21555	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21555	15	;	;	:
18637	21555	16	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21555	17	&	&	CC
18637	21555	18	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	21556	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21556	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21556	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21556	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21556	5	Nye	Nye	NNP
18637	21556	6	Schneider	Schneider	NNP
18637	21556	7	Fowler	Fowler	NNP
18637	21556	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21556	9	,	,	,
18637	21556	10	260	260	CD
18637	21556	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21556	12	35	35	CD
18637	21556	13	,	,	,
18637	21556	14	43	43	CD
18637	21556	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21556	16	44	44	CD
18637	21556	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21556	18	1922	1922	CD
18637	21556	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21556	20	;	;	:
18637	21556	21	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	21556	22	L.	L.	NNP
18637	21556	23	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	21556	24	.	.	.
18637	21557	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21557	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21557	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21557	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21557	5	Blincoe	Blincoe	NNP
18637	21557	6	,	,	,
18637	21557	7	255	255	CD
18637	21557	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21557	9	129	129	CD
18637	21557	10	,	,	,
18637	21557	11	139	139	CD
18637	21557	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21557	13	1921	1921	CD
18637	21557	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21557	15	;	;	:
18637	21557	16	Life	Life	NNP
18637	21557	17	&	&	CC
18637	21557	18	C.	C.	NNP
18637	21557	19	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	21557	20	.	.	.
18637	21558	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21558	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21558	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21558	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21558	5	McCray	McCray	NNP
18637	21558	6	,	,	,
18637	21558	7	291	291	CD
18637	21558	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21558	9	566	566	CD
18637	21558	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21558	11	1934	1934	CD
18637	21558	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21558	13	.	.	.
18637	21559	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21559	2	773	773	CD
18637	21559	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21559	4	Pizitz	Pizitz	NNP
18637	21559	5	Dry	Dry	NNP
18637	21559	6	Goods	Goods	NNPS
18637	21559	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21559	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21559	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21559	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21559	11	Yeldell	Yeldell	NNP
18637	21559	12	,	,	,
18637	21559	13	274	274	CD
18637	21559	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21559	15	112	112	CD
18637	21559	16	,	,	,
18637	21559	17	114	114	CD
18637	21559	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21559	19	1927	1927	CD
18637	21559	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21559	21	.	.	.
18637	21560	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21560	2	774	774	CD
18637	21560	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21560	4	Coffey	Coffey	NNP
18637	21560	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21560	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21560	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21560	8	Harlan	Harlan	NNP
18637	21560	9	County	County	NNP
18637	21560	10	,	,	,
18637	21560	11	204	204	CD
18637	21560	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21560	13	659	659	CD
18637	21560	14	,	,	,
18637	21560	15	663	663	CD
18637	21560	16	,	,	,
18637	21560	17	665	665	CD
18637	21560	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21560	19	1907	1907	CD
18637	21560	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21560	21	.	.	.
18637	21561	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21561	2	775	775	CD
18637	21561	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21561	4	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	21561	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21561	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21561	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21561	8	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	21561	9	,	,	,
18637	21561	10	137	137	CD
18637	21561	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21561	12	245	245	CD
18637	21561	13	,	,	,
18637	21561	14	258	258	CD
18637	21561	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21561	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	21561	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21561	18	;	;	:
18637	21561	19	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21561	20	Union	Union	NNP
18637	21561	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21561	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21561	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	21561	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21561	25	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21561	26	,	,	,
18637	21561	27	219	219	CD
18637	21561	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21561	29	140	140	CD
18637	21561	30	,	,	,
18637	21561	31	156	156	CD
18637	21561	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21561	33	1911	1911	CD
18637	21561	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21561	35	.	.	.
18637	21562	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21562	2	776	776	CD
18637	21562	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21562	4	Blinn	Blinn	NNP
18637	21562	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21562	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21562	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21562	8	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	21562	9	,	,	,
18637	21562	10	222	222	CD
18637	21562	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21562	12	1	1	CD
18637	21562	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21562	14	1911	1911	CD
18637	21562	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21562	16	.	.	.
18637	21563	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21563	2	777	777	CD
18637	21563	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21563	4	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	21563	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21563	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21563	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21563	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21563	9	York	York	NNP
18637	21563	10	,	,	,
18637	21563	11	168	168	CD
18637	21563	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21563	13	90	90	CD
18637	21563	14	,	,	,
18637	21563	15	94	94	CD
18637	21563	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21563	17	1897	1897	CD
18637	21563	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21563	19	.	.	.
18637	21564	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21564	2	778	778	CD
18637	21564	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21564	4	Soper	Soper	NNP
18637	21564	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21564	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21564	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21564	8	Lawrence	Lawrence	NNP
18637	21564	9	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	21564	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21564	11	,	,	,
18637	21564	12	201	201	CD
18637	21564	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21564	14	359	359	CD
18637	21564	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21564	16	1906	1906	CD
18637	21564	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21564	18	.	.	.
18637	21565	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	21565	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	21565	3	a	a	DT
18637	21565	4	former	former	JJ
18637	21565	5	owner	owner	NN
18637	21565	6	who	who	WP
18637	21565	7	had	have	VBD
18637	21565	8	not	not	RB
18637	21565	9	been	be	VBN
18637	21565	10	in	in	IN
18637	21565	11	possession	possession	NN
18637	21565	12	for	for	IN
18637	21565	13	five	five	CD
18637	21565	14	years	year	NNS
18637	21565	15	after	after	IN
18637	21565	16	and	and	CC
18637	21565	17	fifteen	fifteen	CD
18637	21565	18	years	year	NNS
18637	21565	19	before	before	IN
18637	21565	20	said	say	VBD
18637	21565	21	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	21565	22	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	21565	23	deprived	deprive	VBN
18637	21565	24	of	of	IN
18637	21565	25	any	any	DT
18637	21565	26	property	property	NN
18637	21565	27	without	without	IN
18637	21565	28	due	due	JJ
18637	21565	29	process	process	NN
18637	21565	30	.	.	.
18637	21566	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21566	2	779	779	CD
18637	21566	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21566	4	Mattson	Mattson	NNP
18637	21566	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21566	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21566	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21566	8	Department	Department	NNP
18637	21566	9	of	of	IN
18637	21566	10	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	21566	11	,	,	,
18637	21566	12	293	293	CD
18637	21566	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21566	14	151	151	CD
18637	21566	15	,	,	,
18637	21566	16	154	154	CD
18637	21566	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21566	18	1934	1934	CD
18637	21566	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21566	20	.	.	.
18637	21567	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21567	2	780	780	CD
18637	21567	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21567	4	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
18637	21567	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21567	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21567	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21567	8	Holt	Holt	NNP
18637	21567	9	,	,	,
18637	21567	10	115	115	CD
18637	21567	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21567	12	620	620	CD
18637	21567	13	,	,	,
18637	21567	14	623	623	CD
18637	21567	15	,	,	,
18637	21567	16	628	628	CD
18637	21567	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21567	18	1885	1885	CD
18637	21567	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21567	20	.	.	.
18637	21568	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21568	2	781	781	CD
18637	21568	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21568	4	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	21568	5	Securities	Securities	NNP
18637	21568	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	21568	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21568	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21568	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21568	10	Donaldson	Donaldson	NNP
18637	21568	11	,	,	,
18637	21568	12	325	325	CD
18637	21568	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21568	14	304	304	CD
18637	21568	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21568	16	1945	1945	CD
18637	21568	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21568	18	.	.	.
18637	21569	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21569	2	782	782	CD
18637	21569	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21569	4	Gange	Gange	NNP
18637	21569	5	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	21569	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21569	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21569	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21569	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21569	10	Rowley	Rowley	NNP
18637	21569	11	,	,	,
18637	21569	12	326	326	CD
18637	21569	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21569	14	295	295	CD
18637	21569	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21569	16	1945	1945	CD
18637	21569	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21569	18	.	.	.
18637	21570	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21570	2	783	783	CD
18637	21570	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21570	4	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
18637	21570	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21570	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21570	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21570	8	Holt	Holt	NNP
18637	21570	9	,	,	,
18637	21570	10	115	115	CD
18637	21570	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21570	12	620	620	CD
18637	21570	13	,	,	,
18637	21570	14	623	623	CD
18637	21570	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21570	16	1885	1885	CD
18637	21570	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21570	18	.	.	.
18637	21571	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21571	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21571	3	also	also	RB
18637	21571	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21571	5	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	21571	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21571	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21571	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21571	9	Keyes	Keyes	NNP
18637	21571	10	,	,	,
18637	21571	11	295	295	CD
18637	21571	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21571	13	403	403	CD
18637	21571	14	,	,	,
18637	21571	15	417	417	CD
18637	21571	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21571	17	1935	1935	CD
18637	21571	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21571	19	.	.	.
18637	21572	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21572	2	784	784	CD
18637	21572	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21572	4	Home	Home	NNP
18637	21572	5	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	21572	6	.	.	.
18637	21573	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21573	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21573	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21573	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21573	5	Dick	Dick	NNP
18637	21573	6	,	,	,
18637	21573	7	281	281	CD
18637	21573	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21573	9	397	397	CD
18637	21573	10	,	,	,
18637	21573	11	398	398	CD
18637	21573	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21573	13	1930	1930	CD
18637	21573	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21573	15	.	.	.
18637	21574	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21574	2	785	785	CD
18637	21574	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21574	4	Hawkins	Hawkins	NNP
18637	21574	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21574	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21574	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21574	8	Bleakly	Bleakly	NNP
18637	21574	9	,	,	,
18637	21574	10	243	243	CD
18637	21574	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21574	12	210	210	CD
18637	21574	13	,	,	,
18637	21574	14	214	214	CD
18637	21574	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21574	16	1917	1917	CD
18637	21574	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21574	18	;	;	:
18637	21574	19	James	James	NNP
18637	21574	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	21574	21	Dickinson	Dickinson	NNP
18637	21574	22	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	21574	23	Mortg	Mortg	NNP
18637	21574	24	.	.	.
18637	21575	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21575	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21575	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21575	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21575	5	Harry	Harry	NNP
18637	21575	6	,	,	,
18637	21575	7	273	273	CD
18637	21575	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21575	9	119	119	CD
18637	21575	10	,	,	,
18637	21575	11	124	124	CD
18637	21575	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21575	13	1927	1927	CD
18637	21575	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21575	15	.	.	.
18637	21576	1	An	an	DT
18637	21576	2	omission	omission	NN
18637	21576	3	in	in	IN
18637	21576	4	a	a	DT
18637	21576	5	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	21576	6	trial	trial	NN
18637	21576	7	of	of	IN
18637	21576	8	any	any	DT
18637	21576	9	reference	reference	NN
18637	21576	10	to	to	IN
18637	21576	11	the	the	DT
18637	21576	12	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	21576	13	of	of	IN
18637	21576	14	innocence	innocence	NN
18637	21576	15	effects	effect	NNS
18637	21576	16	no	no	DT
18637	21576	17	denial	denial	NN
18637	21576	18	of	of	IN
18637	21576	19	due	due	JJ
18637	21576	20	process	process	NN
18637	21576	21	of	of	IN
18637	21576	22	law	law	NN
18637	21576	23	where	where	WRB
18637	21576	24	the	the	DT
18637	21576	25	State	State	NNP
18637	21576	26	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	21576	27	court	court	NN
18637	21576	28	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	21576	29	that	that	IN
18637	21576	30	such	such	JJ
18637	21576	31	omission	omission	NN
18637	21576	32	did	do	VBD
18637	21576	33	not	not	RB
18637	21576	34	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	21576	35	the	the	DT
18637	21576	36	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	21576	37	.	.	.
18637	21577	1	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	21577	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21577	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21577	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21577	5	Fleming	Fleming	NNP
18637	21577	6	,	,	,
18637	21577	7	191	191	CD
18637	21577	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21577	9	126	126	CD
18637	21577	10	,	,	,
18637	21577	11	136	136	CD
18637	21577	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21577	13	1903	1903	CD
18637	21577	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21577	15	.	.	.
18637	21578	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21578	2	786	786	CD
18637	21578	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21578	4	Manley	Manley	NNP
18637	21578	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21578	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21578	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21578	8	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	21578	9	,	,	,
18637	21578	10	279	279	CD
18637	21578	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21578	12	1	1	CD
18637	21578	13	,	,	,
18637	21578	14	5	5	CD
18637	21578	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21578	16	1929	1929	CD
18637	21578	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21578	18	;	;	:
18637	21578	19	Western	Western	NNP
18637	21578	20	&	&	CC
18637	21578	21	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	21579	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21579	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21579	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21579	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21579	5	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	21579	6	,	,	,
18637	21579	7	279	279	CD
18637	21579	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21579	9	639	639	CD
18637	21579	10	,	,	,
18637	21579	11	642	642	CD
18637	21579	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21579	13	1929	1929	CD
18637	21579	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21579	15	;	;	:
18637	21579	16	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	21579	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21579	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	21579	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21579	20	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	21579	21	,	,	,
18637	21579	22	219	219	CD
18637	21579	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21579	24	219	219	CD
18637	21579	25	,	,	,
18637	21579	26	233	233	CD
18637	21579	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21579	28	1911	1911	CD
18637	21579	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21579	30	;	;	:
18637	21579	31	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	21579	32	,	,	,
18637	21579	33	J.	J.	NNP
18637	21580	1	&	&	CC
18637	21580	2	K.C.R.	K.C.R.	NNP
18637	21581	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21581	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21581	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21581	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21581	5	Turnipseed	Turnipseed	NNP
18637	21581	6	,	,	,
18637	21581	7	219	219	CD
18637	21581	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21581	9	35	35	CD
18637	21581	10	,	,	,
18637	21581	11	42	42	CD
18637	21581	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21581	13	1910	1910	CD
18637	21581	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21581	15	.	.	.
18637	21582	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21582	2	787	787	CD
18637	21582	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21582	4	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	21582	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21582	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21582	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21582	8	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	21582	9	,	,	,
18637	21582	10	219	219	CD
18637	21582	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21582	12	219	219	CD
18637	21582	13	,	,	,
18637	21582	14	233	233	CD
18637	21582	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21582	16	1911	1911	CD
18637	21582	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21582	18	.	.	.
18637	21583	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21583	2	788	788	CD
18637	21583	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21583	4	Manley	Manley	NNP
18637	21583	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21583	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21583	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21583	8	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	21583	9	,	,	,
18637	21583	10	279	279	CD
18637	21583	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21583	12	1	1	CD
18637	21583	13	,	,	,
18637	21583	14	7	7	CD
18637	21583	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21583	16	1929	1929	CD
18637	21583	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21583	18	.	.	.
18637	21584	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21584	2	789	789	CD
18637	21584	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21584	4	Western	Western	NNP
18637	21584	5	&	&	CC
18637	21584	6	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	21585	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21585	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21585	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21585	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21585	5	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	21585	6	,	,	,
18637	21585	7	279	279	CD
18637	21585	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21585	9	639	639	CD
18637	21585	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21585	11	1929	1929	CD
18637	21585	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21585	13	.	.	.
18637	21586	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21586	2	790	790	CD
18637	21586	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21586	4	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	21586	5	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	21586	6	Line	Line	NNP
18637	21586	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	21586	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21586	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21586	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	21586	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21586	12	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	21586	13	,	,	,
18637	21586	14	287	287	CD
18637	21586	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21586	16	502	502	CD
18637	21586	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21586	18	1933	1933	CD
18637	21586	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21586	20	.	.	.
18637	21587	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21587	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21587	3	also	also	RB
18637	21587	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21587	5	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	21587	6	,	,	,
18637	21587	7	J.	J.	NNP
18637	21588	1	&	&	CC
18637	21588	2	K.C.R.	K.C.R.	NNP
18637	21589	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21589	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21589	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21589	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21589	5	Turnipseed	Turnipseed	NNP
18637	21589	6	,	,	,
18637	21589	7	219	219	CD
18637	21589	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21589	9	35	35	CD
18637	21589	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21589	11	1910	1910	CD
18637	21589	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21589	13	.	.	.
18637	21590	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21590	2	791	791	CD
18637	21590	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21590	4	Hawes	Hawes	NNP
18637	21590	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21590	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21590	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21590	8	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	21590	9	,	,	,
18637	21590	10	258	258	CD
18637	21590	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21590	12	1	1	CD
18637	21590	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21590	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	21590	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21590	16	.	.	.
18637	21591	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21591	2	792	792	CD
18637	21591	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21591	4	Bandini	Bandini	NNP
18637	21591	5	Petroleum	Petroleum	NNP
18637	21591	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21591	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21591	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21591	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21591	10	Superior	Superior	NNP
18637	21591	11	Ct	Ct	NNP
18637	21591	12	.	.	NNP
18637	21591	13	,	,	,
18637	21591	14	284	284	CD
18637	21591	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21591	16	8	8	CD
18637	21591	17	,	,	,
18637	21591	18	19	19	CD
18637	21591	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21591	20	1931	1931	CD
18637	21591	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21591	22	.	.	.
18637	21592	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21592	2	793	793	CD
18637	21592	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21592	4	Hawker	Hawker	NNP
18637	21592	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21592	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21592	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21592	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21592	9	York	York	NNP
18637	21592	10	,	,	,
18637	21592	11	170	170	CD
18637	21592	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21592	13	189	189	CD
18637	21592	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21592	15	1898	1898	CD
18637	21592	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21592	17	.	.	.
18637	21593	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21593	2	794	794	CD
18637	21593	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21593	4	Cockrill	Cockrill	NNP
18637	21593	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21593	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21593	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21593	8	California	California	NNP
18637	21593	9	,	,	,
18637	21593	10	268	268	CD
18637	21593	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21593	12	258	258	CD
18637	21593	13	,	,	,
18637	21593	14	261	261	CD
18637	21593	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21593	16	1925	1925	CD
18637	21593	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21593	18	.	.	.
18637	21594	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21594	2	795	795	CD
18637	21594	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21594	4	Morrison	Morrison	NNP
18637	21594	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21594	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21594	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21594	8	California	California	NNP
18637	21594	9	,	,	,
18637	21594	10	288	288	CD
18637	21594	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21594	12	591	591	CD
18637	21594	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21594	14	1933	1933	CD
18637	21594	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21594	16	.	.	.
18637	21595	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21595	2	796	796	CD
18637	21595	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21595	4	Morrison	Morrison	NNP
18637	21595	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21595	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21595	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21595	8	California	California	NNP
18637	21595	9	,	,	,
18637	21595	10	291	291	CD
18637	21595	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21595	12	82	82	CD
18637	21595	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21595	14	1934	1934	CD
18637	21595	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21595	16	.	.	.
18637	21596	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21596	2	797	797	CD
18637	21596	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21596	4	"	"	``
18637	21596	5	The	the	DT
18637	21596	6	limits	limit	NNS
18637	21596	7	are	be	VBP
18637	21596	8	in	in	IN
18637	21596	9	substance	substance	NN
18637	21596	10	these	these	DT
18637	21596	11	,	,	,
18637	21596	12	that	that	IN
18637	21596	13	the	the	DT
18637	21596	14	State	state	NN
18637	21596	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	21596	16	have	have	VB
18637	21596	17	proved	prove	VBN
18637	21596	18	enough	enough	RB
18637	21596	19	to	to	TO
18637	21596	20	make	make	VB
18637	21596	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21596	22	just	just	RB
18637	21596	23	for	for	IN
18637	21596	24	the	the	DT
18637	21596	25	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	21596	26	to	to	TO
18637	21596	27	be	be	VB
18637	21596	28	required	require	VBN
18637	21596	29	to	to	TO
18637	21596	30	repeal	repeal	VB
18637	21596	31	what	what	WP
18637	21596	32	has	have	VBZ
18637	21596	33	been	be	VBN
18637	21596	34	proved	prove	VBN
18637	21596	35	*	*	NFP
18637	21596	36	*	*	NFP
18637	21596	37	*	*	NFP
18637	21596	38	,	,	,
18637	21596	39	or	or	CC
18637	21596	40	at	at	IN
18637	21596	41	least	least	JJS
18637	21596	42	that	that	IN
18637	21596	43	upon	upon	IN
18637	21596	44	a	a	DT
18637	21596	45	balancing	balancing	NN
18637	21596	46	of	of	IN
18637	21596	47	convenience	convenience	NN
18637	21596	48	or	or	CC
18637	21596	49	of	of	IN
18637	21596	50	the	the	DT
18637	21596	51	opportunities	opportunity	NNS
18637	21596	52	for	for	IN
18637	21596	53	knowledge	knowledge	NN
18637	21596	54	the	the	DT
18637	21596	55	shifting	shifting	NN
18637	21596	56	of	of	IN
18637	21596	57	the	the	DT
18637	21596	58	burden	burden	NN
18637	21596	59	will	will	MD
18637	21596	60	be	be	VB
18637	21596	61	found	find	VBN
18637	21596	62	to	to	TO
18637	21596	63	be	be	VB
18637	21596	64	an	an	DT
18637	21596	65	aid	aid	NN
18637	21596	66	to	to	IN
18637	21596	67	the	the	DT
18637	21596	68	accuser	accuser	NN
18637	21596	69	without	without	IN
18637	21596	70	subjecting	subject	VBG
18637	21596	71	the	the	DT
18637	21596	72	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21596	73	to	to	IN
18637	21596	74	hardship	hardship	NN
18637	21596	75	or	or	CC
18637	21596	76	oppression	oppression	NN
18637	21596	77	.	.	.
18637	21596	78	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	21596	79	.	.	.
18637	21597	1	88	88	CD
18637	21597	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21597	3	89	89	CD
18637	21597	4	.	.	.
18637	21598	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21598	2	798	798	CD
18637	21598	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21598	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21598	5	.	.	.
18637	21599	1	87	87	CD
18637	21599	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21599	3	91	91	CD
18637	21599	4	,	,	,
18637	21599	5	96	96	CD
18637	21599	6	-	-	SYM
18637	21599	7	97	97	CD
18637	21599	8	.	.	.
18637	21600	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21600	2	799	799	CD
18637	21600	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21600	4	Leland	Leland	NNP
18637	21600	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21600	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21600	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21600	8	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	21600	9	,	,	,
18637	21600	10	343	343	CD
18637	21600	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21600	12	790	790	CD
18637	21600	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21600	14	1952	1952	CD
18637	21600	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21600	16	.	.	.
18637	21601	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21601	2	800	800	CD
18637	21601	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21601	4	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	21601	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21601	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21601	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21601	8	Sauvinet	Sauvinet	NNP
18637	21601	9	,	,	,
18637	21601	10	92	92	CD
18637	21601	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21601	12	90	90	CD
18637	21601	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21601	14	1876	1876	CD
18637	21601	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21601	16	;	;	:
18637	21601	17	New	New	NNP
18637	21601	18	York	York	NNP
18637	21601	19	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	21602	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21602	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21602	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21602	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21602	5	White	White	NNP
18637	21602	6	,	,	,
18637	21602	7	243	243	CD
18637	21602	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21602	9	188	188	CD
18637	21602	10	,	,	,
18637	21602	11	208	208	CD
18637	21602	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21602	13	1917	1917	CD
18637	21602	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21602	15	;	;	:
18637	21602	16	Snyder	Snyder	NNP
18637	21602	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21602	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	21602	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21602	20	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21602	21	,	,	,
18637	21602	22	291	291	CD
18637	21602	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21602	24	97	97	CD
18637	21602	25	,	,	,
18637	21602	26	105	105	CD
18637	21602	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21602	28	1934	1934	CD
18637	21602	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21602	30	.	.	.
18637	21603	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21603	2	801	801	CD
18637	21603	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21603	4	Marvin	Marvin	NNP
18637	21603	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21603	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21603	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21603	8	Trout	Trout	NNP
18637	21603	9	,	,	,
18637	21603	10	199	199	CD
18637	21603	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21603	12	212	212	CD
18637	21603	13	,	,	,
18637	21603	14	226	226	CD
18637	21603	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21603	16	1905	1905	CD
18637	21603	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21603	18	.	.	.
18637	21604	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21604	2	802	802	CD
18637	21604	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21604	4	Tinsley	Tinsley	NNP
18637	21604	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21604	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21604	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21604	8	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	21604	9	,	,	,
18637	21604	10	171	171	CD
18637	21604	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21604	12	101	101	CD
18637	21604	13	,	,	,
18637	21604	14	108	108	CD
18637	21604	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21604	16	1898	1898	CD
18637	21604	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21604	18	;	;	:
18637	21604	19	Eilenbecker	Eilenbecker	NNP
18637	21604	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21604	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21604	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21604	23	District	District	NNP
18637	21604	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21604	25	,	,	,
18637	21604	26	134	134	CD
18637	21604	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21604	28	31	31	CD
18637	21604	29	,	,	,
18637	21604	30	36	36	CD
18637	21604	31	,	,	,
18637	21604	32	39	39	CD
18637	21604	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21604	34	1890	1890	CD
18637	21604	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21604	36	.	.	.
18637	21605	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21605	2	803	803	CD
18637	21605	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21605	4	Delgado	Delgado	NNP
18637	21605	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21605	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21605	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21605	8	Chavez	Chavez	NNP
18637	21605	9	,	,	,
18637	21605	10	140	140	CD
18637	21605	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21605	12	586	586	CD
18637	21605	13	,	,	,
18637	21605	14	588	588	CD
18637	21605	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21605	16	1891	1891	CD
18637	21605	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21605	18	.	.	.
18637	21606	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21606	2	804	804	CD
18637	21606	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21606	4	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	21606	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21606	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21606	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21606	8	North	North	NNP
18637	21606	9	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	21606	10	ex	ex	NN
18637	21606	11	rel	rel	NN
18637	21606	12	.	.	.
18637	21607	1	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	21607	2	,	,	,
18637	21607	3	169	169	CD
18637	21607	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21607	5	586	586	CD
18637	21607	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21607	7	1898	1898	CD
18637	21607	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21607	9	;	;	:
18637	21607	10	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	21607	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21607	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	21607	13	_	_	NNP
18637	21607	14	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	21607	15	ex	ex	NNP
18637	21607	16	rel	rel	NNP
18637	21607	17	.	.	.
18637	21608	1	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	21608	2	,	,	,
18637	21608	3	112	112	CD
18637	21608	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21608	5	201	201	CD
18637	21608	6	,	,	,
18637	21608	7	206	206	CD
18637	21608	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21608	9	1884	1884	CD
18637	21608	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21608	11	.	.	.
18637	21609	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21609	2	805	805	CD
18637	21609	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21609	4	Long	Long	NNP
18637	21609	5	Island	Island	NNP
18637	21609	6	Water	Water	NNP
18637	21609	7	Supply	Supply	NNP
18637	21609	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21609	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21609	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	21609	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21609	12	Brooklyn	Brooklyn	NNP
18637	21609	13	,	,	,
18637	21609	14	166	166	CD
18637	21609	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21609	16	685	685	CD
18637	21609	17	,	,	,
18637	21609	18	694	694	CD
18637	21609	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21609	20	1897	1897	CD
18637	21609	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21609	22	.	.	.
18637	21610	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21610	2	806	806	CD
18637	21610	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21610	4	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	21610	5	Company	Company	NNP
18637	21610	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21610	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21610	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21610	9	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21610	10	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	21610	11	Min	Min	NNP
18637	21610	12	.	.	.
18637	21611	1	&	&	CC
18637	21611	2	Mill	Mill	NNP
18637	21611	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21611	4	,	,	,
18637	21611	5	152	152	CD
18637	21611	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21611	7	160	160	CD
18637	21611	8	,	,	,
18637	21611	9	171	171	CD
18637	21611	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21611	11	1894	1894	CD
18637	21611	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21611	13	;	;	:
18637	21611	14	Church	Church	NNP
18637	21611	15	_	_	NNP
18637	21611	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	21611	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21611	18	Kelsey	Kelsey	NNP
18637	21611	19	,	,	,
18637	21611	20	121	121	CD
18637	21611	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21611	22	282	282	CD
18637	21611	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21611	24	1887	1887	CD
18637	21611	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21611	26	.	.	.
18637	21612	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21612	2	807	807	CD
18637	21612	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21612	4	Jordan	Jordan	NNP
18637	21612	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21612	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21612	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21612	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21612	9	,	,	,
18637	21612	10	225	225	CD
18637	21612	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21612	12	167	167	CD
18637	21612	13	,	,	,
18637	21612	14	176	176	CD
18637	21612	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21612	16	1912	1912	CD
18637	21612	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21612	18	.	.	.
18637	21613	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21613	2	808	808	CD
18637	21613	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21613	4	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	21613	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21613	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21613	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21613	8	Dow	Dow	NNP
18637	21613	9	,	,	,
18637	21613	10	176	176	CD
18637	21613	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21613	12	581	581	CD
18637	21613	13	,	,	,
18637	21613	14	602	602	CD
18637	21613	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21613	16	1900	1900	CD
18637	21613	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21613	18	.	.	.
18637	21614	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21614	2	809	809	CD
18637	21614	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21614	4	Winters	Winters	NNP
18637	21614	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21614	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21614	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21614	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21614	9	York	York	NNP
18637	21614	10	,	,	,
18637	21614	11	333	333	CD
18637	21614	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21614	13	507	507	CD
18637	21614	14	,	,	,
18637	21614	15	509	509	CD
18637	21614	16	-	-	SYM
18637	21614	17	510	510	CD
18637	21614	18	,	,	,
18637	21614	19	515	515	CD
18637	21614	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21614	21	1948	1948	CD
18637	21614	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21614	23	.	.	.
18637	21615	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21615	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21615	3	also	also	RB
18637	21615	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21615	5	Cline	Cline	NNP
18637	21615	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21615	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21615	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21615	9	Frink	Frink	NNP
18637	21615	10	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
18637	21615	11	,	,	,
18637	21615	12	274	274	CD
18637	21615	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21615	14	445	445	CD
18637	21615	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21615	16	1927	1927	CD
18637	21615	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21615	18	;	;	:
18637	21615	19	Cole	Cole	NNP
18637	21615	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21615	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21615	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21615	23	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	21615	24	,	,	,
18637	21615	25	338	338	CD
18637	21615	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21615	27	345	345	CD
18637	21615	28	,	,	,
18637	21615	29	354	354	CD
18637	21615	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21615	31	1949	1949	CD
18637	21615	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21615	33	.	.	.
18637	21616	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21616	2	810	810	CD
18637	21616	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21616	4	Lanzetta	Lanzetta	NNP
18637	21616	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21616	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21616	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21616	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21616	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	21616	10	,	,	,
18637	21616	11	306	306	CD
18637	21616	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21616	13	451	451	CD
18637	21616	14	,	,	,
18637	21616	15	455	455	CD
18637	21616	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21616	17	1939	1939	CD
18637	21616	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21616	19	.	.	.
18637	21617	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21617	2	811	811	CD
18637	21617	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21617	4	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	21617	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21617	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21617	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21617	8	Probate	Probate	NNP
18637	21617	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21617	10	,	,	,
18637	21617	11	309	309	CD
18637	21617	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21617	13	270	270	CD
18637	21617	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21617	15	1940	1940	CD
18637	21617	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21617	17	.	.	.
18637	21618	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21618	2	812	812	CD
18637	21618	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21618	4	Hurtado	Hurtado	NNP
18637	21618	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21618	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21618	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21618	8	California	California	NNP
18637	21618	9	,	,	,
18637	21618	10	110	110	CD
18637	21618	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21618	12	516	516	CD
18637	21618	13	,	,	,
18637	21618	14	520	520	CD
18637	21618	15	,	,	,
18637	21618	16	538	538	CD
18637	21618	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21618	18	1884	1884	CD
18637	21618	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21618	20	;	;	:
18637	21618	21	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	21618	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21618	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	21618	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21618	25	New	New	NNP
18637	21618	26	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	21618	27	,	,	,
18637	21618	28	175	175	CD
18637	21618	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21618	30	172	172	CD
18637	21618	31	,	,	,
18637	21618	32	175	175	CD
18637	21618	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21618	34	1890	1890	CD
18637	21618	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21618	36	;	;	:
18637	21618	37	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	21618	38	_	_	NNP
18637	21618	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	21618	40	_	_	NNP
18637	21618	41	Dow	Dow	NNP
18637	21618	42	,	,	,
18637	21618	43	176	176	CD
18637	21618	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21618	45	581	581	CD
18637	21618	46	,	,	,
18637	21618	47	602	602	CD
18637	21618	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21618	49	1900	1900	CD
18637	21618	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21618	51	;	;	:
18637	21618	52	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	21618	53	_	_	NNP
18637	21618	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	21618	55	_	_	NNP
18637	21618	56	West	West	NNP
18637	21618	57	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	21618	58	,	,	,
18637	21618	59	224	224	CD
18637	21618	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21618	61	616	616	CD
18637	21618	62	,	,	,
18637	21618	63	627	627	CD
18637	21618	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21618	65	1912	1912	CD
18637	21618	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21618	67	;	;	:
18637	21618	68	Jordan	Jordan	NNP
18637	21618	69	_	_	NNP
18637	21618	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	21618	71	_	_	NNP
18637	21618	72	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21618	73	,	,	,
18637	21618	74	225	225	CD
18637	21618	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21618	76	167	167	CD
18637	21618	77	,	,	,
18637	21618	78	176	176	CD
18637	21618	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21618	80	1912	1912	CD
18637	21618	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21618	82	.	.	.
18637	21619	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21619	2	813	813	CD
18637	21619	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21619	4	Lem	Lem	NNP
18637	21619	5	Woon	Woon	NNP
18637	21619	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21619	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21619	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21619	9	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	21619	10	,	,	,
18637	21619	11	229	229	CD
18637	21619	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21619	13	586	586	CD
18637	21619	14	,	,	,
18637	21619	15	590	590	CD
18637	21619	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21619	17	1913	1913	CD
18637	21619	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21619	19	.	.	.
18637	21620	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21620	2	814	814	CD
18637	21620	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21620	4	Gaines	Gaines	NNP
18637	21620	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21620	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21620	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21620	8	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	21620	9	,	,	,
18637	21620	10	277	277	CD
18637	21620	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21620	12	81	81	CD
18637	21620	13	,	,	,
18637	21620	14	86	86	CD
18637	21620	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21620	16	1928	1928	CD
18637	21620	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21620	18	.	.	.
18637	21621	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21621	2	815	815	CD
18637	21621	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21621	4	Norris	Norris	NNP
18637	21621	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21621	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21621	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21621	8	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	21621	9	,	,	,
18637	21621	10	294	294	CD
18637	21621	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21621	12	587	587	CD
18637	21621	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21621	14	1935	1935	CD
18637	21621	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21621	16	.	.	.
18637	21622	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21622	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21622	3	also	also	RB
18637	21622	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21622	5	Hale	Hale	NNP
18637	21622	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21622	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21622	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21622	9	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21622	10	,	,	,
18637	21622	11	303	303	CD
18637	21622	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21622	13	613	613	CD
18637	21622	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21622	15	1938	1938	CD
18637	21622	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21622	17	;	;	:
18637	21622	18	Pierre	Pierre	NNP
18637	21622	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21622	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	21622	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21622	22	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	21622	23	,	,	,
18637	21622	24	306	306	CD
18637	21622	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21622	26	354	354	CD
18637	21622	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21622	28	1939	1939	CD
18637	21622	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21622	30	;	;	:
18637	21622	31	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	21622	32	_	_	NNP
18637	21622	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	21622	34	_	_	NNP
18637	21622	35	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	21622	36	,	,	,
18637	21622	37	311	311	CD
18637	21622	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21622	39	128	128	CD
18637	21622	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21622	41	1940	1940	CD
18637	21622	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21622	43	;	;	:
18637	21622	44	Shepherd	Shepherd	NNP
18637	21622	45	_	_	NNP
18637	21622	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	21622	47	_	_	NNP
18637	21622	48	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	21622	49	,	,	,
18637	21622	50	341	341	CD
18637	21622	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21622	52	50	50	CD
18637	21622	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21622	54	1951	1951	CD
18637	21622	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21622	56	.	.	.
18637	21623	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21623	2	816	816	CD
18637	21623	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21623	4	Powell	Powell	NNP
18637	21623	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21623	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21623	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21623	8	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	21623	9	,	,	,
18637	21623	10	287	287	CD
18637	21623	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21623	12	45	45	CD
18637	21623	13	,	,	,
18637	21623	14	66	66	CD
18637	21623	15	,	,	,
18637	21623	16	71	71	CD
18637	21623	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21623	18	1932	1932	CD
18637	21623	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21623	20	.	.	.
18637	21624	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21624	2	817	817	CD
18637	21624	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21624	4	Palko	Palko	NNP
18637	21624	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21624	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21624	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21624	8	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	21624	9	,	,	,
18637	21624	10	302	302	CD
18637	21624	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21624	12	319	319	CD
18637	21624	13	,	,	,
18637	21624	14	324	324	CD
18637	21624	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21624	16	325	325	CD
18637	21624	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21624	18	1937	1937	CD
18637	21624	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21624	20	.	.	.
18637	21625	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21625	2	818	818	CD
18637	21625	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21625	4	287	287	CD
18637	21625	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21625	6	45	45	CD
18637	21625	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21625	8	1932	1932	CD
18637	21625	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21625	10	.	.	.
18637	21626	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21626	2	819	819	CD
18637	21626	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21626	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21626	5	.	.	.
18637	21627	1	71	71	CD
18637	21627	2	.	.	.
18637	21628	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21628	2	820	820	CD
18637	21628	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21628	4	287	287	CD
18637	21628	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21628	6	45	45	CD
18637	21628	7	,	,	,
18637	21628	8	71	71	CD
18637	21628	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21628	10	1932).--The	1932).--The	NNP
18637	21628	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21628	12	presently	presently	RB
18637	21628	13	seems	seem	VBZ
18637	21628	14	to	to	TO
18637	21628	15	be	be	VB
18637	21628	16	holding	hold	VBG
18637	21628	17	that	that	DT
18637	21628	18	in	in	IN
18637	21628	19	capital	capital	NN
18637	21628	20	cases	case	NNS
18637	21628	21	,	,	,
18637	21628	22	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	21628	23	the	the	DT
18637	21628	24	absence	absence	NN
18637	21628	25	even	even	RB
18637	21628	26	of	of	IN
18637	21628	27	other	other	JJ
18637	21628	28	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	21628	29	prejudicial	prejudicial	JJ
18637	21628	30	to	to	IN
18637	21628	31	the	the	DT
18637	21628	32	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	21628	33	,	,	,
18637	21628	34	the	the	DT
18637	21628	35	right	right	NN
18637	21628	36	to	to	IN
18637	21628	37	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21628	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	21628	39	unqualified	unqualified	JJ
18637	21628	40	.	.	.
18637	21629	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21629	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21629	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21629	4	the	the	DT
18637	21629	5	later	later	JJ
18637	21629	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	21629	7	discussed	discuss	VBD
18637	21629	8	herein	herein	NNP
18637	21629	9	,	,	,
18637	21629	10	especially	especially	RB
18637	21629	11	Tomkins	Tomkins	NNP
18637	21629	12	_	_	NNP
18637	21629	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	21629	14	_	_	NNP
18637	21629	15	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	21629	16	,	,	,
18637	21629	17	323	323	CD
18637	21629	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21629	19	485	485	CD
18637	21629	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21629	21	1945	1945	CD
18637	21629	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21629	23	;	;	:
18637	21629	24	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	21629	25	_	_	NNP
18637	21629	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	21629	27	_	_	NNP
18637	21629	28	Kaiser	Kaiser	NNP
18637	21629	29	,	,	,
18637	21629	30	323	323	CD
18637	21629	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21629	32	471	471	CD
18637	21629	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21629	34	1945	1945	CD
18637	21629	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21629	36	;	;	:
18637	21629	37	Hawk	Hawk	NNP
18637	21629	38	_	_	NNP
18637	21629	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	21629	40	_	_	NNP
18637	21629	41	Olson	Olson	NNP
18637	21629	42	,	,	,
18637	21629	43	326	326	CD
18637	21629	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21629	45	271	271	CD
18637	21629	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21629	47	1945	1945	CD
18637	21629	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21629	49	;	;	:
18637	21629	50	and	and	CC
18637	21629	51	the	the	DT
18637	21629	52	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21629	53	's	's	POS
18637	21629	54	summary	summary	NN
18637	21629	55	of	of	IN
18637	21629	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21629	57	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	21629	58	in	in	IN
18637	21629	59	Uveges	Uveges	NNP
18637	21629	60	_	_	NNP
18637	21629	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	21629	62	_	_	NNP
18637	21629	63	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21629	64	,	,	,
18637	21629	65	335	335	CD
18637	21629	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21629	67	437	437	CD
18637	21629	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21629	69	1948	1948	CD
18637	21629	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21629	71	,	,	,
18637	21629	72	_	_	NNP
18637	21629	73	supra	supra	NNP
18637	21629	74	_	_	NNP
18637	21629	75	,	,	,
18637	21629	76	p.	p.	NN
18637	21629	77	1108	1108	CD
18637	21629	78	.	.	.
18637	21630	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21630	2	821	821	CD
18637	21630	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21630	4	308	308	CD
18637	21630	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21630	6	444	444	CD
18637	21630	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21630	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	21630	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21630	10	.	.	.
18637	21631	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21631	2	822	822	CD
18637	21631	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21631	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21631	5	.	.	.
18637	21632	1	446	446	CD
18637	21632	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21632	3	447	447	CD
18637	21632	4	.	.	.
18637	21633	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21633	2	823	823	CD
18637	21633	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21633	4	312	312	CD
18637	21633	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21633	6	329	329	CD
18637	21633	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21633	8	1941).--In	1941).--in	CD
18637	21633	9	a	a	DT
18637	21633	10	post	post	FW
18637	21633	11	mortem	mortem	FW
18637	21633	12	comment	comment	NN
18637	21633	13	on	on	IN
18637	21633	14	this	this	DT
18637	21633	15	case	case	NN
18637	21633	16	appearing	appear	VBG
18637	21633	17	in	in	IN
18637	21633	18	the	the	DT
18637	21633	19	later	later	JJ
18637	21633	20	decision	decision	NN
18637	21633	21	of	of	IN
18637	21633	22	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	21633	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21633	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	21633	25	_	_	NNP
18637	21633	26	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	21633	27	,	,	,
18637	21633	28	316	316	CD
18637	21633	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21633	30	455	455	CD
18637	21633	31	,	,	,
18637	21633	32	464	464	CD
18637	21633	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21633	34	1942	1942	CD
18637	21633	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21633	36	,	,	,
18637	21633	37	there	there	EX
18637	21633	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	21633	39	contained	contain	VBN
18637	21633	40	the	the	DT
18637	21633	41	intimation	intimation	NN
18637	21633	42	that	that	IN
18637	21633	43	the	the	DT
18637	21633	44	mere	mere	JJ
18637	21633	45	failure	failure	NN
18637	21633	46	to	to	TO
18637	21633	47	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	21633	48	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21633	49	,	,	,
18637	21633	50	alone	alone	RB
18637	21633	51	,	,	,
18637	21633	52	in	in	IN
18637	21633	53	the	the	DT
18637	21633	54	absence	absence	NN
18637	21633	55	of	of	IN
18637	21633	56	the	the	DT
18637	21633	57	proof	proof	NN
18637	21633	58	of	of	IN
18637	21633	59	other	other	JJ
18637	21633	60	facts	fact	NNS
18637	21633	61	tending	tend	VBG
18637	21633	62	to	to	TO
18637	21633	63	show	show	VB
18637	21633	64	that	that	IN
18637	21633	65	the	the	DT
18637	21633	66	whole	whole	JJ
18637	21633	67	trial	trial	NN
18637	21633	68	was	be	VBD
18637	21633	69	"	"	``
18637	21633	70	a	a	DT
18637	21633	71	mere	mere	JJ
18637	21633	72	sham	sham	NN
18637	21633	73	and	and	CC
18637	21633	74	a	a	DT
18637	21633	75	pretense	pretense	NN
18637	21633	76	,	,	,
18637	21633	77	"	"	``
18637	21633	78	would	would	MD
18637	21633	79	not	not	RB
18637	21633	80	have	have	VB
18637	21633	81	sufficed	suffice	VBN
18637	21633	82	to	to	TO
18637	21633	83	support	support	VB
18637	21633	84	a	a	DT
18637	21633	85	finding	finding	NN
18637	21633	86	of	of	IN
18637	21633	87	a	a	DT
18637	21633	88	denial	denial	NN
18637	21633	89	of	of	IN
18637	21633	90	due	due	JJ
18637	21633	91	process	process	NN
18637	21633	92	.	.	.
18637	21634	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21634	2	824	824	CD
18637	21634	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21634	4	316	316	CD
18637	21634	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21634	6	455	455	CD
18637	21634	7	,	,	,
18637	21634	8	462	462	CD
18637	21634	9	-	-	SYM
18637	21634	10	463	463	CD
18637	21634	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21634	12	1942	1942	CD
18637	21634	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21634	14	.	.	.
18637	21635	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21635	2	825	825	CD
18637	21635	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21635	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21635	5	.	.	.
18637	21636	1	462	462	CD
18637	21636	2	,	,	,
18637	21636	3	473	473	CD
18637	21636	4	.	.	.
18637	21637	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21637	2	826	826	CD
18637	21637	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21637	4	In	in	IN
18637	21637	5	Powell	Powell	NNP
18637	21637	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21637	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21637	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21637	9	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	21637	10	,	,	,
18637	21637	11	287	287	CD
18637	21637	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21637	13	45	45	CD
18637	21637	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21637	15	1932	1932	CD
18637	21637	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21637	17	;	;	:
18637	21637	18	Avery	Avery	NNP
18637	21637	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21637	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	21637	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21637	22	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	21637	23	,	,	,
18637	21637	24	308	308	CD
18637	21637	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21637	26	444	444	CD
18637	21637	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21637	28	1940	1940	CD
18637	21637	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21637	30	;	;	:
18637	21637	31	and	and	CC
18637	21637	32	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	21637	33	_	_	NNP
18637	21637	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	21637	35	_	_	NNP
18637	21637	36	O'Grady	O'Grady	NNP
18637	21637	37	,	,	,
18637	21637	38	312	312	CD
18637	21637	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21637	40	329	329	CD
18637	21637	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21637	42	1941	1941	CD
18637	21637	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21637	44	,	,	,
18637	21637	45	a	a	DT
18637	21637	46	State	State	NNP
18637	21637	47	law	law	NN
18637	21637	48	required	require	VBD
18637	21637	49	the	the	DT
18637	21637	50	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	21637	51	of	of	IN
18637	21637	52	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21637	53	.	.	.
18637	21638	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21638	2	827	827	CD
18637	21638	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21638	4	316	316	CD
18637	21638	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21638	6	455	455	CD
18637	21638	7	,	,	,
18637	21638	8	461	461	CD
18637	21638	9	-	-	SYM
18637	21638	10	462	462	CD
18637	21638	11	,	,	,
18637	21638	12	474	474	CD
18637	21638	13	-	-	SYM
18637	21638	14	476	476	CD
18637	21638	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21638	16	1942).--Dissenting	1942).--Dissenting	NNP
18637	21638	17	,	,	,
18637	21638	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21638	19	Black	Black	NNP
18637	21638	20	,	,	,
18637	21638	21	with	with	IN
18637	21638	22	whom	whom	WP
18637	21638	23	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21638	24	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	21638	25	and	and	CC
18637	21638	26	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21638	27	were	be	VBD
18637	21638	28	in	in	IN
18637	21638	29	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	21638	30	,	,	,
18637	21638	31	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBD
18637	21638	32	regretfully	regretfully	RB
18637	21638	33	that	that	IN
18637	21638	34	the	the	DT
18637	21638	35	view	view	NN
18637	21638	36	that	that	IN
18637	21638	37	the	the	DT
18637	21638	38	"	"	``
18637	21638	39	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21638	40	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21638	41	made	make	VBD
18637	21638	42	the	the	DT
18637	21638	43	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	21638	44	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	21638	45	to	to	IN
18637	21638	46	the	the	DT
18637	21638	47	States	state	NNS
18637	21638	48	*	*	NFP
18637	21638	49	*	*	NFP
18637	21638	50	*	*	NFP
18637	21638	51	has	have	VBZ
18637	21638	52	never	never	RB
18637	21638	53	been	be	VBN
18637	21638	54	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	21638	55	by	by	IN
18637	21638	56	a	a	DT
18637	21638	57	majority	majority	NN
18637	21638	58	of	of	IN
18637	21638	59	this	this	DT
18637	21638	60	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21638	61	,	,	,
18637	21638	62	"	"	''
18637	21638	63	and	and	CC
18637	21638	64	submitted	submit	VBD
18637	21638	65	a	a	DT
18637	21638	66	list	list	NN
18637	21638	67	of	of	IN
18637	21638	68	citations	citation	NNS
18637	21638	69	showing	show	VBG
18637	21638	70	that	that	IN
18637	21638	71	by	by	IN
18637	21638	72	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	21638	73	decision	decision	NN
18637	21638	74	,	,	,
18637	21638	75	as	as	RB
18637	21638	76	well	well	RB
18637	21638	77	as	as	IN
18637	21638	78	by	by	IN
18637	21638	79	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	21638	80	and	and	CC
18637	21638	81	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	21638	82	provision	provision	NN
18637	21638	83	,	,	,
18637	21638	84	a	a	DT
18637	21638	85	majority	majority	NN
18637	21638	86	of	of	IN
18637	21638	87	States	state	NNS
18637	21638	88	require	require	VBP
18637	21638	89	that	that	IN
18637	21638	90	indigent	indigent	JJ
18637	21638	91	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	21638	92	,	,	,
18637	21638	93	in	in	IN
18637	21638	94	noncapital	noncapital	JJ
18637	21638	95	as	as	RB
18637	21638	96	well	well	RB
18637	21638	97	as	as	IN
18637	21638	98	capital	capital	NN
18637	21638	99	cases	case	NNS
18637	21638	100	,	,	,
18637	21638	101	be	be	VB
18637	21638	102	provided	provide	VBN
18637	21638	103	with	with	IN
18637	21638	104	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21638	105	on	on	IN
18637	21638	106	request	request	NN
18637	21638	107	.	.	.
18637	21639	1	This	this	DT
18637	21639	2	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	21639	3	,	,	,
18637	21639	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21639	5	contended	contend	VBD
18637	21639	6	,	,	,
18637	21639	7	supports	support	VBZ
18637	21639	8	the	the	DT
18637	21639	9	conclusion	conclusion	NN
18637	21639	10	that	that	IN
18637	21639	11	"	"	``
18637	21639	12	denial	denial	JJ
18637	21639	13	to	to	IN
18637	21639	14	the	the	DT
18637	21639	15	poor	poor	JJ
18637	21639	16	of	of	IN
18637	21639	17	a	a	DT
18637	21639	18	request	request	NN
18637	21639	19	for	for	IN
18637	21639	20	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21639	21	in	in	IN
18637	21639	22	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	21639	23	based	base	VBN
18637	21639	24	on	on	IN
18637	21639	25	serious	serious	JJ
18637	21639	26	charges	charge	NNS
18637	21639	27	of	of	IN
18637	21639	28	crime	crime	NN
18637	21639	29	,	,	,
18637	21639	30	"	"	''
18637	21639	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	21639	32	"	"	``
18637	21639	33	long	long	RB
18637	21639	34	been	be	VBN
18637	21639	35	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	21639	36	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	21639	37	this	this	DT
18637	21639	38	country	country	NN
18637	21639	39	as	as	IN
18637	21639	40	shocking	shocking	JJ
18637	21639	41	to	to	IN
18637	21639	42	the	the	DT
18637	21639	43	'	'	``
18637	21639	44	universal	universal	JJ
18637	21639	45	sense	sense	NN
18637	21639	46	of	of	IN
18637	21639	47	justice	justice	NN
18637	21639	48	.	.	.
18637	21639	49	'	'	''
18637	21639	50	"	"	''
18637	21640	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21640	2	828	828	CD
18637	21640	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21640	4	323	323	CD
18637	21640	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21640	6	471	471	CD
18637	21640	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21640	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	21640	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21640	10	.	.	.
18637	21641	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21641	2	829	829	CD
18637	21641	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21641	4	323	323	CD
18637	21641	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21641	6	485	485	CD
18637	21641	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21641	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	21641	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21641	10	.	.	.
18637	21642	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21642	2	830	830	CD
18637	21642	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21642	4	287	287	CD
18637	21642	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21642	6	45	45	CD
18637	21642	7	,	,	,
18637	21642	8	69	69	CD
18637	21642	9	,	,	,
18637	21642	10	71	71	CD
18637	21642	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21642	12	1932	1932	CD
18637	21642	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21642	14	.	.	.
18637	21643	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21643	2	831	831	CD
18637	21643	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21643	4	323	323	CD
18637	21643	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21643	6	471	471	CD
18637	21643	7	,	,	,
18637	21643	8	476	476	CD
18637	21643	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21643	10	1945	1945	CD
18637	21643	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21643	12	.	.	.
18637	21644	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21644	2	832	832	CD
18637	21644	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21644	4	324	324	CD
18637	21644	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21644	6	42	42	CD
18637	21644	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21644	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	21644	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21644	10	.	.	.
18637	21645	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21645	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21645	3	also	also	RB
18637	21645	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21645	5	White	White	NNP
18637	21645	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21645	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21645	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21645	9	Ragen	Ragen	NNP
18637	21645	10	,	,	,
18637	21645	11	324	324	CD
18637	21645	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21645	13	760	760	CD
18637	21645	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21645	15	1945	1945	CD
18637	21645	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21645	17	.	.	.
18637	21646	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21646	2	833	833	CD
18637	21646	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21646	4	326	326	CD
18637	21646	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21646	6	271	271	CD
18637	21646	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21646	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	21646	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21646	10	.	.	.
18637	21647	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21647	2	834	834	CD
18637	21647	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21647	4	324	324	CD
18637	21647	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21647	6	42	42	CD
18637	21647	7	,	,	,
18637	21647	8	46	46	CD
18637	21647	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21647	10	1945	1945	CD
18637	21647	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21647	12	.	.	.
18637	21648	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21648	2	835	835	CD
18637	21648	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21648	4	324	324	CD
18637	21648	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21648	6	786	786	CD
18637	21648	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21648	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	21648	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21648	10	.	.	.
18637	21649	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21649	2	836	836	CD
18637	21649	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21649	4	327	327	CD
18637	21649	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21649	6	82	82	CD
18637	21649	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21649	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	21649	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21649	10	.	.	.
18637	21650	1	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21650	2	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21650	3	and	and	CC
18637	21650	4	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21650	5	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	21650	6	,	,	,
18637	21650	7	the	the	DT
18637	21650	8	former	former	JJ
18637	21650	9	contending	contending	NN
18637	21650	10	that	that	IN
18637	21650	11	"	"	``
18637	21650	12	the	the	DT
18637	21650	13	right	right	NN
18637	21650	14	to	to	TO
18637	21650	15	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	21650	16	means	mean	VBZ
18637	21650	17	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	21650	18	unless	unless	IN
18637	21650	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21650	20	means	mean	VBZ
18637	21650	21	the	the	DT
18637	21650	22	right	right	NN
18637	21650	23	to	to	TO
18637	21650	24	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	21650	25	at	at	IN
18637	21650	26	each	each	DT
18637	21650	27	and	and	CC
18637	21650	28	every	every	DT
18637	21650	29	step	step	NN
18637	21650	30	in	in	IN
18637	21650	31	a	a	DT
18637	21650	32	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	21650	33	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	21650	34	.	.	.
18637	21650	35	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	21650	36	.	.	.
18637	21651	1	89	89	CD
18637	21651	2	.	.	.
18637	21652	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21652	2	837	837	CD
18637	21652	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21652	4	329	329	CD
18637	21652	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21652	6	173	173	CD
18637	21652	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21652	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	21652	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21652	10	.	.	.
18637	21653	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21653	2	838	838	CD
18637	21653	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21653	4	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	21653	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21653	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21653	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21653	8	Olson	Olson	NNP
18637	21653	9	,	,	,
18637	21653	10	324	324	CD
18637	21653	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21653	12	786	786	CD
18637	21653	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21653	14	1945	1945	CD
18637	21653	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21653	16	,	,	,
18637	21653	17	was	be	VBD
18637	21653	18	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	21653	19	on	on	IN
18637	21653	20	the	the	DT
18637	21653	21	ground	ground	NN
18637	21653	22	that	that	IN
18637	21653	23	the	the	DT
18637	21653	24	record	record	NN
18637	21653	25	in	in	IN
18637	21653	26	the	the	DT
18637	21653	27	older	old	JJR
18637	21653	28	case	case	NN
18637	21653	29	contained	contain	VBD
18637	21653	30	specific	specific	JJ
18637	21653	31	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	21653	32	bearing	bear	VBG
18637	21653	33	on	on	IN
18637	21653	34	the	the	DT
18637	21653	35	disabilities	disability	NNS
18637	21653	36	of	of	IN
18637	21653	37	the	the	DT
18637	21653	38	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21653	39	to	to	TO
18637	21653	40	stand	stand	VB
18637	21653	41	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	21653	42	without	without	IN
18637	21653	43	the	the	DT
18637	21653	44	aid	aid	NN
18637	21653	45	of	of	IN
18637	21653	46	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21653	47	and	and	CC
18637	21653	48	the	the	DT
18637	21653	49	complete	complete	JJ
18637	21653	50	absence	absence	NN
18637	21653	51	of	of	IN
18637	21653	52	any	any	DT
18637	21653	53	uncontested	uncontested	JJ
18637	21653	54	finding	finding	NN
18637	21653	55	,	,	,
18637	21653	56	as	as	IN
18637	21653	57	in	in	IN
18637	21653	58	the	the	DT
18637	21653	59	instant	instant	JJ
18637	21653	60	case	case	NN
18637	21653	61	,	,	,
18637	21653	62	of	of	IN
18637	21653	63	an	an	DT
18637	21653	64	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
18637	21653	65	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	21653	66	of	of	IN
18637	21653	67	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21653	68	.	.	.
18637	21654	1	Dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	21654	2	for	for	IN
18637	21654	3	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21654	4	and	and	CC
18637	21654	5	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21654	6	Black	Black	NNP
18637	21654	7	and	and	CC
18637	21654	8	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21654	9	,	,	,
18637	21654	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21654	11	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	21654	12	declared	declare	VBD
18637	21654	13	that	that	IN
18637	21654	14	,	,	,
18637	21654	15	under	under	IN
18637	21654	16	the	the	DT
18637	21654	17	authority	authority	NN
18637	21654	18	of	of	IN
18637	21654	19	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	21654	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21654	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21654	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21654	23	Kaiser	Kaiser	NNP
18637	21654	24	,	,	,
18637	21654	25	323	323	CD
18637	21654	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21654	27	471	471	CD
18637	21654	28	,	,	,
18637	21654	29	476	476	CD
18637	21654	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21654	31	1945	1945	CD
18637	21654	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21654	33	,	,	,
18637	21654	34	"	"	``
18637	21654	35	if	if	IN
18637	21654	36	*	*	NFP
18637	21654	37	*	*	NFP
18637	21654	38	*	*	NFP
18637	21654	39	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21654	40	the	the	DT
18637	21654	41	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21654	42	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	21654	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	21654	44	not	not	RB
18637	21654	45	capable	capable	JJ
18637	21654	46	of	of	IN
18637	21654	47	making	make	VBG
18637	21654	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21654	49	own	own	JJ
18637	21654	50	defense	defense	NN
18637	21654	51	,	,	,
18637	21654	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21654	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	21654	54	the	the	DT
18637	21654	55	duty	duty	NN
18637	21654	56	of	of	IN
18637	21654	57	the	the	DT
18637	21654	58	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21654	59	,	,	,
18637	21654	60	at	at	IN
18637	21654	61	least	least	JJS
18637	21654	62	in	in	IN
18637	21654	63	capital	capital	NN
18637	21654	64	cases	case	NNS
18637	21654	65	,	,	,
18637	21654	66	to	to	TO
18637	21654	67	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	21654	68	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21654	69	,	,	,
18637	21654	70	whether	whether	IN
18637	21654	71	requested	request	VBD
18637	21654	72	so	so	RB
18637	21654	73	to	to	TO
18637	21654	74	do	do	VB
18637	21654	75	or	or	CC
18637	21654	76	not	not	RB
18637	21654	77	.	.	.
18637	21654	78	"	"	''
18637	21655	1	--329	--329	:
18637	21655	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21655	3	173	173	CD
18637	21655	4	,	,	,
18637	21655	5	181	181	CD
18637	21655	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21655	7	1946	1946	CD
18637	21655	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21655	9	.	.	.
18637	21656	1	In	in	IN
18637	21656	2	a	a	DT
18637	21656	3	separate	separate	JJ
18637	21656	4	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	21656	5	,	,	,
18637	21656	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21656	7	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21656	8	observed	observe	VBD
18637	21656	9	that	that	IN
18637	21656	10	while	while	IN
18637	21656	11	"	"	``
18637	21656	12	legal	legal	JJ
18637	21656	13	technicalities	technicality	NNS
18637	21656	14	doubtless	doubtless	RB
18637	21656	15	afford	afford	VB
18637	21656	16	justification	justification	NN
18637	21656	17	for	for	IN
18637	21656	18	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21656	19	pretense	pretense	NN
18637	21656	20	of	of	IN
18637	21656	21	ignoring	ignore	VBG
18637	21656	22	plain	plain	JJ
18637	21656	23	facts	fact	NNS
18637	21656	24	before	before	IN
18637	21656	25	us	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21656	26	,	,	,
18637	21656	27	"	"	''
18637	21656	28	facts	fact	NNS
18637	21656	29	which	which	WDT
18637	21656	30	emphasize	emphasize	VBP
18637	21656	31	the	the	DT
18637	21656	32	absence	absence	NN
18637	21656	33	of	of	IN
18637	21656	34	any	any	DT
18637	21656	35	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
18637	21656	36	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	21656	37	of	of	IN
18637	21656	38	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21656	39	,	,	,
18637	21656	40	"	"	''
18637	21656	41	the	the	DT
18637	21656	42	result	result	NN
18637	21656	43	certainly	certainly	RB
18637	21656	44	does	do	VBZ
18637	21656	45	not	not	RB
18637	21656	46	enhance	enhance	VB
18637	21656	47	the	the	DT
18637	21656	48	high	high	JJ
18637	21656	49	traditions	tradition	NNS
18637	21656	50	of	of	IN
18637	21656	51	the	the	DT
18637	21656	52	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	21656	53	process	process	NN
18637	21656	54	.	.	.
18637	21656	55	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	21656	56	.	.	.
18637	21657	1	183	183	CD
18637	21657	2	.	.	.
18637	21658	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21658	2	839	839	CD
18637	21658	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21658	4	329	329	CD
18637	21658	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21658	6	663	663	CD
18637	21658	7	,	,	,
18637	21658	8	665	665	CD
18637	21658	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21658	10	1947	1947	CD
18637	21658	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21658	12	.	.	.
18637	21659	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21659	2	840	840	CD
18637	21659	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21659	4	332	332	CD
18637	21659	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21659	6	134	134	CD
18637	21659	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21659	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	21659	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21659	10	.	.	.
18637	21660	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21660	2	841	841	CD
18637	21660	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21660	4	332	332	CD
18637	21660	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21660	6	145	145	CD
18637	21660	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21660	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	21660	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21660	10	.	.	.
18637	21661	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21661	2	842	842	CD
18637	21661	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21661	4	332	332	CD
18637	21661	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21661	6	134	134	CD
18637	21661	7	,	,	,
18637	21661	8	136	136	CD
18637	21661	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21661	10	1947).--Acknowledging	1947).--acknowledge	VBG
18637	21661	11	that	that	IN
18637	21661	12	the	the	DT
18637	21661	13	decision	decision	NN
18637	21661	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	21661	15	in	in	IN
18637	21661	16	line	line	NN
18637	21661	17	with	with	IN
18637	21661	18	the	the	DT
18637	21661	19	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	21661	20	of	of	IN
18637	21661	21	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	21661	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21661	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	21661	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21661	25	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	21661	26	,	,	,
18637	21661	27	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21661	28	Black	Black	NNP
18637	21661	29	,	,	,
18637	21661	30	who	who	WP
18637	21661	31	was	be	VBD
18637	21661	32	joined	join	VBN
18637	21661	33	by	by	IN
18637	21661	34	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21661	35	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	21661	36	,	,	,
18637	21661	37	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21661	38	,	,	,
18637	21661	39	and	and	CC
18637	21661	40	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21661	41	,	,	,
18637	21661	42	lamented	lament	VBD
18637	21661	43	that	that	IN
18637	21661	44	the	the	DT
18637	21661	45	latter	latter	NN
18637	21661	46	was	be	VBD
18637	21661	47	a	a	DT
18637	21661	48	"	"	``
18637	21661	49	kind	kind	NN
18637	21661	50	of	of	IN
18637	21661	51	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	21661	52	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21661	53	which	which	WDT
18637	21661	54	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21661	55	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21661	56	had	have	VBD
18637	21661	57	hoped	hope	VBN
18637	21661	58	that	that	IN
18637	21661	59	the	the	DT
18637	21661	60	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21661	61	would	would	MD
18637	21661	62	not	not	RB
18637	21661	63	perpetuate	perpetuate	VB
18637	21661	64	.	.	.
18637	21661	65	"	"	''
18637	21662	1	Complaining	complain	VBG
18637	21662	2	of	of	IN
18637	21662	3	the	the	DT
18637	21662	4	loss	loss	NN
18637	21662	5	of	of	IN
18637	21662	6	certainty	certainty	NN
18637	21662	7	occasioned	occasion	VBN
18637	21662	8	by	by	IN
18637	21662	9	the	the	DT
18637	21662	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21662	11	's	's	POS
18637	21662	12	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	21662	13	to	to	TO
18637	21662	14	read	read	VB
18637	21662	15	into	into	IN
18637	21662	16	the	the	DT
18637	21662	17	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21662	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21662	19	the	the	DT
18637	21662	20	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	21662	21	right	right	NN
18637	21662	22	to	to	TO
18637	21662	23	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21662	24	set	set	VBN
18637	21662	25	out	out	RP
18637	21662	26	in	in	IN
18637	21662	27	the	the	DT
18637	21662	28	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	21662	29	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21662	30	,	,	,
18637	21662	31	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21662	32	Black	Black	NNP
18637	21662	33	contends	contend	VBZ
18637	21662	34	that	that	IN
18637	21662	35	the	the	DT
18637	21662	36	fair	fair	JJ
18637	21662	37	trial	trial	NN
18637	21662	38	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	21662	39	as	as	IN
18637	21662	40	enunciated	enunciate	VBN
18637	21662	41	in	in	IN
18637	21662	42	this	this	DT
18637	21662	43	and	and	CC
18637	21662	44	in	in	IN
18637	21662	45	the	the	DT
18637	21662	46	Adamson	Adamson	NNP
18637	21662	47	_	_	NNP
18637	21662	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	21662	49	_	_	NNP
18637	21662	50	California	California	NNP
18637	21662	51	case	case	NN
18637	21662	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21662	53	_	_	NNP
18637	21662	54	see	see	VBP
18637	21662	55	_	_	NNP
18637	21662	56	p.	p.	NN
18637	21662	57	1115	1115	CD
18637	21662	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21662	59	decided	decide	VBD
18637	21662	60	on	on	IN
18637	21662	61	the	the	DT
18637	21662	62	same	same	JJ
18637	21662	63	day	day	NN
18637	21662	64	is	be	VBZ
18637	21662	65	"	"	``
18637	21662	66	another	another	DT
18637	21662	67	example	example	NN
18637	21662	68	of	of	IN
18637	21662	69	the	the	DT
18637	21662	70	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	21662	71	which	which	WDT
18637	21662	72	can	can	MD
18637	21662	73	be	be	VB
18637	21662	74	produced	produce	VBN
18637	21662	75	by	by	IN
18637	21662	76	the	the	DT
18637	21662	77	substitution	substitution	NN
18637	21662	78	of	of	IN
18637	21662	79	this	this	DT
18637	21662	80	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21662	81	's	's	POS
18637	21662	82	day	day	NN
18637	21662	83	-	-	HYPH
18637	21662	84	to	to	IN
18637	21662	85	-	-	HYPH
18637	21662	86	day	day	NN
18637	21662	87	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21662	88	of	of	IN
18637	21662	89	what	what	WP
18637	21662	90	kind	kind	NN
18637	21662	91	of	of	IN
18637	21662	92	trial	trial	NN
18637	21662	93	is	be	VBZ
18637	21662	94	fair	fair	JJ
18637	21662	95	and	and	CC
18637	21662	96	decent	decent	JJ
18637	21662	97	for	for	IN
18637	21662	98	the	the	DT
18637	21662	99	kind	kind	NN
18637	21662	100	of	of	IN
18637	21662	101	trial	trial	NN
18637	21662	102	which	which	WDT
18637	21662	103	the	the	DT
18637	21662	104	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	21662	105	of	of	IN
18637	21662	106	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	21662	107	guarantees	guarantee	NNS
18637	21662	108	.	.	.
18637	21662	109	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	21662	110	.	.	.
18637	21663	1	139	139	CD
18637	21663	2	,	,	,
18637	21663	3	140.--In	140.--in	CD
18637	21663	4	a	a	DT
18637	21663	5	second	second	JJ
18637	21663	6	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	21663	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21663	8	meriting	merit	VBG
18637	21663	9	the	the	DT
18637	21663	10	concurrence	concurrence	NN
18637	21663	11	of	of	IN
18637	21663	12	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21663	13	Black	Black	NNP
18637	21663	14	,	,	,
18637	21663	15	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	21663	16	,	,	,
18637	21663	17	and	and	CC
18637	21663	18	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21663	19	,	,	,
18637	21663	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21663	21	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21663	22	,	,	,
18637	21663	23	who	who	WP
18637	21663	24	also	also	RB
18637	21663	25	is	be	VBZ
18637	21663	26	of	of	IN
18637	21663	27	the	the	DT
18637	21663	28	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21663	29	that	that	IN
18637	21663	30	the	the	DT
18637	21663	31	absolute	absolute	JJ
18637	21663	32	right	right	NN
18637	21663	33	to	to	TO
18637	21663	34	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	21663	35	granted	grant	VBN
18637	21663	36	by	by	IN
18637	21663	37	the	the	DT
18637	21663	38	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	21663	39	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21663	40	should	should	MD
18637	21663	41	be	be	VB
18637	21663	42	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
18637	21663	43	in	in	IN
18637	21663	44	State	State	NNP
18637	21663	45	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	21663	46	trials	trial	NNS
18637	21663	47	,	,	,
18637	21663	48	insisted	insist	VBD
18637	21663	49	that	that	IN
18637	21663	50	even	even	RB
18637	21663	51	under	under	IN
18637	21663	52	the	the	DT
18637	21663	53	fair	fair	JJ
18637	21663	54	trial	trial	NN
18637	21663	55	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	21663	56	,	,	,
18637	21663	57	the	the	DT
18637	21663	58	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21663	59	had	have	VBD
18637	21663	60	not	not	RB
18637	21663	61	been	be	VBN
18637	21663	62	accorded	accord	VBN
18637	21663	63	due	due	JJ
18637	21663	64	process	process	NN
18637	21663	65	.	.	.
18637	21664	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21664	2	843	843	CD
18637	21664	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21664	4	332	332	CD
18637	21664	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21664	6	145	145	CD
18637	21664	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21664	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	21664	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21664	10	.	.	.
18637	21665	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21665	2	844	844	CD
18637	21665	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21665	4	332	332	CD
18637	21665	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21665	6	561	561	CD
18637	21665	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21665	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	21665	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21665	10	.	.	.
18637	21666	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21666	2	845	845	CD
18637	21666	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21666	4	332	332	CD
18637	21666	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21666	6	596	596	CD
18637	21666	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21666	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	21666	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21666	10	.	.	.
18637	21667	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21667	2	846	846	CD
18637	21667	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21667	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21667	5	See	See	NNP
18637	21667	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21667	7	p.	p.	NN
18637	21667	8	1103	1103	CD
18637	21667	9	.	.	.
18637	21668	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21668	2	847	847	CD
18637	21668	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21668	4	333	333	CD
18637	21668	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21668	6	640	640	CD
18637	21668	7	,	,	,
18637	21668	8	678	678	CD
18637	21668	9	,	,	,
18637	21668	10	680	680	CD
18637	21668	11	-	-	SYM
18637	21668	12	682	682	CD
18637	21668	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21668	14	1948).--As	1948).--as	CD
18637	21668	15	against	against	IN
18637	21668	16	the	the	DT
18637	21668	17	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	21668	18	of	of	IN
18637	21668	19	the	the	DT
18637	21668	20	majority	majority	NN
18637	21668	21	that	that	WDT
18637	21668	22	the	the	DT
18637	21668	23	due	due	JJ
18637	21668	24	process	process	NN
18637	21668	25	clause	clause	NN
18637	21668	26	of	of	IN
18637	21668	27	the	the	DT
18637	21668	28	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21668	29	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21668	30	does	do	VBZ
18637	21668	31	not	not	RB
18637	21668	32	of	of	IN
18637	21668	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21668	34	own	own	JJ
18637	21668	35	force	force	NN
18637	21668	36	require	require	VBP
18637	21668	37	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	21668	38	of	of	IN
18637	21668	39	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21668	40	for	for	IN
18637	21668	41	one	one	CD
18637	21668	42	simply	simply	RB
18637	21668	43	because	because	IN
18637	21668	44	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21668	45	would	would	MD
18637	21668	46	have	have	VB
18637	21668	47	a	a	DT
18637	21668	48	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	21668	49	right	right	NN
18637	21668	50	to	to	IN
18637	21668	51	the	the	DT
18637	21668	52	assistance	assistance	NN
18637	21668	53	of	of	IN
18637	21668	54	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21668	55	in	in	IN
18637	21668	56	a	a	DT
18637	21668	57	comparable	comparable	JJ
18637	21668	58	federal	federal	JJ
18637	21668	59	case	case	NN
18637	21668	60	,	,	,
18637	21668	61	the	the	DT
18637	21668	62	minority	minority	NN
18637	21668	63	,	,	,
18637	21668	64	consisting	consist	VBG
18637	21668	65	of	of	IN
18637	21668	66	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21668	67	Black	Black	NNP
18637	21668	68	,	,	,
18637	21668	69	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21668	70	,	,	,
18637	21668	71	and	and	CC
18637	21668	72	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21668	73	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	21668	74	through	through	IN
18637	21668	75	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21668	76	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	21668	77	,	,	,
18637	21668	78	declared	declare	VBD
18637	21668	79	that	that	IN
18637	21668	80	"	"	``
18637	21668	81	the	the	DT
18637	21668	82	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	21668	83	of	of	IN
18637	21668	84	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	21668	85	is	be	VBZ
18637	21668	86	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	21668	87	to	to	IN
18637	21668	88	all	all	DT
18637	21668	89	courts	court	NNS
18637	21668	90	at	at	IN
18637	21668	91	all	all	DT
18637	21668	92	times	time	NNS
18637	21668	93	"	"	''
18637	21668	94	;	;	,
18637	21668	95	for	for	IN
18637	21668	96	,	,	,
18637	21668	97	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	21668	98	,	,	,
18637	21668	99	"	"	''
18637	21668	100	of	of	IN
18637	21668	101	what	what	WDT
18637	21668	102	value	value	NN
18637	21668	103	is	be	VBZ
18637	21668	104	the	the	DT
18637	21668	105	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	21668	106	guarantee	guarantee	NN
18637	21668	107	of	of	IN
18637	21668	108	a	a	DT
18637	21668	109	fair	fair	JJ
18637	21668	110	trial	trial	NN
18637	21668	111	if	if	IN
18637	21668	112	an	an	DT
18637	21668	113	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21668	114	does	do	VBZ
18637	21668	115	not	not	RB
18637	21668	116	have	have	VB
18637	21668	117	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21668	118	to	to	TO
18637	21668	119	advise	advise	VB
18637	21668	120	and	and	CC
18637	21668	121	defend	defend	VB
18637	21668	122	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21668	123	.	.	.
18637	21668	124	"	"	''
18637	21669	1	Noting	note	VBG
18637	21669	2	that	that	IN
18637	21669	3	all	all	DT
18637	21669	4	members	member	NNS
18637	21669	5	of	of	IN
18637	21669	6	the	the	DT
18637	21669	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21669	8	were	be	VBD
18637	21669	9	in	in	IN
18637	21669	10	accord	accord	NN
18637	21669	11	on	on	IN
18637	21669	12	the	the	DT
18637	21669	13	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	21669	14	of	of	IN
18637	21669	15	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21669	16	in	in	IN
18637	21669	17	capital	capital	NN
18637	21669	18	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	21669	19	,	,	,
18637	21669	20	the	the	DT
18637	21669	21	minority	minority	NN
18637	21669	22	contended	contend	VBD
18637	21669	23	that	that	IN
18637	21669	24	the	the	DT
18637	21669	25	considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	21669	26	inducing	induce	VBG
18637	21669	27	such	such	JJ
18637	21669	28	unanimity	unanimity	NN
18637	21669	29	were	be	VBD
18637	21669	30	"	"	``
18637	21669	31	equally	equally	RB
18637	21669	32	germane	germane	NN
18637	21669	33	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21669	34	in	in	IN
18637	21669	35	noncapital	noncapital	JJ
18637	21669	36	cases	case	NNS
18637	21669	37	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21669	38	where	where	WRB
18637	21669	39	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	21669	40	rather	rather	RB
18637	21669	41	than	than	IN
18637	21669	42	life	life	NN
18637	21669	43	hangs	hang	NNS
18637	21669	44	in	in	IN
18637	21669	45	the	the	DT
18637	21669	46	balance	balance	NN
18637	21669	47	.	.	.
18637	21669	48	"	"	''
18637	21670	1	Conceding	concede	VBG
18637	21670	2	that	that	IN
18637	21670	3	"	"	``
18637	21670	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21670	5	might	may	MD
18637	21670	6	not	not	RB
18637	21670	7	be	be	VB
18637	21670	8	nonsense	nonsense	NN
18637	21670	9	to	to	TO
18637	21670	10	draw	draw	VB
18637	21670	11	the	the	DT
18637	21670	12	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	21670	13	_	_	NNP
18637	21670	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	21670	15	_	_	NNP
18637	21670	16	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	21670	17	line	line	NN
18637	21670	18	somewhere	somewhere	RB
18637	21670	19	between	between	IN
18637	21670	20	that	that	DT
18637	21670	21	case	case	NN
18637	21670	22	and	and	CC
18637	21670	23	the	the	DT
18637	21670	24	case	case	NN
18637	21670	25	of	of	IN
18637	21670	26	one	one	CD
18637	21670	27	charged	charge	VBN
18637	21670	28	with	with	IN
18637	21670	29	violation	violation	NN
18637	21670	30	of	of	IN
18637	21670	31	a	a	DT
18637	21670	32	parking	parking	NN
18637	21670	33	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	21670	34	,	,	,
18637	21670	35	and	and	CC
18637	21670	36	to	to	TO
18637	21670	37	say	say	VB
18637	21670	38	the	the	DT
18637	21670	39	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21670	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	21670	41	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	21670	42	to	to	TO
18637	21670	43	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	21670	44	in	in	IN
18637	21670	45	the	the	DT
18637	21670	46	former	former	JJ
18637	21670	47	but	but	CC
18637	21670	48	not	not	RB
18637	21670	49	in	in	IN
18637	21670	50	the	the	DT
18637	21670	51	latter	latter	JJ
18637	21670	52	,	,	,
18637	21670	53	"	"	''
18637	21670	54	the	the	DT
18637	21670	55	minority	minority	NN
18637	21670	56	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	21670	57	as	as	IN
18637	21670	58	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	21670	59	:	:	:
18637	21670	60	"	"	``
18637	21670	61	*	*	NFP
18637	21670	62	*	*	NFP
18637	21670	63	*	*	NFP
18637	21670	64	to	to	TO
18637	21670	65	draw	draw	VB
18637	21670	66	the	the	DT
18637	21670	67	line	line	NN
18637	21670	68	between	between	IN
18637	21670	69	this	this	DT
18637	21670	70	case	case	NN
18637	21670	71	and	and	CC
18637	21670	72	cases	case	NNS
18637	21670	73	where	where	WRB
18637	21670	74	the	the	DT
18637	21670	75	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	21670	76	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	21670	77	is	be	VBZ
18637	21670	78	death	death	NN
18637	21670	79	is	be	VBZ
18637	21670	80	to	to	TO
18637	21670	81	make	make	VB
18637	21670	82	a	a	DT
18637	21670	83	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	21670	84	which	which	WDT
18637	21670	85	makes	make	VBZ
18637	21670	86	no	no	DT
18637	21670	87	sense	sense	NN
18637	21670	88	in	in	IN
18637	21670	89	terms	term	NNS
18637	21670	90	of	of	IN
18637	21670	91	the	the	DT
18637	21670	92	absence	absence	NN
18637	21670	93	or	or	CC
18637	21670	94	presence	presence	NN
18637	21670	95	of	of	IN
18637	21670	96	need	need	NN
18637	21670	97	for	for	IN
18637	21670	98	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21670	99	.	.	.
18637	21671	1	Yet	yet	CC
18637	21671	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21671	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	21671	4	the	the	DT
18637	21671	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21671	6	need	need	NN
18637	21671	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21671	8	for	for	IN
18637	21671	9	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21671	10	that	that	WDT
18637	21671	11	establishes	establish	VBZ
18637	21671	12	the	the	DT
18637	21671	13	real	real	JJ
18637	21671	14	standard	standard	NN
18637	21671	15	for	for	IN
18637	21671	16	determining	determine	VBG
18637	21671	17	whether	whether	IN
18637	21671	18	the	the	DT
18637	21671	19	lack	lack	NN
18637	21671	20	of	of	IN
18637	21671	21	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21671	22	rendered	render	VBD
18637	21671	23	the	the	DT
18637	21671	24	trial	trial	NN
18637	21671	25	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	21671	26	.	.	.
18637	21672	1	And	and	CC
18637	21672	2	the	the	DT
18637	21672	3	need	need	NN
18637	21672	4	for	for	IN
18637	21672	5	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21672	6	,	,	,
18637	21672	7	even	even	RB
18637	21672	8	by	by	IN
18637	21672	9	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	21672	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21672	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	21672	12	_	_	NNP
18637	21672	13	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	21672	14	standards	standard	NNS
18637	21672	15	,	,	,
18637	21672	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	21672	17	not	not	RB
18637	21672	18	determined	determine	VBN
18637	21672	19	by	by	IN
18637	21672	20	the	the	DT
18637	21672	21	complexities	complexity	NNS
18637	21672	22	of	of	IN
18637	21672	23	the	the	DT
18637	21672	24	individual	individual	JJ
18637	21672	25	case	case	NN
18637	21672	26	or	or	CC
18637	21672	27	the	the	DT
18637	21672	28	ability	ability	NN
18637	21672	29	of	of	IN
18637	21672	30	the	the	DT
18637	21672	31	particular	particular	JJ
18637	21672	32	person	person	NN
18637	21672	33	who	who	WP
18637	21672	34	stands	stand	VBZ
18637	21672	35	as	as	IN
18637	21672	36	an	an	DT
18637	21672	37	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21672	38	before	before	IN
18637	21672	39	the	the	DT
18637	21672	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21672	41	.	.	.
18637	21673	1	That	that	DT
18637	21673	2	need	need	NN
18637	21673	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	21673	4	measured	measure	VBN
18637	21673	5	by	by	IN
18637	21673	6	the	the	DT
18637	21673	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21673	8	nature	nature	NN
18637	21673	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21673	10	of	of	IN
18637	21673	11	the	the	DT
18637	21673	12	_	_	NNP
18637	21673	13	charge	charge	NN
18637	21673	14	_	_	NNP
18637	21673	15	and	and	CC
18637	21673	16	the	the	DT
18637	21673	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21673	18	ability	ability	NN
18637	21673	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21673	20	of	of	IN
18637	21673	21	the	the	DT
18637	21673	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21673	23	average	average	JJ
18637	21673	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21673	25	man	man	NN
18637	21673	26	to	to	TO
18637	21673	27	face	face	VB
18637	21673	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21673	29	alone	alone	RB
18637	21673	30	,	,	,
18637	21673	31	unaided	unaide	VBN
18637	21673	32	by	by	IN
18637	21673	33	an	an	DT
18637	21673	34	expert	expert	NN
18637	21673	35	in	in	IN
18637	21673	36	the	the	DT
18637	21673	37	law	law	NN
18637	21673	38	.	.	.
18637	21673	39	"	"	''
18637	21674	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21674	2	848	848	CD
18637	21674	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21674	4	334	334	CD
18637	21674	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21674	6	672	672	CD
18637	21674	7	,	,	,
18637	21674	8	683	683	CD
18637	21674	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21674	10	1948	1948	CD
18637	21674	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21674	12	.	.	.
18637	21675	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21675	2	849	849	CD
18637	21675	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21675	4	334	334	CD
18637	21675	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21675	6	728	728	CD
18637	21675	7	,	,	,
18637	21675	8	730	730	CD
18637	21675	9	,	,	,
18637	21675	10	731	731	CD
18637	21675	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21675	12	1948	1948	CD
18637	21675	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21675	14	.	.	.
18637	21676	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21676	2	850	850	CD
18637	21676	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21676	4	334	334	CD
18637	21676	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21676	6	736	736	CD
18637	21676	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21676	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	21676	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21676	10	.	.	.
18637	21677	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21677	2	851	851	CD
18637	21677	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21677	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21677	5	.	.	.
18637	21678	1	740.--The	740.--the	CD
18637	21678	2	majority	majority	NN
18637	21678	3	also	also	RB
18637	21678	4	observed	observe	VBD
18637	21678	5	that	that	IN
18637	21678	6	"	"	``
18637	21678	7	trial	trial	NN
18637	21678	8	court	court	NN
18637	21678	9	's	's	POS
18637	21678	10	facetiousness	facetiousness	NN
18637	21678	11	casts	cast	VBZ
18637	21678	12	a	a	DT
18637	21678	13	somewhat	somewhat	RB
18637	21678	14	somber	somber	JJ
18637	21678	15	reflection	reflection	NN
18637	21678	16	on	on	IN
18637	21678	17	the	the	DT
18637	21678	18	fairness	fairness	NN
18637	21678	19	of	of	IN
18637	21678	20	the	the	DT
18637	21678	21	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	21678	22	*	*	NFP
18637	21678	23	*	*	NFP
18637	21678	24	*	*	NFP
18637	21678	25	"	"	''
18637	21678	26	Although	although	IN
18637	21678	27	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	21678	28	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21678	29	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	21678	30	and	and	CC
18637	21678	31	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21678	32	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	21678	33	and	and	CC
18637	21678	34	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	21678	35	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	21678	36	without	without	IN
18637	21678	37	an	an	DT
18637	21678	38	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21678	39	in	in	IN
18637	21678	40	Townsend	Townsend	NNP
18637	21678	41	_	_	NNP
18637	21678	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	21678	43	_	_	NNP
18637	21678	44	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	21678	45	,	,	,
18637	21678	46	four	four	CD
18637	21678	47	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21678	48	,	,	,
18637	21678	49	Black	Black	NNP
18637	21678	50	,	,	,
18637	21678	51	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	21678	52	,	,	,
18637	21678	53	and	and	CC
18637	21678	54	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21678	55	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	21678	56	through	through	IN
18637	21678	57	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21678	58	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21678	59	filed	file	VBD
18637	21678	60	a	a	DT
18637	21678	61	vigorous	vigorous	JJ
18637	21678	62	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	21678	63	in	in	IN
18637	21678	64	Gryger	Gryger	NNP
18637	21678	65	_	_	NNP
18637	21678	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	21678	67	_	_	NNP
18637	21678	68	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	21678	69	,	,	,
18637	21678	70	334	334	CD
18637	21678	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21678	72	728	728	CD
18637	21678	73	,	,	,
18637	21678	74	733	733	CD
18637	21678	75	,	,	,
18637	21678	76	736	736	CD
18637	21678	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21678	78	1948	1948	CD
18637	21678	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21678	80	.	.	.
18637	21679	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21679	2	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21679	3	declared	declare	VBD
18637	21679	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21679	5	inability	inability	NN
18637	21679	6	to	to	IN
18637	21679	7	"	"	``
18637	21679	8	square	square	JJ
18637	21679	9	*	*	NFP
18637	21679	10	*	*	NFP
18637	21679	11	*	*	NFP
18637	21679	12	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21679	13	this	this	DT
18637	21679	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21679	15	decision	decision	NN
18637	21679	16	in	in	IN
18637	21679	17	this	this	DT
18637	21679	18	case	case	NN
18637	21679	19	with	with	IN
18637	21679	20	that	that	DT
18637	21679	21	made	make	VBN
18637	21679	22	in	in	IN
18637	21679	23	Townsend	Townsend	NNP
18637	21679	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21679	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	21679	26	_	_	NNP
18637	21679	27	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	21679	28	.	.	.
18637	21680	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21680	2	find	find	VBP
18637	21680	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21680	4	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	21680	5	to	to	TO
18637	21680	6	comprehend	comprehend	VB
18637	21680	7	that	that	IN
18637	21680	8	the	the	DT
18637	21680	9	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21680	10	trial	trial	NN
18637	21680	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21680	12	court	court	NN
18637	21680	13	's	's	POS
18637	21680	14	misreading	misreading	NN
18637	21680	15	or	or	CC
18637	21680	16	misinformation	misinformation	NN
18637	21680	17	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	21680	18	the	the	DT
18637	21680	19	facts	fact	NNS
18637	21680	20	of	of	IN
18637	21680	21	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21680	22	the	the	DT
18637	21680	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21680	24	record	record	NN
18637	21680	25	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21680	26	Townsend	Townsend	NNP
18637	21680	27	_	_	NNP
18637	21680	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	21680	29	_	_	NNP
18637	21680	30	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	21680	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21680	32	vital	vital	JJ
18637	21680	33	to	to	IN
18637	21680	34	the	the	DT
18637	21680	35	proper	proper	JJ
18637	21680	36	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	21680	37	of	of	IN
18637	21680	38	the	the	DT
18637	21680	39	sentencing	sentencing	NN
18637	21680	40	function	function	NN
18637	21680	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	21680	42	prejudicial	prejudicial	JJ
18637	21680	43	*	*	NFP
18637	21680	44	*	*	NFP
18637	21680	45	*	*	NFP
18637	21680	46	,	,	,
18637	21680	47	but	but	CC
18637	21680	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21680	49	misreading	misreading	NN
18637	21680	50	or	or	CC
18637	21680	51	misconception	misconception	NN
18637	21680	52	of	of	IN
18637	21680	53	the	the	DT
18637	21680	54	controlling	control	VBG
18637	21680	55	statute	statute	NN
18637	21680	56	,	,	,
18637	21680	57	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21680	58	Gryger	Gryger	NNP
18637	21680	59	_	_	NNP
18637	21680	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	21680	61	_	_	NNP
18637	21680	62	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	21680	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21680	64	in	in	IN
18637	21680	65	a	a	DT
18637	21680	66	matter	matter	NN
18637	21680	67	so	so	RB
18637	21680	68	vital	vital	JJ
18637	21680	69	as	as	IN
18637	21680	70	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	21680	71	mandatory	mandatory	JJ
18637	21680	72	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	21680	73	or	or	CC
18637	21680	74	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	21680	75	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	21680	76	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	21680	77	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21680	78	,	,	,
18637	21680	79	has	have	VBZ
18637	21680	80	no	no	DT
18637	21680	81	such	such	JJ
18637	21680	82	effect	effect	NN
18637	21680	83	.	.	.
18637	21681	1	Perhaps	perhaps	RB
18637	21681	2	the	the	DT
18637	21681	3	difference	difference	NN
18637	21681	4	serves	serve	VBZ
18637	21681	5	only	only	RB
18637	21681	6	to	to	TO
18637	21681	7	illustrate	illustrate	VB
18637	21681	8	how	how	WRB
18637	21681	9	capricious	capricious	JJ
18637	21681	10	are	be	VBP
18637	21681	11	the	the	DT
18637	21681	12	results	result	NNS
18637	21681	13	when	when	WRB
18637	21681	14	the	the	DT
18637	21681	15	right	right	NN
18637	21681	16	to	to	IN
18637	21681	17	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21681	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	21681	19	made	make	VBN
18637	21681	20	to	to	TO
18637	21681	21	depend	depend	VB
18637	21681	22	not	not	RB
18637	21681	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	21681	24	the	the	DT
18637	21681	25	mandate	mandate	NN
18637	21681	26	of	of	IN
18637	21681	27	the	the	DT
18637	21681	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	21681	29	,	,	,
18637	21681	30	but	but	CC
18637	21681	31	upon	upon	IN
18637	21681	32	the	the	DT
18637	21681	33	vagaries	vagary	NNS
18637	21681	34	of	of	IN
18637	21681	35	whether	whether	IN
18637	21681	36	judges	judge	NNS
18637	21681	37	,	,	,
18637	21681	38	*	*	NFP
18637	21681	39	*	*	NFP
18637	21681	40	*	*	NFP
18637	21681	41	will	will	MD
18637	21681	42	regard	regard	VB
18637	21681	43	this	this	DT
18637	21681	44	incident	incident	NN
18637	21681	45	or	or	CC
18637	21681	46	that	that	IN
18637	21681	47	in	in	IN
18637	21681	48	the	the	DT
18637	21681	49	course	course	NN
18637	21681	50	of	of	IN
18637	21681	51	particular	particular	JJ
18637	21681	52	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	21681	53	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	21681	54	as	as	IN
18637	21681	55	prejudicial	prejudicial	JJ
18637	21681	56	.	.	.
18637	21681	57	"	"	''
18637	21682	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21682	2	852	852	CD
18637	21682	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21682	4	335	335	CD
18637	21682	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21682	6	437	437	CD
18637	21682	7	,	,	,
18637	21682	8	438	438	CD
18637	21682	9	-	-	SYM
18637	21682	10	442	442	CD
18637	21682	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21682	12	1948	1948	CD
18637	21682	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21682	14	.	.	.
18637	21683	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21683	2	853	853	CD
18637	21683	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21683	4	337	337	CD
18637	21683	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21683	6	773	773	CD
18637	21683	7	,	,	,
18637	21683	8	780	780	CD
18637	21683	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21683	10	1949	1949	CD
18637	21683	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21683	12	.	.	.
18637	21684	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21684	2	854	854	CD
18637	21684	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21684	4	342	342	CD
18637	21684	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21684	6	184	184	CD
18637	21684	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21684	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	21684	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21684	10	;	;	:
18637	21684	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21684	12	See	See	NNP
18637	21684	13	also	also	RB
18637	21684	14	_	_	NNP
18637	21684	15	Per	per	IN
18637	21684	16	Curiam	Curiam	NNP
18637	21684	17	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21684	18	granting	grant	VBG
18637	21684	19	certiorari	certiorari	NN
18637	21684	20	in	in	IN
18637	21684	21	Foulke	Foulke	NNP
18637	21684	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21684	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	21684	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21684	25	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	21684	26	,	,	,
18637	21684	27	342	342	CD
18637	21684	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21684	29	881	881	CD
18637	21684	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21684	31	1951	1951	CD
18637	21684	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21684	33	.	.	.
18637	21685	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21685	2	855	855	CD
18637	21685	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21685	4	339	339	CD
18637	21685	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21685	6	660	660	CD
18637	21685	7	,	,	,
18637	21685	8	665	665	CD
18637	21685	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21685	10	1950	1950	CD
18637	21685	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21685	12	.	.	.
18637	21686	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21686	2	856	856	CD
18637	21686	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21686	4	342	342	CD
18637	21686	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21686	6	55	55	CD
18637	21686	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21686	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	21686	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21686	10	.	.	.
18637	21687	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21687	2	857	857	CD
18637	21687	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21687	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21687	5	.	.	.
18637	21688	1	64	64	CD
18637	21688	2	.	.	.
18637	21689	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21689	2	858	858	CD
18637	21689	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21689	4	335	335	CD
18637	21689	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21689	6	437	437	CD
18637	21689	7	,	,	,
18637	21689	8	440	440	CD
18637	21689	9	-	-	SYM
18637	21689	10	441	441	CD
18637	21689	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21689	12	1948	1948	CD
18637	21689	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21689	14	.	.	.
18637	21690	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21690	2	859	859	CD
18637	21690	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21690	4	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	21690	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21690	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21690	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21690	8	Olson	Olson	NNP
18637	21690	9	,	,	,
18637	21690	10	324	324	CD
18637	21690	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21690	12	786	786	CD
18637	21690	13	,	,	,
18637	21690	14	788	788	CD
18637	21690	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21690	16	789	789	CD
18637	21690	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21690	18	1945	1945	CD
18637	21690	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21690	20	.	.	.
18637	21691	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21691	2	860	860	CD
18637	21691	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21691	4	Wade	Wade	NNP
18637	21691	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21691	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21691	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21691	8	Mayo	Mayo	NNP
18637	21691	9	,	,	,
18637	21691	10	334	334	CD
18637	21691	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21691	12	672	672	CD
18637	21691	13	,	,	,
18637	21691	14	683	683	CD
18637	21691	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21691	16	684	684	CD
18637	21691	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21691	18	1948	1948	CD
18637	21691	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21691	20	;	;	:
18637	21691	21	De	De	NNP
18637	21691	22	Meerleer	Meerleer	NNP
18637	21691	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21691	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	21691	25	_	_	NNP
18637	21691	26	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	21691	27	,	,	,
18637	21691	28	329	329	CD
18637	21691	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21691	30	663	663	CD
18637	21691	31	,	,	,
18637	21691	32	664	664	CD
18637	21691	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	21691	34	665	665	CD
18637	21691	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21691	36	1947	1947	CD
18637	21691	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21691	38	;	;	:
18637	21691	39	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	21691	40	_	_	NNP
18637	21691	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	21691	42	_	_	NNP
18637	21691	43	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	21691	44	,	,	,
18637	21691	45	316	316	CD
18637	21691	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21691	47	455	455	CD
18637	21691	48	,	,	,
18637	21691	49	472	472	CD
18637	21691	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21691	51	1942	1942	CD
18637	21691	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21691	53	;	;	:
18637	21691	54	Powell	Powell	NNP
18637	21691	55	_	_	NNP
18637	21691	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	21691	57	_	_	NNP
18637	21691	58	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	21691	59	,	,	,
18637	21691	60	287	287	CD
18637	21691	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21691	62	45	45	CD
18637	21691	63	,	,	,
18637	21691	64	51	51	CD
18637	21691	65	-	-	SYM
18637	21691	66	52	52	CD
18637	21691	67	,	,	,
18637	21691	68	71	71	CD
18637	21691	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21691	70	1932	1932	CD
18637	21691	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21691	72	.	.	.
18637	21692	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21692	2	861	861	CD
18637	21692	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21692	4	Townsend	Townsend	NNP
18637	21692	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21692	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21692	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21692	8	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	21692	9	,	,	,
18637	21692	10	334	334	CD
18637	21692	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21692	12	736	736	CD
18637	21692	13	,	,	,
18637	21692	14	739	739	CD
18637	21692	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21692	16	741	741	CD
18637	21692	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21692	18	1948	1948	CD
18637	21692	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21692	20	;	;	:
18637	21692	21	De	De	NNP
18637	21692	22	Meerleer	Meerleer	NNP
18637	21692	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21692	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	21692	25	_	_	NNP
18637	21692	26	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	21692	27	,	,	,
18637	21692	28	329	329	CD
18637	21692	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21692	30	663	663	CD
18637	21692	31	,	,	,
18637	21692	32	665	665	CD
18637	21692	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21692	34	1947	1947	CD
18637	21692	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21692	36	;	;	:
18637	21692	37	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	21692	38	_	_	NNP
18637	21692	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	21692	40	_	_	NNP
18637	21692	41	O'Grady	O'Grady	NNP
18637	21692	42	,	,	,
18637	21692	43	312	312	CD
18637	21692	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21692	45	329	329	CD
18637	21692	46	,	,	,
18637	21692	47	332	332	CD
18637	21692	48	-	-	SYM
18637	21692	49	333	333	CD
18637	21692	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21692	51	1941	1941	CD
18637	21692	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21692	53	.	.	.
18637	21693	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21693	2	862	862	CD
18637	21693	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21693	4	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	21693	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21693	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21693	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21693	8	Olson	Olson	NNP
18637	21693	9	,	,	,
18637	21693	10	324	324	CD
18637	21693	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21693	12	786	786	CD
18637	21693	13	,	,	,
18637	21693	14	789	789	CD
18637	21693	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21693	16	791	791	CD
18637	21693	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21693	18	1945	1945	CD
18637	21693	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21693	20	.	.	.
18637	21694	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21694	2	863	863	CD
18637	21694	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21694	4	Gibbs	Gibbs	NNPS
18637	21694	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21694	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21694	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21694	8	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	21694	9	,	,	,
18637	21694	10	337	337	CD
18637	21694	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21694	12	773	773	CD
18637	21694	13	,	,	,
18637	21694	14	780	780	CD
18637	21694	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21694	16	781	781	CD
18637	21694	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21694	18	1949	1949	CD
18637	21694	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21694	20	.	.	.
18637	21695	1	Devotion	devotion	NN
18637	21695	2	to	to	IN
18637	21695	3	the	the	DT
18637	21695	4	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	21695	5	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	21695	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	21695	7	has	have	VBZ
18637	21695	8	also	also	RB
18637	21695	9	created	create	VBN
18637	21695	10	another	another	DT
18637	21695	11	problem	problem	NN
18637	21695	12	for	for	IN
18637	21695	13	the	the	DT
18637	21695	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21695	15	,	,	,
18637	21695	16	that	that	DT
18637	21695	17	of	of	IN
18637	21695	18	a	a	DT
18637	21695	19	burdensome	burdensome	JJ
18637	21695	20	increase	increase	NN
18637	21695	21	in	in	IN
18637	21695	22	the	the	DT
18637	21695	23	volume	volume	NN
18637	21695	24	of	of	IN
18637	21695	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21695	26	business	business	NN
18637	21695	27	.	.	.
18637	21696	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	21696	2	as	as	IN
18637	21696	3	accurate	accurate	JJ
18637	21696	4	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	21696	5	of	of	IN
18637	21696	6	the	the	DT
18637	21696	7	effect	effect	NN
18637	21696	8	of	of	IN
18637	21696	9	absence	absence	NN
18637	21696	10	of	of	IN
18637	21696	11	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21696	12	on	on	IN
18637	21696	13	the	the	DT
18637	21696	14	validity	validity	NN
18637	21696	15	of	of	IN
18637	21696	16	a	a	DT
18637	21696	17	State	State	NNP
18637	21696	18	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	21696	19	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	21696	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	21696	21	been	be	VBN
18637	21696	22	rendered	render	VBN
18637	21696	23	more	more	RBR
18637	21696	24	difficult	difficult	JJ
18637	21696	25	by	by	IN
18637	21696	26	the	the	DT
18637	21696	27	vagueness	vagueness	NN
18637	21696	28	of	of	IN
18637	21696	29	that	that	DT
18637	21696	30	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	21696	31	as	as	RB
18637	21696	32	well	well	RB
18637	21696	33	as	as	IN
18637	21696	34	by	by	IN
18637	21696	35	the	the	DT
18637	21696	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21696	37	's	's	POS
18637	21696	38	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	21696	39	variation	variation	NN
18637	21696	40	in	in	IN
18637	21696	41	the	the	DT
18637	21696	42	application	application	NN
18637	21696	43	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	21696	44	,	,	,
18637	21696	45	innumerable	innumerable	JJ
18637	21696	46	State	state	NN
18637	21696	47	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
18637	21696	48	have	have	VBP
18637	21696	49	been	be	VBN
18637	21696	50	tempted	tempt	VBN
18637	21696	51	to	to	TO
18637	21696	52	seek	seek	VB
18637	21696	53	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	21696	54	reconsideration	reconsideration	NN
18637	21696	55	of	of	IN
18637	21696	56	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21696	57	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	21696	58	.	.	.
18637	21697	1	To	to	TO
18637	21697	2	reduce	reduce	VB
18637	21697	3	the	the	DT
18637	21697	4	number	number	NN
18637	21697	5	of	of	IN
18637	21697	6	such	such	JJ
18637	21697	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	21697	8	which	which	WDT
18637	21697	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21697	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	21697	11	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	21697	12	to	to	TO
18637	21697	13	examine	examine	VB
18637	21697	14	on	on	IN
18637	21697	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21697	16	merits	merit	NNS
18637	21697	17	,	,	,
18637	21697	18	the	the	DT
18637	21697	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21697	20	had	have	VBD
18637	21697	21	been	be	VBN
18637	21697	22	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	21697	23	to	to	TO
18637	21697	24	have	have	VB
18637	21697	25	recourse	recourse	VBN
18637	21697	26	to	to	IN
18637	21697	27	certain	certain	JJ
18637	21697	28	protective	protective	JJ
18637	21697	29	rules	rule	NNS
18637	21697	30	.	.	.
18637	21698	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	21698	2	,	,	,
18637	21698	3	when	when	WRB
18637	21698	4	a	a	DT
18637	21698	5	State	state	NN
18637	21698	6	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	21698	7	seeks	seek	VBZ
18637	21698	8	to	to	TO
18637	21698	9	attack	attack	VB
18637	21698	10	the	the	DT
18637	21698	11	validity	validity	NN
18637	21698	12	of	of	IN
18637	21698	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21698	14	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	21698	15	by	by	IN
18637	21698	16	way	way	NN
18637	21698	17	of	of	IN
18637	21698	18	_	_	NNP
18637	21698	19	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	21698	20	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	21698	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21698	22	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	21698	23	begun	begin	VBN
18637	21698	24	in	in	IN
18637	21698	25	a	a	DT
18637	21698	26	lower	low	JJR
18637	21698	27	federal	federal	JJ
18637	21698	28	court	court	NN
18637	21698	29	,	,	,
18637	21698	30	application	application	NN
18637	21698	31	for	for	IN
18637	21698	32	that	that	DT
18637	21698	33	writ	writ	NNP
18637	21698	34	will	will	MD
18637	21698	35	be	be	VB
18637	21698	36	entertained	entertain	VBN
18637	21698	37	only	only	RB
18637	21698	38	after	after	IN
18637	21698	39	all	all	DT
18637	21698	40	State	state	NN
18637	21698	41	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	21698	42	available	available	JJ
18637	21698	43	,	,	,
18637	21698	44	including	include	VBG
18637	21698	45	all	all	DT
18637	21698	46	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	21698	47	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	21698	48	in	in	IN
18637	21698	49	State	State	NNP
18637	21698	50	courts	court	NNS
18637	21698	51	and	and	CC
18637	21698	52	in	in	IN
18637	21698	53	the	the	DT
18637	21698	54	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21698	55	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21698	56	by	by	IN
18637	21698	57	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	21698	58	or	or	CC
18637	21698	59	writ	writ	NNP
18637	21698	60	of	of	IN
18637	21698	61	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	21698	62	,	,	,
18637	21698	63	have	have	VBP
18637	21698	64	been	be	VBN
18637	21698	65	exhausted	exhaust	VBN
18637	21698	66	.	.	.
18637	21699	1	This	this	DT
18637	21699	2	rule	rule	NN
18637	21699	3	,	,	,
18637	21699	4	however	however	RB
18637	21699	5	,	,	,
18637	21699	6	will	will	MD
18637	21699	7	not	not	RB
18637	21699	8	be	be	VB
18637	21699	9	applied	apply	VBN
18637	21699	10	when	when	WRB
18637	21699	11	no	no	DT
18637	21699	12	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	21699	13	State	State	NNP
18637	21699	14	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	21699	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	21699	16	in	in	IN
18637	21699	17	fact	fact	NN
18637	21699	18	available	available	JJ
18637	21699	19	.	.	.
18637	21700	1	Also	also	RB
18637	21700	2	when	when	WRB
18637	21700	3	a	a	DT
18637	21700	4	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	21700	5	's	's	POS
18637	21700	6	petition	petition	NN
18637	21700	7	for	for	IN
18637	21700	8	release	release	NN
18637	21700	9	on	on	IN
18637	21700	10	the	the	DT
18637	21700	11	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	21700	12	of	of	IN
18637	21700	13	the	the	DT
18637	21700	14	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	JJ
18637	21700	15	of	of	IN
18637	21700	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21700	17	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	21700	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	21700	19	been	be	VBN
18637	21700	20	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	21700	21	by	by	IN
18637	21700	22	a	a	DT
18637	21700	23	State	State	NNP
18637	21700	24	court	court	NN
18637	21700	25	,	,	,
18637	21700	26	a	a	DT
18637	21700	27	petition	petition	NN
18637	21700	28	for	for	IN
18637	21700	29	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	21700	30	addressed	address	VBN
18637	21700	31	to	to	IN
18637	21700	32	the	the	DT
18637	21700	33	United	United	NNP
18637	21700	34	States	States	NNP
18637	21700	35	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21700	36	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21700	37	will	will	MD
18637	21700	38	be	be	VB
18637	21700	39	denied	deny	VBN
18637	21700	40	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	21700	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21700	42	appears	appear	VBZ
18637	21700	43	that	that	IN
18637	21700	44	the	the	DT
18637	21700	45	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	21700	46	had	have	VBD
18637	21700	47	not	not	RB
18637	21700	48	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	21700	49	the	the	DT
18637	21700	50	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	21700	51	State	State	NNP
18637	21700	52	remedy	remedy	NN
18637	21700	53	.	.	.
18637	21701	1	Or	or	CC
18637	21701	2	stated	state	VBN
18637	21701	3	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	21701	4	,	,	,
18637	21701	5	where	where	WRB
18637	21701	6	the	the	DT
18637	21701	7	State	State	NNP
18637	21701	8	court	court	NN
18637	21701	9	's	's	POS
18637	21701	10	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	21701	11	or	or	CC
18637	21701	12	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	21701	13	to	to	TO
18637	21701	14	grant	grant	VB
18637	21701	15	writs	writ	NNS
18637	21701	16	of	of	IN
18637	21701	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21701	18	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	21701	19	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	21701	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21701	21	to	to	IN
18637	21701	22	those	those	DT
18637	21701	23	under	under	IN
18637	21701	24	State	State	NNP
18637	21701	25	sentences	sentence	NNS
18637	21701	26	may	may	MD
18637	21701	27	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	21701	28	be	be	VB
18637	21701	29	attributed	attribute	VBN
18637	21701	30	to	to	IN
18637	21701	31	a	a	DT
18637	21701	32	rule	rule	NN
18637	21701	33	of	of	IN
18637	21701	34	local	local	JJ
18637	21701	35	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	21701	36	and	and	CC
18637	21701	37	is	be	VBZ
18637	21701	38	not	not	RB
18637	21701	39	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	21701	40	founded	found	VBN
18637	21701	41	on	on	IN
18637	21701	42	the	the	DT
18637	21701	43	denial	denial	NN
18637	21701	44	of	of	IN
18637	21701	45	a	a	DT
18637	21701	46	federal	federal	JJ
18637	21701	47	claim	claim	NN
18637	21701	48	,	,	,
18637	21701	49	such	such	JJ
18637	21701	50	as	as	IN
18637	21701	51	,	,	,
18637	21701	52	right	right	NN
18637	21701	53	to	to	IN
18637	21701	54	counsel	counsel	VB
18637	21701	55	,	,	,
18637	21701	56	the	the	DT
18637	21701	57	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21701	58	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21701	59	will	will	MD
18637	21701	60	refuse	refuse	VB
18637	21701	61	to	to	TO
18637	21701	62	intervene	intervene	VB
18637	21701	63	.	.	.
18637	21702	1	As	as	IN
18637	21702	2	in	in	IN
18637	21702	3	the	the	DT
18637	21702	4	case	case	NN
18637	21702	5	of	of	IN
18637	21702	6	other	other	JJ
18637	21702	7	legal	legal	JJ
18637	21702	8	rules	rule	NNS
18637	21702	9	,	,	,
18637	21702	10	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21702	11	of	of	IN
18637	21702	12	the	the	DT
18637	21702	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21702	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21702	15	have	have	VBP
18637	21702	16	often	often	RB
18637	21702	17	found	find	VBN
18637	21702	18	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21702	19	in	in	IN
18637	21702	20	disagreement	disagreement	NN
18637	21702	21	as	as	IN
18637	21702	22	to	to	IN
18637	21702	23	the	the	DT
18637	21702	24	manner	manner	NN
18637	21702	25	of	of	IN
18637	21702	26	applying	apply	VBG
18637	21702	27	these	these	DT
18637	21702	28	aforementioned	aforementioned	JJ
18637	21702	29	principles	principle	NNS
18637	21702	30	;	;	:
18637	21702	31	and	and	CC
18637	21702	32	vigorous	vigorous	JJ
18637	21702	33	dissents	dissent	NNS
18637	21702	34	arising	arise	VBG
18637	21702	35	out	out	IN
18637	21702	36	of	of	IN
18637	21702	37	this	this	DT
18637	21702	38	very	very	JJ
18637	21702	39	issue	issue	NN
18637	21702	40	were	be	VBD
18637	21702	41	recorded	record	VBN
18637	21702	42	in	in	IN
18637	21702	43	the	the	DT
18637	21702	44	cases	case	NNS
18637	21702	45	of	of	IN
18637	21702	46	Marino	Marino	NNP
18637	21702	47	_	_	NNP
18637	21702	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	21702	49	_	_	NNP
18637	21702	50	Ragen	Ragen	NNP
18637	21702	51	,	,	,
18637	21702	52	332	332	CD
18637	21702	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21702	54	561	561	CD
18637	21702	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21702	56	1947	1947	CD
18637	21702	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21702	58	;	;	:
18637	21702	59	Wade	Wade	NNP
18637	21702	60	_	_	NNP
18637	21702	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	21702	62	_	_	NNP
18637	21702	63	Mayo	Mayo	NNP
18637	21702	64	,	,	,
18637	21702	65	334	334	CD
18637	21702	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21702	67	672	672	CD
18637	21702	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21702	69	1948	1948	CD
18637	21702	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21702	71	;	;	:
18637	21702	72	and	and	CC
18637	21702	73	Uveges	Uveges	NNPS
18637	21702	74	_	_	NNP
18637	21702	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	21702	76	_	_	NNP
18637	21702	77	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	21702	78	,	,	,
18637	21702	79	335	335	CD
18637	21702	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21702	81	437	437	CD
18637	21702	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21702	83	1948	1948	CD
18637	21702	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21702	85	.	.	.
18637	21703	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21703	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	21703	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	21703	4	frequently	frequently	RB
18637	21703	5	,	,	,
18637	21703	6	albeit	albeit	IN
18637	21703	7	unsuccessfully	unsuccessfully	RB
18637	21703	8	contended	contend	VBD
18637	21703	9	,	,	,
18637	21703	10	that	that	IN
18637	21703	11	"	"	``
18637	21703	12	intervention	intervention	NN
18637	21703	13	by	by	IN
18637	21703	14	*	*	NFP
18637	21703	15	*	*	NFP
18637	21703	16	*	*	NFP
18637	21703	17	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21703	18	the	the	DT
18637	21703	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21703	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21703	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21703	22	in	in	IN
18637	21703	23	the	the	DT
18637	21703	24	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	21703	25	process	process	NN
18637	21703	26	of	of	IN
18637	21703	27	States	state	NNS
18637	21703	28	*	*	NFP
18637	21703	29	*	*	NFP
18637	21703	30	*	*	NFP
18637	21703	31	should	should	MD
18637	21703	32	not	not	RB
18637	21703	33	be	be	VB
18637	21703	34	indulged	indulge	VBN
18637	21703	35	in	in	IN
18637	21703	36	unless	unless	IN
18637	21703	37	no	no	DT
18637	21703	38	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	21703	39	doubt	doubt	NN
18637	21703	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	21703	41	left	leave	VBN
18637	21703	42	that	that	IN
18637	21703	43	a	a	DT
18637	21703	44	State	state	NN
18637	21703	45	denies	deny	VBZ
18637	21703	46	,	,	,
18637	21703	47	or	or	CC
18637	21703	48	has	have	VBZ
18637	21703	49	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	21703	50	to	to	TO
18637	21703	51	exercise	exercise	VB
18637	21703	52	,	,	,
18637	21703	53	means	mean	VBZ
18637	21703	54	of	of	IN
18637	21703	55	correcting	correct	VBG
18637	21703	56	a	a	DT
18637	21703	57	claimed	claim	VBN
18637	21703	58	infraction	infraction	NN
18637	21703	59	of	of	IN
18637	21703	60	the	the	DT
18637	21703	61	United	United	NNP
18637	21703	62	States	States	NNP
18637	21703	63	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	21703	64	.	.	.
18637	21704	1	*	*	NFP
18637	21704	2	*	*	NFP
18637	21704	3	*	*	NFP
18637	21704	4	After	after	RB
18637	21704	5	all	all	RB
18637	21704	6	,	,	,
18637	21704	7	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21704	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21704	9	should	should	MD
18637	21704	10	be	be	VB
18637	21704	11	borne	bear	VBN
18637	21704	12	in	in	IN
18637	21704	13	mind	mind	NN
18637	21704	14	that	that	IN
18637	21704	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21704	16	this	this	DT
18637	21704	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	21704	18	the	the	DT
18637	21704	19	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	21704	20	's	's	POS
18637	21704	21	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	21704	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	21704	23	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	21704	24	,	,	,
18637	21704	25	not	not	RB
18637	21704	26	a	a	DT
18637	21704	27	super	super	JJ
18637	21704	28	-	-	JJ
18637	21704	29	legal	legal	JJ
18637	21704	30	-	-	HYPH
18637	21704	31	aid	aid	NN
18637	21704	32	bureau	bureau	NN
18637	21704	33	.	.	.
18637	21704	34	"	"	''
18637	21705	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21705	2	864	864	CD
18637	21705	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21705	4	176	176	CD
18637	21705	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21705	6	581	581	CD
18637	21705	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21705	8	1900	1900	CD
18637	21705	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21705	10	.	.	.
18637	21706	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21706	2	865	865	CD
18637	21706	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21706	4	110	110	CD
18637	21706	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21706	6	516	516	CD
18637	21706	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21706	8	1884	1884	CD
18637	21706	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21706	10	.	.	.
18637	21707	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21707	2	866	866	CD
18637	21707	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21707	4	Jordan	Jordan	NNP
18637	21707	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21707	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21707	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21707	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21707	9	,	,	,
18637	21707	10	225	225	CD
18637	21707	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21707	12	167	167	CD
18637	21707	13	,	,	,
18637	21707	14	176	176	CD
18637	21707	15	.	.	.
18637	21708	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21708	2	1912	1912	CD
18637	21708	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21708	4	.	.	.
18637	21709	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21709	2	867	867	CD
18637	21709	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21709	4	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	21709	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21709	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21709	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21709	8	Dow	Dow	NNP
18637	21709	9	,	,	,
18637	21709	10	176	176	CD
18637	21709	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21709	12	581	581	CD
18637	21709	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21709	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	21709	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21709	16	.	.	.
18637	21710	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21710	2	868	868	CD
18637	21710	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21710	4	Hallinger	Hallinger	NNP
18637	21710	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21710	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21710	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21710	8	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	21710	9	,	,	,
18637	21710	10	146	146	CD
18637	21710	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21710	12	314	314	CD
18637	21710	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21710	14	1892	1892	CD
18637	21710	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21710	16	.	.	.
18637	21711	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21711	2	869	869	CD
18637	21711	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21711	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21711	5	.	.	.
18637	21712	1	318	318	CD
18637	21712	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21712	3	320	320	CD
18637	21712	4	.	.	.
18637	21713	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21713	2	870	870	CD
18637	21713	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21713	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	21713	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21713	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21713	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21713	8	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	21713	9	,	,	,
18637	21713	10	101	101	CD
18637	21713	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21713	12	22	22	CD
18637	21713	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21713	14	1880	1880	CD
18637	21713	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21713	16	;	;	:
18637	21713	17	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	21713	18	_	_	NNP
18637	21713	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	21713	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21713	21	Dow	Dow	NNP
18637	21713	22	,	,	,
18637	21713	23	176	176	CD
18637	21713	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21713	25	581	581	CD
18637	21713	26	,	,	,
18637	21713	27	603	603	CD
18637	21713	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21713	29	1900	1900	CD
18637	21713	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21713	31	;	;	:
18637	21713	32	Jordan	Jordan	NNP
18637	21713	33	_	_	NNP
18637	21713	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	21713	35	_	_	NNP
18637	21713	36	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21713	37	,	,	,
18637	21713	38	225	225	CD
18637	21713	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21713	40	167	167	CD
18637	21713	41	,	,	,
18637	21713	42	176	176	CD
18637	21713	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21713	44	1912	1912	CD
18637	21713	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21713	46	;	;	:
18637	21713	47	Snyder	Snyder	NNP
18637	21713	48	_	_	NNP
18637	21713	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	21713	50	_	_	NNP
18637	21713	51	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21713	52	,	,	,
18637	21713	53	291	291	CD
18637	21713	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21713	55	97	97	CD
18637	21713	56	,	,	,
18637	21713	57	105	105	CD
18637	21713	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21713	59	1934	1934	CD
18637	21713	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21713	61	.	.	.
18637	21714	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21714	2	871	871	CD
18637	21714	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21714	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	21714	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21714	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21714	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21714	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21714	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	21714	10	,	,	,
18637	21714	11	175	175	CD
18637	21714	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21714	13	172	172	CD
18637	21714	14	,	,	,
18637	21714	15	175	175	CD
18637	21714	16	,	,	,
18637	21714	17	176	176	CD
18637	21714	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21714	19	1899	1899	CD
18637	21714	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21714	21	.	.	.
18637	21715	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21715	2	872	872	CD
18637	21715	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21715	4	Ashe	Ashe	NNP
18637	21715	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21715	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21715	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21715	8	United	United	NNP
18637	21715	9	States	States	NNP
18637	21715	10	ex	ex	NNP
18637	21715	11	rel	rel	NN
18637	21715	12	.	.	.
18637	21716	1	Valotta	Valotta	NNP
18637	21716	2	,	,	,
18637	21716	3	270	270	CD
18637	21716	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21716	5	424	424	CD
18637	21716	6	,	,	,
18637	21716	7	425	425	CD
18637	21716	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21716	9	1926	1926	CD
18637	21716	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21716	11	.	.	.
18637	21717	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21717	2	873	873	CD
18637	21717	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21717	4	Fay	Fay	NNP
18637	21717	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21717	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21717	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21717	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21717	9	York	York	NNP
18637	21717	10	,	,	,
18637	21717	11	332	332	CD
18637	21717	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21717	13	261	261	CD
18637	21717	14	,	,	,
18637	21717	15	288	288	CD
18637	21717	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21717	17	1947	1947	CD
18637	21717	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21717	19	;	;	:
18637	21717	20	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	21717	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21717	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	21717	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21717	24	New	New	NNP
18637	21717	25	York	York	NNP
18637	21717	26	,	,	,
18637	21717	27	333	333	CD
18637	21717	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21717	29	585	585	CD
18637	21717	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21717	31	1948).--Both	1948).--Both	``
18637	21717	32	cases	case	NNS
18637	21717	33	reject	reject	VBP
18637	21717	34	the	the	DT
18637	21717	35	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	21717	36	that	that	IN
18637	21717	37	the	the	DT
18637	21717	38	commandment	commandment	NN
18637	21717	39	of	of	IN
18637	21717	40	the	the	DT
18637	21717	41	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	21717	42	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21717	43	,	,	,
18637	21717	44	which	which	WDT
18637	21717	45	requires	require	VBZ
18637	21717	46	a	a	DT
18637	21717	47	jury	jury	NN
18637	21717	48	trial	trial	NN
18637	21717	49	in	in	IN
18637	21717	50	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	21717	51	cases	case	NNS
18637	21717	52	in	in	IN
18637	21717	53	the	the	DT
18637	21717	54	federal	federal	JJ
18637	21717	55	courts	court	NNS
18637	21717	56	is	be	VBZ
18637	21717	57	picked	pick	VBN
18637	21717	58	up	up	RP
18637	21717	59	by	by	IN
18637	21717	60	the	the	DT
18637	21717	61	due	due	JJ
18637	21717	62	process	process	NN
18637	21717	63	clause	clause	NN
18637	21717	64	of	of	IN
18637	21717	65	the	the	DT
18637	21717	66	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21717	67	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21717	68	so	so	IN
18637	21717	69	as	as	IN
18637	21717	70	to	to	TO
18637	21717	71	become	become	VB
18637	21717	72	a	a	DT
18637	21717	73	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	21717	74	upon	upon	IN
18637	21717	75	the	the	DT
18637	21717	76	States	States	NNP
18637	21717	77	.	.	.
18637	21718	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21718	2	874	874	CD
18637	21718	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21718	4	Fay	Fay	NNP
18637	21718	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21718	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21718	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21718	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21718	9	York	York	NNP
18637	21718	10	,	,	,
18637	21718	11	332	332	CD
18637	21718	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21718	13	261	261	CD
18637	21718	14	,	,	,
18637	21718	15	283	283	CD
18637	21718	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	21718	17	284	284	CD
18637	21718	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21718	19	1947).--Since	1947).--Since	NNP
18637	21718	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	21718	21	,	,	,
18637	21718	22	by	by	IN
18637	21718	23	way	way	NN
18637	21718	24	of	of	IN
18637	21718	25	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	21718	26	the	the	DT
18637	21718	27	guarantees	guarantee	NNS
18637	21718	28	contained	contain	VBN
18637	21718	29	in	in	IN
18637	21718	30	the	the	DT
18637	21718	31	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21718	32	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21718	33	,	,	,
18637	21718	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	21718	35	,	,	,
18637	21718	36	by	by	IN
18637	21718	37	statute	statute	NN
18637	21718	38	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21718	39	18	18	CD
18637	21718	40	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	21718	41	.	.	.
18637	21719	1	336	336	CD
18637	21719	2	,	,	,
18637	21719	3	377	377	CD
18637	21719	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21719	5	1875	1875	CD
18637	21719	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21719	7	;	;	:
18637	21719	8	8	8	CD
18637	21719	9	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	21720	1	44	44	CD
18637	21720	2	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21720	3	,	,	,
18637	21720	4	made	make	VBD
18637	21720	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21720	6	a	a	DT
18637	21720	7	crime	crime	NN
18637	21720	8	to	to	TO
18637	21720	9	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	21720	10	a	a	DT
18637	21720	11	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	21720	12	from	from	IN
18637	21720	13	jury	jury	NN
18637	21720	14	service	service	NN
18637	21720	15	only	only	RB
18637	21720	16	on	on	IN
18637	21720	17	account	account	NN
18637	21720	18	of	of	IN
18637	21720	19	race	race	NN
18637	21720	20	,	,	,
18637	21720	21	color	color	NN
18637	21720	22	,	,	,
18637	21720	23	or	or	CC
18637	21720	24	previous	previous	JJ
18637	21720	25	condition	condition	NN
18637	21720	26	of	of	IN
18637	21720	27	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	21720	28	,	,	,
18637	21720	29	the	the	DT
18637	21720	30	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21720	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21720	32	"	"	''
18637	21720	33	never	never	RB
18637	21720	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	21720	35	interfered	interfere	VBN
18637	21720	36	with	with	IN
18637	21720	37	the	the	DT
18637	21720	38	composition	composition	NN
18637	21720	39	of	of	IN
18637	21720	40	State	State	NNP
18637	21720	41	court	court	NN
18637	21720	42	juries	jury	NNS
18637	21720	43	except	except	IN
18637	21720	44	in	in	IN
18637	21720	45	cases	case	NNS
18637	21720	46	where	where	WRB
18637	21720	47	this	this	DT
18637	21720	48	guidance	guidance	NN
18637	21720	49	of	of	IN
18637	21720	50	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	21720	51	was	be	VBD
18637	21720	52	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	21720	53	.	.	.
18637	21720	54	"	"	''
18637	21721	1	Without	without	IN
18637	21721	2	suggesting	suggest	VBG
18637	21721	3	that	that	IN
18637	21721	4	"	"	``
18637	21721	5	no	no	DT
18637	21721	6	case	case	NN
18637	21721	7	of	of	IN
18637	21721	8	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	21721	9	in	in	IN
18637	21721	10	jury	jury	NN
18637	21721	11	drawing	draw	VBG
18637	21721	12	except	except	IN
18637	21721	13	those	those	DT
18637	21721	14	involving	involve	VBG
18637	21721	15	race	race	NN
18637	21721	16	or	or	CC
18637	21721	17	color	color	NN
18637	21721	18	can	can	MD
18637	21721	19	carry	carry	VB
18637	21721	20	such	such	JJ
18637	21721	21	unjust	unjust	JJ
18637	21721	22	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	21721	23	as	as	IN
18637	21721	24	to	to	TO
18637	21721	25	amount	amount	VB
18637	21721	26	to	to	IN
18637	21721	27	a	a	DT
18637	21721	28	denial	denial	NN
18637	21721	29	of	of	IN
18637	21721	30	*	*	NFP
18637	21721	31	*	*	NFP
18637	21721	32	*	*	NFP
18637	21721	33	due	due	JJ
18637	21721	34	process	process	NN
18637	21721	35	,	,	,
18637	21721	36	"	"	''
18637	21721	37	the	the	DT
18637	21721	38	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21721	39	has	have	VBZ
18637	21721	40	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	21721	41	required	require	VBN
18637	21721	42	that	that	IN
18637	21721	43	a	a	DT
18637	21721	44	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	21721	45	,	,	,
18637	21721	46	alleging	allege	VBG
18637	21721	47	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	21721	48	not	not	RB
18637	21721	49	covered	cover	VBN
18637	21721	50	by	by	IN
18637	21721	51	that	that	DT
18637	21721	52	statute	statute	NN
18637	21721	53	,	,	,
18637	21721	54	"	"	''
18637	21721	55	must	must	MD
18637	21721	56	comply	comply	VB
18637	21721	57	with	with	IN
18637	21721	58	the	the	DT
18637	21721	59	exacting	exact	VBG
18637	21721	60	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	21721	61	of	of	IN
18637	21721	62	proving	prove	VBG
18637	21721	63	clearly	clearly	RB
18637	21721	64	"	"	''
18637	21721	65	that	that	IN
18637	21721	66	the	the	DT
18637	21721	67	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	21721	68	in	in	IN
18637	21721	69	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21721	70	case	case	NN
18637	21721	71	was	be	VBD
18637	21721	72	destructive	destructive	JJ
18637	21721	73	of	of	IN
18637	21721	74	due	due	JJ
18637	21721	75	process	process	NN
18637	21721	76	.	.	.
18637	21722	1	These	these	DT
18637	21722	2	statements	statement	NNS
18637	21722	3	reflect	reflect	VBP
18637	21722	4	the	the	DT
18637	21722	5	views	view	NNS
18637	21722	6	of	of	IN
18637	21722	7	only	only	RB
18637	21722	8	five	five	CD
18637	21722	9	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	21722	10	.	.	.
18637	21723	1	Speaking	speak	VBG
18637	21723	2	for	for	IN
18637	21723	3	the	the	DT
18637	21723	4	minority	minority	NN
18637	21723	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21723	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21723	7	Black	Black	NNP
18637	21723	8	,	,	,
18637	21723	9	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	21723	10	,	,	,
18637	21723	11	and	and	CC
18637	21723	12	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21723	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21723	14	,	,	,
18637	21723	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21723	16	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21723	17	declared	declare	VBD
18637	21723	18	that	that	IN
18637	21723	19	"	"	``
18637	21723	20	the	the	DT
18637	21723	21	vice	vice	NN
18637	21723	22	lies	lie	VBZ
18637	21723	23	in	in	IN
18637	21723	24	the	the	DT
18637	21723	25	very	very	JJ
18637	21723	26	concept	concept	NN
18637	21723	27	of	of	IN
18637	21723	28	'	'	``
18637	21723	29	blue	blue	JJ
18637	21723	30	ribbon	ribbon	NN
18637	21723	31	'	'	''
18637	21723	32	panels	panel	NNS
18637	21723	33	--	--	:
18637	21723	34	the	the	DT
18637	21723	35	systematic	systematic	JJ
18637	21723	36	and	and	CC
18637	21723	37	intentional	intentional	JJ
18637	21723	38	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	21723	39	of	of	IN
18637	21723	40	all	all	DT
18637	21723	41	but	but	CC
18637	21723	42	the	the	DT
18637	21723	43	'	'	``
18637	21723	44	best	good	JJS
18637	21723	45	'	'	''
18637	21723	46	or	or	CC
18637	21723	47	the	the	DT
18637	21723	48	most	most	RBS
18637	21723	49	learned	learned	JJ
18637	21723	50	or	or	CC
18637	21723	51	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
18637	21723	52	of	of	IN
18637	21723	53	the	the	DT
18637	21723	54	general	general	JJ
18637	21723	55	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	21723	56	.	.	.
18637	21724	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	21724	2	panels	panel	NNS
18637	21724	3	are	be	VBP
18637	21724	4	completely	completely	RB
18637	21724	5	at	at	IN
18637	21724	6	war	war	NN
18637	21724	7	with	with	IN
18637	21724	8	the	the	DT
18637	21724	9	democratic	democratic	JJ
18637	21724	10	theory	theory	NN
18637	21724	11	of	of	IN
18637	21724	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21724	13	jury	jury	NN
18637	21724	14	system	system	NN
18637	21724	15	,	,	,
18637	21724	16	a	a	DT
18637	21724	17	theory	theory	NN
18637	21724	18	formulated	formulate	VBN
18637	21724	19	out	out	IN
18637	21724	20	of	of	IN
18637	21724	21	the	the	DT
18637	21724	22	experience	experience	NN
18637	21724	23	of	of	IN
18637	21724	24	generations	generation	NNS
18637	21724	25	.	.	.
18637	21725	1	One	one	CD
18637	21725	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	21725	3	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	21725	4	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	21725	5	to	to	TO
18637	21725	6	be	be	VB
18637	21725	7	judged	judge	VBN
18637	21725	8	by	by	IN
18637	21725	9	a	a	DT
18637	21725	10	fair	fair	JJ
18637	21725	11	sampling	sampling	NN
18637	21725	12	of	of	IN
18637	21725	13	all	all	DT
18637	21725	14	one	one	NN
18637	21725	15	's	's	POS
18637	21725	16	neighbors	neighbor	NNS
18637	21725	17	who	who	WP
18637	21725	18	are	be	VBP
18637	21725	19	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	21725	20	,	,	,
18637	21725	21	not	not	RB
18637	21725	22	merely	merely	RB
18637	21725	23	those	those	DT
18637	21725	24	with	with	IN
18637	21725	25	superior	superior	JJ
18637	21725	26	intelligence	intelligence	NN
18637	21725	27	or	or	CC
18637	21725	28	learning	learning	NN
18637	21725	29	.	.	.
18637	21726	1	Jury	jury	NN
18637	21726	2	panels	panel	NNS
18637	21726	3	are	be	VBP
18637	21726	4	supposed	suppose	VBN
18637	21726	5	to	to	TO
18637	21726	6	be	be	VB
18637	21726	7	representative	representative	JJ
18637	21726	8	of	of	IN
18637	21726	9	all	all	DT
18637	21726	10	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	21726	11	classes	class	NNS
18637	21726	12	.	.	.
18637	21727	1	Within	within	IN
18637	21727	2	those	those	DT
18637	21727	3	classes	class	NNS
18637	21727	4	,	,	,
18637	21727	5	of	of	IN
18637	21727	6	course	course	NN
18637	21727	7	,	,	,
18637	21727	8	are	be	VBP
18637	21727	9	persons	person	NNS
18637	21727	10	with	with	IN
18637	21727	11	varying	vary	VBG
18637	21727	12	degrees	degree	NNS
18637	21727	13	of	of	IN
18637	21727	14	intelligence	intelligence	NN
18637	21727	15	,	,	,
18637	21727	16	wealth	wealth	NN
18637	21727	17	,	,	,
18637	21727	18	education	education	NN
18637	21727	19	,	,	,
18637	21727	20	ability	ability	NN
18637	21727	21	and	and	CC
18637	21727	22	experience	experience	NN
18637	21727	23	.	.	.
18637	21728	1	But	but	CC
18637	21728	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21728	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	21728	4	from	from	IN
18637	21728	5	that	that	DT
18637	21728	6	welter	welter	NN
18637	21728	7	of	of	IN
18637	21728	8	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	21728	9	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	21728	10	,	,	,
18637	21728	11	who	who	WP
18637	21728	12	meet	meet	VBP
18637	21728	13	specified	specified	JJ
18637	21728	14	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	21728	15	standards	standard	NNS
18637	21728	16	,	,	,
18637	21728	17	that	that	IN
18637	21728	18	juries	jury	NNS
18637	21728	19	are	be	VBP
18637	21728	20	to	to	TO
18637	21728	21	be	be	VB
18637	21728	22	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	21728	23	.	.	.
18637	21729	1	Any	any	DT
18637	21729	2	method	method	NN
18637	21729	3	that	that	WDT
18637	21729	4	permits	permit	VBZ
18637	21729	5	only	only	RB
18637	21729	6	the	the	DT
18637	21729	7	'	'	``
18637	21729	8	best	good	JJS
18637	21729	9	'	'	''
18637	21729	10	of	of	IN
18637	21729	11	these	these	DT
18637	21729	12	to	to	TO
18637	21729	13	be	be	VB
18637	21729	14	selected	select	VBN
18637	21729	15	opens	open	VBZ
18637	21729	16	the	the	DT
18637	21729	17	way	way	NN
18637	21729	18	to	to	IN
18637	21729	19	grave	grave	JJ
18637	21729	20	abuses	abuse	NNS
18637	21729	21	.	.	.
18637	21730	1	The	the	DT
18637	21730	2	jury	jury	NN
18637	21730	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	21730	4	then	then	RB
18637	21730	5	in	in	IN
18637	21730	6	danger	danger	NN
18637	21730	7	of	of	IN
18637	21730	8	losing	lose	VBG
18637	21730	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21730	10	democratic	democratic	JJ
18637	21730	11	flavor	flavor	NN
18637	21730	12	and	and	CC
18637	21730	13	becoming	become	VBG
18637	21730	14	the	the	DT
18637	21730	15	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	21730	16	of	of	IN
18637	21730	17	the	the	DT
18637	21730	18	select	select	JJ
18637	21730	19	few	few	JJ
18637	21730	20	.	.	.
18637	21730	21	"	"	''
18637	21731	1	A	a	DT
18637	21731	2	"	"	``
18637	21731	3	blue	blue	JJ
18637	21731	4	ribbon	ribbon	NN
18637	21731	5	jury	jury	NN
18637	21731	6	"	"	''
18637	21731	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	21731	8	neither	neither	CC
18637	21731	9	"	"	``
18637	21731	10	a	a	DT
18637	21731	11	jury	jury	NN
18637	21731	12	of	of	IN
18637	21731	13	the	the	DT
18637	21731	14	*	*	NFP
18637	21731	15	*	*	NFP
18637	21731	16	*	*	NFP
18637	21731	17	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21731	18	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	21731	19	's	's	POS
18637	21731	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21731	21	peers	peer	NNS
18637	21731	22	,	,	,
18637	21731	23	"	"	''
18637	21731	24	nor	nor	CC
18637	21731	25	"	"	``
18637	21731	26	a	a	DT
18637	21731	27	jury	jury	NN
18637	21731	28	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	21731	29	from	from	IN
18637	21731	30	a	a	DT
18637	21731	31	fair	fair	JJ
18637	21731	32	cross	cross	JJ
18637	21731	33	-	-	NN
18637	21731	34	section	section	NN
18637	21731	35	of	of	IN
18637	21731	36	the	the	DT
18637	21731	37	community	community	NN
18637	21731	38	,	,	,
18637	21731	39	*	*	NFP
18637	21731	40	*	*	NFP
18637	21731	41	*	*	NFP
18637	21731	42	"	"	''
18637	21731	43	--Moore	--Moore	:
18637	21731	44	_	_	NNP
18637	21731	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	21731	46	_	_	NNP
18637	21731	47	New	New	NNP
18637	21731	48	York	York	NNP
18637	21731	49	,	,	,
18637	21731	50	333	333	CD
18637	21731	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21731	52	565	565	CD
18637	21731	53	,	,	,
18637	21731	54	569	569	CD
18637	21731	55	-	-	HYPH
18637	21731	56	570	570	CD
18637	21731	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21731	58	1948	1948	CD
18637	21731	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21731	60	.	.	.
18637	21732	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21732	2	875	875	CD
18637	21732	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21732	4	Rawlins	Rawlins	NNPS
18637	21732	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21732	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21732	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21732	8	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	21732	9	,	,	,
18637	21732	10	201	201	CD
18637	21732	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21732	12	638	638	CD
18637	21732	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21732	14	1906	1906	CD
18637	21732	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21732	16	.	.	.
18637	21733	1	The	the	DT
18637	21733	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21733	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21733	4	"	"	''
18637	21733	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	21733	6	never	never	RB
18637	21733	7	entertained	entertain	VBN
18637	21733	8	a	a	DT
18637	21733	9	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	21733	10	's	's	POS
18637	21733	11	objections	objection	NNS
18637	21733	12	to	to	IN
18637	21733	13	exclusions	exclusion	NNS
18637	21733	14	from	from	IN
18637	21733	15	the	the	DT
18637	21733	16	jury	jury	NN
18637	21733	17	except	except	IN
18637	21733	18	when	when	WRB
18637	21733	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21733	20	was	be	VBD
18637	21733	21	a	a	DT
18637	21733	22	member	member	NN
18637	21733	23	of	of	IN
18637	21733	24	the	the	DT
18637	21733	25	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	21733	26	class	class	NN
18637	21733	27	.	.	.
18637	21733	28	"	"	''
18637	21734	1	--Fay	--Fay	:
18637	21734	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21734	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21734	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21734	5	New	New	NNP
18637	21734	6	York	York	NNP
18637	21734	7	,	,	,
18637	21734	8	332	332	CD
18637	21734	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21734	10	261	261	CD
18637	21734	11	,	,	,
18637	21734	12	287	287	CD
18637	21734	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21734	14	1947	1947	CD
18637	21734	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21734	16	.	.	.
18637	21735	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21735	2	876	876	CD
18637	21735	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21735	4	211	211	CD
18637	21735	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21735	6	78	78	CD
18637	21735	7	,	,	,
18637	21735	8	93	93	CD
18637	21735	9	,	,	,
18637	21735	10	106	106	CD
18637	21735	11	-	-	SYM
18637	21735	12	107	107	CD
18637	21735	13	,	,	,
18637	21735	14	113	113	CD
18637	21735	15	;	;	,
18637	21735	16	citing	cite	VBG
18637	21735	17	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	21735	18	_	_	NNP
18637	21735	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	21735	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21735	21	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	21735	22	,	,	,
18637	21735	23	101	101	CD
18637	21735	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21735	25	22	22	CD
18637	21735	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21735	27	1880	1880	CD
18637	21735	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21735	29	;	;	:
18637	21735	30	and	and	CC
18637	21735	31	Holden	Holden	NNP
18637	21735	32	_	_	NNP
18637	21735	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	21735	34	_	_	NNP
18637	21735	35	Hardy	Hardy	NNP
18637	21735	36	,	,	,
18637	21735	37	169	169	CD
18637	21735	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21735	39	366	366	CD
18637	21735	40	,	,	,
18637	21735	41	387	387	CD
18637	21735	42	,	,	,
18637	21735	43	389	389	CD
18637	21735	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21735	45	1898	1898	CD
18637	21735	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21735	47	.	.	.
18637	21736	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21736	2	877	877	CD
18637	21736	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21736	4	In	in	IN
18637	21736	5	several	several	JJ
18637	21736	6	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	21736	7	the	the	DT
18637	21736	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21736	9	,	,	,
18637	21736	10	assuming	assume	VBG
18637	21736	11	,	,	,
18637	21736	12	but	but	CC
18637	21736	13	without	without	IN
18637	21736	14	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	21736	15	,	,	,
18637	21736	16	that	that	IN
18637	21736	17	a	a	DT
18637	21736	18	State	State	NNP
18637	21736	19	law	law	NN
18637	21736	20	requiring	require	VBG
18637	21736	21	a	a	DT
18637	21736	22	witness	witness	NN
18637	21736	23	to	to	TO
18637	21736	24	answer	answer	VB
18637	21736	25	incriminating	incriminate	VBG
18637	21736	26	questions	question	NNS
18637	21736	27	would	would	MD
18637	21736	28	violate	violate	VB
18637	21736	29	the	the	DT
18637	21736	30	due	due	JJ
18637	21736	31	process	process	NN
18637	21736	32	clause	clause	NN
18637	21736	33	,	,	,
18637	21736	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	21736	35	then	then	RB
18637	21736	36	proceeded	proceed	VBN
18637	21736	37	to	to	TO
18637	21736	38	conclude	conclude	VB
18637	21736	39	,	,	,
18637	21736	40	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	21736	41	,	,	,
18637	21736	42	that	that	IN
18637	21736	43	a	a	DT
18637	21736	44	State	State	NNP
18637	21736	45	antitrust	antitrust	JJ
18637	21736	46	law	law	NN
18637	21736	47	which	which	WDT
18637	21736	48	grants	grant	VBZ
18637	21736	49	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	21736	50	from	from	IN
18637	21736	51	local	local	JJ
18637	21736	52	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	21736	53	to	to	IN
18637	21736	54	a	a	DT
18637	21736	55	witness	witness	NN
18637	21736	56	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	21736	57	to	to	TO
18637	21736	58	testify	testify	VB
18637	21736	59	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	21736	60	is	be	VBZ
18637	21736	61	valid	valid	JJ
18637	21736	62	even	even	RB
18637	21736	63	though	though	IN
18637	21736	64	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	21736	65	thus	thus	RB
18637	21736	66	extracted	extract	VBD
18637	21736	67	may	may	MD
18637	21736	68	later	later	RB
18637	21736	69	serve	serve	VB
18637	21736	70	as	as	IN
18637	21736	71	the	the	DT
18637	21736	72	basis	basis	NN
18637	21736	73	of	of	IN
18637	21736	74	a	a	DT
18637	21736	75	federal	federal	JJ
18637	21736	76	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	21736	77	for	for	IN
18637	21736	78	violation	violation	NN
18637	21736	79	of	of	IN
18637	21736	80	federal	federal	JJ
18637	21736	81	antitrust	antitrust	JJ
18637	21736	82	laws.--Jack	laws.--jack	NN
18637	21736	83	_	_	NNP
18637	21736	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	21736	85	_	_	NNP
18637	21736	86	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	21736	87	,	,	,
18637	21736	88	199	199	CD
18637	21736	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21736	90	372	372	CD
18637	21736	91	,	,	,
18637	21736	92	380	380	CD
18637	21736	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21736	94	1905	1905	CD
18637	21736	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21736	96	.	.	.
18637	21737	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21737	2	878	878	CD
18637	21737	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21737	4	Snyder	Snyder	NNP
18637	21737	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21737	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21737	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21737	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21737	9	,	,	,
18637	21737	10	291	291	CD
18637	21737	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21737	12	97	97	CD
18637	21737	13	,	,	,
18637	21737	14	105	105	CD
18637	21737	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21737	16	1934	1934	CD
18637	21737	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21737	18	.	.	.
18637	21738	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21738	2	879	879	CD
18637	21738	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21738	4	Palko	Palko	NNP
18637	21738	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21738	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21738	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21738	8	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	21738	9	,	,	,
18637	21738	10	302	302	CD
18637	21738	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21738	12	319	319	CD
18637	21738	13	,	,	,
18637	21738	14	325	325	CD
18637	21738	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21738	16	326	326	CD
18637	21738	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21738	18	1937	1937	CD
18637	21738	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21738	20	.	.	.
18637	21739	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21739	2	880	880	CD
18637	21739	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21739	4	297	297	CD
18637	21739	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21739	6	278	278	CD
18637	21739	7	,	,	,
18637	21739	8	285	285	CD
18637	21739	9	-	-	SYM
18637	21739	10	286	286	CD
18637	21739	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21739	12	1936	1936	CD
18637	21739	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21739	14	.	.	.
18637	21740	1	For	for	IN
18637	21740	2	the	the	DT
18637	21740	3	significance	significance	NN
18637	21740	4	of	of	IN
18637	21740	5	this	this	DT
18637	21740	6	decision	decision	NN
18637	21740	7	as	as	IN
18637	21740	8	a	a	DT
18637	21740	9	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	21740	10	in	in	IN
18637	21740	11	favor	favor	NN
18637	21740	12	of	of	IN
18637	21740	13	a	a	DT
18637	21740	14	more	more	RBR
18637	21740	15	careful	careful	JJ
18637	21740	16	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
18637	21740	17	by	by	IN
18637	21740	18	the	the	DT
18637	21740	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21740	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21740	21	of	of	IN
18637	21740	22	State	State	NNP
18637	21740	23	trials	trial	NNS
18637	21740	24	in	in	IN
18637	21740	25	which	which	WDT
18637	21740	26	a	a	DT
18637	21740	27	denial	denial	NN
18637	21740	28	of	of	IN
18637	21740	29	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	21740	30	rights	right	NNS
18637	21740	31	allegedly	allegedly	RB
18637	21740	32	occurred	occur	VBD
18637	21740	33	,	,	,
18637	21740	34	see	see	VB
18637	21740	35	p.	p.	NN
18637	21740	36	1138	1138	CD
18637	21740	37	.	.	.
18637	21741	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21741	2	881	881	CD
18637	21741	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21741	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21741	5	,	,	,
18637	21741	6	285	285	CD
18637	21741	7	-	-	SYM
18637	21741	8	286	286	CD
18637	21741	9	.	.	.
18637	21742	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21742	2	882	882	CD
18637	21742	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21742	4	309	309	CD
18637	21742	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21742	6	227	227	CD
18637	21742	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21742	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	21742	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21742	10	.	.	.
18637	21743	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21743	2	883	883	CD
18637	21743	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21743	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21743	5	.	.	.
18637	21744	1	228	228	CD
18637	21744	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21744	3	229	229	CD
18637	21744	4	,	,	,
18637	21744	5	237	237	CD
18637	21744	6	-	-	SYM
18637	21744	7	241	241	CD
18637	21744	8	.	.	.
18637	21745	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21745	2	884	884	CD
18637	21745	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21745	4	310	310	CD
18637	21745	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21745	6	530	530	CD
18637	21745	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21745	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	21745	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21745	10	.	.	.
18637	21746	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21746	2	885	885	CD
18637	21746	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21746	4	314	314	CD
18637	21746	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21746	6	219	219	CD
18637	21746	7	,	,	,
18637	21746	8	237	237	CD
18637	21746	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21746	10	1941	1941	CD
18637	21746	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21746	12	.	.	.
18637	21747	1	This	this	DT
18637	21747	2	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	21747	3	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	21747	4	the	the	DT
18637	21747	5	closest	close	JJS
18637	21747	6	approach	approach	NN
18637	21747	7	which	which	WDT
18637	21747	8	the	the	DT
18637	21747	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21747	10	thus	thus	RB
18637	21747	11	far	far	RB
18637	21747	12	has	have	VBZ
18637	21747	13	made	make	VBN
18637	21747	14	toward	toward	IN
18637	21747	15	inclusion	inclusion	NN
18637	21747	16	of	of	IN
18637	21747	17	the	the	DT
18637	21747	18	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	21747	19	against	against	IN
18637	21747	20	self	self	NN
18637	21747	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	21747	22	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	21747	23	within	within	IN
18637	21747	24	the	the	DT
18637	21747	25	due	due	JJ
18637	21747	26	process	process	NN
18637	21747	27	clause	clause	NN
18637	21747	28	of	of	IN
18637	21747	29	the	the	DT
18637	21747	30	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21747	31	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21747	32	.	.	.
18637	21748	1	In	in	IN
18637	21748	2	all	all	DT
18637	21748	3	but	but	IN
18637	21748	4	a	a	DT
18637	21748	5	few	few	JJ
18637	21748	6	of	of	IN
18637	21748	7	the	the	DT
18637	21748	8	forced	force	VBN
18637	21748	9	confession	confession	NN
18637	21748	10	cases	case	NNS
18637	21748	11	,	,	,
18637	21748	12	however	however	RB
18637	21748	13	,	,	,
18637	21748	14	the	the	DT
18637	21748	15	results	result	NNS
18637	21748	16	achieved	achieve	VBN
18637	21748	17	by	by	IN
18637	21748	18	application	application	NN
18637	21748	19	of	of	IN
18637	21748	20	the	the	DT
18637	21748	21	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	21748	22	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	21748	23	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	21748	24	differ	differ	VBP
18637	21748	25	scarcely	scarcely	RB
18637	21748	26	at	at	RB
18637	21748	27	all	all	RB
18637	21748	28	from	from	IN
18637	21748	29	those	those	DT
18637	21748	30	attainable	attainable	JJ
18637	21748	31	by	by	IN
18637	21748	32	incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	21748	33	of	of	IN
18637	21748	34	the	the	DT
18637	21748	35	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	21748	36	within	within	IN
18637	21748	37	that	that	DT
18637	21748	38	clause	clause	NN
18637	21748	39	.	.	.
18637	21749	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21749	2	886	886	CD
18637	21749	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21749	4	316	316	CD
18637	21749	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21749	6	547	547	CD
18637	21749	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21749	8	1942	1942	CD
18637	21749	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21749	10	.	.	.
18637	21750	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21750	2	887	887	CD
18637	21750	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21750	4	322	322	CD
18637	21750	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21750	6	143	143	CD
18637	21750	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21750	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	21750	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21750	10	.	.	.
18637	21751	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21751	2	888	888	CD
18637	21751	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21751	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21751	5	See	See	NNP
18637	21751	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21751	7	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	21751	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21751	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	21751	10	_	_	NNP
18637	21751	11	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	21751	12	,	,	,
18637	21751	13	281	281	CD
18637	21751	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21751	15	586	586	CD
18637	21751	16	,	,	,
18637	21751	17	595	595	CD
18637	21751	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21751	19	1930	1930	CD
18637	21751	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21751	21	.	.	.
18637	21752	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21752	2	889	889	CD
18637	21752	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21752	4	322	322	CD
18637	21752	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21752	6	143	143	CD
18637	21752	7	,	,	,
18637	21752	8	160	160	CD
18637	21752	9	-	-	SYM
18637	21752	10	162	162	CD
18637	21752	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21752	12	1944).--All	1944).--all	CD
18637	21752	13	members	member	NNS
18637	21752	14	of	of	IN
18637	21752	15	the	the	DT
18637	21752	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21752	17	were	be	VBD
18637	21752	18	in	in	IN
18637	21752	19	accord	accord	NN
18637	21752	20	,	,	,
18637	21752	21	however	however	RB
18637	21752	22	,	,	,
18637	21752	23	in	in	IN
18637	21752	24	condemning	condemn	VBG
18637	21752	25	,	,	,
18637	21752	26	as	as	IN
18637	21752	27	no	no	DT
18637	21752	28	less	less	RBR
18637	21752	29	a	a	DT
18637	21752	30	denial	denial	NN
18637	21752	31	of	of	IN
18637	21752	32	due	due	JJ
18637	21752	33	process	process	NN
18637	21752	34	,	,	,
18637	21752	35	the	the	DT
18637	21752	36	admission	admission	NN
18637	21752	37	at	at	IN
18637	21752	38	the	the	DT
18637	21752	39	second	second	JJ
18637	21752	40	trial	trial	NN
18637	21752	41	of	of	IN
18637	21752	42	Ashcraft	Ashcraft	NNP
18637	21752	43	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21752	44	Ashcraft	Ashcraft	NNP
18637	21752	45	_	_	NNP
18637	21752	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	21752	47	_	_	NNP
18637	21752	48	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	21752	49	,	,	,
18637	21752	50	327	327	CD
18637	21752	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21752	52	274	274	CD
18637	21752	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21752	54	1946	1946	CD
18637	21752	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21752	56	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21752	57	of	of	IN
18637	21752	58	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	21752	59	uncovered	uncover	VBN
18637	21752	60	in	in	IN
18637	21752	61	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	21752	62	of	of	IN
18637	21752	63	the	the	DT
18637	21752	64	written	write	VBN
18637	21752	65	confession	confession	NN
18637	21752	66	,	,	,
18637	21752	67	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	21752	68	of	of	IN
18637	21752	69	which	which	WDT
18637	21752	70	at	at	IN
18637	21752	71	the	the	DT
18637	21752	72	first	first	JJ
18637	21752	73	trial	trial	NN
18637	21752	74	had	have	VBD
18637	21752	75	led	lead	VBN
18637	21752	76	to	to	IN
18637	21752	77	the	the	DT
18637	21752	78	reversal	reversal	NN
18637	21752	79	of	of	IN
18637	21752	80	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21752	81	prior	prior	JJ
18637	21752	82	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	21752	83	.	.	.
18637	21753	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21753	2	890	890	CD
18637	21753	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21753	4	322	322	CD
18637	21753	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21753	6	596	596	CD
18637	21753	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21753	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	21753	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21753	10	.	.	.
18637	21754	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21754	2	891	891	CD
18637	21754	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21754	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21754	5	.	.	.
18637	21755	1	602.--Of	602.--of	CD
18637	21755	2	three	three	CD
18637	21755	3	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	21755	4	who	who	WP
18637	21755	5	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	21755	6	,	,	,
18637	21755	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21755	8	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21755	9	,	,	,
18637	21755	10	with	with	IN
18637	21755	11	whom	whom	WP
18637	21755	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21755	13	Black	Black	NNP
18637	21755	14	was	be	VBD
18637	21755	15	associated	associate	VBN
18637	21755	16	,	,	,
18637	21755	17	declared	declare	VBD
18637	21755	18	that	that	IN
18637	21755	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21755	20	was	be	VBD
18637	21755	21	"	"	``
18637	21755	22	inconceivable	inconceivable	JJ
18637	21755	23	*	*	NFP
18637	21755	24	*	*	NFP
18637	21755	25	*	*	NFP
18637	21755	26	that	that	IN
18637	21755	27	the	the	DT
18637	21755	28	second	second	JJ
18637	21755	29	confession	confession	NN
18637	21755	30	was	be	VBD
18637	21755	31	free	free	JJ
18637	21755	32	from	from	IN
18637	21755	33	the	the	DT
18637	21755	34	coercive	coercive	JJ
18637	21755	35	atmosphere	atmosphere	NN
18637	21755	36	that	that	WDT
18637	21755	37	admittedly	admittedly	RB
18637	21755	38	impregnated	impregnate	VBD
18637	21755	39	the	the	DT
18637	21755	40	first	first	JJ
18637	21755	41	one	one	CD
18637	21755	42	"	"	''
18637	21755	43	;	;	:
18637	21755	44	and	and	CC
18637	21755	45	added	add	VBD
18637	21755	46	that	that	IN
18637	21755	47	previous	previous	JJ
18637	21755	48	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	21755	49	of	of	IN
18637	21755	50	this	this	DT
18637	21755	51	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21755	52	"	"	''
18637	21755	53	in	in	IN
18637	21755	54	effect	effect	NN
18637	21755	55	have	have	VBP
18637	21755	56	held	hold	VBN
18637	21755	57	that	that	IN
18637	21755	58	the	the	DT
18637	21755	59	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21755	60	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21755	61	makes	make	VBZ
18637	21755	62	the	the	DT
18637	21755	63	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	21755	64	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21755	65	of	of	IN
18637	21755	66	the	the	DT
18637	21755	67	Fifth	fifth	JJ
18637	21755	68	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	21755	69	to	to	IN
18637	21755	70	self	self	NN
18637	21755	71	-	-	HYPH
18637	21755	72	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	21755	73	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21755	74	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	21755	75	to	to	IN
18637	21755	76	the	the	DT
18637	21755	77	States	States	NNP
18637	21755	78	.	.	.
18637	21755	79	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	21755	80	.	.	.
18637	21756	1	605	605	CD
18637	21756	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21756	3	606	606	CD
18637	21756	4	.	.	.
18637	21757	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21757	2	892	892	CD
18637	21757	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21757	4	324	324	CD
18637	21757	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21757	6	401	401	CD
18637	21757	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21757	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	21757	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21757	10	.	.	.
18637	21758	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21758	2	893	893	CD
18637	21758	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21758	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	21758	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21758	6	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	21758	7	,	,	,
18637	21758	8	together	together	RB
18637	21758	9	with	with	IN
18637	21758	10	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21758	11	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	21758	12	,	,	,
18637	21758	13	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	21758	14	,	,	,
18637	21758	15	and	and	CC
18637	21758	16	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	21758	17	,	,	,
18637	21758	18	all	all	DT
18637	21758	19	of	of	IN
18637	21758	20	whom	whom	WP
18637	21758	21	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	21758	22	,	,	,
18637	21758	23	would	would	MD
18637	21758	24	have	have	VB
18637	21758	25	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	21758	26	the	the	DT
18637	21758	27	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	21758	28	.	.	.
18637	21759	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21759	2	894	894	CD
18637	21759	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21759	4	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21759	5	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21759	6	and	and	CC
18637	21759	7	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21759	8	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	21759	9	in	in	IN
18637	21759	10	part	part	NN
18637	21759	11	,	,	,
18637	21759	12	assigning	assign	VBG
18637	21759	13	among	among	IN
18637	21759	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21759	15	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	21759	16	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	21759	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21759	18	belief	belief	NN
18637	21759	19	that	that	IN
18637	21759	20	the	the	DT
18637	21759	21	"	"	``
18637	21759	22	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	21759	23	confessions	confession	NNS
18637	21759	24	,	,	,
18637	21759	25	*	*	NFP
18637	21759	26	*	*	NFP
18637	21759	27	*	*	NFP
18637	21759	28	,	,	,
18637	21759	29	were	be	VBD
18637	21759	30	vitiated	vitiate	VBN
18637	21759	31	with	with	IN
18637	21759	32	all	all	PDT
18637	21759	33	the	the	DT
18637	21759	34	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	21759	35	which	which	WDT
18637	21759	36	destroys	destroy	VBZ
18637	21759	37	admissibility	admissibility	NN
18637	21759	38	of	of	IN
18637	21759	39	the	the	DT
18637	21759	40	first	first	JJ
18637	21759	41	one	one	CD
18637	21759	42	.	.	.
18637	21759	43	"	"	''
18637	21760	1	According	accord	VBG
18637	21760	2	to	to	IN
18637	21760	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21760	4	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21760	5	,	,	,
18637	21760	6	"	"	''
18637	21760	7	a	a	DT
18637	21760	8	stricter	strict	JJR
18637	21760	9	standard	standard	NN
18637	21760	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	21760	11	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	21760	12	where	where	WRB
18637	21760	13	the	the	DT
18637	21760	14	confession	confession	NN
18637	21760	15	tendered	tender	VBD
18637	21760	16	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	21760	17	a	a	DT
18637	21760	18	prior	prior	RB
18637	21760	19	coerced	coerce	VBN
18637	21760	20	one	one	CD
18637	21760	21	than	than	IN
18637	21760	22	in	in	IN
18637	21760	23	the	the	DT
18637	21760	24	case	case	NN
18637	21760	25	of	of	IN
18637	21760	26	a	a	DT
18637	21760	27	single	single	JJ
18637	21760	28	confession	confession	NN
18637	21760	29	*	*	NFP
18637	21760	30	*	*	NFP
18637	21760	31	*	*	NFP
18637	21760	32	.	.	.
18637	21761	1	Once	once	RB
18637	21761	2	a	a	DT
18637	21761	3	coerced	coerced	JJ
18637	21761	4	confession	confession	NN
18637	21761	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	21761	6	been	be	VBN
18637	21761	7	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	21761	8	all	all	DT
18637	21761	9	later	later	JJ
18637	21761	10	ones	one	NNS
18637	21761	11	should	should	MD
18637	21761	12	be	be	VB
18637	21761	13	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	21761	14	from	from	IN
18637	21761	15	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	21761	16	,	,	,
18637	21761	17	wherever	wherever	WRB
18637	21761	18	there	there	EX
18637	21761	19	is	be	VBZ
18637	21761	20	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	21761	21	that	that	IN
18637	21761	22	the	the	DT
18637	21761	23	coerced	coerced	JJ
18637	21761	24	one	one	CD
18637	21761	25	has	have	VBZ
18637	21761	26	been	be	VBN
18637	21761	27	used	use	VBN
18637	21761	28	to	to	TO
18637	21761	29	secure	secure	VB
18637	21761	30	the	the	DT
18637	21761	31	later	later	JJ
18637	21761	32	ones	one	NNS
18637	21761	33	.	.	.
18637	21761	34	"	"	''
18637	21762	1	--324	--324	:
18637	21762	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21762	3	401	401	CD
18637	21762	4	,	,	,
18637	21762	5	420	420	CD
18637	21762	6	,	,	,
18637	21762	7	428	428	CD
18637	21762	8	-	-	SYM
18637	21762	9	429	429	CD
18637	21762	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21762	11	1945	1945	CD
18637	21762	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21762	13	.	.	.
18637	21763	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21763	2	895	895	CD
18637	21763	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21763	4	In	in	IN
18637	21763	5	Lyons	Lyons	NNP
18637	21763	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21763	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21763	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21763	9	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	21763	10	,	,	,
18637	21763	11	322	322	CD
18637	21763	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21763	13	596	596	CD
18637	21763	14	,	,	,
18637	21763	15	601	601	CD
18637	21763	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21763	17	1944	1944	CD
18637	21763	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21763	19	,	,	,
18637	21763	20	the	the	DT
18637	21763	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21763	22	stated	state	VBD
18637	21763	23	that	that	IN
18637	21763	24	"	"	``
18637	21763	25	when	when	WRB
18637	21763	26	the	the	DT
18637	21763	27	State	state	NN
18637	21763	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	21763	29	approved	approve	VBN
18637	21763	30	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	21763	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21763	32	to	to	IN
18637	21763	33	the	the	DT
18637	21763	34	jury	jury	NN
18637	21763	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21763	36	fairly	fairly	RB
18637	21763	37	raises	raise	VBZ
18637	21763	38	the	the	DT
18637	21763	39	question	question	NN
18637	21763	40	of	of	IN
18637	21763	41	whether	whether	IN
18637	21763	42	or	or	CC
18637	21763	43	not	not	RB
18637	21763	44	the	the	DT
18637	21763	45	challenged	challenge	VBN
18637	21763	46	confession	confession	NN
18637	21763	47	was	be	VBD
18637	21763	48	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	21763	49	,	,	,
18637	21763	50	*	*	NFP
18637	21763	51	*	*	NFP
18637	21763	52	*	*	NFP
18637	21763	53	,	,	,
18637	21763	54	the	the	DT
18637	21763	55	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	21763	56	of	of	IN
18637	21763	57	due	due	JJ
18637	21763	58	process	process	NN
18637	21763	59	,	,	,
18637	21763	60	*	*	NFP
18637	21763	61	*	*	NFP
18637	21763	62	*	*	NFP
18637	21763	63	,	,	,
18637	21763	64	are	be	VBP
18637	21763	65	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
18637	21763	66	and	and	CC
18637	21763	67	this	this	DT
18637	21763	68	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21763	69	will	will	MD
18637	21763	70	not	not	RB
18637	21763	71	require	require	VB
18637	21763	72	a	a	DT
18637	21763	73	modification	modification	NN
18637	21763	74	of	of	IN
18637	21763	75	local	local	JJ
18637	21763	76	practice	practice	NN
18637	21763	77	to	to	TO
18637	21763	78	meet	meet	VB
18637	21763	79	views	view	NNS
18637	21763	80	that	that	IN
18637	21763	81	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21763	82	might	may	MD
18637	21763	83	have	have	VB
18637	21763	84	as	as	IN
18637	21763	85	to	to	IN
18637	21763	86	*	*	NFP
18637	21763	87	*	*	NFP
18637	21763	88	*	*	NFP
18637	21763	89	how	how	WRB
18637	21763	90	specific	specific	JJ
18637	21763	91	an	an	DT
18637	21763	92	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	21763	93	*	*	NFP
18637	21763	94	*	*	NFP
18637	21763	95	*	*	NFP
18637	21763	96	must	must	MD
18637	21763	97	be	be	VB
18637	21763	98	.	.	.
18637	21763	99	"	"	''
18637	21764	1	In	in	IN
18637	21764	2	Malinski	Malinski	NNP
18637	21764	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21764	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	21764	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21764	6	New	New	NNP
18637	21764	7	York	York	NNP
18637	21764	8	,	,	,
18637	21764	9	the	the	DT
18637	21764	10	four	four	CD
18637	21764	11	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	21764	12	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21764	13	declared	declare	VBD
18637	21764	14	that	that	IN
18637	21764	15	"	"	``
18637	21764	16	the	the	DT
18637	21764	17	trial	trial	NN
18637	21764	18	court	court	NN
18637	21764	19	,	,	,
18637	21764	20	*	*	NFP
18637	21764	21	*	*	NFP
18637	21764	22	*	*	NFP
18637	21764	23	,	,	,
18637	21764	24	instructed	instruct	VBD
18637	21764	25	the	the	DT
18637	21764	26	jury	jury	NN
18637	21764	27	that	that	IN
18637	21764	28	the	the	DT
18637	21764	29	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	21764	30	with	with	IN
18637	21764	31	respect	respect	NN
18637	21764	32	to	to	IN
18637	21764	33	the	the	DT
18637	21764	34	first	first	JJ
18637	21764	35	confession	confession	NN
18637	21764	36	was	be	VBD
18637	21764	37	adduced	adduce	VBN
18637	21764	38	only	only	RB
18637	21764	39	to	to	TO
18637	21764	40	show	show	VB
18637	21764	41	that	that	IN
18637	21764	42	the	the	DT
18637	21764	43	second	second	JJ
18637	21764	44	was	be	VBD
18637	21764	45	coerced	coerce	VBN
18637	21764	46	.	.	.
18637	21765	1	And	and	CC
18637	21765	2	*	*	NFP
18637	21765	3	*	*	NFP
18637	21765	4	*	*	NFP
18637	21765	5	that	that	IN
18637	21765	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21765	7	could	could	MD
18637	21765	8	consider	consider	VB
18637	21765	9	the	the	DT
18637	21765	10	second	second	JJ
18637	21765	11	confession	confession	NN
18637	21765	12	,	,	,
18637	21765	13	only	only	RB
18637	21765	14	if	if	IN
18637	21765	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21765	16	found	find	VBD
18637	21765	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21765	18	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	21765	19	,	,	,
18637	21765	20	and	and	CC
18637	21765	21	that	that	IN
18637	21765	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21765	23	could	could	MD
18637	21765	24	convict	convict	VB
18637	21765	25	in	in	IN
18637	21765	26	that	that	DT
18637	21765	27	case	case	NN
18637	21765	28	.	.	.
18637	21766	1	In	in	IN
18637	21766	2	view	view	NN
18637	21766	3	of	of	IN
18637	21766	4	these	these	DT
18637	21766	5	instructions	instruction	NNS
18637	21766	6	,	,	,
18637	21766	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21766	8	can	can	MD
18637	21766	9	not	not	RB
18637	21766	10	say	say	VB
18637	21766	11	that	that	IN
18637	21766	12	the	the	DT
18637	21766	13	first	first	JJ
18637	21766	14	confession	confession	NN
18637	21766	15	was	be	VBD
18637	21766	16	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	21766	17	to	to	IN
18637	21766	18	the	the	DT
18637	21766	19	jury	jury	NN
18637	21766	20	,	,	,
18637	21766	21	or	or	CC
18637	21766	22	that	that	IN
18637	21766	23	in	in	IN
18637	21766	24	the	the	DT
18637	21766	25	absence	absence	NN
18637	21766	26	of	of	IN
18637	21766	27	any	any	DT
18637	21766	28	exception	exception	NN
18637	21766	29	or	or	CC
18637	21766	30	request	request	NN
18637	21766	31	to	to	TO
18637	21766	32	charge	charge	VB
18637	21766	33	more	more	RBR
18637	21766	34	particularly	particularly	RB
18637	21766	35	,	,	,
18637	21766	36	there	there	EX
18637	21766	37	was	be	VBD
18637	21766	38	any	any	DT
18637	21766	39	error	error	NN
18637	21766	40	,	,	,
18637	21766	41	of	of	IN
18637	21766	42	which	which	WDT
18637	21766	43	the	the	DT
18637	21766	44	*	*	NFP
18637	21766	45	*	*	NFP
18637	21766	46	*	*	NFP
18637	21766	47	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21766	48	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21766	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21766	50	can	can	MD
18637	21766	51	complain	complain	VB
18637	21766	52	.	.	.
18637	21766	53	"	"	''
18637	21767	1	--324	--324	:
18637	21767	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21767	3	401	401	CD
18637	21767	4	,	,	,
18637	21767	5	437	437	CD
18637	21767	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21767	7	1945	1945	CD
18637	21767	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21767	9	.	.	.
18637	21768	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21768	2	896	896	CD
18637	21768	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21768	4	The	the	DT
18637	21768	5	coercive	coercive	JJ
18637	21768	6	nature	nature	NN
18637	21768	7	of	of	IN
18637	21768	8	the	the	DT
18637	21768	9	first	first	JJ
18637	21768	10	oral	oral	JJ
18637	21768	11	confession	confession	NN
18637	21768	12	was	be	VBD
18637	21768	13	apparently	apparently	RB
18637	21768	14	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	21768	15	by	by	IN
18637	21768	16	the	the	DT
18637	21768	17	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
18637	21768	18	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	21768	19	in	in	IN
18637	21768	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21768	21	summation	summation	NN
18637	21768	22	to	to	IN
18637	21768	23	the	the	DT
18637	21768	24	jury	jury	NN
18637	21768	25	;	;	:
18637	21768	26	for	for	IN
18637	21768	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21768	28	declared	declare	VBD
18637	21768	29	that	that	IN
18637	21768	30	the	the	DT
18637	21768	31	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21768	32	"	"	''
18637	21768	33	was	be	VBD
18637	21768	34	not	not	RB
18637	21768	35	hard	hard	JJ
18637	21768	36	to	to	TO
18637	21768	37	break	break	VB
18637	21768	38	,	,	,
18637	21768	39	"	"	''
18637	21768	40	and	and	CC
18637	21768	41	that	that	IN
18637	21768	42	the	the	DT
18637	21768	43	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	21768	44	of	of	IN
18637	21768	45	holding	hold	VBG
18637	21768	46	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21768	47	_	_	NNP
18637	21768	48	incommunicado	incommunicado	NNP
18637	21768	49	_	_	NNP
18637	21768	50	and	and	CC
18637	21768	51	unclothed	unclothed	JJ
18637	21768	52	in	in	IN
18637	21768	53	a	a	DT
18637	21768	54	hotel	hotel	NN
18637	21768	55	room	room	NN
18637	21768	56	from	from	IN
18637	21768	57	8	8	CD
18637	21768	58	a.m.	a.m.	NN
18637	21768	59	to	to	IN
18637	21768	60	6	6	CD
18637	21768	61	p.m.	p.m.	RB
18637	21768	62	,	,	,
18637	21768	63	when	when	WRB
18637	21768	64	the	the	DT
18637	21768	65	confession	confession	NN
18637	21768	66	was	be	VBD
18637	21768	67	made	make	VBN
18637	21768	68	,	,	,
18637	21768	69	was	be	VBD
18637	21768	70	to	to	TO
18637	21768	71	"	"	``
18637	21768	72	let	let	VB
18637	21768	73	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21768	74	think	think	VB
18637	21768	75	that	that	IN
18637	21768	76	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21768	77	is	be	VBZ
18637	21768	78	going	go	VBG
18637	21768	79	to	to	TO
18637	21768	80	get	get	VB
18637	21768	81	a	a	DT
18637	21768	82	shellacking	shellacking	NN
18637	21768	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21768	84	beating	beating	NN
18637	21768	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21768	86	.	.	.
18637	21768	87	"	"	''
18637	21769	1	--324	--324	:
18637	21769	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21769	3	401	401	CD
18637	21769	4	,	,	,
18637	21769	5	407	407	CD
18637	21769	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21769	7	1945	1945	CD
18637	21769	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21769	9	.	.	.
18637	21770	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21770	2	897	897	CD
18637	21770	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21770	4	332	332	CD
18637	21770	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21770	6	46	46	CD
18637	21770	7	,	,	,
18637	21770	8	56	56	CD
18637	21770	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21770	10	1947	1947	CD
18637	21770	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21770	12	.	.	.
18637	21771	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21771	2	898	898	CD
18637	21771	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21771	4	211	211	CD
18637	21771	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21771	6	78	78	CD
18637	21771	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21771	8	1908	1908	CD
18637	21771	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21771	10	.	.	.
18637	21772	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21772	2	899	899	CD
18637	21772	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21772	4	302	302	CD
18637	21772	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21772	6	319	319	CD
18637	21772	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21772	8	1937	1937	CD
18637	21772	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21772	10	.	.	.
18637	21773	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21773	2	900	900	CD
18637	21773	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21773	4	Adamson	Adamson	NNP
18637	21773	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21773	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21773	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21773	8	California	California	NNP
18637	21773	9	,	,	,
18637	21773	10	332	332	CD
18637	21773	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21773	12	46	46	CD
18637	21773	13	,	,	,
18637	21773	14	50	50	CD
18637	21773	15	,	,	,
18637	21773	16	53	53	CD
18637	21773	17	,	,	,
18637	21773	18	56	56	CD
18637	21773	19	,	,	,
18637	21773	20	58	58	CD
18637	21773	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21773	22	1947	1947	CD
18637	21773	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21773	24	.	.	.
18637	21774	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21774	2	901	901	CD
18637	21774	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21774	4	Adamson	Adamson	NNP
18637	21774	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21774	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21774	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21774	8	California	California	NNP
18637	21774	9	,	,	,
18637	21774	10	332	332	CD
18637	21774	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21774	12	46	46	CD
18637	21774	13	,	,	,
18637	21774	14	59	59	CD
18637	21774	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21774	16	60	60	CD
18637	21774	17	,	,	,
18637	21774	18	63	63	CD
18637	21774	19	-	-	SYM
18637	21774	20	64	64	CD
18637	21774	21	,	,	,
18637	21774	22	66	66	CD
18637	21774	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21774	24	1947	1947	CD
18637	21774	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21774	26	.	.	.
18637	21775	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21775	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21775	3	also	also	RB
18637	21775	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21775	5	Malinski	Malinski	NNP
18637	21775	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21775	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21775	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21775	9	New	New	NNP
18637	21775	10	York	York	NNP
18637	21775	11	,	,	,
18637	21775	12	324	324	CD
18637	21775	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21775	14	401	401	CD
18637	21775	15	,	,	,
18637	21775	16	414	414	CD
18637	21775	17	,	,	,
18637	21775	18	415	415	CD
18637	21775	19	,	,	,
18637	21775	20	417	417	CD
18637	21775	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21775	22	1945	1945	CD
18637	21775	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21775	24	.	.	.
18637	21776	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21776	2	902	902	CD
18637	21776	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21776	4	Adamson	Adamson	NNP
18637	21776	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21776	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21776	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21776	8	California	California	NNP
18637	21776	9	,	,	,
18637	21776	10	332	332	CD
18637	21776	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21776	12	46	46	CD
18637	21776	13	,	,	,
18637	21776	14	69	69	CD
18637	21776	15	,	,	,
18637	21776	16	74	74	CD
18637	21776	17	-	-	SYM
18637	21776	18	75	75	CD
18637	21776	19	,	,	,
18637	21776	20	89	89	CD
18637	21776	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21776	22	1947).--Dissenting	1947).--dissente	VBG
18637	21776	23	separately	separately	RB
18637	21776	24	,	,	,
18637	21776	25	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21776	26	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21776	27	,	,	,
18637	21776	28	together	together	RB
18637	21776	29	with	with	IN
18637	21776	30	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21776	31	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21776	32	,	,	,
18637	21776	33	announced	announce	VBD
18637	21776	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21776	35	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	21776	36	with	with	IN
18637	21776	37	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21776	38	Black	Black	NNP
18637	21776	39	,	,	,
18637	21776	40	subject	subject	JJ
18637	21776	41	to	to	IN
18637	21776	42	one	one	CD
18637	21776	43	reservation	reservation	NN
18637	21776	44	.	.	.
18637	21777	1	While	while	IN
18637	21777	2	agreeing	agree	VBG
18637	21777	3	"	"	``
18637	21777	4	that	that	IN
18637	21777	5	the	the	DT
18637	21777	6	specific	specific	JJ
18637	21777	7	guarantees	guarantee	NNS
18637	21777	8	of	of	IN
18637	21777	9	the	the	DT
18637	21777	10	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	21777	11	of	of	IN
18637	21777	12	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	21777	13	should	should	MD
18637	21777	14	be	be	VB
18637	21777	15	carried	carry	VBN
18637	21777	16	over	over	IN
18637	21777	17	intact	intact	JJ
18637	21777	18	into	into	IN
18637	21777	19	the	the	DT
18637	21777	20	first	first	JJ
18637	21777	21	section	section	NN
18637	21777	22	of	of	IN
18637	21777	23	the	the	DT
18637	21777	24	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21777	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21777	26	,	,	,
18637	21777	27	"	"	``
18637	21777	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21777	29	were	be	VBD
18637	21777	30	"	"	``
18637	21777	31	not	not	RB
18637	21777	32	prepared	prepared	JJ
18637	21777	33	to	to	TO
18637	21777	34	say	say	VB
18637	21777	35	that	that	IN
18637	21777	36	the	the	DT
18637	21777	37	latter	latter	NN
18637	21777	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	21777	39	entirely	entirely	RB
18637	21777	40	and	and	CC
18637	21777	41	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	21777	42	limited	limit	VBN
18637	21777	43	by	by	IN
18637	21777	44	the	the	DT
18637	21777	45	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	21777	46	of	of	IN
18637	21777	47	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	21777	48	.	.	.
18637	21778	1	Occasions	occasion	NNS
18637	21778	2	may	may	MD
18637	21778	3	arise	arise	VB
18637	21778	4	where	where	WRB
18637	21778	5	a	a	DT
18637	21778	6	proceeding	proceeding	NN
18637	21778	7	falls	fall	VBZ
18637	21778	8	so	so	RB
18637	21778	9	far	far	RB
18637	21778	10	short	short	RB
18637	21778	11	of	of	IN
18637	21778	12	conforming	conform	VBG
18637	21778	13	to	to	IN
18637	21778	14	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	21778	15	standards	standard	NNS
18637	21778	16	of	of	IN
18637	21778	17	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	21778	18	as	as	IN
18637	21778	19	to	to	TO
18637	21778	20	warrant	warrant	VB
18637	21778	21	*	*	NFP
18637	21778	22	*	*	NFP
18637	21778	23	*	*	NFP
18637	21778	24	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	21778	25	in	in	IN
18637	21778	26	terms	term	NNS
18637	21778	27	of	of	IN
18637	21778	28	a	a	DT
18637	21778	29	lack	lack	NN
18637	21778	30	of	of	IN
18637	21778	31	due	due	JJ
18637	21778	32	process	process	NN
18637	21778	33	despite	despite	IN
18637	21778	34	the	the	DT
18637	21778	35	absence	absence	NN
18637	21778	36	of	of	IN
18637	21778	37	a	a	DT
18637	21778	38	specific	specific	JJ
18637	21778	39	provision	provision	NN
18637	21778	40	in	in	IN
18637	21778	41	the	the	DT
18637	21778	42	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	21778	43	of	of	IN
18637	21778	44	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	21778	45	.	.	.
18637	21778	46	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	21778	47	.	.	.
18637	21779	1	124	124	CD
18637	21779	2	.	.	.
18637	21780	1	In	in	IN
18637	21780	2	a	a	DT
18637	21780	3	lengthy	lengthy	JJ
18637	21780	4	article	article	NN
18637	21780	5	based	base	VBN
18637	21780	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	21780	7	a	a	DT
18637	21780	8	painstaking	painstaking	JJ
18637	21780	9	examination	examination	NN
18637	21780	10	of	of	IN
18637	21780	11	original	original	JJ
18637	21780	12	data	datum	NNS
18637	21780	13	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	21780	14	to	to	IN
18637	21780	15	the	the	DT
18637	21780	16	"	"	``
18637	21780	17	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	21780	18	of	of	IN
18637	21780	19	the	the	DT
18637	21780	20	import	import	NN
18637	21780	21	of	of	IN
18637	21780	22	the	the	DT
18637	21780	23	*	*	NFP
18637	21780	24	*	*	NFP
18637	21780	25	*	*	NFP
18637	21780	26	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	21780	27	of	of	IN
18637	21780	28	Section	section	NN
18637	21780	29	1	1	CD
18637	21780	30	of	of	IN
18637	21780	31	the	the	DT
18637	21780	32	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21780	33	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21780	34	at	at	IN
18637	21780	35	the	the	DT
18637	21780	36	time	time	NN
18637	21780	37	the	the	DT
18637	21780	38	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21780	39	was	be	VBD
18637	21780	40	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	21780	41	"	"	''
18637	21780	42	;	;	:
18637	21780	43	that	that	RB
18637	21780	44	is	is	RB
18637	21780	45	,	,	,
18637	21780	46	during	during	IN
18637	21780	47	the	the	DT
18637	21780	48	period	period	NN
18637	21780	49	1866	1866	CD
18637	21780	50	-	-	SYM
18637	21780	51	1868	1868	CD
18637	21780	52	,	,	,
18637	21780	53	Professor	Professor	NNP
18637	21780	54	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	21780	55	Fairman	Fairman	NNP
18637	21780	56	has	have	VBZ
18637	21780	57	marshalled	marshal	VBN
18637	21780	58	a	a	DT
18637	21780	59	"	"	``
18637	21780	60	mountain	mountain	NN
18637	21780	61	of	of	IN
18637	21780	62	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	21780	63	"	"	''
18637	21780	64	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	21780	65	to	to	TO
18637	21780	66	prove	prove	VB
18637	21780	67	conclusively	conclusively	RB
18637	21780	68	the	the	DT
18637	21780	69	inaccuracy	inaccuracy	NN
18637	21780	70	of	of	IN
18637	21780	71	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21780	72	Black	Black	NNP
18637	21780	73	's	's	POS
18637	21780	74	reading	reading	NN
18637	21780	75	of	of	IN
18637	21780	76	history.--Charles	history.--charles	CD
18637	21780	77	Fairman	fairman	NN
18637	21780	78	.	.	.
18637	21781	1	Does	do	VBZ
18637	21781	2	the	the	DT
18637	21781	3	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21781	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21781	5	Incorporate	Incorporate	NNP
18637	21781	6	the	the	DT
18637	21781	7	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	21781	8	of	of	IN
18637	21781	9	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	21781	10	?	?	.
18637	21782	1	The	the	DT
18637	21782	2	Original	original	JJ
18637	21782	3	Understanding.--2	understanding.--2	CD
18637	21782	4	Stanford	Stanford	NNP
18637	21782	5	Law	Law	NNP
18637	21782	6	Review	Review	NNP
18637	21782	7	,	,	,
18637	21782	8	5	5	CD
18637	21782	9	-	-	SYM
18637	21782	10	139	139	CD
18637	21782	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21782	12	1949	1949	CD
18637	21782	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21782	14	.	.	.
18637	21783	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21783	2	903	903	CD
18637	21783	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21783	4	332	332	CD
18637	21783	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21783	6	596	596	CD
18637	21783	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21783	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	21783	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21783	10	.	.	.
18637	21784	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21784	2	904	904	CD
18637	21784	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21784	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21784	5	.	.	.
18637	21785	1	600	600	CD
18637	21785	2	-	-	:
18637	21785	3	601.--In	601.--in	NN
18637	21785	4	a	a	DT
18637	21785	5	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	21785	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21785	7	,	,	,
18637	21785	8	in	in	IN
18637	21785	9	which	which	WDT
18637	21785	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	21785	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21785	12	Vinson	Vinson	NNP
18637	21785	13	and	and	CC
18637	21785	14	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21785	15	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	21785	16	and	and	CC
18637	21785	17	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	21785	18	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	21785	19	,	,	,
18637	21785	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21785	21	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	21785	22	remarked	remark	VBD
18637	21785	23	that	that	DT
18637	21785	24	inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	21785	25	as	as	IN
18637	21785	26	the	the	DT
18637	21785	27	issue	issue	NN
18637	21785	28	of	of	IN
18637	21785	29	the	the	DT
18637	21785	30	voluntariness	voluntariness	NN
18637	21785	31	of	of	IN
18637	21785	32	the	the	DT
18637	21785	33	confession	confession	NN
18637	21785	34	was	be	VBD
18637	21785	35	one	one	CD
18637	21785	36	of	of	IN
18637	21785	37	fact	fact	NN
18637	21785	38	,	,	,
18637	21785	39	turning	turn	VBG
18637	21785	40	largely	largely	RB
18637	21785	41	on	on	IN
18637	21785	42	the	the	DT
18637	21785	43	credibility	credibility	NN
18637	21785	44	of	of	IN
18637	21785	45	witnesses	witness	NNS
18637	21785	46	,	,	,
18637	21785	47	the	the	DT
18637	21785	48	determination	determination	NN
18637	21785	49	thereof	thereof	VBN
18637	21785	50	by	by	IN
18637	21785	51	the	the	DT
18637	21785	52	trial	trial	NN
18637	21785	53	judge	judge	NN
18637	21785	54	and	and	CC
18637	21785	55	jury	jury	NN
18637	21785	56	should	should	MD
18637	21785	57	not	not	RB
18637	21785	58	be	be	VB
18637	21785	59	overturned	overturn	VBN
18637	21785	60	upon	upon	IN
18637	21785	61	mere	mere	JJ
18637	21785	62	conjecture.--Ibid	conjecture.--ibid	NN
18637	21785	63	.	.	.
18637	21786	1	607	607	CD
18637	21786	2	,	,	,
18637	21786	3	615	615	CD
18637	21786	4	.	.	.
18637	21787	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21787	2	905	905	CD
18637	21787	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21787	4	332	332	CD
18637	21787	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21787	6	742	742	CD
18637	21787	7	,	,	,
18637	21787	8	745	745	CD
18637	21787	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21787	10	1948	1948	CD
18637	21787	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21787	12	.	.	.
18637	21788	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21788	2	906	906	CD
18637	21788	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21788	4	335	335	CD
18637	21788	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21788	6	252	252	CD
18637	21788	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21788	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	21788	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21788	10	.	.	.
18637	21789	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21789	2	907	907	CD
18637	21789	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21789	4	The	the	DT
18637	21789	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21789	6	also	also	RB
18637	21789	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	21789	8	that	that	IN
18637	21789	9	the	the	DT
18637	21789	10	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	21789	11	of	of	IN
18637	21789	12	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	21789	13	,	,	,
18637	21789	14	in	in	IN
18637	21789	15	requiring	require	VBG
18637	21789	16	the	the	DT
18637	21789	17	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21789	18	to	to	TO
18637	21789	19	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	21789	20	permission	permission	NN
18637	21789	21	from	from	IN
18637	21789	22	an	an	DT
18637	21789	23	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	21789	24	court	court	NN
18637	21789	25	before	before	IN
18637	21789	26	filing	file	VBG
18637	21789	27	a	a	DT
18637	21789	28	petition	petition	NN
18637	21789	29	in	in	IN
18637	21789	30	a	a	DT
18637	21789	31	trial	trial	NN
18637	21789	32	court	court	NN
18637	21789	33	for	for	IN
18637	21789	34	a	a	DT
18637	21789	35	writ	writ	NN
18637	21789	36	of	of	IN
18637	21789	37	error	error	NN
18637	21789	38	_	_	NNP
18637	21789	39	coram	coram	NNP
18637	21789	40	nobis	nobis	NNP
18637	21789	41	_	_	NNP
18637	21789	42	was	be	VBD
18637	21789	43	consistent	consistent	JJ
18637	21789	44	with	with	IN
18637	21789	45	due	due	JJ
18637	21789	46	process	process	NN
18637	21789	47	.	.	.
18637	21790	1	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	21790	2	was	be	VBD
18637	21790	3	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	21790	4	to	to	TO
18637	21790	5	possess	possess	VB
18637	21790	6	"	"	``
18637	21790	7	ample	ample	JJ
18637	21790	8	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	21790	9	for	for	IN
18637	21790	10	correcting	correct	VBG
18637	21790	11	the	the	DT
18637	21790	12	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	21790	13	wrong	wrong	NN
18637	21790	14	of	of	IN
18637	21790	15	which	which	WDT
18637	21790	16	the	the	DT
18637	21790	17	*	*	NFP
18637	21790	18	*	*	NFP
18637	21790	19	*	*	NFP
18637	21790	20	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21790	21	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21790	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21790	23	complained	complain	VBN
18637	21790	24	.	.	.
18637	21790	25	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	21790	26	.	.	.
18637	21791	1	254	254	CD
18637	21791	2	,	,	,
18637	21791	3	260	260	CD
18637	21791	4	-	-	SYM
18637	21791	5	261	261	CD
18637	21791	6	.	.	.
18637	21792	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21792	2	908	908	CD
18637	21792	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21792	4	The	the	DT
18637	21792	5	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21792	6	,	,	,
18637	21792	7	in	in	IN
18637	21792	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21792	9	petition	petition	NN
18637	21792	10	,	,	,
18637	21792	11	neither	neither	CC
18637	21792	12	denied	deny	VBD
18637	21792	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21792	14	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	21792	15	nor	nor	CC
18637	21792	16	any	any	DT
18637	21792	17	of	of	IN
18637	21792	18	the	the	DT
18637	21792	19	acts	act	NNS
18637	21792	20	on	on	IN
18637	21792	21	which	which	WDT
18637	21792	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21792	23	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	21792	24	was	be	VBD
18637	21792	25	based	base	VBN
18637	21792	26	.	.	.
18637	21793	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21793	2	simply	simply	RB
18637	21793	3	contended	contend	VBD
18637	21793	4	that	that	IN
18637	21793	5	because	because	IN
18637	21793	6	of	of	IN
18637	21793	7	fear	fear	NN
18637	21793	8	generated	generate	VBN
18637	21793	9	by	by	IN
18637	21793	10	coercive	coercive	JJ
18637	21793	11	police	police	NN
18637	21793	12	methods	method	NNS
18637	21793	13	applied	apply	VBN
18637	21793	14	to	to	IN
18637	21793	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21793	16	,	,	,
18637	21793	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21793	18	had	have	VBD
18637	21793	19	concealed	conceal	VBN
18637	21793	20	such	such	JJ
18637	21793	21	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	21793	22	from	from	IN
18637	21793	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21793	24	own	own	JJ
18637	21793	25	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21793	26	at	at	IN
18637	21793	27	the	the	DT
18637	21793	28	time	time	NN
18637	21793	29	of	of	IN
18637	21793	30	the	the	DT
18637	21793	31	trial	trial	NN
18637	21793	32	and	and	CC
18637	21793	33	had	have	VBD
18637	21793	34	informed	inform	VBN
18637	21793	35	the	the	DT
18637	21793	36	latter	latter	JJ
18637	21793	37	that	that	IN
18637	21793	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21793	39	confessions	confession	NNS
18637	21793	40	were	be	VBD
18637	21793	41	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	21793	42	.	.	.
18637	21794	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21794	2	charges	charge	NNS
18637	21794	3	of	of	IN
18637	21794	4	duress	duress	NN
18637	21794	5	were	be	VBD
18637	21794	6	supported	support	VBN
18637	21794	7	by	by	IN
18637	21794	8	affidavits	affidavit	NNS
18637	21794	9	of	of	IN
18637	21794	10	three	three	CD
18637	21794	11	associates	associate	NNS
18637	21794	12	in	in	IN
18637	21794	13	crime	crime	NN
18637	21794	14	,	,	,
18637	21794	15	none	none	NN
18637	21794	16	of	of	IN
18637	21794	17	whom	whom	WP
18637	21794	18	claims	claim	VBZ
18637	21794	19	to	to	TO
18637	21794	20	have	have	VB
18637	21794	21	seen	see	VBN
18637	21794	22	the	the	DT
18637	21794	23	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	21794	24	beatings	beating	NNS
18637	21794	25	of	of	IN
18637	21794	26	the	the	DT
18637	21794	27	petitioner.--Ibid	petitioner.--ibid	NN
18637	21794	28	.	.	.
18637	21795	1	265	265	CD
18637	21795	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21795	3	266	266	CD
18637	21795	4	.	.	.
18637	21796	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21796	2	909	909	CD
18637	21796	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21796	4	In	in	IN
18637	21796	5	a	a	DT
18637	21796	6	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	21796	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21796	8	,	,	,
18637	21796	9	in	in	IN
18637	21796	10	which	which	WDT
18637	21796	11	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21796	12	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	21796	13	and	and	CC
18637	21796	14	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21796	15	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	21796	16	,	,	,
18637	21796	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21796	18	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21796	19	maintained	maintain	VBD
18637	21796	20	that	that	DT
18637	21796	21	inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	21796	22	as	as	IN
18637	21796	23	there	there	EX
18637	21796	24	was	be	VBD
18637	21796	25	some	some	DT
18637	21796	26	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	21796	27	to	to	TO
18637	21796	28	substantiate	substantiate	VB
18637	21796	29	the	the	DT
18637	21796	30	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	21796	31	's	's	POS
18637	21796	32	claim	claim	NN
18637	21796	33	,	,	,
18637	21796	34	the	the	DT
18637	21796	35	latter	latter	JJ
18637	21796	36	should	should	MD
18637	21796	37	have	have	VB
18637	21796	38	been	be	VBN
18637	21796	39	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	21796	40	a	a	DT
18637	21796	41	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	21796	42	in	in	IN
18637	21796	43	the	the	DT
18637	21796	44	trial	trial	NN
18637	21796	45	court	court	NN
18637	21796	46	.	.	.
18637	21797	1	According	accord	VBG
18637	21797	2	to	to	IN
18637	21797	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21797	4	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21797	5	,	,	,
18637	21797	6	a	a	DT
18637	21797	7	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	21797	8	based	base	VBN
18637	21797	9	on	on	IN
18637	21797	10	a	a	DT
18637	21797	11	coerced	coerced	JJ
18637	21797	12	confession	confession	NN
18637	21797	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	21797	14	"	"	``
18637	21797	15	void	void	RB
18637	21797	16	even	even	RB
18637	21797	17	though	though	IN
18637	21797	18	the	the	DT
18637	21797	19	confession	confession	NN
18637	21797	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	21797	21	in	in	IN
18637	21797	22	fact	fact	NN
18637	21797	23	true	true	JJ
18637	21797	24	"	"	''
18637	21797	25	and	and	CC
18637	21797	26	the	the	DT
18637	21797	27	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	21797	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	21797	29	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	21797	30	.	.	.
18637	21798	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21798	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	21798	3	criticized	criticize	VBD
18637	21798	4	this	this	DT
18637	21798	5	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	21798	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21798	7	as	as	IN
18637	21798	8	having	have	VBG
18637	21798	9	been	be	VBN
18637	21798	10	"	"	``
18637	21798	11	written	write	VBN
18637	21798	12	as	as	IN
18637	21798	13	though	though	IN
18637	21798	14	this	this	DT
18637	21798	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21798	16	was	be	VBD
18637	21798	17	a	a	DT
18637	21798	18	court	court	NN
18637	21798	19	of	of	IN
18637	21798	20	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	21798	21	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	21798	22	for	for	IN
18637	21798	23	revision	revision	NN
18637	21798	24	of	of	IN
18637	21798	25	convictions	conviction	NNS
18637	21798	26	in	in	IN
18637	21798	27	the	the	DT
18637	21798	28	State	State	NNP
18637	21798	29	courts	court	NNS
18637	21798	30	.	.	.
18637	21798	31	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	21798	32	.	.	.
18637	21799	1	272	272	CD
18637	21799	2	,	,	,
18637	21799	3	275	275	CD
18637	21799	4	-	-	SYM
18637	21799	5	276	276	CD
18637	21799	6	.	.	.
18637	21800	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21800	2	910	910	CD
18637	21800	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21800	4	338	338	CD
18637	21800	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21800	6	49	49	CD
18637	21800	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21800	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	21800	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21800	10	.	.	.
18637	21801	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21801	2	911	911	CD
18637	21801	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21801	4	338	338	CD
18637	21801	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21801	6	62	62	CD
18637	21801	7	,	,	,
18637	21801	8	64	64	CD
18637	21801	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21801	10	1949	1949	CD
18637	21801	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21801	12	.	.	.
18637	21802	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21802	2	912	912	CD
18637	21802	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21802	4	338	338	CD
18637	21802	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21802	6	68	68	CD
18637	21802	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21802	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	21802	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21802	10	.	.	.
18637	21803	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21803	2	913	913	CD
18637	21803	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21803	4	Watts	Watts	NNP
18637	21803	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21803	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21803	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21803	8	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	21803	9	,	,	,
18637	21803	10	338	338	CD
18637	21803	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21803	12	49	49	CD
18637	21803	13	,	,	,
18637	21803	14	53	53	CD
18637	21803	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21803	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	21803	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21803	18	.	.	.
18637	21804	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21804	2	914	914	CD
18637	21804	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21804	4	309	309	CD
18637	21804	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21804	6	227	227	CD
18637	21804	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21804	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	21804	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21804	10	.	.	.
18637	21805	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21805	2	915	915	CD
18637	21805	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21805	4	322	322	CD
18637	21805	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21805	6	143	143	CD
18637	21805	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21805	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	21805	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21805	10	.	.	.
18637	21806	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21806	2	916	916	CD
18637	21806	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21806	4	Watts	Watts	NNP
18637	21806	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21806	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21806	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21806	8	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	21806	9	,	,	,
18637	21806	10	338	338	CD
18637	21806	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21806	12	49	49	CD
18637	21806	13	,	,	,
18637	21806	14	57	57	CD
18637	21806	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21806	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	21806	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21806	18	;	;	:
18637	21806	19	citing	cite	VBG
18637	21806	20	Malinski	Malinski	NNP
18637	21806	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21806	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	21806	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21806	24	New	New	NNP
18637	21806	25	York	York	NNP
18637	21806	26	,	,	,
18637	21806	27	324	324	CD
18637	21806	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21806	29	401	401	CD
18637	21806	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21806	31	1945	1945	CD
18637	21806	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21806	33	;	;	:
18637	21806	34	Haley	Haley	NNP
18637	21806	35	_	_	NNP
18637	21806	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	21806	37	_	_	NNP
18637	21806	38	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	21806	39	,	,	,
18637	21806	40	332	332	CD
18637	21806	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21806	42	596	596	CD
18637	21806	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21806	44	1948	1948	CD
18637	21806	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21806	46	.	.	.
18637	21807	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21807	2	917	917	CD
18637	21807	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21807	4	338	338	CD
18637	21807	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21807	6	49	49	CD
18637	21807	7	,	,	,
18637	21807	8	60	60	CD
18637	21807	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21807	10	1949	1949	CD
18637	21807	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21807	12	.	.	.
18637	21808	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21808	2	918	918	CD
18637	21808	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21808	4	338	338	CD
18637	21808	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21808	6	62	62	CD
18637	21808	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21808	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	21808	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21808	10	.	.	.
18637	21809	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21809	2	919	919	CD
18637	21809	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21809	4	338	338	CD
18637	21809	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21809	6	68	68	CD
18637	21809	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21809	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	21809	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21809	10	.	.	.
18637	21810	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21810	2	920	920	CD
18637	21810	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21810	4	338	338	CD
18637	21810	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21810	6	49	49	CD
18637	21810	7	,	,	,
18637	21810	8	61	61	CD
18637	21810	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21810	10	1949	1949	CD
18637	21810	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21810	12	.	.	.
18637	21811	1	In	in	IN
18637	21811	2	the	the	DT
18637	21811	3	1949	1949	CD
18637	21811	4	,	,	,
18637	21811	5	1950	1950	CD
18637	21811	6	,	,	,
18637	21811	7	and	and	CC
18637	21811	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	21811	9	terms	term	NNS
18637	21811	10	only	only	RB
18637	21811	11	one	one	CD
18637	21811	12	case	case	NN
18637	21811	13	arose	arise	VBD
18637	21811	14	which	which	WDT
18637	21811	15	involved	involve	VBD
18637	21811	16	the	the	DT
18637	21811	17	forced	force	VBN
18637	21811	18	confession	confession	NN
18637	21811	19	issue	issue	NN
18637	21811	20	in	in	IN
18637	21811	21	any	any	DT
18637	21811	22	significant	significant	JJ
18637	21811	23	way	way	NN
18637	21811	24	.	.	.
18637	21812	1	This	this	DT
18637	21812	2	was	be	VBD
18637	21812	3	Rochin	Rochin	NNP
18637	21812	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21812	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	21812	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21812	7	California	California	NNP
18637	21812	8	,	,	,
18637	21812	9	342	342	CD
18637	21812	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21812	11	165	165	CD
18637	21812	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21812	13	1952	1952	CD
18637	21812	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21812	15	,	,	,
18637	21812	16	which	which	WDT
18637	21812	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	21812	18	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	21812	19	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	21812	20	below	below	RB
18637	21812	21	in	in	IN
18637	21812	22	another	another	DT
18637	21812	23	connection	connection	NN
18637	21812	24	.	.	.
18637	21813	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21813	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21813	3	also	also	RB
18637	21813	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21813	5	Jennings	Jennings	NNP
18637	21813	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21813	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21813	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21813	9	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	21813	10	,	,	,
18637	21813	11	342	342	CD
18637	21813	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21813	13	104	104	CD
18637	21813	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21813	15	1951	1951	CD
18637	21813	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21813	17	;	;	:
18637	21813	18	and	and	CC
18637	21813	19	Stroble	Stroble	NNP
18637	21813	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21813	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21813	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21813	23	California	California	NNP
18637	21813	24	,	,	,
18637	21813	25	343	343	CD
18637	21813	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21813	27	181	181	CD
18637	21813	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21813	29	1952	1952	CD
18637	21813	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21813	31	,	,	,
18637	21813	32	in	in	IN
18637	21813	33	which	which	WDT
18637	21813	34	diverse	diverse	JJ
18637	21813	35	,	,	,
18637	21813	36	but	but	CC
18637	21813	37	not	not	RB
18637	21813	38	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	21813	39	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	21813	40	,	,	,
18637	21813	41	results	result	NNS
18637	21813	42	were	be	VBD
18637	21813	43	reached	reach	VBN
18637	21813	44	.	.	.
18637	21814	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21814	2	921	921	CD
18637	21814	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21814	4	232	232	CD
18637	21814	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21814	6	58	58	CD
18637	21814	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21814	8	1914	1914	CD
18637	21814	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21814	10	.	.	.
18637	21815	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21815	2	922	922	CD
18637	21815	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21815	4	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	21815	5	Rendering	Rendering	NNP
18637	21815	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21815	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21815	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21815	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21815	10	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	21815	11	,	,	,
18637	21815	12	207	207	CD
18637	21815	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21815	14	541	541	CD
18637	21815	15	,	,	,
18637	21815	16	552	552	CD
18637	21815	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21815	18	1908	1908	CD
18637	21815	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21815	20	;	;	:
18637	21815	21	Hammond	Hammond	NNP
18637	21815	22	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	21815	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21815	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21815	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	21815	26	_	_	NNP
18637	21815	27	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	21815	28	,	,	,
18637	21815	29	212	212	CD
18637	21815	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21815	31	322	322	CD
18637	21815	32	,	,	,
18637	21815	33	348	348	CD
18637	21815	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21815	35	1909	1909	CD
18637	21815	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21815	37	.	.	.
18637	21816	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21816	2	923	923	CD
18637	21816	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21816	4	Wolf	Wolf	NNP
18637	21816	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21816	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21816	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21816	8	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	21816	9	,	,	,
18637	21816	10	338	338	CD
18637	21816	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21816	12	25	25	CD
18637	21816	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21816	14	1949	1949	CD
18637	21816	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21816	16	.	.	.
18637	21817	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21817	2	924	924	CD
18637	21817	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21817	4	332	332	CD
18637	21817	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21817	6	46	46	CD
18637	21817	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21817	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	21817	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21817	10	.	.	.
18637	21818	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21818	2	925	925	CD
18637	21818	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21818	4	302	302	CD
18637	21818	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21818	6	319	319	CD
18637	21818	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21818	8	1937	1937	CD
18637	21818	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21818	10	.	.	.
18637	21819	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21819	2	926	926	CD
18637	21819	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21819	4	338	338	CD
18637	21819	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21819	6	25	25	CD
18637	21819	7	,	,	,
18637	21819	8	27	27	CD
18637	21819	9	-	-	SYM
18637	21819	10	28	28	CD
18637	21819	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21819	12	1949	1949	CD
18637	21819	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21819	14	.	.	.
18637	21820	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21820	2	927	927	CD
18637	21820	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21820	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21820	5	.	.	.
18637	21821	1	28	28	CD
18637	21821	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21821	3	31.--In	31.--in	CD
18637	21821	4	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	21821	5	with	with	IN
18637	21821	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21821	7	views	view	NNS
18637	21821	8	,	,	,
18637	21821	9	as	as	RB
18637	21821	10	previously	previously	RB
18637	21821	11	stated	state	VBN
18637	21821	12	in	in	IN
18637	21821	13	Malinski	Malinski	NNP
18637	21821	14	_	_	NNP
18637	21821	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	21821	16	_	_	NNP
18637	21821	17	New	New	NNP
18637	21821	18	York	York	NNP
18637	21821	19	,	,	,
18637	21821	20	324	324	CD
18637	21821	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21821	22	401	401	CD
18637	21821	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21821	24	1945	1945	CD
18637	21821	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21821	26	and	and	CC
18637	21821	27	Adamson	Adamson	NNP
18637	21821	28	_	_	NNP
18637	21821	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	21821	30	_	_	NNP
18637	21821	31	California	California	NNP
18637	21821	32	,	,	,
18637	21821	33	332	332	CD
18637	21821	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21821	35	46	46	CD
18637	21821	36	,	,	,
18637	21821	37	59	59	CD
18637	21821	38	-	-	SYM
18637	21821	39	66	66	CD
18637	21821	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21821	41	1947	1947	CD
18637	21821	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21821	43	,	,	,
18637	21821	44	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21821	45	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	21821	46	amplified	amplify	VBD
18637	21821	47	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21821	48	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	21821	49	of	of	IN
18637	21821	50	the	the	DT
18637	21821	51	due	due	JJ
18637	21821	52	process	process	NN
18637	21821	53	clause	clause	NN
18637	21821	54	as	as	IN
18637	21821	55	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	21821	56	:	:	:
18637	21821	57	"	"	``
18637	21821	58	Due	due	JJ
18637	21821	59	process	process	NN
18637	21821	60	of	of	IN
18637	21821	61	law	law	NN
18637	21821	62	*	*	NFP
18637	21821	63	*	*	NFP
18637	21821	64	*	*	NFP
18637	21821	65	conveys	convey	NNS
18637	21821	66	neither	neither	CC
18637	21821	67	formal	formal	JJ
18637	21821	68	nor	nor	CC
18637	21821	69	fixed	fixed	JJ
18637	21821	70	nor	nor	CC
18637	21821	71	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	21821	72	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	21821	73	.	.	.
18637	21822	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21822	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	21822	3	the	the	DT
18637	21822	4	compendius	compendius	NN
18637	21822	5	expression	expression	NN
18637	21822	6	for	for	IN
18637	21822	7	all	all	PDT
18637	21822	8	those	those	DT
18637	21822	9	rights	right	NNS
18637	21822	10	which	which	WDT
18637	21822	11	the	the	DT
18637	21822	12	courts	court	NNS
18637	21822	13	must	must	MD
18637	21822	14	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	21822	15	because	because	IN
18637	21822	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21822	17	are	be	VBP
18637	21822	18	basic	basic	JJ
18637	21822	19	to	to	IN
18637	21822	20	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21822	21	free	free	JJ
18637	21822	22	society	society	NN
18637	21822	23	.	.	.
18637	21823	1	But	but	CC
18637	21823	2	basic	basic	JJ
18637	21823	3	rights	right	NNS
18637	21823	4	do	do	VBP
18637	21823	5	not	not	RB
18637	21823	6	become	become	VB
18637	21823	7	petrified	petrified	JJ
18637	21823	8	as	as	IN
18637	21823	9	of	of	IN
18637	21823	10	any	any	DT
18637	21823	11	one	one	CD
18637	21823	12	time	time	NN
18637	21823	13	,	,	,
18637	21823	14	even	even	RB
18637	21823	15	though	though	RB
18637	21823	16	,	,	,
18637	21823	17	as	as	IN
18637	21823	18	a	a	DT
18637	21823	19	matter	matter	NN
18637	21823	20	of	of	IN
18637	21823	21	human	human	JJ
18637	21823	22	experience	experience	NN
18637	21823	23	,	,	,
18637	21823	24	some	some	DT
18637	21823	25	may	may	MD
18637	21823	26	not	not	RB
18637	21823	27	too	too	RB
18637	21823	28	rhetorically	rhetorically	RB
18637	21823	29	be	be	VB
18637	21823	30	called	call	VBN
18637	21823	31	eternal	eternal	JJ
18637	21823	32	verities	verity	NNS
18637	21823	33	.	.	.
18637	21824	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21824	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	21824	3	of	of	IN
18637	21824	4	the	the	DT
18637	21824	5	very	very	JJ
18637	21824	6	nature	nature	NN
18637	21824	7	of	of	IN
18637	21824	8	a	a	DT
18637	21824	9	free	free	JJ
18637	21824	10	society	society	NN
18637	21824	11	to	to	TO
18637	21824	12	advance	advance	VB
18637	21824	13	in	in	IN
18637	21824	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21824	15	standards	standard	NNS
18637	21824	16	of	of	IN
18637	21824	17	what	what	WP
18637	21824	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	21824	19	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	21824	20	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	21824	21	and	and	CC
18637	21824	22	right	right	JJ
18637	21824	23	.	.	.
18637	21825	1	Representing	represent	VBG
18637	21825	2	as	as	IN
18637	21825	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21825	4	does	do	VBZ
18637	21825	5	a	a	DT
18637	21825	6	living	live	VBG
18637	21825	7	principle	principle	NN
18637	21825	8	,	,	,
18637	21825	9	due	due	JJ
18637	21825	10	process	process	NN
18637	21825	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	21825	12	not	not	RB
18637	21825	13	confined	confine	VBN
18637	21825	14	within	within	IN
18637	21825	15	a	a	DT
18637	21825	16	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	21825	17	catalogue	catalogue	NN
18637	21825	18	of	of	IN
18637	21825	19	what	what	WP
18637	21825	20	may	may	MD
18637	21825	21	at	at	IN
18637	21825	22	a	a	DT
18637	21825	23	given	give	VBN
18637	21825	24	time	time	NN
18637	21825	25	be	be	VB
18637	21825	26	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	21825	27	the	the	DT
18637	21825	28	limits	limit	NNS
18637	21825	29	of	of	IN
18637	21825	30	the	the	DT
18637	21825	31	essentials	essential	NNS
18637	21825	32	of	of	IN
18637	21825	33	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	21825	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	21825	35	.	.	.
18637	21826	1	To	to	TO
18637	21826	2	rely	rely	VB
18637	21826	3	on	on	IN
18637	21826	4	a	a	DT
18637	21826	5	tidy	tidy	JJ
18637	21826	6	formula	formula	NN
18637	21826	7	for	for	IN
18637	21826	8	the	the	DT
18637	21826	9	easy	easy	JJ
18637	21826	10	determination	determination	NN
18637	21826	11	of	of	IN
18637	21826	12	what	what	WP
18637	21826	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	21826	14	a	a	DT
18637	21826	15	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	21826	16	right	right	NN
18637	21826	17	for	for	IN
18637	21826	18	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	21826	19	of	of	IN
18637	21826	20	legal	legal	JJ
18637	21826	21	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	21826	22	may	may	MD
18637	21826	23	satisfy	satisfy	VB
18637	21826	24	a	a	DT
18637	21826	25	longing	longing	NN
18637	21826	26	for	for	IN
18637	21826	27	certainty	certainty	NN
18637	21826	28	but	but	CC
18637	21826	29	ignores	ignore	VBZ
18637	21826	30	the	the	DT
18637	21826	31	movements	movement	NNS
18637	21826	32	of	of	IN
18637	21826	33	a	a	DT
18637	21826	34	free	free	JJ
18637	21826	35	society	society	NN
18637	21826	36	.	.	.
18637	21827	1	*	*	NFP
18637	21827	2	*	*	NFP
18637	21827	3	*	*	NFP
18637	21827	4	The	the	DT
18637	21827	5	real	real	JJ
18637	21827	6	clue	clue	NN
18637	21827	7	to	to	IN
18637	21827	8	the	the	DT
18637	21827	9	problem	problem	NN
18637	21827	10	confronting	confront	VBG
18637	21827	11	the	the	DT
18637	21827	12	judiciary	judiciary	NN
18637	21827	13	in	in	IN
18637	21827	14	the	the	DT
18637	21827	15	application	application	NN
18637	21827	16	of	of	IN
18637	21827	17	the	the	DT
18637	21827	18	Due	Due	NNP
18637	21827	19	Process	Process	NNP
18637	21827	20	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	21827	21	is	be	VBZ
18637	21827	22	not	not	RB
18637	21827	23	to	to	TO
18637	21827	24	ask	ask	VB
18637	21827	25	where	where	WRB
18637	21827	26	the	the	DT
18637	21827	27	line	line	NN
18637	21827	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	21827	29	once	once	RB
18637	21827	30	and	and	CC
18637	21827	31	for	for	IN
18637	21827	32	all	all	DT
18637	21827	33	to	to	TO
18637	21827	34	be	be	VB
18637	21827	35	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	21827	36	but	but	CC
18637	21827	37	to	to	TO
18637	21827	38	recognize	recognize	VB
18637	21827	39	that	that	IN
18637	21827	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21827	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	21827	42	for	for	IN
18637	21827	43	the	the	DT
18637	21827	44	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21827	45	to	to	TO
18637	21827	46	draw	draw	VB
18637	21827	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21827	48	by	by	IN
18637	21827	49	the	the	DT
18637	21827	50	gradual	gradual	JJ
18637	21827	51	and	and	CC
18637	21827	52	empiric	empiric	JJ
18637	21827	53	process	process	NN
18637	21827	54	of	of	IN
18637	21827	55	'	'	``
18637	21827	56	inclusion	inclusion	NN
18637	21827	57	and	and	CC
18637	21827	58	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	21827	59	.	.	.
18637	21827	60	'"--Ibid	'"--ibid	UH
18637	21827	61	.	.	.
18637	21828	1	27	27	CD
18637	21828	2	.	.	.
18637	21829	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21829	2	928	928	CD
18637	21829	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21829	4	332	332	CD
18637	21829	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21829	6	46	46	CD
18637	21829	7	,	,	,
18637	21829	8	68	68	CD
18637	21829	9	,	,	,
18637	21829	10	71	71	CD
18637	21829	11	-	-	SYM
18637	21829	12	72	72	CD
18637	21829	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21829	14	1947	1947	CD
18637	21829	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21829	16	.	.	.
18637	21830	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21830	2	929	929	CD
18637	21830	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21830	4	Wolf	Wolf	NNP
18637	21830	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21830	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21830	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21830	8	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	21830	9	,	,	,
18637	21830	10	338	338	CD
18637	21830	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21830	12	25	25	CD
18637	21830	13	,	,	,
18637	21830	14	39	39	CD
18637	21830	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21830	16	40	40	CD
18637	21830	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21830	18	1949	1949	CD
18637	21830	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21830	20	.	.	.
18637	21831	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21831	2	930	930	CD
18637	21831	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21831	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21831	5	.	.	.
18637	21832	1	40	40	CD
18637	21832	2	,	,	,
18637	21832	3	41	41	CD
18637	21832	4	,	,	,
18637	21832	5	44	44	CD
18637	21832	6	,	,	,
18637	21832	7	46	46	CD
18637	21832	8	,	,	,
18637	21832	9	47	47	CD
18637	21832	10	.	.	.
18637	21833	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21833	2	931	931	CD
18637	21833	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21833	4	Stefanelli	Stefanelli	NNP
18637	21833	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21833	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21833	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21833	8	Minard	Minard	NNP
18637	21833	9	,	,	,
18637	21833	10	342	342	CD
18637	21833	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21833	12	117	117	CD
18637	21833	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21833	14	1951	1951	CD
18637	21833	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21833	16	;	;	:
18637	21833	17	Rochin	Rochin	NNP
18637	21833	18	_	_	NNP
18637	21833	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	21833	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21833	21	California	California	NNP
18637	21833	22	,	,	,
18637	21833	23	342	342	CD
18637	21833	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21833	25	165	165	CD
18637	21833	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21833	27	1952	1952	CD
18637	21833	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21833	29	.	.	.
18637	21834	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21834	2	932	932	CD
18637	21834	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21834	4	342	342	CD
18637	21834	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21834	6	117	117	CD
18637	21834	7	,	,	,
18637	21834	8	123	123	CD
18637	21834	9	.	.	.
18637	21835	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21835	2	933	933	CD
18637	21835	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21835	4	342	342	CD
18637	21835	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21835	6	105	105	CD
18637	21835	7	,	,	,
18637	21835	8	168	168	CD
18637	21835	9	,	,	,
18637	21835	10	citing	cite	VBG
18637	21835	11	Malinski	Malinski	NNP
18637	21835	12	_	_	NNP
18637	21835	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	21835	14	_	_	NNP
18637	21835	15	New	New	NNP
18637	21835	16	York	York	NNP
18637	21835	17	,	,	,
18637	21835	18	324	324	CD
18637	21835	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21835	20	401	401	CD
18637	21835	21	,	,	,
18637	21835	22	412	412	CD
18637	21835	23	,	,	,
18637	21835	24	418	418	CD
18637	21835	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21835	26	1945	1945	CD
18637	21835	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21835	28	.	.	.
18637	21836	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21836	2	934	934	CD
18637	21836	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21836	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21836	5	.	.	.
18637	21836	6	,	,	,
18637	21836	7	174	174	CD
18637	21836	8	.	.	.
18637	21837	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21837	2	935	935	CD
18637	21837	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21837	4	332	332	CD
18637	21837	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21837	6	46	46	CD
18637	21837	7	,	,	,
18637	21837	8	68	68	CD
18637	21837	9	-	-	SYM
18637	21837	10	123	123	CD
18637	21837	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21837	12	1947	1947	CD
18637	21837	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21837	14	.	.	.
18637	21838	1	"	"	``
18637	21838	2	Of	of	RB
18637	21838	3	course	course	RB
18637	21838	4	"	"	''
18637	21838	5	,	,	,
18637	21838	6	said	say	VBD
18637	21838	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21838	8	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	21838	9	,	,	,
18637	21838	10	citing	cite	VBG
18637	21838	11	Holt	Holt	NNP
18637	21838	12	_	_	NNP
18637	21838	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	21838	14	_	_	NNP
18637	21838	15	United	United	NNP
18637	21838	16	States	States	NNP
18637	21838	17	,	,	,
18637	21838	18	218	218	CD
18637	21838	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21838	20	245	245	CD
18637	21838	21	,	,	,
18637	21838	22	252	252	CD
18637	21838	23	-	-	SYM
18637	21838	24	253	253	CD
18637	21838	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21838	26	1910	1910	CD
18637	21838	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21838	28	,	,	,
18637	21838	29	"	"	''
18637	21838	30	an	an	DT
18637	21838	31	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21838	32	can	can	MD
18637	21838	33	be	be	VB
18637	21838	34	compelled	compel	VBN
18637	21838	35	to	to	TO
18637	21838	36	be	be	VB
18637	21838	37	present	present	JJ
18637	21838	38	at	at	IN
18637	21838	39	the	the	DT
18637	21838	40	trial	trial	NN
18637	21838	41	,	,	,
18637	21838	42	to	to	TO
18637	21838	43	stand	stand	VB
18637	21838	44	,	,	,
18637	21838	45	to	to	TO
18637	21838	46	sit	sit	VB
18637	21838	47	,	,	,
18637	21838	48	to	to	TO
18637	21838	49	turn	turn	VB
18637	21838	50	this	this	DT
18637	21838	51	way	way	NN
18637	21838	52	or	or	CC
18637	21838	53	that	that	DT
18637	21838	54	,	,	,
18637	21838	55	and	and	CC
18637	21838	56	to	to	TO
18637	21838	57	try	try	VB
18637	21838	58	on	on	IN
18637	21838	59	a	a	DT
18637	21838	60	cap	cap	NN
18637	21838	61	or	or	CC
18637	21838	62	a	a	DT
18637	21838	63	coat	coat	NN
18637	21838	64	.	.	.
18637	21838	65	"	"	''
18637	21839	1	342	342	CD
18637	21839	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21839	3	at	at	IN
18637	21839	4	179	179	CD
18637	21839	5	.	.	.
18637	21840	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21840	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21840	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21840	4	the	the	DT
18637	21840	5	Self	self	NN
18637	21840	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	21840	7	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	21840	8	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	21840	9	of	of	IN
18637	21840	10	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21840	11	V.	V.	NNP
18637	21840	12	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21840	13	936	936	CD
18637	21840	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21840	15	Mooney	Mooney	NNP
18637	21840	16	_	_	NNP
18637	21840	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	21840	18	_	_	NNP
18637	21840	19	Holohan	Holohan	NNP
18637	21840	20	,	,	,
18637	21840	21	294	294	CD
18637	21840	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21840	23	103	103	CD
18637	21840	24	,	,	,
18637	21840	25	112	112	CD
18637	21840	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21840	27	1935	1935	CD
18637	21840	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21840	29	.	.	.
18637	21841	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21841	2	937	937	CD
18637	21841	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21841	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21841	5	.	.	.
18637	21842	1	110.--Because	110.--because	CD
18637	21842	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	21842	3	process	process	NN
18637	21842	4	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	21842	5	to	to	TO
18637	21842	6	correct	correct	VB
18637	21842	7	this	this	DT
18637	21842	8	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	21842	9	wrong	wrong	NN
18637	21842	10	was	be	VBD
18637	21842	11	believed	believe	VBN
18637	21842	12	to	to	TO
18637	21842	13	exist	exist	VB
18637	21842	14	in	in	IN
18637	21842	15	California	California	NNP
18637	21842	16	and	and	CC
18637	21842	17	had	have	VBD
18637	21842	18	not	not	RB
18637	21842	19	been	be	VBN
18637	21842	20	fully	fully	RB
18637	21842	21	invoked	invoke	VBN
18637	21842	22	by	by	IN
18637	21842	23	Mooney	Mooney	NNP
18637	21842	24	,	,	,
18637	21842	25	the	the	DT
18637	21842	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21842	27	denied	deny	VBD
18637	21842	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21842	29	petition	petition	NN
18637	21842	30	.	.	.
18637	21843	1	Subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	21843	2	,	,	,
18637	21843	3	a	a	DT
18637	21843	4	California	California	NNP
18637	21843	5	court	court	NN
18637	21843	6	appraised	appraise	VBD
18637	21843	7	the	the	DT
18637	21843	8	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	21843	9	offered	offer	VBN
18637	21843	10	by	by	IN
18637	21843	11	Mooney	Mooney	NNP
18637	21843	12	and	and	CC
18637	21843	13	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	21843	14	that	that	IN
18637	21843	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21843	16	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	21843	17	had	have	VBD
18637	21843	18	not	not	RB
18637	21843	19	been	be	VBN
18637	21843	20	established.--Ex	established.--Ex	NNP
18637	21843	21	parte	parte	NNP
18637	21843	22	Mooney	Mooney	NNP
18637	21843	23	,	,	,
18637	21843	24	10	10	CD
18637	21843	25	Cal	Cal	NNS
18637	21843	26	.	.	.
18637	21844	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21844	2	2d	2d	NN
18637	21844	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21844	4	1	1	CD
18637	21844	5	,	,	,
18637	21844	6	73	73	CD
18637	21844	7	P	p	NN
18637	21844	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21844	9	2d	2d	CD
18637	21844	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21844	11	554	554	CD
18637	21844	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21844	13	1937	1937	CD
18637	21844	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21844	15	;	;	:
18637	21844	16	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	21844	17	denied	denied	NNP
18637	21844	18	,	,	,
18637	21844	19	305	305	CD
18637	21844	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21844	21	598	598	CD
18637	21844	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21844	23	1938	1938	CD
18637	21844	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21844	25	.	.	.
18637	21845	1	Mooney	Mooney	NNP
18637	21845	2	later	later	RB
18637	21845	3	was	be	VBD
18637	21845	4	pardoned	pardon	VBN
18637	21845	5	by	by	IN
18637	21845	6	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	21845	7	Olson.--New	Olson.--New	NNP
18637	21845	8	York	York	NNP
18637	21845	9	Times	Times	NNP
18637	21845	10	,	,	,
18637	21845	11	January	January	NNP
18637	21845	12	8	8	CD
18637	21845	13	,	,	,
18637	21845	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	21845	15	.	.	.
18637	21846	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21846	2	938	938	CD
18637	21846	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21846	4	315	315	CD
18637	21846	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21846	6	411	411	CD
18637	21846	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21846	8	1942	1942	CD
18637	21846	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21846	10	.	.	.
18637	21847	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21847	2	939	939	CD
18637	21847	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21847	4	317	317	CD
18637	21847	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21847	6	213	213	CD
18637	21847	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21847	8	1942	1942	CD
18637	21847	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21847	10	.	.	.
18637	21848	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21848	2	940	940	CD
18637	21848	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21848	4	324	324	CD
18637	21848	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21848	6	760	760	CD
18637	21848	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21848	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	21848	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21848	10	.	.	.
18637	21849	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21849	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21849	3	also	also	RB
18637	21849	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21849	5	New	New	NNP
18637	21849	6	York	York	NNP
18637	21849	7	ex	ex	NNP
18637	21849	8	rel	rel	NN
18637	21849	9	.	.	.
18637	21850	1	Whitman	Whitman	NNP
18637	21850	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21850	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21850	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21850	5	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	21850	6	,	,	,
18637	21850	7	318	318	CD
18637	21850	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21850	9	688	688	CD
18637	21850	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21850	11	1943	1943	CD
18637	21850	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21850	13	;	;	:
18637	21850	14	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	21850	15	parte	parte	NN
18637	21850	16	Hawk	Hawk	NNP
18637	21850	17	,	,	,
18637	21850	18	321	321	CD
18637	21850	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21850	20	114	114	CD
18637	21850	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21850	22	1944	1944	CD
18637	21850	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21850	24	.	.	.
18637	21851	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21851	2	941	941	CD
18637	21851	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21851	4	315	315	CD
18637	21851	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21851	6	411	411	CD
18637	21851	7	,	,	,
18637	21851	8	413	413	CD
18637	21851	9	,	,	,
18637	21851	10	421	421	CD
18637	21851	11	-	-	SYM
18637	21851	12	422	422	CD
18637	21851	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21851	14	1942).--Justice	1942).--Justice	NNP
18637	21851	15	Black	Black	NNP
18637	21851	16	,	,	,
18637	21851	17	together	together	RB
18637	21851	18	with	with	IN
18637	21851	19	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21851	20	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	21851	21	and	and	CC
18637	21851	22	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21851	23	,	,	,
18637	21851	24	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	21851	25	on	on	IN
18637	21851	26	the	the	DT
18637	21851	27	ground	ground	NN
18637	21851	28	that	that	IN
18637	21851	29	the	the	DT
18637	21851	30	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	21851	31	court	court	NN
18637	21851	32	,	,	,
18637	21851	33	"	"	``
18637	21851	34	with	with	IN
18637	21851	35	intimations	intimation	NNS
18637	21851	36	of	of	IN
18637	21851	37	approval	approval	NN
18637	21851	38	"	"	''
18637	21851	39	by	by	IN
18637	21851	40	the	the	DT
18637	21851	41	majority	majority	NN
18637	21851	42	,	,	,
18637	21851	43	had	have	VBD
18637	21851	44	never	never	RB
18637	21851	45	found	find	VBN
18637	21851	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21851	47	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	21851	48	to	to	TO
18637	21851	49	pass	pass	VB
18637	21851	50	on	on	RP
18637	21851	51	the	the	DT
18637	21851	52	credibility	credibility	NN
18637	21851	53	of	of	IN
18637	21851	54	Hysler	Hysler	NNP
18637	21851	55	's	's	POS
18637	21851	56	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	21851	57	,	,	,
18637	21851	58	but	but	CC
18637	21851	59	had	have	VBD
18637	21851	60	erroneously	erroneously	RB
18637	21851	61	declared	declare	VBN
18637	21851	62	that	that	IN
18637	21851	63	all	all	PDT
18637	21851	64	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21851	65	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	21851	66	,	,	,
18637	21851	67	even	even	RB
18637	21851	68	if	if	IN
18637	21851	69	true	true	JJ
18637	21851	70	and	and	CC
18637	21851	71	fully	fully	RB
18637	21851	72	known	know	VBN
18637	21851	73	to	to	IN
18637	21851	74	the	the	DT
18637	21851	75	trial	trial	NN
18637	21851	76	court	court	NN
18637	21851	77	,	,	,
18637	21851	78	would	would	MD
18637	21851	79	not	not	RB
18637	21851	80	have	have	VB
18637	21851	81	precluded	preclude	VBN
18637	21851	82	a	a	DT
18637	21851	83	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	21851	84	.	.	.
18637	21852	1	In	in	IN
18637	21852	2	an	an	DT
18637	21852	3	earlier	early	JJR
18637	21852	4	case	case	NN
18637	21852	5	,	,	,
18637	21852	6	Lisenba	Lisenba	NNP
18637	21852	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21852	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21852	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21852	10	California	California	NNP
18637	21852	11	,	,	,
18637	21852	12	314	314	CD
18637	21852	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21852	14	219	219	CD
18637	21852	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21852	16	1941	1941	CD
18637	21852	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21852	18	,	,	,
18637	21852	19	the	the	DT
18637	21852	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21852	21	,	,	,
18637	21852	22	without	without	IN
18637	21852	23	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	21852	24	of	of	IN
18637	21852	25	this	this	DT
18637	21852	26	principle	principle	NN
18637	21852	27	relating	relate	VBG
18637	21852	28	to	to	IN
18637	21852	29	the	the	DT
18637	21852	30	use	use	NN
18637	21852	31	of	of	IN
18637	21852	32	perjured	perjured	JJ
18637	21852	33	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	21852	34	,	,	,
18637	21852	35	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	21852	36	a	a	DT
18637	21852	37	California	California	NNP
18637	21852	38	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	21852	39	court	court	NN
18637	21852	40	's	's	POS
18637	21852	41	denial	denial	NN
18637	21852	42	of	of	IN
18637	21852	43	a	a	DT
18637	21852	44	petition	petition	NN
18637	21852	45	for	for	IN
18637	21852	46	_	_	NNP
18637	21852	47	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	21852	48	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	21852	49	_	_	NNP
18637	21852	50	.	.	.
18637	21853	1	The	the	DT
18637	21853	2	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21853	3	,	,	,
18637	21853	4	after	after	IN
18637	21853	5	having	have	VBG
18637	21853	6	been	be	VBN
18637	21853	7	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	21853	8	and	and	CC
18637	21853	9	sentenced	sentence	VBN
18637	21853	10	to	to	IN
18637	21853	11	death	death	NN
18637	21853	12	for	for	IN
18637	21853	13	murder	murder	NN
18637	21853	14	,	,	,
18637	21853	15	filed	file	VBD
18637	21853	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21853	17	petition	petition	NN
18637	21853	18	supported	support	VBN
18637	21853	19	by	by	IN
18637	21853	20	affidavits	affidavit	NNS
18637	21853	21	of	of	IN
18637	21853	22	a	a	DT
18637	21853	23	codefendant	codefendant	NN
18637	21853	24	,	,	,
18637	21853	25	who	who	WP
18637	21853	26	,	,	,
18637	21853	27	after	after	IN
18637	21853	28	pleading	plead	VBG
18637	21853	29	guilty	guilty	JJ
18637	21853	30	and	and	CC
18637	21853	31	serving	serve	VBG
18637	21853	32	as	as	IN
18637	21853	33	a	a	DT
18637	21853	34	witness	witness	NN
18637	21853	35	for	for	IN
18637	21853	36	the	the	DT
18637	21853	37	State	State	NNP
18637	21853	38	had	have	VBD
18637	21853	39	received	receive	VBN
18637	21853	40	a	a	DT
18637	21853	41	life	life	NN
18637	21853	42	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	21853	43	.	.	.
18637	21854	1	The	the	DT
18637	21854	2	latter	latter	JJ
18637	21854	3	affirmed	affirm	VBD
18637	21854	4	that	that	IN
18637	21854	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21854	6	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	21854	7	at	at	IN
18637	21854	8	the	the	DT
18637	21854	9	trial	trial	NN
18637	21854	10	of	of	IN
18637	21854	11	the	the	DT
18637	21854	12	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	21854	13	"	"	''
18637	21854	14	was	be	VBD
18637	21854	15	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	21854	16	by	by	IN
18637	21854	17	deceit	deceit	NN
18637	21854	18	,	,	,
18637	21854	19	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	21854	20	,	,	,
18637	21854	21	collusion	collusion	NN
18637	21854	22	,	,	,
18637	21854	23	and	and	CC
18637	21854	24	coercion	coercion	NN
18637	21854	25	,	,	,
18637	21854	26	and	and	CC
18637	21854	27	was	be	VBD
18637	21854	28	known	know	VBN
18637	21854	29	to	to	IN
18637	21854	30	the	the	DT
18637	21854	31	prosecutor	prosecutor	NN
18637	21854	32	to	to	TO
18637	21854	33	be	be	VB
18637	21854	34	false	false	JJ
18637	21854	35	.	.	.
18637	21854	36	"	"	''
18637	21855	1	Even	even	RB
18637	21855	2	though	though	IN
18637	21855	3	the	the	DT
18637	21855	4	California	California	NNP
18637	21855	5	court	court	NN
18637	21855	6	had	have	VBD
18637	21855	7	denied	deny	VBN
18637	21855	8	the	the	DT
18637	21855	9	petition	petition	NN
18637	21855	10	for	for	IN
18637	21855	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21855	12	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	21855	13	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	21855	14	_	_	NNP
18637	21855	15	without	without	IN
18637	21855	16	taking	take	VBG
18637	21855	17	oral	oral	JJ
18637	21855	18	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	21855	19	and	and	CC
18637	21855	20	without	without	IN
18637	21855	21	requiring	require	VBG
18637	21855	22	the	the	DT
18637	21855	23	State	State	NNP
18637	21855	24	to	to	TO
18637	21855	25	answer	answer	VB
18637	21855	26	,	,	,
18637	21855	27	the	the	DT
18637	21855	28	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21855	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21855	30	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	21855	31	this	this	DT
18637	21855	32	action	action	NN
18637	21855	33	on	on	IN
18637	21855	34	the	the	DT
18637	21855	35	ground	ground	NN
18637	21855	36	that	that	IN
18637	21855	37	there	there	EX
18637	21855	38	was	be	VBD
18637	21855	39	no	no	DT
18637	21855	40	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	21855	41	showing	showing	NN
18637	21855	42	of	of	IN
18637	21855	43	a	a	DT
18637	21855	44	corrupt	corrupt	JJ
18637	21855	45	bargain	bargain	NN
18637	21855	46	between	between	IN
18637	21855	47	the	the	DT
18637	21855	48	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	21855	49	and	and	CC
18637	21855	50	the	the	DT
18637	21855	51	codefendant	codefendant	NN
18637	21855	52	and	and	CC
18637	21855	53	that	that	IN
18637	21855	54	the	the	DT
18637	21855	55	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	21855	56	of	of	IN
18637	21855	57	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	21855	58	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	21855	59	was	be	VBD
18637	21855	60	for	for	IN
18637	21855	61	the	the	DT
18637	21855	62	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21855	63	below	below	RB
18637	21855	64	.	.	.
18637	21856	1	Even	even	RB
18637	21856	2	if	if	IN
18637	21856	3	latter	latter	NN
18637	21856	4	's	's	POS
18637	21856	5	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	21856	6	to	to	TO
18637	21856	7	believe	believe	VB
18637	21856	8	the	the	DT
18637	21856	9	codefendant	codefendant	NN
18637	21856	10	's	's	POS
18637	21856	11	depositions	deposition	NNS
18637	21856	12	were	be	VBD
18637	21856	13	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
18637	21856	14	,	,	,
18637	21856	15	such	such	JJ
18637	21856	16	error	error	NN
18637	21856	17	,	,	,
18637	21856	18	the	the	DT
18637	21856	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21856	20	added	add	VBD
18637	21856	21	,	,	,
18637	21856	22	would	would	MD
18637	21856	23	not	not	RB
18637	21856	24	amount	amount	VB
18637	21856	25	to	to	IN
18637	21856	26	a	a	DT
18637	21856	27	denial	denial	NN
18637	21856	28	of	of	IN
18637	21856	29	due	due	JJ
18637	21856	30	process	process	NN
18637	21856	31	.	.	.
18637	21857	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21857	2	942	942	CD
18637	21857	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21857	4	317	317	CD
18637	21857	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21857	6	213	213	CD
18637	21857	7	,	,	,
18637	21857	8	216	216	CD
18637	21857	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21857	10	1942	1942	CD
18637	21857	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21857	12	.	.	.
18637	21858	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21858	2	943	943	CD
18637	21858	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21858	4	324	324	CD
18637	21858	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21858	6	760	760	CD
18637	21858	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21858	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	21858	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21858	10	.	.	.
18637	21859	1	Certiorari	Certiorari	NNP
18637	21859	2	was	be	VBD
18637	21859	3	denied	deny	VBN
18637	21859	4	,	,	,
18637	21859	5	however	however	RB
18637	21859	6	,	,	,
18637	21859	7	for	for	IN
18637	21859	8	the	the	DT
18637	21859	9	reason	reason	NN
18637	21859	10	that	that	WDT
18637	21859	11	the	the	DT
18637	21859	12	State	State	NNP
18637	21859	13	court	court	NN
18637	21859	14	's	's	POS
18637	21859	15	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	21859	16	to	to	TO
18637	21859	17	issue	issue	VB
18637	21859	18	the	the	DT
18637	21859	19	writ	writ	NNP
18637	21859	20	of	of	IN
18637	21859	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21859	22	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	21859	23	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	21859	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21859	25	was	be	VBD
18637	21859	26	based	base	VBN
18637	21859	27	upon	upon	IN
18637	21859	28	an	an	DT
18637	21859	29	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	21859	30	nonfederal	nonfederal	JJ
18637	21859	31	ground	ground	NN
18637	21859	32	.	.	.
18637	21860	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21860	2	944	944	CD
18637	21860	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21860	4	Schwab	Schwab	NNP
18637	21860	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21860	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21860	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21860	8	Berggren	Berggren	NNP
18637	21860	9	,	,	,
18637	21860	10	143	143	CD
18637	21860	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21860	12	442	442	CD
18637	21860	13	,	,	,
18637	21860	14	448	448	CD
18637	21860	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21860	16	1802).--This	1802).--this	CC
18637	21860	17	statement	statement	NN
18637	21860	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	21860	19	a	a	DT
18637	21860	20	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	21860	21	,	,	,
18637	21860	22	however	however	RB
18637	21860	23	;	;	:
18637	21860	24	for	for	IN
18637	21860	25	the	the	DT
18637	21860	26	issue	issue	NN
18637	21860	27	presented	present	VBN
18637	21860	28	by	by	IN
18637	21860	29	the	the	DT
18637	21860	30	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21860	31	's	's	POS
18637	21860	32	petition	petition	NN
18637	21860	33	for	for	IN
18637	21860	34	a	a	DT
18637	21860	35	writ	writ	NN
18637	21860	36	of	of	IN
18637	21860	37	_	_	NNP
18637	21860	38	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	21860	39	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	21860	40	_	_	NNP
18637	21860	41	was	be	VBD
18637	21860	42	that	that	IN
18637	21860	43	the	the	DT
18637	21860	44	State	State	NNP
18637	21860	45	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	21860	46	court	court	NN
18637	21860	47	had	have	VBD
18637	21860	48	denied	deny	VBN
18637	21860	49	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21860	50	due	due	JJ
18637	21860	51	process	process	NN
18637	21860	52	in	in	IN
18637	21860	53	ruling	rule	VBG
18637	21860	54	on	on	IN
18637	21860	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21860	56	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	21860	57	from	from	IN
18637	21860	58	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21860	59	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	21860	60	in	in	IN
18637	21860	61	the	the	DT
18637	21860	62	absence	absence	NN
18637	21860	63	of	of	IN
18637	21860	64	both	both	CC
18637	21860	65	the	the	DT
18637	21860	66	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	21860	67	and	and	CC
18637	21860	68	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21860	69	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21860	70	and	and	CC
18637	21860	71	without	without	IN
18637	21860	72	notice	notice	NN
18637	21860	73	to	to	IN
18637	21860	74	either	either	CC
18637	21860	75	as	as	IN
18637	21860	76	to	to	IN
18637	21860	77	the	the	DT
18637	21860	78	date	date	NN
18637	21860	79	of	of	IN
18637	21860	80	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21860	81	decision	decision	NN
18637	21860	82	.	.	.
18637	21861	1	Insofar	insofar	RB
18637	21861	2	as	as	IN
18637	21861	3	a	a	DT
18637	21861	4	right	right	NN
18637	21861	5	to	to	TO
18637	21861	6	be	be	VB
18637	21861	7	present	present	JJ
18637	21861	8	exists	exist	NNS
18637	21861	9	,	,	,
18637	21861	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21861	11	application	application	NN
18637	21861	12	,	,	,
18637	21861	13	the	the	DT
18637	21861	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21861	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21861	16	maintained	maintain	VBD
18637	21861	17	,	,	,
18637	21861	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	21861	19	limited	limit	VBN
18637	21861	20	to	to	IN
18637	21861	21	courts	court	NNS
18637	21861	22	of	of	IN
18637	21861	23	original	original	JJ
18637	21861	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	21861	25	trying	try	VBG
18637	21861	26	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	21861	27	cases	case	NNS
18637	21861	28	.	.	.
18637	21862	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21862	2	945	945	CD
18637	21862	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21862	4	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	21862	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21862	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21862	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21862	8	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	21862	9	,	,	,
18637	21862	10	200	200	CD
18637	21862	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21862	12	164	164	CD
18637	21862	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21862	14	1906	1906	CD
18637	21862	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21862	16	.	.	.
18637	21863	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21863	2	946	946	CD
18637	21863	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21863	4	201	201	CD
18637	21863	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21863	6	123	123	CD
18637	21863	7	,	,	,
18637	21863	8	130	130	CD
18637	21863	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21863	10	1906	1906	CD
18637	21863	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21863	12	.	.	.
18637	21864	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21864	2	947	947	CD
18637	21864	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21864	4	237	237	CD
18637	21864	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21864	6	309	309	CD
18637	21864	7	,	,	,
18637	21864	8	343	343	CD
18637	21864	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21864	10	1915	1915	CD
18637	21864	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21864	12	.	.	.
18637	21865	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21865	2	948	948	CD
18637	21865	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21865	4	Snyder	Snyder	NNP
18637	21865	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21865	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21865	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21865	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21865	9	,	,	,
18637	21865	10	291	291	CD
18637	21865	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21865	12	97	97	CD
18637	21865	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21865	14	1934	1934	CD
18637	21865	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21865	16	.	.	.
18637	21866	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21866	2	949	949	CD
18637	21866	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21866	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21866	5	.	.	.
18637	21867	1	105	105	CD
18637	21867	2	,	,	,
18637	21867	3	106	106	CD
18637	21867	4	,	,	,
18637	21867	5	107	107	CD
18637	21867	6	,	,	,
18637	21867	7	108	108	CD
18637	21867	8	,	,	,
18637	21867	9	118.--In	118.--in	CD
18637	21867	10	a	a	DT
18637	21867	11	dissent	dissent	NN
18637	21867	12	,	,	,
18637	21867	13	in	in	IN
18637	21867	14	which	which	WDT
18637	21867	15	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21867	16	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	21867	17	,	,	,
18637	21867	18	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	21867	19	,	,	,
18637	21867	20	and	and	CC
18637	21867	21	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	21867	22	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	21867	23	,	,	,
18637	21867	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21867	25	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	21867	26	insisted	insist	VBD
18637	21867	27	that	that	IN
18637	21867	28	"	"	``
18637	21867	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21867	30	*	*	NFP
18637	21867	31	*	*	NFP
18637	21867	32	*	*	NFP
18637	21867	33	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21867	34	was	be	VBD
18637	21867	35	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21867	36	not	not	RB
18637	21867	37	a	a	DT
18637	21867	38	matter	matter	NN
18637	21867	39	of	of	IN
18637	21867	40	assumption	assumption	NN
18637	21867	41	but	but	CC
18637	21867	42	a	a	DT
18637	21867	43	certainty	certainty	NN
18637	21867	44	*	*	NFP
18637	21867	45	*	*	NFP
18637	21867	46	*	*	NFP
18637	21867	47	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21867	48	that	that	IN
18637	21867	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21867	50	*	*	NFP
18637	21867	51	*	*	NFP
18637	21867	52	*	*	NFP
18637	21867	53	the	the	DT
18637	21867	54	*	*	NFP
18637	21867	55	*	*	NFP
18637	21867	56	*	*	NFP
18637	21867	57	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	21867	58	of	of	IN
18637	21867	59	the	the	DT
18637	21867	60	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21867	61	to	to	TO
18637	21867	62	be	be	VB
18637	21867	63	present	present	JJ
18637	21867	64	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	21867	65	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21867	66	trial	trial	NN
18637	21867	67	is	be	VBZ
18637	21867	68	of	of	IN
18637	21867	69	the	the	DT
18637	21867	70	very	very	JJ
18637	21867	71	essence	essence	NN
18637	21867	72	of	of	IN
18637	21867	73	due	due	JJ
18637	21867	74	process	process	NN
18637	21867	75	,	,	,
18637	21867	76	"	"	''
18637	21867	77	and	and	CC
18637	21867	78	,	,	,
18637	21867	79	in	in	IN
18637	21867	80	that	that	DT
18637	21867	81	connection	connection	NN
18637	21867	82	,	,	,
18637	21867	83	"	"	''
18637	21867	84	the	the	DT
18637	21867	85	great	great	JJ
18637	21867	86	weight	weight	NN
18637	21867	87	of	of	IN
18637	21867	88	authority	authority	NN
18637	21867	89	is	be	VBZ
18637	21867	90	that	that	IN
18637	21867	91	"	"	``
18637	21867	92	the	the	DT
18637	21867	93	view	view	NN
18637	21867	94	by	by	IN
18637	21867	95	the	the	DT
18637	21867	96	jury	jury	NN
18637	21867	97	"	"	``
18637	21867	98	forms	form	VBZ
18637	21867	99	part	part	NN
18637	21867	100	of	of	IN
18637	21867	101	the	the	DT
18637	21867	102	trial	trial	NN
18637	21867	103	.	.	.
18637	21867	104	"	"	''
18637	21868	1	Even	even	RB
18637	21868	2	if	if	IN
18637	21868	3	"	"	``
18637	21868	4	the	the	DT
18637	21868	5	result	result	NN
18637	21868	6	would	would	MD
18637	21868	7	have	have	VB
18637	21868	8	been	be	VBN
18637	21868	9	the	the	DT
18637	21868	10	same	same	JJ
18637	21868	11	had	have	VBD
18637	21868	12	the	the	DT
18637	21868	13	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21868	14	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21868	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21868	16	been	be	VBN
18637	21868	17	present	present	JJ
18637	21868	18	,	,	,
18637	21868	19	still	still	RB
18637	21868	20	the	the	DT
18637	21868	21	denial	denial	NN
18637	21868	22	of	of	IN
18637	21868	23	the	the	DT
18637	21868	24	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	21868	25	right	right	NN
18637	21868	26	ought	ought	MD
18637	21868	27	not	not	RB
18637	21868	28	to	to	TO
18637	21868	29	be	be	VB
18637	21868	30	condoned	condone	VBN
18637	21868	31	.	.	.
18637	21869	1	*	*	NFP
18637	21869	2	*	*	NFP
18637	21869	3	*	*	NFP
18637	21869	4	Nor	nor	CC
18637	21869	5	ought	ought	MD
18637	21869	6	this	this	DT
18637	21869	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21869	8	to	to	TO
18637	21869	9	convert	convert	VB
18637	21869	10	the	the	DT
18637	21869	11	inquiry	inquiry	NN
18637	21869	12	from	from	IN
18637	21869	13	one	one	CD
18637	21869	14	as	as	IN
18637	21869	15	to	to	IN
18637	21869	16	the	the	DT
18637	21869	17	denial	denial	NN
18637	21869	18	of	of	IN
18637	21869	19	the	the	DT
18637	21869	20	right	right	NN
18637	21869	21	into	into	IN
18637	21869	22	one	one	NN
18637	21869	23	as	as	IN
18637	21869	24	to	to	IN
18637	21869	25	the	the	DT
18637	21869	26	prejudice	prejudice	NN
18637	21869	27	suffered	suffer	VBN
18637	21869	28	by	by	IN
18637	21869	29	the	the	DT
18637	21869	30	denial	denial	NN
18637	21869	31	.	.	.
18637	21870	1	To	to	TO
18637	21870	2	pivot	pivot	VB
18637	21870	3	affirmance	affirmance	NN
18637	21870	4	on	on	IN
18637	21870	5	the	the	DT
18637	21870	6	question	question	NN
18637	21870	7	of	of	IN
18637	21870	8	the	the	DT
18637	21870	9	amount	amount	NN
18637	21870	10	of	of	IN
18637	21870	11	harm	harm	NN
18637	21870	12	done	do	VBN
18637	21870	13	the	the	DT
18637	21870	14	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21870	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	21870	16	to	to	TO
18637	21870	17	beg	beg	VB
18637	21870	18	the	the	DT
18637	21870	19	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	21870	20	question	question	NN
18637	21870	21	involved	involve	VBN
18637	21870	22	.	.	.
18637	21871	1	*	*	NFP
18637	21871	2	*	*	NFP
18637	21871	3	*	*	NFP
18637	21871	4	The	the	DT
18637	21871	5	guarantee	guarantee	NN
18637	21871	6	of	of	IN
18637	21871	7	the	the	DT
18637	21871	8	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21871	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21871	10	is	be	VBZ
18637	21871	11	not	not	RB
18637	21871	12	that	that	IN
18637	21871	13	a	a	DT
18637	21871	14	just	just	JJ
18637	21871	15	result	result	NN
18637	21871	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	21871	17	have	have	VB
18637	21871	18	been	be	VBN
18637	21871	19	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	21871	20	,	,	,
18637	21871	21	but	but	CC
18637	21871	22	that	that	IN
18637	21871	23	the	the	DT
18637	21871	24	result	result	NN
18637	21871	25	,	,	,
18637	21871	26	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	21871	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21871	28	be	be	VB
18637	21871	29	,	,	,
18637	21871	30	shall	shall	MD
18637	21871	31	be	be	VB
18637	21871	32	reached	reach	VBN
18637	21871	33	in	in	IN
18637	21871	34	a	a	DT
18637	21871	35	fair	fair	JJ
18637	21871	36	way	way	NN
18637	21871	37	.	.	.
18637	21871	38	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	21871	39	.	.	.
18637	21872	1	130	130	CD
18637	21872	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21872	3	131	131	CD
18637	21872	4	,	,	,
18637	21872	5	134	134	CD
18637	21872	6	,	,	,
18637	21872	7	136	136	CD
18637	21872	8	-	-	SYM
18637	21872	9	137	137	CD
18637	21872	10	.	.	.
18637	21873	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21873	2	950	950	CD
18637	21873	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21873	4	337	337	CD
18637	21873	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21873	6	241	241	CD
18637	21873	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21873	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	21873	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21873	10	.	.	.
18637	21874	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21874	2	951	951	CD
18637	21874	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21874	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21874	5	.	.	.
18637	21875	1	246	246	CD
18637	21875	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	21875	3	247	247	CD
18637	21875	4	,	,	,
18637	21875	5	249	249	CD
18637	21875	6	-	-	SYM
18637	21875	7	250.--Dissenting	250.--dissenting	CD
18637	21875	8	,	,	,
18637	21875	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21875	10	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21875	11	maintained	maintain	VBD
18637	21875	12	that	that	IN
18637	21875	13	the	the	DT
18637	21875	14	use	use	NN
18637	21875	15	in	in	IN
18637	21875	16	a	a	DT
18637	21875	17	capital	capital	NN
18637	21875	18	case	case	NN
18637	21875	19	of	of	IN
18637	21875	20	probation	probation	NN
18637	21875	21	reports	report	NNS
18637	21875	22	which	which	WDT
18637	21875	23	"	"	``
18637	21875	24	concededly	concededly	RB
18637	21875	25	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21875	26	would	would	MD
18637	21875	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21875	28	not	not	RB
18637	21875	29	have	have	VB
18637	21875	30	been	be	VBN
18637	21875	31	admissible	admissible	JJ
18637	21875	32	at	at	IN
18637	21875	33	the	the	DT
18637	21875	34	trial	trial	NN
18637	21875	35	,	,	,
18637	21875	36	and	and	CC
18637	21875	37	*	*	NFP
18637	21875	38	*	*	NFP
18637	21875	39	*	*	NFP
18637	21875	40	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21875	41	were	be	VBD
18637	21875	42	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21875	43	not	not	RB
18637	21875	44	subject	subject	JJ
18637	21875	45	to	to	IN
18637	21875	46	examination	examination	NN
18637	21875	47	by	by	IN
18637	21875	48	the	the	DT
18637	21875	49	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	21875	50	,	,	,
18637	21875	51	*	*	NFP
18637	21875	52	*	*	NFP
18637	21875	53	*	*	NFP
18637	21875	54	"	"	``
18637	21875	55	violated	violate	VBD
18637	21875	56	"	"	''
18637	21875	57	the	the	DT
18637	21875	58	high	high	JJ
18637	21875	59	commands	command	NNS
18637	21875	60	of	of	IN
18637	21875	61	due	due	JJ
18637	21875	62	process	process	NN
18637	21875	63	*	*	NFP
18637	21875	64	*	*	NFP
18637	21875	65	*	*	NFP
18637	21875	66	"	"	''
18637	21875	67	--Ibid	--ibid	NN
18637	21875	68	.	.	.
18637	21876	1	253	253	CD
18637	21876	2	.	.	.
18637	21877	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21877	2	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21877	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	21877	4	without	without	IN
18637	21877	5	an	an	DT
18637	21877	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21877	7	.	.	.
18637	21878	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21878	2	952	952	CD
18637	21878	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21878	4	339	339	CD
18637	21878	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21878	6	9	9	CD
18637	21878	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21878	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	21878	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21878	10	.	.	.
18637	21879	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21879	2	953	953	CD
18637	21879	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21879	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21879	5	.	.	.
18637	21880	1	12	12	CD
18637	21880	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21880	3	13.--Disagreeing	13.--disagreeing	CD
18637	21880	4	,	,	,
18637	21880	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21880	6	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	21880	7	contended	contend	VBD
18637	21880	8	that	that	IN
18637	21880	9	a	a	DT
18637	21880	10	State	state	NN
18637	21880	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	21880	12	"	"	``
18637	21880	13	precluded	preclude	VBN
18637	21880	14	by	by	IN
18637	21880	15	the	the	DT
18637	21880	16	due	due	JJ
18637	21880	17	process	process	NN
18637	21880	18	clause	clause	NN
18637	21880	19	from	from	IN
18637	21880	20	executing	execute	VBG
18637	21880	21	a	a	DT
18637	21880	22	man	man	NN
18637	21880	23	who	who	WP
18637	21880	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	21880	25	temporarily	temporarily	RB
18637	21880	26	or	or	CC
18637	21880	27	permanently	permanently	RB
18637	21880	28	become	become	VBN
18637	21880	29	insane	insane	JJ
18637	21880	30	"	"	''
18637	21880	31	;	;	:
18637	21880	32	and	and	CC
18637	21880	33	thus	thus	RB
18637	21880	34	bereft	bereft	JJ
18637	21880	35	of	of	IN
18637	21880	36	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	21880	37	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	21880	38	as	as	IN
18637	21880	39	to	to	IN
18637	21880	40	"	"	``
18637	21880	41	how	how	WRB
18637	21880	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21880	43	will	will	MD
18637	21880	44	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	21880	45	sanity	sanity	NN
18637	21880	46	,	,	,
18637	21880	47	"	"	''
18637	21880	48	a	a	DT
18637	21880	49	State	state	NN
18637	21880	50	"	"	''
18637	21880	51	must	must	MD
18637	21880	52	afford	afford	VB
18637	21880	53	rudimentary	rudimentary	JJ
18637	21880	54	safeguards	safeguard	NNS
18637	21880	55	for	for	IN
18637	21880	56	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	21880	57	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21880	58	that	that	IN
18637	21880	59	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21880	60	fact	fact	NN
18637	21880	61	.	.	.
18637	21880	62	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	21880	63	.	.	.
18637	21881	1	16	16	CD
18637	21881	2	,	,	,
18637	21881	3	19	19	CD
18637	21881	4	,	,	,
18637	21881	5	21	21	CD
18637	21881	6	,	,	,
18637	21881	7	24	24	CD
18637	21881	8	-	-	SYM
18637	21881	9	25	25	CD
18637	21881	10	.	.	.
18637	21882	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21882	2	954	954	CD
18637	21882	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21882	4	In	in	IN
18637	21882	5	re	re	NN
18637	21882	6	Oliver	Oliver	NNP
18637	21882	7	,	,	,
18637	21882	8	333	333	CD
18637	21882	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21882	10	257	257	CD
18637	21882	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21882	12	1948	1948	CD
18637	21882	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21882	14	.	.	.
18637	21883	1	On	on	IN
18637	21883	2	application	application	NN
18637	21883	3	for	for	IN
18637	21883	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21883	5	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	21883	6	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	21883	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21883	8	,	,	,
18637	21883	9	the	the	DT
18637	21883	10	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	21883	11	's	's	POS
18637	21883	12	commitment	commitment	NN
18637	21883	13	was	be	VBD
18637	21883	14	reviewed	review	VBN
18637	21883	15	by	by	IN
18637	21883	16	the	the	DT
18637	21883	17	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	21883	18	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	21883	19	court	court	NN
18637	21883	20	in	in	IN
18637	21883	21	the	the	DT
18637	21883	22	light	light	NN
18637	21883	23	,	,	,
18637	21883	24	not	not	RB
18637	21883	25	of	of	IN
18637	21883	26	the	the	DT
18637	21883	27	whole	whole	JJ
18637	21883	28	record	record	NN
18637	21883	29	,	,	,
18637	21883	30	but	but	CC
18637	21883	31	only	only	RB
18637	21883	32	of	of	IN
18637	21883	33	fragmentary	fragmentary	JJ
18637	21883	34	excerpts	excerpt	NNS
18637	21883	35	showing	show	VBG
18637	21883	36	merely	merely	RB
18637	21883	37	the	the	DT
18637	21883	38	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	21883	39	alleged	allege	VBD
18637	21883	40	to	to	TO
18637	21883	41	be	be	VB
18637	21883	42	false	false	JJ
18637	21883	43	and	and	CC
18637	21883	44	evasive	evasive	JJ
18637	21883	45	.	.	.
18637	21884	1	In	in	IN
18637	21884	2	a	a	DT
18637	21884	3	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	21884	4	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21884	5	,	,	,
18637	21884	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21884	7	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21884	8	advocated	advocate	VBD
18637	21884	9	disposing	dispose	VBG
18637	21884	10	of	of	IN
18637	21884	11	the	the	DT
18637	21884	12	case	case	NN
18637	21884	13	on	on	IN
18637	21884	14	the	the	DT
18637	21884	15	ground	ground	NN
18637	21884	16	that	that	IN
18637	21884	17	the	the	DT
18637	21884	18	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	21884	19	one	one	CD
18637	21884	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	21884	21	man	man	NN
18637	21884	22	grand	grand	JJ
18637	21884	23	jury	jury	NN
18637	21884	24	system	system	NN
18637	21884	25	was	be	VBD
18637	21884	26	in	in	IN
18637	21884	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21884	28	entirety	entirety	NN
18637	21884	29	in	in	IN
18637	21884	30	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	21884	31	with	with	IN
18637	21884	32	the	the	DT
18637	21884	33	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	21884	34	of	of	IN
18637	21884	35	due	due	JJ
18637	21884	36	process	process	NN
18637	21884	37	.	.	.
18637	21885	1	On	on	IN
18637	21885	2	the	the	DT
18637	21885	3	ground	ground	NN
18637	21885	4	that	that	IN
18637	21885	5	the	the	DT
18637	21885	6	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	21885	7	courts	court	NNS
18637	21885	8	had	have	VBD
18637	21885	9	not	not	RB
18637	21885	10	passed	pass	VBN
18637	21885	11	on	on	IN
18637	21885	12	the	the	DT
18637	21885	13	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	21885	14	of	of	IN
18637	21885	15	the	the	DT
18637	21885	16	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	21885	17	at	at	IN
18637	21885	18	issue	issue	NN
18637	21885	19	,	,	,
18637	21885	20	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21885	21	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	21885	22	and	and	CC
18637	21885	23	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	21885	24	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	21885	25	and	and	CC
18637	21885	26	urged	urge	VBD
18637	21885	27	the	the	DT
18637	21885	28	remanding	remanding	NN
18637	21885	29	of	of	IN
18637	21885	30	the	the	DT
18637	21885	31	case	case	NN
18637	21885	32	.	.	.
18637	21886	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21886	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21886	3	also	also	RB
18637	21886	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21886	5	Gaines	Gaines	NNP
18637	21886	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21886	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21886	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21886	9	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	21886	10	,	,	,
18637	21886	11	277	277	CD
18637	21886	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21886	13	81	81	CD
18637	21886	14	,	,	,
18637	21886	15	85	85	CD
18637	21886	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21886	17	1928	1928	CD
18637	21886	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21886	19	.	.	.
18637	21887	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21887	2	955	955	CD
18637	21887	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21887	4	336	336	CD
18637	21887	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21887	6	155	155	CD
18637	21887	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21887	8	1949	1949	CD
18637	21887	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21887	10	.	.	.
18637	21888	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21888	2	956	956	CD
18637	21888	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21888	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21888	5	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	21888	6	,	,	,
18637	21888	7	with	with	IN
18637	21888	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21888	9	Black	Black	NNP
18637	21888	10	concurring	concurring	NN
18637	21888	11	,	,	,
18637	21888	12	dissented	dissent	VBN
18637	21888	13	on	on	IN
18637	21888	14	the	the	DT
18637	21888	15	ground	ground	NN
18637	21888	16	that	that	IN
18637	21888	17	even	even	RB
18637	21888	18	if	if	IN
18637	21888	19	"	"	``
18637	21888	20	such	such	JJ
18637	21888	21	elements	element	NNS
18637	21888	22	of	of	IN
18637	21888	23	misbehavior	misbehavior	NN
18637	21888	24	as	as	IN
18637	21888	25	expression	expression	NN
18637	21888	26	,	,	,
18637	21888	27	manner	manner	NN
18637	21888	28	of	of	IN
18637	21888	29	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	21888	30	,	,	,
18637	21888	31	bearing	bearing	NN
18637	21888	32	,	,	,
18637	21888	33	and	and	CC
18637	21888	34	attitude	attitude	NN
18637	21888	35	*	*	NFP
18637	21888	36	*	*	NFP
18637	21888	37	*	*	NFP
18637	21888	38	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21888	39	had	have	VBD
18637	21888	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21888	41	a	a	DT
18637	21888	42	contemptuous	contemptuous	JJ
18637	21888	43	flavor	flavor	NN
18637	21888	44	.	.	.
18637	21889	1	*	*	NFP
18637	21889	2	*	*	NFP
18637	21889	3	*	*	NFP
18637	21889	4	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	21889	5	of	of	IN
18637	21889	6	speech	speech	NN
18637	21889	7	should	should	MD
18637	21889	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21889	9	not	not	RB
18637	21889	10	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21889	11	be	be	VB
18637	21889	12	so	so	RB
18637	21889	13	readily	readily	RB
18637	21889	14	sacrificed	sacrifice	VBN
18637	21889	15	in	in	IN
18637	21889	16	a	a	DT
18637	21889	17	courtroom	courtroom	NN
18637	21889	18	.	.	.
18637	21889	19	"	"	''
18637	21890	1	Stressing	stress	VBG
18637	21890	2	that	that	IN
18637	21890	3	the	the	DT
18637	21890	4	trial	trial	NN
18637	21890	5	judge	judge	NN
18637	21890	6	penalized	penalize	VBD
18637	21890	7	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	21890	8	only	only	RB
18637	21890	9	for	for	IN
18637	21890	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21890	11	forbidden	forbidden	JJ
18637	21890	12	comment	comment	NN
18637	21890	13	and	and	CC
18637	21890	14	not	not	RB
18637	21890	15	for	for	IN
18637	21890	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21890	17	behavior	behavior	NN
18637	21890	18	,	,	,
18637	21890	19	and	and	CC
18637	21890	20	that	that	IN
18637	21890	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21890	22	took	take	VBD
18637	21890	23	a	a	DT
18637	21890	24	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	21890	25	of	of	IN
18637	21890	26	the	the	DT
18637	21890	27	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	21890	28	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	21890	29	court	court	NN
18637	21890	30	to	to	TO
18637	21890	31	settle	settle	VB
18637	21890	32	the	the	DT
18637	21890	33	issue	issue	NN
18637	21890	34	whether	whether	IN
18637	21890	35	such	such	JJ
18637	21890	36	comment	comment	NN
18637	21890	37	was	be	VBD
18637	21890	38	improper	improper	JJ
18637	21890	39	under	under	IN
18637	21890	40	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	21890	41	practice	practice	NN
18637	21890	42	,	,	,
18637	21890	43	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21890	44	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	21890	45	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	21890	46	that	that	IN
18637	21890	47	the	the	DT
18637	21890	48	record	record	NN
18637	21890	49	suggests	suggest	VBZ
18637	21890	50	only	only	RB
18637	21890	51	that	that	IN
18637	21890	52	"	"	``
18637	21890	53	the	the	DT
18637	21890	54	judge	judge	NN
18637	21890	55	picked	pick	VBD
18637	21890	56	a	a	DT
18637	21890	57	quarrel	quarrel	NN
18637	21890	58	with	with	IN
18637	21890	59	this	this	DT
18637	21890	60	lawyer	lawyer	NN
18637	21890	61	and	and	CC
18637	21890	62	used	use	VBD
18637	21890	63	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21890	64	high	high	JJ
18637	21890	65	position	position	NN
18637	21890	66	to	to	TO
18637	21890	67	wreak	wreak	VB
18637	21890	68	vengeance	vengeance	NN
18637	21890	69	.	.	.
18637	21890	70	"	"	''
18637	21891	1	There	there	EX
18637	21891	2	having	have	VBG
18637	21891	3	been	be	VBN
18637	21891	4	no	no	DT
18637	21891	5	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	21891	6	obstruction	obstruction	NN
18637	21891	7	of	of	IN
18637	21891	8	the	the	DT
18637	21891	9	trial	trial	NN
18637	21891	10	,	,	,
18637	21891	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21891	12	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21891	13	believed	believe	VBD
18637	21891	14	that	that	IN
18637	21891	15	the	the	DT
18637	21891	16	trial	trial	NN
18637	21891	17	judge	judge	NN
18637	21891	18	's	's	POS
18637	21891	19	use	use	NN
18637	21891	20	of	of	IN
18637	21891	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21891	22	power	power	NN
18637	21891	23	was	be	VBD
18637	21891	24	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	21891	25	with	with	IN
18637	21891	26	due	due	JJ
18637	21891	27	process	process	NN
18637	21891	28	;	;	:
18637	21891	29	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	21891	30	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21891	31	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21891	32	,	,	,
18637	21891	33	in	in	IN
18637	21891	34	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	21891	35	,	,	,
18637	21891	36	contended	contend	VBD
18637	21891	37	"	"	``
18637	21891	38	there	there	EX
18637	21891	39	can	can	MD
18637	21891	40	be	be	VB
18637	21891	41	no	no	DT
18637	21891	42	due	due	JJ
18637	21891	43	process	process	NN
18637	21891	44	in	in	IN
18637	21891	45	trial	trial	NN
18637	21891	46	in	in	IN
18637	21891	47	the	the	DT
18637	21891	48	absence	absence	NN
18637	21891	49	of	of	IN
18637	21891	50	calm	calm	JJ
18637	21891	51	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	21891	52	and	and	CC
18637	21891	53	action	action	NN
18637	21891	54	,	,	,
18637	21891	55	untinged	untinge	VBN
18637	21891	56	with	with	IN
18637	21891	57	anger	anger	NN
18637	21891	58	,	,	,
18637	21891	59	from	from	IN
18637	21891	60	the	the	DT
18637	21891	61	bench	bench	NN
18637	21891	62	.	.	.
18637	21891	63	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	21891	64	.	.	.
18637	21892	1	165	165	CD
18637	21892	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21892	3	166	166	CD
18637	21892	4	,	,	,
18637	21892	5	167	167	CD
18637	21892	6	,	,	,
18637	21892	7	169	169	CD
18637	21892	8	.	.	.
18637	21893	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21893	2	957	957	CD
18637	21893	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21893	4	Tumey	Tumey	NNP
18637	21893	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21893	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21893	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21893	8	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	21893	9	,	,	,
18637	21893	10	273	273	CD
18637	21893	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21893	12	510	510	CD
18637	21893	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21893	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	21893	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21893	16	.	.	.
18637	21894	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21894	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21894	3	also	also	RB
18637	21894	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21894	5	Jordan	Jordan	NNP
18637	21894	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21894	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21894	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21894	9	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21894	10	,	,	,
18637	21894	11	225	225	CD
18637	21894	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21894	13	167	167	CD
18637	21894	14	,	,	,
18637	21894	15	176	176	CD
18637	21894	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21894	17	1912	1912	CD
18637	21894	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21894	19	.	.	.
18637	21895	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21895	2	958	958	CD
18637	21895	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21895	4	"	"	``
18637	21895	5	Unless	unless	IN
18637	21895	6	the	the	DT
18637	21895	7	costs	cost	NNS
18637	21895	8	usually	usually	RB
18637	21895	9	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	21895	10	are	be	VBP
18637	21895	11	so	so	RB
18637	21895	12	small	small	JJ
18637	21895	13	that	that	IN
18637	21895	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21895	15	may	may	MD
18637	21895	16	be	be	VB
18637	21895	17	properly	properly	RB
18637	21895	18	ignored	ignore	VBN
18637	21895	19	as	as	IN
18637	21895	20	within	within	IN
18637	21895	21	the	the	DT
18637	21895	22	maxim	maxim	NN
18637	21895	23	_	_	NNP
18637	21895	24	de	de	FW
18637	21895	25	minimis	minimis	NNP
18637	21895	26	non	non	AFX
18637	21895	27	curat	curat	NNP
18637	21895	28	lex	lex	NNP
18637	21895	29	_	_	NNP
18637	21895	30	.	.	.
18637	21895	31	"	"	''
18637	21896	1	--_See	--_See	:
18637	21896	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21896	3	Tumey	Tumey	NNP
18637	21896	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21896	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	21896	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21896	7	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	21896	8	,	,	,
18637	21896	9	273	273	CD
18637	21896	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21896	11	510	510	CD
18637	21896	12	,	,	,
18637	21896	13	523	523	CD
18637	21896	14	,	,	,
18637	21896	15	531	531	CD
18637	21896	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21896	17	1927	1927	CD
18637	21896	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21896	19	.	.	.
18637	21897	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21897	2	959	959	CD
18637	21897	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21897	4	Dugan	Dugan	NNP
18637	21897	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21897	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21897	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21897	8	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	21897	9	,	,	,
18637	21897	10	277	277	CD
18637	21897	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21897	12	61	61	CD
18637	21897	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21897	14	1928	1928	CD
18637	21897	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21897	16	.	.	.
18637	21898	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21898	2	960	960	CD
18637	21898	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21898	4	Frank	Frank	NNP
18637	21898	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21898	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21898	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21898	8	Mangum	Mangum	NNP
18637	21898	9	,	,	,
18637	21898	10	237	237	CD
18637	21898	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21898	12	309	309	CD
18637	21898	13	,	,	,
18637	21898	14	335	335	CD
18637	21898	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21898	16	1915	1915	CD
18637	21898	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21898	18	.	.	.
18637	21899	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21899	2	961	961	CD
18637	21899	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21899	4	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	21899	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21899	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21899	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21899	8	Dempsey	Dempsey	NNP
18637	21899	9	,	,	,
18637	21899	10	261	261	CD
18637	21899	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21899	12	86	86	CD
18637	21899	13	,	,	,
18637	21899	14	91	91	CD
18637	21899	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21899	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	21899	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21899	18	.	.	.
18637	21900	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21900	2	962	962	CD
18637	21900	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21900	4	Thiel	Thiel	NNP
18637	21900	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21900	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21900	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21900	8	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	21900	9	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	21900	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21900	11	,	,	,
18637	21900	12	328	328	CD
18637	21900	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21900	14	217	217	CD
18637	21900	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21900	16	1946	1946	CD
18637	21900	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21900	18	.	.	.
18637	21901	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21901	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21901	3	also	also	RB
18637	21901	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21901	5	Fay	Fay	NNP
18637	21901	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21901	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21901	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21901	9	New	New	NNP
18637	21901	10	York	York	NNP
18637	21901	11	,	,	,
18637	21901	12	332	332	CD
18637	21901	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21901	14	261	261	CD
18637	21901	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21901	16	1947	1947	CD
18637	21901	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21901	18	,	,	,
18637	21901	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21901	20	supra	supra	NNP
18637	21901	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21901	22	p.	p.	NN
18637	21901	23	1110	1110	CD
18637	21901	24	.	.	.
18637	21902	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21902	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	21902	3	's	's	POS
18637	21902	4	Note	note	NN
18637	21902	5	:	:	:
18637	21902	6	Reference	reference	NN
18637	21902	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	21902	8	to	to	IN
18637	21902	9	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	21902	10	873	873	CD
18637	21902	11	,	,	,
18637	21902	12	above	above	RB
18637	21902	13	.	.	.
18637	21902	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21903	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21903	2	963	963	CD
18637	21903	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21903	4	Snyder	Snyder	NNP
18637	21903	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21903	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21903	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21903	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21903	9	,	,	,
18637	21903	10	291	291	CD
18637	21903	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21903	12	97	97	CD
18637	21903	13	,	,	,
18637	21903	14	116	116	CD
18637	21903	15	,	,	,
18637	21903	16	117	117	CD
18637	21903	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21903	18	1934	1934	CD
18637	21903	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21903	20	.	.	.
18637	21904	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21904	2	964	964	CD
18637	21904	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21904	4	Lisenba	Lisenba	NNP
18637	21904	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21904	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21904	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21904	8	California	California	NNP
18637	21904	9	,	,	,
18637	21904	10	314	314	CD
18637	21904	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21904	12	219	219	CD
18637	21904	13	,	,	,
18637	21904	14	236	236	CD
18637	21904	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21904	16	1941	1941	CD
18637	21904	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21904	18	.	.	.
18637	21905	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21905	2	965	965	CD
18637	21905	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21905	4	Buchalter	Buchalter	NNP
18637	21905	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21905	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21905	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21905	8	New	New	NNP
18637	21905	9	York	York	NNP
18637	21905	10	,	,	,
18637	21905	11	319	319	CD
18637	21905	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21905	13	427	427	CD
18637	21905	14	,	,	,
18637	21905	15	429	429	CD
18637	21905	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21905	17	1943	1943	CD
18637	21905	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21905	19	.	.	.
18637	21906	1	The	the	DT
18637	21906	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21906	3	also	also	RB
18637	21906	4	declared	declare	VBD
18637	21906	5	that	that	IN
18637	21906	6	the	the	DT
18637	21906	7	due	due	JJ
18637	21906	8	process	process	NN
18637	21906	9	clause	clause	NN
18637	21906	10	did	do	VBD
18637	21906	11	"	"	``
18637	21906	12	not	not	RB
18637	21906	13	draw	draw	VB
18637	21906	14	to	to	IN
18637	21906	15	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21906	16	the	the	DT
18637	21906	17	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	21906	18	of	of	IN
18637	21906	19	State	State	NNP
18637	21906	20	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	21906	21	or	or	CC
18637	21906	22	State	state	NN
18637	21906	23	laws	law	NNS
18637	21906	24	.	.	.
18637	21906	25	"	"	''
18637	21907	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21907	2	966	966	CD
18637	21907	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21907	4	Powell	Powell	NNP
18637	21907	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21907	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21907	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21907	8	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	21907	9	,	,	,
18637	21907	10	287	287	CD
18637	21907	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21907	12	45	45	CD
18637	21907	13	,	,	,
18637	21907	14	68	68	CD
18637	21907	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21907	16	1932	1932	CD
18637	21907	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21907	18	;	;	:
18637	21907	19	Snyder	Snyder	NNP
18637	21907	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21907	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21907	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21907	23	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21907	24	,	,	,
18637	21907	25	291	291	CD
18637	21907	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21907	27	97	97	CD
18637	21907	28	,	,	,
18637	21907	29	105	105	CD
18637	21907	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21907	31	1934	1934	CD
18637	21907	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21907	33	.	.	.
18637	21908	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21908	2	967	967	CD
18637	21908	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21908	4	Cole	Cole	NNP
18637	21908	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21908	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21908	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21908	8	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	21908	9	,	,	,
18637	21908	10	333	333	CD
18637	21908	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21908	12	196	196	CD
18637	21908	13	,	,	,
18637	21908	14	202	202	CD
18637	21908	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21908	16	1948	1948	CD
18637	21908	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21908	18	.	.	.
18637	21909	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21909	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21909	3	also	also	RB
18637	21909	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21909	5	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	21909	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21909	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21909	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21909	9	North	North	NNP
18637	21909	10	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	21909	11	,	,	,
18637	21909	12	317	317	CD
18637	21909	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21909	14	287	287	CD
18637	21909	15	,	,	,
18637	21909	16	292	292	CD
18637	21909	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21909	18	1942	1942	CD
18637	21909	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21909	20	,	,	,
18637	21909	21	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	21909	22	the	the	DT
18637	21909	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21909	24	also	also	RB
18637	21909	25	stated	state	VBD
18637	21909	26	that	that	IN
18637	21909	27	where	where	WRB
18637	21909	28	a	a	DT
18637	21909	29	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	21909	30	in	in	IN
18637	21909	31	a	a	DT
18637	21909	32	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	21909	33	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	21909	34	is	be	VBZ
18637	21909	35	based	base	VBN
18637	21909	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	21909	37	a	a	DT
18637	21909	38	general	general	JJ
18637	21909	39	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	21909	40	that	that	WDT
18637	21909	41	does	do	VBZ
18637	21909	42	not	not	RB
18637	21909	43	specify	specify	VB
18637	21909	44	the	the	DT
18637	21909	45	ground	ground	NN
18637	21909	46	on	on	IN
18637	21909	47	which	which	WDT
18637	21909	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21909	49	rests	rest	VBZ
18637	21909	50	,	,	,
18637	21909	51	and	and	CC
18637	21909	52	one	one	CD
18637	21909	53	of	of	IN
18637	21909	54	the	the	DT
18637	21909	55	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	21909	56	upon	upon	IN
18637	21909	57	which	which	WDT
18637	21909	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21909	59	may	may	MD
18637	21909	60	rest	rest	VB
18637	21909	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	21909	62	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	21909	63	under	under	IN
18637	21909	64	the	the	DT
18637	21909	65	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	21909	66	,	,	,
18637	21909	67	the	the	DT
18637	21909	68	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	21909	69	can	can	MD
18637	21909	70	not	not	RB
18637	21909	71	be	be	VB
18637	21909	72	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	21909	73	.	.	.
18637	21910	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21910	2	968	968	CD
18637	21910	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21910	4	Paterno	Paterno	NNP
18637	21910	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21910	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21910	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21910	8	Lyons	Lyons	NNP
18637	21910	9	,	,	,
18637	21910	10	334	334	CD
18637	21910	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21910	12	314	314	CD
18637	21910	13	,	,	,
18637	21910	14	320	320	CD
18637	21910	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21910	16	321	321	CD
18637	21910	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21910	18	1948	1948	CD
18637	21910	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21910	20	.	.	.
18637	21911	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21911	2	969	969	CD
18637	21911	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21911	4	McKane	McKane	NNP
18637	21911	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21911	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21911	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21911	8	Durston	Durston	NNP
18637	21911	9	,	,	,
18637	21911	10	153	153	CD
18637	21911	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21911	12	684	684	CD
18637	21911	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21911	14	1894).--The	1894).--the	CD
18637	21911	15	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	21911	16	of	of	IN
18637	21911	17	the	the	DT
18637	21911	18	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	21911	19	of	of	IN
18637	21911	20	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	21911	21	bail	bail	NN
18637	21911	22	,	,	,
18637	21911	23	expressed	express	VBN
18637	21911	24	in	in	IN
18637	21911	25	the	the	DT
18637	21911	26	Eighth	Eighth	NNP
18637	21911	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21911	28	as	as	IN
18637	21911	29	a	a	DT
18637	21911	30	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	21911	31	against	against	IN
18637	21911	32	the	the	DT
18637	21911	33	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	21911	34	Government	Government	NNP
18637	21911	35	,	,	,
18637	21911	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	21911	37	never	never	RB
18637	21911	38	been	be	VBN
18637	21911	39	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	21911	40	to	to	TO
18637	21911	41	be	be	VB
18637	21911	42	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	21911	43	to	to	IN
18637	21911	44	the	the	DT
18637	21911	45	States	States	NNP
18637	21911	46	by	by	IN
18637	21911	47	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	21911	48	of	of	IN
18637	21911	49	the	the	DT
18637	21911	50	due	due	JJ
18637	21911	51	process	process	NN
18637	21911	52	clause	clause	NN
18637	21911	53	of	of	IN
18637	21911	54	the	the	DT
18637	21911	55	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21911	56	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21911	57	.	.	.
18637	21912	1	However	however	RB
18637	21912	2	,	,	,
18637	21912	3	in	in	IN
18637	21912	4	a	a	DT
18637	21912	5	recent	recent	JJ
18637	21912	6	civil	civil	JJ
18637	21912	7	suit	suit	NN
18637	21912	8	,	,	,
18637	21912	9	a	a	DT
18637	21912	10	United	United	NNP
18637	21912	11	States	States	NNP
18637	21912	12	District	District	NNP
18637	21912	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21912	14	judge	judge	NN
18637	21912	15	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	21912	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21912	17	belief	belief	NN
18637	21912	18	,	,	,
18637	21912	19	by	by	IN
18637	21912	20	way	way	NN
18637	21912	21	of	of	IN
18637	21912	22	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	21912	23	,	,	,
18637	21912	24	that	that	DT
18637	21912	25	protection	protection	NN
18637	21912	26	against	against	IN
18637	21912	27	"	"	``
18637	21912	28	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	21912	29	searches	search	NNS
18637	21912	30	and	and	CC
18637	21912	31	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	21912	32	,	,	,
18637	21912	33	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	21912	34	of	of	IN
18637	21912	35	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	21912	36	of	of	IN
18637	21912	37	speech	speech	NN
18637	21912	38	and	and	CC
18637	21912	39	press	press	NN
18637	21912	40	,	,	,
18637	21912	41	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	21912	42	and	and	CC
18637	21912	43	unwarranted	unwarranted	JJ
18637	21912	44	incarcerations	incarceration	NNS
18637	21912	45	,	,	,
18637	21912	46	arrests	arrest	NNS
18637	21912	47	,	,	,
18637	21912	48	and	and	CC
18637	21912	49	_	_	NNP
18637	21912	50	failure	failure	NN
18637	21912	51	to	to	TO
18637	21912	52	allow	allow	VB
18637	21912	53	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	21912	54	bail	bail	NN
18637	21912	55	_	_	NNP
18637	21912	56	would	would	MD
18637	21912	57	all	all	DT
18637	21912	58	be	be	VB
18637	21912	59	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
18637	21912	60	rights	right	NNS
18637	21912	61	protected	protect	VBN
18637	21912	62	by	by	IN
18637	21912	63	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21912	64	the	the	DT
18637	21912	65	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21912	66	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21912	67	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21912	68	from	from	IN
18637	21912	69	State	state	NN
18637	21912	70	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	21912	71	.	.	.
18637	21912	72	"	"	''
18637	21913	1	--International	--International	:
18637	21913	2	Union	Union	NNP
18637	21913	3	,	,	,
18637	21913	4	Etc	Etc	NNP
18637	21913	5	.	.	.
18637	21914	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21914	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	21914	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21914	4	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	21914	5	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	21914	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21914	7	,	,	,
18637	21914	8	31	31	CD
18637	21914	9	F.	F.	NNP
18637	21914	10	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	21914	11	.	.	.
18637	21915	1	1015	1015	CD
18637	21915	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21915	3	1940	1940	CD
18637	21915	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21915	5	.	.	.
18637	21916	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21916	2	970	970	CD
18637	21916	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21916	4	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	21916	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21916	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21916	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21916	8	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	21916	9	,	,	,
18637	21916	10	237	237	CD
18637	21916	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21916	12	502	502	CD
18637	21916	13	,	,	,
18637	21916	14	510	510	CD
18637	21916	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21916	16	1915).--In	1915).--in	CD
18637	21916	17	affirming	affirm	VBG
18637	21916	18	a	a	DT
18637	21916	19	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	21916	20	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	21916	21	by	by	IN
18637	21916	22	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	21916	23	in	in	IN
18637	21916	24	a	a	DT
18637	21916	25	civil	civil	JJ
18637	21916	26	suit	suit	NN
18637	21916	27	to	to	TO
18637	21916	28	recover	recover	VB
18637	21916	29	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	21916	30	for	for	IN
18637	21916	31	violation	violation	NN
18637	21916	32	of	of	IN
18637	21916	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21916	34	antitrust	antitrust	JJ
18637	21916	35	law	law	NN
18637	21916	36	,	,	,
18637	21916	37	the	the	DT
18637	21916	38	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21916	39	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21916	40	proffered	proffer	VBD
18637	21916	41	the	the	DT
18637	21916	42	following	follow	VBG
18637	21916	43	vague	vague	JJ
18637	21916	44	standard	standard	NN
18637	21916	45	for	for	IN
18637	21916	46	determining	determine	VBG
18637	21916	47	the	the	DT
18637	21916	48	validity	validity	NN
18637	21916	49	of	of	IN
18637	21916	50	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	21916	51	levied	levy	VBN
18637	21916	52	by	by	IN
18637	21916	53	States	state	NNS
18637	21916	54	.	.	.
18637	21917	1	"	"	``
18637	21917	2	The	the	DT
18637	21917	3	fixing	fixing	NN
18637	21917	4	of	of	IN
18637	21917	5	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	21917	6	for	for	IN
18637	21917	7	crime	crime	NN
18637	21917	8	or	or	CC
18637	21917	9	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	21917	10	for	for	IN
18637	21917	11	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	21917	12	acts	act	NNS
18637	21917	13	against	against	IN
18637	21917	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21917	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	21917	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	21917	17	within	within	IN
18637	21917	18	the	the	DT
18637	21917	19	police	police	NN
18637	21917	20	power	power	NN
18637	21917	21	of	of	IN
18637	21917	22	the	the	DT
18637	21917	23	State	State	NNP
18637	21917	24	.	.	.
18637	21918	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21918	2	can	can	MD
18637	21918	3	only	only	RB
18637	21918	4	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	21918	5	with	with	IN
18637	21918	6	such	such	JJ
18637	21918	7	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	21918	8	and	and	CC
18637	21918	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	21918	10	action	action	NN
18637	21918	11	of	of	IN
18637	21918	12	the	the	DT
18637	21918	13	States	States	NNPS
18637	21918	14	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	21918	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21918	16	if	if	IN
18637	21918	17	the	the	DT
18637	21918	18	fines	fine	NNS
18637	21918	19	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	21918	20	are	be	VBP
18637	21918	21	so	so	RB
18637	21918	22	grossly	grossly	RB
18637	21918	23	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	21918	24	as	as	IN
18637	21918	25	to	to	TO
18637	21918	26	amount	amount	VB
18637	21918	27	to	to	IN
18637	21918	28	a	a	DT
18637	21918	29	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	21918	30	of	of	IN
18637	21918	31	property	property	NN
18637	21918	32	without	without	IN
18637	21918	33	due	due	JJ
18637	21918	34	process	process	NN
18637	21918	35	of	of	IN
18637	21918	36	law	law	NN
18637	21918	37	.	.	.
18637	21918	38	"	"	''
18637	21919	1	However	however	RB
18637	21919	2	,	,	,
18637	21919	3	a	a	DT
18637	21919	4	fine	fine	NN
18637	21919	5	of	of	IN
18637	21919	6	$	$	$
18637	21919	7	1,600,000	1,600,000	CD
18637	21919	8	levied	levy	VBN
18637	21919	9	in	in	IN
18637	21919	10	this	this	DT
18637	21919	11	case	case	NN
18637	21919	12	against	against	IN
18637	21919	13	a	a	DT
18637	21919	14	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	21919	15	having	have	VBG
18637	21919	16	assets	asset	NNS
18637	21919	17	of	of	IN
18637	21919	18	$	$	$
18637	21919	19	40,000,000	40,000,000	CD
18637	21919	20	and	and	CC
18637	21919	21	paying	pay	VBG
18637	21919	22	out	out	RP
18637	21919	23	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	21919	24	as	as	RB
18637	21919	25	high	high	JJ
18637	21919	26	as	as	IN
18637	21919	27	700	700	CD
18637	21919	28	%	%	NN
18637	21919	29	,	,	,
18637	21919	30	and	and	CC
18637	21919	31	which	which	WDT
18637	21919	32	was	be	VBD
18637	21919	33	shown	show	VBN
18637	21919	34	to	to	TO
18637	21919	35	have	have	VB
18637	21919	36	profited	profit	VBN
18637	21919	37	from	from	IN
18637	21919	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21919	39	wrong	wrong	NN
18637	21919	40	doing	doing	NN
18637	21919	41	was	be	VBD
18637	21919	42	not	not	RB
18637	21919	43	considered	consider	VBN
18637	21919	44	to	to	TO
18637	21919	45	be	be	VB
18637	21919	46	excessive.--Waters	excessive.--waters	XX
18637	21919	47	-	-	:
18637	21919	48	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	21919	49	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	21919	50	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21919	51	_	_	NNP
18637	21919	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	21919	53	_	_	NNP
18637	21919	54	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	21919	55	,	,	,
18637	21919	56	212	212	CD
18637	21919	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21919	58	86	86	CD
18637	21919	59	,	,	,
18637	21919	60	111	111	CD
18637	21919	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21919	62	1909	1909	CD
18637	21919	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21919	64	.	.	.
18637	21920	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21920	2	971	971	CD
18637	21920	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21920	4	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	21920	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21920	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21920	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21920	8	West	West	NNP
18637	21920	9	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	21920	10	,	,	,
18637	21920	11	224	224	CD
18637	21920	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21920	13	616	616	CD
18637	21920	14	,	,	,
18637	21920	15	623	623	CD
18637	21920	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21920	17	1912	1912	CD
18637	21920	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21920	19	.	.	.
18637	21921	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21921	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21921	3	also	also	RB
18637	21921	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21921	5	Ughbanks	Ughbanks	NNP
18637	21921	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21921	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21921	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21921	9	Armstrong	Armstrong	NNP
18637	21921	10	,	,	,
18637	21921	11	208	208	CD
18637	21921	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21921	13	481	481	CD
18637	21921	14	,	,	,
18637	21921	15	498	498	CD
18637	21921	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21921	17	1908	1908	CD
18637	21921	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21921	19	.	.	.
18637	21922	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21922	2	972	972	CD
18637	21922	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21922	4	136	136	CD
18637	21922	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21922	6	436	436	CD
18637	21922	7	,	,	,
18637	21922	8	447	447	CD
18637	21922	9	-	-	SYM
18637	21922	10	448	448	CD
18637	21922	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21922	12	1890	1890	CD
18637	21922	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21922	14	.	.	.
18637	21923	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21923	2	973	973	CD
18637	21923	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21923	4	329	329	CD
18637	21923	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21923	6	459	459	CD
18637	21923	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21923	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	21923	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21923	10	.	.	.
18637	21924	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21924	2	974	974	CD
18637	21924	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21924	4	Concurring	concur	VBG
18637	21924	5	in	in	IN
18637	21924	6	the	the	DT
18637	21924	7	result	result	NN
18637	21924	8	,	,	,
18637	21924	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21924	10	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	21924	11	concentrated	concentrate	VBD
18637	21924	12	on	on	IN
18637	21924	13	the	the	DT
18637	21924	14	problem	problem	NN
18637	21924	15	suggested	suggest	VBN
18637	21924	16	by	by	IN
18637	21924	17	the	the	DT
18637	21924	18	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	21924	19	absorption	absorption	NN
18637	21924	20	of	of	IN
18637	21924	21	the	the	DT
18637	21924	22	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	21924	23	of	of	IN
18637	21924	24	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	21924	25	by	by	IN
18637	21924	26	the	the	DT
18637	21924	27	due	due	JJ
18637	21924	28	process	process	NN
18637	21924	29	clause	clause	NN
18637	21924	30	of	of	IN
18637	21924	31	the	the	DT
18637	21924	32	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21924	33	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21924	34	,	,	,
18637	21924	35	and	and	CC
18637	21924	36	restated	restate	VBD
18637	21924	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21924	38	previously	previously	RB
18637	21924	39	disclosed	disclose	VBN
18637	21924	40	position	position	NN
18637	21924	41	as	as	IN
18637	21924	42	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	21924	43	:	:	:
18637	21924	44	"	"	``
18637	21924	45	Not	not	RB
18637	21924	46	until	until	IN
18637	21924	47	recently	recently	RB
18637	21924	48	was	be	VBD
18637	21924	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21924	50	suggested	suggest	VBD
18637	21924	51	that	that	IN
18637	21924	52	the	the	DT
18637	21924	53	Due	Due	NNP
18637	21924	54	Process	Process	NNP
18637	21924	55	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	21924	56	of	of	IN
18637	21924	57	the	the	DT
18637	21924	58	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21924	59	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21924	60	was	be	VBD
18637	21924	61	merely	merely	RB
18637	21924	62	a	a	DT
18637	21924	63	compendious	compendious	JJ
18637	21924	64	reference	reference	NN
18637	21924	65	to	to	IN
18637	21924	66	the	the	DT
18637	21924	67	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	21924	68	of	of	IN
18637	21924	69	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	21924	70	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	21924	71	the	the	DT
18637	21924	72	States	States	NNPS
18637	21924	73	were	be	VBD
18637	21924	74	now	now	RB
18637	21924	75	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	21924	76	in	in	IN
18637	21924	77	devising	devise	VBG
18637	21924	78	and	and	CC
18637	21924	79	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	21924	80	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21924	81	penal	penal	JJ
18637	21924	82	code	code	NN
18637	21924	83	precisely	precisely	RB
18637	21924	84	as	as	IN
18637	21924	85	is	be	VBZ
18637	21924	86	the	the	DT
18637	21924	87	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	21924	88	Government	Government	NNP
18637	21924	89	by	by	IN
18637	21924	90	the	the	DT
18637	21924	91	first	first	JJ
18637	21924	92	eight	eight	CD
18637	21924	93	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	21924	94	.	.	.
18637	21925	1	On	on	IN
18637	21925	2	this	this	DT
18637	21925	3	view	view	NN
18637	21925	4	,	,	,
18637	21925	5	the	the	DT
18637	21925	6	States	States	NNPS
18637	21925	7	would	would	MD
18637	21925	8	be	be	VB
18637	21925	9	confined	confine	VBN
18637	21925	10	in	in	IN
18637	21925	11	the	the	DT
18637	21925	12	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	21925	13	of	of	IN
18637	21925	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21925	15	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	21925	16	codes	code	NNS
18637	21925	17	by	by	IN
18637	21925	18	those	those	DT
18637	21925	19	views	view	NNS
18637	21925	20	for	for	IN
18637	21925	21	safeguarding	safeguard	VBG
18637	21925	22	the	the	DT
18637	21925	23	rights	right	NNS
18637	21925	24	of	of	IN
18637	21925	25	the	the	DT
18637	21925	26	individual	individual	NN
18637	21925	27	which	which	WDT
18637	21925	28	were	be	VBD
18637	21925	29	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	21925	30	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	21925	31	in	in	IN
18637	21925	32	the	the	DT
18637	21925	33	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
18637	21925	34	century	century	NN
18637	21925	35	.	.	.
18637	21926	1	Some	some	DT
18637	21926	2	of	of	IN
18637	21926	3	these	these	DT
18637	21926	4	safeguards	safeguard	NNS
18637	21926	5	have	have	VBP
18637	21926	6	perduring	perdure	VBG
18637	21926	7	validity	validity	NN
18637	21926	8	.	.	.
18637	21927	1	Some	some	DT
18637	21927	2	grew	grow	VBD
18637	21927	3	out	out	IN
18637	21927	4	of	of	IN
18637	21927	5	transient	transient	JJ
18637	21927	6	experience	experience	NN
18637	21927	7	or	or	CC
18637	21927	8	formulated	formulate	VBN
18637	21927	9	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	21927	10	which	which	WDT
18637	21927	11	time	time	NN
18637	21927	12	might	may	MD
18637	21927	13	well	well	RB
18637	21927	14	improve	improve	VB
18637	21927	15	.	.	.
18637	21928	1	The	the	DT
18637	21928	2	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21928	3	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21928	4	did	do	VBD
18637	21928	5	not	not	RB
18637	21928	6	mean	mean	VB
18637	21928	7	to	to	TO
18637	21928	8	imprison	imprison	VB
18637	21928	9	the	the	DT
18637	21928	10	States	States	NNP
18637	21928	11	into	into	IN
18637	21928	12	the	the	DT
18637	21928	13	limited	limited	JJ
18637	21928	14	experience	experience	NN
18637	21928	15	of	of	IN
18637	21928	16	the	the	DT
18637	21928	17	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
18637	21928	18	century	century	NN
18637	21928	19	.	.	.
18637	21929	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21929	2	did	do	VBD
18637	21929	3	mean	mean	VB
18637	21929	4	to	to	TO
18637	21929	5	withdraw	withdraw	VB
18637	21929	6	from	from	IN
18637	21929	7	the	the	DT
18637	21929	8	States	States	NNPS
18637	21929	9	the	the	DT
18637	21929	10	right	right	NN
18637	21929	11	to	to	TO
18637	21929	12	act	act	VB
18637	21929	13	in	in	IN
18637	21929	14	ways	way	NNS
18637	21929	15	that	that	WDT
18637	21929	16	are	be	VBP
18637	21929	17	offensive	offensive	JJ
18637	21929	18	to	to	IN
18637	21929	19	a	a	DT
18637	21929	20	decent	decent	JJ
18637	21929	21	respect	respect	NN
18637	21929	22	for	for	IN
18637	21929	23	the	the	DT
18637	21929	24	dignity	dignity	NN
18637	21929	25	of	of	IN
18637	21929	26	man	man	NN
18637	21929	27	,	,	,
18637	21929	28	and	and	CC
18637	21929	29	heedless	heedless	JJ
18637	21929	30	of	of	IN
18637	21929	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21929	32	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	21929	33	.	.	.
18637	21930	1	"	"	``
18637	21930	2	These	these	DT
18637	21930	3	are	be	VBP
18637	21930	4	very	very	RB
18637	21930	5	broad	broad	JJ
18637	21930	6	terms	term	NNS
18637	21930	7	by	by	IN
18637	21930	8	which	which	WDT
18637	21930	9	to	to	TO
18637	21930	10	accommodate	accommodate	VB
18637	21930	11	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	21930	12	and	and	CC
18637	21930	13	authority	authority	NN
18637	21930	14	.	.	.
18637	21931	1	As	as	IN
18637	21931	2	has	have	VBZ
18637	21931	3	been	be	VBN
18637	21931	4	suggested	suggest	VBN
18637	21931	5	*	*	NFP
18637	21931	6	*	*	NFP
18637	21931	7	*	*	NFP
18637	21931	8	,	,	,
18637	21931	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21931	10	may	may	MD
18637	21931	11	be	be	VB
18637	21931	12	too	too	RB
18637	21931	13	large	large	JJ
18637	21931	14	to	to	TO
18637	21931	15	serve	serve	VB
18637	21931	16	as	as	IN
18637	21931	17	the	the	DT
18637	21931	18	basis	basis	NN
18637	21931	19	for	for	IN
18637	21931	20	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	21931	21	in	in	IN
18637	21931	22	that	that	IN
18637	21931	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21931	24	allow	allow	VBP
18637	21931	25	much	much	JJ
18637	21931	26	room	room	NN
18637	21931	27	for	for	IN
18637	21931	28	individual	individual	JJ
18637	21931	29	notions	notion	NNS
18637	21931	30	of	of	IN
18637	21931	31	policy	policy	NN
18637	21931	32	.	.	.
18637	21932	1	That	that	DT
18637	21932	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	21932	3	not	not	RB
18637	21932	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21932	5	concern	concern	NN
18637	21932	6	.	.	.
18637	21933	1	The	the	DT
18637	21933	2	fact	fact	NN
18637	21933	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	21933	4	that	that	IN
18637	21933	5	the	the	DT
18637	21933	6	duty	duty	NN
18637	21933	7	of	of	IN
18637	21933	8	such	such	JJ
18637	21933	9	adjudication	adjudication	NN
18637	21933	10	on	on	IN
18637	21933	11	a	a	DT
18637	21933	12	basis	basis	NN
18637	21933	13	no	no	RB
18637	21933	14	less	less	RBR
18637	21933	15	narrow	narrow	JJ
18637	21933	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	21933	17	been	be	VBN
18637	21933	18	committed	commit	VBN
18637	21933	19	to	to	IN
18637	21933	20	this	this	DT
18637	21933	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21933	22	.	.	.
18637	21934	1	"	"	``
18637	21934	2	In	in	IN
18637	21934	3	an	an	DT
18637	21934	4	impressive	impressive	JJ
18637	21934	5	body	body	NN
18637	21934	6	of	of	IN
18637	21934	7	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	21934	8	this	this	DT
18637	21934	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21934	10	has	have	VBZ
18637	21934	11	decided	decide	VBN
18637	21934	12	that	that	IN
18637	21934	13	the	the	DT
18637	21934	14	Due	Due	NNP
18637	21934	15	Process	Process	NNP
18637	21934	16	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	21934	17	of	of	IN
18637	21934	18	the	the	DT
18637	21934	19	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21934	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21934	21	expresses	express	VBZ
18637	21934	22	a	a	DT
18637	21934	23	demand	demand	NN
18637	21934	24	for	for	IN
18637	21934	25	civilized	civilized	JJ
18637	21934	26	standards	standard	NNS
18637	21934	27	which	which	WDT
18637	21934	28	are	be	VBP
18637	21934	29	not	not	RB
18637	21934	30	defined	define	VBN
18637	21934	31	by	by	IN
18637	21934	32	the	the	DT
18637	21934	33	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	21934	34	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	21934	35	guarantees	guarantee	NNS
18637	21934	36	of	of	IN
18637	21934	37	the	the	DT
18637	21934	38	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	21934	39	of	of	IN
18637	21934	40	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	21934	41	.	.	.
18637	21935	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21935	2	neither	neither	DT
18637	21935	3	contain	contain	VBP
18637	21935	4	the	the	DT
18637	21935	5	particularities	particularity	NNS
18637	21935	6	of	of	IN
18637	21935	7	the	the	DT
18637	21935	8	first	first	JJ
18637	21935	9	eight	eight	CD
18637	21935	10	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	21935	11	nor	nor	CC
18637	21935	12	are	be	VBP
18637	21935	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21935	14	confined	confine	VBN
18637	21935	15	to	to	IN
18637	21935	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21935	17	.	.	.
18637	21936	1	*	*	NFP
18637	21936	2	*	*	NFP
18637	21936	3	*	*	NFP
18637	21936	4	Insofar	insofar	RB
18637	21936	5	as	as	IN
18637	21936	6	due	due	JJ
18637	21936	7	process	process	NN
18637	21936	8	under	under	IN
18637	21936	9	the	the	DT
18637	21936	10	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21936	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21936	12	requires	require	VBZ
18637	21936	13	the	the	DT
18637	21936	14	States	States	NNPS
18637	21936	15	to	to	TO
18637	21936	16	observe	observe	VB
18637	21936	17	any	any	DT
18637	21936	18	of	of	IN
18637	21936	19	the	the	DT
18637	21936	20	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	21936	21	'	'	''
18637	21936	22	that	that	WDT
18637	21936	23	are	be	VBP
18637	21936	24	as	as	RB
18637	21936	25	valid	valid	JJ
18637	21936	26	as	as	IN
18637	21936	27	against	against	IN
18637	21936	28	the	the	DT
18637	21936	29	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	21936	30	Government	Government	NNP
18637	21936	31	by	by	IN
18637	21936	32	force	force	NN
18637	21936	33	of	of	IN
18637	21936	34	the	the	DT
18637	21936	35	specific	specific	JJ
18637	21936	36	pledges	pledge	NNS
18637	21936	37	of	of	IN
18637	21936	38	particular	particular	JJ
18637	21936	39	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	21936	40	'	'	''
18637	21936	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21936	42	does	do	VBZ
18637	21936	43	so	so	RB
18637	21936	44	because	because	IN
18637	21936	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21936	46	'	'	''
18637	21936	47	have	have	VBP
18637	21936	48	been	be	VBN
18637	21936	49	found	find	VBN
18637	21936	50	to	to	TO
18637	21936	51	be	be	VB
18637	21936	52	implicit	implicit	JJ
18637	21936	53	in	in	IN
18637	21936	54	the	the	DT
18637	21936	55	concept	concept	NN
18637	21936	56	of	of	IN
18637	21936	57	ordered	order	VBN
18637	21936	58	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	21936	59	,	,	,
18637	21936	60	and	and	CC
18637	21936	61	thus	thus	RB
18637	21936	62	,	,	,
18637	21936	63	through	through	IN
18637	21936	64	the	the	DT
18637	21936	65	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21936	66	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21936	67	,	,	,
18637	21936	68	become	become	VB
18637	21936	69	valid	valid	JJ
18637	21936	70	as	as	IN
18637	21936	71	against	against	IN
18637	21936	72	the	the	DT
18637	21936	73	States	States	NNP
18637	21936	74	,	,	,
18637	21936	75	'	'	''
18637	21936	76	"	"	''
18637	21936	77	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21936	78	citing	cite	VBG
18637	21936	79	Palko	Palko	NNP
18637	21936	80	_	_	NNP
18637	21936	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	21936	82	_	_	NNP
18637	21936	83	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	21936	84	,	,	,
18637	21936	85	302	302	CD
18637	21936	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21936	87	319	319	CD
18637	21936	88	,	,	,
18637	21936	89	324	324	CD
18637	21936	90	,	,	,
18637	21936	91	325	325	CD
18637	21936	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21936	93	1937).]--Ibid	1937).]--ibid	CD
18637	21936	94	.	.	.
18637	21937	1	467	467	CD
18637	21937	2	-	-	SYM
18637	21937	3	469	469	CD
18637	21937	4	.	.	.
18637	21938	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21938	2	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	21938	3	,	,	,
18637	21938	4	with	with	IN
18637	21938	5	whom	whom	WP
18637	21938	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	21938	7	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21938	8	,	,	,
18637	21938	9	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	21938	10	,	,	,
18637	21938	11	and	and	CC
18637	21938	12	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	21938	13	were	be	VBD
18637	21938	14	associated	associate	VBN
18637	21938	15	,	,	,
18637	21938	16	dissented	dissent	VBN
18637	21938	17	on	on	IN
18637	21938	18	the	the	DT
18637	21938	19	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	21938	20	that	that	IN
18637	21938	21	"	"	``
18637	21938	22	the	the	DT
18637	21938	23	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	21938	24	repeated	repeat	VBD
18637	21938	25	,	,	,
18637	21938	26	and	and	CC
18637	21938	27	at	at	IN
18637	21938	28	least	least	JJS
18637	21938	29	second	second	NN
18637	21938	30	,	,	,
18637	21938	31	application	application	NN
18637	21938	32	to	to	IN
18637	21938	33	the	the	DT
18637	21938	34	*	*	NFP
18637	21938	35	*	*	NFP
18637	21938	36	*	*	NFP
18637	21938	37	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21938	38	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	21938	39	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21938	40	of	of	IN
18637	21938	41	an	an	DT
18637	21938	42	electric	electric	JJ
18637	21938	43	current	current	JJ
18637	21938	44	sufficient	sufficient	NN
18637	21938	45	to	to	TO
18637	21938	46	cause	cause	VB
18637	21938	47	death	death	NN
18637	21938	48	is	be	VBZ
18637	21938	49	*	*	NFP
18637	21938	50	*	*	NFP
18637	21938	51	*	*	NFP
18637	21938	52	,	,	,
18637	21938	53	a	a	DT
18637	21938	54	cruel	cruel	JJ
18637	21938	55	and	and	CC
18637	21938	56	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	21938	57	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	21938	58	violative	violative	JJ
18637	21938	59	of	of	IN
18637	21938	60	due	due	JJ
18637	21938	61	process	process	NN
18637	21938	62	of	of	IN
18637	21938	63	law	law	NN
18637	21938	64	.	.	.
18637	21938	65	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	21938	66	.	.	.
18637	21939	1	479	479	CD
18637	21939	2	.	.	.
18637	21940	1	In	in	IN
18637	21940	2	Solesbee	Solesbee	NNP
18637	21940	3	_	_	NNP
18637	21940	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	21940	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21940	6	Balkcom	Balkcom	NNP
18637	21940	7	,	,	,
18637	21940	8	339	339	CD
18637	21940	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21940	10	9	9	CD
18637	21940	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21940	12	1950	1950	CD
18637	21940	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21940	14	,	,	,
18637	21940	15	the	the	DT
18637	21940	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21940	17	declined	decline	VBD
18637	21940	18	to	to	TO
18637	21940	19	intervene	intervene	VB
18637	21940	20	in	in	IN
18637	21940	21	case	case	NN
18637	21940	22	coming	come	VBG
18637	21940	23	up	up	RP
18637	21940	24	from	from	IN
18637	21940	25	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	21940	26	in	in	IN
18637	21940	27	which	which	WDT
18637	21940	28	appellant	appellant	NN
18637	21940	29	,	,	,
18637	21940	30	claiming	claim	VBG
18637	21940	31	that	that	IN
18637	21940	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21940	33	had	have	VBD
18637	21940	34	become	become	VBN
18637	21940	35	insane	insane	JJ
18637	21940	36	following	follow	VBG
18637	21940	37	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	21940	38	and	and	CC
18637	21940	39	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	21940	40	of	of	IN
18637	21940	41	death	death	NN
18637	21940	42	,	,	,
18637	21940	43	sought	seek	VBD
18637	21940	44	a	a	DT
18637	21940	45	postponement	postponement	NN
18637	21940	46	of	of	IN
18637	21940	47	execution	execution	NN
18637	21940	48	from	from	IN
18637	21940	49	the	the	DT
18637	21940	50	governor	governor	NN
18637	21940	51	of	of	IN
18637	21940	52	the	the	DT
18637	21940	53	State	State	NNP
18637	21940	54	.	.	.
18637	21941	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21941	2	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	21941	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	21941	4	,	,	,
18637	21941	5	asserting	assert	VBG
18637	21941	6	that	that	IN
18637	21941	7	the	the	DT
18637	21941	8	due	due	JJ
18637	21941	9	process	process	NN
18637	21941	10	clause	clause	NN
18637	21941	11	of	of	IN
18637	21941	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21941	13	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	21941	14	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	21941	15	a	a	DT
18637	21941	16	State	state	NN
18637	21941	17	from	from	IN
18637	21941	18	executing	execute	VBG
18637	21941	19	an	an	DT
18637	21941	20	insane	insane	JJ
18637	21941	21	convict	convict	NN
18637	21941	22	.	.	.
18637	21942	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21942	2	975	975	CD
18637	21942	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21942	4	187	187	CD
18637	21942	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21942	6	71	71	CD
18637	21942	7	,	,	,
18637	21942	8	86	86	CD
18637	21942	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21942	10	1902	1902	CD
18637	21942	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21942	12	.	.	.
18637	21943	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21943	2	See	See	NNP
18637	21943	3	also	also	RB
18637	21943	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21943	5	Keerl	Keerl	NNP
18637	21943	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21943	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21943	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21943	9	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	21943	10	,	,	,
18637	21943	11	213	213	CD
18637	21943	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21943	13	135	135	CD
18637	21943	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21943	15	1909	1909	CD
18637	21943	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21943	17	.	.	.
18637	21944	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21944	2	976	976	CD
18637	21944	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21944	4	177	177	CD
18637	21944	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21944	6	155	155	CD
18637	21944	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21944	8	1900	1900	CD
18637	21944	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21944	10	.	.	.
18637	21945	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21945	2	977	977	CD
18637	21945	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21945	4	207	207	CD
18637	21945	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21945	6	188	188	CD
18637	21945	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21945	8	1907	1907	CD
18637	21945	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21945	10	.	.	.
18637	21946	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21946	2	978	978	CD
18637	21946	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21946	4	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	21946	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21946	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21946	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21946	8	West	West	NNP
18637	21946	9	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	21946	10	,	,	,
18637	21946	11	224	224	CD
18637	21946	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21946	13	616	616	CD
18637	21946	14	,	,	,
18637	21946	15	623	623	CD
18637	21946	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21946	17	1912	1912	CD
18637	21946	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21946	19	.	.	.
18637	21947	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21947	2	979	979	CD
18637	21947	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21947	4	302	302	CD
18637	21947	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21947	6	319	319	CD
18637	21947	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21947	8	1937	1937	CD
18637	21947	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21947	10	.	.	.
18637	21948	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21948	2	980	980	CD
18637	21948	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21948	4	In	in	IN
18637	21948	5	a	a	DT
18637	21948	6	lengthy	lengthy	JJ
18637	21948	7	dictum	dictum	NN
18637	21948	8	,	,	,
18637	21948	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21948	10	Cardozo	Cardozo	NNP
18637	21948	11	,	,	,
18637	21948	12	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	21948	13	for	for	IN
18637	21948	14	the	the	DT
18637	21948	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21948	16	,	,	,
18637	21948	17	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	21948	18	the	the	DT
18637	21948	19	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	21948	20	's	's	POS
18637	21948	21	view	view	NN
18637	21948	22	that	that	IN
18637	21948	23	"	"	``
18637	21948	24	Whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	21948	25	would	would	MD
18637	21948	26	be	be	VB
18637	21948	27	a	a	DT
18637	21948	28	violation	violation	NN
18637	21948	29	of	of	IN
18637	21948	30	the	the	DT
18637	21948	31	original	original	JJ
18637	21948	32	bill	bill	NN
18637	21948	33	of	of	IN
18637	21948	34	rights	right	NNS
18637	21948	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21948	36	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	21948	37	One	one	CD
18637	21948	38	to	to	IN
18637	21948	39	Eight	eight	CD
18637	21948	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21948	41	if	if	IN
18637	21948	42	done	do	VBN
18637	21948	43	by	by	IN
18637	21948	44	the	the	DT
18637	21948	45	federal	federal	JJ
18637	21948	46	government	government	NN
18637	21948	47	is	be	VBZ
18637	21948	48	now	now	RB
18637	21948	49	equally	equally	RB
18637	21948	50	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	21948	51	by	by	IN
18637	21948	52	force	force	NN
18637	21948	53	of	of	IN
18637	21948	54	the	the	DT
18637	21948	55	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21948	56	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21948	57	if	if	IN
18637	21948	58	done	do	VBN
18637	21948	59	by	by	IN
18637	21948	60	a	a	DT
18637	21948	61	state	state	NN
18637	21948	62	.	.	.
18637	21948	63	"	"	''
18637	21949	1	By	by	IN
18637	21949	2	a	a	DT
18637	21949	3	selective	selective	JJ
18637	21949	4	process	process	NN
18637	21949	5	of	of	IN
18637	21949	6	inclusion	inclusion	NN
18637	21949	7	and	and	CC
18637	21949	8	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	21949	9	,	,	,
18637	21949	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21949	11	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	21949	12	that	that	IN
18637	21949	13	"	"	``
18637	21949	14	the	the	DT
18637	21949	15	due	due	JJ
18637	21949	16	process	process	NN
18637	21949	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	21949	18	of	of	IN
18637	21949	19	the	the	DT
18637	21949	20	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21949	21	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21949	22	may	may	MD
18637	21949	23	make	make	VB
18637	21949	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21949	25	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	21949	26	for	for	IN
18637	21949	27	a	a	DT
18637	21949	28	state	state	NN
18637	21949	29	to	to	TO
18637	21949	30	abridge	abridge	VB
18637	21949	31	by	by	IN
18637	21949	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21949	33	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	21949	34	the	the	DT
18637	21949	35	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	21949	36	of	of	IN
18637	21949	37	speech	speech	NN
18637	21949	38	which	which	WDT
18637	21949	39	the	the	DT
18637	21949	40	First	First	NNP
18637	21949	41	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21949	42	safeguards	safeguard	NNS
18637	21949	43	against	against	IN
18637	21949	44	encroachment	encroachment	NN
18637	21949	45	by	by	IN
18637	21949	46	the	the	DT
18637	21949	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	21949	48	,	,	,
18637	21949	49	*	*	NFP
18637	21949	50	*	*	NFP
18637	21949	51	*	*	NFP
18637	21949	52	or	or	CC
18637	21949	53	the	the	DT
18637	21949	54	like	like	JJ
18637	21949	55	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	21949	56	of	of	IN
18637	21949	57	the	the	DT
18637	21949	58	press	press	NN
18637	21949	59	,	,	,
18637	21949	60	*	*	NFP
18637	21949	61	*	*	NFP
18637	21949	62	*	*	NFP
18637	21949	63	or	or	CC
18637	21949	64	the	the	DT
18637	21949	65	free	free	JJ
18637	21949	66	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	21949	67	of	of	IN
18637	21949	68	religion	religion	NN
18637	21949	69	,	,	,
18637	21949	70	*	*	NFP
18637	21949	71	*	*	NFP
18637	21949	72	*	*	NFP
18637	21949	73	or	or	CC
18637	21949	74	the	the	DT
18637	21949	75	right	right	NN
18637	21949	76	of	of	IN
18637	21949	77	peaceable	peaceable	JJ
18637	21949	78	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	21949	79	*	*	NFP
18637	21949	80	*	*	NFP
18637	21949	81	*	*	NFP
18637	21949	82	,	,	,
18637	21949	83	or	or	CC
18637	21949	84	the	the	DT
18637	21949	85	right	right	NN
18637	21949	86	of	of	IN
18637	21949	87	one	one	CD
18637	21949	88	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21949	89	of	of	IN
18637	21949	90	crime	crime	NN
18637	21949	91	to	to	IN
18637	21949	92	the	the	DT
18637	21949	93	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	21949	94	of	of	IN
18637	21949	95	counsel	counsel	NN
18637	21949	96	.	.	.
18637	21949	97	"	"	''
18637	21950	1	However	however	RB
18637	21950	2	,	,	,
18637	21950	3	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	21950	4	as	as	IN
18637	21950	5	such	such	JJ
18637	21950	6	"	"	``
18637	21950	7	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	21950	8	,	,	,
18637	21950	9	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21950	10	which	which	WDT
18637	21950	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21950	12	are	be	VBP
18637	21950	13	valid	valid	JJ
18637	21950	14	as	as	IN
18637	21950	15	against	against	IN
18637	21950	16	the	the	DT
18637	21950	17	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	21950	18	Government	Government	NNP
18637	21950	19	by	by	IN
18637	21950	20	force	force	NN
18637	21950	21	of	of	IN
18637	21950	22	the	the	DT
18637	21950	23	specific	specific	JJ
18637	21950	24	pledges	pledge	NNS
18637	21950	25	of	of	IN
18637	21950	26	particular	particular	JJ
18637	21950	27	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	21950	28	,	,	,
18637	21950	29	have	have	VBP
18637	21950	30	become	become	VBN
18637	21950	31	valid	valid	JJ
18637	21950	32	as	as	IN
18637	21950	33	against	against	IN
18637	21950	34	the	the	DT
18637	21950	35	States	States	NNP
18637	21950	36	,	,	,
18637	21950	37	"	"	''
18637	21950	38	that	that	IN
18637	21950	39	result	result	NN
18637	21950	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	21950	41	attributable	attributable	JJ
18637	21950	42	,	,	,
18637	21950	43	not	not	RB
18637	21950	44	to	to	IN
18637	21950	45	the	the	DT
18637	21950	46	absorption	absorption	NN
18637	21950	47	by	by	IN
18637	21950	48	the	the	DT
18637	21950	49	due	due	JJ
18637	21950	50	process	process	NN
18637	21950	51	clause	clause	NN
18637	21950	52	of	of	IN
18637	21950	53	the	the	DT
18637	21950	54	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	21950	55	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	21950	56	of	of	IN
18637	21950	57	particular	particular	JJ
18637	21950	58	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	21950	59	of	of	IN
18637	21950	60	the	the	DT
18637	21950	61	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	21950	62	of	of	IN
18637	21950	63	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	21950	64	,	,	,
18637	21950	65	but	but	CC
18637	21950	66	to	to	IN
18637	21950	67	the	the	DT
18637	21950	68	fact	fact	NN
18637	21950	69	that	that	IN
18637	21950	70	such	such	JJ
18637	21950	71	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	21950	72	"	"	``
18637	21950	73	have	have	VBP
18637	21950	74	been	be	VBN
18637	21950	75	found	find	VBN
18637	21950	76	to	to	TO
18637	21950	77	be	be	VB
18637	21950	78	implicit	implicit	JJ
18637	21950	79	in	in	IN
18637	21950	80	the	the	DT
18637	21950	81	concept	concept	NN
18637	21950	82	of	of	IN
18637	21950	83	ordered	order	VBN
18637	21950	84	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	21950	85	*	*	NFP
18637	21950	86	*	*	NFP
18637	21950	87	*	*	NFP
18637	21950	88	"	"	''
18637	21950	89	protected	protect	VBN
18637	21950	90	by	by	IN
18637	21950	91	that	that	DT
18637	21950	92	clause.--Ibid	clause.--ibid	NN
18637	21950	93	.	.	.
18637	21951	1	323	323	CD
18637	21951	2	,	,	,
18637	21951	3	324	324	CD
18637	21951	4	-	-	SYM
18637	21951	5	325	325	CD
18637	21951	6	.	.	.
18637	21952	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21952	2	981	981	CD
18637	21952	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21952	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	21952	5	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	21952	6	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	21952	7	without	without	IN
18637	21952	8	an	an	DT
18637	21952	9	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	21952	10	.	.	.
18637	21953	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21953	2	982	982	CD
18637	21953	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21953	4	320	320	CD
18637	21953	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21953	6	459	459	CD
18637	21953	7	,	,	,
18637	21953	8	462	462	CD
18637	21953	9	,	,	,
18637	21953	10	463	463	CD
18637	21953	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21953	12	1947).--In	1947).--in	CD
18637	21953	13	line	line	NN
18637	21953	14	with	with	IN
18637	21953	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21953	16	former	former	JJ
18637	21953	17	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	21953	18	in	in	IN
18637	21953	19	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	21953	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21953	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21953	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21953	23	West	West	NNP
18637	21953	24	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	21953	25	,	,	,
18637	21953	26	224	224	CD
18637	21953	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21953	28	616	616	CD
18637	21953	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21953	30	1912	1912	CD
18637	21953	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21953	32	,	,	,
18637	21953	33	the	the	DT
18637	21953	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21953	35	reiterated	reiterate	VBD
18637	21953	36	in	in	IN
18637	21953	37	Gryger	Gryger	NNP
18637	21953	38	_	_	NNP
18637	21953	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	21953	40	_	_	NNP
18637	21953	41	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	21953	42	,	,	,
18637	21953	43	334	334	CD
18637	21953	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21953	45	728	728	CD
18637	21953	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21953	47	1948	1948	CD
18637	21953	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21953	49	,	,	,
18637	21953	50	that	that	IN
18637	21953	51	a	a	DT
18637	21953	52	life	life	NN
18637	21953	53	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	21953	54	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	21953	55	on	on	IN
18637	21953	56	a	a	DT
18637	21953	57	fourth	fourth	JJ
18637	21953	58	offender	offender	NN
18637	21953	59	under	under	IN
18637	21953	60	a	a	DT
18637	21953	61	State	State	NNP
18637	21953	62	habitual	habitual	JJ
18637	21953	63	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	21953	64	act	act	NN
18637	21953	65	is	be	VBZ
18637	21953	66	a	a	DT
18637	21953	67	stiffened	stiffened	JJ
18637	21953	68	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	21953	69	for	for	IN
18637	21953	70	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21953	71	latest	late	JJS
18637	21953	72	offense	offense	NN
18637	21953	73	,	,	,
18637	21953	74	which	which	WDT
18637	21953	75	is	be	VBZ
18637	21953	76	considered	consider	VBN
18637	21953	77	to	to	TO
18637	21953	78	be	be	VB
18637	21953	79	an	an	DT
18637	21953	80	aggravated	aggravated	JJ
18637	21953	81	offense	offense	NN
18637	21953	82	because	because	IN
18637	21953	83	a	a	DT
18637	21953	84	repetitive	repetitive	JJ
18637	21953	85	one	one	NN
18637	21953	86	,	,	,
18637	21953	87	and	and	CC
18637	21953	88	is	be	VBZ
18637	21953	89	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	21953	90	not	not	RB
18637	21953	91	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	21953	92	as	as	IN
18637	21953	93	subjecting	subject	VBG
18637	21953	94	the	the	DT
18637	21953	95	offender	offender	NN
18637	21953	96	to	to	IN
18637	21953	97	a	a	DT
18637	21953	98	new	new	JJ
18637	21953	99	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
18637	21953	100	.	.	.
18637	21954	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21954	2	983	983	CD
18637	21954	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21954	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	21954	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	21954	6	Hull	Hull	NNP
18637	21954	7	,	,	,
18637	21954	8	312	312	CD
18637	21954	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21954	10	546	546	CD
18637	21954	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21954	12	1941	1941	CD
18637	21954	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21954	14	.	.	.
18637	21955	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21955	2	984	984	CD
18637	21955	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21955	4	White	White	NNP
18637	21955	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21955	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21955	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21955	8	Ragen	Ragen	NNP
18637	21955	9	,	,	,
18637	21955	10	324	324	CD
18637	21955	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21955	12	760	760	CD
18637	21955	13	n.	n.	NN
18637	21955	14	1	1	CD
18637	21955	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21955	16	1945	1945	CD
18637	21955	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21955	18	.	.	.
18637	21956	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21956	2	985	985	CD
18637	21956	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21956	4	McKane	McKane	NNP
18637	21956	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21956	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21956	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21956	8	Durston	Durston	NNP
18637	21956	9	,	,	,
18637	21956	10	153	153	CD
18637	21956	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21956	12	684	684	CD
18637	21956	13	,	,	,
18637	21956	14	687	687	CD
18637	21956	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21956	16	1894	1894	CD
18637	21956	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21956	18	;	;	:
18637	21956	19	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
18637	21956	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21956	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21956	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21956	23	Swartz	Swartz	NNP
18637	21956	24	156	156	CD
18637	21956	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21956	26	272	272	CD
18637	21956	27	,	,	,
18637	21956	28	275	275	CD
18637	21956	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21956	30	1895	1895	CD
18637	21956	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21956	32	;	;	:
18637	21956	33	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	21956	34	_	_	NNP
18637	21956	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	21956	36	_	_	NNP
18637	21956	37	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	21956	38	,	,	,
18637	21956	39	177	177	CD
18637	21956	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21956	41	155	155	CD
18637	21956	42	,	,	,
18637	21956	43	158	158	CD
18637	21956	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21956	45	1900	1900	CD
18637	21956	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21956	47	;	;	:
18637	21956	48	Reetz	Reetz	NNP
18637	21956	49	_	_	NNP
18637	21956	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	21956	51	_	_	NNP
18637	21956	52	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	21956	53	,	,	,
18637	21956	54	188	188	CD
18637	21956	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21956	56	505	505	CD
18637	21956	57	,	,	,
18637	21956	58	508	508	CD
18637	21956	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21956	60	1903	1903	CD
18637	21956	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21956	62	.	.	.
18637	21957	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21957	2	986	986	CD
18637	21957	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21957	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	21957	5	,	,	,
18637	21957	6	where	where	WRB
18637	21957	7	on	on	IN
18637	21957	8	the	the	DT
18637	21957	9	day	day	NN
18637	21957	10	assigned	assign	VBN
18637	21957	11	for	for	IN
18637	21957	12	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	21957	13	of	of	IN
18637	21957	14	a	a	DT
18637	21957	15	writ	writ	NN
18637	21957	16	of	of	IN
18637	21957	17	error	error	NN
18637	21957	18	,	,	,
18637	21957	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21957	20	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	21957	21	that	that	IN
18637	21957	22	the	the	DT
18637	21957	23	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21957	24	had	have	VBD
18637	21957	25	escaped	escape	VBN
18637	21957	26	from	from	IN
18637	21957	27	jail	jail	NN
18637	21957	28	,	,	,
18637	21957	29	the	the	DT
18637	21957	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21957	31	,	,	,
18637	21957	32	without	without	IN
18637	21957	33	denial	denial	NN
18637	21957	34	of	of	IN
18637	21957	35	due	due	JJ
18637	21957	36	process	process	NN
18637	21957	37	,	,	,
18637	21957	38	could	could	MD
18637	21957	39	order	order	VB
18637	21957	40	that	that	IN
18637	21957	41	the	the	DT
18637	21957	42	writ	writ	NNP
18637	21957	43	be	be	VB
18637	21957	44	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
18637	21957	45	unless	unless	IN
18637	21957	46	the	the	DT
18637	21957	47	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	21957	48	surrender	surrender	NN
18637	21957	49	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21957	50	within	within	IN
18637	21957	51	60	60	CD
18637	21957	52	days	day	NNS
18637	21957	53	or	or	CC
18637	21957	54	be	be	VB
18637	21957	55	captured.--Allen	captured.--allen	CD
18637	21957	56	_	_	NNP
18637	21957	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	21957	58	_	_	NNP
18637	21957	59	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	21957	60	,	,	,
18637	21957	61	166	166	CD
18637	21957	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21957	63	138	138	CD
18637	21957	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21957	65	1897	1897	CD
18637	21957	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21957	67	.	.	.
18637	21958	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21958	2	987	987	CD
18637	21958	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21958	4	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	21958	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21958	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21958	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21958	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	21958	9	,	,	,
18637	21958	10	329	329	CD
18637	21958	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21958	12	173	173	CD
18637	21958	13	,	,	,
18637	21958	14	175	175	CD
18637	21958	15	-	-	SYM
18637	21958	16	176	176	CD
18637	21958	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21958	18	1946	1946	CD
18637	21958	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21958	20	.	.	.
18637	21959	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21959	2	988	988	CD
18637	21959	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21959	4	Frank	Frank	NNP
18637	21959	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21959	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21959	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21959	8	Mangum	Mangum	NNP
18637	21959	9	,	,	,
18637	21959	10	237	237	CD
18637	21959	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21959	12	309	309	CD
18637	21959	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21959	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	21959	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21959	16	.	.	.
18637	21960	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21960	2	989	989	CD
18637	21960	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21960	4	For	for	IN
18637	21960	5	rules	rule	NNS
18637	21960	6	of	of	IN
18637	21960	7	self	self	NN
18637	21960	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	21960	9	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	21960	10	formulated	formulate	VBN
18637	21960	11	by	by	IN
18637	21960	12	the	the	DT
18637	21960	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21960	14	not	not	RB
18637	21960	15	only	only	RB
18637	21960	16	to	to	TO
18637	21960	17	minimize	minimize	VB
18637	21960	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	21960	19	opportunities	opportunity	NNS
18637	21960	20	for	for	IN
18637	21960	21	such	such	JJ
18637	21960	22	interference	interference	NN
18637	21960	23	but	but	CC
18637	21960	24	also	also	RB
18637	21960	25	to	to	TO
18637	21960	26	curtail	curtail	VB
18637	21960	27	the	the	DT
18637	21960	28	volume	volume	NN
18637	21960	29	of	of	IN
18637	21960	30	litigation	litigation	NN
18637	21960	31	reaching	reach	VBG
18637	21960	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21960	33	for	for	IN
18637	21960	34	final	final	JJ
18637	21960	35	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	21960	36	,	,	,
18637	21960	37	_	_	NNP
18637	21960	38	see	see	VBP
18637	21960	39	_	_	NNP
18637	21960	40	p.	p.	NN
18637	21960	41	1109	1109	CD
18637	21960	42	.	.	.
18637	21961	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21961	2	990	990	CD
18637	21961	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21961	4	297	297	CD
18637	21961	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21961	6	278	278	CD
18637	21961	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21961	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	21961	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21961	10	.	.	.
18637	21962	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21962	2	991	991	CD
18637	21962	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21962	4	237	237	CD
18637	21962	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21962	6	309	309	CD
18637	21962	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21962	8	1915	1915	CD
18637	21962	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21962	10	.	.	.
18637	21963	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21963	2	992	992	CD
18637	21963	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21963	4	261	261	CD
18637	21963	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21963	6	86	86	CD
18637	21963	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21963	8	1923	1923	CD
18637	21963	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21963	10	.	.	.
18637	21964	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21964	2	993	993	CD
18637	21964	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21964	4	Despite	despite	IN
18637	21964	5	the	the	DT
18637	21964	6	court	court	NN
18637	21964	7	's	's	POS
18637	21964	8	contention	contention	NN
18637	21964	9	that	that	IN
18637	21964	10	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	21964	11	_	_	NNP
18637	21964	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	21964	13	_	_	NNP
18637	21964	14	Dempsey	Dempsey	NNP
18637	21964	15	was	be	VBD
18637	21964	16	disposed	dispose	VBN
18637	21964	17	of	of	IN
18637	21964	18	in	in	IN
18637	21964	19	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	21964	20	with	with	IN
18637	21964	21	the	the	DT
18637	21964	22	principles	principle	NNS
18637	21964	23	enunciated	enunciate	VBN
18637	21964	24	in	in	IN
18637	21964	25	Frank	Frank	NNP
18637	21964	26	_	_	NNP
18637	21964	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	21964	28	_	_	NNP
18637	21964	29	Mangum	Mangum	NNP
18637	21964	30	,	,	,
18637	21964	31	the	the	DT
18637	21964	32	two	two	CD
18637	21964	33	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	21964	34	are	be	VBP
18637	21964	35	distinguishable	distinguishable	JJ
18637	21964	36	not	not	RB
18637	21964	37	only	only	RB
18637	21964	38	by	by	IN
18637	21964	39	the	the	DT
18637	21964	40	different	different	JJ
18637	21964	41	results	result	NNS
18637	21964	42	reached	reach	VBD
18637	21964	43	therein	therein	RB
18637	21964	44	,	,	,
18637	21964	45	but	but	CC
18637	21964	46	by	by	IN
18637	21964	47	the	the	DT
18637	21964	48	fact	fact	NN
18637	21964	49	that	that	IN
18637	21964	50	the	the	DT
18637	21964	51	State	State	NNP
18637	21964	52	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	21964	53	court	court	NN
18637	21964	54	in	in	IN
18637	21964	55	Frank	Frank	NNP
18637	21964	56	_	_	NNP
18637	21964	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	21964	58	_	_	NNP
18637	21964	59	Mangum	Mangum	NNP
18637	21964	60	had	have	VBD
18637	21964	61	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	21964	62	that	that	IN
18637	21964	63	the	the	DT
18637	21964	64	trial	trial	NN
18637	21964	65	court	court	NN
18637	21964	66	had	have	VBD
18637	21964	67	correctly	correctly	RB
18637	21964	68	concluded	conclude	VBN
18637	21964	69	,	,	,
18637	21964	70	on	on	IN
18637	21964	71	the	the	DT
18637	21964	72	basis	basis	NN
18637	21964	73	of	of	IN
18637	21964	74	the	the	DT
18637	21964	75	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	21964	76	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	21964	77	,	,	,
18637	21964	78	that	that	IN
18637	21964	79	the	the	DT
18637	21964	80	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	21964	81	of	of	IN
18637	21964	82	mob	mob	NN
18637	21964	83	violence	violence	NN
18637	21964	84	were	be	VBD
18637	21964	85	unsubstantiated	unsubstantiated	JJ
18637	21964	86	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	21964	87	the	the	DT
18637	21964	88	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	21964	89	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	21964	90	court	court	NN
18637	21964	91	,	,	,
18637	21964	92	in	in	IN
18637	21964	93	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	21964	94	_	_	NNP
18637	21964	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	21964	96	_	_	NNP
18637	21964	97	Dempsey	Dempsey	NNP
18637	21964	98	,	,	,
18637	21964	99	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	21964	100	a	a	DT
18637	21964	101	similar	similar	JJ
18637	21964	102	allegation	allegation	NN
18637	21964	103	to	to	TO
18637	21964	104	be	be	VB
18637	21964	105	correct	correct	JJ
18637	21964	106	but	but	CC
18637	21964	107	did	do	VBD
18637	21964	108	not	not	RB
18637	21964	109	deem	deem	VB
18637	21964	110	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	21964	111	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
18637	21964	112	to	to	TO
18637	21964	113	render	render	VB
18637	21964	114	the	the	DT
18637	21964	115	trial	trial	NN
18637	21964	116	a	a	DT
18637	21964	117	nullity	nullity	NN
18637	21964	118	.	.	.
18637	21965	1	Although	although	IN
18637	21965	2	in	in	IN
18637	21965	3	the	the	DT
18637	21965	4	later	later	JJ
18637	21965	5	case	case	NN
18637	21965	6	,	,	,
18637	21965	7	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	21965	8	demurred	demur	VBD
18637	21965	9	and	and	CC
18637	21965	10	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	21965	11	admitted	admit	VBD
18637	21965	12	the	the	DT
18637	21965	13	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	21965	14	supporting	support	VBG
18637	21965	15	the	the	DT
18637	21965	16	_	_	NNP
18637	21965	17	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	21965	18	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	21965	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21965	20	petition	petition	NN
18637	21965	21	to	to	TO
18637	21965	22	be	be	VB
18637	21965	23	true	true	JJ
18637	21965	24	,	,	,
18637	21965	25	that	that	DT
18637	21965	26	fact	fact	NN
18637	21965	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	21965	28	a	a	DT
18637	21965	29	lesser	less	JJR
18637	21965	30	significance	significance	NN
18637	21965	31	,	,	,
18637	21965	32	for	for	IN
18637	21965	33	even	even	RB
18637	21965	34	in	in	IN
18637	21965	35	Frank	Frank	NNP
18637	21965	36	_	_	NNP
18637	21965	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	21965	38	_	_	NNP
18637	21965	39	Mangum	Mangum	NNP
18637	21965	40	,	,	,
18637	21965	41	the	the	DT
18637	21965	42	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	21965	43	Court	Court	NNP
18637	21965	44	abided	abide	VBN
18637	21965	45	by	by	IN
18637	21965	46	the	the	DT
18637	21965	47	rule	rule	NN
18637	21965	48	that	that	IN
18637	21965	49	the	the	DT
18637	21965	50	writ	writ	NNP
18637	21965	51	of	of	IN
18637	21965	52	_	_	NNP
18637	21965	53	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	21965	54	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	21965	55	_	_	NNP
18637	21965	56	relates	relate	VBZ
18637	21965	57	to	to	IN
18637	21965	58	matters	matter	NNS
18637	21965	59	of	of	IN
18637	21965	60	substance	substance	NN
18637	21965	61	and	and	CC
18637	21965	62	not	not	RB
18637	21965	63	of	of	IN
18637	21965	64	mere	mere	JJ
18637	21965	65	form	form	NN
18637	21965	66	,	,	,
18637	21965	67	and	and	CC
18637	21965	68	declared	declare	VBD
18637	21965	69	that	that	IN
18637	21965	70	the	the	DT
18637	21965	71	petitioner	petitioner	NN
18637	21965	72	's	's	POS
18637	21965	73	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	21965	74	should	should	MD
18637	21965	75	be	be	VB
18637	21965	76	treated	treat	VBN
18637	21965	77	as	as	IN
18637	21965	78	if	if	IN
18637	21965	79	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	21965	80	by	by	IN
18637	21965	81	the	the	DT
18637	21965	82	sheriff	sheriff	NN
18637	21965	83	having	have	VBG
18637	21965	84	custody	custody	NN
18637	21965	85	of	of	IN
18637	21965	86	the	the	DT
18637	21965	87	petitioner.--237	petitioner.--237	JJ
18637	21965	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21965	89	309	309	CD
18637	21965	90	,	,	,
18637	21965	91	332	332	CD
18637	21965	92	,	,	,
18637	21965	93	346	346	CD
18637	21965	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21965	95	1915	1915	CD
18637	21965	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21965	97	.	.	.
18637	21966	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21966	2	994	994	CD
18637	21966	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21966	4	James	James	NNP
18637	21966	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21966	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21966	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21966	8	Appel	Appel	NNP
18637	21966	9	,	,	,
18637	21966	10	192	192	CD
18637	21966	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21966	12	129	129	CD
18637	21966	13	,	,	,
18637	21966	14	137	137	CD
18637	21966	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21966	16	1904	1904	CD
18637	21966	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21966	18	;	;	:
18637	21966	19	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	21966	20	,	,	,
18637	21966	21	C.C.	C.C.	NNP
18637	21967	1	&	&	CC
18637	21967	2	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21967	3	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	21968	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21968	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21968	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21968	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21968	5	Backus	Backus	NNP
18637	21968	6	,	,	,
18637	21968	7	154	154	CD
18637	21968	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21968	9	421	421	CD
18637	21968	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21968	11	1894	1894	CD
18637	21968	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21968	13	;	;	:
18637	21968	14	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	21968	15	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	21968	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21968	17	_	_	NNP
18637	21968	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	21968	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21968	20	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	21968	21	ex	ex	NNP
18637	21968	22	rel	rel	NN
18637	21968	23	.	.	.
18637	21969	1	Hadley	Hadley	NNP
18637	21969	2	,	,	,
18637	21969	3	224	224	CD
18637	21969	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21969	5	270	270	CD
18637	21969	6	,	,	,
18637	21969	7	286	286	CD
18637	21969	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21969	9	1912	1912	CD
18637	21969	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21969	11	;	;	:
18637	21969	12	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	21969	13	_	_	NNP
18637	21969	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	21969	15	_	_	NNP
18637	21969	16	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	21969	17	State	State	NNP
18637	21969	18	Traveling	Traveling	NNP
18637	21969	19	Men	Men	NNPS
18637	21969	20	's	's	POS
18637	21969	21	Assoc	Assoc	NNP
18637	21969	22	.	.	.
18637	21969	23	,	,	,
18637	21969	24	283	283	CD
18637	21969	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21969	26	522	522	CD
18637	21969	27	,	,	,
18637	21969	28	524	524	CD
18637	21969	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21969	30	1931	1931	CD
18637	21969	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21969	32	.	.	.
18637	21970	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21970	2	995	995	CD
18637	21970	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21970	4	Tracy	Tracy	NNP
18637	21970	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21970	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21970	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21970	8	Ginzberg	Ginzberg	NNP
18637	21970	9	,	,	,
18637	21970	10	205	205	CD
18637	21970	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21970	12	170	170	CD
18637	21970	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21970	14	1907	1907	CD
18637	21970	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21970	16	;	;	:
18637	21970	17	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	21970	18	_	_	NNP
18637	21970	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	21970	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21970	21	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	21970	22	,	,	,
18637	21970	23	166	166	CD
18637	21970	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21970	25	138	138	CD
18637	21970	26	,	,	,
18637	21970	27	140	140	CD
18637	21970	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21970	29	1897	1897	CD
18637	21970	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21970	31	;	;	:
18637	21970	32	Fallbrook	Fallbrook	NNP
18637	21970	33	Irrig	Irrig	NNP
18637	21970	34	.	.	.
18637	21971	1	District	District	NNP
18637	21971	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21971	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21971	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21971	5	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	21971	6	,	,	,
18637	21971	7	164	164	CD
18637	21971	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21971	9	112	112	CD
18637	21971	10	,	,	,
18637	21971	11	157	157	CD
18637	21971	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21971	13	1896	1896	CD
18637	21971	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21971	15	.	.	.
18637	21972	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21972	2	996	996	CD
18637	21972	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21972	4	Thorington	Thorington	NNP
18637	21972	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21972	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21972	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21972	8	Montgomery	Montgomery	NNP
18637	21972	9	,	,	,
18637	21972	10	147	147	CD
18637	21972	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21972	12	490	490	CD
18637	21972	13	,	,	,
18637	21972	14	492	492	CD
18637	21972	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21972	16	1893	1893	CD
18637	21972	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21972	18	.	.	.
18637	21973	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21973	2	997	997	CD
18637	21973	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21973	4	Cross	Cross	NNP
18637	21973	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21973	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21973	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21973	8	North	North	NNP
18637	21973	9	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	21973	10	,	,	,
18637	21973	11	132	132	CD
18637	21973	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21973	13	131	131	CD
18637	21973	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21973	15	1889	1889	CD
18637	21973	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21973	17	.	.	.
18637	21974	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21974	2	998	998	CD
18637	21974	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21974	4	Ballard	Ballard	NNP
18637	21974	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21974	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21974	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21974	8	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	21974	9	,	,	,
18637	21974	10	204	204	CD
18637	21974	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21974	12	241	241	CD
18637	21974	13	,	,	,
18637	21974	14	258	258	CD
18637	21974	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21974	16	1907	1907	CD
18637	21974	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21974	18	;	;	:
18637	21974	19	Lyons	Lyons	NNP
18637	21974	20	_	_	NNP
18637	21974	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	21974	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21974	23	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	21974	24	,	,	,
18637	21974	25	322	322	CD
18637	21974	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21974	27	596	596	CD
18637	21974	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21974	29	1944	1944	CD
18637	21974	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21974	31	;	;	:
18637	21974	32	Gryger	Gryger	NNP
18637	21974	33	_	_	NNP
18637	21974	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	21974	35	_	_	NNP
18637	21974	36	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	21974	37	,	,	,
18637	21974	38	334	334	CD
18637	21974	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21974	40	728	728	CD
18637	21974	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21974	42	1948	1948	CD
18637	21974	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21974	44	.	.	.
18637	21975	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21975	2	999	999	CD
18637	21975	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21975	4	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	21975	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21975	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21975	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21975	8	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	21975	9	R.	R.	NNP
18637	21975	10	&	&	CC
18637	21975	11	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	21975	12	.	.	.
18637	21976	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21976	2	,	,	,
18637	21976	3	233	233	CD
18637	21976	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21976	5	665	665	CD
18637	21976	6	,	,	,
18637	21976	7	670	670	CD
18637	21976	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21976	9	1914	1914	CD
18637	21976	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21976	11	.	.	.
18637	21977	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21977	2	1000	1000	CD
18637	21977	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21977	4	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	21977	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21977	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21977	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21977	8	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	21977	9	,	,	,
18637	21977	10	137	137	CD
18637	21977	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21977	12	691	691	CD
18637	21977	13	,	,	,
18637	21977	14	692	692	CD
18637	21977	15	,	,	,
18637	21977	16	698	698	CD
18637	21977	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21977	18	1891	1891	CD
18637	21977	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21977	20	;	;	:
18637	21977	21	Bergemann	Bergemann	NNP
18637	21977	22	_	_	NNP
18637	21977	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	21977	24	_	_	NNP
18637	21977	25	Backer	Backer	NNP
18637	21977	26	,	,	,
18637	21977	27	157	157	CD
18637	21977	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21977	29	655	655	CD
18637	21977	30	,	,	,
18637	21977	31	656	656	CD
18637	21977	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21977	33	1895	1895	CD
18637	21977	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21977	35	.	.	.
18637	21978	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21978	2	1001	1001	CD
18637	21978	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21978	4	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	21978	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21978	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21978	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21978	8	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	21978	9	,	,	,
18637	21978	10	199	199	CD
18637	21978	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21978	12	425	425	CD
18637	21978	13	,	,	,
18637	21978	14	435	435	CD
18637	21978	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21978	16	1905	1905	CD
18637	21978	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21978	18	.	.	.
18637	21979	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21979	2	1002	1002	CD
18637	21979	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21979	4	West	West	NNP
18637	21979	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21979	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21979	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21979	8	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	21979	9	,	,	,
18637	21979	10	194	194	CD
18637	21979	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21979	12	258	258	CD
18637	21979	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21979	14	1904	1904	CD
18637	21979	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21979	16	.	.	.
18637	21980	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21980	2	1003	1003	CD
18637	21980	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21980	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	21980	5	L.	L.	NNP
18637	21980	6	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	21980	7	.	.	.
18637	21981	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21981	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21981	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21981	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21981	5	Cherry	Cherry	NNP
18637	21981	6	,	,	,
18637	21981	7	244	244	CD
18637	21981	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21981	9	25	25	CD
18637	21981	10	,	,	,
18637	21981	11	30	30	CD
18637	21981	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21981	13	1917	1917	CD
18637	21981	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21981	15	.	.	.
18637	21982	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21982	2	1004	1004	CD
18637	21982	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21982	4	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	21982	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	21982	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21982	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21982	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	21982	9	_	_	NNP
18637	21982	10	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	21982	11	ex	ex	NNP
18637	21982	12	rel	rel	NN
18637	21982	13	.	.	.
18637	21983	1	Hadley	Hadley	NNP
18637	21983	2	,	,	,
18637	21983	3	224	224	CD
18637	21983	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21983	5	270	270	CD
18637	21983	6	,	,	,
18637	21983	7	287	287	CD
18637	21983	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21983	9	1912	1912	CD
18637	21983	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21983	11	;	;	:
18637	21983	12	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	21983	13	_	_	NNP
18637	21983	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	21983	15	_	_	NNP
18637	21983	16	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	21983	17	ex	ex	FW
18637	21983	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	21983	19	.	.	.
18637	21984	1	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	21984	2	General	General	NNP
18637	21984	3	,	,	,
18637	21984	4	205	205	CD
18637	21984	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21984	6	454	454	CD
18637	21984	7	,	,	,
18637	21984	8	461	461	CD
18637	21984	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21984	10	1907	1907	CD
18637	21984	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21984	12	;	;	:
18637	21984	13	Stockholders	Stockholders	NNPS
18637	21984	14	_	_	NNP
18637	21984	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	21984	16	_	_	NNP
18637	21984	17	Sterling	Sterling	NNP
18637	21984	18	,	,	,
18637	21984	19	300	300	CD
18637	21984	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21984	21	175	175	CD
18637	21984	22	,	,	,
18637	21984	23	182	182	CD
18637	21984	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21984	25	1937	1937	CD
18637	21984	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21984	27	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21984	28	1005	1005	CD
18637	21984	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21984	30	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	21984	31	_	_	NNP
18637	21984	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	21984	33	_	_	NNP
18637	21984	34	Rives	Rives	NNP
18637	21984	35	,	,	,
18637	21984	36	100	100	CD
18637	21984	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21984	38	313	313	CD
18637	21984	39	,	,	,
18637	21984	40	318	318	CD
18637	21984	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21984	42	1880	1880	CD
18637	21984	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21984	44	.	.	.
18637	21985	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21985	2	1006	1006	CD
18637	21985	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21985	4	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
18637	21985	5	&	&	CC
18637	21985	6	St.	St.	NNP
18637	21985	7	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	21986	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	21986	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21986	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21986	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21986	5	Beckwith	Beckwith	NNP
18637	21986	6	,	,	,
18637	21986	7	129	129	CD
18637	21986	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21986	9	26	26	CD
18637	21986	10	,	,	,
18637	21986	11	28	28	CD
18637	21986	12	,	,	,
18637	21986	13	29	29	CD
18637	21986	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21986	15	1889	1889	CD
18637	21986	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21986	17	.	.	.
18637	21987	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21987	2	1007	1007	CD
18637	21987	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21987	4	Yick	Yick	NNP
18637	21987	5	Wo	Wo	NNP
18637	21987	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21987	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21987	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21987	9	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	21987	10	,	,	,
18637	21987	11	118	118	CD
18637	21987	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21987	13	356	356	CD
18637	21987	14	,	,	,
18637	21987	15	373	373	CD
18637	21987	16	,	,	,
18637	21987	17	374	374	CD
18637	21987	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21987	19	1886	1886	CD
18637	21987	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21987	21	.	.	.
18637	21988	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21988	2	1008	1008	CD
18637	21988	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21988	4	Snowden	Snowden	NNP
18637	21988	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21988	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21988	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21988	8	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	21988	9	,	,	,
18637	21988	10	321	321	CD
18637	21988	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21988	12	1	1	CD
18637	21988	13	,	,	,
18637	21988	14	8	8	CD
18637	21988	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21988	16	1944	1944	CD
18637	21988	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21988	18	.	.	.
18637	21989	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21989	2	1009	1009	CD
18637	21989	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21989	4	Truax	Truax	NNP
18637	21989	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21989	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21989	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21989	8	Corrigan	Corrigan	NNP
18637	21989	9	,	,	,
18637	21989	10	257	257	CD
18637	21989	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21989	12	312	312	CD
18637	21989	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21989	14	1921	1921	CD
18637	21989	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21989	16	.	.	.
18637	21990	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21990	2	1010	1010	CD
18637	21990	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21990	4	Neal	Neal	NNP
18637	21990	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21990	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21990	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21990	8	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	21990	9	,	,	,
18637	21990	10	103	103	CD
18637	21990	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21990	12	370	370	CD
18637	21990	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21990	14	1881	1881	CD
18637	21990	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21990	16	.	.	.
18637	21991	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21991	2	1011	1011	CD
18637	21991	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21991	4	Shelley	Shelley	NNP
18637	21991	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21991	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21991	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21991	8	Kraemer	Kraemer	NNP
18637	21991	9	,	,	,
18637	21991	10	334	334	CD
18637	21991	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21991	12	1	1	CD
18637	21991	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21991	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	21991	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21991	16	.	.	.
18637	21992	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21992	2	1012	1012	CD
18637	21992	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21992	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	21992	5	.	.	.
18637	21993	1	19	19	CD
18637	21993	2	.	.	.
18637	21994	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21994	2	1013	1013	CD
18637	21994	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21994	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	21994	5	ex	ex	NNP
18637	21994	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	21994	7	.	.	.
18637	21995	1	Gaines	Gaines	NNP
18637	21995	2	_	_	NNP
18637	21995	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	21995	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21995	5	Canada	Canada	NNP
18637	21995	6	,	,	,
18637	21995	7	305	305	CD
18637	21995	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21995	9	337	337	CD
18637	21995	10	,	,	,
18637	21995	11	343	343	CD
18637	21995	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21995	13	1938	1938	CD
18637	21995	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21995	15	.	.	.
18637	21996	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21996	2	1014	1014	CD
18637	21996	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21996	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	21996	5	_	_	NNP
18637	21996	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	21996	7	_	_	NNP
18637	21996	8	Allwright	Allwright	NNP
18637	21996	9	,	,	,
18637	21996	10	321	321	CD
18637	21996	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21996	12	649	649	CD
18637	21996	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21996	14	1944	1944	CD
18637	21996	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21996	16	.	.	.
18637	21997	1	_	_	NNP
18637	21997	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	21997	3	.	.	.
18637	21997	4	_	_	NNP
18637	21997	5	Nixon	Nixon	NNP
18637	21997	6	_	_	NNP
18637	21997	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	21997	8	_	_	NNP
18637	21997	9	Herndon	Herndon	NNP
18637	21997	10	,	,	,
18637	21997	11	273	273	CD
18637	21997	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21997	13	536	536	CD
18637	21997	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21997	15	1927	1927	CD
18637	21997	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21997	17	;	;	:
18637	21997	18	Nixon	Nixon	NNP
18637	21997	19	_	_	NNP
18637	21997	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	21997	21	_	_	NNP
18637	21997	22	Condon	Condon	NNP
18637	21997	23	,	,	,
18637	21997	24	286	286	CD
18637	21997	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21997	26	73	73	CD
18637	21997	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21997	28	1932	1932	CD
18637	21997	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21997	30	;	;	:
18637	21997	31	Grovey	Grovey	NNP
18637	21997	32	_	_	NNP
18637	21997	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	21997	34	_	_	NNP
18637	21997	35	Townsend	Townsend	NNP
18637	21997	36	,	,	,
18637	21997	37	295	295	CD
18637	21997	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	21997	39	45	45	CD
18637	21997	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21997	41	1938	1938	CD
18637	21997	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21997	43	.	.	.
18637	21998	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	21998	2	1015	1015	CD
18637	21998	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	21998	4	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	21998	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	21998	6	House	House	NNP
18637	21998	7	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	21998	8	,	,	,
18637	21998	9	16	16	CD
18637	21998	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	21998	11	.	.	.
18637	21999	1	36	36	CD
18637	21999	2	,	,	,
18637	21999	3	81	81	CD
18637	21999	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	21999	5	1873	1873	CD
18637	21999	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	21999	7	.	.	.
18637	22000	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22000	2	1016	1016	CD
18637	22000	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22000	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	22000	5	,	,	,
18637	22000	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	22001	1	&	&	CC
18637	22001	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	22002	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22002	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22002	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22002	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22002	5	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	22002	6	,	,	,
18637	22002	7	94	94	CD
18637	22002	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22002	9	155	155	CD
18637	22002	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22002	11	1877	1877	CD
18637	22002	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22002	13	;	;	:
18637	22002	14	Peik	Peik	NNP
18637	22002	15	_	_	NNP
18637	22002	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	22002	17	_	_	NNP
18637	22002	18	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	22002	19	&	&	CC
18637	22002	20	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	22002	21	R.	R.	NNP
18637	22002	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22002	23	,	,	,
18637	22002	24	94	94	CD
18637	22002	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22002	26	164	164	CD
18637	22002	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22002	28	1877	1877	CD
18637	22002	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22002	30	;	;	:
18637	22002	31	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	22002	32	,	,	,
18637	22002	33	M.	M.	NNP
18637	22002	34	&	&	CC
18637	22002	35	St.	St.	NNP
18637	22002	36	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	22003	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22003	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22003	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22003	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22003	5	Ackley	Ackley	NNP
18637	22003	6	,	,	,
18637	22003	7	94	94	CD
18637	22003	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22003	9	179	179	CD
18637	22003	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22003	11	1877	1877	CD
18637	22003	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22003	13	;	;	:
18637	22003	14	Winona	Winona	NNP
18637	22003	15	&	&	CC
18637	22003	16	St.	St.	NNP
18637	22003	17	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	22004	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22004	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22004	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22004	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22004	5	Blake	Blake	NNP
18637	22004	6	,	,	,
18637	22004	7	94	94	CD
18637	22004	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22004	9	180	180	CD
18637	22004	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22004	11	1877	1877	CD
18637	22004	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22004	13	.	.	.
18637	22005	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22005	2	1017	1017	CD
18637	22005	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22005	4	Santa	Santa	NNP
18637	22005	5	Clara	Clara	NNP
18637	22005	6	County	County	NNP
18637	22005	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22005	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22005	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22005	10	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	22005	11	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	22006	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22006	2	,	,	,
18637	22006	3	118	118	CD
18637	22006	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22006	5	394	394	CD
18637	22006	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22006	7	1886	1886	CD
18637	22006	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22006	9	.	.	.
18637	22007	1	The	the	DT
18637	22007	2	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	22007	3	stood	stand	VBD
18637	22007	4	unchallenged	unchallenged	JJ
18637	22007	5	until	until	IN
18637	22007	6	1938	1938	CD
18637	22007	7	when	when	WRB
18637	22007	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22007	9	Black	Black	NNP
18637	22007	10	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	22007	11	in	in	IN
18637	22007	12	a	a	DT
18637	22007	13	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	22007	14	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	22007	15	that	that	IN
18637	22007	16	"	"	``
18637	22007	17	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22007	18	do	do	VBP
18637	22007	19	not	not	RB
18637	22007	20	believe	believe	VB
18637	22007	21	the	the	DT
18637	22007	22	word	word	NN
18637	22007	23	'	'	``
18637	22007	24	person	person	NN
18637	22007	25	'	'	''
18637	22007	26	in	in	IN
18637	22007	27	the	the	DT
18637	22007	28	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	22007	29	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22007	30	includes	include	VBZ
18637	22007	31	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	22007	32	.	.	.
18637	22007	33	"	"	''
18637	22008	1	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	22008	2	General	General	NNP
18637	22008	3	Life	Life	NNP
18637	22008	4	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	22008	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22008	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22008	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22008	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22008	9	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	22008	10	,	,	,
18637	22008	11	303	303	CD
18637	22008	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22008	13	77	77	CD
18637	22008	14	,	,	,
18637	22008	15	85	85	CD
18637	22008	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22008	17	1938	1938	CD
18637	22008	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22008	19	.	.	.
18637	22009	1	More	more	RBR
18637	22009	2	recently	recently	RB
18637	22009	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22009	4	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	22009	5	expressed	express	VBD
18637	22009	6	the	the	DT
18637	22009	7	same	same	JJ
18637	22009	8	view	view	NN
18637	22009	9	in	in	IN
18637	22009	10	a	a	DT
18637	22009	11	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	22009	12	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	22009	13	in	in	IN
18637	22009	14	which	which	WDT
18637	22009	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22009	16	Black	Black	NNP
18637	22009	17	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	22009	18	.	.	.
18637	22010	1	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	22010	2	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	22010	3	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	22010	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22010	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	22010	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22010	7	Glander	Glander	NNP
18637	22010	8	,	,	,
18637	22010	9	337	337	CD
18637	22010	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22010	11	562	562	CD
18637	22010	12	,	,	,
18637	22010	13	576	576	CD
18637	22010	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22010	15	1949	1949	CD
18637	22010	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22010	17	.	.	.
18637	22011	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22011	2	1018	1018	CD
18637	22011	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22011	4	Yick	Yick	NNP
18637	22011	5	Wo	Wo	NNP
18637	22011	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22011	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22011	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22011	9	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	22011	10	,	,	,
18637	22011	11	118	118	CD
18637	22011	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22011	13	356	356	CD
18637	22011	14	,	,	,
18637	22011	15	369	369	CD
18637	22011	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22011	17	1886	1886	CD
18637	22011	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22011	19	.	.	.
18637	22012	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22012	2	1019	1019	CD
18637	22012	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22012	4	Newark	Newark	NNP
18637	22012	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22012	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22012	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22012	8	New	New	NNP
18637	22012	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	22012	10	,	,	,
18637	22012	11	262	262	CD
18637	22012	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22012	13	192	192	CD
18637	22012	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22012	15	1923	1923	CD
18637	22012	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22012	17	;	;	:
18637	22012	18	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	22012	19	_	_	NNP
18637	22012	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	22012	21	_	_	NNP
18637	22012	22	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	22012	23	,	,	,
18637	22012	24	289	289	CD
18637	22012	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22012	26	36	36	CD
18637	22012	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22012	28	1933	1933	CD
18637	22012	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22012	30	.	.	.
18637	22013	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22013	2	1020	1020	CD
18637	22013	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22013	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22013	5	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	22013	6	.	.	.
18637	22013	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22013	8	Hillsborough	Hillsborough	NNP
18637	22013	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22013	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	22013	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22013	12	Cromwell	Cromwell	NNP
18637	22013	13	,	,	,
18637	22013	14	326	326	CD
18637	22013	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22013	16	620	620	CD
18637	22013	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22013	18	1846	1846	CD
18637	22013	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22013	20	.	.	.
18637	22014	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22014	2	1021	1021	CD
18637	22014	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22014	4	Blake	Blake	NNP
18637	22014	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22014	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22014	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22014	8	McClung	McClung	NNP
18637	22014	9	,	,	,
18637	22014	10	172	172	CD
18637	22014	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22014	12	239	239	CD
18637	22014	13	,	,	,
18637	22014	14	261	261	CD
18637	22014	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22014	16	1898	1898	CD
18637	22014	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22014	18	;	;	:
18637	22014	19	Sully	Sully	NNP
18637	22014	20	_	_	NNP
18637	22014	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	22014	22	_	_	NNP
18637	22014	23	American	American	NNP
18637	22014	24	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	22014	25	.	.	.
18637	22015	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	22015	2	,	,	,
18637	22015	3	178	178	CD
18637	22015	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22015	5	289	289	CD
18637	22015	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22015	7	1900	1900	CD
18637	22015	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22015	9	.	.	.
18637	22016	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22016	2	1022	1022	CD
18637	22016	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22016	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	22016	5	Finance	Finance	NNP
18637	22016	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	22016	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22016	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22016	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22016	10	Paramount	Paramount	NNP
18637	22016	11	Auto	Auto	NNP
18637	22016	12	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	22016	13	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	22016	14	,	,	,
18637	22016	15	262	262	CD
18637	22016	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22016	17	544	544	CD
18637	22016	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22016	19	1923	1923	CD
18637	22016	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22016	21	.	.	.
18637	22017	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22017	2	1023	1023	CD
18637	22017	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22017	4	Hillsborough	Hillsborough	NNP
18637	22017	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22017	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22017	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22017	8	Cromwell	Cromwell	NNP
18637	22017	9	,	,	,
18637	22017	10	326	326	CD
18637	22017	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22017	12	620	620	CD
18637	22017	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22017	14	1946	1946	CD
18637	22017	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22017	16	.	.	.
18637	22018	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22018	2	1024	1024	CD
18637	22018	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22018	4	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	22018	5	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	22018	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	22018	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22018	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22018	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22018	10	Glander	Glander	NNP
18637	22018	11	,	,	,
18637	22018	12	337	337	CD
18637	22018	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22018	14	562	562	CD
18637	22018	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22018	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	22018	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22018	18	;	;	:
18637	22018	19	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
18637	22018	20	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	22018	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22018	22	_	_	NNP
18637	22018	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	22018	24	_	_	NNP
18637	22018	25	Harding	Harding	NNP
18637	22018	26	,	,	,
18637	22018	27	272	272	CD
18637	22018	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22018	29	494	494	CD
18637	22018	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22018	31	1926	1926	CD
18637	22018	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22018	33	.	.	.
18637	22019	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22019	2	1025	1025	CD
18637	22019	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22019	4	Fire	Fire	NNP
18637	22019	5	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	22019	6	.	.	.
18637	22020	1	of	of	IN
18637	22020	2	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	22020	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22020	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22020	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22020	6	New	New	NNP
18637	22020	7	York	York	NNP
18637	22020	8	,	,	,
18637	22020	9	119	119	CD
18637	22020	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22020	11	110	110	CD
18637	22020	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22020	13	1886	1886	CD
18637	22020	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22020	15	.	.	.
18637	22021	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22021	2	1026	1026	CD
18637	22021	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22021	4	Yick	Yick	NNP
18637	22021	5	Wo	Wo	NNP
18637	22021	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22021	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22021	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22021	9	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	22021	10	,	,	,
18637	22021	11	118	118	CD
18637	22021	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22021	13	356	356	CD
18637	22021	14	,	,	,
18637	22021	15	369	369	CD
18637	22021	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22021	17	1886	1886	CD
18637	22021	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22021	19	.	.	.
18637	22022	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22022	2	1027	1027	CD
18637	22022	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22022	4	Barbier	Barbier	NNP
18637	22022	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22022	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22022	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22022	8	Connolly	Connolly	NNP
18637	22022	9	,	,	,
18637	22022	10	113	113	CD
18637	22022	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22022	12	27	27	CD
18637	22022	13	,	,	,
18637	22022	14	31	31	CD
18637	22022	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22022	16	1885	1885	CD
18637	22022	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22022	18	.	.	.
18637	22023	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22023	2	1028	1028	CD
18637	22023	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22023	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	22023	5	.	.	.
18637	22024	1	31	31	CD
18637	22024	2	-	-	SYM
18637	22024	3	32	32	CD
18637	22024	4	.	.	.
18637	22025	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22025	2	1029	1029	CD
18637	22025	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22025	4	Truax	Truax	NNP
18637	22025	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22025	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22025	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22025	8	Corrigan	Corrigan	NNP
18637	22025	9	,	,	,
18637	22025	10	257	257	CD
18637	22025	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22025	12	312	312	CD
18637	22025	13	,	,	,
18637	22025	14	332	332	CD
18637	22025	15	-	-	SYM
18637	22025	16	333	333	CD
18637	22025	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22025	18	1921	1921	CD
18637	22025	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22025	20	.	.	.
18637	22026	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22026	2	1030	1030	CD
18637	22026	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22026	4	Barrett	Barrett	NNP
18637	22026	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22026	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22026	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22026	8	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	22026	9	,	,	,
18637	22026	10	229	229	CD
18637	22026	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22026	12	26	26	CD
18637	22026	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22026	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	22026	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22026	16	.	.	.
18637	22027	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22027	2	1031	1031	CD
18637	22027	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22027	4	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	22027	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22027	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22027	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22027	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	22027	9	,	,	,
18637	22027	10	218	218	CD
18637	22027	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22027	12	173	173	CD
18637	22027	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22027	14	1910	1910	CD
18637	22027	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22027	16	.	.	.
18637	22028	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22028	2	1032	1032	CD
18637	22028	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22028	4	Orient	Orient	NNP
18637	22028	5	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	22028	6	.	.	.
18637	22029	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22029	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22029	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22029	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22029	5	Daggs	Daggs	NNP
18637	22029	6	,	,	,
18637	22029	7	172	172	CD
18637	22029	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22029	9	557	557	CD
18637	22029	10	,	,	,
18637	22029	11	562	562	CD
18637	22029	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22029	13	1899	1899	CD
18637	22029	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22029	15	.	.	.
18637	22030	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22030	2	1033	1033	CD
18637	22030	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22030	4	Bachtel	Bachtel	NNP
18637	22030	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22030	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22030	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22030	8	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	22030	9	,	,	,
18637	22030	10	204	204	CD
18637	22030	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22030	12	36	36	CD
18637	22030	13	,	,	,
18637	22030	14	41	41	CD
18637	22030	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22030	16	1907	1907	CD
18637	22030	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22030	18	.	.	.
18637	22031	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22031	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22031	3	also	also	RB
18637	22031	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22031	5	Frost	Frost	NNP
18637	22031	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22031	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22031	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22031	9	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	22031	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	22031	11	,	,	,
18637	22031	12	278	278	CD
18637	22031	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22031	14	515	515	CD
18637	22031	15	,	,	,
18637	22031	16	522	522	CD
18637	22031	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22031	18	1929	1929	CD
18637	22031	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22031	20	;	;	:
18637	22031	21	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	22031	22	_	_	NNP
18637	22031	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	22031	24	_	_	NNP
18637	22031	25	Cahoon	Cahoon	NNP
18637	22031	26	,	,	,
18637	22031	27	283	283	CD
18637	22031	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22031	29	553	553	CD
18637	22031	30	,	,	,
18637	22031	31	566	566	CD
18637	22031	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	22031	33	567	567	CD
18637	22031	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22031	35	1931	1931	CD
18637	22031	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22031	37	.	.	.
18637	22032	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22032	2	1034	1034	CD
18637	22032	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22032	4	Lindsley	Lindsley	NNP
18637	22032	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22032	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22032	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22032	8	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	22032	9	Carbonic	Carbonic	NNP
18637	22032	10	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	22032	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22032	12	,	,	,
18637	22032	13	220	220	CD
18637	22032	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22032	15	61	61	CD
18637	22032	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22032	17	1911	1911	CD
18637	22032	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22032	19	.	.	.
18637	22033	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22033	2	1035	1035	CD
18637	22033	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22033	4	Middleton	Middleton	NNP
18637	22033	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22033	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22033	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22033	8	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	22033	9	Power	Power	NNP
18637	22033	10	&	&	CC
18637	22033	11	Light	Light	NNP
18637	22033	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22033	13	,	,	,
18637	22033	14	249	249	CD
18637	22033	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22033	16	152	152	CD
18637	22033	17	,	,	,
18637	22033	18	157	157	CD
18637	22033	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22033	20	1919	1919	CD
18637	22033	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22033	22	;	;	:
18637	22033	23	Madden	Madden	NNP
18637	22033	24	_	_	NNP
18637	22033	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	22033	26	_	_	NNP
18637	22033	27	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	22033	28	,	,	,
18637	22033	29	309	309	CD
18637	22033	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22033	31	83	83	CD
18637	22033	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22033	33	1940	1940	CD
18637	22033	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22033	35	.	.	.
18637	22034	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22034	2	1036	1036	CD
18637	22034	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22034	4	Crescent	Crescent	NNP
18637	22034	5	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	22034	6	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	22034	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22034	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22034	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22034	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22034	11	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	22034	12	,	,	,
18637	22034	13	257	257	CD
18637	22034	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22034	15	129	129	CD
18637	22034	16	,	,	,
18637	22034	17	137	137	CD
18637	22034	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22034	19	1921	1921	CD
18637	22034	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22034	21	.	.	.
18637	22035	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22035	2	1037	1037	CD
18637	22035	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22035	4	West	West	NNP
18637	22035	5	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	22035	6	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	22035	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22035	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22035	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22035	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22035	11	Parrish	Parrish	NNP
18637	22035	12	,	,	,
18637	22035	13	300	300	CD
18637	22035	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22035	15	379	379	CD
18637	22035	16	,	,	,
18637	22035	17	400	400	CD
18637	22035	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22035	19	1937	1937	CD
18637	22035	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22035	21	.	.	.
18637	22036	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22036	2	1038	1038	CD
18637	22036	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22036	4	Lindsley	Lindsley	NNP
18637	22036	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22036	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22036	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22036	8	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	22036	9	Carbonic	Carbonic	NNP
18637	22036	10	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	22036	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22036	12	,	,	,
18637	22036	13	220	220	CD
18637	22036	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22036	15	61	61	CD
18637	22036	16	,	,	,
18637	22036	17	81	81	CD
18637	22036	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22036	19	1911	1911	CD
18637	22036	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22036	21	.	.	.
18637	22037	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22037	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	22037	3	.	.	.
18637	22037	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22037	5	United	United	NNP
18637	22037	6	States	States	NNP
18637	22037	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22037	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22037	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22037	10	Petrillo	Petrillo	NNP
18637	22037	11	,	,	,
18637	22037	12	332	332	CD
18637	22037	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22037	14	1	1	CD
18637	22037	15	,	,	,
18637	22037	16	8	8	CD
18637	22037	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22037	18	1947	1947	CD
18637	22037	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22037	20	.	.	.
18637	22038	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22038	2	1039	1039	CD
18637	22038	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22038	4	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	22038	5	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	22038	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22038	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22038	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22038	9	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	22038	10	,	,	,
18637	22038	11	249	249	CD
18637	22038	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22038	13	265	265	CD
18637	22038	14	,	,	,
18637	22038	15	268	268	CD
18637	22038	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22038	17	1919	1919	CD
18637	22038	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22038	19	.	.	.
18637	22039	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22039	2	1040	1040	CD
18637	22039	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22039	4	West	West	NNP
18637	22039	5	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	22039	6	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	22039	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22039	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22039	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22039	10	Parrish	Parrish	NNP
18637	22039	11	,	,	,
18637	22039	12	300	300	CD
18637	22039	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22039	14	379	379	CD
18637	22039	15	,	,	,
18637	22039	16	400	400	CD
18637	22039	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22039	18	1937	1937	CD
18637	22039	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22039	20	.	.	.
18637	22040	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22040	2	1041	1041	CD
18637	22040	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22040	4	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	22040	5	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	22040	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22040	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22040	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22040	9	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	22040	10	,	,	,
18637	22040	11	249	249	CD
18637	22040	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22040	13	265	265	CD
18637	22040	14	,	,	,
18637	22040	15	268	268	CD
18637	22040	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22040	17	1919	1919	CD
18637	22040	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22040	19	.	.	.
18637	22041	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22041	2	1042	1042	CD
18637	22041	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22041	4	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	22041	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22041	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22041	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22041	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	22041	9	,	,	,
18637	22041	10	218	218	CD
18637	22041	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22041	12	173	173	CD
18637	22041	13	,	,	,
18637	22041	14	179	179	CD
18637	22041	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22041	16	1910	1910	CD
18637	22041	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22041	18	.	.	.
18637	22042	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22042	2	1043	1043	CD
18637	22042	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22042	4	Phelps	Phelps	NNP
18637	22042	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22042	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22042	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22042	8	Board	Board	NNP
18637	22042	9	of	of	IN
18637	22042	10	Education	Education	NNP
18637	22042	11	,	,	,
18637	22042	12	300	300	CD
18637	22042	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22042	14	319	319	CD
18637	22042	15	,	,	,
18637	22042	16	324	324	CD
18637	22042	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22042	18	1937	1937	CD
18637	22042	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22042	20	.	.	.
18637	22043	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22043	2	1044	1044	CD
18637	22043	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22043	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	22043	5	Dock	Dock	NNP
18637	22043	6	&	&	CC
18637	22043	7	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	22043	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22043	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22043	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	22043	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22043	12	Fraley	Fraley	NNP
18637	22043	13	,	,	,
18637	22043	14	228	228	CD
18637	22043	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22043	16	680	680	CD
18637	22043	17	,	,	,
18637	22043	18	687	687	CD
18637	22043	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22043	20	1913	1913	CD
18637	22043	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22043	22	.	.	.
18637	22044	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22044	2	1045	1045	CD
18637	22044	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22044	4	Davidson	Davidson	NNP
18637	22044	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22044	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22044	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22044	8	New	New	NNP
18637	22044	9	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	22044	10	,	,	,
18637	22044	11	96	96	CD
18637	22044	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22044	13	97	97	CD
18637	22044	14	,	,	,
18637	22044	15	106	106	CD
18637	22044	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22044	17	1878	1878	CD
18637	22044	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22044	19	.	.	.
18637	22045	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22045	2	1046	1046	CD
18637	22045	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22045	4	Fire	Fire	NNP
18637	22045	5	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	22045	6	.	.	.
18637	22046	1	of	of	IN
18637	22046	2	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	22046	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22046	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22046	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22046	6	New	New	NNP
18637	22046	7	York	York	NNP
18637	22046	8	,	,	,
18637	22046	9	119	119	CD
18637	22046	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22046	11	110	110	CD
18637	22046	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22046	13	1886	1886	CD
18637	22046	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22046	15	;	;	:
18637	22046	16	Santa	Santa	NNP
18637	22046	17	Clara	Clara	NNP
18637	22046	18	County	County	NNP
18637	22046	19	_	_	NNP
18637	22046	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	22046	21	_	_	NNP
18637	22046	22	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	22046	23	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	22047	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22047	2	,	,	,
18637	22047	3	118	118	CD
18637	22047	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22047	5	394	394	CD
18637	22047	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22047	7	1886	1886	CD
18637	22047	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22047	9	.	.	.
18637	22048	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22048	2	1047	1047	CD
18637	22048	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22048	4	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	22048	5	's	's	POS
18637	22048	6	Gap	Gap	NNP
18637	22048	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	22048	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22048	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22048	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	22048	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22048	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	22048	13	,	,	,
18637	22048	14	134	134	CD
18637	22048	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22048	16	232	232	CD
18637	22048	17	,	,	,
18637	22048	18	237	237	CD
18637	22048	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22048	20	1890	1890	CD
18637	22048	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22048	22	.	.	.
18637	22049	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22049	2	Emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	22049	3	supplied	supply	VBN
18637	22049	4	.	.	.
18637	22049	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22050	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22050	2	1048	1048	CD
18637	22050	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22050	4	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	22050	5	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	22050	6	&	&	CC
18637	22050	7	E.	E.	NNP
18637	22050	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22050	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22050	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	22050	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22050	12	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	22050	13	,	,	,
18637	22050	14	277	277	CD
18637	22050	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22050	16	32	32	CD
18637	22050	17	,	,	,
18637	22050	18	37	37	CD
18637	22050	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22050	20	1928	1928	CD
18637	22050	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22050	22	.	.	.
18637	22051	1	Classification	classification	NN
18637	22051	2	for	for	IN
18637	22051	3	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	22051	4	of	of	IN
18637	22051	5	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	22051	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	22051	7	been	be	VBN
18637	22051	8	held	hold	VBN
18637	22051	9	valid	valid	JJ
18637	22051	10	in	in	IN
18637	22051	11	the	the	DT
18637	22051	12	following	follow	VBG
18637	22051	13	situations	situation	NNS
18637	22051	14	:	:	:
18637	22051	15	_	_	NNP
18637	22051	16	Banks	Banks	NNPS
18637	22051	17	:	:	:
18637	22051	18	_	_	NNP
18637	22051	19	a	a	DT
18637	22051	20	heavier	heavy	JJR
18637	22051	21	tax	tax	NN
18637	22051	22	on	on	IN
18637	22051	23	banks	bank	NNS
18637	22051	24	which	which	WDT
18637	22051	25	make	make	VBP
18637	22051	26	loans	loan	NNS
18637	22051	27	mainly	mainly	RB
18637	22051	28	from	from	IN
18637	22051	29	money	money	NN
18637	22051	30	of	of	IN
18637	22051	31	depositors	depositor	NNS
18637	22051	32	than	than	IN
18637	22051	33	on	on	IN
18637	22051	34	other	other	JJ
18637	22051	35	financial	financial	JJ
18637	22051	36	institutions	institution	NNS
18637	22051	37	which	which	WDT
18637	22051	38	make	make	VBP
18637	22051	39	loans	loan	NNS
18637	22051	40	mainly	mainly	RB
18637	22051	41	from	from	IN
18637	22051	42	money	money	NN
18637	22051	43	supplied	supply	VBN
18637	22051	44	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	22051	45	than	than	IN
18637	22051	46	by	by	IN
18637	22051	47	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	22051	48	.	.	.
18637	22052	1	First	first	JJ
18637	22052	2	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	22052	3	.	.	.
18637	22053	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	22053	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22053	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22053	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22053	5	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	22053	6	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	22053	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	22053	8	,	,	,
18637	22053	9	289	289	CD
18637	22053	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22053	11	60	60	CD
18637	22053	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22053	13	1933	1933	CD
18637	22053	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22053	15	.	.	.
18637	22054	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22054	2	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	22054	3	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	22054	4	:	:	:
18637	22054	5	_	_	IN
18637	22054	6	a	a	DT
18637	22054	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	22054	8	of	of	IN
18637	22054	9	50¢	50â¢	CD
18637	22054	10	per	per	IN
18637	22054	11	$	$	$
18637	22054	12	100	100	CD
18637	22054	13	on	on	IN
18637	22054	14	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	22054	15	in	in	IN
18637	22054	16	banks	bank	NNS
18637	22054	17	outside	outside	IN
18637	22054	18	a	a	DT
18637	22054	19	State	state	NN
18637	22054	20	in	in	IN
18637	22054	21	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	22054	22	with	with	IN
18637	22054	23	a	a	DT
18637	22054	24	rate	rate	NN
18637	22054	25	of	of	IN
18637	22054	26	10¢	10â¢	CD
18637	22054	27	per	per	IN
18637	22054	28	$	$	$
18637	22054	29	100	100	CD
18637	22054	30	on	on	IN
18637	22054	31	deposits	deposit	NNS
18637	22054	32	in	in	IN
18637	22054	33	the	the	DT
18637	22054	34	State	State	NNP
18637	22054	35	.	.	.
18637	22055	1	Madden	Madden	NNP
18637	22055	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22055	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22055	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22055	5	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	22055	6	,	,	,
18637	22055	7	309	309	CD
18637	22055	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22055	9	83	83	CD
18637	22055	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22055	11	1940	1940	CD
18637	22055	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22055	13	.	.	.
18637	22056	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22056	2	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	22056	3	:	:	:
18637	22056	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22056	5	a	a	DT
18637	22056	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	22056	7	of	of	IN
18637	22056	8	2	2	CD
18637	22056	9	-	-	SYM
18637	22056	10	1/2	1/2	CD
18637	22056	11	percent	percent	NN
18637	22056	12	on	on	IN
18637	22056	13	anthracite	anthracite	NN
18637	22056	14	but	but	CC
18637	22056	15	not	not	RB
18637	22056	16	on	on	IN
18637	22056	17	bituminous	bituminous	JJ
18637	22056	18	coal	coal	NN
18637	22056	19	.	.	.
18637	22057	1	Heisler	Heisler	NNP
18637	22057	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22057	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22057	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22057	5	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	22057	6	Colliery	Colliery	NNP
18637	22057	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22057	8	,	,	,
18637	22057	9	260	260	CD
18637	22057	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22057	11	245	245	CD
18637	22057	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22057	13	1922	1922	CD
18637	22057	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22057	15	.	.	.
18637	22058	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22058	2	Gasoline	Gasoline	NNP
18637	22058	3	:	:	:
18637	22058	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22058	5	a	a	DT
18637	22058	6	graduated	graduate	VBN
18637	22058	7	severance	severance	NN
18637	22058	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	22058	9	on	on	IN
18637	22058	10	oils	oil	NNS
18637	22058	11	sold	sell	VBN
18637	22058	12	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	22058	13	for	for	IN
18637	22058	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22058	15	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	22058	16	content	content	NN
18637	22058	17	,	,	,
18637	22058	18	measured	measure	VBN
18637	22058	19	by	by	IN
18637	22058	20	resort	resort	NN
18637	22058	21	to	to	IN
18637	22058	22	BaumÃ	BaumÃ	NNP
18637	22058	23	©	©	NNP
18637	22058	24	gravity	gravity	NN
18637	22058	25	.	.	.
18637	22059	1	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	22059	2	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	22059	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22059	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22059	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	22059	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22059	7	Conway	Conway	NNP
18637	22059	8	,	,	,
18637	22059	9	281	281	CD
18637	22059	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22059	11	146	146	CD
18637	22059	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22059	13	1930	1930	CD
18637	22059	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22059	15	.	.	.
18637	22060	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22060	2	Chain	Chain	NNP
18637	22060	3	stores	store	NNS
18637	22060	4	:	:	:
18637	22060	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22060	6	a	a	DT
18637	22060	7	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	22060	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	22060	9	graduated	graduate	VBN
18637	22060	10	according	accord	VBG
18637	22060	11	to	to	IN
18637	22060	12	the	the	DT
18637	22060	13	number	number	NN
18637	22060	14	of	of	IN
18637	22060	15	stores	store	NNS
18637	22060	16	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	22060	17	,	,	,
18637	22060	18	State	State	NNP
18637	22060	19	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	22060	20	Comr	Comr	NNP
18637	22060	21	's	's	POS
18637	22060	22	.	.	.
18637	22061	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22061	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	22061	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22061	4	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	22061	5	,	,	,
18637	22061	6	283	283	CD
18637	22061	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22061	8	527	527	CD
18637	22061	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22061	10	1931	1931	CD
18637	22061	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22061	12	;	;	:
18637	22061	13	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	22061	14	_	_	NNP
18637	22061	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	22061	16	_	_	NNP
18637	22061	17	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	22061	18	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	22061	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22061	20	,	,	,
18637	22061	21	294	294	CD
18637	22061	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22061	23	87	87	CD
18637	22061	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22061	25	1935	1935	CD
18637	22061	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22061	27	;	;	:
18637	22061	28	a	a	DT
18637	22061	29	license	license	NN
18637	22061	30	tax	tax	NN
18637	22061	31	based	base	VBN
18637	22061	32	on	on	IN
18637	22061	33	the	the	DT
18637	22061	34	number	number	NN
18637	22061	35	of	of	IN
18637	22061	36	stores	store	NNS
18637	22061	37	both	both	CC
18637	22061	38	within	within	IN
18637	22061	39	and	and	CC
18637	22061	40	without	without	IN
18637	22061	41	the	the	DT
18637	22061	42	State	State	NNP
18637	22061	43	,	,	,
18637	22061	44	Great	Great	NNP
18637	22061	45	A.	a.	NN
18637	22062	1	&	&	CC
18637	22062	2	P.	P.	NNP
18637	22062	3	Tea	Tea	NNP
18637	22062	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22062	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22062	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22062	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22062	8	Grosjean	Grosjean	NNP
18637	22062	9	,	,	,
18637	22062	10	301	301	CD
18637	22062	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22062	12	412	412	CD
18637	22062	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22062	14	1937	1937	CD
18637	22062	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22062	16	.	.	.
18637	22063	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22063	2	Electricity	Electricity	NNP
18637	22063	3	:	:	:
18637	22063	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22063	5	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	22063	6	systems	system	NNS
18637	22063	7	may	may	MD
18637	22063	8	be	be	VB
18637	22063	9	exempted	exempt	VBN
18637	22063	10	,	,	,
18637	22063	11	Puget	Puget	NNP
18637	22063	12	Sound	Sound	NNP
18637	22063	13	Power	Power	NNP
18637	22063	14	&	&	CC
18637	22063	15	Light	Light	NNP
18637	22063	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22063	17	_	_	NNP
18637	22063	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	22063	19	_	_	NNP
18637	22063	20	Seattle	Seattle	NNP
18637	22063	21	,	,	,
18637	22063	22	291	291	CD
18637	22063	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22063	24	619	619	CD
18637	22063	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22063	26	1934	1934	CD
18637	22063	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22063	28	;	;	:
18637	22063	29	that	that	DT
18637	22063	30	portion	portion	NN
18637	22063	31	of	of	IN
18637	22063	32	electricity	electricity	NN
18637	22063	33	produced	produce	VBN
18637	22063	34	which	which	WDT
18637	22063	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	22063	36	used	use	VBN
18637	22063	37	for	for	IN
18637	22063	38	pumping	pump	VBG
18637	22063	39	water	water	NN
18637	22063	40	for	for	IN
18637	22063	41	irrigating	irrigate	VBG
18637	22063	42	lands	land	NNS
18637	22063	43	may	may	MD
18637	22063	44	be	be	VB
18637	22063	45	exempted	exempt	VBN
18637	22063	46	,	,	,
18637	22063	47	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	22063	48	Power	Power	NNP
18637	22063	49	&	&	CC
18637	22063	50	Light	Light	NNP
18637	22063	51	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22063	52	_	_	NNP
18637	22063	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	22063	54	_	_	NNP
18637	22063	55	Pfost	Pfost	NNP
18637	22063	56	,	,	,
18637	22063	57	286	286	CD
18637	22063	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22063	59	165	165	CD
18637	22063	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22063	61	1932	1932	CD
18637	22063	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22063	63	.	.	.
18637	22064	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22064	2	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	22064	3	companies	company	NNS
18637	22064	4	:	:	:
18637	22064	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22064	6	license	license	NN
18637	22064	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	22064	8	measured	measure	VBN
18637	22064	9	by	by	IN
18637	22064	10	gross	gross	JJ
18637	22064	11	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	22064	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	22064	13	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	22064	14	life	life	NN
18637	22064	15	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	22064	16	companies	company	NNS
18637	22064	17	from	from	IN
18637	22064	18	which	which	WDT
18637	22064	19	fraternal	fraternal	JJ
18637	22064	20	societies	society	NNS
18637	22064	21	having	have	VBG
18637	22064	22	lodge	lodge	NN
18637	22064	23	organizations	organization	NNS
18637	22064	24	and	and	CC
18637	22064	25	insuring	insure	VBG
18637	22064	26	lives	life	NNS
18637	22064	27	of	of	IN
18637	22064	28	members	member	NNS
18637	22064	29	only	only	RB
18637	22064	30	are	be	VBP
18637	22064	31	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	22064	32	,	,	,
18637	22064	33	and	and	CC
18637	22064	34	similar	similar	JJ
18637	22064	35	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	22064	36	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	22064	37	are	be	VBP
18637	22064	38	subject	subject	JJ
18637	22064	39	to	to	IN
18637	22064	40	a	a	DT
18637	22064	41	fixed	fixed	JJ
18637	22064	42	and	and	CC
18637	22064	43	comparatively	comparatively	RB
18637	22064	44	slight	slight	JJ
18637	22064	45	fee	fee	NN
18637	22064	46	for	for	IN
18637	22064	47	the	the	DT
18637	22064	48	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	22064	49	of	of	IN
18637	22064	50	doing	do	VBG
18637	22064	51	local	local	JJ
18637	22064	52	business	business	NN
18637	22064	53	of	of	IN
18637	22064	54	the	the	DT
18637	22064	55	same	same	JJ
18637	22064	56	kind	kind	NN
18637	22064	57	.	.	.
18637	22065	1	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	22065	2	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	22065	3	L.	L.	NNP
18637	22065	4	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	22065	5	.	.	.
18637	22066	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22066	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22066	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22066	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22066	5	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	22066	6	,	,	,
18637	22066	7	247	247	CD
18637	22066	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22066	9	132	132	CD
18637	22066	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22066	11	1918	1918	CD
18637	22066	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22066	13	.	.	.
18637	22067	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22067	2	Oleomargarine	Oleomargarine	NNP
18637	22067	3	:	:	:
18637	22067	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22067	5	classified	classify	VBD
18637	22067	6	separately	separately	RB
18637	22067	7	from	from	IN
18637	22067	8	butter	butter	NN
18637	22067	9	.	.	.
18637	22068	1	Magnano	Magnano	NNP
18637	22068	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22068	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22068	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22068	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22068	6	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	22068	7	,	,	,
18637	22068	8	292	292	CD
18637	22068	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22068	10	40	40	CD
18637	22068	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22068	12	1934	1934	CD
18637	22068	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22068	14	.	.	.
18637	22069	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22069	2	Peddlers	Peddlers	NNPS
18637	22069	3	:	:	:
18637	22069	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22069	5	classified	classify	VBD
18637	22069	6	separately	separately	RB
18637	22069	7	from	from	IN
18637	22069	8	other	other	JJ
18637	22069	9	vendors	vendor	NNS
18637	22069	10	.	.	.
18637	22070	1	Caskey	Caskey	NNP
18637	22070	2	Baking	Baking	NNP
18637	22070	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22070	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22070	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	22070	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22070	7	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	22070	8	,	,	,
18637	22070	9	313	313	CD
18637	22070	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22070	11	117	117	CD
18637	22070	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22070	13	1941	1941	CD
18637	22070	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22070	15	.	.	.
18637	22071	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22071	2	Public	public	JJ
18637	22071	3	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	22071	4	:	:	:
18637	22071	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22071	6	a	a	DT
18637	22071	7	gross	gross	JJ
18637	22071	8	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	22071	9	tax	tax	NN
18637	22071	10	at	at	IN
18637	22071	11	a	a	DT
18637	22071	12	higher	high	JJR
18637	22071	13	rate	rate	NN
18637	22071	14	for	for	IN
18637	22071	15	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	22071	16	than	than	IN
18637	22071	17	for	for	IN
18637	22071	18	other	other	JJ
18637	22071	19	public	public	JJ
18637	22071	20	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	22071	21	,	,	,
18637	22071	22	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	22071	23	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	22071	24	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	22071	25	,	,	,
18637	22071	26	232	232	CD
18637	22071	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22071	28	576	576	CD
18637	22071	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22071	30	1914	1914	CD
18637	22071	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22071	32	;	;	:
18637	22071	33	a	a	DT
18637	22071	34	gasoline	gasoline	NN
18637	22071	35	storage	storage	NN
18637	22071	36	tax	tax	NN
18637	22071	37	which	which	WDT
18637	22071	38	places	place	VBZ
18637	22071	39	a	a	DT
18637	22071	40	heavier	heavy	JJR
18637	22071	41	burden	burden	NN
18637	22071	42	upon	upon	IN
18637	22071	43	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	22071	44	than	than	IN
18637	22071	45	upon	upon	IN
18637	22071	46	common	common	JJ
18637	22071	47	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	22071	48	by	by	IN
18637	22071	49	bus	bus	NN
18637	22071	50	,	,	,
18637	22071	51	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	22071	52	C.	C.	NNP
18637	22071	53	&	&	CC
18637	22071	54	St.	St.	NNP
18637	22071	55	L.	L.	NNP
18637	22071	56	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22071	57	_	_	NNP
18637	22071	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	22071	59	_	_	NNP
18637	22071	60	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	22071	61	,	,	,
18637	22071	62	288	288	CD
18637	22071	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22071	64	249	249	CD
18637	22071	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22071	66	1933	1933	CD
18637	22071	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22071	68	;	;	:
18637	22071	69	a	a	DT
18637	22071	70	tax	tax	NN
18637	22071	71	on	on	IN
18637	22071	72	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	22071	73	measured	measure	VBN
18637	22071	74	by	by	IN
18637	22071	75	gross	gross	JJ
18637	22071	76	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	22071	77	from	from	IN
18637	22071	78	local	local	JJ
18637	22071	79	operations	operation	NNS
18637	22071	80	,	,	,
18637	22071	81	as	as	IN
18637	22071	82	applied	apply	VBN
18637	22071	83	to	to	IN
18637	22071	84	a	a	DT
18637	22071	85	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	22071	86	which	which	WDT
18637	22071	87	received	receive	VBD
18637	22071	88	a	a	DT
18637	22071	89	larger	large	JJR
18637	22071	90	net	net	JJ
18637	22071	91	income	income	NN
18637	22071	92	than	than	IN
18637	22071	93	others	other	NNS
18637	22071	94	from	from	IN
18637	22071	95	the	the	DT
18637	22071	96	local	local	JJ
18637	22071	97	activity	activity	NN
18637	22071	98	of	of	IN
18637	22071	99	renting	renting	NN
18637	22071	100	,	,	,
18637	22071	101	and	and	CC
18637	22071	102	borrowing	borrow	VBG
18637	22071	103	cars	car	NNS
18637	22071	104	,	,	,
18637	22071	105	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	22071	106	Central	Central	NNP
18637	22071	107	R.	R.	NNP
18637	22071	108	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22071	109	_	_	NNP
18637	22071	110	v.	v.	IN
18637	22071	111	_	_	NNP
18637	22071	112	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	22071	113	,	,	,
18637	22071	114	309	309	CD
18637	22071	115	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22071	116	157	157	CD
18637	22071	117	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22071	118	1940	1940	CD
18637	22071	119	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22071	120	;	;	:
18637	22071	121	a	a	DT
18637	22071	122	gross	gross	JJ
18637	22071	123	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	22071	124	tax	tax	NN
18637	22071	125	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	22071	126	only	only	RB
18637	22071	127	to	to	IN
18637	22071	128	public	public	JJ
18637	22071	129	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	22071	130	,	,	,
18637	22071	131	including	include	VBG
18637	22071	132	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	22071	133	,	,	,
18637	22071	134	the	the	DT
18637	22071	135	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	22071	136	of	of	IN
18637	22071	137	which	which	WDT
18637	22071	138	are	be	VBP
18637	22071	139	used	use	VBN
18637	22071	140	for	for	IN
18637	22071	141	relieving	relieve	VBG
18637	22071	142	the	the	DT
18637	22071	143	unemployed	unemployed	JJ
18637	22071	144	,	,	,
18637	22071	145	New	New	NNP
18637	22071	146	York	York	NNP
18637	22071	147	Rapid	Rapid	NNP
18637	22071	148	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	22071	149	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	22071	150	_	_	NNP
18637	22071	151	v.	v.	IN
18637	22071	152	_	_	NNP
18637	22071	153	New	New	NNP
18637	22071	154	York	York	NNP
18637	22071	155	,	,	,
18637	22071	156	303	303	CD
18637	22071	157	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22071	158	573	573	CD
18637	22071	159	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22071	160	1938	1938	CD
18637	22071	161	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22071	162	.	.	.
18637	22072	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22072	2	Wine	Wine	NNP
18637	22072	3	:	:	:
18637	22072	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22072	5	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	22072	6	of	of	IN
18637	22072	7	wine	wine	NN
18637	22072	8	from	from	IN
18637	22072	9	grapes	grape	NNS
18637	22072	10	grown	grow	VBN
18637	22072	11	in	in	IN
18637	22072	12	the	the	DT
18637	22072	13	State	State	NNP
18637	22072	14	while	while	IN
18637	22072	15	in	in	IN
18637	22072	16	the	the	DT
18637	22072	17	hands	hand	NNS
18637	22072	18	of	of	IN
18637	22072	19	the	the	DT
18637	22072	20	producer	producer	NN
18637	22072	21	.	.	.
18637	22073	1	Cox	Cox	NNP
18637	22073	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22073	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22073	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22073	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	22073	6	,	,	,
18637	22073	7	202	202	CD
18637	22073	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22073	9	446	446	CD
18637	22073	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22073	11	1906	1906	CD
18637	22073	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22073	13	.	.	.
18637	22074	1	Laws	law	NNS
18637	22074	2	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	22074	3	miscellaneous	miscellaneous	JJ
18637	22074	4	license	license	NN
18637	22074	5	fees	fee	NNS
18637	22074	6	have	have	VBP
18637	22074	7	been	be	VBN
18637	22074	8	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	22074	9	as	as	IN
18637	22074	10	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	22074	11	:	:	:
18637	22074	12	_	_	NNP
18637	22074	13	Cigarette	Cigarette	NNP
18637	22074	14	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	22074	15	:	:	:
18637	22074	16	_	_	XX
18637	22074	17	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	22074	18	retailers	retailer	NNS
18637	22074	19	and	and	CC
18637	22074	20	not	not	RB
18637	22074	21	wholesalers	wholesaler	NNS
18637	22074	22	.	.	.
18637	22075	1	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	22075	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22075	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22075	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22075	5	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	22075	6	County	County	NNP
18637	22075	7	,	,	,
18637	22075	8	196	196	CD
18637	22075	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22075	10	261	261	CD
18637	22075	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22075	12	1905	1905	CD
18637	22075	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22075	14	.	.	.
18637	22076	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22076	2	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	22076	3	merchants	merchant	NNS
18637	22076	4	:	:	:
18637	22076	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22076	6	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	22076	7	that	that	IN
18637	22076	8	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	22076	9	in	in	IN
18637	22076	10	farm	farm	NN
18637	22076	11	products	product	NNS
18637	22076	12	on	on	IN
18637	22076	13	commission	commission	NN
18637	22076	14	procure	procure	VBP
18637	22076	15	a	a	DT
18637	22076	16	license	license	NN
18637	22076	17	,	,	,
18637	22076	18	Payne	Payne	NNP
18637	22076	19	_	_	NNP
18637	22076	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	22076	21	_	_	NNP
18637	22076	22	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	22076	23	,	,	,
18637	22076	24	248	248	CD
18637	22076	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22076	26	112	112	CD
18637	22076	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22076	28	1918	1918	CD
18637	22076	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22076	30	.	.	.
18637	22077	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22077	2	Elevators	Elevators	NNPS
18637	22077	3	and	and	CC
18637	22077	4	warehouses	warehouse	NNS
18637	22077	5	:	:	:
18637	22077	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22077	7	license	license	NN
18637	22077	8	limited	limit	VBN
18637	22077	9	to	to	IN
18637	22077	10	certain	certain	JJ
18637	22077	11	elevators	elevator	NNS
18637	22077	12	and	and	CC
18637	22077	13	warehouses	warehouse	NNS
18637	22077	14	on	on	IN
18637	22077	15	right	right	JJ
18637	22077	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	22077	17	of	of	IN
18637	22077	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	22077	19	way	way	NN
18637	22077	20	of	of	IN
18637	22077	21	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	22077	22	,	,	,
18637	22077	23	Cargill	Cargill	NNP
18637	22077	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22077	25	_	_	NNP
18637	22077	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	22077	27	_	_	NNP
18637	22077	28	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	22077	29	,	,	,
18637	22077	30	180	180	CD
18637	22077	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22077	32	452	452	CD
18637	22077	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22077	34	1901	1901	CD
18637	22077	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22077	36	;	;	:
18637	22077	37	a	a	DT
18637	22077	38	license	license	NN
18637	22077	39	tax	tax	NN
18637	22077	40	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	22077	41	only	only	RB
18637	22077	42	to	to	IN
18637	22077	43	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	22077	44	warehouses	warehouse	NNS
18637	22077	45	where	where	WRB
18637	22077	46	no	no	DT
18637	22077	47	other	other	JJ
18637	22077	48	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	22077	49	warehousing	warehouse	VBG
18637	22077	50	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	22077	51	in	in	IN
18637	22077	52	township	township	NN
18637	22077	53	subject	subject	NN
18637	22077	54	to	to	IN
18637	22077	55	tax	tax	NN
18637	22077	56	,	,	,
18637	22077	57	Independent	Independent	NNP
18637	22077	58	Warehouse	Warehouse	NNP
18637	22077	59	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	22077	60	_	_	NNP
18637	22077	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	22077	62	_	_	NNP
18637	22077	63	Scheele	Scheele	NNP
18637	22077	64	,	,	,
18637	22077	65	331	331	CD
18637	22077	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22077	67	70	70	CD
18637	22077	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22077	69	1947	1947	CD
18637	22077	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22077	71	.	.	.
18637	22078	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22078	2	Laundries	laundry	NNS
18637	22078	3	:	:	:
18637	22078	4	_	_	IN
18637	22078	5	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	22078	6	from	from	IN
18637	22078	7	license	license	NN
18637	22078	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	22078	9	of	of	IN
18637	22078	10	steam	steam	NN
18637	22078	11	laundries	laundry	NNS
18637	22078	12	and	and	CC
18637	22078	13	women	woman	NNS
18637	22078	14	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	22078	15	in	in	IN
18637	22078	16	the	the	DT
18637	22078	17	laundry	laundry	JJ
18637	22078	18	business	business	NN
18637	22078	19	where	where	WRB
18637	22078	20	not	not	RB
18637	22078	21	more	more	JJR
18637	22078	22	than	than	IN
18637	22078	23	two	two	CD
18637	22078	24	women	woman	NNS
18637	22078	25	are	be	VBP
18637	22078	26	employed	employ	VBN
18637	22078	27	.	.	.
18637	22079	1	Quong	quong	JJ
18637	22079	2	Wing	Wing	NNP
18637	22079	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22079	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22079	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22079	6	Kirkendall	Kirkendall	NNP
18637	22079	7	,	,	,
18637	22079	8	223	223	CD
18637	22079	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22079	10	59	59	CD
18637	22079	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22079	12	1912	1912	CD
18637	22079	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22079	14	.	.	.
18637	22080	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22080	2	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	22080	3	:	:	:
18637	22080	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22080	5	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	22080	6	from	from	IN
18637	22080	7	license	license	NN
18637	22080	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	22080	9	measured	measure	VBN
18637	22080	10	by	by	IN
18637	22080	11	amount	amount	NN
18637	22080	12	of	of	IN
18637	22080	13	purchases	purchase	NNS
18637	22080	14	,	,	,
18637	22080	15	of	of	IN
18637	22080	16	manufacturers	manufacturer	NNS
18637	22080	17	within	within	IN
18637	22080	18	the	the	DT
18637	22080	19	State	State	NNP
18637	22080	20	selling	sell	VBG
18637	22080	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22080	22	own	own	JJ
18637	22080	23	product	product	NN
18637	22080	24	.	.	.
18637	22081	1	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	22081	2	&	&	CC
18637	22081	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22081	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22081	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	22081	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22081	7	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	22081	8	,	,	,
18637	22081	9	246	246	CD
18637	22081	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22081	11	1	1	CD
18637	22081	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22081	13	1918	1918	CD
18637	22081	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22081	15	.	.	.
18637	22082	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22082	2	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	22082	3	refineries	refinery	NNS
18637	22082	4	:	:	:
18637	22082	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22082	6	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	22082	7	from	from	IN
18637	22082	8	license	license	NN
18637	22082	9	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	22082	10	to	to	IN
18637	22082	11	refiners	refiner	NNS
18637	22082	12	of	of	IN
18637	22082	13	sugar	sugar	NN
18637	22082	14	and	and	CC
18637	22082	15	molasses	molasse	NNS
18637	22082	16	of	of	IN
18637	22082	17	planters	planter	NNS
18637	22082	18	and	and	CC
18637	22082	19	farmers	farmer	NNS
18637	22082	20	grinding	grind	VBG
18637	22082	21	and	and	CC
18637	22082	22	refining	refine	VBG
18637	22082	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22082	24	own	own	JJ
18637	22082	25	sugar	sugar	NN
18637	22082	26	and	and	CC
18637	22082	27	molasses	molasse	NNS
18637	22082	28	.	.	.
18637	22083	1	American	American	NNP
18637	22083	2	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	22083	3	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	22083	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22083	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22083	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22083	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22083	8	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	22083	9	,	,	,
18637	22083	10	179	179	CD
18637	22083	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22083	12	89	89	CD
18637	22083	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22083	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	22083	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22083	16	.	.	.
18637	22084	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22084	2	Theaters	Theaters	NNPS
18637	22084	3	:	:	:
18637	22084	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22084	5	license	license	NN
18637	22084	6	graded	grade	VBD
18637	22084	7	according	accord	VBG
18637	22084	8	to	to	IN
18637	22084	9	price	price	NN
18637	22084	10	of	of	IN
18637	22084	11	admission	admission	NN
18637	22084	12	.	.	.
18637	22085	1	Metropolis	Metropolis	NNP
18637	22085	2	Theatre	Theatre	NNP
18637	22085	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22085	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22085	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	22085	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22085	7	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	22085	8	,	,	,
18637	22085	9	228	228	CD
18637	22085	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22085	11	61	61	CD
18637	22085	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22085	13	1913	1913	CD
18637	22085	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22085	15	.	.	.
18637	22086	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22086	2	Wholesalers	Wholesalers	NNPS
18637	22086	3	of	of	IN
18637	22086	4	oil	oil	NN
18637	22086	5	:	:	:
18637	22086	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22086	7	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	22086	8	tax	tax	NN
18637	22086	9	on	on	IN
18637	22086	10	wholesalers	wholesaler	NNS
18637	22086	11	in	in	IN
18637	22086	12	oil	oil	NN
18637	22086	13	not	not	RB
18637	22086	14	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	22086	15	to	to	IN
18637	22086	16	wholesalers	wholesaler	NNS
18637	22086	17	in	in	IN
18637	22086	18	other	other	JJ
18637	22086	19	products	product	NNS
18637	22086	20	.	.	.
18637	22087	1	Southwestern	Southwestern	NNP
18637	22087	2	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	22087	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22087	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22087	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	22087	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22087	7	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	22087	8	,	,	,
18637	22087	9	217	217	CD
18637	22087	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22087	11	114	114	CD
18637	22087	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22087	13	1910	1910	CD
18637	22087	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22087	15	.	.	.
18637	22088	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22088	2	1049	1049	CD
18637	22088	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22088	4	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	22088	5	's	's	POS
18637	22088	6	Gap	Gap	NNP
18637	22088	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	22088	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22088	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22088	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	22088	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22088	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	22088	13	,	,	,
18637	22088	14	134	134	CD
18637	22088	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22088	16	232	232	CD
18637	22088	17	,	,	,
18637	22088	18	237	237	CD
18637	22088	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22088	20	1890	1890	CD
18637	22088	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22088	22	.	.	.
18637	22089	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22089	2	1050	1050	CD
18637	22089	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22089	4	Quong	Quong	NNP
18637	22089	5	Wing	Wing	NNP
18637	22089	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22089	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22089	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22089	9	Kirkendall	Kirkendall	NNP
18637	22089	10	,	,	,
18637	22089	11	223	223	CD
18637	22089	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22089	13	59	59	CD
18637	22089	14	,	,	,
18637	22089	15	62	62	CD
18637	22089	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22089	17	1912	1912	CD
18637	22089	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22089	19	.	.	.
18637	22090	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22090	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22090	3	also	also	RB
18637	22090	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22090	5	Hammond	Hammond	NNP
18637	22090	6	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	22090	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22090	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22090	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22090	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22090	11	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	22090	12	,	,	,
18637	22090	13	233	233	CD
18637	22090	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22090	15	331	331	CD
18637	22090	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22090	17	1914	1914	CD
18637	22090	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22090	19	.	.	.
18637	22091	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22091	2	1051	1051	CD
18637	22091	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22091	4	Puget	Puget	NNP
18637	22091	5	Sound	Sound	NNP
18637	22091	6	Power	Power	NNP
18637	22091	7	&	&	CC
18637	22091	8	Light	Light	NNP
18637	22091	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22091	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22091	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	22091	12	_	_	NNP
18637	22091	13	Seattle	Seattle	NNP
18637	22091	14	,	,	,
18637	22091	15	291	291	CD
18637	22091	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22091	17	619	619	CD
18637	22091	18	,	,	,
18637	22091	19	625	625	CD
18637	22091	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22091	21	1934	1934	CD
18637	22091	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22091	23	.	.	.
18637	22092	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22092	2	1052	1052	CD
18637	22092	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22092	4	Colgate	Colgate	NNP
18637	22092	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22092	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22092	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22092	8	Harvey	Harvey	NNP
18637	22092	9	,	,	,
18637	22092	10	296	296	CD
18637	22092	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22092	12	404	404	CD
18637	22092	13	,	,	,
18637	22092	14	422	422	CD
18637	22092	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22092	16	1935	1935	CD
18637	22092	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22092	18	.	.	.
18637	22093	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22093	2	1053	1053	CD
18637	22093	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22093	4	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	22093	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	22093	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22093	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22093	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22093	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22093	10	Greene	Greene	NNP
18637	22093	11	,	,	,
18637	22093	12	216	216	CD
18637	22093	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22093	14	400	400	CD
18637	22093	15	,	,	,
18637	22093	16	417	417	CD
18637	22093	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22093	18	1910	1910	CD
18637	22093	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22093	20	;	;	:
18637	22093	21	Quaker	Quaker	NNP
18637	22093	22	City	City	NNP
18637	22093	23	Cab	Cab	NNP
18637	22093	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22093	25	_	_	NNP
18637	22093	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	22093	27	_	_	NNP
18637	22093	28	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	22093	29	,	,	,
18637	22093	30	277	277	CD
18637	22093	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22093	32	389	389	CD
18637	22093	33	,	,	,
18637	22093	34	400	400	CD
18637	22093	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22093	36	1928	1928	CD
18637	22093	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22093	38	.	.	.
18637	22094	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22094	2	1054	1054	CD
18637	22094	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22094	4	Keeney	Keeney	NNP
18637	22094	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22094	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22094	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22094	8	New	New	NNP
18637	22094	9	York	York	NNP
18637	22094	10	,	,	,
18637	22094	11	222	222	CD
18637	22094	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22094	13	525	525	CD
18637	22094	14	,	,	,
18637	22094	15	536	536	CD
18637	22094	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22094	17	1912	1912	CD
18637	22094	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22094	19	;	;	:
18637	22094	20	State	State	NNP
18637	22094	21	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	22094	22	Comrs	Comrs	NNP
18637	22094	23	.	.	.
18637	22095	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22095	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	22095	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22095	4	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	22095	5	,	,	,
18637	22095	6	283	283	CD
18637	22095	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22095	8	527	527	CD
18637	22095	9	,	,	,
18637	22095	10	538	538	CD
18637	22095	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22095	12	1931	1931	CD
18637	22095	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22095	14	.	.	.
18637	22096	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22096	2	1055	1055	CD
18637	22096	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22096	4	Giozza	Giozza	NNP
18637	22096	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22096	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22096	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22096	8	Tiernan	Tiernan	NNP
18637	22096	9	,	,	,
18637	22096	10	148	148	CD
18637	22096	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22096	12	657	657	CD
18637	22096	13	,	,	,
18637	22096	14	662	662	CD
18637	22096	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22096	16	1893	1893	CD
18637	22096	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22096	18	.	.	.
18637	22097	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22097	2	1056	1056	CD
18637	22097	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22097	4	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	22097	5	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	22097	6	&	&	CC
18637	22097	7	E.	E.	NNP
18637	22097	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22097	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22097	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	22097	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22097	12	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	22097	13	,	,	,
18637	22097	14	277	277	CD
18637	22097	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22097	16	32	32	CD
18637	22097	17	,	,	,
18637	22097	18	37	37	CD
18637	22097	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22097	20	1928	1928	CD
18637	22097	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22097	22	.	.	.
18637	22098	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22098	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22098	3	also	also	RB
18637	22098	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22098	5	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	22098	6	's	's	POS
18637	22098	7	Gap	Gap	NNP
18637	22098	8	R.	R.	NNP
18637	22098	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22098	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22098	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	22098	12	_	_	NNP
18637	22098	13	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	22098	14	,	,	,
18637	22098	15	134	134	CD
18637	22098	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22098	17	232	232	CD
18637	22098	18	,	,	,
18637	22098	19	237	237	CD
18637	22098	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22098	21	1890	1890	CD
18637	22098	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22098	23	.	.	.
18637	22099	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22099	2	1057	1057	CD
18637	22099	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22099	4	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	22099	5	Dry	Dry	NNP
18637	22099	6	Goods	Goods	NNP
18637	22099	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22099	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22099	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22099	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22099	11	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	22099	12	,	,	,
18637	22099	13	294	294	CD
18637	22099	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22099	15	550	550	CD
18637	22099	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22099	17	1935	1935	CD
18637	22099	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22099	19	.	.	.
18637	22100	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22100	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22100	3	also	also	RB
18637	22100	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22100	5	Valentine	Valentine	NNP
18637	22100	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22100	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22100	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22100	9	Great	Great	NNP
18637	22100	10	A.	A.	NNP
18637	22101	1	&	&	CC
18637	22101	2	P.	P.	NNP
18637	22101	3	Tea	Tea	NNP
18637	22101	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22101	5	,	,	,
18637	22101	6	299	299	CD
18637	22101	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22101	8	32	32	CD
18637	22101	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22101	10	1936	1936	CD
18637	22101	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22101	12	.	.	.
18637	22102	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22102	2	1058	1058	CD
18637	22102	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22102	4	Liggett	Liggett	NNP
18637	22102	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22102	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22102	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22102	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22102	9	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	22102	10	,	,	,
18637	22102	11	288	288	CD
18637	22102	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22102	13	517	517	CD
18637	22102	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22102	15	1933	1933	CD
18637	22102	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22102	17	.	.	.
18637	22103	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22103	2	1059	1059	CD
18637	22103	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22103	4	Quaker	Quaker	NNP
18637	22103	5	City	City	NNP
18637	22103	6	Cab	Cab	NNP
18637	22103	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22103	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22103	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22103	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22103	11	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	22103	12	,	,	,
18637	22103	13	277	277	CD
18637	22103	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22103	15	389	389	CD
18637	22103	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22103	17	1928	1928	CD
18637	22103	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22103	19	.	.	.
18637	22104	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22104	2	1060	1060	CD
18637	22104	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22104	4	State	State	NNP
18637	22104	5	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	22104	6	Comrs	Comrs	NNP
18637	22104	7	.	.	.
18637	22105	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22105	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	22105	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22105	4	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	22105	5	,	,	,
18637	22105	6	283	283	CD
18637	22105	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22105	8	527	527	CD
18637	22105	9	,	,	,
18637	22105	10	537	537	CD
18637	22105	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22105	12	1931	1931	CD
18637	22105	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22105	14	.	.	.
18637	22106	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22106	2	1061	1061	CD
18637	22106	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22106	4	Colgate	Colgate	NNP
18637	22106	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22106	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22106	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22106	8	Harvey	Harvey	NNP
18637	22106	9	,	,	,
18637	22106	10	296	296	CD
18637	22106	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22106	12	404	404	CD
18637	22106	13	,	,	,
18637	22106	14	422	422	CD
18637	22106	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22106	16	1935	1935	CD
18637	22106	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22106	18	.	.	.
18637	22107	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22107	2	1062	1062	CD
18637	22107	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22107	4	Darnell	Darnell	NNP
18637	22107	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22107	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22107	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22107	8	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	22107	9	,	,	,
18637	22107	10	226	226	CD
18637	22107	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22107	12	390	390	CD
18637	22107	13	,	,	,
18637	22107	14	398	398	CD
18637	22107	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22107	16	1912	1912	CD
18637	22107	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22107	18	;	;	:
18637	22107	19	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	22107	20	&	&	CC
18637	22107	21	M.	M.	NNP
18637	22107	22	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	22107	23	.	.	.
18637	22108	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	22108	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22108	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22108	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22108	5	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	22108	6	,	,	,
18637	22108	7	232	232	CD
18637	22108	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22108	9	516	516	CD
18637	22108	10	,	,	,
18637	22108	11	531	531	CD
18637	22108	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22108	13	1914	1914	CD
18637	22108	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22108	15	.	.	.
18637	22109	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22109	2	1063	1063	CD
18637	22109	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22109	4	Morf	Morf	NNP
18637	22109	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22109	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22109	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22109	8	Bingaman	Bingaman	NNP
18637	22109	9	,	,	,
18637	22109	10	298	298	CD
18637	22109	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22109	12	407	407	CD
18637	22109	13	,	,	,
18637	22109	14	413	413	CD
18637	22109	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22109	16	1936	1936	CD
18637	22109	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22109	18	.	.	.
18637	22110	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22110	2	1064	1064	CD
18637	22110	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22110	4	Baltic	Baltic	NNP
18637	22110	5	Min	Min	NNP
18637	22110	6	.	.	.
18637	22111	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22111	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22111	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22111	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22111	5	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	22111	6	,	,	,
18637	22111	7	231	231	CD
18637	22111	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22111	9	68	68	CD
18637	22111	10	,	,	,
18637	22111	11	88	88	CD
18637	22111	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22111	13	1913	1913	CD
18637	22111	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22111	15	.	.	.
18637	22112	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22112	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22112	3	also	also	RB
18637	22112	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22112	5	Cheney	Cheney	NNP
18637	22112	6	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	22112	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22112	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22112	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22112	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22112	11	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	22112	12	,	,	,
18637	22112	13	246	246	CD
18637	22112	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22112	15	147	147	CD
18637	22112	16	,	,	,
18637	22112	17	157	157	CD
18637	22112	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22112	19	1918	1918	CD
18637	22112	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22112	21	.	.	.
18637	22113	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22113	2	1065	1065	CD
18637	22113	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22113	4	Fire	Fire	NNP
18637	22113	5	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	22113	6	.	.	.
18637	22114	1	of	of	IN
18637	22114	2	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	22114	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22114	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22114	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22114	6	New	New	NNP
18637	22114	7	York	York	NNP
18637	22114	8	,	,	,
18637	22114	9	119	119	CD
18637	22114	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22114	11	110	110	CD
18637	22114	12	,	,	,
18637	22114	13	119	119	CD
18637	22114	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22114	15	1886	1886	CD
18637	22114	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22114	17	.	.	.
18637	22115	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22115	2	1066	1066	CD
18637	22115	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22115	4	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
18637	22115	5	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22115	6	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	22115	7	.	.	.
18637	22116	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22116	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22116	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22116	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22116	5	Harding	Harding	NNP
18637	22116	6	,	,	,
18637	22116	7	272	272	CD
18637	22116	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22116	9	494	494	CD
18637	22116	10	,	,	,
18637	22116	11	511	511	CD
18637	22116	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22116	13	1926	1926	CD
18637	22116	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22116	15	.	.	.
18637	22117	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22117	2	1067	1067	CD
18637	22117	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22117	4	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	22117	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	22117	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22117	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22117	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22117	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22117	10	Greene	Greene	NNP
18637	22117	11	,	,	,
18637	22117	12	216	216	CD
18637	22117	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22117	14	400	400	CD
18637	22117	15	,	,	,
18637	22117	16	418	418	CD
18637	22117	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22117	18	1910	1910	CD
18637	22117	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22117	20	.	.	.
18637	22118	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22118	2	1068	1068	CD
18637	22118	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22118	4	Concordia	Concordia	NNP
18637	22118	5	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22118	6	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	22118	7	.	.	.
18637	22119	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22119	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22119	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22119	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22119	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	22119	6	,	,	,
18637	22119	7	292	292	CD
18637	22119	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22119	9	535	535	CD
18637	22119	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22119	11	1934	1934	CD
18637	22119	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22119	13	.	.	.
18637	22120	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22120	2	1069	1069	CD
18637	22120	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22120	4	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	22120	5	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	22120	6	.	.	.
18637	22121	1	Life	Life	NNP
18637	22121	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	22121	3	.	.	.
18637	22122	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22122	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22122	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22122	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22122	5	Read	Read	NNP
18637	22122	6	,	,	,
18637	22122	7	325	325	CD
18637	22122	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22122	9	673	673	CD
18637	22122	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22122	11	1945	1945	CD
18637	22122	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22122	13	.	.	.
18637	22123	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22123	2	1070	1070	CD
18637	22123	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22123	4	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	22123	5	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	22123	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	22123	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22123	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22123	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22123	10	Glander	Glander	NNP
18637	22123	11	,	,	,
18637	22123	12	337	337	CD
18637	22123	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22123	14	562	562	CD
18637	22123	15	,	,	,
18637	22123	16	571	571	CD
18637	22123	17	,	,	,
18637	22123	18	572	572	CD
18637	22123	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22123	20	1949	1949	CD
18637	22123	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22123	22	.	.	.
18637	22124	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22124	2	1071	1071	CD
18637	22124	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22124	4	Royster	Royster	NNP
18637	22124	5	Guano	Guano	NNP
18637	22124	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22124	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22124	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22124	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22124	10	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	22124	11	,	,	,
18637	22124	12	253	253	CD
18637	22124	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22124	14	412	412	CD
18637	22124	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22124	16	1920	1920	CD
18637	22124	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22124	18	.	.	.
18637	22125	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22125	2	1072	1072	CD
18637	22125	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22125	4	Shaffer	Shaffer	NNP
18637	22125	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22125	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22125	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22125	8	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	22125	9	,	,	,
18637	22125	10	252	252	CD
18637	22125	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22125	12	37	37	CD
18637	22125	13	,	,	,
18637	22125	14	56	56	CD
18637	22125	15	,	,	,
18637	22125	16	57	57	CD
18637	22125	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22125	18	1920	1920	CD
18637	22125	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22125	20	;	;	:
18637	22125	21	Travis	Travis	NNP
18637	22125	22	_	_	NNP
18637	22125	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	22125	24	_	_	NNP
18637	22125	25	Yale	Yale	NNP
18637	22125	26	&	&	CC
18637	22125	27	T.	T.	NNP
18637	22125	28	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	22125	29	.	.	.
18637	22126	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22126	2	,	,	,
18637	22126	3	252	252	CD
18637	22126	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22126	5	60	60	CD
18637	22126	6	,	,	,
18637	22126	7	75	75	CD
18637	22126	8	,	,	,
18637	22126	9	76	76	CD
18637	22126	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22126	11	1920	1920	CD
18637	22126	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22126	13	.	.	.
18637	22127	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22127	2	1073	1073	CD
18637	22127	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22127	4	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	22127	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22127	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22127	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22127	8	Henry	Henry	NNP
18637	22127	9	,	,	,
18637	22127	10	305	305	CD
18637	22127	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22127	12	134	134	CD
18637	22127	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22127	14	1938	1938	CD
18637	22127	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22127	16	.	.	.
18637	22128	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22128	2	1074	1074	CD
18637	22128	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22128	4	Magoun	Magoun	NNP
18637	22128	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22128	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22128	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22128	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	22128	9	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	22128	10	&	&	CC
18637	22128	11	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	22128	12	.	.	.
18637	22129	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	22129	2	,	,	,
18637	22129	3	170	170	CD
18637	22129	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22129	5	283	283	CD
18637	22129	6	,	,	,
18637	22129	7	288	288	CD
18637	22129	8	,	,	,
18637	22129	9	300	300	CD
18637	22129	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22129	11	1898	1898	CD
18637	22129	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22129	13	.	.	.
18637	22130	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22130	2	1075	1075	CD
18637	22130	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22130	4	Billings	Billings	NNP
18637	22130	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22130	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22130	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22130	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	22130	9	,	,	,
18637	22130	10	188	188	CD
18637	22130	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22130	12	97	97	CD
18637	22130	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22130	14	1903	1903	CD
18637	22130	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22130	16	.	.	.
18637	22131	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22131	2	1076	1076	CD
18637	22131	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22131	4	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
18637	22131	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22131	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22131	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22131	8	California	California	NNP
18637	22131	9	,	,	,
18637	22131	10	200	200	CD
18637	22131	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22131	12	87	87	CD
18637	22131	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22131	14	1906	1906	CD
18637	22131	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22131	16	.	.	.
18637	22132	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22132	2	1077	1077	CD
18637	22132	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22132	4	Salomon	Salomon	NNP
18637	22132	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22132	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22132	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22132	8	State	State	NNP
18637	22132	9	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	22132	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	22132	11	,	,	,
18637	22132	12	278	278	CD
18637	22132	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22132	14	484	484	CD
18637	22132	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22132	16	1929	1929	CD
18637	22132	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22132	18	.	.	.
18637	22133	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22133	2	1078	1078	CD
18637	22133	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22133	4	Board	Board	NNP
18637	22133	5	of	of	IN
18637	22133	6	Education	Education	NNP
18637	22133	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22133	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22133	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22133	10	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	22133	11	,	,	,
18637	22133	12	203	203	CD
18637	22133	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22133	14	553	553	CD
18637	22133	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22133	16	1906	1906	CD
18637	22133	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22133	18	.	.	.
18637	22134	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22134	2	1079	1079	CD
18637	22134	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22134	4	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	22134	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22134	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22134	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22134	8	Bugbee	Bugbee	NNP
18637	22134	9	,	,	,
18637	22134	10	250	250	CD
18637	22134	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22134	12	525	525	CD
18637	22134	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22134	14	1919	1919	CD
18637	22134	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22134	16	.	.	.
18637	22135	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22135	2	1080	1080	CD
18637	22135	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22135	4	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	22135	5	Baking	Baking	NNP
18637	22135	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22135	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22135	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22135	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22135	10	Woodring	Woodring	NNP
18637	22135	11	,	,	,
18637	22135	12	286	286	CD
18637	22135	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22135	14	352	352	CD
18637	22135	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22135	16	1932	1932	CD
18637	22135	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22135	18	.	.	.
18637	22136	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22136	2	1081	1081	CD
18637	22136	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22136	4	Dixie	Dixie	NNP
18637	22136	5	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	22136	6	Express	Express	NNP
18637	22136	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22136	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22136	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22136	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22136	11	State	State	NNP
18637	22136	12	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	22136	13	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	22136	14	,	,	,
18637	22136	15	306	306	CD
18637	22136	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22136	17	72	72	CD
18637	22136	18	,	,	,
18637	22136	19	78	78	CD
18637	22136	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22136	21	1939	1939	CD
18637	22136	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22136	23	.	.	.
18637	22137	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22137	2	1082	1082	CD
18637	22137	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22137	4	Alward	Alward	NNP
18637	22137	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22137	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22137	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22137	8	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	22137	9	,	,	,
18637	22137	10	282	282	CD
18637	22137	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22137	12	509	509	CD
18637	22137	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22137	14	1931	1931	CD
18637	22137	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22137	16	.	.	.
18637	22138	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22138	2	1083	1083	CD
18637	22138	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22138	4	Bekins	Bekins	NNP
18637	22138	5	Van	Van	NNP
18637	22138	6	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	22138	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22138	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22138	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22138	10	Riley	Riley	NNP
18637	22138	11	,	,	,
18637	22138	12	280	280	CD
18637	22138	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22138	14	80	80	CD
18637	22138	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22138	16	1929	1929	CD
18637	22138	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22138	18	.	.	.
18637	22139	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22139	2	1084	1084	CD
18637	22139	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22139	4	Morf	Morf	NNP
18637	22139	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22139	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22139	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22139	8	Bingaman	Bingaman	NNP
18637	22139	9	,	,	,
18637	22139	10	298	298	CD
18637	22139	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22139	12	407	407	CD
18637	22139	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22139	14	1936	1936	CD
18637	22139	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22139	16	.	.	.
18637	22140	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22140	2	1085	1085	CD
18637	22140	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22140	4	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	22140	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22140	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22140	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22140	8	Paul	Paul	NNP
18637	22140	9	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	22140	10	,	,	,
18637	22140	11	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	22140	12	,	,	,
18637	22140	13	306	306	CD
18637	22140	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22140	15	583	583	CD
18637	22140	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22140	17	1939	1939	CD
18637	22140	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22140	19	.	.	.
18637	22141	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22141	2	1086	1086	CD
18637	22141	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22141	4	Carley	Carley	NNP
18637	22141	5	&	&	CC
18637	22141	6	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	22141	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22141	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22141	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22141	10	Snook	Snook	NNP
18637	22141	11	,	,	,
18637	22141	12	281	281	CD
18637	22141	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22141	14	66	66	CD
18637	22141	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22141	16	1930	1930	CD
18637	22141	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22141	18	.	.	.
18637	22142	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22142	2	1087	1087	CD
18637	22142	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22142	4	Aero	Aero	NNP
18637	22142	5	Mayflower	Mayflower	NNP
18637	22142	6	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	22142	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22142	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22142	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22142	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22142	11	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	22142	12	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	22142	13	.	.	.
18637	22143	1	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	22143	2	.	.	.
18637	22144	1	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	22144	2	,	,	,
18637	22144	3	295	295	CD
18637	22144	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22144	5	285	285	CD
18637	22144	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22144	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	22144	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22144	9	.	.	.
18637	22145	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22145	2	1088	1088	CD
18637	22145	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22145	4	Breedlove	Breedlove	NNP
18637	22145	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22145	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22145	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22145	8	Suttles	Suttles	NNP
18637	22145	9	,	,	,
18637	22145	10	302	302	CD
18637	22145	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22145	12	277	277	CD
18637	22145	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22145	14	1937	1937	CD
18637	22145	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22145	16	.	.	.
18637	22146	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22146	2	1089	1089	CD
18637	22146	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22146	4	Royster	Royster	NNP
18637	22146	5	Guano	Guano	NNP
18637	22146	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22146	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22146	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22146	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22146	10	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	22146	11	,	,	,
18637	22146	12	253	253	CD
18637	22146	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22146	14	412	412	CD
18637	22146	15	,	,	,
18637	22146	16	415	415	CD
18637	22146	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22146	18	1920	1920	CD
18637	22146	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22146	20	.	.	.
18637	22147	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22147	2	1090	1090	CD
18637	22147	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22147	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22147	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22147	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22147	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22147	8	Dockery	Dockery	NNP
18637	22147	9	,	,	,
18637	22147	10	191	191	CD
18637	22147	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22147	12	165	165	CD
18637	22147	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22147	14	1903	1903	CD
18637	22147	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22147	16	.	.	.
18637	22148	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22148	2	1091	1091	CD
18637	22148	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22148	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	22148	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	22148	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22148	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22148	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22148	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22148	10	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	22148	11	,	,	,
18637	22148	12	219	219	CD
18637	22148	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22148	14	140	140	CD
18637	22148	15	,	,	,
18637	22148	16	161	161	CD
18637	22148	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22148	18	1911	1911	CD
18637	22148	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22148	20	.	.	.
18637	22149	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22149	2	1092	1092	CD
18637	22149	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22149	4	Sunday	Sunday	NNP
18637	22149	5	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	22149	6	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	22149	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22149	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22149	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22149	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22149	11	Wakefield	Wakefield	NNP
18637	22149	12	Twp	Twp	NNP
18637	22149	13	.	.	NNP
18637	22149	14	,	,	,
18637	22149	15	247	247	CD
18637	22149	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22149	17	350	350	CD
18637	22149	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22149	19	1918	1918	CD
18637	22149	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22149	21	;	;	:
18637	22149	22	Raymond	Raymond	NNP
18637	22149	23	_	_	NNP
18637	22149	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	22149	25	_	_	NNP
18637	22149	26	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	22149	27	Union	Union	NNP
18637	22149	28	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	22149	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22149	30	,	,	,
18637	22149	31	207	207	CD
18637	22149	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22149	33	20	20	CD
18637	22149	34	,	,	,
18637	22149	35	35	35	CD
18637	22149	36	,	,	,
18637	22149	37	37	37	CD
18637	22149	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22149	39	1907	1907	CD
18637	22149	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22149	41	.	.	.
18637	22150	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22150	2	1093	1093	CD
18637	22150	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22150	4	Coulter	Coulter	NNP
18637	22150	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22150	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22150	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22150	8	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	22150	9	&	&	CC
18637	22150	10	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	22151	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22151	2	,	,	,
18637	22151	3	196	196	CD
18637	22151	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22151	5	599	599	CD
18637	22151	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22151	7	1905	1905	CD
18637	22151	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22151	9	.	.	.
18637	22152	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22152	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22152	3	also	also	RB
18637	22152	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22152	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	22152	6	,	,	,
18637	22152	7	B.	B.	NNP
18637	22153	1	&	&	CC
18637	22153	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	22154	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22154	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22154	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22154	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22154	5	Babcock	Babcock	NNP
18637	22154	6	,	,	,
18637	22154	7	204	204	CD
18637	22154	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22154	9	585	585	CD
18637	22154	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22154	11	1907	1907	CD
18637	22154	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22154	13	.	.	.
18637	22155	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22155	2	1094	1094	CD
18637	22155	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22155	4	Charleston	Charleston	NNP
18637	22155	5	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	22155	6	.	.	.
18637	22156	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22156	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	22156	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22156	4	Alderson	Alderson	NNP
18637	22156	5	,	,	,
18637	22156	6	324	324	CD
18637	22156	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22156	8	182	182	CD
18637	22156	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22156	10	1945	1945	CD
18637	22156	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22156	12	.	.	.
18637	22157	1	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	22157	2	,	,	,
18637	22157	3	C.	C.	NNP
18637	22157	4	&	&	CC
18637	22157	5	St.	St.	NNP
18637	22157	6	L.	L.	NNP
18637	22157	7	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	22157	8	.	.	.
18637	22158	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22158	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	22158	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22158	4	Browning	Browning	NNP
18637	22158	5	,	,	,
18637	22158	6	310	310	CD
18637	22158	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22158	8	362	362	CD
18637	22158	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22158	10	1940	1940	CD
18637	22158	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22158	12	.	.	.
18637	22159	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22159	2	1095	1095	CD
18637	22159	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22159	4	Sioux	Sioux	NNP
18637	22159	5	City	City	NNP
18637	22159	6	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	22159	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22159	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22159	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22159	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22159	11	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	22159	12	County	County	NNP
18637	22159	13	,	,	,
18637	22159	14	260	260	CD
18637	22159	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22159	16	441	441	CD
18637	22159	17	,	,	,
18637	22159	18	446	446	CD
18637	22159	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22159	20	1923	1923	CD
18637	22159	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22159	22	.	.	.
18637	22160	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22160	2	1096	1096	CD
18637	22160	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22160	4	Hillsborough	Hillsborough	NNP
18637	22160	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22160	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22160	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22160	8	Cromwell	Cromwell	NNP
18637	22160	9	,	,	,
18637	22160	10	326	326	CD
18637	22160	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22160	12	620	620	CD
18637	22160	13	,	,	,
18637	22160	14	623	623	CD
18637	22160	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22160	16	1946	1946	CD
18637	22160	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22160	18	.	.	.
18637	22161	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22161	2	1097	1097	CD
18637	22161	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22161	4	St.	St.	NNP
18637	22161	5	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	22161	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	22161	7	San	San	NNP
18637	22161	8	Francisco	Francisco	NNP
18637	22161	9	R.	R.	NNP
18637	22161	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22161	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22161	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	22161	13	_	_	NNP
18637	22161	14	Middlekamp	Middlekamp	NNP
18637	22161	15	,	,	,
18637	22161	16	256	256	CD
18637	22161	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22161	18	226	226	CD
18637	22161	19	,	,	,
18637	22161	20	230	230	CD
18637	22161	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22161	22	1921	1921	CD
18637	22161	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22161	24	.	.	.
18637	22162	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22162	2	1098	1098	CD
18637	22162	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22162	4	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	22162	5	&	&	CC
18637	22162	6	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	22163	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22163	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22163	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22163	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22163	5	Pace	Pace	NNP
18637	22163	6	,	,	,
18637	22163	7	282	282	CD
18637	22163	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22163	9	241	241	CD
18637	22163	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22163	11	1931	1931	CD
18637	22163	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22163	13	.	.	.
18637	22164	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22164	2	1099	1099	CD
18637	22164	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22164	4	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	22164	5	City	City	NNP
18637	22164	6	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	22164	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	22164	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22164	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22164	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	22164	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22164	12	Road	Road	NNP
18637	22164	13	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	22164	14	.	.	.
18637	22165	1	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	22165	2	.	.	.
18637	22165	3	,	,	,
18637	22165	4	256	256	CD
18637	22165	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22165	6	658	658	CD
18637	22165	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22165	8	1921	1921	CD
18637	22165	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22165	10	;	;	:
18637	22165	11	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	22165	12	_	_	NNP
18637	22165	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	22165	14	_	_	NNP
18637	22165	15	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	22165	16	City	City	NNP
18637	22165	17	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	22165	18	R.	R.	NNP
18637	22165	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22165	20	,	,	,
18637	22165	21	261	261	CD
18637	22165	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22165	23	481	481	CD
18637	22165	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22165	25	1923	1923	CD
18637	22165	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22165	27	.	.	.
18637	22166	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22166	2	1100	1100	CD
18637	22166	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22166	4	Road	Road	NNP
18637	22166	5	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	22166	6	.	.	.
18637	22167	1	Dist	dist	VB
18637	22167	2	.	.	.
18637	22168	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22168	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	22168	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22168	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22168	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	22169	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22169	2	,	,	,
18637	22169	3	274	274	CD
18637	22169	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22169	5	188	188	CD
18637	22169	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22169	7	1927	1927	CD
18637	22169	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22169	9	.	.	.
18637	22170	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22170	2	1101	1101	CD
18637	22170	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22170	4	Branson	Branson	NNP
18637	22170	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22170	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22170	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22170	8	Bush	Bush	NNP
18637	22170	9	,	,	,
18637	22170	10	251	251	CD
18637	22170	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22170	12	182	182	CD
18637	22170	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22170	14	1919	1919	CD
18637	22170	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22170	16	.	.	.
18637	22171	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22171	2	1102	1102	CD
18637	22171	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22171	4	Columbus	Columbus	NNP
18637	22171	5	&	&	CC
18637	22171	6	G.R.	G.R.	NNP
18637	22172	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22172	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22172	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22172	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22172	5	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	22172	6	,	,	,
18637	22172	7	283	283	CD
18637	22172	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22172	9	96	96	CD
18637	22172	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22172	11	1931	1931	CD
18637	22172	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22172	13	.	.	.
18637	22173	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22173	2	1103	1103	CD
18637	22173	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22173	4	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	22173	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22173	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22173	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22173	8	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	22173	9	,	,	,
18637	22173	10	274	274	CD
18637	22173	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22173	12	200	200	CD
18637	22173	13	,	,	,
18637	22173	14	208	208	CD
18637	22173	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22173	16	1927	1927	CD
18637	22173	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22173	18	.	.	.
18637	22174	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22174	2	1104	1104	CD
18637	22174	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22174	4	Classifications	classification	NNS
18637	22174	5	under	under	IN
18637	22174	6	police	police	NN
18637	22174	7	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	22174	8	have	have	VBP
18637	22174	9	been	be	VBN
18637	22174	10	held	hold	VBN
18637	22174	11	valid	valid	JJ
18637	22174	12	in	in	IN
18637	22174	13	the	the	DT
18637	22174	14	following	follow	VBG
18637	22174	15	situations	situation	NNS
18637	22174	16	:	:	:
18637	22174	17	_	_	NNP
18637	22174	18	Advertising	Advertising	NNP
18637	22174	19	:	:	:
18637	22174	20	_	_	NNP
18637	22174	21	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	22174	22	between	between	IN
18637	22174	23	billboard	billboard	NN
18637	22174	24	and	and	CC
18637	22174	25	newspaper	newspaper	NN
18637	22174	26	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	22174	27	of	of	IN
18637	22174	28	cigarettes	cigarette	NNS
18637	22174	29	,	,	,
18637	22174	30	Packer	Packer	NNP
18637	22174	31	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	22174	32	_	_	NNP
18637	22174	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	22174	34	_	_	NNP
18637	22174	35	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	22174	36	,	,	,
18637	22174	37	285	285	CD
18637	22174	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22174	39	105	105	CD
18637	22174	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22174	41	1932	1932	CD
18637	22174	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22174	43	;	;	:
18637	22174	44	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	22174	45	of	of	IN
18637	22174	46	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	22174	47	signs	sign	NNS
18637	22174	48	on	on	IN
18637	22174	49	motor	motor	NN
18637	22174	50	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	22174	51	,	,	,
18637	22174	52	except	except	IN
18637	22174	53	when	when	WRB
18637	22174	54	used	use	VBN
18637	22174	55	in	in	IN
18637	22174	56	the	the	DT
18637	22174	57	usual	usual	JJ
18637	22174	58	business	business	NN
18637	22174	59	of	of	IN
18637	22174	60	the	the	DT
18637	22174	61	owner	owner	NN
18637	22174	62	,	,	,
18637	22174	63	and	and	CC
18637	22174	64	not	not	RB
18637	22174	65	used	use	VBN
18637	22174	66	mainly	mainly	RB
18637	22174	67	for	for	IN
18637	22174	68	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	22174	69	,	,	,
18637	22174	70	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	22174	71	Ave	Ave	NNP
18637	22174	72	.	.	.
18637	22174	73	Coach	Coach	NNP
18637	22174	74	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22174	75	_	_	NNP
18637	22174	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	22174	77	_	_	NNP
18637	22174	78	New	New	NNP
18637	22174	79	York	York	NNP
18637	22174	80	,	,	,
18637	22174	81	221	221	CD
18637	22174	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22174	83	467	467	CD
18637	22174	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22174	85	1911	1911	CD
18637	22174	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22174	87	;	;	:
18637	22174	88	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	22174	89	of	of	IN
18637	22174	90	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	22174	91	on	on	IN
18637	22174	92	motor	motor	NN
18637	22174	93	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	22174	94	except	except	IN
18637	22174	95	notices	notice	NNS
18637	22174	96	or	or	CC
18637	22174	97	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	22174	98	of	of	IN
18637	22174	99	products	product	NNS
18637	22174	100	of	of	IN
18637	22174	101	the	the	DT
18637	22174	102	owner	owner	NN
18637	22174	103	,	,	,
18637	22174	104	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	22174	105	Express	Express	NNP
18637	22174	106	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	22174	107	_	_	NNP
18637	22174	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	22174	109	_	_	NNP
18637	22174	110	New	New	NNP
18637	22174	111	York	York	NNP
18637	22174	112	,	,	,
18637	22174	113	336	336	CD
18637	22174	114	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22174	115	106	106	CD
18637	22174	116	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22174	117	1949	1949	CD
18637	22174	118	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22174	119	;	;	:
18637	22174	120	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	22174	121	against	against	IN
18637	22174	122	sale	sale	NN
18637	22174	123	of	of	IN
18637	22174	124	articles	article	NNS
18637	22174	125	on	on	IN
18637	22174	126	which	which	WDT
18637	22174	127	there	there	EX
18637	22174	128	is	be	VBZ
18637	22174	129	a	a	DT
18637	22174	130	representation	representation	NN
18637	22174	131	of	of	IN
18637	22174	132	the	the	DT
18637	22174	133	flag	flag	NN
18637	22174	134	for	for	IN
18637	22174	135	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	22174	136	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	22174	137	,	,	,
18637	22174	138	except	except	IN
18637	22174	139	newspapers	newspaper	NNS
18637	22174	140	,	,	,
18637	22174	141	periodicals	periodical	NNS
18637	22174	142	and	and	CC
18637	22174	143	books	book	NNS
18637	22174	144	;	;	:
18637	22174	145	Halter	Halter	NNP
18637	22174	146	_	_	NNP
18637	22174	147	v.	v.	IN
18637	22174	148	_	_	NNP
18637	22174	149	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	22174	150	,	,	,
18637	22174	151	205	205	CD
18637	22174	152	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22174	153	34	34	CD
18637	22174	154	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22174	155	1907	1907	CD
18637	22174	156	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22174	157	.	.	.
18637	22175	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22175	2	Amusement	Amusement	NNP
18637	22175	3	:	:	:
18637	22175	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22175	5	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	22175	6	against	against	IN
18637	22175	7	keeping	keep	VBG
18637	22175	8	billiard	billiard	NN
18637	22175	9	halls	hall	NNS
18637	22175	10	for	for	IN
18637	22175	11	hire	hire	NN
18637	22175	12	,	,	,
18637	22175	13	except	except	IN
18637	22175	14	in	in	IN
18637	22175	15	case	case	NN
18637	22175	16	of	of	IN
18637	22175	17	hotels	hotel	NNS
18637	22175	18	having	have	VBG
18637	22175	19	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	22175	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	22175	21	five	five	CD
18637	22175	22	or	or	CC
18637	22175	23	more	more	JJR
18637	22175	24	rooms	room	NNS
18637	22175	25	for	for	IN
18637	22175	26	use	use	NN
18637	22175	27	of	of	IN
18637	22175	28	regular	regular	JJ
18637	22175	29	guests	guest	NNS
18637	22175	30	.	.	.
18637	22176	1	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	22176	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22176	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22176	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22176	5	California	California	NNP
18637	22176	6	,	,	,
18637	22176	7	225	225	CD
18637	22176	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22176	9	623	623	CD
18637	22176	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22176	11	1912	1912	CD
18637	22176	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22176	13	.	.	.
18637	22177	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22177	2	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	22177	3	shops	shop	NNS
18637	22177	4	:	:	:
18637	22177	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22177	6	a	a	DT
18637	22177	7	law	law	NN
18637	22177	8	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	22177	9	Sunday	Sunday	NNP
18637	22177	10	labor	labor	NN
18637	22177	11	except	except	IN
18637	22177	12	works	work	NNS
18637	22177	13	of	of	IN
18637	22177	14	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	22177	15	or	or	CC
18637	22177	16	charity	charity	NN
18637	22177	17	,	,	,
18637	22177	18	and	and	CC
18637	22177	19	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	22177	20	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	22177	21	the	the	DT
18637	22177	22	keeping	keeping	NN
18637	22177	23	open	open	JJ
18637	22177	24	of	of	IN
18637	22177	25	barber	barber	NN
18637	22177	26	shops	shop	NNS
18637	22177	27	.	.	.
18637	22178	1	Petit	Petit	NNP
18637	22178	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22178	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22178	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22178	5	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	22178	6	,	,	,
18637	22178	7	177	177	CD
18637	22178	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22178	9	164	164	CD
18637	22178	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22178	11	1900	1900	CD
18637	22178	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22178	13	.	.	.
18637	22179	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22179	2	Cattle	Cattle	NNP
18637	22179	3	:	:	:
18637	22179	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22179	5	a	a	DT
18637	22179	6	classification	classification	NN
18637	22179	7	of	of	IN
18637	22179	8	sheep	sheep	NN
18637	22179	9	,	,	,
18637	22179	10	as	as	IN
18637	22179	11	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	22179	12	from	from	IN
18637	22179	13	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	22179	14	,	,	,
18637	22179	15	in	in	IN
18637	22179	16	a	a	DT
18637	22179	17	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	22179	18	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	22179	19	the	the	DT
18637	22179	20	use	use	NN
18637	22179	21	of	of	IN
18637	22179	22	public	public	JJ
18637	22179	23	lands	land	NNS
18637	22179	24	for	for	IN
18637	22179	25	grazing	graze	VBG
18637	22179	26	.	.	.
18637	22180	1	Bacon	Bacon	NNP
18637	22180	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22180	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22180	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22180	5	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	22180	6	,	,	,
18637	22180	7	204	204	CD
18637	22180	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22180	9	311	311	CD
18637	22180	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22180	11	1907	1907	CD
18637	22180	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22180	13	.	.	.
18637	22181	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22181	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22181	3	also	also	RB
18637	22181	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22181	5	Omaechevarria	Omaechevarria	NNP
18637	22181	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22181	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22181	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22181	9	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
18637	22181	10	,	,	,
18637	22181	11	246	246	CD
18637	22181	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22181	13	343	343	CD
18637	22181	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22181	15	1918	1918	CD
18637	22181	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22181	17	.	.	.
18637	22182	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22182	2	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	22182	3	gins	gin	NNS
18637	22182	4	:	:	:
18637	22182	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22182	6	in	in	IN
18637	22182	7	a	a	DT
18637	22182	8	State	State	NNP
18637	22182	9	where	where	WRB
18637	22182	10	cotton	cotton	NN
18637	22182	11	gins	gin	NNS
18637	22182	12	are	be	VBP
18637	22182	13	held	hold	VBN
18637	22182	14	to	to	TO
18637	22182	15	be	be	VB
18637	22182	16	public	public	JJ
18637	22182	17	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	22182	18	and	and	CC
18637	22182	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22182	20	rates	rate	NNS
18637	22182	21	regulated	regulate	VBD
18637	22182	22	,	,	,
18637	22182	23	the	the	DT
18637	22182	24	granting	granting	NN
18637	22182	25	of	of	IN
18637	22182	26	a	a	DT
18637	22182	27	license	license	NN
18637	22182	28	to	to	IN
18637	22182	29	a	a	DT
18637	22182	30	cooperative	cooperative	JJ
18637	22182	31	association	association	NN
18637	22182	32	distributing	distribute	VBG
18637	22182	33	profits	profit	NNS
18637	22182	34	ratably	ratably	RB
18637	22182	35	to	to	IN
18637	22182	36	members	member	NNS
18637	22182	37	and	and	CC
18637	22182	38	nonmembers	nonmember	NNS
18637	22182	39	does	do	VBZ
18637	22182	40	not	not	RB
18637	22182	41	deny	deny	VB
18637	22182	42	other	other	JJ
18637	22182	43	persons	person	NNS
18637	22182	44	operating	operate	VBG
18637	22182	45	gins	gin	NNS
18637	22182	46	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22182	47	protection	protection	NN
18637	22182	48	when	when	WRB
18637	22182	49	there	there	EX
18637	22182	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	22182	51	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	22182	52	in	in	IN
18637	22182	53	the	the	DT
18637	22182	54	laws	law	NNS
18637	22182	55	to	to	TO
18637	22182	56	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	22182	57	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22182	58	to	to	TO
18637	22182	59	distribute	distribute	VB
18637	22182	60	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22182	61	net	net	JJ
18637	22182	62	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	22182	63	among	among	IN
18637	22182	64	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22182	65	patrons	patron	NNS
18637	22182	66	.	.	.
18637	22183	1	Corporations	Corporations	NNPS
18637	22183	2	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	22183	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22183	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22183	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22183	6	Lowe	Lowe	NNP
18637	22183	7	,	,	,
18637	22183	8	281	281	CD
18637	22183	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22183	10	431	431	CD
18637	22183	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22183	12	1930	1930	CD
18637	22183	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22183	14	.	.	.
18637	22184	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22184	2	Fish	Fish	NNP
18637	22184	3	processing	processing	NN
18637	22184	4	:	:	:
18637	22184	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22184	6	stricter	strict	JJR
18637	22184	7	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	22184	8	of	of	IN
18637	22184	9	reduction	reduction	NN
18637	22184	10	of	of	IN
18637	22184	11	fish	fish	NN
18637	22184	12	to	to	IN
18637	22184	13	flour	flour	NN
18637	22184	14	or	or	CC
18637	22184	15	meal	meal	NN
18637	22184	16	than	than	IN
18637	22184	17	of	of	IN
18637	22184	18	canning	canning	NN
18637	22184	19	.	.	.
18637	22185	1	Bayside	Bayside	NNP
18637	22185	2	Fish	Fish	NNP
18637	22185	3	Flour	Flour	NNP
18637	22185	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22185	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22185	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22185	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22185	8	Gentry	Gentry	NNP
18637	22185	9	,	,	,
18637	22185	10	297	297	CD
18637	22185	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22185	12	422	422	CD
18637	22185	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22185	14	1936	1936	CD
18637	22185	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22185	16	.	.	.
18637	22186	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22186	2	Food	Food	NNP
18637	22186	3	:	:	:
18637	22186	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22186	5	bread	bread	NN
18637	22186	6	sold	sell	VBN
18637	22186	7	in	in	IN
18637	22186	8	loaves	loaf	NNS
18637	22186	9	must	must	MD
18637	22186	10	be	be	VB
18637	22186	11	of	of	IN
18637	22186	12	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	22186	13	standard	standard	JJ
18637	22186	14	sizes	size	NNS
18637	22186	15	,	,	,
18637	22186	16	Schmidinger	Schmidinger	NNP
18637	22186	17	_	_	NNP
18637	22186	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	22186	19	_	_	NNP
18637	22186	20	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	22186	21	,	,	,
18637	22186	22	226	226	CD
18637	22186	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22186	24	578	578	CD
18637	22186	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22186	26	1913	1913	CD
18637	22186	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22186	28	;	;	:
18637	22186	29	food	food	NN
18637	22186	30	preservatives	preservative	NNS
18637	22186	31	containing	contain	VBG
18637	22186	32	boric	boric	NN
18637	22186	33	acid	acid	NN
18637	22186	34	may	may	MD
18637	22186	35	not	not	RB
18637	22186	36	be	be	VB
18637	22186	37	sold	sell	VBN
18637	22186	38	,	,	,
18637	22186	39	Price	Price	NNP
18637	22186	40	_	_	NNP
18637	22186	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	22186	42	_	_	NNP
18637	22186	43	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	22186	44	,	,	,
18637	22186	45	238	238	CD
18637	22186	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22186	47	446	446	CD
18637	22186	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22186	49	1915	1915	CD
18637	22186	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22186	51	;	;	:
18637	22186	52	lard	lard	NNP
18637	22186	53	not	not	RB
18637	22186	54	sold	sell	VBN
18637	22186	55	in	in	IN
18637	22186	56	bulk	bulk	NN
18637	22186	57	must	must	MD
18637	22186	58	be	be	VB
18637	22186	59	put	put	VBN
18637	22186	60	up	up	RP
18637	22186	61	in	in	IN
18637	22186	62	containers	container	NNS
18637	22186	63	holding	hold	VBG
18637	22186	64	one	one	CD
18637	22186	65	,	,	,
18637	22186	66	three	three	CD
18637	22186	67	or	or	CC
18637	22186	68	five	five	CD
18637	22186	69	pounds	pound	NNS
18637	22186	70	or	or	CC
18637	22186	71	some	some	DT
18637	22186	72	whole	whole	JJ
18637	22186	73	multiple	multiple	NN
18637	22186	74	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	22186	75	,	,	,
18637	22186	76	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	22186	77	&	&	CC
18637	22186	78	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22186	79	_	_	NNP
18637	22186	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	22186	81	_	_	NNP
18637	22186	82	North	North	NNP
18637	22186	83	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	22186	84	,	,	,
18637	22186	85	240	240	CD
18637	22186	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22186	87	510	510	CD
18637	22186	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22186	89	1916	1916	CD
18637	22186	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22186	91	;	;	:
18637	22186	92	milk	milk	NN
18637	22186	93	industry	industry	NN
18637	22186	94	may	may	MD
18637	22186	95	be	be	VB
18637	22186	96	placed	place	VBN
18637	22186	97	in	in	IN
18637	22186	98	a	a	DT
18637	22186	99	special	special	JJ
18637	22186	100	class	class	NN
18637	22186	101	for	for	IN
18637	22186	102	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	22186	103	,	,	,
18637	22186	104	New	New	NNP
18637	22186	105	York	York	NNP
18637	22186	106	ex	ex	NNP
18637	22186	107	rel	rel	NN
18637	22186	108	.	.	.
18637	22187	1	Lieberman	Lieberman	NNP
18637	22187	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22187	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22187	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22187	5	Van	Van	NNP
18637	22187	6	De	De	NNP
18637	22187	7	Carr	Carr	NNP
18637	22187	8	,	,	,
18637	22187	9	199	199	CD
18637	22187	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22187	11	552	552	CD
18637	22187	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22187	13	1905	1905	CD
18637	22187	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22187	15	;	;	:
18637	22187	16	vendors	vendor	NNS
18637	22187	17	producing	produce	VBG
18637	22187	18	milk	milk	NN
18637	22187	19	outside	outside	IN
18637	22187	20	city	city	NN
18637	22187	21	may	may	MD
18637	22187	22	be	be	VB
18637	22187	23	classified	classify	VBN
18637	22187	24	separately	separately	RB
18637	22187	25	,	,	,
18637	22187	26	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	22187	27	_	_	NNP
18637	22187	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	22187	29	_	_	NNP
18637	22187	30	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	22187	31	,	,	,
18637	22187	32	228	228	CD
18637	22187	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22187	34	572	572	CD
18637	22187	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22187	36	1913	1913	CD
18637	22187	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22187	38	;	;	:
18637	22187	39	producing	produce	VBG
18637	22187	40	and	and	CC
18637	22187	41	nonproducing	nonproducing	JJ
18637	22187	42	vendors	vendor	NNS
18637	22187	43	may	may	MD
18637	22187	44	be	be	VB
18637	22187	45	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	22187	46	in	in	IN
18637	22187	47	milk	milk	NN
18637	22187	48	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	22187	49	,	,	,
18637	22187	50	St.	St.	NNP
18637	22187	51	John	John	NNP
18637	22187	52	_	_	NNP
18637	22187	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	22187	54	_	_	NNP
18637	22187	55	New	New	NNP
18637	22187	56	York	York	NNP
18637	22187	57	,	,	,
18637	22187	58	201	201	CD
18637	22187	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22187	60	633	633	CD
18637	22187	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22187	62	1906	1906	CD
18637	22187	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22187	64	;	;	:
18637	22187	65	different	different	JJ
18637	22187	66	minimum	minimum	NN
18637	22187	67	and	and	CC
18637	22187	68	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	22187	69	milk	milk	NN
18637	22187	70	prices	price	NNS
18637	22187	71	may	may	MD
18637	22187	72	be	be	VB
18637	22187	73	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	22187	74	for	for	IN
18637	22187	75	distributors	distributor	NNS
18637	22187	76	and	and	CC
18637	22187	77	storekeepers	storekeeper	NNS
18637	22187	78	;	;	:
18637	22187	79	Nebbia	Nebbia	NNP
18637	22187	80	_	_	NNP
18637	22187	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	22187	82	_	_	NNP
18637	22187	83	New	New	NNP
18637	22187	84	York	York	NNP
18637	22187	85	,	,	,
18637	22187	86	291	291	CD
18637	22187	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22187	88	502	502	CD
18637	22187	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22187	90	1934	1934	CD
18637	22187	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22187	92	;	;	:
18637	22187	93	price	price	NN
18637	22187	94	differential	differential	NN
18637	22187	95	may	may	MD
18637	22187	96	be	be	VB
18637	22187	97	granted	grant	VBN
18637	22187	98	for	for	IN
18637	22187	99	sellers	seller	NNS
18637	22187	100	of	of	IN
18637	22187	101	milk	milk	NN
18637	22187	102	not	not	RB
18637	22187	103	having	have	VBG
18637	22187	104	a	a	DT
18637	22187	105	well	well	RB
18637	22187	106	advertised	advertise	VBN
18637	22187	107	trade	trade	NN
18637	22187	108	name	name	NN
18637	22187	109	,	,	,
18637	22187	110	Borden	Borden	NNP
18637	22187	111	's	's	POS
18637	22187	112	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	22187	113	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	22187	114	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22187	115	_	_	NNP
18637	22187	116	v.	v.	IN
18637	22187	117	_	_	NNP
18637	22187	118	Ten	Ten	NNP
18637	22187	119	Eyck	Eyck	NNP
18637	22187	120	,	,	,
18637	22187	121	297	297	CD
18637	22187	122	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22187	123	251	251	CD
18637	22187	124	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22187	125	1936	1936	CD
18637	22187	126	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22187	127	;	;	:
18637	22187	128	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
18637	22187	129	colored	color	VBD
18637	22187	130	to	to	TO
18637	22187	131	resemble	resemble	VB
18637	22187	132	butter	butter	NN
18637	22187	133	may	may	MD
18637	22187	134	be	be	VB
18637	22187	135	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	22187	136	,	,	,
18637	22187	137	Capital	Capital	NNP
18637	22187	138	City	City	NNP
18637	22187	139	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
18637	22187	140	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22187	141	_	_	NNP
18637	22187	142	v.	v.	IN
18637	22187	143	_	_	NNP
18637	22187	144	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	22187	145	ex	ex	NNP
18637	22187	146	rel	rel	NN
18637	22187	147	.	.	.
18637	22188	1	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	22188	2	General	General	NNP
18637	22188	3	,	,	,
18637	22188	4	183	183	CD
18637	22188	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22188	6	238	238	CD
18637	22188	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22188	8	1902	1902	CD
18637	22188	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22188	10	;	;	:
18637	22188	11	table	table	NN
18637	22188	12	syrups	syrup	NNS
18637	22188	13	may	may	MD
18637	22188	14	be	be	VB
18637	22188	15	required	require	VBN
18637	22188	16	to	to	TO
18637	22188	17	be	be	VB
18637	22188	18	so	so	RB
18637	22188	19	labelled	labelled	JJ
18637	22188	20	and	and	CC
18637	22188	21	disclose	disclose	VB
18637	22188	22	identity	identity	NN
18637	22188	23	and	and	CC
18637	22188	24	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	22188	25	of	of	IN
18637	22188	26	ingredients	ingredient	NNS
18637	22188	27	,	,	,
18637	22188	28	Corn	Corn	NNP
18637	22188	29	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	22188	30	Ref	Ref	NNP
18637	22188	31	.	.	.
18637	22189	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22189	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22189	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22189	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22189	5	Eddy	Eddy	NNP
18637	22189	6	,	,	,
18637	22189	7	249	249	CD
18637	22189	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22189	9	427	427	CD
18637	22189	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22189	11	1919	1919	CD
18637	22189	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22189	13	.	.	.
18637	22190	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22190	2	Geographical	geographical	JJ
18637	22190	3	discriminations	discrimination	NNS
18637	22190	4	:	:	:
18637	22190	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22190	6	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	22190	7	limited	limit	VBN
18637	22190	8	in	in	IN
18637	22190	9	application	application	NN
18637	22190	10	to	to	IN
18637	22190	11	a	a	DT
18637	22190	12	particular	particular	JJ
18637	22190	13	geographical	geographical	JJ
18637	22190	14	or	or	CC
18637	22190	15	political	political	JJ
18637	22190	16	subdivision	subdivision	NN
18637	22190	17	of	of	IN
18637	22190	18	a	a	DT
18637	22190	19	State	State	NNP
18637	22190	20	,	,	,
18637	22190	21	Ft	Ft	NNP
18637	22190	22	.	.	.
18637	22190	23	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	22190	24	Light	Light	NNP
18637	22190	25	&	&	CC
18637	22190	26	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	22190	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22190	28	_	_	NNP
18637	22190	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	22190	30	_	_	NNP
18637	22190	31	Board	Board	NNP
18637	22190	32	of	of	IN
18637	22190	33	Improvement	Improvement	NNP
18637	22190	34	,	,	,
18637	22190	35	274	274	CD
18637	22190	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22190	37	387	387	CD
18637	22190	38	,	,	,
18637	22190	39	391	391	CD
18637	22190	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22190	41	1927	1927	CD
18637	22190	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22190	43	;	;	:
18637	22190	44	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	22190	45	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	22190	46	a	a	DT
18637	22190	47	particular	particular	JJ
18637	22190	48	business	business	NN
18637	22190	49	in	in	IN
18637	22190	50	certain	certain	JJ
18637	22190	51	sections	section	NNS
18637	22190	52	of	of	IN
18637	22190	53	a	a	DT
18637	22190	54	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	22190	55	,	,	,
18637	22190	56	Hadacheck	Hadacheck	NNP
18637	22190	57	_	_	NNP
18637	22190	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	22190	59	_	_	NNP
18637	22190	60	Sebastian	Sebastian	NNP
18637	22190	61	,	,	,
18637	22190	62	239	239	CD
18637	22190	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22190	64	394	394	CD
18637	22190	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22190	66	1915	1915	CD
18637	22190	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22190	68	;	;	:
18637	22190	69	statute	statute	NN
18637	22190	70	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	22190	71	a	a	DT
18637	22190	72	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	22190	73	commission	commission	NN
18637	22190	74	to	to	TO
18637	22190	75	limit	limit	VB
18637	22190	76	the	the	DT
18637	22190	77	height	height	NN
18637	22190	78	of	of	IN
18637	22190	79	buildings	building	NNS
18637	22190	80	in	in	IN
18637	22190	81	commercial	commercial	JJ
18637	22190	82	districts	district	NNS
18637	22190	83	to	to	IN
18637	22190	84	125	125	CD
18637	22190	85	feet	foot	NNS
18637	22190	86	and	and	CC
18637	22190	87	in	in	IN
18637	22190	88	other	other	JJ
18637	22190	89	districts	district	NNS
18637	22190	90	to	to	IN
18637	22190	91	80	80	CD
18637	22190	92	to	to	TO
18637	22190	93	100	100	CD
18637	22190	94	feet	foot	NNS
18637	22190	95	,	,	,
18637	22190	96	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	22190	97	_	_	NNP
18637	22190	98	v.	v.	IN
18637	22190	99	_	_	NNP
18637	22190	100	Swasey	Swasey	NNP
18637	22190	101	,	,	,
18637	22190	102	214	214	CD
18637	22190	103	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22190	104	91	91	CD
18637	22190	105	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22190	106	1909	1909	CD
18637	22190	107	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22190	108	;	;	:
18637	22190	109	ordinance	ordinance	NN
18637	22190	110	prescribing	prescribing	NN
18637	22190	111	limits	limit	NNS
18637	22190	112	in	in	IN
18637	22190	113	city	city	NN
18637	22190	114	outside	outside	IN
18637	22190	115	of	of	IN
18637	22190	116	which	which	WDT
18637	22190	117	no	no	DT
18637	22190	118	woman	woman	NN
18637	22190	119	of	of	IN
18637	22190	120	lewd	lewd	NNP
18637	22190	121	character	character	NN
18637	22190	122	shall	shall	MD
18637	22190	123	dwell	dwell	VB
18637	22190	124	,	,	,
18637	22190	125	L'Hote	L'Hote	NNP
18637	22190	126	_	_	NNP
18637	22190	127	v.	v.	IN
18637	22190	128	_	_	NNP
18637	22190	129	New	New	NNP
18637	22190	130	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	22190	131	,	,	,
18637	22190	132	177	177	CD
18637	22190	133	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22190	134	587	587	CD
18637	22190	135	,	,	,
18637	22190	136	595	595	CD
18637	22190	137	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22190	138	1900	1900	CD
18637	22190	139	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22190	140	.	.	.
18637	22191	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22191	2	Hotels	Hotels	NNPS
18637	22191	3	:	:	:
18637	22191	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22191	5	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	22191	6	that	that	IN
18637	22191	7	keepers	keeper	NNS
18637	22191	8	of	of	IN
18637	22191	9	hotels	hotel	NNS
18637	22191	10	having	have	VBG
18637	22191	11	over	over	IN
18637	22191	12	fifty	fifty	CD
18637	22191	13	guests	guest	NNS
18637	22191	14	employ	employ	VB
18637	22191	15	night	night	NN
18637	22191	16	watchmen	watchmen	NNP
18637	22191	17	.	.	.
18637	22192	1	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	22192	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22192	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22192	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22192	5	Strahl	Strahl	NNP
18637	22192	6	,	,	,
18637	22192	7	239	239	CD
18637	22192	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22192	9	426	426	CD
18637	22192	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22192	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	22192	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22192	13	.	.	.
18637	22193	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22193	2	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	22193	3	companies	company	NNS
18637	22193	4	:	:	:
18637	22193	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22193	6	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	22193	7	of	of	IN
18637	22193	8	fire	fire	NN
18637	22193	9	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	22193	10	rates	rate	NNS
18637	22193	11	with	with	IN
18637	22193	12	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	22193	13	for	for	IN
18637	22193	14	farmers	farmers	NNP
18637	22193	15	mutuals	mutual	NNS
18637	22193	16	,	,	,
18637	22193	17	German	German	NNP
18637	22193	18	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	22193	19	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	22193	20	.	.	.
18637	22194	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22194	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22194	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22194	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22194	5	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	22194	6	,	,	,
18637	22194	7	233	233	CD
18637	22194	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22194	9	389	389	CD
18637	22194	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22194	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	22194	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22194	13	;	;	:
18637	22194	14	different	different	JJ
18637	22194	15	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	22194	16	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	22194	17	upon	upon	IN
18637	22194	18	reciprocal	reciprocal	JJ
18637	22194	19	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	22194	20	associations	association	NNS
18637	22194	21	than	than	IN
18637	22194	22	upon	upon	IN
18637	22194	23	mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	22194	24	companies	company	NNS
18637	22194	25	,	,	,
18637	22194	26	Hoopeston	Hoopeston	NNP
18637	22194	27	Canning	Canning	NNP
18637	22194	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22194	29	_	_	NNP
18637	22194	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	22194	31	_	_	NNP
18637	22194	32	Cullen	Cullen	NNP
18637	22194	33	,	,	,
18637	22194	34	318	318	CD
18637	22194	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22194	36	313	313	CD
18637	22194	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22194	38	1943	1943	CD
18637	22194	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22194	40	;	;	:
18637	22194	41	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	22194	42	against	against	IN
18637	22194	43	life	life	NN
18637	22194	44	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	22194	45	companies	company	NNS
18637	22194	46	or	or	CC
18637	22194	47	agents	agent	NNS
18637	22194	48	engaging	engage	VBG
18637	22194	49	in	in	IN
18637	22194	50	undertaking	undertaking	NN
18637	22194	51	business	business	NN
18637	22194	52	,	,	,
18637	22194	53	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	22194	54	_	_	NNP
18637	22194	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	22194	56	_	_	NNP
18637	22194	57	Family	Family	NNP
18637	22194	58	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	22194	59	.	.	.
18637	22195	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22195	2	,	,	,
18637	22195	3	336	336	CD
18637	22195	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22195	5	220	220	CD
18637	22195	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22195	7	1949	1949	CD
18637	22195	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22195	9	.	.	.
18637	22196	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22196	2	Intoxicating	Intoxicating	NNP
18637	22196	3	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	22196	4	:	:	:
18637	22196	5	_	_	IN
18637	22196	6	exception	exception	NN
18637	22196	7	of	of	IN
18637	22196	8	druggists	druggist	NNS
18637	22196	9	or	or	CC
18637	22196	10	manufacturers	manufacturer	NNS
18637	22196	11	from	from	IN
18637	22196	12	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	22196	13	.	.	.
18637	22197	1	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	22197	2	ex	ex	NNP
18637	22197	3	rel	rel	NN
18637	22197	4	.	.	.
18637	22198	1	Lloyd	Lloyd	NNP
18637	22198	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22198	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22198	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22198	5	Dollison	Dollison	NNP
18637	22198	6	,	,	,
18637	22198	7	194	194	CD
18637	22198	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22198	9	445	445	CD
18637	22198	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22198	11	1904	1904	CD
18637	22198	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22198	13	;	;	:
18637	22198	14	Eberle	Eberle	NNP
18637	22198	15	_	_	NNP
18637	22198	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	22198	17	_	_	NNP
18637	22198	18	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	22198	19	,	,	,
18637	22198	20	232	232	CD
18637	22198	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22198	22	700	700	CD
18637	22198	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22198	24	1914	1914	CD
18637	22198	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22198	26	.	.	.
18637	22199	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22199	2	Lodging	Lodging	NNP
18637	22199	3	houses	house	NNS
18637	22199	4	:	:	:
18637	22199	5	_	_	XX
18637	22199	6	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	22199	7	that	that	IN
18637	22199	8	sprinkler	sprinkler	NN
18637	22199	9	systems	system	NNS
18637	22199	10	be	be	VB
18637	22199	11	installed	instal	VBN
18637	22199	12	in	in	IN
18637	22199	13	buildings	building	NNS
18637	22199	14	of	of	IN
18637	22199	15	nonfireproof	nonfireproof	JJ
18637	22199	16	construction	construction	NN
18637	22199	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	22199	18	valid	valid	JJ
18637	22199	19	as	as	IN
18637	22199	20	applied	apply	VBN
18637	22199	21	to	to	IN
18637	22199	22	such	such	PDT
18637	22199	23	a	a	DT
18637	22199	24	building	building	NN
18637	22199	25	which	which	WDT
18637	22199	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	22199	27	safeguarded	safeguard	VBN
18637	22199	28	by	by	IN
18637	22199	29	a	a	DT
18637	22199	30	fire	fire	NN
18637	22199	31	alarm	alarm	NN
18637	22199	32	system	system	NN
18637	22199	33	,	,	,
18637	22199	34	constant	constant	JJ
18637	22199	35	watchman	watchman	NN
18637	22199	36	service	service	NN
18637	22199	37	and	and	CC
18637	22199	38	other	other	JJ
18637	22199	39	safety	safety	NN
18637	22199	40	arrangements	arrangement	NNS
18637	22199	41	.	.	.
18637	22200	1	Queenside	Queenside	NNP
18637	22200	2	Hills	Hills	NNP
18637	22200	3	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	22200	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22200	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22200	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22200	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22200	8	Saxl	Saxl	NNP
18637	22200	9	,	,	,
18637	22200	10	328	328	CD
18637	22200	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22200	12	80	80	CD
18637	22200	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22200	14	1946	1946	CD
18637	22200	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22200	16	.	.	.
18637	22201	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22201	2	Markets	Markets	NNPS
18637	22201	3	:	:	:
18637	22201	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22201	5	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	22201	6	against	against	IN
18637	22201	7	operation	operation	NN
18637	22201	8	of	of	IN
18637	22201	9	private	private	JJ
18637	22201	10	market	market	NN
18637	22201	11	within	within	IN
18637	22201	12	six	six	CD
18637	22201	13	squares	square	NNS
18637	22201	14	of	of	IN
18637	22201	15	public	public	JJ
18637	22201	16	market	market	NN
18637	22201	17	.	.	.
18637	22202	1	Natal	Natal	NNP
18637	22202	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22202	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22202	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22202	5	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	22202	6	,	,	,
18637	22202	7	139	139	CD
18637	22202	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22202	9	621	621	CD
18637	22202	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22202	11	1891	1891	CD
18637	22202	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22202	13	.	.	.
18637	22203	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22203	2	Medicine	Medicine	NNP
18637	22203	3	:	:	:
18637	22203	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22203	5	a	a	DT
18637	22203	6	uniform	uniform	JJ
18637	22203	7	standard	standard	NN
18637	22203	8	of	of	IN
18637	22203	9	professional	professional	JJ
18637	22203	10	attainment	attainment	JJ
18637	22203	11	and	and	CC
18637	22203	12	conduct	conduct	VB
18637	22203	13	for	for	IN
18637	22203	14	all	all	DT
18637	22203	15	physicians	physician	NNS
18637	22203	16	,	,	,
18637	22203	17	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22203	18	ex	ex	NNP
18637	22203	19	rel	rel	NN
18637	22203	20	.	.	.
18637	22204	1	Hurwitz	Hurwitz	NNP
18637	22204	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22204	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22204	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22204	5	North	North	NNP
18637	22204	6	,	,	,
18637	22204	7	271	271	CD
18637	22204	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22204	9	40	40	CD
18637	22204	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22204	11	1926	1926	CD
18637	22204	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22204	13	;	;	:
18637	22204	14	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	22204	15	exemptions	exemption	NNS
18637	22204	16	from	from	IN
18637	22204	17	medical	medical	JJ
18637	22204	18	registration	registration	NN
18637	22204	19	law	law	NN
18637	22204	20	,	,	,
18637	22204	21	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	22204	22	_	_	NNP
18637	22204	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	22204	24	_	_	NNP
18637	22204	25	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	22204	26	,	,	,
18637	22204	27	218	218	CD
18637	22204	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22204	29	173	173	CD
18637	22204	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22204	31	1910	1910	CD
18637	22204	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22204	33	;	;	:
18637	22204	34	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	22204	35	of	of	IN
18637	22204	36	persons	person	NNS
18637	22204	37	who	who	WP
18637	22204	38	heal	heal	VBP
18637	22204	39	by	by	IN
18637	22204	40	prayer	prayer	NN
18637	22204	41	from	from	IN
18637	22204	42	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	22204	43	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	22204	44	to	to	TO
18637	22204	45	drugless	drugless	VB
18637	22204	46	physicians	physician	NNS
18637	22204	47	,	,	,
18637	22204	48	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	22204	49	_	_	NNP
18637	22204	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	22204	51	_	_	NNP
18637	22204	52	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	22204	53	,	,	,
18637	22204	54	242	242	CD
18637	22204	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22204	56	339	339	CD
18637	22204	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22204	58	1917	1917	CD
18637	22204	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22204	60	;	;	:
18637	22204	61	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	22204	62	of	of	IN
18637	22204	63	osteopathic	osteopathic	JJ
18637	22204	64	physicians	physician	NNS
18637	22204	65	from	from	IN
18637	22204	66	public	public	JJ
18637	22204	67	hospitals	hospital	NNS
18637	22204	68	,	,	,
18637	22204	69	Hayman	Hayman	NNP
18637	22204	70	_	_	NNP
18637	22204	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	22204	72	_	_	NNP
18637	22204	73	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	22204	74	,	,	,
18637	22204	75	273	273	CD
18637	22204	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22204	77	414	414	CD
18637	22204	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22204	79	1927	1927	CD
18637	22204	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22204	81	;	;	:
18637	22204	82	requirement	requirement	VB
18637	22204	83	that	that	IN
18637	22204	84	persons	person	NNS
18637	22204	85	who	who	WP
18637	22204	86	treat	treat	VBP
18637	22204	87	eyes	eye	NNS
18637	22204	88	without	without	IN
18637	22204	89	use	use	NN
18637	22204	90	of	of	IN
18637	22204	91	drugs	drug	NNS
18637	22204	92	be	be	VB
18637	22204	93	licensed	license	VBN
18637	22204	94	as	as	IN
18637	22204	95	optometrists	optometrist	NNS
18637	22204	96	with	with	IN
18637	22204	97	exception	exception	NN
18637	22204	98	for	for	IN
18637	22204	99	persons	person	NNS
18637	22204	100	treating	treat	VBG
18637	22204	101	eyes	eye	NNS
18637	22204	102	by	by	IN
18637	22204	103	the	the	DT
18637	22204	104	use	use	NN
18637	22204	105	of	of	IN
18637	22204	106	drugs	drug	NNS
18637	22204	107	,	,	,
18637	22204	108	who	who	WP
18637	22204	109	are	be	VBP
18637	22204	110	regulated	regulate	VBN
18637	22204	111	under	under	IN
18637	22204	112	a	a	DT
18637	22204	113	different	different	JJ
18637	22204	114	statute	statute	NN
18637	22204	115	,	,	,
18637	22204	116	McNaughton	McNaughton	NNP
18637	22204	117	_	_	NNP
18637	22204	118	v.	v.	IN
18637	22204	119	_	_	NNP
18637	22204	120	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	22204	121	,	,	,
18637	22204	122	242	242	CD
18637	22204	123	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22204	124	344	344	CD
18637	22204	125	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22204	126	1917	1917	CD
18637	22204	127	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22204	128	;	;	:
18637	22204	129	a	a	DT
18637	22204	130	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	22204	131	against	against	IN
18637	22204	132	advertising	advertising	NN
18637	22204	133	by	by	IN
18637	22204	134	dentists	dentist	NNS
18637	22204	135	,	,	,
18637	22204	136	not	not	RB
18637	22204	137	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	22204	138	to	to	IN
18637	22204	139	other	other	JJ
18637	22204	140	professions	profession	NNS
18637	22204	141	,	,	,
18637	22204	142	Semler	Semler	NNP
18637	22204	143	_	_	NNP
18637	22204	144	v.	v.	IN
18637	22204	145	_	_	NNP
18637	22204	146	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	22204	147	State	State	NNP
18637	22204	148	Dental	Dental	NNP
18637	22204	149	Examiners	Examiners	NNPS
18637	22204	150	,	,	,
18637	22204	151	294	294	CD
18637	22204	152	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22204	153	608	608	CD
18637	22204	154	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22204	155	1935	1935	CD
18637	22204	156	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22204	157	.	.	.
18637	22205	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	2	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	22205	3	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	22205	4	:	:	:
18637	22205	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	6	guest	guest	NN
18637	22205	7	passenger	passenger	NN
18637	22205	8	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	22205	9	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	22205	10	to	to	IN
18637	22205	11	automobiles	automobile	NNS
18637	22205	12	but	but	CC
18637	22205	13	not	not	RB
18637	22205	14	to	to	IN
18637	22205	15	other	other	JJ
18637	22205	16	classes	class	NNS
18637	22205	17	of	of	IN
18637	22205	18	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	22205	19	,	,	,
18637	22205	20	Silver	Silver	NNP
18637	22205	21	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	22205	23	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	24	Silver	Silver	NNP
18637	22205	25	,	,	,
18637	22205	26	280	280	CD
18637	22205	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22205	28	117	117	CD
18637	22205	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22205	30	1929	1929	CD
18637	22205	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22205	32	;	;	:
18637	22205	33	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	22205	34	of	of	IN
18637	22205	35	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	22205	36	from	from	IN
18637	22205	37	other	other	JJ
18637	22205	38	States	state	NNS
18637	22205	39	from	from	IN
18637	22205	40	registration	registration	NN
18637	22205	41	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	22205	42	,	,	,
18637	22205	43	Storaasli	Storaasli	NNP
18637	22205	44	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	22205	46	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	47	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	22205	48	,	,	,
18637	22205	49	283	283	CD
18637	22205	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22205	51	57	57	CD
18637	22205	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22205	53	1931	1931	CD
18637	22205	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22205	55	;	;	:
18637	22205	56	classification	classification	NN
18637	22205	57	of	of	IN
18637	22205	58	driverless	driverless	NN
18637	22205	59	automobiles	automobile	NNS
18637	22205	60	for	for	IN
18637	22205	61	hire	hire	NN
18637	22205	62	as	as	IN
18637	22205	63	public	public	JJ
18637	22205	64	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	22205	65	,	,	,
18637	22205	66	which	which	WDT
18637	22205	67	are	be	VBP
18637	22205	68	required	require	VBN
18637	22205	69	to	to	TO
18637	22205	70	procure	procure	VB
18637	22205	71	a	a	DT
18637	22205	72	license	license	NN
18637	22205	73	and	and	CC
18637	22205	74	to	to	TO
18637	22205	75	carry	carry	VB
18637	22205	76	liability	liability	NN
18637	22205	77	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	22205	78	,	,	,
18637	22205	79	Hodge	Hodge	NNP
18637	22205	80	Drive	Drive	NNP
18637	22205	81	-	-	:
18637	22205	82	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22205	83	-	-	HYPH
18637	22205	84	Yourself	Yourself	NNP
18637	22205	85	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22205	86	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	87	v.	v.	IN
18637	22205	88	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	89	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	22205	90	,	,	,
18637	22205	91	284	284	CD
18637	22205	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22205	93	335	335	CD
18637	22205	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22205	95	1932	1932	CD
18637	22205	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22205	97	;	;	:
18637	22205	98	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	22205	99	from	from	IN
18637	22205	100	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	22205	101	on	on	IN
18637	22205	102	hours	hour	NNS
18637	22205	103	of	of	IN
18637	22205	104	labor	labor	NN
18637	22205	105	for	for	IN
18637	22205	106	drivers	driver	NNS
18637	22205	107	of	of	IN
18637	22205	108	motor	motor	NN
18637	22205	109	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	22205	110	of	of	IN
18637	22205	111	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	22205	112	of	of	IN
18637	22205	113	property	property	NN
18637	22205	114	for	for	IN
18637	22205	115	hire	hire	NN
18637	22205	116	,	,	,
18637	22205	117	of	of	IN
18637	22205	118	those	those	DT
18637	22205	119	not	not	RB
18637	22205	120	principally	principally	RB
18637	22205	121	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	22205	122	in	in	IN
18637	22205	123	transport	transport	NN
18637	22205	124	of	of	IN
18637	22205	125	property	property	NN
18637	22205	126	for	for	IN
18637	22205	127	hire	hire	NN
18637	22205	128	,	,	,
18637	22205	129	and	and	CC
18637	22205	130	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	22205	131	operating	operate	VBG
18637	22205	132	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	22205	133	in	in	IN
18637	22205	134	metropolitan	metropolitan	JJ
18637	22205	135	areas	area	NNS
18637	22205	136	,	,	,
18637	22205	137	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	22205	138	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22205	139	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	140	v.	v.	IN
18637	22205	141	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	142	New	New	NNP
18637	22205	143	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	22205	144	,	,	,
18637	22205	145	306	306	CD
18637	22205	146	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22205	147	79	79	CD
18637	22205	148	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22205	149	1939	1939	CD
18637	22205	150	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22205	151	;	;	:
18637	22205	152	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	22205	153	of	of	IN
18637	22205	154	busses	bus	NNS
18637	22205	155	and	and	CC
18637	22205	156	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	22205	157	movements	movement	NNS
18637	22205	158	of	of	IN
18637	22205	159	farm	farm	NN
18637	22205	160	implements	implement	NNS
18637	22205	161	and	and	CC
18637	22205	162	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	22205	163	and	and	CC
18637	22205	164	trucks	truck	NNS
18637	22205	165	making	make	VBG
18637	22205	166	short	short	JJ
18637	22205	167	hauls	haul	NNS
18637	22205	168	from	from	IN
18637	22205	169	common	common	JJ
18637	22205	170	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	22205	171	from	from	IN
18637	22205	172	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	22205	173	in	in	IN
18637	22205	174	net	net	JJ
18637	22205	175	load	load	NN
18637	22205	176	and	and	CC
18637	22205	177	length	length	NN
18637	22205	178	of	of	IN
18637	22205	179	trucks	truck	NNS
18637	22205	180	,	,	,
18637	22205	181	Sproles	Sproles	NNP
18637	22205	182	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	183	v.	v.	IN
18637	22205	184	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	185	Binford	Binford	NNP
18637	22205	186	,	,	,
18637	22205	187	286	286	CD
18637	22205	188	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22205	189	374	374	CD
18637	22205	190	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22205	191	1932	1932	CD
18637	22205	192	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22205	193	;	;	:
18637	22205	194	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	22205	195	against	against	IN
18637	22205	196	operation	operation	NN
18637	22205	197	of	of	IN
18637	22205	198	uncertified	uncertified	JJ
18637	22205	199	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	22205	200	,	,	,
18637	22205	201	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	22205	202	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	203	v.	v.	IN
18637	22205	204	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	205	Public	Public	NNP
18637	22205	206	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	22205	207	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	22205	208	,	,	,
18637	22205	209	289	289	CD
18637	22205	210	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22205	211	92	92	CD
18637	22205	212	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22205	213	1933	1933	CD
18637	22205	214	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22205	215	;	;	:
18637	22205	216	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	22205	217	from	from	IN
18637	22205	218	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	22205	219	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	22205	220	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	22205	221	for	for	IN
18637	22205	222	hire	hire	NN
18637	22205	223	,	,	,
18637	22205	224	of	of	IN
18637	22205	225	persons	person	NNS
18637	22205	226	whose	whose	WP$
18637	22205	227	chief	chief	JJ
18637	22205	228	business	business	NN
18637	22205	229	is	be	VBZ
18637	22205	230	farming	farm	VBG
18637	22205	231	and	and	CC
18637	22205	232	dairying	dairying	NN
18637	22205	233	,	,	,
18637	22205	234	but	but	CC
18637	22205	235	who	who	WP
18637	22205	236	occasionally	occasionally	RB
18637	22205	237	haul	haul	VBP
18637	22205	238	farm	farm	NN
18637	22205	239	and	and	CC
18637	22205	240	dairy	dairy	NN
18637	22205	241	products	product	NNS
18637	22205	242	for	for	IN
18637	22205	243	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	22205	244	,	,	,
18637	22205	245	Hicklin	Hicklin	NNP
18637	22205	246	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	247	v.	v.	IN
18637	22205	248	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	249	Coney	Coney	NNP
18637	22205	250	,	,	,
18637	22205	251	290	290	CD
18637	22205	252	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22205	253	169	169	CD
18637	22205	254	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22205	255	1933	1933	CD
18637	22205	256	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22205	257	;	;	:
18637	22205	258	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	22205	259	of	of	IN
18637	22205	260	private	private	JJ
18637	22205	261	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	22205	262	,	,	,
18637	22205	263	street	street	NN
18637	22205	264	cars	car	NNS
18637	22205	265	and	and	CC
18637	22205	266	omnibuses	omnibus	NNS
18637	22205	267	from	from	IN
18637	22205	268	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	22205	269	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	22205	270	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	22205	271	to	to	IN
18637	22205	272	taxicabs	taxicab	NNS
18637	22205	273	,	,	,
18637	22205	274	Packard	Packard	NNP
18637	22205	275	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	276	v.	v.	IN
18637	22205	277	_	_	NNP
18637	22205	278	Banton	Banton	NNP
18637	22205	279	,	,	,
18637	22205	280	264	264	CD
18637	22205	281	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22205	282	140	140	CD
18637	22205	283	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22205	284	1924	1924	CD
18637	22205	285	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22205	286	.	.	.
18637	22206	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22206	2	Peddlers	Peddlers	NNPS
18637	22206	3	and	and	CC
18637	22206	4	solicitors	solicitor	NNS
18637	22206	5	:	:	:
18637	22206	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22206	7	a	a	DT
18637	22206	8	State	State	NNP
18637	22206	9	may	may	MD
18637	22206	10	classify	classify	VB
18637	22206	11	and	and	CC
18637	22206	12	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	22206	13	itinerant	itinerant	JJ
18637	22206	14	vendors	vendor	NNS
18637	22206	15	and	and	CC
18637	22206	16	peddlers	peddler	NNS
18637	22206	17	,	,	,
18637	22206	18	Emert	Emert	NNP
18637	22206	19	_	_	NNP
18637	22206	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	22206	21	_	_	NNP
18637	22206	22	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22206	23	,	,	,
18637	22206	24	156	156	CD
18637	22206	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22206	26	296	296	CD
18637	22206	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22206	28	1895	1895	CD
18637	22206	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22206	30	;	;	:
18637	22206	31	may	may	MD
18637	22206	32	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	22206	33	the	the	DT
18637	22206	34	sale	sale	NN
18637	22206	35	by	by	IN
18637	22206	36	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22206	37	of	of	IN
18637	22206	38	drugs	drug	NNS
18637	22206	39	and	and	CC
18637	22206	40	medicines	medicine	NNS
18637	22206	41	,	,	,
18637	22206	42	Baccus	Baccus	NNP
18637	22206	43	_	_	NNP
18637	22206	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	22206	45	_	_	NNP
18637	22206	46	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	22206	47	,	,	,
18637	22206	48	232	232	CD
18637	22206	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22206	50	334	334	CD
18637	22206	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22206	52	1914	1914	CD
18637	22206	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22206	54	;	;	:
18637	22206	55	prohibit	prohibit	NN
18637	22206	56	drumming	drum	VBG
18637	22206	57	or	or	CC
18637	22206	58	soliciting	solicit	VBG
18637	22206	59	on	on	IN
18637	22206	60	trains	train	NNS
18637	22206	61	for	for	IN
18637	22206	62	business	business	NN
18637	22206	63	for	for	IN
18637	22206	64	hotels	hotel	NNS
18637	22206	65	,	,	,
18637	22206	66	medical	medical	JJ
18637	22206	67	practitioners	practitioner	NNS
18637	22206	68	,	,	,
18637	22206	69	etc	etc	FW
18637	22206	70	.	.	FW
18637	22206	71	,	,	,
18637	22206	72	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	22206	73	_	_	NNP
18637	22206	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	22206	75	_	_	NNP
18637	22206	76	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	22206	77	,	,	,
18637	22206	78	217	217	CD
18637	22206	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22206	80	79	79	CD
18637	22206	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22206	82	1910	1910	CD
18637	22206	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22206	84	;	;	:
18637	22206	85	or	or	CC
18637	22206	86	solicitation	solicitation	NN
18637	22206	87	of	of	IN
18637	22206	88	employment	employment	NN
18637	22206	89	to	to	TO
18637	22206	90	prosecute	prosecute	VB
18637	22206	91	or	or	CC
18637	22206	92	collect	collect	VB
18637	22206	93	claims	claim	NNS
18637	22206	94	,	,	,
18637	22206	95	McCloskey	McCloskey	NNP
18637	22206	96	_	_	NNP
18637	22206	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	22206	98	_	_	NNP
18637	22206	99	Tobin	Tobin	NNP
18637	22206	100	,	,	,
18637	22206	101	252	252	CD
18637	22206	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22206	103	107	107	CD
18637	22206	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22206	105	1920	1920	CD
18637	22206	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22206	107	.	.	.
18637	22207	1	And	and	CC
18637	22207	2	a	a	DT
18637	22207	3	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	22207	4	may	may	MD
18637	22207	5	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	22207	6	canvassers	canvasser	NNS
18637	22207	7	or	or	CC
18637	22207	8	peddlers	peddler	NNS
18637	22207	9	from	from	IN
18637	22207	10	calling	call	VBG
18637	22207	11	at	at	IN
18637	22207	12	private	private	JJ
18637	22207	13	residences	residence	NNS
18637	22207	14	unless	unless	IN
18637	22207	15	requested	request	VBN
18637	22207	16	or	or	CC
18637	22207	17	invited	invite	VBN
18637	22207	18	by	by	IN
18637	22207	19	the	the	DT
18637	22207	20	occupant	occupant	NN
18637	22207	21	to	to	TO
18637	22207	22	do	do	VB
18637	22207	23	so	so	RB
18637	22207	24	.	.	.
18637	22208	1	Breard	Breard	NNP
18637	22208	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22208	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22208	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22208	5	Alexandria	Alexandria	NNP
18637	22208	6	,	,	,
18637	22208	7	341	341	CD
18637	22208	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22208	9	622	622	CD
18637	22208	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22208	11	1951	1951	CD
18637	22208	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22208	13	.	.	.
18637	22209	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22209	2	Property	Property	NNP
18637	22209	3	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	22209	4	:	:	:
18637	22209	5	_	_	IN
18637	22209	6	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	22209	7	of	of	IN
18637	22209	8	cedar	cedar	NN
18637	22209	9	trees	tree	NNS
18637	22209	10	to	to	TO
18637	22209	11	protect	protect	VB
18637	22209	12	apple	apple	NN
18637	22209	13	orchards	orchard	NNS
18637	22209	14	from	from	IN
18637	22209	15	cedar	cedar	NN
18637	22209	16	rust	rust	NN
18637	22209	17	.	.	.
18637	22210	1	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	22210	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22210	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22210	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22210	5	Schoene	Schoene	NNP
18637	22210	6	,	,	,
18637	22210	7	276	276	CD
18637	22210	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22210	9	272	272	CD
18637	22210	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22210	11	1928	1928	CD
18637	22210	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22210	13	.	.	.
18637	22211	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22211	2	Railroads	Railroads	NNPS
18637	22211	3	:	:	:
18637	22211	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22211	5	forbid	forbid	NN
18637	22211	6	operation	operation	NN
18637	22211	7	on	on	IN
18637	22211	8	a	a	DT
18637	22211	9	certain	certain	JJ
18637	22211	10	street	street	NN
18637	22211	11	,	,	,
18637	22211	12	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	22211	13	,	,	,
18637	22211	14	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22211	15	&	&	CC
18637	22211	16	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	22212	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22212	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22212	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22212	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22212	5	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	22212	6	,	,	,
18637	22212	7	96	96	CD
18637	22212	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22212	9	521	521	CD
18637	22212	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22212	11	1878	1878	CD
18637	22212	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22212	13	;	;	:
18637	22212	14	require	require	VB
18637	22212	15	fences	fence	NNS
18637	22212	16	and	and	CC
18637	22212	17	cattle	cattle	NNS
18637	22212	18	guards	guard	NNS
18637	22212	19	and	and	CC
18637	22212	20	allowed	allow	VBD
18637	22212	21	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	22212	22	of	of	IN
18637	22212	23	multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	22212	24	damages	damage	NNS
18637	22212	25	for	for	IN
18637	22212	26	failure	failure	NN
18637	22212	27	to	to	TO
18637	22212	28	comply	comply	VB
18637	22212	29	,	,	,
18637	22212	30	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22212	31	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	22213	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22213	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22213	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22213	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22213	5	Humes	Humes	NNP
18637	22213	6	,	,	,
18637	22213	7	115	115	CD
18637	22213	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22213	9	512	512	CD
18637	22213	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22213	11	1885	1885	CD
18637	22213	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22213	13	;	;	:
18637	22213	14	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
18637	22213	15	&	&	CC
18637	22213	16	St.	St.	NNP
18637	22213	17	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	22214	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22214	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22214	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22214	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22214	5	Beckwith	Beckwith	NNP
18637	22214	6	,	,	,
18637	22214	7	129	129	CD
18637	22214	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22214	9	26	26	CD
18637	22214	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22214	11	1889	1889	CD
18637	22214	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22214	13	;	;	:
18637	22214	14	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
18637	22214	15	&	&	CC
18637	22214	16	St.	St.	NNP
18637	22214	17	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	22215	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22215	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22215	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22215	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22215	5	Emmons	Emmons	NNP
18637	22215	6	,	,	,
18637	22215	7	149	149	CD
18637	22215	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22215	9	364	364	CD
18637	22215	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22215	11	1893	1893	CD
18637	22215	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22215	13	;	;	:
18637	22215	14	charge	charge	VB
18637	22215	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22215	16	with	with	IN
18637	22215	17	entire	entire	JJ
18637	22215	18	expense	expense	NN
18637	22215	19	of	of	IN
18637	22215	20	altering	alter	VBG
18637	22215	21	a	a	DT
18637	22215	22	grade	grade	NN
18637	22215	23	crossing	crossing	NN
18637	22215	24	,	,	,
18637	22215	25	New	New	NNP
18637	22215	26	York	York	NNP
18637	22215	27	&	&	CC
18637	22215	28	N.E.R.	N.E.R.	NNP
18637	22216	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22216	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22216	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22216	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22216	5	Bristol	Bristol	NNP
18637	22216	6	,	,	,
18637	22216	7	151	151	CD
18637	22216	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22216	9	556	556	CD
18637	22216	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22216	11	1894	1894	CD
18637	22216	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22216	13	;	;	:
18637	22216	14	makes	make	VBZ
18637	22216	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22216	16	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	22216	17	for	for	IN
18637	22216	18	fire	fire	NN
18637	22216	19	communicated	communicate	VBN
18637	22216	20	by	by	IN
18637	22216	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22216	22	engines	engine	NNS
18637	22216	23	,	,	,
18637	22216	24	St.	St.	NNP
18637	22216	25	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	22216	26	&	&	CC
18637	22216	27	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	22217	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22217	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22217	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22217	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22217	5	Mathews	Mathews	NNP
18637	22217	6	,	,	,
18637	22217	7	165	165	CD
18637	22217	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22217	9	1	1	CD
18637	22217	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22217	11	1897	1897	CD
18637	22217	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22217	13	;	;	:
18637	22217	14	requires	require	VBZ
18637	22217	15	cutting	cut	VBG
18637	22217	16	of	of	IN
18637	22217	17	certain	certain	JJ
18637	22217	18	weeds	weed	NNS
18637	22217	19	,	,	,
18637	22217	20	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22217	21	,	,	,
18637	22217	22	K.	K.	NNP
18637	22217	23	&	&	CC
18637	22217	24	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	22218	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22218	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22218	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22218	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22218	5	May	May	NNP
18637	22218	6	,	,	,
18637	22218	7	194	194	CD
18637	22218	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22218	9	267	267	CD
18637	22218	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22218	11	1904	1904	CD
18637	22218	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22218	13	;	;	:
18637	22218	14	create	create	VB
18637	22218	15	a	a	DT
18637	22218	16	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	22218	17	against	against	IN
18637	22218	18	a	a	DT
18637	22218	19	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	22218	20	failing	fail	VBG
18637	22218	21	to	to	TO
18637	22218	22	give	give	VB
18637	22218	23	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
18637	22218	24	warning	warning	NN
18637	22218	25	signals	signal	NNS
18637	22218	26	,	,	,
18637	22218	27	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	22218	28	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	22218	29	Line	Line	NNP
18637	22218	30	R.	R.	NNP
18637	22218	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22218	32	_	_	NNP
18637	22218	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	22218	34	_	_	NNP
18637	22218	35	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	22218	36	,	,	,
18637	22218	37	287	287	CD
18637	22218	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22218	39	502	502	CD
18637	22218	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22218	41	1933	1933	CD
18637	22218	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22218	43	;	;	:
18637	22218	44	require	require	VB
18637	22218	45	use	use	NN
18637	22218	46	of	of	IN
18637	22218	47	locomotive	locomotive	JJ
18637	22218	48	headlights	headlight	NNS
18637	22218	49	of	of	IN
18637	22218	50	a	a	DT
18637	22218	51	specified	specify	VBN
18637	22218	52	form	form	NN
18637	22218	53	and	and	CC
18637	22218	54	power	power	NN
18637	22218	55	,	,	,
18637	22218	56	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	22218	57	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	22218	58	Line	Line	NNP
18637	22218	59	R.	R.	NNP
18637	22218	60	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22218	61	_	_	NNP
18637	22218	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	22218	63	_	_	NNP
18637	22218	64	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	22218	65	,	,	,
18637	22218	66	234	234	CD
18637	22218	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22218	68	280	280	CD
18637	22218	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22218	70	1914	1914	CD
18637	22218	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22218	72	;	;	:
18637	22218	73	make	make	VB
18637	22218	74	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	22218	75	liable	liable	JJ
18637	22218	76	for	for	IN
18637	22218	77	damage	damage	NN
18637	22218	78	caused	cause	VBN
18637	22218	79	by	by	IN
18637	22218	80	operation	operation	NN
18637	22218	81	of	of	IN
18637	22218	82	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22218	83	locomotives	locomotive	NNS
18637	22218	84	,	,	,
18637	22218	85	unless	unless	IN
18637	22218	86	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22218	87	make	make	VBP
18637	22218	88	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22218	89	appear	appear	VB
18637	22218	90	that	that	IN
18637	22218	91	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22218	92	agents	agent	NNS
18637	22218	93	exercised	exercise	VBD
18637	22218	94	all	all	DT
18637	22218	95	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	22218	96	and	and	CC
18637	22218	97	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	22218	98	care	care	NN
18637	22218	99	and	and	CC
18637	22218	100	diligence	diligence	NN
18637	22218	101	,	,	,
18637	22218	102	Seaboard	Seaboard	NNP
18637	22218	103	Air	Air	NNP
18637	22218	104	Line	Line	NNP
18637	22218	105	R.	R.	NNP
18637	22218	106	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22218	107	_	_	NNP
18637	22218	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	22218	109	_	_	NNP
18637	22218	110	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	22218	111	,	,	,
18637	22218	112	287	287	CD
18637	22218	113	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22218	114	86	86	CD
18637	22218	115	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22218	116	1932	1932	CD
18637	22218	117	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22218	118	;	;	:
18637	22218	119	require	require	VB
18637	22218	120	sprinkling	sprinkling	NN
18637	22218	121	of	of	IN
18637	22218	122	streets	street	NNS
18637	22218	123	between	between	IN
18637	22218	124	tracks	track	NNS
18637	22218	125	to	to	TO
18637	22218	126	lay	lay	VB
18637	22218	127	the	the	DT
18637	22218	128	dust	dust	NN
18637	22218	129	,	,	,
18637	22218	130	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	22218	131	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	22218	132	&	&	CC
18637	22218	133	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	22218	134	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22218	135	_	_	NNP
18637	22218	136	v.	v.	IN
18637	22218	137	_	_	NNP
18637	22218	138	Police	Police	NNP
18637	22218	139	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22218	140	,	,	,
18637	22218	141	251	251	CD
18637	22218	142	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22218	143	22	22	CD
18637	22218	144	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22218	145	1919	1919	CD
18637	22218	146	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22218	147	.	.	.
18637	22219	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22219	2	Sales	Sales	NNP
18637	22219	3	in	in	IN
18637	22219	4	bulk	bulk	NN
18637	22219	5	:	:	:
18637	22219	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22219	7	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	22219	8	of	of	IN
18637	22219	9	notice	notice	NN
18637	22219	10	of	of	IN
18637	22219	11	bulk	bulk	JJ
18637	22219	12	sale	sale	NN
18637	22219	13	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	22219	14	only	only	RB
18637	22219	15	to	to	IN
18637	22219	16	retail	retail	JJ
18637	22219	17	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	22219	18	.	.	.
18637	22220	1	Lemieux	Lemieux	NNP
18637	22220	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22220	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22220	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22220	5	Young	Young	NNP
18637	22220	6	,	,	,
18637	22220	7	211	211	CD
18637	22220	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22220	9	489	489	CD
18637	22220	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22220	11	1909	1909	CD
18637	22220	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22220	13	.	.	.
18637	22221	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22221	2	Secret	secret	JJ
18637	22221	3	societies	society	NNS
18637	22221	4	:	:	:
18637	22221	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22221	6	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	22221	7	applied	apply	VBD
18637	22221	8	only	only	RB
18637	22221	9	to	to	IN
18637	22221	10	one	one	CD
18637	22221	11	class	class	NN
18637	22221	12	of	of	IN
18637	22221	13	oath	oath	NN
18637	22221	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	22221	15	bound	bind	VBN
18637	22221	16	associations	association	NNS
18637	22221	17	,	,	,
18637	22221	18	having	have	VBG
18637	22221	19	a	a	DT
18637	22221	20	membership	membership	NN
18637	22221	21	of	of	IN
18637	22221	22	20	20	CD
18637	22221	23	or	or	CC
18637	22221	24	more	more	JJR
18637	22221	25	persons	person	NNS
18637	22221	26	,	,	,
18637	22221	27	where	where	WRB
18637	22221	28	the	the	DT
18637	22221	29	class	class	NN
18637	22221	30	regulated	regulate	VBD
18637	22221	31	has	have	VBZ
18637	22221	32	a	a	DT
18637	22221	33	tendency	tendency	NN
18637	22221	34	to	to	TO
18637	22221	35	make	make	VB
18637	22221	36	the	the	DT
18637	22221	37	secrecy	secrecy	NN
18637	22221	38	of	of	IN
18637	22221	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22221	40	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	22221	41	and	and	CC
18637	22221	42	membership	membership	NN
18637	22221	43	a	a	DT
18637	22221	44	cloak	cloak	NN
18637	22221	45	for	for	IN
18637	22221	46	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	22221	47	inimical	inimical	JJ
18637	22221	48	to	to	IN
18637	22221	49	the	the	DT
18637	22221	50	personal	personal	JJ
18637	22221	51	rights	right	NNS
18637	22221	52	of	of	IN
18637	22221	53	others	other	NNS
18637	22221	54	and	and	CC
18637	22221	55	to	to	IN
18637	22221	56	the	the	DT
18637	22221	57	public	public	JJ
18637	22221	58	welfare	welfare	NN
18637	22221	59	.	.	.
18637	22222	1	New	New	NNP
18637	22222	2	York	York	NNP
18637	22222	3	ex	ex	NN
18637	22222	4	rel	rel	NN
18637	22222	5	.	.	.
18637	22223	1	Bryant	Bryant	NNP
18637	22223	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22223	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22223	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22223	5	Zimmerman	Zimmerman	NNP
18637	22223	6	,	,	,
18637	22223	7	278	278	CD
18637	22223	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22223	9	63	63	CD
18637	22223	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22223	11	1928	1928	CD
18637	22223	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22223	13	.	.	.
18637	22224	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22224	2	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	22224	3	:	:	:
18637	22224	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22224	5	a	a	DT
18637	22224	6	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	22224	7	on	on	IN
18637	22224	8	the	the	DT
18637	22224	9	sale	sale	NN
18637	22224	10	of	of	IN
18637	22224	11	capital	capital	NN
18637	22224	12	stock	stock	NN
18637	22224	13	on	on	IN
18637	22224	14	margin	margin	NN
18637	22224	15	or	or	CC
18637	22224	16	for	for	IN
18637	22224	17	future	future	JJ
18637	22224	18	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	22224	19	which	which	WDT
18637	22224	20	is	be	VBZ
18637	22224	21	not	not	RB
18637	22224	22	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	22224	23	to	to	IN
18637	22224	24	other	other	JJ
18637	22224	25	objects	object	NNS
18637	22224	26	of	of	IN
18637	22224	27	speculation	speculation	NN
18637	22224	28	,	,	,
18637	22224	29	e.g.	e.g.	RB
18637	22224	30	,	,	,
18637	22224	31	cotton	cotton	NN
18637	22224	32	,	,	,
18637	22224	33	grain	grain	NN
18637	22224	34	.	.	.
18637	22225	1	Otis	Otis	NNP
18637	22225	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22225	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22225	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22225	5	Parker	Parker	NNP
18637	22225	6	,	,	,
18637	22225	7	187	187	CD
18637	22225	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22225	9	606	606	CD
18637	22225	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22225	11	1903	1903	CD
18637	22225	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22225	13	.	.	.
18637	22226	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22226	2	Syndicalism	Syndicalism	NNP
18637	22226	3	:	:	:
18637	22226	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22226	5	a	a	DT
18637	22226	6	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	22226	7	syndicalism	syndicalism	NN
18637	22226	8	statute	statute	NN
18637	22226	9	does	do	VBZ
18637	22226	10	not	not	RB
18637	22226	11	deny	deny	VB
18637	22226	12	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22226	13	protection	protection	NN
18637	22226	14	in	in	IN
18637	22226	15	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	22226	16	those	those	DT
18637	22226	17	who	who	WP
18637	22226	18	advocate	advocate	VBP
18637	22226	19	a	a	DT
18637	22226	20	resort	resort	NN
18637	22226	21	to	to	IN
18637	22226	22	violent	violent	JJ
18637	22226	23	and	and	CC
18637	22226	24	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	22226	25	methods	method	NNS
18637	22226	26	as	as	IN
18637	22226	27	a	a	DT
18637	22226	28	means	means	NN
18637	22226	29	of	of	IN
18637	22226	30	changing	change	VBG
18637	22226	31	industrial	industrial	JJ
18637	22226	32	and	and	CC
18637	22226	33	political	political	JJ
18637	22226	34	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	22226	35	while	while	IN
18637	22226	36	not	not	RB
18637	22226	37	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	22226	38	those	those	DT
18637	22226	39	who	who	WP
18637	22226	40	advocate	advocate	VBP
18637	22226	41	resort	resort	NN
18637	22226	42	to	to	IN
18637	22226	43	such	such	JJ
18637	22226	44	methods	method	NNS
18637	22226	45	for	for	IN
18637	22226	46	maintaining	maintain	VBG
18637	22226	47	such	such	JJ
18637	22226	48	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	22226	49	.	.	.
18637	22227	1	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	22227	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22227	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22227	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22227	5	California	California	NNP
18637	22227	6	,	,	,
18637	22227	7	274	274	CD
18637	22227	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22227	9	357	357	CD
18637	22227	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22227	11	1927	1927	CD
18637	22227	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22227	13	.	.	.
18637	22228	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22228	2	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	22228	3	companies	company	NNS
18637	22228	4	:	:	:
18637	22228	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22228	6	a	a	DT
18637	22228	7	statute	statute	NN
18637	22228	8	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	22228	9	stipulation	stipulation	NN
18637	22228	10	against	against	IN
18637	22228	11	liability	liability	NN
18637	22228	12	for	for	IN
18637	22228	13	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	22228	14	in	in	IN
18637	22228	15	the	the	DT
18637	22228	16	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	22228	17	of	of	IN
18637	22228	18	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	22228	19	message	message	NN
18637	22228	20	,	,	,
18637	22228	21	which	which	WDT
18637	22228	22	did	do	VBD
18637	22228	23	not	not	RB
18637	22228	24	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	22228	25	express	express	JJ
18637	22228	26	companies	company	NNS
18637	22228	27	and	and	CC
18637	22228	28	other	other	JJ
18637	22228	29	common	common	JJ
18637	22228	30	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	22228	31	to	to	TO
18637	22228	32	limit	limit	VB
18637	22228	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22228	34	liability	liability	NN
18637	22228	35	by	by	IN
18637	22228	36	contract	contract	NN
18637	22228	37	.	.	.
18637	22229	1	Western	Western	NNP
18637	22229	2	Union	Union	NNP
18637	22229	3	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	22229	4	.	.	.
18637	22230	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22230	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22230	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22230	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22230	5	Commercial	Commercial	NNP
18637	22230	6	Milling	Milling	NNP
18637	22230	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22230	8	,	,	,
18637	22230	9	218	218	CD
18637	22230	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22230	11	406	406	CD
18637	22230	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22230	13	1910	1910	CD
18637	22230	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22230	15	.	.	.
18637	22231	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22231	2	1105	1105	CD
18637	22231	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22231	4	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	22231	5	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	22231	6	Boiler	Boiler	NNP
18637	22231	7	Inspection	Inspection	NNP
18637	22231	8	&	&	CC
18637	22231	9	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	22231	10	.	.	.
18637	22232	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22232	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22232	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22232	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22232	5	Harrison	Harrison	NNP
18637	22232	6	,	,	,
18637	22232	7	301	301	CD
18637	22232	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22232	9	459	459	CD
18637	22232	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22232	11	1937	1937	CD
18637	22232	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22232	13	.	.	.
18637	22233	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22233	2	1106	1106	CD
18637	22233	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22233	4	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	22233	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22233	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22233	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22233	8	Cahoon	Cahoon	NNP
18637	22233	9	,	,	,
18637	22233	10	283	283	CD
18637	22233	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22233	12	553	553	CD
18637	22233	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22233	14	1931	1931	CD
18637	22233	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22233	16	.	.	.
18637	22234	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22234	2	1107	1107	CD
18637	22234	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22234	4	Mayflower	Mayflower	NNP
18637	22234	5	Farms	Farms	NNP
18637	22234	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22234	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22234	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22234	9	Ten	Ten	NNP
18637	22234	10	Eyck	Eyck	NNP
18637	22234	11	,	,	,
18637	22234	12	297	297	CD
18637	22234	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22234	14	266	266	CD
18637	22234	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22234	16	1936	1936	CD
18637	22234	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22234	18	.	.	.
18637	22235	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22235	2	1108	1108	CD
18637	22235	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22235	4	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	22235	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22235	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22235	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22235	8	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	22235	9	,	,	,
18637	22235	10	274	274	CD
18637	22235	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22235	12	200	200	CD
18637	22235	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22235	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	22235	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22235	16	.	.	.
18637	22236	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22236	2	1109	1109	CD
18637	22236	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22236	4	Skinner	Skinner	NNP
18637	22236	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22236	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22236	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22236	8	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	22236	9	,	,	,
18637	22236	10	316	316	CD
18637	22236	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22236	12	535	535	CD
18637	22236	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22236	14	1942	1942	CD
18637	22236	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22236	16	.	.	.
18637	22237	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22237	2	1110	1110	CD
18637	22237	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22237	4	Yick	Yick	NNP
18637	22237	5	Wo	Wo	NNP
18637	22237	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22237	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22237	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22237	9	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	22237	10	,	,	,
18637	22237	11	118	118	CD
18637	22237	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22237	13	356	356	CD
18637	22237	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22237	15	1886	1886	CD
18637	22237	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22237	17	.	.	.
18637	22238	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22238	2	1111	1111	CD
18637	22238	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22238	4	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	22238	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22238	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22238	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22238	8	St.	St.	NNP
18637	22238	9	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	22238	10	,	,	,
18637	22238	11	194	194	CD
18637	22238	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22238	13	361	361	CD
18637	22238	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22238	15	1904	1904	CD
18637	22238	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22238	17	.	.	.
18637	22239	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22239	2	1112	1112	CD
18637	22239	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22239	4	Gorieb	Gorieb	NNP
18637	22239	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22239	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22239	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22239	8	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	22239	9	,	,	,
18637	22239	10	274	274	CD
18637	22239	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22239	12	603	603	CD
18637	22239	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22239	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	22239	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22239	16	.	.	.
18637	22240	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22240	2	1113	1113	CD
18637	22240	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22240	4	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	22240	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22240	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22240	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22240	8	Eureka	Eureka	NNP
18637	22240	9	City	City	NNP
18637	22240	10	,	,	,
18637	22240	11	173	173	CD
18637	22240	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22240	13	32	32	CD
18637	22240	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22240	15	1899	1899	CD
18637	22240	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22240	17	.	.	.
18637	22241	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22241	2	1114	1114	CD
18637	22241	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22241	4	Gundling	Gundling	NNP
18637	22241	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22241	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22241	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22241	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	22241	9	,	,	,
18637	22241	10	177	177	CD
18637	22241	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22241	12	183	183	CD
18637	22241	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22241	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	22241	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22241	16	.	.	.
18637	22242	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22242	2	1115	1115	CD
18637	22242	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22242	4	Kotch	Kotch	NNP
18637	22242	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22242	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22242	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22242	8	Pilot	Pilot	NNP
18637	22242	9	Comm'rs	Comm'rs	NNP
18637	22242	10	.	.	.
18637	22242	11	,	,	,
18637	22242	12	330	330	CD
18637	22242	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22242	14	552	552	CD
18637	22242	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22242	16	1947	1947	CD
18637	22242	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22242	18	.	.	.
18637	22243	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22243	2	1116	1116	CD
18637	22243	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22243	4	Yick	Yick	NNP
18637	22243	5	Wo	Wo	NNP
18637	22243	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22243	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22243	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22243	9	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	22243	10	,	,	,
18637	22243	11	118	118	CD
18637	22243	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22243	13	356	356	CD
18637	22243	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22243	15	1886	1886	CD
18637	22243	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22243	17	.	.	.
18637	22244	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22244	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	22244	3	.	.	.
18637	22244	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22244	5	Hirabayashi	Hirabayashi	NNP
18637	22244	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22244	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22244	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22244	9	United	United	NNP
18637	22244	10	States	States	NNP
18637	22244	11	,	,	,
18637	22244	12	320	320	CD
18637	22244	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22244	14	81	81	CD
18637	22244	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22244	16	1943	1943	CD
18637	22244	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22244	18	,	,	,
18637	22244	19	where	where	WRB
18637	22244	20	the	the	DT
18637	22244	21	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22244	22	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	22244	23	the	the	DT
18637	22244	24	relocation	relocation	NN
18637	22244	25	of	of	IN
18637	22244	26	American	american	JJ
18637	22244	27	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	22244	28	of	of	IN
18637	22244	29	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	22244	30	ancestry	ancestry	NN
18637	22244	31	on	on	IN
18637	22244	32	the	the	DT
18637	22244	33	ground	ground	NN
18637	22244	34	that	that	IN
18637	22244	35	in	in	IN
18637	22244	36	this	this	DT
18637	22244	37	case	case	NN
18637	22244	38	the	the	DT
18637	22244	39	fact	fact	NN
18637	22244	40	of	of	IN
18637	22244	41	origin	origin	NN
18637	22244	42	might	may	MD
18637	22244	43	reasonably	reasonably	RB
18637	22244	44	be	be	VB
18637	22244	45	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	22244	46	to	to	TO
18637	22244	47	have	have	VB
18637	22244	48	some	some	DT
18637	22244	49	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	22244	50	relation	relation	NN
18637	22244	51	to	to	IN
18637	22244	52	national	national	JJ
18637	22244	53	security	security	NN
18637	22244	54	.	.	.
18637	22245	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22245	2	was	be	VBD
18637	22245	3	careful	careful	JJ
18637	22245	4	to	to	TO
18637	22245	5	point	point	VB
18637	22245	6	out	out	RP
18637	22245	7	however	however	RB
18637	22245	8	,	,	,
18637	22245	9	that	that	IN
18637	22245	10	normally	normally	RB
18637	22245	11	distinctions	distinction	NNS
18637	22245	12	based	base	VBN
18637	22245	13	on	on	IN
18637	22245	14	race	race	NN
18637	22245	15	or	or	CC
18637	22245	16	national	national	JJ
18637	22245	17	origin	origin	NN
18637	22245	18	are	be	VBP
18637	22245	19	invidious	invidious	JJ
18637	22245	20	and	and	CC
18637	22245	21	hence	hence	RB
18637	22245	22	void	void	JJ
18637	22245	23	.	.	.
18637	22246	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22246	2	1117	1117	CD
18637	22246	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22246	4	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	22246	5	ex	ex	NNP
18637	22246	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	22246	7	.	.	.
18637	22247	1	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	22247	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22247	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22247	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22247	5	Deckebach	Deckebach	NNP
18637	22247	6	,	,	,
18637	22247	7	274	274	CD
18637	22247	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22247	9	392	392	CD
18637	22247	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22247	11	1927	1927	CD
18637	22247	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22247	13	.	.	.
18637	22248	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22248	2	1118	1118	CD
18637	22248	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22248	4	Patsone	Patsone	NNP
18637	22248	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22248	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22248	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22248	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	22248	9	,	,	,
18637	22248	10	232	232	CD
18637	22248	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22248	12	138	138	CD
18637	22248	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22248	14	1914	1914	CD
18637	22248	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22248	16	.	.	.
18637	22249	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22249	2	1119	1119	CD
18637	22249	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22249	4	Heim	Heim	NNP
18637	22249	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22249	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22249	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22249	8	McCall	McCall	NNP
18637	22249	9	,	,	,
18637	22249	10	239	239	CD
18637	22249	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22249	12	175	175	CD
18637	22249	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22249	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	22249	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22249	16	;	;	:
18637	22249	17	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	22249	18	_	_	NNP
18637	22249	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	22249	20	_	_	NNP
18637	22249	21	New	New	NNP
18637	22249	22	York	York	NNP
18637	22249	23	,	,	,
18637	22249	24	239	239	CD
18637	22249	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22249	26	195	195	CD
18637	22249	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22249	28	1915	1915	CD
18637	22249	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22249	30	.	.	.
18637	22250	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22250	2	1120	1120	CD
18637	22250	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22250	4	Truax	Truax	NNP
18637	22250	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22250	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22250	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22250	8	Raich	Raich	NNP
18637	22250	9	,	,	,
18637	22250	10	239	239	CD
18637	22250	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22250	12	33	33	CD
18637	22250	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22250	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	22250	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22250	16	.	.	.
18637	22251	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22251	2	1121	1121	CD
18637	22251	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22251	4	Takahashi	Takahashi	NNP
18637	22251	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22251	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22251	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22251	8	Fish	Fish	NNP
18637	22251	9	&	&	CC
18637	22251	10	Game	Game	NNP
18637	22251	11	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	22251	12	.	.	NNP
18637	22251	13	,	,	,
18637	22251	14	334	334	CD
18637	22251	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22251	16	410	410	CD
18637	22251	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22251	18	1948	1948	CD
18637	22251	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22251	20	.	.	.
18637	22252	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22252	2	1122	1122	CD
18637	22252	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22252	4	Terrace	Terrace	NNP
18637	22252	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22252	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22252	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22252	8	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	22252	9	,	,	,
18637	22252	10	263	263	CD
18637	22252	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22252	12	197	197	CD
18637	22252	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22252	14	1923	1923	CD
18637	22252	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22252	16	.	.	.
18637	22253	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22253	2	1123	1123	CD
18637	22253	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22253	4	332	332	CD
18637	22253	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22253	6	633	633	CD
18637	22253	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22253	8	1948	1948	CD
18637	22253	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22253	10	.	.	.
18637	22254	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22254	2	1124	1124	CD
18637	22254	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22254	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	22254	5	.	.	.
18637	22255	1	647	647	CD
18637	22255	2	,	,	,
18637	22255	3	650	650	CD
18637	22255	4	.	.	.
18637	22256	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22256	2	1125	1125	CD
18637	22256	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22256	4	Holden	Holden	NNP
18637	22256	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22256	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22256	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22256	8	Hardy	Hardy	NNP
18637	22256	9	,	,	,
18637	22256	10	169	169	CD
18637	22256	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22256	12	366	366	CD
18637	22256	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22256	14	1898	1898	CD
18637	22256	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22256	16	.	.	.
18637	22257	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22257	2	1126	1126	CD
18637	22257	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22257	4	Bunting	Bunting	NNP
18637	22257	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22257	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22257	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22257	8	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	22257	9	,	,	,
18637	22257	10	243	243	CD
18637	22257	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22257	12	426	426	CD
18637	22257	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22257	14	1917	1917	CD
18637	22257	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22257	16	.	.	.
18637	22258	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22258	2	1127	1127	CD
18637	22258	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22258	4	Atkin	Atkin	NNP
18637	22258	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22258	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22258	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22258	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	22258	9	,	,	,
18637	22258	10	191	191	CD
18637	22258	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22258	12	207	207	CD
18637	22258	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22258	14	1903	1903	CD
18637	22258	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22258	16	.	.	.
18637	22259	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22259	2	1128	1128	CD
18637	22259	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22259	4	Keokee	Keokee	NNP
18637	22259	5	Consol	Consol	NNP
18637	22259	6	.	.	.
18637	22260	1	Coke	Coke	NNP
18637	22260	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22260	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22260	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22260	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22260	6	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	22260	7	,	,	,
18637	22260	8	234	234	CD
18637	22260	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22260	10	224	224	CD
18637	22260	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22260	12	1914	1914	CD
18637	22260	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22260	14	;	;	:
18637	22260	15	_	_	NNP
18637	22260	16	see	see	VB
18637	22260	17	also	also	RB
18637	22260	18	_	_	NNP
18637	22260	19	Knoxville	Knoxville	NNP
18637	22260	20	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	22260	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22260	22	_	_	NNP
18637	22260	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	22260	24	_	_	NNP
18637	22260	25	Harbison	Harbison	NNP
18637	22260	26	,	,	,
18637	22260	27	183	183	CD
18637	22260	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22260	29	13	13	CD
18637	22260	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22260	31	1901	1901	CD
18637	22260	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22260	33	.	.	.
18637	22261	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22261	2	1129	1129	CD
18637	22261	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22261	4	McLean	McLean	NNP
18637	22261	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22261	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22261	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22261	8	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	22261	9	,	,	,
18637	22261	10	211	211	CD
18637	22261	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22261	12	539	539	CD
18637	22261	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22261	14	1909	1909	CD
18637	22261	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22261	16	.	.	.
18637	22262	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22262	2	1130	1130	CD
18637	22262	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22262	4	Prudential	Prudential	NNP
18637	22262	5	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	22262	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22262	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22262	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22262	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22262	10	Cheek	Cheek	NNP
18637	22262	11	,	,	,
18637	22262	12	259	259	CD
18637	22262	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22262	14	530	530	CD
18637	22262	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22262	16	1922	1922	CD
18637	22262	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22262	18	.	.	.
18637	22263	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22263	2	1131	1131	CD
18637	22263	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22263	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	22263	5	,	,	,
18637	22263	6	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	22263	7	&	&	CC
18637	22263	8	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	22264	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22264	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22264	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22264	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22264	5	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	22264	6	,	,	,
18637	22264	7	259	259	CD
18637	22264	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22264	9	548	548	CD
18637	22264	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22264	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	22264	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22264	13	.	.	.
18637	22265	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22265	2	1132	1132	CD
18637	22265	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22265	4	Mountain	Mountain	NNP
18637	22265	5	Timber	Timber	NNP
18637	22265	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22265	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22265	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22265	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22265	10	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	22265	11	,	,	,
18637	22265	12	243	243	CD
18637	22265	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22265	14	219	219	CD
18637	22265	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22265	16	1917	1917	CD
18637	22265	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22265	18	.	.	.
18637	22266	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22266	2	1133	1133	CD
18637	22266	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22266	4	New	New	NNP
18637	22266	5	York	York	NNP
18637	22266	6	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	22267	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22267	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22267	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22267	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22267	5	White	White	NNP
18637	22267	6	,	,	,
18637	22267	7	243	243	CD
18637	22267	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22267	9	188	188	CD
18637	22267	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22267	11	1917	1917	CD
18637	22267	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22267	13	;	;	:
18637	22267	14	Middleton	Middleton	NNP
18637	22267	15	_	_	NNP
18637	22267	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	22267	17	_	_	NNP
18637	22267	18	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	22267	19	Power	Power	NNP
18637	22267	20	&	&	CC
18637	22267	21	Light	Light	NNP
18637	22267	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22267	23	,	,	,
18637	22267	24	249	249	CD
18637	22267	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22267	26	152	152	CD
18637	22267	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22267	28	1919	1919	CD
18637	22267	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22267	30	;	;	:
18637	22267	31	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	22267	32	&	&	CC
18637	22267	33	Gow	Gow	NNP
18637	22267	34	_	_	NNP
18637	22267	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	22267	36	_	_	NNP
18637	22267	37	Krinsky	Krinsky	NNP
18637	22267	38	,	,	,
18637	22267	39	259	259	CD
18637	22267	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22267	41	503	503	CD
18637	22267	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22267	43	1922	1922	CD
18637	22267	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22267	45	.	.	.
18637	22268	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22268	2	1134	1134	CD
18637	22268	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22268	4	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	22268	5	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	22268	6	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	22268	7	Union	Union	NNP
18637	22268	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22268	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22268	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22268	11	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	22268	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22268	13	,	,	,
18637	22268	14	335	335	CD
18637	22268	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22268	16	525	525	CD
18637	22268	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22268	18	1949	1949	CD
18637	22268	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22268	20	.	.	.
18637	22269	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22269	2	1135	1135	CD
18637	22269	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22269	4	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	22269	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22269	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22269	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22269	8	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	22269	9	,	,	,
18637	22269	10	236	236	CD
18637	22269	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22269	12	373	373	CD
18637	22269	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22269	14	1915	1915	CD
18637	22269	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22269	16	;	;	:
18637	22269	17	Bosley	Bosley	NNP
18637	22269	18	_	_	NNP
18637	22269	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	22269	20	_	_	NNP
18637	22269	21	McLaughlin	McLaughlin	NNP
18637	22269	22	,	,	,
18637	22269	23	236	236	CD
18637	22269	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22269	25	385	385	CD
18637	22269	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22269	27	1915	1915	CD
18637	22269	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22269	29	.	.	.
18637	22270	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22270	2	1136	1136	CD
18637	22270	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22270	4	Muller	Muller	NNP
18637	22270	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22270	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22270	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22270	8	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	22270	9	,	,	,
18637	22270	10	208	208	CD
18637	22270	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22270	12	412	412	CD
18637	22270	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22270	14	1908	1908	CD
18637	22270	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22270	16	.	.	.
18637	22271	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22271	2	1137	1137	CD
18637	22271	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22271	4	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	22271	5	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	22271	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22271	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22271	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22271	9	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	22271	10	,	,	,
18637	22271	11	249	249	CD
18637	22271	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22271	13	265	265	CD
18637	22271	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22271	15	1919	1919	CD
18637	22271	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22271	17	.	.	.
18637	22272	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22272	2	1138	1138	CD
18637	22272	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22272	4	Radice	Radice	NNP
18637	22272	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22272	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22272	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22272	8	New	New	NNP
18637	22272	9	York	York	NNP
18637	22272	10	,	,	,
18637	22272	11	264	264	CD
18637	22272	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22272	13	292	292	CD
18637	22272	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22272	15	1924	1924	CD
18637	22272	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22272	17	.	.	.
18637	22273	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22273	2	1139	1139	CD
18637	22273	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22273	4	West	West	NNP
18637	22273	5	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	22273	6	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	22273	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22273	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22273	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22273	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22273	11	Parrish	Parrish	NNP
18637	22273	12	,	,	,
18637	22273	13	300	300	CD
18637	22273	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22273	15	379	379	CD
18637	22273	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22273	17	1937	1937	CD
18637	22273	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22273	19	;	;	:
18637	22273	20	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	22273	21	Adkins	Adkins	NNP
18637	22273	22	_	_	NNP
18637	22273	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	22273	24	_	_	NNP
18637	22273	25	Children	Children	NNP
18637	22273	26	's	's	POS
18637	22273	27	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	22273	28	,	,	,
18637	22273	29	261	261	CD
18637	22273	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22273	31	525	525	CD
18637	22273	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22273	33	1923	1923	CD
18637	22273	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22273	35	;	;	:
18637	22273	36	and	and	CC
18637	22273	37	Morehead	Morehead	NNP
18637	22273	38	_	_	NNP
18637	22273	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	22273	40	_	_	NNP
18637	22273	41	Tipaldo	Tipaldo	NNP
18637	22273	42	,	,	,
18637	22273	43	298	298	CD
18637	22273	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22273	45	587	587	CD
18637	22273	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22273	47	1936	1936	CD
18637	22273	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22273	49	.	.	.
18637	22274	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22274	2	1140	1140	CD
18637	22274	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22274	4	Goesaert	Goesaert	NNP
18637	22274	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22274	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22274	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22274	8	Cleary	Cleary	NNP
18637	22274	9	,	,	,
18637	22274	10	335	335	CD
18637	22274	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22274	12	464	464	CD
18637	22274	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22274	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	22274	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22274	16	.	.	.
18637	22275	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22275	2	1141	1141	CD
18637	22275	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22275	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	22275	5	.	.	.
18637	22276	1	466	466	CD
18637	22276	2	.	.	.
18637	22277	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22277	2	1142	1142	CD
18637	22277	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22277	4	Mallinckrodt	Mallinckrodt	NNP
18637	22277	5	Chemical	Chemical	NNP
18637	22277	6	Works	Works	NNPS
18637	22277	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22277	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22277	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22277	10	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22277	11	ex	ex	NNP
18637	22277	12	rel	rel	NN
18637	22277	13	.	.	.
18637	22278	1	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	22278	2	,	,	,
18637	22278	3	238	238	CD
18637	22278	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22278	5	41	41	CD
18637	22278	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22278	7	1915	1915	CD
18637	22278	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22278	9	.	.	.
18637	22279	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22279	2	1143	1143	CD
18637	22279	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22279	4	International	International	NNP
18637	22279	5	Harvester	Harvester	NNP
18637	22279	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22279	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22279	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22279	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22279	10	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22279	11	ex	ex	NNP
18637	22279	12	rel	rel	NN
18637	22279	13	.	.	.
18637	22280	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	22280	2	.	.	.
18637	22281	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	22281	2	,	,	,
18637	22281	3	234	234	CD
18637	22281	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22281	5	199	199	CD
18637	22281	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22281	7	1914	1914	CD
18637	22281	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22281	9	.	.	.
18637	22282	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22282	2	1144	1144	CD
18637	22282	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22282	4	Tigner	Tigner	NNP
18637	22282	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22282	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22282	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22282	8	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	22282	9	,	,	,
18637	22282	10	310	310	CD
18637	22282	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22282	12	141	141	CD
18637	22282	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22282	14	1940	1940	CD
18637	22282	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22282	16	,	,	,
18637	22282	17	overruling	overrule	VBG
18637	22282	18	Connolly	Connolly	NNP
18637	22282	19	_	_	NNP
18637	22282	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	22282	21	_	_	NNP
18637	22282	22	Union	Union	NNP
18637	22282	23	Sewer	Sewer	NNP
18637	22282	24	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	22282	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22282	26	,	,	,
18637	22282	27	184	184	CD
18637	22282	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22282	29	540	540	CD
18637	22282	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22282	31	1902	1902	CD
18637	22282	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22282	33	.	.	.
18637	22283	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22283	2	1145	1145	CD
18637	22283	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22283	4	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	22283	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	22283	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22283	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22283	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22283	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22283	10	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	22283	11	ex	ex	NNP
18637	22283	12	rel	rel	NN
18637	22283	13	.	.	.
18637	22284	1	Cates	cate	NNS
18637	22284	2	,	,	,
18637	22284	3	217	217	CD
18637	22284	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22284	5	413	413	CD
18637	22284	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22284	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	22284	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22284	9	.	.	.
18637	22285	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22285	2	1146	1146	CD
18637	22285	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22285	4	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	22285	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22285	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22285	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22285	8	Greenwich	Greenwich	NNP
18637	22285	9	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	22285	10	.	.	.
18637	22286	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22286	2	,	,	,
18637	22286	3	199	199	CD
18637	22286	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22286	5	401	401	CD
18637	22286	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22286	7	1905	1905	CD
18637	22286	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22286	9	.	.	.
18637	22287	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22287	2	1147	1147	CD
18637	22287	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22287	4	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	22287	5	States	States	NNP
18637	22287	6	Box	Box	NNP
18637	22287	7	&	&	CC
18637	22287	8	Basket	Basket	NNP
18637	22287	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22287	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22287	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	22287	12	_	_	NNP
18637	22287	13	White	White	NNP
18637	22287	14	,	,	,
18637	22287	15	296	296	CD
18637	22287	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22287	17	176	176	CD
18637	22287	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22287	19	1935	1935	CD
18637	22287	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22287	21	.	.	.
18637	22288	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22288	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22288	3	also	also	RB
18637	22288	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22288	5	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	22288	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	22288	7	House	House	NNP
18637	22288	8	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	22288	9	,	,	,
18637	22288	10	16	16	CD
18637	22288	11	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	22288	12	.	.	.
18637	22289	1	36	36	CD
18637	22289	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22289	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	22289	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22289	5	;	;	:
18637	22289	6	Nebbia	Nebbia	NNP
18637	22289	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22289	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22289	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22289	10	New	New	NNP
18637	22289	11	York	York	NNP
18637	22289	12	,	,	,
18637	22289	13	291	291	CD
18637	22289	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22289	15	502	502	CD
18637	22289	16	,	,	,
18637	22289	17	529	529	CD
18637	22289	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22289	19	1934	1934	CD
18637	22289	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22289	21	.	.	.
18637	22290	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22290	2	1148	1148	CD
18637	22290	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22290	4	Pace	Pace	NNP
18637	22290	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22290	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22290	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22290	8	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	22290	9	,	,	,
18637	22290	10	106	106	CD
18637	22290	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22290	12	583	583	CD
18637	22290	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22290	14	1883	1883	CD
18637	22290	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22290	16	.	.	.
18637	22291	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22291	2	1149	1149	CD
18637	22291	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22291	4	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	22291	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22291	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22291	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22291	8	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	22291	9	,	,	,
18637	22291	10	237	237	CD
18637	22291	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22291	12	502	502	CD
18637	22291	13	,	,	,
18637	22291	14	510	510	CD
18637	22291	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22291	16	1915	1915	CD
18637	22291	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22291	18	;	;	:
18637	22291	19	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	22291	20	ex	ex	NNP
18637	22291	21	rel	rel	NN
18637	22291	22	.	.	.
18637	22292	1	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
18637	22292	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22292	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22292	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22292	5	Ashe	Ashe	NNP
18637	22292	6	,	,	,
18637	22292	7	302	302	CD
18637	22292	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22292	9	51	51	CD
18637	22292	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22292	11	1937	1937	CD
18637	22292	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22292	13	.	.	.
18637	22293	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22293	2	1150	1150	CD
18637	22293	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22293	4	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	22293	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22293	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22293	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22293	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	22293	9	,	,	,
18637	22293	10	180	180	CD
18637	22293	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22293	12	311	311	CD
18637	22293	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22293	14	1901	1901	CD
18637	22293	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22293	16	.	.	.
18637	22294	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22294	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22294	3	also	also	RB
18637	22294	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22294	5	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	22294	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22294	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22294	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22294	9	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22294	10	,	,	,
18637	22294	11	159	159	CD
18637	22294	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22294	13	673	673	CD
18637	22294	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22294	15	1895	1895	CD
18637	22294	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22294	17	;	;	:
18637	22294	18	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	22294	19	_	_	NNP
18637	22294	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	22294	21	_	_	NNP
18637	22294	22	West	West	NNP
18637	22294	23	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	22294	24	,	,	,
18637	22294	25	224	224	CD
18637	22294	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22294	27	616	616	CD
18637	22294	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22294	29	1912	1912	CD
18637	22294	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22294	31	.	.	.
18637	22295	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22295	2	1151	1151	CD
18637	22295	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22295	4	Carlesi	Carlesi	NNP
18637	22295	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22295	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22295	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22295	8	New	New	NNP
18637	22295	9	York	York	NNP
18637	22295	10	,	,	,
18637	22295	11	233	233	CD
18637	22295	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22295	13	51	51	CD
18637	22295	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22295	15	1914	1914	CD
18637	22295	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22295	17	.	.	.
18637	22296	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22296	2	1152	1152	CD
18637	22296	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22296	4	Ughbanks	Ughbanks	NNP
18637	22296	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22296	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22296	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22296	8	Armstrong	Armstrong	NNP
18637	22296	9	,	,	,
18637	22296	10	208	208	CD
18637	22296	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22296	12	481	481	CD
18637	22296	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22296	14	1908	1908	CD
18637	22296	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22296	16	.	.	.
18637	22297	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22297	2	1153	1153	CD
18637	22297	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22297	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	22297	5	ex	ex	NNP
18637	22297	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	22297	7	.	.	.
18637	22298	1	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
18637	22298	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22298	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22298	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22298	5	Ashe	Ashe	NNP
18637	22298	6	,	,	,
18637	22298	7	302	302	CD
18637	22298	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22298	9	51	51	CD
18637	22298	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22298	11	1937	1937	CD
18637	22298	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22298	13	.	.	.
18637	22299	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22299	2	1154	1154	CD
18637	22299	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22299	4	Finley	Finley	NNP
18637	22299	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22299	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22299	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22299	8	California	California	NNP
18637	22299	9	,	,	,
18637	22299	10	222	222	CD
18637	22299	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22299	12	28	28	CD
18637	22299	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22299	14	1911	1911	CD
18637	22299	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22299	16	.	.	.
18637	22300	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22300	2	1155	1155	CD
18637	22300	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22300	4	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	22300	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22300	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22300	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22300	8	Probate	Probate	NNP
18637	22300	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22300	10	,	,	,
18637	22300	11	309	309	CD
18637	22300	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22300	13	270	270	CD
18637	22300	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22300	15	1940	1940	CD
18637	22300	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22300	17	.	.	.
18637	22301	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22301	2	1156	1156	CD
18637	22301	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22301	4	Pace	Pace	NNP
18637	22301	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22301	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22301	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22301	8	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	22301	9	,	,	,
18637	22301	10	106	106	CD
18637	22301	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22301	12	583	583	CD
18637	22301	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22301	14	1883	1883	CD
18637	22301	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22301	16	.	.	.
18637	22302	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22302	2	1157	1157	CD
18637	22302	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22302	4	Francis	Francis	NNP
18637	22302	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22302	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22302	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22302	8	Resweber	Resweber	NNP
18637	22302	9	,	,	,
18637	22302	10	329	329	CD
18637	22302	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22302	12	459	459	CD
18637	22302	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22302	14	1947	1947	CD
18637	22302	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22302	16	.	.	.
18637	22303	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22303	2	1158	1158	CD
18637	22303	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22303	4	Skinner	Skinner	NNP
18637	22303	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22303	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22303	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22303	8	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	22303	9	,	,	,
18637	22303	10	316	316	CD
18637	22303	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22303	12	535	535	CD
18637	22303	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22303	14	1942	1942	CD
18637	22303	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22303	16	.	.	.
18637	22304	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22304	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	22304	3	.	.	.
18637	22304	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22304	5	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	22304	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22304	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22304	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22304	9	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	22304	10	,	,	,
18637	22304	11	274	274	CD
18637	22304	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22304	13	200	200	CD
18637	22304	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22304	15	1927	1927	CD
18637	22304	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22304	17	.	.	.
18637	22305	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22305	2	Sterilization	sterilization	NN
18637	22305	3	of	of	IN
18637	22305	4	defectives	defective	NNS
18637	22305	5	.	.	.
18637	22305	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22306	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22306	2	1159	1159	CD
18637	22306	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22306	4	Buchanan	Buchanan	NNP
18637	22306	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22306	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22306	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22306	8	Warley	Warley	NNP
18637	22306	9	,	,	,
18637	22306	10	245	245	CD
18637	22306	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22306	12	60	60	CD
18637	22306	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22306	14	1917	1917	CD
18637	22306	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22306	16	.	.	.
18637	22307	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22307	2	1160	1160	CD
18637	22307	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22307	4	Corrigan	Corrigan	NNP
18637	22307	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22307	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22307	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22307	8	Buckley	Buckley	NNP
18637	22307	9	,	,	,
18637	22307	10	271	271	CD
18637	22307	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22307	12	323	323	CD
18637	22307	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22307	14	1926	1926	CD
18637	22307	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22307	16	.	.	.
18637	22308	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22308	2	1161	1161	CD
18637	22308	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22308	4	Shelley	Shelley	NNP
18637	22308	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22308	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22308	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22308	8	Kraemer	Kraemer	NNP
18637	22308	9	,	,	,
18637	22308	10	334	334	CD
18637	22308	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22308	12	1	1	CD
18637	22308	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22308	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	22308	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22308	16	.	.	.
18637	22309	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22309	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	22309	3	.	.	.
18637	22309	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22309	5	Hurd	Hurd	NNP
18637	22309	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22309	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22309	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22309	9	Hodge	Hodge	NNP
18637	22309	10	,	,	,
18637	22309	11	334	334	CD
18637	22309	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22309	13	24	24	CD
18637	22309	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22309	15	1948	1948	CD
18637	22309	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22309	17	,	,	,
18637	22309	18	where	where	WRB
18637	22309	19	the	the	DT
18637	22309	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22309	21	held	hold	VBD
18637	22309	22	that	that	IN
18637	22309	23	a	a	DT
18637	22309	24	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	22309	25	covenant	covenant	NN
18637	22309	26	was	be	VBD
18637	22309	27	unenforceable	unenforceable	JJ
18637	22309	28	in	in	IN
18637	22309	29	the	the	DT
18637	22309	30	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	22309	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22309	32	of	of	IN
18637	22309	33	the	the	DT
18637	22309	34	District	District	NNP
18637	22309	35	of	of	IN
18637	22309	36	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	22309	37	for	for	IN
18637	22309	38	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	22309	39	of	of	IN
18637	22309	40	public	public	JJ
18637	22309	41	policy	policy	NN
18637	22309	42	.	.	.
18637	22310	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22310	2	1162	1162	CD
18637	22310	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22310	4	Plessy	Plessy	NNP
18637	22310	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22310	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22310	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22310	8	Ferguson	Ferguson	NNP
18637	22310	9	,	,	,
18637	22310	10	163	163	CD
18637	22310	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22310	12	537	537	CD
18637	22310	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22310	14	1896	1896	CD
18637	22310	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22310	16	.	.	.
18637	22311	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22311	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	22311	3	.	.	.
18637	22311	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22311	5	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	22311	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22311	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22311	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22311	9	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	22311	10	,	,	,
18637	22311	11	328	328	CD
18637	22311	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22311	13	373	373	CD
18637	22311	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22311	15	1946	1946	CD
18637	22311	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22311	17	,	,	,
18637	22311	18	where	where	WRB
18637	22311	19	a	a	DT
18637	22311	20	State	state	NN
18637	22311	21	statute	statute	NN
18637	22311	22	requiring	require	VBG
18637	22311	23	segregation	segregation	NN
18637	22311	24	of	of	IN
18637	22311	25	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	22311	26	on	on	IN
18637	22311	27	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	22311	28	journeys	journey	NNS
18637	22311	29	was	be	VBD
18637	22311	30	held	hold	VBN
18637	22311	31	to	to	TO
18637	22311	32	be	be	VB
18637	22311	33	an	an	DT
18637	22311	34	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	22311	35	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	22311	36	on	on	IN
18637	22311	37	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	22311	38	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	22311	39	.	.	.
18637	22312	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22312	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22312	3	also	also	RB
18637	22312	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22312	5	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	22312	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22312	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22312	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22312	9	De	De	NNP
18637	22312	10	Cuir	Cuir	NNP
18637	22312	11	,	,	,
18637	22312	12	95	95	CD
18637	22312	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22312	14	485	485	CD
18637	22312	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22312	16	1878	1878	CD
18637	22312	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22312	18	,	,	,
18637	22312	19	where	where	WRB
18637	22312	20	a	a	DT
18637	22312	21	State	State	NNP
18637	22312	22	law	law	NN
18637	22312	23	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	22312	24	steamboats	steamboat	NNS
18637	22312	25	on	on	IN
18637	22312	26	the	the	DT
18637	22312	27	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	22312	28	to	to	TO
18637	22312	29	segregate	segregate	VB
18637	22312	30	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	22312	31	according	accord	VBG
18637	22312	32	to	to	IN
18637	22312	33	race	race	NN
18637	22312	34	was	be	VBD
18637	22312	35	held	hold	VBN
18637	22312	36	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	22312	37	under	under	IN
18637	22312	38	the	the	DT
18637	22312	39	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	22312	40	clause	clause	NN
18637	22312	41	,	,	,
18637	22312	42	and	and	CC
18637	22312	43	Bob	Bob	NNP
18637	22312	44	-	-	HYPH
18637	22312	45	Lo	Lo	NNP
18637	22312	46	Excursion	Excursion	NNP
18637	22312	47	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22312	48	_	_	NNP
18637	22312	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	22312	50	_	_	NNP
18637	22312	51	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	22312	52	,	,	,
18637	22312	53	333	333	CD
18637	22312	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22312	55	28	28	CD
18637	22312	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22312	57	1948	1948	CD
18637	22312	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22312	59	,	,	,
18637	22312	60	where	where	WRB
18637	22312	61	a	a	DT
18637	22312	62	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	22312	63	statute	statute	NN
18637	22312	64	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	22312	65	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	22312	66	was	be	VBD
18637	22312	67	held	hold	VBN
18637	22312	68	valid	valid	JJ
18637	22312	69	as	as	IN
18637	22312	70	applied	apply	VBN
18637	22312	71	to	to	IN
18637	22312	72	an	an	DT
18637	22312	73	excursion	excursion	NN
18637	22312	74	boat	boat	NN
18637	22312	75	operating	operate	VBG
18637	22312	76	on	on	IN
18637	22312	77	the	the	DT
18637	22312	78	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	22312	79	River	River	NNP
18637	22312	80	;	;	:
18637	22312	81	and	and	CC
18637	22312	82	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	22312	83	_	_	NNP
18637	22312	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	22312	85	_	_	NNP
18637	22312	86	United	United	NNP
18637	22312	87	States	States	NNP
18637	22312	88	,	,	,
18637	22312	89	339	339	CD
18637	22312	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22312	91	816	816	CD
18637	22312	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22312	93	1950	1950	CD
18637	22312	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22312	95	,	,	,
18637	22312	96	where	where	WRB
18637	22312	97	segregation	segregation	NN
18637	22312	98	in	in	IN
18637	22312	99	a	a	DT
18637	22312	100	dining	dining	NN
18637	22312	101	car	car	NN
18637	22312	102	operated	operate	VBN
18637	22312	103	by	by	IN
18637	22312	104	an	an	DT
18637	22312	105	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	22312	106	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	22312	107	was	be	VBD
18637	22312	108	held	hold	VBN
18637	22312	109	to	to	TO
18637	22312	110	violate	violate	VB
18637	22312	111	a	a	DT
18637	22312	112	federal	federal	JJ
18637	22312	113	statute	statute	NN
18637	22312	114	.	.	.
18637	22313	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22313	2	1163	1163	CD
18637	22313	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22313	4	McCabe	McCabe	NNP
18637	22313	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22313	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22313	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22313	8	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	22313	9	,	,	,
18637	22313	10	T.	T.	NNP
18637	22313	11	&	&	CC
18637	22313	12	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	22314	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22314	2	,	,	,
18637	22314	3	235	235	CD
18637	22314	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22314	5	151	151	CD
18637	22314	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22314	7	1914	1914	CD
18637	22314	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22314	9	.	.	.
18637	22315	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22315	2	1164	1164	CD
18637	22315	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22315	4	Cumming	Cumming	NNP
18637	22315	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22315	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22315	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22315	8	County	County	NNP
18637	22315	9	Board	Board	NNP
18637	22315	10	of	of	IN
18637	22315	11	Education	Education	NNP
18637	22315	12	,	,	,
18637	22315	13	175	175	CD
18637	22315	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22315	15	528	528	CD
18637	22315	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22315	17	1899	1899	CD
18637	22315	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22315	19	.	.	.
18637	22316	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22316	2	1165	1165	CD
18637	22316	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22316	4	Gong	Gong	NNP
18637	22316	5	Lum	Lum	NNP
18637	22316	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22316	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22316	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22316	9	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	22316	10	,	,	,
18637	22316	11	275	275	CD
18637	22316	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22316	13	78	78	CD
18637	22316	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22316	15	1927	1927	CD
18637	22316	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22316	17	.	.	.
18637	22317	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22317	2	1166	1166	CD
18637	22317	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22317	4	305	305	CD
18637	22317	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22317	6	337	337	CD
18637	22317	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22317	8	1938	1938	CD
18637	22317	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22317	10	.	.	.
18637	22318	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22318	2	1167	1167	CD
18637	22318	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22318	4	Sipuel	Sipuel	NNP
18637	22318	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22318	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22318	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22318	8	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	22318	9	,	,	,
18637	22318	10	332	332	CD
18637	22318	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22318	12	631	631	CD
18637	22318	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22318	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	22318	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22318	16	.	.	.
18637	22319	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22319	2	1168	1168	CD
18637	22319	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22319	4	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	22319	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22319	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22319	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22319	8	Hurst	Hurst	NNP
18637	22319	9	,	,	,
18637	22319	10	333	333	CD
18637	22319	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22319	12	147	147	CD
18637	22319	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22319	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	22319	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22319	16	.	.	.
18637	22320	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22320	2	1169	1169	CD
18637	22320	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22320	4	339	339	CD
18637	22320	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22320	6	629	629	CD
18637	22320	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22320	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	22320	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22320	10	.	.	.
18637	22321	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22321	2	1170	1170	CD
18637	22321	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22321	4	339	339	CD
18637	22321	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22321	6	637	637	CD
18637	22321	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22321	8	1950	1950	CD
18637	22321	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22321	10	.	.	.
18637	22322	1	The	the	DT
18637	22322	2	"	"	``
18637	22322	3	Separate	separate	JJ
18637	22322	4	but	but	CC
18637	22322	5	Equal	equal	JJ
18637	22322	6	"	"	''
18637	22322	7	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	22322	8	took	take	VBD
18637	22322	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22322	10	rise	rise	NN
18637	22322	11	in	in	IN
18637	22322	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	22322	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22322	14	Shaw	Shaw	NNP
18637	22322	15	's	's	POS
18637	22322	16	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	22322	17	in	in	IN
18637	22322	18	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	22322	19	_	_	NNP
18637	22322	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	22322	21	_	_	NNP
18637	22322	22	City	City	NNP
18637	22322	23	of	of	IN
18637	22322	24	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	22322	25	,	,	,
18637	22322	26	59	59	CD
18637	22322	27	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	22323	1	198	198	CD
18637	22323	2	,	,	,
18637	22323	3	200	200	CD
18637	22323	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22323	5	1849	1849	CD
18637	22323	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22323	7	,	,	,
18637	22323	8	for	for	IN
18637	22323	9	an	an	DT
18637	22323	10	excellent	excellent	JJ
18637	22323	11	account	account	NN
18637	22323	12	of	of	IN
18637	22323	13	which	which	WDT
18637	22323	14	_	_	NNP
18637	22323	15	see	see	VBP
18637	22323	16	_	_	NNP
18637	22323	17	the	the	DT
18637	22323	18	article	article	NN
18637	22323	19	by	by	IN
18637	22323	20	Leonard	Leonard	NNP
18637	22323	21	W.	W.	NNP
18637	22323	22	Levy	Levy	NNP
18637	22323	23	and	and	CC
18637	22323	24	Harlan	Harlan	NNP
18637	22323	25	B.	B.	NNP
18637	22323	26	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	22323	27	in	in	IN
18637	22323	28	56	56	CD
18637	22323	29	American	American	NNP
18637	22323	30	Historical	Historical	NNP
18637	22323	31	Review	Review	NNP
18637	22323	32	,	,	,
18637	22323	33	510	510	CD
18637	22323	34	-	-	SYM
18637	22323	35	518	518	CD
18637	22323	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22323	37	April	April	NNP
18637	22323	38	,	,	,
18637	22323	39	1951	1951	CD
18637	22323	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22323	41	.	.	.
18637	22324	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22324	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22324	3	also	also	RB
18637	22324	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22324	5	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	22324	6	Danforth	Danforth	NNP
18637	22324	7	's	's	POS
18637	22324	8	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	22324	9	in	in	IN
18637	22324	10	Gallagher	Gallagher	NNP
18637	22324	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22324	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	22324	13	_	_	NNP
18637	22324	14	King	King	NNP
18637	22324	15	,	,	,
18637	22324	16	93	93	CD
18637	22324	17	N.Y.	New York	NNP
18637	22324	18	438	438	CD
18637	22324	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22324	20	1883	1883	CD
18637	22324	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22324	22	.	.	.
18637	22325	1	In	in	IN
18637	22325	2	a	a	DT
18637	22325	3	case	case	NN
18637	22325	4	in	in	IN
18637	22325	5	which	which	WDT
18637	22325	6	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	22325	7	children	child	NNS
18637	22325	8	brought	bring	VBD
18637	22325	9	a	a	DT
18637	22325	10	suit	suit	NN
18637	22325	11	in	in	IN
18637	22325	12	the	the	DT
18637	22325	13	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	22325	14	District	District	NNP
18637	22325	15	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22325	16	for	for	IN
18637	22325	17	the	the	DT
18637	22325	18	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	22325	19	District	District	NNP
18637	22325	20	of	of	IN
18637	22325	21	South	South	NNP
18637	22325	22	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	22325	23	,	,	,
18637	22325	24	to	to	TO
18637	22325	25	enjoin	enjoin	VB
18637	22325	26	certain	certain	JJ
18637	22325	27	school	school	NN
18637	22325	28	officials	official	NNS
18637	22325	29	from	from	IN
18637	22325	30	making	make	VBG
18637	22325	31	any	any	DT
18637	22325	32	distinctions	distinction	NNS
18637	22325	33	based	base	VBN
18637	22325	34	upon	upon	IN
18637	22325	35	race	race	NN
18637	22325	36	or	or	CC
18637	22325	37	color	color	NN
18637	22325	38	in	in	IN
18637	22325	39	providing	provide	VBG
18637	22325	40	educational	educational	JJ
18637	22325	41	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	22325	42	,	,	,
18637	22325	43	the	the	DT
18637	22325	44	court	court	NN
18637	22325	45	found	find	VBD
18637	22325	46	that	that	IN
18637	22325	47	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	22325	48	of	of	IN
18637	22325	49	South	South	NNP
18637	22325	50	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	22325	51	which	which	WDT
18637	22325	52	required	require	VBD
18637	22325	53	separate	separate	JJ
18637	22325	54	schools	school	NNS
18637	22325	55	for	for	IN
18637	22325	56	the	the	DT
18637	22325	57	two	two	CD
18637	22325	58	races	race	NNS
18637	22325	59	did	do	VBD
18637	22325	60	not	not	RB
18637	22325	61	of	of	IN
18637	22325	62	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22325	63	violate	violate	VBP
18637	22325	64	the	the	DT
18637	22325	65	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	22325	66	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22325	67	,	,	,
18637	22325	68	but	but	CC
18637	22325	69	ordered	order	VBD
18637	22325	70	the	the	DT
18637	22325	71	school	school	NN
18637	22325	72	officials	official	NNS
18637	22325	73	to	to	TO
18637	22325	74	proceed	proceed	VB
18637	22325	75	at	at	IN
18637	22325	76	once	once	RB
18637	22325	77	to	to	TO
18637	22325	78	furnish	furnish	VB
18637	22325	79	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22325	80	educational	educational	JJ
18637	22325	81	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	22325	82	and	and	CC
18637	22325	83	to	to	TO
18637	22325	84	report	report	VB
18637	22325	85	to	to	IN
18637	22325	86	the	the	DT
18637	22325	87	court	court	NN
18637	22325	88	within	within	IN
18637	22325	89	six	six	CD
18637	22325	90	months	month	NNS
18637	22325	91	as	as	IN
18637	22325	92	to	to	IN
18637	22325	93	the	the	DT
18637	22325	94	action	action	NN
18637	22325	95	taken	take	VBN
18637	22325	96	.	.	.
18637	22326	1	On	on	IN
18637	22326	2	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	22326	3	to	to	IN
18637	22326	4	the	the	DT
18637	22326	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	22326	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22326	7	the	the	DT
18637	22326	8	case	case	NN
18637	22326	9	was	be	VBD
18637	22326	10	remanded	remand	VBN
18637	22326	11	for	for	IN
18637	22326	12	further	further	JJ
18637	22326	13	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	22326	14	in	in	IN
18637	22326	15	order	order	NN
18637	22326	16	that	that	IN
18637	22326	17	the	the	DT
18637	22326	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	22326	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22326	20	may	may	MD
18637	22326	21	"	"	``
18637	22326	22	have	have	VB
18637	22326	23	the	the	DT
18637	22326	24	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	22326	25	of	of	IN
18637	22326	26	the	the	DT
18637	22326	27	views	view	NNS
18637	22326	28	of	of	IN
18637	22326	29	the	the	DT
18637	22326	30	District	District	NNP
18637	22326	31	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22326	32	upon	upon	IN
18637	22326	33	the	the	DT
18637	22326	34	additional	additional	JJ
18637	22326	35	facts	fact	NNS
18637	22326	36	brought	bring	VBN
18637	22326	37	to	to	IN
18637	22326	38	the	the	DT
18637	22326	39	attention	attention	NN
18637	22326	40	of	of	IN
18637	22326	41	that	that	DT
18637	22326	42	court	court	NN
18637	22326	43	in	in	IN
18637	22326	44	the	the	DT
18637	22326	45	report	report	NN
18637	22326	46	which	which	WDT
18637	22326	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22326	48	ordered	order	VBD
18637	22326	49	.	.	.
18637	22326	50	"	"	''
18637	22327	1	Briggs	Briggs	NNP
18637	22327	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22327	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22327	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22327	5	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	22327	6	,	,	,
18637	22327	7	342	342	CD
18637	22327	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22327	9	350	350	CD
18637	22327	10	,	,	,
18637	22327	11	351	351	CD
18637	22327	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22327	13	1952	1952	CD
18637	22327	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22327	15	.	.	.
18637	22328	1	Recently	recently	RB
18637	22328	2	,	,	,
18637	22328	3	the	the	DT
18637	22328	4	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	22328	5	United	United	NNP
18637	22328	6	States	States	NNP
18637	22328	7	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
18637	22328	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22328	9	of	of	IN
18637	22328	10	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
18637	22328	11	,	,	,
18637	22328	12	sitting	sit	VBG
18637	22328	13	at	at	IN
18637	22328	14	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	22328	15	,	,	,
18637	22328	16	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	22328	17	that	that	IN
18637	22328	18	Negroes	Negroes	NNP
18637	22328	19	must	must	MD
18637	22328	20	be	be	VB
18637	22328	21	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	22328	22	to	to	IN
18637	22328	23	the	the	DT
18637	22328	24	white	white	NNP
18637	22328	25	University	University	NNP
18637	22328	26	of	of	IN
18637	22328	27	North	North	NNP
18637	22328	28	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	22328	29	Law	Law	NNP
18637	22328	30	School	School	NNP
18637	22328	31	in	in	IN
18637	22328	32	terms	term	NNS
18637	22328	33	which	which	WDT
18637	22328	34	flatly	flatly	RB
18637	22328	35	rejected	reject	VBD
18637	22328	36	the	the	DT
18637	22328	37	thesis	thesis	NN
18637	22328	38	of	of	IN
18637	22328	39	separate	separate	JJ
18637	22328	40	but	but	CC
18637	22328	41	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22328	42	facilities	facility	NNS
18637	22328	43	.	.	.
18637	22329	1	"	"	``
18637	22329	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22329	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	22329	4	a	a	DT
18637	22329	5	definite	definite	JJ
18637	22329	6	handicap	handicap	NN
18637	22329	7	to	to	IN
18637	22329	8	the	the	DT
18637	22329	9	colored	colored	JJ
18637	22329	10	student	student	NN
18637	22329	11	to	to	TO
18637	22329	12	confine	confine	VB
18637	22329	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22329	14	association	association	NN
18637	22329	15	in	in	IN
18637	22329	16	the	the	DT
18637	22329	17	Law	Law	NNP
18637	22329	18	School	School	NNP
18637	22329	19	with	with	IN
18637	22329	20	people	people	NNS
18637	22329	21	of	of	IN
18637	22329	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22329	23	own	own	JJ
18637	22329	24	class	class	NN
18637	22329	25	,	,	,
18637	22329	26	"	"	''
18637	22329	27	said	say	VBD
18637	22329	28	the	the	DT
18637	22329	29	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	22329	30	of	of	IN
18637	22329	31	Judge	Judge	NNP
18637	22329	32	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	22329	33	A.	A.	NNP
18637	22330	1	Soper.--McKissick	Soper.--McKissick	NNP
18637	22330	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22330	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22330	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22330	5	Carmichael	Carmichael	NNP
18637	22330	6	,	,	,
18637	22330	7	187	187	CD
18637	22330	8	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22330	9	2d	2d	NNP
18637	22330	10	949	949	CD
18637	22330	11	,	,	,
18637	22330	12	952	952	CD
18637	22330	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22330	14	1951	1951	CD
18637	22330	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22330	16	.	.	.
18637	22331	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22331	2	1171	1171	CD
18637	22331	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22331	4	Guinn	Guinn	NNP
18637	22331	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22331	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22331	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22331	8	United	United	NNP
18637	22331	9	States	States	NNP
18637	22331	10	,	,	,
18637	22331	11	238	238	CD
18637	22331	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22331	13	347	347	CD
18637	22331	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22331	15	1915	1915	CD
18637	22331	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22331	17	.	.	.
18637	22332	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22332	2	1172	1172	CD
18637	22332	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22332	4	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	22332	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22332	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22332	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22332	8	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	22332	9	,	,	,
18637	22332	10	170	170	CD
18637	22332	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22332	12	213	213	CD
18637	22332	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22332	14	1898	1898	CD
18637	22332	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22332	16	.	.	.
18637	22333	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22333	2	1173	1173	CD
18637	22333	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22333	4	Giles	Giles	NNP
18637	22333	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22333	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22333	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22333	8	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	22333	9	,	,	,
18637	22333	10	189	189	CD
18637	22333	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22333	12	475	475	CD
18637	22333	13	,	,	,
18637	22333	14	486	486	CD
18637	22333	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22333	16	1903	1903	CD
18637	22333	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22333	18	.	.	.
18637	22334	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22334	2	1174	1174	CD
18637	22334	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22334	4	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	22334	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22334	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22334	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22334	8	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	22334	9	,	,	,
18637	22334	10	307	307	CD
18637	22334	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22334	12	268	268	CD
18637	22334	13	,	,	,
18637	22334	14	275	275	CD
18637	22334	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22334	16	1939	1939	CD
18637	22334	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22334	18	.	.	.
18637	22335	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22335	2	1175	1175	CD
18637	22335	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22335	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22335	5	See	See	NNP
18637	22335	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22335	7	p.	p.	NN
18637	22335	8	1141	1141	CD
18637	22335	9	,	,	,
18637	22335	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22335	11	ante	ante	NNP
18637	22335	12	_	_	NNP
18637	22335	13	.	.	.
18637	22336	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22336	2	1176	1176	CD
18637	22336	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22336	4	Nixon	Nixon	NNP
18637	22336	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22336	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22336	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22336	8	Herndon	Herndon	NNP
18637	22336	9	,	,	,
18637	22336	10	273	273	CD
18637	22336	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22336	12	536	536	CD
18637	22336	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22336	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	22336	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22336	16	.	.	.
18637	22337	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22337	2	1177	1177	CD
18637	22337	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22337	4	Nixon	Nixon	NNP
18637	22337	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22337	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22337	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22337	8	Condon	Condon	NNP
18637	22337	9	,	,	,
18637	22337	10	286	286	CD
18637	22337	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22337	12	73	73	CD
18637	22337	13	,	,	,
18637	22337	14	89	89	CD
18637	22337	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22337	16	1932	1932	CD
18637	22337	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22337	18	.	.	.
18637	22338	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22338	2	1178	1178	CD
18637	22338	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22338	4	Grovey	Grovey	NNP
18637	22338	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22338	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22338	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22338	8	Townsend	Townsend	NNP
18637	22338	9	,	,	,
18637	22338	10	295	295	CD
18637	22338	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22338	12	45	45	CD
18637	22338	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22338	14	1935	1935	CD
18637	22338	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22338	16	.	.	.
18637	22339	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22339	2	1179	1179	CD
18637	22339	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22339	4	United	United	NNP
18637	22339	5	States	States	NNP
18637	22339	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22339	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22339	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22339	9	Classic	Classic	NNP
18637	22339	10	,	,	,
18637	22339	11	313	313	CD
18637	22339	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22339	13	299	299	CD
18637	22339	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22339	15	1941	1941	CD
18637	22339	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22339	17	.	.	.
18637	22340	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22340	2	1180	1180	CD
18637	22340	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22340	4	321	321	CD
18637	22340	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22340	6	649	649	CD
18637	22340	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22340	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	22340	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22340	10	.	.	.
18637	22341	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22341	2	1181	1181	CD
18637	22341	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22341	4	Pope	Pope	NNP
18637	22341	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22341	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22341	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22341	8	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	22341	9	,	,	,
18637	22341	10	193	193	CD
18637	22341	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22341	12	621	621	CD
18637	22341	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22341	14	1904	1904	CD
18637	22341	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22341	16	.	.	.
18637	22342	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22342	2	1182	1182	CD
18637	22342	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22342	4	321	321	CD
18637	22342	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22342	6	1	1	CD
18637	22342	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22342	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	22342	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22342	10	.	.	.
18637	22343	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22343	2	1183	1183	CD
18637	22343	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22343	4	328	328	CD
18637	22343	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22343	6	549	549	CD
18637	22343	7	,	,	,
18637	22343	8	566	566	CD
18637	22343	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22343	10	1946	1946	CD
18637	22343	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22343	12	.	.	.
18637	22344	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22344	2	Black	Black	NNP
18637	22344	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	22344	4	on	on	IN
18637	22344	5	the	the	DT
18637	22344	6	ground	ground	NN
18637	22344	7	that	that	IN
18637	22344	8	the	the	DT
18637	22344	9	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22344	10	protection	protection	NN
18637	22344	11	clause	clause	NN
18637	22344	12	was	be	VBD
18637	22344	13	violated	violate	VBN
18637	22344	14	.	.	.
18637	22345	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22345	2	1184	1184	CD
18637	22345	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22345	4	335	335	CD
18637	22345	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22345	6	281	281	CD
18637	22345	7	,	,	,
18637	22345	8	287	287	CD
18637	22345	9	,	,	,
18637	22345	10	288	288	CD
18637	22345	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22345	12	1948	1948	CD
18637	22345	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22345	14	.	.	.
18637	22346	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22346	2	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	22346	3	,	,	,
18637	22346	4	with	with	IN
18637	22346	5	whom	whom	WP
18637	22346	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	22346	7	Black	Black	NNP
18637	22346	8	and	and	CC
18637	22346	9	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	22346	10	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	22346	11	,	,	,
18637	22346	12	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	22346	13	saying	say	VBG
18637	22346	14	that	that	IN
18637	22346	15	the	the	DT
18637	22346	16	statute	statute	NN
18637	22346	17	lacked	lack	VBD
18637	22346	18	"	"	``
18637	22346	19	the	the	DT
18637	22346	20	equality	equality	NN
18637	22346	21	to	to	TO
18637	22346	22	which	which	WDT
18637	22346	23	the	the	DT
18637	22346	24	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	22346	25	of	of	IN
18637	22346	26	political	political	JJ
18637	22346	27	rights	right	NNS
18637	22346	28	is	be	VBZ
18637	22346	29	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	22346	30	under	under	IN
18637	22346	31	the	the	DT
18637	22346	32	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	22346	33	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22346	34	.	.	.
18637	22346	35	"	"	''
18637	22347	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22347	2	1185	1185	CD
18637	22347	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22347	4	South	South	NNP
18637	22347	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22347	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22347	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22347	8	Peters	Peters	NNP
18637	22347	9	,	,	,
18637	22347	10	339	339	CD
18637	22347	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22347	12	276	276	CD
18637	22347	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22347	14	1950	1950	CD
18637	22347	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22347	16	.	.	.
18637	22348	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22348	2	1186	1186	CD
18637	22348	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22348	4	Dohany	Dohany	NNP
18637	22348	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22348	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22348	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22348	8	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	22348	9	,	,	,
18637	22348	10	281	281	CD
18637	22348	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22348	12	362	362	CD
18637	22348	13	,	,	,
18637	22348	14	369	369	CD
18637	22348	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22348	16	1930	1930	CD
18637	22348	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22348	18	.	.	.
18637	22349	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22349	2	1187	1187	CD
18637	22349	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22349	4	Hayes	Hayes	NNP
18637	22349	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22349	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22349	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22349	8	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22349	9	,	,	,
18637	22349	10	120	120	CD
18637	22349	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22349	12	68	68	CD
18637	22349	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22349	14	1887	1887	CD
18637	22349	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22349	16	.	.	.
18637	22350	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22350	2	1188	1188	CD
18637	22350	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22350	4	Hardware	Hardware	NNP
18637	22350	5	Dealers	Dealers	NNPS
18637	22350	6	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	22350	7	.	.	.
18637	22351	1	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22351	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	22351	3	.	.	.
18637	22352	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22352	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22352	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22352	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22352	5	Glidden	Glidden	NNP
18637	22352	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22352	7	,	,	,
18637	22352	8	284	284	CD
18637	22352	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22352	10	151	151	CD
18637	22352	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22352	12	1931	1931	CD
18637	22352	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22352	14	.	.	.
18637	22353	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22353	2	1189	1189	CD
18637	22353	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22353	4	Lindsley	Lindsley	NNP
18637	22353	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22353	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22353	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22353	8	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	22353	9	Carbonic	Carbonic	NNP
18637	22353	10	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	22353	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22353	12	,	,	,
18637	22353	13	220	220	CD
18637	22353	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22353	15	61	61	CD
18637	22353	16	,	,	,
18637	22353	17	81	81	CD
18637	22353	18	,	,	,
18637	22353	19	82	82	CD
18637	22353	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22353	21	1911	1911	CD
18637	22353	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22353	23	;	;	:
18637	22353	24	_	_	NNP
18637	22353	25	see	see	VB
18637	22353	26	also	also	RB
18637	22353	27	_	_	NNP
18637	22353	28	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	22353	29	,	,	,
18637	22353	30	J.	J.	NNP
18637	22354	1	&	&	CC
18637	22354	2	K.C.R.	K.C.R.	NNP
18637	22355	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22355	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22355	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22355	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22355	5	Turnipseed	Turnipseed	NNP
18637	22355	6	,	,	,
18637	22355	7	219	219	CD
18637	22355	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22355	9	35	35	CD
18637	22355	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22355	11	1910	1910	CD
18637	22355	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22355	13	;	;	:
18637	22355	14	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	22355	15	_	_	NNP
18637	22355	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	22355	17	_	_	NNP
18637	22355	18	New	New	NNP
18637	22355	19	York	York	NNP
18637	22355	20	,	,	,
18637	22355	21	192	192	CD
18637	22355	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22355	23	585	585	CD
18637	22355	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22355	25	1904	1904	CD
18637	22355	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22355	27	.	.	.
18637	22356	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22356	2	1190	1190	CD
18637	22356	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22356	4	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
18637	22356	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22356	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22356	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22356	8	Beneficial	Beneficial	NNP
18637	22356	9	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	22356	10	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	22356	11	,	,	,
18637	22356	12	337	337	CD
18637	22356	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22356	14	541	541	CD
18637	22356	15	,	,	,
18637	22356	16	552	552	CD
18637	22356	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22356	18	1949	1949	CD
18637	22356	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22356	20	.	.	.
18637	22357	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22357	2	1191	1191	CD
18637	22357	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22357	4	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	22357	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22357	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22357	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22357	8	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	22357	9	,	,	,
18637	22357	10	101	101	CD
18637	22357	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22357	12	22	22	CD
18637	22357	13	,	,	,
18637	22357	14	30	30	CD
18637	22357	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22357	16	1880	1880	CD
18637	22357	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22357	18	.	.	.
18637	22358	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22358	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22358	3	also	also	RB
18637	22358	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22358	5	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	22358	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22358	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22358	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22358	9	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22358	10	,	,	,
18637	22358	11	152	152	CD
18637	22358	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22358	13	377	377	CD
18637	22358	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22358	15	1894	1894	CD
18637	22358	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22358	17	;	;	:
18637	22358	18	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	22358	19	ex	ex	NNP
18637	22358	20	rel	rel	NN
18637	22358	21	.	.	.
18637	22359	1	Bryant	Bryant	NNP
18637	22359	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22359	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22359	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22359	5	Akron	Akron	NNP
18637	22359	6	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
18637	22359	7	Park	Park	NNP
18637	22359	8	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	22359	9	,	,	,
18637	22359	10	281	281	CD
18637	22359	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22359	12	74	74	CD
18637	22359	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22359	14	1930	1930	CD
18637	22359	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22359	16	.	.	.
18637	22360	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22360	2	1192	1192	CD
18637	22360	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22360	4	Mallett	Mallett	NNP
18637	22360	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22360	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22360	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22360	8	North	North	NNP
18637	22360	9	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	22360	10	,	,	,
18637	22360	11	181	181	CD
18637	22360	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22360	13	589	589	CD
18637	22360	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22360	15	1901	1901	CD
18637	22360	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22360	17	;	;	:
18637	22360	18	_	_	NNP
18637	22360	19	see	see	VB
18637	22360	20	also	also	RB
18637	22360	21	_	_	NNP
18637	22360	22	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	22360	23	_	_	NNP
18637	22360	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	22360	25	_	_	NNP
18637	22360	26	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	22360	27	,	,	,
18637	22360	28	101	101	CD
18637	22360	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22360	30	22	22	CD
18637	22360	31	,	,	,
18637	22360	32	30	30	CD
18637	22360	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22360	34	1880	1880	CD
18637	22360	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22360	36	.	.	.
18637	22361	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22361	2	1193	1193	CD
18637	22361	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22361	4	Truax	Truax	NNP
18637	22361	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22361	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22361	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22361	8	Corrigan	Corrigan	NNP
18637	22361	9	,	,	,
18637	22361	10	257	257	CD
18637	22361	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22361	12	312	312	CD
18637	22361	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22361	14	1921	1921	CD
18637	22361	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22361	16	.	.	.
18637	22362	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22362	2	1194	1194	CD
18637	22362	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22362	4	Cochran	Cochran	NNP
18637	22362	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22362	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22362	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22362	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	22362	9	,	,	,
18637	22362	10	316	316	CD
18637	22362	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22362	12	255	255	CD
18637	22362	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22362	14	1942	1942	CD
18637	22362	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22362	16	.	.	.
18637	22363	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22363	2	1195	1195	CD
18637	22363	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22363	4	Bain	Bain	NNP
18637	22363	5	Peanut	Peanut	NNP
18637	22363	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22363	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22363	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22363	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22363	10	Pinson	Pinson	NNP
18637	22363	11	,	,	,
18637	22363	12	282	282	CD
18637	22363	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22363	14	499	499	CD
18637	22363	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22363	16	1931	1931	CD
18637	22363	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22363	18	.	.	.
18637	22364	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22364	2	1196	1196	CD
18637	22364	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22364	4	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	22364	5	Rendering	Rendering	NNP
18637	22364	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22364	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22364	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22364	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22364	10	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	22364	11	,	,	,
18637	22364	12	207	207	CD
18637	22364	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22364	14	541	541	CD
18637	22364	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22364	16	1908	1908	CD
18637	22364	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22364	18	.	.	.
18637	22365	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22365	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22365	3	also	also	RB
18637	22365	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22365	5	Hammond	Hammond	NNP
18637	22365	6	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	22365	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22365	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22365	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22365	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22365	11	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	22365	12	,	,	,
18637	22365	13	212	212	CD
18637	22365	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22365	15	322	322	CD
18637	22365	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22365	17	1909	1909	CD
18637	22365	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22365	19	.	.	.
18637	22366	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22366	2	1197	1197	CD
18637	22366	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22366	4	Power	Power	NNP
18637	22366	5	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	22366	6	.	.	.
18637	22367	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22367	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22367	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22367	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22367	5	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
18637	22367	6	,	,	,
18637	22367	7	274	274	CD
18637	22367	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22367	9	490	490	CD
18637	22367	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22367	11	1927	1927	CD
18637	22367	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22367	13	.	.	.
18637	22368	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22368	2	1198	1198	CD
18637	22368	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22368	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	22368	5	Finance	Finance	NNP
18637	22368	6	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	22368	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22368	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22368	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22368	10	Paramount	Paramount	NNP
18637	22368	11	Auto	Auto	NNP
18637	22368	12	Exch	Exch	NNP
18637	22368	13	.	.	.
18637	22369	1	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	22369	2	,	,	,
18637	22369	3	262	262	CD
18637	22369	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22369	5	544	544	CD
18637	22369	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22369	7	1923	1923	CD
18637	22369	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22369	9	.	.	.
18637	22370	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22370	2	1199	1199	CD
18637	22370	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22370	4	Fidelity	Fidelity	NNP
18637	22370	5	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	22370	6	.	.	.
18637	22371	1	Life	Life	NNP
18637	22371	2	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	22371	3	.	.	.
18637	22372	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22372	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	22372	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22372	4	Mettler	Mettler	NNP
18637	22372	5	,	,	,
18637	22372	6	185	185	CD
18637	22372	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22372	8	308	308	CD
18637	22372	9	,	,	,
18637	22372	10	325	325	CD
18637	22372	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22372	12	1902	1902	CD
18637	22372	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22372	14	.	.	.
18637	22373	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22373	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22373	3	also	also	RB
18637	22373	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22373	5	Manhattan	Manhattan	NNP
18637	22373	6	L.	L.	NNP
18637	22373	7	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	22373	8	.	.	.
18637	22374	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22374	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22374	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22374	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22374	5	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
18637	22374	6	,	,	,
18637	22374	7	234	234	CD
18637	22374	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22374	9	123	123	CD
18637	22374	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22374	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	22374	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22374	13	.	.	.
18637	22375	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22375	2	1200	1200	CD
18637	22375	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22375	4	Lowe	Lowe	NNP
18637	22375	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22375	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22375	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22375	8	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	22375	9	,	,	,
18637	22375	10	163	163	CD
18637	22375	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22375	12	81	81	CD
18637	22375	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22375	14	1896	1896	CD
18637	22375	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22375	16	.	.	.
18637	22376	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22376	2	1201	1201	CD
18637	22376	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22376	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22376	5	,	,	,
18637	22376	6	K.	K.	NNP
18637	22376	7	&	&	CC
18637	22376	8	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	22377	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22377	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22377	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22377	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22377	5	Cade	Cade	NNP
18637	22377	6	,	,	,
18637	22377	7	233	233	CD
18637	22377	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22377	9	642	642	CD
18637	22377	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22377	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	22377	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22377	13	;	;	:
18637	22377	14	_	_	NNP
18637	22377	15	see	see	VB
18637	22377	16	also	also	RB
18637	22377	17	_	_	NNP
18637	22377	18	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22377	19	,	,	,
18637	22377	20	K.	K.	NNP
18637	22377	21	&	&	CC
18637	22377	22	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	22378	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22378	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22378	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22378	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22378	5	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	22378	6	,	,	,
18637	22378	7	234	234	CD
18637	22378	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22378	9	412	412	CD
18637	22378	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22378	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	22378	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22378	13	.	.	.
18637	22379	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22379	2	1202	1202	CD
18637	22379	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22379	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22379	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	22380	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22380	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22380	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22380	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22380	5	Larabee	Larabee	NNP
18637	22380	6	,	,	,
18637	22380	7	234	234	CD
18637	22380	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22380	9	459	459	CD
18637	22380	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22380	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	22380	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22380	13	.	.	.
18637	22381	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22381	2	1203	1203	CD
18637	22381	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22381	4	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	22381	5	,	,	,
18637	22381	6	T.	T.	NNP
18637	22381	7	&	&	CC
18637	22381	8	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	22382	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22382	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22382	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22382	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22382	5	Matthews	Matthews	NNP
18637	22382	6	,	,	,
18637	22382	7	174	174	CD
18637	22382	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22382	9	96	96	CD
18637	22382	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22382	11	1899	1899	CD
18637	22382	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22382	13	.	.	.
18637	22383	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22383	2	1204	1204	CD
18637	22383	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22383	4	Gulf	Gulf	NNP
18637	22383	5	,	,	,
18637	22383	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	22383	7	&	&	CC
18637	22383	8	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	22384	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22384	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22384	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22384	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22384	5	Ellis	Ellis	NNP
18637	22384	6	,	,	,
18637	22384	7	165	165	CD
18637	22384	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22384	9	150	150	CD
18637	22384	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22384	11	1897	1897	CD
18637	22384	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22384	13	.	.	.
18637	22385	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22385	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22385	3	also	also	RB
18637	22385	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22385	5	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	22385	6	,	,	,
18637	22385	7	T.	T.	NNP
18637	22385	8	&	&	CC
18637	22385	9	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	22386	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22386	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22386	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22386	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22386	5	Vosburg	Vosburg	NNP
18637	22386	6	,	,	,
18637	22386	7	238	238	CD
18637	22386	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22386	9	56	56	CD
18637	22386	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22386	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	22386	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22386	13	.	.	.
18637	22387	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22387	2	1205	1205	CD
18637	22387	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22387	4	18	18	CD
18637	22387	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22387	6	.	.	.
18637	22388	1	336	336	CD
18637	22388	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22388	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	22388	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22388	5	;	;	:
18637	22388	6	8	8	CD
18637	22388	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
18637	22389	1	§	§	NNP
18637	22389	2	44	44	CD
18637	22389	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22389	4	1946	1946	CD
18637	22389	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22389	6	.	.	.
18637	22390	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22390	2	1206	1206	CD
18637	22390	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22390	4	Cassell	Cassell	NNP
18637	22390	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22390	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22390	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22390	8	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	22390	9	,	,	,
18637	22390	10	339	339	CD
18637	22390	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22390	12	282	282	CD
18637	22390	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22390	14	1950	1950	CD
18637	22390	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22390	16	;	;	:
18637	22390	17	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	22390	18	_	_	NNP
18637	22390	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	22390	20	_	_	NNP
18637	22390	21	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	22390	22	,	,	,
18637	22390	23	316	316	CD
18637	22390	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22390	25	400	400	CD
18637	22390	26	,	,	,
18637	22390	27	404	404	CD
18637	22390	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22390	29	1942	1942	CD
18637	22390	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22390	31	;	;	:
18637	22390	32	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	22390	33	_	_	NNP
18637	22390	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	22390	35	_	_	NNP
18637	22390	36	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	22390	37	,	,	,
18637	22390	38	311	311	CD
18637	22390	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22390	40	128	128	CD
18637	22390	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22390	42	1940	1940	CD
18637	22390	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22390	44	;	;	:
18637	22390	45	Pierre	Pierre	NNP
18637	22390	46	_	_	NNP
18637	22390	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	22390	48	_	_	NNP
18637	22390	49	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	22390	50	,	,	,
18637	22390	51	306	306	CD
18637	22390	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22390	53	354	354	CD
18637	22390	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22390	55	1939	1939	CD
18637	22390	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22390	57	;	;	:
18637	22390	58	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	22390	59	_	_	NNP
18637	22390	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	22390	61	_	_	NNP
18637	22390	62	Rives	Rives	NNP
18637	22390	63	,	,	,
18637	22390	64	100	100	CD
18637	22390	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22390	66	313	313	CD
18637	22390	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22390	68	1880	1880	CD
18637	22390	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22390	70	.	.	.
18637	22391	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22391	2	1207	1207	CD
18637	22391	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22391	4	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	22391	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22391	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22391	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22391	8	Rives	Rives	NNP
18637	22391	9	,	,	,
18637	22391	10	100	100	CD
18637	22391	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22391	12	313	313	CD
18637	22391	13	,	,	,
18637	22391	14	322	322	CD
18637	22391	15	,	,	,
18637	22391	16	323	323	CD
18637	22391	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22391	18	1880	1880	CD
18637	22391	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22391	20	.	.	.
18637	22392	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22392	2	1208	1208	CD
18637	22392	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22392	4	Akins	Akins	NNP
18637	22392	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22392	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22392	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22392	8	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	22392	9	,	,	,
18637	22392	10	325	325	CD
18637	22392	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22392	12	398	398	CD
18637	22392	13	,	,	,
18637	22392	14	403	403	CD
18637	22392	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22392	16	1945	1945	CD
18637	22392	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22392	18	.	.	.
18637	22393	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22393	2	1209	1209	CD
18637	22393	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22393	4	Patton	Patton	NNP
18637	22393	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22393	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22393	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22393	8	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	22393	9	,	,	,
18637	22393	10	332	332	CD
18637	22393	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22393	12	463	463	CD
18637	22393	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22393	14	1947	1947	CD
18637	22393	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22393	16	.	.	.
18637	22394	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22394	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22394	3	also	also	RB
18637	22394	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22394	5	Shepherd	Shepherd	NNP
18637	22394	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22394	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22394	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22394	9	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	22394	10	,	,	,
18637	22394	11	341	341	CD
18637	22394	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22394	13	50	50	CD
18637	22394	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22394	15	1951	1951	CD
18637	22394	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22394	17	.	.	.
18637	22395	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22395	2	1210	1210	CD
18637	22395	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22395	4	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	22395	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22395	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22395	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22395	8	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	22395	9	,	,	,
18637	22395	10	162	162	CD
18637	22395	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22395	12	565	565	CD
18637	22395	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22395	14	1896	1896	CD
18637	22395	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22395	16	.	.	.
18637	22396	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22396	2	1211	1211	CD
18637	22396	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22396	4	Rawlins	Rawlins	NNPS
18637	22396	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22396	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22396	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22396	8	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	22396	9	,	,	,
18637	22396	10	201	201	CD
18637	22396	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22396	12	638	638	CD
18637	22396	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22396	14	1906	1906	CD
18637	22396	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22396	16	.	.	.
18637	22397	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22397	2	1212	1212	CD
18637	22397	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22397	4	332	332	CD
18637	22397	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22397	6	261	261	CD
18637	22397	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22397	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	22397	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22397	10	.	.	.
18637	22398	1	In	in	IN
18637	22398	2	an	an	DT
18637	22398	3	interesting	interesting	JJ
18637	22398	4	footnote	footnote	NN
18637	22398	5	to	to	IN
18637	22398	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22398	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	22398	8	,	,	,
18637	22398	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22398	10	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	22398	11	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	22398	12	that	that	IN
18637	22398	13	"	"	``
18637	22398	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22398	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	22398	16	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	22398	17	to	to	TO
18637	22398	18	decide	decide	VB
18637	22398	19	whether	whether	IN
18637	22398	20	the	the	DT
18637	22398	21	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22398	22	protection	protection	NN
18637	22398	23	clause	clause	NN
18637	22398	24	of	of	IN
18637	22398	25	the	the	DT
18637	22398	26	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	22398	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22398	28	might	may	MD
18637	22398	29	of	of	IN
18637	22398	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22398	31	own	own	JJ
18637	22398	32	force	force	NN
18637	22398	33	prohibit	prohibit	NN
18637	22398	34	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	22398	35	on	on	IN
18637	22398	36	account	account	NN
18637	22398	37	of	of	IN
18637	22398	38	race	race	NN
18637	22398	39	in	in	IN
18637	22398	40	the	the	DT
18637	22398	41	selection	selection	NN
18637	22398	42	of	of	IN
18637	22398	43	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	22398	44	,	,	,
18637	22398	45	so	so	IN
18637	22398	46	that	that	IN
18637	22398	47	such	such	JJ
18637	22398	48	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	22398	49	would	would	MD
18637	22398	50	violate	violate	VB
18637	22398	51	the	the	DT
18637	22398	52	due	due	JJ
18637	22398	53	process	process	NN
18637	22398	54	clause	clause	NN
18637	22398	55	of	of	IN
18637	22398	56	the	the	DT
18637	22398	57	same	same	JJ
18637	22398	58	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22398	59	.	.	.
18637	22398	60	"	"	''
18637	22399	1	Ibid	ibid	RB
18637	22399	2	.	.	.
18637	22400	1	284	284	CD
18637	22400	2	.	.	.
18637	22401	1	Earlier	early	JJR
18637	22401	2	cases	case	NNS
18637	22401	3	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	22401	4	with	with	IN
18637	22401	5	racial	racial	JJ
18637	22401	6	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	22401	7	have	have	VBP
18637	22401	8	indicated	indicate	VBN
18637	22401	9	that	that	IN
18637	22401	10	the	the	DT
18637	22401	11	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	22401	12	was	be	VBD
18637	22401	13	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	22401	14	by	by	IN
18637	22401	15	the	the	DT
18637	22401	16	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22401	17	protection	protection	NN
18637	22401	18	clause	clause	NN
18637	22401	19	as	as	RB
18637	22401	20	well	well	RB
18637	22401	21	as	as	IN
18637	22401	22	by	by	IN
18637	22401	23	the	the	DT
18637	22401	24	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	22401	25	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	22401	26	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22401	27	of	of	IN
18637	22401	28	1875	1875	CD
18637	22401	29	.	.	.
18637	22402	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22402	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22402	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22402	4	cases	case	NNS
18637	22402	5	cited	cite	VBN
18637	22402	6	to	to	IN
18637	22402	7	the	the	DT
18637	22402	8	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	22402	9	paragraph	paragraph	NN
18637	22402	10	.	.	.
18637	22403	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22403	2	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
18637	22403	3	's	's	POS
18637	22403	4	Note	note	NN
18637	22403	5	:	:	:
18637	22403	6	Reference	reference	NN
18637	22403	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	22403	8	to	to	IN
18637	22403	9	Section	section	NN
18637	22403	10	"	"	``
18637	22403	11	Selection	Selection	NNP
18637	22403	12	of	of	IN
18637	22403	13	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	22403	14	"	"	''
18637	22403	15	,	,	,
18637	22403	16	above	above	RB
18637	22403	17	.	.	.
18637	22403	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22404	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22404	2	1213	1213	CD
18637	22404	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22404	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	22404	5	.	.	.
18637	22405	1	285	285	CD
18637	22405	2	.	.	.
18637	22406	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22406	2	1214	1214	CD
18637	22406	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22406	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	22406	5	.	.	.
18637	22407	1	270	270	CD
18637	22407	2	,	,	,
18637	22407	3	271	271	CD
18637	22407	4	.	.	.
18637	22408	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22408	2	1215	1215	CD
18637	22408	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22408	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	22408	5	.	.	.
18637	22409	1	291	291	CD
18637	22409	2	.	.	.
18637	22410	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22410	2	1216	1216	CD
18637	22410	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22410	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	22410	5	.	.	.
18637	22411	1	288	288	CD
18637	22411	2	,	,	,
18637	22411	3	289	289	CD
18637	22411	4	,	,	,
18637	22411	5	299	299	CD
18637	22411	6	,	,	,
18637	22411	7	300	300	CD
18637	22411	8	.	.	.
18637	22412	1	Four	four	CD
18637	22412	2	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	22412	3	,	,	,
18637	22412	4	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	22412	5	by	by	IN
18637	22412	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22412	7	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	22412	8	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	22412	9	,	,	,
18637	22412	10	saying	say	VBG
18637	22412	11	:	:	:
18637	22412	12	"	"	``
18637	22412	13	The	the	DT
18637	22412	14	proof	proof	NN
18637	22412	15	here	here	RB
18637	22412	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	22412	17	adequate	adequate	JJ
18637	22412	18	enough	enough	RB
18637	22412	19	to	to	TO
18637	22412	20	demonstrate	demonstrate	VB
18637	22412	21	that	that	IN
18637	22412	22	this	this	DT
18637	22412	23	panel	panel	NN
18637	22412	24	,	,	,
18637	22412	25	like	like	IN
18637	22412	26	every	every	DT
18637	22412	27	discriminatorily	discriminatorily	RB
18637	22412	28	selected	select	VBN
18637	22412	29	'	'	''
18637	22412	30	blue	blue	JJ
18637	22412	31	ribbon	ribbon	NN
18637	22412	32	'	'	''
18637	22412	33	panel	panel	NN
18637	22412	34	,	,	,
18637	22412	35	suffers	suffer	VBZ
18637	22412	36	from	from	IN
18637	22412	37	a	a	DT
18637	22412	38	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	22412	39	infirmity	infirmity	NN
18637	22412	40	.	.	.
18637	22413	1	That	that	DT
18637	22413	2	infirmity	infirmity	NN
18637	22413	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	22413	4	the	the	DT
18637	22413	5	denial	denial	NN
18637	22413	6	of	of	IN
18637	22413	7	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22413	8	protection	protection	NN
18637	22413	9	to	to	IN
18637	22413	10	those	those	DT
18637	22413	11	who	who	WP
18637	22413	12	are	be	VBP
18637	22413	13	tried	try	VBN
18637	22413	14	by	by	IN
18637	22413	15	a	a	DT
18637	22413	16	jury	jury	NN
18637	22413	17	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	22413	18	from	from	IN
18637	22413	19	a	a	DT
18637	22413	20	'	'	``
18637	22413	21	blue	blue	JJ
18637	22413	22	ribbon	ribbon	NN
18637	22413	23	'	'	''
18637	22413	24	panel	panel	NN
18637	22413	25	.	.	.
18637	22414	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	22414	2	a	a	DT
18637	22414	3	panel	panel	NN
18637	22414	4	is	be	VBZ
18637	22414	5	narrower	narrow	JJR
18637	22414	6	and	and	CC
18637	22414	7	different	different	JJ
18637	22414	8	from	from	IN
18637	22414	9	that	that	DT
18637	22414	10	used	use	VBN
18637	22414	11	in	in	IN
18637	22414	12	forming	form	VBG
18637	22414	13	juries	jury	NNS
18637	22414	14	to	to	TO
18637	22414	15	try	try	VB
18637	22414	16	the	the	DT
18637	22414	17	vast	vast	JJ
18637	22414	18	majority	majority	NN
18637	22414	19	of	of	IN
18637	22414	20	other	other	JJ
18637	22414	21	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	22414	22	persons	person	NNS
18637	22414	23	.	.	.
18637	22415	1	To	to	IN
18637	22415	2	the	the	DT
18637	22415	3	extent	extent	NN
18637	22415	4	of	of	IN
18637	22415	5	that	that	DT
18637	22415	6	difference	difference	NN
18637	22415	7	,	,	,
18637	22415	8	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	22415	9	,	,	,
18637	22415	10	the	the	DT
18637	22415	11	persons	person	NNS
18637	22415	12	tried	try	VBN
18637	22415	13	by	by	IN
18637	22415	14	'	'	``
18637	22415	15	blue	blue	JJ
18637	22415	16	ribbon	ribbon	NN
18637	22415	17	'	'	''
18637	22415	18	juries	jury	NNS
18637	22415	19	receive	receive	VBP
18637	22415	20	unequal	unequal	JJ
18637	22415	21	protection	protection	NN
18637	22415	22	.	.	.
18637	22415	23	"	"	''
18637	22416	1	"	"	``
18637	22416	2	In	in	IN
18637	22416	3	addition	addition	NN
18637	22416	4	,	,	,
18637	22416	5	as	as	IN
18637	22416	6	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
18637	22416	7	in	in	IN
18637	22416	8	this	this	DT
18637	22416	9	case	case	NN
18637	22416	10	,	,	,
18637	22416	11	the	the	DT
18637	22416	12	distinction	distinction	NN
18637	22416	13	that	that	WDT
18637	22416	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	22416	15	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	22416	16	in	in	IN
18637	22416	17	fact	fact	NN
18637	22416	18	between	between	IN
18637	22416	19	'	'	``
18637	22416	20	blue	blue	JJ
18637	22416	21	ribbon	ribbon	NN
18637	22416	22	'	'	''
18637	22416	23	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	22416	24	and	and	CC
18637	22416	25	general	general	JJ
18637	22416	26	jurors	juror	NNS
18637	22416	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	22416	28	often	often	RB
18637	22416	29	of	of	IN
18637	22416	30	such	such	PDT
18637	22416	31	a	a	DT
18637	22416	32	character	character	NN
18637	22416	33	as	as	IN
18637	22416	34	to	to	TO
18637	22416	35	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	22416	36	the	the	DT
18637	22416	37	representative	representative	JJ
18637	22416	38	nature	nature	NN
18637	22416	39	of	of	IN
18637	22416	40	the	the	DT
18637	22416	41	'	'	``
18637	22416	42	blue	blue	JJ
18637	22416	43	ribbon	ribbon	NN
18637	22416	44	'	'	''
18637	22416	45	panel	panel	NN
18637	22416	46	.	.	.
18637	22417	1	There	there	EX
18637	22417	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	22417	3	no	no	DT
18637	22417	4	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	22417	5	right	right	NN
18637	22417	6	to	to	IN
18637	22417	7	a	a	DT
18637	22417	8	jury	jury	NN
18637	22417	9	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	22417	10	from	from	IN
18637	22417	11	a	a	DT
18637	22417	12	group	group	NN
18637	22417	13	of	of	IN
18637	22417	14	uneducated	uneducated	JJ
18637	22417	15	and	and	CC
18637	22417	16	unintelligent	unintelligent	JJ
18637	22417	17	persons	person	NNS
18637	22417	18	.	.	.
18637	22418	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	22418	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	22418	3	there	there	EX
18637	22418	4	any	any	DT
18637	22418	5	right	right	NN
18637	22418	6	to	to	IN
18637	22418	7	a	a	DT
18637	22418	8	jury	jury	NN
18637	22418	9	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	22418	10	solely	solely	RB
18637	22418	11	from	from	IN
18637	22418	12	those	those	DT
18637	22418	13	at	at	IN
18637	22418	14	the	the	DT
18637	22418	15	lower	low	JJR
18637	22418	16	end	end	NN
18637	22418	17	of	of	IN
18637	22418	18	the	the	DT
18637	22418	19	economic	economic	JJ
18637	22418	20	and	and	CC
18637	22418	21	social	social	JJ
18637	22418	22	scale	scale	NN
18637	22418	23	.	.	.
18637	22419	1	But	but	CC
18637	22419	2	there	there	EX
18637	22419	3	is	be	VBZ
18637	22419	4	a	a	DT
18637	22419	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	22419	6	right	right	NN
18637	22419	7	to	to	IN
18637	22419	8	a	a	DT
18637	22419	9	jury	jury	NN
18637	22419	10	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	22419	11	from	from	IN
18637	22419	12	a	a	DT
18637	22419	13	group	group	NN
18637	22419	14	which	which	WDT
18637	22419	15	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	22419	16	a	a	DT
18637	22419	17	cross	cross	JJ
18637	22419	18	-	-	NN
18637	22419	19	section	section	NN
18637	22419	20	of	of	IN
18637	22419	21	the	the	DT
18637	22419	22	community	community	NN
18637	22419	23	.	.	.
18637	22420	1	And	and	CC
18637	22420	2	a	a	DT
18637	22420	3	cross	cross	NN
18637	22420	4	-	-	NN
18637	22420	5	section	section	NN
18637	22420	6	of	of	IN
18637	22420	7	the	the	DT
18637	22420	8	community	community	NN
18637	22420	9	includes	include	VBZ
18637	22420	10	persons	person	NNS
18637	22420	11	with	with	IN
18637	22420	12	varying	vary	VBG
18637	22420	13	degrees	degree	NNS
18637	22420	14	of	of	IN
18637	22420	15	training	training	NN
18637	22420	16	and	and	CC
18637	22420	17	intelligence	intelligence	NN
18637	22420	18	and	and	CC
18637	22420	19	with	with	IN
18637	22420	20	varying	vary	VBG
18637	22420	21	economic	economic	JJ
18637	22420	22	and	and	CC
18637	22420	23	social	social	JJ
18637	22420	24	positions	position	NNS
18637	22420	25	.	.	.
18637	22421	1	Under	under	IN
18637	22421	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22421	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22421	4	,	,	,
18637	22421	5	the	the	DT
18637	22421	6	jury	jury	NN
18637	22421	7	is	be	VBZ
18637	22421	8	not	not	RB
18637	22421	9	to	to	TO
18637	22421	10	be	be	VB
18637	22421	11	made	make	VBN
18637	22421	12	the	the	DT
18637	22421	13	representative	representative	NN
18637	22421	14	of	of	IN
18637	22421	15	the	the	DT
18637	22421	16	most	most	RBS
18637	22421	17	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
18637	22421	18	,	,	,
18637	22421	19	the	the	DT
18637	22421	20	most	most	RBS
18637	22421	21	wealthy	wealthy	JJ
18637	22421	22	or	or	CC
18637	22421	23	the	the	DT
18637	22421	24	most	most	RBS
18637	22421	25	successful	successful	JJ
18637	22421	26	,	,	,
18637	22421	27	nor	nor	CC
18637	22421	28	of	of	IN
18637	22421	29	the	the	DT
18637	22421	30	least	least	JJS
18637	22421	31	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
18637	22421	32	,	,	,
18637	22421	33	the	the	DT
18637	22421	34	least	least	RBS
18637	22421	35	wealthy	wealthy	JJ
18637	22421	36	or	or	CC
18637	22421	37	the	the	DT
18637	22421	38	least	least	RBS
18637	22421	39	successful	successful	JJ
18637	22421	40	.	.	.
18637	22422	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22422	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	22422	3	a	a	DT
18637	22422	4	democratic	democratic	JJ
18637	22422	5	institution	institution	NN
18637	22422	6	,	,	,
18637	22422	7	representative	representative	NN
18637	22422	8	of	of	IN
18637	22422	9	all	all	DT
18637	22422	10	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	22422	11	classes	class	NNS
18637	22422	12	of	of	IN
18637	22422	13	people	people	NNS
18637	22422	14	.	.	.
18637	22423	1	*	*	NFP
18637	22423	2	*	*	NFP
18637	22423	3	*	*	NFP
18637	22423	4	To	to	IN
18637	22423	5	the	the	DT
18637	22423	6	extent	extent	NN
18637	22423	7	that	that	IN
18637	22423	8	a	a	DT
18637	22423	9	'	'	``
18637	22423	10	blue	blue	JJ
18637	22423	11	ribbon	ribbon	NN
18637	22423	12	'	'	''
18637	22423	13	panel	panel	NN
18637	22423	14	fails	fail	VBZ
18637	22423	15	to	to	TO
18637	22423	16	reflect	reflect	VB
18637	22423	17	this	this	DT
18637	22423	18	democratic	democratic	JJ
18637	22423	19	principle	principle	NN
18637	22423	20	,	,	,
18637	22423	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22423	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	22423	23	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	22423	24	defective	defective	JJ
18637	22423	25	.	.	.
18637	22423	26	"	"	''
18637	22424	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22424	2	1217	1217	CD
18637	22424	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22424	4	112	112	CD
18637	22424	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22424	6	94	94	CD
18637	22424	7	,	,	,
18637	22424	8	102	102	CD
18637	22424	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22424	10	1884	1884	CD
18637	22424	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22424	12	.	.	.
18637	22425	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22425	2	1218	1218	CD
18637	22425	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22425	4	W.G.	W.G.	NNP
18637	22426	1	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	22426	2	,	,	,
18637	22426	3	Esq	Esq	NNP
18637	22426	4	.	.	NNP
18637	22426	5	,	,	,
18637	22426	6	Jr.	Jr.	NNP
18637	22426	7	,	,	,
18637	22426	8	University	University	NNP
18637	22426	9	of	of	IN
18637	22426	10	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	22426	11	Law	Law	NNP
18637	22426	12	School	School	NNP
18637	22426	13	,	,	,
18637	22426	14	The	the	DT
18637	22426	15	Position	position	NN
18637	22426	16	of	of	IN
18637	22426	17	the	the	DT
18637	22426	18	American	American	NNP
18637	22426	19	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	22426	20	in	in	IN
18637	22426	21	the	the	DT
18637	22426	22	Law	Law	NNP
18637	22426	23	of	of	IN
18637	22426	24	the	the	DT
18637	22426	25	United	United	NNP
18637	22426	26	States	States	NNP
18637	22426	27	,	,	,
18637	22426	28	16	16	CD
18637	22426	29	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	22426	30	of	of	IN
18637	22426	31	Comp	Comp	NNP
18637	22426	32	.	.	.
18637	22427	1	Leg	Leg	NNP
18637	22427	2	.	.	.
18637	22428	1	78	78	CD
18637	22428	2	,	,	,
18637	22428	3	80	80	CD
18637	22428	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22428	5	1934	1934	CD
18637	22428	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22428	7	.	.	.
18637	22429	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22429	2	1219	1219	CD
18637	22429	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22429	4	39	39	CD
18637	22429	5	Op	Op	NNP
18637	22429	6	.	.	.
18637	22430	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	22430	2	.	.	.
18637	22431	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	22431	2	518	518	CD
18637	22431	3	,	,	,
18637	22431	4	519	519	CD
18637	22431	5	.	.	.
18637	22432	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22432	2	1220	1220	CD
18637	22432	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22432	4	46	46	CD
18637	22432	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22432	6	.	.	.
18637	22433	1	26	26	CD
18637	22433	2	;	;	:
18637	22433	3	55	55	CD
18637	22433	4	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	22433	5	.	.	.
18637	22434	1	761	761	CD
18637	22434	2	;	;	:
18637	22434	3	2	2	CD
18637	22434	4	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	22435	1	§	§	NNP
18637	22435	2	2a	2a	NNP
18637	22435	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22435	4	a	a	NN
18637	22435	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22435	6	.	.	.
18637	22436	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22436	2	1221	1221	CD
18637	22436	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22436	4	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	22436	5	.	.	.
18637	22437	1	Rec	Rec	NNP
18637	22437	2	.	.	NNP
18637	22437	3	,	,	,
18637	22437	4	77th	77th	NNP
18637	22437	5	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	22437	6	.	.	NNP
18637	22437	7	,	,	,
18637	22437	8	1st	1st	JJ
18637	22437	9	sess	sess	NN
18637	22437	10	.	.	.
18637	22437	11	,	,	,
18637	22437	12	vol	vol	NNP
18637	22437	13	.	.	.
18637	22438	1	87	87	CD
18637	22438	2	,	,	,
18637	22438	3	p.	p.	NN
18637	22438	4	70	70	CD
18637	22438	5	,	,	,
18637	22438	6	January	January	NNP
18637	22438	7	8	8	CD
18637	22438	8	,	,	,
18637	22438	9	1941	1941	CD
18637	22438	10	.	.	.
18637	22439	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22439	2	1222	1222	CD
18637	22439	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22439	4	McPherson	McPherson	NNP
18637	22439	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22439	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22439	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22439	8	Blacker	Blacker	NNP
18637	22439	9	,	,	,
18637	22439	10	146	146	CD
18637	22439	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22439	12	1	1	CD
18637	22439	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22439	14	1892	1892	CD
18637	22439	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22439	16	;	;	:
18637	22439	17	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	22439	18	parte	parte	NN
18637	22439	19	Yarbrough	Yarbrough	NNP
18637	22439	20	,	,	,
18637	22439	21	110	110	CD
18637	22439	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22439	23	651	651	CD
18637	22439	24	,	,	,
18637	22439	25	663	663	CD
18637	22439	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22439	27	1884	1884	CD
18637	22439	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22439	29	.	.	.
18637	22440	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22440	2	1223	1223	CD
18637	22440	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22440	4	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
18637	22440	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22440	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22440	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22440	8	Wilkins	Wilkins	NNP
18637	22440	9	,	,	,
18637	22440	10	152	152	CD
18637	22440	11	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22440	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22440	13	2d	2d	NNP
18637	22440	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22440	15	235	235	CD
18637	22440	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22440	17	1945	1945	CD
18637	22440	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22440	19	;	;	:
18637	22440	20	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	22440	21	denied	deny	VBD
18637	22440	22	,	,	,
18637	22440	23	328	328	CD
18637	22440	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22440	25	870	870	CD
18637	22440	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22440	27	1946	1946	CD
18637	22440	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22440	29	;	;	:
18637	22440	30	rehearing	rehear	VBG
18637	22440	31	denied	deny	VBN
18637	22440	32	,	,	,
18637	22440	33	329	329	CD
18637	22440	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22440	35	825	825	CD
18637	22440	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22440	37	1946	1946	CD
18637	22440	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22440	39	.	.	.
18637	22441	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22441	2	1224	1224	CD
18637	22441	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22441	4	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
18637	22441	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22441	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22441	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22441	8	Wilkins	Wilkins	NNP
18637	22441	9	,	,	,
18637	22441	10	152	152	CD
18637	22441	11	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22441	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22441	13	2d	2d	NNP
18637	22441	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22441	15	235	235	CD
18637	22441	16	,	,	,
18637	22441	17	237	237	CD
18637	22441	18	-	-	SYM
18637	22441	19	238	238	CD
18637	22441	20	,	,	,
18637	22441	21	citing	cite	VBG
18637	22441	22	Willoughby	Willoughby	NNP
18637	22441	23	,	,	,
18637	22441	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22441	25	,	,	,
18637	22441	26	2d	2d	NNP
18637	22441	27	ed	ed	NNP
18637	22441	28	.	.	NNP
18637	22441	29	,	,	,
18637	22441	30	pp	pp	NNP
18637	22441	31	.	.	.
18637	22442	1	626	626	CD
18637	22442	2	,	,	,
18637	22442	3	627	627	CD
18637	22442	4	.	.	.
18637	22443	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22443	2	1225	1225	CD
18637	22443	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22443	4	Legislation	legislation	NN
18637	22443	5	by	by	IN
18637	22443	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22443	7	providing	provide	VBG
18637	22443	8	for	for	IN
18637	22443	9	removal	removal	NN
18637	22443	10	was	be	VBD
18637	22443	11	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	22443	12	to	to	TO
18637	22443	13	give	give	VB
18637	22443	14	effect	effect	NN
18637	22443	15	to	to	IN
18637	22443	16	the	the	DT
18637	22443	17	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	22443	18	of	of	IN
18637	22443	19	section	section	NN
18637	22443	20	3	3	CD
18637	22443	21	;	;	:
18637	22443	22	and	and	CC
18637	22443	23	until	until	IN
18637	22443	24	removed	remove	VBN
18637	22443	25	in	in	IN
18637	22443	26	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	22443	27	of	of	IN
18637	22443	28	such	such	JJ
18637	22443	29	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	22443	30	,	,	,
18637	22443	31	the	the	DT
18637	22443	32	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	22443	33	of	of	IN
18637	22443	34	functions	function	NNS
18637	22443	35	by	by	IN
18637	22443	36	persons	person	NNS
18637	22443	37	in	in	IN
18637	22443	38	office	office	NN
18637	22443	39	before	before	IN
18637	22443	40	promulgation	promulgation	NN
18637	22443	41	of	of	IN
18637	22443	42	the	the	DT
18637	22443	43	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	22443	44	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22443	45	was	be	VBD
18637	22443	46	not	not	RB
18637	22443	47	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	22443	48	.	.	.
18637	22444	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22444	2	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	22444	3	's	's	POS
18637	22444	4	Case	Case	NNP
18637	22444	5	,	,	,
18637	22444	6	11	11	CD
18637	22444	7	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	22444	8	.	.	.
18637	22445	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	22445	2	.	.	.
18637	22446	1	No	no	UH
18637	22446	2	.	.	.
18637	22447	1	5815	5815	CD
18637	22447	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22447	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	22447	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22447	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22447	6	.	.	.
18637	22448	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	22448	2	were	be	VBD
18637	22448	3	persons	person	NNS
18637	22448	4	who	who	WP
18637	22448	5	had	have	VBD
18637	22448	6	taken	take	VBN
18637	22448	7	part	part	NN
18637	22448	8	in	in	IN
18637	22448	9	the	the	DT
18637	22448	10	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	22448	11	War	War	NNP
18637	22448	12	and	and	CC
18637	22448	13	had	have	VBD
18637	22448	14	been	be	VBN
18637	22448	15	pardoned	pardon	VBN
18637	22448	16	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	22448	17	by	by	IN
18637	22448	18	the	the	DT
18637	22448	19	President	President	NNP
18637	22448	20	before	before	IN
18637	22448	21	the	the	DT
18637	22448	22	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	22448	23	of	of	IN
18637	22448	24	this	this	DT
18637	22448	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22448	26	precluded	preclude	VBN
18637	22448	27	by	by	IN
18637	22448	28	this	this	DT
18637	22448	29	section	section	NN
18637	22448	30	from	from	IN
18637	22448	31	again	again	RB
18637	22448	32	holding	hold	VBG
18637	22448	33	office	office	NN
18637	22448	34	under	under	IN
18637	22448	35	the	the	DT
18637	22448	36	United	United	NNP
18637	22448	37	States	States	NNP
18637	22448	38	.	.	.
18637	22449	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22449	2	18	18	CD
18637	22449	3	Op	Op	NNP
18637	22449	4	.	.	.
18637	22450	1	Atty	atty	RB
18637	22450	2	.	.	.
18637	22451	1	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
18637	22451	2	149	149	CD
18637	22451	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22451	4	1885	1885	CD
18637	22451	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22451	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22451	7	.	.	.
18637	22452	1	The	the	DT
18637	22452	2	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	22452	3	,	,	,
18637	22452	4	"	"	``
18637	22452	5	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	22452	6	in	in	IN
18637	22452	7	Rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	22452	8	"	"	''
18637	22452	9	has	have	VBZ
18637	22452	10	been	be	VBN
18637	22452	11	construed	construe	VBN
18637	22452	12	as	as	IN
18637	22452	13	implying	imply	VBG
18637	22452	14	a	a	DT
18637	22452	15	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
18637	22452	16	effort	effort	NN
18637	22452	17	to	to	TO
18637	22452	18	assist	assist	VB
18637	22452	19	an	an	DT
18637	22452	20	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	22452	21	and	and	CC
18637	22452	22	to	to	TO
18637	22452	23	bring	bring	VB
18637	22452	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22452	25	to	to	IN
18637	22452	26	a	a	DT
18637	22452	27	successful	successful	JJ
18637	22452	28	termination	termination	NN
18637	22452	29	;	;	:
18637	22452	30	and	and	CC
18637	22452	31	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	22452	32	as	as	IN
18637	22452	33	not	not	RB
18637	22452	34	embracing	embrace	VBG
18637	22452	35	acts	act	NNS
18637	22452	36	done	do	VBN
18637	22452	37	under	under	IN
18637	22452	38	compulsion	compulsion	NN
18637	22452	39	of	of	IN
18637	22452	40	force	force	NN
18637	22452	41	or	or	CC
18637	22452	42	of	of	IN
18637	22452	43	a	a	DT
18637	22452	44	well	well	RB
18637	22452	45	grounded	ground	VBN
18637	22452	46	fear	fear	NN
18637	22452	47	of	of	IN
18637	22452	48	bodily	bodily	JJ
18637	22452	49	harm	harm	NN
18637	22452	50	.	.	.
18637	22453	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	22453	2	,	,	,
18637	22453	3	while	while	IN
18637	22453	4	the	the	DT
18637	22453	5	mere	mere	JJ
18637	22453	6	holding	holding	NN
18637	22453	7	of	of	IN
18637	22453	8	a	a	DT
18637	22453	9	commission	commission	NN
18637	22453	10	of	of	IN
18637	22453	11	justice	justice	NN
18637	22453	12	of	of	IN
18637	22453	13	the	the	DT
18637	22453	14	peace	peace	NN
18637	22453	15	under	under	IN
18637	22453	16	the	the	DT
18637	22453	17	Confederate	Confederate	NNP
18637	22453	18	government	government	NN
18637	22453	19	was	be	VBD
18637	22453	20	not	not	RB
18637	22453	21	viewed	view	VBN
18637	22453	22	as	as	IN
18637	22453	23	involving	involve	VBG
18637	22453	24	,	,	,
18637	22453	25	of	of	IN
18637	22453	26	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22453	27	,	,	,
18637	22453	28	"	"	``
18637	22453	29	adherence	adherence	NN
18637	22453	30	or	or	CC
18637	22453	31	countenance	countenance	NN
18637	22453	32	to	to	IN
18637	22453	33	the	the	DT
18637	22453	34	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
18637	22453	35	,	,	,
18637	22453	36	"	"	''
18637	22453	37	action	action	NN
18637	22453	38	by	by	IN
18637	22453	39	such	such	JJ
18637	22453	40	officer	officer	NN
18637	22453	41	in	in	IN
18637	22453	42	furnishing	furnish	VBG
18637	22453	43	a	a	DT
18637	22453	44	substitute	substitute	NN
18637	22453	45	for	for	IN
18637	22453	46	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22453	47	to	to	IN
18637	22453	48	the	the	DT
18637	22453	49	Confederate	Confederate	NNP
18637	22453	50	Army	Army	NNP
18637	22453	51	amounted	amount	VBD
18637	22453	52	to	to	IN
18637	22453	53	such	such	JJ
18637	22453	54	participation	participation	NN
18637	22453	55	in	in	IN
18637	22453	56	a	a	DT
18637	22453	57	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
18637	22453	58	unless	unless	IN
18637	22453	59	said	say	VBD
18637	22453	60	action	action	NN
18637	22453	61	could	could	MD
18637	22453	62	be	be	VB
18637	22453	63	shown	show	VBN
18637	22453	64	to	to	TO
18637	22453	65	have	have	VB
18637	22453	66	resulted	result	VBN
18637	22453	67	from	from	IN
18637	22453	68	fear	fear	NN
18637	22453	69	of	of	IN
18637	22453	70	conscription	conscription	NN
18637	22453	71	and	and	CC
18637	22453	72	to	to	TO
18637	22453	73	have	have	VB
18637	22453	74	sprung	spring	VBN
18637	22453	75	,	,	,
18637	22453	76	not	not	RB
18637	22453	77	from	from	IN
18637	22453	78	repugnance	repugnance	NN
18637	22453	79	to	to	IN
18637	22453	80	military	military	JJ
18637	22453	81	service	service	NN
18637	22453	82	,	,	,
18637	22453	83	but	but	CC
18637	22453	84	from	from	IN
18637	22453	85	want	want	NN
18637	22453	86	of	of	IN
18637	22453	87	sympathy	sympathy	NN
18637	22453	88	with	with	IN
18637	22453	89	the	the	DT
18637	22453	90	insurrectionary	insurrectionary	JJ
18637	22453	91	movement	movement	NN
18637	22453	92	.	.	.
18637	22454	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22454	2	United	United	NNP
18637	22454	3	States	States	NNP
18637	22454	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22454	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	22454	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22454	7	Powell	Powell	NNP
18637	22454	8	,	,	,
18637	22454	9	27	27	CD
18637	22454	10	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	22454	11	.	.	.
18637	22455	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	22455	2	.	.	.
18637	22456	1	No	no	UH
18637	22456	2	.	.	.
18637	22457	1	16,079	16,079	CD
18637	22457	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22457	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	22457	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22457	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22457	6	.	.	.
18637	22458	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22458	2	1226	1226	CD
18637	22458	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22458	4	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	22458	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22458	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22458	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22458	8	United	United	NNP
18637	22458	9	States	States	NNP
18637	22458	10	,	,	,
18637	22458	11	294	294	CD
18637	22458	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22458	13	330	330	CD
18637	22458	14	,	,	,
18637	22458	15	354	354	CD
18637	22458	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22458	17	1935	1935	CD
18637	22458	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22458	19	in	in	IN
18637	22458	20	which	which	WDT
18637	22458	21	the	the	DT
18637	22458	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22458	23	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	22458	24	"	"	``
18637	22458	25	that	that	IN
18637	22458	26	the	the	DT
18637	22458	27	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	22458	28	Resolution	Resolution	NNP
18637	22458	29	of	of	IN
18637	22458	30	June	June	NNP
18637	22458	31	5	5	CD
18637	22458	32	,	,	,
18637	22458	33	1933	1933	CD
18637	22458	34	,	,	,
18637	22458	35	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	22458	36	as	as	IN
18637	22458	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22458	38	attempted	attempt	VBD
18637	22458	39	to	to	TO
18637	22458	40	override	override	VB
18637	22458	41	"	"	``
18637	22458	42	the	the	DT
18637	22458	43	gold	gold	NN
18637	22458	44	-	-	HYPH
18637	22458	45	clause	clause	NN
18637	22458	46	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	22458	47	in	in	IN
18637	22458	48	a	a	DT
18637	22458	49	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	22458	50	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	22458	51	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	22458	52	Gold	Gold	NNP
18637	22458	53	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	22458	54	,	,	,
18637	22458	55	"	"	''
18637	22458	56	went	go	VBD
18637	22458	57	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	22458	58	the	the	DT
18637	22458	59	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	22458	60	power	power	NN
18637	22458	61	.	.	.
18637	22458	62	"	"	''
18637	22459	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22459	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22459	3	also	also	RB
18637	22459	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22459	5	Branch	Branch	NNP
18637	22459	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22459	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22459	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22459	9	Haas	Haas	NNP
18637	22459	10	,	,	,
18637	22459	11	16	16	CD
18637	22459	12	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22459	13	53	53	CD
18637	22459	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22459	15	1883	1883	CD
18637	22459	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22459	17	,	,	,
18637	22459	18	citing	cite	VBG
18637	22459	19	Hanauer	Hanauer	NNP
18637	22459	20	_	_	NNP
18637	22459	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	22459	22	_	_	NNP
18637	22459	23	Woodruff	Woodruff	NNP
18637	22459	24	,	,	,
18637	22459	25	15	15	CD
18637	22459	26	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	22459	27	.	.	.
18637	22460	1	439	439	CD
18637	22460	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22460	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	22460	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22460	5	and	and	CC
18637	22460	6	Thorington	Thorington	NNP
18637	22460	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22460	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22460	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22460	10	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	22460	11	,	,	,
18637	22460	12	8	8	CD
18637	22460	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	22460	14	.	.	.
18637	22461	1	1	1	CD
18637	22461	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22461	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	22461	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22461	5	in	in	IN
18637	22461	6	which	which	WDT
18637	22461	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22461	8	was	be	VBD
18637	22461	9	held	hold	VBN
18637	22461	10	that	that	DT
18637	22461	11	inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	22461	12	as	as	IN
18637	22461	13	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	22461	14	issued	issue	VBN
18637	22461	15	by	by	IN
18637	22461	16	the	the	DT
18637	22461	17	Confederate	Confederate	NNP
18637	22461	18	States	States	NNPS
18637	22461	19	were	be	VBD
18637	22461	20	rendered	render	VBN
18637	22461	21	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	22461	22	by	by	IN
18637	22461	23	section	section	NN
18637	22461	24	four	four	CD
18637	22461	25	,	,	,
18637	22461	26	a	a	DT
18637	22461	27	contract	contract	NN
18637	22461	28	for	for	IN
18637	22461	29	the	the	DT
18637	22461	30	sale	sale	NN
18637	22461	31	and	and	CC
18637	22461	32	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	22461	33	before	before	IN
18637	22461	34	October	October	NNP
18637	22461	35	29	29	CD
18637	22461	36	,	,	,
18637	22461	37	1881	1881	CD
18637	22461	38	of	of	IN
18637	22461	39	200	200	CD
18637	22461	40	Confederate	Confederate	NNP
18637	22461	41	coupon	coupon	NN
18637	22461	42	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	22461	43	at	at	IN
18637	22461	44	the	the	DT
18637	22461	45	rate	rate	NN
18637	22461	46	of	of	IN
18637	22461	47	$	$	$
18637	22461	48	1000	1000	CD
18637	22461	49	was	be	VBD
18637	22461	50	void	void	JJ
18637	22461	51	,	,	,
18637	22461	52	and	and	CC
18637	22461	53	a	a	DT
18637	22461	54	suit	suit	NN
18637	22461	55	for	for	IN
18637	22461	56	damages	damage	NNS
18637	22461	57	for	for	IN
18637	22461	58	failure	failure	NN
18637	22461	59	to	to	TO
18637	22461	60	deliver	deliver	VB
18637	22461	61	could	could	MD
18637	22461	62	not	not	RB
18637	22461	63	be	be	VB
18637	22461	64	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	22461	65	.	.	.
18637	22462	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22462	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22462	3	also	also	RB
18637	22462	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22462	5	The	the	DT
18637	22462	6	Pietro	Pietro	NNP
18637	22462	7	Campanella	Campanella	NNP
18637	22462	8	,	,	,
18637	22462	9	73	73	CD
18637	22462	10	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22462	11	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	22462	12	.	.	.
18637	22463	1	18	18	CD
18637	22463	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22463	3	1947	1947	CD
18637	22463	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22463	5	which	which	WDT
18637	22463	6	arose	arise	VBD
18637	22463	7	out	out	IN
18637	22463	8	of	of	IN
18637	22463	9	a	a	DT
18637	22463	10	suit	suit	NN
18637	22463	11	for	for	IN
18637	22463	12	the	the	DT
18637	22463	13	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	22463	14	,	,	,
18637	22463	15	prior	prior	RB
18637	22463	16	to	to	IN
18637	22463	17	our	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22463	18	entry	entry	NN
18637	22463	19	into	into	IN
18637	22463	20	World	World	NNP
18637	22463	21	War	War	NNP
18637	22463	22	II	II	NNP
18637	22463	23	,	,	,
18637	22463	24	of	of	IN
18637	22463	25	Italian	italian	JJ
18637	22463	26	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	22463	27	in	in	IN
18637	22463	28	an	an	DT
18637	22463	29	American	american	JJ
18637	22463	30	port	port	NN
18637	22463	31	and	and	CC
18637	22463	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22463	33	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	22463	34	requisition	requisition	NN
18637	22463	35	by	by	IN
18637	22463	36	the	the	DT
18637	22463	37	Maritime	Maritime	NNP
18637	22463	38	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	22463	39	.	.	.
18637	22464	1	The	the	DT
18637	22464	2	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	22464	3	General	General	NNP
18637	22464	4	,	,	,
18637	22464	5	as	as	IN
18637	22464	6	successor	successor	NN
18637	22464	7	to	to	IN
18637	22464	8	the	the	DT
18637	22464	9	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	22464	10	Property	Property	NNP
18637	22464	11	Custodian	Custodian	NNP
18637	22464	12	,	,	,
18637	22464	13	was	be	VBD
18637	22464	14	declared	declare	VBN
18637	22464	15	to	to	TO
18637	22464	16	be	be	VB
18637	22464	17	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	22464	18	to	to	IN
18637	22464	19	the	the	DT
18637	22464	20	fund	fund	NN
18637	22464	21	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	22464	22	determined	determined	JJ
18637	22464	23	to	to	TO
18637	22464	24	be	be	VB
18637	22464	25	due	due	JJ
18637	22464	26	as	as	IN
18637	22464	27	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	22464	28	for	for	IN
18637	22464	29	the	the	DT
18637	22464	30	use	use	NN
18637	22464	31	and	and	CC
18637	22464	32	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	22464	33	loss	loss	NN
18637	22464	34	of	of	IN
18637	22464	35	the	the	DT
18637	22464	36	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	22464	37	;	;	:
18637	22464	38	and	and	CC
18637	22464	39	the	the	DT
18637	22464	40	order	order	NN
18637	22464	41	of	of	IN
18637	22464	42	the	the	DT
18637	22464	43	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	22464	44	Property	Property	NNP
18637	22464	45	Custodian	Custodian	NNP
18637	22464	46	vesting	vest	VBG
18637	22464	47	in	in	IN
18637	22464	48	himself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22464	49	,	,	,
18637	22464	50	for	for	IN
18637	22464	51	the	the	DT
18637	22464	52	United	United	NNP
18637	22464	53	States	States	NNP
18637	22464	54	,	,	,
18637	22464	55	under	under	IN
18637	22464	56	authority	authority	NN
18637	22464	57	of	of	IN
18637	22464	58	the	the	DT
18637	22464	59	Trading	trading	NN
18637	22464	60	with	with	IN
18637	22464	61	the	the	DT
18637	22464	62	Enemy	Enemy	NNP
18637	22464	63	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22464	64	and	and	CC
18637	22464	65	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	22464	66	Order	Order	NNP
18637	22464	67	,	,	,
18637	22464	68	all	all	DT
18637	22464	69	rights	right	NNS
18637	22464	70	of	of	IN
18637	22464	71	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	22464	72	in	in	IN
18637	22464	73	the	the	DT
18637	22464	74	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	22464	75	and	and	CC
18637	22464	76	to	to	IN
18637	22464	77	the	the	DT
18637	22464	78	fund	fund	NN
18637	22464	79	substituted	substitute	VBN
18637	22464	80	therefor	therefor	IN
18637	22464	81	was	be	VBD
18637	22464	82	held	hold	VBN
18637	22464	83	not	not	RB
18637	22464	84	to	to	TO
18637	22464	85	be	be	VB
18637	22464	86	a	a	DT
18637	22464	87	violation	violation	NN
18637	22464	88	of	of	IN
18637	22464	89	section	section	NN
18637	22464	90	four	four	CD
18637	22464	91	.	.	.
18637	22465	1	An	an	DT
18637	22465	2	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	22465	3	for	for	IN
18637	22465	4	certain	certain	JJ
18637	22465	5	of	of	IN
18637	22465	6	the	the	DT
18637	22465	7	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	22465	8	,	,	,
18637	22465	9	who	who	WP
18637	22465	10	had	have	VBD
18637	22465	11	asserted	assert	VBN
18637	22465	12	a	a	DT
18637	22465	13	personal	personal	JJ
18637	22465	14	right	right	NN
18637	22465	15	to	to	IN
18637	22465	16	a	a	DT
18637	22465	17	lien	lien	NN
18637	22465	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	22465	19	the	the	DT
18637	22465	20	fund	fund	NN
18637	22465	21	for	for	IN
18637	22465	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22465	23	services	service	NNS
18637	22465	24	,	,	,
18637	22465	25	had	have	VBD
18637	22465	26	argued	argue	VBN
18637	22465	27	that	that	IN
18637	22465	28	when	when	WRB
18637	22465	29	the	the	DT
18637	22465	30	Government	Government	NNP
18637	22465	31	requisitioned	requisition	VBD
18637	22465	32	ships	ship	NNS
18637	22465	33	under	under	IN
18637	22465	34	the	the	DT
18637	22465	35	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	22465	36	statute	statute	NN
18637	22465	37	providing	provide	VBG
18637	22465	38	for	for	IN
18637	22465	39	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	22465	40	,	,	,
18637	22465	41	and	and	CC
18637	22465	42	at	at	IN
18637	22465	43	a	a	DT
18637	22465	44	time	time	NN
18637	22465	45	before	before	IN
18637	22465	46	this	this	DT
18637	22465	47	country	country	NN
18637	22465	48	was	be	VBD
18637	22465	49	at	at	IN
18637	22465	50	war	war	NN
18637	22465	51	with	with	IN
18637	22465	52	Italy	Italy	NNP
18637	22465	53	,	,	,
18637	22465	54	the	the	DT
18637	22465	55	United	United	NNP
18637	22465	56	States	States	NNP
18637	22465	57	entered	enter	VBD
18637	22465	58	into	into	IN
18637	22465	59	a	a	DT
18637	22465	60	binding	bind	VBG
18637	22465	61	agreement	agreement	NN
18637	22465	62	with	with	IN
18637	22465	63	the	the	DT
18637	22465	64	owners	owner	NNS
18637	22465	65	for	for	IN
18637	22465	66	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	22465	67	and	and	CC
18637	22465	68	that	that	IN
18637	22465	69	this	this	DT
18637	22465	70	promise	promise	NN
18637	22465	71	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	22465	72	a	a	DT
18637	22465	73	valid	valid	JJ
18637	22465	74	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	22465	75	of	of	IN
18637	22465	76	the	the	DT
18637	22465	77	United	United	NNP
18637	22465	78	States	States	NNP
18637	22465	79	which	which	WDT
18637	22465	80	could	could	MD
18637	22465	81	not	not	RB
18637	22465	82	be	be	VB
18637	22465	83	repudiated	repudiate	VBN
18637	22465	84	without	without	IN
18637	22465	85	violating	violate	VBG
18637	22465	86	section	section	NN
18637	22465	87	four	four	CD
18637	22465	88	.	.	.
18637	22466	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22466	2	1227	1227	CD
18637	22466	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22466	4	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	22466	5	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	22466	6	Cases	case	NNS
18637	22466	7	,	,	,
18637	22466	8	109	109	CD
18637	22466	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22466	10	3	3	CD
18637	22466	11	,	,	,
18637	22466	12	13	13	CD
18637	22466	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22466	14	1883	1883	CD
18637	22466	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22466	16	.	.	.
18637	22467	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22467	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22467	3	also	also	RB
18637	22467	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22467	5	United	United	NNP
18637	22467	6	States	States	NNP
18637	22467	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22467	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22467	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22467	10	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	22467	11	,	,	,
18637	22467	12	254	254	CD
18637	22467	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22467	14	281	281	CD
18637	22467	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22467	16	1920	1920	CD
18637	22467	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22467	18	on	on	IN
18637	22467	19	which	which	WDT
18637	22467	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22467	21	was	be	VBD
18637	22467	22	held	hold	VBN
18637	22467	23	that	that	IN
18637	22467	24	the	the	DT
18637	22467	25	United	United	NNP
18637	22467	26	States	States	NNP
18637	22467	27	is	be	VBZ
18637	22467	28	without	without	IN
18637	22467	29	power	power	NN
18637	22467	30	to	to	TO
18637	22467	31	punish	punish	VB
18637	22467	32	infractions	infraction	NNS
18637	22467	33	by	by	IN
18637	22467	34	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	22467	35	of	of	IN
18637	22467	36	the	the	DT
18637	22467	37	right	right	NN
18637	22467	38	of	of	IN
18637	22467	39	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	22467	40	to	to	TO
18637	22467	41	reside	reside	VB
18637	22467	42	peacefully	peacefully	RB
18637	22467	43	in	in	IN
18637	22467	44	the	the	DT
18637	22467	45	several	several	JJ
18637	22467	46	States	States	NNPS
18637	22467	47	,	,	,
18637	22467	48	and	and	CC
18637	22467	49	to	to	TO
18637	22467	50	have	have	VB
18637	22467	51	free	free	JJ
18637	22467	52	ingress	ingress	NN
18637	22467	53	into	into	IN
18637	22467	54	and	and	CC
18637	22467	55	egress	egress	NN
18637	22467	56	from	from	IN
18637	22467	57	such	such	JJ
18637	22467	58	States	state	NNS
18637	22467	59	.	.	.
18637	22468	1	Authority	authority	NN
18637	22468	2	to	to	TO
18637	22468	3	deal	deal	VB
18637	22468	4	with	with	IN
18637	22468	5	the	the	DT
18637	22468	6	forcible	forcible	JJ
18637	22468	7	eviction	eviction	NN
18637	22468	8	by	by	IN
18637	22468	9	a	a	DT
18637	22468	10	mob	mob	NN
18637	22468	11	of	of	IN
18637	22468	12	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	22468	13	across	across	IN
18637	22468	14	State	State	NNP
18637	22468	15	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	22468	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	22468	17	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	22468	18	within	within	IN
18637	22468	19	the	the	DT
18637	22468	20	power	power	NN
18637	22468	21	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	22468	22	by	by	IN
18637	22468	23	the	the	DT
18637	22468	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22468	25	to	to	IN
18637	22468	26	the	the	DT
18637	22468	27	States	States	NNP
18637	22468	28	.	.	.
18637	22469	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22469	2	1228	1228	CD
18637	22469	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22469	4	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	22469	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22469	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22469	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22469	8	Rives	Rives	NNP
18637	22469	9	,	,	,
18637	22469	10	100	100	CD
18637	22469	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22469	12	313	313	CD
18637	22469	13	,	,	,
18637	22469	14	318	318	CD
18637	22469	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22469	16	1880	1880	CD
18637	22469	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22469	18	;	;	:
18637	22469	19	Strauder	Strauder	NNP
18637	22469	20	_	_	NNP
18637	22469	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	22469	22	_	_	NNP
18637	22469	23	West	West	NNP
18637	22469	24	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	22469	25	,	,	,
18637	22469	26	100	100	CD
18637	22469	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22469	28	303	303	CD
18637	22469	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22469	30	1880	1880	CD
18637	22469	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22469	32	.	.	.
18637	22470	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22470	2	1229	1229	CD
18637	22470	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22470	4	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	22470	5	parte	parte	NN
18637	22470	6	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	22470	7	,	,	,
18637	22470	8	100	100	CD
18637	22470	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22470	10	339	339	CD
18637	22470	11	,	,	,
18637	22470	12	344	344	CD
18637	22470	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22470	14	1880	1880	CD
18637	22470	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22470	16	.	.	.
18637	22471	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22471	2	1230	1230	CD
18637	22471	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22471	4	United	United	NNP
18637	22471	5	States	States	NNP
18637	22471	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22471	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22471	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22471	9	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	22471	10	,	,	,
18637	22471	11	106	106	CD
18637	22471	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22471	13	629	629	CD
18637	22471	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22471	15	1883	1883	CD
18637	22471	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22471	17	.	.	.
18637	22472	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22472	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22472	3	also	also	RB
18637	22472	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22472	5	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	22472	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22472	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22472	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22472	9	Franks	Franks	NNP
18637	22472	10	,	,	,
18637	22472	11	120	120	CD
18637	22472	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22472	13	678	678	CD
18637	22472	14	,	,	,
18637	22472	15	685	685	CD
18637	22472	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22472	17	1887	1887	CD
18637	22472	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22472	19	.	.	.
18637	22473	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22473	2	1231	1231	CD
18637	22473	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22473	4	325	325	CD
18637	22473	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22473	6	91	91	CD
18637	22473	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22473	8	1945	1945	CD
18637	22473	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22473	10	.	.	.
18637	22474	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22474	2	1232	1232	CD
18637	22474	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22474	4	18	18	CD
18637	22474	5	U.S.C.A.	u.s.c.a.	NN
18637	22475	1	§	§	NNP
18637	22475	2	242	242	CD
18637	22475	3	.	.	.
18637	22476	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22476	2	1233	1233	CD
18637	22476	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22476	4	No	no	DT
18637	22476	5	"	"	``
18637	22476	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	22476	7	of	of	IN
18637	22476	8	the	the	DT
18637	22476	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22476	10	"	"	''
18637	22476	11	was	be	VBD
18637	22476	12	given	give	VBN
18637	22476	13	.	.	.
18637	22477	1	In	in	IN
18637	22477	2	announcing	announce	VBG
18637	22477	3	the	the	DT
18637	22477	4	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	22477	5	of	of	IN
18637	22477	6	the	the	DT
18637	22477	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22477	8	,	,	,
18637	22477	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22477	10	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	22477	11	,	,	,
18637	22477	12	who	who	WP
18637	22477	13	was	be	VBD
18637	22477	14	joined	join	VBN
18637	22477	15	by	by	IN
18637	22477	16	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	22477	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22477	18	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	22477	19	and	and	CC
18637	22477	20	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	22477	21	Black	Black	NNP
18637	22477	22	and	and	CC
18637	22477	23	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	22477	24	,	,	,
18637	22477	25	declared	declare	VBD
18637	22477	26	that	that	IN
18637	22477	27	the	the	DT
18637	22477	28	trial	trial	NN
18637	22477	29	judge	judge	NN
18637	22477	30	had	have	VBD
18637	22477	31	erred	err	VBN
18637	22477	32	in	in	IN
18637	22477	33	not	not	RB
18637	22477	34	charging	charge	VBG
18637	22477	35	the	the	DT
18637	22477	36	jury	jury	NN
18637	22477	37	that	that	IN
18637	22477	38	the	the	DT
18637	22477	39	defendants	defendant	NNS
18637	22477	40	must	must	MD
18637	22477	41	be	be	VB
18637	22477	42	found	find	VBN
18637	22477	43	to	to	TO
18637	22477	44	have	have	VB
18637	22477	45	had	have	VBN
18637	22477	46	the	the	DT
18637	22477	47	specific	specific	JJ
18637	22477	48	intention	intention	NN
18637	22477	49	of	of	IN
18637	22477	50	depriving	deprive	VBG
18637	22477	51	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22477	52	victim	victim	NN
18637	22477	53	of	of	IN
18637	22477	54	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22477	55	right	right	NN
18637	22477	56	to	to	IN
18637	22477	57	a	a	DT
18637	22477	58	fair	fair	JJ
18637	22477	59	trial	trial	NN
18637	22477	60	in	in	IN
18637	22477	61	accordance	accordance	NN
18637	22477	62	with	with	IN
18637	22477	63	due	due	JJ
18637	22477	64	process	process	NN
18637	22477	65	of	of	IN
18637	22477	66	law	law	NN
18637	22477	67	,	,	,
18637	22477	68	that	that	IN
18637	22477	69	this	this	DT
18637	22477	70	was	be	VBD
18637	22477	71	the	the	DT
18637	22477	72	force	force	NN
18637	22477	73	of	of	IN
18637	22477	74	the	the	DT
18637	22477	75	word	word	NN
18637	22477	76	,	,	,
18637	22477	77	"	"	``
18637	22477	78	willfully	willfully	RB
18637	22477	79	,	,	,
18637	22477	80	"	"	''
18637	22477	81	in	in	IN
18637	22477	82	section	section	NN
18637	22477	83	20	20	CD
18637	22477	84	,	,	,
18637	22477	85	and	and	CC
18637	22477	86	that	that	IN
18637	22477	87	any	any	DT
18637	22477	88	other	other	JJ
18637	22477	89	construction	construction	NN
18637	22477	90	of	of	IN
18637	22477	91	section	section	NN
18637	22477	92	20	20	CD
18637	22477	93	would	would	MD
18637	22477	94	be	be	VB
18637	22477	95	void	void	JJ
18637	22477	96	for	for	IN
18637	22477	97	want	want	NN
18637	22477	98	of	of	IN
18637	22477	99	laying	lay	VBG
18637	22477	100	down	down	RP
18637	22477	101	an	an	DT
18637	22477	102	"	"	``
18637	22477	103	ascertainable	ascertainable	JJ
18637	22477	104	standard	standard	NN
18637	22477	105	of	of	IN
18637	22477	106	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	22477	107	.	.	.
18637	22477	108	"	"	''
18637	22478	1	To	to	TO
18637	22478	2	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	22478	3	a	a	DT
18637	22478	4	stalemate	stalemate	NN
18637	22478	5	on	on	IN
18637	22478	6	the	the	DT
18637	22478	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22478	8	,	,	,
18637	22478	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22478	10	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
18637	22478	11	concurred	concur	VBD
18637	22478	12	in	in	IN
18637	22478	13	the	the	DT
18637	22478	14	result	result	NN
18637	22478	15	;	;	:
18637	22478	16	but	but	CC
18637	22478	17	,	,	,
18637	22478	18	on	on	IN
18637	22478	19	the	the	DT
18637	22478	20	merits	merit	NNS
18637	22478	21	of	of	IN
18637	22478	22	the	the	DT
18637	22478	23	case	case	NN
18637	22478	24	,	,	,
18637	22478	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22478	26	would	would	MD
18637	22478	27	have	have	VB
18637	22478	28	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	22478	29	the	the	DT
18637	22478	30	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	22478	31	.	.	.
18637	22479	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22479	2	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	22479	3	announced	announce	VBD
18637	22479	4	that	that	IN
18637	22479	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22479	6	favored	favor	VBD
18637	22479	7	affirming	affirm	VBG
18637	22479	8	the	the	DT
18637	22479	9	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	22479	10	and	and	CC
18637	22479	11	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	22479	12	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	22479	13	.	.	.
18637	22480	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22480	2	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	22480	3	,	,	,
18637	22480	4	with	with	IN
18637	22480	5	whom	whom	WP
18637	22480	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	22480	7	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	22480	8	and	and	CC
18637	22480	9	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	22480	10	were	be	VBD
18637	22480	11	associated	associate	VBN
18637	22480	12	,	,	,
18637	22480	13	dissented	dissent	VBN
18637	22480	14	for	for	IN
18637	22480	15	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	22480	16	stated	state	VBN
18637	22480	17	in	in	IN
18637	22480	18	the	the	DT
18637	22480	19	text	text	NN
18637	22480	20	.	.	.
18637	22481	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22481	2	1234	1234	CD
18637	22481	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22481	4	100	100	CD
18637	22481	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22481	6	339	339	CD
18637	22481	7	,	,	,
18637	22481	8	346	346	CD
18637	22481	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22481	10	1880	1880	CD
18637	22481	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22481	12	.	.	.
18637	22482	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22482	2	1235	1235	CD
18637	22482	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22482	4	313	313	CD
18637	22482	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22482	6	299	299	CD
18637	22482	7	,	,	,
18637	22482	8	326	326	CD
18637	22482	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22482	10	1941	1941	CD
18637	22482	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22482	12	.	.	.
18637	22483	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22483	2	1236	1236	CD
18637	22483	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22483	4	325	325	CD
18637	22483	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22483	6	91	91	CD
18637	22483	7	,	,	,
18637	22483	8	114	114	CD
18637	22483	9	-	-	SYM
18637	22483	10	116	116	CD
18637	22483	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22483	12	1945	1945	CD
18637	22483	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22483	14	.	.	.
18637	22484	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22484	2	But	but	CC
18637	22484	3	see	see	VB
18637	22484	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22484	5	Barney	Barney	NNP
18637	22484	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22484	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22484	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22484	9	City	City	NNP
18637	22484	10	of	of	IN
18637	22484	11	New	New	NNP
18637	22484	12	York	York	NNP
18637	22484	13	,	,	,
18637	22484	14	193	193	CD
18637	22484	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22484	16	430	430	CD
18637	22484	17	,	,	,
18637	22484	18	438	438	CD
18637	22484	19	,	,	,
18637	22484	20	441	441	CD
18637	22484	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22484	22	1904	1904	CD
18637	22484	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22484	24	.	.	.
18637	22485	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22485	2	1237	1237	CD
18637	22485	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22485	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	22485	5	.	.	.
18637	22486	1	106	106	CD
18637	22486	2	-	-	SYM
18637	22486	3	107	107	CD
18637	22486	4	.	.	.
18637	22487	1	The	the	DT
18637	22487	2	majority	majority	NN
18637	22487	3	supporting	support	VBG
18637	22487	4	this	this	DT
18637	22487	5	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	22487	6	was	be	VBD
18637	22487	7	not	not	RB
18637	22487	8	the	the	DT
18637	22487	9	same	same	JJ
18637	22487	10	majority	majority	NN
18637	22487	11	as	as	IN
18637	22487	12	the	the	DT
18637	22487	13	one	one	NN
18637	22487	14	which	which	WDT
18637	22487	15	held	hold	VBD
18637	22487	16	that	that	IN
18637	22487	17	"	"	``
18637	22487	18	State	state	NN
18637	22487	19	"	"	''
18637	22487	20	action	action	NN
18637	22487	21	was	be	VBD
18637	22487	22	involved	involve	VBN
18637	22487	23	.	.	.
18637	22488	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22488	2	1238	1238	CD
18637	22488	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22488	4	341	341	CD
18637	22488	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22488	6	97	97	CD
18637	22488	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22488	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	22488	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22488	10	.	.	.
18637	22489	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22489	2	1239	1239	CD
18637	22489	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22489	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	22489	5	.	.	.
18637	22490	1	103	103	CD
18637	22490	2	-	-	SYM
18637	22490	3	104	104	CD
18637	22490	4	.	.	.
18637	22491	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22491	2	1240	1240	CD
18637	22491	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22491	4	342	342	CD
18637	22491	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22491	6	852	852	CD
18637	22491	7	.	.	.
18637	22492	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22492	2	1241	1241	CD
18637	22492	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22492	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	22492	5	.	.	.
18637	22493	1	853	853	CD
18637	22493	2	-	-	SYM
18637	22493	3	854	854	CD
18637	22493	4	.	.	.
18637	22494	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	22494	2	15	15	CD
18637	22494	3	RIGHT	right	NN
18637	22494	4	OF	of	IN
18637	22494	5	CITIZENS	citizen	NNS
18637	22494	6	TO	to	IN
18637	22494	7	VOTE	vote	NN
18637	22494	8	Page	page	NN
18637	22494	9	Affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	22494	10	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	22494	11	1183	1183	CD
18637	22494	12	Negative	negative	JJ
18637	22494	13	application	application	NN
18637	22494	14	;	;	:
18637	22494	15	the	the	DT
18637	22494	16	"	"	``
18637	22494	17	Grandfather	Grandfather	NNP
18637	22494	18	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	22494	19	"	"	''
18637	22494	20	1184	1184	CD
18637	22494	21	Application	Application	NNP
18637	22494	22	to	to	IN
18637	22494	23	party	party	NN
18637	22494	24	primaries	primary	NNS
18637	22494	25	1185	1185	CD
18637	22494	26	Enforcement	Enforcement	NNP
18637	22494	27	1186	1186	CD
18637	22494	28	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	22494	29	15.--RIGHT	15.--right	CD
18637	22494	30	OF	of	IN
18637	22494	31	CITIZENS	citizen	NNS
18637	22494	32	TO	to	IN
18637	22494	33	VOTE	VOTE	NNP
18637	22494	34	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22494	35	15	15	CD
18637	22494	36	Section	Section	NNP
18637	22494	37	1	1	CD
18637	22494	38	.	.	.
18637	22495	1	The	the	DT
18637	22495	2	right	right	NN
18637	22495	3	of	of	IN
18637	22495	4	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	22495	5	of	of	IN
18637	22495	6	the	the	DT
18637	22495	7	United	United	NNP
18637	22495	8	States	States	NNP
18637	22495	9	to	to	TO
18637	22495	10	vote	vote	VB
18637	22495	11	shall	shall	MD
18637	22495	12	not	not	RB
18637	22495	13	be	be	VB
18637	22495	14	denied	deny	VBN
18637	22495	15	or	or	CC
18637	22495	16	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	22495	17	by	by	IN
18637	22495	18	the	the	DT
18637	22495	19	United	United	NNP
18637	22495	20	States	States	NNP
18637	22495	21	or	or	CC
18637	22495	22	by	by	IN
18637	22495	23	any	any	DT
18637	22495	24	State	State	NNP
18637	22495	25	on	on	IN
18637	22495	26	account	account	NN
18637	22495	27	of	of	IN
18637	22495	28	race	race	NN
18637	22495	29	,	,	,
18637	22495	30	color	color	NN
18637	22495	31	,	,	,
18637	22495	32	or	or	CC
18637	22495	33	previous	previous	JJ
18637	22495	34	condition	condition	NN
18637	22495	35	of	of	IN
18637	22495	36	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	22495	37	.	.	.
18637	22496	1	Section	section	NN
18637	22496	2	2	2	CD
18637	22496	3	.	.	.
18637	22497	1	The	the	DT
18637	22497	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22497	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	22497	4	have	have	VB
18637	22497	5	power	power	NN
18637	22497	6	to	to	TO
18637	22497	7	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	22497	8	this	this	DT
18637	22497	9	article	article	NN
18637	22497	10	by	by	IN
18637	22497	11	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	22497	12	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	22497	13	.	.	.
18637	22498	1	Affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	22498	2	Interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	22498	3	In	in	IN
18637	22498	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22498	5	initial	initial	JJ
18637	22498	6	appraisals	appraisal	NNS
18637	22498	7	of	of	IN
18637	22498	8	this	this	DT
18637	22498	9	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22498	10	the	the	DT
18637	22498	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22498	12	appeared	appear	VBD
18637	22498	13	disposed	disposed	JJ
18637	22498	14	to	to	TO
18637	22498	15	emphasize	emphasize	VB
18637	22498	16	only	only	RB
18637	22498	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22498	18	purely	purely	RB
18637	22498	19	negative	negative	JJ
18637	22498	20	aspects	aspect	NNS
18637	22498	21	.	.	.
18637	22499	1	"	"	``
18637	22499	2	The	the	DT
18637	22499	3	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	22499	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22499	5	,	,	,
18637	22499	6	"	"	''
18637	22499	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22499	8	announced	announce	VBD
18637	22499	9	,	,	,
18637	22499	10	did	do	VBD
18637	22499	11	"	"	``
18637	22499	12	not	not	RB
18637	22499	13	confer	confer	VB
18637	22499	14	the	the	DT
18637	22499	15	right	right	NN
18637	22499	16	*	*	NFP
18637	22499	17	*	*	NFP
18637	22499	18	*	*	NFP
18637	22499	19	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22499	20	to	to	TO
18637	22499	21	vote	vote	VB
18637	22499	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22499	23	upon	upon	IN
18637	22499	24	any	any	DT
18637	22499	25	one	one	NN
18637	22499	26	,	,	,
18637	22499	27	"	"	''
18637	22499	28	but	but	CC
18637	22499	29	merely	merely	RB
18637	22499	30	"	"	``
18637	22499	31	invested	invest	VBD
18637	22499	32	the	the	DT
18637	22499	33	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	22499	34	of	of	IN
18637	22499	35	the	the	DT
18637	22499	36	United	United	NNP
18637	22499	37	States	States	NNP
18637	22499	38	with	with	IN
18637	22499	39	a	a	DT
18637	22499	40	new	new	JJ
18637	22499	41	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	22499	42	right	right	NN
18637	22499	43	which	which	WDT
18637	22499	44	is	be	VBZ
18637	22499	45	*	*	NFP
18637	22499	46	*	*	NFP
18637	22499	47	*	*	NFP
18637	22499	48	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	22499	49	from	from	IN
18637	22499	50	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	22499	51	in	in	IN
18637	22499	52	the	the	DT
18637	22499	53	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	22499	54	of	of	IN
18637	22499	55	the	the	DT
18637	22499	56	elective	elective	JJ
18637	22499	57	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	22499	58	on	on	IN
18637	22499	59	account	account	NN
18637	22499	60	of	of	IN
18637	22499	61	race	race	NN
18637	22499	62	,	,	,
18637	22499	63	color	color	NN
18637	22499	64	,	,	,
18637	22499	65	or	or	CC
18637	22499	66	previous	previous	JJ
18637	22499	67	condition	condition	NN
18637	22499	68	of	of	IN
18637	22499	69	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	22499	70	.	.	.
18637	22500	1	"	"	``
18637	22500	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22500	3	1	1	CD
18637	22500	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22500	5	Within	within	IN
18637	22500	6	less	less	JJR
18637	22500	7	than	than	IN
18637	22500	8	ten	ten	CD
18637	22500	9	years	year	NNS
18637	22500	10	,	,	,
18637	22500	11	however	however	RB
18637	22500	12	,	,	,
18637	22500	13	in	in	IN
18637	22500	14	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	22500	15	parte	parte	NN
18637	22500	16	Yarbrough,[2	Yarbrough,[2	NNP
18637	22500	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22500	18	the	the	DT
18637	22500	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22500	20	ventured	venture	VBD
18637	22500	21	to	to	TO
18637	22500	22	read	read	VB
18637	22500	23	into	into	IN
18637	22500	24	the	the	DT
18637	22500	25	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22500	26	an	an	DT
18637	22500	27	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	22500	28	as	as	RB
18637	22500	29	well	well	RB
18637	22500	30	as	as	IN
18637	22500	31	a	a	DT
18637	22500	32	negative	negative	JJ
18637	22500	33	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	22500	34	.	.	.
18637	22501	1	Conceding	concede	VBG
18637	22501	2	"	"	''
18637	22501	3	that	that	IN
18637	22501	4	this	this	DT
18637	22501	5	article	article	NN
18637	22501	6	"	"	``
18637	22501	7	had	have	VBD
18637	22501	8	originally	originally	RB
18637	22501	9	been	be	VBN
18637	22501	10	construed	construe	VBN
18637	22501	11	as	as	IN
18637	22501	12	giving	give	VBG
18637	22501	13	"	"	``
18637	22501	14	no	no	UH
18637	22501	15	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	22501	16	right	right	NN
18637	22501	17	to	to	IN
18637	22501	18	the	the	DT
18637	22501	19	colored	colored	JJ
18637	22501	20	man	man	NN
18637	22501	21	to	to	TO
18637	22501	22	vote	vote	VB
18637	22501	23	,	,	,
18637	22501	24	"	"	''
18637	22501	25	and	and	CC
18637	22501	26	as	as	IN
18637	22501	27	having	have	VBG
18637	22501	28	been	be	VBN
18637	22501	29	"	"	``
18637	22501	30	designed	design	VBN
18637	22501	31	primarily	primarily	RB
18637	22501	32	to	to	TO
18637	22501	33	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	22501	34	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	22501	35	against	against	IN
18637	22501	36	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22501	37	,	,	,
18637	22501	38	"	"	''
18637	22501	39	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22501	40	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	22501	41	,	,	,
18637	22501	42	in	in	IN
18637	22501	43	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	22501	44	of	of	IN
18637	22501	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22501	46	colleagues	colleague	NNS
18637	22501	47	,	,	,
18637	22501	48	disclosed	disclose	VBD
18637	22501	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22501	50	present	present	JJ
18637	22501	51	ability	ability	NN
18637	22501	52	"	"	''
18637	22501	53	to	to	TO
18637	22501	54	see	see	VB
18637	22501	55	that	that	IN
18637	22501	56	under	under	IN
18637	22501	57	some	some	DT
18637	22501	58	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	22501	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22501	60	may	may	MD
18637	22501	61	operate	operate	VB
18637	22501	62	as	as	IN
18637	22501	63	the	the	DT
18637	22501	64	immediate	immediate	JJ
18637	22501	65	source	source	NN
18637	22501	66	of	of	IN
18637	22501	67	a	a	DT
18637	22501	68	right	right	NN
18637	22501	69	to	to	TO
18637	22501	70	vote	vote	VB
18637	22501	71	.	.	.
18637	22502	1	In	in	IN
18637	22502	2	all	all	DT
18637	22502	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	22502	4	where	where	WRB
18637	22502	5	the	the	DT
18637	22502	6	former	former	JJ
18637	22502	7	slave	slave	NN
18637	22502	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	22502	9	holding	hold	VBG
18637	22502	10	States	States	NNP
18637	22502	11	had	have	VBD
18637	22502	12	not	not	RB
18637	22502	13	removed	remove	VBN
18637	22502	14	from	from	IN
18637	22502	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22502	16	Constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	22502	17	the	the	DT
18637	22502	18	words	word	NNS
18637	22502	19	'	'	POS
18637	22502	20	white	white	JJ
18637	22502	21	man	man	NN
18637	22502	22	'	'	''
18637	22502	23	as	as	IN
18637	22502	24	a	a	DT
18637	22502	25	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	22502	26	for	for	IN
18637	22502	27	voting	voting	NN
18637	22502	28	,	,	,
18637	22502	29	this	this	DT
18637	22502	30	provision	provision	NN
18637	22502	31	did	do	VBD
18637	22502	32	,	,	,
18637	22502	33	in	in	IN
18637	22502	34	effect	effect	NN
18637	22502	35	,	,	,
18637	22502	36	confer	confer	VB
18637	22502	37	on	on	IN
18637	22502	38	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22502	39	the	the	DT
18637	22502	40	right	right	NN
18637	22502	41	to	to	TO
18637	22502	42	vote	vote	VB
18637	22502	43	,	,	,
18637	22502	44	because	because	IN
18637	22502	45	,	,	,
18637	22502	46	*	*	NFP
18637	22502	47	*	*	NFP
18637	22502	48	*	*	NFP
18637	22502	49	,	,	,
18637	22502	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22502	51	annulled	annul	VBD
18637	22502	52	the	the	DT
18637	22502	53	discriminating	discriminate	VBG
18637	22502	54	word	word	NN
18637	22502	55	_	_	NNP
18637	22502	56	white	white	JJ
18637	22502	57	_	_	NNP
18637	22502	58	,	,	,
18637	22502	59	and	and	CC
18637	22502	60	thus	thus	RB
18637	22502	61	left	leave	VBD
18637	22502	62	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22502	63	in	in	IN
18637	22502	64	the	the	DT
18637	22502	65	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	22502	66	of	of	IN
18637	22502	67	the	the	DT
18637	22502	68	same	same	JJ
18637	22502	69	right	right	NN
18637	22502	70	as	as	IN
18637	22502	71	white	white	JJ
18637	22502	72	persons	person	NNS
18637	22502	73	.	.	.
18637	22503	1	And	and	CC
18637	22503	2	such	such	JJ
18637	22503	3	would	would	MD
18637	22503	4	be	be	VB
18637	22503	5	the	the	DT
18637	22503	6	effect	effect	NN
18637	22503	7	of	of	IN
18637	22503	8	any	any	DT
18637	22503	9	future	future	JJ
18637	22503	10	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	22503	11	provision	provision	NN
18637	22503	12	of	of	IN
18637	22503	13	a	a	DT
18637	22503	14	State	state	NN
18637	22503	15	which	which	WDT
18637	22503	16	should	should	MD
18637	22503	17	give	give	VB
18637	22503	18	the	the	DT
18637	22503	19	right	right	NN
18637	22503	20	of	of	IN
18637	22503	21	voting	vote	VBG
18637	22503	22	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	22503	23	to	to	IN
18637	22503	24	white	white	JJ
18637	22503	25	people	people	NNS
18637	22503	26	,	,	,
18637	22503	27	*	*	NFP
18637	22503	28	*	*	NFP
18637	22503	29	*	*	NFP
18637	22503	30	"	"	``
18637	22503	31	Negative	Negative	NNP
18637	22503	32	Application	Application	NNP
18637	22503	33	;	;	:
18637	22503	34	the	the	DT
18637	22503	35	"	"	``
18637	22503	36	Grandfather	Grandfather	NNP
18637	22503	37	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	22503	38	"	"	``
18637	22503	39	The	the	DT
18637	22503	40	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	22503	41	history	history	NN
18637	22503	42	of	of	IN
18637	22503	43	the	the	DT
18637	22503	44	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	22503	45	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22503	46	has	have	VBZ
18637	22503	47	been	be	VBN
18637	22503	48	largely	largely	RB
18637	22503	49	a	a	DT
18637	22503	50	record	record	NN
18637	22503	51	of	of	IN
18637	22503	52	belated	belate	VBN
18637	22503	53	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	22503	54	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	22503	55	of	of	IN
18637	22503	56	various	various	JJ
18637	22503	57	attempts	attempt	NNS
18637	22503	58	by	by	IN
18637	22503	59	States	state	NNS
18637	22503	60	to	to	TO
18637	22503	61	disfranchise	disfranchise	VB
18637	22503	62	the	the	DT
18637	22503	63	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	22503	64	either	either	RB
18637	22503	65	overtly	overtly	RB
18637	22503	66	through	through	IN
18637	22503	67	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	22503	68	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	22503	69	,	,	,
18637	22503	70	or	or	CC
18637	22503	71	covertly	covertly	RB
18637	22503	72	through	through	IN
18637	22503	73	inequitable	inequitable	JJ
18637	22503	74	administration	administration	NN
18637	22503	75	of	of	IN
18637	22503	76	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22503	77	electoral	electoral	JJ
18637	22503	78	laws	law	NNS
18637	22503	79	or	or	CC
18637	22503	80	by	by	IN
18637	22503	81	toleration	toleration	NN
18637	22503	82	of	of	IN
18637	22503	83	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	22503	84	membership	membership	NN
18637	22503	85	practices	practice	NNS
18637	22503	86	of	of	IN
18637	22503	87	political	political	JJ
18637	22503	88	parties	party	NNS
18637	22503	89	.	.	.
18637	22504	1	Of	of	IN
18637	22504	2	several	several	JJ
18637	22504	3	devices	device	NNS
18637	22504	4	which	which	WDT
18637	22504	5	have	have	VBP
18637	22504	6	been	be	VBN
18637	22504	7	voided	void	VBN
18637	22504	8	,	,	,
18637	22504	9	one	one	CD
18637	22504	10	of	of	IN
18637	22504	11	the	the	DT
18637	22504	12	first	first	JJ
18637	22504	13	to	to	TO
18637	22504	14	be	be	VB
18637	22504	15	held	hold	VBN
18637	22504	16	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	22504	17	was	be	VBD
18637	22504	18	the	the	DT
18637	22504	19	"	"	``
18637	22504	20	grandfather	grandfather	NN
18637	22504	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	22504	22	.	.	.
18637	22504	23	"	"	''
18637	22505	1	Without	without	IN
18637	22505	2	expressly	expressly	RB
18637	22505	3	disfranchising	disfranchise	VBG
18637	22505	4	the	the	DT
18637	22505	5	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	22505	6	,	,	,
18637	22505	7	but	but	CC
18637	22505	8	with	with	IN
18637	22505	9	a	a	DT
18637	22505	10	view	view	NN
18637	22505	11	to	to	IN
18637	22505	12	facilitating	facilitate	VBG
18637	22505	13	the	the	DT
18637	22505	14	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	22505	15	placement	placement	NN
18637	22505	16	of	of	IN
18637	22505	17	white	white	JJ
18637	22505	18	residents	resident	NNS
18637	22505	19	on	on	IN
18637	22505	20	the	the	DT
18637	22505	21	voting	voting	NN
18637	22505	22	lists	list	NNS
18637	22505	23	while	while	IN
18637	22505	24	continuing	continue	VBG
18637	22505	25	to	to	TO
18637	22505	26	interpose	interpose	VB
18637	22505	27	severe	severe	JJ
18637	22505	28	obstacles	obstacle	NNS
18637	22505	29	upon	upon	IN
18637	22505	30	Negroes	negro	NNS
18637	22505	31	seeking	seek	VBG
18637	22505	32	qualification	qualification	NN
18637	22505	33	as	as	IN
18637	22505	34	voters	voter	NNS
18637	22505	35	,	,	,
18637	22505	36	several	several	JJ
18637	22505	37	States	state	NNS
18637	22505	38	,	,	,
18637	22505	39	beginning	begin	VBG
18637	22505	40	in	in	IN
18637	22505	41	1895	1895	CD
18637	22505	42	,	,	,
18637	22505	43	enacted	enact	VBD
18637	22505	44	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	22505	45	laws	law	NNS
18637	22505	46	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	22505	47	persons	person	NNS
18637	22505	48	who	who	WP
18637	22505	49	were	be	VBD
18637	22505	50	voters	voter	NNS
18637	22505	51	,	,	,
18637	22505	52	or	or	CC
18637	22505	53	descendants	descendant	NNS
18637	22505	54	of	of	IN
18637	22505	55	voters	voter	NNS
18637	22505	56	on	on	IN
18637	22505	57	January	January	NNP
18637	22505	58	1	1	CD
18637	22505	59	,	,	,
18637	22505	60	1867	1867	CD
18637	22505	61	,	,	,
18637	22505	62	could	could	MD
18637	22505	63	be	be	VB
18637	22505	64	registered	register	VBN
18637	22505	65	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	22505	66	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22505	67	inability	inability	NN
18637	22505	68	to	to	TO
18637	22505	69	meet	meet	VB
18637	22505	70	any	any	DT
18637	22505	71	literacy	literacy	NN
18637	22505	72	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	22505	73	.	.	.
18637	22506	1	Unable	unable	JJ
18637	22506	2	because	because	IN
18637	22506	3	of	of	IN
18637	22506	4	the	the	DT
18637	22506	5	date	date	NN
18637	22506	6	to	to	TO
18637	22506	7	avail	avail	VB
18637	22506	8	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22506	9	of	of	IN
18637	22506	10	the	the	DT
18637	22506	11	same	same	JJ
18637	22506	12	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	22506	13	,	,	,
18637	22506	14	Negroes	Negroes	NNPS
18637	22506	15	were	be	VBD
18637	22506	16	thus	thus	RB
18637	22506	17	left	leave	VBN
18637	22506	18	exposed	expose	VBN
18637	22506	19	to	to	IN
18637	22506	20	disfranchisement	disfranchisement	NN
18637	22506	21	on	on	IN
18637	22506	22	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	22506	23	of	of	IN
18637	22506	24	illiteracy	illiteracy	NN
18637	22506	25	while	while	IN
18637	22506	26	whites	white	NNS
18637	22506	27	no	no	DT
18637	22506	28	less	less	RBR
18637	22506	29	illiterate	illiterate	JJ
18637	22506	30	were	be	VBD
18637	22506	31	enabled	enable	VBN
18637	22506	32	to	to	TO
18637	22506	33	become	become	VB
18637	22506	34	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	22506	35	voters	voter	NNS
18637	22506	36	.	.	.
18637	22507	1	With	with	IN
18637	22507	2	the	the	DT
18637	22507	3	achievement	achievement	NN
18637	22507	4	of	of	IN
18637	22507	5	this	this	DT
18637	22507	6	intended	intend	VBN
18637	22507	7	result	result	NN
18637	22507	8	,	,	,
18637	22507	9	most	most	JJS
18637	22507	10	States	state	NNS
18637	22507	11	permitted	permit	VBD
18637	22507	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22507	13	laws	law	NNS
18637	22507	14	to	to	TO
18637	22507	15	lapse	lapse	VB
18637	22507	16	;	;	:
18637	22507	17	but	but	CC
18637	22507	18	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	22507	19	's	's	POS
18637	22507	20	grandfather	grandfather	NN
18637	22507	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	22507	22	was	be	VBD
18637	22507	23	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	22507	24	as	as	IN
18637	22507	25	a	a	DT
18637	22507	26	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	22507	27	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22507	28	to	to	IN
18637	22507	29	the	the	DT
18637	22507	30	State	State	NNP
18637	22507	31	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	22507	32	;	;	:
18637	22507	33	and	and	CC
18637	22507	34	when	when	WRB
18637	22507	35	presented	present	VBN
18637	22507	36	with	with	IN
18637	22507	37	an	an	DT
18637	22507	38	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	22507	39	to	to	TO
18637	22507	40	pass	pass	VB
18637	22507	41	on	on	RP
18637	22507	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22507	43	validity	validity	NN
18637	22507	44	,	,	,
18637	22507	45	a	a	DT
18637	22507	46	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	22507	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22507	48	condemned	condemn	VBD
18637	22507	49	the	the	DT
18637	22507	50	standard	standard	NN
18637	22507	51	of	of	IN
18637	22507	52	voting	voting	NN
18637	22507	53	thus	thus	RB
18637	22507	54	established	establish	VBN
18637	22507	55	as	as	IN
18637	22507	56	recreating	recreate	VBG
18637	22507	57	and	and	CC
18637	22507	58	perpetuating	perpetuate	VBG
18637	22507	59	"	"	``
18637	22507	60	the	the	DT
18637	22507	61	very	very	JJ
18637	22507	62	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	22507	63	which	which	WDT
18637	22507	64	the	the	DT
18637	22507	65	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22507	66	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	22507	67	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22507	68	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22507	69	was	be	VBD
18637	22507	70	intended	intend	VBN
18637	22507	71	to	to	TO
18637	22507	72	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	22507	73	.	.	.
18637	22508	1	"	"	``
18637	22508	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22508	3	3	3	CD
18637	22508	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22508	5	Nor	nor	CC
18637	22508	6	,	,	,
18637	22508	7	when	when	WRB
18637	22508	8	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	22508	9	followed	follow	VBD
18637	22508	10	up	up	RP
18637	22508	11	this	this	DT
18637	22508	12	defeat	defeat	NN
18637	22508	13	with	with	IN
18637	22508	14	a	a	DT
18637	22508	15	statute	statute	NN
18637	22508	16	of	of	IN
18637	22508	17	1916	1916	CD
18637	22508	18	which	which	WDT
18637	22508	19	provided	provide	VBD
18637	22508	20	that	that	IN
18637	22508	21	all	all	DT
18637	22508	22	persons	person	NNS
18637	22508	23	,	,	,
18637	22508	24	except	except	IN
18637	22508	25	those	those	DT
18637	22508	26	who	who	WP
18637	22508	27	voted	vote	VBD
18637	22508	28	in	in	IN
18637	22508	29	1914	1914	CD
18637	22508	30	,	,	,
18637	22508	31	who	who	WP
18637	22508	32	were	be	VBD
18637	22508	33	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	22508	34	to	to	TO
18637	22508	35	vote	vote	VB
18637	22508	36	in	in	IN
18637	22508	37	1916	1916	CD
18637	22508	38	but	but	CC
18637	22508	39	who	who	WP
18637	22508	40	failed	fail	VBD
18637	22508	41	to	to	TO
18637	22508	42	register	register	VB
18637	22508	43	between	between	IN
18637	22508	44	April	April	NNP
18637	22508	45	30	30	CD
18637	22508	46	and	and	CC
18637	22508	47	May	May	NNP
18637	22508	48	11	11	CD
18637	22508	49	,	,	,
18637	22508	50	1916	1916	CD
18637	22508	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22508	52	sick	sick	JJ
18637	22508	53	persons	person	NNS
18637	22508	54	and	and	CC
18637	22508	55	persons	person	NNS
18637	22508	56	absent	absent	JJ
18637	22508	57	had	have	VBD
18637	22508	58	a	a	DT
18637	22508	59	second	second	JJ
18637	22508	60	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	22508	61	to	to	TO
18637	22508	62	register	register	VB
18637	22508	63	between	between	IN
18637	22508	64	May	May	NNP
18637	22508	65	11	11	CD
18637	22508	66	and	and	CC
18637	22508	67	June	June	NNP
18637	22508	68	30	30	CD
18637	22508	69	,	,	,
18637	22508	70	1916	1916	CD
18637	22508	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22508	72	should	should	MD
18637	22508	73	be	be	VB
18637	22508	74	perpetually	perpetually	RB
18637	22508	75	disfranchised	disfranchised	JJ
18637	22508	76	,	,	,
18637	22508	77	did	do	VBD
18637	22508	78	the	the	DT
18637	22508	79	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22508	80	experience	experience	VB
18637	22508	81	any	any	DT
18637	22508	82	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	22508	83	in	in	IN
18637	22508	84	holding	hold	VBG
18637	22508	85	the	the	DT
18637	22508	86	same	same	JJ
18637	22508	87	to	to	TO
18637	22508	88	be	be	VB
18637	22508	89	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	22508	90	to	to	IN
18637	22508	91	the	the	DT
18637	22508	92	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22508	93	.	.	.
18637	22509	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22509	2	4	4	CD
18637	22509	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22509	4	That	that	DT
18637	22509	5	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22509	6	,	,	,
18637	22509	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22509	8	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	22509	9	declared	declare	VBD
18637	22509	10	,	,	,
18637	22509	11	"	"	''
18637	22509	12	nullifies	nullifie	NNS
18637	22509	13	sophisticated	sophisticated	JJ
18637	22509	14	as	as	RB
18637	22509	15	well	well	RB
18637	22509	16	as	as	IN
18637	22509	17	simple	simple	JJ
18637	22509	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	22509	19	minded	minded	JJ
18637	22509	20	modes	mode	NNS
18637	22509	21	of	of	IN
18637	22509	22	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	22509	23	.	.	.
18637	22510	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22510	2	hits	hit	VBZ
18637	22510	3	onerous	onerous	JJ
18637	22510	4	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	22510	5	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	22510	6	which	which	WDT
18637	22510	7	effectively	effectively	RB
18637	22510	8	handicap	handicap	VBP
18637	22510	9	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	22510	10	of	of	IN
18637	22510	11	the	the	DT
18637	22510	12	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	22510	13	by	by	IN
18637	22510	14	the	the	DT
18637	22510	15	colored	colored	JJ
18637	22510	16	race	race	NN
18637	22510	17	although	although	IN
18637	22510	18	the	the	DT
18637	22510	19	abstract	abstract	JJ
18637	22510	20	right	right	NN
18637	22510	21	to	to	TO
18637	22510	22	vote	vote	VB
18637	22510	23	may	may	MD
18637	22510	24	remain	remain	VB
18637	22510	25	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
18637	22510	26	as	as	IN
18637	22510	27	to	to	IN
18637	22510	28	race	race	NN
18637	22510	29	.	.	.
18637	22511	1	"	"	``
18637	22511	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22511	3	5	5	CD
18637	22511	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22511	5	More	more	RBR
18637	22511	6	precisely	precisely	RB
18637	22511	7	,	,	,
18637	22511	8	the	the	DT
18637	22511	9	effect	effect	NN
18637	22511	10	of	of	IN
18637	22511	11	this	this	DT
18637	22511	12	statute	statute	NN
18637	22511	13	,	,	,
18637	22511	14	as	as	IN
18637	22511	15	discerned	discern	VBN
18637	22511	16	by	by	IN
18637	22511	17	the	the	DT
18637	22511	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22511	19	,	,	,
18637	22511	20	was	be	VBD
18637	22511	21	automatically	automatically	RB
18637	22511	22	to	to	TO
18637	22511	23	continue	continue	VB
18637	22511	24	as	as	IN
18637	22511	25	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	22511	26	voters	voter	NNS
18637	22511	27	,	,	,
18637	22511	28	without	without	IN
18637	22511	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22511	30	being	be	VBG
18637	22511	31	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	22511	32	to	to	TO
18637	22511	33	register	register	VB
18637	22511	34	again	again	RB
18637	22511	35	,	,	,
18637	22511	36	all	all	DT
18637	22511	37	white	white	JJ
18637	22511	38	persons	person	NNS
18637	22511	39	who	who	WP
18637	22511	40	were	be	VBD
18637	22511	41	on	on	IN
18637	22511	42	registry	registry	NN
18637	22511	43	lists	list	NNS
18637	22511	44	in	in	IN
18637	22511	45	1914	1914	CD
18637	22511	46	by	by	IN
18637	22511	47	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	22511	48	of	of	IN
18637	22511	49	the	the	DT
18637	22511	50	hitherto	hitherto	NNP
18637	22511	51	invalidated	invalidated	JJ
18637	22511	52	grandfather	grandfather	NN
18637	22511	53	clause	clause	NN
18637	22511	54	;	;	:
18637	22511	55	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	22511	56	Negroes	Negroes	NNP
18637	22511	57	,	,	,
18637	22511	58	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	22511	59	from	from	IN
18637	22511	60	registering	register	VBG
18637	22511	61	by	by	IN
18637	22511	62	that	that	DT
18637	22511	63	clause	clause	NN
18637	22511	64	,	,	,
18637	22511	65	were	be	VBD
18637	22511	66	afforded	afford	VBN
18637	22511	67	only	only	RB
18637	22511	68	a	a	DT
18637	22511	69	twenty	twenty	CD
18637	22511	70	-	-	HYPH
18637	22511	71	day	day	NN
18637	22511	72	registration	registration	NN
18637	22511	73	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	22511	74	to	to	TO
18637	22511	75	avoid	avoid	VB
18637	22511	76	permanent	permanent	JJ
18637	22511	77	disfranchisement	disfranchisement	NN
18637	22511	78	.	.	.
18637	22512	1	Application	application	NN
18637	22512	2	to	to	IN
18637	22512	3	Party	Party	NNP
18637	22512	4	Primaries	Primaries	NNPS
18637	22512	5	Indecision	Indecision	NNP
18637	22512	6	was	be	VBD
18637	22512	7	displayed	display	VBN
18637	22512	8	by	by	IN
18637	22512	9	the	the	DT
18637	22512	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22512	11	,	,	,
18637	22512	12	however	however	RB
18637	22512	13	,	,	,
18637	22512	14	when	when	WRB
18637	22512	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22512	16	was	be	VBD
18637	22512	17	first	first	RB
18637	22512	18	called	call	VBN
18637	22512	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	22512	20	to	to	TO
18637	22512	21	deal	deal	VB
18637	22512	22	with	with	IN
18637	22512	23	the	the	DT
18637	22512	24	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	22512	25	of	of	IN
18637	22512	26	Negroes	Negroes	NNPS
18637	22512	27	from	from	IN
18637	22512	28	participation	participation	NN
18637	22512	29	in	in	IN
18637	22512	30	primary	primary	JJ
18637	22512	31	elections	election	NNS
18637	22512	32	.	.	.
18637	22513	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22513	2	6	6	CD
18637	22513	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22513	4	Prior	prior	RB
18637	22513	5	to	to	IN
18637	22513	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22513	7	becoming	become	VBG
18637	22513	8	convinced	convinced	JJ
18637	22513	9	that	that	IN
18637	22513	10	primary	primary	JJ
18637	22513	11	contests	contest	NNS
18637	22513	12	were	be	VBD
18637	22513	13	in	in	IN
18637	22513	14	fact	fact	NN
18637	22513	15	elections,[7	elections,[7	NN
18637	22513	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22513	17	the	the	DT
18637	22513	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22513	19	had	have	VBD
18637	22513	20	relied	rely	VBN
18637	22513	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	22513	22	the	the	DT
18637	22513	23	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22513	24	protection	protection	NN
18637	22513	25	clause	clause	NN
18637	22513	26	to	to	TO
18637	22513	27	strike	strike	VB
18637	22513	28	down	down	RP
18637	22513	29	a	a	DT
18637	22513	30	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	22513	31	White	White	NNP
18637	22513	32	Primary	Primary	NNP
18637	22513	33	Law[8	Law[8	NNP
18637	22513	34	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22513	35	and	and	CC
18637	22513	36	a	a	DT
18637	22513	37	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	22513	38	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	22513	39	statute	statute	NN
18637	22513	40	which	which	WDT
18637	22513	41	contributed	contribute	VBD
18637	22513	42	to	to	IN
18637	22513	43	a	a	DT
18637	22513	44	like	like	JJ
18637	22513	45	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	22513	46	by	by	IN
18637	22513	47	limiting	limit	VBG
18637	22513	48	voting	voting	NN
18637	22513	49	in	in	IN
18637	22513	50	primaries	primary	NNS
18637	22513	51	to	to	IN
18637	22513	52	members	member	NNS
18637	22513	53	of	of	IN
18637	22513	54	State	State	NNP
18637	22513	55	political	political	JJ
18637	22513	56	parties	party	NNS
18637	22513	57	as	as	IN
18637	22513	58	determined	determine	VBN
18637	22513	59	by	by	IN
18637	22513	60	the	the	DT
18637	22513	61	central	central	JJ
18637	22513	62	committees	committee	NNS
18637	22513	63	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	22513	64	.	.	.
18637	22514	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22514	2	9	9	CD
18637	22514	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22514	4	When	when	WRB
18637	22514	5	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	22514	6	of	of	IN
18637	22514	7	Negroes	Negroes	NNP
18637	22514	8	was	be	VBD
18637	22514	9	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	22514	10	perpetuated	perpetuate	VBN
18637	22514	11	by	by	IN
18637	22514	12	political	political	JJ
18637	22514	13	parties	party	NNS
18637	22514	14	acting	act	VBG
18637	22514	15	not	not	RB
18637	22514	16	in	in	IN
18637	22514	17	obedience	obedience	NN
18637	22514	18	to	to	IN
18637	22514	19	any	any	DT
18637	22514	20	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	22514	21	command	command	NN
18637	22514	22	,	,	,
18637	22514	23	this	this	DT
18637	22514	24	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	22514	25	was	be	VBD
18637	22514	26	for	for	IN
18637	22514	27	a	a	DT
18637	22514	28	time	time	NN
18637	22514	29	viewed	view	VBN
18637	22514	30	as	as	IN
18637	22514	31	not	not	RB
18637	22514	32	constituting	constitute	VBG
18637	22514	33	State	state	NN
18637	22514	34	action	action	NN
18637	22514	35	and	and	CC
18637	22514	36	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	22514	37	not	not	RB
18637	22514	38	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	22514	39	by	by	IN
18637	22514	40	either	either	CC
18637	22514	41	the	the	DT
18637	22514	42	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	22514	43	or	or	CC
18637	22514	44	the	the	DT
18637	22514	45	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	22514	46	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	22514	47	.	.	.
18637	22515	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22515	2	10	10	CD
18637	22515	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22515	4	But	but	CC
18637	22515	5	this	this	DT
18637	22515	6	holding	holding	NN
18637	22515	7	was	be	VBD
18637	22515	8	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	22515	9	nine	nine	CD
18637	22515	10	years	year	NNS
18637	22515	11	later	later	RB
18637	22515	12	when	when	WRB
18637	22515	13	the	the	DT
18637	22515	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22515	15	,	,	,
18637	22515	16	in	in	IN
18637	22515	17	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	22515	18	_	_	NNP
18637	22515	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	22515	20	_	_	NNP
18637	22515	21	Allwright,[11	Allwright,[11	NNP
18637	22515	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22515	23	declared	declare	VBD
18637	22515	24	that	that	IN
18637	22515	25	where	where	WRB
18637	22515	26	the	the	DT
18637	22515	27	selection	selection	NN
18637	22515	28	of	of	IN
18637	22515	29	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	22515	30	for	for	IN
18637	22515	31	public	public	JJ
18637	22515	32	office	office	NN
18637	22515	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	22515	34	entrusted	entrust	VBN
18637	22515	35	by	by	IN
18637	22515	36	statute	statute	NN
18637	22515	37	to	to	IN
18637	22515	38	political	political	JJ
18637	22515	39	parties	party	NNS
18637	22515	40	,	,	,
18637	22515	41	a	a	DT
18637	22515	42	political	political	JJ
18637	22515	43	party	party	NN
18637	22515	44	in	in	IN
18637	22515	45	making	make	VBG
18637	22515	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22515	47	selection	selection	NN
18637	22515	48	at	at	IN
18637	22515	49	a	a	DT
18637	22515	50	primary	primary	JJ
18637	22515	51	election	election	NN
18637	22515	52	is	be	VBZ
18637	22515	53	a	a	DT
18637	22515	54	State	State	NNP
18637	22515	55	agency	agency	NN
18637	22515	56	,	,	,
18637	22515	57	and	and	CC
18637	22515	58	hence	hence	RB
18637	22515	59	may	may	MD
18637	22515	60	not	not	RB
18637	22515	61	under	under	IN
18637	22515	62	this	this	DT
18637	22515	63	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22515	64	exclude	exclude	VB
18637	22515	65	Negroes	Negroes	NNP
18637	22515	66	from	from	IN
18637	22515	67	such	such	JJ
18637	22515	68	elections	election	NNS
18637	22515	69	.	.	.
18637	22516	1	At	at	IN
18637	22516	2	a	a	DT
18637	22516	3	very	very	RB
18637	22516	4	early	early	JJ
18637	22516	5	date	date	NN
18637	22516	6	the	the	DT
18637	22516	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22516	8	held	hold	VBD
18637	22516	9	that	that	IN
18637	22516	10	literacy	literacy	NN
18637	22516	11	tests	test	NNS
18637	22516	12	which	which	WDT
18637	22516	13	are	be	VBP
18637	22516	14	drafted	draft	VBN
18637	22516	15	so	so	IN
18637	22516	16	as	as	IN
18637	22516	17	to	to	TO
18637	22516	18	apply	apply	VB
18637	22516	19	alike	alike	RB
18637	22516	20	to	to	IN
18637	22516	21	all	all	DT
18637	22516	22	applicants	applicant	NNS
18637	22516	23	for	for	IN
18637	22516	24	the	the	DT
18637	22516	25	voting	voting	NN
18637	22516	26	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	22516	27	would	would	MD
18637	22516	28	be	be	VB
18637	22516	29	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	22516	30	to	to	TO
18637	22516	31	be	be	VB
18637	22516	32	fair	fair	JJ
18637	22516	33	on	on	IN
18637	22516	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22516	35	face	face	NN
18637	22516	36	,	,	,
18637	22516	37	and	and	CC
18637	22516	38	in	in	IN
18637	22516	39	the	the	DT
18637	22516	40	absence	absence	NN
18637	22516	41	of	of	IN
18637	22516	42	proof	proof	NN
18637	22516	43	of	of	IN
18637	22516	44	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	22516	45	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	22516	46	could	could	MD
18637	22516	47	not	not	RB
18637	22516	48	be	be	VB
18637	22516	49	viewed	view	VBN
18637	22516	50	as	as	IN
18637	22516	51	denying	deny	VBG
18637	22516	52	the	the	DT
18637	22516	53	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22516	54	protection	protection	NN
18637	22516	55	of	of	IN
18637	22516	56	the	the	DT
18637	22516	57	laws	law	NNS
18637	22516	58	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	22516	59	by	by	IN
18637	22516	60	the	the	DT
18637	22516	61	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	22516	62	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22516	63	.	.	.
18637	22517	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22517	2	12	12	CD
18637	22517	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22517	4	More	more	RBR
18637	22517	5	recently	recently	RB
18637	22517	6	,	,	,
18637	22517	7	the	the	DT
18637	22517	8	Boswell	Boswell	NNP
18637	22517	9	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22517	10	to	to	IN
18637	22517	11	the	the	DT
18637	22517	12	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	22517	13	of	of	IN
18637	22517	14	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	22517	15	,	,	,
18637	22517	16	which	which	WDT
18637	22517	17	provided	provide	VBD
18637	22517	18	that	that	IN
18637	22517	19	only	only	RB
18637	22517	20	persons	person	NNS
18637	22517	21	who	who	WP
18637	22517	22	understood	understand	VBD
18637	22517	23	and	and	CC
18637	22517	24	could	could	MD
18637	22517	25	explain	explain	VB
18637	22517	26	the	the	DT
18637	22517	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22517	28	of	of	IN
18637	22517	29	the	the	DT
18637	22517	30	United	United	NNP
18637	22517	31	States	States	NNP
18637	22517	32	to	to	IN
18637	22517	33	the	the	DT
18637	22517	34	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	22517	35	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
18637	22517	36	of	of	IN
18637	22517	37	boards	board	NNS
18637	22517	38	of	of	IN
18637	22517	39	registrars	registrar	NNS
18637	22517	40	was	be	VBD
18637	22517	41	found	find	VBN
18637	22517	42	,	,	,
18637	22517	43	both	both	DT
18637	22517	44	in	in	IN
18637	22517	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22517	46	object	object	NN
18637	22517	47	as	as	RB
18637	22517	48	well	well	RB
18637	22517	49	as	as	IN
18637	22517	50	in	in	IN
18637	22517	51	the	the	DT
18637	22517	52	manner	manner	NN
18637	22517	53	of	of	IN
18637	22517	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22517	55	administration	administration	NN
18637	22517	56	,	,	,
18637	22517	57	to	to	TO
18637	22517	58	be	be	VB
18637	22517	59	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	22517	60	to	to	IN
18637	22517	61	the	the	DT
18637	22517	62	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	22517	63	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22517	64	.	.	.
18637	22518	1	The	the	DT
18637	22518	2	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	22518	3	history	history	NN
18637	22518	4	of	of	IN
18637	22518	5	the	the	DT
18637	22518	6	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	22518	7	of	of	IN
18637	22518	8	the	the	DT
18637	22518	9	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	22518	10	provision	provision	NN
18637	22518	11	disclosed	disclose	VBD
18637	22518	12	that	that	IN
18637	22518	13	"	"	``
18637	22518	14	the	the	DT
18637	22518	15	ambiguity	ambiguity	NN
18637	22518	16	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	22518	17	in	in	IN
18637	22518	18	the	the	DT
18637	22518	19	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	22518	20	'	'	``
18637	22518	21	understand	understand	VB
18637	22518	22	and	and	CC
18637	22518	23	explain	explain	VB
18637	22518	24	'	'	''
18637	22518	25	*	*	NFP
18637	22518	26	*	*	NFP
18637	22518	27	*	*	NFP
18637	22518	28	was	be	VBD
18637	22518	29	purposeful	purposeful	JJ
18637	22518	30	*	*	NFP
18637	22518	31	*	*	NFP
18637	22518	32	*	*	NFP
18637	22518	33	and	and	CC
18637	22518	34	was	be	VBD
18637	22518	35	intended	intend	VBN
18637	22518	36	as	as	IN
18637	22518	37	a	a	DT
18637	22518	38	grant	grant	NN
18637	22518	39	of	of	IN
18637	22518	40	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	22518	41	power	power	NN
18637	22518	42	in	in	IN
18637	22518	43	an	an	DT
18637	22518	44	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	22518	45	to	to	TO
18637	22518	46	obviate	obviate	VB
18637	22518	47	the	the	DT
18637	22518	48	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	22518	49	of	of	IN
18637	22518	50	"	"	``
18637	22518	51	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	22518	52	_	_	NNP
18637	22518	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	22518	54	_	_	NNP
18637	22518	55	Allwright	Allwright	NNP
18637	22518	56	.	.	.
18637	22519	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22519	2	13	13	CD
18637	22519	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22519	4	Enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	22519	5	Two	two	CD
18637	22519	6	major	major	JJ
18637	22519	7	questions	question	NNS
18637	22519	8	have	have	VBP
18637	22519	9	presented	present	VBN
18637	22519	10	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22519	11	for	for	IN
18637	22519	12	decision	decision	NN
18637	22519	13	as	as	IN
18637	22519	14	a	a	DT
18637	22519	15	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	22519	16	of	of	IN
18637	22519	17	the	the	DT
18637	22519	18	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	22519	19	by	by	IN
18637	22519	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22519	21	of	of	IN
18637	22519	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22519	23	powers	power	NNS
18637	22519	24	to	to	TO
18637	22519	25	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	22519	26	this	this	DT
18637	22519	27	article	article	NN
18637	22519	28	,	,	,
18637	22519	29	an	an	DT
18637	22519	30	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22519	31	which	which	WDT
18637	22519	32	the	the	DT
18637	22519	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22519	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	22519	35	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
18637	22519	36	to	to	TO
18637	22519	37	be	be	VB
18637	22519	38	self	self	NN
18637	22519	39	-	-	HYPH
18637	22519	40	executing	execute	VBG
18637	22519	41	.	.	.
18637	22520	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22520	2	14	14	CD
18637	22520	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22520	4	These	these	DT
18637	22520	5	have	have	VBP
18637	22520	6	pertained	pertain	VBN
18637	22520	7	to	to	IN
18637	22520	8	the	the	DT
18637	22520	9	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	22520	10	which	which	WDT
18637	22520	11	the	the	DT
18637	22520	12	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22520	13	imposes	impose	VBZ
18637	22520	14	on	on	IN
18637	22520	15	the	the	DT
18637	22520	16	competency	competency	NN
18637	22520	17	of	of	IN
18637	22520	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22520	19	legislating	legislate	VBG
18637	22520	20	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	22520	21	to	to	TO
18637	22520	22	punish	punish	VB
18637	22520	23	racial	racial	JJ
18637	22520	24	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	22520	25	founded	found	VBN
18637	22520	26	upon	upon	IN
18637	22520	27	more	more	JJR
18637	22520	28	than	than	IN
18637	22520	29	a	a	DT
18637	22520	30	denial	denial	NN
18637	22520	31	of	of	IN
18637	22520	32	suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	22520	33	and	and	CC
18637	22520	34	to	to	TO
18637	22520	35	penalize	penalize	VB
18637	22520	36	such	such	JJ
18637	22520	37	denials	denial	NNS
18637	22520	38	when	when	WRB
18637	22520	39	perpetrated	perpetrate	VBN
18637	22520	40	by	by	IN
18637	22520	41	private	private	JJ
18637	22520	42	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	22520	43	not	not	RB
18637	22520	44	acting	act	VBG
18637	22520	45	under	under	IN
18637	22520	46	color	color	NN
18637	22520	47	of	of	IN
18637	22520	48	public	public	JJ
18637	22520	49	authority	authority	NN
18637	22520	50	.	.	.
18637	22521	1	Rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	22521	2	on	on	IN
18637	22521	3	both	both	PDT
18637	22521	4	these	these	DT
18637	22521	5	issues	issue	NNS
18637	22521	6	were	be	VBD
18637	22521	7	made	make	VBN
18637	22521	8	very	very	RB
18637	22521	9	early	early	RB
18637	22521	10	;	;	:
18637	22521	11	and	and	CC
18637	22521	12	the	the	DT
18637	22521	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22521	14	thus	thus	RB
18637	22521	15	far	far	RB
18637	22521	16	has	have	VBZ
18637	22521	17	manifested	manifest	VBN
18637	22521	18	no	no	DT
18637	22521	19	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	22521	20	to	to	TO
18637	22521	21	depart	depart	VB
18637	22521	22	from	from	IN
18637	22521	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22521	24	,	,	,
18637	22521	25	although	although	IN
18637	22521	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22521	27	compatibility	compatibility	NN
18637	22521	28	with	with	IN
18637	22521	29	more	more	JJR
18637	22521	30	recent	recent	JJ
18637	22521	31	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	22521	32	may	may	MD
18637	22521	33	be	be	VB
18637	22521	34	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
18637	22521	35	.	.	.
18637	22522	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	22522	2	,	,	,
18637	22522	3	when	when	WRB
18637	22522	4	the	the	DT
18637	22522	5	Enforcement	Enforcement	NNP
18637	22522	6	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22522	7	of	of	IN
18637	22522	8	1870,[15	1870,[15	CD
18637	22522	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22522	10	which	which	WDT
18637	22522	11	penalized	penalize	VBD
18637	22522	12	State	State	NNP
18637	22522	13	officers	officer	NNS
18637	22522	14	for	for	IN
18637	22522	15	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	22522	16	to	to	TO
18637	22522	17	receive	receive	VB
18637	22522	18	the	the	DT
18637	22522	19	vote	vote	NN
18637	22522	20	of	of	IN
18637	22522	21	any	any	DT
18637	22522	22	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	22522	23	citizen	citizen	NN
18637	22522	24	,	,	,
18637	22522	25	was	be	VBD
18637	22522	26	employed	employ	VBN
18637	22522	27	to	to	TO
18637	22522	28	support	support	VB
18637	22522	29	a	a	DT
18637	22522	30	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	22522	31	of	of	IN
18637	22522	32	such	such	JJ
18637	22522	33	officers	officer	NNS
18637	22522	34	for	for	IN
18637	22522	35	having	have	VBG
18637	22522	36	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	22522	37	a	a	DT
18637	22522	38	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	22522	39	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	22522	40	from	from	IN
18637	22522	41	voting	voting	NN
18637	22522	42	,	,	,
18637	22522	43	the	the	DT
18637	22522	44	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22522	45	held	hold	VBD
18637	22522	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22522	47	to	to	TO
18637	22522	48	be	be	VB
18637	22522	49	in	in	IN
18637	22522	50	excess	excess	NN
18637	22522	51	of	of	IN
18637	22522	52	the	the	DT
18637	22522	53	authority	authority	NN
18637	22522	54	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	22522	55	upon	upon	IN
18637	22522	56	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22522	57	.	.	.
18637	22523	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22523	2	16	16	CD
18637	22523	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22523	4	The	the	DT
18637	22523	5	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	22523	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22523	7	,	,	,
18637	22523	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	22523	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22523	10	Waite	Waite	NNP
18637	22523	11	maintained	maintain	VBD
18637	22523	12	,	,	,
18637	22523	13	did	do	VBD
18637	22523	14	not	not	RB
18637	22523	15	confer	confer	VB
18637	22523	16	"	"	``
18637	22523	17	authority	authority	NN
18637	22523	18	to	to	TO
18637	22523	19	impose	impose	VB
18637	22523	20	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	22523	21	for	for	IN
18637	22523	22	every	every	DT
18637	22523	23	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
18637	22523	24	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	22523	25	to	to	TO
18637	22523	26	receive	receive	VB
18637	22523	27	*	*	NFP
18637	22523	28	*	*	NFP
18637	22523	29	*	*	NFP
18637	22523	30	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22523	31	a	a	DT
18637	22523	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22523	33	vote	vote	NN
18637	22523	34	*	*	NFP
18637	22523	35	*	*	NFP
18637	22523	36	*	*	NFP
18637	22523	37	,	,	,
18637	22523	38	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22523	39	but	but	CC
18637	22523	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22523	41	only	only	RB
18637	22523	42	when	when	WRB
18637	22523	43	the	the	DT
18637	22523	44	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
18637	22523	45	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	22523	46	*	*	NFP
18637	22523	47	*	*	NFP
18637	22523	48	*	*	NFP
18637	22523	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	22523	50	because	because	IN
18637	22523	51	of	of	IN
18637	22523	52	race	race	NN
18637	22523	53	,	,	,
18637	22523	54	color	color	NN
18637	22523	55	,	,	,
18637	22523	56	or	or	CC
18637	22523	57	previous	previous	JJ
18637	22523	58	condition	condition	NN
18637	22523	59	of	of	IN
18637	22523	60	servitude	servitude	NN
18637	22523	61	,	,	,
18637	22523	62	*	*	NFP
18637	22523	63	*	*	NFP
18637	22523	64	*	*	NFP
18637	22523	65	"	"	``
18637	22523	66	Voided	void	VBN
18637	22523	67	for	for	IN
18637	22523	68	the	the	DT
18637	22523	69	like	like	JJ
18637	22523	70	reason	reason	NN
18637	22523	71	that	that	IN
18637	22523	72	this	this	DT
18637	22523	73	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22523	74	"	"	``
18637	22523	75	relates	relate	VBZ
18637	22523	76	solely	solely	RB
18637	22523	77	to	to	IN
18637	22523	78	action	action	NN
18637	22523	79	'	'	''
18637	22523	80	by	by	IN
18637	22523	81	the	the	DT
18637	22523	82	United	United	NNP
18637	22523	83	States	States	NNP
18637	22523	84	or	or	CC
18637	22523	85	by	by	IN
18637	22523	86	any	any	DT
18637	22523	87	State	State	NNP
18637	22523	88	,	,	,
18637	22523	89	'	'	''
18637	22523	90	and	and	CC
18637	22523	91	does	do	VBZ
18637	22523	92	not	not	RB
18637	22523	93	contemplate	contemplate	VB
18637	22523	94	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
18637	22523	95	individual	individual	JJ
18637	22523	96	acts	act	NNS
18637	22523	97	"	"	''
18637	22523	98	was	be	VBD
18637	22523	99	another	another	DT
18637	22523	100	provision	provision	NN
18637	22523	101	of	of	IN
18637	22523	102	the	the	DT
18637	22523	103	same	same	JJ
18637	22523	104	act	act	NN
18637	22523	105	,	,	,
18637	22523	106	which	which	WDT
18637	22523	107	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	22523	108	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	22523	109	of	of	IN
18637	22523	110	private	private	JJ
18637	22523	111	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	22523	112	for	for	IN
18637	22523	113	having	have	VBG
18637	22523	114	prevented	prevent	VBN
18637	22523	115	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	22523	116	from	from	IN
18637	22523	117	voting	vote	VBG
18637	22523	118	at	at	IN
18637	22523	119	a	a	DT
18637	22523	120	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	22523	121	election	election	NN
18637	22523	122	.	.	.
18637	22524	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22524	2	17	17	CD
18637	22524	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22524	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	22524	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22524	6	1	1	CD
18637	22524	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22524	8	United	United	NNP
18637	22524	9	States	States	NNP
18637	22524	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22524	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	22524	12	_	_	NNP
18637	22524	13	Reese	Reese	NNP
18637	22524	14	,	,	,
18637	22524	15	92	92	CD
18637	22524	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22524	17	214	214	CD
18637	22524	18	,	,	,
18637	22524	19	217	217	CD
18637	22524	20	-	-	SYM
18637	22524	21	218	218	CD
18637	22524	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22524	23	1876	1876	CD
18637	22524	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22524	25	;	;	:
18637	22524	26	United	United	NNP
18637	22524	27	States	States	NNP
18637	22524	28	_	_	NNP
18637	22524	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	22524	30	_	_	NNP
18637	22524	31	Cruikshank	Cruikshank	NNP
18637	22524	32	,	,	,
18637	22524	33	92	92	CD
18637	22524	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22524	35	542	542	CD
18637	22524	36	,	,	,
18637	22524	37	556	556	CD
18637	22524	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22524	39	1876	1876	CD
18637	22524	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22524	41	.	.	.
18637	22525	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22525	2	2	2	CD
18637	22525	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22525	4	110	110	CD
18637	22525	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22525	6	651	651	CD
18637	22525	7	,	,	,
18637	22525	8	665	665	CD
18637	22525	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22525	10	1884	1884	CD
18637	22525	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22525	12	;	;	:
18637	22525	13	citing	cite	VBG
18637	22525	14	Neal	Neal	NNP
18637	22525	15	_	_	NNP
18637	22525	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	22525	17	_	_	NNP
18637	22525	18	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	22525	19	,	,	,
18637	22525	20	103	103	CD
18637	22525	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22525	22	370	370	CD
18637	22525	23	,	,	,
18637	22525	24	389	389	CD
18637	22525	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22525	26	1881	1881	CD
18637	22525	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22525	28	.	.	.
18637	22526	1	This	this	DT
18637	22526	2	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
18637	22526	3	view	view	NN
18637	22526	4	was	be	VBD
18637	22526	5	later	later	RB
18637	22526	6	reiterated	reiterate	VBN
18637	22526	7	in	in	IN
18637	22526	8	Guinn	Guinn	NNP
18637	22526	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22526	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	22526	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22526	12	United	United	NNP
18637	22526	13	States	States	NNP
18637	22526	14	,	,	,
18637	22526	15	238	238	CD
18637	22526	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22526	17	347	347	CD
18637	22526	18	,	,	,
18637	22526	19	363	363	CD
18637	22526	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22526	21	1915	1915	CD
18637	22526	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22526	23	.	.	.
18637	22527	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22527	2	3	3	LS
18637	22527	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22527	4	Guinn	Guinn	NNP
18637	22527	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22527	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22527	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22527	8	United	United	NNP
18637	22527	9	States	States	NNP
18637	22527	10	,	,	,
18637	22527	11	238	238	CD
18637	22527	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22527	13	347	347	CD
18637	22527	14	,	,	,
18637	22527	15	360	360	CD
18637	22527	16	,	,	,
18637	22527	17	363	363	CD
18637	22527	18	-	-	SYM
18637	22527	19	364	364	CD
18637	22527	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22527	21	1915	1915	CD
18637	22527	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22527	23	.	.	.
18637	22528	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22528	2	4	4	LS
18637	22528	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22528	4	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	22528	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22528	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22528	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22528	8	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	22528	9	,	,	,
18637	22528	10	307	307	CD
18637	22528	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22528	12	268	268	CD
18637	22528	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22528	14	1939	1939	CD
18637	22528	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22528	16	.	.	.
18637	22529	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22529	2	5	5	CD
18637	22529	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22529	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	22529	5	.	.	.
18637	22530	1	275	275	CD
18637	22530	2	.	.	.
18637	22531	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22531	2	6	6	CD
18637	22531	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22531	4	Cases	case	NNS
18637	22531	5	involving	involve	VBG
18637	22531	6	this	this	DT
18637	22531	7	and	and	CC
18637	22531	8	related	relate	VBN
18637	22531	9	issues	issue	NNS
18637	22531	10	are	be	VBP
18637	22531	11	also	also	RB
18637	22531	12	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	22531	13	under	under	IN
18637	22531	14	the	the	DT
18637	22531	15	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22531	16	protection	protection	NN
18637	22531	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	22531	18	,	,	,
18637	22531	19	p.	p.	NN
18637	22531	20	1163	1163	CD
18637	22531	21	.	.	.
18637	22532	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22532	2	7	7	CD
18637	22532	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22532	4	United	United	NNP
18637	22532	5	States	States	NNP
18637	22532	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22532	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22532	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22532	9	Classic	Classic	NNP
18637	22532	10	,	,	,
18637	22532	11	313	313	CD
18637	22532	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22532	13	299	299	CD
18637	22532	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22532	15	1941	1941	CD
18637	22532	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22532	17	;	;	:
18637	22532	18	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	22532	19	_	_	NNP
18637	22532	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	22532	21	_	_	NNP
18637	22532	22	Allwright	Allwright	NNP
18637	22532	23	,	,	,
18637	22532	24	321	321	CD
18637	22532	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22532	26	649	649	CD
18637	22532	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22532	28	1944	1944	CD
18637	22532	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22532	30	.	.	.
18637	22533	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22533	2	8	8	CD
18637	22533	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22533	4	Nixon	Nixon	NNP
18637	22533	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22533	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22533	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22533	8	Herndon	Herndon	NNP
18637	22533	9	,	,	,
18637	22533	10	273	273	CD
18637	22533	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22533	12	536	536	CD
18637	22533	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22533	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	22533	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22533	16	.	.	.
18637	22534	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22534	2	9	9	CD
18637	22534	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22534	4	Nixon	Nixon	NNP
18637	22534	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22534	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22534	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22534	8	Condon	Condon	NNP
18637	22534	9	,	,	,
18637	22534	10	286	286	CD
18637	22534	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22534	12	73	73	CD
18637	22534	13	,	,	,
18637	22534	14	89	89	CD
18637	22534	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22534	16	1932	1932	CD
18637	22534	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22534	18	.	.	.
18637	22535	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22535	2	10	10	CD
18637	22535	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22535	4	Grovey	Grovey	NNP
18637	22535	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22535	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22535	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22535	8	Townsend	Townsend	NNP
18637	22535	9	,	,	,
18637	22535	10	295	295	CD
18637	22535	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22535	12	45	45	CD
18637	22535	13	,	,	,
18637	22535	14	55	55	CD
18637	22535	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22535	16	1935	1935	CD
18637	22535	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22535	18	.	.	.
18637	22536	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22536	2	11	11	CD
18637	22536	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22536	4	321	321	CD
18637	22536	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22536	6	649	649	CD
18637	22536	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22536	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	22536	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22536	10	.	.	.
18637	22537	1	Notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	22537	2	that	that	IN
18637	22537	3	the	the	DT
18637	22537	4	South	South	NNP
18637	22537	5	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	22537	6	Legislature	Legislature	NNP
18637	22537	7	,	,	,
18637	22537	8	after	after	IN
18637	22537	9	the	the	DT
18637	22537	10	decision	decision	NN
18637	22537	11	in	in	IN
18637	22537	12	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	22537	13	_	_	NNP
18637	22537	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	22537	15	_	_	NNP
18637	22537	16	Allwright	Allwright	NNP
18637	22537	17	,	,	,
18637	22537	18	repealed	repeal	VBD
18637	22537	19	all	all	DT
18637	22537	20	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	22537	21	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	22537	22	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	22537	23	primary	primary	JJ
18637	22537	24	elections	election	NNS
18637	22537	25	and	and	CC
18637	22537	26	political	political	JJ
18637	22537	27	organizations	organization	NNS
18637	22537	28	conducting	conduct	VBG
18637	22537	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22537	30	,	,	,
18637	22537	31	a	a	DT
18637	22537	32	political	political	JJ
18637	22537	33	party	party	NN
18637	22537	34	thus	thus	RB
18637	22537	35	freed	free	VBN
18637	22537	36	of	of	IN
18637	22537	37	control	control	NN
18637	22537	38	is	be	VBZ
18637	22537	39	not	not	RB
18637	22537	40	to	to	TO
18637	22537	41	be	be	VB
18637	22537	42	regarded	regard	VBN
18637	22537	43	as	as	IN
18637	22537	44	a	a	DT
18637	22537	45	private	private	JJ
18637	22537	46	club	club	NN
18637	22537	47	and	and	CC
18637	22537	48	for	for	IN
18637	22537	49	that	that	DT
18637	22537	50	reason	reason	NN
18637	22537	51	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	22537	52	from	from	IN
18637	22537	53	the	the	DT
18637	22537	54	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	22537	55	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
18637	22537	56	against	against	IN
18637	22537	57	racial	racial	JJ
18637	22537	58	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	22537	59	contained	contain	VBN
18637	22537	60	in	in	IN
18637	22537	61	the	the	DT
18637	22537	62	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	22537	63	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22537	64	.	.	.
18637	22538	1	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	22538	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22538	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22538	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22538	5	Elmore	Elmore	NNP
18637	22538	6	,	,	,
18637	22538	7	165	165	CD
18637	22538	8	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22538	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22538	10	2d	2d	NNP
18637	22538	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22538	12	387	387	CD
18637	22538	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22538	14	1947	1947	CD
18637	22538	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22538	16	;	;	:
18637	22538	17	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	22538	18	denied	deny	VBD
18637	22538	19	,	,	,
18637	22538	20	333	333	CD
18637	22538	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22538	22	875	875	CD
18637	22538	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22538	24	1948	1948	CD
18637	22538	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22538	26	.	.	.
18637	22539	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22539	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22539	3	also	also	RB
18637	22539	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22539	5	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	22539	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22539	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22539	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22539	9	Baskin	Baskin	NNP
18637	22539	10	,	,	,
18637	22539	11	78	78	CD
18637	22539	12	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22539	13	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	22539	14	.	.	.
18637	22540	1	933	933	CD
18637	22540	2	,	,	,
18637	22540	3	940	940	CD
18637	22540	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22540	5	1948	1948	CD
18637	22540	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22540	7	which	which	WDT
18637	22540	8	held	hold	VBD
18637	22540	9	violative	violative	NN
18637	22540	10	of	of	IN
18637	22540	11	the	the	DT
18637	22540	12	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	22540	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22540	14	a	a	DT
18637	22540	15	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	22540	16	of	of	IN
18637	22540	17	a	a	DT
18637	22540	18	South	South	NNP
18637	22540	19	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	22540	20	political	political	JJ
18637	22540	21	party	party	NN
18637	22540	22	,	,	,
18637	22540	23	which	which	WDT
18637	22540	24	excluded	exclude	VBD
18637	22540	25	Negroes	negro	NNS
18637	22540	26	from	from	IN
18637	22540	27	membership	membership	NN
18637	22540	28	,	,	,
18637	22540	29	that	that	DT
18637	22540	30	white	white	JJ
18637	22540	31	as	as	RB
18637	22540	32	well	well	RB
18637	22540	33	as	as	IN
18637	22540	34	Negro	negro	JJ
18637	22540	35	qualified	qualified	JJ
18637	22540	36	voters	voter	NNS
18637	22540	37	,	,	,
18637	22540	38	as	as	IN
18637	22540	39	a	a	DT
18637	22540	40	prerequisite	prerequisite	NN
18637	22540	41	for	for	IN
18637	22540	42	voting	voting	NN
18637	22540	43	in	in	IN
18637	22540	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22540	45	primary	primary	NN
18637	22540	46	,	,	,
18637	22540	47	take	take	VB
18637	22540	48	an	an	DT
18637	22540	49	oath	oath	NN
18637	22540	50	that	that	IN
18637	22540	51	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22540	52	will	will	MD
18637	22540	53	support	support	VB
18637	22540	54	separation	separation	NN
18637	22540	55	of	of	IN
18637	22540	56	the	the	DT
18637	22540	57	races	race	NNS
18637	22540	58	.	.	.
18637	22541	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22541	2	12	12	CD
18637	22541	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22541	4	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	22541	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22541	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22541	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22541	8	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	22541	9	,	,	,
18637	22541	10	170	170	CD
18637	22541	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22541	12	213	213	CD
18637	22541	13	,	,	,
18637	22541	14	220	220	CD
18637	22541	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22541	16	1898	1898	CD
18637	22541	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22541	18	.	.	.
18637	22542	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22542	2	13	13	CD
18637	22542	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22542	4	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	22542	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22542	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22542	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22542	8	Schnell	Schnell	NNP
18637	22542	9	,	,	,
18637	22542	10	81	81	CD
18637	22542	11	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22542	12	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	22542	13	.	.	.
18637	22543	1	872	872	CD
18637	22543	2	,	,	,
18637	22543	3	878	878	CD
18637	22543	4	,	,	,
18637	22543	5	880	880	CD
18637	22543	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22543	7	1949	1949	CD
18637	22543	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22543	9	;	;	:
18637	22543	10	affirmed	affirm	VBN
18637	22543	11	,	,	,
18637	22543	12	336	336	CD
18637	22543	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22543	14	933	933	CD
18637	22543	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22543	16	1949	1949	CD
18637	22543	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22543	18	.	.	.
18637	22544	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22544	2	14	14	CD
18637	22544	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22544	4	United	United	NNP
18637	22544	5	States	States	NNP
18637	22544	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22544	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22544	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22544	9	Amsden	Amsden	NNP
18637	22544	10	,	,	,
18637	22544	11	6	6	CD
18637	22544	12	F.	f.	NN
18637	22544	13	819	819	CD
18637	22544	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22544	15	1881	1881	CD
18637	22544	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22544	17	.	.	.
18637	22545	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22545	2	15	15	CD
18637	22545	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22545	4	16	16	CD
18637	22545	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22545	6	.	.	.
18637	22546	1	140	140	CD
18637	22546	2	.	.	.
18637	22547	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22547	2	16	16	CD
18637	22547	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22547	4	United	United	NNP
18637	22547	5	States	States	NNP
18637	22547	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22547	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22547	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22547	9	.	.	.
18637	22548	1	Reese	Reese	NNP
18637	22548	2	,	,	,
18637	22548	3	92	92	CD
18637	22548	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22548	5	214	214	CD
18637	22548	6	,	,	,
18637	22548	7	218	218	CD
18637	22548	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22548	9	1876	1876	CD
18637	22548	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22548	11	.	.	.
18637	22549	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22549	2	17	17	CD
18637	22549	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22549	4	James	James	NNP
18637	22549	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22549	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22549	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22549	8	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	22549	9	,	,	,
18637	22549	10	190	190	CD
18637	22549	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22549	12	127	127	CD
18637	22549	13	,	,	,
18637	22549	14	136	136	CD
18637	22549	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22549	16	1903	1903	CD
18637	22549	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22549	18	_	_	NNP
18637	22549	19	See	See	NNP
18637	22549	20	also	also	RB
18637	22549	21	_	_	NNP
18637	22549	22	Karem	Karem	NNP
18637	22549	23	_	_	NNP
18637	22549	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	22549	25	_	_	NNP
18637	22549	26	United	United	NNP
18637	22549	27	States	States	NNP
18637	22549	28	,	,	,
18637	22549	29	121	121	CD
18637	22549	30	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22549	31	250	250	CD
18637	22549	32	,	,	,
18637	22549	33	259	259	CD
18637	22549	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22549	35	1903	1903	CD
18637	22549	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22549	37	.	.	.
18637	22550	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	22550	2	16	16	CD
18637	22550	3	INCOME	income	NN
18637	22550	4	TAX	tax	NN
18637	22550	5	Page	page	NN
18637	22550	6	History	history	NN
18637	22550	7	and	and	CC
18637	22550	8	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	22550	9	of	of	IN
18637	22550	10	the	the	DT
18637	22550	11	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22550	12	1191	1191	CD
18637	22550	13	Meaning	mean	VBG
18637	22550	14	of	of	IN
18637	22550	15	income	income	NN
18637	22550	16	as	as	IN
18637	22550	17	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	22550	18	from	from	IN
18637	22550	19	capital	capital	NN
18637	22550	20	1192	1192	CD
18637	22550	21	Corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	22550	22	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	22550	23	:	:	:
18637	22550	24	when	when	WRB
18637	22550	25	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22550	26	as	as	IN
18637	22550	27	income	income	NN
18637	22550	28	1193	1193	CD
18637	22550	29	The	the	DT
18637	22550	30	"	"	``
18637	22550	31	stock	stock	NN
18637	22550	32	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	22550	33	case	case	NN
18637	22550	34	"	"	``
18637	22550	35	1193	1193	CD
18637	22550	36	Other	other	JJ
18637	22550	37	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	22550	38	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	22550	39	or	or	CC
18637	22550	40	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	22550	41	:	:	:
18637	22550	42	when	when	WRB
18637	22550	43	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22550	44	as	as	IN
18637	22550	45	income	income	NN
18637	22550	46	1196	1196	CD
18637	22550	47	Gains	gain	NNS
18637	22550	48	in	in	IN
18637	22550	49	the	the	DT
18637	22550	50	form	form	NN
18637	22550	51	of	of	IN
18637	22550	52	real	real	JJ
18637	22550	53	estate	estate	NN
18637	22550	54	:	:	:
18637	22550	55	when	when	WRB
18637	22550	56	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22550	57	as	as	IN
18637	22550	58	income	income	NN
18637	22550	59	1197	1197	CD
18637	22550	60	Gains	gain	NNS
18637	22550	61	in	in	IN
18637	22550	62	the	the	DT
18637	22550	63	form	form	NN
18637	22550	64	of	of	IN
18637	22550	65	bequests	bequest	NNS
18637	22550	66	:	:	:
18637	22550	67	when	when	WRB
18637	22550	68	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22550	69	as	as	IN
18637	22550	70	income	income	NN
18637	22550	71	1198	1198	CD
18637	22550	72	Diminution	diminution	NN
18637	22550	73	of	of	IN
18637	22550	74	loss	loss	NN
18637	22550	75	:	:	:
18637	22550	76	not	not	RB
18637	22550	77	income	income	NN
18637	22550	78	1198	1198	CD
18637	22550	79	Dates	date	NNS
18637	22550	80	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	22550	81	in	in	IN
18637	22550	82	computation	computation	NN
18637	22550	83	of	of	IN
18637	22550	84	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22550	85	gains	gain	NNS
18637	22550	86	1199	1199	CD
18637	22550	87	Deductions	deduction	NNS
18637	22550	88	:	:	:
18637	22550	89	exemptions	exemption	NNS
18637	22550	90	,	,	,
18637	22550	91	etc	etc	FW
18637	22550	92	.	.	.
18637	22551	1	1200	1200	CD
18637	22551	2	Illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	22551	3	gains	gain	NNS
18637	22551	4	as	as	IN
18637	22551	5	income	income	NN
18637	22551	6	1201	1201	CD
18637	22551	7	INCOME	INCOME	NNP
18637	22551	8	TAX	TAX	NNP
18637	22551	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22551	10	16	16	CD
18637	22551	11	The	the	DT
18637	22551	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22551	13	shall	shall	MD
18637	22551	14	have	have	VB
18637	22551	15	power	power	NN
18637	22551	16	to	to	TO
18637	22551	17	lay	lay	VB
18637	22551	18	and	and	CC
18637	22551	19	collect	collect	VB
18637	22551	20	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	22551	21	on	on	IN
18637	22551	22	incomes	income	NNS
18637	22551	23	,	,	,
18637	22551	24	from	from	IN
18637	22551	25	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	22551	26	source	source	NN
18637	22551	27	derived	derive	VBN
18637	22551	28	,	,	,
18637	22551	29	without	without	IN
18637	22551	30	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	22551	31	among	among	IN
18637	22551	32	the	the	DT
18637	22551	33	several	several	JJ
18637	22551	34	States	States	NNPS
18637	22551	35	,	,	,
18637	22551	36	and	and	CC
18637	22551	37	without	without	IN
18637	22551	38	regard	regard	NN
18637	22551	39	to	to	IN
18637	22551	40	any	any	DT
18637	22551	41	census	census	NN
18637	22551	42	or	or	CC
18637	22551	43	enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	22551	44	.	.	.
18637	22552	1	History	history	NN
18637	22552	2	and	and	CC
18637	22552	3	Purpose	Purpose	NNP
18637	22552	4	of	of	IN
18637	22552	5	the	the	DT
18637	22552	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22552	7	The	the	DT
18637	22552	8	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	22552	9	of	of	IN
18637	22552	10	this	this	DT
18637	22552	11	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22552	12	was	be	VBD
18637	22552	13	the	the	DT
18637	22552	14	direct	direct	JJ
18637	22552	15	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	22552	16	of	of	IN
18637	22552	17	the	the	DT
18637	22552	18	decision	decision	NN
18637	22552	19	in	in	IN
18637	22552	20	1895[1	1895[1	CD
18637	22552	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22552	22	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	22552	23	the	the	DT
18637	22552	24	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	22552	25	of	of	IN
18637	22552	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22552	27	the	the	DT
18637	22552	28	previous	previous	JJ
18637	22552	29	year	year	NN
18637	22552	30	to	to	IN
18637	22552	31	tax	tax	NN
18637	22552	32	incomes	income	NNS
18637	22552	33	uniformly	uniformly	JJ
18637	22552	34	throughout	throughout	IN
18637	22552	35	the	the	DT
18637	22552	36	United	United	NNP
18637	22552	37	States[2	States[2	NNP
18637	22552	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22552	39	was	be	VBD
18637	22552	40	held	hold	VBN
18637	22552	41	by	by	IN
18637	22552	42	a	a	DT
18637	22552	43	divided	divide	VBN
18637	22552	44	court	court	NN
18637	22552	45	to	to	TO
18637	22552	46	be	be	VB
18637	22552	47	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	22552	48	.	.	.
18637	22553	1	A	a	DT
18637	22553	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	22553	3	on	on	IN
18637	22553	4	incomes	income	NNS
18637	22553	5	derived	derive	VBN
18637	22553	6	from	from	IN
18637	22553	7	property,[3	property,[3	NNP
18637	22553	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22553	9	the	the	DT
18637	22553	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22553	11	declared	declare	VBD
18637	22553	12	,	,	,
18637	22553	13	was	be	VBD
18637	22553	14	a	a	DT
18637	22553	15	"	"	``
18637	22553	16	direct	direct	JJ
18637	22553	17	tax	tax	NN
18637	22553	18	"	"	''
18637	22553	19	which	which	WDT
18637	22553	20	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22553	21	under	under	IN
18637	22553	22	the	the	DT
18637	22553	23	terms	term	NNS
18637	22553	24	of	of	IN
18637	22553	25	article	article	NN
18637	22553	26	I	i	NN
18637	22553	27	,	,	,
18637	22553	28	section	section	NN
18637	22553	29	2	2	CD
18637	22553	30	,	,	,
18637	22553	31	clause	clause	NN
18637	22553	32	3	3	CD
18637	22553	33	,	,	,
18637	22553	34	and	and	CC
18637	22553	35	section	section	NN
18637	22553	36	9	9	CD
18637	22553	37	,	,	,
18637	22553	38	clause	clause	NN
18637	22553	39	4	4	CD
18637	22553	40	,	,	,
18637	22553	41	could	could	MD
18637	22553	42	impose	impose	VB
18637	22553	43	only	only	RB
18637	22553	44	by	by	IN
18637	22553	45	the	the	DT
18637	22553	46	rule	rule	NN
18637	22553	47	of	of	IN
18637	22553	48	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	22553	49	according	accord	VBG
18637	22553	50	to	to	IN
18637	22553	51	population	population	NN
18637	22553	52	;	;	:
18637	22553	53	although	although	IN
18637	22553	54	scarcely	scarcely	RB
18637	22553	55	fifteen	fifteen	CD
18637	22553	56	years	year	NNS
18637	22553	57	prior	prior	RB
18637	22553	58	the	the	DT
18637	22553	59	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	22553	60	had	have	VBD
18637	22553	61	unanimously	unanimously	RB
18637	22553	62	sustained[4	sustained[4	VBN
18637	22553	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22553	64	the	the	DT
18637	22553	65	collection	collection	NN
18637	22553	66	of	of	IN
18637	22553	67	a	a	DT
18637	22553	68	similar	similar	JJ
18637	22553	69	tax	tax	NN
18637	22553	70	during	during	IN
18637	22553	71	the	the	DT
18637	22553	72	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	22553	73	War,[5	War,[5	NNP
18637	22553	74	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22553	75	the	the	DT
18637	22553	76	only	only	JJ
18637	22553	77	other	other	JJ
18637	22553	78	occasion	occasion	NN
18637	22553	79	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	22553	80	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22553	81	Sixteen	Sixteen	NNP
18637	22553	82	in	in	IN
18637	22553	83	which	which	WDT
18637	22553	84	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22553	85	had	have	VBD
18637	22553	86	ventured	venture	VBN
18637	22553	87	to	to	TO
18637	22553	88	utilize	utilize	VB
18637	22553	89	this	this	DT
18637	22553	90	method	method	NN
18637	22553	91	of	of	IN
18637	22553	92	raising	raise	VBG
18637	22553	93	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	22553	94	.	.	.
18637	22554	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22554	2	6	6	CD
18637	22554	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22554	4	During	during	IN
18637	22554	5	the	the	DT
18637	22554	6	interim	interim	NN
18637	22554	7	between	between	IN
18637	22554	8	the	the	DT
18637	22554	9	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	22554	10	decision	decision	NN
18637	22554	11	in	in	IN
18637	22554	12	1895	1895	CD
18637	22554	13	,	,	,
18637	22554	14	and	and	CC
18637	22554	15	the	the	DT
18637	22554	16	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	22554	17	of	of	IN
18637	22554	18	the	the	DT
18637	22554	19	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	22554	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22554	21	in	in	IN
18637	22554	22	1913	1913	CD
18637	22554	23	,	,	,
18637	22554	24	the	the	DT
18637	22554	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22554	26	gave	give	VBD
18637	22554	27	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	22554	28	of	of	IN
18637	22554	29	a	a	DT
18637	22554	30	greater	great	JJR
18637	22554	31	awareness	awareness	NN
18637	22554	32	of	of	IN
18637	22554	33	the	the	DT
18637	22554	34	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
18637	22554	35	consequences	consequence	NNS
18637	22554	36	to	to	IN
18637	22554	37	national	national	JJ
18637	22554	38	solvency	solvency	NN
18637	22554	39	which	which	WDT
18637	22554	40	that	that	IN
18637	22554	41	holding	hold	VBG
18637	22554	42	threatened	threaten	VBD
18637	22554	43	,	,	,
18637	22554	44	and	and	CC
18637	22554	45	partially	partially	RB
18637	22554	46	circumvented	circumvent	VBD
18637	22554	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22554	48	,	,	,
18637	22554	49	either	either	CC
18637	22554	50	by	by	IN
18637	22554	51	taking	take	VBG
18637	22554	52	refuge	refuge	NN
18637	22554	53	in	in	IN
18637	22554	54	redefinitions	redefinition	NNS
18637	22554	55	of	of	IN
18637	22554	56	"	"	``
18637	22554	57	direct	direct	JJ
18637	22554	58	tax	tax	NN
18637	22554	59	"	"	''
18637	22554	60	or	or	CC
18637	22554	61	,	,	,
18637	22554	62	and	and	CC
18637	22554	63	more	more	RBR
18637	22554	64	especially	especially	RB
18637	22554	65	,	,	,
18637	22554	66	by	by	IN
18637	22554	67	emphasizing	emphasize	VBG
18637	22554	68	,	,	,
18637	22554	69	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	22554	70	to	to	IN
18637	22554	71	the	the	DT
18637	22554	72	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	22554	73	of	of	IN
18637	22554	74	the	the	DT
18637	22554	75	former	former	JJ
18637	22554	76	,	,	,
18637	22554	77	the	the	DT
18637	22554	78	history	history	NN
18637	22554	79	of	of	IN
18637	22554	80	excise	excise	NN
18637	22554	81	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	22554	82	.	.	.
18637	22555	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	22555	2	,	,	,
18637	22555	3	in	in	IN
18637	22555	4	a	a	DT
18637	22555	5	series	series	NN
18637	22555	6	of	of	IN
18637	22555	7	cases	case	NNS
18637	22555	8	,	,	,
18637	22555	9	notably	notably	RB
18637	22555	10	Nicol	Nicol	NNP
18637	22555	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	22555	12	Ames,[7	Ames,[7	NNP
18637	22555	13	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22555	14	Knowlton	Knowlton	NNP
18637	22555	15	_	_	NNP
18637	22555	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	22555	17	_	_	NNP
18637	22555	18	Moore[8	Moore[8	NNP
18637	22555	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22555	20	and	and	CC
18637	22555	21	Patton	Patton	NNP
18637	22555	22	_	_	NNP
18637	22555	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	22555	24	_	_	NNP
18637	22555	25	Brady[9	Brady[9	NNP
18637	22555	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22555	27	the	the	DT
18637	22555	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22555	29	held	hold	VBD
18637	22555	30	the	the	DT
18637	22555	31	following	follow	VBG
18637	22555	32	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	22555	33	to	to	TO
18637	22555	34	have	have	VB
18637	22555	35	been	be	VBN
18637	22555	36	levied	levy	VBN
18637	22555	37	merely	merely	RB
18637	22555	38	upon	upon	IN
18637	22555	39	one	one	CD
18637	22555	40	of	of	IN
18637	22555	41	the	the	DT
18637	22555	42	"	"	``
18637	22555	43	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	22555	44	of	of	IN
18637	22555	45	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	22555	46	"	"	''
18637	22555	47	and	and	CC
18637	22555	48	hence	hence	RB
18637	22555	49	to	to	TO
18637	22555	50	be	be	VB
18637	22555	51	excises	excise	NNS
18637	22555	52	;	;	:
18637	22555	53	a	a	DT
18637	22555	54	tax	tax	NN
18637	22555	55	which	which	WDT
18637	22555	56	involved	involve	VBN
18637	22555	57	affixing	affix	VBG
18637	22555	58	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	22555	59	stamps	stamp	NNS
18637	22555	60	to	to	IN
18637	22555	61	memoranda	memorandum	NNS
18637	22555	62	evidencing	evidence	VBG
18637	22555	63	the	the	DT
18637	22555	64	sale	sale	NN
18637	22555	65	of	of	IN
18637	22555	66	merchandise	merchandise	NN
18637	22555	67	on	on	IN
18637	22555	68	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	22555	69	exchanges	exchange	NNS
18637	22555	70	,	,	,
18637	22555	71	an	an	DT
18637	22555	72	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	22555	73	tax	tax	NN
18637	22555	74	,	,	,
18637	22555	75	and	and	CC
18637	22555	76	a	a	DT
18637	22555	77	war	war	NN
18637	22555	78	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	22555	79	tax	tax	NN
18637	22555	80	upon	upon	IN
18637	22555	81	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	22555	82	on	on	IN
18637	22555	83	which	which	WDT
18637	22555	84	the	the	DT
18637	22555	85	hitherto	hitherto	JJ
18637	22555	86	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	22555	87	excise	excise	NN
18637	22555	88	tax	tax	NN
18637	22555	89	had	have	VBD
18637	22555	90	already	already	RB
18637	22555	91	been	be	VBN
18637	22555	92	paid	pay	VBN
18637	22555	93	and	and	CC
18637	22555	94	which	which	WDT
18637	22555	95	was	be	VBD
18637	22555	96	held	hold	VBN
18637	22555	97	by	by	IN
18637	22555	98	the	the	DT
18637	22555	99	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
18637	22555	100	for	for	IN
18637	22555	101	resale	resale	NN
18637	22555	102	.	.	.
18637	22556	1	Thanks	thank	NNS
18637	22556	2	to	to	IN
18637	22556	3	such	such	JJ
18637	22556	4	endeavors	endeavor	NNS
18637	22556	5	the	the	DT
18637	22556	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22556	7	thus	thus	RB
18637	22556	8	found	find	VBD
18637	22556	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22556	10	possible	possible	JJ
18637	22556	11	,	,	,
18637	22556	12	in	in	IN
18637	22556	13	1911,[10	1911,[10	CD
18637	22556	14	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22556	15	to	to	TO
18637	22556	16	sustain	sustain	VB
18637	22556	17	a	a	DT
18637	22556	18	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	22556	19	income	income	NN
18637	22556	20	tax	tax	NN
18637	22556	21	as	as	IN
18637	22556	22	an	an	DT
18637	22556	23	excise	excise	NN
18637	22556	24	"	"	``
18637	22556	25	measured	measure	VBN
18637	22556	26	by	by	IN
18637	22556	27	income	income	NN
18637	22556	28	"	"	''
18637	22556	29	on	on	IN
18637	22556	30	the	the	DT
18637	22556	31	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	22556	32	of	of	IN
18637	22556	33	doing	do	VBG
18637	22556	34	business	business	NN
18637	22556	35	in	in	IN
18637	22556	36	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	22556	37	form	form	NN
18637	22556	38	.	.	.
18637	22557	1	The	the	DT
18637	22557	2	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	22557	3	of	of	IN
18637	22557	4	the	the	DT
18637	22557	5	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	22557	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22557	7	,	,	,
18637	22557	8	however	however	RB
18637	22557	9	,	,	,
18637	22557	10	put	put	VB
18637	22557	11	an	an	DT
18637	22557	12	end	end	NN
18637	22557	13	to	to	IN
18637	22557	14	speculation	speculation	NN
18637	22557	15	as	as	IN
18637	22557	16	to	to	IN
18637	22557	17	whether	whether	IN
18637	22557	18	the	the	DT
18637	22557	19	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22557	20	,	,	,
18637	22557	21	unaided	unaide	VBN
18637	22557	22	by	by	IN
18637	22557	23	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	22557	24	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22557	25	,	,	,
18637	22557	26	would	would	MD
18637	22557	27	persist	persist	VB
18637	22557	28	along	along	IN
18637	22557	29	these	these	DT
18637	22557	30	lines	line	NNS
18637	22557	31	of	of	IN
18637	22557	32	construction	construction	NN
18637	22557	33	until	until	IN
18637	22557	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22557	35	had	have	VBD
18637	22557	36	reversed	reverse	VBN
18637	22557	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22557	38	holding	holding	NN
18637	22557	39	in	in	IN
18637	22557	40	the	the	DT
18637	22557	41	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	22557	42	Case	Case	NNP
18637	22557	43	.	.	.
18637	22558	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
18637	22558	2	,	,	,
18637	22558	3	in	in	IN
18637	22558	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22558	5	initial	initial	JJ
18637	22558	6	appraisal[11	appraisal[11	NN
18637	22558	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22558	8	of	of	IN
18637	22558	9	the	the	DT
18637	22558	10	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22558	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22558	12	classified	classify	VBD
18637	22558	13	income	income	NN
18637	22558	14	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	22558	15	as	as	IN
18637	22558	16	being	be	VBG
18637	22558	17	inherently	inherently	RB
18637	22558	18	"	"	``
18637	22558	19	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	22558	20	.	.	.
18637	22558	21	"	"	''
18637	22559	1	"	"	``
18637	22559	2	The	the	DT
18637	22559	3	command	command	NN
18637	22559	4	of	of	IN
18637	22559	5	the	the	DT
18637	22559	6	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22559	7	that	that	WDT
18637	22559	8	all	all	DT
18637	22559	9	income	income	NN
18637	22559	10	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	22559	11	shall	shall	MD
18637	22559	12	not	not	RB
18637	22559	13	be	be	VB
18637	22559	14	subject	subject	JJ
18637	22559	15	to	to	IN
18637	22559	16	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	22559	17	by	by	IN
18637	22559	18	a	a	DT
18637	22559	19	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	22559	20	of	of	IN
18637	22559	21	the	the	DT
18637	22559	22	sources	source	NNS
18637	22559	23	from	from	IN
18637	22559	24	which	which	WDT
18637	22559	25	the	the	DT
18637	22559	26	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	22559	27	income	income	NN
18637	22559	28	may	may	MD
18637	22559	29	be	be	VB
18637	22559	30	derived	derive	VBN
18637	22559	31	,	,	,
18637	22559	32	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	22559	33	the	the	DT
18637	22559	34	application	application	NN
18637	22559	35	to	to	IN
18637	22559	36	such	such	JJ
18637	22559	37	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	22559	38	of	of	IN
18637	22559	39	the	the	DT
18637	22559	40	rule	rule	NN
18637	22559	41	applied	apply	VBN
18637	22559	42	in	in	IN
18637	22559	43	the	the	DT
18637	22559	44	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	22559	45	Case	Case	NNP
18637	22559	46	by	by	IN
18637	22559	47	which	which	WDT
18637	22559	48	alone	alone	JJ
18637	22559	49	such	such	JJ
18637	22559	50	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	22559	51	were	be	VBD
18637	22559	52	removed	remove	VBN
18637	22559	53	from	from	IN
18637	22559	54	the	the	DT
18637	22559	55	great	great	JJ
18637	22559	56	class	class	NN
18637	22559	57	of	of	IN
18637	22559	58	excises	excise	NNS
18637	22559	59	,	,	,
18637	22559	60	duties	duty	NNS
18637	22559	61	,	,	,
18637	22559	62	and	and	CC
18637	22559	63	imposts	impost	NNS
18637	22559	64	subject	subject	JJ
18637	22559	65	to	to	IN
18637	22559	66	the	the	DT
18637	22559	67	rule	rule	NN
18637	22559	68	of	of	IN
18637	22559	69	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	22559	70	and	and	CC
18637	22559	71	were	be	VBD
18637	22559	72	placed	place	VBN
18637	22559	73	under	under	IN
18637	22559	74	the	the	DT
18637	22559	75	other	other	JJ
18637	22559	76	or	or	CC
18637	22559	77	direct	direct	JJ
18637	22559	78	class	class	NN
18637	22559	79	.	.	.
18637	22560	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22560	2	12	12	CD
18637	22560	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22560	4	*	*	NFP
18637	22560	5	*	*	NFP
18637	22560	6	*	*	NFP
18637	22560	7	The	the	DT
18637	22560	8	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	22560	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22560	10	conferred	confer	VBD
18637	22560	11	no	no	DT
18637	22560	12	new	new	JJ
18637	22560	13	power	power	NN
18637	22560	14	of	of	IN
18637	22560	15	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	22560	16	but	but	CC
18637	22560	17	simply	simply	RB
18637	22560	18	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	22560	19	the	the	DT
18637	22560	20	previous	previous	JJ
18637	22560	21	complete	complete	JJ
18637	22560	22	and	and	CC
18637	22560	23	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	22560	24	power	power	NN
18637	22560	25	of	of	IN
18637	22560	26	income	income	NN
18637	22560	27	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	22560	28	possessed	possess	VBN
18637	22560	29	by	by	IN
18637	22560	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22560	31	from	from	IN
18637	22560	32	the	the	DT
18637	22560	33	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	22560	34	from	from	IN
18637	22560	35	being	be	VBG
18637	22560	36	taken	take	VBN
18637	22560	37	out	out	IN
18637	22560	38	of	of	IN
18637	22560	39	the	the	DT
18637	22560	40	category	category	NN
18637	22560	41	of	of	IN
18637	22560	42	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	22560	43	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	22560	44	to	to	TO
18637	22560	45	which	which	WDT
18637	22560	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22560	47	inherently	inherently	RB
18637	22560	48	belonged	belong	VBD
18637	22560	49	*	*	NFP
18637	22560	50	*	*	NFP
18637	22560	51	*	*	NFP
18637	22560	52	"	"	''
18637	22560	53	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22560	54	13	13	CD
18637	22560	55	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22560	56	Meaning	mean	VBG
18637	22560	57	of	of	IN
18637	22560	58	"	"	``
18637	22560	59	Income	Income	NNP
18637	22560	60	"	"	''
18637	22560	61	as	as	IN
18637	22560	62	Distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	22560	63	From	from	IN
18637	22560	64	Capital	Capital	NNP
18637	22560	65	Building	Building	NNP
18637	22560	66	upon	upon	IN
18637	22560	67	definitions	definition	NNS
18637	22560	68	formulated	formulate	VBN
18637	22560	69	in	in	IN
18637	22560	70	cases	case	NNS
18637	22560	71	construing	construe	VBG
18637	22560	72	the	the	DT
18637	22560	73	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	22560	74	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	22560	75	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22560	76	of	of	IN
18637	22560	77	1909,[14	1909,[14	CD
18637	22560	78	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22560	79	the	the	DT
18637	22560	80	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22560	81	initially	initially	RB
18637	22560	82	described	describe	VBD
18637	22560	83	income	income	NN
18637	22560	84	as	as	IN
18637	22560	85	the	the	DT
18637	22560	86	"	"	``
18637	22560	87	gain	gain	NN
18637	22560	88	derived	derive	VBN
18637	22560	89	from	from	IN
18637	22560	90	capital	capital	NN
18637	22560	91	,	,	,
18637	22560	92	from	from	IN
18637	22560	93	labor	labor	NN
18637	22560	94	,	,	,
18637	22560	95	or	or	CC
18637	22560	96	from	from	IN
18637	22560	97	both	both	CC
18637	22560	98	combined	combine	VBN
18637	22560	99	,	,	,
18637	22560	100	"	"	''
18637	22560	101	inclusive	inclusive	JJ
18637	22560	102	of	of	IN
18637	22560	103	the	the	DT
18637	22560	104	"	"	``
18637	22560	105	profit	profit	NN
18637	22560	106	gained	gain	VBD
18637	22560	107	through	through	IN
18637	22560	108	a	a	DT
18637	22560	109	sale	sale	NN
18637	22560	110	or	or	CC
18637	22560	111	conversion	conversion	NN
18637	22560	112	of	of	IN
18637	22560	113	capital	capital	NN
18637	22560	114	assets";[15	assets";[15	NNP
18637	22560	115	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22560	116	and	and	CC
18637	22560	117	in	in	IN
18637	22560	118	the	the	DT
18637	22560	119	following	follow	VBG
18637	22560	120	array	array	NN
18637	22560	121	of	of	IN
18637	22560	122	factual	factual	JJ
18637	22560	123	situations	situation	NNS
18637	22560	124	has	have	VBZ
18637	22560	125	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	22560	126	applied	apply	VBN
18637	22560	127	this	this	DT
18637	22560	128	definition	definition	NN
18637	22560	129	to	to	TO
18637	22560	130	achieve	achieve	VB
18637	22560	131	results	result	NNS
18637	22560	132	that	that	WDT
18637	22560	133	have	have	VBP
18637	22560	134	been	be	VBN
18637	22560	135	productive	productive	JJ
18637	22560	136	of	of	IN
18637	22560	137	extended	extended	JJ
18637	22560	138	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	22560	139	.	.	.
18637	22561	1	CORPORATE	corporate	JJ
18637	22561	2	DIVIDENDS	dividend	NNS
18637	22561	3	:	:	:
18637	22561	4	WHEN	when	WRB
18637	22561	5	TAXABLE	taxable	NN
18637	22561	6	AS	as	IN
18637	22561	7	INCOME	income	NN
18637	22561	8	Rendered	render	VBN
18637	22561	9	in	in	IN
18637	22561	10	conformity	conformity	NN
18637	22561	11	with	with	IN
18637	22561	12	the	the	DT
18637	22561	13	belief	belief	NN
18637	22561	14	that	that	IN
18637	22561	15	all	all	DT
18637	22561	16	income	income	NN
18637	22561	17	"	"	''
18637	22561	18	in	in	IN
18637	22561	19	the	the	DT
18637	22561	20	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	22561	21	sense	sense	NN
18637	22561	22	of	of	IN
18637	22561	23	the	the	DT
18637	22561	24	word	word	NN
18637	22561	25	"	"	``
18637	22561	26	became	become	VBD
18637	22561	27	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22561	28	under	under	IN
18637	22561	29	the	the	DT
18637	22561	30	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	22561	31	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22561	32	,	,	,
18637	22561	33	the	the	DT
18637	22561	34	earliest	early	JJS
18637	22561	35	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	22561	36	of	of	IN
18637	22561	37	the	the	DT
18637	22561	38	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22561	39	on	on	IN
18637	22561	40	the	the	DT
18637	22561	41	taxability	taxability	NN
18637	22561	42	of	of	IN
18637	22561	43	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	22561	44	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	22561	45	occasioned	occasion	VBD
18637	22561	46	little	little	JJ
18637	22561	47	comment	comment	NN
18637	22561	48	.	.	.
18637	22562	1	Emphasizing	emphasize	VBG
18637	22562	2	that	that	IN
18637	22562	3	in	in	IN
18637	22562	4	all	all	DT
18637	22562	5	such	such	JJ
18637	22562	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	22562	7	the	the	DT
18637	22562	8	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	22562	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	22562	10	to	to	TO
18637	22562	11	be	be	VB
18637	22562	12	viewed	view	VBN
18637	22562	13	as	as	IN
18637	22562	14	"	"	``
18637	22562	15	a	a	DT
18637	22562	16	different	different	JJ
18637	22562	17	entity	entity	NN
18637	22562	18	from	from	IN
18637	22562	19	the	the	DT
18637	22562	20	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22562	21	,	,	,
18637	22562	22	"	"	''
18637	22562	23	the	the	DT
18637	22562	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22562	25	in	in	IN
18637	22562	26	Lynch	Lynch	NNP
18637	22562	27	_	_	NNP
18637	22562	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	22562	29	_	_	NNP
18637	22562	30	Hornby[16	Hornby[16	NNP
18637	22562	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22562	32	held	hold	VBN
18637	22562	33	that	that	IN
18637	22562	34	a	a	DT
18637	22562	35	cash	cash	NN
18637	22562	36	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22562	37	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22562	38	to	to	IN
18637	22562	39	24	24	CD
18637	22562	40	%	%	NN
18637	22562	41	of	of	IN
18637	22562	42	the	the	DT
18637	22562	43	par	par	NN
18637	22562	44	value	value	NN
18637	22562	45	of	of	IN
18637	22562	46	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	22562	47	stock	stock	NN
18637	22562	48	and	and	CC
18637	22562	49	made	make	VBD
18637	22562	50	possible	possible	JJ
18637	22562	51	largely	largely	RB
18637	22562	52	by	by	IN
18637	22562	53	the	the	DT
18637	22562	54	conversion	conversion	NN
18637	22562	55	into	into	IN
18637	22562	56	money	money	NN
18637	22562	57	of	of	IN
18637	22562	58	assets	asset	NNS
18637	22562	59	earned	earn	VBN
18637	22562	60	prior	prior	RB
18637	22562	61	to	to	IN
18637	22562	62	the	the	DT
18637	22562	63	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	22562	64	of	of	IN
18637	22562	65	the	the	DT
18637	22562	66	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22562	67	,	,	,
18637	22562	68	was	be	VBD
18637	22562	69	income	income	NN
18637	22562	70	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22562	71	to	to	IN
18637	22562	72	the	the	DT
18637	22562	73	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	22562	74	for	for	IN
18637	22562	75	the	the	DT
18637	22562	76	year	year	NN
18637	22562	77	in	in	IN
18637	22562	78	which	which	WDT
18637	22562	79	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22562	80	received	receive	VBD
18637	22562	81	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22562	82	,	,	,
18637	22562	83	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	22562	84	that	that	IN
18637	22562	85	such	such	PDT
18637	22562	86	an	an	DT
18637	22562	87	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
18637	22562	88	payment	payment	NN
18637	22562	89	might	may	MD
18637	22562	90	appear	appear	VB
18637	22562	91	"	"	``
18637	22562	92	to	to	TO
18637	22562	93	be	be	VB
18637	22562	94	a	a	DT
18637	22562	95	mere	mere	JJ
18637	22562	96	realization	realization	NN
18637	22562	97	in	in	IN
18637	22562	98	possession	possession	NN
18637	22562	99	of	of	IN
18637	22562	100	an	an	DT
18637	22562	101	inchoate	inchoate	JJ
18637	22562	102	and	and	CC
18637	22562	103	contingent	contingent	JJ
18637	22562	104	interest	interest	NN
18637	22562	105	*	*	NFP
18637	22562	106	*	*	NFP
18637	22562	107	*	*	NFP
18637	22562	108	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22562	109	of	of	IN
18637	22562	110	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22562	111	the	the	DT
18637	22562	112	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	22562	113	*	*	NFP
18637	22562	114	*	*	NFP
18637	22562	115	*	*	NFP
18637	22562	116	in	in	IN
18637	22562	117	a	a	DT
18637	22562	118	surplus	surplus	NN
18637	22562	119	of	of	IN
18637	22562	120	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	22562	121	assets	asset	NNS
18637	22562	122	previously	previously	RB
18637	22562	123	existing	exist	VBG
18637	22562	124	.	.	.
18637	22562	125	"	"	''
18637	22563	1	In	in	IN
18637	22563	2	Peabody	Peabody	NNP
18637	22563	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22563	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22563	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22563	6	Eisner,[17	Eisner,[17	NNP
18637	22563	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22563	8	decided	decide	VBN
18637	22563	9	on	on	IN
18637	22563	10	the	the	DT
18637	22563	11	same	same	JJ
18637	22563	12	day	day	NN
18637	22563	13	and	and	CC
18637	22563	14	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	22563	15	to	to	TO
18637	22563	16	have	have	VB
18637	22563	17	been	be	VBN
18637	22563	18	controlled	control	VBN
18637	22563	19	by	by	IN
18637	22563	20	the	the	DT
18637	22563	21	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	22563	22	case	case	NN
18637	22563	23	,	,	,
18637	22563	24	the	the	DT
18637	22563	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22563	26	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	22563	27	that	that	IN
18637	22563	28	a	a	DT
18637	22563	29	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22563	30	paid	pay	VBN
18637	22563	31	in	in	IN
18637	22563	32	the	the	DT
18637	22563	33	stock	stock	NN
18637	22563	34	of	of	IN
18637	22563	35	another	another	DT
18637	22563	36	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22563	37	,	,	,
18637	22563	38	although	although	IN
18637	22563	39	representing	represent	VBG
18637	22563	40	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	22563	41	that	that	WDT
18637	22563	42	had	have	VBD
18637	22563	43	accrued	accrue	VBN
18637	22563	44	before	before	IN
18637	22563	45	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	22563	46	of	of	IN
18637	22563	47	the	the	DT
18637	22563	48	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22563	49	,	,	,
18637	22563	50	was	be	VBD
18637	22563	51	also	also	RB
18637	22563	52	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22563	53	to	to	IN
18637	22563	54	the	the	DT
18637	22563	55	shareholder	shareholder	NN
18637	22563	56	as	as	IN
18637	22563	57	income	income	NN
18637	22563	58	.	.	.
18637	22564	1	The	the	DT
18637	22564	2	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22564	3	was	be	VBD
18637	22564	4	likened	liken	VBN
18637	22564	5	to	to	IN
18637	22564	6	a	a	DT
18637	22564	7	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	22564	8	in	in	IN
18637	22564	9	specie	specie	NN
18637	22564	10	.	.	.
18637	22565	1	THE	the	DT
18637	22565	2	"	"	``
18637	22565	3	STOCK	stock	NN
18637	22565	4	DIVIDENDS	dividend	NNS
18637	22565	5	CASE	case	NN
18637	22565	6	"	"	``
18637	22565	7	Two	two	CD
18637	22565	8	years	year	NNS
18637	22565	9	later	later	RBR
18637	22565	10	the	the	DT
18637	22565	11	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22565	12	decided	decide	VBD
18637	22565	13	Eisner	Eisner	NNP
18637	22565	14	_	_	NNP
18637	22565	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	22565	16	_	_	NNP
18637	22565	17	Macomber,[18	Macomber,[18	NNP
18637	22565	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22565	19	and	and	CC
18637	22565	20	the	the	DT
18637	22565	21	controversy	controversy	NN
18637	22565	22	which	which	WDT
18637	22565	23	that	that	DT
18637	22565	24	decision	decision	NN
18637	22565	25	precipitated	precipitate	VBD
18637	22565	26	still	still	RB
18637	22565	27	endures	endure	VBZ
18637	22565	28	.	.	.
18637	22566	1	Departing	depart	VBG
18637	22566	2	from	from	IN
18637	22566	3	the	the	DT
18637	22566	4	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	22566	5	placed	place	VBN
18637	22566	6	upon	upon	IN
18637	22566	7	the	the	DT
18637	22566	8	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	22566	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22566	10	in	in	IN
18637	22566	11	the	the	DT
18637	22566	12	earlier	early	JJR
18637	22566	13	cases	case	NNS
18637	22566	14	;	;	:
18637	22566	15	namely	namely	RB
18637	22566	16	,	,	,
18637	22566	17	that	that	IN
18637	22566	18	the	the	DT
18637	22566	19	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	22566	20	of	of	IN
18637	22566	21	the	the	DT
18637	22566	22	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22566	23	was	be	VBD
18637	22566	24	to	to	TO
18637	22566	25	correct	correct	VB
18637	22566	26	the	the	DT
18637	22566	27	"	"	``
18637	22566	28	error	error	NN
18637	22566	29	"	"	''
18637	22566	30	committed	commit	VBN
18637	22566	31	in	in	IN
18637	22566	32	the	the	DT
18637	22566	33	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	22566	34	Case	Case	NNP
18637	22566	35	and	and	CC
18637	22566	36	to	to	TO
18637	22566	37	restore	restore	VB
18637	22566	38	income	income	NN
18637	22566	39	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	22566	40	to	to	IN
18637	22566	41	"	"	``
18637	22566	42	the	the	DT
18637	22566	43	category	category	NN
18637	22566	44	of	of	IN
18637	22566	45	indirect	indirect	JJ
18637	22566	46	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	22566	47	to	to	TO
18637	22566	48	which	which	WDT
18637	22566	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22566	50	inherently	inherently	RB
18637	22566	51	belonged	belong	VBD
18637	22566	52	,	,	,
18637	22566	53	"	"	''
18637	22566	54	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22566	55	Pitney	Pitney	NNP
18637	22566	56	,	,	,
18637	22566	57	who	who	WP
18637	22566	58	delivered	deliver	VBD
18637	22566	59	the	the	DT
18637	22566	60	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	22566	61	in	in	IN
18637	22566	62	the	the	DT
18637	22566	63	Eisner	Eisner	NNP
18637	22566	64	Case	Case	NNP
18637	22566	65	,	,	,
18637	22566	66	indicated	indicate	VBD
18637	22566	67	that	that	IN
18637	22566	68	the	the	DT
18637	22566	69	sole	sole	JJ
18637	22566	70	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	22566	71	of	of	IN
18637	22566	72	the	the	DT
18637	22566	73	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	22566	74	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22566	75	was	be	VBD
18637	22566	76	merely	merely	RB
18637	22566	77	to	to	TO
18637	22566	78	"	"	``
18637	22566	79	remove	remove	VB
18637	22566	80	the	the	DT
18637	22566	81	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	22566	82	which	which	WDT
18637	22566	83	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	22566	84	might	may	MD
18637	22566	85	exist	exist	VB
18637	22566	86	for	for	IN
18637	22566	87	an	an	DT
18637	22566	88	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	22566	89	among	among	IN
18637	22566	90	the	the	DT
18637	22566	91	States	States	NNP
18637	22566	92	of	of	IN
18637	22566	93	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	22566	94	laid	lay	VBN
18637	22566	95	on	on	IN
18637	22566	96	income	income	NN
18637	22566	97	.	.	.
18637	22566	98	"	"	''
18637	22567	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22567	2	thereupon	thereupon	RB
18637	22567	3	undertook	undertake	VBD
18637	22567	4	to	to	TO
18637	22567	5	demonstrate	demonstrate	VB
18637	22567	6	how	how	WRB
18637	22567	7	what	what	WP
18637	22567	8	was	be	VBD
18637	22567	9	not	not	RB
18637	22567	10	income	income	NN
18637	22567	11	,	,	,
18637	22567	12	but	but	CC
18637	22567	13	an	an	DT
18637	22567	14	increment	increment	NN
18637	22567	15	of	of	IN
18637	22567	16	capital	capital	NN
18637	22567	17	when	when	WRB
18637	22567	18	received	receive	VBN
18637	22567	19	,	,	,
18637	22567	20	could	could	MD
18637	22567	21	later	later	RB
18637	22567	22	be	be	VB
18637	22567	23	transmitted	transmit	VBN
18637	22567	24	into	into	IN
18637	22567	25	income	income	NN
18637	22567	26	upon	upon	IN
18637	22567	27	sale	sale	NN
18637	22567	28	or	or	CC
18637	22567	29	conversion	conversion	NN
18637	22567	30	,	,	,
18637	22567	31	and	and	CC
18637	22567	32	could	could	MD
18637	22567	33	be	be	VB
18637	22567	34	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	22567	35	as	as	IN
18637	22567	36	such	such	JJ
18637	22567	37	without	without	IN
18637	22567	38	the	the	DT
18637	22567	39	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	22567	40	of	of	IN
18637	22567	41	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	22567	42	.	.	.
18637	22568	1	In	in	IN
18637	22568	2	short	short	JJ
18637	22568	3	,	,	,
18637	22568	4	the	the	DT
18637	22568	5	term	term	NN
18637	22568	6	"	"	``
18637	22568	7	income	income	NN
18637	22568	8	"	"	''
18637	22568	9	reacquired	reacquire	VBD
18637	22568	10	to	to	IN
18637	22568	11	some	some	DT
18637	22568	12	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
18637	22568	13	extent	extent	NN
18637	22568	14	a	a	DT
18637	22568	15	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
18637	22568	16	significance	significance	NN
18637	22568	17	.	.	.
18637	22569	1	Specifically	specifically	RB
18637	22569	2	,	,	,
18637	22569	3	the	the	DT
18637	22569	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22569	5	held	hold	VBD
18637	22569	6	that	that	IN
18637	22569	7	a	a	DT
18637	22569	8	stock	stock	NN
18637	22569	9	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22569	10	was	be	VBD
18637	22569	11	capital	capital	NN
18637	22569	12	when	when	WRB
18637	22569	13	received	receive	VBN
18637	22569	14	by	by	IN
18637	22569	15	a	a	DT
18637	22569	16	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	22569	17	of	of	IN
18637	22569	18	the	the	DT
18637	22569	19	issuing	issue	VBG
18637	22569	20	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22569	21	and	and	CC
18637	22569	22	did	do	VBD
18637	22569	23	not	not	RB
18637	22569	24	become	become	VB
18637	22569	25	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22569	26	without	without	IN
18637	22569	27	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	22569	28	;	;	:
18637	22569	29	that	that	RB
18637	22569	30	is	is	RB
18637	22569	31	,	,	,
18637	22569	32	as	as	IN
18637	22569	33	"	"	``
18637	22569	34	income	income	NN
18637	22569	35	,	,	,
18637	22569	36	"	"	''
18637	22569	37	until	until	IN
18637	22569	38	sold	sell	VBN
18637	22569	39	or	or	CC
18637	22569	40	converted	convert	VBN
18637	22569	41	,	,	,
18637	22569	42	and	and	CC
18637	22569	43	then	then	RB
18637	22569	44	only	only	RB
18637	22569	45	to	to	IN
18637	22569	46	the	the	DT
18637	22569	47	extent	extent	NN
18637	22569	48	that	that	IN
18637	22569	49	a	a	DT
18637	22569	50	gain	gain	NN
18637	22569	51	was	be	VBD
18637	22569	52	realized	realize	VBN
18637	22569	53	upon	upon	IN
18637	22569	54	the	the	DT
18637	22569	55	proportion	proportion	NN
18637	22569	56	of	of	IN
18637	22569	57	the	the	DT
18637	22569	58	original	original	JJ
18637	22569	59	investment	investment	NN
18637	22569	60	which	which	WDT
18637	22569	61	such	such	JJ
18637	22569	62	stock	stock	NN
18637	22569	63	represented	represent	VBD
18637	22569	64	.	.	.
18637	22570	1	"	"	``
18637	22570	2	A	a	DT
18637	22570	3	stock	stock	NN
18637	22570	4	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22570	5	,	,	,
18637	22570	6	"	"	''
18637	22570	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22570	8	Pitney	Pitney	NNP
18637	22570	9	maintained	maintain	VBD
18637	22570	10	,	,	,
18637	22570	11	"	"	''
18637	22570	12	far	far	RB
18637	22570	13	from	from	IN
18637	22570	14	being	be	VBG
18637	22570	15	a	a	DT
18637	22570	16	realization	realization	NN
18637	22570	17	of	of	IN
18637	22570	18	profits	profit	NNS
18637	22570	19	to	to	IN
18637	22570	20	the	the	DT
18637	22570	21	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	22570	22	,	,	,
18637	22570	23	*	*	NFP
18637	22570	24	*	*	NFP
18637	22570	25	*	*	NFP
18637	22570	26	tends	tend	VBZ
18637	22570	27	rather	rather	RB
18637	22570	28	to	to	TO
18637	22570	29	postpone	postpone	VB
18637	22570	30	such	such	JJ
18637	22570	31	realization	realization	NN
18637	22570	32	,	,	,
18637	22570	33	in	in	IN
18637	22570	34	that	that	IN
18637	22570	35	the	the	DT
18637	22570	36	fund	fund	NN
18637	22570	37	represented	represent	VBN
18637	22570	38	by	by	IN
18637	22570	39	the	the	DT
18637	22570	40	new	new	JJ
18637	22570	41	stock	stock	NN
18637	22570	42	has	have	VBZ
18637	22570	43	been	be	VBN
18637	22570	44	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	22570	45	from	from	IN
18637	22570	46	surplus	surplus	NN
18637	22570	47	to	to	IN
18637	22570	48	capital	capital	NN
18637	22570	49	,	,	,
18637	22570	50	and	and	CC
18637	22570	51	no	no	RB
18637	22570	52	longer	long	RBR
18637	22570	53	is	be	VBZ
18637	22570	54	available	available	JJ
18637	22570	55	for	for	IN
18637	22570	56	actual	actual	JJ
18637	22570	57	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	22570	58	.	.	.
18637	22571	1	*	*	NFP
18637	22571	2	*	*	NFP
18637	22571	3	*	*	NFP
18637	22571	4	not	not	RB
18637	22571	5	only	only	RB
18637	22571	6	does	do	VBZ
18637	22571	7	a	a	DT
18637	22571	8	stock	stock	NN
18637	22571	9	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22571	10	really	really	RB
18637	22571	11	take	take	VB
18637	22571	12	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	22571	13	from	from	IN
18637	22571	14	*	*	NFP
18637	22571	15	*	*	NFP
18637	22571	16	*	*	NFP
18637	22571	17	the	the	DT
18637	22571	18	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22571	19	and	and	CC
18637	22571	20	add	add	VB
18637	22571	21	nothing	nothing	NN
18637	22571	22	to	to	IN
18637	22571	23	that	that	DT
18637	22571	24	of	of	IN
18637	22571	25	the	the	DT
18637	22571	26	shareholder	shareholder	NN
18637	22571	27	,	,	,
18637	22571	28	but	but	CC
18637	22571	29	*	*	NFP
18637	22571	30	*	*	NFP
18637	22571	31	*	*	NFP
18637	22571	32	the	the	DT
18637	22571	33	antecedent	antecedent	NN
18637	22571	34	accumulation	accumulation	NN
18637	22571	35	of	of	IN
18637	22571	36	profits	profit	NNS
18637	22571	37	evidenced	evidence	VBN
18637	22571	38	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	22571	39	,	,	,
18637	22571	40	while	while	IN
18637	22571	41	indicating	indicate	VBG
18637	22571	42	that	that	IN
18637	22571	43	the	the	DT
18637	22571	44	shareholder	shareholder	NN
18637	22571	45	is	be	VBZ
18637	22571	46	richer	rich	JJR
18637	22571	47	because	because	IN
18637	22571	48	of	of	IN
18637	22571	49	an	an	DT
18637	22571	50	increase	increase	NN
18637	22571	51	of	of	IN
18637	22571	52	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22571	53	capital	capital	NN
18637	22571	54	,	,	,
18637	22571	55	at	at	IN
18637	22571	56	the	the	DT
18637	22571	57	same	same	JJ
18637	22571	58	time	time	NN
18637	22571	59	shows	show	VBZ
18637	22571	60	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22571	61	that	that	IN
18637	22571	62	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22571	63	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22571	64	has	have	VBZ
18637	22571	65	not	not	RB
18637	22571	66	realized	realize	VBN
18637	22571	67	or	or	CC
18637	22571	68	received	receive	VBN
18637	22571	69	any	any	DT
18637	22571	70	income	income	NN
18637	22571	71	in	in	IN
18637	22571	72	"	"	``
18637	22571	73	what	what	WP
18637	22571	74	is	be	VBZ
18637	22571	75	no	no	DT
18637	22571	76	more	more	JJR
18637	22571	77	than	than	IN
18637	22571	78	a	a	DT
18637	22571	79	"	"	``
18637	22571	80	bookkeeping	bookkeepe	VBG
18637	22571	81	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	22571	82	.	.	.
18637	22571	83	"	"	''
18637	22572	1	But	but	CC
18637	22572	2	conceding	concede	VBG
18637	22572	3	that	that	IN
18637	22572	4	a	a	DT
18637	22572	5	stock	stock	NN
18637	22572	6	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22572	7	represented	represent	VBD
18637	22572	8	a	a	DT
18637	22572	9	gain	gain	NN
18637	22572	10	,	,	,
18637	22572	11	the	the	DT
18637	22572	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22572	13	concluded	conclude	VBD
18637	22572	14	that	that	IN
18637	22572	15	the	the	DT
18637	22572	16	only	only	JJ
18637	22572	17	gain	gain	NN
18637	22572	18	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22572	19	as	as	IN
18637	22572	20	"	"	``
18637	22572	21	income	income	NN
18637	22572	22	"	"	''
18637	22572	23	under	under	IN
18637	22572	24	the	the	DT
18637	22572	25	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22572	26	was	be	VBD
18637	22572	27	"	"	``
18637	22572	28	a	a	DT
18637	22572	29	gain	gain	NN
18637	22572	30	,	,	,
18637	22572	31	a	a	DT
18637	22572	32	profit	profit	NN
18637	22572	33	,	,	,
18637	22572	34	something	something	NN
18637	22572	35	of	of	IN
18637	22572	36	exchangeable	exchangeable	JJ
18637	22572	37	value	value	NN
18637	22572	38	_	_	NNP
18637	22572	39	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	22572	40	from	from	IN
18637	22572	41	_	_	NNP
18637	22572	42	the	the	DT
18637	22572	43	property	property	NN
18637	22572	44	,	,	,
18637	22572	45	_	_	NNP
18637	22572	46	severed	sever	VBD
18637	22572	47	from	from	IN
18637	22572	48	_	_	NNP
18637	22572	49	the	the	DT
18637	22572	50	capital	capital	NN
18637	22572	51	however	however	RB
18637	22572	52	invested	invest	VBN
18637	22572	53	or	or	CC
18637	22572	54	employed	employ	VBN
18637	22572	55	,	,	,
18637	22572	56	and	and	CC
18637	22572	57	_	_	NNP
18637	22572	58	coming	come	VBG
18637	22572	59	in	in	IN
18637	22572	60	_	_	NNP
18637	22572	61	,	,	,
18637	22572	62	being	be	VBG
18637	22572	63	'	'	''
18637	22572	64	_	_	NNP
18637	22572	65	derived	derive	VBD
18637	22572	66	_	_	NNP
18637	22572	67	,	,	,
18637	22572	68	'	'	''
18637	22572	69	that	that	DT
18637	22572	70	is	be	VBZ
18637	22572	71	,	,	,
18637	22572	72	_	_	NNP
18637	22572	73	received	receive	VBD
18637	22572	74	_	_	NNP
18637	22572	75	or	or	CC
18637	22572	76	_	_	NNP
18637	22572	77	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	22572	78	by	by	IN
18637	22572	79	_	_	NNP
18637	22572	80	the	the	DT
18637	22572	81	recipient	recipient	NN
18637	22572	82	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22572	83	the	the	DT
18637	22572	84	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	22572	85	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22572	86	for	for	IN
18637	22572	87	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22572	88	_	_	NNP
18637	22572	89	separate	separate	JJ
18637	22572	90	_	_	NNP
18637	22572	91	use	use	NN
18637	22572	92	,	,	,
18637	22572	93	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	22572	94	,	,	,
18637	22572	95	and	and	CC
18637	22572	96	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	22572	97	;	;	,
18637	22572	98	*	*	NFP
18637	22572	99	*	*	NFP
18637	22572	100	*	*	NFP
18637	22572	101	.	.	.
18637	22572	102	"	"	''
18637	22573	1	Only	only	RB
18637	22573	2	the	the	DT
18637	22573	3	latter	latter	JJ
18637	22573	4	,	,	,
18637	22573	5	in	in	IN
18637	22573	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22573	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	22573	8	,	,	,
18637	22573	9	answered	answer	VBD
18637	22573	10	the	the	DT
18637	22573	11	description	description	NN
18637	22573	12	of	of	IN
18637	22573	13	income	income	NN
18637	22573	14	"	"	``
18637	22573	15	derived	derive	VBN
18637	22573	16	"	"	''
18637	22573	17	from	from	IN
18637	22573	18	property	property	NN
18637	22573	19	;	;	:
18637	22573	20	whereas	whereas	IN
18637	22573	21	"	"	``
18637	22573	22	a	a	DT
18637	22573	23	gain	gain	NN
18637	22573	24	accruing	accrue	VBG
18637	22573	25	to	to	IN
18637	22573	26	capital	capital	NN
18637	22573	27	,	,	,
18637	22573	28	not	not	RB
18637	22573	29	a	a	DT
18637	22573	30	_	_	NNP
18637	22573	31	growth	growth	NN
18637	22573	32	_	_	NNP
18637	22573	33	or	or	CC
18637	22573	34	an	an	DT
18637	22573	35	_	_	NNP
18637	22573	36	increment	increment	NN
18637	22573	37	_	_	NNP
18637	22573	38	of	of	IN
18637	22573	39	value	value	NN
18637	22573	40	_	_	NNP
18637	22573	41	in	in	IN
18637	22573	42	_	_	NNP
18637	22573	43	the	the	DT
18637	22573	44	investment	investment	NN
18637	22573	45	"	"	``
18637	22573	46	did	do	VBD
18637	22573	47	not	not	RB
18637	22573	48	.	.	.
18637	22574	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22574	2	19	19	CD
18637	22574	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22574	4	Although	although	IN
18637	22574	5	steadfastly	steadfastly	RB
18637	22574	6	refusing	refuse	VBG
18637	22574	7	to	to	TO
18637	22574	8	depart	depart	VB
18637	22574	9	from	from	IN
18637	22574	10	the	the	DT
18637	22574	11	principle[20	principle[20	NN
18637	22574	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22574	13	which	which	WDT
18637	22574	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22574	15	asserted	assert	VBD
18637	22574	16	in	in	IN
18637	22574	17	Eisner	Eisner	NNP
18637	22574	18	_	_	NNP
18637	22574	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	22574	20	_	_	NNP
18637	22574	21	Macomber	Macomber	NNP
18637	22574	22	,	,	,
18637	22574	23	the	the	DT
18637	22574	24	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22574	25	in	in	IN
18637	22574	26	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	22574	27	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	22574	28	has	have	VBZ
18637	22574	29	,	,	,
18637	22574	30	however	however	RB
18637	22574	31	,	,	,
18637	22574	32	slightly	slightly	RB
18637	22574	33	narrowed	narrow	VBD
18637	22574	34	the	the	DT
18637	22574	35	application	application	NN
18637	22574	36	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	22574	37	.	.	.
18637	22575	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	22575	2	,	,	,
18637	22575	3	the	the	DT
18637	22575	4	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	22575	5	,	,	,
18637	22575	6	as	as	IN
18637	22575	7	a	a	DT
18637	22575	8	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22575	9	,	,	,
18637	22575	10	to	to	IN
18637	22575	11	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	22575	12	of	of	IN
18637	22575	13	an	an	DT
18637	22575	14	existing	exist	VBG
18637	22575	15	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22575	16	of	of	IN
18637	22575	17	the	the	DT
18637	22575	18	stock	stock	NN
18637	22575	19	of	of	IN
18637	22575	20	a	a	DT
18637	22575	21	new	new	JJ
18637	22575	22	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22575	23	to	to	TO
18637	22575	24	which	which	WDT
18637	22575	25	the	the	DT
18637	22575	26	former	former	JJ
18637	22575	27	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22575	28	,	,	,
18637	22575	29	under	under	IN
18637	22575	30	a	a	DT
18637	22575	31	reorganization	reorganization	NN
18637	22575	32	,	,	,
18637	22575	33	had	have	VBD
18637	22575	34	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	22575	35	all	all	PDT
18637	22575	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22575	37	assets	asset	NNS
18637	22575	38	,	,	,
18637	22575	39	including	include	VBG
18637	22575	40	a	a	DT
18637	22575	41	surplus	surplus	NN
18637	22575	42	of	of	IN
18637	22575	43	accumulated	accumulate	VBN
18637	22575	44	profits	profit	NNS
18637	22575	45	,	,	,
18637	22575	46	was	be	VBD
18637	22575	47	treated	treat	VBN
18637	22575	48	as	as	IN
18637	22575	49	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22575	50	income	income	NN
18637	22575	51	.	.	.
18637	22576	1	The	the	DT
18637	22576	2	fact	fact	NN
18637	22576	3	that	that	IN
18637	22576	4	a	a	DT
18637	22576	5	comparison	comparison	NN
18637	22576	6	of	of	IN
18637	22576	7	the	the	DT
18637	22576	8	market	market	NN
18637	22576	9	value	value	NN
18637	22576	10	of	of	IN
18637	22576	11	the	the	DT
18637	22576	12	shares	share	NNS
18637	22576	13	in	in	IN
18637	22576	14	the	the	DT
18637	22576	15	older	old	JJR
18637	22576	16	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22576	17	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	22576	18	before	before	RB
18637	22576	19	,	,	,
18637	22576	20	with	with	IN
18637	22576	21	the	the	DT
18637	22576	22	aggregate	aggregate	JJ
18637	22576	23	market	market	NN
18637	22576	24	value	value	NN
18637	22576	25	of	of	IN
18637	22576	26	those	those	DT
18637	22576	27	shares	share	NNS
18637	22576	28	plus	plus	CC
18637	22576	29	the	the	DT
18637	22576	30	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22576	31	shares	share	NNS
18637	22576	32	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	22576	33	after	after	IN
18637	22576	34	,	,	,
18637	22576	35	the	the	DT
18637	22576	36	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22576	37	showed	show	VBD
18637	22576	38	that	that	IN
18637	22576	39	the	the	DT
18637	22576	40	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	22576	41	experienced	experience	VBD
18637	22576	42	no	no	DT
18637	22576	43	increase	increase	NN
18637	22576	44	in	in	IN
18637	22576	45	aggregate	aggregate	JJ
18637	22576	46	wealth	wealth	NN
18637	22576	47	was	be	VBD
18637	22576	48	declared	declare	VBN
18637	22576	49	not	not	RB
18637	22576	50	to	to	TO
18637	22576	51	be	be	VB
18637	22576	52	a	a	DT
18637	22576	53	proper	proper	JJ
18637	22576	54	test	test	NN
18637	22576	55	for	for	IN
18637	22576	56	determining	determine	VBG
18637	22576	57	whether	whether	IN
18637	22576	58	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22576	59	income	income	NN
18637	22576	60	had	have	VBD
18637	22576	61	been	be	VBN
18637	22576	62	received	receive	VBN
18637	22576	63	by	by	IN
18637	22576	64	these	these	DT
18637	22576	65	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	22576	66	.	.	.
18637	22577	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22577	2	21	21	CD
18637	22577	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22577	4	On	on	IN
18637	22577	5	the	the	DT
18637	22577	6	other	other	JJ
18637	22577	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	22577	8	,	,	,
18637	22577	9	no	no	DT
18637	22577	10	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22577	11	income	income	NN
18637	22577	12	was	be	VBD
18637	22577	13	held	hold	VBN
18637	22577	14	to	to	TO
18637	22577	15	have	have	VB
18637	22577	16	been	be	VBN
18637	22577	17	produced	produce	VBN
18637	22577	18	by	by	IN
18637	22577	19	the	the	DT
18637	22577	20	mere	mere	JJ
18637	22577	21	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	22577	22	by	by	IN
18637	22577	23	a	a	DT
18637	22577	24	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	22577	25	of	of	IN
18637	22577	26	rights	right	NNS
18637	22577	27	to	to	TO
18637	22577	28	subscribe	subscribe	VB
18637	22577	29	for	for	IN
18637	22577	30	shares	share	NNS
18637	22577	31	in	in	IN
18637	22577	32	a	a	DT
18637	22577	33	new	new	JJ
18637	22577	34	issue	issue	NN
18637	22577	35	of	of	IN
18637	22577	36	capital	capital	NN
18637	22577	37	stock	stock	NN
18637	22577	38	,	,	,
18637	22577	39	the	the	DT
18637	22577	40	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
18637	22577	41	value	value	NN
18637	22577	42	of	of	IN
18637	22577	43	which	which	WDT
18637	22577	44	was	be	VBD
18637	22577	45	assumed	assume	VBN
18637	22577	46	to	to	TO
18637	22577	47	be	be	VB
18637	22577	48	in	in	IN
18637	22577	49	excess	excess	NN
18637	22577	50	of	of	IN
18637	22577	51	the	the	DT
18637	22577	52	issuing	issuing	NN
18637	22577	53	price	price	NN
18637	22577	54	.	.	.
18637	22578	1	The	the	DT
18637	22578	2	right	right	NN
18637	22578	3	to	to	TO
18637	22578	4	subscribe	subscribe	VB
18637	22578	5	was	be	VBD
18637	22578	6	declared	declare	VBN
18637	22578	7	to	to	TO
18637	22578	8	be	be	VB
18637	22578	9	analogous	analogous	JJ
18637	22578	10	to	to	IN
18637	22578	11	a	a	DT
18637	22578	12	stock	stock	NN
18637	22578	13	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22578	14	,	,	,
18637	22578	15	and	and	CC
18637	22578	16	"	"	``
18637	22578	17	only	only	RB
18637	22578	18	so	so	RB
18637	22578	19	much	much	JJ
18637	22578	20	of	of	IN
18637	22578	21	the	the	DT
18637	22578	22	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	22578	23	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	22578	24	upon	upon	IN
18637	22578	25	the	the	DT
18637	22578	26	sale	sale	NN
18637	22578	27	of	of	IN
18637	22578	28	such	such	JJ
18637	22578	29	rights	right	NNS
18637	22578	30	as	as	IN
18637	22578	31	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	22578	32	a	a	DT
18637	22578	33	realized	realize	VBN
18637	22578	34	profit	profit	NN
18637	22578	35	over	over	IN
18637	22578	36	cost	cost	NN
18637	22578	37	"	"	''
18637	22578	38	to	to	IN
18637	22578	39	the	the	DT
18637	22578	40	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	22578	41	was	be	VBD
18637	22578	42	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	22578	43	to	to	TO
18637	22578	44	be	be	VB
18637	22578	45	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22578	46	income	income	NN
18637	22578	47	.	.	.
18637	22579	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22579	2	22	22	CD
18637	22579	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22579	4	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	22579	5	,	,	,
18637	22579	6	on	on	IN
18637	22579	7	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	22579	8	of	of	IN
18637	22579	9	consistency	consistency	NN
18637	22579	10	with	with	IN
18637	22579	11	Eisner	Eisner	NNP
18637	22579	12	_	_	NNP
18637	22579	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	22579	14	_	_	NNP
18637	22579	15	Macomber	Macomber	NNP
18637	22579	16	,	,	,
18637	22579	17	the	the	DT
18637	22579	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22579	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	22579	20	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	22579	21	that	that	DT
18637	22579	22	inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	22579	23	as	as	IN
18637	22579	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22579	25	gave	give	VBD
18637	22579	26	the	the	DT
18637	22579	27	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	22579	28	an	an	DT
18637	22579	29	interest	interest	NN
18637	22579	30	different	different	JJ
18637	22579	31	from	from	IN
18637	22579	32	that	that	DT
18637	22579	33	represented	represent	VBN
18637	22579	34	by	by	IN
18637	22579	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22579	36	former	former	JJ
18637	22579	37	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	22579	38	,	,	,
18637	22579	39	a	a	DT
18637	22579	40	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22579	41	in	in	IN
18637	22579	42	common	common	JJ
18637	22579	43	stock	stock	NN
18637	22579	44	to	to	IN
18637	22579	45	holders	holder	NNS
18637	22579	46	of	of	IN
18637	22579	47	preferred	prefer	VBN
18637	22579	48	stock,[23	stock,[23	CD
18637	22579	49	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22579	50	or	or	CC
18637	22579	51	a	a	DT
18637	22579	52	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22579	53	in	in	IN
18637	22579	54	preferred	preferred	JJ
18637	22579	55	stock	stock	NN
18637	22579	56	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	22579	57	by	by	IN
18637	22579	58	a	a	DT
18637	22579	59	holder	holder	NN
18637	22579	60	of	of	IN
18637	22579	61	common	common	JJ
18637	22579	62	stock[24	stock[24	NN
18637	22579	63	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22579	64	was	be	VBD
18637	22579	65	income	income	NN
18637	22579	66	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22579	67	under	under	IN
18637	22579	68	the	the	DT
18637	22579	69	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	22579	70	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22579	71	.	.	.
18637	22580	1	OTHER	other	JJ
18637	22580	2	CORPORATE	corporate	JJ
18637	22580	3	EARNINGS	earning	NNS
18637	22580	4	OR	or	CC
18637	22580	5	RECEIPTS	receipt	NNS
18637	22580	6	:	:	:
18637	22580	7	WHEN	when	WRB
18637	22580	8	TAXABLE	taxable	NN
18637	22580	9	AS	as	IN
18637	22580	10	INCOME	income	NN
18637	22580	11	On	on	RP
18637	22580	12	at	at	RB
18637	22580	13	least	least	RBS
18637	22580	14	two	two	CD
18637	22580	15	occasions	occasion	NNS
18637	22580	16	the	the	DT
18637	22580	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22580	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	22580	19	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	22580	20	as	as	RB
18637	22580	21	untenable	untenable	JJ
18637	22580	22	the	the	DT
18637	22580	23	contention	contention	NN
18637	22580	24	that	that	IN
18637	22580	25	a	a	DT
18637	22580	26	tax	tax	NN
18637	22580	27	on	on	IN
18637	22580	28	undistributed	undistributed	JJ
18637	22580	29	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	22580	30	profits	profit	NNS
18637	22580	31	is	be	VBZ
18637	22580	32	essentially	essentially	RB
18637	22580	33	a	a	DT
18637	22580	34	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	22580	35	rather	rather	RB
18637	22580	36	than	than	IN
18637	22580	37	a	a	DT
18637	22580	38	tax	tax	NN
18637	22580	39	or	or	CC
18637	22580	40	that	that	IN
18637	22580	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22580	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	22580	43	a	a	DT
18637	22580	44	direct	direct	JJ
18637	22580	45	tax	tax	NN
18637	22580	46	on	on	IN
18637	22580	47	capital	capital	NN
18637	22580	48	and	and	CC
18637	22580	49	hence	hence	RB
18637	22580	50	is	be	VBZ
18637	22580	51	not	not	RB
18637	22580	52	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	22580	53	from	from	IN
18637	22580	54	the	the	DT
18637	22580	55	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	22580	56	of	of	IN
18637	22580	57	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	22580	58	.	.	.
18637	22581	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	22581	2	as	as	IN
18637	22581	3	the	the	DT
18637	22581	4	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	22581	5	was	be	VBD
18637	22581	6	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	22581	7	as	as	IN
18637	22581	8	a	a	DT
18637	22581	9	tax	tax	NN
18637	22581	10	,	,	,
18637	22581	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22581	12	validity	validity	NN
18637	22581	13	was	be	VBD
18637	22581	14	held	hold	VBN
18637	22581	15	not	not	RB
18637	22581	16	to	to	TO
18637	22581	17	be	be	VB
18637	22581	18	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	22581	19	by	by	IN
18637	22581	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22581	21	penal	penal	JJ
18637	22581	22	objective	objective	NN
18637	22581	23	,	,	,
18637	22581	24	namely	namely	RB
18637	22581	25	,	,	,
18637	22581	26	"	"	''
18637	22581	27	to	to	TO
18637	22581	28	force	force	VB
18637	22581	29	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	22581	30	to	to	TO
18637	22581	31	distribute	distribute	VB
18637	22581	32	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	22581	33	in	in	IN
18637	22581	34	order	order	NN
18637	22581	35	to	to	TO
18637	22581	36	create	create	VB
18637	22581	37	a	a	DT
18637	22581	38	basis	basis	NN
18637	22581	39	for	for	IN
18637	22581	40	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	22581	41	against	against	IN
18637	22581	42	the	the	DT
18637	22581	43	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	22581	44	.	.	.
18637	22581	45	"	"	''
18637	22582	1	As	as	IN
18637	22582	2	to	to	IN
18637	22582	3	the	the	DT
18637	22582	4	added	add	VBN
18637	22582	5	contention	contention	NN
18637	22582	6	that	that	IN
18637	22582	7	,	,	,
18637	22582	8	because	because	IN
18637	22582	9	liability	liability	NN
18637	22582	10	was	be	VBD
18637	22582	11	assessed	assess	VBN
18637	22582	12	upon	upon	IN
18637	22582	13	a	a	DT
18637	22582	14	mere	mere	JJ
18637	22582	15	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	22582	16	to	to	TO
18637	22582	17	evade	evade	VB
18637	22582	18	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	22582	19	of	of	IN
18637	22582	20	surtaxes	surtax	NNS
18637	22582	21	against	against	IN
18637	22582	22	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	22582	23	,	,	,
18637	22582	24	the	the	DT
18637	22582	25	tax	tax	NN
18637	22582	26	was	be	VBD
18637	22582	27	a	a	DT
18637	22582	28	direct	direct	JJ
18637	22582	29	tax	tax	NN
18637	22582	30	on	on	IN
18637	22582	31	a	a	DT
18637	22582	32	state	state	NN
18637	22582	33	of	of	IN
18637	22582	34	mind	mind	NN
18637	22582	35	,	,	,
18637	22582	36	the	the	DT
18637	22582	37	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22582	38	replied	reply	VBD
18637	22582	39	that	that	IN
18637	22582	40	while	while	IN
18637	22582	41	"	"	``
18637	22582	42	the	the	DT
18637	22582	43	existence	existence	NN
18637	22582	44	of	of	IN
18637	22582	45	the	the	DT
18637	22582	46	defined	define	VBN
18637	22582	47	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	22582	48	was	be	VBD
18637	22582	49	a	a	DT
18637	22582	50	condition	condition	NN
18637	22582	51	precedent	precedent	NN
18637	22582	52	to	to	IN
18637	22582	53	the	the	DT
18637	22582	54	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	22582	55	of	of	IN
18637	22582	56	the	the	DT
18637	22582	57	tax	tax	NN
18637	22582	58	liability	liability	NN
18637	22582	59	,	,	,
18637	22582	60	*	*	NFP
18637	22582	61	*	*	NFP
18637	22582	62	*	*	NFP
18637	22582	63	this	this	DT
18637	22582	64	*	*	NFP
18637	22582	65	*	*	NFP
18637	22582	66	*	*	NFP
18637	22582	67	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22582	68	did	do	VBD
18637	22582	69	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22582	70	not	not	RB
18637	22582	71	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	22582	72	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22582	73	from	from	IN
18637	22582	74	being	be	VBG
18637	22582	75	a	a	DT
18637	22582	76	true	true	JJ
18637	22582	77	income	income	NN
18637	22582	78	tax	tax	NN
18637	22582	79	within	within	IN
18637	22582	80	the	the	DT
18637	22582	81	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	22582	82	of	of	IN
18637	22582	83	the	the	DT
18637	22582	84	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	22582	85	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22582	86	.	.	.
18637	22583	1	"	"	``
18637	22583	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22583	3	25	25	CD
18637	22583	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22583	5	Subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	22583	6	,	,	,
18637	22583	7	in	in	IN
18637	22583	8	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	22583	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22583	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	22583	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22583	12	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	22583	13	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	22583	14	Mills,[26	Mills,[26	NNP
18637	22583	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22583	16	this	this	DT
18637	22583	17	appraisal	appraisal	NN
18637	22583	18	of	of	IN
18637	22583	19	the	the	DT
18637	22583	20	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	22583	21	of	of	IN
18637	22583	22	the	the	DT
18637	22583	23	undistributed	undistributed	JJ
18637	22583	24	profits	profit	NNS
18637	22583	25	tax	tax	NN
18637	22583	26	was	be	VBD
18637	22583	27	buttressed	buttress	VBN
18637	22583	28	by	by	IN
18637	22583	29	the	the	DT
18637	22583	30	following	following	JJ
18637	22583	31	observation	observation	NN
18637	22583	32	:	:	:
18637	22583	33	"	"	``
18637	22583	34	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22583	35	is	be	VBZ
18637	22583	36	true	true	JJ
18637	22583	37	that	that	IN
18637	22583	38	the	the	DT
18637	22583	39	surtax	surtax	NN
18637	22583	40	is	be	VBZ
18637	22583	41	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	22583	42	upon	upon	IN
18637	22583	43	the	the	DT
18637	22583	44	annual	annual	JJ
18637	22583	45	income	income	NN
18637	22583	46	only	only	RB
18637	22583	47	if	if	IN
18637	22583	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22583	49	is	be	VBZ
18637	22583	50	not	not	RB
18637	22583	51	distributed	distribute	VBN
18637	22583	52	,	,	,
18637	22583	53	but	but	CC
18637	22583	54	this	this	DT
18637	22583	55	does	do	VBZ
18637	22583	56	not	not	RB
18637	22583	57	serve	serve	VB
18637	22583	58	to	to	TO
18637	22583	59	make	make	VB
18637	22583	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22583	61	anything	anything	NN
18637	22583	62	other	other	JJ
18637	22583	63	than	than	IN
18637	22583	64	a	a	DT
18637	22583	65	true	true	JJ
18637	22583	66	tax	tax	NN
18637	22583	67	on	on	IN
18637	22583	68	income	income	NN
18637	22583	69	within	within	IN
18637	22583	70	the	the	DT
18637	22583	71	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	22583	72	of	of	IN
18637	22583	73	the	the	DT
18637	22583	74	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	22583	75	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22583	76	.	.	.
18637	22584	1	Nor	nor	CC
18637	22584	2	is	be	VBZ
18637	22584	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22584	4	true	true	JJ
18637	22584	5	,	,	,
18637	22584	6	*	*	NFP
18637	22584	7	*	*	NFP
18637	22584	8	*	*	NFP
18637	22584	9	,	,	,
18637	22584	10	that	that	IN
18637	22584	11	because	because	IN
18637	22584	12	there	there	EX
18637	22584	13	might	may	MD
18637	22584	14	be	be	VB
18637	22584	15	an	an	DT
18637	22584	16	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	22584	17	of	of	IN
18637	22584	18	the	the	DT
18637	22584	19	capital	capital	NN
18637	22584	20	stock	stock	NN
18637	22584	21	,	,	,
18637	22584	22	the	the	DT
18637	22584	23	tax	tax	NN
18637	22584	24	on	on	IN
18637	22584	25	the	the	DT
18637	22584	26	current	current	JJ
18637	22584	27	annual	annual	JJ
18637	22584	28	profit	profit	NN
18637	22584	29	would	would	MD
18637	22584	30	be	be	VB
18637	22584	31	the	the	DT
18637	22584	32	equivalent	equivalent	NN
18637	22584	33	of	of	IN
18637	22584	34	a	a	DT
18637	22584	35	tax	tax	NN
18637	22584	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	22584	37	capital	capital	NN
18637	22584	38	.	.	.
18637	22585	1	Whether	whether	IN
18637	22585	2	there	there	EX
18637	22585	3	was	be	VBD
18637	22585	4	an	an	DT
18637	22585	5	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	22585	6	of	of	IN
18637	22585	7	the	the	DT
18637	22585	8	capital	capital	NN
18637	22585	9	stock	stock	NN
18637	22585	10	or	or	CC
18637	22585	11	not	not	RB
18637	22585	12	,	,	,
18637	22585	13	the	the	DT
18637	22585	14	tax	tax	NN
18637	22585	15	*	*	NFP
18637	22585	16	*	*	NFP
18637	22585	17	*	*	NFP
18637	22585	18	was	be	VBD
18637	22585	19	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	22585	20	on	on	IN
18637	22585	21	profits	profit	NNS
18637	22585	22	earned	earn	VBN
18637	22585	23	during	during	IN
18637	22585	24	*	*	NFP
18637	22585	25	*	*	NFP
18637	22585	26	*	*	NFP
18637	22585	27	--a	--a	HYPH
18637	22585	28	tax	tax	NN
18637	22585	29	year	year	NN
18637	22585	30	--	--	:
18637	22585	31	and	and	CC
18637	22585	32	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	22585	33	on	on	IN
18637	22585	34	profits	profit	NNS
18637	22585	35	constituting	constitute	VBG
18637	22585	36	income	income	NN
18637	22585	37	within	within	IN
18637	22585	38	the	the	DT
18637	22585	39	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	22585	40	of	of	IN
18637	22585	41	the	the	DT
18637	22585	42	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	22585	43	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22585	44	.	.	.
18637	22586	1	"	"	``
18637	22586	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22586	3	27	27	CD
18637	22586	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22586	5	Likening	liken	VBG
18637	22586	6	a	a	DT
18637	22586	7	cooperative	cooperative	NN
18637	22586	8	to	to	IN
18637	22586	9	a	a	DT
18637	22586	10	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22586	11	,	,	,
18637	22586	12	federal	federal	JJ
18637	22586	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	22586	14	have	have	VBP
18637	22586	15	also	also	RB
18637	22586	16	declared	declare	VBN
18637	22586	17	to	to	TO
18637	22586	18	be	be	VB
18637	22586	19	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22586	20	income	income	NN
18637	22586	21	the	the	DT
18637	22586	22	net	net	JJ
18637	22586	23	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	22586	24	of	of	IN
18637	22586	25	a	a	DT
18637	22586	26	farmers	farmer	NNS
18637	22586	27	'	'	POS
18637	22586	28	cooperative	cooperative	NN
18637	22586	29	,	,	,
18637	22586	30	a	a	DT
18637	22586	31	portion	portion	NN
18637	22586	32	of	of	IN
18637	22586	33	which	which	WDT
18637	22586	34	was	be	VBD
18637	22586	35	used	use	VBN
18637	22586	36	to	to	TO
18637	22586	37	pay	pay	VB
18637	22586	38	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	22586	39	on	on	IN
18637	22586	40	capital	capital	NN
18637	22586	41	stock	stock	NN
18637	22586	42	without	without	IN
18637	22586	43	reference	reference	NN
18637	22586	44	to	to	TO
18637	22586	45	patronage	patronage	VB
18637	22586	46	.	.	.
18637	22587	1	The	the	DT
18637	22587	2	argument	argument	NN
18637	22587	3	that	that	IN
18637	22587	4	such	such	JJ
18637	22587	5	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	22587	6	were	be	VBD
18637	22587	7	in	in	IN
18637	22587	8	reality	reality	NN
18637	22587	9	accumulated	accumulate	VBN
18637	22587	10	savings	saving	NNS
18637	22587	11	of	of	IN
18637	22587	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22587	13	patrons	patron	NNS
18637	22587	14	which	which	WDT
18637	22587	15	the	the	DT
18637	22587	16	cooperative	cooperative	NN
18637	22587	17	held	hold	VBN
18637	22587	18	as	as	IN
18637	22587	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22587	20	bailee	bailee	NN
18637	22587	21	was	be	VBD
18637	22587	22	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	22587	23	as	as	IN
18637	22587	24	unsound	unsound	JJ
18637	22587	25	for	for	IN
18637	22587	26	the	the	DT
18637	22587	27	reason	reason	NN
18637	22587	28	that	that	IN
18637	22587	29	"	"	``
18637	22587	30	while	while	IN
18637	22587	31	those	those	DT
18637	22587	32	who	who	WP
18637	22587	33	might	may	MD
18637	22587	34	be	be	VB
18637	22587	35	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	22587	36	to	to	TO
18637	22587	37	patronage	patronage	VB
18637	22587	38	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	22587	39	have	have	VBP
18637	22587	40	,	,	,
18637	22587	41	*	*	NFP
18637	22587	42	*	*	NFP
18637	22587	43	*	*	NFP
18637	22587	44	,	,	,
18637	22587	45	an	an	DT
18637	22587	46	interest	interest	NN
18637	22587	47	in	in	IN
18637	22587	48	such	such	JJ
18637	22587	49	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	22587	50	,	,	,
18637	22587	51	such	such	JJ
18637	22587	52	interest	interest	NN
18637	22587	53	never	never	RB
18637	22587	54	ripens	ripen	VBZ
18637	22587	55	into	into	IN
18637	22587	56	an	an	DT
18637	22587	57	individual	individual	JJ
18637	22587	58	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	22587	59	*	*	NFP
18637	22587	60	*	*	NFP
18637	22587	61	*	*	NFP
18637	22587	62	until	until	IN
18637	22587	63	and	and	CC
18637	22587	64	if	if	IN
18637	22587	65	a	a	DT
18637	22587	66	patronage	patronage	NN
18637	22587	67	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22587	68	be	be	VB
18637	22587	69	declared	declare	VBN
18637	22587	70	.	.	.
18637	22587	71	"	"	''
18637	22588	1	Had	have	VBD
18637	22588	2	such	such	JJ
18637	22588	3	net	net	JJ
18637	22588	4	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	22588	5	been	be	VBN
18637	22588	6	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	22588	7	to	to	IN
18637	22588	8	all	all	DT
18637	22588	9	of	of	IN
18637	22588	10	the	the	DT
18637	22588	11	patrons	patron	NNS
18637	22588	12	during	during	IN
18637	22588	13	the	the	DT
18637	22588	14	year	year	NN
18637	22588	15	,	,	,
18637	22588	16	"	"	``
18637	22588	17	there	there	EX
18637	22588	18	might	may	MD
18637	22588	19	be	be	VB
18637	22588	20	*	*	NFP
18637	22588	21	*	*	NFP
18637	22588	22	*	*	NFP
18637	22588	23	a	a	DT
18637	22588	24	more	more	RBR
18637	22588	25	serious	serious	JJ
18637	22588	26	question	question	NN
18637	22588	27	as	as	IN
18637	22588	28	to	to	IN
18637	22588	29	whether	whether	IN
18637	22588	30	such	such	JJ
18637	22588	31	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	22588	32	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	22588	33	'	'	``
18637	22588	34	income	income	NN
18637	22588	35	'	'	''
18637	22588	36	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22588	37	of	of	IN
18637	22588	38	the	the	DT
18637	22588	39	cooperative	cooperative	NN
18637	22588	40	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22588	41	within	within	IN
18637	22588	42	the	the	DT
18637	22588	43	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22588	44	.	.	.
18637	22589	1	"	"	``
18637	22589	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22589	3	28	28	CD
18637	22589	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22589	5	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	22589	6	,	,	,
18637	22589	7	the	the	DT
18637	22589	8	power	power	NN
18637	22589	9	of	of	IN
18637	22589	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22589	11	to	to	TO
18637	22589	12	tax	tax	VB
18637	22589	13	the	the	DT
18637	22589	14	income	income	NN
18637	22589	15	of	of	IN
18637	22589	16	an	an	DT
18637	22589	17	unincorporated	unincorporated	JJ
18637	22589	18	joint	joint	NNP
18637	22589	19	stock	stock	NNP
18637	22589	20	association	association	NNP
18637	22589	21	has	have	VBZ
18637	22589	22	been	be	VBN
18637	22589	23	held	hold	VBN
18637	22589	24	to	to	TO
18637	22589	25	be	be	VB
18637	22589	26	unaffected	unaffected	JJ
18637	22589	27	by	by	IN
18637	22589	28	the	the	DT
18637	22589	29	fact	fact	NN
18637	22589	30	that	that	IN
18637	22589	31	under	under	IN
18637	22589	32	State	State	NNP
18637	22589	33	law	law	NN
18637	22589	34	the	the	DT
18637	22589	35	association	association	NN
18637	22589	36	is	be	VBZ
18637	22589	37	not	not	RB
18637	22589	38	a	a	DT
18637	22589	39	legal	legal	JJ
18637	22589	40	entity	entity	NN
18637	22589	41	and	and	CC
18637	22589	42	can	can	MD
18637	22589	43	not	not	RB
18637	22589	44	hold	hold	VB
18637	22589	45	title	title	NN
18637	22589	46	to	to	IN
18637	22589	47	property	property	NN
18637	22589	48	,	,	,
18637	22589	49	or	or	CC
18637	22589	50	by	by	IN
18637	22589	51	the	the	DT
18637	22589	52	fact	fact	NN
18637	22589	53	that	that	IN
18637	22589	54	the	the	DT
18637	22589	55	shareholders	shareholder	NNS
18637	22589	56	are	be	VBP
18637	22589	57	liable	liable	JJ
18637	22589	58	for	for	IN
18637	22589	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22589	60	debts	debt	NNS
18637	22589	61	as	as	IN
18637	22589	62	partners	partner	NNS
18637	22589	63	.	.	.
18637	22590	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22590	2	29	29	CD
18637	22590	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22590	4	Whether	whether	IN
18637	22590	5	subsidies	subsidy	NNS
18637	22590	6	paid	pay	VBN
18637	22590	7	to	to	IN
18637	22590	8	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	22590	9	in	in	IN
18637	22590	10	money	money	NN
18637	22590	11	or	or	CC
18637	22590	12	in	in	IN
18637	22590	13	the	the	DT
18637	22590	14	form	form	NN
18637	22590	15	of	of	IN
18637	22590	16	grants	grant	NNS
18637	22590	17	of	of	IN
18637	22590	18	land	land	NN
18637	22590	19	or	or	CC
18637	22590	20	other	other	JJ
18637	22590	21	physical	physical	JJ
18637	22590	22	property	property	NN
18637	22590	23	constitute	constitute	NN
18637	22590	24	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22590	25	income	income	NN
18637	22590	26	has	have	VBZ
18637	22590	27	also	also	RB
18637	22590	28	concerned	concern	VBN
18637	22590	29	the	the	DT
18637	22590	30	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22590	31	.	.	.
18637	22591	1	In	in	IN
18637	22591	2	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	22591	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22591	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22591	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22591	6	Cuba	Cuba	NNP
18637	22591	7	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	22591	8	Co.[30	Co.[30	NNP
18637	22591	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22591	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22591	11	ruled	rule	VBD
18637	22591	12	that	that	IN
18637	22591	13	subsidies	subsidy	NNS
18637	22591	14	of	of	IN
18637	22591	15	lands	land	NNS
18637	22591	16	,	,	,
18637	22591	17	equipment	equipment	NN
18637	22591	18	,	,	,
18637	22591	19	and	and	CC
18637	22591	20	money	money	NN
18637	22591	21	paid	pay	VBN
18637	22591	22	by	by	IN
18637	22591	23	Cuba	Cuba	NNP
18637	22591	24	for	for	IN
18637	22591	25	the	the	DT
18637	22591	26	construction	construction	NN
18637	22591	27	of	of	IN
18637	22591	28	a	a	DT
18637	22591	29	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	22591	30	were	be	VBD
18637	22591	31	not	not	RB
18637	22591	32	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22591	33	income	income	NN
18637	22591	34	but	but	CC
18637	22591	35	were	be	VBD
18637	22591	36	to	to	TO
18637	22591	37	be	be	VB
18637	22591	38	viewed	view	VBN
18637	22591	39	as	as	IN
18637	22591	40	having	have	VBG
18637	22591	41	been	be	VBN
18637	22591	42	received	receive	VBN
18637	22591	43	by	by	IN
18637	22591	44	the	the	DT
18637	22591	45	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	22591	46	as	as	IN
18637	22591	47	a	a	DT
18637	22591	48	reimbursement	reimbursement	NN
18637	22591	49	for	for	IN
18637	22591	50	capital	capital	NN
18637	22591	51	expenditures	expenditure	NNS
18637	22591	52	in	in	IN
18637	22591	53	completing	complete	VBG
18637	22591	54	such	such	JJ
18637	22591	55	project	project	NN
18637	22591	56	.	.	.
18637	22592	1	On	on	IN
18637	22592	2	the	the	DT
18637	22592	3	other	other	JJ
18637	22592	4	hand	hand	NN
18637	22592	5	,	,	,
18637	22592	6	sums	sum	NNS
18637	22592	7	paid	pay	VBN
18637	22592	8	out	out	RP
18637	22592	9	by	by	IN
18637	22592	10	the	the	DT
18637	22592	11	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	22592	12	Government	Government	NNP
18637	22592	13	to	to	TO
18637	22592	14	fulfil	fulfil	VB
18637	22592	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22592	16	guarantee	guarantee	NN
18637	22592	17	of	of	IN
18637	22592	18	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	22592	19	operating	operating	NN
18637	22592	20	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	22592	21	to	to	IN
18637	22592	22	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	22592	23	during	during	IN
18637	22592	24	the	the	DT
18637	22592	25	six	six	CD
18637	22592	26	months	month	NNS
18637	22592	27	following	follow	VBG
18637	22592	28	relinquishment	relinquishment	NN
18637	22592	29	of	of	IN
18637	22592	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22592	31	control	control	NN
18637	22592	32	by	by	IN
18637	22592	33	that	that	DT
18637	22592	34	government	government	NN
18637	22592	35	were	be	VBD
18637	22592	36	found	find	VBN
18637	22592	37	to	to	TO
18637	22592	38	be	be	VB
18637	22592	39	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22592	40	income	income	NN
18637	22592	41	.	.	.
18637	22593	1	Such	such	JJ
18637	22593	2	payments	payment	NNS
18637	22593	3	were	be	VBD
18637	22593	4	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	22593	5	from	from	IN
18637	22593	6	those	those	DT
18637	22593	7	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	22593	8	from	from	IN
18637	22593	9	computation	computation	NN
18637	22593	10	of	of	IN
18637	22593	11	income	income	NN
18637	22593	12	in	in	IN
18637	22593	13	the	the	DT
18637	22593	14	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	22593	15	case	case	NN
18637	22593	16	in	in	IN
18637	22593	17	that	that	IN
18637	22593	18	the	the	DT
18637	22593	19	former	former	JJ
18637	22593	20	were	be	VBD
18637	22593	21	neither	neither	DT
18637	22593	22	bonuses	bonus	NNS
18637	22593	23	,	,	,
18637	22593	24	nor	nor	CC
18637	22593	25	gifts	gift	NNS
18637	22593	26	,	,	,
18637	22593	27	nor	nor	CC
18637	22593	28	subsidies	subsidy	NNS
18637	22593	29	;	;	,
18637	22593	30	"	"	``
18637	22593	31	that	that	RB
18637	22593	32	is	is	RB
18637	22593	33	,	,	,
18637	22593	34	contributions	contribution	NNS
18637	22593	35	to	to	IN
18637	22593	36	capital	capital	NN
18637	22593	37	.	.	.
18637	22594	1	"	"	``
18637	22594	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22594	3	31	31	CD
18637	22594	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22594	5	GAINS	gain	VBN
18637	22594	6	IN	in	IN
18637	22594	7	THE	the	DT
18637	22594	8	FORM	form	NN
18637	22594	9	OF	of	IN
18637	22594	10	REAL	REAL	NNP
18637	22594	11	ESTATE	ESTATE	NNP
18637	22594	12	;	;	:
18637	22594	13	WHEN	when	WRB
18637	22594	14	TAXABLE	taxable	NN
18637	22594	15	AS	as	IN
18637	22594	16	INCOME	income	NN
18637	22594	17	When	when	WRB
18637	22594	18	through	through	IN
18637	22594	19	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	22594	20	of	of	IN
18637	22594	21	a	a	DT
18637	22594	22	lease	lease	NN
18637	22594	23	in	in	IN
18637	22594	24	1933	1933	CD
18637	22594	25	,	,	,
18637	22594	26	a	a	DT
18637	22594	27	landlord	landlord	NN
18637	22594	28	became	become	VBD
18637	22594	29	possessed	possess	VBN
18637	22594	30	of	of	IN
18637	22594	31	a	a	DT
18637	22594	32	new	new	JJ
18637	22594	33	building	building	NN
18637	22594	34	erected	erect	VBN
18637	22594	35	on	on	IN
18637	22594	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22594	37	land	land	NN
18637	22594	38	by	by	IN
18637	22594	39	the	the	DT
18637	22594	40	outgoing	outgoing	JJ
18637	22594	41	tenant	tenant	NN
18637	22594	42	,	,	,
18637	22594	43	the	the	DT
18637	22594	44	resulting	result	VBG
18637	22594	45	gain	gain	NN
18637	22594	46	to	to	IN
18637	22594	47	the	the	DT
18637	22594	48	former	former	JJ
18637	22594	49	was	be	VBD
18637	22594	50	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22594	51	to	to	IN
18637	22594	52	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22594	53	in	in	IN
18637	22594	54	that	that	DT
18637	22594	55	year	year	NN
18637	22594	56	.	.	.
18637	22595	1	Although	although	IN
18637	22595	2	"	"	``
18637	22595	3	economic	economic	JJ
18637	22595	4	gain	gain	NN
18637	22595	5	is	be	VBZ
18637	22595	6	not	not	RB
18637	22595	7	always	always	RB
18637	22595	8	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22595	9	as	as	IN
18637	22595	10	income	income	NN
18637	22595	11	,	,	,
18637	22595	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22595	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	22595	14	settled	settle	VBN
18637	22595	15	that	that	IN
18637	22595	16	the	the	DT
18637	22595	17	realization	realization	NN
18637	22595	18	of	of	IN
18637	22595	19	gain	gain	NN
18637	22595	20	need	nee	MD
18637	22595	21	not	not	RB
18637	22595	22	be	be	VB
18637	22595	23	in	in	IN
18637	22595	24	cash	cash	NN
18637	22595	25	derived	derive	VBN
18637	22595	26	from	from	IN
18637	22595	27	the	the	DT
18637	22595	28	sale	sale	NN
18637	22595	29	of	of	IN
18637	22595	30	an	an	DT
18637	22595	31	asset	asset	NN
18637	22595	32	.	.	.
18637	22596	1	*	*	NFP
18637	22596	2	*	*	NFP
18637	22596	3	*	*	NFP
18637	22596	4	The	the	DT
18637	22596	5	fact	fact	NN
18637	22596	6	that	that	IN
18637	22596	7	the	the	DT
18637	22596	8	gain	gain	NN
18637	22596	9	is	be	VBZ
18637	22596	10	a	a	DT
18637	22596	11	portion	portion	NN
18637	22596	12	of	of	IN
18637	22596	13	the	the	DT
18637	22596	14	value	value	NN
18637	22596	15	of	of	IN
18637	22596	16	the	the	DT
18637	22596	17	property	property	NN
18637	22596	18	received	receive	VBN
18637	22596	19	by	by	IN
18637	22596	20	the	the	DT
18637	22596	21	*	*	NN
18637	22596	22	*	*	NFP
18637	22596	23	*	*	NFP
18637	22596	24	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22596	25	landlord	landlord	NN
18637	22596	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22596	27	does	do	VBZ
18637	22596	28	not	not	RB
18637	22596	29	negative	negative	VB
18637	22596	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22596	31	realization	realization	NN
18637	22596	32	.	.	.
18637	22597	1	*	*	NFP
18637	22597	2	*	*	NFP
18637	22597	3	*	*	NFP
18637	22597	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22597	5	Nor	nor	CC
18637	22597	6	is	be	VBZ
18637	22597	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22597	8	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	22597	9	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22597	10	to	to	TO
18637	22597	11	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	22597	12	of	of	IN
18637	22597	13	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22597	14	gain	gain	NN
18637	22597	15	that	that	IN
18637	22597	16	*	*	NFP
18637	22597	17	*	*	NFP
18637	22597	18	*	*	NFP
18637	22597	19	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22597	20	the	the	DT
18637	22597	21	landlord	landlord	NN
18637	22597	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22597	23	should	should	MD
18637	22597	24	be	be	VB
18637	22597	25	able	able	JJ
18637	22597	26	to	to	TO
18637	22597	27	sever	sever	VB
18637	22597	28	the	the	DT
18637	22597	29	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	22597	30	begetting	beget	VBG
18637	22597	31	the	the	DT
18637	22597	32	gain	gain	NN
18637	22597	33	from	from	IN
18637	22597	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22597	35	original	original	JJ
18637	22597	36	capital	capital	NN
18637	22597	37	.	.	.
18637	22597	38	"	"	''
18637	22598	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	22598	2	,	,	,
18637	22598	3	the	the	DT
18637	22598	4	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	22598	5	was	be	VBD
18637	22598	6	incorrect	incorrect	JJ
18637	22598	7	in	in	IN
18637	22598	8	contending	contend	VBG
18637	22598	9	that	that	IN
18637	22598	10	the	the	DT
18637	22598	11	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22598	12	"	"	``
18637	22598	13	does	do	VBZ
18637	22598	14	not	not	RB
18637	22598	15	permit	permit	VB
18637	22598	16	the	the	DT
18637	22598	17	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	22598	18	of	of	IN
18637	22598	19	such	such	JJ
18637	22598	20	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22598	21	a	a	DT
18637	22598	22	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22598	23	gain	gain	NN
18637	22598	24	without	without	IN
18637	22598	25	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	22598	26	amongst	amongst	IN
18637	22598	27	the	the	DT
18637	22598	28	states	state	NNS
18637	22598	29	.	.	.
18637	22599	1	"	"	``
18637	22599	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22599	3	32	32	CD
18637	22599	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22599	5	Consistently	consistently	RB
18637	22599	6	with	with	IN
18637	22599	7	this	this	DT
18637	22599	8	holding	hold	VBG
18637	22599	9	the	the	DT
18637	22599	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22599	11	has	have	VBZ
18637	22599	12	also	also	RB
18637	22599	13	ruled	rule	VBN
18637	22599	14	that	that	IN
18637	22599	15	when	when	WRB
18637	22599	16	an	an	DT
18637	22599	17	apartment	apartment	NN
18637	22599	18	house	house	NN
18637	22599	19	was	be	VBD
18637	22599	20	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	22599	21	by	by	IN
18637	22599	22	bequest	bequest	NNP
18637	22599	23	subject	subject	NNP
18637	22599	24	to	to	IN
18637	22599	25	an	an	DT
18637	22599	26	unassumed	unassumed	JJ
18637	22599	27	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	22599	28	,	,	,
18637	22599	29	and	and	CC
18637	22599	30	several	several	JJ
18637	22599	31	years	year	NNS
18637	22599	32	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	22599	33	was	be	VBD
18637	22599	34	sold	sell	VBN
18637	22599	35	for	for	IN
18637	22599	36	a	a	DT
18637	22599	37	price	price	NN
18637	22599	38	slightly	slightly	RB
18637	22599	39	in	in	IN
18637	22599	40	excess	excess	NN
18637	22599	41	of	of	IN
18637	22599	42	the	the	DT
18637	22599	43	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	22599	44	,	,	,
18637	22599	45	the	the	DT
18637	22599	46	basis	basis	NN
18637	22599	47	for	for	IN
18637	22599	48	determining	determine	VBG
18637	22599	49	the	the	DT
18637	22599	50	gain	gain	NN
18637	22599	51	from	from	IN
18637	22599	52	that	that	DT
18637	22599	53	sale	sale	NN
18637	22599	54	was	be	VBD
18637	22599	55	the	the	DT
18637	22599	56	difference	difference	NN
18637	22599	57	between	between	IN
18637	22599	58	the	the	DT
18637	22599	59	selling	selling	NN
18637	22599	60	price	price	NN
18637	22599	61	,	,	,
18637	22599	62	undiminished	undiminishe	VBN
18637	22599	63	by	by	IN
18637	22599	64	the	the	DT
18637	22599	65	amount	amount	NN
18637	22599	66	of	of	IN
18637	22599	67	the	the	DT
18637	22599	68	mortgage	mortgage	NN
18637	22599	69	,	,	,
18637	22599	70	and	and	CC
18637	22599	71	the	the	DT
18637	22599	72	value	value	NN
18637	22599	73	of	of	IN
18637	22599	74	the	the	DT
18637	22599	75	property	property	NN
18637	22599	76	at	at	IN
18637	22599	77	the	the	DT
18637	22599	78	time	time	NN
18637	22599	79	of	of	IN
18637	22599	80	the	the	DT
18637	22599	81	acquisition	acquisition	NN
18637	22599	82	,	,	,
18637	22599	83	less	less	JJR
18637	22599	84	deductions	deduction	NNS
18637	22599	85	for	for	IN
18637	22599	86	depreciation	depreciation	NN
18637	22599	87	during	during	IN
18637	22599	88	the	the	DT
18637	22599	89	years	year	NNS
18637	22599	90	the	the	DT
18637	22599	91	building	building	NN
18637	22599	92	was	be	VBD
18637	22599	93	held	hold	VBN
18637	22599	94	by	by	IN
18637	22599	95	the	the	DT
18637	22599	96	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	22599	97	.	.	.
18637	22600	1	The	the	DT
18637	22600	2	latter	latter	NN
18637	22600	3	's	's	POS
18637	22600	4	contention	contention	NN
18637	22600	5	that	that	IN
18637	22600	6	the	the	DT
18637	22600	7	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	22600	8	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22600	9	,	,	,
18637	22600	10	as	as	IN
18637	22600	11	thus	thus	RB
18637	22600	12	applied	apply	VBN
18637	22600	13	,	,	,
18637	22600	14	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	22600	15	something	something	NN
18637	22600	16	which	which	WDT
18637	22600	17	was	be	VBD
18637	22600	18	not	not	RB
18637	22600	19	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	22600	20	was	be	VBD
18637	22600	21	declared	declare	VBN
18637	22600	22	to	to	TO
18637	22600	23	be	be	VB
18637	22600	24	unfounded	unfounded	JJ
18637	22600	25	.	.	.
18637	22601	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22601	2	33	33	CD
18637	22601	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22601	4	GAINS	gain	VBN
18637	22601	5	IN	in	IN
18637	22601	6	THE	the	DT
18637	22601	7	FORM	form	NN
18637	22601	8	OF	of	IN
18637	22601	9	BEQUESTS	bequest	NNS
18637	22601	10	;	;	:
18637	22601	11	WHEN	when	WRB
18637	22601	12	TAXABLE	taxable	NN
18637	22601	13	AS	as	IN
18637	22601	14	INCOME	income	NN
18637	22601	15	As	as	IN
18637	22601	16	against	against	IN
18637	22601	17	the	the	DT
18637	22601	18	argument	argument	NN
18637	22601	19	of	of	IN
18637	22601	20	a	a	DT
18637	22601	21	donee	donee	NN
18637	22601	22	that	that	IN
18637	22601	23	a	a	DT
18637	22601	24	gift	gift	NN
18637	22601	25	of	of	IN
18637	22601	26	stock	stock	NN
18637	22601	27	became	become	VBD
18637	22601	28	a	a	DT
18637	22601	29	capital	capital	NN
18637	22601	30	asset	asset	NN
18637	22601	31	when	when	WRB
18637	22601	32	received	receive	VBD
18637	22601	33	and	and	CC
18637	22601	34	that	that	IN
18637	22601	35	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	22601	36	,	,	,
18637	22601	37	when	when	WRB
18637	22601	38	disposed	dispose	VBN
18637	22601	39	of	of	IN
18637	22601	40	,	,	,
18637	22601	41	no	no	DT
18637	22601	42	part	part	NN
18637	22601	43	of	of	IN
18637	22601	44	that	that	DT
18637	22601	45	value	value	NN
18637	22601	46	could	could	MD
18637	22601	47	be	be	VB
18637	22601	48	treated	treat	VBN
18637	22601	49	as	as	IN
18637	22601	50	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22601	51	income	income	NN
18637	22601	52	to	to	IN
18637	22601	53	said	say	VBD
18637	22601	54	donee	donee	NN
18637	22601	55	,	,	,
18637	22601	56	the	the	DT
18637	22601	57	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22601	58	has	have	VBZ
18637	22601	59	declared	declare	VBN
18637	22601	60	that	that	IN
18637	22601	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22601	62	was	be	VBD
18637	22601	63	within	within	IN
18637	22601	64	the	the	DT
18637	22601	65	power	power	NN
18637	22601	66	of	of	IN
18637	22601	67	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22601	68	to	to	TO
18637	22601	69	require	require	VB
18637	22601	70	a	a	DT
18637	22601	71	donee	donee	NN
18637	22601	72	of	of	IN
18637	22601	73	stock	stock	NN
18637	22601	74	,	,	,
18637	22601	75	who	who	WP
18637	22601	76	sells	sell	VBZ
18637	22601	77	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22601	78	at	at	IN
18637	22601	79	a	a	DT
18637	22601	80	profit	profit	NN
18637	22601	81	,	,	,
18637	22601	82	to	to	TO
18637	22601	83	pay	pay	VB
18637	22601	84	income	income	NN
18637	22601	85	tax	tax	NN
18637	22601	86	on	on	IN
18637	22601	87	the	the	DT
18637	22601	88	difference	difference	NN
18637	22601	89	between	between	IN
18637	22601	90	the	the	DT
18637	22601	91	selling	selling	NN
18637	22601	92	price	price	NN
18637	22601	93	and	and	CC
18637	22601	94	the	the	DT
18637	22601	95	value	value	NN
18637	22601	96	when	when	WRB
18637	22601	97	the	the	DT
18637	22601	98	donor	donor	NN
18637	22601	99	acquired	acquire	VBD
18637	22601	100	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22601	101	.	.	.
18637	22602	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22602	2	34	34	CD
18637	22602	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22602	4	Moreover	moreover	RB
18637	22602	5	,	,	,
18637	22602	6	"	"	``
18637	22602	7	the	the	DT
18637	22602	8	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	22602	9	in	in	IN
18637	22602	10	cash	cash	NN
18637	22602	11	or	or	CC
18637	22602	12	property	property	NN
18637	22602	13	*	*	NFP
18637	22602	14	*	*	NFP
18637	22602	15	*	*	NFP
18637	22602	16	not	not	RB
18637	22602	17	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22602	18	being	be	VBG
18637	22602	19	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22602	20	the	the	DT
18637	22602	21	only	only	JJ
18637	22602	22	characteristic	characteristic	NN
18637	22602	23	of	of	IN
18637	22602	24	realization	realization	NN
18637	22602	25	of	of	IN
18637	22602	26	income	income	NN
18637	22602	27	to	to	IN
18637	22602	28	a	a	DT
18637	22602	29	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	22602	30	on	on	IN
18637	22602	31	the	the	DT
18637	22602	32	cash	cash	NN
18637	22602	33	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	22602	34	basis	basis	NN
18637	22602	35	,	,	,
18637	22602	36	"	"	''
18637	22602	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22602	38	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	22602	39	that	that	IN
18637	22602	40	one	one	NN
18637	22602	41	who	who	WP
18637	22602	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	22602	43	normally	normally	RB
18637	22602	44	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22602	45	only	only	RB
18637	22602	46	on	on	IN
18637	22602	47	the	the	DT
18637	22602	48	receipt	receipt	NN
18637	22602	49	of	of	IN
18637	22602	50	interest	interest	NN
18637	22602	51	payments	payment	NNS
18637	22602	52	can	can	MD
18637	22602	53	not	not	RB
18637	22602	54	escape	escape	VB
18637	22602	55	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	22602	56	thereon	thereon	NN
18637	22602	57	by	by	IN
18637	22602	58	giving	give	VBG
18637	22602	59	away	away	RB
18637	22602	60	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22602	61	right	right	NN
18637	22602	62	to	to	IN
18637	22602	63	such	such	JJ
18637	22602	64	income	income	NN
18637	22602	65	in	in	IN
18637	22602	66	advance	advance	NN
18637	22602	67	of	of	IN
18637	22602	68	payment	payment	NN
18637	22602	69	.	.	.
18637	22603	1	When	when	WRB
18637	22603	2	"	"	``
18637	22603	3	the	the	DT
18637	22603	4	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	22603	5	does	do	VBZ
18637	22603	6	not	not	RB
18637	22603	7	receive	receive	VB
18637	22603	8	payment	payment	NN
18637	22603	9	of	of	IN
18637	22603	10	income	income	NN
18637	22603	11	in	in	IN
18637	22603	12	money	money	NN
18637	22603	13	or	or	CC
18637	22603	14	property	property	NN
18637	22603	15	,	,	,
18637	22603	16	realization	realization	NN
18637	22603	17	may	may	MD
18637	22603	18	occur	occur	VB
18637	22603	19	when	when	WRB
18637	22603	20	the	the	DT
18637	22603	21	last	last	JJ
18637	22603	22	step	step	NN
18637	22603	23	is	be	VBZ
18637	22603	24	taken	take	VBN
18637	22603	25	by	by	IN
18637	22603	26	which	which	WDT
18637	22603	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22603	28	obtains	obtain	VBZ
18637	22603	29	the	the	DT
18637	22603	30	fruition	fruition	NN
18637	22603	31	of	of	IN
18637	22603	32	the	the	DT
18637	22603	33	economic	economic	JJ
18637	22603	34	gain	gain	NN
18637	22603	35	which	which	WDT
18637	22603	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	22603	37	already	already	RB
18637	22603	38	accrued	accrue	VBN
18637	22603	39	to	to	IN
18637	22603	40	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22603	41	.	.	.
18637	22603	42	"	"	''
18637	22604	1	Hence	hence	RB
18637	22604	2	an	an	DT
18637	22604	3	owner	owner	NN
18637	22604	4	of	of	IN
18637	22604	5	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	22604	6	,	,	,
18637	22604	7	reporting	report	VBG
18637	22604	8	on	on	IN
18637	22604	9	the	the	DT
18637	22604	10	cash	cash	NN
18637	22604	11	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	22604	12	basis	basis	NN
18637	22604	13	,	,	,
18637	22604	14	who	who	WP
18637	22604	15	clipped	clip	VBD
18637	22604	16	interest	interest	NN
18637	22604	17	coupons	coupon	NNS
18637	22604	18	therefrom	therefrom	JJ
18637	22604	19	before	before	IN
18637	22604	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22604	21	due	due	JJ
18637	22604	22	date	date	NN
18637	22604	23	and	and	CC
18637	22604	24	gave	give	VBD
18637	22604	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22604	26	to	to	IN
18637	22604	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22604	28	son	son	NN
18637	22604	29	,	,	,
18637	22604	30	was	be	VBD
18637	22604	31	held	hold	VBN
18637	22604	32	to	to	TO
18637	22604	33	have	have	VB
18637	22604	34	realized	realize	VBN
18637	22604	35	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22604	36	income	income	NN
18637	22604	37	in	in	IN
18637	22604	38	the	the	DT
18637	22604	39	amount	amount	NN
18637	22604	40	of	of	IN
18637	22604	41	said	say	VBN
18637	22604	42	coupons	coupon	NNS
18637	22604	43	,	,	,
18637	22604	44	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	22604	45	that	that	IN
18637	22604	46	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22604	47	son	son	NN
18637	22604	48	had	have	VBD
18637	22604	49	collected	collect	VBN
18637	22604	50	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22604	51	upon	upon	IN
18637	22604	52	maturity	maturity	NN
18637	22604	53	later	later	RB
18637	22604	54	in	in	IN
18637	22604	55	the	the	DT
18637	22604	56	year	year	NN
18637	22604	57	.	.	.
18637	22605	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22605	2	35	35	CD
18637	22605	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22605	4	DIMINUTION	diminution	NN
18637	22605	5	OF	of	IN
18637	22605	6	LOSS	LOSS	NNP
18637	22605	7	,	,	,
18637	22605	8	NOT	not	RB
18637	22605	9	INCOME	INCOME	NNP
18637	22605	10	Mere	mere	JJ
18637	22605	11	diminution	diminution	NN
18637	22605	12	of	of	IN
18637	22605	13	loss	loss	NN
18637	22605	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	22605	15	neither	neither	CC
18637	22605	16	gain	gain	NN
18637	22605	17	,	,	,
18637	22605	18	profit	profit	NN
18637	22605	19	,	,	,
18637	22605	20	nor	nor	CC
18637	22605	21	income	income	NN
18637	22605	22	.	.	.
18637	22606	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	22606	2	,	,	,
18637	22606	3	one	one	CD
18637	22606	4	who	who	WP
18637	22606	5	in	in	IN
18637	22606	6	1913	1913	CD
18637	22606	7	borrowed	borrow	VBD
18637	22606	8	a	a	DT
18637	22606	9	sum	sum	NN
18637	22606	10	of	of	IN
18637	22606	11	money	money	NN
18637	22606	12	to	to	TO
18637	22606	13	be	be	VB
18637	22606	14	repaid	repay	VBN
18637	22606	15	in	in	IN
18637	22606	16	German	german	JJ
18637	22606	17	marks	mark	NNS
18637	22606	18	and	and	CC
18637	22606	19	who	who	WP
18637	22606	20	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	22606	21	lost	lose	VBD
18637	22606	22	said	say	VBD
18637	22606	23	money	money	NN
18637	22606	24	in	in	IN
18637	22606	25	a	a	DT
18637	22606	26	business	business	NN
18637	22606	27	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	22606	28	can	can	MD
18637	22606	29	not	not	RB
18637	22606	30	be	be	VB
18637	22606	31	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	22606	32	on	on	IN
18637	22606	33	the	the	DT
18637	22606	34	curtailment	curtailment	NN
18637	22606	35	of	of	IN
18637	22606	36	debt	debt	NN
18637	22606	37	effected	effect	VBN
18637	22606	38	by	by	IN
18637	22606	39	using	use	VBG
18637	22606	40	depreciated	depreciate	VBN
18637	22606	41	marks	mark	NNS
18637	22606	42	in	in	IN
18637	22606	43	1921	1921	CD
18637	22606	44	to	to	TO
18637	22606	45	settle	settle	VB
18637	22606	46	a	a	DT
18637	22606	47	liability	liability	NN
18637	22606	48	of	of	IN
18637	22606	49	$	$	$
18637	22606	50	798,144	798,144	CD
18637	22606	51	for	for	IN
18637	22606	52	$	$	$
18637	22606	53	113,688	113,688	CD
18637	22606	54	,	,	,
18637	22606	55	the	the	DT
18637	22606	56	"	"	``
18637	22606	57	saving	saving	NN
18637	22606	58	"	"	''
18637	22606	59	having	have	VBG
18637	22606	60	been	be	VBN
18637	22606	61	exceeded	exceed	VBN
18637	22606	62	by	by	IN
18637	22606	63	a	a	DT
18637	22606	64	loss	loss	NN
18637	22606	65	on	on	IN
18637	22606	66	the	the	DT
18637	22606	67	entire	entire	JJ
18637	22606	68	operation	operation	NN
18637	22606	69	.	.	.
18637	22607	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22607	2	36	36	CD
18637	22607	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22607	4	DATES	date	NNS
18637	22607	5	APPLICABLE	applicable	NN
18637	22607	6	IN	in	IN
18637	22607	7	COMPUTATION	computation	NN
18637	22607	8	OF	of	IN
18637	22607	9	TAXABLE	taxable	NN
18637	22607	10	GAINS	gain	VBD
18637	22607	11	With	with	IN
18637	22607	12	a	a	DT
18637	22607	13	frequency	frequency	NN
18637	22607	14	that	that	IN
18637	22607	15	for	for	IN
18637	22607	16	obvious	obvious	JJ
18637	22607	17	reasons	reason	NNS
18637	22607	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	22607	19	progressively	progressively	RB
18637	22607	20	diminishing	diminish	VBG
18637	22607	21	,	,	,
18637	22607	22	the	the	DT
18637	22607	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22607	24	has	have	VBZ
18637	22607	25	also	also	RB
18637	22607	26	been	be	VBN
18637	22607	27	called	call	VBN
18637	22607	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	22607	29	to	to	TO
18637	22607	30	resolve	resolve	VB
18637	22607	31	questions	question	NNS
18637	22607	32	as	as	IN
18637	22607	33	to	to	IN
18637	22607	34	whether	whether	IN
18637	22607	35	gains	gain	NNS
18637	22607	36	,	,	,
18637	22607	37	realized	realize	VBN
18637	22607	38	after	after	IN
18637	22607	39	1913	1913	CD
18637	22607	40	,	,	,
18637	22607	41	on	on	IN
18637	22607	42	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	22607	43	consummated	consummate	VBN
18637	22607	44	prior	prior	RB
18637	22607	45	to	to	IN
18637	22607	46	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	22607	47	of	of	IN
18637	22607	48	the	the	DT
18637	22607	49	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	22607	50	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22607	51	are	be	VBP
18637	22607	52	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22607	53	,	,	,
18637	22607	54	and	and	CC
18637	22607	55	if	if	IN
18637	22607	56	so	so	RB
18637	22607	57	,	,	,
18637	22607	58	how	how	WRB
18637	22607	59	such	such	JJ
18637	22607	60	tax	tax	NN
18637	22607	61	is	be	VBZ
18637	22607	62	to	to	TO
18637	22607	63	be	be	VB
18637	22607	64	determined	determine	VBN
18637	22607	65	.	.	.
18637	22608	1	The	the	DT
18637	22608	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22608	3	's	's	POS
18637	22608	4	answer	answer	NN
18637	22608	5	generally	generally	RB
18637	22608	6	has	have	VBZ
18637	22608	7	been	be	VBN
18637	22608	8	that	that	IN
18637	22608	9	if	if	IN
18637	22608	10	the	the	DT
18637	22608	11	gain	gain	NN
18637	22608	12	to	to	IN
18637	22608	13	the	the	DT
18637	22608	14	person	person	NN
18637	22608	15	whose	whose	WP$
18637	22608	16	income	income	NN
18637	22608	17	is	be	VBZ
18637	22608	18	under	under	IN
18637	22608	19	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	22608	20	became	become	VBD
18637	22608	21	such	such	JJ
18637	22608	22	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	22608	23	to	to	IN
18637	22608	24	the	the	DT
18637	22608	25	date	date	NN
18637	22608	26	at	at	IN
18637	22608	27	which	which	WDT
18637	22608	28	the	the	DT
18637	22608	29	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22608	30	went	go	VBD
18637	22608	31	into	into	IN
18637	22608	32	effect	effect	NN
18637	22608	33	;	;	:
18637	22608	34	namely	namely	RB
18637	22608	35	,	,	,
18637	22608	36	March	March	NNP
18637	22608	37	1	1	CD
18637	22608	38	,	,	,
18637	22608	39	1913	1913	CD
18637	22608	40	,	,	,
18637	22608	41	and	and	CC
18637	22608	42	is	be	VBZ
18637	22608	43	a	a	DT
18637	22608	44	real	real	JJ
18637	22608	45	and	and	CC
18637	22608	46	not	not	RB
18637	22608	47	merely	merely	RB
18637	22608	48	an	an	DT
18637	22608	49	apparent	apparent	JJ
18637	22608	50	gain	gain	NN
18637	22608	51	,	,	,
18637	22608	52	said	say	VBD
18637	22608	53	gain	gain	NN
18637	22608	54	is	be	VBZ
18637	22608	55	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22608	56	.	.	.
18637	22609	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	22609	2	,	,	,
18637	22609	3	one	one	CD
18637	22609	4	who	who	WP
18637	22609	5	purchased	purchase	VBD
18637	22609	6	stock	stock	NN
18637	22609	7	in	in	IN
18637	22609	8	1912	1912	CD
18637	22609	9	for	for	IN
18637	22609	10	$	$	$
18637	22609	11	500	500	CD
18637	22609	12	could	could	MD
18637	22609	13	not	not	RB
18637	22609	14	limit	limit	VB
18637	22609	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22609	16	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22609	17	gain	gain	NN
18637	22609	18	to	to	IN
18637	22609	19	the	the	DT
18637	22609	20	difference	difference	NN
18637	22609	21	between	between	IN
18637	22609	22	$	$	$
18637	22609	23	695	695	CD
18637	22609	24	,	,	,
18637	22609	25	the	the	DT
18637	22609	26	value	value	NN
18637	22609	27	of	of	IN
18637	22609	28	the	the	DT
18637	22609	29	stock	stock	NN
18637	22609	30	on	on	IN
18637	22609	31	March	March	NNP
18637	22609	32	1	1	CD
18637	22609	33	,	,	,
18637	22609	34	1913	1913	CD
18637	22609	35	and	and	CC
18637	22609	36	$	$	$
18637	22609	37	13,931	13,931	CD
18637	22609	38	,	,	,
18637	22609	39	the	the	DT
18637	22609	40	price	price	NN
18637	22609	41	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	22609	42	on	on	IN
18637	22609	43	the	the	DT
18637	22609	44	sale	sale	NN
18637	22609	45	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	22609	46	in	in	IN
18637	22609	47	1916	1916	CD
18637	22609	48	;	;	:
18637	22609	49	but	but	CC
18637	22609	50	was	be	VBD
18637	22609	51	obliged	oblige	VBN
18637	22609	52	to	to	TO
18637	22609	53	pay	pay	VB
18637	22609	54	tax	tax	NN
18637	22609	55	on	on	IN
18637	22609	56	the	the	DT
18637	22609	57	entire	entire	JJ
18637	22609	58	gain	gain	NN
18637	22609	59	,	,	,
18637	22609	60	that	that	RB
18637	22609	61	is	is	RB
18637	22609	62	,	,	,
18637	22609	63	the	the	DT
18637	22609	64	difference	difference	NN
18637	22609	65	between	between	IN
18637	22609	66	the	the	DT
18637	22609	67	original	original	JJ
18637	22609	68	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	22609	69	price	price	NN
18637	22609	70	and	and	CC
18637	22609	71	the	the	DT
18637	22609	72	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	22609	73	of	of	IN
18637	22609	74	the	the	DT
18637	22609	75	sale	sale	NN
18637	22609	76	.	.	.
18637	22610	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22610	2	37	37	CD
18637	22610	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22610	4	Conversely	conversely	RB
18637	22610	5	,	,	,
18637	22610	6	one	one	CD
18637	22610	7	who	who	WP
18637	22610	8	acquired	acquire	VBD
18637	22610	9	stock	stock	NN
18637	22610	10	in	in	IN
18637	22610	11	1912	1912	CD
18637	22610	12	for	for	IN
18637	22610	13	$	$	$
18637	22610	14	291,600	291,600	CD
18637	22610	15	and	and	CC
18637	22610	16	who	who	WP
18637	22610	17	sold	sell	VBD
18637	22610	18	the	the	DT
18637	22610	19	same	same	JJ
18637	22610	20	in	in	IN
18637	22610	21	1916	1916	CD
18637	22610	22	for	for	IN
18637	22610	23	only	only	RB
18637	22610	24	$	$	$
18637	22610	25	269,346	269,346	CD
18637	22610	26	,	,	,
18637	22610	27	incurred	incur	VBD
18637	22610	28	a	a	DT
18637	22610	29	loss	loss	NN
18637	22610	30	and	and	CC
18637	22610	31	could	could	MD
18637	22610	32	not	not	RB
18637	22610	33	be	be	VB
18637	22610	34	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	22610	35	at	at	RB
18637	22610	36	all	all	RB
18637	22610	37	,	,	,
18637	22610	38	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	22610	39	the	the	DT
18637	22610	40	fact	fact	NN
18637	22610	41	that	that	IN
18637	22610	42	on	on	IN
18637	22610	43	March	March	NNP
18637	22610	44	1	1	CD
18637	22610	45	,	,	,
18637	22610	46	1913	1913	CD
18637	22610	47	,	,	,
18637	22610	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22610	49	stock	stock	NN
18637	22610	50	had	have	VBD
18637	22610	51	depreciated	depreciate	VBN
18637	22610	52	to	to	IN
18637	22610	53	$	$	$
18637	22610	54	148,635	148,635	CD
18637	22610	55	.	.	.
18637	22611	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22611	2	38	38	CD
18637	22611	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22611	4	On	on	IN
18637	22611	5	the	the	DT
18637	22611	6	other	other	JJ
18637	22611	7	hand	hand	NN
18637	22611	8	,	,	,
18637	22611	9	although	although	IN
18637	22611	10	the	the	DT
18637	22611	11	difference	difference	NN
18637	22611	12	between	between	IN
18637	22611	13	the	the	DT
18637	22611	14	amount	amount	NN
18637	22611	15	of	of	IN
18637	22611	16	life	life	NN
18637	22611	17	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	22611	18	premiums	premium	NNS
18637	22611	19	,	,	,
18637	22611	20	paid	pay	VBD
18637	22611	21	as	as	IN
18637	22611	22	of	of	IN
18637	22611	23	1908	1908	CD
18637	22611	24	,	,	,
18637	22611	25	and	and	CC
18637	22611	26	the	the	DT
18637	22611	27	amount	amount	NN
18637	22611	28	distributed	distribute	VBN
18637	22611	29	in	in	IN
18637	22611	30	1919	1919	CD
18637	22611	31	,	,	,
18637	22611	32	when	when	WRB
18637	22611	33	the	the	DT
18637	22611	34	insured	insure	VBN
18637	22611	35	received	receive	VBD
18637	22611	36	the	the	DT
18637	22611	37	amount	amount	NN
18637	22611	38	of	of	IN
18637	22611	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22611	40	policy	policy	NN
18637	22611	41	plus	plus	CC
18637	22611	42	cash	cash	NN
18637	22611	43	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	22611	44	apportioned	apportion	VBD
18637	22611	45	thereto	thereto	NN
18637	22611	46	since	since	IN
18637	22611	47	1908	1908	CD
18637	22611	48	,	,	,
18637	22611	49	constituted	constitute	VBD
18637	22611	50	a	a	DT
18637	22611	51	gain	gain	NN
18637	22611	52	,	,	,
18637	22611	53	that	that	DT
18637	22611	54	portion	portion	NN
18637	22611	55	of	of	IN
18637	22611	56	the	the	DT
18637	22611	57	latter	latter	JJ
18637	22611	58	which	which	WDT
18637	22611	59	accrued	accrue	VBN
18637	22611	60	between	between	IN
18637	22611	61	1908	1908	CD
18637	22611	62	and	and	CC
18637	22611	63	1913	1913	CD
18637	22611	64	was	be	VBD
18637	22611	65	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	22611	66	to	to	TO
18637	22611	67	be	be	VB
18637	22611	68	an	an	DT
18637	22611	69	accretion	accretion	NN
18637	22611	70	of	of	IN
18637	22611	71	capital	capital	NN
18637	22611	72	and	and	CC
18637	22611	73	hence	hence	RB
18637	22611	74	not	not	RB
18637	22611	75	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22611	76	.	.	.
18637	22612	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22612	2	39	39	CD
18637	22612	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22612	4	DEDUCTIONS	deduction	NNS
18637	22612	5	;	;	:
18637	22612	6	EXEMPTIONS	EXEMPTIONS	NNP
18637	22612	7	,	,	,
18637	22612	8	ETC	ETC	NNP
18637	22612	9	.	.	.
18637	22613	1	Notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	22613	2	the	the	DT
18637	22613	3	authorization	authorization	NN
18637	22613	4	contained	contain	VBN
18637	22613	5	in	in	IN
18637	22613	6	the	the	DT
18637	22613	7	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	22613	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22613	9	to	to	TO
18637	22613	10	tax	tax	VB
18637	22613	11	income	income	NN
18637	22613	12	"	"	''
18637	22613	13	from	from	IN
18637	22613	14	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	22613	15	source	source	NN
18637	22613	16	derived	derive	VBN
18637	22613	17	,	,	,
18637	22613	18	"	"	''
18637	22613	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22613	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	22613	21	been	be	VBN
18637	22613	22	held	hold	VBN
18637	22613	23	not	not	RB
18637	22613	24	to	to	TO
18637	22613	25	be	be	VB
18637	22613	26	precluded	preclude	VBN
18637	22613	27	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	22613	28	from	from	IN
18637	22613	29	granting	grant	VBG
18637	22613	30	exemptions	exemption	NNS
18637	22613	31	.	.	.
18637	22614	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22614	2	40	40	CD
18637	22614	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22614	4	Thus	thus	RB
18637	22614	5	,	,	,
18637	22614	6	the	the	DT
18637	22614	7	fact	fact	NN
18637	22614	8	that	that	IN
18637	22614	9	"	"	``
18637	22614	10	under	under	IN
18637	22614	11	the	the	DT
18637	22614	12	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	22614	13	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	22614	14	of	of	IN
18637	22614	15	1913	1913	CD
18637	22614	16	,	,	,
18637	22614	17	1916	1916	CD
18637	22614	18	,	,	,
18637	22614	19	1917	1917	CD
18637	22614	20	,	,	,
18637	22614	21	and	and	CC
18637	22614	22	1918	1918	CD
18637	22614	23	,	,	,
18637	22614	24	stock	stock	NN
18637	22614	25	fire	fire	NN
18637	22614	26	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	22614	27	companies	company	NNS
18637	22614	28	were	be	VBD
18637	22614	29	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	22614	30	*	*	NFP
18637	22614	31	*	*	NFP
18637	22614	32	*	*	NFP
18637	22614	33	upon	upon	IN
18637	22614	34	gains	gain	NNS
18637	22614	35	realized	realize	VBN
18637	22614	36	from	from	IN
18637	22614	37	the	the	DT
18637	22614	38	sale	sale	NN
18637	22614	39	*	*	NFP
18637	22614	40	*	*	NFP
18637	22614	41	*	*	NFP
18637	22614	42	of	of	IN
18637	22614	43	property	property	NN
18637	22614	44	accruing	accrue	VBG
18637	22614	45	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	22614	46	to	to	IN
18637	22614	47	March	March	NNP
18637	22614	48	1	1	CD
18637	22614	49	,	,	,
18637	22614	50	1913	1913	CD
18637	22614	51	,	,	,
18637	22614	52	"	"	``
18637	22614	53	but	but	CC
18637	22614	54	were	be	VBD
18637	22614	55	not	not	RB
18637	22614	56	so	so	RB
18637	22614	57	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	22614	58	by	by	IN
18637	22614	59	the	the	DT
18637	22614	60	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	22614	61	Acts	Acts	NNPS
18637	22614	62	of	of	IN
18637	22614	63	1921	1921	CD
18637	22614	64	,	,	,
18637	22614	65	1924	1924	CD
18637	22614	66	,	,	,
18637	22614	67	and	and	CC
18637	22614	68	1926	1926	CD
18637	22614	69	,	,	,
18637	22614	70	did	do	VBD
18637	22614	71	not	not	RB
18637	22614	72	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	22614	73	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22614	74	,	,	,
18637	22614	75	under	under	IN
18637	22614	76	the	the	DT
18637	22614	77	terms	term	NNS
18637	22614	78	of	of	IN
18637	22614	79	the	the	DT
18637	22614	80	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	22614	81	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22614	82	of	of	IN
18637	22614	83	1928	1928	CD
18637	22614	84	,	,	,
18637	22614	85	from	from	IN
18637	22614	86	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	22614	87	all	all	PDT
18637	22614	88	the	the	DT
18637	22614	89	gain	gain	NN
18637	22614	90	attributable	attributable	JJ
18637	22614	91	to	to	TO
18637	22614	92	increase	increase	VB
18637	22614	93	in	in	IN
18637	22614	94	value	value	NN
18637	22614	95	after	after	IN
18637	22614	96	March	March	NNP
18637	22614	97	1	1	CD
18637	22614	98	,	,	,
18637	22614	99	1913	1913	CD
18637	22614	100	which	which	WDT
18637	22614	101	such	such	PDT
18637	22614	102	a	a	DT
18637	22614	103	company	company	NN
18637	22614	104	realized	realize	VBN
18637	22614	105	from	from	IN
18637	22614	106	a	a	DT
18637	22614	107	sale	sale	NN
18637	22614	108	of	of	IN
18637	22614	109	property	property	NN
18637	22614	110	in	in	IN
18637	22614	111	1928	1928	CD
18637	22614	112	.	.	.
18637	22615	1	The	the	DT
18637	22615	2	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	22615	3	power	power	NN
18637	22615	4	of	of	IN
18637	22615	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22615	6	to	to	TO
18637	22615	7	tax	tax	VB
18637	22615	8	a	a	DT
18637	22615	9	gain	gain	NN
18637	22615	10	being	be	VBG
18637	22615	11	well	well	RB
18637	22615	12	established	establish	VBN
18637	22615	13	,	,	,
18637	22615	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22615	15	,	,	,
18637	22615	16	was	be	VBD
18637	22615	17	declared	declare	VBN
18637	22615	18	competent	competent	JJ
18637	22615	19	to	to	TO
18637	22615	20	choose	choose	VB
18637	22615	21	"	"	``
18637	22615	22	the	the	DT
18637	22615	23	moment	moment	NN
18637	22615	24	of	of	IN
18637	22615	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22615	26	realization	realization	NN
18637	22615	27	and	and	CC
18637	22615	28	the	the	DT
18637	22615	29	amount	amount	NN
18637	22615	30	realized	realize	VBD
18637	22615	31	"	"	''
18637	22615	32	;	;	:
18637	22615	33	and	and	CC
18637	22615	34	"	"	``
18637	22615	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22615	36	failure	failure	NN
18637	22615	37	to	to	TO
18637	22615	38	impose	impose	VB
18637	22615	39	a	a	DT
18637	22615	40	tax	tax	NN
18637	22615	41	upon	upon	IN
18637	22615	42	the	the	DT
18637	22615	43	increase	increase	NN
18637	22615	44	in	in	IN
18637	22615	45	value	value	NN
18637	22615	46	in	in	IN
18637	22615	47	the	the	DT
18637	22615	48	earlier	early	JJR
18637	22615	49	years	year	NNS
18637	22615	50	*	*	NFP
18637	22615	51	*	*	NFP
18637	22615	52	*	*	NFP
18637	22615	53	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22615	54	could	could	MD
18637	22615	55	not	not	RB
18637	22615	56	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22615	57	preclude	preclude	VB
18637	22615	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22615	59	from	from	IN
18637	22615	60	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	22615	61	the	the	DT
18637	22615	62	gain	gain	NN
18637	22615	63	in	in	IN
18637	22615	64	the	the	DT
18637	22615	65	year	year	NN
18637	22615	66	when	when	WRB
18637	22615	67	realized	realize	VBN
18637	22615	68	*	*	NFP
18637	22615	69	*	*	NFP
18637	22615	70	*	*	NFP
18637	22615	71	"	"	''
18637	22615	72	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22615	73	41	41	CD
18637	22615	74	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22615	75	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22615	76	is	be	VBZ
18637	22615	77	equally	equally	RB
18637	22615	78	well	well	RB
18637	22615	79	equipped	equip	VBN
18637	22615	80	with	with	IN
18637	22615	81	the	the	DT
18637	22615	82	"	"	``
18637	22615	83	power	power	NN
18637	22615	84	to	to	IN
18637	22615	85	condition	condition	NN
18637	22615	86	,	,	,
18637	22615	87	limit	limit	NN
18637	22615	88	,	,	,
18637	22615	89	or	or	CC
18637	22615	90	deny	deny	VB
18637	22615	91	deductions	deduction	NNS
18637	22615	92	from	from	IN
18637	22615	93	gross	gross	JJ
18637	22615	94	incomes	income	NNS
18637	22615	95	in	in	IN
18637	22615	96	order	order	NN
18637	22615	97	to	to	TO
18637	22615	98	arrive	arrive	VB
18637	22615	99	at	at	IN
18637	22615	100	the	the	DT
18637	22615	101	net	net	NN
18637	22615	102	that	that	WDT
18637	22615	103	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22615	104	chooses	choose	VBZ
18637	22615	105	to	to	IN
18637	22615	106	tax	tax	NN
18637	22615	107	.	.	.
18637	22616	1	"	"	``
18637	22616	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22616	3	42	42	CD
18637	22616	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22616	5	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	22616	6	,	,	,
18637	22616	7	even	even	RB
18637	22616	8	though	though	IN
18637	22616	9	the	the	DT
18637	22616	10	rental	rental	JJ
18637	22616	11	value	value	NN
18637	22616	12	of	of	IN
18637	22616	13	a	a	DT
18637	22616	14	building	building	NN
18637	22616	15	used	use	VBN
18637	22616	16	by	by	IN
18637	22616	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22616	18	owner	owner	NN
18637	22616	19	does	do	VBZ
18637	22616	20	not	not	RB
18637	22616	21	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	22616	22	income	income	NN
18637	22616	23	within	within	IN
18637	22616	24	the	the	DT
18637	22616	25	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	22616	26	of	of	IN
18637	22616	27	the	the	DT
18637	22616	28	amendment,[43	amendment,[43	CD
18637	22616	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22616	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22616	31	was	be	VBD
18637	22616	32	competent	competent	JJ
18637	22616	33	to	to	TO
18637	22616	34	provide	provide	VB
18637	22616	35	that	that	IN
18637	22616	36	an	an	DT
18637	22616	37	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	22616	38	company	company	NN
18637	22616	39	shall	shall	MD
18637	22616	40	not	not	RB
18637	22616	41	be	be	VB
18637	22616	42	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	22616	43	to	to	IN
18637	22616	44	deductions	deduction	NNS
18637	22616	45	for	for	IN
18637	22616	46	depreciation	depreciation	NN
18637	22616	47	,	,	,
18637	22616	48	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	22616	49	,	,	,
18637	22616	50	and	and	CC
18637	22616	51	property	property	NN
18637	22616	52	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	22616	53	on	on	IN
18637	22616	54	real	real	JJ
18637	22616	55	estate	estate	NN
18637	22616	56	owned	own	VBN
18637	22616	57	and	and	CC
18637	22616	58	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	22616	59	by	by	IN
18637	22616	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22616	61	unless	unless	IN
18637	22616	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22616	63	includes	include	VBZ
18637	22616	64	in	in	IN
18637	22616	65	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22616	66	computation	computation	NN
18637	22616	67	of	of	IN
18637	22616	68	gross	gross	JJ
18637	22616	69	income	income	NN
18637	22616	70	the	the	DT
18637	22616	71	rental	rental	JJ
18637	22616	72	value	value	NN
18637	22616	73	of	of	IN
18637	22616	74	the	the	DT
18637	22616	75	space	space	NN
18637	22616	76	thus	thus	RB
18637	22616	77	used	use	VBD
18637	22616	78	.	.	.
18637	22617	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22617	2	44	44	CD
18637	22617	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22617	4	ILLEGAL	illegal	NN
18637	22617	5	GAINS	gain	VBN
18637	22617	6	AS	as	IN
18637	22617	7	INCOME	income	NN
18637	22617	8	In	in	IN
18637	22617	9	United	United	NNP
18637	22617	10	States	States	NNP
18637	22617	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22617	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	22617	13	_	_	NNP
18637	22617	14	Sullivan[45	Sullivan[45	NNP
18637	22617	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22617	16	the	the	DT
18637	22617	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22617	18	held	hold	VBD
18637	22617	19	,	,	,
18637	22617	20	in	in	IN
18637	22617	21	1927	1927	CD
18637	22617	22	,	,	,
18637	22617	23	that	that	WDT
18637	22617	24	gains	gain	NNS
18637	22617	25	derived	derive	VBN
18637	22617	26	from	from	IN
18637	22617	27	illicit	illicit	JJ
18637	22617	28	traffic	traffic	NN
18637	22617	29	in	in	IN
18637	22617	30	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	22617	31	were	be	VBD
18637	22617	32	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22617	33	income	income	NN
18637	22617	34	under	under	IN
18637	22617	35	the	the	DT
18637	22617	36	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22617	37	of	of	IN
18637	22617	38	1921	1921	CD
18637	22617	39	.	.	.
18637	22618	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22618	2	46	46	CD
18637	22618	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22618	4	Said	Said	NNP
18637	22618	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22618	6	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	22618	7	for	for	IN
18637	22618	8	the	the	DT
18637	22618	9	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
18637	22618	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22618	11	:	:	:
18637	22618	12	"	"	``
18637	22618	13	We	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22618	14	see	see	VBP
18637	22618	15	no	no	DT
18637	22618	16	reason	reason	NN
18637	22618	17	*	*	NFP
18637	22618	18	*	*	NFP
18637	22618	19	*	*	NFP
18637	22618	20	why	why	WRB
18637	22618	21	the	the	DT
18637	22618	22	fact	fact	NN
18637	22618	23	that	that	IN
18637	22618	24	a	a	DT
18637	22618	25	business	business	NN
18637	22618	26	is	be	VBZ
18637	22618	27	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	22618	28	should	should	MD
18637	22618	29	exempt	exempt	VB
18637	22618	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22618	31	from	from	IN
18637	22618	32	paying	pay	VBG
18637	22618	33	the	the	DT
18637	22618	34	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	22618	35	that	that	WDT
18637	22618	36	if	if	IN
18637	22618	37	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	22618	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22618	39	would	would	MD
18637	22618	40	have	have	VB
18637	22618	41	to	to	TO
18637	22618	42	pay	pay	VB
18637	22618	43	.	.	.
18637	22619	1	"	"	``
18637	22619	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22619	3	47	47	CD
18637	22619	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22619	5	But	but	CC
18637	22619	6	in	in	IN
18637	22619	7	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	22619	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22619	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22619	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22619	11	Wilcox,[48	Wilcox,[48	NNP
18637	22619	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22619	13	decided	decide	VBD
18637	22619	14	in	in	IN
18637	22619	15	1946	1946	CD
18637	22619	16	,	,	,
18637	22619	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22619	18	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	22619	19	,	,	,
18637	22619	20	speaking	speak	VBG
18637	22619	21	for	for	IN
18637	22619	22	a	a	DT
18637	22619	23	majority	majority	NN
18637	22619	24	of	of	IN
18637	22619	25	the	the	DT
18637	22619	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22619	27	,	,	,
18637	22619	28	held	hold	VBD
18637	22619	29	that	that	IN
18637	22619	30	embezzled	embezzle	VBN
18637	22619	31	money	money	NN
18637	22619	32	was	be	VBD
18637	22619	33	not	not	RB
18637	22619	34	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22619	35	income	income	NN
18637	22619	36	to	to	IN
18637	22619	37	the	the	DT
18637	22619	38	embezzler	embezzler	NN
18637	22619	39	,	,	,
18637	22619	40	although	although	IN
18637	22619	41	any	any	DT
18637	22619	42	gain	gain	NN
18637	22619	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22619	44	derived	derive	VBD
18637	22619	45	from	from	IN
18637	22619	46	the	the	DT
18637	22619	47	use	use	NN
18637	22619	48	of	of	IN
18637	22619	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22619	50	would	would	MD
18637	22619	51	be	be	VB
18637	22619	52	.	.	.
18637	22620	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22620	2	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	22620	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
18637	22620	4	on	on	IN
18637	22620	5	the	the	DT
18637	22620	6	basis	basis	NN
18637	22620	7	of	of	IN
18637	22620	8	the	the	DT
18637	22620	9	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
18637	22620	10	Case	Case	NNP
18637	22620	11	.	.	.
18637	22621	1	In	in	IN
18637	22621	2	Rutkin	Rutkin	NNP
18637	22621	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22621	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22621	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22621	6	United	United	NNP
18637	22621	7	States,[49	States,[49	NNP
18637	22621	8	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22621	9	decided	decide	VBD
18637	22621	10	in	in	IN
18637	22621	11	1952	1952	CD
18637	22621	12	,	,	,
18637	22621	13	a	a	DT
18637	22621	14	sharply	sharply	RB
18637	22621	15	divided	divide	VBN
18637	22621	16	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22621	17	cuts	cut	NNS
18637	22621	18	loose	loose	JJ
18637	22621	19	from	from	IN
18637	22621	20	the	the	DT
18637	22621	21	metaphysics	metaphysic	NNS
18637	22621	22	of	of	IN
18637	22621	23	the	the	DT
18637	22621	24	Wilcox	Wilcox	NNP
18637	22621	25	case	case	NN
18637	22621	26	and	and	CC
18637	22621	27	holds	hold	VBZ
18637	22621	28	that	that	IN
18637	22621	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22621	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	22621	31	the	the	DT
18637	22621	32	power	power	NN
18637	22621	33	under	under	IN
18637	22621	34	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22621	35	XVI	XVI	NNP
18637	22621	36	to	to	IN
18637	22621	37	tax	tax	NN
18637	22621	38	as	as	IN
18637	22621	39	income	income	NN
18637	22621	40	monies	monie	NNS
18637	22621	41	received	receive	VBN
18637	22621	42	by	by	IN
18637	22621	43	an	an	DT
18637	22621	44	extortioner	extortioner	NN
18637	22621	45	.	.	.
18637	22622	1	Notes	note	NNS
18637	22622	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22622	3	1	1	CD
18637	22622	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22622	5	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	22622	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22622	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22622	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22622	9	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	22622	10	'	'	POS
18637	22622	11	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	22622	12	&	&	CC
18637	22622	13	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	22622	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22622	15	,	,	,
18637	22622	16	157	157	CD
18637	22622	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22622	18	429	429	CD
18637	22622	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22622	20	1895	1895	CD
18637	22622	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22622	22	;	;	:
18637	22622	23	158	158	CD
18637	22622	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22622	25	601	601	CD
18637	22622	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22622	27	1895	1895	CD
18637	22622	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22622	29	.	.	.
18637	22623	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22623	2	2	2	CD
18637	22623	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22623	4	28	28	CD
18637	22623	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22623	6	.	.	.
18637	22624	1	509	509	CD
18637	22624	2	.	.	.
18637	22625	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22625	2	3	3	LS
18637	22625	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22625	4	The	the	DT
18637	22625	5	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22625	6	conceded	concede	VBD
18637	22625	7	that	that	IN
18637	22625	8	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	22625	9	on	on	IN
18637	22625	10	Incomes	income	NNS
18637	22625	11	from	from	IN
18637	22625	12	"	"	``
18637	22625	13	professions	profession	NNS
18637	22625	14	,	,	,
18637	22625	15	trades	trade	NNS
18637	22625	16	,	,	,
18637	22625	17	employments	employment	NNS
18637	22625	18	,	,	,
18637	22625	19	or	or	CC
18637	22625	20	vocations	vocation	NNS
18637	22625	21	"	"	``
18637	22625	22	levied	levy	VBN
18637	22625	23	by	by	IN
18637	22625	24	this	this	DT
18637	22625	25	act	act	NN
18637	22625	26	were	be	VBD
18637	22625	27	excise	excise	NN
18637	22625	28	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	22625	29	and	and	CC
18637	22625	30	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	22625	31	valid	valid	JJ
18637	22625	32	.	.	.
18637	22626	1	The	the	DT
18637	22626	2	entire	entire	JJ
18637	22626	3	statute	statute	NN
18637	22626	4	,	,	,
18637	22626	5	however	however	RB
18637	22626	6	,	,	,
18637	22626	7	was	be	VBD
18637	22626	8	voided	void	VBN
18637	22626	9	on	on	IN
18637	22626	10	the	the	DT
18637	22626	11	ground	ground	NN
18637	22626	12	that	that	IN
18637	22626	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22626	14	never	never	RB
18637	22626	15	intended	intend	VBD
18637	22626	16	to	to	TO
18637	22626	17	permit	permit	VB
18637	22626	18	the	the	DT
18637	22626	19	entire	entire	JJ
18637	22626	20	"	"	''
18637	22626	21	burden	burden	NN
18637	22626	22	of	of	IN
18637	22626	23	the	the	DT
18637	22626	24	tax	tax	NN
18637	22626	25	to	to	TO
18637	22626	26	be	be	VB
18637	22626	27	borne	bear	VBN
18637	22626	28	by	by	IN
18637	22626	29	professions	profession	NNS
18637	22626	30	,	,	,
18637	22626	31	trades	trade	NNS
18637	22626	32	,	,	,
18637	22626	33	employments	employment	NNS
18637	22626	34	,	,	,
18637	22626	35	or	or	CC
18637	22626	36	vocations	vocation	NNS
18637	22626	37	"	"	''
18637	22626	38	after	after	IN
18637	22626	39	real	real	JJ
18637	22626	40	estate	estate	NN
18637	22626	41	and	and	CC
18637	22626	42	personal	personal	JJ
18637	22626	43	property	property	NN
18637	22626	44	had	have	VBD
18637	22626	45	been	be	VBN
18637	22626	46	exempted	exempt	VBN
18637	22626	47	.	.	.
18637	22627	1	158	158	CD
18637	22627	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22627	3	601	601	CD
18637	22627	4	,	,	,
18637	22627	5	635	635	CD
18637	22627	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22627	7	1895	1895	CD
18637	22627	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22627	9	.	.	.
18637	22628	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22628	2	4	4	CD
18637	22628	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22628	4	Springer	Springer	NNP
18637	22628	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22628	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22628	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22628	8	United	United	NNP
18637	22628	9	States	States	NNP
18637	22628	10	,	,	,
18637	22628	11	102	102	CD
18637	22628	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22628	13	586	586	CD
18637	22628	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22628	15	1881	1881	CD
18637	22628	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22628	17	.	.	.
18637	22629	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22629	2	5	5	CD
18637	22629	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22629	4	13	13	CD
18637	22629	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22629	6	.	.	.
18637	22630	1	223	223	CD
18637	22630	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22630	3	1864	1864	CD
18637	22630	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22630	5	.	.	.
18637	22631	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22631	2	6	6	CD
18637	22631	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22631	4	For	for	IN
18637	22631	5	an	an	DT
18637	22631	6	account	account	NN
18637	22631	7	of	of	IN
18637	22631	8	the	the	DT
18637	22631	9	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	22631	10	decision	decision	NN
18637	22631	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22631	12	see	see	VBP
18637	22631	13	_	_	NNP
18637	22631	14	pp	pp	NNP
18637	22631	15	.	.	.
18637	22632	1	319	319	CD
18637	22632	2	-	-	SYM
18637	22632	3	320	320	CD
18637	22632	4	.	.	.
18637	22633	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22633	2	7	7	CD
18637	22633	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22633	4	173	173	CD
18637	22633	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22633	6	509	509	CD
18637	22633	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22633	8	1899	1899	CD
18637	22633	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22633	10	.	.	.
18637	22634	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22634	2	8	8	CD
18637	22634	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22634	4	178	178	CD
18637	22634	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22634	6	41	41	CD
18637	22634	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22634	8	1900	1900	CD
18637	22634	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22634	10	.	.	.
18637	22635	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22635	2	9	9	CD
18637	22635	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22635	4	184	184	CD
18637	22635	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22635	6	608	608	CD
18637	22635	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22635	8	1902	1902	CD
18637	22635	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22635	10	.	.	.
18637	22636	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22636	2	10	10	CD
18637	22636	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22636	4	Flint	Flint	NNP
18637	22636	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22636	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22636	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22636	8	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	22636	9	Tracy	Tracy	NNP
18637	22636	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22636	11	,	,	,
18637	22636	12	220	220	CD
18637	22636	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22636	14	107	107	CD
18637	22636	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22636	16	1911	1911	CD
18637	22636	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22636	18	.	.	.
18637	22637	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22637	2	11	11	CD
18637	22637	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22637	4	Brushaber	Brushaber	NNP
18637	22637	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22637	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22637	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22637	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	22637	9	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	22638	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22638	2	,	,	,
18637	22638	3	240	240	CD
18637	22638	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22638	5	1	1	CD
18637	22638	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22638	7	1916	1916	CD
18637	22638	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22638	9	;	;	:
18637	22638	10	Stanton	Stanton	NNP
18637	22638	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22638	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	22638	13	_	_	NNP
18637	22638	14	Baltic	Baltic	NNP
18637	22638	15	Min	Min	NNP
18637	22638	16	.	.	.
18637	22639	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22639	2	,	,	,
18637	22639	3	240	240	CD
18637	22639	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22639	5	103	103	CD
18637	22639	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22639	7	1916	1916	CD
18637	22639	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22639	9	;	;	:
18637	22639	10	Tyee	Tyee	NNP
18637	22639	11	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	22639	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22639	13	_	_	NNP
18637	22639	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	22639	15	_	_	NNP
18637	22639	16	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	22639	17	,	,	,
18637	22639	18	210	210	CD
18637	22639	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22639	20	115	115	CD
18637	22639	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22639	22	1916	1916	CD
18637	22639	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22639	24	.	.	.
18637	22640	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22640	2	12	12	CD
18637	22640	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22640	4	Brushaber	Brushaber	NNP
18637	22640	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22640	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22640	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22640	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	22640	9	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	22641	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22641	2	,	,	,
18637	22641	3	240	240	CD
18637	22641	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22641	5	1	1	CD
18637	22641	6	,	,	,
18637	22641	7	18	18	CD
18637	22641	8	-	-	SYM
18637	22641	9	19	19	CD
18637	22641	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22641	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	22641	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22641	13	.	.	.
18637	22642	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22642	2	13	13	CD
18637	22642	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22642	4	Stanton	Stanton	NNP
18637	22642	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22642	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22642	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22642	8	Baltic	Baltic	NNP
18637	22642	9	Min	Min	NNP
18637	22642	10	.	.	.
18637	22643	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22643	2	,	,	,
18637	22643	3	240	240	CD
18637	22643	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22643	5	103	103	CD
18637	22643	6	,	,	,
18637	22643	7	112	112	CD
18637	22643	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22643	9	1916	1916	CD
18637	22643	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22643	11	.	.	.
18637	22644	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22644	2	14	14	CD
18637	22644	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22644	4	Stratton	Stratton	NNP
18637	22644	5	's	's	POS
18637	22644	6	Independence	Independence	NNP
18637	22644	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22644	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22644	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22644	10	Howbert	Howbert	NNP
18637	22644	11	,	,	,
18637	22644	12	231	231	CD
18637	22644	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22644	14	399	399	CD
18637	22644	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22644	16	1914	1914	CD
18637	22644	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22644	18	;	;	:
18637	22644	19	Doyle	Doyle	NNP
18637	22644	20	_	_	NNP
18637	22644	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	22644	22	_	_	NNP
18637	22644	23	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	22644	24	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	22644	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22644	26	,	,	,
18637	22644	27	247	247	CD
18637	22644	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22644	29	179	179	CD
18637	22644	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22644	31	1918	1918	CD
18637	22644	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22644	33	.	.	.
18637	22645	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22645	2	15	15	CD
18637	22645	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22645	4	Eisner	Eisner	NNP
18637	22645	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22645	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22645	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22645	8	Macomber	Macomber	NNP
18637	22645	9	,	,	,
18637	22645	10	252	252	CD
18637	22645	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22645	12	189	189	CD
18637	22645	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22645	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	22645	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22645	16	;	;	:
18637	22645	17	Bowers	Bowers	NNP
18637	22645	18	_	_	NNP
18637	22645	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	22645	20	_	_	NNP
18637	22645	21	Kerbaugh	Kerbaugh	NNP
18637	22645	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	22645	23	Empire	Empire	NNP
18637	22645	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22645	25	,	,	,
18637	22645	26	271	271	CD
18637	22645	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22645	28	170	170	CD
18637	22645	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22645	30	1926	1926	CD
18637	22645	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22645	32	.	.	.
18637	22646	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22646	2	16	16	CD
18637	22646	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22646	4	247	247	CD
18637	22646	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22646	6	339	339	CD
18637	22646	7	,	,	,
18637	22646	8	344	344	CD
18637	22646	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22646	10	1918).--On	1918).--on	CD
18637	22646	11	the	the	DT
18637	22646	12	other	other	JJ
18637	22646	13	hand	hand	NN
18637	22646	14	,	,	,
18637	22646	15	in	in	IN
18637	22646	16	Lynch	Lynch	NNP
18637	22646	17	_	_	NNP
18637	22646	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	22646	19	_	_	NNP
18637	22646	20	Turrish	Turrish	NNP
18637	22646	21	,	,	,
18637	22646	22	247	247	CD
18637	22646	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22646	24	221	221	CD
18637	22646	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22646	26	1918	1918	CD
18637	22646	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22646	28	,	,	,
18637	22646	29	the	the	DT
18637	22646	30	single	single	JJ
18637	22646	31	and	and	CC
18637	22646	32	final	final	JJ
18637	22646	33	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22646	34	distributed	distribute	VBN
18637	22646	35	upon	upon	IN
18637	22646	36	liquidation	liquidation	NN
18637	22646	37	of	of	IN
18637	22646	38	the	the	DT
18637	22646	39	entire	entire	JJ
18637	22646	40	assets	asset	NNS
18637	22646	41	of	of	IN
18637	22646	42	a	a	DT
18637	22646	43	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22646	44	,	,	,
18637	22646	45	although	although	IN
18637	22646	46	equalling	equal	VBG
18637	22646	47	twice	twice	PDT
18637	22646	48	the	the	DT
18637	22646	49	par	par	NN
18637	22646	50	value	value	NN
18637	22646	51	of	of	IN
18637	22646	52	the	the	DT
18637	22646	53	capital	capital	NN
18637	22646	54	stock	stock	NN
18637	22646	55	,	,	,
18637	22646	56	was	be	VBD
18637	22646	57	declared	declare	VBN
18637	22646	58	to	to	TO
18637	22646	59	represent	represent	VB
18637	22646	60	only	only	RB
18637	22646	61	the	the	DT
18637	22646	62	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
18637	22646	63	value	value	NN
18637	22646	64	of	of	IN
18637	22646	65	the	the	DT
18637	22646	66	latter	latter	JJ
18637	22646	67	earned	earn	VBN
18637	22646	68	prior	prior	RB
18637	22646	69	to	to	IN
18637	22646	70	the	the	DT
18637	22646	71	effective	effective	JJ
18637	22646	72	date	date	NN
18637	22646	73	of	of	IN
18637	22646	74	the	the	DT
18637	22646	75	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22646	76	,	,	,
18637	22646	77	and	and	CC
18637	22646	78	hence	hence	RB
18637	22646	79	was	be	VBD
18637	22646	80	not	not	RB
18637	22646	81	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22646	82	as	as	IN
18637	22646	83	income	income	NN
18637	22646	84	to	to	IN
18637	22646	85	the	the	DT
18637	22646	86	shareholder	shareholder	NN
18637	22646	87	in	in	IN
18637	22646	88	the	the	DT
18637	22646	89	year	year	NN
18637	22646	90	in	in	IN
18637	22646	91	which	which	WDT
18637	22646	92	actually	actually	RB
18637	22646	93	received	receive	VBD
18637	22646	94	.	.	.
18637	22647	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	22647	2	,	,	,
18637	22647	3	in	in	IN
18637	22647	4	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	22647	5	P.	P.	NNP
18637	22647	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22647	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22647	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22647	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22647	10	Lowe	Lowe	NNP
18637	22647	11	,	,	,
18637	22647	12	247	247	CD
18637	22647	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22647	14	330	330	CD
18637	22647	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22647	16	1918	1918	CD
18637	22647	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22647	18	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	22647	19	paid	pay	VBN
18637	22647	20	out	out	IN
18637	22647	21	of	of	IN
18637	22647	22	surplus	surplus	JJ
18637	22647	23	accumulated	accumulate	VBN
18637	22647	24	before	before	IN
18637	22647	25	the	the	DT
18637	22647	26	effective	effective	JJ
18637	22647	27	date	date	NN
18637	22647	28	of	of	IN
18637	22647	29	the	the	DT
18637	22647	30	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22647	31	by	by	IN
18637	22647	32	a	a	DT
18637	22647	33	railway	railway	NN
18637	22647	34	company	company	NN
18637	22647	35	whose	whose	WP$
18637	22647	36	entire	entire	JJ
18637	22647	37	capital	capital	NN
18637	22647	38	stock	stock	NN
18637	22647	39	was	be	VBD
18637	22647	40	owned	own	VBN
18637	22647	41	by	by	IN
18637	22647	42	another	another	DT
18637	22647	43	railway	railway	NN
18637	22647	44	company	company	NN
18637	22647	45	and	and	CC
18637	22647	46	whose	whose	WP$
18637	22647	47	physical	physical	JJ
18637	22647	48	assets	asset	NNS
18637	22647	49	were	be	VBD
18637	22647	50	leased	lease	VBN
18637	22647	51	to	to	IN
18637	22647	52	and	and	CC
18637	22647	53	used	use	VBN
18637	22647	54	by	by	IN
18637	22647	55	the	the	DT
18637	22647	56	latter	latter	NN
18637	22647	57	was	be	VBD
18637	22647	58	declared	declare	VBN
18637	22647	59	to	to	TO
18637	22647	60	be	be	VB
18637	22647	61	a	a	DT
18637	22647	62	nontaxable	nontaxable	JJ
18637	22647	63	bookkeeping	bookkeepe	VBG
18637	22647	64	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	22647	65	between	between	IN
18637	22647	66	virtually	virtually	RB
18637	22647	67	identical	identical	JJ
18637	22647	68	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	22647	69	.	.	.
18637	22648	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22648	2	17	17	CD
18637	22648	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22648	4	247	247	CD
18637	22648	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22648	6	347	347	CD
18637	22648	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22648	8	1918	1918	CD
18637	22648	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22648	10	.	.	.
18637	22649	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22649	2	18	18	CD
18637	22649	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22649	4	252	252	CD
18637	22649	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22649	6	189	189	CD
18637	22649	7	,	,	,
18637	22649	8	206	206	CD
18637	22649	9	-	-	SYM
18637	22649	10	208	208	CD
18637	22649	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22649	12	1920	1920	CD
18637	22649	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22649	14	.	.	.
18637	22650	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22650	2	19	19	CD
18637	22650	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22650	4	Eisner	Eisner	NNP
18637	22650	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22650	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22650	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22650	8	Macomber	Macomber	NNP
18637	22650	9	,	,	,
18637	22650	10	252	252	CD
18637	22650	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22650	12	189	189	CD
18637	22650	13	,	,	,
18637	22650	14	207	207	CD
18637	22650	15	,	,	,
18637	22650	16	211	211	CD
18637	22650	17	-	-	SYM
18637	22650	18	212	212	CD
18637	22650	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22650	20	1920	1920	CD
18637	22650	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22650	22	.	.	.
18637	22651	1	This	this	DT
18637	22651	2	decision	decision	NN
18637	22651	3	has	have	VBZ
18637	22651	4	been	be	VBN
18637	22651	5	severely	severely	RB
18637	22651	6	criticized	criticize	VBN
18637	22651	7	,	,	,
18637	22651	8	chiefly	chiefly	RB
18637	22651	9	on	on	IN
18637	22651	10	the	the	DT
18637	22651	11	ground	ground	NN
18637	22651	12	that	that	IN
18637	22651	13	gains	gain	NNS
18637	22651	14	accruing	accrue	VBG
18637	22651	15	to	to	TO
18637	22651	16	capital	capital	VB
18637	22651	17	over	over	IN
18637	22651	18	a	a	DT
18637	22651	19	period	period	NN
18637	22651	20	of	of	IN
18637	22651	21	years	year	NNS
18637	22651	22	are	be	VBP
18637	22651	23	not	not	RB
18637	22651	24	income	income	NN
18637	22651	25	and	and	CC
18637	22651	26	are	be	VBP
18637	22651	27	not	not	RB
18637	22651	28	transformed	transform	VBN
18637	22651	29	into	into	IN
18637	22651	30	income	income	NN
18637	22651	31	by	by	IN
18637	22651	32	being	be	VBG
18637	22651	33	dissevered	dissever	VBN
18637	22651	34	from	from	IN
18637	22651	35	capital	capital	NN
18637	22651	36	through	through	IN
18637	22651	37	sale	sale	NN
18637	22651	38	or	or	CC
18637	22651	39	conversion	conversion	NN
18637	22651	40	.	.	.
18637	22652	1	Critics	critic	NNS
18637	22652	2	have	have	VBP
18637	22652	3	also	also	RB
18637	22652	4	experienced	experience	VBN
18637	22652	5	difficulty	difficulty	NN
18637	22652	6	in	in	IN
18637	22652	7	understanding	understand	VBG
18637	22652	8	how	how	WRB
18637	22652	9	a	a	DT
18637	22652	10	tax	tax	NN
18637	22652	11	on	on	IN
18637	22652	12	income	income	NN
18637	22652	13	which	which	WDT
18637	22652	14	has	have	VBZ
18637	22652	15	been	be	VBN
18637	22652	16	severed	sever	VBN
18637	22652	17	from	from	IN
18637	22652	18	capital	capital	NN
18637	22652	19	can	can	MD
18637	22652	20	continue	continue	VB
18637	22652	21	to	to	TO
18637	22652	22	be	be	VB
18637	22652	23	labeled	label	VBN
18637	22652	24	a	a	DT
18637	22652	25	"	"	``
18637	22652	26	direct	direct	JJ
18637	22652	27	"	"	''
18637	22652	28	tax	tax	NN
18637	22652	29	on	on	IN
18637	22652	30	the	the	DT
18637	22652	31	capital	capital	NN
18637	22652	32	from	from	IN
18637	22652	33	which	which	WDT
18637	22652	34	the	the	DT
18637	22652	35	severance	severance	NN
18637	22652	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	22652	37	thus	thus	RB
18637	22652	38	been	be	VBN
18637	22652	39	made	make	VBN
18637	22652	40	.	.	.
18637	22653	1	Finally	finally	RB
18637	22653	2	,	,	,
18637	22653	3	the	the	DT
18637	22653	4	contention	contention	NN
18637	22653	5	has	have	VBZ
18637	22653	6	been	be	VBN
18637	22653	7	made	make	VBN
18637	22653	8	that	that	IN
18637	22653	9	in	in	IN
18637	22653	10	stressing	stress	VBG
18637	22653	11	the	the	DT
18637	22653	12	separate	separate	JJ
18637	22653	13	identities	identity	NNS
18637	22653	14	of	of	IN
18637	22653	15	a	a	DT
18637	22653	16	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22653	17	and	and	CC
18637	22653	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22653	19	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	22653	20	,	,	,
18637	22653	21	the	the	DT
18637	22653	22	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22653	23	overlooked	overlook	VBD
18637	22653	24	the	the	DT
18637	22653	25	fact	fact	NN
18637	22653	26	that	that	IN
18637	22653	27	when	when	WRB
18637	22653	28	a	a	DT
18637	22653	29	surplus	surplus	NN
18637	22653	30	has	have	VBZ
18637	22653	31	been	be	VBN
18637	22653	32	accumulated	accumulate	VBN
18637	22653	33	,	,	,
18637	22653	34	the	the	DT
18637	22653	35	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	22653	36	are	be	VBP
18637	22653	37	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	22653	38	enriched	enrich	VBN
18637	22653	39	,	,	,
18637	22653	40	and	and	CC
18637	22653	41	that	that	IN
18637	22653	42	a	a	DT
18637	22653	43	stock	stock	NN
18637	22653	44	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	22653	45	may	may	MD
18637	22653	46	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	22653	47	be	be	VB
18637	22653	48	appropriately	appropriately	RB
18637	22653	49	viewed	view	VBN
18637	22653	50	simply	simply	RB
18637	22653	51	as	as	IN
18637	22653	52	a	a	DT
18637	22653	53	device	device	NN
18637	22653	54	whereby	whereby	WRB
18637	22653	55	the	the	DT
18637	22653	56	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22653	57	reinvests	reinvest	VBZ
18637	22653	58	money	money	NN
18637	22653	59	earned	earn	VBN
18637	22653	60	in	in	IN
18637	22653	61	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22653	62	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	22653	63	.	.	.
18637	22654	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22654	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22654	3	also	also	RB
18637	22654	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22654	5	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	22654	6	'	'	POS
18637	22654	7	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	22654	8	&	&	CC
18637	22654	9	T.	T.	NNP
18637	22654	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22654	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22654	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	22654	13	_	_	NNP
18637	22654	14	Smietanka	Smietanka	NNP
18637	22654	15	,	,	,
18637	22654	16	255	255	CD
18637	22654	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22654	18	509	509	CD
18637	22654	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22654	20	1921	1921	CD
18637	22654	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22654	22	.	.	.
18637	22655	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22655	2	20	20	CD
18637	22655	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22655	4	Reconsideration	reconsideration	NN
18637	22655	5	was	be	VBD
18637	22655	6	refused	refuse	VBN
18637	22655	7	in	in	IN
18637	22655	8	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	22655	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22655	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	22655	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22655	12	Griffiths	Griffiths	NNP
18637	22655	13	,	,	,
18637	22655	14	318	318	CD
18637	22655	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22655	16	371	371	CD
18637	22655	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22655	18	1943	1943	CD
18637	22655	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22655	20	.	.	.
18637	22656	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22656	2	21	21	CD
18637	22656	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22656	4	United	United	NNP
18637	22656	5	States	States	NNP
18637	22656	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22656	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22656	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22656	9	Phellis	Phellis	NNP
18637	22656	10	,	,	,
18637	22656	11	257	257	CD
18637	22656	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22656	13	156	156	CD
18637	22656	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22656	15	1921	1921	CD
18637	22656	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22656	17	;	;	:
18637	22656	18	Rockefeller	Rockefeller	NNP
18637	22656	19	_	_	NNP
18637	22656	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	22656	21	_	_	NNP
18637	22656	22	United	United	NNP
18637	22656	23	States	States	NNP
18637	22656	24	,	,	,
18637	22656	25	257	257	CD
18637	22656	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22656	27	176	176	CD
18637	22656	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22656	29	1921	1921	CD
18637	22656	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22656	31	.	.	.
18637	22657	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22657	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22657	3	also	also	RB
18637	22657	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22657	5	Cullinan	Cullinan	NNP
18637	22657	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22657	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22657	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22657	9	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	22657	10	,	,	,
18637	22657	11	262	262	CD
18637	22657	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22657	13	134	134	CD
18637	22657	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22657	15	1923	1923	CD
18637	22657	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22657	17	.	.	.
18637	22658	1	In	in	IN
18637	22658	2	Marr	Marr	NNP
18637	22658	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22658	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22658	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22658	6	United	United	NNP
18637	22658	7	States	States	NNP
18637	22658	8	,	,	,
18637	22658	9	268	268	CD
18637	22658	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22658	11	536	536	CD
18637	22658	12	,	,	,
18637	22658	13	540	540	CD
18637	22658	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	22658	15	541	541	CD
18637	22658	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22658	17	1925	1925	CD
18637	22658	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22658	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22658	20	was	be	VBD
18637	22658	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	22658	22	that	that	IN
18637	22658	23	the	the	DT
18637	22658	24	increased	increase	VBN
18637	22658	25	market	market	NN
18637	22658	26	value	value	NN
18637	22658	27	of	of	IN
18637	22658	28	stock	stock	NN
18637	22658	29	issued	issue	VBN
18637	22658	30	by	by	IN
18637	22658	31	a	a	DT
18637	22658	32	new	new	JJ
18637	22658	33	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22658	34	in	in	IN
18637	22658	35	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	22658	36	for	for	IN
18637	22658	37	stock	stock	NN
18637	22658	38	of	of	IN
18637	22658	39	an	an	DT
18637	22658	40	older	old	JJR
18637	22658	41	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22658	42	,	,	,
18637	22658	43	the	the	DT
18637	22658	44	assets	asset	NNS
18637	22658	45	of	of	IN
18637	22658	46	which	which	WDT
18637	22658	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22658	48	was	be	VBD
18637	22658	49	organized	organize	VBN
18637	22658	50	to	to	TO
18637	22658	51	absorb	absorb	VB
18637	22658	52	,	,	,
18637	22658	53	was	be	VBD
18637	22658	54	subject	subject	JJ
18637	22658	55	to	to	IN
18637	22658	56	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	22658	57	as	as	IN
18637	22658	58	income	income	NN
18637	22658	59	to	to	IN
18637	22658	60	the	the	DT
18637	22658	61	holder	holder	NN
18637	22658	62	,	,	,
18637	22658	63	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	22658	64	that	that	IN
18637	22658	65	the	the	DT
18637	22658	66	income	income	NN
18637	22658	67	represented	represent	VBD
18637	22658	68	profits	profit	NNS
18637	22658	69	of	of	IN
18637	22658	70	the	the	DT
18637	22658	71	older	old	JJR
18637	22658	72	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22658	73	and	and	CC
18637	22658	74	that	that	IN
18637	22658	75	the	the	DT
18637	22658	76	capital	capital	NN
18637	22658	77	remained	remain	VBD
18637	22658	78	invested	invest	VBN
18637	22658	79	in	in	IN
18637	22658	80	the	the	DT
18637	22658	81	same	same	JJ
18637	22658	82	general	general	JJ
18637	22658	83	enterprise	enterprise	NN
18637	22658	84	.	.	.
18637	22659	1	Weiss	Weiss	NNP
18637	22659	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22659	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22659	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22659	5	Stearn	Stearn	NNP
18637	22659	6	,	,	,
18637	22659	7	265	265	CD
18637	22659	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22659	9	242	242	CD
18637	22659	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22659	11	1924	1924	CD
18637	22659	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22659	13	,	,	,
18637	22659	14	in	in	IN
18637	22659	15	which	which	WDT
18637	22659	16	the	the	DT
18637	22659	17	additional	additional	JJ
18637	22659	18	value	value	NN
18637	22659	19	in	in	IN
18637	22659	20	new	new	JJ
18637	22659	21	securities	security	NNS
18637	22659	22	was	be	VBD
18637	22659	23	held	hold	VBN
18637	22659	24	not	not	RB
18637	22659	25	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22659	26	,	,	,
18637	22659	27	was	be	VBD
18637	22659	28	likened	liken	VBN
18637	22659	29	to	to	IN
18637	22659	30	Eisner	Eisner	NNP
18637	22659	31	_	_	NNP
18637	22659	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	22659	33	_	_	NNP
18637	22659	34	Macomber	Macomber	NNP
18637	22659	35	,	,	,
18637	22659	36	and	and	CC
18637	22659	37	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	22659	38	from	from	IN
18637	22659	39	the	the	DT
18637	22659	40	aforementioned	aforementioned	JJ
18637	22659	41	cases	case	NNS
18637	22659	42	on	on	IN
18637	22659	43	the	the	DT
18637	22659	44	ground	ground	NN
18637	22659	45	of	of	IN
18637	22659	46	preservation	preservation	NN
18637	22659	47	of	of	IN
18637	22659	48	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	22659	49	identity	identity	NN
18637	22659	50	.	.	.
18637	22660	1	Although	although	IN
18637	22660	2	the	the	DT
18637	22660	3	"	"	``
18637	22660	4	new	new	JJ
18637	22660	5	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22660	6	had	have	VBD
18637	22660	7	*	*	NFP
18637	22660	8	*	*	NFP
18637	22660	9	*	*	NFP
18637	22660	10	been	be	VBN
18637	22660	11	organized	organize	VBN
18637	22660	12	to	to	TO
18637	22660	13	take	take	VB
18637	22660	14	over	over	RP
18637	22660	15	the	the	DT
18637	22660	16	assets	asset	NNS
18637	22660	17	and	and	CC
18637	22660	18	business	business	NN
18637	22660	19	of	of	IN
18637	22660	20	the	the	DT
18637	22660	21	old	old	JJ
18637	22660	22	*	*	NFP
18637	22660	23	*	*	NFP
18637	22660	24	*	*	NFP
18637	22660	25	,	,	,
18637	22660	26	the	the	DT
18637	22660	27	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	22660	28	identity	identity	NN
18637	22660	29	was	be	VBD
18637	22660	30	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	22660	31	to	to	TO
18637	22660	32	have	have	VB
18637	22660	33	been	be	VBN
18637	22660	34	substantially	substantially	RB
18637	22660	35	maintained	maintain	VBN
18637	22660	36	because	because	IN
18637	22660	37	the	the	DT
18637	22660	38	new	new	JJ
18637	22660	39	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22660	40	was	be	VBD
18637	22660	41	organized	organize	VBN
18637	22660	42	under	under	IN
18637	22660	43	the	the	DT
18637	22660	44	laws	law	NNS
18637	22660	45	of	of	IN
18637	22660	46	the	the	DT
18637	22660	47	same	same	JJ
18637	22660	48	State	state	NN
18637	22660	49	with	with	IN
18637	22660	50	presumably	presumably	RB
18637	22660	51	the	the	DT
18637	22660	52	same	same	JJ
18637	22660	53	powers	power	NNS
18637	22660	54	as	as	IN
18637	22660	55	the	the	DT
18637	22660	56	old	old	JJ
18637	22660	57	.	.	.
18637	22661	1	There	there	EX
18637	22661	2	was	be	VBD
18637	22661	3	also	also	RB
18637	22661	4	no	no	DT
18637	22661	5	change	change	NN
18637	22661	6	in	in	IN
18637	22661	7	the	the	DT
18637	22661	8	character	character	NN
18637	22661	9	of	of	IN
18637	22661	10	the	the	DT
18637	22661	11	securities	security	NNS
18637	22661	12	issued	issue	VBN
18637	22661	13	,	,	,
18637	22661	14	"	"	``
18637	22661	15	with	with	IN
18637	22661	16	the	the	DT
18637	22661	17	result	result	NN
18637	22661	18	that	that	IN
18637	22661	19	"	"	``
18637	22661	20	the	the	DT
18637	22661	21	proportional	proportional	JJ
18637	22661	22	interest	interest	NN
18637	22661	23	of	of	IN
18637	22661	24	the	the	DT
18637	22661	25	stockholder	stockholder	NN
18637	22661	26	after	after	IN
18637	22661	27	the	the	DT
18637	22661	28	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	22661	29	of	of	IN
18637	22661	30	the	the	DT
18637	22661	31	new	new	JJ
18637	22661	32	securities	security	NNS
18637	22661	33	was	be	VBD
18637	22661	34	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	22661	35	to	to	TO
18637	22661	36	be	be	VB
18637	22661	37	exactly	exactly	RB
18637	22661	38	the	the	DT
18637	22661	39	same	same	JJ
18637	22661	40	.	.	.
18637	22661	41	"	"	''
18637	22662	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22662	2	22	22	CD
18637	22662	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22662	4	Miles	Miles	NNP
18637	22662	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22662	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22662	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22662	8	Safe	Safe	NNP
18637	22662	9	Deposit	Deposit	NNP
18637	22662	10	&	&	CC
18637	22662	11	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	22662	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22662	13	,	,	,
18637	22662	14	259	259	CD
18637	22662	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22662	16	247	247	CD
18637	22662	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22662	18	1922	1922	CD
18637	22662	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22662	20	.	.	.
18637	22663	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22663	2	23	23	CD
18637	22663	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22663	4	Koshland	Koshland	NNP
18637	22663	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22663	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22663	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22663	8	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	22663	9	,	,	,
18637	22663	10	298	298	CD
18637	22663	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22663	12	441	441	CD
18637	22663	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22663	14	1936	1936	CD
18637	22663	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22663	16	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22663	17	24	24	CD
18637	22663	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22663	19	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	22663	20	_	_	NNP
18637	22663	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	22663	22	_	_	NNP
18637	22663	23	Gowran	Gowran	NNP
18637	22663	24	,	,	,
18637	22663	25	302	302	CD
18637	22663	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22663	27	238	238	CD
18637	22663	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22663	29	1937	1937	CD
18637	22663	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22663	31	.	.	.
18637	22664	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22664	2	25	25	CD
18637	22664	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22664	4	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	22664	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22664	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22664	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22664	8	National	National	NNP
18637	22664	9	Grocery	Grocery	NNP
18637	22664	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22664	11	,	,	,
18637	22664	12	304	304	CD
18637	22664	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22664	14	282	282	CD
18637	22664	15	,	,	,
18637	22664	16	288	288	CD
18637	22664	17	-	-	SYM
18637	22664	18	289	289	CD
18637	22664	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22664	20	1938	1938	CD
18637	22664	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22664	22	.	.	.
18637	22665	1	In	in	IN
18637	22665	2	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	22665	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22665	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22665	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22665	6	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	22665	7	,	,	,
18637	22665	8	303	303	CD
18637	22665	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22665	10	391	391	CD
18637	22665	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22665	12	1938	1938	CD
18637	22665	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22665	14	the	the	DT
18637	22665	15	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	22665	16	contended	contend	VBD
18637	22665	17	the	the	DT
18637	22665	18	collection	collection	NN
18637	22665	19	of	of	IN
18637	22665	20	50	50	CD
18637	22665	21	%	%	NN
18637	22665	22	of	of	IN
18637	22665	23	any	any	DT
18637	22665	24	deficiency	deficiency	NN
18637	22665	25	in	in	IN
18637	22665	26	addition	addition	NN
18637	22665	27	to	to	IN
18637	22665	28	the	the	DT
18637	22665	29	deficiency	deficiency	NN
18637	22665	30	alleged	allege	VBN
18637	22665	31	to	to	TO
18637	22665	32	have	have	VB
18637	22665	33	resulted	result	VBN
18637	22665	34	from	from	IN
18637	22665	35	a	a	DT
18637	22665	36	fraudulent	fraudulent	JJ
18637	22665	37	intent	intent	NN
18637	22665	38	to	to	TO
18637	22665	39	evade	evade	VB
18637	22665	40	the	the	DT
18637	22665	41	income	income	NN
18637	22665	42	tax	tax	NN
18637	22665	43	amounted	amount	VBD
18637	22665	44	to	to	IN
18637	22665	45	the	the	DT
18637	22665	46	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	22665	47	of	of	IN
18637	22665	48	a	a	DT
18637	22665	49	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	22665	50	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	22665	51	.	.	.
18637	22666	1	The	the	DT
18637	22666	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22666	3	,	,	,
18637	22666	4	however	however	RB
18637	22666	5	,	,	,
18637	22666	6	described	describe	VBD
18637	22666	7	the	the	DT
18637	22666	8	additional	additional	JJ
18637	22666	9	sum	sum	NN
18637	22666	10	as	as	IN
18637	22666	11	a	a	DT
18637	22666	12	civil	civil	NN
18637	22666	13	and	and	CC
18637	22666	14	not	not	RB
18637	22666	15	a	a	DT
18637	22666	16	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	22666	17	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	22666	18	,	,	,
18637	22666	19	and	and	CC
18637	22666	20	one	one	CD
18637	22666	21	which	which	WDT
18637	22666	22	could	could	MD
18637	22666	23	be	be	VB
18637	22666	24	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	22666	25	employed	employ	VBN
18637	22666	26	to	to	TO
18637	22666	27	safeguard	safeguard	VB
18637	22666	28	the	the	DT
18637	22666	29	Government	Government	NNP
18637	22666	30	against	against	IN
18637	22666	31	loss	loss	NN
18637	22666	32	of	of	IN
18637	22666	33	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	22666	34	.	.	.
18637	22667	1	In	in	IN
18637	22667	2	contrast	contrast	NN
18637	22667	3	,	,	,
18637	22667	4	the	the	DT
18637	22667	5	exaction	exaction	NN
18637	22667	6	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	22667	7	in	in	IN
18637	22667	8	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	22667	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22667	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	22667	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22667	12	National	National	NNP
18637	22667	13	Grocery	Grocery	NNP
18637	22667	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22667	15	,	,	,
18637	22667	16	though	though	IN
18637	22667	17	conceded	concede	VBN
18637	22667	18	to	to	TO
18637	22667	19	possess	possess	VB
18637	22667	20	the	the	DT
18637	22667	21	attributes	attribute	NNS
18637	22667	22	of	of	IN
18637	22667	23	a	a	DT
18637	22667	24	civil	civil	JJ
18637	22667	25	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	22667	26	,	,	,
18637	22667	27	was	be	VBD
18637	22667	28	declared	declare	VBN
18637	22667	29	to	to	TO
18637	22667	30	be	be	VB
18637	22667	31	sustainable	sustainable	JJ
18637	22667	32	as	as	IN
18637	22667	33	a	a	DT
18637	22667	34	tax	tax	NN
18637	22667	35	.	.	.
18637	22668	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22668	2	26	26	CD
18637	22668	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22668	4	311	311	CD
18637	22668	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22668	6	46	46	CD
18637	22668	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22668	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	22668	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22668	10	.	.	.
18637	22669	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22669	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22669	3	also	also	RB
18637	22669	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22669	5	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	22669	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	22669	7	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	22669	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22669	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22669	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	22669	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22669	12	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	22669	13	,	,	,
18637	22669	14	311	311	CD
18637	22669	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22669	16	54	54	CD
18637	22669	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22669	18	1940	1940	CD
18637	22669	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22669	20	.	.	.
18637	22670	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22670	2	27	27	CD
18637	22670	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22670	4	311	311	CD
18637	22670	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22670	6	46	46	CD
18637	22670	7	,	,	,
18637	22670	8	53	53	CD
18637	22670	9	.	.	.
18637	22671	1	Another	another	DT
18637	22671	2	provision	provision	NN
18637	22671	3	of	of	IN
18637	22671	4	the	the	DT
18637	22671	5	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	22671	6	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22671	7	,	,	,
18637	22671	8	requiring	require	VBG
18637	22671	9	undistributed	undistributed	JJ
18637	22671	10	net	net	JJ
18637	22671	11	income	income	NN
18637	22671	12	of	of	IN
18637	22671	13	a	a	DT
18637	22671	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	22671	15	personal	personal	JJ
18637	22671	16	holding	hold	VBG
18637	22671	17	company	company	NN
18637	22671	18	to	to	TO
18637	22671	19	be	be	VB
18637	22671	20	included	include	VBN
18637	22671	21	in	in	IN
18637	22671	22	the	the	DT
18637	22671	23	gross	gross	JJ
18637	22671	24	income	income	NN
18637	22671	25	of	of	IN
18637	22671	26	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	22671	27	or	or	CC
18637	22671	28	residents	resident	NNS
18637	22671	29	who	who	WP
18637	22671	30	are	be	VBP
18637	22671	31	shareholders	shareholder	NNS
18637	22671	32	in	in	IN
18637	22671	33	such	such	JJ
18637	22671	34	company	company	NN
18637	22671	35	,	,	,
18637	22671	36	was	be	VBD
18637	22671	37	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	22671	38	as	as	IN
18637	22671	39	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	22671	40	in	in	IN
18637	22671	41	Rodney	Rodney	NNP
18637	22671	42	_	_	NNP
18637	22671	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	22671	44	_	_	NNP
18637	22671	45	Hoey	Hoey	NNP
18637	22671	46	,	,	,
18637	22671	47	53	53	CD
18637	22671	48	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22671	49	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	22671	50	.	.	.
18637	22672	1	604	604	CD
18637	22672	2	,	,	,
18637	22672	3	607	607	CD
18637	22672	4	-	-	SYM
18637	22672	5	608	608	CD
18637	22672	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22672	7	1944	1944	CD
18637	22672	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22672	9	.	.	.
18637	22673	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22673	2	28	28	CD
18637	22673	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22673	4	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	22673	5	Union	Union	NNP
18637	22673	6	Co	Co	NNP
18637	22673	7	-	-	NNP
18637	22673	8	op	op	NNP
18637	22673	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22673	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22673	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	22673	12	_	_	NNP
18637	22673	13	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	22673	14	of	of	IN
18637	22673	15	Int	Int	NNP
18637	22673	16	.	.	.
18637	22674	1	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	22674	2	,	,	,
18637	22674	3	90	90	CD
18637	22674	4	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22674	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22674	6	2d	2d	NN
18637	22674	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22674	8	488	488	CD
18637	22674	9	,	,	,
18637	22674	10	491	491	CD
18637	22674	11	,	,	,
18637	22674	12	492	492	CD
18637	22674	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22674	14	1937	1937	CD
18637	22674	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22674	16	.	.	.
18637	22675	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22675	2	29	29	CD
18637	22675	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22675	4	Burk	Burk	NNP
18637	22675	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	22675	6	Waggoner	Waggoner	NNP
18637	22675	7	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	22675	8	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	22675	9	.	.	.
18637	22676	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22676	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	22676	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22676	4	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	22676	5	,	,	,
18637	22676	6	269	269	CD
18637	22676	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22676	8	110	110	CD
18637	22676	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22676	10	1925	1925	CD
18637	22676	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22676	12	.	.	.
18637	22677	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22677	2	30	30	CD
18637	22677	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22677	4	268	268	CD
18637	22677	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22677	6	628	628	CD
18637	22677	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22677	8	1925	1925	CD
18637	22677	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22677	10	.	.	.
18637	22678	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22678	2	31	31	CD
18637	22678	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22678	4	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	22678	5	&	&	CC
18637	22678	6	P.	P.	NNP
18637	22678	7	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	22678	8	.	.	.
18637	22679	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22679	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22679	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22679	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22679	5	United	United	NNP
18637	22679	6	States	States	NNP
18637	22679	7	,	,	,
18637	22679	8	286	286	CD
18637	22679	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22679	10	285	285	CD
18637	22679	11	,	,	,
18637	22679	12	289	289	CD
18637	22679	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22679	14	1932	1932	CD
18637	22679	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22679	16	;	;	:
18637	22679	17	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	22679	18	Tie	Tie	NNP
18637	22679	19	&	&	CC
18637	22679	20	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	22679	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22679	22	_	_	NNP
18637	22679	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	22679	24	_	_	NNP
18637	22679	25	United	United	NNP
18637	22679	26	States	States	NNP
18637	22679	27	,	,	,
18637	22679	28	286	286	CD
18637	22679	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22679	30	290	290	CD
18637	22679	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22679	32	1932	1932	CD
18637	22679	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22679	34	.	.	.
18637	22680	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22680	2	32	32	CD
18637	22680	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22680	4	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	22680	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22680	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22680	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22680	8	Bruun	Bruun	NNP
18637	22680	9	,	,	,
18637	22680	10	309	309	CD
18637	22680	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22680	12	461	461	CD
18637	22680	13	,	,	,
18637	22680	14	468	468	CD
18637	22680	15	-	-	SYM
18637	22680	16	469	469	CD
18637	22680	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22680	18	1940	1940	CD
18637	22680	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22680	20	.	.	.
18637	22681	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22681	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22681	3	also	also	RB
18637	22681	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22681	5	Hewitt	Hewitt	NNP
18637	22681	6	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	22681	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22681	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22681	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22681	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22681	11	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	22681	12	of	of	IN
18637	22681	13	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	22681	14	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	22681	15	,	,	,
18637	22681	16	76	76	CD
18637	22681	17	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22681	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22681	19	2d	2d	NN
18637	22681	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22681	21	880	880	CD
18637	22681	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22681	23	1935	1935	CD
18637	22681	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22681	25	.	.	.
18637	22682	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22682	2	33	33	CD
18637	22682	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22682	4	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	22682	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22682	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22682	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22682	8	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	22682	9	,	,	,
18637	22682	10	331	331	CD
18637	22682	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22682	12	1	1	CD
18637	22682	13	,	,	,
18637	22682	14	15	15	CD
18637	22682	15	-	-	SYM
18637	22682	16	16	16	CD
18637	22682	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22682	18	1947	1947	CD
18637	22682	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22682	20	.	.	.
18637	22683	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22683	2	34	34	CD
18637	22683	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22683	4	The	the	DT
18637	22683	5	donor	donor	NN
18637	22683	6	could	could	MD
18637	22683	7	not	not	RB
18637	22683	8	,	,	,
18637	22683	9	"	"	''
18637	22683	10	by	by	IN
18637	22683	11	mere	mere	JJ
18637	22683	12	gift	gift	NN
18637	22683	13	,	,	,
18637	22683	14	enable	enable	VB
18637	22683	15	another	another	DT
18637	22683	16	to	to	TO
18637	22683	17	hold	hold	VB
18637	22683	18	this	this	DT
18637	22683	19	stock	stock	NN
18637	22683	20	free	free	JJ
18637	22683	21	from	from	IN
18637	22683	22	*	*	NFP
18637	22683	23	*	*	NFP
18637	22683	24	*	*	NFP
18637	22683	25	the	the	DT
18637	22683	26	right	right	NN
18637	22683	27	of	of	IN
18637	22683	28	the	the	DT
18637	22683	29	sovereign	sovereign	NN
18637	22683	30	to	to	TO
18637	22683	31	take	take	VB
18637	22683	32	part	part	NN
18637	22683	33	of	of	IN
18637	22683	34	any	any	DT
18637	22683	35	increase	increase	NN
18637	22683	36	in	in	IN
18637	22683	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22683	38	value	value	NN
18637	22683	39	when	when	WRB
18637	22683	40	separated	separate	VBN
18637	22683	41	through	through	IN
18637	22683	42	sale	sale	NN
18637	22683	43	or	or	CC
18637	22683	44	conversion	conversion	NN
18637	22683	45	and	and	CC
18637	22683	46	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	22683	47	to	to	IN
18637	22683	48	possession	possession	NN
18637	22683	49	.	.	.
18637	22683	50	"	"	''
18637	22684	1	--Taft	--Taft	NNP
18637	22684	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22684	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22684	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22684	5	Bowers	Bowers	NNP
18637	22684	6	,	,	,
18637	22684	7	278	278	CD
18637	22684	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22684	9	470	470	CD
18637	22684	10	,	,	,
18637	22684	11	482	482	CD
18637	22684	12	,	,	,
18637	22684	13	484	484	CD
18637	22684	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22684	15	1929	1929	CD
18637	22684	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22684	17	.	.	.
18637	22685	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22685	2	35	35	CD
18637	22685	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22685	4	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	22685	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22685	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22685	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22685	8	Horst	Horst	NNP
18637	22685	9	,	,	,
18637	22685	10	311	311	CD
18637	22685	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22685	12	112	112	CD
18637	22685	13	,	,	,
18637	22685	14	115	115	CD
18637	22685	15	-	-	SYM
18637	22685	16	116	116	CD
18637	22685	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22685	18	1940	1940	CD
18637	22685	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22685	20	.	.	.
18637	22686	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22686	2	36	36	CD
18637	22686	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22686	4	Bowers	Bowers	NNP
18637	22686	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22686	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22686	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22686	8	Kerbaugh	Kerbaugh	NNP
18637	22686	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	22686	10	Empire	Empire	NNP
18637	22686	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22686	12	,	,	,
18637	22686	13	271	271	CD
18637	22686	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22686	15	170	170	CD
18637	22686	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22686	17	1926	1926	CD
18637	22686	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22686	19	.	.	.
18637	22687	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22687	2	37	37	CD
18637	22687	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22687	4	Goodrich	Goodrich	NNP
18637	22687	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22687	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22687	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22687	8	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	22687	9	,	,	,
18637	22687	10	255	255	CD
18637	22687	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22687	12	527	527	CD
18637	22687	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22687	14	1921	1921	CD
18637	22687	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22687	16	.	.	.
18637	22688	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22688	2	38	38	CD
18637	22688	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22688	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	22688	5	.	.	.
18637	22689	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22689	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22689	3	also	also	RB
18637	22689	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22689	5	Walsh	Walsh	NNP
18637	22689	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22689	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22689	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22689	9	Brewster	Brewster	NNP
18637	22689	10	,	,	,
18637	22689	11	255	255	CD
18637	22689	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22689	13	536	536	CD
18637	22689	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22689	15	1921	1921	CD
18637	22689	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22689	17	.	.	.
18637	22690	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22690	2	39	39	CD
18637	22690	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22690	4	Lucas	Lucas	NNP
18637	22690	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22690	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22690	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22690	8	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	22690	9	,	,	,
18637	22690	10	279	279	CD
18637	22690	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22690	12	573	573	CD
18637	22690	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22690	14	1929	1929	CD
18637	22690	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22690	16	.	.	.
18637	22691	1	However	however	RB
18637	22691	2	,	,	,
18637	22691	3	a	a	DT
18637	22691	4	litigant	litigant	NN
18637	22691	5	who	who	WP
18637	22691	6	,	,	,
18637	22691	7	in	in	IN
18637	22691	8	1915	1915	CD
18637	22691	9	,	,	,
18637	22691	10	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	22691	11	to	to	IN
18637	22691	12	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	22691	13	,	,	,
18637	22691	14	a	a	DT
18637	22691	15	suit	suit	NN
18637	22691	16	pending	pende	VBG
18637	22691	17	on	on	IN
18637	22691	18	February	February	NNP
18637	22691	19	26	26	CD
18637	22691	20	,	,	,
18637	22691	21	1913	1913	CD
18637	22691	22	for	for	IN
18637	22691	23	an	an	DT
18637	22691	24	accounting	accounting	NN
18637	22691	25	under	under	IN
18637	22691	26	a	a	DT
18637	22691	27	patent	patent	NN
18637	22691	28	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	22691	29	,	,	,
18637	22691	30	was	be	VBD
18637	22691	31	unable	unable	JJ
18637	22691	32	to	to	TO
18637	22691	33	have	have	VB
18637	22691	34	treated	treat	VBN
18637	22691	35	as	as	IN
18637	22691	36	capital	capital	NN
18637	22691	37	,	,	,
18637	22691	38	and	and	CC
18637	22691	39	excluded	exclude	VBN
18637	22691	40	from	from	IN
18637	22691	41	the	the	DT
18637	22691	42	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22691	43	income	income	NN
18637	22691	44	produced	produce	VBN
18637	22691	45	by	by	IN
18637	22691	46	such	such	JJ
18637	22691	47	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	22691	48	,	,	,
18637	22691	49	that	that	DT
18637	22691	50	portion	portion	NN
18637	22691	51	of	of	IN
18637	22691	52	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22691	53	claim	claim	NN
18637	22691	54	which	which	WDT
18637	22691	55	had	have	VBD
18637	22691	56	accrued	accrue	VBN
18637	22691	57	prior	prior	RB
18637	22691	58	to	to	IN
18637	22691	59	March	March	NNP
18637	22691	60	1	1	CD
18637	22691	61	,	,	,
18637	22691	62	1913	1913	CD
18637	22691	63	.	.	.
18637	22692	1	Income	income	NN
18637	22692	2	within	within	IN
18637	22692	3	the	the	DT
18637	22692	4	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	22692	5	of	of	IN
18637	22692	6	the	the	DT
18637	22692	7	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22692	8	was	be	VBD
18637	22692	9	interpreted	interpret	VBN
18637	22692	10	to	to	TO
18637	22692	11	be	be	VB
18637	22692	12	the	the	DT
18637	22692	13	fruit	fruit	NN
18637	22692	14	that	that	WDT
18637	22692	15	is	be	VBZ
18637	22692	16	born	bear	VBN
18637	22692	17	of	of	IN
18637	22692	18	capital	capital	NN
18637	22692	19	,	,	,
18637	22692	20	not	not	RB
18637	22692	21	the	the	DT
18637	22692	22	potency	potency	NN
18637	22692	23	of	of	IN
18637	22692	24	fruition	fruition	NN
18637	22692	25	.	.	.
18637	22693	1	All	all	DT
18637	22693	2	that	that	WDT
18637	22693	3	the	the	DT
18637	22693	4	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	22693	5	possessed	possess	VBD
18637	22693	6	in	in	IN
18637	22693	7	1913	1913	CD
18637	22693	8	was	be	VBD
18637	22693	9	a	a	DT
18637	22693	10	contingent	contingent	NN
18637	22693	11	chose	choose	VBD
18637	22693	12	in	in	IN
18637	22693	13	action	action	NN
18637	22693	14	which	which	WDT
18637	22693	15	was	be	VBD
18637	22693	16	inchoate	inchoate	JJ
18637	22693	17	,	,	,
18637	22693	18	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
18637	22693	19	,	,	,
18637	22693	20	and	and	CC
18637	22693	21	contested.--United	contested.--United	NNP
18637	22693	22	States	States	NNP
18637	22693	23	_	_	NNP
18637	22693	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	22693	25	_	_	NNP
18637	22693	26	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	22693	27	Car	Car	NNP
18637	22693	28	Heating	Heating	NNP
18637	22693	29	&	&	CC
18637	22693	30	L.	L.	NNP
18637	22693	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22693	32	,	,	,
18637	22693	33	297	297	CD
18637	22693	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22693	35	88	88	CD
18637	22693	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22693	37	1936	1936	CD
18637	22693	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22693	39	.	.	.
18637	22694	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
18637	22694	2	,	,	,
18637	22694	3	purchasers	purchaser	NNS
18637	22694	4	of	of	IN
18637	22694	5	coal	coal	NN
18637	22694	6	lands	land	NNS
18637	22694	7	subject	subject	JJ
18637	22694	8	to	to	IN
18637	22694	9	mining	mining	NN
18637	22694	10	leases	lease	NNS
18637	22694	11	executed	execute	VBN
18637	22694	12	before	before	IN
18637	22694	13	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	22694	14	of	of	IN
18637	22694	15	the	the	DT
18637	22694	16	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22694	17	could	could	MD
18637	22694	18	not	not	RB
18637	22694	19	successfully	successfully	RB
18637	22694	20	contend	contend	VB
18637	22694	21	that	that	IN
18637	22694	22	royalties	royalty	NNS
18637	22694	23	received	receive	VBD
18637	22694	24	during	during	IN
18637	22694	25	1920	1920	CD
18637	22694	26	-	-	SYM
18637	22694	27	1926	1926	CD
18637	22694	28	were	be	VBD
18637	22694	29	payments	payment	NNS
18637	22694	30	for	for	IN
18637	22694	31	capital	capital	NN
18637	22694	32	assets	asset	NNS
18637	22694	33	sold	sell	VBN
18637	22694	34	before	before	IN
18637	22694	35	March	March	NNP
18637	22694	36	1	1	CD
18637	22694	37	,	,	,
18637	22694	38	1913	1913	CD
18637	22694	39	,	,	,
18637	22694	40	and	and	CC
18637	22694	41	hence	hence	RB
18637	22694	42	not	not	RB
18637	22694	43	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22694	44	.	.	.
18637	22695	1	Such	such	PDT
18637	22695	2	an	an	DT
18637	22695	3	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	22695	4	,	,	,
18637	22695	5	these	these	DT
18637	22695	6	purchasers	purchaser	NNS
18637	22695	7	argued	argue	VBD
18637	22695	8	,	,	,
18637	22695	9	would	would	MD
18637	22695	10	have	have	VB
18637	22695	11	been	be	VBN
18637	22695	12	in	in	IN
18637	22695	13	harmony	harmony	NN
18637	22695	14	with	with	IN
18637	22695	15	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	22695	16	local	local	JJ
18637	22695	17	law	law	NN
18637	22695	18	whereunder	whereunder	NN
18637	22695	19	title	title	NN
18637	22695	20	to	to	IN
18637	22695	21	coal	coal	NN
18637	22695	22	passes	pass	VBZ
18637	22695	23	immediately	immediately	RB
18637	22695	24	to	to	IN
18637	22695	25	the	the	DT
18637	22695	26	lessee	lessee	NN
18637	22695	27	on	on	IN
18637	22695	28	execution	execution	NN
18637	22695	29	of	of	IN
18637	22695	30	such	such	JJ
18637	22695	31	leases	lease	NNS
18637	22695	32	.	.	.
18637	22696	1	To	to	IN
18637	22696	2	the	the	DT
18637	22696	3	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22696	4	,	,	,
18637	22696	5	on	on	IN
18637	22696	6	the	the	DT
18637	22696	7	other	other	JJ
18637	22696	8	hand	hand	NN
18637	22696	9	,	,	,
18637	22696	10	such	such	JJ
18637	22696	11	leases	lease	NNS
18637	22696	12	were	be	VBD
18637	22696	13	not	not	RB
18637	22696	14	to	to	TO
18637	22696	15	be	be	VB
18637	22696	16	viewed	view	VBN
18637	22696	17	"	"	``
18637	22696	18	as	as	IN
18637	22696	19	a	a	DT
18637	22696	20	'	'	``
18637	22696	21	sale	sale	NN
18637	22696	22	'	'	''
18637	22696	23	of	of	IN
18637	22696	24	the	the	DT
18637	22696	25	mineral	mineral	NN
18637	22696	26	content	content	NN
18637	22696	27	of	of	IN
18637	22696	28	the	the	DT
18637	22696	29	soil	soil	NN
18637	22696	30	"	"	``
18637	22696	31	inasmuch	inasmuch	NN
18637	22696	32	as	as	IN
18637	22696	33	minerals	mineral	NNS
18637	22696	34	"	"	``
18637	22696	35	may	may	MD
18637	22696	36	or	or	CC
18637	22696	37	may	may	MD
18637	22696	38	not	not	RB
18637	22696	39	be	be	VB
18637	22696	40	present	present	JJ
18637	22696	41	in	in	IN
18637	22696	42	the	the	DT
18637	22696	43	leased	lease	VBN
18637	22696	44	premises	premise	NNS
18637	22696	45	and	and	CC
18637	22696	46	may	may	MD
18637	22696	47	or	or	CC
18637	22696	48	may	may	MD
18637	22696	49	not	not	RB
18637	22696	50	be	be	VB
18637	22696	51	found	find	VBN
18637	22696	52	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22696	53	therein	therein	RB
18637	22696	54	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22696	55	.	.	.
18637	22697	1	*	*	NFP
18637	22697	2	*	*	NFP
18637	22697	3	*	*	NFP
18637	22697	4	If	if	IN
18637	22697	5	found	find	VBN
18637	22697	6	,	,	,
18637	22697	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22697	8	abstraction	abstraction	NN
18637	22697	9	*	*	NFP
18637	22697	10	*	*	NFP
18637	22697	11	*	*	NFP
18637	22697	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	22697	13	a	a	DT
18637	22697	14	time	time	NN
18637	22697	15	consuming	consume	VBG
18637	22697	16	operation	operation	NN
18637	22697	17	and	and	CC
18637	22697	18	the	the	DT
18637	22697	19	payments	payment	NNS
18637	22697	20	made	make	VBN
18637	22697	21	by	by	IN
18637	22697	22	the	the	DT
18637	22697	23	lessee	lessee	NN
18637	22697	24	*	*	NFP
18637	22697	25	*	*	NFP
18637	22697	26	*	*	NFP
18637	22697	27	do	do	VBP
18637	22697	28	not	not	RB
18637	22697	29	normally	normally	RB
18637	22697	30	become	become	VB
18637	22697	31	payable	payable	JJ
18637	22697	32	as	as	IN
18637	22697	33	the	the	DT
18637	22697	34	result	result	NN
18637	22697	35	of	of	IN
18637	22697	36	a	a	DT
18637	22697	37	single	single	JJ
18637	22697	38	transaction	transaction	NN
18637	22697	39	.	.	.
18637	22697	40	"	"	''
18637	22698	1	The	the	DT
18637	22698	2	result	result	NN
18637	22698	3	for	for	IN
18637	22698	4	tax	tax	NN
18637	22698	5	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	22698	6	would	would	MD
18637	22698	7	have	have	VB
18637	22698	8	been	be	VBN
18637	22698	9	the	the	DT
18637	22698	10	same	same	JJ
18637	22698	11	even	even	RB
18637	22698	12	had	have	VBD
18637	22698	13	the	the	DT
18637	22698	14	lease	lease	NN
18637	22698	15	provided	provide	VBN
18637	22698	16	that	that	DT
18637	22698	17	title	title	NN
18637	22698	18	to	to	IN
18637	22698	19	the	the	DT
18637	22698	20	minerals	mineral	NNS
18637	22698	21	would	would	MD
18637	22698	22	pass	pass	VB
18637	22698	23	only	only	RB
18637	22698	24	"	"	''
18637	22698	25	on	on	IN
18637	22698	26	severance	severance	NN
18637	22698	27	by	by	IN
18637	22698	28	the	the	DT
18637	22698	29	lessee	lessee	NN
18637	22698	30	.	.	.
18637	22698	31	"	"	''
18637	22699	1	--Bankers	--Bankers	:
18637	22699	2	Pocahontas	Pocahontas	NNP
18637	22699	3	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	22699	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22699	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22699	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22699	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22699	8	Burnet	Burnet	NNP
18637	22699	9	,	,	,
18637	22699	10	287	287	CD
18637	22699	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22699	12	308	308	CD
18637	22699	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22699	14	1932	1932	CD
18637	22699	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22699	16	;	;	:
18637	22699	17	Burnet	Burnet	NNP
18637	22699	18	_	_	NNP
18637	22699	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	22699	20	_	_	NNP
18637	22699	21	Harmel	Harmel	NNP
18637	22699	22	,	,	,
18637	22699	23	287	287	CD
18637	22699	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22699	25	103	103	CD
18637	22699	26	,	,	,
18637	22699	27	106	106	CD
18637	22699	28	-	-	SYM
18637	22699	29	107	107	CD
18637	22699	30	,	,	,
18637	22699	31	111	111	CD
18637	22699	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22699	33	1932	1932	CD
18637	22699	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22699	35	.	.	.
18637	22700	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22700	2	40	40	CD
18637	22700	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22700	4	Brushaber	Brushaber	NNP
18637	22700	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22700	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22700	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22700	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	22700	9	Pac	Pac	NNP
18637	22700	10	.	.	.
18637	22701	1	R.	R.	NNP
18637	22701	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22701	3	,	,	,
18637	22701	4	240	240	CD
18637	22701	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22701	6	1	1	CD
18637	22701	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22701	8	1916	1916	CD
18637	22701	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22701	10	.	.	.
18637	22702	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22702	2	41	41	CD
18637	22702	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22702	4	MacLaughlin	MacLaughlin	NNP
18637	22702	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22702	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22702	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22702	8	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	22702	9	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	22702	10	.	.	.
18637	22703	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22703	2	,	,	,
18637	22703	3	286	286	CD
18637	22703	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22703	5	244	244	CD
18637	22703	6	,	,	,
18637	22703	7	250	250	CD
18637	22703	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22703	9	1932	1932	CD
18637	22703	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22703	11	.	.	.
18637	22704	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22704	2	42	42	CD
18637	22704	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22704	4	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	22704	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22704	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22704	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22704	8	Independent	Independent	NNP
18637	22704	9	L.	L.	NNP
18637	22704	10	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	22704	11	.	.	.
18637	22705	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22705	2	,	,	,
18637	22705	3	292	292	CD
18637	22705	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22705	5	371	371	CD
18637	22705	6	,	,	,
18637	22705	7	381	381	CD
18637	22705	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22705	9	1934	1934	CD
18637	22705	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22705	11	;	;	:
18637	22705	12	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	22705	13	_	_	NNP
18637	22705	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	22705	15	_	_	NNP
18637	22705	16	Winmill	Winmill	NNP
18637	22705	17	,	,	,
18637	22705	18	305	305	CD
18637	22705	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22705	20	79	79	CD
18637	22705	21	,	,	,
18637	22705	22	84	84	CD
18637	22705	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22705	24	1938	1938	CD
18637	22705	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22705	26	.	.	.
18637	22706	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22706	2	43	43	CD
18637	22706	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22706	4	A	a	DT
18637	22706	5	tax	tax	NN
18637	22706	6	on	on	IN
18637	22706	7	the	the	DT
18637	22706	8	rental	rental	JJ
18637	22706	9	value	value	NN
18637	22706	10	of	of	IN
18637	22706	11	property	property	NN
18637	22706	12	so	so	RB
18637	22706	13	occupied	occupy	VBN
18637	22706	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	22706	15	a	a	DT
18637	22706	16	direct	direct	JJ
18637	22706	17	tax	tax	NN
18637	22706	18	on	on	IN
18637	22706	19	the	the	DT
18637	22706	20	land	land	NN
18637	22706	21	and	and	CC
18637	22706	22	must	must	MD
18637	22706	23	be	be	VB
18637	22706	24	apportioned.--Helvering	apportioned.--helvere	VBG
18637	22706	25	_	_	NNP
18637	22706	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	22706	27	_	_	NNP
18637	22706	28	Independent	Independent	NNP
18637	22706	29	L.	L.	NNP
18637	22706	30	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	22706	31	.	.	.
18637	22707	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22707	2	,	,	,
18637	22707	3	292	292	CD
18637	22707	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22707	5	371	371	CD
18637	22707	6	,	,	,
18637	22707	7	378	378	CD
18637	22707	8	-	-	SYM
18637	22707	9	379	379	CD
18637	22707	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22707	11	1934	1934	CD
18637	22707	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22707	13	.	.	.
18637	22708	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22708	2	44	44	CD
18637	22708	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22708	4	292	292	CD
18637	22708	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22709	1	381.--Expenditures	381.--expenditures	CD
18637	22709	2	incurred	incur	VBN
18637	22709	3	in	in	IN
18637	22709	4	the	the	DT
18637	22709	5	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	22709	6	of	of	IN
18637	22709	7	work	work	NN
18637	22709	8	under	under	IN
18637	22709	9	a	a	DT
18637	22709	10	contract	contract	NN
18637	22709	11	for	for	IN
18637	22709	12	the	the	DT
18637	22709	13	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	22709	14	of	of	IN
18637	22709	15	earning	earn	VBG
18637	22709	16	profits	profit	NNS
18637	22709	17	are	be	VBP
18637	22709	18	not	not	RB
18637	22709	19	capital	capital	NN
18637	22709	20	investments	investment	NNS
18637	22709	21	,	,	,
18637	22709	22	the	the	DT
18637	22709	23	cost	cost	NN
18637	22709	24	of	of	IN
18637	22709	25	which	which	WDT
18637	22709	26	,	,	,
18637	22709	27	if	if	IN
18637	22709	28	converted	convert	VBN
18637	22709	29	,	,	,
18637	22709	30	must	must	MD
18637	22709	31	first	first	RB
18637	22709	32	be	be	VB
18637	22709	33	restored	restore	VBN
18637	22709	34	from	from	IN
18637	22709	35	the	the	DT
18637	22709	36	proceeds	proceed	NNS
18637	22709	37	before	before	IN
18637	22709	38	there	there	EX
18637	22709	39	is	be	VBZ
18637	22709	40	a	a	DT
18637	22709	41	capital	capital	NN
18637	22709	42	gain	gain	NN
18637	22709	43	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	22709	44	as	as	IN
18637	22709	45	income	income	NN
18637	22709	46	.	.	.
18637	22710	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	22710	2	,	,	,
18637	22710	3	a	a	DT
18637	22710	4	dredging	dredging	NN
18637	22710	5	contractor	contractor	NN
18637	22710	6	,	,	,
18637	22710	7	recovering	recover	VBG
18637	22710	8	a	a	DT
18637	22710	9	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	22710	10	for	for	IN
18637	22710	11	breach	breach	NN
18637	22710	12	of	of	IN
18637	22710	13	warranty	warranty	NN
18637	22710	14	of	of	IN
18637	22710	15	the	the	DT
18637	22710	16	character	character	NN
18637	22710	17	of	of	IN
18637	22710	18	the	the	DT
18637	22710	19	material	material	NN
18637	22710	20	to	to	TO
18637	22710	21	be	be	VB
18637	22710	22	dredged	dredge	VBN
18637	22710	23	,	,	,
18637	22710	24	must	must	MD
18637	22710	25	include	include	VB
18637	22710	26	the	the	DT
18637	22710	27	amount	amount	NN
18637	22710	28	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	22710	29	in	in	IN
18637	22710	30	the	the	DT
18637	22710	31	gross	gross	JJ
18637	22710	32	income	income	NN
18637	22710	33	of	of	IN
18637	22710	34	the	the	DT
18637	22710	35	year	year	NN
18637	22710	36	in	in	IN
18637	22710	37	which	which	WDT
18637	22710	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22710	39	was	be	VBD
18637	22710	40	received	receive	VBN
18637	22710	41	,	,	,
18637	22710	42	rather	rather	RB
18637	22710	43	than	than	IN
18637	22710	44	of	of	IN
18637	22710	45	the	the	DT
18637	22710	46	years	year	NNS
18637	22710	47	during	during	IN
18637	22710	48	which	which	WDT
18637	22710	49	the	the	DT
18637	22710	50	contract	contract	NN
18637	22710	51	was	be	VBD
18637	22710	52	performed	perform	VBN
18637	22710	53	,	,	,
18637	22710	54	even	even	RB
18637	22710	55	though	though	IN
18637	22710	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22710	57	merely	merely	RB
18637	22710	58	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	22710	59	a	a	DT
18637	22710	60	return	return	NN
18637	22710	61	of	of	IN
18637	22710	62	expenditures	expenditure	NNS
18637	22710	63	made	make	VBN
18637	22710	64	in	in	IN
18637	22710	65	performing	perform	VBG
18637	22710	66	the	the	DT
18637	22710	67	contract	contract	NN
18637	22710	68	and	and	CC
18637	22710	69	resulting	result	VBG
18637	22710	70	in	in	IN
18637	22710	71	a	a	DT
18637	22710	72	loss	loss	NN
18637	22710	73	.	.	.
18637	22711	1	The	the	DT
18637	22711	2	gain	gain	NN
18637	22711	3	or	or	CC
18637	22711	4	profit	profit	NN
18637	22711	5	subject	subject	NN
18637	22711	6	to	to	IN
18637	22711	7	tax	tax	NN
18637	22711	8	under	under	IN
18637	22711	9	the	the	DT
18637	22711	10	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	22711	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22711	12	is	be	VBZ
18637	22711	13	the	the	DT
18637	22711	14	excess	excess	NN
18637	22711	15	of	of	IN
18637	22711	16	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	22711	17	over	over	IN
18637	22711	18	allowable	allowable	JJ
18637	22711	19	deductions	deduction	NNS
18637	22711	20	during	during	IN
18637	22711	21	the	the	DT
18637	22711	22	accounting	accounting	NN
18637	22711	23	period	period	NN
18637	22711	24	,	,	,
18637	22711	25	without	without	IN
18637	22711	26	regard	regard	NN
18637	22711	27	to	to	IN
18637	22711	28	whether	whether	IN
18637	22711	29	or	or	CC
18637	22711	30	not	not	RB
18637	22711	31	such	such	JJ
18637	22711	32	excess	excess	JJ
18637	22711	33	represents	represent	VBZ
18637	22711	34	a	a	DT
18637	22711	35	profit	profit	NN
18637	22711	36	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
18637	22711	37	on	on	IN
18637	22711	38	the	the	DT
18637	22711	39	basis	basis	NN
18637	22711	40	of	of	IN
18637	22711	41	particular	particular	JJ
18637	22711	42	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	22711	43	of	of	IN
18637	22711	44	the	the	DT
18637	22711	45	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
18637	22711	46	when	when	WRB
18637	22711	47	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22711	48	are	be	VBP
18637	22711	49	brought	bring	VBN
18637	22711	50	to	to	IN
18637	22711	51	a	a	DT
18637	22711	52	conclusion.--Burnet	conclusion.--burnet	NN
18637	22711	53	_	_	NNP
18637	22711	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	22711	55	_	_	NNP
18637	22711	56	Sanford	Sanford	NNP
18637	22711	57	&	&	CC
18637	22711	58	B.	B.	NNP
18637	22711	59	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22711	60	,	,	,
18637	22711	61	282	282	CD
18637	22711	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22711	63	353	353	CD
18637	22711	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22711	65	1931	1931	CD
18637	22711	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22711	67	.	.	.
18637	22712	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22712	2	45	45	CD
18637	22712	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22712	4	274	274	CD
18637	22712	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22712	6	259	259	CD
18637	22712	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22712	8	1927	1927	CD
18637	22712	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22712	10	.	.	.
18637	22713	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22713	2	46	46	CD
18637	22713	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22713	4	42	42	CD
18637	22713	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22713	6	.	.	.
18637	22714	1	227	227	CD
18637	22714	2	,	,	,
18637	22714	3	250	250	CD
18637	22714	4	,	,	,
18637	22714	5	268	268	CD
18637	22714	6	.	.	.
18637	22715	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22715	2	47	47	CD
18637	22715	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22715	4	274	274	CD
18637	22715	5	at	at	IN
18637	22715	6	263	263	CD
18637	22715	7	.	.	.
18637	22716	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22716	2	48	48	CD
18637	22716	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22716	4	327	327	CD
18637	22716	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22716	6	404	404	CD
18637	22716	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22716	8	1946	1946	CD
18637	22716	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22716	10	.	.	.
18637	22717	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22717	2	49	49	CD
18637	22717	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22717	4	343	343	CD
18637	22717	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22717	6	130	130	CD
18637	22717	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22717	8	1952	1952	CD
18637	22717	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22717	10	.	.	.
18637	22718	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	22718	2	17	17	CD
18637	22718	3	POPULAR	POPULAR	NNP
18637	22718	4	ELECTION	ELECTION	NNP
18637	22718	5	OF	of	IN
18637	22718	6	SENATORS	SENATORS	NNP
18637	22718	7	Page	Page	NNP
18637	22718	8	Historical	historical	JJ
18637	22718	9	origin	origin	NN
18637	22718	10	1207	1207	CD
18637	22718	11	Right	right	UH
18637	22718	12	to	to	TO
18637	22718	13	vote	vote	VB
18637	22718	14	for	for	IN
18637	22718	15	Senators	senator	NNS
18637	22718	16	1208	1208	CD
18637	22718	17	POPULAR	POPULAR	NNP
18637	22718	18	ELECTION	ELECTION	NNP
18637	22718	19	OF	of	IN
18637	22718	20	SENATORS	SENATORS	NNP
18637	22718	21	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22718	22	17	17	CD
18637	22718	23	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	22718	24	1	1	CD
18637	22718	25	.	.	.
18637	22719	1	The	the	DT
18637	22719	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	22719	3	of	of	IN
18637	22719	4	the	the	DT
18637	22719	5	United	United	NNP
18637	22719	6	States	States	NNP
18637	22719	7	shall	shall	MD
18637	22719	8	be	be	VB
18637	22719	9	composed	compose	VBN
18637	22719	10	of	of	IN
18637	22719	11	two	two	CD
18637	22719	12	Senators	senator	NNS
18637	22719	13	from	from	IN
18637	22719	14	each	each	DT
18637	22719	15	State	state	NN
18637	22719	16	,	,	,
18637	22719	17	elected	elect	VBN
18637	22719	18	by	by	IN
18637	22719	19	the	the	DT
18637	22719	20	people	people	NNS
18637	22719	21	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	22719	22	,	,	,
18637	22719	23	for	for	IN
18637	22719	24	six	six	CD
18637	22719	25	years	year	NNS
18637	22719	26	;	;	:
18637	22719	27	and	and	CC
18637	22719	28	each	each	DT
18637	22719	29	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	22719	30	shall	shall	MD
18637	22719	31	have	have	VB
18637	22719	32	one	one	CD
18637	22719	33	vote	vote	NN
18637	22719	34	.	.	.
18637	22720	1	The	the	DT
18637	22720	2	electors	elector	NNS
18637	22720	3	in	in	IN
18637	22720	4	each	each	DT
18637	22720	5	State	state	NN
18637	22720	6	shall	shall	MD
18637	22720	7	have	have	VB
18637	22720	8	the	the	DT
18637	22720	9	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	22720	10	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	22720	11	for	for	IN
18637	22720	12	electors	elector	NNS
18637	22720	13	of	of	IN
18637	22720	14	the	the	DT
18637	22720	15	most	most	RBS
18637	22720	16	numerous	numerous	JJ
18637	22720	17	branch	branch	NN
18637	22720	18	of	of	IN
18637	22720	19	the	the	DT
18637	22720	20	State	State	NNP
18637	22720	21	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	22720	22	.	.	.
18637	22721	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	22721	2	2	2	CD
18637	22721	3	.	.	.
18637	22722	1	When	when	WRB
18637	22722	2	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	22722	3	happen	happen	VBP
18637	22722	4	in	in	IN
18637	22722	5	the	the	DT
18637	22722	6	representation	representation	NN
18637	22722	7	of	of	IN
18637	22722	8	any	any	DT
18637	22722	9	State	State	NNP
18637	22722	10	in	in	IN
18637	22722	11	the	the	DT
18637	22722	12	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	22722	13	,	,	,
18637	22722	14	the	the	DT
18637	22722	15	executive	executive	JJ
18637	22722	16	authority	authority	NN
18637	22722	17	of	of	IN
18637	22722	18	such	such	JJ
18637	22722	19	State	State	NNP
18637	22722	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	22722	21	issue	issue	VB
18637	22722	22	writs	writ	NNS
18637	22722	23	of	of	IN
18637	22722	24	election	election	NN
18637	22722	25	to	to	TO
18637	22722	26	fill	fill	VB
18637	22722	27	such	such	JJ
18637	22722	28	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	22722	29	:	:	:
18637	22722	30	_	_	NNP
18637	22722	31	Provided	Provided	NNP
18637	22722	32	_	_	NNP
18637	22722	33	That	that	IN
18637	22722	34	the	the	DT
18637	22722	35	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	22722	36	of	of	IN
18637	22722	37	any	any	DT
18637	22722	38	State	State	NNP
18637	22722	39	may	may	MD
18637	22722	40	empower	empower	VB
18637	22722	41	the	the	DT
18637	22722	42	executive	executive	NN
18637	22722	43	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	22722	44	to	to	TO
18637	22722	45	make	make	VB
18637	22722	46	temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	22722	47	appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	22722	48	until	until	IN
18637	22722	49	the	the	DT
18637	22722	50	people	people	NNS
18637	22722	51	fill	fill	VBP
18637	22722	52	the	the	DT
18637	22722	53	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	22722	54	by	by	IN
18637	22722	55	election	election	NN
18637	22722	56	as	as	IN
18637	22722	57	the	the	DT
18637	22722	58	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	22722	59	may	may	MD
18637	22722	60	direct	direct	VB
18637	22722	61	.	.	.
18637	22723	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	22723	2	3	3	CD
18637	22723	3	.	.	.
18637	22724	1	This	this	DT
18637	22724	2	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22724	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	22724	4	not	not	RB
18637	22724	5	be	be	VB
18637	22724	6	so	so	RB
18637	22724	7	construed	construe	VBN
18637	22724	8	as	as	IN
18637	22724	9	to	to	TO
18637	22724	10	affect	affect	VB
18637	22724	11	the	the	DT
18637	22724	12	election	election	NN
18637	22724	13	or	or	CC
18637	22724	14	term	term	NN
18637	22724	15	of	of	IN
18637	22724	16	any	any	DT
18637	22724	17	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	22724	18	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	22724	19	before	before	IN
18637	22724	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22724	21	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	22724	22	valid	valid	JJ
18637	22724	23	as	as	IN
18637	22724	24	part	part	NN
18637	22724	25	of	of	IN
18637	22724	26	the	the	DT
18637	22724	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22724	28	.	.	.
18637	22725	1	Historical	historical	JJ
18637	22725	2	Origin	origin	NN
18637	22725	3	The	the	DT
18637	22725	4	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	22725	5	of	of	IN
18637	22725	6	this	this	DT
18637	22725	7	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22725	8	was	be	VBD
18637	22725	9	the	the	DT
18637	22725	10	outcome	outcome	NN
18637	22725	11	of	of	IN
18637	22725	12	increasing	increase	VBG
18637	22725	13	popular	popular	JJ
18637	22725	14	dissatisfaction	dissatisfaction	NN
18637	22725	15	with	with	IN
18637	22725	16	the	the	DT
18637	22725	17	operation	operation	NN
18637	22725	18	of	of	IN
18637	22725	19	the	the	DT
18637	22725	20	originally	originally	RB
18637	22725	21	established	establish	VBN
18637	22725	22	method	method	NN
18637	22725	23	of	of	IN
18637	22725	24	electing	elect	VBG
18637	22725	25	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	22725	26	.	.	.
18637	22726	1	As	as	IN
18637	22726	2	the	the	DT
18637	22726	3	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	22726	4	became	become	VBD
18637	22726	5	exercisable	exercisable	JJ
18637	22726	6	by	by	IN
18637	22726	7	greater	great	JJR
18637	22726	8	numbers	number	NNS
18637	22726	9	of	of	IN
18637	22726	10	people	people	NNS
18637	22726	11	,	,	,
18637	22726	12	the	the	DT
18637	22726	13	belief	belief	NN
18637	22726	14	became	become	VBD
18637	22726	15	widespread	widespread	JJ
18637	22726	16	that	that	IN
18637	22726	17	Senators	senator	NNS
18637	22726	18	ought	ought	MD
18637	22726	19	to	to	TO
18637	22726	20	be	be	VB
18637	22726	21	popularly	popularly	RB
18637	22726	22	elected	elect	VBN
18637	22726	23	in	in	IN
18637	22726	24	the	the	DT
18637	22726	25	same	same	JJ
18637	22726	26	manner	manner	NN
18637	22726	27	as	as	IN
18637	22726	28	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	22726	29	.	.	.
18637	22727	1	Acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	22727	2	of	of	IN
18637	22727	3	this	this	DT
18637	22727	4	idea	idea	NN
18637	22727	5	was	be	VBD
18637	22727	6	fostered	foster	VBN
18637	22727	7	by	by	IN
18637	22727	8	the	the	DT
18637	22727	9	mounting	mount	VBG
18637	22727	10	accumulation	accumulation	NN
18637	22727	11	of	of	IN
18637	22727	12	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	22727	13	of	of	IN
18637	22727	14	the	the	DT
18637	22727	15	practical	practical	JJ
18637	22727	16	disadvantages	disadvantage	NNS
18637	22727	17	and	and	CC
18637	22727	18	malpractices	malpractice	VBZ
18637	22727	19	attendant	attendant	JJ
18637	22727	20	upon	upon	IN
18637	22727	21	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	22727	22	selection	selection	NN
18637	22727	23	,	,	,
18637	22727	24	such	such	JJ
18637	22727	25	as	as	IN
18637	22727	26	deadlocks	deadlock	NNS
18637	22727	27	within	within	IN
18637	22727	28	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	22727	29	resulting	result	VBG
18637	22727	30	in	in	IN
18637	22727	31	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	22727	32	remaining	remain	VBG
18637	22727	33	unfilled	unfilled	JJ
18637	22727	34	for	for	IN
18637	22727	35	substantial	substantial	JJ
18637	22727	36	intervals	interval	NNS
18637	22727	37	,	,	,
18637	22727	38	the	the	DT
18637	22727	39	influencing	influencing	NN
18637	22727	40	of	of	IN
18637	22727	41	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	22727	42	selection	selection	NN
18637	22727	43	by	by	IN
18637	22727	44	corrupt	corrupt	JJ
18637	22727	45	political	political	JJ
18637	22727	46	organizations	organization	NNS
18637	22727	47	and	and	CC
18637	22727	48	special	special	JJ
18637	22727	49	interest	interest	NN
18637	22727	50	groups	group	NNS
18637	22727	51	through	through	IN
18637	22727	52	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	22727	53	of	of	IN
18637	22727	54	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	22727	55	seats	seat	NNS
18637	22727	56	,	,	,
18637	22727	57	and	and	CC
18637	22727	58	the	the	DT
18637	22727	59	neglect	neglect	NN
18637	22727	60	of	of	IN
18637	22727	61	duties	duty	NNS
18637	22727	62	by	by	IN
18637	22727	63	legislators	legislator	NNS
18637	22727	64	as	as	IN
18637	22727	65	a	a	DT
18637	22727	66	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	22727	67	of	of	IN
18637	22727	68	protracted	protract	VBN
18637	22727	69	electoral	electoral	JJ
18637	22727	70	contests	contest	NNS
18637	22727	71	.	.	.
18637	22728	1	Prior	prior	RB
18637	22728	2	to	to	IN
18637	22728	3	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	22728	4	,	,	,
18637	22728	5	however	however	RB
18637	22728	6	,	,	,
18637	22728	7	many	many	JJ
18637	22728	8	States	States	NNPS
18637	22728	9	had	have	VBD
18637	22728	10	perfected	perfect	VBN
18637	22728	11	arrangements	arrangement	NNS
18637	22728	12	calculated	calculate	VBN
18637	22728	13	to	to	TO
18637	22728	14	afford	afford	VB
18637	22728	15	the	the	DT
18637	22728	16	voters	voter	NNS
18637	22728	17	more	more	RBR
18637	22728	18	effective	effective	JJ
18637	22728	19	control	control	NN
18637	22728	20	over	over	IN
18637	22728	21	the	the	DT
18637	22728	22	selection	selection	NN
18637	22728	23	of	of	IN
18637	22728	24	Senators	senator	NNS
18637	22728	25	.	.	.
18637	22729	1	State	state	NN
18637	22729	2	laws	law	NNS
18637	22729	3	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	22729	4	direct	direct	JJ
18637	22729	5	primaries	primary	NNS
18637	22729	6	were	be	VBD
18637	22729	7	amended	amend	VBN
18637	22729	8	so	so	IN
18637	22729	9	as	as	IN
18637	22729	10	to	to	TO
18637	22729	11	enable	enable	VB
18637	22729	12	voters	voter	NNS
18637	22729	13	participating	participate	VBG
18637	22729	14	in	in	IN
18637	22729	15	primaries	primary	NNS
18637	22729	16	to	to	TO
18637	22729	17	designate	designate	VB
18637	22729	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22729	19	preference	preference	NN
18637	22729	20	for	for	IN
18637	22729	21	one	one	CD
18637	22729	22	of	of	IN
18637	22729	23	several	several	JJ
18637	22729	24	party	party	NN
18637	22729	25	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	22729	26	for	for	IN
18637	22729	27	a	a	DT
18637	22729	28	senatorial	senatorial	JJ
18637	22729	29	seat	seat	NN
18637	22729	30	:	:	:
18637	22729	31	and	and	CC
18637	22729	32	nominations	nomination	NNS
18637	22729	33	unofficially	unofficially	RB
18637	22729	34	effected	effect	VBN
18637	22729	35	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	22729	36	were	be	VBD
18637	22729	37	transmitted	transmit	VBN
18637	22729	38	to	to	IN
18637	22729	39	the	the	DT
18637	22729	40	legislature	legislature	NN
18637	22729	41	.	.	.
18637	22730	1	Although	although	IN
18637	22730	2	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22730	3	action	action	NN
18637	22730	4	rested	rest	VBD
18637	22730	5	upon	upon	IN
18637	22730	6	no	no	DT
18637	22730	7	stronger	strong	JJR
18637	22730	8	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	22730	9	than	than	IN
18637	22730	10	common	common	JJ
18637	22730	11	understanding	understanding	NN
18637	22730	12	,	,	,
18637	22730	13	the	the	DT
18637	22730	14	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	22730	15	generally	generally	RB
18637	22730	16	elected	elect	VBD
18637	22730	17	the	the	DT
18637	22730	18	winning	win	VBG
18637	22730	19	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	22730	20	of	of	IN
18637	22730	21	the	the	DT
18637	22730	22	majority	majority	NN
18637	22730	23	,	,	,
18637	22730	24	and	and	CC
18637	22730	25	,	,	,
18637	22730	26	indeed	indeed	RB
18637	22730	27	,	,	,
18637	22730	28	in	in	IN
18637	22730	29	two	two	CD
18637	22730	30	States	States	NNPS
18637	22730	31	,	,	,
18637	22730	32	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	22730	33	for	for	IN
18637	22730	34	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	22730	35	seats	seat	NNS
18637	22730	36	were	be	VBD
18637	22730	37	required	require	VBN
18637	22730	38	to	to	TO
18637	22730	39	promise	promise	VB
18637	22730	40	to	to	TO
18637	22730	41	support	support	VB
18637	22730	42	,	,	,
18637	22730	43	without	without	IN
18637	22730	44	regard	regard	NN
18637	22730	45	to	to	IN
18637	22730	46	party	party	NN
18637	22730	47	ties	tie	NNS
18637	22730	48	,	,	,
18637	22730	49	the	the	DT
18637	22730	50	senatorial	senatorial	JJ
18637	22730	51	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	22730	52	polling	poll	VBG
18637	22730	53	the	the	DT
18637	22730	54	most	most	JJS
18637	22730	55	votes	vote	NNS
18637	22730	56	.	.	.
18637	22731	1	As	as	IN
18637	22731	2	a	a	DT
18637	22731	3	result	result	NN
18637	22731	4	of	of	IN
18637	22731	5	such	such	JJ
18637	22731	6	developments	development	NNS
18637	22731	7	,	,	,
18637	22731	8	at	at	RB
18637	22731	9	least	least	RBS
18637	22731	10	29	29	CD
18637	22731	11	States	state	NNS
18637	22731	12	by	by	IN
18637	22731	13	1912	1912	CD
18637	22731	14	,	,	,
18637	22731	15	one	one	CD
18637	22731	16	year	year	NN
18637	22731	17	before	before	IN
18637	22731	18	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	22731	19	,	,	,
18637	22731	20	were	be	VBD
18637	22731	21	nominating	nominate	VBG
18637	22731	22	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	22731	23	on	on	IN
18637	22731	24	a	a	DT
18637	22731	25	popular	popular	JJ
18637	22731	26	basis	basis	NN
18637	22731	27	;	;	:
18637	22731	28	and	and	CC
18637	22731	29	,	,	,
18637	22731	30	as	as	IN
18637	22731	31	a	a	DT
18637	22731	32	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	22731	33	,	,	,
18637	22731	34	the	the	DT
18637	22731	35	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	22731	36	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	22731	37	of	of	IN
18637	22731	38	the	the	DT
18637	22731	39	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	22731	40	had	have	VBD
18637	22731	41	been	be	VBN
18637	22731	42	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	22731	43	to	to	IN
18637	22731	44	little	little	JJ
18637	22731	45	more	more	JJR
18637	22731	46	than	than	IN
18637	22731	47	that	that	DT
18637	22731	48	retained	retain	VBN
18637	22731	49	by	by	IN
18637	22731	50	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	22731	51	electors	elector	NNS
18637	22731	52	.	.	.
18637	22732	1	Right	right	JJ
18637	22732	2	to	to	TO
18637	22732	3	Vote	vote	VB
18637	22732	4	for	for	IN
18637	22732	5	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	22732	6	Very	very	RB
18637	22732	7	shortly	shortly	RB
18637	22732	8	after	after	IN
18637	22732	9	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	22732	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22732	11	was	be	VBD
18637	22732	12	established	establish	VBN
18637	22732	13	that	that	IN
18637	22732	14	if	if	IN
18637	22732	15	a	a	DT
18637	22732	16	person	person	NN
18637	22732	17	possessed	possess	VBD
18637	22732	18	the	the	DT
18637	22732	19	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	22732	20	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	22732	21	for	for	IN
18637	22732	22	voting	vote	VBG
18637	22732	23	for	for	IN
18637	22732	24	a	a	DT
18637	22732	25	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	22732	26	,	,	,
18637	22732	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22732	28	right	right	NN
18637	22732	29	to	to	TO
18637	22732	30	vote	vote	VB
18637	22732	31	for	for	IN
18637	22732	32	such	such	PDT
18637	22732	33	an	an	DT
18637	22732	34	officer	officer	NN
18637	22732	35	was	be	VBD
18637	22732	36	not	not	RB
18637	22732	37	derived	derive	VBN
18637	22732	38	merely	merely	RB
18637	22732	39	from	from	IN
18637	22732	40	the	the	DT
18637	22732	41	constitution	constitution	NN
18637	22732	42	and	and	CC
18637	22732	43	laws	law	NNS
18637	22732	44	of	of	IN
18637	22732	45	the	the	DT
18637	22732	46	State	State	NNP
18637	22732	47	in	in	IN
18637	22732	48	which	which	WDT
18637	22732	49	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22732	50	are	be	VBP
18637	22732	51	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	22732	52	but	but	CC
18637	22732	53	has	have	VBZ
18637	22732	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22732	55	foundation	foundation	NN
18637	22732	56	in	in	IN
18637	22732	57	the	the	DT
18637	22732	58	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22732	59	of	of	IN
18637	22732	60	the	the	DT
18637	22732	61	United	United	NNP
18637	22732	62	States	States	NNP
18637	22732	63	.	.	.
18637	22733	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22733	2	1	1	LS
18637	22733	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22733	4	Consistently	consistently	RB
18637	22733	5	with	with	IN
18637	22733	6	this	this	DT
18637	22733	7	view	view	NN
18637	22733	8	,	,	,
18637	22733	9	federal	federal	JJ
18637	22733	10	courts	court	NNS
18637	22733	11	more	more	RBR
18637	22733	12	recently	recently	RB
18637	22733	13	have	have	VBP
18637	22733	14	declared	declare	VBN
18637	22733	15	that	that	IN
18637	22733	16	when	when	WRB
18637	22733	17	local	local	JJ
18637	22733	18	party	party	NN
18637	22733	19	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	22733	20	,	,	,
18637	22733	21	acting	act	VBG
18637	22733	22	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	22733	23	to	to	IN
18637	22733	24	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	22733	25	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	22733	26	by	by	IN
18637	22733	27	a	a	DT
18637	22733	28	party	party	NN
18637	22733	29	's	's	POS
18637	22733	30	State	State	NNP
18637	22733	31	executive	executive	NN
18637	22733	32	committee	committee	NN
18637	22733	33	,	,	,
18637	22733	34	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	22733	35	to	to	TO
18637	22733	36	permit	permit	VB
18637	22733	37	a	a	DT
18637	22733	38	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	22733	39	,	,	,
18637	22733	40	on	on	IN
18637	22733	41	account	account	NN
18637	22733	42	of	of	IN
18637	22733	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22733	44	race	race	NN
18637	22733	45	,	,	,
18637	22733	46	to	to	TO
18637	22733	47	vote	vote	VB
18637	22733	48	in	in	IN
18637	22733	49	a	a	DT
18637	22733	50	primary	primary	NN
18637	22733	51	to	to	TO
18637	22733	52	select	select	VB
18637	22733	53	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	22733	54	for	for	IN
18637	22733	55	the	the	DT
18637	22733	56	office	office	NN
18637	22733	57	of	of	IN
18637	22733	58	United	United	NNP
18637	22733	59	States	States	NNP
18637	22733	60	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	22733	61	,	,	,
18637	22733	62	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22733	63	deprived	deprive	VBD
18637	22733	64	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22733	65	of	of	IN
18637	22733	66	a	a	DT
18637	22733	67	right	right	JJ
18637	22733	68	secured	secure	VBN
18637	22733	69	to	to	IN
18637	22733	70	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22733	71	by	by	IN
18637	22733	72	the	the	DT
18637	22733	73	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22733	74	and	and	CC
18637	22733	75	laws	law	NNS
18637	22733	76	,	,	,
18637	22733	77	in	in	IN
18637	22733	78	violation	violation	NN
18637	22733	79	of	of	IN
18637	22733	80	this	this	DT
18637	22733	81	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22733	82	.	.	.
18637	22734	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22734	2	2	2	LS
18637	22734	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22734	4	An	an	DT
18637	22734	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	22734	6	statute	statute	NN
18637	22734	7	,	,	,
18637	22734	8	on	on	IN
18637	22734	9	the	the	DT
18637	22734	10	other	other	JJ
18637	22734	11	hand	hand	NN
18637	22734	12	,	,	,
18637	22734	13	which	which	WDT
18637	22734	14	required	require	VBD
18637	22734	15	that	that	IN
18637	22734	16	a	a	DT
18637	22734	17	petition	petition	NN
18637	22734	18	to	to	TO
18637	22734	19	form	form	VB
18637	22734	20	,	,	,
18637	22734	21	and	and	CC
18637	22734	22	to	to	TO
18637	22734	23	nominate	nominate	VB
18637	22734	24	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	22734	25	for	for	IN
18637	22734	26	,	,	,
18637	22734	27	a	a	DT
18637	22734	28	new	new	JJ
18637	22734	29	political	political	JJ
18637	22734	30	party	party	NN
18637	22734	31	be	be	VB
18637	22734	32	signed	sign	VBN
18637	22734	33	by	by	IN
18637	22734	34	at	at	RB
18637	22734	35	least	least	RBS
18637	22734	36	25,000	25,000	CD
18637	22734	37	voters	voter	NNS
18637	22734	38	from	from	IN
18637	22734	39	at	at	RB
18637	22734	40	least	least	JJS
18637	22734	41	50	50	CD
18637	22734	42	counties	county	NNS
18637	22734	43	was	be	VBD
18637	22734	44	held	hold	VBN
18637	22734	45	not	not	RB
18637	22734	46	to	to	TO
18637	22734	47	impair	impair	VB
18637	22734	48	any	any	DT
18637	22734	49	right	right	NN
18637	22734	50	under	under	IN
18637	22734	51	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22734	52	XVII	XVII	NNP
18637	22734	53	,	,	,
18637	22734	54	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	22734	55	that	that	IN
18637	22734	56	52	52	CD
18637	22734	57	%	%	NN
18637	22734	58	of	of	IN
18637	22734	59	the	the	DT
18637	22734	60	State	State	NNP
18637	22734	61	's	's	POS
18637	22734	62	voters	voter	NNS
18637	22734	63	were	be	VBD
18637	22734	64	residents	resident	NNS
18637	22734	65	of	of	IN
18637	22734	66	one	one	CD
18637	22734	67	county	county	NN
18637	22734	68	,	,	,
18637	22734	69	87	87	CD
18637	22734	70	%	%	NN
18637	22734	71	were	be	VBD
18637	22734	72	residents	resident	NNS
18637	22734	73	of	of	IN
18637	22734	74	49	49	CD
18637	22734	75	counties	county	NNS
18637	22734	76	,	,	,
18637	22734	77	and	and	CC
18637	22734	78	only	only	RB
18637	22734	79	13	13	CD
18637	22734	80	%	%	NN
18637	22734	81	resided	reside	VBD
18637	22734	82	in	in	IN
18637	22734	83	the	the	DT
18637	22734	84	53	53	CD
18637	22734	85	least	least	JJS
18637	22734	86	populous	populous	JJ
18637	22734	87	counties	county	NNS
18637	22734	88	.	.	.
18637	22735	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22735	2	3	3	LS
18637	22735	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22735	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	22735	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22735	6	1	1	CD
18637	22735	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22735	8	United	United	NNP
18637	22735	9	States	States	NNP
18637	22735	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22735	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	22735	12	_	_	NNP
18637	22735	13	Aczel	Aczel	NNP
18637	22735	14	,	,	,
18637	22735	15	219	219	CD
18637	22735	16	F.	f.	NN
18637	22735	17	917	917	CD
18637	22735	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22735	19	1915	1915	CD
18637	22735	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22735	21	,	,	,
18637	22735	22	citing	cite	VBG
18637	22735	23	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	22735	24	parte	parte	NN
18637	22735	25	Yarbrough	Yarbrough	NNP
18637	22735	26	,	,	,
18637	22735	27	110	110	CD
18637	22735	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22735	29	651	651	CD
18637	22735	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22735	31	1884	1884	CD
18637	22735	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22735	33	.	.	.
18637	22736	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22736	2	2	2	LS
18637	22736	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22736	4	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	22736	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22736	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22736	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22736	8	King	King	NNP
18637	22736	9	,	,	,
18637	22736	10	154	154	CD
18637	22736	11	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22736	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22736	13	2d	2d	CD
18637	22736	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22736	15	460	460	CD
18637	22736	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22736	17	1946	1946	CD
18637	22736	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22736	19	;	;	:
18637	22736	20	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	22736	21	denied	denied	NNP
18637	22736	22	,	,	,
18637	22736	23	327	327	CD
18637	22736	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22736	25	800	800	CD
18637	22736	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22736	27	1946	1946	CD
18637	22736	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22736	29	.	.	.
18637	22737	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22737	2	3	3	LS
18637	22737	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22737	4	MacDougall	MacDougall	NNP
18637	22737	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22737	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22737	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22737	8	Green	Green	NNP
18637	22737	9	,	,	,
18637	22737	10	335	335	CD
18637	22737	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22737	12	281	281	CD
18637	22737	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22737	14	1948	1948	CD
18637	22737	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22737	16	.	.	.
18637	22738	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	22738	2	18	18	CD
18637	22738	3	PROHIBITION	prohibition	NN
18637	22738	4	OF	of	IN
18637	22738	5	INTOXICATING	INTOXICATING	NNP
18637	22738	6	LIQUORS	LIQUORS	NNP
18637	22738	7	Page	Page	NNP
18637	22738	8	Validity	validity	NN
18637	22738	9	of	of	IN
18637	22738	10	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	22738	11	1213	1213	CD
18637	22738	12	Enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	22738	13	1213	1213	CD
18637	22738	14	Repeal	repeal	NN
18637	22738	15	1213	1213	CD
18637	22738	16	PROHIBITION	prohibition	NN
18637	22738	17	OF	of	IN
18637	22738	18	INTOXICATING	INTOXICATING	NNP
18637	22738	19	LIQUORS	LIQUORS	NNP
18637	22738	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22738	21	18	18	CD
18637	22738	22	Section	Section	NNP
18637	22738	23	1	1	CD
18637	22738	24	.	.	.
18637	22739	1	After	after	IN
18637	22739	2	one	one	CD
18637	22739	3	year	year	NN
18637	22739	4	from	from	IN
18637	22739	5	the	the	DT
18637	22739	6	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	22739	7	of	of	IN
18637	22739	8	this	this	DT
18637	22739	9	article	article	NN
18637	22739	10	the	the	DT
18637	22739	11	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	22739	12	,	,	,
18637	22739	13	sale	sale	NN
18637	22739	14	,	,	,
18637	22739	15	or	or	CC
18637	22739	16	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	22739	17	of	of	IN
18637	22739	18	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	22739	19	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	22739	20	within	within	IN
18637	22739	21	,	,	,
18637	22739	22	the	the	DT
18637	22739	23	importation	importation	NN
18637	22739	24	thereof	thereof	VBD
18637	22739	25	into	into	IN
18637	22739	26	,	,	,
18637	22739	27	or	or	CC
18637	22739	28	the	the	DT
18637	22739	29	exportation	exportation	NN
18637	22739	30	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	22739	31	from	from	IN
18637	22739	32	the	the	DT
18637	22739	33	United	United	NNP
18637	22739	34	States	States	NNP
18637	22739	35	and	and	CC
18637	22739	36	all	all	DT
18637	22739	37	territory	territory	NN
18637	22739	38	subject	subject	JJ
18637	22739	39	to	to	IN
18637	22739	40	the	the	DT
18637	22739	41	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	22739	42	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	22739	43	for	for	IN
18637	22739	44	beverage	beverage	NN
18637	22739	45	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	22739	46	is	be	VBZ
18637	22739	47	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	22739	48	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	22739	49	.	.	.
18637	22740	1	Section	section	NN
18637	22740	2	2	2	CD
18637	22740	3	.	.	.
18637	22741	1	The	the	DT
18637	22741	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22741	3	and	and	CC
18637	22741	4	the	the	DT
18637	22741	5	several	several	JJ
18637	22741	6	States	state	NNS
18637	22741	7	shall	shall	MD
18637	22741	8	have	have	VB
18637	22741	9	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	22741	10	power	power	NN
18637	22741	11	to	to	TO
18637	22741	12	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	22741	13	this	this	DT
18637	22741	14	article	article	NN
18637	22741	15	by	by	IN
18637	22741	16	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	22741	17	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	22741	18	.	.	.
18637	22742	1	Section	section	NN
18637	22742	2	3	3	CD
18637	22742	3	.	.	.
18637	22743	1	This	this	DT
18637	22743	2	article	article	NN
18637	22743	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	22743	4	be	be	VB
18637	22743	5	inoperative	inoperative	JJ
18637	22743	6	unless	unless	IN
18637	22743	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22743	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	22743	9	have	have	VB
18637	22743	10	been	be	VBN
18637	22743	11	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	22743	12	as	as	IN
18637	22743	13	an	an	DT
18637	22743	14	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22743	15	to	to	IN
18637	22743	16	the	the	DT
18637	22743	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22743	18	by	by	IN
18637	22743	19	the	the	DT
18637	22743	20	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	22743	21	of	of	IN
18637	22743	22	the	the	DT
18637	22743	23	several	several	JJ
18637	22743	24	States	States	NNPS
18637	22743	25	,	,	,
18637	22743	26	as	as	IN
18637	22743	27	provided	provide	VBN
18637	22743	28	in	in	IN
18637	22743	29	the	the	DT
18637	22743	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22743	31	,	,	,
18637	22743	32	within	within	IN
18637	22743	33	seven	seven	CD
18637	22743	34	years	year	NNS
18637	22743	35	from	from	IN
18637	22743	36	the	the	DT
18637	22743	37	date	date	NN
18637	22743	38	of	of	IN
18637	22743	39	the	the	DT
18637	22743	40	submission	submission	NN
18637	22743	41	hereof	hereof	NNP
18637	22743	42	to	to	IN
18637	22743	43	the	the	DT
18637	22743	44	States	States	NNP
18637	22743	45	by	by	IN
18637	22743	46	the	the	DT
18637	22743	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22743	48	.	.	.
18637	22744	1	Validity	validity	NN
18637	22744	2	of	of	IN
18637	22744	3	Adoption	Adoption	NNP
18637	22744	4	Cases	case	NNS
18637	22744	5	relating	relate	VBG
18637	22744	6	to	to	IN
18637	22744	7	this	this	DT
18637	22744	8	question	question	NN
18637	22744	9	are	be	VBP
18637	22744	10	presented	present	VBN
18637	22744	11	and	and	CC
18637	22744	12	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	22744	13	under	under	IN
18637	22744	14	article	article	NN
18637	22744	15	V.	V.	NNP
18637	22744	16	Enforcement	Enforcement	NNP
18637	22744	17	Cases	case	NNS
18637	22744	18	produced	produce	VBN
18637	22744	19	by	by	IN
18637	22744	20	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	22744	21	and	and	CC
18637	22744	22	arising	arise	VBG
18637	22744	23	under	under	IN
18637	22744	24	Amendments	Amendments	NNP
18637	22744	25	Four	four	CD
18637	22744	26	and	and	CC
18637	22744	27	Five	five	CD
18637	22744	28	are	be	VBP
18637	22744	29	considered	consider	VBN
18637	22744	30	in	in	IN
18637	22744	31	the	the	DT
18637	22744	32	discussion	discussion	NN
18637	22744	33	appearing	appear	VBG
18637	22744	34	under	under	IN
18637	22744	35	the	the	DT
18637	22744	36	latter	latter	JJ
18637	22744	37	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	22744	38	.	.	.
18637	22745	1	Repeal	Repeal	NNP
18637	22745	2	This	this	DT
18637	22745	3	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22745	4	was	be	VBD
18637	22745	5	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	22745	6	by	by	IN
18637	22745	7	the	the	DT
18637	22745	8	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	22745	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	22745	10	first	first	NNP
18637	22745	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22745	12	,	,	,
18637	22745	13	and	and	CC
18637	22745	14	titles	title	NNS
18637	22745	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22745	16	and	and	CC
18637	22745	17	II	ii	CD
18637	22745	18	of	of	IN
18637	22745	19	the	the	DT
18637	22745	20	National	National	NNP
18637	22745	21	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	22745	22	Act[1	Act[1	NNP
18637	22745	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22745	24	were	be	VBD
18637	22745	25	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	22745	26	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	22745	27	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	22745	28	by	by	IN
18637	22745	29	the	the	DT
18637	22745	30	act	act	NN
18637	22745	31	of	of	IN
18637	22745	32	August	August	NNP
18637	22745	33	27	27	CD
18637	22745	34	,	,	,
18637	22745	35	1935	1935	CD
18637	22745	36	.	.	.
18637	22746	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22746	2	2	2	LS
18637	22746	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22746	4	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	22746	5	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	22746	6	laws	law	NNS
18637	22746	7	effective	effective	JJ
18637	22746	8	in	in	IN
18637	22746	9	various	various	JJ
18637	22746	10	Districts	Districts	NNPS
18637	22746	11	and	and	CC
18637	22746	12	Territories	Territories	NNPS
18637	22746	13	were	be	VBD
18637	22746	14	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	22746	15	as	as	IN
18637	22746	16	follows	follow	VBZ
18637	22746	17	:	:	:
18637	22746	18	District	District	NNP
18637	22746	19	of	of	IN
18637	22746	20	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	22746	21	--	--	:
18637	22746	22	April	April	NNP
18637	22746	23	5	5	CD
18637	22746	24	,	,	,
18637	22746	25	1933	1933	CD
18637	22746	26	,	,	,
18637	22746	27	and	and	CC
18637	22746	28	January	January	NNP
18637	22746	29	24	24	CD
18637	22746	30	,	,	,
18637	22746	31	1934;[3	1934;[3	NNP
18637	22746	32	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22746	33	Puerto	Puerto	NNP
18637	22746	34	Rico	Rico	NNP
18637	22746	35	and	and	CC
18637	22746	36	Virgin	Virgin	NNP
18637	22746	37	Islands	Islands	NNP
18637	22746	38	--	--	:
18637	22746	39	March	March	NNP
18637	22746	40	2	2	CD
18637	22746	41	,	,	,
18637	22746	42	1934;[4	1934;[4	NNP
18637	22746	43	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22746	44	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	22746	45	--	--	:
18637	22746	46	March	March	NNP
18637	22746	47	26	26	CD
18637	22746	48	,	,	,
18637	22746	49	1934;[5	1934;[5	NNP
18637	22746	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22746	51	and	and	CC
18637	22746	52	Panama	Panama	NNP
18637	22746	53	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	22746	54	Zone	Zone	NNP
18637	22746	55	--	--	:
18637	22746	56	June	June	NNP
18637	22746	57	19	19	CD
18637	22746	58	,	,	,
18637	22746	59	1934	1934	CD
18637	22746	60	.	.	.
18637	22747	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22747	2	6	6	CD
18637	22747	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22747	4	Taking	take	VBG
18637	22747	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	22747	6	notice	notice	NN
18637	22747	7	of	of	IN
18637	22747	8	the	the	DT
18637	22747	9	fact	fact	NN
18637	22747	10	that	that	IN
18637	22747	11	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	22747	12	of	of	IN
18637	22747	13	the	the	DT
18637	22747	14	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	22747	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	22747	16	first	first	NNP
18637	22747	17	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22747	18	was	be	VBD
18637	22747	19	consummated	consummate	VBN
18637	22747	20	on	on	IN
18637	22747	21	December	December	NNP
18637	22747	22	5	5	CD
18637	22747	23	,	,	,
18637	22747	24	1933	1933	CD
18637	22747	25	,	,	,
18637	22747	26	the	the	DT
18637	22747	27	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	22747	28	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22747	29	held	hold	VBD
18637	22747	30	that	that	IN
18637	22747	31	the	the	DT
18637	22747	32	National	National	NNP
18637	22747	33	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	22747	34	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22747	35	,	,	,
18637	22747	36	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	22747	37	as	as	IN
18637	22747	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22747	39	rested	rest	VBD
18637	22747	40	upon	upon	IN
18637	22747	41	a	a	DT
18637	22747	42	grant	grant	NN
18637	22747	43	of	of	IN
18637	22747	44	authority	authority	NN
18637	22747	45	to	to	IN
18637	22747	46	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22747	47	by	by	IN
18637	22747	48	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22747	49	XVIII	XVIII	NNP
18637	22747	50	thereupon	thereupon	RB
18637	22747	51	became	become	VBD
18637	22747	52	inoperative	inoperative	JJ
18637	22747	53	;	;	:
18637	22747	54	with	with	IN
18637	22747	55	the	the	DT
18637	22747	56	result	result	NN
18637	22747	57	that	that	IN
18637	22747	58	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	22747	59	for	for	IN
18637	22747	60	violations	violation	NNS
18637	22747	61	of	of	IN
18637	22747	62	the	the	DT
18637	22747	63	National	National	NNP
18637	22747	64	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	22747	65	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22747	66	,	,	,
18637	22747	67	including	include	VBG
18637	22747	68	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	22747	69	on	on	IN
18637	22747	70	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	22747	71	,	,	,
18637	22747	72	pending	pende	VBG
18637	22747	73	on	on	IN
18637	22747	74	,	,	,
18637	22747	75	or	or	CC
18637	22747	76	begun	begin	VBN
18637	22747	77	after	after	RB
18637	22747	78	,	,	,
18637	22747	79	the	the	DT
18637	22747	80	date	date	NN
18637	22747	81	of	of	IN
18637	22747	82	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	22747	83	,	,	,
18637	22747	84	had	have	VBD
18637	22747	85	to	to	TO
18637	22747	86	be	be	VB
18637	22747	87	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
18637	22747	88	for	for	IN
18637	22747	89	want	want	NN
18637	22747	90	of	of	IN
18637	22747	91	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	22747	92	.	.	.
18637	22748	1	Only	only	RB
18637	22748	2	final	final	JJ
18637	22748	3	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	22748	4	of	of	IN
18637	22748	5	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	22748	6	rendered	render	VBN
18637	22748	7	while	while	IN
18637	22748	8	the	the	DT
18637	22748	9	National	National	NNP
18637	22748	10	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	22748	11	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22748	12	was	be	VBD
18637	22748	13	in	in	IN
18637	22748	14	force	force	NN
18637	22748	15	remained	remain	VBD
18637	22748	16	unaffected	unaffected	JJ
18637	22748	17	.	.	.
18637	22749	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22749	2	7	7	LS
18637	22749	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22749	4	Likewise	likewise	RB
18637	22749	5	a	a	DT
18637	22749	6	heavy	heavy	JJ
18637	22749	7	"	"	``
18637	22749	8	special	special	JJ
18637	22749	9	excise	excise	NN
18637	22749	10	tax	tax	NN
18637	22749	11	,	,	,
18637	22749	12	"	"	''
18637	22749	13	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	22749	14	as	as	IN
18637	22749	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22749	16	could	could	MD
18637	22749	17	be	be	VB
18637	22749	18	construed	construe	VBN
18637	22749	19	as	as	IN
18637	22749	20	part	part	NN
18637	22749	21	of	of	IN
18637	22749	22	the	the	DT
18637	22749	23	machinery	machinery	NN
18637	22749	24	for	for	IN
18637	22749	25	enforcing	enforce	VBG
18637	22749	26	the	the	DT
18637	22749	27	Eighteenth	Eighteenth	NNP
18637	22749	28	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22749	29	,	,	,
18637	22749	30	was	be	VBD
18637	22749	31	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	22749	32	to	to	TO
18637	22749	33	have	have	VB
18637	22749	34	become	become	VBN
18637	22749	35	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	22749	36	automatically	automatically	RB
18637	22749	37	upon	upon	IN
18637	22749	38	the	the	DT
18637	22749	39	latter	latter	NN
18637	22749	40	's	's	POS
18637	22749	41	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	22749	42	.	.	.
18637	22750	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22750	2	8	8	CD
18637	22750	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22750	4	However	however	RB
18637	22750	5	,	,	,
18637	22750	6	liability	liability	NN
18637	22750	7	on	on	IN
18637	22750	8	a	a	DT
18637	22750	9	bond	bond	NN
18637	22750	10	conditioned	condition	VBN
18637	22750	11	upon	upon	IN
18637	22750	12	the	the	DT
18637	22750	13	return	return	NN
18637	22750	14	on	on	IN
18637	22750	15	the	the	DT
18637	22750	16	day	day	NN
18637	22750	17	of	of	IN
18637	22750	18	trial	trial	NN
18637	22750	19	of	of	IN
18637	22750	20	a	a	DT
18637	22750	21	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	22750	22	seized	seize	VBN
18637	22750	23	for	for	IN
18637	22750	24	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	22750	25	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	22750	26	of	of	IN
18637	22750	27	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	22750	28	was	be	VBD
18637	22750	29	held	hold	VBN
18637	22750	30	not	not	RB
18637	22750	31	to	to	TO
18637	22750	32	have	have	VB
18637	22750	33	been	be	VBN
18637	22750	34	extinguished	extinguish	VBN
18637	22750	35	by	by	IN
18637	22750	36	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	22750	37	when	when	WRB
18637	22750	38	the	the	DT
18637	22750	39	facts	fact	NNS
18637	22750	40	disclosed	disclose	VBD
18637	22750	41	that	that	IN
18637	22750	42	the	the	DT
18637	22750	43	trial	trial	NN
18637	22750	44	took	take	VBD
18637	22750	45	place	place	NN
18637	22750	46	in	in	IN
18637	22750	47	1931	1931	CD
18637	22750	48	and	and	CC
18637	22750	49	had	have	VBD
18637	22750	50	resulted	result	VBN
18637	22750	51	in	in	IN
18637	22750	52	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	22750	53	of	of	IN
18637	22750	54	the	the	DT
18637	22750	55	crew	crew	NN
18637	22750	56	.	.	.
18637	22751	1	The	the	DT
18637	22751	2	liability	liability	NN
18637	22751	3	became	become	VBD
18637	22751	4	complete	complete	JJ
18637	22751	5	upon	upon	IN
18637	22751	6	occurrence	occurrence	NN
18637	22751	7	of	of	IN
18637	22751	8	the	the	DT
18637	22751	9	breach	breach	NN
18637	22751	10	of	of	IN
18637	22751	11	the	the	DT
18637	22751	12	express	express	JJ
18637	22751	13	contractual	contractual	JJ
18637	22751	14	condition	condition	NN
18637	22751	15	and	and	CC
18637	22751	16	a	a	DT
18637	22751	17	civil	civil	JJ
18637	22751	18	action	action	NN
18637	22751	19	for	for	IN
18637	22751	20	recovery	recovery	NN
18637	22751	21	was	be	VBD
18637	22751	22	viewed	view	VBN
18637	22751	23	as	as	IN
18637	22751	24	unaffected	unaffected	JJ
18637	22751	25	by	by	IN
18637	22751	26	the	the	DT
18637	22751	27	loss	loss	NN
18637	22751	28	of	of	IN
18637	22751	29	penal	penal	JJ
18637	22751	30	sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	22751	31	.	.	.
18637	22752	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22752	2	9	9	CD
18637	22752	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22752	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	22752	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22752	6	1	1	CD
18637	22752	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22752	8	41	41	CD
18637	22752	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22752	10	.	.	.
18637	22753	1	305	305	CD
18637	22753	2	.	.	.
18637	22754	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22754	2	2	2	CD
18637	22754	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22754	4	49	49	CD
18637	22754	5	Stat	stat	NN
18637	22754	6	.	.	.
18637	22755	1	872	872	CD
18637	22755	2	.	.	.
18637	22756	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22756	2	3	3	CD
18637	22756	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22756	4	48	48	CD
18637	22756	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22756	6	.	.	.
18637	22757	1	28	28	CD
18637	22757	2	,	,	,
18637	22757	3	§	§	NNP
18637	22757	4	12	12	CD
18637	22757	5	;	;	:
18637	22757	6	48	48	CD
18637	22757	7	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	22757	8	.	.	.
18637	22758	1	319	319	CD
18637	22758	2	.	.	.
18637	22759	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22759	2	4	4	CD
18637	22759	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22759	4	48	48	CD
18637	22759	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22759	6	.	.	.
18637	22760	1	361	361	CD
18637	22760	2	.	.	.
18637	22761	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22761	2	5	5	CD
18637	22761	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22761	4	48	48	CD
18637	22761	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22761	6	.	.	.
18637	22762	1	467	467	CD
18637	22762	2	.	.	.
18637	22763	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22763	2	6	6	CD
18637	22763	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22763	4	48	48	CD
18637	22763	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22763	6	.	.	.
18637	22764	1	1116	1116	CD
18637	22764	2	.	.	.
18637	22765	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22765	2	7	7	CD
18637	22765	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22765	4	United	United	NNP
18637	22765	5	States	States	NNP
18637	22765	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22765	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22765	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22765	9	Chambers	Chambers	NNPS
18637	22765	10	,	,	,
18637	22765	11	291	291	CD
18637	22765	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22765	13	217	217	CD
18637	22765	14	,	,	,
18637	22765	15	222	222	CD
18637	22765	16	-	-	SYM
18637	22765	17	226	226	CD
18637	22765	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22765	19	1934	1934	CD
18637	22765	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22765	21	.	.	.
18637	22766	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22766	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22766	3	also	also	RB
18637	22766	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22766	5	Ellerbee	Ellerbee	NNP
18637	22766	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22766	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22766	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22766	9	Aderhold	Aderhold	NNP
18637	22766	10	,	,	,
18637	22766	11	5	5	CD
18637	22766	12	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22766	13	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	22766	14	.	.	.
18637	22767	1	1022	1022	CD
18637	22767	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22767	3	1934	1934	CD
18637	22767	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22767	5	;	;	:
18637	22767	6	United	United	NNP
18637	22767	7	States	States	NNP
18637	22767	8	ex	ex	NNP
18637	22767	9	rel	rel	NN
18637	22767	10	.	.	.
18637	22768	1	Randall	Randall	NNP
18637	22768	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22768	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22768	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22768	5	United	United	NNP
18637	22768	6	States	States	NNP
18637	22768	7	Marshal	Marshal	NNP
18637	22768	8	for	for	IN
18637	22768	9	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	22768	10	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	22768	11	.	.	.
18637	22769	1	of	of	IN
18637	22769	2	New	New	NNP
18637	22769	3	York	York	NNP
18637	22769	4	,	,	,
18637	22769	5	143	143	CD
18637	22769	6	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22769	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22769	8	2d	2d	NNP
18637	22769	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22769	10	830	830	CD
18637	22769	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22769	12	1944).--The	1944).--The	NNP
18637	22769	13	Twenty	twenty	CD
18637	22769	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	22769	15	first	first	NNP
18637	22769	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22769	17	containing	contain	VBG
18637	22769	18	"	"	``
18637	22769	19	no	no	DT
18637	22769	20	saving	save	VBG
18637	22769	21	clause	clause	NN
18637	22769	22	as	as	IN
18637	22769	23	to	to	IN
18637	22769	24	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	22769	25	for	for	IN
18637	22769	26	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	22769	27	theretofore	theretofore	RB
18637	22769	28	committed	commit	VBD
18637	22769	29	,	,	,
18637	22769	30	"	"	``
18637	22769	31	these	these	DT
18637	22769	32	holdings	holding	NNS
18637	22769	33	were	be	VBD
18637	22769	34	rendered	render	VBN
18637	22769	35	unavoidable	unavoidable	JJ
18637	22769	36	by	by	IN
18637	22769	37	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	22769	38	of	of	IN
18637	22769	39	the	the	DT
18637	22769	40	well	well	RB
18637	22769	41	-	-	HYPH
18637	22769	42	established	establish	VBN
18637	22769	43	principle	principle	NN
18637	22769	44	that	that	IN
18637	22769	45	after	after	IN
18637	22769	46	"	"	``
18637	22769	47	the	the	DT
18637	22769	48	expiration	expiration	NN
18637	22769	49	or	or	CC
18637	22769	50	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	22769	51	of	of	IN
18637	22769	52	a	a	DT
18637	22769	53	law	law	NN
18637	22769	54	,	,	,
18637	22769	55	no	no	DT
18637	22769	56	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	22769	57	can	can	MD
18637	22769	58	be	be	VB
18637	22769	59	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	22769	60	,	,	,
18637	22769	61	nor	nor	CC
18637	22769	62	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	22769	63	inflicted	inflict	VBN
18637	22769	64	,	,	,
18637	22769	65	for	for	IN
18637	22769	66	violations	violation	NNS
18637	22769	67	of	of	IN
18637	22769	68	the	the	DT
18637	22769	69	law	law	NN
18637	22769	70	committed	commit	VBD
18637	22769	71	while	while	IN
18637	22769	72	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22769	73	was	be	VBD
18637	22769	74	in	in	IN
18637	22769	75	force	force	NN
18637	22769	76	*	*	NFP
18637	22769	77	*	*	NFP
18637	22769	78	*	*	NFP
18637	22769	79	"	"	''
18637	22769	80	--Yeaton	--Yeaton	:
18637	22769	81	_	_	NNP
18637	22769	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	22769	83	_	_	NNP
18637	22769	84	United	United	NNP
18637	22769	85	States	States	NNP
18637	22769	86	,	,	,
18637	22769	87	5	5	CD
18637	22769	88	Cr	cr	NN
18637	22769	89	.	.	.
18637	22770	1	281	281	CD
18637	22770	2	,	,	,
18637	22770	3	283	283	CD
18637	22770	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22770	5	1809	1809	CD
18637	22770	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22770	7	,	,	,
18637	22770	8	quoted	quote	VBN
18637	22770	9	in	in	IN
18637	22770	10	United	United	NNP
18637	22770	11	States	States	NNP
18637	22770	12	_	_	NNP
18637	22770	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	22770	14	_	_	NNP
18637	22770	15	Chambers	Chambers	NNP
18637	22770	16	at	at	IN
18637	22770	17	pages	page	NNS
18637	22770	18	223	223	CD
18637	22770	19	-	-	SYM
18637	22770	20	224	224	CD
18637	22770	21	.	.	.
18637	22771	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22771	2	8	8	CD
18637	22771	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22771	4	United	United	NNP
18637	22771	5	States	States	NNP
18637	22771	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22771	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22771	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22771	9	Constantine	Constantine	NNP
18637	22771	10	,	,	,
18637	22771	11	296	296	CD
18637	22771	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22771	13	287	287	CD
18637	22771	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22771	15	1935	1935	CD
18637	22771	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22771	17	.	.	.
18637	22772	1	The	the	DT
18637	22772	2	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22772	3	also	also	RB
18637	22772	4	took	take	VBD
18637	22772	5	the	the	DT
18637	22772	6	position	position	NN
18637	22772	7	that	that	IN
18637	22772	8	even	even	RB
18637	22772	9	if	if	IN
18637	22772	10	the	the	DT
18637	22772	11	statute	statute	NN
18637	22772	12	embodying	embody	VBG
18637	22772	13	this	this	DT
18637	22772	14	"	"	``
18637	22772	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	22772	16	"	"	''
18637	22772	17	had	have	VBD
18637	22772	18	not	not	RB
18637	22772	19	been	be	VBN
18637	22772	20	"	"	``
18637	22772	21	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	22772	22	to	to	TO
18637	22772	23	penalize	penalize	VB
18637	22772	24	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22772	25	a	a	DT
18637	22772	26	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22772	27	violations	violation	NNS
18637	22772	28	of	of	IN
18637	22772	29	the	the	DT
18637	22772	30	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22772	31	,	,	,
18637	22772	32	"	"	''
18637	22772	33	but	but	CC
18637	22772	34	merely	merely	RB
18637	22772	35	to	to	TO
18637	22772	36	ordain	ordain	VB
18637	22772	37	a	a	DT
18637	22772	38	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	22772	39	for	for	IN
18637	22772	40	violations	violation	NNS
18637	22772	41	of	of	IN
18637	22772	42	State	State	NNP
18637	22772	43	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	22772	44	laws	law	NNS
18637	22772	45	,	,	,
18637	22772	46	"	"	''
18637	22772	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22772	48	ceased	cease	VBD
18637	22772	49	to	to	TO
18637	22772	50	be	be	VB
18637	22772	51	enforceable	enforceable	JJ
18637	22772	52	at	at	IN
18637	22772	53	the	the	DT
18637	22772	54	date	date	NN
18637	22772	55	of	of	IN
18637	22772	56	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	22772	57	"	"	''
18637	22772	58	;	;	,
18637	22772	59	for	for	IN
18637	22772	60	with	with	IN
18637	22772	61	the	the	DT
18637	22772	62	lapse	lapse	NN
18637	22772	63	of	of	IN
18637	22772	64	the	the	DT
18637	22772	65	unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	22772	66	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	22772	67	powers	power	NNS
18637	22772	68	contained	contain	VBN
18637	22772	69	in	in	IN
18637	22772	70	the	the	DT
18637	22772	71	Eighteenth	Eighteenth	NNP
18637	22772	72	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22772	73	,	,	,
18637	22772	74	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22772	75	could	could	MD
18637	22772	76	not	not	RB
18637	22772	77	,	,	,
18637	22772	78	without	without	IN
18637	22772	79	infringing	infringe	VBG
18637	22772	80	upon	upon	IN
18637	22772	81	powers	power	NNS
18637	22772	82	reserved	reserve	VBN
18637	22772	83	to	to	IN
18637	22772	84	the	the	DT
18637	22772	85	States	States	NNP
18637	22772	86	by	by	IN
18637	22772	87	the	the	DT
18637	22772	88	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	22772	89	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22772	90	,	,	,
18637	22772	91	"	"	''
18637	22772	92	impose	impose	VB
18637	22772	93	cumulative	cumulative	JJ
18637	22772	94	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	22772	95	above	above	IN
18637	22772	96	and	and	CC
18637	22772	97	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	22772	98	those	those	DT
18637	22772	99	specified	specify	VBN
18637	22772	100	by	by	IN
18637	22772	101	State	state	NN
18637	22772	102	law	law	NN
18637	22772	103	for	for	IN
18637	22772	104	infractions	infraction	NNS
18637	22772	105	of	of	IN
18637	22772	106	*	*	NN
18637	22772	107	*	*	NFP
18637	22772	108	*	*	NFP
18637	22772	109	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22772	110	a	a	DT
18637	22772	111	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22772	112	State	State	NNP
18637	22772	113	's	's	POS
18637	22772	114	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	22772	115	code	code	NN
18637	22772	116	by	by	IN
18637	22772	117	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22772	118	own	own	JJ
18637	22772	119	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	22772	120	.	.	.
18637	22772	121	"	"	''
18637	22773	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22773	2	Cardozo	Cardozo	NNP
18637	22773	3	,	,	,
18637	22773	4	with	with	IN
18637	22773	5	whom	whom	WP
18637	22773	6	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	22773	7	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
18637	22773	8	and	and	CC
18637	22773	9	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	22773	10	were	be	VBD
18637	22773	11	associated	associate	VBN
18637	22773	12	,	,	,
18637	22773	13	dissented	dissent	VBN
18637	22773	14	on	on	IN
18637	22773	15	the	the	DT
18637	22773	16	ground	ground	NN
18637	22773	17	that	that	IN
18637	22773	18	,	,	,
18637	22773	19	on	on	IN
18637	22773	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22773	21	face	face	NN
18637	22773	22	,	,	,
18637	22773	23	the	the	DT
18637	22773	24	statute	statute	NN
18637	22773	25	levying	levy	VBG
18637	22773	26	this	this	DT
18637	22773	27	"	"	``
18637	22773	28	tax	tax	NN
18637	22773	29	"	"	''
18637	22773	30	was	be	VBD
18637	22773	31	"	"	``
18637	22773	32	an	an	DT
18637	22773	33	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	22773	34	instrument	instrument	NN
18637	22773	35	of	of	IN
18637	22773	36	*	*	NFP
18637	22773	37	*	*	NFP
18637	22773	38	*	*	NFP
18637	22773	39	fiscal	fiscal	JJ
18637	22773	40	policy	policy	NN
18637	22773	41	*	*	NFP
18637	22773	42	*	*	NFP
18637	22773	43	*	*	NFP
18637	22773	44	Classification	classification	NN
18637	22773	45	by	by	IN
18637	22773	46	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22773	47	according	accord	VBG
18637	22773	48	to	to	IN
18637	22773	49	the	the	DT
18637	22773	50	nature	nature	NN
18637	22773	51	of	of	IN
18637	22773	52	the	the	DT
18637	22773	53	calling	calling	NN
18637	22773	54	affected	affect	VBN
18637	22773	55	by	by	IN
18637	22773	56	a	a	DT
18637	22773	57	tax	tax	NN
18637	22773	58	*	*	NFP
18637	22773	59	*	*	NFP
18637	22773	60	*	*	NFP
18637	22773	61	does	do	VBZ
18637	22773	62	not	not	RB
18637	22773	63	cease	cease	VB
18637	22773	64	to	to	TO
18637	22773	65	be	be	VB
18637	22773	66	permissible	permissible	JJ
18637	22773	67	because	because	IN
18637	22773	68	the	the	DT
18637	22773	69	line	line	NN
18637	22773	70	of	of	IN
18637	22773	71	division	division	NN
18637	22773	72	between	between	IN
18637	22773	73	callings	calling	NNS
18637	22773	74	to	to	TO
18637	22773	75	be	be	VB
18637	22773	76	favored	favor	VBN
18637	22773	77	and	and	CC
18637	22773	78	those	those	DT
18637	22773	79	to	to	TO
18637	22773	80	be	be	VB
18637	22773	81	reproved	reprove	VBN
18637	22773	82	corresponds	correspond	NNS
18637	22773	83	with	with	IN
18637	22773	84	a	a	DT
18637	22773	85	division	division	NN
18637	22773	86	between	between	IN
18637	22773	87	innocence	innocence	NN
18637	22773	88	and	and	CC
18637	22773	89	criminality	criminality	NN
18637	22773	90	under	under	IN
18637	22773	91	the	the	DT
18637	22773	92	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	22773	93	of	of	IN
18637	22773	94	a	a	DT
18637	22773	95	state	state	NN
18637	22773	96	.	.	.
18637	22773	97	"--Ibid	"--Ibid	''
18637	22773	98	.	.	.
18637	22774	1	294	294	CD
18637	22774	2	,	,	,
18637	22774	3	296	296	CD
18637	22774	4	,	,	,
18637	22774	5	297	297	CD
18637	22774	6	-	-	SYM
18637	22774	7	298	298	CD
18637	22774	8	.	.	.
18637	22775	1	In	in	IN
18637	22775	2	earlier	early	JJR
18637	22775	3	cases	case	NNS
18637	22775	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22775	5	was	be	VBD
18637	22775	6	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
18637	22775	7	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	22775	8	that	that	IN
18637	22775	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22775	10	also	also	RB
18637	22775	11	may	may	MD
18637	22775	12	tax	tax	VB
18637	22775	13	what	what	WP
18637	22775	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22775	15	forbids	forbid	VBZ
18637	22775	16	and	and	CC
18637	22775	17	that	that	IN
18637	22775	18	the	the	DT
18637	22775	19	basic	basic	JJ
18637	22775	20	tax	tax	NN
18637	22775	21	on	on	IN
18637	22775	22	distilled	distil	VBN
18637	22775	23	spirits	spirit	NNS
18637	22775	24	remained	remain	VBD
18637	22775	25	valid	valid	JJ
18637	22775	26	and	and	CC
18637	22775	27	enforceable	enforceable	JJ
18637	22775	28	during	during	IN
18637	22775	29	as	as	RB
18637	22775	30	well	well	RB
18637	22775	31	as	as	IN
18637	22775	32	after	after	IN
18637	22775	33	the	the	DT
18637	22775	34	life	life	NN
18637	22775	35	of	of	IN
18637	22775	36	the	the	DT
18637	22775	37	amendment--_See	amendment--_See	NNP
18637	22775	38	_	_	NNP
18637	22775	39	United	United	NNP
18637	22775	40	States	States	NNP
18637	22775	41	_	_	NNP
18637	22775	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	22775	43	_	_	NNP
18637	22775	44	Yuginovich	Yuginovich	NNP
18637	22775	45	,	,	,
18637	22775	46	256	256	CD
18637	22775	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22775	48	450	450	CD
18637	22775	49	,	,	,
18637	22775	50	462	462	CD
18637	22775	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22775	52	1921	1921	CD
18637	22775	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22775	54	;	;	:
18637	22775	55	United	United	NNP
18637	22775	56	States	States	NNP
18637	22775	57	_	_	NNP
18637	22775	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	22775	59	_	_	NNP
18637	22775	60	Stafoff	Stafoff	NNP
18637	22775	61	,	,	,
18637	22775	62	260	260	CD
18637	22775	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22775	64	477	477	CD
18637	22775	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22775	66	1923	1923	CD
18637	22775	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22775	68	;	;	:
18637	22775	69	United	United	NNP
18637	22775	70	States	States	NNP
18637	22775	71	_	_	NNP
18637	22775	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	22775	73	_	_	NNP
18637	22775	74	Rizzo	Rizzo	NNP
18637	22775	75	,	,	,
18637	22775	76	297	297	CD
18637	22775	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22775	78	530	530	CD
18637	22775	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22775	80	1936	1936	CD
18637	22775	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22775	82	.	.	.
18637	22776	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22776	2	9	9	CD
18637	22776	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22776	4	United	United	NNP
18637	22776	5	States	States	NNP
18637	22776	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22776	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22776	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22776	9	Mack	Mack	NNP
18637	22776	10	,	,	,
18637	22776	11	295	295	CD
18637	22776	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22776	13	480	480	CD
18637	22776	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22776	15	1935	1935	CD
18637	22776	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22776	17	.	.	.
18637	22777	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	22777	2	19	19	CD
18637	22777	3	EQUAL	EQUAL	NNP
18637	22777	4	SUFFRAGE	suffrage	NN
18637	22777	5	Page	Page	NNP
18637	22777	6	Origin	Origin	NNP
18637	22777	7	of	of	IN
18637	22777	8	the	the	DT
18637	22777	9	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22777	10	1219	1219	CD
18637	22777	11	Validity	validity	NN
18637	22777	12	of	of	IN
18637	22777	13	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	22777	14	1219	1219	CD
18637	22777	15	Effect	Effect	NNP
18637	22777	16	of	of	IN
18637	22777	17	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22777	18	1219	1219	CD
18637	22777	19	EQUAL	EQUAL	NNP
18637	22777	20	SUFFRAGE	SUFFRAGE	NNP
18637	22777	21	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22777	22	19	19	CD
18637	22777	23	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	22777	24	1	1	CD
18637	22777	25	.	.	.
18637	22778	1	The	the	DT
18637	22778	2	right	right	NN
18637	22778	3	of	of	IN
18637	22778	4	the	the	DT
18637	22778	5	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	22778	6	of	of	IN
18637	22778	7	the	the	DT
18637	22778	8	United	United	NNP
18637	22778	9	States	States	NNP
18637	22778	10	to	to	TO
18637	22778	11	vote	vote	VB
18637	22778	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	22778	13	not	not	RB
18637	22778	14	be	be	VB
18637	22778	15	denied	deny	VBN
18637	22778	16	or	or	CC
18637	22778	17	abridged	abridge	VBN
18637	22778	18	by	by	IN
18637	22778	19	the	the	DT
18637	22778	20	United	United	NNP
18637	22778	21	States	States	NNP
18637	22778	22	or	or	CC
18637	22778	23	by	by	IN
18637	22778	24	any	any	DT
18637	22778	25	State	State	NNP
18637	22778	26	on	on	IN
18637	22778	27	account	account	NN
18637	22778	28	of	of	IN
18637	22778	29	sex	sex	NN
18637	22778	30	.	.	.
18637	22779	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	22779	2	2	2	CD
18637	22779	3	.	.	.
18637	22780	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22780	2	shall	shall	MD
18637	22780	3	have	have	VB
18637	22780	4	power	power	NN
18637	22780	5	to	to	TO
18637	22780	6	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	22780	7	this	this	DT
18637	22780	8	article	article	NN
18637	22780	9	by	by	IN
18637	22780	10	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	22780	11	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	22780	12	.	.	.
18637	22781	1	Origin	origin	NN
18637	22781	2	of	of	IN
18637	22781	3	the	the	DT
18637	22781	4	Nineteenth	Nineteenth	NNP
18637	22781	5	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22781	6	The	the	DT
18637	22781	7	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	22781	8	of	of	IN
18637	22781	9	this	this	DT
18637	22781	10	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22781	11	is	be	VBZ
18637	22781	12	attributable	attributable	JJ
18637	22781	13	in	in	IN
18637	22781	14	great	great	JJ
18637	22781	15	measure	measure	NN
18637	22781	16	to	to	IN
18637	22781	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22781	18	advocacy	advocacy	NN
18637	22781	19	since	since	IN
18637	22781	20	1869	1869	CD
18637	22781	21	by	by	IN
18637	22781	22	certain	certain	JJ
18637	22781	23	long	long	JJ
18637	22781	24	term	term	NN
18637	22781	25	supporters	supporter	NNS
18637	22781	26	of	of	IN
18637	22781	27	women	woman	NNS
18637	22781	28	suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	22781	29	who	who	WP
18637	22781	30	had	have	VBD
18637	22781	31	despaired	despair	VBN
18637	22781	32	of	of	IN
18637	22781	33	attaining	attain	VBG
18637	22781	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22781	35	goal	goal	NN
18637	22781	36	through	through	IN
18637	22781	37	modification	modification	NN
18637	22781	38	of	of	IN
18637	22781	39	individual	individual	JJ
18637	22781	40	State	State	NNP
18637	22781	41	laws	law	NNS
18637	22781	42	.	.	.
18637	22782	1	Agitation	agitation	NN
18637	22782	2	in	in	IN
18637	22782	3	behalf	behalf	NN
18637	22782	4	of	of	IN
18637	22782	5	women	woman	NNS
18637	22782	6	suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	22782	7	was	be	VBD
18637	22782	8	recorded	record	VBN
18637	22782	9	as	as	RB
18637	22782	10	early	early	RB
18637	22782	11	as	as	IN
18637	22782	12	the	the	DT
18637	22782	13	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	22782	14	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	22782	15	,	,	,
18637	22782	16	but	but	CC
18637	22782	17	the	the	DT
18637	22782	18	initial	initial	JJ
18637	22782	19	results	result	NNS
18637	22782	20	were	be	VBD
18637	22782	21	meager	meager	JJ
18637	22782	22	.	.	.
18637	22783	1	Beginning	begin	VBG
18637	22783	2	in	in	IN
18637	22783	3	1838	1838	CD
18637	22783	4	,	,	,
18637	22783	5	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	22783	6	did	do	VBD
18637	22783	7	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	22783	8	women	woman	NNS
18637	22783	9	to	to	TO
18637	22783	10	vote	vote	VB
18637	22783	11	in	in	IN
18637	22783	12	school	school	NN
18637	22783	13	elections	election	NNS
18637	22783	14	,	,	,
18637	22783	15	and	and	CC
18637	22783	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22783	17	action	action	NN
18637	22783	18	was	be	VBD
18637	22783	19	later	later	RB
18637	22783	20	copied	copy	VBN
18637	22783	21	by	by	IN
18637	22783	22	a	a	DT
18637	22783	23	number	number	NN
18637	22783	24	of	of	IN
18637	22783	25	other	other	JJ
18637	22783	26	States	state	NNS
18637	22783	27	.	.	.
18637	22784	1	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	22784	2	in	in	IN
18637	22784	3	1887	1887	CD
18637	22784	4	even	even	RB
18637	22784	5	granted	grant	VBN
18637	22784	6	women	woman	NNS
18637	22784	7	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
18637	22784	8	rights	right	NNS
18637	22784	9	to	to	TO
18637	22784	10	vote	vote	VB
18637	22784	11	in	in	IN
18637	22784	12	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	22784	13	elections	election	NNS
18637	22784	14	.	.	.
18637	22785	1	Not	not	RB
18637	22785	2	until	until	IN
18637	22785	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	22785	4	,	,	,
18637	22785	5	however	however	RB
18637	22785	6	,	,	,
18637	22785	7	when	when	WRB
18637	22785	8	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	22785	9	,	,	,
18637	22785	10	as	as	IN
18637	22785	11	a	a	DT
18637	22785	12	territory	territory	NN
18637	22785	13	,	,	,
18637	22785	14	accorded	accorded	JJ
18637	22785	15	women	woman	NNS
18637	22785	16	suffrage	suffrage	VBP
18637	22785	17	on	on	IN
18637	22785	18	terms	term	NNS
18637	22785	19	of	of	IN
18637	22785	20	equality	equality	NN
18637	22785	21	with	with	IN
18637	22785	22	men	man	NNS
18637	22785	23	and	and	CC
18637	22785	24	continued	continue	VBD
18637	22785	25	to	to	TO
18637	22785	26	grant	grant	VB
18637	22785	27	such	such	JJ
18637	22785	28	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	22785	29	after	after	IN
18637	22785	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22785	31	admission	admission	NN
18637	22785	32	as	as	IN
18637	22785	33	a	a	DT
18637	22785	34	State	State	NNP
18637	22785	35	in	in	IN
18637	22785	36	1890	1890	CD
18637	22785	37	,	,	,
18637	22785	38	did	do	VBD
18637	22785	39	these	these	DT
18637	22785	40	advocates	advocate	NNS
18637	22785	41	register	register	VB
18637	22785	42	a	a	DT
18637	22785	43	notable	notable	JJ
18637	22785	44	victory	victory	NN
18637	22785	45	.	.	.
18637	22786	1	Progress	progress	NN
18637	22786	2	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	22786	3	proved	prove	VBD
18637	22786	4	discouraging	discouraging	NN
18637	22786	5	,	,	,
18637	22786	6	only	only	RB
18637	22786	7	ten	ten	CD
18637	22786	8	additional	additional	JJ
18637	22786	9	other	other	JJ
18637	22786	10	States	States	NNPS
18637	22786	11	having	have	VBG
18637	22786	12	been	be	VBN
18637	22786	13	added	add	VBN
18637	22786	14	to	to	IN
18637	22786	15	the	the	DT
18637	22786	16	fold	fold	NN
18637	22786	17	as	as	IN
18637	22786	18	of	of	IN
18637	22786	19	1914	1914	CD
18637	22786	20	;	;	:
18637	22786	21	and	and	CC
18637	22786	22	as	as	IN
18637	22786	23	a	a	DT
18637	22786	24	consequence	consequence	NN
18637	22786	25	sponsors	sponsor	NNS
18637	22786	26	of	of	IN
18637	22786	27	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22786	28	voting	voting	NN
18637	22786	29	rights	right	NNS
18637	22786	30	for	for	IN
18637	22786	31	women	woman	NNS
18637	22786	32	concentrated	concentrate	VBD
18637	22786	33	on	on	IN
18637	22786	34	obtaining	obtain	VBG
18637	22786	35	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	22786	36	of	of	IN
18637	22786	37	this	this	DT
18637	22786	38	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22786	39	.	.	.
18637	22787	1	Validity	validity	NN
18637	22787	2	of	of	IN
18637	22787	3	Adoption	Adoption	NNP
18637	22787	4	Cases	case	NNS
18637	22787	5	relating	relate	VBG
18637	22787	6	to	to	IN
18637	22787	7	this	this	DT
18637	22787	8	question	question	NN
18637	22787	9	are	be	VBP
18637	22787	10	presented	present	VBN
18637	22787	11	and	and	CC
18637	22787	12	discussed	discuss	VBN
18637	22787	13	under	under	IN
18637	22787	14	article	article	NN
18637	22787	15	V.	V.	NNP
18637	22787	16	Effect	Effect	NNP
18637	22787	17	of	of	IN
18637	22787	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22787	19	Although	although	IN
18637	22787	20	owning	own	VBG
18637	22787	21	that	that	IN
18637	22787	22	the	the	DT
18637	22787	23	Nineteenth	Nineteenth	NNP
18637	22787	24	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22787	25	"	"	''
18637	22787	26	applies	apply	VBZ
18637	22787	27	to	to	IN
18637	22787	28	men	man	NNS
18637	22787	29	and	and	CC
18637	22787	30	women	woman	NNS
18637	22787	31	alike	alike	RB
18637	22787	32	and	and	CC
18637	22787	33	by	by	IN
18637	22787	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22787	35	own	own	JJ
18637	22787	36	force	force	NN
18637	22787	37	supersedes	supersede	NNS
18637	22787	38	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	22787	39	measures	measure	NNS
18637	22787	40	,	,	,
18637	22787	41	whether	whether	IN
18637	22787	42	federal	federal	JJ
18637	22787	43	or	or	CC
18637	22787	44	State	State	NNP
18637	22787	45	,	,	,
18637	22787	46	"	"	''
18637	22787	47	the	the	DT
18637	22787	48	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22787	49	was	be	VBD
18637	22787	50	unable	unable	JJ
18637	22787	51	to	to	TO
18637	22787	52	concede	concede	VB
18637	22787	53	that	that	IN
18637	22787	54	a	a	DT
18637	22787	55	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	22787	56	statute	statute	NN
18637	22787	57	levying	levy	VBG
18637	22787	58	on	on	IN
18637	22787	59	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
18637	22787	60	of	of	IN
18637	22787	61	the	the	DT
18637	22787	62	State	State	NNP
18637	22787	63	a	a	DT
18637	22787	64	poll	poll	JJ
18637	22787	65	tax	tax	NN
18637	22787	66	payment	payment	NN
18637	22787	67	of	of	IN
18637	22787	68	which	which	WDT
18637	22787	69	is	be	VBZ
18637	22787	70	made	make	VBN
18637	22787	71	a	a	DT
18637	22787	72	prerequisite	prerequisite	NN
18637	22787	73	for	for	IN
18637	22787	74	voting	voting	NN
18637	22787	75	but	but	CC
18637	22787	76	exempting	exempt	VBG
18637	22787	77	females	female	NNS
18637	22787	78	who	who	WP
18637	22787	79	do	do	VBP
18637	22787	80	not	not	RB
18637	22787	81	register	register	VB
18637	22787	82	for	for	IN
18637	22787	83	voting	voting	NN
18637	22787	84	,	,	,
18637	22787	85	in	in	IN
18637	22787	86	any	any	DT
18637	22787	87	way	way	NN
18637	22787	88	abridged	abridge	VBD
18637	22787	89	the	the	DT
18637	22787	90	right	right	NN
18637	22787	91	of	of	IN
18637	22787	92	male	male	JJ
18637	22787	93	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	22787	94	to	to	TO
18637	22787	95	vote	vote	VB
18637	22787	96	on	on	IN
18637	22787	97	account	account	NN
18637	22787	98	of	of	IN
18637	22787	99	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22787	100	sex	sex	NN
18637	22787	101	.	.	.
18637	22788	1	To	to	TO
18637	22788	2	accept	accept	VB
18637	22788	3	the	the	DT
18637	22788	4	appellant	appellant	NN
18637	22788	5	's	's	POS
18637	22788	6	contention	contention	NN
18637	22788	7	,	,	,
18637	22788	8	the	the	DT
18637	22788	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22788	10	urged	urge	VBD
18637	22788	11	,	,	,
18637	22788	12	would	would	MD
18637	22788	13	make	make	VB
18637	22788	14	the	the	DT
18637	22788	15	Nineteenth	Nineteenth	NNP
18637	22788	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22788	17	a	a	DT
18637	22788	18	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	22788	19	on	on	IN
18637	22788	20	the	the	DT
18637	22788	21	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	22788	22	power	power	NN
18637	22788	23	.	.	.
18637	22789	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22789	2	1	1	LS
18637	22789	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22789	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	22789	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22789	6	1	1	CD
18637	22789	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22789	8	Breedlove	Breedlove	NNP
18637	22789	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22789	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	22789	11	_	_	NNP
18637	22789	12	Suttles	Suttles	NNP
18637	22789	13	,	,	,
18637	22789	14	302	302	CD
18637	22789	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22789	16	277	277	CD
18637	22789	17	,	,	,
18637	22789	18	283	283	CD
18637	22789	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	22789	20	284	284	CD
18637	22789	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22789	22	1937	1937	CD
18637	22789	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22789	24	.	.	.
18637	22790	1	Although	although	IN
18637	22790	2	other	other	JJ
18637	22790	3	interpretive	interpretive	JJ
18637	22790	4	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	22790	5	of	of	IN
18637	22790	6	federal	federal	JJ
18637	22790	7	courts	court	NNS
18637	22790	8	are	be	VBP
18637	22790	9	unavailable	unavailable	JJ
18637	22790	10	,	,	,
18637	22790	11	many	many	JJ
18637	22790	12	State	State	NNP
18637	22790	13	courts	court	NNS
18637	22790	14	,	,	,
18637	22790	15	taking	take	VBG
18637	22790	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22790	17	cue	cue	NN
18637	22790	18	from	from	IN
18637	22790	19	pronouncements	pronouncement	NNS
18637	22790	20	of	of	IN
18637	22790	21	the	the	DT
18637	22790	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	22790	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22790	24	as	as	IN
18637	22790	25	to	to	IN
18637	22790	26	the	the	DT
18637	22790	27	operative	operative	JJ
18637	22790	28	effect	effect	NN
18637	22790	29	of	of	IN
18637	22790	30	the	the	DT
18637	22790	31	similarly	similarly	RB
18637	22790	32	phrased	phrase	VBN
18637	22790	33	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	22790	34	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22790	35	,	,	,
18637	22790	36	have	have	VBP
18637	22790	37	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
18637	22790	38	that	that	IN
18637	22790	39	the	the	DT
18637	22790	40	Nineteenth	Nineteenth	NNP
18637	22790	41	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22790	42	did	do	VBD
18637	22790	43	not	not	RB
18637	22790	44	confer	confer	VB
18637	22790	45	upon	upon	IN
18637	22790	46	women	woman	NNS
18637	22790	47	the	the	DT
18637	22790	48	right	right	NN
18637	22790	49	to	to	TO
18637	22790	50	vote	vote	VB
18637	22790	51	but	but	CC
18637	22790	52	only	only	RB
18637	22790	53	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
18637	22790	54	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	22790	55	against	against	IN
18637	22790	56	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22790	57	in	in	IN
18637	22790	58	the	the	DT
18637	22790	59	drafting	drafting	NN
18637	22790	60	and	and	CC
18637	22790	61	administration	administration	NN
18637	22790	62	of	of	IN
18637	22790	63	laws	law	NNS
18637	22790	64	relating	relate	VBG
18637	22790	65	to	to	IN
18637	22790	66	suffrage	suffrage	JJ
18637	22790	67	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	22790	68	and	and	CC
18637	22790	69	the	the	DT
18637	22790	70	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	22790	71	of	of	IN
18637	22790	72	elections	election	NNS
18637	22790	73	.	.	.
18637	22791	1	Like	like	IN
18637	22791	2	the	the	DT
18637	22791	3	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	22791	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22791	5	,	,	,
18637	22791	6	the	the	DT
18637	22791	7	Nineteenth	Nineteenth	NNP
18637	22791	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22791	9	,	,	,
18637	22791	10	according	accord	VBG
18637	22791	11	to	to	IN
18637	22791	12	these	these	DT
18637	22791	13	State	State	NNP
18637	22791	14	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
18637	22791	15	,	,	,
18637	22791	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	22791	17	self	self	NN
18637	22791	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	22791	19	executing	execute	VBG
18637	22791	20	and	and	CC
18637	22791	21	by	by	IN
18637	22791	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22791	23	own	own	JJ
18637	22791	24	force	force	NN
18637	22791	25	and	and	CC
18637	22791	26	effect	effect	NN
18637	22791	27	legally	legally	RB
18637	22791	28	expunged	expunge	VBD
18637	22791	29	the	the	DT
18637	22791	30	word	word	NN
18637	22791	31	,	,	,
18637	22791	32	"	"	``
18637	22791	33	male	male	JJ
18637	22791	34	,	,	,
18637	22791	35	"	"	''
18637	22791	36	and	and	CC
18637	22791	37	the	the	DT
18637	22791	38	masculine	masculine	NN
18637	22791	39	pronoun	pronoun	NN
18637	22791	40	from	from	IN
18637	22791	41	State	State	NNP
18637	22791	42	constitutions	constitution	NNS
18637	22791	43	and	and	CC
18637	22791	44	laws	law	NNS
18637	22791	45	defining	define	VBG
18637	22791	46	voting	voting	NN
18637	22791	47	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	22791	48	and	and	CC
18637	22791	49	the	the	DT
18637	22791	50	right	right	NN
18637	22791	51	to	to	TO
18637	22791	52	vote	vote	VB
18637	22791	53	to	to	IN
18637	22791	54	the	the	DT
18637	22791	55	end	end	NN
18637	22791	56	that	that	IN
18637	22791	57	such	such	JJ
18637	22791	58	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	22791	59	now	now	RB
18637	22791	60	apply	apply	VBP
18637	22791	61	to	to	IN
18637	22791	62	both	both	DT
18637	22791	63	sexes.--_See	sexes.--_See	,
18637	22791	64	_	_	NNP
18637	22791	65	State	State	NNP
18637	22791	66	_	_	NNP
18637	22791	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	22791	68	_	_	NNP
18637	22791	69	Mittle	Mittle	NNP
18637	22791	70	,	,	,
18637	22791	71	120	120	CD
18637	22791	72	S.C.	South Carolina	NNP
18637	22791	73	526	526	CD
18637	22791	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22791	75	1922	1922	CD
18637	22791	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22791	77	;	;	:
18637	22791	78	writ	writ	VBN
18637	22791	79	of	of	IN
18637	22791	80	error	error	NN
18637	22791	81	dismissed	dismiss	VBD
18637	22791	82	,	,	,
18637	22791	83	260	260	CD
18637	22791	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22791	85	705	705	CD
18637	22791	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22791	87	1922	1922	CD
18637	22791	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22791	89	;	;	:
18637	22791	90	Graves	Graves	NNPS
18637	22791	91	_	_	NNP
18637	22791	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	22791	93	_	_	NNP
18637	22791	94	Eubank	Eubank	NNP
18637	22791	95	,	,	,
18637	22791	96	205	205	CD
18637	22791	97	Ala.	Alabama	NNP
18637	22791	98	174	174	CD
18637	22791	99	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22791	100	1921	1921	CD
18637	22791	101	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22791	102	;	;	:
18637	22791	103	in	in	IN
18637	22791	104	re	re	IN
18637	22791	105	Cavellier	Cavellier	NNP
18637	22791	106	,	,	,
18637	22791	107	159	159	CD
18637	22791	108	Misc	Misc	NNP
18637	22791	109	.	.	.
18637	22792	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22792	2	N.Y.	New York	NNP
18637	22792	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22792	4	212	212	CD
18637	22792	5	;	;	:
18637	22792	6	287	287	CD
18637	22792	7	N.Y.S.	n.y.s.	NN
18637	22793	1	739	739	CD
18637	22793	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22793	3	1936	1936	CD
18637	22793	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22793	5	.	.	.
18637	22794	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	22794	2	20	20	CD
18637	22794	3	COMMENCEMENT	commencement	NN
18637	22794	4	OF	of	IN
18637	22794	5	THE	the	DT
18637	22794	6	TERMS	term	NNS
18637	22794	7	OF	of	IN
18637	22794	8	THE	the	DT
18637	22794	9	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	22794	10	,	,	,
18637	22794	11	VICE	VICE	NNP
18637	22794	12	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	22794	13	,	,	,
18637	22794	14	AND	and	CC
18637	22794	15	MEMBERS	member	NNS
18637	22794	16	OF	of	IN
18637	22794	17	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	22794	18	,	,	,
18637	22794	19	ETC	ETC	NNP
18637	22794	20	.	.	.
18637	22795	1	Page	page	NN
18637	22795	2	Extension	extension	NN
18637	22795	3	of	of	IN
18637	22795	4	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	22795	5	succession	succession	NN
18637	22795	6	1225	1225	CD
18637	22795	7	COMMENCEMENT	commencement	NN
18637	22795	8	OF	of	IN
18637	22795	9	THE	the	DT
18637	22795	10	TERMS	term	NNS
18637	22795	11	OF	of	IN
18637	22795	12	THE	the	DT
18637	22795	13	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	22795	14	,	,	,
18637	22795	15	VICE	VICE	NNP
18637	22795	16	PRESIDENT	PRESIDENT	NNP
18637	22795	17	,	,	,
18637	22795	18	AND	and	CC
18637	22795	19	MEMBERS	member	NNS
18637	22795	20	OF	of	IN
18637	22795	21	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	22795	22	,	,	,
18637	22795	23	ETC	ETC	NNP
18637	22795	24	.	.	.
18637	22796	1	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22796	2	20	20	CD
18637	22796	3	Section	Section	NNP
18637	22796	4	1	1	CD
18637	22796	5	.	.	.
18637	22797	1	The	the	DT
18637	22797	2	terms	term	NNS
18637	22797	3	of	of	IN
18637	22797	4	the	the	DT
18637	22797	5	President	President	NNP
18637	22797	6	and	and	CC
18637	22797	7	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	22797	8	President	President	NNP
18637	22797	9	shall	shall	MD
18637	22797	10	end	end	VB
18637	22797	11	at	at	IN
18637	22797	12	noon	noon	NN
18637	22797	13	on	on	IN
18637	22797	14	the	the	DT
18637	22797	15	20th	20th	JJ
18637	22797	16	day	day	NN
18637	22797	17	of	of	IN
18637	22797	18	January	January	NNP
18637	22797	19	,	,	,
18637	22797	20	and	and	CC
18637	22797	21	the	the	DT
18637	22797	22	terms	term	NNS
18637	22797	23	of	of	IN
18637	22797	24	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	22797	25	and	and	CC
18637	22797	26	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	22797	27	at	at	IN
18637	22797	28	noon	noon	NN
18637	22797	29	on	on	IN
18637	22797	30	the	the	DT
18637	22797	31	3d	3d	JJ
18637	22797	32	day	day	NN
18637	22797	33	of	of	IN
18637	22797	34	January	January	NNP
18637	22797	35	,	,	,
18637	22797	36	of	of	IN
18637	22797	37	the	the	DT
18637	22797	38	years	year	NNS
18637	22797	39	in	in	IN
18637	22797	40	which	which	WDT
18637	22797	41	such	such	JJ
18637	22797	42	terms	term	NNS
18637	22797	43	would	would	MD
18637	22797	44	have	have	VB
18637	22797	45	ended	end	VBN
18637	22797	46	if	if	IN
18637	22797	47	this	this	DT
18637	22797	48	article	article	NN
18637	22797	49	had	have	VBD
18637	22797	50	not	not	RB
18637	22797	51	been	be	VBN
18637	22797	52	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	22797	53	;	;	:
18637	22797	54	and	and	CC
18637	22797	55	the	the	DT
18637	22797	56	terms	term	NNS
18637	22797	57	of	of	IN
18637	22797	58	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22797	59	successors	successor	NNS
18637	22797	60	shall	shall	MD
18637	22797	61	then	then	RB
18637	22797	62	begin	begin	VB
18637	22797	63	.	.	.
18637	22798	1	Section	section	NN
18637	22798	2	2	2	CD
18637	22798	3	.	.	.
18637	22799	1	The	the	DT
18637	22799	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22799	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	22799	4	assemble	assemble	VB
18637	22799	5	at	at	IN
18637	22799	6	least	least	JJS
18637	22799	7	once	once	RB
18637	22799	8	in	in	IN
18637	22799	9	every	every	DT
18637	22799	10	year	year	NN
18637	22799	11	,	,	,
18637	22799	12	and	and	CC
18637	22799	13	such	such	JJ
18637	22799	14	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	22799	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	22799	16	begin	begin	VB
18637	22799	17	at	at	IN
18637	22799	18	noon	noon	NN
18637	22799	19	on	on	IN
18637	22799	20	the	the	DT
18637	22799	21	3d	3d	JJ
18637	22799	22	day	day	NN
18637	22799	23	of	of	IN
18637	22799	24	January	January	NNP
18637	22799	25	,	,	,
18637	22799	26	unless	unless	IN
18637	22799	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22799	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	22799	29	by	by	IN
18637	22799	30	law	law	NN
18637	22799	31	appoint	appoint	VB
18637	22799	32	a	a	DT
18637	22799	33	different	different	JJ
18637	22799	34	day	day	NN
18637	22799	35	.	.	.
18637	22800	1	Section	section	NN
18637	22800	2	3	3	CD
18637	22800	3	.	.	.
18637	22801	1	If	if	IN
18637	22801	2	,	,	,
18637	22801	3	at	at	IN
18637	22801	4	the	the	DT
18637	22801	5	time	time	NN
18637	22801	6	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	22801	7	for	for	IN
18637	22801	8	the	the	DT
18637	22801	9	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	22801	10	of	of	IN
18637	22801	11	the	the	DT
18637	22801	12	term	term	NN
18637	22801	13	of	of	IN
18637	22801	14	the	the	DT
18637	22801	15	President	President	NNP
18637	22801	16	,	,	,
18637	22801	17	the	the	DT
18637	22801	18	President	President	NNP
18637	22801	19	elect	elect	NN
18637	22801	20	shall	shall	MD
18637	22801	21	have	have	VB
18637	22801	22	died	die	VBN
18637	22801	23	,	,	,
18637	22801	24	the	the	DT
18637	22801	25	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	22801	26	President	President	NNP
18637	22801	27	elect	elect	NNP
18637	22801	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	22801	29	become	become	VB
18637	22801	30	President	President	NNP
18637	22801	31	.	.	.
18637	22802	1	If	if	IN
18637	22802	2	a	a	DT
18637	22802	3	President	President	NNP
18637	22802	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	22802	5	not	not	RB
18637	22802	6	have	have	VB
18637	22802	7	been	be	VBN
18637	22802	8	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	22802	9	before	before	IN
18637	22802	10	the	the	DT
18637	22802	11	time	time	NN
18637	22802	12	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	22802	13	for	for	IN
18637	22802	14	the	the	DT
18637	22802	15	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	22802	16	of	of	IN
18637	22802	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22802	18	term	term	NN
18637	22802	19	,	,	,
18637	22802	20	or	or	CC
18637	22802	21	if	if	IN
18637	22802	22	the	the	DT
18637	22802	23	President	President	NNP
18637	22802	24	elect	elect	NN
18637	22802	25	shall	shall	MD
18637	22802	26	have	have	VB
18637	22802	27	failed	fail	VBN
18637	22802	28	to	to	TO
18637	22802	29	qualify	qualify	VB
18637	22802	30	,	,	,
18637	22802	31	then	then	RB
18637	22802	32	the	the	DT
18637	22802	33	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	22802	34	President	President	NNP
18637	22802	35	elect	elect	NNP
18637	22802	36	shall	shall	MD
18637	22802	37	act	act	VB
18637	22802	38	as	as	IN
18637	22802	39	President	President	NNP
18637	22802	40	until	until	IN
18637	22802	41	a	a	DT
18637	22802	42	President	President	NNP
18637	22802	43	shall	shall	MD
18637	22802	44	have	have	VB
18637	22802	45	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	22802	46	;	;	:
18637	22802	47	and	and	CC
18637	22802	48	the	the	DT
18637	22802	49	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22802	50	may	may	MD
18637	22802	51	by	by	IN
18637	22802	52	law	law	NN
18637	22802	53	provide	provide	VB
18637	22802	54	for	for	IN
18637	22802	55	the	the	DT
18637	22802	56	case	case	NN
18637	22802	57	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	22802	58	neither	neither	CC
18637	22802	59	a	a	DT
18637	22802	60	President	President	NNP
18637	22802	61	elect	elect	NN
18637	22802	62	nor	nor	CC
18637	22802	63	a	a	DT
18637	22802	64	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	22802	65	President	President	NNP
18637	22802	66	elect	elect	NN
18637	22802	67	shall	shall	MD
18637	22802	68	have	have	VB
18637	22802	69	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	22802	70	,	,	,
18637	22802	71	declaring	declare	VBG
18637	22802	72	who	who	WP
18637	22802	73	shall	shall	MD
18637	22802	74	then	then	RB
18637	22802	75	act	act	VB
18637	22802	76	as	as	IN
18637	22802	77	President	President	NNP
18637	22802	78	,	,	,
18637	22802	79	or	or	CC
18637	22802	80	the	the	DT
18637	22802	81	manner	manner	NN
18637	22802	82	in	in	IN
18637	22802	83	which	which	WDT
18637	22802	84	one	one	NN
18637	22802	85	who	who	WP
18637	22802	86	is	be	VBZ
18637	22802	87	to	to	TO
18637	22802	88	act	act	VB
18637	22802	89	shall	shall	MD
18637	22802	90	be	be	VB
18637	22802	91	selected	select	VBN
18637	22802	92	,	,	,
18637	22802	93	and	and	CC
18637	22802	94	such	such	JJ
18637	22802	95	person	person	NN
18637	22802	96	shall	shall	MD
18637	22802	97	act	act	VB
18637	22802	98	accordingly	accordingly	RB
18637	22802	99	until	until	IN
18637	22802	100	a	a	DT
18637	22802	101	President	President	NNP
18637	22802	102	or	or	CC
18637	22802	103	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	22802	104	President	President	NNP
18637	22802	105	shall	shall	MD
18637	22802	106	have	have	VB
18637	22802	107	qualified	qualify	VBN
18637	22802	108	.	.	.
18637	22803	1	Section	section	NN
18637	22803	2	4	4	CD
18637	22803	3	.	.	.
18637	22804	1	The	the	DT
18637	22804	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22804	3	may	may	MD
18637	22804	4	by	by	IN
18637	22804	5	law	law	NN
18637	22804	6	provide	provide	VB
18637	22804	7	for	for	IN
18637	22804	8	the	the	DT
18637	22804	9	case	case	NN
18637	22804	10	of	of	IN
18637	22804	11	the	the	DT
18637	22804	12	death	death	NN
18637	22804	13	of	of	IN
18637	22804	14	any	any	DT
18637	22804	15	of	of	IN
18637	22804	16	the	the	DT
18637	22804	17	persons	person	NNS
18637	22804	18	from	from	IN
18637	22804	19	whom	whom	WP
18637	22804	20	the	the	DT
18637	22804	21	House	House	NNP
18637	22804	22	of	of	IN
18637	22804	23	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	22804	24	may	may	MD
18637	22804	25	choose	choose	VB
18637	22804	26	a	a	DT
18637	22804	27	President	President	NNP
18637	22804	28	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	22804	29	the	the	DT
18637	22804	30	right	right	NN
18637	22804	31	of	of	IN
18637	22804	32	choice	choice	NN
18637	22804	33	shall	shall	MD
18637	22804	34	have	have	VB
18637	22804	35	devolved	devolve	VBN
18637	22804	36	upon	upon	IN
18637	22804	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22804	38	,	,	,
18637	22804	39	and	and	CC
18637	22804	40	for	for	IN
18637	22804	41	the	the	DT
18637	22804	42	case	case	NN
18637	22804	43	of	of	IN
18637	22804	44	the	the	DT
18637	22804	45	death	death	NN
18637	22804	46	of	of	IN
18637	22804	47	any	any	DT
18637	22804	48	of	of	IN
18637	22804	49	the	the	DT
18637	22804	50	persons	person	NNS
18637	22804	51	from	from	IN
18637	22804	52	whom	whom	WP
18637	22804	53	the	the	DT
18637	22804	54	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	22804	55	may	may	MD
18637	22804	56	choose	choose	VB
18637	22804	57	a	a	DT
18637	22804	58	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	22804	59	President	President	NNP
18637	22804	60	whenever	whenever	WRB
18637	22804	61	the	the	DT
18637	22804	62	right	right	NN
18637	22804	63	of	of	IN
18637	22804	64	choice	choice	NN
18637	22804	65	shall	shall	MD
18637	22804	66	have	have	VB
18637	22804	67	devolved	devolve	VBN
18637	22804	68	upon	upon	IN
18637	22804	69	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22804	70	.	.	.
18637	22805	1	Section	section	NN
18637	22805	2	5	5	CD
18637	22805	3	.	.	.
18637	22806	1	Sections	section	NNS
18637	22806	2	1	1	CD
18637	22806	3	and	and	CC
18637	22806	4	2	2	CD
18637	22806	5	shall	shall	MD
18637	22806	6	take	take	VB
18637	22806	7	effect	effect	NN
18637	22806	8	on	on	IN
18637	22806	9	the	the	DT
18637	22806	10	15th	15th	JJ
18637	22806	11	day	day	NN
18637	22806	12	of	of	IN
18637	22806	13	October	October	NNP
18637	22806	14	following	follow	VBG
18637	22806	15	the	the	DT
18637	22806	16	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	22806	17	of	of	IN
18637	22806	18	this	this	DT
18637	22806	19	article	article	NN
18637	22806	20	.	.	.
18637	22807	1	Section	section	NN
18637	22807	2	6	6	CD
18637	22807	3	.	.	.
18637	22808	1	This	this	DT
18637	22808	2	article	article	NN
18637	22808	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	22808	4	be	be	VB
18637	22808	5	inoperative	inoperative	JJ
18637	22808	6	unless	unless	IN
18637	22808	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22808	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	22808	9	have	have	VB
18637	22808	10	been	be	VBN
18637	22808	11	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	22808	12	as	as	IN
18637	22808	13	an	an	DT
18637	22808	14	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22808	15	to	to	IN
18637	22808	16	the	the	DT
18637	22808	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22808	18	by	by	IN
18637	22808	19	the	the	DT
18637	22808	20	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	22808	21	of	of	IN
18637	22808	22	three	three	CD
18637	22808	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	22808	24	fourths	fourth	NNS
18637	22808	25	of	of	IN
18637	22808	26	the	the	DT
18637	22808	27	several	several	JJ
18637	22808	28	States	state	NNS
18637	22808	29	within	within	IN
18637	22808	30	seven	seven	CD
18637	22808	31	years	year	NNS
18637	22808	32	from	from	IN
18637	22808	33	the	the	DT
18637	22808	34	date	date	NN
18637	22808	35	of	of	IN
18637	22808	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22808	37	submission	submission	NN
18637	22808	38	.	.	.
18637	22809	1	Extension	extension	NN
18637	22809	2	of	of	IN
18637	22809	3	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	22809	4	Succession	Succession	NNP
18637	22809	5	Pursuant	Pursuant	NNP
18637	22809	6	to	to	IN
18637	22809	7	the	the	DT
18637	22809	8	authority	authority	NN
18637	22809	9	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	22809	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	22809	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22809	12	by	by	IN
18637	22809	13	section	section	NN
18637	22809	14	3	3	CD
18637	22809	15	of	of	IN
18637	22809	16	this	this	DT
18637	22809	17	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22809	18	,	,	,
18637	22809	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22809	20	shaped	shape	VBD
18637	22809	21	the	the	DT
18637	22809	22	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
18637	22809	23	Succession	Succession	NNP
18637	22809	24	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22809	25	of	of	IN
18637	22809	26	1948[1	1948[1	NNP
18637	22809	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22809	28	to	to	TO
18637	22809	29	meet	meet	VB
18637	22809	30	the	the	DT
18637	22809	31	situation	situation	NN
18637	22809	32	which	which	WDT
18637	22809	33	would	would	MD
18637	22809	34	arise	arise	VB
18637	22809	35	from	from	IN
18637	22809	36	the	the	DT
18637	22809	37	failure	failure	NN
18637	22809	38	of	of	IN
18637	22809	39	both	both	DT
18637	22809	40	President	President	NNP
18637	22809	41	elect	elect	NNP
18637	22809	42	and	and	CC
18637	22809	43	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	22809	44	President	President	NNP
18637	22809	45	elect	elect	VB
18637	22809	46	to	to	TO
18637	22809	47	qualify	qualify	VB
18637	22809	48	on	on	IN
18637	22809	49	or	or	CC
18637	22809	50	before	before	IN
18637	22809	51	the	the	DT
18637	22809	52	time	time	NN
18637	22809	53	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	22809	54	for	for	IN
18637	22809	55	the	the	DT
18637	22809	56	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	22809	57	of	of	IN
18637	22809	58	the	the	DT
18637	22809	59	new	new	JJ
18637	22809	60	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	22809	61	term	term	NN
18637	22809	62	.	.	.
18637	22810	1	Notes	note	NNS
18637	22810	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22810	3	1	1	CD
18637	22810	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22810	5	62	62	CD
18637	22810	6	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22810	7	.	.	.
18637	22811	1	672	672	CD
18637	22811	2	,	,	,
18637	22811	3	677	677	CD
18637	22811	4	;	;	SYM
18637	22811	5	3	3	CD
18637	22811	6	U.S.C.A.	U.S.C.A.	NNP
18637	22812	1	19	19	CD
18637	22812	2	;	;	:
18637	22812	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22812	4	See	See	NNP
18637	22812	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22812	6	p.	p.	NN
18637	22812	7	388	388	CD
18637	22812	8	.	.	.
18637	22813	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	22813	2	21	21	CD
18637	22813	3	REPEAL	REPEAL	NNP
18637	22813	4	OF	of	IN
18637	22813	5	EIGHTEENTH	EIGHTEENTH	NNP
18637	22813	6	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	22813	7	Page	Page	NNP
18637	22813	8	Effect	Effect	NNP
18637	22813	9	of	of	IN
18637	22813	10	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	22813	11	1231	1231	CD
18637	22813	12	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	22813	13	of	of	IN
18637	22813	14	the	the	DT
18637	22813	15	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	22813	16	power	power	NN
18637	22813	17	conferred	confer	VBN
18637	22813	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	22813	19	the	the	DT
18637	22813	20	States	States	NNP
18637	22813	21	1231	1231	CD
18637	22813	22	Discrimination	Discrimination	NNP
18637	22813	23	as	as	IN
18637	22813	24	between	between	IN
18637	22813	25	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	22813	26	and	and	CC
18637	22813	27	imported	import	VBN
18637	22813	28	products	product	NNS
18637	22813	29	1231	1231	CD
18637	22813	30	Regulation	regulation	NN
18637	22813	31	of	of	IN
18637	22813	32	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	22813	33	and	and	CC
18637	22813	34	"	"	``
18637	22813	35	through	through	IN
18637	22813	36	"	"	''
18637	22813	37	shipments	shipment	NNS
18637	22813	38	1231	1231	CD
18637	22813	39	Regulation	regulation	NN
18637	22813	40	of	of	IN
18637	22813	41	imports	import	NNS
18637	22813	42	destined	destine	VBN
18637	22813	43	for	for	IN
18637	22813	44	a	a	DT
18637	22813	45	federal	federal	JJ
18637	22813	46	area	area	NN
18637	22813	47	1233	1233	CD
18637	22813	48	Effect	effect	NN
18637	22813	49	on	on	IN
18637	22813	50	federal	federal	JJ
18637	22813	51	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	22813	52	1233	1233	CD
18637	22813	53	REPEAL	REPEAL	NNP
18637	22813	54	OF	of	IN
18637	22813	55	EIGHTEENTH	EIGHTEENTH	NNP
18637	22813	56	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	22813	57	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22813	58	21	21	CD
18637	22813	59	Section	Section	NNP
18637	22813	60	1	1	CD
18637	22813	61	.	.	.
18637	22814	1	The	the	DT
18637	22814	2	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
18637	22814	3	article	article	NN
18637	22814	4	of	of	IN
18637	22814	5	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22814	6	to	to	IN
18637	22814	7	the	the	DT
18637	22814	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22814	9	of	of	IN
18637	22814	10	the	the	DT
18637	22814	11	United	United	NNP
18637	22814	12	States	States	NNP
18637	22814	13	is	be	VBZ
18637	22814	14	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	22814	15	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	22814	16	.	.	.
18637	22815	1	Section	section	NN
18637	22815	2	2	2	CD
18637	22815	3	.	.	.
18637	22816	1	The	the	DT
18637	22816	2	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	22816	3	or	or	CC
18637	22816	4	importation	importation	NN
18637	22816	5	into	into	IN
18637	22816	6	any	any	DT
18637	22816	7	State	State	NNP
18637	22816	8	,	,	,
18637	22816	9	Territory	territory	NN
18637	22816	10	,	,	,
18637	22816	11	or	or	CC
18637	22816	12	possession	possession	NN
18637	22816	13	of	of	IN
18637	22816	14	the	the	DT
18637	22816	15	United	United	NNP
18637	22816	16	States	States	NNP
18637	22816	17	for	for	IN
18637	22816	18	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	22816	19	or	or	CC
18637	22816	20	use	use	VBP
18637	22816	21	therein	therein	RB
18637	22816	22	of	of	IN
18637	22816	23	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	22816	24	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	22816	25	,	,	,
18637	22816	26	in	in	IN
18637	22816	27	violation	violation	NN
18637	22816	28	of	of	IN
18637	22816	29	the	the	DT
18637	22816	30	laws	law	NNS
18637	22816	31	thereof	thereof	RB
18637	22816	32	,	,	,
18637	22816	33	is	be	VBZ
18637	22816	34	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	22816	35	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	22816	36	.	.	.
18637	22817	1	Section	section	NN
18637	22817	2	3	3	CD
18637	22817	3	.	.	.
18637	22818	1	This	this	DT
18637	22818	2	article	article	NN
18637	22818	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	22818	4	be	be	VB
18637	22818	5	inoperative	inoperative	JJ
18637	22818	6	unless	unless	IN
18637	22818	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22818	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	22818	9	have	have	VB
18637	22818	10	been	be	VBN
18637	22818	11	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	22818	12	as	as	IN
18637	22818	13	an	an	DT
18637	22818	14	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22818	15	to	to	IN
18637	22818	16	the	the	DT
18637	22818	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22818	18	by	by	IN
18637	22818	19	conventions	convention	NNS
18637	22818	20	in	in	IN
18637	22818	21	the	the	DT
18637	22818	22	several	several	JJ
18637	22818	23	States	States	NNPS
18637	22818	24	,	,	,
18637	22818	25	as	as	IN
18637	22818	26	provided	provide	VBN
18637	22818	27	in	in	IN
18637	22818	28	the	the	DT
18637	22818	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22818	30	,	,	,
18637	22818	31	within	within	IN
18637	22818	32	seven	seven	CD
18637	22818	33	years	year	NNS
18637	22818	34	from	from	IN
18637	22818	35	the	the	DT
18637	22818	36	date	date	NN
18637	22818	37	of	of	IN
18637	22818	38	the	the	DT
18637	22818	39	submission	submission	NN
18637	22818	40	hereof	hereof	NNP
18637	22818	41	to	to	IN
18637	22818	42	the	the	DT
18637	22818	43	States	States	NNP
18637	22818	44	by	by	IN
18637	22818	45	the	the	DT
18637	22818	46	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22818	47	.	.	.
18637	22819	1	Effect	effect	NN
18637	22819	2	of	of	IN
18637	22819	3	Repeal	Repeal	NNP
18637	22819	4	The	the	DT
18637	22819	5	operative	operative	JJ
18637	22819	6	effect	effect	NN
18637	22819	7	of	of	IN
18637	22819	8	section	section	NN
18637	22819	9	1	1	CD
18637	22819	10	,	,	,
18637	22819	11	repealing	repeal	VBG
18637	22819	12	the	the	DT
18637	22819	13	Eighteenth	Eighteenth	NNP
18637	22819	14	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22819	15	,	,	,
18637	22819	16	is	be	VBZ
18637	22819	17	considered	consider	VBN
18637	22819	18	under	under	IN
18637	22819	19	the	the	DT
18637	22819	20	latter	latter	JJ
18637	22819	21	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22819	22	.	.	.
18637	22820	1	Scope	scope	NN
18637	22820	2	of	of	IN
18637	22820	3	the	the	DT
18637	22820	4	Regulatory	Regulatory	NNP
18637	22820	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	22820	6	Conferred	Conferred	NNP
18637	22820	7	Upon	upon	IN
18637	22820	8	the	the	DT
18637	22820	9	States	state	NNS
18637	22820	10	DISCRIMINATION	discrimination	VBP
18637	22820	11	AS	as	IN
18637	22820	12	BETWEEN	between	IN
18637	22820	13	DOMESTIC	domestic	NN
18637	22820	14	AND	and	CC
18637	22820	15	IMPORTED	imported	JJ
18637	22820	16	PRODUCTS	PRODUCTS	NNP
18637	22820	17	In	in	IN
18637	22820	18	a	a	DT
18637	22820	19	series	series	NN
18637	22820	20	of	of	IN
18637	22820	21	interpretive	interpretive	JJ
18637	22820	22	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	22820	23	rendered	render	VBN
18637	22820	24	shortly	shortly	RB
18637	22820	25	after	after	IN
18637	22820	26	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	22820	27	of	of	IN
18637	22820	28	this	this	DT
18637	22820	29	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22820	30	,	,	,
18637	22820	31	the	the	DT
18637	22820	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22820	33	established	establish	VBD
18637	22820	34	the	the	DT
18637	22820	35	proposition	proposition	NN
18637	22820	36	that	that	IN
18637	22820	37	States	state	NNS
18637	22820	38	are	be	VBP
18637	22820	39	competent	competent	JJ
18637	22820	40	to	to	TO
18637	22820	41	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	22820	42	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	22820	43	discriminating	discriminate	VBG
18637	22820	44	against	against	IN
18637	22820	45	imported	import	VBN
18637	22820	46	intoxicating	intoxicating	NN
18637	22820	47	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	22820	48	in	in	IN
18637	22820	49	favor	favor	NN
18637	22820	50	of	of	IN
18637	22820	51	those	those	DT
18637	22820	52	of	of	IN
18637	22820	53	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	22820	54	origin	origin	NN
18637	22820	55	and	and	CC
18637	22820	56	that	that	IN
18637	22820	57	such	such	JJ
18637	22820	58	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	22820	59	offends	offend	VBZ
18637	22820	60	neither	neither	CC
18637	22820	61	the	the	DT
18637	22820	62	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	22820	63	clause	clause	NN
18637	22820	64	of	of	IN
18637	22820	65	article	article	NN
18637	22820	66	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22820	67	nor	nor	CC
18637	22820	68	the	the	DT
18637	22820	69	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22820	70	protection	protection	NN
18637	22820	71	and	and	CC
18637	22820	72	due	due	JJ
18637	22820	73	process	process	NN
18637	22820	74	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	22820	75	of	of	IN
18637	22820	76	the	the	DT
18637	22820	77	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	22820	78	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22820	79	.	.	.
18637	22821	1	Thus	thus	RB
18637	22821	2	,	,	,
18637	22821	3	in	in	IN
18637	22821	4	State	State	NNP
18637	22821	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	22821	6	of	of	IN
18637	22821	7	Equalization	Equalization	NNP
18637	22821	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22821	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22821	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22821	11	Young	Young	NNP
18637	22821	12	's	's	POS
18637	22821	13	Market	Market	NNP
18637	22821	14	Co.[1	Co.[1	NNP
18637	22821	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22821	16	a	a	DT
18637	22821	17	California	California	NNP
18637	22821	18	statute	statute	NN
18637	22821	19	was	be	VBD
18637	22821	20	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	22821	21	which	which	WDT
18637	22821	22	exacted	exact	VBD
18637	22821	23	a	a	DT
18637	22821	24	$	$	$
18637	22821	25	500	500	CD
18637	22821	26	annual	annual	JJ
18637	22821	27	license	license	NN
18637	22821	28	fee	fee	NN
18637	22821	29	for	for	IN
18637	22821	30	the	the	DT
18637	22821	31	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	22821	32	of	of	IN
18637	22821	33	importing	import	VBG
18637	22821	34	beer	beer	NN
18637	22821	35	from	from	IN
18637	22821	36	other	other	JJ
18637	22821	37	States	States	NNPS
18637	22821	38	and	and	CC
18637	22821	39	a	a	DT
18637	22821	40	$	$	$
18637	22821	41	750	750	CD
18637	22821	42	fee	fee	NN
18637	22821	43	for	for	IN
18637	22821	44	the	the	DT
18637	22821	45	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	22821	46	of	of	IN
18637	22821	47	manufacturing	manufacture	VBG
18637	22821	48	beer	beer	NN
18637	22821	49	;	;	:
18637	22821	50	and	and	CC
18637	22821	51	in	in	IN
18637	22821	52	Mahoney	Mahoney	NNP
18637	22821	53	_	_	NNP
18637	22821	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	22821	55	_	_	NNP
18637	22821	56	Triner	Triner	NNP
18637	22821	57	Corp.[2	Corp.[2	NNP
18637	22821	58	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22821	59	a	a	DT
18637	22821	60	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	22821	61	statute	statute	NN
18637	22821	62	was	be	VBD
18637	22821	63	sustained	sustained	JJ
18637	22821	64	which	which	WDT
18637	22821	65	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	22821	66	a	a	DT
18637	22821	67	licensed	license	VBN
18637	22821	68	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
18637	22821	69	or	or	CC
18637	22821	70	wholesaler	wholesaler	NN
18637	22821	71	from	from	IN
18637	22821	72	importing	import	VBG
18637	22821	73	any	any	DT
18637	22821	74	brand	brand	NN
18637	22821	75	of	of	IN
18637	22821	76	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	22821	77	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	22821	78	containing	contain	VBG
18637	22821	79	more	more	JJR
18637	22821	80	than	than	IN
18637	22821	81	25	25	CD
18637	22821	82	%	%	NN
18637	22821	83	of	of	IN
18637	22821	84	alcohol	alcohol	NN
18637	22821	85	by	by	IN
18637	22821	86	volume	volume	NN
18637	22821	87	and	and	CC
18637	22821	88	ready	ready	JJ
18637	22821	89	for	for	IN
18637	22821	90	sale	sale	NN
18637	22821	91	without	without	IN
18637	22821	92	further	further	JJ
18637	22821	93	processing	processing	NN
18637	22821	94	,	,	,
18637	22821	95	unless	unless	IN
18637	22821	96	such	such	JJ
18637	22821	97	brand	brand	NN
18637	22821	98	was	be	VBD
18637	22821	99	registered	register	VBN
18637	22821	100	in	in	IN
18637	22821	101	the	the	DT
18637	22821	102	United	United	NNP
18637	22821	103	States	States	NNP
18637	22821	104	Patent	Patent	NNP
18637	22821	105	Office	Office	NNP
18637	22821	106	.	.	.
18637	22822	1	Also	also	RB
18637	22822	2	validated	validate	VBN
18637	22822	3	in	in	IN
18637	22822	4	Indianapolis	Indianapolis	NNP
18637	22822	5	Brewing	Brewing	NNP
18637	22822	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22822	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22822	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	22822	9	_	_	NNP
18637	22822	10	Liquor	Liquor	NNP
18637	22822	11	Commission[3	Commission[3	NNP
18637	22822	12	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22822	13	and	and	CC
18637	22822	14	Finch	Finch	NNP
18637	22822	15	&	&	CC
18637	22822	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22822	17	_	_	NNP
18637	22822	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	22822	19	_	_	NNP
18637	22822	20	McKittrick[4	McKittrick[4	NNP
18637	22822	21	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22822	22	were	be	VBD
18637	22822	23	retaliation	retaliation	NN
18637	22822	24	laws	law	NNS
18637	22822	25	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	22822	26	by	by	IN
18637	22822	27	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	22822	28	and	and	CC
18637	22822	29	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22822	30	,	,	,
18637	22822	31	respectively	respectively	RB
18637	22822	32	,	,	,
18637	22822	33	by	by	IN
18637	22822	34	the	the	DT
18637	22822	35	terms	term	NNS
18637	22822	36	of	of	IN
18637	22822	37	which	which	WDT
18637	22822	38	sales	sale	NNS
18637	22822	39	in	in	IN
18637	22822	40	each	each	DT
18637	22822	41	of	of	IN
18637	22822	42	these	these	DT
18637	22822	43	States	States	NNPS
18637	22822	44	of	of	IN
18637	22822	45	beer	beer	NN
18637	22822	46	manufactured	manufacture	VBN
18637	22822	47	in	in	IN
18637	22822	48	a	a	DT
18637	22822	49	State	state	NN
18637	22822	50	already	already	RB
18637	22822	51	discriminating	discriminate	VBG
18637	22822	52	against	against	IN
18637	22822	53	beer	beer	NN
18637	22822	54	produced	produce	VBN
18637	22822	55	in	in	IN
18637	22822	56	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	22822	57	or	or	CC
18637	22822	58	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22822	59	were	be	VBD
18637	22822	60	rendered	render	VBN
18637	22822	61	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	22822	62	.	.	.
18637	22823	1	Conceding	Conceding	NNP
18637	22823	2	,	,	,
18637	22823	3	in	in	IN
18637	22823	4	State	State	NNP
18637	22823	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	22823	6	of	of	IN
18637	22823	7	Equalization	Equalization	NNP
18637	22823	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22823	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	22823	10	_	_	NNP
18637	22823	11	Young	Young	NNP
18637	22823	12	's	's	POS
18637	22823	13	Market	Market	NNP
18637	22823	14	Co	Co	NNP
18637	22823	15	.	.	.
18637	22823	16	,[5	,[5	,
18637	22823	17	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22823	18	that	that	IN
18637	22823	19	"	"	``
18637	22823	20	prior	prior	RB
18637	22823	21	to	to	IN
18637	22823	22	the	the	DT
18637	22823	23	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	22823	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	22823	25	first	first	NNP
18637	22823	26	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22823	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22823	28	would	would	MD
18637	22823	29	obviously	obviously	RB
18637	22823	30	have	have	VB
18637	22823	31	been	be	VBN
18637	22823	32	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	22823	33	to	to	TO
18637	22823	34	have	have	VB
18637	22823	35	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	22823	36	any	any	DT
18637	22823	37	fee	fee	NN
18637	22823	38	for	for	IN
18637	22823	39	*	*	NFP
18637	22823	40	*	*	NFP
18637	22823	41	*	*	NFP
18637	22823	42	the	the	DT
18637	22823	43	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	22823	44	of	of	IN
18637	22823	45	importation	importation	NN
18637	22823	46	*	*	NFP
18637	22823	47	*	*	NFP
18637	22823	48	*	*	NFP
18637	22823	49	even	even	RB
18637	22823	50	if	if	IN
18637	22823	51	the	the	DT
18637	22823	52	State	State	NNP
18637	22823	53	had	have	VBD
18637	22823	54	exacted	exact	VBN
18637	22823	55	an	an	DT
18637	22823	56	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22823	57	fee	fee	NN
18637	22823	58	for	for	IN
18637	22823	59	the	the	DT
18637	22823	60	privilege	privilege	NN
18637	22823	61	of	of	IN
18637	22823	62	transporting	transport	VBG
18637	22823	63	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	22823	64	beer	beer	NN
18637	22823	65	from	from	IN
18637	22823	66	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22823	67	place	place	NN
18637	22823	68	of	of	IN
18637	22823	69	manufacture	manufacture	NN
18637	22823	70	to	to	IN
18637	22823	71	the	the	DT
18637	22823	72	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22823	73	seller	seller	NN
18637	22823	74	's	's	POS
18637	22823	75	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22823	76	place	place	NN
18637	22823	77	of	of	IN
18637	22823	78	business	business	NN
18637	22823	79	,	,	,
18637	22823	80	"	"	''
18637	22823	81	the	the	DT
18637	22823	82	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22823	83	proclaimed	proclaim	VBD
18637	22823	84	that	that	IN
18637	22823	85	this	this	DT
18637	22823	86	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22823	87	"	"	``
18637	22823	88	abrogated	abrogate	VBD
18637	22823	89	the	the	DT
18637	22823	90	right	right	NN
18637	22823	91	to	to	TO
18637	22823	92	import	import	VB
18637	22823	93	free	free	JJ
18637	22823	94	,	,	,
18637	22823	95	so	so	RB
18637	22823	96	far	far	RB
18637	22823	97	as	as	IN
18637	22823	98	concerns	concern	NNS
18637	22823	99	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	22823	100	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	22823	101	.	.	.
18637	22823	102	"	"	''
18637	22824	1	Inasmuch	inasmuch	IN
18637	22824	2	as	as	IN
18637	22824	3	the	the	DT
18637	22824	4	States	States	NNPS
18637	22824	5	were	be	VBD
18637	22824	6	viewed	view	VBN
18637	22824	7	as	as	IN
18637	22824	8	having	have	VBG
18637	22824	9	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	22824	10	therefrom	therefrom	IN
18637	22824	11	an	an	DT
18637	22824	12	unconditioned	unconditioned	JJ
18637	22824	13	authority	authority	NN
18637	22824	14	to	to	TO
18637	22824	15	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	22824	16	totally	totally	RB
18637	22824	17	the	the	DT
18637	22824	18	importation	importation	NN
18637	22824	19	of	of	IN
18637	22824	20	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	22824	21	beverages	beverage	NNS
18637	22824	22	,	,	,
18637	22824	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22824	24	logically	logically	RB
18637	22824	25	followed	follow	VBD
18637	22824	26	that	that	IN
18637	22824	27	any	any	DT
18637	22824	28	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	22824	29	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	22824	30	falling	fall	VBG
18637	22824	31	short	short	RB
18637	22824	32	of	of	IN
18637	22824	33	total	total	JJ
18637	22824	34	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	22824	35	was	be	VBD
18637	22824	36	equally	equally	RB
18637	22824	37	valid	valid	JJ
18637	22824	38	,	,	,
18637	22824	39	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
18637	22824	40	the	the	DT
18637	22824	41	absence	absence	NN
18637	22824	42	of	of	IN
18637	22824	43	any	any	DT
18637	22824	44	connection	connection	NN
18637	22824	45	between	between	IN
18637	22824	46	such	such	JJ
18637	22824	47	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	22824	48	and	and	CC
18637	22824	49	public	public	JJ
18637	22824	50	health	health	NN
18637	22824	51	,	,	,
18637	22824	52	safety	safety	NN
18637	22824	53	or	or	CC
18637	22824	54	morals	moral	NNS
18637	22824	55	.	.	.
18637	22825	1	As	as	IN
18637	22825	2	to	to	IN
18637	22825	3	the	the	DT
18637	22825	4	contention	contention	NN
18637	22825	5	that	that	IN
18637	22825	6	the	the	DT
18637	22825	7	unequal	unequal	JJ
18637	22825	8	treatment	treatment	NN
18637	22825	9	of	of	IN
18637	22825	10	imported	import	VBN
18637	22825	11	beer	beer	NN
18637	22825	12	would	would	MD
18637	22825	13	contravene	contravene	VB
18637	22825	14	the	the	DT
18637	22825	15	equal	equal	JJ
18637	22825	16	protection	protection	NN
18637	22825	17	clause	clause	NN
18637	22825	18	,	,	,
18637	22825	19	the	the	DT
18637	22825	20	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22825	21	succinctly	succinctly	RB
18637	22825	22	observed	observe	VBD
18637	22825	23	that	that	IN
18637	22825	24	a	a	DT
18637	22825	25	"	"	``
18637	22825	26	classification	classification	NN
18637	22825	27	recognized	recognize	VBN
18637	22825	28	by	by	IN
18637	22825	29	the	the	DT
18637	22825	30	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	22825	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	22825	32	first	first	NNP
18637	22825	33	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22825	34	can	can	MD
18637	22825	35	not	not	RB
18637	22825	36	be	be	VB
18637	22825	37	deemed	deem	VBN
18637	22825	38	forbidden	forbid	VBN
18637	22825	39	by	by	IN
18637	22825	40	the	the	DT
18637	22825	41	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	22825	42	.	.	.
18637	22826	1	"	"	``
18637	22826	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22826	3	6	6	CD
18637	22826	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22826	5	REGULATION	regulation	NN
18637	22826	6	OF	of	IN
18637	22826	7	TRANSPORTATION	transportation	NN
18637	22826	8	AND	and	CC
18637	22826	9	"	"	``
18637	22826	10	THROUGH	through	NN
18637	22826	11	"	"	''
18637	22826	12	SHIPMENTS	shipment	NNS
18637	22826	13	Lately	lately	RB
18637	22826	14	,	,	,
18637	22826	15	however	however	RB
18637	22826	16	,	,	,
18637	22826	17	when	when	WRB
18637	22826	18	passing	pass	VBG
18637	22826	19	upon	upon	IN
18637	22826	20	the	the	DT
18637	22826	21	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	22826	22	of	of	IN
18637	22826	23	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	22826	24	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	22826	25	the	the	DT
18637	22826	26	carriage	carriage	NN
18637	22826	27	of	of	IN
18637	22826	28	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	22826	29	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	22826	30	,	,	,
18637	22826	31	a	a	DT
18637	22826	32	majority	majority	NN
18637	22826	33	of	of	IN
18637	22826	34	the	the	DT
18637	22826	35	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	22826	36	have	have	VBP
18637	22826	37	been	be	VBN
18637	22826	38	disposed	dispose	VBN
18637	22826	39	to	to	IN
18637	22826	40	by	by	NN
18637	22826	41	-	-	:
18637	22826	42	pass	pass	VB
18637	22826	43	the	the	DT
18637	22826	44	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	22826	45	-	-	HYPH
18637	22826	46	first	first	NNP
18637	22826	47	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22826	48	and	and	CC
18637	22826	49	to	to	TO
18637	22826	50	resolve	resolve	VB
18637	22826	51	the	the	DT
18637	22826	52	issue	issue	NN
18637	22826	53	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	22826	54	in	in	IN
18637	22826	55	terms	term	NNS
18637	22826	56	of	of	IN
18637	22826	57	the	the	DT
18637	22826	58	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	22826	59	clause	clause	NN
18637	22826	60	and	and	CC
18637	22826	61	State	State	NNP
18637	22826	62	police	police	NN
18637	22826	63	power	power	NN
18637	22826	64	.	.	.
18637	22827	1	This	this	DT
18637	22827	2	trend	trend	NN
18637	22827	3	toward	toward	IN
18637	22827	4	devaluation	devaluation	NN
18637	22827	5	of	of	IN
18637	22827	6	the	the	DT
18637	22827	7	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	22827	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	22827	9	first	first	NNP
18637	22827	10	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22827	11	was	be	VBD
18637	22827	12	set	set	VBN
18637	22827	13	in	in	IN
18637	22827	14	motion	motion	NN
18637	22827	15	by	by	IN
18637	22827	16	Ziffrin	Ziffrin	NNP
18637	22827	17	,	,	,
18637	22827	18	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	22827	19	_	_	NNP
18637	22827	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	22827	21	_	_	NNP
18637	22827	22	Reeves[7	Reeves[7	NNP
18637	22827	23	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22827	24	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	22827	25	a	a	DT
18637	22827	26	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	22827	27	statute	statute	NN
18637	22827	28	,	,	,
18637	22827	29	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	22827	30	the	the	DT
18637	22827	31	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	22827	32	of	of	IN
18637	22827	33	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	22827	34	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	22827	35	by	by	IN
18637	22827	36	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	22827	37	other	other	JJ
18637	22827	38	than	than	IN
18637	22827	39	licensed	license	VBN
18637	22827	40	common	common	JJ
18637	22827	41	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	22827	42	,	,	,
18637	22827	43	was	be	VBD
18637	22827	44	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	22827	45	as	as	IN
18637	22827	46	to	to	IN
18637	22827	47	an	an	DT
18637	22827	48	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	22827	49	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22827	50	,	,	,
18637	22827	51	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	22827	52	in	in	IN
18637	22827	53	delivering	deliver	VBG
18637	22827	54	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	22827	55	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	22827	56	from	from	IN
18637	22827	57	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	22827	58	distillers	distiller	NNS
18637	22827	59	to	to	IN
18637	22827	60	consignees	consignee	NNS
18637	22827	61	in	in	IN
18637	22827	62	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	22827	63	;	;	:
18637	22827	64	but	but	CC
18637	22827	65	licensed	license	VBD
18637	22827	66	only	only	RB
18637	22827	67	as	as	IN
18637	22827	68	a	a	DT
18637	22827	69	contract	contract	NN
18637	22827	70	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	22827	71	under	under	IN
18637	22827	72	the	the	DT
18637	22827	73	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	22827	74	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	22827	75	Carriers	Carriers	NNPS
18637	22827	76	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22827	77	.	.	.
18637	22828	1	After	after	IN
18637	22828	2	acknowledging	acknowledge	VBG
18637	22828	3	that	that	IN
18637	22828	4	"	"	``
18637	22828	5	the	the	DT
18637	22828	6	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	22828	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	22828	8	first	first	NNP
18637	22828	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22828	10	sanctions	sanction	NNS
18637	22828	11	the	the	DT
18637	22828	12	right	right	NN
18637	22828	13	of	of	IN
18637	22828	14	a	a	DT
18637	22828	15	State	State	NNP
18637	22828	16	to	to	TO
18637	22828	17	legislate	legislate	VB
18637	22828	18	concerning	concern	VBG
18637	22828	19	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	22828	20	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	22828	21	brought	bring	VBN
18637	22828	22	from	from	IN
18637	22828	23	without	without	IN
18637	22828	24	,	,	,
18637	22828	25	unfettered	unfettere	VBN
18637	22828	26	by	by	IN
18637	22828	27	the	the	DT
18637	22828	28	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	22828	29	Clause,"[8	Clause,"[8	NNP
18637	22828	30	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22828	31	the	the	DT
18637	22828	32	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22828	33	then	then	RB
18637	22828	34	proceeded	proceed	VBD
18637	22828	35	to	to	TO
18637	22828	36	found	find	VBN
18637	22828	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22828	38	ruling	ruling	NN
18637	22828	39	largely	largely	RB
18637	22828	40	upon	upon	IN
18637	22828	41	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	22828	42	antedating	antedate	VBG
18637	22828	43	the	the	DT
18637	22828	44	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22828	45	which	which	WDT
18637	22828	46	sustained	sustain	VBD
18637	22828	47	similar	similar	JJ
18637	22828	48	State	State	NNP
18637	22828	49	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	22828	50	as	as	IN
18637	22828	51	a	a	DT
18637	22828	52	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
18637	22828	53	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	22828	54	of	of	IN
18637	22828	55	the	the	DT
18637	22828	56	police	police	NN
18637	22828	57	power	power	NN
18637	22828	58	not	not	RB
18637	22828	59	unduly	unduly	RB
18637	22828	60	burdening	burden	VBG
18637	22828	61	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	22828	62	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	22828	63	.	.	.
18637	22829	1	In	in	IN
18637	22829	2	the	the	DT
18637	22829	3	light	light	NN
18637	22829	4	of	of	IN
18637	22829	5	the	the	DT
18637	22829	6	cases	case	NNS
18637	22829	7	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	22829	8	in	in	IN
18637	22829	9	the	the	DT
18637	22829	10	preceding	precede	VBG
18637	22829	11	paragraph	paragraph	NN
18637	22829	12	,	,	,
18637	22829	13	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	22829	14	the	the	DT
18637	22829	15	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	22829	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	22829	17	first	first	NNP
18637	22829	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22829	19	was	be	VBD
18637	22829	20	construed	construe	VBN
18637	22829	21	as	as	IN
18637	22829	22	according	accord	VBG
18637	22829	23	a	a	DT
18637	22829	24	plenary	plenary	JJ
18637	22829	25	power	power	NN
18637	22829	26	to	to	IN
18637	22829	27	the	the	DT
18637	22829	28	States	States	NNP
18637	22829	29	,	,	,
18637	22829	30	such	such	JJ
18637	22829	31	extended	extended	JJ
18637	22829	32	emphasis	emphasis	NN
18637	22829	33	on	on	IN
18637	22829	34	the	the	DT
18637	22829	35	police	police	NN
18637	22829	36	power	power	NN
18637	22829	37	and	and	CC
18637	22829	38	the	the	DT
18637	22829	39	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	22829	40	clause	clause	NN
18637	22829	41	would	would	MD
18637	22829	42	seem	seem	VB
18637	22829	43	to	to	TO
18637	22829	44	have	have	VB
18637	22829	45	been	be	VBN
18637	22829	46	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	22829	47	.	.	.
18637	22830	1	Thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	22830	2	,	,	,
18637	22830	3	a	a	DT
18637	22830	4	total	total	JJ
18637	22830	5	eclipse	eclipse	NN
18637	22830	6	of	of	IN
18637	22830	7	the	the	DT
18637	22830	8	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	22830	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	22830	10	first	first	NNP
18637	22830	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22830	12	was	be	VBD
18637	22830	13	recorded	record	VBN
18637	22830	14	in	in	IN
18637	22830	15	Duckworth	Duckworth	NNP
18637	22830	16	_	_	NNP
18637	22830	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	22830	18	_	_	NNP
18637	22830	19	Arkansas[9	Arkansas[9	NNP
18637	22830	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22830	21	and	and	CC
18637	22830	22	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	22830	23	_	_	NNP
18637	22830	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	22830	25	_	_	NNP
18637	22830	26	Virginia[10	Virginia[10	NNP
18637	22830	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22830	28	wherein	wherein	WRB
18637	22830	29	,	,	,
18637	22830	30	without	without	IN
18637	22830	31	even	even	RB
18637	22830	32	considering	consider	VBG
18637	22830	33	that	that	DT
18637	22830	34	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22830	35	,	,	,
18637	22830	36	a	a	DT
18637	22830	37	majority	majority	NN
18637	22830	38	of	of	IN
18637	22830	39	the	the	DT
18637	22830	40	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22830	41	upheld	uphold	VBD
18637	22830	42	,	,	,
18637	22830	43	as	as	IN
18637	22830	44	not	not	RB
18637	22830	45	contravening	contravene	VBG
18637	22830	46	the	the	DT
18637	22830	47	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	22830	48	clause	clause	NN
18637	22830	49	,	,	,
18637	22830	50	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	22830	51	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	22830	52	the	the	DT
18637	22830	53	transport	transport	NN
18637	22830	54	through	through	IN
18637	22830	55	the	the	DT
18637	22830	56	State	State	NNP
18637	22830	57	of	of	IN
18637	22830	58	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	22830	59	cargoes	cargo	NNS
18637	22830	60	originating	originate	VBG
18637	22830	61	and	and	CC
18637	22830	62	ending	end	VBG
18637	22830	63	outside	outside	IN
18637	22830	64	the	the	DT
18637	22830	65	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	22830	66	State	State	NNP
18637	22830	67	's	's	POS
18637	22830	68	boundaries	boundary	NNS
18637	22830	69	.	.	.
18637	22831	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22831	2	11	11	CD
18637	22831	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22831	4	REGULATION	regulation	NN
18637	22831	5	OF	of	IN
18637	22831	6	IMPORTS	imports	NN
18637	22831	7	DESTINED	destined	NN
18637	22831	8	FOR	for	IN
18637	22831	9	A	a	DT
18637	22831	10	FEDERAL	federal	JJ
18637	22831	11	AREA	area	NN
18637	22831	12	Intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
18637	22831	13	beverages	beverage	NNS
18637	22831	14	brought	bring	VBD
18637	22831	15	into	into	IN
18637	22831	16	a	a	DT
18637	22831	17	State	State	NNP
18637	22831	18	for	for	IN
18637	22831	19	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
18637	22831	20	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	22831	21	at	at	IN
18637	22831	22	a	a	DT
18637	22831	23	National	National	NNP
18637	22831	24	Park	Park	NNP
18637	22831	25	located	locate	VBN
18637	22831	26	therein	therein	RB
18637	22831	27	but	but	CC
18637	22831	28	over	over	IN
18637	22831	29	which	which	WDT
18637	22831	30	the	the	DT
18637	22831	31	United	United	NNP
18637	22831	32	States	States	NNP
18637	22831	33	retained	retain	VBD
18637	22831	34	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	22831	35	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	22831	36	has	have	VBZ
18637	22831	37	been	be	VBN
18637	22831	38	construed	construe	VBN
18637	22831	39	as	as	IN
18637	22831	40	not	not	RB
18637	22831	41	constituting	constitute	VBG
18637	22831	42	"	"	``
18637	22831	43	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	22831	44	*	*	NFP
18637	22831	45	*	*	NFP
18637	22831	46	*	*	NFP
18637	22831	47	into	into	IN
18637	22831	48	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22831	49	a	a	DT
18637	22831	50	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22831	51	State	state	NN
18637	22831	52	for	for	IN
18637	22831	53	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	22831	54	and	and	CC
18637	22831	55	use	use	VB
18637	22831	56	therein	therein	RB
18637	22831	57	"	"	''
18637	22831	58	within	within	IN
18637	22831	59	the	the	DT
18637	22831	60	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	22831	61	of	of	IN
18637	22831	62	section	section	NN
18637	22831	63	2	2	CD
18637	22831	64	of	of	IN
18637	22831	65	this	this	DT
18637	22831	66	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22831	67	.	.	.
18637	22832	1	The	the	DT
18637	22832	2	importation	importation	NN
18637	22832	3	having	have	VBG
18637	22832	4	had	have	VBN
18637	22832	5	as	as	IN
18637	22832	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22832	7	objective	objective	JJ
18637	22832	8	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	22832	9	and	and	CC
18637	22832	10	use	use	NN
18637	22832	11	in	in	IN
18637	22832	12	a	a	DT
18637	22832	13	federal	federal	JJ
18637	22832	14	area	area	NN
18637	22832	15	over	over	IN
18637	22832	16	which	which	WDT
18637	22832	17	the	the	DT
18637	22832	18	State	state	NN
18637	22832	19	retained	retain	VBD
18637	22832	20	no	no	DT
18637	22832	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	22832	22	,	,	,
18637	22832	23	the	the	DT
18637	22832	24	increased	increase	VBN
18637	22832	25	powers	power	NNS
18637	22832	26	which	which	WDT
18637	22832	27	the	the	DT
18637	22832	28	latter	latter	JJ
18637	22832	29	acquired	acquire	VBD
18637	22832	30	from	from	IN
18637	22832	31	the	the	DT
18637	22832	32	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	22832	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	22832	34	first	first	NNP
18637	22832	35	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22832	36	were	be	VBD
18637	22832	37	declared	declare	VBN
18637	22832	38	to	to	TO
18637	22832	39	be	be	VB
18637	22832	40	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	22832	41	.	.	.
18637	22833	1	California	California	NNP
18637	22833	2	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	22833	3	could	could	MD
18637	22833	4	not	not	RB
18637	22833	5	extend	extend	VB
18637	22833	6	the	the	DT
18637	22833	7	importation	importation	NN
18637	22833	8	license	license	NN
18637	22833	9	and	and	CC
18637	22833	10	other	other	JJ
18637	22833	11	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	22833	12	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	22833	13	of	of	IN
18637	22833	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22833	15	Alcoholic	Alcoholic	NNP
18637	22833	16	Beverage	Beverage	NNP
18637	22833	17	Control	Control	NNP
18637	22833	18	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22833	19	to	to	IN
18637	22833	20	a	a	DT
18637	22833	21	retail	retail	JJ
18637	22833	22	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	22833	23	dealer	dealer	NN
18637	22833	24	doing	do	VBG
18637	22833	25	business	business	NN
18637	22833	26	in	in	IN
18637	22833	27	the	the	DT
18637	22833	28	Park	Park	NNP
18637	22833	29	.	.	.
18637	22834	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22834	2	12	12	CD
18637	22834	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22834	4	Effect	effect	NN
18637	22834	5	on	on	IN
18637	22834	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	22834	7	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	22834	8	The	The	NNP
18637	22834	9	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	22834	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	22834	11	first	first	NNP
18637	22834	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22834	13	of	of	IN
18637	22834	14	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22834	15	did	do	VBD
18637	22834	16	not	not	RB
18637	22834	17	,	,	,
18637	22834	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22834	19	was	be	VBD
18637	22834	20	held	hold	VBN
18637	22834	21	,	,	,
18637	22834	22	bar	bar	VB
18637	22834	23	a	a	DT
18637	22834	24	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	22834	25	under	under	IN
18637	22834	26	the	the	DT
18637	22834	27	federal	federal	JJ
18637	22834	28	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	22834	29	Antitrust	Antitrust	NNP
18637	22834	30	Law	Law	NNP
18637	22834	31	of	of	IN
18637	22834	32	producers	producer	NNS
18637	22834	33	,	,	,
18637	22834	34	wholesalers	wholesaler	NNS
18637	22834	35	,	,	,
18637	22834	36	and	and	CC
18637	22834	37	retailers	retailer	NNS
18637	22834	38	charged	charge	VBN
18637	22834	39	with	with	IN
18637	22834	40	conspiring	conspire	VBG
18637	22834	41	to	to	TO
18637	22834	42	fix	fix	VB
18637	22834	43	and	and	CC
18637	22834	44	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	22834	45	retail	retail	JJ
18637	22834	46	prices	price	NNS
18637	22834	47	of	of	IN
18637	22834	48	alcoholic	alcoholic	JJ
18637	22834	49	beverages	beverage	NNS
18637	22834	50	in	in	IN
18637	22834	51	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	22834	52	.	.	.
18637	22835	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22835	2	13	13	CD
18637	22835	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22835	4	In	in	IN
18637	22835	5	a	a	DT
18637	22835	6	concurring	concur	VBG
18637	22835	7	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	22835	8	,	,	,
18637	22835	9	supported	support	VBN
18637	22835	10	by	by	IN
18637	22835	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22835	12	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	22835	13	,	,	,
18637	22835	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22835	15	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	22835	16	took	take	VBD
18637	22835	17	the	the	DT
18637	22835	18	position	position	NN
18637	22835	19	that	that	IN
18637	22835	20	if	if	IN
18637	22835	21	the	the	DT
18637	22835	22	State	State	NNP
18637	22835	23	of	of	IN
18637	22835	24	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	22835	25	had	have	VBD
18637	22835	26	in	in	IN
18637	22835	27	fact	fact	NN
18637	22835	28	"	"	``
18637	22835	29	*	*	NFP
18637	22835	30	*	*	NFP
18637	22835	31	*	*	NFP
18637	22835	32	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	22835	33	the	the	DT
18637	22835	34	transactions	transaction	NNS
18637	22835	35	here	here	RB
18637	22835	36	complained	complain	VBD
18637	22835	37	of	of	IN
18637	22835	38	,	,	,
18637	22835	39	the	the	DT
18637	22835	40	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	22835	41	Law	Law	NNP
18637	22835	42	could	could	MD
18637	22835	43	not	not	RB
18637	22835	44	override	override	VB
18637	22835	45	such	such	JJ
18637	22835	46	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	22835	47	of	of	IN
18637	22835	48	state	state	NN
18637	22835	49	power	power	NN
18637	22835	50	.	.	.
18637	22836	1	*	*	NFP
18637	22836	2	*	*	NFP
18637	22836	3	*	*	NFP
18637	22836	4	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22836	5	Since	since	IN
18637	22836	6	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22836	7	the	the	DT
18637	22836	8	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	22836	9	Law	Law	NNP
18637	22836	10	,	,	,
18637	22836	11	*	*	NFP
18637	22836	12	*	*	NFP
18637	22836	13	*	*	NFP
18637	22836	14	,	,	,
18637	22836	15	can	can	MD
18637	22836	16	have	have	VB
18637	22836	17	no	no	DT
18637	22836	18	greater	great	JJR
18637	22836	19	potency	potency	NN
18637	22836	20	than	than	IN
18637	22836	21	the	the	DT
18637	22836	22	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	22836	23	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	22836	24	itself	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22836	25	,	,	,
18637	22836	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22836	27	must	must	MD
18637	22836	28	equally	equally	RB
18637	22836	29	yield	yield	VB
18637	22836	30	to	to	IN
18637	22836	31	state	state	NN
18637	22836	32	power	power	NN
18637	22836	33	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	22836	34	from	from	IN
18637	22836	35	the	the	DT
18637	22836	36	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	22836	37	-	-	HYPH
18637	22836	38	first	first	NNP
18637	22836	39	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22836	40	.	.	.
18637	22837	1	"	"	``
18637	22837	2	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22837	3	14	14	CD
18637	22837	4	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22837	5	All	all	DT
18637	22837	6	other	other	JJ
18637	22837	7	efforts	effort	NNS
18637	22837	8	to	to	TO
18637	22837	9	invoke	invoke	VB
18637	22837	10	the	the	DT
18637	22837	11	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	22837	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	22837	13	first	first	NNP
18637	22837	14	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22837	15	as	as	IN
18637	22837	16	a	a	DT
18637	22837	17	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	22837	18	upon	upon	IN
18637	22837	19	the	the	DT
18637	22837	20	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	22837	21	powers	power	NNS
18637	22837	22	of	of	IN
18637	22837	23	the	the	DT
18637	22837	24	National	National	NNP
18637	22837	25	Government	Government	NNP
18637	22837	26	,	,	,
18637	22837	27	notably	notably	RB
18637	22837	28	to	to	TO
18637	22837	29	invalidate	invalidate	VB
18637	22837	30	the	the	DT
18637	22837	31	imposition	imposition	NN
18637	22837	32	,	,	,
18637	22837	33	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	22837	34	to	to	IN
18637	22837	35	the	the	DT
18637	22837	36	war	war	NN
18637	22837	37	power	power	NN
18637	22837	38	,	,	,
18637	22837	39	of	of	IN
18637	22837	40	federal	federal	JJ
18637	22837	41	price	price	NN
18637	22837	42	controls	control	NNS
18637	22837	43	on	on	IN
18637	22837	44	retail	retail	JJ
18637	22837	45	sales	sale	NNS
18637	22837	46	of	of	IN
18637	22837	47	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	22837	48	,	,	,
18637	22837	49	have	have	VBP
18637	22837	50	been	be	VBN
18637	22837	51	equally	equally	RB
18637	22837	52	abortive	abortive	JJ
18637	22837	53	.	.	.
18637	22838	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22838	2	15	15	CD
18637	22838	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22838	4	Notes	note	NNS
18637	22838	5	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22838	6	1	1	CD
18637	22838	7	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22838	8	299	299	CD
18637	22838	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22838	10	59	59	CD
18637	22838	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22838	12	1936	1936	CD
18637	22838	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22838	14	.	.	.
18637	22839	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22839	2	2	2	CD
18637	22839	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22839	4	304	304	CD
18637	22839	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22839	6	401	401	CD
18637	22839	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22839	8	1938	1938	CD
18637	22839	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22839	10	.	.	.
18637	22840	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22840	2	3	3	CD
18637	22840	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22840	4	305	305	CD
18637	22840	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22840	6	391	391	CD
18637	22840	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22840	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	22840	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22840	10	.	.	.
18637	22841	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22841	2	4	4	CD
18637	22841	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22841	4	305	305	CD
18637	22841	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22841	6	395	395	CD
18637	22841	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22841	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	22841	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22841	10	.	.	.
18637	22842	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22842	2	5	5	CD
18637	22842	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22842	4	299	299	CD
18637	22842	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22842	6	59	59	CD
18637	22842	7	,	,	,
18637	22842	8	62	62	CD
18637	22842	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22842	10	1936	1936	CD
18637	22842	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22842	12	.	.	.
18637	22843	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22843	2	6	6	CD
18637	22843	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22843	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	22843	5	63	63	CD
18637	22843	6	-	-	SYM
18637	22843	7	64	64	CD
18637	22843	8	.	.	.
18637	22844	1	In	in	IN
18637	22844	2	the	the	DT
18637	22844	3	three	three	CD
18637	22844	4	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	22844	5	rendered	render	VBN
18637	22844	6	subsequently	subsequently	RB
18637	22844	7	,	,	,
18637	22844	8	the	the	DT
18637	22844	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22844	10	merely	merely	RB
18637	22844	11	restated	restate	VBD
18637	22844	12	these	these	DT
18637	22844	13	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
18637	22844	14	.	.	.
18637	22845	1	The	the	DT
18637	22845	2	contention	contention	NN
18637	22845	3	that	that	IN
18637	22845	4	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	22845	5	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	22845	6	of	of	IN
18637	22845	7	imported	import	VBN
18637	22845	8	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	22845	9	violated	violate	VBD
18637	22845	10	the	the	DT
18637	22845	11	due	due	JJ
18637	22845	12	process	process	NN
18637	22845	13	clause	clause	NN
18637	22845	14	was	be	VBD
18637	22845	15	summarily	summarily	RB
18637	22845	16	rejected	reject	VBN
18637	22845	17	in	in	IN
18637	22845	18	Indianapolis	Indianapolis	NNP
18637	22845	19	Brewing	Brewing	NNP
18637	22845	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22845	21	_	_	NNP
18637	22845	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	22845	23	_	_	NNP
18637	22845	24	Liquor	Liquor	NNP
18637	22845	25	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	22845	26	,	,	,
18637	22845	27	305	305	CD
18637	22845	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22845	29	391	391	CD
18637	22845	30	,	,	,
18637	22845	31	394	394	CD
18637	22845	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22845	33	1939	1939	CD
18637	22845	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22845	35	.	.	.
18637	22846	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22846	2	7	7	CD
18637	22846	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22846	4	308	308	CD
18637	22846	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22846	6	132	132	CD
18637	22846	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22846	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	22846	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22846	10	.	.	.
18637	22847	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22847	2	8	8	CD
18637	22847	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22847	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	22847	5	.	.	.
18637	22848	1	138	138	CD
18637	22848	2	.	.	.
18637	22849	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22849	2	9	9	CD
18637	22849	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22849	4	314	314	CD
18637	22849	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22849	6	390	390	CD
18637	22849	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22849	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	22849	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22849	10	.	.	.
18637	22850	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22850	2	10	10	CD
18637	22850	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22850	4	321	321	CD
18637	22850	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22850	6	131	131	CD
18637	22850	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22850	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	22850	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22850	10	.	.	.
18637	22851	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22851	2	See	See	NNP
18637	22851	3	also	also	RB
18637	22851	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22851	5	Cartlidge	Cartlidge	NNP
18637	22851	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22851	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22851	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22851	9	Rainey	Rainey	NNP
18637	22851	10	,	,	,
18637	22851	11	168	168	CD
18637	22851	12	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22851	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22851	14	2d	2d	NNP
18637	22851	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22851	16	841	841	CD
18637	22851	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22851	18	1948	1948	CD
18637	22851	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22851	20	;	;	:
18637	22851	21	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	22851	22	denied	denied	NNP
18637	22851	23	,	,	,
18637	22851	24	335	335	CD
18637	22851	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22851	26	885	885	CD
18637	22851	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22851	28	1948	1948	CD
18637	22851	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22851	30	.	.	.
18637	22852	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22852	2	11	11	CD
18637	22852	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22852	4	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	22852	5	required	require	VBD
18637	22852	6	a	a	DT
18637	22852	7	permit	permit	NN
18637	22852	8	for	for	IN
18637	22852	9	the	the	DT
18637	22852	10	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	22852	11	of	of	IN
18637	22852	12	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	22852	13	across	across	IN
18637	22852	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22852	15	territory	territory	NN
18637	22852	16	,	,	,
18637	22852	17	but	but	CC
18637	22852	18	granted	grant	VBD
18637	22852	19	the	the	DT
18637	22852	20	same	same	JJ
18637	22852	21	upon	upon	IN
18637	22852	22	application	application	NN
18637	22852	23	and	and	CC
18637	22852	24	payment	payment	NN
18637	22852	25	of	of	IN
18637	22852	26	a	a	DT
18637	22852	27	nominal	nominal	JJ
18637	22852	28	fee	fee	NN
18637	22852	29	.	.	.
18637	22853	1	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	22853	2	required	require	VBD
18637	22853	3	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	22853	4	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	22853	5	in	in	IN
18637	22853	6	similar	similar	JJ
18637	22853	7	through	through	NN
18637	22853	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	22853	9	shipments	shipment	NNS
18637	22853	10	to	to	TO
18637	22853	11	use	use	VB
18637	22853	12	the	the	DT
18637	22853	13	most	most	RBS
18637	22853	14	direct	direct	JJ
18637	22853	15	route	route	NN
18637	22853	16	,	,	,
18637	22853	17	carry	carry	VBP
18637	22853	18	a	a	DT
18637	22853	19	bill	bill	NN
18637	22853	20	of	of	IN
18637	22853	21	lading	lade	VBG
18637	22853	22	describing	describe	VBG
18637	22853	23	that	that	DT
18637	22853	24	route	route	NN
18637	22853	25	,	,	,
18637	22853	26	and	and	CC
18637	22853	27	post	post	VB
18637	22853	28	a	a	DT
18637	22853	29	$	$	$
18637	22853	30	1000	1000	CD
18637	22853	31	bond	bond	NN
18637	22853	32	conditioned	condition	VBN
18637	22853	33	on	on	IN
18637	22853	34	lawful	lawful	JJ
18637	22853	35	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	22853	36	;	;	:
18637	22853	37	and	and	CC
18637	22853	38	also	also	RB
18637	22853	39	stipulated	stipulate	VBD
18637	22853	40	that	that	IN
18637	22853	41	the	the	DT
18637	22853	42	true	true	JJ
18637	22853	43	consignee	consignee	NN
18637	22853	44	be	be	VB
18637	22853	45	named	name	VBN
18637	22853	46	in	in	IN
18637	22853	47	the	the	DT
18637	22853	48	bill	bill	NN
18637	22853	49	of	of	IN
18637	22853	50	lading	lading	NN
18637	22853	51	and	and	CC
18637	22853	52	be	be	VB
18637	22853	53	one	one	CD
18637	22853	54	having	have	VBG
18637	22853	55	the	the	DT
18637	22853	56	legal	legal	JJ
18637	22853	57	right	right	NN
18637	22853	58	to	to	TO
18637	22853	59	receive	receive	VB
18637	22853	60	the	the	DT
18637	22853	61	shipment	shipment	NN
18637	22853	62	at	at	IN
18637	22853	63	destination	destination	NN
18637	22853	64	.	.	.
18637	22854	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22854	2	12	12	CD
18637	22854	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22854	4	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	22854	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22854	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22854	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22854	8	Yosemite	Yosemite	NNP
18637	22854	9	Park	Park	NNP
18637	22854	10	,	,	,
18637	22854	11	304	304	CD
18637	22854	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22854	13	518	518	CD
18637	22854	14	,	,	,
18637	22854	15	537	537	CD
18637	22854	16	-	-	SYM
18637	22854	17	538	538	CD
18637	22854	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22854	19	1938	1938	CD
18637	22854	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22854	21	.	.	.
18637	22855	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22855	2	13	13	CD
18637	22855	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22855	4	United	United	NNP
18637	22855	5	States	States	NNP
18637	22855	6	_	_	NNP
18637	22855	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	22855	8	_	_	NNP
18637	22855	9	Frankfort	Frankfort	NNP
18637	22855	10	Distilleries	Distilleries	NNPS
18637	22855	11	,	,	,
18637	22855	12	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	22855	13	,	,	,
18637	22855	14	324	324	CD
18637	22855	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22855	16	293	293	CD
18637	22855	17	,	,	,
18637	22855	18	297	297	CD
18637	22855	19	-	-	SYM
18637	22855	20	299	299	CD
18637	22855	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22855	22	1945	1945	CD
18637	22855	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22855	24	.	.	.
18637	22856	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22856	2	14	14	CD
18637	22856	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22856	4	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	22856	5	.	.	.
18637	22857	1	301	301	CD
18637	22857	2	-	-	SYM
18637	22857	3	302	302	CD
18637	22857	4	.	.	.
18637	22858	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22858	2	15	15	CD
18637	22858	3	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22858	4	Jatros	Jatros	NNP
18637	22858	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22858	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	22858	7	_	_	NNP
18637	22858	8	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	22858	9	,	,	,
18637	22858	10	143	143	CD
18637	22858	11	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22858	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22858	13	2d	2d	CD
18637	22858	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22858	15	453	453	CD
18637	22858	16	,	,	,
18637	22858	17	455	455	CD
18637	22858	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22858	19	1944	1944	CD
18637	22858	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22858	21	;	;	:
18637	22858	22	Barnett	Barnett	NNP
18637	22858	23	_	_	NNP
18637	22858	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	22858	25	_	_	NNP
18637	22858	26	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	22858	27	,	,	,
18637	22858	28	151	151	CD
18637	22858	29	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22858	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22858	31	2d	2d	NNP
18637	22858	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22858	33	77	77	CD
18637	22858	34	,	,	,
18637	22858	35	79	79	CD
18637	22858	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22858	37	1945	1945	CD
18637	22858	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22858	39	,	,	,
18637	22858	40	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	22858	41	denied	denied	NNP
18637	22858	42	,	,	,
18637	22858	43	326	326	CD
18637	22858	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22858	45	766	766	CD
18637	22858	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22858	47	1945	1945	CD
18637	22858	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22858	49	;	;	:
18637	22858	50	Dowling	Dowling	NNP
18637	22858	51	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	22858	52	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	22858	53	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22858	54	_	_	NNP
18637	22858	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	22858	56	_	_	NNP
18637	22858	57	United	United	NNP
18637	22858	58	States	States	NNP
18637	22858	59	,	,	,
18637	22858	60	153	153	CD
18637	22858	61	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22858	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22858	63	2d	2d	NNP
18637	22858	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22858	65	353	353	CD
18637	22858	66	,	,	,
18637	22858	67	357	357	CD
18637	22858	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22858	69	1946	1946	CD
18637	22858	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22858	71	,	,	,
18637	22858	72	certiorari	certiorari	NNP
18637	22858	73	denied	deny	VBD
18637	22858	74	,	,	,
18637	22858	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22858	76	Gould	Gould	NNP
18637	22858	77	et	et	NNP
18637	22858	78	al	al	NNP
18637	22858	79	.	.	.
18637	22859	1	_	_	NNP
18637	22859	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	22859	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22859	4	United	United	NNP
18637	22859	5	States	States	NNP
18637	22859	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22859	7	328	328	CD
18637	22859	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22859	9	848	848	CD
18637	22859	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22859	11	1946	1946	CD
18637	22859	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22859	13	;	;	:
18637	22859	14	rehearing	rehear	VBG
18637	22859	15	denied	deny	VBN
18637	22859	16	,	,	,
18637	22859	17	329	329	CD
18637	22859	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22859	19	820	820	CD
18637	22859	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22859	21	1946	1946	CD
18637	22859	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22859	23	.	.	.
18637	22860	1	AMENDMENT	AMENDMENT	NNP
18637	22860	2	22	22	CD
18637	22860	3	PRESIDENTIAL	presidential	JJ
18637	22860	4	TENURE	TENURE	NNP
18637	22860	5	Section	section	NN
18637	22860	6	1	1	CD
18637	22860	7	.	.	.
18637	22861	1	No	no	DT
18637	22861	2	person	person	NN
18637	22861	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	22861	4	be	be	VB
18637	22861	5	elected	elect	VBN
18637	22861	6	to	to	IN
18637	22861	7	the	the	DT
18637	22861	8	office	office	NN
18637	22861	9	of	of	IN
18637	22861	10	the	the	DT
18637	22861	11	President	President	NNP
18637	22861	12	more	more	RBR
18637	22861	13	than	than	IN
18637	22861	14	twice	twice	RB
18637	22861	15	,	,	,
18637	22861	16	and	and	CC
18637	22861	17	no	no	DT
18637	22861	18	person	person	NN
18637	22861	19	who	who	WP
18637	22861	20	has	have	VBZ
18637	22861	21	held	hold	VBN
18637	22861	22	the	the	DT
18637	22861	23	office	office	NN
18637	22861	24	of	of	IN
18637	22861	25	President	President	NNP
18637	22861	26	,	,	,
18637	22861	27	or	or	CC
18637	22861	28	acted	act	VBD
18637	22861	29	as	as	IN
18637	22861	30	President	President	NNP
18637	22861	31	,	,	,
18637	22861	32	for	for	IN
18637	22861	33	more	more	JJR
18637	22861	34	than	than	IN
18637	22861	35	two	two	CD
18637	22861	36	years	year	NNS
18637	22861	37	of	of	IN
18637	22861	38	a	a	DT
18637	22861	39	term	term	NN
18637	22861	40	to	to	TO
18637	22861	41	which	which	WDT
18637	22861	42	some	some	DT
18637	22861	43	other	other	JJ
18637	22861	44	person	person	NN
18637	22861	45	was	be	VBD
18637	22861	46	elected	elect	VBN
18637	22861	47	President	President	NNP
18637	22861	48	shall	shall	MD
18637	22861	49	be	be	VB
18637	22861	50	elected	elect	VBN
18637	22861	51	to	to	IN
18637	22861	52	the	the	DT
18637	22861	53	office	office	NN
18637	22861	54	of	of	IN
18637	22861	55	the	the	DT
18637	22861	56	President	President	NNP
18637	22861	57	more	more	RBR
18637	22861	58	than	than	IN
18637	22861	59	once	once	RB
18637	22861	60	.	.	.
18637	22862	1	But	but	CC
18637	22862	2	this	this	DT
18637	22862	3	Article	article	NN
18637	22862	4	shall	shall	MD
18637	22862	5	not	not	RB
18637	22862	6	apply	apply	VB
18637	22862	7	to	to	IN
18637	22862	8	any	any	DT
18637	22862	9	person	person	NN
18637	22862	10	holding	hold	VBG
18637	22862	11	the	the	DT
18637	22862	12	office	office	NN
18637	22862	13	of	of	IN
18637	22862	14	President	President	NNP
18637	22862	15	when	when	WRB
18637	22862	16	this	this	DT
18637	22862	17	Article	article	NN
18637	22862	18	was	be	VBD
18637	22862	19	proposed	propose	VBN
18637	22862	20	by	by	IN
18637	22862	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22862	22	,	,	,
18637	22862	23	and	and	CC
18637	22862	24	shall	shall	MD
18637	22862	25	not	not	RB
18637	22862	26	prevent	prevent	VB
18637	22862	27	any	any	DT
18637	22862	28	person	person	NN
18637	22862	29	who	who	WP
18637	22862	30	may	may	MD
18637	22862	31	be	be	VB
18637	22862	32	holding	hold	VBG
18637	22862	33	the	the	DT
18637	22862	34	office	office	NN
18637	22862	35	of	of	IN
18637	22862	36	President	President	NNP
18637	22862	37	,	,	,
18637	22862	38	or	or	CC
18637	22862	39	acting	act	VBG
18637	22862	40	as	as	IN
18637	22862	41	President	President	NNP
18637	22862	42	,	,	,
18637	22862	43	during	during	IN
18637	22862	44	the	the	DT
18637	22862	45	term	term	NN
18637	22862	46	within	within	IN
18637	22862	47	which	which	WDT
18637	22862	48	this	this	DT
18637	22862	49	Article	article	NN
18637	22862	50	becomes	become	VBZ
18637	22862	51	operative	operative	JJ
18637	22862	52	from	from	IN
18637	22862	53	holding	hold	VBG
18637	22862	54	the	the	DT
18637	22862	55	office	office	NN
18637	22862	56	of	of	IN
18637	22862	57	President	President	NNP
18637	22862	58	or	or	CC
18637	22862	59	acting	act	VBG
18637	22862	60	as	as	IN
18637	22862	61	President	President	NNP
18637	22862	62	during	during	IN
18637	22862	63	the	the	DT
18637	22862	64	remainder	remainder	NN
18637	22862	65	of	of	IN
18637	22862	66	such	such	JJ
18637	22862	67	term	term	NN
18637	22862	68	.	.	.
18637	22863	1	Section	section	NN
18637	22863	2	2	2	CD
18637	22863	3	.	.	.
18637	22864	1	This	this	DT
18637	22864	2	Article	article	NN
18637	22864	3	shall	shall	MD
18637	22864	4	be	be	VB
18637	22864	5	inoperative	inoperative	JJ
18637	22864	6	unless	unless	IN
18637	22864	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22864	8	shall	shall	MD
18637	22864	9	have	have	VB
18637	22864	10	been	be	VBN
18637	22864	11	ratified	ratify	VBN
18637	22864	12	as	as	IN
18637	22864	13	an	an	DT
18637	22864	14	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	22864	15	to	to	IN
18637	22864	16	the	the	DT
18637	22864	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22864	18	by	by	IN
18637	22864	19	the	the	DT
18637	22864	20	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	22864	21	of	of	IN
18637	22864	22	three	three	CD
18637	22864	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	22864	24	fourths	fourth	NNS
18637	22864	25	of	of	IN
18637	22864	26	the	the	DT
18637	22864	27	several	several	JJ
18637	22864	28	States	state	NNS
18637	22864	29	within	within	IN
18637	22864	30	seven	seven	CD
18637	22864	31	years	year	NNS
18637	22864	32	from	from	IN
18637	22864	33	the	the	DT
18637	22864	34	date	date	NN
18637	22864	35	of	of	IN
18637	22864	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22864	37	submission	submission	NN
18637	22864	38	to	to	IN
18637	22864	39	the	the	DT
18637	22864	40	States	States	NNP
18637	22864	41	by	by	IN
18637	22864	42	the	the	DT
18637	22864	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22864	44	.	.	.
18637	22865	1	ACTS	ACTS	NNP
18637	22865	2	OF	of	IN
18637	22865	3	CONGRESS	CONGRESS	NNP
18637	22865	4	HELD	HELD	NNP
18637	22865	5	UNCONSTITUTIONAL	UNCONSTITUTIONAL	NNP
18637	22865	6	IN	in	IN
18637	22865	7	WHOLE	whole	NN
18637	22865	8	OR	or	CC
18637	22865	9	IN	in	IN
18637	22865	10	PART	part	NN
18637	22865	11	BY	by	IN
18637	22865	12	THE	the	DT
18637	22865	13	SUPREME	SUPREME	NNP
18637	22865	14	COURT	COURT	NNP
18637	22865	15	OF	of	IN
18637	22865	16	THE	the	DT
18637	22865	17	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
18637	22865	18	STATES	STATES	NNP
18637	22865	19	1	1	CD
18637	22865	20	.	.	.
18637	22866	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22866	2	of	of	IN
18637	22866	3	September	September	NNP
18637	22866	4	24	24	CD
18637	22866	5	,	,	,
18637	22866	6	1789	1789	CD
18637	22866	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22866	8	1	1	CD
18637	22866	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22866	10	.	.	.
18637	22867	1	81	81	CD
18637	22867	2	,	,	,
18637	22867	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22867	4	.	.	.
18637	22868	1	13	13	CD
18637	22868	2	,	,	,
18637	22868	3	in	in	IN
18637	22868	4	part	part	NN
18637	22868	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22868	6	.	.	.
18637	22869	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	22869	2	that	that	IN
18637	22869	3	"	"	``
18637	22869	4	*	*	NFP
18637	22869	5	*	*	NFP
18637	22869	6	*	*	NFP
18637	22869	7	[	[	-LRB-
18637	22869	8	the	the	DT
18637	22869	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	22869	10	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22869	11	]	]	-RRB-
18637	22869	12	shall	shall	MD
18637	22869	13	have	have	VB
18637	22869	14	power	power	NN
18637	22869	15	to	to	TO
18637	22869	16	issue	issue	VB
18637	22869	17	*	*	NFP
18637	22869	18	*	*	NFP
18637	22869	19	*	*	NFP
18637	22869	20	writs	writ	NNS
18637	22869	21	of	of	IN
18637	22869	22	mandamus	mandamus	NNP
18637	22869	23	,	,	,
18637	22869	24	in	in	IN
18637	22869	25	cases	case	NNS
18637	22869	26	warranted	warrant	VBN
18637	22869	27	by	by	IN
18637	22869	28	the	the	DT
18637	22869	29	principles	principle	NNS
18637	22869	30	and	and	CC
18637	22869	31	usages	usage	NNS
18637	22869	32	of	of	IN
18637	22869	33	law	law	NN
18637	22869	34	,	,	,
18637	22869	35	to	to	IN
18637	22869	36	any	any	DT
18637	22869	37	*	*	NFP
18637	22869	38	*	*	NFP
18637	22869	39	*	*	NFP
18637	22869	40	persons	person	NNS
18637	22869	41	holding	hold	VBG
18637	22869	42	office	office	NN
18637	22869	43	,	,	,
18637	22869	44	under	under	IN
18637	22869	45	authority	authority	NN
18637	22869	46	of	of	IN
18637	22869	47	the	the	DT
18637	22869	48	United	United	NNP
18637	22869	49	States	States	NNP
18637	22869	50	"	"	''
18637	22869	51	as	as	IN
18637	22869	52	applied	apply	VBN
18637	22869	53	to	to	IN
18637	22869	54	the	the	DT
18637	22869	55	issue	issue	NN
18637	22869	56	of	of	IN
18637	22869	57	mandamus	mandamus	NN
18637	22869	58	to	to	IN
18637	22869	59	the	the	DT
18637	22869	60	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	22869	61	of	of	IN
18637	22869	62	State	State	NNP
18637	22869	63	requiring	require	VBG
18637	22869	64	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22869	65	to	to	TO
18637	22869	66	deliver	deliver	VB
18637	22869	67	to	to	TO
18637	22869	68	plaintiff	plaintiff	VB
18637	22869	69	a	a	DT
18637	22869	70	commission	commission	NN
18637	22869	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22869	72	duly	duly	RB
18637	22869	73	signed	sign	VBN
18637	22869	74	by	by	IN
18637	22869	75	the	the	DT
18637	22869	76	President	President	NNP
18637	22869	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22869	78	as	as	IN
18637	22869	79	justice	justice	NN
18637	22869	80	of	of	IN
18637	22869	81	the	the	DT
18637	22869	82	peace	peace	NN
18637	22869	83	in	in	IN
18637	22869	84	the	the	DT
18637	22869	85	District	District	NNP
18637	22869	86	of	of	IN
18637	22869	87	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	22869	88	,	,	,
18637	22869	89	_	_	NNP
18637	22869	90	held	hold	VBD
18637	22869	91	_	_	NNP
18637	22869	92	an	an	DT
18637	22869	93	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	22869	94	to	to	TO
18637	22869	95	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	22869	96	the	the	DT
18637	22869	97	original	original	JJ
18637	22869	98	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	22869	99	of	of	IN
18637	22869	100	the	the	DT
18637	22869	101	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	22869	102	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22869	103	,	,	,
18637	22869	104	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	22869	105	by	by	IN
18637	22869	106	article	article	NN
18637	22869	107	III	III	NNP
18637	22869	108	,	,	,
18637	22869	109	section	section	NN
18637	22869	110	2	2	CD
18637	22869	111	.	.	.
18637	22870	1	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	22870	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22870	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22870	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22870	5	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	22870	6	,	,	,
18637	22870	7	1	1	CD
18637	22870	8	Cr	cr	NN
18637	22870	9	.	.	.
18637	22871	1	137	137	CD
18637	22871	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22871	3	February	February	NNP
18637	22871	4	24	24	CD
18637	22871	5	,	,	,
18637	22871	6	1803	1803	CD
18637	22871	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22871	8	.	.	.
18637	22872	1	2	2	LS
18637	22872	2	.	.	.
18637	22873	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22873	2	of	of	IN
18637	22873	3	February	February	NNP
18637	22873	4	20	20	CD
18637	22873	5	,	,	,
18637	22873	6	1812	1812	CD
18637	22873	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22873	8	2	2	CD
18637	22873	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22873	10	.	.	.
18637	22874	1	677	677	CD
18637	22874	2	,	,	,
18637	22874	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	22874	4	.	.	.
18637	22875	1	22	22	CD
18637	22875	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22875	3	.	.	.
18637	22876	1	Provisions	provision	NNS
18637	22876	2	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	22876	3	land	land	NN
18637	22876	4	officers	officer	NNS
18637	22876	5	to	to	TO
18637	22876	6	examine	examine	VB
18637	22876	7	into	into	IN
18637	22876	8	"	"	``
18637	22876	9	validity	validity	NN
18637	22876	10	of	of	IN
18637	22876	11	claims	claim	NNS
18637	22876	12	to	to	TO
18637	22876	13	land	land	NN
18637	22876	14	*	*	NFP
18637	22876	15	*	*	NFP
18637	22876	16	*	*	NFP
18637	22876	17	which	which	WDT
18637	22876	18	are	be	VBP
18637	22876	19	derived	derive	VBN
18637	22876	20	from	from	IN
18637	22876	21	confirmations	confirmation	NNS
18637	22876	22	made	make	VBN
18637	22876	23	*	*	NFP
18637	22876	24	*	*	NFP
18637	22876	25	*	*	NFP
18637	22876	26	by	by	IN
18637	22876	27	the	the	DT
18637	22876	28	governors	governor	NNS
18637	22876	29	of	of	IN
18637	22876	30	the	the	DT
18637	22876	31	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	22876	32	*	*	NFP
18637	22876	33	*	*	NFP
18637	22876	34	*	*	NFP
18637	22876	35	territory	territory	NN
18637	22876	36	"	"	''
18637	22876	37	,	,	,
18637	22876	38	_	_	NNP
18637	22876	39	held	hold	VBD
18637	22876	40	_	_	NNP
18637	22876	41	not	not	RB
18637	22876	42	to	to	TO
18637	22876	43	authorize	authorize	VB
18637	22876	44	annulment	annulment	JJ
18637	22876	45	of	of	IN
18637	22876	46	title	title	NN
18637	22876	47	confirmed	confirm	VBN
18637	22876	48	by	by	IN
18637	22876	49	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	22876	50	St.	St.	NNP
18637	22876	51	Clair	Clair	NNP
18637	22876	52	in	in	IN
18637	22876	53	1799	1799	CD
18637	22876	54	,	,	,
18637	22876	55	nor	nor	CC
18637	22876	56	to	to	TO
18637	22876	57	validate	validate	VB
18637	22876	58	a	a	DT
18637	22876	59	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	22876	60	sale	sale	NN
18637	22876	61	and	and	CC
18637	22876	62	patent	patent	NN
18637	22876	63	by	by	IN
18637	22876	64	the	the	DT
18637	22876	65	United	United	NNP
18637	22876	66	States	States	NNP
18637	22876	67	.	.	.
18637	22877	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22877	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22877	3	See	See	NNP
18637	22877	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22877	5	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	22877	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22877	7	.	.	.
18637	22877	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22878	1	Reichert	Reichert	NNP
18637	22878	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22878	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22878	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22878	5	Felps	Felps	NNP
18637	22878	6	,	,	,
18637	22878	7	6	6	CD
18637	22878	8	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	22878	9	160	160	CD
18637	22878	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22878	11	March	March	NNP
18637	22878	12	16	16	CD
18637	22878	13	,	,	,
18637	22878	14	1868	1868	CD
18637	22878	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22878	16	.	.	.
18637	22879	1	3	3	LS
18637	22879	2	.	.	.
18637	22880	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22880	2	of	of	IN
18637	22880	3	March	March	NNP
18637	22880	4	6	6	CD
18637	22880	5	,	,	,
18637	22880	6	1820	1820	CD
18637	22880	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22880	8	3	3	CD
18637	22880	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22880	10	.	.	.
18637	22881	1	548	548	CD
18637	22881	2	,	,	,
18637	22881	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22881	4	.	.	.
18637	22882	1	8	8	CD
18637	22882	2	,	,	,
18637	22882	3	proviso	proviso	NN
18637	22882	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22882	5	.	.	.
18637	22883	1	The	the	DT
18637	22883	2	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22883	3	Compromise	Compromise	NNP
18637	22883	4	,	,	,
18637	22883	5	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	22883	6	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	22883	7	within	within	IN
18637	22883	8	the	the	DT
18637	22883	9	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	22883	10	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	22883	11	north	north	RB
18637	22883	12	of	of	IN
18637	22883	13	36Â	36Â	NNP
18637	22883	14	°	°	,
18637	22883	15	30	30	CD
18637	22883	16	'	'	''
18637	22883	17	,	,	,
18637	22883	18	except	except	IN
18637	22883	19	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	22883	20	,	,	,
18637	22883	21	_	_	NNP
18637	22883	22	held	hold	VBD
18637	22883	23	_	_	NNP
18637	22883	24	not	not	RB
18637	22883	25	warranted	warrant	VBN
18637	22883	26	as	as	IN
18637	22883	27	a	a	DT
18637	22883	28	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	22883	29	of	of	IN
18637	22883	30	Territory	territory	NN
18637	22883	31	belonging	belong	VBG
18637	22883	32	to	to	IN
18637	22883	33	the	the	DT
18637	22883	34	United	United	NNP
18637	22883	35	States	States	NNP
18637	22883	36	under	under	IN
18637	22883	37	article	article	NN
18637	22883	38	IV	IV	NNP
18637	22883	39	,	,	,
18637	22883	40	section	section	NN
18637	22883	41	3	3	CD
18637	22883	42	,	,	,
18637	22883	43	clause	clause	NN
18637	22883	44	2	2	CD
18637	22883	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22883	46	and	and	CC
18637	22883	47	_	_	NNP
18637	22883	48	see	see	VBP
18637	22883	49	_	_	NNP
18637	22883	50	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	22883	51	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22883	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22883	53	.	.	.
18637	22884	1	Dred	Dred	NNP
18637	22884	2	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	22884	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22884	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22884	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22884	6	Sandford	Sandford	NNP
18637	22884	7	,	,	,
18637	22884	8	19	19	CD
18637	22884	9	Howard	howard	NN
18637	22884	10	393	393	CD
18637	22884	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22884	12	March	March	NNP
18637	22884	13	6	6	CD
18637	22884	14	,	,	,
18637	22884	15	1857	1857	CD
18637	22884	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22884	17	.	.	.
18637	22885	1	4	4	LS
18637	22885	2	.	.	.
18637	22886	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22886	2	of	of	IN
18637	22886	3	February	February	NNP
18637	22886	4	25	25	CD
18637	22886	5	,	,	,
18637	22886	6	1862	1862	CD
18637	22886	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22886	8	12	12	CD
18637	22886	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22886	10	.	.	.
18637	22887	1	345	345	CD
18637	22887	2	,	,	,
18637	22887	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22887	4	.	.	.
18637	22888	1	1	1	LS
18637	22888	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22888	3	;	;	:
18637	22888	4	July	July	NNP
18637	22888	5	11	11	CD
18637	22888	6	,	,	,
18637	22888	7	1862	1862	CD
18637	22888	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22888	9	12	12	CD
18637	22888	10	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22888	11	.	.	.
18637	22889	1	532	532	CD
18637	22889	2	,	,	,
18637	22889	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22889	4	.	.	.
18637	22890	1	1	1	LS
18637	22890	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22890	3	;	;	:
18637	22890	4	March	March	NNP
18637	22890	5	3	3	CD
18637	22890	6	,	,	,
18637	22890	7	1863	1863	CD
18637	22890	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22890	9	12	12	CD
18637	22890	10	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22890	11	.	.	.
18637	22891	1	711	711	CD
18637	22891	2	,	,	,
18637	22891	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22891	4	.	.	.
18637	22892	1	3	3	LS
18637	22892	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22892	3	,	,	,
18637	22892	4	each	each	DT
18637	22892	5	in	in	IN
18637	22892	6	part	part	NN
18637	22892	7	only	only	RB
18637	22892	8	.	.	.
18637	22893	1	"	"	``
18637	22893	2	Legal	legal	JJ
18637	22893	3	tender	tender	NN
18637	22893	4	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	22893	5	"	"	''
18637	22893	6	,	,	,
18637	22893	7	making	make	VBG
18637	22893	8	noninterest	noninterest	JJ
18637	22893	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	22893	10	bearing	bearing	NN
18637	22893	11	United	United	NNP
18637	22893	12	States	States	NNP
18637	22893	13	notes	note	VBZ
18637	22893	14	legal	legal	JJ
18637	22893	15	tender	tender	NN
18637	22893	16	in	in	IN
18637	22893	17	payment	payment	NN
18637	22893	18	of	of	IN
18637	22893	19	"	"	``
18637	22893	20	all	all	DT
18637	22893	21	debts	debt	NNS
18637	22893	22	,	,	,
18637	22893	23	public	public	JJ
18637	22893	24	and	and	CC
18637	22893	25	private	private	JJ
18637	22893	26	"	"	''
18637	22893	27	,	,	,
18637	22893	28	so	so	RB
18637	22893	29	far	far	RB
18637	22893	30	as	as	IN
18637	22893	31	applied	apply	VBN
18637	22893	32	to	to	IN
18637	22893	33	debts	debt	NNS
18637	22893	34	contracted	contract	VBN
18637	22893	35	before	before	IN
18637	22893	36	passage	passage	NN
18637	22893	37	of	of	IN
18637	22893	38	the	the	DT
18637	22893	39	act	act	NN
18637	22893	40	,	,	,
18637	22893	41	_	_	NNP
18637	22893	42	held	hold	VBD
18637	22893	43	_	_	NNP
18637	22893	44	not	not	RB
18637	22893	45	within	within	IN
18637	22893	46	express	express	JJ
18637	22893	47	or	or	CC
18637	22893	48	implied	imply	VBN
18637	22893	49	powers	power	NNS
18637	22893	50	of	of	IN
18637	22893	51	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	22893	52	under	under	IN
18637	22893	53	article	article	NN
18637	22893	54	I	i	NN
18637	22893	55	,	,	,
18637	22893	56	section	section	NN
18637	22893	57	8	8	CD
18637	22893	58	,	,	,
18637	22893	59	and	and	CC
18637	22893	60	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
18637	22893	61	with	with	IN
18637	22893	62	article	article	NN
18637	22893	63	I	i	NN
18637	22893	64	,	,	,
18637	22893	65	section	section	NN
18637	22893	66	10	10	CD
18637	22893	67	,	,	,
18637	22893	68	and	and	CC
18637	22893	69	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	22893	70	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22893	71	.	.	.
18637	22894	1	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	22894	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22894	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22894	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22894	5	Griswold	Griswold	NNP
18637	22894	6	,	,	,
18637	22894	7	8	8	CD
18637	22894	8	Wallace	wallace	NN
18637	22894	9	603	603	CD
18637	22894	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22894	11	February	February	NNP
18637	22894	12	7	7	CD
18637	22894	13	,	,	,
18637	22894	14	1870	1870	CD
18637	22894	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22894	16	;	;	,
18637	22894	17	overruled	overrule	VBN
18637	22894	18	in	in	IN
18637	22894	19	Knox	Knox	NNP
18637	22894	20	_	_	NNP
18637	22894	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	22894	22	_	_	NNP
18637	22894	23	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	22894	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22894	25	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	22894	26	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	22894	27	cases	case	NNS
18637	22894	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22894	29	,	,	,
18637	22894	30	12	12	CD
18637	22894	31	Wallace	wallace	NN
18637	22894	32	457	457	CD
18637	22894	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22894	34	May	May	NNP
18637	22894	35	1	1	CD
18637	22894	36	,	,	,
18637	22894	37	1871	1871	CD
18637	22894	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22894	39	.	.	.
18637	22895	1	5	5	CD
18637	22895	2	.	.	.
18637	22896	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22896	2	of	of	IN
18637	22896	3	March	March	NNP
18637	22896	4	3	3	CD
18637	22896	5	,	,	,
18637	22896	6	1863	1863	CD
18637	22896	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22896	8	12	12	CD
18637	22896	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22896	10	.	.	.
18637	22897	1	756	756	CD
18637	22897	2	,	,	,
18637	22897	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	22897	4	.	.	.
18637	22898	1	81	81	CD
18637	22898	2	,	,	,
18637	22898	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22898	4	.	.	.
18637	22899	1	5	5	LS
18637	22899	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22899	3	.	.	.
18637	22900	1	"	"	``
18637	22900	2	So	so	RB
18637	22900	3	much	much	JJ
18637	22900	4	of	of	IN
18637	22900	5	the	the	DT
18637	22900	6	fifth	fifth	JJ
18637	22900	7	section	section	NN
18637	22900	8	*	*	NFP
18637	22900	9	*	*	NFP
18637	22900	10	*	*	NFP
18637	22900	11	as	as	IN
18637	22900	12	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	22900	13	for	for	IN
18637	22900	14	the	the	DT
18637	22900	15	removal	removal	NN
18637	22900	16	of	of	IN
18637	22900	17	a	a	DT
18637	22900	18	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	22900	19	in	in	IN
18637	22900	20	a	a	DT
18637	22900	21	State	State	NNP
18637	22900	22	court	court	NN
18637	22900	23	,	,	,
18637	22900	24	and	and	CC
18637	22900	25	in	in	IN
18637	22900	26	which	which	WDT
18637	22900	27	the	the	DT
18637	22900	28	cause	cause	NN
18637	22900	29	was	be	VBD
18637	22900	30	tried	try	VBN
18637	22900	31	by	by	IN
18637	22900	32	a	a	DT
18637	22900	33	jury	jury	NN
18637	22900	34	to	to	IN
18637	22900	35	the	the	DT
18637	22900	36	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	22900	37	court	court	NN
18637	22900	38	of	of	IN
18637	22900	39	the	the	DT
18637	22900	40	United	United	NNP
18637	22900	41	States	States	NNP
18637	22900	42	for	for	IN
18637	22900	43	a	a	DT
18637	22900	44	retrial	retrial	NN
18637	22900	45	on	on	IN
18637	22900	46	the	the	DT
18637	22900	47	facts	fact	NNS
18637	22900	48	and	and	CC
18637	22900	49	law	law	NN
18637	22900	50	,	,	,
18637	22900	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	22900	52	not	not	RB
18637	22900	53	in	in	IN
18637	22900	54	pursuance	pursuance	NN
18637	22900	55	of	of	IN
18637	22900	56	the	the	DT
18637	22900	57	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22900	58	,	,	,
18637	22900	59	and	and	CC
18637	22900	60	is	be	VBZ
18637	22900	61	void	void	JJ
18637	22900	62	"	"	``
18637	22900	63	under	under	IN
18637	22900	64	the	the	DT
18637	22900	65	Seventh	Seventh	NNP
18637	22900	66	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22900	67	.	.	.
18637	22901	1	The	the	DT
18637	22901	2	Justices	Justices	NNPS
18637	22901	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22901	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22901	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22901	6	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	22901	7	,	,	,
18637	22901	8	9	9	CD
18637	22901	9	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	22901	10	274	274	CD
18637	22901	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22901	12	March	March	NNP
18637	22901	13	14	14	CD
18637	22901	14	,	,	,
18637	22901	15	1870	1870	CD
18637	22901	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22901	17	.	.	.
18637	22902	1	6	6	CD
18637	22902	2	.	.	.
18637	22903	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22903	2	of	of	IN
18637	22903	3	March	March	NNP
18637	22903	4	3	3	CD
18637	22903	5	,	,	,
18637	22903	6	1863	1863	CD
18637	22903	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22903	8	12	12	CD
18637	22903	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22903	10	.	.	.
18637	22904	1	766	766	CD
18637	22904	2	,	,	,
18637	22904	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	22904	4	.	.	.
18637	22905	1	92	92	CD
18637	22905	2	,	,	,
18637	22905	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22905	4	.	.	.
18637	22906	1	5	5	LS
18637	22906	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22906	3	.	.	.
18637	22907	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	22907	2	for	for	IN
18637	22907	3	an	an	DT
18637	22907	4	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	22907	5	from	from	IN
18637	22907	6	the	the	DT
18637	22907	7	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22907	8	of	of	IN
18637	22907	9	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	22907	10	to	to	IN
18637	22907	11	the	the	DT
18637	22907	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	22907	13	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22907	14	--	--	:
18637	22907	15	there	there	EX
18637	22907	16	being	be	VBG
18637	22907	17	,	,	,
18637	22907	18	at	at	IN
18637	22907	19	the	the	DT
18637	22907	20	time	time	NN
18637	22907	21	,	,	,
18637	22907	22	a	a	DT
18637	22907	23	further	further	JJ
18637	22907	24	provision	provision	NN
18637	22907	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22907	26	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22907	27	.	.	.
18637	22908	1	14	14	CD
18637	22908	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22908	3	requiring	require	VBG
18637	22908	4	an	an	DT
18637	22908	5	estimate	estimate	NN
18637	22908	6	by	by	IN
18637	22908	7	the	the	DT
18637	22908	8	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	22908	9	of	of	IN
18637	22908	10	the	the	DT
18637	22908	11	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	22908	12	before	before	IN
18637	22908	13	payment	payment	NN
18637	22908	14	of	of	IN
18637	22908	15	final	final	JJ
18637	22908	16	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	22908	17	,	,	,
18637	22908	18	_	_	NNP
18637	22908	19	held	hold	VBD
18637	22908	20	_	_	NNP
18637	22908	21	to	to	TO
18637	22908	22	contravene	contravene	VB
18637	22908	23	the	the	DT
18637	22908	24	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	22908	25	finality	finality	NN
18637	22908	26	intended	intend	VBN
18637	22908	27	by	by	IN
18637	22908	28	the	the	DT
18637	22908	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22908	30	,	,	,
18637	22908	31	article	article	NN
18637	22908	32	III	iii	CD
18637	22908	33	.	.	.
18637	22909	1	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	22909	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22909	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22909	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22909	5	United	United	NNP
18637	22909	6	States	States	NNP
18637	22909	7	,	,	,
18637	22909	8	2	2	CD
18637	22909	9	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	22909	10	561	561	CD
18637	22909	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22909	12	March	March	NNP
18637	22909	13	10	10	CD
18637	22909	14	,	,	,
18637	22909	15	1865	1865	CD
18637	22909	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22909	17	.	.	.
18637	22910	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22910	2	Case	case	NN
18637	22910	3	was	be	VBD
18637	22910	4	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
18637	22910	5	without	without	IN
18637	22910	6	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	22910	7	;	;	:
18637	22910	8	the	the	DT
18637	22910	9	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	22910	10	upon	upon	IN
18637	22910	11	which	which	WDT
18637	22910	12	this	this	DT
18637	22910	13	decision	decision	NN
18637	22910	14	was	be	VBD
18637	22910	15	made	make	VBN
18637	22910	16	were	be	VBD
18637	22910	17	stated	state	VBN
18637	22910	18	in	in	IN
18637	22910	19	a	a	DT
18637	22910	20	posthumous	posthumous	JJ
18637	22910	21	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	22910	22	by	by	IN
18637	22910	23	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	22910	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	22910	25	Taney	Taney	NNP
18637	22910	26	printed	print	VBD
18637	22910	27	in	in	IN
18637	22910	28	the	the	DT
18637	22910	29	appendix	appendix	NNP
18637	22910	30	to	to	TO
18637	22910	31	volume	volume	VB
18637	22910	32	117	117	CD
18637	22910	33	of	of	IN
18637	22910	34	the	the	DT
18637	22910	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22910	36	Reports	Reports	NNPS
18637	22910	37	at	at	IN
18637	22910	38	p.	p.	NN
18637	22911	1	697	697	CD
18637	22911	2	.	.	.
18637	22911	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22912	1	7	7	LS
18637	22912	2	.	.	.
18637	22913	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22913	2	of	of	IN
18637	22913	3	June	June	NNP
18637	22913	4	30	30	CD
18637	22913	5	,	,	,
18637	22913	6	1864	1864	CD
18637	22913	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22913	8	13	13	CD
18637	22913	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22913	10	.	.	.
18637	22914	1	311	311	CD
18637	22914	2	,	,	,
18637	22914	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	22914	4	.	.	.
18637	22915	1	174	174	CD
18637	22915	2	,	,	,
18637	22915	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22915	4	.	.	.
18637	22916	1	13	13	CD
18637	22916	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22916	3	.	.	.
18637	22917	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	22917	2	that	that	IN
18637	22917	3	"	"	``
18637	22917	4	any	any	DT
18637	22917	5	prize	prize	NN
18637	22917	6	cause	cause	NN
18637	22917	7	now	now	RB
18637	22917	8	pending	pende	VBG
18637	22917	9	in	in	IN
18637	22917	10	any	any	DT
18637	22917	11	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	22917	12	court	court	NN
18637	22917	13	shall	shall	MD
18637	22917	14	,	,	,
18637	22917	15	on	on	IN
18637	22917	16	the	the	DT
18637	22917	17	application	application	NN
18637	22917	18	of	of	IN
18637	22917	19	all	all	DT
18637	22917	20	parties	party	NNS
18637	22917	21	in	in	IN
18637	22917	22	interest	interest	NN
18637	22917	23	*	*	NFP
18637	22917	24	*	*	NFP
18637	22917	25	*	*	NFP
18637	22917	26	be	be	VB
18637	22917	27	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	22917	28	by	by	IN
18637	22917	29	that	that	DT
18637	22917	30	court	court	NN
18637	22917	31	to	to	IN
18637	22917	32	the	the	DT
18637	22917	33	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	22917	34	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22917	35	*	*	NFP
18637	22917	36	*	*	NFP
18637	22917	37	*	*	NFP
18637	22917	38	"	"	''
18637	22917	39	,	,	,
18637	22917	40	as	as	IN
18637	22917	41	applied	apply	VBN
18637	22917	42	in	in	IN
18637	22917	43	a	a	DT
18637	22917	44	case	case	NN
18637	22917	45	where	where	WRB
18637	22917	46	no	no	DT
18637	22917	47	action	action	NN
18637	22917	48	had	have	VBD
18637	22917	49	been	be	VBN
18637	22917	50	taken	take	VBN
18637	22917	51	in	in	IN
18637	22917	52	the	the	DT
18637	22917	53	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
18637	22917	54	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22917	55	on	on	IN
18637	22917	56	the	the	DT
18637	22917	57	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	22917	58	from	from	IN
18637	22917	59	the	the	DT
18637	22917	60	District	District	NNP
18637	22917	61	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22917	62	,	,	,
18637	22917	63	_	_	NNP
18637	22917	64	held	hold	VBD
18637	22917	65	_	_	NNP
18637	22917	66	to	to	TO
18637	22917	67	propose	propose	VB
18637	22917	68	an	an	DT
18637	22917	69	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	22917	70	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	22917	71	not	not	RB
18637	22917	72	within	within	IN
18637	22917	73	article	article	NN
18637	22917	74	III	III	NNP
18637	22917	75	,	,	,
18637	22917	76	section	section	NN
18637	22917	77	2	2	CD
18637	22917	78	.	.	.
18637	22918	1	The	the	DT
18637	22918	2	"	"	``
18637	22918	3	Alicia	Alicia	NNP
18637	22918	4	"	"	''
18637	22918	5	,	,	,
18637	22918	6	7	7	CD
18637	22918	7	Wallace	wallace	NN
18637	22918	8	571	571	CD
18637	22918	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22918	10	January	January	NNP
18637	22918	11	25	25	CD
18637	22918	12	,	,	,
18637	22918	13	1869	1869	CD
18637	22918	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22918	15	.	.	.
18637	22919	1	8	8	LS
18637	22919	2	.	.	.
18637	22920	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22920	2	of	of	IN
18637	22920	3	January	January	NNP
18637	22920	4	24	24	CD
18637	22920	5	,	,	,
18637	22920	6	1865	1865	CD
18637	22920	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22920	8	13	13	CD
18637	22920	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22920	10	.	.	.
18637	22921	1	424	424	CD
18637	22921	2	,	,	,
18637	22921	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	22921	4	.	.	.
18637	22922	1	20	20	CD
18637	22922	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22922	3	.	.	.
18637	22923	1	Requirement	requirement	NN
18637	22923	2	of	of	IN
18637	22923	3	a	a	DT
18637	22923	4	test	test	NN
18637	22923	5	oath	oath	NN
18637	22923	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22923	7	disavowing	disavow	VBG
18637	22923	8	actions	action	NNS
18637	22923	9	in	in	IN
18637	22923	10	hostility	hostility	NN
18637	22923	11	to	to	IN
18637	22923	12	the	the	DT
18637	22923	13	United	United	NNP
18637	22923	14	States	States	NNP
18637	22923	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22923	16	before	before	IN
18637	22923	17	admission	admission	NN
18637	22923	18	to	to	TO
18637	22923	19	appear	appear	VB
18637	22923	20	as	as	IN
18637	22923	21	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	22923	22	in	in	IN
18637	22923	23	a	a	DT
18637	22923	24	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	22923	25	court	court	NN
18637	22923	26	by	by	IN
18637	22923	27	virtue	virtue	NN
18637	22923	28	of	of	IN
18637	22923	29	any	any	DT
18637	22923	30	previous	previous	JJ
18637	22923	31	admission	admission	NN
18637	22923	32	,	,	,
18637	22923	33	_	_	NNP
18637	22923	34	held	hold	VBD
18637	22923	35	_	_	NNP
18637	22923	36	invalid	invalid	NN
18637	22923	37	as	as	IN
18637	22923	38	applied	apply	VBN
18637	22923	39	to	to	IN
18637	22923	40	an	an	DT
18637	22923	41	attorney	attorney	NN
18637	22923	42	who	who	WP
18637	22923	43	had	have	VBD
18637	22923	44	been	be	VBN
18637	22923	45	pardoned	pardon	VBN
18637	22923	46	by	by	IN
18637	22923	47	the	the	DT
18637	22923	48	President	President	NNP
18637	22923	49	for	for	IN
18637	22923	50	all	all	DT
18637	22923	51	offenses	offense	NNS
18637	22923	52	during	during	IN
18637	22923	53	the	the	DT
18637	22923	54	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
18637	22923	55	--	--	:
18637	22923	56	as	as	IN
18637	22923	57	_	_	NNP
18637	22923	58	ex	ex	FW
18637	22923	59	post	post	FW
18637	22923	60	facto	facto	FW
18637	22923	61	_	_	NNP
18637	22923	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22923	63	art	art	NN
18637	22923	64	.	.	.
18637	22924	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22924	2	,	,	,
18637	22924	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22924	4	.	.	.
18637	22925	1	9	9	CD
18637	22925	2	,	,	,
18637	22925	3	clause	clause	NN
18637	22925	4	3	3	CD
18637	22925	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22925	6	and	and	CC
18637	22925	7	an	an	DT
18637	22925	8	interference	interference	NN
18637	22925	9	with	with	IN
18637	22925	10	the	the	DT
18637	22925	11	pardoning	pardon	VBG
18637	22925	12	power	power	NN
18637	22925	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22925	14	art	art	NN
18637	22925	15	.	.	.
18637	22926	1	II	II	NNP
18637	22926	2	,	,	,
18637	22926	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22926	4	.	.	.
18637	22927	1	2	2	CD
18637	22927	2	,	,	,
18637	22927	3	clause	clause	NN
18637	22927	4	1	1	CD
18637	22927	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22927	6	.	.	.
18637	22928	1	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	22928	2	parte	parte	NN
18637	22928	3	Garland	Garland	NNP
18637	22928	4	,	,	,
18637	22928	5	4	4	CD
18637	22928	6	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	22928	7	333	333	CD
18637	22928	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22928	9	January	January	NNP
18637	22928	10	14	14	CD
18637	22928	11	,	,	,
18637	22928	12	1867	1867	CD
18637	22928	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22928	14	.	.	.
18637	22929	1	9	9	CD
18637	22929	2	.	.	.
18637	22930	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22930	2	of	of	IN
18637	22930	3	July	July	NNP
18637	22930	4	13	13	CD
18637	22930	5	,	,	,
18637	22930	6	1866	1866	CD
18637	22930	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22930	8	14	14	CD
18637	22930	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22930	10	.	.	.
18637	22931	1	138	138	CD
18637	22931	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22931	3	,	,	,
18637	22931	4	amending	amend	VBG
18637	22931	5	act	act	NN
18637	22931	6	of	of	IN
18637	22931	7	June	June	NNP
18637	22931	8	30	30	CD
18637	22931	9	,	,	,
18637	22931	10	1864	1864	CD
18637	22931	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22931	12	13	13	CD
18637	22931	13	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22931	14	.	.	.
18637	22932	1	284	284	CD
18637	22932	2	,	,	,
18637	22932	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	22932	4	.	.	.
18637	22933	1	173	173	CD
18637	22933	2	,	,	,
18637	22933	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22933	4	.	.	.
18637	22934	1	122	122	CD
18637	22934	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22934	3	.	.	.
18637	22935	1	Tax	tax	NN
18637	22935	2	on	on	IN
18637	22935	3	indebtedness	indebtedness	NN
18637	22935	4	of	of	IN
18637	22935	5	railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	22935	6	,	,	,
18637	22935	7	"	"	''
18637	22935	8	*	*	NFP
18637	22935	9	*	*	NFP
18637	22935	10	*	*	NFP
18637	22935	11	to	to	IN
18637	22935	12	whatsoever	whatsoever	JJ
18637	22935	13	party	party	NN
18637	22935	14	or	or	CC
18637	22935	15	person	person	NN
18637	22935	16	the	the	DT
18637	22935	17	same	same	JJ
18637	22935	18	may	may	MD
18637	22935	19	be	be	VB
18637	22935	20	payable	payable	JJ
18637	22935	21	"	"	''
18637	22935	22	,	,	,
18637	22935	23	as	as	IN
18637	22935	24	applied	apply	VBN
18637	22935	25	to	to	IN
18637	22935	26	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	22935	27	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	22935	28	held	hold	VBN
18637	22935	29	by	by	IN
18637	22935	30	a	a	DT
18637	22935	31	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	22935	32	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	22935	33	under	under	IN
18637	22935	34	authority	authority	NN
18637	22935	35	of	of	IN
18637	22935	36	the	the	DT
18637	22935	37	State	State	NNP
18637	22935	38	,	,	,
18637	22935	39	_	_	NNP
18637	22935	40	held	hold	VBD
18637	22935	41	_	_	NNP
18637	22935	42	an	an	DT
18637	22935	43	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	22935	44	of	of	IN
18637	22935	45	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	22935	46	State	State	NNP
18637	22935	47	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	22935	48	.	.	.
18637	22936	1	United	United	NNP
18637	22936	2	States	States	NNP
18637	22936	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22936	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22936	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22936	6	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	22936	7	&	&	CC
18637	22936	8	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	22937	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	22937	2	,	,	,
18637	22937	3	17	17	CD
18637	22937	4	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	22937	5	322	322	CD
18637	22937	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22937	7	April	April	NNP
18637	22937	8	3	3	CD
18637	22937	9	,	,	,
18637	22937	10	1873	1873	CD
18637	22937	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22937	12	.	.	.
18637	22938	1	10	10	CD
18637	22938	2	.	.	.
18637	22939	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22939	2	of	of	IN
18637	22939	3	March	March	NNP
18637	22939	4	2	2	CD
18637	22939	5	,	,	,
18637	22939	6	1867	1867	CD
18637	22939	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22939	8	14	14	CD
18637	22939	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22939	10	.	.	.
18637	22940	1	477	477	CD
18637	22940	2	,	,	,
18637	22940	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	22940	4	.	.	.
18637	22941	1	169	169	CD
18637	22941	2	,	,	,
18637	22941	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22941	4	.	.	.
18637	22942	1	13	13	CD
18637	22942	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22942	3	,	,	,
18637	22942	4	amending	amend	VBG
18637	22942	5	act	act	NN
18637	22942	6	of	of	IN
18637	22942	7	June	June	NNP
18637	22942	8	30	30	CD
18637	22942	9	,	,	,
18637	22942	10	1864	1864	CD
18637	22942	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22942	12	13	13	CD
18637	22942	13	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22942	14	.	.	.
18637	22943	1	281	281	CD
18637	22943	2	,	,	,
18637	22943	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22943	4	.	.	.
18637	22944	1	116	116	CD
18637	22944	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22944	3	.	.	.
18637	22945	1	Tax	tax	NN
18637	22945	2	on	on	IN
18637	22945	3	income	income	NN
18637	22945	4	of	of	IN
18637	22945	5	"	"	``
18637	22945	6	*	*	NFP
18637	22945	7	*	*	NFP
18637	22945	8	*	*	NFP
18637	22945	9	every	every	DT
18637	22945	10	person	person	NN
18637	22945	11	residing	reside	VBG
18637	22945	12	in	in	IN
18637	22945	13	the	the	DT
18637	22945	14	United	United	NNP
18637	22945	15	States	States	NNP
18637	22945	16	*	*	NFP
18637	22945	17	*	*	NFP
18637	22945	18	*	*	NFP
18637	22945	19	whether	whether	IN
18637	22945	20	derived	derive	VBN
18637	22945	21	from	from	IN
18637	22945	22	*	*	NN
18637	22945	23	*	*	NFP
18637	22945	24	*	*	NFP
18637	22945	25	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	22945	26	*	*	NFP
18637	22945	27	*	*	NFP
18637	22945	28	*	*	NFP
18637	22945	29	or	or	CC
18637	22945	30	from	from	IN
18637	22945	31	any	any	DT
18637	22945	32	source	source	NN
18637	22945	33	whatever	whatever	WDT
18637	22945	34	*	*	NFP
18637	22945	35	*	*	NFP
18637	22945	36	*	*	NFP
18637	22945	37	"	"	''
18637	22945	38	,	,	,
18637	22945	39	as	as	IN
18637	22945	40	applied	apply	VBN
18637	22945	41	to	to	IN
18637	22945	42	income	income	NN
18637	22945	43	of	of	IN
18637	22945	44	State	State	NNP
18637	22945	45	judges	judge	NNS
18637	22945	46	,	,	,
18637	22945	47	_	_	NNP
18637	22945	48	held	hold	VBD
18637	22945	49	_	_	NNP
18637	22945	50	an	an	DT
18637	22945	51	interference	interference	NN
18637	22945	52	with	with	IN
18637	22945	53	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	22945	54	powers	power	NNS
18637	22945	55	of	of	IN
18637	22945	56	State	State	NNP
18637	22945	57	.	.	.
18637	22946	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22946	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22946	3	See	See	NNP
18637	22946	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22946	5	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	22946	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22946	7	.	.	.
18637	22946	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22947	1	The	the	DT
18637	22947	2	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	22947	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22947	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22947	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22947	6	Day	Day	NNP
18637	22947	7	,	,	,
18637	22947	8	11	11	CD
18637	22947	9	Wallace	wallace	NN
18637	22947	10	113	113	CD
18637	22947	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22947	12	April	April	NNP
18637	22947	13	3	3	CD
18637	22947	14	,	,	,
18637	22947	15	1871	1871	CD
18637	22947	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22947	17	.	.	.
18637	22948	1	11	11	CD
18637	22948	2	.	.	.
18637	22949	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22949	2	of	of	IN
18637	22949	3	March	March	NNP
18637	22949	4	2	2	CD
18637	22949	5	,	,	,
18637	22949	6	1867	1867	CD
18637	22949	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22949	8	14	14	CD
18637	22949	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22949	10	.	.	.
18637	22950	1	484	484	CD
18637	22950	2	,	,	,
18637	22950	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	22950	4	.	.	.
18637	22951	1	169	169	CD
18637	22951	2	,	,	,
18637	22951	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22951	4	.	.	.
18637	22952	1	29	29	CD
18637	22952	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22952	3	.	.	.
18637	22953	1	General	general	JJ
18637	22953	2	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	22953	3	on	on	IN
18637	22953	4	sale	sale	NN
18637	22953	5	of	of	IN
18637	22953	6	naphtha	naphtha	NN
18637	22953	7	,	,	,
18637	22953	8	etc	etc	FW
18637	22953	9	.	.	FW
18637	22953	10	,	,	,
18637	22953	11	for	for	IN
18637	22953	12	illuminating	illuminate	VBG
18637	22953	13	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	22953	14	,	,	,
18637	22953	15	if	if	IN
18637	22953	16	inflammable	inflammable	JJ
18637	22953	17	at	at	IN
18637	22953	18	less	less	JJR
18637	22953	19	temperature	temperature	NN
18637	22953	20	than	than	IN
18637	22953	21	110Â	110Â	NNP
18637	22953	22	°	°	,
18637	22953	23	F.	F.	NNP
18637	22953	24	,	,	,
18637	22953	25	_	_	NNP
18637	22953	26	held	hold	VBD
18637	22953	27	_	_	NNP
18637	22953	28	invalid	invalid	NN
18637	22953	29	"	"	``
18637	22953	30	except	except	IN
18637	22953	31	so	so	RB
18637	22953	32	far	far	RB
18637	22953	33	as	as	IN
18637	22953	34	the	the	DT
18637	22953	35	section	section	NN
18637	22953	36	named	name	VBN
18637	22953	37	operates	operate	NNS
18637	22953	38	within	within	IN
18637	22953	39	the	the	DT
18637	22953	40	United	United	NNP
18637	22953	41	States	States	NNP
18637	22953	42	,	,	,
18637	22953	43	but	but	CC
18637	22953	44	without	without	IN
18637	22953	45	the	the	DT
18637	22953	46	limits	limit	NNS
18637	22953	47	of	of	IN
18637	22953	48	any	any	DT
18637	22953	49	State	State	NNP
18637	22953	50	,	,	,
18637	22953	51	"	"	''
18637	22953	52	as	as	IN
18637	22953	53	being	be	VBG
18637	22953	54	a	a	DT
18637	22953	55	mere	mere	JJ
18637	22953	56	police	police	NN
18637	22953	57	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	22953	58	.	.	.
18637	22954	1	United	United	NNP
18637	22954	2	States	States	NNP
18637	22954	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22954	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22954	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22954	6	Dewitt	Dewitt	NNP
18637	22954	7	,	,	,
18637	22954	8	9	9	CD
18637	22954	9	Wallace	wallace	NN
18637	22954	10	41	41	CD
18637	22954	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22954	12	February	February	NNP
18637	22954	13	21	21	CD
18637	22954	14	,	,	,
18637	22954	15	1870	1870	CD
18637	22954	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22954	17	.	.	.
18637	22955	1	12	12	CD
18637	22955	2	.	.	.
18637	22956	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22956	2	of	of	IN
18637	22956	3	May	May	NNP
18637	22956	4	31	31	CD
18637	22956	5	,	,	,
18637	22956	6	1870	1870	CD
18637	22956	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22956	8	16	16	CD
18637	22956	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22956	10	.	.	.
18637	22957	1	140	140	CD
18637	22957	2	,	,	,
18637	22957	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	22957	4	.	.	.
18637	22958	1	114	114	CD
18637	22958	2	,	,	,
18637	22958	3	sees	see	VBZ
18637	22958	4	.	.	.
18637	22959	1	3	3	CD
18637	22959	2	,	,	,
18637	22959	3	4	4	CD
18637	22959	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22959	5	.	.	.
18637	22960	1	Provisions	provision	NNS
18637	22960	2	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	22960	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22960	4	1	1	CD
18637	22960	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22960	6	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	22960	7	of	of	IN
18637	22960	8	local	local	JJ
18637	22960	9	election	election	NN
18637	22960	10	officials	official	NNS
18637	22960	11	to	to	TO
18637	22960	12	permit	permit	VB
18637	22960	13	voting	voting	NN
18637	22960	14	by	by	IN
18637	22960	15	persons	person	NNS
18637	22960	16	offering	offer	VBG
18637	22960	17	to	to	TO
18637	22960	18	qualify	qualify	VB
18637	22960	19	under	under	IN
18637	22960	20	State	State	NNP
18637	22960	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	22960	22	,	,	,
18637	22960	23	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	22960	24	to	to	IN
18637	22960	25	any	any	DT
18637	22960	26	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	22960	27	;	;	:
18637	22960	28	and	and	CC
18637	22960	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22960	30	2	2	LS
18637	22960	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22960	32	hindering	hinder	VBG
18637	22960	33	of	of	IN
18637	22960	34	any	any	DT
18637	22960	35	person	person	NN
18637	22960	36	from	from	IN
18637	22960	37	qualifying	qualify	VBG
18637	22960	38	or	or	CC
18637	22960	39	voting	voting	NN
18637	22960	40	,	,	,
18637	22960	41	_	_	NNP
18637	22960	42	held	hold	VBD
18637	22960	43	_	_	NNP
18637	22960	44	invalid	invalid	NN
18637	22960	45	under	under	IN
18637	22960	46	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	22960	47	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22960	48	.	.	.
18637	22961	1	United	United	NNP
18637	22961	2	States	States	NNP
18637	22961	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22961	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22961	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22961	6	Reese	Reese	NNP
18637	22961	7	et	et	FW
18637	22961	8	al	al	NNP
18637	22961	9	.	.	NNP
18637	22961	10	,	,	,
18637	22961	11	92	92	CD
18637	22961	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22961	13	214	214	CD
18637	22961	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22961	15	March	March	NNP
18637	22961	16	27	27	CD
18637	22961	17	,	,	,
18637	22961	18	1876	1876	CD
18637	22961	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22961	20	.	.	.
18637	22962	1	13	13	CD
18637	22962	2	.	.	.
18637	22963	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22963	2	of	of	IN
18637	22963	3	July	July	NNP
18637	22963	4	12	12	CD
18637	22963	5	,	,	,
18637	22963	6	1870	1870	CD
18637	22963	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22963	8	16	16	CD
18637	22963	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22963	10	.	.	.
18637	22964	1	235	235	CD
18637	22964	2	,	,	,
18637	22964	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	22964	4	.	.	.
18637	22965	1	251	251	CD
18637	22965	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22965	3	.	.	.
18637	22966	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	22966	2	making	make	VBG
18637	22966	3	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	22966	4	pardons	pardon	NNS
18637	22966	5	inadmissible	inadmissible	JJ
18637	22966	6	in	in	IN
18637	22966	7	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	22966	8	in	in	IN
18637	22966	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22966	10	of	of	IN
18637	22966	11	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	22966	12	,	,	,
18637	22966	13	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	22966	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	22966	15	use	use	NN
18637	22966	16	by	by	IN
18637	22966	17	that	that	DT
18637	22966	18	court	court	NN
18637	22966	19	in	in	IN
18637	22966	20	deciding	decide	VBG
18637	22966	21	claims	claim	NNS
18637	22966	22	or	or	CC
18637	22966	23	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	22966	24	,	,	,
18637	22966	25	and	and	CC
18637	22966	26	requiring	require	VBG
18637	22966	27	dismissal	dismissal	NN
18637	22966	28	of	of	IN
18637	22966	29	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	22966	30	by	by	IN
18637	22966	31	the	the	DT
18637	22966	32	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	22966	33	Court	Court	NNP
18637	22966	34	in	in	IN
18637	22966	35	cases	case	NNS
18637	22966	36	where	where	WRB
18637	22966	37	proof	proof	NN
18637	22966	38	of	of	IN
18637	22966	39	loyalty	loyalty	NN
18637	22966	40	had	have	VBD
18637	22966	41	been	be	VBN
18637	22966	42	made	make	VBN
18637	22966	43	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	22966	44	than	than	IN
18637	22966	45	as	as	IN
18637	22966	46	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
18637	22966	47	by	by	IN
18637	22966	48	law	law	NN
18637	22966	49	,	,	,
18637	22966	50	_	_	NNP
18637	22966	51	held	hold	VBD
18637	22966	52	_	_	NNP
18637	22966	53	an	an	DT
18637	22966	54	interference	interference	NN
18637	22966	55	with	with	IN
18637	22966	56	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	22966	57	power	power	NN
18637	22966	58	under	under	IN
18637	22966	59	article	article	NN
18637	22966	60	III	III	NNP
18637	22966	61	,	,	,
18637	22966	62	section	section	NN
18637	22966	63	1	1	CD
18637	22966	64	,	,	,
18637	22966	65	and	and	CC
18637	22966	66	with	with	IN
18637	22966	67	the	the	DT
18637	22966	68	pardoning	pardon	VBG
18637	22966	69	power	power	NN
18637	22966	70	under	under	IN
18637	22966	71	article	article	NN
18637	22966	72	II	II	NNP
18637	22966	73	,	,	,
18637	22966	74	section	section	NN
18637	22966	75	2	2	CD
18637	22966	76	,	,	,
18637	22966	77	clause	clause	NN
18637	22966	78	1	1	CD
18637	22966	79	.	.	.
18637	22967	1	United	United	NNP
18637	22967	2	States	States	NNP
18637	22967	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22967	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22967	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22967	6	Klein	Klein	NNP
18637	22967	7	,	,	,
18637	22967	8	13	13	CD
18637	22967	9	Wallace	wallace	NN
18637	22967	10	128	128	CD
18637	22967	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22967	12	January	January	NNP
18637	22967	13	29	29	CD
18637	22967	14	,	,	,
18637	22967	15	1872	1872	CD
18637	22967	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22967	17	.	.	.
18637	22968	1	14	14	CD
18637	22968	2	.	.	.
18637	22969	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	22969	2	of	of	IN
18637	22969	3	June	June	NNP
18637	22969	4	22	22	CD
18637	22969	5	,	,	,
18637	22969	6	1874	1874	CD
18637	22969	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22969	8	18	18	CD
18637	22969	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22969	10	.	.	.
18637	22970	1	187	187	CD
18637	22970	2	,	,	,
18637	22970	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22970	4	.	.	.
18637	22971	1	5	5	LS
18637	22971	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22971	3	.	.	.
18637	22972	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	22972	2	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	22972	3	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	22972	4	courts	court	NNS
18637	22972	5	to	to	TO
18637	22972	6	require	require	VB
18637	22972	7	production	production	NN
18637	22972	8	of	of	IN
18637	22972	9	documents	document	NNS
18637	22972	10	in	in	IN
18637	22972	11	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	22972	12	,	,	,
18637	22972	13	other	other	JJ
18637	22972	14	than	than	IN
18637	22972	15	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	22972	16	,	,	,
18637	22972	17	under	under	IN
18637	22972	18	the	the	DT
18637	22972	19	revenue	revenue	NN
18637	22972	20	laws	law	NNS
18637	22972	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22972	22	the	the	DT
18637	22972	23	allegations	allegation	NNS
18637	22972	24	expected	expect	VBN
18637	22972	25	to	to	TO
18637	22972	26	be	be	VB
18637	22972	27	proved	prove	VBN
18637	22972	28	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	22972	29	to	to	TO
18637	22972	30	be	be	VB
18637	22972	31	taken	take	VBN
18637	22972	32	as	as	IN
18637	22972	33	proved	prove	VBN
18637	22972	34	,	,	,
18637	22972	35	on	on	IN
18637	22972	36	failure	failure	NN
18637	22972	37	to	to	TO
18637	22972	38	produce	produce	VB
18637	22972	39	such	such	JJ
18637	22972	40	documents	document	NNS
18637	22972	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22972	42	,	,	,
18637	22972	43	_	_	NNP
18637	22972	44	held	hold	VBD
18637	22972	45	_	_	NNP
18637	22972	46	as	as	IN
18637	22972	47	applied	apply	VBN
18637	22972	48	to	to	IN
18637	22972	49	a	a	DT
18637	22972	50	suit	suit	NN
18637	22972	51	for	for	IN
18637	22972	52	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	22972	53	under	under	IN
18637	22972	54	the	the	DT
18637	22972	55	customs	custom	NNS
18637	22972	56	laws	law	NNS
18637	22972	57	,	,	,
18637	22972	58	to	to	TO
18637	22972	59	constitute	constitute	VB
18637	22972	60	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	22972	61	search	search	NN
18637	22972	62	in	in	IN
18637	22972	63	violation	violation	NN
18637	22972	64	of	of	IN
18637	22972	65	the	the	DT
18637	22972	66	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	22972	67	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22972	68	.	.	.
18637	22973	1	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
18637	22973	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22973	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22973	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22973	5	United	United	NNP
18637	22973	6	States	States	NNP
18637	22973	7	,	,	,
18637	22973	8	116	116	CD
18637	22973	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22973	10	616	616	CD
18637	22973	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22973	12	February	February	NNP
18637	22973	13	1	1	CD
18637	22973	14	,	,	,
18637	22973	15	1886	1886	CD
18637	22973	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22973	17	.	.	.
18637	22974	1	15	15	CD
18637	22974	2	.	.	.
18637	22975	1	Revised	revise	VBN
18637	22975	2	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	22975	3	1977	1977	CD
18637	22975	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22975	5	act	act	NN
18637	22975	6	of	of	IN
18637	22975	7	May	May	NNP
18637	22975	8	31	31	CD
18637	22975	9	,	,	,
18637	22975	10	1870	1870	CD
18637	22975	11	,	,	,
18637	22975	12	16	16	CD
18637	22975	13	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	22975	14	.	.	.
18637	22976	1	144	144	LS
18637	22976	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22976	3	.	.	.
18637	22977	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	22977	2	that	that	IN
18637	22977	3	"	"	``
18637	22977	4	all	all	DT
18637	22977	5	persons	person	NNS
18637	22977	6	within	within	IN
18637	22977	7	the	the	DT
18637	22977	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	22977	9	of	of	IN
18637	22977	10	the	the	DT
18637	22977	11	United	United	NNP
18637	22977	12	States	States	NNP
18637	22977	13	shall	shall	MD
18637	22977	14	have	have	VB
18637	22977	15	the	the	DT
18637	22977	16	same	same	JJ
18637	22977	17	right	right	NN
18637	22977	18	in	in	IN
18637	22977	19	every	every	DT
18637	22977	20	State	State	NNP
18637	22977	21	and	and	CC
18637	22977	22	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	22977	23	to	to	TO
18637	22977	24	make	make	VB
18637	22977	25	and	and	CC
18637	22977	26	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	22977	27	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	22977	28	*	*	NFP
18637	22977	29	*	*	NFP
18637	22977	30	*	*	NFP
18637	22977	31	as	as	IN
18637	22977	32	is	be	VBZ
18637	22977	33	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
18637	22977	34	by	by	IN
18637	22977	35	white	white	JJ
18637	22977	36	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	22977	37	*	*	NFP
18637	22977	38	*	*	NFP
18637	22977	39	*	*	NFP
18637	22977	40	,	,	,
18637	22977	41	"	"	''
18637	22977	42	_	_	NNP
18637	22977	43	held	hold	VBD
18637	22977	44	_	_	NNP
18637	22977	45	invalid	invalid	NN
18637	22977	46	under	under	IN
18637	22977	47	the	the	DT
18637	22977	48	Thirteenth	Thirteenth	NNP
18637	22977	49	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22977	50	.	.	.
18637	22978	1	Hodges	Hodges	NNPS
18637	22978	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22978	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22978	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22978	5	United	United	NNP
18637	22978	6	States	States	NNP
18637	22978	7	,	,	,
18637	22978	8	203	203	CD
18637	22978	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22978	10	1	1	CD
18637	22978	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22978	12	May	May	NNP
18637	22978	13	28	28	CD
18637	22978	14	,	,	,
18637	22978	15	1906	1906	CD
18637	22978	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22978	17	.	.	.
18637	22979	1	16	16	CD
18637	22979	2	.	.	.
18637	22980	1	Revised	revise	VBN
18637	22980	2	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	22980	3	4937	4937	CD
18637	22980	4	-	-	SYM
18637	22980	5	4947	4947	CD
18637	22980	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22980	7	act	act	NN
18637	22980	8	of	of	IN
18637	22980	9	July	July	NNP
18637	22980	10	8	8	CD
18637	22980	11	,	,	,
18637	22980	12	1870	1870	CD
18637	22980	13	,	,	,
18637	22980	14	16	16	CD
18637	22980	15	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	22980	16	.	.	.
18637	22981	1	210	210	CD
18637	22981	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22981	3	,	,	,
18637	22981	4	and	and	CC
18637	22981	5	act	act	NN
18637	22981	6	of	of	IN
18637	22981	7	August	August	NNP
18637	22981	8	14	14	CD
18637	22981	9	,	,	,
18637	22981	10	1876	1876	CD
18637	22981	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22981	12	19	19	CD
18637	22981	13	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	22981	14	.	.	.
18637	22982	1	141	141	CD
18637	22982	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22982	3	.	.	.
18637	22983	1	Original	original	JJ
18637	22983	2	trademark	trademark	NN
18637	22983	3	law	law	NN
18637	22983	4	,	,	,
18637	22983	5	applying	apply	VBG
18637	22983	6	to	to	IN
18637	22983	7	marks	mark	NNS
18637	22983	8	"	"	''
18637	22983	9	for	for	IN
18637	22983	10	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
18637	22983	11	use	use	NN
18637	22983	12	within	within	IN
18637	22983	13	the	the	DT
18637	22983	14	United	United	NNP
18637	22983	15	States	States	NNP
18637	22983	16	,	,	,
18637	22983	17	"	"	''
18637	22983	18	and	and	CC
18637	22983	19	a	a	DT
18637	22983	20	penal	penal	JJ
18637	22983	21	act	act	NN
18637	22983	22	designed	design	VBN
18637	22983	23	solely	solely	RB
18637	22983	24	for	for	IN
18637	22983	25	the	the	DT
18637	22983	26	protection	protection	NN
18637	22983	27	of	of	IN
18637	22983	28	rights	right	NNS
18637	22983	29	defined	define	VBN
18637	22983	30	in	in	IN
18637	22983	31	the	the	DT
18637	22983	32	earlier	early	JJR
18637	22983	33	measure	measure	NN
18637	22983	34	,	,	,
18637	22983	35	_	_	NNP
18637	22983	36	held	hold	VBD
18637	22983	37	_	_	NNP
18637	22983	38	not	not	RB
18637	22983	39	supportable	supportable	JJ
18637	22983	40	by	by	IN
18637	22983	41	article	article	NN
18637	22983	42	I	i	NN
18637	22983	43	,	,	,
18637	22983	44	section	section	NN
18637	22983	45	8	8	CD
18637	22983	46	,	,	,
18637	22983	47	clause	clause	NN
18637	22983	48	8	8	CD
18637	22983	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22983	50	copyright	copyright	NN
18637	22983	51	clause	clause	NN
18637	22983	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22983	53	,	,	,
18637	22983	54	nor	nor	CC
18637	22983	55	article	article	NN
18637	22983	56	I	i	NN
18637	22983	57	,	,	,
18637	22983	58	section	section	NN
18637	22983	59	8	8	CD
18637	22983	60	,	,	,
18637	22983	61	clause	clause	NN
18637	22983	62	3	3	CD
18637	22983	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22983	64	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	22983	65	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	22983	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22983	67	.	.	.
18637	22984	1	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	22984	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	22984	3	Mark	Mark	NNP
18637	22984	4	Cases	case	NNS
18637	22984	5	,	,	,
18637	22984	6	100	100	CD
18637	22984	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22984	8	82	82	CD
18637	22984	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22984	10	November	November	NNP
18637	22984	11	17	17	CD
18637	22984	12	,	,	,
18637	22984	13	1879	1879	CD
18637	22984	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22984	15	.	.	.
18637	22985	1	17	17	CD
18637	22985	2	.	.	.
18637	22986	1	Revised	revise	VBN
18637	22986	2	Statutes	statute	NNS
18637	22986	3	5132	5132	CD
18637	22986	4	,	,	,
18637	22986	5	subdivision	subdivision	NN
18637	22986	6	9	9	CD
18637	22986	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22986	8	act	act	NN
18637	22986	9	of	of	IN
18637	22986	10	March	March	NNP
18637	22986	11	2	2	CD
18637	22986	12	,	,	,
18637	22986	13	1867	1867	CD
18637	22986	14	,	,	,
18637	22986	15	14	14	CD
18637	22986	16	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	22986	17	.	.	.
18637	22987	1	539	539	CD
18637	22987	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22987	3	.	.	.
18637	22988	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	22988	2	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	22988	3	"	"	``
18637	22988	4	any	any	DT
18637	22988	5	person	person	NN
18637	22988	6	respecting	respect	VBG
18637	22988	7	whom	whom	WP
18637	22988	8	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	22988	9	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	22988	10	are	be	VBP
18637	22988	11	commenced	commence	VBN
18637	22988	12	*	*	NFP
18637	22988	13	*	*	NFP
18637	22988	14	*	*	NFP
18637	22988	15	who	who	WP
18637	22988	16	,	,	,
18637	22988	17	within	within	IN
18637	22988	18	3	3	CD
18637	22988	19	months	month	NNS
18637	22988	20	before	before	IN
18637	22988	21	the	the	DT
18637	22988	22	commencement	commencement	NN
18637	22988	23	of	of	IN
18637	22988	24	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	22988	25	in	in	IN
18637	22988	26	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	22988	27	,	,	,
18637	22988	28	under	under	IN
18637	22988	29	the	the	DT
18637	22988	30	false	false	JJ
18637	22988	31	color	color	NN
18637	22988	32	and	and	CC
18637	22988	33	pretense	pretense	NN
18637	22988	34	of	of	IN
18637	22988	35	carrying	carry	VBG
18637	22988	36	on	on	IN
18637	22988	37	business	business	NN
18637	22988	38	and	and	CC
18637	22988	39	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	22988	40	in	in	IN
18637	22988	41	the	the	DT
18637	22988	42	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
18637	22988	43	course	course	NN
18637	22988	44	of	of	IN
18637	22988	45	trade	trade	NN
18637	22988	46	,	,	,
18637	22988	47	obtains	obtain	NNS
18637	22988	48	on	on	IN
18637	22988	49	credit	credit	NN
18637	22988	50	from	from	IN
18637	22988	51	any	any	DT
18637	22988	52	person	person	NN
18637	22988	53	any	any	DT
18637	22988	54	goods	good	NNS
18637	22988	55	or	or	CC
18637	22988	56	chattels	chattel	NNS
18637	22988	57	with	with	IN
18637	22988	58	intent	intent	NN
18637	22988	59	to	to	TO
18637	22988	60	defraud	defraud	VB
18637	22988	61	*	*	NFP
18637	22988	62	*	*	NFP
18637	22988	63	*	*	NFP
18637	22988	64	,	,	,
18637	22988	65	"	"	''
18637	22988	66	_	_	NNP
18637	22988	67	held	hold	VBD
18637	22988	68	_	_	NNP
18637	22988	69	a	a	DT
18637	22988	70	police	police	NN
18637	22988	71	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	22988	72	not	not	RB
18637	22988	73	within	within	IN
18637	22988	74	the	the	DT
18637	22988	75	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	22988	76	power	power	NN
18637	22988	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22988	78	art	art	NN
18637	22988	79	.	.	.
18637	22989	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	22989	2	,	,	,
18637	22989	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22989	4	.	.	.
18637	22990	1	8	8	CD
18637	22990	2	,	,	,
18637	22990	3	clause	clause	NN
18637	22990	4	4	4	CD
18637	22990	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22990	6	.	.	.
18637	22991	1	United	United	NNP
18637	22991	2	States	States	NNP
18637	22991	3	_	_	NNP
18637	22991	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	22991	5	_	_	NNP
18637	22991	6	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	22991	7	,	,	,
18637	22991	8	95	95	CD
18637	22991	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22991	10	670	670	CD
18637	22991	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22991	12	January	January	NNP
18637	22991	13	7	7	CD
18637	22991	14	,	,	,
18637	22991	15	1878	1878	CD
18637	22991	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22991	17	.	.	.
18637	22992	1	18	18	CD
18637	22992	2	.	.	.
18637	22993	1	Revised	revise	VBN
18637	22993	2	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	22993	3	5507	5507	CD
18637	22993	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22993	5	act	act	NN
18637	22993	6	of	of	IN
18637	22993	7	May	May	NNP
18637	22993	8	31	31	CD
18637	22993	9	,	,	,
18637	22993	10	1870	1870	CD
18637	22993	11	,	,	,
18637	22993	12	16	16	CD
18637	22993	13	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	22993	14	.	.	.
18637	22994	1	141	141	CD
18637	22994	2	,	,	,
18637	22994	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	22994	4	.	.	.
18637	22995	1	4	4	LS
18637	22995	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22995	3	.	.	.
18637	22996	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	22996	2	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	22996	3	"	"	``
18637	22996	4	every	every	DT
18637	22996	5	person	person	NN
18637	22996	6	who	who	WP
18637	22996	7	prevents	prevent	VBZ
18637	22996	8	,	,	,
18637	22996	9	hinders	hinder	NNS
18637	22996	10	,	,	,
18637	22996	11	controls	control	NNS
18637	22996	12	,	,	,
18637	22996	13	or	or	CC
18637	22996	14	intimidates	intimidate	VBZ
18637	22996	15	another	another	DT
18637	22996	16	from	from	IN
18637	22996	17	exercising	exercise	VBG
18637	22996	18	*	*	NFP
18637	22996	19	*	*	NFP
18637	22996	20	*	*	NFP
18637	22996	21	the	the	DT
18637	22996	22	right	right	NN
18637	22996	23	of	of	IN
18637	22996	24	suffrage	suffrage	NN
18637	22996	25	,	,	,
18637	22996	26	to	to	TO
18637	22996	27	whom	whom	WP
18637	22996	28	that	that	IN
18637	22996	29	right	right	RB
18637	22996	30	is	be	VBZ
18637	22996	31	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	22996	32	by	by	IN
18637	22996	33	the	the	DT
18637	22996	34	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	22996	35	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22996	36	to	to	IN
18637	22996	37	the	the	DT
18637	22996	38	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	22996	39	of	of	IN
18637	22996	40	the	the	DT
18637	22996	41	United	United	NNP
18637	22996	42	States	States	NNP
18637	22996	43	,	,	,
18637	22996	44	by	by	IN
18637	22996	45	means	mean	NNS
18637	22996	46	of	of	IN
18637	22996	47	bribery	bribery	NN
18637	22996	48	*	*	NFP
18637	22996	49	*	*	NFP
18637	22996	50	*	*	NFP
18637	22996	51	,	,	,
18637	22996	52	"	"	''
18637	22996	53	_	_	NNP
18637	22996	54	held	hold	VBD
18637	22996	55	_	_	NNP
18637	22996	56	not	not	RB
18637	22996	57	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	22996	58	by	by	IN
18637	22996	59	the	the	DT
18637	22996	60	said	say	VBN
18637	22996	61	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	22996	62	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	22996	63	.	.	.
18637	22997	1	James	James	NNP
18637	22997	2	_	_	NNP
18637	22997	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	22997	4	_	_	NNP
18637	22997	5	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	22997	6	,	,	,
18637	22997	7	190	190	CD
18637	22997	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	22997	9	127	127	CD
18637	22997	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22997	11	May	May	NNP
18637	22997	12	4	4	CD
18637	22997	13	,	,	,
18637	22997	14	1903	1903	CD
18637	22997	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	22997	16	.	.	.
18637	22998	1	19	19	CD
18637	22998	2	.	.	.
18637	22999	1	Revised	revise	VBN
18637	22999	2	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	22999	3	5519	5519	CD
18637	22999	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	22999	5	act	act	NN
18637	22999	6	of	of	IN
18637	22999	7	April	April	NNP
18637	22999	8	20	20	CD
18637	22999	9	,	,	,
18637	22999	10	1871	1871	CD
18637	22999	11	,	,	,
18637	22999	12	17	17	CD
18637	22999	13	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	22999	14	.	.	.
18637	23000	1	13	13	CD
18637	23000	2	,	,	,
18637	23000	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23000	4	.	.	.
18637	23001	1	22	22	CD
18637	23001	2	,	,	,
18637	23001	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23001	4	.	.	.
18637	23002	1	2	2	LS
18637	23002	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23002	3	.	.	.
18637	23003	1	Section	section	NN
18637	23003	2	providing	provide	VBG
18637	23003	3	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	23003	4	in	in	IN
18637	23003	5	case	case	NN
18637	23003	6	"	"	``
18637	23003	7	two	two	CD
18637	23003	8	or	or	CC
18637	23003	9	more	more	JJR
18637	23003	10	persons	person	NNS
18637	23003	11	in	in	IN
18637	23003	12	any	any	DT
18637	23003	13	State	state	NN
18637	23003	14	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	15	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	16	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	17	conspire	conspire	NN
18637	23003	18	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	19	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	20	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	21	for	for	IN
18637	23003	22	the	the	DT
18637	23003	23	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	23003	24	of	of	IN
18637	23003	25	depriving	deprive	VBG
18637	23003	26	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	27	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	28	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	29	any	any	DT
18637	23003	30	person	person	NN
18637	23003	31	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	32	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	33	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	34	of	of	IN
18637	23003	35	the	the	DT
18637	23003	36	equal	equal	JJ
18637	23003	37	protection	protection	NN
18637	23003	38	of	of	IN
18637	23003	39	the	the	DT
18637	23003	40	laws	law	NNS
18637	23003	41	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	42	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	43	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	44	or	or	CC
18637	23003	45	for	for	IN
18637	23003	46	the	the	DT
18637	23003	47	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	23003	48	of	of	IN
18637	23003	49	preventing	prevent	VBG
18637	23003	50	or	or	CC
18637	23003	51	hindering	hinder	VBG
18637	23003	52	the	the	DT
18637	23003	53	constituted	constituted	JJ
18637	23003	54	authorities	authority	NNS
18637	23003	55	of	of	IN
18637	23003	56	any	any	DT
18637	23003	57	State	state	NN
18637	23003	58	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	59	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	60	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	61	from	from	IN
18637	23003	62	giving	give	VBG
18637	23003	63	or	or	CC
18637	23003	64	securing	secure	VBG
18637	23003	65	to	to	IN
18637	23003	66	all	all	DT
18637	23003	67	persons	person	NNS
18637	23003	68	within	within	IN
18637	23003	69	such	such	JJ
18637	23003	70	State	state	NN
18637	23003	71	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	72	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	73	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	74	the	the	DT
18637	23003	75	equal	equal	JJ
18637	23003	76	protection	protection	NN
18637	23003	77	of	of	IN
18637	23003	78	the	the	DT
18637	23003	79	laws	law	NNS
18637	23003	80	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	81	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	82	*	*	NFP
18637	23003	83	,	,	,
18637	23003	84	"	"	''
18637	23003	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23003	86	held	hold	VBD
18637	23003	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23003	88	invalid	invalid	NN
18637	23003	89	for	for	IN
18637	23003	90	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	23003	91	of	of	IN
18637	23003	92	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	23003	93	within	within	IN
18637	23003	94	a	a	DT
18637	23003	95	State	state	NN
18637	23003	96	--	--	:
18637	23003	97	as	as	IN
18637	23003	98	not	not	RB
18637	23003	99	supported	support	VBN
18637	23003	100	by	by	IN
18637	23003	101	the	the	DT
18637	23003	102	Thirteenth	Thirteenth	NNP
18637	23003	103	to	to	IN
18637	23003	104	Fifteenth	Fifteenth	NNP
18637	23003	105	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	23003	106	.	.	.
18637	23004	1	United	United	NNP
18637	23004	2	States	States	NNP
18637	23004	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23004	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23004	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23004	6	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	23004	7	,	,	,
18637	23004	8	106	106	CD
18637	23004	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23004	10	629	629	CD
18637	23004	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23004	12	January	January	NNP
18637	23004	13	22	22	CD
18637	23004	14	,	,	,
18637	23004	15	1883	1883	CD
18637	23004	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23004	17	.	.	.
18637	23005	1	In	in	IN
18637	23005	2	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	23005	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23005	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23005	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23005	6	.	.	.
18637	23006	1	Franks	frank	NNS
18637	23006	2	,	,	,
18637	23006	3	120	120	CD
18637	23006	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23006	5	678	678	CD
18637	23006	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23006	7	March	March	NNP
18637	23006	8	7	7	CD
18637	23006	9	,	,	,
18637	23006	10	1887	1887	CD
18637	23006	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23006	12	,	,	,
18637	23006	13	an	an	DT
18637	23006	14	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	23006	15	was	be	VBD
18637	23006	16	made	make	VBN
18637	23006	17	to	to	TO
18637	23006	18	distinguish	distinguish	VB
18637	23006	19	the	the	DT
18637	23006	20	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	23006	21	case	case	NN
18637	23006	22	,	,	,
18637	23006	23	and	and	CC
18637	23006	24	apply	apply	VB
18637	23006	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	23006	26	to	to	IN
18637	23006	27	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	23006	28	against	against	IN
18637	23006	29	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	23006	30	,	,	,
18637	23006	31	though	though	IN
18637	23006	32	within	within	IN
18637	23006	33	a	a	DT
18637	23006	34	State	State	NNP
18637	23006	35	,	,	,
18637	23006	36	and	and	CC
18637	23006	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23006	38	held	hold	VBD
18637	23006	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23006	40	,	,	,
18637	23006	41	the	the	DT
18637	23006	42	provision	provision	NN
18637	23006	43	was	be	VBD
18637	23006	44	not	not	RB
18637	23006	45	separable	separable	JJ
18637	23006	46	in	in	IN
18637	23006	47	such	such	JJ
18637	23006	48	case	case	NN
18637	23006	49	.	.	.
18637	23007	1	20	20	CD
18637	23007	2	.	.	.
18637	23008	1	Revised	revise	VBN
18637	23008	2	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	23008	3	of	of	IN
18637	23008	4	the	the	DT
18637	23008	5	District	District	NNP
18637	23008	6	of	of	IN
18637	23008	7	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23008	8	,	,	,
18637	23008	9	section	section	NN
18637	23008	10	1064	1064	CD
18637	23008	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23008	12	act	act	NN
18637	23008	13	of	of	IN
18637	23008	14	June	June	NNP
18637	23008	15	17	17	CD
18637	23008	16	,	,	,
18637	23008	17	1870	1870	CD
18637	23008	18	,	,	,
18637	23008	19	16	16	CD
18637	23008	20	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	23008	21	.	.	.
18637	23009	1	154	154	CD
18637	23009	2	,	,	,
18637	23009	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23009	4	.	.	.
18637	23010	1	133	133	CD
18637	23010	2	,	,	,
18637	23010	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23010	4	.	.	.
18637	23011	1	3	3	LS
18637	23011	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23011	3	.	.	.
18637	23012	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	23012	2	that	that	IN
18637	23012	3	"	"	``
18637	23012	4	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
18637	23012	5	in	in	IN
18637	23012	6	the	the	DT
18637	23012	7	police	police	NN
18637	23012	8	court	court	NN
18637	23012	9	[	[	-LRB-
18637	23012	10	of	of	IN
18637	23012	11	the	the	DT
18637	23012	12	District	District	NNP
18637	23012	13	of	of	IN
18637	23012	14	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23012	15	]	]	-RRB-
18637	23012	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	23012	17	be	be	VB
18637	23012	18	by	by	IN
18637	23012	19	information	information	NN
18637	23012	20	under	under	IN
18637	23012	21	oath	oath	NN
18637	23012	22	,	,	,
18637	23012	23	without	without	IN
18637	23012	24	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	23012	25	by	by	IN
18637	23012	26	grand	grand	JJ
18637	23012	27	jury	jury	NN
18637	23012	28	or	or	CC
18637	23012	29	trial	trial	NN
18637	23012	30	by	by	IN
18637	23012	31	petit	petit	NNP
18637	23012	32	jury	jury	NN
18637	23012	33	,	,	,
18637	23012	34	"	"	''
18637	23012	35	as	as	IN
18637	23012	36	applied	apply	VBN
18637	23012	37	to	to	IN
18637	23012	38	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	23012	39	for	for	IN
18637	23012	40	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
18637	23012	41	,	,	,
18637	23012	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23012	43	held	hold	VBD
18637	23012	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23012	45	to	to	IN
18637	23012	46	Contravene	Contravene	NNP
18637	23012	47	article	article	NN
18637	23012	48	III	iii	CD
18637	23012	49	,	,	,
18637	23012	50	section	section	NN
18637	23012	51	2	2	CD
18637	23012	52	,	,	,
18637	23012	53	clause	clause	NN
18637	23012	54	3	3	CD
18637	23012	55	,	,	,
18637	23012	56	requiring	require	VBG
18637	23012	57	jury	jury	NN
18637	23012	58	trial	trial	NN
18637	23012	59	of	of	IN
18637	23012	60	all	all	DT
18637	23012	61	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	23012	62	.	.	.
18637	23013	1	Callan	Callan	NNP
18637	23013	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23013	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23013	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23013	5	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	23013	6	,	,	,
18637	23013	7	127	127	CD
18637	23013	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23013	9	540	540	CD
18637	23013	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23013	11	May	May	NNP
18637	23013	12	14	14	CD
18637	23013	13	,	,	,
18637	23013	14	1888	1888	CD
18637	23013	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23013	16	.	.	.
18637	23014	1	21	21	CD
18637	23014	2	.	.	.
18637	23015	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23015	2	of	of	IN
18637	23015	3	March	March	NNP
18637	23015	4	1	1	CD
18637	23015	5	,	,	,
18637	23015	6	1875	1875	CD
18637	23015	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23015	8	18	18	CD
18637	23015	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23015	10	.	.	.
18637	23016	1	336	336	CD
18637	23016	2	,	,	,
18637	23016	3	secs	secs	JJ
18637	23016	4	.	.	.
18637	23017	1	1	1	CD
18637	23017	2	,	,	,
18637	23017	3	2	2	CD
18637	23017	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23017	5	.	.	.
18637	23018	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	23018	2	"	"	``
18637	23018	3	That	that	IN
18637	23018	4	all	all	DT
18637	23018	5	persons	person	NNS
18637	23018	6	within	within	IN
18637	23018	7	the	the	DT
18637	23018	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	23018	9	of	of	IN
18637	23018	10	the	the	DT
18637	23018	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23018	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23018	13	shall	shall	MD
18637	23018	14	be	be	VB
18637	23018	15	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	23018	16	to	to	IN
18637	23018	17	the	the	DT
18637	23018	18	full	full	JJ
18637	23018	19	and	and	CC
18637	23018	20	equal	equal	JJ
18637	23018	21	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	23018	22	of	of	IN
18637	23018	23	the	the	DT
18637	23018	24	accommodations	accommodation	NNS
18637	23018	25	*	*	NFP
18637	23018	26	*	*	NFP
18637	23018	27	*	*	NFP
18637	23018	28	of	of	IN
18637	23018	29	inns	inn	NNS
18637	23018	30	,	,	,
18637	23018	31	public	public	JJ
18637	23018	32	conveyances	conveyance	NNS
18637	23018	33	on	on	IN
18637	23018	34	land	land	NN
18637	23018	35	or	or	CC
18637	23018	36	water	water	NN
18637	23018	37	,	,	,
18637	23018	38	theaters	theater	NNS
18637	23018	39	,	,	,
18637	23018	40	and	and	CC
18637	23018	41	other	other	JJ
18637	23018	42	places	place	NNS
18637	23018	43	of	of	IN
18637	23018	44	public	public	JJ
18637	23018	45	amusement	amusement	NN
18637	23018	46	;	;	:
18637	23018	47	subject	subject	JJ
18637	23018	48	only	only	RB
18637	23018	49	to	to	IN
18637	23018	50	the	the	DT
18637	23018	51	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	23018	52	and	and	CC
18637	23018	53	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	23018	54	established	establish	VBN
18637	23018	55	by	by	IN
18637	23018	56	law	law	NN
18637	23018	57	,	,	,
18637	23018	58	and	and	CC
18637	23018	59	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	23018	60	alike	alike	RB
18637	23018	61	to	to	IN
18637	23018	62	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	23018	63	of	of	IN
18637	23018	64	every	every	DT
18637	23018	65	race	race	NN
18637	23018	66	and	and	CC
18637	23018	67	color	color	NN
18637	23018	68	,	,	,
18637	23018	69	regardless	regardless	RB
18637	23018	70	of	of	IN
18637	23018	71	any	any	DT
18637	23018	72	previous	previous	JJ
18637	23018	73	condition	condition	NN
18637	23018	74	of	of	IN
18637	23018	75	servitude"--subject	servitude"--subject	NN
18637	23018	76	to	to	IN
18637	23018	77	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	23018	78	,	,	,
18637	23018	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23018	80	held	hold	VBD
18637	23018	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23018	82	not	not	RB
18637	23018	83	to	to	TO
18637	23018	84	be	be	VB
18637	23018	85	supported	support	VBN
18637	23018	86	by	by	IN
18637	23018	87	the	the	DT
18637	23018	88	Thirteenth	Thirteenth	NNP
18637	23018	89	or	or	CC
18637	23018	90	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	23018	91	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	23018	92	.	.	.
18637	23019	1	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	23019	2	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	23019	3	Cases	case	NNS
18637	23019	4	,	,	,
18637	23019	5	109	109	CD
18637	23019	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23019	7	3	3	CD
18637	23019	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23019	9	October	October	NNP
18637	23019	10	15	15	CD
18637	23019	11	,	,	,
18637	23019	12	1883	1883	CD
18637	23019	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23019	14	,	,	,
18637	23019	15	as	as	IN
18637	23019	16	to	to	IN
18637	23019	17	operation	operation	NN
18637	23019	18	within	within	IN
18637	23019	19	States	States	NNP
18637	23019	20	.	.	.
18637	23020	1	Butts	Butts	NNP
18637	23020	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23020	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23020	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23020	5	Merchants	Merchants	NNPS
18637	23020	6	and	and	CC
18637	23020	7	Miners	Miners	NNPS
18637	23020	8	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	23020	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23020	10	,	,	,
18637	23020	11	230	230	CD
18637	23020	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23020	13	126	126	CD
18637	23020	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23020	15	June	June	NNP
18637	23020	16	16	16	CD
18637	23020	17	,	,	,
18637	23020	18	1913	1913	CD
18637	23020	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23020	20	as	as	IN
18637	23020	21	to	to	IN
18637	23020	22	operation	operation	NN
18637	23020	23	outside	outside	IN
18637	23020	24	the	the	DT
18637	23020	25	States	States	NNP
18637	23020	26	.	.	.
18637	23021	1	22	22	CD
18637	23021	2	.	.	.
18637	23022	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23022	2	of	of	IN
18637	23022	3	March	March	NNP
18637	23022	4	3	3	CD
18637	23022	5	,	,	,
18637	23022	6	1875	1875	CD
18637	23022	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23022	8	18	18	CD
18637	23022	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23022	10	.	.	.
18637	23023	1	479	479	CD
18637	23023	2	,	,	,
18637	23023	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23023	4	.	.	.
18637	23024	1	144	144	CD
18637	23024	2	,	,	,
18637	23024	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23024	4	.	.	.
18637	23025	1	2	2	LS
18637	23025	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23025	3	.	.	.
18637	23026	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	23026	2	that	that	IN
18637	23026	3	"	"	``
18637	23026	4	if	if	IN
18637	23026	5	the	the	DT
18637	23026	6	party	party	NN
18637	23026	7	[	[	-LRB-
18637	23026	8	i.e.	i.e.	FW
18637	23026	9	,	,	,
18637	23026	10	a	a	DT
18637	23026	11	person	person	NN
18637	23026	12	stealing	steal	VBG
18637	23026	13	property	property	NN
18637	23026	14	from	from	IN
18637	23026	15	the	the	DT
18637	23026	16	United	United	NNP
18637	23026	17	States	States	NNP
18637	23026	18	]	]	-RRB-
18637	23026	19	has	have	VBZ
18637	23026	20	been	be	VBN
18637	23026	21	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	23026	22	,	,	,
18637	23026	23	then	then	RB
18637	23026	24	the	the	DT
18637	23026	25	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	23026	26	against	against	IN
18637	23026	27	him	-PRON-	PRP
18637	23026	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	23026	29	be	be	VB
18637	23026	30	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
18637	23026	31	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	23026	32	in	in	IN
18637	23026	33	the	the	DT
18637	23026	34	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	23026	35	against	against	IN
18637	23026	36	[	[	-LRB-
18637	23026	37	the	the	DT
18637	23026	38	]	]	-RRB-
18637	23026	39	receiver	receiver	NN
18637	23026	40	that	that	IN
18637	23026	41	the	the	DT
18637	23026	42	property	property	NN
18637	23026	43	of	of	IN
18637	23026	44	the	the	DT
18637	23026	45	United	United	NNP
18637	23026	46	States	States	NNP
18637	23026	47	therein	therein	RB
18637	23026	48	described	describe	VBD
18637	23026	49	has	have	VBZ
18637	23026	50	been	be	VBN
18637	23026	51	embezzled	embezzle	VBN
18637	23026	52	,	,	,
18637	23026	53	stolen	steal	VBN
18637	23026	54	,	,	,
18637	23026	55	or	or	CC
18637	23026	56	purloined	purloin	VBN
18637	23026	57	,	,	,
18637	23026	58	"	"	''
18637	23026	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23026	60	held	hold	VBD
18637	23026	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23026	62	to	to	TO
18637	23026	63	contravene	contravene	VB
18637	23026	64	the	the	DT
18637	23026	65	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	23026	66	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23026	67	.	.	.
18637	23027	1	Kirby	Kirby	NNP
18637	23027	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23027	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23027	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23027	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23027	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23027	7	,	,	,
18637	23027	8	174	174	CD
18637	23027	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23027	10	47	47	CD
18637	23027	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23027	12	April	April	NNP
18637	23027	13	11	11	CD
18637	23027	14	,	,	,
18637	23027	15	1899	1899	CD
18637	23027	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23027	17	.	.	.
18637	23028	1	23	23	CD
18637	23028	2	.	.	.
18637	23029	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23029	2	of	of	IN
18637	23029	3	July	July	NNP
18637	23029	4	12	12	CD
18637	23029	5	,	,	,
18637	23029	6	1876	1876	CD
18637	23029	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23029	8	19	19	CD
18637	23029	9	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	23029	10	.	.	.
18637	23030	1	80	80	CD
18637	23030	2	,	,	,
18637	23030	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23030	4	.	.	.
18637	23031	1	6	6	LS
18637	23031	2	,	,	,
18637	23031	3	in	in	IN
18637	23031	4	part	part	NN
18637	23031	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23031	6	.	.	.
18637	23032	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	23032	2	that	that	IN
18637	23032	3	"	"	``
18637	23032	4	postmasters	postmaster	NNS
18637	23032	5	of	of	IN
18637	23032	6	the	the	DT
18637	23032	7	first	first	JJ
18637	23032	8	,	,	,
18637	23032	9	second	second	JJ
18637	23032	10	,	,	,
18637	23032	11	and	and	CC
18637	23032	12	third	third	JJ
18637	23032	13	classes	class	NNS
18637	23032	14	*	*	NFP
18637	23032	15	*	*	NFP
18637	23032	16	*	*	NFP
18637	23032	17	may	may	MD
18637	23032	18	be	be	VB
18637	23032	19	removed	remove	VBN
18637	23032	20	by	by	IN
18637	23032	21	the	the	DT
18637	23032	22	President	President	NNP
18637	23032	23	by	by	IN
18637	23032	24	and	and	CC
18637	23032	25	with	with	IN
18637	23032	26	the	the	DT
18637	23032	27	advice	advice	NN
18637	23032	28	and	and	CC
18637	23032	29	consent	consent	NN
18637	23032	30	of	of	IN
18637	23032	31	the	the	DT
18637	23032	32	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	23032	33	,	,	,
18637	23032	34	"	"	''
18637	23032	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23032	36	held	hold	VBD
18637	23032	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23032	38	to	to	TO
18637	23032	39	infringe	infringe	VB
18637	23032	40	the	the	DT
18637	23032	41	executive	executive	JJ
18637	23032	42	power	power	NN
18637	23032	43	under	under	IN
18637	23032	44	article	article	NN
18637	23032	45	II	II	NNP
18637	23032	46	,	,	,
18637	23032	47	section	section	NN
18637	23032	48	1	1	CD
18637	23032	49	,	,	,
18637	23032	50	clause	clause	NN
18637	23032	51	1	1	CD
18637	23032	52	.	.	.
18637	23033	1	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	23033	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23033	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23033	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23033	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23033	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23033	7	,	,	,
18637	23033	8	272	272	CD
18637	23033	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23033	10	52	52	CD
18637	23033	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23033	12	October	October	NNP
18637	23033	13	25	25	CD
18637	23033	14	,	,	,
18637	23033	15	1926	1926	CD
18637	23033	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23033	17	.	.	.
18637	23034	1	24	24	CD
18637	23034	2	.	.	.
18637	23035	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23035	2	of	of	IN
18637	23035	3	August	August	NNP
18637	23035	4	14	14	CD
18637	23035	5	,	,	,
18637	23035	6	1876	1876	CD
18637	23035	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23035	8	19	19	CD
18637	23035	9	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	23035	10	.	.	.
18637	23036	1	141	141	CD
18637	23036	2	,	,	,
18637	23036	3	trademark	trademark	NNP
18637	23036	4	act	act	NNP
18637	23036	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23036	6	,	,	,
18637	23036	7	_	_	NNP
18637	23036	8	see	see	VBP
18637	23036	9	_	_	NNP
18637	23036	10	Revised	Revised	NNP
18637	23036	11	Statutes	Statutes	NNP
18637	23036	12	4937	4937	CD
18637	23036	13	.	.	.
18637	23037	1	25	25	CD
18637	23037	2	.	.	.
18637	23038	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23038	2	of	of	IN
18637	23038	3	August	August	NNP
18637	23038	4	11	11	CD
18637	23038	5	,	,	,
18637	23038	6	1888	1888	CD
18637	23038	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23038	8	25	25	CD
18637	23038	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23038	10	.	.	.
18637	23039	1	411	411	CD
18637	23039	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23039	3	.	.	.
18637	23040	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	23040	2	,	,	,
18637	23040	3	in	in	IN
18637	23040	4	a	a	DT
18637	23040	5	provision	provision	NN
18637	23040	6	for	for	IN
18637	23040	7	the	the	DT
18637	23040	8	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	23040	9	or	or	CC
18637	23040	10	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	23040	11	of	of	IN
18637	23040	12	a	a	DT
18637	23040	13	certain	certain	JJ
18637	23040	14	lock	lock	NN
18637	23040	15	and	and	CC
18637	23040	16	dam	dam	NN
18637	23040	17	in	in	IN
18637	23040	18	the	the	DT
18637	23040	19	Monongahela	Monongahela	NNP
18637	23040	20	River	River	NNP
18637	23040	21	,	,	,
18637	23040	22	that	that	IN
18637	23040	23	"	"	``
18637	23040	24	*	*	NFP
18637	23040	25	*	*	NFP
18637	23040	26	*	*	NFP
18637	23040	27	in	in	IN
18637	23040	28	estimating	estimate	VBG
18637	23040	29	the	the	DT
18637	23040	30	sum	sum	NN
18637	23040	31	to	to	TO
18637	23040	32	be	be	VB
18637	23040	33	paid	pay	VBN
18637	23040	34	by	by	IN
18637	23040	35	the	the	DT
18637	23040	36	United	United	NNP
18637	23040	37	States	States	NNP
18637	23040	38	,	,	,
18637	23040	39	the	the	DT
18637	23040	40	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	23040	41	of	of	IN
18637	23040	42	said	say	VBD
18637	23040	43	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	23040	44	to	to	TO
18637	23040	45	collect	collect	VB
18637	23040	46	tolls	toll	NNS
18637	23040	47	shall	shall	MD
18637	23040	48	not	not	RB
18637	23040	49	be	be	VB
18637	23040	50	considered	consider	VBN
18637	23040	51	or	or	CC
18637	23040	52	estimated	estimate	VBN
18637	23040	53	*	*	NFP
18637	23040	54	*	*	NFP
18637	23040	55	*	*	NFP
18637	23040	56	,	,	,
18637	23040	57	"	"	''
18637	23040	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23040	59	held	hold	VBD
18637	23040	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23040	61	to	to	TO
18637	23040	62	contravene	contravene	VB
18637	23040	63	the	the	DT
18637	23040	64	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	23040	65	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23040	66	.	.	.
18637	23041	1	Monongahela	Monongahela	NNP
18637	23041	2	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	23041	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23041	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23041	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	23041	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23041	7	United	United	NNP
18637	23041	8	States	States	NNP
18637	23041	9	,	,	,
18637	23041	10	148	148	CD
18637	23041	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23041	12	312	312	CD
18637	23041	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23041	14	March	March	NNP
18637	23041	15	27	27	CD
18637	23041	16	,	,	,
18637	23041	17	1893	1893	CD
18637	23041	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23041	19	.	.	.
18637	23042	1	26	26	CD
18637	23042	2	.	.	.
18637	23043	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23043	2	of	of	IN
18637	23043	3	May	May	NNP
18637	23043	4	5	5	CD
18637	23043	5	,	,	,
18637	23043	6	1892	1892	CD
18637	23043	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23043	8	27	27	CD
18637	23043	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23043	10	.	.	.
18637	23044	1	25	25	CD
18637	23044	2	,	,	,
18637	23044	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23044	4	.	.	.
18637	23045	1	60	60	CD
18637	23045	2	,	,	,
18637	23045	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23045	4	.	.	.
18637	23046	1	4	4	LS
18637	23046	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23046	3	.	.	.
18637	23047	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	23047	2	of	of	IN
18637	23047	3	a	a	DT
18637	23047	4	Chinese	chinese	JJ
18637	23047	5	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	23047	6	act	act	NN
18637	23047	7	,	,	,
18637	23047	8	that	that	IN
18637	23047	9	Chinese	chinese	JJ
18637	23047	10	persons	person	NNS
18637	23047	11	"	"	``
18637	23047	12	convicted	convict	VBN
18637	23047	13	and	and	CC
18637	23047	14	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
18637	23047	15	to	to	TO
18637	23047	16	be	be	VB
18637	23047	17	not	not	RB
18637	23047	18	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	23047	19	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	23047	20	to	to	TO
18637	23047	21	be	be	VB
18637	23047	22	or	or	CC
18637	23047	23	remain	remain	VB
18637	23047	24	in	in	IN
18637	23047	25	the	the	DT
18637	23047	26	United	United	NNP
18637	23047	27	States	States	NNP
18637	23047	28	shall	shall	MD
18637	23047	29	be	be	VB
18637	23047	30	imprisoned	imprison	VBN
18637	23047	31	at	at	IN
18637	23047	32	hard	hard	JJ
18637	23047	33	labor	labor	NN
18637	23047	34	for	for	IN
18637	23047	35	a	a	DT
18637	23047	36	period	period	NN
18637	23047	37	not	not	RB
18637	23047	38	exceeding	exceed	VBG
18637	23047	39	1	1	CD
18637	23047	40	year	year	NN
18637	23047	41	and	and	CC
18637	23047	42	thereafter	thereafter	RB
18637	23047	43	removed	remove	VBN
18637	23047	44	from	from	IN
18637	23047	45	the	the	DT
18637	23047	46	United	United	NNP
18637	23047	47	States	States	NNP
18637	23047	48	*	*	NFP
18637	23047	49	*	*	NFP
18637	23047	50	*	*	NFP
18637	23047	51	"	"	''
18637	23047	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23047	53	such	such	JJ
18637	23047	54	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	23047	55	and	and	CC
18637	23047	56	judgment	judgment	NN
18637	23047	57	being	be	VBG
18637	23047	58	had	have	VBN
18637	23047	59	before	before	IN
18637	23047	60	a	a	DT
18637	23047	61	justice	justice	NN
18637	23047	62	,	,	,
18637	23047	63	judge	judge	NN
18637	23047	64	,	,	,
18637	23047	65	or	or	CC
18637	23047	66	commissioner	commissioner	NN
18637	23047	67	upon	upon	IN
18637	23047	68	a	a	DT
18637	23047	69	summary	summary	NN
18637	23047	70	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	23047	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23047	72	,	,	,
18637	23047	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23047	74	held	hold	VBD
18637	23047	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23047	76	to	to	TO
18637	23047	77	contravene	contravene	VB
18637	23047	78	the	the	DT
18637	23047	79	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	23047	80	and	and	CC
18637	23047	81	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	23047	82	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	23047	83	.	.	.
18637	23048	1	Wong	Wong	NNP
18637	23048	2	Wing	Wing	NNP
18637	23048	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23048	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23048	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23048	6	United	United	NNP
18637	23048	7	States	States	NNP
18637	23048	8	,	,	,
18637	23048	9	163	163	CD
18637	23048	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23048	11	228	228	CD
18637	23048	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23048	13	May	May	NNP
18637	23048	14	18	18	CD
18637	23048	15	,	,	,
18637	23048	16	1896	1896	CD
18637	23048	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23048	18	.	.	.
18637	23049	1	27	27	CD
18637	23049	2	.	.	.
18637	23050	1	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	23050	2	Resolution	Resolution	NNP
18637	23050	3	of	of	IN
18637	23050	4	August	August	NNP
18637	23050	5	4	4	CD
18637	23050	6	,	,	,
18637	23050	7	1894	1894	CD
18637	23050	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23050	9	28	28	CD
18637	23050	10	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23050	11	.	.	.
18637	23051	1	1018	1018	CD
18637	23051	2	,	,	,
18637	23051	3	No	no	UH
18637	23051	4	.	.	.
18637	23052	1	41	41	CD
18637	23052	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23052	3	.	.	.
18637	23053	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	23053	2	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	23053	3	the	the	DT
18637	23053	4	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	23053	5	of	of	IN
18637	23053	6	the	the	DT
18637	23053	7	Interior	Interior	NNP
18637	23053	8	to	to	TO
18637	23053	9	approve	approve	VB
18637	23053	10	a	a	DT
18637	23053	11	second	second	JJ
18637	23053	12	lease	lease	NN
18637	23053	13	of	of	IN
18637	23053	14	certain	certain	JJ
18637	23053	15	land	land	NN
18637	23053	16	by	by	IN
18637	23053	17	an	an	DT
18637	23053	18	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	23053	19	chief	chief	NN
18637	23053	20	in	in	IN
18637	23053	21	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23053	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23053	23	granted	grant	VBN
18637	23053	24	to	to	IN
18637	23053	25	lessor	lessor	NN
18637	23053	26	's	's	POS
18637	23053	27	ancestor	ancestor	NN
18637	23053	28	by	by	IN
18637	23053	29	art	art	NN
18637	23053	30	.	.	.
18637	23054	1	9	9	CD
18637	23054	2	of	of	IN
18637	23054	3	a	a	DT
18637	23054	4	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	23054	5	with	with	IN
18637	23054	6	the	the	DT
18637	23054	7	Chippewa	Chippewa	NNP
18637	23054	8	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	23054	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23054	10	,	,	,
18637	23054	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23054	12	held	hold	VBD
18637	23054	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23054	14	an	an	DT
18637	23054	15	interference	interference	NN
18637	23054	16	with	with	IN
18637	23054	17	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	23054	18	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	23054	19	of	of	IN
18637	23054	20	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	23054	21	under	under	IN
18637	23054	22	article	article	NN
18637	23054	23	III	III	NNP
18637	23054	24	,	,	,
18637	23054	25	section	section	NN
18637	23054	26	2	2	CD
18637	23054	27	,	,	,
18637	23054	28	clause	clause	NN
18637	23054	29	1	1	CD
18637	23054	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23054	31	and	and	CC
18637	23054	32	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
18637	23054	33	to	to	IN
18637	23054	34	the	the	DT
18637	23054	35	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	23054	36	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23054	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23054	38	.	.	.
18637	23055	1	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	23055	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23055	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23055	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23055	5	Meehan	Meehan	NNP
18637	23055	6	,	,	,
18637	23055	7	175	175	CD
18637	23055	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23055	9	1	1	CD
18637	23055	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23055	11	October	October	NNP
18637	23055	12	30	30	CD
18637	23055	13	,	,	,
18637	23055	14	1899	1899	CD
18637	23055	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23055	16	.	.	.
18637	23056	1	28	28	CD
18637	23056	2	.	.	.
18637	23057	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23057	2	of	of	IN
18637	23057	3	August	August	NNP
18637	23057	4	27	27	CD
18637	23057	5	,	,	,
18637	23057	6	1894	1894	CD
18637	23057	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23057	8	28	28	CD
18637	23057	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23057	10	.	.	.
18637	23058	1	553	553	CD
18637	23058	2	-	-	SYM
18637	23058	3	560	560	CD
18637	23058	4	,	,	,
18637	23058	5	secs	secs	JJ
18637	23058	6	.	.	.
18637	23059	1	27	27	CD
18637	23059	2	-	-	SYM
18637	23059	3	37	37	CD
18637	23059	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23059	5	.	.	.
18637	23060	1	Income	income	NN
18637	23060	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	23060	3	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	23060	4	of	of	IN
18637	23060	5	the	the	DT
18637	23060	6	tariff	tariff	NN
18637	23060	7	act	act	NNP
18637	23060	8	of	of	IN
18637	23060	9	1894	1894	CD
18637	23060	10	.	.	.
18637	23061	1	"	"	``
18637	23061	2	The	the	DT
18637	23061	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	23061	4	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	23061	5	by	by	IN
18637	23061	6	sections	section	NNS
18637	23061	7	27	27	CD
18637	23061	8	and	and	CC
18637	23061	9	37	37	CD
18637	23061	10	,	,	,
18637	23061	11	inclusive	inclusive	JJ
18637	23061	12	*	*	NFP
18637	23061	13	*	*	NFP
18637	23061	14	*	*	NFP
18637	23061	15	so	so	RB
18637	23061	16	far	far	RB
18637	23061	17	as	as	IN
18637	23061	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	23061	19	falls	fall	VBZ
18637	23061	20	on	on	IN
18637	23061	21	the	the	DT
18637	23061	22	income	income	NN
18637	23061	23	of	of	IN
18637	23061	24	real	real	JJ
18637	23061	25	estate	estate	NN
18637	23061	26	and	and	CC
18637	23061	27	of	of	IN
18637	23061	28	personal	personal	JJ
18637	23061	29	property	property	NN
18637	23061	30	,	,	,
18637	23061	31	being	be	VBG
18637	23061	32	a	a	DT
18637	23061	33	direct	direct	JJ
18637	23061	34	tax	tax	NN
18637	23061	35	within	within	IN
18637	23061	36	the	the	DT
18637	23061	37	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	23061	38	of	of	IN
18637	23061	39	the	the	DT
18637	23061	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	23061	41	,	,	,
18637	23061	42	and	and	CC
18637	23061	43	,	,	,
18637	23061	44	therefore	therefore	RB
18637	23061	45	,	,	,
18637	23061	46	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	23061	47	and	and	CC
18637	23061	48	void	void	JJ
18637	23061	49	because	because	IN
18637	23061	50	not	not	RB
18637	23061	51	apportioned	apportion	VBN
18637	23061	52	according	accord	VBG
18637	23061	53	to	to	IN
18637	23061	54	representation	representation	NN
18637	23061	55	[	[	-LRB-
18637	23061	56	art	art	NN
18637	23061	57	.	.	.
18637	23062	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	23062	2	,	,	,
18637	23062	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23062	4	.	.	.
18637	23063	1	2	2	CD
18637	23063	2	,	,	,
18637	23063	3	clause	clause	NN
18637	23063	4	3	3	CD
18637	23063	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	23063	6	,	,	,
18637	23063	7	all	all	PDT
18637	23063	8	those	those	DT
18637	23063	9	sections	section	NNS
18637	23063	10	,	,	,
18637	23063	11	constituting	constitute	VBG
18637	23063	12	one	one	CD
18637	23063	13	entire	entire	JJ
18637	23063	14	scheme	scheme	NN
18637	23063	15	of	of	IN
18637	23063	16	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	23063	17	,	,	,
18637	23063	18	are	be	VBP
18637	23063	19	necessarily	necessarily	RB
18637	23063	20	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	23063	21	"	"	''
18637	23063	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23063	23	158	158	CD
18637	23063	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23063	25	601	601	CD
18637	23063	26	,	,	,
18637	23063	27	637	637	CD
18637	23063	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23063	29	.	.	.
18637	23064	1	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	23064	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23064	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23064	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23064	5	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	23064	6	'	'	POS
18637	23064	7	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	23064	8	and	and	CC
18637	23064	9	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23064	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23064	11	,	,	,
18637	23064	12	157	157	CD
18637	23064	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23064	14	429	429	CD
18637	23064	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23064	16	April	April	NNP
18637	23064	17	8	8	CD
18637	23064	18	,	,	,
18637	23064	19	1895	1895	CD
18637	23064	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23064	21	and	and	CC
18637	23064	22	rehearing	rehear	VBG
18637	23064	23	,	,	,
18637	23064	24	158	158	CD
18637	23064	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23064	26	601	601	CD
18637	23064	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23064	28	May	May	NNP
18637	23064	29	20	20	CD
18637	23064	30	,	,	,
18637	23064	31	1895	1895	CD
18637	23064	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23064	33	.	.	.
18637	23065	1	29	29	CD
18637	23065	2	.	.	.
18637	23066	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23066	2	of	of	IN
18637	23066	3	January	January	NNP
18637	23066	4	30	30	CD
18637	23066	5	,	,	,
18637	23066	6	1897	1897	CD
18637	23066	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23066	8	29	29	CD
18637	23066	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23066	10	.	.	.
18637	23067	1	506	506	CD
18637	23067	2	,	,	,
18637	23067	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23067	4	.	.	.
18637	23068	1	109	109	CD
18637	23068	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23068	3	.	.	.
18637	23069	1	Prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	23069	2	on	on	IN
18637	23069	3	sale	sale	NN
18637	23069	4	of	of	IN
18637	23069	5	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	23069	6	"	"	''
18637	23069	7	*	*	NFP
18637	23069	8	*	*	NFP
18637	23069	9	*	*	NFP
18637	23069	10	to	to	IN
18637	23069	11	any	any	DT
18637	23069	12	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	23069	13	to	to	TO
18637	23069	14	whom	whom	WP
18637	23069	15	allotment	allotment	NN
18637	23069	16	of	of	IN
18637	23069	17	land	land	NN
18637	23069	18	has	have	VBZ
18637	23069	19	been	be	VBN
18637	23069	20	made	make	VBN
18637	23069	21	while	while	IN
18637	23069	22	the	the	DT
18637	23069	23	title	title	NN
18637	23069	24	to	to	IN
18637	23069	25	the	the	DT
18637	23069	26	same	same	JJ
18637	23069	27	shall	shall	MD
18637	23069	28	be	be	VB
18637	23069	29	held	hold	VBN
18637	23069	30	in	in	IN
18637	23069	31	trust	trust	NN
18637	23069	32	by	by	IN
18637	23069	33	the	the	DT
18637	23069	34	Government	Government	NNP
18637	23069	35	*	*	NFP
18637	23069	36	*	*	NFP
18637	23069	37	*	*	NFP
18637	23069	38	,	,	,
18637	23069	39	"	"	''
18637	23069	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23069	41	held	hold	VBD
18637	23069	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23069	43	a	a	DT
18637	23069	44	police	police	NN
18637	23069	45	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	23069	46	infringing	infringe	VBG
18637	23069	47	State	State	NNP
18637	23069	48	powers	power	NNS
18637	23069	49	,	,	,
18637	23069	50	and	and	CC
18637	23069	51	not	not	RB
18637	23069	52	warranted	warrant	VBN
18637	23069	53	by	by	IN
18637	23069	54	the	the	DT
18637	23069	55	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	23069	56	clause	clause	NNP
18637	23069	57	,	,	,
18637	23069	58	article	article	NN
18637	23069	59	I	i	NN
18637	23069	60	,	,	,
18637	23069	61	section	section	NN
18637	23069	62	8	8	CD
18637	23069	63	,	,	,
18637	23069	64	clause	clause	NN
18637	23069	65	3	3	CD
18637	23069	66	.	.	.
18637	23070	1	Matter	Matter	NNP
18637	23070	2	of	of	IN
18637	23070	3	Heff	Heff	NNP
18637	23070	4	,	,	,
18637	23070	5	197	197	CD
18637	23070	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23070	7	488	488	CD
18637	23070	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23070	9	April	April	NNP
18637	23070	10	10	10	CD
18637	23070	11	,	,	,
18637	23070	12	1905	1905	CD
18637	23070	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23070	14	overruled	overrule	VBD
18637	23070	15	in	in	IN
18637	23070	16	United	United	NNP
18637	23070	17	States	States	NNP
18637	23070	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23070	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23070	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23070	21	Nice	Nice	NNP
18637	23070	22	,	,	,
18637	23070	23	241	241	CD
18637	23070	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23070	25	591	591	CD
18637	23070	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23070	27	1916	1916	CD
18637	23070	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23070	29	.	.	.
18637	23071	1	30	30	CD
18637	23071	2	.	.	.
18637	23072	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23072	2	of	of	IN
18637	23072	3	June	June	NNP
18637	23072	4	1	1	CD
18637	23072	5	,	,	,
18637	23072	6	1898	1898	CD
18637	23072	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23072	8	30	30	CD
18637	23072	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23072	10	.	.	.
18637	23073	1	428	428	CD
18637	23073	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23073	3	.	.	.
18637	23074	1	Section	section	NN
18637	23074	2	10	10	CD
18637	23074	3	,	,	,
18637	23074	4	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	23074	5	"	"	``
18637	23074	6	any	any	DT
18637	23074	7	employer	employer	NN
18637	23074	8	subject	subject	JJ
18637	23074	9	to	to	IN
18637	23074	10	the	the	DT
18637	23074	11	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	23074	12	of	of	IN
18637	23074	13	this	this	DT
18637	23074	14	act	act	NN
18637	23074	15	"	"	''
18637	23074	16	who	who	WP
18637	23074	17	should	should	MD
18637	23074	18	"	"	``
18637	23074	19	threaten	threaten	VB
18637	23074	20	any	any	DT
18637	23074	21	employee	employee	NN
18637	23074	22	with	with	IN
18637	23074	23	loss	loss	NN
18637	23074	24	of	of	IN
18637	23074	25	employment	employment	NN
18637	23074	26	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	27	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	28	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	29	because	because	IN
18637	23074	30	of	of	IN
18637	23074	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23074	32	membership	membership	NN
18637	23074	33	in	in	IN
18637	23074	34	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	35	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	36	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	37	a	a	DT
18637	23074	38	labor	labor	NNP
18637	23074	39	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	23074	40	,	,	,
18637	23074	41	association	association	NNP
18637	23074	42	,	,	,
18637	23074	43	or	or	CC
18637	23074	44	organization	organization	NN
18637	23074	45	"	"	''
18637	23074	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23074	47	the	the	DT
18637	23074	48	act	act	NN
18637	23074	49	being	be	VBG
18637	23074	50	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	23074	51	"	"	''
18637	23074	52	to	to	IN
18637	23074	53	any	any	DT
18637	23074	54	common	common	JJ
18637	23074	55	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	23074	56	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	57	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	58	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	59	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	23074	60	in	in	IN
18637	23074	61	the	the	DT
18637	23074	62	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	23074	63	of	of	IN
18637	23074	64	passengers	passenger	NNS
18637	23074	65	,	,	,
18637	23074	66	or	or	CC
18637	23074	67	property	property	NN
18637	23074	68	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	69	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	70	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	71	from	from	IN
18637	23074	72	one	one	CD
18637	23074	73	State	state	NN
18637	23074	74	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	75	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	76	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	77	to	to	IN
18637	23074	78	another	another	DT
18637	23074	79	State	state	NN
18637	23074	80	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	81	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	82	*	*	NFP
18637	23074	83	,	,	,
18637	23074	84	"	"	``
18637	23074	85	etc	etc	FW
18637	23074	86	.	.	.
18637	23075	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23075	2	,	,	,
18637	23075	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23075	4	held	hold	VBD
18637	23075	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23075	6	an	an	DT
18637	23075	7	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	23075	8	of	of	IN
18637	23075	9	the	the	DT
18637	23075	10	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	23075	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23075	12	,	,	,
18637	23075	13	not	not	RB
18637	23075	14	supported	support	VBN
18637	23075	15	by	by	IN
18637	23075	16	the	the	DT
18637	23075	17	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	23075	18	clause	clause	NN
18637	23075	19	.	.	.
18637	23076	1	Adair	Adair	NNP
18637	23076	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23076	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23076	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23076	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23076	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23076	7	,	,	,
18637	23076	8	208	208	CD
18637	23076	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23076	10	161	161	CD
18637	23076	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23076	12	January	January	NNP
18637	23076	13	27	27	CD
18637	23076	14	,	,	,
18637	23076	15	1908	1908	CD
18637	23076	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23076	17	.	.	.
18637	23077	1	31	31	CD
18637	23077	2	.	.	.
18637	23078	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23078	2	of	of	IN
18637	23078	3	June	June	NNP
18637	23078	4	13	13	CD
18637	23078	5	,	,	,
18637	23078	6	1898	1898	CD
18637	23078	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23078	8	30	30	CD
18637	23078	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23078	10	.	.	.
18637	23079	1	451	451	CD
18637	23079	2	,	,	,
18637	23079	3	459	459	CD
18637	23079	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23079	5	.	.	.
18637	23080	1	Stamp	Stamp	NNP
18637	23080	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	23080	3	on	on	IN
18637	23080	4	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	23080	5	bills	bill	NNS
18637	23080	6	of	of	IN
18637	23080	7	lading	lading	NN
18637	23080	8	,	,	,
18637	23080	9	_	_	NNP
18637	23080	10	held	hold	VBD
18637	23080	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23080	12	a	a	DT
18637	23080	13	tax	tax	NN
18637	23080	14	on	on	IN
18637	23080	15	exports	export	NNS
18637	23080	16	in	in	IN
18637	23080	17	violation	violation	NN
18637	23080	18	of	of	IN
18637	23080	19	article	article	NN
18637	23080	20	I	i	NN
18637	23080	21	,	,	,
18637	23080	22	section	section	NN
18637	23080	23	9	9	CD
18637	23080	24	.	.	.
18637	23081	1	Fairbank	Fairbank	NNP
18637	23081	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23081	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23081	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23081	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23081	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23081	7	,	,	,
18637	23081	8	181	181	CD
18637	23081	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23081	10	283	283	CD
18637	23081	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23081	12	April	April	NNP
18637	23081	13	15	15	CD
18637	23081	14	,	,	,
18637	23081	15	1901	1901	CD
18637	23081	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23081	17	.	.	.
18637	23082	1	32	32	CD
18637	23082	2	.	.	.
18637	23083	1	Same	same	JJ
18637	23083	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23083	3	30	30	CD
18637	23083	4	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23083	5	.	.	.
18637	23084	1	451	451	CD
18637	23084	2	,	,	,
18637	23084	3	460	460	CD
18637	23084	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23084	5	.	.	.
18637	23085	1	Tax	tax	NN
18637	23085	2	on	on	IN
18637	23085	3	charter	charter	NN
18637	23085	4	parties	party	NNS
18637	23085	5	,	,	,
18637	23085	6	as	as	IN
18637	23085	7	applied	apply	VBN
18637	23085	8	to	to	IN
18637	23085	9	shipments	shipment	NNS
18637	23085	10	exclusively	exclusively	RB
18637	23085	11	from	from	IN
18637	23085	12	ports	port	NNS
18637	23085	13	in	in	IN
18637	23085	14	United	United	NNP
18637	23085	15	States	States	NNP
18637	23085	16	to	to	IN
18637	23085	17	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	23085	18	ports	port	NNS
18637	23085	19	,	,	,
18637	23085	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23085	21	held	hold	VBD
18637	23085	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23085	23	a	a	DT
18637	23085	24	tax	tax	NN
18637	23085	25	on	on	IN
18637	23085	26	exports	export	NNS
18637	23085	27	in	in	IN
18637	23085	28	violation	violation	NN
18637	23085	29	of	of	IN
18637	23085	30	article	article	NN
18637	23085	31	I	i	NN
18637	23085	32	,	,	,
18637	23085	33	section	section	NN
18637	23085	34	9	9	CD
18637	23085	35	.	.	.
18637	23086	1	United	United	NNP
18637	23086	2	States	States	NNP
18637	23086	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23086	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23086	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23086	6	Hvoslef	Hvoslef	NNP
18637	23086	7	,	,	,
18637	23086	8	237	237	CD
18637	23086	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23086	10	1	1	CD
18637	23086	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23086	12	March	March	NNP
18637	23086	13	22	22	CD
18637	23086	14	,	,	,
18637	23086	15	1915	1915	CD
18637	23086	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23086	17	.	.	.
18637	23087	1	33	33	CD
18637	23087	2	.	.	.
18637	23088	1	Same	same	JJ
18637	23088	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23088	3	30	30	CD
18637	23088	4	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23088	5	.	.	.
18637	23089	1	451	451	CD
18637	23089	2	,	,	,
18637	23089	3	461	461	CD
18637	23089	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23089	5	.	.	.
18637	23090	1	Tax	tax	NN
18637	23090	2	on	on	IN
18637	23090	3	policies	policy	NNS
18637	23090	4	of	of	IN
18637	23090	5	marine	marine	JJ
18637	23090	6	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	23090	7	,	,	,
18637	23090	8	as	as	IN
18637	23090	9	applied	apply	VBN
18637	23090	10	to	to	IN
18637	23090	11	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	23090	12	during	during	IN
18637	23090	13	voyage	voyage	NN
18637	23090	14	to	to	IN
18637	23090	15	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	23090	16	ports	port	NNS
18637	23090	17	,	,	,
18637	23090	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23090	19	held	hold	VBD
18637	23090	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23090	21	a	a	DT
18637	23090	22	tax	tax	NN
18637	23090	23	on	on	IN
18637	23090	24	exports	export	NNS
18637	23090	25	in	in	IN
18637	23090	26	violation	violation	NN
18637	23090	27	of	of	IN
18637	23090	28	article	article	NN
18637	23090	29	I	i	NN
18637	23090	30	,	,	,
18637	23090	31	section	section	NN
18637	23090	32	9	9	CD
18637	23090	33	.	.	.
18637	23091	1	Thames	Thames	NNP
18637	23091	2	and	and	CC
18637	23091	3	Mersey	Mersey	NNP
18637	23091	4	Marine	Marine	NNP
18637	23091	5	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	23091	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23091	7	_	_	NNP
18637	23091	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	23091	9	_	_	NNP
18637	23091	10	United	United	NNP
18637	23091	11	States	States	NNP
18637	23091	12	,	,	,
18637	23091	13	237	237	CD
18637	23091	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23091	15	19	19	CD
18637	23091	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23091	17	April	April	NNP
18637	23091	18	5	5	CD
18637	23091	19	,	,	,
18637	23091	20	1915	1915	CD
18637	23091	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23091	22	.	.	.
18637	23092	1	34	34	CD
18637	23092	2	.	.	.
18637	23093	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23093	2	of	of	IN
18637	23093	3	June	June	NNP
18637	23093	4	6	6	CD
18637	23093	5	,	,	,
18637	23093	6	1900	1900	CD
18637	23093	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23093	8	31	31	CD
18637	23093	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23093	10	.	.	.
18637	23094	1	359	359	CD
18637	23094	2	,	,	,
18637	23094	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23094	4	.	.	.
18637	23095	1	171	171	LS
18637	23095	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23095	3	.	.	.
18637	23096	1	Section	section	NN
18637	23096	2	of	of	IN
18637	23096	3	the	the	DT
18637	23096	4	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	23096	5	Code	Code	NNP
18637	23096	6	providing	provide	VBG
18637	23096	7	for	for	IN
18637	23096	8	a	a	DT
18637	23096	9	six	six	CD
18637	23096	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	23096	11	person	person	NN
18637	23096	12	jury	jury	NN
18637	23096	13	in	in	IN
18637	23096	14	trials	trial	NNS
18637	23096	15	for	for	IN
18637	23096	16	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
18637	23096	17	,	,	,
18637	23096	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23096	19	held	hold	VBD
18637	23096	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23096	21	repugnant	repugnant	NN
18637	23096	22	to	to	IN
18637	23096	23	the	the	DT
18637	23096	24	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	23096	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23096	26	,	,	,
18637	23096	27	requiring	require	VBG
18637	23096	28	"	"	``
18637	23096	29	jury	jury	NN
18637	23096	30	"	"	''
18637	23096	31	trial	trial	NN
18637	23096	32	of	of	IN
18637	23096	33	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	23096	34	.	.	.
18637	23097	1	Rassmussen	Rassmussen	NNP
18637	23097	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23097	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23097	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23097	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23097	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23097	7	,	,	,
18637	23097	8	197	197	CD
18637	23097	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23097	10	516	516	CD
18637	23097	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23097	12	April	April	NNP
18637	23097	13	10	10	CD
18637	23097	14	,	,	,
18637	23097	15	1905	1905	CD
18637	23097	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23097	17	.	.	.
18637	23098	1	35	35	CD
18637	23098	2	.	.	.
18637	23099	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23099	2	of	of	IN
18637	23099	3	March	March	NNP
18637	23099	4	3	3	CD
18637	23099	5	,	,	,
18637	23099	6	1901	1901	CD
18637	23099	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23099	8	31	31	CD
18637	23099	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23099	10	.	.	.
18637	23100	1	1341	1341	CD
18637	23100	2	,	,	,
18637	23100	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23100	4	.	.	.
18637	23101	1	935	935	CD
18637	23101	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23101	3	.	.	.
18637	23102	1	Section	section	NN
18637	23102	2	of	of	IN
18637	23102	3	the	the	DT
18637	23102	4	District	District	NNP
18637	23102	5	of	of	IN
18637	23102	6	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23102	7	Code	Code	NNP
18637	23102	8	granting	grant	VBG
18637	23102	9	the	the	DT
18637	23102	10	same	same	JJ
18637	23102	11	right	right	NN
18637	23102	12	of	of	IN
18637	23102	13	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	23102	14	,	,	,
18637	23102	15	in	in	IN
18637	23102	16	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	23102	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	23102	18	,	,	,
18637	23102	19	to	to	IN
18637	23102	20	the	the	DT
18637	23102	21	United	United	NNP
18637	23102	22	States	States	NNP
18637	23102	23	or	or	CC
18637	23102	24	the	the	DT
18637	23102	25	District	District	NNP
18637	23102	26	of	of	IN
18637	23102	27	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23102	28	as	as	IN
18637	23102	29	to	to	IN
18637	23102	30	the	the	DT
18637	23102	31	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	23102	32	,	,	,
18637	23102	33	but	but	CC
18637	23102	34	providing	provide	VBG
18637	23102	35	that	that	IN
18637	23102	36	a	a	DT
18637	23102	37	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	23102	38	was	be	VBD
18637	23102	39	not	not	RB
18637	23102	40	to	to	TO
18637	23102	41	be	be	VB
18637	23102	42	set	set	VBN
18637	23102	43	aside	aside	RB
18637	23102	44	for	for	IN
18637	23102	45	error	error	NN
18637	23102	46	found	find	VBN
18637	23102	47	in	in	IN
18637	23102	48	rulings	ruling	NNS
18637	23102	49	during	during	IN
18637	23102	50	trial	trial	NN
18637	23102	51	,	,	,
18637	23102	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23102	53	held	hold	VBD
18637	23102	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23102	55	an	an	DT
18637	23102	56	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	23102	57	to	to	TO
18637	23102	58	take	take	VB
18637	23102	59	an	an	DT
18637	23102	60	advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	23102	61	opinion	opinion	NN
18637	23102	62	,	,	,
18637	23102	63	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	23102	64	to	to	IN
18637	23102	65	article	article	NN
18637	23102	66	III	III	NNP
18637	23102	67	,	,	,
18637	23102	68	section	section	NN
18637	23102	69	2	2	CD
18637	23102	70	.	.	.
18637	23103	1	United	United	NNP
18637	23103	2	States	States	NNP
18637	23103	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23103	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23103	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23103	6	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	23103	7	,	,	,
18637	23103	8	213	213	CD
18637	23103	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23103	10	297	297	CD
18637	23103	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23103	12	April	April	NNP
18637	23103	13	19	19	CD
18637	23103	14	,	,	,
18637	23103	15	1909	1909	CD
18637	23103	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23103	17	.	.	.
18637	23104	1	36	36	CD
18637	23104	2	.	.	.
18637	23105	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23105	2	of	of	IN
18637	23105	3	June	June	NNP
18637	23105	4	11	11	CD
18637	23105	5	,	,	,
18637	23105	6	1906	1906	CD
18637	23105	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23105	8	34	34	CD
18637	23105	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23105	10	.	.	.
18637	23106	1	232	232	CD
18637	23106	2	,	,	,
18637	23106	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23106	4	.	.	.
18637	23107	1	3073	3073	CD
18637	23107	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23107	3	.	.	.
18637	23108	1	Act	act	NN
18637	23108	2	providing	provide	VBG
18637	23108	3	that	that	IN
18637	23108	4	"	"	``
18637	23108	5	every	every	DT
18637	23108	6	common	common	JJ
18637	23108	7	carrier	carrier	NN
18637	23108	8	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	23108	9	in	in	IN
18637	23108	10	trade	trade	NN
18637	23108	11	or	or	CC
18637	23108	12	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	23108	13	in	in	IN
18637	23108	14	the	the	DT
18637	23108	15	District	District	NNP
18637	23108	16	of	of	IN
18637	23108	17	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23108	18	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	19	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	20	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	21	or	or	CC
18637	23108	22	between	between	IN
18637	23108	23	the	the	DT
18637	23108	24	several	several	JJ
18637	23108	25	States	state	NNS
18637	23108	26	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	27	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	28	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	29	shall	shall	MD
18637	23108	30	be	be	VB
18637	23108	31	liable	liable	JJ
18637	23108	32	to	to	IN
18637	23108	33	any	any	DT
18637	23108	34	of	of	IN
18637	23108	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23108	36	employees	employee	NNS
18637	23108	37	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	38	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	39	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	40	for	for	IN
18637	23108	41	all	all	DT
18637	23108	42	damages	damage	NNS
18637	23108	43	which	which	WDT
18637	23108	44	may	may	MD
18637	23108	45	result	result	VB
18637	23108	46	from	from	IN
18637	23108	47	the	the	DT
18637	23108	48	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	23108	49	of	of	IN
18637	23108	50	any	any	DT
18637	23108	51	of	of	IN
18637	23108	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23108	53	officers	officer	NNS
18637	23108	54	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	55	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	56	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	57	or	or	CC
18637	23108	58	by	by	IN
18637	23108	59	reason	reason	NN
18637	23108	60	of	of	IN
18637	23108	61	any	any	DT
18637	23108	62	defect	defect	NN
18637	23108	63	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	64	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	65	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	66	due	due	IN
18637	23108	67	to	to	IN
18637	23108	68	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23108	69	negligence	negligence	NN
18637	23108	70	in	in	IN
18637	23108	71	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23108	72	cars	car	NNS
18637	23108	73	,	,	,
18637	23108	74	engines	engine	NNS
18637	23108	75	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	76	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	77	*	*	NFP
18637	23108	78	roadbed	roadbed	NN
18637	23108	79	"	"	''
18637	23108	80	,	,	,
18637	23108	81	etc	etc	FW
18637	23108	82	.	.	FW
18637	23108	83	,	,	,
18637	23108	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23108	85	held	hold	VBD
18637	23108	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23108	87	not	not	RB
18637	23108	88	supportable	supportable	JJ
18637	23108	89	under	under	IN
18637	23108	90	article	article	NN
18637	23108	91	I	i	NN
18637	23108	92	,	,	,
18637	23108	93	section	section	NN
18637	23108	94	8	8	CD
18637	23108	95	,	,	,
18637	23108	96	clause	clause	NN
18637	23108	97	3	3	CD
18637	23108	98	as	as	IN
18637	23108	99	applied	apply	VBN
18637	23108	100	to	to	IN
18637	23108	101	employees	employee	NNS
18637	23108	102	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	23108	103	in	in	IN
18637	23108	104	moving	move	VBG
18637	23108	105	trains	train	NNS
18637	23108	106	in	in	IN
18637	23108	107	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	23108	108	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	23108	109	.	.	.
18637	23109	1	Employers	employer	NNS
18637	23109	2	'	'	POS
18637	23109	3	Liability	liability	NN
18637	23109	4	Cases	case	NNS
18637	23109	5	,	,	,
18637	23109	6	207	207	CD
18637	23109	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23109	8	463	463	CD
18637	23109	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23109	10	January	January	NNP
18637	23109	11	6	6	CD
18637	23109	12	,	,	,
18637	23109	13	1908	1908	CD
18637	23109	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23109	15	.	.	.
18637	23110	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	23110	2	The	the	DT
18637	23110	3	act	act	NN
18637	23110	4	was	be	VBD
18637	23110	5	upheld	uphold	VBN
18637	23110	6	as	as	IN
18637	23110	7	to	to	IN
18637	23110	8	the	the	DT
18637	23110	9	District	District	NNP
18637	23110	10	of	of	IN
18637	23110	11	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23110	12	in	in	IN
18637	23110	13	Hyde	Hyde	NNP
18637	23110	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23110	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23110	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23110	17	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	23110	18	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23110	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23110	20	,	,	,
18637	23110	21	31	31	CD
18637	23110	22	App	App	NNP
18637	23110	23	.	.	.
18637	23111	1	D.C.	D.C.	NNP
18637	23111	2	466	466	CD
18637	23111	3	[	[	-LRB-
18637	23111	4	1908	1908	CD
18637	23111	5	]	]	-RRB-
18637	23111	6	;	;	:
18637	23111	7	and	and	CC
18637	23111	8	as	as	IN
18637	23111	9	to	to	IN
18637	23111	10	Territories	Territories	NNPS
18637	23111	11	,	,	,
18637	23111	12	in	in	IN
18637	23111	13	El	El	NNP
18637	23111	14	Paso	Paso	NNP
18637	23111	15	and	and	CC
18637	23111	16	Northeastern	Northeastern	NNP
18637	23111	17	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23111	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23111	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23111	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	23111	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23111	22	Gutierrez	Gutierrez	NNP
18637	23111	23	,	,	,
18637	23111	24	215	215	CD
18637	23111	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23111	26	87	87	CD
18637	23111	27	[	[	-LRB-
18637	23111	28	1909	1909	CD
18637	23111	29	]	]	-RRB-
18637	23111	30	.	.	.
18637	23111	31	]	]	-RRB-
18637	23112	1	37	37	CD
18637	23112	2	.	.	.
18637	23113	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23113	2	of	of	IN
18637	23113	3	June	June	NNP
18637	23113	4	16	16	CD
18637	23113	5	,	,	,
18637	23113	6	1906	1906	CD
18637	23113	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23113	8	34	34	CD
18637	23113	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23113	10	.	.	.
18637	23114	1	269	269	CD
18637	23114	2	,	,	,
18637	23114	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23114	4	.	.	.
18637	23115	1	2	2	LS
18637	23115	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23115	3	.	.	.
18637	23116	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	23116	2	of	of	IN
18637	23116	3	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	23116	4	Enabling	Enabling	NNP
18637	23116	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23116	6	restricting	restrict	VBG
18637	23116	7	relocation	relocation	NN
18637	23116	8	of	of	IN
18637	23116	9	the	the	DT
18637	23116	10	State	State	NNP
18637	23116	11	capital	capital	NN
18637	23116	12	prior	prior	RB
18637	23116	13	to	to	IN
18637	23116	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	23116	15	,	,	,
18637	23116	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23116	17	held	hold	VBD
18637	23116	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23116	19	not	not	RB
18637	23116	20	supportable	supportable	JJ
18637	23116	21	by	by	IN
18637	23116	22	article	article	NN
18637	23116	23	IV	IV	NNP
18637	23116	24	,	,	,
18637	23116	25	section	section	NN
18637	23116	26	3	3	CD
18637	23116	27	,	,	,
18637	23116	28	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	23116	29	admission	admission	NN
18637	23116	30	of	of	IN
18637	23116	31	new	new	JJ
18637	23116	32	States	States	NNPS
18637	23116	33	.	.	.
18637	23117	1	Coyle	coyle	VB
18637	23117	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23117	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23117	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23117	5	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	23117	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23117	7	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	23117	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23117	9	,	,	,
18637	23117	10	221	221	CD
18637	23117	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23117	12	559	559	CD
18637	23117	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23117	14	May	May	NNP
18637	23117	15	29	29	CD
18637	23117	16	,	,	,
18637	23117	17	1911	1911	CD
18637	23117	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23117	19	.	.	.
18637	23118	1	38	38	CD
18637	23118	2	.	.	.
18637	23119	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23119	2	of	of	IN
18637	23119	3	February	February	NNP
18637	23119	4	20	20	CD
18637	23119	5	,	,	,
18637	23119	6	1907	1907	CD
18637	23119	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23119	8	34	34	CD
18637	23119	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23119	10	.	.	.
18637	23120	1	899	899	CD
18637	23120	2	,	,	,
18637	23120	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23120	4	.	.	.
18637	23121	1	3	3	LS
18637	23121	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23121	3	.	.	.
18637	23122	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	23122	2	in	in	IN
18637	23122	3	the	the	DT
18637	23122	4	Immigration	Immigration	NNP
18637	23122	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23122	6	of	of	IN
18637	23122	7	1907	1907	CD
18637	23122	8	penalizing	penalize	VBG
18637	23122	9	"	"	''
18637	23122	10	whoever	whoever	WP
18637	23122	11	*	*	NFP
18637	23122	12	*	*	NFP
18637	23122	13	*	*	NFP
18637	23122	14	shall	shall	MD
18637	23122	15	keep	keep	VB
18637	23122	16	,	,	,
18637	23122	17	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	23122	18	,	,	,
18637	23122	19	control	control	NN
18637	23122	20	,	,	,
18637	23122	21	support	support	NN
18637	23122	22	,	,	,
18637	23122	23	or	or	CC
18637	23122	24	harbor	harbor	VB
18637	23122	25	in	in	IN
18637	23122	26	any	any	DT
18637	23122	27	house	house	NN
18637	23122	28	or	or	CC
18637	23122	29	other	other	JJ
18637	23122	30	place	place	NN
18637	23122	31	,	,	,
18637	23122	32	for	for	IN
18637	23122	33	the	the	DT
18637	23122	34	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	23122	35	of	of	IN
18637	23122	36	prostitution	prostitution	NN
18637	23122	37	*	*	NFP
18637	23122	38	*	*	NFP
18637	23122	39	*	*	NFP
18637	23122	40	any	any	DT
18637	23122	41	alien	alien	JJ
18637	23122	42	woman	woman	NN
18637	23122	43	or	or	CC
18637	23122	44	girl	girl	NN
18637	23122	45	,	,	,
18637	23122	46	within	within	IN
18637	23122	47	3	3	CD
18637	23122	48	years	year	NNS
18637	23122	49	after	after	IN
18637	23122	50	she	-PRON-	PRP
18637	23122	51	shall	shall	MD
18637	23122	52	have	have	VB
18637	23122	53	entered	enter	VBN
18637	23122	54	the	the	DT
18637	23122	55	United	United	NNP
18637	23122	56	States	States	NNP
18637	23122	57	,	,	,
18637	23122	58	"	"	''
18637	23122	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23122	60	held	hold	VBD
18637	23122	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23122	62	an	an	DT
18637	23122	63	exercise	exercise	NN
18637	23122	64	of	of	IN
18637	23122	65	police	police	NN
18637	23122	66	power	power	NN
18637	23122	67	not	not	RB
18637	23122	68	within	within	IN
18637	23122	69	the	the	DT
18637	23122	70	control	control	NN
18637	23122	71	of	of	IN
18637	23122	72	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	23122	73	over	over	IN
18637	23122	74	immigration	immigration	NN
18637	23122	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23122	76	whether	whether	IN
18637	23122	77	drawn	draw	VBN
18637	23122	78	from	from	IN
18637	23122	79	the	the	DT
18637	23122	80	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	23122	81	clause	clause	NNP
18637	23122	82	or	or	CC
18637	23122	83	based	base	VBN
18637	23122	84	on	on	IN
18637	23122	85	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	23122	86	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	23122	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23122	88	.	.	.
18637	23123	1	Keller	Keller	NNP
18637	23123	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23123	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23123	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23123	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23123	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23123	7	,	,	,
18637	23123	8	213	213	CD
18637	23123	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23123	10	138	138	CD
18637	23123	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23123	12	April	April	NNP
18637	23123	13	5	5	CD
18637	23123	14	,	,	,
18637	23123	15	1909	1909	CD
18637	23123	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23123	17	.	.	.
18637	23124	1	39	39	CD
18637	23124	2	.	.	.
18637	23125	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23125	2	of	of	IN
18637	23125	3	March	March	NNP
18637	23125	4	1	1	CD
18637	23125	5	,	,	,
18637	23125	6	1907	1907	CD
18637	23125	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23125	8	34	34	CD
18637	23125	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23125	10	.	.	.
18637	23126	1	1028	1028	CD
18637	23126	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23126	3	.	.	.
18637	23127	1	Provisions	provision	NNS
18637	23127	2	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	23127	3	certain	certain	JJ
18637	23127	4	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	23127	5	"	"	''
18637	23127	6	to	to	TO
18637	23127	7	institute	institute	VB
18637	23127	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23127	9	suits	suit	NNS
18637	23127	10	in	in	IN
18637	23127	11	the	the	DT
18637	23127	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	23127	13	of	of	IN
18637	23127	14	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	23127	15	to	to	TO
18637	23127	16	determine	determine	VB
18637	23127	17	the	the	DT
18637	23127	18	validity	validity	NN
18637	23127	19	of	of	IN
18637	23127	20	any	any	DT
18637	23127	21	acts	act	NNS
18637	23127	22	of	of	IN
18637	23127	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	23127	24	passed	pass	VBD
18637	23127	25	since	since	IN
18637	23127	26	*	*	NFP
18637	23127	27	*	*	NFP
18637	23127	28	*	*	NFP
18637	23127	29	1902	1902	CD
18637	23127	30	,	,	,
18637	23127	31	insofar	insofar	RB
18637	23127	32	as	as	IN
18637	23127	33	said	say	VBD
18637	23127	34	acts	act	NNS
18637	23127	35	*	*	NFP
18637	23127	36	*	*	NFP
18637	23127	37	*	*	NFP
18637	23127	38	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	23127	39	to	to	TO
18637	23127	40	increase	increase	VB
18637	23127	41	or	or	CC
18637	23127	42	extend	extend	VB
18637	23127	43	the	the	DT
18637	23127	44	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	23127	45	upon	upon	IN
18637	23127	46	alienation	alienation	NN
18637	23127	47	*	*	NFP
18637	23127	48	*	*	NFP
18637	23127	49	*	*	NFP
18637	23127	50	of	of	IN
18637	23127	51	allotments	allotment	NNS
18637	23127	52	of	of	IN
18637	23127	53	lands	land	NNS
18637	23127	54	of	of	IN
18637	23127	55	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	23127	56	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	23127	57	*	*	NFP
18637	23127	58	*	*	NFP
18637	23127	59	*	*	NFP
18637	23127	60	,	,	,
18637	23127	61	"	"	''
18637	23127	62	and	and	CC
18637	23127	63	giving	give	VBG
18637	23127	64	a	a	DT
18637	23127	65	right	right	NN
18637	23127	66	of	of	IN
18637	23127	67	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	23127	68	to	to	IN
18637	23127	69	the	the	DT
18637	23127	70	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	23127	71	Court	Court	NNP
18637	23127	72	,	,	,
18637	23127	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23127	74	held	hold	VBD
18637	23127	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23127	76	an	an	DT
18637	23127	77	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	23127	78	to	to	TO
18637	23127	79	enlarge	enlarge	VB
18637	23127	80	the	the	DT
18637	23127	81	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	23127	82	power	power	NN
18637	23127	83	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	23127	84	by	by	IN
18637	23127	85	article	article	NN
18637	23127	86	III	III	NNP
18637	23127	87	,	,	,
18637	23127	88	section	section	NN
18637	23127	89	2	2	CD
18637	23127	90	,	,	,
18637	23127	91	to	to	IN
18637	23127	92	cases	case	NNS
18637	23127	93	and	and	CC
18637	23127	94	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	23127	95	.	.	.
18637	23128	1	Muskrat	Muskrat	NNP
18637	23128	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23128	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23128	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23128	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23128	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23128	7	and	and	CC
18637	23128	8	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23128	9	and	and	CC
18637	23128	10	Gritts	Gritts	NNP
18637	23128	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23128	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	23128	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23128	14	United	United	NNP
18637	23128	15	States	States	NNP
18637	23128	16	,	,	,
18637	23128	17	219	219	CD
18637	23128	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23128	19	346	346	CD
18637	23128	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23128	21	January	January	NNP
18637	23128	22	23	23	CD
18637	23128	23	,	,	,
18637	23128	24	1911	1911	CD
18637	23128	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23128	26	.	.	.
18637	23129	1	40	40	CD
18637	23129	2	.	.	.
18637	23130	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23130	2	of	of	IN
18637	23130	3	May	May	NNP
18637	23130	4	27	27	CD
18637	23130	5	,	,	,
18637	23130	6	1908	1908	CD
18637	23130	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23130	8	35	35	CD
18637	23130	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23130	10	.	.	.
18637	23131	1	313	313	CD
18637	23131	2	,	,	,
18637	23131	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23131	4	.	.	.
18637	23132	1	4	4	LS
18637	23132	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23132	3	.	.	.
18637	23133	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	23133	2	making	make	VBG
18637	23133	3	locally	locally	RB
18637	23133	4	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	23133	5	"	"	''
18637	23133	6	all	all	DT
18637	23133	7	land	land	NN
18637	23133	8	[	[	-LRB-
18637	23133	9	of	of	IN
18637	23133	10	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	23133	11	of	of	IN
18637	23133	12	the	the	DT
18637	23133	13	Five	five	CD
18637	23133	14	Civilized	Civilized	NNP
18637	23133	15	Tribes	Tribes	NNPS
18637	23133	16	]	]	-RRB-
18637	23133	17	from	from	IN
18637	23133	18	which	which	WDT
18637	23133	19	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	23133	20	have	have	VBP
18637	23133	21	been	be	VBN
18637	23133	22	or	or	CC
18637	23133	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	23133	24	be	be	VB
18637	23133	25	removed	remove	VBN
18637	23133	26	,	,	,
18637	23133	27	"	"	''
18637	23133	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23133	29	held	hold	VBD
18637	23133	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23133	31	a	a	DT
18637	23133	32	violation	violation	NN
18637	23133	33	of	of	IN
18637	23133	34	the	the	DT
18637	23133	35	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	23133	36	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23133	37	,	,	,
18637	23133	38	in	in	IN
18637	23133	39	view	view	NN
18637	23133	40	of	of	IN
18637	23133	41	the	the	DT
18637	23133	42	Atoka	Atoka	NNP
18637	23133	43	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	23133	44	,	,	,
18637	23133	45	embodied	embody	VBN
18637	23133	46	in	in	IN
18637	23133	47	the	the	DT
18637	23133	48	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	23133	49	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23133	50	of	of	IN
18637	23133	51	June	June	NNP
18637	23133	52	28	28	CD
18637	23133	53	,	,	,
18637	23133	54	1898	1898	CD
18637	23133	55	,	,	,
18637	23133	56	providing	provide	VBG
18637	23133	57	tax	tax	NN
18637	23133	58	-	-	HYPH
18637	23133	59	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	23133	60	for	for	IN
18637	23133	61	allotted	allotted	JJ
18637	23133	62	lands	land	NNS
18637	23133	63	while	while	IN
18637	23133	64	title	title	NN
18637	23133	65	in	in	IN
18637	23133	66	original	original	JJ
18637	23133	67	allottee	allottee	NN
18637	23133	68	,	,	,
18637	23133	69	not	not	RB
18637	23133	70	exceeding	exceed	VBG
18637	23133	71	21	21	CD
18637	23133	72	years	year	NNS
18637	23133	73	.	.	.
18637	23134	1	Choate	Choate	NNP
18637	23134	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23134	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23134	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23134	5	Trapp	Trapp	NNP
18637	23134	6	,	,	,
18637	23134	7	224	224	CD
18637	23134	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23134	9	665	665	CD
18637	23134	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23134	11	May	May	NNP
18637	23134	12	13	13	CD
18637	23134	13	,	,	,
18637	23134	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	23134	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23134	16	.	.	.
18637	23135	1	41	41	CD
18637	23135	2	.	.	.
18637	23136	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23136	2	of	of	IN
18637	23136	3	August	August	NNP
18637	23136	4	19	19	CD
18637	23136	5	,	,	,
18637	23136	6	1911	1911	CD
18637	23136	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23136	8	37	37	CD
18637	23136	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23136	10	.	.	.
18637	23137	1	28	28	CD
18637	23137	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23137	3	.	.	.
18637	23138	1	A	a	DT
18637	23138	2	proviso	proviso	NN
18637	23138	3	in	in	IN
18637	23138	4	section	section	NN
18637	23138	5	8	8	CD
18637	23138	6	of	of	IN
18637	23138	7	the	the	DT
18637	23138	8	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23138	9	Corrupt	Corrupt	NNP
18637	23138	10	Practices	Practices	NNPS
18637	23138	11	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23138	12	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	23138	13	a	a	DT
18637	23138	14	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	23138	15	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	23138	16	expenditure	expenditure	NN
18637	23138	17	by	by	IN
18637	23138	18	a	a	DT
18637	23138	19	candidate	candidate	NN
18637	23138	20	for	for	IN
18637	23138	21	Senator	Senator	NNP
18637	23138	22	"	"	''
18637	23138	23	in	in	IN
18637	23138	24	any	any	DT
18637	23138	25	campaign	campaign	NN
18637	23138	26	for	for	IN
18637	23138	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23138	28	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	23138	29	and	and	CC
18637	23138	30	election	election	NN
18637	23138	31	,	,	,
18637	23138	32	"	"	''
18637	23138	33	as	as	IN
18637	23138	34	applied	apply	VBN
18637	23138	35	to	to	IN
18637	23138	36	a	a	DT
18637	23138	37	primary	primary	JJ
18637	23138	38	election	election	NN
18637	23138	39	,	,	,
18637	23138	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23138	41	held	hold	VBD
18637	23138	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23138	43	not	not	RB
18637	23138	44	supported	support	VBN
18637	23138	45	by	by	IN
18637	23138	46	article	article	NN
18637	23138	47	I	i	NN
18637	23138	48	,	,	,
18637	23138	49	section	section	NN
18637	23138	50	4	4	CD
18637	23138	51	,	,	,
18637	23138	52	giving	give	VBG
18637	23138	53	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	23138	54	power	power	NN
18637	23138	55	to	to	TO
18637	23138	56	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	23138	57	the	the	DT
18637	23138	58	manner	manner	NN
18637	23138	59	of	of	IN
18637	23138	60	holding	hold	VBG
18637	23138	61	elections	election	NNS
18637	23138	62	for	for	IN
18637	23138	63	Senators	Senators	NNPS
18637	23138	64	and	and	CC
18637	23138	65	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	23138	66	.	.	.
18637	23139	1	Newberry	Newberry	NNP
18637	23139	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23139	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23139	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23139	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23139	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23139	7	,	,	,
18637	23139	8	256	256	CD
18637	23139	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23139	10	232	232	CD
18637	23139	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23139	12	May	May	NNP
18637	23139	13	2	2	CD
18637	23139	14	,	,	,
18637	23139	15	1921	1921	CD
18637	23139	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23139	17	.	.	.
18637	23140	1	42	42	CD
18637	23140	2	.	.	.
18637	23141	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23141	2	of	of	IN
18637	23141	3	June	June	NNP
18637	23141	4	18	18	CD
18637	23141	5	,	,	,
18637	23141	6	1912	1912	CD
18637	23141	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23141	8	37	37	CD
18637	23141	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23141	10	.	.	.
18637	23142	1	136	136	CD
18637	23142	2	,	,	,
18637	23142	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23142	4	.	.	.
18637	23143	1	8)	8)	CD
18637	23143	2	.	.	.
18637	23144	1	Part	part	NN
18637	23144	2	of	of	IN
18637	23144	3	section	section	NN
18637	23144	4	8	8	CD
18637	23144	5	giving	give	VBG
18637	23144	6	the	the	DT
18637	23144	7	Juvenile	Juvenile	NNP
18637	23144	8	Court	Court	NNP
18637	23144	9	of	of	IN
18637	23144	10	the	the	DT
18637	23144	11	District	District	NNP
18637	23144	12	of	of	IN
18637	23144	13	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23144	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23144	15	proceeding	proceed	VBG
18637	23144	16	upon	upon	IN
18637	23144	17	information	information	NN
18637	23144	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23144	19	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	23144	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	23144	21	of	of	IN
18637	23144	22	desertion	desertion	NN
18637	23144	23	cases	case	NNS
18637	23144	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23144	25	which	which	WDT
18637	23144	26	were	be	VBD
18637	23144	27	,	,	,
18637	23144	28	by	by	IN
18637	23144	29	law	law	NN
18637	23144	30	,	,	,
18637	23144	31	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
18637	23144	32	punishable	punishable	JJ
18637	23144	33	by	by	IN
18637	23144	34	fine	fine	JJ
18637	23144	35	or	or	CC
18637	23144	36	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
18637	23144	37	in	in	IN
18637	23144	38	the	the	DT
18637	23144	39	workhouse	workhouse	NN
18637	23144	40	at	at	IN
18637	23144	41	hard	hard	JJ
18637	23144	42	labor	labor	NN
18637	23144	43	for	for	IN
18637	23144	44	1	1	CD
18637	23144	45	year	year	NN
18637	23144	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23144	47	,	,	,
18637	23144	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23144	49	held	hold	VBD
18637	23144	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23144	51	invalid	invalid	NN
18637	23144	52	under	under	IN
18637	23144	53	the	the	DT
18637	23144	54	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	23144	55	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23144	56	,	,	,
18637	23144	57	which	which	WDT
18637	23144	58	gives	give	VBZ
18637	23144	59	right	right	NN
18637	23144	60	to	to	TO
18637	23144	61	presentment	presentment	VB
18637	23144	62	by	by	IN
18637	23144	63	a	a	DT
18637	23144	64	grand	grand	JJ
18637	23144	65	jury	jury	NN
18637	23144	66	in	in	IN
18637	23144	67	case	case	NN
18637	23144	68	of	of	IN
18637	23144	69	infamous	infamous	JJ
18637	23144	70	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	23144	71	.	.	.
18637	23145	1	United	United	NNP
18637	23145	2	States	States	NNP
18637	23145	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23145	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23145	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23145	6	Moreland	Moreland	NNP
18637	23145	7	,	,	,
18637	23145	8	258	258	CD
18637	23145	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23145	10	433	433	CD
18637	23145	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23145	12	April	April	NNP
18637	23145	13	17	17	CD
18637	23145	14	,	,	,
18637	23145	15	1922	1922	CD
18637	23145	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23145	17	.	.	.
18637	23146	1	43	43	CD
18637	23146	2	.	.	.
18637	23147	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23147	2	of	of	IN
18637	23147	3	March	March	NNP
18637	23147	4	4	4	CD
18637	23147	5	,	,	,
18637	23147	6	1913	1913	CD
18637	23147	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23147	8	37	37	CD
18637	23147	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23147	10	.	.	.
18637	23148	1	988	988	CD
18637	23148	2	,	,	,
18637	23148	3	part	part	NN
18637	23148	4	of	of	IN
18637	23148	5	par	par	NN
18637	23148	6	.	.	.
18637	23149	1	64	64	CD
18637	23149	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23149	3	.	.	.
18637	23150	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	23150	2	of	of	IN
18637	23150	3	the	the	DT
18637	23150	4	District	District	NNP
18637	23150	5	of	of	IN
18637	23150	6	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23150	7	Public	Public	NNP
18637	23150	8	Utility	Utility	NNP
18637	23150	9	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23150	10	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23150	11	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	23150	12	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	23150	13	to	to	IN
18637	23150	14	the	the	DT
18637	23150	15	United	United	NNP
18637	23150	16	States	States	NNP
18637	23150	17	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	23150	18	Court	Court	NNP
18637	23150	19	from	from	IN
18637	23150	20	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	23150	21	of	of	IN
18637	23150	22	the	the	DT
18637	23150	23	District	District	NNP
18637	23150	24	of	of	IN
18637	23150	25	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23150	26	Court	Court	NNP
18637	23150	27	of	of	IN
18637	23150	28	Appeals	Appeals	NNP
18637	23150	29	modifying	modify	VBG
18637	23150	30	valuation	valuation	NN
18637	23150	31	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	23150	32	of	of	IN
18637	23150	33	the	the	DT
18637	23150	34	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	23150	35	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23150	36	,	,	,
18637	23150	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23150	38	held	hold	VBD
18637	23150	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23150	40	an	an	DT
18637	23150	41	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	23150	42	to	to	TO
18637	23150	43	extend	extend	VB
18637	23150	44	the	the	DT
18637	23150	45	appellate	appellate	JJ
18637	23150	46	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	23150	47	of	of	IN
18637	23150	48	the	the	DT
18637	23150	49	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	23150	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	23150	51	to	to	IN
18637	23150	52	cases	case	NNS
18637	23150	53	not	not	RB
18637	23150	54	strictly	strictly	RB
18637	23150	55	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	23150	56	within	within	IN
18637	23150	57	the	the	DT
18637	23150	58	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	23150	59	of	of	IN
18637	23150	60	article	article	NN
18637	23150	61	III	III	NNP
18637	23150	62	,	,	,
18637	23150	63	section	section	NN
18637	23150	64	2	2	CD
18637	23150	65	.	.	.
18637	23151	1	Keller	Keller	NNP
18637	23151	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23151	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23151	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23151	5	Potomac	Potomac	NNP
18637	23151	6	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	23151	7	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23151	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23151	9	et	et	NNP
18637	23151	10	al	al	NNP
18637	23151	11	.	.	NNP
18637	23151	12	,	,	,
18637	23151	13	261	261	CD
18637	23151	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23151	15	428	428	CD
18637	23151	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23151	17	April	April	NNP
18637	23151	18	9	9	CD
18637	23151	19	,	,	,
18637	23151	20	1923	1923	CD
18637	23151	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23151	22	.	.	.
18637	23152	1	44	44	CD
18637	23152	2	.	.	.
18637	23153	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23153	2	of	of	IN
18637	23153	3	September	September	NNP
18637	23153	4	1	1	CD
18637	23153	5	,	,	,
18637	23153	6	1916	1916	CD
18637	23153	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23153	8	39	39	CD
18637	23153	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23153	10	.	.	.
18637	23154	1	675	675	CD
18637	23154	2	,	,	,
18637	23154	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23154	4	.	.	.
18637	23155	1	432	432	CD
18637	23155	2	,	,	,
18637	23155	3	entire	entire	JJ
18637	23155	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23155	5	.	.	.
18637	23156	1	The	the	DT
18637	23156	2	original	original	JJ
18637	23156	3	Child	Child	NNP
18637	23156	4	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	23156	5	Law	Law	NNP
18637	23156	6	,	,	,
18637	23156	7	providing	provide	VBG
18637	23156	8	"	"	``
18637	23156	9	that	that	IN
18637	23156	10	no	no	DT
18637	23156	11	producer	producer	NN
18637	23156	12	*	*	NFP
18637	23156	13	*	*	NFP
18637	23156	14	*	*	NFP
18637	23156	15	shall	shall	MD
18637	23156	16	ship	ship	NN
18637	23156	17	*	*	NFP
18637	23156	18	*	*	NFP
18637	23156	19	*	*	NFP
18637	23156	20	in	in	IN
18637	23156	21	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	23156	22	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	23156	23	*	*	NFP
18637	23156	24	*	*	NFP
18637	23156	25	*	*	NFP
18637	23156	26	any	any	DT
18637	23156	27	article	article	NN
18637	23156	28	or	or	CC
18637	23156	29	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	23156	30	the	the	DT
18637	23156	31	product	product	NN
18637	23156	32	of	of	IN
18637	23156	33	any	any	DT
18637	23156	34	mill	mill	NN
18637	23156	35	*	*	NFP
18637	23156	36	*	*	NFP
18637	23156	37	*	*	NFP
18637	23156	38	in	in	IN
18637	23156	39	which	which	WDT
18637	23156	40	within	within	IN
18637	23156	41	30	30	CD
18637	23156	42	days	day	NNS
18637	23156	43	prior	prior	RB
18637	23156	44	to	to	IN
18637	23156	45	the	the	DT
18637	23156	46	removal	removal	NN
18637	23156	47	of	of	IN
18637	23156	48	such	such	JJ
18637	23156	49	product	product	NN
18637	23156	50	therefrom	therefrom	JJ
18637	23156	51	children	child	NNS
18637	23156	52	under	under	IN
18637	23156	53	the	the	DT
18637	23156	54	age	age	NN
18637	23156	55	of	of	IN
18637	23156	56	14	14	CD
18637	23156	57	years	year	NNS
18637	23156	58	have	have	VBP
18637	23156	59	been	be	VBN
18637	23156	60	employed	employ	VBN
18637	23156	61	or	or	CC
18637	23156	62	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	23156	63	to	to	TO
18637	23156	64	work	work	VB
18637	23156	65	more	more	JJR
18637	23156	66	than	than	IN
18637	23156	67	8	8	CD
18637	23156	68	hours	hour	NNS
18637	23156	69	in	in	IN
18637	23156	70	any	any	DT
18637	23156	71	day	day	NN
18637	23156	72	,	,	,
18637	23156	73	or	or	CC
18637	23156	74	more	more	JJR
18637	23156	75	than	than	IN
18637	23156	76	6	6	CD
18637	23156	77	days	day	NNS
18637	23156	78	in	in	IN
18637	23156	79	any	any	DT
18637	23156	80	week	week	NN
18637	23156	81	*	*	NFP
18637	23156	82	*	*	NFP
18637	23156	83	*	*	NFP
18637	23156	84	,	,	,
18637	23156	85	"	"	''
18637	23156	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23156	87	held	hold	VBD
18637	23156	88	_	_	NNP
18637	23156	89	not	not	RB
18637	23156	90	within	within	IN
18637	23156	91	the	the	DT
18637	23156	92	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	23156	93	power	power	NN
18637	23156	94	of	of	IN
18637	23156	95	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	23156	96	.	.	.
18637	23157	1	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	23157	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23157	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23157	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23157	5	Dagenhart	Dagenhart	NNP
18637	23157	6	,	,	,
18637	23157	7	247	247	CD
18637	23157	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23157	9	251	251	CD
18637	23157	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23157	11	June	June	NNP
18637	23157	12	3	3	CD
18637	23157	13	,	,	,
18637	23157	14	1918	1918	CD
18637	23157	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23157	16	.	.	.
18637	23158	1	45	45	CD
18637	23158	2	.	.	.
18637	23159	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23159	2	of	of	IN
18637	23159	3	September	September	NNP
18637	23159	4	8	8	CD
18637	23159	5	,	,	,
18637	23159	6	1916	1916	CD
18637	23159	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23159	8	39	39	CD
18637	23159	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23159	10	.	.	.
18637	23160	1	757	757	CD
18637	23160	2	,	,	,
18637	23160	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23160	4	.	.	.
18637	23161	1	2(a	2(a	LS
18637	23161	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23161	3	in	in	IN
18637	23161	4	part	part	NN
18637	23161	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23161	6	.	.	.
18637	23162	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	23162	2	of	of	IN
18637	23162	3	the	the	DT
18637	23162	4	income	income	NN
18637	23162	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	23162	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	23162	7	law	law	NN
18637	23162	8	of	of	IN
18637	23162	9	1916	1916	CD
18637	23162	10	,	,	,
18637	23162	11	that	that	IN
18637	23162	12	a	a	DT
18637	23162	13	"	"	``
18637	23162	14	stock	stock	NN
18637	23162	15	dividend	dividend	NN
18637	23162	16	shall	shall	MD
18637	23162	17	be	be	VB
18637	23162	18	considered	consider	VBN
18637	23162	19	income	income	NN
18637	23162	20	,	,	,
18637	23162	21	to	to	IN
18637	23162	22	the	the	DT
18637	23162	23	amount	amount	NN
18637	23162	24	of	of	IN
18637	23162	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23162	26	cash	cash	NN
18637	23162	27	value	value	NN
18637	23162	28	,	,	,
18637	23162	29	"	"	''
18637	23162	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23162	31	held	hold	VBD
18637	23162	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23162	33	invalid	invalid	NNP
18637	23162	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23162	35	in	in	IN
18637	23162	36	spite	spite	NN
18637	23162	37	of	of	IN
18637	23162	38	the	the	DT
18637	23162	39	Sixteenth	Sixteenth	NNP
18637	23162	40	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23162	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23162	42	as	as	IN
18637	23162	43	an	an	DT
18637	23162	44	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	23162	45	to	to	TO
18637	23162	46	tax	tax	VB
18637	23162	47	something	something	NN
18637	23162	48	not	not	RB
18637	23162	49	actually	actually	RB
18637	23162	50	income	income	NN
18637	23162	51	,	,	,
18637	23162	52	without	without	IN
18637	23162	53	regard	regard	NN
18637	23162	54	to	to	IN
18637	23162	55	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	23162	56	under	under	IN
18637	23162	57	article	article	NN
18637	23162	58	I	i	NN
18637	23162	59	,	,	,
18637	23162	60	section	section	NN
18637	23162	61	2	2	CD
18637	23162	62	,	,	,
18637	23162	63	clause	clause	NN
18637	23162	64	3	3	CD
18637	23162	65	.	.	.
18637	23163	1	Eisner	Eisner	NNP
18637	23163	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23163	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23163	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23163	5	Macomber	Macomber	NNP
18637	23163	6	,	,	,
18637	23163	7	252	252	CD
18637	23163	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23163	9	189	189	CD
18637	23163	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23163	11	March	March	NNP
18637	23163	12	8	8	CD
18637	23163	13	,	,	,
18637	23163	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	23163	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23163	16	.	.	.
18637	23164	1	46	46	CD
18637	23164	2	.	.	.
18637	23165	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23165	2	of	of	IN
18637	23165	3	October	October	NNP
18637	23165	4	3	3	CD
18637	23165	5	,	,	,
18637	23165	6	1917	1917	CD
18637	23165	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23165	8	40	40	CD
18637	23165	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23165	10	.	.	.
18637	23166	1	302	302	CD
18637	23166	2	,	,	,
18637	23166	3	secs	secs	JJ
18637	23166	4	.	.	.
18637	23167	1	4	4	CD
18637	23167	2	,	,	,
18637	23167	3	303	303	CD
18637	23167	4	,	,	,
18637	23167	5	secs	secs	JJ
18637	23167	6	.	.	.
18637	23168	1	201	201	CD
18637	23168	2	and	and	CC
18637	23168	3	333	333	CD
18637	23168	4	,	,	,
18637	23168	5	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23168	6	.	.	.
18637	23169	1	1206	1206	CD
18637	23169	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23169	3	amending	amend	VBG
18637	23169	4	39	39	CD
18637	23169	5	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23169	6	.	.	.
18637	23170	1	765	765	CD
18637	23170	2	,	,	,
18637	23170	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23170	4	.	.	.
18637	23171	1	10	10	LS
18637	23171	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23171	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23171	4	;	;	:
18637	23171	5	and	and	CC
18637	23171	6	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23171	7	of	of	IN
18637	23171	8	February	February	NNP
18637	23171	9	24	24	CD
18637	23171	10	,	,	,
18637	23171	11	1919	1919	CD
18637	23171	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23171	13	40	40	CD
18637	23171	14	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23171	15	.	.	.
18637	23172	1	1075	1075	CD
18637	23172	2	,	,	,
18637	23172	3	secs	secs	JJ
18637	23172	4	.	.	.
18637	23173	1	230	230	CD
18637	23173	2	and	and	CC
18637	23173	3	1088	1088	CD
18637	23173	4	,	,	,
18637	23173	5	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23173	6	.	.	.
18637	23174	1	301	301	CD
18637	23174	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23174	3	.	.	.
18637	23175	1	Income	income	NN
18637	23175	2	and	and	CC
18637	23175	3	excess	excess	JJ
18637	23175	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	23175	5	profits	profit	NNS
18637	23175	6	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	23175	7	on	on	IN
18637	23175	8	income	income	NN
18637	23175	9	of	of	IN
18637	23175	10	"	"	``
18637	23175	11	every	every	DT
18637	23175	12	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	23175	13	,	,	,
18637	23175	14	"	"	''
18637	23175	15	as	as	IN
18637	23175	16	applied	apply	VBN
18637	23175	17	to	to	IN
18637	23175	18	income	income	NN
18637	23175	19	of	of	IN
18637	23175	20	an	an	DT
18637	23175	21	oil	oil	NN
18637	23175	22	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	23175	23	from	from	IN
18637	23175	24	leases	lease	NNS
18637	23175	25	of	of	IN
18637	23175	26	land	land	NN
18637	23175	27	granted	grant	VBN
18637	23175	28	by	by	IN
18637	23175	29	the	the	DT
18637	23175	30	United	United	NNP
18637	23175	31	States	States	NNP
18637	23175	32	to	to	IN
18637	23175	33	a	a	DT
18637	23175	34	State	state	NN
18637	23175	35	,	,	,
18637	23175	36	for	for	IN
18637	23175	37	the	the	DT
18637	23175	38	support	support	NN
18637	23175	39	of	of	IN
18637	23175	40	common	common	JJ
18637	23175	41	schools	school	NNS
18637	23175	42	,	,	,
18637	23175	43	etc	etc	FW
18637	23175	44	.	.	FW
18637	23175	45	,	,	,
18637	23175	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23175	47	held	hold	VBD
18637	23175	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23175	49	an	an	DT
18637	23175	50	interference	interference	NN
18637	23175	51	with	with	IN
18637	23175	52	State	State	NNP
18637	23175	53	governmental	governmental	JJ
18637	23175	54	functions	function	NNS
18637	23175	55	.	.	.
18637	23176	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23176	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23176	3	See	See	NNP
18637	23176	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23176	5	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	23176	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23176	7	.	.	.
18637	23176	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23177	1	Burnet	Burnet	NNP
18637	23177	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23177	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23177	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23177	5	Coronado	Coronado	NNP
18637	23177	6	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	23177	7	&	&	CC
18637	23177	8	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23177	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23177	10	,	,	,
18637	23177	11	285	285	CD
18637	23177	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23177	13	393	393	CD
18637	23177	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23177	15	April	April	NNP
18637	23177	16	11	11	CD
18637	23177	17	,	,	,
18637	23177	18	1932	1932	CD
18637	23177	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23177	20	.	.	.
18637	23178	1	47	47	CD
18637	23178	2	.	.	.
18637	23179	1	Same	same	JJ
18637	23179	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23179	3	40	40	CD
18637	23179	4	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23179	5	.	.	.
18637	23180	1	316	316	CD
18637	23180	2	,	,	,
18637	23180	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23180	4	.	.	.
18637	23181	1	600	600	CD
18637	23181	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23181	3	f	f	NN
18637	23181	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23181	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23181	6	.	.	.
18637	23182	1	The	the	DT
18637	23182	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	23182	3	"	"	``
18637	23182	4	upon	upon	IN
18637	23182	5	all	all	DT
18637	23182	6	tennis	tennis	NN
18637	23182	7	rackets	racket	NNS
18637	23182	8	,	,	,
18637	23182	9	golf	golf	NN
18637	23182	10	clubs	club	NNS
18637	23182	11	,	,	,
18637	23182	12	baseball	baseball	NN
18637	23182	13	bats	bat	NNS
18637	23182	14	*	*	NFP
18637	23182	15	*	*	NFP
18637	23182	16	*	*	NFP
18637	23182	17	balls	ball	NNS
18637	23182	18	of	of	IN
18637	23182	19	all	all	DT
18637	23182	20	kinds	kind	NNS
18637	23182	21	,	,	,
18637	23182	22	including	include	VBG
18637	23182	23	baseballs	baseball	NNS
18637	23182	24	*	*	NFP
18637	23182	25	*	*	NFP
18637	23182	26	*	*	NFP
18637	23182	27	sold	sell	VBN
18637	23182	28	by	by	IN
18637	23182	29	the	the	DT
18637	23182	30	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
18637	23182	31	,	,	,
18637	23182	32	producer	producer	NN
18637	23182	33	,	,	,
18637	23182	34	or	or	CC
18637	23182	35	importer	importer	NN
18637	23182	36	*	*	NFP
18637	23182	37	*	*	NFP
18637	23182	38	*	*	NFP
18637	23182	39	"	"	''
18637	23182	40	as	as	IN
18637	23182	41	applied	apply	VBN
18637	23182	42	to	to	IN
18637	23182	43	articles	article	NNS
18637	23182	44	sold	sell	VBN
18637	23182	45	by	by	IN
18637	23182	46	a	a	DT
18637	23182	47	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
18637	23182	48	to	to	IN
18637	23182	49	a	a	DT
18637	23182	50	commission	commission	NN
18637	23182	51	merchant	merchant	NN
18637	23182	52	for	for	IN
18637	23182	53	exportation	exportation	NN
18637	23182	54	,	,	,
18637	23182	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23182	56	held	hold	VBD
18637	23182	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23182	58	a	a	DT
18637	23182	59	tax	tax	NN
18637	23182	60	on	on	IN
18637	23182	61	exports	export	NNS
18637	23182	62	within	within	IN
18637	23182	63	the	the	DT
18637	23182	64	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	23182	65	of	of	IN
18637	23182	66	article	article	NN
18637	23182	67	I	i	NN
18637	23182	68	,	,	,
18637	23182	69	section	section	NN
18637	23182	70	9	9	CD
18637	23182	71	.	.	.
18637	23183	1	Spalding	Spalding	NNP
18637	23183	2	&	&	CC
18637	23183	3	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	23183	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23183	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	23183	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23183	7	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	23183	8	,	,	,
18637	23183	9	262	262	CD
18637	23183	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23183	11	66	66	CD
18637	23183	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23183	13	April	April	NNP
18637	23183	14	23	23	CD
18637	23183	15	,	,	,
18637	23183	16	1923	1923	CD
18637	23183	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23183	18	.	.	.
18637	23184	1	48	48	CD
18637	23184	2	.	.	.
18637	23185	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23185	2	of	of	IN
18637	23185	3	October	October	NNP
18637	23185	4	6	6	CD
18637	23185	5	,	,	,
18637	23185	6	1917	1917	CD
18637	23185	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23185	8	40	40	CD
18637	23185	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23185	10	.	.	.
18637	23186	1	395	395	CD
18637	23186	2	,	,	,
18637	23186	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23186	4	.	.	.
18637	23187	1	97	97	CD
18637	23187	2	,	,	,
18637	23187	3	in	in	IN
18637	23187	4	part	part	NN
18637	23187	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23187	6	.	.	.
18637	23188	1	The	the	DT
18637	23188	2	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	23188	3	of	of	IN
18637	23188	4	sections	section	NNS
18637	23188	5	24	24	CD
18637	23188	6	and	and	CC
18637	23188	7	256	256	CD
18637	23188	8	of	of	IN
18637	23188	9	the	the	DT
18637	23188	10	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	23188	11	Code	Code	NNP
18637	23188	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23188	13	which	which	WDT
18637	23188	14	prescribe	prescribe	VBP
18637	23188	15	the	the	DT
18637	23188	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	23188	17	of	of	IN
18637	23188	18	district	district	NN
18637	23188	19	courts	court	NNS
18637	23188	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23188	21	"	"	``
18637	23188	22	saving	save	VBG
18637	23188	23	*	*	NFP
18637	23188	24	*	*	NFP
18637	23188	25	*	*	NFP
18637	23188	26	to	to	IN
18637	23188	27	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	23188	28	the	the	DT
18637	23188	29	rights	right	NNS
18637	23188	30	and	and	CC
18637	23188	31	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	23188	32	under	under	IN
18637	23188	33	the	the	DT
18637	23188	34	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	23188	35	's	's	POS
18637	23188	36	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	23188	37	law	law	NN
18637	23188	38	of	of	IN
18637	23188	39	any	any	DT
18637	23188	40	State	State	NNP
18637	23188	41	,	,	,
18637	23188	42	"	"	''
18637	23188	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23188	44	held	hold	VBD
18637	23188	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23188	46	an	an	DT
18637	23188	47	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	23188	48	to	to	TO
18637	23188	49	transfer	transfer	VB
18637	23188	50	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	23188	51	power	power	NN
18637	23188	52	to	to	IN
18637	23188	53	the	the	DT
18637	23188	54	States	States	NNPS
18637	23188	55	--	--	:
18637	23188	56	the	the	DT
18637	23188	57	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	23188	58	,	,	,
18637	23188	59	by	by	IN
18637	23188	60	article	article	NN
18637	23188	61	III	III	NNP
18637	23188	62	,	,	,
18637	23188	63	section	section	NN
18637	23188	64	2	2	CD
18637	23188	65	,	,	,
18637	23188	66	and	and	CC
18637	23188	67	article	article	NN
18637	23188	68	I	i	NN
18637	23188	69	,	,	,
18637	23188	70	section	section	NN
18637	23188	71	8	8	CD
18637	23188	72	,	,	,
18637	23188	73	having	have	VBG
18637	23188	74	adopted	adopt	VBN
18637	23188	75	rules	rule	NNS
18637	23188	76	of	of	IN
18637	23188	77	general	general	JJ
18637	23188	78	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	23188	79	law	law	NN
18637	23188	80	.	.	.
18637	23189	1	Knickerbocker	Knickerbocker	NNP
18637	23189	2	Ice	Ice	NNP
18637	23189	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23189	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23189	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	23189	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23189	7	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	23189	8	,	,	,
18637	23189	9	253	253	CD
18637	23189	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23189	11	149	149	CD
18637	23189	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23189	13	May	May	NNP
18637	23189	14	17	17	CD
18637	23189	15	,	,	,
18637	23189	16	1920	1920	CD
18637	23189	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23189	18	.	.	.
18637	23190	1	49	49	CD
18637	23190	2	.	.	.
18637	23191	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23191	2	of	of	IN
18637	23191	3	September	September	NNP
18637	23191	4	19	19	CD
18637	23191	5	,	,	,
18637	23191	6	1918	1918	CD
18637	23191	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23191	8	40	40	CD
18637	23191	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23191	10	.	.	.
18637	23192	1	960	960	CD
18637	23192	2	,	,	,
18637	23192	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23192	4	.	.	.
18637	23193	1	174	174	CD
18637	23193	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23193	3	.	.	.
18637	23194	1	Specifically	specifically	RB
18637	23194	2	,	,	,
18637	23194	3	that	that	DT
18637	23194	4	part	part	NN
18637	23194	5	of	of	IN
18637	23194	6	the	the	DT
18637	23194	7	Minimum	Minimum	NNP
18637	23194	8	Wage	Wage	NNP
18637	23194	9	Law	Law	NNP
18637	23194	10	of	of	IN
18637	23194	11	the	the	DT
18637	23194	12	District	District	NNP
18637	23194	13	of	of	IN
18637	23194	14	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23194	15	which	which	WDT
18637	23194	16	authorized	authorize	VBD
18637	23194	17	the	the	DT
18637	23194	18	Wage	Wage	NNP
18637	23194	19	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23194	20	"	"	''
18637	23194	21	to	to	TO
18637	23194	22	ascertain	ascertain	VB
18637	23194	23	and	and	CC
18637	23194	24	declare	declare	VB
18637	23194	25	*	*	NFP
18637	23194	26	*	*	NFP
18637	23194	27	*	*	NFP
18637	23194	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23194	29	a	a	DT
18637	23194	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23194	31	Standards	standard	NNS
18637	23194	32	of	of	IN
18637	23194	33	minimum	minimum	JJ
18637	23194	34	wages	wage	NNS
18637	23194	35	for	for	IN
18637	23194	36	women	woman	NNS
18637	23194	37	in	in	IN
18637	23194	38	any	any	DT
18637	23194	39	occupation	occupation	NN
18637	23194	40	within	within	IN
18637	23194	41	the	the	DT
18637	23194	42	District	District	NNP
18637	23194	43	of	of	IN
18637	23194	44	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23194	45	,	,	,
18637	23194	46	and	and	CC
18637	23194	47	what	what	WDT
18637	23194	48	wages	wage	NNS
18637	23194	49	are	be	VBP
18637	23194	50	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
18637	23194	51	to	to	TO
18637	23194	52	supply	supply	VB
18637	23194	53	the	the	DT
18637	23194	54	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	23194	55	cost	cost	NN
18637	23194	56	of	of	IN
18637	23194	57	living	live	VBG
18637	23194	58	to	to	IN
18637	23194	59	any	any	DT
18637	23194	60	such	such	JJ
18637	23194	61	women	woman	NNS
18637	23194	62	workers	worker	NNS
18637	23194	63	to	to	TO
18637	23194	64	maintain	maintain	VB
18637	23194	65	them	-PRON-	PRP
18637	23194	66	in	in	IN
18637	23194	67	good	good	JJ
18637	23194	68	health	health	NN
18637	23194	69	and	and	CC
18637	23194	70	to	to	TO
18637	23194	71	protect	protect	VB
18637	23194	72	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23194	73	morals	moral	NNS
18637	23194	74	*	*	NFP
18637	23194	75	*	*	NFP
18637	23194	76	*	*	NFP
18637	23194	77	,	,	,
18637	23194	78	"	"	''
18637	23194	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23194	80	held	hold	VBD
18637	23194	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23194	82	to	to	TO
18637	23194	83	interfere	interfere	VB
18637	23194	84	with	with	IN
18637	23194	85	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	23194	86	of	of	IN
18637	23194	87	contract	contract	NN
18637	23194	88	under	under	IN
18637	23194	89	the	the	DT
18637	23194	90	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	23194	91	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23194	92	.	.	.
18637	23195	1	Adkins	Adkins	NNP
18637	23195	2	et	et	FW
18637	23195	3	al	al	NNP
18637	23195	4	.	.	.
18637	23196	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23196	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23196	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23196	4	Children	Children	NNP
18637	23196	5	's	's	POS
18637	23196	6	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	23196	7	and	and	CC
18637	23196	8	Adkins	Adkins	NNPS
18637	23196	9	et	et	FW
18637	23196	10	al	al	NNP
18637	23196	11	.	.	.
18637	23197	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23197	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23197	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23197	4	Lyons	Lyons	NNP
18637	23197	5	,	,	,
18637	23197	6	261	261	CD
18637	23197	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23197	8	525	525	CD
18637	23197	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23197	10	April	April	NNP
18637	23197	11	9	9	CD
18637	23197	12	,	,	,
18637	23197	13	1923)--overruled	1923)--overruled	CD
18637	23197	14	in	in	IN
18637	23197	15	West	West	NNP
18637	23197	16	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	23197	17	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	23197	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23197	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23197	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	23197	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23197	22	Parrish	Parrish	NNP
18637	23197	23	,	,	,
18637	23197	24	300	300	CD
18637	23197	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23197	26	379	379	CD
18637	23197	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23197	28	March	March	NNP
18637	23197	29	29	29	CD
18637	23197	30	,	,	,
18637	23197	31	1937	1937	CD
18637	23197	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23197	33	.	.	.
18637	23198	1	50	50	CD
18637	23198	2	.	.	.
18637	23199	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23199	2	of	of	IN
18637	23199	3	February	February	NNP
18637	23199	4	24	24	CD
18637	23199	5	,	,	,
18637	23199	6	1919	1919	CD
18637	23199	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23199	8	40	40	CD
18637	23199	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23199	10	.	.	.
18637	23200	1	1065	1065	CD
18637	23200	2	,	,	,
18637	23200	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23200	4	.	.	.
18637	23201	1	18	18	CD
18637	23201	2	,	,	,
18637	23201	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23201	4	.	.	.
18637	23202	1	213	213	CD
18637	23202	2	,	,	,
18637	23202	3	in	in	IN
18637	23202	4	part	part	NN
18637	23202	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23202	6	.	.	.
18637	23203	1	That	that	DT
18637	23203	2	part	part	NN
18637	23203	3	of	of	IN
18637	23203	4	section	section	NN
18637	23203	5	213	213	CD
18637	23203	6	of	of	IN
18637	23203	7	the	the	DT
18637	23203	8	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	23203	9	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23203	10	of	of	IN
18637	23203	11	1918	1918	CD
18637	23203	12	which	which	WDT
18637	23203	13	provided	provide	VBD
18637	23203	14	that	that	IN
18637	23203	15	"	"	``
18637	23203	16	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	17	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	18	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	19	for	for	IN
18637	23203	20	the	the	DT
18637	23203	21	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	23203	22	of	of	IN
18637	23203	23	this	this	DT
18637	23203	24	title	title	NN
18637	23203	25	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	26	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	27	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	28	the	the	DT
18637	23203	29	term	term	NN
18637	23203	30	'	'	POS
18637	23203	31	gross	gross	JJ
18637	23203	32	income	income	NN
18637	23203	33	'	'	''
18637	23203	34	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	35	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	36	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	37	includes	include	VBZ
18637	23203	38	gains	gain	NNS
18637	23203	39	,	,	,
18637	23203	40	profits	profit	NNS
18637	23203	41	,	,	,
18637	23203	42	and	and	CC
18637	23203	43	income	income	NN
18637	23203	44	derived	derive	VBN
18637	23203	45	from	from	IN
18637	23203	46	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	23203	47	,	,	,
18637	23203	48	wages	wage	NNS
18637	23203	49	,	,	,
18637	23203	50	or	or	CC
18637	23203	51	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	23203	52	for	for	IN
18637	23203	53	personal	personal	JJ
18637	23203	54	service	service	NN
18637	23203	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23203	56	including	include	VBG
18637	23203	57	in	in	IN
18637	23203	58	the	the	DT
18637	23203	59	case	case	NN
18637	23203	60	of	of	IN
18637	23203	61	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	62	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	63	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	64	judges	judge	NNS
18637	23203	65	of	of	IN
18637	23203	66	the	the	DT
18637	23203	67	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	23203	68	and	and	CC
18637	23203	69	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	23203	70	courts	court	NNS
18637	23203	71	of	of	IN
18637	23203	72	the	the	DT
18637	23203	73	United	United	NNP
18637	23203	74	States	States	NNP
18637	23203	75	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	76	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	77	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	78	the	the	DT
18637	23203	79	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	23203	80	received	receive	VBD
18637	23203	81	as	as	IN
18637	23203	82	such	such	JJ
18637	23203	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23203	84	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	85	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	86	*	*	NFP
18637	23203	87	"	"	''
18637	23203	88	as	as	IN
18637	23203	89	applied	apply	VBN
18637	23203	90	to	to	IN
18637	23203	91	a	a	DT
18637	23203	92	judge	judge	NN
18637	23203	93	in	in	IN
18637	23203	94	office	office	NN
18637	23203	95	when	when	WRB
18637	23203	96	the	the	DT
18637	23203	97	act	act	NN
18637	23203	98	was	be	VBD
18637	23203	99	passed	pass	VBN
18637	23203	100	,	,	,
18637	23203	101	_	_	NNP
18637	23203	102	held	hold	VBD
18637	23203	103	_	_	NNP
18637	23203	104	a	a	DT
18637	23203	105	violation	violation	NN
18637	23203	106	of	of	IN
18637	23203	107	the	the	DT
18637	23203	108	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	23203	109	of	of	IN
18637	23203	110	judges	judge	NNS
18637	23203	111	'	'	POS
18637	23203	112	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	23203	113	,	,	,
18637	23203	114	in	in	IN
18637	23203	115	article	article	NN
18637	23203	116	III	III	NNP
18637	23203	117	,	,	,
18637	23203	118	section	section	NN
18637	23203	119	1	1	CD
18637	23203	120	.	.	.
18637	23204	1	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	23204	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23204	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23204	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23204	5	Gore	Gore	NNP
18637	23204	6	,	,	,
18637	23204	7	253	253	CD
18637	23204	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23204	9	245	245	CD
18637	23204	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23204	11	June	June	NNP
18637	23204	12	1	1	CD
18637	23204	13	,	,	,
18637	23204	14	1920	1920	CD
18637	23204	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23204	16	.	.	.
18637	23205	1	Miles	Miles	NNP
18637	23205	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23205	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23205	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23205	5	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	23205	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23205	7	268	268	CD
18637	23205	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23205	9	501	501	CD
18637	23205	10	,	,	,
18637	23205	11	June	June	NNP
18637	23205	12	1	1	CD
18637	23205	13	,	,	,
18637	23205	14	1925	1925	CD
18637	23205	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23205	16	,	,	,
18637	23205	17	held	hold	VBD
18637	23205	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	23205	19	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	23205	20	as	as	IN
18637	23205	21	applied	apply	VBN
18637	23205	22	to	to	IN
18637	23205	23	a	a	DT
18637	23205	24	judge	judge	NN
18637	23205	25	taking	take	VBG
18637	23205	26	office	office	NN
18637	23205	27	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
18637	23205	28	to	to	IN
18637	23205	29	the	the	DT
18637	23205	30	date	date	NN
18637	23205	31	of	of	IN
18637	23205	32	the	the	DT
18637	23205	33	act	act	NN
18637	23205	34	.	.	.
18637	23206	1	51	51	CD
18637	23206	2	.	.	.
18637	23207	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23207	2	of	of	IN
18637	23207	3	February	February	NNP
18637	23207	4	24	24	CD
18637	23207	5	,	,	,
18637	23207	6	1919	1919	CD
18637	23207	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23207	8	40	40	CD
18637	23207	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23207	10	.	.	.
18637	23208	1	1097	1097	CD
18637	23208	2	,	,	,
18637	23208	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23208	4	.	.	.
18637	23209	1	402	402	CD
18637	23209	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23209	3	c	c	NN
18637	23209	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23209	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23209	6	.	.	.
18637	23210	1	That	that	DT
18637	23210	2	part	part	NN
18637	23210	3	of	of	IN
18637	23210	4	the	the	DT
18637	23210	5	estate	estate	NN
18637	23210	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	23210	7	providing	provide	VBG
18637	23210	8	that	that	IN
18637	23210	9	"	"	``
18637	23210	10	gross	gross	JJ
18637	23210	11	estate	estate	NN
18637	23210	12	"	"	''
18637	23210	13	of	of	IN
18637	23210	14	a	a	DT
18637	23210	15	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	23210	16	should	should	MD
18637	23210	17	include	include	VB
18637	23210	18	value	value	NN
18637	23210	19	of	of	IN
18637	23210	20	all	all	DT
18637	23210	21	property	property	NN
18637	23210	22	"	"	''
18637	23210	23	to	to	IN
18637	23210	24	the	the	DT
18637	23210	25	extent	extent	NN
18637	23210	26	of	of	IN
18637	23210	27	any	any	DT
18637	23210	28	interest	interest	NN
18637	23210	29	therein	therein	RB
18637	23210	30	of	of	IN
18637	23210	31	which	which	WDT
18637	23210	32	the	the	DT
18637	23210	33	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	23210	34	has	have	VBZ
18637	23210	35	at	at	IN
18637	23210	36	any	any	DT
18637	23210	37	time	time	NN
18637	23210	38	made	make	VBD
18637	23210	39	a	a	DT
18637	23210	40	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	23210	41	or	or	CC
18637	23210	42	with	with	IN
18637	23210	43	respect	respect	NN
18637	23210	44	to	to	TO
18637	23210	45	which	which	WDT
18637	23210	46	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	23210	47	had	have	VBD
18637	23210	48	at	at	IN
18637	23210	49	any	any	DT
18637	23210	50	time	time	NN
18637	23210	51	created	create	VBD
18637	23210	52	a	a	DT
18637	23210	53	trust	trust	NN
18637	23210	54	,	,	,
18637	23210	55	in	in	IN
18637	23210	56	contemplation	contemplation	NN
18637	23210	57	of	of	IN
18637	23210	58	or	or	CC
18637	23210	59	intended	intend	VBN
18637	23210	60	to	to	TO
18637	23210	61	take	take	VB
18637	23210	62	effect	effect	NN
18637	23210	63	in	in	IN
18637	23210	64	possession	possession	NN
18637	23210	65	or	or	CC
18637	23210	66	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	23210	67	at	at	IN
18637	23210	68	or	or	CC
18637	23210	69	after	after	IN
18637	23210	70	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23210	71	death	death	NN
18637	23210	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23210	73	whether	whether	IN
18637	23210	74	such	such	JJ
18637	23210	75	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	23210	76	or	or	CC
18637	23210	77	trust	trust	NN
18637	23210	78	is	be	VBZ
18637	23210	79	made	make	VBN
18637	23210	80	or	or	CC
18637	23210	81	created	create	VBN
18637	23210	82	before	before	RB
18637	23210	83	or	or	CC
18637	23210	84	after	after	IN
18637	23210	85	the	the	DT
18637	23210	86	passage	passage	NN
18637	23210	87	of	of	IN
18637	23210	88	this	this	DT
18637	23210	89	act	act	NN
18637	23210	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23210	91	,	,	,
18637	23210	92	except	except	IN
18637	23210	93	in	in	IN
18637	23210	94	case	case	NN
18637	23210	95	of	of	IN
18637	23210	96	a	a	DT
18637	23210	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23210	98	bona	bona	NN
18637	23210	99	fide	fide	FW
18637	23210	100	_	_	NNP
18637	23210	101	sale	sale	NN
18637	23210	102	*	*	NFP
18637	23210	103	*	*	NFP
18637	23210	104	*	*	NFP
18637	23210	105	"	"	''
18637	23210	106	as	as	IN
18637	23210	107	applied	apply	VBN
18637	23210	108	to	to	IN
18637	23210	109	a	a	DT
18637	23210	110	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	23210	111	of	of	IN
18637	23210	112	property	property	NN
18637	23210	113	made	make	VBN
18637	23210	114	prior	prior	RB
18637	23210	115	to	to	IN
18637	23210	116	the	the	DT
18637	23210	117	act	act	NN
18637	23210	118	and	and	CC
18637	23210	119	intended	intend	VBD
18637	23210	120	to	to	TO
18637	23210	121	take	take	VB
18637	23210	122	effect	effect	NN
18637	23210	123	"	"	''
18637	23210	124	in	in	IN
18637	23210	125	possession	possession	NN
18637	23210	126	or	or	CC
18637	23210	127	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	23210	128	"	"	''
18637	23210	129	at	at	IN
18637	23210	130	death	death	NN
18637	23210	131	of	of	IN
18637	23210	132	grantor	grantor	NN
18637	23210	133	,	,	,
18637	23210	134	but	but	CC
18637	23210	135	not	not	RB
18637	23210	136	in	in	IN
18637	23210	137	fact	fact	NN
18637	23210	138	testamentary	testamentary	NN
18637	23210	139	or	or	CC
18637	23210	140	designed	design	VBN
18637	23210	141	to	to	TO
18637	23210	142	evade	evade	VB
18637	23210	143	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	23210	144	,	,	,
18637	23210	145	_	_	NNP
18637	23210	146	held	hold	VBD
18637	23210	147	_	_	NNP
18637	23210	148	confiscatory	confiscatory	NN
18637	23210	149	,	,	,
18637	23210	150	contrary	contrary	JJ
18637	23210	151	to	to	IN
18637	23210	152	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	23210	153	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23210	154	.	.	.
18637	23211	1	Nichols	Nichols	NNP
18637	23211	2	,	,	,
18637	23211	3	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	23211	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23211	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	23211	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23211	7	Coolidge	Coolidge	NNP
18637	23211	8	et	et	NNP
18637	23211	9	al	al	NNP
18637	23211	10	.	.	NNP
18637	23211	11	,	,	,
18637	23211	12	Executors	Executors	NNP
18637	23211	13	,	,	,
18637	23211	14	274	274	CD
18637	23211	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23211	16	531	531	CD
18637	23211	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23211	18	May	May	NNP
18637	23211	19	31	31	CD
18637	23211	20	,	,	,
18637	23211	21	1927	1927	CD
18637	23211	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23211	23	.	.	.
18637	23212	1	52	52	CD
18637	23212	2	.	.	.
18637	23213	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23213	2	of	of	IN
18637	23213	3	February	February	NNP
18637	23213	4	24	24	CD
18637	23213	5	,	,	,
18637	23213	6	1919	1919	CD
18637	23213	7	,	,	,
18637	23213	8	title	title	NN
18637	23213	9	XII	XII	NNP
18637	23213	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23213	11	40	40	CD
18637	23213	12	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23213	13	.	.	.
18637	23214	1	1138	1138	CD
18637	23214	2	,	,	,
18637	23214	3	entire	entire	JJ
18637	23214	4	title	title	NN
18637	23214	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23214	6	.	.	.
18637	23215	1	The	the	DT
18637	23215	2	Child	Child	NNP
18637	23215	3	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	23215	4	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23215	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23215	6	,	,	,
18637	23215	7	providing	provide	VBG
18637	23215	8	that	that	IN
18637	23215	9	"	"	``
18637	23215	10	every	every	DT
18637	23215	11	person	person	NN
18637	23215	12	*	*	NFP
18637	23215	13	*	*	NFP
18637	23215	14	*	*	NFP
18637	23215	15	operating	operating	NN
18637	23215	16	*	*	NFP
18637	23215	17	*	*	NFP
18637	23215	18	*	*	NFP
18637	23215	19	any	any	DT
18637	23215	20	*	*	NFP
18637	23215	21	*	*	NFP
18637	23215	22	*	*	NFP
18637	23215	23	factory	factory	NN
18637	23215	24	[	[	-LRB-
18637	23215	25	etc	etc	FW
18637	23215	26	.	.	.
18637	23215	27	]	]	-RRB-
18637	23216	1	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	2	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	3	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	4	in	in	IN
18637	23216	5	which	which	WDT
18637	23216	6	children	child	NNS
18637	23216	7	under	under	IN
18637	23216	8	the	the	DT
18637	23216	9	age	age	NN
18637	23216	10	of	of	IN
18637	23216	11	14	14	CD
18637	23216	12	years	year	NNS
18637	23216	13	have	have	VBP
18637	23216	14	been	be	VBN
18637	23216	15	employed	employ	VBN
18637	23216	16	or	or	CC
18637	23216	17	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	23216	18	to	to	TO
18637	23216	19	work	work	NN
18637	23216	20	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	21	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	22	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	23	shall	shall	MD
18637	23216	24	pay	pay	VB
18637	23216	25	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	26	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	27	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	28	in	in	IN
18637	23216	29	addition	addition	NN
18637	23216	30	to	to	IN
18637	23216	31	all	all	DT
18637	23216	32	other	other	JJ
18637	23216	33	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	23216	34	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	23216	35	by	by	IN
18637	23216	36	law	law	NN
18637	23216	37	,	,	,
18637	23216	38	an	an	DT
18637	23216	39	excise	excise	NN
18637	23216	40	tax	tax	NN
18637	23216	41	equivalent	equivalent	NN
18637	23216	42	to	to	IN
18637	23216	43	10	10	CD
18637	23216	44	percent	percent	NN
18637	23216	45	of	of	IN
18637	23216	46	the	the	DT
18637	23216	47	entire	entire	JJ
18637	23216	48	net	net	JJ
18637	23216	49	profits	profit	NNS
18637	23216	50	received	receive	VBN
18637	23216	51	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	52	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	53	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	54	for	for	IN
18637	23216	55	such	such	JJ
18637	23216	56	year	year	NN
18637	23216	57	from	from	IN
18637	23216	58	the	the	DT
18637	23216	59	sale	sale	NN
18637	23216	60	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	61	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	62	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	63	of	of	IN
18637	23216	64	the	the	DT
18637	23216	65	product	product	NN
18637	23216	66	of	of	IN
18637	23216	67	such	such	JJ
18637	23216	68	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	69	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	70	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	71	factory	factory	NN
18637	23216	72	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	73	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	74	*	*	NFP
18637	23216	75	,	,	,
18637	23216	76	"	"	''
18637	23216	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23216	78	held	hold	VBD
18637	23216	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23216	80	beyond	beyond	IN
18637	23216	81	the	the	DT
18637	23216	82	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	23216	83	power	power	NN
18637	23216	84	under	under	IN
18637	23216	85	article	article	NN
18637	23216	86	I	i	NN
18637	23216	87	,	,	,
18637	23216	88	section	section	NN
18637	23216	89	8	8	CD
18637	23216	90	,	,	,
18637	23216	91	clause	clause	NN
18637	23216	92	1	1	CD
18637	23216	93	,	,	,
18637	23216	94	and	and	CC
18637	23216	95	an	an	DT
18637	23216	96	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	23216	97	of	of	IN
18637	23216	98	State	State	NNP
18637	23216	99	authority	authority	NN
18637	23216	100	.	.	.
18637	23217	1	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	23217	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23217	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23217	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23217	5	Drexel	Drexel	NNP
18637	23217	6	Furniture	Furniture	NNP
18637	23217	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23217	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23217	9	Child	Child	NNP
18637	23217	10	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	23217	11	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23217	12	Case	Case	NNP
18637	23217	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23217	14	,	,	,
18637	23217	15	259	259	CD
18637	23217	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23217	17	20	20	CD
18637	23217	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23217	19	May	May	NNP
18637	23217	20	15	15	CD
18637	23217	21	,	,	,
18637	23217	22	1922	1922	CD
18637	23217	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23217	24	.	.	.
18637	23218	1	53	53	CD
18637	23218	2	.	.	.
18637	23219	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23219	2	of	of	IN
18637	23219	3	October	October	NNP
18637	23219	4	22	22	CD
18637	23219	5	,	,	,
18637	23219	6	1919	1919	CD
18637	23219	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23219	8	41	41	CD
18637	23219	9	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	23219	10	.	.	.
18637	23220	1	298	298	CD
18637	23220	2	,	,	,
18637	23220	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23220	4	.	.	.
18637	23221	1	2	2	LS
18637	23221	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23221	3	,	,	,
18637	23221	4	amending	amend	VBG
18637	23221	5	act	act	NN
18637	23221	6	of	of	IN
18637	23221	7	August	August	NNP
18637	23221	8	10	10	CD
18637	23221	9	,	,	,
18637	23221	10	1917	1917	CD
18637	23221	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23221	12	40	40	CD
18637	23221	13	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23221	14	.	.	.
18637	23222	1	277	277	CD
18637	23222	2	,	,	,
18637	23222	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23222	4	.	.	.
18637	23223	1	4	4	LS
18637	23223	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23223	3	.	.	.
18637	23224	1	Section	section	NN
18637	23224	2	4	4	CD
18637	23224	3	of	of	IN
18637	23224	4	the	the	DT
18637	23224	5	Lever	Lever	NNP
18637	23224	6	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23224	7	,	,	,
18637	23224	8	providing	provide	VBG
18637	23224	9	in	in	IN
18637	23224	10	part	part	NN
18637	23224	11	"	"	''
18637	23224	12	that	that	IN
18637	23224	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	23224	14	is	be	VBZ
18637	23224	15	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	23224	16	made	make	VBN
18637	23224	17	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	23224	18	for	for	IN
18637	23224	19	any	any	DT
18637	23224	20	person	person	NN
18637	23224	21	willfully	willfully	RB
18637	23224	22	*	*	NFP
18637	23224	23	*	*	NFP
18637	23224	24	*	*	NFP
18637	23224	25	to	to	TO
18637	23224	26	make	make	VB
18637	23224	27	any	any	DT
18637	23224	28	unjust	unjust	JJ
18637	23224	29	or	or	CC
18637	23224	30	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	23224	31	rate	rate	NN
18637	23224	32	or	or	CC
18637	23224	33	charge	charge	NN
18637	23224	34	in	in	IN
18637	23224	35	handling	handling	NN
18637	23224	36	or	or	CC
18637	23224	37	dealing	deal	VBG
18637	23224	38	in	in	RB
18637	23224	39	or	or	CC
18637	23224	40	with	with	IN
18637	23224	41	any	any	DT
18637	23224	42	necessaries	necessary	NNS
18637	23224	43	*	*	NFP
18637	23224	44	*	*	NFP
18637	23224	45	*	*	NFP
18637	23224	46	"	"	''
18637	23224	47	and	and	CC
18637	23224	48	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	23224	49	a	a	DT
18637	23224	50	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	23224	51	,	,	,
18637	23224	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23224	53	held	hold	VBD
18637	23224	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23224	55	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	23224	56	to	to	TO
18637	23224	57	support	support	VB
18637	23224	58	an	an	DT
18637	23224	59	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	23224	60	for	for	IN
18637	23224	61	charging	charge	VBG
18637	23224	62	an	an	DT
18637	23224	63	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	23224	64	price	price	NN
18637	23224	65	on	on	IN
18637	23224	66	sale	sale	NN
18637	23224	67	--	--	:
18637	23224	68	as	as	IN
18637	23224	69	not	not	RB
18637	23224	70	setting	set	VBG
18637	23224	71	up	up	RP
18637	23224	72	an	an	DT
18637	23224	73	ascertainable	ascertainable	JJ
18637	23224	74	standard	standard	NN
18637	23224	75	of	of	IN
18637	23224	76	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	23224	77	within	within	IN
18637	23224	78	the	the	DT
18637	23224	79	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	23224	80	of	of	IN
18637	23224	81	the	the	DT
18637	23224	82	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	23224	83	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23224	84	.	.	.
18637	23225	1	United	United	NNP
18637	23225	2	States	States	NNP
18637	23225	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23225	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23225	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23225	6	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
18637	23225	7	Grocery	Grocery	NNP
18637	23225	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23225	9	,	,	,
18637	23225	10	255	255	CD
18637	23225	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23225	12	81	81	CD
18637	23225	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23225	14	February	February	NNP
18637	23225	15	28	28	CD
18637	23225	16	,	,	,
18637	23225	17	1921	1921	CD
18637	23225	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23225	19	.	.	.
18637	23226	1	54	54	CD
18637	23226	2	.	.	.
18637	23227	1	Same	same	JJ
18637	23227	2	.	.	.
18637	23228	1	That	that	DT
18637	23228	2	provision	provision	NN
18637	23228	3	of	of	IN
18637	23228	4	section	section	NN
18637	23228	5	4	4	CD
18637	23228	6	making	make	VBG
18637	23228	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	23228	8	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	23228	9	"	"	''
18637	23228	10	to	to	TO
18637	23228	11	conspire	conspire	VB
18637	23228	12	,	,	,
18637	23228	13	combine	combine	VB
18637	23228	14	,	,	,
18637	23228	15	agree	agree	VBP
18637	23228	16	,	,	,
18637	23228	17	or	or	CC
18637	23228	18	arrange	arrange	VB
18637	23228	19	with	with	IN
18637	23228	20	any	any	DT
18637	23228	21	other	other	JJ
18637	23228	22	person	person	NN
18637	23228	23	to	to	IN
18637	23228	24	*	*	NFP
18637	23228	25	*	*	NFP
18637	23228	26	*	*	NFP
18637	23228	27	exact	exact	JJ
18637	23228	28	excessive	excessive	JJ
18637	23228	29	prices	price	NNS
18637	23228	30	for	for	IN
18637	23228	31	any	any	DT
18637	23228	32	necessaries	necessary	NNS
18637	23228	33	"	"	''
18637	23228	34	and	and	CC
18637	23228	35	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	23228	36	a	a	DT
18637	23228	37	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	23228	38	,	,	,
18637	23228	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23228	40	held	hold	VBD
18637	23228	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23228	42	invalid	invalid	JJ
18637	23228	43	to	to	TO
18637	23228	44	support	support	VB
18637	23228	45	an	an	DT
18637	23228	46	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	23228	47	,	,	,
18637	23228	48	on	on	IN
18637	23228	49	the	the	DT
18637	23228	50	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	23228	51	of	of	IN
18637	23228	52	the	the	DT
18637	23228	53	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
18637	23228	54	case	case	NN
18637	23228	55	.	.	.
18637	23229	1	Weeds	Weeds	NNP
18637	23229	2	,	,	,
18637	23229	3	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	23229	4	,	,	,
18637	23229	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23229	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	23229	7	_	_	NNP
18637	23229	8	United	United	NNP
18637	23229	9	States	States	NNP
18637	23229	10	,	,	,
18637	23229	11	255	255	CD
18637	23229	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23229	13	109	109	CD
18637	23229	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23229	15	February	February	NNP
18637	23229	16	28	28	CD
18637	23229	17	,	,	,
18637	23229	18	1921	1921	CD
18637	23229	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23229	20	55	55	CD
18637	23229	21	.	.	.
18637	23230	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23230	2	of	of	IN
18637	23230	3	August	August	NNP
18637	23230	4	24	24	CD
18637	23230	5	,	,	,
18637	23230	6	1921	1921	CD
18637	23230	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23230	8	42	42	CD
18637	23230	9	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	23230	10	.	.	.
18637	23231	1	187	187	CD
18637	23231	2	,	,	,
18637	23231	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23231	4	.	.	.
18637	23232	1	86	86	CD
18637	23232	2	,	,	,
18637	23232	3	Future	Future	NNP
18637	23232	4	Trading	Trading	NNP
18637	23232	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23232	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23232	7	.	.	.
18637	23233	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23233	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23233	3	a	a	DT
18637	23233	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23233	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23233	6	Section	section	NN
18637	23233	7	4	4	CD
18637	23233	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23233	9	and	and	CC
18637	23233	10	interwoven	interwoven	JJ
18637	23233	11	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	23233	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23233	13	providing	provide	VBG
18637	23233	14	a	a	DT
18637	23233	15	"	"	``
18637	23233	16	tax	tax	NN
18637	23233	17	of	of	IN
18637	23233	18	20	20	CD
18637	23233	19	cents	cent	NNS
18637	23233	20	a	a	DT
18637	23233	21	bushel	bushel	NN
18637	23233	22	on	on	IN
18637	23233	23	every	every	DT
18637	23233	24	bushel	bushel	NN
18637	23233	25	involved	involve	VBN
18637	23233	26	therein	therein	RB
18637	23233	27	,	,	,
18637	23233	28	upon	upon	IN
18637	23233	29	each	each	DT
18637	23233	30	contract	contract	NN
18637	23233	31	of	of	IN
18637	23233	32	sale	sale	NN
18637	23233	33	of	of	IN
18637	23233	34	grain	grain	NN
18637	23233	35	for	for	IN
18637	23233	36	future	future	JJ
18637	23233	37	delivery	delivery	NN
18637	23233	38	,	,	,
18637	23233	39	except	except	IN
18637	23233	40	*	*	NFP
18637	23233	41	*	*	NFP
18637	23233	42	*	*	NFP
18637	23233	43	where	where	WRB
18637	23233	44	such	such	JJ
18637	23233	45	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	23233	46	are	be	VBP
18637	23233	47	made	make	VBN
18637	23233	48	by	by	IN
18637	23233	49	or	or	CC
18637	23233	50	through	through	IN
18637	23233	51	a	a	DT
18637	23233	52	member	member	NN
18637	23233	53	of	of	IN
18637	23233	54	a	a	DT
18637	23233	55	board	board	NN
18637	23233	56	of	of	IN
18637	23233	57	trade	trade	NN
18637	23233	58	which	which	WDT
18637	23233	59	has	have	VBZ
18637	23233	60	been	be	VBN
18637	23233	61	designated	designate	VBN
18637	23233	62	by	by	IN
18637	23233	63	the	the	DT
18637	23233	64	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	23233	65	of	of	IN
18637	23233	66	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	23233	67	as	as	IN
18637	23233	68	a	a	DT
18637	23233	69	'	'	``
18637	23233	70	contract	contract	NN
18637	23233	71	market	market	NN
18637	23233	72	'	'	''
18637	23233	73	*	*	NFP
18637	23233	74	*	*	NFP
18637	23233	75	*	*	NFP
18637	23233	76	,	,	,
18637	23233	77	"	"	''
18637	23233	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23233	79	held	hold	VBD
18637	23233	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23233	81	not	not	RB
18637	23233	82	within	within	IN
18637	23233	83	the	the	DT
18637	23233	84	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	23233	85	power	power	NN
18637	23233	86	under	under	IN
18637	23233	87	article	article	NN
18637	23233	88	I	i	NN
18637	23233	89	,	,	,
18637	23233	90	section	section	NN
18637	23233	91	8	8	CD
18637	23233	92	.	.	.
18637	23234	1	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	23234	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23234	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23234	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23234	5	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	23234	6	,	,	,
18637	23234	7	259	259	CD
18637	23234	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23234	9	44	44	CD
18637	23234	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23234	11	May	May	NNP
18637	23234	12	15	15	CD
18637	23234	13	,	,	,
18637	23234	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	23234	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23234	16	.	.	.
18637	23235	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23235	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23235	3	b	b	NNP
18637	23235	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23235	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23235	6	Section	section	NN
18637	23235	7	3	3	CD
18637	23235	8	,	,	,
18637	23235	9	providing	provide	VBG
18637	23235	10	"	"	``
18637	23235	11	That	that	IN
18637	23235	12	in	in	IN
18637	23235	13	addition	addition	NN
18637	23235	14	to	to	IN
18637	23235	15	the	the	DT
18637	23235	16	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	23235	17	now	now	RB
18637	23235	18	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	23235	19	by	by	IN
18637	23235	20	law	law	NN
18637	23235	21	there	there	EX
18637	23235	22	is	be	VBZ
18637	23235	23	hereby	hereby	NNP
18637	23235	24	levied	levy	VBN
18637	23235	25	a	a	DT
18637	23235	26	tax	tax	NN
18637	23235	27	amounting	amount	VBG
18637	23235	28	to	to	IN
18637	23235	29	20	20	CD
18637	23235	30	cents	cent	NNS
18637	23235	31	per	per	IN
18637	23235	32	bushel	bushel	NN
18637	23235	33	on	on	IN
18637	23235	34	each	each	DT
18637	23235	35	bushel	bushel	NN
18637	23235	36	involved	involve	VBN
18637	23235	37	therein	therein	RB
18637	23235	38	,	,	,
18637	23235	39	whether	whether	IN
18637	23235	40	the	the	DT
18637	23235	41	actual	actual	JJ
18637	23235	42	commodity	commodity	NN
18637	23235	43	is	be	VBZ
18637	23235	44	intended	intend	VBN
18637	23235	45	to	to	TO
18637	23235	46	be	be	VB
18637	23235	47	delivered	deliver	VBN
18637	23235	48	or	or	CC
18637	23235	49	only	only	RB
18637	23235	50	nominally	nominally	RB
18637	23235	51	referred	refer	VBN
18637	23235	52	to	to	IN
18637	23235	53	,	,	,
18637	23235	54	upon	upon	IN
18637	23235	55	each	each	DT
18637	23235	56	*	*	NFP
18637	23235	57	*	*	NFP
18637	23235	58	*	*	NFP
18637	23235	59	option	option	NN
18637	23235	60	for	for	IN
18637	23235	61	a	a	DT
18637	23235	62	contract	contract	NN
18637	23235	63	either	either	CC
18637	23235	64	of	of	IN
18637	23235	65	purchase	purchase	NN
18637	23235	66	or	or	CC
18637	23235	67	sale	sale	NN
18637	23235	68	of	of	IN
18637	23235	69	grain	grain	NN
18637	23235	70	*	*	NFP
18637	23235	71	*	*	NFP
18637	23235	72	*	*	NFP
18637	23235	73	"	"	''
18637	23235	74	,	,	,
18637	23235	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23235	76	held	hold	VBD
18637	23235	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23235	78	invalid	invalid	NNP
18637	23235	79	on	on	IN
18637	23235	80	the	the	DT
18637	23235	81	same	same	JJ
18637	23235	82	reasoning	reasoning	NN
18637	23235	83	.	.	.
18637	23236	1	Trusler	Trusler	NNP
18637	23236	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23236	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23236	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23236	5	Crooks	Crooks	NNP
18637	23236	6	,	,	,
18637	23236	7	269	269	CD
18637	23236	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23236	9	475	475	CD
18637	23236	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23236	11	Jan.	January	NNP
18637	23236	12	11	11	CD
18637	23236	13	,	,	,
18637	23236	14	1926	1926	CD
18637	23236	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23236	16	.	.	.
18637	23237	1	56	56	CD
18637	23237	2	.	.	.
18637	23238	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23238	2	of	of	IN
18637	23238	3	November	November	NNP
18637	23238	4	23	23	CD
18637	23238	5	,	,	,
18637	23238	6	1921	1921	CD
18637	23238	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23238	8	42	42	CD
18637	23238	9	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	23238	10	.	.	.
18637	23239	1	261	261	CD
18637	23239	2	,	,	,
18637	23239	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23239	4	.	.	.
18637	23240	1	245	245	CD
18637	23240	2	,	,	,
18637	23240	3	part	part	NN
18637	23240	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23240	5	.	.	.
18637	23241	1	Provision	Provision	NNP
18637	23241	2	of	of	IN
18637	23241	3	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	23241	4	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23241	5	of	of	IN
18637	23241	6	1921	1921	CD
18637	23241	7	abating	abate	VBG
18637	23241	8	the	the	DT
18637	23241	9	deduction	deduction	NN
18637	23241	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23241	11	4	4	CD
18637	23241	12	percent	percent	NN
18637	23241	13	of	of	IN
18637	23241	14	mean	mean	JJ
18637	23241	15	reserves	reserve	NNS
18637	23241	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23241	17	allowed	allow	VBN
18637	23241	18	from	from	IN
18637	23241	19	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	23241	20	income	income	NN
18637	23241	21	of	of	IN
18637	23241	22	life	life	NN
18637	23241	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	23241	24	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	23241	25	companies	company	NNS
18637	23241	26	in	in	IN
18637	23241	27	general	general	JJ
18637	23241	28	by	by	IN
18637	23241	29	the	the	DT
18637	23241	30	amount	amount	NN
18637	23241	31	of	of	IN
18637	23241	32	interest	interest	NN
18637	23241	33	on	on	IN
18637	23241	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23241	35	tax	tax	NN
18637	23241	36	-	-	HYPH
18637	23241	37	exempts	exempt	NNS
18637	23241	38	,	,	,
18637	23241	39	and	and	CC
18637	23241	40	so	so	RB
18637	23241	41	according	accord	VBG
18637	23241	42	no	no	DT
18637	23241	43	relative	relative	JJ
18637	23241	44	advantage	advantage	NN
18637	23241	45	to	to	IN
18637	23241	46	the	the	DT
18637	23241	47	owners	owner	NNS
18637	23241	48	of	of	IN
18637	23241	49	the	the	DT
18637	23241	50	tax	tax	NN
18637	23241	51	-	-	HYPH
18637	23241	52	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	23241	53	securities	security	NNS
18637	23241	54	,	,	,
18637	23241	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23241	56	held	hold	VBD
18637	23241	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23241	58	to	to	TO
18637	23241	59	destroy	destroy	VB
18637	23241	60	a	a	DT
18637	23241	61	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
18637	23241	62	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	23241	63	.	.	.
18637	23242	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23242	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23242	3	See	See	NNP
18637	23242	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23242	5	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	23242	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23242	7	.	.	.
18637	23242	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23243	1	National	National	NNP
18637	23243	2	Life	Life	NNP
18637	23243	3	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	23243	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23243	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23243	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	23243	7	_	_	NNP
18637	23243	8	United	United	NNP
18637	23243	9	States	States	NNP
18637	23243	10	,	,	,
18637	23243	11	277	277	CD
18637	23243	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23243	13	508	508	CD
18637	23243	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23243	15	June	June	NNP
18637	23243	16	4	4	CD
18637	23243	17	,	,	,
18637	23243	18	1928	1928	CD
18637	23243	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23243	20	.	.	.
18637	23244	1	57	57	CD
18637	23244	2	.	.	.
18637	23245	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23245	2	of	of	IN
18637	23245	3	June	June	NNP
18637	23245	4	10	10	CD
18637	23245	5	,	,	,
18637	23245	6	1922	1922	CD
18637	23245	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23245	8	42	42	CD
18637	23245	9	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	23245	10	.	.	.
18637	23246	1	634	634	CD
18637	23246	2	,	,	,
18637	23246	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23246	4	.	.	.
18637	23247	1	216	216	CD
18637	23247	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23247	3	.	.	.
18637	23248	1	A	a	DT
18637	23248	2	second	second	JJ
18637	23248	3	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	23248	4	to	to	TO
18637	23248	5	amend	amend	VB
18637	23248	6	sections	section	NNS
18637	23248	7	24	24	CD
18637	23248	8	and	and	CC
18637	23248	9	256	256	CD
18637	23248	10	of	of	IN
18637	23248	11	the	the	DT
18637	23248	12	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	23248	13	Code	Code	NNP
18637	23248	14	,	,	,
18637	23248	15	relating	relate	VBG
18637	23248	16	to	to	IN
18637	23248	17	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	23248	18	of	of	IN
18637	23248	19	district	district	NN
18637	23248	20	courts	court	NNS
18637	23248	21	,	,	,
18637	23248	22	by	by	IN
18637	23248	23	saving	save	VBG
18637	23248	24	"	"	''
18637	23248	25	to	to	IN
18637	23248	26	claimants	claimant	NNS
18637	23248	27	for	for	IN
18637	23248	28	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	23248	29	for	for	IN
18637	23248	30	injuries	injury	NNS
18637	23248	31	to	to	IN
18637	23248	32	or	or	CC
18637	23248	33	death	death	NN
18637	23248	34	of	of	IN
18637	23248	35	persons	person	NNS
18637	23248	36	other	other	JJ
18637	23248	37	than	than	IN
18637	23248	38	the	the	DT
18637	23248	39	master	master	NN
18637	23248	40	or	or	CC
18637	23248	41	members	member	NNS
18637	23248	42	of	of	IN
18637	23248	43	the	the	DT
18637	23248	44	crew	crew	NN
18637	23248	45	of	of	IN
18637	23248	46	a	a	DT
18637	23248	47	vessel	vessel	NN
18637	23248	48	,	,	,
18637	23248	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23248	50	rights	right	NNS
18637	23248	51	and	and	CC
18637	23248	52	remedies	remedy	NNS
18637	23248	53	under	under	IN
18637	23248	54	the	the	DT
18637	23248	55	workmen	workman	NNS
18637	23248	56	's	's	POS
18637	23248	57	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	23248	58	law	law	NN
18637	23248	59	of	of	IN
18637	23248	60	any	any	DT
18637	23248	61	State	state	NN
18637	23248	62	*	*	NFP
18637	23248	63	*	*	NFP
18637	23248	64	*	*	NFP
18637	23248	65	"	"	``
18637	23248	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23248	67	held	hold	VBD
18637	23248	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23248	69	invalid	invalid	NNP
18637	23248	70	on	on	IN
18637	23248	71	authority	authority	NN
18637	23248	72	of	of	IN
18637	23248	73	Knickerbocker	Knickerbocker	NNP
18637	23248	74	Ice	Ice	NNP
18637	23248	75	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23248	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23248	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	23248	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23248	79	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	23248	80	.	.	.
18637	23249	1	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	23249	2	Accident	Accident	NNP
18637	23249	3	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23249	4	of	of	IN
18637	23249	5	California	California	NNP
18637	23249	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23249	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	23249	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23249	9	Rolph	Rolph	NNP
18637	23249	10	et	et	NNP
18637	23249	11	al	al	NNP
18637	23249	12	.	.	NNP
18637	23249	13	,	,	,
18637	23249	14	and	and	CC
18637	23249	15	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	23249	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23249	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23249	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23249	19	Dawson	Dawson	NNP
18637	23249	20	&	&	CC
18637	23249	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23249	22	,	,	,
18637	23249	23	264	264	CD
18637	23249	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23249	25	219	219	CD
18637	23249	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23249	27	February	February	NNP
18637	23249	28	25	25	CD
18637	23249	29	,	,	,
18637	23249	30	1924	1924	CD
18637	23249	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23249	32	.	.	.
18637	23250	1	58	58	CD
18637	23250	2	.	.	.
18637	23251	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23251	2	of	of	IN
18637	23251	3	June	June	NNP
18637	23251	4	2	2	CD
18637	23251	5	,	,	,
18637	23251	6	1924	1924	CD
18637	23251	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23251	8	43	43	CD
18637	23251	9	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	23251	10	.	.	.
18637	23252	1	313	313	CD
18637	23252	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23252	3	.	.	.
18637	23253	1	The	the	DT
18637	23253	2	gift	gift	NN
18637	23253	3	tax	tax	NN
18637	23253	4	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	23253	5	of	of	IN
18637	23253	6	the	the	DT
18637	23253	7	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	23253	8	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23253	9	of	of	IN
18637	23253	10	1924	1924	CD
18637	23253	11	,	,	,
18637	23253	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23253	13	held	hold	VBD
18637	23253	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23253	15	invalid	invalid	NN
18637	23253	16	under	under	IN
18637	23253	17	the	the	DT
18637	23253	18	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	23253	19	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23253	20	as	as	IN
18637	23253	21	applied	apply	VBN
18637	23253	22	to	to	IN
18637	23253	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23253	24	bona	bona	JJ
18637	23253	25	fide	fide	FW
18637	23253	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23253	27	gifts	gift	NNS
18637	23253	28	made	make	VBN
18637	23253	29	before	before	IN
18637	23253	30	passage	passage	NN
18637	23253	31	of	of	IN
18637	23253	32	the	the	DT
18637	23253	33	act	act	NN
18637	23253	34	.	.	.
18637	23254	1	Untermeyer	Untermeyer	NNP
18637	23254	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23254	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23254	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23254	5	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	23254	6	,	,	,
18637	23254	7	276	276	CD
18637	23254	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23254	9	440	440	CD
18637	23254	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23254	11	April	April	NNP
18637	23254	12	9	9	CD
18637	23254	13	,	,	,
18637	23254	14	1928	1928	CD
18637	23254	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23254	16	.	.	.
18637	23255	1	59	59	CD
18637	23255	2	.	.	.
18637	23256	1	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	23256	2	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23256	3	of	of	IN
18637	23256	4	June	June	NNP
18637	23256	5	2	2	CD
18637	23256	6	,	,	,
18637	23256	7	1924	1924	CD
18637	23256	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23256	9	43	43	CD
18637	23256	10	Stat	stat	JJ
18637	23256	11	.	.	.
18637	23257	1	322	322	CD
18637	23257	2	,	,	,
18637	23257	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23257	4	.	.	.
18637	23258	1	600	600	CD
18637	23258	2	,	,	,
18637	23258	3	in	in	IN
18637	23258	4	part	part	NN
18637	23258	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23258	6	.	.	.
18637	23259	1	Excise	excise	VB
18637	23259	2	tax	tax	NN
18637	23259	3	on	on	IN
18637	23259	4	certain	certain	JJ
18637	23259	5	articles	article	NNS
18637	23259	6	"	"	``
18637	23259	7	sold	sell	VBN
18637	23259	8	or	or	CC
18637	23259	9	leased	lease	VBN
18637	23259	10	by	by	IN
18637	23259	11	the	the	DT
18637	23259	12	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
18637	23259	13	"	"	''
18637	23259	14	,	,	,
18637	23259	15	measured	measure	VBN
18637	23259	16	by	by	IN
18637	23259	17	sale	sale	NN
18637	23259	18	price	price	NN
18637	23259	19	[	[	-LRB-
18637	23259	20	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	23259	21	,	,	,
18637	23259	22	"	"	''
18637	23259	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23259	24	2	2	LS
18637	23259	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23259	26	*	*	NFP
18637	23259	27	*	*	NFP
18637	23259	28	*	*	NFP
18637	23259	29	motorcycles	motorcycle	NNS
18637	23259	30	*	*	NFP
18637	23259	31	*	*	NFP
18637	23259	32	*	*	NFP
18637	23259	33	5	5	CD
18637	23259	34	per	per	IN
18637	23259	35	centum"]--as	centum"]--as	NNP
18637	23259	36	applied	apply	VBN
18637	23259	37	to	to	IN
18637	23259	38	sale	sale	NN
18637	23259	39	of	of	IN
18637	23259	40	motorcycle	motorcycle	NN
18637	23259	41	to	to	IN
18637	23259	42	a	a	DT
18637	23259	43	municipality	municipality	NN
18637	23259	44	for	for	IN
18637	23259	45	police	police	NN
18637	23259	46	use	use	NN
18637	23259	47	,	,	,
18637	23259	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23259	49	held	hold	VBD
18637	23259	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23259	51	an	an	DT
18637	23259	52	infringement	infringement	NN
18637	23259	53	of	of	IN
18637	23259	54	State	state	NN
18637	23259	55	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	23259	56	under	under	IN
18637	23259	57	the	the	DT
18637	23259	58	principle	principle	NN
18637	23259	59	of	of	IN
18637	23259	60	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	23259	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23259	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	23259	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23259	64	Day	Day	NNP
18637	23259	65	.	.	.
18637	23260	1	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	23260	2	Motorcycle	Motorcycle	NNP
18637	23260	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23260	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23260	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	23260	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23260	7	United	United	NNP
18637	23260	8	States	States	NNP
18637	23260	9	,	,	,
18637	23260	10	283	283	CD
18637	23260	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23260	12	570	570	CD
18637	23260	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23260	14	May	May	NNP
18637	23260	15	25	25	CD
18637	23260	16	,	,	,
18637	23260	17	1931	1931	CD
18637	23260	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23260	19	.	.	.
18637	23261	1	60	60	CD
18637	23261	2	.	.	.
18637	23262	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23262	2	of	of	IN
18637	23262	3	February	February	NNP
18637	23262	4	26	26	CD
18637	23262	5	,	,	,
18637	23262	6	1926	1926	CD
18637	23262	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23262	8	44	44	CD
18637	23262	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23262	10	.	.	.
18637	23263	1	9	9	CD
18637	23263	2	,	,	,
18637	23263	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23263	4	.	.	.
18637	23264	1	27	27	CD
18637	23264	2	,	,	,
18637	23264	3	in	in	IN
18637	23264	4	part	part	NN
18637	23264	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23264	6	.	.	.
18637	23265	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23265	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23265	3	a	a	DT
18637	23265	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23265	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23265	6	.	.	.
18637	23266	1	Section	section	NN
18637	23266	2	302	302	CD
18637	23266	3	in	in	IN
18637	23266	4	part	part	NN
18637	23266	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23266	6	44	44	CD
18637	23266	7	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23266	8	.	.	.
18637	23267	1	70	70	CD
18637	23267	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23267	3	.	.	.
18637	23268	1	Second	second	JJ
18637	23268	2	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	23268	3	,	,	,
18637	23268	4	defining	define	VBG
18637	23268	5	,	,	,
18637	23268	6	for	for	IN
18637	23268	7	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	23268	8	of	of	IN
18637	23268	9	the	the	DT
18637	23268	10	estate	estate	NN
18637	23268	11	tax	tax	NN
18637	23268	12	,	,	,
18637	23268	13	the	the	DT
18637	23268	14	term	term	NN
18637	23268	15	"	"	``
18637	23268	16	made	make	VBN
18637	23268	17	in	in	IN
18637	23268	18	contemplation	contemplation	NN
18637	23268	19	of	of	IN
18637	23268	20	death	death	NN
18637	23268	21	"	"	''
18637	23268	22	as	as	IN
18637	23268	23	including	include	VBG
18637	23268	24	the	the	DT
18637	23268	25	value	value	NN
18637	23268	26	,	,	,
18637	23268	27	over	over	IN
18637	23268	28	$	$	$
18637	23268	29	5,000	5,000	CD
18637	23268	30	,	,	,
18637	23268	31	of	of	IN
18637	23268	32	property	property	NN
18637	23268	33	transferred	transfer	VBN
18637	23268	34	by	by	IN
18637	23268	35	a	a	DT
18637	23268	36	decedent	decedent	NN
18637	23268	37	,	,	,
18637	23268	38	by	by	IN
18637	23268	39	trust	trust	NN
18637	23268	40	,	,	,
18637	23268	41	etc	etc	FW
18637	23268	42	.	.	FW
18637	23268	43	,	,	,
18637	23268	44	without	without	IN
18637	23268	45	full	full	JJ
18637	23268	46	consideration	consideration	NN
18637	23268	47	in	in	IN
18637	23268	48	money	money	NN
18637	23268	49	or	or	CC
18637	23268	50	money	money	NN
18637	23268	51	's	's	POS
18637	23268	52	worth	worth	JJ
18637	23268	53	,	,	,
18637	23268	54	"	"	''
18637	23268	55	within	within	IN
18637	23268	56	2	2	CD
18637	23268	57	years	year	NNS
18637	23268	58	prior	prior	RB
18637	23268	59	to	to	IN
18637	23268	60	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23268	61	death	death	NN
18637	23268	62	but	but	CC
18637	23268	63	after	after	IN
18637	23268	64	the	the	DT
18637	23268	65	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	23268	66	of	of	IN
18637	23268	67	this	this	DT
18637	23268	68	act	act	NN
18637	23268	69	"	"	''
18637	23268	70	,	,	,
18637	23268	71	although	although	IN
18637	23268	72	"	"	``
18637	23268	73	not	not	RB
18637	23268	74	admitted	admit	VBN
18637	23268	75	or	or	CC
18637	23268	76	shown	show	VBN
18637	23268	77	to	to	TO
18637	23268	78	have	have	VB
18637	23268	79	been	be	VBN
18637	23268	80	made	make	VBN
18637	23268	81	in	in	IN
18637	23268	82	contemplation	contemplation	NN
18637	23268	83	of	of	IN
18637	23268	84	or	or	CC
18637	23268	85	intended	intend	VBN
18637	23268	86	to	to	TO
18637	23268	87	take	take	VB
18637	23268	88	effect	effect	NN
18637	23268	89	in	in	IN
18637	23268	90	possession	possession	NN
18637	23268	91	or	or	CC
18637	23268	92	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	23268	93	at	at	IN
18637	23268	94	or	or	CC
18637	23268	95	after	after	IN
18637	23268	96	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23268	97	death	death	NN
18637	23268	98	"	"	''
18637	23268	99	,	,	,
18637	23268	100	_	_	NNP
18637	23268	101	held	hold	VBD
18637	23268	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23268	103	as	as	IN
18637	23268	104	applied	apply	VBN
18637	23268	105	to	to	IN
18637	23268	106	a	a	DT
18637	23268	107	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	23268	108	completed	complete	VBN
18637	23268	109	wholly	wholly	RB
18637	23268	110	between	between	IN
18637	23268	111	the	the	DT
18637	23268	112	living	living	NN
18637	23268	113	,	,	,
18637	23268	114	spoliation	spoliation	NN
18637	23268	115	without	without	IN
18637	23268	116	due	due	JJ
18637	23268	117	process	process	NN
18637	23268	118	of	of	IN
18637	23268	119	law	law	NN
18637	23268	120	under	under	IN
18637	23268	121	the	the	DT
18637	23268	122	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	23268	123	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23268	124	.	.	.
18637	23269	1	Heiner	Heiner	NNP
18637	23269	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23269	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23269	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23269	5	Donnan	Donnan	NNP
18637	23269	6	,	,	,
18637	23269	7	285	285	CD
18637	23269	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23269	9	312	312	CD
18637	23269	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23269	11	March	March	NNP
18637	23269	12	21	21	CD
18637	23269	13	,	,	,
18637	23269	14	1932	1932	CD
18637	23269	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23269	16	.	.	.
18637	23270	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23270	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23270	3	b	b	NNP
18637	23270	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23270	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23270	6	.	.	.
18637	23271	1	Section	section	NN
18637	23271	2	701	701	CD
18637	23271	3	in	in	IN
18637	23271	4	part	part	NN
18637	23271	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23271	6	44	44	CD
18637	23271	7	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23271	8	.	.	.
18637	23272	1	95	95	CD
18637	23272	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23272	3	.	.	.
18637	23273	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	23273	2	imposing	impose	VBG
18637	23273	3	a	a	DT
18637	23273	4	special	special	JJ
18637	23273	5	excise	excise	NN
18637	23273	6	tax	tax	NN
18637	23273	7	of	of	IN
18637	23273	8	$	$	$
18637	23273	9	1,000	1,000	CD
18637	23273	10	on	on	IN
18637	23273	11	liquor	liquor	NN
18637	23273	12	dealers	dealer	NNS
18637	23273	13	in	in	IN
18637	23273	14	States	States	NNP
18637	23273	15	where	where	WRB
18637	23273	16	such	such	JJ
18637	23273	17	business	business	NN
18637	23273	18	is	be	VBZ
18637	23273	19	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	23273	20	,	,	,
18637	23273	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23273	22	held	hold	VBD
18637	23273	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23273	24	a	a	DT
18637	23273	25	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	23273	26	,	,	,
18637	23273	27	without	without	IN
18637	23273	28	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	23273	29	support	support	NN
18637	23273	30	following	follow	VBG
18637	23273	31	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	23273	32	of	of	IN
18637	23273	33	the	the	DT
18637	23273	34	Eighteenth	Eighteenth	NNP
18637	23273	35	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23273	36	.	.	.
18637	23274	1	United	United	NNP
18637	23274	2	States	States	NNP
18637	23274	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23274	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23274	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23274	6	Constantine	Constantine	NNP
18637	23274	7	,	,	,
18637	23274	8	296	296	CD
18637	23274	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23274	10	287	287	CD
18637	23274	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23274	12	December	December	NNP
18637	23274	13	9	9	CD
18637	23274	14	,	,	,
18637	23274	15	1935	1935	CD
18637	23274	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23274	17	.	.	.
18637	23275	1	61	61	CD
18637	23275	2	.	.	.
18637	23276	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23276	2	of	of	IN
18637	23276	3	March	March	NNP
18637	23276	4	20	20	CD
18637	23276	5	,	,	,
18637	23276	6	1933	1933	CD
18637	23276	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23276	8	48	48	CD
18637	23276	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23276	10	.	.	.
18637	23277	1	11	11	CD
18637	23277	2	,	,	,
18637	23277	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23277	4	.	.	.
18637	23278	1	17	17	CD
18637	23278	2	,	,	,
18637	23278	3	in	in	IN
18637	23278	4	part	part	NN
18637	23278	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23278	6	.	.	.
18637	23279	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	23279	2	in	in	IN
18637	23279	3	the	the	DT
18637	23279	4	Economy	Economy	NNP
18637	23279	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23279	6	of	of	IN
18637	23279	7	1933	1933	CD
18637	23279	8	providing	provide	VBG
18637	23279	9	"	"	``
18637	23279	10	*	*	NFP
18637	23279	11	*	*	NFP
18637	23279	12	*	*	NFP
18637	23279	13	all	all	DT
18637	23279	14	laws	law	NNS
18637	23279	15	granting	grant	VBG
18637	23279	16	or	or	CC
18637	23279	17	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	23279	18	to	to	IN
18637	23279	19	yearly	yearly	JJ
18637	23279	20	renewable	renewable	JJ
18637	23279	21	term	term	NN
18637	23279	22	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	23279	23	are	be	VBP
18637	23279	24	hereby	hereby	RB
18637	23279	25	repealed	repeal	VBN
18637	23279	26	"	"	''
18637	23279	27	,	,	,
18637	23279	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23279	29	held	hold	VBD
18637	23279	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23279	31	invalid	invalid	NNP
18637	23279	32	to	to	TO
18637	23279	33	abrogate	abrogate	VB
18637	23279	34	an	an	DT
18637	23279	35	outstanding	outstanding	JJ
18637	23279	36	contract	contract	NN
18637	23279	37	of	of	IN
18637	23279	38	insurance	insurance	NN
18637	23279	39	,	,	,
18637	23279	40	which	which	WDT
18637	23279	41	is	be	VBZ
18637	23279	42	a	a	DT
18637	23279	43	vested	vested	JJ
18637	23279	44	right	right	NN
18637	23279	45	protected	protect	VBN
18637	23279	46	by	by	IN
18637	23279	47	the	the	DT
18637	23279	48	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	23279	49	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23279	50	.	.	.
18637	23280	1	Lynch	Lynch	NNP
18637	23280	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23280	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23280	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23280	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23280	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23280	7	,	,	,
18637	23280	8	292	292	CD
18637	23280	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23280	10	571	571	CD
18637	23280	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23280	12	June	June	NNP
18637	23280	13	4	4	CD
18637	23280	14	,	,	,
18637	23280	15	1934	1934	CD
18637	23280	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23280	17	.	.	.
18637	23281	1	62	62	CD
18637	23281	2	.	.	.
18637	23282	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23282	2	of	of	IN
18637	23282	3	May	May	NNP
18637	23282	4	12	12	CD
18637	23282	5	,	,	,
18637	23282	6	1933	1933	CD
18637	23282	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23282	8	48	48	CD
18637	23282	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23282	10	.	.	.
18637	23283	1	31	31	CD
18637	23283	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23283	3	.	.	.
18637	23284	1	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	23284	2	Adjustment	Adjustment	NNP
18637	23284	3	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23284	4	providing	provide	VBG
18637	23284	5	for	for	IN
18637	23284	6	processing	process	VBG
18637	23284	7	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	23284	8	on	on	IN
18637	23284	9	agricultural	agricultural	JJ
18637	23284	10	commodities	commodity	NNS
18637	23284	11	and	and	CC
18637	23284	12	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	23284	13	payments	payment	NNS
18637	23284	14	therefrom	therefrom	JJ
18637	23284	15	to	to	IN
18637	23284	16	farmers	farmer	NNS
18637	23284	17	,	,	,
18637	23284	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23284	19	held	hold	VBD
18637	23284	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23284	21	not	not	RB
18637	23284	22	within	within	IN
18637	23284	23	the	the	DT
18637	23284	24	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	23284	25	power	power	NN
18637	23284	26	under	under	IN
18637	23284	27	article	article	NN
18637	23284	28	I	i	NN
18637	23284	29	,	,	,
18637	23284	30	section	section	NN
18637	23284	31	8	8	CD
18637	23284	32	,	,	,
18637	23284	33	clause	clause	NN
18637	23284	34	1	1	CD
18637	23284	35	.	.	.
18637	23285	1	United	United	NNP
18637	23285	2	States	States	NNP
18637	23285	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23285	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23285	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23285	6	Wm	Wm	NNP
18637	23285	7	.	.	.
18637	23286	1	M.	M.	NNP
18637	23286	2	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	23286	3	et	et	NNP
18637	23286	4	al	al	NNP
18637	23286	5	.	.	NNP
18637	23286	6	,	,	,
18637	23286	7	Receivers	Receivers	NNPS
18637	23286	8	of	of	IN
18637	23286	9	Hoosac	Hoosac	NNP
18637	23286	10	Mills	Mills	NNPS
18637	23286	11	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23286	12	,	,	,
18637	23286	13	297	297	CD
18637	23286	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23286	15	1	1	CD
18637	23286	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23286	17	January	January	NNP
18637	23286	18	6	6	CD
18637	23286	19	,	,	,
18637	23286	20	1936	1936	CD
18637	23286	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23286	22	.	.	.
18637	23287	1	63	63	CD
18637	23287	2	.	.	.
18637	23288	1	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	23288	2	Resolution	Resolution	NNP
18637	23288	3	of	of	IN
18637	23288	4	June	June	NNP
18637	23288	5	5	5	CD
18637	23288	6	,	,	,
18637	23288	7	1933	1933	CD
18637	23288	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23288	9	48	48	CD
18637	23288	10	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23288	11	.	.	.
18637	23289	1	113	113	CD
18637	23289	2	,	,	,
18637	23289	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23289	4	.	.	.
18637	23290	1	1	1	LS
18637	23290	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23290	3	.	.	.
18637	23291	1	Abrogation	abrogation	NN
18637	23291	2	of	of	IN
18637	23291	3	gold	gold	NN
18637	23291	4	clause	clause	NN
18637	23291	5	in	in	IN
18637	23291	6	Government	Government	NNP
18637	23291	7	obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	23291	8	,	,	,
18637	23291	9	_	_	NNP
18637	23291	10	held	hold	VBD
18637	23291	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23291	12	a	a	DT
18637	23291	13	repudiation	repudiation	NN
18637	23291	14	of	of	IN
18637	23291	15	the	the	DT
18637	23291	16	pledge	pledge	NN
18637	23291	17	implicit	implicit	NN
18637	23291	18	in	in	IN
18637	23291	19	the	the	DT
18637	23291	20	power	power	NN
18637	23291	21	to	to	TO
18637	23291	22	borrow	borrow	VB
18637	23291	23	money	money	NN
18637	23291	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23291	25	art	art	NN
18637	23291	26	.	.	.
18637	23292	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	23292	2	,	,	,
18637	23292	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23292	4	.	.	.
18637	23293	1	8	8	CD
18637	23293	2	,	,	,
18637	23293	3	clause	clause	NN
18637	23293	4	2	2	CD
18637	23293	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23293	6	,	,	,
18637	23293	7	and	and	CC
18637	23293	8	within	within	IN
18637	23293	9	the	the	DT
18637	23293	10	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	23293	11	of	of	IN
18637	23293	12	the	the	DT
18637	23293	13	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	23293	14	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23293	15	,	,	,
18637	23293	16	against	against	IN
18637	23293	17	questioning	question	VBG
18637	23293	18	the	the	DT
18637	23293	19	validity	validity	NN
18637	23293	20	of	of	IN
18637	23293	21	the	the	DT
18637	23293	22	public	public	JJ
18637	23293	23	debt	debt	NN
18637	23293	24	.	.	.
18637	23294	1	[	[	-LRB-
18637	23294	2	The	the	DT
18637	23294	3	majority	majority	NN
18637	23294	4	of	of	IN
18637	23294	5	the	the	DT
18637	23294	6	Court	Court	NNP
18637	23294	7	,	,	,
18637	23294	8	however	however	RB
18637	23294	9	,	,	,
18637	23294	10	held	hold	VBD
18637	23294	11	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	23294	12	not	not	RB
18637	23294	13	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	23294	14	to	to	TO
18637	23294	15	recover	recover	VB
18637	23294	16	under	under	IN
18637	23294	17	the	the	DT
18637	23294	18	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
18637	23294	19	.	.	.
18637	23294	20	]	]	-RRB-
18637	23295	1	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	23295	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23295	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23295	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23295	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23295	6	,	,	,
18637	23295	7	294	294	CD
18637	23295	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23295	9	330	330	CD
18637	23295	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23295	11	February	February	NNP
18637	23295	12	18	18	CD
18637	23295	13	,	,	,
18637	23295	14	1935	1935	CD
18637	23295	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23295	16	.	.	.
18637	23296	1	64	64	CD
18637	23296	2	.	.	.
18637	23297	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23297	2	of	of	IN
18637	23297	3	June	June	NNP
18637	23297	4	16	16	CD
18637	23297	5	,	,	,
18637	23297	6	1933	1933	CD
18637	23297	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23297	8	48	48	CD
18637	23297	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23297	10	.	.	.
18637	23298	1	195	195	CD
18637	23298	2	,	,	,
18637	23298	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23298	4	.	.	.
18637	23299	1	90	90	CD
18637	23299	2	,	,	,
18637	23299	3	the	the	DT
18637	23299	4	National	National	NNP
18637	23299	5	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	23299	6	Recovery	Recovery	NNP
18637	23299	7	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23299	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23299	9	.	.	.
18637	23300	1	A.	A.	NNP
18637	23301	1	Title	Title	NNP
18637	23301	2	I	I	NNP
18637	23301	3	,	,	,
18637	23301	4	except	except	IN
18637	23301	5	section	section	NN
18637	23301	6	9	9	CD
18637	23301	7	.	.	.
18637	23302	1	Provisions	provision	NNS
18637	23302	2	relating	relate	VBG
18637	23302	3	to	to	IN
18637	23302	4	codes	code	NNS
18637	23302	5	of	of	IN
18637	23302	6	fair	fair	JJ
18637	23302	7	competition	competition	NN
18637	23302	8	,	,	,
18637	23302	9	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	23302	10	to	to	TO
18637	23302	11	be	be	VB
18637	23302	12	approved	approve	VBN
18637	23302	13	by	by	IN
18637	23302	14	the	the	DT
18637	23302	15	President	President	NNP
18637	23302	16	in	in	IN
18637	23302	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23302	18	discretion	discretion	NN
18637	23302	19	"	"	''
18637	23302	20	to	to	TO
18637	23302	21	effectuate	effectuate	VB
18637	23302	22	the	the	DT
18637	23302	23	policy	policy	NN
18637	23302	24	"	"	''
18637	23302	25	of	of	IN
18637	23302	26	the	the	DT
18637	23302	27	act	act	NN
18637	23302	28	,	,	,
18637	23302	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23302	30	held	hold	VBD
18637	23302	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23302	32	invalid	invalid	NN
18637	23302	33	as	as	IN
18637	23302	34	a	a	DT
18637	23302	35	grant	grant	NN
18637	23302	36	of	of	IN
18637	23302	37	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	23302	38	power	power	NN
18637	23302	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23302	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23302	41	see	see	VBP
18637	23302	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23302	43	art	art	NN
18637	23302	44	.	.	.
18637	23303	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	23303	2	,	,	,
18637	23303	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23303	4	.	.	.
18637	23304	1	1	1	LS
18637	23304	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23304	3	and	and	CC
18637	23304	4	not	not	RB
18637	23304	5	within	within	IN
18637	23304	6	the	the	DT
18637	23304	7	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	23304	8	power	power	NN
18637	23304	9	.	.	.
18637	23305	1	Schechter	Schechter	NNP
18637	23305	2	Poultry	Poultry	NNP
18637	23305	3	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23305	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23305	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	23305	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23305	7	United	United	NNP
18637	23305	8	States	States	NNP
18637	23305	9	,	,	,
18637	23305	10	295	295	CD
18637	23305	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23305	12	495	495	CD
18637	23305	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23305	14	May	May	NNP
18637	23305	15	27	27	CD
18637	23305	16	,	,	,
18637	23305	17	1935	1935	CD
18637	23305	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23305	19	.	.	.
18637	23306	1	B.	B.	NNP
18637	23307	1	Section	section	NN
18637	23307	2	9	9	CD
18637	23307	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23307	4	c	c	NN
18637	23307	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23307	6	.	.	.
18637	23308	1	Clause	clause	NN
18637	23308	2	of	of	IN
18637	23308	3	the	the	DT
18637	23308	4	oil	oil	NN
18637	23308	5	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	23308	6	section	section	NN
18637	23308	7	authorizing	authorize	VBG
18637	23308	8	the	the	DT
18637	23308	9	President	President	NNP
18637	23308	10	"	"	''
18637	23308	11	to	to	TO
18637	23308	12	prohibit	prohibit	VB
18637	23308	13	the	the	DT
18637	23308	14	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	23308	15	in	in	IN
18637	23308	16	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	23308	17	*	*	NFP
18637	23308	18	*	*	NFP
18637	23308	19	*	*	NFP
18637	23308	20	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	23308	21	of	of	IN
18637	23308	22	petroleum	petroleum	NNP
18637	23308	23	*	*	NFP
18637	23308	24	*	*	NFP
18637	23308	25	*	*	NFP
18637	23308	26	produced	produce	VBN
18637	23308	27	or	or	CC
18637	23308	28	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
18637	23308	29	from	from	IN
18637	23308	30	storage	storage	NN
18637	23308	31	in	in	IN
18637	23308	32	excess	excess	NN
18637	23308	33	of	of	IN
18637	23308	34	the	the	DT
18637	23308	35	amount	amount	NN
18637	23308	36	permitted	permit	VBN
18637	23308	37	*	*	NFP
18637	23308	38	*	*	NFP
18637	23308	39	*	*	NFP
18637	23308	40	by	by	IN
18637	23308	41	any	any	DT
18637	23308	42	State	State	NNP
18637	23308	43	law	law	NN
18637	23308	44	*	*	NFP
18637	23308	45	*	*	NFP
18637	23308	46	*	*	NFP
18637	23308	47	"	"	''
18637	23308	48	and	and	CC
18637	23308	49	prescribing	prescribe	VBG
18637	23308	50	a	a	DT
18637	23308	51	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	23308	52	for	for	IN
18637	23308	53	violation	violation	NN
18637	23308	54	of	of	IN
18637	23308	55	orders	order	NNS
18637	23308	56	issued	issue	VBN
18637	23308	57	thereunder	thereunder	NN
18637	23308	58	,	,	,
18637	23308	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23308	60	held	hold	VBD
18637	23308	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23308	62	invalid	invalid	NN
18637	23308	63	as	as	IN
18637	23308	64	a	a	DT
18637	23308	65	grant	grant	NN
18637	23308	66	of	of	IN
18637	23308	67	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	23308	68	power	power	NN
18637	23308	69	.	.	.
18637	23309	1	Panama	Panama	NNP
18637	23309	2	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	23309	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23309	4	et	et	NNP
18637	23309	5	al	al	NNP
18637	23309	6	.	.	.
18637	23310	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23310	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23310	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23310	4	Ryan	Ryan	NNP
18637	23310	5	et	et	NNP
18637	23310	6	al	al	NNP
18637	23310	7	.	.	.
18637	23311	1	and	and	CC
18637	23311	2	Amazon	Amazon	NNP
18637	23311	3	Petroleum	Petroleum	NNP
18637	23311	4	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23311	5	,	,	,
18637	23311	6	et	et	NNP
18637	23311	7	al	al	NNP
18637	23311	8	.	.	.
18637	23312	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23312	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23312	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23312	4	Ryan	Ryan	NNP
18637	23312	5	et	et	NNP
18637	23312	6	al	al	NNP
18637	23312	7	.	.	NNP
18637	23312	8	,	,	,
18637	23312	9	293	293	CD
18637	23312	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23312	11	388	388	CD
18637	23312	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23312	13	January	January	NNP
18637	23312	14	7	7	CD
18637	23312	15	,	,	,
18637	23312	16	1935	1935	CD
18637	23312	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23312	18	.	.	.
18637	23313	1	65	65	CD
18637	23313	2	.	.	.
18637	23314	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23314	2	of	of	IN
18637	23314	3	June	June	NNP
18637	23314	4	16	16	CD
18637	23314	5	,	,	,
18637	23314	6	1933	1933	CD
18637	23314	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23314	8	48	48	CD
18637	23314	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23314	10	.	.	.
18637	23315	1	307	307	CD
18637	23315	2	,	,	,
18637	23315	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23315	4	.	.	.
18637	23316	1	13	13	CD
18637	23316	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23316	3	.	.	.
18637	23317	1	Temporary	temporary	JJ
18637	23317	2	reduction	reduction	NN
18637	23317	3	of	of	IN
18637	23317	4	15	15	CD
18637	23317	5	percent	percent	NN
18637	23317	6	in	in	IN
18637	23317	7	retired	retire	VBN
18637	23317	8	pay	pay	NN
18637	23317	9	of	of	IN
18637	23317	10	"	"	``
18637	23317	11	judges	judge	NNS
18637	23317	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23317	13	whose	whose	WP$
18637	23317	14	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	23317	15	,	,	,
18637	23317	16	prior	prior	RB
18637	23317	17	to	to	IN
18637	23317	18	retirement	retirement	NN
18637	23317	19	or	or	CC
18637	23317	20	resignation	resignation	NN
18637	23317	21	,	,	,
18637	23317	22	could	could	MD
18637	23317	23	not	not	RB
18637	23317	24	,	,	,
18637	23317	25	under	under	IN
18637	23317	26	the	the	DT
18637	23317	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	23317	28	,	,	,
18637	23317	29	have	have	VBP
18637	23317	30	been	be	VBN
18637	23317	31	diminished	diminish	VBN
18637	23317	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23317	33	"	"	''
18637	23317	34	,	,	,
18637	23317	35	as	as	IN
18637	23317	36	applied	apply	VBN
18637	23317	37	to	to	TO
18637	23317	38	circuit	circuit	NN
18637	23317	39	or	or	CC
18637	23317	40	district	district	NN
18637	23317	41	judges	judge	NNS
18637	23317	42	retired	retire	VBN
18637	23317	43	from	from	IN
18637	23317	44	active	active	JJ
18637	23317	45	service	service	NN
18637	23317	46	,	,	,
18637	23317	47	but	but	CC
18637	23317	48	still	still	RB
18637	23317	49	subject	subject	JJ
18637	23317	50	to	to	TO
18637	23317	51	perform	perform	VB
18637	23317	52	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	23317	53	duties	duty	NNS
18637	23317	54	under	under	IN
18637	23317	55	the	the	DT
18637	23317	56	act	act	NN
18637	23317	57	of	of	IN
18637	23317	58	March	March	NNP
18637	23317	59	1	1	CD
18637	23317	60	,	,	,
18637	23317	61	1929	1929	CD
18637	23317	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23317	63	45	45	CD
18637	23317	64	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23317	65	.	.	.
18637	23318	1	1422	1422	CD
18637	23318	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23318	3	,	,	,
18637	23318	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23318	5	held	hold	VBD
18637	23318	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23318	7	a	a	DT
18637	23318	8	violation	violation	NN
18637	23318	9	of	of	IN
18637	23318	10	the	the	DT
18637	23318	11	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	23318	12	of	of	IN
18637	23318	13	judges	judge	NNS
18637	23318	14	'	'	POS
18637	23318	15	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	23318	16	under	under	IN
18637	23318	17	article	article	NN
18637	23318	18	III	III	NNP
18637	23318	19	,	,	,
18637	23318	20	section	section	NN
18637	23318	21	1	1	CD
18637	23318	22	.	.	.
18637	23319	1	Booth	Booth	NNP
18637	23319	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23319	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23319	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23319	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23319	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23319	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23319	8	together	together	RB
18637	23319	9	with	with	IN
18637	23319	10	Amidon	Amidon	NNP
18637	23319	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23319	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	23319	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23319	14	United	United	NNP
18637	23319	15	States	States	NNP
18637	23319	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23319	17	,	,	,
18637	23319	18	291	291	CD
18637	23319	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23319	20	339	339	CD
18637	23319	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23319	22	February	February	NNP
18637	23319	23	5	5	CD
18637	23319	24	,	,	,
18637	23319	25	1934	1934	CD
18637	23319	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23319	27	.	.	.
18637	23320	1	66	66	CD
18637	23320	2	.	.	.
18637	23321	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23321	2	of	of	IN
18637	23321	3	April	April	NNP
18637	23321	4	27	27	CD
18637	23321	5	,	,	,
18637	23321	6	1934	1934	CD
18637	23321	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23321	8	48	48	CD
18637	23321	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23321	10	.	.	.
18637	23322	1	646	646	CD
18637	23322	2	,	,	,
18637	23322	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23322	4	.	.	.
18637	23323	1	6	6	CD
18637	23323	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23323	3	,	,	,
18637	23323	4	amending	amend	VBG
18637	23323	5	section	section	NN
18637	23323	6	5	5	CD
18637	23323	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23323	8	i	i	NN
18637	23323	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23323	10	of	of	IN
18637	23323	11	Home	Home	NNP
18637	23323	12	Owners	Owners	NNP
18637	23323	13	'	'	POS
18637	23323	14	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	23323	15	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23323	16	of	of	IN
18637	23323	17	1933	1933	CD
18637	23323	18	.	.	.
18637	23324	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	23324	2	for	for	IN
18637	23324	3	conversion	conversion	NN
18637	23324	4	of	of	IN
18637	23324	5	State	State	NNP
18637	23324	6	building	building	NN
18637	23324	7	and	and	CC
18637	23324	8	loan	loan	NN
18637	23324	9	associations	association	NNS
18637	23324	10	into	into	IN
18637	23324	11	federal	federal	JJ
18637	23324	12	associations	association	NNS
18637	23324	13	,	,	,
18637	23324	14	upon	upon	IN
18637	23324	15	vote	vote	NN
18637	23324	16	of	of	IN
18637	23324	17	51	51	CD
18637	23324	18	percent	percent	NN
18637	23324	19	of	of	IN
18637	23324	20	the	the	DT
18637	23324	21	votes	vote	NNS
18637	23324	22	cast	cast	VBN
18637	23324	23	at	at	IN
18637	23324	24	a	a	DT
18637	23324	25	meeting	meeting	NN
18637	23324	26	of	of	IN
18637	23324	27	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	23324	28	called	call	VBD
18637	23324	29	to	to	TO
18637	23324	30	consider	consider	VB
18637	23324	31	such	such	JJ
18637	23324	32	action	action	NN
18637	23324	33	,	,	,
18637	23324	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23324	35	held	hold	VBD
18637	23324	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23324	37	an	an	DT
18637	23324	38	encroachment	encroachment	NN
18637	23324	39	on	on	IN
18637	23324	40	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	23324	41	powers	power	NNS
18637	23324	42	of	of	IN
18637	23324	43	State	State	NNP
18637	23324	44	.	.	.
18637	23325	1	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	23325	2	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23325	3	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	23325	4	&	&	CC
18637	23325	5	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	23325	6	Association	Association	NNP
18637	23325	7	_	_	NNP
18637	23325	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	23325	9	_	_	NNP
18637	23325	10	Cleary	Cleary	NNP
18637	23325	11	,	,	,
18637	23325	12	296	296	CD
18637	23325	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23325	14	315	315	CD
18637	23325	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23325	16	December	December	NNP
18637	23325	17	9	9	CD
18637	23325	18	,	,	,
18637	23325	19	1935	1935	CD
18637	23325	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23325	21	.	.	.
18637	23326	1	67	67	CD
18637	23326	2	.	.	.
18637	23327	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23327	2	of	of	IN
18637	23327	3	May	May	NNP
18637	23327	4	24	24	CD
18637	23327	5	,	,	,
18637	23327	6	1934	1934	CD
18637	23327	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23327	8	48	48	CD
18637	23327	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23327	10	.	.	.
18637	23328	1	798	798	CD
18637	23328	2	,	,	,
18637	23328	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23328	4	.	.	.
18637	23329	1	345	345	CD
18637	23329	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23329	3	.	.	.
18637	23330	1	Provision	provision	NN
18637	23330	2	for	for	IN
18637	23330	3	readjustment	readjustment	NN
18637	23330	4	of	of	IN
18637	23330	5	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	23330	6	indebtedness	indebtedness	NN
18637	23330	7	,	,	,
18637	23330	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23330	9	held	hold	VBD
18637	23330	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23330	11	invalid	invalid	NNP
18637	23330	12	,	,	,
18637	23330	13	though	though	IN
18637	23330	14	"	"	``
18637	23330	15	adequately	adequately	RB
18637	23330	16	related	relate	VBN
18637	23330	17	"	"	''
18637	23330	18	to	to	IN
18637	23330	19	the	the	DT
18637	23330	20	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	23330	21	power	power	NN
18637	23330	22	,	,	,
18637	23330	23	as	as	IN
18637	23330	24	an	an	DT
18637	23330	25	interference	interference	NN
18637	23330	26	with	with	IN
18637	23330	27	State	State	NNP
18637	23330	28	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	23330	29	.	.	.
18637	23331	1	Ashton	Ashton	NNP
18637	23331	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23331	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23331	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23331	5	Cameron	Cameron	NNP
18637	23331	6	County	County	NNP
18637	23331	7	Water	Water	NNP
18637	23331	8	Improvement	Improvement	NNP
18637	23331	9	District	District	NNP
18637	23331	10	No	no	UH
18637	23331	11	.	.	.
18637	23332	1	1	1	CD
18637	23332	2	,	,	,
18637	23332	3	298	298	CD
18637	23332	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23332	5	513	513	CD
18637	23332	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23332	7	May	May	NNP
18637	23332	8	25	25	CD
18637	23332	9	,	,	,
18637	23332	10	1936	1936	CD
18637	23332	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23332	12	.	.	.
18637	23333	1	68	68	CD
18637	23333	2	.	.	.
18637	23334	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23334	2	of	of	IN
18637	23334	3	June	June	NNP
18637	23334	4	27	27	CD
18637	23334	5	,	,	,
18637	23334	6	1934	1934	CD
18637	23334	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23334	8	48	48	CD
18637	23334	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23334	10	.	.	.
18637	23335	1	1283	1283	CD
18637	23335	2	,	,	,
18637	23335	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23335	4	.	.	.
18637	23336	1	868	868	CD
18637	23336	2	entire	entire	JJ
18637	23336	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23336	4	.	.	.
18637	23337	1	The	the	DT
18637	23337	2	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	23337	3	Retirement	Retirement	NNP
18637	23337	4	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23337	5	,	,	,
18637	23337	6	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	23337	7	a	a	DT
18637	23337	8	detailed	detailed	JJ
18637	23337	9	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	23337	10	retirement	retirement	NN
18637	23337	11	system	system	NN
18637	23337	12	for	for	IN
18637	23337	13	employees	employee	NNS
18637	23337	14	of	of	IN
18637	23337	15	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	23337	16	subject	subject	JJ
18637	23337	17	to	to	IN
18637	23337	18	the	the	DT
18637	23337	19	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23337	20	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	23337	21	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23337	22	,	,	,
18637	23337	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23337	24	held	hold	VBD
18637	23337	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23337	26	,	,	,
18637	23337	27	not	not	RB
18637	23337	28	a	a	DT
18637	23337	29	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	23337	30	of	of	IN
18637	23337	31	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	23337	32	within	within	IN
18637	23337	33	the	the	DT
18637	23337	34	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	23337	35	of	of	IN
18637	23337	36	article	article	NN
18637	23337	37	I	i	NN
18637	23337	38	,	,	,
18637	23337	39	section	section	NN
18637	23337	40	8	8	CD
18637	23337	41	,	,	,
18637	23337	42	clause	clause	NN
18637	23337	43	3	3	CD
18637	23337	44	.	.	.
18637	23338	1	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	23338	2	Retirement	Retirement	NNP
18637	23338	3	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23338	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23338	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	23338	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23338	7	Alton	Alton	NNP
18637	23338	8	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	23339	1	et	et	NNP
18637	23339	2	al	al	NNP
18637	23339	3	.	.	NNP
18637	23339	4	,	,	,
18637	23339	5	295	295	CD
18637	23339	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23339	7	330	330	CD
18637	23339	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23339	9	May	May	NNP
18637	23339	10	6	6	CD
18637	23339	11	,	,	,
18637	23339	12	1935	1935	CD
18637	23339	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23339	14	.	.	.
18637	23340	1	69	69	CD
18637	23340	2	.	.	.
18637	23341	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23341	2	of	of	IN
18637	23341	3	June	June	NNP
18637	23341	4	28	28	CD
18637	23341	5	,	,	,
18637	23341	6	1934	1934	CD
18637	23341	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23341	8	48	48	CD
18637	23341	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23341	10	.	.	.
18637	23342	1	1289	1289	CD
18637	23342	2	,	,	,
18637	23342	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23342	4	.	.	.
18637	23343	1	869	869	CD
18637	23343	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23343	3	.	.	.
18637	23344	1	The	the	DT
18637	23344	2	Frazier	Frazier	NNP
18637	23344	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	23344	4	Lemke	Lemke	NNP
18637	23344	5	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23344	6	,	,	,
18637	23344	7	adding	add	VBG
18637	23344	8	subsection	subsection	NN
18637	23344	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23344	10	s	s	NNP
18637	23344	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23344	12	to	to	IN
18637	23344	13	section	section	NN
18637	23344	14	75	75	CD
18637	23344	15	of	of	IN
18637	23344	16	the	the	DT
18637	23344	17	Bankruptcy	Bankruptcy	NNP
18637	23344	18	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23344	19	,	,	,
18637	23344	20	designed	design	VBN
18637	23344	21	to	to	TO
18637	23344	22	preserve	preserve	VB
18637	23344	23	to	to	IN
18637	23344	24	mortgagors	mortgagor	NNS
18637	23344	25	the	the	DT
18637	23344	26	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	23344	27	and	and	CC
18637	23344	28	enjoyment	enjoyment	NN
18637	23344	29	of	of	IN
18637	23344	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	23344	31	farm	farm	NN
18637	23344	32	property	property	NN
18637	23344	33	and	and	CC
18637	23344	34	providing	provide	VBG
18637	23344	35	specifically	specifically	RB
18637	23344	36	,	,	,
18637	23344	37	in	in	IN
18637	23344	38	paragraph	paragraph	NN
18637	23344	39	7	7	CD
18637	23344	40	,	,	,
18637	23344	41	that	that	IN
18637	23344	42	a	a	DT
18637	23344	43	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
18637	23344	44	left	left	NN
18637	23344	45	in	in	IN
18637	23344	46	possession	possession	NN
18637	23344	47	has	have	VBZ
18637	23344	48	the	the	DT
18637	23344	49	option	option	NN
18637	23344	50	at	at	IN
18637	23344	51	any	any	DT
18637	23344	52	time	time	NN
18637	23344	53	within	within	IN
18637	23344	54	5	5	CD
18637	23344	55	years	year	NNS
18637	23344	56	of	of	IN
18637	23344	57	buying	buying	NN
18637	23344	58	at	at	IN
18637	23344	59	the	the	DT
18637	23344	60	appraised	appraise	VBN
18637	23344	61	value	value	NN
18637	23344	62	--	--	:
18637	23344	63	subject	subject	VB
18637	23344	64	meanwhile	meanwhile	RB
18637	23344	65	to	to	IN
18637	23344	66	no	no	DT
18637	23344	67	monetary	monetary	JJ
18637	23344	68	obligation	obligation	NN
18637	23344	69	other	other	JJ
18637	23344	70	than	than	IN
18637	23344	71	payment	payment	NN
18637	23344	72	of	of	IN
18637	23344	73	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
18637	23344	74	rental	rental	NN
18637	23344	75	,	,	,
18637	23344	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23344	77	held	hold	VBD
18637	23344	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23344	79	a	a	DT
18637	23344	80	violation	violation	NN
18637	23344	81	of	of	IN
18637	23344	82	property	property	NN
18637	23344	83	rights	right	NNS
18637	23344	84	,	,	,
18637	23344	85	under	under	IN
18637	23344	86	the	the	DT
18637	23344	87	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	23344	88	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23344	89	.	.	.
18637	23345	1	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	23345	2	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	23345	3	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	23345	4	Land	Land	NNP
18637	23345	5	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23345	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23345	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	23345	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23345	9	Radford	Radford	NNP
18637	23345	10	,	,	,
18637	23345	11	295	295	CD
18637	23345	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23345	13	555	555	CD
18637	23345	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23345	15	May	May	NNP
18637	23345	16	27	27	CD
18637	23345	17	,	,	,
18637	23345	18	1935	1935	CD
18637	23345	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23345	20	.	.	.
18637	23346	1	70	70	CD
18637	23346	2	.	.	.
18637	23347	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23347	2	of	of	IN
18637	23347	3	August	August	NNP
18637	23347	4	24	24	CD
18637	23347	5	,	,	,
18637	23347	6	1935	1935	CD
18637	23347	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23347	8	49	49	CD
18637	23347	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23347	10	.	.	.
18637	23348	1	750	750	CD
18637	23348	2	,	,	,
18637	23348	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23348	4	.	.	.
18637	23349	1	641	641	CD
18637	23349	2	,	,	,
18637	23349	3	title	title	NN
18637	23349	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	23349	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23349	6	.	.	.
18637	23350	1	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	23350	2	Adjustment	Adjustment	NNP
18637	23350	3	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23350	4	amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	23350	5	,	,	,
18637	23350	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23350	7	held	hold	VBD
18637	23350	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23350	9	not	not	RB
18637	23350	10	within	within	IN
18637	23350	11	the	the	DT
18637	23350	12	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	23350	13	power	power	NN
18637	23350	14	.	.	.
18637	23351	1	Rickert	Rickert	NNP
18637	23351	2	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	23351	3	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	23351	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23351	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	23351	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23351	7	Fontenot	Fontenot	NNP
18637	23351	8	,	,	,
18637	23351	9	297	297	CD
18637	23351	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23351	11	110	110	CD
18637	23351	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23351	13	January	January	NNP
18637	23351	14	13	13	CD
18637	23351	15	,	,	,
18637	23351	16	1936	1936	CD
18637	23351	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23351	18	.	.	.
18637	23352	1	71	71	CD
18637	23352	2	.	.	.
18637	23353	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23353	2	of	of	IN
18637	23353	3	August	August	NNP
18637	23353	4	30	30	CD
18637	23353	5	,	,	,
18637	23353	6	1935	1935	CD
18637	23353	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23353	8	49	49	CD
18637	23353	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23353	10	.	.	.
18637	23354	1	991	991	CD
18637	23354	2	,	,	,
18637	23354	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23354	4	.	.	.
18637	23355	1	824	824	CD
18637	23355	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23355	3	.	.	.
18637	23356	1	Bituminous	Bituminous	NNP
18637	23356	2	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	23356	3	Conservation	Conservation	NNP
18637	23356	4	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23356	5	of	of	IN
18637	23356	6	1935	1935	CD
18637	23356	7	,	,	,
18637	23356	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23356	9	held	hold	VBD
18637	23356	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23356	11	to	to	TO
18637	23356	12	impose	impose	VB
18637	23356	13	not	not	RB
18637	23356	14	a	a	DT
18637	23356	15	tax	tax	NN
18637	23356	16	within	within	IN
18637	23356	17	article	article	NN
18637	23356	18	I	i	NN
18637	23356	19	,	,	,
18637	23356	20	section	section	NN
18637	23356	21	8	8	CD
18637	23356	22	,	,	,
18637	23356	23	but	but	CC
18637	23356	24	a	a	DT
18637	23356	25	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	23356	26	not	not	RB
18637	23356	27	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	23356	28	by	by	IN
18637	23356	29	the	the	DT
18637	23356	30	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	23356	31	clause	clause	NN
18637	23356	32	.	.	.
18637	23357	1	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	23357	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23357	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23357	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23357	5	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	23357	6	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	23357	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23357	8	,	,	,
18637	23357	9	298	298	CD
18637	23357	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23357	11	238	238	CD
18637	23357	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23357	13	May	May	NNP
18637	23357	14	18	18	CD
18637	23357	15	,	,	,
18637	23357	16	1936	1936	CD
18637	23357	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23357	18	.	.	.
18637	23358	1	72	72	CD
18637	23358	2	.	.	.
18637	23359	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23359	2	of	of	IN
18637	23359	3	June	June	NNP
18637	23359	4	30	30	CD
18637	23359	5	,	,	,
18637	23359	6	1938	1938	CD
18637	23359	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23359	8	52	52	CD
18637	23359	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23359	10	.	.	.
18637	23360	1	1251	1251	CD
18637	23360	2	,	,	,
18637	23360	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23360	4	.	.	.
18637	23361	1	850	850	CD
18637	23361	2	,	,	,
18637	23361	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23361	4	.	.	.
18637	23362	1	2	2	CD
18637	23362	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23362	3	f	f	NNP
18637	23362	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23362	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23362	6	.	.	.
18637	23363	1	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23363	2	Firearms	Firearms	NNPS
18637	23363	3	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23363	4	,	,	,
18637	23363	5	section	section	NN
18637	23363	6	2	2	CD
18637	23363	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23363	8	f	f	NN
18637	23363	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23363	10	,	,	,
18637	23363	11	establishing	establish	VBG
18637	23363	12	a	a	DT
18637	23363	13	presumption	presumption	NN
18637	23363	14	of	of	IN
18637	23363	15	guilt	guilt	NN
18637	23363	16	based	base	VBN
18637	23363	17	on	on	IN
18637	23363	18	a	a	DT
18637	23363	19	prior	prior	JJ
18637	23363	20	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	23363	21	and	and	CC
18637	23363	22	present	present	JJ
18637	23363	23	possession	possession	NN
18637	23363	24	of	of	IN
18637	23363	25	a	a	DT
18637	23363	26	firearm	firearm	NN
18637	23363	27	,	,	,
18637	23363	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23363	29	held	hold	VBD
18637	23363	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23363	31	to	to	TO
18637	23363	32	violate	violate	VB
18637	23363	33	the	the	DT
18637	23363	34	test	test	NN
18637	23363	35	of	of	IN
18637	23363	36	due	due	JJ
18637	23363	37	process	process	NN
18637	23363	38	under	under	IN
18637	23363	39	the	the	DT
18637	23363	40	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	23363	41	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	23363	42	.	.	.
18637	23364	1	Tot	Tot	NNP
18637	23364	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23364	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23364	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23364	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23364	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23364	7	,	,	,
18637	23364	8	319	319	CD
18637	23364	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23364	10	463	463	CD
18637	23364	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23364	12	June	June	NNP
18637	23364	13	7	7	CD
18637	23364	14	,	,	,
18637	23364	15	1943	1943	CD
18637	23364	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23364	17	.	.	.
18637	23365	1	73	73	CD
18637	23365	2	.	.	.
18637	23366	1	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23366	2	of	of	IN
18637	23366	3	November	November	NNP
18637	23366	4	15	15	CD
18637	23366	5	,	,	,
18637	23366	6	1943	1943	CD
18637	23366	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23366	8	57	57	CD
18637	23366	9	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	23366	10	.	.	.
18637	23367	1	450	450	CD
18637	23367	2	,	,	,
18637	23367	3	ch	ch	NN
18637	23367	4	.	.	.
18637	23368	1	218	218	CD
18637	23368	2	,	,	,
18637	23368	3	sec	sec	NNP
18637	23368	4	.	.	.
18637	23369	1	304	304	CD
18637	23369	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23369	3	.	.	.
18637	23370	1	Urgent	Urgent	NNP
18637	23370	2	Deficiency	Deficiency	NNP
18637	23370	3	Appropriation	Appropriation	NNP
18637	23370	4	Act	Act	NNP
18637	23370	5	of	of	IN
18637	23370	6	1943	1943	CD
18637	23370	7	,	,	,
18637	23370	8	section	section	NN
18637	23370	9	304	304	CD
18637	23370	10	,	,	,
18637	23370	11	providing	provide	VBG
18637	23370	12	that	that	IN
18637	23370	13	no	no	DT
18637	23370	14	salary	salary	NN
18637	23370	15	should	should	MD
18637	23370	16	be	be	VB
18637	23370	17	paid	pay	VBN
18637	23370	18	to	to	IN
18637	23370	19	certain	certain	JJ
18637	23370	20	,	,	,
18637	23370	21	named	name	VBN
18637	23370	22	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23370	23	employees	employee	NNS
18637	23370	24	out	out	IN
18637	23370	25	of	of	IN
18637	23370	26	moneys	money	NNS
18637	23370	27	appropriated	appropriate	VBN
18637	23370	28	,	,	,
18637	23370	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23370	30	held	hold	VBD
18637	23370	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23370	32	to	to	TO
18637	23370	33	violate	violate	VB
18637	23370	34	article	article	NN
18637	23370	35	I	i	NN
18637	23370	36	,	,	,
18637	23370	37	section	section	NN
18637	23370	38	9	9	CD
18637	23370	39	,	,	,
18637	23370	40	clause	clause	NN
18637	23370	41	3	3	CD
18637	23370	42	,	,	,
18637	23370	43	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	23370	44	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	23370	45	of	of	IN
18637	23370	46	bill	bill	NN
18637	23370	47	of	of	IN
18637	23370	48	attainder	attainder	NNP
18637	23370	49	or	or	CC
18637	23370	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23370	51	ex	ex	FW
18637	23370	52	post	post	FW
18637	23370	53	facto	facto	FW
18637	23370	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23370	55	law	law	NN
18637	23370	56	.	.	.
18637	23371	1	United	United	NNP
18637	23371	2	States	States	NNP
18637	23371	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23371	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23371	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23371	6	Lovett	Lovett	NNP
18637	23371	7	,	,	,
18637	23371	8	328	328	CD
18637	23371	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23371	10	303	303	CD
18637	23371	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23371	12	June	June	NNP
18637	23371	13	3	3	CD
18637	23371	14	,	,	,
18637	23371	15	1946	1946	CD
18637	23371	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23371	17	.	.	.
18637	23372	1	TABLE	TABLE	NNS
18637	23372	2	OF	of	IN
18637	23372	3	CASES	case	NNS
18637	23372	4	A	a	DT
18637	23372	5	Abby	Abby	NNP
18637	23372	6	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	23372	7	,	,	,
18637	23372	8	The	the	DT
18637	23372	9	,	,	,
18637	23372	10	223	223	CD
18637	23372	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23372	12	166	166	CD
18637	23372	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23372	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	23372	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23372	16	,	,	,
18637	23372	17	162	162	CD
18637	23372	18	Abie	Abie	NNP
18637	23372	19	State	State	NNP
18637	23372	20	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23372	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23372	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	23372	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23372	24	Bryan	Bryan	NNP
18637	23372	25	,	,	,
18637	23372	26	282	282	CD
18637	23372	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23372	28	765	765	CD
18637	23372	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23372	30	1931	1931	CD
18637	23372	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23372	32	,	,	,
18637	23372	33	983	983	CD
18637	23372	34	,	,	,
18637	23372	35	1020	1020	CD
18637	23372	36	Ableman	Ableman	NNP
18637	23372	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23372	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	23372	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23372	40	Booth	Booth	NNP
18637	23372	41	,	,	,
18637	23372	42	21	21	CD
18637	23372	43	How	how	WRB
18637	23372	44	.	.	.
18637	23373	1	506	506	CD
18637	23373	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23373	3	1859	1859	CD
18637	23373	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23373	5	,	,	,
18637	23373	6	555	555	CD
18637	23373	7	,	,	,
18637	23373	8	625	625	CD
18637	23373	9	,	,	,
18637	23373	10	631	631	CD
18637	23373	11	,	,	,
18637	23373	12	696	696	CD
18637	23373	13	,	,	,
18637	23373	14	728	728	CD
18637	23373	15	Abrams	Abrams	NNP
18637	23373	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23373	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	19	United	United	NNP
18637	23373	20	States	States	NNP
18637	23373	21	,	,	,
18637	23373	22	250	250	CD
18637	23373	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23373	24	616	616	CD
18637	23373	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23373	26	1919	1919	CD
18637	23373	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23373	28	,	,	,
18637	23373	29	297	297	CD
18637	23373	30	,	,	,
18637	23373	31	774	774	CD
18637	23373	32	,	,	,
18637	23373	33	775	775	CD
18637	23373	34	,	,	,
18637	23373	35	794	794	CD
18637	23373	36	,	,	,
18637	23373	37	991	991	CD
18637	23373	38	Adair	Adair	NNP
18637	23373	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23373	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	42	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23373	43	of	of	IN
18637	23373	44	America	America	NNP
18637	23373	45	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	23373	46	.	.	.
18637	23373	47	,	,	,
18637	23373	48	303	303	CD
18637	23373	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23373	50	350	350	CD
18637	23373	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23373	52	1938	1938	CD
18637	23373	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23373	54	,	,	,
18637	23373	55	263	263	CD
18637	23373	56	Adair	Adair	NNP
18637	23373	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	23373	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	60	United	United	NNP
18637	23373	61	States	States	NNP
18637	23373	62	,	,	,
18637	23373	63	208	208	CD
18637	23373	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23373	65	161	161	CD
18637	23373	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23373	67	1908	1908	CD
18637	23373	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23373	69	,	,	,
18637	23373	70	141	141	CD
18637	23373	71	,	,	,
18637	23373	72	846	846	CD
18637	23373	73	,	,	,
18637	23373	74	854	854	CD
18637	23373	75	Adam	Adam	NNP
18637	23373	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	23373	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	79	Saenger	Saenger	NNP
18637	23373	80	,	,	,
18637	23373	81	303	303	CD
18637	23373	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23373	83	59	59	CD
18637	23373	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23373	85	1904	1904	CD
18637	23373	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23373	87	,	,	,
18637	23373	88	570	570	CD
18637	23373	89	,	,	,
18637	23373	90	659	659	CD
18637	23373	91	,	,	,
18637	23373	92	1073	1073	CD
18637	23373	93	,	,	,
18637	23373	94	1090	1090	CD
18637	23373	95	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	23373	96	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	23373	98	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	99	Bellaire	Bellaire	NNP
18637	23373	100	Stamping	Stamping	NNP
18637	23373	101	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23373	102	,	,	,
18637	23373	103	141	141	CD
18637	23373	104	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23373	105	539	539	CD
18637	23373	106	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23373	107	1891	1891	CD
18637	23373	108	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23373	109	,	,	,
18637	23373	110	273	273	CD
18637	23373	111	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	23373	112	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	23373	114	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	115	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	23373	116	,	,	,
18637	23373	117	228	228	CD
18637	23373	118	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23373	119	572	572	CD
18637	23373	120	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23373	121	1913	1913	CD
18637	23373	122	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23373	123	,	,	,
18637	23373	124	1030	1030	CD
18637	23373	125	,	,	,
18637	23373	126	1154	1154	CD
18637	23373	127	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	23373	128	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	129	v.	v.	IN
18637	23373	130	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	131	New	New	NNP
18637	23373	132	York	York	NNP
18637	23373	133	,	,	,
18637	23373	134	192	192	CD
18637	23373	135	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23373	136	585	585	CD
18637	23373	137	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23373	138	1904	1904	CD
18637	23373	139	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23373	140	,	,	,
18637	23373	141	831	831	CD
18637	23373	142	,	,	,
18637	23373	143	1166	1166	CD
18637	23373	144	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	23373	145	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	146	v.	v.	IN
18637	23373	147	_	_	NNP
18637	23373	148	Storey	Storey	NNP
18637	23373	149	,	,	,
18637	23373	150	1	1	CD
18637	23373	151	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	23373	152	.	.	.
18637	23374	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	23374	2	.	.	.
18637	23375	1	No	no	UH
18637	23375	2	.	.	.
18637	23376	1	66	66	CD
18637	23376	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23376	3	1817	1817	CD
18637	23376	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23376	5	,	,	,
18637	23376	6	262	262	CD
18637	23376	7	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	23376	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23376	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23376	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23376	11	Tanner	Tanner	NNP
18637	23376	12	,	,	,
18637	23376	13	244	244	CD
18637	23376	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23376	15	590	590	CD
18637	23376	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23376	17	1917	1917	CD
18637	23376	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23376	19	,	,	,
18637	23376	20	1023	1023	CD
18637	23376	21	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	23376	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23376	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23376	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23376	25	United	United	NNP
18637	23376	26	States	States	NNP
18637	23376	27	,	,	,
18637	23376	28	317	317	CD
18637	23376	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23376	30	269,(1942	269,(1942	CD
18637	23376	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23376	32	,	,	,
18637	23376	33	314	314	CD
18637	23376	34	,	,	,
18637	23376	35	885	885	CD
18637	23376	36	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	23376	37	Express	Express	NNP
18637	23376	38	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23376	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23376	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23376	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23376	42	Croninger	Croninger	NNP
18637	23376	43	,	,	,
18637	23376	44	226	226	CD
18637	23376	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23376	46	491	491	CD
18637	23376	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23376	48	1913	1913	CD
18637	23376	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23376	50	,	,	,
18637	23376	51	247	247	CD
18637	23376	52	,	,	,
18637	23376	53	1015	1015	CD
18637	23376	54	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	23376	55	Express	Express	NNP
18637	23376	56	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23376	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23376	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	23376	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23376	60	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23376	61	,	,	,
18637	23376	62	238	238	CD
18637	23376	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23376	64	190	190	CD
18637	23376	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23376	66	1915	1915	CD
18637	23376	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23376	68	,	,	,
18637	23376	69	219	219	CD
18637	23376	70	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	23376	71	Express	Express	NNP
18637	23376	72	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23376	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23376	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	23376	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23376	76	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	23376	77	,	,	,
18637	23376	78	165	165	CD
18637	23376	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23376	80	194	194	CD
18637	23376	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23376	82	1897	1897	CD
18637	23376	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23376	84	,	,	,
18637	23376	85	200	200	CD
18637	23376	86	,	,	,
18637	23376	87	201	201	CD
18637	23376	88	,	,	,
18637	23376	89	1050	1050	CD
18637	23376	90	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	23376	91	Express	Express	NNP
18637	23376	92	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23376	93	_	_	NNP
18637	23376	94	v.	v.	IN
18637	23376	95	_	_	NNP
18637	23376	96	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	23376	97	,	,	,
18637	23376	98	166	166	CD
18637	23376	99	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23376	100	185	185	CD
18637	23376	101	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23376	102	1897	1897	CD
18637	23376	103	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23376	104	,	,	,
18637	23376	105	201	201	CD
18637	23376	106	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	23376	107	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23376	108	.	.	.
18637	23377	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23377	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23377	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	5	Storen	Storen	NNP
18637	23377	6	,	,	,
18637	23377	7	304	304	CD
18637	23377	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23377	9	307	307	CD
18637	23377	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23377	11	1938	1938	CD
18637	23377	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23377	13	,	,	,
18637	23377	14	195	195	CD
18637	23377	15	,	,	,
18637	23377	16	204	204	CD
18637	23377	17	,	,	,
18637	23377	18	207	207	CD
18637	23377	19	Adamson	Adamson	NNP
18637	23377	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	23377	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	23	California	California	NNP
18637	23377	24	,	,	,
18637	23377	25	332	332	CD
18637	23377	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23377	27	46	46	CD
18637	23377	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23377	29	1947	1947	CD
18637	23377	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23377	31	,	,	,
18637	23377	32	752	752	CD
18637	23377	33	,	,	,
18637	23377	34	971	971	CD
18637	23377	35	,	,	,
18637	23377	36	1104	1104	CD
18637	23377	37	,	,	,
18637	23377	38	1115	1115	CD
18637	23377	39	,	,	,
18637	23377	40	1116	1116	CD
18637	23377	41	,	,	,
18637	23377	42	1117	1117	CD
18637	23377	43	,	,	,
18637	23377	44	1118	1118	CD
18637	23377	45	,	,	,
18637	23377	46	1122	1122	CD
18637	23377	47	,	,	,
18637	23377	48	1123	1123	CD
18637	23377	49	,	,	,
18637	23377	50	1124	1124	CD
18637	23377	51	Addyston	Addyston	NNP
18637	23377	52	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	23377	53	&	&	CC
18637	23377	54	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	23377	55	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23377	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	23377	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	59	United	United	NNP
18637	23377	60	States	States	NNP
18637	23377	61	,	,	,
18637	23377	62	175	175	CD
18637	23377	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23377	64	211	211	CD
18637	23377	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23377	66	1899	1899	CD
18637	23377	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23377	68	,	,	,
18637	23377	69	146	146	CD
18637	23377	70	,	,	,
18637	23377	71	168	168	CD
18637	23377	72	,	,	,
18637	23377	73	219	219	CD
18637	23377	74	,	,	,
18637	23377	75	855	855	CD
18637	23377	76	Adirondack	Adirondack	NNP
18637	23377	77	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23377	78	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23377	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	23377	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	82	New	New	NNP
18637	23377	83	York	York	NNP
18637	23377	84	,	,	,
18637	23377	85	176	176	CD
18637	23377	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23377	87	335	335	CD
18637	23377	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23377	89	1900	1900	CD
18637	23377	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23377	91	,	,	,
18637	23377	92	344	344	CD
18637	23377	93	Adkins	Adkins	NNPS
18637	23377	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	23377	96	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	97	Children	Children	NNP
18637	23377	98	's	's	POS
18637	23377	99	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	23377	100	,	,	,
18637	23377	101	261	261	CD
18637	23377	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23377	103	525	525	CD
18637	23377	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23377	105	1923	1923	CD
18637	23377	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23377	107	,	,	,
18637	23377	108	303	303	CD
18637	23377	109	,	,	,
18637	23377	110	561	561	CD
18637	23377	111	,	,	,
18637	23377	112	563	563	CD
18637	23377	113	,	,	,
18637	23377	114	846	846	CD
18637	23377	115	,	,	,
18637	23377	116	854	854	CD
18637	23377	117	,	,	,
18637	23377	118	980	980	CD
18637	23377	119	,	,	,
18637	23377	120	988	988	CD
18637	23377	121	,	,	,
18637	23377	122	1159	1159	CD
18637	23377	123	Adler	Adler	NNP
18637	23377	124	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	125	v.	v.	IN
18637	23377	126	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	127	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23377	128	of	of	IN
18637	23377	129	Education	Education	NNP
18637	23377	130	,	,	,
18637	23377	131	342	342	CD
18637	23377	132	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23377	133	485	485	CD
18637	23377	134	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23377	135	1952	1952	CD
18637	23377	136	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23377	137	,	,	,
18637	23377	138	801	801	CD
18637	23377	139	Admiral	Admiral	NNP
18637	23377	140	Peoples	Peoples	NNPS
18637	23377	141	,	,	,
18637	23377	142	The	the	DT
18637	23377	143	,	,	,
18637	23377	144	295	295	CD
18637	23377	145	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23377	146	649	649	CD
18637	23377	147	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23377	148	1935	1935	CD
18637	23377	149	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23377	150	,	,	,
18637	23377	151	575	575	CD
18637	23377	152	Advance	advance	NN
18637	23377	153	-	-	HYPH
18637	23377	154	Rumely	Rumely	NNP
18637	23377	155	Thresher	Thresher	NNP
18637	23377	156	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23377	157	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	158	v.	v.	IN
18637	23377	159	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	160	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	23377	161	,	,	,
18637	23377	162	287	287	CD
18637	23377	163	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23377	164	283	283	CD
18637	23377	165	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23377	166	1932	1932	CD
18637	23377	167	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23377	168	,	,	,
18637	23377	169	1019	1019	CD
18637	23377	170	Aero	Aero	NNP
18637	23377	171	Mayflower	Mayflower	NNP
18637	23377	172	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	23377	173	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23377	174	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	175	v.	v.	IN
18637	23377	176	_	_	NNP
18637	23377	177	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23377	178	of	of	IN
18637	23377	179	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	23378	1	Commrs	Commrs	NNP
18637	23378	2	.	.	NNP
18637	23378	3	,	,	,
18637	23378	4	332	332	CD
18637	23378	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23378	6	495	495	CD
18637	23378	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23378	8	1947	1947	CD
18637	23378	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23378	10	,	,	,
18637	23378	11	212	212	CD
18637	23378	12	Aero	Aero	NNP
18637	23378	13	Mayflower	Mayflower	NNP
18637	23378	14	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	23378	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23378	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23378	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23378	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23378	19	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23378	20	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	23378	21	.	.	.
18637	23379	1	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	23379	2	.	.	.
18637	23380	1	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23380	2	,	,	,
18637	23380	3	295	295	CD
18637	23380	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23380	5	285	285	CD
18637	23380	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23380	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	23380	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23380	9	,	,	,
18637	23380	10	212	212	CD
18637	23380	11	,	,	,
18637	23380	12	1151	1151	CD
18637	23380	13	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	23380	14	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23380	15	.	.	.
18637	23381	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23381	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23381	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23381	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23381	5	Hyde	Hyde	NNP
18637	23381	6	,	,	,
18637	23381	7	275	275	CD
18637	23381	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23381	9	440	440	CD
18637	23381	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23381	11	1928	1928	CD
18637	23381	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23381	13	,	,	,
18637	23381	14	896	896	CD
18637	23381	15	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	23381	16	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23381	17	.	.	.
18637	23382	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23382	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23382	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23382	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23382	5	Kennedy	Kennedy	NNP
18637	23382	6	,	,	,
18637	23382	7	301	301	CD
18637	23382	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23382	9	389	389	CD
18637	23382	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23382	11	1937	1937	CD
18637	23382	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23382	13	,	,	,
18637	23382	14	897	897	CD
18637	23382	15	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	23382	16	Life	Life	NNP
18637	23382	17	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23382	18	.	.	.
18637	23383	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23383	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23383	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23383	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23383	5	Dunken	Dunken	NNP
18637	23383	6	,	,	,
18637	23383	7	266	266	CD
18637	23383	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23383	9	389	389	CD
18637	23383	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23383	11	1924	1924	CD
18637	23383	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23383	13	,	,	,
18637	23383	14	679	679	CD
18637	23383	15	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	23383	16	Life	Life	NNP
18637	23383	17	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23383	18	.	.	.
18637	23384	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23384	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23384	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23384	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23384	5	Haworth	Haworth	NNP
18637	23384	6	,	,	,
18637	23384	7	300	300	CD
18637	23384	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23384	9	227	227	CD
18637	23384	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23384	11	1937	1937	CD
18637	23384	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23384	13	,	,	,
18637	23384	14	514	514	CD
18637	23384	15	,	,	,
18637	23384	16	551	551	CD
18637	23384	17	,	,	,
18637	23384	18	552	552	CD
18637	23384	19	,	,	,
18637	23384	20	553	553	CD
18637	23384	21	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	23384	22	Life	Life	NNP
18637	23384	23	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23384	24	.	.	.
18637	23385	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23385	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23385	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23385	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23385	5	Tremblay	Tremblay	NNP
18637	23385	6	,	,	,
18637	23385	7	223	223	CD
18637	23385	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23385	9	185	185	CD
18637	23385	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23385	11	1912	1912	CD
18637	23385	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23385	13	,	,	,
18637	23385	14	685	685	CD
18637	23385	15	Ager	Ager	NNP
18637	23385	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23385	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23385	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23385	19	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	23385	20	,	,	,
18637	23385	21	105	105	CD
18637	23385	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23385	23	126	126	CD
18637	23385	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23385	25	1882	1882	CD
18637	23385	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23385	27	,	,	,
18637	23385	28	275	275	CD
18637	23385	29	Agnello	Agnello	NNP
18637	23385	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23385	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23385	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23385	33	United	United	NNP
18637	23385	34	States	States	NNP
18637	23385	35	,	,	,
18637	23385	36	269	269	CD
18637	23385	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23385	38	20	20	CD
18637	23385	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23385	40	1925	1925	CD
18637	23385	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23385	42	,	,	,
18637	23385	43	825	825	CD
18637	23385	44	,	,	,
18637	23385	45	828	828	CD
18637	23385	46	Ah	Ah	NNP
18637	23385	47	Sin	Sin	NNP
18637	23385	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23385	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	23385	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23385	51	Wittman	Wittman	NNP
18637	23385	52	,	,	,
18637	23385	53	198	198	CD
18637	23385	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23385	55	500	500	CD
18637	23385	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23385	57	1905	1905	CD
18637	23385	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23385	59	,	,	,
18637	23385	60	1031	1031	CD
18637	23385	61	Aikens	Aikens	NNPS
18637	23385	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23385	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	23385	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23385	65	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	23385	66	,	,	,
18637	23385	67	195	195	CD
18637	23385	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23385	69	194	194	CD
18637	23385	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23385	71	1904	1904	CD
18637	23385	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23385	73	,	,	,
18637	23385	74	1018	1018	CD
18637	23385	75	Akins	Akins	NNP
18637	23385	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23385	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	23385	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23385	79	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23385	80	,	,	,
18637	23385	81	325	325	CD
18637	23385	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23385	83	398	398	CD
18637	23385	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23385	85	1945	1945	CD
18637	23385	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23385	87	,	,	,
18637	23385	88	1168	1168	CD
18637	23385	89	Akron	Akron	NNP
18637	23385	90	C.	C.	NNP
18637	23385	91	&	&	CC
18637	23385	92	Y.R.	Y.R.	NNP
18637	23386	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23386	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23386	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23386	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23386	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23386	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23386	7	,	,	,
18637	23386	8	261	261	CD
18637	23386	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23386	10	184	184	CD
18637	23386	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23386	12	1923	1923	CD
18637	23386	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23386	14	,	,	,
18637	23386	15	861	861	CD
18637	23386	16	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	23386	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23386	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23386	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23386	20	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	23386	21	,	,	,
18637	23386	22	291	291	CD
18637	23386	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23386	24	286	286	CD
18637	23386	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23386	26	1934	1934	CD
18637	23386	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23386	28	,	,	,
18637	23386	29	594	594	CD
18637	23386	30	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	23386	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23386	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	23386	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23386	34	King	King	NNP
18637	23386	35	&	&	CC
18637	23386	36	Boozer	Boozer	NNP
18637	23386	37	,	,	,
18637	23386	38	314	314	CD
18637	23386	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23386	40	1	1	CD
18637	23386	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23386	42	1941	1941	CD
18637	23386	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23386	44	,	,	,
18637	23386	45	731	731	CD
18637	23386	46	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	23386	47	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	23386	48	.	.	.
18637	23387	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23387	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23387	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23387	4	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	23387	5	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23387	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23387	7	,	,	,
18637	23387	8	341	341	CD
18637	23387	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23387	10	341	341	CD
18637	23387	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23387	12	1951	1951	CD
18637	23387	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23387	14	,	,	,
18637	23387	15	934	934	CD
18637	23387	16	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	23387	17	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23387	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23387	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23387	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	23387	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23387	22	Ickes	Ickes	NNP
18637	23387	23	,	,	,
18637	23387	24	302	302	CD
18637	23387	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23387	26	464	464	CD
18637	23387	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23387	28	1938	1938	CD
18637	23387	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23387	30	,	,	,
18637	23387	31	115	115	CD
18637	23387	32	,	,	,
18637	23387	33	542	542	CD
18637	23387	34	,	,	,
18637	23387	35	701	701	CD
18637	23387	36	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	23387	37	State	State	NNP
18637	23387	38	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	23387	39	of	of	IN
18637	23387	40	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	23387	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23387	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	23387	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23387	44	McAdory	McAdory	NNP
18637	23387	45	,	,	,
18637	23387	46	325	325	CD
18637	23387	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23387	48	450	450	CD
18637	23387	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23387	50	1945	1945	CD
18637	23387	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23387	52	,	,	,
18637	23387	53	544	544	CD
18637	23387	54	,	,	,
18637	23387	55	550	550	CD
18637	23387	56	,	,	,
18637	23387	57	553	553	CD
18637	23387	58	,	,	,
18637	23387	59	561	561	CD
18637	23387	60	,	,	,
18637	23387	61	563	563	CD
18637	23387	62	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	23387	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23387	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	23387	65	_	_	NNP
18637	23387	66	Troy	Troy	NNP
18637	23387	67	,	,	,
18637	23387	68	258	258	CD
18637	23387	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23387	70	101	101	CD
18637	23387	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23387	72	1922	1922	CD
18637	23387	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23387	74	,	,	,
18637	23387	75	323	323	NNP
18637	23387	76	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	23387	77	Fish	Fish	NNP
18637	23387	78	Salting	Salting	NNP
18637	23387	79	&	&	CC
18637	23387	80	By	By	NNP
18637	23387	81	-	-	HYPH
18637	23387	82	Products	Products	NNP
18637	23387	83	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23387	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23387	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	23387	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23387	87	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	23387	88	,	,	,
18637	23387	89	255	255	CD
18637	23387	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23387	91	44	44	CD
18637	23387	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23387	93	1921	1921	CD
18637	23387	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23387	95	,	,	,
18637	23387	96	863	863	CD
18637	23387	97	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	23387	98	Packers	Packers	NNP
18637	23387	99	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	23387	100	.	.	.
18637	23388	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23388	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23388	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23388	4	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	23388	5	Acci	Acci	NNP
18637	23388	6	.	.	.
18637	23389	1	Commission	commission	NN
18637	23389	2	,	,	,
18637	23389	3	276	276	CD
18637	23389	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23389	5	467	467	CD
18637	23389	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23389	7	1928	1928	CD
18637	23389	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23389	9	,	,	,
18637	23389	10	581	581	CD
18637	23389	11	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	23389	12	Packers	Packers	NNP
18637	23389	13	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	23389	14	.	.	.
18637	23390	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23390	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23390	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23390	4	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	23390	5	Acci	Acci	NNP
18637	23390	6	.	.	.
18637	23391	1	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23391	2	,	,	,
18637	23391	3	294	294	CD
18637	23391	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23391	5	532	532	CD
18637	23391	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23391	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	23391	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23391	9	,	,	,
18637	23391	10	676	676	CD
18637	23391	11	,	,	,
18637	23391	12	990	990	CD
18637	23391	13	Albrecht	Albrecht	NNP
18637	23391	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23391	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23391	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23391	17	United	United	NNP
18637	23391	18	States	States	NNP
18637	23391	19	,	,	,
18637	23391	20	273	273	CD
18637	23391	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23391	22	1	1	CD
18637	23391	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23391	24	1927	1927	CD
18637	23391	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23391	26	,	,	,
18637	23391	27	825	825	CD
18637	23391	28	,	,	,
18637	23391	29	840	840	CD
18637	23391	30	Albrecht	Albrecht	NNP
18637	23391	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23391	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	23391	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23391	34	United	United	NNP
18637	23391	35	States	States	NNP
18637	23391	36	,	,	,
18637	23391	37	329	329	CD
18637	23391	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23391	39	599	599	CD
18637	23391	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23391	41	1947	1947	CD
18637	23391	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23391	43	,	,	,
18637	23391	44	872	872	CD
18637	23391	45	Algoma	Algoma	NNP
18637	23391	46	Plywood	Plywood	NNP
18637	23391	47	&	&	CC
18637	23391	48	Veneer	Veneer	NNP
18637	23391	49	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23391	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23391	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	23391	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23391	53	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	23391	54	,	,	,
18637	23391	55	336	336	CD
18637	23391	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23391	57	301	301	CD
18637	23391	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23391	59	1949	1949	CD
18637	23391	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23391	61	,	,	,
18637	23391	62	252	252	CD
18637	23391	63	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	23391	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23391	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	23391	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23391	67	Alleghany	Alleghany	NNP
18637	23391	68	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23391	69	,	,	,
18637	23391	70	196	196	CD
18637	23391	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23391	72	458	458	CD
18637	23391	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23391	74	1905	1905	CD
18637	23391	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23391	76	,	,	,
18637	23391	77	676	676	CD
18637	23391	78	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	23391	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23391	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	23391	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23391	82	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23391	83	&	&	CC
18637	23391	84	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	23392	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23392	2	,	,	,
18637	23392	3	114	114	CD
18637	23392	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23392	5	311	311	CD
18637	23392	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23392	7	1885	1885	CD
18637	23392	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23392	9	,	,	,
18637	23392	10	931	931	CD
18637	23392	11	,	,	,
18637	23392	12	933	933	CD
18637	23392	13	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	23392	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23392	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23392	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23392	17	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23392	18	,	,	,
18637	23392	19	166	166	CD
18637	23392	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23392	21	138	138	CD
18637	23392	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23392	23	1897	1897	CD
18637	23392	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23392	25	,	,	,
18637	23392	26	1138	1138	CD
18637	23392	27	,	,	,
18637	23392	28	1140	1140	CD
18637	23392	29	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	23392	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23392	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23392	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23392	33	McKean	McKean	NNP
18637	23392	34	,	,	,
18637	23392	35	1	1	CD
18637	23392	36	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	23392	37	.	.	.
18637	23393	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	23393	2	.	.	.
18637	23394	1	No	no	UH
18637	23394	2	.	.	.
18637	23395	1	229	229	CD
18637	23395	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23395	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	23395	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23395	5	,	,	,
18637	23395	6	344	344	CD
18637	23395	7	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	23395	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23395	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	11	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	23395	12	's	's	POS
18637	23395	13	Palace	Palace	NNP
18637	23395	14	Car	Car	NNP
18637	23395	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23395	16	,	,	,
18637	23395	17	191	191	CD
18637	23395	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23395	19	171	171	CD
18637	23395	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23395	21	1903	1903	CD
18637	23395	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23395	23	,	,	,
18637	23395	24	196	196	CD
18637	23395	25	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	23395	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23395	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	29	Regents	Regents	NNPS
18637	23395	30	of	of	IN
18637	23395	31	University	University	NNP
18637	23395	32	System	System	NNP
18637	23395	33	of	of	IN
18637	23395	34	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23395	35	,	,	,
18637	23395	36	304	304	CD
18637	23395	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23395	38	439	439	CD
18637	23395	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23395	40	1938	1938	CD
18637	23395	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23395	42	,	,	,
18637	23395	43	107	107	CD
18637	23395	44	,	,	,
18637	23395	45	621	621	CD
18637	23395	46	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	23395	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	23395	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	50	Riley	Riley	NNP
18637	23395	51	,	,	,
18637	23395	52	203	203	CD
18637	23395	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23395	54	347	347	CD
18637	23395	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23395	56	1906	1906	CD
18637	23395	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23395	58	,	,	,
18637	23395	59	276	276	CD
18637	23395	60	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	23395	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	23395	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	64	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	23395	65	,	,	,
18637	23395	66	173	173	CD
18637	23395	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23395	68	389	389	CD
18637	23395	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23395	70	1899	1899	CD
18637	23395	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23395	72	,	,	,
18637	23395	73	323	323	CD
18637	23395	74	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	23395	75	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	23395	76	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23395	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	23395	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	80	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23395	81	,	,	,
18637	23395	82	325	325	CD
18637	23395	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23395	84	797	797	CD
18637	23395	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23395	86	1945	1945	CD
18637	23395	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23395	88	,	,	,
18637	23395	89	149	149	CD
18637	23395	90	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	23395	91	-	-	HYPH
18637	23395	92	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	23395	93	Local	Local	NNP
18637	23395	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	23395	96	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	97	Employment	Employment	NNP
18637	23395	98	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	23395	99	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23395	100	,	,	,
18637	23395	101	315	315	CD
18637	23395	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23395	103	740	740	CD
18637	23395	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23395	105	1942	1942	CD
18637	23395	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23395	107	,	,	,
18637	23395	108	250	250	CD
18637	23395	109	Allgeyer	Allgeyer	NNP
18637	23395	110	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	111	v.	v.	IN
18637	23395	112	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	113	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	23395	114	,	,	,
18637	23395	115	165	165	CD
18637	23395	116	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23395	117	578	578	CD
18637	23395	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23395	119	1897	1897	CD
18637	23395	120	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23395	121	,	,	,
18637	23395	122	1021	1021	CD
18637	23395	123	,	,	,
18637	23395	124	1022	1022	CD
18637	23395	125	Alma	Alma	NNP
18637	23395	126	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	23395	127	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23395	128	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	129	v.	v.	IN
18637	23395	130	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	131	Timken	Timken	NNP
18637	23395	132	-	-	HYPH
18637	23395	133	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	23395	134	Axle	Axle	NNP
18637	23395	135	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23395	136	,	,	,
18637	23395	137	329	329	CD
18637	23395	138	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23395	139	129	129	CD
18637	23395	140	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23395	141	1946	1946	CD
18637	23395	142	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23395	143	,	,	,
18637	23395	144	562	562	CD
18637	23395	145	Almy	Almy	NNP
18637	23395	146	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	147	v.	v.	IN
18637	23395	148	_	_	NNP
18637	23395	149	California	California	NNP
18637	23395	150	,	,	,
18637	23395	151	24	24	CD
18637	23395	152	How	how	WRB
18637	23395	153	.	.	.
18637	23396	1	169	169	CD
18637	23396	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23396	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	23396	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23396	5	,	,	,
18637	23396	6	321	321	CD
18637	23396	7	,	,	,
18637	23396	8	364	364	CD
18637	23396	9	Alpha	Alpha	NNP
18637	23396	10	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	23396	11	Cement	Cement	NNP
18637	23396	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23396	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23396	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	23396	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23396	16	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	23396	17	,	,	,
18637	23396	18	268	268	CD
18637	23396	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23396	20	203	203	CD
18637	23396	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23396	22	1925	1925	CD
18637	23396	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23396	24	,	,	,
18637	23396	25	194	194	CD
18637	23396	26	,	,	,
18637	23396	27	202	202	CD
18637	23396	28	,	,	,
18637	23396	29	1050	1050	CD
18637	23396	30	Altman	Altman	NNP
18637	23396	31	&	&	CC
18637	23396	32	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23396	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23396	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	23396	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23396	36	United	United	NNP
18637	23396	37	States	States	NNP
18637	23396	38	,	,	,
18637	23396	39	224	224	CD
18637	23396	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23396	41	583	583	CD
18637	23396	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23396	43	1912	1912	CD
18637	23396	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23396	45	,	,	,
18637	23396	46	442	442	CD
18637	23396	47	Alton	Alton	NNP
18637	23396	48	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23396	49	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23396	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23396	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	23396	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23396	53	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23396	54	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	23396	55	.	.	NNP
18637	23396	56	,	,	,
18637	23396	57	305	305	CD
18637	23396	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23396	59	548	548	CD
18637	23396	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23396	61	1939	1939	CD
18637	23396	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23396	63	,	,	,
18637	23396	64	1012	1012	CD
18637	23396	65	Altvater	Altvater	NNP
18637	23396	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23396	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23396	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23396	69	Freeman	Freeman	NNP
18637	23396	70	,	,	,
18637	23396	71	319	319	CD
18637	23396	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23396	73	359	359	CD
18637	23396	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23396	75	1943	1943	CD
18637	23396	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23396	77	,	,	,
18637	23396	78	553	553	CD
18637	23396	79	Alward	Alward	NNP
18637	23396	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23396	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	23396	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23396	83	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23396	84	,	,	,
18637	23396	85	282	282	CD
18637	23396	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23396	87	509	509	CD
18637	23396	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23396	89	1931	1931	CD
18637	23396	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23396	91	,	,	,
18637	23396	92	731	731	CD
18637	23396	93	,	,	,
18637	23396	94	1151	1151	CD
18637	23396	95	American	American	NNP
18637	23396	96	Communications	Communications	NNP
18637	23396	97	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	23396	98	.	.	.
18637	23397	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23397	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23397	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23397	4	Douds	Douds	NNP
18637	23397	5	,	,	,
18637	23397	6	339	339	CD
18637	23397	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23397	8	382	382	CD
18637	23397	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23397	10	1950	1950	CD
18637	23397	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23397	12	,	,	,
18637	23397	13	794	794	CD
18637	23397	14	American	American	NNP
18637	23397	15	Construction	Construction	NNP
18637	23397	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23397	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23397	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23397	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23397	20	Jacksonville	Jacksonville	NNP
18637	23397	21	T.	T.	NNP
18637	23397	22	&	&	CC
18637	23397	23	K.W.R.	K.W.R.	NNP
18637	23398	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23398	2	,	,	,
18637	23398	3	184	184	CD
18637	23398	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23398	5	372	372	CD
18637	23398	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23398	7	1893	1893	CD
18637	23398	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23398	9	,	,	,
18637	23398	10	616	616	CD
18637	23398	11	American	American	NNP
18637	23398	12	Express	Express	NNP
18637	23398	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23398	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23398	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23398	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23398	17	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	23398	18	,	,	,
18637	23398	19	244	244	CD
18637	23398	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23398	21	617	617	CD
18637	23398	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23398	23	1917	1917	CD
18637	23398	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23398	25	,	,	,
18637	23398	26	136	136	CD
18637	23398	27	,	,	,
18637	23398	28	137	137	CD
18637	23398	29	,	,	,
18637	23398	30	219	219	CD
18637	23398	31	American	American	NNP
18637	23398	32	Express	Express	NNP
18637	23398	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23398	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23398	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23398	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23398	37	Mullins	Mullins	NNP
18637	23398	38	,	,	,
18637	23398	39	212	212	CD
18637	23398	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23398	41	311	311	CD
18637	23398	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23398	43	1909	1909	CD
18637	23398	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23398	45	,	,	,
18637	23398	46	654	654	CD
18637	23398	47	,	,	,
18637	23398	48	656	656	CD
18637	23398	49	,	,	,
18637	23398	50	674	674	CD
18637	23398	51	American	American	NNP
18637	23398	52	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	23398	53	of	of	IN
18637	23398	54	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	23398	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23398	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	23398	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23398	58	American	American	NNP
18637	23398	59	Sash	Sash	NNP
18637	23398	60	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23398	61	,	,	,
18637	23398	62	335	335	CD
18637	23398	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23398	64	538	538	CD
18637	23398	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23398	66	1949	1949	CD
18637	23398	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23398	68	,	,	,
18637	23398	69	680	680	CD
18637	23398	70	,	,	,
18637	23398	71	783	783	CD
18637	23398	72	,	,	,
18637	23398	73	991	991	CD
18637	23398	74	,	,	,
18637	23398	75	993	993	CD
18637	23398	76	American	American	NNP
18637	23398	77	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	23398	78	of	of	IN
18637	23398	79	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	23398	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23398	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	23398	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23398	83	Swing	Swing	NNP
18637	23398	84	,	,	,
18637	23398	85	312	312	CD
18637	23398	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23398	87	321	321	CD
18637	23398	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23398	89	1941	1941	CD
18637	23398	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23398	91	,	,	,
18637	23398	92	782	782	CD
18637	23398	93	American	American	NNP
18637	23398	94	Fire	Fire	NNP
18637	23398	95	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23398	96	.	.	.
18637	23399	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23399	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23399	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23399	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23399	5	King	King	NNP
18637	23399	6	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	23399	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23399	8	,	,	,
18637	23399	9	250	250	CD
18637	23399	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23399	11	2	2	CD
18637	23399	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23399	13	1919	1919	CD
18637	23399	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23399	15	,	,	,
18637	23399	16	680	680	CD
18637	23399	17	American	American	NNP
18637	23399	18	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23399	19	.	.	.
18637	23400	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23400	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23400	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23400	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23400	5	Canter	Canter	NNP
18637	23400	6	,	,	,
18637	23400	7	1	1	CD
18637	23400	8	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23400	9	.	.	.
18637	23401	1	511	511	CD
18637	23401	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23401	3	1828	1828	CD
18637	23401	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23401	5	,	,	,
18637	23401	6	72	72	CD
18637	23401	7	,	,	,
18637	23401	8	73	73	CD
18637	23401	9	,	,	,
18637	23401	10	533	533	CD
18637	23401	11	,	,	,
18637	23401	12	704	704	CD
18637	23401	13	American	American	NNP
18637	23401	14	Land	Land	NNP
18637	23401	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23401	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23401	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23401	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23401	19	Zeiss	Zeiss	NNP
18637	23401	20	,	,	,
18637	23401	21	219	219	CD
18637	23401	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23401	23	47	47	CD
18637	23401	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23401	25	1911	1911	CD
18637	23401	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23401	27	,	,	,
18637	23401	28	1080	1080	CD
18637	23401	29	American	American	NNP
18637	23401	30	Manufacturing	Manufacturing	NNP
18637	23401	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23401	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23401	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23401	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23401	35	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23401	36	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	23401	37	,	,	,
18637	23401	38	250	250	CD
18637	23401	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23401	40	459	459	CD
18637	23401	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23401	42	1919	1919	CD
18637	23401	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23401	44	,	,	,
18637	23401	45	181	181	CD
18637	23401	46	,	,	,
18637	23401	47	1051	1051	CD
18637	23401	48	American	American	NNP
18637	23401	49	Medical	Medical	NNP
18637	23401	50	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	23401	51	.	.	.
18637	23402	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23402	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	4	United	United	NNP
18637	23402	5	States	States	NNP
18637	23402	6	,	,	,
18637	23402	7	317	317	CD
18637	23402	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23402	9	519	519	CD
18637	23402	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23402	11	1943	1943	CD
18637	23402	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23402	13	,	,	,
18637	23402	14	121	121	CD
18637	23402	15	American	American	NNP
18637	23402	16	Mills	Mills	NNPS
18637	23402	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23402	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23402	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	21	American	American	NNP
18637	23402	22	Surety	Surety	NNP
18637	23402	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23402	24	,	,	,
18637	23402	25	260	260	CD
18637	23402	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23402	27	360	360	CD
18637	23402	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23402	29	1922	1922	CD
18637	23402	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23402	31	,	,	,
18637	23402	32	895	895	CD
18637	23402	33	American	American	NNP
18637	23402	34	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23402	35	&	&	CC
18637	23402	36	Light	Light	NNP
18637	23402	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23402	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23402	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	41	Securities	Securities	NNP
18637	23402	42	&	&	CC
18637	23402	43	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	23402	44	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23402	45	,	,	,
18637	23402	46	329	329	CD
18637	23402	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23402	48	90	90	CD
18637	23402	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23402	50	1946	1946	CD
18637	23402	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23402	52	,	,	,
18637	23402	53	75	75	CD
18637	23402	54	,	,	,
18637	23402	55	151	151	CD
18637	23402	56	,	,	,
18637	23402	57	564	564	CD
18637	23402	58	American	American	NNP
18637	23402	59	Publishing	Publishing	NNP
18637	23402	60	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23402	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	23402	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	64	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	23402	65	,	,	,
18637	23402	66	166	166	CD
18637	23402	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23402	68	464	464	CD
18637	23402	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23402	70	1897	1897	CD
18637	23402	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23402	72	,	,	,
18637	23402	73	892	892	CD
18637	23402	74	American	American	NNP
18637	23402	75	School	School	NNP
18637	23402	76	of	of	IN
18637	23402	77	Magnetic	Magnetic	NNP
18637	23402	78	Healing	Healing	NNP
18637	23402	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	23402	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	82	McAnnulty	McAnnulty	NNP
18637	23402	83	,	,	,
18637	23402	84	187	187	CD
18637	23402	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23402	86	94	94	CD
18637	23402	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23402	88	1902	1902	CD
18637	23402	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23402	90	,	,	,
18637	23402	91	860	860	CD
18637	23402	92	American	American	NNP
18637	23402	93	Seeding	Seeding	NNP
18637	23402	94	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	23402	95	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23402	96	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	23402	98	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	99	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23402	100	,	,	,
18637	23402	101	236	236	CD
18637	23402	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23402	103	660	660	CD
18637	23402	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23402	105	1915	1915	CD
18637	23402	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23402	107	,	,	,
18637	23402	108	1017	1017	CD
18637	23402	109	American	American	NNP
18637	23402	110	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	23402	111	&	&	CC
18637	23402	112	Wire	Wire	NNP
18637	23402	113	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23402	114	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	115	v.	v.	IN
18637	23402	116	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	117	Speed	Speed	NNP
18637	23402	118	,	,	,
18637	23402	119	192	192	CD
18637	23402	120	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23402	121	500	500	CD
18637	23402	122	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23402	123	1904	1904	CD
18637	23402	124	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23402	125	,	,	,
18637	23402	126	185	185	CD
18637	23402	127	American	American	NNP
18637	23402	128	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	23402	129	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	23402	130	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23402	131	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	132	v.	v.	IN
18637	23402	133	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	134	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	23402	135	,	,	,
18637	23402	136	179	179	CD
18637	23402	137	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23402	138	89	89	CD
18637	23402	139	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23402	140	1900	1900	CD
18637	23402	141	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23402	142	,	,	,
18637	23402	143	1149	1149	CD
18637	23402	144	American	American	NNP
18637	23402	145	Surety	Surety	NNP
18637	23402	146	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23402	147	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	148	v.	v.	IN
18637	23402	149	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	150	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	23402	151	,	,	,
18637	23402	152	287	287	CD
18637	23402	153	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23402	154	156	156	CD
18637	23402	155	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23402	156	1932	1932	CD
18637	23402	157	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23402	158	,	,	,
18637	23402	159	684	684	CD
18637	23402	160	,	,	,
18637	23402	161	1088	1088	CD
18637	23402	162	,	,	,
18637	23402	163	1089	1089	CD
18637	23402	164	American	American	NNP
18637	23402	165	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	23402	166	&	&	CC
18637	23402	167	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	23402	168	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23402	169	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	170	v.	v.	IN
18637	23402	171	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	172	United	United	NNP
18637	23402	173	States	States	NNP
18637	23402	174	,	,	,
18637	23402	175	299	299	CD
18637	23402	176	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23402	177	232	232	CD
18637	23402	178	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23402	179	1936	1936	CD
18637	23402	180	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23402	181	,	,	,
18637	23402	182	860	860	CD
18637	23402	183	American	American	NNP
18637	23402	184	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	23402	185	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23402	186	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	187	v.	v.	IN
18637	23402	188	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	189	United	United	NNP
18637	23402	190	States	States	NNP
18637	23402	191	,	,	,
18637	23402	192	328	328	CD
18637	23402	193	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23402	194	781	781	CD
18637	23402	195	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23402	196	1946	1946	CD
18637	23402	197	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23402	198	,	,	,
18637	23402	199	840	840	CD
18637	23402	200	American	American	NNP
18637	23402	201	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	23402	202	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23402	203	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	204	v.	v.	IN
18637	23402	205	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	206	Werckmeister	Werckmeister	NNP
18637	23402	207	,	,	,
18637	23402	208	207	207	CD
18637	23402	209	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23402	210	284	284	CD
18637	23402	211	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23402	212	1907	1907	CD
18637	23402	213	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23402	214	,	,	,
18637	23402	215	831	831	CD
18637	23402	216	American	American	NNP
18637	23402	217	Toll	Toll	NNP
18637	23402	218	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	23402	219	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23402	220	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	221	v.	v.	IN
18637	23402	222	_	_	NNP
18637	23402	223	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	23402	224	Com	Com	NNP
18637	23402	225	.	.	.
18637	23403	1	of	of	IN
18637	23403	2	California	California	NNP
18637	23403	3	et	et	NNP
18637	23403	4	al	al	NNP
18637	23403	5	.	.	NNP
18637	23403	6	,	,	,
18637	23403	7	307	307	CD
18637	23403	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23403	9	486	486	CD
18637	23403	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23403	11	1939	1939	CD
18637	23403	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23403	13	,	,	,
18637	23403	14	349	349	CD
18637	23403	15	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	23403	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23403	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23403	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23403	19	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23403	20	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23403	21	rel	rel	NNP
18637	23403	22	.	.	.
18637	23404	1	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	23404	2	,	,	,
18637	23404	3	111	111	CD
18637	23404	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23404	5	449	449	CD
18637	23404	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23404	7	1884	1884	CD
18637	23404	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23404	9	,	,	,
18637	23404	10	571	571	CD
18637	23404	11	,	,	,
18637	23404	12	613	613	CD
18637	23404	13	Amos	Amos	NNP
18637	23404	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23404	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23404	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23404	17	United	United	NNP
18637	23404	18	States	States	NNP
18637	23404	19	,	,	,
18637	23404	20	255	255	CD
18637	23404	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23404	22	313	313	CD
18637	23404	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23404	24	1921	1921	CD
18637	23404	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23404	26	,	,	,
18637	23404	27	824	824	CD
18637	23404	28	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	23404	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23404	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	23404	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23404	32	Dunn	Dunn	NNP
18637	23404	33	,	,	,
18637	23404	34	6	6	CD
18637	23404	35	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23404	36	.	.	.
18637	23405	1	204	204	CD
18637	23405	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23405	3	1821	1821	CD
18637	23405	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23405	5	,	,	,
18637	23405	6	85	85	CD
18637	23405	7	,	,	,
18637	23405	8	86	86	CD
18637	23405	9	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	23405	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23405	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23405	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23405	13	Santa	Santa	NNP
18637	23405	14	Anna	Anna	NNP
18637	23405	15	,	,	,
18637	23405	16	116	116	CD
18637	23405	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23405	18	356	356	CD
18637	23405	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23405	20	1886	1886	CD
18637	23405	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23405	22	,	,	,
18637	23405	23	331	331	CD
18637	23405	24	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	23405	25	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23405	26	.	.	.
18637	23406	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23406	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23406	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23406	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23406	5	Luckett	Luckett	NNP
18637	23406	6	,	,	,
18637	23406	7	321	321	CD
18637	23406	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23406	9	233	233	CD
18637	23406	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23406	11	1944	1944	CD
18637	23406	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23406	13	,	,	,
18637	23406	14	1020	1020	CD
18637	23406	15	,	,	,
18637	23406	16	1071	1071	CD
18637	23406	17	,	,	,
18637	23406	18	1083	1083	CD
18637	23406	19	,	,	,
18637	23406	20	1087	1087	CD
18637	23406	21	Andres	Andres	NNP
18637	23406	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23406	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23406	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23406	25	United	United	NNP
18637	23406	26	States	States	NNP
18637	23406	27	,	,	,
18637	23406	28	333	333	CD
18637	23406	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23406	30	740	740	CD
18637	23406	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23406	32	1948	1948	CD
18637	23406	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23406	34	,	,	,
18637	23406	35	879	879	CD
18637	23406	36	,	,	,
18637	23406	37	892	892	CD
18637	23406	38	Andrews	Andrews	NNPS
18637	23406	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23406	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23406	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23406	42	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
18637	23406	43	,	,	,
18637	23406	44	188	188	CD
18637	23406	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23406	46	14	14	CD
18637	23406	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23406	48	1903	1903	CD
18637	23406	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23406	50	,	,	,
18637	23406	51	352	352	CD
18637	23406	52	,	,	,
18637	23406	53	429	429	CD
18637	23406	54	,	,	,
18637	23406	55	662	662	CD
18637	23406	56	,	,	,
18637	23406	57	665	665	CD
18637	23406	58	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
18637	23406	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23406	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23406	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23406	62	Swartz	Swartz	NNP
18637	23406	63	,	,	,
18637	23406	64	156	156	CD
18637	23406	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23406	66	272	272	CD
18637	23406	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23406	68	1895	1895	CD
18637	23406	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23406	70	,	,	,
18637	23406	71	1138	1138	CD
18637	23406	72	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
18637	23406	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23406	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	23406	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23406	76	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23406	77	,	,	,
18637	23406	78	3	3	CD
18637	23406	79	How	how	WRB
18637	23406	80	.	.	.
18637	23407	1	568	568	CD
18637	23407	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23407	3	1845	1845	CD
18637	23407	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23407	5	,	,	,
18637	23407	6	574	574	CD
18637	23407	7	Angel	Angel	NNP
18637	23407	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23407	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23407	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23407	11	Bullington	Bullington	NNP
18637	23407	12	,	,	,
18637	23407	13	330	330	CD
18637	23407	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23407	15	183	183	CD
18637	23407	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23407	17	1947	1947	CD
18637	23407	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23407	19	,	,	,
18637	23407	20	1089	1089	CD
18637	23407	21	Angle	Angle	NNP
18637	23407	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23407	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23407	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23407	25	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23407	26	,	,	,
18637	23407	27	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23408	1	P.M.	P.M.	NNP
18637	23408	2	&	&	CC
18637	23408	3	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	23409	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23409	2	,	,	,
18637	23409	3	151	151	CD
18637	23409	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23409	5	1	1	CD
18637	23409	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23409	7	1894	1894	CD
18637	23409	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23409	9	,	,	,
18637	23409	10	1035	1035	CD
18637	23409	11	Anglo	anglo	JJ
18637	23409	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	23409	13	American	American	NNP
18637	23409	14	Provision	Provision	NNP
18637	23409	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23409	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23409	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23409	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23409	19	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23409	20	Provision	Provision	NNP
18637	23409	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23409	22	,	,	,
18637	23409	23	191	191	CD
18637	23409	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23409	25	373	373	CD
18637	23409	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23409	27	1903	1903	CD
18637	23409	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23409	29	,	,	,
18637	23409	30	657	657	CD
18637	23409	31	,	,	,
18637	23409	32	674	674	CD
18637	23409	33	Anglo	anglo	JJ
18637	23409	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	23409	35	Chilean	Chilean	NNP
18637	23409	36	Nitrate	Nitrate	NNP
18637	23409	37	Sales	Sales	NNPS
18637	23409	38	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23409	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23409	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23409	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23409	42	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	23409	43	,	,	,
18637	23409	44	288	288	CD
18637	23409	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23409	46	218	218	CD
18637	23409	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23409	48	1933	1933	CD
18637	23409	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23409	50	,	,	,
18637	23409	51	195	195	CD
18637	23409	52	,	,	,
18637	23409	53	364	364	CD
18637	23409	54	Anniston	Anniston	NNP
18637	23409	55	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23409	56	.	.	.
18637	23410	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23410	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23410	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23410	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23410	5	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23410	6	,	,	,
18637	23410	7	301	301	CD
18637	23410	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23410	9	337	337	CD
18637	23410	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23410	11	1937	1937	CD
18637	23410	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23410	13	,	,	,
18637	23410	14	858	858	CD
18637	23410	15	Antelope	Antelope	NNP
18637	23410	16	,	,	,
18637	23410	17	The	the	DT
18637	23410	18	,	,	,
18637	23410	19	10	10	CD
18637	23410	20	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23410	21	.	.	.
18637	23411	1	66	66	CD
18637	23411	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23411	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	23411	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23411	5	,	,	,
18637	23411	6	675	675	CD
18637	23411	7	Anti	Anti	NNP
18637	23411	8	-	-	NNP
18637	23411	9	Fascist	Fascist	NNP
18637	23411	10	Committee	Committee	NNP
18637	23411	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	23411	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	14	McGrath	McGrath	NNP
18637	23411	15	,	,	,
18637	23411	16	341	341	CD
18637	23411	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23411	18	123	123	CD
18637	23411	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23411	20	1951	1951	CD
18637	23411	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23411	22	,	,	,
18637	23411	23	801	801	CD
18637	23411	24	Antoni	Antoni	NNP
18637	23411	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23411	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	28	Greenhow	Greenhow	NNP
18637	23411	29	,	,	,
18637	23411	30	107	107	CD
18637	23411	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23411	32	769	769	CD
18637	23411	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23411	34	1883	1883	CD
18637	23411	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23411	36	,	,	,
18637	23411	37	355	355	CD
18637	23411	38	Appalachian	Appalachian	NNP
18637	23411	39	Coals	Coals	NNPS
18637	23411	40	,	,	,
18637	23411	41	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	23411	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23411	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	45	United	United	NNP
18637	23411	46	States	States	NNP
18637	23411	47	,	,	,
18637	23411	48	288	288	CD
18637	23411	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23411	50	344	344	CD
18637	23411	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23411	52	1933	1933	CD
18637	23411	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23411	54	,	,	,
18637	23411	55	152	152	CD
18637	23411	56	Appleby	Appleby	NNP
18637	23411	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	23411	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	60	Buffalo	Buffalo	NNP
18637	23411	61	,	,	,
18637	23411	62	221	221	CD
18637	23411	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23411	64	524	524	CD
18637	23411	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23411	66	1911	1911	CD
18637	23411	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23411	68	,	,	,
18637	23411	69	1066	1066	CD
18637	23411	70	Appleby	Appleby	NNP
18637	23411	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	23411	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	74	Delaney	Delaney	NNP
18637	23411	75	,	,	,
18637	23411	76	271	271	CD
18637	23411	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23411	78	403	403	CD
18637	23411	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23411	80	1926	1926	CD
18637	23411	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23411	82	,	,	,
18637	23411	83	329	329	CD
18637	23411	84	Appleyard	Appleyard	NNP
18637	23411	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	23411	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	88	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	23411	89	,	,	,
18637	23411	90	203	203	CD
18637	23411	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23411	92	222	222	CD
18637	23411	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23411	94	1906	1906	CD
18637	23411	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23411	96	,	,	,
18637	23411	97	695	695	CD
18637	23411	98	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	23411	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	23411	101	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	102	California	California	NNP
18637	23411	103	,	,	,
18637	23411	104	283	283	CD
18637	23411	105	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23411	106	423	423	CD
18637	23411	107	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23411	108	1931	1931	CD
18637	23411	109	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23411	110	,	,	,
18637	23411	111	131	131	CD
18637	23411	112	,	,	,
18637	23411	113	544	544	CD
18637	23411	114	,	,	,
18637	23411	115	564	564	CD
18637	23411	116	,	,	,
18637	23411	117	724	724	CD
18637	23411	118	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	23411	119	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	120	v.	v.	IN
18637	23411	121	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	122	California	California	NNP
18637	23411	123	,	,	,
18637	23411	124	292	292	CD
18637	23411	125	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23411	126	341	341	CD
18637	23411	127	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23411	128	1934	1934	CD
18637	23411	129	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23411	130	,	,	,
18637	23411	131	369	369	CD
18637	23411	132	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	23411	133	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	23411	134	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23411	135	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	136	v.	v.	IN
18637	23411	137	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	138	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	23411	139	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23411	140	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	23411	141	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	23411	142	'	'	POS
18637	23411	143	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	23411	144	Cases	case	NNS
18637	23411	145	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23411	146	,	,	,
18637	23411	147	250	250	CD
18637	23411	148	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23411	149	400	400	CD
18637	23411	150	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23411	151	1919	1919	CD
18637	23411	152	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23411	153	,	,	,
18637	23411	154	989	989	CD
18637	23411	155	Arkadelphia	Arkadelphia	NNP
18637	23411	156	Milling	Milling	NNP
18637	23411	157	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23411	158	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	159	v.	v.	IN
18637	23411	160	_	_	NNP
18637	23411	161	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23411	162	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	23411	163	S.W.R.	S.W.R.	NNP
18637	23412	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23412	2	,	,	,
18637	23412	3	249	249	CD
18637	23412	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23412	5	134	134	CD
18637	23412	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23412	7	1919	1919	CD
18637	23412	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23412	9	,	,	,
18637	23412	10	526	526	CD
18637	23412	11	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	23412	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23412	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23412	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23412	15	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23412	16	&	&	CC
18637	23412	17	T.C.	T.C.	NNP
18637	23413	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23413	2	&	&	CC
18637	23413	3	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	23413	4	,	,	,
18637	23413	5	183	183	CD
18637	23413	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23413	7	185	185	CD
18637	23413	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23413	9	1901	1901	CD
18637	23413	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23413	11	,	,	,
18637	23413	12	567	567	CD
18637	23413	13	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	23413	14	Land	Land	NNP
18637	23413	15	&	&	CC
18637	23413	16	Cattle	Cattle	NNP
18637	23413	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23413	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23413	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23413	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23413	21	Mann	Mann	NNP
18637	23413	22	,	,	,
18637	23413	23	130	130	CD
18637	23413	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23413	25	69	69	CD
18637	23413	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23413	27	1889	1889	CD
18637	23413	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23413	29	,	,	,
18637	23413	30	896	896	CD
18637	23413	31	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	23413	32	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	23413	33	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23413	34	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23413	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23413	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	23413	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23413	38	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	23413	39	.	.	.
18637	23414	1	of	of	IN
18637	23414	2	Public	Public	NNP
18637	23414	3	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	23414	4	,	,	,
18637	23414	5	304	304	CD
18637	23414	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23414	7	61	61	CD
18637	23414	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23414	9	1938	1938	CD
18637	23414	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23414	11	,	,	,
18637	23414	12	234	234	CD
18637	23414	13	Arlington	Arlington	NNP
18637	23414	14	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	23414	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23414	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23414	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23414	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23414	19	Fant	Fant	NNP
18637	23414	20	,	,	,
18637	23414	21	278	278	CD
18637	23414	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23414	23	439	439	CD
18637	23414	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23414	25	1929	1929	CD
18637	23414	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23414	27	,	,	,
18637	23414	28	305	305	CD
18637	23414	29	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	23414	30	&	&	CC
18637	23414	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23414	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23414	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23414	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23414	35	North	North	NNP
18637	23414	36	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	23414	37	,	,	,
18637	23414	38	240	240	CD
18637	23414	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23414	40	510	510	CD
18637	23414	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23414	42	1916	1916	CD
18637	23414	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23414	44	,	,	,
18637	23414	45	248	248	CD
18637	23414	46	,	,	,
18637	23414	47	1019	1019	CD
18637	23414	48	,	,	,
18637	23414	49	1154	1154	CD
18637	23414	50	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	23414	51	&	&	CC
18637	23414	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23414	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23414	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	23414	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23414	56	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	23414	57	,	,	,
18637	23414	58	246	246	CD
18637	23414	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23414	60	1	1	CD
18637	23414	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23414	62	1918	1918	CD
18637	23414	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23414	64	,	,	,
18637	23414	65	1148	1148	CD
18637	23414	66	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	23414	67	&	&	CC
18637	23414	68	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23414	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23414	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	23414	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23414	72	Wantock	Wantock	NNP
18637	23414	73	,	,	,
18637	23414	74	323	323	CD
18637	23414	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23414	76	126	126	CD
18637	23414	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23414	78	1944	1944	CD
18637	23414	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23414	80	,	,	,
18637	23414	81	157	157	CD
18637	23414	82	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	23414	83	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	23414	84	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23414	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23414	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	23414	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23414	88	Lacy	Lacy	NNP
18637	23414	89	,	,	,
18637	23414	90	200	200	CD
18637	23414	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23414	92	226	226	CD
18637	23414	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23414	94	1906	1906	CD
18637	23414	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23414	96	,	,	,
18637	23414	97	185	185	CD
18637	23414	98	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	23414	99	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	23414	100	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23414	101	_	_	NNP
18637	23414	102	v.	v.	IN
18637	23414	103	_	_	NNP
18637	23414	104	United	United	NNP
18637	23414	105	States	States	NNP
18637	23414	106	,	,	,
18637	23414	107	209	209	CD
18637	23414	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23414	109	56	56	CD
18637	23414	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23414	111	1908	1908	CD
18637	23414	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23414	113	,	,	,
18637	23414	114	137	137	CD
18637	23414	115	,	,	,
18637	23414	116	881	881	CD
18637	23414	117	Armstrong	Armstrong	NNP
18637	23414	118	_	_	NNP
18637	23414	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	23414	120	_	_	NNP
18637	23414	121	United	United	NNP
18637	23414	122	States	States	NNP
18637	23414	123	,	,	,
18637	23414	124	13	13	CD
18637	23414	125	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23414	126	.	.	.
18637	23415	1	154	154	CD
18637	23415	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23415	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	23415	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23415	5	,	,	,
18637	23415	6	407	407	CD
18637	23415	7	Armstrong	Armstrong	NNP
18637	23415	8	's	's	POS
18637	23415	9	Foundry	Foundry	NNP
18637	23415	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23415	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23415	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23415	13	United	United	NNP
18637	23415	14	States	States	NNP
18637	23415	15	,	,	,
18637	23415	16	6	6	CD
18637	23415	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23415	18	.	.	.
18637	23416	1	766	766	CD
18637	23416	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23416	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	23416	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23416	5	,	,	,
18637	23416	6	645	645	CD
18637	23416	7	Arndstein	Arndstein	NNP
18637	23416	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23416	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	11	McCarthy	McCarthy	NNP
18637	23416	12	,	,	,
18637	23416	13	254	254	CD
18637	23416	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23416	15	71	71	CD
18637	23416	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23416	17	1920	1920	CD
18637	23416	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23416	19	,	,	,
18637	23416	20	843	843	CD
18637	23416	21	Arndt	Arndt	NNP
18637	23416	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23416	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	25	Griggs	Griggs	NNP
18637	23416	26	,	,	,
18637	23416	27	134	134	CD
18637	23416	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23416	29	316	316	CD
18637	23416	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23416	31	1890	1890	CD
18637	23416	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23416	33	,	,	,
18637	23416	34	1072	1072	CD
18637	23416	35	,	,	,
18637	23416	36	1080	1080	CD
18637	23416	37	Arrowsmith	Arrowsmith	NNP
18637	23416	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23416	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	41	Gleason	Gleason	NNP
18637	23416	42	,	,	,
18637	23416	43	129	129	CD
18637	23416	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23416	45	86	86	CD
18637	23416	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23416	47	1889	1889	CD
18637	23416	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23416	49	,	,	,
18637	23416	50	629	629	CD
18637	23416	51	Arver	Arver	NNP
18637	23416	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	23416	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	55	United	United	NNP
18637	23416	56	States	States	NNP
18637	23416	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23416	58	Selective	Selective	NNP
18637	23416	59	Draft	Draft	NNP
18637	23416	60	Law	Law	NNP
18637	23416	61	Cases	case	NNS
18637	23416	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23416	63	,	,	,
18637	23416	64	245	245	CD
18637	23416	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23416	66	366	366	CD
18637	23416	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23416	68	1918	1918	CD
18637	23416	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23416	70	,	,	,
18637	23416	71	768	768	CD
18637	23416	72	,	,	,
18637	23416	73	953	953	CD
18637	23416	74	,	,	,
18637	23416	75	965	965	CD
18637	23416	76	Asbell	Asbell	NNP
18637	23416	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	23416	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	80	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23416	81	,	,	,
18637	23416	82	209	209	CD
18637	23416	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23416	84	251	251	CD
18637	23416	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23416	86	1908	1908	CD
18637	23416	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23416	88	,	,	,
18637	23416	89	248	248	CD
18637	23416	90	Asbury	Asbury	NNP
18637	23416	91	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	23416	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	23416	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	95	Cass	Cass	NNP
18637	23416	96	County	County	NNP
18637	23416	97	,	,	,
18637	23416	98	326	326	CD
18637	23416	99	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23416	100	207	207	CD
18637	23416	101	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23416	102	1945	1945	CD
18637	23416	103	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23416	104	,	,	,
18637	23416	105	362	362	CD
18637	23416	106	,	,	,
18637	23416	107	1016	1016	CD
18637	23416	108	Ashcraft	Ashcraft	NNP
18637	23416	109	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	110	v.	v.	IN
18637	23416	111	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	112	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	23416	113	,	,	,
18637	23416	114	322	322	CD
18637	23416	115	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23416	116	143	143	CD
18637	23416	117	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23416	118	1944	1944	CD
18637	23416	119	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23416	120	,	,	,
18637	23416	121	1113	1113	CD
18637	23416	122	,	,	,
18637	23416	123	1121	1121	CD
18637	23416	124	Ashcraft	Ashcraft	NNP
18637	23416	125	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	126	v.	v.	IN
18637	23416	127	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	128	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	23416	129	,	,	,
18637	23416	130	327	327	CD
18637	23416	131	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23416	132	274	274	CD
18637	23416	133	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23416	134	1946	1946	CD
18637	23416	135	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23416	136	,	,	,
18637	23416	137	1114	1114	CD
18637	23416	138	Ashe	Ashe	NNP
18637	23416	139	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	140	v.	v.	IN
18637	23416	141	_	_	NNP
18637	23416	142	United	United	NNP
18637	23416	143	States	States	NNP
18637	23416	144	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23416	145	rel	rel	NN
18637	23416	146	.	.	.
18637	23417	1	Valotta	Valotta	NNP
18637	23417	2	,	,	,
18637	23417	3	270	270	CD
18637	23417	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23417	5	424	424	CD
18637	23417	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23417	7	1926	1926	CD
18637	23417	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23417	9	,	,	,
18637	23417	10	1110	1110	CD
18637	23417	11	Asher	Asher	NNP
18637	23417	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23417	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23417	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23417	15	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23417	16	,	,	,
18637	23417	17	128	128	CD
18637	23417	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23417	19	129	129	CD
18637	23417	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23417	21	1888	1888	CD
18637	23417	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23417	23	,	,	,
18637	23417	24	187	187	CD
18637	23417	25	Ashton	Ashton	NNP
18637	23417	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23417	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23417	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23417	29	Cameron	Cameron	NNP
18637	23417	30	County	County	NNP
18637	23417	31	Water	Water	NNP
18637	23417	32	Improvement	Improvement	NNP
18637	23417	33	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	23417	34	,	,	,
18637	23417	35	298	298	CD
18637	23417	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23417	37	513	513	CD
18637	23417	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23417	39	1936	1936	CD
18637	23417	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23417	41	,	,	,
18637	23417	42	262	262	CD
18637	23417	43	,	,	,
18637	23417	44	264	264	CD
18637	23417	45	,	,	,
18637	23417	46	936	936	CD
18637	23417	47	Ashwander	Ashwander	NNP
18637	23417	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23417	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	23417	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23417	51	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	23417	52	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	23417	53	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	23417	54	,	,	,
18637	23417	55	297	297	CD
18637	23417	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23417	57	288	288	CD
18637	23417	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23417	59	1936	1936	CD
18637	23417	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23417	61	,	,	,
18637	23417	62	132	132	CD
18637	23417	63	,	,	,
18637	23417	64	291	291	CD
18637	23417	65	,	,	,
18637	23417	66	440	440	CD
18637	23417	67	,	,	,
18637	23417	68	541	541	CD
18637	23417	69	,	,	,
18637	23417	70	544	544	CD
18637	23417	71	,	,	,
18637	23417	72	552	552	CD
18637	23417	73	,	,	,
18637	23417	74	562	562	CD
18637	23417	75	,	,	,
18637	23417	76	701	701	CD
18637	23417	77	,	,	,
18637	23417	78	909	909	CD
18637	23417	79	Askren	Askren	NNP
18637	23417	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23417	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	23417	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23417	83	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	23417	84	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	23417	85	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23417	86	,	,	,
18637	23417	87	252	252	CD
18637	23417	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23417	89	444	444	CD
18637	23417	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23417	91	1920	1920	CD
18637	23417	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23417	93	,	,	,
18637	23417	94	184	184	CD
18637	23417	95	,	,	,
18637	23417	96	239	239	CD
18637	23417	97	Assaria	Assaria	NNP
18637	23417	98	State	State	NNP
18637	23417	99	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23417	100	_	_	NNP
18637	23417	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	23417	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23417	103	Dolley	Dolley	NNP
18637	23417	104	,	,	,
18637	23417	105	219	219	CD
18637	23417	106	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23417	107	121	121	CD
18637	23417	108	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23417	109	1911	1911	CD
18637	23417	110	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23417	111	,	,	,
18637	23417	112	1020	1020	CD
18637	23417	113	Associated	Associated	NNP
18637	23417	114	Press	Press	NNP
18637	23417	115	_	_	NNP
18637	23417	116	v.	v.	IN
18637	23417	117	_	_	NNP
18637	23417	118	National	National	NNP
18637	23417	119	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	23417	120	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	23417	121	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23417	122	,	,	,
18637	23417	123	301	301	CD
18637	23417	124	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23417	125	103	103	CD
18637	23417	126	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23417	127	1937	1937	CD
18637	23417	128	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23417	129	,	,	,
18637	23417	130	121	121	CD
18637	23417	131	,	,	,
18637	23417	132	793	793	CD
18637	23417	133	Associated	Associated	NNP
18637	23417	134	Press	Press	NNP
18637	23417	135	_	_	NNP
18637	23417	136	v.	v.	IN
18637	23417	137	_	_	NNP
18637	23417	138	United	United	NNP
18637	23417	139	States	States	NNP
18637	23417	140	,	,	,
18637	23417	141	326	326	CD
18637	23417	142	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23417	143	1	1	CD
18637	23417	144	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23417	145	1945	1945	CD
18637	23417	146	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23417	147	,	,	,
18637	23417	148	793	793	CD
18637	23417	149	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	23417	150	,	,	,
18637	23417	151	T.	T.	NNP
18637	23417	152	&	&	CC
18637	23417	153	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	23418	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23418	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23418	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23418	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23418	5	Harold	Harold	NNP
18637	23418	6	,	,	,
18637	23418	7	241	241	CD
18637	23418	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23418	9	371	371	CD
18637	23418	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23418	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	23418	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23418	13	,	,	,
18637	23418	14	247	247	CD
18637	23418	15	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	23418	16	,	,	,
18637	23418	17	T.	T.	NNP
18637	23418	18	&	&	CC
18637	23418	19	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	23419	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23419	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23419	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23419	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23419	5	Matthews	Matthews	NNP
18637	23419	6	,	,	,
18637	23419	7	174	174	CD
18637	23419	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23419	9	96	96	CD
18637	23419	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23419	11	1899	1899	CD
18637	23419	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23419	13	,	,	,
18637	23419	14	1167	1167	CD
18637	23419	15	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	23419	16	,	,	,
18637	23419	17	T.	T.	NNP
18637	23419	18	&	&	CC
18637	23419	19	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	23420	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23420	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23420	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23420	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23420	5	O'Connor	O'Connor	NNP
18637	23420	6	,	,	,
18637	23420	7	223	223	CD
18637	23420	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23420	9	280	280	CD
18637	23420	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23420	11	1912	1912	CD
18637	23420	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23420	13	,	,	,
18637	23420	14	196	196	CD
18637	23420	15	,	,	,
18637	23420	16	931	931	CD
18637	23420	17	,	,	,
18637	23420	18	935	935	CD
18637	23420	19	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	23420	20	,	,	,
18637	23420	21	T	T	NNP
18637	23420	22	&	&	CC
18637	23420	23	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	23421	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23421	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23421	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23421	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23421	5	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	23421	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23421	7	,	,	,
18637	23421	8	283	283	CD
18637	23421	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23421	10	380	380	CD
18637	23421	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23421	12	1931	1931	CD
18637	23421	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23421	14	,	,	,
18637	23421	15	223	223	CD
18637	23421	16	,	,	,
18637	23421	17	1012	1012	CD
18637	23421	18	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	23421	19	,	,	,
18637	23421	20	T.	T.	NNP
18637	23421	21	&	&	CC
18637	23421	22	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	23422	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23422	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23422	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23422	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23422	5	Sowers	Sowers	NNP
18637	23422	6	,	,	,
18637	23422	7	213	213	CD
18637	23422	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23422	9	55	55	CD
18637	23422	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23422	11	1909	1909	CD
18637	23422	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23422	13	,	,	,
18637	23422	14	677	677	CD
18637	23422	15	,	,	,
18637	23422	16	685	685	CD
18637	23422	17	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	23422	18	,	,	,
18637	23422	19	T.	T.	NNP
18637	23422	20	&	&	CC
18637	23422	21	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	23423	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23423	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23423	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23423	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23423	5	Vosburg	Vosburg	NNP
18637	23423	6	,	,	,
18637	23423	7	238	238	CD
18637	23423	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23423	9	56	56	CD
18637	23423	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23423	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	23423	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23423	13	,	,	,
18637	23423	14	1167	1167	CD
18637	23423	15	Atherton	Atherton	NNP
18637	23423	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23423	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23423	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23423	19	Atherton	Atherton	NNP
18637	23423	20	,	,	,
18637	23423	21	181	181	CD
18637	23423	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23423	23	155	155	CD
18637	23423	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23423	25	1901	1901	CD
18637	23423	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23423	27	,	,	,
18637	23423	28	663	663	CD
18637	23423	29	Atkin	Atkin	NNP
18637	23423	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23423	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23423	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23423	33	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23423	34	,	,	,
18637	23423	35	191	191	CD
18637	23423	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23423	37	207	207	CD
18637	23423	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23423	39	1903	1903	CD
18637	23423	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23423	41	,	,	,
18637	23423	42	987	987	CD
18637	23423	43	,	,	,
18637	23423	44	1158	1158	CD
18637	23423	45	Atkins	Atkins	NNP
18637	23423	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23423	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	23423	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23423	49	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	23423	50	,	,	,
18637	23423	51	212	212	CD
18637	23423	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23423	53	285	285	CD
18637	23423	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23423	55	1909	1909	CD
18637	23423	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23423	57	,	,	,
18637	23423	58	537	537	CD
18637	23423	59	Atkinson	Atkinson	NNP
18637	23423	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23423	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23423	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23423	63	State	State	NNP
18637	23423	64	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23423	65	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23423	66	,	,	,
18637	23423	67	303	303	CD
18637	23423	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23423	69	20	20	CD
18637	23423	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23423	71	1938	1938	CD
18637	23423	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23423	73	,	,	,
18637	23423	74	307	307	CD
18637	23423	75	,	,	,
18637	23423	76	731	731	CD
18637	23423	77	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	23423	78	&	&	CC
18637	23423	79	P.	P.	NNP
18637	23423	80	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	23423	81	.	.	.
18637	23424	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23424	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23424	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	5	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	23424	6	,	,	,
18637	23424	7	190	190	CD
18637	23424	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23424	9	160	160	CD
18637	23424	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23424	11	1903	1903	CD
18637	23424	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23424	13	,	,	,
18637	23424	14	214	214	CD
18637	23424	15	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	23424	16	Cleaners	Cleaners	NNPS
18637	23424	17	&	&	CC
18637	23424	18	Dyers	Dyers	NNPS
18637	23424	19	,	,	,
18637	23424	20	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	23424	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	23424	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	24	United	United	NNP
18637	23424	25	States	States	NNP
18637	23424	26	,	,	,
18637	23424	27	286	286	CD
18637	23424	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23424	29	427	427	CD
18637	23424	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23424	31	1932	1932	CD
18637	23424	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23424	33	,	,	,
18637	23424	34	122	122	CD
18637	23424	35	,	,	,
18637	23424	36	303	303	CD
18637	23424	37	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	23424	38	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	23424	39	Line	Line	NNP
18637	23424	40	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23424	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23424	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23424	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	45	Daughton	Daughton	NNP
18637	23424	46	,	,	,
18637	23424	47	262	262	CD
18637	23424	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23424	49	413	413	CD
18637	23424	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23424	51	1923	1923	CD
18637	23424	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23424	53	,	,	,
18637	23424	54	209	209	CD
18637	23424	55	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	23424	56	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	23424	57	Line	Line	NNP
18637	23424	58	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23424	59	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23424	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23424	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	63	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	23424	64	,	,	,
18637	23424	65	287	287	CD
18637	23424	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23424	67	502	502	CD
18637	23424	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23424	69	1933	1933	CD
18637	23424	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23424	71	,	,	,
18637	23424	72	1095	1095	CD
18637	23424	73	,	,	,
18637	23424	74	1156	1156	CD
18637	23424	75	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	23424	76	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	23424	77	Line	Line	NNP
18637	23424	78	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23424	79	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23424	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	23424	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	83	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23424	84	,	,	,
18637	23424	85	234	234	CD
18637	23424	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23424	87	280	280	CD
18637	23424	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23424	89	1914	1914	CD
18637	23424	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23424	91	,	,	,
18637	23424	92	1014	1014	CD
18637	23424	93	,	,	,
18637	23424	94	1156	1156	CD
18637	23424	95	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	23424	96	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	23424	97	Line	Line	NNP
18637	23424	98	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23424	99	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23424	100	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	23424	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	103	Glenn	Glenn	NNP
18637	23424	104	,	,	,
18637	23424	105	239	239	CD
18637	23424	106	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23424	107	388	388	CD
18637	23424	108	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23424	109	1915	1915	CD
18637	23424	110	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23424	111	,	,	,
18637	23424	112	1015	1015	CD
18637	23424	113	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	23424	114	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	23424	115	Line	Line	NNP
18637	23424	116	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23424	117	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23424	118	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	23424	120	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	121	Goldsboro	Goldsboro	NNP
18637	23424	122	,	,	,
18637	23424	123	232	232	CD
18637	23424	124	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23424	125	548	548	CD
18637	23424	126	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23424	127	1914	1914	CD
18637	23424	128	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23424	129	,	,	,
18637	23424	130	329	329	CD
18637	23424	131	,	,	,
18637	23424	132	352	352	CD
18637	23424	133	,	,	,
18637	23424	134	983	983	CD
18637	23424	135	,	,	,
18637	23424	136	1010	1010	CD
18637	23424	137	,	,	,
18637	23424	138	1014	1014	CD
18637	23424	139	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	23424	140	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	23424	141	Line	Line	NNP
18637	23424	142	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23424	143	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23424	144	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	145	v.	v.	IN
18637	23424	146	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	147	North	North	NNP
18637	23424	148	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	23424	149	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23424	150	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23424	151	,	,	,
18637	23424	152	206	206	CD
18637	23424	153	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23424	154	1	1	CD
18637	23424	155	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23424	156	1907	1907	CD
18637	23424	157	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23424	158	,	,	,
18637	23424	159	1009	1009	CD
18637	23424	160	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	23424	161	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	23424	162	Line	Line	NNP
18637	23424	163	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23424	164	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23424	165	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	166	v.	v.	IN
18637	23424	167	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	168	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	23424	169	,	,	,
18637	23424	170	332	332	CD
18637	23424	171	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23424	172	168	168	CD
18637	23424	173	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23424	174	1947	1947	CD
18637	23424	175	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23424	176	,	,	,
18637	23424	177	330	330	CD
18637	23424	178	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	23424	179	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	23424	180	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23424	181	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	182	v.	v.	IN
18637	23424	183	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	184	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	23424	185	,	,	,
18637	23424	186	298	298	CD
18637	23424	187	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23424	188	553	553	CD
18637	23424	189	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23424	190	1936	1936	CD
18637	23424	191	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23424	192	,	,	,
18637	23424	193	198	198	CD
18637	23424	194	,	,	,
18637	23424	195	202	202	CD
18637	23424	196	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	23424	197	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	23424	198	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23424	199	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	200	v.	v.	IN
18637	23424	201	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	202	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	23424	203	,	,	,
18637	23424	204	302	302	CD
18637	23424	205	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23424	206	22	22	CD
18637	23424	207	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23424	208	1937	1937	CD
18637	23424	209	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23424	210	,	,	,
18637	23424	211	198	198	CD
18637	23424	212	,	,	,
18637	23424	213	1051	1051	CD
18637	23424	214	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	23424	215	Works	Works	NNP
18637	23424	216	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	217	v.	v.	IN
18637	23424	218	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	219	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	23424	220	,	,	,
18637	23424	221	107	107	CD
18637	23424	222	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23424	223	192	192	CD
18637	23424	224	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23424	225	1882	1882	CD
18637	23424	226	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23424	227	,	,	,
18637	23424	228	272	272	CD
18637	23424	229	Atlee	Atlee	NNP
18637	23424	230	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	231	v.	v.	IN
18637	23424	232	_	_	NNP
18637	23424	233	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	23424	234	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23424	235	P.	P.	NNP
18637	23424	236	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23424	237	,	,	,
18637	23424	238	21	21	CD
18637	23424	239	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23424	240	.	.	.
18637	23425	1	389	389	CD
18637	23425	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23425	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	23425	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23425	5	,	,	,
18637	23425	6	574	574	CD
18637	23425	7	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	23425	8	General	General	NNP
18637	23425	9	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23425	10	rel	rel	NN
18637	23425	11	.	.	.
18637	23426	1	Kies	Kies	NNPS
18637	23426	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23426	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	5	Lowrey	Lowrey	NNP
18637	23426	6	,	,	,
18637	23426	7	199	199	CD
18637	23426	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23426	9	233	233	CD
18637	23426	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	11	1905	1905	CD
18637	23426	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23426	13	,	,	,
18637	23426	14	340	340	CD
18637	23426	15	,	,	,
18637	23426	16	1036	1036	CD
18637	23426	17	Audubon	Audubon	NNP
18637	23426	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23426	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	21	Shufeldt	Shufeldt	NNP
18637	23426	22	,	,	,
18637	23426	23	181	181	CD
18637	23426	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23426	25	575	575	CD
18637	23426	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	27	1901	1901	CD
18637	23426	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23426	29	,	,	,
18637	23426	30	671	671	CD
18637	23426	31	Auffmordt	Auffmordt	NNP
18637	23426	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23426	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	35	Hedden	Hedden	NNP
18637	23426	36	,	,	,
18637	23426	37	137	137	CD
18637	23426	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23426	39	310	310	CD
18637	23426	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	41	1890	1890	CD
18637	23426	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23426	43	,	,	,
18637	23426	44	452	452	CD
18637	23426	45	,	,	,
18637	23426	46	893	893	CD
18637	23426	47	Austin	Austin	NNP
18637	23426	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	23426	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	51	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	23426	52	,	,	,
18637	23426	53	179	179	CD
18637	23426	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23426	55	343	343	CD
18637	23426	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	57	1900	1900	CD
18637	23426	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23426	59	,	,	,
18637	23426	60	240	240	CD
18637	23426	61	Austin	Austin	NNP
18637	23426	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	23426	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	65	United	United	NNP
18637	23426	66	States	States	NNP
18637	23426	67	,	,	,
18637	23426	68	155	155	CD
18637	23426	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23426	70	417	417	CD
18637	23426	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	72	1894	1894	CD
18637	23426	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23426	74	,	,	,
18637	23426	75	324	324	CD
18637	23426	76	Automobile	Automobile	NNP
18637	23426	77	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	23426	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	23426	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	81	O'Brien	O'Brien	NNP
18637	23426	82	,	,	,
18637	23426	83	339	339	CD
18637	23426	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23426	85	454	454	CD
18637	23426	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	87	1950	1950	CD
18637	23426	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23426	89	,	,	,
18637	23426	90	252	252	CD
18637	23426	91	Auto	Auto	NNP
18637	23426	92	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	23426	93	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	94	v.	v.	IN
18637	23426	95	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	96	Wis.	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	23426	97	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23426	98	,	,	,
18637	23426	99	336	336	CD
18637	23426	100	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23426	101	245	245	CD
18637	23426	102	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	103	1919	1919	CD
18637	23426	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23426	105	,	,	,
18637	23426	106	252	252	CD
18637	23426	107	,	,	,
18637	23426	108	724	724	CD
18637	23426	109	,	,	,
18637	23426	110	783	783	CD
18637	23426	111	,	,	,
18637	23426	112	810	810	CD
18637	23426	113	,	,	,
18637	23426	114	953	953	CD
18637	23426	115	,	,	,
18637	23426	116	993	993	CD
18637	23426	117	Avent	Avent	NNP
18637	23426	118	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	23426	120	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	121	United	United	NNP
18637	23426	122	States	States	NNP
18637	23426	123	,	,	,
18637	23426	124	266	266	CD
18637	23426	125	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23426	126	127	127	CD
18637	23426	127	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	128	1924	1924	CD
18637	23426	129	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23426	130	,	,	,
18637	23426	131	76	76	CD
18637	23426	132	Avery	Avery	NNP
18637	23426	133	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	134	v.	v.	IN
18637	23426	135	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	136	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	23426	137	,	,	,
18637	23426	138	308	308	CD
18637	23426	139	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23426	140	444	444	CD
18637	23426	141	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	142	1940	1940	CD
18637	23426	143	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23426	144	,	,	,
18637	23426	145	1099	1099	CD
18637	23426	146	,	,	,
18637	23426	147	1101	1101	CD
18637	23426	148	Ayer	Ayer	NNP
18637	23426	149	&	&	CC
18637	23426	150	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23426	151	Tie	Tie	NNP
18637	23426	152	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23426	153	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	154	v.	v.	IN
18637	23426	155	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	156	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23426	157	,	,	,
18637	23426	158	202	202	CD
18637	23426	159	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23426	160	409	409	CD
18637	23426	161	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	162	1906	1906	CD
18637	23426	163	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23426	164	,	,	,
18637	23426	165	210	210	CD
18637	23426	166	Ayers	Ayers	NNPS
18637	23426	167	,	,	,
18637	23426	168	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23426	169	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23426	170	,	,	,
18637	23426	171	123	123	CD
18637	23426	172	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23426	173	443	443	CD
18637	23426	174	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	175	1887	1887	CD
18637	23426	176	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23426	177	,	,	,
18637	23426	178	351	351	CD
18637	23426	179	,	,	,
18637	23426	180	930	930	CD
18637	23426	181	,	,	,
18637	23426	182	933	933	CD
18637	23426	183	,	,	,
18637	23426	184	934	934	CD
18637	23426	185	B	B	NNP
18637	23426	186	Bacardi	Bacardi	NNP
18637	23426	187	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23426	188	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	189	v.	v.	IN
18637	23426	190	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	191	Domenech	Domenech	NNP
18637	23426	192	,	,	,
18637	23426	193	311	311	CD
18637	23426	194	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23426	195	150	150	CD
18637	23426	196	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	197	1940	1940	CD
18637	23426	198	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23426	199	,	,	,
18637	23426	200	418	418	CD
18637	23426	201	Baccus	Baccus	NNP
18637	23426	202	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	203	v.	v.	IN
18637	23426	204	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	205	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	23426	206	,	,	,
18637	23426	207	232	232	CD
18637	23426	208	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23426	209	334	334	CD
18637	23426	210	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	211	1914	1914	CD
18637	23426	212	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23426	213	,	,	,
18637	23426	214	1156	1156	CD
18637	23426	215	Bachtel	Bachtel	NNP
18637	23426	216	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	217	v.	v.	IN
18637	23426	218	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	219	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	23426	220	,	,	,
18637	23426	221	204	204	CD
18637	23426	222	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23426	223	36	36	CD
18637	23426	224	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	225	1907	1907	CD
18637	23426	226	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23426	227	,	,	,
18637	23426	228	1145	1145	CD
18637	23426	229	Backus	Backus	NNP
18637	23426	230	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	231	v.	v.	IN
18637	23426	232	_	_	NNP
18637	23426	233	Lebanon	Lebanon	NNP
18637	23426	234	,	,	,
18637	23426	235	11	11	CD
18637	23426	236	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	23426	237	19	19	CD
18637	23426	238	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	239	1840	1840	CD
18637	23426	240	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23426	241	,	,	,
18637	23426	242	350	350	CD
18637	23426	243	Backus	Backus	NNP
18637	23426	244	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23426	245	A.	a.	NN
18637	23426	246	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23427	1	Jr.	Jr.	NNP
18637	23427	2	&	&	CC
18637	23427	3	Sons	Sons	NNP
18637	23427	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23427	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	23427	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23427	7	Port	Port	NNP
18637	23427	8	Street	Street	NNP
18637	23427	9	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23427	10	Depot	Depot	NNP
18637	23427	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23427	12	,	,	,
18637	23427	13	169	169	CD
18637	23427	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23427	15	577	577	CD
18637	23427	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23427	17	1898	1898	CD
18637	23427	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23427	19	,	,	,
18637	23427	20	1066	1066	CD
18637	23427	21	Bacon	Bacon	NNP
18637	23427	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23427	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23427	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23427	25	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	23427	26	,	,	,
18637	23427	27	20	20	CD
18637	23427	28	How	how	WRB
18637	23427	29	.	.	.
18637	23428	1	22	22	CD
18637	23428	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23428	3	1858	1858	CD
18637	23428	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23428	5	,	,	,
18637	23428	6	654	654	CD
18637	23428	7	Bacon	Bacon	NNP
18637	23428	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23428	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23428	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23428	11	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23428	12	,	,	,
18637	23428	13	227	227	CD
18637	23428	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23428	15	504	504	CD
18637	23428	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23428	17	1913	1913	CD
18637	23428	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23428	19	,	,	,
18637	23428	20	185	185	CD
18637	23428	21	Bacon	Bacon	NNP
18637	23428	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23428	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23428	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23428	25	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23428	26	,	,	,
18637	23428	27	163	163	CD
18637	23428	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23428	29	207	207	CD
18637	23428	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23428	31	1896	1896	CD
18637	23428	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23428	33	,	,	,
18637	23428	34	330	330	CD
18637	23428	35	Bacon	Bacon	NNP
18637	23428	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23428	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23428	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23428	39	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	23428	40	,	,	,
18637	23428	41	204	204	CD
18637	23428	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23428	43	311	311	CD
18637	23428	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23428	45	1907	1907	CD
18637	23428	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23428	47	,	,	,
18637	23428	48	982	982	CD
18637	23428	49	,	,	,
18637	23428	50	1028	1028	CD
18637	23428	51	,	,	,
18637	23428	52	1154	1154	CD
18637	23428	53	Bacon	Bacon	NNP
18637	23428	54	&	&	CC
18637	23428	55	Sons	Sons	NNPS
18637	23428	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23428	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	23428	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23428	59	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	23428	60	,	,	,
18637	23428	61	305	305	CD
18637	23428	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23428	63	380	380	CD
18637	23428	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23428	65	1939	1939	CD
18637	23428	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23428	67	,	,	,
18637	23428	68	190	190	CD
18637	23428	69	Badders	Badders	NNPS
18637	23428	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23428	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	23428	72	_	_	NNP
18637	23428	73	United	United	NNP
18637	23428	74	States	States	NNP
18637	23428	75	,	,	,
18637	23428	76	240	240	CD
18637	23428	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23428	78	391	391	CD
18637	23428	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23428	80	1916	1916	CD
18637	23428	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23428	82	,	,	,
18637	23428	83	905	905	CD
18637	23428	84	Baender	Baender	NNP
18637	23428	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23428	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	23428	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23428	88	Barnett	Barnett	NNP
18637	23428	89	,	,	,
18637	23428	90	255	255	CD
18637	23428	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23428	92	224	224	CD
18637	23428	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23428	94	1921	1921	CD
18637	23428	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23428	96	,	,	,
18637	23428	97	266	266	CD
18637	23428	98	Bagnell	Bagnell	NNP
18637	23428	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23428	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	23428	101	_	_	NNP
18637	23428	102	Broderick	Broderick	NNP
18637	23428	103	,	,	,
18637	23428	104	13	13	CD
18637	23428	105	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23428	106	.	.	.
18637	23429	1	436	436	CD
18637	23429	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23429	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	23429	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23429	5	,	,	,
18637	23429	6	702	702	CD
18637	23429	7	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	23429	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23429	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	11	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	23429	12	,	,	,
18637	23429	13	219	219	CD
18637	23429	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23429	15	219	219	CD
18637	23429	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23429	17	1911	1911	CD
18637	23429	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23429	19	,	,	,
18637	23429	20	950	950	CD
18637	23429	21	,	,	,
18637	23429	22	951	951	CD
18637	23429	23	,	,	,
18637	23429	24	1094	1094	CD
18637	23429	25	,	,	,
18637	23429	26	1095	1095	CD
18637	23429	27	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	23429	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23429	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	31	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	23429	32	,	,	,
18637	23429	33	326	326	CD
18637	23429	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23429	35	203	203	CD
18637	23429	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23429	37	1945	1945	CD
18637	23429	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23429	39	,	,	,
18637	23429	40	1070	1070	CD
18637	23429	41	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	23429	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23429	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	45	Drexel	Drexel	NNP
18637	23429	46	Furniture	Furniture	NNP
18637	23429	47	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23429	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23429	49	Child	Child	NNP
18637	23429	50	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	23429	51	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23429	52	Case	Case	NNP
18637	23429	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23429	54	,	,	,
18637	23429	55	259	259	CD
18637	23429	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23429	57	20	20	CD
18637	23429	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23429	59	1922	1922	CD
18637	23429	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23429	61	,	,	,
18637	23429	62	111	111	CD
18637	23429	63	,	,	,
18637	23429	64	564	564	CD
18637	23429	65	,	,	,
18637	23429	66	918	918	CD
18637	23429	67	Bain	Bain	NNP
18637	23429	68	,	,	,
18637	23429	69	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23429	70	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23429	71	,	,	,
18637	23429	72	121	121	CD
18637	23429	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23429	74	1	1	CD
18637	23429	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23429	76	1837	1837	CD
18637	23429	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23429	78	,	,	,
18637	23429	79	838	838	CD
18637	23429	80	Bain	Bain	NNP
18637	23429	81	Peanut	Peanut	NNP
18637	23429	82	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23429	83	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	23429	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	86	Pinson	Pinson	NNP
18637	23429	87	,	,	,
18637	23429	88	282	282	CD
18637	23429	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23429	90	499	499	CD
18637	23429	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23429	92	1931	1931	CD
18637	23429	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23429	94	,	,	,
18637	23429	95	1167	1167	CD
18637	23429	96	Baiz	Baiz	NNP
18637	23429	97	,	,	,
18637	23429	98	In	in	IN
18637	23429	99	re	re	NN
18637	23429	100	,	,	,
18637	23429	101	135	135	CD
18637	23429	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23429	103	403	403	CD
18637	23429	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23429	105	1890	1890	CD
18637	23429	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23429	107	,	,	,
18637	23429	108	473	473	CD
18637	23429	109	,	,	,
18637	23429	110	572	572	CD
18637	23429	111	Baizley	Baizley	NNP
18637	23429	112	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	23429	113	Works	Works	NNP
18637	23429	114	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	115	v.	v.	IN
18637	23429	116	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	117	Span	Span	NNP
18637	23429	118	,	,	,
18637	23429	119	281	281	CD
18637	23429	120	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23429	121	222	222	CD
18637	23429	122	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23429	123	1930	1930	CD
18637	23429	124	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23429	125	,	,	,
18637	23429	126	581	581	CD
18637	23429	127	,	,	,
18637	23429	128	582	582	CD
18637	23429	129	Bakelite	Bakelite	NNP
18637	23429	130	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	23429	131	,	,	,
18637	23429	132	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23429	133	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23429	134	,	,	,
18637	23429	135	279	279	CD
18637	23429	136	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23429	137	438	438	CD
18637	23429	138	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23429	139	1929	1929	CD
18637	23429	140	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23429	141	,	,	,
18637	23429	142	311	311	CD
18637	23429	143	,	,	,
18637	23429	144	534	534	CD
18637	23429	145	,	,	,
18637	23429	146	536	536	CD
18637	23429	147	Baker	Baker	NNP
18637	23429	148	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	149	v.	v.	IN
18637	23429	150	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	151	Baker	Baker	NNP
18637	23429	152	,	,	,
18637	23429	153	E.	E.	NNP
18637	23429	154	&	&	CC
18637	23429	155	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23429	156	,	,	,
18637	23429	157	242	242	CD
18637	23429	158	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23429	159	394	394	CD
18637	23429	160	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23429	161	1917	1917	CD
18637	23429	162	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23429	163	,	,	,
18637	23429	164	1088	1088	CD
18637	23429	165	Baker	Baker	NNP
18637	23429	166	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	167	v.	v.	IN
18637	23429	168	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	169	Grice	Grice	NNP
18637	23429	170	,	,	,
18637	23429	171	169	169	CD
18637	23429	172	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23429	173	284	284	CD
18637	23429	174	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23429	175	1898	1898	CD
18637	23429	176	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23429	177	,	,	,
18637	23429	178	634	634	CD
18637	23429	179	Baker	Baker	NNP
18637	23429	180	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	181	v.	v.	IN
18637	23429	182	_	_	NNP
18637	23429	183	Morton	Morton	NNP
18637	23429	184	,	,	,
18637	23429	185	12	12	CD
18637	23429	186	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23429	187	.	.	.
18637	23430	1	150	150	CD
18637	23430	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23430	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	23430	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23430	5	,	,	,
18637	23430	6	699	699	CD
18637	23430	7	Baker	Baker	NNP
18637	23430	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23430	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23430	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23430	11	Selden	Selden	NNP
18637	23430	12	,	,	,
18637	23430	13	101	101	CD
18637	23430	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23430	15	99	99	CD
18637	23430	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23430	17	1880	1880	CD
18637	23430	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23430	19	,	,	,
18637	23430	20	275	275	CD
18637	23430	21	Bakery	Bakery	NNP
18637	23430	22	&	&	CC
18637	23430	23	Pastry	Pastry	NNP
18637	23430	24	Drivers	Drivers	NNPS
18637	23430	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23430	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23430	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23430	28	Wohl	Wohl	NNP
18637	23430	29	,	,	,
18637	23430	30	315	315	CD
18637	23430	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23430	32	769	769	CD
18637	23430	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23430	34	1942	1942	CD
18637	23430	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23430	36	,	,	,
18637	23430	37	782	782	CD
18637	23430	38	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	23430	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23430	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23430	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23430	42	Franks	Franks	NNP
18637	23430	43	,	,	,
18637	23430	44	120	120	CD
18637	23430	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23430	46	678	678	CD
18637	23430	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23430	48	1887	1887	CD
18637	23430	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23430	50	,	,	,
18637	23430	51	427	427	CD
18637	23430	52	,	,	,
18637	23430	53	688	688	CD
18637	23430	54	,	,	,
18637	23430	55	1176	1176	CD
18637	23430	56	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	23430	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23430	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	23430	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23430	60	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	23430	61	State	State	NNP
18637	23430	62	Traveling	Traveling	NNP
18637	23430	63	Men	Men	NNPS
18637	23430	64	's	's	POS
18637	23430	65	Assoc	Assoc	NNP
18637	23430	66	.	.	.
18637	23430	67	,	,	,
18637	23430	68	283	283	CD
18637	23430	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23430	70	522	522	CD
18637	23430	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23430	72	1931	1931	CD
18637	23430	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23430	74	,	,	,
18637	23430	75	684	684	CD
18637	23430	76	,	,	,
18637	23430	77	1140	1140	CD
18637	23430	78	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	23430	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23430	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	23430	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23430	82	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	23430	83	,	,	,
18637	23430	84	281	281	CD
18637	23430	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23430	86	586	586	CD
18637	23430	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23430	88	1930	1930	CD
18637	23430	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23430	90	,	,	,
18637	23430	91	1046	1046	CD
18637	23430	92	,	,	,
18637	23430	93	1114	1114	CD
18637	23430	94	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	23430	95	_	_	NNP
18637	23430	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	23430	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23430	98	Seelig	Seelig	NNP
18637	23430	99	,	,	,
18637	23430	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23430	101	G.A.F.	g.a.f.	NN
18637	23431	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23431	2	,	,	,
18637	23431	3	294	294	CD
18637	23431	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23431	5	511	511	CD
18637	23431	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23431	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	23431	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23431	9	,	,	,
18637	23431	10	241	241	CD
18637	23431	11	,	,	,
18637	23431	12	242	242	CD
18637	23431	13	,	,	,
18637	23431	14	244	244	CD
18637	23431	15	Ballard	Ballard	NNP
18637	23431	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23431	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23431	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23431	19	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	23431	20	,	,	,
18637	23431	21	204	204	CD
18637	23431	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23431	23	241	241	CD
18637	23431	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23431	25	1907	1907	CD
18637	23431	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23431	27	,	,	,
18637	23431	28	1071	1071	CD
18637	23431	29	,	,	,
18637	23431	30	1080	1080	CD
18637	23431	31	,	,	,
18637	23431	32	1092	1092	CD
18637	23431	33	,	,	,
18637	23431	34	1141	1141	CD
18637	23431	35	Baltic	Baltic	NNP
18637	23431	36	Min	Min	NNP
18637	23431	37	.	.	.
18637	23432	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23432	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23432	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23432	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23432	5	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	23432	6	,	,	,
18637	23432	7	231	231	CD
18637	23432	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23432	9	68	68	CD
18637	23432	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23432	11	1913	1913	CD
18637	23432	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23432	13	,	,	,
18637	23432	14	197	197	CD
18637	23432	15	,	,	,
18637	23432	16	1150	1150	CD
18637	23432	17	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23432	18	&	&	CC
18637	23432	19	C.	C.	NNP
18637	23432	20	Line	Line	NNP
18637	23432	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23432	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	23432	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23432	24	Redman	Redman	NNP
18637	23432	25	,	,	,
18637	23432	26	295	295	CD
18637	23432	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23432	28	654	654	CD
18637	23432	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23432	30	1935	1935	CD
18637	23432	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23432	32	,	,	,
18637	23432	33	891	891	CD
18637	23432	34	,	,	,
18637	23432	35	892	892	CD
18637	23432	36	,	,	,
18637	23432	37	897	897	CD
18637	23432	38	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23432	39	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23432	40	.	.	.
18637	23433	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23433	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23433	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23433	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23433	5	State	State	NNP
18637	23433	6	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23433	7	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	23433	8	.	.	.
18637	23433	9	,	,	,
18637	23433	10	297	297	CD
18637	23433	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23433	12	209	209	CD
18637	23433	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23433	14	1936	1936	CD
18637	23433	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23433	16	,	,	,
18637	23433	17	734	734	CD
18637	23433	18	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23433	19	&	&	CC
18637	23433	20	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	23434	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23434	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23434	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23434	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23434	5	Baugh	Baugh	NNP
18637	23434	6	,	,	,
18637	23434	7	149	149	CD
18637	23434	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23434	9	368	368	CD
18637	23434	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23434	11	1893	1893	CD
18637	23434	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23434	13	,	,	,
18637	23434	14	604	604	CD
18637	23434	15	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23434	16	&	&	CC
18637	23434	17	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	23435	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23435	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23435	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23435	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23435	5	Hostetter	Hostetter	NNP
18637	23435	6	,	,	,
18637	23435	7	240	240	CD
18637	23435	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23435	9	620	620	CD
18637	23435	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23435	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	23435	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23435	13	,	,	,
18637	23435	14	674	674	CD
18637	23435	15	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23435	16	&	&	CC
18637	23435	17	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	23436	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23436	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23436	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23436	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23436	5	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23436	6	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	23436	7	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	23436	8	.	.	NNP
18637	23436	9	,	,	,
18637	23436	10	221	221	CD
18637	23436	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23436	12	612	612	CD
18637	23436	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23436	14	1911	1911	CD
18637	23436	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23436	16	,	,	,
18637	23436	17	140	140	CD
18637	23436	18	,	,	,
18637	23436	19	827	827	CD
18637	23436	20	,	,	,
18637	23436	21	855	855	CD
18637	23436	22	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23436	23	&	&	CC
18637	23436	24	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	23437	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23437	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23437	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23437	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23437	5	Nesbit	Nesbit	NNP
18637	23437	6	,	,	,
18637	23437	7	10	10	CD
18637	23437	8	How	how	WRB
18637	23437	9	.	.	.
18637	23438	1	395	395	CD
18637	23438	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23438	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	23438	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23438	5	,	,	,
18637	23438	6	327	327	CD
18637	23438	7	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23438	8	Shipbuilding	Shipbuilding	NNP
18637	23438	9	&	&	CC
18637	23438	10	Dry	Dry	NNP
18637	23438	11	Dock	Dock	NNP
18637	23438	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23438	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23438	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	23438	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23438	16	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23438	17	,	,	,
18637	23438	18	195	195	CD
18637	23438	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23438	20	375	375	CD
18637	23438	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23438	22	1904	1904	CD
18637	23438	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23438	24	,	,	,
18637	23438	25	732	732	CD
18637	23438	26	Balzac	Balzac	NNP
18637	23438	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23438	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	23438	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23438	30	Porto	Porto	NNP
18637	23438	31	Rico	Rico	NNP
18637	23438	32	,	,	,
18637	23438	33	258	258	CD
18637	23438	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23438	35	298	298	CD
18637	23438	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23438	37	1922	1922	CD
18637	23438	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23438	39	,	,	,
18637	23438	40	703	703	CD
18637	23438	41	,	,	,
18637	23438	42	877	877	CD
18637	23438	43	Bandini	Bandini	NNP
18637	23438	44	Petroleum	Petroleum	NNP
18637	23438	45	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23438	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23438	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	23438	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23438	49	Superior	Superior	NNP
18637	23438	50	Court	Court	NNP
18637	23438	51	,	,	,
18637	23438	52	284	284	CD
18637	23438	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23438	54	8	8	CD
18637	23438	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23438	56	1931	1931	CD
18637	23438	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23438	58	,	,	,
18637	23438	59	1026	1026	CD
18637	23438	60	,	,	,
18637	23438	61	1096	1096	CD
18637	23438	62	Banholzer	Banholzer	NNP
18637	23438	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23438	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	23438	65	_	_	NNP
18637	23438	66	New	New	NNP
18637	23438	67	York	York	NNP
18637	23438	68	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23438	69	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23438	70	.	.	.
18637	23439	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23439	2	,	,	,
18637	23439	3	178	178	CD
18637	23439	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23439	5	402	402	CD
18637	23439	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23439	7	1900	1900	CD
18637	23439	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23439	9	,	,	,
18637	23439	10	676	676	CD
18637	23439	11	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23439	12	of	of	IN
18637	23439	13	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	23439	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23439	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23439	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23439	17	Dalton	Dalton	NNP
18637	23439	18	,	,	,
18637	23439	19	9	9	CD
18637	23439	20	How	how	WRB
18637	23439	21	.	.	.
18637	23440	1	522	522	CD
18637	23440	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23440	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	23440	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23440	5	,	,	,
18637	23440	6	654	654	CD
18637	23440	7	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23440	8	of	of	IN
18637	23440	9	Augusta	Augusta	NNP
18637	23440	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23440	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23440	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23440	13	Earle	Earle	NNP
18637	23440	14	,	,	,
18637	23440	15	13	13	CD
18637	23440	16	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23440	17	.	.	.
18637	23441	1	519	519	CD
18637	23441	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23441	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	23441	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23441	5	,	,	,
18637	23441	6	198	198	CD
18637	23441	7	,	,	,
18637	23441	8	675	675	CD
18637	23441	9	,	,	,
18637	23441	10	688	688	CD
18637	23441	11	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23441	12	of	of	IN
18637	23441	13	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23441	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23441	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23441	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23441	17	Wister	Wister	NNP
18637	23441	18	,	,	,
18637	23441	19	2	2	CD
18637	23441	20	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23441	21	.	.	.
18637	23442	1	318	318	CD
18637	23442	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23442	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	23442	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23442	5	,	,	,
18637	23442	6	930	930	CD
18637	23442	7	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23442	8	of	of	IN
18637	23442	9	Minden	Minden	NNP
18637	23442	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23442	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23442	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23442	13	Clement	Clement	NNP
18637	23442	14	,	,	,
18637	23442	15	256	256	CD
18637	23442	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23442	17	126	126	CD
18637	23442	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23442	19	1921	1921	CD
18637	23442	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23442	21	,	,	,
18637	23442	22	356	356	CD
18637	23442	23	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23442	24	of	of	IN
18637	23442	25	United	United	NNP
18637	23442	26	States	States	NNP
18637	23442	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23442	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	23442	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23442	30	Deveaux	Deveaux	NNP
18637	23442	31	,	,	,
18637	23442	32	5	5	CD
18637	23442	33	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23442	34	.	.	.
18637	23443	1	61	61	CD
18637	23443	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23443	3	1809	1809	CD
18637	23443	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23443	5	,	,	,
18637	23443	6	568	568	CD
18637	23443	7	,	,	,
18637	23443	8	601	601	CD
18637	23443	9	,	,	,
18637	23443	10	618	618	CD
18637	23443	11	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23443	12	of	of	IN
18637	23443	13	United	United	NNP
18637	23443	14	States	States	NNP
18637	23443	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23443	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	23443	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23443	18	Halstead	Halstead	NNP
18637	23443	19	,	,	,
18637	23443	20	10	10	CD
18637	23443	21	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23443	22	.	.	.
18637	23444	1	51	51	CD
18637	23444	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23444	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	23444	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23444	5	,	,	,
18637	23444	6	311	311	CD
18637	23444	7	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23444	8	of	of	IN
18637	23444	9	the	the	DT
18637	23444	10	United	United	NNP
18637	23444	11	States	States	NNP
18637	23444	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23444	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23444	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23444	15	Planters	Planters	NNPS
18637	23444	16	'	'	POS
18637	23444	17	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23444	18	of	of	IN
18637	23444	19	Ga.	Georgia	NNP
18637	23444	20	,	,	,
18637	23444	21	9	9	CD
18637	23444	22	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23444	23	.	.	.
18637	23445	1	904	904	CD
18637	23445	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23445	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	23445	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23445	5	,	,	,
18637	23445	6	930	930	CD
18637	23445	7	Banker	Banker	NNP
18637	23445	8	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	23445	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23445	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23445	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23445	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23445	13	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	23445	14	,	,	,
18637	23445	15	222	222	CD
18637	23445	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23445	17	210	210	CD
18637	23445	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23445	19	1911	1911	CD
18637	23445	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23445	21	,	,	,
18637	23445	22	188	188	CD
18637	23445	23	Bankers	Bankers	NNPS
18637	23445	24	Pocahontas	Pocahontas	NNP
18637	23445	25	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	23445	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23445	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23445	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	23445	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23445	30	Burnet	Burnet	NNP
18637	23445	31	,	,	,
18637	23445	32	287	287	CD
18637	23445	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23445	34	308	308	CD
18637	23445	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23445	36	1932	1932	CD
18637	23445	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23445	38	,	,	,
18637	23445	39	1200	1200	CD
18637	23445	40	Bankers	Bankers	NNPS
18637	23445	41	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23445	42	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23445	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23445	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	23445	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23445	46	Blodgett	Blodgett	NNP
18637	23445	47	,	,	,
18637	23445	48	260	260	CD
18637	23445	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23445	50	647	647	CD
18637	23445	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23445	52	1923	1923	CD
18637	23445	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23445	54	,	,	,
18637	23445	55	316	316	CD
18637	23445	56	,	,	,
18637	23445	57	1061	1061	CD
18637	23445	58	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	23445	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23445	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23445	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23445	62	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	23445	63	,	,	,
18637	23445	64	21	21	CD
18637	23445	65	How	how	WRB
18637	23445	66	.	.	.
18637	23446	1	582	582	CD
18637	23446	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23446	3	1859	1859	CD
18637	23446	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23446	5	,	,	,
18637	23446	6	671	671	CD
18637	23446	7	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	23446	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23446	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23446	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23446	11	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	23446	12	,	,	,
18637	23446	13	323	323	CD
18637	23446	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23446	15	77	77	CD
18637	23446	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23446	17	1944	1944	CD
18637	23446	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23446	19	,	,	,
18637	23446	20	671	671	CD
18637	23446	21	Barbier	Barbier	NNP
18637	23446	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23446	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23446	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23446	25	Connolly	Connolly	NNP
18637	23446	26	,	,	,
18637	23446	27	113	113	CD
18637	23446	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23446	29	27	27	CD
18637	23446	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23446	31	1885	1885	CD
18637	23446	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23446	33	,	,	,
18637	23446	34	1029	1029	CD
18637	23446	35	,	,	,
18637	23446	36	1145	1145	CD
18637	23446	37	Barbour	Barbour	NNP
18637	23446	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23446	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23446	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23446	41	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23446	42	,	,	,
18637	23446	43	249	249	CD
18637	23446	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23446	45	454	454	CD
18637	23446	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23446	47	1919	1919	CD
18637	23446	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23446	49	,	,	,
18637	23446	50	1032	1032	CD
18637	23446	51	Barnes	Barnes	NNPS
18637	23446	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23446	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	23446	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23446	55	Barnes	Barnes	NNPS
18637	23446	56	,	,	,
18637	23446	57	8	8	CD
18637	23446	58	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	23446	59	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23446	60	53	53	CD
18637	23446	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23446	62	N.C.	North Carolina	NNP
18637	23446	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23446	64	366	366	CD
18637	23446	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23446	66	1861	1861	CD
18637	23446	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23446	68	,	,	,
18637	23446	69	336	336	CD
18637	23446	70	Barnett	Barnett	NNP
18637	23446	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23446	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	23446	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23446	74	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	23446	75	,	,	,
18637	23446	76	151	151	CD
18637	23446	77	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23446	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23446	79	2d	2d	NNP
18637	23446	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23446	81	77	77	CD
18637	23446	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23446	83	1945	1945	CD
18637	23446	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23446	85	,	,	,
18637	23446	86	1234	1234	CD
18637	23446	87	Barnett	Barnett	NNP
18637	23446	88	_	_	NNP
18637	23446	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	23446	90	_	_	NNP
18637	23446	91	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	23446	92	,	,	,
18637	23446	93	326	326	CD
18637	23446	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23446	95	766	766	CD
18637	23446	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23446	97	1945	1945	CD
18637	23446	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23446	99	,	,	,
18637	23446	100	1234	1234	CD
18637	23446	101	Barney	Barney	NNP
18637	23446	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23446	103	v.	v.	IN
18637	23446	104	_	_	NNP
18637	23446	105	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23446	106	,	,	,
18637	23446	107	6	6	CD
18637	23446	108	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23446	109	.	.	.
18637	23447	1	280	280	CD
18637	23447	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23447	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	23447	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23447	5	,	,	,
18637	23447	6	302	302	CD
18637	23447	7	Barney	Barney	NNP
18637	23447	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23447	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23447	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23447	11	City	City	NNP
18637	23447	12	of	of	IN
18637	23447	13	New	New	NNP
18637	23447	14	York	York	NNP
18637	23447	15	,	,	,
18637	23447	16	193	193	CD
18637	23447	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23447	18	430	430	CD
18637	23447	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23447	20	1904	1904	CD
18637	23447	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23447	22	,	,	,
18637	23447	23	1177	1177	CD
18637	23447	24	Barnitz	Barnitz	NNP
18637	23447	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23447	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23447	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23447	28	Beverly	Beverly	NNP
18637	23447	29	,	,	,
18637	23447	30	163	163	CD
18637	23447	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23447	32	118	118	CD
18637	23447	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23447	34	1896	1896	CD
18637	23447	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23447	36	,	,	,
18637	23447	37	360	360	CD
18637	23447	38	Barrett	Barrett	NNP
18637	23447	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23447	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23447	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23447	42	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	23447	43	,	,	,
18637	23447	44	299	299	CD
18637	23447	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23447	46	26	26	CD
18637	23447	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23447	48	1913	1913	CD
18637	23447	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23447	50	,	,	,
18637	23447	51	987	987	CD
18637	23447	52	,	,	,
18637	23447	53	1145	1145	CD
18637	23447	54	Barrett	Barrett	NNP
18637	23447	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23447	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	23447	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23447	58	New	New	NNP
18637	23447	59	York	York	NNP
18637	23447	60	,	,	,
18637	23447	61	232	232	CD
18637	23447	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23447	63	14	14	CD
18637	23447	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23447	65	1914	1914	CD
18637	23447	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23447	67	,	,	,
18637	23447	68	247	247	CD
18637	23447	69	Barron	Barron	NNP
18637	23447	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23447	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	23447	72	_	_	NNP
18637	23447	73	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23447	74	,	,	,
18637	23447	75	7	7	CD
18637	23447	76	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	23447	77	.	.	.
18637	23448	1	243	243	CD
18637	23448	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23448	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	23448	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23448	5	,	,	,
18637	23448	6	751	751	CD
18637	23448	7	,	,	,
18637	23448	8	1062	1062	CD
18637	23448	9	Barron	Barron	NNP
18637	23448	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23448	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23448	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23448	13	Burnside	Burnside	NNP
18637	23448	14	,	,	,
18637	23448	15	121	121	CD
18637	23448	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23448	17	186	186	CD
18637	23448	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23448	19	1887	1887	CD
18637	23448	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23448	21	,	,	,
18637	23448	22	638	638	CD
18637	23448	23	Barrow	Barrow	NNP
18637	23448	24	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	23448	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23448	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23448	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23448	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23448	29	Kane	Kane	NNP
18637	23448	30	,	,	,
18637	23448	31	170	170	CD
18637	23448	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23448	33	100	100	CD
18637	23448	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23448	35	1898	1898	CD
18637	23448	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23448	37	,	,	,
18637	23448	38	638	638	CD
18637	23448	39	Barry	Barry	NNP
18637	23448	40	,	,	,
18637	23448	41	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23448	42	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23448	43	,	,	,
18637	23448	44	2	2	CD
18637	23448	45	How	how	WRB
18637	23448	46	.	.	.
18637	23449	1	65	65	CD
18637	23449	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23449	3	1844	1844	CD
18637	23449	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23449	5	,	,	,
18637	23449	6	612	612	CD
18637	23449	7	Barry	Barry	NNP
18637	23449	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23449	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23449	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23449	11	Mercein	Mercein	NNP
18637	23449	12	,	,	,
18637	23449	13	5	5	CD
18637	23449	14	How	how	WRB
18637	23449	15	.	.	.
18637	23450	1	103	103	CD
18637	23450	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23450	3	1847	1847	CD
18637	23450	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23450	5	,	,	,
18637	23450	6	616	616	CD
18637	23450	7	Barry	Barry	NNP
18637	23450	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23450	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23450	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23450	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23450	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23450	13	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23450	14	rel	rel	NN
18637	23450	15	.	.	.
18637	23451	1	Cunningham	Cunningham	NNP
18637	23451	2	,	,	,
18637	23451	3	279	279	CD
18637	23451	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23451	5	597	597	CD
18637	23451	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23451	7	1929	1929	CD
18637	23451	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23451	9	,	,	,
18637	23451	10	85	85	CD
18637	23451	11	,	,	,
18637	23451	12	96	96	CD
18637	23451	13	Barsky	Barsky	NNP
18637	23451	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23451	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23451	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23451	17	United	United	NNP
18637	23451	18	States	States	NNP
18637	23451	19	,	,	,
18637	23451	20	334	334	CD
18637	23451	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23451	22	843	843	CD
18637	23451	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23451	24	1948	1948	CD
18637	23451	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23451	26	,	,	,
18637	23451	27	100	100	CD
18637	23451	28	Barsky	Barsky	NNP
18637	23451	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23451	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	23451	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23451	32	United	United	NNP
18637	23451	33	States	States	NNP
18637	23451	34	,	,	,
18637	23451	35	167	167	CD
18637	23451	36	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23451	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23451	38	2d	2d	NNP
18637	23451	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23451	40	241	241	CD
18637	23451	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23451	42	1948	1948	CD
18637	23451	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23451	44	,	,	,
18637	23451	45	100	100	CD
18637	23451	46	Bartell	Bartell	NNP
18637	23451	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23451	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	23451	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23451	50	United	United	NNP
18637	23451	51	States	States	NNP
18637	23451	52	,	,	,
18637	23451	53	227	227	CD
18637	23451	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23451	55	427	427	CD
18637	23451	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23451	57	1913	1913	CD
18637	23451	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23451	59	,	,	,
18637	23451	60	884	884	CD
18637	23451	61	Bartemeyer	Bartemeyer	NNP
18637	23451	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23451	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	23451	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23451	65	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	23451	66	,	,	,
18637	23451	67	18	18	CD
18637	23451	68	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23451	69	.	.	.
18637	23452	1	129	129	CD
18637	23452	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23452	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	23452	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23452	5	,	,	,
18637	23452	6	971	971	CD
18637	23452	7	Barton	Barton	NNP
18637	23452	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23452	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23452	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23452	11	Barbour	Barbour	NNP
18637	23452	12	,	,	,
18637	23452	13	104	104	CD
18637	23452	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23452	15	126	126	CD
18637	23452	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23452	17	1881	1881	CD
18637	23452	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23452	19	,	,	,
18637	23452	20	893	893	CD
18637	23452	21	Barwise	Barwise	NNP
18637	23452	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23452	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23452	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23452	25	Sheppard	Sheppard	NNP
18637	23452	26	,	,	,
18637	23452	27	299	299	CD
18637	23452	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23452	29	33	33	CD
18637	23452	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23452	31	1936	1936	CD
18637	23452	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23452	33	,	,	,
18637	23452	34	1039	1039	CD
18637	23452	35	Bas	Bas	NNP
18637	23452	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23452	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23452	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23452	39	Tingy	Tingy	NNP
18637	23452	40	,	,	,
18637	23452	41	4	4	CD
18637	23452	42	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	23452	43	.	.	.
18637	23453	1	37	37	CD
18637	23453	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23453	3	1800	1800	CD
18637	23453	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23453	5	,	,	,
18637	23453	6	282	282	CD
18637	23453	7	,	,	,
18637	23453	8	423	423	CD
18637	23453	9	Bass	Bass	NNP
18637	23453	10	,	,	,
18637	23453	11	Ratcliff	Ratcliff	NNP
18637	23453	12	&	&	CC
18637	23453	13	Gretton	Gretton	NNP
18637	23453	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23453	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23453	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23453	17	State	State	NNP
18637	23453	18	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23453	19	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23453	20	,	,	,
18637	23453	21	266	266	CD
18637	23453	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23453	23	271	271	CD
18637	23453	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23453	25	1924	1924	CD
18637	23453	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23453	27	,	,	,
18637	23453	28	203	203	CD
18637	23453	29	,	,	,
18637	23453	30	209	209	CD
18637	23453	31	,	,	,
18637	23453	32	1054	1054	CD
18637	23453	33	Bassing	Bassing	NNP
18637	23453	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23453	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23453	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23453	37	Cady	Cady	NNP
18637	23453	38	,	,	,
18637	23453	39	208	208	CD
18637	23453	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23453	41	386	386	CD
18637	23453	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23453	43	1908	1908	CD
18637	23453	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23453	45	,	,	,
18637	23453	46	695	695	CD
18637	23453	47	,	,	,
18637	23453	48	839	839	CD
18637	23453	49	Bates	Bates	NNP
18637	23453	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23453	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	23453	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23453	53	Bodie	Bodie	NNP
18637	23453	54	,	,	,
18637	23453	55	245	245	CD
18637	23453	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23453	57	520	520	CD
18637	23453	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23453	59	1918	1918	CD
18637	23453	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23453	61	,	,	,
18637	23453	62	671	671	CD
18637	23453	63	Battle	Battle	NNP
18637	23453	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23453	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	23453	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23453	67	United	United	NNP
18637	23453	68	States	States	NNP
18637	23453	69	,	,	,
18637	23453	70	209	209	CD
18637	23453	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23453	72	36	36	CD
18637	23453	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23453	74	1908	1908	CD
18637	23453	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23453	76	,	,	,
18637	23453	77	305	305	CD
18637	23453	78	Bauman	Bauman	NNP
18637	23453	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23453	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	23453	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23453	82	Ross	Ross	NNP
18637	23453	83	,	,	,
18637	23453	84	167	167	CD
18637	23453	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23453	86	548	548	CD
18637	23453	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23453	88	1897	1897	CD
18637	23453	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23453	90	,	,	,
18637	23453	91	872	872	CD
18637	23453	92	,	,	,
18637	23453	93	1059	1059	CD
18637	23453	94	Baumgartner	Baumgartner	NNP
18637	23453	95	_	_	NNP
18637	23453	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	23453	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23453	98	United	United	NNP
18637	23453	99	States	States	NNP
18637	23453	100	,	,	,
18637	23453	101	322	322	CD
18637	23453	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23453	103	665	665	CD
18637	23453	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23453	105	1944	1944	CD
18637	23453	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23453	107	,	,	,
18637	23453	108	257	257	CD
18637	23453	109	,	,	,
18637	23453	110	870	870	CD
18637	23453	111	Baylis	Baylis	NNP
18637	23453	112	_	_	NNP
18637	23453	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	23453	114	_	_	NNP
18637	23453	115	Travelers	Travelers	NNPS
18637	23453	116	'	'	POS
18637	23453	117	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23453	118	.	.	.
18637	23454	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23454	2	,	,	,
18637	23454	3	113	113	CD
18637	23454	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23454	5	316	316	CD
18637	23454	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23454	7	1885	1885	CD
18637	23454	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23454	9	,	,	,
18637	23454	10	897	897	CD
18637	23454	11	Bayside	Bayside	NNP
18637	23454	12	Fish	Fish	NNP
18637	23454	13	Flour	Flour	NNP
18637	23454	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23454	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23454	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	23454	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23454	18	Gentry	Gentry	NNP
18637	23454	19	,	,	,
18637	23454	20	297	297	CD
18637	23454	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23454	22	422	422	CD
18637	23454	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23454	24	1936	1936	CD
18637	23454	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23454	26	,	,	,
18637	23454	27	217	217	CD
18637	23454	28	,	,	,
18637	23454	29	237	237	CD
18637	23454	30	,	,	,
18637	23454	31	246	246	CD
18637	23454	32	,	,	,
18637	23454	33	1027	1027	CD
18637	23454	34	,	,	,
18637	23454	35	1154	1154	CD
18637	23454	36	Beal	Beal	NNP
18637	23454	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23454	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	23454	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23454	40	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	23454	41	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	23454	42	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23454	43	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23454	44	,	,	,
18637	23454	45	312	312	CD
18637	23454	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23454	47	45	45	CD
18637	23454	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23454	49	1941	1941	CD
18637	23454	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23454	51	,	,	,
18637	23454	52	631	631	CD
18637	23454	53	Beall	Beall	NNP
18637	23454	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23454	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	23454	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23454	57	New	New	NNP
18637	23454	58	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	23454	59	ex	ex	NN
18637	23454	60	rel	rel	NN
18637	23454	61	.	.	.
18637	23455	1	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	23455	2	,	,	,
18637	23455	3	16	16	CD
18637	23455	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23455	5	.	.	.
18637	23456	1	535	535	CD
18637	23456	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23456	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	23456	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23456	5	,	,	,
18637	23456	6	848	848	CD
18637	23456	7	Beauharnais	Beauharnais	NNP
18637	23456	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23456	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	11	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23456	12	,	,	,
18637	23456	13	343	343	CD
18637	23456	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23456	15	250	250	CD
18637	23456	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23456	17	1952	1952	CD
18637	23456	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23456	19	,	,	,
18637	23456	20	752	752	CD
18637	23456	21	,	,	,
18637	23456	22	802	802	CD
18637	23456	23	Beavers	Beavers	NNPS
18637	23456	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23456	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	27	Haubert	Haubert	NNP
18637	23456	28	,	,	,
18637	23456	29	198	198	CD
18637	23456	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23456	31	77	77	CD
18637	23456	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23456	33	1905	1905	CD
18637	23456	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23456	35	,	,	,
18637	23456	36	881	881	CD
18637	23456	37	Beavers	Beavers	NNPS
18637	23456	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23456	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	41	Henkel	Henkel	NNP
18637	23456	42	,	,	,
18637	23456	43	194	194	CD
18637	23456	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23456	45	73	73	CD
18637	23456	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23456	47	1904	1904	CD
18637	23456	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23456	49	,	,	,
18637	23456	50	881	881	CD
18637	23456	51	Beazell	Beazell	NNP
18637	23456	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	23456	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	55	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	23456	56	,	,	,
18637	23456	57	269	269	CD
18637	23456	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23456	59	167	167	CD
18637	23456	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23456	61	1925	1925	CD
18637	23456	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23456	63	,	,	,
18637	23456	64	329	329	CD
18637	23456	65	Becker	Becker	NNP
18637	23456	66	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	23456	67	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23456	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	23456	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	71	Cummings	Cummings	NNP
18637	23456	72	,	,	,
18637	23456	73	296	296	CD
18637	23456	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23456	75	74	74	CD
18637	23456	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23456	77	1935	1935	CD
18637	23456	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23456	79	,	,	,
18637	23456	80	865	865	CD
18637	23456	81	Bedford	Bedford	NNP
18637	23456	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	23456	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	85	United	United	NNP
18637	23456	86	States	States	NNP
18637	23456	87	,	,	,
18637	23456	88	192	192	CD
18637	23456	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23456	90	217	217	CD
18637	23456	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23456	92	1904	1904	CD
18637	23456	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23456	94	,	,	,
18637	23456	95	128	128	CD
18637	23456	96	Bedford	Bedford	NNP
18637	23456	97	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23456	98	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	99	v.	v.	IN
18637	23456	100	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	101	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	23456	102	Cutters	Cutters	NNPS
18637	23456	103	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	23456	104	.	.	.
18637	23456	105	,	,	,
18637	23456	106	274	274	CD
18637	23456	107	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23456	108	37	37	CD
18637	23456	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23456	110	1927	1927	CD
18637	23456	111	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23456	112	,	,	,
18637	23456	113	149	149	CD
18637	23456	114	Beidler	Beidler	NNP
18637	23456	115	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	116	v.	v.	IN
18637	23456	117	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	118	South	South	NNP
18637	23456	119	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	23456	120	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23456	121	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23456	122	,	,	,
18637	23456	123	282	282	CD
18637	23456	124	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23456	125	1	1	CD
18637	23456	126	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23456	127	1930	1930	CD
18637	23456	128	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23456	129	,	,	,
18637	23456	130	1047	1047	CD
18637	23456	131	Bekins	Bekins	NNP
18637	23456	132	Van	Van	NNP
18637	23456	133	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	23456	134	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	135	v.	v.	IN
18637	23456	136	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	137	Riley	Riley	NNP
18637	23456	138	,	,	,
18637	23456	139	280	280	CD
18637	23456	140	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23456	141	80	80	CD
18637	23456	142	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23456	143	1929	1929	CD
18637	23456	144	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23456	145	,	,	,
18637	23456	146	1151	1151	CD
18637	23456	147	"	"	``
18637	23456	148	Belfast	Belfast	NNP
18637	23456	149	,	,	,
18637	23456	150	"	"	''
18637	23456	151	The	the	DT
18637	23456	152	,	,	,
18637	23456	153	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	154	v.	v.	IN
18637	23456	155	_	_	NNP
18637	23456	156	Boon	Boon	NNP
18637	23456	157	,	,	,
18637	23456	158	7	7	CD
18637	23456	159	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23456	160	.	.	.
18637	23457	1	624	624	CD
18637	23457	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23457	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	23457	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23457	5	,	,	,
18637	23457	6	575	575	CD
18637	23457	7	Belknap	Belknap	NNP
18637	23457	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23457	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23457	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23457	11	Schild	Schild	NNP
18637	23457	12	,	,	,
18637	23457	13	161	161	CD
18637	23457	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23457	15	10	10	CD
18637	23457	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23457	17	1896	1896	CD
18637	23457	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23457	19	,	,	,
18637	23457	20	275	275	CD
18637	23457	21	,	,	,
18637	23457	22	590	590	CD
18637	23457	23	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	23457	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23457	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23457	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23457	27	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	23457	28	,	,	,
18637	23457	29	181	181	CD
18637	23457	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23457	31	175	175	CD
18637	23457	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23457	33	1901	1901	CD
18637	23457	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23457	35	,	,	,
18637	23457	36	665	665	CD
18637	23457	37	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	23457	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23457	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23457	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23457	41	Hood	Hood	NNP
18637	23457	42	,	,	,
18637	23457	43	327	327	CD
18637	23457	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23457	45	678	678	CD
18637	23457	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23457	47	1946	1946	CD
18637	23457	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23457	49	,	,	,
18637	23457	50	501	501	CD
18637	23457	51	,	,	,
18637	23457	52	567	567	CD
18637	23457	53	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	23457	54	's	's	POS
18637	23457	55	Gap	Gap	NNP
18637	23457	56	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23457	57	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23457	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23457	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	23457	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23457	61	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	23457	62	,	,	,
18637	23457	63	134	134	CD
18637	23457	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23457	65	232	232	CD
18637	23457	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23457	67	1890	1890	CD
18637	23457	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23457	69	,	,	,
18637	23457	70	1057	1057	CD
18637	23457	71	,	,	,
18637	23457	72	1146	1146	CD
18637	23457	73	,	,	,
18637	23457	74	1159	1159	CD
18637	23457	75	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	23457	76	Tele	Tele	NNP
18637	23457	77	.	.	.
18637	23458	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23458	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23458	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23458	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23458	5	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	23458	6	Public	Public	NNP
18637	23458	7	Util	Util	NNP
18637	23458	8	.	.	.
18637	23459	1	Com	Com	NNP
18637	23459	2	.	.	NNP
18637	23459	3	,	,	,
18637	23459	4	309	309	CD
18637	23459	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23459	6	30	30	CD
18637	23459	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23459	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	23459	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23459	10	,	,	,
18637	23459	11	232	232	CD
18637	23459	12	Benner	Benner	NNP
18637	23459	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23459	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	23459	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23459	16	Porter	Porter	NNP
18637	23459	17	,	,	,
18637	23459	18	9	9	CD
18637	23459	19	How	how	WRB
18637	23459	20	.	.	.
18637	23460	1	235	235	CD
18637	23460	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23460	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	23460	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23460	5	,	,	,
18637	23460	6	699	699	CD
18637	23460	7	Bennett	Bennett	NNP
18637	23460	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23460	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23460	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23460	11	Butterworth	Butterworth	NNP
18637	23460	12	,	,	,
18637	23460	13	11	11	CD
18637	23460	14	How	how	WRB
18637	23460	15	.	.	.
18637	23461	1	669	669	CD
18637	23461	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23461	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	23461	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23461	5	,	,	,
18637	23461	6	895	895	CD
18637	23461	7	Benson	Benson	NNP
18637	23461	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23461	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23461	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23461	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23461	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23461	13	,	,	,
18637	23461	14	146	146	CD
18637	23461	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23461	16	325	325	CD
18637	23461	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23461	18	1892	1892	CD
18637	23461	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23461	20	,	,	,
18637	23461	21	306	306	CD
18637	23461	22	Berea	Berea	NNP
18637	23461	23	College	College	NNP
18637	23461	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23461	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23461	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23461	27	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23461	28	,	,	,
18637	23461	29	211	211	CD
18637	23461	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23461	31	45	45	CD
18637	23461	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23461	33	1908	1908	CD
18637	23461	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23461	35	,	,	,
18637	23461	36	344	344	CD
18637	23461	37	,	,	,
18637	23461	38	562	562	CD
18637	23461	39	,	,	,
18637	23461	40	965	965	CD
18637	23461	41	Bergemann	Bergemann	NNP
18637	23461	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23461	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23461	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23461	45	Backer	Backer	NNP
18637	23461	46	,	,	,
18637	23461	47	157	157	CD
18637	23461	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23461	49	655	655	CD
18637	23461	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23461	51	1895	1895	CD
18637	23461	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23461	53	,	,	,
18637	23461	54	1141	1141	CD
18637	23461	55	Berizzi	Berizzi	NNP
18637	23461	56	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	23461	57	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23461	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23461	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	23461	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23461	61	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	23461	62	Pesaro	Pesaro	NNP
18637	23461	63	,	,	,
18637	23461	64	271	271	CD
18637	23461	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23461	66	562	562	CD
18637	23461	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23461	68	1926	1926	CD
18637	23461	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23461	70	,	,	,
18637	23461	71	609	609	NNP
18637	23461	72	Bernheimer	Bernheimer	NNP
18637	23461	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23461	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	23461	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23461	76	Converse	Converse	NNP
18637	23461	77	,	,	,
18637	23461	78	206	206	CD
18637	23461	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23461	80	516	516	CD
18637	23461	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23461	82	1907	1907	CD
18637	23461	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23461	84	,	,	,
18637	23461	85	355	355	CD
18637	23461	86	Bessette	Bessette	NNP
18637	23461	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23461	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	23461	89	_	_	NNP
18637	23461	90	W.B.	W.B.	NNP
18637	23462	1	Conkey	Conkey	NNP
18637	23462	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23462	3	,	,	,
18637	23462	4	194	194	CD
18637	23462	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23462	6	324	324	CD
18637	23462	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23462	8	1904	1904	CD
18637	23462	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23462	10	,	,	,
18637	23462	11	521	521	CD
18637	23462	12	Best	good	JJS
18637	23462	13	&	&	CC
18637	23462	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23462	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	23462	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	18	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	23462	19	,	,	,
18637	23462	20	311	311	CD
18637	23462	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23462	22	454	454	CD
18637	23462	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23462	24	1940	1940	CD
18637	23462	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23462	26	,	,	,
18637	23462	27	189	189	CD
18637	23462	28	Bethlehem	Bethlehem	NNP
18637	23462	29	Motors	Motors	NNPS
18637	23462	30	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23462	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	23462	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	34	Flynt	Flynt	NNP
18637	23462	35	,	,	,
18637	23462	36	256	256	CD
18637	23462	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23462	38	421	421	CD
18637	23462	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23462	40	1921	1921	CD
18637	23462	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23462	42	,	,	,
18637	23462	43	185	185	CD
18637	23462	44	Bethlehem	Bethlehem	NNP
18637	23462	45	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	23462	46	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23462	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	23462	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	50	New	New	NNP
18637	23462	51	York	York	NNP
18637	23462	52	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	23462	53	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	23462	54	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	23462	55	.	.	NNP
18637	23462	56	,	,	,
18637	23462	57	330	330	CD
18637	23462	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23462	59	767	767	CD
18637	23462	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23462	61	1947	1947	CD
18637	23462	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23462	63	,	,	,
18637	23462	64	136	136	CD
18637	23462	65	Betts	Betts	NNP
18637	23462	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23462	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	69	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	23462	70	,	,	,
18637	23462	71	316	316	CD
18637	23462	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23462	73	455	455	CD
18637	23462	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23462	75	1942	1942	CD
18637	23462	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23462	77	,	,	,
18637	23462	78	1099	1099	CD
18637	23462	79	,	,	,
18637	23462	80	1104	1104	CD
18637	23462	81	,	,	,
18637	23462	82	1105	1105	CD
18637	23462	83	,	,	,
18637	23462	84	1108	1108	CD
18637	23462	85	Biddinger	Biddinger	NNP
18637	23462	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	87	v.	v.	IN
18637	23462	88	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	89	Police	Police	NNP
18637	23462	90	Comr	Comr	NNP
18637	23462	91	.	.	.
18637	23462	92	,	,	,
18637	23462	93	245	245	CD
18637	23462	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23462	95	128	128	CD
18637	23462	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23462	97	1917	1917	CD
18637	23462	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23462	99	,	,	,
18637	23462	100	695	695	CD
18637	23462	101	Biddle	Biddle	NNP
18637	23462	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	103	v.	v.	IN
18637	23462	104	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	105	Perovich	Perovich	NNP
18637	23462	106	,	,	,
18637	23462	107	274	274	CD
18637	23462	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23462	109	480	480	CD
18637	23462	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23462	111	1927	1927	CD
18637	23462	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23462	113	,	,	,
18637	23462	114	407	407	CD
18637	23462	115	,	,	,
18637	23462	116	842	842	CD
18637	23462	117	Bier	Bier	NNP
18637	23462	118	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	23462	120	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	121	McGehee	McGehee	NNP
18637	23462	122	,	,	,
18637	23462	123	148	148	CD
18637	23462	124	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23462	125	137	137	CD
18637	23462	126	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23462	127	1893	1893	CD
18637	23462	128	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23462	129	,	,	,
18637	23462	130	329	329	CD
18637	23462	131	Bigelow	Bigelow	NNP
18637	23462	132	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	133	v.	v.	IN
18637	23462	134	_	_	NNP
18637	23462	135	Old	Old	NNP
18637	23462	136	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	23462	137	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	23462	138	Min	Min	NNP
18637	23462	139	.	.	.
18637	23463	1	&	&	CC
18637	23463	2	S.	S.	NNP
18637	23463	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23463	4	,	,	,
18637	23463	5	225	225	CD
18637	23463	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23463	7	111	111	CD
18637	23463	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23463	9	1912	1912	CD
18637	23463	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23463	11	,	,	,
18637	23463	12	654	654	CD
18637	23463	13	,	,	,
18637	23463	14	658	658	CD
18637	23463	15	,	,	,
18637	23463	16	660	660	CD
18637	23463	17	Billings	Billings	NNPS
18637	23463	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23463	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23463	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23463	21	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23463	22	,	,	,
18637	23463	23	188	188	CD
18637	23463	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23463	25	97	97	CD
18637	23463	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23463	27	1903	1903	CD
18637	23463	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23463	29	,	,	,
18637	23463	30	1151	1151	CD
18637	23463	31	Billings	Billings	NNP
18637	23463	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23463	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23463	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23463	35	United	United	NNP
18637	23463	36	States	States	NNP
18637	23463	37	,	,	,
18637	23463	38	232	232	CD
18637	23463	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23463	40	261	261	CD
18637	23463	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23463	42	1914	1914	CD
18637	23463	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23463	44	,	,	,
18637	23463	45	320	320	CD
18637	23463	46	,	,	,
18637	23463	47	863	863	CD
18637	23463	48	Bilokumsky	Bilokumsky	NNP
18637	23463	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23463	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	23463	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23463	52	Tod	Tod	NNP
18637	23463	53	,	,	,
18637	23463	54	263	263	CD
18637	23463	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23463	56	149	149	CD
18637	23463	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23463	58	1923	1923	CD
18637	23463	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23463	60	,	,	,
18637	23463	61	824	824	CD
18637	23463	62	Bi	Bi	NNP
18637	23463	63	-	-	HYPH
18637	23463	64	Metallic	Metallic	NNP
18637	23463	65	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23463	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23463	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23463	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23463	69	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	23463	70	,	,	,
18637	23463	71	239	239	CD
18637	23463	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23463	73	441	441	CD
18637	23463	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23463	75	1915	1915	CD
18637	23463	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23463	77	,	,	,
18637	23463	78	1059	1059	CD
18637	23463	79	,	,	,
18637	23463	80	1084	1084	CD
18637	23463	81	Binderup	Binderup	NNP
18637	23463	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23463	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	23463	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23463	85	Pathe	Pathe	NNP
18637	23463	86	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	23463	87	,	,	,
18637	23463	88	263	263	CD
18637	23463	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23463	90	291	291	CD
18637	23463	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23463	92	1923	1923	CD
18637	23463	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23463	94	,	,	,
18637	23463	95	567	567	CD
18637	23463	96	Bingaman	Bingaman	NNP
18637	23463	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23463	98	v.	v.	IN
18637	23463	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23463	100	Golden	Golden	NNP
18637	23463	101	Eagle	Eagle	NNP
18637	23463	102	Western	Western	NNP
18637	23463	103	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	23463	104	,	,	,
18637	23463	105	297	297	CD
18637	23463	106	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23463	107	626	626	CD
18637	23463	108	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23463	109	1936	1936	CD
18637	23463	110	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23463	111	,	,	,
18637	23463	112	186	186	CD
18637	23463	113	,	,	,
18637	23463	114	195	195	CD
18637	23463	115	Binghamton	Binghamton	NNP
18637	23463	116	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	23463	117	,	,	,
18637	23463	118	The	the	DT
18637	23463	119	,	,	,
18637	23463	120	3	3	CD
18637	23463	121	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23463	122	.	.	.
18637	23464	1	51	51	CD
18637	23464	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	3	1865	1865	CD
18637	23464	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	5	,	,	,
18637	23464	6	347	347	CD
18637	23464	7	Binney	Binney	NNP
18637	23464	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	11	Long	Long	NNP
18637	23464	12	,	,	,
18637	23464	13	299	299	CD
18637	23464	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	15	280	280	CD
18637	23464	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	17	1936	1936	CD
18637	23464	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	19	,	,	,
18637	23464	20	1039	1039	CD
18637	23464	21	Binns	Binns	NNP
18637	23464	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	25	United	United	NNP
18637	23464	26	States	States	NNP
18637	23464	27	,	,	,
18637	23464	28	194	194	CD
18637	23464	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	30	486	486	CD
18637	23464	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	32	1904	1904	CD
18637	23464	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	34	,	,	,
18637	23464	35	109	109	CD
18637	23464	36	,	,	,
18637	23464	37	703	703	CD
18637	23464	38	Bishop	Bishop	NNP
18637	23464	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	42	United	United	NNP
18637	23464	43	States	States	NNP
18637	23464	44	,	,	,
18637	23464	45	197	197	CD
18637	23464	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	47	334	334	CD
18637	23464	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	49	1905	1905	CD
18637	23464	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	51	,	,	,
18637	23464	52	476	476	CD
18637	23464	53	Black	Black	NNP
18637	23464	54	&	&	CC
18637	23464	55	White	White	NNP
18637	23464	56	Taxicab	Taxicab	NNP
18637	23464	57	&	&	CC
18637	23464	58	T.	T.	NNP
18637	23464	59	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23464	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	63	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23464	64	&	&	CC
18637	23464	65	Yellow	Yellow	NNP
18637	23464	66	Taxicab	Taxicab	NNP
18637	23464	67	&	&	CC
18637	23464	68	T.	T.	NNP
18637	23464	69	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23464	70	,	,	,
18637	23464	71	276	276	CD
18637	23464	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	73	518	518	CD
18637	23464	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	75	1928	1928	CD
18637	23464	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	77	,	,	,
18637	23464	78	603	603	CD
18637	23464	79	Blackmer	Blackmer	NNP
18637	23464	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	83	United	United	NNP
18637	23464	84	States	States	NNP
18637	23464	85	,	,	,
18637	23464	86	284	284	CD
18637	23464	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	88	421	421	CD
18637	23464	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	90	1932	1932	CD
18637	23464	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	92	,	,	,
18637	23464	93	540	540	CD
18637	23464	94	,	,	,
18637	23464	95	847	847	CD
18637	23464	96	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
18637	23464	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	98	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	100	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	23464	101	,	,	,
18637	23464	102	188	188	CD
18637	23464	103	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	104	189	189	CD
18637	23464	105	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	106	1903	1903	CD
18637	23464	107	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	108	,	,	,
18637	23464	109	1046	1046	CD
18637	23464	110	,	,	,
18637	23464	111	1047	1047	CD
18637	23464	112	Blair	Blair	NNP
18637	23464	113	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	114	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	115	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	116	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23464	117	,	,	,
18637	23464	118	201	201	CD
18637	23464	119	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	120	400	400	CD
18637	23464	121	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	122	1906	1906	CD
18637	23464	123	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	124	,	,	,
18637	23464	125	347	347	CD
18637	23464	126	Blake	Blake	NNP
18637	23464	127	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	128	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	129	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	130	McClung	McClung	NNP
18637	23464	131	,	,	,
18637	23464	132	172	172	CD
18637	23464	133	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	134	239	239	CD
18637	23464	135	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	136	1898	1898	CD
18637	23464	137	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	138	,	,	,
18637	23464	139	687	687	CD
18637	23464	140	,	,	,
18637	23464	141	690	690	CD
18637	23464	142	,	,	,
18637	23464	143	691	691	CD
18637	23464	144	,	,	,
18637	23464	145	1144	1144	CD
18637	23464	146	Blake	Blake	NNP
18637	23464	147	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	148	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	149	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	150	United	United	NNP
18637	23464	151	States	States	NNP
18637	23464	152	,	,	,
18637	23464	153	103	103	CD
18637	23464	154	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	155	227	227	CD
18637	23464	156	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	157	1881	1881	CD
18637	23464	158	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	159	,	,	,
18637	23464	160	460	460	CD
18637	23464	161	Blau	Blau	NNP
18637	23464	162	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	163	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	164	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	165	United	United	NNP
18637	23464	166	States	States	NNP
18637	23464	167	,	,	,
18637	23464	168	340	340	CD
18637	23464	169	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	170	159	159	CD
18637	23464	171	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	172	1950	1950	CD
18637	23464	173	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	174	,	,	,
18637	23464	175	843	843	CD
18637	23464	176	Blau	Blau	NNP
18637	23464	177	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	178	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	179	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	180	United	United	NNP
18637	23464	181	States	States	NNP
18637	23464	182	,	,	,
18637	23464	183	340	340	CD
18637	23464	184	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	185	332	332	CD
18637	23464	186	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	187	1951	1951	CD
18637	23464	188	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	189	,	,	,
18637	23464	190	843	843	CD
18637	23464	191	Bleistein	Bleistein	NNP
18637	23464	192	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	193	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	194	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	195	Donaldson	Donaldson	NNP
18637	23464	196	Lithographing	Lithographing	NNP
18637	23464	197	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23464	198	,	,	,
18637	23464	199	188	188	CD
18637	23464	200	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	201	239	239	CD
18637	23464	202	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	203	1903	1903	CD
18637	23464	204	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	205	,	,	,
18637	23464	206	276	276	CD
18637	23464	207	Blinn	Blinn	NNP
18637	23464	208	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	209	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	210	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	211	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	23464	212	,	,	,
18637	23464	213	222	222	CD
18637	23464	214	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	215	1	1	CD
18637	23464	216	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	217	1911	1911	CD
18637	23464	218	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	219	,	,	,
18637	23464	220	1093	1093	CD
18637	23464	221	Block	Block	NNP
18637	23464	222	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	223	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	224	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	225	Hirsh	Hirsh	NNP
18637	23464	226	,	,	,
18637	23464	227	256	256	CD
18637	23464	228	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	229	135	135	CD
18637	23464	230	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	231	1921	1921	CD
18637	23464	232	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	233	,	,	,
18637	23464	234	293	293	CD
18637	23464	235	,	,	,
18637	23464	236	296	296	CD
18637	23464	237	Blodgett	Blodgett	NNP
18637	23464	238	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	239	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	240	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	241	Holden	Holden	NNP
18637	23464	242	,	,	,
18637	23464	243	275	275	CD
18637	23464	244	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	245	142	142	CD
18637	23464	246	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	247	1927	1927	CD
18637	23464	248	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	249	,	,	,
18637	23464	250	863	863	CD
18637	23464	251	Blodgett	Blodgett	NNP
18637	23464	252	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	253	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	254	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	255	Silberman	Silberman	NNP
18637	23464	256	,	,	,
18637	23464	257	277	277	CD
18637	23464	258	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23464	259	1	1	CD
18637	23464	260	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23464	261	1928	1928	CD
18637	23464	262	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23464	263	,	,	,
18637	23464	264	673	673	CD
18637	23464	265	,	,	,
18637	23464	266	730	730	CD
18637	23464	267	,	,	,
18637	23464	268	1042	1042	CD
18637	23464	269	,	,	,
18637	23464	270	1045	1045	CD
18637	23464	271	Bloomer	Bloomer	NNP
18637	23464	272	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	273	v.	v.	IN
18637	23464	274	_	_	NNP
18637	23464	275	McQuewan	McQuewan	NNP
18637	23464	276	,	,	,
18637	23464	277	14	14	CD
18637	23464	278	How	how	WRB
18637	23464	279	.	.	.
18637	23465	1	539	539	CD
18637	23465	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23465	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	23465	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23465	5	,	,	,
18637	23465	6	271	271	CD
18637	23465	7	,	,	,
18637	23465	8	275	275	CD
18637	23465	9	Bloomer	Bloomer	NNP
18637	23465	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23465	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23465	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23465	13	Millinger	Millinger	NNP
18637	23465	14	,	,	,
18637	23465	15	1	1	CD
18637	23465	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23465	17	.	.	.
18637	23466	1	340	340	CD
18637	23466	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23466	3	1864	1864	CD
18637	23466	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23466	5	,	,	,
18637	23466	6	271	271	CD
18637	23466	7	Bluefield	Bluefield	NNP
18637	23466	8	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	23466	9	&	&	CC
18637	23466	10	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	23466	11	.	.	.
18637	23467	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23467	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23467	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23467	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23467	5	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	23467	6	.	.	.
18637	23468	1	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	23468	2	.	.	.
18637	23469	1	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	23469	2	.	.	NNP
18637	23469	3	,	,	,
18637	23469	4	262	262	CD
18637	23469	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23469	6	679	679	CD
18637	23469	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23469	8	1923	1923	CD
18637	23469	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23469	10	,	,	,
18637	23469	11	1006	1006	CD
18637	23469	12	Blumenstock	Blumenstock	NNP
18637	23469	13	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	23469	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23469	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23469	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23469	17	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	23469	18	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	23469	19	.	.	.
18637	23470	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23470	2	,	,	,
18637	23470	3	252	252	CD
18637	23470	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23470	5	436	436	CD
18637	23470	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23470	7	1920	1920	CD
18637	23470	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23470	9	,	,	,
18637	23470	10	120	120	CD
18637	23470	11	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23470	12	of	of	IN
18637	23470	13	Assessors	Assessors	NNPS
18637	23470	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23470	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23470	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23470	17	New	New	NNP
18637	23470	18	York	York	NNP
18637	23470	19	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23470	20	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23470	21	.	.	.
18637	23471	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23471	2	,	,	,
18637	23471	3	216	216	CD
18637	23471	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23471	5	517	517	CD
18637	23471	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23471	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	23471	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23471	9	,	,	,
18637	23471	10	1056	1056	CD
18637	23471	11	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23471	12	of	of	IN
18637	23471	13	Comms	Comms	NNP
18637	23471	14	.	.	.
18637	23472	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23472	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23472	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23472	4	Seber	Seber	NNP
18637	23472	5	,	,	,
18637	23472	6	318	318	CD
18637	23472	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23472	8	705	705	CD
18637	23472	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23472	10	1943	1943	CD
18637	23472	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23472	12	,	,	,
18637	23472	13	735	735	CD
18637	23472	14	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23472	15	of	of	IN
18637	23472	16	Councilmen	Councilmen	NNP
18637	23472	17	of	of	IN
18637	23472	18	Frankfort	Frankfort	NNP
18637	23472	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23472	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	23472	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23472	22	State	State	NNP
18637	23472	23	National	National	NNP
18637	23472	24	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23472	25	,	,	,
18637	23472	26	184	184	CD
18637	23472	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23472	28	696	696	CD
18637	23472	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23472	30	1902	1902	CD
18637	23472	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23472	32	,	,	,
18637	23472	33	567	567	CD
18637	23472	34	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23472	35	of	of	IN
18637	23472	36	Education	Education	NNP
18637	23472	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23472	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	23472	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23472	40	Barnette	Barnette	NNP
18637	23472	41	,	,	,
18637	23472	42	319	319	CD
18637	23472	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23472	44	624	624	CD
18637	23472	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23472	46	1943	1943	CD
18637	23472	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23472	48	,	,	,
18637	23472	49	563	563	CD
18637	23472	50	,	,	,
18637	23472	51	767	767	CD
18637	23472	52	,	,	,
18637	23472	53	786	786	CD
18637	23472	54	,	,	,
18637	23472	55	787	787	CD
18637	23472	56	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23472	57	of	of	IN
18637	23472	58	Education	Education	NNP
18637	23472	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23472	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23472	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23472	62	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23472	63	,	,	,
18637	23472	64	203	203	CD
18637	23472	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23472	66	553	553	CD
18637	23472	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23472	68	1906	1906	CD
18637	23472	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23472	70	,	,	,
18637	23472	71	1051	1051	CD
18637	23472	72	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23472	73	of	of	IN
18637	23472	74	Liquidation	Liquidation	NNP
18637	23472	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23472	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	23472	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23472	78	McComb	McComb	NNP
18637	23472	79	,	,	,
18637	23472	80	92	92	CD
18637	23472	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23472	82	531	531	CD
18637	23472	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23472	84	1876	1876	CD
18637	23472	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23472	86	,	,	,
18637	23472	87	931	931	CD
18637	23472	88	,	,	,
18637	23472	89	932	932	CD
18637	23472	90	,	,	,
18637	23472	91	933	933	CD
18637	23472	92	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23472	93	of	of	IN
18637	23472	94	Public	Public	NNP
18637	23472	95	Works	Works	NNP
18637	23472	96	_	_	NNP
18637	23472	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	23472	98	_	_	NNP
18637	23472	99	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23472	100	College	College	NNP
18637	23472	101	,	,	,
18637	23472	102	17	17	CD
18637	23472	103	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23472	104	.	.	.
18637	23473	1	521	521	CD
18637	23473	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23473	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	23473	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23473	5	,	,	,
18637	23473	6	656	656	CD
18637	23473	7	,	,	,
18637	23473	8	658	658	CD
18637	23473	9	Bob	Bob	NNP
18637	23473	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	23473	11	Lo	Lo	NNP
18637	23473	12	Excursion	Excursion	NNP
18637	23473	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23473	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23473	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23473	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23473	17	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	23473	18	,	,	,
18637	23473	19	333	333	CD
18637	23473	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23473	21	28	28	CD
18637	23473	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23473	23	1948	1948	CD
18637	23473	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23473	25	,	,	,
18637	23473	26	230	230	CD
18637	23473	27	,	,	,
18637	23473	28	1162	1162	CD
18637	23473	29	Bollman	Bollman	NNP
18637	23473	30	,	,	,
18637	23473	31	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23473	32	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23473	33	,	,	,
18637	23473	34	4	4	CD
18637	23473	35	Cr	Cr	NNP
18637	23473	36	.	.	.
18637	23474	1	75	75	CD
18637	23474	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23474	3	1807	1807	CD
18637	23474	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23474	5	,	,	,
18637	23474	6	313	313	CD
18637	23474	7	,	,	,
18637	23474	8	314	314	CD
18637	23474	9	,	,	,
18637	23474	10	315	315	CD
18637	23474	11	,	,	,
18637	23474	12	512	512	CD
18637	23474	13	,	,	,
18637	23474	14	523	523	CD
18637	23474	15	,	,	,
18637	23474	16	612	612	CD
18637	23474	17	,	,	,
18637	23474	18	618	618	CD
18637	23474	19	,	,	,
18637	23474	20	639	639	CD
18637	23474	21	,	,	,
18637	23474	22	643	643	CD
18637	23474	23	,	,	,
18637	23474	24	645	645	CD
18637	23474	25	Bonaparte	Bonaparte	NNP
18637	23474	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23474	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23474	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23474	29	Camden	Camden	NNP
18637	23474	30	&	&	CC
18637	23474	31	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	23475	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23475	2	,	,	,
18637	23475	3	3	3	CD
18637	23475	4	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	23475	5	.	.	.
18637	23476	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	23476	2	.	.	.
18637	23477	1	No	no	UH
18637	23477	2	.	.	.
18637	23478	1	1,617	1,617	CD
18637	23478	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23478	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	23478	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23478	5	,	,	,
18637	23478	6	350	350	CD
18637	23478	7	Bonaparte	Bonaparte	NNP
18637	23478	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23478	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	11	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23478	12	Court	Court	NNP
18637	23478	13	,	,	,
18637	23478	14	104	104	CD
18637	23478	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23478	16	592	592	CD
18637	23478	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23478	18	1882	1882	CD
18637	23478	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23478	20	,	,	,
18637	23478	21	675	675	CD
18637	23478	22	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	23478	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23478	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	26	Hume	Hume	NNP
18637	23478	27	,	,	,
18637	23478	28	243	243	CD
18637	23478	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23478	30	15	15	CD
18637	23478	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23478	32	1917	1917	CD
18637	23478	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23478	34	,	,	,
18637	23478	35	675	675	CD
18637	23478	36	,	,	,
18637	23478	37	681	681	CD
18637	23478	38	Boom	Boom	NNP
18637	23478	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23478	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23478	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	43	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	23478	44	,	,	,
18637	23478	45	98	98	CD
18637	23478	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23478	47	403	403	CD
18637	23478	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23478	49	1879	1879	CD
18637	23478	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23478	51	,	,	,
18637	23478	52	870	870	CD
18637	23478	53	Booth	Booth	NNP
18637	23478	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	23478	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	57	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23478	58	,	,	,
18637	23478	59	184	184	CD
18637	23478	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23478	61	425	425	CD
18637	23478	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23478	63	1902	1902	CD
18637	23478	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23478	65	,	,	,
18637	23478	66	1019	1019	CD
18637	23478	67	Booth	Booth	NNP
18637	23478	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	23478	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	71	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	23478	72	,	,	,
18637	23478	73	237	237	CD
18637	23478	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23478	75	391	391	CD
18637	23478	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23478	77	1915	1915	CD
18637	23478	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23478	79	,	,	,
18637	23478	80	987	987	CD
18637	23478	81	Booth	Booth	NNP
18637	23478	82	Fisheries	Fisheries	NNPS
18637	23478	83	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23478	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	23478	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	87	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	23478	88	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23478	89	,	,	,
18637	23478	90	271	271	CD
18637	23478	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23478	92	208	208	CD
18637	23478	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23478	94	1926	1926	CD
18637	23478	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23478	96	,	,	,
18637	23478	97	990	990	CD
18637	23478	98	Borden	Borden	NNP
18637	23478	99	Company	Company	NNP
18637	23478	100	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	23478	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	103	Borella	Borella	NNP
18637	23478	104	,	,	,
18637	23478	105	325	325	CD
18637	23478	106	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23478	107	679	679	CD
18637	23478	108	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23478	109	1945	1945	CD
18637	23478	110	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23478	111	,	,	,
18637	23478	112	157	157	CD
18637	23478	113	Borden	Borden	NNP
18637	23478	114	's	's	POS
18637	23478	115	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	23478	116	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	23478	117	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23478	118	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	23478	120	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	121	Ten	Ten	NNP
18637	23478	122	Eyck	Eyck	NNP
18637	23478	123	,	,	,
18637	23478	124	297	297	CD
18637	23478	125	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23478	126	251	251	CD
18637	23478	127	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23478	128	1936	1936	CD
18637	23478	129	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23478	130	,	,	,
18637	23478	131	1154	1154	CD
18637	23478	132	Borer	Borer	NNP
18637	23478	133	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	134	v.	v.	IN
18637	23478	135	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	136	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	23478	137	,	,	,
18637	23478	138	119	119	CD
18637	23478	139	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23478	140	587	587	CD
18637	23478	141	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23478	142	1887	1887	CD
18637	23478	143	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23478	144	,	,	,
18637	23478	145	672	672	CD
18637	23478	146	Börs	bã¶rs	RB
18637	23478	147	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	148	v.	v.	IN
18637	23478	149	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	150	Preston	Preston	NNP
18637	23478	151	,	,	,
18637	23478	152	111	111	CD
18637	23478	153	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23478	154	252	252	CD
18637	23478	155	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23478	156	1884	1884	CD
18637	23478	157	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23478	158	,	,	,
18637	23478	159	571	571	CD
18637	23478	160	Boske	Boske	NNP
18637	23478	161	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	162	v.	v.	IN
18637	23478	163	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	164	Comingore	Comingore	NNP
18637	23478	165	,	,	,
18637	23478	166	177	177	CD
18637	23478	167	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23478	168	459	459	CD
18637	23478	169	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23478	170	1900	1900	CD
18637	23478	171	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23478	172	,	,	,
18637	23478	173	633	633	CD
18637	23478	174	Bosley	Bosley	NNP
18637	23478	175	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	176	v.	v.	IN
18637	23478	177	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	178	McLaughlin	McLaughlin	NNP
18637	23478	179	,	,	,
18637	23478	180	236	236	CD
18637	23478	181	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23478	182	385	385	CD
18637	23478	183	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23478	184	1915	1915	CD
18637	23478	185	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23478	186	,	,	,
18637	23478	187	986	986	CD
18637	23478	188	,	,	,
18637	23478	189	1159	1159	CD
18637	23478	190	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	23478	191	Beer	Beer	NNP
18637	23478	192	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23478	193	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	194	v.	v.	IN
18637	23478	195	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	196	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	23478	197	,	,	,
18637	23478	198	97	97	CD
18637	23478	199	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23478	200	25	25	CD
18637	23478	201	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23478	202	1878	1878	CD
18637	23478	203	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23478	204	,	,	,
18637	23478	205	346	346	CD
18637	23478	206	,	,	,
18637	23478	207	358	358	CD
18637	23478	208	,	,	,
18637	23478	209	1032	1032	CD
18637	23478	210	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	23478	211	&	&	CC
18637	23478	212	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	23478	213	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	23478	214	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	23478	215	&	&	CC
18637	23478	216	Silver	Silver	NNP
18637	23478	217	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	23478	218	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23478	219	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	220	v.	v.	IN
18637	23478	221	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	222	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	23478	223	Ore	Ore	NNP
18637	23478	224	Purchasing	Purchasing	NNP
18637	23478	225	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23478	226	,	,	,
18637	23478	227	188	188	CD
18637	23478	228	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23478	229	632	632	CD
18637	23478	230	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23478	231	1903	1903	CD
18637	23478	232	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23478	233	,	,	,
18637	23478	234	567	567	CD
18637	23478	235	Boswell	Boswell	NNP
18637	23478	236	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	237	v.	v.	IN
18637	23478	238	_	_	NNP
18637	23478	239	Otis	Otis	NNP
18637	23478	240	,	,	,
18637	23478	241	9	9	CD
18637	23478	242	How	how	WRB
18637	23478	243	.	.	.
18637	23479	1	336	336	CD
18637	23479	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23479	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	23479	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23479	5	,	,	,
18637	23479	6	1081	1081	CD
18637	23479	7	Bothwell	Bothwell	NNP
18637	23479	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23479	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	11	Buckbee	Buckbee	NNP
18637	23479	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	23479	13	Mears	Mears	NNP
18637	23479	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23479	15	,	,	,
18637	23479	16	275	275	CD
18637	23479	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23479	18	274	274	CD
18637	23479	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23479	20	1927	1927	CD
18637	23479	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23479	22	,	,	,
18637	23479	23	120	120	CD
18637	23479	24	Botiller	Botiller	NNP
18637	23479	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23479	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	28	Dominguez	Dominguez	NNP
18637	23479	29	,	,	,
18637	23479	30	130	130	CD
18637	23479	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23479	32	238	238	CD
18637	23479	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23479	34	1889	1889	CD
18637	23479	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23479	36	,	,	,
18637	23479	37	421	421	CD
18637	23479	38	,	,	,
18637	23479	39	493	493	CD
18637	23479	40	Bourjois	Bourjois	NNP
18637	23479	41	,	,	,
18637	23479	42	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	23479	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	23479	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	46	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	23479	47	,	,	,
18637	23479	48	301	301	CD
18637	23479	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23479	50	183	183	CD
18637	23479	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23479	52	1937	1937	CD
18637	23479	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23479	54	,	,	,
18637	23479	55	237	237	CD
18637	23479	56	,	,	,
18637	23479	57	1024	1024	CD
18637	23479	58	Boutell	Boutell	NNP
18637	23479	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23479	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	62	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	23479	63	,	,	,
18637	23479	64	327	327	CD
18637	23479	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23479	66	463	463	CD
18637	23479	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23479	68	1946	1946	CD
18637	23479	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23479	70	,	,	,
18637	23479	71	158	158	CD
18637	23479	72	Bowen	Bowen	NNP
18637	23479	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	23479	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	76	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	23479	77	,	,	,
18637	23479	78	306	306	CD
18637	23479	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23479	80	19	19	CD
18637	23479	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23479	82	1939	1939	CD
18637	23479	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23479	84	,	,	,
18637	23479	85	305	305	CD
18637	23479	86	Bowers	Bowers	NNPS
18637	23479	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	23479	89	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	90	Kerbaugh	Kerbaugh	NNP
18637	23479	91	-	-	HYPH
18637	23479	92	Empire	Empire	NNP
18637	23479	93	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23479	94	,	,	,
18637	23479	95	271	271	CD
18637	23479	96	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23479	97	170	170	CD
18637	23479	98	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23479	99	1926	1926	CD
18637	23479	100	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23479	101	,	,	,
18637	23479	102	1192	1192	CD
18637	23479	103	,	,	,
18637	23479	104	1199	1199	CD
18637	23479	105	Bowersock	Bowersock	NNP
18637	23479	106	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	107	v.	v.	IN
18637	23479	108	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	109	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	23479	110	,	,	,
18637	23479	111	243	243	CD
18637	23479	112	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23479	113	29	29	CD
18637	23479	114	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23479	115	1917	1917	CD
18637	23479	116	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23479	117	,	,	,
18637	23479	118	1091	1091	CD
18637	23479	119	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	23479	120	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	121	v.	v.	IN
18637	23479	122	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	123	Willingham	Willingham	NNP
18637	23479	124	,	,	,
18637	23479	125	321	321	CD
18637	23479	126	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23479	127	503	503	CD
18637	23479	128	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23479	129	1944	1944	CD
18637	23479	130	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23479	131	,	,	,
18637	23479	132	76	76	CD
18637	23479	133	,	,	,
18637	23479	134	296	296	CD
18637	23479	135	,	,	,
18637	23479	136	849	849	CD
18637	23479	137	,	,	,
18637	23479	138	855	855	CD
18637	23479	139	,	,	,
18637	23479	140	859	859	CD
18637	23479	141	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	23479	142	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	143	v.	v.	IN
18637	23479	144	_	_	NNP
18637	23479	145	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23479	146	,	,	,
18637	23479	147	&	&	CC
18637	23479	148	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	23480	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23480	2	,	,	,
18637	23480	3	125	125	CD
18637	23480	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23480	5	465	465	CD
18637	23480	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23480	7	1888	1888	CD
18637	23480	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23480	9	,	,	,
18637	23480	10	218	218	CD
18637	23480	11	,	,	,
18637	23480	12	238	238	CD
18637	23480	13	,	,	,
18637	23480	14	268	268	CD
18637	23480	15	,	,	,
18637	23480	16	365	365	CD
18637	23480	17	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	23480	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23480	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23480	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23480	21	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	23480	22	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	23480	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23480	24	,	,	,
18637	23480	25	256	256	CD
18637	23480	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23480	27	642	642	CD
18637	23480	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23480	29	1921	1921	CD
18637	23480	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23480	31	,	,	,
18637	23480	32	184	184	CD
18637	23480	33	,	,	,
18637	23480	34	239	239	CD
18637	23480	35	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	23480	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23480	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23480	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23480	39	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	23480	40	,	,	,
18637	23480	41	101	101	CD
18637	23480	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23480	43	22	22	CD
18637	23480	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23480	45	1880	1880	CD
18637	23480	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23480	47	,	,	,
18637	23480	48	1166	1166	CD
18637	23480	49	Boyce	Boyce	NNP
18637	23480	50	's	's	POS
18637	23480	51	Executors	Executors	NNP
18637	23480	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23480	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	23480	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23480	55	Grundy	Grundy	NNP
18637	23480	56	,	,	,
18637	23480	57	3	3	CD
18637	23480	58	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	23480	59	.	.	.
18637	23481	1	210	210	CD
18637	23481	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23481	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	23481	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23481	5	,	,	,
18637	23481	6	524	524	CD
18637	23481	7	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
18637	23481	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23481	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23481	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23481	11	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	23481	12	ex	ex	NN
18637	23481	13	rel	rel	NN
18637	23481	14	.	.	.
18637	23482	1	Thayer	Thayer	NNP
18637	23482	2	,	,	,
18637	23482	3	143	143	CD
18637	23482	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23482	5	135	135	CD
18637	23482	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23482	7	1892	1892	CD
18637	23482	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23482	9	,	,	,
18637	23482	10	255	255	CD
18637	23482	11	,	,	,
18637	23482	12	699	699	CD
18637	23482	13	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
18637	23482	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23482	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	17	United	United	NNP
18637	23482	18	States	States	NNP
18637	23482	19	,	,	,
18637	23482	20	116	116	CD
18637	23482	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23482	22	616	616	CD
18637	23482	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23482	24	1886	1886	CD
18637	23482	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23482	26	,	,	,
18637	23482	27	824	824	CD
18637	23482	28	,	,	,
18637	23482	29	825	825	CD
18637	23482	30	,	,	,
18637	23482	31	842	842	CD
18637	23482	32	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
18637	23482	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	23482	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	36	United	United	NNP
18637	23482	37	States	States	NNP
18637	23482	38	,	,	,
18637	23482	39	142	142	CD
18637	23482	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23482	41	450	450	CD
18637	23482	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23482	43	1892	1892	CD
18637	23482	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23482	45	,	,	,
18637	23482	46	410	410	CD
18637	23482	47	Boyer	Boyer	NNP
18637	23482	48	,	,	,
18637	23482	49	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23482	50	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23482	51	,	,	,
18637	23482	52	109	109	CD
18637	23482	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23482	54	629	629	CD
18637	23482	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23482	56	1884	1884	CD
18637	23482	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23482	58	,	,	,
18637	23482	59	577	577	CD
18637	23482	60	Boynton	Boynton	NNP
18637	23482	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	23482	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	64	Hutchinson	Hutchinson	NNP
18637	23482	65	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23482	66	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23482	67	,	,	,
18637	23482	68	291	291	CD
18637	23482	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23482	70	656	656	CD
18637	23482	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23482	72	1934	1934	CD
18637	23482	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23482	74	,	,	,
18637	23482	75	982	982	CD
18637	23482	76	Bozza	Bozza	NNP
18637	23482	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	23482	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	80	United	United	NNP
18637	23482	81	States	States	NNP
18637	23482	82	,	,	,
18637	23482	83	330	330	CD
18637	23482	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23482	85	160	160	CD
18637	23482	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23482	87	1947	1947	CD
18637	23482	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23482	89	,	,	,
18637	23482	90	839	839	CD
18637	23482	91	Brader	Brader	NNP
18637	23482	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	23482	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	95	James	James	NNP
18637	23482	96	,	,	,
18637	23482	97	246	246	CD
18637	23482	98	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23482	99	88	88	CD
18637	23482	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23482	101	1918	1918	CD
18637	23482	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23482	103	,	,	,
18637	23482	104	864	864	CD
18637	23482	105	Bradfield	Bradfield	NNP
18637	23482	106	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	107	v.	v.	IN
18637	23482	108	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	109	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	23482	110	,	,	,
18637	23482	111	175	175	CD
18637	23482	112	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23482	113	291	291	CD
18637	23482	114	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23482	115	1899	1899	CD
18637	23482	116	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23482	117	,	,	,
18637	23482	118	764	764	CD
18637	23482	119	Bradford	Bradford	NNP
18637	23482	120	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	23482	121	Light	Light	NNP
18637	23482	122	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23482	123	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	124	v.	v.	IN
18637	23482	125	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	126	Clapper	Clapper	NNP
18637	23482	127	,	,	,
18637	23482	128	286	286	CD
18637	23482	129	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23482	130	145	145	CD
18637	23482	131	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23482	132	1932	1932	CD
18637	23482	133	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23482	134	,	,	,
18637	23482	135	676	676	CD
18637	23482	136	,	,	,
18637	23482	137	681	681	CD
18637	23482	138	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	23482	139	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	140	v.	v.	IN
18637	23482	141	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	142	Lightcap	Lightcap	NNP
18637	23482	143	,	,	,
18637	23482	144	195	195	CD
18637	23482	145	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23482	146	1	1	CD
18637	23482	147	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23482	148	1904	1904	CD
18637	23482	149	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23482	150	,	,	,
18637	23482	151	356	356	CD
18637	23482	152	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	23482	153	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	154	v.	v.	IN
18637	23482	155	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	156	Public	Public	NNP
18637	23482	157	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	23482	158	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23482	159	,	,	,
18637	23482	160	289	289	CD
18637	23482	161	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23482	162	92	92	CD
18637	23482	163	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23482	164	1933	1933	CD
18637	23482	165	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23482	166	,	,	,
18637	23482	167	226	226	CD
18637	23482	168	,	,	,
18637	23482	169	1032	1032	CD
18637	23482	170	,	,	,
18637	23482	171	1155	1155	CD
18637	23482	172	Bradwell	Bradwell	NNP
18637	23482	173	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	174	v.	v.	IN
18637	23482	175	_	_	NNP
18637	23482	176	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23482	177	,	,	,
18637	23482	178	16	16	CD
18637	23482	179	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23482	180	.	.	.
18637	23483	1	130	130	CD
18637	23483	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23483	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	23483	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23483	5	,	,	,
18637	23483	6	687	687	CD
18637	23483	7	,	,	,
18637	23483	8	971	971	CD
18637	23483	9	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	23483	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23483	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23483	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23483	13	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
18637	23483	14	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	23483	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23483	16	,	,	,
18637	23483	17	317	317	CD
18637	23483	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23483	19	575	575	CD
18637	23483	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23483	21	1943	1943	CD
18637	23483	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23483	23	,	,	,
18637	23483	24	587	587	CD
18637	23483	25	Bragg	Bragg	NNP
18637	23483	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23483	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23483	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23483	29	Weaver	Weaver	NNP
18637	23483	30	,	,	,
18637	23483	31	251	251	CD
18637	23483	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23483	33	57	57	CD
18637	23483	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23483	35	1919	1919	CD
18637	23483	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23483	37	,	,	,
18637	23483	38	1064	1064	CD
18637	23483	39	,	,	,
18637	23483	40	1069	1069	CD
18637	23483	41	,	,	,
18637	23483	42	1084	1084	CD
18637	23483	43	Branch	Branch	NNP
18637	23483	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23483	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	23483	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23483	47	Haas	Haas	NNP
18637	23483	48	,	,	,
18637	23483	49	16	16	CD
18637	23483	50	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23483	51	53	53	CD
18637	23483	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23483	53	1883	1883	CD
18637	23483	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23483	55	,	,	,
18637	23483	56	1174	1174	CD
18637	23483	57	Brannan	Brannan	NNP
18637	23483	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23483	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	23483	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23483	61	Stark	Stark	NNP
18637	23483	62	,	,	,
18637	23483	63	342	342	CD
18637	23483	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23483	65	451	451	CD
18637	23483	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23483	67	1952	1952	CD
18637	23483	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23483	69	,	,	,
18637	23483	70	78	78	CD
18637	23483	71	Bransford	Bransford	NNP
18637	23483	72	,	,	,
18637	23483	73	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23483	74	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23483	75	,	,	,
18637	23483	76	310	310	CD
18637	23483	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23483	78	354	354	CD
18637	23483	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23483	80	1940	1940	CD
18637	23483	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23483	82	,	,	,
18637	23483	83	631	631	CD
18637	23483	84	Branson	Branson	NNP
18637	23483	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23483	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	23483	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23483	88	Bush	Bush	NNP
18637	23483	89	,	,	,
18637	23483	90	251	251	CD
18637	23483	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23483	92	182	182	CD
18637	23483	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23483	94	1919	1919	CD
18637	23483	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23483	96	,	,	,
18637	23483	97	1153	1153	CD
18637	23483	98	Brass	Brass	NNP
18637	23483	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23483	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	23483	101	_	_	NNP
18637	23483	102	North	North	NNP
18637	23483	103	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	23483	104	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23483	105	rel	rel	NN
18637	23483	106	.	.	.
18637	23484	1	Stoeser	Stoeser	NNP
18637	23484	2	,	,	,
18637	23484	3	153	153	CD
18637	23484	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23484	5	391	391	CD
18637	23484	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23484	7	1894	1894	CD
18637	23484	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23484	9	,	,	,
18637	23484	10	996	996	CD
18637	23484	11	Bratton	Bratton	NNP
18637	23484	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23484	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	15	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	23484	16	,	,	,
18637	23484	17	260	260	CD
18637	23484	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23484	19	110	110	CD
18637	23484	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23484	21	1922	1922	CD
18637	23484	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23484	23	,	,	,
18637	23484	24	1085	1085	CD
18637	23484	25	,	,	,
18637	23484	26	1086	1086	CD
18637	23484	27	Braxton	Braxton	NNP
18637	23484	28	County	County	NNP
18637	23484	29	Court	Court	NNP
18637	23484	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23484	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	33	West	West	NNP
18637	23484	34	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	23484	35	,	,	,
18637	23484	36	208	208	CD
18637	23484	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23484	38	192	192	CD
18637	23484	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23484	40	1908	1908	CD
18637	23484	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23484	42	,	,	,
18637	23484	43	540	540	CD
18637	23484	44	,	,	,
18637	23484	45	982	982	CD
18637	23484	46	Brazee	Brazee	NNP
18637	23484	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	23484	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	50	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	23484	51	,	,	,
18637	23484	52	241	241	CD
18637	23484	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23484	54	340	340	CD
18637	23484	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23484	56	1916	1916	CD
18637	23484	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23484	58	,	,	,
18637	23484	59	1023	1023	CD
18637	23484	60	Breard	Breard	NNP
18637	23484	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	23484	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	64	Alexandria	Alexandria	NNP
18637	23484	65	,	,	,
18637	23484	66	341	341	CD
18637	23484	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23484	68	622	622	CD
18637	23484	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23484	70	1951	1951	CD
18637	23484	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23484	72	,	,	,
18637	23484	73	786	786	CD
18637	23484	74	,	,	,
18637	23484	75	1156	1156	CD
18637	23484	76	Breedlove	Breedlove	NNP
18637	23484	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	23484	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	80	Suttles	Suttles	NNP
18637	23484	81	,	,	,
18637	23484	82	302	302	CD
18637	23484	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23484	84	277	277	CD
18637	23484	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23484	86	1937	1937	CD
18637	23484	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23484	88	,	,	,
18637	23484	89	87	87	CD
18637	23484	90	,	,	,
18637	23484	91	971	971	CD
18637	23484	92	,	,	,
18637	23484	93	1152	1152	CD
18637	23484	94	,	,	,
18637	23484	95	1220	1220	CD
18637	23484	96	Breese	Breese	NNP
18637	23484	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	98	v.	v.	IN
18637	23484	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	100	United	United	NNP
18637	23484	101	States	States	NNP
18637	23484	102	,	,	,
18637	23484	103	226	226	CD
18637	23484	104	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23484	105	1	1	CD
18637	23484	106	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23484	107	1912	1912	CD
18637	23484	108	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23484	109	,	,	,
18637	23484	110	838	838	CD
18637	23484	111	Breiholz	Breiholz	NNP
18637	23484	112	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	23484	114	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	115	Pocahontas	Pocahontas	NNP
18637	23484	116	County	County	NNP
18637	23484	117	,	,	,
18637	23484	118	257	257	CD
18637	23484	119	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23484	120	118	118	CD
18637	23484	121	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23484	122	1921	1921	CD
18637	23484	123	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23484	124	,	,	,
18637	23484	125	1059	1059	CD
18637	23484	126	Brennan	Brennan	NNP
18637	23484	127	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	128	v.	v.	IN
18637	23484	129	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	130	Titusville	Titusville	NNP
18637	23484	131	,	,	,
18637	23484	132	153	153	CD
18637	23484	133	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23484	134	289	289	CD
18637	23484	135	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23484	136	1894	1894	CD
18637	23484	137	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23484	138	,	,	,
18637	23484	139	187	187	CD
18637	23484	140	,	,	,
18637	23484	141	218	218	CD
18637	23484	142	Brewing	Brewing	NNP
18637	23484	143	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23484	144	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	145	v.	v.	IN
18637	23484	146	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	147	Liquor	Liquor	NNP
18637	23484	148	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	23484	149	.	.	NNP
18637	23484	150	,	,	,
18637	23484	151	305	305	CD
18637	23484	152	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23484	153	391	391	CD
18637	23484	154	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23484	155	1939	1939	CD
18637	23484	156	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23484	157	,	,	,
18637	23484	158	241	241	CD
18637	23484	159	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	23484	160	Proprietors	Proprietors	NNPS
18637	23484	161	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	162	v.	v.	IN
18637	23484	163	_	_	NNP
18637	23484	164	Hoboken	Hoboken	NNP
18637	23484	165	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23484	166	,	,	,
18637	23484	167	1	1	CD
18637	23484	168	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23484	169	.	.	.
18637	23485	1	116	116	CD
18637	23485	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23485	3	1863	1863	CD
18637	23485	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23485	5	,	,	,
18637	23485	6	330	330	CD
18637	23485	7	Bridges	Bridges	NNPS
18637	23485	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23485	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23485	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23485	11	California	California	NNP
18637	23485	12	,	,	,
18637	23485	13	314	314	CD
18637	23485	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23485	15	252	252	CD
18637	23485	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23485	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	23485	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23485	19	,	,	,
18637	23485	20	517	517	CD
18637	23485	21	,	,	,
18637	23485	22	563	563	CD
18637	23485	23	,	,	,
18637	23485	24	783	783	CD
18637	23485	25	,	,	,
18637	23485	26	788	788	CD
18637	23485	27	,	,	,
18637	23485	28	800	800	CD
18637	23485	29	,	,	,
18637	23485	30	809	809	CD
18637	23485	31	Brig	Brig	NNP
18637	23485	32	Ann	Ann	NNP
18637	23485	33	,	,	,
18637	23485	34	The	the	DT
18637	23485	35	,	,	,
18637	23485	36	9	9	CD
18637	23485	37	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23485	38	.	.	.
18637	23486	1	289	289	CD
18637	23486	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23486	3	1815	1815	CD
18637	23486	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23486	5	,	,	,
18637	23486	6	575	575	CD
18637	23486	7	Brigantine	Brigantine	NNP
18637	23486	8	William	William	NNP
18637	23486	9	,	,	,
18637	23486	10	The	the	DT
18637	23486	11	,	,	,
18637	23486	12	28	28	CD
18637	23486	13	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	23486	14	.	.	.
18637	23487	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	23487	2	.	.	.
18637	23488	1	16,700	16,700	CD
18637	23488	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23488	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	23488	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23488	5	,	,	,
18637	23488	6	167	167	CD
18637	23488	7	Brig	Brig	NNP
18637	23488	8	Aurora	Aurora	NNP
18637	23488	9	,	,	,
18637	23488	10	The	the	DT
18637	23488	11	,	,	,
18637	23488	12	7	7	CD
18637	23488	13	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23488	14	.	.	.
18637	23489	1	382	382	CD
18637	23489	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23489	3	1813	1813	CD
18637	23489	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23489	5	,	,	,
18637	23489	6	74	74	CD
18637	23489	7	,	,	,
18637	23489	8	79	79	CD
18637	23489	9	Briggs	Briggs	NNP
18637	23489	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23489	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23489	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23489	13	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	23489	14	,	,	,
18637	23489	15	342	342	CD
18637	23489	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23489	17	350	350	CD
18637	23489	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23489	19	1952	1952	CD
18637	23489	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23489	21	,	,	,
18637	23489	22	1163	1163	CD
18637	23489	23	Brillhart	Brillhart	NNP
18637	23489	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23489	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23489	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23489	27	Excess	Excess	NNP
18637	23489	28	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	23489	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23489	30	,	,	,
18637	23489	31	316	316	CD
18637	23489	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23489	33	491	491	CD
18637	23489	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23489	35	1942	1942	CD
18637	23489	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23489	37	,	,	,
18637	23489	38	553	553	CD
18637	23489	39	,	,	,
18637	23489	40	627	627	CD
18637	23489	41	Brimmer	Brimmer	NNP
18637	23489	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23489	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23489	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23489	45	Rebman	Rebman	NNP
18637	23489	46	,	,	,
18637	23489	47	138	138	CD
18637	23489	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23489	49	78	78	CD
18637	23489	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23489	51	1891	1891	CD
18637	23489	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23489	53	,	,	,
18637	23489	54	183	183	CD
18637	23489	55	,	,	,
18637	23489	56	214	214	CD
18637	23489	57	,	,	,
18637	23489	58	238	238	CD
18637	23489	59	Brinegar	Brinegar	NNP
18637	23489	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23489	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23489	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23489	63	United	United	NNP
18637	23489	64	States	States	NNP
18637	23489	65	,	,	,
18637	23489	66	338	338	CD
18637	23489	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23489	68	160	160	CD
18637	23489	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23489	70	1949	1949	CD
18637	23489	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23489	72	,	,	,
18637	23489	73	791	791	CD
18637	23489	74	,	,	,
18637	23489	75	830	830	CD
18637	23489	76	Brinkerhoff	Brinkerhoff	NNP
18637	23489	77	-	-	HYPH
18637	23489	78	Faris	Faris	NNP
18637	23489	79	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23489	80	&	&	CC
18637	23489	81	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	23489	82	.	.	.
18637	23490	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23490	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23490	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23490	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23490	5	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	23490	6	,	,	,
18637	23490	7	281	281	CD
18637	23490	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23490	9	673	673	CD
18637	23490	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23490	11	1930	1930	CD
18637	23490	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23490	13	,	,	,
18637	23490	14	1060	1060	CD
18637	23490	15	Briscoe	Briscoe	NNP
18637	23490	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23490	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23490	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23490	19	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23490	20	of	of	IN
18637	23490	21	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23490	22	,	,	,
18637	23490	23	11	11	CD
18637	23490	24	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23490	25	.	.	.
18637	23491	1	257	257	CD
18637	23491	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23491	3	1837	1837	CD
18637	23491	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23491	5	,	,	,
18637	23491	6	326	326	CD
18637	23491	7	,	,	,
18637	23491	8	930	930	CD
18637	23491	9	Briscoe	Briscoe	NNP
18637	23491	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23491	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23491	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23491	13	Rudolph	Rudolph	NNP
18637	23491	14	,	,	,
18637	23491	15	221	221	CD
18637	23491	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23491	17	547	547	CD
18637	23491	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23491	19	1911	1911	CD
18637	23491	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23491	21	,	,	,
18637	23491	22	304	304	CD
18637	23491	23	Bristol	Bristol	NNP
18637	23491	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23491	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23491	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23491	27	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	23491	28	County	County	NNP
18637	23491	29	,	,	,
18637	23491	30	177	177	CD
18637	23491	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23491	32	133	133	CD
18637	23491	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23491	34	1900	1900	CD
18637	23491	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23491	36	,	,	,
18637	23491	37	1044	1044	CD
18637	23491	38	Broad	Broad	NNP
18637	23491	39	River	River	NNP
18637	23491	40	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23491	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23491	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23491	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23491	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23491	45	South	South	NNP
18637	23491	46	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	23491	47	ex	ex	NN
18637	23491	48	rel	rel	NN
18637	23491	49	.	.	.
18637	23492	1	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	23492	2	,	,	,
18637	23492	3	281	281	CD
18637	23492	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23492	5	537	537	CD
18637	23492	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23492	7	1930	1930	CD
18637	23492	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23492	9	,	,	,
18637	23492	10	1011	1011	CD
18637	23492	11	Broderick	Broderick	NNP
18637	23492	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23492	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23492	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23492	15	Rosner	Rosner	NNP
18637	23492	16	,	,	,
18637	23492	17	294	294	CD
18637	23492	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23492	19	629	629	CD
18637	23492	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23492	21	1935	1935	CD
18637	23492	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23492	23	,	,	,
18637	23492	24	657	657	CD
18637	23492	25	,	,	,
18637	23492	26	678	678	CD
18637	23492	27	Brodnax	Brodnax	NNP
18637	23492	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23492	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23492	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23492	31	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	23492	32	,	,	,
18637	23492	33	219	219	CD
18637	23492	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23492	35	285	285	CD
18637	23492	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23492	37	1911	1911	CD
18637	23492	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23492	39	,	,	,
18637	23492	40	189	189	CD
18637	23492	41	,	,	,
18637	23492	42	1019	1019	CD
18637	23492	43	Brolan	Brolan	NNP
18637	23492	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23492	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	23492	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23492	47	United	United	NNP
18637	23492	48	States	States	NNP
18637	23492	49	,	,	,
18637	23492	50	236	236	CD
18637	23492	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23492	52	216	216	CD
18637	23492	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23492	54	1915	1915	CD
18637	23492	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23492	56	,	,	,
18637	23492	57	124	124	CD
18637	23492	58	,	,	,
18637	23492	59	163	163	CD
18637	23492	60	Bromley	Bromley	NNP
18637	23492	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23492	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	23492	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23492	64	McCaughn	McCaughn	NNP
18637	23492	65	,	,	,
18637	23492	66	280	280	CD
18637	23492	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23492	68	124	124	CD
18637	23492	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23492	70	1929	1929	CD
18637	23492	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23492	72	,	,	,
18637	23492	73	321	321	CD
18637	23492	74	,	,	,
18637	23492	75	863	863	CD
18637	23492	76	Bronson	Bronson	NNP
18637	23492	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23492	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	23492	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23492	80	Kinzie	Kinzie	NNP
18637	23492	81	,	,	,
18637	23492	82	1	1	CD
18637	23492	83	How	how	WRB
18637	23492	84	.	.	.
18637	23493	1	311	311	CD
18637	23493	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23493	3	1843	1843	CD
18637	23493	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23493	5	,	,	,
18637	23493	6	354	354	CD
18637	23493	7	Brooke	Brooke	NNP
18637	23493	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23493	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23493	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23493	11	Norfolk	Norfolk	NNP
18637	23493	12	,	,	,
18637	23493	13	277	277	CD
18637	23493	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23493	15	27	27	CD
18637	23493	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23493	17	1928	1928	CD
18637	23493	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23493	19	,	,	,
18637	23493	20	1044	1044	CD
18637	23493	21	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
18637	23493	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23493	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23493	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23493	25	United	United	NNP
18637	23493	26	States	States	NNP
18637	23493	27	,	,	,
18637	23493	28	267	267	CD
18637	23493	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23493	30	432	432	CD
18637	23493	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23493	32	1925	1925	CD
18637	23493	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23493	34	,	,	,
18637	23493	35	171	171	CD
18637	23493	36	,	,	,
18637	23493	37	919	919	CD
18637	23493	38	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
18637	23493	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23493	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23493	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23493	42	United	United	NNP
18637	23493	43	States	States	NNP
18637	23493	44	,	,	,
18637	23493	45	147	147	CD
18637	23493	46	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23493	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23493	48	2d	2d	CD
18637	23493	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23493	50	134	134	CD
18637	23493	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23493	52	1945	1945	CD
18637	23493	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23493	54	,	,	,
18637	23493	55	953	953	CD
18637	23493	56	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
18637	23493	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23493	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	23493	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23493	60	United	United	NNP
18637	23493	61	States	States	NNP
18637	23493	62	,	,	,
18637	23493	63	324	324	CD
18637	23493	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23493	65	878	878	CD
18637	23493	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23493	67	1945	1945	CD
18637	23493	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23493	69	,	,	,
18637	23493	70	953	953	CD
18637	23493	71	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
18637	23493	72	-	-	HYPH
18637	23493	73	Scanlon	Scanlon	NNP
18637	23493	74	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23493	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23493	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	23493	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23493	78	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	23493	79	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23493	80	,	,	,
18637	23493	81	251	251	CD
18637	23493	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23493	83	396	396	CD
18637	23493	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23493	85	1920	1920	CD
18637	23493	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23493	87	,	,	,
18637	23493	88	1011	1011	CD
18637	23493	89	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23493	90	_	_	NNP
18637	23493	91	v.	v.	IN
18637	23493	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23493	93	Baskin	Baskin	NNP
18637	23493	94	,	,	,
18637	23493	95	78	78	CD
18637	23493	96	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23493	97	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	23493	98	.	.	.
18637	23494	1	933	933	CD
18637	23494	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23494	3	1948	1948	CD
18637	23494	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23494	5	,	,	,
18637	23494	6	1185	1185	CD
18637	23494	7	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23494	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23494	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23494	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23494	11	Duchesne	Duchesne	NNP
18637	23494	12	,	,	,
18637	23494	13	19	19	CD
18637	23494	14	How	how	WRB
18637	23494	15	.	.	.
18637	23495	1	183	183	CD
18637	23495	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23495	3	1857	1857	CD
18637	23495	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23495	5	,	,	,
18637	23495	6	271	271	CD
18637	23495	7	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23495	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23495	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23495	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23495	11	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	23495	12	,	,	,
18637	23495	13	225	225	CD
18637	23495	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23495	15	392	392	CD
18637	23495	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23495	17	1912	1912	CD
18637	23495	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23495	19	,	,	,
18637	23495	20	881	881	CD
18637	23495	21	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23495	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23495	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23495	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23495	25	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	23495	26	,	,	,
18637	23495	27	210	210	CD
18637	23495	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23495	29	82	82	CD
18637	23495	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23495	31	1908	1908	CD
18637	23495	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23495	33	,	,	,
18637	23495	34	658	658	CD
18637	23495	35	,	,	,
18637	23495	36	659	659	CD
18637	23495	37	,	,	,
18637	23495	38	662	662	CD
18637	23495	39	,	,	,
18637	23495	40	672	672	CD
18637	23495	41	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23495	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23495	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23495	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23495	45	Grant	Grant	NNP
18637	23495	46	,	,	,
18637	23495	47	116	116	CD
18637	23495	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23495	49	207	207	CD
18637	23495	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23495	51	1886	1886	CD
18637	23495	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23495	53	,	,	,
18637	23495	54	700	700	CD
18637	23495	55	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23495	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23495	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	23495	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23495	59	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	23495	60	,	,	,
18637	23495	61	114	114	CD
18637	23495	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23495	63	622	622	CD
18637	23495	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23495	65	1885	1885	CD
18637	23495	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23495	67	,	,	,
18637	23495	68	169	169	CD
18637	23495	69	,	,	,
18637	23495	70	183	183	CD
18637	23495	71	,	,	,
18637	23495	72	218	218	CD
18637	23495	73	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23495	74	_	_	NNP
18637	23495	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	23495	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23495	77	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	23495	78	,	,	,
18637	23495	79	12	12	CD
18637	23495	80	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23495	81	.	.	.
18637	23496	1	419	419	CD
18637	23496	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23496	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	23496	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23496	5	,	,	,
18637	23496	6	107	107	CD
18637	23496	7	,	,	,
18637	23496	8	175	175	CD
18637	23496	9	,	,	,
18637	23496	10	177	177	CD
18637	23496	11	,	,	,
18637	23496	12	178	178	CD
18637	23496	13	,	,	,
18637	23496	14	182	182	CD
18637	23496	15	,	,	,
18637	23496	16	183	183	CD
18637	23496	17	,	,	,
18637	23496	18	198	198	CD
18637	23496	19	,	,	,
18637	23496	20	215	215	CD
18637	23496	21	,	,	,
18637	23496	22	218	218	CD
18637	23496	23	,	,	,
18637	23496	24	238	238	CD
18637	23496	25	,	,	,
18637	23496	26	363	363	CD
18637	23496	27	,	,	,
18637	23496	28	364	364	CD
18637	23496	29	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23496	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23496	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23496	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23496	33	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	23496	34	,	,	,
18637	23496	35	297	297	CD
18637	23496	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23496	37	278	278	CD
18637	23496	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23496	39	1936	1936	CD
18637	23496	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23496	41	,	,	,
18637	23496	42	1112	1112	CD
18637	23496	43	,	,	,
18637	23496	44	1119	1119	CD
18637	23496	45	,	,	,
18637	23496	46	1138	1138	CD
18637	23496	47	,	,	,
18637	23496	48	1139	1139	CD
18637	23496	49	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23496	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23496	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	23496	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23496	53	New	New	NNP
18637	23496	54	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	23496	55	,	,	,
18637	23496	56	175	175	CD
18637	23496	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23496	58	172	172	CD
18637	23496	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23496	60	1899	1899	CD
18637	23496	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23496	62	,	,	,
18637	23496	63	1071	1071	CD
18637	23496	64	,	,	,
18637	23496	65	1098	1098	CD
18637	23496	66	,	,	,
18637	23496	67	1110	1110	CD
18637	23496	68	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23496	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23496	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	23496	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23496	72	Penobscot	Penobscot	NNP
18637	23496	73	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23496	74	,	,	,
18637	23496	75	8	8	CD
18637	23496	76	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	23497	1	445	445	CD
18637	23497	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23497	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	23497	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23497	5	,	,	,
18637	23497	6	357	357	CD
18637	23497	7	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23497	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23497	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23497	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23497	11	Piper	Piper	NNP
18637	23497	12	,	,	,
18637	23497	13	91	91	CD
18637	23497	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23497	15	37	37	CD
18637	23497	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23497	17	1875	1875	CD
18637	23497	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23497	19	,	,	,
18637	23497	20	273	273	CD
18637	23497	21	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23497	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23497	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23497	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23497	25	Smart	Smart	NNP
18637	23497	26	,	,	,
18637	23497	27	145	145	CD
18637	23497	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23497	29	454	454	CD
18637	23497	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23497	31	1892	1892	CD
18637	23497	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23497	33	,	,	,
18637	23497	34	265	265	CD
18637	23497	35	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23497	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23497	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23497	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23497	39	United	United	NNP
18637	23497	40	States	States	NNP
18637	23497	41	,	,	,
18637	23497	42	8	8	CD
18637	23497	43	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23497	44	.	.	.
18637	23498	1	110	110	CD
18637	23498	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23498	3	1814	1814	CD
18637	23498	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23498	5	,	,	,
18637	23498	6	865	865	CD
18637	23498	7	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23498	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23498	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23498	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23498	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23498	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23498	13	,	,	,
18637	23498	14	263	263	CD
18637	23498	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23498	16	78	78	CD
18637	23498	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23498	18	1923	1923	CD
18637	23498	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23498	20	,	,	,
18637	23498	21	294	294	CD
18637	23498	22	,	,	,
18637	23498	23	866	866	CD
18637	23498	24	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23498	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23498	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23498	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23498	28	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	23498	29	,	,	,
18637	23498	30	161	161	CD
18637	23498	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23498	32	591	591	CD
18637	23498	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23498	34	1896	1896	CD
18637	23498	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23498	36	,	,	,
18637	23498	37	407	407	CD
18637	23498	38	,	,	,
18637	23498	39	411	411	CD
18637	23498	40	,	,	,
18637	23498	41	842	842	CD
18637	23498	42	,	,	,
18637	23498	43	843	843	CD
18637	23498	44	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23498	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23498	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	23498	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23498	48	Western	Western	NNP
18637	23498	49	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	23498	50	.	.	.
18637	23499	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23499	2	of	of	IN
18637	23499	3	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	23499	4	,	,	,
18637	23499	5	338	338	CD
18637	23499	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23499	7	294	294	CD
18637	23499	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23499	9	1949	1949	CD
18637	23499	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23499	11	,	,	,
18637	23499	12	637	637	CD
18637	23499	13	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23499	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23499	15	Marcus	Marcus	NNP
18637	23499	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23499	17	Holding	Holding	NNP
18637	23499	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23499	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23499	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	23499	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23499	22	Feldman	Feldman	NNP
18637	23499	23	,	,	,
18637	23499	24	256	256	CD
18637	23499	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23499	26	170	170	CD
18637	23499	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23499	28	1921	1921	CD
18637	23499	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23499	30	,	,	,
18637	23499	31	359	359	CD
18637	23499	32	,	,	,
18637	23499	33	953	953	CD
18637	23499	34	Browne	Browne	NNP
18637	23499	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23499	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	23499	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23499	38	Strode	Strode	NNP
18637	23499	39	,	,	,
18637	23499	40	5	5	CD
18637	23499	41	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23499	42	.	.	.
18637	23500	1	303	303	CD
18637	23500	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23500	3	1809	1809	CD
18637	23500	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23500	5	,	,	,
18637	23500	6	611	611	CD
18637	23500	7	Browning	Browning	NNP
18637	23500	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23500	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23500	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23500	11	Hooper	Hooper	NNP
18637	23500	12	,	,	,
18637	23500	13	269	269	CD
18637	23500	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23500	15	396	396	CD
18637	23500	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23500	17	1926	1926	CD
18637	23500	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23500	19	,	,	,
18637	23500	20	1059	1059	CD
18637	23500	21	Browning	Browning	NNP
18637	23500	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23500	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23500	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23500	25	Waycross	Waycross	NNP
18637	23500	26	,	,	,
18637	23500	27	233	233	CD
18637	23500	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23500	29	16	16	CD
18637	23500	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23500	31	1914	1914	CD
18637	23500	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23500	33	,	,	,
18637	23500	34	121	121	CD
18637	23500	35	,	,	,
18637	23500	36	188	188	CD
18637	23500	37	Bruno	Bruno	NNP
18637	23500	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23500	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23500	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23500	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23500	42	,	,	,
18637	23500	43	308	308	CD
18637	23500	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23500	45	287	287	CD
18637	23500	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23500	47	1939	1939	CD
18637	23500	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23500	49	,	,	,
18637	23500	50	843	843	CD
18637	23500	51	Brushaber	Brushaber	NNP
18637	23500	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23500	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	23500	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23500	55	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23500	56	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	23500	57	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23500	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23500	59	,	,	,
18637	23500	60	240	240	CD
18637	23500	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23500	62	1	1	CD
18637	23500	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23500	64	1916	1916	CD
18637	23500	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23500	66	,	,	,
18637	23500	67	105	105	CD
18637	23500	68	,	,	,
18637	23500	69	110	110	CD
18637	23500	70	,	,	,
18637	23500	71	541	541	CD
18637	23500	72	,	,	,
18637	23500	73	862	862	CD
18637	23500	74	,	,	,
18637	23500	75	863	863	CD
18637	23500	76	,	,	,
18637	23500	77	1192	1192	CD
18637	23500	78	,	,	,
18637	23500	79	1200	1200	CD
18637	23500	80	Bryant	Bryant	NNP
18637	23500	81	,	,	,
18637	23500	82	In	in	IN
18637	23500	83	re	re	NN
18637	23500	84	,	,	,
18637	23500	85	4	4	CD
18637	23500	86	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	23500	87	.	.	.
18637	23501	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	23501	2	.	.	.
18637	23502	1	No	no	UH
18637	23502	2	.	.	.
18637	23503	1	2067	2067	CD
18637	23503	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23503	3	1865	1865	CD
18637	23503	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23503	5	,	,	,
18637	23503	6	122	122	CD
18637	23503	7	Buchalter	Buchalter	NNP
18637	23503	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23503	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23503	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23503	11	New	New	NNP
18637	23503	12	York	York	NNP
18637	23503	13	,	,	,
18637	23503	14	319	319	CD
18637	23503	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23503	16	427	427	CD
18637	23503	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23503	18	1943	1943	CD
18637	23503	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23503	20	,	,	,
18637	23503	21	1132	1132	CD
18637	23503	22	Buchanan	Buchanan	NNP
18637	23503	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23503	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23503	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23503	26	Warley	Warley	NNP
18637	23503	27	,	,	,
18637	23503	28	245	245	CD
18637	23503	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23503	30	60	60	CD
18637	23503	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23503	32	1917	1917	CD
18637	23503	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23503	34	,	,	,
18637	23503	35	1029	1029	CD
18637	23503	36	,	,	,
18637	23503	37	1161	1161	CD
18637	23503	38	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	23503	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23503	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23503	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23503	42	Beach	Beach	NNP
18637	23503	43	,	,	,
18637	23503	44	206	206	CD
18637	23503	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23503	46	392	392	CD
18637	23503	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23503	48	1907	1907	CD
18637	23503	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23503	50	,	,	,
18637	23503	51	1044	1044	CD
18637	23503	52	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	23503	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23503	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	23503	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23503	56	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	23503	57	,	,	,
18637	23503	58	274	274	CD
18637	23503	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23503	60	200	200	CD
18637	23503	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23503	62	1927	1927	CD
18637	23503	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23503	64	,	,	,
18637	23503	65	984	984	CD
18637	23503	66	,	,	,
18637	23503	67	1153	1153	CD
18637	23503	68	,	,	,
18637	23503	69	1156	1156	CD
18637	23503	70	,	,	,
18637	23503	71	1161	1161	CD
18637	23503	72	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	23503	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23503	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	23503	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23503	76	California	California	NNP
18637	23503	77	,	,	,
18637	23503	78	342	342	CD
18637	23503	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23503	80	99	99	CD
18637	23503	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23503	82	1952	1952	CD
18637	23503	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23503	84	,	,	,
18637	23503	85	227	227	CD
18637	23503	86	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	23503	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23503	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	23503	89	_	_	NNP
18637	23503	90	Colbath	Colbath	NNP
18637	23503	91	,	,	,
18637	23503	92	3	3	CD
18637	23503	93	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23503	94	.	.	.
18637	23504	1	334	334	CD
18637	23504	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23504	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	23504	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23504	5	,	,	,
18637	23504	6	526	526	CD
18637	23504	7	,	,	,
18637	23504	8	627	627	CD
18637	23504	9	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	23504	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23504	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	13	Kuykendall	Kuykendall	NNP
18637	23504	14	,	,	,
18637	23504	15	267	267	CD
18637	23504	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23504	17	307	307	CD
18637	23504	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23504	19	1925	1925	CD
18637	23504	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23504	21	,	,	,
18637	23504	22	228	228	CD
18637	23504	23	Buckstaff	Buckstaff	NNP
18637	23504	24	Bath	Bath	NNP
18637	23504	25	House	House	NNP
18637	23504	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23504	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	29	McKinley	McKinley	NNP
18637	23504	30	,	,	,
18637	23504	31	308	308	CD
18637	23504	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23504	33	358	358	CD
18637	23504	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23504	35	1939	1939	CD
18637	23504	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23504	37	,	,	,
18637	23504	38	731	731	CD
18637	23504	39	Budd	Budd	NNPS
18637	23504	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23504	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	43	New	New	NNP
18637	23504	44	York	York	NNP
18637	23504	45	,	,	,
18637	23504	46	143	143	CD
18637	23504	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23504	48	517	517	CD
18637	23504	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23504	50	1892	1892	CD
18637	23504	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23504	52	,	,	,
18637	23504	53	975	975	CD
18637	23504	54	,	,	,
18637	23504	55	996	996	CD
18637	23504	56	,	,	,
18637	23504	57	999	999	CD
18637	23504	58	Bugajewitz	Bugajewitz	NNPS
18637	23504	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23504	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	62	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	23504	63	,	,	,
18637	23504	64	228	228	CD
18637	23504	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23504	66	585	585	CD
18637	23504	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23504	68	1913	1913	CD
18637	23504	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23504	70	,	,	,
18637	23504	71	259	259	CD
18637	23504	72	,	,	,
18637	23504	73	317	317	CD
18637	23504	74	Building	Building	NNP
18637	23504	75	Service	Service	NNP
18637	23504	76	Employees	Employees	NNPS
18637	23504	77	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23504	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	23504	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	81	Gazzam	Gazzam	NNP
18637	23504	82	,	,	,
18637	23504	83	339	339	CD
18637	23504	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23504	85	532	532	CD
18637	23504	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23504	87	1950	1950	CD
18637	23504	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23504	89	,	,	,
18637	23504	90	782	782	CD
18637	23504	91	Bullen	Bullen	NNP
18637	23504	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	23504	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	95	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	23504	96	,	,	,
18637	23504	97	240	240	CD
18637	23504	98	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23504	99	625	625	CD
18637	23504	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23504	101	1916	1916	CD
18637	23504	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23504	103	,	,	,
18637	23504	104	1045	1045	CD
18637	23504	105	Bunting	Bunting	NNP
18637	23504	106	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	107	v.	v.	IN
18637	23504	108	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	109	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	23504	110	,	,	,
18637	23504	111	243	243	CD
18637	23504	112	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23504	113	426	426	CD
18637	23504	114	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23504	115	1917	1917	CD
18637	23504	116	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23504	117	,	,	,
18637	23504	118	979	979	CD
18637	23504	119	,	,	,
18637	23504	120	987	987	CD
18637	23504	121	,	,	,
18637	23504	122	1158	1158	CD
18637	23504	123	Burbank	Burbank	NNP
18637	23504	124	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	125	v.	v.	IN
18637	23504	126	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	127	Ernst	Ernst	NNP
18637	23504	128	,	,	,
18637	23504	129	232	232	CD
18637	23504	130	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23504	131	162	162	CD
18637	23504	132	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23504	133	1914	1914	CD
18637	23504	134	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23504	135	,	,	,
18637	23504	136	672	672	CD
18637	23504	137	Burdeau	Burdeau	NNP
18637	23504	138	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	139	v.	v.	IN
18637	23504	140	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	141	McDowell	McDowell	NNP
18637	23504	142	,	,	,
18637	23504	143	256	256	CD
18637	23504	144	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23504	145	465	465	CD
18637	23504	146	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23504	147	1921	1921	CD
18637	23504	148	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23504	149	,	,	,
18637	23504	150	823	823	CD
18637	23504	151	,	,	,
18637	23504	152	831	831	CD
18637	23504	153	Burdick	Burdick	NNP
18637	23504	154	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	155	v.	v.	IN
18637	23504	156	_	_	NNP
18637	23504	157	United	United	NNP
18637	23504	158	States	States	NNP
18637	23504	159	,	,	,
18637	23504	160	236	236	CD
18637	23504	161	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23504	162	79	79	CD
18637	23504	163	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23504	164	1915	1915	CD
18637	23504	165	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23504	166	,	,	,
18637	23504	167	407	407	CD
18637	23504	168	,	,	,
18637	23504	169	842	842	CD
18637	23504	170	Burford	Burford	NNP
18637	23504	171	,	,	,
18637	23504	172	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23504	173	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23504	174	,	,	,
18637	23504	175	3	3	NNP
18637	23504	176	Cr	Cr	NNP
18637	23504	177	.	.	.
18637	23505	1	448	448	CD
18637	23505	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23505	3	1806	1806	CD
18637	23505	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23505	5	,	,	,
18637	23505	6	825	825	CD
18637	23505	7	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
18637	23505	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23505	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23505	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23505	11	Salmon	Salmon	NNP
18637	23505	12	,	,	,
18637	23505	13	97	97	CD
18637	23505	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23505	15	381	381	CD
18637	23505	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23505	17	1878	1878	CD
18637	23505	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23505	19	,	,	,
18637	23505	20	103	103	CD
18637	23505	21	,	,	,
18637	23505	22	316	316	CD
18637	23505	23	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
18637	23505	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23505	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23505	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23505	27	Seligman	Seligman	NNP
18637	23505	28	,	,	,
18637	23505	29	107	107	CD
18637	23505	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23505	31	20	20	CD
18637	23505	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23505	33	1883	1883	CD
18637	23505	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23505	35	,	,	,
18637	23505	36	332	332	CD
18637	23505	37	,	,	,
18637	23505	38	606	606	CD
18637	23505	39	Burk	Burk	NNP
18637	23505	40	-	-	HYPH
18637	23505	41	Waggoner	Waggoner	NNP
18637	23505	42	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	23505	43	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	23505	44	.	.	.
18637	23506	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23506	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23506	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23506	4	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	23506	5	,	,	,
18637	23506	6	269	269	CD
18637	23506	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23506	8	110	110	CD
18637	23506	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23506	10	1925	1925	CD
18637	23506	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23506	12	,	,	,
18637	23506	13	1197	1197	CD
18637	23506	14	Burnes	Burnes	NNPS
18637	23506	15	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23506	16	.	.	.
18637	23507	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23507	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	5	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	23507	6	,	,	,
18637	23507	7	265	265	CD
18637	23507	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23507	9	17	17	CD
18637	23507	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	11	1924	1924	CD
18637	23507	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	13	,	,	,
18637	23507	14	309	309	CD
18637	23507	15	Burnet	Burnet	NNP
18637	23507	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	19	Coronado	Coronado	NNP
18637	23507	20	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	23507	21	&	&	CC
18637	23507	22	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23507	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23507	24	,	,	,
18637	23507	25	285	285	CD
18637	23507	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23507	27	393	393	CD
18637	23507	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	29	1932	1932	CD
18637	23507	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	31	,	,	,
18637	23507	32	108	108	CD
18637	23507	33	,	,	,
18637	23507	34	566	566	CD
18637	23507	35	Burnet	Burnet	NNP
18637	23507	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	39	Harmel	Harmel	NNP
18637	23507	40	,	,	,
18637	23507	41	287	287	CD
18637	23507	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23507	43	103	103	CD
18637	23507	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	45	1932	1932	CD
18637	23507	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	47	,	,	,
18637	23507	48	1200	1200	CD
18637	23507	49	Burnet	Burnet	NNP
18637	23507	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	53	Sanford	Sanford	NNP
18637	23507	54	&	&	CC
18637	23507	55	B.	B.	NNP
18637	23507	56	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23507	57	,	,	,
18637	23507	58	282	282	CD
18637	23507	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23507	60	359	359	CD
18637	23507	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	62	1931	1931	CD
18637	23507	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	64	,	,	,
18637	23507	65	1201	1201	CD
18637	23507	66	Burns	Burns	NNP
18637	23507	67	Baking	Baking	NNP
18637	23507	68	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23507	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	72	Bryan	Bryan	NNP
18637	23507	73	,	,	,
18637	23507	74	264	264	CD
18637	23507	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23507	76	504	504	CD
18637	23507	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	78	1924	1924	CD
18637	23507	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	80	,	,	,
18637	23507	81	1019	1019	CD
18637	23507	82	Burroughs	Burroughs	NNP
18637	23507	83	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	86	United	United	NNP
18637	23507	87	States	States	NNP
18637	23507	88	,	,	,
18637	23507	89	290	290	CD
18637	23507	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23507	91	534	534	CD
18637	23507	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	93	1934	1934	CD
18637	23507	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	95	,	,	,
18637	23507	96	386	386	CD
18637	23507	97	Burrow	Burrow	NNP
18637	23507	98	-	-	HYPH
18637	23507	99	Giles	Giles	NNP
18637	23507	100	Lithographic	Lithographic	NNP
18637	23507	101	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23507	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	103	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	104	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	105	Sarony	Sarony	NNP
18637	23507	106	,	,	,
18637	23507	107	111	111	CD
18637	23507	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23507	109	53	53	CD
18637	23507	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	111	1884	1884	CD
18637	23507	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	113	,	,	,
18637	23507	114	276	276	CD
18637	23507	115	Burstyn	Burstyn	NNP
18637	23507	116	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	117	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
18637	23507	118	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	119	,	,	,
18637	23507	120	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	23507	121	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	122	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	123	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	124	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	23507	125	,	,	,
18637	23507	126	343	343	CD
18637	23507	127	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23507	128	495	495	CD
18637	23507	129	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	130	1952	1952	CD
18637	23507	131	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	132	,	,	,
18637	23507	133	788	788	CD
18637	23507	134	Burton	Burton	NNP
18637	23507	135	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	136	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	137	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	138	United	United	NNP
18637	23507	139	States	States	NNP
18637	23507	140	,	,	,
18637	23507	141	202	202	CD
18637	23507	142	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23507	143	344	344	CD
18637	23507	144	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	145	1906	1906	CD
18637	23507	146	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	147	,	,	,
18637	23507	148	88	88	CD
18637	23507	149	,	,	,
18637	23507	150	98	98	CD
18637	23507	151	,	,	,
18637	23507	152	840	840	CD
18637	23507	153	,	,	,
18637	23507	154	881	881	CD
18637	23507	155	,	,	,
18637	23507	156	884	884	CD
18637	23507	157	Bus	Bus	NNP
18637	23507	158	Employees	Employees	NNP
18637	23507	159	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	160	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	161	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	162	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	23507	163	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23507	164	,	,	,
18637	23507	165	340	340	CD
18637	23507	166	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23507	167	383	383	CD
18637	23507	168	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	169	1951	1951	CD
18637	23507	170	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	171	,	,	,
18637	23507	172	173	173	CD
18637	23507	173	,	,	,
18637	23507	174	252	252	CD
18637	23507	175	,	,	,
18637	23507	176	724	724	CD
18637	23507	177	Bush	Bush	NNP
18637	23507	178	&	&	CC
18637	23507	179	Sons	Sons	NNP
18637	23507	180	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23507	181	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	182	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	183	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	184	Maloy	Maloy	NNP
18637	23507	185	,	,	,
18637	23507	186	267	267	CD
18637	23507	187	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23507	188	317	317	CD
18637	23507	189	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	190	1925	1925	CD
18637	23507	191	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	192	,	,	,
18637	23507	193	228	228	CD
18637	23507	194	Butchers	Butchers	NNPS
18637	23507	195	'	'	POS
18637	23507	196	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23507	197	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23507	198	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	199	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	200	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	201	Crescent	Crescent	NNP
18637	23507	202	City	City	NNP
18637	23507	203	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23507	204	,	,	,
18637	23507	205	111	111	CD
18637	23507	206	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23507	207	746	746	CD
18637	23507	208	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	209	1884	1884	CD
18637	23507	210	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	211	,	,	,
18637	23507	212	351	351	CD
18637	23507	213	Bute	Bute	NNP
18637	23507	214	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	215	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	216	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	217	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23507	218	,	,	,
18637	23507	219	333	333	CD
18637	23507	220	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23507	221	640	640	CD
18637	23507	222	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	223	1948	1948	CD
18637	23507	224	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	225	,	,	,
18637	23507	226	1105	1105	CD
18637	23507	227	,	,	,
18637	23507	228	1108	1108	CD
18637	23507	229	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	23507	230	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	231	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	232	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	233	Boston	Boston	NNP
18637	23507	234	&	&	CC
18637	23507	235	Savannah	Savannah	NNP
18637	23507	236	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	23507	237	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23507	238	,	,	,
18637	23507	239	130	130	CD
18637	23507	240	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23507	241	527	527	CD
18637	23507	242	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	243	1889	1889	CD
18637	23507	244	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	245	,	,	,
18637	23507	246	583	583	CD
18637	23507	247	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	23507	248	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	249	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	250	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	251	Goreley	Goreley	NNP
18637	23507	252	,	,	,
18637	23507	253	146	146	CD
18637	23507	254	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23507	255	303	303	CD
18637	23507	256	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23507	257	1892	1892	CD
18637	23507	258	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23507	259	,	,	,
18637	23507	260	264	264	CD
18637	23507	261	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	23507	262	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	263	v.	v.	IN
18637	23507	264	_	_	NNP
18637	23507	265	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	23507	266	,	,	,
18637	23507	267	10	10	CD
18637	23507	268	How	how	WRB
18637	23507	269	.	.	.
18637	23508	1	402	402	CD
18637	23508	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23508	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	23508	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23508	5	,	,	,
18637	23508	6	341	341	CD
18637	23508	7	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	23508	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23508	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	11	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	23508	12	,	,	,
18637	23508	13	240	240	CD
18637	23508	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23508	15	328	328	CD
18637	23508	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23508	17	1916	1916	CD
18637	23508	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23508	19	,	,	,
18637	23508	20	285	285	CD
18637	23508	21	,	,	,
18637	23508	22	952	952	CD
18637	23508	23	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	23508	24	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	23508	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23508	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	28	McColgan	McColgan	NNP
18637	23508	29	,	,	,
18637	23508	30	315	315	CD
18637	23508	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23508	32	501	501	CD
18637	23508	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23508	34	1942	1942	CD
18637	23508	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23508	36	,	,	,
18637	23508	37	209	209	CD
18637	23508	38	Butte	Butte	NNP
18637	23508	39	City	City	NNP
18637	23508	40	Water	Water	NNP
18637	23508	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23508	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23508	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	45	Baker	Baker	NNP
18637	23508	46	,	,	,
18637	23508	47	196	196	CD
18637	23508	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23508	49	119	119	CD
18637	23508	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23508	51	1905	1905	CD
18637	23508	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23508	53	,	,	,
18637	23508	54	78	78	CD
18637	23508	55	Butters	Butters	NNPS
18637	23508	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	23508	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	59	Oakland	Oakland	NNP
18637	23508	60	,	,	,
18637	23508	61	263	263	CD
18637	23508	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23508	63	162	162	CD
18637	23508	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23508	65	1923	1923	CD
18637	23508	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23508	67	,	,	,
18637	23508	68	1040	1040	CD
18637	23508	69	Butterworth	Butterworth	NNP
18637	23508	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	23508	72	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	73	Hoe	Hoe	NNP
18637	23508	74	,	,	,
18637	23508	75	112	112	CD
18637	23508	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23508	77	50	50	CD
18637	23508	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23508	79	1884	1884	CD
18637	23508	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23508	81	,	,	,
18637	23508	82	274	274	CD
18637	23508	83	,	,	,
18637	23508	84	536	536	CD
18637	23508	85	Buttfield	Buttfield	NNP
18637	23508	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	87	v.	v.	IN
18637	23508	88	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	89	Stranahan	Stranahan	NNP
18637	23508	90	,	,	,
18637	23508	91	192	192	CD
18637	23508	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23508	93	470	470	CD
18637	23508	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23508	95	1904	1904	CD
18637	23508	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23508	97	,	,	,
18637	23508	98	76	76	CD
18637	23508	99	,	,	,
18637	23508	100	162	162	CD
18637	23508	101	Buzard	Buzard	NNP
18637	23508	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	103	v.	v.	IN
18637	23508	104	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	105	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	23508	106	,	,	,
18637	23508	107	119	119	CD
18637	23508	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23508	109	347	347	CD
18637	23508	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23508	111	1886	1886	CD
18637	23508	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23508	113	,	,	,
18637	23508	114	895	895	CD
18637	23508	115	Byars	Byars	NNPS
18637	23508	116	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	117	v.	v.	IN
18637	23508	118	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	119	United	United	NNP
18637	23508	120	States	States	NNP
18637	23508	121	,	,	,
18637	23508	122	273	273	CD
18637	23508	123	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23508	124	28	28	CD
18637	23508	125	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23508	126	1927	1927	CD
18637	23508	127	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23508	128	,	,	,
18637	23508	129	825	825	CD
18637	23508	130	,	,	,
18637	23508	131	828	828	CD
18637	23508	132	,	,	,
18637	23508	133	831	831	CD
18637	23508	134	Byrne	Byrne	NNP
18637	23508	135	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	136	v.	v.	IN
18637	23508	137	_	_	NNP
18637	23508	138	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	23508	139	,	,	,
18637	23508	140	8	8	CD
18637	23508	141	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23508	142	.	.	.
18637	23509	1	40	40	CD
18637	23509	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23509	3	1834	1834	CD
18637	23509	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23509	5	,	,	,
18637	23509	6	326	326	CD
18637	23509	7	C	C	NNP
18637	23509	8	Cafeteria	Cafeteria	NNP
18637	23509	9	Employees	Employees	NNPS
18637	23509	10	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23509	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23509	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	23509	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23509	14	Angelos	Angelos	NNP
18637	23509	15	,	,	,
18637	23509	16	320	320	CD
18637	23509	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23509	18	293	293	CD
18637	23509	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23509	20	1943	1943	CD
18637	23509	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23509	22	,	,	,
18637	23509	23	782	782	CD
18637	23509	24	Cahen	Cahen	NNP
18637	23509	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23509	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23509	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23509	28	Brewster	Brewster	NNP
18637	23509	29	,	,	,
18637	23509	30	203	203	CD
18637	23509	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23509	32	543	543	CD
18637	23509	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23509	34	1906	1906	CD
18637	23509	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23509	36	,	,	,
18637	23509	37	1037	1037	CD
18637	23509	38	Cairo	Cairo	NNP
18637	23509	39	&	&	CC
18637	23509	40	F.R.	F.R.	NNP
18637	23510	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23510	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23510	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23510	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23510	5	Hecht	Hecht	NNP
18637	23510	6	,	,	,
18637	23510	7	95	95	CD
18637	23510	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23510	9	168	168	CD
18637	23510	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23510	11	1877	1877	CD
18637	23510	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23510	13	,	,	,
18637	23510	14	355	355	CD
18637	23510	15	Calder	Calder	NNP
18637	23510	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23510	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23510	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23510	19	Bull	Bull	NNP
18637	23510	20	,	,	,
18637	23510	21	3	3	CD
18637	23510	22	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	23510	23	.	.	.
18637	23511	1	386	386	CD
18637	23511	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23511	3	1798	1798	CD
18637	23511	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23511	5	,	,	,
18637	23511	6	316	316	CD
18637	23511	7	,	,	,
18637	23511	8	317	317	CD
18637	23511	9	,	,	,
18637	23511	10	327	327	CD
18637	23511	11	,	,	,
18637	23511	12	555	555	CD
18637	23511	13	,	,	,
18637	23511	14	558	558	CD
18637	23511	15	,	,	,
18637	23511	16	563	563	CD
18637	23511	17	,	,	,
18637	23511	18	564	564	CD
18637	23511	19	Calder	Calder	NNP
18637	23511	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23511	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	23511	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23511	23	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	23511	24	,	,	,
18637	23511	25	218	218	CD
18637	23511	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23511	27	591	591	CD
18637	23511	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23511	29	1910	1910	CD
18637	23511	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23511	31	,	,	,
18637	23511	32	344	344	CD
18637	23511	33	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	23511	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23511	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23511	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23511	37	North	North	NNP
18637	23511	38	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	23511	39	,	,	,
18637	23511	40	187	187	CD
18637	23511	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23511	42	622	622	CD
18637	23511	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23511	44	1903	1903	CD
18637	23511	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23511	46	,	,	,
18637	23511	47	187	187	CD
18637	23511	48	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	23511	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23511	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	23511	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23511	52	Sioux	Sioux	NNP
18637	23511	53	Falls	Falls	NNP
18637	23511	54	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	23511	55	Yards	Yards	NNP
18637	23511	56	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23511	57	,	,	,
18637	23511	58	242	242	CD
18637	23511	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23511	60	559	559	CD
18637	23511	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23511	62	1917	1917	CD
18637	23511	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23511	64	,	,	,
18637	23511	65	235	235	CD
18637	23511	66	,	,	,
18637	23511	67	1019	1019	CD
18637	23511	68	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	23511	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23511	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	23511	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23511	72	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23511	73	,	,	,
18637	23511	74	137	137	CD
18637	23511	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23511	76	691	691	CD
18637	23511	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23511	78	1891	1891	CD
18637	23511	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23511	80	,	,	,
18637	23511	81	1141	1141	CD
18637	23511	82	California	California	NNP
18637	23511	83	_	_	NNP
18637	23511	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	23511	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23511	86	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23511	87	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	23511	88	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	23511	89	,	,	,
18637	23511	90	127	127	CD
18637	23511	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23511	92	1	1	CD
18637	23511	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23511	94	1888	1888	CD
18637	23511	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23511	96	,	,	,
18637	23511	97	132	132	CD
18637	23511	98	,	,	,
18637	23511	99	310	310	CD
18637	23511	100	California	California	NNP
18637	23511	101	_	_	NNP
18637	23511	102	v.	v.	IN
18637	23511	103	_	_	NNP
18637	23511	104	Deseret	Deseret	NNP
18637	23511	105	Water	Water	NNP
18637	23511	106	,	,	,
18637	23511	107	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	23511	108	&	&	CC
18637	23511	109	Irrig	Irrig	NNP
18637	23511	110	.	.	.
18637	23512	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23512	2	,	,	,
18637	23512	3	243	243	CD
18637	23512	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23512	5	415	415	CD
18637	23512	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23512	7	1917	1917	CD
18637	23512	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23512	9	,	,	,
18637	23512	10	702	702	CD
18637	23512	11	California	California	NNP
18637	23512	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23512	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23512	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23512	15	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	23512	16	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	23512	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23512	18	,	,	,
18637	23512	19	157	157	CD
18637	23512	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23512	21	229	229	CD
18637	23512	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23512	23	1895	1895	CD
18637	23512	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23512	25	,	,	,
18637	23512	26	596	596	CD
18637	23512	27	,	,	,
18637	23512	28	597	597	CD
18637	23512	29	,	,	,
18637	23512	30	612	612	CD
18637	23512	31	California	California	NNP
18637	23512	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23512	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23512	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23512	35	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	23512	36	,	,	,
18637	23512	37	313	313	CD
18637	23512	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23512	39	109	109	CD
18637	23512	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23512	41	1941	1941	CD
18637	23512	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23512	43	,	,	,
18637	23512	44	177	177	CD
18637	23512	45	,	,	,
18637	23512	46	196	196	CD
18637	23512	47	,	,	,
18637	23512	48	218	218	CD
18637	23512	49	,	,	,
18637	23512	50	219	219	CD
18637	23512	51	,	,	,
18637	23512	52	228	228	CD
18637	23512	53	California	California	NNP
18637	23512	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23512	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	23512	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23512	57	United	United	NNP
18637	23512	58	States	States	NNP
18637	23512	59	,	,	,
18637	23512	60	320	320	CD
18637	23512	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23512	62	577	577	CD
18637	23512	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23512	64	1944	1944	CD
18637	23512	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23512	66	,	,	,
18637	23512	67	130	130	CD
18637	23512	68	California	California	NNP
18637	23512	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23512	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	23512	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23512	72	Zook	Zook	NNP
18637	23512	73	,	,	,
18637	23512	74	336	336	CD
18637	23512	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23512	76	725	725	CD
18637	23512	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23512	78	1949	1949	CD
18637	23512	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23512	80	,	,	,
18637	23512	81	250	250	CD
18637	23512	82	California	California	NNP
18637	23512	83	Auto	Auto	NNP
18637	23512	84	Ass'n	Ass'n	NFP
18637	23512	85	.	.	.
18637	23513	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23513	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23513	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23513	4	Maloney	Maloney	NNP
18637	23513	5	,	,	,
18637	23513	6	341	341	CD
18637	23513	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23513	8	105	105	CD
18637	23513	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23513	10	1951	1951	CD
18637	23513	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23513	12	,	,	,
18637	23513	13	1021	1021	CD
18637	23513	14	California	California	NNP
18637	23513	15	Reduction	Reduction	NNP
18637	23513	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23513	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23513	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23513	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23513	20	Sanitary	Sanitary	NNP
18637	23513	21	Reduction	Reduction	NNP
18637	23513	22	Works	Works	NNP
18637	23513	23	,	,	,
18637	23513	24	199	199	CD
18637	23513	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23513	26	306	306	CD
18637	23513	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23513	28	1905	1905	CD
18637	23513	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23513	30	,	,	,
18637	23513	31	982	982	CD
18637	23513	32	,	,	,
18637	23513	33	1030	1030	CD
18637	23513	34	Callan	Callan	NNP
18637	23513	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23513	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	23513	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23513	38	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	23513	39	,	,	,
18637	23513	40	127	127	CD
18637	23513	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23513	42	540	540	CD
18637	23513	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23513	44	1888	1888	CD
18637	23513	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23513	46	,	,	,
18637	23513	47	303	303	CD
18637	23513	48	,	,	,
18637	23513	49	877	877	CD
18637	23513	50	,	,	,
18637	23513	51	878	878	CD
18637	23513	52	,	,	,
18637	23513	53	879	879	CD
18637	23513	54	Camfield	Camfield	NNP
18637	23513	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23513	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	23513	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23513	58	United	United	NNP
18637	23513	59	States	States	NNP
18637	23513	60	,	,	,
18637	23513	61	167	167	CD
18637	23513	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23513	63	518	518	CD
18637	23513	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23513	65	1897	1897	CD
18637	23513	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23513	67	,	,	,
18637	23513	68	702	702	CD
18637	23513	69	Caminetti	Caminetti	NNP
18637	23513	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23513	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	23513	72	_	_	NNP
18637	23513	73	United	United	NNP
18637	23513	74	States	States	NNP
18637	23513	75	,	,	,
18637	23513	76	242	242	CD
18637	23513	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23513	78	470	470	CD
18637	23513	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23513	80	1917	1917	CD
18637	23513	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23513	82	,	,	,
18637	23513	83	170	170	CD
18637	23513	84	Cammeyer	Cammeyer	NNP
18637	23513	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23513	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	23513	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23513	88	Newton	Newton	NNP
18637	23513	89	,	,	,
18637	23513	90	94	94	CD
18637	23513	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23513	92	225	225	CD
18637	23513	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23513	94	1877	1877	CD
18637	23513	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23513	96	,	,	,
18637	23513	97	275	275	CD
18637	23513	98	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
18637	23513	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23513	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	23513	101	_	_	NNP
18637	23513	102	Boyreau	Boyreau	NNP
18637	23513	103	,	,	,
18637	23513	104	21	21	CD
18637	23513	105	How	how	WRB
18637	23513	106	.	.	.
18637	23514	1	223	223	CD
18637	23514	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23514	3	1859	1859	CD
18637	23514	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23514	5	,	,	,
18637	23514	6	897	897	CD
18637	23514	7	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
18637	23514	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23514	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23514	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23514	11	California	California	NNP
18637	23514	12	,	,	,
18637	23514	13	200	200	CD
18637	23514	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23514	15	87	87	CD
18637	23514	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23514	17	1906	1906	CD
18637	23514	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23514	19	,	,	,
18637	23514	20	1151	1151	CD
18637	23514	21	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
18637	23514	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23514	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23514	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23514	25	Holt	Holt	NNP
18637	23514	26	,	,	,
18637	23514	27	115	115	CD
18637	23514	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23514	29	620	620	CD
18637	23514	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23514	31	1885	1885	CD
18637	23514	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23514	33	,	,	,
18637	23514	34	1093	1093	CD
18637	23514	35	Canadian	Canadian	NNP
18637	23514	36	Aviator	Aviator	NNP
18637	23514	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23514	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	23514	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23514	40	United	United	NNP
18637	23514	41	States	States	NNP
18637	23514	42	,	,	,
18637	23514	43	324	324	CD
18637	23514	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23514	45	215	215	CD
18637	23514	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23514	47	1945	1945	CD
18637	23514	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23514	49	,	,	,
18637	23514	50	575	575	CD
18637	23514	51	Canadian	canadian	JJ
18637	23514	52	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	23515	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23515	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23515	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23515	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23515	5	Eggen	Eggen	NNP
18637	23515	6	,	,	,
18637	23515	7	252	252	CD
18637	23515	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23515	9	553	553	CD
18637	23515	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23515	11	1920	1920	CD
18637	23515	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23515	13	,	,	,
18637	23515	14	692	692	CD
18637	23515	15	Canizio	Canizio	NNP
18637	23515	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23515	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23515	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23515	19	New	New	NNP
18637	23515	20	York	York	NNP
18637	23515	21	,	,	,
18637	23515	22	327	327	CD
18637	23515	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23515	24	82	82	CD
18637	23515	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23515	26	1946	1946	CD
18637	23515	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23515	28	,	,	,
18637	23515	29	1102	1102	CD
18637	23515	30	Cannon	Cannon	NNP
18637	23515	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23515	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	23515	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23515	34	New	New	NNP
18637	23515	35	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	23515	36	,	,	,
18637	23515	37	20	20	CD
18637	23515	38	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23515	39	.	.	.
18637	23516	1	577	577	CD
18637	23516	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23516	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	23516	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23516	5	,	,	,
18637	23516	6	366	366	CD
18637	23516	7	Canton	Canton	NNP
18637	23516	8	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23516	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23516	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23516	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23516	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23516	13	Rogan	Rogan	NNP
18637	23516	14	,	,	,
18637	23516	15	340	340	CD
18637	23516	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23516	17	511	511	CD
18637	23516	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23516	19	1951	1951	CD
18637	23516	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23516	21	,	,	,
18637	23516	22	363	363	CD
18637	23516	23	Cantwell	Cantwell	NNP
18637	23516	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23516	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23516	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23516	27	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	23516	28	,	,	,
18637	23516	29	310	310	CD
18637	23516	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23516	31	296	296	CD
18637	23516	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23516	33	1940	1940	CD
18637	23516	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23516	35	,	,	,
18637	23516	36	757	757	CD
18637	23516	37	,	,	,
18637	23516	38	765	765	CD
18637	23516	39	,	,	,
18637	23516	40	766	766	CD
18637	23516	41	,	,	,
18637	23516	42	777	777	CD
18637	23516	43	,	,	,
18637	23516	44	788	788	CD
18637	23516	45	Capital	Capital	NNP
18637	23516	46	City	City	NNP
18637	23516	47	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
18637	23516	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23516	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23516	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	23516	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23516	52	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	23516	53	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23516	54	rel	rel	NN
18637	23516	55	.	.	.
18637	23517	1	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	23517	2	General	General	NNP
18637	23517	3	,	,	,
18637	23517	4	183	183	CD
18637	23517	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23517	6	238	238	CD
18637	23517	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23517	8	1902	1902	CD
18637	23517	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23517	10	,	,	,
18637	23517	11	1154	1154	CD
18637	23517	12	Capital	Capital	NNP
18637	23517	13	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	23517	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23517	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	23517	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	18	Hof	Hof	NNP
18637	23517	19	,	,	,
18637	23517	20	174	174	CD
18637	23517	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23517	22	1	1	CD
18637	23517	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23517	24	1899	1899	CD
18637	23517	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23517	26	,	,	,
18637	23517	27	303	303	CD
18637	23517	28	,	,	,
18637	23517	29	879	879	CD
18637	23517	30	,	,	,
18637	23517	31	892	892	CD
18637	23517	32	,	,	,
18637	23517	33	893	893	CD
18637	23517	34	,	,	,
18637	23517	35	896	896	CD
18637	23517	36	Capital	Capital	NNP
18637	23517	37	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23517	38	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23517	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23517	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	42	Calhoun	Calhoun	NNP
18637	23517	43	,	,	,
18637	23517	44	250	250	CD
18637	23517	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23517	46	208	208	CD
18637	23517	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23517	48	1919	1919	CD
18637	23517	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23517	50	,	,	,
18637	23517	51	857	857	CD
18637	23517	52	Capitol	Capitol	NNP
18637	23517	53	Greyhound	Greyhound	NNP
18637	23517	54	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	23517	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	23517	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	58	Brice	Brice	NNP
18637	23517	59	,	,	,
18637	23517	60	339	339	CD
18637	23517	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23517	62	542	542	CD
18637	23517	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23517	64	1950	1950	CD
18637	23517	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23517	66	,	,	,
18637	23517	67	212	212	CD
18637	23517	68	Cardillo	Cardillo	NNP
18637	23517	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	23517	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	72	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	23517	73	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	23517	74	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23517	75	,	,	,
18637	23517	76	330	330	CD
18637	23517	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23517	78	469	469	CD
18637	23517	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23517	80	1947	1947	CD
18637	23517	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23517	82	,	,	,
18637	23517	83	682	682	CD
18637	23517	84	Cardwell	Cardwell	NNP
18637	23517	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	23517	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	88	American	American	NNP
18637	23517	89	River	River	NNP
18637	23517	90	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	23517	91	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23517	92	,	,	,
18637	23517	93	113	113	CD
18637	23517	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23517	95	205	205	CD
18637	23517	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23517	97	1885	1885	CD
18637	23517	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23517	99	,	,	,
18637	23517	100	231	231	CD
18637	23517	101	Carfer	Carfer	NNP
18637	23517	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	103	v.	v.	IN
18637	23517	104	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	105	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	23517	106	,	,	,
18637	23517	107	200	200	CD
18637	23517	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23517	109	293	293	CD
18637	23517	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23517	111	1906	1906	CD
18637	23517	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23517	113	,	,	,
18637	23517	114	1072	1072	CD
18637	23517	115	Cargill	Cargill	NNP
18637	23517	116	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23517	117	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	118	v.	v.	IN
18637	23517	119	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	120	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23517	121	,	,	,
18637	23517	122	180	180	CD
18637	23517	123	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23517	124	452	452	CD
18637	23517	125	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23517	126	1901	1901	CD
18637	23517	127	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23517	128	,	,	,
18637	23517	129	235	235	CD
18637	23517	130	,	,	,
18637	23517	131	1024	1024	CD
18637	23517	132	,	,	,
18637	23517	133	1148	1148	CD
18637	23517	134	Carlesi	Carlesi	NNP
18637	23517	135	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	136	v.	v.	IN
18637	23517	137	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	138	New	New	NNP
18637	23517	139	York	York	NNP
18637	23517	140	,	,	,
18637	23517	141	233	233	CD
18637	23517	142	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23517	143	51	51	CD
18637	23517	144	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23517	145	1914	1914	CD
18637	23517	146	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23517	147	,	,	,
18637	23517	148	410	410	CD
18637	23517	149	,	,	,
18637	23517	150	1161	1161	CD
18637	23517	151	Carley	Carley	NNP
18637	23517	152	&	&	CC
18637	23517	153	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	23517	154	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	155	v.	v.	IN
18637	23517	156	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	157	Snook	Snook	NNP
18637	23517	158	,	,	,
18637	23517	159	281	281	CD
18637	23517	160	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23517	161	66	66	CD
18637	23517	162	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23517	163	1930	1930	CD
18637	23517	164	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23517	165	,	,	,
18637	23517	166	1151	1151	CD
18637	23517	167	Carlisle	Carlisle	NNP
18637	23517	168	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	169	v.	v.	IN
18637	23517	170	_	_	NNP
18637	23517	171	United	United	NNP
18637	23517	172	States	States	NNP
18637	23517	173	,	,	,
18637	23517	174	16	16	CD
18637	23517	175	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23517	176	.	.	.
18637	23518	1	147	147	CD
18637	23518	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23518	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	23518	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23518	5	,	,	,
18637	23518	6	645	645	CD
18637	23518	7	Carll	Carll	NNP
18637	23518	8	,	,	,
18637	23518	9	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23518	10	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23518	11	,	,	,
18637	23518	12	106	106	CD
18637	23518	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23518	14	521	521	CD
18637	23518	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23518	16	1883	1883	CD
18637	23518	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23518	18	,	,	,
18637	23518	19	309	309	CD
18637	23518	20	Carlson	Carlson	NNP
18637	23518	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23518	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	23518	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23518	24	California	California	NNP
18637	23518	25	,	,	,
18637	23518	26	310	310	CD
18637	23518	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23518	28	106	106	CD
18637	23518	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23518	30	1940	1940	CD
18637	23518	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23518	32	,	,	,
18637	23518	33	781	781	CD
18637	23518	34	Carlson	Carlson	NNP
18637	23518	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23518	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	23518	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23518	38	Landon	Landon	NNP
18637	23518	39	,	,	,
18637	23518	40	342	342	CD
18637	23518	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23518	42	524	524	CD
18637	23518	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23518	44	1952	1952	CD
18637	23518	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23518	46	,	,	,
18637	23518	47	261	261	CD
18637	23518	48	,	,	,
18637	23518	49	904	904	CD
18637	23518	50	Carmichael	Carmichael	NNP
18637	23518	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23518	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	23518	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23518	54	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	23518	55	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	23518	56	&	&	CC
18637	23518	57	Coke	Coke	NNP
18637	23518	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23518	59	,	,	,
18637	23518	60	300	300	CD
18637	23518	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23518	62	644	644	CD
18637	23518	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23518	64	1937	1937	CD
18637	23518	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23518	66	,	,	,
18637	23518	67	1037	1037	CD
18637	23518	68	Carmichael	Carmichael	NNP
18637	23518	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23518	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	23518	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23518	72	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	23518	73	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	23518	74	&	&	CC
18637	23518	75	Coke	Coke	NNP
18637	23518	76	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23518	77	,	,	,
18637	23518	78	301	301	CD
18637	23518	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23518	80	495	495	CD
18637	23518	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23518	82	1937	1937	CD
18637	23518	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23518	84	,	,	,
18637	23518	85	540	540	CD
18637	23518	86	Carneal	Carneal	NNP
18637	23518	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23518	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	23518	89	_	_	NNP
18637	23518	90	Banks	Banks	NNPS
18637	23518	91	,	,	,
18637	23518	92	10	10	CD
18637	23518	93	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23518	94	.	.	.
18637	23519	1	181	181	CD
18637	23519	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23519	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	23519	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23519	5	,	,	,
18637	23519	6	416	416	CD
18637	23519	7	Carolene	Carolene	NNP
18637	23519	8	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	23519	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23519	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23519	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23519	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23519	13	United	United	NNP
18637	23519	14	States	States	NNP
18637	23519	15	,	,	,
18637	23519	16	323	323	CD
18637	23519	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23519	18	18	18	CD
18637	23519	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23519	20	1944	1944	CD
18637	23519	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23519	22	,	,	,
18637	23519	23	859	859	CD
18637	23519	24	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	23519	25	Glass	Glass	NNP
18637	23519	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23519	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23519	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	23519	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23519	30	South	South	NNP
18637	23519	31	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	23519	32	,	,	,
18637	23519	33	240	240	CD
18637	23519	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23519	35	305	305	CD
18637	23519	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23519	37	1916	1916	CD
18637	23519	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23519	39	,	,	,
18637	23519	40	932	932	CD
18637	23519	41	Carondelet	Carondelet	NNP
18637	23519	42	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	23519	43	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23519	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23519	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	23519	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23519	47	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	23519	48	,	,	,
18637	23519	49	233	233	CD
18637	23519	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23519	51	362	362	CD
18637	23519	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23519	53	1914	1914	CD
18637	23519	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23519	55	,	,	,
18637	23519	56	330	330	CD
18637	23519	57	Carpenter	Carpenter	NNP
18637	23519	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23519	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	23519	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23519	61	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	23519	62	,	,	,
18637	23519	63	17	17	CD
18637	23519	64	How	how	WRB
18637	23519	65	.	.	.
18637	23520	1	456	456	CD
18637	23520	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23520	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	23520	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23520	5	,	,	,
18637	23520	6	327	327	CD
18637	23520	7	Carpenter	Carpenter	NNP
18637	23520	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23520	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23520	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23520	11	Shaw	Shaw	NNP
18637	23520	12	,	,	,
18637	23520	13	280	280	CD
18637	23520	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23520	15	363	363	CD
18637	23520	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23520	17	1930	1930	CD
18637	23520	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23520	19	,	,	,
18637	23520	20	864	864	CD
18637	23520	21	,	,	,
18637	23520	22	1060	1060	CD
18637	23520	23	Carpenters	Carpenters	NNP
18637	23520	24	&	&	CC
18637	23520	25	Joiners	Joiners	NNPS
18637	23520	26	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23520	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23520	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	23520	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23520	30	Ritter	Ritter	NNP
18637	23520	31	's	's	POS
18637	23520	32	Cafe	Cafe	NNP
18637	23520	33	,	,	,
18637	23520	34	315	315	CD
18637	23520	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23520	36	722	722	CD
18637	23520	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23520	38	1942	1942	CD
18637	23520	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23520	40	,	,	,
18637	23520	41	782	782	CD
18637	23520	42	,	,	,
18637	23520	43	787	787	CD
18637	23520	44	Carr	Carr	NNP
18637	23520	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23520	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	23520	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23520	48	United	United	NNP
18637	23520	49	States	States	NNP
18637	23520	50	,	,	,
18637	23520	51	98	98	CD
18637	23520	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23520	53	433	433	CD
18637	23520	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23520	55	1879	1879	CD
18637	23520	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23520	57	,	,	,
18637	23520	58	586	586	CD
18637	23520	59	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	23520	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23520	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23520	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23520	63	Becker	Becker	NNP
18637	23520	64	,	,	,
18637	23520	65	285	285	CD
18637	23520	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23520	67	380	380	CD
18637	23520	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23520	69	1932	1932	CD
18637	23520	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23520	71	,	,	,
18637	23520	72	93	93	CD
18637	23520	73	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	23520	74	_	_	NNP
18637	23520	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	23520	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23520	77	Greenwich	Greenwich	NNP
18637	23520	78	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23520	79	.	.	.
18637	23521	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23521	2	,	,	,
18637	23521	3	199	199	CD
18637	23521	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23521	5	401	401	CD
18637	23521	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23521	7	1905	1905	CD
18637	23521	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23521	9	,	,	,
18637	23521	10	971	971	CD
18637	23521	11	,	,	,
18637	23521	12	1022	1022	CD
18637	23521	13	,	,	,
18637	23521	14	1160	1160	CD
18637	23521	15	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	23521	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23521	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	19	United	United	NNP
18637	23521	20	States	States	NNP
18637	23521	21	,	,	,
18637	23521	22	267	267	CD
18637	23521	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23521	24	132	132	CD
18637	23521	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23521	26	1925	1925	CD
18637	23521	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23521	28	,	,	,
18637	23521	29	823	823	CD
18637	23521	30	,	,	,
18637	23521	31	824	824	CD
18637	23521	32	,	,	,
18637	23521	33	830	830	CD
18637	23521	34	Carson	Carson	NNP
18637	23521	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	23521	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	38	Roane	Roane	NNP
18637	23521	39	-	-	HYPH
18637	23521	40	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	23521	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23521	42	,	,	,
18637	23521	43	342	342	CD
18637	23521	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23521	45	232	232	CD
18637	23521	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23521	47	1952	1952	CD
18637	23521	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23521	49	,	,	,
18637	23521	50	734	734	CD
18637	23521	51	Carson	Carson	NNP
18637	23521	52	Petroleum	Petroleum	NNP
18637	23521	53	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23521	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	23521	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	57	Vial	Vial	NNP
18637	23521	58	,	,	,
18637	23521	59	279	279	CD
18637	23521	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23521	61	95	95	CD
18637	23521	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23521	63	1929	1929	CD
18637	23521	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23521	65	,	,	,
18637	23521	66	186	186	CD
18637	23521	67	Carstairs	Carstairs	NNPS
18637	23521	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	23521	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	71	Cochran	Cochran	NNP
18637	23521	72	,	,	,
18637	23521	73	193	193	CD
18637	23521	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23521	75	10	10	CD
18637	23521	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23521	77	1904	1904	CD
18637	23521	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23521	79	,	,	,
18637	23521	80	1042	1042	CD
18637	23521	81	,	,	,
18637	23521	82	1061	1061	CD
18637	23521	83	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	23521	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	23521	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	87	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	23521	88	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	23521	89	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23521	90	,	,	,
18637	23521	91	298	298	CD
18637	23521	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23521	93	238	238	CD
18637	23521	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23521	95	1936	1936	CD
18637	23521	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23521	97	,	,	,
18637	23521	98	78	78	CD
18637	23521	99	,	,	,
18637	23521	100	154	154	CD
18637	23521	101	,	,	,
18637	23521	102	541	541	CD
18637	23521	103	,	,	,
18637	23521	104	562	562	CD
18637	23521	105	,	,	,
18637	23521	106	565	565	CD
18637	23521	107	,	,	,
18637	23521	108	918	918	CD
18637	23521	109	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	23521	110	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	111	v.	v.	IN
18637	23521	112	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	113	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23521	114	,	,	,
18637	23521	115	329	329	CD
18637	23521	116	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23521	117	173	173	CD
18637	23521	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23521	119	1946	1946	CD
18637	23521	120	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23521	121	,	,	,
18637	23521	122	1102	1102	CD
18637	23521	123	,	,	,
18637	23521	124	1138	1138	CD
18637	23521	125	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	23521	126	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	127	v.	v.	IN
18637	23521	128	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	129	McClaughry	McClaughry	NNP
18637	23521	130	,	,	,
18637	23521	131	183	183	CD
18637	23521	132	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23521	133	365	365	CD
18637	23521	134	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23521	135	1902	1902	CD
18637	23521	136	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23521	137	,	,	,
18637	23521	138	840	840	CD
18637	23521	139	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	23521	140	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	141	v.	v.	IN
18637	23521	142	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	143	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	23521	144	,	,	,
18637	23521	145	177	177	CD
18637	23521	146	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23521	147	496	496	CD
18637	23521	148	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23521	149	1900	1900	CD
18637	23521	150	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23521	151	,	,	,
18637	23521	152	286	286	CD
18637	23521	153	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	23521	154	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	155	v.	v.	IN
18637	23521	156	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	157	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	23521	158	,	,	,
18637	23521	159	321	321	CD
18637	23521	160	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23521	161	131	131	CD
18637	23521	162	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23521	163	1944	1944	CD
18637	23521	164	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23521	165	,	,	,
18637	23521	166	241	241	CD
18637	23521	167	,	,	,
18637	23521	168	1233	1233	CD
18637	23521	169	Cartlidge	Cartlidge	NNP
18637	23521	170	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	171	v.	v.	IN
18637	23521	172	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	173	Rainey	Rainey	NNP
18637	23521	174	,	,	,
18637	23521	175	168	168	CD
18637	23521	176	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23521	177	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23521	178	2d	2d	NNP
18637	23521	179	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23521	180	841	841	CD
18637	23521	181	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23521	182	1948	1948	CD
18637	23521	183	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23521	184	,	,	,
18637	23521	185	1233	1233	CD
18637	23521	186	Carver	Carver	NNP
18637	23521	187	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	188	v.	v.	IN
18637	23521	189	_	_	NNP
18637	23521	190	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	23521	191	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23521	192	dem	dem	NNP
18637	23521	193	.	.	.
18637	23522	1	Astor	Astor	NNP
18637	23522	2	,	,	,
18637	23522	3	4	4	CD
18637	23522	4	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23522	5	.	.	.
18637	23523	1	1	1	CD
18637	23523	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23523	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	23523	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23523	5	,	,	,
18637	23523	6	896	896	CD
18637	23523	7	Cary	Cary	NNP
18637	23523	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23523	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23523	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23523	11	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	23523	12	,	,	,
18637	23523	13	3	3	CD
18637	23523	14	How	how	WRB
18637	23523	15	.	.	.
18637	23524	1	236	236	CD
18637	23524	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23524	3	1845	1845	CD
18637	23524	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23524	5	,	,	,
18637	23524	6	512	512	CD
18637	23524	7	,	,	,
18637	23524	8	525	525	CD
18637	23524	9	,	,	,
18637	23524	10	618	618	CD
18637	23524	11	,	,	,
18637	23524	12	619	619	CD
18637	23524	13	,	,	,
18637	23524	14	620	620	CD
18637	23524	15	Case	Case	NNP
18637	23524	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23524	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23524	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23524	19	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	23524	20	,	,	,
18637	23524	21	327	327	CD
18637	23524	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23524	23	92	92	CD
18637	23524	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23524	25	1946	1946	CD
18637	23524	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23524	27	,	,	,
18637	23524	28	918	918	CD
18637	23524	29	,	,	,
18637	23524	30	919	919	CD
18637	23524	31	,	,	,
18637	23524	32	1064	1064	CD
18637	23524	33	Case	Case	NNP
18637	23524	34	of	of	IN
18637	23524	35	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	23524	36	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23524	37	,	,	,
18637	23524	38	7	7	CD
18637	23524	39	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	23524	40	.	.	.
18637	23525	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	23525	2	.	.	.
18637	23526	1	No	no	UH
18637	23526	2	.	.	.
18637	23527	1	3621a	3621a	CD
18637	23527	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23527	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	23527	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23527	5	,	,	,
18637	23527	6	643	643	CD
18637	23527	7	Case	case	NN
18637	23527	8	of	of	IN
18637	23527	9	the	the	DT
18637	23527	10	State	State	NNP
18637	23527	11	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23527	12	on	on	IN
18637	23527	13	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	23527	14	-	-	HYPH
18637	23527	15	Held	hold	VBN
18637	23527	16	Bonds	Bonds	NNPS
18637	23527	17	,	,	,
18637	23527	18	15	15	CD
18637	23527	19	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23527	20	.	.	.
18637	23528	1	300	300	CD
18637	23528	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23528	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	23528	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23528	5	,	,	,
18637	23528	6	179	179	CD
18637	23528	7	,	,	,
18637	23528	8	193	193	CD
18637	23528	9	,	,	,
18637	23528	10	198	198	CD
18637	23528	11	Caskey	Caskey	NNP
18637	23528	12	Baking	Baking	NNP
18637	23528	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23528	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23528	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23528	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23528	17	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	23528	18	,	,	,
18637	23528	19	313	313	CD
18637	23528	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23528	21	117	117	CD
18637	23528	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23528	23	1941	1941	CD
18637	23528	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23528	25	,	,	,
18637	23528	26	184	184	CD
18637	23528	27	,	,	,
18637	23528	28	1148	1148	CD
18637	23528	29	Cass	Cass	NNP
18637	23528	30	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	23528	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23528	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23528	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23528	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23528	35	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	23528	36	,	,	,
18637	23528	37	181	181	CD
18637	23528	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23528	39	396	396	CD
18637	23528	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23528	41	1901	1901	CD
18637	23528	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23528	43	,	,	,
18637	23528	44	1036	1036	CD
18637	23528	45	Cassell	Cassell	NNP
18637	23528	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23528	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	23528	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23528	49	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23528	50	,	,	,
18637	23528	51	339	339	CD
18637	23528	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23528	53	282	282	CD
18637	23528	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23528	55	1950	1950	CD
18637	23528	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23528	57	,	,	,
18637	23528	58	1168	1168	CD
18637	23528	59	Cavanaugh	Cavanaugh	NNP
18637	23528	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23528	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23528	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23528	63	Looney	Looney	NNP
18637	23528	64	,	,	,
18637	23528	65	248	248	CD
18637	23528	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23528	67	453	453	CD
18637	23528	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23528	69	1919	1919	CD
18637	23528	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23528	71	,	,	,
18637	23528	72	934	934	CD
18637	23528	73	Cavellier	Cavellier	NNP
18637	23528	74	,	,	,
18637	23528	75	In	in	IN
18637	23528	76	re	re	NN
18637	23528	77	,	,	,
18637	23528	78	159	159	CD
18637	23528	79	Misc	Misc	NNP
18637	23528	80	.	.	.
18637	23529	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23529	2	N.Y.	New York	NNP
18637	23529	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23529	4	212	212	CD
18637	23529	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23529	6	1936	1936	CD
18637	23529	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23529	8	,	,	,
18637	23529	9	1220	1220	CD
18637	23529	10	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23529	11	Greyhound	Greyhound	NNP
18637	23529	12	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	23529	13	,	,	,
18637	23529	14	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	23529	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23529	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	23529	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23529	18	Mealey	Mealey	NNP
18637	23529	19	,	,	,
18637	23529	20	334	334	CD
18637	23529	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23529	22	653	653	CD
18637	23529	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23529	24	1948	1948	CD
18637	23529	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23529	26	,	,	,
18637	23529	27	206	206	CD
18637	23529	28	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23529	29	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
18637	23529	30	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23529	31	&	&	CC
18637	23529	32	T.	T.	NNP
18637	23529	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23529	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23529	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23529	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23529	37	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
18637	23529	38	,	,	,
18637	23529	39	319	319	CD
18637	23529	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23529	41	94	94	CD
18637	23529	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23529	43	1943	1943	CD
18637	23529	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23529	45	,	,	,
18637	23529	46	1049	1049	CD
18637	23529	47	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23529	48	Land	Land	NNP
18637	23529	49	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23529	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23529	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	23529	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23529	53	Laidley	Laidley	NNP
18637	23529	54	,	,	,
18637	23529	55	159	159	CD
18637	23529	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23529	57	103	103	CD
18637	23529	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23529	59	1895	1895	CD
18637	23529	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23529	61	,	,	,
18637	23529	62	329	329	CD
18637	23529	63	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23529	64	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	23529	65	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23529	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23529	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23529	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23529	69	South	South	NNP
18637	23529	70	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	23529	71	,	,	,
18637	23529	72	226	226	CD
18637	23529	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23529	74	157	157	CD
18637	23529	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23529	76	1912	1912	CD
18637	23529	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23529	78	,	,	,
18637	23529	79	1018	1018	CD
18637	23529	80	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23529	81	National	National	NNP
18637	23529	82	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23529	83	_	_	NNP
18637	23529	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	23529	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23529	86	Stevens	Stevens	NNP
18637	23529	87	,	,	,
18637	23529	88	169	169	CD
18637	23529	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23529	90	432	432	CD
18637	23529	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23529	92	1898	1898	CD
18637	23529	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23529	94	,	,	,
18637	23529	95	627	627	CD
18637	23529	96	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23529	97	of	of	IN
18637	23529	98	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23529	99	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23529	100	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23529	101	_	_	NNP
18637	23529	102	v.	v.	IN
18637	23529	103	_	_	NNP
18637	23529	104	Murphey	Murphey	NNP
18637	23529	105	,	,	,
18637	23529	106	196	196	CD
18637	23529	107	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23529	108	194	194	CD
18637	23529	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23529	110	1905	1905	CD
18637	23529	111	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23529	112	,	,	,
18637	23529	113	247	247	CD
18637	23529	114	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23529	115	of	of	IN
18637	23529	116	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23529	117	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23529	118	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23529	119	_	_	NNP
18637	23529	120	v.	v.	IN
18637	23529	121	_	_	NNP
18637	23529	122	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	23529	123	,	,	,
18637	23529	124	207	207	CD
18637	23529	125	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23529	126	127	127	CD
18637	23529	127	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23529	128	1907	1907	CD
18637	23529	129	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23529	130	,	,	,
18637	23529	131	849	849	CD
18637	23529	132	,	,	,
18637	23529	133	1060	1060	CD
18637	23529	134	,	,	,
18637	23529	135	1085	1085	CD
18637	23529	136	Central	central	JJ
18637	23529	137	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23530	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23530	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23530	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23530	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23530	5	Gallatin	Gallatin	NNP
18637	23530	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23530	7	Sinking	Sinking	NNP
18637	23530	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	23530	9	Fund	Fund	NNP
18637	23530	10	Cases	case	NNS
18637	23530	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23530	12	,	,	,
18637	23530	13	99	99	CD
18637	23530	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23530	15	700	700	CD
18637	23530	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23530	17	1879	1879	CD
18637	23530	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23530	19	,	,	,
18637	23530	20	362	362	CD
18637	23530	21	,	,	,
18637	23530	22	563	563	CD
18637	23530	23	,	,	,
18637	23530	24	981	981	CD
18637	23530	25	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23530	26	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23530	27	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23530	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23530	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23530	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	23530	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23530	32	Garvan	Garvan	NNP
18637	23530	33	,	,	,
18637	23530	34	254	254	CD
18637	23530	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23530	36	554	554	CD
18637	23530	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23530	38	1921	1921	CD
18637	23530	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23530	40	,	,	,
18637	23530	41	295	295	CD
18637	23530	42	Chae	Chae	NNP
18637	23530	43	Chan	Chan	NNP
18637	23530	44	Ping	Ping	NNP
18637	23530	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23530	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	23530	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23530	48	United	United	NNP
18637	23530	49	States	States	NNP
18637	23530	50	,	,	,
18637	23530	51	130	130	CD
18637	23530	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23530	53	581	581	CD
18637	23530	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23530	55	1889	1889	CD
18637	23530	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23530	57	,	,	,
18637	23530	58	421	421	CD
18637	23530	59	Chaffin	Chaffin	NNP
18637	23530	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23530	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23530	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23530	63	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	23530	64	,	,	,
18637	23530	65	116	116	CD
18637	23530	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23530	67	567	567	CD
18637	23530	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23530	69	1886	1886	CD
18637	23530	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23530	71	,	,	,
18637	23530	72	326	326	CD
18637	23530	73	Chalker	Chalker	NNP
18637	23530	74	_	_	NNP
18637	23530	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	23530	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23530	77	Birmingham	Birmingham	NNP
18637	23530	78	&	&	CC
18637	23530	79	M.W.R.	M.W.R.	NNP
18637	23531	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23531	2	,	,	,
18637	23531	3	249	249	CD
18637	23531	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23531	5	522	522	CD
18637	23531	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23531	7	1919	1919	CD
18637	23531	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23531	9	,	,	,
18637	23531	10	693	693	CD
18637	23531	11	Chambers	Chambers	NNPS
18637	23531	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23531	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23531	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23531	15	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23531	16	&	&	CC
18637	23531	17	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	23532	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23532	2	,	,	,
18637	23532	3	207	207	CD
18637	23532	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23532	5	142	142	CD
18637	23532	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23532	7	1907	1907	CD
18637	23532	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23532	9	,	,	,
18637	23532	10	687	687	CD
18637	23532	11	,	,	,
18637	23532	12	692	692	CD
18637	23532	13	Chambers	Chambers	NNPS
18637	23532	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23532	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23532	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23532	17	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	23532	18	,	,	,
18637	23532	19	309	309	CD
18637	23532	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23532	21	227	227	CD
18637	23532	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23532	23	1940	1940	CD
18637	23532	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23532	25	,	,	,
18637	23532	26	1112	1112	CD
18637	23532	27	,	,	,
18637	23532	28	1113	1113	CD
18637	23532	29	,	,	,
18637	23532	30	1121	1121	CD
18637	23532	31	Champion	Champion	NNP
18637	23532	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23532	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23532	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23532	35	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	23532	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23532	37	The	the	DT
18637	23532	38	Lottery	Lottery	NNP
18637	23532	39	Case	Case	NNP
18637	23532	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23532	41	,	,	,
18637	23532	42	188	188	CD
18637	23532	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23532	44	321	321	CD
18637	23532	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23532	46	1903	1903	CD
18637	23532	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23532	48	,	,	,
18637	23532	49	124	124	CD
18637	23532	50	,	,	,
18637	23532	51	168	168	CD
18637	23532	52	,	,	,
18637	23532	53	169	169	CD
18637	23532	54	,	,	,
18637	23532	55	919	919	CD
18637	23532	56	Champlain	Champlain	NNP
18637	23532	57	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	23532	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23532	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23532	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23532	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23532	62	Brattleboro	Brattleboro	NNP
18637	23532	63	,	,	,
18637	23532	64	260	260	CD
18637	23532	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23532	66	366	366	CD
18637	23532	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23532	68	1922	1922	CD
18637	23532	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23532	70	,	,	,
18637	23532	71	186	186	CD
18637	23532	72	Champlin	Champlin	NNP
18637	23532	73	Ref	Ref	NNP
18637	23532	74	.	.	.
18637	23533	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23533	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23533	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	5	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	23533	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23533	7	,	,	,
18637	23533	8	286	286	CD
18637	23533	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23533	10	210	210	CD
18637	23533	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23533	12	1932	1932	CD
18637	23533	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23533	14	,	,	,
18637	23533	15	1025	1025	CD
18637	23533	16	Champlin	Champlin	NNP
18637	23533	17	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	23533	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23533	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	23533	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	22	United	United	NNP
18637	23533	23	States	States	NNP
18637	23533	24	,	,	,
18637	23533	25	329	329	CD
18637	23533	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23533	27	29	29	CD
18637	23533	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23533	29	1946	1946	CD
18637	23533	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23533	31	,	,	,
18637	23533	32	860	860	CD
18637	23533	33	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	23533	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23533	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	37	Dix	Dix	NNP
18637	23533	38	,	,	,
18637	23533	39	194	194	CD
18637	23533	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23533	41	590	590	CD
18637	23533	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23533	43	1904	1904	CD
18637	23533	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23533	45	,	,	,
18637	23533	46	931	931	CD
18637	23533	47	,	,	,
18637	23533	48	936	936	CD
18637	23533	49	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	23533	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	23533	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	53	Wise	Wise	NNP
18637	23533	54	,	,	,
18637	23533	55	307	307	CD
18637	23533	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23533	57	474	474	CD
18637	23533	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23533	59	1939	1939	CD
18637	23533	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23533	61	,	,	,
18637	23533	62	715	715	CD
18637	23533	63	Chanler	Chanler	NNP
18637	23533	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	23533	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	67	Kelsey	Kelsey	NNP
18637	23533	68	,	,	,
18637	23533	69	205	205	CD
18637	23533	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23533	71	466	466	CD
18637	23533	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23533	73	1907	1907	CD
18637	23533	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23533	75	,	,	,
18637	23533	76	1038	1038	CD
18637	23533	77	Chaplinsky	Chaplinsky	NNP
18637	23533	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	23533	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	81	New	New	NNP
18637	23533	82	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	23533	83	,	,	,
18637	23533	84	315	315	CD
18637	23533	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23533	86	568	568	CD
18637	23533	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23533	88	1942	1942	CD
18637	23533	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23533	90	,	,	,
18637	23533	91	786	786	CD
18637	23533	92	,	,	,
18637	23533	93	788	788	CD
18637	23533	94	,	,	,
18637	23533	95	791	791	CD
18637	23533	96	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	23533	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	98	v.	v.	IN
18637	23533	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	100	Brewer	Brewer	NNP
18637	23533	101	,	,	,
18637	23533	102	114	114	CD
18637	23533	103	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23533	104	158	158	CD
18637	23533	105	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23533	106	1885	1885	CD
18637	23533	107	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23533	108	,	,	,
18637	23533	109	895	895	CD
18637	23533	110	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	23533	111	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	112	v.	v.	IN
18637	23533	113	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	114	King	King	NNP
18637	23533	115	,	,	,
18637	23533	116	154	154	CD
18637	23533	117	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23533	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23533	119	2d	2d	CD
18637	23533	120	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23533	121	460	460	CD
18637	23533	122	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23533	123	1946	1946	CD
18637	23533	124	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23533	125	,	,	,
18637	23533	126	1208	1208	CD
18637	23533	127	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	23533	128	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	129	v.	v.	IN
18637	23533	130	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	131	King	King	NNP
18637	23533	132	,	,	,
18637	23533	133	327	327	CD
18637	23533	134	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23533	135	800	800	CD
18637	23533	136	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23533	137	1946	1946	CD
18637	23533	138	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23533	139	,	,	,
18637	23533	140	1208	1208	CD
18637	23533	141	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	23533	142	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	143	v.	v.	IN
18637	23533	144	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	145	Zobelein	Zobelein	NNP
18637	23533	146	,	,	,
18637	23533	147	237	237	CD
18637	23533	148	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23533	149	135	135	CD
18637	23533	150	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23533	151	1915	1915	CD
18637	23533	152	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23533	153	,	,	,
18637	23533	154	1037	1037	CD
18637	23533	155	,	,	,
18637	23533	156	1062	1062	CD
18637	23533	157	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	23533	158	,	,	,
18637	23533	159	In	in	IN
18637	23533	160	re	re	NN
18637	23533	161	,	,	,
18637	23533	162	166	166	CD
18637	23533	163	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23533	164	661	661	CD
18637	23533	165	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23533	166	1897	1897	CD
18637	23533	167	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23533	168	,	,	,
18637	23533	169	84	84	CD
18637	23533	170	-	-	SYM
18637	23533	171	86	86	CD
18637	23533	172	,	,	,
18637	23533	173	98	98	CD
18637	23533	174	,	,	,
18637	23533	175	476	476	CD
18637	23533	176	,	,	,
18637	23533	177	841	841	CD
18637	23533	178	Chappell	Chappell	NNP
18637	23533	179	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	180	v.	v.	IN
18637	23533	181	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	182	United	United	NNP
18637	23533	183	States	States	NNP
18637	23533	184	,	,	,
18637	23533	185	160	160	CD
18637	23533	186	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23533	187	499	499	CD
18637	23533	188	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23533	189	1896	1896	CD
18637	23533	190	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23533	191	,	,	,
18637	23533	192	865	865	CD
18637	23533	193	Charles	Charles	NNP
18637	23533	194	River	River	NNP
18637	23533	195	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	23533	196	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23533	197	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	198	v.	v.	IN
18637	23533	199	_	_	NNP
18637	23533	200	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	23533	201	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	23533	202	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23533	203	,	,	,
18637	23533	204	11	11	CD
18637	23533	205	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23533	206	.	.	.
18637	23534	1	420	420	CD
18637	23534	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23534	3	1837	1837	CD
18637	23534	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23534	5	,	,	,
18637	23534	6	339	339	CD
18637	23534	7	,	,	,
18637	23534	8	343	343	CD
18637	23534	9	,	,	,
18637	23534	10	346	346	CD
18637	23534	11	Charleston	Charleston	NNP
18637	23534	12	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	23534	13	.	.	.
18637	23535	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23535	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23535	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23535	4	Alderson	Alderson	NNP
18637	23535	5	,	,	,
18637	23535	6	324	324	CD
18637	23535	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23535	8	182	182	CD
18637	23535	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23535	10	1945	1945	CD
18637	23535	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23535	12	,	,	,
18637	23535	13	1152	1152	CD
18637	23535	14	Charlotte	Charlotte	NNP
18637	23535	15	,	,	,
18637	23535	16	C.	C.	NNP
18637	23535	17	&	&	CC
18637	23535	18	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	23536	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23536	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23536	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23536	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23536	5	Gibbes	Gibbes	NNP
18637	23536	6	,	,	,
18637	23536	7	142	142	CD
18637	23536	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23536	9	386	386	CD
18637	23536	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23536	11	1892	1892	CD
18637	23536	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23536	13	,	,	,
18637	23536	14	213	213	CD
18637	23536	15	Charlotte	Charlotte	NNP
18637	23536	16	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	23536	17	&	&	CC
18637	23536	18	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	23537	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23537	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23537	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23537	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23537	5	Welles	Welles	NNP
18637	23537	6	,	,	,
18637	23537	7	260	260	CD
18637	23537	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23537	9	8	8	CD
18637	23537	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23537	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	23537	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23537	13	,	,	,
18637	23537	14	1041	1041	CD
18637	23537	15	Charlton	Charlton	NNP
18637	23537	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23537	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23537	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23537	19	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
18637	23537	20	,	,	,
18637	23537	21	229	229	CD
18637	23537	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23537	23	447	447	CD
18637	23537	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23537	25	1913	1913	CD
18637	23537	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23537	27	,	,	,
18637	23537	28	425	425	CD
18637	23537	29	,	,	,
18637	23537	30	426	426	CD
18637	23537	31	,	,	,
18637	23537	32	473	473	CD
18637	23537	33	,	,	,
18637	23537	34	493	493	CD
18637	23537	35	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	23537	36	National	National	NNP
18637	23537	37	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23537	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23537	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23537	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23537	41	United	United	NNP
18637	23537	42	States	States	NNP
18637	23537	43	,	,	,
18637	23537	44	278	278	CD
18637	23537	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23537	46	327	327	CD
18637	23537	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23537	48	1929	1929	CD
18637	23537	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23537	50	,	,	,
18637	23537	51	321	321	CD
18637	23537	52	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	23537	53	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	23537	54	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23537	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23537	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	23537	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23537	58	Donaldson	Donaldson	NNP
18637	23537	59	,	,	,
18637	23537	60	325	325	CD
18637	23537	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23537	62	304	304	CD
18637	23537	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23537	64	1945	1945	CD
18637	23537	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23537	66	,	,	,
18637	23537	67	1035	1035	CD
18637	23537	68	,	,	,
18637	23537	69	1093	1093	CD
18637	23537	70	Chassaniol	Chassaniol	NNP
18637	23537	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23537	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	23537	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23537	74	Greenwood	Greenwood	NNP
18637	23537	75	,	,	,
18637	23537	76	291	291	CD
18637	23537	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23537	78	584	584	CD
18637	23537	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23537	80	1934	1934	CD
18637	23537	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23537	82	,	,	,
18637	23537	83	189	189	CD
18637	23537	84	Chastleton	Chastleton	NNP
18637	23537	85	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23537	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23537	87	v.	v.	IN
18637	23537	88	_	_	NNP
18637	23537	89	Sinclair	Sinclair	NNP
18637	23537	90	,	,	,
18637	23537	91	264	264	CD
18637	23537	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23537	93	543	543	CD
18637	23537	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23537	95	1924	1924	CD
18637	23537	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23537	97	,	,	,
18637	23537	98	293	293	CD
18637	23537	99	,	,	,
18637	23537	100	359	359	CD
18637	23537	101	Cheatham	Cheatham	NNP
18637	23537	102	et	et	NNP
18637	23537	103	al	al	NNP
18637	23537	104	.	.	.
18637	23538	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23538	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23538	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23538	4	United	United	NNP
18637	23538	5	States	States	NNP
18637	23538	6	,	,	,
18637	23538	7	92	92	CD
18637	23538	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23538	9	85	85	CD
18637	23538	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23538	11	1875	1875	CD
18637	23538	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23538	13	,	,	,
18637	23538	14	541	541	CD
18637	23538	15	,	,	,
18637	23538	16	621	621	CD
18637	23538	17	Cheever	Cheever	NNP
18637	23538	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23538	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23538	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23538	21	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	23538	22	,	,	,
18637	23538	23	9	9	CD
18637	23538	24	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23538	25	.	.	.
18637	23539	1	108	108	CD
18637	23539	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23539	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	23539	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23539	5	,	,	,
18637	23539	6	662	662	CD
18637	23539	7	,	,	,
18637	23539	8	682	682	CD
18637	23539	9	Chelentis	Chelentis	NNP
18637	23539	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23539	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23539	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23539	13	Luckenbach	Luckenbach	NNP
18637	23539	14	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	23539	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23539	16	,	,	,
18637	23539	17	247	247	CD
18637	23539	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23539	19	372	372	CD
18637	23539	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23539	21	1918	1918	CD
18637	23539	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23539	23	,	,	,
18637	23539	24	579	579	CD
18637	23539	25	Chemung	Chemung	NNP
18637	23539	26	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	23539	27	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23539	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23539	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23539	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23539	31	Lowery	Lowery	NNP
18637	23539	32	,	,	,
18637	23539	33	93	93	CD
18637	23539	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23539	35	72	72	CD
18637	23539	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23539	37	1876	1876	CD
18637	23539	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23539	39	,	,	,
18637	23539	40	692	692	CD
18637	23539	41	Cheney	Cheney	NNP
18637	23539	42	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	23539	43	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23539	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23539	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	23539	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23539	47	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	23539	48	,	,	,
18637	23539	49	246	246	CD
18637	23539	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23539	51	147	147	CD
18637	23539	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23539	53	1918	1918	CD
18637	23539	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23539	55	,	,	,
18637	23539	56	187	187	CD
18637	23539	57	,	,	,
18637	23539	58	197	197	CD
18637	23539	59	,	,	,
18637	23539	60	1150	1150	CD
18637	23539	61	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	23539	62	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	23539	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23539	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	23539	65	_	_	NNP
18637	23539	66	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23539	67	,	,	,
18637	23539	68	5	5	CD
18637	23539	69	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23539	70	.	.	.
18637	23540	1	1	1	CD
18637	23540	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23540	3	1831	1831	CD
18637	23540	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23540	5	,	,	,
18637	23540	6	431	431	CD
18637	23540	7	,	,	,
18637	23540	8	548	548	CD
18637	23540	9	,	,	,
18637	23540	10	610	610	CD
18637	23540	11	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	23540	12	Nation	Nation	NNP
18637	23540	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23540	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	23540	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23540	16	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	23540	17	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23540	18	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23540	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23540	20	,	,	,
18637	23540	21	135	135	CD
18637	23540	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23540	23	641	641	CD
18637	23540	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23540	25	1890	1890	CD
18637	23540	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23540	27	,	,	,
18637	23540	28	132	132	CD
18637	23540	29	,	,	,
18637	23540	30	432	432	CD
18637	23540	31	,	,	,
18637	23540	32	872	872	CD
18637	23540	33	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
18637	23540	34	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	23540	35	,	,	,
18637	23540	36	The	the	DT
18637	23540	37	,	,	,
18637	23540	38	11	11	CD
18637	23540	39	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23540	40	.	.	.
18637	23541	1	616	616	CD
18637	23541	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23541	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	23541	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23541	5	,	,	,
18637	23541	6	421	421	CD
18637	23541	7	,	,	,
18637	23541	8	432	432	CD
18637	23541	9	,	,	,
18637	23541	10	433	433	CD
18637	23541	11	Chesapeake	Chesapeake	NNP
18637	23541	12	&	&	CC
18637	23541	13	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	23542	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23542	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23542	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23542	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23542	5	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	23542	6	,	,	,
18637	23542	7	114	114	CD
18637	23542	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23542	9	176	176	CD
18637	23542	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23542	11	1885	1885	CD
18637	23542	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23542	13	,	,	,
18637	23542	14	343	343	CD
18637	23542	15	Chesapeake	Chesapeake	NNP
18637	23542	16	&	&	CC
18637	23542	17	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	23543	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23543	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23543	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23543	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23543	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	23543	6	Service	Service	NNP
18637	23543	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23543	8	,	,	,
18637	23543	9	242	242	CD
18637	23543	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23543	11	603	603	CD
18637	23543	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23543	13	1917	1917	CD
18637	23543	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23543	15	,	,	,
18637	23543	16	1011	1011	CD
18637	23543	17	,	,	,
18637	23543	18	1012	1012	CD
18637	23543	19	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23543	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23543	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	23543	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23543	23	Sturges	Sturges	NNP
18637	23543	24	,	,	,
18637	23543	25	222	222	CD
18637	23543	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23543	27	313	313	CD
18637	23543	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23543	29	1911	1911	CD
18637	23543	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23543	31	,	,	,
18637	23543	32	1036	1036	CD
18637	23543	33	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23543	34	&	&	CC
18637	23543	35	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	23544	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23544	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23544	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23544	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23544	5	Tranbarger	Tranbarger	NNP
18637	23544	6	,	,	,
18637	23544	7	238	238	CD
18637	23544	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23544	9	67	67	CD
18637	23544	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23544	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	23544	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23544	13	,	,	,
18637	23544	14	327	327	CD
18637	23544	15	,	,	,
18637	23544	16	346	346	CD
18637	23544	17	,	,	,
18637	23544	18	352	352	CD
18637	23544	19	,	,	,
18637	23544	20	1011	1011	CD
18637	23544	21	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23544	22	&	&	CC
18637	23544	23	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	23545	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23545	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23545	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23545	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23545	5	Wiggins	Wiggins	NNP
18637	23545	6	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	23545	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23545	8	,	,	,
18637	23545	9	119	119	CD
18637	23545	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23545	11	615	615	CD
18637	23545	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23545	13	1887	1887	CD
18637	23545	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23545	15	,	,	,
18637	23545	16	654	654	CD
18637	23545	17	,	,	,
18637	23545	18	676	676	CD
18637	23545	19	,	,	,
18637	23545	20	677	677	CD
18637	23545	21	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23545	22	&	&	CC
18637	23545	23	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	23545	24	Trunk	Trunk	NNP
18637	23545	25	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	23545	26	.	.	.
18637	23546	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23546	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23546	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23546	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23546	5	Wellman	Wellman	NNP
18637	23546	6	,	,	,
18637	23546	7	143	143	CD
18637	23546	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23546	9	339	339	CD
18637	23546	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23546	11	1892	1892	CD
18637	23546	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23546	13	,	,	,
18637	23546	14	539	539	CD
18637	23546	15	,	,	,
18637	23546	16	540	540	CD
18637	23546	17	,	,	,
18637	23546	18	561	561	CD
18637	23546	19	,	,	,
18637	23546	20	1005	1005	CD
18637	23546	21	,	,	,
18637	23546	22	1009	1009	CD
18637	23546	23	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23546	24	&	&	CC
18637	23546	25	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	23547	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23547	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23547	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23547	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23547	5	Fuller	Fuller	NNP
18637	23547	6	,	,	,
18637	23547	7	17	17	CD
18637	23547	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23547	9	.	.	.
18637	23548	1	560	560	CD
18637	23548	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23548	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	23548	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23548	5	,	,	,
18637	23548	6	126	126	CD
18637	23548	7	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23548	8	&	&	CC
18637	23548	9	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	23549	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23549	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23549	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23549	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23549	5	Nye	Nye	NNP
18637	23549	6	Schneider	Schneider	NNP
18637	23549	7	Fowler	Fowler	NNP
18637	23549	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23549	9	,	,	,
18637	23549	10	260	260	CD
18637	23549	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23549	12	35	35	CD
18637	23549	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23549	14	1922	1922	CD
18637	23549	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23549	16	,	,	,
18637	23549	17	1015	1015	CD
18637	23549	18	,	,	,
18637	23549	19	1092	1092	CD
18637	23549	20	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23549	21	&	&	CC
18637	23549	22	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	23550	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23550	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23550	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23550	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23550	5	Whitton	Whitton	NNP
18637	23550	6	,	,	,
18637	23550	7	13	13	CD
18637	23550	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23550	9	.	.	.
18637	23551	1	270	270	CD
18637	23551	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23551	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	23551	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23551	5	,	,	,
18637	23551	6	311	311	CD
18637	23551	7	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23551	8	&	&	CC
18637	23551	9	S.	S.	NNP
18637	23551	10	Airlines	Airlines	NNP
18637	23551	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23551	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	23551	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23551	14	Waterman	Waterman	NNP
18637	23551	15	Steamship	Steamship	NNP
18637	23551	16	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23551	17	,	,	,
18637	23551	18	333	333	CD
18637	23551	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23551	20	103	103	CD
18637	23551	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23551	22	1948	1948	CD
18637	23551	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23551	24	,	,	,
18637	23551	25	473	473	CD
18637	23551	26	,	,	,
18637	23551	27	474	474	CD
18637	23551	28	,	,	,
18637	23551	29	550	550	CD
18637	23551	30	,	,	,
18637	23551	31	623	623	CD
18637	23551	32	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23551	33	,	,	,
18637	23551	34	B.	B.	NNP
18637	23552	1	&	&	CC
18637	23552	2	K.C.R.	K.C.R.	NNP
18637	23553	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23553	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23553	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23553	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23553	5	Guffey	Guffey	NNP
18637	23553	6	,	,	,
18637	23553	7	120	120	CD
18637	23553	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23553	9	569	569	CD
18637	23553	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23553	11	1887	1887	CD
18637	23553	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23553	13	,	,	,
18637	23553	14	348	348	CD
18637	23553	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23553	16	,	,	,
18637	23553	17	B.	B.	NNP
18637	23554	1	&	&	CC
18637	23554	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	23555	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23555	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23555	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23555	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23555	5	Babcock	Babcock	NNP
18637	23555	6	,	,	,
18637	23555	7	204	204	CD
18637	23555	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23555	9	585	585	CD
18637	23555	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23555	11	1907	1907	CD
18637	23555	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23555	13	,	,	,
18637	23555	14	1152	1152	CD
18637	23555	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23555	16	,	,	,
18637	23555	17	B.	B.	NNP
18637	23556	1	&	&	CC
18637	23556	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	23557	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23557	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23557	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23557	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23557	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23557	6	,	,	,
18637	23557	7	166	166	CD
18637	23557	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23557	9	226	226	CD
18637	23557	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23557	11	1897	1897	CD
18637	23557	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23557	13	,	,	,
18637	23557	14	752	752	CD
18637	23557	15	,	,	,
18637	23557	16	897	897	CD
18637	23557	17	,	,	,
18637	23557	18	999	999	CD
18637	23557	19	,	,	,
18637	23557	20	1010	1010	CD
18637	23557	21	,	,	,
18637	23557	22	1063	1063	CD
18637	23557	23	,	,	,
18637	23557	24	1067	1067	CD
18637	23557	25	,	,	,
18637	23557	26	1089	1089	CD
18637	23557	27	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23557	28	,	,	,
18637	23557	29	B.	B.	NNP
18637	23558	1	&	&	CC
18637	23558	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	23559	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23559	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23559	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23559	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23559	5	Cram	Cram	NNP
18637	23559	6	,	,	,
18637	23559	7	228	228	CD
18637	23559	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23559	9	70	70	CD
18637	23559	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23559	11	1913	1913	CD
18637	23559	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23559	13	,	,	,
18637	23559	14	1016	1016	CD
18637	23559	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23559	16	,	,	,
18637	23559	17	B.	B.	NNP
18637	23560	1	&	&	CC
18637	23560	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	23561	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23561	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23561	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23561	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23561	5	Harrington	Harrington	NNP
18637	23561	6	,	,	,
18637	23561	7	241	241	CD
18637	23561	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23561	9	177	177	CD
18637	23561	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23561	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	23561	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23561	13	,	,	,
18637	23561	14	141	141	CD
18637	23561	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23561	16	,	,	,
18637	23561	17	B.	B.	NNP
18637	23562	1	&	&	CC
18637	23562	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	23563	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23563	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23563	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23563	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23563	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23563	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23563	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	23563	8	.	.	.
18637	23564	1	Grimwood	Grimwood	NNP
18637	23564	2	,	,	,
18637	23564	3	200	200	CD
18637	23564	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23564	5	561	561	CD
18637	23564	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23564	7	1906	1906	CD
18637	23564	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23564	9	,	,	,
18637	23564	10	982	982	CD
18637	23564	11	,	,	,
18637	23564	12	1010	1010	CD
18637	23564	13	,	,	,
18637	23564	14	1011	1011	CD
18637	23564	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23564	16	,	,	,
18637	23564	17	B.	B.	NNP
18637	23565	1	&	&	CC
18637	23565	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	23566	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23566	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23566	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23566	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23566	5	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	23566	6	,	,	,
18637	23566	7	94	94	CD
18637	23566	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23566	9	155	155	CD
18637	23566	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23566	11	1877	1877	CD
18637	23566	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23566	13	,	,	,
18637	23566	14	1009	1009	CD
18637	23566	15	,	,	,
18637	23566	16	1143	1143	CD
18637	23566	17	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23566	18	,	,	,
18637	23566	19	B.	B.	NNP
18637	23567	1	&	&	CC
18637	23567	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	23568	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23568	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23568	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23568	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23568	5	McGuire	McGuire	NNP
18637	23568	6	,	,	,
18637	23568	7	219	219	CD
18637	23568	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23568	9	549	549	CD
18637	23568	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23568	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	23568	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23568	13	,	,	,
18637	23568	14	986	986	CD
18637	23568	15	,	,	,
18637	23568	16	990	990	CD
18637	23568	17	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23568	18	,	,	,
18637	23568	19	B.	B.	NNP
18637	23569	1	&	&	CC
18637	23569	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	23570	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23570	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23570	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23570	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23570	5	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	23570	6	,	,	,
18637	23570	7	170	170	CD
18637	23570	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23570	9	57	57	CD
18637	23570	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23570	11	1898	1898	CD
18637	23570	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23570	13	,	,	,
18637	23570	14	1011	1011	CD
18637	23570	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23570	16	,	,	,
18637	23570	17	B.	B.	NNP
18637	23571	1	&	&	CC
18637	23571	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	23572	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23572	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23572	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23572	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23572	5	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	23572	6	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	23573	1	Com	Com	NNP
18637	23573	2	.	.	NNP
18637	23573	3	,	,	,
18637	23573	4	237	237	CD
18637	23573	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23573	6	220	220	CD
18637	23573	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23573	8	1915	1915	CD
18637	23573	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23573	10	,	,	,
18637	23573	11	221	221	CD
18637	23573	12	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23573	13	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23573	14	of	of	IN
18637	23573	15	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	23573	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23573	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23573	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23573	19	Olsen	Olsen	NNP
18637	23573	20	,	,	,
18637	23573	21	262	262	CD
18637	23573	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23573	23	1	1	CD
18637	23573	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23573	25	1923	1923	CD
18637	23573	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23573	27	,	,	,
18637	23573	28	149	149	CD
18637	23573	29	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23573	30	City	City	NNP
18637	23573	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23573	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	23573	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23573	34	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	23573	35	,	,	,
18637	23573	36	2	2	CD
18637	23573	37	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	23573	38	.	.	.
18637	23574	1	419	419	CD
18637	23574	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23574	3	1862	1862	CD
18637	23574	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23574	5	,	,	,
18637	23574	6	604	604	CD
18637	23574	7	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23574	8	Dock	Dock	NNP
18637	23574	9	&	&	CC
18637	23574	10	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	23574	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23574	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23574	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23574	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23574	15	Fraley	Fraley	NNP
18637	23574	16	,	,	,
18637	23574	17	228	228	CD
18637	23574	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23574	19	680	680	CD
18637	23574	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23574	21	1913	1913	CD
18637	23574	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23574	23	,	,	,
18637	23574	24	1146	1146	CD
18637	23574	25	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23574	26	,	,	,
18637	23574	27	I.	I.	NNP
18637	23575	1	&	&	CC
18637	23575	2	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	23576	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23576	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23576	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23576	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23576	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23576	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23576	7	,	,	,
18637	23576	8	219	219	CD
18637	23576	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23576	10	486	486	CD
18637	23576	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23576	12	1911	1911	CD
18637	23576	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23576	14	,	,	,
18637	23576	15	247	247	CD
18637	23576	16	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23576	17	,	,	,
18637	23576	18	I.	I.	NNP
18637	23577	1	&	&	CC
18637	23577	2	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	23578	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23578	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23578	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23578	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23578	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23578	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23578	7	,	,	,
18637	23578	8	270	270	CD
18637	23578	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23578	10	287	287	CD
18637	23578	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23578	12	1926	1926	CD
18637	23578	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23578	14	,	,	,
18637	23578	15	861	861	CD
18637	23578	16	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23578	17	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23578	18	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23578	19	.	.	.
18637	23579	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23579	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23579	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23579	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23579	5	Cherry	Cherry	NNP
18637	23579	6	,	,	,
18637	23579	7	244	244	CD
18637	23579	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23579	9	25	25	CD
18637	23579	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23579	11	1917	1917	CD
18637	23579	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23579	13	,	,	,
18637	23579	14	1141	1141	CD
18637	23579	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23579	16	,	,	,
18637	23579	17	M.	M.	NNP
18637	23579	18	&	&	CC
18637	23579	19	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23579	20	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23580	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23580	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23580	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23580	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23580	5	Ackley	Ackley	NNP
18637	23580	6	,	,	,
18637	23580	7	94	94	CD
18637	23580	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23580	9	179	179	CD
18637	23580	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23580	11	1877	1877	CD
18637	23580	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23580	13	,	,	,
18637	23580	14	1143	1143	CD
18637	23580	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23580	16	,	,	,
18637	23580	17	M.	M.	NNP
18637	23580	18	&	&	CC
18637	23580	19	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23580	20	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23581	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23581	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23581	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23581	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23581	5	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	23581	6	,	,	,
18637	23581	7	233	233	CD
18637	23581	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23581	9	334	334	CD
18637	23581	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23581	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	23581	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23581	13	,	,	,
18637	23581	14	1013	1013	CD
18637	23581	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23581	16	,	,	,
18637	23581	17	M.	M.	NNP
18637	23581	18	&	&	CC
18637	23581	19	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23581	20	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23582	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23582	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23582	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23582	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23582	5	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
18637	23582	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	23582	7	&	&	CC
18637	23582	8	C.	C.	NNP
18637	23583	1	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	23583	2	.	.	.
18637	23583	3	,	,	,
18637	23583	4	247	247	CD
18637	23583	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23583	6	490	490	CD
18637	23583	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23583	8	1918	1918	CD
18637	23583	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23583	10	,	,	,
18637	23583	11	1013	1013	CD
18637	23583	12	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23583	13	,	,	,
18637	23583	14	M.	M.	NNP
18637	23583	15	&	&	CC
18637	23583	16	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23583	17	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23584	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23584	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23584	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23584	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23584	5	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23584	6	,	,	,
18637	23584	7	134	134	CD
18637	23584	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23584	9	418	418	CD
18637	23584	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23584	11	1890	1890	CD
18637	23584	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23584	13	,	,	,
18637	23584	14	77	77	CD
18637	23584	15	,	,	,
18637	23584	16	995	995	CD
18637	23584	17	,	,	,
18637	23584	18	999	999	CD
18637	23584	19	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23584	20	,	,	,
18637	23584	21	M.	M.	NNP
18637	23584	22	&	&	CC
18637	23584	23	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23584	24	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23585	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23585	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23585	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23585	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23585	5	Polt	Polt	NNP
18637	23585	6	,	,	,
18637	23585	7	232	232	CD
18637	23585	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23585	9	165	165	CD
18637	23585	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23585	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	23585	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23585	13	,	,	,
18637	23585	14	1015	1015	CD
18637	23585	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23585	16	,	,	,
18637	23585	17	M.	M.	NNP
18637	23585	18	&	&	CC
18637	23585	19	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23585	20	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23586	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23586	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23586	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23586	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23586	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	23586	6	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	23586	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23586	8	,	,	,
18637	23586	9	274	274	CD
18637	23586	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23586	11	344	344	CD
18637	23586	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23586	13	1927	1927	CD
18637	23586	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23586	15	,	,	,
18637	23586	16	1000	1000	CD
18637	23586	17	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23586	18	,	,	,
18637	23586	19	M.	M.	NNP
18637	23586	20	&	&	CC
18637	23586	21	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23586	22	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23587	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23587	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23587	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23587	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23587	5	Solan	Solan	NNP
18637	23587	6	,	,	,
18637	23587	7	169	169	CD
18637	23587	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23587	9	133	133	CD
18637	23587	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23587	11	1898	1898	CD
18637	23587	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23587	13	,	,	,
18637	23587	14	223	223	CD
18637	23587	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23587	16	,	,	,
18637	23587	17	M.	M.	NNP
18637	23587	18	&	&	CC
18637	23587	19	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23587	20	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23588	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23588	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23588	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23588	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23588	5	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	23588	6	,	,	,
18637	23588	7	238	238	CD
18637	23588	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23588	9	491	491	CD
18637	23588	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23588	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	23588	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23588	13	,	,	,
18637	23588	14	344	344	CD
18637	23588	15	,	,	,
18637	23588	16	1012	1012	CD
18637	23588	17	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23588	18	,	,	,
18637	23588	19	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	23588	20	&	&	CC
18637	23588	21	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23589	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23589	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23589	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23589	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23589	5	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	23589	6	,	,	,
18637	23589	7	219	219	CD
18637	23589	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23589	9	453	453	CD
18637	23589	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23589	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	23589	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23589	13	,	,	,
18637	23589	14	223	223	CD
18637	23589	15	,	,	,
18637	23589	16	1014	1014	CD
18637	23589	17	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23589	18	,	,	,
18637	23589	19	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	23589	20	&	&	CC
18637	23589	21	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23590	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23590	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23590	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23590	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23590	5	Cole	Cole	NNP
18637	23590	6	,	,	,
18637	23590	7	251	251	CD
18637	23590	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23590	9	54	54	CD
18637	23590	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23590	11	1919	1919	CD
18637	23590	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23590	13	,	,	,
18637	23590	14	1091	1091	CD
18637	23590	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23590	16	,	,	,
18637	23590	17	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	23590	18	&	&	CC
18637	23590	19	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23591	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23591	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23591	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23591	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23591	5	Cramer	Cramer	NNP
18637	23591	6	,	,	,
18637	23591	7	232	232	CD
18637	23591	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23591	9	490	490	CD
18637	23591	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23591	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	23591	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23591	13	,	,	,
18637	23591	14	247	247	CD
18637	23591	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23591	16	,	,	,
18637	23591	17	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	23591	18	&	&	CC
18637	23591	19	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23592	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23592	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23592	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23592	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23592	5	Hardwick	Hardwick	NNP
18637	23592	6	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	23592	7	Elevator	Elevator	NNP
18637	23592	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23592	9	,	,	,
18637	23592	10	226	226	CD
18637	23592	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23592	12	426	426	CD
18637	23592	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23592	14	1913	1913	CD
18637	23592	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23592	16	,	,	,
18637	23592	17	247	247	CD
18637	23592	18	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23592	19	,	,	,
18637	23592	20	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	23592	21	&	&	CC
18637	23592	22	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23593	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23593	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23593	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23593	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23593	5	McGlinn	McGlinn	NNP
18637	23593	6	,	,	,
18637	23593	7	114	114	CD
18637	23593	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23593	9	542	542	CD
18637	23593	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23593	11	1885	1885	CD
18637	23593	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23593	13	,	,	,
18637	23593	14	305	305	CD
18637	23593	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23593	16	,	,	,
18637	23593	17	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	23593	18	&	&	CC
18637	23593	19	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23594	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23594	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23594	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23594	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23594	5	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	23594	6	,	,	,
18637	23594	7	259	259	CD
18637	23594	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23594	9	548	548	CD
18637	23594	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23594	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	23594	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23594	13	,	,	,
18637	23594	14	992	992	CD
18637	23594	15	,	,	,
18637	23594	16	1158	1158	CD
18637	23594	17	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23594	18	,	,	,
18637	23594	19	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	23594	20	&	&	CC
18637	23594	21	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23595	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23595	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23595	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23595	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23595	5	Sturm	Sturm	NNP
18637	23595	6	,	,	,
18637	23595	7	174	174	CD
18637	23595	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23595	9	710	710	CD
18637	23595	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23595	11	1899	1899	CD
18637	23595	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23595	13	,	,	,
18637	23595	14	674	674	CD
18637	23595	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23595	16	,	,	,
18637	23595	17	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	23595	18	&	&	CC
18637	23595	19	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23596	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23596	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23596	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23596	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23596	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23596	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23596	7	,	,	,
18637	23596	8	284	284	CD
18637	23596	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23596	10	80	80	CD
18637	23596	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23596	12	1931	1931	CD
18637	23596	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23596	14	,	,	,
18637	23596	15	862	862	CD
18637	23596	16	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23596	17	,	,	,
18637	23596	18	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23596	19	P.	P.	NNP
18637	23596	20	,	,	,
18637	23596	21	M.	M.	NNP
18637	23596	22	&	&	CC
18637	23596	23	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	23597	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23597	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23597	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23597	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23597	5	Holmberg	Holmberg	NNP
18637	23597	6	,	,	,
18637	23597	7	282	282	CD
18637	23597	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23597	9	162	162	CD
18637	23597	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23597	11	1930	1930	CD
18637	23597	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23597	13	,	,	,
18637	23597	14	1011	1011	CD
18637	23597	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23597	16	Title	Title	NNP
18637	23597	17	&	&	CC
18637	23597	18	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23597	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23597	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23597	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	23597	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23597	23	4136	4136	CD
18637	23597	24	Wilcox	Wilcox	NNP
18637	23597	25	Bldg	Bldg	NNP
18637	23597	26	.	.	.
18637	23598	1	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23598	2	,	,	,
18637	23598	3	302	302	CD
18637	23598	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23598	5	120	120	CD
18637	23598	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23598	7	1937	1937	CD
18637	23598	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23598	9	,	,	,
18637	23598	10	264	264	CD
18637	23598	11	Chinese	Chinese	NNP
18637	23598	12	Exclusion	Exclusion	NNP
18637	23598	13	Case	Case	NNP
18637	23598	14	,	,	,
18637	23598	15	120	120	CD
18637	23598	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23598	17	581	581	CD
18637	23598	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23598	19	1889	1889	CD
18637	23598	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23598	21	,	,	,
18637	23598	22	259	259	CD
18637	23598	23	Chin	Chin	NNP
18637	23598	24	Tow	Tow	NNP
18637	23598	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23598	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23598	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23598	28	United	United	NNP
18637	23598	29	States	States	NNP
18637	23598	30	,	,	,
18637	23598	31	208	208	CD
18637	23598	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23598	33	8	8	CD
18637	23598	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23598	35	1908	1908	CD
18637	23598	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23598	37	,	,	,
18637	23598	38	852	852	CD
18637	23598	39	Chirac	Chirac	NNP
18637	23598	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23598	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23598	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23598	43	Chirac	Chirac	NNP
18637	23598	44	,	,	,
18637	23598	45	2	2	CD
18637	23598	46	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23598	47	.	.	.
18637	23599	1	259	259	CD
18637	23599	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23599	3	1817	1817	CD
18637	23599	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23599	5	,	,	,
18637	23599	6	258	258	CD
18637	23599	7	,	,	,
18637	23599	8	416	416	CD
18637	23599	9	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
18637	23599	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23599	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23599	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23599	13	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23599	14	,	,	,
18637	23599	15	2	2	CD
18637	23599	16	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	23599	17	.	.	.
18637	23600	1	419	419	CD
18637	23600	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23600	3	1793	1793	CD
18637	23600	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23600	5	,	,	,
18637	23600	6	60	60	CD
18637	23600	7	,	,	,
18637	23600	8	334	334	CD
18637	23600	9	,	,	,
18637	23600	10	512	512	CD
18637	23600	11	,	,	,
18637	23600	12	539	539	CD
18637	23600	13	,	,	,
18637	23600	14	585	585	CD
18637	23600	15	,	,	,
18637	23600	16	591	591	CD
18637	23600	17	,	,	,
18637	23600	18	596	596	CD
18637	23600	19	,	,	,
18637	23600	20	597	597	CD
18637	23600	21	,	,	,
18637	23600	22	611	611	CD
18637	23600	23	,	,	,
18637	23600	24	929	929	CD
18637	23600	25	,	,	,
18637	23600	26	930	930	CD
18637	23600	27	Choate	Choate	NNP
18637	23600	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23600	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23600	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23600	31	Trapp	Trapp	NNP
18637	23600	32	,	,	,
18637	23600	33	224	224	CD
18637	23600	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23600	35	665	665	CD
18637	23600	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23600	37	1912	1912	CD
18637	23600	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23600	39	,	,	,
18637	23600	40	433	433	CD
18637	23600	41	,	,	,
18637	23600	42	864	864	CD
18637	23600	43	Choctaw	Choctaw	NNP
18637	23600	44	O.	O.	NNP
18637	23601	1	&	&	CC
18637	23601	2	G.R.	G.R.	NNP
18637	23602	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23602	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23602	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23602	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23602	5	Harrison	Harrison	NNP
18637	23602	6	,	,	,
18637	23602	7	235	235	CD
18637	23602	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23602	9	292	292	CD
18637	23602	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23602	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	23602	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23602	13	,	,	,
18637	23602	14	735	735	CD
18637	23602	15	Christ	Christ	NNP
18637	23602	16	Church	Church	NNP
18637	23602	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23602	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23602	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23602	20	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	23602	21	County	County	NNP
18637	23602	22	,	,	,
18637	23602	23	24	24	CD
18637	23602	24	How	how	WRB
18637	23602	25	.	.	.
18637	23603	1	300	300	CD
18637	23603	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23603	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	23603	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23603	5	,	,	,
18637	23603	6	343	343	CD
18637	23603	7	Christian	Christian	NNP
18637	23603	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23603	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23603	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23603	11	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	23603	12	&	&	CC
18637	23603	13	N.C.R.	N.C.R.	NNP
18637	23604	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23604	2	,	,	,
18637	23604	3	133	133	CD
18637	23604	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23604	5	233	233	CD
18637	23604	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23604	7	1890	1890	CD
18637	23604	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23604	9	,	,	,
18637	23604	10	932	932	CD
18637	23604	11	Christmas	Christmas	NNP
18637	23604	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23604	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23604	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23604	15	Russell	Russell	NNP
18637	23604	16	,	,	,
18637	23604	17	5	5	CD
18637	23604	18	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23604	19	.	.	.
18637	23605	1	290	290	CD
18637	23605	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23605	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	23605	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23605	5	,	,	,
18637	23605	6	654	654	CD
18637	23605	7	,	,	,
18637	23605	8	674	674	CD
18637	23605	9	Christoffel	Christoffel	NNP
18637	23605	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23605	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23605	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23605	13	United	United	NNP
18637	23605	14	States	States	NNP
18637	23605	15	,	,	,
18637	23605	16	338	338	CD
18637	23605	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23605	18	84	84	CD
18637	23605	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23605	20	1949	1949	CD
18637	23605	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23605	22	,	,	,
18637	23605	23	86	86	CD
18637	23605	24	,	,	,
18637	23605	25	97	97	CD
18637	23605	26	,	,	,
18637	23605	27	98	98	CD
18637	23605	28	Church	Church	NNP
18637	23605	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23605	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	23605	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23605	32	Hubbart	Hubbart	NNP
18637	23605	33	,	,	,
18637	23605	34	2	2	CD
18637	23605	35	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23605	36	.	.	.
18637	23606	1	187	187	CD
18637	23606	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23606	3	1804	1804	CD
18637	23606	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23606	5	,	,	,
18637	23606	6	575	575	CD
18637	23606	7	Church	Church	NNP
18637	23606	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23606	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23606	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23606	11	Kelsey	Kelsey	NNP
18637	23606	12	,	,	,
18637	23606	13	121	121	CD
18637	23606	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23606	15	282	282	CD
18637	23606	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23606	17	1887	1887	CD
18637	23606	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23606	19	,	,	,
18637	23606	20	1096	1096	CD
18637	23606	21	Church	Church	NNP
18637	23606	22	of	of	IN
18637	23606	23	Jesus	Jesus	NNP
18637	23606	24	Christ	Christ	NNP
18637	23606	25	of	of	IN
18637	23606	26	L.D.S.	L.D.S.	NNP
18637	23607	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23607	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23607	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23607	4	United	United	NNP
18637	23607	5	States	States	NNP
18637	23607	6	,	,	,
18637	23607	7	136	136	CD
18637	23607	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23607	9	1	1	CD
18637	23607	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23607	11	1890	1890	CD
18637	23607	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23607	13	,	,	,
18637	23607	14	703	703	CD
18637	23607	15	Chy	Chy	NNP
18637	23607	16	Lung	Lung	NNP
18637	23607	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23607	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23607	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23607	20	Freeman	Freeman	NNP
18637	23607	21	,	,	,
18637	23607	22	92	92	CD
18637	23607	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23607	24	275	275	CD
18637	23607	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23607	26	1876	1876	CD
18637	23607	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23607	28	,	,	,
18637	23607	29	216	216	CD
18637	23607	30	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	23607	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23607	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	23607	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23607	34	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	23607	35	&	&	CC
18637	23607	36	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	23608	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23608	2	,	,	,
18637	23608	3	223	223	CD
18637	23608	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23608	5	390	390	CD
18637	23608	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23608	7	1912	1912	CD
18637	23608	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23608	9	,	,	,
18637	23608	10	699	699	CD
18637	23608	11	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	23608	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23608	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23608	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23608	15	Vester	Vester	NNP
18637	23608	16	,	,	,
18637	23608	17	281	281	CD
18637	23608	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23608	19	439	439	CD
18637	23608	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23608	21	1930	1930	CD
18637	23608	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23608	23	,	,	,
18637	23608	24	866	866	CD
18637	23608	25	,	,	,
18637	23608	26	1064	1064	CD
18637	23608	27	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	23608	28	,	,	,
18637	23608	29	N.O.	N.O.	NNP
18637	23609	1	&	&	CC
18637	23609	2	T.P.R.	T.P.R.	NNP
18637	23610	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23610	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23610	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23610	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23610	5	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23610	6	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	23610	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23610	8	,	,	,
18637	23610	9	162	162	CD
18637	23610	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23610	11	184	184	CD
18637	23610	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23610	13	1896	1896	CD
18637	23610	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23610	15	,	,	,
18637	23610	16	134	134	CD
18637	23610	17	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	23610	18	,	,	,
18637	23610	19	N.O.	N.O.	NNP
18637	23611	1	&	&	CC
18637	23611	2	T.P.R.	T.P.R.	NNP
18637	23612	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23612	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23612	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23612	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23612	5	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23612	6	,	,	,
18637	23612	7	115	115	CD
18637	23612	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23612	9	321	321	CD
18637	23612	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23612	11	1885	1885	CD
18637	23612	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23612	13	,	,	,
18637	23612	14	1060	1060	CD
18637	23612	15	,	,	,
18637	23612	16	1085	1085	CD
18637	23612	17	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	23612	18	,	,	,
18637	23612	19	P.B.S.	P.B.S.	NNP
18637	23613	1	&	&	CC
18637	23613	2	P.	P.	NNP
18637	23613	3	Packet	Packet	NNP
18637	23613	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23613	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23613	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	23613	7	_	_	NNP
18637	23613	8	Catlettsburg	Catlettsburg	NNP
18637	23613	9	,	,	,
18637	23613	10	105	105	CD
18637	23613	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23613	12	559	559	CD
18637	23613	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23613	14	1882	1882	CD
18637	23613	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23613	16	,	,	,
18637	23613	17	366	366	CD
18637	23613	18	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	23613	19	Soap	Soap	NNP
18637	23613	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23613	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23613	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	23613	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23613	24	United	United	NNP
18637	23613	25	States	States	NNP
18637	23613	26	,	,	,
18637	23613	27	301	301	CD
18637	23613	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23613	29	308	308	CD
18637	23613	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23613	31	1937	1937	CD
18637	23613	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23613	33	,	,	,
18637	23613	34	116	116	CD
18637	23613	35	,	,	,
18637	23613	36	117	117	CD
18637	23613	37	,	,	,
18637	23613	38	323	323	CD
18637	23613	39	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	23613	40	Street	Street	NNP
18637	23613	41	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23613	42	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23613	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23613	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	23613	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23613	46	Snell	Snell	NNP
18637	23613	47	,	,	,
18637	23613	48	193	193	CD
18637	23613	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23613	50	30	30	CD
18637	23613	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23613	52	1904	1904	CD
18637	23613	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23613	54	,	,	,
18637	23613	55	1089	1089	CD
18637	23613	56	Cities	Cities	NNP
18637	23613	57	Service	Service	NNP
18637	23613	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23613	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23613	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23613	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23613	62	Peerless	Peerless	NNP
18637	23613	63	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23613	64	,	,	,
18637	23613	65	340	340	CD
18637	23613	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23613	67	179	179	CD
18637	23613	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23613	69	1950	1950	CD
18637	23613	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23613	71	,	,	,
18637	23613	72	234	234	CD
18637	23613	73	,	,	,
18637	23613	74	1026	1026	CD
18637	23613	75	Cities	Cities	NNP
18637	23613	76	Service	Service	NNP
18637	23613	77	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23613	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23613	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	23613	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23613	81	McGrath	McGrath	NNP
18637	23613	82	,	,	,
18637	23613	83	342	342	CD
18637	23613	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23613	85	330	330	CD
18637	23613	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23613	87	1952	1952	CD
18637	23613	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23613	89	,	,	,
18637	23613	90	295	295	CD
18637	23613	91	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	23613	92	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23613	93	.	.	.
18637	23614	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23614	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23614	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23614	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23614	5	Durr	Durr	NNP
18637	23614	6	,	,	,
18637	23614	7	257	257	CD
18637	23614	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23614	9	99	99	CD
18637	23614	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23614	11	1921	1921	CD
18637	23614	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23614	13	,	,	,
18637	23614	14	1044	1044	CD
18637	23614	15	Citizens	Citizens	NNP
18637	23614	16	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	23614	17	&	&	CC
18637	23614	18	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	23614	19	Association	Association	NNP
18637	23614	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23614	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	23614	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23614	23	Topeka	Topeka	NNP
18637	23614	24	,	,	,
18637	23614	25	20	20	CD
18637	23614	26	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23614	27	.	.	.
18637	23615	1	655	655	CD
18637	23615	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23615	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	23615	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23615	5	,	,	,
18637	23615	6	751	751	CD
18637	23615	7	,	,	,
18637	23615	8	1037	1037	CD
18637	23615	9	City	City	NNP
18637	23615	10	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23615	11	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	23615	12	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23615	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23615	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23615	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23615	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23615	17	Schnader	Schnader	NNP
18637	23615	18	,	,	,
18637	23615	19	293	293	CD
18637	23615	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23615	21	112	112	CD
18637	23615	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23615	23	1934	1934	CD
18637	23615	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23615	25	,	,	,
18637	23615	26	1045	1045	CD
18637	23615	27	City	City	NNP
18637	23615	28	of	of	IN
18637	23615	29	Panama	Panama	NNP
18637	23615	30	,	,	,
18637	23615	31	The	the	DT
18637	23615	32	,	,	,
18637	23615	33	101	101	CD
18637	23615	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23615	35	453	453	CD
18637	23615	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23615	37	1880	1880	CD
18637	23615	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23615	39	,	,	,
18637	23615	40	575	575	CD
18637	23615	41	,	,	,
18637	23615	42	704	704	CD
18637	23615	43	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	23615	44	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	23615	45	Cases	case	NNS
18637	23615	46	,	,	,
18637	23615	47	109	109	CD
18637	23615	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23615	49	3	3	CD
18637	23615	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23615	51	1883	1883	CD
18637	23615	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23615	53	,	,	,
18637	23615	54	919	919	CD
18637	23615	55	,	,	,
18637	23615	56	952	952	CD
18637	23615	57	,	,	,
18637	23615	58	953	953	CD
18637	23615	59	,	,	,
18637	23615	60	1175	1175	CD
18637	23615	61	Claflin	Claflin	NNP
18637	23615	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23615	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	23615	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23615	65	Houseman	Houseman	NNP
18637	23615	66	,	,	,
18637	23615	67	93	93	CD
18637	23615	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23615	69	130	130	CD
18637	23615	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23615	71	1876	1876	CD
18637	23615	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23615	73	,	,	,
18637	23615	74	636	636	CD
18637	23615	75	,	,	,
18637	23615	76	637	637	CD
18637	23615	77	,	,	,
18637	23615	78	726	726	CD
18637	23615	79	,	,	,
18637	23615	80	739	739	CD
18637	23615	81	Clallam	Clallam	NNP
18637	23615	82	County	County	NNP
18637	23615	83	_	_	NNP
18637	23615	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	23615	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23615	86	United	United	NNP
18637	23615	87	States	States	NNP
18637	23615	88	,	,	,
18637	23615	89	263	263	CD
18637	23615	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23615	91	341	341	CD
18637	23615	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23615	93	1923	1923	CD
18637	23615	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23615	95	,	,	,
18637	23615	96	289	289	CD
18637	23615	97	,	,	,
18637	23615	98	310	310	CD
18637	23615	99	,	,	,
18637	23615	100	733	733	CD
18637	23615	101	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	23615	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23615	103	v.	v.	IN
18637	23615	104	_	_	NNP
18637	23615	105	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	23615	106	,	,	,
18637	23615	107	331	331	CD
18637	23615	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23615	109	503	503	CD
18637	23615	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23615	111	1947	1947	CD
18637	23615	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23615	113	,	,	,
18637	23615	114	417	417	CD
18637	23615	115	,	,	,
18637	23615	116	425	425	CD
18637	23615	117	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	23615	118	_	_	NNP
18637	23615	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	23615	120	_	_	NNP
18637	23615	121	Barnard	Barnard	NNP
18637	23615	122	,	,	,
18637	23615	123	108	108	CD
18637	23615	124	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23615	125	436	436	CD
18637	23615	126	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23615	127	1883	1883	CD
18637	23615	128	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23615	129	,	,	,
18637	23615	130	936	936	CD
18637	23615	131	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	23615	132	_	_	NNP
18637	23615	133	v.	v.	IN
18637	23615	134	_	_	NNP
18637	23615	135	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	23615	136	,	,	,
18637	23615	137	6	6	CD
18637	23615	138	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23615	139	.	.	.
18637	23616	1	577	577	CD
18637	23616	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23616	3	1821	1821	CD
18637	23616	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23616	5	,	,	,
18637	23616	6	651	651	CD
18637	23616	7	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	23616	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23616	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23616	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23616	11	Nash	Nash	NNP
18637	23616	12	,	,	,
18637	23616	13	198	198	CD
18637	23616	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23616	15	361	361	CD
18637	23616	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23616	17	1905	1905	CD
18637	23616	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23616	19	,	,	,
18637	23616	20	1063	1063	CD
18637	23616	21	,	,	,
18637	23616	22	1065	1065	CD
18637	23616	23	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	23616	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23616	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23616	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23616	27	Paul	Paul	NNP
18637	23616	28	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	23616	29	,	,	,
18637	23616	30	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	23616	31	,	,	,
18637	23616	32	306	306	CD
18637	23616	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23616	34	583	583	CD
18637	23616	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23616	36	1939	1939	CD
18637	23616	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23616	38	,	,	,
18637	23616	39	212	212	CD
18637	23616	40	,	,	,
18637	23616	41	1151	1151	CD
18637	23616	42	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	23616	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23616	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	23616	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23616	46	Poor	Poor	NNP
18637	23616	47	,	,	,
18637	23616	48	274	274	CD
18637	23616	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23616	50	554	554	CD
18637	23616	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23616	52	1927	1927	CD
18637	23616	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23616	54	,	,	,
18637	23616	55	212	212	CD
18637	23616	56	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	23616	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23616	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	23616	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23616	60	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	23616	61	,	,	,
18637	23616	62	13	13	CD
18637	23616	63	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23616	64	.	.	.
18637	23617	1	195	195	CD
18637	23617	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23617	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	23617	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23617	5	,	,	,
18637	23617	6	895	895	CD
18637	23617	7	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	23617	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23617	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23617	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23617	11	Willard	Willard	NNP
18637	23617	12	,	,	,
18637	23617	13	292	292	CD
18637	23617	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23617	15	112	112	CD
18637	23617	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23617	17	1934	1934	CD
18637	23617	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23617	19	,	,	,
18637	23617	20	681	681	CD
18637	23617	21	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	23617	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23617	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23617	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23617	25	Wooster	Wooster	NNP
18637	23617	26	,	,	,
18637	23617	27	119	119	CD
18637	23617	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23617	29	322	322	CD
18637	23617	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23617	31	1886	1886	CD
18637	23617	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23617	33	,	,	,
18637	23617	34	893	893	CD
18637	23617	35	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	23617	36	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	23617	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23617	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23617	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23617	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23617	41	Western	Western	NNP
18637	23617	42	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	23617	43	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23617	44	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23617	45	,	,	,
18637	23617	46	242	242	CD
18637	23617	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23617	48	311	311	CD
18637	23617	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23617	50	1917	1917	CD
18637	23617	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23617	52	,	,	,
18637	23617	53	176	176	CD
18637	23617	54	,	,	,
18637	23617	55	219	219	CD
18637	23617	56	,	,	,
18637	23617	57	239	239	CD
18637	23617	58	,	,	,
18637	23617	59	1032	1032	CD
18637	23617	60	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	23617	61	Thread	Thread	NNP
18637	23617	62	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23617	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23617	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	23617	65	_	_	NNP
18637	23617	66	Willimantic	Willimantic	NNP
18637	23617	67	Linen	Linen	NNP
18637	23617	68	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23617	69	,	,	,
18637	23617	70	140	140	CD
18637	23617	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23617	72	481	481	CD
18637	23617	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23617	74	1891	1891	CD
18637	23617	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23617	76	,	,	,
18637	23617	77	272	272	CD
18637	23617	78	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	23617	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23617	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	23617	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23617	82	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	23617	83	,	,	,
18637	23617	84	178	178	CD
18637	23617	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23617	86	186	186	CD
18637	23617	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23617	88	1900	1900	CD
18637	23617	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23617	90	,	,	,
18637	23617	91	673	673	CD
18637	23617	92	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	23617	93	,	,	,
18637	23617	94	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23617	95	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23617	96	,	,	,
18637	23617	97	100	100	CD
18637	23617	98	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23617	99	399	399	CD
18637	23617	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23617	101	1880	1880	CD
18637	23617	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23617	103	,	,	,
18637	23617	104	93	93	CD
18637	23617	105	,	,	,
18637	23617	106	94	94	CD
18637	23617	107	Clason	Clason	NNP
18637	23617	108	_	_	NNP
18637	23617	109	v.	v.	IN
18637	23617	110	_	_	NNP
18637	23617	111	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	23617	112	,	,	,
18637	23617	113	306	306	CD
18637	23617	114	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23617	115	439	439	CD
18637	23617	116	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23617	117	1939	1939	CD
18637	23617	118	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23617	119	,	,	,
18637	23617	120	237	237	CD
18637	23617	121	Clement	Clement	NNP
18637	23617	122	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23617	123	.	.	.
18637	23618	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23618	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23618	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23618	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23618	5	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	23618	6	,	,	,
18637	23618	7	231	231	CD
18637	23618	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23618	9	120	120	CD
18637	23618	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23618	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	23618	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23618	13	,	,	,
18637	23618	14	1058	1058	CD
18637	23618	15	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
18637	23618	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23618	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23618	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23618	19	United	United	NNP
18637	23618	20	States	States	NNP
18637	23618	21	,	,	,
18637	23618	22	323	323	CD
18637	23618	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23618	24	329	329	CD
18637	23618	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23618	26	1945	1945	CD
18637	23618	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23618	28	,	,	,
18637	23618	29	115	115	CD
18637	23618	30	,	,	,
18637	23618	31	733	733	CD
18637	23618	32	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
18637	23618	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23618	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	23618	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23618	36	United	United	NNP
18637	23618	37	States	States	NNP
18637	23618	38	,	,	,
18637	23618	39	329	329	CD
18637	23618	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23618	41	14	14	CD
18637	23618	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23618	43	1946	1946	CD
18637	23618	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23618	45	,	,	,
18637	23618	46	170	170	CD
18637	23618	47	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
18637	23618	48	,	,	,
18637	23618	49	C.C.	C.C.	NNP
18637	23619	1	&	&	CC
18637	23619	2	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23619	3	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	23620	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23620	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23620	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23620	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23620	5	Backus	Backus	NNP
18637	23620	6	,	,	,
18637	23620	7	154	154	CD
18637	23620	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23620	9	439	439	CD
18637	23620	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23620	11	1894	1894	CD
18637	23620	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23620	13	,	,	,
18637	23620	14	201	201	CD
18637	23620	15	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
18637	23620	16	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	23620	17	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	23620	18	.	.	.
18637	23621	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23621	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23621	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23621	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23621	5	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
18637	23621	6	,	,	,
18637	23621	7	204	204	CD
18637	23621	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23621	9	116	116	CD
18637	23621	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23621	11	1907	1907	CD
18637	23621	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23621	13	,	,	,
18637	23621	14	1009	1009	CD
18637	23621	15	Cline	Cline	NNP
18637	23621	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23621	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23621	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23621	19	Frink	Frink	NNP
18637	23621	20	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
18637	23621	21	,	,	,
18637	23621	22	274	274	CD
18637	23621	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23621	24	445	445	CD
18637	23621	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23621	26	1927	1927	CD
18637	23621	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23621	28	,	,	,
18637	23621	29	1097	1097	CD
18637	23621	30	Clinton	Clinton	NNP
18637	23621	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23621	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	23621	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23621	34	Englebrecht	Englebrecht	NNP
18637	23621	35	,	,	,
18637	23621	36	13	13	CD
18637	23621	37	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23621	38	.	.	.
18637	23622	1	434	434	CD
18637	23622	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23622	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	23622	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23622	5	,	,	,
18637	23622	6	704	704	CD
18637	23622	7	Cloverleaf	Cloverleaf	NNP
18637	23622	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23622	9	_	_	NNP
18637	23622	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	23622	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23622	12	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	23622	13	,	,	,
18637	23622	14	315	315	CD
18637	23622	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23622	16	148	148	CD
18637	23622	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23622	18	1942	1942	CD
18637	23622	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23622	20	,	,	,
18637	23622	21	250	250	CD
18637	23622	22	Cluett	Cluett	NNP
18637	23622	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23622	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23622	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23622	26	Claflin	Claflin	NNP
18637	23622	27	,	,	,
18637	23622	28	140	140	CD
18637	23622	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23622	30	180	180	CD
18637	23622	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23622	32	1891	1891	CD
18637	23622	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23622	34	,	,	,
18637	23622	35	273	273	CD
18637	23622	36	Clyatt	Clyatt	NNPS
18637	23622	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23622	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	23622	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23622	40	United	United	NNP
18637	23622	41	States	States	NNP
18637	23622	42	,	,	,
18637	23622	43	197	197	CD
18637	23622	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23622	45	207	207	CD
18637	23622	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23622	47	1905	1905	CD
18637	23622	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23622	49	,	,	,
18637	23622	50	951	951	CD
18637	23622	51	,	,	,
18637	23622	52	953	953	CD
18637	23622	53	Clyde	Clyde	NNP
18637	23622	54	Mallory	Mallory	NNP
18637	23622	55	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	23622	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23622	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	23622	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23622	59	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	23622	60	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23622	61	rel	rel	NN
18637	23622	62	.	.	.
18637	23623	1	State	State	NNP
18637	23623	2	Docks	Docks	NNPS
18637	23623	3	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23623	4	,	,	,
18637	23623	5	296	296	CD
18637	23623	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23623	7	261	261	CD
18637	23623	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23623	9	1935	1935	CD
18637	23623	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23623	11	,	,	,
18637	23623	12	366	366	CD
18637	23623	13	Cochran	Cochran	NNP
18637	23623	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23623	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23623	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23623	17	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23623	18	,	,	,
18637	23623	19	316	316	CD
18637	23623	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23623	21	255	255	CD
18637	23623	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23623	23	1942	1942	CD
18637	23623	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23623	25	,	,	,
18637	23623	26	1166	1166	CD
18637	23623	27	Cochran	Cochran	NNP
18637	23623	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23623	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23623	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23623	31	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	23623	32	State	State	NNP
18637	23623	33	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	23623	34	.	.	.
18637	23624	1	of	of	IN
18637	23624	2	Ed	Ed	NNP
18637	23624	3	.	.	NNP
18637	23624	4	,	,	,
18637	23624	5	281	281	CD
18637	23624	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23624	7	370	370	CD
18637	23624	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23624	9	1930	1930	CD
18637	23624	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23624	11	,	,	,
18637	23624	12	764	764	CD
18637	23624	13	,	,	,
18637	23624	14	1037	1037	CD
18637	23624	15	Cockrill	Cockrill	NNP
18637	23624	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23624	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23624	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23624	19	California	California	NNP
18637	23624	20	,	,	,
18637	23624	21	268	268	CD
18637	23624	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23624	23	258	258	CD
18637	23624	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23624	25	1925	1925	CD
18637	23624	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23624	27	,	,	,
18637	23624	28	1096	1096	CD
18637	23624	29	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	23624	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23624	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23624	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23624	33	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	23624	34	Fertilizer	Fertilizer	NNP
18637	23624	35	Works	Works	NNP
18637	23624	36	,	,	,
18637	23624	37	237	237	CD
18637	23624	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23624	39	413	413	CD
18637	23624	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23624	41	1915	1915	CD
18637	23624	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23624	43	,	,	,
18637	23624	44	1074	1074	CD
18637	23624	45	,	,	,
18637	23624	46	1085	1085	CD
18637	23624	47	,	,	,
18637	23624	48	1088	1088	CD
18637	23624	49	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	23624	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23624	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	23624	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23624	53	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	23624	54	,	,	,
18637	23624	55	334	334	CD
18637	23624	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23624	57	378	378	CD
18637	23624	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23624	59	1948	1948	CD
18637	23624	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23624	61	,	,	,
18637	23624	62	668	668	CD
18637	23624	63	,	,	,
18637	23624	64	669	669	CD
18637	23624	65	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	23624	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23624	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23624	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23624	69	Errol	Errol	NNP
18637	23624	70	,	,	,
18637	23624	71	116	116	CD
18637	23624	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23624	73	517	517	CD
18637	23624	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23624	75	1886	1886	CD
18637	23624	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23624	77	,	,	,
18637	23624	78	171	171	CD
18637	23624	79	,	,	,
18637	23624	80	180	180	CD
18637	23624	81	,	,	,
18637	23624	82	185	185	CD
18637	23624	83	Coffey	Coffey	NNP
18637	23624	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23624	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	23624	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23624	87	Harlan	Harlan	NNP
18637	23624	88	County	County	NNP
18637	23624	89	,	,	,
18637	23624	90	204	204	CD
18637	23624	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23624	92	659	659	CD
18637	23624	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23624	94	1907	1907	CD
18637	23624	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23624	96	,	,	,
18637	23624	97	1092	1092	CD
18637	23624	98	Coffey	Coffey	NNP
18637	23624	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23624	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	23624	101	_	_	NNP
18637	23624	102	United	United	NNP
18637	23624	103	States	States	NNP
18637	23624	104	,	,	,
18637	23624	105	116	116	CD
18637	23624	106	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23624	107	436	436	CD
18637	23624	108	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23624	109	1886	1886	CD
18637	23624	110	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23624	111	,	,	,
18637	23624	112	840	840	CD
18637	23624	113	Coffin	Coffin	NNP
18637	23624	114	_	_	NNP
18637	23624	115	v.	v.	IN
18637	23624	116	_	_	NNP
18637	23624	117	Coffin	Coffin	NNP
18637	23624	118	,	,	,
18637	23624	119	4	4	CD
18637	23624	120	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	23625	1	1	1	CD
18637	23625	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23625	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	23625	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23625	5	,	,	,
18637	23625	6	99	99	CD
18637	23625	7	,	,	,
18637	23625	8	100	100	CD
18637	23625	9	Coffin	Coffin	NNP
18637	23625	10	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	23625	11	&	&	CC
18637	23625	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23625	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	23625	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	16	Bennett	Bennett	NNP
18637	23625	17	,	,	,
18637	23625	18	277	277	CD
18637	23625	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23625	20	29	29	CD
18637	23625	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23625	22	1928	1928	CD
18637	23625	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23625	24	,	,	,
18637	23625	25	1087	1087	CD
18637	23625	26	Coffman	Coffman	NNP
18637	23625	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	23625	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	30	Breeze	Breeze	NNP
18637	23625	31	Corporations	Corporations	NNP
18637	23625	32	,	,	,
18637	23625	33	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	23625	34	,	,	,
18637	23625	35	323	323	CD
18637	23625	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23625	37	316	316	CD
18637	23625	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23625	39	1945	1945	CD
18637	23625	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23625	41	,	,	,
18637	23625	42	540	540	CD
18637	23625	43	,	,	,
18637	23625	44	550	550	CD
18637	23625	45	,	,	,
18637	23625	46	553	553	CD
18637	23625	47	,	,	,
18637	23625	48	562	562	CD
18637	23625	49	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
18637	23625	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	23625	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	53	Beneficial	Beneficial	NNP
18637	23625	54	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	23625	55	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	23625	56	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23625	57	,	,	,
18637	23625	58	337	337	CD
18637	23625	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23625	60	541	541	CD
18637	23625	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23625	62	1949	1949	CD
18637	23625	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23625	64	,	,	,
18637	23625	65	564	564	CD
18637	23625	66	,	,	,
18637	23625	67	608	608	CD
18637	23625	68	,	,	,
18637	23625	69	1090	1090	CD
18637	23625	70	,	,	,
18637	23625	71	1166	1166	CD
18637	23625	72	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
18637	23625	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	23625	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	76	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	23625	77	,	,	,
18637	23625	78	6	6	CD
18637	23625	79	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23625	80	264	264	CD
18637	23625	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23625	82	1821	1821	CD
18637	23625	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23625	84	,	,	,
18637	23625	85	121	121	CD
18637	23625	86	,	,	,
18637	23625	87	303	303	CD
18637	23625	88	,	,	,
18637	23625	89	538	538	CD
18637	23625	90	,	,	,
18637	23625	91	554	554	CD
18637	23625	92	,	,	,
18637	23625	93	560	560	CD
18637	23625	94	,	,	,
18637	23625	95	569	569	CD
18637	23625	96	,	,	,
18637	23625	97	585	585	CD
18637	23625	98	,	,	,
18637	23625	99	593	593	CD
18637	23625	100	,	,	,
18637	23625	101	597	597	CD
18637	23625	102	,	,	,
18637	23625	103	612	612	CD
18637	23625	104	,	,	,
18637	23625	105	613	613	CD
18637	23625	106	,	,	,
18637	23625	107	625	625	CD
18637	23625	108	,	,	,
18637	23625	109	929	929	CD
18637	23625	110	Cole	Cole	NNP
18637	23625	111	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	112	v.	v.	IN
18637	23625	113	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	114	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	23625	115	,	,	,
18637	23625	116	333	333	CD
18637	23625	117	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23625	118	196	196	CD
18637	23625	119	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23625	120	1948	1948	CD
18637	23625	121	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23625	122	,	,	,
18637	23625	123	1133	1133	CD
18637	23625	124	Cole	Cole	NNP
18637	23625	125	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	126	v.	v.	IN
18637	23625	127	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	128	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	23625	129	,	,	,
18637	23625	130	338	338	CD
18637	23625	131	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23625	132	345	345	CD
18637	23625	133	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23625	134	1949	1949	CD
18637	23625	135	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23625	136	,	,	,
18637	23625	137	1097	1097	CD
18637	23625	138	Cole	Cole	NNP
18637	23625	139	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	140	v.	v.	IN
18637	23625	141	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	142	Cunningham	Cunningham	NNP
18637	23625	143	,	,	,
18637	23625	144	133	133	CD
18637	23625	145	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23625	146	107	107	CD
18637	23625	147	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23625	148	1890	1890	CD
18637	23625	149	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23625	150	,	,	,
18637	23625	151	654	654	CD
18637	23625	152	,	,	,
18637	23625	153	674	674	CD
18637	23625	154	,	,	,
18637	23625	155	687	687	CD
18637	23625	156	Colegrove	Colegrove	NNP
18637	23625	157	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	158	v.	v.	IN
18637	23625	159	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	160	Green	Green	NNP
18637	23625	161	,	,	,
18637	23625	162	328	328	CD
18637	23625	163	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23625	164	549	549	CD
18637	23625	165	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23625	166	1946	1946	CD
18637	23625	167	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23625	168	,	,	,
18637	23625	169	93	93	CD
18637	23625	170	,	,	,
18637	23625	171	94	94	CD
18637	23625	172	,	,	,
18637	23625	173	548	548	CD
18637	23625	174	,	,	,
18637	23625	175	1165	1165	CD
18637	23625	176	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	23625	177	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	178	v.	v.	IN
18637	23625	179	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	180	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	23625	181	,	,	,
18637	23625	182	307	307	CD
18637	23625	183	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23625	184	433	433	CD
18637	23625	185	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23625	186	1939	1939	CD
18637	23625	187	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23625	188	,	,	,
18637	23625	189	98	98	CD
18637	23625	190	,	,	,
18637	23625	191	547	547	CD
18637	23625	192	,	,	,
18637	23625	193	548	548	CD
18637	23625	194	,	,	,
18637	23625	195	712	712	CD
18637	23625	196	,	,	,
18637	23625	197	714	714	CD
18637	23625	198	,	,	,
18637	23625	199	982	982	CD
18637	23625	200	Colgate	Colgate	NNP
18637	23625	201	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	202	v.	v.	IN
18637	23625	203	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	204	Harvey	Harvey	NNP
18637	23625	205	,	,	,
18637	23625	206	296	296	CD
18637	23625	207	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23625	208	404	404	CD
18637	23625	209	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23625	210	1935	1935	CD
18637	23625	211	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23625	212	,	,	,
18637	23625	213	693	693	CD
18637	23625	214	,	,	,
18637	23625	215	968	968	CD
18637	23625	216	,	,	,
18637	23625	217	971	971	CD
18637	23625	218	,	,	,
18637	23625	219	1149	1149	CD
18637	23625	220	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	23625	221	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	222	v.	v.	IN
18637	23625	223	_	_	NNP
18637	23625	224	Day	Day	NNP
18637	23625	225	,	,	,
18637	23625	226	11	11	CD
18637	23625	227	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23625	228	.	.	.
18637	23626	1	113	113	CD
18637	23626	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23626	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	23626	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23626	5	,	,	,
18637	23626	6	106	106	CD
18637	23626	7	,	,	,
18637	23626	8	916	916	CD
18637	23626	9	,	,	,
18637	23626	10	917	917	CD
18637	23626	11	Collins	collin	NNS
18637	23626	12	,	,	,
18637	23626	13	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23626	14	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23626	15	,	,	,
18637	23626	16	277	277	CD
18637	23626	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23626	18	565	565	CD
18637	23626	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23626	20	1938	1938	CD
18637	23626	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23626	22	,	,	,
18637	23626	23	631	631	CD
18637	23626	24	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	23626	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23626	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23626	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23626	28	Hardyman	Hardyman	NNP
18637	23626	29	,	,	,
18637	23626	30	341	341	CD
18637	23626	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23626	32	651	651	CD
18637	23626	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23626	34	1951	1951	CD
18637	23626	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23626	36	,	,	,
18637	23626	37	810	810	CD
18637	23626	38	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	23626	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23626	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23626	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23626	42	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	23626	43	,	,	,
18637	23626	44	237	237	CD
18637	23626	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23626	46	502	502	CD
18637	23626	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23626	48	1915	1915	CD
18637	23626	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23626	50	,	,	,
18637	23626	51	1133	1133	CD
18637	23626	52	,	,	,
18637	23626	53	1161	1161	CD
18637	23626	54	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	23626	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23626	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	23626	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23626	58	Loisel	Loisel	NNP
18637	23626	59	,	,	,
18637	23626	60	262	262	CD
18637	23626	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23626	62	426	426	CD
18637	23626	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23626	64	1923	1923	CD
18637	23626	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23626	66	,	,	,
18637	23626	67	839	839	CD
18637	23626	68	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	23626	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23626	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	23626	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23626	72	New	New	NNP
18637	23626	73	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	23626	74	,	,	,
18637	23626	75	171	171	CD
18637	23626	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23626	77	30	30	CD
18637	23626	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23626	79	1898	1898	CD
18637	23626	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23626	81	,	,	,
18637	23626	82	240	240	CD
18637	23626	83	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	23626	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23626	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	23626	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23626	87	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23626	88	,	,	,
18637	23626	89	223	223	CD
18637	23626	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23626	91	288	288	CD
18637	23626	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23626	93	1912	1912	CD
18637	23626	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23626	95	,	,	,
18637	23626	96	1024	1024	CD
18637	23626	97	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	23626	98	_	_	NNP
18637	23626	99	v.	v.	IN
18637	23626	100	_	_	NNP
18637	23626	101	Yosemite	Yosemite	NNP
18637	23626	102	Park	Park	NNP
18637	23626	103	&	&	CC
18637	23626	104	Curry	Curry	NNP
18637	23626	105	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23626	106	,	,	,
18637	23626	107	304	304	CD
18637	23626	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23626	109	518	518	CD
18637	23626	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23626	111	1938	1938	CD
18637	23626	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23626	113	,	,	,
18637	23626	114	305	305	CD
18637	23626	115	,	,	,
18637	23626	116	731	731	CD
18637	23626	117	,	,	,
18637	23626	118	1233	1233	CD
18637	23626	119	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	23626	120	_	_	NNP
18637	23626	121	v.	v.	IN
18637	23626	122	_	_	NNP
18637	23626	123	United	United	NNP
18637	23626	124	States	States	NNP
18637	23626	125	,	,	,
18637	23626	126	271	271	CD
18637	23626	127	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23626	128	153	153	CD
18637	23626	129	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23626	130	1926	1926	CD
18637	23626	131	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23626	132	,	,	,
18637	23626	133	137	137	CD
18637	23626	134	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	23626	135	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23626	136	Consol	Consol	NNP
18637	23626	137	.	.	.
18637	23627	1	Min	Min	NNP
18637	23627	2	.	.	.
18637	23628	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23628	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23628	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23628	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23628	5	Turck	Turck	NNP
18637	23628	6	,	,	,
18637	23628	7	150	150	CD
18637	23628	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23628	9	138	138	CD
18637	23628	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23628	11	1893	1893	CD
18637	23628	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23628	13	,	,	,
18637	23628	14	616	616	CD
18637	23628	15	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	23628	16	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23628	17	.	.	.
18637	23629	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23629	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23629	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23629	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23629	5	Bedford	Bedford	NNP
18637	23629	6	,	,	,
18637	23629	7	310	310	CD
18637	23629	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23629	9	41	41	CD
18637	23629	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23629	11	1940	1940	CD
18637	23629	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23629	13	,	,	,
18637	23629	14	734	734	CD
18637	23629	15	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	23629	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	23629	17	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	23629	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23629	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23629	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	23629	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23629	22	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	23629	23	.	.	NNP
18637	23629	24	,	,	,
18637	23629	25	324	324	CD
18637	23629	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23629	27	626	626	CD
18637	23629	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23629	29	1945	1945	CD
18637	23629	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23629	31	,	,	,
18637	23629	32	138	138	CD
18637	23629	33	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23629	34	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23629	35	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23629	36	&	&	CC
18637	23629	37	E.	E.	NNP
18637	23629	38	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23629	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23629	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23629	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23629	42	South	South	NNP
18637	23629	43	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	23629	44	,	,	,
18637	23629	45	261	261	CD
18637	23629	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23629	47	236	236	CD
18637	23629	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23629	49	1923	1923	CD
18637	23629	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23629	51	,	,	,
18637	23629	52	329	329	CD
18637	23629	53	Columbus	Columbus	NNP
18637	23629	54	&	&	CC
18637	23629	55	G.R.	G.R.	NNP
18637	23630	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23630	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23630	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23630	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23630	5	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	23630	6	,	,	,
18637	23630	7	283	283	CD
18637	23630	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23630	9	96	96	CD
18637	23630	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23630	11	1931	1931	CD
18637	23630	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23630	13	,	,	,
18637	23630	14	982	982	CD
18637	23630	15	,	,	,
18637	23630	16	1153	1153	CD
18637	23630	17	Commercial	Commercial	NNP
18637	23630	18	&	&	CC
18637	23630	19	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	23630	20	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23630	21	of	of	IN
18637	23630	22	Vicksburg	Vicksburg	NNP
18637	23630	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23630	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23630	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23630	26	Slocomb	Slocomb	NNP
18637	23630	27	,	,	,
18637	23630	28	14	14	CD
18637	23630	29	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23630	30	.	.	.
18637	23631	1	60	60	CD
18637	23631	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23631	3	1840	1840	CD
18637	23631	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23631	5	,	,	,
18637	23631	6	601	601	CD
18637	23631	7	Commercial	Commercial	NNP
18637	23631	8	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	23631	9	.	.	.
18637	23632	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23632	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23632	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23632	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23632	5	Beckwith	Beckwith	NNP
18637	23632	6	,	,	,
18637	23632	7	188	188	CD
18637	23632	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23632	9	567	567	CD
18637	23632	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23632	11	1903	1903	CD
18637	23632	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23632	13	,	,	,
18637	23632	14	656	656	CD
18637	23632	15	Commercial	Commercial	NNP
18637	23632	16	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23632	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23632	18	of	of	IN
18637	23632	19	New	New	NNP
18637	23632	20	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	23632	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23632	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	23632	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23632	24	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	23632	25	,	,	,
18637	23632	26	262	262	CD
18637	23632	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23632	28	51	51	CD
18637	23632	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23632	30	1923	1923	CD
18637	23632	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23632	32	,	,	,
18637	23632	33	547	547	CD
18637	23632	34	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	23632	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23632	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	23632	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23632	38	Wilcox	Wilcox	NNP
18637	23632	39	,	,	,
18637	23632	40	327	327	CD
18637	23632	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23632	42	404	404	CD
18637	23632	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23632	44	1946	1946	CD
18637	23632	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23632	46	,	,	,
18637	23632	47	1201	1201	CD
18637	23632	48	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
18637	23632	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23632	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	23632	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23632	52	Blanding	Blanding	NNP
18637	23632	53	,	,	,
18637	23632	54	3	3	CD
18637	23632	55	Pick	Pick	NNP
18637	23632	56	.	.	.
18637	23633	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23633	2	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	23633	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23634	1	304	304	CD
18637	23634	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23634	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	23634	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23634	5	,	,	,
18637	23634	6	771	771	CD
18637	23634	7	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
18637	23634	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23634	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23634	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23634	11	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	23634	12	,	,	,
18637	23634	13	66	66	CD
18637	23634	14	D	D	NNP
18637	23634	15	&	&	CC
18637	23634	16	C	C	NNP
18637	23634	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23634	18	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	23634	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23634	20	101	101	CD
18637	23634	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23634	22	1949	1949	CD
18637	23634	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23634	24	,	,	,
18637	23634	25	781	781	CD
18637	23634	26	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
18637	23634	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23634	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	23634	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23634	30	Pouliot	Pouliot	NNP
18637	23634	31	,	,	,
18637	23634	32	292	292	CD
18637	23634	33	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	23635	1	229	229	CD
18637	23635	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23635	3	1935	1935	CD
18637	23635	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23635	5	,	,	,
18637	23635	6	952	952	CD
18637	23635	7	Communications	Communications	NNPS
18637	23635	8	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
18637	23635	9	.	.	.
18637	23636	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23636	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23636	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23636	4	N.B.C	N.B.C	NNP
18637	23636	5	,	,	,
18637	23636	6	319	319	CD
18637	23636	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23636	8	239	239	CD
18637	23636	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23636	10	1943	1943	CD
18637	23636	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23636	12	,	,	,
18637	23636	13	788	788	CD
18637	23636	14	Compania	Compania	NNP
18637	23636	15	Espanola	Espanola	NNP
18637	23636	16	de	de	NNP
18637	23636	17	Navegacion	Navegacion	NNP
18637	23636	18	Maritima	Maritima	NNP
18637	23636	19	,	,	,
18637	23636	20	S.A.	S.A.	NNP
18637	23636	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23636	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	23636	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23636	24	The	the	DT
18637	23636	25	Navemar	Navemar	NNP
18637	23636	26	,	,	,
18637	23636	27	303	303	CD
18637	23636	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23636	29	68	68	CD
18637	23636	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23636	31	1938	1938	CD
18637	23636	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23636	33	,	,	,
18637	23636	34	474	474	CD
18637	23636	35	,	,	,
18637	23636	36	609	609	CD
18637	23636	37	Compagnie	Compagnie	NNP
18637	23636	38	Francaise	Francaise	NNP
18637	23636	39	de	de	NNP
18637	23636	40	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	23636	41	Ã	Ã	NNP
18637	23636	42	  	  	_SP
18637	23636	43	Vapeur	Vapeur	NNP
18637	23636	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23636	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	23636	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23636	47	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	23636	48	State	State	NNP
18637	23636	49	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23636	50	of	of	IN
18637	23636	51	Health	Health	NNP
18637	23636	52	,	,	,
18637	23636	53	186	186	CD
18637	23636	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23636	55	380	380	CD
18637	23636	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23636	57	1902	1902	CD
18637	23636	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23636	59	,	,	,
18637	23636	60	217	217	CD
18637	23636	61	,	,	,
18637	23636	62	1029	1029	CD
18637	23636	63	Concordia	Concordia	NNP
18637	23636	64	P.	P.	NNP
18637	23636	65	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23636	66	.	.	.
18637	23637	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23637	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23637	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23637	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23637	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23637	6	,	,	,
18637	23637	7	292	292	CD
18637	23637	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23637	9	535	535	CD
18637	23637	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23637	11	1934	1934	CD
18637	23637	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23637	13	,	,	,
18637	23637	14	1150	1150	CD
18637	23637	15	Concrete	Concrete	NNP
18637	23637	16	Appliances	Appliances	NNPS
18637	23637	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23637	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23637	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23637	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23637	21	Gomery	Gomery	NNP
18637	23637	22	,	,	,
18637	23637	23	269	269	CD
18637	23637	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23637	25	177	177	CD
18637	23637	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23637	27	1925	1925	CD
18637	23637	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23637	29	,	,	,
18637	23637	30	273	273	CD
18637	23637	31	Confiscation	Confiscation	NNP
18637	23637	32	Cases	case	NNS
18637	23637	33	,	,	,
18637	23637	34	The	the	DT
18637	23637	35	.	.	.
18637	23638	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23638	2	See	See	NNP
18637	23638	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23638	4	United	United	NNP
18637	23638	5	States	States	NNP
18637	23638	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23638	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	23638	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23638	9	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	23638	10	.	.	.
18637	23639	1	Conley	Conley	NNP
18637	23639	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23639	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23639	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23639	5	Mathieson	Mathieson	NNP
18637	23639	6	Alkali	Alkali	NNP
18637	23639	7	Works	Works	NNP
18637	23639	8	,	,	,
18637	23639	9	190	190	CD
18637	23639	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23639	11	406	406	CD
18637	23639	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23639	13	1903	1903	CD
18637	23639	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23639	15	,	,	,
18637	23639	16	1077	1077	CD
18637	23639	17	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	23639	18	General	General	NNP
18637	23639	19	Life	Life	NNP
18637	23639	20	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	23639	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23639	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23639	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23639	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23639	25	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23639	26	,	,	,
18637	23639	27	303	303	CD
18637	23639	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23639	29	77	77	CD
18637	23639	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23639	31	1938	1938	CD
18637	23639	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23639	33	,	,	,
18637	23639	34	1056	1056	CD
18637	23639	35	,	,	,
18637	23639	36	1143	1143	CD
18637	23639	37	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	23639	38	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23639	39	.	.	.
18637	23640	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23640	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23640	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23640	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23640	5	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	23640	6	,	,	,
18637	23640	7	333	333	CD
18637	23640	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23640	9	541	541	CD
18637	23640	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23640	11	1948	1948	CD
18637	23640	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23640	13	,	,	,
18637	23640	14	362	362	CD
18637	23640	15	,	,	,
18637	23640	16	1034	1034	CD
18637	23640	17	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	23640	18	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	23640	19	.	.	.
18637	23641	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23641	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23641	3	.	.	.
18637	23642	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23642	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23642	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23642	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23642	5	Cushman	Cushman	NNP
18637	23642	6	,	,	,
18637	23642	7	108	108	CD
18637	23642	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23642	9	51	51	CD
18637	23642	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23642	11	1883	1883	CD
18637	23642	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23642	13	,	,	,
18637	23642	14	355	355	CD
18637	23642	15	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	23642	16	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	23642	17	.	.	.
18637	23643	1	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23643	2	.	.	.
18637	23644	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23644	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23644	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23644	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23644	5	Spratley	Spratley	NNP
18637	23644	6	,	,	,
18637	23644	7	172	172	CD
18637	23644	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23644	9	602	602	CD
18637	23644	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23644	11	1899	1899	CD
18637	23644	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23644	13	,	,	,
18637	23644	14	660	660	CD
18637	23644	15	Conner	Conner	NNP
18637	23644	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23644	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23644	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23644	19	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	23644	20	,	,	,
18637	23644	21	18	18	CD
18637	23644	22	How	how	WRB
18637	23644	23	.	.	.
18637	23645	1	591	591	CD
18637	23645	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23645	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	23645	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23645	5	,	,	,
18637	23645	6	691	691	CD
18637	23645	7	Connolly	Connolly	NNP
18637	23645	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23645	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	11	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23645	12	Sewer	Sewer	NNP
18637	23645	13	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	23645	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23645	15	,	,	,
18637	23645	16	184	184	CD
18637	23645	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23645	18	540	540	CD
18637	23645	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23645	20	1902	1902	CD
18637	23645	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23645	22	,	,	,
18637	23645	23	1160	1160	CD
18637	23645	24	Conrad	Conrad	NNP
18637	23645	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23645	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	28	Waples	Waples	NNP
18637	23645	29	,	,	,
18637	23645	30	96	96	CD
18637	23645	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23645	32	279	279	CD
18637	23645	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23645	34	1878	1878	CD
18637	23645	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23645	36	,	,	,
18637	23645	37	295	295	CD
18637	23645	38	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	23645	39	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	23645	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23645	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	23645	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	44	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23645	45	,	,	,
18637	23645	46	185	185	CD
18637	23645	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23645	48	203	203	CD
18637	23645	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23645	50	1902	1902	CD
18637	23645	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23645	52	,	,	,
18637	23645	53	987	987	CD
18637	23645	54	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	23645	55	Edison	Edison	NNP
18637	23645	56	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23645	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	23645	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	60	National	National	NNP
18637	23645	61	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	23645	62	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	23645	63	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23645	64	,	,	,
18637	23645	65	305	305	CD
18637	23645	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23645	67	197	197	CD
18637	23645	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23645	69	1938	1938	CD
18637	23645	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23645	71	,	,	,
18637	23645	72	849	849	CD
18637	23645	73	,	,	,
18637	23645	74	850	850	CD
18637	23645	75	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	23645	76	Rendering	Rendering	NNP
18637	23645	77	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23645	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	23645	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	81	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	23645	82	,	,	,
18637	23645	83	207	207	CD
18637	23645	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23645	85	541	541	CD
18637	23645	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23645	87	1908	1908	CD
18637	23645	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23645	89	,	,	,
18637	23645	90	1122	1122	CD
18637	23645	91	,	,	,
18637	23645	92	1167	1167	CD
18637	23645	93	Consumers	Consumers	NNPS
18637	23645	94	'	'	POS
18637	23645	95	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23645	96	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	23645	98	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	99	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	23645	100	,	,	,
18637	23645	101	224	224	CD
18637	23645	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23645	103	148	148	CD
18637	23645	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23645	105	1912	1912	CD
18637	23645	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23645	107	,	,	,
18637	23645	108	1010	1010	CD
18637	23645	109	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	23645	110	Baking	Baking	NNP
18637	23645	111	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23645	112	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	23645	114	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	115	Woodring	Woodring	NNP
18637	23645	116	,	,	,
18637	23645	117	286	286	CD
18637	23645	118	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23645	119	352	352	CD
18637	23645	120	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23645	121	1932	1932	CD
18637	23645	122	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23645	123	,	,	,
18637	23645	124	212	212	CD
18637	23645	125	,	,	,
18637	23645	126	227	227	CD
18637	23645	127	,	,	,
18637	23645	128	228	228	CD
18637	23645	129	,	,	,
18637	23645	130	934	934	CD
18637	23645	131	,	,	,
18637	23645	132	1033	1033	CD
18637	23645	133	,	,	,
18637	23645	134	1151	1151	CD
18637	23645	135	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	23645	136	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23645	137	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	138	v.	v.	IN
18637	23645	139	_	_	NNP
18637	23645	140	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	23645	141	,	,	,
18637	23645	142	311	311	CD
18637	23645	143	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23645	144	5	5	CD
18637	23645	145	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23645	146	1940	1940	CD
18637	23645	147	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23645	148	,	,	,
18637	23645	149	1055	1055	CD
18637	23645	150	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	23645	151	Ill.	Illinois	NNP
18637	23645	152	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23645	153	.	.	.
18637	23646	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23646	2	&	&	CC
18637	23646	3	T.	T.	NNP
18637	23646	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23646	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23646	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	23646	7	_	_	NNP
18637	23646	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23646	9	,	,	,
18637	23646	10	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	23646	11	,	,	,
18637	23646	12	&	&	CC
18637	23646	13	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23647	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23647	2	,	,	,
18637	23647	3	294	294	CD
18637	23647	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23647	5	648	648	CD
18637	23647	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23647	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	23647	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23647	9	,	,	,
18637	23647	10	262	262	CD
18637	23647	11	,	,	,
18637	23647	12	263	263	CD
18637	23647	13	,	,	,
18637	23647	14	362	362	CD
18637	23647	15	,	,	,
18637	23647	16	858	858	CD
18637	23647	17	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	23647	18	Tie	Tie	NNP
18637	23647	19	&	&	CC
18637	23647	20	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	23647	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23647	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23647	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23647	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23647	25	United	United	NNP
18637	23647	26	States	States	NNP
18637	23647	27	,	,	,
18637	23647	28	286	286	CD
18637	23647	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23647	30	290	290	CD
18637	23647	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23647	32	1932	1932	CD
18637	23647	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23647	34	,	,	,
18637	23647	35	1197	1197	CD
18637	23647	36	Converse	Converse	NNP
18637	23647	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23647	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	23647	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23647	40	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	23647	41	,	,	,
18637	23647	42	224	224	CD
18637	23647	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23647	44	243	243	CD
18637	23647	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23647	46	1912	1912	CD
18637	23647	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23647	48	,	,	,
18637	23647	49	678	678	CD
18637	23647	50	Conway	Conway	NNP
18637	23647	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23647	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	23647	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23647	54	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	23647	55	,	,	,
18637	23647	56	1	1	CD
18637	23647	57	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	23647	58	.	.	.
18637	23648	1	603	603	CD
18637	23648	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23648	3	1862	1862	CD
18637	23648	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23648	5	,	,	,
18637	23648	6	231	231	CD
18637	23648	7	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	23648	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23648	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	11	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	23648	12	,	,	,
18637	23648	13	342	342	CD
18637	23648	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23648	15	126	126	CD
18637	23648	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23648	17	1951	1951	CD
18637	23648	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23648	19	,	,	,
18637	23648	20	670	670	CD
18637	23648	21	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	23648	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23648	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	25	Hart	Hart	NNP
18637	23648	26	,	,	,
18637	23648	27	146	146	CD
18637	23648	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23648	29	183	183	CD
18637	23648	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23648	31	1892	1892	CD
18637	23648	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23648	33	,	,	,
18637	23648	34	696	696	CD
18637	23648	35	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	23648	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23648	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	39	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	23648	40	County	County	NNP
18637	23648	41	,	,	,
18637	23648	42	196	196	CD
18637	23648	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23648	44	261	261	CD
18637	23648	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23648	46	1905	1905	CD
18637	23648	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23648	48	,	,	,
18637	23648	49	1148	1148	CD
18637	23648	50	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	23648	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	23648	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	54	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	23648	55	,	,	,
18637	23648	56	97	97	CD
18637	23648	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23648	58	566	566	CD
18637	23648	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23648	60	1878	1878	CD
18637	23648	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23648	62	,	,	,
18637	23648	63	185	185	CD
18637	23648	64	,	,	,
18637	23648	65	364	364	CD
18637	23648	66	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	23648	67	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	23648	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	70	Tait	Tait	NNP
18637	23648	71	,	,	,
18637	23648	72	265	265	CD
18637	23648	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23648	74	47	47	CD
18637	23648	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23648	76	1924	1924	CD
18637	23648	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23648	78	,	,	,
18637	23648	79	862	862	CD
18637	23648	80	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	23648	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	23648	83	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	84	United	United	NNP
18637	23648	85	States	States	NNP
18637	23648	86	,	,	,
18637	23648	87	138	138	CD
18637	23648	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23648	89	157	157	CD
18637	23648	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23648	91	1891	1891	CD
18637	23648	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23648	93	,	,	,
18637	23648	94	317	317	CD
18637	23648	95	,	,	,
18637	23648	96	881	881	CD
18637	23648	97	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	23648	98	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	99	v.	v.	IN
18637	23648	100	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	101	United	United	NNP
18637	23648	102	States	States	NNP
18637	23648	103	,	,	,
18637	23648	104	288	288	CD
18637	23648	105	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23648	106	102	102	CD
18637	23648	107	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23648	108	1933	1933	CD
18637	23648	109	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23648	110	,	,	,
18637	23648	111	422	422	CD
18637	23648	112	Cooke	Cooke	NNP
18637	23648	113	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	114	v.	v.	IN
18637	23648	115	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	116	United	United	NNP
18637	23648	117	States	States	NNP
18637	23648	118	,	,	,
18637	23648	119	267	267	CD
18637	23648	120	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23648	121	517	517	CD
18637	23648	122	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23648	123	1925	1925	CD
18637	23648	124	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23648	125	,	,	,
18637	23648	126	517	517	CD
18637	23648	127	,	,	,
18637	23648	128	847	847	CD
18637	23648	129	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
18637	23648	130	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	131	v.	v.	IN
18637	23648	132	_	_	NNP
18637	23648	133	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23648	134	of	of	IN
18637	23648	135	Wardens	Wardens	NNP
18637	23648	136	of	of	IN
18637	23648	137	Port	Port	NNP
18637	23648	138	of	of	IN
18637	23648	139	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	23648	140	,	,	,
18637	23648	141	12	12	CD
18637	23648	142	How	how	WRB
18637	23648	143	.	.	.
18637	23649	1	299	299	CD
18637	23649	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23649	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	23649	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23649	5	,	,	,
18637	23649	6	176	176	CD
18637	23649	7	,	,	,
18637	23649	8	180	180	CD
18637	23649	9	,	,	,
18637	23649	10	217	217	CD
18637	23649	11	,	,	,
18637	23649	12	219	219	CD
18637	23649	13	,	,	,
18637	23649	14	227	227	CD
18637	23649	15	,	,	,
18637	23649	16	229	229	CD
18637	23649	17	,	,	,
18637	23649	18	323	323	CD
18637	23649	19	,	,	,
18637	23649	20	364	364	CD
18637	23649	21	,	,	,
18637	23649	22	366	366	CD
18637	23649	23	Coolidge	Coolidge	NNP
18637	23649	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23649	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23649	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23649	27	Long	Long	NNP
18637	23649	28	,	,	,
18637	23649	29	282	282	CD
18637	23649	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23649	31	582	582	CD
18637	23649	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23649	33	1931	1931	CD
18637	23649	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23649	35	,	,	,
18637	23649	36	863	863	CD
18637	23649	37	,	,	,
18637	23649	38	1039	1039	CD
18637	23649	39	Coombes	Coombes	NNPS
18637	23649	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23649	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23649	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23649	43	Getz	Getz	NNP
18637	23649	44	,	,	,
18637	23649	45	285	285	CD
18637	23649	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23649	47	434	434	CD
18637	23649	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23649	49	1932	1932	CD
18637	23649	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23649	51	,	,	,
18637	23649	52	330	330	CD
18637	23649	53	,	,	,
18637	23649	54	344	344	CD
18637	23649	55	,	,	,
18637	23649	56	1035	1035	CD
18637	23649	57	Cooney	Cooney	NNP
18637	23649	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23649	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	23649	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23649	61	Mountain	Mountain	NNP
18637	23649	62	States	States	NNP
18637	23649	63	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	23649	64	&	&	CC
18637	23649	65	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	23649	66	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23649	67	,	,	,
18637	23649	68	294	294	CD
18637	23649	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23649	70	384	384	CD
18637	23649	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23649	72	1935	1935	CD
18637	23649	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23649	74	,	,	,
18637	23649	75	126	126	CD
18637	23649	76	,	,	,
18637	23649	77	195	195	CD
18637	23649	78	,	,	,
18637	23649	79	197	197	CD
18637	23649	80	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	23649	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23649	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	23649	83	_	_	NNP
18637	23649	84	Newell	Newell	NNP
18637	23649	85	,	,	,
18637	23649	86	173	173	CD
18637	23649	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23649	88	555	555	CD
18637	23649	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23649	90	1899	1899	CD
18637	23649	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23649	92	,	,	,
18637	23649	93	684	684	CD
18637	23649	94	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	23649	95	_	_	NNP
18637	23649	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	23649	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23649	98	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	23649	99	,	,	,
18637	23649	100	10	10	CD
18637	23649	101	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23649	102	.	.	.
18637	23650	1	308	308	CD
18637	23650	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23650	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	23650	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23650	5	,	,	,
18637	23650	6	658	658	CD
18637	23650	7	,	,	,
18637	23650	8	1081	1081	CD
18637	23650	9	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	23650	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23650	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23650	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23650	13	United	United	NNP
18637	23650	14	States	States	NNP
18637	23650	15	,	,	,
18637	23650	16	280	280	CD
18637	23650	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23650	18	409	409	CD
18637	23650	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23650	20	1930	1930	CD
18637	23650	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23650	22	,	,	,
18637	23650	23	863	863	CD
18637	23650	24	Coppage	Coppage	NNP
18637	23650	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23650	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23650	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23650	28	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23650	29	,	,	,
18637	23650	30	236	236	CD
18637	23650	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23650	32	1	1	CD
18637	23650	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23650	34	1915	1915	CD
18637	23650	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23650	36	,	,	,
18637	23650	37	985	985	CD
18637	23650	38	,	,	,
18637	23650	39	991	991	CD
18637	23650	40	Corfield	Corfield	NNP
18637	23650	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23650	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	23650	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23650	44	Coryell	Coryell	NNP
18637	23650	45	,	,	,
18637	23650	46	6	6	CD
18637	23650	47	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	23650	48	.	.	.
18637	23651	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	23651	2	.	.	.
18637	23652	1	3230	3230	CD
18637	23652	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23652	3	1823	1823	CD
18637	23652	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23652	5	,	,	,
18637	23652	6	689	689	CD
18637	23652	7	,	,	,
18637	23652	8	690	690	CD
18637	23652	9	Corn	corn	NN
18637	23652	10	Exch	Exch	NNS
18637	23652	11	.	.	.
18637	23653	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23653	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23653	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23653	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23653	5	Coler	Coler	NNP
18637	23653	6	,	,	,
18637	23653	7	280	280	CD
18637	23653	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23653	9	218	218	CD
18637	23653	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23653	11	1930	1930	CD
18637	23653	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23653	13	,	,	,
18637	23653	14	1081	1081	CD
18637	23653	15	Corn	Corn	NNP
18637	23653	16	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	23653	17	Ref	Ref	NNP
18637	23653	18	.	.	.
18637	23654	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23654	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23654	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	5	Eddy	Eddy	NNP
18637	23654	6	,	,	,
18637	23654	7	249	249	CD
18637	23654	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23654	9	427	427	CD
18637	23654	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23654	11	1919	1919	CD
18637	23654	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23654	13	,	,	,
18637	23654	14	238	238	CD
18637	23654	15	,	,	,
18637	23654	16	241	241	CD
18637	23654	17	,	,	,
18637	23654	18	1019	1019	CD
18637	23654	19	,	,	,
18637	23654	20	1154	1154	CD
18637	23654	21	Cornell	Cornell	NNP
18637	23654	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23654	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	25	Coyne	Coyne	NNP
18637	23654	26	,	,	,
18637	23654	27	192	192	CD
18637	23654	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23654	29	418	418	CD
18637	23654	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23654	31	1904	1904	CD
18637	23654	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23654	33	,	,	,
18637	23654	34	321	321	CD
18637	23654	35	Cornell	Cornell	NNP
18637	23654	36	Steamboat	Steamboat	NNP
18637	23654	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23654	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23654	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	41	United	United	NNP
18637	23654	42	States	States	NNP
18637	23654	43	,	,	,
18637	23654	44	321	321	CD
18637	23654	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23654	46	634	634	CD
18637	23654	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23654	48	1944	1944	CD
18637	23654	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23654	50	,	,	,
18637	23654	51	130	130	CD
18637	23654	52	Coronado	Coronado	NNP
18637	23654	53	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	23654	54	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23654	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	23654	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	58	United	United	NNP
18637	23654	59	Mine	Mine	NNP
18637	23654	60	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	23654	61	,	,	,
18637	23654	62	268	268	CD
18637	23654	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23654	64	295	295	CD
18637	23654	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23654	66	1925	1925	CD
18637	23654	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23654	68	,	,	,
18637	23654	69	149	149	CD
18637	23654	70	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23654	71	of	of	IN
18637	23654	72	Brick	Brick	NNP
18637	23654	73	Church	Church	NNP
18637	23654	74	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	23654	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	77	Mayor	Mayor	NNP
18637	23654	78	et	et	NNP
18637	23654	79	al	al	NNP
18637	23654	80	.	.	NNP
18637	23654	81	,	,	,
18637	23654	82	5	5	CD
18637	23654	83	Cowen	Cowen	NNP
18637	23654	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23654	85	N.Y.	New York	NNP
18637	23654	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23654	87	538	538	CD
18637	23654	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23654	89	1826	1826	CD
18637	23654	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23654	91	,	,	,
18637	23654	92	349	349	CD
18637	23654	93	Corporations	Corporations	NNPS
18637	23654	94	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23654	95	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	23654	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	98	Lowe	Lowe	NNP
18637	23654	99	,	,	,
18637	23654	100	281	281	CD
18637	23654	101	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23654	102	431	431	CD
18637	23654	103	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23654	104	1930	1930	CD
18637	23654	105	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23654	106	,	,	,
18637	23654	107	1154	1154	CD
18637	23654	108	Corrigan	Corrigan	NNP
18637	23654	109	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	110	v.	v.	IN
18637	23654	111	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	112	Buckley	Buckley	NNP
18637	23654	113	,	,	,
18637	23654	114	271	271	CD
18637	23654	115	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23654	116	323	323	CD
18637	23654	117	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23654	118	1926	1926	CD
18637	23654	119	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23654	120	,	,	,
18637	23654	121	1161	1161	CD
18637	23654	122	Corry	Corry	NNP
18637	23654	123	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	124	v.	v.	IN
18637	23654	125	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	126	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23654	127	,	,	,
18637	23654	128	196	196	CD
18637	23654	129	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23654	130	466	466	CD
18637	23654	131	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23654	132	1905	1905	CD
18637	23654	133	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23654	134	,	,	,
18637	23654	135	1060	1060	CD
18637	23654	136	Corson	Corson	NNP
18637	23654	137	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	138	v.	v.	IN
18637	23654	139	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	140	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	23654	141	,	,	,
18637	23654	142	120	120	CD
18637	23654	143	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23654	144	502	502	CD
18637	23654	145	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23654	146	1887	1887	CD
18637	23654	147	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23654	148	,	,	,
18637	23654	149	187	187	CD
18637	23654	150	Cotting	Cotting	NNP
18637	23654	151	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	152	v.	v.	IN
18637	23654	153	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	154	Godard	Godard	NNP
18637	23654	155	,	,	,
18637	23654	156	183	183	CD
18637	23654	157	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23654	158	79	79	CD
18637	23654	159	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23654	160	1901	1901	CD
18637	23654	161	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23654	162	,	,	,
18637	23654	163	996	996	CD
18637	23654	164	Coughran	Coughran	NNP
18637	23654	165	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	166	v.	v.	IN
18637	23654	167	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	168	Bigelow	Bigelow	NNP
18637	23654	169	,	,	,
18637	23654	170	164	164	CD
18637	23654	171	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23654	172	301	301	CD
18637	23654	173	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23654	174	1896	1896	CD
18637	23654	175	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23654	176	,	,	,
18637	23654	177	896	896	CD
18637	23654	178	Coulter	Coulter	NNP
18637	23654	179	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	180	v.	v.	IN
18637	23654	181	_	_	NNP
18637	23654	182	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	23654	183	&	&	CC
18637	23654	184	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	23655	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23655	2	,	,	,
18637	23655	3	196	196	CD
18637	23655	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23655	5	599	599	CD
18637	23655	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23655	7	1905	1905	CD
18637	23655	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23655	9	,	,	,
18637	23655	10	1152	1152	CD
18637	23655	11	Counselman	Counselman	NNP
18637	23655	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23655	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23655	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23655	15	Hitchcock	Hitchcock	NNP
18637	23655	16	,	,	,
18637	23655	17	142	142	CD
18637	23655	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23655	19	547	547	CD
18637	23655	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23655	21	1892	1892	CD
18637	23655	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23655	23	,	,	,
18637	23655	24	842	842	CD
18637	23655	25	,	,	,
18637	23655	26	878	878	CD
18637	23655	27	Covell	Covell	NNP
18637	23655	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23655	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23655	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23655	31	Heyman	Heyman	NNP
18637	23655	32	,	,	,
18637	23655	33	111	111	CD
18637	23655	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23655	35	176	176	CD
18637	23655	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23655	37	1884	1884	CD
18637	23655	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23655	39	,	,	,
18637	23655	40	526	526	CD
18637	23655	41	,	,	,
18637	23655	42	626	626	CD
18637	23655	43	,	,	,
18637	23655	44	627	627	CD
18637	23655	45	Coverdale	Coverdale	NNP
18637	23655	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23655	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	23655	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23655	49	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	23655	50	-	-	HYPH
18637	23655	51	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	23655	52	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	23655	53	Line	Line	NNP
18637	23655	54	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23655	55	,	,	,
18637	23655	56	303	303	CD
18637	23655	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23655	58	604	604	CD
18637	23655	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23655	60	1938	1938	CD
18637	23655	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23655	62	,	,	,
18637	23655	63	181	181	CD
18637	23655	64	,	,	,
18637	23655	65	198	198	CD
18637	23655	66	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	23655	67	_	_	NNP
18637	23655	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	23655	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23655	70	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23655	71	,	,	,
18637	23655	72	173	173	CD
18637	23655	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23655	74	231	231	CD
18637	23655	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23655	76	1899	1899	CD
18637	23655	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23655	78	,	,	,
18637	23655	79	340	340	CD
18637	23655	80	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	23655	81	&	&	CC
18637	23655	82	C.	C.	NNP
18637	23655	83	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	23655	84	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23655	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23655	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	23655	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23655	88	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23655	89	,	,	,
18637	23655	90	154	154	CD
18637	23655	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23655	92	204	204	CD
18637	23655	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23655	94	1894	1894	CD
18637	23655	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23655	96	,	,	,
18637	23655	97	120	120	CD
18637	23655	98	,	,	,
18637	23655	99	193	193	CD
18637	23655	100	,	,	,
18637	23655	101	218	218	CD
18637	23655	102	,	,	,
18637	23655	103	231	231	CD
18637	23655	104	Cox	Cox	NNP
18637	23655	105	_	_	NNP
18637	23655	106	v.	v.	IN
18637	23655	107	_	_	NNP
18637	23655	108	Lott	Lott	NNP
18637	23655	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23655	110	State	State	NNP
18637	23655	111	Tonnage	Tonnage	NNP
18637	23655	112	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23655	113	Cases	case	NNS
18637	23655	114	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23655	115	,	,	,
18637	23655	116	12	12	CD
18637	23655	117	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23655	118	.	.	.
18637	23656	1	204	204	CD
18637	23656	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23656	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	23656	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23656	5	,	,	,
18637	23656	6	366	366	CD
18637	23656	7	Cox	Cox	NNP
18637	23656	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23656	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23656	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23656	11	New	New	NNP
18637	23656	12	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	23656	13	,	,	,
18637	23656	14	312	312	CD
18637	23656	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23656	16	569	569	CD
18637	23656	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23656	18	1941	1941	CD
18637	23656	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23656	20	,	,	,
18637	23656	21	788	788	CD
18637	23656	22	Cox	Cox	NNP
18637	23656	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23656	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23656	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23656	26	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23656	27	,	,	,
18637	23656	28	202	202	CD
18637	23656	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23656	30	446	446	CD
18637	23656	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23656	32	1906	1906	CD
18637	23656	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23656	34	,	,	,
18637	23656	35	1148	1148	CD
18637	23656	36	Cox	Cox	NNP
18637	23656	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23656	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	23656	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23656	40	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	23656	41	,	,	,
18637	23656	42	247	247	CD
18637	23656	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23656	44	3	3	CD
18637	23656	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23656	46	1918	1918	CD
18637	23656	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23656	48	,	,	,
18637	23656	49	285	285	CD
18637	23656	50	Coy	Coy	NNP
18637	23656	51	,	,	,
18637	23656	52	In	in	IN
18637	23656	53	re	re	NN
18637	23656	54	,	,	,
18637	23656	55	127	127	CD
18637	23656	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23656	57	731	731	CD
18637	23656	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23656	59	1888	1888	CD
18637	23656	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23656	61	,	,	,
18637	23656	62	94	94	CD
18637	23656	63	Coyle	Coyle	NNP
18637	23656	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23656	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	23656	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23656	67	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	23656	68	,	,	,
18637	23656	69	221	221	CD
18637	23656	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23656	71	559	559	CD
18637	23656	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23656	73	1911	1911	CD
18637	23656	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23656	75	,	,	,
18637	23656	76	698	698	CD
18637	23656	77	Craig	Craig	NNP
18637	23656	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23656	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	23656	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23656	81	Harney	Harney	NNP
18637	23656	82	,	,	,
18637	23656	83	331	331	CD
18637	23656	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23656	85	367	367	CD
18637	23656	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23656	87	1947	1947	CD
18637	23656	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23656	89	,	,	,
18637	23656	90	784	784	CD
18637	23656	91	Craig	Craig	NNP
18637	23656	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23656	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	23656	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23656	95	Hecht	Hecht	NNP
18637	23656	96	,	,	,
18637	23656	97	263	263	CD
18637	23656	98	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23656	99	255	255	CD
18637	23656	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23656	101	1923	1923	CD
18637	23656	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23656	103	,	,	,
18637	23656	104	516	516	CD
18637	23656	105	Craig	Craig	NNP
18637	23656	106	_	_	NNP
18637	23656	107	v.	v.	IN
18637	23656	108	_	_	NNP
18637	23656	109	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	23656	110	,	,	,
18637	23656	111	4	4	CD
18637	23656	112	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	23656	113	.	.	.
18637	23657	1	410	410	CD
18637	23657	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23657	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	23657	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23657	5	,	,	,
18637	23657	6	326	326	CD
18637	23657	7	Crain	Crain	NNP
18637	23657	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23657	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23657	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23657	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23657	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23657	13	,	,	,
18637	23657	14	162	162	CD
18637	23657	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23657	16	625	625	CD
18637	23657	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23657	18	1896	1896	CD
18637	23657	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23657	20	,	,	,
18637	23657	21	847	847	CD
18637	23657	22	Cramer	Cramer	NNP
18637	23657	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23657	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23657	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23657	26	United	United	NNP
18637	23657	27	States	States	NNP
18637	23657	28	,	,	,
18637	23657	29	325	325	CD
18637	23657	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23657	31	1	1	CD
18637	23657	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23657	33	1945	1945	CD
18637	23657	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23657	35	,	,	,
18637	23657	36	640	640	CD
18637	23657	37	,	,	,
18637	23657	38	642	642	CD
18637	23657	39	,	,	,
18637	23657	40	645	645	CD
18637	23657	41	Crandall	Crandall	NNP
18637	23657	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23657	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23657	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23657	45	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
18637	23657	46	,	,	,
18637	23657	47	6	6	CD
18637	23657	48	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23657	49	.	.	.
18637	23658	1	35	35	CD
18637	23658	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23658	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	23658	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23658	5	,	,	,
18637	23658	6	180	180	CD
18637	23658	7	,	,	,
18637	23658	8	192	192	CD
18637	23658	9	,	,	,
18637	23658	10	242	242	CD
18637	23658	11	,	,	,
18637	23658	12	967	967	CD
18637	23658	13	,	,	,
18637	23658	14	968	968	CD
18637	23658	15	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	23658	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23658	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23658	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23658	19	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	23658	20	,	,	,
18637	23658	21	331	331	CD
18637	23658	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23658	23	1	1	CD
18637	23658	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23658	25	1947	1947	CD
18637	23658	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23658	27	,	,	,
18637	23658	28	1198	1198	CD
18637	23658	29	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	23658	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23658	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23658	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23658	33	Hahlo	Hahlo	NNP
18637	23658	34	,	,	,
18637	23658	35	258	258	CD
18637	23658	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23658	37	142	142	CD
18637	23658	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23658	39	1922	1922	CD
18637	23658	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23658	41	,	,	,
18637	23658	42	343	343	CD
18637	23658	43	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	23658	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23658	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	23658	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23658	47	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23658	48	,	,	,
18637	23658	49	242	242	CD
18637	23658	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23658	51	339	339	CD
18637	23658	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23658	53	1917	1917	CD
18637	23658	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23658	55	,	,	,
18637	23658	56	1155	1155	CD
18637	23658	57	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	23658	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23658	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	23658	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23658	61	New	New	NNP
18637	23658	62	York	York	NNP
18637	23658	63	,	,	,
18637	23658	64	239	239	CD
18637	23658	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23658	66	195	195	CD
18637	23658	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23658	68	1915	1915	CD
18637	23658	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23658	70	,	,	,
18637	23658	71	971	971	CD
18637	23658	72	,	,	,
18637	23658	73	1158	1158	CD
18637	23658	74	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	23658	75	-	-	HYPH
18637	23658	76	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23658	77	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23658	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23658	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	23658	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23658	81	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23658	82	,	,	,
18637	23658	83	311	311	CD
18637	23658	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23658	85	54	54	CD
18637	23658	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23658	87	1940	1940	CD
18637	23658	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23658	89	,	,	,
18637	23658	90	1197	1197	CD
18637	23658	91	Crawford	Crawford	NNP
18637	23658	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23658	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	23658	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23658	95	Branch	Branch	NNP
18637	23658	96	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23658	97	of	of	IN
18637	23658	98	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	23658	99	,	,	,
18637	23658	100	7	7	CD
18637	23658	101	How	how	WRB
18637	23658	102	.	.	.
18637	23659	1	279	279	CD
18637	23659	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	23659	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	5	,	,	,
18637	23659	6	355	355	CD
18637	23659	7	Crawford	Crawford	NNP
18637	23659	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23659	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23659	13	,	,	,
18637	23659	14	212	212	CD
18637	23659	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	16	183	183	CD
18637	23659	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	18	1909	1909	CD
18637	23659	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	20	,	,	,
18637	23659	21	879	879	CD
18637	23659	22	Cream	Cream	NNP
18637	23659	23	of	of	IN
18637	23659	24	Wheat	Wheat	NNP
18637	23659	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23659	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	29	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	23659	30	Forks	Forks	NNP
18637	23659	31	County	County	NNP
18637	23659	32	,	,	,
18637	23659	33	253	253	CD
18637	23659	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	35	325	325	CD
18637	23659	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	37	1920	1920	CD
18637	23659	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	39	,	,	,
18637	23659	40	1050	1050	CD
18637	23659	41	Crenshaw	Crenshaw	NNP
18637	23659	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	45	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	23659	46	,	,	,
18637	23659	47	227	227	CD
18637	23659	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	49	389	389	CD
18637	23659	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	51	1913	1913	CD
18637	23659	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	53	,	,	,
18637	23659	54	187	187	CD
18637	23659	55	Crenshaw	Crenshaw	NNP
18637	23659	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	59	United	United	NNP
18637	23659	60	States	States	NNP
18637	23659	61	,	,	,
18637	23659	62	134	134	CD
18637	23659	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	64	99	99	CD
18637	23659	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	66	1890	1890	CD
18637	23659	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	68	,	,	,
18637	23659	69	340	340	CD
18637	23659	70	,	,	,
18637	23659	71	458	458	CD
18637	23659	72	Crescent	Crescent	NNP
18637	23659	73	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	23659	74	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	23659	75	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23659	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	79	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	23659	80	,	,	,
18637	23659	81	257	257	CD
18637	23659	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	83	129	129	CD
18637	23659	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	85	1921	1921	CD
18637	23659	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	87	,	,	,
18637	23659	88	1145	1145	CD
18637	23659	89	Crew	Crew	NNP
18637	23659	90	Levick	Levick	NNP
18637	23659	91	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23659	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	95	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	23659	96	,	,	,
18637	23659	97	245	245	CD
18637	23659	98	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	99	292	292	CD
18637	23659	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	101	1917	1917	CD
18637	23659	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	103	,	,	,
18637	23659	104	364	364	CD
18637	23659	105	Cross	Cross	NNP
18637	23659	106	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	107	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	108	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	109	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	23659	110	,	,	,
18637	23659	111	146	146	CD
18637	23659	112	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	113	82	82	CD
18637	23659	114	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	115	1892	1892	CD
18637	23659	116	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	117	,	,	,
18637	23659	118	615	615	CD
18637	23659	119	Cross	Cross	NNP
18637	23659	120	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	121	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	122	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	123	North	North	NNP
18637	23659	124	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	23659	125	,	,	,
18637	23659	126	132	132	CD
18637	23659	127	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	128	131	131	CD
18637	23659	129	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	130	1889	1889	CD
18637	23659	131	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	132	,	,	,
18637	23659	133	1141	1141	CD
18637	23659	134	Crossman	Crossman	NNP
18637	23659	135	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	136	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	137	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	138	Lurman	Lurman	NNP
18637	23659	139	,	,	,
18637	23659	140	192	192	CD
18637	23659	141	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	142	189	189	CD
18637	23659	143	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	144	1904	1904	CD
18637	23659	145	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	146	,	,	,
18637	23659	147	248	248	CD
18637	23659	148	Crowell	Crowell	NNP
18637	23659	149	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	150	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	151	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	152	Benson	Benson	NNP
18637	23659	153	,	,	,
18637	23659	154	285	285	CD
18637	23659	155	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	156	22	22	CD
18637	23659	157	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	158	1932	1932	CD
18637	23659	159	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	160	,	,	,
18637	23659	161	622	622	CD
18637	23659	162	,	,	,
18637	23659	163	893	893	CD
18637	23659	164	,	,	,
18637	23659	165	1003	1003	CD
18637	23659	166	Crowley	Crowley	NNP
18637	23659	167	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	168	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	169	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	170	Christensen	Christensen	NNP
18637	23659	171	,	,	,
18637	23659	172	137	137	CD
18637	23659	173	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	174	86	86	CD
18637	23659	175	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	176	1890	1890	CD
18637	23659	177	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	178	,	,	,
18637	23659	179	971	971	CD
18637	23659	180	Crutcher	Crutcher	NNP
18637	23659	181	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	182	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	183	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	184	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23659	185	,	,	,
18637	23659	186	141	141	CD
18637	23659	187	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	188	47	47	CD
18637	23659	189	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	190	1891	1891	CD
18637	23659	191	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	192	,	,	,
18637	23659	193	194	194	CD
18637	23659	194	,	,	,
18637	23659	195	202	202	CD
18637	23659	196	,	,	,
18637	23659	197	689	689	CD
18637	23659	198	,	,	,
18637	23659	199	967	967	CD
18637	23659	200	Cudahy	Cudahy	NNP
18637	23659	201	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	23659	202	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23659	203	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	204	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	205	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	206	Hinkle	Hinkle	NNP
18637	23659	207	,	,	,
18637	23659	208	278	278	CD
18637	23659	209	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	210	460	460	CD
18637	23659	211	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	212	1929	1929	CD
18637	23659	213	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	214	,	,	,
18637	23659	215	195	195	CD
18637	23659	216	,	,	,
18637	23659	217	1051	1051	CD
18637	23659	218	Cudahy	Cudahy	NNP
18637	23659	219	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	23659	220	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23659	221	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	222	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	223	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	224	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23659	225	,	,	,
18637	23659	226	246	246	CD
18637	23659	227	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	228	450	450	CD
18637	23659	229	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	230	1918	1918	CD
18637	23659	231	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	232	,	,	,
18637	23659	233	200	200	CD
18637	23659	234	Cudahy	Cudahy	NNP
18637	23659	235	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	23659	236	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23659	237	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	238	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	239	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	240	Parramore	Parramore	NNP
18637	23659	241	,	,	,
18637	23659	242	263	263	CD
18637	23659	243	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	244	418	418	CD
18637	23659	245	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	246	1923	1923	CD
18637	23659	247	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	248	,	,	,
18637	23659	249	681	681	CD
18637	23659	250	Cullinan	Cullinan	NNP
18637	23659	251	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	252	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	253	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	254	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	23659	255	,	,	,
18637	23659	256	262	262	CD
18637	23659	257	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	258	134	134	CD
18637	23659	259	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	260	1923	1923	CD
18637	23659	261	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	262	,	,	,
18637	23659	263	1195	1195	CD
18637	23659	264	Cumming	Cumming	NNP
18637	23659	265	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	266	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	267	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	268	County	County	NNP
18637	23659	269	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23659	270	of	of	IN
18637	23659	271	Education	Education	NNP
18637	23659	272	,	,	,
18637	23659	273	175	175	CD
18637	23659	274	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	275	528	528	CD
18637	23659	276	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	277	1899	1899	CD
18637	23659	278	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	279	,	,	,
18637	23659	280	1162	1162	CD
18637	23659	281	Cummings	Cummings	NNP
18637	23659	282	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	283	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	284	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	285	Deutsche	Deutsche	NNP
18637	23659	286	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23659	287	,	,	,
18637	23659	288	300	300	CD
18637	23659	289	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23659	290	115	115	CD
18637	23659	291	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23659	292	1937	1937	CD
18637	23659	293	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23659	294	,	,	,
18637	23659	295	865	865	CD
18637	23659	296	Cummings	Cummings	NNPS
18637	23659	297	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	298	v.	v.	IN
18637	23659	299	_	_	NNP
18637	23659	300	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	23659	301	,	,	,
18637	23659	302	4	4	CD
18637	23659	303	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23659	304	.	.	.
18637	23660	1	277	277	CD
18637	23660	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23660	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	23660	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23660	5	,	,	,
18637	23660	6	316	316	CD
18637	23660	7	,	,	,
18637	23660	8	327	327	CD
18637	23660	9	,	,	,
18637	23660	10	328	328	CD
18637	23660	11	,	,	,
18637	23660	12	736	736	CD
18637	23660	13	Cummings	Cummings	NNPS
18637	23660	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23660	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23660	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23660	17	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23660	18	.	.	.
18637	23661	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23661	2	,	,	,
18637	23661	3	101	101	CD
18637	23661	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23661	5	153	153	CD
18637	23661	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23661	7	1880	1880	CD
18637	23661	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23661	9	,	,	,
18637	23661	10	895	895	CD
18637	23661	11	Cunningham	Cunningham	NNP
18637	23661	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23661	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23661	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23661	15	Macon	Macon	NNP
18637	23661	16	&	&	CC
18637	23661	17	Brunswick	Brunswick	NNP
18637	23661	18	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23661	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23661	20	,	,	,
18637	23661	21	109	109	CD
18637	23661	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23661	23	446	446	CD
18637	23661	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23661	25	1883	1883	CD
18637	23661	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23661	27	,	,	,
18637	23661	28	588	588	CD
18637	23661	29	,	,	,
18637	23661	30	589	589	CD
18637	23661	31	,	,	,
18637	23661	32	931	931	CD
18637	23661	33	Cunningham	Cunningham	NNP
18637	23661	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23661	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23661	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23661	37	Neagle	Neagle	NNP
18637	23661	38	,	,	,
18637	23661	39	135	135	CD
18637	23661	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23661	41	1	1	CD
18637	23661	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23661	43	1890	1890	CD
18637	23661	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23661	45	,	,	,
18637	23661	46	727	727	CD
18637	23661	47	Cunnius	Cunnius	NNP
18637	23661	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23661	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	23661	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23661	51	Reading	Reading	NNP
18637	23661	52	School	School	NNP
18637	23661	53	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	23661	54	.	.	NNP
18637	23661	55	,	,	,
18637	23661	56	198	198	CD
18637	23661	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23661	58	458	458	CD
18637	23661	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23661	60	1905	1905	CD
18637	23661	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23661	62	,	,	,
18637	23661	63	1082	1082	CD
18637	23661	64	Cuno	Cuno	NNP
18637	23661	65	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23661	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23661	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23661	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23661	69	Automatic	Automatic	NNP
18637	23661	70	Devices	Devices	NNPS
18637	23661	71	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23661	72	,	,	,
18637	23661	73	314	314	CD
18637	23661	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23661	75	84	84	CD
18637	23661	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23661	77	1941	1941	CD
18637	23661	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23661	79	,	,	,
18637	23661	80	272	272	CD
18637	23661	81	,	,	,
18637	23661	82	273	273	CD
18637	23661	83	Curran	Curran	NNP
18637	23661	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23661	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	23661	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23661	87	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	23661	88	,	,	,
18637	23661	89	15	15	CD
18637	23661	90	How	how	WRB
18637	23661	91	.	.	.
18637	23662	1	304	304	CD
18637	23662	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23662	3	1853	1853	CD
18637	23662	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23662	5	,	,	,
18637	23662	6	326	326	CD
18637	23662	7	,	,	,
18637	23662	8	332	332	CD
18637	23662	9	,	,	,
18637	23662	10	344	344	CD
18637	23662	11	Currin	Currin	NNP
18637	23662	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23662	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23662	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23662	15	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	23662	16	,	,	,
18637	23662	17	306	306	CD
18637	23662	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23662	19	1	1	CD
18637	23662	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23662	21	1939	1939	CD
18637	23662	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23662	23	,	,	,
18637	23662	24	76	76	CD
18637	23662	25	,	,	,
18637	23662	26	78	78	CD
18637	23662	27	,	,	,
18637	23662	28	176	176	CD
18637	23662	29	,	,	,
18637	23662	30	552	552	CD
18637	23662	31	,	,	,
18637	23662	32	853	853	CD
18637	23662	33	,	,	,
18637	23662	34	854	854	CD
18637	23662	35	Curry	Curry	NNP
18637	23662	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23662	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23662	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23662	39	McCanless	McCanless	NNP
18637	23662	40	,	,	,
18637	23662	41	307	307	CD
18637	23662	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23662	43	357	357	CD
18637	23662	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23662	45	1939	1939	CD
18637	23662	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23662	47	,	,	,
18637	23662	48	1047	1047	CD
18637	23662	49	,	,	,
18637	23662	50	1048	1048	CD
18637	23662	51	,	,	,
18637	23662	52	1050	1050	CD
18637	23662	53	Curry	Curry	NNP
18637	23662	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23662	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	23662	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23662	57	United	United	NNP
18637	23662	58	States	States	NNP
18637	23662	59	,	,	,
18637	23662	60	314	314	CD
18637	23662	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23662	62	14	14	CD
18637	23662	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23662	64	1941	1941	CD
18637	23662	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23662	66	,	,	,
18637	23662	67	731	731	CD
18637	23662	68	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	23662	69	,	,	,
18637	23662	70	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23662	71	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23662	72	,	,	,
18637	23662	73	106	106	CD
18637	23662	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23662	75	371	371	CD
18637	23662	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23662	77	1882	1882	CD
18637	23662	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23662	79	,	,	,
18637	23662	80	309	309	CD
18637	23662	81	,	,	,
18637	23662	82	460	460	CD
18637	23662	83	,	,	,
18637	23662	84	793	793	CD
18637	23662	85	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	23662	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23662	87	v.	v.	IN
18637	23662	88	_	_	NNP
18637	23662	89	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	23662	90	,	,	,
18637	23662	91	13	13	CD
18637	23662	92	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23662	93	.	.	.
18637	23663	1	68	68	CD
18637	23663	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23663	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	23663	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23663	5	,	,	,
18637	23663	6	355	355	CD
18637	23663	7	Cusack	Cusack	NNP
18637	23663	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23663	9	_	_	NNP
18637	23663	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	23663	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23663	12	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23663	13	,	,	,
18637	23663	14	242	242	CD
18637	23663	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23663	16	526	526	CD
18637	23663	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23663	18	1917	1917	CD
18637	23663	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23663	20	,	,	,
18637	23663	21	1029	1029	CD
18637	23663	22	Cuyahoga	Cuyahoga	NNP
18637	23663	23	River	River	NNP
18637	23663	24	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23663	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23663	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23663	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23663	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23663	29	Akron	Akron	NNP
18637	23663	30	,	,	,
18637	23663	31	240	240	CD
18637	23663	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23663	33	462	462	CD
18637	23663	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23663	35	1916	1916	CD
18637	23663	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23663	37	,	,	,
18637	23663	38	329	329	CD
18637	23663	39	D	D	NNP
18637	23663	40	Dahnke	Dahnke	NNP
18637	23663	41	-	-	HYPH
18637	23663	42	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	23663	43	Milling	Milling	NNP
18637	23663	44	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23663	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23663	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	23663	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23663	48	Bondurant	Bondurant	NNP
18637	23663	49	,	,	,
18637	23663	50	257	257	CD
18637	23663	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23663	52	282	282	CD
18637	23663	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23663	54	1921	1921	CD
18637	23663	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23663	56	,	,	,
18637	23663	57	120	120	CD
18637	23663	58	,	,	,
18637	23663	59	182	182	CD
18637	23663	60	Dallemagne	Dallemagne	NNP
18637	23663	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23663	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	23663	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23663	64	Moisan	Moisan	NNP
18637	23663	65	,	,	,
18637	23663	66	197	197	CD
18637	23663	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23663	68	169	169	CD
18637	23663	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23663	70	1905	1905	CD
18637	23663	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23663	72	,	,	,
18637	23663	73	636	636	CD
18637	23663	74	Dalton	Dalton	NNP
18637	23663	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23663	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	23663	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23663	78	Jennings	Jennings	NNP
18637	23663	79	,	,	,
18637	23663	80	93	93	CD
18637	23663	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23663	82	271	271	CD
18637	23663	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23663	84	1876	1876	CD
18637	23663	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23663	86	,	,	,
18637	23663	87	273	273	CD
18637	23663	88	Dane	Dane	NNP
18637	23663	89	_	_	NNP
18637	23663	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	23663	91	_	_	NNP
18637	23663	92	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	23663	93	,	,	,
18637	23663	94	256	256	CD
18637	23663	95	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23663	96	589	589	CD
18637	23663	97	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23663	98	1921	1921	CD
18637	23663	99	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23663	100	,	,	,
18637	23663	101	1037	1037	CD
18637	23663	102	Danforth	Danforth	NNP
18637	23663	103	_	_	NNP
18637	23663	104	v.	v.	IN
18637	23663	105	_	_	NNP
18637	23663	106	United	United	NNP
18637	23663	107	States	States	NNP
18637	23663	108	,	,	,
18637	23663	109	308	308	CD
18637	23663	110	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23663	111	271	271	CD
18637	23663	112	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23663	113	1939	1939	CD
18637	23663	114	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23663	115	,	,	,
18637	23663	116	871	871	CD
18637	23663	117	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	23663	118	Ball	Ball	NNP
18637	23663	119	,	,	,
18637	23663	120	The	the	DT
18637	23663	121	,	,	,
18637	23663	122	10	10	CD
18637	23663	123	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23663	124	.	.	.
18637	23664	1	557	557	CD
18637	23664	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23664	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	23664	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23664	5	,	,	,
18637	23664	6	125	125	CD
18637	23664	7	,	,	,
18637	23664	8	128	128	CD
18637	23664	9	,	,	,
18637	23664	10	577	577	CD
18637	23664	11	,	,	,
18637	23664	12	868	868	CD
18637	23664	13	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	23664	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23664	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23664	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23664	17	Family	Family	NNP
18637	23664	18	Security	Security	NNP
18637	23664	19	Life	Life	NNP
18637	23664	20	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23664	21	.	.	.
18637	23665	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23665	2	,	,	,
18637	23665	3	336	336	CD
18637	23665	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23665	5	220	220	CD
18637	23665	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23665	7	1949	1949	CD
18637	23665	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23665	9	,	,	,
18637	23665	10	564	564	CD
18637	23665	11	,	,	,
18637	23665	12	1021	1021	CD
18637	23665	13	,	,	,
18637	23665	14	1155	1155	CD
18637	23665	15	Danzer	Danzer	NNP
18637	23665	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23665	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23665	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23665	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23665	20	Gulf	Gulf	NNP
18637	23665	21	&	&	CC
18637	23665	22	S.I.R.	S.I.R.	NNP
18637	23666	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23666	2	,	,	,
18637	23666	3	268	268	CD
18637	23666	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23666	5	633	633	CD
18637	23666	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23666	7	1925	1925	CD
18637	23666	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23666	9	,	,	,
18637	23666	10	857	857	CD
18637	23666	11	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	23666	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23666	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23666	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23666	15	Mayer	Mayer	NNP
18637	23666	16	,	,	,
18637	23666	17	10	10	CD
18637	23666	18	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23666	19	.	.	.
18637	23667	1	465	465	CD
18637	23667	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23667	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	23667	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23667	5	,	,	,
18637	23667	6	673	673	CD
18637	23667	7	D'Arcy	D'Arcy	NNP
18637	23667	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23667	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23667	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23667	11	Ketchum	Ketchum	NNP
18637	23667	12	,	,	,
18637	23667	13	11	11	CD
18637	23667	14	How	how	WRB
18637	23667	15	.	.	.
18637	23668	1	165	165	CD
18637	23668	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23668	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	23668	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23668	5	,	,	,
18637	23668	6	658	658	CD
18637	23668	7	Darling	Darling	NNP
18637	23668	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23668	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23668	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23668	11	Newport	Newport	NNP
18637	23668	12	News	News	NNP
18637	23668	13	,	,	,
18637	23668	14	249	249	CD
18637	23668	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23668	16	540	540	CD
18637	23668	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23668	18	1919	1919	CD
18637	23668	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23668	20	,	,	,
18637	23668	21	1067	1067	CD
18637	23668	22	Darnell	Darnell	NNP
18637	23668	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23668	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23668	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23668	26	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	23668	27	,	,	,
18637	23668	28	226	226	CD
18637	23668	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23668	30	390	390	CD
18637	23668	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23668	32	1912	1912	CD
18637	23668	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23668	34	,	,	,
18637	23668	35	1149	1149	CD
18637	23668	36	Darnell	Darnell	NNP
18637	23668	37	&	&	CC
18637	23668	38	Son	Son	NNP
18637	23668	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23668	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23668	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23668	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23668	43	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	23668	44	,	,	,
18637	23668	45	208	208	CD
18637	23668	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23668	47	113	113	CD
18637	23668	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23668	49	1908	1908	CD
18637	23668	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23668	51	,	,	,
18637	23668	52	185	185	CD
18637	23668	53	Darrington	Darrington	NNP
18637	23668	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23668	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	23668	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23668	57	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23668	58	of	of	IN
18637	23668	59	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	23668	60	,	,	,
18637	23668	61	13	13	CD
18637	23668	62	How	how	WRB
18637	23668	63	.	.	.
18637	23669	1	12	12	CD
18637	23669	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23669	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	23669	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23669	5	,	,	,
18637	23669	6	326	326	CD
18637	23669	7	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
18637	23669	8	College	College	NNP
18637	23669	9	_	_	NNP
18637	23669	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	23669	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23669	12	Woodward	Woodward	NNP
18637	23669	13	,	,	,
18637	23669	14	4	4	CD
18637	23669	15	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23669	16	.	.	.
18637	23670	1	518	518	CD
18637	23670	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23670	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	23670	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23670	5	,	,	,
18637	23670	6	332	332	CD
18637	23670	7	,	,	,
18637	23670	8	336	336	CD
18637	23670	9	,	,	,
18637	23670	10	338	338	CD
18637	23670	11	,	,	,
18637	23670	12	352	352	CD
18637	23670	13	,	,	,
18637	23670	14	555	555	CD
18637	23670	15	Davidson	Davidson	NNP
18637	23670	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23670	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23670	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23670	19	New	New	NNP
18637	23670	20	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	23670	21	,	,	,
18637	23670	22	96	96	CD
18637	23670	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23670	24	97	97	CD
18637	23670	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23670	26	1878	1878	CD
18637	23670	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23670	28	,	,	,
18637	23670	29	847	847	CD
18637	23670	30	,	,	,
18637	23670	31	972	972	CD
18637	23670	32	,	,	,
18637	23670	33	999	999	CD
18637	23670	34	,	,	,
18637	23670	35	1062	1062	CD
18637	23670	36	,	,	,
18637	23670	37	1146	1146	CD
18637	23670	38	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23670	39	,	,	,
18637	23670	40	The	the	DT
18637	23670	41	,	,	,
18637	23670	42	10	10	CD
18637	23670	43	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23670	44	.	.	.
18637	23671	1	15	15	CD
18637	23671	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23671	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	23671	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23671	5	,	,	,
18637	23671	6	586	586	CD
18637	23671	7	,	,	,
18637	23671	8	610	610	CD
18637	23671	9	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23671	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23671	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23671	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23671	13	Beason	Beason	NNP
18637	23671	14	,	,	,
18637	23671	15	133	133	CD
18637	23671	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23671	17	333	333	CD
18637	23671	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23671	19	1890	1890	CD
18637	23671	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23671	21	,	,	,
18637	23671	22	765	765	CD
18637	23671	23	,	,	,
18637	23671	24	766	766	CD
18637	23671	25	,	,	,
18637	23671	26	772	772	CD
18637	23671	27	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23671	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23671	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23671	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23671	31	Brig	Brig	NNP
18637	23671	32	Seneca	Seneca	NNP
18637	23671	33	,	,	,
18637	23671	34	21	21	CD
18637	23671	35	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	23671	36	.	.	.
18637	23672	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	23672	2	.	.	.
18637	23673	1	No	no	UH
18637	23673	2	.	.	.
18637	23674	1	12,670	12,670	CD
18637	23674	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23674	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	23674	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23674	5	,	,	,
18637	23674	6	573	573	CD
18637	23674	7	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23674	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23674	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23674	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23674	11	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
18637	23674	12	,	,	,
18637	23674	13	C.C.	C.C.	NNP
18637	23675	1	&	&	CC
18637	23675	2	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23675	3	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	23676	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23676	2	,	,	,
18637	23676	3	217	217	CD
18637	23676	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23676	5	157	157	CD
18637	23676	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23676	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	23676	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23676	9	,	,	,
18637	23676	10	235	235	CD
18637	23676	11	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23676	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23676	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23676	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23676	15	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23676	16	,	,	,
18637	23676	17	305	305	CD
18637	23676	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23676	19	32	32	CD
18637	23676	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23676	21	1938	1938	CD
18637	23676	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23676	23	,	,	,
18637	23676	24	663	663	CD
18637	23676	25	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23676	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23676	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23676	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23676	29	Department	Department	NNP
18637	23676	30	of	of	IN
18637	23676	31	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	23676	32	,	,	,
18637	23676	33	317	317	CD
18637	23676	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23676	35	249	249	CD
18637	23676	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23676	37	1942	1942	CD
18637	23676	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23676	39	,	,	,
18637	23676	40	581	581	CD
18637	23676	41	,	,	,
18637	23676	42	583	583	CD
18637	23676	43	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23676	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23676	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	23676	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23676	47	Elmira	Elmira	NNP
18637	23676	48	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	23676	49	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23676	50	,	,	,
18637	23676	51	161	161	CD
18637	23676	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23676	53	275	275	CD
18637	23676	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23676	55	1896	1896	CD
18637	23676	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23676	57	,	,	,
18637	23676	58	725	725	CD
18637	23676	59	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23676	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23676	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23676	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23676	63	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	23676	64	Co	Co	NNP
18637	23676	65	-	-	NNP
18637	23676	66	operative	operative	JJ
18637	23676	67	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23676	68	,	,	,
18637	23676	69	262	262	CD
18637	23676	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23676	71	312	312	CD
18637	23676	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23676	73	1923	1923	CD
18637	23676	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23676	75	,	,	,
18637	23676	76	1076	1076	CD
18637	23676	77	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23676	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23676	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	23676	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23676	81	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	23676	82	,	,	,
18637	23676	83	16	16	CD
18637	23676	84	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23676	85	.	.	.
18637	23677	1	203	203	CD
18637	23677	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23677	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	23677	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23677	5	,	,	,
18637	23677	6	931	931	CD
18637	23677	7	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23677	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23677	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23677	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23677	11	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	23677	12	,	,	,
18637	23677	13	167	167	CD
18637	23677	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23677	15	43	43	CD
18637	23677	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23677	17	1897	1897	CD
18637	23677	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23677	19	,	,	,
18637	23677	20	785	785	CD
18637	23677	21	,	,	,
18637	23677	22	809	809	CD
18637	23677	23	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23677	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23677	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23677	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23677	27	Hildebrant	Hildebrant	NNP
18637	23677	28	.	.	.
18637	23678	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23678	2	See	See	NNP
18637	23678	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23678	4	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	23678	5	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23678	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	23678	7	.	.	.
18637	23679	1	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23679	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23679	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23679	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23679	5	Hildebrant	Hildebrant	NNP
18637	23679	6	.	.	.
18637	23680	1	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23680	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23680	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23680	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23680	5	Schnell	Schnell	NNP
18637	23680	6	,	,	,
18637	23680	7	81	81	CD
18637	23680	8	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23680	9	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	23680	10	.	.	.
18637	23681	1	872	872	CD
18637	23681	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23681	3	1949	1949	CD
18637	23681	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23681	5	,	,	,
18637	23681	6	1186	1186	CD
18637	23681	7	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23681	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23681	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23681	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23681	13	,	,	,
18637	23681	14	328	328	CD
18637	23681	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23681	16	582	582	CD
18637	23681	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23681	18	1946	1946	CD
18637	23681	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23681	20	,	,	,
18637	23681	21	824	824	CD
18637	23681	22	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23681	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23681	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	26	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	23681	27	,	,	,
18637	23681	28	236	236	CD
18637	23681	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23681	30	697	697	CD
18637	23681	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23681	32	1915	1915	CD
18637	23681	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23681	34	,	,	,
18637	23681	35	187	187	CD
18637	23681	36	Day	Day	NNP
18637	23681	37	-	-	HYPH
18637	23681	38	Brite	Brite	NNP
18637	23681	39	Lighting	Lighting	NNP
18637	23681	40	,	,	,
18637	23681	41	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	23681	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23681	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	45	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	23681	46	,	,	,
18637	23681	47	342	342	CD
18637	23681	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23681	49	421	421	CD
18637	23681	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23681	51	1952	1952	CD
18637	23681	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23681	53	,	,	,
18637	23681	54	989	989	CD
18637	23681	55	Dayton	Dayton	NNP
18637	23681	56	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	23681	57	&	&	CC
18637	23681	58	I.	I.	NNP
18637	23681	59	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23681	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23681	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	63	Barton	Barton	NNP
18637	23681	64	,	,	,
18637	23681	65	183	183	CD
18637	23681	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23681	67	23	23	CD
18637	23681	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23681	69	1901	1901	CD
18637	23681	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23681	71	,	,	,
18637	23681	72	987	987	CD
18637	23681	73	Dayton	Dayton	NNP
18637	23681	74	-	-	HYPH
18637	23681	75	Goose	Goose	NNP
18637	23681	76	Creek	Creek	NNP
18637	23681	77	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23681	78	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23681	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	23681	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	82	United	United	NNP
18637	23681	83	States	States	NNP
18637	23681	84	,	,	,
18637	23681	85	263	263	CD
18637	23681	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23681	87	456	456	CD
18637	23681	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23681	89	1924	1924	CD
18637	23681	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23681	91	,	,	,
18637	23681	92	861	861	CD
18637	23681	93	Dean	Dean	NNP
18637	23681	94	Milk	Milk	NNP
18637	23681	95	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23681	96	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	23681	98	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	99	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	23681	100	,	,	,
18637	23681	101	340	340	CD
18637	23681	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23681	103	349	349	CD
18637	23681	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23681	105	1951	1951	CD
18637	23681	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23681	107	,	,	,
18637	23681	108	238	238	CD
18637	23681	109	Debs	debs	NN
18637	23681	110	,	,	,
18637	23681	111	In	in	IN
18637	23681	112	re	re	NN
18637	23681	113	,	,	,
18637	23681	114	158	158	CD
18637	23681	115	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23681	116	564	564	CD
18637	23681	117	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23681	118	1895	1895	CD
18637	23681	119	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23681	120	,	,	,
18637	23681	121	268	268	CD
18637	23681	122	,	,	,
18637	23681	123	484	484	CD
18637	23681	124	,	,	,
18637	23681	125	495	495	CD
18637	23681	126	,	,	,
18637	23681	127	516	516	CD
18637	23681	128	,	,	,
18637	23681	129	878	878	CD
18637	23681	130	Debs	Debs	NNP
18637	23681	131	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	132	v.	v.	IN
18637	23681	133	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	134	United	United	NNP
18637	23681	135	States	States	NNP
18637	23681	136	,	,	,
18637	23681	137	249	249	CD
18637	23681	138	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23681	139	211	211	CD
18637	23681	140	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23681	141	1919	1919	CD
18637	23681	142	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23681	143	,	,	,
18637	23681	144	297	297	CD
18637	23681	145	,	,	,
18637	23681	146	774	774	CD
18637	23681	147	,	,	,
18637	23681	148	794	794	CD
18637	23681	149	Decatur	Decatur	NNP
18637	23681	150	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	151	v.	v.	IN
18637	23681	152	_	_	NNP
18637	23681	153	Paulding	Paulding	NNP
18637	23681	154	,	,	,
18637	23681	155	14	14	CD
18637	23681	156	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23681	157	.	.	.
18637	23682	1	497	497	CD
18637	23682	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23682	3	1840	1840	CD
18637	23682	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23682	5	,	,	,
18637	23682	6	501	501	CD
18637	23682	7	,	,	,
18637	23682	8	546	546	CD
18637	23682	9	De	De	NNP
18637	23682	10	Geofroy	Geofroy	NNP
18637	23682	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23682	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	23682	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23682	14	Riggs	Riggs	NNP
18637	23682	15	,	,	,
18637	23682	16	133	133	CD
18637	23682	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23682	18	258	258	CD
18637	23682	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23682	20	1890	1890	CD
18637	23682	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23682	22	,	,	,
18637	23682	23	302	302	CD
18637	23682	24	,	,	,
18637	23682	25	416	416	CD
18637	23682	26	De	De	NNP
18637	23682	27	Groot	Groot	NNP
18637	23682	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23682	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23682	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23682	31	United	United	NNP
18637	23682	32	States	States	NNP
18637	23682	33	,	,	,
18637	23682	34	5	5	CD
18637	23682	35	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23682	36	.	.	.
18637	23683	1	419	419	CD
18637	23683	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23683	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	23683	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23683	5	,	,	,
18637	23683	6	514	514	CD
18637	23683	7	,	,	,
18637	23683	8	536	536	CD
18637	23683	9	,	,	,
18637	23683	10	586	586	CD
18637	23683	11	De	De	NNP
18637	23683	12	Jonge	Jonge	NNP
18637	23683	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23683	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	23683	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23683	16	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	23683	17	,	,	,
18637	23683	18	299	299	CD
18637	23683	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23683	20	353	353	CD
18637	23683	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23683	22	1937	1937	CD
18637	23683	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23683	24	,	,	,
18637	23683	25	757	757	CD
18637	23683	26	,	,	,
18637	23683	27	773	773	CD
18637	23683	28	,	,	,
18637	23683	29	806	806	CD
18637	23683	30	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	23683	31	,	,	,
18637	23683	32	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23683	33	&	&	CC
18637	23683	34	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	23683	35	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23683	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23683	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23683	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23683	39	Morristown	Morristown	NNP
18637	23683	40	,	,	,
18637	23683	41	276	276	CD
18637	23683	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23683	43	182	182	CD
18637	23683	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23683	45	1928	1928	CD
18637	23683	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23683	47	,	,	,
18637	23683	48	1066	1066	CD
18637	23683	49	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	23683	50	,	,	,
18637	23683	51	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23683	52	&	&	CC
18637	23683	53	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	23683	54	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23683	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23683	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	23683	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23683	58	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	23683	59	,	,	,
18637	23683	60	198	198	CD
18637	23683	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23683	62	341	341	CD
18637	23683	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23683	64	1905	1905	CD
18637	23683	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23683	66	,	,	,
18637	23683	67	1050	1050	CD
18637	23683	68	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	23683	69	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	23683	70	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23683	71	,	,	,
18637	23683	72	18	18	CD
18637	23683	73	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23683	74	.	.	.
18637	23684	1	206	206	CD
18637	23684	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23684	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	23684	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23684	5	,	,	,
18637	23684	6	342	342	CD
18637	23684	7	Delgado	Delgado	NNP
18637	23684	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23684	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23684	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23684	11	Chavez	Chavez	NNP
18637	23684	12	,	,	,
18637	23684	13	140	140	CD
18637	23684	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23684	15	586	586	CD
18637	23684	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23684	17	1891	1891	CD
18637	23684	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23684	19	,	,	,
18637	23684	20	1096	1096	CD
18637	23684	21	.	.	.
18637	23685	1	De	De	NNP
18637	23685	2	Lima	Lima	NNP
18637	23685	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23685	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23685	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23685	6	Bidwell	Bidwell	NNP
18637	23685	7	,	,	,
18637	23685	8	182	182	CD
18637	23685	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23685	10	1	1	CD
18637	23685	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23685	12	1901	1901	CD
18637	23685	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23685	14	,	,	,
18637	23685	15	419	419	CD
18637	23685	16	De	De	NNP
18637	23685	17	Meerleer	Meerleer	NNP
18637	23685	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23685	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23685	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23685	21	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	23685	22	,	,	,
18637	23685	23	329	329	CD
18637	23685	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23685	25	663	663	CD
18637	23685	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23685	27	1947	1947	CD
18637	23685	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23685	29	,	,	,
18637	23685	30	1103	1103	CD
18637	23685	31	,	,	,
18637	23685	32	1108	1108	CD
18637	23685	33	Demorest	Demorest	NNP
18637	23685	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23685	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23685	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23685	37	City	City	NNP
18637	23685	38	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23685	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23685	40	,	,	,
18637	23685	41	321	321	CD
18637	23685	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23685	43	36	36	CD
18637	23685	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23685	45	1944	1944	CD
18637	23685	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23685	47	,	,	,
18637	23685	48	1034	1034	CD
18637	23685	49	Den	Den	NNP
18637	23685	50	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23685	51	dem	dem	NNP
18637	23685	52	.	.	.
18637	23686	1	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	23686	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23686	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23686	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23686	5	Hoboken	Hoboken	NNP
18637	23686	6	Land	Land	NNP
18637	23686	7	&	&	CC
18637	23686	8	Improvement	Improvement	NNP
18637	23686	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23686	10	,	,	,
18637	23686	11	18	18	CD
18637	23686	12	How	how	WRB
18637	23686	13	.	.	.
18637	23687	1	272	272	CD
18637	23687	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23687	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	23687	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23687	5	,	,	,
18637	23687	6	308	308	CD
18637	23687	7	,	,	,
18637	23687	8	823	823	CD
18637	23687	9	,	,	,
18637	23687	10	845	845	CD
18637	23687	11	,	,	,
18637	23687	12	846	846	CD
18637	23687	13	Dennick	Dennick	NNP
18637	23687	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23687	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23687	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23687	17	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	23687	18	,	,	,
18637	23687	19	103	103	CD
18637	23687	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23687	21	11	11	CD
18637	23687	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23687	23	1881	1881	CD
18637	23687	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23687	25	,	,	,
18637	23687	26	675	675	CD
18637	23687	27	,	,	,
18637	23687	28	676	676	CD
18637	23687	29	Dennis	Dennis	NNP
18637	23687	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23687	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23687	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23687	33	United	United	NNP
18637	23687	34	States	States	NNP
18637	23687	35	,	,	,
18637	23687	36	339	339	CD
18637	23687	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23687	38	162	162	CD
18637	23687	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23687	40	1950	1950	CD
18637	23687	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23687	42	,	,	,
18637	23687	43	879	879	CD
18637	23687	44	Dennis	Dennis	NNP
18637	23687	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23687	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	23687	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23687	48	United	United	NNP
18637	23687	49	States	States	NNP
18637	23687	50	,	,	,
18637	23687	51	341	341	CD
18637	23687	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23687	53	494	494	CD
18637	23687	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23687	55	1951	1951	CD
18637	23687	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23687	57	,	,	,
18637	23687	58	519	519	CD
18637	23687	59	,	,	,
18637	23687	60	770	770	CD
18637	23687	61	,	,	,
18637	23687	62	795	795	CD
18637	23687	63	,	,	,
18637	23687	64	796	796	CD
18637	23687	65	,	,	,
18637	23687	66	801	801	CD
18637	23687	67	,	,	,
18637	23687	68	843	843	CD
18637	23687	69	Denny	Denny	NNP
18637	23687	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23687	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	23687	72	_	_	NNP
18637	23687	73	Bennett	Bennett	NNP
18637	23687	74	,	,	,
18637	23687	75	128	128	CD
18637	23687	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23687	77	489	489	CD
18637	23687	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23687	79	1888	1888	CD
18637	23687	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23687	81	,	,	,
18637	23687	82	265	265	CD
18637	23687	83	Dent	Dent	NNP
18637	23687	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23687	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	23687	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23687	87	West	West	NNP
18637	23687	88	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	23687	89	,	,	,
18637	23687	90	129	129	CD
18637	23687	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23687	92	114	114	CD
18637	23687	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23687	94	1889	1889	CD
18637	23687	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23687	96	,	,	,
18637	23687	97	1024	1024	CD
18637	23687	98	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	23687	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23687	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	23687	101	_	_	NNP
18637	23687	102	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	23687	103	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23687	104	Water	Water	NNP
18637	23687	105	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23687	106	,	,	,
18637	23687	107	216	216	CD
18637	23687	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23687	109	178	178	CD
18637	23687	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23687	111	1918	1918	CD
18637	23687	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23687	113	,	,	,
18637	23687	114	1008	1008	CD
18637	23687	115	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	23687	116	_	_	NNP
18637	23687	117	v.	v.	IN
18637	23687	118	_	_	NNP
18637	23687	119	New	New	NNP
18637	23687	120	York	York	NNP
18637	23687	121	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23687	122	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23687	123	,	,	,
18637	23687	124	229	229	CD
18637	23687	125	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23687	126	123	123	CD
18637	23687	127	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23687	128	1913	1913	CD
18637	23687	129	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23687	130	,	,	,
18637	23687	131	1009	1009	CD
18637	23687	132	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	23687	133	&	&	CC
18637	23687	134	R.G.R.	R.G.R.	NNP
18637	23688	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23688	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23688	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23688	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23688	5	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	23688	6	,	,	,
18637	23688	7	250	250	CD
18637	23688	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23688	9	241	241	CD
18637	23688	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23688	11	1919	1919	CD
18637	23688	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23688	13	,	,	,
18637	23688	14	223	223	CD
18637	23688	15	,	,	,
18637	23688	16	345	345	CD
18637	23688	17	,	,	,
18637	23688	18	1009	1009	CD
18637	23688	19	,	,	,
18637	23688	20	1014	1014	CD
18637	23688	21	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	23688	22	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23688	23	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	23688	24	Yards	Yards	NNP
18637	23688	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23688	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23688	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23688	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23688	29	United	United	NNP
18637	23688	30	States	States	NNP
18637	23688	31	,	,	,
18637	23688	32	304	304	CD
18637	23688	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23688	34	470	470	CD
18637	23688	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23688	36	1938	1938	CD
18637	23688	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23688	38	,	,	,
18637	23688	39	860	860	CD
18637	23688	40	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	23688	41	.	.	.
18637	23689	1	of	of	IN
18637	23689	2	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	23689	3	of	of	IN
18637	23689	4	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	23689	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23689	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	23689	7	_	_	NNP
18637	23689	8	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23689	9	.	.	.
18637	23690	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23690	2	,	,	,
18637	23690	3	313	313	CD
18637	23690	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23690	5	252	252	CD
18637	23690	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23690	7	1941	1941	CD
18637	23690	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23690	9	,	,	,
18637	23690	10	204	204	CD
18637	23690	11	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	23690	12	.	.	.
18637	23691	1	of	of	IN
18637	23691	2	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	23691	3	of	of	IN
18637	23691	4	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	23691	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23691	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	23691	7	_	_	NNP
18637	23691	8	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	23691	9	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23691	10	,	,	,
18637	23691	11	313	313	CD
18637	23691	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23691	13	62	62	CD
18637	23691	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23691	15	1941	1941	CD
18637	23691	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23691	17	,	,	,
18637	23691	18	198	198	CD
18637	23691	19	,	,	,
18637	23691	20	204	204	CD
18637	23691	21	Des	Des	NNP
18637	23691	22	Moines	Moines	NNP
18637	23691	23	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23691	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23691	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23691	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23691	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23691	28	Des	Des	NNP
18637	23691	29	Moines	Moines	NNP
18637	23691	30	,	,	,
18637	23691	31	238	238	CD
18637	23691	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23691	33	153	153	CD
18637	23691	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23691	35	1915	1915	CD
18637	23691	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23691	37	,	,	,
18637	23691	38	1002	1002	CD
18637	23691	39	,	,	,
18637	23691	40	1007	1007	CD
18637	23691	41	,	,	,
18637	23691	42	1008	1008	CD
18637	23691	43	Des	Des	NNP
18637	23691	44	Moines	Moines	NNP
18637	23691	45	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23691	46	.	.	.
18637	23692	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23692	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	5	Fairweather	Fairweather	NNP
18637	23692	6	,	,	,
18637	23692	7	263	263	CD
18637	23692	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	9	103	103	CD
18637	23692	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	11	1923	1923	CD
18637	23692	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	13	,	,	,
18637	23692	14	734	734	CD
18637	23692	15	De	De	NNP
18637	23692	16	Treville	Treville	NNP
18637	23692	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	20	Smalls	Smalls	NNP
18637	23692	21	,	,	,
18637	23692	22	98	98	CD
18637	23692	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	24	517	517	CD
18637	23692	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	26	1879	1879	CD
18637	23692	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	28	,	,	,
18637	23692	29	321	321	CD
18637	23692	30	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	23692	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	34	Osborne	Osborne	NNP
18637	23692	35	,	,	,
18637	23692	36	135	135	CD
18637	23692	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	38	492	492	CD
18637	23692	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	40	1890	1890	CD
18637	23692	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	42	,	,	,
18637	23692	43	687	687	CD
18637	23692	44	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	23692	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	48	Parker	Parker	NNP
18637	23692	49	,	,	,
18637	23692	50	181	181	CD
18637	23692	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	52	399	399	CD
18637	23692	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	54	1901	1901	CD
18637	23692	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	56	,	,	,
18637	23692	57	1059	1059	CD
18637	23692	58	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	23692	59	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23692	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	63	United	United	NNP
18637	23692	64	States	States	NNP
18637	23692	65	,	,	,
18637	23692	66	317	317	CD
18637	23692	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	68	329	329	CD
18637	23692	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	70	1943	1943	CD
18637	23692	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	72	,	,	,
18637	23692	73	853	853	CD
18637	23692	74	,	,	,
18637	23692	75	854	854	CD
18637	23692	76	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	23692	77	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23692	78	Company	Company	NNP
18637	23692	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	82	The	the	DT
18637	23692	83	"	"	``
18637	23692	84	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	23692	85	Barlum	Barlum	NNP
18637	23692	86	,	,	,
18637	23692	87	"	"	''
18637	23692	88	293	293	CD
18637	23692	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	90	21	21	CD
18637	23692	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	92	1934	1934	CD
18637	23692	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	94	,	,	,
18637	23692	95	311	311	CD
18637	23692	96	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	23692	97	United	United	NNP
18637	23692	98	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	23692	99	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23692	100	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	103	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	23692	104	,	,	,
18637	23692	105	255	255	CD
18637	23692	106	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	107	171	171	CD
18637	23692	108	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	109	1921	1921	CD
18637	23692	110	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	111	,	,	,
18637	23692	112	1009	1009	CD
18637	23692	113	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	23692	114	United	United	NNP
18637	23692	115	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	23692	116	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23692	117	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	118	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	119	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	120	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	23692	121	,	,	,
18637	23692	122	242	242	CD
18637	23692	123	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	124	238	238	CD
18637	23692	125	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	126	1916	1916	CD
18637	23692	127	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	128	,	,	,
18637	23692	129	329	329	CD
18637	23692	130	Dewey	Dewey	NNP
18637	23692	131	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	132	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	133	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	134	Des	Des	NNP
18637	23692	135	Moines	Moines	NNP
18637	23692	136	,	,	,
18637	23692	137	173	173	CD
18637	23692	138	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	139	193	193	CD
18637	23692	140	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	141	1899	1899	CD
18637	23692	142	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	143	,	,	,
18637	23692	144	1062	1062	CD
18637	23692	145	,	,	,
18637	23692	146	1080	1080	CD
18637	23692	147	Dewing	Dewing	NNP
18637	23692	148	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	149	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	150	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	151	Perdicaries	Perdicaries	NNP
18637	23692	152	,	,	,
18637	23692	153	96	96	CD
18637	23692	154	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	155	193	193	CD
18637	23692	156	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	157	1878	1878	CD
18637	23692	158	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	159	,	,	,
18637	23692	160	728	728	CD
18637	23692	161	Diamond	Diamond	NNP
18637	23692	162	Glue	Glue	NNP
18637	23692	163	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23692	164	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	165	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	166	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	167	United	United	NNP
18637	23692	168	States	States	NNP
18637	23692	169	Glue	Glue	NNP
18637	23692	170	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23692	171	,	,	,
18637	23692	172	187	187	CD
18637	23692	173	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	174	611	611	CD
18637	23692	175	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	176	1903	1903	CD
18637	23692	177	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	178	,	,	,
18637	23692	179	120	120	CD
18637	23692	180	Diamond	Diamond	NNP
18637	23692	181	Match	Match	NNP
18637	23692	182	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23692	183	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	184	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	185	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	186	Ontonagon	Ontonagon	NNP
18637	23692	187	,	,	,
18637	23692	188	188	188	CD
18637	23692	189	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	190	82	82	CD
18637	23692	191	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	192	1903	1903	CD
18637	23692	193	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	194	,	,	,
18637	23692	195	181	181	CD
18637	23692	196	Diamond	Diamond	NNP
18637	23692	197	Rubber	Rubber	NNP
18637	23692	198	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23692	199	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	200	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	201	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	202	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	23692	203	Tire	Tire	NNP
18637	23692	204	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23692	205	,	,	,
18637	23692	206	220	220	CD
18637	23692	207	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	208	428	428	CD
18637	23692	209	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	210	1911	1911	CD
18637	23692	211	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	212	,	,	,
18637	23692	213	272	272	CD
18637	23692	214	Dick	Dick	NNP
18637	23692	215	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	216	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	217	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	218	United	United	NNP
18637	23692	219	States	States	NNP
18637	23692	220	,	,	,
18637	23692	221	208	208	CD
18637	23692	222	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	223	340	340	CD
18637	23692	224	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	225	1908	1908	CD
18637	23692	226	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	227	,	,	,
18637	23692	228	253	253	CD
18637	23692	229	,	,	,
18637	23692	230	432	432	CD
18637	23692	231	,	,	,
18637	23692	232	699	699	CD
18637	23692	233	Dier	Dier	NNP
18637	23692	234	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	235	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	236	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	237	Banton	Banton	NNP
18637	23692	238	,	,	,
18637	23692	239	262	262	CD
18637	23692	240	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	241	147	147	CD
18637	23692	242	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	243	1923	1923	CD
18637	23692	244	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	245	,	,	,
18637	23692	246	843	843	CD
18637	23692	247	Dietzsch	Dietzsch	NNP
18637	23692	248	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	249	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	250	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	251	Huidekoper	Huidekoper	NNP
18637	23692	252	,	,	,
18637	23692	253	103	103	CD
18637	23692	254	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23692	255	494	494	CD
18637	23692	256	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23692	257	1881	1881	CD
18637	23692	258	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23692	259	,	,	,
18637	23692	260	629	629	CD
18637	23692	261	Diggs	Diggs	NNP
18637	23692	262	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	263	v.	v.	IN
18637	23692	264	_	_	NNP
18637	23692	265	Wolcott	Wolcott	NNP
18637	23692	266	,	,	,
18637	23692	267	4	4	CD
18637	23692	268	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23692	269	.	.	.
18637	23693	1	179	179	CD
18637	23693	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23693	3	1807	1807	CD
18637	23693	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23693	5	,	,	,
18637	23693	6	628	628	CD
18637	23693	7	Dillon	Dillon	NNP
18637	23693	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23693	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	11	Gloss	Gloss	NNP
18637	23693	12	,	,	,
18637	23693	13	256	256	CD
18637	23693	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23693	15	368	368	CD
18637	23693	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23693	17	1921	1921	CD
18637	23693	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23693	19	,	,	,
18637	23693	20	39	39	CD
18637	23693	21	,	,	,
18637	23693	22	712	712	CD
18637	23693	23	,	,	,
18637	23693	24	713	713	CD
18637	23693	25	,	,	,
18637	23693	26	714	714	CD
18637	23693	27	Dimick	Dimick	NNP
18637	23693	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23693	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	31	Schiedt	Schiedt	NNP
18637	23693	32	,	,	,
18637	23693	33	293	293	CD
18637	23693	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23693	35	474	474	CD
18637	23693	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23693	37	1935	1935	CD
18637	23693	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23693	39	,	,	,
18637	23693	40	892	892	CD
18637	23693	41	,	,	,
18637	23693	42	896	896	CD
18637	23693	43	Di	Di	NNP
18637	23693	44	Santo	Santo	NNP
18637	23693	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	23693	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	48	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	23693	49	,	,	,
18637	23693	50	273	273	CD
18637	23693	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23693	52	34	34	CD
18637	23693	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23693	54	1927	1927	CD
18637	23693	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23693	56	,	,	,
18637	23693	57	196	196	CD
18637	23693	58	,	,	,
18637	23693	59	219	219	CD
18637	23693	60	,	,	,
18637	23693	61	228	228	CD
18637	23693	62	District	District	NNP
18637	23693	63	of	of	IN
18637	23693	64	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23693	65	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	23693	67	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	68	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	23693	69	,	,	,
18637	23693	70	171	171	CD
18637	23693	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23693	72	161	161	CD
18637	23693	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23693	74	1898	1898	CD
18637	23693	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23693	76	,	,	,
18637	23693	77	301	301	CD
18637	23693	78	,	,	,
18637	23693	79	854	854	CD
18637	23693	80	District	District	NNP
18637	23693	81	of	of	IN
18637	23693	82	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23693	83	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	23693	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	86	Brooke	Brooke	NNP
18637	23693	87	,	,	,
18637	23693	88	214	214	CD
18637	23693	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23693	90	138	138	CD
18637	23693	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23693	92	1909	1909	CD
18637	23693	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23693	94	,	,	,
18637	23693	95	854	854	CD
18637	23693	96	District	District	NNP
18637	23693	97	of	of	IN
18637	23693	98	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23693	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	23693	101	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	102	Clawans	Clawans	NNP
18637	23693	103	,	,	,
18637	23693	104	300	300	CD
18637	23693	105	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23693	106	617	617	CD
18637	23693	107	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23693	108	1937	1937	CD
18637	23693	109	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23693	110	,	,	,
18637	23693	111	878	878	CD
18637	23693	112	District	District	NNP
18637	23693	113	of	of	IN
18637	23693	114	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23693	115	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	116	v.	v.	IN
18637	23693	117	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	118	Colts	Colts	NNP
18637	23693	119	,	,	,
18637	23693	120	282	282	CD
18637	23693	121	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23693	122	63	63	CD
18637	23693	123	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23693	124	1930	1930	CD
18637	23693	125	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23693	126	,	,	,
18637	23693	127	878	878	CD
18637	23693	128	Dixie	Dixie	NNP
18637	23693	129	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	23693	130	Express	Express	NNP
18637	23693	131	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23693	132	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	133	v.	v.	IN
18637	23693	134	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	135	State	State	NNP
18637	23693	136	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	23693	137	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23693	138	,	,	,
18637	23693	139	306	306	CD
18637	23693	140	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23693	141	72	72	CD
18637	23693	142	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23693	143	1939	1939	CD
18637	23693	144	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23693	145	,	,	,
18637	23693	146	212	212	CD
18637	23693	147	Dobbins	Dobbins	NNPS
18637	23693	148	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	149	v.	v.	IN
18637	23693	150	_	_	NNP
18637	23693	151	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	23693	152	County	County	NNP
18637	23693	153	,	,	,
18637	23693	154	16	16	CD
18637	23693	155	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23693	156	.	.	.
18637	23694	1	435	435	CD
18637	23694	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23694	3	1842	1842	CD
18637	23694	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23694	5	,	,	,
18637	23694	6	731	731	CD
18637	23694	7	Dobbins	Dobbins	NNPS
18637	23694	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23694	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23694	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23694	11	Los	Los	NNP
18637	23694	12	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	23694	13	,	,	,
18637	23694	14	195	195	CD
18637	23694	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23694	16	223	223	CD
18637	23694	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23694	18	1904	1904	CD
18637	23694	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23694	20	,	,	,
18637	23694	21	1028	1028	CD
18637	23694	22	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	23694	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23694	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23694	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23694	26	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23694	27	of	of	IN
18637	23694	28	Education	Education	NNP
18637	23694	29	of	of	IN
18637	23694	30	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23694	31	,	,	,
18637	23694	32	302	302	CD
18637	23694	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23694	34	74	74	CD
18637	23694	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23694	36	1937	1937	CD
18637	23694	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23694	38	,	,	,
18637	23694	39	340	340	CD
18637	23694	40	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	23694	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23694	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	23694	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23694	44	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	23694	45	,	,	,
18637	23694	46	240	240	CD
18637	23694	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23694	48	122	122	CD
18637	23694	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23694	50	1916	1916	CD
18637	23694	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23694	52	,	,	,
18637	23694	53	621	621	CD
18637	23694	54	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	23694	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23694	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	23694	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23694	58	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	23694	59	,	,	,
18637	23694	60	240	240	CD
18637	23694	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23694	62	118	118	CD
18637	23694	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23694	64	1916	1916	CD
18637	23694	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23694	66	,	,	,
18637	23694	67	621	621	CD
18637	23694	68	,	,	,
18637	23694	69	858	858	CD
18637	23694	70	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	23694	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23694	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	23694	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23694	74	Woolsey	Woolsey	NNP
18637	23694	75	,	,	,
18637	23694	76	18	18	CD
18637	23694	77	How	how	WRB
18637	23694	78	.	.	.
18637	23695	1	331	331	CD
18637	23695	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23695	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	23695	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23695	5	,	,	,
18637	23695	6	329	329	CD
18637	23695	7	,	,	,
18637	23695	8	541	541	CD
18637	23695	9	,	,	,
18637	23695	10	602	602	CD
18637	23695	11	Doe	Doe	NNP
18637	23695	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23695	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23695	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23695	15	Braden	Braden	NNP
18637	23695	16	,	,	,
18637	23695	17	16	16	CD
18637	23695	18	How	how	WRB
18637	23695	19	.	.	.
18637	23696	1	636	636	CD
18637	23696	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23696	3	1853	1853	CD
18637	23696	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23696	5	,	,	,
18637	23696	6	473	473	CD
18637	23696	7	Doe	Doe	NNP
18637	23696	8	ex	ex	FW
18637	23696	9	dem	dem	NN
18637	23696	10	.	.	.
18637	23697	1	Governeur	Governeur	NNP
18637	23697	2	's	's	POS
18637	23697	3	Heirs	Heirs	NNPS
18637	23697	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23697	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	23697	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23697	7	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	23697	8	,	,	,
18637	23697	9	11	11	CD
18637	23697	10	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23697	11	.	.	.
18637	23698	1	332	332	CD
18637	23698	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23698	3	1826	1826	CD
18637	23698	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23698	5	,	,	,
18637	23698	6	258	258	CD
18637	23698	7	Dohany	Dohany	NNP
18637	23698	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23698	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	11	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	23698	12	,	,	,
18637	23698	13	281	281	CD
18637	23698	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23698	15	362	362	CD
18637	23698	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23698	17	1930	1930	CD
18637	23698	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23698	19	,	,	,
18637	23698	20	1065	1065	CD
18637	23698	21	,	,	,
18637	23698	22	1067	1067	CD
18637	23698	23	,	,	,
18637	23698	24	1166	1166	CD
18637	23698	25	Doherty	Doherty	NNP
18637	23698	26	&	&	CC
18637	23698	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23698	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23698	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	31	Goodman	Goodman	NNP
18637	23698	32	,	,	,
18637	23698	33	294	294	CD
18637	23698	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23698	35	623	623	CD
18637	23698	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23698	37	1935	1935	CD
18637	23698	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23698	39	,	,	,
18637	23698	40	691	691	CD
18637	23698	41	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	23698	42	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	23698	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	23698	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	46	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	23698	47	,	,	,
18637	23698	48	249	249	CD
18637	23698	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23698	50	265	265	CD
18637	23698	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23698	52	1919	1919	CD
18637	23698	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23698	54	,	,	,
18637	23698	55	1146	1146	CD
18637	23698	56	,	,	,
18637	23698	57	1159	1159	CD
18637	23698	58	Donald	Donald	NNP
18637	23698	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23698	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	62	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	23698	63	&	&	CC
18637	23698	64	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23698	65	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	23698	66	&	&	CC
18637	23698	67	I.	I.	NNP
18637	23698	68	Co	Co	NNP
18637	23698	69	,	,	,
18637	23698	70	241	241	CD
18637	23698	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23698	72	329	329	CD
18637	23698	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23698	74	1916	1916	CD
18637	23698	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23698	76	,	,	,
18637	23698	77	638	638	CD
18637	23698	78	Donaldson	Donaldson	NNP
18637	23698	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	23698	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	82	Read	Read	NNP
18637	23698	83	Magazine	Magazine	NNP
18637	23698	84	,	,	,
18637	23698	85	333	333	CD
18637	23698	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23698	87	178	178	CD
18637	23698	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23698	89	1948	1948	CD
18637	23698	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23698	91	,	,	,
18637	23698	92	269	269	CD
18637	23698	93	,	,	,
18637	23698	94	805	805	CD
18637	23698	95	,	,	,
18637	23698	96	859	859	CD
18637	23698	97	,	,	,
18637	23698	98	905	905	CD
18637	23698	99	Dooley	Dooley	NNP
18637	23698	100	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	23698	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	103	United	United	NNP
18637	23698	104	States	States	NNP
18637	23698	105	,	,	,
18637	23698	106	182	182	CD
18637	23698	107	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23698	108	222	222	CD
18637	23698	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23698	110	1901	1901	CD
18637	23698	111	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23698	112	,	,	,
18637	23698	113	404	404	CD
18637	23698	114	Dooley	Dooley	NNP
18637	23698	115	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	116	v.	v.	IN
18637	23698	117	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	118	United	United	NNP
18637	23698	119	States	States	NNP
18637	23698	120	,	,	,
18637	23698	121	183	183	CD
18637	23698	122	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23698	123	151	151	CD
18637	23698	124	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23698	125	1901	1901	CD
18637	23698	126	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23698	127	,	,	,
18637	23698	128	321	321	CD
18637	23698	129	Dorchy	Dorchy	NNP
18637	23698	130	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	131	v.	v.	IN
18637	23698	132	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	133	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23698	134	,	,	,
18637	23698	135	264	264	CD
18637	23698	136	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23698	137	286	286	CD
18637	23698	138	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23698	139	1924	1924	CD
18637	23698	140	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23698	141	,	,	,
18637	23698	142	992	992	CD
18637	23698	143	Doremus	Doremus	NNP
18637	23698	144	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	145	v.	v.	IN
18637	23698	146	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	147	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23698	148	of	of	IN
18637	23698	149	Education	Education	NNP
18637	23698	150	,	,	,
18637	23698	151	342	342	CD
18637	23698	152	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23698	153	429	429	CD
18637	23698	154	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23698	155	1952	1952	CD
18637	23698	156	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23698	157	,	,	,
18637	23698	158	542	542	CD
18637	23698	159	,	,	,
18637	23698	160	763	763	CD
18637	23698	161	Dorr	Dorr	NNP
18637	23698	162	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	163	v.	v.	IN
18637	23698	164	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	165	United	United	NNP
18637	23698	166	States	States	NNP
18637	23698	167	,	,	,
18637	23698	168	195	195	CD
18637	23698	169	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23698	170	138	138	CD
18637	23698	171	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23698	172	1904	1904	CD
18637	23698	173	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23698	174	,	,	,
18637	23698	175	703	703	CD
18637	23698	176	Doty	Doty	NNP
18637	23698	177	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	178	v.	v.	IN
18637	23698	179	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	180	Love	Love	NNP
18637	23698	181	,	,	,
18637	23698	182	295	295	CD
18637	23698	183	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23698	184	64	64	CD
18637	23698	185	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23698	186	1935	1935	CD
18637	23698	187	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23698	188	,	,	,
18637	23698	189	1020	1020	CD
18637	23698	190	Double	double	JJ
18637	23698	191	-	-	HYPH
18637	23698	192	Pointed	Pointed	NNP
18637	23698	193	Tack	Tack	NNP
18637	23698	194	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23698	195	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	196	v.	v.	IN
18637	23698	197	_	_	NNP
18637	23698	198	Two	Two	NNP
18637	23698	199	Rivers	Rivers	NNPS
18637	23698	200	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23698	201	.	.	.
18637	23699	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23699	2	,	,	,
18637	23699	3	109	109	CD
18637	23699	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23699	5	117	117	CD
18637	23699	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23699	7	1883	1883	CD
18637	23699	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23699	9	,	,	,
18637	23699	10	273	273	CD
18637	23699	11	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	23699	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23699	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23699	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23699	15	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23699	16	,	,	,
18637	23699	17	168	168	CD
18637	23699	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23699	19	488	488	CD
18637	23699	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23699	21	1897	1897	CD
18637	23699	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23699	23	,	,	,
18637	23699	24	1031	1031	CD
18637	23699	25	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	23699	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23699	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23699	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23699	29	New	New	NNP
18637	23699	30	York	York	NNP
18637	23699	31	,	,	,
18637	23699	32	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	23699	33	&	&	CC
18637	23699	34	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	23700	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23700	2	,	,	,
18637	23700	3	279	279	CD
18637	23700	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23700	5	377	377	CD
18637	23700	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23700	7	1929	1929	CD
18637	23700	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23700	9	,	,	,
18637	23700	10	687	687	CD
18637	23700	11	,	,	,
18637	23700	12	692	692	CD
18637	23700	13	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
18637	23700	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23700	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23700	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23700	17	Noble	Noble	NNP
18637	23700	18	,	,	,
18637	23700	19	261	261	CD
18637	23700	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23700	21	165	165	CD
18637	23700	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23700	23	1923	1923	CD
18637	23700	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23700	25	,	,	,
18637	23700	26	1024	1024	CD
18637	23700	27	Dow	Dow	NNP
18637	23700	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23700	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23700	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23700	31	Beidelman	Beidelman	NNP
18637	23700	32	,	,	,
18637	23700	33	125	125	CD
18637	23700	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23700	35	680	680	CD
18637	23700	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23700	37	1888	1888	CD
18637	23700	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23700	39	,	,	,
18637	23700	40	999	999	CD
18637	23700	41	Dow	Dow	NNP
18637	23700	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23700	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23700	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23700	45	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23700	46	,	,	,
18637	23700	47	100	100	CD
18637	23700	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23700	49	158	158	CD
18637	23700	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23700	51	1880	1880	CD
18637	23700	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23700	53	,	,	,
18637	23700	54	294	294	CD
18637	23700	55	Dow	Dow	NNP
18637	23700	56	Chemical	Chemical	NNP
18637	23700	57	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23700	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23700	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	23700	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23700	61	Halliburton	Halliburton	NNP
18637	23700	62	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23700	63	,	,	,
18637	23700	64	324	324	CD
18637	23700	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23700	66	320	320	CD
18637	23700	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23700	68	1945	1945	CD
18637	23700	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23700	70	,	,	,
18637	23700	71	272	272	CD
18637	23700	72	Dowling	Dowling	NNP
18637	23700	73	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	23700	74	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	23700	75	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23700	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23700	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	23700	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23700	79	United	United	NNP
18637	23700	80	States	States	NNP
18637	23700	81	,	,	,
18637	23700	82	153	153	CD
18637	23700	83	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23700	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23700	85	2d	2d	CD
18637	23700	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23700	87	353	353	CD
18637	23700	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23700	89	1946	1946	CD
18637	23700	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23700	91	,	,	,
18637	23700	92	1234	1234	CD
18637	23700	93	Downes	Downes	NNPS
18637	23700	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23700	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	23700	96	_	_	NNP
18637	23700	97	Bidwell	Bidwell	NNP
18637	23700	98	,	,	,
18637	23700	99	182	182	CD
18637	23700	100	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23700	101	244	244	CD
18637	23700	102	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23700	103	1901	1901	CD
18637	23700	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23700	105	,	,	,
18637	23700	106	60	60	CD
18637	23700	107	,	,	,
18637	23700	108	110	110	CD
18637	23700	109	,	,	,
18637	23700	110	430	430	CD
18637	23700	111	,	,	,
18637	23700	112	703	703	CD
18637	23700	113	Downham	Downham	NNP
18637	23700	114	_	_	NNP
18637	23700	115	v.	v.	IN
18637	23700	116	_	_	NNP
18637	23700	117	Alexandria	Alexandria	NNP
18637	23700	118	,	,	,
18637	23700	119	10	10	CD
18637	23700	120	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23700	121	.	.	.
18637	23701	1	173	173	CD
18637	23701	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23701	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	23701	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23701	5	,	,	,
18637	23701	6	693	693	CD
18637	23701	7	Doyle	Doyle	NNP
18637	23701	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23701	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23701	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23701	11	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	23701	12	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23701	13	.	.	.
18637	23702	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23702	2	,	,	,
18637	23702	3	94	94	CD
18637	23702	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23702	5	535	535	CD
18637	23702	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23702	7	1877	1877	CD
18637	23702	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23702	9	,	,	,
18637	23702	10	638	638	CD
18637	23702	11	Doyle	Doyle	NNP
18637	23702	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23702	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23702	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23702	15	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	23702	16	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	23702	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23702	18	,	,	,
18637	23702	19	247	247	CD
18637	23702	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23702	21	179	179	CD
18637	23702	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23702	23	1918	1918	CD
18637	23702	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23702	25	,	,	,
18637	23702	26	1192	1192	CD
18637	23702	27	Dozier	Dozier	NNP
18637	23702	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23702	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23702	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23702	31	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	23702	32	,	,	,
18637	23702	33	218	218	CD
18637	23702	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23702	35	124	124	CD
18637	23702	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23702	37	1910	1910	CD
18637	23702	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23702	39	,	,	,
18637	23702	40	187	187	CD
18637	23702	41	Draper	Draper	NNP
18637	23702	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23702	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23702	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23702	45	United	United	NNP
18637	23702	46	States	States	NNP
18637	23702	47	,	,	,
18637	23702	48	164	164	CD
18637	23702	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23702	50	240	240	CD
18637	23702	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23702	52	1896	1896	CD
18637	23702	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23702	54	,	,	,
18637	23702	55	699	699	CD
18637	23702	56	Dred	Dred	NNP
18637	23702	57	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	23702	58	Case	Case	NNP
18637	23702	59	:	:	:
18637	23702	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23702	61	See	See	NNP
18637	23702	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23702	63	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	23702	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23702	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	23702	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23702	67	Sandford	Sandford	NNP
18637	23702	68	.	.	.
18637	23703	1	Drew	Drew	NNP
18637	23703	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23703	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23703	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23703	5	Thaw	Thaw	NNP
18637	23703	6	,	,	,
18637	23703	7	235	235	CD
18637	23703	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23703	9	432	432	CD
18637	23703	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23703	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	23703	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23703	13	,	,	,
18637	23703	14	695	695	CD
18637	23703	15	Dreyer	Dreyer	NNP
18637	23703	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23703	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23703	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23703	19	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23703	20	,	,	,
18637	23703	21	187	187	CD
18637	23703	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23703	23	71	71	CD
18637	23703	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23703	25	1902	1902	CD
18637	23703	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23703	27	,	,	,
18637	23703	28	1071	1071	CD
18637	23703	29	,	,	,
18637	23703	30	1135	1135	CD
18637	23703	31	Driscoll	Driscoll	NNP
18637	23703	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23703	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23703	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23703	35	Edison	Edison	NNP
18637	23703	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23703	37	,	,	,
18637	23703	38	307	307	CD
18637	23703	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23703	40	104	104	CD
18637	23703	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23703	42	1939	1939	CD
18637	23703	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23703	44	,	,	,
18637	23703	45	1005	1005	CD
18637	23703	46	Drivers	Drivers	NNPS
18637	23703	47	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23703	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23703	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	23703	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23703	51	Meadowmoor	Meadowmoor	NNP
18637	23703	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23703	53	,	,	,
18637	23703	54	312	312	CD
18637	23703	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23703	56	287	287	CD
18637	23703	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23703	58	1941	1941	CD
18637	23703	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23703	60	,	,	,
18637	23703	61	781	781	CD
18637	23703	62	,	,	,
18637	23703	63	787	787	CD
18637	23703	64	Dubuque	Dubuque	NNP
18637	23703	65	&	&	CC
18637	23703	66	S.C.R.	S.C.R.	NNP
18637	23704	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23704	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23704	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23704	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23704	5	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	23704	6	,	,	,
18637	23704	7	19	19	CD
18637	23704	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23704	9	.	.	.
18637	23705	1	584	584	CD
18637	23705	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23705	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	23705	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23705	5	,	,	,
18637	23705	6	362	362	CD
18637	23705	7	Duckworth	Duckworth	NNP
18637	23705	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23705	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23705	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23705	11	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	23705	12	,	,	,
18637	23705	13	314	314	CD
18637	23705	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23705	15	390	390	CD
18637	23705	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23705	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	23705	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23705	19	,	,	,
18637	23705	20	218	218	CD
18637	23705	21	,	,	,
18637	23705	22	241	241	CD
18637	23705	23	,	,	,
18637	23705	24	1233	1233	CD
18637	23705	25	Dugan	Dugan	NNP
18637	23705	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23705	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23705	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23705	29	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	23705	30	,	,	,
18637	23705	31	277	277	CD
18637	23705	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23705	33	61	61	CD
18637	23705	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23705	35	1928	1928	CD
18637	23705	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23705	37	,	,	,
18637	23705	38	1131	1131	CD
18637	23705	39	Dugan	Dugan	NNP
18637	23705	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23705	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23705	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23705	43	United	United	NNP
18637	23705	44	States	States	NNP
18637	23705	45	,	,	,
18637	23705	46	3	3	CD
18637	23705	47	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23705	48	.	.	.
18637	23706	1	172	172	CD
18637	23706	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23706	3	1818	1818	CD
18637	23706	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23706	5	,	,	,
18637	23706	6	584	584	CD
18637	23706	7	Duhne	Duhne	NNP
18637	23706	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23706	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23706	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23706	11	New	New	NNP
18637	23706	12	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	23706	13	,	,	,
18637	23706	14	251	251	CD
18637	23706	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23706	16	311	311	CD
18637	23706	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23706	18	1920	1920	CD
18637	23706	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23706	20	,	,	,
18637	23706	21	930	930	CD
18637	23706	22	Duignan	Duignan	NNP
18637	23706	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23706	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23706	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23706	26	United	United	NNP
18637	23706	27	States	States	NNP
18637	23706	28	,	,	,
18637	23706	29	274	274	CD
18637	23706	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23706	31	195	195	CD
18637	23706	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23706	33	1927	1927	CD
18637	23706	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23706	35	,	,	,
18637	23706	36	897	897	CD
18637	23706	37	Duke	Duke	NNP
18637	23706	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23706	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23706	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23706	41	United	United	NNP
18637	23706	42	States	States	NNP
18637	23706	43	,	,	,
18637	23706	44	301	301	CD
18637	23706	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23706	46	492	492	CD
18637	23706	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23706	48	1937	1937	CD
18637	23706	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23706	50	,	,	,
18637	23706	51	838	838	CD
18637	23706	52	Dumbra	Dumbra	NNP
18637	23706	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23706	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	23706	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23706	56	United	United	NNP
18637	23706	57	States	States	NNP
18637	23706	58	,	,	,
18637	23706	59	268	268	CD
18637	23706	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23706	61	435	435	CD
18637	23706	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23706	63	1925	1925	CD
18637	23706	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23706	65	,	,	,
18637	23706	66	825	825	CD
18637	23706	67	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	23706	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23706	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	23706	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23706	71	Darst	Darst	NNP
18637	23706	72	,	,	,
18637	23706	73	1	1	CD
18637	23706	74	How	how	WRB
18637	23706	75	.	.	.
18637	23707	1	301	301	CD
18637	23707	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23707	3	1843	1843	CD
18637	23707	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23707	5	,	,	,
18637	23707	6	627	627	CD
18637	23707	7	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	23707	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23707	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23707	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23707	11	Kahanamoku	Kahanamoku	NNP
18637	23707	12	,	,	,
18637	23707	13	324	324	CD
18637	23707	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23707	15	833	833	CD
18637	23707	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23707	17	1945	1945	CD
18637	23707	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23707	19	,	,	,
18637	23707	20	401	401	CD
18637	23707	21	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	23707	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23707	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23707	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23707	25	Kahanamoku	Kahanamoku	NNP
18637	23707	26	,	,	,
18637	23707	27	327	327	CD
18637	23707	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23707	29	304	304	CD
18637	23707	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23707	31	1946	1946	CD
18637	23707	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23707	33	,	,	,
18637	23707	34	294	294	CD
18637	23707	35	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	23707	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23707	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23707	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23707	39	McCall	McCall	NNP
18637	23707	40	,	,	,
18637	23707	41	139	139	CD
18637	23707	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23707	43	449	449	CD
18637	23707	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23707	45	1891	1891	CD
18637	23707	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23707	47	,	,	,
18637	23707	48	634	634	CD
18637	23707	49	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	23707	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23707	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	23707	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23707	53	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	23707	54	,	,	,
18637	23707	55	152	152	CD
18637	23707	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23707	57	377	377	CD
18637	23707	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23707	59	1894	1894	CD
18637	23707	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23707	61	,	,	,
18637	23707	62	329	329	CD
18637	23707	63	,	,	,
18637	23707	64	1166	1166	CD
18637	23707	65	Dunham	Dunham	NNP
18637	23707	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23707	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23707	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23707	69	Dennison	Dennison	NNP
18637	23707	70	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23707	71	.	.	.
18637	23708	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23708	2	,	,	,
18637	23708	3	154	154	CD
18637	23708	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23708	5	103	103	CD
18637	23708	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23708	7	1894	1894	CD
18637	23708	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23708	9	,	,	,
18637	23708	10	273	273	CD
18637	23708	11	Duplex	Duplex	NNP
18637	23708	12	Printing	Printing	NNP
18637	23708	13	Press	Press	NNP
18637	23708	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23708	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23708	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	23708	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23708	18	Deering	Deering	NNP
18637	23708	19	,	,	,
18637	23708	20	254	254	CD
18637	23708	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23708	22	443	443	CD
18637	23708	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23708	24	1921	1921	CD
18637	23708	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23708	26	,	,	,
18637	23708	27	149	149	CD
18637	23708	28	,	,	,
18637	23708	29	524	524	CD
18637	23708	30	Durand	Durand	NNP
18637	23708	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23708	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	23708	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23708	34	Hollins	Hollins	NNP
18637	23708	35	,	,	,
18637	23708	36	4	4	CD
18637	23708	37	Blatch	Blatch	NNP
18637	23708	38	.	.	.
18637	23709	1	451	451	CD
18637	23709	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23709	3	1860	1860	CD
18637	23709	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23709	5	,	,	,
18637	23709	6	487	487	CD
18637	23709	7	Durousseau	Durousseau	NNP
18637	23709	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23709	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23709	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23709	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23709	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23709	13	,	,	,
18637	23709	14	6	6	CD
18637	23709	15	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23709	16	.	.	.
18637	23710	1	307	307	CD
18637	23710	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23710	3	1810	1810	CD
18637	23710	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23710	5	,	,	,
18637	23710	6	614	614	CD
18637	23710	7	Dynes	Dynes	NNPS
18637	23710	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23710	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23710	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23710	11	Hoover	Hoover	NNP
18637	23710	12	,	,	,
18637	23710	13	20	20	CD
18637	23710	14	How	how	WRB
18637	23710	15	.	.	.
18637	23711	1	65	65	CD
18637	23711	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23711	3	1858	1858	CD
18637	23711	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23711	5	,	,	,
18637	23711	6	286	286	CD
18637	23711	7	E	E	NNP
18637	23711	8	East	East	NNP
18637	23711	9	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	23711	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23711	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23711	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23711	13	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	23711	14	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	23711	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23711	16	,	,	,
18637	23711	17	10	10	CD
18637	23711	18	How	how	WRB
18637	23711	19	.	.	.
18637	23712	1	511	511	CD
18637	23712	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23712	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	23712	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23712	5	,	,	,
18637	23712	6	340	340	CD
18637	23712	7	East	East	NNP
18637	23712	8	New	New	NNP
18637	23712	9	York	York	NNP
18637	23712	10	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	23712	11	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23712	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23712	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23712	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23712	15	Hahn	Hahn	NNP
18637	23712	16	,	,	,
18637	23712	17	326	326	CD
18637	23712	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23712	19	230	230	CD
18637	23712	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23712	21	1945	1945	CD
18637	23712	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23712	23	,	,	,
18637	23712	24	361	361	CD
18637	23712	25	East	East	NNP
18637	23712	26	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	23712	27	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23712	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23712	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23712	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	23712	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23712	32	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23712	33	Com	Com	NNP
18637	23712	34	.	.	.
18637	23713	1	of	of	IN
18637	23713	2	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	23713	3	,	,	,
18637	23713	4	283	283	CD
18637	23713	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23713	6	465	465	CD
18637	23713	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23713	8	1931	1931	CD
18637	23713	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23713	10	,	,	,
18637	23713	11	195	195	CD
18637	23713	12	,	,	,
18637	23713	13	234	234	CD
18637	23713	14	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	23713	15	Air	Air	NNP
18637	23713	16	Transport	Transport	NNP
18637	23713	17	,	,	,
18637	23713	18	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	23713	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23713	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	23713	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23713	22	South	South	NNP
18637	23713	23	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	23713	24	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23713	25	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	23713	26	.	.	NNP
18637	23713	27	,	,	,
18637	23713	28	285	285	CD
18637	23713	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23713	30	147	147	CD
18637	23713	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23713	32	1932	1932	CD
18637	23713	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23713	34	,	,	,
18637	23713	35	184	184	CD
18637	23713	36	,	,	,
18637	23713	37	186	186	CD
18637	23713	38	Easton	Easton	NNP
18637	23713	39	,	,	,
18637	23713	40	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23713	41	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23713	42	,	,	,
18637	23713	43	95	95	CD
18637	23713	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23713	45	68	68	CD
18637	23713	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23713	47	1877	1877	CD
18637	23713	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23713	49	,	,	,
18637	23713	50	574	574	CD
18637	23713	51	Eberle	Eberle	NNP
18637	23713	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23713	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	23713	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23713	55	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	23713	56	,	,	,
18637	23713	57	232	232	CD
18637	23713	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23713	59	700	700	CD
18637	23713	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23713	61	1914	1914	CD
18637	23713	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23713	63	,	,	,
18637	23713	64	1155	1155	CD
18637	23713	65	Eberly	eberly	RB
18637	23713	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23713	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23713	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23713	69	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	23713	70	,	,	,
18637	23713	71	24	24	CD
18637	23713	72	How	how	WRB
18637	23713	73	.	.	.
18637	23714	1	147	147	CD
18637	23714	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23714	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	23714	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23714	5	,	,	,
18637	23714	6	526	526	CD
18637	23714	7	Economy	Economy	NNP
18637	23714	8	Light	Light	NNP
18637	23714	9	and	and	CC
18637	23714	10	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23714	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23714	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23714	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23714	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23714	15	United	United	NNP
18637	23714	16	States	States	NNP
18637	23714	17	,	,	,
18637	23714	18	256	256	CD
18637	23714	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23714	20	113	113	CD
18637	23714	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23714	22	1921	1921	CD
18637	23714	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23714	24	,	,	,
18637	23714	25	128	128	CD
18637	23714	26	,	,	,
18637	23714	27	230	230	CD
18637	23714	28	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
18637	23714	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23714	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	23714	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23714	32	Boeing	Boeing	NNP
18637	23714	33	Air	Air	NNP
18637	23714	34	Transport	Transport	NNP
18637	23714	35	,	,	,
18637	23714	36	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	23714	37	,	,	,
18637	23714	38	289	289	CD
18637	23714	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23714	40	249	249	CD
18637	23714	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23714	42	1933	1933	CD
18637	23714	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23714	44	,	,	,
18637	23714	45	186	186	CD
18637	23714	46	Educational	Educational	NNP
18637	23714	47	Films	Films	NNPS
18637	23714	48	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23714	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23714	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	23714	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23714	52	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	23714	53	,	,	,
18637	23714	54	282	282	CD
18637	23714	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23714	56	379	379	CD
18637	23714	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23714	58	1931	1931	CD
18637	23714	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23714	60	,	,	,
18637	23714	61	734	734	CD
18637	23714	62	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	23714	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23714	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	23714	65	_	_	NNP
18637	23714	66	California	California	NNP
18637	23714	67	,	,	,
18637	23714	68	314	314	CD
18637	23714	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23714	70	160	160	CD
18637	23714	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23714	72	1941	1941	CD
18637	23714	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23714	74	,	,	,
18637	23714	75	120	120	CD
18637	23714	76	,	,	,
18637	23714	77	192	192	CD
18637	23714	78	,	,	,
18637	23714	79	218	218	CD
18637	23714	80	,	,	,
18637	23714	81	242	242	CD
18637	23714	82	,	,	,
18637	23714	83	968	968	CD
18637	23714	84	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	23714	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23714	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	23714	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23714	88	Cuba	Cuba	NNP
18637	23714	89	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	23714	90	,	,	,
18637	23714	91	268	268	CD
18637	23714	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23714	93	628	628	CD
18637	23714	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23714	95	1925	1925	CD
18637	23714	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23714	97	,	,	,
18637	23714	98	1197	1197	CD
18637	23714	99	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	23714	100	_	_	NNP
18637	23714	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	23714	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23714	103	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	23714	104	,	,	,
18637	23714	105	21	21	CD
18637	23714	106	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23714	107	.	.	.
18637	23715	1	532	532	CD
18637	23715	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23715	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	23715	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23715	5	,	,	,
18637	23715	6	892	892	CD
18637	23715	7	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	23715	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23715	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23715	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23715	11	Kearzey	Kearzey	NNP
18637	23715	12	,	,	,
18637	23715	13	96	96	CD
18637	23715	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23715	15	595	595	CD
18637	23715	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23715	17	1878	1878	CD
18637	23715	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23715	19	,	,	,
18637	23715	20	360	360	CD
18637	23715	21	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	23715	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23715	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23715	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23715	25	United	United	NNP
18637	23715	26	States	States	NNP
18637	23715	27	,	,	,
18637	23715	28	286	286	CD
18637	23715	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23715	30	482	482	CD
18637	23715	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23715	32	1932	1932	CD
18637	23715	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23715	34	,	,	,
18637	23715	35	103	103	CD
18637	23715	36	Edye	Edye	NNP
18637	23715	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23715	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	23715	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23715	40	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	23715	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23715	42	Head	Head	NNP
18637	23715	43	Money	Money	NNP
18637	23715	44	Cases	case	NNS
18637	23715	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23715	46	,	,	,
18637	23715	47	112	112	CD
18637	23715	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23715	49	580	580	CD
18637	23715	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23715	51	1884	1884	CD
18637	23715	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23715	53	,	,	,
18637	23715	54	418	418	CD
18637	23715	55	,	,	,
18637	23715	56	420	420	CD
18637	23715	57	,	,	,
18637	23715	58	431	431	CD
18637	23715	59	Effinger	Effinger	NNP
18637	23715	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23715	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23715	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23715	63	Kenney	Kenney	NNP
18637	23715	64	,	,	,
18637	23715	65	115	115	CD
18637	23715	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23715	67	566	566	CD
18637	23715	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23715	69	1885	1885	CD
18637	23715	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23715	71	,	,	,
18637	23715	72	356	356	CD
18637	23715	73	Eichholz	Eichholz	NNP
18637	23715	74	_	_	NNP
18637	23715	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	23715	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23715	77	Public	Public	NNP
18637	23715	78	Service	Service	NNP
18637	23715	79	Com	Com	NNP
18637	23715	80	.	.	.
18637	23716	1	of	of	IN
18637	23716	2	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	23716	3	,	,	,
18637	23716	4	306	306	CD
18637	23716	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23716	6	268	268	CD
18637	23716	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23716	8	1939	1939	CD
18637	23716	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23716	10	,	,	,
18637	23716	11	227	227	CD
18637	23716	12	Eilenbecker	Eilenbecker	NNP
18637	23716	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23716	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	23716	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23716	16	District	District	NNP
18637	23716	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	23716	18	,	,	,
18637	23716	19	134	134	CD
18637	23716	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23716	21	31	31	CD
18637	23716	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23716	23	1890	1890	CD
18637	23716	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23716	25	,	,	,
18637	23716	26	1096	1096	CD
18637	23716	27	Eisner	Eisner	NNP
18637	23716	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23716	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23716	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23716	31	Macomber	Macomber	NNP
18637	23716	32	,	,	,
18637	23716	33	252	252	CD
18637	23716	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23716	35	189	189	CD
18637	23716	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23716	37	1920	1920	CD
18637	23716	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23716	39	,	,	,
18637	23716	40	1192	1192	CD
18637	23716	41	,	,	,
18637	23716	42	1193	1193	CD
18637	23716	43	,	,	,
18637	23716	44	1194	1194	CD
18637	23716	45	,	,	,
18637	23716	46	1195	1195	CD
18637	23716	47	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	23716	48	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	23716	49	&	&	CC
18637	23716	50	Share	Share	NNP
18637	23716	51	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23716	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23716	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	23716	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23716	55	Securities	Securities	NNP
18637	23716	56	&	&	CC
18637	23716	57	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	23716	58	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23716	59	,	,	,
18637	23716	60	303	303	CD
18637	23716	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23716	62	419	419	CD
18637	23716	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23716	64	1938	1938	CD
18637	23716	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23716	66	,	,	,
18637	23716	67	151	151	CD
18637	23716	68	,	,	,
18637	23716	69	270	270	CD
18637	23716	70	,	,	,
18637	23716	71	550	550	CD
18637	23716	72	,	,	,
18637	23716	73	552	552	CD
18637	23716	74	Elk	Elk	NNP
18637	23716	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23716	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	23716	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23716	78	Wilkins	Wilkins	NNP
18637	23716	79	,	,	,
18637	23716	80	112	112	CD
18637	23716	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23716	82	94	94	CD
18637	23716	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23716	84	1884	1884	CD
18637	23716	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23716	86	,	,	,
18637	23716	87	255	255	CD
18637	23716	88	,	,	,
18637	23716	89	1171	1171	CD
18637	23716	90	Elkison	Elkison	NNP
18637	23716	91	_	_	NNP
18637	23716	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	23716	93	_	_	NNP
18637	23716	94	Deliesseline	Deliesseline	NNP
18637	23716	95	,	,	,
18637	23716	96	8	8	CD
18637	23716	97	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	23716	98	.	.	.
18637	23717	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	23717	2	.	.	.
18637	23718	1	No	no	UH
18637	23718	2	.	.	.
18637	23719	1	4366	4366	CD
18637	23719	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23719	3	1823	1823	CD
18637	23719	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23719	5	,	,	,
18637	23719	6	241	241	CD
18637	23719	7	Ellerbee	Ellerbee	NNP
18637	23719	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23719	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23719	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23719	11	Aderhold	Aderhold	NNP
18637	23719	12	,	,	,
18637	23719	13	5	5	CD
18637	23719	14	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23719	15	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	23719	16	.	.	.
18637	23720	1	1022	1022	CD
18637	23720	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23720	3	1934	1934	CD
18637	23720	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23720	5	,	,	,
18637	23720	6	1214	1214	CD
18637	23720	7	Ellis	Ellis	NNP
18637	23720	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23720	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23720	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23720	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23720	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23720	13	,	,	,
18637	23720	14	206	206	CD
18637	23720	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23720	16	246	246	CD
18637	23720	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23720	18	1007	1007	CD
18637	23720	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23720	20	,	,	,
18637	23720	21	855	855	CD
18637	23720	22	El	El	NNP
18637	23720	23	Paso	Paso	NNP
18637	23720	24	&	&	CC
18637	23720	25	N.E.R.	N.E.R.	NNP
18637	23721	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23721	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23721	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23721	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23721	5	Gutierrez	Gutierrez	NNP
18637	23721	6	,	,	,
18637	23721	7	215	215	CD
18637	23721	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23721	9	87	87	CD
18637	23721	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23721	11	1909	1909	CD
18637	23721	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23721	13	,	,	,
18637	23721	14	703	703	CD
18637	23721	15	Emblem	Emblem	NNP
18637	23721	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23721	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23721	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23721	19	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	23721	20	Land	Land	NNP
18637	23721	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23721	22	,	,	,
18637	23721	23	184	184	CD
18637	23721	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23721	25	600	600	CD
18637	23721	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23721	27	1902	1902	CD
18637	23721	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23721	29	,	,	,
18637	23721	30	702	702	CD
18637	23721	31	,	,	,
18637	23721	32	703	703	CD
18637	23721	33	Embry	Embry	NNP
18637	23721	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23721	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23721	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23721	37	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	23721	38	,	,	,
18637	23721	39	107	107	CD
18637	23721	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23721	41	3	3	CD
18637	23721	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23721	43	1883	1883	CD
18637	23721	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23721	45	,	,	,
18637	23721	46	305	305	CD
18637	23721	47	,	,	,
18637	23721	48	311	311	CD
18637	23721	49	,	,	,
18637	23721	50	657	657	CD
18637	23721	51	,	,	,
18637	23721	52	685	685	CD
18637	23721	53	Emert	Emert	NNP
18637	23721	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23721	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	23721	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23721	57	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	23721	58	,	,	,
18637	23721	59	156	156	CD
18637	23721	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23721	61	296	296	CD
18637	23721	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23721	63	1895	1895	CD
18637	23721	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23721	65	,	,	,
18637	23721	66	184	184	CD
18637	23721	67	,	,	,
18637	23721	68	1155	1155	CD
18637	23721	69	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	23721	70	'	'	POS
18637	23721	71	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	23721	72	Assurance	Assurance	NNP
18637	23721	73	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23721	74	_	_	NNP
18637	23721	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	23721	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23721	77	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	23721	78	,	,	,
18637	23721	79	281	281	CD
18637	23721	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23721	81	233	233	CD
18637	23721	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23721	83	1930	1930	CD
18637	23721	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23721	85	,	,	,
18637	23721	86	582	582	CD
18637	23721	87	Employers	employer	NNS
18637	23721	88	'	'	POS
18637	23721	89	Liability	liability	NN
18637	23721	90	Cases	case	NNS
18637	23721	91	.	.	.
18637	23722	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23722	2	See	See	NNP
18637	23722	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23722	4	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	23722	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23722	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	23722	7	_	_	NNP
18637	23722	8	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23722	9	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	23723	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23723	2	Endicott	Endicott	NNP
18637	23723	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23723	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23723	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	23723	6	_	_	NNP
18637	23723	7	Encyclopedia	Encyclopedia	NNP
18637	23723	8	Press	Press	NNP
18637	23723	9	,	,	,
18637	23723	10	266	266	CD
18637	23723	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23723	12	285	285	CD
18637	23723	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23723	14	1924	1924	CD
18637	23723	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23723	16	,	,	,
18637	23723	17	1081	1081	CD
18637	23723	18	Endicott	Endicott	NNP
18637	23723	19	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23723	20	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23723	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23723	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	23723	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23723	24	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
18637	23723	25	,	,	,
18637	23723	26	317	317	CD
18637	23723	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23723	28	501	501	CD
18637	23723	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23723	30	1943	1943	CD
18637	23723	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23723	32	,	,	,
18637	23723	33	521	521	CD
18637	23723	34	Endo	Endo	NNP
18637	23723	35	,	,	,
18637	23723	36	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23723	37	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23723	38	,	,	,
18637	23723	39	323	323	CD
18637	23723	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23723	41	283	283	CD
18637	23723	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23723	43	1944	1944	CD
18637	23723	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23723	45	,	,	,
18637	23723	46	297	297	CD
18637	23723	47	Engel	Engel	NNP
18637	23723	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23723	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	23723	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23723	51	O'Malley	O'Malley	NNP
18637	23723	52	,	,	,
18637	23723	53	219	219	CD
18637	23723	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23723	55	128	128	CD
18637	23723	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23723	57	1911	1911	CD
18637	23723	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23723	59	,	,	,
18637	23723	60	235	235	CD
18637	23723	61	English	English	NNP
18637	23723	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23723	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	23723	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23723	65	Richardson	Richardson	NNP
18637	23723	66	,	,	,
18637	23723	67	224	224	CD
18637	23723	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23723	69	680	680	CD
18637	23723	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23723	71	1912	1912	CD
18637	23723	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23723	73	,	,	,
18637	23723	74	864	864	CD
18637	23723	75	Equitable	Equitable	NNP
18637	23723	76	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23723	77	Assur	Assur	NNP
18637	23723	78	.	.	.
18637	23724	1	Soc	Soc	NNP
18637	23724	2	.	.	.
18637	23725	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23725	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23725	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23725	4	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23725	5	,	,	,
18637	23725	6	187	187	CD
18637	23725	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23725	8	308	308	CD
18637	23725	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23725	10	1902	1902	CD
18637	23725	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23725	12	,	,	,
18637	23725	13	684	684	CD
18637	23725	14	Equitable	Equitable	NNP
18637	23725	15	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23725	16	Assur	Assur	NNP
18637	23725	17	.	.	.
18637	23726	1	Soc	Soc	NNP
18637	23726	2	.	.	.
18637	23727	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23727	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	23727	5	,	,	,
18637	23727	6	238	238	CD
18637	23727	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23727	8	143	143	CD
18637	23727	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23727	10	1915	1915	CD
18637	23727	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23727	12	,	,	,
18637	23727	13	1055	1055	CD
18637	23727	14	Erb	Erb	NNP
18637	23727	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	23727	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	18	Morasch	Morasch	NNP
18637	23727	19	,	,	,
18637	23727	20	177	177	CD
18637	23727	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23727	22	584	584	CD
18637	23727	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23727	24	1900	1900	CD
18637	23727	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23727	26	,	,	,
18637	23727	27	223	223	CD
18637	23727	28	Erhardt	Erhardt	NNP
18637	23727	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	23727	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	32	Boaro	Boaro	NNP
18637	23727	33	,	,	,
18637	23727	34	113	113	CD
18637	23727	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23727	36	527	527	CD
18637	23727	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23727	38	1885	1885	CD
18637	23727	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23727	40	,	,	,
18637	23727	41	78	78	CD
18637	23727	42	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	23727	43	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23727	44	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23727	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	23727	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	48	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	23727	49	&	&	CC
18637	23727	50	Western	Western	NNP
18637	23727	51	T.	T.	NNP
18637	23727	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23727	53	,	,	,
18637	23727	54	204	204	CD
18637	23727	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23727	56	220	220	CD
18637	23727	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23727	58	1907	1907	CD
18637	23727	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23727	60	,	,	,
18637	23727	61	575	575	CD
18637	23727	62	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	23727	63	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23727	64	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23727	65	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	23727	67	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	68	New	New	NNP
18637	23727	69	York	York	NNP
18637	23727	70	,	,	,
18637	23727	71	233	233	CD
18637	23727	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23727	73	671	671	CD
18637	23727	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23727	75	1914	1914	CD
18637	23727	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23727	77	,	,	,
18637	23727	78	247	247	CD
18637	23727	79	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	23727	80	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23727	81	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23727	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	23727	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	85	Public	Public	NNP
18637	23727	86	Utility	Utility	NNP
18637	23727	87	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23727	88	,	,	,
18637	23727	89	254	254	CD
18637	23727	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23727	91	394	394	CD
18637	23727	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23727	93	1921	1921	CD
18637	23727	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23727	95	,	,	,
18637	23727	96	223	223	CD
18637	23727	97	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	23727	98	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23727	99	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23727	100	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	23727	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	103	Solomon	Solomon	NNP
18637	23727	104	,	,	,
18637	23727	105	237	237	CD
18637	23727	106	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23727	107	427	427	CD
18637	23727	108	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23727	109	1915	1915	CD
18637	23727	110	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23727	111	,	,	,
18637	23727	112	1014	1014	CD
18637	23727	113	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	23727	114	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23727	115	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23727	116	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	117	v.	v.	IN
18637	23727	118	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	119	Tompkins	Tompkins	NNP
18637	23727	120	,	,	,
18637	23727	121	304	304	CD
18637	23727	122	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23727	123	64	64	CD
18637	23727	124	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23727	125	1938	1938	CD
18637	23727	126	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23727	127	,	,	,
18637	23727	128	332	332	CD
18637	23727	129	,	,	,
18637	23727	130	605	605	CD
18637	23727	131	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	23727	132	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23727	133	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23727	134	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	135	v.	v.	IN
18637	23727	136	_	_	NNP
18637	23727	137	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	23727	138	,	,	,
18637	23727	139	233	233	CD
18637	23727	140	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23727	141	685	685	CD
18637	23727	142	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23727	143	1914	1914	CD
18637	23727	144	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23727	145	,	,	,
18637	23727	146	983	983	CD
18637	23727	147	,	,	,
18637	23727	148	987	987	CD
18637	23727	149	Escanaba	Escanaba	NNP
18637	23727	150	&	&	CC
18637	23727	151	L.M.	L.M.	NNP
18637	23728	1	Transp	Transp	NNP
18637	23728	2	.	.	.
18637	23729	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23729	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23729	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23729	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23729	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23729	6	,	,	,
18637	23729	7	107	107	CD
18637	23729	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23729	9	678	678	CD
18637	23729	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23729	11	1883	1883	CD
18637	23729	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23729	13	,	,	,
18637	23729	14	231	231	CD
18637	23729	15	,	,	,
18637	23729	16	698	698	CD
18637	23729	17	Esenwein	Esenwein	NNP
18637	23729	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23729	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23729	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23729	21	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
18637	23729	22	,	,	,
18637	23729	23	325	325	CD
18637	23729	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23729	25	279	279	CD
18637	23729	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23729	27	1945	1945	CD
18637	23729	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23729	29	,	,	,
18637	23729	30	666	666	CD
18637	23729	31	,	,	,
18637	23729	32	667	667	CD
18637	23729	33	Essanay	Essanay	NNP
18637	23729	34	Film	Film	NNP
18637	23729	35	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23729	36	.	.	.
18637	23730	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23730	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23730	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23730	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23730	5	Kane	Kane	NNP
18637	23730	6	,	,	,
18637	23730	7	258	258	CD
18637	23730	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23730	9	358	358	CD
18637	23730	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23730	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	23730	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23730	13	,	,	,
18637	23730	14	524	524	CD
18637	23730	15	Essex	Essex	NNP
18637	23730	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23730	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23730	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23730	19	New	New	NNP
18637	23730	20	England	England	NNP
18637	23730	21	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	23730	22	.	.	.
18637	23731	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23731	2	,	,	,
18637	23731	3	239	239	CD
18637	23731	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23731	5	313	313	CD
18637	23731	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23731	7	1915	1915	CD
18637	23731	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23731	9	,	,	,
18637	23731	10	232	232	CD
18637	23731	11	Essgee	Essgee	NNP
18637	23731	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23731	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23731	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	23731	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23731	16	United	United	NNP
18637	23731	17	States	States	NNP
18637	23731	18	,	,	,
18637	23731	19	262	262	CD
18637	23731	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23731	21	151	151	CD
18637	23731	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23731	23	1923	1923	CD
18637	23731	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23731	25	,	,	,
18637	23731	26	827	827	CD
18637	23731	27	Estin	Estin	NNP
18637	23731	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23731	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23731	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23731	31	Estin	Estin	NNP
18637	23731	32	,	,	,
18637	23731	33	334	334	CD
18637	23731	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23731	35	541	541	CD
18637	23731	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23731	37	1948	1948	CD
18637	23731	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23731	39	,	,	,
18637	23731	40	667	667	CD
18637	23731	41	,	,	,
18637	23731	42	670	670	CD
18637	23731	43	Ettor	Ettor	NNP
18637	23731	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23731	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	23731	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23731	47	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
18637	23731	48	,	,	,
18637	23731	49	228	228	CD
18637	23731	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23731	51	148	148	CD
18637	23731	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23731	53	1913	1913	CD
18637	23731	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23731	55	,	,	,
18637	23731	56	342	342	CD
18637	23731	57	Eubank	Eubank	NNP
18637	23731	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23731	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	23731	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23731	61	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	23731	62	,	,	,
18637	23731	63	226	226	CD
18637	23731	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23731	65	137	137	CD
18637	23731	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23731	67	1912	1912	CD
18637	23731	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23731	69	,	,	,
18637	23731	70	983	983	CD
18637	23731	71	,	,	,
18637	23731	72	1029	1029	CD
18637	23731	73	Euclid	Euclid	NNP
18637	23731	74	_	_	NNP
18637	23731	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	23731	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23731	77	Ambler	Ambler	NNP
18637	23731	78	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	23731	79	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23731	80	,	,	,
18637	23731	81	272	272	CD
18637	23731	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23731	83	365	365	CD
18637	23731	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23731	85	1026	1026	CD
18637	23731	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23731	87	,	,	,
18637	23731	88	1028	1028	CD
18637	23731	89	Eunson	Eunson	NNP
18637	23731	90	_	_	NNP
18637	23731	91	v.	v.	IN
18637	23731	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23731	93	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	23731	94	,	,	,
18637	23731	95	18	18	CD
18637	23731	96	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23731	97	.	.	.
18637	23732	1	414	414	CD
18637	23732	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23732	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	23732	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23732	5	,	,	,
18637	23732	6	271	271	CD
18637	23732	7	Eureka	Eureka	NNP
18637	23732	8	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	23732	9	Line	Line	NNP
18637	23732	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23732	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23732	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	23732	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23732	14	Hallanan	Hallanan	NNP
18637	23732	15	,	,	,
18637	23732	16	257	257	CD
18637	23732	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23732	18	265	265	CD
18637	23732	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23732	20	1921	1921	CD
18637	23732	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23732	22	,	,	,
18637	23732	23	138	138	CD
18637	23732	24	,	,	,
18637	23732	25	182	182	CD
18637	23732	26	,	,	,
18637	23732	27	195	195	CD
18637	23732	28	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	23732	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23732	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	23732	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23732	32	Eaton	Eaton	NNP
18637	23732	33	,	,	,
18637	23732	34	3	3	CD
18637	23732	35	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23732	36	454	454	CD
18637	23732	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23732	38	1818	1818	CD
18637	23732	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23732	40	,	,	,
18637	23732	41	274	274	CD
18637	23732	42	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	23732	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23732	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	23732	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23732	46	Gore	Gore	NNP
18637	23732	47	,	,	,
18637	23732	48	253	253	CD
18637	23732	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23732	50	245	245	CD
18637	23732	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23732	52	1920	1920	CD
18637	23732	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23732	54	,	,	,
18637	23732	55	105	105	CD
18637	23732	56	,	,	,
18637	23732	57	530	530	CD
18637	23732	58	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	23732	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23732	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23732	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23732	62	Jordan	Jordan	NNP
18637	23732	63	,	,	,
18637	23732	64	9	9	CD
18637	23732	65	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23732	66	.	.	.
18637	23733	1	199	199	CD
18637	23733	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23733	3	1815	1815	CD
18637	23733	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23733	5	,	,	,
18637	23733	6	271	271	CD
18637	23733	7	,	,	,
18637	23733	8	275	275	CD
18637	23733	9	Everard	Everard	NNP
18637	23733	10	's	's	POS
18637	23733	11	Breweries	Breweries	NNP
18637	23733	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23733	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23733	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23733	15	Day	Day	NNP
18637	23733	16	,	,	,
18637	23733	17	265	265	CD
18637	23733	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23733	19	545	545	CD
18637	23733	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23733	21	1924	1924	CD
18637	23733	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23733	23	,	,	,
18637	23733	24	919	919	CD
18637	23733	25	Everett	Everett	NNP
18637	23733	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23733	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23733	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23733	29	Everett	Everett	NNP
18637	23733	30	,	,	,
18637	23733	31	215	215	CD
18637	23733	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23733	33	203	203	CD
18637	23733	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23733	35	1909	1909	CD
18637	23733	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23733	37	,	,	,
18637	23733	38	654	654	CD
18637	23733	39	Everson	Everson	NNP
18637	23733	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23733	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23733	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23733	43	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23733	44	of	of	IN
18637	23733	45	Education	Education	NNP
18637	23733	46	,	,	,
18637	23733	47	330	330	CD
18637	23733	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23733	49	1	1	CD
18637	23733	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23733	51	1947	1947	CD
18637	23733	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23733	53	,	,	,
18637	23733	54	760	760	CD
18637	23733	55	,	,	,
18637	23733	56	764	764	CD
18637	23733	57	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	23733	58	,	,	,
18637	23733	59	The	the	DT
18637	23733	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23733	61	v.	v.	NN
18637	23733	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23733	63	McFaddon	McFaddon	NNP
18637	23733	64	,	,	,
18637	23733	65	7	7	CD
18637	23733	66	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23733	67	.	.	.
18637	23734	1	116	116	CD
18637	23734	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23734	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	23734	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23734	5	,	,	,
18637	23734	6	609	609	CD
18637	23734	7	F	F	NNP
18637	23734	8	Fahey	Fahey	NNP
18637	23734	9	_	_	NNP
18637	23734	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	23734	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23734	12	Mallonee	Mallonee	NNP
18637	23734	13	,	,	,
18637	23734	14	332	332	CD
18637	23734	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23734	16	245	245	CD
18637	23734	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23734	18	1947	1947	CD
18637	23734	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23734	20	,	,	,
18637	23734	21	76	76	NNP
18637	23734	22	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	23734	23	,	,	,
18637	23734	24	The	the	DT
18637	23734	25	,	,	,
18637	23734	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23734	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23734	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23734	29	Kohler	Kohler	NNP
18637	23734	30	Die	Die	NNP
18637	23734	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23734	32	,	,	,
18637	23734	33	228	228	CD
18637	23734	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23734	35	22	22	CD
18637	23734	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23734	37	1913	1913	CD
18637	23734	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23734	39	,	,	,
18637	23734	40	567	567	CD
18637	23734	41	Fairbank	Fairbank	NNP
18637	23734	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23734	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23734	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23734	45	United	United	NNP
18637	23734	46	States	States	NNP
18637	23734	47	,	,	,
18637	23734	48	181	181	CD
18637	23734	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23734	50	283	283	CD
18637	23734	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23734	52	1901	1901	CD
18637	23734	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23734	54	,	,	,
18637	23734	55	322	322	CD
18637	23734	56	Fairchild	Fairchild	NNP
18637	23734	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23734	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	23734	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23734	60	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	23734	61	,	,	,
18637	23734	62	258	258	CD
18637	23734	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23734	64	126	126	CD
18637	23734	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23734	66	1922	1922	CD
18637	23734	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23734	68	,	,	,
18637	23734	69	542	542	CD
18637	23734	70	,	,	,
18637	23734	71	715	715	CD
18637	23734	72	Fairfax	Fairfax	NNP
18637	23734	73	's	's	POS
18637	23734	74	Devisee	Devisee	NNP
18637	23734	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23734	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	23734	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23734	78	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	23734	79	's	's	POS
18637	23734	80	Lessee	Lessee	NNP
18637	23734	81	,	,	,
18637	23734	82	7	7	CD
18637	23734	83	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23734	84	.	.	.
18637	23735	1	603	603	CD
18637	23735	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23735	3	1813	1813	CD
18637	23735	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23735	5	,	,	,
18637	23735	6	416	416	CD
18637	23735	7	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	23735	8	Haven	Haven	NNP
18637	23735	9	&	&	CC
18637	23735	10	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	23735	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23735	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23735	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23735	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23735	15	New	New	NNP
18637	23735	16	Haven	Haven	NNP
18637	23735	17	,	,	,
18637	23735	18	203	203	CD
18637	23735	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23735	20	379	379	CD
18637	23735	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23735	22	1906	1906	CD
18637	23735	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23735	24	,	,	,
18637	23735	25	344	344	CD
18637	23735	26	Fairmont	Fairmont	NNP
18637	23735	27	Creamery	Creamery	NNP
18637	23735	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23735	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23735	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	23735	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23735	32	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23735	33	,	,	,
18637	23735	34	274	274	CD
18637	23735	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23735	36	1	1	CD
18637	23735	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23735	38	1927	1927	CD
18637	23735	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23735	40	,	,	,
18637	23735	41	1018	1018	CD
18637	23735	42	Faitoute	Faitoute	NNP
18637	23735	43	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	23735	44	&	&	CC
18637	23735	45	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	23735	46	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23735	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23735	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	23735	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23735	50	Asbury	Asbury	NNP
18637	23735	51	Park	Park	NNP
18637	23735	52	,	,	,
18637	23735	53	316	316	CD
18637	23735	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23735	55	502	502	CD
18637	23735	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23735	57	1942	1942	CD
18637	23735	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23735	59	,	,	,
18637	23735	60	340	340	CD
18637	23735	61	,	,	,
18637	23735	62	357	357	CD
18637	23735	63	Fall	Fall	NNP
18637	23735	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23735	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	23735	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23735	67	Eastin	Eastin	NNP
18637	23735	68	,	,	,
18637	23735	69	215	215	CD
18637	23735	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23735	71	1	1	CD
18637	23735	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23735	73	1909	1909	CD
18637	23735	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23735	75	,	,	,
18637	23735	76	655	655	CD
18637	23735	77	,	,	,
18637	23735	78	673	673	CD
18637	23735	79	Fallbrook	Fallbrook	NNP
18637	23735	80	Irrig	Irrig	NNP
18637	23735	81	.	.	.
18637	23736	1	District	District	NNP
18637	23736	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23736	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23736	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23736	5	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	23736	6	,	,	,
18637	23736	7	164	164	CD
18637	23736	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23736	9	112	112	CD
18637	23736	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23736	11	1896	1896	CD
18637	23736	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23736	13	,	,	,
18637	23736	14	1059	1059	CD
18637	23736	15	,	,	,
18637	23736	16	1140	1140	CD
18637	23736	17	Fargo	Fargo	NNP
18637	23736	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23736	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23736	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23736	21	Hart	Hart	NNP
18637	23736	22	,	,	,
18637	23736	23	193	193	CD
18637	23736	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23736	25	490	490	CD
18637	23736	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23736	27	1904	1904	CD
18637	23736	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23736	29	,	,	,
18637	23736	30	1053	1053	CD
18637	23736	31	Fargo	Fargo	NNP
18637	23736	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23736	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23736	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23736	35	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	23736	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23736	37	Fargo	Fargo	NNP
18637	23736	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23736	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23736	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23736	41	Stevens	Stevens	NNP
18637	23736	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23736	43	,	,	,
18637	23736	44	121	121	CD
18637	23736	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23736	46	230	230	CD
18637	23736	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23736	48	1887	1887	CD
18637	23736	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23736	50	,	,	,
18637	23736	51	204	204	CD
18637	23736	52	Farish	Farish	NNP
18637	23736	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23736	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	23736	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23736	56	State	State	NNP
18637	23736	57	Banking	Banking	NNP
18637	23736	58	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23736	59	,	,	,
18637	23736	60	235	235	CD
18637	23736	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23736	62	498	498	CD
18637	23736	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23736	64	1915	1915	CD
18637	23736	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23736	66	,	,	,
18637	23736	67	936	936	CD
18637	23736	68	Farmers	farmer	NNS
18637	23736	69	'	'	POS
18637	23736	70	&	&	CC
18637	23736	71	Mechanics	Mechanics	NNPS
18637	23736	72	'	'	POS
18637	23736	73	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23736	74	.	.	.
18637	23737	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23737	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23737	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23737	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23737	5	Dearing	Dearing	NNP
18637	23737	6	,	,	,
18637	23737	7	91	91	CD
18637	23737	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23737	9	29	29	CD
18637	23737	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23737	11	1875	1875	CD
18637	23737	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23737	13	,	,	,
18637	23737	14	267	267	CD
18637	23737	15	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	23737	16	&	&	CC
18637	23737	17	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	23737	18	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23737	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23737	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	23737	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23737	22	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23737	23	Reserve	Reserve	NNP
18637	23737	24	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23737	25	,	,	,
18637	23737	26	262	262	CD
18637	23737	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23737	28	649	649	CD
18637	23737	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23737	30	1923	1923	CD
18637	23737	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23737	32	,	,	,
18637	23737	33	326	326	CD
18637	23737	34	,	,	,
18637	23737	35	1020	1020	CD
18637	23737	36	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	23737	37	&	&	CC
18637	23737	38	M.	M.	NNP
18637	23737	39	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	23737	40	.	.	.
18637	23738	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23738	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23738	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23738	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23738	5	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23738	6	,	,	,
18637	23738	7	232	232	CD
18637	23738	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23738	9	516	516	CD
18637	23738	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23738	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	23738	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23738	13	,	,	,
18637	23738	14	1149	1149	CD
18637	23738	15	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	23738	16	'	'	POS
18637	23738	17	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	23738	18	&	&	CC
18637	23738	19	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23738	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23738	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23738	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	23738	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23738	24	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	23738	25	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23738	26	Elev	Elev	NNP
18637	23738	27	.	.	.
18637	23739	1	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23739	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23739	3	,	,	,
18637	23739	4	177	177	CD
18637	23739	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23739	6	51	51	CD
18637	23739	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23739	8	1900	1900	CD
18637	23739	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23739	10	,	,	,
18637	23739	11	627	627	CD
18637	23739	12	,	,	,
18637	23739	13	628	628	CD
18637	23739	14	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	23739	15	'	'	POS
18637	23739	16	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	23739	17	&	&	CC
18637	23739	18	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23739	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23739	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23739	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	23739	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23739	23	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23739	24	,	,	,
18637	23739	25	280	280	CD
18637	23739	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23739	27	204	204	CD
18637	23739	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23739	29	1930	1930	CD
18637	23739	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23739	31	,	,	,
18637	23739	32	1046	1046	CD
18637	23739	33	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	23739	34	'	'	POS
18637	23739	35	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23739	36	Co	Co	NNP
18637	23739	37	-	-	NN
18637	23739	38	op	op	NNP
18637	23739	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23739	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23739	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23739	42	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	23739	43	of	of	IN
18637	23739	44	Int	Int	NNP
18637	23739	45	.	.	.
18637	23740	1	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	23740	2	,	,	,
18637	23740	3	90	90	CD
18637	23740	4	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23740	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	6	2d	2d	NN
18637	23740	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	8	488	488	CD
18637	23740	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	10	1937	1937	CD
18637	23740	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	12	,	,	,
18637	23740	13	1197	1197	CD
18637	23740	14	Farncomb	Farncomb	NNP
18637	23740	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	18	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	23740	19	,	,	,
18637	23740	20	252	252	CD
18637	23740	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	22	7	7	CD
18637	23740	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	24	1920	1920	CD
18637	23740	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	26	,	,	,
18637	23740	27	1061	1061	CD
18637	23740	28	Farrington	Farrington	NNP
18637	23740	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	32	Tokushige	Tokushige	NNP
18637	23740	33	,	,	,
18637	23740	34	273	273	CD
18637	23740	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	36	284	284	CD
18637	23740	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	38	1927	1927	CD
18637	23740	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	40	,	,	,
18637	23740	41	855	855	CD
18637	23740	42	Fassett	Fassett	NNP
18637	23740	43	,	,	,
18637	23740	44	In	in	IN
18637	23740	45	re	re	NN
18637	23740	46	,	,	,
18637	23740	47	142	142	CD
18637	23740	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	49	479	479	CD
18637	23740	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	51	1892	1892	CD
18637	23740	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	53	,	,	,
18637	23740	54	575	575	CD
18637	23740	55	Fauntleroy	Fauntleroy	NNP
18637	23740	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	59	Lum	Lum	NNP
18637	23740	60	,	,	,
18637	23740	61	210	210	CD
18637	23740	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	63	230	230	CD
18637	23740	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	65	1908	1908	CD
18637	23740	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	67	,	,	,
18637	23740	68	654	654	CD
18637	23740	69	,	,	,
18637	23740	70	657	657	CD
18637	23740	71	,	,	,
18637	23740	72	674	674	CD
18637	23740	73	Fay	Fay	NNP
18637	23740	74	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	77	New	New	NNP
18637	23740	78	York	York	NNP
18637	23740	79	,	,	,
18637	23740	80	332	332	CD
18637	23740	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	82	261	261	CD
18637	23740	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	84	1947	1947	CD
18637	23740	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	86	,	,	,
18637	23740	87	1110	1110	CD
18637	23740	88	,	,	,
18637	23740	89	1111	1111	CD
18637	23740	90	,	,	,
18637	23740	91	1131	1131	CD
18637	23740	92	,	,	,
18637	23740	93	1168	1168	CD
18637	23740	94	Fayerweather	Fayerweather	NNP
18637	23740	95	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	98	Ritch	Ritch	NNP
18637	23740	99	,	,	,
18637	23740	100	195	195	CD
18637	23740	101	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	102	276	276	CD
18637	23740	103	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	104	1904	1904	CD
18637	23740	105	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	106	,	,	,
18637	23740	107	848	848	CD
18637	23740	108	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23740	109	Baseball	Baseball	NNP
18637	23740	110	Club	Club	NNP
18637	23740	111	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	112	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	113	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	114	National	National	NNP
18637	23740	115	League	League	NNP
18637	23740	116	,	,	,
18637	23740	117	259	259	CD
18637	23740	118	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	119	200	200	CD
18637	23740	120	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	121	1922	1922	CD
18637	23740	122	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	123	,	,	,
18637	23740	124	120	120	CD
18637	23740	125	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23740	126	Communications	Communications	NNPS
18637	23740	127	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23740	128	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	129	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	130	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	131	Pottsville	Pottsville	NNP
18637	23740	132	Broadcasting	Broadcasting	NNP
18637	23740	133	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23740	134	,	,	,
18637	23740	135	309	309	CD
18637	23740	136	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	137	134	134	CD
18637	23740	138	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	139	1940	1940	CD
18637	23740	140	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	141	,	,	,
18637	23740	142	75	75	CD
18637	23740	143	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23740	144	Communications	Communications	NNPS
18637	23740	145	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23740	146	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	147	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	148	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	149	WJR	WJR	NNP
18637	23740	150	,	,	,
18637	23740	151	337	337	CD
18637	23740	152	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	153	265	265	CD
18637	23740	154	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	155	1949	1949	CD
18637	23740	156	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	157	,	,	,
18637	23740	158	850	850	CD
18637	23740	159	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23740	160	Compress	Compress	NNP
18637	23740	161	&	&	CC
18637	23740	162	Warehouse	Warehouse	NNP
18637	23740	163	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23740	164	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	165	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	166	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	167	McLean	McLean	NNP
18637	23740	168	,	,	,
18637	23740	169	291	291	CD
18637	23740	170	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	171	17	17	CD
18637	23740	172	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	173	1934	1934	CD
18637	23740	174	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	175	,	,	,
18637	23740	176	235	235	CD
18637	23740	177	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23740	178	Housing	Housing	NNP
18637	23740	179	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	23740	180	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	181	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	182	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	183	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	23740	184	,	,	,
18637	23740	185	309	309	CD
18637	23740	186	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	187	242	242	CD
18637	23740	188	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	189	1940	1940	CD
18637	23740	190	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	191	,	,	,
18637	23740	192	591	591	CD
18637	23740	193	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23740	194	Land	Land	NNP
18637	23740	195	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23740	196	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	197	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	198	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	199	Bismarck	Bismarck	NNP
18637	23740	200	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	23740	201	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23740	202	,	,	,
18637	23740	203	314	314	CD
18637	23740	204	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	205	95	95	CD
18637	23740	206	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	207	1941	1941	CD
18637	23740	208	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	209	,	,	,
18637	23740	210	733	733	CD
18637	23740	211	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23740	212	Land	Land	NNP
18637	23740	213	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23740	214	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	215	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	216	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	217	Priddy	Priddy	NNP
18637	23740	218	,	,	,
18637	23740	219	295	295	CD
18637	23740	220	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	221	229	229	CD
18637	23740	222	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	223	1935	1935	CD
18637	23740	224	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	225	,	,	,
18637	23740	226	586	586	CD
18637	23740	227	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23740	228	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23740	229	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23740	230	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	231	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	232	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	233	East	East	NNP
18637	23740	234	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	23740	235	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23740	236	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23740	237	,	,	,
18637	23740	238	338	338	CD
18637	23740	239	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	240	464	464	CD
18637	23740	241	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	242	1950	1950	CD
18637	23740	243	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	244	,	,	,
18637	23740	245	138	138	CD
18637	23740	246	,	,	,
18637	23740	247	921	921	CD
18637	23740	248	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23740	249	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23740	250	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23740	251	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	252	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	253	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	254	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	23740	255	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	23740	256	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23740	257	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23740	258	,	,	,
18637	23740	259	320	320	CD
18637	23740	260	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	261	591	591	CD
18637	23740	262	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	263	1944	1944	CD
18637	23740	264	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	265	,	,	,
18637	23740	266	851	851	CD
18637	23740	267	,	,	,
18637	23740	268	860	860	CD
18637	23740	269	,	,	,
18637	23740	270	1004	1004	CD
18637	23740	271	,	,	,
18637	23740	272	1005	1005	CD
18637	23740	273	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23740	274	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23740	275	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23740	276	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	277	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	278	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	279	National	National	NNP
18637	23740	280	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23740	281	Pipeline	Pipeline	NNP
18637	23740	282	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23740	283	,	,	,
18637	23740	284	315	315	CD
18637	23740	285	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	286	575	575	CD
18637	23740	287	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	288	1942	1942	CD
18637	23740	289	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	290	,	,	,
18637	23740	291	137	137	CD
18637	23740	292	,	,	,
18637	23740	293	851	851	CD
18637	23740	294	,	,	,
18637	23740	295	860	860	CD
18637	23740	296	,	,	,
18637	23740	297	1004	1004	CD
18637	23740	298	,	,	,
18637	23740	299	1005	1005	CD
18637	23740	300	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23740	301	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23740	302	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23740	303	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	304	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	305	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	306	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	23740	307	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23740	308	&	&	CC
18637	23740	309	Light	Light	NNP
18637	23740	310	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23740	311	,	,	,
18637	23740	312	307	307	CD
18637	23740	313	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	314	156	156	CD
18637	23740	315	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	316	1939	1939	CD
18637	23740	317	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	318	,	,	,
18637	23740	319	620	620	CD
18637	23740	320	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23740	321	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	23740	322	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23740	323	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	324	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	325	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	326	General	General	NNP
18637	23740	327	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	23740	328	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23740	329	,	,	,
18637	23740	330	281	281	CD
18637	23740	331	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23740	332	464	464	CD
18637	23740	333	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23740	334	1930	1930	CD
18637	23740	335	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23740	336	,	,	,
18637	23740	337	535	535	CD
18637	23740	338	,	,	,
18637	23740	339	536	536	CD
18637	23740	340	,	,	,
18637	23740	341	537	537	CD
18637	23740	342	,	,	,
18637	23740	343	623	623	CD
18637	23740	344	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23740	345	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	23740	346	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23740	347	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	348	v.	v.	IN
18637	23740	349	_	_	NNP
18637	23740	350	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	23740	351	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	23741	1	Bond	Bond	NNP
18637	23741	2	&	&	CC
18637	23741	3	Mortgage	Mortgage	NNP
18637	23741	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23741	5	,	,	,
18637	23741	6	289	289	CD
18637	23741	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23741	8	266	266	CD
18637	23741	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23741	10	1933	1933	CD
18637	23741	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23741	12	,	,	,
18637	23741	13	75	75	CD
18637	23741	14	,	,	,
18637	23741	15	78	78	CD
18637	23741	16	,	,	,
18637	23741	17	120	120	CD
18637	23741	18	,	,	,
18637	23741	19	126	126	CD
18637	23741	20	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23741	21	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	23741	22	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23741	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23741	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	26	American	American	NNP
18637	23741	27	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	23741	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23741	29	,	,	,
18637	23741	30	264	264	CD
18637	23741	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23741	32	298	298	CD
18637	23741	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23741	34	1924	1924	CD
18637	23741	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23741	36	,	,	,
18637	23741	37	827	827	CD
18637	23741	38	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23741	39	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	23741	40	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23741	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	23741	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	44	Bunte	Bunte	NNP
18637	23741	45	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	23741	46	,	,	,
18637	23741	47	312	312	CD
18637	23741	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23741	49	349	349	CD
18637	23741	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23741	51	1941	1941	CD
18637	23741	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23741	53	,	,	,
18637	23741	54	153	153	CD
18637	23741	55	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23741	56	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	23741	57	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23741	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	23741	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	61	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	23741	62	States	States	NNP
18637	23741	63	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	23741	64	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	23741	65	Assoc	Assoc	NNP
18637	23741	66	.	.	.
18637	23741	67	,	,	,
18637	23741	68	273	273	CD
18637	23741	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23741	70	52	52	CD
18637	23741	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23741	72	1927	1927	CD
18637	23741	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23741	74	,	,	,
18637	23741	75	120	120	CD
18637	23741	76	Feiner	Feiner	NNP
18637	23741	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	23741	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	80	New	New	NNP
18637	23741	81	York	York	NNP
18637	23741	82	,	,	,
18637	23741	83	340	340	CD
18637	23741	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23741	85	315	315	CD
18637	23741	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23741	87	1951	1951	CD
18637	23741	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23741	89	,	,	,
18637	23741	90	768	768	CD
18637	23741	91	,	,	,
18637	23741	92	778	778	CD
18637	23741	93	Feldman	Feldman	NNP
18637	23741	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	23741	96	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	97	United	United	NNP
18637	23741	98	States	States	NNP
18637	23741	99	,	,	,
18637	23741	100	322	322	CD
18637	23741	101	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23741	102	487	487	CD
18637	23741	103	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23741	104	1944	1944	CD
18637	23741	105	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23741	106	,	,	,
18637	23741	107	843	843	CD
18637	23741	108	Felsenheld	Felsenheld	NNP
18637	23741	109	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	110	v.	v.	IN
18637	23741	111	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	112	United	United	NNP
18637	23741	113	States	States	NNP
18637	23741	114	,	,	,
18637	23741	115	186	186	CD
18637	23741	116	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23741	117	126	126	CD
18637	23741	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23741	119	1902	1902	CD
18637	23741	120	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23741	121	,	,	,
18637	23741	122	111	111	CD
18637	23741	123	Felt	Felt	NNP
18637	23741	124	&	&	CC
18637	23741	125	Tarrant	Tarrant	NNP
18637	23741	126	Manufacturing	Manufacturing	NNP
18637	23741	127	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23741	128	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	129	v.	v.	IN
18637	23741	130	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	131	Gallagher	Gallagher	NNP
18637	23741	132	,	,	,
18637	23741	133	306	306	CD
18637	23741	134	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23741	135	62	62	CD
18637	23741	136	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23741	137	1939	1939	CD
18637	23741	138	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23741	139	,	,	,
18637	23741	140	190	190	CD
18637	23741	141	Felts	Felts	NNPS
18637	23741	142	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	143	v.	v.	IN
18637	23741	144	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	145	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	23741	146	,	,	,
18637	23741	147	201	201	CD
18637	23741	148	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23741	149	123	123	CD
18637	23741	150	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23741	151	1906	1906	CD
18637	23741	152	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23741	153	,	,	,
18637	23741	154	1127	1127	CD
18637	23741	155	Fenner	Fenner	NNP
18637	23741	156	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	157	v.	v.	IN
18637	23741	158	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	159	Boykin	Boykin	NNP
18637	23741	160	,	,	,
18637	23741	161	271	271	CD
18637	23741	162	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23741	163	240	240	CD
18637	23741	164	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23741	165	1926	1926	CD
18637	23741	166	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23741	167	,	,	,
18637	23741	168	934	934	CD
18637	23741	169	Fernandez	Fernandez	NNP
18637	23741	170	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	171	v.	v.	IN
18637	23741	172	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	173	Wiener	Wiener	NNP
18637	23741	174	,	,	,
18637	23741	175	326	326	CD
18637	23741	176	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23741	177	340	340	CD
18637	23741	178	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23741	179	1945	1945	CD
18637	23741	180	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23741	181	,	,	,
18637	23741	182	110	110	CD
18637	23741	183	,	,	,
18637	23741	184	321	321	CD
18637	23741	185	,	,	,
18637	23741	186	863	863	CD
18637	23741	187	,	,	,
18637	23741	188	918	918	CD
18637	23741	189	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	23741	190	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	191	v.	v.	IN
18637	23741	192	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	193	Corbett	Corbett	NNP
18637	23741	194	,	,	,
18637	23741	195	258	258	CD
18637	23741	196	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23741	197	609	609	CD
18637	23741	198	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23741	199	1922	1922	CD
18637	23741	200	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23741	201	,	,	,
18637	23741	202	691	691	CD
18637	23741	203	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	23741	204	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	205	v.	v.	IN
18637	23741	206	_	_	NNP
18637	23741	207	Spokane	Spokane	NNP
18637	23741	208	P.	P.	NNP
18637	23741	209	&	&	CC
18637	23741	210	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	23742	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23742	2	,	,	,
18637	23742	3	258	258	CD
18637	23742	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23742	5	314	314	CD
18637	23742	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23742	7	1922	1922	CD
18637	23742	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23742	9	,	,	,
18637	23742	10	691	691	CD
18637	23742	11	,	,	,
18637	23742	12	971	971	CD
18637	23742	13	Fertilizing	Fertilizing	NNP
18637	23742	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23742	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23742	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	23742	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23742	18	Hyde	Hyde	NNP
18637	23742	19	Park	Park	NNP
18637	23742	20	,	,	,
18637	23742	21	97	97	CD
18637	23742	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23742	23	659	659	CD
18637	23742	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23742	25	1878	1878	CD
18637	23742	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23742	27	,	,	,
18637	23742	28	345	345	CD
18637	23742	29	Ficklen	Ficklen	NNP
18637	23742	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23742	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23742	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23742	33	Shelby	Shelby	NNP
18637	23742	34	County	County	NNP
18637	23742	35	Taxing	Taxing	NNP
18637	23742	36	District	District	NNP
18637	23742	37	,	,	,
18637	23742	38	145	145	CD
18637	23742	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23742	40	1	1	CD
18637	23742	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23742	42	1892	1892	CD
18637	23742	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23742	44	188	188	CD
18637	23742	45	,	,	,
18637	23742	46	191	191	CD
18637	23742	47	Fidelity	Fidelity	NNP
18637	23742	48	&	&	CC
18637	23742	49	C.	C.	NNP
18637	23742	50	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23742	51	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23742	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23742	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	23742	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23742	55	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	23742	56	,	,	,
18637	23742	57	245	245	CD
18637	23742	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23742	59	54	54	CD
18637	23742	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23742	61	1917	1917	CD
18637	23742	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23742	63	,	,	,
18637	23742	64	1044	1044	CD
18637	23742	65	Fidelity	Fidelity	NNP
18637	23742	66	&	&	CC
18637	23742	67	D.	D.	NNP
18637	23742	68	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23742	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23742	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	23742	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23742	72	United	United	NNP
18637	23742	73	States	States	NNP
18637	23742	74	,	,	,
18637	23742	75	187	187	CD
18637	23742	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23742	77	315	315	CD
18637	23742	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23742	79	1902	1902	CD
18637	23742	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23742	81	,	,	,
18637	23742	82	894	894	CD
18637	23742	83	Fidelity	Fidelity	NNP
18637	23742	84	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	23742	85	.	.	.
18637	23743	1	Life	Life	NNP
18637	23743	2	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	23743	3	.	.	.
18637	23744	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23744	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23744	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23744	4	Mettler	Mettler	NNP
18637	23744	5	,	,	,
18637	23744	6	185	185	CD
18637	23744	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23744	8	308	308	CD
18637	23744	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23744	10	1902	1902	CD
18637	23744	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23744	12	,	,	,
18637	23744	13	1167	1167	CD
18637	23744	14	Fidelity	Fidelity	NNP
18637	23744	15	National	National	NNP
18637	23744	16	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23744	17	&	&	CC
18637	23744	18	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23744	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23744	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23744	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	23744	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23744	23	Swope	Swope	NNP
18637	23744	24	,	,	,
18637	23744	25	274	274	CD
18637	23744	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23744	27	123	123	CD
18637	23744	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23744	29	1927	1927	CD
18637	23744	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23744	31	514	514	CD
18637	23744	32	,	,	,
18637	23744	33	551	551	CD
18637	23744	34	Fidelity	Fidelity	NNP
18637	23744	35	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23744	36	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23744	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23744	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23744	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23744	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23744	41	Field	Field	NNP
18637	23744	42	,	,	,
18637	23744	43	311	311	CD
18637	23744	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23744	45	169	169	CD
18637	23744	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23744	47	1940	1940	CD
18637	23744	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23744	49	,	,	,
18637	23744	50	607	607	CD
18637	23744	51	Field	Field	NNP
18637	23744	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23744	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	23744	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23744	55	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	23744	56	,	,	,
18637	23744	57	143	143	CD
18637	23744	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23744	59	649	649	CD
18637	23744	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23744	61	1892	1892	CD
18637	23744	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23744	63	,	,	,
18637	23744	64	79	79	CD
18637	23744	65	,	,	,
18637	23744	66	80	80	CD
18637	23744	67	,	,	,
18637	23744	68	97	97	CD
18637	23744	69	,	,	,
18637	23744	70	98	98	CD
18637	23744	71	,	,	,
18637	23744	72	442	442	CD
18637	23744	73	,	,	,
18637	23744	74	547	547	CD
18637	23744	75	Field	Field	NNP
18637	23744	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23744	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	23744	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23744	79	Seabury	Seabury	NNP
18637	23744	80	,	,	,
18637	23744	81	19	19	CD
18637	23744	82	How	how	WRB
18637	23744	83	.	.	.
18637	23745	1	323	323	NNP
18637	23745	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23745	3	1857	1857	CD
18637	23745	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23745	5	,	,	,
18637	23745	6	702	702	CD
18637	23745	7	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	23745	8	Ave	Ave	NNP
18637	23745	9	.	.	.
18637	23745	10	Coach	Coach	NNP
18637	23745	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23745	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23745	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23745	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23745	15	New	New	NNP
18637	23745	16	York	York	NNP
18637	23745	17	,	,	,
18637	23745	18	221	221	CD
18637	23745	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23745	20	467	467	CD
18637	23745	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23745	22	1911	1911	CD
18637	23745	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23745	24	,	,	,
18637	23745	25	1154	1154	CD
18637	23745	26	Filer	Filer	NNP
18637	23745	27	&	&	CC
18637	23745	28	S.	S.	NNP
18637	23745	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23745	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23745	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23745	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23745	33	Diamond	Diamond	NNP
18637	23745	34	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	23745	35	Works	Works	NNP
18637	23745	36	,	,	,
18637	23745	37	270	270	CD
18637	23745	38	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23745	39	489	489	CD
18637	23745	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23745	41	1921	1921	CD
18637	23745	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23745	43	,	,	,
18637	23745	44	893	893	CD
18637	23745	45	Filer	Filer	NNP
18637	23745	46	&	&	CC
18637	23745	47	S.	S.	NNP
18637	23745	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23745	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23745	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	23745	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23745	52	Diamond	Diamond	NNP
18637	23745	53	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	23745	54	Works	Works	NNP
18637	23745	55	,	,	,
18637	23745	56	256	256	CD
18637	23745	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23745	58	691	691	CD
18637	23745	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23745	60	1921	1921	CD
18637	23745	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23745	62	,	,	,
18637	23745	63	893	893	CD
18637	23745	64	Finch	Finch	NNP
18637	23745	65	&	&	CC
18637	23745	66	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23745	67	_	_	NNP
18637	23745	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	23745	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23745	70	McKittrick	McKittrick	NNP
18637	23745	71	,	,	,
18637	23745	72	305	305	CD
18637	23745	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23745	74	395	395	CD
18637	23745	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23745	76	1939	1939	CD
18637	23745	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23745	78	,	,	,
18637	23745	79	241	241	CD
18637	23745	80	,	,	,
18637	23745	81	1232	1232	CD
18637	23745	82	Fink	Fink	NNP
18637	23745	83	_	_	NNP
18637	23745	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	23745	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23745	86	O'Neil	O'Neil	NNP
18637	23745	87	,	,	,
18637	23745	88	106	106	CD
18637	23745	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23745	90	272	272	CD
18637	23745	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23745	92	1882	1882	CD
18637	23745	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23745	94	,	,	,
18637	23745	95	526	526	CD
18637	23745	96	Finley	Finley	NNP
18637	23745	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23745	98	v.	v.	IN
18637	23745	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23745	100	California	California	NNP
18637	23745	101	,	,	,
18637	23745	102	222	222	CD
18637	23745	103	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23745	104	28	28	CD
18637	23745	105	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23745	106	1911	1911	CD
18637	23745	107	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23745	108	,	,	,
18637	23745	109	1161	1161	CD
18637	23745	110	Fire	Fire	NNP
18637	23745	111	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	23745	112	.	.	.
18637	23746	1	of	of	IN
18637	23746	2	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	23746	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23746	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23746	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23746	6	New	New	NNP
18637	23746	7	York	York	NNP
18637	23746	8	,	,	,
18637	23746	9	119	119	CD
18637	23746	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23746	11	110	110	CD
18637	23746	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23746	13	1886	1886	CD
18637	23746	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23746	15	,	,	,
18637	23746	16	120	120	CD
18637	23746	17	,	,	,
18637	23746	18	1144	1144	CD
18637	23746	19	,	,	,
18637	23746	20	1146	1146	CD
18637	23746	21	,	,	,
18637	23746	22	1150	1150	CD
18637	23746	23	First	First	NNP
18637	23746	24	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23746	25	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	23746	26	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23746	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23746	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	23746	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23746	30	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23746	31	,	,	,
18637	23746	32	301	301	CD
18637	23746	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23746	34	234	234	CD
18637	23746	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23746	36	1937	1937	CD
18637	23746	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23746	38	,	,	,
18637	23746	39	1044	1044	CD
18637	23746	40	First	First	NNP
18637	23746	41	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23746	42	.	.	.
18637	23747	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23747	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23747	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23747	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23747	5	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	23747	6	,	,	,
18637	23747	7	258	258	CD
18637	23747	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23747	9	362	362	CD
18637	23747	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23747	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	23747	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23747	13	,	,	,
18637	23747	14	734	734	CD
18637	23747	15	First	first	JJ
18637	23747	16	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23747	17	.	.	.
18637	23748	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23748	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23748	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23748	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23748	5	Fellows	Fellows	NNP
18637	23748	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23748	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	23748	8	.	.	.
18637	23749	1	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23749	2	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23749	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23749	4	,	,	,
18637	23749	5	244	244	CD
18637	23749	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23749	7	416	416	CD
18637	23749	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23749	9	1917	1917	CD
18637	23749	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23749	11	,	,	,
18637	23749	12	78	78	CD
18637	23749	13	,	,	,
18637	23749	14	309	309	CD
18637	23749	15	First	first	JJ
18637	23749	16	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23749	17	.	.	.
18637	23750	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23750	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23750	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23750	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23750	5	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23750	6	,	,	,
18637	23750	7	9	9	CD
18637	23750	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23750	9	.	.	.
18637	23751	1	353	353	CD
18637	23751	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23751	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	23751	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23751	5	,	,	,
18637	23751	6	725	725	CD
18637	23751	7	First	first	JJ
18637	23751	8	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23751	9	.	.	.
18637	23752	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23752	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23752	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23752	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23752	5	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	23752	6	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23752	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23752	8	,	,	,
18637	23752	9	289	289	CD
18637	23752	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23752	11	60	60	CD
18637	23752	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23752	13	1933	1933	CD
18637	23752	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23752	15	,	,	,
18637	23752	16	1147	1147	CD
18637	23752	17	First	First	NNP
18637	23752	18	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23752	19	.	.	.
18637	23753	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23753	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23753	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23753	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23753	5	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	23753	6	,	,	,
18637	23753	7	284	284	CD
18637	23753	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23753	9	312	312	CD
18637	23753	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23753	11	1932	1932	CD
18637	23753	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23753	13	,	,	,
18637	23753	14	1046	1046	CD
18637	23753	15	,	,	,
18637	23753	16	1047	1047	CD
18637	23753	17	First	First	NNP
18637	23753	18	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23753	19	.	.	.
18637	23754	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23754	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23754	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23754	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23754	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23754	6	Air	Air	NNP
18637	23754	7	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	23754	8	,	,	,
18637	23754	9	342	342	CD
18637	23754	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23754	11	396	396	CD
18637	23754	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23754	13	1952	1952	CD
18637	23754	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23754	15	,	,	,
18637	23754	16	677	677	CD
18637	23754	17	First	first	JJ
18637	23754	18	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23754	19	.	.	.
18637	23755	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23755	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23755	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23755	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23755	5	Yankton	Yankton	NNP
18637	23755	6	County	County	NNP
18637	23755	7	,	,	,
18637	23755	8	101	101	CD
18637	23755	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23755	10	129	129	CD
18637	23755	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23755	12	1880	1880	CD
18637	23755	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23755	14	,	,	,
18637	23755	15	703	703	CD
18637	23755	16	Fischer	Fischer	NNP
18637	23755	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23755	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23755	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23755	20	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23755	21	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	23755	22	,	,	,
18637	23755	23	194	194	CD
18637	23755	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23755	25	361	361	CD
18637	23755	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23755	27	1904	1904	CD
18637	23755	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23755	29	,	,	,
18637	23755	30	1028	1028	CD
18637	23755	31	,	,	,
18637	23755	32	1157	1157	CD
18637	23755	33	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	23755	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23755	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23755	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23755	37	Hurst	Hurst	NNP
18637	23755	38	,	,	,
18637	23755	39	333	333	CD
18637	23755	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23755	41	147	147	CD
18637	23755	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23755	43	1948	1948	CD
18637	23755	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23755	45	,	,	,
18637	23755	46	1163	1163	CD
18637	23755	47	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	23755	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23755	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	23755	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23755	51	Pace	Pace	NNP
18637	23755	52	,	,	,
18637	23755	53	336	336	CD
18637	23755	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23755	55	155	155	CD
18637	23755	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23755	57	1949	1949	CD
18637	23755	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23755	59	,	,	,
18637	23755	60	1130	1130	CD
18637	23755	61	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	23755	62	's	's	POS
18637	23755	63	Blend	Blend	NNP
18637	23755	64	Station	Station	NNP
18637	23755	65	_	_	NNP
18637	23755	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	23755	67	_	_	NNP
18637	23755	68	State	State	NNP
18637	23755	69	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23755	70	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23755	71	,	,	,
18637	23755	72	297	297	CD
18637	23755	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23755	74	650	650	CD
18637	23755	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23755	76	1936	1936	CD
18637	23755	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23755	78	,	,	,
18637	23755	79	126	126	CD
18637	23755	80	,	,	,
18637	23755	81	195	195	CD
18637	23755	82	,	,	,
18637	23755	83	204	204	CD
18637	23755	84	Fisheries	Fisheries	NNPS
18637	23755	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23755	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	23755	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23755	88	Holyoke	Holyoke	NNP
18637	23755	89	Water	Water	NNP
18637	23755	90	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23755	91	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23755	92	,	,	,
18637	23755	93	104	104	CD
18637	23755	94	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	23756	1	446	446	CD
18637	23756	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23756	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	23756	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23756	5	,	,	,
18637	23756	6	344	344	CD
18637	23756	7	Fisk	Fisk	NNP
18637	23756	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23756	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23756	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23756	11	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	23756	12	Police	Police	NNP
18637	23756	13	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	23756	14	,	,	,
18637	23756	15	116	116	CD
18637	23756	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23756	17	131	131	CD
18637	23756	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23756	19	1885	1885	CD
18637	23756	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23756	21	,	,	,
18637	23756	22	341	341	CD
18637	23756	23	,	,	,
18637	23756	24	356	356	CD
18637	23756	25	Fiske	Fiske	NNP
18637	23756	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23756	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23756	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23756	29	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23756	30	,	,	,
18637	23756	31	274	274	CD
18637	23756	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23756	33	380	380	CD
18637	23756	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23756	35	1927	1927	CD
18637	23756	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23756	37	,	,	,
18637	23756	38	757	757	CD
18637	23756	39	,	,	,
18637	23756	40	772	772	CD
18637	23756	41	,	,	,
18637	23756	42	773	773	CD
18637	23756	43	Fitts	Fitts	NNP
18637	23756	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23756	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	23756	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23756	47	McGhee	McGhee	NNP
18637	23756	48	,	,	,
18637	23756	49	172	172	CD
18637	23756	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23756	51	516	516	CD
18637	23756	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23756	53	1899	1899	CD
18637	23756	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23756	55	,	,	,
18637	23756	56	930	930	CD
18637	23756	57	,	,	,
18637	23756	58	933	933	CD
18637	23756	59	Fitzgerald	Fitzgerald	NNP
18637	23756	60	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23756	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23756	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	23756	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23756	64	Pedersen	Pedersen	NNP
18637	23756	65	,	,	,
18637	23756	66	324	324	CD
18637	23756	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23756	68	720	720	CD
18637	23756	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23756	70	1945	1945	CD
18637	23756	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23756	72	,	,	,
18637	23756	73	157	157	CD
18637	23756	74	Flanagan	Flanagan	NNP
18637	23756	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23756	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	23756	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23756	78	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23756	79	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	23756	80	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23756	81	,	,	,
18637	23756	82	267	267	CD
18637	23756	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23756	84	222	222	CD
18637	23756	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23756	86	1925	1925	CD
18637	23756	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23756	88	,	,	,
18637	23756	89	182	182	CD
18637	23756	90	Fleming	Fleming	NNP
18637	23756	91	_	_	NNP
18637	23756	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	23756	93	_	_	NNP
18637	23756	94	Mohawk	Mohawk	NNP
18637	23756	95	Wrecking	Wrecking	NNP
18637	23756	96	&	&	CC
18637	23756	97	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	23756	98	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23756	99	,	,	,
18637	23756	100	331	331	CD
18637	23756	101	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23756	102	111	111	CD
18637	23756	103	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23756	104	1947	1947	CD
18637	23756	105	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23756	106	,	,	,
18637	23756	107	293	293	CD
18637	23756	108	Fleming	Fleming	NNP
18637	23756	109	_	_	NNP
18637	23756	110	v.	v.	IN
18637	23756	111	_	_	NNP
18637	23756	112	Page	Page	NNP
18637	23756	113	,	,	,
18637	23756	114	9	9	CD
18637	23756	115	How	how	WRB
18637	23756	116	.	.	.
18637	23757	1	603	603	CD
18637	23757	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23757	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	23757	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23757	5	,	,	,
18637	23757	6	390	390	CD
18637	23757	7	,	,	,
18637	23757	8	404	404	CD
18637	23757	9	Fleming	Fleming	NNP
18637	23757	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23757	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23757	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23757	13	Rhodes	Rhodes	NNP
18637	23757	14	,	,	,
18637	23757	15	331	331	CD
18637	23757	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23757	17	100	100	CD
18637	23757	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23757	19	1947	1947	CD
18637	23757	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23757	21	,	,	,
18637	23757	22	540	540	CD
18637	23757	23	,	,	,
18637	23757	24	561	561	CD
18637	23757	25	,	,	,
18637	23757	26	856	856	CD
18637	23757	27	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	23757	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23757	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23757	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23757	31	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	23757	32	,	,	,
18637	23757	33	6	6	CD
18637	23757	34	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23757	35	.	.	.
18637	23758	1	87	87	CD
18637	23758	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23758	3	1810	1810	CD
18637	23758	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23758	5	,	,	,
18637	23758	6	335	335	CD
18637	23758	7	,	,	,
18637	23758	8	350	350	CD
18637	23758	9	,	,	,
18637	23758	10	352	352	CD
18637	23758	11	,	,	,
18637	23758	12	555	555	CD
18637	23758	13	,	,	,
18637	23758	14	560	560	CD
18637	23758	15	,	,	,
18637	23758	16	976	976	CD
18637	23758	17	Flexner	Flexner	NNP
18637	23758	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23758	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23758	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23758	21	Farson	Farson	NNP
18637	23758	22	,	,	,
18637	23758	23	248	248	CD
18637	23758	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23758	25	289	289	CD
18637	23758	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23758	27	1919	1919	CD
18637	23758	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23758	29	,	,	,
18637	23758	30	1074	1074	CD
18637	23758	31	Flint	Flint	NNP
18637	23758	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23758	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23758	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23758	35	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	23758	36	Tracy	Tracy	NNP
18637	23758	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23758	38	,	,	,
18637	23758	39	220	220	CD
18637	23758	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23758	41	107	107	CD
18637	23758	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23758	43	1911	1911	CD
18637	23758	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23758	45	,	,	,
18637	23758	46	98	98	CD
18637	23758	47	,	,	,
18637	23758	48	102	102	CD
18637	23758	49	,	,	,
18637	23758	50	107	107	CD
18637	23758	51	,	,	,
18637	23758	52	319	319	CD
18637	23758	53	,	,	,
18637	23758	54	827	827	CD
18637	23758	55	,	,	,
18637	23758	56	863	863	CD
18637	23758	57	,	,	,
18637	23758	58	1192	1192	CD
18637	23758	59	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	23758	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23758	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23758	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23758	63	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23758	64	,	,	,
18637	23758	65	17	17	CD
18637	23758	66	How	how	WRB
18637	23758	67	.	.	.
18637	23759	1	478	478	CD
18637	23759	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23759	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	23759	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23759	5	,	,	,
18637	23759	6	612	612	CD
18637	23759	7	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	23759	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23759	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	11	Mellon	Mellon	NNP
18637	23759	12	,	,	,
18637	23759	13	273	273	CD
18637	23759	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23759	15	12	12	CD
18637	23759	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23759	17	1927	1927	CD
18637	23759	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23759	19	,	,	,
18637	23759	20	110	110	CD
18637	23759	21	,	,	,
18637	23759	22	594	594	CD
18637	23759	23	,	,	,
18637	23759	24	596	596	CD
18637	23759	25	Florsheim	Florsheim	NNP
18637	23759	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23759	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	29	Schilling	Schilling	NNP
18637	23759	30	,	,	,
18637	23759	31	137	137	CD
18637	23759	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23759	33	64	64	CD
18637	23759	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23759	35	1890	1890	CD
18637	23759	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23759	37	,	,	,
18637	23759	38	273	273	CD
18637	23759	39	Follett	Follett	NNP
18637	23759	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23759	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	43	Town	Town	NNP
18637	23759	44	of	of	IN
18637	23759	45	McCormick	McCormick	NNP
18637	23759	46	,	,	,
18637	23759	47	321	321	CD
18637	23759	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23759	49	573	573	CD
18637	23759	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23759	51	1944	1944	CD
18637	23759	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23759	53	,	,	,
18637	23759	54	563	563	CD
18637	23759	55	,	,	,
18637	23759	56	792	792	CD
18637	23759	57	Fonda	Fonda	NNP
18637	23759	58	,	,	,
18637	23759	59	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23759	60	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23759	61	,	,	,
18637	23759	62	117	117	CD
18637	23759	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23759	64	516	516	CD
18637	23759	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23759	66	1886	1886	CD
18637	23759	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23759	68	,	,	,
18637	23759	69	634	634	CD
18637	23759	70	Fong	Fong	NNP
18637	23759	71	Yue	Yue	NNP
18637	23759	72	Ting	Ting	NNP
18637	23759	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	23759	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	76	United	United	NNP
18637	23759	77	States	States	NNP
18637	23759	78	,	,	,
18637	23759	79	149	149	CD
18637	23759	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23759	81	698	698	CD
18637	23759	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23759	83	1893	1893	CD
18637	23759	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23759	85	,	,	,
18637	23759	86	73	73	CD
18637	23759	87	,	,	,
18637	23759	88	259	259	CD
18637	23759	89	,	,	,
18637	23759	90	421	421	CD
18637	23759	91	,	,	,
18637	23759	92	624	624	CD
18637	23759	93	Foote	Foote	NNP
18637	23759	94	&	&	CC
18637	23759	95	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23759	96	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	23759	98	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	99	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
18637	23759	100	,	,	,
18637	23759	101	232	232	CD
18637	23759	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23759	103	494	494	CD
18637	23759	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23759	105	1914	1914	CD
18637	23759	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23759	107	,	,	,
18637	23759	108	183	183	CD
18637	23759	109	,	,	,
18637	23759	110	214	214	CD
18637	23759	111	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	23759	112	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	23759	114	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	115	Delta	Delta	NNP
18637	23759	116	&	&	CC
18637	23759	117	Pine	Pine	NNP
18637	23759	118	Land	Land	NNP
18637	23759	119	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23759	120	,	,	,
18637	23759	121	164	164	CD
18637	23759	122	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23759	123	662	662	CD
18637	23759	124	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23759	125	1897	1897	CD
18637	23759	126	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23759	127	,	,	,
18637	23759	128	348	348	CD
18637	23759	129	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	23759	130	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	131	v.	v.	IN
18637	23759	132	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	133	Surget	Surget	NNP
18637	23759	134	,	,	,
18637	23759	135	97	97	CD
18637	23759	136	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23759	137	594	594	CD
18637	23759	138	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23759	139	1878	1878	CD
18637	23759	140	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23759	141	,	,	,
18637	23759	142	728	728	CD
18637	23759	143	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	23759	144	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	23759	145	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23759	146	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	147	v.	v.	IN
18637	23759	148	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	149	Beauchamp	Beauchamp	NNP
18637	23759	150	,	,	,
18637	23759	151	308	308	CD
18637	23759	152	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23759	153	331	331	CD
18637	23759	154	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23759	155	1939	1939	CD
18637	23759	156	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23759	157	,	,	,
18637	23759	158	198	198	CD
18637	23759	159	,	,	,
18637	23759	160	203	203	CD
18637	23759	161	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	23759	162	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	23759	163	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23759	164	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	165	v.	v.	IN
18637	23759	166	_	_	NNP
18637	23759	167	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	23759	168	.	.	.
18637	23760	1	of	of	IN
18637	23760	2	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	23760	3	of	of	IN
18637	23760	4	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	23760	5	,	,	,
18637	23760	6	323	323	CD
18637	23760	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23760	8	459	459	CD
18637	23760	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23760	10	1945	1945	CD
18637	23760	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23760	12	,	,	,
18637	23760	13	935	935	CD
18637	23760	14	,	,	,
18637	23760	15	936	936	CD
18637	23760	16	Forsyth	Forsyth	NNP
18637	23760	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23760	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23760	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23760	20	Hammond	Hammond	NNP
18637	23760	21	,	,	,
18637	23760	22	166	166	CD
18637	23760	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23760	24	506	506	CD
18637	23760	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23760	26	1897	1897	CD
18637	23760	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23760	28	,	,	,
18637	23760	29	705	705	CD
18637	23760	30	Fort	Fort	NNP
18637	23760	31	Leavenworth	Leavenworth	NNP
18637	23760	32	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23760	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23760	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23760	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23760	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23760	37	Lowe	Lowe	NNP
18637	23760	38	,	,	,
18637	23760	39	114	114	CD
18637	23760	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23760	41	525	525	CD
18637	23760	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23760	43	1885	1885	CD
18637	23760	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23760	45	,	,	,
18637	23760	46	307	307	CD
18637	23760	47	,	,	,
18637	23760	48	429	429	CD
18637	23760	49	Ft	Ft	NNP
18637	23760	50	.	.	.
18637	23760	51	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	23760	52	Light	Light	NNP
18637	23760	53	&	&	CC
18637	23760	54	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	23760	55	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23760	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23760	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	23760	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23760	59	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23760	60	of	of	IN
18637	23760	61	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	23760	62	.	.	.
18637	23760	63	,	,	,
18637	23760	64	274	274	CD
18637	23760	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23760	66	387	387	CD
18637	23760	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23760	68	1927	1927	CD
18637	23760	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23760	70	,	,	,
18637	23760	71	1154	1154	CD
18637	23760	72	Ft	Ft	NNP
18637	23760	73	.	.	.
18637	23760	74	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	23760	75	Light	Light	NNP
18637	23760	76	&	&	CC
18637	23760	77	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	23760	78	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23760	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23760	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	23760	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23760	82	Bourland	Bourland	NNP
18637	23760	83	,	,	,
18637	23760	84	267	267	CD
18637	23760	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23760	86	330	330	CD
18637	23760	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23760	88	1925	1925	CD
18637	23760	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23760	90	,	,	,
18637	23760	91	1011	1011	CD
18637	23760	92	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	23760	93	_	_	NNP
18637	23760	94	v.	v.	IN
18637	23760	95	_	_	NNP
18637	23760	96	Davenport	Davenport	NNP
18637	23760	97	,	,	,
18637	23760	98	22	22	CD
18637	23760	99	How	how	WRB
18637	23760	100	.	.	.
18637	23761	1	244	244	CD
18637	23761	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23761	3	1859	1859	CD
18637	23761	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23761	5	,	,	,
18637	23761	6	229	229	CD
18637	23761	7	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	23761	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23761	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23761	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23761	11	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23761	12	,	,	,
18637	23761	13	332	332	CD
18637	23761	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23761	15	134	134	CD
18637	23761	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23761	17	1947	1947	CD
18637	23761	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23761	19	,	,	,
18637	23761	20	1103	1103	CD
18637	23761	21	,	,	,
18637	23761	22	1104	1104	CD
18637	23761	23	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	23761	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23761	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23761	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23761	27	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23761	28	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23761	29	rel	rel	NNP
18637	23761	30	.	.	.
18637	23762	1	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	23762	2	,	,	,
18637	23762	3	112	112	CD
18637	23762	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23762	5	201	201	CD
18637	23762	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23762	7	1884	1884	CD
18637	23762	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23762	9	,	,	,
18637	23762	10	1096	1096	CD
18637	23762	11	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	23762	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23762	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23762	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23762	15	Master	Master	NNP
18637	23762	16	&	&	CC
18637	23762	17	Wardens	Wardens	NNP
18637	23762	18	of	of	IN
18637	23762	19	Port	Port	NNP
18637	23762	20	of	of	IN
18637	23762	21	New	New	NNP
18637	23762	22	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	23762	23	,	,	,
18637	23762	24	94	94	CD
18637	23762	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23762	26	246	246	CD
18637	23762	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23762	28	1877	1877	CD
18637	23762	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23762	30	,	,	,
18637	23762	31	229	229	CD
18637	23762	32	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	23762	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23762	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	23762	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23762	36	Neilson	Neilson	NNP
18637	23762	37	,	,	,
18637	23762	38	2	2	CD
18637	23762	39	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23762	40	.	.	.
18637	23763	1	253	253	CD
18637	23763	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23763	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	23763	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23763	5	,	,	,
18637	23763	6	414	414	CD
18637	23763	7	,	,	,
18637	23763	8	418	418	CD
18637	23763	9	,	,	,
18637	23763	10	422	422	CD
18637	23763	11	,	,	,
18637	23763	12	426	426	CD
18637	23763	13	,	,	,
18637	23763	14	472	472	CD
18637	23763	15	,	,	,
18637	23763	16	473	473	CD
18637	23763	17	,	,	,
18637	23763	18	547	547	CD
18637	23763	19	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	23763	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	23763	21	Fountain	Fountain	NNP
18637	23763	22	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	23763	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23763	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23763	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23763	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23763	27	Haydel	Haydel	NNP
18637	23763	28	278	278	CD
18637	23763	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23763	30	1	1	CD
18637	23763	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23763	32	1928	1928	CD
18637	23763	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23763	34	,	,	,
18637	23763	35	219	219	CD
18637	23763	36	,	,	,
18637	23763	37	245	245	CD
18637	23763	38	Foulke	Foulke	NNP
18637	23763	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23763	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23763	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23763	42	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	23763	43	,	,	,
18637	23763	44	342	342	CD
18637	23763	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23763	46	881	881	CD
18637	23763	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23763	48	1951	1951	CD
18637	23763	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23763	50	,	,	,
18637	23763	51	1107	1107	CD
18637	23763	52	Fourteen	Fourteen	NNP
18637	23763	53	Diamond	Diamond	NNP
18637	23763	54	Rings	Rings	NNPS
18637	23763	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23763	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	23763	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23763	58	United	United	NNP
18637	23763	59	States	States	NNP
18637	23763	60	,	,	,
18637	23763	61	183	183	CD
18637	23763	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23763	63	176	176	CD
18637	23763	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23763	65	1901	1901	CD
18637	23763	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23763	67	,	,	,
18637	23763	68	413	413	CD
18637	23763	69	Fowler	Fowler	NNP
18637	23763	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23763	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	23763	72	_	_	NNP
18637	23763	73	Lindsay	Lindsay	NNP
18637	23763	74	,	,	,
18637	23763	75	3	3	CD
18637	23763	76	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	23763	77	.	.	.
18637	23764	1	411	411	CD
18637	23764	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23764	3	1799	1799	CD
18637	23764	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23764	5	,	,	,
18637	23764	6	592	592	CD
18637	23764	7	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	23764	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23764	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23764	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23764	11	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	23764	12	,	,	,
18637	23764	13	5	5	CD
18637	23764	14	How	how	WRB
18637	23764	15	.	.	.
18637	23765	1	410	410	CD
18637	23765	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23765	3	1847	1847	CD
18637	23765	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23765	5	,	,	,
18637	23765	6	266	266	CD
18637	23765	7	,	,	,
18637	23765	8	751	751	CD
18637	23765	9	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	23765	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23765	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	13	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	23765	14	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	23765	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23765	16	,	,	,
18637	23765	17	294	294	CD
18637	23765	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23765	19	87	87	CD
18637	23765	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23765	21	1935	1935	CD
18637	23765	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23765	23	,	,	,
18637	23765	24	1037	1037	CD
18637	23765	25	,	,	,
18637	23765	26	1148	1148	CD
18637	23765	27	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	23765	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23765	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	31	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	23765	32	,	,	,
18637	23765	33	236	236	CD
18637	23765	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23765	35	273	273	CD
18637	23765	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23765	37	1915	1915	CD
18637	23765	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23765	39	,	,	,
18637	23765	40	773	773	CD
18637	23765	41	,	,	,
18637	23765	42	778	778	CD
18637	23765	43	,	,	,
18637	23765	44	782	782	CD
18637	23765	45	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	23765	46	Film	Film	NNP
18637	23765	47	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23765	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	23765	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	51	Doyal	Doyal	NNP
18637	23765	52	,	,	,
18637	23765	53	286	286	CD
18637	23765	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23765	55	123	123	CD
18637	23765	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23765	57	1932	1932	CD
18637	23765	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23765	59	,	,	,
18637	23765	60	276	276	CD
18637	23765	61	,	,	,
18637	23765	62	734	734	CD
18637	23765	63	Francis	Francis	NNP
18637	23765	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	23765	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	67	Resweber	Resweber	NNP
18637	23765	68	,	,	,
18637	23765	69	329	329	CD
18637	23765	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23765	71	459	459	CD
18637	23765	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23765	73	1947	1947	CD
18637	23765	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23765	75	,	,	,
18637	23765	76	1161	1161	CD
18637	23765	77	Francis	Francis	NNP
18637	23765	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	23765	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	81	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	23765	82	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	23765	83	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23765	84	,	,	,
18637	23765	85	333	333	CD
18637	23765	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23765	87	445	445	CD
18637	23765	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23765	89	1948	1948	CD
18637	23765	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23765	91	,	,	,
18637	23765	92	724	724	CD
18637	23765	93	Francis	Francis	NNP
18637	23765	94	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	23765	95	,	,	,
18637	23765	96	The	the	DT
18637	23765	97	,	,	,
18637	23765	98	105	105	CD
18637	23765	99	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23765	100	381	381	CD
18637	23765	101	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23765	102	1882	1882	CD
18637	23765	103	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23765	104	,	,	,
18637	23765	105	615	615	CD
18637	23765	106	Frank	Frank	NNP
18637	23765	107	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	23765	109	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	110	Mangum	Mangum	NNP
18637	23765	111	,	,	,
18637	23765	112	237	237	CD
18637	23765	113	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23765	114	309	309	CD
18637	23765	115	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23765	116	1915	1915	CD
18637	23765	117	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23765	118	,	,	,
18637	23765	119	314	314	CD
18637	23765	120	,	,	,
18637	23765	121	327	327	CD
18637	23765	122	,	,	,
18637	23765	123	634	634	CD
18637	23765	124	,	,	,
18637	23765	125	1127	1127	CD
18637	23765	126	,	,	,
18637	23765	127	1131	1131	CD
18637	23765	128	,	,	,
18637	23765	129	1138	1138	CD
18637	23765	130	,	,	,
18637	23765	131	1139	1139	CD
18637	23765	132	Frasch	Frasch	NNP
18637	23765	133	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	134	v.	v.	IN
18637	23765	135	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	136	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	23765	137	,	,	,
18637	23765	138	211	211	CD
18637	23765	139	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23765	140	1	1	CD
18637	23765	141	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23765	142	1908	1908	CD
18637	23765	143	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23765	144	,	,	,
18637	23765	145	514	514	CD
18637	23765	146	,	,	,
18637	23765	147	537	537	CD
18637	23765	148	Frazier	Frazier	NNP
18637	23765	149	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	150	v.	v.	IN
18637	23765	151	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	152	United	United	NNP
18637	23765	153	States	States	NNP
18637	23765	154	,	,	,
18637	23765	155	335	335	CD
18637	23765	156	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23765	157	497	497	CD
18637	23765	158	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23765	159	1948	1948	CD
18637	23765	160	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23765	161	,	,	,
18637	23765	162	879	879	CD
18637	23765	163	Frederickson	Frederickson	NNP
18637	23765	164	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	165	v.	v.	IN
18637	23765	166	_	_	NNP
18637	23765	167	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	23765	168	,	,	,
18637	23765	169	23	23	CD
18637	23765	170	How	how	WRB
18637	23765	171	.	.	.
18637	23766	1	445	445	CD
18637	23766	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23766	3	1860	1860	CD
18637	23766	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23766	5	,	,	,
18637	23766	6	429	429	CD
18637	23766	7	Freeborn	Freeborn	NNP
18637	23766	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23766	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23766	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23766	11	The	the	DT
18637	23766	12	"	"	``
18637	23766	13	Protector	Protector	NNP
18637	23766	14	,	,	,
18637	23766	15	"	"	''
18637	23766	16	12	12	CD
18637	23766	17	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23766	18	.	.	.
18637	23767	1	700	700	CD
18637	23767	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23767	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	23767	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23767	5	,	,	,
18637	23767	6	282	282	CD
18637	23767	7	Freeborn	Freeborn	NNP
18637	23767	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23767	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23767	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23767	11	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	23767	12	,	,	,
18637	23767	13	2	2	CD
18637	23767	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23767	15	.	.	.
18637	23768	1	160	160	CD
18637	23768	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23768	3	1865	1865	CD
18637	23768	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23768	5	,	,	,
18637	23768	6	699	699	CD
18637	23768	7	Freeman	Freeman	NNP
18637	23768	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23768	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23768	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23768	11	Hewit	Hewit	NNP
18637	23768	12	,	,	,
18637	23768	13	329	329	CD
18637	23768	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23768	15	249	249	CD
18637	23768	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23768	17	1946	1946	CD
18637	23768	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23768	19	,	,	,
18637	23768	20	179	179	CD
18637	23768	21	,	,	,
18637	23768	22	204	204	CD
18637	23768	23	,	,	,
18637	23768	24	206	206	CD
18637	23768	25	Freeman	Freeman	NNP
18637	23768	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23768	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23768	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23768	29	Howe	Howe	NNP
18637	23768	30	,	,	,
18637	23768	31	24	24	CD
18637	23768	32	How	how	WRB
18637	23768	33	.	.	.
18637	23769	1	450	450	CD
18637	23769	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23769	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	23769	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23769	5	,	,	,
18637	23769	6	524	524	CD
18637	23769	7	,	,	,
18637	23769	8	627	627	CD
18637	23769	9	,	,	,
18637	23769	10	628	628	CD
18637	23769	11	French	French	NNP
18637	23769	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23769	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23769	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23769	15	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	23769	16	Asphalt	Asphalt	NNP
18637	23769	17	Paving	Paving	NNP
18637	23769	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23769	19	,	,	,
18637	23769	20	181	181	CD
18637	23769	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23769	22	324	324	CD
18637	23769	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23769	24	1901	1901	CD
18637	23769	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23769	26	,	,	,
18637	23769	27	972	972	CD
18637	23769	28	,	,	,
18637	23769	29	1059	1059	CD
18637	23769	30	French	French	NNP
18637	23769	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23769	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	23769	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23769	34	Hay	Hay	NNP
18637	23769	35	,	,	,
18637	23769	36	22	22	CD
18637	23769	37	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23769	38	.	.	.
18637	23770	1	231	231	CD
18637	23770	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23770	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	23770	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23770	5	,	,	,
18637	23770	6	629	629	CD
18637	23770	7	French	French	NNP
18637	23770	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23770	9	v.	v.	NN
18637	23770	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23770	11	Weeks	Weeks	NNP
18637	23770	12	,	,	,
18637	23770	13	259	259	CD
18637	23770	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23770	15	326	326	CD
18637	23770	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23770	17	1922	1922	CD
18637	23770	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23770	19	,	,	,
18637	23770	20	477	477	CD
18637	23770	21	Frick	Frick	NNP
18637	23770	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23770	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23770	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23770	25	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	23770	26	,	,	,
18637	23770	27	268	268	CD
18637	23770	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23770	29	473	473	CD
18637	23770	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23770	31	1925	1925	CD
18637	23770	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23770	33	,	,	,
18637	23770	34	1042	1042	CD
18637	23770	35	,	,	,
18637	23770	36	1045	1045	CD
18637	23770	37	Fries	Fries	NNP
18637	23770	38	Case	Case	NNP
18637	23770	39	,	,	,
18637	23770	40	9	9	CD
18637	23770	41	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	23770	42	.	.	.
18637	23771	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	23771	2	.	.	.
18637	23772	1	No	no	UH
18637	23772	2	.	.	.
18637	23773	1	5126	5126	CD
18637	23773	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23773	3	1799	1799	CD
18637	23773	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23773	5	,	,	,
18637	23773	6	640	640	CD
18637	23773	7	Fries	Fries	NNPS
18637	23773	8	Case	Case	NNP
18637	23773	9	,	,	,
18637	23773	10	9	9	CD
18637	23773	11	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	23773	12	.	.	.
18637	23774	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	23774	2	.	.	.
18637	23775	1	No	no	UH
18637	23775	2	.	.	.
18637	23776	1	5127	5127	CD
18637	23776	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23776	3	1800	1800	CD
18637	23776	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23776	5	,	,	,
18637	23776	6	640	640	CD
18637	23776	7	Frisbie	Frisbie	NNP
18637	23776	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23776	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23776	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23776	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23776	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23776	13	,	,	,
18637	23776	14	157	157	CD
18637	23776	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23776	16	160	160	CD
18637	23776	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23776	18	1895	1895	CD
18637	23776	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23776	20	,	,	,
18637	23776	21	857	857	CD
18637	23776	22	Frohwerk	Frohwerk	NNP
18637	23776	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23776	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23776	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23776	26	United	United	NNP
18637	23776	27	States	States	NNP
18637	23776	28	,	,	,
18637	23776	29	249	249	CD
18637	23776	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23776	31	204	204	CD
18637	23776	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23776	33	1919	1919	CD
18637	23776	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23776	35	,	,	,
18637	23776	36	297	297	CD
18637	23776	37	,	,	,
18637	23776	38	774	774	CD
18637	23776	39	,	,	,
18637	23776	40	794	794	CD
18637	23776	41	Frost	Frost	NNP
18637	23776	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23776	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23776	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23776	45	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	23776	46	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23776	47	,	,	,
18637	23776	48	278	278	CD
18637	23776	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23776	50	515	515	CD
18637	23776	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23776	52	1929	1929	CD
18637	23776	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23776	54	,	,	,
18637	23776	55	1145	1145	CD
18637	23776	56	Frost	Frost	NNP
18637	23776	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23776	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	23776	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23776	60	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	23776	61	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23776	62	,	,	,
18637	23776	63	271	271	CD
18637	23776	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23776	65	583	583	CD
18637	23776	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23776	67	1926	1926	CD
18637	23776	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23776	69	,	,	,
18637	23776	70	1032	1032	CD
18637	23776	71	Frothingham	Frothingham	NNP
18637	23776	72	_	_	NNP
18637	23776	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	23776	74	_	_	NNP
18637	23776	75	Mellon	Mellon	NNP
18637	23776	76	,	,	,
18637	23776	77	262	262	CD
18637	23776	78	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23776	79	447	447	CD
18637	23776	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23776	81	1923	1923	CD
18637	23776	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23776	83	,	,	,
18637	23776	84	114	114	CD
18637	23776	85	Fuller	Fuller	NNP
18637	23776	86	,	,	,
18637	23776	87	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23776	88	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23776	89	,	,	,
18637	23776	90	262	262	CD
18637	23776	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23776	92	91	91	CD
18637	23776	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23776	94	1923	1923	CD
18637	23776	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23776	96	,	,	,
18637	23776	97	827	827	CD
18637	23776	98	,	,	,
18637	23776	99	843	843	CD
18637	23776	100	Funk	Funk	NNP
18637	23776	101	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	23777	1	Seed	Seed	NNP
18637	23777	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23777	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23777	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23777	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23777	6	Kalo	Kalo	NNP
18637	23777	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23777	8	,	,	,
18637	23777	9	333	333	CD
18637	23777	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23777	11	127	127	CD
18637	23777	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23777	13	1948	1948	CD
18637	23777	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23777	15	,	,	,
18637	23777	16	272	272	CD
18637	23777	17	G	G	NNP
18637	23777	18	Gagnon	Gagnon	NNP
18637	23777	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23777	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	23777	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23777	22	United	United	NNP
18637	23777	23	States	States	NNP
18637	23777	24	,	,	,
18637	23777	25	193	193	CD
18637	23777	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23777	27	451	451	CD
18637	23777	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23777	29	1904	1904	CD
18637	23777	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23777	31	,	,	,
18637	23777	32	526	526	CD
18637	23777	33	Gaines	Gaines	NNPS
18637	23777	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23777	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23777	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23777	37	Fuentes	Fuentes	NNP
18637	23777	38	,	,	,
18637	23777	39	92	92	CD
18637	23777	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23777	41	10	10	CD
18637	23777	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23777	43	1876	1876	CD
18637	23777	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23777	45	,	,	,
18637	23777	46	524	524	CD
18637	23777	47	,	,	,
18637	23777	48	619	619	CD
18637	23777	49	Gaines	Gaines	NNPS
18637	23777	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23777	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	23777	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23777	53	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	23777	54	,	,	,
18637	23777	55	277	277	CD
18637	23777	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23777	57	81	81	CD
18637	23777	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23777	59	1928	1928	CD
18637	23777	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23777	61	,	,	,
18637	23777	62	1098	1098	CD
18637	23777	63	,	,	,
18637	23777	64	1130	1130	CD
18637	23777	65	Gallegos	Gallegos	NNP
18637	23777	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23777	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23777	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23777	69	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	23777	70	,	,	,
18637	23777	71	342	342	CD
18637	23777	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23777	73	55	55	CD
18637	23777	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23777	75	1951	1951	CD
18637	23777	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23777	77	,	,	,
18637	23777	78	1107	1107	CD
18637	23777	79	Galloway	Galloway	NNP
18637	23777	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23777	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	23777	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23777	83	United	United	NNP
18637	23777	84	States	States	NNP
18637	23777	85	,	,	,
18637	23777	86	319	319	CD
18637	23777	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23777	88	372	372	CD
18637	23777	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23777	90	1943	1943	CD
18637	23777	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23777	92	,	,	,
18637	23777	93	893	893	CD
18637	23777	94	,	,	,
18637	23777	95	897	897	CD
18637	23777	96	Galpin	Galpin	NNP
18637	23777	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23777	98	v.	v.	IN
18637	23777	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23777	100	Page	Page	NNP
18637	23777	101	,	,	,
18637	23777	102	18	18	CD
18637	23777	103	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23777	104	.	.	.
18637	23778	1	350	350	CD
18637	23778	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23778	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	23778	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23778	5	,	,	,
18637	23778	6	659	659	CD
18637	23778	7	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	23778	8	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	23778	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23778	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23778	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23778	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23778	13	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	23778	14	,	,	,
18637	23778	15	258	258	CD
18637	23778	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23778	17	388	388	CD
18637	23778	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23778	19	1922	1922	CD
18637	23778	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23778	21	,	,	,
18637	23778	22	1006	1006	CD
18637	23778	23	,	,	,
18637	23778	24	1008	1008	CD
18637	23778	25	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	23778	26	,	,	,
18637	23778	27	H.	H.	NNP
18637	23778	28	&	&	CC
18637	23778	29	S.A.	S.A.	NNP
18637	23778	30	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	23778	31	.	.	.
18637	23779	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23779	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23779	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23779	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23779	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23779	6	,	,	,
18637	23779	7	170	170	CD
18637	23779	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23779	9	226	226	CD
18637	23779	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23779	11	1898	1898	CD
18637	23779	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23779	13	,	,	,
18637	23779	14	200	200	CD
18637	23779	15	,	,	,
18637	23779	16	567	567	CD
18637	23779	17	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	23779	18	,	,	,
18637	23779	19	H.	H.	NNP
18637	23779	20	&	&	CC
18637	23779	21	S.A.	S.A.	NNP
18637	23779	22	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	23779	23	.	.	.
18637	23780	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23780	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23780	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23780	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23780	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23780	6	,	,	,
18637	23780	7	210	210	CD
18637	23780	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23780	9	217	217	CD
18637	23780	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23780	11	1908	1908	CD
18637	23780	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23780	13	,	,	,
18637	23780	14	202	202	CD
18637	23780	15	,	,	,
18637	23780	16	203	203	CD
18637	23780	17	,	,	,
18637	23780	18	204	204	CD
18637	23780	19	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	23780	20	Wharf	Wharf	NNP
18637	23780	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23780	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23780	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23780	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23780	25	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	23780	26	,	,	,
18637	23780	27	260	260	CD
18637	23780	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23780	29	473	473	CD
18637	23780	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23780	31	1923	1923	CD
18637	23780	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23780	33	,	,	,
18637	23780	34	1063	1063	CD
18637	23780	35	Gambino	Gambino	NNP
18637	23780	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23780	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23780	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23780	39	United	United	NNP
18637	23780	40	States	States	NNP
18637	23780	41	,	,	,
18637	23780	42	275	275	CD
18637	23780	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23780	44	310	310	CD
18637	23780	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23780	46	1927	1927	CD
18637	23780	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23780	48	,	,	,
18637	23780	49	831	831	CD
18637	23780	50	Games	Games	NNPS
18637	23780	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23780	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	23780	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23780	54	Dunn	Dunn	NNP
18637	23780	55	,	,	,
18637	23780	56	14	14	CD
18637	23780	57	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23780	58	.	.	.
18637	23781	1	322	322	CD
18637	23781	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23781	3	1840	1840	CD
18637	23781	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23781	5	,	,	,
18637	23781	6	896	896	CD
18637	23781	7	Gange	Gange	NNP
18637	23781	8	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	23781	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23781	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23781	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23781	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23781	13	Rowley	Rowley	NNP
18637	23781	14	,	,	,
18637	23781	15	326	326	CD
18637	23781	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23781	17	295	295	CD
18637	23781	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23781	19	1945	1945	CD
18637	23781	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23781	21	,	,	,
18637	23781	22	1093	1093	CD
18637	23781	23	Gant	Gant	NNP
18637	23781	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23781	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23781	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23781	27	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	23781	28	City	City	NNP
18637	23781	29	,	,	,
18637	23781	30	289	289	CD
18637	23781	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23781	32	98	98	CD
18637	23781	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23781	34	1933	1933	CD
18637	23781	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23781	36	,	,	,
18637	23781	37	1026	1026	CD
18637	23781	38	Gardner	Gardner	NNP
18637	23781	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23781	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23781	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23781	42	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	23781	43	,	,	,
18637	23781	44	6	6	CD
18637	23781	45	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23781	46	.	.	.
18637	23782	1	499	499	CD
18637	23782	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23782	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	23782	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23782	5	,	,	,
18637	23782	6	103	103	CD
18637	23782	7	Garfield	Garfield	NNP
18637	23782	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23782	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23782	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23782	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23782	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23782	13	,	,	,
18637	23782	14	211	211	CD
18637	23782	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23782	16	249	249	CD
18637	23782	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23782	18	1908	1908	CD
18637	23782	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23782	20	,	,	,
18637	23782	21	864	864	CD
18637	23782	22	Garland	Garland	NNP
18637	23782	23	,	,	,
18637	23782	24	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23782	25	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23782	26	,	,	,
18637	23782	27	4	4	CD
18637	23782	28	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23782	29	.	.	.
18637	23783	1	333	333	CD
18637	23783	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23783	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	23783	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23783	5	,	,	,
18637	23783	6	316	316	CD
18637	23783	7	,	,	,
18637	23783	8	317	317	CD
18637	23783	9	,	,	,
18637	23783	10	409	409	CD
18637	23783	11	,	,	,
18637	23783	12	512	512	CD
18637	23783	13	,	,	,
18637	23783	14	527	527	CD
18637	23783	15	,	,	,
18637	23783	16	736	736	CD
18637	23783	17	Garner	Garner	NNP
18637	23783	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23783	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23783	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23783	21	Los	Los	NNP
18637	23783	22	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	23783	23	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23783	24	,	,	,
18637	23783	25	341	341	CD
18637	23783	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23783	27	716	716	CD
18637	23783	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23783	29	1951	1951	CD
18637	23783	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23783	31	,	,	,
18637	23783	32	801	801	CD
18637	23783	33	Garnett	Garnett	NNP
18637	23783	34	,	,	,
18637	23783	35	In	in	IN
18637	23783	36	re	re	NN
18637	23783	37	,	,	,
18637	23783	38	141	141	CD
18637	23783	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23783	40	1	1	CD
18637	23783	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23783	42	1891	1891	CD
18637	23783	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23783	44	,	,	,
18637	23783	45	575	575	CD
18637	23783	46	,	,	,
18637	23783	47	577	577	CD
18637	23783	48	,	,	,
18637	23783	49	583	583	CD
18637	23783	50	Garrison	Garrison	NNP
18637	23783	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23783	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	23783	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23783	54	New	New	NNP
18637	23783	55	York	York	NNP
18637	23783	56	,	,	,
18637	23783	57	21	21	CD
18637	23783	58	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23783	59	.	.	.
18637	23784	1	196	196	CD
18637	23784	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23784	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	23784	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23784	5	,	,	,
18637	23784	6	352	352	CD
18637	23784	7	Gasoline	Gasoline	NNP
18637	23784	8	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	23784	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23784	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23784	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23784	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23784	13	Champlin	Champlin	NNP
18637	23784	14	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	23784	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23784	16	,	,	,
18637	23784	17	283	283	CD
18637	23784	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23784	19	494	494	CD
18637	23784	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23784	21	1931	1931	CD
18637	23784	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23784	23	,	,	,
18637	23784	24	892	892	CD
18637	23784	25	Gasquet	Gasquet	NNP
18637	23784	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23784	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23784	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23784	29	Fenner	Fenner	NNP
18637	23784	30	,	,	,
18637	23784	31	247	247	CD
18637	23784	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23784	33	16	16	CD
18637	23784	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23784	35	1918	1918	CD
18637	23784	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23784	37	,	,	,
18637	23784	38	673	673	CD
18637	23784	39	Gasquet	Gasquet	NNP
18637	23784	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23784	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23784	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23784	43	Lapeyre	Lapeyre	NNP
18637	23784	44	,	,	,
18637	23784	45	242	242	CD
18637	23784	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23784	47	367	367	CD
18637	23784	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23784	49	1917	1917	CD
18637	23784	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23784	51	,	,	,
18637	23784	52	313	313	CD
18637	23784	53	Gassies	Gassies	NNPS
18637	23784	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23784	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	23784	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23784	57	Ballon	Ballon	NNP
18637	23784	58	,	,	,
18637	23784	59	6	6	CD
18637	23784	60	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	23784	61	.	.	.
18637	23785	1	761	761	CD
18637	23785	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23785	3	1832	1832	CD
18637	23785	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23785	5	,	,	,
18637	23785	6	255	255	CD
18637	23785	7	Gayes	Gayes	NNP
18637	23785	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23785	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23785	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23785	11	New	New	NNP
18637	23785	12	York	York	NNP
18637	23785	13	,	,	,
18637	23785	14	332	332	CD
18637	23785	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23785	16	145	145	CD
18637	23785	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23785	18	1947	1947	CD
18637	23785	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23785	20	,	,	,
18637	23785	21	1103	1103	CD
18637	23785	22	Gee	Gee	NNP
18637	23785	23	Wah	Wah	NNP
18637	23785	24	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	23785	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23785	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23785	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23785	28	United	United	NNP
18637	23785	29	States	States	NNP
18637	23785	30	,	,	,
18637	23785	31	25	25	CD
18637	23785	32	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23785	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23785	34	2d	2d	NNP
18637	23785	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23785	36	107	107	CD
18637	23785	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23785	38	1928	1928	CD
18637	23785	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23785	40	,	,	,
18637	23785	41	893	893	CD
18637	23785	42	Gee	Gee	NNP
18637	23785	43	Wah	Wah	NNP
18637	23785	44	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	23785	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23785	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	23785	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23785	48	United	United	NNP
18637	23785	49	States	States	NNP
18637	23785	50	,	,	,
18637	23785	51	277	277	CD
18637	23785	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23785	53	608	608	CD
18637	23785	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23785	55	1928	1928	CD
18637	23785	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23785	57	,	,	,
18637	23785	58	893	893	CD
18637	23785	59	Geer	Geer	NNP
18637	23785	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23785	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23785	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23785	63	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	23785	64	,	,	,
18637	23785	65	161	161	CD
18637	23785	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23785	67	519	519	CD
18637	23785	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23785	69	1896	1896	CD
18637	23785	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23785	71	,	,	,
18637	23785	72	242	242	CD
18637	23785	73	,	,	,
18637	23785	74	245	245	CD
18637	23785	75	,	,	,
18637	23785	76	690	690	CD
18637	23785	77	,	,	,
18637	23785	78	1027	1027	CD
18637	23785	79	Gelfert	Gelfert	NNP
18637	23785	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23785	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	23785	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23785	83	National	National	NNP
18637	23785	84	City	City	NNP
18637	23785	85	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23785	86	,	,	,
18637	23785	87	313	313	CD
18637	23785	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23785	89	221	221	CD
18637	23785	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23785	91	1941	1941	CD
18637	23785	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23785	93	,	,	,
18637	23785	94	361	361	CD
18637	23785	95	Gelpcke	Gelpcke	NNP
18637	23785	96	_	_	NNP
18637	23785	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	23785	98	_	_	NNP
18637	23785	99	Dubuque	Dubuque	NNP
18637	23785	100	,	,	,
18637	23785	101	1	1	CD
18637	23785	102	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23785	103	.	.	.
18637	23786	1	175	175	CD
18637	23786	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23786	3	1864	1864	CD
18637	23786	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23786	5	,	,	,
18637	23786	6	331	331	CD
18637	23786	7	,	,	,
18637	23786	8	604	604	CD
18637	23786	9	,	,	,
18637	23786	10	605	605	CD
18637	23786	11	Gemsco	Gemsco	NNP
18637	23786	12	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	23786	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23786	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	23786	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23786	16	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	23786	17	,	,	,
18637	23786	18	324	324	CD
18637	23786	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23786	20	244	244	CD
18637	23786	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23786	22	1945	1945	CD
18637	23786	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23786	24	,	,	,
18637	23786	25	157	157	CD
18637	23786	26	General	General	NNP
18637	23786	27	Investment	Investment	NNP
18637	23786	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23786	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23786	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	23786	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23786	32	New	New	NNP
18637	23786	33	York	York	NNP
18637	23786	34	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23786	35	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23786	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23786	37	,	,	,
18637	23786	38	271	271	CD
18637	23786	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23786	40	228	228	CD
18637	23786	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23786	42	1926	1926	CD
18637	23786	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23786	44	,	,	,
18637	23786	45	512	512	CD
18637	23786	46	General	General	NNP
18637	23786	47	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	23786	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23786	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23786	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	23786	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23786	52	Crain	Crain	NNP
18637	23786	53	,	,	,
18637	23786	54	209	209	CD
18637	23786	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23786	56	211	211	CD
18637	23786	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23786	58	1908	1908	CD
18637	23786	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23786	60	,	,	,
18637	23786	61	185	185	CD
18637	23786	62	General	General	NNP
18637	23786	63	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	23786	64	Signal	Signal	NNP
18637	23786	65	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23786	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23786	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23786	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23786	69	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	23786	70	,	,	,
18637	23786	71	246	246	CD
18637	23786	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23786	73	500	500	CD
18637	23786	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23786	75	1918	1918	CD
18637	23786	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23786	77	,	,	,
18637	23786	78	121	121	CD
18637	23786	79	General	General	NNP
18637	23786	80	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	23786	81	,	,	,
18637	23786	82	The	the	DT
18637	23786	83	,	,	,
18637	23786	84	4	4	CD
18637	23786	85	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23786	86	.	.	.
18637	23787	1	438	438	CD
18637	23787	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23787	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	23787	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23787	5	,	,	,
18637	23787	6	574	574	CD
18637	23787	7	General	General	NNP
18637	23787	8	Trading	Trading	NNP
18637	23787	9	Company	Company	NNP
18637	23787	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23787	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23787	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23787	13	State	State	NNP
18637	23787	14	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23787	15	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23787	16	,	,	,
18637	23787	17	322	322	CD
18637	23787	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23787	19	335	335	CD
18637	23787	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23787	21	1944	1944	CD
18637	23787	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23787	23	,	,	,
18637	23787	24	190	190	CD
18637	23787	25	Genesee	Genesee	NNP
18637	23787	26	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	23787	27	,	,	,
18637	23787	28	The	the	DT
18637	23787	29	,	,	,
18637	23787	30	12	12	CD
18637	23787	31	How	how	WRB
18637	23787	32	.	.	.
18637	23788	1	443	443	CD
18637	23788	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23788	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	23788	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23788	5	,	,	,
18637	23788	6	577	577	CD
18637	23788	7	Geofroy	Geofroy	NNP
18637	23788	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23788	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23788	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23788	11	Riggs	Riggs	NNP
18637	23788	12	,	,	,
18637	23788	13	133	133	CD
18637	23788	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23788	15	258	258	CD
18637	23788	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23788	17	1890	1890	CD
18637	23788	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23788	19	,	,	,
18637	23788	20	428	428	CD
18637	23788	21	,	,	,
18637	23788	22	429	429	CD
18637	23788	23	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23788	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23788	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23788	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23788	27	Brailsford	Brailsford	NNP
18637	23788	28	,	,	,
18637	23788	29	2	2	CD
18637	23788	30	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	23788	31	.	.	.
18637	23789	1	402	402	CD
18637	23789	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23789	3	1792	1792	CD
18637	23789	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23789	5	,	,	,
18637	23789	6	612	612	CD
18637	23789	7	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23789	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23789	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23789	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23789	11	Chattanooga	Chattanooga	NNP
18637	23789	12	,	,	,
18637	23789	13	264	264	CD
18637	23789	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23789	15	472	472	CD
18637	23789	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23789	17	1924	1924	CD
18637	23789	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23789	19	,	,	,
18637	23789	20	1069	1069	CD
18637	23789	21	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23789	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23789	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23789	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23789	25	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	23789	26	,	,	,
18637	23789	27	316	316	CD
18637	23789	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23789	29	159	159	CD
18637	23789	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23789	31	1942	1942	CD
18637	23789	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23789	33	,	,	,
18637	23789	34	598	598	CD
18637	23789	35	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23789	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23789	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23789	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23789	39	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	23789	40	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23789	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23789	42	,	,	,
18637	23789	43	324	324	CD
18637	23789	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23789	45	439	439	CD
18637	23789	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23789	47	1945	1945	CD
18637	23789	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23789	49	,	,	,
18637	23789	50	544	544	CD
18637	23789	51	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23789	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23789	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	23789	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23789	55	Stanton	Stanton	NNP
18637	23789	56	,	,	,
18637	23789	57	6	6	CD
18637	23789	58	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23789	59	.	.	.
18637	23790	1	50	50	CD
18637	23790	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23790	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	23790	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23790	5	,	,	,
18637	23790	6	543	543	CD
18637	23790	7	,	,	,
18637	23790	8	545	545	CD
18637	23790	9	,	,	,
18637	23790	10	548	548	CD
18637	23790	11	,	,	,
18637	23790	12	596	596	CD
18637	23790	13	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23790	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23790	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23790	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23790	17	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	23790	18	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	23790	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23790	20	,	,	,
18637	23790	21	206	206	CD
18637	23790	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23790	23	230	230	CD
18637	23790	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23790	25	1907	1907	CD
18637	23790	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23790	27	,	,	,
18637	23790	28	544	544	CD
18637	23790	29	,	,	,
18637	23790	30	598	598	CD
18637	23790	31	,	,	,
18637	23790	32	599	599	CD
18637	23790	33	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23790	34	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23790	35	&	&	CC
18637	23790	36	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23790	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23790	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23790	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23790	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23790	41	Decatur	Decatur	NNP
18637	23790	42	,	,	,
18637	23790	43	262	262	CD
18637	23790	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23790	45	432	432	CD
18637	23790	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23790	47	1923	1923	CD
18637	23790	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23790	49	,	,	,
18637	23790	50	349	349	CD
18637	23790	51	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23790	52	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23790	53	&	&	CC
18637	23790	54	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23790	55	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23790	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23790	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	23790	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23790	59	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	23790	60	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	23790	61	.	.	NNP
18637	23790	62	,	,	,
18637	23790	63	262	262	CD
18637	23790	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23790	65	625	625	CD
18637	23790	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23790	67	1923	1923	CD
18637	23790	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23790	69	,	,	,
18637	23790	70	1002	1002	CD
18637	23790	71	,	,	,
18637	23790	72	1006	1006	CD
18637	23790	73	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23790	74	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23790	75	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23790	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23790	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	23790	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23790	79	Redwine	Redwine	NNP
18637	23790	80	,	,	,
18637	23790	81	342	342	CD
18637	23790	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23790	83	299	299	CD
18637	23790	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23790	85	1952	1952	CD
18637	23790	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23790	87	,	,	,
18637	23790	88	351	351	CD
18637	23790	89	,	,	,
18637	23790	90	934	934	CD
18637	23790	91	Gerling	Gerling	NNP
18637	23790	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23790	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	23790	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23790	95	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23790	96	&	&	CC
18637	23790	97	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	23791	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23791	2	,	,	,
18637	23791	3	151	151	CD
18637	23791	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23791	5	673	673	CD
18637	23791	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23791	7	1894	1894	CD
18637	23791	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23791	9	,	,	,
18637	23791	10	638	638	CD
18637	23791	11	German	German	NNP
18637	23791	12	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	23791	13	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23791	14	.	.	.
18637	23792	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23792	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23792	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23792	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23792	5	Hale	Hale	NNP
18637	23792	6	,	,	,
18637	23792	7	219	219	CD
18637	23792	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23792	9	307	307	CD
18637	23792	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23792	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	23792	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23792	13	,	,	,
18637	23792	14	1022	1022	CD
18637	23792	15	German	German	NNP
18637	23792	16	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	23792	17	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23792	18	.	.	.
18637	23793	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23793	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23793	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23793	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23793	5	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	23793	6	,	,	,
18637	23793	7	233	233	CD
18637	23793	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23793	9	389	389	CD
18637	23793	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23793	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	23793	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23793	13	,	,	,
18637	23793	14	996	996	CD
18637	23793	15	,	,	,
18637	23793	16	1021	1021	CD
18637	23793	17	,	,	,
18637	23793	18	1155	1155	CD
18637	23793	19	German	German	NNP
18637	23793	20	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	23793	21	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	23793	22	Society	Society	NNP
18637	23793	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23793	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23793	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23793	26	Dormitzer	Dormitzer	NNP
18637	23793	27	,	,	,
18637	23793	28	192	192	CD
18637	23793	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23793	30	125	125	CD
18637	23793	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23793	32	1904	1904	CD
18637	23793	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23793	34	,	,	,
18637	23793	35	662	662	CD
18637	23793	36	Gibbes	Gibbes	NNPS
18637	23793	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23793	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	23793	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23793	40	Zimmerman	Zimmerman	NNP
18637	23793	41	,	,	,
18637	23793	42	290	290	CD
18637	23793	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23793	44	326	326	CD
18637	23793	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23793	46	1933	1933	CD
18637	23793	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23793	48	,	,	,
18637	23793	49	1020	1020	CD
18637	23793	50	,	,	,
18637	23793	51	1035	1035	CD
18637	23793	52	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNPS
18637	23793	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23793	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	23793	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23793	56	District	District	NNP
18637	23793	57	of	of	IN
18637	23793	58	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23793	59	,	,	,
18637	23793	60	116	116	CD
18637	23793	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23793	62	404	404	CD
18637	23793	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23793	64	1886	1886	CD
18637	23793	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23793	66	,	,	,
18637	23793	67	304	304	CD
18637	23793	68	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNPS
18637	23793	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23793	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	23793	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23793	72	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	23793	73	,	,	,
18637	23793	74	9	9	CD
18637	23793	75	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23793	76	1	1	CD
18637	23793	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23793	78	1824	1824	CD
18637	23793	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23793	80	,	,	,
18637	23793	81	118	118	CD
18637	23793	82	,	,	,
18637	23793	83	121	121	CD
18637	23793	84	,	,	,
18637	23793	85	122	122	CD
18637	23793	86	,	,	,
18637	23793	87	125	125	CD
18637	23793	88	,	,	,
18637	23793	89	151	151	CD
18637	23793	90	,	,	,
18637	23793	91	156	156	CD
18637	23793	92	,	,	,
18637	23793	93	161	161	CD
18637	23793	94	,	,	,
18637	23793	95	162	162	CD
18637	23793	96	,	,	,
18637	23793	97	166	166	CD
18637	23793	98	,	,	,
18637	23793	99	169	169	CD
18637	23793	100	,	,	,
18637	23793	101	174	174	CD
18637	23793	102	,	,	,
18637	23793	103	175	175	CD
18637	23793	104	,	,	,
18637	23793	105	176	176	CD
18637	23793	106	,	,	,
18637	23793	107	192	192	CD
18637	23793	108	,	,	,
18637	23793	109	215	215	CD
18637	23793	110	,	,	,
18637	23793	111	228	228	CD
18637	23793	112	,	,	,
18637	23793	113	246	246	CD
18637	23793	114	,	,	,
18637	23793	115	721	721	CD
18637	23793	116	,	,	,
18637	23793	117	723	723	CD
18637	23793	118	,	,	,
18637	23793	119	735	735	CD
18637	23793	120	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNPS
18637	23793	121	_	_	NNP
18637	23793	122	v.	v.	IN
18637	23793	123	_	_	NNP
18637	23793	124	United	United	NNP
18637	23793	125	States	States	NNP
18637	23793	126	,	,	,
18637	23793	127	8	8	CD
18637	23793	128	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23793	129	.	.	.
18637	23794	1	269	269	CD
18637	23794	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23794	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	23794	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23794	5	,	,	,
18637	23794	6	586	586	CD
18637	23794	7	Gibbs	Gibbs	NNPS
18637	23794	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23794	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23794	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23794	11	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	23794	12	,	,	,
18637	23794	13	337	337	CD
18637	23794	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23794	15	773	773	CD
18637	23794	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23794	17	1949	1949	CD
18637	23794	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23794	19	,	,	,
18637	23794	20	1107	1107	CD
18637	23794	21	,	,	,
18637	23794	22	1109	1109	CD
18637	23794	23	Giboney	Giboney	NNP
18637	23794	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23794	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23794	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23794	27	Empire	Empire	NNP
18637	23794	28	Storage	Storage	NNP
18637	23794	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23794	30	,	,	,
18637	23794	31	336	336	CD
18637	23794	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23794	33	490	490	CD
18637	23794	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23794	35	1949	1949	CD
18637	23794	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23794	37	,	,	,
18637	23794	38	782	782	CD
18637	23794	39	,	,	,
18637	23794	40	994	994	CD
18637	23794	41	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	23794	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23794	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23794	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23794	45	Chouteau	Chouteau	NNP
18637	23794	46	,	,	,
18637	23794	47	13	13	CD
18637	23794	48	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23794	49	.	.	.
18637	23795	1	92	92	CD
18637	23795	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23795	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	23795	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23795	5	,	,	,
18637	23795	6	702	702	CD
18637	23795	7	,	,	,
18637	23795	8	703	703	CD
18637	23795	9	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	23795	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23795	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	13	Lyon	Lyon	NNP
18637	23795	14	,	,	,
18637	23795	15	115	115	CD
18637	23795	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23795	17	439	439	CD
18637	23795	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23795	19	1885	1885	CD
18637	23795	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23795	21	,	,	,
18637	23795	22	684	684	CD
18637	23795	23	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	23795	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23795	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	27	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	23795	28	,	,	,
18637	23795	29	162	162	CD
18637	23795	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23795	31	565	565	CD
18637	23795	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23795	33	1896	1896	CD
18637	23795	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23795	35	,	,	,
18637	23795	36	329	329	CD
18637	23795	37	,	,	,
18637	23795	38	1169	1169	CD
18637	23795	39	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	23795	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23795	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	43	United	United	NNP
18637	23795	44	States	States	NNP
18637	23795	45	,	,	,
18637	23795	46	166	166	CD
18637	23795	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23795	48	269	269	CD
18637	23795	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23795	50	1897	1897	CD
18637	23795	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23795	52	,	,	,
18637	23795	53	128	128	CD
18637	23795	54	,	,	,
18637	23795	55	868	868	CD
18637	23795	56	Gilbert	Gilbert	NNP
18637	23795	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	23795	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	60	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23795	61	,	,	,
18637	23795	62	254	254	CD
18637	23795	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23795	64	325	325	CD
18637	23795	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23795	66	1920	1920	CD
18637	23795	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23795	68	,	,	,
18637	23795	69	297	297	CD
18637	23795	70	,	,	,
18637	23795	71	794	794	CD
18637	23795	72	Gilchrist	Gilchrist	NNP
18637	23795	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	23795	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	76	Interborough	Interborough	NNP
18637	23795	77	Rapid	Rapid	NNP
18637	23795	78	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	23795	79	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23795	80	,	,	,
18637	23795	81	279	279	CD
18637	23795	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23795	83	159	159	CD
18637	23795	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23795	85	1929	1929	CD
18637	23795	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23795	87	,	,	,
18637	23795	88	570	570	CD
18637	23795	89	,	,	,
18637	23795	90	631	631	CD
18637	23795	91	Giles	Giles	NNPS
18637	23795	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	23795	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	95	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	23795	96	,	,	,
18637	23795	97	189	189	CD
18637	23795	98	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23795	99	475	475	CD
18637	23795	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23795	101	1903	1903	CD
18637	23795	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23795	103	,	,	,
18637	23795	104	544	544	CD
18637	23795	105	,	,	,
18637	23795	106	1164	1164	CD
18637	23795	107	Gilfillan	Gilfillan	NNP
18637	23795	108	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	109	v.	v.	IN
18637	23795	110	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	111	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23795	112	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	23795	113	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23795	114	,	,	,
18637	23795	115	109	109	CD
18637	23795	116	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23795	117	401	401	CD
18637	23795	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23795	119	1883	1883	CD
18637	23795	120	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23795	121	,	,	,
18637	23795	122	355	355	CD
18637	23795	123	Gillespie	Gillespie	NNP
18637	23795	124	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	125	v.	v.	IN
18637	23795	126	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	127	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	23795	128	,	,	,
18637	23795	129	257	257	CD
18637	23795	130	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23795	131	501	501	CD
18637	23795	132	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23795	133	1922	1922	CD
18637	23795	134	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23795	135	,	,	,
18637	23795	136	735	735	CD
18637	23795	137	Gilman	Gilman	NNP
18637	23795	138	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	139	v.	v.	IN
18637	23795	140	_	_	NNP
18637	23795	141	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	23795	142	,	,	,
18637	23795	143	3	3	CD
18637	23795	144	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23795	145	.	.	.
18637	23796	1	713	713	CD
18637	23796	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	23796	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	5	,	,	,
18637	23796	6	127	127	CD
18637	23796	7	,	,	,
18637	23796	8	180	180	CD
18637	23796	9	Giozza	Giozza	NNP
18637	23796	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	13	Tiernan	Tiernan	NNP
18637	23796	14	,	,	,
18637	23796	15	148	148	CD
18637	23796	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	17	657	657	CD
18637	23796	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	19	1893	1893	CD
18637	23796	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	21	,	,	,
18637	23796	22	971	971	CD
18637	23796	23	,	,	,
18637	23796	24	1149	1149	CD
18637	23796	25	Girouard	Girouard	NNP
18637	23796	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	29	United	United	NNP
18637	23796	30	States	States	NNP
18637	23796	31	,	,	,
18637	23796	32	328	328	CD
18637	23796	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	34	61	61	CD
18637	23796	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	36	1946	1946	CD
18637	23796	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	38	,	,	,
18637	23796	39	257	257	CD
18637	23796	40	,	,	,
18637	23796	41	768	768	CD
18637	23796	42	Gitlow	Gitlow	NNP
18637	23796	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	46	New	New	NNP
18637	23796	47	York	York	NNP
18637	23796	48	,	,	,
18637	23796	49	268	268	CD
18637	23796	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	51	652	652	CD
18637	23796	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	53	1925	1925	CD
18637	23796	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	55	,	,	,
18637	23796	56	752	752	CD
18637	23796	57	,	,	,
18637	23796	58	757	757	CD
18637	23796	59	,	,	,
18637	23796	60	775	775	CD
18637	23796	61	,	,	,
18637	23796	62	778	778	CD
18637	23796	63	,	,	,
18637	23796	64	798	798	CD
18637	23796	65	Given	give	VBN
18637	23796	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	69	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	23796	70	,	,	,
18637	23796	71	117	117	CD
18637	23796	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	73	648	648	CD
18637	23796	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	75	1886	1886	CD
18637	23796	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	77	,	,	,
18637	23796	78	336	336	CD
18637	23796	79	Givens	Givens	NNP
18637	23796	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	83	Zerbst	Zerbst	NNP
18637	23796	84	,	,	,
18637	23796	85	255	255	CD
18637	23796	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	87	11	11	CD
18637	23796	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	89	1921	1921	CD
18637	23796	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	91	,	,	,
18637	23796	92	404	404	CD
18637	23796	93	Gladson	Gladson	NNP
18637	23796	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	96	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	97	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23796	98	,	,	,
18637	23796	99	166	166	CD
18637	23796	100	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	101	427	427	CD
18637	23796	102	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	103	1897	1897	CD
18637	23796	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	105	,	,	,
18637	23796	106	221	221	CD
18637	23796	107	,	,	,
18637	23796	108	270	270	CD
18637	23796	109	,	,	,
18637	23796	110	1012	1012	CD
18637	23796	111	Glasgow	Glasgow	NNP
18637	23796	112	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	114	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	115	Moyer	Moyer	NNP
18637	23796	116	,	,	,
18637	23796	117	225	225	CD
18637	23796	118	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	119	420	420	CD
18637	23796	120	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	121	1912	1912	CD
18637	23796	122	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	123	,	,	,
18637	23796	124	314	314	CD
18637	23796	125	Glasser	Glasser	NNP
18637	23796	126	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	127	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	128	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	129	United	United	NNP
18637	23796	130	States	States	NNP
18637	23796	131	,	,	,
18637	23796	132	315	315	CD
18637	23796	133	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	134	60	60	CD
18637	23796	135	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	136	1942	1942	CD
18637	23796	137	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	138	,	,	,
18637	23796	139	885	885	CD
18637	23796	140	Glenn	Glenn	NNP
18637	23796	141	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	142	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	143	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	144	Garth	Garth	NNP
18637	23796	145	,	,	,
18637	23796	146	147	147	CD
18637	23796	147	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	148	360	360	CD
18637	23796	149	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	150	1893	1893	CD
18637	23796	151	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	152	,	,	,
18637	23796	153	676	676	CD
18637	23796	154	,	,	,
18637	23796	155	677	677	CD
18637	23796	156	Glidden	Glidden	NNP
18637	23796	157	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	158	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	159	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	160	Harrington	Harrington	NNP
18637	23796	161	,	,	,
18637	23796	162	189	189	CD
18637	23796	163	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	164	255	255	CD
18637	23796	165	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	166	1903	1903	CD
18637	23796	167	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	168	,	,	,
18637	23796	169	1057	1057	CD
18637	23796	170	,	,	,
18637	23796	171	1060	1060	CD
18637	23796	172	Gloucester	Gloucester	NNP
18637	23796	173	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	23796	174	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23796	175	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	176	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	177	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	178	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	23796	179	,	,	,
18637	23796	180	114	114	CD
18637	23796	181	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	182	196	196	CD
18637	23796	183	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	184	1885	1885	CD
18637	23796	185	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	186	,	,	,
18637	23796	187	192	192	CD
18637	23796	188	,	,	,
18637	23796	189	209	209	CD
18637	23796	190	,	,	,
18637	23796	191	231	231	CD
18637	23796	192	,	,	,
18637	23796	193	366	366	CD
18637	23796	194	Go	Go	NNP
18637	23796	195	-	-	HYPH
18637	23796	196	Bart	Bart	NNP
18637	23796	197	Importing	Importing	NNP
18637	23796	198	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23796	199	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	200	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	201	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	202	United	United	NNP
18637	23796	203	States	States	NNP
18637	23796	204	,	,	,
18637	23796	205	282	282	CD
18637	23796	206	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	207	344	344	CD
18637	23796	208	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	209	1931	1931	CD
18637	23796	210	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	211	,	,	,
18637	23796	212	828	828	CD
18637	23796	213	Goesaert	Goesaert	NNP
18637	23796	214	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	215	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	216	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	217	Cleary	Cleary	NNP
18637	23796	218	,	,	,
18637	23796	219	335	335	CD
18637	23796	220	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	221	464	464	CD
18637	23796	222	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	223	1948	1948	CD
18637	23796	224	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	225	,	,	,
18637	23796	226	1159	1159	CD
18637	23796	227	Goldey	Goldey	NNP
18637	23796	228	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	229	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	230	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	231	Morning	Morning	NNP
18637	23796	232	News	News	NNP
18637	23796	233	,	,	,
18637	23796	234	156	156	CD
18637	23796	235	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	236	518	518	CD
18637	23796	237	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	238	1895	1895	CD
18637	23796	239	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	240	,	,	,
18637	23796	241	660	660	CD
18637	23796	242	,	,	,
18637	23796	243	1077	1077	CD
18637	23796	244	Goldman	Goldman	NNP
18637	23796	245	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	246	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	247	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	248	United	United	NNP
18637	23796	249	States	States	NNP
18637	23796	250	,	,	,
18637	23796	251	316	316	CD
18637	23796	252	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	253	129	129	CD
18637	23796	254	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	255	1942	1942	CD
18637	23796	256	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	257	,	,	,
18637	23796	258	824	824	CD
18637	23796	259	Goltra	Goltra	NNP
18637	23796	260	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	261	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	262	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	263	Weeks	Weeks	NNP
18637	23796	264	,	,	,
18637	23796	265	271	271	CD
18637	23796	266	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	267	536	536	CD
18637	23796	268	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	269	1926	1926	CD
18637	23796	270	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	271	,	,	,
18637	23796	272	588	588	CD
18637	23796	273	,	,	,
18637	23796	274	589	589	CD
18637	23796	275	,	,	,
18637	23796	276	590	590	CD
18637	23796	277	Gompers	Gompers	NNPS
18637	23796	278	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	279	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	280	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	281	Bucks	Bucks	NNP
18637	23796	282	Stove	Stove	NNP
18637	23796	283	&	&	CC
18637	23796	284	Range	Range	NNP
18637	23796	285	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23796	286	,	,	,
18637	23796	287	221	221	CD
18637	23796	288	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	289	418	418	CD
18637	23796	290	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	291	1911	1911	CD
18637	23796	292	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	293	,	,	,
18637	23796	294	516	516	CD
18637	23796	295	,	,	,
18637	23796	296	786	786	CD
18637	23796	297	,	,	,
18637	23796	298	792	792	CD
18637	23796	299	Gompers	Gompers	NNPS
18637	23796	300	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	301	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	302	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	303	United	United	NNP
18637	23796	304	States	States	NNP
18637	23796	305	,	,	,
18637	23796	306	233	233	CD
18637	23796	307	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	308	604	604	CD
18637	23796	309	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	310	1914	1914	CD
18637	23796	311	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	312	,	,	,
18637	23796	313	521	521	CD
18637	23796	314	,	,	,
18637	23796	315	770	770	CD
18637	23796	316	,	,	,
18637	23796	317	878	878	CD
18637	23796	318	Gong	Gong	NNP
18637	23796	319	Lum	Lum	NNP
18637	23796	320	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	321	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	322	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	323	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	23796	324	,	,	,
18637	23796	325	275	275	CD
18637	23796	326	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	327	78	78	CD
18637	23796	328	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	329	1927	1927	CD
18637	23796	330	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	331	,	,	,
18637	23796	332	1162	1162	CD
18637	23796	333	Gonsalves	Gonsalves	NNPS
18637	23796	334	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	335	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	336	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	337	Morse	Morse	NNP
18637	23796	338	Dry	Dry	NNP
18637	23796	339	Dock	Dock	NNP
18637	23796	340	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23796	341	,	,	,
18637	23796	342	266	266	CD
18637	23796	343	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	344	171	171	CD
18637	23796	345	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	346	1924	1924	CD
18637	23796	347	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	348	,	,	,
18637	23796	349	582	582	CD
18637	23796	350	Goodrich	Goodrich	NNP
18637	23796	351	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	352	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	353	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	354	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	23796	355	,	,	,
18637	23796	356	255	255	CD
18637	23796	357	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	358	527	527	CD
18637	23796	359	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	360	1921	1921	CD
18637	23796	361	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	362	,	,	,
18637	23796	363	1199	1199	CD
18637	23796	364	Goodrich	Goodrich	NNP
18637	23796	365	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	366	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	367	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	368	Ferris	Ferris	NNP
18637	23796	369	,	,	,
18637	23796	370	214	214	CD
18637	23796	371	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23796	372	71	71	CD
18637	23796	373	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23796	374	1909	1909	CD
18637	23796	375	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23796	376	,	,	,
18637	23796	377	1072	1072	CD
18637	23796	378	,	,	,
18637	23796	379	1082	1082	CD
18637	23796	380	,	,	,
18637	23796	381	1088	1088	CD
18637	23796	382	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	23796	383	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	384	v.	v.	IN
18637	23796	385	_	_	NNP
18637	23796	386	United	United	NNP
18637	23796	387	States	States	NNP
18637	23796	388	,	,	,
18637	23796	389	2	2	CD
18637	23796	390	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23796	391	.	.	.
18637	23797	1	561	561	CD
18637	23797	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23797	3	1865	1865	CD
18637	23797	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23797	5	,	,	,
18637	23797	6	513	513	CD
18637	23797	7	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	23797	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23797	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23797	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23797	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23797	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23797	13	,	,	,
18637	23797	14	117	117	CD
18637	23797	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23797	16	697	697	CD
18637	23797	17	decided	decide	VBN
18637	23797	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23797	19	1864	1864	CD
18637	23797	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23797	21	reported	report	VBD
18637	23797	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23797	23	1886	1886	CD
18637	23797	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23797	25	,	,	,
18637	23797	26	513	513	CD
18637	23797	27	,	,	,
18637	23797	28	534	534	CD
18637	23797	29	,	,	,
18637	23797	30	535	535	CD
18637	23797	31	,	,	,
18637	23797	32	550	550	CD
18637	23797	33	,	,	,
18637	23797	34	623	623	CD
18637	23797	35	Gorieb	Gorieb	NNP
18637	23797	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23797	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23797	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23797	39	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	23797	40	,	,	,
18637	23797	41	274	274	CD
18637	23797	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23797	43	603	603	CD
18637	23797	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23797	45	1927	1927	CD
18637	23797	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23797	47	,	,	,
18637	23797	48	1029	1029	CD
18637	23797	49	,	,	,
18637	23797	50	1157	1157	CD
18637	23797	51	Gorin	Gorin	NNP
18637	23797	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23797	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	23797	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23797	55	United	United	NNP
18637	23797	56	States	States	NNP
18637	23797	57	,	,	,
18637	23797	58	312	312	CD
18637	23797	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23797	60	19	19	CD
18637	23797	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23797	62	1941	1941	CD
18637	23797	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23797	64	,	,	,
18637	23797	65	883	883	CD
18637	23797	66	Goto	Goto	NNP
18637	23797	67	_	_	NNP
18637	23797	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	23797	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23797	70	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	23797	71	,	,	,
18637	23797	72	265	265	CD
18637	23797	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23797	74	393	393	CD
18637	23797	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23797	76	1924	1924	CD
18637	23797	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23797	78	,	,	,
18637	23797	79	314	314	CD
18637	23797	80	Gould	Gould	NNP
18637	23797	81	et	et	NNP
18637	23797	82	al	al	NNP
18637	23797	83	.	.	.
18637	23798	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23798	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23798	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23798	4	United	United	NNP
18637	23798	5	States	States	NNP
18637	23798	6	,	,	,
18637	23798	7	328	328	CD
18637	23798	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23798	9	848	848	CD
18637	23798	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23798	11	1946	1946	CD
18637	23798	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23798	13	,	,	,
18637	23798	14	1234	1234	CD
18637	23798	15	Gould	Gould	NNP
18637	23798	16	et	et	NNP
18637	23798	17	al	al	NNP
18637	23798	18	.	.	.
18637	23799	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23799	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23799	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23799	4	United	United	NNP
18637	23799	5	States	States	NNP
18637	23799	6	,	,	,
18637	23799	7	329	329	CD
18637	23799	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23799	9	820	820	CD
18637	23799	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23799	11	1946	1946	CD
18637	23799	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23799	13	,	,	,
18637	23799	14	1234	1234	CD
18637	23799	15	Gouled	Gouled	NNP
18637	23799	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23799	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23799	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23799	19	United	United	NNP
18637	23799	20	States	States	NNP
18637	23799	21	,	,	,
18637	23799	22	255	255	CD
18637	23799	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23799	24	298	298	CD
18637	23799	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23799	26	1921	1921	CD
18637	23799	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23799	28	,	,	,
18637	23799	29	824	824	CD
18637	23799	30	,	,	,
18637	23799	31	825	825	CD
18637	23799	32	Governor	Governor	NNP
18637	23799	33	of	of	IN
18637	23799	34	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23799	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23799	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	23799	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23799	38	Madrazo	Madrazo	NNP
18637	23799	39	,	,	,
18637	23799	40	1	1	CD
18637	23799	41	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23799	42	.	.	.
18637	23800	1	110	110	CD
18637	23800	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23800	3	1828	1828	CD
18637	23800	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23800	5	,	,	,
18637	23800	6	929	929	CD
18637	23800	7	,	,	,
18637	23800	8	931	931	CD
18637	23800	9	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	23800	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23800	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23800	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23800	13	Folsom	Folsom	NNP
18637	23800	14	,	,	,
18637	23800	15	200	200	CD
18637	23800	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23800	17	248	248	CD
18637	23800	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23800	19	1906	1906	CD
18637	23800	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23800	21	,	,	,
18637	23800	22	356	356	CD
18637	23800	23	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	23800	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23800	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23800	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23800	27	Goodcell	Goodcell	NNP
18637	23800	28	,	,	,
18637	23800	29	282	282	CD
18637	23800	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23800	31	409	409	CD
18637	23800	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23800	33	1931	1931	CD
18637	23800	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23800	35	,	,	,
18637	23800	36	858	858	CD
18637	23800	37	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	23800	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23800	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23800	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23800	41	West	West	NNP
18637	23800	42	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	23800	43	,	,	,
18637	23800	44	224	224	CD
18637	23800	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23800	46	616	616	CD
18637	23800	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23800	48	1912	1912	CD
18637	23800	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23800	50	,	,	,
18637	23800	51	328	328	CD
18637	23800	52	,	,	,
18637	23800	53	1098	1098	CD
18637	23800	54	,	,	,
18637	23800	55	1133	1133	CD
18637	23800	56	,	,	,
18637	23800	57	1135	1135	CD
18637	23800	58	,	,	,
18637	23800	59	1137	1137	CD
18637	23800	60	,	,	,
18637	23800	61	1161	1161	CD
18637	23800	62	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	23800	63	Lodge	Lodge	NNP
18637	23800	64	,	,	,
18637	23800	65	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23800	66	&	&	CC
18637	23800	67	A.M.	A.M.	NNP
18637	23800	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23800	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	23800	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23800	71	New	New	NNP
18637	23800	72	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	23800	73	,	,	,
18637	23800	74	166	166	CD
18637	23800	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23800	76	143	143	CD
18637	23800	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23800	78	1897	1897	CD
18637	23800	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23800	80	,	,	,
18637	23800	81	342	342	CD
18637	23800	82	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	23800	83	Trunk	Trunk	NNP
18637	23800	84	Western	Western	NNP
18637	23800	85	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23800	86	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23800	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23800	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	23800	89	_	_	NNP
18637	23800	90	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	23800	91	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23800	92	,	,	,
18637	23800	93	221	221	CD
18637	23800	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23800	95	400	400	CD
18637	23800	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23800	97	1911	1911	CD
18637	23800	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23800	99	,	,	,
18637	23800	100	329	329	CD
18637	23800	101	Granger	Granger	NNP
18637	23800	102	Cases	case	NNS
18637	23800	103	,	,	,
18637	23800	104	94	94	CD
18637	23800	105	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23800	106	113	113	CD
18637	23800	107	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23800	108	1877	1877	CD
18637	23800	109	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23800	110	,	,	,
18637	23800	111	220	220	CD
18637	23800	112	,	,	,
18637	23800	113	981	981	CD
18637	23800	114	Graniteville	Graniteville	NNP
18637	23800	115	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23800	116	.	.	.
18637	23801	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23801	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23801	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23801	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23801	5	Query	Query	NNP
18637	23801	6	,	,	,
18637	23801	7	283	283	CD
18637	23801	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23801	9	376	376	CD
18637	23801	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23801	11	1931	1931	CD
18637	23801	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23801	13	,	,	,
18637	23801	14	1044	1044	CD
18637	23801	15	Grannis	Grannis	NNP
18637	23801	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23801	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23801	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23801	19	Ordean	Ordean	NNP
18637	23801	20	,	,	,
18637	23801	21	234	234	CD
18637	23801	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23801	23	385	385	CD
18637	23801	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23801	25	1914	1914	CD
18637	23801	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23801	27	,	,	,
18637	23801	28	1072	1072	CD
18637	23801	29	,	,	,
18637	23801	30	1073	1073	CD
18637	23801	31	,	,	,
18637	23801	32	1083	1083	CD
18637	23801	33	Grant	Grant	NNP
18637	23801	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23801	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23801	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23801	37	United	United	NNP
18637	23801	38	States	States	NNP
18637	23801	39	,	,	,
18637	23801	40	227	227	CD
18637	23801	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23801	42	74	74	CD
18637	23801	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23801	44	1913	1913	CD
18637	23801	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23801	46	,	,	,
18637	23801	47	827	827	CD
18637	23801	48	Grant	Grant	NNP
18637	23801	49	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	23801	50	-	-	HYPH
18637	23801	51	Porter	Porter	NNP
18637	23801	52	Ship	Ship	NNP
18637	23801	53	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23801	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23801	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	23801	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23801	57	Rohde	Rohde	NNP
18637	23801	58	,	,	,
18637	23801	59	257	257	CD
18637	23801	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23801	61	469	469	CD
18637	23801	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23801	63	1922	1922	CD
18637	23801	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23801	65	,	,	,
18637	23801	66	574	574	CD
18637	23801	67	,	,	,
18637	23801	68	582	582	CD
18637	23801	69	Grant	Grant	NNP
18637	23801	70	Timber	Timber	NNP
18637	23801	71	&	&	CC
18637	23801	72	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23801	73	.	.	.
18637	23802	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23802	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23802	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23802	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23802	5	Gray	Gray	NNP
18637	23802	6	,	,	,
18637	23802	7	236	236	CD
18637	23802	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23802	9	133	133	CD
18637	23802	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23802	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	23802	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23802	13	,	,	,
18637	23802	14	1091	1091	CD
18637	23802	15	Grapeshot	Grapeshot	NNP
18637	23802	16	,	,	,
18637	23802	17	The	the	DT
18637	23802	18	,	,	,
18637	23802	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23802	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	23802	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23802	22	Wallerstein	Wallerstein	NNP
18637	23802	23	,	,	,
18637	23802	24	9	9	CD
18637	23802	25	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23802	26	.	.	.
18637	23803	1	129	129	CD
18637	23803	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23803	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	23803	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23803	5	,	,	,
18637	23803	6	574	574	CD
18637	23803	7	Graves	Graves	NNPS
18637	23803	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23803	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23803	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23803	11	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	23803	12	,	,	,
18637	23803	13	307	307	CD
18637	23803	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23803	15	383	383	CD
18637	23803	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23803	17	1939	1939	CD
18637	23803	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23803	19	,	,	,
18637	23803	20	1048	1048	CD
18637	23803	21	Graves	Graves	NNPS
18637	23803	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23803	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23803	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23803	25	Eubank	Eubank	NNP
18637	23803	26	,	,	,
18637	23803	27	205	205	CD
18637	23803	28	Ala.	Alabama	NNP
18637	23803	29	174	174	CD
18637	23803	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23803	31	1921	1921	CD
18637	23803	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23803	33	,	,	,
18637	23803	34	1220	1220	CD
18637	23803	35	Graves	Graves	NNPS
18637	23803	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23803	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23803	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23803	39	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23803	40	,	,	,
18637	23803	41	272	272	CD
18637	23803	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23803	43	425	425	CD
18637	23803	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23803	45	1926	1926	CD
18637	23803	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23803	47	,	,	,
18637	23803	48	1024	1024	CD
18637	23803	49	Graves	Graves	NNPS
18637	23803	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23803	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	23803	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23803	53	New	New	NNP
18637	23803	54	York	York	NNP
18637	23803	55	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23803	56	rel	rel	NN
18637	23803	57	.	.	.
18637	23804	1	O'Keefe	O'Keefe	NNP
18637	23804	2	,	,	,
18637	23804	3	306	306	CD
18637	23804	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23804	5	466	466	CD
18637	23804	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23804	7	1939	1939	CD
18637	23804	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23804	9	,	,	,
18637	23804	10	106	106	CD
18637	23804	11	,	,	,
18637	23804	12	219	219	CD
18637	23804	13	,	,	,
18637	23804	14	916	916	CD
18637	23804	15	Graves	Graves	NNPS
18637	23804	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23804	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23804	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23804	19	O'Keefe	O'Keefe	NNP
18637	23804	20	,	,	,
18637	23804	21	306	306	CD
18637	23804	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23804	23	466	466	CD
18637	23804	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23804	25	1939	1939	CD
18637	23804	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23804	27	,	,	,
18637	23804	28	731	731	CD
18637	23804	29	Graves	Graves	NNPS
18637	23804	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23804	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23804	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23804	33	Schmidlapp	Schmidlapp	NNP
18637	23804	34	,	,	,
18637	23804	35	315	315	CD
18637	23804	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23804	37	657	657	CD
18637	23804	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23804	39	1942	1942	CD
18637	23804	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23804	41	,	,	,
18637	23804	42	1046	1046	CD
18637	23804	43	,	,	,
18637	23804	44	1049	1049	CD
18637	23804	45	Graves	Graves	NNPS
18637	23804	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23804	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	23804	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23804	49	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23804	50	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23804	51	,	,	,
18637	23804	52	298	298	CD
18637	23804	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23804	54	393	393	CD
18637	23804	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23804	56	1936	1936	CD
18637	23804	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23804	58	,	,	,
18637	23804	59	731	731	CD
18637	23804	60	,	,	,
18637	23804	61	936	936	CD
18637	23804	62	Great	great	JJ
18637	23804	63	A.	a.	NN
18637	23805	1	&	&	CC
18637	23805	2	P.	P.	NNP
18637	23805	3	Tea	Tea	NNP
18637	23805	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23805	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23805	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	23805	7	_	_	NNP
18637	23805	8	Grosjean	Grosjean	NNP
18637	23805	9	,	,	,
18637	23805	10	301	301	CD
18637	23805	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23805	12	412	412	CD
18637	23805	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23805	14	1937	1937	CD
18637	23805	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23805	16	,	,	,
18637	23805	17	1055	1055	CD
18637	23805	18	,	,	,
18637	23805	19	1148	1148	CD
18637	23805	20	Great	Great	NNP
18637	23805	21	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	23805	22	&	&	CC
18637	23805	23	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	23805	24	Tea	Tea	NNP
18637	23805	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23805	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23805	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23805	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23805	29	Supermarket	Supermarket	NNP
18637	23805	30	Equipment	Equipment	NNP
18637	23805	31	,	,	,
18637	23805	32	340	340	CD
18637	23805	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23805	34	147	147	CD
18637	23805	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23805	36	1950	1950	CD
18637	23805	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23805	38	,	,	,
18637	23805	39	271	271	CD
18637	23805	40	,	,	,
18637	23805	41	272	272	CD
18637	23805	42	,	,	,
18637	23805	43	274	274	CD
18637	23805	44	Great	Great	NNP
18637	23805	45	Lakes	Lakes	NNPS
18637	23805	46	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23805	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23805	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	23805	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23805	50	Huffman	Huffman	NNP
18637	23805	51	,	,	,
18637	23805	52	319	319	CD
18637	23805	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23805	54	293	293	CD
18637	23805	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23805	56	1943	1943	CD
18637	23805	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23805	58	,	,	,
18637	23805	59	553	553	CD
18637	23805	60	Great	Great	NNP
18637	23805	61	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	23805	62	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23805	63	.	.	.
18637	23806	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23806	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23806	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23806	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23806	5	Read	Read	NNP
18637	23806	6	,	,	,
18637	23806	7	322	322	CD
18637	23806	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23806	9	47	47	CD
18637	23806	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23806	11	1944	1944	CD
18637	23806	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23806	13	,	,	,
18637	23806	14	587	587	CD
18637	23806	15	,	,	,
18637	23806	16	935	935	CD
18637	23806	17	,	,	,
18637	23806	18	936	936	CD
18637	23806	19	Great	Great	NNP
18637	23806	20	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	23806	21	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23806	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23806	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23806	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23806	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23806	26	Cahill	Cahill	NNP
18637	23806	27	,	,	,
18637	23806	28	253	253	CD
18637	23806	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23806	30	71	71	CD
18637	23806	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23806	32	1920	1920	CD
18637	23806	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23806	34	,	,	,
18637	23806	35	1012	1012	CD
18637	23806	36	Great	Great	NNP
18637	23806	37	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	23806	38	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23806	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23806	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23806	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23806	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23806	43	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23806	44	,	,	,
18637	23806	45	278	278	CD
18637	23806	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23806	47	503	503	CD
18637	23806	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23806	49	1929	1929	CD
18637	23806	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23806	51	,	,	,
18637	23806	52	201	201	CD
18637	23806	53	,	,	,
18637	23806	54	1053	1053	CD
18637	23806	55	Great	Great	NNP
18637	23806	56	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	23806	57	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23806	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23806	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23806	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23806	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23806	62	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23806	63	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23806	64	rel	rel	NN
18637	23806	65	.	.	.
18637	23807	1	Clara	Clara	NNP
18637	23807	2	City	City	NNP
18637	23807	3	,	,	,
18637	23807	4	246	246	CD
18637	23807	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23807	6	434	434	CD
18637	23807	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23807	8	1918	1918	CD
18637	23807	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23807	10	,	,	,
18637	23807	11	345	345	CD
18637	23807	12	,	,	,
18637	23807	13	1014	1014	CD
18637	23807	14	Great	Great	NNP
18637	23807	15	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	23807	16	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23807	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23807	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23807	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23807	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23807	21	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23807	22	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23807	23	rel	rel	NN
18637	23807	24	.	.	.
18637	23808	1	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	23808	2	&	&	CC
18637	23808	3	Warehouse	Warehouse	NNP
18637	23808	4	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23808	5	,	,	,
18637	23808	6	238	238	CD
18637	23808	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23808	8	340	340	CD
18637	23808	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23808	10	1915	1915	CD
18637	23808	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23808	12	,	,	,
18637	23808	13	1012	1012	CD
18637	23808	14	Great	Great	NNP
18637	23808	15	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	23808	16	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23808	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23808	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23808	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23808	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23808	21	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	23808	22	,	,	,
18637	23808	23	300	300	CD
18637	23808	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23808	25	154	154	CD
18637	23808	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23808	27	1937	1937	CD
18637	23808	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23808	29	,	,	,
18637	23808	30	213	213	CD
18637	23808	31	Great	Great	NNP
18637	23808	32	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	23808	33	Fire	Fire	NNP
18637	23808	34	Proof	Proof	NNP
18637	23808	35	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	23808	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23808	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23808	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	23808	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23808	40	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	23808	41	,	,	,
18637	23808	42	193	193	CD
18637	23808	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23808	44	532	532	CD
18637	23808	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23808	46	1904	1904	CD
18637	23808	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23808	48	,	,	,
18637	23808	49	331	331	CD
18637	23808	50	Great	Great	NNP
18637	23808	51	Western	Western	NNP
18637	23808	52	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	23808	53	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23808	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23808	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	23808	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23808	57	Purdy	Purdy	NNP
18637	23808	58	,	,	,
18637	23808	59	162	162	CD
18637	23808	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23808	61	329	329	CD
18637	23808	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23808	63	1896	1896	CD
18637	23808	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23808	65	,	,	,
18637	23808	66	654	654	CD
18637	23808	67	Greeley	Greeley	NNP
18637	23808	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23808	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	23808	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23808	71	Lowe	Lowe	NNP
18637	23808	72	,	,	,
18637	23808	73	155	155	CD
18637	23808	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23808	75	58	58	CD
18637	23808	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23808	77	1894	1894	CD
18637	23808	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23808	79	,	,	,
18637	23808	80	895	895	CD
18637	23808	81	Green	Green	NNP
18637	23808	82	,	,	,
18637	23808	83	In	in	IN
18637	23808	84	re	re	NN
18637	23808	85	,	,	,
18637	23808	86	134	134	CD
18637	23808	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23808	88	377	377	CD
18637	23808	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23808	90	1890	1890	CD
18637	23808	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23808	92	,	,	,
18637	23808	93	386	386	CD
18637	23808	94	Green	Green	NNP
18637	23808	95	_	_	NNP
18637	23808	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	23808	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23808	98	Biddle	Biddle	NNP
18637	23808	99	,	,	,
18637	23808	100	8	8	CD
18637	23808	101	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23808	102	.	.	.
18637	23809	1	1	1	CD
18637	23809	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23809	3	1823	1823	CD
18637	23809	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23809	5	,	,	,
18637	23809	6	369	369	CD
18637	23809	7	,	,	,
18637	23809	8	370	370	CD
18637	23809	9	Green	Green	NNP
18637	23809	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23809	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23809	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23809	13	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23809	14	,	,	,
18637	23809	15	B.	B.	NNP
18637	23810	1	&	&	CC
18637	23810	2	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	23811	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23811	2	,	,	,
18637	23811	3	205	205	CD
18637	23811	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23811	5	530	530	CD
18637	23811	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23811	7	1907	1907	CD
18637	23811	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23811	9	,	,	,
18637	23811	10	1076	1076	CD
18637	23811	11	,	,	,
18637	23811	12	1079	1079	CD
18637	23811	13	Green	Green	NNP
18637	23811	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23811	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23811	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23811	17	Frazier	Frazier	NNP
18637	23811	18	,	,	,
18637	23811	19	253	253	CD
18637	23811	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23811	21	233	233	CD
18637	23811	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23811	23	1920	1920	CD
18637	23811	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23811	25	,	,	,
18637	23811	26	1037	1037	CD
18637	23811	27	,	,	,
18637	23811	28	1063	1063	CD
18637	23811	29	,	,	,
18637	23811	30	1064	1064	CD
18637	23811	31	Green	Green	NNP
18637	23811	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23811	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23811	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23811	35	Van	Van	NNP
18637	23811	36	Buskirk	Buskirk	NNP
18637	23811	37	,	,	,
18637	23811	38	7	7	CD
18637	23811	39	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23811	40	.	.	.
18637	23812	1	139	139	CD
18637	23812	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23812	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	23812	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23812	5	,	,	,
18637	23812	6	655	655	CD
18637	23812	7	Green	Green	NNP
18637	23812	8	Bay	Bay	NNP
18637	23812	9	&	&	CC
18637	23812	10	M.	M.	NNP
18637	23812	11	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	23812	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23812	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23812	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	23812	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23812	16	Patten	Patten	NNP
18637	23812	17	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	23812	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23812	19	,	,	,
18637	23812	20	172	172	CD
18637	23812	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23812	22	58	58	CD
18637	23812	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23812	24	1898	1898	CD
18637	23812	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23812	26	,	,	,
18637	23812	27	131	131	CD
18637	23812	28	Greene	Greene	NNP
18637	23812	29	,	,	,
18637	23812	30	In	in	IN
18637	23812	31	re	re	NN
18637	23812	32	,	,	,
18637	23812	33	52	52	CD
18637	23812	34	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	23812	35	.	.	.
18637	23813	1	104	104	CD
18637	23813	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23813	3	1892	1892	CD
18637	23813	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23813	5	,	,	,
18637	23813	6	171	171	CD
18637	23813	7	Greene	Greene	NNP
18637	23813	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23813	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23813	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23813	11	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	23813	12	&	&	CC
18637	23813	13	I.R.	I.R.	NNP
18637	23814	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23814	2	,	,	,
18637	23814	3	244	244	CD
18637	23814	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23814	5	499	499	CD
18637	23814	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23814	7	1917	1917	CD
18637	23814	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23814	9	,	,	,
18637	23814	10	931	931	CD
18637	23814	11	Greenough	Greenough	NNP
18637	23814	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23814	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23814	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23814	15	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23814	16	Assessors	Assessors	NNPS
18637	23814	17	,	,	,
18637	23814	18	331	331	CD
18637	23814	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23814	20	486	486	CD
18637	23814	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23814	22	1947	1947	CD
18637	23814	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23814	24	,	,	,
18637	23814	25	1044	1044	CD
18637	23814	26	Greenwood	Greenwood	NNP
18637	23814	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23814	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	23814	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23814	30	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23814	31	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	23814	32	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23814	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23814	34	,	,	,
18637	23814	35	105	105	CD
18637	23814	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23814	37	13	13	CD
18637	23814	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23814	39	1882	1882	CD
18637	23814	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23814	41	,	,	,
18637	23814	42	343	343	CD
18637	23814	43	,	,	,
18637	23814	44	344	344	CD
18637	23814	45	Gregory	Gregory	NNP
18637	23814	46	,	,	,
18637	23814	47	In	in	IN
18637	23814	48	re	re	NN
18637	23814	49	,	,	,
18637	23814	50	219	219	CD
18637	23814	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23814	52	210	210	CD
18637	23814	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23814	54	1911	1911	CD
18637	23814	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23814	56	,	,	,
18637	23814	57	314	314	CD
18637	23814	58	Greiner	Greiner	NNP
18637	23814	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23814	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23814	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23814	62	Lewellyn	Lewellyn	NNP
18637	23814	63	,	,	,
18637	23814	64	258	258	CD
18637	23814	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23814	66	384	384	CD
18637	23814	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23814	68	1922	1922	CD
18637	23814	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23814	70	,	,	,
18637	23814	71	107	107	CD
18637	23814	72	Grenada	Grenada	NNP
18637	23814	73	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	23814	74	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23814	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23814	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	23814	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23814	78	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	23814	79	,	,	,
18637	23814	80	217	217	CD
18637	23814	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23814	82	433	433	CD
18637	23814	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23814	84	1910	1910	CD
18637	23814	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23814	86	,	,	,
18637	23814	87	1017	1017	CD
18637	23814	88	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	23814	89	_	_	NNP
18637	23814	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	23814	91	_	_	NNP
18637	23814	92	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	23814	93	,	,	,
18637	23814	94	327	327	CD
18637	23814	95	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23814	96	220	220	CD
18637	23814	97	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23814	98	1946	1946	CD
18637	23814	99	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23814	100	,	,	,
18637	23814	101	671	671	CD
18637	23814	102	,	,	,
18637	23814	103	1074	1074	CD
18637	23814	104	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	23814	105	_	_	NNP
18637	23814	106	v.	v.	IN
18637	23814	107	_	_	NNP
18637	23814	108	McCoach	McCoach	NNP
18637	23814	109	,	,	,
18637	23814	110	313	313	CD
18637	23814	111	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23814	112	498	498	CD
18637	23814	113	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23814	114	1941	1941	CD
18637	23814	115	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23814	116	,	,	,
18637	23814	117	680	680	CD
18637	23814	118	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	23814	119	_	_	NNP
18637	23814	120	v.	v.	IN
18637	23814	121	_	_	NNP
18637	23814	122	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	23814	123	,	,	,
18637	23814	124	2	2	CD
18637	23814	125	How	how	WRB
18637	23814	126	.	.	.
18637	23815	1	244	244	CD
18637	23815	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23815	3	1844	1844	CD
18637	23815	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23815	5	,	,	,
18637	23815	6	326	326	CD
18637	23815	7	,	,	,
18637	23815	8	526	526	CD
18637	23815	9	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	23815	10	's	's	POS
18637	23815	11	Case	Case	NNP
18637	23815	12	,	,	,
18637	23815	13	11	11	CD
18637	23815	14	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	23815	15	.	.	.
18637	23816	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	23816	2	.	.	.
18637	23817	1	No	no	UH
18637	23817	2	.	.	.
18637	23818	1	5815	5815	CD
18637	23818	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23818	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	23818	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23818	5	,	,	,
18637	23818	6	1173	1173	CD
18637	23818	7	Griffith	Griffith	NNP
18637	23818	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23818	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23818	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23818	11	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	23818	12	,	,	,
18637	23818	13	218	218	CD
18637	23818	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23818	15	563	563	CD
18637	23818	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23818	17	1910	1910	CD
18637	23818	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23818	19	,	,	,
18637	23818	20	1021	1021	CD
18637	23818	21	Grimley	Grimley	NNP
18637	23818	22	,	,	,
18637	23818	23	In	in	IN
18637	23818	24	re	re	NN
18637	23818	25	,	,	,
18637	23818	26	137	137	CD
18637	23818	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23818	28	147	147	CD
18637	23818	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23818	30	1890	1890	CD
18637	23818	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23818	32	,	,	,
18637	23818	33	285	285	CD
18637	23818	34	Gring	Gring	NNP
18637	23818	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23818	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	23818	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23818	38	Ives	Ives	NNP
18637	23818	39	,	,	,
18637	23818	40	222	222	CD
18637	23818	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23818	42	365	365	CD
18637	23818	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23818	44	1912	1912	CD
18637	23818	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23818	46	,	,	,
18637	23818	47	231	231	CD
18637	23818	48	Groesbeck	Groesbeck	NNP
18637	23818	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23818	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	23818	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23818	52	Duluth	Duluth	NNP
18637	23818	53	,	,	,
18637	23818	54	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	23818	55	&	&	CC
18637	23818	56	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	23819	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23819	2	,	,	,
18637	23819	3	250	250	CD
18637	23819	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23819	5	607	607	CD
18637	23819	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23819	7	1919	1919	CD
18637	23819	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23819	9	,	,	,
18637	23819	10	1000	1000	CD
18637	23819	11	Grosjean	Grosjean	NNP
18637	23819	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23819	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23819	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23819	15	American	American	NNP
18637	23819	16	Press	Press	NNP
18637	23819	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23819	18	,	,	,
18637	23819	19	297	297	CD
18637	23819	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23819	21	233	233	CD
18637	23819	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23819	23	1936	1936	CD
18637	23819	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23819	25	,	,	,
18637	23819	26	792	792	CD
18637	23819	27	,	,	,
18637	23819	28	965	965	CD
18637	23819	29	,	,	,
18637	23819	30	981	981	CD
18637	23819	31	Grossman	Grossman	NNP
18637	23819	32	,	,	,
18637	23819	33	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23819	34	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23819	35	,	,	,
18637	23819	36	267	267	CD
18637	23819	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23819	38	87	87	CD
18637	23819	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23819	40	1925	1925	CD
18637	23819	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23819	42	,	,	,
18637	23819	43	408	408	CD
18637	23819	44	,	,	,
18637	23819	45	521	521	CD
18637	23819	46	Grover	Grover	NNP
18637	23819	47	&	&	CC
18637	23819	48	B.	B.	NNP
18637	23819	49	Sewing	Sewing	NNP
18637	23819	50	-	-	:
18637	23819	51	Mach	Mach	NNP
18637	23819	52	.	.	.
18637	23820	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23820	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23820	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23820	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23820	5	Radcliffe	Radcliffe	NNP
18637	23820	6	,	,	,
18637	23820	7	137	137	CD
18637	23820	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23820	9	287	287	CD
18637	23820	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23820	11	1890	1890	CD
18637	23820	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23820	13	,	,	,
18637	23820	14	656	656	CD
18637	23820	15	,	,	,
18637	23820	16	659	659	CD
18637	23820	17	,	,	,
18637	23820	18	662	662	CD
18637	23820	19	Groves	Groves	NNPS
18637	23820	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23820	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	23820	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23820	23	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	23820	24	,	,	,
18637	23820	25	15	15	CD
18637	23820	26	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23820	27	.	.	.
18637	23821	1	449	449	CD
18637	23821	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23821	3	1841	1841	CD
18637	23821	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23821	5	,	,	,
18637	23821	6	162	162	CD
18637	23821	7	,	,	,
18637	23821	8	164	164	CD
18637	23821	9	Grovey	Grovey	NNP
18637	23821	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23821	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	13	Townsend	Townsend	NNP
18637	23821	14	,	,	,
18637	23821	15	295	295	CD
18637	23821	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23821	17	45	45	CD
18637	23821	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23821	19	1935	1935	CD
18637	23821	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23821	21	,	,	,
18637	23821	22	565	565	CD
18637	23821	23	,	,	,
18637	23821	24	1142	1142	CD
18637	23821	25	,	,	,
18637	23821	26	1164	1164	CD
18637	23821	27	,	,	,
18637	23821	28	1185	1185	CD
18637	23821	29	Grubb	Grubb	NNP
18637	23821	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23821	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	33	Public	Public	NNP
18637	23821	34	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	23821	35	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23821	36	,	,	,
18637	23821	37	281	281	CD
18637	23821	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23821	39	470	470	CD
18637	23821	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23821	41	1930	1930	CD
18637	23821	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23821	43	,	,	,
18637	23821	44	631	631	CD
18637	23821	45	Gruber	Gruber	NNP
18637	23821	46	,	,	,
18637	23821	47	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23821	48	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23821	49	,	,	,
18637	23821	50	269	269	CD
18637	23821	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23821	52	302	302	CD
18637	23821	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23821	54	1925	1925	CD
18637	23821	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23821	56	,	,	,
18637	23821	57	572	572	CD
18637	23821	58	Gryger	Gryger	NNP
18637	23821	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23821	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	62	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	23821	63	,	,	,
18637	23821	64	334	334	CD
18637	23821	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23821	66	728	728	CD
18637	23821	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23821	68	1948	1948	CD
18637	23821	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23821	70	,	,	,
18637	23821	71	328	328	CD
18637	23821	72	,	,	,
18637	23821	73	1106	1106	CD
18637	23821	74	,	,	,
18637	23821	75	1137	1137	CD
18637	23821	76	,	,	,
18637	23821	77	1141	1141	CD
18637	23821	78	Guaranty	Guaranty	NNP
18637	23821	79	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23821	80	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23821	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	23821	83	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	84	United	United	NNP
18637	23821	85	States	States	NNP
18637	23821	86	,	,	,
18637	23821	87	304	304	CD
18637	23821	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23821	89	126	126	CD
18637	23821	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23821	91	1938	1938	CD
18637	23821	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23821	93	,	,	,
18637	23821	94	439	439	CD
18637	23821	95	,	,	,
18637	23821	96	609	609	CD
18637	23821	97	,	,	,
18637	23821	98	610	610	CD
18637	23821	99	Guaranty	Guaranty	NNP
18637	23821	100	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23821	101	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23821	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	103	v.	v.	IN
18637	23821	104	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	105	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	23821	106	,	,	,
18637	23821	107	305	305	CD
18637	23821	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23821	109	19	19	CD
18637	23821	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23821	111	1938	1938	CD
18637	23821	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23821	113	,	,	,
18637	23821	114	1054	1054	CD
18637	23821	115	Guaranty	Guaranty	NNP
18637	23821	116	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23821	117	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23821	118	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	23821	120	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	121	York	York	NNP
18637	23821	122	,	,	,
18637	23821	123	326	326	CD
18637	23821	124	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23821	125	99	99	CD
18637	23821	126	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23821	127	1945	1945	CD
18637	23821	128	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23821	129	,	,	,
18637	23821	130	608	608	CD
18637	23821	131	Guessefeldt	Guessefeldt	NNP
18637	23821	132	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	133	v.	v.	IN
18637	23821	134	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	135	McGrath	McGrath	NNP
18637	23821	136	,	,	,
18637	23821	137	342	342	CD
18637	23821	138	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23821	139	308	308	CD
18637	23821	140	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23821	141	1952	1952	CD
18637	23821	142	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23821	143	,	,	,
18637	23821	144	865	865	CD
18637	23821	145	Guinn	Guinn	NNP
18637	23821	146	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	147	v.	v.	IN
18637	23821	148	_	_	NNP
18637	23821	149	United	United	NNP
18637	23821	150	States	States	NNP
18637	23821	151	,	,	,
18637	23821	152	238	238	CD
18637	23821	153	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23821	154	347	347	CD
18637	23821	155	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23821	156	1915	1915	CD
18637	23821	157	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23821	158	,	,	,
18637	23821	159	1164	1164	CD
18637	23821	160	,	,	,
18637	23821	161	1183	1183	CD
18637	23821	162	,	,	,
18637	23821	163	1184	1184	CD
18637	23821	164	Gulf	Gulf	NNP
18637	23821	165	,	,	,
18637	23821	166	C.	C.	NNP
18637	23821	167	&	&	CC
18637	23821	168	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	23822	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23822	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23822	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23822	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23822	5	Ellis	Ellis	NNP
18637	23822	6	,	,	,
18637	23822	7	165	165	CD
18637	23822	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23822	9	150	150	CD
18637	23822	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23822	11	1897	1897	CD
18637	23822	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23822	13	,	,	,
18637	23822	14	1167	1167	CD
18637	23822	15	Gulf	Gulf	NNP
18637	23822	16	Fisheries	Fisheries	NNPS
18637	23822	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23822	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23822	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23822	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23822	21	MacInerney	MacInerney	NNP
18637	23822	22	,	,	,
18637	23822	23	276	276	CD
18637	23822	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23822	25	124	124	CD
18637	23822	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23822	27	1928	1928	CD
18637	23822	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23822	29	,	,	,
18637	23822	30	363	363	CD
18637	23822	31	,	,	,
18637	23822	32	364	364	CD
18637	23822	33	Gully	gully	RB
18637	23822	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23822	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23822	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23822	37	First	First	NNP
18637	23822	38	National	National	NNP
18637	23822	39	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23822	40	,	,	,
18637	23822	41	299	299	CD
18637	23822	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23822	43	109	109	CD
18637	23822	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23822	45	1936	1936	CD
18637	23822	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23822	47	,	,	,
18637	23822	48	567	567	CD
18637	23822	49	Gumbel	Gumbel	NNP
18637	23822	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23822	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	23822	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23822	53	Pitkin	Pitkin	NNP
18637	23822	54	,	,	,
18637	23822	55	124	124	CD
18637	23822	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23822	57	131	131	CD
18637	23822	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23822	59	1888	1888	CD
18637	23822	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23822	61	,	,	,
18637	23822	62	512	512	CD
18637	23822	63	,	,	,
18637	23822	64	526	526	CD
18637	23822	65	Gundling	Gundling	NNP
18637	23822	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23822	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23822	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23822	69	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23822	70	,	,	,
18637	23822	71	177	177	CD
18637	23822	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23822	73	183	183	CD
18637	23822	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23822	75	1900	1900	CD
18637	23822	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23822	77	,	,	,
18637	23822	78	1024	1024	CD
18637	23822	79	,	,	,
18637	23822	80	1157	1157	CD
18637	23822	81	Gunter	Gunter	NNP
18637	23822	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23822	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	23822	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23822	85	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	23822	86	C.L.R.	C.L.R.	NNP
18637	23823	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23823	2	,	,	,
18637	23823	3	200	200	CD
18637	23823	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23823	5	273	273	CD
18637	23823	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23823	7	1906	1906	CD
18637	23823	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23823	9	,	,	,
18637	23823	10	931	931	CD
18637	23823	11	Gusik	Gusik	NNP
18637	23823	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23823	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23823	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23823	15	Schilder	Schilder	NNP
18637	23823	16	,	,	,
18637	23823	17	339	339	CD
18637	23823	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23823	19	977	977	CD
18637	23823	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23823	21	1950	1950	CD
18637	23823	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23823	23	,	,	,
18637	23823	24	314	314	CD
18637	23823	25	Gut	Gut	NNP
18637	23823	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23823	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23823	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23823	29	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23823	30	,	,	,
18637	23823	31	9	9	CD
18637	23823	32	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23823	33	.	.	.
18637	23824	1	35	35	CD
18637	23824	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23824	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	23824	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23824	5	,	,	,
18637	23824	6	329	329	CD
18637	23824	7	Guthrie	Guthrie	NNP
18637	23824	8	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23824	9	.	.	.
18637	23825	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23825	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23825	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23825	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23825	5	Guthrie	Guthrie	NNP
18637	23825	6	,	,	,
18637	23825	7	173	173	CD
18637	23825	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23825	9	528	528	CD
18637	23825	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23825	11	1899	1899	CD
18637	23825	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23825	13	,	,	,
18637	23825	14	893	893	CD
18637	23825	15	Guy	Guy	NNP
18637	23825	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23825	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23825	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23825	19	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23825	20	,	,	,
18637	23825	21	100	100	CD
18637	23825	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23825	23	434	434	CD
18637	23825	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23825	25	1880	1880	CD
18637	23825	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23825	27	,	,	,
18637	23825	28	185	185	CD
18637	23825	29	Gwin	Gwin	NNP
18637	23825	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23825	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23825	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23825	33	Breedlove	Breedlove	NNP
18637	23825	34	,	,	,
18637	23825	35	2	2	CD
18637	23825	36	How	how	WRB
18637	23825	37	.	.	.
18637	23826	1	29	29	CD
18637	23826	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23826	3	1844	1844	CD
18637	23826	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23826	5	,	,	,
18637	23826	6	326	326	CD
18637	23826	7	Gwin	Gwin	NNP
18637	23826	8	,	,	,
18637	23826	9	White	White	NNP
18637	23826	10	&	&	CC
18637	23826	11	Prince	Prince	NNP
18637	23826	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23826	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23826	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23826	15	Henneford	Henneford	NNP
18637	23826	16	,	,	,
18637	23826	17	305	305	CD
18637	23826	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23826	19	434	434	CD
18637	23826	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23826	21	1939	1939	CD
18637	23826	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23826	23	,	,	,
18637	23826	24	196	196	CD
18637	23826	25	,	,	,
18637	23826	26	204	204	CD
18637	23826	27	,	,	,
18637	23826	28	205	205	CD
18637	23826	29	,	,	,
18637	23826	30	219	219	CD
18637	23826	31	,	,	,
18637	23826	32	220	220	CD
18637	23826	33	H	H	NNP
18637	23826	34	Haas	Haas	NNP
18637	23826	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23826	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	23826	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23826	38	Henkel	Henkel	NNP
18637	23826	39	,	,	,
18637	23826	40	216	216	CD
18637	23826	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23826	42	462	462	CD
18637	23826	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23826	44	1910	1910	CD
18637	23826	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23826	46	,	,	,
18637	23826	47	881	881	CD
18637	23826	48	Haavik	Haavik	NNP
18637	23826	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23826	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	23826	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23826	52	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
18637	23826	53	Packers	Packers	NNP
18637	23826	54	'	'	POS
18637	23826	55	Association	Association	NNP
18637	23826	56	,	,	,
18637	23826	57	263	263	CD
18637	23826	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23826	59	510	510	CD
18637	23826	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23826	61	1924	1924	CD
18637	23826	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23826	63	,	,	,
18637	23826	64	693	693	CD
18637	23826	65	,	,	,
18637	23826	66	863	863	CD
18637	23826	67	Hadacheck	Hadacheck	NNP
18637	23826	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23826	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	23826	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23826	71	Sebastian	Sebastian	NNP
18637	23826	72	,	,	,
18637	23826	73	239	239	CD
18637	23826	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23826	75	394	394	CD
18637	23826	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23826	77	1915	1915	CD
18637	23826	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23826	79	,	,	,
18637	23826	80	983	983	CD
18637	23826	81	,	,	,
18637	23826	82	1028	1028	CD
18637	23826	83	,	,	,
18637	23826	84	1154	1154	CD
18637	23826	85	Haddock	Haddock	NNP
18637	23826	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23826	87	v.	v.	IN
18637	23826	88	_	_	NNP
18637	23826	89	Haddock	Haddock	NNP
18637	23826	90	,	,	,
18637	23826	91	201	201	CD
18637	23826	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23826	93	562	562	CD
18637	23826	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23826	95	1906	1906	CD
18637	23826	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23826	97	,	,	,
18637	23826	98	662	662	CD
18637	23826	99	,	,	,
18637	23826	100	664	664	CD
18637	23826	101	Hagar	Hagar	NNP
18637	23826	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23826	103	v.	v.	IN
18637	23826	104	_	_	NNP
18637	23826	105	Reclamation	Reclamation	NNP
18637	23826	106	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	23826	107	.	.	.
18637	23827	1	No	no	UH
18637	23827	2	.	.	.
18637	23828	1	108	108	CD
18637	23828	2	,	,	,
18637	23828	3	111	111	CD
18637	23828	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	5	701	701	CD
18637	23828	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	7	1884	1884	CD
18637	23828	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	9	,	,	,
18637	23828	10	1040	1040	CD
18637	23828	11	,	,	,
18637	23828	12	1057	1057	CD
18637	23828	13	,	,	,
18637	23828	14	1058	1058	CD
18637	23828	15	,	,	,
18637	23828	16	1070	1070	CD
18637	23828	17	Hagner	Hagner	NNP
18637	23828	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	21	United	United	NNP
18637	23828	22	States	States	NNP
18637	23828	23	,	,	,
18637	23828	24	285	285	CD
18637	23828	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	26	427	427	CD
18637	23828	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	28	1932	1932	CD
18637	23828	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	30	,	,	,
18637	23828	31	881	881	CD
18637	23828	32	Hagood	Hagood	NNP
18637	23828	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	36	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	23828	37	,	,	,
18637	23828	38	117	117	CD
18637	23828	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	40	52	52	CD
18637	23828	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	42	1886	1886	CD
18637	23828	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	44	,	,	,
18637	23828	45	931	931	CD
18637	23828	46	,	,	,
18637	23828	47	932	932	CD
18637	23828	48	Hague	Hague	NNP
18637	23828	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	52	C.I.O.	C.I.O.	NNP
18637	23828	53	,	,	,
18637	23828	54	307	307	CD
18637	23828	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	56	496	496	CD
18637	23828	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	58	1939	1939	CD
18637	23828	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	60	,	,	,
18637	23828	61	785	785	CD
18637	23828	62	,	,	,
18637	23828	63	788	788	CD
18637	23828	64	,	,	,
18637	23828	65	808	808	CD
18637	23828	66	,	,	,
18637	23828	67	809	809	CD
18637	23828	68	,	,	,
18637	23828	69	968	968	CD
18637	23828	70	Hairston	Hairston	NNP
18637	23828	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	74	Danville	Danville	NNP
18637	23828	75	&	&	CC
18637	23828	76	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	23828	77	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23828	78	,	,	,
18637	23828	79	208	208	CD
18637	23828	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	81	598	598	CD
18637	23828	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	83	1908	1908	CD
18637	23828	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	85	,	,	,
18637	23828	86	1064	1064	CD
18637	23828	87	,	,	,
18637	23828	88	1065	1065	CD
18637	23828	89	,	,	,
18637	23828	90	1066	1066	CD
18637	23828	91	Hale	Hale	NNP
18637	23828	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	95	Bimco	Bimco	NNP
18637	23828	96	Trading	Trading	NNP
18637	23828	97	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23828	98	,	,	,
18637	23828	99	306	306	CD
18637	23828	100	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	101	375	375	CD
18637	23828	102	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	103	1939	1939	CD
18637	23828	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	105	,	,	,
18637	23828	106	238	238	CD
18637	23828	107	Hale	Hale	NNP
18637	23828	108	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	109	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	110	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	111	Henkel	Henkel	NNP
18637	23828	112	,	,	,
18637	23828	113	201	201	CD
18637	23828	114	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	115	43	43	CD
18637	23828	116	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	117	1906	1906	CD
18637	23828	118	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	119	,	,	,
18637	23828	120	824	824	CD
18637	23828	121	,	,	,
18637	23828	122	827	827	CD
18637	23828	123	,	,	,
18637	23828	124	844	844	CD
18637	23828	125	Hale	Hale	NNP
18637	23828	126	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	127	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	128	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	129	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	23828	130	State	State	NNP
18637	23828	131	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23828	132	of	of	IN
18637	23828	133	Assessment	Assessment	NNP
18637	23828	134	,	,	,
18637	23828	135	302	302	CD
18637	23828	136	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	137	95	95	CD
18637	23828	138	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	139	1937	1937	CD
18637	23828	140	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	141	,	,	,
18637	23828	142	348	348	CD
18637	23828	143	Hale	Hale	NNP
18637	23828	144	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	145	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	146	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	147	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23828	148	,	,	,
18637	23828	149	303	303	CD
18637	23828	150	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	151	613	613	CD
18637	23828	152	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	153	1938	1938	CD
18637	23828	154	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	155	,	,	,
18637	23828	156	1098	1098	CD
18637	23828	157	Haley	Haley	NNP
18637	23828	158	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	159	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	160	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	161	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	23828	162	,	,	,
18637	23828	163	332	332	CD
18637	23828	164	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	165	596	596	CD
18637	23828	166	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	167	1948	1948	CD
18637	23828	168	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	169	,	,	,
18637	23828	170	1104	1104	CD
18637	23828	171	,	,	,
18637	23828	172	1118	1118	CD
18637	23828	173	,	,	,
18637	23828	174	1121	1121	CD
18637	23828	175	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	23828	176	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	177	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	178	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	179	De	De	NNP
18637	23828	180	Cuir	Cuir	NNP
18637	23828	181	,	,	,
18637	23828	182	95	95	CD
18637	23828	183	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	184	485	485	CD
18637	23828	185	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	186	1878	1878	CD
18637	23828	187	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	188	,	,	,
18637	23828	189	218	218	CD
18637	23828	190	,	,	,
18637	23828	191	230	230	CD
18637	23828	192	,	,	,
18637	23828	193	1162	1162	CD
18637	23828	194	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	23828	195	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	196	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	197	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	198	Geiger	Geiger	NNP
18637	23828	199	-	-	HYPH
18637	23828	200	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	23828	201	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23828	202	,	,	,
18637	23828	203	242	242	CD
18637	23828	204	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	205	539	539	CD
18637	23828	206	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	207	1917	1917	CD
18637	23828	208	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	209	,	,	,
18637	23828	210	235	235	CD
18637	23828	211	,	,	,
18637	23828	212	983	983	CD
18637	23828	213	,	,	,
18637	23828	214	1019	1019	CD
18637	23828	215	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	23828	216	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	217	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	218	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	219	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	23828	220	,	,	,
18637	23828	221	103	103	CD
18637	23828	222	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	223	5	5	CD
18637	23828	224	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	225	1880	1880	CD
18637	23828	226	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	227	,	,	,
18637	23828	228	341	341	CD
18637	23828	229	Hallinger	Hallinger	NNP
18637	23828	230	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	231	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	232	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	233	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23828	234	,	,	,
18637	23828	235	146	146	CD
18637	23828	236	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	237	314	314	CD
18637	23828	238	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	239	1892	1892	CD
18637	23828	240	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	241	,	,	,
18637	23828	242	1110	1110	CD
18637	23828	243	Halter	Halter	NNP
18637	23828	244	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	245	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	246	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	247	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	23828	248	,	,	,
18637	23828	249	205	205	CD
18637	23828	250	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	251	34	34	CD
18637	23828	252	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	253	1907	1907	CD
18637	23828	254	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	255	,	,	,
18637	23828	256	1024	1024	CD
18637	23828	257	,	,	,
18637	23828	258	1154	1154	CD
18637	23828	259	Halvey	Halvey	NNP
18637	23828	260	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	261	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	262	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	263	Halvey	Halvey	NNP
18637	23828	264	,	,	,
18637	23828	265	330	330	CD
18637	23828	266	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	267	610	610	CD
18637	23828	268	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	269	1947	1947	CD
18637	23828	270	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	271	,	,	,
18637	23828	272	671	671	CD
18637	23828	273	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	23828	274	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	275	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	276	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	277	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23828	278	,	,	,
18637	23828	279	161	161	CD
18637	23828	280	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23828	281	256	256	CD
18637	23828	282	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23828	283	1896	1896	CD
18637	23828	284	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23828	285	,	,	,
18637	23828	286	1083	1083	CD
18637	23828	287	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	23828	288	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	289	v.	v.	IN
18637	23828	290	_	_	NNP
18637	23828	291	Dillin	Dillin	NNP
18637	23828	292	,	,	,
18637	23828	293	21	21	CD
18637	23828	294	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23828	295	.	.	.
18637	23829	1	73	73	CD
18637	23829	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23829	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	23829	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23829	5	,	,	,
18637	23829	6	280	280	CD
18637	23829	7	,	,	,
18637	23829	8	289	289	CD
18637	23829	9	,	,	,
18637	23829	10	404	404	CD
18637	23829	11	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	23829	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23829	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23829	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23829	15	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23829	16	Distilleries	Distilleries	NNP
18637	23829	17	&	&	CC
18637	23829	18	Wine	Wine	NNP
18637	23829	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23829	20	,	,	,
18637	23829	21	251	251	CD
18637	23829	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23829	23	146	146	CD
18637	23829	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23829	25	1919	1919	CD
18637	23829	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23829	27	,	,	,
18637	23829	28	292	292	CD
18637	23829	29	,	,	,
18637	23829	30	564	564	CD
18637	23829	31	,	,	,
18637	23829	32	918	918	CD
18637	23829	33	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	23829	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23829	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23829	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23829	37	Regents	Regents	NNP
18637	23829	38	,	,	,
18637	23829	39	293	293	CD
18637	23829	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23829	41	245	245	CD
18637	23829	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23829	43	1934	1934	CD
18637	23829	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23829	45	,	,	,
18637	23829	46	768	768	CD
18637	23829	47	,	,	,
18637	23829	48	985	985	CD
18637	23829	49	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	23829	50	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23829	51	.	.	.
18637	23830	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23830	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23830	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23830	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23830	5	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	23830	6	,	,	,
18637	23830	7	6	6	CD
18637	23830	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23830	9	.	.	.
18637	23831	1	632	632	CD
18637	23831	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23831	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	23831	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23831	5	,	,	,
18637	23831	6	730	730	CD
18637	23831	7	Hammer	Hammer	NNP
18637	23831	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23831	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23831	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23831	11	Dagenhart	Dagenhart	NNP
18637	23831	12	,	,	,
18637	23831	13	247	247	CD
18637	23831	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23831	15	251	251	CD
18637	23831	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23831	17	1918	1918	CD
18637	23831	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23831	19	,	,	,
18637	23831	20	122	122	CD
18637	23831	21	,	,	,
18637	23831	22	166	166	CD
18637	23831	23	,	,	,
18637	23831	24	168	168	CD
18637	23831	25	,	,	,
18637	23831	26	170	170	CD
18637	23831	27	,	,	,
18637	23831	28	171	171	CD
18637	23831	29	,	,	,
18637	23831	30	172	172	CD
18637	23831	31	,	,	,
18637	23831	32	173	173	CD
18637	23831	33	,	,	,
18637	23831	34	917	917	CD
18637	23831	35	,	,	,
18637	23831	36	918	918	CD
18637	23831	37	Hammond	Hammond	NNP
18637	23831	38	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	23831	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23831	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23831	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23831	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23831	43	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	23831	44	,	,	,
18637	23831	45	212	212	CD
18637	23831	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23831	47	322	322	CD
18637	23831	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23831	49	1909	1909	CD
18637	23831	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23831	51	,	,	,
18637	23831	52	345	345	CD
18637	23831	53	,	,	,
18637	23831	54	1122	1122	CD
18637	23831	55	,	,	,
18637	23831	56	1166	1166	CD
18637	23831	57	Hammond	Hammond	NNP
18637	23831	58	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	23831	59	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23831	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23831	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23831	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23831	63	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	23831	64	,	,	,
18637	23831	65	233	233	CD
18637	23831	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23831	67	331	331	CD
18637	23831	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23831	69	1914	1914	CD
18637	23831	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23831	71	,	,	,
18637	23831	72	1149	1149	CD
18637	23831	73	Hampton	Hampton	NNP
18637	23831	74	,	,	,
18637	23831	75	The	the	DT
18637	23831	76	,	,	,
18637	23831	77	5	5	CD
18637	23831	78	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23831	79	.	.	.
18637	23832	1	372	372	CD
18637	23832	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23832	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	23832	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23832	5	,	,	,
18637	23832	6	296	296	CD
18637	23832	7	Hampton	Hampton	NNP
18637	23832	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23832	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23832	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23832	11	McConnell	McConnell	NNP
18637	23832	12	,	,	,
18637	23832	13	3	3	CD
18637	23832	14	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23832	15	.	.	.
18637	23833	1	234	234	CD
18637	23833	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23833	3	1818	1818	CD
18637	23833	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23833	5	,	,	,
18637	23833	6	653	653	CD
18637	23833	7	,	,	,
18637	23833	8	654	654	CD
18637	23833	9	,	,	,
18637	23833	10	656	656	CD
18637	23833	11	,	,	,
18637	23833	12	657	657	CD
18637	23833	13	Hampton	Hampton	NNP
18637	23833	14	&	&	CC
18637	23833	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23833	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23833	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23833	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23833	19	United	United	NNP
18637	23833	20	States	States	NNP
18637	23833	21	,	,	,
18637	23833	22	276	276	CD
18637	23833	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23833	24	394	394	CD
18637	23833	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23833	26	1928	1928	CD
18637	23833	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23833	28	,	,	,
18637	23833	29	73	73	CD
18637	23833	30	,	,	,
18637	23833	31	74	74	CD
18637	23833	32	,	,	,
18637	23833	33	77	77	CD
18637	23833	34	,	,	,
18637	23833	35	80	80	CD
18637	23833	36	,	,	,
18637	23833	37	112	112	CD
18637	23833	38	Hanauer	Hanauer	NNP
18637	23833	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23833	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23833	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23833	42	Doane	Doane	NNP
18637	23833	43	,	,	,
18637	23833	44	12	12	CD
18637	23833	45	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23833	46	.	.	.
18637	23834	1	342	342	CD
18637	23834	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23834	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	23834	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23834	5	,	,	,
18637	23834	6	640	640	CD
18637	23834	7	,	,	,
18637	23834	8	643	643	CD
18637	23834	9	Hanauer	Hanauer	NNP
18637	23834	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23834	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23834	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23834	13	Woodruff	Woodruff	NNP
18637	23834	14	,	,	,
18637	23834	15	15	15	CD
18637	23834	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23834	17	.	.	.
18637	23835	1	439	439	CD
18637	23835	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23835	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	23835	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23835	5	,	,	,
18637	23835	6	1174	1174	CD
18637	23835	7	Hancock	Hancock	NNP
18637	23835	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23835	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23835	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23835	11	Muskogee	Muskogee	NNP
18637	23835	12	,	,	,
18637	23835	13	250	250	CD
18637	23835	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23835	15	454	454	CD
18637	23835	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23835	17	1919	1919	CD
18637	23835	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23835	19	,	,	,
18637	23835	20	1059	1059	CD
18637	23835	21	Hancock	Hancock	NNP
18637	23835	22	National	National	NNP
18637	23835	23	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23835	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23835	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23835	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23835	27	Farnum	Farnum	NNP
18637	23835	28	,	,	,
18637	23835	29	176	176	CD
18637	23835	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23835	31	640	640	CD
18637	23835	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23835	33	1900	1900	CD
18637	23835	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23835	35	,	,	,
18637	23835	36	660	660	CD
18637	23835	37	,	,	,
18637	23835	38	678	678	CD
18637	23835	39	Hanford	Hanford	NNP
18637	23835	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23835	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23835	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23835	43	Davies	Davies	NNP
18637	23835	44	,	,	,
18637	23835	45	163	163	CD
18637	23835	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23835	47	273	273	CD
18637	23835	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23835	49	1896	1896	CD
18637	23835	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23835	51	,	,	,
18637	23835	52	329	329	CD
18637	23835	53	Hanley	Hanley	NNP
18637	23835	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23835	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	23835	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23835	57	Donoghue	Donoghue	NNP
18637	23835	58	,	,	,
18637	23835	59	116	116	CD
18637	23835	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23835	61	1	1	CD
18637	23835	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23835	63	1885	1885	CD
18637	23835	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23835	65	,	,	,
18637	23835	66	654	654	CD
18637	23835	67	,	,	,
18637	23835	68	674	674	CD
18637	23835	69	Hanley	Hanley	NNP
18637	23835	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23835	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	23835	72	_	_	NNP
18637	23835	73	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23835	74	City	City	NNP
18637	23835	75	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	23835	76	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23835	77	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23835	78	,	,	,
18637	23835	79	187	187	CD
18637	23835	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23835	81	617	617	CD
18637	23835	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23835	83	1903	1903	CD
18637	23835	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23835	85	,	,	,
18637	23835	86	122	122	CD
18637	23835	87	Hannegan	Hannegan	NNP
18637	23835	88	_	_	NNP
18637	23835	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	23835	90	_	_	NNP
18637	23835	91	Esquire	Esquire	NNP
18637	23835	92	,	,	,
18637	23835	93	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	23835	94	,	,	,
18637	23835	95	327	327	CD
18637	23835	96	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23835	97	146	146	CD
18637	23835	98	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23835	99	1946	1946	CD
18637	23835	100	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23835	101	,	,	,
18637	23835	102	269	269	CD
18637	23835	103	,	,	,
18637	23835	104	804	804	CD
18637	23835	105	Hannibal	Hannibal	NNP
18637	23835	106	&	&	CC
18637	23835	107	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23835	108	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	23836	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23836	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23836	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23836	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23836	5	Husen	Husen	NNP
18637	23836	6	,	,	,
18637	23836	7	95	95	CD
18637	23836	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23836	9	465	465	CD
18637	23836	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23836	11	1878	1878	CD
18637	23836	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23836	13	,	,	,
18637	23836	14	222	222	CD
18637	23836	15	Hannibal	Hannibal	NNP
18637	23836	16	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	23836	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23836	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23836	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23836	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23836	21	United	United	NNP
18637	23836	22	States	States	NNP
18637	23836	23	,	,	,
18637	23836	24	221	221	CD
18637	23836	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23836	26	194	194	CD
18637	23836	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23836	28	1911	1911	CD
18637	23836	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23836	30	,	,	,
18637	23836	31	867	867	CD
18637	23836	32	Hannis	Hannis	NNP
18637	23836	33	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	23836	34	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23836	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23836	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	23836	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23836	38	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	23836	39	,	,	,
18637	23836	40	216	216	CD
18637	23836	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23836	42	285	285	CD
18637	23836	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23836	44	1910	1910	CD
18637	23836	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23836	46	,	,	,
18637	23836	47	1042	1042	CD
18637	23836	48	,	,	,
18637	23836	49	1061	1061	CD
18637	23836	50	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
18637	23836	51	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	23836	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23836	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23836	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	23836	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23836	56	Harding	Harding	NNP
18637	23836	57	,	,	,
18637	23836	58	272	272	CD
18637	23836	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23836	60	494	494	CD
18637	23836	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23836	62	1926	1926	CD
18637	23836	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23836	64	,	,	,
18637	23836	65	1144	1144	CD
18637	23836	66	,	,	,
18637	23836	67	1150	1150	CD
18637	23836	68	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
18637	23836	69	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	23836	70	.	.	.
18637	23837	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23837	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23837	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23837	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23837	5	Moyses	Moyses	NNP
18637	23837	6	,	,	,
18637	23837	7	186	186	CD
18637	23837	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23837	9	181	181	CD
18637	23837	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23837	11	1902	1902	CD
18637	23837	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23837	13	,	,	,
18637	23837	14	262	262	CD
18637	23837	15	,	,	,
18637	23837	16	264	264	CD
18637	23837	17	,	,	,
18637	23837	18	848	848	CD
18637	23837	19	Hans	Hans	NNPS
18637	23837	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23837	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	23837	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23837	23	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	23837	24	,	,	,
18637	23837	25	134	134	CD
18637	23837	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23837	27	1	1	CD
18637	23837	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23837	29	1890	1890	CD
18637	23837	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23837	31	,	,	,
18637	23837	32	930	930	CD
18637	23837	33	Hans	Hans	NNP
18637	23837	34	Rees	Rees	NNPS
18637	23837	35	'	'	POS
18637	23837	36	Sons	Sons	NNPS
18637	23837	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23837	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	23837	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23837	40	North	North	NNP
18637	23837	41	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	23837	42	,	,	,
18637	23837	43	283	283	CD
18637	23837	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23837	45	123	123	CD
18637	23837	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23837	47	1931	1931	CD
18637	23837	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23837	49	,	,	,
18637	23837	50	209	209	CD
18637	23837	51	,	,	,
18637	23837	52	1054	1054	CD
18637	23837	53	Harding	Harding	NNP
18637	23837	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23837	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	23837	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23837	57	Harding	Harding	NNP
18637	23837	58	,	,	,
18637	23837	59	198	198	CD
18637	23837	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23837	61	317	317	CD
18637	23837	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23837	63	1905	1905	CD
18637	23837	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23837	65	,	,	,
18637	23837	66	656	656	CD
18637	23837	67	Hardware	Hardware	NNP
18637	23837	68	Dealers	Dealers	NNPS
18637	23837	69	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	23837	70	.	.	.
18637	23838	1	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23838	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23838	3	.	.	.
18637	23839	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23839	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23839	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	5	Glidden	Glidden	NNP
18637	23839	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23839	7	,	,	,
18637	23839	8	284	284	CD
18637	23839	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23839	10	151	151	CD
18637	23839	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23839	12	1931	1931	CD
18637	23839	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23839	14	,	,	,
18637	23839	15	1089	1089	CD
18637	23839	16	,	,	,
18637	23839	17	1166	1166	CD
18637	23839	18	Harisiades	Harisiades	NNP
18637	23839	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	23839	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	22	Shaughnessy	Shaughnessy	NNP
18637	23839	23	,	,	,
18637	23839	24	342	342	CD
18637	23839	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23839	26	580	580	CD
18637	23839	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23839	28	1952	1952	CD
18637	23839	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23839	30	,	,	,
18637	23839	31	261	261	CD
18637	23839	32	Harkin	Harkin	NNP
18637	23839	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	23839	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	36	Brundage	Brundage	NNP
18637	23839	37	,	,	,
18637	23839	38	276	276	CD
18637	23839	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23839	40	36	36	CD
18637	23839	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23839	42	1928	1928	CD
18637	23839	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23839	44	,	,	,
18637	23839	45	627	627	CD
18637	23839	46	Harkness	Harkness	NNP
18637	23839	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	23839	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	50	Hyde	Hyde	NNP
18637	23839	51	,	,	,
18637	23839	52	98	98	CD
18637	23839	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23839	54	476	476	CD
18637	23839	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23839	56	1879	1879	CD
18637	23839	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23839	58	,	,	,
18637	23839	59	1074	1074	CD
18637	23839	60	Harkrader	Harkrader	NNP
18637	23839	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	23839	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	64	Wadley	Wadley	NNP
18637	23839	65	,	,	,
18637	23839	66	172	172	CD
18637	23839	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23839	68	148	148	CD
18637	23839	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23839	70	1898	1898	CD
18637	23839	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23839	72	,	,	,
18637	23839	73	627	627	CD
18637	23839	74	,	,	,
18637	23839	75	630	630	CD
18637	23839	76	,	,	,
18637	23839	77	634	634	CD
18637	23839	78	Harman	Harman	NNP
18637	23839	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	23839	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	82	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23839	83	,	,	,
18637	23839	84	147	147	CD
18637	23839	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23839	86	396	396	CD
18637	23839	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23839	88	1893	1893	CD
18637	23839	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23839	90	,	,	,
18637	23839	91	230	230	CD
18637	23839	92	Harriman	Harriman	NNP
18637	23839	93	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	94	v.	v.	IN
18637	23839	95	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	96	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23839	97	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	23839	98	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	23839	99	.	.	NNP
18637	23839	100	,	,	,
18637	23839	101	211	211	CD
18637	23839	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23839	103	407	407	CD
18637	23839	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23839	105	1908	1908	CD
18637	23839	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23839	107	,	,	,
18637	23839	108	84	84	CD
18637	23839	109	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	23839	110	,	,	,
18637	23839	111	Re	Re	NNP
18637	23839	112	,	,	,
18637	23839	113	221	221	CD
18637	23839	114	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23839	115	274	274	CD
18637	23839	116	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23839	117	1911	1911	CD
18637	23839	118	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23839	119	,	,	,
18637	23839	120	843	843	CD
18637	23839	121	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	23839	122	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	123	v.	v.	IN
18637	23839	124	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	125	Balk	Balk	NNP
18637	23839	126	,	,	,
18637	23839	127	198	198	CD
18637	23839	128	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23839	129	215	215	CD
18637	23839	130	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23839	131	1905	1905	CD
18637	23839	132	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23839	133	,	,	,
18637	23839	134	674	674	CD
18637	23839	135	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	23839	136	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	137	v.	v.	IN
18637	23839	138	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	139	South	South	NNP
18637	23839	140	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	23839	141	,	,	,
18637	23839	142	338	338	CD
18637	23839	143	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23839	144	68	68	CD
18637	23839	145	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23839	146	1949	1949	CD
18637	23839	147	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23839	148	,	,	,
18637	23839	149	1120	1120	CD
18637	23839	150	,	,	,
18637	23839	151	1121	1121	CD
18637	23839	152	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	23839	153	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	154	v.	v.	IN
18637	23839	155	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	156	United	United	NNP
18637	23839	157	States	States	NNP
18637	23839	158	,	,	,
18637	23839	159	331	331	CD
18637	23839	160	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23839	161	145	145	CD
18637	23839	162	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23839	163	1947	1947	CD
18637	23839	164	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23839	165	,	,	,
18637	23839	166	828	828	NNP
18637	23839	167	Harrisburg	Harrisburg	NNP
18637	23839	168	,	,	,
18637	23839	169	The	the	DT
18637	23839	170	,	,	,
18637	23839	171	119	119	CD
18637	23839	172	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23839	173	199	199	CD
18637	23839	174	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23839	175	1886	1886	CD
18637	23839	176	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23839	177	,	,	,
18637	23839	178	575	575	CD
18637	23839	179	Harrison	Harrison	NNP
18637	23839	180	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	181	v.	v.	IN
18637	23839	182	_	_	NNP
18637	23839	183	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23839	184	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	23839	185	&	&	CC
18637	23839	186	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	23840	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23840	2	,	,	,
18637	23840	3	232	232	CD
18637	23840	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23840	5	318	318	CD
18637	23840	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23840	7	1914	1914	CD
18637	23840	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23840	9	,	,	,
18637	23840	10	638	638	CD
18637	23840	11	Hart	Hart	NNP
18637	23840	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23840	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23840	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23840	15	United	United	NNP
18637	23840	16	States	States	NNP
18637	23840	17	,	,	,
18637	23840	18	118	118	CD
18637	23840	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23840	20	62	62	CD
18637	23840	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23840	22	1886	1886	CD
18637	23840	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23840	24	,	,	,
18637	23840	25	323	323	CD
18637	23840	26	,	,	,
18637	23840	27	324	324	CD
18637	23840	28	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	23840	29	Accident	Accident	NNP
18637	23840	30	&	&	CC
18637	23840	31	Indemnity	Indemnity	NNP
18637	23840	32	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23840	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23840	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	23840	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23840	36	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23840	37	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23840	38	rel	rel	NN
18637	23840	39	.	.	.
18637	23841	1	McLaughlin	McLaughlin	NNP
18637	23841	2	,	,	,
18637	23841	3	298	298	CD
18637	23841	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23841	5	155	155	CD
18637	23841	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23841	7	1936	1936	CD
18637	23841	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23841	9	,	,	,
18637	23841	10	235	235	CD
18637	23841	11	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	23841	12	Acci	Acci	NNP
18637	23841	13	.	.	.
18637	23842	1	&	&	CC
18637	23842	2	Indem	Indem	NNP
18637	23842	3	.	.	.
18637	23843	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23843	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23843	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23843	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23843	5	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	23843	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23843	7	N.O.	N.O.	NNP
18637	23843	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23844	1	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23844	2	.	.	.
18637	23845	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23845	2	,	,	,
18637	23845	3	291	291	CD
18637	23845	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23845	5	352	352	CD
18637	23845	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23845	7	1934	1934	CD
18637	23845	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23845	9	,	,	,
18637	23845	10	1022	1022	CD
18637	23845	11	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	23845	12	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23845	13	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23845	14	.	.	.
18637	23846	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23846	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23846	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23846	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23846	5	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	23846	6	,	,	,
18637	23846	7	245	245	CD
18637	23846	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23846	9	146	146	CD
18637	23846	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23846	11	1917	1917	CD
18637	23846	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23846	13	,	,	,
18637	23846	14	654	654	CD
18637	23846	15	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	23846	16	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23846	17	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23846	18	.	.	.
18637	23847	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23847	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23847	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23847	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23847	5	Blincoe	Blincoe	NNP
18637	23847	6	,	,	,
18637	23847	7	255	255	CD
18637	23847	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23847	9	129	129	CD
18637	23847	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23847	11	1921	1921	CD
18637	23847	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23847	13	,	,	,
18637	23847	14	1092	1092	CD
18637	23847	15	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	23847	16	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23847	17	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23847	18	.	.	.
18637	23848	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23848	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23848	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23848	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23848	5	Ibs	Ibs	NNP
18637	23848	6	,	,	,
18637	23848	7	237	237	CD
18637	23848	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23848	9	662	662	CD
18637	23848	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23848	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	23848	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23848	13	,	,	,
18637	23848	14	654	654	CD
18637	23848	15	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	23848	16	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	23848	17	Boiler	Boiler	NNP
18637	23848	18	Inspection	Inspection	NNP
18637	23848	19	&	&	CC
18637	23848	20	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23848	21	.	.	.
18637	23849	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23849	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23849	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23849	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23849	5	Harrison	Harrison	NNP
18637	23849	6	,	,	,
18637	23849	7	301	301	CD
18637	23849	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23849	9	459	459	CD
18637	23849	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23849	11	1937	1937	CD
18637	23849	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23849	13	,	,	,
18637	23849	14	1156	1156	CD
18637	23849	15	Hartzel	Hartzel	NNP
18637	23849	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23849	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23849	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23849	19	United	United	NNP
18637	23849	20	States	States	NNP
18637	23849	21	,	,	,
18637	23849	22	322	322	CD
18637	23849	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23849	24	680	680	CD
18637	23849	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23849	26	1944	1944	CD
18637	23849	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23849	28	,	,	,
18637	23849	29	794	794	CD
18637	23849	30	Harvester	Harvester	NNP
18637	23849	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23849	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23849	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23849	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23849	35	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	23849	36	.	.	.
18637	23850	1	of	of	IN
18637	23850	2	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	23850	3	,	,	,
18637	23850	4	322	322	CD
18637	23850	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23850	6	435	435	CD
18637	23850	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23850	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	23850	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23850	10	,	,	,
18637	23850	11	1044	1044	CD
18637	23850	12	Harvester	Harvester	NNP
18637	23850	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23850	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23850	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23850	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23850	17	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	23850	18	.	.	.
18637	23851	1	of	of	IN
18637	23851	2	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	23851	3	,	,	,
18637	23851	4	322	322	CD
18637	23851	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23851	6	340	340	CD
18637	23851	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23851	8	1944	1944	CD
18637	23851	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23851	10	,	,	,
18637	23851	11	204	204	CD
18637	23851	12	Hauenstein	Hauenstein	NNP
18637	23851	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23851	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	23851	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23851	16	Lynham	Lynham	NNP
18637	23851	17	,	,	,
18637	23851	18	100	100	CD
18637	23851	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23851	20	483	483	CD
18637	23851	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23851	22	1880	1880	CD
18637	23851	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23851	24	,	,	,
18637	23851	25	415	415	CD
18637	23851	26	Hauge	Hauge	NNP
18637	23851	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23851	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	23851	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23851	30	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23851	31	,	,	,
18637	23851	32	299	299	CD
18637	23851	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23851	34	387	387	CD
18637	23851	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23851	36	1937	1937	CD
18637	23851	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23851	38	,	,	,
18637	23851	39	1018	1018	CD
18637	23851	40	Haupt	Haupt	NNP
18637	23851	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23851	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	23851	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23851	44	United	United	NNP
18637	23851	45	States	States	NNP
18637	23851	46	,	,	,
18637	23851	47	330	330	CD
18637	23851	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23851	49	631	631	CD
18637	23851	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23851	51	1947	1947	CD
18637	23851	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23851	53	,	,	,
18637	23851	54	641	641	CD
18637	23851	55	,	,	,
18637	23851	56	645	645	CD
18637	23851	57	Havemeyer	Havemeyer	NNP
18637	23851	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23851	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	23851	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23851	61	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	23851	62	County	County	NNP
18637	23851	63	,	,	,
18637	23851	64	3	3	CD
18637	23851	65	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23851	66	.	.	.
18637	23852	1	294	294	CD
18637	23852	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23852	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	23852	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23852	5	,	,	,
18637	23852	6	331	331	CD
18637	23852	7	Haver	Haver	NNP
18637	23852	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23852	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23852	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23852	11	Yaker	Yaker	NNP
18637	23852	12	,	,	,
18637	23852	13	9	9	CD
18637	23852	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23852	15	.	.	.
18637	23853	1	32	32	CD
18637	23853	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23853	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	23853	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23853	5	,	,	,
18637	23853	6	404	404	CD
18637	23853	7	,	,	,
18637	23853	8	418	418	CD
18637	23853	9	Hawaii	Hawaii	NNP
18637	23853	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23853	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23853	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23853	13	Mankichi	Mankichi	NNP
18637	23853	14	,	,	,
18637	23853	15	190	190	CD
18637	23853	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23853	17	197	197	CD
18637	23853	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23853	19	1903	1903	CD
18637	23853	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23853	21	,	,	,
18637	23853	22	703	703	CD
18637	23853	23	Hawes	Hawes	NNP
18637	23853	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23853	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23853	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23853	27	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23853	28	,	,	,
18637	23853	29	258	258	CD
18637	23853	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23853	31	1	1	CD
18637	23853	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23853	33	1922	1922	CD
18637	23853	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23853	35	,	,	,
18637	23853	36	1032	1032	CD
18637	23853	37	,	,	,
18637	23853	38	1096	1096	CD
18637	23853	39	Hawes	Hawes	NNP
18637	23853	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23853	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23853	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23853	43	Oakland	Oakland	NNP
18637	23853	44	,	,	,
18637	23853	45	104	104	CD
18637	23853	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23853	47	450	450	CD
18637	23853	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23853	49	1881	1881	CD
18637	23853	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23853	51	,	,	,
18637	23853	52	541	541	CD
18637	23853	53	Hawk	Hawk	NNP
18637	23853	54	,	,	,
18637	23853	55	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23853	56	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23853	57	,	,	,
18637	23853	58	321	321	CD
18637	23853	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23853	60	114	114	CD
18637	23853	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23853	62	1944	1944	CD
18637	23853	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23853	64	,	,	,
18637	23853	65	1125	1125	CD
18637	23853	66	Hawk	Hawk	NNP
18637	23853	67	_	_	NNP
18637	23853	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	23853	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23853	70	Olson	Olson	NNP
18637	23853	71	,	,	,
18637	23853	72	326	326	CD
18637	23853	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23853	74	271	271	CD
18637	23853	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23853	76	1945	1945	CD
18637	23853	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23853	78	,	,	,
18637	23853	79	1100	1100	CD
18637	23853	80	,	,	,
18637	23853	81	1102	1102	CD
18637	23853	82	Hawke	Hawke	NNP
18637	23853	83	_	_	NNP
18637	23853	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	23853	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23853	86	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	23853	87	,	,	,
18637	23853	88	253	253	CD
18637	23853	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23853	90	221	221	CD
18637	23853	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23853	92	1920	1920	CD
18637	23853	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23853	94	,	,	,
18637	23853	95	386	386	CD
18637	23853	96	,	,	,
18637	23853	97	713	713	CD
18637	23853	98	Hawker	Hawker	NNP
18637	23853	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23853	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	23853	101	_	_	NNP
18637	23853	102	New	New	NNP
18637	23853	103	York	York	NNP
18637	23853	104	,	,	,
18637	23853	105	170	170	CD
18637	23853	106	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23853	107	189	189	CD
18637	23853	108	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23853	109	1898	1898	CD
18637	23853	110	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23853	111	,	,	,
18637	23853	112	328	328	CD
18637	23853	113	,	,	,
18637	23853	114	1024	1024	CD
18637	23853	115	,	,	,
18637	23853	116	1096	1096	CD
18637	23853	117	Hawkins	Hawkins	NNP
18637	23853	118	_	_	NNP
18637	23853	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	23853	120	_	_	NNP
18637	23853	121	Barney	Barney	NNP
18637	23853	122	,	,	,
18637	23853	123	5	5	CD
18637	23853	124	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23853	125	.	.	.
18637	23854	1	457	457	CD
18637	23854	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23854	3	1831	1831	CD
18637	23854	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23854	5	,	,	,
18637	23854	6	355	355	CD
18637	23854	7	Hawkins	Hawkins	NNP
18637	23854	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23854	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23854	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23854	11	Bleakly	Bleakly	NNP
18637	23854	12	,	,	,
18637	23854	13	243	243	CD
18637	23854	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23854	15	210	210	CD
18637	23854	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23854	17	1917	1917	CD
18637	23854	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23854	19	,	,	,
18637	23854	20	989	989	CD
18637	23854	21	,	,	,
18637	23854	22	1094	1094	CD
18637	23854	23	Hawks	Hawks	NNPS
18637	23854	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23854	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23854	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23854	27	Hamill	Hamill	NNP
18637	23854	28	,	,	,
18637	23854	29	288	288	CD
18637	23854	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23854	31	52	52	CD
18637	23854	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23854	33	1933	1933	CD
18637	23854	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23854	35	,	,	,
18637	23854	36	934	934	CD
18637	23854	37	Hawley	Hawley	NNP
18637	23854	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23854	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23854	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23854	41	Malden	Malden	NNP
18637	23854	42	,	,	,
18637	23854	43	232	232	CD
18637	23854	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23854	45	1	1	CD
18637	23854	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23854	47	1914	1914	CD
18637	23854	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23854	49	,	,	,
18637	23854	50	1044	1044	CD
18637	23854	51	Hawley	Hawley	NNP
18637	23854	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23854	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	23854	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23854	55	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	23854	56	,	,	,
18637	23854	57	232	232	CD
18637	23854	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23854	59	718	718	CD
18637	23854	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23854	61	1914	1914	CD
18637	23854	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23854	63	,	,	,
18637	23854	64	987	987	CD
18637	23854	65	Hayburn	Hayburn	NNP
18637	23854	66	's	's	POS
18637	23854	67	Case	Case	NNP
18637	23854	68	,	,	,
18637	23854	69	2	2	CD
18637	23854	70	Dall	dall	NN
18637	23854	71	.	.	.
18637	23855	1	409	409	CD
18637	23855	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23855	3	1792	1792	CD
18637	23855	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23855	5	,	,	,
18637	23855	6	485	485	CD
18637	23855	7	,	,	,
18637	23855	8	512	512	CD
18637	23855	9	,	,	,
18637	23855	10	550	550	CD
18637	23855	11	,	,	,
18637	23855	12	558	558	CD
18637	23855	13	,	,	,
18637	23855	14	623	623	CD
18637	23855	15	Hayes	Hayes	NNP
18637	23855	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23855	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23855	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23855	19	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	23855	20	,	,	,
18637	23855	21	120	120	CD
18637	23855	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23855	23	68	68	CD
18637	23855	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23855	25	1887	1887	CD
18637	23855	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23855	27	,	,	,
18637	23855	28	210	210	CD
18637	23855	29	,	,	,
18637	23855	30	1166	1166	CD
18637	23855	31	Hayman	Hayman	NNP
18637	23855	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23855	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23855	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23855	35	Galveston	Galveston	NNP
18637	23855	36	,	,	,
18637	23855	37	273	273	CD
18637	23855	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23855	39	414	414	CD
18637	23855	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23855	41	1927	1927	CD
18637	23855	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23855	43	,	,	,
18637	23855	44	1024	1024	CD
18637	23855	45	,	,	,
18637	23855	46	1155	1155	CD
18637	23855	47	Hays	Hays	NNP
18637	23855	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23855	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	23855	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23855	51	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	23855	52	Mail	Mail	NNP
18637	23855	53	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	23855	54	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23855	55	,	,	,
18637	23855	56	17	17	CD
18637	23855	57	How	how	WRB
18637	23855	58	.	.	.
18637	23856	1	596	596	CD
18637	23856	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23856	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	23856	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23856	5	,	,	,
18637	23856	6	210	210	CD
18637	23856	7	Hays	Hays	NNPS
18637	23856	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23856	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23856	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23856	11	Seattle	Seattle	NNP
18637	23856	12	,	,	,
18637	23856	13	251	251	CD
18637	23856	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23856	15	233	233	CD
18637	23856	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23856	17	1920	1920	CD
18637	23856	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23856	19	,	,	,
18637	23856	20	1070	1070	CD
18637	23856	21	Head	Head	NNP
18637	23856	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23856	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23856	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23856	25	Amoskeag	Amoskeag	NNP
18637	23856	26	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23856	27	.	.	.
18637	23857	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23857	2	,	,	,
18637	23857	3	113	113	CD
18637	23857	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23857	5	9	9	CD
18637	23857	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23857	7	1885	1885	CD
18637	23857	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23857	9	,	,	,
18637	23857	10	1066	1066	CD
18637	23857	11	Head	Head	NNP
18637	23857	12	Money	Money	NNP
18637	23857	13	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	23857	14	,	,	,
18637	23857	15	112	112	CD
18637	23857	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23857	17	580	580	CD
18637	23857	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23857	19	1884	1884	CD
18637	23857	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23857	21	,	,	,
18637	23857	22	110	110	CD
18637	23857	23	,	,	,
18637	23857	24	111	111	CD
18637	23857	25	,	,	,
18637	23857	26	414	414	CD
18637	23857	27	Heald	Heald	NNP
18637	23857	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23857	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23857	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23857	31	District	District	NNP
18637	23857	32	of	of	IN
18637	23857	33	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23857	34	,	,	,
18637	23857	35	259	259	CD
18637	23857	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23857	37	114	114	CD
18637	23857	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23857	39	1922	1922	CD
18637	23857	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23857	41	,	,	,
18637	23857	42	304	304	CD
18637	23857	43	Heath	Heath	NNP
18637	23857	44	&	&	CC
18637	23857	45	M.	M.	NNP
18637	23857	46	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23857	47	.	.	.
18637	23858	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23858	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23858	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23858	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23858	5	Worst	Worst	NNP
18637	23858	6	,	,	,
18637	23858	7	207	207	CD
18637	23858	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23858	9	338	338	CD
18637	23858	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23858	11	1907	1907	CD
18637	23858	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23858	13	,	,	,
18637	23858	14	1019	1019	CD
18637	23858	15	Hebe	Hebe	NNP
18637	23858	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23858	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23858	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23858	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23858	20	Shaw	Shaw	NNP
18637	23858	21	,	,	,
18637	23858	22	248	248	CD
18637	23858	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23858	24	297	297	CD
18637	23858	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23858	26	1919	1919	CD
18637	23858	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23858	28	,	,	,
18637	23858	29	237	237	CD
18637	23858	30	,	,	,
18637	23858	31	1031	1031	CD
18637	23858	32	Heckers	Heckers	NNP
18637	23858	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23858	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	23858	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23858	36	Fowler	Fowler	NNP
18637	23858	37	,	,	,
18637	23858	38	2	2	CD
18637	23858	39	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23858	40	.	.	.
18637	23859	1	123	123	CD
18637	23859	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23859	3	1864	1864	CD
18637	23859	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23859	5	,	,	,
18637	23859	6	527	527	CD
18637	23859	7	Heff	Heff	NNP
18637	23859	8	,	,	,
18637	23859	9	In	in	IN
18637	23859	10	re	re	NN
18637	23859	11	,	,	,
18637	23859	12	197	197	CD
18637	23859	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23859	14	488	488	CD
18637	23859	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23859	16	1905	1905	CD
18637	23859	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23859	18	,	,	,
18637	23859	19	253	253	CD
18637	23859	20	Hegeman	Hegeman	NNP
18637	23859	21	Farms	Farms	NNPS
18637	23859	22	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23859	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23859	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23859	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23859	26	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	23859	27	,	,	,
18637	23859	28	293	293	CD
18637	23859	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23859	30	163	163	CD
18637	23859	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23859	32	1934	1934	CD
18637	23859	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23859	34	,	,	,
18637	23859	35	245	245	CD
18637	23859	36	Heim	Heim	NNP
18637	23859	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23859	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	23859	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23859	40	McCall	McCall	NNP
18637	23859	41	,	,	,
18637	23859	42	239	239	CD
18637	23859	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23859	44	175	175	CD
18637	23859	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23859	46	1915	1915	CD
18637	23859	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23859	48	,	,	,
18637	23859	49	971	971	CD
18637	23859	50	,	,	,
18637	23859	51	1158	1158	CD
18637	23859	52	Heine	Heine	NNP
18637	23859	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23859	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	23859	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23859	56	Levee	Levee	NNP
18637	23859	57	Commissioners	Commissioners	NNP
18637	23859	58	,	,	,
18637	23859	59	19	19	CD
18637	23859	60	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23859	61	.	.	.
18637	23860	1	655	655	CD
18637	23860	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23860	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	23860	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23860	5	,	,	,
18637	23860	6	356	356	CD
18637	23860	7	Heiner	Heiner	NNP
18637	23860	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23860	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	11	Donnan	Donnan	NNP
18637	23860	12	,	,	,
18637	23860	13	285	285	CD
18637	23860	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23860	15	312	312	CD
18637	23860	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23860	17	1932	1932	CD
18637	23860	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23860	19	,	,	,
18637	23860	20	863	863	CD
18637	23860	21	Heisler	Heisler	NNP
18637	23860	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23860	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	25	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	23860	26	Colliery	Colliery	NNP
18637	23860	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23860	28	,	,	,
18637	23860	29	260	260	CD
18637	23860	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23860	31	245	245	CD
18637	23860	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23860	33	1922	1922	CD
18637	23860	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23860	35	,	,	,
18637	23860	36	181	181	CD
18637	23860	37	,	,	,
18637	23860	38	1148	1148	CD
18637	23860	39	Helena	Helena	NNP
18637	23860	40	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	23860	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23860	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23860	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	45	Helena	Helena	NNP
18637	23860	46	,	,	,
18637	23860	47	195	195	CD
18637	23860	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23860	49	383	383	CD
18637	23860	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23860	51	1904	1904	CD
18637	23860	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23860	53	,	,	,
18637	23860	54	1009	1009	CD
18637	23860	55	Helis	Helis	NNP
18637	23860	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	23860	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	59	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	23860	60	,	,	,
18637	23860	61	308	308	CD
18637	23860	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23860	63	365	365	CD
18637	23860	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23860	65	1939	1939	CD
18637	23860	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23860	67	,	,	,
18637	23860	68	848	848	CD
18637	23860	69	Helson	Helson	NNP
18637	23860	70	&	&	CC
18637	23860	71	Randolph	Randolph	NNP
18637	23860	72	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	23860	74	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	75	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23860	76	,	,	,
18637	23860	77	279	279	CD
18637	23860	78	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23860	79	245	245	CD
18637	23860	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23860	81	1929	1929	CD
18637	23860	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23860	83	,	,	,
18637	23860	84	186	186	CD
18637	23860	85	,	,	,
18637	23860	86	195	195	CD
18637	23860	87	,	,	,
18637	23860	88	231	231	CD
18637	23860	89	,	,	,
18637	23860	90	968	968	CD
18637	23860	91	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23860	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	23860	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	95	Bruun	Bruun	NNP
18637	23860	96	,	,	,
18637	23860	97	309	309	CD
18637	23860	98	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23860	99	461	461	CD
18637	23860	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23860	101	1940	1940	CD
18637	23860	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23860	103	,	,	,
18637	23860	104	1198	1198	CD
18637	23860	105	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23860	106	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	107	v.	v.	IN
18637	23860	108	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	109	Bullard	Bullard	NNP
18637	23860	110	,	,	,
18637	23860	111	303	303	CD
18637	23860	112	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23860	113	297	297	CD
18637	23860	114	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23860	115	1938	1938	CD
18637	23860	116	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23860	117	,	,	,
18637	23860	118	321	321	CD
18637	23860	119	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23860	120	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	121	v.	v.	IN
18637	23860	122	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	123	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	23860	124	,	,	,
18637	23860	125	301	301	CD
18637	23860	126	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23860	127	619	619	CD
18637	23860	128	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23860	129	1937	1937	CD
18637	23860	130	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23860	131	,	,	,
18637	23860	132	116	116	CD
18637	23860	133	,	,	,
18637	23860	134	724	724	CD
18637	23860	135	,	,	,
18637	23860	136	863	863	CD
18637	23860	137	,	,	,
18637	23860	138	918	918	CD
18637	23860	139	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23860	140	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	141	v.	v.	IN
18637	23860	142	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	143	Gerhardt	Gerhardt	NNP
18637	23860	144	,	,	,
18637	23860	145	304	304	CD
18637	23860	146	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23860	147	405	405	CD
18637	23860	148	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23860	149	1938	1938	CD
18637	23860	150	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23860	151	,	,	,
18637	23860	152	106	106	CD
18637	23860	153	,	,	,
18637	23860	154	108	108	CD
18637	23860	155	,	,	,
18637	23860	156	109	109	CD
18637	23860	157	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23860	158	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	159	v.	v.	IN
18637	23860	160	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	161	Gowran	Gowran	NNP
18637	23860	162	,	,	,
18637	23860	163	302	302	CD
18637	23860	164	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23860	165	238	238	CD
18637	23860	166	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23860	167	1937	1937	CD
18637	23860	168	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23860	169	,	,	,
18637	23860	170	1195	1195	CD
18637	23860	171	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23860	172	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	173	v.	v.	IN
18637	23860	174	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	175	Griffiths	Griffiths	NNP
18637	23860	176	,	,	,
18637	23860	177	318	318	CD
18637	23860	178	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23860	179	371	371	CD
18637	23860	180	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23860	181	1943	1943	CD
18637	23860	182	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23860	183	,	,	,
18637	23860	184	566	566	CD
18637	23860	185	,	,	,
18637	23860	186	1195	1195	CD
18637	23860	187	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23860	188	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	189	v.	v.	IN
18637	23860	190	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	191	Horst	Horst	NNP
18637	23860	192	,	,	,
18637	23860	193	311	311	CD
18637	23860	194	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23860	195	112	112	CD
18637	23860	196	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23860	197	1940	1940	CD
18637	23860	198	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23860	199	,	,	,
18637	23860	200	1198	1198	CD
18637	23860	201	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23860	202	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	203	v.	v.	IN
18637	23860	204	_	_	NNP
18637	23860	205	Independent	Independent	NNP
18637	23860	206	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23860	207	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23860	208	.	.	.
18637	23861	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23861	2	,	,	,
18637	23861	3	292	292	CD
18637	23861	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23861	5	371	371	CD
18637	23861	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23861	7	1934	1934	CD
18637	23861	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23861	9	,	,	,
18637	23861	10	1200	1200	CD
18637	23861	11	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23861	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23861	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	15	Lerner	Lerner	NNP
18637	23861	16	Stores	Stores	NNP
18637	23861	17	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23861	18	,	,	,
18637	23861	19	314	314	CD
18637	23861	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23861	21	463	463	CD
18637	23861	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23861	23	1941	1941	CD
18637	23861	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23861	25	,	,	,
18637	23861	26	862	862	CD
18637	23861	27	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23861	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23861	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	31	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	23861	32	,	,	,
18637	23861	33	303	303	CD
18637	23861	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23861	35	391	391	CD
18637	23861	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23861	37	1938	1938	CD
18637	23861	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23861	39	,	,	,
18637	23861	40	840	840	CD
18637	23861	41	,	,	,
18637	23861	42	841	841	CD
18637	23861	43	,	,	,
18637	23861	44	863	863	CD
18637	23861	45	,	,	,
18637	23861	46	1197	1197	CD
18637	23861	47	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23861	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	23861	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	51	Mountain	Mountain	NNP
18637	23861	52	Producers	Producers	NNPS
18637	23861	53	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23861	54	,	,	,
18637	23861	55	303	303	CD
18637	23861	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23861	57	376	376	CD
18637	23861	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23861	59	1938	1938	CD
18637	23861	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23861	61	,	,	,
18637	23861	62	108	108	CD
18637	23861	63	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23861	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	23861	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	67	National	National	NNP
18637	23861	68	Grocery	Grocery	NNP
18637	23861	69	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23861	70	,	,	,
18637	23861	71	304	304	CD
18637	23861	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23861	73	282	282	CD
18637	23861	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23861	75	1938	1938	CD
18637	23861	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23861	77	,	,	,
18637	23861	78	863	863	CD
18637	23861	79	,	,	,
18637	23861	80	921	921	CD
18637	23861	81	,	,	,
18637	23861	82	1197	1197	CD
18637	23861	83	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23861	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	23861	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	87	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	23861	88	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	23861	89	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	23861	90	,	,	,
18637	23861	91	311	311	CD
18637	23861	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23861	93	46	46	CD
18637	23861	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23861	95	1940	1940	CD
18637	23861	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23861	97	,	,	,
18637	23861	98	863	863	CD
18637	23861	99	,	,	,
18637	23861	100	921	921	CD
18637	23861	101	,	,	,
18637	23861	102	1196	1196	CD
18637	23861	103	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23861	104	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	105	v.	v.	IN
18637	23861	106	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	107	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	23861	108	,	,	,
18637	23861	109	293	293	CD
18637	23861	110	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23861	111	214	214	CD
18637	23861	112	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23861	113	1934	1934	CD
18637	23861	114	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23861	115	,	,	,
18637	23861	116	107	107	CD
18637	23861	117	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23861	118	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	23861	120	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	121	Winmill	Winmill	NNP
18637	23861	122	,	,	,
18637	23861	123	305	305	CD
18637	23861	124	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23861	125	79	79	CD
18637	23861	126	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23861	127	1938	1938	CD
18637	23861	128	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23861	129	,	,	,
18637	23861	130	1200	1200	CD
18637	23861	131	Helwig	Helwig	NNP
18637	23861	132	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	133	v.	v.	IN
18637	23861	134	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	135	United	United	NNP
18637	23861	136	States	States	NNP
18637	23861	137	,	,	,
18637	23861	138	188	188	CD
18637	23861	139	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23861	140	605	605	CD
18637	23861	141	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23861	142	1903	1903	CD
18637	23861	143	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23861	144	,	,	,
18637	23861	145	111	111	CD
18637	23861	146	Hemphill	Hemphill	NNP
18637	23861	147	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	148	v.	v.	IN
18637	23861	149	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	150	Orloff	Orloff	NNP
18637	23861	151	,	,	,
18637	23861	152	277	277	CD
18637	23861	153	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23861	154	537	537	CD
18637	23861	155	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23861	156	1928	1928	CD
18637	23861	157	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23861	158	,	,	,
18637	23861	159	689	689	CD
18637	23861	160	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	23861	161	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	162	v.	v.	IN
18637	23861	163	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	164	New	New	NNP
18637	23861	165	York	York	NNP
18637	23861	166	,	,	,
18637	23861	167	92	92	CD
18637	23861	168	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23861	169	259	259	CD
18637	23861	170	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23861	171	1876	1876	CD
18637	23861	172	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23861	173	,	,	,
18637	23861	174	122	122	CD
18637	23861	175	,	,	,
18637	23861	176	193	193	CD
18637	23861	177	,	,	,
18637	23861	178	216	216	CD
18637	23861	179	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	23861	180	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	181	v.	v.	IN
18637	23861	182	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	183	United	United	NNP
18637	23861	184	States	States	NNP
18637	23861	185	,	,	,
18637	23861	186	339	339	CD
18637	23861	187	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23861	188	816	816	CD
18637	23861	189	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23861	190	1950	1950	CD
18637	23861	191	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23861	192	,	,	,
18637	23861	193	1162	1162	CD
18637	23861	194	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	23861	195	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23861	196	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	197	v.	v.	IN
18637	23861	198	_	_	NNP
18637	23861	199	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	23861	200	,	,	,
18637	23861	201	300	300	CD
18637	23861	202	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23861	203	258	258	CD
18637	23861	204	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23861	205	1937	1937	CD
18637	23861	206	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23861	207	,	,	,
18637	23861	208	1026	1026	CD
18637	23861	209	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	23861	210	's	's	POS
18637	23861	211	Distilled	Distilled	NNP
18637	23861	212	Spirits	Spirits	NNPS
18637	23861	213	,	,	,
18637	23861	214	14	14	CD
18637	23861	215	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23861	216	.	.	.
18637	23862	1	44	44	CD
18637	23862	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23862	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	23862	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23862	5	,	,	,
18637	23862	6	897	897	CD
18637	23862	7	Hendersonville	Hendersonville	NNP
18637	23862	8	Light	Light	NNP
18637	23862	9	&	&	CC
18637	23862	10	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23862	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23862	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23862	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23862	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23862	15	Blue	Blue	NNP
18637	23862	16	Ridge	Ridge	NNP
18637	23862	17	Interurban	Interurban	NNP
18637	23862	18	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23862	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23862	20	,	,	,
18637	23862	21	243	243	CD
18637	23862	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23862	23	563	563	CD
18637	23862	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23862	25	1917	1917	CD
18637	23862	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23862	27	,	,	,
18637	23862	28	1065	1065	CD
18637	23862	29	Hendrick	Hendrick	NNP
18637	23862	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23862	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23862	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23862	33	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	23862	34	,	,	,
18637	23862	35	235	235	CD
18637	23862	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23862	37	610	610	CD
18637	23862	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23862	39	1915	1915	CD
18637	23862	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23862	41	,	,	,
18637	23862	42	211	211	CD
18637	23862	43	,	,	,
18637	23862	44	212	212	CD
18637	23862	45	,	,	,
18637	23862	46	227	227	CD
18637	23862	47	,	,	,
18637	23862	48	540	540	CD
18637	23862	49	Hendry	Hendry	NNP
18637	23862	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23862	51	C.J.	C.J.	NNP
18637	23862	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23863	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23863	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23863	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23863	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23863	5	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	23863	6	,	,	,
18637	23863	7	318	318	CD
18637	23863	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23863	9	133	133	CD
18637	23863	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23863	11	1943	1943	CD
18637	23863	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23863	13	,	,	,
18637	23863	14	575	575	CD
18637	23863	15	,	,	,
18637	23863	16	576	576	CD
18637	23863	17	Hendy	Hendy	NNP
18637	23863	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23863	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23863	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23863	21	Miners	Miners	NNPS
18637	23863	22	'	'	POS
18637	23863	23	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	23863	24	Works	Works	NNP
18637	23863	25	,	,	,
18637	23863	26	127	127	CD
18637	23863	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23863	28	370	370	CD
18637	23863	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23863	30	1888	1888	CD
18637	23863	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23863	32	,	,	,
18637	23863	33	273	273	CD
18637	23863	34	Henkels	Henkels	NNPS
18637	23863	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23863	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	23863	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23863	38	Sutherland	Sutherland	NNP
18637	23863	39	,	,	,
18637	23863	40	271	271	CD
18637	23863	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23863	42	298	298	CD
18637	23863	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23863	44	1926	1926	CD
18637	23863	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23863	46	,	,	,
18637	23863	47	872	872	CD
18637	23863	48	Henley	Henley	NNP
18637	23863	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23863	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	23863	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23863	52	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	23863	53	,	,	,
18637	23863	54	215	215	CD
18637	23863	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23863	56	373	373	CD
18637	23863	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23863	58	1910	1910	CD
18637	23863	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23863	60	,	,	,
18637	23863	61	355	355	CD
18637	23863	62	Henneford	Henneford	NNP
18637	23863	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23863	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	23863	65	_	_	NNP
18637	23863	66	Silas	Silas	NNP
18637	23863	67	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	23863	68	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23863	69	,	,	,
18637	23863	70	300	300	CD
18637	23863	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23863	72	577	577	CD
18637	23863	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23863	74	1937	1937	CD
18637	23863	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23863	76	,	,	,
18637	23863	77	189	189	CD
18637	23863	78	Hennen	Hennen	NNP
18637	23863	79	,	,	,
18637	23863	80	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23863	81	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23863	82	,	,	,
18637	23863	83	13	13	CD
18637	23863	84	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23863	85	.	.	.
18637	23864	1	225	225	CD
18637	23864	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23864	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	23864	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23864	5	,	,	,
18637	23864	6	453	453	CD
18637	23864	7	,	,	,
18637	23864	8	457	457	CD
18637	23864	9	Hennen	Hennen	NNP
18637	23864	10	,	,	,
18637	23864	11	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23864	12	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23864	13	,	,	,
18637	23864	14	13	13	CD
18637	23864	15	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23864	16	.	.	.
18637	23865	1	230	230	CD
18637	23865	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23865	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	23865	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23865	5	,	,	,
18637	23865	6	452	452	CD
18637	23865	7	Hennington	Hennington	NNP
18637	23865	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23865	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23865	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23865	11	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23865	12	,	,	,
18637	23865	13	163	163	CD
18637	23865	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23865	15	299	299	CD
18637	23865	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23865	17	1896	1896	CD
18637	23865	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23865	19	,	,	,
18637	23865	20	222	222	CD
18637	23865	21	Henry	Henry	NNP
18637	23865	22	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	23865	23	&	&	CC
18637	23865	24	Son	Son	NNP
18637	23865	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23865	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23865	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23865	28	Little	Little	NNP
18637	23865	29	Falls	Falls	NNP
18637	23865	30	Fibre	Fibre	NNP
18637	23865	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23865	32	,	,	,
18637	23865	33	280	280	CD
18637	23865	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23865	35	369	369	CD
18637	23865	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23865	37	1930	1930	CD
18637	23865	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23865	39	,	,	,
18637	23865	40	128	128	CD
18637	23865	41	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	23865	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23865	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23865	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23865	45	Ellzey	Ellzey	NNP
18637	23865	46	,	,	,
18637	23865	47	2	2	CD
18637	23865	48	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23865	49	.	.	.
18637	23866	1	445	445	CD
18637	23866	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23866	3	1805	1805	CD
18637	23866	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23866	5	,	,	,
18637	23866	6	302	302	CD
18637	23866	7	,	,	,
18637	23866	8	599	599	CD
18637	23866	9	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
18637	23866	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23866	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23866	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23866	13	Griswold	Griswold	NNP
18637	23866	14	,	,	,
18637	23866	15	8	8	CD
18637	23866	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23866	17	.	.	.
18637	23867	1	603	603	CD
18637	23867	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23867	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	23867	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23867	5	,	,	,
18637	23867	6	118	118	CD
18637	23867	7	,	,	,
18637	23867	8	287	287	CD
18637	23867	9	,	,	,
18637	23867	10	362	362	CD
18637	23867	11	Hepner	Hepner	NNP
18637	23867	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23867	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23867	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23867	15	United	United	NNP
18637	23867	16	States	States	NNP
18637	23867	17	,	,	,
18637	23867	18	213	213	CD
18637	23867	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23867	20	103	103	CD
18637	23867	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23867	22	1909	1909	CD
18637	23867	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23867	24	,	,	,
18637	23867	25	878	878	CD
18637	23867	26	Herndon	Herndon	NNP
18637	23867	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23867	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	23867	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23867	30	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23867	31	,	,	,
18637	23867	32	R.I.	R.I.	NNP
18637	23867	33	&	&	CC
18637	23867	34	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	23868	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23868	2	,	,	,
18637	23868	3	218	218	CD
18637	23868	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23868	5	135	135	CD
18637	23868	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23868	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	23868	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23868	9	,	,	,
18637	23868	10	638	638	CD
18637	23868	11	Herndon	Herndon	NNP
18637	23868	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23868	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	15	Lowry	Lowry	NNP
18637	23868	16	,	,	,
18637	23868	17	301	301	CD
18637	23868	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23868	19	242	242	CD
18637	23868	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23868	21	1937	1937	CD
18637	23868	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23868	23	,	,	,
18637	23868	24	563	563	CD
18637	23868	25	,	,	,
18637	23868	26	777	777	CD
18637	23868	27	,	,	,
18637	23868	28	806	806	CD
18637	23868	29	Herron	Herron	NNP
18637	23868	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23868	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	33	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	23868	34	P.	P.	NNP
18637	23868	35	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23868	36	,	,	,
18637	23868	37	283	283	CD
18637	23868	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23868	39	91	91	CD
18637	23868	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23868	41	1931	1931	CD
18637	23868	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23868	43	,	,	,
18637	23868	44	1091	1091	CD
18637	23868	45	Hess	Hess	NNP
18637	23868	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	23868	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	49	Pawloski	Pawloski	NNP
18637	23868	50	,	,	,
18637	23868	51	274	274	CD
18637	23868	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23868	53	352	352	CD
18637	23868	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23868	55	1927	1927	CD
18637	23868	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23868	57	,	,	,
18637	23868	58	661	661	CD
18637	23868	59	,	,	,
18637	23868	60	691	691	CD
18637	23868	61	,	,	,
18637	23868	62	1074	1074	CD
18637	23868	63	Hester	Hester	NNP
18637	23868	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	23868	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	67	United	United	NNP
18637	23868	68	States	States	NNP
18637	23868	69	,	,	,
18637	23868	70	265	265	CD
18637	23868	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23868	72	57	57	CD
18637	23868	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23868	74	1924	1924	CD
18637	23868	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23868	76	,	,	,
18637	23868	77	824	824	CD
18637	23868	78	Hewitt	Hewitt	NNP
18637	23868	79	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	23868	80	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23868	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	23868	83	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	84	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	23868	85	of	of	IN
18637	23868	86	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	23868	87	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
18637	23868	88	,	,	,
18637	23868	89	76	76	CD
18637	23868	90	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23868	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23868	92	2d	2d	NN
18637	23868	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23868	94	880	880	CD
18637	23868	95	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23868	96	1935	1935	CD
18637	23868	97	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23868	98	,	,	,
18637	23868	99	1198	1198	CD
18637	23868	100	Heyman	Heyman	NNP
18637	23868	101	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	102	v.	v.	IN
18637	23868	103	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	104	Hays	Hays	NNP
18637	23868	105	,	,	,
18637	23868	106	236	236	CD
18637	23868	107	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23868	108	178	178	CD
18637	23868	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23868	110	1915	1915	CD
18637	23868	111	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23868	112	,	,	,
18637	23868	113	187	187	CD
18637	23868	114	,	,	,
18637	23868	115	195	195	CD
18637	23868	116	Hiatt	Hiatt	NNP
18637	23868	117	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	118	v.	v.	IN
18637	23868	119	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	120	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	23868	121	,	,	,
18637	23868	122	339	339	CD
18637	23868	123	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23868	124	103	103	CD
18637	23868	125	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23868	126	1950	1950	CD
18637	23868	127	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23868	128	,	,	,
18637	23868	129	286	286	CD
18637	23868	130	,	,	,
18637	23868	131	551	551	CD
18637	23868	132	Hibben	Hibben	NNP
18637	23868	133	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	134	v.	v.	IN
18637	23868	135	_	_	NNP
18637	23868	136	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	23868	137	,	,	,
18637	23868	138	191	191	CD
18637	23868	139	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23868	140	310	310	CD
18637	23868	141	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23868	142	1903	1903	CD
18637	23868	143	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23868	144	,	,	,
18637	23868	145	972	972	CD
18637	23868	146	,	,	,
18637	23868	147	1059	1059	CD
18637	23868	148	Hibernia	Hibernia	NNP
18637	23868	149	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	23868	150	.	.	.
18637	23869	1	&	&	CC
18637	23869	2	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23869	3	Soc	Soc	NNP
18637	23869	4	.	.	.
18637	23870	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23870	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23870	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23870	4	San	San	NNP
18637	23870	5	Francisco	Francisco	NNP
18637	23870	6	,	,	,
18637	23870	7	200	200	CD
18637	23870	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23870	9	310	310	CD
18637	23870	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23870	11	1906	1906	CD
18637	23870	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23870	13	,	,	,
18637	23870	14	730	730	CD
18637	23870	15	Hicklin	Hicklin	NNP
18637	23870	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23870	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23870	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23870	19	Coney	Coney	NNP
18637	23870	20	,	,	,
18637	23870	21	290	290	CD
18637	23870	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23870	23	169	169	CD
18637	23870	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23870	25	1933	1933	CD
18637	23870	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23870	27	,	,	,
18637	23870	28	212	212	CD
18637	23870	29	,	,	,
18637	23870	30	227	227	CD
18637	23870	31	,	,	,
18637	23870	32	1155	1155	CD
18637	23870	33	Hickman	Hickman	NNP
18637	23870	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23870	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23870	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23870	37	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	23870	38	,	,	,
18637	23870	39	9	9	CD
18637	23870	40	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23870	41	.	.	.
18637	23871	1	197	197	CD
18637	23871	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23871	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	23871	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23871	5	,	,	,
18637	23871	6	728	728	CD
18637	23871	7	Higginbotham	Higginbotham	NNP
18637	23871	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23871	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23871	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23871	11	Baton	Baton	NNP
18637	23871	12	Rouge	Rouge	NNP
18637	23871	13	,	,	,
18637	23871	14	306	306	CD
18637	23871	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23871	16	535	535	CD
18637	23871	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23871	18	1939	1939	CD
18637	23871	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23871	20	,	,	,
18637	23871	21	341	341	CD
18637	23871	22	Highland	Highland	NNP
18637	23871	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23871	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23871	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23871	26	Russell	Russell	NNP
18637	23871	27	Car	Car	NNP
18637	23871	28	&	&	CC
18637	23871	29	Snow	Snow	NNP
18637	23871	30	Plow	Plow	NNP
18637	23871	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23871	32	,	,	,
18637	23871	33	279	279	CD
18637	23871	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23871	35	253	253	CD
18637	23871	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23871	37	1929	1929	CD
18637	23871	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23871	39	,	,	,
18637	23871	40	855	855	CD
18637	23871	41	Highland	Highland	NNP
18637	23871	42	Farms	Farms	NNPS
18637	23871	43	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
18637	23871	44	,	,	,
18637	23871	45	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	23871	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23871	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	23871	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23871	49	Agnew	Agnew	NNP
18637	23871	50	,	,	,
18637	23871	51	300	300	CD
18637	23871	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23871	53	608	608	CD
18637	23871	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23871	55	1937	1937	CD
18637	23871	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23871	57	,	,	,
18637	23871	58	237	237	CD
18637	23871	59	,	,	,
18637	23871	60	705	705	CD
18637	23871	61	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	23871	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23871	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	23871	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23871	65	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	23871	66	,	,	,
18637	23871	67	325	325	CD
18637	23871	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23871	69	538	538	CD
18637	23871	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23871	71	1945	1945	CD
18637	23871	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23871	73	,	,	,
18637	23871	74	252	252	CD
18637	23871	75	,	,	,
18637	23871	76	724	724	CD
18637	23871	77	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	23871	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23871	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	23871	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23871	81	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	23871	82	,	,	,
18637	23871	83	296	296	CD
18637	23871	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23871	85	393	393	CD
18637	23871	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23871	87	1935	1935	CD
18637	23871	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23871	89	,	,	,
18637	23871	90	524	524	CD
18637	23871	91	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	23871	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23871	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	23871	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23871	95	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	23871	96	'	'	POS
18637	23871	97	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	23871	98	.	.	.
18637	23872	1	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23872	2	.	.	.
18637	23873	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23873	2	,	,	,
18637	23873	3	134	134	CD
18637	23873	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23873	5	515	515	CD
18637	23873	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23873	7	1890	1890	CD
18637	23873	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23873	9	,	,	,
18637	23873	10	355	355	CD
18637	23873	11	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	23873	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23873	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23873	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23873	15	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23873	16	,	,	,
18637	23873	17	316	316	CD
18637	23873	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23873	19	400	400	CD
18637	23873	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23873	21	1942	1942	CD
18637	23873	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23873	23	,	,	,
18637	23873	24	1168	1168	CD
18637	23873	25	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	23873	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23873	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23873	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23873	29	United	United	NNP
18637	23873	30	States	States	NNP
18637	23873	31	,	,	,
18637	23873	32	9	9	CD
18637	23873	33	How	how	WRB
18637	23873	34	.	.	.
18637	23874	1	386	386	CD
18637	23874	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23874	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	23874	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23874	5	,	,	,
18637	23874	6	585	585	CD
18637	23874	7	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	23874	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23874	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23874	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23874	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23874	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23874	13	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23874	14	rel	rel	NN
18637	23874	15	.	.	.
18637	23875	1	Weiner	Weiner	NNP
18637	23875	2	,	,	,
18637	23875	3	300	300	CD
18637	23875	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23875	5	105	105	CD
18637	23875	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23875	7	1937	1937	CD
18637	23875	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23875	9	,	,	,
18637	23875	10	853	853	CD
18637	23875	11	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	23875	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23875	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23875	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23875	15	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	23875	16	,	,	,
18637	23875	17	259	259	CD
18637	23875	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23875	19	44	44	CD
18637	23875	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23875	21	1922	1922	CD
18637	23875	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23875	23	,	,	,
18637	23875	24	111	111	CD
18637	23875	25	,	,	,
18637	23875	26	621	621	CD
18637	23875	27	,	,	,
18637	23875	28	918	918	CD
18637	23875	29	Hillsborough	Hillsborough	NNP
18637	23875	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23875	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23875	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23875	33	Cromwell	Cromwell	NNP
18637	23875	34	,	,	,
18637	23875	35	326	326	CD
18637	23875	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23875	37	620	620	CD
18637	23875	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23875	39	1946	1946	CD
18637	23875	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23875	41	,	,	,
18637	23875	42	1144	1144	CD
18637	23875	43	,	,	,
18637	23875	44	1152	1152	CD
18637	23875	45	Hilton	Hilton	NNP
18637	23875	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23875	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	23875	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23875	49	Guyot	Guyot	NNP
18637	23875	50	,	,	,
18637	23875	51	159	159	CD
18637	23875	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23875	53	113	113	CD
18637	23875	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23875	55	1895	1895	CD
18637	23875	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23875	57	,	,	,
18637	23875	58	685	685	CD
18637	23875	59	Hinderlider	Hinderlider	NNP
18637	23875	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23875	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23875	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23875	63	La	La	NNP
18637	23875	64	Plata	Plata	NNP
18637	23875	65	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23875	66	,	,	,
18637	23875	67	304	304	CD
18637	23875	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23875	69	92	92	CD
18637	23875	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23875	71	1938	1938	CD
18637	23875	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23875	73	,	,	,
18637	23875	74	367	367	CD
18637	23875	75	,	,	,
18637	23875	76	370	370	CD
18637	23875	77	Hine	Hine	NNP
18637	23875	78	,	,	,
18637	23875	79	The	the	DT
18637	23875	80	,	,	,
18637	23875	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23875	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	23875	83	_	_	NNP
18637	23875	84	Trevor	Trevor	NNP
18637	23875	85	,	,	,
18637	23875	86	4	4	CD
18637	23875	87	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23875	88	.	.	.
18637	23876	1	555	555	CD
18637	23876	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23876	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	23876	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23876	5	,	,	,
18637	23876	6	579	579	CD
18637	23876	7	Hines	Hines	NNPS
18637	23876	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23876	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23876	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23876	11	Davidowitz	Davidowitz	NNP
18637	23876	12	et	et	NNP
18637	23876	13	al	al	NNP
18637	23876	14	.	.	NNP
18637	23876	15	,	,	,
18637	23876	16	312	312	CD
18637	23876	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23876	18	52	52	CD
18637	23876	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23876	20	1941	1941	CD
18637	23876	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23876	22	,	,	,
18637	23876	23	73	73	CD
18637	23876	24	,	,	,
18637	23876	25	259	259	CD
18637	23876	26	,	,	,
18637	23876	27	260	260	CD
18637	23876	28	,	,	,
18637	23876	29	417	417	CD
18637	23876	30	Hines	Hines	NNPS
18637	23876	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23876	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	23876	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23876	34	Lowrey	Lowrey	NNP
18637	23876	35	,	,	,
18637	23876	36	305	305	CD
18637	23876	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23876	38	85	85	CD
18637	23876	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23876	40	1938	1938	CD
18637	23876	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23876	42	,	,	,
18637	23876	43	857	857	CD
18637	23876	44	Hinson	Hinson	NNP
18637	23876	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23876	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	23876	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23876	48	Lott	Lott	NNP
18637	23876	49	,	,	,
18637	23876	50	8	8	CD
18637	23876	51	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23876	52	.	.	.
18637	23877	1	148	148	CD
18637	23877	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23877	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	23877	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23877	5	,	,	,
18637	23877	6	189	189	CD
18637	23877	7	Hipp	Hipp	NNP
18637	23877	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23877	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23877	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23877	11	Babin	Babin	NNP
18637	23877	12	,	,	,
18637	23877	13	19	19	CD
18637	23877	14	How	how	WRB
18637	23877	15	.	.	.
18637	23878	1	271	271	CD
18637	23878	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23878	3	1857	1857	CD
18637	23878	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23878	5	,	,	,
18637	23878	6	895	895	CD
18637	23878	7	Hirabayashi	Hirabayashi	NNP
18637	23878	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23878	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23878	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23878	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23878	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23878	13	,	,	,
18637	23878	14	320	320	CD
18637	23878	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23878	16	81	81	CD
18637	23878	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23878	18	1943	1943	CD
18637	23878	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23878	20	,	,	,
18637	23878	21	76	76	CD
18637	23878	22	,	,	,
18637	23878	23	290	290	CD
18637	23878	24	,	,	,
18637	23878	25	297	297	CD
18637	23878	26	,	,	,
18637	23878	27	395	395	CD
18637	23878	28	,	,	,
18637	23878	29	1158	1158	CD
18637	23878	30	Hirota	Hirota	NNP
18637	23878	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23878	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	23878	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23878	34	MacArthur	MacArthur	NNP
18637	23878	35	,	,	,
18637	23878	36	338	338	CD
18637	23878	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23878	38	197	197	CD
18637	23878	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23878	40	1948	1948	CD
18637	23878	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23878	42	,	,	,
18637	23878	43	317	317	CD
18637	23878	44	Hodge	Hodge	NNP
18637	23878	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23878	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	23878	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23878	48	Muscatine	Muscatine	NNP
18637	23878	49	County	County	NNP
18637	23878	50	,	,	,
18637	23878	51	196	196	CD
18637	23878	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23878	53	276	276	CD
18637	23878	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23878	55	1905	1905	CD
18637	23878	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23878	57	,	,	,
18637	23878	58	1057	1057	CD
18637	23878	59	Hodge	Hodge	NNP
18637	23878	60	Drive	Drive	NNP
18637	23878	61	-	-	:
18637	23878	62	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	23878	63	-	-	HYPH
18637	23878	64	Yourself	Yourself	NNP
18637	23878	65	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23878	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23878	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23878	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23878	69	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	23878	70	,	,	,
18637	23878	71	284	284	CD
18637	23878	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23878	73	335	335	CD
18637	23878	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23878	75	1932	1932	CD
18637	23878	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23878	77	,	,	,
18637	23878	78	1033	1033	CD
18637	23878	79	,	,	,
18637	23878	80	1155	1155	CD
18637	23878	81	Hodges	Hodges	NNPS
18637	23878	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23878	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	23878	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23878	85	Easton	Easton	NNP
18637	23878	86	,	,	,
18637	23878	87	106	106	CD
18637	23878	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23878	89	408	408	CD
18637	23878	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23878	91	1883	1883	CD
18637	23878	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23878	93	,	,	,
18637	23878	94	897	897	CD
18637	23878	95	Hodges	Hodges	NNPS
18637	23878	96	_	_	NNP
18637	23878	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	23878	98	_	_	NNP
18637	23878	99	United	United	NNP
18637	23878	100	States	States	NNP
18637	23878	101	,	,	,
18637	23878	102	203	203	CD
18637	23878	103	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23878	104	1	1	CD
18637	23878	105	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23878	106	1906	1906	CD
18637	23878	107	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23878	108	,	,	,
18637	23878	109	949	949	CD
18637	23878	110	,	,	,
18637	23878	111	952	952	CD
18637	23878	112	Hodgson	Hodgson	NNP
18637	23878	113	&	&	CC
18637	23878	114	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	23878	115	_	_	NNP
18637	23878	116	v.	v.	IN
18637	23878	117	_	_	NNP
18637	23878	118	Bowerbank	Bowerbank	NNP
18637	23878	119	,	,	,
18637	23878	120	5	5	CD
18637	23878	121	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23878	122	.	.	.
18637	23879	1	303	303	CD
18637	23879	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23879	3	1809	1809	CD
18637	23879	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23879	5	,	,	,
18637	23879	6	611	611	CD
18637	23879	7	,	,	,
18637	23879	8	623	623	CD
18637	23879	9	Hoeper	Hoeper	NNP
18637	23879	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23879	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23879	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23879	13	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23879	14	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	23879	15	,	,	,
18637	23879	16	284	284	CD
18637	23879	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23879	18	206	206	CD
18637	23879	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23879	20	1931	1931	CD
18637	23879	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23879	22	,	,	,
18637	23879	23	1039	1039	CD
18637	23879	24	Hoffman	Hoffman	NNP
18637	23879	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23879	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23879	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23879	28	United	United	NNP
18637	23879	29	States	States	NNP
18637	23879	30	,	,	,
18637	23879	31	341	341	CD
18637	23879	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23879	33	479	479	CD
18637	23879	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23879	35	1951	1951	CD
18637	23879	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23879	37	,	,	,
18637	23879	38	842	842	CD
18637	23879	39	Hoke	Hoke	NNP
18637	23879	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23879	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23879	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23879	43	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	23879	44	,	,	,
18637	23879	45	15	15	CD
18637	23879	46	N.C.	North Carolina	NNP
18637	23879	47	1	1	CD
18637	23879	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23879	49	4	4	CD
18637	23879	50	Dev	Dev	NNP
18637	23879	51	.	.	.
18637	23880	1	1	1	LS
18637	23880	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23880	3	,	,	,
18637	23880	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23880	5	1833	1833	CD
18637	23880	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23880	7	,	,	,
18637	23880	8	341	341	NNP
18637	23880	9	Hoke	Hoke	NNP
18637	23880	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23880	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23880	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23880	13	United	United	NNP
18637	23880	14	States	States	NNP
18637	23880	15	,	,	,
18637	23880	16	227	227	CD
18637	23880	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23880	18	308	308	CD
18637	23880	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23880	20	1913	1913	CD
18637	23880	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23880	22	,	,	,
18637	23880	23	170	170	CD
18637	23880	24	,	,	,
18637	23880	25	919	919	CD
18637	23880	26	Holden	Holden	NNP
18637	23880	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23880	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	23880	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23880	30	Hardy	Hardy	NNP
18637	23880	31	,	,	,
18637	23880	32	169	169	CD
18637	23880	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23880	34	366	366	CD
18637	23880	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23880	36	1898	1898	CD
18637	23880	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23880	38	,	,	,
18637	23880	39	971	971	CD
18637	23880	40	,	,	,
18637	23880	41	977	977	CD
18637	23880	42	,	,	,
18637	23880	43	986	986	CD
18637	23880	44	,	,	,
18637	23880	45	1112	1112	CD
18637	23880	46	,	,	,
18637	23880	47	1158	1158	CD
18637	23880	48	Holden	Holden	NNP
18637	23880	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23880	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	23880	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23880	52	Joy	Joy	NNP
18637	23880	53	,	,	,
18637	23880	54	17	17	CD
18637	23880	55	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23880	56	.	.	.
18637	23881	1	211	211	CD
18637	23881	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23881	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	23881	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23881	5	,	,	,
18637	23881	6	432	432	CD
18637	23881	7	Holden	Holden	NNP
18637	23881	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23881	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23881	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23881	11	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23881	12	,	,	,
18637	23881	13	137	137	CD
18637	23881	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23881	15	483	483	CD
18637	23881	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23881	17	1890	1890	CD
18637	23881	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23881	19	,	,	,
18637	23881	20	328	328	CD
18637	23881	21	Holland	Holland	NNP
18637	23881	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23881	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23881	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23881	25	Challen	Challen	NNP
18637	23881	26	,	,	,
18637	23881	27	110	110	CD
18637	23881	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23881	29	15	15	CD
18637	23881	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23881	31	1884	1884	CD
18637	23881	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23881	33	,	,	,
18637	23881	34	895	895	CD
18637	23881	35	Hollingsworth	Hollingsworth	NNP
18637	23881	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23881	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23881	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23881	39	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	23881	40	,	,	,
18637	23881	41	3	3	CD
18637	23881	42	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	23881	43	.	.	.
18637	23882	1	378	378	CD
18637	23882	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23882	3	1798	1798	CD
18637	23882	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23882	5	,	,	,
18637	23882	6	105	105	CD
18637	23882	7	,	,	,
18637	23882	8	712	712	CD
18637	23882	9	Hollister	Hollister	NNP
18637	23882	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23882	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23882	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23882	13	Benedict	Benedict	NNP
18637	23882	14	&	&	CC
18637	23882	15	B.	B.	NNP
18637	23882	16	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23882	17	.	.	.
18637	23883	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23883	2	,	,	,
18637	23883	3	113	113	CD
18637	23883	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23883	5	59	59	CD
18637	23883	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23883	7	1885	1885	CD
18637	23883	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23883	9	,	,	,
18637	23883	10	275	275	CD
18637	23883	11	,	,	,
18637	23883	12	867	867	CD
18637	23883	13	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	23883	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23883	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23883	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23883	17	Conway	Conway	NNP
18637	23883	18	,	,	,
18637	23883	19	241	241	CD
18637	23883	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23883	21	624	624	CD
18637	23883	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23883	23	1916	1916	CD
18637	23883	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23883	25	,	,	,
18637	23883	26	1089	1089	CD
18637	23883	27	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	23883	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23883	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23883	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23883	31	Goldsmith	Goldsmith	NNP
18637	23883	32	,	,	,
18637	23883	33	147	147	CD
18637	23883	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23883	35	150	150	CD
18637	23883	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23883	37	1893	1893	CD
18637	23883	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23883	39	,	,	,
18637	23883	40	619	619	CD
18637	23883	41	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	23883	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23883	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23883	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23883	45	Hurst	Hurst	NNP
18637	23883	46	,	,	,
18637	23883	47	174	174	CD
18637	23883	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23883	49	82	82	CD
18637	23883	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23883	51	1899	1899	CD
18637	23883	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23883	53	,	,	,
18637	23883	54	275	275	CD
18637	23883	55	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	23883	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23883	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	23883	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23883	59	Jennison	Jennison	NNP
18637	23883	60	,	,	,
18637	23883	61	14	14	CD
18637	23883	62	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23883	63	.	.	.
18637	23884	1	540	540	CD
18637	23884	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23884	3	1840	1840	CD
18637	23884	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23884	5	,	,	,
18637	23884	6	73	73	CD
18637	23884	7	,	,	,
18637	23884	8	325	325	CD
18637	23884	9	,	,	,
18637	23884	10	367	367	CD
18637	23884	11	,	,	,
18637	23884	12	433	433	CD
18637	23884	13	Holmgren	Holmgren	NNP
18637	23884	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23884	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23884	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23884	17	United	United	NNP
18637	23884	18	States	States	NNP
18637	23884	19	,	,	,
18637	23884	20	217	217	CD
18637	23884	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23884	22	509	509	CD
18637	23884	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23884	24	1910	1910	CD
18637	23884	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23884	26	,	,	,
18637	23884	27	258	258	CD
18637	23884	28	,	,	,
18637	23884	29	737	737	CD
18637	23884	30	Holt	Holt	NNP
18637	23884	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23884	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	23884	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23884	34	United	United	NNP
18637	23884	35	States	States	NNP
18637	23884	36	,	,	,
18637	23884	37	218	218	CD
18637	23884	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23884	39	245	245	CD
18637	23884	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23884	41	1910	1910	CD
18637	23884	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23884	43	,	,	,
18637	23884	44	843	843	CD
18637	23884	45	,	,	,
18637	23884	46	1124	1124	CD
18637	23884	47	Holyoke	Holyoke	NNP
18637	23884	48	Water	Water	NNP
18637	23884	49	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23884	50	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23884	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23884	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	23884	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23884	54	Lyman	Lyman	NNP
18637	23884	55	,	,	,
18637	23884	56	15	15	CD
18637	23884	57	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23884	58	.	.	.
18637	23885	1	500	500	CD
18637	23885	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23885	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	23885	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23885	5	,	,	,
18637	23885	6	344	344	CD
18637	23885	7	Home	home	NN
18637	23885	8	Bldg	Bldg	NNP
18637	23885	9	.	.	.
18637	23886	1	&	&	CC
18637	23886	2	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	23886	3	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	23886	4	.	.	.
18637	23887	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23887	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23887	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23887	4	Blaisdell	Blaisdell	NNP
18637	23887	5	,	,	,
18637	23887	6	290	290	CD
18637	23887	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23887	8	398	398	CD
18637	23887	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23887	10	1934	1934	CD
18637	23887	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23887	12	,	,	,
18637	23887	13	280	280	CD
18637	23887	14	,	,	,
18637	23887	15	332	332	CD
18637	23887	16	,	,	,
18637	23887	17	359	359	CD
18637	23887	18	,	,	,
18637	23887	19	360	360	CD
18637	23887	20	,	,	,
18637	23887	21	362	362	CD
18637	23887	22	,	,	,
18637	23887	23	564	564	CD
18637	23887	24	Home	Home	NNP
18637	23887	25	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23887	26	.	.	.
18637	23888	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23888	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23888	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23888	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23888	5	Dick	Dick	NNP
18637	23888	6	,	,	,
18637	23888	7	281	281	CD
18637	23888	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23888	9	397	397	CD
18637	23888	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23888	11	1930	1930	CD
18637	23888	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23888	13	,	,	,
18637	23888	14	1093	1093	CD
18637	23888	15	Home	Home	NNP
18637	23888	16	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23888	17	.	.	.
18637	23889	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23889	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23889	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23889	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23889	5	Morse	Morse	NNP
18637	23889	6	,	,	,
18637	23889	7	20	20	CD
18637	23889	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23889	9	.	.	.
18637	23890	1	445	445	CD
18637	23890	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23890	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	23890	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23890	5	,	,	,
18637	23890	6	638	638	CD
18637	23890	7	Home	Home	NNP
18637	23890	8	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23890	9	.	.	.
18637	23891	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23891	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23891	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23891	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23891	5	New	New	NNP
18637	23891	6	York	York	NNP
18637	23891	7	,	,	,
18637	23891	8	134	134	CD
18637	23891	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23891	10	594	594	CD
18637	23891	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23891	12	1890	1890	CD
18637	23891	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23891	14	,	,	,
18637	23891	15	730	730	CD
18637	23891	16	Home	Home	NNP
18637	23891	17	of	of	IN
18637	23891	18	Friendless	Friendless	NNP
18637	23891	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23891	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	23891	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23891	22	Rouse	Rouse	NNP
18637	23891	23	,	,	,
18637	23891	24	8	8	CD
18637	23891	25	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23891	26	.	.	.
18637	23892	1	430	430	CD
18637	23892	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23892	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	23892	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23892	5	,	,	,
18637	23892	6	339	339	CD
18637	23892	7	,	,	,
18637	23892	8	342	342	CD
18637	23892	9	,	,	,
18637	23892	10	343	343	CD
18637	23892	11	,	,	,
18637	23892	12	351	351	CD
18637	23892	13	Home	Home	NNP
18637	23892	14	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	23892	15	&	&	CC
18637	23892	16	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	23892	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23892	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23892	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23892	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23892	21	Los	Los	NNP
18637	23892	22	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	23892	23	,	,	,
18637	23892	24	227	227	CD
18637	23892	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23892	26	278	278	CD
18637	23892	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23892	28	1913	1913	CD
18637	23892	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23892	30	,	,	,
18637	23892	31	934	934	CD
18637	23892	32	Home	Home	NNP
18637	23892	33	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	23892	34	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23892	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23892	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	23892	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23892	38	Los	Los	NNP
18637	23892	39	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	23892	40	,	,	,
18637	23892	41	211	211	CD
18637	23892	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23892	43	265	265	CD
18637	23892	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23892	45	1908	1908	CD
18637	23892	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23892	47	,	,	,
18637	23892	48	349	349	CD
18637	23892	49	,	,	,
18637	23892	50	352	352	CD
18637	23892	51	Honeyman	Honeyman	NNP
18637	23892	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23892	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	23892	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23892	55	Hanan	Hanan	NNP
18637	23892	56	,	,	,
18637	23892	57	302	302	CD
18637	23892	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23892	59	375	375	CD
18637	23892	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23892	61	1937	1937	CD
18637	23892	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23892	63	,	,	,
18637	23892	64	1089	1089	CD
18637	23892	65	Honeyman	Honeyman	NNP
18637	23892	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23892	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23892	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23892	69	Jacobs	Jacobs	NNP
18637	23892	70	,	,	,
18637	23892	71	306	306	CD
18637	23892	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23892	73	549	549	CD
18637	23892	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23892	75	1939	1939	CD
18637	23892	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23892	77	,	,	,
18637	23892	78	361	361	CD
18637	23892	79	Hood	Hood	NNP
18637	23892	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23892	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	23892	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23892	83	Du	Du	NNP
18637	23892	84	Mond	Mond	NNP
18637	23892	85	,	,	,
18637	23892	86	336	336	CD
18637	23892	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23892	88	525	525	CD
18637	23892	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23892	90	1949	1949	CD
18637	23892	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23892	92	,	,	,
18637	23892	93	245	245	CD
18637	23892	94	Hood	Hood	NNP
18637	23892	95	_	_	NNP
18637	23892	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	23892	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23892	98	McGehee	McGehee	NNP
18637	23892	99	,	,	,
18637	23892	100	237	237	CD
18637	23892	101	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23892	102	611	611	CD
18637	23892	103	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23892	104	1915	1915	CD
18637	23892	105	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23892	106	,	,	,
18637	23892	107	673	673	CD
18637	23892	108	Hood	Hood	NNP
18637	23892	109	,	,	,
18637	23892	110	H.P.	H.P.	NNP
18637	23893	1	&	&	CC
18637	23893	2	Sons	Sons	NNPS
18637	23893	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23893	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	6	United	United	NNP
18637	23893	7	States	States	NNP
18637	23893	8	,	,	,
18637	23893	9	307	307	CD
18637	23893	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23893	11	588	588	CD
18637	23893	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23893	13	1939	1939	CD
18637	23893	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23893	15	,	,	,
18637	23893	16	160	160	CD
18637	23893	17	Hooe	Hooe	NNP
18637	23893	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23893	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	21	Jamieson	Jamieson	NNP
18637	23893	22	,	,	,
18637	23893	23	166	166	CD
18637	23893	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23893	25	395	395	CD
18637	23893	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23893	27	1897	1897	CD
18637	23893	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23893	29	,	,	,
18637	23893	30	302	302	CD
18637	23893	31	Hooe	Hooe	NNP
18637	23893	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	33	v.	v.	CC
18637	23893	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	35	United	United	NNP
18637	23893	36	States	States	NNP
18637	23893	37	,	,	,
18637	23893	38	218	218	CD
18637	23893	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23893	40	322	322	CD
18637	23893	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23893	42	1910	1910	CD
18637	23893	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23893	44	,	,	,
18637	23893	45	495	495	CD
18637	23893	46	Hooe	Hooe	NNP
18637	23893	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	23893	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	50	Werner	Werner	NNP
18637	23893	51	,	,	,
18637	23893	52	166	166	CD
18637	23893	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23893	54	399	399	CD
18637	23893	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23893	56	1897	1897	CD
18637	23893	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23893	58	,	,	,
18637	23893	59	302	302	CD
18637	23893	60	Hooper	Hooper	NNP
18637	23893	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	23893	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	64	California	California	NNP
18637	23893	65	,	,	,
18637	23893	66	155	155	CD
18637	23893	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23893	68	648	648	CD
18637	23893	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23893	70	1895	1895	CD
18637	23893	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23893	72	,	,	,
18637	23893	73	1021	1021	CD
18637	23893	74	Hoopeston	Hoopeston	NNP
18637	23893	75	Canning	Canning	NNP
18637	23893	76	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23893	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	23893	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	80	Cullen	Cullen	NNP
18637	23893	81	,	,	,
18637	23893	82	318	318	CD
18637	23893	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23893	84	313	313	CD
18637	23893	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23893	86	1943	1943	CD
18637	23893	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23893	88	,	,	,
18637	23893	89	1022	1022	CD
18637	23893	90	,	,	,
18637	23893	91	1155	1155	CD
18637	23893	92	Hooven	Hooven	NNP
18637	23893	93	&	&	CC
18637	23893	94	Allison	Allison	NNP
18637	23893	95	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23893	96	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	23893	98	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	99	Evatt	Evatt	NNP
18637	23893	100	,	,	,
18637	23893	101	324	324	CD
18637	23893	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23893	103	652	652	CD
18637	23893	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23893	105	1945	1945	CD
18637	23893	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23893	107	,	,	,
18637	23893	108	178	178	CD
18637	23893	109	,	,	,
18637	23893	110	219	219	CD
18637	23893	111	,	,	,
18637	23893	112	363	363	CD
18637	23893	113	,	,	,
18637	23893	114	364	364	CD
18637	23893	115	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	23893	116	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23893	117	Case	Case	NNP
18637	23893	118	,	,	,
18637	23893	119	320	320	CD
18637	23893	120	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23893	121	591	591	CD
18637	23893	122	,	,	,
18637	23893	123	606	606	CD
18637	23893	124	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23893	125	1944	1944	CD
18637	23893	126	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23893	127	,	,	,
18637	23893	128	1007	1007	CD
18637	23893	129	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	23893	130	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	23893	131	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23893	132	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23893	133	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	134	v.	v.	IN
18637	23893	135	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	136	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	23893	137	,	,	,
18637	23893	138	274	274	CD
18637	23893	139	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23893	140	284	284	CD
18637	23893	141	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23893	142	1927	1927	CD
18637	23893	143	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23893	144	,	,	,
18637	23893	145	181	181	CD
18637	23893	146	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	23893	147	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	148	v.	v.	IN
18637	23893	149	_	_	NNP
18637	23893	150	Clemson	Clemson	NNP
18637	23893	151	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	23893	152	College	College	NNP
18637	23893	153	,	,	,
18637	23893	154	221	221	CD
18637	23893	155	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23893	156	636	636	CD
18637	23893	157	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23893	158	1911	1911	CD
18637	23893	159	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23893	160	,	,	,
18637	23893	161	930	930	CD
18637	23893	162	,	,	,
18637	23893	163	931	931	CD
18637	23893	164	,	,	,
18637	23893	165	936	936	CD
18637	23893	166	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	23893	167	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23893	168	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	23893	169	&	&	CC
18637	23893	170	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	23893	171	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	23893	172	.	.	.
18637	23894	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23894	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23894	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23894	4	Cleary	Cleary	NNP
18637	23894	5	,	,	,
18637	23894	6	296	296	CD
18637	23894	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23894	8	315	315	CD
18637	23894	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23894	10	1935	1935	CD
18637	23894	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23894	12	,	,	,
18637	23894	13	920	920	CD
18637	23894	14	Hopkirk	Hopkirk	NNP
18637	23894	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23894	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	23894	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23894	18	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	23894	19	,	,	,
18637	23894	20	3	3	CD
18637	23894	21	Cr	Cr	NNP
18637	23894	22	.	.	.
18637	23895	1	454	454	CD
18637	23895	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23895	3	1806	1806	CD
18637	23895	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23895	5	,	,	,
18637	23895	6	415	415	CD
18637	23895	7	Hopt	Hopt	NNP
18637	23895	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23895	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23895	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23895	11	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	23895	12	,	,	,
18637	23895	13	110	110	CD
18637	23895	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23895	15	574	574	CD
18637	23895	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23895	17	1884	1884	CD
18637	23895	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23895	19	,	,	,
18637	23895	20	317	317	CD
18637	23895	21	,	,	,
18637	23895	22	847	847	CD
18637	23895	23	Horn	Horn	NNP
18637	23895	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23895	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23895	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23895	27	Lockhart	Lockhart	NNP
18637	23895	28	,	,	,
18637	23895	29	17	17	CD
18637	23895	30	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23895	31	.	.	.
18637	23896	1	570	570	CD
18637	23896	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23896	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	23896	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23896	5	,	,	,
18637	23896	6	728	728	CD
18637	23896	7	Hornbuckle	Hornbuckle	NNP
18637	23896	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23896	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23896	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23896	11	Toombs	Toombs	NNP
18637	23896	12	,	,	,
18637	23896	13	18	18	CD
18637	23896	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23896	15	.	.	.
18637	23897	1	648	648	CD
18637	23897	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23897	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	23897	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23897	5	,	,	,
18637	23897	6	704	704	CD
18637	23897	7	Horstmann	Horstmann	NNP
18637	23897	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23897	9	_	_	NNP
18637	23897	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	23897	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23897	12	United	United	NNP
18637	23897	13	States	States	NNP
18637	23897	14	,	,	,
18637	23897	15	257	257	CD
18637	23897	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23897	17	138	138	CD
18637	23897	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23897	19	1921	1921	CD
18637	23897	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23897	21	,	,	,
18637	23897	22	869	869	CD
18637	23897	23	Hotchkiss	Hotchkiss	NNP
18637	23897	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23897	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23897	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23897	27	Greenwood	Greenwood	NNP
18637	23897	28	,	,	,
18637	23897	29	11	11	CD
18637	23897	30	How	how	WRB
18637	23897	31	.	.	.
18637	23898	1	248	248	CD
18637	23898	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23898	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	23898	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23898	5	,	,	,
18637	23898	6	272	272	CD
18637	23898	7	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	23898	8	&	&	CC
18637	23898	9	Restaurant	Restaurant	NNP
18637	23898	10	Employees	Employees	NNP
18637	23898	11	'	'	POS
18637	23898	12	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	23898	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23898	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	23898	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23898	16	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23898	17	,	,	,
18637	23898	18	315	315	CD
18637	23898	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23898	20	437	437	CD
18637	23898	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23898	22	1942	1942	CD
18637	23898	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23898	24	,	,	,
18637	23898	25	781	781	CD
18637	23898	26	Houck	Houck	NNP
18637	23898	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23898	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	23898	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23898	30	Little	Little	NNP
18637	23898	31	River	River	NNP
18637	23898	32	Drainage	Drainage	NNP
18637	23898	33	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	23898	34	.	.	.
18637	23898	35	,	,	,
18637	23898	36	239	239	CD
18637	23898	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23898	38	254	254	CD
18637	23898	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23898	40	1915	1915	CD
18637	23898	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23898	42	,	,	,
18637	23898	43	1041	1041	CD
18637	23898	44	House	House	NNP
18637	23898	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23898	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	23898	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23898	48	Mayes	Mayes	NNP
18637	23898	49	,	,	,
18637	23898	50	219	219	CD
18637	23898	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23898	52	270	270	CD
18637	23898	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23898	54	1911	1911	CD
18637	23898	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23898	56	,	,	,
18637	23898	57	1019	1019	CD
18637	23898	58	House	House	NNP
18637	23898	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23898	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23898	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23898	62	Mayo	Mayo	NNP
18637	23898	63	,	,	,
18637	23898	64	324	324	CD
18637	23898	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23898	66	42	42	CD
18637	23898	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23898	68	1945	1945	CD
18637	23898	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23898	70	,	,	,
18637	23898	71	1101	1101	CD
18637	23898	72	,	,	,
18637	23898	73	1102	1102	CD
18637	23898	74	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	23898	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23898	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	23898	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23898	78	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	23898	79	,	,	,
18637	23898	80	5	5	CD
18637	23898	81	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23898	82	.	.	.
18637	23899	1	1	1	CD
18637	23899	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23899	3	1820	1820	CD
18637	23899	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23899	5	,	,	,
18637	23899	6	299	299	CD
18637	23899	7	,	,	,
18637	23899	8	300	300	CD
18637	23899	9	,	,	,
18637	23899	10	635	635	CD
18637	23899	11	,	,	,
18637	23899	12	636	636	CD
18637	23899	13	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	23899	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23899	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23899	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23899	17	Ormes	Ormes	NNP
18637	23899	18	,	,	,
18637	23899	19	252	252	CD
18637	23899	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23899	21	469	469	CD
18637	23899	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23899	23	1920	1920	CD
18637	23899	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23899	25	,	,	,
18637	23899	26	932	932	CD
18637	23899	27	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	23899	28	,	,	,
18637	23899	29	E.	E.	NNP
18637	23899	30	&	&	CC
18637	23899	31	W.T.R.	W.T.R.	NNP
18637	23900	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23900	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23900	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23900	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23900	5	United	United	NNP
18637	23900	6	States	States	NNP
18637	23900	7	,	,	,
18637	23900	8	234	234	CD
18637	23900	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23900	10	342	342	CD
18637	23900	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23900	12	1914	1914	CD
18637	23900	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23900	14	,	,	,
18637	23900	15	135	135	CD
18637	23900	16	,	,	,
18637	23900	17	219	219	CD
18637	23900	18	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	23900	19	&	&	CC
18637	23900	20	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23900	21	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23900	22	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	23901	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23901	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23901	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23901	6	,	,	,
18637	23901	7	177	177	CD
18637	23901	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23901	9	66	66	CD
18637	23901	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23901	11	1900	1900	CD
18637	23901	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23901	13	,	,	,
18637	23901	14	326	326	CD
18637	23901	15	,	,	,
18637	23901	16	330	330	CD
18637	23901	17	Hovey	Hovey	NNP
18637	23901	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23901	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	21	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	23901	22	,	,	,
18637	23901	23	167	167	CD
18637	23901	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23901	25	409	409	CD
18637	23901	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23901	27	1897	1897	CD
18637	23901	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23901	29	,	,	,
18637	23901	30	848	848	CD
18637	23901	31	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	23901	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23901	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	35	Fleming	Fleming	NNP
18637	23901	36	,	,	,
18637	23901	37	191	191	CD
18637	23901	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23901	39	126	126	CD
18637	23901	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23901	41	1903	1903	CD
18637	23901	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23901	43	,	,	,
18637	23901	44	1094	1094	CD
18637	23901	45	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	23901	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	23901	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	49	Gipsy	Gipsy	NNP
18637	23901	50	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	23901	51	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23901	52	,	,	,
18637	23901	53	247	247	CD
18637	23901	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23901	55	503	503	CD
18637	23901	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23901	57	1918	1918	CD
18637	23901	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23901	59	,	,	,
18637	23901	60	734	734	CD
18637	23901	61	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	23901	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	23901	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	65	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23901	66	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23901	67	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23901	68	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23901	69	,	,	,
18637	23901	70	207	207	CD
18637	23901	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23901	72	463	463	CD
18637	23901	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23901	74	1908	1908	CD
18637	23901	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23901	76	,	,	,
18637	23901	77	141	141	CD
18637	23901	78	,	,	,
18637	23901	79	165	165	CD
18637	23901	80	,	,	,
18637	23901	81	563	563	CD
18637	23901	82	,	,	,
18637	23901	83	917	917	CD
18637	23901	84	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	23901	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	23901	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	88	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23901	89	,	,	,
18637	23901	90	200	200	CD
18637	23901	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23901	92	164	164	CD
18637	23901	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23901	94	1906	1906	CD
18637	23901	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23901	96	,	,	,
18637	23901	97	1127	1127	CD
18637	23901	98	Howe	Howe	NNP
18637	23901	99	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	23901	100	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23901	101	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	102	v.	v.	IN
18637	23901	103	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	104	Gage	Gage	NNP
18637	23901	105	,	,	,
18637	23901	106	100	100	CD
18637	23901	107	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23901	108	676	676	CD
18637	23901	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23901	110	1880	1880	CD
18637	23901	111	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23901	112	,	,	,
18637	23901	113	184	184	CD
18637	23901	114	,	,	,
18637	23901	115	185	185	CD
18637	23901	116	,	,	,
18637	23901	117	191	191	CD
18637	23901	118	Hoxie	Hoxie	NNP
18637	23901	119	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	120	v.	v.	IN
18637	23901	121	_	_	NNP
18637	23901	122	New	New	NNP
18637	23901	123	York	York	NNP
18637	23901	124	,	,	,
18637	23901	125	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	23901	126	&	&	CC
18637	23901	127	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	23902	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23902	2	,	,	,
18637	23902	3	82	82	CD
18637	23902	4	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
18637	23902	5	352	352	CD
18637	23902	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23902	7	1909	1909	CD
18637	23902	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23902	9	,	,	,
18637	23902	10	637	637	CD
18637	23902	11	Hubert	Hubert	NNP
18637	23902	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23902	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23902	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23902	15	New	New	NNP
18637	23902	16	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	23902	17	,	,	,
18637	23902	18	215	215	CD
18637	23902	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23902	20	170	170	CD
18637	23902	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23902	22	1909	1909	CD
18637	23902	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23902	24	,	,	,
18637	23902	25	330	330	CD
18637	23902	26	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	23902	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23902	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	23902	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23902	30	Guestier	Guestier	NNP
18637	23902	31	,	,	,
18637	23902	32	4	4	CD
18637	23902	33	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23902	34	.	.	.
18637	23903	1	293	293	CD
18637	23903	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23903	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	23903	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23903	5	,	,	,
18637	23903	6	575	575	CD
18637	23903	7	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	23903	8	County	County	NNP
18637	23903	9	Water	Water	NNP
18637	23903	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23903	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23903	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	23903	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23903	14	McCarter	McCarter	NNP
18637	23903	15	,	,	,
18637	23903	16	209	209	CD
18637	23903	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23903	18	349	349	CD
18637	23903	19	,	,	,
18637	23903	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23903	21	1908	1908	CD
18637	23903	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23903	23	,	,	,
18637	23903	24	243	243	CD
18637	23903	25	,	,	,
18637	23903	26	358	358	CD
18637	23903	27	,	,	,
18637	23903	28	690	690	CD
18637	23903	29	,	,	,
18637	23903	30	983	983	CD
18637	23903	31	,	,	,
18637	23903	32	1026	1026	CD
18637	23903	33	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	23903	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23903	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23903	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23903	37	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	23903	38	,	,	,
18637	23903	39	9	9	CD
18637	23903	40	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23903	41	.	.	.
18637	23904	1	489	489	CD
18637	23904	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23904	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	23904	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23904	5	,	,	,
18637	23904	6	416	416	CD
18637	23904	7	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	23904	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23904	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23904	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23904	11	Fetter	Fetter	NNP
18637	23904	12	,	,	,
18637	23904	13	341	341	CD
18637	23904	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23904	15	609	609	CD
18637	23904	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23904	17	1951	1951	CD
18637	23904	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23904	19	,	,	,
18637	23904	20	657	657	CD
18637	23904	21	,	,	,
18637	23904	22	677	677	CD
18637	23904	23	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	23904	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23904	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23904	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23904	27	Gault	Gault	NNP
18637	23904	28	,	,	,
18637	23904	29	271	271	CD
18637	23904	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23904	31	142	142	CD
18637	23904	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23904	33	1926	1926	CD
18637	23904	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23904	35	,	,	,
18637	23904	36	881	881	CD
18637	23904	37	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	23904	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23904	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23904	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23904	41	Superior	Superior	NNP
18637	23904	42	Court	Court	NNP
18637	23904	43	of	of	IN
18637	23904	44	California	California	NNP
18637	23904	45	,	,	,
18637	23904	46	339	339	CD
18637	23904	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23904	48	460	460	CD
18637	23904	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23904	50	1950	1950	CD
18637	23904	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23904	52	,	,	,
18637	23904	53	782	782	CD
18637	23904	54	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	23904	55	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	23905	1	Timber	Timber	NNP
18637	23905	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23905	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23905	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23905	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23905	6	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23905	7	,	,	,
18637	23905	8	272	272	CD
18637	23905	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23905	10	469	469	CD
18637	23905	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23905	12	1926	1926	CD
18637	23905	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23905	14	,	,	,
18637	23905	15	186	186	CD
18637	23905	16	Hull	Hull	NNP
18637	23905	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23905	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23905	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23905	20	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	23905	21	,	,	,
18637	23905	22	234	234	CD
18637	23905	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23905	24	712	712	CD
18637	23905	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23905	26	1914	1914	CD
18637	23905	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23905	28	,	,	,
18637	23905	29	567	567	CD
18637	23905	30	Hull	Hull	NNP
18637	23905	31	,	,	,
18637	23905	32	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23905	33	parte	parte	NN
18637	23905	34	,	,	,
18637	23905	35	312	312	CD
18637	23905	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23905	37	546	546	CD
18637	23905	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23905	39	1941	1941	CD
18637	23905	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23905	41	,	,	,
18637	23905	42	1137	1137	CD
18637	23905	43	Hump	Hump	NNP
18637	23905	44	Hairpin	Hairpin	NNP
18637	23905	45	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23905	46	.	.	.
18637	23906	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23906	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23906	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23906	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23906	5	Emerson	Emerson	NNP
18637	23906	6	,	,	,
18637	23906	7	258	258	CD
18637	23906	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23906	9	290	290	CD
18637	23906	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23906	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	23906	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23906	13	,	,	,
18637	23906	14	187	187	CD
18637	23906	15	,	,	,
18637	23906	16	197	197	CD
18637	23906	17	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	23906	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23906	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23906	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23906	21	Pegues	Pegues	NNP
18637	23906	22	,	,	,
18637	23906	23	16	16	CD
18637	23906	24	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23906	25	.	.	.
18637	23907	1	244	244	CD
18637	23907	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23907	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	23907	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23907	5	,	,	,
18637	23907	6	342	342	CD
18637	23907	7	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	23907	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23907	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23907	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23907	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23907	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23907	13	,	,	,
18637	23907	14	295	295	CD
18637	23907	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23907	16	602	602	CD
18637	23907	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23907	18	1935	1935	CD
18637	23907	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23907	20	,	,	,
18637	23907	21	458	458	CD
18637	23907	22	,	,	,
18637	23907	23	460	460	CD
18637	23907	24	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
18637	23907	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23907	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23907	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23907	28	Palao	Palao	NNP
18637	23907	29	,	,	,
18637	23907	30	4	4	CD
18637	23907	31	How	how	WRB
18637	23907	32	.	.	.
18637	23908	1	589	589	CD
18637	23908	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23908	3	1846	1846	CD
18637	23908	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23908	5	,	,	,
18637	23908	6	699	699	CD
18637	23908	7	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	23908	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23908	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23908	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23908	11	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	23908	12	,	,	,
18637	23908	13	207	207	CD
18637	23908	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23908	15	161	161	CD
18637	23908	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23908	17	1907	1907	CD
18637	23908	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23908	19	,	,	,
18637	23908	20	340	340	CD
18637	23908	21	,	,	,
18637	23908	22	1036	1036	CD
18637	23908	23	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	23908	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23908	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23908	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23908	27	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	23908	28	,	,	,
18637	23908	29	209	209	CD
18637	23908	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23908	31	205	205	CD
18637	23908	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23908	33	1908	1908	CD
18637	23908	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23908	35	,	,	,
18637	23908	36	633	633	NNP
18637	23908	37	Huntington	Huntington	NNP
18637	23908	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23908	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23908	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23908	41	Attrill	Attrill	NNP
18637	23908	42	,	,	,
18637	23908	43	146	146	CD
18637	23908	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23908	45	657	657	CD
18637	23908	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23908	47	1892	1892	CD
18637	23908	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23908	49	,	,	,
18637	23908	50	658	658	CD
18637	23908	51	,	,	,
18637	23908	52	674	674	CD
18637	23908	53	Huntington	Huntington	NNP
18637	23908	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23908	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	23908	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23908	57	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23908	58	,	,	,
18637	23908	59	16	16	CD
18637	23908	60	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23908	61	.	.	.
18637	23909	1	402	402	CD
18637	23909	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23909	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	23909	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23909	5	,	,	,
18637	23909	6	728	728	CD
18637	23909	7	Hurd	Hurd	NNP
18637	23909	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23909	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23909	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23909	11	Hodge	Hodge	NNP
18637	23909	12	,	,	,
18637	23909	13	334	334	CD
18637	23909	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23909	15	24	24	CD
18637	23909	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23909	17	1948	1948	CD
18637	23909	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23909	19	,	,	,
18637	23909	20	854	854	CD
18637	23909	21	,	,	,
18637	23909	22	1161	1161	CD
18637	23909	23	Hurley	Hurley	NNP
18637	23909	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23909	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23909	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23909	27	Kincaid	Kincaid	NNP
18637	23909	28	,	,	,
18637	23909	29	285	285	CD
18637	23909	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23909	31	95	95	CD
18637	23909	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23909	33	1932	1932	CD
18637	23909	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23909	35	,	,	,
18637	23909	36	872	872	CD
18637	23909	37	Hurtado	Hurtado	NNP
18637	23909	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23909	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23909	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23909	41	California	California	NNP
18637	23909	42	,	,	,
18637	23909	43	110	110	CD
18637	23909	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23909	45	516	516	CD
18637	23909	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23909	47	1884	1884	CD
18637	23909	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23909	49	,	,	,
18637	23909	50	752	752	CD
18637	23909	51	,	,	,
18637	23909	52	845	845	CD
18637	23909	53	,	,	,
18637	23909	54	973	973	CD
18637	23909	55	,	,	,
18637	23909	56	1070	1070	CD
18637	23909	57	,	,	,
18637	23909	58	1071	1071	CD
18637	23909	59	,	,	,
18637	23909	60	1098	1098	CD
18637	23909	61	,	,	,
18637	23909	62	1109	1109	CD
18637	23909	63	Huse	Huse	NNP
18637	23909	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23909	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	23909	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23909	67	Glover	Glover	NNP
18637	23909	68	,	,	,
18637	23909	69	119	119	CD
18637	23909	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23909	71	543	543	CD
18637	23909	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23909	73	1886	1886	CD
18637	23909	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23909	75	,	,	,
18637	23909	76	230	230	CD
18637	23909	77	,	,	,
18637	23909	78	366	366	CD
18637	23909	79	,	,	,
18637	23909	80	699	699	CD
18637	23909	81	Husty	Husty	NNP
18637	23909	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23909	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	23909	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23909	85	United	United	NNP
18637	23909	86	States	States	NNP
18637	23909	87	,	,	,
18637	23909	88	282	282	CD
18637	23909	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23909	90	694	694	CD
18637	23909	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23909	92	1931	1931	CD
18637	23909	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23909	94	,	,	,
18637	23909	95	830	830	CD
18637	23909	96	Hutchings	Hutchings	NNPS
18637	23909	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23909	98	v.	v.	IN
18637	23909	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23909	100	Low	Low	NNP
18637	23909	101	,	,	,
18637	23909	102	15	15	CD
18637	23909	103	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23909	104	.	.	.
18637	23910	1	77	77	CD
18637	23910	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23910	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	23910	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23910	5	,	,	,
18637	23910	6	702	702	CD
18637	23910	7	Hutchinson	Hutchinson	NNP
18637	23910	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23910	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23910	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23910	11	Valdosta	Valdosta	NNP
18637	23910	12	,	,	,
18637	23910	13	227	227	CD
18637	23910	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23910	15	303	303	CD
18637	23910	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23910	17	1913	1913	CD
18637	23910	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23910	19	,	,	,
18637	23910	20	1030	1030	CD
18637	23910	21	Hutchinson	Hutchinson	NNP
18637	23910	22	Ice	Ice	NNP
18637	23910	23	Cream	Cream	NNP
18637	23910	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23910	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23910	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23910	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23910	28	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	23910	29	,	,	,
18637	23910	30	242	242	CD
18637	23910	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23910	32	153	153	CD
18637	23910	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23910	34	1916	1916	CD
18637	23910	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23910	36	,	,	,
18637	23910	37	1031	1031	CD
18637	23910	38	Hyatt	Hyatt	NNP
18637	23910	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23910	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23910	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23910	42	New	New	NNP
18637	23910	43	York	York	NNP
18637	23910	44	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23910	45	rel	rel	NN
18637	23910	46	.	.	.
18637	23911	1	Corkran	Corkran	NNP
18637	23911	2	,	,	,
18637	23911	3	188	188	CD
18637	23911	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23911	5	691	691	CD
18637	23911	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23911	7	1903	1903	CD
18637	23911	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23911	9	,	,	,
18637	23911	10	695	695	CD
18637	23911	11	Hyde	Hyde	NNP
18637	23911	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23911	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23911	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23911	15	United	United	NNP
18637	23911	16	States	States	NNP
18637	23911	17	,	,	,
18637	23911	18	225	225	CD
18637	23911	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23911	20	347	347	CD
18637	23911	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23911	22	1912	1912	CD
18637	23911	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23911	24	,	,	,
18637	23911	25	881	881	CD
18637	23911	26	Hygrade	Hygrade	NNP
18637	23911	27	Provision	Provision	NNP
18637	23911	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23911	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23911	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	23911	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23911	32	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	23911	33	,	,	,
18637	23911	34	266	266	CD
18637	23911	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23911	36	497	497	CD
18637	23911	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23911	38	1925	1925	CD
18637	23911	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23911	40	,	,	,
18637	23911	41	237	237	CD
18637	23911	42	,	,	,
18637	23911	43	934	934	CD
18637	23911	44	Hylton	Hylton	NNP
18637	23911	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23911	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	23911	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23911	48	United	United	NNP
18637	23911	49	States	States	NNP
18637	23911	50	,	,	,
18637	23911	51	3	3	CD
18637	23911	52	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	23911	53	.	.	.
18637	23912	1	171	171	CD
18637	23912	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23912	3	1796	1796	CD
18637	23912	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23912	5	,	,	,
18637	23912	6	318	318	CD
18637	23912	7	,	,	,
18637	23912	8	558	558	CD
18637	23912	9	Hysler	Hysler	NNP
18637	23912	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23912	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23912	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23912	13	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	23912	14	,	,	,
18637	23912	15	315	315	CD
18637	23912	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23912	17	411	411	CD
18637	23912	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23912	19	1942	1942	CD
18637	23912	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23912	21	,	,	,
18637	23912	22	1125	1125	CD
18637	23912	23	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	23912	24	Ickes	Ickes	NNP
18637	23912	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23912	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23912	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23912	28	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	23912	29	,	,	,
18637	23912	30	300	300	CD
18637	23912	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23912	32	82	82	CD
18637	23912	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23912	34	1937	1937	CD
18637	23912	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23912	36	,	,	,
18637	23912	37	590	590	CD
18637	23912	38	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23912	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23912	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23912	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23912	42	Economy	Economy	NNP
18637	23912	43	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23912	44	Light	Light	NNP
18637	23912	45	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23912	46	,	,	,
18637	23912	47	234	234	CD
18637	23912	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23912	49	497	497	CD
18637	23912	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23912	51	1914	1914	CD
18637	23912	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23912	53	,	,	,
18637	23912	54	229	229	CD
18637	23912	55	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23912	56	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23912	57	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23912	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23912	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23912	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23912	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23912	62	Behrens	Behrens	NNP
18637	23912	63	,	,	,
18637	23912	64	233	233	CD
18637	23912	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23912	66	473	473	CD
18637	23912	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23912	68	1914	1914	CD
18637	23912	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23912	70	,	,	,
18637	23912	71	141	141	CD
18637	23912	72	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23912	73	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23912	74	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23912	75	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23912	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23912	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	23912	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23912	79	Bosworth	Bosworth	NNP
18637	23912	80	,	,	,
18637	23912	81	133	133	CD
18637	23912	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23912	83	92	92	CD
18637	23912	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23912	85	1890	1890	CD
18637	23912	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23912	87	,	,	,
18637	23912	88	408	408	CD
18637	23912	89	,	,	,
18637	23912	90	645	645	CD
18637	23912	91	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23912	92	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23912	93	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23912	94	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23912	95	_	_	NNP
18637	23912	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	23912	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23912	98	Decatur	Decatur	NNP
18637	23912	99	,	,	,
18637	23912	100	147	147	CD
18637	23912	101	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23912	102	190	190	CD
18637	23912	103	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23912	104	1893	1893	CD
18637	23912	105	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23912	106	,	,	,
18637	23912	107	343	343	CD
18637	23912	108	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23912	109	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23912	110	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23912	111	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23912	112	_	_	NNP
18637	23912	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	23912	114	_	_	NNP
18637	23912	115	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23912	116	,	,	,
18637	23912	117	146	146	CD
18637	23912	118	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23912	119	387	387	CD
18637	23912	120	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23912	121	1892	1892	CD
18637	23912	122	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23912	123	,	,	,
18637	23912	124	221	221	CD
18637	23912	125	,	,	,
18637	23912	126	350	350	CD
18637	23912	127	,	,	,
18637	23912	128	698	698	CD
18637	23912	129	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23912	130	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	23913	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23913	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23913	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23913	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23913	5	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23913	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23913	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	23913	8	.	.	.
18637	23914	1	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	23914	2	,	,	,
18637	23914	3	163	163	CD
18637	23914	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23914	5	142	142	CD
18637	23914	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23914	7	1896	1896	CD
18637	23914	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23914	9	,	,	,
18637	23914	10	270	270	CD
18637	23914	11	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23914	12	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23914	13	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23914	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23914	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23914	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	23914	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23914	18	McKendree	McKendree	NNP
18637	23914	19	,	,	,
18637	23914	20	203	203	CD
18637	23914	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23914	22	514	514	CD
18637	23914	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23914	24	1906	1906	CD
18637	23914	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23914	26	,	,	,
18637	23914	27	122	122	CD
18637	23914	28	,	,	,
18637	23914	29	168	168	CD
18637	23914	30	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23914	31	Cent	Cent	NNP
18637	23914	32	.	.	.
18637	23915	1	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23915	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23915	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23915	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23915	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23915	6	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	23915	7	,	,	,
18637	23915	8	309	309	CD
18637	23915	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23915	10	157	157	CD
18637	23915	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23915	12	1940	1940	CD
18637	23915	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23915	14	,	,	,
18637	23915	15	203	203	CD
18637	23915	16	,	,	,
18637	23915	17	204	204	CD
18637	23915	18	,	,	,
18637	23915	19	1053	1053	CD
18637	23915	20	,	,	,
18637	23915	21	1148	1148	CD
18637	23915	22	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23915	23	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23915	24	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23915	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23915	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23915	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23915	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23915	29	Peery	Peery	NNP
18637	23915	30	,	,	,
18637	23915	31	242	242	CD
18637	23915	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23915	33	292	292	CD
18637	23915	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23915	35	1916	1916	CD
18637	23915	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23915	37	,	,	,
18637	23915	38	141	141	CD
18637	23915	39	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23915	40	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	23916	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23916	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23916	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23916	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23916	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	23916	6	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	23916	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23916	8	,	,	,
18637	23916	9	245	245	CD
18637	23916	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23916	11	493	493	CD
18637	23916	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23916	13	1918	1918	CD
18637	23916	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23916	15	,	,	,
18637	23916	16	219	219	CD
18637	23916	17	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23916	18	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23916	19	rel	rel	NN
18637	23916	20	.	.	.
18637	23917	1	McCollum	McCollum	NNP
18637	23917	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23917	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23917	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23917	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23917	6	of	of	IN
18637	23917	7	Education	Education	NNP
18637	23917	8	,	,	,
18637	23917	9	333	333	CD
18637	23917	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23917	11	203	203	CD
18637	23917	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23917	13	1948	1948	CD
18637	23917	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23917	15	,	,	,
18637	23917	16	542	542	CD
18637	23917	17	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23917	18	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23917	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23917	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23917	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	23917	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23917	23	Public	Public	NNP
18637	23917	24	Service	Service	NNP
18637	23917	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23917	26	,	,	,
18637	23917	27	314	314	CD
18637	23917	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23917	29	498	498	CD
18637	23917	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23917	31	1942	1942	CD
18637	23917	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23917	33	,	,	,
18637	23917	34	219	219	CD
18637	23917	35	,	,	,
18637	23917	36	251	251	CD
18637	23917	37	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23917	38	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	23917	39	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23917	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23917	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23917	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	23917	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23917	44	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23917	45	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	23917	46	.	.	.
18637	23918	1	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	23918	2	.	.	.
18637	23919	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23919	2	,	,	,
18637	23919	3	314	314	CD
18637	23919	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23919	5	498	498	CD
18637	23919	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23919	7	1942	1942	CD
18637	23919	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23919	9	,	,	,
18637	23919	10	138	138	CD
18637	23919	11	Independent	Independent	NNP
18637	23919	12	Warehouses	Warehouses	NNPS
18637	23919	13	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	23919	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23919	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23919	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23919	17	Scheele	Scheele	NNP
18637	23919	18	,	,	,
18637	23919	19	331	331	CD
18637	23919	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23919	21	70	70	CD
18637	23919	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23919	23	1947	1947	CD
18637	23919	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23919	25	,	,	,
18637	23919	26	185	185	CD
18637	23919	27	,	,	,
18637	23919	28	1148	1148	CD
18637	23919	29	Indian	Indian	NNP
18637	23919	30	Motorcycle	Motorcycle	NNP
18637	23919	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23919	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23919	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23919	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23919	35	United	United	NNP
18637	23919	36	States	States	NNP
18637	23919	37	,	,	,
18637	23919	38	283	283	CD
18637	23919	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23919	40	570	570	CD
18637	23919	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23919	42	1931	1931	CD
18637	23919	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23919	44	,	,	,
18637	23919	45	106	106	CD
18637	23919	46	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	23919	47	Territory	Territory	NNP
18637	23919	48	Illuminating	Illuminating	NNP
18637	23919	49	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	23919	50	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23919	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23919	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	23919	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23919	54	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	23919	55	,	,	,
18637	23919	56	240	240	CD
18637	23919	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23919	58	522	522	CD
18637	23919	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23919	60	1916	1916	CD
18637	23919	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23919	62	,	,	,
18637	23919	63	735	735	CD
18637	23919	64	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	23919	65	ex	ex	FW
18637	23919	66	rel	rel	FW
18637	23919	67	.	.	.
18637	23920	1	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	23920	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23920	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23920	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23920	5	Brand	Brand	NNP
18637	23920	6	Trustee	Trustee	NNP
18637	23920	7	,	,	,
18637	23920	8	303	303	CD
18637	23920	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23920	10	95	95	CD
18637	23920	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23920	12	1938	1938	CD
18637	23920	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23920	14	,	,	,
18637	23920	15	341	341	CD
18637	23920	16	,	,	,
18637	23920	17	570	570	CD
18637	23920	18	Indianapolis	Indianapolis	NNP
18637	23920	19	,	,	,
18637	23920	20	City	City	NNP
18637	23920	21	of	of	IN
18637	23920	22	,	,	,
18637	23920	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23920	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23920	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23920	26	Chase	Chase	NNP
18637	23920	27	National	National	NNP
18637	23920	28	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23920	29	,	,	,
18637	23920	30	314	314	CD
18637	23920	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23920	32	63	63	CD
18637	23920	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23920	34	1941	1941	CD
18637	23920	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23920	36	,	,	,
18637	23920	37	603	603	CD
18637	23920	38	Indianapolis	Indianapolis	NNP
18637	23920	39	Brewing	Brewing	NNP
18637	23920	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23920	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23920	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	23920	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23920	44	Liquor	Liquor	NNP
18637	23920	45	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23920	46	,	,	,
18637	23920	47	305	305	CD
18637	23920	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23920	49	391	391	CD
18637	23920	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23920	51	1939	1939	CD
18637	23920	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23920	53	,	,	,
18637	23920	54	1232	1232	CD
18637	23920	55	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	23920	56	Commn	Commn	NNP
18637	23920	57	.	.	.
18637	23921	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23921	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23921	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23921	4	McCartin	McCartin	NNP
18637	23921	5	,	,	,
18637	23921	6	330	330	CD
18637	23921	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23921	8	622	622	CD
18637	23921	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23921	10	1947	1947	CD
18637	23921	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23921	12	,	,	,
18637	23921	13	682	682	CD
18637	23921	14	Ingels	Ingels	NNPS
18637	23921	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23921	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	23921	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23921	18	Morf	Morf	NNP
18637	23921	19	,	,	,
18637	23921	20	300	300	CD
18637	23921	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23921	22	290	290	CD
18637	23921	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23921	24	1937	1937	CD
18637	23921	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23921	26	,	,	,
18637	23921	27	212	212	CD
18637	23921	28	Ingenohl	Ingenohl	NNP
18637	23921	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23921	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	23921	31	_	_	NNP
18637	23921	32	Olsen	Olsen	NNP
18637	23921	33	,	,	,
18637	23921	34	273	273	CD
18637	23921	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23921	36	541	541	CD
18637	23921	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23921	38	1927	1927	CD
18637	23921	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23921	40	,	,	,
18637	23921	41	685	685	CD
18637	23921	42	Inland	Inland	NNP
18637	23921	43	Empire	Empire	NNP
18637	23921	44	Council	Council	NNP
18637	23921	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23921	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	23921	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23921	48	Millis	Millis	NNP
18637	23921	49	,	,	,
18637	23921	50	325	325	CD
18637	23921	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23921	52	697	697	CD
18637	23921	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23921	54	1945	1945	CD
18637	23921	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23921	56	,	,	,
18637	23921	57	850	850	CD
18637	23921	58	Inman	Inman	NNP
18637	23921	59	Steamship	Steamship	NNP
18637	23921	60	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23921	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23921	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	23921	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23921	64	Tinker	Tinker	NNP
18637	23921	65	,	,	,
18637	23921	66	94	94	CD
18637	23921	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23921	68	238	238	CD
18637	23921	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23921	70	1877	1877	CD
18637	23921	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23921	72	,	,	,
18637	23921	73	366	366	CD
18637	23921	74	Innes	Innes	NNPS
18637	23921	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23921	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	23921	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23921	78	Tobin	Tobin	NNP
18637	23921	79	,	,	,
18637	23921	80	240	240	CD
18637	23921	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23921	82	127	127	CD
18637	23921	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23921	84	1916	1916	CD
18637	23921	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23921	86	,	,	,
18637	23921	87	694	694	CD
18637	23921	88	,	,	,
18637	23921	89	695	695	CD
18637	23921	90	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	23921	91	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23921	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23921	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	23921	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23921	95	New	New	NNP
18637	23921	96	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	23921	97	,	,	,
18637	23921	98	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	23921	99	.	.	.
18637	23922	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	23922	2	.	.	.
18637	23923	1	No	no	UH
18637	23923	2	.	.	.
18637	23924	1	7,052	7,052	CD
18637	23924	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23924	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	23924	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23924	5	,	,	,
18637	23924	6	965	965	CD
18637	23924	7	Intermountain	Intermountain	NNP
18637	23924	8	Rate	Rate	NNP
18637	23924	9	Cases	case	NNS
18637	23924	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23924	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23924	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23924	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23924	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	23924	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23924	16	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	23924	17	,	,	,
18637	23924	18	T.	T.	NNP
18637	23924	19	&	&	CC
18637	23924	20	S.P.R.	S.P.R.	NNP
18637	23925	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23925	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23925	3	234	234	CD
18637	23925	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23925	5	476	476	CD
18637	23925	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23925	7	1914	1914	CD
18637	23925	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23925	9	,	,	,
18637	23925	10	137	137	CD
18637	23925	11	International	International	NNP
18637	23925	12	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	23925	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23925	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23925	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23925	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23925	17	New	New	NNP
18637	23925	18	York	York	NNP
18637	23925	19	,	,	,
18637	23925	20	254	254	CD
18637	23925	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23925	22	126	126	CD
18637	23925	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23925	24	1920	1920	CD
18637	23925	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23925	26	,	,	,
18637	23925	27	1010	1010	CD
18637	23925	28	International	International	NNP
18637	23925	29	Brotherhood	Brotherhood	NNP
18637	23925	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23925	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23925	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23925	33	Western	Western	NNP
18637	23925	34	U.	U.	NNP
18637	23925	35	Tel	Tel	NNP
18637	23925	36	.	.	.
18637	23926	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23926	2	,	,	,
18637	23926	3	46	46	CD
18637	23926	4	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23926	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23926	6	2d	2d	NNP
18637	23926	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23926	8	736	736	CD
18637	23926	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23926	10	1931	1931	CD
18637	23926	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23926	12	,	,	,
18637	23926	13	953	953	CD
18637	23926	14	International	International	NNP
18637	23926	15	Brotherhood	Brotherhood	NNP
18637	23926	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23926	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23926	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23926	19	Western	Western	NNP
18637	23926	20	U.	U.	NNP
18637	23926	21	Tel	Tel	NNP
18637	23926	22	.	.	.
18637	23927	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23927	2	,	,	,
18637	23927	3	284	284	CD
18637	23927	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23927	5	630	630	CD
18637	23927	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23927	7	1931	1931	CD
18637	23927	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23927	9	,	,	,
18637	23927	10	953	953	CD
18637	23927	11	International	International	NNP
18637	23927	12	Harvester	Harvester	NNP
18637	23927	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23927	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23927	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	17	Evatt	Evatt	NNP
18637	23927	18	,	,	,
18637	23927	19	329	329	CD
18637	23927	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23927	21	416	416	CD
18637	23927	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23927	23	1947	1947	CD
18637	23927	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23927	25	,	,	,
18637	23927	26	203	203	CD
18637	23927	27	International	International	NNP
18637	23927	28	Harvester	Harvester	NNP
18637	23927	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23927	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23927	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	33	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23927	34	,	,	,
18637	23927	35	234	234	CD
18637	23927	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23927	37	579	579	CD
18637	23927	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23927	39	1914	1914	CD
18637	23927	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23927	41	,	,	,
18637	23927	42	234	234	CD
18637	23927	43	,	,	,
18637	23927	44	660	660	CD
18637	23927	45	,	,	,
18637	23927	46	1079	1079	CD
18637	23927	47	International	International	NNP
18637	23927	48	Harvester	Harvester	NNP
18637	23927	49	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23927	50	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	23927	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	53	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	23927	54	,	,	,
18637	23927	55	234	234	CD
18637	23927	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23927	57	199	199	CD
18637	23927	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23927	59	1914	1914	CD
18637	23927	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23927	61	,	,	,
18637	23927	62	1017	1017	CD
18637	23927	63	International	International	NNP
18637	23927	64	Milling	Milling	NNP
18637	23927	65	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23927	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23927	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	69	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	23927	70	T.	T.	NNP
18637	23927	71	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23927	72	,	,	,
18637	23927	73	292	292	CD
18637	23927	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23927	75	511	511	CD
18637	23927	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23927	77	1934	1934	CD
18637	23927	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23927	79	,	,	,
18637	23927	80	234	234	CD
18637	23927	81	,	,	,
18637	23927	82	1100	1100	CD
18637	23927	83	International	International	NNP
18637	23927	84	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	23927	85	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23927	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	87	v.	v.	IN
18637	23927	88	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	89	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	23927	90	,	,	,
18637	23927	91	246	246	CD
18637	23927	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23927	93	135	135	CD
18637	23927	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23927	95	1918	1918	CD
18637	23927	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23927	97	,	,	,
18637	23927	98	196	196	CD
18637	23927	99	,	,	,
18637	23927	100	1051	1051	CD
18637	23927	101	International	International	NNP
18637	23927	102	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	23927	103	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23927	104	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	105	v.	v.	IN
18637	23927	106	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	107	United	United	NNP
18637	23927	108	States	States	NNP
18637	23927	109	,	,	,
18637	23927	110	282	282	CD
18637	23927	111	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23927	112	399	399	CD
18637	23927	113	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23927	114	1931	1931	CD
18637	23927	115	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23927	116	,	,	,
18637	23927	117	867	867	CD
18637	23927	118	International	International	NNP
18637	23927	119	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	23927	120	Supply	Supply	NNP
18637	23927	121	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23927	122	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	123	v.	v.	IN
18637	23927	124	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	125	Bruce	Bruce	NNP
18637	23927	126	,	,	,
18637	23927	127	194	194	CD
18637	23927	128	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23927	129	601	601	CD
18637	23927	130	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23927	131	1904	1904	CD
18637	23927	132	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23927	133	,	,	,
18637	23927	134	590	590	CD
18637	23927	135	International	International	NNP
18637	23927	136	Shoe	Shoe	NNP
18637	23927	137	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23927	138	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	139	v.	v.	IN
18637	23927	140	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	141	Pinkus	Pinkus	NNP
18637	23927	142	,	,	,
18637	23927	143	278	278	CD
18637	23927	144	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23927	145	261	261	CD
18637	23927	146	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23927	147	1929	1929	CD
18637	23927	148	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23927	149	,	,	,
18637	23927	150	265	265	CD
18637	23927	151	International	International	NNP
18637	23927	152	Shoe	Shoe	NNP
18637	23927	153	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23927	154	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	155	v.	v.	IN
18637	23927	156	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	157	Shartel	Shartel	NNP
18637	23927	158	,	,	,
18637	23927	159	279	279	CD
18637	23927	160	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23927	161	429	429	CD
18637	23927	162	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23927	163	1929	1929	CD
18637	23927	164	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23927	165	,	,	,
18637	23927	166	203	203	CD
18637	23927	167	International	International	NNP
18637	23927	168	Shoe	Shoe	NNP
18637	23927	169	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23927	170	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	171	v.	v.	IN
18637	23927	172	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	173	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	23927	174	,	,	,
18637	23927	175	326	326	CD
18637	23927	176	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23927	177	310	310	CD
18637	23927	178	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23927	179	1945	1945	CD
18637	23927	180	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23927	181	,	,	,
18637	23927	182	1075	1075	CD
18637	23927	183	,	,	,
18637	23927	184	1078	1078	CD
18637	23927	185	,	,	,
18637	23927	186	1079	1079	CD
18637	23927	187	International	International	NNP
18637	23927	188	Text	Text	NNP
18637	23927	189	Book	Book	NNP
18637	23927	190	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23927	191	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	192	v.	v.	IN
18637	23927	193	_	_	NNP
18637	23927	194	Pigg	Pigg	NNP
18637	23927	195	,	,	,
18637	23927	196	217	217	CD
18637	23927	197	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23927	198	91	91	CD
18637	23927	199	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23927	200	1910	1910	CD
18637	23927	201	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23927	202	,	,	,
18637	23927	203	120	120	CD
18637	23927	204	International	International	NNP
18637	23927	205	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23927	206	,	,	,
18637	23927	207	Etc	Etc	NNP
18637	23927	208	.	.	.
18637	23928	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23928	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23928	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23928	4	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	23928	5	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	23928	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23928	7	,	,	,
18637	23928	8	31	31	CD
18637	23928	9	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23928	10	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	23928	11	.	.	.
18637	23929	1	1015	1015	CD
18637	23929	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23929	3	1940	1940	CD
18637	23929	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23929	5	,	,	,
18637	23929	6	1133	1133	CD
18637	23929	7	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23929	8	Amusement	Amusement	NNP
18637	23929	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23929	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23929	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23929	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23929	13	Albert	Albert	NNP
18637	23929	14	,	,	,
18637	23929	15	239	239	CD
18637	23929	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23929	17	560	560	CD
18637	23929	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23929	19	1916	1916	CD
18637	23929	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23929	21	,	,	,
18637	23929	22	234	234	CD
18637	23929	23	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23929	24	Busses	Busses	NNPS
18637	23929	25	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23929	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23929	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23929	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23929	29	Blodgett	Blodgett	NNP
18637	23929	30	,	,	,
18637	23929	31	276	276	CD
18637	23929	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23929	33	245	245	CD
18637	23929	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23929	35	1928	1928	CD
18637	23929	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23929	37	,	,	,
18637	23929	38	212	212	CD
18637	23929	39	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23929	40	Busses	Busses	NNPS
18637	23929	41	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23929	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23929	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23929	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23929	45	Holyoke	Holyoke	NNP
18637	23929	46	Street	Street	NNP
18637	23929	47	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23929	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23929	49	,	,	,
18637	23929	50	273	273	CD
18637	23929	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23929	52	45	45	CD
18637	23929	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23929	54	1927	1927	CD
18637	23929	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23929	56	,	,	,
18637	23929	57	228	228	CD
18637	23929	58	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23929	59	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	23929	60	Com	Com	NNP
18637	23929	61	.	.	.
18637	23930	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23930	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23930	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23930	4	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	23930	5	Midland	Midland	NNP
18637	23930	6	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23930	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23930	8	,	,	,
18637	23930	9	168	168	CD
18637	23930	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23930	11	144	144	CD
18637	23930	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23930	13	1897	1897	CD
18637	23930	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23930	15	,	,	,
18637	23930	16	134	134	CD
18637	23930	17	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23930	18	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	23930	19	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23930	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23930	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	23930	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23930	23	Baird	Baird	NNP
18637	23930	24	,	,	,
18637	23930	25	194	194	CD
18637	23930	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23930	27	25	25	CD
18637	23930	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23930	29	1904	1904	CD
18637	23930	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23930	31	,	,	,
18637	23930	32	827	827	CD
18637	23930	33	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23930	34	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	23930	35	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23930	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23930	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23930	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23930	39	Brimson	Brimson	NNP
18637	23930	40	,	,	,
18637	23930	41	154	154	CD
18637	23930	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23930	43	447	447	CD
18637	23930	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23930	45	1894	1894	CD
18637	23930	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23930	47	,	,	,
18637	23930	48	84	84	CD
18637	23930	49	,	,	,
18637	23930	50	134	134	CD
18637	23930	51	,	,	,
18637	23930	52	514	514	CD
18637	23930	53	,	,	,
18637	23930	54	521	521	CD
18637	23930	55	,	,	,
18637	23930	56	550	550	CD
18637	23930	57	,	,	,
18637	23930	58	847	847	CD
18637	23930	59	,	,	,
18637	23930	60	893	893	CD
18637	23930	61	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23930	62	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	23930	63	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23930	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23930	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	23930	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23930	67	Goodrich	Goodrich	NNP
18637	23930	68	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	23930	69	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23930	70	,	,	,
18637	23930	71	224	224	CD
18637	23930	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23930	73	194	194	CD
18637	23930	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23930	75	1912	1912	CD
18637	23930	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23930	77	,	,	,
18637	23930	78	76	76	CD
18637	23930	79	,	,	,
18637	23930	80	137	137	CD
18637	23930	81	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23930	82	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	23930	83	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23930	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23930	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	23930	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23930	87	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23930	88	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	23931	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23931	2	,	,	,
18637	23931	3	215	215	CD
18637	23931	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23931	5	452	452	CD
18637	23931	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23931	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	23931	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23931	9	,	,	,
18637	23931	10	1001	1001	CD
18637	23931	11	,	,	,
18637	23931	12	1003	1003	CD
18637	23931	13	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23931	14	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	23931	15	Comn	Comn	NNP
18637	23931	16	.	.	.
18637	23932	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23932	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23932	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23932	4	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	23932	5	&	&	CC
18637	23932	6	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	23933	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23933	2	,	,	,
18637	23933	3	227	227	CD
18637	23933	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23933	5	88	88	CD
18637	23933	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23933	7	1913	1913	CD
18637	23933	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23933	9	,	,	,
18637	23933	10	77	77	CD
18637	23933	11	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23933	12	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	23933	13	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23933	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23933	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23933	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23933	17	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23933	18	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	23933	19	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23933	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23933	21	,	,	,
18637	23933	22	222	222	CD
18637	23933	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23933	24	541	541	CD
18637	23933	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23933	26	1912	1912	CD
18637	23933	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23933	28	,	,	,
18637	23933	29	1002	1002	CD
18637	23933	30	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23933	31	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	23933	32	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23933	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23933	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	23933	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23933	36	United	United	NNP
18637	23933	37	States	States	NNP
18637	23933	38	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23933	39	rel	rel	NN
18637	23933	40	.	.	.
18637	23934	1	Humboldt	Humboldt	NNP
18637	23934	2	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	23934	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23934	4	,	,	,
18637	23934	5	224	224	CD
18637	23934	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23934	7	474	474	CD
18637	23934	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23934	9	1912	1912	CD
18637	23934	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23934	11	,	,	,
18637	23934	12	703	703	CD
18637	23934	13	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23934	14	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	23934	15	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23934	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23934	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23934	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23934	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23934	20	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	23934	21	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23934	22	Com	Com	NNP
18637	23934	23	.	.	NNP
18637	23934	24	,	,	,
18637	23934	25	331	331	CD
18637	23934	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23934	27	682	682	CD
18637	23934	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23934	29	1947	1947	CD
18637	23934	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23934	31	,	,	,
18637	23934	32	251	251	CD
18637	23934	33	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23934	34	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	23934	35	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	23934	36	Line	Line	NNP
18637	23934	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23934	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23934	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23934	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23934	41	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	23934	42	,	,	,
18637	23934	43	337	337	CD
18637	23934	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23934	45	662	662	CD
18637	23934	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23934	47	1949	1949	CD
18637	23934	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23934	49	,	,	,
18637	23934	50	203	203	CD
18637	23934	51	,	,	,
18637	23934	52	208	208	CD
18637	23934	53	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	23934	54	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	23934	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23934	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	23934	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23934	58	Lindsey	Lindsey	NNP
18637	23934	59	,	,	,
18637	23934	60	283	283	CD
18637	23934	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23934	62	183	183	CD
18637	23934	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23934	64	1931	1931	CD
18637	23934	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23934	66	,	,	,
18637	23934	67	195	195	CD
18637	23934	68	,	,	,
18637	23934	69	212	212	CD
18637	23934	70	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	23934	71	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	23935	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23935	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23935	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23935	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23935	5	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	23935	6	,	,	,
18637	23935	7	160	160	CD
18637	23935	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23935	9	389	389	CD
18637	23935	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23935	11	1896	1896	CD
18637	23935	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23935	13	,	,	,
18637	23935	14	1089	1089	CD
18637	23935	15	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	23935	16	Cliffs	Cliffs	NNP
18637	23935	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23935	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23935	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23935	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23935	21	Negaunee	Negaunee	NNP
18637	23935	22	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	23935	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23935	24	,	,	,
18637	23935	25	197	197	CD
18637	23935	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23935	27	463	463	CD
18637	23935	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23935	29	1905	1905	CD
18637	23935	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23935	31	,	,	,
18637	23935	32	1072	1072	CD
18637	23935	33	Irvine	Irvine	NNP
18637	23935	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23935	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23935	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23935	37	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	23935	38	,	,	,
18637	23935	39	20	20	CD
18637	23935	40	How	how	WRB
18637	23935	41	.	.	.
18637	23936	1	558	558	CD
18637	23936	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23936	3	1858	1858	CD
18637	23936	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23936	5	,	,	,
18637	23936	6	702	702	CD
18637	23936	7	,	,	,
18637	23936	8	703	703	CD
18637	23936	9	Irving	Irving	NNP
18637	23936	10	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23936	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23936	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23936	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23936	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23936	15	Day	Day	NNP
18637	23936	16	,	,	,
18637	23936	17	314	314	CD
18637	23936	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23936	19	556	556	CD
18637	23936	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23936	21	1942	1942	CD
18637	23936	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23936	23	,	,	,
18637	23936	24	1034	1034	CD
18637	23936	25	Irwin	Irwin	NNP
18637	23936	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23936	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23936	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23936	29	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	23936	30	,	,	,
18637	23936	31	258	258	CD
18637	23936	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23936	33	219	219	CD
18637	23936	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23936	35	1922	1922	CD
18637	23936	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23936	37	,	,	,
18637	23936	38	732	732	CD
18637	23936	39	Isbrandtsen	Isbrandtsen	NNP
18637	23936	40	-	-	HYPH
18637	23936	41	Moller	Moller	NNP
18637	23936	42	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23936	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23936	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	23936	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23936	46	United	United	NNP
18637	23936	47	States	States	NNP
18637	23936	48	,	,	,
18637	23936	49	300	300	CD
18637	23936	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23936	51	139	139	CD
18637	23936	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23936	53	1937	1937	CD
18637	23936	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23936	55	,	,	,
18637	23936	56	860	860	CD
18637	23936	57	J	J	NNP
18637	23936	58	Jack	Jack	NNP
18637	23936	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23936	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23936	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23936	62	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23936	63	,	,	,
18637	23936	64	199	199	CD
18637	23936	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23936	66	372	372	CD
18637	23936	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23936	68	1905	1905	CD
18637	23936	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23936	70	,	,	,
18637	23936	71	1112	1112	CD
18637	23936	72	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	23936	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23936	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	23936	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23936	76	Lamphire	Lamphire	NNP
18637	23936	77	,	,	,
18637	23936	78	3	3	CD
18637	23936	79	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	23936	80	.	.	.
18637	23937	1	280	280	CD
18637	23937	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23937	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	23937	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23937	5	,	,	,
18637	23937	6	355	355	CD
18637	23937	7	,	,	,
18637	23937	8	358	358	CD
18637	23937	9	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	23937	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23937	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23937	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23937	13	Roby	Roby	NNP
18637	23937	14	,	,	,
18637	23937	15	109	109	CD
18637	23937	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23937	17	440	440	CD
18637	23937	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23937	19	1883	1883	CD
18637	23937	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23937	21	,	,	,
18637	23937	22	78	78	CD
18637	23937	23	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	23937	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23937	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23937	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23937	27	Steamboat	Steamboat	NNP
18637	23937	28	Magnolia	Magnolia	NNP
18637	23937	29	,	,	,
18637	23937	30	20	20	CD
18637	23937	31	How	how	WRB
18637	23937	32	.	.	.
18637	23938	1	296	296	CD
18637	23938	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23938	3	1858	1858	CD
18637	23938	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23938	5	,	,	,
18637	23938	6	578	578	CD
18637	23938	7	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	23938	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23938	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23938	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23938	11	Twentyman	Twentyman	NNP
18637	23938	12	,	,	,
18637	23938	13	2	2	CD
18637	23938	14	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23938	15	.	.	.
18637	23939	1	136	136	CD
18637	23939	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23939	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	23939	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23939	5	,	,	,
18637	23939	6	611	611	CD
18637	23939	7	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	23939	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23939	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	11	United	United	NNP
18637	23939	12	States	States	NNP
18637	23939	13	,	,	,
18637	23939	14	230	230	CD
18637	23939	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23939	16	1	1	CD
18637	23939	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23939	18	1913	1913	CD
18637	23939	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23939	20	,	,	,
18637	23939	21	128	128	CD
18637	23939	22	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	23939	23	,	,	,
18637	23939	24	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23939	25	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23939	26	,	,	,
18637	23939	27	96	96	CD
18637	23939	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23939	29	727	727	CD
18637	23939	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23939	31	1878	1878	CD
18637	23939	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23939	33	,	,	,
18637	23939	34	268	268	CD
18637	23939	35	,	,	,
18637	23939	36	824	824	CD
18637	23939	37	Jacob	Jacob	NNP
18637	23939	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23939	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	41	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	23939	42	,	,	,
18637	23939	43	223	223	CD
18637	23939	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23939	45	261	261	CD
18637	23939	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23939	47	1912	1912	CD
18637	23939	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23939	49	,	,	,
18637	23939	50	1084	1084	CD
18637	23939	51	Jacobs	Jacobs	NNP
18637	23939	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	23939	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	55	Marks	Marks	NNP
18637	23939	56	,	,	,
18637	23939	57	182	182	CD
18637	23939	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23939	59	583	583	CD
18637	23939	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23939	61	1901	1901	CD
18637	23939	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23939	63	,	,	,
18637	23939	64	656	656	CD
18637	23939	65	Jacobs	Jacobs	NNP
18637	23939	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23939	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	69	United	United	NNP
18637	23939	70	States	States	NNP
18637	23939	71	,	,	,
18637	23939	72	290	290	CD
18637	23939	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23939	74	13	13	CD
18637	23939	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23939	76	1933	1933	CD
18637	23939	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23939	78	,	,	,
18637	23939	79	869	869	CD
18637	23939	80	,	,	,
18637	23939	81	871	871	CD
18637	23939	82	,	,	,
18637	23939	83	872	872	CD
18637	23939	84	Jacobson	Jacobson	NNP
18637	23939	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	23939	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	88	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	23939	89	,	,	,
18637	23939	90	197	197	CD
18637	23939	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23939	92	11	11	CD
18637	23939	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23939	94	1905	1905	CD
18637	23939	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23939	96	,	,	,
18637	23939	97	60	60	CD
18637	23939	98	,	,	,
18637	23939	99	564	564	CD
18637	23939	100	,	,	,
18637	23939	101	984	984	CD
18637	23939	102	,	,	,
18637	23939	103	1029	1029	CD
18637	23939	104	Jaehne	Jaehne	NNP
18637	23939	105	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	106	v.	v.	IN
18637	23939	107	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	108	New	New	NNP
18637	23939	109	York	York	NNP
18637	23939	110	,	,	,
18637	23939	111	128	128	CD
18637	23939	112	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23939	113	189	189	CD
18637	23939	114	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23939	115	1888	1888	CD
18637	23939	116	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23939	117	,	,	,
18637	23939	118	327	327	CD
18637	23939	119	James	James	NNP
18637	23939	120	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	121	v.	v.	IN
18637	23939	122	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	123	Appel	Appel	NNP
18637	23939	124	,	,	,
18637	23939	125	192	192	CD
18637	23939	126	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23939	127	129	129	CD
18637	23939	128	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23939	129	1904	1904	CD
18637	23939	130	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23939	131	,	,	,
18637	23939	132	1140	1140	CD
18637	23939	133	James	James	NNP
18637	23939	134	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	135	v.	v.	IN
18637	23939	136	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	137	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
18637	23939	138	,	,	,
18637	23939	139	190	190	CD
18637	23939	140	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23939	141	127	127	CD
18637	23939	142	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23939	143	1903	1903	CD
18637	23939	144	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23939	145	,	,	,
18637	23939	146	1186	1186	CD
18637	23939	147	James	James	NNP
18637	23939	148	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	149	v.	v.	IN
18637	23939	150	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	151	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
18637	23939	152	,	,	,
18637	23939	153	104	104	CD
18637	23939	154	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23939	155	356	356	CD
18637	23939	156	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23939	157	1882	1882	CD
18637	23939	158	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23939	159	,	,	,
18637	23939	160	275	275	CD
18637	23939	161	,	,	,
18637	23939	162	867	867	CD
18637	23939	163	James	James	NNP
18637	23939	164	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	165	v.	v.	IN
18637	23939	166	_	_	NNP
18637	23939	167	Dravo	Dravo	NNP
18637	23939	168	Contracting	Contracting	NNP
18637	23939	169	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23939	170	,	,	,
18637	23939	171	302	302	CD
18637	23939	172	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23939	173	134	134	CD
18637	23939	174	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23939	175	1937	1937	CD
18637	23939	176	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23939	177	,	,	,
18637	23939	178	198	198	CD
18637	23939	179	,	,	,
18637	23939	180	305	305	CD
18637	23939	181	,	,	,
18637	23939	182	307	307	CD
18637	23939	183	,	,	,
18637	23939	184	369	369	CD
18637	23939	185	,	,	,
18637	23939	186	730	730	CD
18637	23939	187	,	,	,
18637	23939	188	731	731	CD
18637	23939	189	,	,	,
18637	23939	190	1051	1051	CD
18637	23939	191	James	James	NNP
18637	23939	192	-	-	HYPH
18637	23939	193	Dickinson	Dickinson	NNP
18637	23939	194	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	23939	195	Mortg	Mortg	NNP
18637	23939	196	.	.	.
18637	23940	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23940	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23940	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23940	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23940	5	Harry	Harry	NNP
18637	23940	6	,	,	,
18637	23940	7	273	273	CD
18637	23940	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23940	9	119	119	CD
18637	23940	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23940	11	1927	1927	CD
18637	23940	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23940	13	,	,	,
18637	23940	14	1094	1094	CD
18637	23940	15	James	James	NNP
18637	23940	16	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	23940	17	&	&	CC
18637	23940	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23940	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23940	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	23940	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23940	22	Sadrakula	Sadrakula	NNP
18637	23940	23	,	,	,
18637	23940	24	309	309	CD
18637	23940	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23940	26	94	94	CD
18637	23940	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23940	28	1940	1940	CD
18637	23940	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23940	30	,	,	,
18637	23940	31	305	305	CD
18637	23940	32	Jamison	Jamison	NNP
18637	23940	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23940	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	23940	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23940	36	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23940	37	,	,	,
18637	23940	38	318	318	CD
18637	23940	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23940	40	413	413	CD
18637	23940	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23940	42	1943	1943	CD
18637	23940	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23940	44	,	,	,
18637	23940	45	786	786	CD
18637	23940	46	Janney	Janney	NNP
18637	23940	47	_	_	NNP
18637	23940	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	23940	49	_	_	NNP
18637	23940	50	Columbian	Columbian	NNP
18637	23940	51	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23940	52	.	.	.
18637	23941	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23941	2	,	,	,
18637	23941	3	10	10	CD
18637	23941	4	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23941	5	.	.	.
18637	23942	1	411	411	CD
18637	23942	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23942	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	23942	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23942	5	,	,	,
18637	23942	6	574	574	CD
18637	23942	7	,	,	,
18637	23942	8	579	579	CD
18637	23942	9	Japanese	japanese	JJ
18637	23942	10	Immigrant	Immigrant	NNP
18637	23942	11	Case	Case	NNP
18637	23942	12	,	,	,
18637	23942	13	189	189	CD
18637	23942	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23942	15	86	86	CD
18637	23942	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23942	17	1903	1903	CD
18637	23942	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23942	19	,	,	,
18637	23942	20	259	259	CD
18637	23942	21	Jaster	Jaster	NNP
18637	23942	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23942	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23942	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23942	25	Currie	Currie	NNP
18637	23942	26	,	,	,
18637	23942	27	198	198	CD
18637	23942	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23942	29	144	144	CD
18637	23942	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23942	31	1905	1905	CD
18637	23942	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23942	33	,	,	,
18637	23942	34	659	659	CD
18637	23942	35	Jatros	Jatros	NNP
18637	23942	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23942	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23942	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23942	39	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	23942	40	,	,	,
18637	23942	41	143	143	CD
18637	23942	42	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23942	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23942	44	2d	2d	CD
18637	23942	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23942	46	453	453	CD
18637	23942	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23942	48	1944	1944	CD
18637	23942	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23942	50	,	,	,
18637	23942	51	1234	1234	CD
18637	23942	52	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	23942	53	Branch	Branch	NNP
18637	23942	54	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	23942	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23942	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	23942	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23942	58	Skelly	Skelly	NNP
18637	23942	59	,	,	,
18637	23942	60	1	1	CD
18637	23942	61	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	23942	62	.	.	.
18637	23943	1	436	436	CD
18637	23943	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23943	3	1862	1862	CD
18637	23943	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23943	5	,	,	,
18637	23943	6	330	330	CD
18637	23943	7	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	23943	8	City	City	NNP
18637	23943	9	Gaslight	Gaslight	NNP
18637	23943	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23943	11	_	_	NNP
18637	23943	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	23943	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23943	14	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	23943	15	,	,	,
18637	23943	16	95	95	CD
18637	23943	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23943	18	644	644	CD
18637	23943	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23943	20	1877	1877	CD
18637	23943	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23943	22	,	,	,
18637	23943	23	893	893	CD
18637	23943	24	Jennings	Jennings	NNPS
18637	23943	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23943	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23943	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23943	28	Carson	Carson	NNP
18637	23943	29	,	,	,
18637	23943	30	4	4	CD
18637	23943	31	Cr	Cr	NNP
18637	23943	32	.	.	.
18637	23944	1	2	2	CD
18637	23944	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23944	3	1807	1807	CD
18637	23944	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23944	5	,	,	,
18637	23944	6	575	575	CD
18637	23944	7	Jennings	Jennings	NNPS
18637	23944	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23944	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23944	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23944	11	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23944	12	,	,	,
18637	23944	13	343	343	CD
18637	23944	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23944	15	104	104	CD
18637	23944	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23944	17	1952	1952	CD
18637	23944	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23944	19	,	,	,
18637	23944	20	1121	1121	CD
18637	23944	21	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	23944	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23944	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23944	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23944	25	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	23944	26	Life	Life	NNP
18637	23944	27	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23944	28	.	.	.
18637	23945	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23945	2	,	,	,
18637	23945	3	28	28	CD
18637	23945	4	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23945	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23945	6	2d	2d	NNP
18637	23945	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23945	8	545	545	CD
18637	23945	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23945	10	1928	1928	CD
18637	23945	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23945	12	,	,	,
18637	23945	13	894	894	CD
18637	23945	14	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	23945	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23945	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	23945	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23945	18	Continental	Continental	NNP
18637	23945	19	Life	Life	NNP
18637	23945	20	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23945	21	.	.	.
18637	23946	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23946	2	,	,	,
18637	23946	3	279	279	CD
18637	23946	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23946	5	842	842	CD
18637	23946	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23946	7	1929	1929	CD
18637	23946	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23946	9	,	,	,
18637	23946	10	894	894	CD
18637	23946	11	Jerome	Jerome	NNP
18637	23946	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23946	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23946	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23946	15	United	United	NNP
18637	23946	16	States	States	NNP
18637	23946	17	,	,	,
18637	23946	18	318	318	CD
18637	23946	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23946	20	101	101	CD
18637	23946	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23946	22	1943	1943	CD
18637	23946	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23946	24	,	,	,
18637	23946	25	841	841	CD
18637	23946	26	Johannessen	Johannessen	NNP
18637	23946	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23946	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	23946	29	_	_	NNP
18637	23946	30	United	United	NNP
18637	23946	31	States	States	NNP
18637	23946	32	,	,	,
18637	23946	33	225	225	CD
18637	23946	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23946	35	227	227	CD
18637	23946	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23946	37	1912	1912	CD
18637	23946	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23946	39	,	,	,
18637	23946	40	257	257	CD
18637	23946	41	,	,	,
18637	23946	42	258	258	CD
18637	23946	43	,	,	,
18637	23946	44	317	317	CD
18637	23946	45	John	John	NNP
18637	23946	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23946	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	23946	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23946	49	Paullin	Paullin	NNP
18637	23946	50	,	,	,
18637	23946	51	231	231	CD
18637	23946	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23946	53	583	583	CD
18637	23946	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23946	55	1913	1913	CD
18637	23946	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23946	57	,	,	,
18637	23946	58	699	699	CD
18637	23946	59	John	John	NNP
18637	23946	60	Hancock	Hancock	NNP
18637	23946	61	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	23946	62	.	.	.
18637	23947	1	Life	Life	NNP
18637	23947	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23947	3	.	.	.
18637	23948	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23948	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23948	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	5	Yates	Yates	NNP
18637	23948	6	,	,	,
18637	23948	7	299	299	CD
18637	23948	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23948	9	178	178	CD
18637	23948	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23948	11	1936	1936	CD
18637	23948	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23948	13	,	,	,
18637	23948	14	677	677	CD
18637	23948	15	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23948	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23948	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	19	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	23948	20	&	&	CC
18637	23948	21	P.	P.	NNP
18637	23948	22	Elevator	Elevator	NNP
18637	23948	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23948	24	,	,	,
18637	23948	25	119	119	CD
18637	23948	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23948	27	388	388	CD
18637	23948	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23948	29	1886	1886	CD
18637	23948	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23948	31	,	,	,
18637	23948	32	312	312	CD
18637	23948	33	,	,	,
18637	23948	34	323	323	CD
18637	23948	35	,	,	,
18637	23948	36	1089	1089	CD
18637	23948	37	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23948	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23948	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	41	Eisentrager	Eisentrager	NNP
18637	23948	42	,	,	,
18637	23948	43	339	339	CD
18637	23948	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23948	45	763	763	CD
18637	23948	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23948	47	1950	1950	CD
18637	23948	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23948	49	,	,	,
18637	23948	50	404	404	CD
18637	23948	51	,	,	,
18637	23948	52	846	846	CD
18637	23948	53	,	,	,
18637	23948	54	851	851	CD
18637	23948	55	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23948	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	23948	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	59	Gearlds	Gearlds	NNP
18637	23948	60	,	,	,
18637	23948	61	234	234	CD
18637	23948	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23948	63	422	422	CD
18637	23948	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23948	65	1914	1914	CD
18637	23948	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23948	67	,	,	,
18637	23948	68	253	253	CD
18637	23948	69	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23948	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	23948	72	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	73	Lankford	Lankford	NNP
18637	23948	74	,	,	,
18637	23948	75	245	245	CD
18637	23948	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23948	77	541	541	CD
18637	23948	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23948	79	1918	1918	CD
18637	23948	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23948	81	,	,	,
18637	23948	82	935	935	CD
18637	23948	83	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23948	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	23948	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	87	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	23948	88	,	,	,
18637	23948	89	254	254	CD
18637	23948	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23948	91	51	51	CD
18637	23948	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23948	93	1920	1920	CD
18637	23948	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23948	95	,	,	,
18637	23948	96	270	270	CD
18637	23948	97	,	,	,
18637	23948	98	724	724	CD
18637	23948	99	,	,	,
18637	23948	100	725	725	CD
18637	23948	101	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23948	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	103	v.	v.	IN
18637	23948	104	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	105	Muelberger	Muelberger	NNP
18637	23948	106	,	,	,
18637	23948	107	341	341	CD
18637	23948	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23948	109	581	581	CD
18637	23948	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23948	111	1951	1951	CD
18637	23948	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23948	113	,	,	,
18637	23948	114	671	671	CD
18637	23948	115	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23948	116	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	117	v.	v.	IN
18637	23948	118	_	_	NNP
18637	23948	119	New	New	NNP
18637	23948	120	York	York	NNP
18637	23948	121	Life	Life	NNP
18637	23948	122	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	23948	123	.	.	.
18637	23949	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23949	2	,	,	,
18637	23949	3	187	187	CD
18637	23949	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23949	5	491	491	CD
18637	23949	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23949	7	1903	1903	CD
18637	23949	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23949	9	,	,	,
18637	23949	10	676	676	CD
18637	23949	11	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23949	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23949	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23949	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23949	15	Sayre	Sayre	NNP
18637	23949	16	,	,	,
18637	23949	17	158	158	CD
18637	23949	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23949	19	109	109	CD
18637	23949	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23949	21	1895	1895	CD
18637	23949	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23949	23	,	,	,
18637	23949	24	838	838	CD
18637	23949	25	,	,	,
18637	23949	26	847	847	CD
18637	23949	27	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23949	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23949	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	23949	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23949	31	United	United	NNP
18637	23949	32	States	States	NNP
18637	23949	33	,	,	,
18637	23949	34	318	318	CD
18637	23949	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23949	36	189	189	CD
18637	23949	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23949	38	1943	1943	CD
18637	23949	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23949	40	,	,	,
18637	23949	41	843	843	CD
18637	23949	42	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23949	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23949	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	23949	45	_	_	NNP
18637	23949	46	United	United	NNP
18637	23949	47	States	States	NNP
18637	23949	48	,	,	,
18637	23949	49	333	333	CD
18637	23949	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23949	51	10	10	CD
18637	23949	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23949	53	1948	1948	CD
18637	23949	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23949	55	,	,	,
18637	23949	56	824	824	CD
18637	23949	57	,	,	,
18637	23949	58	828	828	CD
18637	23949	59	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23949	60	_	_	NNP
18637	23949	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	23949	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23949	63	Yellow	Yellow	NNP
18637	23949	64	Cab	Cab	NNP
18637	23949	65	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23949	66	,	,	,
18637	23949	67	321	321	CD
18637	23949	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23949	69	383	383	CD
18637	23949	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23949	71	1944	1944	CD
18637	23949	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23949	73	,	,	,
18637	23949	74	305	305	CD
18637	23949	75	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23949	76	_	_	NNP
18637	23949	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	23949	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23949	79	Zerbst	Zerbst	NNP
18637	23949	80	,	,	,
18637	23949	81	304	304	CD
18637	23949	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23949	83	458	458	CD
18637	23949	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23949	85	1938	1938	CD
18637	23949	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23949	87	,	,	,
18637	23949	88	885	885	CD
18637	23949	89	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23949	90	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	23949	91	Ref	Ref	NNP
18637	23949	92	.	.	.
18637	23950	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23950	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23950	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23950	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23950	5	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	23950	6	ex	ex	NN
18637	23950	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	23950	8	.	.	.
18637	23951	1	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	23951	2	,	,	,
18637	23951	3	290	290	CD
18637	23951	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23951	5	158	158	CD
18637	23951	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23951	7	1933	1933	CD
18637	23951	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23951	9	,	,	,
18637	23951	10	1042	1042	CD
18637	23951	11	,	,	,
18637	23951	12	1053	1053	CD
18637	23951	13	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23951	14	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	23951	15	Str	Str	NNP
18637	23951	16	.	.	.
18637	23952	1	Rail	Rail	NNP
18637	23952	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23952	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23952	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23952	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23952	6	Wharton	Wharton	NNP
18637	23952	7	,	,	,
18637	23952	8	152	152	CD
18637	23952	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23952	10	252	252	CD
18637	23952	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23952	12	1894	1894	CD
18637	23952	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23952	14	,	,	,
18637	23952	15	620	620	CD
18637	23952	16	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	23952	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23952	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23952	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23952	20	Buffalo	Buffalo	NNP
18637	23952	21	Creek	Creek	NNP
18637	23952	22	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	23952	23	&	&	CC
18637	23952	24	Coke	Coke	NNP
18637	23952	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23952	26	,	,	,
18637	23952	27	245	245	CD
18637	23952	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23952	29	328	328	CD
18637	23952	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23952	31	1917	1917	CD
18637	23952	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23952	33	,	,	,
18637	23952	34	849	849	CD
18637	23952	35	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	23952	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23952	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23952	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23952	39	League	League	NNP
18637	23952	40	,	,	,
18637	23952	41	18	18	CD
18637	23952	42	How	how	WRB
18637	23952	43	.	.	.
18637	23953	1	76	76	CD
18637	23953	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23953	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	23953	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23953	5	,	,	,
18637	23953	6	601	601	CD
18637	23953	7	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	23953	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23953	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	11	Meehan	Meehan	NNP
18637	23953	12	,	,	,
18637	23953	13	175	175	CD
18637	23953	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23953	15	1	1	CD
18637	23953	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23953	17	1899	1899	CD
18637	23953	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23953	19	,	,	,
18637	23953	20	433	433	CD
18637	23953	21	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	23953	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23953	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	25	Opelika	Opelika	NNP
18637	23953	26	,	,	,
18637	23953	27	316	316	CD
18637	23953	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23953	29	584	584	CD
18637	23953	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23953	31	1942	1942	CD
18637	23953	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23953	33	,	,	,
18637	23953	34	767	767	CD
18637	23953	35	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	23953	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	23953	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	39	Opelika	Opelika	NNP
18637	23953	40	,	,	,
18637	23953	41	319	319	CD
18637	23953	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23953	43	103	103	CD
18637	23953	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23953	45	1943	1943	CD
18637	23953	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23953	47	,	,	,
18637	23953	48	767	767	CD
18637	23953	49	,	,	,
18637	23953	50	792	792	CD
18637	23953	51	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	23953	52	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	23953	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	55	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	23953	56	,	,	,
18637	23953	57	245	245	CD
18637	23953	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23953	59	217	217	CD
18637	23953	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23953	61	1917	1917	CD
18637	23953	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23953	63	,	,	,
18637	23953	64	1037	1037	CD
18637	23953	65	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	23953	66	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	23953	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	69	Prairie	Prairie	NNP
18637	23953	70	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	23953	71	&	&	CC
18637	23953	72	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	23953	73	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23953	74	,	,	,
18637	23953	75	273	273	CD
18637	23953	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23953	77	195	195	CD
18637	23953	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23953	79	1927	1927	CD
18637	23953	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23953	81	,	,	,
18637	23953	82	1082	1082	CD
18637	23953	83	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	23953	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	23953	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	87	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23953	88	Guano	Guano	NNP
18637	23953	89	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23953	90	,	,	,
18637	23953	91	264	264	CD
18637	23953	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23953	93	171	171	CD
18637	23953	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23953	95	1924	1924	CD
18637	23953	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23953	97	,	,	,
18637	23953	98	1090	1090	CD
18637	23953	99	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	23953	100	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	23953	102	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	103	United	United	NNP
18637	23953	104	States	States	NNP
18637	23953	105	,	,	,
18637	23953	106	137	137	CD
18637	23953	107	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23953	108	202	202	CD
18637	23953	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23953	110	1890	1890	CD
18637	23953	111	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23953	112	,	,	,
18637	23953	113	610	610	CD
18637	23953	114	,	,	,
18637	23953	115	619	619	CD
18637	23953	116	,	,	,
18637	23953	117	881	881	CD
18637	23953	118	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	23953	119	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	120	v.	v.	IN
18637	23953	121	_	_	NNP
18637	23953	122	Van	Van	NNP
18637	23953	123	Zandt	Zandt	NNP
18637	23953	124	,	,	,
18637	23953	125	5	5	CD
18637	23953	126	How	how	WRB
18637	23953	127	.	.	.
18637	23954	1	215	215	CD
18637	23954	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23954	3	1847	1847	CD
18637	23954	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23954	5	,	,	,
18637	23954	6	696	696	CD
18637	23954	7	Jordan	Jordan	NNP
18637	23954	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23954	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23954	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23954	11	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	23954	12	,	,	,
18637	23954	13	225	225	CD
18637	23954	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23954	15	167	167	CD
18637	23954	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23954	17	1912	1912	CD
18637	23954	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23954	19	,	,	,
18637	23954	20	1089	1089	CD
18637	23954	21	,	,	,
18637	23954	22	1096	1096	CD
18637	23954	23	,	,	,
18637	23954	24	1098	1098	CD
18637	23954	25	,	,	,
18637	23954	26	1110	1110	CD
18637	23954	27	,	,	,
18637	23954	28	1131	1131	CD
18637	23954	29	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
18637	23954	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23954	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23954	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23954	33	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	23954	34	&	&	CC
18637	23954	35	Weekes	Weekes	NNP
18637	23954	36	Stevedoring	Stevedoring	NNP
18637	23954	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23954	38	,	,	,
18637	23954	39	330	330	CD
18637	23954	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23954	41	422	422	CD
18637	23954	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23954	43	1947	1947	CD
18637	23954	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23954	45	,	,	,
18637	23954	46	206	206	CD
18637	23954	47	Joslin	Joslin	NNP
18637	23954	48	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23954	49	.	.	.
18637	23955	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23955	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23955	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23955	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23955	5	Providence	Providence	NNP
18637	23955	6	,	,	,
18637	23955	7	262	262	CD
18637	23955	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23955	9	668	668	CD
18637	23955	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23955	11	1923	1923	CD
18637	23955	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23955	13	,	,	,
18637	23955	14	1064	1064	CD
18637	23955	15	,	,	,
18637	23955	16	1067	1067	CD
18637	23955	17	,	,	,
18637	23955	18	1069	1069	CD
18637	23955	19	Jourdan	Jourdan	NNP
18637	23955	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23955	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	23955	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23955	23	Barrett	Barrett	NNP
18637	23955	24	,	,	,
18637	23955	25	4	4	CD
18637	23955	26	How	how	WRB
18637	23955	27	.	.	.
18637	23956	1	169	169	CD
18637	23956	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23956	3	1846	1846	CD
18637	23956	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23956	5	,	,	,
18637	23956	6	702	702	CD
18637	23956	7	Joy	Joy	NNP
18637	23956	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23956	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23956	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23956	11	St.	St.	NNP
18637	23956	12	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	23956	13	,	,	,
18637	23956	14	201	201	CD
18637	23956	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23956	16	332	332	CD
18637	23956	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23956	18	1906	1906	CD
18637	23956	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23956	20	,	,	,
18637	23956	21	700	700	CD
18637	23956	22	Juilliard	Juilliard	NNP
18637	23956	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23956	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23956	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23956	26	Greenman	Greenman	NNP
18637	23956	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23956	28	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	23956	29	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	23956	30	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	23956	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23956	32	,	,	,
18637	23956	33	12	12	CD
18637	23956	34	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23956	35	.	.	.
18637	23957	1	457	457	CD
18637	23957	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23957	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	23957	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23957	5	,	,	,
18637	23957	6	118	118	CD
18637	23957	7	,	,	,
18637	23957	8	267	267	CD
18637	23957	9	,	,	,
18637	23957	10	310	310	CD
18637	23957	11	,	,	,
18637	23957	12	362	362	CD
18637	23957	13	,	,	,
18637	23957	14	563	563	CD
18637	23957	15	Juilliard	Juilliard	NNP
18637	23957	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23957	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23957	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23957	19	Greenman	Greenman	NNP
18637	23957	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23957	21	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	23957	22	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	23957	23	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	23957	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23957	25	,	,	,
18637	23957	26	110	110	CD
18637	23957	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23957	28	421	421	CD
18637	23957	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23957	30	1884	1884	CD
18637	23957	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23957	32	,	,	,
18637	23957	33	73	73	CD
18637	23957	34	,	,	,
18637	23957	35	166	166	CD
18637	23957	36	,	,	,
18637	23957	37	266	266	CD
18637	23957	38	,	,	,
18637	23957	39	310	310	CD
18637	23957	40	Julian	Julian	NNP
18637	23957	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23957	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	23957	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23957	44	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23957	45	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23957	46	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23957	47	,	,	,
18637	23957	48	193	193	CD
18637	23957	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23957	50	93	93	CD
18637	23957	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23957	52	1904	1904	CD
18637	23957	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23957	54	,	,	,
18637	23957	55	628	628	CD
18637	23957	56	,	,	,
18637	23957	57	629	629	CD
18637	23957	58	Jurney	Jurney	NNP
18637	23957	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23957	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23957	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23957	62	MacCracken	MacCracken	NNP
18637	23957	63	,	,	,
18637	23957	64	294	294	CD
18637	23957	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23957	66	125	125	CD
18637	23957	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23957	68	1935	1935	CD
18637	23957	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23957	70	,	,	,
18637	23957	71	85	85	CD
18637	23957	72	,	,	,
18637	23957	73	86	86	CD
18637	23957	74	Just	just	RB
18637	23957	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23957	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	23957	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23957	78	Chambers	Chambers	NNP
18637	23957	79	,	,	,
18637	23957	80	312	312	CD
18637	23957	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23957	82	383	383	CD
18637	23957	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23957	84	1941	1941	CD
18637	23957	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23957	86	,	,	,
18637	23957	87	575	575	CD
18637	23957	88	,	,	,
18637	23957	89	579	579	CD
18637	23957	90	Justices	justice	NNS
18637	23957	91	of	of	IN
18637	23957	92	the	the	DT
18637	23957	93	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	23957	94	Court	Court	NNP
18637	23957	95	_	_	NNP
18637	23957	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	23957	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23957	98	United	United	NNP
18637	23957	99	States	States	NNP
18637	23957	100	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23957	101	rel	rel	NN
18637	23957	102	.	.	.
18637	23958	1	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	23958	2	,	,	,
18637	23958	3	9	9	CD
18637	23958	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23958	5	.	.	.
18637	23959	1	274	274	CD
18637	23959	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23959	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	23959	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23959	5	,	,	,
18637	23959	6	892	892	CD
18637	23959	7	,	,	,
18637	23959	8	893	893	CD
18637	23959	9	,	,	,
18637	23959	10	897	897	CD
18637	23959	11	K	K	NNP
18637	23959	12	Kahn	Kahn	NNP
18637	23959	13	_	_	NNP
18637	23959	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	23959	15	_	_	NNP
18637	23959	16	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	23959	17	255	255	CD
18637	23959	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23959	19	1	1	CD
18637	23959	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23959	21	1921	1921	CD
18637	23959	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23959	23	,	,	,
18637	23959	24	847	847	CD
18637	23959	25	Kalb	Kalb	NNP
18637	23959	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23959	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23959	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23959	29	Feuerstein	Feuerstein	NNP
18637	23959	30	,	,	,
18637	23959	31	308	308	CD
18637	23959	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23959	33	433	433	CD
18637	23959	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23959	35	1940	1940	CD
18637	23959	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23959	37	,	,	,
18637	23959	38	265	265	CD
18637	23959	39	Kalem	Kalem	NNP
18637	23959	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23959	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23959	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	23959	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23959	44	Harper	Harper	NNP
18637	23959	45	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	23959	46	,	,	,
18637	23959	47	222	222	CD
18637	23959	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23959	49	55	55	CD
18637	23959	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23959	51	1911	1911	CD
18637	23959	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23959	53	,	,	,
18637	23959	54	275	275	CD
18637	23959	55	Kane	Kane	NNP
18637	23959	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23959	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	23959	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23959	59	New	New	NNP
18637	23959	60	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	23959	61	,	,	,
18637	23959	62	242	242	CD
18637	23959	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23959	64	160	160	CD
18637	23959	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23959	66	1916	1916	CD
18637	23959	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23959	68	,	,	,
18637	23959	69	212	212	CD
18637	23959	70	,	,	,
18637	23959	71	227	227	CD
18637	23959	72	,	,	,
18637	23959	73	661	661	CD
18637	23959	74	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23959	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23959	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	23959	77	_	_	NNP
18637	23959	78	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	23959	79	,	,	,
18637	23959	80	206	206	CD
18637	23959	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23959	82	46	46	CD
18637	23959	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23959	84	1907	1907	CD
18637	23959	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23959	86	,	,	,
18637	23959	87	71	71	CD
18637	23959	88	,	,	,
18637	23959	89	73	73	CD
18637	23959	90	,	,	,
18637	23959	91	379	379	CD
18637	23959	92	,	,	,
18637	23959	93	592	592	CD
18637	23959	94	,	,	,
18637	23959	95	593	593	CD
18637	23959	96	,	,	,
18637	23959	97	920	920	CD
18637	23959	98	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23959	99	_	_	NNP
18637	23959	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	23959	101	_	_	NNP
18637	23959	102	United	United	NNP
18637	23959	103	States	States	NNP
18637	23959	104	,	,	,
18637	23959	105	204	204	CD
18637	23959	106	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23959	107	331	331	CD
18637	23959	108	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23959	109	1907	1907	CD
18637	23959	110	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23959	111	,	,	,
18637	23959	112	587	587	CD
18637	23959	113	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23959	114	City	City	NNP
18637	23959	115	,	,	,
18637	23959	116	M.	M.	NNP
18637	23959	117	&	&	CC
18637	23959	118	B.R.	B.R.	NNP
18637	23960	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23960	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23960	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23960	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23960	5	Stiles	Stiles	NNP
18637	23960	6	,	,	,
18637	23960	7	242	242	CD
18637	23960	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23960	9	111	111	CD
18637	23960	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23960	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	23960	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23960	13	,	,	,
18637	23960	14	197	197	CD
18637	23960	15	,	,	,
18637	23960	16	1051	1051	CD
18637	23960	17	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23960	18	City	City	NNP
18637	23960	19	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	23960	20	.	.	.
18637	23961	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23961	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23961	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23961	4	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23961	5	,	,	,
18637	23961	6	240	240	CD
18637	23961	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23961	8	227	227	CD
18637	23961	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23961	10	1916	1916	CD
18637	23961	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23961	12	,	,	,
18637	23961	13	197	197	CD
18637	23961	14	,	,	,
18637	23961	15	1051	1051	CD
18637	23961	16	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23961	17	City	City	NNP
18637	23961	18	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	23961	19	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23961	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23961	21	_	_	NNP
18637	23961	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	23961	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23961	24	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	23961	25	,	,	,
18637	23961	26	233	233	CD
18637	23961	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23961	28	325	325	CD
18637	23961	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23961	30	1914	1914	CD
18637	23961	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23961	32	,	,	,
18637	23961	33	1015	1015	CD
18637	23961	34	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23961	35	City	City	NNP
18637	23961	36	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	23961	37	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23961	38	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23961	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23961	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23961	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23961	42	Kaw	Kaw	NNP
18637	23961	43	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	23961	44	Drainage	Drainage	NNP
18637	23961	45	District	District	NNP
18637	23961	46	,	,	,
18637	23961	47	233	233	CD
18637	23961	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23961	49	75	75	CD
18637	23961	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23961	51	1914	1914	CD
18637	23961	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23961	53	,	,	,
18637	23961	54	219	219	CD
18637	23961	55	,	,	,
18637	23961	56	224	224	CD
18637	23961	57	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23961	58	City	City	NNP
18637	23961	59	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	23961	60	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23961	61	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23961	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23961	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	23961	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23961	65	Road	Road	NNP
18637	23961	66	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	23961	67	.	.	.
18637	23962	1	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	23962	2	.	.	.
18637	23962	3	,	,	,
18637	23962	4	256	256	CD
18637	23962	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23962	6	658	658	CD
18637	23962	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23962	8	1921	1921	CD
18637	23962	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23962	10	,	,	,
18637	23962	11	1153	1153	CD
18637	23962	12	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23962	13	City	City	NNP
18637	23962	14	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	23962	15	R.	R.	NNP
18637	23962	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23962	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23962	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23962	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23962	20	Road	Road	NNP
18637	23962	21	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	23962	22	.	.	.
18637	23963	1	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	23963	2	.	.	.
18637	23963	3	,	,	,
18637	23963	4	266	266	CD
18637	23963	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23963	6	379	379	CD
18637	23963	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23963	8	1924	1924	CD
18637	23963	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23963	10	,	,	,
18637	23963	11	1041	1041	CD
18637	23963	12	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23963	13	City	City	NNP
18637	23963	14	Structural	Structural	NNP
18637	23963	15	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	23963	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23963	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23963	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23963	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23963	20	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	23963	21	,	,	,
18637	23963	22	269	269	CD
18637	23963	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23963	24	148	148	CD
18637	23963	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23963	26	1925	1925	CD
18637	23963	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23963	28	,	,	,
18637	23963	29	121	121	CD
18637	23963	30	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	23963	31	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	23963	32	,	,	,
18637	23963	33	The	the	DT
18637	23963	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23963	35	Blue	Blue	NNP
18637	23963	36	Jacket	Jacket	NNP
18637	23963	37	_	_	NNP
18637	23963	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	23963	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23963	40	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23963	41	County	County	NNP
18637	23963	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23963	43	,	,	,
18637	23963	44	5	5	CD
18637	23963	45	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23963	46	.	.	.
18637	23964	1	737	737	CD
18637	23964	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23964	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	23964	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23964	5	,	,	,
18637	23964	6	432	432	CD
18637	23964	7	,	,	,
18637	23964	8	735	735	CD
18637	23964	9	Karem	Karem	NNP
18637	23964	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23964	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23964	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23964	13	United	United	NNP
18637	23964	14	States	States	NNP
18637	23964	15	,	,	,
18637	23964	16	121	121	CD
18637	23964	17	F.	f.	NN
18637	23964	18	250	250	CD
18637	23964	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23964	20	1903	1903	CD
18637	23964	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23964	22	,	,	,
18637	23964	23	1186	1186	CD
18637	23964	24	Kauffman	Kauffman	NNP
18637	23964	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23964	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	23964	27	_	_	NNP
18637	23964	28	Wooters	Wooters	NNP
18637	23964	29	,	,	,
18637	23964	30	138	138	CD
18637	23964	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23964	32	285	285	CD
18637	23964	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23964	34	1891	1891	CD
18637	23964	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23964	36	,	,	,
18637	23964	37	1090	1090	CD
18637	23964	38	Kaukauna	Kaukauna	NNP
18637	23964	39	Water	Water	NNP
18637	23964	40	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23964	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23964	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23964	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23964	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23964	45	Green	Green	NNP
18637	23964	46	Bay	Bay	NNP
18637	23964	47	&	&	CC
18637	23964	48	M.	M.	NNP
18637	23964	49	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	23964	50	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23964	51	,	,	,
18637	23964	52	142	142	CD
18637	23964	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23964	54	254	254	CD
18637	23964	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23964	56	1891	1891	CD
18637	23964	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23964	58	,	,	,
18637	23964	59	131	131	CD
18637	23964	60	Kawakita	Kawakita	NNP
18637	23964	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23964	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	23964	63	_	_	NNP
18637	23964	64	United	United	NNP
18637	23964	65	States	States	NNP
18637	23964	66	,	,	,
18637	23964	67	343	343	CD
18637	23964	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23964	69	717	717	CD
18637	23964	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23964	71	1952	1952	CD
18637	23964	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23964	73	,	,	,
18637	23964	74	642	642	CD
18637	23964	75	,	,	,
18637	23964	76	643	643	CD
18637	23964	77	Kawananakoa	Kawananakoa	NNP
18637	23964	78	_	_	NNP
18637	23964	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	23964	80	_	_	NNP
18637	23964	81	Polyblank	Polyblank	NNP
18637	23964	82	,	,	,
18637	23964	83	205	205	CD
18637	23964	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23964	85	349	349	CD
18637	23964	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23964	87	1907	1907	CD
18637	23964	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23964	89	,	,	,
18637	23964	90	586	586	CD
18637	23964	91	Kay	Kay	NNP
18637	23964	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23964	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	23964	94	_	_	NNP
18637	23964	95	United	United	NNP
18637	23964	96	States	States	NNP
18637	23964	97	,	,	,
18637	23964	98	303	303	CD
18637	23964	99	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23964	100	1	1	CD
18637	23964	101	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23964	102	1938	1938	CD
18637	23964	103	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23964	104	,	,	,
18637	23964	105	883	883	CD
18637	23964	106	Kearney	Kearney	NNP
18637	23964	107	,	,	,
18637	23964	108	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23964	109	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23964	110	,	,	,
18637	23964	111	7	7	CD
18637	23964	112	Wheat	Wheat	NNP
18637	23964	113	.	.	.
18637	23965	1	38	38	CD
18637	23965	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23965	3	1822	1822	CD
18637	23965	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23965	5	,	,	,
18637	23965	6	314	314	CD
18637	23965	7	Keefe	Keefe	NNP
18637	23965	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23965	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	11	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	23965	12	,	,	,
18637	23965	13	322	322	CD
18637	23965	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23965	15	393	393	CD
18637	23965	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23965	17	1944	1944	CD
18637	23965	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23965	19	,	,	,
18637	23965	20	349	349	CD
18637	23965	21	Keeney	Keeney	NNP
18637	23965	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23965	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	25	New	New	NNP
18637	23965	26	York	York	NNP
18637	23965	27	,	,	,
18637	23965	28	222	222	CD
18637	23965	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23965	30	525	525	CD
18637	23965	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23965	32	1912	1912	CD
18637	23965	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23965	34	,	,	,
18637	23965	35	1037	1037	CD
18637	23965	36	,	,	,
18637	23965	37	1149	1149	CD
18637	23965	38	Keerl	Keerl	NNP
18637	23965	39	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	23965	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	42	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	23965	43	,	,	,
18637	23965	44	213	213	CD
18637	23965	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23965	46	135	135	CD
18637	23965	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23965	48	1909	1909	CD
18637	23965	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23965	50	,	,	,
18637	23965	51	1135	1135	CD
18637	23965	52	Kehrer	Kehrer	NNP
18637	23965	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	23965	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	56	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	23965	57	,	,	,
18637	23965	58	197	197	CD
18637	23965	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23965	60	60	60	CD
18637	23965	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23965	62	1905	1905	CD
18637	23965	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23965	64	,	,	,
18637	23965	65	184	184	CD
18637	23965	66	Keifer	Keifer	NNP
18637	23965	67	&	&	CC
18637	23965	68	Keifer	Keifer	NNP
18637	23965	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	23965	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	72	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
18637	23965	73	Finance	Finance	NNP
18637	23965	74	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23965	75	&	&	CC
18637	23965	76	Regional	Regional	NNP
18637	23965	77	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	23965	78	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	23965	79	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23965	80	,	,	,
18637	23965	81	306	306	CD
18637	23965	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23965	83	381	381	CD
18637	23965	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23965	85	1939	1939	CD
18637	23965	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23965	87	,	,	,
18637	23965	88	590	590	CD
18637	23965	89	Keim	Keim	NNP
18637	23965	90	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	91	v.	v.	IN
18637	23965	92	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	93	United	United	NNP
18637	23965	94	States	States	NNP
18637	23965	95	,	,	,
18637	23965	96	177	177	CD
18637	23965	97	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23965	98	290	290	CD
18637	23965	99	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23965	100	1900	1900	CD
18637	23965	101	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23965	102	,	,	,
18637	23965	103	546	546	CD
18637	23965	104	Keith	Keith	NNP
18637	23965	105	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	106	v.	v.	IN
18637	23965	107	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	108	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	23965	109	,	,	,
18637	23965	110	97	97	CD
18637	23965	111	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23965	112	454	454	CD
18637	23965	113	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23965	114	1878	1878	CD
18637	23965	115	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23965	116	,	,	,
18637	23965	117	728	728	CD
18637	23965	118	Keller	Keller	NNP
18637	23965	119	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	120	v.	v.	IN
18637	23965	121	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	122	Potomac	Potomac	NNP
18637	23965	123	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	23965	124	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23965	125	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23965	126	,	,	,
18637	23965	127	261	261	CD
18637	23965	128	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23965	129	428	428	CD
18637	23965	130	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23965	131	1923	1923	CD
18637	23965	132	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23965	133	,	,	,
18637	23965	134	304	304	CD
18637	23965	135	,	,	,
18637	23965	136	535	535	CD
18637	23965	137	,	,	,
18637	23965	138	536	536	CD
18637	23965	139	,	,	,
18637	23965	140	537	537	CD
18637	23965	141	,	,	,
18637	23965	142	623	623	CD
18637	23965	143	Keller	Keller	NNP
18637	23965	144	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	145	v.	v.	IN
18637	23965	146	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	147	United	United	NNP
18637	23965	148	States	States	NNP
18637	23965	149	,	,	,
18637	23965	150	213	213	CD
18637	23965	151	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23965	152	138	138	CD
18637	23965	153	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23965	154	1909	1909	CD
18637	23965	155	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23965	156	,	,	,
18637	23965	157	122	122	CD
18637	23965	158	,	,	,
18637	23965	159	261	261	CD
18637	23965	160	,	,	,
18637	23965	161	917	917	CD
18637	23965	162	Kelley	Kelley	NNP
18637	23965	163	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	164	v.	v.	IN
18637	23965	165	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	166	Rhoads	Rhoads	NNP
18637	23965	167	,	,	,
18637	23965	168	188	188	CD
18637	23965	169	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23965	170	1	1	CD
18637	23965	171	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23965	172	1903	1903	CD
18637	23965	173	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23965	174	,	,	,
18637	23965	175	120	120	CD
18637	23965	176	,	,	,
18637	23965	177	186	186	CD
18637	23965	178	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
18637	23965	179	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	180	v.	v.	IN
18637	23965	181	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	182	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	23965	183	,	,	,
18637	23965	184	104	104	CD
18637	23965	185	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23965	186	78	78	CD
18637	23965	187	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23965	188	1881	1881	CD
18637	23965	189	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23965	190	,	,	,
18637	23965	191	1037	1037	CD
18637	23965	192	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
18637	23965	193	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	194	v.	v.	IN
18637	23965	195	_	_	NNP
18637	23965	196	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	23965	197	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23965	198	rel	rel	NN
18637	23965	199	.	.	.
18637	23966	1	Foss	Foss	NNP
18637	23966	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23966	3	,	,	,
18637	23966	4	302	302	CD
18637	23966	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23966	6	1	1	CD
18637	23966	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23966	8	1937	1937	CD
18637	23966	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23966	10	,	,	,
18637	23966	11	223	223	CD
18637	23966	12	,	,	,
18637	23966	13	230	230	CD
18637	23966	14	,	,	,
18637	23966	15	251	251	CD
18637	23966	16	Kemmler	Kemmler	NNP
18637	23966	17	,	,	,
18637	23966	18	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23966	19	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23966	20	,	,	,
18637	23966	21	136	136	CD
18637	23966	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23966	23	436	436	CD
18637	23966	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23966	25	1890	1890	CD
18637	23966	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23966	27	,	,	,
18637	23966	28	971	971	CD
18637	23966	29	,	,	,
18637	23966	30	1134	1134	CD
18637	23966	31	Kendall	Kendall	NNP
18637	23966	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23966	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	23966	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23966	35	United	United	NNP
18637	23966	36	States	States	NNP
18637	23966	37	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23966	38	rel	rel	NN
18637	23966	39	.	.	.
18637	23967	1	Stokes	stoke	NNS
18637	23967	2	,	,	,
18637	23967	3	12	12	CD
18637	23967	4	Pet	pet	NN
18637	23967	5	.	.	.
18637	23968	1	524	524	CD
18637	23968	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23968	3	1838	1838	CD
18637	23968	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23968	5	,	,	,
18637	23968	6	303	303	CD
18637	23968	7	,	,	,
18637	23968	8	479	479	CD
18637	23968	9	,	,	,
18637	23968	10	501	501	CD
18637	23968	11	,	,	,
18637	23968	12	522	522	CD
18637	23968	13	,	,	,
18637	23968	14	546	546	CD
18637	23968	15	Kendall	Kendall	NNP
18637	23968	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23968	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23968	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23968	19	Winsor	Winsor	NNP
18637	23968	20	,	,	,
18637	23968	21	21	21	CD
18637	23968	22	How	how	WRB
18637	23968	23	.	.	.
18637	23969	1	322	322	CD
18637	23969	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23969	3	1859	1859	CD
18637	23969	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23969	5	,	,	,
18637	23969	6	271	271	CD
18637	23969	7	Kennecott	Kennecott	NNP
18637	23969	8	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	23969	9	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23969	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23969	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23969	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23969	13	State	State	NNP
18637	23969	14	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23969	15	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23969	16	,	,	,
18637	23969	17	327	327	CD
18637	23969	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23969	19	573	573	CD
18637	23969	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23969	21	1946	1946	CD
18637	23969	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23969	23	,	,	,
18637	23969	24	932	932	CD
18637	23969	25	,	,	,
18637	23969	26	935	935	CD
18637	23969	27	,	,	,
18637	23969	28	936	936	CD
18637	23969	29	Kennedy	Kennedy	NNP
18637	23969	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23969	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23969	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23969	33	Becker	Becker	NNP
18637	23969	34	,	,	,
18637	23969	35	241	241	CD
18637	23969	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23969	37	556	556	CD
18637	23969	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23969	39	1916	1916	CD
18637	23969	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23969	41	,	,	,
18637	23969	42	701	701	CD
18637	23969	43	Kenney	Kenney	NNP
18637	23969	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23969	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	23969	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23969	47	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	23969	48	Lodge	Lodge	NNP
18637	23969	49	,	,	,
18637	23969	50	252	252	CD
18637	23969	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23969	52	411	411	CD
18637	23969	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23969	54	1920	1920	CD
18637	23969	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23969	56	,	,	,
18637	23969	57	657	657	CD
18637	23969	58	Kennon	Kennon	NNP
18637	23969	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23969	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23969	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23969	62	Gilmer	Gilmer	NNP
18637	23969	63	,	,	,
18637	23969	64	131	131	CD
18637	23969	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23969	66	22	22	CD
18637	23969	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23969	68	1889	1889	CD
18637	23969	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23969	70	,	,	,
18637	23969	71	893	893	CD
18637	23969	72	Kenosha	Kenosha	NNP
18637	23969	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23969	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	23969	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23969	76	Lamson	Lamson	NNP
18637	23969	77	,	,	,
18637	23969	78	9	9	CD
18637	23969	79	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23969	80	.	.	.
18637	23970	1	477	477	CD
18637	23970	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23970	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	23970	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23970	5	,	,	,
18637	23970	6	331	331	CD
18637	23970	7	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23970	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23970	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23970	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23970	11	Dennison	Dennison	NNP
18637	23970	12	,	,	,
18637	23970	13	24	24	CD
18637	23970	14	How	how	WRB
18637	23970	15	.	.	.
18637	23971	1	66	66	CD
18637	23971	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23971	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	23971	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23971	5	,	,	,
18637	23971	6	512	512	CD
18637	23971	7	,	,	,
18637	23971	8	612	612	CD
18637	23971	9	,	,	,
18637	23971	10	694	694	CD
18637	23971	11	,	,	,
18637	23971	12	695	695	CD
18637	23971	13	,	,	,
18637	23971	14	738	738	CD
18637	23971	15	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23971	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23971	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23971	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23971	19	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	23971	20	,	,	,
18637	23971	21	281	281	CD
18637	23971	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23971	23	163	163	CD
18637	23971	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23971	25	1930	1930	CD
18637	23971	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23971	27	,	,	,
18637	23971	28	593	593	CD
18637	23971	29	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23971	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23971	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23971	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23971	33	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	23971	34	,	,	,
18637	23971	35	201	201	CD
18637	23971	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23971	37	1	1	CD
18637	23971	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23971	39	1906	1906	CD
18637	23971	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23971	41	,	,	,
18637	23971	42	620	620	CD
18637	23971	43	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23971	44	Finance	Finance	NNP
18637	23971	45	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23971	46	_	_	NNP
18637	23971	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	23971	48	_	_	NNP
18637	23971	49	Paramount	Paramount	NNP
18637	23971	50	Auto	Auto	NNP
18637	23971	51	Exch	Exch	NNP
18637	23971	52	.	.	.
18637	23972	1	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23972	2	,	,	,
18637	23972	3	262	262	CD
18637	23972	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23972	5	544	544	CD
18637	23972	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23972	7	1923	1923	CD
18637	23972	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23972	9	,	,	,
18637	23972	10	981	981	CD
18637	23972	11	,	,	,
18637	23972	12	1144	1144	CD
18637	23972	13	,	,	,
18637	23972	14	1167	1167	CD
18637	23972	15	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23972	16	Union	Union	NNP
18637	23972	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23972	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23972	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23972	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23972	21	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23972	22	,	,	,
18637	23972	23	219	219	CD
18637	23972	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23972	25	140	140	CD
18637	23972	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23972	27	1911	1911	CD
18637	23972	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23972	29	,	,	,
18637	23972	30	327	327	CD
18637	23972	31	,	,	,
18637	23972	32	1092	1092	CD
18637	23972	33	,	,	,
18637	23972	34	1152	1152	CD
18637	23972	35	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	23972	36	Whip	Whip	NNP
18637	23972	37	&	&	CC
18637	23972	38	Collar	Collar	NNP
18637	23972	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23972	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23972	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23972	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23972	43	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23972	44	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	23973	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23973	2	,	,	,
18637	23973	3	299	299	CD
18637	23973	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23973	5	334	334	CD
18637	23973	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23973	7	1937	1937	CD
18637	23973	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23973	9	,	,	,
18637	23973	10	172	172	CD
18637	23973	11	,	,	,
18637	23973	12	219	219	CD
18637	23973	13	,	,	,
18637	23973	14	859	859	CD
18637	23973	15	,	,	,
18637	23973	16	919	919	CD
18637	23973	17	Kenward	Kenward	NNP
18637	23973	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23973	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23973	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23973	21	"	"	``
18637	23973	22	Admiral	Admiral	NNP
18637	23973	23	Peoples	Peoples	NNPS
18637	23973	24	,	,	,
18637	23973	25	"	"	''
18637	23973	26	The	the	DT
18637	23973	27	.	.	.
18637	23974	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23974	2	See	See	NNP
18637	23974	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23974	4	"	"	``
18637	23974	5	Admiral	Admiral	NNP
18637	23974	6	Peoples	Peoples	NNPS
18637	23974	7	,	,	,
18637	23974	8	"	"	''
18637	23974	9	The	the	DT
18637	23974	10	.	.	.
18637	23975	1	Keokee	Keokee	NNP
18637	23975	2	Consol	Consol	NNP
18637	23975	3	.	.	.
18637	23976	1	Coke	Coke	NNP
18637	23976	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23976	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23976	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	23976	5	_	_	NNP
18637	23976	6	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	23976	7	,	,	,
18637	23976	8	234	234	CD
18637	23976	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23976	10	224	224	CD
18637	23976	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23976	12	1914	1914	CD
18637	23976	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23976	14	,	,	,
18637	23976	15	987	987	CD
18637	23976	16	,	,	,
18637	23976	17	1158	1158	CD
18637	23976	18	Keokuk	Keokuk	NNP
18637	23976	19	&	&	CC
18637	23976	20	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	23976	21	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	23976	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23976	23	_	_	NNP
18637	23976	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	23976	25	_	_	NNP
18637	23976	26	United	United	NNP
18637	23976	27	States	States	NNP
18637	23976	28	,	,	,
18637	23976	29	260	260	CD
18637	23976	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23976	31	125	125	CD
18637	23976	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23976	33	1922	1922	CD
18637	23976	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23976	35	,	,	,
18637	23976	36	586	586	CD
18637	23976	37	Keokuk	Keokuk	NNP
18637	23976	38	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	23976	39	Line	Line	NNP
18637	23976	40	Packet	Packet	NNP
18637	23976	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23976	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23976	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23976	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23976	45	Keokuk	Keokuk	NNP
18637	23976	46	,	,	,
18637	23976	47	95	95	CD
18637	23976	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23976	49	80	80	CD
18637	23976	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23976	51	1877	1877	CD
18637	23976	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23976	53	,	,	,
18637	23976	54	366	366	CD
18637	23976	55	Kepner	Kepner	NNP
18637	23976	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23976	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	23976	58	_	_	NNP
18637	23976	59	United	United	NNP
18637	23976	60	States	States	NNP
18637	23976	61	,	,	,
18637	23976	62	195	195	CD
18637	23976	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23976	64	100	100	CD
18637	23976	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23976	66	1904	1904	CD
18637	23976	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23976	68	,	,	,
18637	23976	69	839	839	CD
18637	23976	70	Ker	Ker	NNP
18637	23976	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23976	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	23976	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23976	74	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	23976	75	,	,	,
18637	23976	76	119	119	CD
18637	23976	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23976	78	436	436	CD
18637	23976	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23976	80	1886	1886	CD
18637	23976	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23976	82	,	,	,
18637	23976	83	696	696	CD
18637	23976	84	Kerr	Kerr	NNP
18637	23976	85	_	_	NNP
18637	23976	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	23976	87	_	_	NNP
18637	23976	88	Devisees	Devisees	NNPS
18637	23976	89	of	of	IN
18637	23976	90	Moon	Moon	NNP
18637	23976	91	,	,	,
18637	23976	92	9	9	CD
18637	23976	93	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	23976	94	.	.	.
18637	23977	1	565	565	CD
18637	23977	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23977	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	23977	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23977	5	,	,	,
18637	23977	6	673	673	CD
18637	23977	7	Kersh	Kersh	NNP
18637	23977	8	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	23977	9	Drainage	Drainage	NNP
18637	23977	10	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	23977	11	.	.	.
18637	23978	1	_	_	NNP
18637	23978	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	23978	3	_	_	NNP
18637	23978	4	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	23978	5	,	,	,
18637	23978	6	309	309	CD
18637	23978	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23978	8	485	485	CD
18637	23978	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23978	10	1940	1940	CD
18637	23978	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23978	12	,	,	,
18637	23978	13	656	656	CD
18637	23978	14	Keystone	Keystone	NNP
18637	23978	15	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	23978	16	.	.	.
18637	23979	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23979	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23979	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	5	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	23979	6	,	,	,
18637	23979	7	151	151	CD
18637	23979	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23979	9	139	139	CD
18637	23979	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23979	11	1894	1894	CD
18637	23979	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23979	13	,	,	,
18637	23979	14	272	272	CD
18637	23979	15	Kidd	Kidd	NNP
18637	23979	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	23979	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	19	Pearson	Pearson	NNP
18637	23979	20	,	,	,
18637	23979	21	128	128	CD
18637	23979	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23979	23	1	1	CD
18637	23979	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23979	25	1888	1888	CD
18637	23979	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23979	27	,	,	,
18637	23979	28	120	120	CD
18637	23979	29	,	,	,
18637	23979	30	122	122	CD
18637	23979	31	,	,	,
18637	23979	32	239	239	CD
18637	23979	33	,	,	,
18637	23979	34	1032	1032	CD
18637	23979	35	Kidd	Kidd	NNP
18637	23979	36	,	,	,
18637	23979	37	D.	D.	NNP
18637	23979	38	&	&	CC
18637	23979	39	P.	P.	NNP
18637	23979	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23979	41	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	23979	43	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	44	Musselman	Musselman	NNP
18637	23979	45	Grocer	Grocer	NNP
18637	23979	46	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23979	47	,	,	,
18637	23979	48	217	217	CD
18637	23979	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23979	50	461	461	CD
18637	23979	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23979	52	1910	1910	CD
18637	23979	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23979	54	,	,	,
18637	23979	55	1018	1018	CD
18637	23979	56	Kiernan	Kiernan	NNP
18637	23979	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	23979	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	60	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	23979	61	,	,	,
18637	23979	62	223	223	CD
18637	23979	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23979	64	151	151	CD
18637	23979	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23979	66	1912	1912	CD
18637	23979	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23979	68	,	,	,
18637	23979	69	705	705	CD
18637	23979	70	Kilbourn	Kilbourn	NNP
18637	23979	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	23979	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	74	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	23979	75	,	,	,
18637	23979	76	103	103	CD
18637	23979	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23979	78	168	168	CD
18637	23979	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23979	80	1881	1881	CD
18637	23979	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23979	82	,	,	,
18637	23979	83	83	83	CD
18637	23979	84	,	,	,
18637	23979	85	84	84	CD
18637	23979	86	,	,	,
18637	23979	87	85	85	CD
18637	23979	88	,	,	,
18637	23979	89	99	99	CD
18637	23979	90	,	,	,
18637	23979	91	100	100	CD
18637	23979	92	Killian	Killian	NNP
18637	23979	93	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	94	v.	v.	IN
18637	23979	95	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	96	Ebbinghaus	Ebbinghaus	NNP
18637	23979	97	,	,	,
18637	23979	98	110	110	CD
18637	23979	99	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23979	100	568	568	CD
18637	23979	101	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23979	102	1884	1884	CD
18637	23979	103	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23979	104	,	,	,
18637	23979	105	895	895	CD
18637	23979	106	Kimball	Kimball	NNP
18637	23979	107	Laundry	Laundry	NNP
18637	23979	108	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23979	109	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	110	v.	v.	IN
18637	23979	111	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	112	United	United	NNP
18637	23979	113	States	States	NNP
18637	23979	114	,	,	,
18637	23979	115	338	338	CD
18637	23979	116	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23979	117	1	1	CD
18637	23979	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23979	119	1949	1949	CD
18637	23979	120	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23979	121	,	,	,
18637	23979	122	298	298	CD
18637	23979	123	,	,	,
18637	23979	124	870	870	CD
18637	23979	125	,	,	,
18637	23979	126	871	871	CD
18637	23979	127	Kimmish	Kimmish	NNP
18637	23979	128	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	129	v.	v.	IN
18637	23979	130	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	131	Ball	Ball	NNP
18637	23979	132	,	,	,
18637	23979	133	129	129	CD
18637	23979	134	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23979	135	217	217	CD
18637	23979	136	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23979	137	1889	1889	CD
18637	23979	138	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23979	139	,	,	,
18637	23979	140	236	236	CD
18637	23979	141	King	King	NNP
18637	23979	142	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	143	v.	v.	IN
18637	23979	144	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	145	Cross	Cross	NNP
18637	23979	146	,	,	,
18637	23979	147	175	175	CD
18637	23979	148	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23979	149	396	396	CD
18637	23979	150	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23979	151	1899	1899	CD
18637	23979	152	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23979	153	,	,	,
18637	23979	154	674	674	CD
18637	23979	155	King	King	NNP
18637	23979	156	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	157	v.	v.	IN
18637	23979	158	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	159	Mullins	Mullins	NNP
18637	23979	160	,	,	,
18637	23979	161	171	171	CD
18637	23979	162	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23979	163	404	404	CD
18637	23979	164	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23979	165	1898	1898	CD
18637	23979	166	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23979	167	,	,	,
18637	23979	168	1062	1062	CD
18637	23979	169	King	King	NNP
18637	23979	170	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	171	v.	v.	IN
18637	23979	172	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	173	Order	Order	NNP
18637	23979	174	of	of	IN
18637	23979	175	United	United	NNP
18637	23979	176	Commercial	Commercial	NNP
18637	23979	177	Travelers	Travelers	NNPS
18637	23979	178	,	,	,
18637	23979	179	333	333	CD
18637	23979	180	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23979	181	153	153	CD
18637	23979	182	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23979	183	1948	1948	CD
18637	23979	184	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23979	185	,	,	,
18637	23979	186	607	607	CD
18637	23979	187	Kirby	Kirby	NNP
18637	23979	188	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	189	v.	v.	IN
18637	23979	190	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	191	United	United	NNP
18637	23979	192	States	States	NNP
18637	23979	193	,	,	,
18637	23979	194	174	174	CD
18637	23979	195	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23979	196	47	47	CD
18637	23979	197	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23979	198	1899	1899	CD
18637	23979	199	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23979	200	,	,	,
18637	23979	201	884	884	CD
18637	23979	202	Kirschbaum	Kirschbaum	NNP
18637	23979	203	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	204	v.	v.	IN
18637	23979	205	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	206	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	23979	207	,	,	,
18637	23979	208	316	316	CD
18637	23979	209	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23979	210	517	517	CD
18637	23979	211	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23979	212	1942	1942	CD
18637	23979	213	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23979	214	,	,	,
18637	23979	215	157	157	CD
18637	23979	216	Kirtland	Kirtland	NNP
18637	23979	217	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	218	v.	v.	IN
18637	23979	219	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	220	Hotchkiss	Hotchkiss	NNP
18637	23979	221	,	,	,
18637	23979	222	100	100	CD
18637	23979	223	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23979	224	491	491	CD
18637	23979	225	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23979	226	1879	1879	CD
18637	23979	227	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23979	228	,	,	,
18637	23979	229	693	693	CD
18637	23979	230	,	,	,
18637	23979	231	971	971	CD
18637	23979	232	,	,	,
18637	23979	233	1044	1044	CD
18637	23979	234	Klaxon	Klaxon	NNP
18637	23979	235	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23979	236	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	237	v.	v.	IN
18637	23979	238	_	_	NNP
18637	23979	239	Stentor	Stentor	NNP
18637	23979	240	,	,	,
18637	23979	241	313	313	CD
18637	23979	242	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23979	243	487	487	CD
18637	23979	244	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23979	245	1941	1941	CD
18637	23979	246	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23979	247	,	,	,
18637	23979	248	677	677	CD
18637	23979	249	Klein	Klein	NNP
18637	23979	250	,	,	,
18637	23979	251	In	in	IN
18637	23979	252	re	re	NN
18637	23979	253	,	,	,
18637	23979	254	1	1	CD
18637	23979	255	How	how	WRB
18637	23979	256	.	.	.
18637	23980	1	277	277	CD
18637	23980	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23980	3	1843	1843	CD
18637	23980	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23980	5	,	,	,
18637	23980	6	264	264	CD
18637	23980	7	Kline	Kline	NNP
18637	23980	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23980	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23980	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23980	11	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	23980	12	Construction	Construction	NNP
18637	23980	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23980	14	,	,	,
18637	23980	15	260	260	CD
18637	23980	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23980	17	226	226	CD
18637	23980	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23980	19	1922	1922	CD
18637	23980	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23980	21	,	,	,
18637	23980	22	512	512	CD
18637	23980	23	,	,	,
18637	23980	24	620	620	CD
18637	23980	25	,	,	,
18637	23980	26	623	623	CD
18637	23980	27	,	,	,
18637	23980	28	628	628	CD
18637	23980	29	Klinger	Klinger	NNP
18637	23980	30	_	_	NNP
18637	23980	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	23980	32	_	_	NNP
18637	23980	33	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	23980	34	,	,	,
18637	23980	35	13	13	CD
18637	23980	36	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23980	37	.	.	.
18637	23981	1	257	257	CD
18637	23981	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23981	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	23981	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23981	5	,	,	,
18637	23981	6	327	327	CD
18637	23981	7	Knapp	Knapp	NNP
18637	23981	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23981	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	11	Morss	Morss	NNP
18637	23981	12	,	,	,
18637	23981	13	150	150	CD
18637	23981	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23981	15	221	221	CD
18637	23981	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23981	17	1893	1893	CD
18637	23981	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23981	19	,	,	,
18637	23981	20	273	273	CD
18637	23981	21	Knapp	Knapp	NNP
18637	23981	22	,	,	,
18637	23981	23	Stout	Stout	NNP
18637	23981	24	&	&	CC
18637	23981	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23981	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23981	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	29	McCaffrey	McCaffrey	NNP
18637	23981	30	,	,	,
18637	23981	31	177	177	CD
18637	23981	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23981	33	638	638	CD
18637	23981	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23981	35	1900	1900	CD
18637	23981	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23981	37	,	,	,
18637	23981	38	574	574	CD
18637	23981	39	,	,	,
18637	23981	40	579	579	CD
18637	23981	41	Knauer	Knauer	NNP
18637	23981	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	23981	44	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	45	United	United	NNP
18637	23981	46	States	States	NNP
18637	23981	47	,	,	,
18637	23981	48	328	328	CD
18637	23981	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23981	50	654	654	CD
18637	23981	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23981	52	1946	1946	CD
18637	23981	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23981	54	,	,	,
18637	23981	55	257	257	CD
18637	23981	56	,	,	,
18637	23981	57	258	258	CD
18637	23981	58	Knauff	Knauff	NNP
18637	23981	59	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	23981	61	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	62	Shaughnessy	Shaughnessy	NNP
18637	23981	63	,	,	,
18637	23981	64	338	338	CD
18637	23981	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23981	66	537	537	CD
18637	23981	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23981	68	1950	1950	CD
18637	23981	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23981	70	,	,	,
18637	23981	71	260	260	CD
18637	23981	72	Kneedler	Kneedler	NNP
18637	23981	73	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	23981	75	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	76	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	23981	77	,	,	,
18637	23981	78	45	45	CD
18637	23981	79	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	23981	80	238	238	CD
18637	23981	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23981	82	1863	1863	CD
18637	23981	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23981	84	,	,	,
18637	23981	85	285	285	CD
18637	23981	86	Knickerbocker	Knickerbocker	NNP
18637	23981	87	Ice	Ice	NNP
18637	23981	88	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23981	89	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	23981	91	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	92	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	23981	93	,	,	,
18637	23981	94	253	253	CD
18637	23981	95	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23981	96	149	149	CD
18637	23981	97	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23981	98	1920	1920	CD
18637	23981	99	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23981	100	,	,	,
18637	23981	101	311	311	CD
18637	23981	102	,	,	,
18637	23981	103	580	580	CD
18637	23981	104	,	,	,
18637	23981	105	583	583	CD
18637	23981	106	Knight	Knight	NNP
18637	23981	107	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	23981	109	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	110	United	United	NNP
18637	23981	111	Land	Land	NNP
18637	23981	112	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	23981	113	.	.	.
18637	23981	114	,	,	,
18637	23981	115	142	142	CD
18637	23981	116	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23981	117	161	161	CD
18637	23981	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23981	119	1891	1891	CD
18637	23981	120	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23981	121	,	,	,
18637	23981	122	698	698	CD
18637	23981	123	Knights	Knights	NNPS
18637	23981	124	of	of	IN
18637	23981	125	Pythias	Pythias	NNP
18637	23981	126	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	127	v.	v.	IN
18637	23981	128	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	129	Meyer	Meyer	NNP
18637	23981	130	,	,	,
18637	23981	131	265	265	CD
18637	23981	132	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23981	133	30	30	CD
18637	23981	134	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23981	135	1924	1924	CD
18637	23981	136	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23981	137	,	,	,
18637	23981	138	685	685	CD
18637	23981	139	Knote	Knote	NNP
18637	23981	140	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	141	v.	v.	IN
18637	23981	142	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	143	United	United	NNP
18637	23981	144	States	States	NNP
18637	23981	145	,	,	,
18637	23981	146	95	95	CD
18637	23981	147	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23981	148	149	149	CD
18637	23981	149	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23981	150	1877	1877	CD
18637	23981	151	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23981	152	,	,	,
18637	23981	153	323	323	CD
18637	23981	154	,	,	,
18637	23981	155	324	324	CD
18637	23981	156	,	,	,
18637	23981	157	411	411	CD
18637	23981	158	,	,	,
18637	23981	159	645	645	CD
18637	23981	160	Knowlton	Knowlton	NNP
18637	23981	161	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	162	v.	v.	IN
18637	23981	163	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	164	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	23981	165	,	,	,
18637	23981	166	178	178	CD
18637	23981	167	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23981	168	41	41	CD
18637	23981	169	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23981	170	1900	1900	CD
18637	23981	171	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23981	172	,	,	,
18637	23981	173	110	110	CD
18637	23981	174	,	,	,
18637	23981	175	320	320	CD
18637	23981	176	,	,	,
18637	23981	177	1191	1191	CD
18637	23981	178	Knox	Knox	NNP
18637	23981	179	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	180	v.	v.	IN
18637	23981	181	_	_	NNP
18637	23981	182	Greenleaf	Greenleaf	NNP
18637	23981	183	,	,	,
18637	23981	184	4	4	CD
18637	23981	185	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	23981	186	.	.	.
18637	23982	1	360	360	CD
18637	23982	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23982	3	1802	1802	CD
18637	23982	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23982	5	,	,	,
18637	23982	6	601	601	CD
18637	23982	7	Knox	Knox	NNP
18637	23982	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23982	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23982	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23982	11	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	23982	12	,	,	,
18637	23982	13	12	12	CD
18637	23982	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23982	15	.	.	.
18637	23983	1	457	457	CD
18637	23983	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23983	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	23983	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23983	5	,	,	,
18637	23983	6	73	73	CD
18637	23983	7	,	,	,
18637	23983	8	266	266	CD
18637	23983	9	,	,	,
18637	23983	10	287	287	CD
18637	23983	11	,	,	,
18637	23983	12	856	856	CD
18637	23983	13	Knoxville	Knoxville	NNP
18637	23983	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	23983	16	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	17	Water	Water	NNP
18637	23983	18	Company	Company	NNP
18637	23983	19	,	,	,
18637	23983	20	212	212	CD
18637	23983	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23983	22	1	1	CD
18637	23983	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23983	24	1909	1909	CD
18637	23983	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23983	26	,	,	,
18637	23983	27	1002	1002	CD
18637	23983	28	,	,	,
18637	23983	29	1007	1007	CD
18637	23983	30	Knoxville	Knoxville	NNP
18637	23983	31	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	23983	32	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23983	33	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	23983	35	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	36	Harbison	Harbison	NNP
18637	23983	37	,	,	,
18637	23983	38	183	183	CD
18637	23983	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23983	40	13	13	CD
18637	23983	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23983	42	1901	1901	CD
18637	23983	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23983	44	,	,	,
18637	23983	45	987	987	CD
18637	23983	46	,	,	,
18637	23983	47	1158	1158	CD
18637	23983	48	Knoxville	Knoxville	NNP
18637	23983	49	Water	Water	NNP
18637	23983	50	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23983	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	23983	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	54	Knoxville	Knoxville	NNP
18637	23983	55	,	,	,
18637	23983	56	200	200	CD
18637	23983	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23983	58	22	22	CD
18637	23983	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23983	60	1906	1906	CD
18637	23983	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23983	62	,	,	,
18637	23983	63	349	349	CD
18637	23983	64	Koehler	Koehler	NNP
18637	23983	65	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	23983	67	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	68	United	United	NNP
18637	23983	69	States	States	NNP
18637	23983	70	,	,	,
18637	23983	71	342	342	CD
18637	23983	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23983	73	852	852	CD
18637	23983	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23983	75	1951	1951	CD
18637	23983	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23983	77	,	,	,
18637	23983	78	883	883	CD
18637	23983	79	,	,	,
18637	23983	80	1176	1176	CD
18637	23983	81	Koenig	Koenig	NNP
18637	23983	82	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	23983	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	85	Flynn	Flynn	NNP
18637	23983	86	,	,	,
18637	23983	87	285	285	CD
18637	23983	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23983	89	375	375	CD
18637	23983	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23983	91	1932	1932	CD
18637	23983	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23983	93	,	,	,
18637	23983	94	93	93	CD
18637	23983	95	Kohl	Kohl	NNP
18637	23983	96	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	23983	98	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	99	United	United	NNP
18637	23983	100	States	States	NNP
18637	23983	101	,	,	,
18637	23983	102	91	91	CD
18637	23983	103	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23983	104	367	367	CD
18637	23983	105	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23983	106	1876	1876	CD
18637	23983	107	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23983	108	,	,	,
18637	23983	109	268	268	CD
18637	23983	110	,	,	,
18637	23983	111	308	308	CD
18637	23983	112	,	,	,
18637	23983	113	865	865	CD
18637	23983	114	Kohn	Kohn	NNP
18637	23983	115	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	116	v.	v.	IN
18637	23983	117	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	118	Central	Central	NNP
18637	23983	119	Distributing	Distributing	NNP
18637	23983	120	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23983	121	,	,	,
18637	23983	122	306	306	CD
18637	23983	123	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23983	124	531	531	CD
18637	23983	125	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23983	126	1939	1939	CD
18637	23983	127	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23983	128	,	,	,
18637	23983	129	524	524	CD
18637	23983	130	Kollock	Kollock	NNP
18637	23983	131	,	,	,
18637	23983	132	In	in	IN
18637	23983	133	re	re	NN
18637	23983	134	,	,	,
18637	23983	135	165	165	CD
18637	23983	136	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23983	137	526	526	CD
18637	23983	138	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23983	139	1897	1897	CD
18637	23983	140	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23983	141	,	,	,
18637	23983	142	76	76	CD
18637	23983	143	,	,	,
18637	23983	144	111	111	CD
18637	23983	145	Korematsu	Korematsu	NNP
18637	23983	146	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	147	v.	v.	IN
18637	23983	148	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	149	United	United	NNP
18637	23983	150	States	States	NNP
18637	23983	151	,	,	,
18637	23983	152	323	323	CD
18637	23983	153	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23983	154	214	214	CD
18637	23983	155	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23983	156	1944	1944	CD
18637	23983	157	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23983	158	,	,	,
18637	23983	159	76	76	CD
18637	23983	160	,	,	,
18637	23983	161	297	297	CD
18637	23983	162	,	,	,
18637	23983	163	395	395	CD
18637	23983	164	Korn	Korn	NNP
18637	23983	165	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	166	v.	v.	IN
18637	23983	167	_	_	NNP
18637	23983	168	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	23983	169	Assur	Assur	NNP
18637	23983	170	.	.	.
18637	23984	1	Soc	Soc	NNP
18637	23984	2	,	,	,
18637	23984	3	6	6	CD
18637	23984	4	Cr	cr	NN
18637	23984	5	.	.	.
18637	23985	1	192	192	CD
18637	23985	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	3	1810	1810	CD
18637	23985	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	5	,	,	,
18637	23985	6	302	302	CD
18637	23985	7	Koshland	Koshland	NNP
18637	23985	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	11	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	23985	12	,	,	,
18637	23985	13	298	298	CD
18637	23985	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	15	441	441	CD
18637	23985	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	17	1936	1936	CD
18637	23985	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	19	,	,	,
18637	23985	20	1195	1195	CD
18637	23985	21	Kotch	Kotch	NNP
18637	23985	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	25	Pilot	Pilot	NNP
18637	23985	26	Comm'rs	Comm'rs	NNP
18637	23985	27	.	.	.
18637	23985	28	,	,	,
18637	23985	29	330	330	CD
18637	23985	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	31	552	552	CD
18637	23985	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	33	1947	1947	CD
18637	23985	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	35	,	,	,
18637	23985	36	1157	1157	CD
18637	23985	37	Kovacs	Kovacs	NNP
18637	23985	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	41	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	23985	42	,	,	,
18637	23985	43	336	336	CD
18637	23985	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	45	77	77	CD
18637	23985	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	47	1949	1949	CD
18637	23985	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	49	,	,	,
18637	23985	50	563	563	CD
18637	23985	51	,	,	,
18637	23985	52	564	564	CD
18637	23985	53	,	,	,
18637	23985	54	768	768	CD
18637	23985	55	,	,	,
18637	23985	56	785	785	CD
18637	23985	57	,	,	,
18637	23985	58	791	791	CD
18637	23985	59	Kraus	Kraus	NNP
18637	23985	60	&	&	CC
18637	23985	61	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	23985	62	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	64	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	65	United	United	NNP
18637	23985	66	States	States	NNP
18637	23985	67	,	,	,
18637	23985	68	327	327	CD
18637	23985	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	70	614	614	CD
18637	23985	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	72	1946	1946	CD
18637	23985	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	74	,	,	,
18637	23985	75	82	82	CD
18637	23985	76	,	,	,
18637	23985	77	881	881	CD
18637	23985	78	Kreiger	Kreiger	NNP
18637	23985	79	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	82	Kreiger	Kreiger	NNP
18637	23985	83	,	,	,
18637	23985	84	334	334	CD
18637	23985	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	86	555	555	CD
18637	23985	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	88	1948	1948	CD
18637	23985	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	90	,	,	,
18637	23985	91	667	667	CD
18637	23985	92	,	,	,
18637	23985	93	668	668	CD
18637	23985	94	Kring	Kring	NNP
18637	23985	95	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	97	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	98	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	23985	99	,	,	,
18637	23985	100	107	107	CD
18637	23985	101	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	102	221	221	CD
18637	23985	103	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	104	1883	1883	CD
18637	23985	105	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	106	,	,	,
18637	23985	107	328	328	CD
18637	23985	108	Krippendorf	Krippendorf	NNP
18637	23985	109	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	110	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	111	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	112	Hyde	Hyde	NNP
18637	23985	113	,	,	,
18637	23985	114	110	110	CD
18637	23985	115	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	116	276	276	CD
18637	23985	117	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	118	1884	1884	CD
18637	23985	119	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	120	,	,	,
18637	23985	121	627	627	CD
18637	23985	122	Kryger	Kryger	NNP
18637	23985	123	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	124	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	125	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	126	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	23985	127	,	,	,
18637	23985	128	242	242	CD
18637	23985	129	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	130	171	171	CD
18637	23985	131	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	132	1916	1916	CD
18637	23985	133	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	134	,	,	,
18637	23985	135	675	675	CD
18637	23985	136	,	,	,
18637	23985	137	681	681	CD
18637	23985	138	Kuehner	Kuehner	NNP
18637	23985	139	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	140	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	141	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	142	Irving	Irving	NNP
18637	23985	143	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	23985	144	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23985	145	,	,	,
18637	23985	146	299	299	CD
18637	23985	147	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	148	445	445	CD
18637	23985	149	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	150	1937	1937	CD
18637	23985	151	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	152	,	,	,
18637	23985	153	858	858	CD
18637	23985	154	Kuhn	Kuhn	NNP
18637	23985	155	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	156	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	157	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	158	Fairmont	Fairmont	NNP
18637	23985	159	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	23985	160	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23985	161	,	,	,
18637	23985	162	215	215	CD
18637	23985	163	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	164	349	349	CD
18637	23985	165	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	166	1910	1910	CD
18637	23985	167	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	168	,	,	,
18637	23985	169	604	604	CD
18637	23985	170	,	,	,
18637	23985	171	605	605	CD
18637	23985	172	Kunz	Kunz	NNP
18637	23985	173	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	174	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	175	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	176	New	New	NNP
18637	23985	177	York	York	NNP
18637	23985	178	,	,	,
18637	23985	179	340	340	CD
18637	23985	180	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	181	290	290	CD
18637	23985	182	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	183	1951	1951	CD
18637	23985	184	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	185	,	,	,
18637	23985	186	768	768	CD
18637	23985	187	,	,	,
18637	23985	188	792	792	CD
18637	23985	189	Kurtz	Kurtz	NNP
18637	23985	190	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	191	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	192	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	193	Moffitt	Moffitt	NNP
18637	23985	194	,	,	,
18637	23985	195	115	115	CD
18637	23985	196	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	197	487	487	CD
18637	23985	198	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	199	1885	1885	CD
18637	23985	200	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	201	,	,	,
18637	23985	202	482	482	CD
18637	23985	203	,	,	,
18637	23985	204	615	615	CD
18637	23985	205	Kwock	Kwock	NNP
18637	23985	206	Jan	Jan	NNP
18637	23985	207	Fat	Fat	NNP
18637	23985	208	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	209	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	210	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	211	White	White	NNP
18637	23985	212	,	,	,
18637	23985	213	253	253	CD
18637	23985	214	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	215	454	454	CD
18637	23985	216	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	217	1920	1920	CD
18637	23985	218	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	219	,	,	,
18637	23985	220	852	852	CD
18637	23985	221	L	L	NNP
18637	23985	222	La	La	NNP
18637	23985	223	Abra	Abra	NNP
18637	23985	224	Silver	Silver	NNP
18637	23985	225	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	23985	226	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23985	227	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	228	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	229	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	230	United	United	NNP
18637	23985	231	States	States	NNP
18637	23985	232	,	,	,
18637	23985	233	175	175	CD
18637	23985	234	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	235	423	423	CD
18637	23985	236	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	237	1899	1899	CD
18637	23985	238	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	239	,	,	,
18637	23985	240	103	103	CD
18637	23985	241	,	,	,
18637	23985	242	421	421	CD
18637	23985	243	,	,	,
18637	23985	244	514	514	CD
18637	23985	245	,	,	,
18637	23985	246	550	550	CD
18637	23985	247	,	,	,
18637	23985	248	624	624	CD
18637	23985	249	LaBelle	LaBelle	NNP
18637	23985	250	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	23985	251	Works	Works	NNP
18637	23985	252	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	253	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	254	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	255	United	United	NNP
18637	23985	256	States	States	NNP
18637	23985	257	,	,	,
18637	23985	258	256	256	CD
18637	23985	259	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	260	377	377	CD
18637	23985	261	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	262	1921	1921	CD
18637	23985	263	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	264	,	,	,
18637	23985	265	110	110	CD
18637	23985	266	,	,	,
18637	23985	267	863	863	CD
18637	23985	268	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	23985	269	Board	Board	NNP
18637	23985	270	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	271	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	272	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	273	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	23985	274	Power	Power	NNP
18637	23985	275	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23985	276	,	,	,
18637	23985	277	314	314	CD
18637	23985	278	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	279	469	469	CD
18637	23985	280	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	281	1941	1941	CD
18637	23985	282	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	283	,	,	,
18637	23985	284	793	793	CD
18637	23985	285	Lacassagne	Lacassagne	NNP
18637	23985	286	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	287	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	288	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	289	Chapuis	Chapuis	NNP
18637	23985	290	,	,	,
18637	23985	291	144	144	CD
18637	23985	292	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	293	119	119	CD
18637	23985	294	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	295	1892	1892	CD
18637	23985	296	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	297	,	,	,
18637	23985	298	611	611	CD
18637	23985	299	Ladew	Ladew	NNP
18637	23985	300	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	301	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	302	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	303	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	23985	304	Copper	Copper	NNP
18637	23985	305	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23985	306	,	,	,
18637	23985	307	218	218	CD
18637	23985	308	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23985	309	357	357	CD
18637	23985	310	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23985	311	1910	1910	CD
18637	23985	312	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23985	313	,	,	,
18637	23985	314	620	620	CD
18637	23985	315	Lafayette	Lafayette	NNP
18637	23985	316	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	23985	317	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23985	318	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	319	v.	v.	IN
18637	23985	320	_	_	NNP
18637	23985	321	French	French	NNP
18637	23985	322	et	et	FW
18637	23985	323	al	al	NNP
18637	23985	324	.	.	NNP
18637	23985	325	,	,	,
18637	23985	326	18	18	CD
18637	23985	327	How	how	WRB
18637	23985	328	.	.	.
18637	23986	1	404	404	CD
18637	23986	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23986	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	23986	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23986	5	,	,	,
18637	23986	6	660	660	CD
18637	23986	7	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	23986	8	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	23986	9	&	&	CC
18637	23986	10	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	23986	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23986	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23986	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	23986	14	_	_	NNP
18637	23986	15	State	State	NNP
18637	23986	16	Public	Public	NNP
18637	23986	17	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	23986	18	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	23986	19	.	.	.
18637	23987	1	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23987	2	rel	rel	NNP
18637	23987	3	.	.	.
18637	23988	1	Cameron	Cameron	NNP
18637	23988	2	,	,	,
18637	23988	3	249	249	CD
18637	23988	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23988	5	422	422	CD
18637	23988	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23988	7	1919	1919	CD
18637	23988	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23988	9	,	,	,
18637	23988	10	1012	1012	CD
18637	23988	11	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	23988	12	Shore	Shore	NNP
18637	23988	13	&	&	CC
18637	23988	14	M.S.R.	M.S.R.	NNP
18637	23989	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23989	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23989	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23989	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23989	5	Clough	Clough	NNP
18637	23989	6	,	,	,
18637	23989	7	242	242	CD
18637	23989	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23989	9	375	375	CD
18637	23989	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23989	11	1917	1917	CD
18637	23989	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23989	13	,	,	,
18637	23989	14	1011	1011	CD
18637	23989	15	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	23989	16	Shore	Shore	NNP
18637	23989	17	&	&	CC
18637	23989	18	M.S.R.	M.S.R.	NNP
18637	23990	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23990	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23990	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23990	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23990	5	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	23990	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	23990	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	23990	8	.	.	.
18637	23991	1	Lawrence	Lawrence	NNP
18637	23991	2	,	,	,
18637	23991	3	173	173	CD
18637	23991	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23991	5	285	285	CD
18637	23991	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23991	7	1899	1899	CD
18637	23991	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23991	9	,	,	,
18637	23991	10	221	221	CD
18637	23991	11	,	,	,
18637	23991	12	222	222	CD
18637	23991	13	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	23991	14	Shore	Shore	NNP
18637	23991	15	&	&	CC
18637	23991	16	M.S.R.	M.S.R.	NNP
18637	23992	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23992	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23992	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23992	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23992	5	Prentice	Prentice	NNP
18637	23992	6	,	,	,
18637	23992	7	147	147	CD
18637	23992	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23992	9	101	101	CD
18637	23992	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23992	11	1893	1893	CD
18637	23992	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23992	13	,	,	,
18637	23992	14	604	604	CD
18637	23992	15	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	23992	16	Shore	Shore	NNP
18637	23992	17	&	&	CC
18637	23992	18	M.S.R.	M.S.R.	NNP
18637	23993	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23993	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23993	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23993	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23993	5	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	23993	6	,	,	,
18637	23993	7	173	173	CD
18637	23993	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23993	9	684	684	CD
18637	23993	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23993	11	1899	1899	CD
18637	23993	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23993	13	,	,	,
18637	23993	14	344	344	CD
18637	23993	15	,	,	,
18637	23993	16	1016	1016	CD
18637	23993	17	Lamar	Lamar	NNP
18637	23993	18	_	_	NNP
18637	23993	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	23993	20	_	_	NNP
18637	23993	21	United	United	NNP
18637	23993	22	States	States	NNP
18637	23993	23	,	,	,
18637	23993	24	241	241	CD
18637	23993	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23993	26	103	103	CD
18637	23993	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23993	28	1916	1916	CD
18637	23993	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23993	30	,	,	,
18637	23993	31	881	881	CD
18637	23993	32	Lam	Lam	NNP
18637	23993	33	Mow	Mow	NNP
18637	23993	34	_	_	NNP
18637	23993	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	23993	36	_	_	NNP
18637	23993	37	Nagle	Nagle	NNP
18637	23993	38	,	,	,
18637	23993	39	24	24	CD
18637	23993	40	F.	F.	NNP
18637	23993	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23993	42	2d	2d	CD
18637	23993	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23993	44	316	316	CD
18637	23993	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23993	46	1928	1928	CD
18637	23993	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23993	48	,	,	,
18637	23993	49	964	964	CD
18637	23993	50	Lampasas	Lampasas	NNP
18637	23993	51	_	_	NNP
18637	23993	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	23993	53	_	_	NNP
18637	23993	54	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	23993	55	,	,	,
18637	23993	56	180	180	CD
18637	23993	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23993	58	276	276	CD
18637	23993	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23993	60	1901	1901	CD
18637	23993	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23993	62	,	,	,
18637	23993	63	540	540	CD
18637	23993	64	Land	Land	NNP
18637	23993	65	_	_	NNP
18637	23993	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	23993	67	_	_	NNP
18637	23993	68	Dollar	Dollar	NNP
18637	23993	69	,	,	,
18637	23993	70	330	330	CD
18637	23993	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23993	72	731	731	CD
18637	23993	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23993	74	1947	1947	CD
18637	23993	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23993	76	,	,	,
18637	23993	77	588	588	CD
18637	23993	78	,	,	,
18637	23993	79	590	590	CD
18637	23993	80	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	23993	81	_	_	NNP
18637	23993	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	23993	83	_	_	NNP
18637	23993	84	Vick	Vick	NNP
18637	23993	85	,	,	,
18637	23993	86	3	3	CD
18637	23993	87	How	how	WRB
18637	23993	88	.	.	.
18637	23994	1	464	464	CD
18637	23994	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23994	3	1845	1845	CD
18637	23994	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23994	5	,	,	,
18637	23994	6	604	604	CD
18637	23994	7	,	,	,
18637	23994	8	605	605	CD
18637	23994	9	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	23994	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23994	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23994	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23994	13	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	23994	14	,	,	,
18637	23994	15	307	307	CD
18637	23994	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23994	17	268	268	CD
18637	23994	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23994	19	1939	1939	CD
18637	23994	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23994	21	,	,	,
18637	23994	22	571	571	CD
18637	23994	23	,	,	,
18637	23994	24	1164	1164	CD
18637	23994	25	,	,	,
18637	23994	26	1184	1184	CD
18637	23994	27	Lange	Lange	NNP
18637	23994	28	,	,	,
18637	23994	29	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	23994	30	parte	parte	NNP
18637	23994	31	,	,	,
18637	23994	32	18	18	CD
18637	23994	33	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23994	34	.	.	.
18637	23995	1	163	163	CD
18637	23995	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23995	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	23995	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23995	5	,	,	,
18637	23995	6	839	839	CD
18637	23995	7	Langnes	Langnes	NNPS
18637	23995	8	_	_	NNP
18637	23995	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	23995	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23995	11	Green	Green	NNP
18637	23995	12	,	,	,
18637	23995	13	282	282	CD
18637	23995	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23995	15	531	531	CD
18637	23995	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23995	17	1931	1931	CD
18637	23995	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23995	19	,	,	,
18637	23995	20	524	524	CD
18637	23995	21	Lankford	Lankford	NNP
18637	23995	22	_	_	NNP
18637	23995	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	23995	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23995	25	Platte	Platte	NNP
18637	23995	26	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	23995	27	Works	Works	NNP
18637	23995	28	,	,	,
18637	23995	29	235	235	CD
18637	23995	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23995	31	461	461	CD
18637	23995	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23995	33	1915	1915	CD
18637	23995	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23995	35	,	,	,
18637	23995	36	932	932	CD
18637	23995	37	Lanzetta	Lanzetta	NNP
18637	23995	38	_	_	NNP
18637	23995	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	23995	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23995	41	New	New	NNP
18637	23995	42	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	23995	43	,	,	,
18637	23995	44	306	306	CD
18637	23995	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23995	46	451	451	CD
18637	23995	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23995	48	1939	1939	CD
18637	23995	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23995	50	,	,	,
18637	23995	51	984	984	CD
18637	23995	52	,	,	,
18637	23995	53	1098	1098	CD
18637	23995	54	Lapeyre	Lapeyre	NNP
18637	23995	55	_	_	NNP
18637	23995	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	23995	57	_	_	NNP
18637	23995	58	United	United	NNP
18637	23995	59	States	States	NNP
18637	23995	60	,	,	,
18637	23995	61	17	17	CD
18637	23995	62	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	23995	63	.	.	.
18637	23996	1	191	191	CD
18637	23996	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23996	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	23996	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23996	5	,	,	,
18637	23996	6	103	103	CD
18637	23996	7	Large	Large	NNP
18637	23996	8	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	23996	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23996	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23996	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23996	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23996	13	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	23996	14	,	,	,
18637	23996	15	248	248	CD
18637	23996	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23996	17	549	549	CD
18637	23996	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23996	19	1919	1919	CD
18637	23996	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23996	21	,	,	,
18637	23996	22	735	735	CD
18637	23996	23	Largent	Largent	NNP
18637	23996	24	_	_	NNP
18637	23996	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	23996	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23996	27	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23996	28	,	,	,
18637	23996	29	318	318	CD
18637	23996	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23996	31	418	418	CD
18637	23996	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23996	33	1943	1943	CD
18637	23996	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23996	35	,	,	,
18637	23996	36	786	786	CD
18637	23996	37	,	,	,
18637	23996	38	788	788	CD
18637	23996	39	Larson	Larson	NNP
18637	23996	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23996	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23996	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23996	43	Domestic	Domestic	NNP
18637	23996	44	&	&	CC
18637	23996	45	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	23996	46	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	23996	47	,	,	,
18637	23996	48	337	337	CD
18637	23996	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23996	50	682	682	CD
18637	23996	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23996	52	1949	1949	CD
18637	23996	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23996	54	,	,	,
18637	23996	55	495	495	CD
18637	23996	56	,	,	,
18637	23996	57	588	588	CD
18637	23996	58	,	,	,
18637	23996	59	589	589	CD
18637	23996	60	,	,	,
18637	23996	61	590	590	CD
18637	23996	62	,	,	,
18637	23996	63	929	929	CD
18637	23996	64	,	,	,
18637	23996	65	931	931	CD
18637	23996	66	,	,	,
18637	23996	67	934	934	CD
18637	23996	68	Lascelles	Lascelles	NNPS
18637	23996	69	_	_	NNP
18637	23996	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	23996	71	_	_	NNP
18637	23996	72	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	23996	73	,	,	,
18637	23996	74	148	148	CD
18637	23996	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23996	76	537	537	CD
18637	23996	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23996	78	1893	1893	CD
18637	23996	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23996	80	,	,	,
18637	23996	81	696	696	CD
18637	23996	82	La	La	NNP
18637	23996	83	Tourette	Tourette	NNP
18637	23996	84	_	_	NNP
18637	23996	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	23996	86	_	_	NNP
18637	23996	87	McMaster	McMaster	NNP
18637	23996	88	,	,	,
18637	23996	89	248	248	CD
18637	23996	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23996	91	465	465	CD
18637	23996	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23996	93	1919	1919	CD
18637	23996	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23996	95	,	,	,
18637	23996	96	687	687	CD
18637	23996	97	,	,	,
18637	23996	98	691	691	CD
18637	23996	99	,	,	,
18637	23996	100	1021	1021	CD
18637	23996	101	Latta	Latta	NNP
18637	23996	102	&	&	CC
18637	23996	103	T.	T.	NNP
18637	23996	104	Constr	Constr	NNP
18637	23996	105	.	.	.
18637	23997	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23997	2	_	_	NNP
18637	23997	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	23997	4	_	_	NNP
18637	23997	5	The	The	NNP
18637	23997	6	Raithmoor	Raithmoor	NNP
18637	23997	7	,	,	,
18637	23997	8	241	241	CD
18637	23997	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23997	10	166	166	CD
18637	23997	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23997	12	1916	1916	CD
18637	23997	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23997	14	,	,	,
18637	23997	15	575	575	CD
18637	23997	16	Lauf	Lauf	NNP
18637	23997	17	_	_	NNP
18637	23997	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	23997	19	_	_	NNP
18637	23997	20	E.G.	E.G.	NNP
18637	23998	1	Shinner	Shinner	NNP
18637	23998	2	&	&	CC
18637	23998	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	23998	4	,	,	,
18637	23998	5	303	303	CD
18637	23998	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23998	7	323	323	CD
18637	23998	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23998	9	1938	1938	CD
18637	23998	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23998	11	,	,	,
18637	23998	12	524	524	CD
18637	23998	13	,	,	,
18637	23998	14	620	620	CD
18637	23998	15	,	,	,
18637	23998	16	622	622	CD
18637	23998	17	Laura	Laura	NNP
18637	23998	18	,	,	,
18637	23998	19	The	the	DT
18637	23998	20	,	,	,
18637	23998	21	114	114	CD
18637	23998	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23998	23	411	411	CD
18637	23998	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23998	25	1885	1885	CD
18637	23998	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23998	27	,	,	,
18637	23998	28	411	411	CD
18637	23998	29	La	La	NNP
18637	23998	30	Vengeance	Vengeance	NNP
18637	23998	31	,	,	,
18637	23998	32	3	3	CD
18637	23998	33	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	23998	34	.	.	.
18637	23999	1	297	297	CD
18637	23999	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23999	3	1796	1796	CD
18637	23999	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23999	5	,	,	,
18637	23999	6	575	575	CD
18637	23999	7	,	,	,
18637	23999	8	576	576	CD
18637	23999	9	Lawrence	Lawrence	NNP
18637	23999	10	_	_	NNP
18637	23999	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	23999	12	_	_	NNP
18637	23999	13	State	State	NNP
18637	23999	14	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	23999	15	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	23999	16	,	,	,
18637	23999	17	286	286	CD
18637	23999	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23999	19	276	276	CD
18637	23999	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23999	21	1932	1932	CD
18637	23999	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23999	23	,	,	,
18637	23999	24	1054	1054	CD
18637	23999	25	Lawton	Lawton	NNP
18637	23999	26	_	_	NNP
18637	23999	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	23999	28	_	_	NNP
18637	23999	29	Steele	Steele	NNP
18637	23999	30	,	,	,
18637	23999	31	152	152	CD
18637	23999	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23999	33	133	133	CD
18637	23999	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23999	35	1894	1894	CD
18637	23999	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23999	37	,	,	,
18637	23999	38	1086	1086	CD
18637	23999	39	League	League	NNP
18637	23999	40	_	_	NNP
18637	23999	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	23999	42	_	_	NNP
18637	23999	43	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	23999	44	,	,	,
18637	23999	45	184	184	CD
18637	23999	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23999	47	156	156	CD
18637	23999	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23999	49	1902	1902	CD
18637	23999	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23999	51	,	,	,
18637	23999	52	1062	1062	CD
18637	23999	53	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	23999	54	_	_	NNP
18637	23999	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	23999	56	_	_	NNP
18637	23999	57	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	23999	58	,	,	,
18637	23999	59	332	332	CD
18637	23999	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	23999	61	742	742	CD
18637	23999	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	23999	63	1948	1948	CD
18637	23999	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	23999	65	,	,	,
18637	23999	66	1119	1119	CD
18637	23999	67	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	23999	68	_	_	NNP
18637	23999	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	23999	70	_	_	NNP
18637	23999	71	Osceola	Osceola	NNP
18637	23999	72	&	&	CC
18637	23999	73	L.	L.	NNP
18637	23999	74	River	River	NNP
18637	23999	75	Road	Road	NNP
18637	23999	76	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	23999	77	.	.	.
18637	24000	1	Dist	dist	NN
18637	24000	2	,	,	,
18637	24000	3	268	268	CD
18637	24000	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24000	5	643	643	CD
18637	24000	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24000	7	1925	1925	CD
18637	24000	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24000	9	,	,	,
18637	24000	10	732	732	CD
18637	24000	11	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	24000	12	,	,	,
18637	24000	13	On	on	IN
18637	24000	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24000	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24000	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24000	17	United	United	NNP
18637	24000	18	States	States	NNP
18637	24000	19	,	,	,
18637	24000	20	343	343	CD
18637	24000	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24000	22	747	747	CD
18637	24000	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24000	24	1952	1952	CD
18637	24000	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24000	26	,	,	,
18637	24000	27	824	824	CD
18637	24000	28	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	24000	29	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	24000	30	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	24000	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24000	32	Juilliard	Juilliard	NNP
18637	24000	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24000	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24000	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24000	36	Greenman	Greenman	NNP
18637	24000	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24000	38	,	,	,
18637	24000	39	12	12	CD
18637	24000	40	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24000	41	.	.	.
18637	24001	1	457	457	CD
18637	24001	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24001	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	5	,	,	,
18637	24001	6	118	118	CD
18637	24001	7	,	,	,
18637	24001	8	267	267	CD
18637	24001	9	,	,	,
18637	24001	10	310	310	CD
18637	24001	11	,	,	,
18637	24001	12	362	362	CD
18637	24001	13	,	,	,
18637	24001	14	563	563	CD
18637	24001	15	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	24001	16	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	24001	17	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	24001	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	19	Juilliard	Juilliard	NNP
18637	24001	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24001	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	23	Greenman	Greenman	NNP
18637	24001	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	25	,	,	,
18637	24001	26	110	110	CD
18637	24001	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24001	28	421	421	CD
18637	24001	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	30	1884	1884	CD
18637	24001	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	32	,	,	,
18637	24001	33	266	266	CD
18637	24001	34	,	,	,
18637	24001	35	326	326	CD
18637	24001	36	Lehigh	Lehigh	NNP
18637	24001	37	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	24001	38	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24001	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24001	40	,	,	,
18637	24001	41	In	in	IN
18637	24001	42	re	re	NN
18637	24001	43	,	,	,
18637	24001	44	265	265	CD
18637	24001	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24001	46	573	573	CD
18637	24001	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	48	1924	1924	CD
18637	24001	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	50	,	,	,
18637	24001	51	610	610	CD
18637	24001	52	Lehigh	Lehigh	NNP
18637	24001	53	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	24001	54	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24001	55	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24001	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24001	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	59	Barlow	Barlow	NNP
18637	24001	60	,	,	,
18637	24001	61	244	244	CD
18637	24001	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24001	63	183	183	CD
18637	24001	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	65	1917	1917	CD
18637	24001	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	67	,	,	,
18637	24001	68	141	141	CD
18637	24001	69	Lehigh	Lehigh	NNP
18637	24001	70	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	24001	71	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24001	72	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24001	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	24001	75	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	76	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24001	77	Utility	Utility	NNP
18637	24001	78	Comrs	Comrs	NNP
18637	24001	79	.	.	.
18637	24001	80	,	,	,
18637	24001	81	278	278	CD
18637	24001	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24001	83	24	24	CD
18637	24001	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	85	1928	1928	CD
18637	24001	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	87	,	,	,
18637	24001	88	1011	1011	CD
18637	24001	89	Lehmann	Lehmann	NNP
18637	24001	90	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	91	v.	v.	IN
18637	24001	92	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	93	State	State	NNP
18637	24001	94	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24001	95	of	of	IN
18637	24001	96	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24001	97	Accountancy	Accountancy	NNP
18637	24001	98	,	,	,
18637	24001	99	263	263	CD
18637	24001	100	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24001	101	394	394	CD
18637	24001	102	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	103	1923	1923	CD
18637	24001	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	105	,	,	,
18637	24001	106	328	328	CD
18637	24001	107	Lehon	Lehon	NNP
18637	24001	108	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	109	v.	v.	IN
18637	24001	110	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	111	Atlanta	Atlanta	NNP
18637	24001	112	,	,	,
18637	24001	113	242	242	CD
18637	24001	114	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24001	115	53	53	CD
18637	24001	116	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	117	1916	1916	CD
18637	24001	118	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	119	,	,	,
18637	24001	120	1024	1024	CD
18637	24001	121	Leigh	Leigh	NNP
18637	24001	122	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	123	v.	v.	IN
18637	24001	124	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	125	Green	Green	NNP
18637	24001	126	,	,	,
18637	24001	127	193	193	CD
18637	24001	128	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24001	129	79	79	CD
18637	24001	130	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	131	1904	1904	CD
18637	24001	132	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	133	,	,	,
18637	24001	134	1060	1060	CD
18637	24001	135	,	,	,
18637	24001	136	1062	1062	CD
18637	24001	137	Leisy	Leisy	NNP
18637	24001	138	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	139	v.	v.	IN
18637	24001	140	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	141	Hardin	Hardin	NNP
18637	24001	142	,	,	,
18637	24001	143	135	135	CD
18637	24001	144	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24001	145	100	100	CD
18637	24001	146	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	147	1890	1890	CD
18637	24001	148	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	149	,	,	,
18637	24001	150	218	218	CD
18637	24001	151	,	,	,
18637	24001	152	239	239	CD
18637	24001	153	,	,	,
18637	24001	154	268	268	CD
18637	24001	155	Leland	Leland	NNP
18637	24001	156	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	157	v.	v.	IN
18637	24001	158	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	159	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24001	160	,	,	,
18637	24001	161	343	343	CD
18637	24001	162	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24001	163	790	790	CD
18637	24001	164	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	165	1952	1952	CD
18637	24001	166	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	167	,	,	,
18637	24001	168	1096	1096	CD
18637	24001	169	Leloup	Leloup	NNP
18637	24001	170	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	171	v.	v.	IN
18637	24001	172	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	173	Port	Port	NNP
18637	24001	174	of	of	IN
18637	24001	175	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	24001	176	,	,	,
18637	24001	177	127	127	CD
18637	24001	178	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24001	179	640	640	CD
18637	24001	180	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	181	1888	1888	CD
18637	24001	182	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	183	,	,	,
18637	24001	184	193	193	CD
18637	24001	185	,	,	,
18637	24001	186	202	202	CD
18637	24001	187	Lemieux	Lemieux	NNP
18637	24001	188	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	189	v.	v.	IN
18637	24001	190	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	191	Young	Young	NNP
18637	24001	192	,	,	,
18637	24001	193	211	211	CD
18637	24001	194	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24001	195	489	489	CD
18637	24001	196	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	197	1909	1909	CD
18637	24001	198	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	199	,	,	,
18637	24001	200	1018	1018	CD
18637	24001	201	,	,	,
18637	24001	202	1156	1156	CD
18637	24001	203	Lemke	Lemke	NNP
18637	24001	204	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	205	v.	v.	IN
18637	24001	206	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	207	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	24001	208	Grain	Grain	NNP
18637	24001	209	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24001	210	,	,	,
18637	24001	211	258	258	CD
18637	24001	212	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24001	213	50	50	CD
18637	24001	214	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	215	1922	1922	CD
18637	24001	216	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	217	,	,	,
18637	24001	218	149	149	CD
18637	24001	219	,	,	,
18637	24001	220	244	244	CD
18637	24001	221	Lem	Lem	NNP
18637	24001	222	Woon	Woon	NNP
18637	24001	223	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	224	v.	v.	IN
18637	24001	225	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	226	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24001	227	,	,	,
18637	24001	228	229	229	CD
18637	24001	229	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24001	230	586	586	CD
18637	24001	231	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	232	1913	1913	CD
18637	24001	233	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	234	,	,	,
18637	24001	235	1098	1098	CD
18637	24001	236	Leser	Leser	NNP
18637	24001	237	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	238	v.	v.	IN
18637	24001	239	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	240	Garnett	Garnett	NNP
18637	24001	241	,	,	,
18637	24001	242	258	258	CD
18637	24001	243	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24001	244	130	130	CD
18637	24001	245	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24001	246	1922	1922	CD
18637	24001	247	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24001	248	,	,	,
18637	24001	249	98	98	CD
18637	24001	250	,	,	,
18637	24001	251	712	712	CD
18637	24001	252	,	,	,
18637	24001	253	713	713	CD
18637	24001	254	,	,	,
18637	24001	255	714	714	CD
18637	24001	256	Lessee	Lessee	NNP
18637	24001	257	of	of	IN
18637	24001	258	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
18637	24001	259	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	260	v.	v.	IN
18637	24001	261	_	_	NNP
18637	24001	262	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	24001	263	,	,	,
18637	24001	264	7	7	CD
18637	24001	265	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	24001	266	.	.	.
18637	24002	1	469	469	CD
18637	24002	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24002	3	1933	1933	CD
18637	24002	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24002	5	,	,	,
18637	24002	6	751	751	CD
18637	24002	7	Levering	Levering	NNP
18637	24002	8	&	&	CC
18637	24002	9	Garrigues	Garrigues	NNP
18637	24002	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24002	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24002	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24002	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24002	14	Morrin	Morrin	NNP
18637	24002	15	,	,	,
18637	24002	16	289	289	CD
18637	24002	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24002	18	103	103	CD
18637	24002	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24002	20	1933	1933	CD
18637	24002	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24002	22	,	,	,
18637	24002	23	567	567	CD
18637	24002	24	Levitt	Levitt	NNP
18637	24002	25	,	,	,
18637	24002	26	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24002	27	parte	parte	NN
18637	24002	28	,	,	,
18637	24002	29	302	302	CD
18637	24002	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24002	31	633	633	CD
18637	24002	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24002	33	1937	1937	CD
18637	24002	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24002	35	,	,	,
18637	24002	36	101	101	CD
18637	24002	37	,	,	,
18637	24002	38	542	542	CD
18637	24002	39	,	,	,
18637	24002	40	612	612	CD
18637	24002	41	Levy	Levy	NNP
18637	24002	42	Leasing	Leasing	NNP
18637	24002	43	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24002	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24002	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24002	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24002	47	Siegel	Siegel	NNP
18637	24002	48	,	,	,
18637	24002	49	258	258	CD
18637	24002	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24002	51	242	242	CD
18637	24002	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24002	53	1922	1922	CD
18637	24002	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24002	55	,	,	,
18637	24002	56	359	359	CD
18637	24002	57	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	24002	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24002	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24002	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24002	61	Cocks	Cocks	NNP
18637	24002	62	,	,	,
18637	24002	63	23	23	CD
18637	24002	64	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24002	65	.	.	.
18637	24003	1	466	466	CD
18637	24003	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24003	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	24003	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24003	5	,	,	,
18637	24003	6	895	895	CD
18637	24003	7	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	24003	8	Blue	Blue	NNP
18637	24003	9	Point	Point	NNP
18637	24003	10	Oyster	Oyster	NNP
18637	24003	11	Cultivation	Cultivation	NNP
18637	24003	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24003	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24003	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24003	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24003	16	Briggs	Briggs	NNP
18637	24003	17	,	,	,
18637	24003	18	229	229	CD
18637	24003	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24003	20	82	82	CD
18637	24003	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24003	22	1913	1913	CD
18637	24003	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24003	24	,	,	,
18637	24003	25	868	868	CD
18637	24003	26	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	24003	27	Publishing	Publishing	NNP
18637	24003	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24003	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24003	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24003	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24003	32	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	24003	33	,	,	,
18637	24003	34	229	229	CD
18637	24003	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24003	36	288	288	CD
18637	24003	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24003	38	1913	1913	CD
18637	24003	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24003	40	,	,	,
18637	24003	41	269	269	CD
18637	24003	42	L'Hote	L'Hote	NNP
18637	24003	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24003	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24003	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24003	46	New	New	NNP
18637	24003	47	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24003	48	,	,	,
18637	24003	49	177	177	CD
18637	24003	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24003	51	587	587	CD
18637	24003	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24003	53	1900	1900	CD
18637	24003	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24003	55	,	,	,
18637	24003	56	1031	1031	CD
18637	24003	57	,	,	,
18637	24003	58	1154	1154	CD
18637	24003	59	Liberato	Liberato	NNP
18637	24003	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24003	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	24003	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24003	63	Royer	Royer	NNP
18637	24003	64	,	,	,
18637	24003	65	270	270	CD
18637	24003	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24003	67	535	535	CD
18637	24003	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24003	69	1926	1926	CD
18637	24003	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24003	71	,	,	,
18637	24003	72	416	416	CD
18637	24003	73	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	24003	74	Warehouse	Warehouse	NNP
18637	24003	75	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24003	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24003	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	24003	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24003	79	Burley	Burley	NNP
18637	24003	80	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	24003	81	Growers	Growers	NNPS
18637	24003	82	'	'	POS
18637	24003	83	Co	co	NN
18637	24003	84	-	-	NN
18637	24003	85	op	op	NN
18637	24003	86	.	.	.
18637	24004	1	Marketing	Marketing	NNP
18637	24004	2	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	24004	3	.	.	.
18637	24004	4	,	,	,
18637	24004	5	276	276	CD
18637	24004	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24004	7	71	71	CD
18637	24004	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24004	9	1928	1928	CD
18637	24004	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24004	11	,	,	,
18637	24004	12	513	513	CD
18637	24004	13	,	,	,
18637	24004	14	965	965	CD
18637	24004	15	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	24004	16	Warehouse	Warehouse	NNP
18637	24004	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24004	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24004	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24004	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24004	21	Grannis	Grannis	NNP
18637	24004	22	,	,	,
18637	24004	23	273	273	CD
18637	24004	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24004	25	70	70	CD
18637	24004	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24004	27	1927	1927	CD
18637	24004	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24004	29	,	,	,
18637	24004	30	513	513	CD
18637	24004	31	,	,	,
18637	24004	32	551	551	CD
18637	24004	33	License	license	NN
18637	24004	34	Cases	case	NNS
18637	24004	35	,	,	,
18637	24004	36	5	5	CD
18637	24004	37	How	how	WRB
18637	24004	38	.	.	.
18637	24005	1	504	504	CD
18637	24005	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24005	3	1847	1847	CD
18637	24005	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24005	5	,	,	,
18637	24005	6	122	122	CD
18637	24005	7	,	,	,
18637	24005	8	723	723	CD
18637	24005	9	License	License	NNP
18637	24005	10	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24005	11	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	24005	12	,	,	,
18637	24005	13	5	5	CD
18637	24005	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24005	15	.	.	.
18637	24006	1	462	462	CD
18637	24006	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24006	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	24006	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24006	5	,	,	,
18637	24006	6	105	105	CD
18637	24006	7	,	,	,
18637	24006	8	110	110	CD
18637	24006	9	Lichter	Lichter	NNP
18637	24006	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24006	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24006	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24006	13	United	United	NNP
18637	24006	14	States	States	NNP
18637	24006	15	,	,	,
18637	24006	16	334	334	CD
18637	24006	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24006	18	742	742	CD
18637	24006	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24006	20	1948	1948	CD
18637	24006	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24006	22	,	,	,
18637	24006	23	75	75	CD
18637	24006	24	,	,	,
18637	24006	25	281	281	CD
18637	24006	26	,	,	,
18637	24006	27	289	289	CD
18637	24006	28	,	,	,
18637	24006	29	290	290	CD
18637	24006	30	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24006	31	&	&	CC
18637	24006	32	C.	C.	NNP
18637	24006	33	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24006	34	.	.	.
18637	24007	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24007	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24007	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24007	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24007	5	McCray	McCray	NNP
18637	24007	6	,	,	,
18637	24007	7	291	291	CD
18637	24007	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24007	9	566	566	CD
18637	24007	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24007	11	1934	1934	CD
18637	24007	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24007	13	,	,	,
18637	24007	14	1023	1023	CD
18637	24007	15	,	,	,
18637	24007	16	1092	1092	CD
18637	24007	17	Liggett	Liggett	NNP
18637	24007	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24007	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24007	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24007	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24007	22	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	24007	23	,	,	,
18637	24007	24	288	288	CD
18637	24007	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24007	26	517	517	CD
18637	24007	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24007	28	1933	1933	CD
18637	24007	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24007	30	,	,	,
18637	24007	31	1149	1149	CD
18637	24007	32	Liggett	Liggett	NNP
18637	24007	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24007	34	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24007	35	K.	K.	NNP
18637	24007	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24007	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24007	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24007	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24007	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24007	41	Baldridge	Baldridge	NNP
18637	24007	42	,	,	,
18637	24007	43	278	278	CD
18637	24007	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24007	45	105	105	CD
18637	24007	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24007	47	1928	1928	CD
18637	24007	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24007	49	,	,	,
18637	24007	50	981	981	CD
18637	24007	51	,	,	,
18637	24007	52	983	983	CD
18637	24007	53	,	,	,
18637	24007	54	1023	1023	CD
18637	24007	55	Light	Light	NNP
18637	24007	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24007	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24007	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24007	59	United	United	NNP
18637	24007	60	States	States	NNP
18637	24007	61	,	,	,
18637	24007	62	220	220	CD
18637	24007	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24007	64	523	523	CD
18637	24007	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24007	66	1911	1911	CD
18637	24007	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24007	68	,	,	,
18637	24007	69	702	702	CD
18637	24007	70	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	24007	71	County	County	NNP
18637	24007	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24007	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	24007	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24007	75	Luning	Luning	NNP
18637	24007	76	,	,	,
18637	24007	77	133	133	CD
18637	24007	78	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24007	79	529	529	CD
18637	24007	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24007	81	1890	1890	CD
18637	24007	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24007	83	,	,	,
18637	24007	84	930	930	CD
18637	24007	85	,	,	,
18637	24007	86	936	936	CD
18637	24007	87	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	24007	88	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24007	89	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24007	90	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24007	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24007	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	24007	93	_	_	NNP
18637	24007	94	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	24007	95	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24007	96	,	,	,
18637	24007	97	335	335	CD
18637	24007	98	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24007	99	525	525	CD
18637	24007	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24007	101	1949	1949	CD
18637	24007	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24007	103	,	,	,
18637	24007	104	783	783	CD
18637	24007	105	,	,	,
18637	24007	106	991	991	CD
18637	24007	107	,	,	,
18637	24007	108	993	993	CD
18637	24007	109	,	,	,
18637	24007	110	1023	1023	CD
18637	24007	111	,	,	,
18637	24007	112	1150	1150	CD
18637	24007	113	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
18637	24007	114	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	24007	115	.	.	.
18637	24008	1	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24008	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24008	3	.	.	.
18637	24009	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24009	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24009	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24009	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24009	5	Read	Read	NNP
18637	24009	6	,	,	,
18637	24009	7	325	325	CD
18637	24009	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24009	9	673	673	CD
18637	24009	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24009	11	1945	1945	CD
18637	24009	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24009	13	,	,	,
18637	24009	14	1150	1150	CD
18637	24009	15	Lindenmuller	Lindenmuller	NNP
18637	24009	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24009	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24009	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24009	19	The	the	DT
18637	24009	20	People	People	NNPS
18637	24009	21	,	,	,
18637	24009	22	33	33	CD
18637	24009	23	Barbour	Barbour	NNP
18637	24009	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24009	25	N.Y.	New York	NNP
18637	24009	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24009	27	548	548	CD
18637	24009	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24009	29	1861	1861	CD
18637	24009	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24009	31	,	,	,
18637	24009	32	357	357	CD
18637	24009	33	Lindsay	Lindsay	NNP
18637	24009	34	&	&	CC
18637	24009	35	Phelps	Phelps	NNP
18637	24009	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24009	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24009	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	24009	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24009	40	Mullen	Mullen	NNP
18637	24009	41	,	,	,
18637	24009	42	176	176	CD
18637	24009	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24009	44	126	126	CD
18637	24009	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24009	46	1900	1900	CD
18637	24009	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24009	48	,	,	,
18637	24009	49	231	231	CD
18637	24009	50	Lindsey	Lindsey	NNP
18637	24009	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24009	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	24009	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24009	54	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24009	55	,	,	,
18637	24009	56	301	301	CD
18637	24009	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24009	58	397	397	CD
18637	24009	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24009	60	1937	1937	CD
18637	24009	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24009	62	,	,	,
18637	24009	63	328	328	CD
18637	24009	64	Lindsley	Lindsley	NNP
18637	24009	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24009	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	24009	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24009	68	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	24009	69	Carbonic	Carbonic	NNP
18637	24009	70	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24009	71	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24009	72	,	,	,
18637	24009	73	220	220	CD
18637	24009	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24009	75	61	61	CD
18637	24009	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24009	77	1911	1911	CD
18637	24009	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24009	79	,	,	,
18637	24009	80	1025	1025	CD
18637	24009	81	,	,	,
18637	24009	82	1145	1145	CD
18637	24009	83	,	,	,
18637	24009	84	1146	1146	CD
18637	24009	85	,	,	,
18637	24009	86	1166	1166	CD
18637	24009	87	Ling	Ling	NNP
18637	24009	88	Su	Su	NNP
18637	24009	89	Fan	Fan	NNP
18637	24009	90	_	_	NNP
18637	24009	91	v.	v.	IN
18637	24009	92	_	_	NNP
18637	24009	93	United	United	NNP
18637	24009	94	States	States	NNP
18637	24009	95	,	,	,
18637	24009	96	218	218	CD
18637	24009	97	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24009	98	302	302	CD
18637	24009	99	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24009	100	1910	1910	CD
18637	24009	101	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24009	102	,	,	,
18637	24009	103	266	266	CD
18637	24009	104	L'Invincible	L'Invincible	NNP
18637	24009	105	,	,	,
18637	24009	106	1	1	CD
18637	24009	107	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24009	108	.	.	.
18637	24010	1	238	238	CD
18637	24010	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24010	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	24010	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24010	5	,	,	,
18637	24010	6	575	575	CD
18637	24010	7	Lipke	Lipke	NNP
18637	24010	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24010	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24010	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24010	11	Lederer	Lederer	NNP
18637	24010	12	,	,	,
18637	24010	13	259	259	CD
18637	24010	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24010	15	557	557	CD
18637	24010	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24010	17	1922	1922	CD
18637	24010	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24010	19	,	,	,
18637	24010	20	621	621	CD
18637	24010	21	,	,	,
18637	24010	22	849	849	CD
18637	24010	23	Lisenba	Lisenba	NNP
18637	24010	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24010	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24010	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24010	27	California	California	NNP
18637	24010	28	,	,	,
18637	24010	29	314	314	CD
18637	24010	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24010	31	219	219	CD
18637	24010	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24010	33	1941	1941	CD
18637	24010	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24010	35	,	,	,
18637	24010	36	1113	1113	CD
18637	24010	37	,	,	,
18637	24010	38	1125	1125	CD
18637	24010	39	,	,	,
18637	24010	40	1132	1132	CD
18637	24010	41	Litchfield	Litchfield	NNP
18637	24010	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24010	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24010	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24010	45	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	24010	46	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24010	47	,	,	,
18637	24010	48	101	101	CD
18637	24010	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24010	50	773	773	CD
18637	24010	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24010	52	1880	1880	CD
18637	24010	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24010	54	,	,	,
18637	24010	55	931	931	CD
18637	24010	56	Little	Little	NNP
18637	24010	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24010	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	24010	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24010	60	Barreme	Barreme	NNP
18637	24010	61	,	,	,
18637	24010	62	2	2	CD
18637	24010	63	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24010	64	.	.	.
18637	24011	1	170	170	CD
18637	24011	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24011	3	1804	1804	CD
18637	24011	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24011	5	,	,	,
18637	24011	6	492	492	CD
18637	24011	7	,	,	,
18637	24011	8	498	498	CD
18637	24011	9	,	,	,
18637	24011	10	501	501	CD
18637	24011	11	Liverpool	Liverpool	NNP
18637	24011	12	&	&	CC
18637	24011	13	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24011	14	&	&	CC
18637	24011	15	G.	G.	NNP
18637	24011	16	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24011	17	.	.	.
18637	24012	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24012	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24012	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24012	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24012	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24012	6	of	of	IN
18637	24012	7	Assessors	Assessors	NNPS
18637	24012	8	,	,	,
18637	24012	9	221	221	CD
18637	24012	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24012	11	346	346	CD
18637	24012	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24012	13	1911	1911	CD
18637	24012	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24012	15	,	,	,
18637	24012	16	1056	1056	CD
18637	24012	17	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
18637	24012	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24012	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24012	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24012	21	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	24012	22	,	,	,
18637	24012	23	7	7	CD
18637	24012	24	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	24012	25	.	.	.
18637	24013	1	469	469	CD
18637	24013	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24013	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	24013	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24013	5	,	,	,
18637	24013	6	352	352	CD
18637	24013	7	Lloyd	Lloyd	NNP
18637	24013	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24013	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24013	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24013	11	Matthews	Matthews	NNP
18637	24013	12	,	,	,
18637	24013	13	155	155	CD
18637	24013	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24013	15	222	222	CD
18637	24013	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24013	17	1894	1894	CD
18637	24013	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24013	19	,	,	,
18637	24013	20	676	676	CD
18637	24013	21	Local	local	JJ
18637	24013	22	167	167	CD
18637	24013	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24013	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24013	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24013	26	United	United	NNP
18637	24013	27	States	States	NNP
18637	24013	28	,	,	,
18637	24013	29	291	291	CD
18637	24013	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24013	31	293	293	CD
18637	24013	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24013	33	1934	1934	CD
18637	24013	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24013	35	,	,	,
18637	24013	36	149	149	CD
18637	24013	37	Loche	Loche	NNP
18637	24013	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24013	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24013	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24013	41	New	New	NNP
18637	24013	42	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24013	43	,	,	,
18637	24013	44	4	4	CD
18637	24013	45	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24013	46	.	.	.
18637	24014	1	172	172	CD
18637	24014	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24014	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	24014	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24014	5	,	,	,
18637	24014	6	327	327	CD
18637	24014	7	,	,	,
18637	24014	8	338	338	CD
18637	24014	9	Lochner	Lochner	NNP
18637	24014	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24014	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24014	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24014	13	New	New	NNP
18637	24014	14	York	York	NNP
18637	24014	15	,	,	,
18637	24014	16	198	198	CD
18637	24014	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24014	18	45	45	CD
18637	24014	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24014	20	1905	1905	CD
18637	24014	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24014	22	,	,	,
18637	24014	23	564	564	CD
18637	24014	24	,	,	,
18637	24014	25	846	846	CD
18637	24014	26	,	,	,
18637	24014	27	977	977	CD
18637	24014	28	Locke	Locke	NNP
18637	24014	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24014	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24014	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24014	32	Dane	Dane	NNP
18637	24014	33	,	,	,
18637	24014	34	9	9	CD
18637	24014	35	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24015	1	360	360	CD
18637	24015	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	24015	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	5	,	,	,
18637	24015	6	338	338	CD
18637	24015	7	Lockerty	Lockerty	NNP
18637	24015	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	11	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	24015	12	,	,	,
18637	24015	13	319	319	CD
18637	24015	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	15	182	182	CD
18637	24015	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	17	1943	1943	CD
18637	24015	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	19	,	,	,
18637	24015	20	525	525	CD
18637	24015	21	,	,	,
18637	24015	22	532	532	CD
18637	24015	23	,	,	,
18637	24015	24	620	620	CD
18637	24015	25	Lockwood	Lockwood	NNP
18637	24015	26	,	,	,
18637	24015	27	In	in	IN
18637	24015	28	re	re	NN
18637	24015	29	,	,	,
18637	24015	30	154	154	CD
18637	24015	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	32	116	116	CD
18637	24015	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	34	1894	1894	CD
18637	24015	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	36	,	,	,
18637	24015	37	971	971	CD
18637	24015	38	Locomobile	Locomobile	NNP
18637	24015	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24015	40	of	of	IN
18637	24015	41	America	America	NNP
18637	24015	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	45	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24015	46	,	,	,
18637	24015	47	246	246	CD
18637	24015	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	49	146	146	CD
18637	24015	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	51	1918	1918	CD
18637	24015	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	53	,	,	,
18637	24015	54	197	197	CD
18637	24015	55	Loewe	Loewe	NNP
18637	24015	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	59	Lawlor	Lawlor	NNP
18637	24015	60	,	,	,
18637	24015	61	208	208	CD
18637	24015	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	63	274	274	CD
18637	24015	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	65	1908	1908	CD
18637	24015	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	67	,	,	,
18637	24015	68	149	149	CD
18637	24015	69	Logan	Logan	NNP
18637	24015	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	73	United	United	NNP
18637	24015	74	States	States	NNP
18637	24015	75	,	,	,
18637	24015	76	144	144	CD
18637	24015	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	78	263	263	CD
18637	24015	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	80	1892	1892	CD
18637	24015	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	82	,	,	,
18637	24015	83	309	309	CD
18637	24015	84	,	,	,
18637	24015	85	839	839	CD
18637	24015	86	,	,	,
18637	24015	87	967	967	CD
18637	24015	88	Londoner	Londoner	NNP
18637	24015	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	92	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	24015	93	,	,	,
18637	24015	94	210	210	CD
18637	24015	95	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	96	373	373	CD
18637	24015	97	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	98	1908	1908	CD
18637	24015	99	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	100	,	,	,
18637	24015	101	850	850	CD
18637	24015	102	,	,	,
18637	24015	103	1059	1059	CD
18637	24015	104	,	,	,
18637	24015	105	1060	1060	CD
18637	24015	106	Lonergan	Lonergan	NNP
18637	24015	107	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	109	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	110	United	United	NNP
18637	24015	111	States	States	NNP
18637	24015	112	,	,	,
18637	24015	113	303	303	CD
18637	24015	114	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	115	33	33	CD
18637	24015	116	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	117	1938	1938	CD
18637	24015	118	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	119	,	,	,
18637	24015	120	587	587	CD
18637	24015	121	Lone	Lone	NNP
18637	24015	122	Star	Star	NNP
18637	24015	123	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24015	124	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24015	125	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	126	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	127	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	128	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24015	129	,	,	,
18637	24015	130	304	304	CD
18637	24015	131	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	132	224	224	CD
18637	24015	133	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	134	1938	1938	CD
18637	24015	135	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	136	,	,	,
18637	24015	137	218	218	CD
18637	24015	138	,	,	,
18637	24015	139	234	234	CD
18637	24015	140	Lone	Lone	NNP
18637	24015	141	Wolf	Wolf	NNP
18637	24015	142	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	143	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	144	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	145	Hitchcock	Hitchcock	NNP
18637	24015	146	,	,	,
18637	24015	147	187	187	CD
18637	24015	148	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	149	553	553	CD
18637	24015	150	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	151	1903	1903	CD
18637	24015	152	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	153	,	,	,
18637	24015	154	432	432	CD
18637	24015	155	,	,	,
18637	24015	156	864	864	CD
18637	24015	157	Loney	Loney	NNP
18637	24015	158	,	,	,
18637	24015	159	In	in	IN
18637	24015	160	re	re	NN
18637	24015	161	,	,	,
18637	24015	162	134	134	CD
18637	24015	163	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	164	372	372	CD
18637	24015	165	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	166	1890	1890	CD
18637	24015	167	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	168	,	,	,
18637	24015	169	96	96	CD
18637	24015	170	,	,	,
18637	24015	171	633	633	CD
18637	24015	172	Long	Long	NNP
18637	24015	173	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	174	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	175	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	176	Ansell	Ansell	NNP
18637	24015	177	,	,	,
18637	24015	178	293	293	CD
18637	24015	179	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	180	76	76	CD
18637	24015	181	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	182	1934	1934	CD
18637	24015	183	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	184	,	,	,
18637	24015	185	99	99	CD
18637	24015	186	Long	Long	NNP
18637	24015	187	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	188	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	189	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	190	Rockwood	Rockwood	NNP
18637	24015	191	,	,	,
18637	24015	192	277	277	CD
18637	24015	193	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	194	142	142	CD
18637	24015	195	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	196	1928	1928	CD
18637	24015	197	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	198	,	,	,
18637	24015	199	276	276	CD
18637	24015	200	,	,	,
18637	24015	201	734	734	CD
18637	24015	202	Long	Long	NNP
18637	24015	203	Island	Island	NNP
18637	24015	204	Water	Water	NNP
18637	24015	205	Supply	Supply	NNP
18637	24015	206	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24015	207	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	208	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	209	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	210	Brooklyn	Brooklyn	NNP
18637	24015	211	,	,	,
18637	24015	212	166	166	CD
18637	24015	213	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	214	685	685	CD
18637	24015	215	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	216	1897	1897	CD
18637	24015	217	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	218	,	,	,
18637	24015	219	1063	1063	CD
18637	24015	220	,	,	,
18637	24015	221	1065	1065	CD
18637	24015	222	,	,	,
18637	24015	223	1069	1069	CD
18637	24015	224	,	,	,
18637	24015	225	1096	1096	CD
18637	24015	226	Long	Long	NNP
18637	24015	227	Sault	Sault	NNP
18637	24015	228	Development	Development	NNP
18637	24015	229	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24015	230	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	231	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	232	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	233	Call	Call	NNP
18637	24015	234	,	,	,
18637	24015	235	242	242	CD
18637	24015	236	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	237	272	272	CD
18637	24015	238	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	239	1916	1916	CD
18637	24015	240	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	241	,	,	,
18637	24015	242	329	329	CD
18637	24015	243	Longyear	Longyear	NNP
18637	24015	244	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	245	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	246	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	247	Toolan	Toolan	NNP
18637	24015	248	,	,	,
18637	24015	249	209	209	CD
18637	24015	250	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	251	414	414	CD
18637	24015	252	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	253	1908	1908	CD
18637	24015	254	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	255	,	,	,
18637	24015	256	1060	1060	CD
18637	24015	257	Look	look	VB
18637	24015	258	Tin	Tin	NNP
18637	24015	259	Sing	sing	NN
18637	24015	260	,	,	,
18637	24015	261	In	in	IN
18637	24015	262	re	re	NN
18637	24015	263	,	,	,
18637	24015	264	21	21	CD
18637	24015	265	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24015	266	905	905	CD
18637	24015	267	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	268	1884	1884	CD
18637	24015	269	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	270	,	,	,
18637	24015	271	964	964	CD
18637	24015	272	Looney	Looney	NNP
18637	24015	273	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	274	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	275	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	276	Crane	Crane	NNP
18637	24015	277	Company	Company	NNP
18637	24015	278	,	,	,
18637	24015	279	245	245	CD
18637	24015	280	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	281	178	178	CD
18637	24015	282	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	283	1917	1917	CD
18637	24015	284	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	285	,	,	,
18637	24015	286	196	196	CD
18637	24015	287	,	,	,
18637	24015	288	197	197	CD
18637	24015	289	,	,	,
18637	24015	290	1051	1051	CD
18637	24015	291	Looney	Looney	NNP
18637	24015	292	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	293	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	294	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	295	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	24015	296	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24015	297	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24015	298	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24015	299	,	,	,
18637	24015	300	247	247	CD
18637	24015	301	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	302	214	214	CD
18637	24015	303	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	304	1918	1918	CD
18637	24015	305	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	306	,	,	,
18637	24015	307	628	628	CD
18637	24015	308	Lorain	Lorain	NNP
18637	24015	309	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	24015	310	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	311	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	312	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	313	United	United	NNP
18637	24015	314	States	States	NNP
18637	24015	315	,	,	,
18637	24015	316	342	342	CD
18637	24015	317	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	318	143	143	CD
18637	24015	319	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	320	1951	1951	CD
18637	24015	321	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	322	,	,	,
18637	24015	323	793	793	CD
18637	24015	324	Lord	Lord	NNP
18637	24015	325	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	326	v.	v.	IN
18637	24015	327	_	_	NNP
18637	24015	328	Steamship	Steamship	NNP
18637	24015	329	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24015	330	,	,	,
18637	24015	331	102	102	CD
18637	24015	332	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24015	333	541	541	CD
18637	24015	334	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24015	335	1881	1881	CD
18637	24015	336	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24015	337	,	,	,
18637	24015	338	229	229	CD
18637	24015	339	Lord	Lord	NNP
18637	24015	340	de	de	NNP
18637	24015	341	la	la	NNP
18637	24015	342	Warre	Warre	NNP
18637	24015	343	's	's	POS
18637	24015	344	Case	Case	NNP
18637	24015	345	,	,	,
18637	24015	346	11	11	CD
18637	24015	347	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24015	348	Rep.	Rep.	NNP
18637	24015	349	1	1	CD
18637	24015	350	a	a	DT
18637	24015	351	,	,	,
18637	24015	352	77	77	CD
18637	24015	353	Eng	Eng	NNP
18637	24015	354	.	.	.
18637	24016	1	Repr	Repr	NNP
18637	24016	2	.	.	.
18637	24017	1	1145	1145	CD
18637	24017	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24017	3	1597	1597	CD
18637	24017	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24017	5	,	,	,
18637	24017	6	645	645	CD
18637	24017	7	Los	Los	NNP
18637	24017	8	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	24017	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24017	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24017	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24017	12	Los	Los	NNP
18637	24017	13	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	24017	14	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24017	15	&	&	CC
18637	24017	16	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	24017	17	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24017	18	,	,	,
18637	24017	19	251	251	CD
18637	24017	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24017	21	32	32	CD
18637	24017	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24017	23	1919	1919	CD
18637	24017	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24017	25	,	,	,
18637	24017	26	1009	1009	CD
18637	24017	27	Los	Los	NNP
18637	24017	28	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	24017	29	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24017	30	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24017	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24017	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24017	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24017	34	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	24018	1	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	24018	2	.	.	.
18637	24018	3	,	,	,
18637	24018	4	289	289	CD
18637	24018	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24018	6	287	287	CD
18637	24018	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24018	8	1933	1933	CD
18637	24018	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24018	10	,	,	,
18637	24018	11	1007	1007	CD
18637	24018	12	,	,	,
18637	24018	13	1008	1008	CD
18637	24018	14	Lothrop	Lothrop	NNP
18637	24018	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24018	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24018	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24018	18	Stedman	Stedman	NNP
18637	24018	19	,	,	,
18637	24018	20	15	15	CD
18637	24018	21	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24018	22	.	.	.
18637	24019	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24019	2	.	.	.
18637	24020	1	No	no	UH
18637	24020	2	.	.	.
18637	24021	1	8,519	8,519	CD
18637	24021	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24021	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	24021	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24021	5	,	,	,
18637	24021	6	344	344	CD
18637	24021	7	Lottawanna	Lottawanna	NNP
18637	24021	8	,	,	,
18637	24021	9	The	the	DT
18637	24021	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24021	11	Rodd	Rodd	NNP
18637	24021	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24021	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24021	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24021	15	Heartt	Heartt	NNP
18637	24021	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24021	17	,	,	,
18637	24021	18	21	21	CD
18637	24021	19	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24021	20	.	.	.
18637	24022	1	558	558	CD
18637	24022	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24022	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	24022	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24022	5	,	,	,
18637	24022	6	130	130	CD
18637	24022	7	,	,	,
18637	24022	8	579	579	CD
18637	24022	9	,	,	,
18637	24022	10	582	582	CD
18637	24022	11	,	,	,
18637	24022	12	583	583	CD
18637	24022	13	Lottery	Lottery	NNP
18637	24022	14	Cases	case	NNS
18637	24022	15	,	,	,
18637	24022	16	The	the	DT
18637	24022	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24022	18	Champion	Champion	NNP
18637	24022	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24022	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24022	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24022	22	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	24022	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24022	24	,	,	,
18637	24022	25	188	188	CD
18637	24022	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24022	27	321	321	CD
18637	24022	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24022	29	1903	1903	CD
18637	24022	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24022	31	,	,	,
18637	24022	32	124	124	CD
18637	24022	33	,	,	,
18637	24022	34	168	168	CD
18637	24022	35	,	,	,
18637	24022	36	169	169	CD
18637	24022	37	,	,	,
18637	24022	38	919	919	CD
18637	24022	39	Loughborough	Loughborough	NNP
18637	24022	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24022	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24022	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24022	43	Blake	Blake	NNP
18637	24022	44	,	,	,
18637	24022	45	5	5	CD
18637	24022	46	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24022	47	.	.	.
18637	24023	1	317	317	CD
18637	24023	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24023	3	1820	1820	CD
18637	24023	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24023	5	,	,	,
18637	24023	6	304	304	CD
18637	24023	7	,	,	,
18637	24023	8	321	321	CD
18637	24023	9	Loughran	Loughran	NNP
18637	24023	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24023	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24023	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24023	13	Loughran	Loughran	NNP
18637	24023	14	,	,	,
18637	24023	15	292	292	CD
18637	24023	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24023	17	216	216	CD
18637	24023	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24023	19	1934	1934	CD
18637	24023	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24023	21	,	,	,
18637	24023	22	671	671	CD
18637	24023	23	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24023	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24023	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24023	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24023	27	Cummins	Cummins	NNP
18637	24023	28	,	,	,
18637	24023	29	314	314	CD
18637	24023	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24023	31	577	577	CD
18637	24023	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24023	33	1941	1941	CD
18637	24023	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24023	35	,	,	,
18637	24023	36	613	613	CD
18637	24023	37	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24023	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24023	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24023	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24023	41	Garfield	Garfield	NNP
18637	24023	42	,	,	,
18637	24023	43	211	211	CD
18637	24023	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24023	45	70	70	CD
18637	24023	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24023	47	1908	1908	CD
18637	24023	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24023	49	,	,	,
18637	24023	50	588	588	CD
18637	24023	51	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24023	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24023	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	24023	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24023	55	McAdoo	McAdoo	NNP
18637	24023	56	,	,	,
18637	24023	57	234	234	CD
18637	24023	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24023	59	627	627	CD
18637	24023	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24023	61	1914	1914	CD
18637	24023	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24023	63	,	,	,
18637	24023	64	588	588	CD
18637	24023	65	,	,	,
18637	24023	66	590	590	CD
18637	24023	67	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24023	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24023	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	24023	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24023	71	Pilsbury	Pilsbury	NNP
18637	24023	72	,	,	,
18637	24023	73	105	105	CD
18637	24023	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24023	75	278	278	CD
18637	24023	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24023	77	1882	1882	CD
18637	24023	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24023	79	,	,	,
18637	24023	80	330	330	CD
18637	24023	81	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24023	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24023	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	24023	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24023	85	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24023	86	,	,	,
18637	24023	87	176	176	CD
18637	24023	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24023	89	1	1	CD
18637	24023	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24023	91	1900	1900	CD
18637	24023	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24023	93	,	,	,
18637	24023	94	217	217	CD
18637	24023	95	,	,	,
18637	24023	96	595	595	CD
18637	24023	97	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24023	98	ex	ex	FW
18637	24023	99	rel	rel	NN
18637	24023	100	.	.	.
18637	24024	1	Elliott	Elliott	NNP
18637	24024	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24024	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24024	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24024	5	Jumel	Jumel	NNP
18637	24024	6	,	,	,
18637	24024	7	107	107	CD
18637	24024	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24024	9	711	711	CD
18637	24024	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24024	11	1883	1883	CD
18637	24024	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24024	13	,	,	,
18637	24024	14	931	931	CD
18637	24024	15	,	,	,
18637	24024	16	932	932	CD
18637	24024	17	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24024	18	ex	ex	NN
18637	24024	19	rel	rel	NN
18637	24024	20	.	.	.
18637	24025	1	Folsom	Folsom	NNP
18637	24025	2	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	24025	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24025	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	24025	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24025	6	New	New	NNP
18637	24025	7	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24025	8	,	,	,
18637	24025	9	109	109	CD
18637	24025	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24025	11	285	285	CD
18637	24025	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24025	13	1883	1883	CD
18637	24025	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24025	15	,	,	,
18637	24025	16	343	343	CD
18637	24025	17	,	,	,
18637	24025	18	1036	1036	CD
18637	24025	19	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24025	20	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24025	21	rel	rel	NN
18637	24025	22	.	.	.
18637	24026	1	Francis	Francis	NNP
18637	24026	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24026	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24026	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24026	5	Resweber	Resweber	NNP
18637	24026	6	,	,	,
18637	24026	7	329	329	CD
18637	24026	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24026	9	459	459	CD
18637	24026	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24026	11	1947	1947	CD
18637	24026	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24026	13	,	,	,
18637	24026	14	1134	1134	CD
18637	24026	15	,	,	,
18637	24026	16	1136	1136	CD
18637	24026	17	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24026	18	ex	ex	NN
18637	24026	19	rel	rel	NN
18637	24026	20	.	.	.
18637	24027	1	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	24027	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24027	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24027	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24027	5	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24027	6	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	24027	7	's	's	POS
18637	24027	8	Parish	Parish	NNP
18637	24027	9	,	,	,
18637	24027	10	111	111	CD
18637	24027	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24027	12	716	716	CD
18637	24027	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24027	14	1884	1884	CD
18637	24027	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24027	16	,	,	,
18637	24027	17	356	356	CD
18637	24027	18	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24027	19	ex	ex	NN
18637	24027	20	rel	rel	NN
18637	24027	21	.	.	.
18637	24028	1	Ranger	Ranger	NNP
18637	24028	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24028	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24028	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24028	5	New	New	NNP
18637	24028	6	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24028	7	,	,	,
18637	24028	8	102	102	CD
18637	24028	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24028	10	203	203	CD
18637	24028	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24028	12	1880	1880	CD
18637	24028	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24028	14	,	,	,
18637	24028	15	355	355	CD
18637	24028	16	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24028	17	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24028	18	Service	Service	NNP
18637	24028	19	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	24028	20	.	.	.
18637	24029	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24029	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24029	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24029	4	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24029	5	&	&	CC
18637	24029	6	N.O.R.	N.O.R.	NNP
18637	24030	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24030	2	,	,	,
18637	24030	3	284	284	CD
18637	24030	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24030	5	125	125	CD
18637	24030	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24030	7	1931	1931	CD
18637	24030	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24030	9	,	,	,
18637	24030	10	219	219	CD
18637	24030	11	,	,	,
18637	24030	12	322	322	CD
18637	24030	13	,	,	,
18637	24030	14	323	323	CD
18637	24030	15	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24030	16	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	24030	17	.	.	.
18637	24031	1	&	&	CC
18637	24031	2	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	24031	3	.	.	.
18637	24032	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24032	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24032	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24032	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24032	5	New	New	NNP
18637	24032	6	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24032	7	,	,	,
18637	24032	8	235	235	CD
18637	24032	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24032	10	164	164	CD
18637	24032	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24032	12	1914	1914	CD
18637	24032	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24032	14	,	,	,
18637	24032	15	330	330	CD
18637	24032	16	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24032	17	&	&	CC
18637	24032	18	J.	J.	NNP
18637	24033	1	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	24033	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24033	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24033	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	24033	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24033	6	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	24033	7	,	,	,
18637	24033	8	188	188	CD
18637	24033	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24033	10	385	385	CD
18637	24033	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24033	12	1903	1903	CD
18637	24033	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24033	14	,	,	,
18637	24033	15	1041	1041	CD
18637	24033	16	,	,	,
18637	24033	17	1050	1050	CD
18637	24033	18	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24033	19	&	&	CC
18637	24033	20	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	24034	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24034	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24034	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24034	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24034	5	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	24034	6	Asphalt	Asphalt	NNP
18637	24034	7	Pav	Pav	NNP
18637	24034	8	.	.	.
18637	24035	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24035	2	,	,	,
18637	24035	3	197	197	CD
18637	24035	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24035	5	430	430	CD
18637	24035	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24035	7	1905	1905	CD
18637	24035	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24035	9	,	,	,
18637	24035	10	1041	1041	CD
18637	24035	11	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24035	12	&	&	CC
18637	24035	13	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	24036	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24036	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24036	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24036	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24036	5	Central	Central	NNP
18637	24036	6	Stockyards	Stockyards	NNPS
18637	24036	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24036	8	,	,	,
18637	24036	9	212	212	CD
18637	24036	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24036	11	132	132	CD
18637	24036	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24036	13	1909	1909	CD
18637	24036	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24036	15	,	,	,
18637	24036	16	685	685	CD
18637	24036	17	,	,	,
18637	24036	18	1013	1013	CD
18637	24036	19	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24036	20	&	&	CC
18637	24036	21	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	24037	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24037	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24037	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24037	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24037	5	Deer	Deer	NNP
18637	24037	6	,	,	,
18637	24037	7	200	200	CD
18637	24037	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24037	9	176	176	CD
18637	24037	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24037	11	1906	1906	CD
18637	24037	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24037	13	,	,	,
18637	24037	14	674	674	CD
18637	24037	15	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24037	16	&	&	CC
18637	24037	17	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	24038	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24038	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24038	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24038	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24038	5	Garrett	Garrett	NNP
18637	24038	6	,	,	,
18637	24038	7	231	231	CD
18637	24038	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24038	9	298	298	CD
18637	24038	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24038	11	1913	1913	CD
18637	24038	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24038	13	,	,	,
18637	24038	14	329	329	CD
18637	24038	15	,	,	,
18637	24038	16	1001	1001	CD
18637	24038	17	,	,	,
18637	24038	18	1004	1004	CD
18637	24038	19	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24038	20	&	&	CC
18637	24038	21	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	24039	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24039	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24039	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24039	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24039	5	Greene	Greene	NNP
18637	24039	6	,	,	,
18637	24039	7	244	244	CD
18637	24039	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24039	9	522	522	CD
18637	24039	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24039	11	1917	1917	CD
18637	24039	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24039	13	,	,	,
18637	24039	14	931	931	CD
18637	24039	15	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24039	16	&	&	CC
18637	24039	17	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	24040	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24040	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24040	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24040	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24040	5	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	24040	6	,	,	,
18637	24040	7	183	183	CD
18637	24040	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24040	9	503	503	CD
18637	24040	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24040	11	1902	1902	CD
18637	24040	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24040	13	,	,	,
18637	24040	14	1013	1013	CD
18637	24040	15	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24040	16	&	&	CC
18637	24040	17	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	24041	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24041	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24041	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24041	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24041	5	Mottley	Mottley	NNP
18637	24041	6	,	,	,
18637	24041	7	219	219	CD
18637	24041	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24041	9	467	467	CD
18637	24041	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24041	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	24041	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24041	13	,	,	,
18637	24041	14	137	137	CD
18637	24041	15	,	,	,
18637	24041	16	219	219	CD
18637	24041	17	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24041	18	&	&	CC
18637	24041	19	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	24042	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24042	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24042	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24042	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24042	5	Palmes	Palmes	NNP
18637	24042	6	,	,	,
18637	24042	7	109	109	CD
18637	24042	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24042	9	244	244	CD
18637	24042	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24042	11	1883	1883	CD
18637	24042	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24042	13	,	,	,
18637	24042	14	347	347	CD
18637	24042	15	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24042	16	&	&	CC
18637	24042	17	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	24043	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24043	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24043	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24043	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24043	5	Parker	Parker	NNP
18637	24043	6	,	,	,
18637	24043	7	242	242	CD
18637	24043	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24043	9	13	13	CD
18637	24043	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24043	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	24043	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24043	13	,	,	,
18637	24043	14	141	141	CD
18637	24043	15	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24043	16	&	&	CC
18637	24043	17	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	24044	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24044	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24044	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24044	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24044	5	Schmidt	Schmidt	NNP
18637	24044	6	,	,	,
18637	24044	7	177	177	CD
18637	24044	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24044	9	230	230	CD
18637	24044	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24044	11	1900	1900	CD
18637	24044	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24044	13	,	,	,
18637	24044	14	1073	1073	CD
18637	24044	15	,	,	,
18637	24044	16	1088	1088	CD
18637	24044	17	,	,	,
18637	24044	18	1089	1089	CD
18637	24044	19	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24044	20	,	,	,
18637	24044	21	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	24044	22	&	&	CC
18637	24044	23	Charleston	Charleston	NNP
18637	24044	24	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24044	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24044	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24044	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24044	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24044	29	Letson	Letson	NNP
18637	24044	30	,	,	,
18637	24044	31	2	2	CD
18637	24044	32	How	how	WRB
18637	24044	33	.	.	.
18637	24045	1	497	497	CD
18637	24045	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24045	3	1844	1844	CD
18637	24045	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24045	5	,	,	,
18637	24045	6	601	601	CD
18637	24045	7	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24045	8	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24045	9	&	&	CC
18637	24045	10	E.	E.	NNP
18637	24045	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24045	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24045	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24045	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24045	15	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	24045	16	,	,	,
18637	24045	17	277	277	CD
18637	24045	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24045	19	32	32	CD
18637	24045	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24045	21	1928	1928	CD
18637	24045	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24045	23	,	,	,
18637	24045	24	1147	1147	CD
18637	24045	25	,	,	,
18637	24045	26	1149	1149	CD
18637	24045	27	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24045	28	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	24045	29	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	24045	30	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24045	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24045	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24045	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24045	34	Radford	Radford	NNP
18637	24045	35	,	,	,
18637	24045	36	295	295	CD
18637	24045	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24045	38	555	555	CD
18637	24045	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24045	40	1935	1935	CD
18637	24045	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24045	42	,	,	,
18637	24045	43	264	264	CD
18637	24045	44	,	,	,
18637	24045	45	362	362	CD
18637	24045	46	,	,	,
18637	24045	47	858	858	CD
18637	24045	48	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24045	49	Water	Water	NNP
18637	24045	50	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24045	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24045	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	24045	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24045	54	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	24045	55	,	,	,
18637	24045	56	143	143	CD
18637	24045	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24045	58	1	1	CD
18637	24045	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24045	60	1892	1892	CD
18637	24045	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24045	62	,	,	,
18637	24045	63	343	343	CD
18637	24045	64	,	,	,
18637	24045	65	846	846	CD
18637	24045	66	,	,	,
18637	24045	67	877	877	CD
18637	24045	68	Lovell	Lovell	NNP
18637	24045	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24045	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	24045	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24045	72	City	City	NNP
18637	24045	73	of	of	IN
18637	24045	74	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
18637	24045	75	,	,	,
18637	24045	76	303	303	CD
18637	24045	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24045	78	444	444	CD
18637	24045	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24045	80	1938	1938	CD
18637	24045	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24045	82	,	,	,
18637	24045	83	570	570	CD
18637	24045	84	,	,	,
18637	24045	85	786	786	CD
18637	24045	86	,	,	,
18637	24045	87	788	788	CD
18637	24045	88	Low	Low	NNP
18637	24045	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24045	90	v.	v.	NN
18637	24045	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24045	92	Austin	Austin	NNP
18637	24045	93	,	,	,
18637	24045	94	13	13	CD
18637	24045	95	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24045	96	.	.	.
18637	24046	1	29	29	CD
18637	24046	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24046	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	24046	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24046	5	,	,	,
18637	24046	6	303	303	CD
18637	24046	7	,	,	,
18637	24046	8	364	364	CD
18637	24046	9	Lowe	Lowe	NNP
18637	24046	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24046	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24046	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24046	13	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24046	14	,	,	,
18637	24046	15	163	163	CD
18637	24046	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24046	17	81	81	CD
18637	24046	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24046	19	1896	1896	CD
18637	24046	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24046	21	,	,	,
18637	24046	22	1092	1092	CD
18637	24046	23	,	,	,
18637	24046	24	1167	1167	CD
18637	24046	25	Lucas	Lucas	NNP
18637	24046	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24046	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24046	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24046	29	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	24046	30	,	,	,
18637	24046	31	279	279	CD
18637	24046	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24046	33	573	573	CD
18637	24046	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24046	35	1929	1929	CD
18637	24046	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24046	37	,	,	,
18637	24046	38	1199	1199	CD
18637	24046	39	Luckenbach	Luckenbach	NNP
18637	24046	40	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	24046	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24046	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24046	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24046	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24046	45	United	United	NNP
18637	24046	46	States	States	NNP
18637	24046	47	,	,	,
18637	24046	48	272	272	CD
18637	24046	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24046	50	533	533	CD
18637	24046	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24046	52	1926	1926	CD
18637	24046	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24046	54	,	,	,
18637	24046	55	616	616	CD
18637	24046	56	Ludecke	Ludecke	NNP
18637	24046	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24046	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	24046	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24046	60	Watkins	Watkins	NNP
18637	24046	61	,	,	,
18637	24046	62	335	335	CD
18637	24046	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24046	64	160	160	CD
18637	24046	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24046	66	1948	1948	CD
18637	24046	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24046	68	,	,	,
18637	24046	69	293	293	CD
18637	24046	70	,	,	,
18637	24046	71	298	298	CD
18637	24046	72	,	,	,
18637	24046	73	474	474	CD
18637	24046	74	,	,	,
18637	24046	75	548	548	CD
18637	24046	76	,	,	,
18637	24046	77	853	853	CD
18637	24046	78	Ludwig	Ludwig	NNP
18637	24046	79	_	_	NNP
18637	24046	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	24046	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24046	82	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24046	83	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24046	84	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24046	85	.	.	.
18637	24047	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24047	2	,	,	,
18637	24047	3	216	216	CD
18637	24047	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24047	5	146	146	CD
18637	24047	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24047	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	24047	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24047	9	,	,	,
18637	24047	10	196	196	CD
18637	24047	11	Lugo	Lugo	NNP
18637	24047	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24047	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24047	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24047	15	Suazo	Suazo	NNP
18637	24047	16	,	,	,
18637	24047	17	59	59	CD
18637	24047	18	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24047	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24047	20	2d	2d	CD
18637	24047	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24047	22	386	386	CD
18637	24047	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24047	24	1932	1932	CD
18637	24047	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24047	26	,	,	,
18637	24047	27	214	214	CD
18637	24047	28	Luke	Luke	NNP
18637	24047	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24047	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24047	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24047	32	Lyde	Lyde	NNP
18637	24047	33	,	,	,
18637	24047	34	2	2	CD
18637	24047	35	Burr	Burr	NNS
18637	24047	36	.	.	.
18637	24048	1	883	883	CD
18637	24048	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24048	3	1759	1759	CD
18637	24048	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24048	5	,	,	,
18637	24048	6	604	604	CD
18637	24048	7	Luria	Luria	NNP
18637	24048	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24048	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24048	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24048	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24048	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24048	13	,	,	,
18637	24048	14	231	231	CD
18637	24048	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24048	16	9	9	CD
18637	24048	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24048	18	1913	1913	CD
18637	24048	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24048	20	,	,	,
18637	24048	21	849	849	CD
18637	24048	22	,	,	,
18637	24048	23	893	893	CD
18637	24048	24	Lustig	Lustig	NNP
18637	24048	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24048	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24048	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24048	28	United	United	NNP
18637	24048	29	States	States	NNP
18637	24048	30	,	,	,
18637	24048	31	338	338	CD
18637	24048	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24048	33	74	74	CD
18637	24048	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24048	35	1949	1949	CD
18637	24048	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24048	37	,	,	,
18637	24048	38	831	831	CD
18637	24048	39	Luther	Luther	NNP
18637	24048	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24048	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24048	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24048	43	Borden	Borden	NNP
18637	24048	44	,	,	,
18637	24048	45	7	7	CD
18637	24048	46	How	how	WRB
18637	24048	47	.	.	.
18637	24049	1	1	1	CD
18637	24049	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24049	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	24049	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24049	5	,	,	,
18637	24049	6	386	386	CD
18637	24049	7	,	,	,
18637	24049	8	399	399	CD
18637	24049	9	,	,	,
18637	24049	10	546	546	CD
18637	24049	11	,	,	,
18637	24049	12	548	548	CD
18637	24049	13	,	,	,
18637	24049	14	705	705	CD
18637	24049	15	Luxton	Luxton	NNP
18637	24049	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24049	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	19	North	North	NNP
18637	24049	20	River	River	NNP
18637	24049	21	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	24049	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24049	23	,	,	,
18637	24049	24	153	153	CD
18637	24049	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24049	26	525	525	CD
18637	24049	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24049	28	1894	1894	CD
18637	24049	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24049	30	,	,	,
18637	24049	31	132	132	CD
18637	24049	32	,	,	,
18637	24049	33	310	310	CD
18637	24049	34	Lynch	Lynch	NNP
18637	24049	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24049	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	38	Hornby	Hornby	NNP
18637	24049	39	,	,	,
18637	24049	40	247	247	CD
18637	24049	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24049	42	339	339	CD
18637	24049	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24049	44	1918	1918	CD
18637	24049	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24049	46	,	,	,
18637	24049	47	863	863	CD
18637	24049	48	,	,	,
18637	24049	49	1193	1193	CD
18637	24049	50	Lynch	Lynch	NNP
18637	24049	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	24049	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	54	Turrish	Turrish	NNP
18637	24049	55	,	,	,
18637	24049	56	247	247	CD
18637	24049	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24049	58	221	221	CD
18637	24049	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24049	60	1918	1918	CD
18637	24049	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24049	62	,	,	,
18637	24049	63	1193	1193	CD
18637	24049	64	Lynch	Lynch	NNP
18637	24049	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	24049	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	68	United	United	NNP
18637	24049	69	States	States	NNP
18637	24049	70	,	,	,
18637	24049	71	292	292	CD
18637	24049	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24049	73	571	571	CD
18637	24049	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24049	75	1934	1934	CD
18637	24049	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24049	77	,	,	,
18637	24049	78	118	118	CD
18637	24049	79	,	,	,
18637	24049	80	857	857	CD
18637	24049	81	,	,	,
18637	24049	82	858	858	CD
18637	24049	83	Lynde	Lynde	NNP
18637	24049	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	24049	86	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	87	Lynde	Lynde	NNP
18637	24049	88	,	,	,
18637	24049	89	181	181	CD
18637	24049	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24049	91	183	183	CD
18637	24049	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24049	93	1901	1901	CD
18637	24049	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24049	95	,	,	,
18637	24049	96	671	671	CD
18637	24049	97	Lyon	Lyon	NNP
18637	24049	98	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	99	v.	v.	IN
18637	24049	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	101	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	24049	102	Benefit	Benefit	NNP
18637	24049	103	Health	Health	NNP
18637	24049	104	&	&	CC
18637	24049	105	Accident	Accident	NNP
18637	24049	106	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	24049	107	.	.	NNP
18637	24049	108	,	,	,
18637	24049	109	305	305	CD
18637	24049	110	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24049	111	484	484	CD
18637	24049	112	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24049	113	1039	1039	CD
18637	24049	114	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24049	115	,	,	,
18637	24049	116	897	897	CD
18637	24049	117	Lyons	Lyons	NNPS
18637	24049	118	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	24049	120	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	121	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24049	122	,	,	,
18637	24049	123	322	322	CD
18637	24049	124	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24049	125	596	596	CD
18637	24049	126	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24049	127	1944	1944	CD
18637	24049	128	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24049	129	,	,	,
18637	24049	130	1114	1114	CD
18637	24049	131	,	,	,
18637	24049	132	1115	1115	CD
18637	24049	133	,	,	,
18637	24049	134	1141	1141	CD
18637	24049	135	M	M	NNP
18637	24049	136	Mabee	Mabee	NNP
18637	24049	137	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	138	v.	v.	IN
18637	24049	139	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	140	White	White	NNP
18637	24049	141	Plains	Plains	NNPS
18637	24049	142	Publishing	Publishing	NNP
18637	24049	143	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24049	144	,	,	,
18637	24049	145	327	327	CD
18637	24049	146	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24049	147	178	178	CD
18637	24049	148	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24049	149	1946	1946	CD
18637	24049	150	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24049	151	,	,	,
18637	24049	152	158	158	CD
18637	24049	153	Macallen	Macallen	NNP
18637	24049	154	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	155	v.	v.	IN
18637	24049	156	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	157	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24049	158	,	,	,
18637	24049	159	279	279	CD
18637	24049	160	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24049	161	620	620	CD
18637	24049	162	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24049	163	1929	1929	CD
18637	24049	164	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24049	165	,	,	,
18637	24049	166	730	730	CD
18637	24049	167	MacDougall	MacDougall	NNP
18637	24049	168	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	169	v.	v.	IN
18637	24049	170	_	_	NNP
18637	24049	171	Green	Green	NNP
18637	24049	172	,	,	,
18637	24049	173	335	335	CD
18637	24049	174	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24049	175	281	281	CD
18637	24049	176	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24049	177	1948	1948	CD
18637	24049	178	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24049	179	,	,	,
18637	24049	180	548	548	CD
18637	24049	181	,	,	,
18637	24049	182	971	971	CD
18637	24049	183	,	,	,
18637	24049	184	1165	1165	CD
18637	24049	185	,	,	,
18637	24049	186	1208	1208	CD
18637	24049	187	Mackay	Mackay	NNP
18637	24049	188	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24049	189	.	.	.
18637	24050	1	&	&	CC
18637	24050	2	Cable	Cable	NNP
18637	24050	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24050	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24050	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	24050	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24050	7	Little	Little	NNP
18637	24050	8	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	24050	9	,	,	,
18637	24050	10	250	250	CD
18637	24050	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24050	12	94	94	CD
18637	24050	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24050	14	1919	1919	CD
18637	24050	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24050	16	,	,	,
18637	24050	17	214	214	CD
18637	24050	18	Mackenzie	Mackenzie	NNP
18637	24050	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24050	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24050	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24050	22	Hare	Hare	NNP
18637	24050	23	,	,	,
18637	24050	24	239	239	CD
18637	24050	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24050	26	299	299	CD
18637	24050	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24050	28	1915	1915	CD
18637	24050	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24050	30	,	,	,
18637	24050	31	255	255	CD
18637	24050	32	,	,	,
18637	24050	33	259	259	CD
18637	24050	34	Mackin	Mackin	NNP
18637	24050	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24050	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24050	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24050	38	United	United	NNP
18637	24050	39	States	States	NNP
18637	24050	40	,	,	,
18637	24050	41	117	117	CD
18637	24050	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24050	43	348	348	CD
18637	24050	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24050	45	1886	1886	CD
18637	24050	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24050	47	,	,	,
18637	24050	48	838	838	CD
18637	24050	49	MacLaughlin	MacLaughlin	NNP
18637	24050	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24050	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	24050	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24050	53	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	24050	54	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24050	55	.	.	.
18637	24051	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24051	2	,	,	,
18637	24051	3	286	286	CD
18637	24051	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24051	5	244	244	CD
18637	24051	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24051	7	1932	1932	CD
18637	24051	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24051	9	,	,	,
18637	24051	10	1200	1200	CD
18637	24051	11	Madden	Madden	NNP
18637	24051	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24051	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24051	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24051	15	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	24051	16	,	,	,
18637	24051	17	309	309	CD
18637	24051	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24051	19	83	83	CD
18637	24051	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24051	21	1940	1940	CD
18637	24051	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24051	23	,	,	,
18637	24051	24	563	563	CD
18637	24051	25	,	,	,
18637	24051	26	693	693	CD
18637	24051	27	,	,	,
18637	24051	28	969	969	CD
18637	24051	29	,	,	,
18637	24051	30	971	971	CD
18637	24051	31	,	,	,
18637	24051	32	1145	1145	CD
18637	24051	33	,	,	,
18637	24051	34	1148	1148	CD
18637	24051	35	Madera	Madera	NNP
18637	24051	36	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	24051	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24051	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	24051	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24051	40	Madera	Madera	NNP
18637	24051	41	,	,	,
18637	24051	42	228	228	CD
18637	24051	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24051	44	454	454	CD
18637	24051	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24051	46	1913	1913	CD
18637	24051	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24051	48	,	,	,
18637	24051	49	349	349	CD
18637	24051	50	,	,	,
18637	24051	51	1009	1009	CD
18637	24051	52	Madisonville	Madisonville	NNP
18637	24051	53	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	24051	54	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24051	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24051	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24051	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24051	58	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24051	59	Bernard	Bernard	NNP
18637	24051	60	Min	Min	NNP
18637	24051	61	.	.	.
18637	24052	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24052	2	,	,	,
18637	24052	3	196	196	CD
18637	24052	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24052	5	239	239	CD
18637	24052	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24052	7	1905	1905	CD
18637	24052	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24052	9	,	,	,
18637	24052	10	629	629	CD
18637	24052	11	Madsen	Madsen	NNP
18637	24052	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24052	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24052	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24052	15	Kinsella	Kinsella	NNP
18637	24052	16	,	,	,
18637	24052	17	343	343	CD
18637	24052	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24052	19	341	341	CD
18637	24052	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24052	21	1952	1952	CD
18637	24052	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24052	23	,	,	,
18637	24052	24	404	404	CD
18637	24052	25	,	,	,
18637	24052	26	493	493	CD
18637	24052	27	Mager	Mager	NNP
18637	24052	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24052	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24052	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24052	31	Grima	Grima	NNP
18637	24052	32	,	,	,
18637	24052	33	8	8	CD
18637	24052	34	How	how	WRB
18637	24052	35	.	.	.
18637	24053	1	490	490	CD
18637	24053	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24053	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	24053	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24053	5	,	,	,
18637	24053	6	364	364	CD
18637	24053	7	Magnano	Magnano	NNP
18637	24053	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24053	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24053	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24053	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24053	12	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	24053	13	,	,	,
18637	24053	14	292	292	CD
18637	24053	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24053	16	40	40	CD
18637	24053	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24053	18	1934	1934	CD
18637	24053	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24053	20	,	,	,
18637	24053	21	111	111	CD
18637	24053	22	,	,	,
18637	24053	23	1030	1030	CD
18637	24053	24	,	,	,
18637	24053	25	1148	1148	CD
18637	24053	26	Magniac	Magniac	NNP
18637	24053	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24053	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24053	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24053	30	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24053	31	,	,	,
18637	24053	32	7	7	CD
18637	24053	33	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	24053	34	.	.	.
18637	24054	1	348	348	CD
18637	24054	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24054	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	24054	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24054	5	,	,	,
18637	24054	6	896	896	CD
18637	24054	7	Magnolia	Magnolia	NNP
18637	24054	8	Petroleum	Petroleum	NNP
18637	24054	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24054	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24054	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24054	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24054	13	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
18637	24054	14	,	,	,
18637	24054	15	320	320	CD
18637	24054	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24054	17	430	430	CD
18637	24054	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24054	19	1943	1943	CD
18637	24054	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24054	21	,	,	,
18637	24054	22	682	682	CD
18637	24054	23	Magoun	Magoun	NNP
18637	24054	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24054	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24054	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24054	27	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	24054	28	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24054	29	&	&	CC
18637	24054	30	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	24054	31	.	.	.
18637	24055	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24055	2	,	,	,
18637	24055	3	170	170	CD
18637	24055	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24055	5	283	283	CD
18637	24055	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24055	7	1898	1898	CD
18637	24055	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24055	9	,	,	,
18637	24055	10	1151	1151	CD
18637	24055	11	Maguire	Maguire	NNP
18637	24055	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24055	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	15	Reardon	Reardon	NNP
18637	24055	16	,	,	,
18637	24055	17	255	255	CD
18637	24055	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24055	19	271	271	CD
18637	24055	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24055	21	1921	1921	CD
18637	24055	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24055	23	,	,	,
18637	24055	24	1029	1029	CD
18637	24055	25	Maguire	Maguire	NNP
18637	24055	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24055	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	29	Trefry	Trefry	NNP
18637	24055	30	,	,	,
18637	24055	31	253	253	CD
18637	24055	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24055	33	12	12	CD
18637	24055	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24055	35	1920	1920	CD
18637	24055	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24055	37	,	,	,
18637	24055	38	1054	1054	CD
18637	24055	39	Mahler	Mahler	NNP
18637	24055	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24055	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	43	Eby	Eby	NNP
18637	24055	44	,	,	,
18637	24055	45	264	264	CD
18637	24055	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24055	47	32	32	CD
18637	24055	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24055	49	1924	1924	CD
18637	24055	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24055	51	,	,	,
18637	24055	52	78	78	CD
18637	24055	53	,	,	,
18637	24055	54	317	317	CD
18637	24055	55	,	,	,
18637	24055	56	853	853	CD
18637	24055	57	Mahn	Mahn	NNP
18637	24055	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24055	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	61	Hardwood	Hardwood	NNP
18637	24055	62	,	,	,
18637	24055	63	112	112	CD
18637	24055	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24055	65	354	354	CD
18637	24055	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24055	67	1884	1884	CD
18637	24055	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24055	69	,	,	,
18637	24055	70	274	274	CD
18637	24055	71	Mahnich	Mahnich	NNP
18637	24055	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	24055	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	75	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24055	76	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	24055	77	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24055	78	,	,	,
18637	24055	79	321	321	CD
18637	24055	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24055	81	96	96	CD
18637	24055	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24055	83	1944	1944	CD
18637	24055	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24055	85	,	,	,
18637	24055	86	566	566	CD
18637	24055	87	Mahon	Mahon	NNP
18637	24055	88	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	24055	90	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	91	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	24055	92	,	,	,
18637	24055	93	127	127	CD
18637	24055	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24055	95	700	700	CD
18637	24055	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24055	97	1888	1888	CD
18637	24055	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24055	99	,	,	,
18637	24055	100	696	696	CD
18637	24055	101	Mahoney	Mahoney	NNP
18637	24055	102	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	103	v.	v.	IN
18637	24055	104	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	105	Triner	Triner	NNP
18637	24055	106	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24055	107	,	,	,
18637	24055	108	304	304	CD
18637	24055	109	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24055	110	401	401	CD
18637	24055	111	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24055	112	1938	1938	CD
18637	24055	113	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24055	114	,	,	,
18637	24055	115	1231	1231	CD
18637	24055	116	Maine	Maine	NNP
18637	24055	117	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	118	v.	v.	IN
18637	24055	119	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	120	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	24055	121	Trunk	Trunk	NNP
18637	24055	122	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24055	123	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24055	124	,	,	,
18637	24055	125	142	142	CD
18637	24055	126	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24055	127	217	217	CD
18637	24055	128	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24055	129	1891	1891	CD
18637	24055	130	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24055	131	,	,	,
18637	24055	132	202	202	CD
18637	24055	133	,	,	,
18637	24055	134	207	207	CD
18637	24055	135	Maiorano	Maiorano	NNP
18637	24055	136	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	137	v.	v.	IN
18637	24055	138	_	_	NNP
18637	24055	139	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	24055	140	&	&	CC
18637	24055	141	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	24056	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24056	2	,	,	,
18637	24056	3	213	213	CD
18637	24056	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24056	5	268	268	CD
18637	24056	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24056	7	1909	1909	CD
18637	24056	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24056	9	,	,	,
18637	24056	10	416	416	CD
18637	24056	11	Malinski	Malinski	NNP
18637	24056	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24056	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24056	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24056	15	New	New	NNP
18637	24056	16	York	York	NNP
18637	24056	17	,	,	,
18637	24056	18	324	324	CD
18637	24056	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24056	20	401	401	CD
18637	24056	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24056	22	1945	1945	CD
18637	24056	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24056	24	,	,	,
18637	24056	25	1114	1114	CD
18637	24056	26	,	,	,
18637	24056	27	1115	1115	CD
18637	24056	28	,	,	,
18637	24056	29	1117	1117	CD
18637	24056	30	,	,	,
18637	24056	31	1121	1121	CD
18637	24056	32	,	,	,
18637	24056	33	1123	1123	CD
18637	24056	34	,	,	,
18637	24056	35	1124	1124	CD
18637	24056	36	Mallett	Mallett	NNP
18637	24056	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24056	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	24056	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24056	40	North	North	NNP
18637	24056	41	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24056	42	,	,	,
18637	24056	43	181	181	CD
18637	24056	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24056	45	589	589	CD
18637	24056	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24056	47	1901	1901	CD
18637	24056	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24056	49	,	,	,
18637	24056	50	329	329	CD
18637	24056	51	,	,	,
18637	24056	52	1166	1166	CD
18637	24056	53	Mallinckrodt	Mallinckrodt	NNP
18637	24056	54	Chemical	Chemical	NNP
18637	24056	55	Works	Works	NNPS
18637	24056	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24056	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24056	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24056	59	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24056	60	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24056	61	rel	rel	NN
18637	24056	62	.	.	.
18637	24057	1	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	24057	2	,	,	,
18637	24057	3	238	238	CD
18637	24057	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24057	5	41	41	CD
18637	24057	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24057	7	1915	1915	CD
18637	24057	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24057	9	,	,	,
18637	24057	10	1160	1160	CD
18637	24057	11	Malloy	Malloy	NNP
18637	24057	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24057	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24057	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24057	15	South	South	NNP
18637	24057	16	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24057	17	,	,	,
18637	24057	18	237	237	CD
18637	24057	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24057	20	180	180	CD
18637	24057	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24057	22	1915	1915	CD
18637	24057	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24057	24	,	,	,
18637	24057	25	328	328	CD
18637	24057	26	Manchester	Manchester	NNP
18637	24057	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24057	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24057	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24057	30	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24057	31	,	,	,
18637	24057	32	139	139	CD
18637	24057	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24057	34	240	240	CD
18637	24057	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24057	36	1891	1891	CD
18637	24057	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24057	38	,	,	,
18637	24057	39	578	578	CD
18637	24057	40	,	,	,
18637	24057	41	1027	1027	CD
18637	24057	42	Mandeville	Mandeville	NNP
18637	24057	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24057	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24057	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24057	46	Canterbury	Canterbury	NNP
18637	24057	47	,	,	,
18637	24057	48	318	318	CD
18637	24057	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24057	50	47	47	CD
18637	24057	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24057	52	1943	1943	CD
18637	24057	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24057	54	,	,	,
18637	24057	55	627	627	CD
18637	24057	56	Mandeville	Mandeville	NNP
18637	24057	57	Is	be	VBZ
18637	24057	58	.	.	.
18637	24058	1	Farms	Farms	NNP
18637	24058	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24058	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24058	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24058	5	American	American	NNP
18637	24058	6	C.S.	C.S.	NNP
18637	24059	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24059	2	,	,	,
18637	24059	3	334	334	CD
18637	24059	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24059	5	219	219	CD
18637	24059	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24059	7	1948	1948	CD
18637	24059	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24059	9	,	,	,
18637	24059	10	143	143	CD
18637	24059	11	,	,	,
18637	24059	12	147	147	CD
18637	24059	13	Manhattan	Manhattan	NNP
18637	24059	14	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24059	15	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24059	16	.	.	.
18637	24060	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24060	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24060	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24060	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24060	5	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
18637	24060	6	,	,	,
18637	24060	7	234	234	CD
18637	24060	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24060	9	123	123	CD
18637	24060	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24060	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	24060	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24060	13	,	,	,
18637	24060	14	1167	1167	CD
18637	24060	15	Manigault	Manigault	NNP
18637	24060	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24060	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24060	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24060	19	Springs	Springs	NNP
18637	24060	20	,	,	,
18637	24060	21	199	199	CD
18637	24060	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24060	23	473	473	CD
18637	24060	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24060	25	1905	1905	CD
18637	24060	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24060	27	,	,	,
18637	24060	28	357	357	CD
18637	24060	29	,	,	,
18637	24060	30	358	358	CD
18637	24060	31	,	,	,
18637	24060	32	1067	1067	CD
18637	24060	33	Mankin	Mankin	NNP
18637	24060	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24060	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	24060	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24060	37	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	24060	38	&	&	CC
18637	24060	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24060	40	,	,	,
18637	24060	41	2	2	CD
18637	24060	42	Brock	Brock	NNP
18637	24060	43	.	.	.
18637	24061	1	125	125	CD
18637	24061	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24061	3	1823	1823	CD
18637	24061	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24061	5	,	,	,
18637	24061	6	653	653	CD
18637	24061	7	Manley	Manley	NNP
18637	24061	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24061	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24061	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24061	11	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	24061	12	,	,	,
18637	24061	13	279	279	CD
18637	24061	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24061	15	1	1	CD
18637	24061	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24061	17	1929	1929	CD
18637	24061	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24061	19	,	,	,
18637	24061	20	1094	1094	CD
18637	24061	21	,	,	,
18637	24061	22	1095	1095	CD
18637	24061	23	Mantle	Mantle	NNP
18637	24061	24	Lamp	Lamp	NNP
18637	24061	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24061	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24061	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24061	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24061	29	Aluminum	Aluminum	NNP
18637	24061	30	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24061	31	,	,	,
18637	24061	32	301	301	CD
18637	24061	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24061	34	544	544	CD
18637	24061	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24061	36	1937	1937	CD
18637	24061	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24061	38	,	,	,
18637	24061	39	273	273	CD
18637	24061	40	Manuel	Manuel	NNP
18637	24061	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24061	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24061	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24061	44	Wulff	Wulff	NNP
18637	24061	45	,	,	,
18637	24061	46	152	152	CD
18637	24061	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24061	48	505	505	CD
18637	24061	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24061	50	1894	1894	CD
18637	24061	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24061	52	,	,	,
18637	24061	53	258	258	CD
18637	24061	54	Marbles	Marbles	NNPS
18637	24061	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24061	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24061	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24061	58	Creecy	Creecy	NNP
18637	24061	59	,	,	,
18637	24061	60	215	215	CD
18637	24061	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24061	62	63	63	CD
18637	24061	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24061	64	1909	1909	CD
18637	24061	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24061	66	,	,	,
18637	24061	67	695	695	CD
18637	24061	68	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
18637	24061	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24061	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	24061	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24061	72	Madison	Madison	NNP
18637	24061	73	,	,	,
18637	24061	74	1	1	CD
18637	24061	75	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24061	76	.	.	.
18637	24062	1	137	137	CD
18637	24062	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24062	3	1803	1803	CD
18637	24062	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24062	5	,	,	,
18637	24062	6	101	101	CD
18637	24062	7	,	,	,
18637	24062	8	341	341	CD
18637	24062	9	,	,	,
18637	24062	10	453	453	CD
18637	24062	11	,	,	,
18637	24062	12	454	454	CD
18637	24062	13	,	,	,
18637	24062	14	458	458	CD
18637	24062	15	,	,	,
18637	24062	16	460	460	CD
18637	24062	17	,	,	,
18637	24062	18	478	478	CD
18637	24062	19	,	,	,
18637	24062	20	522	522	CD
18637	24062	21	,	,	,
18637	24062	22	545	545	CD
18637	24062	23	,	,	,
18637	24062	24	546	546	CD
18637	24062	25	,	,	,
18637	24062	26	559	559	CD
18637	24062	27	,	,	,
18637	24062	28	560	560	CD
18637	24062	29	,	,	,
18637	24062	30	612	612	CD
18637	24062	31	Marchant	Marchant	NNP
18637	24062	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24062	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	24062	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24062	35	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24062	36	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24062	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24062	38	,	,	,
18637	24062	39	153	153	CD
18637	24062	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24062	41	380	380	CD
18637	24062	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24062	43	1894	1894	CD
18637	24062	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24062	45	,	,	,
18637	24062	46	1068	1068	CD
18637	24062	47	,	,	,
18637	24062	48	1071	1071	CD
18637	24062	49	Marconi	Marconi	NNP
18637	24062	50	Wireless	Wireless	NNP
18637	24062	51	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24062	52	.	.	.
18637	24063	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24063	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24063	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24063	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24063	5	United	United	NNP
18637	24063	6	States	States	NNP
18637	24063	7	,	,	,
18637	24063	8	320	320	CD
18637	24063	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24063	10	1	1	CD
18637	24063	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24063	12	1943	1943	CD
18637	24063	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24063	14	,	,	,
18637	24063	15	272	272	CD
18637	24063	16	Margolin	Margolin	NNP
18637	24063	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24063	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24063	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24063	20	United	United	NNP
18637	24063	21	States	States	NNP
18637	24063	22	,	,	,
18637	24063	23	269	269	CD
18637	24063	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24063	25	93	93	CD
18637	24063	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24063	27	1925	1925	CD
18637	24063	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24063	29	,	,	,
18637	24063	30	857	857	CD
18637	24063	31	Marianna	Marianna	NNP
18637	24063	32	Flora	Flora	NNP
18637	24063	33	,	,	,
18637	24063	34	The	the	DT
18637	24063	35	,	,	,
18637	24063	36	11	11	CD
18637	24063	37	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24063	38	.	.	.
18637	24064	1	1	1	CD
18637	24064	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24064	3	1826	1826	CD
18637	24064	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24064	5	,	,	,
18637	24064	6	278	278	CD
18637	24064	7	Maricopa	Maricopa	NNP
18637	24064	8	County	County	NNP
18637	24064	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24064	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	12	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	24064	13	National	National	NNP
18637	24064	14	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24064	15	,	,	,
18637	24064	16	318	318	CD
18637	24064	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24064	18	357	357	CD
18637	24064	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24064	20	1943	1943	CD
18637	24064	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24064	22	,	,	,
18637	24064	23	734	734	CD
18637	24064	24	Marin	Marin	NNP
18637	24064	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24064	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	28	Augedahl	Augedahl	NNP
18637	24064	29	,	,	,
18637	24064	30	247	247	CD
18637	24064	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24064	32	142	142	CD
18637	24064	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24064	34	1918	1918	CD
18637	24064	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24064	36	,	,	,
18637	24064	37	678	678	CD
18637	24064	38	Marino	Marino	NNP
18637	24064	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24064	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	42	Ragen	Ragen	NNP
18637	24064	43	,	,	,
18637	24064	44	332	332	CD
18637	24064	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24064	46	561	561	CD
18637	24064	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24064	48	1947	1947	CD
18637	24064	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24064	50	,	,	,
18637	24064	51	1104	1104	CD
18637	24064	52	,	,	,
18637	24064	53	1109	1109	CD
18637	24064	54	Marine	Marine	NNP
18637	24064	55	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24064	56	&	&	CC
18637	24064	57	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	24064	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24064	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	24064	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	62	United	United	NNP
18637	24064	63	States	States	NNP
18637	24064	64	,	,	,
18637	24064	65	257	257	CD
18637	24064	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24064	67	47	47	CD
18637	24064	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24064	69	1921	1921	CD
18637	24064	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24064	71	,	,	,
18637	24064	72	301	301	CD
18637	24064	73	Market	Market	NNP
18637	24064	74	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24064	75	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24064	76	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24064	77	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	24064	79	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	80	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	24064	81	.	.	NNP
18637	24064	82	,	,	,
18637	24064	83	324	324	CD
18637	24064	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24064	85	548	548	CD
18637	24064	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24064	87	1945	1945	CD
18637	24064	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24064	89	,	,	,
18637	24064	90	1008	1008	CD
18637	24064	91	Markham	Markham	NNP
18637	24064	92	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	24064	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	95	Allen	Allen	NNP
18637	24064	96	,	,	,
18637	24064	97	326	326	CD
18637	24064	98	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24064	99	490	490	CD
18637	24064	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24064	101	1946	1946	CD
18637	24064	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24064	103	,	,	,
18637	24064	104	627	627	CD
18637	24064	105	Marr	Marr	NNP
18637	24064	106	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	107	v.	v.	IN
18637	24064	108	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	109	United	United	NNP
18637	24064	110	States	States	NNP
18637	24064	111	,	,	,
18637	24064	112	268	268	CD
18637	24064	113	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24064	114	536	536	CD
18637	24064	115	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24064	116	1925	1925	CD
18637	24064	117	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24064	118	,	,	,
18637	24064	119	1195	1195	CD
18637	24064	120	Marron	Marron	NNP
18637	24064	121	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	122	v.	v.	IN
18637	24064	123	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	124	United	United	NNP
18637	24064	125	States	States	NNP
18637	24064	126	,	,	,
18637	24064	127	275	275	CD
18637	24064	128	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24064	129	192	192	CD
18637	24064	130	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24064	131	1927	1927	CD
18637	24064	132	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24064	133	,	,	,
18637	24064	134	825	825	CD
18637	24064	135	,	,	,
18637	24064	136	828	828	CD
18637	24064	137	Marsh	Marsh	NNP
18637	24064	138	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	139	v.	v.	IN
18637	24064	140	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	141	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	24064	142	,	,	,
18637	24064	143	326	326	CD
18637	24064	144	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24064	145	501	501	CD
18637	24064	146	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24064	147	1946	1946	CD
18637	24064	148	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24064	149	,	,	,
18637	24064	150	563	563	CD
18637	24064	151	,	,	,
18637	24064	152	786	786	CD
18637	24064	153	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	24064	154	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	155	v.	v.	IN
18637	24064	156	_	_	NNP
18637	24064	157	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	24064	158	&	&	CC
18637	24064	159	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24064	160	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24064	161	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24064	162	,	,	,
18637	24064	163	16	16	CD
18637	24064	164	How	how	WRB
18637	24064	165	.	.	.
18637	24065	1	314	314	CD
18637	24065	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24065	3	1854	1854	CD
18637	24065	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24065	5	,	,	,
18637	24065	6	602	602	CD
18637	24065	7	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	24065	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24065	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24065	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24065	11	Dye	Dye	NNP
18637	24065	12	,	,	,
18637	24065	13	231	231	CD
18637	24065	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24065	15	250	250	CD
18637	24065	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24065	17	1913	1913	CD
18637	24065	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24065	19	,	,	,
18637	24065	20	705	705	CD
18637	24065	21	,	,	,
18637	24065	22	982	982	CD
18637	24065	23	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	24065	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24065	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24065	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24065	27	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	24065	28	,	,	,
18637	24065	29	243	243	CD
18637	24065	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24065	31	521	521	CD
18637	24065	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24065	33	1917	1917	CD
18637	24065	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24065	35	,	,	,
18637	24065	36	85	85	CD
18637	24065	37	,	,	,
18637	24065	38	86	86	CD
18637	24065	39	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	24065	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24065	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24065	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24065	43	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	24065	44	,	,	,
18637	24065	45	141	141	CD
18637	24065	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24065	47	589	589	CD
18637	24065	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24065	49	1891	1891	CD
18637	24065	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24065	51	,	,	,
18637	24065	52	629	629	CD
18637	24065	53	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	24065	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24065	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	24065	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24065	57	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	24065	58	,	,	,
18637	24065	59	1	1	CD
18637	24065	60	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24065	61	.	.	.
18637	24066	1	304	304	CD
18637	24066	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24066	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	24066	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24066	5	,	,	,
18637	24066	6	60	60	CD
18637	24066	7	,	,	,
18637	24066	8	554	554	CD
18637	24066	9	,	,	,
18637	24066	10	555	555	CD
18637	24066	11	,	,	,
18637	24066	12	569	569	CD
18637	24066	13	,	,	,
18637	24066	14	616	616	CD
18637	24066	15	,	,	,
18637	24066	16	622	622	CD
18637	24066	17	,	,	,
18637	24066	18	625	625	CD
18637	24066	19	,	,	,
18637	24066	20	727	727	CD
18637	24066	21	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	24066	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24066	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24066	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24066	25	Lankford	Lankford	NNP
18637	24066	26	,	,	,
18637	24066	27	245	245	CD
18637	24066	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24066	29	547	547	CD
18637	24066	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24066	31	1918	1918	CD
18637	24066	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24066	33	,	,	,
18637	24066	34	935	935	CD
18637	24066	35	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	24066	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24066	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24066	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24066	39	Mott	Mott	NNP
18637	24066	40	,	,	,
18637	24066	41	12	12	CD
18637	24066	42	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24066	43	.	.	.
18637	24067	1	19	19	CD
18637	24067	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24067	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	24067	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24067	5	,	,	,
18637	24067	6	299	299	CD
18637	24067	7	,	,	,
18637	24067	8	391	391	CD
18637	24067	9	,	,	,
18637	24067	10	400	400	CD
18637	24067	11	,	,	,
18637	24067	12	483	483	CD
18637	24067	13	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	24067	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24067	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24067	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24067	17	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	24067	18	&	&	CC
18637	24067	19	L.E.R.	L.E.R.	NNP
18637	24068	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24068	2	,	,	,
18637	24068	3	203	203	CD
18637	24068	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24068	5	284	284	CD
18637	24068	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24068	7	1906	1906	CD
18637	24068	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24068	9	,	,	,
18637	24068	10	270	270	CD
18637	24068	11	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	24068	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24068	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24068	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24068	15	Struthers	Struthers	NNP
18637	24068	16	,	,	,
18637	24068	17	319	319	CD
18637	24068	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24068	19	141	141	CD
18637	24068	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24068	21	1943	1943	CD
18637	24068	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24068	23	,	,	,
18637	24068	24	768	768	CD
18637	24068	25	,	,	,
18637	24068	26	786	786	CD
18637	24068	27	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	24068	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24068	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24068	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24068	31	Waddell	Waddell	NNP
18637	24068	32	,	,	,
18637	24068	33	16	16	CD
18637	24068	34	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24068	35	.	.	.
18637	24069	1	367	367	CD
18637	24069	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24069	3	1842	1842	CD
18637	24069	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24069	5	,	,	,
18637	24069	6	700	700	CD
18637	24069	7	Martin	Martin	NNP
18637	24069	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24069	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	11	West	West	NNP
18637	24069	12	,	,	,
18637	24069	13	222	222	CD
18637	24069	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24069	15	191	191	CD
18637	24069	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24069	17	1911	1911	CD
18637	24069	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24069	19	,	,	,
18637	24069	20	235	235	CD
18637	24069	21	Martino	Martino	NNP
18637	24069	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24069	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	25	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	24069	26	Window	Window	NNP
18637	24069	27	Cleaning	Cleaning	NNP
18637	24069	28	Company	Company	NNP
18637	24069	29	,	,	,
18637	24069	30	327	327	CD
18637	24069	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24069	32	173	173	CD
18637	24069	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24069	34	1946	1946	CD
18637	24069	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24069	36	,	,	,
18637	24069	37	158	158	CD
18637	24069	38	Marvin	Marvin	NNP
18637	24069	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24069	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	42	Trout	Trout	NNP
18637	24069	43	,	,	,
18637	24069	44	199	199	CD
18637	24069	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24069	46	212	212	CD
18637	24069	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24069	48	1905	1905	CD
18637	24069	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24069	50	,	,	,
18637	24069	51	1031	1031	CD
18637	24069	52	,	,	,
18637	24069	53	1096	1096	CD
18637	24069	54	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	24069	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24069	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	58	Soper	Soper	NNP
18637	24069	59	,	,	,
18637	24069	60	270	270	CD
18637	24069	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24069	62	9	9	CD
18637	24069	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24069	64	1926	1926	CD
18637	24069	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24069	66	,	,	,
18637	24069	67	501	501	CD
18637	24069	68	,	,	,
18637	24069	69	634	634	CD
18637	24069	70	,	,	,
18637	24069	71	728	728	CD
18637	24069	72	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	24069	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	24069	75	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	76	Soper	Soper	NNP
18637	24069	77	,	,	,
18637	24069	78	270	270	CD
18637	24069	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24069	80	96	96	CD
18637	24069	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24069	82	1926	1926	CD
18637	24069	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24069	84	,	,	,
18637	24069	85	634	634	CD
18637	24069	86	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	24069	87	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	24069	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	90	West	West	NNP
18637	24069	91	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24069	92	,	,	,
18637	24069	93	217	217	CD
18637	24069	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24069	95	577	577	CD
18637	24069	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24069	97	1910	1910	CD
18637	24069	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24069	99	,	,	,
18637	24069	100	301	301	CD
18637	24069	101	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	24069	102	Casualty	Casualty	NNP
18637	24069	103	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24069	104	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	105	v.	v.	IN
18637	24069	106	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	107	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24069	108	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	24069	109	&	&	CC
18637	24069	110	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24069	111	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24069	112	,	,	,
18637	24069	113	312	312	CD
18637	24069	114	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24069	115	270	270	CD
18637	24069	116	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24069	117	1941	1941	CD
18637	24069	118	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24069	119	,	,	,
18637	24069	120	553	553	CD
18637	24069	121	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	24069	122	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	123	v.	v.	IN
18637	24069	124	_	_	NNP
18637	24069	125	Haile	Haile	NNP
18637	24069	126	,	,	,
18637	24069	127	12	12	CD
18637	24069	128	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24069	129	.	.	.
18637	24070	1	370	370	CD
18637	24070	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24070	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	24070	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24070	5	,	,	,
18637	24070	6	355	355	CD
18637	24070	7	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	24070	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24070	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24070	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24070	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24070	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24070	13	,	,	,
18637	24070	14	244	244	CD
18637	24070	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24070	16	362	362	CD
18637	24070	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24070	18	1917	1917	CD
18637	24070	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24070	20	,	,	,
18637	24070	21	842	842	CD
18637	24070	22	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	24070	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24070	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24070	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24070	26	United	United	NNP
18637	24070	27	States	States	NNP
18637	24070	28	,	,	,
18637	24070	29	260	260	CD
18637	24070	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24070	31	545	545	CD
18637	24070	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24070	33	1923	1923	CD
18637	24070	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24070	35	,	,	,
18637	24070	36	482	482	CD
18637	24070	37	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24070	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24070	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24070	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24070	41	Mellon	Mellon	NNP
18637	24070	42	,	,	,
18637	24070	43	262	262	CD
18637	24070	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24070	45	447	447	CD
18637	24070	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24070	47	1923	1923	CD
18637	24070	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24070	49	,	,	,
18637	24070	50	114	114	CD
18637	24070	51	,	,	,
18637	24070	52	542	542	CD
18637	24070	53	,	,	,
18637	24070	54	543	543	CD
18637	24070	55	,	,	,
18637	24070	56	548	548	CD
18637	24070	57	,	,	,
18637	24070	58	561	561	CD
18637	24070	59	,	,	,
18637	24070	60	596	596	CD
18637	24070	61	,	,	,
18637	24070	62	612	612	CD
18637	24070	63	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24070	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24070	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	24070	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24070	67	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24070	68	,	,	,
18637	24070	69	308	308	CD
18637	24070	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24070	71	1	1	CD
18637	24070	72	.	.	.
18637	24071	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24071	2	1939	1939	CD
18637	24071	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24071	4	,	,	,
18637	24071	5	594	594	CD
18637	24071	6	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24071	7	State	State	NNP
18637	24071	8	Grange	Grange	NNP
18637	24071	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24071	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24071	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24071	12	Benton	Benton	NNP
18637	24071	13	,	,	,
18637	24071	14	272	272	CD
18637	24071	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24071	16	525	525	CD
18637	24071	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24071	18	1926	1926	CD
18637	24071	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24071	20	,	,	,
18637	24071	21	542	542	CD
18637	24071	22	,	,	,
18637	24071	23	934	934	CD
18637	24071	24	Mast	Mast	NNP
18637	24071	25	,	,	,
18637	24071	26	Foos	Foos	NNP
18637	24071	27	&	&	CC
18637	24071	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24071	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24071	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24071	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24071	32	Stover	Stover	NNP
18637	24071	33	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	24071	34	.	.	.
18637	24072	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24072	2	,	,	,
18637	24072	3	177	177	CD
18637	24072	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24072	5	485	485	CD
18637	24072	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24072	7	1900	1900	CD
18637	24072	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24072	9	,	,	,
18637	24072	10	626	626	CD
18637	24072	11	Mathews	Mathews	NNP
18637	24072	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24072	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24072	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24072	15	Zane	Zane	NNP
18637	24072	16	,	,	,
18637	24072	17	7	7	CD
18637	24072	18	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24072	19	.	.	.
18637	24073	1	164	164	CD
18637	24073	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24073	3	1822	1822	CD
18637	24073	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24073	5	,	,	,
18637	24073	6	103	103	CD
18637	24073	7	Matson	Matson	NNP
18637	24073	8	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	24073	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24073	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24073	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	13	State	State	NNP
18637	24073	14	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24073	15	,	,	,
18637	24073	16	297	297	CD
18637	24073	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24073	18	441	441	CD
18637	24073	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24073	20	1936	1936	CD
18637	24073	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24073	22	,	,	,
18637	24073	23	203	203	CD
18637	24073	24	,	,	,
18637	24073	25	209	209	CD
18637	24073	26	,	,	,
18637	24073	27	1054	1054	CD
18637	24073	28	Mattingly	Mattingly	NNP
18637	24073	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24073	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	32	District	District	NNP
18637	24073	33	of	of	IN
18637	24073	34	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	24073	35	,	,	,
18637	24073	36	97	97	CD
18637	24073	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24073	38	687	687	CD
18637	24073	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24073	40	1878	1878	CD
18637	24073	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24073	42	,	,	,
18637	24073	43	304	304	CD
18637	24073	44	Mattox	Mattox	NNPS
18637	24073	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	24073	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	48	United	United	NNP
18637	24073	49	States	States	NNP
18637	24073	50	,	,	,
18637	24073	51	156	156	CD
18637	24073	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24073	53	237	237	CD
18637	24073	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24073	55	1895	1895	CD
18637	24073	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24073	57	,	,	,
18637	24073	58	884	884	CD
18637	24073	59	Mattson	Mattson	NNP
18637	24073	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	24073	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	63	Department	Department	NNP
18637	24073	64	of	of	IN
18637	24073	65	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24073	66	,	,	,
18637	24073	67	293	293	CD
18637	24073	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24073	69	151	151	CD
18637	24073	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24073	71	1934	1934	CD
18637	24073	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24073	73	,	,	,
18637	24073	74	1093	1093	CD
18637	24073	75	Maul	Maul	NNP
18637	24073	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	24073	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	79	United	United	NNP
18637	24073	80	States	States	NNP
18637	24073	81	,	,	,
18637	24073	82	274	274	CD
18637	24073	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24073	84	501	501	CD
18637	24073	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24073	86	1927	1927	CD
18637	24073	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24073	88	,	,	,
18637	24073	89	575	575	CD
18637	24073	90	Maurer	Maurer	NNP
18637	24073	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	24073	93	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	94	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	24073	95	,	,	,
18637	24073	96	309	309	CD
18637	24073	97	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24073	98	598	598	CD
18637	24073	99	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24073	100	1940	1940	CD
18637	24073	101	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24073	102	,	,	,
18637	24073	103	218	218	CD
18637	24073	104	,	,	,
18637	24073	105	226	226	CD
18637	24073	106	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	24073	107	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	24073	109	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	110	Bugbee	Bugbee	NNP
18637	24073	111	,	,	,
18637	24073	112	250	250	CD
18637	24073	113	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24073	114	525	525	CD
18637	24073	115	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24073	116	1919	1919	CD
18637	24073	117	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24073	118	,	,	,
18637	24073	119	687	687	CD
18637	24073	120	,	,	,
18637	24073	121	693	693	CD
18637	24073	122	,	,	,
18637	24073	123	1151	1151	CD
18637	24073	124	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	24073	125	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	126	v.	v.	IN
18637	24073	127	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	128	Dow	Dow	NNP
18637	24073	129	,	,	,
18637	24073	130	176	176	CD
18637	24073	131	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24073	132	581	581	CD
18637	24073	133	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24073	134	1900	1900	CD
18637	24073	135	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24073	136	,	,	,
18637	24073	137	752	752	CD
18637	24073	138	,	,	,
18637	24073	139	879	879	CD
18637	24073	140	,	,	,
18637	24073	141	882	882	CD
18637	24073	142	,	,	,
18637	24073	143	971	971	CD
18637	24073	144	,	,	,
18637	24073	145	1096	1096	CD
18637	24073	146	,	,	,
18637	24073	147	1098	1098	CD
18637	24073	148	,	,	,
18637	24073	149	1109	1109	CD
18637	24073	150	,	,	,
18637	24073	151	1110	1110	CD
18637	24073	152	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	24073	153	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	154	v.	v.	IN
18637	24073	155	_	_	NNP
18637	24073	156	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	24073	157	,	,	,
18637	24073	158	21	21	CD
18637	24073	159	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24073	160	.	.	.
18637	24074	1	71	71	CD
18637	24074	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24074	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	24074	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24074	5	,	,	,
18637	24074	6	674	674	CD
18637	24074	7	May	May	NNP
18637	24074	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24074	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24074	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24074	11	New	New	NNP
18637	24074	12	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24074	13	,	,	,
18637	24074	14	178	178	CD
18637	24074	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24074	16	496	496	CD
18637	24074	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24074	18	1900	1900	CD
18637	24074	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24074	20	,	,	,
18637	24074	21	178	178	CD
18637	24074	22	,	,	,
18637	24074	23	363	363	CD
18637	24074	24	Mayfield	Mayfield	NNP
18637	24074	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24074	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24074	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24074	28	Richards	Richards	NNP
18637	24074	29	,	,	,
18637	24074	30	115	115	CD
18637	24074	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24074	32	137	137	CD
18637	24074	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24074	34	1885	1885	CD
18637	24074	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24074	36	,	,	,
18637	24074	37	293	293	CD
18637	24074	38	Mayflower	Mayflower	NNP
18637	24074	39	Farms	Farms	NNP
18637	24074	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24074	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24074	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24074	43	Ten	Ten	NNP
18637	24074	44	Eyck	Eyck	NNP
18637	24074	45	,	,	,
18637	24074	46	297	297	CD
18637	24074	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24074	48	266	266	CD
18637	24074	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24074	50	1936	1936	CD
18637	24074	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24074	52	,	,	,
18637	24074	53	1156	1156	CD
18637	24074	54	Maynard	Maynard	NNP
18637	24074	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24074	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24074	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24074	58	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	24074	59	,	,	,
18637	24074	60	125	125	CD
18637	24074	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24074	62	190	190	CD
18637	24074	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24074	64	1888	1888	CD
18637	24074	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24074	66	,	,	,
18637	24074	67	352	352	CD
18637	24074	68	Mayo	Mayo	NNP
18637	24074	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24074	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	24074	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24074	72	United	United	NNP
18637	24074	73	States	States	NNP
18637	24074	74	,	,	,
18637	24074	75	319	319	CD
18637	24074	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24074	77	441	441	CD
18637	24074	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24074	79	1943	1943	CD
18637	24074	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24074	81	,	,	,
18637	24074	82	733	733	CD
18637	24074	83	Mayor	Mayor	NNP
18637	24074	84	of	of	IN
18637	24074	85	Vidalia	Vidalia	NNP
18637	24074	86	_	_	NNP
18637	24074	87	v.	v.	IN
18637	24074	88	_	_	NNP
18637	24074	89	McNeely	McNeely	NNP
18637	24074	90	,	,	,
18637	24074	91	274	274	CD
18637	24074	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24074	93	676	676	CD
18637	24074	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24074	95	1927	1927	CD
18637	24074	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24074	97	,	,	,
18637	24074	98	231	231	CD
18637	24074	99	Mayor	Mayor	NNP
18637	24074	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24074	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	24074	102	_	_	NNP
18637	24074	103	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	24074	104	,	,	,
18637	24074	105	6	6	CD
18637	24074	106	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24074	107	.	.	.
18637	24075	1	247	247	CD
18637	24075	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24075	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	24075	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24075	5	,	,	,
18637	24075	6	512	512	CD
18637	24075	7	,	,	,
18637	24075	8	569	569	CD
18637	24075	9	,	,	,
18637	24075	10	619	619	CD
18637	24075	11	,	,	,
18637	24075	12	620	620	CD
18637	24075	13	,	,	,
18637	24075	14	623	623	CD
18637	24075	15	McAllister	McAllister	NNP
18637	24075	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24075	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24075	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24075	19	United	United	NNP
18637	24075	20	States	States	NNP
18637	24075	21	,	,	,
18637	24075	22	141	141	CD
18637	24075	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24075	24	174	174	CD
18637	24075	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24075	26	1891	1891	CD
18637	24075	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24075	28	,	,	,
18637	24075	29	534	534	CD
18637	24075	30	McCabe	McCabe	NNP
18637	24075	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24075	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24075	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24075	34	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	24075	35	,	,	,
18637	24075	36	T.	T.	NNP
18637	24075	37	&	&	CC
18637	24075	38	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	24076	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24076	2	,	,	,
18637	24076	3	235	235	CD
18637	24076	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24076	5	151	151	CD
18637	24076	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24076	7	1914	1914	CD
18637	24076	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24076	9	,	,	,
18637	24076	10	698	698	CD
18637	24076	11	,	,	,
18637	24076	12	699	699	CD
18637	24076	13	,	,	,
18637	24076	14	704	704	CD
18637	24076	15	,	,	,
18637	24076	16	1162	1162	CD
18637	24076	17	McCall	McCall	NNP
18637	24076	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24076	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24076	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24076	21	California	California	NNP
18637	24076	22	,	,	,
18637	24076	23	136	136	CD
18637	24076	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24076	25	104	104	CD
18637	24076	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24076	27	1890	1890	CD
18637	24076	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24076	29	,	,	,
18637	24076	30	222	222	CD
18637	24076	31	,	,	,
18637	24076	32	228	228	CD
18637	24076	33	McCandless	McCandless	NNP
18637	24076	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24076	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	24076	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24076	37	United	United	NNP
18637	24076	38	States	States	NNP
18637	24076	39	,	,	,
18637	24076	40	298	298	CD
18637	24076	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24076	42	342	342	CD
18637	24076	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24076	44	1936	1936	CD
18637	24076	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24076	46	,	,	,
18637	24076	47	870	870	CD
18637	24076	48	McCardle	McCardle	NNP
18637	24076	49	,	,	,
18637	24076	50	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24076	51	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24076	52	,	,	,
18637	24076	53	6	6	CD
18637	24076	54	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24076	55	.	.	.
18637	24077	1	318	318	CD
18637	24077	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24077	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	24077	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24077	5	,	,	,
18637	24077	6	614	614	CD
18637	24077	7	McCardle	McCardle	NNP
18637	24077	8	,	,	,
18637	24077	9	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24077	10	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24077	11	,	,	,
18637	24077	12	7	7	CD
18637	24077	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24077	14	.	.	.
18637	24078	1	506	506	CD
18637	24078	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24078	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24078	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24078	5	,	,	,
18637	24078	6	523	523	CD
18637	24078	7	,	,	,
18637	24078	8	614	614	CD
18637	24078	9	McCardle	McCardle	NNP
18637	24078	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24078	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24078	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24078	13	Indianapolis	Indianapolis	NNP
18637	24078	14	Water	Water	NNP
18637	24078	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24078	16	,	,	,
18637	24078	17	272	272	CD
18637	24078	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24078	19	400	400	CD
18637	24078	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24078	21	1926	1926	CD
18637	24078	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24078	23	,	,	,
18637	24078	24	1006	1006	CD
18637	24078	25	McCarroll	McCarroll	NNP
18637	24078	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24078	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24078	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24078	29	Dixie	Dixie	NNP
18637	24078	30	Greyhound	Greyhound	NNP
18637	24078	31	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	24078	32	,	,	,
18637	24078	33	309	309	CD
18637	24078	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24078	35	176	176	CD
18637	24078	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24078	37	1940	1940	CD
18637	24078	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24078	39	,	,	,
18637	24078	40	177	177	CD
18637	24078	41	,	,	,
18637	24078	42	186	186	CD
18637	24078	43	,	,	,
18637	24078	44	195	195	CD
18637	24078	45	,	,	,
18637	24078	46	206	206	CD
18637	24078	47	,	,	,
18637	24078	48	219	219	CD
18637	24078	49	McCarthy	McCarthy	NNP
18637	24078	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24078	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	24078	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24078	53	Arndstein	Arndstein	NNP
18637	24078	54	,	,	,
18637	24078	55	262	262	CD
18637	24078	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24078	57	355	355	CD
18637	24078	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24078	59	1923	1923	CD
18637	24078	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24078	61	,	,	,
18637	24078	62	827	827	CD
18637	24078	63	,	,	,
18637	24078	64	843	843	CD
18637	24078	65	McCarthy	McCarthy	NNP
18637	24078	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24078	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	24078	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24078	69	Arndstein	Arndstein	NNP
18637	24078	70	,	,	,
18637	24078	71	266	266	CD
18637	24078	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24078	73	34	34	CD
18637	24078	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24078	75	1924	1924	CD
18637	24078	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24078	77	,	,	,
18637	24078	78	842	842	CD
18637	24078	79	,	,	,
18637	24078	80	843	843	CD
18637	24078	81	McCaughey	McCaughey	NNP
18637	24078	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24078	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	24078	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24078	85	Lyall	Lyall	NNP
18637	24078	86	,	,	,
18637	24078	87	224	224	CD
18637	24078	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24078	89	558	558	CD
18637	24078	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24078	91	1912	1912	CD
18637	24078	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24078	93	,	,	,
18637	24078	94	1082	1082	CD
18637	24078	95	McCloskey	McCloskey	NNP
18637	24078	96	_	_	NNP
18637	24078	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	24078	98	_	_	NNP
18637	24078	99	Tobin	Tobin	NNP
18637	24078	100	,	,	,
18637	24078	101	252	252	CD
18637	24078	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24078	103	107	107	CD
18637	24078	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24078	105	1920	1920	CD
18637	24078	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24078	107	,	,	,
18637	24078	108	1024	1024	CD
18637	24078	109	,	,	,
18637	24078	110	1156	1156	CD
18637	24078	111	McClung	McClung	NNP
18637	24078	112	_	_	NNP
18637	24078	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	24078	114	_	_	NNP
18637	24078	115	Silliman	Silliman	NNP
18637	24078	116	,	,	,
18637	24078	117	6	6	CD
18637	24078	118	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24078	119	.	.	.
18637	24079	1	598	598	CD
18637	24079	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24079	3	1821	1821	CD
18637	24079	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24079	5	,	,	,
18637	24079	6	522	522	CD
18637	24079	7	McClurg	McClurg	NNP
18637	24079	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24079	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24079	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24079	11	Kingsland	Kingsland	NNP
18637	24079	12	,	,	,
18637	24079	13	1	1	CD
18637	24079	14	How	how	WRB
18637	24079	15	.	.	.
18637	24080	1	202	202	CD
18637	24080	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24080	3	1843	1843	CD
18637	24080	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24080	5	,	,	,
18637	24080	6	275	275	CD
18637	24080	7	McCollum	McCollum	NNP
18637	24080	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24080	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24080	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24080	11	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24080	12	of	of	IN
18637	24080	13	Education	Education	NNP
18637	24080	14	,	,	,
18637	24080	15	333	333	CD
18637	24080	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24080	17	203	203	CD
18637	24080	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24080	19	1948	1948	CD
18637	24080	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24080	21	,	,	,
18637	24080	22	758	758	CD
18637	24080	23	,	,	,
18637	24080	24	760	760	CD
18637	24080	25	,	,	,
18637	24080	26	762	762	CD
18637	24080	27	McCormick	McCormick	NNP
18637	24080	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24080	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24080	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24080	31	Sullivant	Sullivant	NNP
18637	24080	32	,	,	,
18637	24080	33	10	10	CD
18637	24080	34	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24080	35	.	.	.
18637	24081	1	192	192	CD
18637	24081	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24081	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	24081	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24081	5	,	,	,
18637	24081	6	673	673	CD
18637	24081	7	McCoy	McCoy	NNP
18637	24081	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24081	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24081	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24081	11	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24081	12	Elev	Elev	NNP
18637	24081	13	.	.	.
18637	24082	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24082	2	,	,	,
18637	24082	3	247	247	CD
18637	24082	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24082	5	354	354	CD
18637	24082	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24082	7	1918	1918	CD
18637	24082	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24082	9	,	,	,
18637	24082	10	329	329	CD
18637	24082	11	McCracken	McCracken	NNP
18637	24082	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24082	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24082	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24082	15	Hayward	Hayward	NNP
18637	24082	16	,	,	,
18637	24082	17	2	2	CD
18637	24082	18	How	how	WRB
18637	24082	19	.	.	.
18637	24083	1	608	608	CD
18637	24083	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24083	3	1844	1844	CD
18637	24083	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24083	5	,	,	,
18637	24083	6	354	354	CD
18637	24083	7	McCray	McCray	NNP
18637	24083	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24083	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24083	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24083	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24083	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24083	13	,	,	,
18637	24083	14	195	195	CD
18637	24083	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24083	16	27	27	CD
18637	24083	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24083	18	1904	1904	CD
18637	24083	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24083	20	,	,	,
18637	24083	21	111	111	CD
18637	24083	22	,	,	,
18637	24083	23	564	564	CD
18637	24083	24	,	,	,
18637	24083	25	863	863	CD
18637	24083	26	McCready	McCready	NNP
18637	24083	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24083	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24083	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24083	30	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24083	31	,	,	,
18637	24083	32	94	94	CD
18637	24083	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24083	34	391	391	CD
18637	24083	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24083	36	1877	1877	CD
18637	24083	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24083	38	,	,	,
18637	24083	39	690	690	CD
18637	24083	40	McCrone	McCrone	NNP
18637	24083	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24083	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24083	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24083	44	United	United	NNP
18637	24083	45	States	States	NNP
18637	24083	46	,	,	,
18637	24083	47	307	307	CD
18637	24083	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24083	49	61	61	CD
18637	24083	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24083	51	1939	1939	CD
18637	24083	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24083	53	,	,	,
18637	24083	54	521	521	CD
18637	24083	55	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	24083	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24083	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24083	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24083	59	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	24083	60	,	,	,
18637	24083	61	4	4	CD
18637	24083	62	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24083	63	.	.	.
18637	24084	1	316	316	CD
18637	24084	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24084	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	24084	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24084	5	,	,	,
18637	24084	6	60	60	CD
18637	24084	7	,	,	,
18637	24084	8	71	71	CD
18637	24084	9	,	,	,
18637	24084	10	73	73	CD
18637	24084	11	,	,	,
18637	24084	12	106	106	CD
18637	24084	13	,	,	,
18637	24084	14	146	146	CD
18637	24084	15	,	,	,
18637	24084	16	156	156	CD
18637	24084	17	,	,	,
18637	24084	18	266	266	CD
18637	24084	19	,	,	,
18637	24084	20	267	267	CD
18637	24084	21	,	,	,
18637	24084	22	279	279	CD
18637	24084	23	,	,	,
18637	24084	24	307	307	CD
18637	24084	25	,	,	,
18637	24084	26	309	309	CD
18637	24084	27	,	,	,
18637	24084	28	495	495	CD
18637	24084	29	,	,	,
18637	24084	30	555	555	CD
18637	24084	31	,	,	,
18637	24084	32	721	721	CD
18637	24084	33	,	,	,
18637	24084	34	728	728	CD
18637	24084	35	,	,	,
18637	24084	36	729	729	CD
18637	24084	37	,	,	,
18637	24084	38	732	732	CD
18637	24084	39	,	,	,
18637	24084	40	735	735	CD
18637	24084	41	,	,	,
18637	24084	42	736	736	CD
18637	24084	43	,	,	,
18637	24084	44	790	790	CD
18637	24084	45	,	,	,
18637	24084	46	915	915	CD
18637	24084	47	,	,	,
18637	24084	48	1049	1049	CD
18637	24084	49	McCullough	McCullough	NNP
18637	24084	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24084	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	24084	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24084	53	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24084	54	,	,	,
18637	24084	55	172	172	CD
18637	24084	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24084	57	102	102	CD
18637	24084	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24084	59	1898	1898	CD
18637	24084	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24084	61	,	,	,
18637	24084	62	330	330	CD
18637	24084	63	McDermott	McDermott	NNP
18637	24084	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24084	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	24084	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24084	67	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	24084	68	,	,	,
18637	24084	69	228	228	CD
18637	24084	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24084	71	115	115	CD
18637	24084	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24084	73	1913	1913	CD
18637	24084	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24084	75	,	,	,
18637	24084	76	153	153	CD
18637	24084	77	,	,	,
18637	24084	78	248	248	CD
18637	24084	79	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	24084	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24084	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	24084	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24084	83	Mabee	Mabee	NNP
18637	24084	84	,	,	,
18637	24084	85	243	243	CD
18637	24084	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24084	87	90	90	CD
18637	24084	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24084	89	1917	1917	CD
18637	24084	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24084	91	,	,	,
18637	24084	92	659	659	CD
18637	24084	93	,	,	,
18637	24084	94	1073	1073	CD
18637	24084	95	,	,	,
18637	24084	96	1074	1074	CD
18637	24084	97	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	24084	98	_	_	NNP
18637	24084	99	v.	v.	IN
18637	24084	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24084	101	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24084	102	,	,	,
18637	24084	103	180	180	CD
18637	24084	104	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24084	105	311	311	CD
18637	24084	106	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24084	107	1901	1901	CD
18637	24084	108	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24084	109	,	,	,
18637	24084	110	328	328	CD
18637	24084	111	,	,	,
18637	24084	112	1161	1161	CD
18637	24084	113	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	24084	114	_	_	NNP
18637	24084	115	v.	v.	IN
18637	24084	116	_	_	NNP
18637	24084	117	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24084	118	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24084	119	&	&	CC
18637	24084	120	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	24084	121	.	.	.
18637	24085	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24085	2	,	,	,
18637	24085	3	233	233	CD
18637	24085	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24085	5	665	665	CD
18637	24085	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24085	7	1914	1914	CD
18637	24085	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24085	9	,	,	,
18637	24085	10	1141	1141	CD
18637	24085	11	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	24085	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24085	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24085	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24085	15	Pless	Pless	NNP
18637	24085	16	,	,	,
18637	24085	17	238	238	CD
18637	24085	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24085	19	264	264	CD
18637	24085	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24085	21	1915	1915	CD
18637	24085	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24085	23	,	,	,
18637	24085	24	526	526	CD
18637	24085	25	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	24085	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24085	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24085	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24085	29	United	United	NNP
18637	24085	30	States	States	NNP
18637	24085	31	,	,	,
18637	24085	32	335	335	CD
18637	24085	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24085	34	451	451	CD
18637	24085	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24085	36	1948	1948	CD
18637	24085	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24085	38	,	,	,
18637	24085	39	829	829	CD
18637	24085	40	McElmoyle	McElmoyle	NNP
18637	24085	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24085	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24085	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24085	44	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
18637	24085	45	,	,	,
18637	24085	46	13	13	CD
18637	24085	47	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24085	48	.	.	.
18637	24086	1	312	312	CD
18637	24086	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24086	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	24086	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24086	5	,	,	,
18637	24086	6	654	654	CD
18637	24086	7	McElrath	McElrath	NNP
18637	24086	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24086	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24086	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24086	13	,	,	,
18637	24086	14	102	102	CD
18637	24086	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24086	16	426	426	CD
18637	24086	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24086	18	1880	1880	CD
18637	24086	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24086	20	,	,	,
18637	24086	21	534	534	CD
18637	24086	22	,	,	,
18637	24086	23	893	893	CD
18637	24086	24	McFaddin	McFaddin	NNP
18637	24086	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24086	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	28	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	24086	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	24086	30	Snider	Snider	NNP
18637	24086	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	24086	32	Buel	Buel	NNP
18637	24086	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24086	34	,	,	,
18637	24086	35	185	185	CD
18637	24086	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24086	37	505	505	CD
18637	24086	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24086	39	1902	1902	CD
18637	24086	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24086	41	,	,	,
18637	24086	42	856	856	CD
18637	24086	43	McGahey	McGahey	NNP
18637	24086	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24086	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	47	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24086	48	,	,	,
18637	24086	49	135	135	CD
18637	24086	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24086	51	662	662	CD
18637	24086	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24086	53	1890	1890	CD
18637	24086	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24086	55	,	,	,
18637	24086	56	330	330	CD
18637	24086	57	,	,	,
18637	24086	58	355	355	CD
18637	24086	59	McGoldrick	McGoldrick	NNP
18637	24086	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	24086	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	63	Berwind	Berwind	NNP
18637	24086	64	-	-	HYPH
18637	24086	65	White	White	NNP
18637	24086	66	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	24086	67	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	24086	68	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24086	69	,	,	,
18637	24086	70	309	309	CD
18637	24086	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24086	72	33	33	CD
18637	24086	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24086	74	1940	1940	CD
18637	24086	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24086	76	,	,	,
18637	24086	77	189	189	CD
18637	24086	78	,	,	,
18637	24086	79	190	190	CD
18637	24086	80	McGoldrick	McGoldrick	NNP
18637	24086	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	24086	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	84	Compagnie	Compagnie	NNP
18637	24086	85	Generale	Generale	NNP
18637	24086	86	,	,	,
18637	24086	87	309	309	CD
18637	24086	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24086	89	430	430	CD
18637	24086	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24086	91	1940	1940	CD
18637	24086	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24086	93	,	,	,
18637	24086	94	190	190	CD
18637	24086	95	McGoldrick	McGoldrick	NNP
18637	24086	96	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	24086	98	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	99	Felt	Felt	NNP
18637	24086	100	&	&	CC
18637	24086	101	Tarrant	Tarrant	NNP
18637	24086	102	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24086	103	,	,	,
18637	24086	104	309	309	CD
18637	24086	105	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24086	106	70	70	CD
18637	24086	107	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24086	108	1940	1940	CD
18637	24086	109	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24086	110	,	,	,
18637	24086	111	190	190	CD
18637	24086	112	McGoldrick	McGoldrick	NNP
18637	24086	113	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	114	v.	v.	IN
18637	24086	115	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	116	Gulf	Gulf	NNP
18637	24086	117	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24086	118	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24086	119	,	,	,
18637	24086	120	309	309	CD
18637	24086	121	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24086	122	414	414	CD
18637	24086	123	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24086	124	1940	1940	CD
18637	24086	125	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24086	126	,	,	,
18637	24086	127	363	363	CD
18637	24086	128	McGovern	McGovern	NNP
18637	24086	129	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	130	v.	v.	IN
18637	24086	131	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	132	New	New	NNP
18637	24086	133	York	York	NNP
18637	24086	134	,	,	,
18637	24086	135	229	229	CD
18637	24086	136	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24086	137	363	363	CD
18637	24086	138	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24086	139	1913	1913	CD
18637	24086	140	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24086	141	,	,	,
18637	24086	142	1066	1066	CD
18637	24086	143	McGrain	McGrain	NNP
18637	24086	144	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	145	v.	v.	IN
18637	24086	146	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	147	Daugherty	Daugherty	NNP
18637	24086	148	,	,	,
18637	24086	149	273	273	CD
18637	24086	150	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24086	151	135	135	CD
18637	24086	152	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24086	153	1927	1927	CD
18637	24086	154	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24086	155	,	,	,
18637	24086	156	83	83	CD
18637	24086	157	-	-	SYM
18637	24086	158	85	85	CD
18637	24086	159	,	,	,
18637	24086	160	91	91	CD
18637	24086	161	,	,	,
18637	24086	162	97	97	CD
18637	24086	163	,	,	,
18637	24086	164	825	825	CD
18637	24086	165	McGuire	McGuire	NNP
18637	24086	166	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	167	v.	v.	IN
18637	24086	168	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	169	United	United	NNP
18637	24086	170	States	States	NNP
18637	24086	171	,	,	,
18637	24086	172	273	273	CD
18637	24086	173	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24086	174	95	95	CD
18637	24086	175	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24086	176	1927	1927	CD
18637	24086	177	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24086	178	,	,	,
18637	24086	179	831	831	CD
18637	24086	180	McIntire	McIntire	NNP
18637	24086	181	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	182	v.	v.	IN
18637	24086	183	_	_	NNP
18637	24086	184	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	24086	185	,	,	,
18637	24086	186	7	7	CD
18637	24086	187	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24086	188	.	.	.
18637	24087	1	504	504	CD
18637	24087	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24087	3	1813	1813	CD
18637	24087	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24087	5	,	,	,
18637	24087	6	512	512	CD
18637	24087	7	,	,	,
18637	24087	8	522	522	CD
18637	24087	9	McKane	McKane	NNP
18637	24087	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24087	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24087	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24087	13	Durston	Durston	NNP
18637	24087	14	,	,	,
18637	24087	15	153	153	CD
18637	24087	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24087	17	684	684	CD
18637	24087	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24087	19	1894	1894	CD
18637	24087	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24087	21	,	,	,
18637	24087	22	687	687	CD
18637	24087	23	,	,	,
18637	24087	24	1133	1133	CD
18637	24087	25	,	,	,
18637	24087	26	1138	1138	CD
18637	24087	27	McKim	McKim	NNP
18637	24087	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24087	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24087	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24087	31	Voorhies	Voorhies	NNPS
18637	24087	32	,	,	,
18637	24087	33	7	7	CD
18637	24087	34	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24087	35	.	.	.
18637	24088	1	279	279	CD
18637	24088	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24088	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	24088	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24088	5	,	,	,
18637	24088	6	627	627	CD
18637	24088	7	McKinley	McKinley	NNP
18637	24088	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24088	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24088	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24088	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24088	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24088	13	,	,	,
18637	24088	14	249	249	CD
18637	24088	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24088	16	397	397	CD
18637	24088	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24088	18	1919	1919	CD
18637	24088	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24088	20	,	,	,
18637	24088	21	285	285	CD
18637	24088	22	McKissick	McKissick	NNP
18637	24088	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24088	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24088	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24088	26	Carmichael	Carmichael	NNP
18637	24088	27	,	,	,
18637	24088	28	187	187	CD
18637	24088	29	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24088	30	2d	2d	NNP
18637	24088	31	949	949	CD
18637	24088	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24088	33	1951	1951	CD
18637	24088	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24088	35	,	,	,
18637	24088	36	1163	1163	CD
18637	24088	37	McKnett	McKnett	NNP
18637	24088	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24088	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24088	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24088	41	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24088	42	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24088	43	&	&	CC
18637	24088	44	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	24089	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24089	2	,	,	,
18637	24089	3	292	292	CD
18637	24089	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24089	5	230	230	CD
18637	24089	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24089	7	1934	1934	CD
18637	24089	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24089	9	,	,	,
18637	24089	10	692	692	CD
18637	24089	11	McLaurin	McLaurin	NNP
18637	24089	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24089	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24089	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24089	15	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24089	16	State	State	NNP
18637	24089	17	Regents	Regents	NNPS
18637	24089	18	,	,	,
18637	24089	19	339	339	CD
18637	24089	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24089	21	637	637	CD
18637	24089	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24089	23	1950	1950	CD
18637	24089	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24089	25	,	,	,
18637	24089	26	1162	1162	CD
18637	24089	27	McLean	McLean	NNP
18637	24089	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24089	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24089	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24089	31	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	24089	32	,	,	,
18637	24089	33	211	211	CD
18637	24089	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24089	35	539	539	CD
18637	24089	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24089	37	1909	1909	CD
18637	24089	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24089	39	,	,	,
18637	24089	40	988	988	CD
18637	24089	41	,	,	,
18637	24089	42	1018	1018	CD
18637	24089	43	,	,	,
18637	24089	44	1158	1158	CD
18637	24089	45	McLean	McLean	NNP
18637	24089	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24089	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	24089	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24089	49	Meek	Meek	NNP
18637	24089	50	,	,	,
18637	24089	51	18	18	CD
18637	24089	52	How	how	WRB
18637	24089	53	.	.	.
18637	24090	1	16	16	CD
18637	24090	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24090	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	24090	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24090	5	,	,	,
18637	24090	6	672	672	CD
18637	24090	7	McLeod	McLeod	NNP
18637	24090	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24090	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24090	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24090	11	Dilworth	Dilworth	NNP
18637	24090	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24090	13	,	,	,
18637	24090	14	322	322	CD
18637	24090	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24090	16	327	327	CD
18637	24090	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24090	18	1944	1944	CD
18637	24090	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24090	20	,	,	,
18637	24090	21	191	191	CD
18637	24090	22	McLeod	McLeod	NNP
18637	24090	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24090	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24090	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24090	26	Threlkeld	Threlkeld	NNP
18637	24090	27	,	,	,
18637	24090	28	319	319	CD
18637	24090	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24090	30	491	491	CD
18637	24090	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24090	32	1943	1943	CD
18637	24090	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24090	34	,	,	,
18637	24090	35	158	158	CD
18637	24090	36	McMillen	McMillen	NNP
18637	24090	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24090	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	24090	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24090	40	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	24090	41	,	,	,
18637	24090	42	95	95	CD
18637	24090	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24090	44	37	37	CD
18637	24090	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24090	46	1877	1877	CD
18637	24090	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24090	48	,	,	,
18637	24090	49	1057	1057	CD
18637	24090	50	,	,	,
18637	24090	51	1058	1058	CD
18637	24090	52	,	,	,
18637	24090	53	1071	1071	CD
18637	24090	54	McNabb	McNabb	NNP
18637	24090	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24090	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24090	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24090	58	United	United	NNP
18637	24090	59	States	States	NNP
18637	24090	60	,	,	,
18637	24090	61	318	318	CD
18637	24090	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24090	63	332	332	CD
18637	24090	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24090	65	1943	1943	CD
18637	24090	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24090	67	,	,	,
18637	24090	68	842	842	CD
18637	24090	69	McNally	McNally	NNP
18637	24090	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24090	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	24090	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24090	73	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	24090	74	,	,	,
18637	24090	75	293	293	CD
18637	24090	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24090	77	131	131	CD
18637	24090	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24090	79	1934	1934	CD
18637	24090	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24090	81	,	,	,
18637	24090	82	314	314	CD
18637	24090	83	McNaughton	McNaughton	NNP
18637	24090	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24090	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	24090	86	_	_	NNP
18637	24090	87	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	24090	88	,	,	,
18637	24090	89	242	242	CD
18637	24090	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24090	91	344	344	CD
18637	24090	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24090	93	1917	1917	CD
18637	24090	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24090	95	,	,	,
18637	24090	96	1024	1024	CD
18637	24090	97	,	,	,
18637	24090	98	1155	1155	CD
18637	24090	99	McNeill	McNeill	NNP
18637	24090	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24090	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	24090	102	_	_	NNP
18637	24090	103	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24090	104	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24090	105	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24090	106	,	,	,
18637	24090	107	202	202	CD
18637	24090	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24090	109	543	543	CD
18637	24090	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24090	111	1906	1906	CD
18637	24090	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24090	113	,	,	,
18637	24090	114	222	222	CD
18637	24090	115	McNiel	McNiel	NNP
18637	24090	116	,	,	,
18637	24090	117	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24090	118	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24090	119	,	,	,
18637	24090	120	13	13	CD
18637	24090	121	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24090	122	.	.	.
18637	24091	1	236	236	CD
18637	24091	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24091	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	24091	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24091	5	,	,	,
18637	24091	6	366	366	CD
18637	24091	7	,	,	,
18637	24091	8	574	574	CD
18637	24091	9	McPherson	McPherson	NNP
18637	24091	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24091	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24091	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24091	13	Blacker	Blacker	NNP
18637	24091	14	,	,	,
18637	24091	15	146	146	CD
18637	24091	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24091	17	1	1	CD
18637	24091	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24091	19	1892	1892	CD
18637	24091	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24091	21	,	,	,
18637	24091	22	385	385	CD
18637	24091	23	,	,	,
18637	24091	24	548	548	CD
18637	24091	25	,	,	,
18637	24091	26	1172	1172	CD
18637	24091	27	Mechanics	Mechanics	NNP
18637	24091	28	'	'	POS
18637	24091	29	&	&	CC
18637	24091	30	Traders	Traders	NNPS
18637	24091	31	'	'	POS
18637	24091	32	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24091	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24091	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24091	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24091	36	Debolt	Debolt	NNP
18637	24091	37	,	,	,
18637	24091	38	18	18	CD
18637	24091	39	How	how	WRB
18637	24091	40	.	.	.
18637	24092	1	380	380	CD
18637	24092	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24092	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	24092	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24092	5	,	,	,
18637	24092	6	602	602	CD
18637	24092	7	Medley	Medley	NNP
18637	24092	8	,	,	,
18637	24092	9	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24092	10	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24092	11	,	,	,
18637	24092	12	134	134	CD
18637	24092	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24092	14	160	160	CD
18637	24092	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24092	16	1890	1890	CD
18637	24092	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24092	18	,	,	,
18637	24092	19	328	328	CD
18637	24092	20	Meehan	Meehan	NNP
18637	24092	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24092	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	24092	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24092	24	Valentine	Valentine	NNP
18637	24092	25	,	,	,
18637	24092	26	145	145	CD
18637	24092	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24092	28	611	611	CD
18637	24092	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24092	30	1892	1892	CD
18637	24092	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24092	32	,	,	,
18637	24092	33	896	896	CD
18637	24092	34	Meeker	Meeker	NNP
18637	24092	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24092	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24092	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24092	38	Lehigh	Lehigh	NNP
18637	24092	39	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	24092	40	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24092	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24092	42	,	,	,
18637	24092	43	236	236	CD
18637	24092	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24092	45	434	434	CD
18637	24092	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24092	47	1915	1915	CD
18637	24092	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24092	49	,	,	,
18637	24092	50	894	894	CD
18637	24092	51	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	24092	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24092	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	24092	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24092	55	United	United	NNP
18637	24092	56	States	States	NNP
18637	24092	57	,	,	,
18637	24092	58	97	97	CD
18637	24092	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24092	60	293	293	CD
18637	24092	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24092	62	1878	1878	CD
18637	24092	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24092	64	,	,	,
18637	24092	65	356	356	CD
18637	24092	66	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	24092	67	&	&	CC
18637	24092	68	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	24093	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24093	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24093	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24093	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24093	5	Pace	Pace	NNP
18637	24093	6	,	,	,
18637	24093	7	282	282	CD
18637	24093	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24093	9	241	241	CD
18637	24093	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24093	11	1931	1931	CD
18637	24093	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24093	13	,	,	,
18637	24093	14	1153	1153	CD
18637	24093	15	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	24093	16	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24093	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24093	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24093	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24093	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24093	21	Beeler	Beeler	NNP
18637	24093	22	,	,	,
18637	24093	23	315	315	CD
18637	24093	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24093	25	649	649	CD
18637	24093	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24093	27	1942	1942	CD
18637	24093	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24093	29	,	,	,
18637	24093	30	209	209	CD
18637	24093	31	,	,	,
18637	24093	32	1050	1050	CD
18637	24093	33	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	24093	34	&	&	CC
18637	24093	35	L.R.R.	L.R.R.	NNP
18637	24094	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24094	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24094	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24094	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24094	5	Berry	Berry	NNP
18637	24094	6	,	,	,
18637	24094	7	112	112	CD
18637	24094	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24094	9	609	609	CD
18637	24094	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24094	11	1884	1884	CD
18637	24094	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24094	13	,	,	,
18637	24094	14	347	347	CD
18637	24094	15	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	24094	16	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	24094	17	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24094	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24094	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24094	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24094	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24094	22	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	24094	23	,	,	,
18637	24094	24	335	335	CD
18637	24094	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24094	26	80	80	CD
18637	24094	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24094	28	1948	1948	CD
18637	24094	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24094	30	,	,	,
18637	24094	31	198	198	CD
18637	24094	32	,	,	,
18637	24094	33	207	207	CD
18637	24094	34	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
18637	24094	35	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	24094	36	Laundry	Laundry	NNP
18637	24094	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24094	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	24094	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24094	40	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	24094	41	,	,	,
18637	24094	42	342	342	CD
18637	24094	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24094	44	389	389	CD
18637	24094	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24094	46	1952	1952	CD
18637	24094	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24094	48	,	,	,
18637	24094	49	192	192	CD
18637	24094	50	Merchants	Merchants	NNPS
18637	24094	51	'	'	POS
18637	24094	52	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24094	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24094	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	24094	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24094	56	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24094	57	,	,	,
18637	24094	58	167	167	CD
18637	24094	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24094	60	461	461	CD
18637	24094	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24094	62	1897	1897	CD
18637	24094	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24094	64	,	,	,
18637	24094	65	1060	1060	CD
18637	24094	66	Merchants	Merchants	NNPS
18637	24094	67	Exch	Exch	NNP
18637	24094	68	.	.	.
18637	24095	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24095	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24095	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24095	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24095	5	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24095	6	rel	rel	NN
18637	24095	7	.	.	.
18637	24096	1	Barker	Barker	NNP
18637	24096	2	,	,	,
18637	24096	3	248	248	CD
18637	24096	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24096	5	365	365	CD
18637	24096	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24096	7	1919	1919	CD
18637	24096	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24096	9	,	,	,
18637	24096	10	1018	1018	CD
18637	24096	11	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	24096	12	'	'	POS
18637	24096	13	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	24096	14	&	&	CC
18637	24096	15	T.	T.	NNP
18637	24096	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24096	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24096	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24096	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24096	20	Smietanka	Smietanka	NNP
18637	24096	21	,	,	,
18637	24096	22	255	255	CD
18637	24096	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24096	24	509	509	CD
18637	24096	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24096	26	1921	1921	CD
18637	24096	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24096	28	,	,	,
18637	24096	29	1194	1194	CD
18637	24096	30	Merchants	Merchants	NNPS
18637	24096	31	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	24096	32	.	.	.
18637	24097	1	Auto	Auto	NNP
18637	24097	2	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	24097	3	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24097	4	.	.	.
18637	24098	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24098	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24098	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24098	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24098	5	Smart	Smart	NNP
18637	24098	6	,	,	,
18637	24098	7	267	267	CD
18637	24098	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24098	9	126	126	CD
18637	24098	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24098	11	1925	1925	CD
18637	24098	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24098	13	,	,	,
18637	24098	14	1022	1022	CD
18637	24098	15	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	24098	16	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	24098	17	.	.	.
18637	24099	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24099	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24099	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24099	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24099	5	United	United	NNP
18637	24099	6	States	States	NNP
18637	24099	7	,	,	,
18637	24099	8	101	101	CD
18637	24099	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24099	10	1	1	CD
18637	24099	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24099	12	1880	1880	CD
18637	24099	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24099	14	,	,	,
18637	24099	15	266	266	CD
18637	24099	16	Meriwether	Meriwether	NNP
18637	24099	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24099	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24099	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24099	20	Garrett	Garrett	NNP
18637	24099	21	,	,	,
18637	24099	22	102	102	CD
18637	24099	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24099	24	472	472	CD
18637	24099	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24099	26	1880	1880	CD
18637	24099	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24099	28	,	,	,
18637	24099	29	340	340	CD
18637	24099	30	Merrick	Merrick	NNP
18637	24099	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24099	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24099	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24099	34	Halsey	Halsey	NNP
18637	24099	35	&	&	CC
18637	24099	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24099	37	,	,	,
18637	24099	38	242	242	CD
18637	24099	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24099	40	568	568	CD
18637	24099	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24099	42	1917	1917	CD
18637	24099	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24099	44	,	,	,
18637	24099	45	235	235	CD
18637	24099	46	,	,	,
18637	24099	47	1019	1019	CD
18637	24099	48	Merryman	Merryman	NNP
18637	24099	49	,	,	,
18637	24099	50	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24099	51	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24099	52	,	,	,
18637	24099	53	17	17	CD
18637	24099	54	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24099	55	.	.	.
18637	24100	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24100	2	.	.	.
18637	24101	1	No	no	UH
18637	24101	2	.	.	.
18637	24102	1	9487	9487	CD
18637	24102	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24102	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	24102	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24102	5	,	,	,
18637	24102	6	315	315	CD
18637	24102	7	Metcalf	Metcalf	NNP
18637	24102	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24102	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24102	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24102	11	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	24102	12	,	,	,
18637	24102	13	269	269	CD
18637	24102	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24102	15	514	514	CD
18637	24102	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24102	17	1926	1926	CD
18637	24102	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24102	19	,	,	,
18637	24102	20	107	107	CD
18637	24102	21	Metropolis	Metropolis	NNP
18637	24102	22	Theatre	Theatre	NNP
18637	24102	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24102	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24102	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24102	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24102	27	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	24102	28	,	,	,
18637	24102	29	228	228	CD
18637	24102	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24102	31	61	61	CD
18637	24102	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24102	33	1913	1913	CD
18637	24102	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24102	35	,	,	,
18637	24102	36	1149	1149	CD
18637	24102	37	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
18637	24102	38	Casualty	Casualty	NNP
18637	24102	39	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24102	40	.	.	.
18637	24103	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24103	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24103	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24103	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24103	5	Brownell	Brownell	NNP
18637	24103	6	,	,	,
18637	24103	7	294	294	CD
18637	24103	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24103	9	580	580	CD
18637	24103	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24103	11	1935	1935	CD
18637	24103	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24103	13	,	,	,
18637	24103	14	120	120	CD
18637	24103	15	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
18637	24103	16	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24103	17	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24103	18	.	.	.
18637	24104	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24104	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24104	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24104	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24104	5	New	New	NNP
18637	24104	6	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24104	7	,	,	,
18637	24104	8	205	205	CD
18637	24104	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24104	10	395	395	CD
18637	24104	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24104	12	1907	1907	CD
18637	24104	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24104	14	,	,	,
18637	24104	15	,	,	,
18637	24104	16	1056	1056	CD
18637	24104	17	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
18637	24104	18	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24104	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24104	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24104	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24104	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24104	23	District	District	NNP
18637	24104	24	of	of	IN
18637	24104	25	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	24104	26	,	,	,
18637	24104	27	132	132	CD
18637	24104	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24104	29	1	1	CD
18637	24104	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24104	31	1889	1889	CD
18637	24104	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24104	33	,	,	,
18637	24104	34	301	301	CD
18637	24104	35	Meyer	Meyer	NNP
18637	24104	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24104	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24104	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24104	39	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	24104	40	,	,	,
18637	24104	41	262	262	CD
18637	24104	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24104	43	390	390	CD
18637	24104	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24104	45	1923	1923	CD
18637	24104	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24104	47	,	,	,
18637	24104	48	984	984	CD
18637	24104	49	Meyer	Meyer	NNP
18637	24104	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24104	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	24104	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24104	53	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	24104	54	,	,	,
18637	24104	55	172	172	CD
18637	24104	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24104	57	82	82	CD
18637	24104	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24104	59	1898	1898	CD
18637	24104	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24104	61	,	,	,
18637	24104	62	1068	1068	CD
18637	24104	63	Meyer	Meyer	NNP
18637	24104	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24104	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	24104	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24104	67	Wells	Wells	NNP
18637	24104	68	,	,	,
18637	24104	69	Fargo	Fargo	NNP
18637	24104	70	&	&	CC
18637	24104	71	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24104	72	,	,	,
18637	24104	73	223	223	CD
18637	24104	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24104	75	298	298	CD
18637	24104	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24104	77	1912	1912	CD
18637	24104	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24104	79	,	,	,
18637	24104	80	204	204	CD
18637	24104	81	Michaelson	Michaelson	NNP
18637	24104	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24104	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	24104	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24104	85	United	United	NNP
18637	24104	86	States	States	NNP
18637	24104	87	,	,	,
18637	24104	88	266	266	CD
18637	24104	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24104	90	42	42	CD
18637	24104	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24104	92	1924	1924	CD
18637	24104	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24104	94	,	,	,
18637	24104	95	512	512	CD
18637	24104	96	,	,	,
18637	24104	97	516	516	CD
18637	24104	98	,	,	,
18637	24104	99	521	521	CD
18637	24104	100	,	,	,
18637	24104	101	565	565	CD
18637	24104	102	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	24104	103	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	24105	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24105	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24105	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24105	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24105	5	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	24105	6	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24105	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24105	8	,	,	,
18637	24105	9	236	236	CD
18637	24105	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24105	11	615	615	CD
18637	24105	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24105	13	1915	1915	CD
18637	24105	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24105	15	,	,	,
18637	24105	16	1013	1013	CD
18637	24105	17	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	24105	18	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	24106	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24106	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24106	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	5	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	24106	6	,	,	,
18637	24106	7	201	201	CD
18637	24106	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24106	9	245	245	CD
18637	24106	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24106	11	1906	1906	CD
18637	24106	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24106	13	,	,	,
18637	24106	14	1058	1058	CD
18637	24106	15	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	24106	16	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24106	17	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	24106	18	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24106	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24106	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	22	Duke	Duke	NNP
18637	24106	23	,	,	,
18637	24106	24	266	266	CD
18637	24106	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24106	26	570	570	CD
18637	24106	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24106	28	1925	1925	CD
18637	24106	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24106	30	,	,	,
18637	24106	31	1032	1032	CD
18637	24106	32	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	24106	33	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24106	34	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24106	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24106	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	38	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	24106	39	,	,	,
18637	24106	40	228	228	CD
18637	24106	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24106	42	346	346	CD
18637	24106	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24106	44	1913	1913	CD
18637	24106	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24106	46	,	,	,
18637	24106	47	655	655	CD
18637	24106	48	,	,	,
18637	24106	49	1082	1082	CD
18637	24106	50	Middleton	Middleton	NNP
18637	24106	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	24106	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	54	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24106	55	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24106	56	&	&	CC
18637	24106	57	Light	Light	NNP
18637	24106	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24106	59	,	,	,
18637	24106	60	249	249	CD
18637	24106	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24106	62	152	152	CD
18637	24106	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24106	64	1919	1919	CD
18637	24106	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24106	66	,	,	,
18637	24106	67	1145	1145	CD
18637	24106	68	,	,	,
18637	24106	69	1159	1159	CD
18637	24106	70	Midland	Midland	NNP
18637	24106	71	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	24106	72	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24106	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	24106	75	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	76	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24106	77	City	City	NNP
18637	24106	78	P.	P.	NNP
18637	24106	79	&	&	CC
18637	24106	80	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24106	81	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24106	82	,	,	,
18637	24106	83	300	300	CD
18637	24106	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24106	85	109	109	CD
18637	24106	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24106	87	1937	1937	CD
18637	24106	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24106	89	,	,	,
18637	24106	90	358	358	CD
18637	24106	91	Miedreich	Miedreich	NNP
18637	24106	92	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	24106	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	95	Lauenstein	Lauenstein	NNP
18637	24106	96	,	,	,
18637	24106	97	232	232	CD
18637	24106	98	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24106	99	236	236	CD
18637	24106	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24106	101	1914	1914	CD
18637	24106	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24106	103	,	,	,
18637	24106	104	1083	1083	CD
18637	24106	105	Miles	Miles	NNP
18637	24106	106	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	107	v.	v.	IN
18637	24106	108	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	109	Graham	Graham	NNP
18637	24106	110	,	,	,
18637	24106	111	268	268	CD
18637	24106	112	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24106	113	501	501	CD
18637	24106	114	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24106	115	1925	1925	CD
18637	24106	116	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24106	117	,	,	,
18637	24106	118	105	105	CD
18637	24106	119	,	,	,
18637	24106	120	530	530	CD
18637	24106	121	,	,	,
18637	24106	122	535	535	CD
18637	24106	123	Miles	Miles	NNP
18637	24106	124	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	125	v.	v.	IN
18637	24106	126	_	_	NNP
18637	24106	127	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	24106	128	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	24107	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24107	2	,	,	,
18637	24107	3	315	315	CD
18637	24107	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24107	5	698	698	CD
18637	24107	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24107	7	1942	1942	CD
18637	24107	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24107	9	,	,	,
18637	24107	10	692	692	CD
18637	24107	11	Miles	Miles	NNP
18637	24107	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24107	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24107	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24107	15	Safe	Safe	NNP
18637	24107	16	Deposit	Deposit	NNP
18637	24107	17	&	&	CC
18637	24107	18	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24107	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24107	20	,	,	,
18637	24107	21	259	259	CD
18637	24107	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24107	23	247	247	CD
18637	24107	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24107	25	1922	1922	CD
18637	24107	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24107	27	,	,	,
18637	24107	28	1195	1195	CD
18637	24107	29	Milheim	Milheim	NNP
18637	24107	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24107	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24107	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24107	33	Moffat	Moffat	NNP
18637	24107	34	Tunnel	Tunnel	NNP
18637	24107	35	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	24107	36	.	.	.
18637	24108	1	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	24108	2	.	.	.
18637	24108	3	,	,	,
18637	24108	4	262	262	CD
18637	24108	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24108	6	710	710	CD
18637	24108	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24108	8	1923	1923	CD
18637	24108	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24108	10	,	,	,
18637	24108	11	1037	1037	CD
18637	24108	12	Milk	Milk	NNP
18637	24108	13	Control	Control	NNP
18637	24108	14	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24108	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24108	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24108	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24108	18	Eisenberg	Eisenberg	NNP
18637	24108	19	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	24108	20	Products	Products	NNPS
18637	24108	21	,	,	,
18637	24108	22	306	306	CD
18637	24108	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24108	24	346	346	CD
18637	24108	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24108	26	1939	1939	CD
18637	24108	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24108	28	,	,	,
18637	24108	29	218	218	CD
18637	24108	30	,	,	,
18637	24108	31	237	237	CD
18637	24108	32	,	,	,
18637	24108	33	245	245	CD
18637	24108	34	Milk	milk	NN
18637	24108	35	Wagon	Wagon	NNP
18637	24108	36	Drivers	Drivers	NNPS
18637	24108	37	'	'	POS
18637	24108	38	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24108	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24108	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24108	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24108	42	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	24108	43	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	24108	44	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	24108	45	Products	Products	NNP
18637	24108	46	,	,	,
18637	24108	47	311	311	CD
18637	24108	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24108	49	91	91	CD
18637	24108	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24108	51	1940	1940	CD
18637	24108	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24108	53	,	,	,
18637	24108	54	524	524	CD
18637	24108	55	,	,	,
18637	24108	56	622	622	CD
18637	24108	57	Millard	Millard	NNP
18637	24108	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24108	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24108	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24108	61	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	24108	62	,	,	,
18637	24108	63	202	202	CD
18637	24108	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24108	65	429	429	CD
18637	24108	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24108	67	1906	1906	CD
18637	24108	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24108	69	,	,	,
18637	24108	70	102	102	CD
18637	24108	71	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24108	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24108	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	24108	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24108	75	Foree	Foree	NNP
18637	24108	76	,	,	,
18637	24108	77	116	116	CD
18637	24108	78	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24108	79	22	22	CD
18637	24108	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24108	81	1885	1885	CD
18637	24108	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24108	83	,	,	,
18637	24108	84	273	273	CD
18637	24108	85	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24108	86	_	_	NNP
18637	24108	87	v.	v.	IN
18637	24108	88	_	_	NNP
18637	24108	89	Horton	Horton	NNP
18637	24108	90	,	,	,
18637	24108	91	152	152	CD
18637	24108	92	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24109	1	540	540	CD
18637	24109	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24109	3	1891	1891	CD
18637	24109	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24109	5	,	,	,
18637	24109	6	1086	1086	CD
18637	24109	7	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24109	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24109	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24109	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24109	11	McLaughlin	McLaughlin	NNP
18637	24109	12	,	,	,
18637	24109	13	281	281	CD
18637	24109	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24109	15	261	261	CD
18637	24109	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24109	17	1930	1930	CD
18637	24109	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24109	19	,	,	,
18637	24109	20	1027	1027	CD
18637	24109	21	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24109	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24109	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24109	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24109	25	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	24109	26	,	,	,
18637	24109	27	272	272	CD
18637	24109	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24109	29	713	713	CD
18637	24109	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24109	31	1927	1927	CD
18637	24109	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24109	33	,	,	,
18637	24109	34	730	730	CD
18637	24109	35	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24109	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24109	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24109	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24109	39	New	New	NNP
18637	24109	40	York	York	NNP
18637	24109	41	,	,	,
18637	24109	42	15	15	CD
18637	24109	43	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24109	44	.	.	.
18637	24110	1	478	478	CD
18637	24110	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24110	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	24110	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24110	5	,	,	,
18637	24110	6	343	343	CD
18637	24110	7	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24110	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24110	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24110	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24110	11	Schoene	Schoene	NNP
18637	24110	12	,	,	,
18637	24110	13	276	276	CD
18637	24110	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24110	15	272	272	CD
18637	24110	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24110	17	1928	1928	CD
18637	24110	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24110	19	,	,	,
18637	24110	20	1027	1027	CD
18637	24110	21	,	,	,
18637	24110	22	1156	1156	CD
18637	24110	23	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24110	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24110	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24110	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24110	27	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	24110	28	Nut	Nut	NNP
18637	24110	29	Margarine	Margarine	NNP
18637	24110	30	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24110	31	,	,	,
18637	24110	32	284	284	CD
18637	24110	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24110	34	498	498	CD
18637	24110	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24110	36	1932	1932	CD
18637	24110	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24110	38	,	,	,
18637	24110	39	621	621	CD
18637	24110	40	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24110	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24110	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24110	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24110	44	Strahl	Strahl	NNP
18637	24110	45	,	,	,
18637	24110	46	239	239	CD
18637	24110	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24110	48	426	426	CD
18637	24110	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24110	50	1915	1915	CD
18637	24110	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24110	52	,	,	,
18637	24110	53	1155	1155	CD
18637	24110	54	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24110	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24110	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24110	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24110	58	United	United	NNP
18637	24110	59	States	States	NNP
18637	24110	60	,	,	,
18637	24110	61	11	11	CD
18637	24110	62	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24110	63	.	.	.
18637	24111	1	268	268	CD
18637	24111	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24111	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24111	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24111	5	,	,	,
18637	24111	6	280	280	CD
18637	24111	7	,	,	,
18637	24111	8	295	295	CD
18637	24111	9	,	,	,
18637	24111	10	565	565	CD
18637	24111	11	,	,	,
18637	24111	12	645	645	CD
18637	24111	13	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24111	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24111	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24111	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24111	17	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24111	18	,	,	,
18637	24111	19	236	236	CD
18637	24111	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24111	21	373	373	CD
18637	24111	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24111	23	1915	1915	CD
18637	24111	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24111	25	,	,	,
18637	24111	26	986	986	CD
18637	24111	27	,	,	,
18637	24111	28	1159	1159	CD
18637	24111	29	Millers	miller	NNS
18637	24111	30	'	'	POS
18637	24111	31	Underwriters	Underwriters	NNPS
18637	24111	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24111	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	24111	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24111	35	Braud	Braud	NNP
18637	24111	36	,	,	,
18637	24111	37	270	270	CD
18637	24111	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24111	39	59	59	CD
18637	24111	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24111	41	1926	1926	CD
18637	24111	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24111	43	,	,	,
18637	24111	44	582	582	CD
18637	24111	45	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
18637	24111	46	,	,	,
18637	24111	47	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24111	48	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24111	49	,	,	,
18637	24111	50	4	4	CD
18637	24111	51	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24111	52	.	.	.
18637	24112	1	2	2	CD
18637	24112	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24112	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	24112	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24112	5	,	,	,
18637	24112	6	280	280	CD
18637	24112	7	,	,	,
18637	24112	8	286	286	CD
18637	24112	9	,	,	,
18637	24112	10	294	294	CD
18637	24112	11	,	,	,
18637	24112	12	314	314	CD
18637	24112	13	,	,	,
18637	24112	14	315	315	CD
18637	24112	15	,	,	,
18637	24112	16	390	390	CD
18637	24112	17	,	,	,
18637	24112	18	399	399	CD
18637	24112	19	Milliken	Milliken	NNP
18637	24112	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24112	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24112	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24112	23	Meyer	Meyer	NNP
18637	24112	24	,	,	,
18637	24112	25	311	311	CD
18637	24112	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24112	27	457	457	CD
18637	24112	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24112	29	1940	1940	CD
18637	24112	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24112	31	,	,	,
18637	24112	32	659	659	CD
18637	24112	33	,	,	,
18637	24112	34	1074	1074	CD
18637	24112	35	Mills	Mills	NNPS
18637	24112	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24112	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24112	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24112	39	Duryee	Duryee	NNP
18637	24112	40	,	,	,
18637	24112	41	7	7	CD
18637	24112	42	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24112	43	.	.	.
18637	24113	1	481	481	CD
18637	24113	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24113	3	1813	1813	CD
18637	24113	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24113	5	,	,	,
18637	24113	6	653	653	CD
18637	24113	7	,	,	,
18637	24113	8	658	658	CD
18637	24113	9	,	,	,
18637	24113	10	661	661	CD
18637	24113	11	Mills	Mills	NNPS
18637	24113	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24113	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24113	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24113	15	Green	Green	NNP
18637	24113	16	,	,	,
18637	24113	17	159	159	CD
18637	24113	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24113	19	651	651	CD
18637	24113	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24113	21	1895	1895	CD
18637	24113	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24113	23	,	,	,
18637	24113	24	545	545	CD
18637	24113	25	Millsaps	Millsaps	NNP
18637	24113	26	College	College	NNP
18637	24113	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24113	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24113	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24113	30	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	24113	31	,	,	,
18637	24113	32	275	275	CD
18637	24113	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24113	34	129	129	CD
18637	24113	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24113	36	1927	1927	CD
18637	24113	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24113	38	,	,	,
18637	24113	39	348	348	CD
18637	24113	40	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	24113	41	County	County	NNP
18637	24113	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24113	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24113	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24113	45	White	White	NNP
18637	24113	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24113	47	M.E.	M.E.	NNP
18637	24114	1	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24114	2	,	,	,
18637	24114	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24114	4	,	,	,
18637	24114	5	296	296	CD
18637	24114	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24114	7	268	268	CD
18637	24114	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24114	9	1935	1935	CD
18637	24114	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24114	11	,	,	,
18637	24114	12	654	654	CD
18637	24114	13	,	,	,
18637	24114	14	655	655	CD
18637	24114	15	,	,	,
18637	24114	16	675	675	CD
18637	24114	17	,	,	,
18637	24114	18	684	684	CD
18637	24114	19	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	24114	20	Social	Social	NNP
18637	24114	21	Democratic	Democratic	NNP
18637	24114	22	Publishing	Publishing	NNP
18637	24114	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24114	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24114	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24114	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24114	27	Burleson	Burleson	NNP
18637	24114	28	,	,	,
18637	24114	29	255	255	CD
18637	24114	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24114	31	407	407	CD
18637	24114	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24114	33	1921	1921	CD
18637	24114	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24114	35	,	,	,
18637	24114	36	269	269	CD
18637	24114	37	Mimmack	Mimmack	NNP
18637	24114	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24114	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24114	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24114	41	United	United	NNP
18637	24114	42	States	States	NNP
18637	24114	43	,	,	,
18637	24114	44	97	97	CD
18637	24114	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24114	46	426	426	CD
18637	24114	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24114	48	1878	1878	CD
18637	24114	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24114	50	,	,	,
18637	24114	51	404	404	CD
18637	24114	52	Minersville	Minersville	NNP
18637	24114	53	School	School	NNP
18637	24114	54	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	24114	55	.	.	.
18637	24115	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24115	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24115	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24115	4	Gobitis	Gobitis	NNP
18637	24115	5	,	,	,
18637	24115	6	310	310	CD
18637	24115	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24115	8	586	586	CD
18637	24115	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24115	10	1940	1940	CD
18637	24115	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24115	12	,	,	,
18637	24115	13	767	767	NNP
18637	24115	14	Mine	Mine	NNP
18637	24115	15	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	24115	16	Appliances	Appliances	NNPS
18637	24115	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24115	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24115	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24115	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24115	21	Forrestal	Forrestal	NNP
18637	24115	22	,	,	,
18637	24115	23	326	326	CD
18637	24115	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24115	25	371	371	CD
18637	24115	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24115	27	1945	1945	CD
18637	24115	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24115	29	,	,	,
18637	24115	30	588	588	CD
18637	24115	31	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
18637	24115	32	&	&	CC
18637	24115	33	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24115	34	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	24116	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24116	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24116	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24116	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24116	5	Beckwith	Beckwith	NNP
18637	24116	6	,	,	,
18637	24116	7	129	129	CD
18637	24116	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24116	9	26	26	CD
18637	24116	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24116	11	1889	1889	CD
18637	24116	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24116	13	,	,	,
18637	24116	14	1016	1016	CD
18637	24116	15	,	,	,
18637	24116	16	1142	1142	CD
18637	24116	17	,	,	,
18637	24116	18	1156	1156	CD
18637	24116	19	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
18637	24116	20	&	&	CC
18637	24116	21	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24116	22	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	24117	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24117	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24117	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24117	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24117	5	Bombolis	Bombolis	NNP
18637	24117	6	,	,	,
18637	24117	7	241	241	CD
18637	24117	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24117	9	211	211	CD
18637	24117	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24117	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	24117	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24117	13	,	,	,
18637	24117	14	893	893	CD
18637	24117	15	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
18637	24117	16	&	&	CC
18637	24117	17	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24117	18	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	24118	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24118	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24118	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24118	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24118	5	Emmons	Emmons	NNP
18637	24118	6	,	,	,
18637	24118	7	149	149	CD
18637	24118	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24118	9	364	364	CD
18637	24118	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24118	11	1893	1893	CD
18637	24118	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24118	13	,	,	,
18637	24118	14	345	345	CD
18637	24118	15	,	,	,
18637	24118	16	1156	1156	CD
18637	24118	17	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
18637	24118	18	&	&	CC
18637	24118	19	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24118	20	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	24119	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24119	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24119	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24119	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24119	5	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24119	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24119	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	24119	8	.	.	.
18637	24120	1	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24120	2	&	&	CC
18637	24120	3	W.	W.	NNP
18637	24120	4	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24120	5	,	,	,
18637	24120	6	193	193	CD
18637	24120	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24120	8	53	53	CD
18637	24120	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24120	10	1904	1904	CD
18637	24120	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24120	12	,	,	,
18637	24120	13	1012	1012	CD
18637	24120	14	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24120	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24120	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24120	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24120	18	Barber	Barber	NNP
18637	24120	19	,	,	,
18637	24120	20	136	136	CD
18637	24120	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24120	22	313	313	CD
18637	24120	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24120	24	1890	1890	CD
18637	24120	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24120	26	,	,	,
18637	24120	27	238	238	CD
18637	24120	28	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24120	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24120	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24120	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24120	32	Blasius	Blasius	NNP
18637	24120	33	,	,	,
18637	24120	34	290	290	CD
18637	24120	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24120	36	1	1	CD
18637	24120	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24120	38	1933	1933	CD
18637	24120	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24120	40	,	,	,
18637	24120	41	149	149	CD
18637	24120	42	,	,	,
18637	24120	43	185	185	CD
18637	24120	44	,	,	,
18637	24120	45	189	189	CD
18637	24120	46	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24120	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24120	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	24120	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24120	50	Hitchcock	Hitchcock	NNP
18637	24120	51	,	,	,
18637	24120	52	185	185	CD
18637	24120	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24120	54	373	373	CD
18637	24120	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24120	56	1902	1902	CD
18637	24120	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24120	58	,	,	,
18637	24120	59	588	588	CD
18637	24120	60	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24120	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24120	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	24120	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24120	64	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	24120	65	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	24120	66	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24120	67	,	,	,
18637	24120	68	184	184	CD
18637	24120	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24120	70	199	199	CD
18637	24120	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24120	72	1902	1902	CD
18637	24120	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24120	74	,	,	,
18637	24120	75	596	596	CD
18637	24120	76	,	,	,
18637	24120	77	597	597	CD
18637	24120	78	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24120	79	_	_	NNP
18637	24120	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	24120	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24120	82	Probate	Probate	NNP
18637	24120	83	Court	Court	NNP
18637	24120	84	,	,	,
18637	24120	85	309	309	CD
18637	24120	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24120	87	270	270	CD
18637	24120	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24120	89	1940	1940	CD
18637	24120	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24120	91	,	,	,
18637	24120	92	984	984	CD
18637	24120	93	,	,	,
18637	24120	94	1098	1098	CD
18637	24120	95	,	,	,
18637	24120	96	1161	1161	CD
18637	24120	97	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24120	98	_	_	NNP
18637	24120	99	v.	v.	IN
18637	24120	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24120	101	United	United	NNP
18637	24120	102	States	States	NNP
18637	24120	103	,	,	,
18637	24120	104	305	305	CD
18637	24120	105	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24120	106	382	382	CD
18637	24120	107	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24120	108	1939	1939	CD
18637	24120	109	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24120	110	,	,	,
18637	24120	111	587	587	CD
18637	24120	112	,	,	,
18637	24120	113	588	588	CD
18637	24120	114	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24120	115	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	24120	116	.	.	.
18637	24121	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24121	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24121	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24121	4	Benn	Benn	NNP
18637	24121	5	,	,	,
18637	24121	6	261	261	CD
18637	24121	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24121	8	140	140	CD
18637	24121	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24121	10	1923	1923	CD
18637	24121	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24121	12	,	,	,
18637	24121	13	1079	1079	CD
18637	24121	14	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24121	15	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24121	16	rel	rel	NN
18637	24121	17	.	.	.
18637	24122	1	Whipple	Whipple	NNP
18637	24122	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24122	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24122	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24122	5	Martinson	Martinson	NNP
18637	24122	6	,	,	,
18637	24122	7	256	256	CD
18637	24122	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24122	9	41	41	CD
18637	24122	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24122	11	1921	1921	CD
18637	24122	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24122	13	,	,	,
18637	24122	14	1030	1030	CD
18637	24122	15	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24122	16	Rate	Rate	NNP
18637	24122	17	Cases	case	NNS
18637	24122	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24122	19	Simpson	Simpson	NNP
18637	24122	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24122	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24122	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24122	23	Shepard	shepard	RB
18637	24122	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24122	25	230	230	CD
18637	24122	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24122	27	352	352	CD
18637	24122	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24122	29	1913	1913	CD
18637	24122	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24122	31	,	,	,
18637	24122	32	176	176	CD
18637	24122	33	,	,	,
18637	24122	34	218	218	CD
18637	24122	35	,	,	,
18637	24122	36	236	236	CD
18637	24122	37	,	,	,
18637	24122	38	1006	1006	CD
18637	24122	39	Minor	Minor	NNP
18637	24122	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24122	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24122	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24122	43	Happersett	Happersett	NNP
18637	24122	44	,	,	,
18637	24122	45	21	21	CD
18637	24122	46	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24122	47	.	.	.
18637	24123	1	162	162	CD
18637	24123	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24123	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	24123	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24123	5	,	,	,
18637	24123	6	87	87	CD
18637	24123	7	,	,	,
18637	24123	8	705	705	CD
18637	24123	9	,	,	,
18637	24123	10	971	971	CD
18637	24123	11	Mintz	Mintz	NNP
18637	24123	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24123	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24123	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24123	15	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	24123	16	,	,	,
18637	24123	17	289	289	CD
18637	24123	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24123	19	346	346	CD
18637	24123	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24123	21	1933	1933	CD
18637	24123	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24123	23	,	,	,
18637	24123	24	237	237	CD
18637	24123	25	,	,	,
18637	24123	26	250	250	CD
18637	24123	27	,	,	,
18637	24123	28	251	251	CD
18637	24123	29	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	24123	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24123	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24123	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24123	33	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	24123	34	,	,	,
18637	24123	35	4	4	CD
18637	24123	36	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24123	37	.	.	.
18637	24124	1	475	475	CD
18637	24124	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24124	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	24124	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24124	5	,	,	,
18637	24124	6	499	499	CD
18637	24124	7	,	,	,
18637	24124	8	543	543	CD
18637	24124	9	,	,	,
18637	24124	10	546	546	CD
18637	24124	11	,	,	,
18637	24124	12	596	596	CD
18637	24124	13	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	24124	14	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24124	15	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24124	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24124	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24124	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24124	19	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	24124	20	&	&	CC
18637	24124	21	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	24125	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24125	2	,	,	,
18637	24125	3	244	244	CD
18637	24125	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24125	5	388	388	CD
18637	24125	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24125	7	1917	1917	CD
18637	24125	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24125	9	,	,	,
18637	24125	10	1009	1009	CD
18637	24125	11	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	24125	12	Use	Use	NNP
18637	24125	13	of	of	IN
18637	24125	14	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	24125	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24125	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	18	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24125	19	,	,	,
18637	24125	20	276	276	CD
18637	24125	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24125	22	174	174	CD
18637	24125	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24125	24	1928	1928	CD
18637	24125	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24125	26	,	,	,
18637	24125	27	341	341	CD
18637	24125	28	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24125	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24125	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	32	Canada	Canada	NNP
18637	24125	33	,	,	,
18637	24125	34	305	305	CD
18637	24125	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24125	36	337	337	CD
18637	24125	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24125	38	1938	1938	CD
18637	24125	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24125	40	,	,	,
18637	24125	41	1162	1162	CD
18637	24125	42	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24125	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24125	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	46	Dockery	Dockery	NNP
18637	24125	47	,	,	,
18637	24125	48	191	191	CD
18637	24125	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24125	50	165	165	CD
18637	24125	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24125	52	1903	1903	CD
18637	24125	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24125	54	,	,	,
18637	24125	55	1152	1152	CD
18637	24125	56	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24125	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	24125	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	60	Fiske	Fiske	NNP
18637	24125	61	,	,	,
18637	24125	62	290	290	CD
18637	24125	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24125	64	18	18	CD
18637	24125	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24125	66	1933	1933	CD
18637	24125	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24125	68	,	,	,
18637	24125	69	934	934	CD
18637	24125	70	,	,	,
18637	24125	71	936	936	CD
18637	24125	72	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24125	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	24125	75	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	76	Holland	Holland	NNP
18637	24125	77	,	,	,
18637	24125	78	252	252	CD
18637	24125	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24125	80	416	416	CD
18637	24125	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24125	82	1920	1920	CD
18637	24125	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24125	84	,	,	,
18637	24125	85	308	308	CD
18637	24125	86	,	,	,
18637	24125	87	428	428	CD
18637	24125	88	,	,	,
18637	24125	89	544	544	CD
18637	24125	90	,	,	,
18637	24125	91	612	612	CD
18637	24125	92	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24125	93	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	94	v.	v.	IN
18637	24125	95	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	96	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	24125	97	,	,	,
18637	24125	98	180	180	CD
18637	24125	99	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24125	100	208	208	CD
18637	24125	101	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24125	102	1901	1901	CD
18637	24125	103	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24125	104	,	,	,
18637	24125	105	592	592	CD
18637	24125	106	,	,	,
18637	24125	107	599	599	CD
18637	24125	108	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24125	109	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	110	v.	v.	IN
18637	24125	111	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	112	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	24125	113	,	,	,
18637	24125	114	101	101	CD
18637	24125	115	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24125	116	22	22	CD
18637	24125	117	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24125	118	1880	1880	CD
18637	24125	119	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24125	120	,	,	,
18637	24125	121	1110	1110	CD
18637	24125	122	,	,	,
18637	24125	123	1112	1112	CD
18637	24125	124	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24125	125	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	126	v.	v.	IN
18637	24125	127	_	_	NNP
18637	24125	128	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24125	129	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24125	130	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24125	131	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24125	132	,	,	,
18637	24125	133	292	292	CD
18637	24125	134	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24125	135	13	13	CD
18637	24125	136	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24125	137	1934	1934	CD
18637	24125	138	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24125	139	,	,	,
18637	24125	140	615	615	CD
18637	24125	141	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24125	142	&	&	CC
18637	24125	143	A.	A.	NNP
18637	24126	1	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	24126	2	&	&	CC
18637	24126	3	Min	Min	NNP
18637	24126	4	.	.	.
18637	24127	1	Co	co	VB
18637	24127	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24127	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24127	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24127	5	Greenwood	Greenwood	NNP
18637	24127	6	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	24127	7	.	.	.
18637	24127	8	,	,	,
18637	24127	9	249	249	CD
18637	24127	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24127	11	170	170	CD
18637	24127	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24127	13	1919	1919	CD
18637	24127	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24127	15	,	,	,
18637	24127	16	352	352	CD
18637	24127	17	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24127	18	ex	ex	NN
18637	24127	19	rel	rel	NN
18637	24127	20	.	.	.
18637	24128	1	Barrett	Barrett	NNP
18637	24128	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24128	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24128	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24128	5	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24128	6	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	24128	7	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24128	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24128	9	,	,	,
18637	24128	10	265	265	CD
18637	24128	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24128	12	298	298	CD
18637	24128	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24128	14	1924	1924	CD
18637	24128	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24128	16	,	,	,
18637	24128	17	138	138	CD
18637	24128	18	,	,	,
18637	24128	19	233	233	CD
18637	24128	20	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24128	21	ex	ex	NN
18637	24128	22	rel	rel	NN
18637	24128	23	.	.	.
18637	24129	1	Gaines	Gaines	NNP
18637	24129	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24129	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24129	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24129	5	Canada	Canada	NNP
18637	24129	6	,	,	,
18637	24129	7	305	305	CD
18637	24129	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24129	9	337	337	CD
18637	24129	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24129	11	1938	1938	CD
18637	24129	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24129	13	,	,	,
18637	24129	14	1142	1142	CD
18637	24129	15	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24129	16	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24129	17	rel	rel	NN
18637	24129	18	.	.	.
18637	24130	1	Hurwitz	Hurwitz	NNP
18637	24130	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24130	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24130	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24130	5	North	North	NNP
18637	24130	6	,	,	,
18637	24130	7	271	271	CD
18637	24130	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24130	9	40	40	CD
18637	24130	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24130	11	1926	1926	CD
18637	24130	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24130	13	,	,	,
18637	24130	14	1086	1086	CD
18637	24130	15	,	,	,
18637	24130	16	1155	1155	CD
18637	24130	17	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24130	18	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24130	19	rel	rel	NN
18637	24130	20	.	.	.
18637	24131	1	Southwestern	Southwestern	NNP
18637	24131	2	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	24131	3	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	24131	4	.	.	.
18637	24132	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24132	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24132	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24132	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24132	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24132	6	Service	Service	NNP
18637	24132	7	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24132	8	,	,	,
18637	24132	9	262	262	CD
18637	24132	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24132	11	276	276	CD
18637	24132	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24132	13	1923	1923	CD
18637	24132	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24132	15	,	,	,
18637	24132	16	1005	1005	CD
18637	24132	17	,	,	,
18637	24132	18	1006	1006	CD
18637	24132	19	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24132	20	,	,	,
18637	24132	21	K.	K.	NNP
18637	24132	22	&	&	CC
18637	24132	23	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	24133	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24133	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24133	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24133	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24133	5	Cade	Cade	NNP
18637	24133	6	,	,	,
18637	24133	7	233	233	CD
18637	24133	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24133	9	642	642	CD
18637	24133	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24133	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	24133	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24133	13	,	,	,
18637	24133	14	1092	1092	CD
18637	24133	15	,	,	,
18637	24133	16	1167	1167	CD
18637	24133	17	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24133	18	,	,	,
18637	24133	19	K.	K.	NNP
18637	24133	20	&	&	CC
18637	24133	21	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	24134	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24134	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24134	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24134	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24134	5	Haber	Haber	NNP
18637	24134	6	,	,	,
18637	24134	7	169	169	CD
18637	24134	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24134	9	613	613	CD
18637	24134	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24134	11	1898	1898	CD
18637	24134	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24134	13	,	,	,
18637	24134	14	222	222	CD
18637	24134	15	,	,	,
18637	24134	16	248	248	CD
18637	24134	17	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24134	18	,	,	,
18637	24134	19	K.	K.	NNP
18637	24134	20	&	&	CC
18637	24134	21	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	24135	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24135	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24135	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24135	4	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	24135	5	,	,	,
18637	24135	6	234	234	CD
18637	24135	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24135	8	412	412	CD
18637	24135	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24135	10	1914	1914	CD
18637	24135	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24135	12	,	,	,
18637	24135	13	1167	1167	CD
18637	24135	14	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24135	15	,	,	,
18637	24135	16	K.	K.	NNP
18637	24135	17	&	&	CC
18637	24135	18	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	24136	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24136	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24136	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24136	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24136	5	May	May	NNP
18637	24136	6	,	,	,
18637	24136	7	194	194	CD
18637	24136	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24136	9	267	267	CD
18637	24136	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24136	11	1904	1904	CD
18637	24136	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24136	13	,	,	,
18637	24136	14	1156	1156	CD
18637	24136	15	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24136	16	,	,	,
18637	24136	17	K.	K.	NNP
18637	24136	18	&	&	CC
18637	24136	19	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	24137	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24137	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24137	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24137	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24137	5	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	24137	6	,	,	,
18637	24137	7	255	255	CD
18637	24137	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24137	9	565	565	CD
18637	24137	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24137	11	1921	1921	CD
18637	24137	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24137	13	,	,	,
18637	24137	14	1076	1076	CD
18637	24137	15	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24137	16	,	,	,
18637	24137	17	K.	K.	NNP
18637	24137	18	&	&	CC
18637	24137	19	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	24138	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24138	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24138	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24138	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24138	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24138	6	,	,	,
18637	24138	7	245	245	CD
18637	24138	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24138	9	484	484	CD
18637	24138	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24138	11	1918	1918	CD
18637	24138	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24138	13	,	,	,
18637	24138	14	219	219	CD
18637	24138	15	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24138	16	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24139	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24139	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24139	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24139	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24139	5	Castle	Castle	NNP
18637	24139	6	,	,	,
18637	24139	7	224	224	CD
18637	24139	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24139	9	541	541	CD
18637	24139	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24139	11	1912	1912	CD
18637	24139	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24139	13	,	,	,
18637	24139	14	971	971	CD
18637	24139	15	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24139	16	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24140	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24140	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24140	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24140	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24140	5	Humes	Humes	NNP
18637	24140	6	,	,	,
18637	24140	7	115	115	CD
18637	24140	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24140	9	512	512	CD
18637	24140	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24140	11	1885	1885	CD
18637	24140	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24140	13	,	,	,
18637	24140	14	1016	1016	CD
18637	24140	15	,	,	,
18637	24140	16	1156	1156	CD
18637	24140	17	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24140	18	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24141	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24141	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24141	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24141	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24141	5	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24141	6	,	,	,
18637	24141	7	248	248	CD
18637	24141	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24141	9	276	276	CD
18637	24141	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24141	11	1919	1919	CD
18637	24141	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24141	13	,	,	,
18637	24141	14	103	103	CD
18637	24141	15	,	,	,
18637	24141	16	413	413	CD
18637	24141	17	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24141	18	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24142	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24142	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24142	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24142	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24142	5	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24142	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24142	7	rel	rel	NNP
18637	24142	8	.	.	.
18637	24143	1	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24143	2	,	,	,
18637	24143	3	216	216	CD
18637	24143	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24143	5	262	262	CD
18637	24143	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24143	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	24143	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24143	9	,	,	,
18637	24143	10	1011	1011	CD
18637	24143	11	,	,	,
18637	24143	12	1012	1012	CD
18637	24143	13	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24143	14	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24144	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24144	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24144	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24144	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24144	5	Larabee	Larabee	NNP
18637	24144	6	,	,	,
18637	24144	7	234	234	CD
18637	24144	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24144	9	459	459	CD
18637	24144	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24144	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	24144	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24144	13	,	,	,
18637	24144	14	1167	1167	CD
18637	24144	15	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24144	16	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24145	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24145	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24145	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24145	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24145	5	Larabee	Larabee	NNP
18637	24145	6	Flour	Flour	NNP
18637	24145	7	Mills	Mills	NNPS
18637	24145	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24145	9	,	,	,
18637	24145	10	211	211	CD
18637	24145	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24145	12	612	612	CD
18637	24145	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24145	14	1909	1909	CD
18637	24145	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24145	16	,	,	,
18637	24145	17	222	222	CD
18637	24145	18	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24145	19	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24146	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24146	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24146	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24146	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24146	5	McGrew	McGrew	NNP
18637	24146	6	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	24146	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24146	8	,	,	,
18637	24146	9	244	244	CD
18637	24146	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24146	11	191	191	CD
18637	24146	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24146	13	1917	1917	CD
18637	24146	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24146	15	,	,	,
18637	24146	16	1013	1013	CD
18637	24146	17	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24146	18	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24147	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24147	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24147	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24147	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24147	5	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	24147	6	,	,	,
18637	24147	7	217	217	CD
18637	24147	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24147	9	196	196	CD
18637	24147	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24147	11	1910	1910	CD
18637	24147	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24147	13	,	,	,
18637	24147	14	1009	1009	CD
18637	24147	15	,	,	,
18637	24147	16	1012	1012	CD
18637	24147	17	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24147	18	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24148	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24148	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24148	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24148	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24148	5	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	24148	6	ex	ex	NN
18637	24148	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	24148	8	.	.	.
18637	24149	1	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24149	2	of	of	IN
18637	24149	3	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	24149	4	,	,	,
18637	24149	5	164	164	CD
18637	24149	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24149	7	403	403	CD
18637	24149	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24149	9	1896	1896	CD
18637	24149	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24149	11	,	,	,
18637	24149	12	1066	1066	CD
18637	24149	13	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24149	14	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24150	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24150	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24150	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24150	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24150	5	Norwood	Norwood	NNP
18637	24150	6	,	,	,
18637	24150	7	283	283	CD
18637	24150	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24150	9	249	249	CD
18637	24150	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24150	11	1931	1931	CD
18637	24150	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24150	13	,	,	,
18637	24150	14	223	223	CD
18637	24150	15	,	,	,
18637	24150	16	1014	1014	CD
18637	24150	17	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24150	18	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24151	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24151	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24151	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24151	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24151	5	Porter	Porter	NNP
18637	24151	6	,	,	,
18637	24151	7	273	273	CD
18637	24151	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24151	9	341	341	CD
18637	24151	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24151	11	1927	1927	CD
18637	24151	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24151	13	,	,	,
18637	24151	14	247	247	CD
18637	24151	15	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24151	16	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24152	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24152	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24152	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24152	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24152	5	Tucker	Tucker	NNP
18637	24152	6	,	,	,
18637	24152	7	230	230	CD
18637	24152	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24152	9	340	340	CD
18637	24152	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24152	11	1913	1913	CD
18637	24152	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24152	13	,	,	,
18637	24152	14	1015	1015	CD
18637	24152	15	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24152	16	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24153	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24153	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24153	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24153	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24153	5	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24153	6	Crawford	Crawford	NNP
18637	24153	7	Road	Road	NNP
18637	24153	8	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	24153	9	.	.	.
18637	24154	1	Dist	dist	VB
18637	24154	2	,	,	,
18637	24154	3	266	266	CD
18637	24154	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24154	5	187	187	CD
18637	24154	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24154	7	1924	1924	CD
18637	24154	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24154	9	,	,	,
18637	24154	10	1040	1040	CD
18637	24154	11	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	24154	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24154	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24154	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24154	15	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	24154	16	,	,	,
18637	24154	17	110	110	CD
18637	24154	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24154	19	633	633	CD
18637	24154	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24154	21	1884	1884	CD
18637	24154	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24154	23	,	,	,
18637	24154	24	362	362	CD
18637	24154	25	,	,	,
18637	24154	26	501	501	CD
18637	24154	27	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	24154	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24154	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24154	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24154	31	Harmony	Harmony	NNP
18637	24154	32	,	,	,
18637	24154	33	13	13	CD
18637	24154	34	How	how	WRB
18637	24154	35	.	.	.
18637	24155	1	115	115	CD
18637	24155	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24155	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	24155	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24155	5	,	,	,
18637	24155	6	298	298	CD
18637	24155	7	,	,	,
18637	24155	8	404	404	CD
18637	24155	9	,	,	,
18637	24155	10	496	496	CD
18637	24155	11	,	,	,
18637	24155	12	896	896	CD
18637	24155	13	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	24155	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24155	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24155	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24155	17	United	United	NNP
18637	24155	18	States	States	NNP
18637	24155	19	,	,	,
18637	24155	20	267	267	CD
18637	24155	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24155	22	341	341	CD
18637	24155	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24155	24	1925	1925	CD
18637	24155	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24155	26	,	,	,
18637	24155	27	871	871	CD
18637	24155	28	Mittle	Mittle	NNP
18637	24155	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24155	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24155	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24155	32	State	State	NNP
18637	24155	33	of	of	IN
18637	24155	34	South	South	NNP
18637	24155	35	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24155	36	,	,	,
18637	24155	37	260	260	CD
18637	24155	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24155	39	705	705	CD
18637	24155	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24155	41	1922	1922	CD
18637	24155	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24155	43	,	,	,
18637	24155	44	1220	1220	CD
18637	24155	45	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	24155	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24155	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	24155	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24155	49	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	24155	50	,	,	,
18637	24155	51	116	116	CD
18637	24155	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24155	53	289	289	CD
18637	24155	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24155	55	1886	1886	CD
18637	24155	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24155	57	,	,	,
18637	24155	58	356	356	CD
18637	24155	59	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	24155	60	&	&	CC
18637	24155	61	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24155	62	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	24156	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24156	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24156	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24156	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24156	5	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	24156	6	,	,	,
18637	24156	7	153	153	CD
18637	24156	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24156	9	486	486	CD
18637	24156	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24156	11	1894	1894	CD
18637	24156	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24156	13	,	,	,
18637	24156	14	330	330	CD
18637	24156	15	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	24156	16	County	County	NNP
18637	24156	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24156	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24156	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24156	20	Kimball	Kimball	NNP
18637	24156	21	,	,	,
18637	24156	22	102	102	CD
18637	24156	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24156	24	691	691	CD
18637	24156	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24156	26	1881	1881	CD
18637	24156	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24156	28	,	,	,
18637	24156	29	120	120	CD
18637	24156	30	,	,	,
18637	24156	31	124	124	CD
18637	24156	32	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	24156	33	,	,	,
18637	24156	34	J.	J.	NNP
18637	24157	1	&	&	CC
18637	24157	2	K.C.R.	K.C.R.	NNP
18637	24158	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24158	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24158	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24158	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24158	5	Turnipseed	Turnipseed	NNP
18637	24158	6	,	,	,
18637	24158	7	219	219	CD
18637	24158	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24158	9	35	35	CD
18637	24158	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24158	11	1910	1910	CD
18637	24158	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24158	13	,	,	,
18637	24158	14	1094	1094	CD
18637	24158	15	,	,	,
18637	24158	16	1095	1095	CD
18637	24158	17	,	,	,
18637	24158	18	1166	1166	CD
18637	24158	19	Modern	Modern	NNP
18637	24158	20	Woodmen	Woodmen	NNP
18637	24158	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24158	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	24158	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24158	24	Mixer	Mixer	NNP
18637	24158	25	,	,	,
18637	24158	26	267	267	CD
18637	24158	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24158	28	544	544	CD
18637	24158	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24158	30	1925	1925	CD
18637	24158	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24158	32	,	,	,
18637	24158	33	678	678	CD
18637	24158	34	Moffitt	Moffitt	NNP
18637	24158	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24158	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24158	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24158	38	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
18637	24158	39	,	,	,
18637	24158	40	218	218	CD
18637	24158	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24158	42	400	400	CD
18637	24158	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24158	44	1910	1910	CD
18637	24158	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24158	46	,	,	,
18637	24158	47	352	352	CD
18637	24158	48	Monaco	Monaco	NNP
18637	24158	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24158	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	24158	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24158	52	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	24158	53	,	,	,
18637	24158	54	292	292	CD
18637	24158	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24158	56	313	313	CD
18637	24158	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24158	58	1934	1934	CD
18637	24158	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24158	60	,	,	,
18637	24158	61	930	930	CD
18637	24158	62	Monamotor	Monamotor	NNP
18637	24158	63	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24158	64	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24158	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24158	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	24158	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24158	68	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	24158	69	,	,	,
18637	24158	70	292	292	CD
18637	24158	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24158	72	86	86	CD
18637	24158	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24158	74	1934	1934	CD
18637	24158	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24158	76	,	,	,
18637	24158	77	186	186	CD
18637	24158	78	Mondou	Mondou	NNP
18637	24158	79	_	_	NNP
18637	24158	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	24158	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24158	82	New	New	NNP
18637	24158	83	York	York	NNP
18637	24158	84	,	,	,
18637	24158	85	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	24158	86	&	&	CC
18637	24158	87	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	24159	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24159	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24159	3	Second	Second	NNP
18637	24159	4	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	24159	5	'	'	POS
18637	24159	6	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	24159	7	Cases	case	NNS
18637	24159	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24159	9	,	,	,
18637	24159	10	223	223	CD
18637	24159	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24159	12	1	1	CD
18637	24159	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24159	14	1912	1912	CD
18637	24159	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24159	16	,	,	,
18637	24159	17	141	141	CD
18637	24159	18	,	,	,
18637	24159	19	247	247	CD
18637	24159	20	,	,	,
18637	24159	21	637	637	CD
18637	24159	22	,	,	,
18637	24159	23	727	727	CD
18637	24159	24	Monongahela	Monongahela	NNP
18637	24159	25	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	24159	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24159	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24159	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24159	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24159	30	United	United	NNP
18637	24159	31	States	States	NNP
18637	24159	32	,	,	,
18637	24159	33	216	216	CD
18637	24159	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24159	35	177	177	CD
18637	24159	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24159	37	1910	1910	CD
18637	24159	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24159	39	,	,	,
18637	24159	40	128	128	CD
18637	24159	41	Monongahela	Monongahela	NNP
18637	24159	42	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	24159	43	.	.	.
18637	24160	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24160	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24160	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24160	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24160	5	United	United	NNP
18637	24160	6	States	States	NNP
18637	24160	7	,	,	,
18637	24160	8	148	148	CD
18637	24160	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24160	10	312	312	CD
18637	24160	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24160	12	1893	1893	CD
18637	24160	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24160	14	,	,	,
18637	24160	15	129	129	CD
18637	24160	16	,	,	,
18637	24160	17	750	750	CD
18637	24160	18	,	,	,
18637	24160	19	867	867	CD
18637	24160	20	,	,	,
18637	24160	21	870	870	CD
18637	24160	22	,	,	,
18637	24160	23	872	872	CD
18637	24160	24	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	24160	25	Catholic	Catholic	NNP
18637	24160	26	Missions	Missions	NNPS
18637	24160	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24160	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24160	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24160	30	Missoula	Missoula	NNP
18637	24160	31	County	County	NNP
18637	24160	32	,	,	,
18637	24160	33	200	200	CD
18637	24160	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24160	35	118	118	CD
18637	24160	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24160	37	1906	1906	CD
18637	24160	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24160	39	,	,	,
18637	24160	40	567	567	CD
18637	24160	41	Montana	Montana	NNP
18637	24160	42	Company	Company	NNP
18637	24160	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24160	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24160	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24160	46	St	St	NNP
18637	24160	47	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24160	48	Min	Min	NNP
18637	24160	49	.	.	.
18637	24161	1	&	&	CC
18637	24161	2	Mill	Mill	NNP
18637	24161	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24161	4	,	,	,
18637	24161	5	152	152	CD
18637	24161	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24161	7	160	160	CD
18637	24161	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24161	9	1894	1894	CD
18637	24161	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24161	11	,	,	,
18637	24161	12	1096	1096	CD
18637	24161	13	Montello	Montello	NNP
18637	24161	14	,	,	,
18637	24161	15	The	the	DT
18637	24161	16	,	,	,
18637	24161	17	20	20	CD
18637	24161	18	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24161	19	.	.	.
18637	24162	1	430	430	CD
18637	24162	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24162	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	24162	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24162	5	,	,	,
18637	24162	6	578	578	CD
18637	24162	7	Montoya	Montoya	NNP
18637	24162	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24162	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24162	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24162	11	Gonzales	Gonzales	NNP
18637	24162	12	,	,	,
18637	24162	13	232	232	CD
18637	24162	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24162	15	375	375	CD
18637	24162	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24162	17	1914	1914	CD
18637	24162	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24162	19	,	,	,
18637	24162	20	856	856	CD
18637	24162	21	Mooney	Mooney	NNP
18637	24162	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24162	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24162	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24162	25	Holohan	Holohan	NNP
18637	24162	26	,	,	,
18637	24162	27	294	294	CD
18637	24162	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24162	29	103	103	CD
18637	24162	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24162	31	1935	1935	CD
18637	24162	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24162	33	,	,	,
18637	24162	34	634	634	CD
18637	24162	35	,	,	,
18637	24162	36	1125	1125	CD
18637	24162	37	Mooney	Mooney	NNP
18637	24162	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24162	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24162	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24162	41	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24162	42	,	,	,
18637	24162	43	305	305	CD
18637	24162	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24162	45	598	598	CD
18637	24162	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24162	47	1938	1938	CD
18637	24162	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24162	49	,	,	,
18637	24162	50	1125	1125	CD
18637	24162	51	Mooney	Mooney	NNP
18637	24162	52	,	,	,
18637	24162	53	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24162	54	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24162	55	,	,	,
18637	24162	56	10	10	CD
18637	24162	57	Cal	Cal	NNS
18637	24162	58	.	.	.
18637	24163	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24163	2	2d	2d	NN
18637	24163	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24163	4	1	1	CD
18637	24163	5	,	,	,
18637	24163	6	73	73	CD
18637	24163	7	P.	P.	NNP
18637	24163	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24163	9	2d	2d	NNP
18637	24163	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24163	11	554	554	CD
18637	24163	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24163	13	1937	1937	CD
18637	24163	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24163	15	,	,	,
18637	24163	16	1125	1125	CD
18637	24163	17	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	24163	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24163	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24163	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24163	21	Dempsey	Dempsey	NNP
18637	24163	22	,	,	,
18637	24163	23	261	261	CD
18637	24163	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24163	25	86	86	CD
18637	24163	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24163	27	1923	1923	CD
18637	24163	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24163	29	,	,	,
18637	24163	30	1131	1131	CD
18637	24163	31	,	,	,
18637	24163	32	1138	1138	CD
18637	24163	33	,	,	,
18637	24163	34	1139	1139	CD
18637	24163	35	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	24163	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24163	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24163	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24163	39	Fidelity	Fidelity	NNP
18637	24163	40	&	&	CC
18637	24163	41	Deposit	Deposit	NNP
18637	24163	42	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24163	43	,	,	,
18637	24163	44	272	272	CD
18637	24163	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24163	46	317	317	CD
18637	24163	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24163	48	1926	1926	CD
18637	24163	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24163	50	,	,	,
18637	24163	51	631	631	CD
18637	24163	52	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	24163	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24163	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	24163	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24163	56	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	24163	57	,	,	,
18637	24163	58	3	3	NNP
18637	24163	59	S.	S.	NNP
18637	24163	60	&	&	CC
18637	24163	61	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24163	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24163	63	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24163	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24163	65	169	169	CD
18637	24163	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24163	67	1817	1817	CD
18637	24163	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24163	69	,	,	,
18637	24163	70	299	299	CD
18637	24163	71	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	24163	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24163	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	24163	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24163	75	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	24163	76	,	,	,
18637	24163	77	14	14	CD
18637	24163	78	How	how	WRB
18637	24163	79	.	.	.
18637	24164	1	13	13	CD
18637	24164	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24164	3	1853	1853	CD
18637	24164	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24164	5	,	,	,
18637	24164	6	696	696	CD
18637	24164	7	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	24164	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24164	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24164	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24164	11	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24164	12	,	,	,
18637	24164	13	159	159	CD
18637	24164	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24164	15	673	673	CD
18637	24164	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24164	17	1895	1895	CD
18637	24164	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24164	19	,	,	,
18637	24164	20	1161	1161	CD
18637	24164	21	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	24164	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24164	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24164	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24164	25	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	24164	26	,	,	,
18637	24164	27	281	281	CD
18637	24164	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24164	29	18	18	CD
18637	24164	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24164	31	1930	1930	CD
18637	24164	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24164	33	,	,	,
18637	24164	34	675	675	CD
18637	24164	35	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	24164	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24164	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24164	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24164	39	New	New	NNP
18637	24164	40	York	York	NNP
18637	24164	41	,	,	,
18637	24164	42	333	333	CD
18637	24164	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24164	44	565	565	CD
18637	24164	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24164	46	1948	1948	CD
18637	24164	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24164	48	,	,	,
18637	24164	49	1110	1110	CD
18637	24164	50	,	,	,
18637	24164	51	1111	1111	CD
18637	24164	52	Moran	Moran	NNP
18637	24164	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24164	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	24164	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24164	56	Sturges	Sturges	NNP
18637	24164	57	,	,	,
18637	24164	58	154	154	CD
18637	24164	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24164	60	256	256	CD
18637	24164	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24164	62	1894	1894	CD
18637	24164	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24164	64	,	,	,
18637	24164	65	627	627	CD
18637	24164	66	Moran	Moran	NNP
18637	24164	67	,	,	,
18637	24164	68	In	in	IN
18637	24164	69	re	re	NN
18637	24164	70	,	,	,
18637	24164	71	203	203	CD
18637	24164	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24164	73	96	96	CD
18637	24164	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24164	75	1903	1903	CD
18637	24164	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24164	77	,	,	,
18637	24164	78	634	634	CD
18637	24164	79	More	More	JJR
18637	24164	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24164	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	24164	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24164	83	Steinbach	Steinbach	NNP
18637	24164	84	,	,	,
18637	24164	85	127	127	CD
18637	24164	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24164	87	70	70	CD
18637	24164	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24164	89	1888	1888	CD
18637	24164	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24164	91	,	,	,
18637	24164	92	895	895	CD
18637	24164	93	Morehead	Morehead	NNP
18637	24164	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24164	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	24164	96	_	_	NNP
18637	24164	97	New	New	NNP
18637	24164	98	York	York	NNP
18637	24164	99	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24164	100	rel	rel	NN
18637	24164	101	.	.	.
18637	24165	1	Tipaldo	Tipaldo	NNP
18637	24165	2	,	,	,
18637	24165	3	298	298	CD
18637	24165	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24165	5	587	587	CD
18637	24165	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24165	7	1936	1936	CD
18637	24165	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24165	9	,	,	,
18637	24165	10	980	980	CD
18637	24165	11	,	,	,
18637	24165	12	989	989	CD
18637	24165	13	,	,	,
18637	24165	14	1159	1159	CD
18637	24165	15	Morf	Morf	NNP
18637	24165	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24165	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24165	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24165	19	Bingaman	Bingaman	NNP
18637	24165	20	,	,	,
18637	24165	21	298	298	CD
18637	24165	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24165	23	407	407	CD
18637	24165	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24165	25	1936	1936	CD
18637	24165	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24165	27	,	,	,
18637	24165	28	212	212	CD
18637	24165	29	,	,	,
18637	24165	30	1149	1149	CD
18637	24165	31	,	,	,
18637	24165	32	1151	1151	CD
18637	24165	33	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	24165	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24165	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	24165	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24165	37	Devine	Devine	NNP
18637	24165	38	,	,	,
18637	24165	39	237	237	CD
18637	24165	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24165	41	632	632	CD
18637	24165	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24165	43	1915	1915	CD
18637	24165	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24165	45	,	,	,
18637	24165	46	840	840	CD
18637	24165	47	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	24165	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24165	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	24165	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24165	51	Gay	Gay	NNP
18637	24165	52	,	,	,
18637	24165	53	19	19	CD
18637	24165	54	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24165	55	.	.	.
18637	24166	1	81	81	CD
18637	24166	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24166	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	24166	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24166	5	,	,	,
18637	24166	6	619	619	CD
18637	24166	7	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	24166	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24166	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24166	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24166	11	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24166	12	,	,	,
18637	24166	13	93	93	CD
18637	24166	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24166	15	217	217	CD
18637	24166	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24166	17	1876	1876	CD
18637	24166	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24166	19	,	,	,
18637	24166	20	347	347	CD
18637	24166	21	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	24166	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24166	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24166	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24166	25	TVA	TVA	NNP
18637	24166	26	,	,	,
18637	24166	27	28	28	CD
18637	24166	28	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24166	29	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	24166	30	.	.	.
18637	24167	1	732	732	CD
18637	24167	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24167	3	1939	1939	CD
18637	24167	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24167	5	,	,	,
18637	24167	6	460	460	CD
18637	24167	7	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	24167	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24167	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24167	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24167	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24167	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24167	13	,	,	,
18637	24167	14	304	304	CD
18637	24167	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24167	16	1	1	CD
18637	24167	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24167	18	1938	1938	CD
18637	24167	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24167	20	,	,	,
18637	24167	21	850	850	CD
18637	24167	22	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	24167	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24167	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24167	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24167	26	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24167	27	,	,	,
18637	24167	28	328	328	CD
18637	24167	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24167	30	373	373	CD
18637	24167	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24167	32	1946	1946	CD
18637	24167	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24167	34	,	,	,
18637	24167	35	225	225	CD
18637	24167	36	,	,	,
18637	24167	37	1162	1162	CD
18637	24167	38	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	24167	39	Envelope	Envelope	NNP
18637	24167	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24167	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24167	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24167	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24167	44	Albany	Albany	NNP
18637	24167	45	Perforated	Perforated	NNP
18637	24167	46	Wrapping	Wrapping	NNP
18637	24167	47	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	24167	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24167	49	,	,	,
18637	24167	50	152	152	CD
18637	24167	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24167	52	425	425	CD
18637	24167	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24167	54	1894	1894	CD
18637	24167	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24167	56	,	,	,
18637	24167	57	273	273	CD
18637	24167	58	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	24167	59	's	's	POS
18637	24167	60	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24167	61	&	&	CC
18637	24167	62	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	24168	1	&	&	CC
18637	24168	2	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	24168	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24168	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24168	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	24168	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24168	7	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24168	8	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	24168	9	.	.	.
18637	24169	1	of	of	IN
18637	24169	2	Health	Health	NNP
18637	24169	3	,	,	,
18637	24169	4	118	118	CD
18637	24169	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24169	6	455	455	CD
18637	24169	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24169	8	1886	1886	CD
18637	24169	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24169	10	,	,	,
18637	24169	11	217	217	CD
18637	24169	12	,	,	,
18637	24169	13	236	236	CD
18637	24169	14	,	,	,
18637	24169	15	312	312	CD
18637	24169	16	,	,	,
18637	24169	17	323	323	CD
18637	24169	18	,	,	,
18637	24169	19	366	366	CD
18637	24169	20	Morley	Morley	NNP
18637	24169	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24169	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	24169	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24169	24	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	24169	25	Shore	Shore	NNP
18637	24169	26	&	&	CC
18637	24169	27	M.S.R.	M.S.R.	NNP
18637	24170	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24170	2	,	,	,
18637	24170	3	146	146	CD
18637	24170	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24170	5	162	162	CD
18637	24170	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24170	7	1892	1892	CD
18637	24170	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24170	9	,	,	,
18637	24170	10	343	343	CD
18637	24170	11	,	,	,
18637	24170	12	352	352	CD
18637	24170	13	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	24170	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24170	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	17	Duby	Duby	NNP
18637	24170	18	,	,	,
18637	24170	19	274	274	CD
18637	24170	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24170	21	135	135	CD
18637	24170	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24170	23	1927	1927	CD
18637	24170	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24170	25	,	,	,
18637	24170	26	227	227	CD
18637	24170	27	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	24170	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24170	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	31	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	24170	32	,	,	,
18637	24170	33	329	329	CD
18637	24170	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24170	35	545	545	CD
18637	24170	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24170	37	1947	1947	CD
18637	24170	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24170	39	,	,	,
18637	24170	40	657	657	CD
18637	24170	41	Morris	Morris	NNP
18637	24170	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24170	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	45	United	United	NNP
18637	24170	46	States	States	NNP
18637	24170	47	,	,	,
18637	24170	48	174	174	CD
18637	24170	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24170	50	196	196	CD
18637	24170	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24170	52	1899	1899	CD
18637	24170	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24170	54	,	,	,
18637	24170	55	301	301	CD
18637	24170	56	Morrison	Morrison	NNP
18637	24170	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	24170	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	60	California	California	NNP
18637	24170	61	,	,	,
18637	24170	62	288	288	CD
18637	24170	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24170	64	591	591	CD
18637	24170	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24170	66	1933	1933	CD
18637	24170	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24170	68	,	,	,
18637	24170	69	1096	1096	CD
18637	24170	70	Morrison	Morrison	NNP
18637	24170	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	24170	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	74	California	California	NNP
18637	24170	75	,	,	,
18637	24170	76	291	291	CD
18637	24170	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24170	78	82	82	CD
18637	24170	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24170	80	1934	1934	CD
18637	24170	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24170	82	,	,	,
18637	24170	83	1096	1096	CD
18637	24170	84	Morrison	Morrison	NNP
18637	24170	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	24170	87	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	88	Work	Work	NNP
18637	24170	89	,	,	,
18637	24170	90	266	266	CD
18637	24170	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24170	92	481	481	CD
18637	24170	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24170	94	1925	1925	CD
18637	24170	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24170	96	,	,	,
18637	24170	97	588	588	CD
18637	24170	98	Morrissey	Morrissey	NNP
18637	24170	99	,	,	,
18637	24170	100	In	in	IN
18637	24170	101	re	re	NN
18637	24170	102	,	,	,
18637	24170	103	137	137	CD
18637	24170	104	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24170	105	157	157	CD
18637	24170	106	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24170	107	1890	1890	CD
18637	24170	108	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24170	109	,	,	,
18637	24170	110	285	285	CD
18637	24170	111	Morton	Morton	NNP
18637	24170	112	Salt	Salt	NNP
18637	24170	113	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24170	114	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	115	v.	v.	IN
18637	24170	116	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	117	Suppiger	Suppiger	NNP
18637	24170	118	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24170	119	,	,	,
18637	24170	120	314	314	CD
18637	24170	121	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24170	122	488	488	CD
18637	24170	123	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24170	124	1942	1942	CD
18637	24170	125	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24170	126	,	,	,
18637	24170	127	275	275	CD
18637	24170	128	Moses	Moses	NNP
18637	24170	129	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24170	130	,	,	,
18637	24170	131	The	The	NNP
18637	24170	132	,	,	,
18637	24170	133	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	134	v.	v.	IN
18637	24170	135	_	_	NNP
18637	24170	136	Hammons	Hammons	NNP
18637	24170	137	,	,	,
18637	24170	138	4	4	CD
18637	24170	139	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24170	140	.	.	.
18637	24171	1	411	411	CD
18637	24171	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24171	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	24171	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24171	5	,	,	,
18637	24171	6	576	576	CD
18637	24171	7	,	,	,
18637	24171	8	579	579	CD
18637	24171	9	Mosher	Mosher	NNP
18637	24171	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24171	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24171	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24171	13	Phoenix	Phoenix	NNP
18637	24171	14	,	,	,
18637	24171	15	287	287	CD
18637	24171	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24171	17	29	29	CD
18637	24171	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24171	19	1932	1932	CD
18637	24171	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24171	21	,	,	,
18637	24171	22	567	567	CD
18637	24171	23	Motes	Motes	NNPS
18637	24171	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24171	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24171	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24171	27	United	United	NNP
18637	24171	28	States	States	NNP
18637	24171	29	,	,	,
18637	24171	30	178	178	CD
18637	24171	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24171	32	458	458	CD
18637	24171	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24171	34	1900	1900	CD
18637	24171	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24171	36	,	,	,
18637	24171	37	309	309	CD
18637	24171	38	,	,	,
18637	24171	39	884	884	CD
18637	24171	40	Motion	Motion	NNP
18637	24171	41	Picture	Picture	NNP
18637	24171	42	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24171	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24171	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24171	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24171	46	Universal	Universal	NNP
18637	24171	47	Film	Film	NNP
18637	24171	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24171	49	,	,	,
18637	24171	50	243	243	CD
18637	24171	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24171	52	502	502	CD
18637	24171	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24171	54	1917	1917	CD
18637	24171	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24171	56	,	,	,
18637	24171	57	275	275	CD
18637	24171	58	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	24171	59	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	24171	60	Carriers	Carriers	NNPS
18637	24171	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24171	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	24171	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24171	64	National	National	NNP
18637	24171	65	War	War	NNP
18637	24171	66	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24171	67	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24171	68	,	,	,
18637	24171	69	143	143	CD
18637	24171	70	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24171	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24171	72	2d	2d	NNP
18637	24171	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24171	74	145	145	CD
18637	24171	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24171	76	1944	1944	CD
18637	24171	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24171	78	,	,	,
18637	24171	79	394	394	CD
18637	24171	80	Mountain	Mountain	NNP
18637	24171	81	Timber	Timber	NNP
18637	24171	82	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24171	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24171	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	24171	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24171	86	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24171	87	,	,	,
18637	24171	88	243	243	CD
18637	24171	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24171	90	219	219	CD
18637	24171	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24171	92	1917	1917	CD
18637	24171	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24171	94	,	,	,
18637	24171	95	704	704	CD
18637	24171	96	,	,	,
18637	24171	97	989	989	CD
18637	24171	98	,	,	,
18637	24171	99	1159	1159	CD
18637	24171	100	Mt.	Mount	NNP
18637	24172	1	Vernon	Vernon	NNP
18637	24172	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	24172	3	Woodberry	Woodberry	NNP
18637	24172	4	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	24172	5	Duck	Duck	NNP
18637	24172	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24172	7	_	_	NNP
18637	24172	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	24172	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24172	10	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	24172	11	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	24172	12	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24172	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24172	14	,	,	,
18637	24172	15	240	240	CD
18637	24172	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24172	17	30	30	CD
18637	24172	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24172	19	1916	1916	CD
18637	24172	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24172	21	,	,	,
18637	24172	22	1065	1065	CD
18637	24172	23	Moyer	Moyer	NNP
18637	24172	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24172	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24172	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24172	27	Peabody	Peabody	NNP
18637	24172	28	,	,	,
18637	24172	29	212	212	CD
18637	24172	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24172	31	78	78	CD
18637	24172	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24172	33	1909	1909	CD
18637	24172	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24172	35	,	,	,
18637	24172	36	484	484	CD
18637	24172	37	Mugler	Mugler	NNP
18637	24172	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24172	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24172	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24172	41	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24172	42	,	,	,
18637	24172	43	123	123	CD
18637	24172	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24172	45	623	623	CD
18637	24172	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24172	47	1887	1887	CD
18637	24172	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24172	49	,	,	,
18637	24172	50	239	239	CD
18637	24172	51	,	,	,
18637	24172	52	973	973	CD
18637	24172	53	,	,	,
18637	24172	54	975	975	CD
18637	24172	55	,	,	,
18637	24172	56	976	976	CD
18637	24172	57	,	,	,
18637	24172	58	977	977	CD
18637	24172	59	,	,	,
18637	24172	60	1032	1032	CD
18637	24172	61	Muhlker	Muhlker	NNP
18637	24172	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24172	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	24172	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24172	65	New	New	NNP
18637	24172	66	York	York	NNP
18637	24172	67	&	&	CC
18637	24172	68	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	24173	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24173	2	,	,	,
18637	24173	3	197	197	CD
18637	24173	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24173	5	544	544	CD
18637	24173	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24173	7	1905	1905	CD
18637	24173	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24173	9	,	,	,
18637	24173	10	331	331	CD
18637	24173	11	Mulford	Mulford	NNP
18637	24173	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24173	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24173	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24173	15	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24173	16	,	,	,
18637	24173	17	307	307	CD
18637	24173	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24173	19	38	38	CD
18637	24173	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24173	21	1939	1939	CD
18637	24173	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24173	23	,	,	,
18637	24173	24	76	76	CD
18637	24173	25	,	,	,
18637	24173	26	160	160	CD
18637	24173	27	,	,	,
18637	24173	28	856	856	CD
18637	24173	29	Mullan	Mullan	NNP
18637	24173	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24173	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24173	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24173	33	United	United	NNP
18637	24173	34	States	States	NNP
18637	24173	35	,	,	,
18637	24173	36	140	140	CD
18637	24173	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24173	38	240	240	CD
18637	24173	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24173	40	1891	1891	CD
18637	24173	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24173	42	,	,	,
18637	24173	43	404	404	CD
18637	24173	44	,	,	,
18637	24173	45	847	847	CD
18637	24173	46	Mullan	Mullan	NNP
18637	24173	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24173	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	24173	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24173	50	United	United	NNP
18637	24173	51	States	States	NNP
18637	24173	52	,	,	,
18637	24173	53	212	212	CD
18637	24173	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24173	55	516	516	CD
18637	24173	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24173	57	1909	1909	CD
18637	24173	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24173	59	,	,	,
18637	24173	60	286	286	CD
18637	24173	61	Mullane	Mullane	NNP
18637	24173	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24173	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	24173	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24173	65	Central	Central	NNP
18637	24173	66	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
18637	24173	67	Tr	Tr	NNP
18637	24173	68	.	.	.
18637	24174	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24174	2	,	,	,
18637	24174	3	339	339	CD
18637	24174	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24174	5	306	306	CD
18637	24174	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24174	7	1950	1950	CD
18637	24174	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24174	9	,	,	,
18637	24174	10	1083	1083	CD
18637	24174	11	Mullaney	Mullaney	NNP
18637	24174	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24174	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	15	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	24174	16	,	,	,
18637	24174	17	342	342	CD
18637	24174	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24174	19	415	415	CD
18637	24174	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24174	21	1952	1952	CD
18637	24174	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24174	23	,	,	,
18637	24174	24	690	690	CD
18637	24174	25	Muller	Muller	NNP
18637	24174	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24174	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	29	Dows	Dows	NNP
18637	24174	30	,	,	,
18637	24174	31	94	94	CD
18637	24174	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24174	33	444	444	CD
18637	24174	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24174	35	1877	1877	CD
18637	24174	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24174	37	,	,	,
18637	24174	38	602	602	CD
18637	24174	39	Muller	Muller	NNP
18637	24174	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24174	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	43	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24174	44	,	,	,
18637	24174	45	208	208	CD
18637	24174	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24174	47	412	412	CD
18637	24174	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24174	49	1908	1908	CD
18637	24174	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24174	51	,	,	,
18637	24174	52	979	979	CD
18637	24174	53	,	,	,
18637	24174	54	986	986	CD
18637	24174	55	,	,	,
18637	24174	56	1159	1159	CD
18637	24174	57	Munday	Munday	NNP
18637	24174	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24174	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	61	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	24174	62	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24174	63	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24174	64	,	,	,
18637	24174	65	252	252	CD
18637	24174	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24174	67	499	499	CD
18637	24174	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24174	69	1920	1920	CD
18637	24174	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24174	71	,	,	,
18637	24174	72	1016	1016	CD
18637	24174	73	Munn	Munn	NNP
18637	24174	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	24174	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	77	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	24174	78	,	,	,
18637	24174	79	94	94	CD
18637	24174	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24174	81	113	113	CD
18637	24174	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24174	83	1877	1877	CD
18637	24174	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24174	85	,	,	,
18637	24174	86	133	133	CD
18637	24174	87	,	,	,
18637	24174	88	312	312	CD
18637	24174	89	,	,	,
18637	24174	90	323	323	CD
18637	24174	91	,	,	,
18637	24174	92	340	340	CD
18637	24174	93	,	,	,
18637	24174	94	972	972	CD
18637	24174	95	,	,	,
18637	24174	96	973	973	CD
18637	24174	97	,	,	,
18637	24174	98	975	975	CD
18637	24174	99	,	,	,
18637	24174	100	994	994	CD
18637	24174	101	,	,	,
18637	24174	102	996	996	CD
18637	24174	103	,	,	,
18637	24174	104	998	998	CD
18637	24174	105	,	,	,
18637	24174	106	999	999	CD
18637	24174	107	,	,	,
18637	24174	108	1004	1004	CD
18637	24174	109	,	,	,
18637	24174	110	1005	1005	CD
18637	24174	111	Munsey	Munsey	NNP
18637	24174	112	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	24174	114	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	115	Clough	Clough	NNP
18637	24174	116	,	,	,
18637	24174	117	196	196	CD
18637	24174	118	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24174	119	364	364	CD
18637	24174	120	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24174	121	1905	1905	CD
18637	24174	122	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24174	123	,	,	,
18637	24174	124	695	695	CD
18637	24174	125	Murdock	Murdock	NNP
18637	24174	126	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	127	v.	v.	IN
18637	24174	128	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	129	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24174	130	,	,	,
18637	24174	131	319	319	CD
18637	24174	132	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24174	133	105	105	CD
18637	24174	134	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24174	135	1943	1943	CD
18637	24174	136	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24174	137	,	,	,
18637	24174	138	563	563	CD
18637	24174	139	,	,	,
18637	24174	140	767	767	CD
18637	24174	141	,	,	,
18637	24174	142	792	792	CD
18637	24174	143	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	24174	144	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	145	v.	v.	IN
18637	24174	146	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	147	California	California	NNP
18637	24174	148	,	,	,
18637	24174	149	225	225	CD
18637	24174	150	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24174	151	623	623	CD
18637	24174	152	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24174	153	1912	1912	CD
18637	24174	154	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24174	155	,	,	,
18637	24174	156	1024	1024	CD
18637	24174	157	,	,	,
18637	24174	158	1154	1154	CD
18637	24174	159	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	24174	160	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	161	v.	v.	IN
18637	24174	162	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	163	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24174	164	,	,	,
18637	24174	165	177	177	CD
18637	24174	166	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24174	167	155	155	CD
18637	24174	168	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24174	169	1900	1900	CD
18637	24174	170	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24174	171	,	,	,
18637	24174	172	1135	1135	CD
18637	24174	173	,	,	,
18637	24174	174	1138	1138	CD
18637	24174	175	Murphy	Murphy	NNP
18637	24174	176	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	177	v.	v.	IN
18637	24174	178	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	179	Ramsey	Ramsey	NNP
18637	24174	180	,	,	,
18637	24174	181	114	114	CD
18637	24174	182	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24174	183	15	15	CD
18637	24174	184	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24174	185	1885	1885	CD
18637	24174	186	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24174	187	,	,	,
18637	24174	188	317	317	CD
18637	24174	189	,	,	,
18637	24174	190	703	703	CD
18637	24174	191	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	24174	192	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	193	v.	v.	IN
18637	24174	194	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	195	Charleston	Charleston	NNP
18637	24174	196	,	,	,
18637	24174	197	96	96	CD
18637	24174	198	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24174	199	432	432	CD
18637	24174	200	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24174	201	1878	1878	CD
18637	24174	202	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24174	203	,	,	,
18637	24174	204	343	343	CD
18637	24174	205	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	24174	206	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	207	v.	v.	IN
18637	24174	208	_	_	NNP
18637	24174	209	Hoboken	Hoboken	NNP
18637	24174	210	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24174	211	&	&	CC
18637	24174	212	Improvement	Improvement	NNP
18637	24174	213	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24174	214	,	,	,
18637	24174	215	18	18	CD
18637	24174	216	How	how	WRB
18637	24174	217	.	.	.
18637	24175	1	272	272	CD
18637	24175	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24175	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	24175	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24175	5	,	,	,
18637	24175	6	622	622	CD
18637	24175	7	Murray	Murray	NNP
18637	24175	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24175	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24175	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24175	11	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24175	12	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	24175	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24175	14	,	,	,
18637	24175	15	213	213	CD
18637	24175	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24175	17	151	151	CD
18637	24175	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24175	19	1909	1909	CD
18637	24175	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24175	21	,	,	,
18637	24175	22	930	930	CD
18637	24175	23	,	,	,
18637	24175	24	931	931	CD
18637	24175	25	,	,	,
18637	24175	26	936	936	CD
18637	24175	27	Muskrat	Muskrat	NNP
18637	24175	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24175	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24175	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24175	31	United	United	NNP
18637	24175	32	States	States	NNP
18637	24175	33	,	,	,
18637	24175	34	219	219	CD
18637	24175	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24175	36	346	346	CD
18637	24175	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24175	38	1911	1911	CD
18637	24175	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24175	40	,	,	,
18637	24175	41	511	511	CD
18637	24175	42	,	,	,
18637	24175	43	514	514	CD
18637	24175	44	,	,	,
18637	24175	45	539	539	CD
18637	24175	46	,	,	,
18637	24175	47	540	540	CD
18637	24175	48	,	,	,
18637	24175	49	550	550	CD
18637	24175	50	,	,	,
18637	24175	51	551	551	CD
18637	24175	52	,	,	,
18637	24175	53	561	561	CD
18637	24175	54	,	,	,
18637	24175	55	623	623	CD
18637	24175	56	Musser	Musser	NNP
18637	24175	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24175	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	24175	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24175	60	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	24175	61	,	,	,
18637	24175	62	333	333	CD
18637	24175	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24175	64	95	95	CD
18637	24175	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24175	66	1948	1948	CD
18637	24175	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24175	68	,	,	,
18637	24175	69	780	780	CD
18637	24175	70	Mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	24175	71	Assur	Assur	NNP
18637	24175	72	.	.	.
18637	24176	1	Soc	Soc	NNP
18637	24176	2	.	.	.
18637	24177	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24177	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24177	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24177	4	Watts	Watts	NNP
18637	24177	5	,	,	,
18637	24177	6	1	1	CD
18637	24177	7	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24177	8	.	.	.
18637	24178	1	279	279	CD
18637	24178	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24178	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	24178	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24178	5	,	,	,
18637	24178	6	302	302	CD
18637	24178	7	Mutual	mutual	JJ
18637	24178	8	Ben	Ben	NNP
18637	24178	9	.	.	.
18637	24179	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24179	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24179	3	.	.	.
18637	24180	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24180	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24180	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24180	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24180	5	Tisdale	Tisdale	NNP
18637	24180	6	,	,	,
18637	24180	7	91	91	CD
18637	24180	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24180	9	238	238	CD
18637	24180	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24180	11	1876	1876	CD
18637	24180	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24180	13	,	,	,
18637	24180	14	258	258	CD
18637	24180	15	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	24180	16	Film	Film	NNP
18637	24180	17	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24180	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24180	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24180	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24180	21	Hodges	Hodges	NNPS
18637	24180	22	,	,	,
18637	24180	23	236	236	CD
18637	24180	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24180	25	248	248	CD
18637	24180	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24180	27	1915	1915	CD
18637	24180	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24180	29	,	,	,
18637	24180	30	238	238	CD
18637	24180	31	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	24180	32	Film	Film	NNP
18637	24180	33	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24180	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24180	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	24180	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24180	37	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	24180	38	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24180	39	,	,	,
18637	24180	40	236	236	CD
18637	24180	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24180	42	230	230	CD
18637	24180	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24180	44	1915	1915	CD
18637	24180	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24180	46	,	,	,
18637	24180	47	788	788	CD
18637	24180	48	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	24180	49	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24180	50	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24180	51	.	.	.
18637	24181	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24181	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24181	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24181	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24181	5	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	24181	6	,	,	,
18637	24181	7	97	97	CD
18637	24181	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24181	9	331	331	CD
18637	24181	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24181	11	1878	1878	CD
18637	24181	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24181	13	,	,	,
18637	24181	14	654	654	CD
18637	24181	15	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	24181	16	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24181	17	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24181	18	.	.	.
18637	24182	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24182	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24182	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24182	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24182	5	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	24182	6	,	,	,
18637	24182	7	293	293	CD
18637	24182	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24182	9	335	335	CD
18637	24182	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24182	11	1934	1934	CD
18637	24182	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24182	13	,	,	,
18637	24182	14	605	605	CD
18637	24182	15	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	24182	16	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24182	17	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	24182	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24182	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24182	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24182	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24182	22	Spratley	Spratley	NNP
18637	24182	23	,	,	,
18637	24182	24	172	172	CD
18637	24182	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24182	26	602	602	CD
18637	24182	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24182	28	1899	1899	CD
18637	24182	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24182	30	,	,	,
18637	24182	31	,	,	,
18637	24182	32	1077	1077	CD
18637	24182	33	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	24182	34	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	24182	35	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24182	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24182	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24182	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24182	39	Martell	Martell	NNP
18637	24182	40	,	,	,
18637	24182	41	222	222	CD
18637	24182	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24182	43	225	225	CD
18637	24182	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24182	45	1911	1911	CD
18637	24182	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24182	47	,	,	,
18637	24182	48	1021	1021	CD
18637	24182	49	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	24182	50	Reserve	Reserve	NNP
18637	24182	51	,	,	,
18637	24182	52	etc	etc	FW
18637	24182	53	.	.	.
18637	24183	1	Assn	assn	UH
18637	24183	2	.	.	.
18637	24184	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24184	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	4	Phelps	Phelps	NNP
18637	24184	5	,	,	,
18637	24184	6	190	190	CD
18637	24184	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24184	8	147	147	CD
18637	24184	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24184	10	1903	1903	CD
18637	24184	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24184	12	,	,	,
18637	24184	13	,	,	,
18637	24184	14	1078	1078	CD
18637	24184	15	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	24184	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24184	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	19	Irwin	Irwin	NNP
18637	24184	20	,	,	,
18637	24184	21	2	2	CD
18637	24184	22	Sergeant	Sergeant	NNP
18637	24184	23	&	&	CC
18637	24184	24	Rawle	Rawle	NNP
18637	24184	25	's	's	POS
18637	24184	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24184	27	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24184	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24184	29	367	367	CD
18637	24184	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24184	31	1816	1816	CD
18637	24184	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24184	33	,	,	,
18637	24184	34	357	357	CD
18637	24184	35	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	24184	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24184	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	39	United	United	NNP
18637	24184	40	States	States	NNP
18637	24184	41	,	,	,
18637	24184	42	264	264	CD
18637	24184	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24184	44	95	95	CD
18637	24184	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24184	46	1924	1924	CD
18637	24184	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24184	48	,	,	,
18637	24184	49	878	878	CD
18637	24184	50	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	24184	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	24184	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	54	United	United	NNP
18637	24184	55	States	States	NNP
18637	24184	56	,	,	,
18637	24184	57	272	272	CD
18637	24184	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24184	59	52	52	CD
18637	24184	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24184	61	1926	1926	CD
18637	24184	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24184	63	,	,	,
18637	24184	64	380	380	CD
18637	24184	65	,	,	,
18637	24184	66	450	450	CD
18637	24184	67	,	,	,
18637	24184	68	456	456	CD
18637	24184	69	Myles	Myles	NNP
18637	24184	70	Salt	Salt	NNP
18637	24184	71	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24184	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	24184	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	75	Iberia	Iberia	NNP
18637	24184	76	&	&	CC
18637	24184	77	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24184	78	M.	M.	NNP
18637	24184	79	Drainage	Drainage	NNP
18637	24184	80	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	24184	81	.	.	.
18637	24184	82	,	,	,
18637	24184	83	239	239	CD
18637	24184	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24184	85	478	478	CD
18637	24184	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24184	87	1916	1916	CD
18637	24184	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24184	89	,	,	,
18637	24184	90	1041	1041	CD
18637	24184	91	N	N	NNP
18637	24184	92	Napier	Napier	NNP
18637	24184	93	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	94	v.	v.	IN
18637	24184	95	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	96	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	24184	97	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	24184	98	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24184	99	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24184	100	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24184	101	,	,	,
18637	24184	102	272	272	CD
18637	24184	103	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24184	104	605	605	CD
18637	24184	105	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24184	106	1926	1926	CD
18637	24184	107	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24184	108	,	,	,
18637	24184	109	,	,	,
18637	24184	110	250	250	CD
18637	24184	111	Nardone	Nardone	NNP
18637	24184	112	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	24184	114	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	115	United	United	NNP
18637	24184	116	States	States	NNP
18637	24184	117	,	,	,
18637	24184	118	302	302	CD
18637	24184	119	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24184	120	379	379	CD
18637	24184	121	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24184	122	1937	1937	CD
18637	24184	123	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24184	124	,	,	,
18637	24184	125	824	824	CD
18637	24184	126	Nardone	Nardone	NNP
18637	24184	127	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	128	v.	v.	IN
18637	24184	129	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	130	United	United	NNP
18637	24184	131	States	States	NNP
18637	24184	132	,	,	,
18637	24184	133	308	308	CD
18637	24184	134	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24184	135	338	338	CD
18637	24184	136	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24184	137	1939	1939	CD
18637	24184	138	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24184	139	,	,	,
18637	24184	140	824	824	CD
18637	24184	141	Nash	Nash	NNP
18637	24184	142	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	143	v.	v.	IN
18637	24184	144	_	_	NNP
18637	24184	145	United	United	NNP
18637	24184	146	States	States	NNP
18637	24184	147	,	,	,
18637	24184	148	229	229	CD
18637	24184	149	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24184	150	373	373	CD
18637	24184	151	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24184	152	1913	1913	CD
18637	24184	153	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24184	154	,	,	,
18637	24184	155	883	883	CD
18637	24184	156	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	24184	157	,	,	,
18637	24184	158	C.	C.	NNP
18637	24184	159	&	&	CC
18637	24184	160	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24184	161	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	24185	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24185	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24185	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24185	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24185	5	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	24185	6	,	,	,
18637	24185	7	128	128	CD
18637	24185	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24185	9	96	96	CD
18637	24185	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24185	11	1888	1888	CD
18637	24185	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24185	13	,	,	,
18637	24185	14	141	141	CD
18637	24185	15	,	,	,
18637	24185	16	222	222	CD
18637	24185	17	,	,	,
18637	24185	18	1014	1014	CD
18637	24185	19	,	,	,
18637	24185	20	1024	1024	CD
18637	24185	21	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	24185	22	,	,	,
18637	24185	23	C.	C.	NNP
18637	24185	24	&	&	CC
18637	24185	25	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24185	26	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24185	27	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	24185	28	.	.	.
18637	24186	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24186	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24186	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24186	4	Browning	Browning	NNP
18637	24186	5	,	,	,
18637	24186	6	310	310	CD
18637	24186	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24186	8	362	362	CD
18637	24186	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24186	10	1940	1940	CD
18637	24186	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24186	12	,	,	,
18637	24186	13	201	201	CD
18637	24186	14	,	,	,
18637	24186	15	204	204	CD
18637	24186	16	,	,	,
18637	24186	17	1040	1040	CD
18637	24186	18	,	,	,
18637	24186	19	1152	1152	CD
18637	24186	20	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	24186	21	,	,	,
18637	24186	22	C.	C.	NNP
18637	24186	23	&	&	CC
18637	24186	24	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24186	25	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	24187	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24187	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24187	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24187	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24187	5	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	24187	6	,	,	,
18637	24187	7	288	288	CD
18637	24187	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24187	9	249	249	CD
18637	24187	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24187	11	1933	1933	CD
18637	24187	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24187	13	,	,	,
18637	24187	14	186	186	CD
18637	24187	15	,	,	,
18637	24187	16	514	514	CD
18637	24187	17	,	,	,
18637	24187	18	551	551	CD
18637	24187	19	,	,	,
18637	24187	20	553	553	CD
18637	24187	21	,	,	,
18637	24187	22	1037	1037	CD
18637	24187	23	,	,	,
18637	24187	24	1148	1148	CD
18637	24187	25	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	24187	26	,	,	,
18637	24187	27	C.	C.	NNP
18637	24187	28	&	&	CC
18637	24187	29	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24187	30	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	24188	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24188	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24188	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24188	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24188	5	Walters	Walters	NNP
18637	24188	6	,	,	,
18637	24188	7	294	294	CD
18637	24188	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24188	9	405	405	CD
18637	24188	10	,	,	,
18637	24188	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24188	12	1935	1935	CD
18637	24188	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24188	14	,	,	,
18637	24188	15	982	982	CD
18637	24188	16	,	,	,
18637	24188	17	1009	1009	CD
18637	24188	18	,	,	,
18637	24188	19	1011	1011	CD
18637	24188	20	Nashville	Nashville	NNP
18637	24188	21	,	,	,
18637	24188	22	C.	C.	NNP
18637	24188	23	&	&	CC
18637	24188	24	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24188	25	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	24189	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24189	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24189	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24189	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24189	5	White	White	NNP
18637	24189	6	,	,	,
18637	24189	7	278	278	CD
18637	24189	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24189	9	456	456	CD
18637	24189	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24189	11	1929	1929	CD
18637	24189	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24189	13	,	,	,
18637	24189	14	1014	1014	CD
18637	24189	15	Natal	Natal	NNP
18637	24189	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24189	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24189	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24189	19	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24189	20	,	,	,
18637	24189	21	139	139	CD
18637	24189	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24189	23	621	621	CD
18637	24189	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24189	25	1891	1891	CD
18637	24189	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24189	27	,	,	,
18637	24189	28	1024	1024	CD
18637	24189	29	,	,	,
18637	24189	30	1155	1155	CD
18637	24189	31	Nathan	Nathan	NNP
18637	24189	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24189	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	24189	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24189	35	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24189	36	,	,	,
18637	24189	37	8	8	CD
18637	24189	38	How	how	WRB
18637	24189	39	.	.	.
18637	24190	1	73	73	CD
18637	24190	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24190	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	24190	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24190	5	,	,	,
18637	24190	6	188	188	CD
18637	24190	7	,	,	,
18637	24190	8	364	364	CD
18637	24190	9	Nathanson	Nathanson	NNP
18637	24190	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24190	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24190	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24190	13	United	United	NNP
18637	24190	14	States	States	NNP
18637	24190	15	,	,	,
18637	24190	16	290	290	CD
18637	24190	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24190	18	41	41	CD
18637	24190	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24190	20	1933	1933	CD
18637	24190	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24190	22	,	,	,
18637	24190	23	823	823	CD
18637	24190	24	National	National	NNP
18637	24190	25	Association	Association	NNP
18637	24190	26	of	of	IN
18637	24190	27	Manufacturers	Manufacturers	NNPS
18637	24190	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24190	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24190	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24190	31	McGrath	McGrath	NNP
18637	24190	32	,	,	,
18637	24190	33	103	103	CD
18637	24190	34	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24190	35	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	24190	36	.	.	.
18637	24191	1	510	510	CD
18637	24191	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24191	3	1952	1952	CD
18637	24191	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24191	5	,	,	,
18637	24191	6	810	810	CD
18637	24191	7	National	National	NNP
18637	24191	8	Broadcasting	Broadcasting	NNP
18637	24191	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24191	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24191	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24191	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24191	13	United	United	NNP
18637	24191	14	States	States	NNP
18637	24191	15	,	,	,
18637	24191	16	319	319	CD
18637	24191	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24191	18	190	190	CD
18637	24191	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24191	20	1943	1943	CD
18637	24191	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24191	22	,	,	,
18637	24191	23	75	75	CD
18637	24191	24	,	,	,
18637	24191	25	78	78	CD
18637	24191	26	National	National	NNP
18637	24191	27	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	24191	28	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24191	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24191	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24191	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24191	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24191	33	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24191	34	,	,	,
18637	24191	35	197	197	CD
18637	24191	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24191	37	115	115	CD
18637	24191	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24191	39	1905	1905	CD
18637	24191	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24191	41	,	,	,
18637	24191	42	1017	1017	CD
18637	24191	43	National	National	NNP
18637	24191	44	Council	Council	NNP
18637	24191	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24191	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	24191	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24191	48	State	State	NNP
18637	24191	49	Council	Council	NNP
18637	24191	50	,	,	,
18637	24191	51	203	203	CD
18637	24191	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24191	53	151	151	CD
18637	24191	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24191	55	1906	1906	CD
18637	24191	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24191	57	,	,	,
18637	24191	58	1016	1016	CD
18637	24191	59	National	National	NNP
18637	24191	60	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	24191	61	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24191	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24191	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	24191	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24191	65	Peters	Peters	NNP
18637	24191	66	,	,	,
18637	24191	67	144	144	CD
18637	24191	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24191	69	570	570	CD
18637	24191	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24191	71	1892	1892	CD
18637	24191	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24191	73	,	,	,
18637	24191	74	616	616	CD
18637	24191	75	National	National	NNP
18637	24191	76	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	24191	77	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24191	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24191	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	24191	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24191	81	Wiley	Wiley	NNP
18637	24191	82	,	,	,
18637	24191	83	195	195	CD
18637	24191	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24191	85	257	257	CD
18637	24191	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24191	87	1904	1904	CD
18637	24191	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24191	89	,	,	,
18637	24191	90	656	656	CD
18637	24191	91	,	,	,
18637	24191	92	1072	1072	CD
18637	24191	93	National	National	NNP
18637	24191	94	Fertilizer	Fertilizer	NNP
18637	24191	95	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	24191	96	.	.	.
18637	24192	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24192	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	4	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	24192	5	,	,	,
18637	24192	6	301	301	CD
18637	24192	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24192	8	178	178	CD
18637	24192	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24192	10	1937	1937	CD
18637	24192	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24192	12	,	,	,
18637	24192	13	1019	1019	CD
18637	24192	14	National	National	NNP
18637	24192	15	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24192	16	Pipeline	Pipeline	NNP
18637	24192	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24192	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24192	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	21	Slattery	Slattery	NNP
18637	24192	22	,	,	,
18637	24192	23	302	302	CD
18637	24192	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24192	25	300	300	CD
18637	24192	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24192	27	1937	1937	CD
18637	24192	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24192	29	,	,	,
18637	24192	30	234	234	CD
18637	24192	31	National	National	NNP
18637	24192	32	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24192	33	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	24192	34	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24192	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24192	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	38	Fainblatt	Fainblatt	NNP
18637	24192	39	,	,	,
18637	24192	40	306	306	CD
18637	24192	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24192	42	601	601	CD
18637	24192	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24192	44	1939	1939	CD
18637	24192	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24192	46	,	,	,
18637	24192	47	155	155	CD
18637	24192	48	National	National	NNP
18637	24192	49	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24192	50	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	24192	51	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24192	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	24192	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	55	Friedman	Friedman	NNP
18637	24192	56	-	-	HYPH
18637	24192	57	Harry	Harry	NNP
18637	24192	58	Marks	Marks	NNP
18637	24192	59	Clothing	Clothing	NNP
18637	24192	60	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24192	61	,	,	,
18637	24192	62	301	301	CD
18637	24192	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24192	64	58	58	CD
18637	24192	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24192	66	1937	1937	CD
18637	24192	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24192	68	,	,	,
18637	24192	69	155	155	CD
18637	24192	70	National	National	NNP
18637	24192	71	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24192	72	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	24192	73	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24192	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	24192	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	77	Fruehauf	Fruehauf	NNP
18637	24192	78	Trailer	Trailer	NNP
18637	24192	79	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24192	80	,	,	,
18637	24192	81	301	301	CD
18637	24192	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24192	83	49	49	CD
18637	24192	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24192	85	1937	1937	CD
18637	24192	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24192	87	,	,	,
18637	24192	88	155	155	CD
18637	24192	89	National	National	NNP
18637	24192	90	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24192	91	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	24192	92	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24192	93	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	94	v.	v.	IN
18637	24192	95	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	96	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	24192	97	&	&	CC
18637	24192	98	Laughlin	Laughlin	NNP
18637	24192	99	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	24192	100	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	24192	101	,	,	,
18637	24192	102	301	301	CD
18637	24192	103	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24192	104	1	1	CD
18637	24192	105	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24192	106	1937	1937	CD
18637	24192	107	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24192	108	,	,	,
18637	24192	109	154	154	CD
18637	24192	110	,	,	,
18637	24192	111	723	723	CD
18637	24192	112	,	,	,
18637	24192	113	855	855	CD
18637	24192	114	,	,	,
18637	24192	115	859	859	CD
18637	24192	116	,	,	,
18637	24192	117	893	893	CD
18637	24192	118	,	,	,
18637	24192	119	918	918	CD
18637	24192	120	,	,	,
18637	24192	121	980	980	CD
18637	24192	122	National	National	NNP
18637	24192	123	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24192	124	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	24192	125	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24192	126	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	127	v.	v.	IN
18637	24192	128	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	129	Mackay	Mackay	NNP
18637	24192	130	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24192	131	,	,	,
18637	24192	132	304	304	CD
18637	24192	133	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24192	134	333	333	CD
18637	24192	135	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24192	136	1938	1938	CD
18637	24192	137	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24192	138	,	,	,
18637	24192	139	850	850	CD
18637	24192	140	,	,	,
18637	24192	141	859	859	CD
18637	24192	142	National	National	NNP
18637	24192	143	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24192	144	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	24192	145	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24192	146	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	147	v.	v.	IN
18637	24192	148	_	_	NNP
18637	24192	149	Stowe	Stowe	NNP
18637	24192	150	Spinning	Spinning	NNP
18637	24192	151	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24192	152	,	,	,
18637	24192	153	336	336	CD
18637	24192	154	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24192	155	226	226	CD
18637	24192	156	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24192	157	1949	1949	CD
18637	24192	158	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24192	159	,	,	,
18637	24192	160	859	859	CD
18637	24192	161	National	National	NNP
18637	24192	162	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	24192	163	B.	B.	NNP
18637	24193	1	&	&	CC
18637	24193	2	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24193	3	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	24193	4	.	.	.
18637	24194	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24194	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24194	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24194	4	Brahan	Brahan	NNP
18637	24194	5	,	,	,
18637	24194	6	193	193	CD
18637	24194	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24194	8	635	635	CD
18637	24194	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24194	10	1904	1904	CD
18637	24194	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24194	12	,	,	,
18637	24194	13	676	676	CD
18637	24194	14	,	,	,
18637	24194	15	679	679	CD
18637	24194	16	,	,	,
18637	24194	17	680	680	CD
18637	24194	18	National	National	NNP
18637	24194	19	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	24194	20	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	24194	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24194	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24194	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24194	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24194	25	Tidewater	Tidewater	NNP
18637	24194	26	Transfer	Transfer	NNP
18637	24194	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24194	28	,	,	,
18637	24194	29	337	337	CD
18637	24194	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24194	31	582	582	CD
18637	24194	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24194	33	1949	1949	CD
18637	24194	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24194	35	303	303	CD
18637	24194	36	,	,	,
18637	24194	37	537	537	CD
18637	24194	38	,	,	,
18637	24194	39	600	600	CD
18637	24194	40	National	National	NNP
18637	24194	41	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	24194	42	&	&	CC
18637	24194	43	Type	Type	NNP
18637	24194	44	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24194	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24194	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	24194	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24194	48	Bowers	Bowers	NNP
18637	24194	49	,	,	,
18637	24194	50	266	266	CD
18637	24194	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24194	52	373	373	CD
18637	24194	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24194	54	1924	1924	CD
18637	24194	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24194	56	,	,	,
18637	24194	57	321	321	CD
18637	24194	58	,	,	,
18637	24194	59	868	868	CD
18637	24194	60	National	National	NNP
18637	24194	61	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	24194	62	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	24194	63	.	.	.
18637	24195	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24195	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24195	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24195	4	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	24195	5	Island	Island	NNP
18637	24195	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24195	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	24195	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24195	9	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	24195	10	.	.	.
18637	24196	1	National	National	NNP
18637	24196	2	Safe	Safe	NNP
18637	24196	3	Deposit	Deposit	NNP
18637	24196	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24196	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24196	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	24196	7	_	_	NNP
18637	24196	8	Stead	Stead	NNP
18637	24196	9	,	,	,
18637	24196	10	232	232	CD
18637	24196	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24196	12	58	58	CD
18637	24196	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24196	14	1914	1914	CD
18637	24196	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24196	16	,	,	,
18637	24196	17	1061	1061	CD
18637	24196	18	,	,	,
18637	24196	19	1121	1121	CD
18637	24196	20	National	National	NNP
18637	24196	21	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24196	22	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24196	23	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24196	24	.	.	.
18637	24197	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24197	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24197	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	5	Wanberg	Wanberg	NNP
18637	24197	6	,	,	,
18637	24197	7	260	260	CD
18637	24197	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24197	9	71	71	CD
18637	24197	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24197	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	24197	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24197	13	,	,	,
18637	24197	14	1022	1022	CD
18637	24197	15	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	24197	16	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24197	17	Pipeline	Pipeline	NNP
18637	24197	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24197	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24197	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	22	Slattery	Slattery	NNP
18637	24197	23	,	,	,
18637	24197	24	302	302	CD
18637	24197	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24197	26	300	300	CD
18637	24197	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24197	28	1937	1937	CD
18637	24197	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24197	30	,	,	,
18637	24197	31	234	234	CD
18637	24197	32	Neagle	Neagle	NNP
18637	24197	33	,	,	,
18637	24197	34	In	in	IN
18637	24197	35	re	re	NN
18637	24197	36	,	,	,
18637	24197	37	135	135	CD
18637	24197	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24197	39	1	1	CD
18637	24197	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24197	41	1890	1890	CD
18637	24197	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24197	43	,	,	,
18637	24197	44	460	460	CD
18637	24197	45	,	,	,
18637	24197	46	482	482	CD
18637	24197	47	,	,	,
18637	24197	48	501	501	CD
18637	24197	49	,	,	,
18637	24197	50	633	633	CD
18637	24197	51	Neal	Neal	NNP
18637	24197	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	24197	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	55	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	24197	56	,	,	,
18637	24197	57	103	103	CD
18637	24197	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24197	59	370	370	CD
18637	24197	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24197	61	1881	1881	CD
18637	24197	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24197	63	,	,	,
18637	24197	64	1142	1142	CD
18637	24197	65	,	,	,
18637	24197	66	1183	1183	CD
18637	24197	67	Near	near	IN
18637	24197	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	24197	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	71	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24197	72	,	,	,
18637	24197	73	283	283	CD
18637	24197	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24197	75	697	697	CD
18637	24197	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24197	77	1931	1931	CD
18637	24197	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24197	79	,	,	,
18637	24197	80	757	757	CD
18637	24197	81	,	,	,
18637	24197	82	786	786	CD
18637	24197	83	Nebbia	Nebbia	NNP
18637	24197	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	24197	86	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	87	New	New	NNP
18637	24197	88	York	York	NNP
18637	24197	89	,	,	,
18637	24197	90	291	291	CD
18637	24197	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24197	92	502	502	CD
18637	24197	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24197	94	1934	1934	CD
18637	24197	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24197	96	,	,	,
18637	24197	97	244	244	CD
18637	24197	98	,	,	,
18637	24197	99	982	982	CD
18637	24197	100	,	,	,
18637	24197	101	996	996	CD
18637	24197	102	,	,	,
18637	24197	103	997	997	CD
18637	24197	104	,	,	,
18637	24197	105	998	998	CD
18637	24197	106	,	,	,
18637	24197	107	1017	1017	CD
18637	24197	108	,	,	,
18637	24197	109	1154	1154	CD
18637	24197	110	,	,	,
18637	24197	111	1160	1160	CD
18637	24197	112	Neblett	Neblett	NNP
18637	24197	113	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	114	v.	v.	IN
18637	24197	115	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	116	Carpenter	Carpenter	NNP
18637	24197	117	,	,	,
18637	24197	118	305	305	CD
18637	24197	119	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24197	120	297	297	CD
18637	24197	121	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24197	122	1938	1938	CD
18637	24197	123	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24197	124	,	,	,
18637	24197	125	362	362	CD
18637	24197	126	,	,	,
18637	24197	127	1023	1023	CD
18637	24197	128	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	24197	129	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	130	v.	v.	IN
18637	24197	131	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	132	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	24197	133	,	,	,
18637	24197	134	325	325	CD
18637	24197	135	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24197	136	589	589	CD
18637	24197	137	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24197	138	1945	1945	CD
18637	24197	139	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24197	140	,	,	,
18637	24197	141	593	593	CD
18637	24197	142	Nectaw	Nectaw	NNP
18637	24197	143	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	144	v.	v.	IN
18637	24197	145	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	146	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
18637	24197	147	,	,	,
18637	24197	148	277	277	CD
18637	24197	149	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24197	150	183	183	CD
18637	24197	151	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24197	152	1928	1928	CD
18637	24197	153	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24197	154	,	,	,
18637	24197	155	1028	1028	CD
18637	24197	156	Neely	neely	RB
18637	24197	157	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	158	v.	v.	IN
18637	24197	159	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	160	Hankel	Hankel	NNP
18637	24197	161	,	,	,
18637	24197	162	180	180	CD
18637	24197	163	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24197	164	109	109	CD
18637	24197	165	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24197	166	1901	1901	CD
18637	24197	167	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24197	168	,	,	,
18637	24197	169	308	308	CD
18637	24197	170	,	,	,
18637	24197	171	317	317	CD
18637	24197	172	,	,	,
18637	24197	173	427	427	CD
18637	24197	174	,	,	,
18637	24197	175	473	473	CD
18637	24197	176	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	24197	177	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	178	v.	v.	IN
18637	24197	179	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	180	Montgomery	Montgomery	NNP
18637	24197	181	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	24197	182	&	&	CC
18637	24197	183	Company	Company	NNP
18637	24197	184	,	,	,
18637	24197	185	312	312	CD
18637	24197	186	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24197	187	373	373	CD
18637	24197	188	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24197	189	1941	1941	CD
18637	24197	190	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24197	191	,	,	,
18637	24197	192	190	190	CD
18637	24197	193	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	24197	194	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	195	v.	v.	IN
18637	24197	196	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	197	Sears	Sears	NNP
18637	24197	198	,	,	,
18637	24197	199	Roebuck	Roebuck	NNP
18637	24197	200	&	&	CC
18637	24197	201	Company	Company	NNP
18637	24197	202	,	,	,
18637	24197	203	312	312	CD
18637	24197	204	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24197	205	359	359	CD
18637	24197	206	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24197	207	1941	1941	CD
18637	24197	208	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24197	209	,	,	,
18637	24197	210	190	190	CD
18637	24197	211	Newark	Newark	NNP
18637	24197	212	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	213	v.	v.	IN
18637	24197	214	_	_	NNP
18637	24197	215	New	New	NNP
18637	24197	216	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	24197	217	,	,	,
18637	24197	218	262	262	CD
18637	24197	219	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24197	220	192	192	CD
18637	24197	221	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24197	222	1923	1923	CD
18637	24197	223	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24197	224	,	,	,
18637	24197	225	1143	1143	CD
18637	24197	226	Newark	Newark	NNP
18637	24197	227	Fire	Fire	NNP
18637	24197	228	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24197	229	.	.	.
18637	24198	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24198	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24198	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24198	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24198	5	State	State	NNP
18637	24198	6	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24198	7	,	,	,
18637	24198	8	307	307	CD
18637	24198	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24198	10	313	313	CD
18637	24198	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24198	12	1939	1939	CD
18637	24198	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24198	14	,	,	,
18637	24198	15	1050	1050	CD
18637	24198	16	New	New	NNP
18637	24198	17	Bedford	Bedford	NNP
18637	24198	18	Dry	Dry	NNP
18637	24198	19	Dock	Dock	NNP
18637	24198	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24198	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24198	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	24198	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24198	24	Purdy	Purdy	NNP
18637	24198	25	,	,	,
18637	24198	26	258	258	CD
18637	24198	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24198	28	96	96	CD
18637	24198	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24198	30	1922	1922	CD
18637	24198	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24198	32	,	,	,
18637	24198	33	574	574	CD
18637	24198	34	Newberry	Newberry	NNP
18637	24198	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24198	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24198	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24198	38	United	United	NNP
18637	24198	39	States	States	NNP
18637	24198	40	,	,	,
18637	24198	41	256	256	CD
18637	24198	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24198	43	232	232	CD
18637	24198	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24198	45	1921	1921	CD
18637	24198	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24198	47	,	,	,
18637	24198	48	94	94	CD
18637	24198	49	,	,	,
18637	24198	50	96	96	CD
18637	24198	51	New	New	NNP
18637	24198	52	Brunswick	Brunswick	NNP
18637	24198	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24198	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	24198	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24198	56	United	United	NNP
18637	24198	57	States	States	NNP
18637	24198	58	,	,	,
18637	24198	59	276	276	CD
18637	24198	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24198	61	547	547	CD
18637	24198	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24198	63	1928	1928	CD
18637	24198	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24198	65	,	,	,
18637	24198	66	732	732	CD
18637	24198	67	Newburyport	Newburyport	NNP
18637	24198	68	Water	Water	NNP
18637	24198	69	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24198	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24198	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	24198	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24198	73	Newburyport	Newburyport	NNP
18637	24198	74	,	,	,
18637	24198	75	193	193	CD
18637	24198	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24198	77	561	561	CD
18637	24198	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24198	79	1904	1904	CD
18637	24198	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24198	81	,	,	,
18637	24198	82	567	567	CD
18637	24198	83	,	,	,
18637	24198	84	1009	1009	CD
18637	24198	85	New	New	NNP
18637	24198	86	England	England	NNP
18637	24198	87	Divisions	Divisions	NNPS
18637	24198	88	Case	Case	NNP
18637	24198	89	.	.	.
18637	24199	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24199	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24199	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24199	4	Akron	Akron	NNP
18637	24199	5	,	,	,
18637	24199	6	C.	C.	NNP
18637	24199	7	&	&	CC
18637	24199	8	Y.R.	Y.R.	NNP
18637	24200	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24200	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24200	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24200	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24200	5	United	United	NNP
18637	24200	6	States	States	NNP
18637	24200	7	.	.	.
18637	24201	1	New	New	NNP
18637	24201	2	England	England	NNP
18637	24201	3	M.	M.	NNP
18637	24201	4	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	24201	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24201	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24201	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	24201	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24201	9	Dunham	Dunham	NNP
18637	24201	10	,	,	,
18637	24201	11	11	11	CD
18637	24201	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24201	13	.	.	.
18637	24202	1	1	1	CD
18637	24202	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24202	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24202	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24202	5	,	,	,
18637	24202	6	574	574	CD
18637	24202	7	New	New	NNP
18637	24202	8	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	24202	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24202	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24202	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24202	12	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24202	13	,	,	,
18637	24202	14	108	108	CD
18637	24202	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24202	16	76	76	CD
18637	24202	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24202	18	1883	1883	CD
18637	24202	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24202	20	,	,	,
18637	24202	21	594	594	CD
18637	24202	22	,	,	,
18637	24202	23	930	930	CD
18637	24202	24	New	New	NNP
18637	24202	25	Haven	Haven	NNP
18637	24202	26	&	&	CC
18637	24202	27	N.	N.	NNP
18637	24202	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24202	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24202	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24202	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24202	32	Hamersley	Hamersley	NNP
18637	24202	33	,	,	,
18637	24202	34	104	104	CD
18637	24202	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24202	36	1	1	CD
18637	24202	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24202	38	1881	1881	CD
18637	24202	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24202	40	,	,	,
18637	24202	41	345	345	CD
18637	24202	42	New	New	NNP
18637	24202	43	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	24202	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24202	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24202	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24202	47	New	New	NNP
18637	24202	48	York	York	NNP
18637	24202	49	,	,	,
18637	24202	50	283	283	CD
18637	24202	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24202	52	336	336	CD
18637	24202	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24202	54	1931	1931	CD
18637	24202	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24202	56	,	,	,
18637	24202	57	612	612	CD
18637	24202	58	New	New	NNP
18637	24202	59	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	24202	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24202	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	24202	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24202	63	New	New	NNP
18637	24202	64	York	York	NNP
18637	24202	65	,	,	,
18637	24202	66	5	5	CD
18637	24202	67	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24202	68	.	.	.
18637	24203	1	284	284	CD
18637	24203	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24203	3	1831	1831	CD
18637	24203	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24203	5	,	,	,
18637	24203	6	592	592	CD
18637	24203	7	New	New	NNP
18637	24203	8	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	24203	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24203	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24203	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24203	12	Sargent	Sargent	NNP
18637	24203	13	,	,	,
18637	24203	14	269	269	CD
18637	24203	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24203	16	328	328	CD
18637	24203	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24203	18	1926	1926	CD
18637	24203	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24203	20	,	,	,
18637	24203	21	543	543	CD
18637	24203	22	,	,	,
18637	24203	23	596	596	CD
18637	24203	24	New	New	NNP
18637	24203	25	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	24203	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24203	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24203	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24203	29	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24203	30	,	,	,
18637	24203	31	7	7	CD
18637	24203	32	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24203	33	.	.	.
18637	24204	1	164	164	NNP
18637	24204	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24204	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	24204	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24204	5	,	,	,
18637	24204	6	341	341	CD
18637	24204	7	New	New	NNP
18637	24204	8	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	24204	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24204	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24204	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24204	12	Yard	Yard	NNP
18637	24204	13	,	,	,
18637	24204	14	95	95	CD
18637	24204	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24204	16	104	104	CD
18637	24204	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24204	18	1877	1877	CD
18637	24204	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24204	20	,	,	,
18637	24204	21	343	343	CD
18637	24204	22	New	New	NNP
18637	24204	23	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	24204	24	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	24204	25	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	24204	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24204	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24204	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24204	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24204	30	State	State	NNP
18637	24204	31	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	24204	32	.	.	.
18637	24205	1	of	of	IN
18637	24205	2	Taxes	Taxes	NNP
18637	24205	3	&	&	CC
18637	24205	4	Assessments	Assessments	NNPS
18637	24205	5	,	,	,
18637	24205	6	280	280	CD
18637	24205	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24205	8	338	338	CD
18637	24205	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24205	10	1930	1930	CD
18637	24205	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24205	12	,	,	,
18637	24205	13	126	126	CD
18637	24205	14	,	,	,
18637	24205	15	203	203	CD
18637	24205	16	,	,	,
18637	24205	17	204	204	CD
18637	24205	18	New	New	NNP
18637	24205	19	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	24205	20	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	24205	21	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	24205	22	.	.	.
18637	24206	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24206	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24206	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24206	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24206	5	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	24206	6	'	'	POS
18637	24206	7	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24206	8	,	,	,
18637	24206	9	6	6	CD
18637	24206	10	How	how	WRB
18637	24206	11	.	.	.
18637	24207	1	344	344	CD
18637	24207	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24207	3	1848	1848	CD
18637	24207	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24207	5	,	,	,
18637	24207	6	573	573	CD
18637	24207	7	,	,	,
18637	24207	8	574	574	CD
18637	24207	9	,	,	,
18637	24207	10	577	577	CD
18637	24207	11	New	New	NNP
18637	24207	12	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	24207	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24207	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24207	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24207	16	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	24207	17	,	,	,
18637	24207	18	243	243	CD
18637	24207	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24207	20	52	52	CD
18637	24207	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24207	22	1917	1917	CD
18637	24207	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24207	24	,	,	,
18637	24207	25	588	588	CD
18637	24207	26	New	New	NNP
18637	24207	27	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	24207	28	ex	ex	NN
18637	24207	29	rel	rel	NN
18637	24207	30	.	.	.
18637	24208	1	McLean	McLean	NNP
18637	24208	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24208	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24208	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24208	5	Denver	Denver	NNP
18637	24208	6	&	&	CC
18637	24208	7	R.G.R.	R.G.R.	NNP
18637	24209	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24209	2	,	,	,
18637	24209	3	203	203	CD
18637	24209	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24209	5	38	38	CD
18637	24209	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24209	7	1906	1906	CD
18637	24209	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24209	9	,	,	,
18637	24209	10	214	214	CD
18637	24209	11	New	New	NNP
18637	24209	12	Negro	Negro	NNP
18637	24209	13	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	24209	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24209	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24209	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24209	17	Sanitary	Sanitary	NNP
18637	24209	18	Grocery	Grocery	NNP
18637	24209	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24209	20	,	,	,
18637	24209	21	303	303	CD
18637	24209	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24209	23	552	552	CD
18637	24209	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24209	25	1938	1938	CD
18637	24209	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24209	27	,	,	,
18637	24209	28	524	524	CD
18637	24209	29	,	,	,
18637	24209	30	622	622	CD
18637	24209	31	New	New	NNP
18637	24209	32	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24209	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24209	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24209	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24209	36	New	New	NNP
18637	24209	37	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24209	38	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	24209	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24209	40	,	,	,
18637	24209	41	142	142	CD
18637	24209	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24209	43	79	79	CD
18637	24209	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24209	45	1891	1891	CD
18637	24209	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24209	47	,	,	,
18637	24209	48	352	352	CD
18637	24209	49	New	New	NNP
18637	24209	50	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24209	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24209	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	24209	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24209	54	Winter	Winter	NNP
18637	24209	55	,	,	,
18637	24209	56	1	1	CD
18637	24209	57	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24209	58	.	.	.
18637	24210	1	91	91	CD
18637	24210	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24210	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	24210	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24210	5	,	,	,
18637	24210	6	302	302	CD
18637	24210	7	,	,	,
18637	24210	8	600	600	CD
18637	24210	9	New	New	NNP
18637	24210	10	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24210	11	&	&	CC
18637	24210	12	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	24210	13	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24210	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24210	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24210	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24210	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24210	18	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24210	19	,	,	,
18637	24210	20	157	157	CD
18637	24210	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24210	22	219	219	CD
18637	24210	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24210	24	1895	1895	CD
18637	24210	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24210	26	,	,	,
18637	24210	27	355	355	CD
18637	24210	28	New	New	NNP
18637	24210	29	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24210	30	Debenture	Debenture	NNP
18637	24210	31	Redemption	Redemption	NNP
18637	24210	32	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24210	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24210	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24210	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24210	36	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24210	37	,	,	,
18637	24210	38	180	180	CD
18637	24210	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24210	40	320	320	CD
18637	24210	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24210	42	1901	1901	CD
18637	24210	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24210	44	,	,	,
18637	24210	45	1016	1016	CD
18637	24210	46	New	New	NNP
18637	24210	47	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24210	48	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24210	49	Light	Light	NNP
18637	24210	50	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24210	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24210	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	24210	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24210	54	Drainage	Drainage	NNP
18637	24210	55	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24210	56	,	,	,
18637	24210	57	197	197	CD
18637	24210	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24210	59	453	453	CD
18637	24210	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24210	61	1905	1905	CD
18637	24210	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24210	63	,	,	,
18637	24210	64	1010	1010	CD
18637	24210	65	New	New	NNP
18637	24210	66	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24210	67	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24210	68	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24210	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24210	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	24210	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24210	72	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24210	73	Light	Light	NNP
18637	24210	74	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24210	75	,	,	,
18637	24210	76	115	115	CD
18637	24210	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24210	78	650	650	CD
18637	24210	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24210	80	1885	1885	CD
18637	24210	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24210	82	,	,	,
18637	24210	83	329	329	CD
18637	24210	84	,	,	,
18637	24210	85	351	351	CD
18637	24210	86	New	New	NNP
18637	24210	87	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24210	88	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24210	89	Service	Service	NNP
18637	24210	90	,	,	,
18637	24210	91	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	24210	92	,	,	,
18637	24210	93	_	_	NNP
18637	24210	94	v.	v.	IN
18637	24210	95	_	_	NNP
18637	24210	96	New	New	NNP
18637	24210	97	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24210	98	,	,	,
18637	24210	99	281	281	CD
18637	24210	100	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24210	101	682	682	CD
18637	24210	102	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24210	103	1930	1930	CD
18637	24210	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24210	105	,	,	,
18637	24210	106	983	983	CD
18637	24210	107	,	,	,
18637	24210	108	1010	1010	CD
18637	24210	109	New	New	NNP
18637	24210	110	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24210	111	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	24210	112	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24210	113	_	_	NNP
18637	24210	114	v.	v.	IN
18637	24210	115	_	_	NNP
18637	24210	116	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24210	117	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	24210	118	Ref	Ref	NNP
18637	24210	119	.	.	.
18637	24211	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24211	2	,	,	,
18637	24211	3	125	125	CD
18637	24211	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24211	5	18	18	CD
18637	24211	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24211	7	1888	1888	CD
18637	24211	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24211	9	,	,	,
18637	24211	10	329	329	CD
18637	24211	11	New	New	NNP
18637	24211	12	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24211	13	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	24211	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24211	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24211	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	18	Rivers	Rivers	NNP
18637	24211	19	,	,	,
18637	24211	20	115	115	CD
18637	24211	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24211	22	674	674	CD
18637	24211	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24211	24	1885	1885	CD
18637	24211	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24211	26	,	,	,
18637	24211	27	329	329	CD
18637	24211	28	Newport	Newport	NNP
18637	24211	29	&	&	CC
18637	24211	30	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
18637	24211	31	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	24211	32	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24211	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24211	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	36	United	United	NNP
18637	24211	37	States	States	NNP
18637	24211	38	,	,	,
18637	24211	39	105	105	CD
18637	24211	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24211	41	470	470	CD
18637	24211	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24211	43	1882	1882	CD
18637	24211	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24211	45	,	,	,
18637	24211	46	128	128	CD
18637	24211	47	New	New	NNP
18637	24211	48	State	State	NNP
18637	24211	49	Ice	Ice	NNP
18637	24211	50	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24211	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	24211	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	54	Liebmann	Liebmann	NNP
18637	24211	55	,	,	,
18637	24211	56	285	285	CD
18637	24211	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24211	58	262	262	CD
18637	24211	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24211	60	1932	1932	CD
18637	24211	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24211	62	,	,	,
18637	24211	63	996	996	CD
18637	24211	64	,	,	,
18637	24211	65	997	997	CD
18637	24211	66	Newton	Newton	NNP
18637	24211	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	24211	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	70	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	24211	71	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24211	72	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24211	73	,	,	,
18637	24211	74	258	258	CD
18637	24211	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24211	76	165	165	CD
18637	24211	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24211	78	1922	1922	CD
18637	24211	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24211	80	,	,	,
18637	24211	81	1008	1008	CD
18637	24211	82	Newton	Newton	NNP
18637	24211	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	24211	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	86	Mahoning	Mahoning	NNP
18637	24211	87	County	County	NNP
18637	24211	88	,	,	,
18637	24211	89	100	100	CD
18637	24211	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24211	91	548	548	CD
18637	24211	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24211	93	1880	1880	CD
18637	24211	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24211	95	,	,	,
18637	24211	96	340	340	CD
18637	24211	97	New	New	NNP
18637	24211	98	York	York	NNP
18637	24211	99	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	24211	101	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	102	Compagnie	Compagnie	NNP
18637	24211	103	GÃ	GÃ	NNP
18637	24211	104	©	©	NNP
18637	24211	105	nÃ	nÃ	NNP
18637	24211	106	©	©	NNP
18637	24211	107	rale	rale	NN
18637	24211	108	Transatlantique	Transatlantique	NNP
18637	24211	109	,	,	,
18637	24211	110	107	107	CD
18637	24211	111	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24211	112	59	59	CD
18637	24211	113	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24211	114	1883	1883	CD
18637	24211	115	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24211	116	,	,	,
18637	24211	117	193	193	CD
18637	24211	118	New	New	NNP
18637	24211	119	York	York	NNP
18637	24211	120	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	121	v.	v.	IN
18637	24211	122	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	123	Eno	Eno	NNP
18637	24211	124	,	,	,
18637	24211	125	155	155	CD
18637	24211	126	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24211	127	89	89	CD
18637	24211	128	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24211	129	1894	1894	CD
18637	24211	130	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24211	131	,	,	,
18637	24211	132	634	634	CD
18637	24211	133	New	New	NNP
18637	24211	134	York	York	NNP
18637	24211	135	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	136	v.	v.	IN
18637	24211	137	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	138	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	24211	139	,	,	,
18637	24211	140	274	274	CD
18637	24211	141	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24211	142	488	488	CD
18637	24211	143	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24211	144	1927	1927	CD
18637	24211	145	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24211	146	,	,	,
18637	24211	147	544	544	CD
18637	24211	148	New	New	NNP
18637	24211	149	York	York	NNP
18637	24211	150	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	151	v.	v.	IN
18637	24211	152	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	153	Irving	Irving	NNP
18637	24211	154	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24211	155	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24211	156	,	,	,
18637	24211	157	288	288	CD
18637	24211	158	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24211	159	329	329	CD
18637	24211	160	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24211	161	1933	1933	CD
18637	24211	162	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24211	163	,	,	,
18637	24211	164	265	265	CD
18637	24211	165	New	New	NNP
18637	24211	166	York	York	NNP
18637	24211	167	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	168	v.	v.	IN
18637	24211	169	_	_	NNP
18637	24211	170	Miln	Miln	NNP
18637	24211	171	,	,	,
18637	24211	172	11	11	CD
18637	24211	173	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24211	174	.	.	.
18637	24212	1	102	102	CD
18637	24212	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24212	3	1837	1837	CD
18637	24212	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24212	5	,	,	,
18637	24212	6	122	122	CD
18637	24212	7	,	,	,
18637	24212	8	216	216	CD
18637	24212	9	,	,	,
18637	24212	10	241	241	CD
18637	24212	11	,	,	,
18637	24212	12	722	722	CD
18637	24212	13	New	New	NNP
18637	24212	14	York	York	NNP
18637	24212	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24212	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24212	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24212	18	United	United	NNP
18637	24212	19	States	States	NNP
18637	24212	20	,	,	,
18637	24212	21	257	257	CD
18637	24212	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24212	23	591	591	CD
18637	24212	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24212	25	1922	1922	CD
18637	24212	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24212	27	,	,	,
18637	24212	28	219	219	CD
18637	24212	29	,	,	,
18637	24212	30	362	362	CD
18637	24212	31	,	,	,
18637	24212	32	921	921	CD
18637	24212	33	New	New	NNP
18637	24212	34	York	York	NNP
18637	24212	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24212	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24212	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24212	38	United	United	NNP
18637	24212	39	States	States	NNP
18637	24212	40	,	,	,
18637	24212	41	326	326	CD
18637	24212	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24212	43	572	572	CD
18637	24212	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24212	45	1946	1946	CD
18637	24212	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24212	47	,	,	,
18637	24212	48	108	108	CD
18637	24212	49	,	,	,
18637	24212	50	916	916	CD
18637	24212	51	,	,	,
18637	24212	52	1064	1064	CD
18637	24212	53	New	New	NNP
18637	24212	54	York	York	NNP
18637	24212	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24212	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24212	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24212	58	United	United	NNP
18637	24212	59	States	States	NNP
18637	24212	60	,	,	,
18637	24212	61	331	331	CD
18637	24212	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24212	63	284	284	CD
18637	24212	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24212	65	1947	1947	CD
18637	24212	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24212	67	,	,	,
18637	24212	68	77	77	CD
18637	24212	69	New	New	NNP
18637	24212	70	York	York	NNP
18637	24212	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24212	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	24212	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24212	74	United	United	NNP
18637	24212	75	States	States	NNP
18637	24212	76	,	,	,
18637	24212	77	342	342	CD
18637	24212	78	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24212	79	882	882	CD
18637	24212	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24212	81	1951	1951	CD
18637	24212	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24212	83	,	,	,
18637	24212	84	77	77	CD
18637	24212	85	New	New	NNP
18637	24212	86	York	York	NNP
18637	24212	87	Central	Central	NNP
18637	24212	88	_	_	NNP
18637	24212	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	24212	90	_	_	NNP
18637	24212	91	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24212	92	,	,	,
18637	24212	93	202	202	CD
18637	24212	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24212	95	584	584	CD
18637	24212	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24212	97	1906	1906	CD
18637	24212	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24212	99	,	,	,
18637	24212	100	1052	1052	CD
18637	24212	101	New	New	NNP
18637	24212	102	York	York	NNP
18637	24212	103	C.	C.	NNP
18637	24212	104	&	&	CC
18637	24212	105	H.R.R.	H.R.R.	NNP
18637	24213	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24213	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24213	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24213	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24213	5	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	24213	6	.	.	.
18637	24214	1	of	of	IN
18637	24214	2	Chosen	Chosen	NNP
18637	24214	3	Freeholders	Freeholders	NNP
18637	24214	4	,	,	,
18637	24214	5	227	227	CD
18637	24214	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24214	7	248	248	CD
18637	24214	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24214	9	1913	1913	CD
18637	24214	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24214	11	,	,	,
18637	24214	12	130	130	CD
18637	24214	13	,	,	,
18637	24214	14	231	231	CD
18637	24214	15	New	New	NNP
18637	24214	16	York	York	NNP
18637	24214	17	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	24215	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24215	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24215	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24215	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24215	5	Bianc	Bianc	NNP
18637	24215	6	,	,	,
18637	24215	7	250	250	CD
18637	24215	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24215	9	596	596	CD
18637	24215	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24215	11	1919	1919	CD
18637	24215	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24215	13	,	,	,
18637	24215	14	990	990	CD
18637	24215	15	New	New	NNP
18637	24215	16	York	York	NNP
18637	24215	17	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	24216	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24216	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24216	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24216	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24216	5	White	White	NNP
18637	24216	6	,	,	,
18637	24216	7	243	243	CD
18637	24216	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24216	9	188	188	CD
18637	24216	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24216	11	1917	1917	CD
18637	24216	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24216	13	,	,	,
18637	24216	14	141	141	CD
18637	24216	15	,	,	,
18637	24216	16	358	358	CD
18637	24216	17	,	,	,
18637	24216	18	989	989	CD
18637	24216	19	,	,	,
18637	24216	20	1096	1096	CD
18637	24216	21	,	,	,
18637	24216	22	1159	1159	CD
18637	24216	23	New	New	NNP
18637	24216	24	York	York	NNP
18637	24216	25	Central	Central	NNP
18637	24216	26	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	24216	27	Corp	Corp	NNP
18637	24216	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24216	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24216	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24216	31	United	United	NNP
18637	24216	32	States	States	NNP
18637	24216	33	,	,	,
18637	24216	34	287	287	CD
18637	24216	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24216	36	12	12	CD
18637	24216	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24216	38	1932	1932	CD
18637	24216	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24216	40	,	,	,
18637	24216	41	75	75	CD
18637	24216	42	,	,	,
18637	24216	43	78	78	CD
18637	24216	44	New	New	NNP
18637	24216	45	York	York	NNP
18637	24216	46	,	,	,
18637	24216	47	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24216	48	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24216	49	,	,	,
18637	24216	50	256	256	CD
18637	24216	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24216	52	490	490	CD
18637	24216	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24216	54	1921	1921	CD
18637	24216	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24216	56	,	,	,
18637	24216	57	930	930	CD
18637	24216	58	New	New	NNP
18637	24216	59	York	York	NNP
18637	24216	60	ex	ex	NN
18637	24216	61	rel	rel	NN
18637	24216	62	.	.	.
18637	24217	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24217	2	of	of	IN
18637	24217	3	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24217	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24217	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	24217	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24217	7	Comrs	Comrs	NNP
18637	24217	8	.	.	.
18637	24218	1	of	of	IN
18637	24218	2	Taxes	Taxes	NNP
18637	24218	3	&	&	CC
18637	24218	4	Assessments	Assessments	NNPS
18637	24218	5	,	,	,
18637	24218	6	2	2	CD
18637	24218	7	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	24218	8	.	.	.
18637	24219	1	620	620	CD
18637	24219	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24219	3	1863	1863	CD
18637	24219	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24219	5	,	,	,
18637	24219	6	729	729	CD
18637	24219	7	New	New	NNP
18637	24219	8	York	York	NNP
18637	24219	9	ex	ex	NN
18637	24219	10	rel	rel	NN
18637	24219	11	.	.	.
18637	24220	1	Bryant	Bryant	NNP
18637	24220	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24220	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24220	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24220	5	Zimmerman	Zimmerman	NNP
18637	24220	6	,	,	,
18637	24220	7	278	278	CD
18637	24220	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24220	9	63	63	CD
18637	24220	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24220	11	1928	1928	CD
18637	24220	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24220	13	,	,	,
18637	24220	14	971	971	CD
18637	24220	15	,	,	,
18637	24220	16	1156	1156	CD
18637	24220	17	New	New	NNP
18637	24220	18	York	York	NNP
18637	24220	19	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24220	20	rel	rel	NN
18637	24220	21	.	.	.
18637	24221	1	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	24221	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24221	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24221	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24221	5	Wells	Wells	NNP
18637	24221	6	,	,	,
18637	24221	7	208	208	CD
18637	24221	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24221	9	14	14	CD
18637	24221	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24221	11	1908	1908	CD
18637	24221	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24221	13	,	,	,
18637	24221	14	364	364	CD
18637	24221	15	New	New	NNP
18637	24221	16	York	York	NNP
18637	24221	17	ex	ex	NN
18637	24221	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24221	19	.	.	.
18637	24222	1	Cohn	Cohn	NNP
18637	24222	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24222	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24222	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24222	5	Graves	Graves	NNP
18637	24222	6	,	,	,
18637	24222	7	300	300	CD
18637	24222	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24222	9	308	308	CD
18637	24222	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24222	11	1937	1937	CD
18637	24222	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24222	13	,	,	,
18637	24222	14	1054	1054	CD
18637	24222	15	New	New	NNP
18637	24222	16	York	York	NNP
18637	24222	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24222	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24222	19	.	.	.
18637	24223	1	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	24223	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24223	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24223	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24223	5	Reardon	Reardon	NNP
18637	24223	6	,	,	,
18637	24223	7	204	204	CD
18637	24223	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24223	9	152	152	CD
18637	24223	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24223	11	1907	1907	CD
18637	24223	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24223	13	,	,	,
18637	24223	14	188	188	CD
18637	24223	15	,	,	,
18637	24223	16	1044	1044	CD
18637	24223	17	New	New	NNP
18637	24223	18	York	York	NNP
18637	24223	19	ex	ex	NN
18637	24223	20	rel	rel	NN
18637	24223	21	.	.	.
18637	24224	1	Lieberman	Lieberman	NNP
18637	24224	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24224	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24224	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24224	5	Van	Van	NNP
18637	24224	6	De	De	NNP
18637	24224	7	Carr	Carr	NNP
18637	24224	8	,	,	,
18637	24224	9	199	199	CD
18637	24224	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24224	11	552	552	CD
18637	24224	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24224	13	1905	1905	CD
18637	24224	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24224	15	,	,	,
18637	24224	16	1029	1029	CD
18637	24224	17	,	,	,
18637	24224	18	1071	1071	CD
18637	24224	19	,	,	,
18637	24224	20	1154	1154	CD
18637	24224	21	New	New	NNP
18637	24224	22	York	York	NNP
18637	24224	23	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24224	24	rel	rel	NN
18637	24224	25	.	.	.
18637	24225	1	New	New	NNP
18637	24225	2	York	York	NNP
18637	24225	3	,	,	,
18637	24225	4	C.	C.	NNP
18637	24225	5	&	&	CC
18637	24225	6	H.R.R.	H.R.R.	NNP
18637	24226	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24226	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24226	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24226	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24226	5	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24226	6	,	,	,
18637	24226	7	202	202	CD
18637	24226	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24226	9	584	584	CD
18637	24226	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24226	11	1906	1906	CD
18637	24226	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24226	13	,	,	,
18637	24226	14	211	211	CD
18637	24226	15	,	,	,
18637	24226	16	1042	1042	CD
18637	24226	17	New	New	NNP
18637	24226	18	York	York	NNP
18637	24226	19	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24226	20	rel	rel	NN
18637	24226	21	.	.	.
18637	24227	1	New	New	NNP
18637	24227	2	York	York	NNP
18637	24227	3	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	24227	4	Lines	Lines	NNPS
18637	24227	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24227	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24227	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	24227	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24227	9	Squire	Squire	NNP
18637	24227	10	,	,	,
18637	24227	11	145	145	CD
18637	24227	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24227	13	175	175	CD
18637	24227	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24227	15	1892	1892	CD
18637	24227	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24227	17	,	,	,
18637	24227	18	213	213	CD
18637	24227	19	New	New	NNP
18637	24227	20	York	York	NNP
18637	24227	21	ex	ex	NN
18637	24227	22	rel	rel	NN
18637	24227	23	.	.	.
18637	24228	1	New	New	NNP
18637	24228	2	York	York	NNP
18637	24228	3	&	&	CC
18637	24228	4	O.	O.	NNP
18637	24229	1	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24229	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24229	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24229	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	24229	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24229	6	McCall	McCall	NNP
18637	24229	7	,	,	,
18637	24229	8	245	245	CD
18637	24229	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24229	10	345	345	CD
18637	24229	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24229	12	1917	1917	CD
18637	24229	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24229	14	,	,	,
18637	24229	15	1011	1011	CD
18637	24229	16	New	New	NNP
18637	24229	17	York	York	NNP
18637	24229	18	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24229	19	rel	rel	NN
18637	24229	20	.	.	.
18637	24230	1	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	24230	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24230	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24230	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24230	5	Graves	Graves	NNP
18637	24230	6	,	,	,
18637	24230	7	299	299	CD
18637	24230	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24230	9	401	401	CD
18637	24230	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24230	11	1937	1937	CD
18637	24230	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24230	13	,	,	,
18637	24230	14	731	731	CD
18637	24230	15	New	New	NNP
18637	24230	16	York	York	NNP
18637	24230	17	ex	ex	NN
18637	24230	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24230	19	.	.	.
18637	24231	1	Whitman	Whitman	NNP
18637	24231	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24231	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24231	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24231	5	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24231	6	,	,	,
18637	24231	7	318	318	CD
18637	24231	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24231	9	688	688	CD
18637	24231	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24231	11	1943	1943	CD
18637	24231	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24231	13	,	,	,
18637	24231	14	1125	1125	CD
18637	24231	15	New	New	NNP
18637	24231	16	York	York	NNP
18637	24231	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24231	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24231	19	.	.	.
18637	24232	1	Woodhaven	Woodhaven	NNP
18637	24232	2	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24232	3	Light	Light	NNP
18637	24232	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24232	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24232	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	24232	7	_	_	NNP
18637	24232	8	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24232	9	Service	Service	NNP
18637	24232	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24232	11	,	,	,
18637	24232	12	269	269	CD
18637	24232	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24232	14	244	244	CD
18637	24232	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24232	16	1925	1925	CD
18637	24232	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24232	18	,	,	,
18637	24232	19	1011	1011	CD
18637	24232	20	New	New	NNP
18637	24232	21	York	York	NNP
18637	24232	22	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	24232	23	,	,	,
18637	24232	24	The	the	DT
18637	24232	25	,	,	,
18637	24232	26	5	5	CD
18637	24232	27	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24232	28	.	.	.
18637	24233	1	761	761	CD
18637	24233	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24233	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	24233	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24233	5	,	,	,
18637	24233	6	432	432	CD
18637	24233	7	,	,	,
18637	24233	8	735	735	CD
18637	24233	9	New	New	NNP
18637	24233	10	York	York	NNP
18637	24233	11	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24233	12	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24233	13	.	.	.
18637	24234	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24234	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24234	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24234	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24234	5	Cravens	Cravens	NNP
18637	24234	6	,	,	,
18637	24234	7	178	178	CD
18637	24234	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24234	9	389	389	CD
18637	24234	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24234	11	1900	1900	CD
18637	24234	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24234	13	,	,	,
18637	24234	14	120	120	CD
18637	24234	15	,	,	,
18637	24234	16	680	680	CD
18637	24234	17	New	New	NNP
18637	24234	18	York	York	NNP
18637	24234	19	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24234	20	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24234	21	.	.	.
18637	24235	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24235	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24235	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24235	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24235	5	Deer	Deer	NNP
18637	24235	6	Lodge	Lodge	NNP
18637	24235	7	County	County	NNP
18637	24235	8	,	,	,
18637	24235	9	231	231	CD
18637	24235	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24235	11	495	495	CD
18637	24235	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24235	13	1913	1913	CD
18637	24235	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24235	15	,	,	,
18637	24235	16	120	120	CD
18637	24235	17	New	New	NNP
18637	24235	18	York	York	NNP
18637	24235	19	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24235	20	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24235	21	.	.	.
18637	24236	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24236	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24236	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24236	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24236	5	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	24236	6	,	,	,
18637	24236	7	246	246	CD
18637	24236	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24236	9	375	375	CD
18637	24236	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24236	11	1918	1918	CD
18637	24236	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24236	13	,	,	,
18637	24236	14	1022	1022	CD
18637	24236	15	New	New	NNP
18637	24236	16	York	York	NNP
18637	24236	17	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24236	18	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24236	19	.	.	.
18637	24237	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24237	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24237	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24237	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24237	5	Head	Head	NNP
18637	24237	6	,	,	,
18637	24237	7	234	234	CD
18637	24237	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24237	9	149	149	CD
18637	24237	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24237	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	24237	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24237	13	,	,	,
18637	24237	14	679	679	CD
18637	24237	15	New	New	NNP
18637	24237	16	York	York	NNP
18637	24237	17	&	&	CC
18637	24237	18	N.E.R.	N.E.R.	NNP
18637	24238	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24238	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24238	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24238	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24238	5	Bristol	Bristol	NNP
18637	24238	6	,	,	,
18637	24238	7	151	151	CD
18637	24238	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24238	9	556	556	CD
18637	24238	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24238	11	1894	1894	CD
18637	24238	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24238	13	,	,	,
18637	24238	14	345	345	CD
18637	24238	15	,	,	,
18637	24238	16	1156	1156	CD
18637	24238	17	New	New	NNP
18637	24238	18	York	York	NNP
18637	24238	19	,	,	,
18637	24238	20	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	24238	21	&	&	CC
18637	24238	22	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	24239	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24239	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24239	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24239	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24239	5	New	New	NNP
18637	24239	6	York	York	NNP
18637	24239	7	,	,	,
18637	24239	8	165	165	CD
18637	24239	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24239	10	628	628	CD
18637	24239	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24239	12	1897	1897	CD
18637	24239	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24239	14	,	,	,
18637	24239	15	222	222	CD
18637	24239	16	,	,	,
18637	24239	17	223	223	CD
18637	24239	18	,	,	,
18637	24239	19	1014	1014	CD
18637	24239	20	New	New	NNP
18637	24239	21	York	York	NNP
18637	24239	22	,	,	,
18637	24239	23	P.	P.	NNP
18637	24239	24	&	&	CC
18637	24239	25	N.	N.	NNP
18637	24239	26	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24239	27	.	.	.
18637	24240	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24240	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24240	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	5	Dolan	Dolan	NNP
18637	24240	6	,	,	,
18637	24240	7	265	265	CD
18637	24240	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24240	9	96	96	CD
18637	24240	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24240	11	1924	1924	CD
18637	24240	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24240	13	,	,	,
18637	24240	14	1039	1039	CD
18637	24240	15	New	New	NNP
18637	24240	16	York	York	NNP
18637	24240	17	Rapid	Rapid	NNP
18637	24240	18	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	24240	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24240	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24240	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	23	City	City	NNP
18637	24240	24	of	of	IN
18637	24240	25	New	New	NNP
18637	24240	26	York	York	NNP
18637	24240	27	,	,	,
18637	24240	28	303	303	CD
18637	24240	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24240	30	573	573	CD
18637	24240	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24240	32	1938	1938	CD
18637	24240	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24240	34	,	,	,
18637	24240	35	347	347	CD
18637	24240	36	,	,	,
18637	24240	37	1148	1148	CD
18637	24240	38	New	New	NNP
18637	24240	39	York	York	NNP
18637	24240	40	State	State	NNP
18637	24240	41	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24240	42	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24240	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24240	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	46	Shuler	Shuler	NNP
18637	24240	47	,	,	,
18637	24240	48	265	265	CD
18637	24240	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24240	50	379	379	CD
18637	24240	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24240	52	1924	1924	CD
18637	24240	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24240	54	,	,	,
18637	24240	55	990	990	CD
18637	24240	56	New	New	NNP
18637	24240	57	York	York	NNP
18637	24240	58	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24240	59	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24240	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	24240	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	63	Eisner	Eisner	NNP
18637	24240	64	,	,	,
18637	24240	65	256	256	CD
18637	24240	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24240	67	345	345	CD
18637	24240	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24240	69	1921	1921	CD
18637	24240	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24240	71	,	,	,
18637	24240	72	320	320	CD
18637	24240	73	Ng	Ng	NNP
18637	24240	74	Fung	Fung	NNP
18637	24240	75	Ho	Ho	NNP
18637	24240	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	24240	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	79	White	White	NNP
18637	24240	80	,	,	,
18637	24240	81	259	259	CD
18637	24240	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24240	83	276	276	CD
18637	24240	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24240	85	1922	1922	CD
18637	24240	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24240	87	,	,	,
18637	24240	88	853	853	CD
18637	24240	89	Nicchia	Nicchia	NNP
18637	24240	90	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	91	v.	v.	IN
18637	24240	92	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	93	New	New	NNP
18637	24240	94	York	York	NNP
18637	24240	95	,	,	,
18637	24240	96	254	254	CD
18637	24240	97	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24240	98	228	228	CD
18637	24240	99	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24240	100	1920	1920	CD
18637	24240	101	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24240	102	,	,	,
18637	24240	103	1037	1037	CD
18637	24240	104	Nichols	Nichols	NNP
18637	24240	105	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	106	v.	v.	IN
18637	24240	107	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	108	Coolidge	Coolidge	NNP
18637	24240	109	,	,	,
18637	24240	110	274	274	CD
18637	24240	111	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24240	112	531	531	CD
18637	24240	113	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24240	114	1927	1927	CD
18637	24240	115	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24240	116	,	,	,
18637	24240	117	863	863	CD
18637	24240	118	Nichols	Nichols	NNP
18637	24240	119	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	120	v.	v.	IN
18637	24240	121	_	_	NNP
18637	24240	122	United	United	NNP
18637	24240	123	States	States	NNP
18637	24240	124	,	,	,
18637	24240	125	7	7	CD
18637	24240	126	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24240	127	.	.	.
18637	24241	1	122	122	CD
18637	24241	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24241	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24241	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24241	5	,	,	,
18637	24241	6	586	586	CD
18637	24241	7	Nickel	Nickel	NNP
18637	24241	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24241	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	11	Cole	Cole	NNP
18637	24241	12	,	,	,
18637	24241	13	256	256	CD
18637	24241	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24241	15	222	222	CD
18637	24241	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24241	17	1921	1921	CD
18637	24241	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24241	19	,	,	,
18637	24241	20	1038	1038	CD
18637	24241	21	Nickey	Nickey	NNP
18637	24241	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24241	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	25	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	24241	26	,	,	,
18637	24241	27	292	292	CD
18637	24241	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24241	29	393	393	CD
18637	24241	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24241	31	1934	1934	CD
18637	24241	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24241	33	,	,	,
18637	24241	34	1058	1058	CD
18637	24241	35	Nicol	Nicol	NNP
18637	24241	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24241	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	39	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	24241	40	,	,	,
18637	24241	41	173	173	CD
18637	24241	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24241	43	509	509	CD
18637	24241	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24241	45	1899	1899	CD
18637	24241	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24241	47	,	,	,
18637	24241	48	320	320	CD
18637	24241	49	,	,	,
18637	24241	50	1191	1191	CD
18637	24241	51	Nielsen	Nielsen	NNP
18637	24241	52	,	,	,
18637	24241	53	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24241	54	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24241	55	,	,	,
18637	24241	56	131	131	CD
18637	24241	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24241	58	176	176	CD
18637	24241	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24241	60	1889	1889	CD
18637	24241	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24241	62	,	,	,
18637	24241	63	840	840	CD
18637	24241	64	Nielsen	Nielsen	NNP
18637	24241	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	24241	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	68	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	24241	69	,	,	,
18637	24241	70	279	279	CD
18637	24241	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24241	72	47	47	CD
18637	24241	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24241	74	1929	1929	CD
18637	24241	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24241	76	,	,	,
18637	24241	77	416	416	CD
18637	24241	78	,	,	,
18637	24241	79	439	439	CD
18637	24241	80	Niemotko	Niemotko	NNP
18637	24241	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	24241	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	84	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	24241	85	,	,	,
18637	24241	86	340	340	CD
18637	24241	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24241	88	268	268	CD
18637	24241	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24241	90	1951	1951	CD
18637	24241	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24241	92	,	,	,
18637	24241	93	768	768	CD
18637	24241	94	Nigro	Nigro	NNP
18637	24241	95	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	24241	97	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	98	United	United	NNP
18637	24241	99	States	States	NNP
18637	24241	100	,	,	,
18637	24241	101	276	276	CD
18637	24241	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24241	103	332	332	CD
18637	24241	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24241	105	1928	1928	CD
18637	24241	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24241	107	,	,	,
18637	24241	108	111	111	CD
18637	24241	109	Nippert	Nippert	NNP
18637	24241	110	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	111	v.	v.	IN
18637	24241	112	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	113	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	24241	114	,	,	,
18637	24241	115	327	327	CD
18637	24241	116	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24241	117	416	416	CD
18637	24241	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24241	119	1946	1946	CD
18637	24241	120	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24241	121	,	,	,
18637	24241	122	191	191	CD
18637	24241	123	,	,	,
18637	24241	124	1079	1079	CD
18637	24241	125	Nishimura	Nishimura	NNP
18637	24241	126	Ekiu	Ekiu	NNP
18637	24241	127	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	128	v.	v.	IN
18637	24241	129	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	130	United	United	NNP
18637	24241	131	States	States	NNP
18637	24241	132	,	,	,
18637	24241	133	142	142	CD
18637	24241	134	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24241	135	651	651	CD
18637	24241	136	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24241	137	1892	1892	CD
18637	24241	138	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24241	139	,	,	,
18637	24241	140	452	452	CD
18637	24241	141	Nixon	Nixon	NNP
18637	24241	142	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	143	v.	v.	IN
18637	24241	144	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	145	Condon	Condon	NNP
18637	24241	146	,	,	,
18637	24241	147	286	286	CD
18637	24241	148	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24241	149	73	73	CD
18637	24241	150	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24241	151	1932	1932	CD
18637	24241	152	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24241	153	,	,	,
18637	24241	154	1142	1142	CD
18637	24241	155	,	,	,
18637	24241	156	1164	1164	CD
18637	24241	157	,	,	,
18637	24241	158	1185	1185	CD
18637	24241	159	Nixon	Nixon	NNP
18637	24241	160	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	161	v.	v.	IN
18637	24241	162	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	163	Herndon	Herndon	NNP
18637	24241	164	,	,	,
18637	24241	165	273	273	CD
18637	24241	166	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24241	167	536	536	CD
18637	24241	168	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24241	169	1927	1927	CD
18637	24241	170	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24241	171	,	,	,
18637	24241	172	1142	1142	CD
18637	24241	173	,	,	,
18637	24241	174	1164	1164	CD
18637	24241	175	,	,	,
18637	24241	176	1185	1185	CD
18637	24241	177	Noble	Noble	NNP
18637	24241	178	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	179	v.	v.	IN
18637	24241	180	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	181	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24241	182	River	River	NNP
18637	24241	183	Logging	Logging	NNP
18637	24241	184	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24241	185	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24241	186	,	,	,
18637	24241	187	147	147	CD
18637	24241	188	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24241	189	165	165	CD
18637	24241	190	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24241	191	1893	1893	CD
18637	24241	192	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24241	193	,	,	,
18637	24241	194	501	501	CD
18637	24241	195	,	,	,
18637	24241	196	857	857	CD
18637	24241	197	Noble	Noble	NNP
18637	24241	198	State	State	NNP
18637	24241	199	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24241	200	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	201	v.	v.	IN
18637	24241	202	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	203	Haskell	Haskell	NNP
18637	24241	204	,	,	,
18637	24241	205	219	219	CD
18637	24241	206	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24241	207	104	104	CD
18637	24241	208	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24241	209	1911	1911	CD
18637	24241	210	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24241	211	,	,	,
18637	24241	212	983	983	CD
18637	24241	213	,	,	,
18637	24241	214	1020	1020	CD
18637	24241	215	Nogueira	Nogueira	NNP
18637	24241	216	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	217	v.	v.	IN
18637	24241	218	_	_	NNP
18637	24241	219	New	New	NNP
18637	24241	220	York	York	NNP
18637	24241	221	,	,	,
18637	24241	222	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	24241	223	&	&	CC
18637	24241	224	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	24242	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24242	2	,	,	,
18637	24242	3	281	281	CD
18637	24242	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24242	5	128	128	CD
18637	24242	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24242	7	1930	1930	CD
18637	24242	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24242	9	,	,	,
18637	24242	10	581	581	CD
18637	24242	11	,	,	,
18637	24242	12	582	582	CD
18637	24242	13	Norfolk	Norfolk	NNP
18637	24242	14	&	&	CC
18637	24242	15	S.	S.	NNP
18637	24242	16	Turnpike	Turnpike	NNP
18637	24242	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24242	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24242	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24242	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24242	21	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24242	22	,	,	,
18637	24242	23	225	225	CD
18637	24242	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24242	25	264	264	CD
18637	24242	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24242	27	1912	1912	CD
18637	24242	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24242	29	,	,	,
18637	24242	30	1010	1010	CD
18637	24242	31	Norfolk	Norfolk	NNP
18637	24242	32	&	&	CC
18637	24242	33	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	24242	34	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24242	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24242	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24242	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24242	38	Pendleton	Pendleton	NNP
18637	24242	39	,	,	,
18637	24242	40	156	156	CD
18637	24242	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24242	42	667	667	CD
18637	24242	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24242	44	1895	1895	CD
18637	24242	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24242	46	,	,	,
18637	24242	47	347	347	CD
18637	24242	48	Norfolk	Norfolk	NNP
18637	24242	49	&	&	CC
18637	24242	50	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	24242	51	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24242	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24242	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	24242	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24242	55	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24242	56	,	,	,
18637	24242	57	136	136	CD
18637	24242	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24242	59	114	114	CD
18637	24242	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24242	61	1890	1890	CD
18637	24242	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24242	63	,	,	,
18637	24242	64	195	195	CD
18637	24242	65	Norfolk	Norfolk	NNP
18637	24242	66	&	&	CC
18637	24242	67	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	24242	68	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24242	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24242	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	24242	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24242	72	Sims	Sims	NNP
18637	24242	73	,	,	,
18637	24242	74	191	191	CD
18637	24242	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24242	76	441	441	CD
18637	24242	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24242	78	1903	1903	CD
18637	24242	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24242	80	,	,	,
18637	24242	81	187	187	CD
18637	24242	82	Norman	Norman	NNP
18637	24242	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24242	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	24242	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24242	86	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	24242	87	&	&	CC
18637	24242	88	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	24243	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24243	2	,	,	,
18637	24243	3	294	294	CD
18637	24243	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24243	5	240	240	CD
18637	24243	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24243	7	1935	1935	CD
18637	24243	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24243	9	,	,	,
18637	24243	10	266	266	CD
18637	24243	11	,	,	,
18637	24243	12	310	310	CD
18637	24243	13	,	,	,
18637	24243	14	856	856	CD
18637	24243	15	Norris	Norris	NNP
18637	24243	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24243	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24243	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24243	19	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	24243	20	,	,	,
18637	24243	21	294	294	CD
18637	24243	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24243	23	587	587	CD
18637	24243	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24243	25	1935	1935	CD
18637	24243	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24243	27	,	,	,
18637	24243	28	1098	1098	CD
18637	24243	29	North	North	NNP
18637	24243	30	American	American	NNP
18637	24243	31	Cold	Cold	NNP
18637	24243	32	Storage	Storage	NNP
18637	24243	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24243	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24243	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	24243	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24243	37	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	24243	38	,	,	,
18637	24243	39	211	211	CD
18637	24243	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24243	41	306	306	CD
18637	24243	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24243	43	1908	1908	CD
18637	24243	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24243	45	,	,	,
18637	24243	46	1030	1030	CD
18637	24243	47	,	,	,
18637	24243	48	1087	1087	CD
18637	24243	49	North	North	NNP
18637	24243	50	American	American	NNP
18637	24243	51	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24243	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24243	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	24243	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24243	55	S.E.C.	S.E.C.	NNP
18637	24243	56	,	,	,
18637	24243	57	327	327	CD
18637	24243	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24243	59	686	686	CD
18637	24243	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24243	61	1946	1946	CD
18637	24243	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24243	63	,	,	,
18637	24243	64	151	151	CD
18637	24243	65	North	North	NNP
18637	24243	66	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24243	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24243	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	24243	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24243	70	Temple	Temple	NNP
18637	24243	71	,	,	,
18637	24243	72	134	134	CD
18637	24243	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24243	74	22	22	CD
18637	24243	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24243	76	1890	1890	CD
18637	24243	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24243	78	,	,	,
18637	24243	79	933	933	CD
18637	24243	80	North	North	NNP
18637	24243	81	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24243	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24243	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	24243	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24243	85	United	United	NNP
18637	24243	86	States	States	NNP
18637	24243	87	,	,	,
18637	24243	88	325	325	CD
18637	24243	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24243	90	507	507	CD
18637	24243	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24243	92	1945	1945	CD
18637	24243	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24243	94	,	,	,
18637	24243	95	137	137	CD
18637	24243	96	North	North	NNP
18637	24243	97	Laramie	Laramie	NNP
18637	24243	98	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24243	99	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24243	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24243	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	24243	102	_	_	NNP
18637	24243	103	Hoffman	Hoffman	NNP
18637	24243	104	,	,	,
18637	24243	105	268	268	CD
18637	24243	106	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24243	107	276	276	CD
18637	24243	108	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24243	109	1925	1925	CD
18637	24243	110	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24243	111	,	,	,
18637	24243	112	1069	1069	CD
18637	24243	113	North	North	NNP
18637	24243	114	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24243	115	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	24243	116	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24243	117	_	_	NNP
18637	24243	118	v.	v.	IN
18637	24243	119	_	_	NNP
18637	24243	120	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	24243	121	Brothers	Brothers	NNP
18637	24243	122	M.R.	M.R.	NNP
18637	24244	1	&	&	CC
18637	24244	2	S.	S.	NNP
18637	24244	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24244	4	,	,	,
18637	24244	5	249	249	CD
18637	24244	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24244	7	119	119	CD
18637	24244	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24244	9	1919	1919	CD
18637	24244	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24244	11	,	,	,
18637	24244	12	574	574	CD
18637	24244	13	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	24244	14	Assur	Assur	NNP
18637	24244	15	.	.	.
18637	24245	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24245	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24245	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24245	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24245	5	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	24245	6	View	View	NNP
18637	24245	7	Bldg	Bldg	NNP
18637	24245	8	.	.	.
18637	24246	1	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	24246	2	.	.	.
18637	24246	3	,	,	,
18637	24246	4	203	203	CD
18637	24246	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24246	6	106	106	CD
18637	24246	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24246	8	1906	1906	CD
18637	24246	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24246	10	,	,	,
18637	24246	11	685	685	CD
18637	24246	12	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	24246	13	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	24246	14	&	&	CC
18637	24246	15	Dock	Dock	NNP
18637	24246	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24246	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24246	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24246	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24246	20	Strand	Strand	NNP
18637	24246	21	,	,	,
18637	24246	22	278	278	CD
18637	24246	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24246	24	142	142	CD
18637	24246	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24246	26	1928	1928	CD
18637	24246	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24246	28	,	,	,
18637	24246	29	582	582	CD
18637	24246	30	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	24246	31	Pac	Pac	NNP
18637	24246	32	.	.	.
18637	24247	1	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	24248	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24248	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24248	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24248	4	Babcock	Babcock	NNP
18637	24248	5	,	,	,
18637	24248	6	154	154	CD
18637	24248	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24248	8	190	190	CD
18637	24248	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24248	10	1894	1894	CD
18637	24248	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24248	12	,	,	,
18637	24248	13	677	677	CD
18637	24248	14	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	24248	15	Pac	Pac	NNP
18637	24248	16	.	.	.
18637	24249	1	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24249	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24249	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24249	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	24249	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24249	6	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24249	7	,	,	,
18637	24249	8	208	208	CD
18637	24249	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24249	10	583	583	CD
18637	24249	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24249	12	1908	1908	CD
18637	24249	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24249	14	,	,	,
18637	24249	15	345	345	CD
18637	24249	16	Northern	northern	JJ
18637	24249	17	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24250	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24250	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24250	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24250	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24250	5	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	24250	6	,	,	,
18637	24250	7	172	172	CD
18637	24250	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24250	9	589	589	CD
18637	24250	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24250	11	1899	1899	CD
18637	24250	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24250	13	,	,	,
18637	24250	14	732	732	CD
18637	24250	15	Northern	northern	JJ
18637	24250	16	P.R.	p.r.	NN
18637	24251	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24251	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24251	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24251	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24251	5	North	North	NNP
18637	24251	6	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	24251	7	,	,	,
18637	24251	8	250	250	CD
18637	24251	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24251	10	135	135	CD
18637	24251	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24251	12	1919	1919	CD
18637	24251	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24251	14	,	,	,
18637	24251	15	280	280	CD
18637	24251	16	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	24251	17	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	24251	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24251	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24251	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24251	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24251	22	United	United	NNP
18637	24251	23	States	States	NNP
18637	24251	24	,	,	,
18637	24251	25	193	193	CD
18637	24251	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24251	27	197	197	CD
18637	24251	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24251	29	1904	1904	CD
18637	24251	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24251	31	,	,	,
18637	24251	32	147	147	CD
18637	24251	33	,	,	,
18637	24251	34	166	166	CD
18637	24251	35	,	,	,
18637	24251	36	920	920	CD
18637	24251	37	,	,	,
18637	24251	38	981	981	CD
18637	24251	39	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	24251	40	Transp	Transp	NNP
18637	24251	41	.	.	.
18637	24252	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24252	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24252	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24252	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24252	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	24252	6	,	,	,
18637	24252	7	99	99	CD
18637	24252	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24252	9	635	635	CD
18637	24252	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24252	11	1879	1879	CD
18637	24252	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24252	13	,	,	,
18637	24252	14	229	229	CD
18637	24252	15	,	,	,
18637	24252	16	1068	1068	CD
18637	24252	17	Northwest	Northwest	NNP
18637	24252	18	Airlines	Airlines	NNPS
18637	24252	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24252	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24252	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24252	22	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24252	23	,	,	,
18637	24252	24	322	322	CD
18637	24252	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24252	26	292	292	CD
18637	24252	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24252	28	1944	1944	CD
18637	24252	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24252	30	,	,	,
18637	24252	31	210	210	CD
18637	24252	32	,	,	,
18637	24252	33	211	211	CD
18637	24252	34	,	,	,
18637	24252	35	1052	1052	CD
18637	24252	36	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	24252	37	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	24252	38	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	24252	39	.	.	.
18637	24253	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24253	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24253	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24253	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24253	5	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	24253	6	State	State	NNP
18637	24253	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24254	1	Com	Com	NNP
18637	24254	2	.	.	NNP
18637	24254	3	,	,	,
18637	24254	4	297	297	CD
18637	24254	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24254	6	471	471	CD
18637	24254	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24254	8	1936	1936	CD
18637	24254	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24254	10	,	,	,
18637	24254	11	232	232	CD
18637	24254	12	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	24254	13	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	24254	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24254	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24254	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24254	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24254	18	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24254	19	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24254	20	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24254	21	,	,	,
18637	24254	22	321	321	CD
18637	24254	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24254	24	119	119	CD
18637	24254	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24254	26	1944	1944	CD
18637	24254	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24254	28	,	,	,
18637	24254	29	860	860	CD
18637	24254	30	,	,	,
18637	24254	31	921	921	CD
18637	24254	32	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	24254	33	Laundry	Laundry	NNP
18637	24254	34	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24254	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24254	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24254	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24254	38	Des	Des	NNP
18637	24254	39	Moines	Moines	NNP
18637	24254	40	,	,	,
18637	24254	41	239	239	CD
18637	24254	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24254	43	486	486	CD
18637	24254	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24254	45	1916	1916	CD
18637	24254	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24254	47	,	,	,
18637	24254	48	1028	1028	CD
18637	24254	49	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	24254	50	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	24254	51	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24254	52	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24254	53	.	.	.
18637	24255	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24255	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24255	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24255	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24255	5	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	24255	6	,	,	,
18637	24255	7	247	247	CD
18637	24255	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24255	9	132	132	CD
18637	24255	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24255	11	1918	1918	CD
18637	24255	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24255	13	,	,	,
18637	24255	14	1148	1148	CD
18637	24255	15	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	24255	16	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	24255	17	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24255	18	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24255	19	.	.	.
18637	24256	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24256	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24256	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24256	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24256	5	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	24256	6	,	,	,
18637	24256	7	275	275	CD
18637	24256	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24256	9	136	136	CD
18637	24256	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24256	11	1927	1927	CD
18637	24256	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24256	13	,	,	,
18637	24256	14	730	730	CD
18637	24256	15	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	24256	16	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	24256	17	.	.	.
18637	24257	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24257	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24257	3	.	.	.
18637	24258	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24258	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24258	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24258	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24258	5	Riggs	Riggs	NNP
18637	24258	6	,	,	,
18637	24258	7	203	203	CD
18637	24258	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24258	9	243	243	CD
18637	24258	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24258	11	1906	1906	CD
18637	24258	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24258	13	,	,	,
18637	24258	14	809	809	CD
18637	24258	15	,	,	,
18637	24258	16	981	981	CD
18637	24258	17	,	,	,
18637	24258	18	1023	1023	CD
18637	24258	19	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	24258	20	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24258	21	Packet	Packet	NNP
18637	24258	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24258	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24258	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24258	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24258	26	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24258	27	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24258	28	,	,	,
18637	24258	29	100	100	CD
18637	24258	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24258	31	423	423	CD
18637	24258	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24258	33	1880	1880	CD
18637	24258	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24258	35	,	,	,
18637	24258	36	366	366	CD
18637	24258	37	Norton	Norton	NNP
18637	24258	38	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24258	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24258	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24258	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24258	42	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	24258	43	.	.	.
18637	24259	1	of	of	IN
18637	24259	2	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	24259	3	,	,	,
18637	24259	4	340	340	CD
18637	24259	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24259	6	534	534	CD
18637	24259	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24259	8	1951	1951	CD
18637	24259	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24259	10	,	,	,
18637	24259	11	192	192	CD
18637	24259	12	Nortz	Nortz	NNP
18637	24259	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24259	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24259	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24259	16	United	United	NNP
18637	24259	17	States	States	NNP
18637	24259	18	,	,	,
18637	24259	19	294	294	CD
18637	24259	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24259	21	317	317	CD
18637	24259	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24259	23	1935	1935	CD
18637	24259	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24259	25	,	,	,
18637	24259	26	266	266	CD
18637	24259	27	Nutting	Nutting	NNP
18637	24259	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24259	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24259	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24259	31	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24259	32	,	,	,
18637	24259	33	185	185	CD
18637	24259	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24259	35	553	553	CD
18637	24259	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24259	37	1902	1902	CD
18637	24259	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24259	39	,	,	,
18637	24259	40	1021	1021	CD
18637	24259	41	Nye	Nye	NNP
18637	24259	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24259	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24259	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24259	45	United	United	NNP
18637	24259	46	States	States	NNP
18637	24259	47	,	,	,
18637	24259	48	313	313	CD
18637	24259	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24259	50	33	33	CD
18637	24259	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24259	52	1941	1941	CD
18637	24259	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24259	54	,	,	,
18637	24259	55	517	517	CD
18637	24259	56	,	,	,
18637	24259	57	784	784	CD
18637	24259	58	O	o	NN
18637	24259	59	O'Brien	O'Brien	NNP
18637	24259	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24259	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	24259	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24259	63	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24259	64	,	,	,
18637	24259	65	168	168	CD
18637	24259	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24259	67	287	287	CD
18637	24259	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24259	69	1897	1897	CD
18637	24259	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24259	71	,	,	,
18637	24259	72	574	574	CD
18637	24259	73	Oceanic	Oceanic	NNP
18637	24259	74	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	24259	75	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	24259	76	.	.	.
18637	24260	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24260	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24260	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24260	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24260	5	Stranahan	Stranahan	NNP
18637	24260	6	,	,	,
18637	24260	7	214	214	CD
18637	24260	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24260	9	320	320	CD
18637	24260	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24260	11	1909	1909	CD
18637	24260	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24260	13	,	,	,
18637	24260	14	852	852	CD
18637	24260	15	,	,	,
18637	24260	16	878	878	CD
18637	24260	17	Ochoa	Ochoa	NNP
18637	24260	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24260	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24260	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24260	21	Hernandez	Hernandez	NNP
18637	24260	22	Y	Y	NNP
18637	24260	23	Morales	Morales	NNPS
18637	24260	24	,	,	,
18637	24260	25	230	230	CD
18637	24260	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24260	27	139	139	CD
18637	24260	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24260	29	1913	1913	CD
18637	24260	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24260	31	,	,	,
18637	24260	32	856	856	CD
18637	24260	33	Octavia	Octavia	NNP
18637	24260	34	,	,	,
18637	24260	35	The	the	DT
18637	24260	36	,	,	,
18637	24260	37	1	1	CD
18637	24260	38	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24260	39	.	.	.
18637	24261	1	20	20	CD
18637	24261	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24261	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	24261	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24261	5	,	,	,
18637	24261	6	573	573	CD
18637	24261	7	O'Donnell	O'Donnell	NNP
18637	24261	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24261	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24261	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24261	11	Great	Great	NNP
18637	24261	12	Lakes	Lakes	NNP
18637	24261	13	Dredge	Dredge	NNP
18637	24261	14	&	&	CC
18637	24261	15	Dock	Dock	NNP
18637	24261	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24261	17	,	,	,
18637	24261	18	318	318	CD
18637	24261	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24261	20	36	36	CD
18637	24261	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24261	22	1943	1943	CD
18637	24261	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24261	24	,	,	,
18637	24261	25	130	130	CD
18637	24261	26	,	,	,
18637	24261	27	583	583	CD
18637	24261	28	O'Donoghue	O'Donoghue	NNP
18637	24261	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24261	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24261	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24261	32	United	United	NNP
18637	24261	33	States	States	NNP
18637	24261	34	,	,	,
18637	24261	35	289	289	CD
18637	24261	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24261	37	516	516	CD
18637	24261	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24261	39	1933	1933	CD
18637	24261	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24261	41	,	,	,
18637	24261	42	303	303	CD
18637	24261	43	,	,	,
18637	24261	44	305	305	CD
18637	24261	45	,	,	,
18637	24261	46	531	531	CD
18637	24261	47	,	,	,
18637	24261	48	537	537	CD
18637	24261	49	Oetjen	Oetjen	NNP
18637	24261	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24261	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	24261	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24261	53	Central	Central	NNP
18637	24261	54	Leather	Leather	NNP
18637	24261	55	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24261	56	,	,	,
18637	24261	57	246	246	CD
18637	24261	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24261	59	297	297	CD
18637	24261	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24261	61	1918	1918	CD
18637	24261	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24261	63	,	,	,
18637	24261	64	439	439	CD
18637	24261	65	,	,	,
18637	24261	66	473	473	CD
18637	24261	67	,	,	,
18637	24261	68	474	474	CD
18637	24261	69	Offield	Offield	NNP
18637	24261	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24261	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	24261	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24261	73	New	New	NNP
18637	24261	74	York	York	NNP
18637	24261	75	,	,	,
18637	24261	76	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	24261	77	&	&	CC
18637	24261	78	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	24262	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24262	2	,	,	,
18637	24262	3	203	203	CD
18637	24262	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24262	5	372	372	CD
18637	24262	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24262	7	1906	1906	CD
18637	24262	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24262	9	,	,	,
18637	24262	10	1063	1063	CD
18637	24262	11	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	24262	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24262	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24262	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24262	15	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
18637	24262	16	,	,	,
18637	24262	17	12	12	CD
18637	24262	18	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24262	19	.	.	.
18637	24263	1	213	213	CD
18637	24263	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24263	3	1827	1827	CD
18637	24263	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24263	5	,	,	,
18637	24263	6	264	264	CD
18637	24263	7	,	,	,
18637	24263	8	265	265	CD
18637	24263	9	,	,	,
18637	24263	10	334	334	CD
18637	24263	11	,	,	,
18637	24263	12	353	353	CD
18637	24263	13	,	,	,
18637	24263	14	563	563	CD
18637	24263	15	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
18637	24263	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24263	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24263	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24263	19	Witherspoon	Witherspoon	NNP
18637	24263	20	,	,	,
18637	24263	21	18	18	CD
18637	24263	22	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24263	23	.	.	.
18637	24264	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24264	2	.	.	.
18637	24265	1	No	no	UH
18637	24265	2	.	.	.
18637	24266	1	10	10	CD
18637	24266	2	,	,	,
18637	24266	3	461	461	CD
18637	24266	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24266	5	1802	1802	CD
18637	24266	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24266	7	,	,	,
18637	24266	8	560	560	CD
18637	24266	9	O'Gorman	O'Gorman	NNP
18637	24266	10	&	&	CC
18637	24266	11	Young	Young	NNP
18637	24266	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24266	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24266	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24266	15	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
18637	24266	16	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24266	17	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24266	18	.	.	.
18637	24267	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24267	2	,	,	,
18637	24267	3	282	282	CD
18637	24267	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24267	5	251	251	CD
18637	24267	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24267	7	1931	1931	CD
18637	24267	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24267	9	996	996	CD
18637	24267	10	,	,	,
18637	24267	11	1021	1021	CD
18637	24267	12	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24267	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24267	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24267	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24267	16	Chattanooga	Chattanooga	NNP
18637	24267	17	Boiler	Boiler	NNP
18637	24267	18	&	&	CC
18637	24267	19	Tank	Tank	NNP
18637	24267	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24267	21	,	,	,
18637	24267	22	289	289	CD
18637	24267	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24267	24	439	439	CD
18637	24267	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24267	26	1933	1933	CD
18637	24267	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24267	28	,	,	,
18637	24267	29	655	655	CD
18637	24267	30	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24267	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24267	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24267	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24267	34	Helvering	Helvering	NNP
18637	24267	35	,	,	,
18637	24267	36	292	292	CD
18637	24267	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24267	38	360	360	CD
18637	24267	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24267	40	1934	1934	CD
18637	24267	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24267	42	,	,	,
18637	24267	43	107	107	CD
18637	24267	44	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24267	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24267	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	24267	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24267	48	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	24267	49	,	,	,
18637	24267	50	173	173	CD
18637	24267	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24267	52	276	276	CD
18637	24267	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24267	54	1899	1899	CD
18637	24267	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24267	56	,	,	,
18637	24267	57	633	633	CD
18637	24267	58	,	,	,
18637	24267	59	724	724	CD
18637	24267	60	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24267	61	ex	ex	JJ
18637	24267	62	rel	rel	NN
18637	24267	63	.	.	.
18637	24268	1	Bryant	Bryant	NNP
18637	24268	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24268	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24268	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24268	5	Akron	Akron	NNP
18637	24268	6	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
18637	24268	7	Park	Park	NNP
18637	24268	8	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	24268	9	.	.	NNP
18637	24268	10	,	,	,
18637	24268	11	281	281	CD
18637	24268	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24268	13	74	74	CD
18637	24268	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24268	15	1930	1930	CD
18637	24268	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24268	17	,	,	,
18637	24268	18	704	704	CD
18637	24268	19	,	,	,
18637	24268	20	705	705	CD
18637	24268	21	,	,	,
18637	24268	22	1072	1072	CD
18637	24268	23	,	,	,
18637	24268	24	1166	1166	CD
18637	24268	25	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24268	26	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24268	27	rel	rel	NN
18637	24268	28	.	.	.
18637	24269	1	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	24269	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24269	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24269	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24269	5	Deckebach	Deckebach	NNP
18637	24269	6	,	,	,
18637	24269	7	274	274	CD
18637	24269	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24269	9	392	392	CD
18637	24269	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24269	11	1927	1927	CD
18637	24269	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24269	13	,	,	,
18637	24269	14	1158	1158	CD
18637	24269	15	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24269	16	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24269	17	rel	rel	NN
18637	24269	18	.	.	.
18637	24270	1	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	24270	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24270	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24270	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24270	5	Hildebrant	Hildebrant	NNP
18637	24270	6	,	,	,
18637	24270	7	241	241	CD
18637	24270	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24270	9	565	565	CD
18637	24270	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24270	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	24270	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24270	13	,	,	,
18637	24270	14	93	93	CD
18637	24270	15	,	,	,
18637	24270	16	705	705	CD
18637	24270	17	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24270	18	ex	ex	JJ
18637	24270	19	rel	rel	NN
18637	24270	20	.	.	.
18637	24271	1	Lloyd	Lloyd	NNP
18637	24271	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24271	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24271	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24271	5	Dollison	Dollison	NNP
18637	24271	6	,	,	,
18637	24271	7	194	194	CD
18637	24271	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24271	9	445	445	CD
18637	24271	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24271	11	1904	1904	CD
18637	24271	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24271	13	,	,	,
18637	24271	14	1155	1155	CD
18637	24271	15	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24271	16	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24271	17	rel	rel	NN
18637	24271	18	.	.	.
18637	24272	1	Popovici	Popovici	NNP
18637	24272	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24272	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24272	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24272	5	Agler	Agler	NNP
18637	24272	6	,	,	,
18637	24272	7	280	280	CD
18637	24272	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24272	9	379	379	CD
18637	24272	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24272	11	1930	1930	CD
18637	24272	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24272	13	,	,	,
18637	24272	14	571	571	CD
18637	24272	15	,	,	,
18637	24272	16	613	613	CD
18637	24272	17	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24272	18	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24272	19	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	24272	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24272	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24272	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	24272	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24272	24	Debolt	Debolt	NNP
18637	24272	25	,	,	,
18637	24272	26	16	16	CD
18637	24272	27	How	how	WRB
18637	24272	28	.	.	.
18637	24273	1	416	416	CD
18637	24273	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24273	3	1854	1854	CD
18637	24273	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24273	5	,	,	,
18637	24273	6	330	330	CD
18637	24273	7	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24273	8	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24273	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24273	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24273	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24273	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24273	13	Conway	Conway	NNP
18637	24273	14	,	,	,
18637	24273	15	281	281	CD
18637	24273	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24273	17	146	146	CD
18637	24273	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24273	19	1930	1930	CD
18637	24273	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24273	21	,	,	,
18637	24273	22	1148	1148	CD
18637	24273	23	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24273	24	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24273	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24273	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24273	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24273	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24273	29	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	24273	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24273	31	No	no	UH
18637	24273	32	.	.	.
18637	24274	1	1	1	LS
18637	24274	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24274	3	,	,	,
18637	24274	4	177	177	CD
18637	24274	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24274	6	190	190	CD
18637	24274	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24274	8	1900	1900	CD
18637	24274	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24274	10	,	,	,
18637	24274	11	1025	1025	CD
18637	24274	12	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24274	13	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24274	14	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	24274	15	,	,	,
18637	24274	16	232	232	CD
18637	24274	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24274	18	576	576	CD
18637	24274	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24274	20	1914	1914	CD
18637	24274	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24274	22	,	,	,
18637	24274	23	1148	1148	CD
18637	24274	24	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24274	25	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	24274	26	Water	Water	NNP
18637	24274	27	Company	Company	NNP
18637	24274	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24274	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24274	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24274	31	Ben	Ben	NNP
18637	24274	32	Avon	Avon	NNP
18637	24274	33	Borough	Borough	NNP
18637	24274	34	,	,	,
18637	24274	35	253	253	CD
18637	24274	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24274	37	287	287	CD
18637	24274	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24274	39	1920	1920	CD
18637	24274	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24274	41	,	,	,
18637	24274	42	1003	1003	CD
18637	24274	43	Okanogan	Okanogan	NNP
18637	24274	44	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	24274	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24274	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	24274	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24274	48	United	United	NNP
18637	24274	49	States	States	NNP
18637	24274	50	,	,	,
18637	24274	51	279	279	CD
18637	24274	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24274	53	655	655	CD
18637	24274	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24274	55	1929	1929	CD
18637	24274	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24274	57	,	,	,
18637	24274	58	103	103	CD
18637	24274	59	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24274	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24274	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	24274	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24274	63	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	24274	64	,	,	,
18637	24274	65	Topeka	Topeka	NNP
18637	24274	66	&	&	CC
18637	24274	67	Santa	Santa	NNP
18637	24274	68	Fe	Fe	NNP
18637	24274	69	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24274	70	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24274	71	,	,	,
18637	24274	72	220	220	CD
18637	24274	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24274	74	277	277	CD
18637	24274	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24274	76	1911	1911	CD
18637	24274	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24274	78	,	,	,
18637	24274	79	594	594	CD
18637	24274	80	,	,	,
18637	24274	81	596	596	CD
18637	24274	82	,	,	,
18637	24274	83	597	597	CD
18637	24274	84	,	,	,
18637	24274	85	598	598	CD
18637	24274	86	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24274	87	_	_	NNP
18637	24274	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	24274	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24274	90	Atkinson	Atkinson	NNP
18637	24274	91	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24274	92	,	,	,
18637	24274	93	313	313	CD
18637	24274	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24274	95	508	508	CD
18637	24274	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24274	97	1941	1941	CD
18637	24274	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24274	99	,	,	,
18637	24274	100	865	865	CD
18637	24274	101	,	,	,
18637	24274	102	868	868	CD
18637	24274	103	,	,	,
18637	24274	104	920	920	CD
18637	24274	105	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24274	106	_	_	NNP
18637	24274	107	v.	v.	IN
18637	24274	108	_	_	NNP
18637	24274	109	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24274	110	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	24274	111	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24274	112	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24274	113	,	,	,
18637	24274	114	221	221	CD
18637	24274	115	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24274	116	229	229	CD
18637	24274	117	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24274	118	1911	1911	CD
18637	24274	119	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24274	120	,	,	,
18637	24274	121	243	243	CD
18637	24274	122	,	,	,
18637	24274	123	245	245	CD
18637	24274	124	,	,	,
18637	24274	125	1025	1025	CD
18637	24274	126	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24274	127	_	_	NNP
18637	24274	128	v.	v.	IN
18637	24274	129	_	_	NNP
18637	24274	130	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24274	131	,	,	,
18637	24274	132	258	258	CD
18637	24274	133	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24274	134	574	574	CD
18637	24274	135	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24274	136	1922	1922	CD
18637	24274	137	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24274	138	,	,	,
18637	24274	139	703	703	CD
18637	24274	140	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24274	141	_	_	NNP
18637	24274	142	v.	v.	IN
18637	24274	143	_	_	NNP
18637	24274	144	United	United	NNP
18637	24274	145	States	States	NNP
18637	24274	146	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	24274	147	Service	Service	NNP
18637	24274	148	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24274	149	,	,	,
18637	24274	150	330	330	CD
18637	24274	151	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24274	152	127	127	CD
18637	24274	153	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24274	154	1947	1947	CD
18637	24274	155	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24274	156	,	,	,
18637	24274	157	116	116	CD
18637	24274	158	,	,	,
18637	24274	159	794	794	CD
18637	24274	160	,	,	,
18637	24274	161	920	920	CD
18637	24274	162	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24274	163	ex	ex	NN
18637	24274	164	rel	rel	NN
18637	24274	165	.	.	.
18637	24275	1	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	24275	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24275	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24275	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24275	5	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	24275	6	,	,	,
18637	24275	7	304	304	CD
18637	24275	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24275	9	387	387	CD
18637	24275	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24275	11	1938	1938	CD
18637	24275	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24275	13	,	,	,
18637	24275	14	594	594	CD
18637	24275	15	,	,	,
18637	24275	16	596	596	CD
18637	24275	17	,	,	,
18637	24275	18	597	597	CD
18637	24275	19	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24275	20	ex	ex	NN
18637	24275	21	rel	rel	NN
18637	24275	22	.	.	.
18637	24276	1	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	24276	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24276	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24276	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24276	5	Atkinson	Atkinson	NNP
18637	24276	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24276	7	,	,	,
18637	24276	8	313	313	CD
18637	24276	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24276	10	508	508	CD
18637	24276	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24276	12	1941	1941	CD
18637	24276	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24276	14	,	,	,
18637	24276	15	132	132	CD
18637	24276	16	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24276	17	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24276	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24276	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24276	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24276	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24276	22	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	24276	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24276	24	,	,	,
18637	24276	25	292	292	CD
18637	24276	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24276	27	386	386	CD
18637	24276	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24276	29	1934	1934	CD
18637	24276	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24276	31	,	,	,
18637	24276	32	631	631	CD
18637	24276	33	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24276	34	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	24276	35	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24276	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24276	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24276	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24276	39	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24276	40	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24276	41	and	and	CC
18637	24276	42	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	24276	43	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24276	44	,	,	,
18637	24276	45	309	309	CD
18637	24276	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24276	47	4	4	CD
18637	24276	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24276	49	1940	1940	CD
18637	24276	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24276	51	,	,	,
18637	24276	52	524	524	CD
18637	24276	53	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24276	54	Press	Press	NNP
18637	24276	55	Publishing	Publishing	NNP
18637	24276	56	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24276	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24276	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	24276	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24276	60	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	24276	61	,	,	,
18637	24276	62	327	327	CD
18637	24276	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24276	64	186	186	CD
18637	24276	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24276	66	1946	1946	CD
18637	24276	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24276	68	,	,	,
18637	24276	69	521	521	CD
18637	24276	70	,	,	,
18637	24276	71	793	793	CD
18637	24276	72	,	,	,
18637	24276	73	826	826	CD
18637	24276	74	,	,	,
18637	24276	75	827	827	CD
18637	24276	76	,	,	,
18637	24276	77	828	828	CD
18637	24276	78	,	,	,
18637	24276	79	844	844	CD
18637	24276	80	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24276	81	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24276	82	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
18637	24276	83	.	.	.
18637	24277	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24277	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24277	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24277	4	Barnsdall	Barnsdall	NNP
18637	24277	5	Refiners	Refiners	NNPS
18637	24277	6	,	,	,
18637	24277	7	296	296	CD
18637	24277	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24277	9	521	521	CD
18637	24277	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24277	11	1936	1936	CD
18637	24277	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24277	13	,	,	,
18637	24277	14	734	734	CD
18637	24277	15	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24277	16	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24277	17	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
18637	24277	18	.	.	.
18637	24278	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24278	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24278	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24278	4	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24278	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24278	6	,	,	,
18637	24278	7	336	336	CD
18637	24278	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24278	9	342	342	CD
18637	24278	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24278	11	1949	1949	CD
18637	24278	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24278	13	,	,	,
18637	24278	14	734	734	CD
18637	24278	15	Olcott	Olcott	NNP
18637	24278	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24278	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24278	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24278	19	Fond	Fond	NNP
18637	24278	20	du	du	NNP
18637	24278	21	Lac	Lac	NNP
18637	24278	22	County	County	NNP
18637	24278	23	,	,	,
18637	24278	24	16	16	CD
18637	24278	25	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24278	26	.	.	.
18637	24279	1	678	678	CD
18637	24279	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24279	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	24279	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24279	5	,	,	,
18637	24279	6	331	331	CD
18637	24279	7	Old	Old	NNP
18637	24279	8	Colony	Colony	NNP
18637	24279	9	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24279	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24279	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24279	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24279	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24279	14	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	24279	15	of	of	IN
18637	24279	16	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	24279	17	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	24279	18	,	,	,
18637	24279	19	279	279	CD
18637	24279	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24279	21	716	716	CD
18637	24279	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24279	23	1920	1920	CD
18637	24279	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24279	25	,	,	,
18637	24279	26	534	534	CD
18637	24279	27	Old	Old	NNP
18637	24279	28	Colony	Colony	NNP
18637	24279	29	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24279	30	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24279	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24279	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24279	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24279	34	Seattle	Seattle	NNP
18637	24279	35	,	,	,
18637	24279	36	271	271	CD
18637	24279	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24279	38	426	426	CD
18637	24279	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24279	40	1926	1926	CD
18637	24279	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24279	42	,	,	,
18637	24279	43	934	934	CD
18637	24279	44	Old	Old	NNP
18637	24279	45	Dearborn	Dearborn	NNP
18637	24279	46	Distributing	Distributing	NNP
18637	24279	47	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24279	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24279	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	24279	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24279	51	Seagram	Seagram	NNP
18637	24279	52	-	-	HYPH
18637	24279	53	Distillers	Distillers	NNP
18637	24279	54	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24279	55	,	,	,
18637	24279	56	299	299	CD
18637	24279	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24279	58	183	183	CD
18637	24279	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24279	60	1936	1936	CD
18637	24279	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24279	62	,	,	,
18637	24279	63	1018	1018	CD
18637	24279	64	Old	Old	NNP
18637	24279	65	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	24279	66	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24279	67	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24279	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24279	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	24279	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24279	71	United	United	NNP
18637	24279	72	States	States	NNP
18637	24279	73	,	,	,
18637	24279	74	269	269	CD
18637	24279	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24279	76	55	55	CD
18637	24279	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24279	78	1925	1925	CD
18637	24279	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24279	80	,	,	,
18637	24279	81	866	866	CD
18637	24279	82	,	,	,
18637	24279	83	867	867	CD
18637	24279	84	Old	Old	NNP
18637	24279	85	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	24279	86	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	24279	87	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24279	88	_	_	NNP
18637	24279	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	24279	90	_	_	NNP
18637	24279	91	Gilmore	Gilmore	NNP
18637	24279	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24279	93	The	the	DT
18637	24279	94	"	"	``
18637	24279	95	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	24279	96	"	"	''
18637	24279	97	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24279	98	,	,	,
18637	24279	99	207	207	CD
18637	24279	100	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24279	101	398	398	CD
18637	24279	102	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24279	103	1907	1907	CD
18637	24279	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24279	105	,	,	,
18637	24279	106	130	130	CD
18637	24279	107	,	,	,
18637	24279	108	575	575	CD
18637	24279	109	,	,	,
18637	24279	110	579	579	CD
18637	24279	111	Old	Old	NNP
18637	24279	112	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
18637	24279	113	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	24279	114	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24279	115	_	_	NNP
18637	24279	116	v.	v.	IN
18637	24279	117	_	_	NNP
18637	24279	118	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24279	119	,	,	,
18637	24279	120	198	198	CD
18637	24279	121	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24279	122	299	299	CD
18637	24279	123	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24279	124	1905	1905	CD
18637	24279	125	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24279	126	,	,	,
18637	24279	127	210	210	CD
18637	24279	128	,	,	,
18637	24279	129	1052	1052	CD
18637	24279	130	Old	Old	NNP
18637	24279	131	Wayne	Wayne	NNP
18637	24279	132	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24279	133	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	24279	134	.	.	.
18637	24280	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	4	McDonough	McDonough	NNP
18637	24280	5	,	,	,
18637	24280	6	204	204	CD
18637	24280	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	8	8	8	CD
18637	24280	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	10	1907	1907	CD
18637	24280	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	12	,	,	,
18637	24280	13	659	659	CD
18637	24280	14	,	,	,
18637	24280	15	1076	1076	CD
18637	24280	16	Olin	Olin	NNP
18637	24280	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	20	Kitzmiller	Kitzmiller	NNP
18637	24280	21	,	,	,
18637	24280	22	259	259	CD
18637	24280	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	24	260	260	CD
18637	24280	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	26	1922	1922	CD
18637	24280	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	28	,	,	,
18637	24280	29	370	370	CD
18637	24280	30	Oliver	Oliver	NNP
18637	24280	31	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	24280	32	Company	Company	NNP
18637	24280	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	36	Lord	Lord	NNP
18637	24280	37	,	,	,
18637	24280	38	262	262	CD
18637	24280	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	40	172	172	CD
18637	24280	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	42	1923	1923	CD
18637	24280	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	44	,	,	,
18637	24280	45	120	120	CD
18637	24280	46	,	,	,
18637	24280	47	181	181	CD
18637	24280	48	Oliver	Oliver	NNP
18637	24280	49	,	,	,
18637	24280	50	In	in	IN
18637	24280	51	re	re	NN
18637	24280	52	,	,	,
18637	24280	53	333	333	CD
18637	24280	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	55	257	257	CD
18637	24280	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	57	1948	1948	CD
18637	24280	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	59	,	,	,
18637	24280	60	1130	1130	CD
18637	24280	61	Olmstead	Olmstead	NNP
18637	24280	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	65	United	United	NNP
18637	24280	66	States	States	NNP
18637	24280	67	,	,	,
18637	24280	68	277	277	CD
18637	24280	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	70	438	438	CD
18637	24280	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	72	1928	1928	CD
18637	24280	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	74	,	,	,
18637	24280	75	824	824	CD
18637	24280	76	Olmsted	Olmsted	NNP
18637	24280	77	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	79	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	80	Olmsted	Olmsted	NNP
18637	24280	81	,	,	,
18637	24280	82	216	216	CD
18637	24280	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	84	386	386	CD
18637	24280	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	86	1910	1910	CD
18637	24280	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	88	,	,	,
18637	24280	89	673	673	CD
18637	24280	90	Olsen	Olsen	NNP
18637	24280	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	93	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	94	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
18637	24280	95	,	,	,
18637	24280	96	313	313	CD
18637	24280	97	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	98	236	236	CD
18637	24280	99	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	100	1941	1941	CD
18637	24280	101	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	102	,	,	,
18637	24280	103	997	997	CD
18637	24280	104	,	,	,
18637	24280	105	1023	1023	CD
18637	24280	106	Olsen	Olsen	NNP
18637	24280	107	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	109	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	110	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24280	111	,	,	,
18637	24280	112	195	195	CD
18637	24280	113	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	114	332	332	CD
18637	24280	115	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	116	1904	1904	CD
18637	24280	117	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	118	,	,	,
18637	24280	119	1024	1024	CD
18637	24280	120	Olson	Olson	NNP
18637	24280	121	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	122	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	123	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	124	United	United	NNP
18637	24280	125	States	States	NNP
18637	24280	126	,	,	,
18637	24280	127	292	292	CD
18637	24280	128	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	129	246	246	CD
18637	24280	130	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	131	1934	1934	CD
18637	24280	132	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	133	,	,	,
18637	24280	134	870	870	CD
18637	24280	135	Omaechevarria	Omaechevarria	NNP
18637	24280	136	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	137	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	138	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	139	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
18637	24280	140	,	,	,
18637	24280	141	246	246	CD
18637	24280	142	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	143	343	343	CD
18637	24280	144	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	145	1918	1918	CD
18637	24280	146	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	147	,	,	,
18637	24280	148	1154	1154	CD
18637	24280	149	O'Malley	O'Malley	NNP
18637	24280	150	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	151	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	152	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	153	Woodrough	Woodrough	NNP
18637	24280	154	,	,	,
18637	24280	155	307	307	CD
18637	24280	156	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	157	277	277	CD
18637	24280	158	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	159	1939	1939	CD
18637	24280	160	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	161	,	,	,
18637	24280	162	106	106	CD
18637	24280	163	,	,	,
18637	24280	164	530	530	CD
18637	24280	165	Omnia	Omnia	NNP
18637	24280	166	Commercial	Commercial	NNP
18637	24280	167	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24280	168	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	169	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	170	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	171	United	United	NNP
18637	24280	172	States	States	NNP
18637	24280	173	,	,	,
18637	24280	174	261	261	CD
18637	24280	175	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	176	502	502	CD
18637	24280	177	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	178	1923	1923	CD
18637	24280	179	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	180	,	,	,
18637	24280	181	867	867	CD
18637	24280	182	O'Neil	O'Neil	NNP
18637	24280	183	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	184	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	185	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	186	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	24280	187	,	,	,
18637	24280	188	144	144	CD
18637	24280	189	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	190	323	323	CD
18637	24280	191	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	192	1892	1892	CD
18637	24280	193	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	194	,	,	,
18637	24280	195	752	752	CD
18637	24280	196	,	,	,
18637	24280	197	904	904	CD
18637	24280	198	O'Neill	O'Neill	NNP
18637	24280	199	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	200	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	201	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	202	Leamer	Leamer	NNP
18637	24280	203	,	,	,
18637	24280	204	239	239	CD
18637	24280	205	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	206	244	244	CD
18637	24280	207	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	208	1915	1915	CD
18637	24280	209	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	210	,	,	,
18637	24280	211	705	705	CD
18637	24280	212	Ontario	Ontario	NNP
18637	24280	213	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24280	214	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24280	215	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	216	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	217	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	218	Yordy	Yordy	NNP
18637	24280	219	,	,	,
18637	24280	220	212	212	CD
18637	24280	221	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	222	152	152	CD
18637	24280	223	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	224	1909	1909	CD
18637	24280	225	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	226	,	,	,
18637	24280	227	1060	1060	CD
18637	24280	228	Opp	Opp	NNP
18637	24280	229	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	24280	230	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	24280	231	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	232	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	233	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	234	Administrator	Administrator	NNP
18637	24280	235	,	,	,
18637	24280	236	312	312	CD
18637	24280	237	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	238	126	126	CD
18637	24280	239	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	240	1941	1941	CD
18637	24280	241	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	242	,	,	,
18637	24280	243	75	75	CD
18637	24280	244	,	,	,
18637	24280	245	81	81	CD
18637	24280	246	,	,	,
18637	24280	247	849	849	CD
18637	24280	248	Order	order	NN
18637	24280	249	of	of	IN
18637	24280	250	Travelers	Travelers	NNPS
18637	24280	251	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	252	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	253	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	254	Wolfe	Wolfe	NNP
18637	24280	255	,	,	,
18637	24280	256	331	331	CD
18637	24280	257	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	258	586	586	CD
18637	24280	259	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	260	1947	1947	CD
18637	24280	261	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	262	,	,	,
18637	24280	263	679	679	CD
18637	24280	264	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24280	265	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	266	v.	v.	IN
18637	24280	267	_	_	NNP
18637	24280	268	Hitchcock	Hitchcock	NNP
18637	24280	269	,	,	,
18637	24280	270	202	202	CD
18637	24280	271	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24280	272	60	60	CD
18637	24280	273	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24280	274	1906	1906	CD
18637	24280	275	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24280	276	,	,	,
18637	24280	277	588	588	CD
18637	24280	278	,	,	,
18637	24280	279	590	590	CD
18637	24280	280	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24280	281	&	&	CC
18637	24280	282	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	24281	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24281	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24281	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24281	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24281	5	United	United	NNP
18637	24281	6	States	States	NNP
18637	24281	7	,	,	,
18637	24281	8	243	243	CD
18637	24281	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24281	10	549	549	CD
18637	24281	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24281	12	1917	1917	CD
18637	24281	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24281	14	,	,	,
18637	24281	15	857	857	CD
18637	24281	16	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24281	17	Short	Short	NNP
18637	24281	18	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24281	19	&	&	CC
18637	24281	20	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	24281	21	N.	N.	NNP
18637	24281	22	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	24281	23	.	.	.
18637	24282	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24282	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24282	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24282	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24282	5	Skottowe	Skottowe	NNP
18637	24282	6	,	,	,
18637	24282	7	162	162	CD
18637	24282	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24282	9	490	490	CD
18637	24282	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24282	11	1896	1896	CD
18637	24282	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24282	13	,	,	,
18637	24282	14	567	567	CD
18637	24282	15	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24282	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	24282	17	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24282	18	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24282	19	&	&	CC
18637	24282	20	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	24282	21	.	.	.
18637	24283	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24283	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24283	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24283	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24283	5	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24283	6	,	,	,
18637	24283	7	270	270	CD
18637	24283	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24283	9	87	87	CD
18637	24283	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24283	11	1926	1926	CD
18637	24283	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24283	13	,	,	,
18637	24283	14	249	249	CD
18637	24283	15	Orient	Orient	NNP
18637	24283	16	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24283	17	.	.	.
18637	24284	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24284	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24284	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24284	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24284	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24284	6	of	of	IN
18637	24284	7	Assessors	Assessors	NNPS
18637	24284	8	,	,	,
18637	24284	9	221	221	CD
18637	24284	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24284	11	358	358	CD
18637	24284	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24284	13	1911	1911	CD
18637	24284	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24284	15	,	,	,
18637	24284	16	1056	1056	CD
18637	24284	17	Orient	Orient	NNP
18637	24284	18	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24284	19	.	.	.
18637	24285	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24285	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24285	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24285	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24285	5	Daggs	Daggs	NNP
18637	24285	6	,	,	,
18637	24285	7	172	172	CD
18637	24285	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24285	9	557	557	CD
18637	24285	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24285	11	1899	1899	CD
18637	24285	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24285	13	,	,	,
18637	24285	14	965	965	CD
18637	24285	15	,	,	,
18637	24285	16	1022	1022	CD
18637	24285	17	,	,	,
18637	24285	18	1145	1145	CD
18637	24285	19	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24285	20	,	,	,
18637	24285	21	The	the	DT
18637	24285	22	,	,	,
18637	24285	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24285	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24285	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24285	26	Phoebus	Phoebus	NNP
18637	24285	27	,	,	,
18637	24285	28	11	11	CD
18637	24285	29	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24285	30	.	.	.
18637	24286	1	175	175	CD
18637	24286	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24286	3	1837	1837	CD
18637	24286	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24286	5	,	,	,
18637	24286	6	578	578	CD
18637	24286	7	Orr	Orr	NNP
18637	24286	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24286	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24286	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24286	11	Gilman	Gilman	NNP
18637	24286	12	,	,	,
18637	24286	13	183	183	CD
18637	24286	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24286	15	278	278	CD
18637	24286	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24286	17	1902	1902	CD
18637	24286	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24286	19	,	,	,
18637	24286	20	327	327	CD
18637	24286	21	,	,	,
18637	24286	22	1038	1038	CD
18637	24286	23	Orr	Orr	NNP
18637	24286	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24286	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24286	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24286	27	Hodgson	Hodgson	NNP
18637	24286	28	,	,	,
18637	24286	29	4	4	CD
18637	24286	30	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24286	31	.	.	.
18637	24287	1	458	458	CD
18637	24287	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24287	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	24287	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24287	5	,	,	,
18637	24287	6	416	416	CD
18637	24287	7	Orton	Orton	NNP
18637	24287	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24287	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24287	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24287	11	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24287	12	,	,	,
18637	24287	13	18	18	CD
18637	24287	14	How	how	WRB
18637	24287	15	.	.	.
18637	24288	1	263	263	CD
18637	24288	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24288	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	24288	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24288	5	,	,	,
18637	24288	6	627	627	CD
18637	24288	7	,	,	,
18637	24288	8	628	628	CD
18637	24288	9	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	24288	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24288	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24288	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24288	13	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24288	14	of	of	IN
18637	24288	15	the	the	DT
18637	24288	16	United	United	NNP
18637	24288	17	States	States	NNP
18637	24288	18	,	,	,
18637	24288	19	9	9	CD
18637	24288	20	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24288	21	.	.	.
18637	24289	1	738	738	CD
18637	24289	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24289	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	24289	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24289	5	,	,	,
18637	24289	6	257	257	CD
18637	24289	7	,	,	,
18637	24289	8	267	267	CD
18637	24289	9	,	,	,
18637	24289	10	309	309	CD
18637	24289	11	,	,	,
18637	24289	12	538	538	CD
18637	24289	13	,	,	,
18637	24289	14	561	561	CD
18637	24289	15	,	,	,
18637	24289	16	568	568	CD
18637	24289	17	,	,	,
18637	24289	18	629	629	CD
18637	24289	19	,	,	,
18637	24289	20	728	728	CD
18637	24289	21	,	,	,
18637	24289	22	730	730	CD
18637	24289	23	,	,	,
18637	24289	24	929	929	CD
18637	24289	25	,	,	,
18637	24289	26	931	931	CD
18637	24289	27	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
18637	24289	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24289	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24289	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24289	31	Ozlin	Ozlin	NNP
18637	24289	32	,	,	,
18637	24289	33	310	310	CD
18637	24289	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24289	35	53	53	CD
18637	24289	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24289	37	1940	1940	CD
18637	24289	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24289	39	,	,	,
18637	24289	40	1021	1021	CD
18637	24289	41	Osborne	Osborne	NNP
18637	24289	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24289	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24289	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24289	45	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	24289	46	,	,	,
18637	24289	47	164	164	CD
18637	24289	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24289	49	650	650	CD
18637	24289	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24289	51	1897	1897	CD
18637	24289	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24289	53	,	,	,
18637	24289	54	196	196	CD
18637	24289	55	Osborne	Osborne	NNP
18637	24289	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24289	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24289	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24289	59	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	24289	60	,	,	,
18637	24289	61	16	16	CD
18637	24289	62	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24289	63	.	.	.
18637	24290	1	479	479	CD
18637	24290	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24290	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	24290	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24290	5	,	,	,
18637	24290	6	366	366	CD
18637	24290	7	Oshkosh	Oshkosh	NNP
18637	24290	8	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	24290	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24290	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24290	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24290	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24290	13	Oshkosh	Oshkosh	NNP
18637	24290	14	,	,	,
18637	24290	15	187	187	CD
18637	24290	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24290	17	437	437	CD
18637	24290	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24290	19	1903	1903	CD
18637	24290	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24290	21	,	,	,
18637	24290	22	355	355	CD
18637	24290	23	Osman	Osman	NNP
18637	24290	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24290	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24290	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24290	27	Douds	Douds	NNP
18637	24290	28	,	,	,
18637	24290	29	339	339	CD
18637	24290	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24290	31	846	846	CD
18637	24290	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24290	33	1950	1950	CD
18637	24290	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24290	35	,	,	,
18637	24290	36	795	795	CD
18637	24290	37	Osterman	Osterman	NNP
18637	24290	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24290	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24290	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24290	41	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	24290	42	,	,	,
18637	24290	43	6	6	CD
18637	24290	44	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24290	45	.	.	.
18637	24291	1	116	116	CD
18637	24291	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24291	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	24291	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24291	5	,	,	,
18637	24291	6	257	257	CD
18637	24291	7	Otis	Otis	NNP
18637	24291	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24291	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24291	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24291	11	Parker	Parker	NNP
18637	24291	12	,	,	,
18637	24291	13	187	187	CD
18637	24291	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24291	15	606	606	CD
18637	24291	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24291	17	1903	1903	CD
18637	24291	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24291	19	,	,	,
18637	24291	20	1019	1019	CD
18637	24291	21	,	,	,
18637	24291	22	1156	1156	CD
18637	24291	23	Otis	Otis	NNP
18637	24291	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24291	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24291	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24291	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24291	28	Ludlow	Ludlow	NNP
18637	24291	29	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	24291	30	.	.	.
18637	24292	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24292	2	,	,	,
18637	24292	3	201	201	CD
18637	24292	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24292	5	140	140	CD
18637	24292	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24292	7	1906	1906	CD
18637	24292	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24292	9	,	,	,
18637	24292	10	1066	1066	CD
18637	24292	11	Ott	Ott	NNP
18637	24292	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24292	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24292	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24292	15	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	24292	16	Barge	Barge	NNP
18637	24292	17	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24292	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24292	19	,	,	,
18637	24292	20	336	336	CD
18637	24292	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24292	22	169	169	CD
18637	24292	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24292	24	1949	1949	CD
18637	24292	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24292	26	,	,	,
18637	24292	27	210	210	CD
18637	24292	28	Ouachita	Ouachita	NNP
18637	24292	29	Packet	Packet	NNP
18637	24292	30	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24292	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24292	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24292	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24292	34	Aiken	Aiken	NNP
18637	24292	35	,	,	,
18637	24292	36	121	121	CD
18637	24292	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24292	38	444	444	CD
18637	24292	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24292	40	1887	1887	CD
18637	24292	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24292	42	,	,	,
18637	24292	43	231	231	CD
18637	24292	44	,	,	,
18637	24292	45	366	366	CD
18637	24292	46	Overnight	Overnight	NNP
18637	24292	47	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	24292	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24292	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24292	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	24292	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24292	52	Missel	Missel	NNP
18637	24292	53	,	,	,
18637	24292	54	316	316	CD
18637	24292	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24292	56	572	572	CD
18637	24292	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24292	58	1942	1942	CD
18637	24292	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24292	60	,	,	,
18637	24292	61	157	157	CD
18637	24292	62	Overstreet	Overstreet	NNP
18637	24292	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24292	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	24292	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24292	66	North	North	NNP
18637	24292	67	Shore	Shore	NNP
18637	24292	68	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24292	69	,	,	,
18637	24292	70	318	318	CD
18637	24292	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24292	72	125	125	CD
18637	24292	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24292	74	1943	1943	CD
18637	24292	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24292	76	,	,	,
18637	24292	77	157	157	CD
18637	24292	78	Owensboro	Owensboro	NNP
18637	24292	79	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	24292	80	.	.	.
18637	24293	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24293	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24293	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24293	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24293	5	Owensboro	Owensboro	NNP
18637	24293	6	,	,	,
18637	24293	7	173	173	CD
18637	24293	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24293	9	664	664	CD
18637	24293	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24293	11	1899	1899	CD
18637	24293	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24293	13	,	,	,
18637	24293	14	734	734	CD
18637	24293	15	Owings	Owings	NNPS
18637	24293	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24293	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24293	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24293	19	Speed	Speed	NNP
18637	24293	20	,	,	,
18637	24293	21	5	5	CD
18637	24293	22	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24293	23	.	.	.
18637	24294	1	420	420	CD
18637	24294	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24294	3	1820	1820	CD
18637	24294	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24294	5	,	,	,
18637	24294	6	743	743	CD
18637	24294	7	Ownbey	Ownbey	NNP
18637	24294	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24294	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24294	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24294	11	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	24294	12	,	,	,
18637	24294	13	256	256	CD
18637	24294	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24294	15	94	94	CD
18637	24294	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24294	17	1921),1089	1921),1089	CD
18637	24294	18	,	,	,
18637	24294	19	1091	1091	CD
18637	24294	20	Oyama	Oyama	NNP
18637	24294	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24294	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	24294	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24294	24	California	California	NNP
18637	24294	25	,	,	,
18637	24294	26	332	332	CD
18637	24294	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24294	28	633	633	CD
18637	24294	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24294	30	1948	1948	CD
18637	24294	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24294	32	,	,	,
18637	24294	33	417	417	CD
18637	24294	34	,	,	,
18637	24294	35	968	968	CD
18637	24294	36	,	,	,
18637	24294	37	1157	1157	CD
18637	24294	38	Ozan	Ozan	NNP
18637	24294	39	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	24294	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24294	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24294	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24294	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24294	44	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24294	45	County	County	NNP
18637	24294	46	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	24294	47	.	.	.
18637	24295	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24295	2	,	,	,
18637	24295	3	207	207	CD
18637	24295	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24295	5	251	251	CD
18637	24295	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24295	7	1907	1907	CD
18637	24295	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24295	9	,	,	,
18637	24295	10	276	276	CD
18637	24295	11	Ozark	Ozark	NNP
18637	24295	12	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	24295	13	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24295	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24295	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24295	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24295	17	Monier	Monier	NNP
18637	24295	18	,	,	,
18637	24295	19	266	266	CD
18637	24295	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24295	21	555	555	CD
18637	24295	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24295	23	1925	1925	CD
18637	24295	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24295	25	,	,	,
18637	24295	26	194	194	CD
18637	24295	27	P	p	NN
18637	24295	28	Pace	Pace	NNP
18637	24295	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24295	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24295	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24295	32	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	24295	33	,	,	,
18637	24295	34	106	106	CD
18637	24295	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24295	36	583	583	CD
18637	24295	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24295	38	1883	1883	CD
18637	24295	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24295	40	,	,	,
18637	24295	41	1161	1161	CD
18637	24295	42	Pace	Pace	NNP
18637	24295	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24295	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24295	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24295	46	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
18637	24295	47	,	,	,
18637	24295	48	92	92	CD
18637	24295	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24295	50	372	372	CD
18637	24295	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24295	52	1876	1876	CD
18637	24295	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24295	54	,	,	,
18637	24295	55	322	322	CD
18637	24295	56	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24295	57	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	24295	58	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
18637	24295	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24295	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	24295	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24295	62	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	24295	63	.	.	.
18637	24296	1	of	of	IN
18637	24296	2	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	24296	3	,	,	,
18637	24296	4	318	318	CD
18637	24296	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24296	6	285	285	CD
18637	24296	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24296	8	1943	1943	CD
18637	24296	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24296	10	,	,	,
18637	24296	11	305	305	CD
18637	24296	12	,	,	,
18637	24296	13	726	726	CD
18637	24296	14	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24296	15	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24296	16	&	&	CC
18637	24296	17	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	24296	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24296	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24296	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24296	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24296	22	Police	Police	NNP
18637	24296	23	Court	Court	NNP
18637	24296	24	,	,	,
18637	24296	25	251	251	CD
18637	24296	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24296	27	22	22	CD
18637	24296	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24296	29	1919	1919	CD
18637	24296	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24296	31	,	,	,
18637	24296	32	1011	1011	CD
18637	24296	33	,	,	,
18637	24296	34	1156	1156	CD
18637	24296	35	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24296	36	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24296	37	.	.	.
18637	24297	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24297	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24297	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24297	4	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	24297	5	.	.	NNP
18637	24297	6	,	,	,
18637	24297	7	306	306	CD
18637	24297	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24297	9	493	493	CD
18637	24297	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24297	11	1939	1939	CD
18637	24297	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24297	13	,	,	,
18637	24297	14	682	682	CD
18637	24297	15	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24297	16	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24297	17	.	.	.
18637	24298	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24298	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24298	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24298	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24298	5	Soule	Soule	NNP
18637	24298	6	,	,	,
18637	24298	7	7	7	CD
18637	24298	8	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24298	9	.	.	.
18637	24299	1	433	433	CD
18637	24299	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24299	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24299	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24299	5	,	,	,
18637	24299	6	319	319	CD
18637	24299	7	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24299	8	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24299	9	Removal	Removal	NNP
18637	24299	10	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	24299	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24299	12	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24299	13	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24300	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24300	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24300	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24300	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24300	5	Myers	Myers	NNP
18637	24300	6	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24300	7	,	,	,
18637	24300	8	115	115	CD
18637	24300	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24300	10	1	1	CD
18637	24300	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24300	12	1885	1885	CD
18637	24300	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24300	14	,	,	,
18637	24300	15	310	310	CD
18637	24300	16	,	,	,
18637	24300	17	568	568	CD
18637	24300	18	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24300	19	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	24300	20	Cases	case	NNS
18637	24300	21	,	,	,
18637	24300	22	127	127	CD
18637	24300	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24300	24	1	1	CD
18637	24300	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24300	26	1888	1888	CD
18637	24300	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24300	28	,	,	,
18637	24300	29	114	114	CD
18637	24300	30	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24300	31	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	24300	32	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24300	33	,	,	,
18637	24300	34	In	in	IN
18637	24300	35	re	re	NN
18637	24300	36	,	,	,
18637	24300	37	32	32	CD
18637	24300	38	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24300	39	.	.	.
18637	24301	1	241	241	CD
18637	24301	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24301	3	1887	1887	CD
18637	24301	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24301	5	,	,	,
18637	24301	6	539	539	CD
18637	24301	7	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24301	8	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24301	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24301	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24301	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24301	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24301	13	Maguire	Maguire	NNP
18637	24301	14	,	,	,
18637	24301	15	20	20	CD
18637	24301	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24301	17	.	.	.
18637	24302	1	36	36	CD
18637	24302	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24302	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	24302	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24302	5	,	,	,
18637	24302	6	342	342	CD
18637	24302	7	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24302	8	States	States	NNPS
18637	24302	9	Box	Box	NNP
18637	24302	10	&	&	CC
18637	24302	11	Basket	Basket	NNP
18637	24302	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24302	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24302	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24302	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24302	16	White	White	NNP
18637	24302	17	,	,	,
18637	24302	18	296	296	CD
18637	24302	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24302	20	176	176	CD
18637	24302	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24302	22	1935	1935	CD
18637	24302	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24302	24	,	,	,
18637	24302	25	1019	1019	CD
18637	24302	26	,	,	,
18637	24302	27	1085	1085	CD
18637	24302	28	,	,	,
18637	24302	29	1160	1160	CD
18637	24302	30	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24302	31	States	States	NNPS
18637	24302	32	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	24302	33	&	&	CC
18637	24302	34	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	24302	35	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24302	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24302	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24302	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24302	39	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24302	40	,	,	,
18637	24302	41	223	223	CD
18637	24302	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24302	43	118	118	CD
18637	24302	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24302	45	1912	1912	CD
18637	24302	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24302	47	,	,	,
18637	24302	48	548	548	CD
18637	24302	49	,	,	,
18637	24302	50	705	705	CD
18637	24302	51	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24302	52	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	24302	53	Whaling	Whaling	NNP
18637	24302	54	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24302	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24302	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24302	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24302	58	United	United	NNP
18637	24302	59	States	States	NNP
18637	24302	60	,	,	,
18637	24302	61	187	187	CD
18637	24302	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24302	63	447	447	CD
18637	24302	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24302	65	1903	1903	CD
18637	24302	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24302	67	,	,	,
18637	24302	68	621	621	CD
18637	24302	69	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24302	70	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	24302	71	&	&	CC
18637	24302	72	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	24302	73	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24302	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24302	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	24302	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24302	77	Gallagher	Gallagher	NNP
18637	24302	78	,	,	,
18637	24302	79	306	306	CD
18637	24302	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24302	81	182	182	CD
18637	24302	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24302	83	1939	1939	CD
18637	24302	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24302	85	,	,	,
18637	24302	86	186	186	CD
18637	24302	87	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24302	88	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	24302	89	.	.	.
18637	24303	1	&	&	CC
18637	24303	2	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24303	3	.	.	.
18637	24304	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24304	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24304	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24304	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24304	5	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24304	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24304	7	,	,	,
18637	24304	8	297	297	CD
18637	24304	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24304	10	403	403	CD
18637	24304	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24304	12	1936	1936	CD
18637	24304	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24304	14	,	,	,
18637	24304	15	126	126	CD
18637	24304	16	,	,	,
18637	24304	17	136	136	CD
18637	24304	18	,	,	,
18637	24304	19	197	197	CD
18637	24304	20	Packard	Packard	NNP
18637	24304	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24304	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	24304	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24304	24	Banton	Banton	NNP
18637	24304	25	,	,	,
18637	24304	26	264	264	CD
18637	24304	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24304	28	140	140	CD
18637	24304	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24304	30	1924	1924	CD
18637	24304	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24304	32	,	,	,
18637	24304	33	1033	1033	CD
18637	24304	34	,	,	,
18637	24304	35	1155	1155	CD
18637	24304	36	Packer	Packer	NNP
18637	24304	37	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24304	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24304	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24304	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24304	41	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	24304	42	,	,	,
18637	24304	43	285	285	CD
18637	24304	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24304	45	105	105	CD
18637	24304	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24304	47	1932	1932	CD
18637	24304	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24304	49	,	,	,
18637	24304	50	1024	1024	CD
18637	24304	51	,	,	,
18637	24304	52	1153	1153	CD
18637	24304	53	Packet	Packet	NNP
18637	24304	54	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24304	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24304	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24304	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24304	58	Keokuk	Keokuk	NNP
18637	24304	59	,	,	,
18637	24304	60	95	95	CD
18637	24304	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24304	62	80	80	CD
18637	24304	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24304	64	1877	1877	CD
18637	24304	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24304	66	,	,	,
18637	24304	67	210	210	CD
18637	24304	68	,	,	,
18637	24304	69	231	231	CD
18637	24304	70	Paddell	Paddell	NNP
18637	24304	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24304	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	24304	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24304	74	New	New	NNP
18637	24304	75	York	York	NNP
18637	24304	76	,	,	,
18637	24304	77	211	211	CD
18637	24304	78	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24304	79	446	446	CD
18637	24304	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24304	81	1908	1908	CD
18637	24304	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24304	83	,	,	,
18637	24304	84	1040	1040	CD
18637	24304	85	Page	Page	NNP
18637	24304	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24304	87	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24304	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24304	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24304	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	24304	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24304	92	United	United	NNP
18637	24304	93	States	States	NNP
18637	24304	94	,	,	,
18637	24304	95	11	11	CD
18637	24304	96	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24304	97	.	.	.
18637	24305	1	268	268	CD
18637	24305	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24305	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24305	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24305	5	,	,	,
18637	24305	6	865	865	CD
18637	24305	7	Page	Page	NNP
18637	24305	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24305	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24305	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24305	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24305	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24305	13	,	,	,
18637	24305	14	127	127	CD
18637	24305	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24305	16	67	67	CD
18637	24305	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24305	18	1888	1888	CD
18637	24305	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24305	20	,	,	,
18637	24305	21	99	99	CD
18637	24305	22	Paine	Paine	NNP
18637	24305	23	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	24305	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24305	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24305	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24305	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24305	28	Neal	Neal	NNP
18637	24305	29	,	,	,
18637	24305	30	244	244	CD
18637	24305	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24305	32	459	459	CD
18637	24305	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24305	34	1917	1917	CD
18637	24305	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24305	36	,	,	,
18637	24305	37	524	524	CD
18637	24305	38	Palko	Palko	NNP
18637	24305	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24305	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24305	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24305	42	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	24305	43	,	,	,
18637	24305	44	302	302	CD
18637	24305	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24305	46	319	319	CD
18637	24305	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24305	48	1937	1937	CD
18637	24305	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24305	50	,	,	,
18637	24305	51	791	791	CD
18637	24305	52	,	,	,
18637	24305	53	971	971	CD
18637	24305	54	,	,	,
18637	24305	55	1098	1098	CD
18637	24305	56	,	,	,
18637	24305	57	1112	1112	CD
18637	24305	58	,	,	,
18637	24305	59	1116	1116	CD
18637	24305	60	,	,	,
18637	24305	61	1122	1122	CD
18637	24305	62	,	,	,
18637	24305	63	1135	1135	CD
18637	24305	64	,	,	,
18637	24305	65	1136	1136	CD
18637	24305	66	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	24305	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24305	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	24305	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24305	70	Ashe	Ashe	NNP
18637	24305	71	,	,	,
18637	24305	72	342	342	CD
18637	24305	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24305	74	134	134	CD
18637	24305	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24305	76	1951	1951	CD
18637	24305	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24305	78	,	,	,
18637	24305	79	1107	1107	CD
18637	24305	80	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	24305	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24305	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	24305	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24305	84	Barrett	Barrett	NNP
18637	24305	85	,	,	,
18637	24305	86	162	162	CD
18637	24305	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24305	88	399	399	CD
18637	24305	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24305	90	1896	1896	CD
18637	24305	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24305	92	,	,	,
18637	24305	93	306	306	CD
18637	24305	94	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	24305	95	_	_	NNP
18637	24305	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	24305	97	_	_	NNP
18637	24305	98	McMahon	McMahon	NNP
18637	24305	99	,	,	,
18637	24305	100	133	133	CD
18637	24305	101	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24305	102	660	660	CD
18637	24305	103	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24305	104	1890	1890	CD
18637	24305	105	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24305	106	,	,	,
18637	24305	107	1062	1062	CD
18637	24305	108	,	,	,
18637	24305	109	1071	1071	CD
18637	24305	110	Palmetto	Palmetto	NNP
18637	24305	111	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24305	112	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24305	113	.	.	.
18637	24306	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24306	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24306	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24306	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24306	5	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	24306	6	,	,	,
18637	24306	7	272	272	CD
18637	24306	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24306	9	295	295	CD
18637	24306	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24306	11	1926	1926	CD
18637	24306	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24306	13	,	,	,
18637	24306	14	1056	1056	CD
18637	24306	15	Panama	Panama	NNP
18637	24306	16	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24306	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24306	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24306	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24306	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24306	21	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	24306	22	,	,	,
18637	24306	23	264	264	CD
18637	24306	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24306	25	375	375	CD
18637	24306	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24306	27	1924	1924	CD
18637	24306	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24306	29	,	,	,
18637	24306	30	854	854	CD
18637	24306	31	Panama	Panama	NNP
18637	24306	32	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	24306	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24306	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24306	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	24306	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24306	37	Ryan	Ryan	NNP
18637	24306	38	,	,	,
18637	24306	39	293	293	CD
18637	24306	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24306	41	388	388	CD
18637	24306	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24306	43	1935	1935	CD
18637	24306	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24306	45	,	,	,
18637	24306	46	76	76	CD
18637	24306	47	,	,	,
18637	24306	48	80	80	CD
18637	24306	49	,	,	,
18637	24306	50	81	81	CD
18637	24306	51	,	,	,
18637	24306	52	380	380	CD
18637	24306	53	Panhandle	Panhandle	NNP
18637	24306	54	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24306	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24306	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24306	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24306	58	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	24306	59	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	24306	60	.	.	.
18637	24306	61	,	,	,
18637	24306	62	341	341	CD
18637	24306	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24306	64	329	329	CD
18637	24306	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24306	66	1951	1951	CD
18637	24306	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24306	68	,	,	,
18637	24306	69	234	234	CD
18637	24306	70	Panhandle	Panhandle	NNP
18637	24306	71	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	24306	72	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	24306	73	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24306	74	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24306	75	_	_	NNP
18637	24306	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	24306	77	_	_	NNP
18637	24306	78	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24306	79	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	24306	80	.	.	.
18637	24307	1	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24307	2	of	of	IN
18637	24307	3	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	24307	4	,	,	,
18637	24307	5	332	332	CD
18637	24307	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24307	7	507	507	CD
18637	24307	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24307	9	1947	1947	CD
18637	24307	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24307	11	,	,	,
18637	24307	12	234	234	CD
18637	24307	13	,	,	,
18637	24307	14	250	250	CD
18637	24307	15	Panhandle	Panhandle	NNP
18637	24307	16	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	24307	17	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	24307	18	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24307	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24307	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24307	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24307	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24307	23	State	State	NNP
18637	24307	24	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	24307	25	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24307	26	,	,	,
18637	24307	27	294	294	CD
18637	24307	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24307	29	613	613	CD
18637	24307	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24307	31	1935	1935	CD
18637	24307	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24307	33	,	,	,
18637	24307	34	983	983	CD
18637	24307	35	,	,	,
18637	24307	36	1010	1010	CD
18637	24307	37	Panhandle	Panhandle	NNP
18637	24307	38	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24307	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24307	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24307	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24307	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24307	43	Knox	Knox	NNP
18637	24307	44	,	,	,
18637	24307	45	277	277	CD
18637	24307	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24307	47	218	218	CD
18637	24307	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24307	49	1928	1928	CD
18637	24307	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24307	51	,	,	,
18637	24307	52	731	731	CD
18637	24307	53	Paquete	Paquete	NNP
18637	24307	54	Habana	Habana	NNP
18637	24307	55	,	,	,
18637	24307	56	The	the	DT
18637	24307	57	,	,	,
18637	24307	58	175	175	CD
18637	24307	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24307	60	677	677	CD
18637	24307	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24307	62	1900	1900	CD
18637	24307	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24307	64	,	,	,
18637	24307	65	296	296	CD
18637	24307	66	Paramino	Paramino	NNP
18637	24307	67	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	24307	68	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24307	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24307	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	24307	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24307	72	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
18637	24307	73	,	,	,
18637	24307	74	309	309	CD
18637	24307	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24307	76	370	370	CD
18637	24307	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24307	78	1940	1940	CD
18637	24307	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24307	80	,	,	,
18637	24307	81	311	311	CD
18637	24307	82	,	,	,
18637	24307	83	856	856	CD
18637	24307	84	Parker	Parker	NNP
18637	24307	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24307	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	24307	87	_	_	NNP
18637	24307	88	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	24307	89	,	,	,
18637	24307	90	317	317	CD
18637	24307	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24307	92	341	341	CD
18637	24307	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24307	94	1943	1943	CD
18637	24307	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24307	96	,	,	,
18637	24307	97	177	177	CD
18637	24307	98	,	,	,
18637	24307	99	218	218	CD
18637	24307	100	,	,	,
18637	24307	101	219	219	CD
18637	24307	102	,	,	,
18637	24307	103	250	250	CD
18637	24307	104	Parker	Parker	NNP
18637	24307	105	_	_	NNP
18637	24307	106	v.	v.	IN
18637	24307	107	_	_	NNP
18637	24307	108	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	24307	109	Boat	Boat	NNP
18637	24307	110	Sales	Sales	NNP
18637	24307	111	,	,	,
18637	24307	112	314	314	CD
18637	24307	113	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24307	114	244	244	CD
18637	24307	115	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24307	116	1941	1941	CD
18637	24307	117	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24307	118	,	,	,
18637	24307	119	582	582	CD
18637	24307	120	Parkersburg	Parkersburg	NNP
18637	24307	121	&	&	CC
18637	24307	122	O.	O.	NNP
18637	24307	123	Transp	Transp	NNP
18637	24307	124	.	.	.
18637	24308	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24308	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24308	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24308	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24308	5	Parkersburg	Parkersburg	NNP
18637	24308	6	,	,	,
18637	24308	7	107	107	CD
18637	24308	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24308	9	691	691	CD
18637	24308	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24308	11	1883	1883	CD
18637	24308	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24308	13	,	,	,
18637	24308	14	127	127	CD
18637	24308	15	,	,	,
18637	24308	16	231	231	CD
18637	24308	17	,	,	,
18637	24308	18	366	366	CD
18637	24308	19	Parkinson	Parkinson	NNP
18637	24308	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24308	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24308	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24308	23	United	United	NNP
18637	24308	24	States	States	NNP
18637	24308	25	,	,	,
18637	24308	26	121	121	CD
18637	24308	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24308	28	281	281	CD
18637	24308	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24308	30	1887	1887	CD
18637	24308	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24308	32	,	,	,
18637	24308	33	838	838	CD
18637	24308	34	Parsons	Parsons	NNPS
18637	24308	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24308	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24308	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24308	38	Armor	Armor	NNP
18637	24308	39	,	,	,
18637	24308	40	3	3	CD
18637	24308	41	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	24308	42	.	.	.
18637	24309	1	413	413	CD
18637	24309	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24309	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	24309	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24309	5	,	,	,
18637	24309	6	897	897	CD
18637	24309	7	Parsons	Parsons	NNPS
18637	24309	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24309	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24309	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24309	11	Bedford	Bedford	NNP
18637	24309	12	,	,	,
18637	24309	13	3	3	CD
18637	24309	14	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	24309	15	.	.	.
18637	24310	1	433	433	CD
18637	24310	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24310	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	24310	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24310	5	,	,	,
18637	24310	6	891	891	CD
18637	24310	7	,	,	,
18637	24310	8	893	893	CD
18637	24310	9	Parsons	Parsons	NNPS
18637	24310	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24310	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24310	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24310	13	District	District	NNP
18637	24310	14	of	of	IN
18637	24310	15	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	24310	16	,	,	,
18637	24310	17	170	170	CD
18637	24310	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24310	19	45	45	CD
18637	24310	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24310	21	1898	1898	CD
18637	24310	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24310	23	,	,	,
18637	24310	24	848	848	CD
18637	24310	25	Parsons	Parsons	NNPS
18637	24310	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24310	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24310	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24310	29	United	United	NNP
18637	24310	30	States	States	NNP
18637	24310	31	,	,	,
18637	24310	32	167	167	CD
18637	24310	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24310	34	324	324	CD
18637	24310	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24310	36	1897	1897	CD
18637	24310	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24310	38	,	,	,
18637	24310	39	460	460	CD
18637	24310	40	Passaic	Passaic	NNP
18637	24310	41	Bridges	Bridges	NNPS
18637	24310	42	,	,	,
18637	24310	43	The	the	DT
18637	24310	44	,	,	,
18637	24310	45	3	3	CD
18637	24310	46	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24310	47	.	.	.
18637	24311	1	782	782	CD
18637	24311	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24311	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	24311	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24311	5	,	,	,
18637	24311	6	122	122	CD
18637	24311	7	Passavant	Passavant	NNP
18637	24311	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24311	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24311	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24311	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24311	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24311	13	,	,	,
18637	24311	14	148	148	CD
18637	24311	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24311	16	214	214	CD
18637	24311	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24311	18	1893	1893	CD
18637	24311	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24311	20	,	,	,
18637	24311	21	849	849	CD
18637	24311	22	Passenger	Passenger	NNP
18637	24311	23	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	24311	24	,	,	,
18637	24311	25	7	7	CD
18637	24311	26	How	how	WRB
18637	24311	27	.	.	.
18637	24312	1	283	283	CD
18637	24312	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24312	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	24312	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24312	5	,	,	,
18637	24312	6	122	122	CD
18637	24312	7	Patapsco	Patapsco	NNP
18637	24312	8	Guano	Guano	NNP
18637	24312	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24312	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24312	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	13	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24312	14	of	of	IN
18637	24312	15	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	24312	16	,	,	,
18637	24312	17	171	171	CD
18637	24312	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24312	19	345	345	CD
18637	24312	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24312	21	1898	1898	CD
18637	24312	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24312	23	,	,	,
18637	24312	24	183	183	CD
18637	24312	25	,	,	,
18637	24312	26	238	238	CD
18637	24312	27	,	,	,
18637	24312	28	365	365	CD
18637	24312	29	Patent	Patent	NNP
18637	24312	30	Clothing	Clothing	NNP
18637	24312	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24312	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	24312	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	35	Glover	Glover	NNP
18637	24312	36	,	,	,
18637	24312	37	141	141	CD
18637	24312	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24312	39	560	560	CD
18637	24312	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24312	41	1891	1891	CD
18637	24312	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24312	43	,	,	,
18637	24312	44	273	273	CD
18637	24312	45	Paterno	Paterno	NNPS
18637	24312	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	24312	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	49	Lyons	Lyons	NNP
18637	24312	50	,	,	,
18637	24312	51	334	334	CD
18637	24312	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24312	53	314	314	CD
18637	24312	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24312	55	1948	1948	CD
18637	24312	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24312	57	,	,	,
18637	24312	58	1133	1133	CD
18637	24312	59	Patsone	Patsone	NNP
18637	24312	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	24312	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	63	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24312	64	,	,	,
18637	24312	65	232	232	CD
18637	24312	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24312	67	138	138	CD
18637	24312	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24312	69	1914	1914	CD
18637	24312	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24312	71	,	,	,
18637	24312	72	1158	1158	CD
18637	24312	73	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	24312	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	24312	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	77	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	24312	78	,	,	,
18637	24312	79	205	205	CD
18637	24312	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24312	81	454	454	CD
18637	24312	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24312	83	1907	1907	CD
18637	24312	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24312	85	,	,	,
18637	24312	86	752	752	CD
18637	24312	87	,	,	,
18637	24312	88	771	771	CD
18637	24312	89	,	,	,
18637	24312	90	774	774	CD
18637	24312	91	,	,	,
18637	24312	92	784	784	CD
18637	24312	93	,	,	,
18637	24312	94	1141	1141	CD
18637	24312	95	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	24312	96	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	24312	98	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	99	The	the	DT
18637	24312	100	"	"	``
18637	24312	101	Eudora	Eudora	NNP
18637	24312	102	,	,	,
18637	24312	103	"	"	''
18637	24312	104	190	190	CD
18637	24312	105	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24312	106	169	169	CD
18637	24312	107	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24312	108	1903	1903	CD
18637	24312	109	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24312	110	,	,	,
18637	24312	111	855	855	CD
18637	24312	112	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	24312	113	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	114	v.	v.	IN
18637	24312	115	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	116	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	24312	117	,	,	,
18637	24312	118	97	97	CD
18637	24312	119	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24312	120	501	501	CD
18637	24312	121	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24312	122	1879	1879	CD
18637	24312	123	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24312	124	,	,	,
18637	24312	125	122	122	CD
18637	24312	126	,	,	,
18637	24312	127	276	276	CD
18637	24312	128	Patton	Patton	NNP
18637	24312	129	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	130	v.	v.	IN
18637	24312	131	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	132	Brady	Brady	NNP
18637	24312	133	,	,	,
18637	24312	134	184	184	CD
18637	24312	135	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24312	136	608	608	CD
18637	24312	137	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24312	138	1902	1902	CD
18637	24312	139	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24312	140	,	,	,
18637	24312	141	320	320	CD
18637	24312	142	,	,	,
18637	24312	143	864	864	CD
18637	24312	144	,	,	,
18637	24312	145	1191	1191	CD
18637	24312	146	Patton	Patton	NNP
18637	24312	147	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	148	v.	v.	IN
18637	24312	149	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	150	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	24312	151	,	,	,
18637	24312	152	332	332	CD
18637	24312	153	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24312	154	463	463	CD
18637	24312	155	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24312	156	1947	1947	CD
18637	24312	157	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24312	158	,	,	,
18637	24312	159	1168	1168	CD
18637	24312	160	Patton	Patton	NNP
18637	24312	161	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	162	v.	v.	IN
18637	24312	163	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	164	United	United	NNP
18637	24312	165	States	States	NNP
18637	24312	166	,	,	,
18637	24312	167	281	281	CD
18637	24312	168	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24312	169	276	276	CD
18637	24312	170	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24312	171	1930	1930	CD
18637	24312	172	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24312	173	,	,	,
18637	24312	174	879	879	CD
18637	24312	175	Paul	Paul	NNP
18637	24312	176	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	177	v.	v.	IN
18637	24312	178	_	_	NNP
18637	24312	179	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24312	180	,	,	,
18637	24312	181	8	8	CD
18637	24312	182	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24312	183	.	.	.
18637	24313	1	168	168	CD
18637	24313	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24313	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24313	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24313	5	,	,	,
18637	24313	6	120	120	CD
18637	24313	7	,	,	,
18637	24313	8	193	193	CD
18637	24313	9	,	,	,
18637	24313	10	198	198	CD
18637	24313	11	,	,	,
18637	24313	12	361	361	CD
18637	24313	13	,	,	,
18637	24313	14	689	689	CD
18637	24313	15	,	,	,
18637	24313	16	965	965	CD
18637	24313	17	Paulsen	Paulsen	NNP
18637	24313	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24313	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24313	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24313	21	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	24313	22	,	,	,
18637	24313	23	149	149	CD
18637	24313	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24313	25	30	30	CD
18637	24313	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24313	27	1893	1893	CD
18637	24313	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24313	29	,	,	,
18637	24313	30	1059	1059	CD
18637	24313	31	,	,	,
18637	24313	32	1085	1085	CD
18637	24313	33	Pawhuska	Pawhuska	NNP
18637	24313	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24313	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	24313	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24313	37	Pawhuska	Pawhuska	NNP
18637	24313	38	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24313	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24313	40	,	,	,
18637	24313	41	250	250	CD
18637	24313	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24313	43	394	394	CD
18637	24313	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24313	45	1919	1919	CD
18637	24313	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24313	47	,	,	,
18637	24313	48	982	982	CD
18637	24313	49	Pawlet	Pawlet	NNP
18637	24313	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24313	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	24313	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24313	53	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	24313	54	,	,	,
18637	24313	55	9	9	CD
18637	24313	56	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24313	57	.	.	.
18637	24314	1	292	292	CD
18637	24314	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24314	3	1815	1815	CD
18637	24314	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24314	5	,	,	,
18637	24314	6	609	609	CD
18637	24314	7	Payne	Payne	NNP
18637	24314	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24314	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24314	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24314	11	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24314	12	,	,	,
18637	24314	13	248	248	CD
18637	24314	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24314	15	112	112	CD
18637	24314	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24314	17	1918	1918	CD
18637	24314	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24314	19	,	,	,
18637	24314	20	1148	1148	CD
18637	24314	21	Peabody	Peabody	NNP
18637	24314	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24314	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24314	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24314	25	Eisner	Eisner	NNP
18637	24314	26	,	,	,
18637	24314	27	247	247	CD
18637	24314	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24314	29	347	347	CD
18637	24314	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24314	31	1918	1918	CD
18637	24314	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24314	33	,	,	,
18637	24314	34	1193	1193	CD
18637	24314	35	Peabody	Peabody	NNP
18637	24314	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24314	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24314	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24314	39	United	United	NNP
18637	24314	40	States	States	NNP
18637	24314	41	,	,	,
18637	24314	42	231	231	CD
18637	24314	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24314	44	530	530	CD
18637	24314	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24314	46	1913	1913	CD
18637	24314	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24314	48	,	,	,
18637	24314	49	586	586	CD
18637	24314	50	,	,	,
18637	24314	51	867	867	CD
18637	24314	52	Pearson	Pearson	NNP
18637	24314	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24314	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	24314	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24314	56	McGraw	McGraw	NNP
18637	24314	57	,	,	,
18637	24314	58	308	308	CD
18637	24314	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24314	60	313	313	CD
18637	24314	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24314	62	1939	1939	CD
18637	24314	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24314	64	,	,	,
18637	24314	65	1048	1048	CD
18637	24314	66	Pearson	Pearson	NNP
18637	24314	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24314	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	24314	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24314	70	Yewdall	Yewdall	NNP
18637	24314	71	,	,	,
18637	24314	72	95	95	CD
18637	24314	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24314	74	294	294	CD
18637	24314	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24314	76	1877	1877	CD
18637	24314	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24314	78	,	,	,
18637	24314	79	892	892	CD
18637	24314	80	Pease	Pease	NNP
18637	24314	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24314	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	24314	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24314	84	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	24314	85	,	,	,
18637	24314	86	18	18	CD
18637	24314	87	How	how	WRB
18637	24314	88	.	.	.
18637	24315	1	595	595	CD
18637	24315	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24315	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	24315	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24315	5	,	,	,
18637	24315	6	604	604	CD
18637	24315	7	Pease	Pease	NNP
18637	24315	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24315	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24315	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24315	11	Rathbun	Rathbun	NNP
18637	24315	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	24315	13	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	24315	14	Eng	Eng	NNP
18637	24315	15	.	.	.
18637	24316	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24316	2	,	,	,
18637	24316	3	243	243	CD
18637	24316	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24316	5	273	273	CD
18637	24316	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24316	7	1917	1917	CD
18637	24316	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24316	9	,	,	,
18637	24316	10	893	893	CD
18637	24316	11	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	24316	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24316	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24316	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24316	15	Jenness	Jenness	NNP
18637	24316	16	,	,	,
18637	24316	17	7	7	CD
18637	24316	18	How	how	WRB
18637	24316	19	.	.	.
18637	24317	1	612	612	CD
18637	24317	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24317	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	24317	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24317	5	,	,	,
18637	24317	6	627	627	CD
18637	24317	7	,	,	,
18637	24317	8	628	628	CD
18637	24317	9	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	24317	10	&	&	CC
18637	24317	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24317	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24317	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24317	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24317	15	Lowe	Lowe	NNP
18637	24317	16	,	,	,
18637	24317	17	247	247	CD
18637	24317	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24317	19	165	165	CD
18637	24317	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24317	21	1918	1918	CD
18637	24317	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24317	23	,	,	,
18637	24317	24	321	321	CD
18637	24317	25	Pedersen	Pedersen	NNP
18637	24317	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24317	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24317	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24317	29	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	24317	30	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24317	31	&	&	CC
18637	24317	32	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	24317	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24317	34	,	,	,
18637	24317	35	229	229	CD
18637	24317	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24317	37	146	146	CD
18637	24317	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24317	39	1913	1913	CD
18637	24317	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24317	41	,	,	,
18637	24317	42	141	141	CD
18637	24317	43	Peete	Peete	NNP
18637	24317	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24317	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24317	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24317	47	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	24317	48	,	,	,
18637	24317	49	19	19	CD
18637	24317	50	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24317	51	.	.	.
18637	24318	1	581	581	CD
18637	24318	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24318	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	24318	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24318	5	,	,	,
18637	24318	6	366	366	CD
18637	24318	7	Peggy	Peggy	NNP
18637	24318	8	,	,	,
18637	24318	9	The	the	DT
18637	24318	10	.	.	.
18637	24319	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24319	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24319	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24319	4	United	United	NNP
18637	24319	5	States	States	NNP
18637	24319	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24319	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	24319	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24319	9	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
18637	24319	10	Peggy	Peggy	NNP
18637	24319	11	.	.	.
18637	24320	1	Peik	Peik	NNP
18637	24320	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24320	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24320	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24320	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	24320	6	&	&	CC
18637	24320	7	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	24320	8	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24320	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24320	10	,	,	,
18637	24320	11	94	94	CD
18637	24320	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24320	13	164	164	CD
18637	24320	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24320	15	1877	1877	CD
18637	24320	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24320	17	,	,	,
18637	24320	18	220	220	CD
18637	24320	19	,	,	,
18637	24320	20	998	998	CD
18637	24320	21	,	,	,
18637	24320	22	1143	1143	CD
18637	24320	23	Penfield	Penfield	NNP
18637	24320	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24320	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24320	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24320	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24320	28	Securities	Securities	NNP
18637	24320	29	&	&	CC
18637	24320	30	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	24320	31	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24320	32	,	,	,
18637	24320	33	330	330	CD
18637	24320	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24320	35	585	585	CD
18637	24320	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24320	37	1947	1947	CD
18637	24320	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24320	39	,	,	,
18637	24320	40	521	521	CD
18637	24320	41	Penhallow	Penhallow	NNP
18637	24320	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24320	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24320	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24320	45	Doane	Doane	NNP
18637	24320	46	,	,	,
18637	24320	47	3	3	CD
18637	24320	48	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	24320	49	.	.	.
18637	24321	1	54	54	CD
18637	24321	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24321	3	1795	1795	CD
18637	24321	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24321	5	,	,	,
18637	24321	6	73	73	CD
18637	24321	7	,	,	,
18637	24321	8	280	280	CD
18637	24321	9	Penn	Penn	NNP
18637	24321	10	Dairies	Dairies	NNPS
18637	24321	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24321	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24321	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24321	14	Milk	Milk	NNP
18637	24321	15	Control	Control	NNP
18637	24321	16	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	24321	17	.	.	.
18637	24321	18	,	,	,
18637	24321	19	318	318	CD
18637	24321	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24321	21	261	261	CD
18637	24321	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24321	23	1943	1943	CD
18637	24321	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24321	25	,	,	,
18637	24321	26	726	726	CD
18637	24321	27	Pennekamp	Pennekamp	NNP
18637	24321	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24321	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24321	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24321	31	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	24321	32	,	,	,
18637	24321	33	328	328	CD
18637	24321	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24321	35	331	331	CD
18637	24321	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24321	37	1946	1946	CD
18637	24321	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24321	39	,	,	,
18637	24321	40	784	784	CD
18637	24321	41	,	,	,
18637	24321	42	789	789	CD
18637	24321	43	Pennie	Pennie	NNP
18637	24321	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24321	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24321	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24321	47	Reis	Reis	NNP
18637	24321	48	,	,	,
18637	24321	49	132	132	CD
18637	24321	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24321	51	464	464	CD
18637	24321	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24321	53	1889	1889	CD
18637	24321	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24321	55	,	,	,
18637	24321	56	982	982	CD
18637	24321	57	Pennington	Pennington	NNP
18637	24321	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24321	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24321	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24321	61	Fourth	Fourth	NNP
18637	24321	62	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	24321	63	.	.	.
18637	24322	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24322	2	,	,	,
18637	24322	3	243	243	CD
18637	24322	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24322	5	269	269	CD
18637	24322	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24322	7	1917	1917	CD
18637	24322	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24322	9	,	,	,
18637	24322	10	1072	1072	CD
18637	24322	11	,	,	,
18637	24322	12	1081	1081	CD
18637	24322	13	Pennington	Pennington	NNP
18637	24322	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24322	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24322	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24322	17	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	24322	18	,	,	,
18637	24322	19	16	16	CD
18637	24322	20	How	how	WRB
18637	24322	21	.	.	.
18637	24323	1	65	65	CD
18637	24323	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24323	3	1854	1854	CD
18637	24323	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24323	5	,	,	,
18637	24323	6	684	684	CD
18637	24323	7	Pennock	Pennock	NNP
18637	24323	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24323	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24323	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24323	11	Dialogue	Dialogue	NNP
18637	24323	12	,	,	,
18637	24323	13	2	2	CD
18637	24323	14	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24323	15	.	.	.
18637	24324	1	1	1	CD
18637	24324	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24324	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	24324	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24324	5	,	,	,
18637	24324	6	271	271	CD
18637	24324	7	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
18637	24324	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24324	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24324	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24324	11	McConnaughy	McConnaughy	NNP
18637	24324	12	,	,	,
18637	24324	13	140	140	CD
18637	24324	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24324	15	1	1	CD
18637	24324	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24324	17	1891	1891	CD
18637	24324	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24324	19	,	,	,
18637	24324	20	931	931	CD
18637	24324	21	,	,	,
18637	24324	22	932	932	CD
18637	24324	23	,	,	,
18637	24324	24	933	933	CD
18637	24324	25	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
18637	24324	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24324	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24324	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24324	29	Neff	Neff	NNP
18637	24324	30	,	,	,
18637	24324	31	95	95	CD
18637	24324	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24324	33	714	714	CD
18637	24324	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24324	35	1878	1878	CD
18637	24324	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24324	37	,	,	,
18637	24324	38	659	659	CD
18637	24324	39	,	,	,
18637	24324	40	1072	1072	CD
18637	24324	41	,	,	,
18637	24324	42	1073	1073	CD
18637	24324	43	,	,	,
18637	24324	44	1080	1080	CD
18637	24324	45	,	,	,
18637	24324	46	1081	1081	CD
18637	24324	47	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24324	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24324	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	24324	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24324	51	Quicksilver	Quicksilver	NNP
18637	24324	52	Min	Min	NNP
18637	24324	53	.	.	.
18637	24325	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24325	2	,	,	,
18637	24325	3	10	10	CD
18637	24325	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24325	5	.	.	.
18637	24326	1	553	553	CD
18637	24326	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24326	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24326	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24326	5	,	,	,
18637	24326	6	596	596	CD
18637	24326	7	,	,	,
18637	24326	8	597	597	CD
18637	24326	9	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24326	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24326	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24326	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24326	13	West	West	NNP
18637	24326	14	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24326	15	,	,	,
18637	24326	16	262	262	CD
18637	24326	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24326	18	553	553	CD
18637	24326	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24326	20	1923	1923	CD
18637	24326	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24326	22	,	,	,
18637	24326	23	138	138	CD
18637	24326	24	,	,	,
18637	24326	25	218	218	CD
18637	24326	26	,	,	,
18637	24326	27	243	243	CD
18637	24326	28	,	,	,
18637	24326	29	593	593	CD
18637	24326	30	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24326	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24326	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24326	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24326	34	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	24326	35	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	24326	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24326	37	,	,	,
18637	24326	38	13	13	CD
18637	24326	39	How	how	WRB
18637	24326	40	.	.	.
18637	24327	1	518	518	CD
18637	24327	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24327	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	24327	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24327	5	,	,	,
18637	24327	6	126	126	CD
18637	24327	7	,	,	,
18637	24327	8	127	127	CD
18637	24327	9	,	,	,
18637	24327	10	214	214	CD
18637	24327	11	,	,	,
18637	24327	12	545	545	CD
18637	24327	13	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24327	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24327	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24327	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24327	17	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	24327	18	&	&	CC
18637	24327	19	B.	B.	NNP
18637	24327	20	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	24327	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24327	22	,	,	,
18637	24327	23	18	18	CD
18637	24327	24	How	how	WRB
18637	24327	25	.	.	.
18637	24328	1	421	421	CD
18637	24328	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24328	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	24328	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24328	5	,	,	,
18637	24328	6	120	120	CD
18637	24328	7	,	,	,
18637	24328	8	214	214	CD
18637	24328	9	,	,	,
18637	24328	10	322	322	CD
18637	24328	11	,	,	,
18637	24328	12	369	369	CD
18637	24328	13	,	,	,
18637	24328	14	370	370	CD
18637	24328	15	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24328	16	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	24328	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24328	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24328	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24328	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24328	21	Mahon	Mahon	NNP
18637	24328	22	,	,	,
18637	24328	23	260	260	CD
18637	24328	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24328	25	393	393	CD
18637	24328	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24328	27	1922	1922	CD
18637	24328	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24328	29	,	,	,
18637	24328	30	983	983	CD
18637	24328	31	,	,	,
18637	24328	32	1026	1026	CD
18637	24328	33	,	,	,
18637	24328	34	1065	1065	CD
18637	24328	35	,	,	,
18637	24328	36	1068	1068	CD
18637	24328	37	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24328	38	College	College	NNP
18637	24328	39	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	24328	40	,	,	,
18637	24328	41	13	13	CD
18637	24328	42	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24328	43	.	.	.
18637	24329	1	190	190	CD
18637	24329	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24329	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	24329	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24329	5	,	,	,
18637	24329	6	343	343	CD
18637	24329	7	,	,	,
18637	24329	8	344	344	CD
18637	24329	9	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24329	10	ex	ex	NN
18637	24329	11	rel	rel	NN
18637	24329	12	.	.	.
18637	24330	1	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
18637	24330	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24330	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24330	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24330	5	Ashe	Ashe	NNP
18637	24330	6	,	,	,
18637	24330	7	302	302	CD
18637	24330	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24330	9	51	51	CD
18637	24330	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24330	11	1937	1937	CD
18637	24330	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24330	13	,	,	,
18637	24330	14	1161	1161	CD
18637	24330	15	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24330	16	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24330	17	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24330	18	.	.	.
18637	24331	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24331	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24331	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24331	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24331	5	Gold	Gold	NNP
18637	24331	6	Issue	Issue	NNP
18637	24331	7	Min	Min	NNP
18637	24331	8	.	.	.
18637	24332	1	&	&	CC
18637	24332	2	Mill	Mill	NNP
18637	24332	3	.	.	.
18637	24333	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24333	2	,	,	,
18637	24333	3	243	243	CD
18637	24333	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24333	5	93	93	CD
18637	24333	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24333	7	1917	1917	CD
18637	24333	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24333	9	,	,	,
18637	24333	10	676	676	CD
18637	24333	11	,	,	,
18637	24333	12	1076	1076	CD
18637	24333	13	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24333	14	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	24333	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24333	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24333	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24333	18	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	24333	19	,	,	,
18637	24333	20	245	245	CD
18637	24333	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24333	22	20	20	CD
18637	24333	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24333	24	1917	1917	CD
18637	24333	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24333	26	,	,	,
18637	24333	27	350	350	CD
18637	24333	28	,	,	,
18637	24333	29	352	352	CD
18637	24333	30	,	,	,
18637	24333	31	1063	1063	CD
18637	24333	32	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24333	33	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	24333	34	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24333	35	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24333	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24333	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24333	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24333	39	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24333	40	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	24333	41	.	.	.
18637	24334	1	Com	Com	NNP
18637	24334	2	.	.	NNP
18637	24334	3	,	,	,
18637	24334	4	252	252	CD
18637	24334	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24334	6	23	23	CD
18637	24334	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24334	8	1920	1920	CD
18637	24334	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24334	10	,	,	,
18637	24334	11	233	233	CD
18637	24334	12	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24334	13	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24334	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24334	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24334	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24334	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24334	18	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	24334	19	Brick	Brick	NNP
18637	24334	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24334	21	,	,	,
18637	24334	22	297	297	CD
18637	24334	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24334	24	447	447	CD
18637	24334	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24334	26	1936	1936	CD
18637	24334	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24334	28	,	,	,
18637	24334	29	220	220	CD
18637	24334	30	Pensacola	Pensacola	NNP
18637	24334	31	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24334	32	.	.	.
18637	24335	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24335	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24335	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24335	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24335	5	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24335	6	U.	U.	NNP
18637	24335	7	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24335	8	.	.	.
18637	24336	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24336	2	,	,	,
18637	24336	3	96	96	CD
18637	24336	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24336	5	1	1	CD
18637	24336	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24336	7	1878	1878	CD
18637	24336	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24336	9	,	,	,
18637	24336	10	120	120	CD
18637	24336	11	,	,	,
18637	24336	12	125	125	CD
18637	24336	13	,	,	,
18637	24336	14	133	133	CD
18637	24336	15	,	,	,
18637	24336	16	193	193	CD
18637	24336	17	,	,	,
18637	24336	18	232	232	CD
18637	24336	19	,	,	,
18637	24336	20	270	270	CD
18637	24336	21	Peonage	peonage	NN
18637	24336	22	Cases	case	NNS
18637	24336	23	,	,	,
18637	24336	24	123	123	CD
18637	24336	25	F.	f.	NN
18637	24336	26	671	671	CD
18637	24336	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24336	28	1903	1903	CD
18637	24336	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24336	30	,	,	,
18637	24336	31	951	951	CD
18637	24336	32	People	People	NNPS
18637	24336	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24336	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24336	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24336	36	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24336	37	of	of	IN
18637	24336	38	Supervisors	Supervisors	NNPS
18637	24336	39	,	,	,
18637	24336	40	7	7	CD
18637	24336	41	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24336	42	.	.	.
18637	24337	1	26	26	CD
18637	24337	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24337	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24337	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24337	5	,	,	,
18637	24337	6	729	729	CD
18637	24337	7	People	People	NNS
18637	24337	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24337	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24337	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24337	11	Croswell	Croswell	NNP
18637	24337	12	,	,	,
18637	24337	13	3	3	CD
18637	24337	14	Johns	Johns	NNP
18637	24337	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24337	16	N.Y.	New York	NNP
18637	24337	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24337	18	337	337	CD
18637	24337	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24337	20	1804	1804	CD
18637	24337	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24337	22	,	,	,
18637	24337	23	771	771	CD
18637	24337	24	Peoples	Peoples	NNPS
18637	24337	25	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	24337	26	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24337	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24337	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24337	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24337	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24337	31	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24337	32	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	24337	33	.	.	.
18637	24338	1	Com	Com	NNP
18637	24338	2	.	.	NNP
18637	24338	3	,	,	,
18637	24338	4	270	270	CD
18637	24338	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24338	6	550	550	CD
18637	24338	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24338	8	1926	1926	CD
18637	24338	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24338	10	,	,	,
18637	24338	11	234	234	CD
18637	24338	12	Pep	Pep	NNP
18637	24338	13	Boys	Boys	NNPS
18637	24338	14	,	,	,
18637	24338	15	The	the	DT
18637	24338	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24338	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24338	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24338	19	Pyroil	Pyroil	NNP
18637	24338	20	Sales	Sales	NNP
18637	24338	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24338	22	,	,	,
18637	24338	23	299	299	CD
18637	24338	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24338	25	198	198	CD
18637	24338	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24338	27	1936	1936	CD
18637	24338	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24338	29	,	,	,
18637	24338	30	1018	1018	CD
18637	24338	31	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
18637	24338	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24338	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	24338	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24338	35	Benguet	Benguet	NNP
18637	24338	36	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	24338	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24338	38	,	,	,
18637	24338	39	342	342	CD
18637	24338	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24338	41	437	437	CD
18637	24338	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24338	43	1952	1952	CD
18637	24338	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24338	45	,	,	,
18637	24338	46	1080	1080	CD
18637	24338	47	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
18637	24338	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24338	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	24338	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24338	51	Elg	Elg	NNP
18637	24338	52	,	,	,
18637	24338	53	307	307	CD
18637	24338	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24338	55	325	325	CD
18637	24338	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24338	57	1939	1939	CD
18637	24338	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24338	59	,	,	,
18637	24338	60	258	258	CD
18637	24338	61	,	,	,
18637	24338	62	552	552	CD
18637	24338	63	,	,	,
18637	24338	64	964	964	CD
18637	24338	65	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
18637	24338	66	,	,	,
18637	24338	67	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
18637	24338	68	of	of	IN
18637	24338	69	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24338	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24338	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	24338	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24338	73	Lukens	Lukens	NNP
18637	24338	74	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	24338	75	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24338	76	,	,	,
18637	24338	77	310	310	CD
18637	24338	78	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24338	79	113	113	CD
18637	24338	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24338	81	1940	1940	CD
18637	24338	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24338	83	,	,	,
18637	24338	84	589	589	CD
18637	24338	85	Perley	Perley	NNP
18637	24338	86	_	_	NNP
18637	24338	87	v.	v.	IN
18637	24338	88	_	_	NNP
18637	24338	89	North	North	NNP
18637	24338	90	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24338	91	,	,	,
18637	24338	92	249	249	CD
18637	24338	93	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24338	94	510	510	CD
18637	24338	95	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24338	96	1919	1919	CD
18637	24338	97	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24338	98	,	,	,
18637	24338	99	1030	1030	CD
18637	24338	100	Perlman	Perlman	NNP
18637	24338	101	_	_	NNP
18637	24338	102	v.	v.	IN
18637	24338	103	_	_	NNP
18637	24338	104	United	United	NNP
18637	24338	105	States	States	NNP
18637	24338	106	,	,	,
18637	24338	107	247	247	CD
18637	24338	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24338	109	7	7	CD
18637	24338	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24338	111	1918	1918	CD
18637	24338	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24338	113	,	,	,
18637	24338	114	827	827	CD
18637	24338	115	Permoli	Permoli	NNP
18637	24338	116	_	_	NNP
18637	24338	117	v.	v.	IN
18637	24338	118	_	_	NNP
18637	24338	119	New	New	NNP
18637	24338	120	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24338	121	,	,	,
18637	24338	122	3	3	CD
18637	24338	123	How	how	WRB
18637	24338	124	.	.	.
18637	24339	1	589	589	CD
18637	24339	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24339	3	1845	1845	CD
18637	24339	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24339	5	,	,	,
18637	24339	6	698	698	CD
18637	24339	7	,	,	,
18637	24339	8	699	699	CD
18637	24339	9	,	,	,
18637	24339	10	751	751	CD
18637	24339	11	Perrin	Perrin	NNP
18637	24339	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24339	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24339	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24339	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24339	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24339	17	,	,	,
18637	24339	18	232	232	CD
18637	24339	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24339	20	478	478	CD
18637	24339	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24339	22	1914	1914	CD
18637	24339	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24339	24	,	,	,
18637	24339	25	253	253	CD
18637	24339	26	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	24339	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24339	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24339	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24339	30	Haines	Haines	NNP
18637	24339	31	,	,	,
18637	24339	32	191	191	CD
18637	24339	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24339	34	17	17	CD
18637	24339	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24339	36	1903	1903	CD
18637	24339	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24339	38	,	,	,
18637	24339	39	578	578	CD
18637	24339	40	Perry	Perry	NNP
18637	24339	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24339	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24339	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24339	44	United	United	NNP
18637	24339	45	States	States	NNP
18637	24339	46	,	,	,
18637	24339	47	294	294	CD
18637	24339	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24339	49	330	330	CD
18637	24339	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24339	51	1935	1935	CD
18637	24339	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24339	53	,	,	,
18637	24339	54	118	118	CD
18637	24339	55	,	,	,
18637	24339	56	267	267	CD
18637	24339	57	,	,	,
18637	24339	58	362	362	CD
18637	24339	59	,	,	,
18637	24339	60	857	857	CD
18637	24339	61	,	,	,
18637	24339	62	1174	1174	CD
18637	24339	63	Pervear	Pervear	NNP
18637	24339	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24339	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	24339	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24339	67	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24339	68	,	,	,
18637	24339	69	5	5	CD
18637	24339	70	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24339	71	.	.	.
18637	24340	1	475	475	CD
18637	24340	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24340	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	24340	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24340	5	,	,	,
18637	24340	6	364	364	CD
18637	24340	7	,	,	,
18637	24340	8	751	751	CD
18637	24340	9	Petersen	Petersen	NNP
18637	24340	10	Baking	Baking	NNP
18637	24340	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24340	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24340	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24340	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24340	15	Bryan	Bryan	NNP
18637	24340	16	,	,	,
18637	24340	17	290	290	CD
18637	24340	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24340	19	570	570	CD
18637	24340	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24340	21	1934	1934	CD
18637	24340	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24340	23	,	,	,
18637	24340	24	1019	1019	CD
18637	24340	25	Peterson	Peterson	NNP
18637	24340	26	,	,	,
18637	24340	27	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24340	28	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24340	29	,	,	,
18637	24340	30	253	253	CD
18637	24340	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24340	32	300	300	CD
18637	24340	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24340	34	1920	1920	CD
18637	24340	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24340	36	,	,	,
18637	24340	37	512	512	CD
18637	24340	38	,	,	,
18637	24340	39	527	527	CD
18637	24340	40	,	,	,
18637	24340	41	892	892	CD
18637	24340	42	,	,	,
18637	24340	43	894	894	CD
18637	24340	44	Petit	Petit	NNP
18637	24340	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24340	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	24340	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24340	48	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24340	49	,	,	,
18637	24340	50	177	177	CD
18637	24340	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24340	52	164	164	CD
18637	24340	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24340	54	1900	1900	CD
18637	24340	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24340	56	,	,	,
18637	24340	57	1031	1031	CD
18637	24340	58	,	,	,
18637	24340	59	1154	1154	CD
18637	24340	60	Pettibone	Pettibone	NNP
18637	24340	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24340	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	24340	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24340	64	Nichols	Nichols	NNP
18637	24340	65	,	,	,
18637	24340	66	203	203	CD
18637	24340	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24340	68	192	192	CD
18637	24340	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24340	70	1906	1906	CD
18637	24340	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24340	72	,	,	,
18637	24340	73	695	695	CD
18637	24340	74	,	,	,
18637	24340	75	696	696	CD
18637	24340	76	Peyroux	Peyroux	NNP
18637	24340	77	_	_	NNP
18637	24340	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	24340	79	_	_	NNP
18637	24340	80	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	24340	81	,	,	,
18637	24340	82	7	7	CD
18637	24340	83	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	24340	84	.	.	.
18637	24341	1	324	324	CD
18637	24341	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24341	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	24341	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24341	5	,	,	,
18637	24341	6	577	577	CD
18637	24341	7	Phalen	Phalen	NNP
18637	24341	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24341	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24341	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24341	11	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24341	12	,	,	,
18637	24341	13	8	8	CD
18637	24341	14	How	how	WRB
18637	24341	15	.	.	.
18637	24342	1	163	163	CD
18637	24342	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24342	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	24342	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24342	5	,	,	,
18637	24342	6	358	358	CD
18637	24342	7	Phelps	Phelps	NNP
18637	24342	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24342	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24342	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24342	11	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24342	12	of	of	IN
18637	24342	13	Education	Education	NNP
18637	24342	14	,	,	,
18637	24342	15	300	300	CD
18637	24342	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24342	17	319	319	CD
18637	24342	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24342	19	1937	1937	CD
18637	24342	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24342	21	,	,	,
18637	24342	22	341	341	CD
18637	24342	23	,	,	,
18637	24342	24	1146	1146	CD
18637	24342	25	Phelps	Phelps	NNP
18637	24342	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24342	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24342	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24342	29	United	United	NNP
18637	24342	30	States	States	NNP
18637	24342	31	,	,	,
18637	24342	32	274	274	CD
18637	24342	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24342	34	341	341	CD
18637	24342	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24342	36	1927	1927	CD
18637	24342	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24342	38	,	,	,
18637	24342	39	872	872	CD
18637	24342	40	Phelps	Phelps	NNP
18637	24342	41	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	24342	42	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24342	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24342	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24342	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24342	46	National	National	NNP
18637	24342	47	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24342	48	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	24342	49	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	24342	50	.	.	NNP
18637	24342	51	,	,	,
18637	24342	52	313	313	CD
18637	24342	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24342	54	177	177	CD
18637	24342	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24342	56	1941	1941	CD
18637	24342	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24342	58	,	,	,
18637	24342	59	854	854	CD
18637	24342	60	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	24342	61	,	,	,
18637	24342	62	B.	B.	NNP
18637	24343	1	&	&	CC
18637	24343	2	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	24343	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24343	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24343	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	24343	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24343	7	Schubert	Schubert	NNP
18637	24343	8	,	,	,
18637	24343	9	224	224	CD
18637	24343	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24343	11	603	603	CD
18637	24343	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24343	13	1912	1912	CD
18637	24343	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24343	15	,	,	,
18637	24343	16	855	855	CD
18637	24343	17	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	24343	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24343	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24343	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24343	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24343	22	Stimson	Stimson	NNP
18637	24343	23	,	,	,
18637	24343	24	223	223	CD
18637	24343	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24343	26	605	605	CD
18637	24343	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24343	28	1912	1912	CD
18637	24343	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24343	30	,	,	,
18637	24343	31	501	501	CD
18637	24343	32	,	,	,
18637	24343	33	588	588	CD
18637	24343	34	,	,	,
18637	24343	35	590	590	CD
18637	24343	36	,	,	,
18637	24343	37	855	855	CD
18637	24343	38	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	24343	39	&	&	CC
18637	24343	40	Reading	Reading	NNP
18637	24343	41	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	24343	42	.	.	.
18637	24344	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24344	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24344	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24344	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24344	5	McKibbin	McKibbin	NNP
18637	24344	6	,	,	,
18637	24344	7	243	243	CD
18637	24344	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24344	9	264	264	CD
18637	24344	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24344	11	1917	1917	CD
18637	24344	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24344	13	,	,	,
18637	24344	14	1075	1075	CD
18637	24344	15	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	24344	16	&	&	CC
18637	24344	17	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	24345	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24345	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24345	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24345	4	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24345	5	,	,	,
18637	24345	6	15	15	CD
18637	24345	7	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24345	8	.	.	.
18637	24346	1	232	232	CD
18637	24346	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24346	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	24346	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24346	5	,	,	,
18637	24346	6	180	180	CD
18637	24346	7	,	,	,
18637	24346	8	193	193	CD
18637	24346	9	,	,	,
18637	24346	10	198	198	CD
18637	24346	11	,	,	,
18637	24346	12	200	200	CD
18637	24346	13	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	24346	14	&	&	CC
18637	24346	15	S.	S.	NNP
18637	24346	16	Mail	Mail	NNP
18637	24346	17	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	24346	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24346	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24346	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24346	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24346	22	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24346	23	,	,	,
18637	24346	24	122	122	CD
18637	24346	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24346	26	326	326	CD
18637	24346	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24346	28	1887	1887	CD
18637	24346	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24346	30	,	,	,
18637	24346	31	200	200	CD
18637	24346	32	,	,	,
18637	24346	33	204	204	CD
18637	24346	34	,	,	,
18637	24346	35	366	366	CD
18637	24346	36	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	24346	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24346	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	24346	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24346	40	Comr	Comr	NNP
18637	24346	41	.	.	.
18637	24347	1	of	of	IN
18637	24347	2	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	24347	3	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	24347	4	,	,	,
18637	24347	5	283	283	CD
18637	24347	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24347	7	589	589	CD
18637	24347	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24347	9	1931	1931	CD
18637	24347	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24347	11	,	,	,
18637	24347	12	110	110	CD
18637	24347	13	,	,	,
18637	24347	14	849	849	CD
18637	24347	15	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	24347	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24347	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	19	Dime	Dime	NNP
18637	24347	20	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24347	21	&	&	CC
18637	24347	22	Safe	Safe	NNP
18637	24347	23	Deposit	Deposit	NNP
18637	24347	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24347	25	,	,	,
18637	24347	26	284	284	CD
18637	24347	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24347	28	160	160	CD
18637	24347	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24347	30	1931	1931	CD
18637	24347	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24347	32	,	,	,
18637	24347	33	320	320	CD
18637	24347	34	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	24347	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24347	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	38	Payne	Payne	NNP
18637	24347	39	,	,	,
18637	24347	40	92	92	CD
18637	24347	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24347	42	130	130	CD
18637	24347	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24347	44	1876	1876	CD
18637	24347	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24347	46	,	,	,
18637	24347	47	301	301	CD
18637	24347	48	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	24347	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	24347	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	52	United	United	NNP
18637	24347	53	States	States	NNP
18637	24347	54	,	,	,
18637	24347	55	312	312	CD
18637	24347	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24347	57	246	246	CD
18637	24347	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24347	59	1941	1941	CD
18637	24347	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24347	61	,	,	,
18637	24347	62	631	631	CD
18637	24347	63	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	24347	64	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24347	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	24347	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	68	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	24347	69	,	,	,
18637	24347	70	324	324	CD
18637	24347	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24347	72	490	490	CD
18637	24347	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24347	74	1945	1945	CD
18637	24347	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24347	76	,	,	,
18637	24347	77	157	157	CD
18637	24347	78	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	24347	79	Petroleum	Petroleum	NNP
18637	24347	80	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24347	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	24347	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	84	Jenkins	Jenkins	NNP
18637	24347	85	,	,	,
18637	24347	86	297	297	CD
18637	24347	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24347	88	629	629	CD
18637	24347	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24347	90	1936	1936	CD
18637	24347	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24347	92	,	,	,
18637	24347	93	344	344	CD
18637	24347	94	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
18637	24347	95	Petroleum	Petroleum	NNP
18637	24347	96	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24347	97	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	98	v.	v.	IN
18637	24347	99	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	100	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24347	101	,	,	,
18637	24347	102	ibid	ibid	NNP
18637	24347	103	.	.	.
18637	24347	104	,	,	,
18637	24347	105	190	190	CD
18637	24347	106	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24347	107	1950	1950	CD
18637	24347	108	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24347	109	,	,	,
18637	24347	110	1026	1026	CD
18637	24347	111	Phipps	Phipps	NNP
18637	24347	112	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	24347	114	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	115	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
18637	24347	116	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	24347	117	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24347	118	,	,	,
18637	24347	119	261	261	CD
18637	24347	120	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24347	121	449	449	CD
18637	24347	122	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24347	123	1923	1923	CD
18637	24347	124	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24347	125	,	,	,
18637	24347	126	184	184	CD
18637	24347	127	Phoenix	Phoenix	NNP
18637	24347	128	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24347	129	&	&	CC
18637	24347	130	M.	M.	NNP
18637	24347	131	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	24347	132	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24347	133	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	134	v.	v.	IN
18637	24347	135	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	136	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	24347	137	,	,	,
18637	24347	138	161	161	CD
18637	24347	139	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24347	140	174	174	CD
18637	24347	141	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24347	142	1896	1896	CD
18637	24347	143	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24347	144	,	,	,
18637	24347	145	347	347	CD
18637	24347	146	Picard	Picard	NNP
18637	24347	147	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	148	v.	v.	IN
18637	24347	149	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	150	East	East	NNP
18637	24347	151	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	24347	152	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24347	153	&	&	CC
18637	24347	154	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	24347	155	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24347	156	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24347	157	,	,	,
18637	24347	158	130	130	CD
18637	24347	159	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24347	160	637	637	CD
18637	24347	161	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24347	162	1889	1889	CD
18637	24347	163	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24347	164	,	,	,
18637	24347	165	347	347	CD
18637	24347	166	Pickard	Pickard	NNP
18637	24347	167	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	168	v.	v.	IN
18637	24347	169	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	170	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	24347	171	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24347	172	Car	Car	NNP
18637	24347	173	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24347	174	,	,	,
18637	24347	175	117	117	CD
18637	24347	176	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24347	177	34	34	CD
18637	24347	178	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24347	179	1886	1886	CD
18637	24347	180	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24347	181	,	,	,
18637	24347	182	202	202	CD
18637	24347	183	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	24347	184	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	185	v.	v.	IN
18637	24347	186	_	_	NNP
18637	24347	187	Carskadon	Carskadon	NNP
18637	24347	188	,	,	,
18637	24347	189	16	16	CD
18637	24347	190	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24347	191	.	.	.
18637	24348	1	234	234	CD
18637	24348	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24348	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	24348	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24348	5	,	,	,
18637	24348	6	327	327	CD
18637	24348	7	,	,	,
18637	24348	8	328	328	CD
18637	24348	9	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	24348	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24348	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24348	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24348	13	Creecy	Creecy	NNP
18637	24348	14	,	,	,
18637	24348	15	210	210	CD
18637	24348	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24348	17	387	387	CD
18637	24348	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24348	19	1908	1908	CD
18637	24348	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24348	21	,	,	,
18637	24348	22	695	695	CD
18637	24348	23	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	24348	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24348	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24348	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24348	27	Society	Society	NNP
18637	24348	28	of	of	IN
18637	24348	29	Sisters	Sisters	NNPS
18637	24348	30	,	,	,
18637	24348	31	268	268	CD
18637	24348	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24348	33	510	510	CD
18637	24348	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24348	35	1925	1925	CD
18637	24348	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24348	37	,	,	,
18637	24348	38	765	765	CD
18637	24348	39	,	,	,
18637	24348	40	981	981	CD
18637	24348	41	,	,	,
18637	24348	42	984	984	CD
18637	24348	43	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	24348	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24348	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24348	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24348	47	United	United	NNP
18637	24348	48	States	States	NNP
18637	24348	49	,	,	,
18637	24348	50	160	160	CD
18637	24348	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24348	52	355	355	CD
18637	24348	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24348	54	1896	1896	CD
18637	24348	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24348	56	,	,	,
18637	24348	57	843	843	CD
18637	24348	58	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	24348	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24348	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	24348	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24348	62	United	United	NNP
18637	24348	63	States	States	NNP
18637	24348	64	,	,	,
18637	24348	65	252	252	CD
18637	24348	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24348	67	239	239	CD
18637	24348	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24348	69	1920	1920	CD
18637	24348	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24348	71	,	,	,
18637	24348	72	775	775	CD
18637	24348	73	,	,	,
18637	24348	74	794	794	CD
18637	24348	75	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	24348	76	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24348	77	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24348	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24348	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	24348	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24348	81	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	24348	82	,	,	,
18637	24348	83	248	248	CD
18637	24348	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24348	85	498	498	CD
18637	24348	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24348	87	1919	1919	CD
18637	24348	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24348	89	,	,	,
18637	24348	90	1029	1029	CD
18637	24348	91	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	24348	92	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24348	93	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24348	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24348	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	24348	96	_	_	NNP
18637	24348	97	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	24348	98	,	,	,
18637	24348	99	264	264	CD
18637	24348	100	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24348	101	137	137	CD
18637	24348	102	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24348	103	1924	1924	CD
18637	24348	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24348	105	,	,	,
18637	24348	106	1061	1061	CD
18637	24348	107	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	24348	108	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24348	109	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24348	110	_	_	NNP
18637	24348	111	v.	v.	IN
18637	24348	112	_	_	NNP
18637	24348	113	Phoenix	Phoenix	NNP
18637	24348	114	Ref	Ref	NNP
18637	24348	115	.	.	.
18637	24349	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24349	2	,	,	,
18637	24349	3	259	259	CD
18637	24349	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24349	5	125	125	CD
18637	24349	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24349	7	1922	1922	CD
18637	24349	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24349	9	,	,	,
18637	24349	10	1009	1009	CD
18637	24349	11	Pierre	Pierre	NNP
18637	24349	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24349	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24349	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24349	15	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24349	16	,	,	,
18637	24349	17	306	306	CD
18637	24349	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24349	19	354	354	CD
18637	24349	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24349	21	1939	1939	CD
18637	24349	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24349	23	,	,	,
18637	24349	24	1098	1098	CD
18637	24349	25	,	,	,
18637	24349	26	1168	1168	CD
18637	24349	27	Pietro	Pietro	NNP
18637	24349	28	Campanella	Campanella	NNP
18637	24349	29	,	,	,
18637	24349	30	The	the	DT
18637	24349	31	,	,	,
18637	24349	32	73	73	CD
18637	24349	33	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24349	34	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	24349	35	.	.	.
18637	24350	1	18	18	CD
18637	24350	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24350	3	1947	1947	CD
18637	24350	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24350	5	,	,	,
18637	24350	6	1174	1174	CD
18637	24350	7	Pink	Pink	NNP
18637	24350	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24350	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24350	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24350	11	A.A.A.	A.A.A.	NNP
18637	24351	1	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	24351	2	Express	Express	NNP
18637	24351	3	,	,	,
18637	24351	4	314	314	CD
18637	24351	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24351	6	201	201	CD
18637	24351	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24351	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	24351	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24351	10	,	,	,
18637	24351	11	680	680	CD
18637	24351	12	Pinkerton	Pinkerton	NNP
18637	24351	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24351	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24351	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24351	16	United	United	NNP
18637	24351	17	States	States	NNP
18637	24351	18	,	,	,
18637	24351	19	328	328	CD
18637	24351	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24351	21	640	640	CD
18637	24351	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24351	23	1946	1946	CD
18637	24351	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24351	25	,	,	,
18637	24351	26	840	840	CD
18637	24351	27	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	24351	28	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24351	29	Cases	case	NNS
18637	24351	30	.	.	.
18637	24352	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24352	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24352	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24352	4	United	United	NNP
18637	24352	5	States	States	NNP
18637	24352	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24352	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	24352	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24352	9	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24352	10	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24352	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24352	12	Piqua	Piqua	NNP
18637	24352	13	Branch	Branch	NNP
18637	24352	14	of	of	IN
18637	24352	15	the	the	DT
18637	24352	16	State	State	NNP
18637	24352	17	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24352	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24352	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24352	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24352	21	Knoop	Knoop	NNP
18637	24352	22	,	,	,
18637	24352	23	16	16	CD
18637	24352	24	How	how	WRB
18637	24352	25	.	.	.
18637	24353	1	369	369	CD
18637	24353	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24353	3	1854	1854	CD
18637	24353	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24353	5	,	,	,
18637	24353	6	342	342	CD
18637	24353	7	Pitney	Pitney	NNP
18637	24353	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24353	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24353	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24353	11	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24353	12	,	,	,
18637	24353	13	240	240	CD
18637	24353	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24353	15	387	387	CD
18637	24353	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24353	17	1916	1916	CD
18637	24353	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24353	19	,	,	,
18637	24353	20	184	184	CD
18637	24353	21	,	,	,
18637	24353	22	1019	1019	CD
18637	24353	23	Pittman	Pittman	NNP
18637	24353	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24353	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24353	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24353	27	Home	Home	NNP
18637	24353	28	Owners	Owners	NNP
18637	24353	29	'	'	POS
18637	24353	30	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	24353	31	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24353	32	,	,	,
18637	24353	33	308	308	CD
18637	24353	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24353	35	21	21	CD
18637	24353	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24353	37	1939	1939	CD
18637	24353	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24353	39	,	,	,
18637	24353	40	309	309	CD
18637	24353	41	,	,	,
18637	24353	42	733	733	NNP
18637	24353	43	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	24353	44	,	,	,
18637	24353	45	C.C.	C.C.	NNP
18637	24354	1	&	&	CC
18637	24354	2	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24354	3	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	24355	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24355	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24355	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24355	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24355	5	Backus	Backus	NNP
18637	24355	6	,	,	,
18637	24355	7	154	154	CD
18637	24355	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24355	9	421	421	CD
18637	24355	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24355	11	1894	1894	CD
18637	24355	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24355	13	,	,	,
18637	24355	14	201	201	CD
18637	24355	15	,	,	,
18637	24355	16	1053	1053	CD
18637	24355	17	,	,	,
18637	24355	18	1058	1058	CD
18637	24355	19	,	,	,
18637	24355	20	1140	1140	CD
18637	24355	21	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	24355	22	,	,	,
18637	24355	23	C.C.	C.C.	NNP
18637	24356	1	&	&	CC
18637	24356	2	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24356	3	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	24357	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24357	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24357	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24357	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24357	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24357	6	of	of	IN
18637	24357	7	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24357	8	Works	Works	NNP
18637	24357	9	,	,	,
18637	24357	10	172	172	CD
18637	24357	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24357	12	32	32	CD
18637	24357	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24357	14	1898	1898	CD
18637	24357	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24357	16	,	,	,
18637	24357	17	1058	1058	CD
18637	24357	18	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	24357	19	&	&	CC
18637	24357	20	S.	S.	NNP
18637	24357	21	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	24357	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24357	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24357	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24357	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24357	26	Bates	Bates	NNP
18637	24357	27	,	,	,
18637	24357	28	156	156	CD
18637	24357	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24357	30	577	577	CD
18637	24357	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24357	32	1895	1895	CD
18637	24357	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24357	34	,	,	,
18637	24357	35	124	124	CD
18637	24357	36	,	,	,
18637	24357	37	183	183	CD
18637	24357	38	Pizitz	Pizitz	NNP
18637	24357	39	Dry	Dry	NNP
18637	24357	40	Goods	Goods	NNPS
18637	24357	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24357	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24357	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24357	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24357	45	Yeldell	Yeldell	NNP
18637	24357	46	,	,	,
18637	24357	47	274	274	CD
18637	24357	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24357	49	112	112	CD
18637	24357	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24357	51	1927	1927	CD
18637	24357	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24357	53	,	,	,
18637	24357	54	1092	1092	CD
18637	24357	55	Plaquemines	Plaquemines	NNP
18637	24357	56	Tropical	Tropical	NNP
18637	24357	57	Fruit	Fruit	NNP
18637	24357	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24357	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24357	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	24357	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24357	62	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	24357	63	,	,	,
18637	24357	64	170	170	CD
18637	24357	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24357	66	511	511	CD
18637	24357	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24357	68	1898	1898	CD
18637	24357	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24357	70	,	,	,
18637	24357	71	620	620	CD
18637	24357	72	Pleasants	Pleasants	NNPS
18637	24357	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24357	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	24357	75	_	_	NNP
18637	24357	76	Fant	Fant	NNP
18637	24357	77	,	,	,
18637	24357	78	22	22	CD
18637	24357	79	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24357	80	.	.	.
18637	24358	1	116	116	CD
18637	24358	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24358	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	24358	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24358	5	,	,	,
18637	24358	6	896	896	CD
18637	24358	7	Plessy	Plessy	NNP
18637	24358	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24358	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	11	Ferguson	Ferguson	NNP
18637	24358	12	,	,	,
18637	24358	13	163	163	CD
18637	24358	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24358	15	537	537	CD
18637	24358	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24358	17	1896	1896	CD
18637	24358	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24358	19	,	,	,
18637	24358	20	952	952	CD
18637	24358	21	,	,	,
18637	24358	22	1162	1162	CD
18637	24358	23	Plumley	Plumley	NNP
18637	24358	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24358	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	27	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24358	28	,	,	,
18637	24358	29	155	155	CD
18637	24358	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24358	31	461	461	CD
18637	24358	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24358	33	1894	1894	CD
18637	24358	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24358	35	,	,	,
18637	24358	36	239	239	CD
18637	24358	37	,	,	,
18637	24358	38	241	241	CD
18637	24358	39	Plummer	Plummer	NNP
18637	24358	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24358	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	43	Coler	Coler	NNP
18637	24358	44	,	,	,
18637	24358	45	178	178	CD
18637	24358	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24358	47	115	115	CD
18637	24358	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24358	49	1900	1900	CD
18637	24358	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24358	51	,	,	,
18637	24358	52	730	730	CD
18637	24358	53	Plymouth	Plymouth	NNP
18637	24358	54	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	24358	55	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24358	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24358	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	59	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24358	60	,	,	,
18637	24358	61	232	232	CD
18637	24358	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24358	63	531	531	CD
18637	24358	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24358	65	1914	1914	CD
18637	24358	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24358	67	,	,	,
18637	24358	68	987	987	CD
18637	24358	69	Poe	Poe	NNP
18637	24358	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	24358	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	73	Seaborn	Seaborn	NNP
18637	24358	74	,	,	,
18637	24358	75	282	282	CD
18637	24358	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24358	77	101	101	CD
18637	24358	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24358	79	1930	1930	CD
18637	24358	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24358	81	,	,	,
18637	24358	82	110	110	CD
18637	24358	83	Poindexter	Poindexter	NNP
18637	24358	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	24358	86	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	87	Greenhow	Greenhow	NNP
18637	24358	88	,	,	,
18637	24358	89	114	114	CD
18637	24358	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24358	91	270	270	CD
18637	24358	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24358	93	1885	1885	CD
18637	24358	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24358	95	,	,	,
18637	24358	96	326	326	CD
18637	24358	97	,	,	,
18637	24358	98	356	356	CD
18637	24358	99	,	,	,
18637	24358	100	931	931	CD
18637	24358	101	,	,	,
18637	24358	102	933	933	CD
18637	24358	103	Polish	Polish	NNP
18637	24358	104	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
18637	24358	105	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	106	v.	v.	IN
18637	24358	107	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	108	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24358	109	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24358	110	,	,	,
18637	24358	111	322	322	CD
18637	24358	112	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24358	113	643	643	CD
18637	24358	114	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24358	115	1944	1944	CD
18637	24358	116	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24358	117	,	,	,
18637	24358	118	173	173	CD
18637	24358	119	Polk	Polk	NNP
18637	24358	120	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	121	v.	v.	IN
18637	24358	122	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	123	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
18637	24358	124	Reserve	Reserve	NNP
18637	24358	125	Fund	Fund	NNP
18637	24358	126	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24358	127	Association	Association	NNP
18637	24358	128	,	,	,
18637	24358	129	207	207	CD
18637	24358	130	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24358	131	310	310	CD
18637	24358	132	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24358	133	1907	1907	CD
18637	24358	134	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24358	135	,	,	,
18637	24358	136	1023	1023	CD
18637	24358	137	Pollard	Pollard	NNP
18637	24358	138	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	139	v.	v.	IN
18637	24358	140	_	_	NNP
18637	24358	141	Hagan	Hagan	NNP
18637	24358	142	,	,	,
18637	24358	143	3	3	CD
18637	24358	144	How	how	WRB
18637	24358	145	.	.	.
18637	24359	1	212	212	CD
18637	24359	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24359	3	1845	1845	CD
18637	24359	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24359	5	,	,	,
18637	24359	6	130	130	CD
18637	24359	7	,	,	,
18637	24359	8	698	698	CD
18637	24359	9	,	,	,
18637	24359	10	699	699	CD
18637	24359	11	,	,	,
18637	24359	12	700	700	CD
18637	24359	13	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	24359	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24359	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24359	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24359	17	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	24359	18	'	'	POS
18637	24359	19	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	24359	20	&	&	CC
18637	24359	21	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24359	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24359	23	,	,	,
18637	24359	24	157	157	CD
18637	24359	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24359	26	429	429	CD
18637	24359	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24359	28	1895	1895	CD
18637	24359	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24359	30	,	,	,
18637	24359	31	106	106	CD
18637	24359	32	,	,	,
18637	24359	33	317	317	CD
18637	24359	34	,	,	,
18637	24359	35	541	541	CD
18637	24359	36	,	,	,
18637	24359	37	565	565	CD
18637	24359	38	,	,	,
18637	24359	39	1191	1191	CD
18637	24359	40	-	-	SYM
18637	24359	41	1193	1193	CD
18637	24359	42	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	24359	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24359	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24359	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24359	46	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	24359	47	'	'	POS
18637	24359	48	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	24359	49	&	&	CC
18637	24359	50	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24359	51	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24359	52	,	,	,
18637	24359	53	158	158	CD
18637	24359	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24359	55	601	601	CD
18637	24359	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24359	57	1895	1895	CD
18637	24359	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24359	59	,	,	,
18637	24359	60	319	319	CD
18637	24359	61	,	,	,
18637	24359	62	565	565	CD
18637	24359	63	,	,	,
18637	24359	64	1191	1191	CD
18637	24359	65	-	-	SYM
18637	24359	66	1193	1193	CD
18637	24359	67	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
18637	24359	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24359	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	24359	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24359	71	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24359	72	,	,	,
18637	24359	73	322	322	CD
18637	24359	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24359	75	4	4	CD
18637	24359	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24359	77	1944	1944	CD
18637	24359	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24359	79	,	,	,
18637	24359	80	951	951	CD
18637	24359	81	Ponzi	Ponzi	NNP
18637	24359	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24359	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	24359	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24359	85	Fessenden	Fessenden	NNP
18637	24359	86	,	,	,
18637	24359	87	258	258	CD
18637	24359	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24359	89	254	254	CD
18637	24359	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24359	91	1922	1922	CD
18637	24359	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24359	93	,	,	,
18637	24359	94	634	634	CD
18637	24359	95	Poole	Poole	NNP
18637	24359	96	_	_	NNP
18637	24359	97	v.	v.	IN
18637	24359	98	_	_	NNP
18637	24359	99	Fleeger	Fleeger	NNP
18637	24359	100	,	,	,
18637	24359	101	11	11	CD
18637	24359	102	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24359	103	.	.	.
18637	24360	1	185	185	CD
18637	24360	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24360	3	1837	1837	CD
18637	24360	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24360	5	,	,	,
18637	24360	6	367	367	CD
18637	24360	7	,	,	,
18637	24360	8	370	370	CD
18637	24360	9	Pope	Pope	NNP
18637	24360	10	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	24360	11	.	.	.
18637	24361	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24361	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24361	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24361	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24361	5	Gormully	Gormully	NNP
18637	24361	6	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	24361	7	.	.	.
18637	24362	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24362	2	,	,	,
18637	24362	3	144	144	CD
18637	24362	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24362	5	238	238	CD
18637	24362	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24362	7	1892	1892	CD
18637	24362	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24362	9	,	,	,
18637	24362	10	273	273	CD
18637	24362	11	Pope	Pope	NNP
18637	24362	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24362	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24362	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24362	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24362	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24362	17	,	,	,
18637	24362	18	323	323	CD
18637	24362	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24362	20	1	1	CD
18637	24362	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24362	22	1944	1944	CD
18637	24362	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24362	24	,	,	,
18637	24362	25	117	117	CD
18637	24362	26	,	,	,
18637	24362	27	311	311	CD
18637	24362	28	,	,	,
18637	24362	29	536	536	CD
18637	24362	30	Pope	Pope	NNP
18637	24362	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24362	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24362	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24362	34	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24362	35	,	,	,
18637	24362	36	193	193	CD
18637	24362	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24362	38	621	621	CD
18637	24362	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24362	40	1904	1904	CD
18637	24362	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24362	42	,	,	,
18637	24362	43	971	971	CD
18637	24362	44	,	,	,
18637	24362	45	1165	1165	CD
18637	24362	46	Poresky	Poresky	NNP
18637	24362	47	,	,	,
18637	24362	48	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24362	49	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24362	50	,	,	,
18637	24362	51	290	290	CD
18637	24362	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24362	53	30	30	CD
18637	24362	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24362	55	1933	1933	CD
18637	24362	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24362	57	,	,	,
18637	24362	58	1033	1033	CD
18637	24362	59	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	24362	60	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	24362	61	,	,	,
18637	24362	62	Light	Light	NNP
18637	24362	63	&	&	CC
18637	24362	64	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24362	65	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24362	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24362	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	24362	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24362	69	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24362	70	Com	Com	NNP
18637	24362	71	.	.	.
18637	24363	1	of	of	IN
18637	24363	2	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24363	3	,	,	,
18637	24363	4	229	229	CD
18637	24363	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24363	6	397	397	CD
18637	24363	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24363	8	1913	1913	CD
18637	24363	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24363	10	,	,	,
18637	24363	11	358	358	CD
18637	24363	12	Port	Port	NNP
18637	24363	13	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	24363	14	&	&	CC
18637	24363	15	Bergen	Bergen	NNP
18637	24363	16	Point	Point	NNP
18637	24363	17	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	24363	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24363	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24363	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24363	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24363	22	Bd	Bd	NNP
18637	24363	23	.	.	.
18637	24364	1	of	of	IN
18637	24364	2	Chosen	Chosen	NNP
18637	24364	3	Freeholders	Freeholders	NNP
18637	24364	4	,	,	,
18637	24364	5	234	234	CD
18637	24364	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24364	7	317	317	CD
18637	24364	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24364	9	1914	1914	CD
18637	24364	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24364	11	,	,	,
18637	24364	12	231	231	CD
18637	24364	13	Portsmouth	Portsmouth	NNP
18637	24364	14	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	24364	15	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24364	16	&	&	CC
18637	24364	17	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	24364	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24364	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24364	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24364	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24364	22	United	United	NNP
18637	24364	23	States	States	NNP
18637	24364	24	,	,	,
18637	24364	25	250	250	CD
18637	24364	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24364	27	1	1	CD
18637	24364	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24364	29	1919	1919	CD
18637	24364	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24364	31	,	,	,
18637	24364	32	867	867	CD
18637	24364	33	Portsmouth	Portsmouth	NNP
18637	24364	34	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	24364	35	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24364	36	&	&	CC
18637	24364	37	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	24364	38	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24364	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24364	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24364	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24364	42	United	United	NNP
18637	24364	43	States	States	NNP
18637	24364	44	,	,	,
18637	24364	45	260	260	CD
18637	24364	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24364	47	327	327	CD
18637	24364	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24364	49	1922	1922	CD
18637	24364	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24364	51	,	,	,
18637	24364	52	496	496	CD
18637	24364	53	,	,	,
18637	24364	54	867	867	CD
18637	24364	55	,	,	,
18637	24364	56	1065	1065	CD
18637	24364	57	,	,	,
18637	24364	58	1068	1068	CD
18637	24364	59	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	24364	60	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24364	61	.	.	.
18637	24365	1	Cable	Cable	NNP
18637	24365	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24365	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24365	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	24365	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24365	6	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	24365	7	,	,	,
18637	24365	8	155	155	CD
18637	24365	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24365	10	688	688	CD
18637	24365	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24365	12	1895	1895	CD
18637	24365	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24365	14	,	,	,
18637	24365	15	203	203	CD
18637	24365	16	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	24365	17	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24365	18	.	.	.
18637	24366	1	Cable	Cable	NNP
18637	24366	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24366	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24366	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	24366	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24366	6	New	New	NNP
18637	24366	7	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	24366	8	,	,	,
18637	24366	9	192	192	CD
18637	24366	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24366	11	55	55	CD
18637	24366	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24366	13	1904	1904	CD
18637	24366	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24366	15	,	,	,
18637	24366	16	214	214	CD
18637	24366	17	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	24366	18	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24366	19	.	.	.
18637	24367	1	Cable	Cable	NNP
18637	24367	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24367	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24367	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	24367	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24367	6	Newport	Newport	NNP
18637	24367	7	,	,	,
18637	24367	8	247	247	CD
18637	24367	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24367	10	464	464	CD
18637	24367	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24367	12	1918	1918	CD
18637	24367	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24367	14	,	,	,
18637	24367	15	1088	1088	CD
18637	24367	16	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	24367	17	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24367	18	.	.	.
18637	24368	1	Cable	Cable	NNP
18637	24368	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24368	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24368	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	24368	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24368	6	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	24368	7	,	,	,
18637	24368	8	249	249	CD
18637	24368	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24368	10	252	252	CD
18637	24368	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24368	12	1919	1919	CD
18637	24368	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24368	14	,	,	,
18637	24368	15	232	232	CD
18637	24368	16	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	24368	17	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24368	18	.	.	.
18637	24369	1	Cable	Cable	NNP
18637	24369	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24369	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24369	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	24369	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24369	6	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24369	7	,	,	,
18637	24369	8	192	192	CD
18637	24369	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24369	10	64	64	CD
18637	24369	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24369	12	1904	1904	CD
18637	24369	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24369	14	,	,	,
18637	24369	15	214	214	CD
18637	24369	16	Postum	Postum	NNP
18637	24369	17	Cereal	Cereal	NNP
18637	24369	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24369	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24369	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24369	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24369	22	California	California	NNP
18637	24369	23	Fig	Fig	NNP
18637	24369	24	Nut	Nut	NNP
18637	24369	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24369	26	,	,	,
18637	24369	27	272	272	CD
18637	24369	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24369	29	693	693	CD
18637	24369	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24369	31	1927	1927	CD
18637	24369	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24369	33	,	,	,
18637	24369	34	514	514	CD
18637	24369	35	,	,	,
18637	24369	36	536	536	CD
18637	24369	37	,	,	,
18637	24369	38	623	623	CD
18637	24369	39	Potter	Potter	NNP
18637	24369	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24369	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24369	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24369	43	United	United	NNP
18637	24369	44	States	States	NNP
18637	24369	45	,	,	,
18637	24369	46	155	155	CD
18637	24369	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24369	48	438	438	CD
18637	24369	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24369	50	1894	1894	CD
18637	24369	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24369	52	,	,	,
18637	24369	53	884	884	CD
18637	24369	54	Potts	Potts	NNP
18637	24369	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24369	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24369	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24369	58	Creager	Creager	NNP
18637	24369	59	,	,	,
18637	24369	60	155	155	CD
18637	24369	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24369	62	597	597	CD
18637	24369	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24369	64	1895	1895	CD
18637	24369	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24369	66	,	,	,
18637	24369	67	273	273	CD
18637	24369	68	Pound	Pound	NNP
18637	24369	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24369	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	24369	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24369	72	Turck	Turck	NNP
18637	24369	73	,	,	,
18637	24369	74	95	95	CD
18637	24369	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24369	76	459	459	CD
18637	24369	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24369	78	1878	1878	CD
18637	24369	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24369	80	,	,	,
18637	24369	81	231	231	CD
18637	24369	82	Powell	Powell	NNP
18637	24369	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24369	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	24369	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24369	86	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	24369	87	,	,	,
18637	24369	88	287	287	CD
18637	24369	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24369	90	45	45	CD
18637	24369	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24369	92	1932	1932	CD
18637	24369	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24369	94	,	,	,
18637	24369	95	1098	1098	CD
18637	24369	96	,	,	,
18637	24369	97	1099	1099	CD
18637	24369	98	,	,	,
18637	24369	99	1101	1101	CD
18637	24369	100	,	,	,
18637	24369	101	1108	1108	CD
18637	24369	102	,	,	,
18637	24369	103	1133	1133	CD
18637	24369	104	Powell	Powell	NNP
18637	24369	105	_	_	NNP
18637	24369	106	v.	v.	IN
18637	24369	107	_	_	NNP
18637	24369	108	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24369	109	,	,	,
18637	24369	110	127	127	CD
18637	24369	111	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24369	112	678	678	CD
18637	24369	113	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24369	114	1888	1888	CD
18637	24369	115	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24369	116	,	,	,
18637	24369	117	976	976	CD
18637	24369	118	,	,	,
18637	24369	119	977	977	CD
18637	24369	120	,	,	,
18637	24369	121	1030	1030	CD
18637	24369	122	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24369	123	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
18637	24369	124	.	.	.
18637	24370	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24370	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24370	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24370	4	Pipeline	Pipeline	NNP
18637	24370	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24370	6	,	,	,
18637	24370	7	315	315	CD
18637	24370	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24370	9	575	575	CD
18637	24370	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24370	11	1942	1942	CD
18637	24370	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24370	13	,	,	,
18637	24370	14	998	998	CD
18637	24370	15	,	,	,
18637	24370	16	1007	1007	CD
18637	24370	17	,	,	,
18637	24370	18	1008	1008	CD
18637	24370	19	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24370	20	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	24370	21	.	.	.
18637	24371	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24371	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24371	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	5	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
18637	24371	6	,	,	,
18637	24371	7	274	274	CD
18637	24371	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24371	9	490	490	CD
18637	24371	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24371	11	1927	1927	CD
18637	24371	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24371	13	,	,	,
18637	24371	14	1167	1167	CD
18637	24371	15	Prentis	Prentis	NNP
18637	24371	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24371	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	19	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	24371	20	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	24371	21	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24371	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24371	23	,	,	,
18637	24371	24	211	211	CD
18637	24371	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24371	26	210	210	CD
18637	24371	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24371	28	1908	1908	CD
18637	24371	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24371	30	,	,	,
18637	24371	31	631	631	CD
18637	24371	32	,	,	,
18637	24371	33	1009	1009	CD
18637	24371	34	Presser	Presser	NNP
18637	24371	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24371	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	38	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	24371	39	,	,	,
18637	24371	40	116	116	CD
18637	24371	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24371	42	252	252	CD
18637	24371	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24371	44	1886	1886	CD
18637	24371	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24371	46	,	,	,
18637	24371	47	366	366	CD
18637	24371	48	,	,	,
18637	24371	49	813	813	CD
18637	24371	50	,	,	,
18637	24371	51	971	971	CD
18637	24371	52	Preston	Preston	NNP
18637	24371	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	24371	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	56	Manard	Manard	NNP
18637	24371	57	,	,	,
18637	24371	58	116	116	CD
18637	24371	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24371	60	661	661	CD
18637	24371	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24371	62	1886	1886	CD
18637	24371	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24371	64	,	,	,
18637	24371	65	273	273	CD
18637	24371	66	Price	Price	NNP
18637	24371	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	24371	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	70	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	24371	71	,	,	,
18637	24371	72	238	238	CD
18637	24371	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24371	74	446	446	CD
18637	24371	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24371	76	1915	1915	CD
18637	24371	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24371	78	,	,	,
18637	24371	79	1031	1031	CD
18637	24371	80	,	,	,
18637	24371	81	1154	1154	CD
18637	24371	82	Price	Price	NNP
18637	24371	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	24371	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	86	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	24371	87	,	,	,
18637	24371	88	334	334	CD
18637	24371	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24371	90	266	266	CD
18637	24371	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24371	92	1948	1948	CD
18637	24371	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24371	94	,	,	,
18637	24371	95	313	313	CD
18637	24371	96	,	,	,
18637	24371	97	315	315	CD
18637	24371	98	Price	Price	NNP
18637	24371	99	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	24371	101	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	102	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24371	103	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24371	104	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24371	105	,	,	,
18637	24371	106	113	113	CD
18637	24371	107	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24371	108	218	218	CD
18637	24371	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24371	110	1885	1885	CD
18637	24371	111	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24371	112	,	,	,
18637	24371	113	270	270	CD
18637	24371	114	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
18637	24371	115	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	116	v.	v.	IN
18637	24371	117	_	_	NNP
18637	24371	118	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24371	119	,	,	,
18637	24371	120	16	16	CD
18637	24371	121	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24371	122	.	.	.
18637	24372	1	539	539	CD
18637	24372	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24372	3	1842	1842	CD
18637	24372	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24372	5	,	,	,
18637	24372	6	72	72	CD
18637	24372	7	,	,	,
18637	24372	8	73	73	CD
18637	24372	9	,	,	,
18637	24372	10	427	427	CD
18637	24372	11	,	,	,
18637	24372	12	636	636	CD
18637	24372	13	,	,	,
18637	24372	14	637	637	CD
18637	24372	15	,	,	,
18637	24372	16	694	694	CD
18637	24372	17	,	,	,
18637	24372	18	696	696	CD
18637	24372	19	,	,	,
18637	24372	20	737	737	CD
18637	24372	21	Prince	Prince	NNP
18637	24372	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24372	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24372	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24372	25	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24372	26	,	,	,
18637	24372	27	321	321	CD
18637	24372	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24372	29	158	158	CD
18637	24372	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24372	31	1944	1944	CD
18637	24372	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24372	33	,	,	,
18637	24372	34	563	563	CD
18637	24372	35	,	,	,
18637	24372	36	768	768	CD
18637	24372	37	Princess	Princess	NNP
18637	24372	38	Lida	Lida	NNP
18637	24372	39	of	of	IN
18637	24372	40	Thurn	Thurn	NNP
18637	24372	41	&	&	CC
18637	24372	42	Taxis	Taxis	NNP
18637	24372	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24372	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24372	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24372	46	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24372	47	,	,	,
18637	24372	48	305	305	CD
18637	24372	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24372	50	456	456	CD
18637	24372	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24372	52	1939	1939	CD
18637	24372	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24372	54	,	,	,
18637	24372	55	627	627	CD
18637	24372	56	Principality	Principality	NNP
18637	24372	57	of	of	IN
18637	24372	58	Monaco	Monaco	NNP
18637	24372	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24372	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	24372	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24372	62	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	24372	63	,	,	,
18637	24372	64	292	292	CD
18637	24372	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24372	66	313	313	CD
18637	24372	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24372	68	1934	1934	CD
18637	24372	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24372	70	,	,	,
18637	24372	71	609	609	CD
18637	24372	72	Prize	Prize	NNP
18637	24372	73	Cases	case	NNS
18637	24372	74	,	,	,
18637	24372	75	The	the	DT
18637	24372	76	,	,	,
18637	24372	77	2	2	CD
18637	24372	78	Black	Black	NNP
18637	24372	79	635	635	CD
18637	24372	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24372	81	1863	1863	CD
18637	24372	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24372	83	,	,	,
18637	24372	84	283	283	CD
18637	24372	85	,	,	,
18637	24372	86	390	390	CD
18637	24372	87	Propper	Propper	NNP
18637	24372	88	_	_	NNP
18637	24372	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	24372	90	_	_	NNP
18637	24372	91	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	24372	92	,	,	,
18637	24372	93	337	337	CD
18637	24372	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24372	95	472	472	CD
18637	24372	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24372	97	1949	1949	CD
18637	24372	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24372	99	,	,	,
18637	24372	100	627	627	CD
18637	24372	101	Prosser	Prosser	NNP
18637	24372	102	_	_	NNP
18637	24372	103	v.	v.	IN
18637	24372	104	_	_	NNP
18637	24372	105	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	24372	106	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24373	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24373	2	,	,	,
18637	24373	3	152	152	CD
18637	24373	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24373	5	59	59	CD
18637	24373	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24373	7	1894	1894	CD
18637	24373	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24373	9	,	,	,
18637	24373	10	231	231	CD
18637	24373	11	Prout	Prout	NNP
18637	24373	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24373	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24373	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24373	15	Starr	Starr	NNP
18637	24373	16	,	,	,
18637	24373	17	188	188	CD
18637	24373	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24373	19	537	537	CD
18637	24373	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24373	21	1903	1903	CD
18637	24373	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24373	23	,	,	,
18637	24373	24	629	629	CD
18637	24373	25	,	,	,
18637	24373	26	931	931	CD
18637	24373	27	Providence	Providence	NNP
18637	24373	28	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24373	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24373	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24373	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24373	32	Billings	Billings	NNP
18637	24373	33	,	,	,
18637	24373	34	4	4	CD
18637	24373	35	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24373	36	.	.	.
18637	24374	1	514	514	CD
18637	24374	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24374	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	24374	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24374	5	,	,	,
18637	24374	6	339	339	CD
18637	24374	7	,	,	,
18637	24374	8	345	345	CD
18637	24374	9	,	,	,
18637	24374	10	563	563	CD
18637	24374	11	Providence	Providence	NNP
18637	24374	12	&	&	CC
18637	24374	13	N.Y.S.S.	N.Y.S.S.	NNP
18637	24375	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24375	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24375	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24375	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24375	5	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	24375	6	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	24375	7	.	.	.
18637	24376	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24376	2	,	,	,
18637	24376	3	109	109	CD
18637	24376	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24376	5	578	578	CD
18637	24376	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24376	7	1883	1883	CD
18637	24376	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24376	9	,	,	,
18637	24376	10	130	130	CD
18637	24376	11	Provident	Provident	NNP
18637	24376	12	Inst	Inst	NNP
18637	24376	13	.	.	.
18637	24377	1	for	for	IN
18637	24377	2	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	24377	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24377	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	24377	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24377	6	Malone	Malone	NNP
18637	24377	7	,	,	,
18637	24377	8	221	221	CD
18637	24377	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24377	10	660	660	CD
18637	24377	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24377	12	1911	1911	CD
18637	24377	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24377	14	,	,	,
18637	24377	15	1020	1020	CD
18637	24377	16	Provident	Provident	NNP
18637	24377	17	Inst	Inst	NNP
18637	24377	18	.	.	.
18637	24378	1	for	for	IN
18637	24378	2	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	24378	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24378	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	24378	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24378	6	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24378	7	,	,	,
18637	24378	8	6	6	CD
18637	24378	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24378	10	.	.	.
18637	24379	1	611	611	CD
18637	24379	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24379	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	24379	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24379	5	,	,	,
18637	24379	6	730	730	CD
18637	24379	7	Provident	Provident	NNP
18637	24379	8	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	24379	9	.	.	.
18637	24380	1	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24380	2	Assur	Assur	NNP
18637	24380	3	.	.	.
18637	24381	1	Soc	Soc	NNP
18637	24381	2	.	.	.
18637	24382	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24382	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24382	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24382	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	24382	5	,	,	,
18637	24382	6	239	239	CD
18637	24382	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24382	8	103	103	CD
18637	24382	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24382	10	1915	1915	CD
18637	24382	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24382	12	,	,	,
18637	24382	13	1055	1055	CD
18637	24382	14	Provo	Provo	NNP
18637	24382	15	Bench	Bench	NNP
18637	24382	16	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	24382	17	&	&	CC
18637	24382	18	Irrig	Irrig	NNP
18637	24382	19	.	.	.
18637	24383	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24383	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24383	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24383	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24383	5	Tanner	Tanner	NNP
18637	24383	6	,	,	,
18637	24383	7	239	239	CD
18637	24383	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24383	9	323	323	CD
18637	24383	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24383	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	24383	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24383	13	,	,	,
18637	24383	14	1066	1066	CD
18637	24383	15	Prudential	Prudential	NNP
18637	24383	16	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24383	17	.	.	.
18637	24384	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24384	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24384	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24384	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24384	5	Cheek	Cheek	NNP
18637	24384	6	,	,	,
18637	24384	7	259	259	CD
18637	24384	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24384	9	530	530	CD
18637	24384	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24384	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	24384	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24384	13	,	,	,
18637	24384	14	771	771	CD
18637	24384	15	,	,	,
18637	24384	16	992	992	CD
18637	24384	17	,	,	,
18637	24384	18	1158	1158	CD
18637	24384	19	Prudential	Prudential	NNP
18637	24384	20	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	24384	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24384	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24384	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24384	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24384	25	Benjamin	Benjamin	NNP
18637	24384	26	,	,	,
18637	24384	27	328	328	CD
18637	24384	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24384	29	408	408	CD
18637	24384	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24384	31	1946	1946	CD
18637	24384	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24384	33	,	,	,
18637	24384	34	127	127	CD
18637	24384	35	,	,	,
18637	24384	36	176	176	CD
18637	24384	37	,	,	,
18637	24384	38	198	198	CD
18637	24384	39	,	,	,
18637	24384	40	214	214	CD
18637	24384	41	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24384	42	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24384	43	,	,	,
18637	24384	44	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24384	45	Parte	Parte	NNP
18637	24384	46	,	,	,
18637	24384	47	278	278	CD
18637	24384	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24384	49	101	101	CD
18637	24384	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24384	51	1928	1928	CD
18637	24384	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24384	53	,	,	,
18637	24384	54	631	631	CD
18637	24384	55	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24384	56	Clearing	Clearing	NNP
18637	24384	57	House	House	NNP
18637	24384	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24384	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24384	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24384	61	Coyne	Coyne	NNP
18637	24384	62	,	,	,
18637	24384	63	194	194	CD
18637	24384	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24384	65	497	497	CD
18637	24384	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24384	67	1904	1904	CD
18637	24384	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24384	69	,	,	,
18637	24384	70	269	269	CD
18637	24384	71	,	,	,
18637	24384	72	805	805	CD
18637	24384	73	,	,	,
18637	24384	74	847	847	CD
18637	24384	75	,	,	,
18637	24384	76	859	859	CD
18637	24384	77	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24384	78	Service	Service	NNP
18637	24384	79	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24384	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24384	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	24384	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24384	83	Corboy	Corboy	NNP
18637	24384	84	,	,	,
18637	24384	85	250	250	CD
18637	24384	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24384	87	153	153	CD
18637	24384	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24384	89	1919	1919	CD
18637	24384	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24384	91	,	,	,
18637	24384	92	931	931	CD
18637	24384	93	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24384	94	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	24384	95	Com	Com	NNP
18637	24384	96	.	.	.
18637	24385	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24385	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24385	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24385	4	Attleboro	Attleboro	NNP
18637	24385	5	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	24385	6	&	&	CC
18637	24385	7	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	24385	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24385	9	,	,	,
18637	24385	10	273	273	CD
18637	24385	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24385	12	83	83	CD
18637	24385	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24385	14	1927	1927	CD
18637	24385	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24385	16	,	,	,
18637	24385	17	138	138	CD
18637	24385	18	,	,	,
18637	24385	19	233	233	CD
18637	24385	20	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24385	21	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	24385	22	Com	Com	NNP
18637	24385	23	.	.	.
18637	24386	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24386	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24386	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24386	4	Landon	Landon	NNP
18637	24386	5	,	,	,
18637	24386	6	249	249	CD
18637	24386	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24386	8	236	236	CD
18637	24386	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24386	10	1919	1919	CD
18637	24386	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24386	12	,	,	,
18637	24386	13	233	233	CD
18637	24386	14	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24386	15	Utilities	Utilities	NNPS
18637	24386	16	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24386	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24386	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24386	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24386	20	Pollak	Pollak	NNP
18637	24386	21	,	,	,
18637	24386	22	343	343	CD
18637	24386	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24386	24	451	451	CD
18637	24386	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24386	26	1952	1952	CD
18637	24386	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24386	28	,	,	,
18637	24386	29	785	785	CD
18637	24386	30	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24386	31	Utility	Utility	NNP
18637	24386	32	Commissioners	Commissioners	NNPS
18637	24386	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24386	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24386	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24386	36	New	New	NNP
18637	24386	37	York	York	NNP
18637	24386	38	Telegh	Telegh	NNP
18637	24386	39	.	.	.
18637	24387	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24387	2	,	,	,
18637	24387	3	271	271	CD
18637	24387	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24387	5	23	23	CD
18637	24387	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24387	7	1926	1926	CD
18637	24387	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24387	9	,	,	,
18637	24387	10	1008	1008	CD
18637	24387	11	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24387	12	Utility	Utility	NNP
18637	24387	13	Comrs	Comrs	NNP
18637	24387	14	.	.	.
18637	24388	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24388	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24388	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24388	4	Ynchausti	Ynchausti	NNP
18637	24388	5	&	&	CC
18637	24388	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24388	7	,	,	,
18637	24388	8	251	251	CD
18637	24388	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24388	10	401	401	CD
18637	24388	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24388	12	1920	1920	CD
18637	24388	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24388	14	,	,	,
18637	24388	15	846	846	CD
18637	24388	16	Puget	Puget	NNP
18637	24388	17	Sound	Sound	NNP
18637	24388	18	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24388	19	&	&	CC
18637	24388	20	Light	Light	NNP
18637	24388	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24388	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24388	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24388	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24388	25	Seattle	Seattle	NNP
18637	24388	26	,	,	,
18637	24388	27	291	291	CD
18637	24388	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24388	29	619	619	CD
18637	24388	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24388	31	1934	1934	CD
18637	24388	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24388	33	,	,	,
18637	24388	34	1039	1039	CD
18637	24388	35	,	,	,
18637	24388	36	1148	1148	CD
18637	24388	37	,	,	,
18637	24388	38	1149	1149	CD
18637	24388	39	Puget	Puget	NNP
18637	24388	40	Sound	Sound	NNP
18637	24388	41	Stevedoring	Stevedoring	NNP
18637	24388	42	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24388	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24388	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24388	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24388	46	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24388	47	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24388	48	of	of	IN
18637	24388	49	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24388	50	,	,	,
18637	24388	51	302	302	CD
18637	24388	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24388	53	90	90	CD
18637	24388	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24388	55	1937	1937	CD
18637	24388	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24388	57	,	,	,
18637	24388	58	195	195	CD
18637	24388	59	,	,	,
18637	24388	60	204	204	CD
18637	24388	61	,	,	,
18637	24388	62	207	207	CD
18637	24388	63	Puget	Puget	NNP
18637	24388	64	Sound	Sound	NNP
18637	24388	65	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	24388	66	,	,	,
18637	24388	67	Light	Light	NNP
18637	24388	68	&	&	CC
18637	24388	69	P.	P.	NNP
18637	24388	70	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24388	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24388	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	24388	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24388	74	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	24388	75	,	,	,
18637	24388	76	244	244	CD
18637	24388	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24388	78	574	574	CD
18637	24388	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24388	80	1917	1917	CD
18637	24388	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24388	82	,	,	,
18637	24388	83	349	349	CD
18637	24388	84	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	24388	85	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24388	86	_	_	NNP
18637	24388	87	v.	v.	IN
18637	24388	88	_	_	NNP
18637	24388	89	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	24388	90	,	,	,
18637	24388	91	189	189	CD
18637	24388	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24388	93	420	420	CD
18637	24388	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24388	95	1903	1903	CD
18637	24388	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24388	97	,	,	,
18637	24388	98	196	196	CD
18637	24388	99	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	24388	100	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24388	101	_	_	NNP
18637	24388	102	v.	v.	IN
18637	24388	103	_	_	NNP
18637	24388	104	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24388	105	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24388	106	rel	rel	NNP
18637	24388	107	.	.	.
18637	24389	1	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	24389	2	,	,	,
18637	24389	3	216	216	CD
18637	24389	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24389	5	56	56	CD
18637	24389	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24389	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	24389	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24389	9	,	,	,
18637	24389	10	196	196	CD
18637	24389	11	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	24389	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24389	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24389	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24389	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24389	16	Knott	Knott	NNP
18637	24389	17	,	,	,
18637	24389	18	235	235	CD
18637	24389	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24389	20	23	23	CD
18637	24389	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24389	22	1914	1914	CD
18637	24389	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24389	24	,	,	,
18637	24389	25	1061	1061	CD
18637	24389	26	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	24389	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24389	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24389	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24389	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24389	31	Richardson	Richardson	NNP
18637	24389	32	,	,	,
18637	24389	33	261	261	CD
18637	24389	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24389	35	330	330	CD
18637	24389	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24389	37	1923	1923	CD
18637	24389	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24389	39	,	,	,
18637	24389	40	200	200	CD
18637	24389	41	Pullman	Pullman	NNP
18637	24389	42	's	's	POS
18637	24389	43	Palace	Palace	NNP
18637	24389	44	Car	Car	NNP
18637	24389	45	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24389	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24389	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	24389	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24389	49	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24389	50	,	,	,
18637	24389	51	141	141	CD
18637	24389	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24389	53	18	18	CD
18637	24389	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24389	55	1891	1891	CD
18637	24389	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24389	57	,	,	,
18637	24389	58	199	199	CD
18637	24389	59	,	,	,
18637	24389	60	201	201	CD
18637	24389	61	,	,	,
18637	24389	62	211	211	CD
18637	24389	63	,	,	,
18637	24389	64	1052	1052	CD
18637	24389	65	Pumpelly	Pumpelly	NNP
18637	24389	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24389	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	24389	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24389	69	Green	Green	NNP
18637	24389	70	Bay	Bay	NNP
18637	24389	71	Company	Company	NNP
18637	24389	72	,	,	,
18637	24389	73	13	13	CD
18637	24389	74	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24389	75	.	.	.
18637	24390	1	166	166	CD
18637	24390	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24390	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	24390	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24390	5	,	,	,
18637	24390	6	1065	1065	CD
18637	24390	7	,	,	,
18637	24390	8	1068	1068	CD
18637	24390	9	Pure	Pure	NNP
18637	24390	10	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24390	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24390	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24390	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	15	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24390	16	,	,	,
18637	24390	17	248	248	CD
18637	24390	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24390	19	158	158	CD
18637	24390	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24390	21	1918	1918	CD
18637	24390	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24390	23	,	,	,
18637	24390	24	214	214	CD
18637	24390	25	,	,	,
18637	24390	26	238	238	CD
18637	24390	27	Purity	Purity	NNP
18637	24390	28	Extract	Extract	NNP
18637	24390	29	&	&	CC
18637	24390	30	Tonic	Tonic	NNP
18637	24390	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24390	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	24390	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	35	Lynch	Lynch	NNP
18637	24390	36	,	,	,
18637	24390	37	226	226	CD
18637	24390	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24390	39	192	192	CD
18637	24390	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24390	41	1912	1912	CD
18637	24390	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24390	43	,	,	,
18637	24390	44	1032	1032	CD
18637	24390	45	Pyle	Pyle	NNP
18637	24390	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	24390	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	49	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24390	50	,	,	,
18637	24390	51	317	317	CD
18637	24390	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24390	53	213	213	CD
18637	24390	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24390	55	1942	1942	CD
18637	24390	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24390	57	,	,	,
18637	24390	58	1125	1125	CD
18637	24390	59	,	,	,
18637	24390	60	1126	1126	CD
18637	24390	61	Q	Q	NNP
18637	24390	62	Quackenbush	Quackenbush	NNP
18637	24390	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	24390	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	66	United	United	NNP
18637	24390	67	States	States	NNP
18637	24390	68	,	,	,
18637	24390	69	177	177	CD
18637	24390	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24390	71	20	20	CD
18637	24390	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24390	73	1900	1900	CD
18637	24390	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24390	75	,	,	,
18637	24390	76	460	460	CD
18637	24390	77	Quaker	Quaker	NNP
18637	24390	78	City	City	NNP
18637	24390	79	Cab	Cab	NNP
18637	24390	80	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24390	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	24390	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	84	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24390	85	,	,	,
18637	24390	86	277	277	CD
18637	24390	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24390	88	389	389	CD
18637	24390	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24390	90	1928	1928	CD
18637	24390	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24390	92	,	,	,
18637	24390	93	1149	1149	CD
18637	24390	94	Quarles	Quarles	NNPS
18637	24390	95	,	,	,
18637	24390	96	In	in	IN
18637	24390	97	re	re	NN
18637	24390	98	,	,	,
18637	24390	99	158	158	CD
18637	24390	100	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24390	101	532	532	CD
18637	24390	102	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24390	103	1895	1895	CD
18637	24390	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24390	105	,	,	,
18637	24390	106	309	309	CD
18637	24390	107	,	,	,
18637	24390	108	967	967	CD
18637	24390	109	Queenside	Queenside	NNP
18637	24390	110	Hills	Hills	NNP
18637	24390	111	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	24390	112	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24390	113	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	114	v.	v.	IN
18637	24390	115	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	116	Saxl	Saxl	NNP
18637	24390	117	,	,	,
18637	24390	118	328	328	CD
18637	24390	119	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24390	120	80	80	CD
18637	24390	121	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24390	122	1946	1946	CD
18637	24390	123	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24390	124	,	,	,
18637	24390	125	1029	1029	CD
18637	24390	126	,	,	,
18637	24390	127	1155	1155	CD
18637	24390	128	Quick	Quick	NNP
18637	24390	129	Bear	Bear	NNP
18637	24390	130	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	131	v.	v.	IN
18637	24390	132	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	133	Leupp	Leupp	NNP
18637	24390	134	,	,	,
18637	24390	135	210	210	CD
18637	24390	136	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24390	137	50	50	CD
18637	24390	138	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24390	139	1908	1908	CD
18637	24390	140	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24390	141	,	,	,
18637	24390	142	764	764	CD
18637	24390	143	Quicksall	Quicksall	NNP
18637	24390	144	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	145	v.	v.	IN
18637	24390	146	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	147	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	24390	148	,	,	,
18637	24390	149	339	339	CD
18637	24390	150	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24390	151	660	660	CD
18637	24390	152	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24390	153	1950	1950	CD
18637	24390	154	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24390	155	,	,	,
18637	24390	156	1107	1107	CD
18637	24390	157	Quirin	Quirin	NNP
18637	24390	158	,	,	,
18637	24390	159	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24390	160	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24390	161	,	,	,
18637	24390	162	317	317	CD
18637	24390	163	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24390	164	1	1	CD
18637	24390	165	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24390	166	1942	1942	CD
18637	24390	167	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24390	168	,	,	,
18637	24390	169	286	286	CD
18637	24390	170	,	,	,
18637	24390	171	401	401	CD
18637	24390	172	,	,	,
18637	24390	173	404	404	CD
18637	24390	174	,	,	,
18637	24390	175	838	838	CD
18637	24390	176	Quong	Quong	NNP
18637	24390	177	Wing	Wing	NNP
18637	24390	178	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	179	v.	v.	IN
18637	24390	180	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	181	Kirkendall	Kirkendall	NNP
18637	24390	182	,	,	,
18637	24390	183	223	223	CD
18637	24390	184	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24390	185	59	59	CD
18637	24390	186	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24390	187	1912	1912	CD
18637	24390	188	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24390	189	,	,	,
18637	24390	190	1148	1148	CD
18637	24390	191	,	,	,
18637	24390	192	1149	1149	CD
18637	24390	193	Quon	Quon	NNP
18637	24390	194	Quon	Quon	NNP
18637	24390	195	Poy	Poy	NNP
18637	24390	196	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	197	v.	v.	IN
18637	24390	198	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	199	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	24390	200	,	,	,
18637	24390	201	273	273	CD
18637	24390	202	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24390	203	352	352	CD
18637	24390	204	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24390	205	1927	1927	CD
18637	24390	206	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24390	207	,	,	,
18637	24390	208	846	846	CD
18637	24390	209	,	,	,
18637	24390	210	852	852	CD
18637	24390	211	R	R	NNP
18637	24390	212	Radice	Radice	NNP
18637	24390	213	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	214	v.	v.	IN
18637	24390	215	_	_	NNP
18637	24390	216	New	New	NNP
18637	24390	217	York	York	NNP
18637	24390	218	,	,	,
18637	24390	219	264	264	CD
18637	24390	220	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24390	221	292	292	CD
18637	24390	222	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24390	223	1924	1924	CD
18637	24390	224	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24390	225	,	,	,
18637	24390	226	1159	1159	CD
18637	24390	227	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	24390	228	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	24390	229	.	.	.
18637	24391	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24391	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24391	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24391	4	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
18637	24391	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	24391	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24391	7	,	,	,
18637	24391	8	289	289	CD
18637	24391	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24391	10	266	266	CD
18637	24391	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24391	12	1933	1933	CD
18637	24391	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24391	14	,	,	,
18637	24391	15	788	788	CD
18637	24391	16	Ragan	Ragan	NNP
18637	24391	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24391	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24391	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24391	20	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	24391	21	Transfer	Transfer	NNP
18637	24391	22	&	&	CC
18637	24391	23	W.	W.	NNP
18637	24391	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24391	25	,	,	,
18637	24391	26	337	337	CD
18637	24391	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24391	28	530	530	CD
18637	24391	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24391	30	1949	1949	CD
18637	24391	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24391	32	,	,	,
18637	24391	33	608	608	CD
18637	24391	34	Rahrer	Rahrer	NNP
18637	24391	35	,	,	,
18637	24391	36	In	in	IN
18637	24391	37	re	re	NN
18637	24391	38	,	,	,
18637	24391	39	140	140	CD
18637	24391	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24391	41	545	545	CD
18637	24391	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24391	43	1891	1891	CD
18637	24391	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24391	45	,	,	,
18637	24391	46	218	218	CD
18637	24391	47	,	,	,
18637	24391	48	219	219	CD
18637	24391	49	,	,	,
18637	24391	50	239	239	CD
18637	24391	51	Rail	Rail	NNP
18637	24391	52	&	&	CC
18637	24391	53	River	River	NNP
18637	24391	54	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	24391	55	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24391	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24391	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24391	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24391	59	Yaple	Yaple	NNP
18637	24391	60	,	,	,
18637	24391	61	236	236	CD
18637	24391	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24391	63	338	338	CD
18637	24391	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24391	65	1915	1915	CD
18637	24391	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24391	67	,	,	,
18637	24391	68	988	988	NNP
18637	24391	69	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24391	70	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24391	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24391	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	24391	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24391	74	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	24391	75	,	,	,
18637	24391	76	98	98	CD
18637	24391	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24391	78	359	359	CD
18637	24391	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24391	80	1879	1879	CD
18637	24391	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24391	82	,	,	,
18637	24391	83	347	347	CD
18637	24391	84	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24391	85	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24391	86	_	_	NNP
18637	24391	87	v.	v.	IN
18637	24391	88	_	_	NNP
18637	24391	89	Grant	Grant	NNP
18637	24391	90	,	,	,
18637	24391	91	98	98	CD
18637	24391	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24391	93	398	398	CD
18637	24391	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24391	95	1879	1879	CD
18637	24391	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24391	97	,	,	,
18637	24391	98	615	615	CD
18637	24391	99	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24391	100	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24391	101	_	_	NNP
18637	24391	102	v.	v.	IN
18637	24391	103	_	_	NNP
18637	24391	104	Husen	Husen	NNP
18637	24391	105	,	,	,
18637	24391	106	95	95	CD
18637	24391	107	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24391	108	465	465	CD
18637	24391	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24391	110	1878	1878	CD
18637	24391	111	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24391	112	,	,	,
18637	24391	113	236	236	CD
18637	24391	114	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24391	115	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24391	116	_	_	NNP
18637	24391	117	v.	v.	IN
18637	24391	118	_	_	NNP
18637	24391	119	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	24391	120	,	,	,
18637	24391	121	10	10	CD
18637	24391	122	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24391	123	.	.	.
18637	24392	1	511	511	CD
18637	24392	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24392	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24392	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24392	5	,	,	,
18637	24392	6	329	329	CD
18637	24392	7	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24392	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24392	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24392	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24392	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24392	12	Peniston	Peniston	NNP
18637	24392	13	,	,	,
18637	24392	14	18	18	CD
18637	24392	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24392	16	.	.	.
18637	24393	1	5	5	CD
18637	24393	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24393	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	24393	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24393	5	,	,	,
18637	24393	6	200	200	CD
18637	24393	7	,	,	,
18637	24393	8	732	732	CD
18637	24393	9	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24393	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24393	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24393	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24393	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24393	14	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	24393	15	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24393	16	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24393	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24393	18	,	,	,
18637	24393	19	264	264	CD
18637	24393	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24393	21	79	79	CD
18637	24393	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24393	23	1924	1924	CD
18637	24393	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24393	25	,	,	,
18637	24393	26	1011	1011	CD
18637	24393	27	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24393	28	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24393	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24393	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24393	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24393	32	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24393	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24393	34	,	,	,
18637	24393	35	310	310	CD
18637	24393	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24393	37	573	573	CD
18637	24393	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24393	39	1940	1940	CD
18637	24393	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24393	41	,	,	,
18637	24393	42	1025	1025	CD
18637	24393	43	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	24394	1	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24394	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24394	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24394	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24394	5	Humble	Humble	NNP
18637	24394	6	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24394	7	&	&	CC
18637	24394	8	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	24394	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24394	10	,	,	,
18637	24394	11	311	311	CD
18637	24394	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24394	13	578	578	CD
18637	24394	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24394	15	1941	1941	CD
18637	24394	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24394	17	,	,	,
18637	24394	18	1025	1025	CD
18637	24394	19	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	24395	1	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24395	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24395	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24395	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24395	5	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24395	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24395	7	,	,	,
18637	24395	8	311	311	CD
18637	24395	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24395	10	570	570	CD
18637	24395	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24395	12	1941	1941	CD
18637	24395	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24395	14	,	,	,
18637	24395	15	1025	1025	CD
18637	24395	16	,	,	,
18637	24395	17	1071	1071	CD
18637	24395	18	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	24396	1	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24396	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24396	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24396	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24396	5	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24396	6	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24396	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24396	8	,	,	,
18637	24396	9	302	302	CD
18637	24396	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24396	11	388	388	CD
18637	24396	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24396	13	1938	1938	CD
18637	24396	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24396	15	,	,	,
18637	24396	16	1007	1007	CD
18637	24396	17	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24396	18	Retirement	Retirement	NNP
18637	24396	19	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24396	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24396	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24396	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24396	23	Alton	Alton	NNP
18637	24396	24	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24396	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24396	26	,	,	,
18637	24396	27	295	295	CD
18637	24396	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24396	29	330	330	CD
18637	24396	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24396	31	1935	1935	CD
18637	24396	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24396	33	,	,	,
18637	24396	34	142	142	CD
18637	24396	35	,	,	,
18637	24396	36	564	564	CD
18637	24396	37	,	,	,
18637	24396	38	862	862	CD
18637	24396	39	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24396	40	Retirement	Retirement	NNP
18637	24396	41	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24396	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24396	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24396	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24396	45	Duquesne	Duquesne	NNP
18637	24396	46	Warehouse	Warehouse	NNP
18637	24396	47	Company	Company	NNP
18637	24396	48	,	,	,
18637	24396	49	326	326	CD
18637	24396	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24396	51	446	446	CD
18637	24396	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24396	53	1946	1946	CD
18637	24396	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24396	55	,	,	,
18637	24396	56	143	143	CD
18637	24396	57	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	24396	58	Express	Express	NNP
18637	24396	59	Agency	Agency	NNP
18637	24396	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24396	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	24396	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24396	63	New	New	NNP
18637	24396	64	York	York	NNP
18637	24396	65	,	,	,
18637	24396	66	336	336	CD
18637	24396	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24396	68	106	106	CD
18637	24396	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24396	70	1949	1949	CD
18637	24396	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24396	72	,	,	,
18637	24396	73	227	227	CD
18637	24396	74	,	,	,
18637	24396	75	564	564	CD
18637	24396	76	,	,	,
18637	24396	77	854	854	CD
18637	24396	78	,	,	,
18637	24396	79	1033	1033	CD
18637	24396	80	,	,	,
18637	24396	81	1134	1134	CD
18637	24396	82	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	24396	83	Mail	Mail	NNP
18637	24396	84	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	24396	85	.	.	.
18637	24397	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24397	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24397	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24397	4	Corsi	Corsi	NNP
18637	24397	5	,	,	,
18637	24397	6	326	326	CD
18637	24397	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24397	8	88	88	CD
18637	24397	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24397	10	1945	1945	CD
18637	24397	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24397	12	,	,	,
18637	24397	13	270	270	CD
18637	24397	14	,	,	,
18637	24397	15	993	993	CD
18637	24397	16	Rainey	Rainey	NNP
18637	24397	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24397	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24397	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24397	20	United	United	NNP
18637	24397	21	States	States	NNP
18637	24397	22	,	,	,
18637	24397	23	232	232	CD
18637	24397	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24397	25	310	310	CD
18637	24397	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24397	27	1914	1914	CD
18637	24397	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24397	29	,	,	,
18637	24397	30	102	102	CD
18637	24397	31	Rakes	Rakes	NNP
18637	24397	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24397	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	24397	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24397	35	United	United	NNP
18637	24397	36	States	States	NNP
18637	24397	37	,	,	,
18637	24397	38	212	212	CD
18637	24397	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24397	40	55	55	CD
18637	24397	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24397	42	1909	1909	CD
18637	24397	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24397	44	,	,	,
18637	24397	45	309	309	CD
18637	24397	46	Randall	Randall	NNP
18637	24397	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24397	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	24397	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24397	50	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	24397	51	&	&	CC
18637	24397	52	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	24398	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24398	2	,	,	,
18637	24398	3	109	109	CD
18637	24398	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24398	5	478	478	CD
18637	24398	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24398	7	1883	1883	CD
18637	24398	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24398	9	,	,	,
18637	24398	10	896	896	CD
18637	24398	11	Rapier	Rapier	NNP
18637	24398	12	,	,	,
18637	24398	13	In	in	IN
18637	24398	14	re	re	NN
18637	24398	15	,	,	,
18637	24398	16	143	143	CD
18637	24398	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24398	18	110	110	CD
18637	24398	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24398	20	1892	1892	CD
18637	24398	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24398	22	,	,	,
18637	24398	23	167	167	CD
18637	24398	24	,	,	,
18637	24398	25	168	168	CD
18637	24398	26	Rassmussen	Rassmussen	NNP
18637	24398	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24398	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24398	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24398	30	United	United	NNP
18637	24398	31	States	States	NNP
18637	24398	32	,	,	,
18637	24398	33	197	197	CD
18637	24398	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24398	35	516	516	CD
18637	24398	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24398	37	1905	1905	CD
18637	24398	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24398	39	,	,	,
18637	24398	40	703	703	CD
18637	24398	41	,	,	,
18637	24398	42	877	877	CD
18637	24398	43	,	,	,
18637	24398	44	879	879	CD
18637	24398	45	Rast	Rast	NNP
18637	24398	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24398	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	24398	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24398	49	Van	Van	NNP
18637	24398	50	Deman	Deman	NNP
18637	24398	51	&	&	CC
18637	24398	52	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	24398	53	,	,	,
18637	24398	54	240	240	CD
18637	24398	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24398	56	342	342	CD
18637	24398	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24398	58	1916	1916	CD
18637	24398	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24398	60	,	,	,
18637	24398	61	184	184	CD
18637	24398	62	,	,	,
18637	24398	63	1019	1019	CD
18637	24398	64	Rathbun	Rathbun	NNP
18637	24398	65	,	,	,
18637	24398	66	Executor	Executor	NNP
18637	24398	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24398	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	24398	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24398	70	United	United	NNP
18637	24398	71	States	States	NNP
18637	24398	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24398	73	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	24398	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24398	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	24398	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24398	77	United	United	NNP
18637	24398	78	States	States	NNP
18637	24398	79	,	,	,
18637	24398	80	295	295	CD
18637	24398	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24398	82	602	602	CD
18637	24398	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24398	84	1935	1935	CD
18637	24398	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24398	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24398	87	,	,	,
18637	24398	88	458	458	CD
18637	24398	89	Ratterman	Ratterman	NNP
18637	24398	90	_	_	NNP
18637	24398	91	v.	v.	IN
18637	24398	92	_	_	NNP
18637	24398	93	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24398	94	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24398	95	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24398	96	.	.	.
18637	24399	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24399	2	,	,	,
18637	24399	3	127	127	CD
18637	24399	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24399	5	411	411	CD
18637	24399	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24399	7	1888	1888	CD
18637	24399	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24399	9	,	,	,
18637	24399	10	204	204	CD
18637	24399	11	,	,	,
18637	24399	12	207	207	CD
18637	24399	13	Rawlins	Rawlins	NNPS
18637	24399	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24399	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	17	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	24399	18	,	,	,
18637	24399	19	201	201	CD
18637	24399	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24399	21	638	638	CD
18637	24399	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24399	23	1906	1906	CD
18637	24399	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24399	25	,	,	,
18637	24399	26	1111	1111	CD
18637	24399	27	,	,	,
18637	24399	28	1169	1169	CD
18637	24399	29	Ray	Ray	NNP
18637	24399	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24399	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	33	Blair	Blair	NNP
18637	24399	34	,	,	,
18637	24399	35	343	343	CD
18637	24399	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24399	37	214	214	CD
18637	24399	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24399	39	1952	1952	CD
18637	24399	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24399	41	,	,	,
18637	24399	42	386	386	CD
18637	24399	43	,	,	,
18637	24399	44	942	942	CD
18637	24399	45	-	-	HYPH
18637	24399	46	944	944	CD
18637	24399	47	Raymond	Raymond	NNP
18637	24399	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	24399	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	51	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	24399	52	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24399	53	Traction	Traction	NNP
18637	24399	54	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24399	55	,	,	,
18637	24399	56	207	207	CD
18637	24399	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24399	58	20	20	CD
18637	24399	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24399	60	1907	1907	CD
18637	24399	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24399	62	,	,	,
18637	24399	63	1152	1152	CD
18637	24399	64	Reagan	Reagan	NNP
18637	24399	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	24399	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	68	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	24399	69	'	'	POS
18637	24399	70	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	24399	71	&	&	CC
18637	24399	72	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24399	73	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24399	74	,	,	,
18637	24399	75	154	154	CD
18637	24399	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24399	77	362	362	CD
18637	24399	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24399	79	1894	1894	CD
18637	24399	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24399	81	,	,	,
18637	24399	82	630	630	CD
18637	24399	83	,	,	,
18637	24399	84	931	931	CD
18637	24399	85	,	,	,
18637	24399	86	933	933	CD
18637	24399	87	,	,	,
18637	24399	88	999	999	CD
18637	24399	89	,	,	,
18637	24399	90	1001	1001	CD
18637	24399	91	Reagan	Reagan	NNP
18637	24399	92	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	24399	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	95	Mercantile	Mercantile	NNP
18637	24399	96	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24399	97	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24399	98	,	,	,
18637	24399	99	154	154	CD
18637	24399	100	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24399	101	413	413	CD
18637	24399	102	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24399	103	1894	1894	CD
18637	24399	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24399	105	,	,	,
18637	24399	106	725	725	CD
18637	24399	107	Real	real	JJ
18637	24399	108	Silk	silk	NN
18637	24399	109	Hosiery	Hosiery	NNP
18637	24399	110	Mills	Mills	NNPS
18637	24399	111	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	112	v.	v.	IN
18637	24399	113	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	114	Portland	Portland	NNP
18637	24399	115	,	,	,
18637	24399	116	268	268	CD
18637	24399	117	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24399	118	325	325	CD
18637	24399	119	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24399	120	1925	1925	CD
18637	24399	121	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24399	122	,	,	,
18637	24399	123	187	187	CD
18637	24399	124	Rearick	Rearick	NNP
18637	24399	125	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	126	v.	v.	IN
18637	24399	127	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	128	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24399	129	,	,	,
18637	24399	130	203	203	CD
18637	24399	131	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24399	132	507	507	CD
18637	24399	133	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24399	134	1906	1906	CD
18637	24399	135	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24399	136	,	,	,
18637	24399	137	187	187	CD
18637	24399	138	Reaves	Reaves	NNPS
18637	24399	139	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	140	v.	v.	IN
18637	24399	141	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	142	Ainsworth	Ainsworth	NNP
18637	24399	143	,	,	,
18637	24399	144	219	219	CD
18637	24399	145	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24399	146	296	296	CD
18637	24399	147	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24399	148	1911	1911	CD
18637	24399	149	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24399	150	,	,	,
18637	24399	151	847	847	CD
18637	24399	152	Reckendorfer	Reckendorfer	NNP
18637	24399	153	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	154	v.	v.	IN
18637	24399	155	_	_	NNP
18637	24399	156	Faber	Faber	NNP
18637	24399	157	,	,	,
18637	24399	158	92	92	CD
18637	24399	159	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24399	160	347	347	CD
18637	24399	161	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24399	162	1876	1876	CD
18637	24399	163	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24399	164	,	,	,
18637	24399	165	272	272	CD
18637	24399	166	,	,	,
18637	24399	167	273	273	CD
18637	24399	168	Red	Red	NNP
18637	24399	169	"	"	``
18637	24399	170	C	C	NNP
18637	24399	171	"	"	''
18637	24399	172	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24399	173	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	24399	174	.	.	.
18637	24400	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24400	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24400	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24400	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24400	5	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24400	6	of	of	IN
18637	24400	7	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	24400	8	,	,	,
18637	24400	9	222	222	CD
18637	24400	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24400	11	380	380	CD
18637	24400	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24400	13	1912	1912	CD
18637	24400	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24400	15	,	,	,
18637	24400	16	183	183	CD
18637	24400	17	,	,	,
18637	24400	18	214	214	CD
18637	24400	19	Red	Red	NNP
18637	24400	20	Cross	Cross	NNP
18637	24400	21	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24400	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24400	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24400	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24400	25	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	24400	26	Fruit	Fruit	NNP
18637	24400	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24400	28	,	,	,
18637	24400	29	264	264	CD
18637	24400	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24400	31	109	109	CD
18637	24400	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24400	33	1924	1924	CD
18637	24400	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24400	35	,	,	,
18637	24400	36	579	579	CD
18637	24400	37	Red	Red	NNP
18637	24400	38	River	River	NNP
18637	24400	39	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	24400	40	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	24400	41	.	.	.
18637	24401	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24401	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24401	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24401	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24401	5	Craig	Craig	NNP
18637	24401	6	,	,	,
18637	24401	7	181	181	CD
18637	24401	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24401	9	548	548	CD
18637	24401	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24401	11	1901	1901	CD
18637	24401	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24401	13	,	,	,
18637	24401	14	355	355	CD
18637	24401	15	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	24401	16	,	,	,
18637	24401	17	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24401	18	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24401	19	,	,	,
18637	24401	20	100	100	CD
18637	24401	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24401	22	13	13	CD
18637	24401	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24401	24	1879	1879	CD
18637	24401	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24401	26	,	,	,
18637	24401	27	847	847	CD
18637	24401	28	Reed	Reed	NNP
18637	24401	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24401	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24401	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24401	32	Director	Director	NNP
18637	24401	33	General	General	NNP
18637	24401	34	of	of	IN
18637	24401	35	Railroads	Railroads	NNP
18637	24401	36	,	,	,
18637	24401	37	258	258	CD
18637	24401	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24401	39	92	92	CD
18637	24401	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24401	41	1922	1922	CD
18637	24401	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24401	43	,	,	,
18637	24401	44	141	141	CD
18637	24401	45	Rees	Rees	NNPS
18637	24401	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24401	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	24401	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24401	49	Watertown	Watertown	NNP
18637	24401	50	,	,	,
18637	24401	51	19	19	CD
18637	24401	52	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24401	53	107	107	CD
18637	24401	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24401	55	1874	1874	CD
18637	24401	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24401	57	,	,	,
18637	24401	58	357	357	CD
18637	24401	59	,	,	,
18637	24401	60	1074	1074	CD
18637	24401	61	Reeside	Reeside	NNP
18637	24401	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24401	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	24401	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24401	65	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	24401	66	,	,	,
18637	24401	67	11	11	CD
18637	24401	68	How	how	WRB
18637	24401	69	.	.	.
18637	24402	1	272	272	CD
18637	24402	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24402	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	24402	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24402	5	,	,	,
18637	24402	6	324	324	CD
18637	24402	7	Reetz	Reetz	NNP
18637	24402	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24402	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24402	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24402	11	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	24402	12	,	,	,
18637	24402	13	188	188	CD
18637	24402	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24402	15	505	505	CD
18637	24402	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24402	17	1903	1903	CD
18637	24402	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24402	19	,	,	,
18637	24402	20	328	328	CD
18637	24402	21	,	,	,
18637	24402	22	1024	1024	CD
18637	24402	23	,	,	,
18637	24402	24	1138	1138	CD
18637	24402	25	Reggel	Reggel	NNP
18637	24402	26	,	,	,
18637	24402	27	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24402	28	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24402	29	,	,	,
18637	24402	30	114	114	CD
18637	24402	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24402	32	642	642	CD
18637	24402	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24402	34	1885	1885	CD
18637	24402	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24402	36	,	,	,
18637	24402	37	695	695	CD
18637	24402	38	Reichelderfer	Reichelderfer	NNP
18637	24402	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24402	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24402	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24402	42	Quinn	Quinn	NNP
18637	24402	43	,	,	,
18637	24402	44	287	287	CD
18637	24402	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24402	46	315	315	CD
18637	24402	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24402	48	1932	1932	CD
18637	24402	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24402	50	,	,	,
18637	24402	51	870	870	CD
18637	24402	52	Reichert	Reichert	NNP
18637	24402	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24402	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	24402	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24402	56	Felps	Felps	NNP
18637	24402	57	,	,	,
18637	24402	58	6	6	CD
18637	24402	59	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24402	60	.	.	.
18637	24403	1	160	160	CD
18637	24403	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24403	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	24403	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24403	5	,	,	,
18637	24403	6	421	421	CD
18637	24403	7	Reid	Reid	NNP
18637	24403	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24403	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24403	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24403	11	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	24403	12	,	,	,
18637	24403	13	187	187	CD
18637	24403	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24403	15	137	137	CD
18637	24403	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24403	17	1902	1902	CD
18637	24403	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24403	19	,	,	,
18637	24403	20	248	248	CD
18637	24403	21	Reily	Reily	NNP
18637	24403	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24403	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24403	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24403	25	Lamar	Lamar	NNP
18637	24403	26	,	,	,
18637	24403	27	2	2	CD
18637	24403	28	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24403	29	.	.	.
18637	24404	1	344	344	CD
18637	24404	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24404	3	1805	1805	CD
18637	24404	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24404	5	,	,	,
18637	24404	6	302	302	CD
18637	24404	7	Reiman	Reiman	NNP
18637	24404	8	,	,	,
18637	24404	9	In	in	IN
18637	24404	10	re	re	NN
18637	24404	11	,	,	,
18637	24404	12	20	20	CD
18637	24404	13	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24404	14	.	.	.
18637	24405	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24405	2	.	.	.
18637	24406	1	No	no	UH
18637	24406	2	.	.	.
18637	24407	1	11,673	11,673	CD
18637	24407	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24407	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	24407	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24407	5	,	,	,
18637	24407	6	263	263	CD
18637	24407	7	Reinecke	Reinecke	NNP
18637	24407	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24407	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24407	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24407	11	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24407	12	,	,	,
18637	24407	13	289	289	CD
18637	24407	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24407	15	172	172	CD
18637	24407	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24407	17	1933	1933	CD
18637	24407	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24407	19	,	,	,
18637	24407	20	863	863	CD
18637	24407	21	,	,	,
18637	24407	22	864	864	CD
18637	24407	23	Reinman	Reinman	NNP
18637	24407	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24407	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24407	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24407	27	Little	Little	NNP
18637	24407	28	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	24407	29	,	,	,
18637	24407	30	237	237	CD
18637	24407	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24407	32	171	171	CD
18637	24407	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24407	34	1915	1915	CD
18637	24407	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24407	36	,	,	,
18637	24407	37	1028	1028	CD
18637	24407	38	Reitz	Reitz	NNP
18637	24407	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24407	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24407	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24407	42	Mealey	Mealey	NNP
18637	24407	43	,	,	,
18637	24407	44	314	314	CD
18637	24407	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24407	46	33	33	CD
18637	24407	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24407	48	1941	1941	CD
18637	24407	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24407	50	,	,	,
18637	24407	51	265	265	CD
18637	24407	52	,	,	,
18637	24407	53	1033	1033	CD
18637	24407	54	Renaud	Renaud	NNP
18637	24407	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24407	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24407	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24407	58	Abbott	Abbott	NNP
18637	24407	59	,	,	,
18637	24407	60	116	116	CD
18637	24407	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24407	62	277	277	CD
18637	24407	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24407	64	1886	1886	CD
18637	24407	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24407	66	,	,	,
18637	24407	67	659	659	CD
18637	24407	68	Republic	Republic	NNP
18637	24407	69	of	of	IN
18637	24407	70	Colombia	Colombia	NNP
18637	24407	71	,	,	,
18637	24407	72	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24407	73	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24407	74	,	,	,
18637	24407	75	195	195	CD
18637	24407	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24407	77	604	604	CD
18637	24407	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24407	79	1904	1904	CD
18637	24407	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24407	81	,	,	,
18637	24407	82	610	610	CD
18637	24407	83	Republic	Republic	NNP
18637	24407	84	of	of	IN
18637	24407	85	Peru	Peru	NNP
18637	24407	86	,	,	,
18637	24407	87	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24407	88	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24407	89	,	,	,
18637	24407	90	318	318	CD
18637	24407	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24407	92	578	578	CD
18637	24407	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24407	94	1943	1943	CD
18637	24407	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24407	96	,	,	,
18637	24407	97	474	474	CD
18637	24407	98	Rescue	Rescue	NNP
18637	24407	99	Army	Army	NNP
18637	24407	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24407	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	24407	102	_	_	NNP
18637	24407	103	Municipal	Municipal	NNP
18637	24407	104	Court	Court	NNP
18637	24407	105	of	of	IN
18637	24407	106	Los	Los	NNP
18637	24407	107	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	24407	108	,	,	,
18637	24407	109	331	331	CD
18637	24407	110	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24407	111	549	549	CD
18637	24407	112	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24407	113	1947	1947	CD
18637	24407	114	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24407	115	,	,	,
18637	24407	116	562	562	CD
18637	24407	117	Respublica	Respublica	NNP
18637	24407	118	_	_	NNP
18637	24407	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	24407	120	_	_	NNP
18637	24407	121	Oswald	Oswald	NNP
18637	24407	122	,	,	,
18637	24407	123	1	1	CD
18637	24407	124	Dall	dall	NN
18637	24407	125	.	.	.
18637	24408	1	319	319	CD
18637	24408	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24408	3	1788	1788	CD
18637	24408	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24408	5	,	,	,
18637	24408	6	771	771	CD
18637	24408	7	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	24408	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24408	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24408	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24408	11	Crawfordsville	Crawfordsville	NNP
18637	24408	12	First	First	NNP
18637	24408	13	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	24408	14	.	.	.
18637	24409	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24409	2	,	,	,
18637	24409	3	112	112	CD
18637	24409	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24409	5	405	405	CD
18637	24409	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24409	7	1884	1884	CD
18637	24409	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24409	9	,	,	,
18637	24409	10	895	895	CD
18637	24409	11	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNPS
18637	24409	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24409	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24409	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24409	15	Stockton	Stockton	NNP
18637	24409	16	,	,	,
18637	24409	17	140	140	CD
18637	24409	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24409	19	254	254	CD
18637	24409	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24409	21	1891	1891	CD
18637	24409	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24409	23	,	,	,
18637	24409	24	659	659	CD
18637	24409	25	,	,	,
18637	24409	26	678	678	CD
18637	24409	27	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	24409	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24409	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24409	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24409	31	United	United	NNP
18637	24409	32	States	States	NNP
18637	24409	33	,	,	,
18637	24409	34	98	98	CD
18637	24409	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24409	36	145	145	CD
18637	24409	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24409	38	1879	1879	CD
18637	24409	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24409	40	,	,	,
18637	24409	41	704	704	CD
18637	24409	42	,	,	,
18637	24409	43	759	759	CD
18637	24409	44	,	,	,
18637	24409	45	766	766	CD
18637	24409	46	,	,	,
18637	24409	47	877	877	CD
18637	24409	48	,	,	,
18637	24409	49	880	880	CD
18637	24409	50	,	,	,
18637	24409	51	884	884	CD
18637	24409	52	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	24409	53	Island	Island	NNP
18637	24409	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24409	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	24409	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24409	57	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24409	58	,	,	,
18637	24409	59	12	12	CD
18637	24409	60	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24409	61	.	.	.
18637	24410	1	657	657	CD
18637	24410	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24410	3	1838	1838	CD
18637	24410	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24410	5	,	,	,
18637	24410	6	311	311	CD
18637	24410	7	,	,	,
18637	24410	8	370	370	CD
18637	24410	9	,	,	,
18637	24410	10	592	592	CD
18637	24410	11	,	,	,
18637	24410	12	593	593	CD
18637	24410	13	,	,	,
18637	24410	14	612	612	CD
18637	24410	15	,	,	,
18637	24410	16	618	618	CD
18637	24410	17	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	24410	18	Island	Island	NNP
18637	24410	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	24410	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	22	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	24410	23	,	,	,
18637	24410	24	253	253	CD
18637	24410	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24410	26	350	350	CD
18637	24410	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24410	28	1920	1920	CD
18637	24410	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24410	30	,	,	,
18637	24410	31	712	712	CD
18637	24410	32	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
18637	24410	33	Island	Island	NNP
18637	24410	34	Hospital	Hospital	NNP
18637	24410	35	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24410	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24410	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	24410	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	40	Doughton	Doughton	NNP
18637	24410	41	,	,	,
18637	24410	42	270	270	CD
18637	24410	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24410	44	69	69	CD
18637	24410	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24410	46	1926	1926	CD
18637	24410	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24410	48	,	,	,
18637	24410	49	1046	1046	CD
18637	24410	50	Rhodes	Rhodes	NNP
18637	24410	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	24410	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	54	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	24410	55	,	,	,
18637	24410	56	170	170	CD
18637	24410	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24410	58	412	412	CD
18637	24410	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24410	60	1898	1898	CD
18637	24410	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24410	62	,	,	,
18637	24410	63	239	239	CD
18637	24410	64	Ribnik	Ribnik	NNP
18637	24410	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	24410	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	68	McBride	McBride	NNP
18637	24410	69	,	,	,
18637	24410	70	277	277	CD
18637	24410	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24410	72	350	350	CD
18637	24410	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24410	74	1928	1928	CD
18637	24410	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24410	76	,	,	,
18637	24410	77	997	997	CD
18637	24410	78	Ricaud	Ricaud	NNP
18637	24410	79	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	24410	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	82	American	American	NNP
18637	24410	83	Metal	Metal	NNP
18637	24410	84	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24410	85	,	,	,
18637	24410	86	246	246	CD
18637	24410	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24410	88	304	304	CD
18637	24410	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24410	90	1918	1918	CD
18637	24410	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24410	92	,	,	,
18637	24410	93	474	474	CD
18637	24410	94	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	24410	95	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	24410	97	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	98	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	24410	99	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24410	100	of	of	IN
18637	24410	101	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	24410	102	,	,	,
18637	24410	103	331	331	CD
18637	24410	104	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24410	105	247	247	CD
18637	24410	106	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24410	107	1947	1947	CD
18637	24410	108	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24410	109	,	,	,
18637	24410	110	250	250	CD
18637	24410	111	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	24410	112	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	24410	114	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	115	Elmore	Elmore	NNP
18637	24410	116	,	,	,
18637	24410	117	165	165	CD
18637	24410	118	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24410	119	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24410	120	2d	2d	NNP
18637	24410	121	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24410	122	387	387	CD
18637	24410	123	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24410	124	1947	1947	CD
18637	24410	125	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24410	126	,	,	,
18637	24410	127	1185	1185	CD
18637	24410	128	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	24410	129	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	130	v.	v.	IN
18637	24410	131	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	132	Elmore	Elmore	NNP
18637	24410	133	,	,	,
18637	24410	134	333	333	CD
18637	24410	135	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24410	136	875	875	CD
18637	24410	137	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24410	138	1948	1948	CD
18637	24410	139	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24410	140	,	,	,
18637	24410	141	1185	1185	CD
18637	24410	142	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	24410	143	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	144	v.	v.	IN
18637	24410	145	_	_	NNP
18637	24410	146	M.	M.	NNP
18637	24410	147	&	&	CC
18637	24410	148	N.W.R.	N.W.R.	NNP
18637	24411	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24411	2	,	,	,
18637	24411	3	1	1	CD
18637	24411	4	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	24411	5	.	.	.
18637	24412	1	358	358	CD
18637	24412	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24412	3	1862	1862	CD
18637	24412	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24412	5	,	,	,
18637	24412	6	619	619	CD
18637	24412	7	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	24412	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24412	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24412	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24412	11	Olson	Olson	NNP
18637	24412	12	,	,	,
18637	24412	13	324	324	CD
18637	24412	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24412	15	786	786	CD
18637	24412	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24412	17	1945	1945	CD
18637	24412	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24412	19	,	,	,
18637	24412	20	1102	1102	CD
18637	24412	21	,	,	,
18637	24412	22	1103	1103	CD
18637	24412	23	,	,	,
18637	24412	24	1108	1108	CD
18637	24412	25	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	24412	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24412	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24412	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24412	29	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	24412	30	,	,	,
18637	24412	31	336	336	CD
18637	24412	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24412	33	674	674	CD
18637	24412	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24412	35	1949	1949	CD
18637	24412	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24412	37	,	,	,
18637	24412	38	669	669	CD
18637	24412	39	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	24412	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24412	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24412	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24412	43	Santa	Santa	NNP
18637	24412	44	Fe	Fe	NNP
18637	24412	45	Elevator	Elevator	NNP
18637	24412	46	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24412	47	,	,	,
18637	24412	48	331	331	CD
18637	24412	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24412	50	218	218	CD
18637	24412	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24412	52	1947	1947	CD
18637	24412	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24412	54	,	,	,
18637	24412	55	251	251	CD
18637	24412	56	,	,	,
18637	24412	57	724	724	CD
18637	24412	58	Richards	Richards	NNPS
18637	24412	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24412	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	24412	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24412	62	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24412	63	Terminal	Terminal	NNP
18637	24412	64	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24412	65	,	,	,
18637	24412	66	233	233	CD
18637	24412	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24412	68	546	546	CD
18637	24412	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24412	70	1914	1914	CD
18637	24412	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24412	72	,	,	,
18637	24412	73	867	867	CD
18637	24412	74	Richfield	Richfield	NNP
18637	24412	75	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24412	76	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24412	77	_	_	NNP
18637	24412	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	24412	79	_	_	NNP
18637	24412	80	State	State	NNP
18637	24412	81	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24412	82	of	of	IN
18637	24412	83	Equalization	Equalization	NNP
18637	24412	84	,	,	,
18637	24412	85	329	329	CD
18637	24412	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24412	87	69	69	CD
18637	24412	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24412	89	1946	1946	CD
18637	24412	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24412	91	,	,	,
18637	24412	92	204	204	CD
18637	24412	93	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	24412	94	&	&	CC
18637	24412	95	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	24413	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24413	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24413	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24413	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24413	5	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
18637	24413	6	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	24413	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24413	8	,	,	,
18637	24413	9	169	169	CD
18637	24413	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24413	11	311	311	CD
18637	24413	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24413	13	1898	1898	CD
18637	24413	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24413	15	,	,	,
18637	24413	16	223	223	CD
18637	24413	17	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	24413	18	,	,	,
18637	24413	19	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24413	20	&	&	CC
18637	24413	21	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24414	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24414	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24414	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	5	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	24414	6	,	,	,
18637	24414	7	96	96	CD
18637	24414	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24414	9	521	521	CD
18637	24414	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24414	11	1878	1878	CD
18637	24414	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24414	13	,	,	,
18637	24414	14	1014	1014	CD
18637	24414	15	,	,	,
18637	24414	16	1156	1156	CD
18637	24414	17	Rickert	Rickert	NNP
18637	24414	18	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	24414	19	Mills	Mills	NNP
18637	24414	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24414	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	23	Fontenot	Fontenot	NNP
18637	24414	24	,	,	,
18637	24414	25	297	297	CD
18637	24414	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24414	27	110	110	CD
18637	24414	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24414	29	1936	1936	CD
18637	24414	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24414	31	,	,	,
18637	24414	32	590	590	CD
18637	24414	33	Riehle	Riehle	NNP
18637	24414	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	24414	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	37	Margolies	Margolies	NNP
18637	24414	38	,	,	,
18637	24414	39	279	279	CD
18637	24414	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24414	41	218	218	CD
18637	24414	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24414	43	1929	1929	CD
18637	24414	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24414	45	,	,	,
18637	24414	46	524	524	CD
18637	24414	47	,	,	,
18637	24414	48	627	627	CD
18637	24414	49	Riggs	Riggs	NNP
18637	24414	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	24414	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	53	Del	Del	NNP
18637	24414	54	Drago	Drago	NNP
18637	24414	55	,	,	,
18637	24414	56	317	317	CD
18637	24414	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24414	58	95	95	CD
18637	24414	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24414	60	1942	1942	CD
18637	24414	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24414	62	,	,	,
18637	24414	63	110	110	CD
18637	24414	64	Riley	Riley	NNP
18637	24414	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	24414	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	68	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24414	69	,	,	,
18637	24414	70	232	232	CD
18637	24414	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24414	72	671	671	CD
18637	24414	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24414	74	1914	1914	CD
18637	24414	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24414	76	,	,	,
18637	24414	77	986	986	CD
18637	24414	78	,	,	,
18637	24414	79	987	987	CD
18637	24414	80	Riley	Riley	NNP
18637	24414	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	24414	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	84	New	New	NNP
18637	24414	85	York	York	NNP
18637	24414	86	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24414	87	Company	Company	NNP
18637	24414	88	,	,	,
18637	24414	89	315	315	CD
18637	24414	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24414	91	343	343	CD
18637	24414	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24414	93	1942	1942	CD
18637	24414	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24414	95	,	,	,
18637	24414	96	672	672	CD
18637	24414	97	Rindge	Rindge	NNP
18637	24414	98	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24414	99	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	24414	101	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	102	Los	Los	NNP
18637	24414	103	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
18637	24414	104	County	County	NNP
18637	24414	105	,	,	,
18637	24414	106	262	262	CD
18637	24414	107	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24414	108	700	700	CD
18637	24414	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24414	110	1923	1923	CD
18637	24414	111	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24414	112	,	,	,
18637	24414	113	866	866	CD
18637	24414	114	,	,	,
18637	24414	115	1065	1065	CD
18637	24414	116	Ritchie	Ritchie	NNP
18637	24414	117	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	118	v.	v.	IN
18637	24414	119	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	120	McMullen	McMullen	NNP
18637	24414	121	,	,	,
18637	24414	122	159	159	CD
18637	24414	123	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24414	124	235	235	CD
18637	24414	125	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24414	126	1895	1895	CD
18637	24414	127	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24414	128	,	,	,
18637	24414	129	685	685	CD
18637	24414	130	Riverdale	Riverdale	NNP
18637	24414	131	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	24414	132	Mills	Mills	NNPS
18637	24414	133	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	134	v.	v.	IN
18637	24414	135	_	_	NNP
18637	24414	136	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	24414	137	&	&	CC
18637	24414	138	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	24414	139	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	24414	140	.	.	.
18637	24415	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24415	2	,	,	,
18637	24415	3	198	198	CD
18637	24415	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24415	5	188	188	CD
18637	24415	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24415	7	1905	1905	CD
18637	24415	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24415	9	,	,	,
18637	24415	10	628	628	CD
18637	24415	11	,	,	,
18637	24415	12	660	660	CD
18637	24415	13	Riverside	Riverside	NNP
18637	24415	14	Mills	Mills	NNPS
18637	24415	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24415	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24415	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24415	18	Menefee	Menefee	NNP
18637	24415	19	,	,	,
18637	24415	20	237	237	CD
18637	24415	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24415	22	189	189	CD
18637	24415	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24415	24	1915	1915	CD
18637	24415	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24415	26	,	,	,
18637	24415	27	1074	1074	CD
18637	24415	28	,	,	,
18637	24415	29	1077	1077	CD
18637	24415	30	Riverside	Riverside	NNP
18637	24415	31	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24415	32	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24415	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24415	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24415	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24415	36	Hitchcock	Hitchcock	NNP
18637	24415	37	,	,	,
18637	24415	38	190	190	CD
18637	24415	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24415	40	316	316	CD
18637	24415	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24415	42	1903	1903	CD
18637	24415	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24415	44	,	,	,
18637	24415	45	501	501	CD
18637	24415	46	Road	Road	NNP
18637	24415	47	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	24415	48	.	.	.
18637	24416	1	Dist	dist	VB
18637	24416	2	.	.	.
18637	24417	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24417	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24417	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24417	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24417	5	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24418	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24418	2	,	,	,
18637	24418	3	274	274	CD
18637	24418	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24418	5	188	188	CD
18637	24418	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24418	7	1927	1927	CD
18637	24418	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24418	9	,	,	,
18637	24418	10	1041	1041	CD
18637	24418	11	,	,	,
18637	24418	12	1153	1153	CD
18637	24418	13	RoBards	RoBards	NNP
18637	24418	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24418	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24418	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24418	17	Lamb	Lamb	NNP
18637	24418	18	,	,	,
18637	24418	19	127	127	CD
18637	24418	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24418	21	58	58	CD
18637	24418	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24418	23	1888	1888	CD
18637	24418	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24418	25	,	,	,
18637	24418	26	1082	1082	CD
18637	24418	27	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
18637	24418	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24418	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24418	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24418	31	Shelby	Shelby	NNP
18637	24418	32	County	County	NNP
18637	24418	33	Taxing	Taxing	NNP
18637	24418	34	District	District	NNP
18637	24418	35	,	,	,
18637	24418	36	120	120	CD
18637	24418	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24418	38	489	489	CD
18637	24418	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24418	40	1887	1887	CD
18637	24418	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24418	42	,	,	,
18637	24418	43	186	186	CD
18637	24418	44	,	,	,
18637	24418	45	189	189	CD
18637	24418	46	,	,	,
18637	24418	47	191	191	CD
18637	24418	48	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	24418	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24418	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	24418	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24418	52	New	New	NNP
18637	24418	53	York	York	NNP
18637	24418	54	,	,	,
18637	24418	55	295	295	CD
18637	24418	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24418	57	264	264	CD
18637	24418	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24418	59	1935	1935	CD
18637	24418	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24418	61	,	,	,
18637	24418	62	1067	1067	CD
18637	24418	63	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	24418	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24418	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	24418	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24418	67	Reilly	Reilly	NNP
18637	24418	68	,	,	,
18637	24418	69	116	116	CD
18637	24418	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24418	71	80	80	CD
18637	24418	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24418	73	1885	1885	CD
18637	24418	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24418	75	,	,	,
18637	24418	76	694	694	CD
18637	24418	77	,	,	,
18637	24418	78	695	695	CD
18637	24418	79	Roberts	Roberts	NNP
18637	24418	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24418	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	24418	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24418	83	Richland	Richland	NNP
18637	24418	84	Irrig	Irrig	NNP
18637	24418	85	.	.	.
18637	24419	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24419	2	,	,	,
18637	24419	3	289	289	CD
18637	24419	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24419	5	71	71	CD
18637	24419	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24419	7	1933	1933	CD
18637	24419	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24419	9	,	,	,
18637	24419	10	1040	1040	CD
18637	24419	11	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	24419	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24419	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24419	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24419	15	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
18637	24419	16	,	,	,
18637	24419	17	165	165	CD
18637	24419	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24419	19	275	275	CD
18637	24419	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24419	21	1897	1897	CD
18637	24419	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24419	23	,	,	,
18637	24419	24	636	636	CD
18637	24419	25	,	,	,
18637	24419	26	770	770	CD
18637	24419	27	,	,	,
18637	24419	28	774	774	CD
18637	24419	29	,	,	,
18637	24419	30	884	884	CD
18637	24419	31	,	,	,
18637	24419	32	952	952	CD
18637	24419	33	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	24419	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24419	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	24419	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24419	37	Pickrell	Pickrell	NNP
18637	24419	38	,	,	,
18637	24419	39	109	109	CD
18637	24419	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24419	41	608	608	CD
18637	24419	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24419	43	1883	1883	CD
18637	24419	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24419	45	,	,	,
18637	24419	46	656	656	CD
18637	24419	47	,	,	,
18637	24419	48	673	673	CD
18637	24419	49	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	24419	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24419	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	24419	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24419	53	California	California	NNP
18637	24419	54	,	,	,
18637	24419	55	328	328	CD
18637	24419	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24419	57	440	440	CD
18637	24419	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24419	59	1946	1946	CD
18637	24419	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24419	61	,	,	,
18637	24419	62	127	127	CD
18637	24419	63	Robinson	Robinson	NNP
18637	24419	64	,	,	,
18637	24419	65	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24419	66	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24419	67	,	,	,
18637	24419	68	19	19	CD
18637	24419	69	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24419	70	.	.	.
18637	24420	1	505	505	CD
18637	24420	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24420	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	24420	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24420	5	,	,	,
18637	24420	6	515	515	CD
18637	24420	7	Roche	Roche	NNP
18637	24420	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24420	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24420	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24420	11	McDonald	McDonald	NNP
18637	24420	12	,	,	,
18637	24420	13	275	275	CD
18637	24420	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24420	15	449	449	CD
18637	24420	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24420	17	1928	1928	CD
18637	24420	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24420	19	,	,	,
18637	24420	20	655	655	CD
18637	24420	21	,	,	,
18637	24420	22	657	657	CD
18637	24420	23	Rochester	Rochester	NNP
18637	24420	24	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24420	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24420	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24420	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24420	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24420	29	Rochester	Rochester	NNP
18637	24420	30	,	,	,
18637	24420	31	205	205	CD
18637	24420	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24420	33	236	236	CD
18637	24420	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24420	35	1907	1907	CD
18637	24420	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24420	37	,	,	,
18637	24420	38	347	347	CD
18637	24420	39	Rochin	Rochin	NNP
18637	24420	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24420	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24420	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24420	43	California	California	NNP
18637	24420	44	,	,	,
18637	24420	45	342	342	CD
18637	24420	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24420	47	165	165	CD
18637	24420	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24420	49	1952	1952	CD
18637	24420	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24420	51	,	,	,
18637	24420	52	843	843	CD
18637	24420	53	,	,	,
18637	24420	54	1121	1121	CD
18637	24420	55	,	,	,
18637	24420	56	1124	1124	CD
18637	24420	57	Rockefeller	Rockefeller	NNP
18637	24420	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24420	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24420	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24420	61	United	United	NNP
18637	24420	62	States	States	NNP
18637	24420	63	,	,	,
18637	24420	64	257	257	CD
18637	24420	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24420	66	176	176	CD
18637	24420	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24420	68	1921	1921	CD
18637	24420	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24420	70	,	,	,
18637	24420	71	1195	1195	CD
18637	24420	72	Rodd	Rodd	NNP
18637	24420	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24420	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	24420	75	_	_	NNP
18637	24420	76	Heartt	Heartt	NNP
18637	24420	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24420	78	The	the	DT
18637	24420	79	"	"	``
18637	24420	80	Lottawanna	Lottawanna	NNP
18637	24420	81	"	"	''
18637	24420	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24420	83	,	,	,
18637	24420	84	21	21	CD
18637	24420	85	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24420	86	.	.	.
18637	24421	1	558	558	CD
18637	24421	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24421	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	24421	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24421	5	,	,	,
18637	24421	6	130	130	CD
18637	24421	7	,	,	,
18637	24421	8	579	579	CD
18637	24421	9	Rodman	Rodman	NNP
18637	24421	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24421	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24421	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24421	13	Pothier	Pothier	NNP
18637	24421	14	,	,	,
18637	24421	15	264	264	CD
18637	24421	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24421	17	399	399	CD
18637	24421	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24421	19	1924	1924	CD
18637	24421	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24421	21	,	,	,
18637	24421	22	695	695	CD
18637	24421	23	Rodney	Rodney	NNP
18637	24421	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24421	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24421	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24421	27	Hoey	Hoey	NNP
18637	24421	28	,	,	,
18637	24421	29	53	53	CD
18637	24421	30	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24421	31	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	24421	32	.	.	.
18637	24422	1	604	604	CD
18637	24422	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24422	3	1944	1944	CD
18637	24422	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24422	5	,	,	,
18637	24422	6	1197	1197	CD
18637	24422	7	Roe	Roe	NNP
18637	24422	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24422	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24422	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24422	11	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24422	12	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24422	13	rel	rel	NNP
18637	24422	14	.	.	.
18637	24423	1	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24423	2	,	,	,
18637	24423	3	278	278	CD
18637	24423	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	5	191	191	CD
18637	24423	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	7	1929	1929	CD
18637	24423	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	9	,	,	,
18637	24423	10	1065	1065	CD
18637	24423	11	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	24423	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	15	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	24423	16	,	,	,
18637	24423	17	192	192	CD
18637	24423	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	19	226	226	CD
18637	24423	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	21	1904	1904	CD
18637	24423	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	23	,	,	,
18637	24423	24	658	658	CD
18637	24423	25	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	24423	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	29	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	24423	30	,	,	,
18637	24423	31	227	227	CD
18637	24423	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	33	401	401	CD
18637	24423	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	35	1913	1913	CD
18637	24423	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	37	,	,	,
18637	24423	38	187	187	CD
18637	24423	39	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	24423	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	43	Hennepin	Hennepin	NNP
18637	24423	44	County	County	NNP
18637	24423	45	,	,	,
18637	24423	46	240	240	CD
18637	24423	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	48	184	184	CD
18637	24423	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	50	1916	1916	CD
18637	24423	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	52	,	,	,
18637	24423	53	1044	1044	CD
18637	24423	54	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	24423	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	58	Peck	Peck	NNP
18637	24423	59	,	,	,
18637	24423	60	199	199	CD
18637	24423	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	62	425	425	CD
18637	24423	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	64	1905	1905	CD
18637	24423	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	66	,	,	,
18637	24423	67	1141	1141	CD
18637	24423	68	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	24423	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	72	United	United	NNP
18637	24423	73	States	States	NNP
18637	24423	74	,	,	,
18637	24423	75	141	141	CD
18637	24423	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	77	548	548	CD
18637	24423	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	79	1891	1891	CD
18637	24423	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	81	,	,	,
18637	24423	82	897	897	CD
18637	24423	83	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	24423	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	86	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	87	United	United	NNP
18637	24423	88	States	States	NNP
18637	24423	89	,	,	,
18637	24423	90	340	340	CD
18637	24423	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	92	367	367	CD
18637	24423	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	94	1951	1951	CD
18637	24423	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	96	,	,	,
18637	24423	97	842	842	CD
18637	24423	98	,	,	,
18637	24423	99	843	843	CD
18637	24423	100	,	,	,
18637	24423	101	844	844	CD
18637	24423	102	Rogers	Rogers	NNP
18637	24423	103	Park	Park	NNP
18637	24423	104	Water	Water	NNP
18637	24423	105	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24423	106	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	107	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	108	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	109	Fergus	Fergus	NNP
18637	24423	110	,	,	,
18637	24423	111	180	180	CD
18637	24423	112	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	113	624	624	CD
18637	24423	114	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	115	1901	1901	CD
18637	24423	116	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	117	,	,	,
18637	24423	118	349	349	CD
18637	24423	119	Roland	Roland	NNP
18637	24423	120	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24423	121	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	122	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	123	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	124	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	24423	125	,	,	,
18637	24423	126	326	326	CD
18637	24423	127	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	128	657	657	CD
18637	24423	129	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	130	1946	1946	CD
18637	24423	131	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	132	,	,	,
18637	24423	133	158	158	CD
18637	24423	134	,	,	,
18637	24423	135	173	173	CD
18637	24423	136	Roller	Roller	NNP
18637	24423	137	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	138	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	139	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	140	Holly	Holly	NNP
18637	24423	141	,	,	,
18637	24423	142	176	176	CD
18637	24423	143	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	144	398	398	CD
18637	24423	145	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	146	1900	1900	CD
18637	24423	147	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	148	,	,	,
18637	24423	149	1088	1088	CD
18637	24423	150	Rolston	Rolston	NNP
18637	24423	151	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	152	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	153	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	154	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24423	155	Fund	Fund	NNP
18637	24423	156	Commissioners	Commissioners	NNPS
18637	24423	157	,	,	,
18637	24423	158	120	120	CD
18637	24423	159	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	160	390	390	CD
18637	24423	161	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	162	1887	1887	CD
18637	24423	163	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	164	,	,	,
18637	24423	165	932	932	CD
18637	24423	166	Romeu	Romeu	NNP
18637	24423	167	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	168	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	169	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	170	Todd	Todd	NNP
18637	24423	171	,	,	,
18637	24423	172	206	206	CD
18637	24423	173	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	174	358	358	CD
18637	24423	175	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	176	1907	1907	CD
18637	24423	177	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	178	,	,	,
18637	24423	179	704	704	CD
18637	24423	180	Rooney	Rooney	NNP
18637	24423	181	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	182	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	183	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	184	North	North	NNP
18637	24423	185	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	24423	186	,	,	,
18637	24423	187	196	196	CD
18637	24423	188	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	189	319	319	CD
18637	24423	190	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	191	1905	1905	CD
18637	24423	192	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	193	,	,	,
18637	24423	194	327	327	CD
18637	24423	195	,	,	,
18637	24423	196	328	328	CD
18637	24423	197	Root	Root	NNP
18637	24423	198	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	199	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	200	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	201	Woolworth	Woolworth	NNP
18637	24423	202	,	,	,
18637	24423	203	150	150	CD
18637	24423	204	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	205	401	401	CD
18637	24423	206	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	207	1893	1893	CD
18637	24423	208	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	209	,	,	,
18637	24423	210	629	629	CD
18637	24423	211	Rorick	Rorick	NNP
18637	24423	212	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	213	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	214	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	215	Commissioners	Commissioners	NNP
18637	24423	216	,	,	,
18637	24423	217	307	307	CD
18637	24423	218	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	219	208	208	CD
18637	24423	220	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	221	1939	1939	CD
18637	24423	222	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	223	,	,	,
18637	24423	224	631	631	CD
18637	24423	225	Roschen	Roschen	NNP
18637	24423	226	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	227	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	228	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	229	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	24423	230	,	,	,
18637	24423	231	279	279	CD
18637	24423	232	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	233	337	337	CD
18637	24423	234	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	235	1929	1929	CD
18637	24423	236	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	237	,	,	,
18637	24423	238	1030	1030	CD
18637	24423	239	Rosen	Rosen	NNP
18637	24423	240	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	241	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	242	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	243	United	United	NNP
18637	24423	244	States	States	NNP
18637	24423	245	,	,	,
18637	24423	246	161	161	CD
18637	24423	247	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	248	29	29	CD
18637	24423	249	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	250	1896	1896	CD
18637	24423	251	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	252	,	,	,
18637	24423	253	884	884	CD
18637	24423	254	Rosenberg	Rosenberg	NNP
18637	24423	255	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	24423	256	&	&	CC
18637	24423	257	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24423	258	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	259	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	260	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	261	Curtis	Curtis	NNP
18637	24423	262	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	24423	263	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24423	264	,	,	,
18637	24423	265	260	260	CD
18637	24423	266	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24423	267	516	516	CD
18637	24423	268	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24423	269	1923	1923	CD
18637	24423	270	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24423	271	,	,	,
18637	24423	272	1076	1076	CD
18637	24423	273	Rosenberger	Rosenberger	NNP
18637	24423	274	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	275	v.	v.	IN
18637	24423	276	_	_	NNP
18637	24423	277	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24423	278	Exp	Exp	NNP
18637	24423	279	.	.	.
18637	24424	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24424	2	,	,	,
18637	24424	3	241	241	CD
18637	24424	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24424	5	48	48	CD
18637	24424	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24424	7	1916	1916	CD
18637	24424	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24424	9	,	,	,
18637	24424	10	219	219	CD
18637	24424	11	Rosengrant	rosengrant	JJ
18637	24424	12	,	,	,
18637	24424	13	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24424	14	parte	parte	NN
18637	24424	15	,	,	,
18637	24424	16	213	213	CD
18637	24424	17	Ala.	Alabama	NNP
18637	24424	18	202	202	CD
18637	24424	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24424	20	1925	1925	CD
18637	24424	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24424	22	,	,	,
18637	24424	23	582	582	CD
18637	24424	24	Rosengrant	Rosengrant	NNP
18637	24424	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24424	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24424	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24424	28	Havard	Havard	NNP
18637	24424	29	,	,	,
18637	24424	30	273	273	CD
18637	24424	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24424	32	664	664	CD
18637	24424	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24424	34	1927	1927	CD
18637	24424	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24424	36	,	,	,
18637	24424	37	582	582	CD
18637	24424	38	Rosenthal	Rosenthal	NNP
18637	24424	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24424	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24424	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24424	42	New	New	NNP
18637	24424	43	York	York	NNP
18637	24424	44	,	,	,
18637	24424	45	226	226	CD
18637	24424	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24424	47	260	260	CD
18637	24424	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24424	49	1912	1912	CD
18637	24424	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24424	51	,	,	,
18637	24424	52	1024	1024	CD
18637	24424	53	Ross	Ross	NNP
18637	24424	54	,	,	,
18637	24424	55	In	in	IN
18637	24424	56	re	re	NN
18637	24424	57	,	,	,
18637	24424	58	140	140	CD
18637	24424	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24424	60	453	453	CD
18637	24424	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24424	62	1891	1891	CD
18637	24424	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24424	64	,	,	,
18637	24424	65	60	60	CD
18637	24424	66	,	,	,
18637	24424	67	427	427	CD
18637	24424	68	,	,	,
18637	24424	69	430	430	CD
18637	24424	70	,	,	,
18637	24424	71	533	533	CD
18637	24424	72	,	,	,
18637	24424	73	877	877	CD
18637	24424	74	Ross	Ross	NNP
18637	24424	75	_	_	NNP
18637	24424	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	24424	77	_	_	NNP
18637	24424	78	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24424	79	,	,	,
18637	24424	80	227	227	CD
18637	24424	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24424	82	150	150	CD
18637	24424	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24424	84	1913	1913	CD
18637	24424	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24424	86	,	,	,
18637	24424	87	327	327	CD
18637	24424	88	,	,	,
18637	24424	89	329	329	CD
18637	24424	90	Rowan	Rowan	NNP
18637	24424	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24424	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	24424	93	_	_	NNP
18637	24424	94	Runnels	Runnels	NNP
18637	24424	95	,	,	,
18637	24424	96	5	5	CD
18637	24424	97	How	how	WRB
18637	24424	98	.	.	.
18637	24425	1	134	134	CD
18637	24425	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24425	3	1847	1847	CD
18637	24425	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24425	5	,	,	,
18637	24425	6	604	604	CD
18637	24425	7	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	24425	8	Arcanum	Arcanum	NNP
18637	24425	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24425	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24425	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24425	12	Green	Green	NNP
18637	24425	13	,	,	,
18637	24425	14	237	237	CD
18637	24425	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24425	16	531	531	CD
18637	24425	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24425	18	1915	1915	CD
18637	24425	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24425	20	,	,	,
18637	24425	21	678	678	CD
18637	24425	22	Royall	Royall	NNP
18637	24425	23	,	,	,
18637	24425	24	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24425	25	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24425	26	,	,	,
18637	24425	27	117	117	CD
18637	24425	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24425	29	241	241	CD
18637	24425	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24425	31	1886	1886	CD
18637	24425	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24425	33	,	,	,
18637	24425	34	633	633	CD
18637	24425	35	Royster	Royster	NNP
18637	24425	36	Guano	Guano	NNP
18637	24425	37	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24425	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24425	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24425	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24425	41	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24425	42	,	,	,
18637	24425	43	253	253	CD
18637	24425	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24425	45	412	412	CD
18637	24425	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24425	47	1920	1920	CD
18637	24425	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24425	49	,	,	,
18637	24425	50	1150	1150	CD
18637	24425	51	,	,	,
18637	24425	52	1152	1152	CD
18637	24425	53	Rubber	Rubber	NNP
18637	24425	54	-	-	HYPH
18637	24425	55	Tip	Tip	NNP
18637	24425	56	Pencil	Pencil	NNP
18637	24425	57	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24425	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24425	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24425	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24425	61	Howard	Howard	NNP
18637	24425	62	,	,	,
18637	24425	63	20	20	CD
18637	24425	64	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24425	65	.	.	.
18637	24426	1	498	498	CD
18637	24426	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24426	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	24426	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24426	5	,	,	,
18637	24426	6	272	272	CD
18637	24426	7	,	,	,
18637	24426	8	273	273	CD
18637	24426	9	Ruddy	Ruddy	NNP
18637	24426	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24426	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24426	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24426	13	Rossi	Rossi	NNP
18637	24426	14	,	,	,
18637	24426	15	248	248	CD
18637	24426	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24426	17	104	104	CD
18637	24426	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24426	19	1918	1918	CD
18637	24426	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24426	21	,	,	,
18637	24426	22	702	702	CD
18637	24426	23	Ruhlin	Ruhlin	NNP
18637	24426	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24426	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24426	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24426	27	New	New	NNP
18637	24426	28	York	York	NNP
18637	24426	29	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24426	30	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24426	31	.	.	.
18637	24427	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24427	2	,	,	,
18637	24427	3	304	304	CD
18637	24427	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24427	5	202	202	CD
18637	24427	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	7	1938	1938	CD
18637	24427	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	9	,	,	,
18637	24427	10	608	608	CD
18637	24427	11	Rumely	rumely	RB
18637	24427	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24427	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24427	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24427	17	,	,	,
18637	24427	18	197	197	CD
18637	24427	19	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24427	20	2d	2d	CD
18637	24427	21	166	166	CD
18637	24427	22	,	,	,
18637	24427	23	174	174	CD
18637	24427	24	-	-	SYM
18637	24427	25	175	175	CD
18637	24427	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	27	1952	1952	CD
18637	24427	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	29	,	,	,
18637	24427	30	810	810	CD
18637	24427	31	Runkle	Runkle	NNP
18637	24427	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	24427	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	35	United	United	NNP
18637	24427	36	States	States	NNP
18637	24427	37	,	,	,
18637	24427	38	122	122	CD
18637	24427	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24427	40	543	543	CD
18637	24427	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	42	1887	1887	CD
18637	24427	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	44	,	,	,
18637	24427	45	476	476	CD
18637	24427	46	,	,	,
18637	24427	47	477	477	CD
18637	24427	48	Ruppert	Ruppert	NNP
18637	24427	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	24427	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	52	Caffey	Caffey	NNP
18637	24427	53	,	,	,
18637	24427	54	251	251	CD
18637	24427	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24427	56	264	264	CD
18637	24427	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	58	1920	1920	CD
18637	24427	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	60	,	,	,
18637	24427	61	293	293	CD
18637	24427	62	Russian	russian	JJ
18637	24427	63	Volunteer	Volunteer	NNP
18637	24427	64	Fleet	Fleet	NNP
18637	24427	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	24427	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	68	United	United	NNP
18637	24427	69	States	States	NNP
18637	24427	70	,	,	,
18637	24427	71	282	282	CD
18637	24427	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24427	73	481	481	CD
18637	24427	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	75	1931	1931	CD
18637	24427	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	77	,	,	,
18637	24427	78	865	865	CD
18637	24427	79	Ruthenberg	Ruthenberg	NNP
18637	24427	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	24427	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	83	United	United	NNP
18637	24427	84	States	States	NNP
18637	24427	85	,	,	,
18637	24427	86	245	245	CD
18637	24427	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24427	88	480	480	CD
18637	24427	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	90	1918	1918	CD
18637	24427	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	92	,	,	,
18637	24427	93	880	880	CD
18637	24427	94	Rutkin	Rutkin	NNP
18637	24427	95	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	24427	97	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	98	United	United	NNP
18637	24427	99	States	States	NNP
18637	24427	100	,	,	,
18637	24427	101	343	343	CD
18637	24427	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24427	103	130	130	CD
18637	24427	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	105	1952	1952	CD
18637	24427	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	107	,	,	,
18637	24427	108	1201	1201	CD
18637	24427	109	S	S	NNP
18637	24427	110	Sacher	Sacher	NNP
18637	24427	111	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	112	v.	v.	IN
18637	24427	113	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	114	United	United	NNP
18637	24427	115	States	States	NNP
18637	24427	116	,	,	,
18637	24427	117	343	343	CD
18637	24427	118	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24427	119	1	1	CD
18637	24427	120	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	121	1952	1952	CD
18637	24427	122	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	123	,	,	,
18637	24427	124	519	519	CD
18637	24427	125	Safe	Safe	NNP
18637	24427	126	Deposit	Deposit	NNP
18637	24427	127	and	and	CC
18637	24427	128	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24427	129	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24427	130	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	131	v.	v.	IN
18637	24427	132	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	133	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24427	134	,	,	,
18637	24427	135	280	280	CD
18637	24427	136	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24427	137	83	83	CD
18637	24427	138	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	139	1929	1929	CD
18637	24427	140	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	141	,	,	,
18637	24427	142	1044	1044	CD
18637	24427	143	Sage	Sage	NNP
18637	24427	144	Stores	Stores	NNPS
18637	24427	145	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	146	v.	v.	IN
18637	24427	147	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	148	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24427	149	,	,	,
18637	24427	150	323	323	CD
18637	24427	151	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24427	152	32	32	CD
18637	24427	153	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	154	1944	1944	CD
18637	24427	155	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	156	,	,	,
18637	24427	157	1031	1031	CD
18637	24427	158	Saia	Saia	NNP
18637	24427	159	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	160	v.	v.	IN
18637	24427	161	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	162	New	New	NNP
18637	24427	163	York	York	NNP
18637	24427	164	,	,	,
18637	24427	165	334	334	CD
18637	24427	166	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24427	167	558	558	CD
18637	24427	168	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	169	1948	1948	CD
18637	24427	170	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	171	,	,	,
18637	24427	172	563	563	CD
18637	24427	173	,	,	,
18637	24427	174	785	785	CD
18637	24427	175	,	,	,
18637	24427	176	788	788	CD
18637	24427	177	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24427	178	Anthony	Anthony	NNP
18637	24427	179	Falls	Falls	NNP
18637	24427	180	Water	Water	NNP
18637	24427	181	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24427	182	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24427	183	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	184	v.	v.	IN
18637	24427	185	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	186	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24427	187	of	of	IN
18637	24427	188	Water	Water	NNP
18637	24427	189	Commissioners	Commissioners	NNPS
18637	24427	190	,	,	,
18637	24427	191	168	168	CD
18637	24427	192	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24427	193	349	349	CD
18637	24427	194	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	195	1897	1897	CD
18637	24427	196	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	197	,	,	,
18637	24427	198	362	362	CD
18637	24427	199	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24427	200	Clair	Clair	NNP
18637	24427	201	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	202	v.	v.	IN
18637	24427	203	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	204	Cox	Cox	NNP
18637	24427	205	,	,	,
18637	24427	206	106	106	CD
18637	24427	207	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24427	208	350	350	CD
18637	24427	209	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	210	1882	1882	CD
18637	24427	211	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	212	,	,	,
18637	24427	213	1077	1077	CD
18637	24427	214	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24427	215	Germain	Germain	NNP
18637	24427	216	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	217	v.	v.	IN
18637	24427	218	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	219	Brunswick	Brunswick	NNP
18637	24427	220	,	,	,
18637	24427	221	135	135	CD
18637	24427	222	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24427	223	227	227	CD
18637	24427	224	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	225	1890	1890	CD
18637	24427	226	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	227	,	,	,
18637	24427	228	273	273	CD
18637	24427	229	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24427	230	John	John	NNP
18637	24427	231	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	232	v.	v.	IN
18637	24427	233	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	234	New	New	NNP
18637	24427	235	York	York	NNP
18637	24427	236	,	,	,
18637	24427	237	201	201	CD
18637	24427	238	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24427	239	633	633	CD
18637	24427	240	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	241	1906	1906	CD
18637	24427	242	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	243	,	,	,
18637	24427	244	1154	1154	CD
18637	24427	245	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24427	246	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
18637	24427	247	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	24427	248	Yards	Yards	NNP
18637	24427	249	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24427	250	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	251	v.	v.	IN
18637	24427	252	_	_	NNP
18637	24427	253	United	United	NNP
18637	24427	254	States	States	NNP
18637	24427	255	,	,	,
18637	24427	256	298	298	CD
18637	24427	257	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24427	258	38	38	CD
18637	24427	259	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24427	260	1936	1936	CD
18637	24427	261	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24427	262	,	,	,
18637	24427	263	850	850	CD
18637	24427	264	,	,	,
18637	24427	265	860	860	CD
18637	24427	266	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24427	267	Lawrence	Lawrence	NNP
18637	24427	268	,	,	,
18637	24427	269	The	the	DT
18637	24427	270	,	,	,
18637	24427	271	1	1	CD
18637	24427	272	Bl	Bl	NNP
18637	24427	273	.	.	.
18637	24428	1	522	522	CD
18637	24428	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24428	3	1862	1862	CD
18637	24428	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24428	5	,	,	,
18637	24428	6	579	579	CD
18637	24428	7	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24428	8	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24428	9	&	&	CC
18637	24428	10	K.C.	K.C.	NNP
18637	24429	1	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24429	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24429	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24429	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	24429	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24429	6	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24429	7	City	City	NNP
18637	24429	8	,	,	,
18637	24429	9	241	241	CD
18637	24429	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24429	11	419	419	CD
18637	24429	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24429	13	1916	1916	CD
18637	24429	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24429	15	,	,	,
18637	24429	16	893	893	CD
18637	24429	17	,	,	,
18637	24429	18	1059	1059	CD
18637	24429	19	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24429	20	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24429	21	&	&	CC
18637	24429	22	O'Fallon	O'Fallon	NNP
18637	24429	23	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	24429	24	.	.	.
18637	24430	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24430	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24430	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24430	4	United	United	NNP
18637	24430	5	States	States	NNP
18637	24430	6	,	,	,
18637	24430	7	279	279	CD
18637	24430	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24430	9	461	461	CD
18637	24430	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24430	11	1929	1929	CD
18637	24430	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24430	13	,	,	,
18637	24430	14	1006	1006	CD
18637	24430	15	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24430	16	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24430	17	&	&	CC
18637	24430	18	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	24431	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24431	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24431	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24431	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24431	5	James	James	NNP
18637	24431	6	,	,	,
18637	24431	7	161	161	CD
18637	24431	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24431	9	545	545	CD
18637	24431	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24431	11	1896	1896	CD
18637	24431	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24431	13	,	,	,
18637	24431	14	369	369	CD
18637	24431	15	,	,	,
18637	24431	16	602	602	CD
18637	24431	17	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24431	18	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24431	19	&	&	CC
18637	24431	20	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	24432	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24432	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24432	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24432	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24432	5	Mathews	Mathews	NNP
18637	24432	6	,	,	,
18637	24432	7	165	165	CD
18637	24432	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24432	9	1	1	CD
18637	24432	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24432	11	1897	1897	CD
18637	24432	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24432	13	,	,	,
18637	24432	14	345	345	CD
18637	24432	15	,	,	,
18637	24432	16	1015	1015	CD
18637	24432	17	,	,	,
18637	24432	18	1156	1156	CD
18637	24432	19	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24432	20	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24432	21	&	&	CC
18637	24432	22	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	24433	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24433	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24433	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24433	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24433	5	Middlekamp	Middlekamp	NNP
18637	24433	6	,	,	,
18637	24433	7	256	256	CD
18637	24433	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24433	9	226	226	CD
18637	24433	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24433	11	1921	1921	CD
18637	24433	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24433	13	,	,	,
18637	24433	14	1152	1152	CD
18637	24433	15	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24433	16	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24433	17	&	&	CC
18637	24433	18	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	24434	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24434	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24434	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24434	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24434	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24434	6	Service	Service	NNP
18637	24434	7	Com	Com	NNP
18637	24434	8	.	.	NNP
18637	24434	9	,	,	,
18637	24434	10	261	261	CD
18637	24434	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24434	12	369	369	CD
18637	24434	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24434	14	1923	1923	CD
18637	24434	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24434	16	,	,	,
18637	24434	17	221	221	CD
18637	24434	18	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24434	19	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24434	20	&	&	CC
18637	24434	21	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	24435	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24435	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24435	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24435	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24435	5	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24435	6	Service	Service	NNP
18637	24435	7	Com	Com	NNP
18637	24435	8	.	.	NNP
18637	24435	9	,	,	,
18637	24435	10	254	254	CD
18637	24435	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24435	12	535	535	CD
18637	24435	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24435	14	1921	1921	CD
18637	24435	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24435	16	,	,	,
18637	24435	17	219	219	CD
18637	24435	18	,	,	,
18637	24435	19	221	221	CD
18637	24435	20	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24435	21	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24435	22	Cotton	Cotton	NNP
18637	24435	23	Compress	Compress	NNP
18637	24435	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24435	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24435	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24435	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24435	28	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	24435	29	,	,	,
18637	24435	30	260	260	CD
18637	24435	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24435	32	346	346	CD
18637	24435	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24435	34	1922	1922	CD
18637	24435	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24435	36	,	,	,
18637	24435	37	1056	1056	CD
18637	24435	38	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24435	39	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24435	40	,	,	,
18637	24435	41	I.M.	I.M.	NNP
18637	24436	1	&	&	CC
18637	24436	2	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	24437	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24437	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24437	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24437	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24437	5	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	24437	6	,	,	,
18637	24437	7	240	240	CD
18637	24437	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24437	9	518	518	CD
18637	24437	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24437	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	24437	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24437	13	,	,	,
18637	24437	14	223	223	CD
18637	24437	15	,	,	,
18637	24437	16	1014	1014	CD
18637	24437	17	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24437	18	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24437	19	,	,	,
18637	24437	20	I.M.	I.M.	NNP
18637	24438	1	&	&	CC
18637	24438	2	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	24439	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24439	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24439	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24439	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24439	5	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	24439	6	,	,	,
18637	24439	7	227	227	CD
18637	24439	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24439	9	265	265	CD
18637	24439	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24439	11	1913	1913	CD
18637	24439	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24439	13	,	,	,
18637	24439	14	247	247	CD
18637	24439	15	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24439	16	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24439	17	,	,	,
18637	24439	18	I.M.	I.M.	NNP
18637	24440	1	&	&	CC
18637	24440	2	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	24441	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24441	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24441	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24441	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24441	5	Paul	Paul	NNP
18637	24441	6	,	,	,
18637	24441	7	173	173	CD
18637	24441	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24441	9	404	404	CD
18637	24441	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24441	11	1899	1899	CD
18637	24441	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24441	13	,	,	,
18637	24441	14	988	988	CD
18637	24441	15	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24441	16	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24441	17	,	,	,
18637	24441	18	I.M.	I.M.	NNP
18637	24442	1	&	&	CC
18637	24442	2	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	24443	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24443	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24443	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24443	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24443	5	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24443	6	,	,	,
18637	24443	7	210	210	CD
18637	24443	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24443	9	281	281	CD
18637	24443	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24443	11	1908	1908	CD
18637	24443	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24443	13	,	,	,
18637	24443	14	78	78	CD
18637	24443	15	,	,	,
18637	24443	16	616	616	CD
18637	24443	17	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24443	18	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24443	19	,	,	,
18637	24443	20	I.M.	I.M.	NNP
18637	24444	1	&	&	CC
18637	24444	2	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	24445	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24445	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24445	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24445	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24445	5	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24445	6	,	,	,
18637	24445	7	251	251	CD
18637	24445	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24445	9	63	63	CD
18637	24445	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24445	11	1919	1919	CD
18637	24445	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24445	13	,	,	,
18637	24445	14	1015	1015	CD
18637	24445	15	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24445	16	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24445	17	,	,	,
18637	24445	18	I.M.	I.M.	NNP
18637	24446	1	&	&	CC
18637	24446	2	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	24447	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24447	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24447	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24447	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24447	5	Wynne	Wynne	NNP
18637	24447	6	,	,	,
18637	24447	7	224	224	CD
18637	24447	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24447	9	354	354	CD
18637	24447	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24447	11	1912	1912	CD
18637	24447	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24447	13	,	,	,
18637	24447	14	1015	1015	CD
18637	24447	15	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24447	16	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24447	17	Poster	Poster	NNP
18637	24447	18	Advertising	Advertising	NNP
18637	24447	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24447	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24447	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24447	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24447	23	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24447	24	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24447	25	,	,	,
18637	24447	26	249	249	CD
18637	24447	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24447	28	269	269	CD
18637	24447	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24447	30	1919	1919	CD
18637	24447	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24447	32	,	,	,
18637	24447	33	1029	1029	CD
18637	24447	34	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24447	35	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24447	36	,	,	,
18637	24447	37	S.F.	S.F.	NNP
18637	24448	1	&	&	CC
18637	24448	2	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	24449	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24449	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24449	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24449	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24449	5	Seale	Seale	NNP
18637	24449	6	,	,	,
18637	24449	7	229	229	CD
18637	24449	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24449	9	156	156	CD
18637	24449	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24449	11	1913	1913	CD
18637	24449	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24449	13	,	,	,
18637	24449	14	141	141	CD
18637	24449	15	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24449	16	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24449	17	,	,	,
18637	24449	18	S.W.R.	S.W.R.	NNP
18637	24450	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24450	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24450	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24450	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24450	5	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	24450	6	,	,	,
18637	24450	7	227	227	CD
18637	24450	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24450	9	218	218	CD
18637	24450	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24450	11	1913	1913	CD
18637	24450	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24450	13	,	,	,
18637	24450	14	1076	1076	CD
18637	24450	15	,	,	,
18637	24450	16	1077	1077	CD
18637	24450	17	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24450	18	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24450	19	,	,	,
18637	24450	20	S.W.R.	S.W.R.	NNP
18637	24451	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24451	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24451	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24451	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24451	5	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	24451	6	,	,	,
18637	24451	7	217	217	CD
18637	24451	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24451	9	136	136	CD
18637	24451	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24451	11	1910	1910	CD
18637	24451	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24451	13	,	,	,
18637	24451	14	222	222	CD
18637	24451	15	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24451	16	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24451	17	,	,	,
18637	24451	18	S.W.R.	S.W.R.	NNP
18637	24452	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24452	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24452	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24452	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24452	5	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	24452	6	ex	ex	VBD
18637	24452	7	rel	rel	NN
18637	24452	8	.	.	.
18637	24453	1	Norwood	Norwood	NNP
18637	24453	2	,	,	,
18637	24453	3	235	235	CD
18637	24453	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24453	5	350	350	CD
18637	24453	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24453	7	1914	1914	CD
18637	24453	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24453	9	,	,	,
18637	24453	10	1051	1051	CD
18637	24453	11	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24453	12	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24453	13	,	,	,
18637	24453	14	S.W.	S.W.	NNP
18637	24454	1	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	24454	2	.	.	.
18637	24455	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24455	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24455	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24455	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24455	5	United	United	NNP
18637	24455	6	States	States	NNP
18637	24455	7	,	,	,
18637	24455	8	245	245	CD
18637	24455	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24455	10	136	136	CD
18637	24455	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24455	12	1917	1917	CD
18637	24455	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24455	14	,	,	,
18637	24455	15	861	861	CD
18637	24455	16	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24455	17	Pierre	Pierre	NNP
18637	24455	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24455	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24455	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24455	21	United	United	NNP
18637	24455	22	States	States	NNP
18637	24455	23	,	,	,
18637	24455	24	319	319	CD
18637	24455	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24455	26	41	41	CD
18637	24455	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24455	28	1943	1943	CD
18637	24455	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24455	30	,	,	,
18637	24455	31	545	545	CD
18637	24455	32	Salinger	Salinger	NNP
18637	24455	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24455	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24455	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24455	36	Loisel	Loisel	NNP
18637	24455	37	,	,	,
18637	24455	38	265	265	CD
18637	24455	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24455	40	224	224	CD
18637	24455	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24455	42	1924	1924	CD
18637	24455	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24455	44	,	,	,
18637	24455	45	315	315	CD
18637	24455	46	,	,	,
18637	24455	47	881	881	CD
18637	24455	48	Salinger	Salinger	NNP
18637	24455	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24455	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	24455	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24455	52	United	United	NNP
18637	24455	53	States	States	NNP
18637	24455	54	,	,	,
18637	24455	55	272	272	CD
18637	24455	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24455	57	542	542	CD
18637	24455	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24455	59	1926	1926	CD
18637	24455	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24455	61	,	,	,
18637	24455	62	884	884	CD
18637	24455	63	Salomon	Salomon	NNP
18637	24455	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24455	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	24455	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24455	67	State	State	NNP
18637	24455	68	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24455	69	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24455	70	,	,	,
18637	24455	71	278	278	CD
18637	24455	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24455	73	484	484	CD
18637	24455	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24455	75	1929	1929	CD
18637	24455	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24455	77	,	,	,
18637	24455	78	1038	1038	CD
18637	24455	79	Salt	Salt	NNP
18637	24455	80	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24455	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24455	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	24455	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24455	84	East	East	NNP
18637	24455	85	Saginaw	Saginaw	NNP
18637	24455	86	,	,	,
18637	24455	87	13	13	CD
18637	24455	88	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24455	89	.	.	.
18637	24456	1	373	373	CD
18637	24456	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24456	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	24456	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24456	5	,	,	,
18637	24456	6	342	342	CD
18637	24456	7	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
18637	24456	8	,	,	,
18637	24456	9	The	the	DT
18637	24456	10	,	,	,
18637	24456	11	1	1	CD
18637	24456	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24456	13	.	.	.
18637	24457	1	9	9	CD
18637	24457	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24457	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	24457	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24457	5	,	,	,
18637	24457	6	,	,	,
18637	24457	7	576	576	CD
18637	24457	8	Samuels	Samuels	NNPS
18637	24457	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24457	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24457	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24457	12	McCurdy	McCurdy	NNP
18637	24457	13	,	,	,
18637	24457	14	267	267	CD
18637	24457	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24457	16	188	188	CD
18637	24457	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24457	18	1925	1925	CD
18637	24457	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24457	20	,	,	,
18637	24457	21	327	327	CD
18637	24457	22	,	,	,
18637	24457	23	1087	1087	CD
18637	24457	24	Sanborn	Sanborn	NNP
18637	24457	25	,	,	,
18637	24457	26	In	in	IN
18637	24457	27	re	re	NN
18637	24457	28	,	,	,
18637	24457	29	148	148	CD
18637	24457	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24457	31	222	222	CD
18637	24457	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24457	33	1893	1893	CD
18637	24457	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24457	35	,	,	,
18637	24457	36	514	514	CD
18637	24457	37	,	,	,
18637	24457	38	550	550	CD
18637	24457	39	Sanders	Sanders	NNPS
18637	24457	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24457	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24457	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24457	43	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	24457	44	Fertilizer	Fertilizer	NNP
18637	24457	45	Works	Works	NNP
18637	24457	46	,	,	,
18637	24457	47	292	292	CD
18637	24457	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24457	49	190	190	CD
18637	24457	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24457	51	1934	1934	CD
18637	24457	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24457	53	,	,	,
18637	24457	54	684	684	CD
18637	24457	55	San	San	NNP
18637	24457	56	Diego	Diego	NNP
18637	24457	57	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24457	58	&	&	CC
18637	24457	59	Town	Town	NNP
18637	24457	60	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24457	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24457	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	24457	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24457	64	Jasper	Jasper	NNP
18637	24457	65	,	,	,
18637	24457	66	189	189	CD
18637	24457	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24457	68	439	439	CD
18637	24457	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24457	70	1903	1903	CD
18637	24457	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24457	72	,	,	,
18637	24457	73	1002	1002	CD
18637	24457	74	,	,	,
18637	24457	75	1006	1006	CD
18637	24457	76	San	San	NNP
18637	24457	77	Diego	Diego	NNP
18637	24457	78	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24457	79	&	&	CC
18637	24457	80	Town	Town	NNP
18637	24457	81	Company	Company	NNP
18637	24457	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24457	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	24457	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24457	85	National	National	NNP
18637	24457	86	City	City	NNP
18637	24457	87	,	,	,
18637	24457	88	174	174	CD
18637	24457	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24457	90	739	739	CD
18637	24457	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24457	92	1899	1899	CD
18637	24457	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24457	94	,	,	,
18637	24457	95	1002	1002	CD
18637	24457	96	,	,	,
18637	24457	97	1006	1006	CD
18637	24457	98	Sands	Sands	NNPS
18637	24457	99	_	_	NNP
18637	24457	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	24457	101	_	_	NNP
18637	24457	102	Manistee	Manistee	NNP
18637	24457	103	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24457	104	Imp	Imp	NNP
18637	24457	105	.	.	.
18637	24458	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24458	2	,	,	,
18637	24458	3	123	123	CD
18637	24458	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24458	5	288	288	CD
18637	24458	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24458	7	1887	1887	CD
18637	24458	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24458	9	,	,	,
18637	24458	10	231	231	CD
18637	24458	11	,	,	,
18637	24458	12	699	699	CD
18637	24458	13	Sanitary	Sanitary	NNP
18637	24458	14	District	District	NNP
18637	24458	15	of	of	IN
18637	24458	16	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	24458	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24458	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24458	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24458	20	United	United	NNP
18637	24458	21	States	States	NNP
18637	24458	22	,	,	,
18637	24458	23	266	266	CD
18637	24458	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24458	25	405	405	CD
18637	24458	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24458	27	1925	1925	CD
18637	24458	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24458	29	,	,	,
18637	24458	30	920	920	CD
18637	24458	31	Santa	Santa	NNP
18637	24458	32	Clara	Clara	NNP
18637	24458	33	County	County	NNP
18637	24458	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24458	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	24458	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24458	37	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24458	38	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24459	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24459	2	,	,	,
18637	24459	3	118	118	CD
18637	24459	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24459	5	394	394	CD
18637	24459	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24459	7	1886	1886	CD
18637	24459	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24459	9	,	,	,
18637	24459	10	1143	1143	CD
18637	24459	11	,	,	,
18637	24459	12	1146	1146	CD
18637	24459	13	Santa	Santa	NNP
18637	24459	14	Cruz	Cruz	NNP
18637	24459	15	Fruit	Fruit	NNP
18637	24459	16	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	24459	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24459	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24459	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24459	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24459	21	N.L.R.B.	N.L.R.B.	NNP
18637	24459	22	,	,	,
18637	24459	23	303	303	CD
18637	24459	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24459	25	453	453	CD
18637	24459	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24459	27	1938	1938	CD
18637	24459	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24459	29	,	,	,
18637	24459	30	,	,	,
18637	24459	31	155	155	CD
18637	24459	32	Santiago	Santiago	NNP
18637	24459	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24459	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24459	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24459	36	Nogueras	Nogueras	NNP
18637	24459	37	,	,	,
18637	24459	38	214	214	CD
18637	24459	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24459	40	260	260	CD
18637	24459	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24459	42	1909	1909	CD
18637	24459	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24459	44	,	,	,
18637	24459	45	404	404	CD
18637	24459	46	,	,	,
18637	24459	47	493	493	CD
18637	24459	48	Santovincenzo	Santovincenzo	NNP
18637	24459	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24459	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	24459	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24459	52	Egan	Egan	NNP
18637	24459	53	,	,	,
18637	24459	54	284	284	CD
18637	24459	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24459	56	30	30	CD
18637	24459	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24459	58	1931	1931	CD
18637	24459	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24459	60	,	,	,
18637	24459	61	439	439	CD
18637	24459	62	Sapphire	Sapphire	NNP
18637	24459	63	,	,	,
18637	24459	64	The	the	DT
18637	24459	65	,	,	,
18637	24459	66	11	11	CD
18637	24459	67	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24459	68	.	.	.
18637	24460	1	164	164	CD
18637	24460	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24460	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24460	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24460	5	,	,	,
18637	24460	6	610	610	CD
18637	24460	7	Sarah	Sarah	NNP
18637	24460	8	,	,	,
18637	24460	9	The	the	DT
18637	24460	10	,	,	,
18637	24460	11	8	8	CD
18637	24460	12	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24460	13	.	.	.
18637	24461	1	391	391	CD
18637	24461	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24461	3	1823	1823	CD
18637	24461	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24461	5	,	,	,
18637	24461	6	575	575	CD
18637	24461	7	,	,	,
18637	24461	8	893	893	CD
18637	24461	9	Satterlee	Satterlee	NNP
18637	24461	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24461	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24461	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24461	13	Matthewson	Matthewson	NNP
18637	24461	14	,	,	,
18637	24461	15	2	2	CD
18637	24461	16	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24461	17	.	.	.
18637	24462	1	380	380	CD
18637	24462	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24462	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	24462	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24462	5	,	,	,
18637	24462	6	336	336	CD
18637	24462	7	,	,	,
18637	24462	8	343	343	CD
18637	24462	9	Sauer	Sauer	NNP
18637	24462	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24462	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	13	New	New	NNP
18637	24462	14	York	York	NNP
18637	24462	15	,	,	,
18637	24462	16	206	206	CD
18637	24462	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24462	18	536	536	CD
18637	24462	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24462	20	1907	1907	CD
18637	24462	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24462	22	,	,	,
18637	24462	23	331	331	CD
18637	24462	24	,	,	,
18637	24462	25	1068	1068	CD
18637	24462	26	Sanders	Sanders	NNPS
18637	24462	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24462	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	30	Armour	Armour	NNP
18637	24462	31	Fertilizer	Fertilizer	NNP
18637	24462	32	Works	Works	NNP
18637	24462	33	,	,	,
18637	24462	34	292	292	CD
18637	24462	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24462	36	190	190	CD
18637	24462	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24462	38	1934	1934	CD
18637	24462	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24462	40	,	,	,
18637	24462	41	684	684	CD
18637	24462	42	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
18637	24462	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24462	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	46	Shaw	Shaw	NNP
18637	24462	47	,	,	,
18637	24462	48	244	244	CD
18637	24462	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24462	50	317	317	CD
18637	24462	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24462	52	1917	1917	CD
18637	24462	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24462	54	,	,	,
18637	24462	55	1088	1088	CD
18637	24462	56	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
18637	24462	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	24462	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	60	Wilkins	Wilkins	NNP
18637	24462	61	,	,	,
18637	24462	62	152	152	CD
18637	24462	63	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24462	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24462	65	2d	2d	NNP
18637	24462	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24462	67	235	235	CD
18637	24462	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24462	69	1945	1945	CD
18637	24462	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24462	71	,	,	,
18637	24462	72	1172	1172	CD
18637	24462	73	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
18637	24462	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	24462	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	77	Wilkins	Wilkins	NNP
18637	24462	78	,	,	,
18637	24462	79	328	328	CD
18637	24462	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24462	81	870	870	CD
18637	24462	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24462	83	1946	1946	CD
18637	24462	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24462	85	,	,	,
18637	24462	86	1172	1172	CD
18637	24462	87	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
18637	24462	88	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	24462	90	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	91	Wilkins	Wilkins	NNP
18637	24462	92	,	,	,
18637	24462	93	329	329	CD
18637	24462	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24462	95	825	825	CD
18637	24462	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24462	97	1946	1946	CD
18637	24462	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24462	99	,	,	,
18637	24462	100	1172	1172	CD
18637	24462	101	Savage	Savage	NNP
18637	24462	102	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	103	v.	v.	IN
18637	24462	104	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	105	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	24462	106	,	,	,
18637	24462	107	225	225	CD
18637	24462	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24462	109	501	501	CD
18637	24462	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24462	111	1912	1912	CD
18637	24462	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24462	113	,	,	,
18637	24462	114	183	183	CD
18637	24462	115	,	,	,
18637	24462	116	238	238	CD
18637	24462	117	,	,	,
18637	24462	118	241	241	CD
18637	24462	119	,	,	,
18637	24462	120	248	248	CD
18637	24462	121	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	24462	122	&	&	CC
18637	24462	123	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	24462	124	Association	Association	NNP
18637	24462	125	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	126	v.	v.	IN
18637	24462	127	_	_	NNP
18637	24462	128	Topeka	Topeka	NNP
18637	24462	129	,	,	,
18637	24462	130	20	20	CD
18637	24462	131	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24462	132	.	.	.
18637	24463	1	655	655	CD
18637	24463	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24463	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	24463	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24463	5	,	,	,
18637	24463	6	975	975	CD
18637	24463	7	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	24463	8	&	&	CC
18637	24463	9	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24463	10	Soc	Soc	NNP
18637	24463	11	.	.	.
18637	24464	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24464	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	4	Multnomah	Multnomah	NNP
18637	24464	5	County	County	NNP
18637	24464	6	,	,	,
18637	24464	7	169	169	CD
18637	24464	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24464	9	421	421	CD
18637	24464	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24464	11	1898	1898	CD
18637	24464	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24464	13	,	,	,
18637	24464	14	1044	1044	CD
18637	24464	15	Sawyer	Sawyer	NNP
18637	24464	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24464	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	19	Kochersperger	Kochersperger	NNP
18637	24464	20	,	,	,
18637	24464	21	170	170	CD
18637	24464	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24464	23	303	303	CD
18637	24464	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24464	25	1898	1898	CD
18637	24464	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24464	27	,	,	,
18637	24464	28	567	567	CD
18637	24464	29	Sawyer	Sawyer	NNP
18637	24464	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24464	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	33	Piper	Piper	NNP
18637	24464	34	,	,	,
18637	24464	35	189	189	CD
18637	24464	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24464	37	154	154	CD
18637	24464	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24464	39	1903	1903	CD
18637	24464	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24464	41	,	,	,
18637	24464	42	1091	1091	CD
18637	24464	43	Sawyer	Sawyer	NNP
18637	24464	44	,	,	,
18637	24464	45	In	in	IN
18637	24464	46	re	re	NN
18637	24464	47	,	,	,
18637	24464	48	124	124	CD
18637	24464	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24464	50	200	200	CD
18637	24464	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24464	52	1888	1888	CD
18637	24464	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24464	54	,	,	,
18637	24464	55	630	630	CD
18637	24464	56	Schaefer	Schaefer	NNP
18637	24464	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	24464	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	60	United	United	NNP
18637	24464	61	States	States	NNP
18637	24464	62	,	,	,
18637	24464	63	251	251	CD
18637	24464	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24464	65	466	466	CD
18637	24464	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24464	67	1920	1920	CD
18637	24464	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24464	69	,	,	,
18637	24464	70	774	774	CD
18637	24464	71	,	,	,
18637	24464	72	794	794	CD
18637	24464	73	Schechter	Schechter	NNP
18637	24464	74	Poultry	Poultry	NNP
18637	24464	75	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	24464	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	24464	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	79	United	United	NNP
18637	24464	80	States	States	NNP
18637	24464	81	,	,	,
18637	24464	82	295	295	CD
18637	24464	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24464	84	495	495	CD
18637	24464	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24464	86	1935	1935	CD
18637	24464	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24464	88	,	,	,
18637	24464	89	75	75	CD
18637	24464	90	,	,	,
18637	24464	91	76	76	CD
18637	24464	92	,	,	,
18637	24464	93	78	78	CD
18637	24464	94	,	,	,
18637	24464	95	153	153	CD
18637	24464	96	,	,	,
18637	24464	97	917	917	CD
18637	24464	98	Schenck	Schenck	NNP
18637	24464	99	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	24464	101	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	102	United	United	NNP
18637	24464	103	States	States	NNP
18637	24464	104	,	,	,
18637	24464	105	249	249	CD
18637	24464	106	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24464	107	47	47	CD
18637	24464	108	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24464	109	1919	1919	CD
18637	24464	110	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24464	111	,	,	,
18637	24464	112	297	297	CD
18637	24464	113	,	,	,
18637	24464	114	772	772	CD
18637	24464	115	,	,	,
18637	24464	116	773	773	CD
18637	24464	117	,	,	,
18637	24464	118	774	774	CD
18637	24464	119	,	,	,
18637	24464	120	776	776	CD
18637	24464	121	,	,	,
18637	24464	122	794	794	CD
18637	24464	123	,	,	,
18637	24464	124	799	799	CD
18637	24464	125	Scher	Scher	NNP
18637	24464	126	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	127	v.	v.	IN
18637	24464	128	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	129	United	United	NNP
18637	24464	130	States	States	NNP
18637	24464	131	,	,	,
18637	24464	132	305	305	CD
18637	24464	133	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24464	134	251	251	CD
18637	24464	135	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24464	136	1938	1938	CD
18637	24464	137	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24464	138	,	,	,
18637	24464	139	,	,	,
18637	24464	140	830	830	CD
18637	24464	141	Schick	Schick	NNP
18637	24464	142	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	143	v.	v.	IN
18637	24464	144	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	145	United	United	NNP
18637	24464	146	States	States	NNP
18637	24464	147	,	,	,
18637	24464	148	195	195	CD
18637	24464	149	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24464	150	65	65	CD
18637	24464	151	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24464	152	1904	1904	CD
18637	24464	153	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24464	154	,	,	,
18637	24464	155	878	878	CD
18637	24464	156	Schmidinger	Schmidinger	NNP
18637	24464	157	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	158	v.	v.	IN
18637	24464	159	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	160	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	24464	161	,	,	,
18637	24464	162	226	226	CD
18637	24464	163	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24464	164	578	578	CD
18637	24464	165	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24464	166	1913	1913	CD
18637	24464	167	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24464	168	,	,	,
18637	24464	169	982	982	CD
18637	24464	170	,	,	,
18637	24464	171	1018	1018	CD
18637	24464	172	,	,	,
18637	24464	173	1019	1019	CD
18637	24464	174	,	,	,
18637	24464	175	1154	1154	CD
18637	24464	176	Schneider	Schneider	NNP
18637	24464	177	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	178	v.	v.	IN
18637	24464	179	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	180	Irvington	Irvington	NNP
18637	24464	181	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24464	182	State	State	NNP
18637	24464	183	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24464	184	,	,	,
18637	24464	185	308	308	CD
18637	24464	186	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24464	187	147	147	CD
18637	24464	188	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24464	189	1939	1939	CD
18637	24464	190	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24464	191	,	,	,
18637	24464	192	563	563	CD
18637	24464	193	,	,	,
18637	24464	194	786	786	CD
18637	24464	195	,	,	,
18637	24464	196	788	788	CD
18637	24464	197	Schneiderman	Schneiderman	NNP
18637	24464	198	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	199	v.	v.	IN
18637	24464	200	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	201	United	United	NNP
18637	24464	202	States	States	NNP
18637	24464	203	,	,	,
18637	24464	204	320	320	CD
18637	24464	205	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24464	206	118	118	CD
18637	24464	207	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24464	208	1943	1943	CD
18637	24464	209	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24464	210	,	,	,
18637	24464	211	257	257	CD
18637	24464	212	Schnell	Schnell	NNP
18637	24464	213	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	214	v.	v.	IN
18637	24464	215	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	216	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	24464	217	,	,	,
18637	24464	218	336	336	CD
18637	24464	219	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24464	220	933	933	CD
18637	24464	221	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24464	222	1949	1949	CD
18637	24464	223	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24464	224	,	,	,
18637	24464	225	1186	1186	CD
18637	24464	226	Schoenthal	Schoenthal	NNP
18637	24464	227	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	228	v.	v.	IN
18637	24464	229	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	230	Irving	Irving	NNP
18637	24464	231	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24464	232	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24464	233	,	,	,
18637	24464	234	287	287	CD
18637	24464	235	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24464	236	92	92	CD
18637	24464	237	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24464	238	1932	1932	CD
18637	24464	239	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24464	240	,	,	,
18637	24464	241	895	895	CD
18637	24464	242	Scholey	Scholey	NNP
18637	24464	243	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	244	v.	v.	IN
18637	24464	245	_	_	NNP
18637	24464	246	Rew	Rew	NNP
18637	24464	247	,	,	,
18637	24464	248	23	23	CD
18637	24464	249	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24464	250	.	.	.
18637	24465	1	331	331	CD
18637	24465	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24465	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	24465	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24465	5	,	,	,
18637	24465	6	319	319	CD
18637	24465	7	Schollenberger	Schollenberger	NNP
18637	24465	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24465	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24465	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24465	11	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24465	12	,	,	,
18637	24465	13	171	171	CD
18637	24465	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24465	15	1	1	CD
18637	24465	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24465	17	1898	1898	CD
18637	24465	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24465	19	,	,	,
18637	24465	20	240	240	CD
18637	24465	21	,	,	,
18637	24465	22	364	364	CD
18637	24465	23	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
18637	24465	24	Betsey	Betsey	NNP
18637	24465	25	,	,	,
18637	24465	26	The	the	DT
18637	24465	27	,	,	,
18637	24465	28	4	4	CD
18637	24465	29	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24465	30	.	.	.
18637	24466	1	443	443	CD
18637	24466	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24466	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	24466	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24466	5	,	,	,
18637	24466	6	575	575	CD
18637	24466	7	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
18637	24466	8	Sally	Sally	NNP
18637	24466	9	,	,	,
18637	24466	10	The	the	DT
18637	24466	11	,	,	,
18637	24466	12	2	2	CD
18637	24466	13	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24466	14	.	.	.
18637	24467	1	406	406	CD
18637	24467	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24467	3	1805	1805	CD
18637	24467	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24467	5	,	,	,
18637	24467	6	575	575	CD
18637	24467	7	Schulte	Schulte	NNP
18637	24467	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24467	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	11	Gangi	Gangi	NNP
18637	24467	12	,	,	,
18637	24467	13	328	328	CD
18637	24467	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24467	15	108	108	CD
18637	24467	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24467	17	1946	1946	CD
18637	24467	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24467	19	,	,	,
18637	24467	20	158	158	CD
18637	24467	21	Schuylkill	Schuylkill	NNP
18637	24467	22	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24467	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24467	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24467	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	27	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24467	28	,	,	,
18637	24467	29	302	302	CD
18637	24467	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24467	31	506	506	CD
18637	24467	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24467	33	1938	1938	CD
18637	24467	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24467	35	,	,	,
18637	24467	36	571	571	CD
18637	24467	37	,	,	,
18637	24467	38	1044	1044	CD
18637	24467	39	Schwab	Schwab	NNP
18637	24467	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24467	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	43	Berggren	Berggren	NNP
18637	24467	44	,	,	,
18637	24467	45	143	143	CD
18637	24467	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24467	47	442	442	CD
18637	24467	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24467	49	1892	1892	CD
18637	24467	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24467	51	,	,	,
18637	24467	52	1127	1127	CD
18637	24467	53	Schwab	Schwab	NNP
18637	24467	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	24467	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	57	Richardson	Richardson	NNP
18637	24467	58	,	,	,
18637	24467	59	263	263	CD
18637	24467	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24467	61	88	88	CD
18637	24467	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24467	63	1923	1923	CD
18637	24467	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24467	65	,	,	,
18637	24467	66	1051	1051	CD
18637	24467	67	Schwabacher	Schwabacher	NNP
18637	24467	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	24467	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	71	United	United	NNP
18637	24467	72	States	States	NNP
18637	24467	73	,	,	,
18637	24467	74	334	334	CD
18637	24467	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24467	76	182	182	CD
18637	24467	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24467	78	1948	1948	CD
18637	24467	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24467	80	,	,	,
18637	24467	81	251	251	CD
18637	24467	82	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	24467	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	24467	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	86	Donald	Donald	NNP
18637	24467	87	,	,	,
18637	24467	88	165	165	CD
18637	24467	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24467	90	58	58	CD
18637	24467	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24467	92	1897	1897	CD
18637	24467	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24467	94	,	,	,
18637	24467	95	931	931	CD
18637	24467	96	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	24467	97	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	98	v.	v.	IN
18637	24467	99	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	100	Donald	Donald	NNP
18637	24467	101	,	,	,
18637	24467	102	165	165	CD
18637	24467	103	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24467	104	107	107	CD
18637	24467	105	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24467	106	1897	1897	CD
18637	24467	107	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24467	108	,	,	,
18637	24467	109	931	931	CD
18637	24467	110	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	24467	111	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	112	v.	v.	IN
18637	24467	113	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	114	McNeal	McNeal	NNP
18637	24467	115	,	,	,
18637	24467	116	154	154	CD
18637	24467	117	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24467	118	34	34	CD
18637	24467	119	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24467	120	1894	1894	CD
18637	24467	121	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24467	122	,	,	,
18637	24467	123	330	330	CD
18637	24467	124	,	,	,
18637	24467	125	1072	1072	CD
18637	24467	126	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	24467	127	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	128	v.	v.	IN
18637	24467	129	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	130	Neely	neely	RB
18637	24467	131	,	,	,
18637	24467	132	140	140	CD
18637	24467	133	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24467	134	106	106	CD
18637	24467	135	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24467	136	1891	1891	CD
18637	24467	137	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24467	138	,	,	,
18637	24467	139	895	895	CD
18637	24467	140	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	24467	141	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	142	v.	v.	IN
18637	24467	143	_	_	NNP
18637	24467	144	Sandford	Sandford	NNP
18637	24467	145	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24467	146	Dred	Dred	NNP
18637	24467	147	Scott	Scott	NNP
18637	24467	148	Case	Case	NNP
18637	24467	149	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24467	150	,	,	,
18637	24467	151	19	19	CD
18637	24467	152	How	how	WRB
18637	24467	153	.	.	.
18637	24468	1	393	393	CD
18637	24468	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24468	3	1857	1857	CD
18637	24468	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24468	5	,	,	,
18637	24468	6	60	60	CD
18637	24468	7	,	,	,
18637	24468	8	61	61	CD
18637	24468	9	,	,	,
18637	24468	10	254	254	CD
18637	24468	11	,	,	,
18637	24468	12	312	312	CD
18637	24468	13	,	,	,
18637	24468	14	687	687	CD
18637	24468	15	,	,	,
18637	24468	16	688	688	CD
18637	24468	17	,	,	,
18637	24468	18	845	845	CD
18637	24468	19	,	,	,
18637	24468	20	846	846	CD
18637	24468	21	,	,	,
18637	24468	22	963	963	CD
18637	24468	23	,	,	,
18637	24468	24	964	964	CD
18637	24468	25	,	,	,
18637	24468	26	972	972	CD
18637	24468	27	Scottish	Scottish	NNP
18637	24468	28	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24468	29	&	&	CC
18637	24468	30	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	24468	31	.	.	.
18637	24469	1	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24469	2	.	.	.
18637	24470	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24470	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24470	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	5	Bowland	Bowland	NNP
18637	24470	6	,	,	,
18637	24470	7	196	196	CD
18637	24470	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24470	9	611	611	CD
18637	24470	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24470	11	1905	1905	CD
18637	24470	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24470	13	,	,	,
18637	24470	14	1062	1062	CD
18637	24470	15	Scranton	Scranton	NNP
18637	24470	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24470	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	19	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	24470	20	,	,	,
18637	24470	21	179	179	CD
18637	24470	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24470	23	141	141	CD
18637	24470	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24470	25	1900	1900	CD
18637	24470	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24470	27	,	,	,
18637	24470	28	588	588	CD
18637	24470	29	Screws	Screws	NNPS
18637	24470	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24470	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	33	United	United	NNP
18637	24470	34	States	States	NNP
18637	24470	35	,	,	,
18637	24470	36	325	325	CD
18637	24470	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24470	38	91	91	CD
18637	24470	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24470	40	1945	1945	CD
18637	24470	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24470	42	,	,	,
18637	24470	43	882	882	CD
18637	24470	44	,	,	,
18637	24470	45	1176	1176	CD
18637	24470	46	Scully	scully	RB
18637	24470	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	24470	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	50	Bird	Bird	NNP
18637	24470	51	,	,	,
18637	24470	52	209	209	CD
18637	24470	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24470	54	481	481	CD
18637	24470	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24470	56	1908	1908	CD
18637	24470	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24470	58	,	,	,
18637	24470	59	931	931	CD
18637	24470	60	Seaboard	Seaboard	NNP
18637	24470	61	Air	Air	NNP
18637	24470	62	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24470	63	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24470	64	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24470	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	24470	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	68	Blackwell	Blackwell	NNP
18637	24470	69	,	,	,
18637	24470	70	244	244	CD
18637	24470	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24470	72	310	310	CD
18637	24470	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24470	74	1917	1917	CD
18637	24470	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24470	76	,	,	,
18637	24470	77	223	223	CD
18637	24470	78	Seaboard	Seaboard	NNP
18637	24470	79	Air	Air	NNP
18637	24470	80	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24470	81	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24470	82	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24470	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	24470	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	86	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
18637	24470	87	,	,	,
18637	24470	88	333	333	CD
18637	24470	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24470	90	118	118	CD
18637	24470	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24470	92	1948	1948	CD
18637	24470	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24470	94	,	,	,
18637	24470	95	251	251	CD
18637	24470	96	Seaboard	Seaboard	NNP
18637	24470	97	Air	Air	NNP
18637	24470	98	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24470	99	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24470	100	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24470	101	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	102	v.	v.	IN
18637	24470	103	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	104	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24470	105	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24470	106	,	,	,
18637	24470	107	240	240	CD
18637	24470	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24470	109	324	324	CD
18637	24470	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24470	111	1916	1916	CD
18637	24470	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24470	113	,	,	,
18637	24470	114	1013	1013	CD
18637	24470	115	Seaboard	Seaboard	NNP
18637	24470	116	Air	Air	NNP
18637	24470	117	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24470	118	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24470	119	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24470	120	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	121	v.	v.	IN
18637	24470	122	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	123	United	United	NNP
18637	24470	124	States	States	NNP
18637	24470	125	,	,	,
18637	24470	126	254	254	CD
18637	24470	127	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24470	128	57	57	CD
18637	24470	129	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24470	130	1920	1920	CD
18637	24470	131	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24470	132	,	,	,
18637	24470	133	861	861	CD
18637	24470	134	Seaboard	Seaboard	NNP
18637	24470	135	Air	Air	NNP
18637	24470	136	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24470	137	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24470	138	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24470	139	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	140	v.	v.	IN
18637	24470	141	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	142	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	24470	143	,	,	,
18637	24470	144	287	287	CD
18637	24470	145	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24470	146	86	86	CD
18637	24470	147	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24470	148	1932	1932	CD
18637	24470	149	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24470	150	,	,	,
18637	24470	151	1156	1156	CD
18637	24470	152	Searight	Searight	NNP
18637	24470	153	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	154	v.	v.	IN
18637	24470	155	_	_	NNP
18637	24470	156	Stokes	Stokes	NNP
18637	24470	157	,	,	,
18637	24470	158	3	3	CD
18637	24470	159	How	how	WRB
18637	24470	160	.	.	.
18637	24471	1	151	151	CD
18637	24471	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24471	3	1845	1845	CD
18637	24471	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24471	5	,	,	,
18637	24471	6	268	268	CD
18637	24471	7	Seattle	Seattle	NNP
18637	24471	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24471	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24471	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24471	11	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24471	12	&	&	CC
18637	24471	13	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	24471	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24471	15	,	,	,
18637	24471	16	255	255	CD
18637	24471	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24471	18	56	56	CD
18637	24471	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24471	20	1921	1921	CD
18637	24471	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24471	22	,	,	,
18637	24471	23	128	128	CD
18637	24471	24	Secombe	Secombe	NNP
18637	24471	25	,	,	,
18637	24471	26	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24471	27	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24471	28	,	,	,
18637	24471	29	19	19	CD
18637	24471	30	How	how	WRB
18637	24471	31	.	.	.
18637	24472	1	9	9	CD
18637	24472	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24472	3	1857	1857	CD
18637	24472	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24472	5	,	,	,
18637	24472	6	528	528	CD
18637	24472	7	Second	Second	NNP
18637	24472	8	Employers	Employers	NNPS
18637	24472	9	'	'	POS
18637	24472	10	Liability	liability	NN
18637	24472	11	Cases	case	NNS
18637	24472	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24472	13	Mondou	Mondou	NNP
18637	24472	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24472	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24472	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24472	17	New	New	NNP
18637	24472	18	York	York	NNP
18637	24472	19	,	,	,
18637	24472	20	N.H.	New Hampshire	NNP
18637	24472	21	&	&	CC
18637	24472	22	H.R.	H.R.	NNP
18637	24473	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24473	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24473	3	,	,	,
18637	24473	4	223	223	CD
18637	24473	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24473	6	1	1	CD
18637	24473	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24473	8	1912	1912	CD
18637	24473	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24473	10	,	,	,
18637	24473	11	125	125	CD
18637	24473	12	,	,	,
18637	24473	13	739	739	CD
18637	24473	14	Second	Second	NNP
18637	24473	15	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24473	16	Case	Case	NNP
18637	24473	17	,	,	,
18637	24473	18	325	325	CD
18637	24473	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24473	20	279	279	CD
18637	24473	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24473	22	1945	1945	CD
18637	24473	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24473	24	,	,	,
18637	24473	25	663	663	CD
18637	24473	26	,	,	,
18637	24473	27	665	665	CD
18637	24473	28	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	24473	29	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	24473	30	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24473	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24473	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24473	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24473	34	Chenery	Chenery	NNP
18637	24473	35	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24473	36	,	,	,
18637	24473	37	332	332	CD
18637	24473	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24473	39	194	194	CD
18637	24473	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24473	41	1947	1947	CD
18637	24473	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24473	43	,	,	,
18637	24473	44	856	856	CD
18637	24473	45	Security	Security	NNP
18637	24473	46	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	24473	47	.	.	.
18637	24474	1	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24474	2	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24474	3	.	.	.
18637	24475	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24475	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24475	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24475	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24475	5	Prewitt	Prewitt	NNP
18637	24475	6	,	,	,
18637	24475	7	202	202	CD
18637	24475	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24475	9	246	246	CD
18637	24475	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24475	11	1906	1906	CD
18637	24475	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24475	13	,	,	,
18637	24475	14	198	198	CD
18637	24475	15	,	,	,
18637	24475	16	638	638	CD
18637	24475	17	Security	Security	NNP
18637	24475	18	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	24475	19	.	.	.
18637	24476	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24476	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24476	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	5	California	California	NNP
18637	24476	6	,	,	,
18637	24476	7	263	263	CD
18637	24476	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24476	9	282	282	CD
18637	24476	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24476	11	1923	1923	CD
18637	24476	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24476	13	,	,	,
18637	24476	14	355	355	CD
18637	24476	15	Sei	Sei	NNP
18637	24476	16	Fujii	Fujii	NNP
18637	24476	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24476	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	20	State	State	NNP
18637	24476	21	of	of	IN
18637	24476	22	California	California	NNP
18637	24476	23	,	,	,
18637	24476	24	242	242	CD
18637	24476	25	P.	p.	NN
18637	24476	26	2d	2d	NNP
18637	24476	27	617	617	CD
18637	24476	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24476	29	1952	1952	CD
18637	24476	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24476	31	,	,	,
18637	24476	32	417	417	CD
18637	24476	33	Selective	Selective	NNP
18637	24476	34	Draft	Draft	NNP
18637	24476	35	Law	Law	NNP
18637	24476	36	Cases	case	NNS
18637	24476	37	,	,	,
18637	24476	38	245	245	CD
18637	24476	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24476	40	366	366	CD
18637	24476	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24476	42	1918	1918	CD
18637	24476	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24476	44	,	,	,
18637	24476	45	285	285	CD
18637	24476	46	Selig	Selig	NNP
18637	24476	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	24476	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	50	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	24476	51	,	,	,
18637	24476	52	234	234	CD
18637	24476	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24476	54	652	652	CD
18637	24476	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24476	56	1914	1914	CD
18637	24476	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24476	58	,	,	,
18637	24476	59	355	355	CD
18637	24476	60	,	,	,
18637	24476	61	678	678	CD
18637	24476	62	Selliger	Selliger	NNP
18637	24476	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	24476	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	66	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	24476	67	,	,	,
18637	24476	68	213	213	CD
18637	24476	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24476	70	200	200	CD
18637	24476	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24476	72	1909	1909	CD
18637	24476	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24476	74	,	,	,
18637	24476	75	364	364	CD
18637	24476	76	Selover	Selover	NNP
18637	24476	77	,	,	,
18637	24476	78	Bates	Bates	NNP
18637	24476	79	&	&	CC
18637	24476	80	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24476	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	24476	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	84	Walsh	Walsh	NNP
18637	24476	85	,	,	,
18637	24476	86	226	226	CD
18637	24476	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24476	88	112	112	CD
18637	24476	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24476	90	1912	1912	CD
18637	24476	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24476	92	,	,	,
18637	24476	93	965	965	CD
18637	24476	94	Semler	Semler	NNP
18637	24476	95	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	24476	97	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	98	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24476	99	State	State	NNP
18637	24476	100	Dental	Dental	NNP
18637	24476	101	Examiners	Examiners	NNPS
18637	24476	102	,	,	,
18637	24476	103	294	294	CD
18637	24476	104	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24476	105	608	608	CD
18637	24476	106	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24476	107	1935	1935	CD
18637	24476	108	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24476	109	,	,	,
18637	24476	110	1024	1024	CD
18637	24476	111	,	,	,
18637	24476	112	1155	1155	CD
18637	24476	113	Senior	Senior	NNP
18637	24476	114	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	115	v.	v.	IN
18637	24476	116	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	117	Braden	Braden	NNP
18637	24476	118	,	,	,
18637	24476	119	295	295	CD
18637	24476	120	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24476	121	422	422	CD
18637	24476	122	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24476	123	1935	1935	CD
18637	24476	124	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24476	125	,	,	,
18637	24476	126	1045	1045	CD
18637	24476	127	Senn	Senn	NNP
18637	24476	128	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	129	v.	v.	IN
18637	24476	130	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	131	Tile	Tile	NNP
18637	24476	132	Layers	Layers	NNP
18637	24476	133	Protective	Protective	NNP
18637	24476	134	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24476	135	,	,	,
18637	24476	136	301	301	CD
18637	24476	137	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24476	138	468	468	CD
18637	24476	139	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24476	140	1937	1937	CD
18637	24476	141	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24476	142	,	,	,
18637	24476	143	991	991	CD
18637	24476	144	,	,	,
18637	24476	145	992	992	CD
18637	24476	146	Sentell	Sentell	NNP
18637	24476	147	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	148	v.	v.	IN
18637	24476	149	_	_	NNP
18637	24476	150	New	New	NNP
18637	24476	151	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
18637	24476	152	&	&	CC
18637	24476	153	C.R.	C.R.	NNP
18637	24477	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24477	2	,	,	,
18637	24477	3	166	166	CD
18637	24477	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24477	5	698	698	CD
18637	24477	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24477	7	1897	1897	CD
18637	24477	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24477	9	,	,	,
18637	24477	10	1035	1035	CD
18637	24477	11	Serè	Serè	NNP
18637	24477	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24477	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24477	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24477	15	Pitot	Pitot	NNP
18637	24477	16	,	,	,
18637	24477	17	6	6	CD
18637	24477	18	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24477	19	.	.	.
18637	24478	1	332	332	CD
18637	24478	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24478	3	1810	1810	CD
18637	24478	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24478	5	,	,	,
18637	24478	6	302	302	CD
18637	24478	7	,	,	,
18637	24478	8	703	703	CD
18637	24478	9	Seton	Seton	NNP
18637	24478	10	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	24478	11	College	College	NNP
18637	24478	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24478	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24478	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24478	15	South	South	NNP
18637	24478	16	Orange	Orange	NNP
18637	24478	17	,	,	,
18637	24478	18	242	242	CD
18637	24478	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24478	20	100	100	CD
18637	24478	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24478	22	1916	1916	CD
18637	24478	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24478	24	,	,	,
18637	24478	25	343	343	CD
18637	24478	26	Seufert	Seufert	NNP
18637	24478	27	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	24478	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24478	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24478	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24478	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24478	32	United	United	NNP
18637	24478	33	States	States	NNP
18637	24478	34	,	,	,
18637	24478	35	249	249	CD
18637	24478	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24478	37	194	194	CD
18637	24478	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24478	39	1919	1919	CD
18637	24478	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24478	41	,	,	,
18637	24478	42	700	700	CD
18637	24478	43	Sewing	Sewing	NNP
18637	24478	44	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	24478	45	Companies	company	NNS
18637	24478	46	,	,	,
18637	24478	47	18	18	CD
18637	24478	48	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24478	49	.	.	.
18637	24479	1	553	553	CD
18637	24479	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24479	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	24479	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24479	5	,	,	,
18637	24479	6	619	619	CD
18637	24479	7	Seymour	Seymour	NNP
18637	24479	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24479	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24479	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24479	11	Osborne	Osborne	NNP
18637	24479	12	,	,	,
18637	24479	13	11	11	CD
18637	24479	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24479	15	.	.	.
18637	24480	1	516	516	CD
18637	24480	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24480	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24480	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24480	5	,	,	,
18637	24480	6	272	272	CD
18637	24480	7	Shaffer	Shaffer	NNP
18637	24480	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24480	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24480	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24480	11	Carter	Carter	NNP
18637	24480	12	,	,	,
18637	24480	13	252	252	CD
18637	24480	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24480	15	37	37	CD
18637	24480	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24480	17	1920	1920	CD
18637	24480	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24480	19	,	,	,
18637	24480	20	209	209	CD
18637	24480	21	,	,	,
18637	24480	22	693	693	CD
18637	24480	23	,	,	,
18637	24480	24	1054	1054	CD
18637	24480	25	,	,	,
18637	24480	26	1150	1150	CD
18637	24480	27	Shallenberger	Shallenberger	NNP
18637	24480	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24480	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24480	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24480	31	First	First	NNP
18637	24480	32	State	State	NNP
18637	24480	33	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24480	34	,	,	,
18637	24480	35	219	219	CD
18637	24480	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24480	37	114	114	CD
18637	24480	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24480	39	1911	1911	CD
18637	24480	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24480	41	,	,	,
18637	24480	42	1020	1020	CD
18637	24480	43	Shanks	Shanks	NNP
18637	24480	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24480	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24480	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24480	47	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	24480	48	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24480	49	&	&	CC
18637	24480	50	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	24480	51	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24480	52	,	,	,
18637	24480	53	239	239	CD
18637	24480	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24480	55	556	556	CD
18637	24480	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24480	57	1916	1916	CD
18637	24480	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24480	59	,	,	,
18637	24480	60	141	141	CD
18637	24480	61	Shanks	Shanks	NNP
18637	24480	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24480	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	24480	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24480	65	Dupont	Dupont	NNP
18637	24480	66	,	,	,
18637	24480	67	3	3	CD
18637	24480	68	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	24480	69	.	.	.
18637	24481	1	242	242	CD
18637	24481	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24481	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	24481	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24481	5	,	,	,
18637	24481	6	258	258	CD
18637	24481	7	Shapiro	Shapiro	NNP
18637	24481	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24481	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24481	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24481	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24481	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24481	13	,	,	,
18637	24481	14	335	335	CD
18637	24481	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24481	16	1	1	CD
18637	24481	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24481	18	1948	1948	CD
18637	24481	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24481	20	,	,	,
18637	24481	21	827	827	CD
18637	24481	22	,	,	,
18637	24481	23	828	828	CD
18637	24481	24	,	,	,
18637	24481	25	844	844	CD
18637	24481	26	Sharp	Sharp	NNP
18637	24481	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24481	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24481	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24481	30	United	United	NNP
18637	24481	31	States	States	NNP
18637	24481	32	,	,	,
18637	24481	33	191	191	CD
18637	24481	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24481	35	341	341	CD
18637	24481	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24481	37	1903	1903	CD
18637	24481	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24481	39	,	,	,
18637	24481	40	870	870	CD
18637	24481	41	Shaw	Shaw	NNP
18637	24481	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24481	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24481	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24481	45	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
18637	24481	46	-	-	HYPH
18637	24481	47	Zahniser	Zahniser	NNP
18637	24481	48	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24481	49	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24481	50	,	,	,
18637	24481	51	276	276	CD
18637	24481	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24481	53	575	575	CD
18637	24481	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24481	55	1928	1928	CD
18637	24481	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24481	57	,	,	,
18637	24481	58	735	735	CD
18637	24481	59	Sheehan	Sheehan	NNP
18637	24481	60	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24481	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24481	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	24481	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24481	64	Shuler	Shuler	NNP
18637	24481	65	,	,	,
18637	24481	66	265	265	CD
18637	24481	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24481	68	371	371	CD
18637	24481	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24481	70	1924	1924	CD
18637	24481	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24481	72	,	,	,
18637	24481	73	990	990	CD
18637	24481	74	Sheldon	Sheldon	NNP
18637	24481	75	_	_	NNP
18637	24481	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	24481	77	_	_	NNP
18637	24481	78	Sill	Sill	NNP
18637	24481	79	,	,	,
18637	24481	80	8	8	CD
18637	24481	81	How	how	WRB
18637	24481	82	.	.	.
18637	24482	1	441	441	CD
18637	24482	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24482	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	24482	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24482	5	,	,	,
18637	24482	6	512	512	CD
18637	24482	7	,	,	,
18637	24482	8	619	619	CD
18637	24482	9	,	,	,
18637	24482	10	620	620	CD
18637	24482	11	Shelley	Shelley	NNP
18637	24482	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24482	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24482	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24482	15	Kraemer	Kraemer	NNP
18637	24482	16	,	,	,
18637	24482	17	334	334	CD
18637	24482	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24482	19	1	1	CD
18637	24482	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24482	21	1948	1948	CD
18637	24482	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24482	23	,	,	,
18637	24482	24	1142	1142	CD
18637	24482	25	,	,	,
18637	24482	26	1161	1161	CD
18637	24482	27	Shelton	Shelton	NNP
18637	24482	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24482	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24482	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24482	31	Platt	Platt	NNP
18637	24482	32	,	,	,
18637	24482	33	139	139	CD
18637	24482	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24482	35	591	591	CD
18637	24482	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24482	37	1891	1891	CD
18637	24482	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24482	39	,	,	,
18637	24482	40	621	621	CD
18637	24482	41	Shelton	Shelton	NNP
18637	24482	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24482	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24482	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24482	45	Tiffin	Tiffin	NNP
18637	24482	46	,	,	,
18637	24482	47	6	6	CD
18637	24482	48	How	how	WRB
18637	24482	49	.	.	.
18637	24483	1	163	163	CD
18637	24483	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24483	3	1848	1848	CD
18637	24483	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24483	5	,	,	,
18637	24483	6	601	601	CD
18637	24483	7	Shenfield	Shenfield	NNP
18637	24483	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24483	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24483	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24483	11	Nashawannuck	Nashawannuck	NNP
18637	24483	12	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	24483	13	.	.	.
18637	24484	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24484	2	,	,	,
18637	24484	3	137	137	CD
18637	24484	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24484	5	56	56	CD
18637	24484	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24484	7	1890	1890	CD
18637	24484	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24484	9	,	,	,
18637	24484	10	273	273	CD
18637	24484	11	Shepherd	Shepherd	NNP
18637	24484	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24484	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24484	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24484	15	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	24484	16	,	,	,
18637	24484	17	341	341	CD
18637	24484	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24484	19	50	50	CD
18637	24484	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24484	21	1951	1951	CD
18637	24484	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24484	23	,	,	,
18637	24484	24	1098	1098	CD
18637	24484	25	,	,	,
18637	24484	26	1168	1168	CD
18637	24484	27	Sheppard	Sheppard	NNP
18637	24484	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24484	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24484	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24484	31	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24484	32	,	,	,
18637	24484	33	5	5	CD
18637	24484	34	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24484	35	.	.	.
18637	24485	1	675	675	CD
18637	24485	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24485	3	1831	1831	CD
18637	24485	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24485	5	,	,	,
18637	24485	6	574	574	CD
18637	24485	7	Sherlock	Sherlock	NNP
18637	24485	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24485	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24485	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24485	11	Alling	Alling	NNP
18637	24485	12	,	,	,
18637	24485	13	93	93	CD
18637	24485	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24485	15	99	99	CD
18637	24485	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24485	17	1876	1876	CD
18637	24485	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24485	19	,	,	,
18637	24485	20	575	575	CD
18637	24485	21	Sherrer	Sherrer	NNP
18637	24485	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24485	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24485	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24485	25	Sherrer	Sherrer	NNP
18637	24485	26	,	,	,
18637	24485	27	334	334	CD
18637	24485	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24485	29	343	343	CD
18637	24485	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24485	31	1948	1948	CD
18637	24485	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24485	33	,	,	,
18637	24485	34	668	668	CD
18637	24485	35	,	,	,
18637	24485	36	669	669	CD
18637	24485	37	Shields	Shields	NNPS
18637	24485	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24485	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24485	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24485	41	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	24485	42	,	,	,
18637	24485	43	157	157	CD
18637	24485	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24485	45	168	168	CD
18637	24485	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24485	47	1895	1895	CD
18637	24485	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24485	49	,	,	,
18637	24485	50	627	627	CD
18637	24485	51	Shields	Shields	NNP
18637	24485	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24485	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	24485	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24485	55	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24485	56	,	,	,
18637	24485	57	95	95	CD
18637	24485	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24485	59	319	319	CD
18637	24485	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24485	61	1877	1877	CD
18637	24485	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24485	63	,	,	,
18637	24485	64	344	344	CD
18637	24485	65	Shields	Shields	NNPS
18637	24485	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24485	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	24485	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24485	69	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	24485	70	,	,	,
18637	24485	71	18	18	CD
18637	24485	72	How	how	WRB
18637	24485	73	.	.	.
18637	24486	1	253	253	CD
18637	24486	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24486	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	24486	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24486	5	,	,	,
18637	24486	6	893	893	CD
18637	24486	7	Shields	Shields	NNPS
18637	24486	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24486	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24486	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24486	11	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	24486	12	,	,	,
18637	24486	13	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
18637	24486	14	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24486	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24486	16	,	,	,
18637	24486	17	305	305	CD
18637	24486	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24486	19	185	185	CD
18637	24486	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24486	21	1938	1938	CD
18637	24486	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24486	23	,	,	,
18637	24486	24	623	623	CD
18637	24486	25	Shively	shively	RB
18637	24486	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24486	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24486	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24486	29	Bowlby	Bowlby	NNP
18637	24486	30	,	,	,
18637	24486	31	152	152	CD
18637	24486	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24486	33	1	1	CD
18637	24486	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24486	35	1894	1894	CD
18637	24486	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24486	37	,	,	,
18637	24486	38	130	130	CD
18637	24486	39	,	,	,
18637	24486	40	700	700	CD
18637	24486	41	Shoemaker	Shoemaker	NNP
18637	24486	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24486	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24486	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24486	45	United	United	NNP
18637	24486	46	States	States	NNP
18637	24486	47	,	,	,
18637	24486	48	147	147	CD
18637	24486	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24486	50	282	282	CD
18637	24486	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24486	52	1893	1893	CD
18637	24486	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24486	54	,	,	,
18637	24486	55	301	301	CD
18637	24486	56	,	,	,
18637	24486	57	303	303	CD
18637	24486	58	,	,	,
18637	24486	59	452	452	CD
18637	24486	60	,	,	,
18637	24486	61	866	866	CD
18637	24486	62	,	,	,
18637	24486	63	872	872	CD
18637	24486	64	Shoener	Shoener	NNP
18637	24486	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24486	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	24486	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24486	68	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24486	69	,	,	,
18637	24486	70	207	207	CD
18637	24486	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24486	72	188	188	CD
18637	24486	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24486	74	1907	1907	CD
18637	24486	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24486	76	,	,	,
18637	24486	77	1133	1133	CD
18637	24486	78	Shreveport	Shreveport	NNP
18637	24486	79	Case	Case	NNP
18637	24486	80	,	,	,
18637	24486	81	The	the	DT
18637	24486	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24486	83	Houston	Houston	NNP
18637	24486	84	E.	E.	NNP
18637	24486	85	&	&	CC
18637	24486	86	W.T.R.	W.T.R.	NNP
18637	24487	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24487	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24487	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24487	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24487	5	United	United	NNP
18637	24487	6	States	States	NNP
18637	24487	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24487	8	,	,	,
18637	24487	9	234	234	CD
18637	24487	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24487	11	342	342	CD
18637	24487	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24487	13	1914	1914	CD
18637	24487	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24487	15	,	,	,
18637	24487	16	135	135	CD
18637	24487	17	,	,	,
18637	24487	18	219	219	CD
18637	24487	19	Shriver	Shriver	NNP
18637	24487	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24487	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24487	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24487	23	Woodbine	Woodbine	NNP
18637	24487	24	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	24487	25	.	.	.
18637	24488	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24488	2	,	,	,
18637	24488	3	285	285	CD
18637	24488	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24488	5	467	467	CD
18637	24488	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24488	7	1932	1932	CD
18637	24488	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24488	9	,	,	,
18637	24488	10	1035	1035	CD
18637	24488	11	Shurtleff	Shurtleff	NNP
18637	24488	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24488	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24488	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24488	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24488	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24488	17	,	,	,
18637	24488	18	189	189	CD
18637	24488	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24488	20	311	311	CD
18637	24488	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24488	22	1903	1903	CD
18637	24488	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24488	24	,	,	,
18637	24488	25	460	460	CD
18637	24488	26	Siebold	siebold	JJ
18637	24488	27	,	,	,
18637	24488	28	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24488	29	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24488	30	,	,	,
18637	24488	31	100	100	CD
18637	24488	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24488	33	371	371	CD
18637	24488	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24488	35	1880	1880	CD
18637	24488	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24488	37	,	,	,
18637	24488	38	93	93	CD
18637	24488	39	,	,	,
18637	24488	40	94	94	CD
18637	24488	41	,	,	,
18637	24488	42	452	452	CD
18637	24488	43	,	,	,
18637	24488	44	495	495	CD
18637	24488	45	,	,	,
18637	24488	46	722	722	CD
18637	24488	47	,	,	,
18637	24488	48	738	738	CD
18637	24488	49	Silas	Silas	NNP
18637	24488	50	Mason	Mason	NNP
18637	24488	51	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24488	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24488	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	24488	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24488	55	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24488	56	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24488	57	of	of	IN
18637	24488	58	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24488	59	,	,	,
18637	24488	60	302	302	CD
18637	24488	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24488	62	186	186	CD
18637	24488	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24488	64	1937	1937	CD
18637	24488	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24488	66	,	,	,
18637	24488	67	307	307	CD
18637	24488	68	Siler	Siler	NNP
18637	24488	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24488	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	24488	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24488	72	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24488	73	&	&	CC
18637	24488	74	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	24489	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24489	2	,	,	,
18637	24489	3	213	213	CD
18637	24489	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24489	5	175	175	CD
18637	24489	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	7	1909	1909	CD
18637	24489	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24489	9	,	,	,
18637	24489	10	562	562	CD
18637	24489	11	Silesian	Silesian	NNP
18637	24489	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	24489	13	American	American	NNP
18637	24489	14	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24489	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24489	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	18	Clark	Clark	NNP
18637	24489	19	,	,	,
18637	24489	20	332	332	CD
18637	24489	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24489	22	469	469	CD
18637	24489	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	24	1947	1947	CD
18637	24489	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24489	26	,	,	,
18637	24489	27	295	295	CD
18637	24489	28	,	,	,
18637	24489	29	865	865	CD
18637	24489	30	Silver	Silver	NNP
18637	24489	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24489	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	34	Silver	Silver	NNP
18637	24489	35	,	,	,
18637	24489	36	280	280	CD
18637	24489	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24489	38	117	117	CD
18637	24489	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	40	1929	1929	CD
18637	24489	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24489	42	,	,	,
18637	24489	43	,	,	,
18637	24489	44	1155	1155	CD
18637	24489	45	Silver	Silver	NNP
18637	24489	46	Thorne	Thorne	NNP
18637	24489	47	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	24489	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24489	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	24489	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	52	United	United	NNP
18637	24489	53	States	States	NNP
18637	24489	54	,	,	,
18637	24489	55	251	251	CD
18637	24489	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24489	57	385	385	CD
18637	24489	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	59	1920	1920	CD
18637	24489	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24489	61	,	,	,
18637	24489	62	831	831	CD
18637	24489	63	Silz	Silz	NNP
18637	24489	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	24489	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	67	Hesterberg	Hesterberg	NNP
18637	24489	68	,	,	,
18637	24489	69	211	211	CD
18637	24489	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24489	71	31	31	CD
18637	24489	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	73	1908	1908	CD
18637	24489	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24489	75	,	,	,
18637	24489	76	217	217	CD
18637	24489	77	,	,	,
18637	24489	78	246	246	CD
18637	24489	79	,	,	,
18637	24489	80	1027	1027	CD
18637	24489	81	Simmons	Simmons	NNPS
18637	24489	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	24489	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	85	Saul	Saul	NNP
18637	24489	86	,	,	,
18637	24489	87	138	138	CD
18637	24489	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24489	89	439	439	CD
18637	24489	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	91	1891	1891	CD
18637	24489	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24489	93	,	,	,
18637	24489	94	660	660	CD
18637	24489	95	,	,	,
18637	24489	96	674	674	CD
18637	24489	97	Simmons	Simmons	NNPS
18637	24489	98	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	99	v.	v.	IN
18637	24489	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	101	United	United	NNP
18637	24489	102	States	States	NNP
18637	24489	103	,	,	,
18637	24489	104	142	142	CD
18637	24489	105	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24489	106	148	148	CD
18637	24489	107	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	108	1891	1891	CD
18637	24489	109	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24489	110	,	,	,
18637	24489	111	839	839	CD
18637	24489	112	Simms	Simms	NNP
18637	24489	113	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	114	v.	v.	IN
18637	24489	115	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	116	Simms	Simms	NNP
18637	24489	117	,	,	,
18637	24489	118	175	175	CD
18637	24489	119	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24489	120	162	162	CD
18637	24489	121	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	122	1899	1899	CD
18637	24489	123	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24489	124	,	,	,
18637	24489	125	703	703	CD
18637	24489	126	Simon	Simon	NNP
18637	24489	127	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	128	v.	v.	IN
18637	24489	129	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	130	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24489	131	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24489	132	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24489	133	,	,	,
18637	24489	134	236	236	CD
18637	24489	135	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24489	136	115	115	CD
18637	24489	137	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	138	1915	1915	CD
18637	24489	139	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24489	140	,	,	,
18637	24489	141	629	629	CD
18637	24489	142	,	,	,
18637	24489	143	660	660	CD
18637	24489	144	,	,	,
18637	24489	145	1073	1073	CD
18637	24489	146	,	,	,
18637	24489	147	1076	1076	CD
18637	24489	148	Simons	Simons	NNPS
18637	24489	149	,	,	,
18637	24489	150	In	in	IN
18637	24489	151	re	re	NN
18637	24489	152	,	,	,
18637	24489	153	247	247	CD
18637	24489	154	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24489	155	231	231	CD
18637	24489	156	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	157	1918	1918	CD
18637	24489	158	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24489	159	,	,	,
18637	24489	160	895	895	CD
18637	24489	161	Simpson	Simpson	NNP
18637	24489	162	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	163	v.	v.	IN
18637	24489	164	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	165	Shepard	Shepard	NNP
18637	24489	166	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	167	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24489	168	Rate	Rate	NNP
18637	24489	169	Cases	Cases	NNP
18637	24489	170	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24489	171	,	,	,
18637	24489	172	230	230	CD
18637	24489	173	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24489	174	352	352	CD
18637	24489	175	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	176	1913	1913	CD
18637	24489	177	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24489	178	,	,	,
18637	24489	179	177	177	CD
18637	24489	180	,	,	,
18637	24489	181	222	222	CD
18637	24489	182	,	,	,
18637	24489	183	235	235	CD
18637	24489	184	,	,	,
18637	24489	185	1000	1000	CD
18637	24489	186	,	,	,
18637	24489	187	1002	1002	CD
18637	24489	188	Sinclair	Sinclair	NNP
18637	24489	189	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	190	v.	v.	IN
18637	24489	191	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	192	United	United	NNP
18637	24489	193	States	States	NNP
18637	24489	194	,	,	,
18637	24489	195	279	279	CD
18637	24489	196	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24489	197	263	263	CD
18637	24489	198	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	199	1929	1929	CD
18637	24489	200	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24489	201	,	,	,
18637	24489	202	84	84	CD
18637	24489	203	,	,	,
18637	24489	204	85	85	CD
18637	24489	205	,	,	,
18637	24489	206	311	311	CD
18637	24489	207	,	,	,
18637	24489	208	493	493	CD
18637	24489	209	Sinclair	Sinclair	NNP
18637	24489	210	&	&	CC
18637	24489	211	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	24489	212	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24489	213	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	214	v.	v.	IN
18637	24489	215	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	216	Interchemical	Interchemical	NNP
18637	24489	217	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24489	218	,	,	,
18637	24489	219	325	325	CD
18637	24489	220	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24489	221	327	327	CD
18637	24489	222	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	223	1945	1945	CD
18637	24489	224	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24489	225	,	,	,
18637	24489	226	272	272	CD
18637	24489	227	Singer	Singer	NNP
18637	24489	228	Sewing	Sewing	NNP
18637	24489	229	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	24489	230	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24489	231	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	232	v.	v.	IN
18637	24489	233	_	_	NNP
18637	24489	234	Brickell	Brickell	NNP
18637	24489	235	,	,	,
18637	24489	236	233	233	CD
18637	24489	237	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24489	238	304	304	CD
18637	24489	239	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	240	1914	1914	CD
18637	24489	241	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24489	242	,	,	,
18637	24489	243	184	184	CD
18637	24489	244	Sinking	Sinking	NNP
18637	24489	245	Fund	Fund	NNP
18637	24489	246	Cases	case	NNS
18637	24489	247	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24489	248	Central	Central	NNP
18637	24489	249	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24490	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24490	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24490	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24490	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24490	5	Gallatin	Gallatin	NNP
18637	24490	6	&	&	CC
18637	24490	7	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24490	8	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24491	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24491	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24491	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24491	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24491	5	United	United	NNP
18637	24491	6	States	States	NNP
18637	24491	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24491	8	,	,	,
18637	24491	9	99	99	CD
18637	24491	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24491	11	700	700	CD
18637	24491	12	,	,	,
18637	24491	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24491	14	1879	1879	CD
18637	24491	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24491	16	,	,	,
18637	24491	17	362	362	CD
18637	24491	18	,	,	,
18637	24491	19	563	563	CD
18637	24491	20	,	,	,
18637	24491	21	981	981	CD
18637	24491	22	Sinnot	Sinnot	NNP
18637	24491	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24491	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24491	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24491	26	Davenport	Davenport	NNP
18637	24491	27	,	,	,
18637	24491	28	22	22	CD
18637	24491	29	How	how	WRB
18637	24491	30	.	.	.
18637	24492	1	227	227	CD
18637	24492	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24492	3	1859	1859	CD
18637	24492	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24492	5	,	,	,
18637	24492	6	229	229	CD
18637	24492	7	Sioux	Sioux	NNP
18637	24492	8	City	City	NNP
18637	24492	9	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	24492	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24492	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24492	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24492	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24492	14	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	24492	15	County	County	NNP
18637	24492	16	,	,	,
18637	24492	17	260	260	CD
18637	24492	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24492	19	441	441	CD
18637	24492	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24492	21	1923	1923	CD
18637	24492	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24492	23	,	,	,
18637	24492	24	1152	1152	CD
18637	24492	25	Sioux	Sioux	NNP
18637	24492	26	Remedy	Remedy	NNP
18637	24492	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24492	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24492	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24492	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24492	31	Cope	Cope	NNP
18637	24492	32	,	,	,
18637	24492	33	235	235	CD
18637	24492	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24492	35	197	197	CD
18637	24492	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24492	37	1914	1914	CD
18637	24492	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24492	39	,	,	,
18637	24492	40	234	234	CD
18637	24492	41	Sioux	Sioux	NNP
18637	24492	42	Tribe	Tribe	NNP
18637	24492	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24492	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24492	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24492	46	United	United	NNP
18637	24492	47	States	States	NNP
18637	24492	48	,	,	,
18637	24492	49	316	316	CD
18637	24492	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24492	51	317	317	CD
18637	24492	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24492	53	1942	1942	CD
18637	24492	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24492	55	,	,	,
18637	24492	56	702	702	CD
18637	24492	57	Sipuel	Sipuel	NNP
18637	24492	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24492	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24492	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24492	61	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24492	62	,	,	,
18637	24492	63	332	332	CD
18637	24492	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24492	65	631	631	CD
18637	24492	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24492	67	1948	1948	CD
18637	24492	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24492	69	,	,	,
18637	24492	70	1163	1163	CD
18637	24492	71	Siren	Siren	NNP
18637	24492	72	,	,	,
18637	24492	73	The	the	DT
18637	24492	74	,	,	,
18637	24492	75	7	7	CD
18637	24492	76	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24492	77	.	.	.
18637	24493	1	152	152	CD
18637	24493	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24493	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24493	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24493	5	,	,	,
18637	24493	6	586	586	CD
18637	24493	7	,	,	,
18637	24493	8	610	610	CD
18637	24493	9	Siren	Siren	NNP
18637	24493	10	,	,	,
18637	24493	11	The	the	DT
18637	24493	12	,	,	,
18637	24493	13	13	13	CD
18637	24493	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24493	15	.	.	.
18637	24494	1	389	389	CD
18637	24494	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24494	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24494	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24494	5	,	,	,
18637	24494	6	296	296	CD
18637	24494	7	,	,	,
18637	24494	8	575	575	CD
18637	24494	9	Sistare	Sistare	NNP
18637	24494	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24494	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24494	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24494	13	Sistare	Sistare	NNP
18637	24494	14	,	,	,
18637	24494	15	218	218	CD
18637	24494	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24494	17	1	1	CD
18637	24494	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24494	19	1910	1910	CD
18637	24494	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24494	21	,	,	,
18637	24494	22	655	655	CD
18637	24494	23	,	,	,
18637	24494	24	671	671	CD
18637	24494	25	Six	six	CD
18637	24494	26	Companies	company	NNS
18637	24494	27	of	of	IN
18637	24494	28	California	California	NNP
18637	24494	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24494	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24494	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24494	32	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	24494	33	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	24494	34	,	,	,
18637	24494	35	311	311	CD
18637	24494	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24494	37	180	180	CD
18637	24494	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24494	39	1940	1940	CD
18637	24494	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24494	41	,	,	,
18637	24494	42	608	608	CD
18637	24494	43	Six	six	CD
18637	24494	44	Hundred	Hundred	NNP
18637	24494	45	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	24494	46	Church	Church	NNP
18637	24494	47	Street	Street	NNP
18637	24494	48	Bldg	Bldg	NNP
18637	24494	49	.	.	.
18637	24495	1	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24495	2	,	,	,
18637	24495	3	In	in	IN
18637	24495	4	re	re	NN
18637	24495	5	,	,	,
18637	24495	6	299	299	CD
18637	24495	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24495	8	24	24	CD
18637	24495	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24495	10	1936	1936	CD
18637	24495	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24495	12	,	,	,
18637	24495	13	,	,	,
18637	24495	14	858	858	CD
18637	24495	15	Skaneateles	Skaneateles	NNP
18637	24495	16	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	24495	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24495	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24495	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24495	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24495	21	Skaneateles	Skaneateles	NNP
18637	24495	22	,	,	,
18637	24495	23	184	184	CD
18637	24495	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24495	25	354	354	CD
18637	24495	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24495	27	1902	1902	CD
18637	24495	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24495	29	,	,	,
18637	24495	30	349	349	CD
18637	24495	31	,	,	,
18637	24495	32	1009	1009	CD
18637	24495	33	Skinner	Skinner	NNP
18637	24495	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24495	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	24495	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24495	37	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24495	38	,	,	,
18637	24495	39	316	316	CD
18637	24495	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24495	41	535	535	CD
18637	24495	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24495	43	1942	1942	CD
18637	24495	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24495	45	,	,	,
18637	24495	46	1156	1156	CD
18637	24495	47	,	,	,
18637	24495	48	1161	1161	CD
18637	24495	49	Skinner	Skinner	NNP
18637	24495	50	&	&	CC
18637	24495	51	Eddy	Eddy	NNP
18637	24495	52	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24495	53	,	,	,
18637	24495	54	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24495	55	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24495	56	,	,	,
18637	24495	57	265	265	CD
18637	24495	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24495	59	86	86	CD
18637	24495	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24495	61	1924	1924	CD
18637	24495	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24495	63	,	,	,
18637	24495	64	895	895	CD
18637	24495	65	Skiriotes	Skiriotes	NNPS
18637	24495	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24495	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	24495	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24495	69	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	24495	70	,	,	,
18637	24495	71	313	313	CD
18637	24495	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24495	73	69	69	CD
18637	24495	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24495	75	1941	1941	CD
18637	24495	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24495	77	,	,	,
18637	24495	78	325	325	CD
18637	24495	79	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	24495	80	-	-	HYPH
18637	24495	81	House	House	NNP
18637	24495	82	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	24495	83	,	,	,
18637	24495	84	16	16	CD
18637	24495	85	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24495	86	.	.	.
18637	24496	1	36	36	CD
18637	24496	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24496	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	24496	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24496	5	,	,	,
18637	24496	6	686	686	CD
18637	24496	7	,	,	,
18637	24496	8	687	687	CD
18637	24496	9	,	,	,
18637	24496	10	752	752	CD
18637	24496	11	,	,	,
18637	24496	12	949	949	CD
18637	24496	13	,	,	,
18637	24496	14	965	965	CD
18637	24496	15	,	,	,
18637	24496	16	972	972	CD
18637	24496	17	,	,	,
18637	24496	18	974	974	CD
18637	24496	19	,	,	,
18637	24496	20	985	985	CD
18637	24496	21	,	,	,
18637	24496	22	1143	1143	CD
18637	24496	23	,	,	,
18637	24496	24	1160	1160	CD
18637	24496	25	Sligh	Sligh	NNP
18637	24496	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24496	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	29	Kirkwood	Kirkwood	NNP
18637	24496	30	,	,	,
18637	24496	31	237	237	CD
18637	24496	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24496	33	52	52	CD
18637	24496	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24496	35	1915	1915	CD
18637	24496	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24496	37	,	,	,
18637	24496	38	243	243	CD
18637	24496	39	,	,	,
18637	24496	40	982	982	CD
18637	24496	41	,	,	,
18637	24496	42	983	983	CD
18637	24496	43	,	,	,
18637	24496	44	1027	1027	CD
18637	24496	45	,	,	,
18637	24496	46	1030	1030	CD
18637	24496	47	Sloan	Sloan	NNP
18637	24496	48	Shipyards	Shipyards	NNPS
18637	24496	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	24496	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	52	United	United	NNP
18637	24496	53	States	States	NNP
18637	24496	54	Fleet	Fleet	NNP
18637	24496	55	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24496	56	,	,	,
18637	24496	57	258	258	CD
18637	24496	58	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24496	59	549	549	CD
18637	24496	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24496	61	1922	1922	CD
18637	24496	62	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24496	63	,	,	,
18637	24496	64	289	289	CD
18637	24496	65	,	,	,
18637	24496	66	310	310	CD
18637	24496	67	,	,	,
18637	24496	68	586	586	CD
18637	24496	69	Slocum	Slocum	NNP
18637	24496	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	24496	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	73	New	New	NNP
18637	24496	74	York	York	NNP
18637	24496	75	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24496	76	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	24496	77	Company	Company	NNP
18637	24496	78	,	,	,
18637	24496	79	228	228	CD
18637	24496	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24496	81	364	364	CD
18637	24496	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24496	83	1913	1913	CD
18637	24496	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24496	85	,	,	,
18637	24496	86	896	896	CD
18637	24496	87	Smiley	Smiley	NNP
18637	24496	88	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	24496	90	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	91	Holm	Holm	NNP
18637	24496	92	,	,	,
18637	24496	93	285	285	CD
18637	24496	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24496	95	355	355	CD
18637	24496	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24496	97	1932	1932	CD
18637	24496	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24496	99	,	,	,
18637	24496	100	93	93	CD
18637	24496	101	,	,	,
18637	24496	102	548	548	CD
18637	24496	103	Smiley	Smiley	NNP
18637	24496	104	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	105	v.	v.	IN
18637	24496	106	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	107	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24496	108	,	,	,
18637	24496	109	196	196	CD
18637	24496	110	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24496	111	447	447	CD
18637	24496	112	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24496	113	1905	1905	CD
18637	24496	114	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24496	115	,	,	,
18637	24496	116	1017	1017	CD
18637	24496	117	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24496	118	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	24496	120	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	121	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	24496	122	,	,	,
18637	24496	123	130	130	CD
18637	24496	124	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24496	125	167	167	CD
18637	24496	126	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24496	127	1889	1889	CD
18637	24496	128	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24496	129	,	,	,
18637	24496	130	539	539	CD
18637	24496	131	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24496	132	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	133	v.	v.	IN
18637	24496	134	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	135	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	24496	136	,	,	,
18637	24496	137	124	124	CD
18637	24496	138	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24496	139	465	465	CD
18637	24496	140	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24496	141	1888	1888	CD
18637	24496	142	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24496	143	,	,	,
18637	24496	144	222	222	CD
18637	24496	145	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24496	146	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	147	v.	v.	IN
18637	24496	148	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	149	Allwright	Allwright	NNP
18637	24496	150	,	,	,
18637	24496	151	321	321	CD
18637	24496	152	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24496	153	649	649	CD
18637	24496	154	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24496	155	1944	1944	CD
18637	24496	156	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24496	157	,	,	,
18637	24496	158	565	565	CD
18637	24496	159	,	,	,
18637	24496	160	566	566	CD
18637	24496	161	,	,	,
18637	24496	162	1142	1142	CD
18637	24496	163	,	,	,
18637	24496	164	1164	1164	CD
18637	24496	165	,	,	,
18637	24496	166	1185	1185	CD
18637	24496	167	,	,	,
18637	24496	168	1186	1186	CD
18637	24496	169	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24496	170	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	171	v.	v.	IN
18637	24496	172	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	173	Cahoon	Cahoon	NNP
18637	24496	174	,	,	,
18637	24496	175	283	283	CD
18637	24496	176	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24496	177	553	553	CD
18637	24496	178	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24496	179	1931	1931	CD
18637	24496	180	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24496	181	,	,	,
18637	24496	182	228	228	CD
18637	24496	183	,	,	,
18637	24496	184	1032	1032	CD
18637	24496	185	,	,	,
18637	24496	186	1145	1145	CD
18637	24496	187	,	,	,
18637	24496	188	1156	1156	CD
18637	24496	189	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24496	190	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	191	v.	v.	IN
18637	24496	192	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	193	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	24496	194	,	,	,
18637	24496	195	323	323	CD
18637	24496	196	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24496	197	111	111	CD
18637	24496	198	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24496	199	1944	1944	CD
18637	24496	200	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24496	201	,	,	,
18637	24496	202	730	730	CD
18637	24496	203	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24496	204	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	205	v.	v.	IN
18637	24496	206	_	_	NNP
18637	24496	207	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	24496	208	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	24496	209	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	24496	210	.	.	.
18637	24497	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24497	2	,	,	,
18637	24497	3	270	270	CD
18637	24497	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24497	5	587	587	CD
18637	24497	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24497	7	1926	1926	CD
18637	24497	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24497	9	,	,	,
18637	24497	10	1002	1002	CD
18637	24497	11	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24497	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24497	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24497	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24497	15	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	24497	16	,	,	,
18637	24497	17	191	191	CD
18637	24497	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24497	19	138	138	CD
18637	24497	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24497	21	1903	1903	CD
18637	24497	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24497	23	,	,	,
18637	24497	24	540	540	CD
18637	24497	25	,	,	,
18637	24497	26	982	982	CD
18637	24497	27	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24497	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24497	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24497	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24497	31	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	24497	32	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24497	33	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	24497	34	.	.	NNP
18637	24497	35	,	,	,
18637	24497	36	245	245	CD
18637	24497	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24497	38	33	33	CD
18637	24497	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24497	40	1917	1917	CD
18637	24497	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24497	42	,	,	,
18637	24497	43	84	84	CD
18637	24497	44	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24497	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24497	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	24497	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24497	48	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24497	49	City	City	NNP
18637	24497	50	Title	Title	NNP
18637	24497	51	&	&	CC
18637	24497	52	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24497	53	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24497	54	,	,	,
18637	24497	55	255	255	CD
18637	24497	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24497	57	180	180	CD
18637	24497	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24497	59	1921	1921	CD
18637	24497	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24497	61	,	,	,
18637	24497	62	114	114	CD
18637	24497	63	,	,	,
18637	24497	64	267	267	CD
18637	24497	65	,	,	,
18637	24497	66	309	309	CD
18637	24497	67	,	,	,
18637	24497	68	541	541	CD
18637	24497	69	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24497	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24497	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	24497	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24497	73	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	24497	74	,	,	,
18637	24497	75	18	18	CD
18637	24497	76	How	how	WRB
18637	24497	77	.	.	.
18637	24498	1	71	71	CD
18637	24498	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24498	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	24498	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24498	5	,	,	,
18637	24498	6	576	576	CD
18637	24498	7	,	,	,
18637	24498	8	751	751	CD
18637	24498	9	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24498	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24498	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24498	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24498	13	Nichols	Nichols	NNP
18637	24498	14	,	,	,
18637	24498	15	21	21	CD
18637	24498	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24498	17	.	.	.
18637	24499	1	112	112	CD
18637	24499	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24499	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	24499	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24499	5	,	,	,
18637	24499	6	272	272	CD
18637	24499	7	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24499	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24499	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24499	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24499	11	O'Grady	O'Grady	NNP
18637	24499	12	,	,	,
18637	24499	13	312	312	CD
18637	24499	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24499	15	329	329	CD
18637	24499	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24499	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	24499	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24499	19	,	,	,
18637	24499	20	1099	1099	CD
18637	24499	21	,	,	,
18637	24499	22	1101	1101	CD
18637	24499	23	,	,	,
18637	24499	24	1108	1108	CD
18637	24499	25	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24499	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24499	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24499	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24499	29	Reeves	Reeves	NNP
18637	24499	30	,	,	,
18637	24499	31	178	178	CD
18637	24499	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24499	33	436	436	CD
18637	24499	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24499	35	1900	1900	CD
18637	24499	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24499	37	,	,	,
18637	24499	38	588	588	CD
18637	24499	39	,	,	,
18637	24499	40	930	930	CD
18637	24499	41	,	,	,
18637	24499	42	935	935	CD
18637	24499	43	,	,	,
18637	24499	44	936	936	CD
18637	24499	45	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24499	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24499	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	24499	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24499	49	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24499	50	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24499	51	,	,	,
18637	24499	52	&	&	CC
18637	24499	53	S.W.R.	S.W.R.	NNP
18637	24500	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24500	2	,	,	,
18637	24500	3	181	181	CD
18637	24500	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24500	5	248	248	CD
18637	24500	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24500	7	1901	1901	CD
18637	24500	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24500	9	,	,	,
18637	24500	10	236	236	CD
18637	24500	11	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24500	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24500	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24500	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24500	15	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24500	16	,	,	,
18637	24500	17	233	233	CD
18637	24500	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24500	19	630	630	CD
18637	24500	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24500	21	1914	1914	CD
18637	24500	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24500	23	,	,	,
18637	24500	24	1024	1024	CD
18637	24500	25	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24500	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24500	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24500	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24500	29	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24500	30	,	,	,
18637	24500	31	311	311	CD
18637	24500	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24500	33	128	128	CD
18637	24500	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24500	35	1940	1940	CD
18637	24500	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24500	37	,	,	,
18637	24500	38	1098	1098	CD
18637	24500	39	,	,	,
18637	24500	40	1168	1168	CD
18637	24500	41	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24500	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24500	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24500	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24500	45	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	24500	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24500	47	Passenger	Passenger	NNP
18637	24500	48	Cases	Cases	NNP
18637	24500	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24500	50	,	,	,
18637	24500	51	7	7	CD
18637	24500	52	How	how	WRB
18637	24500	53	.	.	.
18637	24501	1	283	283	CD
18637	24501	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24501	3	1849	1849	CD
18637	24501	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24501	5	,	,	,
18637	24501	6	192	192	CD
18637	24501	7	,	,	,
18637	24501	8	216	216	CD
18637	24501	9	,	,	,
18637	24501	10	242	242	CD
18637	24501	11	,	,	,
18637	24501	12	323	323	CD
18637	24501	13	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24501	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24501	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	17	Whitman	Whitman	NNP
18637	24501	18	Saddle	Saddle	NNP
18637	24501	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24501	20	,	,	,
18637	24501	21	148	148	CD
18637	24501	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24501	23	674	674	CD
18637	24501	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24501	25	1893	1893	CD
18637	24501	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24501	27	,	,	,
18637	24501	28	273	273	CD
18637	24501	29	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24501	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24501	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	33	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	24501	34	,	,	,
18637	24501	35	116	116	CD
18637	24501	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24501	37	167	167	CD
18637	24501	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24501	39	1886	1886	CD
18637	24501	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24501	41	,	,	,
18637	24501	42	286	286	CD
18637	24501	43	,	,	,
18637	24501	44	482	482	CD
18637	24501	45	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24501	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	24501	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	49	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24501	50	,	,	,
18637	24501	51	273	273	CD
18637	24501	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24501	53	388	388	CD
18637	24501	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24501	55	1927	1927	CD
18637	24501	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24501	57	,	,	,
18637	24501	58	631	631	CD
18637	24501	59	Smithsonian	Smithsonian	NNP
18637	24501	60	Institution	Institution	NNP
18637	24501	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	24501	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	64	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24501	65	John	John	NNP
18637	24501	66	,	,	,
18637	24501	67	214	214	CD
18637	24501	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24501	69	19	19	CD
18637	24501	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24501	71	1909	1909	CD
18637	24501	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24501	73	,	,	,
18637	24501	74	676	676	CD
18637	24501	75	Smoot	Smoot	NNP
18637	24501	76	Sand	Sand	NNP
18637	24501	77	&	&	CC
18637	24501	78	Gravel	Gravel	NNP
18637	24501	79	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24501	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	24501	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	83	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24501	84	Airport	Airport	NNP
18637	24501	85	,	,	,
18637	24501	86	283	283	CD
18637	24501	87	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24501	88	348	348	CD
18637	24501	89	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24501	90	1931	1931	CD
18637	24501	91	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24501	92	,	,	,
18637	24501	93	301	301	CD
18637	24501	94	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
18637	24501	95	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	24501	97	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	98	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	24501	99	,	,	,
18637	24501	100	169	169	CD
18637	24501	101	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24501	102	466	466	CD
18637	24501	103	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24501	104	1898	1898	CD
18637	24501	105	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24501	106	,	,	,
18637	24501	107	630	630	CD
18637	24501	108	,	,	,
18637	24501	109	931	931	CD
18637	24501	110	,	,	,
18637	24501	111	933	933	CD
18637	24501	112	,	,	,
18637	24501	113	981	981	CD
18637	24501	114	,	,	,
18637	24501	115	1000	1000	CD
18637	24501	116	,	,	,
18637	24501	117	1005	1005	CD
18637	24501	118	,	,	,
18637	24501	119	1006	1006	CD
18637	24501	120	,	,	,
18637	24501	121	1007	1007	CD
18637	24501	122	Snowden	Snowden	NNP
18637	24501	123	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	124	v.	v.	IN
18637	24501	125	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	126	Hughes	Hughes	NNP
18637	24501	127	,	,	,
18637	24501	128	321	321	CD
18637	24501	129	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24501	130	1	1	CD
18637	24501	131	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24501	132	1944	1944	CD
18637	24501	133	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24501	134	,	,	,
18637	24501	135	971	971	CD
18637	24501	136	,	,	,
18637	24501	137	1035	1035	CD
18637	24501	138	,	,	,
18637	24501	139	1142	1142	CD
18637	24501	140	,	,	,
18637	24501	141	1165	1165	CD
18637	24501	142	Snyder	Snyder	NNP
18637	24501	143	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	144	v.	v.	IN
18637	24501	145	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	146	Bettman	Bettman	NNP
18637	24501	147	,	,	,
18637	24501	148	190	190	CD
18637	24501	149	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24501	150	249	249	CD
18637	24501	151	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24501	152	1903	1903	CD
18637	24501	153	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24501	154	,	,	,
18637	24501	155	107	107	CD
18637	24501	156	Snyder	Snyder	NNP
18637	24501	157	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	158	v.	v.	IN
18637	24501	159	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	160	Marks	Marks	NNP
18637	24501	161	,	,	,
18637	24501	162	109	109	CD
18637	24501	163	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24501	164	189	189	CD
18637	24501	165	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24501	166	1883	1883	CD
18637	24501	167	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24501	168	,	,	,
18637	24501	169	541	541	CD
18637	24501	170	,	,	,
18637	24501	171	621	621	CD
18637	24501	172	Snyder	Snyder	NNP
18637	24501	173	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	174	v.	v.	IN
18637	24501	175	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	176	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24501	177	,	,	,
18637	24501	178	291	291	CD
18637	24501	179	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24501	180	97	97	CD
18637	24501	181	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24501	182	1934	1934	CD
18637	24501	183	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24501	184	,	,	,
18637	24501	185	1089	1089	CD
18637	24501	186	,	,	,
18637	24501	187	1096	1096	CD
18637	24501	188	,	,	,
18637	24501	189	1110	1110	CD
18637	24501	190	,	,	,
18637	24501	191	1112	1112	CD
18637	24501	192	,	,	,
18637	24501	193	1128	1128	CD
18637	24501	194	,	,	,
18637	24501	195	1132	1132	CD
18637	24501	196	,	,	,
18637	24501	197	1133	1133	CD
18637	24501	198	Society	Society	NNP
18637	24501	199	for	for	IN
18637	24501	200	Savings	Savings	NNP
18637	24501	201	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	202	v.	v.	IN
18637	24501	203	_	_	NNP
18637	24501	204	Coite	Coite	NNP
18637	24501	205	,	,	,
18637	24501	206	6	6	CD
18637	24501	207	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24501	208	.	.	.
18637	24502	1	594	594	CD
18637	24502	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24502	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	24502	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24502	5	,	,	,
18637	24502	6	730	730	CD
18637	24502	7	Sola	Sola	NNP
18637	24502	8	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	24502	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24502	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24502	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24502	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24502	13	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	24502	14	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	24502	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24502	16	,	,	,
18637	24502	17	317	317	CD
18637	24502	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24502	19	173	173	CD
18637	24502	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24502	21	1942	1942	CD
18637	24502	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24502	23	,	,	,
18637	24502	24	724	724	CD
18637	24502	25	Solesbee	Solesbee	NNP
18637	24502	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24502	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24502	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24502	29	Balkcom	Balkcom	NNP
18637	24502	30	,	,	,
18637	24502	31	339	339	CD
18637	24502	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24502	33	9	9	CD
18637	24502	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24502	35	1950	1950	CD
18637	24502	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24502	37	,	,	,
18637	24502	38	1129	1129	CD
18637	24502	39	,	,	,
18637	24502	40	1135	1135	CD
18637	24502	41	Soliah	Soliah	NNP
18637	24502	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24502	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24502	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24502	45	Heskin	Heskin	NNP
18637	24502	46	,	,	,
18637	24502	47	222	222	CD
18637	24502	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24502	49	522	522	CD
18637	24502	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24502	51	1912	1912	CD
18637	24502	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24502	53	,	,	,
18637	24502	54	1036	1036	CD
18637	24502	55	,	,	,
18637	24502	56	1059	1059	CD
18637	24502	57	Sonneborn	Sonneborn	NNP
18637	24502	58	Eros	Eros	NNP
18637	24502	59	.	.	.
18637	24503	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24503	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	4	Cureton	Cureton	NNP
18637	24503	5	,	,	,
18637	24503	6	262	262	CD
18637	24503	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24503	8	506	506	CD
18637	24503	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24503	10	1923	1923	CD
18637	24503	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24503	12	,	,	,
18637	24503	13	184	184	CD
18637	24503	14	,	,	,
18637	24503	15	239	239	CD
18637	24503	16	Sonzinsky	Sonzinsky	NNP
18637	24503	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24503	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	20	United	United	NNP
18637	24503	21	States	States	NNP
18637	24503	22	,	,	,
18637	24503	23	300	300	CD
18637	24503	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24503	25	506	506	CD
18637	24503	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24503	27	1937	1937	CD
18637	24503	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24503	29	,	,	,
18637	24503	30	111	111	CD
18637	24503	31	Soon	soon	RB
18637	24503	32	Hing	Hing	NNP
18637	24503	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24503	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	36	Crowley	Crowley	NNP
18637	24503	37	,	,	,
18637	24503	38	113	113	CD
18637	24503	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24503	40	703	703	CD
18637	24503	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24503	42	1885	1885	CD
18637	24503	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24503	44	,	,	,
18637	24503	45	1029	1029	CD
18637	24503	46	Soper	Soper	NNP
18637	24503	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	24503	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	50	Lawrence	Lawrence	NNP
18637	24503	51	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	24503	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24503	53	,	,	,
18637	24503	54	201	201	CD
18637	24503	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24503	56	359	359	CD
18637	24503	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24503	58	1906	1906	CD
18637	24503	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24503	60	,	,	,
18637	24503	61	1093	1093	CD
18637	24503	62	South	South	NNP
18637	24503	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	24503	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	66	Peters	Peters	NNP
18637	24503	67	,	,	,
18637	24503	68	339	339	CD
18637	24503	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24503	70	276	276	CD
18637	24503	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24503	72	1950	1950	CD
18637	24503	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24503	74	,	,	,
18637	24503	75	548	548	CD
18637	24503	76	,	,	,
18637	24503	77	1165	1165	CD
18637	24503	78	South	South	NNP
18637	24503	79	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24503	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	24503	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	83	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	24503	84	,	,	,
18637	24503	85	289	289	CD
18637	24503	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24503	87	412	412	CD
18637	24503	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24503	89	1933	1933	CD
18637	24503	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24503	91	,	,	,
18637	24503	92	695	695	CD
18637	24503	93	South	South	NNP
18637	24503	94	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24503	95	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	24503	97	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	98	Gaillard	Gaillard	NNP
18637	24503	99	,	,	,
18637	24503	100	101	101	CD
18637	24503	101	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24503	102	433	433	CD
18637	24503	103	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24503	104	1880	1880	CD
18637	24503	105	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24503	106	,	,	,
18637	24503	107	355	355	CD
18637	24503	108	South	South	NNP
18637	24503	109	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24503	110	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	111	v.	v.	IN
18637	24503	112	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	113	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	24503	114	,	,	,
18637	24503	115	93	93	CD
18637	24503	116	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24503	117	4	4	CD
18637	24503	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24503	119	1876	1876	CD
18637	24503	120	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24503	121	,	,	,
18637	24503	122	128	128	CD
18637	24503	123	,	,	,
18637	24503	124	322	322	CD
18637	24503	125	South	South	NNP
18637	24503	126	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24503	127	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	128	v.	v.	IN
18637	24503	129	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	130	United	United	NNP
18637	24503	131	States	States	NNP
18637	24503	132	,	,	,
18637	24503	133	199	199	CD
18637	24503	134	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24503	135	437	437	CD
18637	24503	136	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24503	137	1905	1905	CD
18637	24503	138	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24503	139	,	,	,
18637	24503	140	107	107	CD
18637	24503	141	South	South	NNP
18637	24503	142	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24503	143	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	144	v.	v.	IN
18637	24503	145	_	_	NNP
18637	24503	146	Wesley	Wesley	NNP
18637	24503	147	,	,	,
18637	24503	148	155	155	CD
18637	24503	149	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24503	150	542	542	CD
18637	24503	151	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24503	152	1895	1895	CD
18637	24503	153	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24503	154	,	,	,
18637	24503	155	931	931	CD
18637	24503	156	South	South	NNP
18637	24503	157	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24503	158	Highway	Highway	NNP
18637	24503	159	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	24503	160	.	.	.
18637	24504	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24504	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24504	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24504	4	Barnwell	Barnwell	NNP
18637	24504	5	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	24504	6	,	,	,
18637	24504	7	303	303	CD
18637	24504	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24504	9	177	177	CD
18637	24504	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24504	11	1938	1938	CD
18637	24504	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24504	13	,	,	,
18637	24504	14	177	177	CD
18637	24504	15	,	,	,
18637	24504	16	218	218	CD
18637	24504	17	,	,	,
18637	24504	18	227	227	CD
18637	24504	19	,	,	,
18637	24504	20	982	982	CD
18637	24504	21	South	South	NNP
18637	24504	22	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	24504	23	&	&	CC
18637	24504	24	C.	C.	NNP
18637	24504	25	Street	Street	NNP
18637	24504	26	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24504	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24504	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24504	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24504	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24504	31	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	24504	32	,	,	,
18637	24504	33	235	235	CD
18637	24504	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24504	35	537	537	CD
18637	24504	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24504	37	1915	1915	CD
18637	24504	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24504	39	,	,	,
18637	24504	40	219	219	CD
18637	24504	41	,	,	,
18637	24504	42	223	223	CD
18637	24504	43	South	South	NNP
18637	24504	44	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	24504	45	&	&	CC
18637	24504	46	C.	C.	NNP
18637	24504	47	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24504	48	By	By	NNP
18637	24504	49	.	.	.
18637	24505	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	5	Newport	Newport	NNP
18637	24505	6	,	,	,
18637	24505	7	259	259	CD
18637	24505	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	9	97	97	CD
18637	24505	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	24505	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	13	,	,	,
18637	24505	14	567	567	CD
18637	24505	15	South	South	NNP
18637	24505	16	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
18637	24505	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	20	North	North	NNP
18637	24505	21	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24505	22	,	,	,
18637	24505	23	192	192	CD
18637	24505	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	25	286	286	CD
18637	24505	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	27	1904	1904	CD
18637	24505	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	29	,	,	,
18637	24505	30	593	593	CD
18637	24505	31	,	,	,
18637	24505	32	930	930	CD
18637	24505	33	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	34	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	24505	35	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	24505	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	40	Chariton	Chariton	NNP
18637	24505	41	,	,	,
18637	24505	42	255	255	CD
18637	24505	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	44	539	539	CD
18637	24505	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	46	1921	1921	CD
18637	24505	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	48	,	,	,
18637	24505	49	349	349	CD
18637	24505	50	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	51	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	24505	52	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24505	53	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24505	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	57	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	24505	58	,	,	,
18637	24505	59	301	301	CD
18637	24505	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	61	148	148	CD
18637	24505	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	63	1937	1937	CD
18637	24505	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	65	,	,	,
18637	24505	66	198	198	CD
18637	24505	67	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	68	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24505	69	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	73	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	24505	74	,	,	,
18637	24505	75	325	325	CD
18637	24505	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	77	761	761	CD
18637	24505	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	79	1945	1945	CD
18637	24505	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	81	,	,	,
18637	24505	82	177	177	CD
18637	24505	83	,	,	,
18637	24505	84	217	217	CD
18637	24505	85	,	,	,
18637	24505	86	223	223	CD
18637	24505	87	,	,	,
18637	24505	88	225	225	CD
18637	24505	89	,	,	,
18637	24505	90	724	724	CD
18637	24505	91	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	92	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24505	93	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	96	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	97	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
18637	24505	98	,	,	,
18637	24505	99	230	230	CD
18637	24505	100	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	101	537	537	CD
18637	24505	102	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	103	1913	1913	CD
18637	24505	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	105	,	,	,
18637	24505	106	349	349	CD
18637	24505	107	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	108	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24505	109	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	110	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	111	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	112	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	113	Denton	Denton	NNP
18637	24505	114	,	,	,
18637	24505	115	146	146	CD
18637	24505	116	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	117	202	202	CD
18637	24505	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	119	1892	1892	CD
18637	24505	120	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	121	,	,	,
18637	24505	122	638	638	CD
18637	24505	123	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	124	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24505	125	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	126	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	127	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	128	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	129	Gallagher	Gallagher	NNP
18637	24505	130	,	,	,
18637	24505	131	306	306	CD
18637	24505	132	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	133	167	167	CD
18637	24505	134	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	135	1939	1939	CD
18637	24505	136	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	137	,	,	,
18637	24505	138	186	186	CD
18637	24505	139	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	140	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24505	141	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	142	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	143	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	144	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	145	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	24505	146	,	,	,
18637	24505	147	244	244	CD
18637	24505	148	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	149	205	205	CD
18637	24505	150	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	151	1917	1917	CD
18637	24505	152	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	153	,	,	,
18637	24505	154	580	580	CD
18637	24505	155	,	,	,
18637	24505	156	583	583	CD
18637	24505	157	,	,	,
18637	24505	158	625	625	CD
18637	24505	159	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	160	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24505	161	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	162	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	163	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	164	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	165	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	24505	166	,	,	,
18637	24505	167	222	222	CD
18637	24505	168	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	169	63	63	CD
18637	24505	170	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	171	1911	1911	CD
18637	24505	172	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	173	,	,	,
18637	24505	174	1052	1052	CD
18637	24505	175	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	176	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24505	177	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	178	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	179	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	180	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	181	Lowe	Lowe	NNP
18637	24505	182	,	,	,
18637	24505	183	247	247	CD
18637	24505	184	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	185	330	330	CD
18637	24505	186	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	187	1918	1918	CD
18637	24505	188	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	189	,	,	,
18637	24505	190	1193	1193	CD
18637	24505	191	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	192	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24505	193	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	194	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	195	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	196	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	197	Burlington	Burlington	NNP
18637	24505	198	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	24505	199	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	200	,	,	,
18637	24505	201	225	225	CD
18637	24505	202	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	203	99	99	CD
18637	24505	204	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	205	1912	1912	CD
18637	24505	206	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	207	,	,	,
18637	24505	208	247	247	CD
18637	24505	209	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	210	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24505	211	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	212	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	213	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	214	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	215	Greene	Greene	NNP
18637	24505	216	,	,	,
18637	24505	217	216	216	CD
18637	24505	218	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	219	400	400	CD
18637	24505	220	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	221	1910	1910	CD
18637	24505	222	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	223	,	,	,
18637	24505	224	1149	1149	CD
18637	24505	225	,	,	,
18637	24505	226	1150	1150	CD
18637	24505	227	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	228	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24505	229	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	230	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	231	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	232	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	233	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	24505	234	,	,	,
18637	24505	235	274	274	CD
18637	24505	236	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	237	76	76	CD
18637	24505	238	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	239	1927	1927	CD
18637	24505	240	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	241	,	,	,
18637	24505	242	202	202	CD
18637	24505	243	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	244	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24505	245	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	246	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	247	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	248	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	249	King	King	NNP
18637	24505	250	,	,	,
18637	24505	251	217	217	CD
18637	24505	252	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	253	524	524	CD
18637	24505	254	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	255	1910	1910	CD
18637	24505	256	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	257	,	,	,
18637	24505	258	220	220	CD
18637	24505	259	,	,	,
18637	24505	260	224	224	CD
18637	24505	261	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	262	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24505	263	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	264	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	265	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	266	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	267	Painter	Painter	NNP
18637	24505	268	,	,	,
18637	24505	269	314	314	CD
18637	24505	270	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	271	155	155	CD
18637	24505	272	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	273	1941	1941	CD
18637	24505	274	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	275	,	,	,
18637	24505	276	629	629	CD
18637	24505	277	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	278	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24505	279	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	280	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	281	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	282	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	283	Puckett	Puckett	NNP
18637	24505	284	,	,	,
18637	24505	285	244	244	CD
18637	24505	286	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	287	571	571	CD
18637	24505	288	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	289	1917	1917	CD
18637	24505	290	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	291	,	,	,
18637	24505	292	141	141	CD
18637	24505	293	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	294	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24505	295	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	296	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	297	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	298	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	299	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24505	300	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	24505	301	.	.	NNP
18637	24505	302	,	,	,
18637	24505	303	236	236	CD
18637	24505	304	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	305	439	439	CD
18637	24505	306	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	307	1915	1915	CD
18637	24505	308	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	309	,	,	,
18637	24505	310	247	247	CD
18637	24505	311	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	312	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24505	313	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	314	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	315	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	316	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	317	Reid	Reid	NNP
18637	24505	318	,	,	,
18637	24505	319	222	222	CD
18637	24505	320	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	321	424	424	CD
18637	24505	322	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	323	1912	1912	CD
18637	24505	324	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	325	,	,	,
18637	24505	326	247	247	CD
18637	24505	327	,	,	,
18637	24505	328	248	248	CD
18637	24505	329	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	330	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24505	331	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	332	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	333	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	334	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	335	United	United	NNP
18637	24505	336	States	States	NNP
18637	24505	337	,	,	,
18637	24505	338	222	222	CD
18637	24505	339	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	340	20	20	CD
18637	24505	341	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	342	1911	1911	CD
18637	24505	343	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	344	,	,	,
18637	24505	345	139	139	CD
18637	24505	346	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	347	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	24505	348	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	349	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	350	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	351	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	352	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	24505	353	,	,	,
18637	24505	354	211	211	CD
18637	24505	355	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	356	603	603	CD
18637	24505	357	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	358	1909	1909	CD
18637	24505	359	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	360	,	,	,
18637	24505	361	603	603	CD
18637	24505	362	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	363	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	24505	364	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	365	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	366	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	367	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	368	National	National	NNP
18637	24505	369	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24505	370	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	24505	371	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24505	372	,	,	,
18637	24505	373	316	316	CD
18637	24505	374	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24505	375	31	31	CD
18637	24505	376	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24505	377	1942	1942	CD
18637	24505	378	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24505	379	,	,	,
18637	24505	380	577	577	CD
18637	24505	381	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24505	382	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	24505	383	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24505	384	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	385	v.	v.	IN
18637	24505	386	_	_	NNP
18637	24505	387	Portwardens	Portwardens	NNP
18637	24505	388	,	,	,
18637	24505	389	6	6	CD
18637	24505	390	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24505	391	.	.	.
18637	24506	1	31	31	CD
18637	24506	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24506	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	24506	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24506	5	,	,	,
18637	24506	6	366	366	CD
18637	24506	7	Southwestern	Southwestern	NNP
18637	24506	8	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	24506	9	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	24506	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24506	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24506	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24506	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24506	14	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
18637	24506	15	,	,	,
18637	24506	16	303	303	CD
18637	24506	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24506	18	206	206	CD
18637	24506	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24506	20	1938	1938	CD
18637	24506	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24506	22	,	,	,
18637	24506	23	570	570	CD
18637	24506	24	Southwestern	Southwestern	NNP
18637	24506	25	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	24506	26	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	24506	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24506	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24506	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24506	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24506	31	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	24506	32	.	.	.
18637	24507	1	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	24507	2	.	.	.
18637	24508	1	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	24508	2	.	.	NNP
18637	24508	3	,	,	,
18637	24508	4	262	262	CD
18637	24508	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24508	6	276	276	CD
18637	24508	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24508	8	1923	1923	CD
18637	24508	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24508	10	,	,	,
18637	24508	11	1006	1006	CD
18637	24508	12	Southwestern	Southwestern	NNP
18637	24508	13	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24508	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24508	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24508	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24508	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24508	18	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24508	19	,	,	,
18637	24508	20	217	217	CD
18637	24508	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24508	22	114	114	CD
18637	24508	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24508	24	1910	1910	CD
18637	24508	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24508	26	,	,	,
18637	24508	27	1036	1036	CD
18637	24508	28	,	,	,
18637	24508	29	1149	1149	CD
18637	24508	30	Southwestern	Southwestern	NNP
18637	24508	31	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24508	32	.	.	.
18637	24509	1	&	&	CC
18637	24509	2	Teleph	Teleph	NNP
18637	24509	3	.	.	.
18637	24510	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24510	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24510	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	5	Danaher	Danaher	NNP
18637	24510	6	,	,	,
18637	24510	7	238	238	CD
18637	24510	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24510	9	482	482	CD
18637	24510	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24510	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	24510	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24510	13	,	,	,
18637	24510	14	1016	1016	CD
18637	24510	15	Sovereign	Sovereign	NNP
18637	24510	16	Camp	Camp	NNP
18637	24510	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24510	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	20	Bolin	Bolin	NNP
18637	24510	21	,	,	,
18637	24510	22	305	305	CD
18637	24510	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24510	24	66	66	CD
18637	24510	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24510	26	1938	1938	CD
18637	24510	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24510	28	,	,	,
18637	24510	29	678	678	CD
18637	24510	30	Spalding	Spalding	NNP
18637	24510	31	&	&	CC
18637	24510	32	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	24510	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24510	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	36	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	24510	37	,	,	,
18637	24510	38	262	262	CD
18637	24510	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24510	40	66	66	CD
18637	24510	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24510	42	1923	1923	CD
18637	24510	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24510	44	,	,	,
18637	24510	45	321	321	CD
18637	24510	46	Sparf	Sparf	NNP
18637	24510	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	24510	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	50	United	United	NNP
18637	24510	51	States	States	NNP
18637	24510	52	,	,	,
18637	24510	53	156	156	CD
18637	24510	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24510	55	51	51	CD
18637	24510	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24510	57	1895	1895	CD
18637	24510	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24510	59	,	,	,
18637	24510	60	896	896	CD
18637	24510	61	Spaulding	spaulde	VBG
18637	24510	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	24510	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	65	Vilas	Vilas	NNP
18637	24510	66	,	,	,
18637	24510	67	161	161	CD
18637	24510	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24510	69	483	483	CD
18637	24510	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24510	71	1896	1896	CD
18637	24510	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24510	73	,	,	,
18637	24510	74	501	501	CD
18637	24510	75	Spector	Spector	NNP
18637	24510	76	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	24510	77	Service	Service	NNP
18637	24510	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	24510	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	81	McLaughlin	McLaughlin	NNP
18637	24510	82	,	,	,
18637	24510	83	323	323	CD
18637	24510	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24510	85	101	101	CD
18637	24510	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24510	87	1944	1944	CD
18637	24510	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24510	89	,	,	,
18637	24510	90	562	562	CD
18637	24510	91	Spector	Spector	NNP
18637	24510	92	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	24510	93	Service	Service	NNP
18637	24510	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	24510	96	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	97	O'Connor	O'Connor	NNP
18637	24510	98	,	,	,
18637	24510	99	340	340	CD
18637	24510	100	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24510	101	602	602	CD
18637	24510	102	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24510	103	1951	1951	CD
18637	24510	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24510	105	,	,	,
18637	24510	106	209	209	CD
18637	24510	107	Spies	Spies	NNPS
18637	24510	108	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	109	v.	v.	IN
18637	24510	110	_	_	NNP
18637	24510	111	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	24510	112	,	,	,
18637	24510	113	123	123	CD
18637	24510	114	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24510	115	131	131	CD
18637	24510	116	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24510	117	1887	1887	CD
18637	24510	118	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24510	119	,	,	,
18637	24510	120	752	752	CD
18637	24510	121	Spokane	Spokane	NNP
18637	24510	122	&	&	CC
18637	24510	123	I.E.R.	I.E.R.	NNP
18637	24511	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24511	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24511	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	5	Whitley	Whitley	NNP
18637	24511	6	,	,	,
18637	24511	7	237	237	CD
18637	24511	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24511	9	487	487	CD
18637	24511	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24511	11	1915	1915	CD
18637	24511	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24511	13	,	,	,
18637	24511	14	658	658	CD
18637	24511	15	Spokane	Spokane	NNP
18637	24511	16	County	County	NNP
18637	24511	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24511	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	20	United	United	NNP
18637	24511	21	States	States	NNP
18637	24511	22	,	,	,
18637	24511	23	279	279	CD
18637	24511	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24511	25	80	80	CD
18637	24511	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24511	27	1929	1929	CD
18637	24511	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24511	29	,	,	,
18637	24511	30	722	722	CD
18637	24511	31	Spragins	Spragins	NNPS
18637	24511	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	24511	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	35	Houghton	Houghton	NNP
18637	24511	36	,	,	,
18637	24511	37	3	3	CD
18637	24511	38	Ill.	Illinois	NNP
18637	24511	39	377	377	CD
18637	24511	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24511	41	1840	1840	CD
18637	24511	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24511	43	,	,	,
18637	24511	44	258	258	CD
18637	24511	45	Spreckels	Spreckels	NNP
18637	24511	46	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	24511	47	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	24511	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24511	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	50	v.	v.	IN
18637	24511	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	52	McClain	McClain	NNP
18637	24511	53	,	,	,
18637	24511	54	192	192	CD
18637	24511	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24511	56	397	397	CD
18637	24511	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24511	58	1904	1904	CD
18637	24511	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24511	60	,	,	,
18637	24511	61	319	319	CD
18637	24511	62	Springer	Springer	NNP
18637	24511	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	24511	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	66	Philippine	Philippine	NNP
18637	24511	67	Islands	Islands	NNPS
18637	24511	68	,	,	,
18637	24511	69	277	277	CD
18637	24511	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24511	71	189	189	CD
18637	24511	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24511	73	1928	1928	CD
18637	24511	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24511	75	,	,	,
18637	24511	76	459	459	CD
18637	24511	77	Springer	Springer	NNP
18637	24511	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	24511	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	81	United	United	NNP
18637	24511	82	States	States	NNP
18637	24511	83	,	,	,
18637	24511	84	102	102	CD
18637	24511	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24511	86	586	586	CD
18637	24511	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24511	88	1881	1881	CD
18637	24511	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24511	90	,	,	,
18637	24511	91	319	319	CD
18637	24511	92	,	,	,
18637	24511	93	849	849	CD
18637	24511	94	,	,	,
18637	24511	95	1191	1191	CD
18637	24511	96	Springville	Springville	NNP
18637	24511	97	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	98	v.	v.	IN
18637	24511	99	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	100	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	24511	101	,	,	,
18637	24511	102	166	166	CD
18637	24511	103	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24511	104	707	707	CD
18637	24511	105	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24511	106	1897	1897	CD
18637	24511	107	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24511	108	,	,	,
18637	24511	109	892	892	CD
18637	24511	110	Sproles	Sproles	NNPS
18637	24511	111	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	112	v.	v.	IN
18637	24511	113	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	114	Binford	Binford	NNP
18637	24511	115	,	,	,
18637	24511	116	286	286	CD
18637	24511	117	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24511	118	374	374	CD
18637	24511	119	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24511	120	1932	1932	CD
18637	24511	121	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24511	122	,	,	,
18637	24511	123	227	227	CD
18637	24511	124	,	,	,
18637	24511	125	1033	1033	CD
18637	24511	126	,	,	,
18637	24511	127	1155	1155	CD
18637	24511	128	Sprott	Sprott	NNP
18637	24511	129	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	130	v.	v.	IN
18637	24511	131	_	_	NNP
18637	24511	132	United	United	NNP
18637	24511	133	States	States	NNP
18637	24511	134	,	,	,
18637	24511	135	20	20	CD
18637	24511	136	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24511	137	.	.	.
18637	24512	1	459	459	CD
18637	24512	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24512	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	24512	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24512	5	,	,	,
18637	24512	6	640	640	CD
18637	24512	7	,	,	,
18637	24512	8	643	643	CD
18637	24512	9	Sprout	Sprout	NNP
18637	24512	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24512	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24512	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24512	13	South	South	NNP
18637	24512	14	Bend	Bend	NNP
18637	24512	15	,	,	,
18637	24512	16	277	277	CD
18637	24512	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24512	18	163	163	CD
18637	24512	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24512	20	1928	1928	CD
18637	24512	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24512	22	,	,	,
18637	24512	23	197	197	CD
18637	24512	24	,	,	,
18637	24512	25	212	212	CD
18637	24512	26	,	,	,
18637	24512	27	1033	1033	CD
18637	24512	28	S.R.A.	S.R.A.	NNP
18637	24512	29	,	,	,
18637	24512	30	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	24512	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24512	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24512	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24512	34	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24512	35	,	,	,
18637	24512	36	327	327	CD
18637	24512	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24512	38	558	558	CD
18637	24512	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24512	40	1946	1946	CD
18637	24512	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24512	42	,	,	,
18637	24512	43	306	306	CD
18637	24512	44	Stack	Stack	NNP
18637	24512	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24512	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	24512	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24512	48	Boyle	Boyle	NNP
18637	24512	49	,	,	,
18637	24512	50	342	342	CD
18637	24512	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24512	52	1	1	CD
18637	24512	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24512	54	1951	1951	CD
18637	24512	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24512	56	,	,	,
18637	24512	57	904	904	CD
18637	24512	58	Stacy	Stacy	NNP
18637	24512	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24512	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	24512	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24512	62	Thrasher	Thrasher	NNP
18637	24512	63	,	,	,
18637	24512	64	use	use	NN
18637	24512	65	of	of	IN
18637	24512	66	Sellers	seller	NNS
18637	24512	67	,	,	,
18637	24512	68	6	6	CD
18637	24512	69	How	how	WRB
18637	24512	70	.	.	.
18637	24513	1	44	44	CD
18637	24513	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24513	3	1848	1848	CD
18637	24513	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24513	5	,	,	,
18637	24513	6	654	654	CD
18637	24513	7	,	,	,
18637	24513	8	660	660	CD
18637	24513	9	,	,	,
18637	24513	10	672	672	CD
18637	24513	11	Stafford	Stafford	NNP
18637	24513	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24513	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24513	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24513	15	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	24513	16	,	,	,
18637	24513	17	258	258	CD
18637	24513	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24513	19	495	495	CD
18637	24513	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24513	21	1922	1922	CD
18637	24513	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24513	23	,	,	,
18637	24513	24	120	120	CD
18637	24513	25	,	,	,
18637	24513	26	149	149	CD
18637	24513	27	Stamey	Stamey	NNP
18637	24513	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24513	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24513	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24513	31	United	United	NNP
18637	24513	32	States	States	NNP
18637	24513	33	,	,	,
18637	24513	34	37	37	CD
18637	24513	35	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24513	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24513	37	2d	2d	NNP
18637	24513	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24513	39	188	188	CD
18637	24513	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24513	41	1929	1929	CD
18637	24513	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24513	43	,	,	,
18637	24513	44	895	895	CD
18637	24513	45	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	24513	46	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24513	47	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24513	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24513	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	24513	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24513	51	Graves	Graves	NNP
18637	24513	52	,	,	,
18637	24513	53	249	249	CD
18637	24513	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24513	55	389	389	CD
18637	24513	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24513	57	1919	1919	CD
18637	24513	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24513	59	,	,	,
18637	24513	60	184	184	CD
18637	24513	61	,	,	,
18637	24513	62	239	239	CD
18637	24513	63	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	24513	64	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24513	65	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24513	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24513	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	24513	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24513	69	Marysville	Marysville	NNP
18637	24513	70	,	,	,
18637	24513	71	279	279	CD
18637	24513	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24513	73	582	582	CD
18637	24513	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24513	75	1929	1929	CD
18637	24513	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24513	77	,	,	,
18637	24513	78	1029	1029	CD
18637	24513	79	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	24513	80	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24513	81	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24513	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24513	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	24513	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24513	85	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24513	86	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24513	87	rel	rel	NN
18637	24513	88	.	.	.
18637	24514	1	Hadley	Hadley	NNP
18637	24514	2	,	,	,
18637	24514	3	224	224	CD
18637	24514	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24514	5	270	270	CD
18637	24514	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24514	7	1912	1912	CD
18637	24514	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24514	9	,	,	,
18637	24514	10	1140	1140	CD
18637	24514	11	,	,	,
18637	24514	12	1141	1141	CD
18637	24514	13	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	24514	14	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24514	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24514	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24514	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24514	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24514	19	New	New	NNP
18637	24514	20	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	24514	21	,	,	,
18637	24514	22	341	341	CD
18637	24514	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24514	24	428	428	CD
18637	24514	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24514	26	1951	1951	CD
18637	24514	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24514	28	,	,	,
18637	24514	29	1034	1034	CD
18637	24514	30	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	24514	31	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24514	32	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24514	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24514	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24514	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24514	36	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	24514	37	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24514	38	rel	rel	NN
18637	24514	39	.	.	.
18637	24515	1	Cates	cate	NNS
18637	24515	2	,	,	,
18637	24515	3	217	217	CD
18637	24515	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24515	5	413	413	CD
18637	24515	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24515	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	24515	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24515	9	,	,	,
18637	24515	10	1160	1160	CD
18637	24515	11	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
18637	24515	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24515	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24515	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24515	15	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24515	16	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	24515	17	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24515	18	,	,	,
18637	24515	19	295	295	CD
18637	24515	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24515	21	76	76	CD
18637	24515	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24515	23	1935	1935	CD
18637	24515	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24515	25	,	,	,
18637	24515	26	1032	1032	CD
18637	24515	27	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
18637	24515	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24515	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24515	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24515	31	Schwalby	Schwalby	NNP
18637	24515	32	,	,	,
18637	24515	33	162	162	CD
18637	24515	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24515	35	255	255	CD
18637	24515	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24515	37	1896	1896	CD
18637	24515	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24515	39	,	,	,
18637	24515	40	587	587	CD
18637	24515	41	Stanton	Stanton	NNP
18637	24515	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24515	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24515	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24515	45	Baltic	Baltic	NNP
18637	24515	46	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	24515	47	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24515	48	,	,	,
18637	24515	49	240	240	CD
18637	24515	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24515	51	103	103	CD
18637	24515	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24515	53	1916	1916	CD
18637	24515	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24515	55	,	,	,
18637	24515	56	319	319	CD
18637	24515	57	,	,	,
18637	24515	58	320	320	CD
18637	24515	59	,	,	,
18637	24515	60	1192	1192	CD
18637	24515	61	State	State	NNP
18637	24515	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24515	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	24515	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24515	65	McClure	McClure	NNP
18637	24515	66	,	,	,
18637	24515	67	7	7	CD
18637	24515	68	Boyce	Boyce	NNP
18637	24515	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24515	70	Del.	Delaware	NNP
18637	24515	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24516	1	265	265	CD
18637	24516	2	;	;	:
18637	24516	3	105	105	CD
18637	24516	4	A.	a.	NN
18637	24517	1	712	712	CD
18637	24517	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24517	3	1919	1919	CD
18637	24517	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24517	5	,	,	,
18637	24517	6	952	952	CD
18637	24517	7	State	State	NNP
18637	24517	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24517	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24517	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24517	11	Mittle	Mittle	NNP
18637	24517	12	,	,	,
18637	24517	13	120	120	CD
18637	24517	14	S.C.	South Carolina	NNP
18637	24517	15	526	526	CD
18637	24517	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24517	17	1922	1922	CD
18637	24517	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24517	19	,	,	,
18637	24517	20	1220	1220	CD
18637	24517	21	State	State	NNP
18637	24517	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24517	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24517	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24517	25	Mittle	Mittle	NNP
18637	24517	26	,	,	,
18637	24517	27	260	260	CD
18637	24517	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24517	29	705	705	CD
18637	24517	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24517	31	1922	1922	CD
18637	24517	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24517	33	,	,	,
18637	24517	34	1220	1220	CD
18637	24517	35	State	State	NNP
18637	24517	36	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24517	37	of	of	IN
18637	24517	38	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24517	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24517	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24517	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24517	42	Knoop	Knoop	NNP
18637	24517	43	,	,	,
18637	24517	44	16	16	CD
18637	24517	45	How	how	WRB
18637	24517	46	.	.	.
18637	24518	1	369	369	CD
18637	24518	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24518	3	1854	1854	CD
18637	24518	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24518	5	,	,	,
18637	24518	6	330	330	CD
18637	24518	7	State	State	NNP
18637	24518	8	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24518	9	of	of	IN
18637	24518	10	Equalization	Equalization	NNP
18637	24518	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24518	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24518	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24518	14	Young	Young	NNP
18637	24518	15	's	's	POS
18637	24518	16	Market	Market	NNP
18637	24518	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24518	18	,	,	,
18637	24518	19	299	299	CD
18637	24518	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24518	21	59	59	CD
18637	24518	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24518	23	1936	1936	CD
18637	24518	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24518	25	,	,	,
18637	24518	26	241	241	CD
18637	24518	27	,	,	,
18637	24518	28	1231	1231	CD
18637	24518	29	,	,	,
18637	24518	30	1232	1232	CD
18637	24518	31	State	State	NNP
18637	24518	32	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24518	33	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24518	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24518	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	24518	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24518	37	Wichita	Wichita	NNP
18637	24518	38	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24518	39	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24518	40	,	,	,
18637	24518	41	290	290	CD
18637	24518	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24518	43	561	561	CD
18637	24518	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24518	45	1934	1934	CD
18637	24518	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24518	47	,	,	,
18637	24518	48	138	138	CD
18637	24518	49	State	State	NNP
18637	24518	50	Farm	Farm	NNP
18637	24518	51	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24518	52	.	.	.
18637	24519	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24519	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24519	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24519	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24519	5	Duel	Duel	NNP
18637	24519	6	,	,	,
18637	24519	7	324	324	CD
18637	24519	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24519	9	154	154	CD
18637	24519	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24519	11	1945	1945	CD
18637	24519	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24519	13	,	,	,
18637	24519	14	680	680	CD
18637	24519	15	,	,	,
18637	24519	16	1016	1016	CD
18637	24519	17	State	State	NNP
18637	24519	18	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	24519	19	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24519	20	Case	Case	NNP
18637	24519	21	.	.	.
18637	24520	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24520	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24520	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24520	4	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
18637	24520	5	&	&	CC
18637	24520	6	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	24521	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24521	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24521	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24521	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24521	5	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24521	6	.	.	.
18637	24522	1	State	State	NNP
18637	24522	2	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	24522	3	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24522	4	of	of	IN
18637	24522	5	N.Y.	New York	NNP
18637	24522	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24522	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	24522	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24522	9	Terry	Terry	NNP
18637	24522	10	&	&	CC
18637	24522	11	Trench	Trench	NNP
18637	24522	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24522	13	,	,	,
18637	24522	14	273	273	CD
18637	24522	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24522	16	639	639	CD
18637	24522	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24522	18	1926	1926	CD
18637	24522	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24522	20	,	,	,
18637	24522	21	582	582	CD
18637	24522	22	State	State	NNP
18637	24522	23	of	of	IN
18637	24522	24	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24522	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24522	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24522	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24522	28	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	24522	29	,	,	,
18637	24522	30	M.	M.	NNP
18637	24522	31	&	&	CC
18637	24522	32	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24522	33	Paul	Paul	NNP
18637	24522	34	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24522	35	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24522	36	,	,	,
18637	24522	37	38	38	CD
18637	24522	38	Minn.	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24522	39	281	281	CD
18637	24522	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24522	41	1888	1888	CD
18637	24522	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24522	43	,	,	,
18637	24522	44	77	77	CD
18637	24522	45	State	State	NNP
18637	24522	46	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24522	47	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24522	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24522	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	24522	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24522	51	Aldrich	Aldrich	NNP
18637	24522	52	,	,	,
18637	24522	53	316	316	CD
18637	24522	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24522	55	174	174	CD
18637	24522	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24522	57	1942	1942	CD
18637	24522	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24522	59	,	,	,
18637	24522	60	1045	1045	CD
18637	24522	61	,	,	,
18637	24522	62	1047	1047	CD
18637	24522	63	State	State	NNP
18637	24522	64	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24522	65	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24522	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24522	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	24522	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24522	69	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	24522	70	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	24522	71	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24522	72	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24522	73	,	,	,
18637	24522	74	284	284	CD
18637	24522	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24522	76	41	41	CD
18637	24522	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24522	78	1931	1931	CD
18637	24522	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24522	80	,	,	,
18637	24522	81	182	182	CD
18637	24522	82	,	,	,
18637	24522	83	195	195	CD
18637	24522	84	State	State	NNP
18637	24522	85	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24522	86	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
18637	24522	87	.	.	.
18637	24523	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24523	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24523	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24523	4	Van	Van	NNP
18637	24523	5	Cott	Cott	NNP
18637	24523	6	,	,	,
18637	24523	7	306	306	CD
18637	24523	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24523	9	511	511	CD
18637	24523	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24523	11	1939	1939	CD
18637	24523	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24523	13	,	,	,
18637	24523	14	731	731	CD
18637	24523	15	State	State	NNP
18637	24523	16	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24523	17	Comrs	Comrs	NNP
18637	24523	18	.	.	.
18637	24524	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24524	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24524	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24524	4	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	24524	5	,	,	,
18637	24524	6	283	283	CD
18637	24524	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24524	8	527	527	CD
18637	24524	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24524	10	1931	1931	CD
18637	24524	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24524	12	,	,	,
18637	24524	13	1148	1148	CD
18637	24524	14	,	,	,
18637	24524	15	1149	1149	CD
18637	24524	16	Staten	Staten	NNP
18637	24524	17	Island	Island	NNP
18637	24524	18	R.T.R.	R.T.R.	NNP
18637	24525	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24525	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24525	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24525	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24525	5	Phoenix	Phoenix	NNP
18637	24525	6	Indemnity	Indemnity	NNP
18637	24525	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24525	8	,	,	,
18637	24525	9	281	281	CD
18637	24525	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24525	11	98	98	CD
18637	24525	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24525	13	1930	1930	CD
18637	24525	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24525	15	,	,	,
18637	24525	16	990	990	CD
18637	24525	17	Steamship	Steamship	NNP
18637	24525	18	Appam	Appam	NNP
18637	24525	19	,	,	,
18637	24525	20	The	the	DT
18637	24525	21	,	,	,
18637	24525	22	243	243	CD
18637	24525	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24525	24	124	124	CD
18637	24525	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24525	26	1917	1917	CD
18637	24525	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24525	28	,	,	,
18637	24525	29	418	418	CD
18637	24525	30	Stearns	Stearns	NNP
18637	24525	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24525	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24525	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24525	34	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24525	35	,	,	,
18637	24525	36	179	179	CD
18637	24525	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24525	38	223	223	CD
18637	24525	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24525	40	1900	1900	CD
18637	24525	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24525	42	,	,	,
18637	24525	43	330	330	CD
18637	24525	44	,	,	,
18637	24525	45	344	344	CD
18637	24525	46	,	,	,
18637	24525	47	367	367	CD
18637	24525	48	,	,	,
18637	24525	49	699	699	CD
18637	24525	50	,	,	,
18637	24525	51	700	700	CD
18637	24525	52	Stebbins	Stebbins	NNPS
18637	24525	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24525	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	24525	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24525	56	Riley	Riley	NNP
18637	24525	57	,	,	,
18637	24525	58	268	268	CD
18637	24525	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24525	60	137	137	CD
18637	24525	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24525	62	1925	1925	CD
18637	24525	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24525	64	,	,	,
18637	24525	65	1037	1037	CD
18637	24525	66	,	,	,
18637	24525	67	1045	1045	CD
18637	24525	68	Steele	Steele	NNP
18637	24525	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24525	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	24525	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24525	72	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
18637	24525	73	&	&	CC
18637	24525	74	N.R.	N.R.	NNP
18637	24526	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24526	2	,	,	,
18637	24526	3	323	323	CD
18637	24526	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24526	5	192	192	CD
18637	24526	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24526	7	1944	1944	CD
18637	24526	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24526	9	,	,	,
18637	24526	10	854	854	CD
18637	24526	11	Steele	Steele	NNP
18637	24526	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24526	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24526	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24526	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24526	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24526	17	,	,	,
18637	24526	18	No	no	UH
18637	24526	19	.	.	.
18637	24527	1	1	1	CD
18637	24527	2	,	,	,
18637	24527	3	267	267	CD
18637	24527	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24527	5	498	498	CD
18637	24527	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24527	7	1925	1925	CD
18637	24527	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24527	9	,	,	,
18637	24527	10	825	825	CD
18637	24527	11	Steele	Steele	NNP
18637	24527	12	,	,	,
18637	24527	13	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24527	14	parte	parte	NN
18637	24527	15	,	,	,
18637	24527	16	162	162	CD
18637	24527	17	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24527	18	.	.	.
18637	24528	1	694	694	CD
18637	24528	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24528	3	1908	1908	CD
18637	24528	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24528	5	,	,	,
18637	24528	6	545	545	CD
18637	24528	7	Stefanelli	Stefanelli	NNP
18637	24528	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24528	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24528	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24528	11	Minard	Minard	NNP
18637	24528	12	,	,	,
18637	24528	13	342	342	CD
18637	24528	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24528	15	117	117	CD
18637	24528	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24528	17	1951	1951	CD
18637	24528	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24528	19	,	,	,
18637	24528	20	1124	1124	CD
18637	24528	21	Stelle	Stelle	NNP
18637	24528	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24528	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24528	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24528	25	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	24528	26	,	,	,
18637	24528	27	12	12	CD
18637	24528	28	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24528	29	.	.	.
18637	24529	1	201	201	CD
18637	24529	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24529	3	1838	1838	CD
18637	24529	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24529	5	,	,	,
18637	24529	6	302	302	CD
18637	24529	7	Stellwagen	Stellwagen	NNP
18637	24529	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24529	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	11	Clum	Clum	NNP
18637	24529	12	,	,	,
18637	24529	13	245	245	CD
18637	24529	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24529	15	605	605	CD
18637	24529	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24529	17	1918	1918	CD
18637	24529	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24529	19	,	,	,
18637	24529	20	264	264	CD
18637	24529	21	,	,	,
18637	24529	22	265	265	CD
18637	24529	23	Stephan	Stephan	NNP
18637	24529	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24529	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	27	United	United	NNP
18637	24529	28	States	States	NNP
18637	24529	29	,	,	,
18637	24529	30	319	319	CD
18637	24529	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24529	32	423	423	CD
18637	24529	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24529	34	1943	1943	CD
18637	24529	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24529	36	,	,	,
18637	24529	37	615	615	CD
18637	24529	38	Stephan	Stephan	NNP
18637	24529	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24529	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	42	United	United	NNP
18637	24529	43	States	States	NNP
18637	24529	44	,	,	,
18637	24529	45	133	133	CD
18637	24529	46	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24529	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24529	48	2d	2d	NNP
18637	24529	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24529	50	87	87	CD
18637	24529	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24529	52	1943	1943	CD
18637	24529	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24529	54	,	,	,
18637	24529	55	643	643	CD
18637	24529	56	Stephenson	Stephenson	NNP
18637	24529	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	24529	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	60	Binford	Binford	NNP
18637	24529	61	,	,	,
18637	24529	62	287	287	CD
18637	24529	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24529	64	251	251	CD
18637	24529	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24529	66	1932	1932	CD
18637	24529	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24529	68	,	,	,
18637	24529	69	1032	1032	CD
18637	24529	70	Sterling	Sterling	NNP
18637	24529	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	24529	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	74	Constantin	Constantin	NNP
18637	24529	75	,	,	,
18637	24529	76	287	287	CD
18637	24529	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24529	78	378	378	CD
18637	24529	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24529	80	1932	1932	CD
18637	24529	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24529	82	,	,	,
18637	24529	83	484	484	CD
18637	24529	84	,	,	,
18637	24529	85	931	931	CD
18637	24529	86	,	,	,
18637	24529	87	934	934	CD
18637	24529	88	Stettler	Stettler	NNP
18637	24529	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	24529	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	92	O'Hara	O'Hara	NNP
18637	24529	93	,	,	,
18637	24529	94	243	243	CD
18637	24529	95	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24529	96	629	629	CD
18637	24529	97	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24529	98	1917	1917	CD
18637	24529	99	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24529	100	,	,	,
18637	24529	101	980	980	CD
18637	24529	102	Steuart	Steuart	NNP
18637	24529	103	&	&	CC
18637	24529	104	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	24529	105	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	24529	106	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	107	v.	v.	IN
18637	24529	108	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	109	Bowles	Bowles	NNP
18637	24529	110	,	,	,
18637	24529	111	322	322	CD
18637	24529	112	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24529	113	398	398	CD
18637	24529	114	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24529	115	1944	1944	CD
18637	24529	116	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24529	117	,	,	,
18637	24529	118	82	82	CD
18637	24529	119	,	,	,
18637	24529	120	397	397	CD
18637	24529	121	Stevens	Stevens	NNP
18637	24529	122	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	123	v.	v.	IN
18637	24529	124	_	_	NNP
18637	24529	125	Gladding	Gladding	NNP
18637	24529	126	,	,	,
18637	24529	127	17	17	CD
18637	24529	128	How	how	WRB
18637	24529	129	.	.	.
18637	24530	1	447	447	CD
18637	24530	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24530	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	24530	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24530	5	,	,	,
18637	24530	6	275	275	CD
18637	24530	7	Stevenson	Stevenson	NNP
18637	24530	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24530	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24530	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24530	11	Fain	Fain	NNP
18637	24530	12	,	,	,
18637	24530	13	195	195	CD
18637	24530	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24530	15	165	165	CD
18637	24530	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24530	17	1904	1904	CD
18637	24530	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24530	19	,	,	,
18637	24530	20	620	620	CD
18637	24530	21	Steward	Steward	NNP
18637	24530	22	Machine	Machine	NNP
18637	24530	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24530	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24530	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24530	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24530	27	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	24530	28	,	,	,
18637	24530	29	301	301	CD
18637	24530	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24530	31	548	548	CD
18637	24530	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24530	33	1937	1937	CD
18637	24530	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24530	35	,	,	,
18637	24530	36	115	115	CD
18637	24530	37	,	,	,
18637	24530	38	116	116	CD
18637	24530	39	,	,	,
18637	24530	40	724	724	CD
18637	24530	41	,	,	,
18637	24530	42	853	853	CD
18637	24530	43	,	,	,
18637	24530	44	863	863	CD
18637	24530	45	,	,	,
18637	24530	46	918	918	CD
18637	24530	47	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	24530	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24530	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	24530	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24530	51	B.	B.	NNP
18637	24531	1	&	&	CC
18637	24531	2	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	24532	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24532	2	,	,	,
18637	24532	3	168	168	CD
18637	24532	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24532	5	445	445	CD
18637	24532	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24532	7	1897	1897	CD
18637	24532	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24532	9	,	,	,
18637	24532	10	676	676	CD
18637	24532	11	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	24532	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24532	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24532	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24532	15	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	24532	16	,	,	,
18637	24532	17	2	2	CD
18637	24532	18	Binney	Binney	NNP
18637	24532	19	's	's	POS
18637	24532	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24532	21	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24532	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24532	23	110	110	CD
18637	24532	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24532	25	1809	1809	CD
18637	24532	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24532	27	,	,	,
18637	24532	28	258	258	CD
18637	24532	29	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	24532	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24532	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24532	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24532	33	Kahn	Kahn	NNP
18637	24532	34	,	,	,
18637	24532	35	11	11	CD
18637	24532	36	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24532	37	.	.	.
18637	24533	1	493	493	CD
18637	24533	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24533	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24533	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24533	5	,	,	,
18637	24533	6	293	293	CD
18637	24533	7	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	24533	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24533	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24533	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24533	11	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24533	12	City	City	NNP
18637	24533	13	,	,	,
18637	24533	14	239	239	CD
18637	24533	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24533	16	14	14	CD
18637	24533	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24533	18	1915	1915	CD
18637	24533	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24533	20	,	,	,
18637	24533	21	982	982	CD
18637	24533	22	,	,	,
18637	24533	23	1036	1036	CD
18637	24533	24	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	24533	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24533	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24533	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24533	28	Keyes	Keyes	NNP
18637	24533	29	,	,	,
18637	24533	30	295	295	CD
18637	24533	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24533	32	403	403	CD
18637	24533	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24533	34	1935	1935	CD
18637	24533	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24533	36	,	,	,
18637	24533	37	1093	1093	CD
18637	24533	38	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	24533	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24533	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24533	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24533	42	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	24533	43	,	,	,
18637	24533	44	232	232	CD
18637	24533	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24533	46	665	665	CD
18637	24533	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24533	48	1914	1914	CD
18637	24533	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24533	50	,	,	,
18637	24533	51	187	187	CD
18637	24533	52	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
18637	24533	53	Dry	Dry	NNP
18637	24533	54	Goods	Goods	NNP
18637	24533	55	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24533	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24533	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24533	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24533	59	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
18637	24533	60	,	,	,
18637	24533	61	294	294	CD
18637	24533	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24533	63	550	550	CD
18637	24533	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24533	65	1935	1935	CD
18637	24533	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24533	67	,	,	,
18637	24533	68	1037	1037	CD
18637	24533	69	,	,	,
18637	24533	70	1149	1149	CD
18637	24533	71	Stilson	Stilson	NNP
18637	24533	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24533	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	24533	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24533	75	United	United	NNP
18637	24533	76	States	States	NNP
18637	24533	77	,	,	,
18637	24533	78	250	250	CD
18637	24533	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24533	80	583	583	CD
18637	24533	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24533	82	1919	1919	CD
18637	24533	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24533	84	,	,	,
18637	24533	85	880	880	CD
18637	24533	86	Stipcich	Stipcich	NNP
18637	24533	87	_	_	NNP
18637	24533	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	24533	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24533	90	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
18637	24533	91	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24533	92	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24533	93	.	.	.
18637	24534	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24534	2	,	,	,
18637	24534	3	277	277	CD
18637	24534	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24534	5	311	311	CD
18637	24534	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24534	7	1928	1928	CD
18637	24534	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24534	9	,	,	,
18637	24534	10	1021	1021	CD
18637	24534	11	Stockard	Stockard	NNP
18637	24534	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24534	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24534	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24534	15	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
18637	24534	16	,	,	,
18637	24534	17	185	185	CD
18637	24534	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24534	19	27	27	CD
18637	24534	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24534	21	1902	1902	CD
18637	24534	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24534	23	,	,	,
18637	24534	24	187	187	CD
18637	24534	25	Stockdale	Stockdale	NNP
18637	24534	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24534	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24534	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24534	29	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
18637	24534	30	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24534	31	.	.	.
18637	24535	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24535	2	,	,	,
18637	24535	3	20	20	CD
18637	24535	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24535	5	.	.	.
18637	24536	1	323	323	NNP
18637	24536	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24536	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	24536	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24536	5	,	,	,
18637	24536	6	863	863	CD
18637	24536	7	Stockholders	Stockholders	NNPS
18637	24536	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24536	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24536	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24536	11	Sterling	Sterling	NNP
18637	24536	12	,	,	,
18637	24536	13	300	300	CD
18637	24536	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24536	15	175	175	CD
18637	24536	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24536	17	1937	1937	CD
18637	24536	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24536	19	,	,	,
18637	24536	20	1141	1141	CD
18637	24536	21	Stoehr	Stoehr	NNP
18637	24536	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24536	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24536	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24536	25	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	24536	26	,	,	,
18637	24536	27	255	255	CD
18637	24536	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24536	29	239	239	CD
18637	24536	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24536	31	1921	1921	CD
18637	24536	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24536	33	,	,	,
18637	24536	34	295	295	CD
18637	24536	35	,	,	,
18637	24536	36	865	865	CD
18637	24536	37	Stoll	Stoll	NNP
18637	24536	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24536	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24536	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24536	41	Gottlieb	Gottlieb	NNP
18637	24536	42	,	,	,
18637	24536	43	305	305	CD
18637	24536	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24536	45	165	165	CD
18637	24536	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24536	47	1938	1938	CD
18637	24536	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24536	49	,	,	,
18637	24536	50	570	570	CD
18637	24536	51	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	24536	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24536	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	24536	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24536	55	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
18637	24536	56	'	'	POS
18637	24536	57	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	24536	58	&	&	CC
18637	24536	59	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24536	60	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24536	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24536	62	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24536	63	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24536	64	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	24536	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24536	66	,	,	,
18637	24536	67	116	116	CD
18637	24536	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24536	69	307	307	CD
18637	24536	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24536	71	1886	1886	CD
18637	24536	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24536	73	,	,	,
18637	24536	74	349	349	CD
18637	24536	75	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	24536	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24536	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	24536	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24536	79	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	24536	80	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24536	81	rel	rel	NN
18637	24536	82	.	.	.
18637	24537	1	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	24537	2	,	,	,
18637	24537	3	101	101	CD
18637	24537	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24537	5	814	814	CD
18637	24537	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24537	7	1880	1880	CD
18637	24537	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24537	9	,	,	,
18637	24537	10	351	351	CD
18637	24537	11	,	,	,
18637	24537	12	358	358	CD
18637	24537	13	,	,	,
18637	24537	14	1031	1031	CD
18637	24537	15	Stoner	Stoner	NNP
18637	24537	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24537	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24537	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24537	19	New	New	NNP
18637	24537	20	York	York	NNP
18637	24537	21	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24537	22	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24537	23	.	.	.
18637	24538	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24538	2	,	,	,
18637	24538	3	311	311	CD
18637	24538	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24538	5	464	464	CD
18637	24538	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24538	7	1940	1940	CD
18637	24538	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24538	9	,	,	,
18637	24538	10	608	608	CD
18637	24538	11	Storaasli	Storaasli	NNP
18637	24538	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24538	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24538	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24538	15	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24538	16	,	,	,
18637	24538	17	283	283	CD
18637	24538	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24538	19	57	57	CD
18637	24538	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24538	21	1931	1931	CD
18637	24538	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24538	23	,	,	,
18637	24538	24	1155	1155	CD
18637	24538	25	Stoughton	Stoughton	NNP
18637	24538	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24538	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24538	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24538	29	Baker	Baker	NNP
18637	24538	30	et	et	NNP
18637	24538	31	al	al	NNP
18637	24538	32	.	.	NNP
18637	24538	33	,	,	,
18637	24538	34	4	4	CD
18637	24538	35	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24539	1	522	522	CD
18637	24539	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24539	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	24539	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24539	5	,	,	,
18637	24539	6	338	338	CD
18637	24539	7	Stoutenburgh	Stoutenburgh	NNP
18637	24539	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24539	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24539	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24539	11	Hennick	Hennick	NNP
18637	24539	12	,	,	,
18637	24539	13	129	129	CD
18637	24539	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24539	15	141	141	CD
18637	24539	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24539	17	1889	1889	CD
18637	24539	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24539	19	,	,	,
18637	24539	20	122	122	CD
18637	24539	21	,	,	,
18637	24539	22	187	187	CD
18637	24539	23	,	,	,
18637	24539	24	304	304	CD
18637	24539	25	Strassheim	Strassheim	NNP
18637	24539	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24539	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24539	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24539	29	Daily	Daily	NNP
18637	24539	30	,	,	,
18637	24539	31	221	221	CD
18637	24539	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24539	33	280	280	CD
18637	24539	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24539	35	1911	1911	CD
18637	24539	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24539	37	,	,	,
18637	24539	38	695	695	CD
18637	24539	39	Stratton	Stratton	NNP
18637	24539	40	's	's	POS
18637	24539	41	Independence	Independence	NNP
18637	24539	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24539	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24539	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24539	45	Howbert	Howbert	NNP
18637	24539	46	,	,	,
18637	24539	47	231	231	CD
18637	24539	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24539	49	399	399	CD
18637	24539	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24539	51	1914	1914	CD
18637	24539	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24539	53	,	,	,
18637	24539	54	1192	1192	CD
18637	24539	55	Strauder	Strauder	NNP
18637	24539	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24539	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24539	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24539	59	West	West	NNP
18637	24539	60	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24539	61	,	,	,
18637	24539	62	100	100	CD
18637	24539	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24539	64	303	303	CD
18637	24539	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24539	66	1880	1880	CD
18637	24539	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24539	68	,	,	,
18637	24539	69	1176	1176	CD
18637	24539	70	Straus	Straus	NNP
18637	24539	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24539	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	24539	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24539	74	Foxworth	Foxworth	NNP
18637	24539	75	,	,	,
18637	24539	76	231	231	CD
18637	24539	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24539	78	162	162	CD
18637	24539	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24539	80	1913	1913	CD
18637	24539	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24539	82	,	,	,
18637	24539	83	982	982	CD
18637	24539	84	,	,	,
18637	24539	85	1062	1062	CD
18637	24539	86	Strauss	Strauss	NNP
18637	24539	87	,	,	,
18637	24539	88	In	in	IN
18637	24539	89	re	re	NN
18637	24539	90	,	,	,
18637	24539	91	197	197	CD
18637	24539	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24539	93	324	324	CD
18637	24539	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24539	95	1905	1905	CD
18637	24539	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24539	97	,	,	,
18637	24539	98	695	695	CD
18637	24539	99	Strawbridge	Strawbridge	NNP
18637	24539	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24539	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	24539	102	_	_	NNP
18637	24539	103	Curtiss	Curtiss	NNP
18637	24539	104	,	,	,
18637	24539	105	3	3	CD
18637	24539	106	Cr	Cr	NNP
18637	24539	107	.	.	.
18637	24540	1	267	267	CD
18637	24540	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24540	3	1806	1806	CD
18637	24540	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24540	5	,	,	,
18637	24540	6	601	601	CD
18637	24540	7	Strickley	Strickley	NNP
18637	24540	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24540	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24540	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24540	11	Highland	Highland	NNP
18637	24540	12	Boy	Boy	NNP
18637	24540	13	Gold	Gold	NNP
18637	24540	14	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	24540	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24540	16	,	,	,
18637	24540	17	200	200	CD
18637	24540	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24540	19	527	527	CD
18637	24540	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24540	21	1906	1906	CD
18637	24540	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24540	23	,	,	,
18637	24540	24	1065	1065	CD
18637	24540	25	Stroble	Stroble	NNP
18637	24540	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24540	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24540	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24540	29	California	California	NNP
18637	24540	30	,	,	,
18637	24540	31	343	343	CD
18637	24540	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24540	33	181	181	CD
18637	24540	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24540	35	1952	1952	CD
18637	24540	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24540	37	,	,	,
18637	24540	38	1121	1121	CD
18637	24540	39	Stromberg	Stromberg	NNP
18637	24540	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24540	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24540	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24540	43	California	California	NNP
18637	24540	44	,	,	,
18637	24540	45	283	283	CD
18637	24540	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24540	47	359	359	CD
18637	24540	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24540	49	1931	1931	CD
18637	24540	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24540	51	,	,	,
18637	24540	52	773	773	CD
18637	24540	53	,	,	,
18637	24540	54	778	778	CD
18637	24540	55	Strother	Strother	NNP
18637	24540	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24540	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24540	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24540	59	Lucas	Lucas	NNP
18637	24540	60	,	,	,
18637	24540	61	12	12	CD
18637	24540	62	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24540	63	.	.	.
18637	24541	1	410	410	CD
18637	24541	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24541	3	1838	1838	CD
18637	24541	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24541	5	,	,	,
18637	24541	6	418	418	CD
18637	24541	7	Stroud	Stroud	NNP
18637	24541	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24541	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24541	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24541	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24541	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24541	13	,	,	,
18637	24541	14	251	251	CD
18637	24541	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24541	16	15	15	CD
18637	24541	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24541	18	1919	1919	CD
18637	24541	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24541	20	,	,	,
18637	24541	21	824	824	CD
18637	24541	22	Stuart	Stuart	NNP
18637	24541	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24541	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24541	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24541	26	Laird	Laird	NNP
18637	24541	27	,	,	,
18637	24541	28	1	1	CD
18637	24541	29	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24541	30	.	.	.
18637	24542	1	299	299	CD
18637	24542	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24542	3	1803	1803	CD
18637	24542	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24542	5	,	,	,
18637	24542	6	529	529	CD
18637	24542	7	Sturges	Sturges	NNPS
18637	24542	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24542	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24542	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24542	11	Crowninshield	Crowninshield	NNP
18637	24542	12	,	,	,
18637	24542	13	4	4	CD
18637	24542	14	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24542	15	.	.	.
18637	24543	1	122	122	CD
18637	24543	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24543	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	24543	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24543	5	,	,	,
18637	24543	6	264	264	CD
18637	24543	7	,	,	,
18637	24543	8	334	334	CD
18637	24543	9	,	,	,
18637	24543	10	355	355	CD
18637	24543	11	,	,	,
18637	24543	12	555	555	CD
18637	24543	13	Sturges	Sturges	NNP
18637	24543	14	&	&	CC
18637	24543	15	B.	B.	NNP
18637	24543	16	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	24543	17	.	.	.
18637	24544	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24544	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24544	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24544	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24544	5	Beauchamp	Beauchamp	NNP
18637	24544	6	,	,	,
18637	24544	7	231	231	CD
18637	24544	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24544	9	320	320	CD
18637	24544	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24544	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	24544	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24544	13	,	,	,
18637	24544	14	987	987	CD
18637	24544	15	Sugarman	Sugarman	NNP
18637	24544	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24544	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24544	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24544	19	United	United	NNP
18637	24544	20	States	States	NNP
18637	24544	21	,	,	,
18637	24544	22	249	249	CD
18637	24544	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24544	24	182	182	CD
18637	24544	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24544	26	1919	1919	CD
18637	24544	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24544	28	,	,	,
18637	24544	29	297	297	CD
18637	24544	30	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	24544	31	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24544	32	Case	Case	NNP
18637	24544	33	,	,	,
18637	24544	34	The	the	DT
18637	24544	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24544	36	United	United	NNP
18637	24544	37	States	States	NNP
18637	24544	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24544	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24544	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24544	41	E.C.	E.C.	NNP
18637	24545	1	Knight	Knight	NNP
18637	24545	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24545	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24545	4	,	,	,
18637	24545	5	156	156	CD
18637	24545	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24545	7	1	1	CD
18637	24545	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24545	9	1895	1895	CD
18637	24545	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24545	11	,	,	,
18637	24545	12	153	153	CD
18637	24545	13	Sugg	Sugg	NNP
18637	24545	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24545	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24545	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24545	17	Hendrix	Hendrix	NNP
18637	24545	18	,	,	,
18637	24545	19	142	142	CD
18637	24545	20	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24545	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24545	22	2d	2d	NNP
18637	24545	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24545	24	740	740	CD
18637	24545	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24545	26	1944	1944	CD
18637	24545	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24545	28	,	,	,
18637	24545	29	1074	1074	CD
18637	24545	30	Sugg	Sugg	NNP
18637	24545	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24545	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24545	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24545	34	Thornton	Thornton	NNP
18637	24545	35	,	,	,
18637	24545	36	132	132	CD
18637	24545	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24545	38	524	524	CD
18637	24545	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24545	40	1889	1889	CD
18637	24545	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24545	42	,	,	,
18637	24545	43	1074	1074	CD
18637	24545	44	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
18637	24545	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24545	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	24545	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24545	48	Kidd	Kidd	NNP
18637	24545	49	,	,	,
18637	24545	50	254	254	CD
18637	24545	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24545	52	433	433	CD
18637	24545	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24545	54	1921	1921	CD
18637	24545	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24545	56	,	,	,
18637	24545	57	416	416	CD
18637	24545	58	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
18637	24545	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24545	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	24545	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24545	62	United	United	NNP
18637	24545	63	States	States	NNP
18637	24545	64	,	,	,
18637	24545	65	274	274	CD
18637	24545	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24545	67	259	259	CD
18637	24545	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24545	69	1950	1950	CD
18637	24545	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24545	71	,	,	,
18637	24545	72	843	843	CD
18637	24545	73	Sully	Sully	NNP
18637	24545	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24545	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	24545	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24545	77	American	American	NNP
18637	24545	78	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	24545	79	.	.	.
18637	24546	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24546	2	,	,	,
18637	24546	3	178	178	CD
18637	24546	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24546	5	289	289	CD
18637	24546	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24546	7	1900	1900	CD
18637	24546	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24546	9	,	,	,
18637	24546	10	1144	1144	CD
18637	24546	11	Sultan	Sultan	NNP
18637	24546	12	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	24546	13	.	.	.
18637	24547	1	&	&	CC
18637	24547	2	Timber	Timber	NNP
18637	24547	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24547	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24547	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	24547	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24547	7	Dept	Dept	NNP
18637	24547	8	.	.	.
18637	24548	1	of	of	IN
18637	24548	2	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24548	3	,	,	,
18637	24548	4	277	277	CD
18637	24548	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24548	6	135	135	CD
18637	24548	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24548	8	1928	1928	CD
18637	24548	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24548	10	,	,	,
18637	24548	11	582	582	CD
18637	24548	12	Summers	summer	NNS
18637	24548	13	,	,	,
18637	24548	14	In	in	IN
18637	24548	15	re	re	NN
18637	24548	16	,	,	,
18637	24548	17	325	325	CD
18637	24548	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24548	19	561	561	CD
18637	24548	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24548	21	1945	1945	CD
18637	24548	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24548	23	,	,	,
18637	24548	24	768	768	CD
18637	24548	25	Sunday	Sunday	NNP
18637	24548	26	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	24548	27	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	24548	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24548	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24548	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24548	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24548	32	Wakefield	Wakefield	NNP
18637	24548	33	Twp	Twp	NNP
18637	24548	34	.	.	NNP
18637	24548	35	,	,	,
18637	24548	36	247	247	CD
18637	24548	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24548	38	350	350	CD
18637	24548	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24548	40	1918	1918	CD
18637	24548	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24548	42	,	,	,
18637	24548	43	1152	1152	CD
18637	24548	44	Sunshine	Sunshine	NNP
18637	24548	45	Anthracite	Anthracite	NNP
18637	24548	46	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	24548	47	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24548	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24548	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	24548	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24548	51	Adkins	Adkins	NNP
18637	24548	52	,	,	,
18637	24548	53	310	310	CD
18637	24548	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24548	55	381	381	CD
18637	24548	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24548	57	1940	1940	CD
18637	24548	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24548	59	,	,	,
18637	24548	60	75	75	CD
18637	24548	61	,	,	,
18637	24548	62	76	76	CD
18637	24548	63	,	,	,
18637	24548	64	111	111	CD
18637	24548	65	,	,	,
18637	24548	66	564	564	CD
18637	24548	67	,	,	,
18637	24548	68	853	853	CD
18637	24548	69	,	,	,
18637	24548	70	855	855	CD
18637	24548	71	Superintendent	Superintendent	NNP
18637	24548	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24548	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	24548	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24548	75	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
18637	24548	76	,	,	,
18637	24548	77	295	295	CD
18637	24548	78	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24548	79	418	418	CD
18637	24548	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24548	81	1935	1935	CD
18637	24548	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24548	83	,	,	,
18637	24548	84	1171	1171	CD
18637	24548	85	Superior	Superior	NNP
18637	24548	86	Bath	Bath	NNP
18637	24548	87	House	House	NNP
18637	24548	88	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24548	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24548	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	24548	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24548	92	McCarroll	McCarroll	NNP
18637	24548	93	,	,	,
18637	24548	94	312	312	CD
18637	24548	95	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24548	96	176	176	CD
18637	24548	97	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24548	98	1941	1941	CD
18637	24548	99	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24548	100	,	,	,
18637	24548	101	731	731	CD
18637	24548	102	Superior	Superior	NNP
18637	24548	103	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24548	104	_	_	NNP
18637	24548	105	v.	v.	IN
18637	24548	106	_	_	NNP
18637	24548	107	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	24548	108	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24548	109	rel	rel	NN
18637	24548	110	.	.	.
18637	24549	1	Knox	Knox	NNP
18637	24549	2	,	,	,
18637	24549	3	280	280	CD
18637	24549	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24549	5	390	390	CD
18637	24549	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24549	7	1930	1930	CD
18637	24549	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24549	9	,	,	,
18637	24549	10	189	189	CD
18637	24549	11	Surplus	Surplus	NNP
18637	24549	12	Trading	Trading	NNP
18637	24549	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24549	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24549	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24549	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24549	17	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	24549	18	,	,	,
18637	24549	19	281	281	CD
18637	24549	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24549	21	647	647	CD
18637	24549	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24549	23	1930	1930	CD
18637	24549	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24549	25	,	,	,
18637	24549	26	305	305	CD
18637	24549	27	,	,	,
18637	24549	28	307	307	CD
18637	24549	29	Susquehanna	Susquehanna	NNP
18637	24549	30	&	&	CC
18637	24549	31	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
18637	24549	32	V.R.	V.R.	NNP
18637	24550	1	&	&	CC
18637	24550	2	C.	C.	NNP
18637	24550	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24550	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24550	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	24550	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24550	7	Blatchford	Blatchford	NNP
18637	24550	8	,	,	,
18637	24550	9	11	11	CD
18637	24550	10	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24550	11	.	.	.
18637	24551	1	172	172	CD
18637	24551	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24551	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24551	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24551	5	,	,	,
18637	24551	6	611	611	CD
18637	24551	7	Susquehanna	Susquehanna	NNP
18637	24551	8	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	24551	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24551	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24551	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	13	South	South	NNP
18637	24551	14	Amboy	Amboy	NNP
18637	24551	15	,	,	,
18637	24551	16	228	228	CD
18637	24551	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24551	18	665	665	CD
18637	24551	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24551	20	1913	1913	CD
18637	24551	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24551	22	,	,	,
18637	24551	23	185	185	CD
18637	24551	24	Susquehanna	Susquehanna	NNP
18637	24551	25	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24551	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24551	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24551	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	30	State	State	NNP
18637	24551	31	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24551	32	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	24551	33	.	.	.
18637	24551	34	,	,	,
18637	24551	35	283	283	CD
18637	24551	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24551	37	291	291	CD
18637	24551	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24551	39	1931	1931	CD
18637	24551	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24551	41	,	,	,
18637	24551	42	732	732	CD
18637	24551	43	Sutton	Sutton	NNP
18637	24551	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24551	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	47	Leib	Leib	NNP
18637	24551	48	,	,	,
18637	24551	49	342	342	CD
18637	24551	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24551	51	402	402	CD
18637	24551	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24551	53	1952	1952	CD
18637	24551	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24551	55	,	,	,
18637	24551	56	671	671	CD
18637	24551	57	Swafford	Swafford	NNP
18637	24551	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24551	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	61	Templeton	Templeton	NNP
18637	24551	62	,	,	,
18637	24551	63	185	185	CD
18637	24551	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24551	65	487	487	CD
18637	24551	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24551	67	1902	1902	CD
18637	24551	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24551	69	,	,	,
18637	24551	70	87	87	CD
18637	24551	71	Swaim	Swaim	NNP
18637	24551	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	24551	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	75	United	United	NNP
18637	24551	76	States	States	NNP
18637	24551	77	,	,	,
18637	24551	78	165	165	CD
18637	24551	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24551	80	553	553	CD
18637	24551	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24551	82	1897	1897	CD
18637	24551	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24551	84	,	,	,
18637	24551	85	286	286	CD
18637	24551	86	,	,	,
18637	24551	87	404	404	CD
18637	24551	88	Swanson	Swanson	NNP
18637	24551	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	24551	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	92	Marra	Marra	NNP
18637	24551	93	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	24551	94	,	,	,
18637	24551	95	328	328	CD
18637	24551	96	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24551	97	1	1	CD
18637	24551	98	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24551	99	1946	1946	CD
18637	24551	100	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24551	101	,	,	,
18637	24551	102	583	583	CD
18637	24551	103	Sweatt	Sweatt	NNP
18637	24551	104	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	105	v.	v.	IN
18637	24551	106	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	107	Painter	Painter	NNP
18637	24551	108	,	,	,
18637	24551	109	339	339	CD
18637	24551	110	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24551	111	629	629	CD
18637	24551	112	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24551	113	1950	1950	CD
18637	24551	114	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24551	115	,	,	,
18637	24551	116	1162	1162	CD
18637	24551	117	Sweet	Sweet	NNP
18637	24551	118	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	24551	120	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	121	Rechel	Rechel	NNP
18637	24551	122	,	,	,
18637	24551	123	159	159	CD
18637	24551	124	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24551	125	380	380	CD
18637	24551	126	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24551	127	1895	1895	CD
18637	24551	128	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24551	129	,	,	,
18637	24551	130	1063	1063	CD
18637	24551	131	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	24551	132	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	133	v.	v.	IN
18637	24551	134	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	135	McPherson	McPherson	NNP
18637	24551	136	,	,	,
18637	24551	137	232	232	CD
18637	24551	138	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24551	139	51	51	CD
18637	24551	140	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24551	141	1914	1914	CD
18637	24551	142	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24551	143	,	,	,
18637	24551	144	656	656	CD
18637	24551	145	,	,	,
18637	24551	146	684	684	CD
18637	24551	147	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	24551	148	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	149	v.	v.	IN
18637	24551	150	_	_	NNP
18637	24551	151	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	24551	152	,	,	,
18637	24551	153	16	16	CD
18637	24551	154	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24551	155	.	.	.
18637	24552	1	1	1	CD
18637	24552	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24552	3	1842	1842	CD
18637	24552	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24552	5	,	,	,
18637	24552	6	603	603	CD
18637	24552	7	,	,	,
18637	24552	8	604	604	CD
18637	24552	9	,	,	,
18637	24552	10	605	605	CD
18637	24552	11	,	,	,
18637	24552	12	606	606	CD
18637	24552	13	,	,	,
18637	24552	14	607	607	CD
18637	24552	15	Swift	Swift	NNP
18637	24552	16	&	&	CC
18637	24552	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24552	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24552	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24552	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24552	21	United	United	NNP
18637	24552	22	States	States	NNP
18637	24552	23	,	,	,
18637	24552	24	196	196	CD
18637	24552	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24552	26	375	375	CD
18637	24552	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24552	28	1905	1905	CD
18637	24552	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24552	30	,	,	,
18637	24552	31	120	120	CD
18637	24552	32	,	,	,
18637	24552	33	147	147	CD
18637	24552	34	,	,	,
18637	24552	35	148	148	CD
18637	24552	36	T	t	NN
18637	24552	37	Taft	Taft	NNP
18637	24552	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24552	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24552	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24552	41	Bowers	Bowers	NNP
18637	24552	42	,	,	,
18637	24552	43	278	278	CD
18637	24552	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24552	45	470	470	CD
18637	24552	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24552	47	1929	1929	CD
18637	24552	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24552	49	,	,	,
18637	24552	50	1198	1198	CD
18637	24552	51	Takahashi	Takahashi	NNP
18637	24552	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24552	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	24552	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24552	55	Fish	Fish	NNP
18637	24552	56	&	&	CC
18637	24552	57	Game	Game	NNP
18637	24552	58	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	24552	59	.	.	NNP
18637	24552	60	,	,	,
18637	24552	61	334	334	CD
18637	24552	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24552	63	410	410	CD
18637	24552	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24552	65	1948	1948	CD
18637	24552	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24552	67	,	,	,
18637	24552	68	417	417	CD
18637	24552	69	,	,	,
18637	24552	70	1158	1158	CD
18637	24552	71	Tameling	Tameling	NNP
18637	24552	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24552	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	24552	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24552	75	United	United	NNP
18637	24552	76	States	States	NNP
18637	24552	77	Freehold	Freehold	NNP
18637	24552	78	&	&	CC
18637	24552	79	Emigration	Emigration	NNP
18637	24552	80	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24552	81	,	,	,
18637	24552	82	93	93	CD
18637	24552	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24552	84	644	644	CD
18637	24552	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24552	86	1877	1877	CD
18637	24552	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24552	88	,	,	,
18637	24552	89	702	702	CD
18637	24552	90	Tanner	Tanner	NNP
18637	24552	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24552	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	24552	93	_	_	NNP
18637	24552	94	Little	Little	NNP
18637	24552	95	,	,	,
18637	24552	96	240	240	CD
18637	24552	97	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24552	98	369	369	CD
18637	24552	99	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24552	100	1916	1916	CD
18637	24552	101	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24552	102	,	,	,
18637	24552	103	184	184	CD
18637	24552	104	,	,	,
18637	24552	105	1019	1019	CD
18637	24552	106	Tayloe	Tayloe	NNP
18637	24552	107	_	_	NNP
18637	24552	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	24552	109	_	_	NNP
18637	24552	110	Thomson	Thomson	NNP
18637	24552	111	,	,	,
18637	24552	112	5	5	CD
18637	24552	113	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24552	114	.	.	.
18637	24553	1	358	358	CD
18637	24553	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24553	3	1831	1831	CD
18637	24553	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24553	5	,	,	,
18637	24553	6	302	302	CD
18637	24553	7	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24553	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24553	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24553	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24553	11	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	24553	12	,	,	,
18637	24553	13	335	335	CD
18637	24553	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24553	15	252	252	CD
18637	24553	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24553	17	1948	1948	CD
18637	24553	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24553	19	,	,	,
18637	24553	20	1119	1119	CD
18637	24553	21	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24553	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24553	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24553	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24553	25	Beckham	Beckham	NNP
18637	24553	26	,	,	,
18637	24553	27	178	178	CD
18637	24553	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24553	29	548	548	CD
18637	24553	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24553	31	1900	1900	CD
18637	24553	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24553	33	,	,	,
18637	24553	34	705	705	CD
18637	24553	35	,	,	,
18637	24553	36	982	982	CD
18637	24553	37	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24553	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24553	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24553	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24553	41	Carryl	Carryl	NNP
18637	24553	42	,	,	,
18637	24553	43	20	20	CD
18637	24553	44	How	how	WRB
18637	24553	45	.	.	.
18637	24554	1	583	583	CD
18637	24554	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24554	3	1857	1857	CD
18637	24554	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24554	5	,	,	,
18637	24554	6	575	575	CD
18637	24554	7	,	,	,
18637	24554	8	625	625	CD
18637	24554	9	,	,	,
18637	24554	10	627	627	CD
18637	24554	11	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24554	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24554	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24554	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24554	15	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	24554	16	,	,	,
18637	24554	17	315	315	CD
18637	24554	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24554	19	25	25	CD
18637	24554	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24554	21	1942	1942	CD
18637	24554	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24554	23	,	,	,
18637	24554	24	951	951	CD
18637	24554	25	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24554	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24554	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24554	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24554	29	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	24554	30	,	,	,
18637	24554	31	319	319	CD
18637	24554	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24554	33	583	583	CD
18637	24554	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24554	35	1943	1943	CD
18637	24554	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24554	37	,	,	,
18637	24554	38	768	768	CD
18637	24554	39	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24554	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24554	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24554	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24554	43	Morton	Morton	NNP
18637	24554	44	,	,	,
18637	24554	45	23	23	CD
18637	24554	46	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24554	47	.	.	.
18637	24555	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24555	2	.	.	.
18637	24556	1	No	no	UH
18637	24556	2	.	.	.
18637	24557	1	13,799	13,799	CD
18637	24557	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24557	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	24557	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24557	5	,	,	,
18637	24557	6	420	420	CD
18637	24557	7	,	,	,
18637	24557	8	426	426	CD
18637	24557	9	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24557	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24557	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24557	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24557	13	Secor	Secor	NNP
18637	24557	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24557	15	State	State	NNP
18637	24557	16	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24557	17	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24557	18	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	24557	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24557	20	,	,	,
18637	24557	21	92	92	CD
18637	24557	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24557	23	575	575	CD
18637	24557	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24557	25	1876	1876	CD
18637	24557	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24557	27	,	,	,
18637	24557	28	1058	1058	CD
18637	24557	29	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24557	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24557	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24557	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24557	33	Taintor	Taintor	NNP
18637	24557	34	,	,	,
18637	24557	35	16	16	CD
18637	24557	36	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24557	37	.	.	.
18637	24558	1	366	366	CD
18637	24558	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24558	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	24558	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24558	5	,	,	,
18637	24558	6	694	694	CD
18637	24558	7	,	,	,
18637	24558	8	695	695	CD
18637	24558	9	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24558	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24558	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24558	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24558	13	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	24558	14	,	,	,
18637	24558	15	22	22	CD
18637	24558	16	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24558	17	.	.	.
18637	24559	1	479	479	CD
18637	24559	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24559	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	24559	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24559	5	,	,	,
18637	24559	6	728	728	CD
18637	24559	7	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24559	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24559	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24559	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24559	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24559	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24559	13	,	,	,
18637	24559	14	207	207	CD
18637	24559	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24559	16	120	120	CD
18637	24559	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24559	18	1907	1907	CD
18637	24559	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24559	20	,	,	,
18637	24559	21	839	839	CD
18637	24559	22	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24559	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24559	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24559	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24559	26	United	United	NNP
18637	24559	27	States	States	NNP
18637	24559	28	,	,	,
18637	24559	29	286	286	CD
18637	24559	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24559	31	1	1	CD
18637	24559	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24559	33	1932	1932	CD
18637	24559	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24559	35	,	,	,
18637	24559	36	824	824	CD
18637	24559	37	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24559	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24559	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24559	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24559	41	Ypsilanti	Ypsilanti	NNP
18637	24559	42	,	,	,
18637	24559	43	105	105	CD
18637	24559	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24559	45	60	60	CD
18637	24559	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24559	47	1882	1882	CD
18637	24559	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24559	49	,	,	,
18637	24559	50	331	331	CD
18637	24559	51	Teal	Teal	NNP
18637	24559	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24559	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	24559	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24559	55	Felton	Felton	NNP
18637	24559	56	,	,	,
18637	24559	57	12	12	CD
18637	24559	58	How	how	WRB
18637	24559	59	.	.	.
18637	24560	1	284	284	CD
18637	24560	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24560	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	24560	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24560	5	,	,	,
18637	24560	6	636	636	CD
18637	24560	7	Teamsters	Teamsters	NNPS
18637	24560	8	'	'	POS
18637	24560	9	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24560	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24560	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	13	Hanke	Hanke	NNP
18637	24560	14	,	,	,
18637	24560	15	339	339	CD
18637	24560	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24560	17	470	470	CD
18637	24560	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24560	19	1950	1950	CD
18637	24560	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24560	21	,	,	,
18637	24560	22	782	782	CD
18637	24560	23	Ten	ten	CD
18637	24560	24	East	East	NNP
18637	24560	25	Fortieth	Fortieth	NNP
18637	24560	26	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24560	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24560	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24560	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	31	Callus	Callus	NNP
18637	24560	32	,	,	,
18637	24560	33	325	325	CD
18637	24560	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24560	35	578	578	CD
18637	24560	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24560	37	1945	1945	CD
18637	24560	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24560	39	,	,	,
18637	24560	40	158	158	CD
18637	24560	41	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	24560	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24560	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	45	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	24560	46	,	,	,
18637	24560	47	100	100	CD
18637	24560	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24560	49	257	257	CD
18637	24560	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24560	51	1880	1880	CD
18637	24560	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24560	53	,	,	,
18637	24560	54	311	311	CD
18637	24560	55	,	,	,
18637	24560	56	501	501	CD
18637	24560	57	,	,	,
18637	24560	58	569	569	CD
18637	24560	59	,	,	,
18637	24560	60	632	632	CD
18637	24560	61	,	,	,
18637	24560	62	722	722	CD
18637	24560	63	,	,	,
18637	24560	64	728	728	CD
18637	24560	65	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	24560	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	24560	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	69	Sneed	Sneed	NNP
18637	24560	70	,	,	,
18637	24560	71	96	96	CD
18637	24560	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24560	73	69	69	CD
18637	24560	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24560	75	1877	1877	CD
18637	24560	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24560	77	,	,	,
18637	24560	78	355	355	CD
18637	24560	79	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	24560	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	24560	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	83	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24560	84	&	&	CC
18637	24560	85	Planters	Planters	NNPS
18637	24560	86	'	'	POS
18637	24560	87	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24560	88	,	,	,
18637	24560	89	152	152	CD
18637	24560	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24560	91	454	454	CD
18637	24560	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24560	93	1894	1894	CD
18637	24560	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24560	95	,	,	,
18637	24560	96	567	567	CD
18637	24560	97	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	24560	98	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	99	v.	v.	IN
18637	24560	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	101	Whitworth	Whitworth	NNP
18637	24560	102	,	,	,
18637	24560	103	117	117	CD
18637	24560	104	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24560	105	139	139	CD
18637	24560	106	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24560	107	1886	1886	CD
18637	24560	108	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24560	109	,	,	,
18637	24560	110	347	347	CD
18637	24560	111	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	24560	112	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	24560	113	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24560	114	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	115	v.	v.	IN
18637	24560	116	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	117	George	George	NNP
18637	24560	118	,	,	,
18637	24560	119	233	233	CD
18637	24560	120	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24560	121	354	354	CD
18637	24560	122	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24560	123	1914	1914	CD
18637	24560	124	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24560	125	,	,	,
18637	24560	126	677	677	CD
18637	24560	127	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	24560	128	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	24560	129	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24560	130	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24560	131	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	132	v.	v.	IN
18637	24560	133	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	134	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	24560	135	Valley	Valley	NNP
18637	24560	136	Authority	Authority	NNP
18637	24560	137	,	,	,
18637	24560	138	306	306	CD
18637	24560	139	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24560	140	118	118	CD
18637	24560	141	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24560	142	1939	1939	CD
18637	24560	143	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24560	144	590	590	CD
18637	24560	145	,	,	,
18637	24560	146	909	909	CD
18637	24560	147	Tenney	Tenney	NNP
18637	24560	148	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	149	v.	v.	IN
18637	24560	150	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	151	Brandhove	Brandhove	NNP
18637	24560	152	,	,	,
18637	24560	153	341	341	CD
18637	24560	154	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24560	155	367	367	CD
18637	24560	156	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24560	157	1951	1951	CD
18637	24560	158	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24560	159	,	,	,
18637	24560	160	100	100	CD
18637	24560	161	Terlinden	Terlinden	NNP
18637	24560	162	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	163	v.	v.	IN
18637	24560	164	_	_	NNP
18637	24560	165	Ames	Ames	NNP
18637	24560	166	,	,	,
18637	24560	167	184	184	CD
18637	24560	168	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24560	169	270	270	CD
18637	24560	170	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24560	171	1902	1902	CD
18637	24560	172	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24560	173	,	,	,
18637	24560	174	473	473	CD
18637	24560	175	Terminal	Terminal	NNP
18637	24560	176	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24560	177	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	24560	178	.	.	.
18637	24561	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24561	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24561	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24561	4	Brotherhood	Brotherhood	NNP
18637	24561	5	of	of	IN
18637	24561	6	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	24562	1	Trainmen	trainman	NNS
18637	24562	2	,	,	,
18637	24562	3	318	318	CD
18637	24562	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24562	5	1	1	CD
18637	24562	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24562	7	1943	1943	CD
18637	24562	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24562	9	,	,	,
18637	24562	10	219	219	CD
18637	24562	11	,	,	,
18637	24562	12	220	220	CD
18637	24562	13	,	,	,
18637	24562	14	223	223	CD
18637	24562	15	Terminiello	Terminiello	NNP
18637	24562	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24562	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24562	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24562	19	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	24562	20	,	,	,
18637	24562	21	337	337	CD
18637	24562	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24562	23	1	1	CD
18637	24562	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24562	25	1949	1949	CD
18637	24562	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24562	27	,	,	,
18637	24562	28	778	778	CD
18637	24562	29	,	,	,
18637	24562	30	792	792	CD
18637	24562	31	Terrace	Terrace	NNP
18637	24562	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24562	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	24562	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24562	35	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24562	36	,	,	,
18637	24562	37	263	263	CD
18637	24562	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24562	39	197	197	CD
18637	24562	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24562	41	1923	1923	CD
18637	24562	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24562	43	,	,	,
18637	24562	44	417	417	CD
18637	24562	45	,	,	,
18637	24562	46	934	934	CD
18637	24562	47	,	,	,
18637	24562	48	981	981	CD
18637	24562	49	,	,	,
18637	24562	50	1158	1158	CD
18637	24562	51	Terral	Terral	NNP
18637	24562	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24562	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	24562	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24562	55	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	24562	56	Construction	Construction	NNP
18637	24562	57	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24562	58	,	,	,
18637	24562	59	257	257	CD
18637	24562	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24562	61	529	529	CD
18637	24562	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24562	63	1922	1922	CD
18637	24562	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24562	65	,	,	,
18637	24562	66	638	638	CD
18637	24562	67	Terrett	Terrett	NNP
18637	24562	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24562	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	24562	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24562	71	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
18637	24562	72	,	,	,
18637	24562	73	9	9	CD
18637	24562	74	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24562	75	.	.	.
18637	24563	1	43	43	CD
18637	24563	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24563	3	1815	1815	CD
18637	24563	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24563	5	,	,	,
18637	24563	6	338	338	CD
18637	24563	7	Terry	Terry	NNP
18637	24563	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24563	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24563	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24563	11	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	24563	12	,	,	,
18637	24563	13	95	95	CD
18637	24563	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24563	15	628	628	CD
18637	24563	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24563	17	1877	1877	CD
18637	24563	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24563	19	,	,	,
18637	24563	20	355	355	CD
18637	24563	21	Testa	Testa	NNP
18637	24563	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24563	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24563	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24563	25	Katt	Katt	NNP
18637	24563	26	,	,	,
18637	24563	27	330	330	CD
18637	24563	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24563	29	386	386	CD
18637	24563	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24563	31	1947	1947	CD
18637	24563	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24563	33	,	,	,
18637	24563	34	637	637	CD
18637	24563	35	,	,	,
18637	24563	36	724	724	CD
18637	24563	37	,	,	,
18637	24563	38	727	727	CD
18637	24563	39	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24563	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24563	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24563	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24563	43	Florida	Florida	NNP
18637	24563	44	,	,	,
18637	24563	45	306	306	CD
18637	24563	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24563	47	398	398	CD
18637	24563	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24563	49	1939	1939	CD
18637	24563	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24563	51	,	,	,
18637	24563	52	593	593	CD
18637	24563	53	,	,	,
18637	24563	54	594	594	CD
18637	24563	55	,	,	,
18637	24563	56	1049	1049	CD
18637	24563	57	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24563	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24563	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24563	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24563	61	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	24563	62	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24563	63	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24563	64	,	,	,
18637	24563	65	258	258	CD
18637	24563	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24563	67	158	158	CD
18637	24563	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24563	69	1922	1922	CD
18637	24563	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24563	71	,	,	,
18637	24563	72	544	544	CD
18637	24563	73	,	,	,
18637	24563	74	613	613	CD
18637	24563	75	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24563	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24563	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	24563	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24563	79	White	White	NNP
18637	24563	80	,	,	,
18637	24563	81	7	7	CD
18637	24563	82	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24563	83	.	.	.
18637	24564	1	700	700	CD
18637	24564	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24564	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24564	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24564	5	,	,	,
18637	24564	6	299	299	CD
18637	24564	7	,	,	,
18637	24564	8	704	704	CD
18637	24564	9	,	,	,
18637	24564	10	728	728	CD
18637	24564	11	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24564	12	&	&	CC
18637	24564	13	N.O.R.	N.O.R.	NNP
18637	24565	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24565	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24565	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24565	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24565	5	Brotherhood	Brotherhood	NNP
18637	24565	6	of	of	IN
18637	24565	7	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	24565	8	&	&	CC
18637	24565	9	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	24565	10	Clerks	Clerks	NNP
18637	24565	11	,	,	,
18637	24565	12	281	281	CD
18637	24565	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24565	14	548	548	CD
18637	24565	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24565	16	1930	1930	CD
18637	24565	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24565	18	,	,	,
18637	24565	19	142	142	CD
18637	24565	20	,	,	,
18637	24565	21	855	855	CD
18637	24565	22	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24565	23	&	&	CC
18637	24565	24	N.O.R.	N.O.R.	NNP
18637	24566	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24566	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24566	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24566	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24566	5	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24566	6	,	,	,
18637	24566	7	221	221	CD
18637	24566	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24566	9	408	408	CD
18637	24566	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24566	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	24566	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24566	13	,	,	,
18637	24566	14	676	676	CD
18637	24566	15	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24566	16	&	&	CC
18637	24566	17	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24567	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24567	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24567	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24567	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24567	5	Rigsby	Rigsby	NNP
18637	24567	6	,	,	,
18637	24567	7	241	241	CD
18637	24567	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24567	9	33	33	CD
18637	24567	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24567	11	1916	1916	CD
18637	24567	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24567	13	,	,	,
18637	24567	14	139	139	CD
18637	24567	15	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24567	16	&	&	CC
18637	24567	17	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24568	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24568	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24568	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24568	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24568	5	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24568	6	P.	P.	NNP
18637	24568	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24568	8	,	,	,
18637	24568	9	137	137	CD
18637	24568	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24568	11	48	48	CD
18637	24568	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24568	13	1890	1890	CD
18637	24568	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24568	15	,	,	,
18637	24568	16	656	656	CD
18637	24568	17	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24568	18	&	&	CC
18637	24568	19	P.	P.	NNP
18637	24568	20	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	24568	21	.	.	.
18637	24569	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24569	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24569	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24569	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24569	5	United	United	NNP
18637	24569	6	States	States	NNP
18637	24569	7	,	,	,
18637	24569	8	286	286	CD
18637	24569	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24569	10	285	285	CD
18637	24569	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24569	12	1932	1932	CD
18637	24569	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24569	14	,	,	,
18637	24569	15	1197	1197	CD
18637	24569	16	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24569	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24569	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24569	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	24569	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24569	21	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	24569	22	,	,	,
18637	24569	23	258	258	CD
18637	24569	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24569	25	466	466	CD
18637	24569	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24569	27	1922	1922	CD
18637	24569	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24569	29	,	,	,
18637	24569	30	184	184	CD
18637	24569	31	,	,	,
18637	24569	32	239	239	CD
18637	24569	33	Thames	Thames	NNP
18637	24569	34	&	&	CC
18637	24569	35	Mersey	Mersey	NNP
18637	24569	36	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24569	37	.	.	.
18637	24570	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24570	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24570	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24570	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24570	5	United	United	NNP
18637	24570	6	States	States	NNP
18637	24570	7	,	,	,
18637	24570	8	237	237	CD
18637	24570	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24570	10	19	19	CD
18637	24570	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24570	12	1915	1915	CD
18637	24570	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24570	14	,	,	,
18637	24570	15	322	322	CD
18637	24570	16	Thiel	Thiel	NNP
18637	24570	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24570	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24570	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24570	20	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24570	21	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24570	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24570	23	,	,	,
18637	24570	24	328	328	CD
18637	24570	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24570	26	217	217	CD
18637	24570	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24570	28	1946	1946	CD
18637	24570	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24570	30	,	,	,
18637	24570	31	854	854	CD
18637	24570	32	,	,	,
18637	24570	33	1131	1131	CD
18637	24570	34	Thirty	thirty	CD
18637	24570	35	Hogsheads	Hogsheads	NNPS
18637	24570	36	of	of	IN
18637	24570	37	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	24570	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24570	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24570	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24570	41	Boyle	Boyle	NNP
18637	24570	42	,	,	,
18637	24570	43	9	9	CD
18637	24570	44	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24570	45	.	.	.
18637	24571	1	191	191	CD
18637	24571	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24571	3	1815	1815	CD
18637	24571	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24571	5	,	,	,
18637	24571	6	575	575	CD
18637	24571	7	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	24571	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24571	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24571	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24571	11	Collins	Collins	NNP
18637	24571	12	,	,	,
18637	24571	13	323	323	CD
18637	24571	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24571	15	516	516	CD
18637	24571	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24571	17	1945	1945	CD
18637	24571	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24571	19	,	,	,
18637	24571	20	563	563	CD
18637	24571	21	,	,	,
18637	24571	22	783	783	CD
18637	24571	23	,	,	,
18637	24571	24	788	788	CD
18637	24571	25	,	,	,
18637	24571	26	789	789	CD
18637	24571	27	,	,	,
18637	24571	28	809	809	CD
18637	24571	29	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	24571	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24571	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24571	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24571	33	Gay	Gay	NNP
18637	24571	34	,	,	,
18637	24571	35	169	169	CD
18637	24571	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24571	37	264	264	CD
18637	24571	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24571	39	1898	1898	CD
18637	24571	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24571	41	,	,	,
18637	24571	42	432	432	CD
18637	24571	43	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	24571	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24571	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24571	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24571	47	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24571	48	City	City	NNP
18637	24571	49	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24571	50	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24571	51	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24571	52	,	,	,
18637	24571	53	261	261	CD
18637	24571	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24571	55	481	481	CD
18637	24571	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24571	57	1923	1923	CD
18637	24571	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24571	59	,	,	,
18637	24571	60	1153	1153	CD
18637	24571	61	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	24571	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24571	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	24571	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24571	65	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	24571	66	,	,	,
18637	24571	67	12	12	CD
18637	24571	68	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24571	69	.	.	.
18637	24572	1	349	349	CD
18637	24572	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24572	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24572	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24572	5	,	,	,
18637	24572	6	728	728	CD
18637	24572	7	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	24572	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24572	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24572	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24572	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24572	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24572	13	,	,	,
18637	24572	14	192	192	CD
18637	24572	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24572	16	363	363	CD
18637	24572	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24572	18	1904	1904	CD
18637	24572	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24572	20	,	,	,
18637	24572	21	319	319	CD
18637	24572	22	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	24572	23	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	24572	24	,	,	,
18637	24572	25	The	the	DT
18637	24572	26	,	,	,
18637	24572	27	10	10	CD
18637	24572	28	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24572	29	.	.	.
18637	24573	1	428	428	CD
18637	24573	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24573	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	24573	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24573	5	,	,	,
18637	24573	6	576	576	CD
18637	24573	7	,	,	,
18637	24573	8	578	578	CD
18637	24573	9	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24573	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24573	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24573	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24573	13	Central	Central	NNP
18637	24573	14	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24573	15	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24573	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24573	17	,	,	,
18637	24573	18	6	6	CD
18637	24573	19	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24573	20	.	.	.
18637	24574	1	134	134	CD
18637	24574	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24574	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	24574	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24574	5	,	,	,
18637	24574	6	895	895	CD
18637	24574	7	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24574	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24574	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24574	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24574	11	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	24574	12	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24574	13	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	24574	14	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24574	15	,	,	,
18637	24574	16	300	300	CD
18637	24574	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24574	18	55	55	CD
18637	24574	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24574	20	1937	1937	CD
18637	24574	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24574	22	,	,	,
18637	24574	23	1025	1025	CD
18637	24574	24	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24574	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24574	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24574	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24574	28	Darden	Darden	NNP
18637	24574	29	,	,	,
18637	24574	30	198	198	CD
18637	24574	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24574	32	310	310	CD
18637	24574	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24574	34	1905	1905	CD
18637	24574	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24574	36	,	,	,
18637	24574	37	323	323	NNP
18637	24574	38	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24574	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24574	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24574	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24574	42	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	24574	43	County	County	NNP
18637	24574	44	,	,	,
18637	24574	45	3	3	CD
18637	24574	46	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24574	47	.	.	.
18637	24575	1	327	327	CD
18637	24575	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24575	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	24575	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24575	5	,	,	,
18637	24575	6	331	331	CD
18637	24575	7	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24575	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24575	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24575	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24575	11	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24575	12	,	,	,
18637	24575	13	171	171	CD
18637	24575	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24575	15	380	380	CD
18637	24575	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24575	17	1898	1898	CD
18637	24575	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24575	19	,	,	,
18637	24575	20	329	329	CD
18637	24575	21	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24575	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24575	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24575	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24575	25	Roe	Roe	NNP
18637	24575	26	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24575	27	dem	dem	NNP
18637	24575	28	.	.	.
18637	24576	1	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
18637	24576	2	,	,	,
18637	24576	3	22	22	CD
18637	24576	4	How	how	WRB
18637	24576	5	.	.	.
18637	24577	1	422	422	CD
18637	24577	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24577	3	1860	1860	CD
18637	24577	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24577	5	,	,	,
18637	24577	6	304	304	CD
18637	24577	7	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24577	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24577	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24577	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24577	11	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24577	12	,	,	,
18637	24577	13	226	226	CD
18637	24577	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24577	15	551	551	CD
18637	24577	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24577	17	1913	1913	CD
18637	24577	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24577	19	,	,	,
18637	24577	20	657	657	CD
18637	24577	21	,	,	,
18637	24577	22	663	663	CD
18637	24577	23	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24577	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24577	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24577	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24577	27	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24577	28	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24578	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24578	2	,	,	,
18637	24578	3	9	9	CD
18637	24578	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24578	5	.	.	.
18637	24579	1	579	579	CD
18637	24579	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24579	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	24579	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24579	5	,	,	,
18637	24579	6	732	732	CD
18637	24579	7	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24579	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24579	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24579	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24579	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24579	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24579	13	,	,	,
18637	24579	14	142	142	CD
18637	24579	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24579	16	471	471	CD
18637	24579	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24579	18	1892	1892	CD
18637	24579	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24579	20	,	,	,
18637	24579	21	321	321	CD
18637	24579	22	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24579	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24579	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24579	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24579	26	United	United	NNP
18637	24579	27	States	States	NNP
18637	24579	28	,	,	,
18637	24579	29	155	155	CD
18637	24579	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24579	31	271	271	CD
18637	24579	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24579	33	1894	1894	CD
18637	24579	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24579	35	,	,	,
18637	24579	36	839	839	CD
18637	24579	37	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24579	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24579	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24579	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24579	41	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	24579	42	,	,	,
18637	24579	43	170	170	CD
18637	24579	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24579	45	343	343	CD
18637	24579	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24579	47	1898	1898	CD
18637	24579	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24579	49	,	,	,
18637	24579	50	329	329	CD
18637	24579	51	,	,	,
18637	24579	52	879	879	CD
18637	24579	53	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
18637	24579	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24579	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	24579	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24579	57	Whitman	Whitman	NNP
18637	24579	58	,	,	,
18637	24579	59	18	18	CD
18637	24579	60	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24579	61	.	.	.
18637	24580	1	457	457	CD
18637	24580	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24580	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	24580	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24580	5	,	,	,
18637	24580	6	661	661	CD
18637	24580	7	Thomson	Thomson	NNP
18637	24580	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24580	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24580	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24580	11	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24580	12	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24580	13	,	,	,
18637	24580	14	9	9	CD
18637	24580	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24580	16	.	.	.
18637	24581	1	579	579	CD
18637	24581	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24581	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	24581	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24581	5	,	,	,
18637	24581	6	132	132	CD
18637	24581	7	Thorington	Thorington	NNP
18637	24581	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24581	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24581	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24581	11	Montgomery	Montgomery	NNP
18637	24581	12	,	,	,
18637	24581	13	147	147	CD
18637	24581	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24581	15	490	490	CD
18637	24581	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24581	17	1893	1893	CD
18637	24581	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24581	19	,	,	,
18637	24581	20	1141	1141	CD
18637	24581	21	Thorington	Thorington	NNP
18637	24581	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24581	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24581	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24581	25	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24581	26	,	,	,
18637	24581	27	8	8	CD
18637	24581	28	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24581	29	.	.	.
18637	24582	1	1	1	CD
18637	24582	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24582	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24582	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24582	5	,	,	,
18637	24582	6	640	640	CD
18637	24582	7	,	,	,
18637	24582	8	1174	1174	CD
18637	24582	9	Thormann	Thormann	NNP
18637	24582	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24582	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24582	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24582	13	Frame	Frame	NNP
18637	24582	14	,	,	,
18637	24582	15	176	176	CD
18637	24582	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24582	17	350	350	CD
18637	24582	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24582	19	1900	1900	CD
18637	24582	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24582	21	,	,	,
18637	24582	22	678	678	CD
18637	24582	23	Thornhill	Thornhill	NNP
18637	24582	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24582	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24582	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24582	27	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	24582	28	,	,	,
18637	24582	29	310	310	CD
18637	24582	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24582	31	88	88	CD
18637	24582	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24582	33	1940	1940	CD
18637	24582	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24582	35	,	,	,
18637	24582	36	563	563	CD
18637	24582	37	,	,	,
18637	24582	38	777	777	CD
18637	24582	39	,	,	,
18637	24582	40	781	781	CD
18637	24582	41	,	,	,
18637	24582	42	782	782	CD
18637	24582	43	Thornton	Thornton	NNP
18637	24582	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24582	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24582	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24582	47	Duffy	Duffy	NNP
18637	24582	48	,	,	,
18637	24582	49	254	254	CD
18637	24582	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24582	51	361	361	CD
18637	24582	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24582	53	1920	1920	CD
18637	24582	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24582	55	,	,	,
18637	24582	56	990	990	CD
18637	24582	57	Thornton	Thornton	NNP
18637	24582	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24582	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24582	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24582	61	United	United	NNP
18637	24582	62	States	States	NNP
18637	24582	63	,	,	,
18637	24582	64	271	271	CD
18637	24582	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24582	66	414	414	CD
18637	24582	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24582	68	1926	1926	CD
18637	24582	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24582	70	,	,	,
18637	24582	71	919	919	CD
18637	24582	72	Thorpe	Thorpe	NNPS
18637	24582	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24582	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	24582	75	_	_	NNP
18637	24582	76	Rutland	Rutland	NNP
18637	24582	77	&	&	CC
18637	24582	78	Burlington	Burlington	NNP
18637	24582	79	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24582	80	,	,	,
18637	24582	81	27	27	CD
18637	24582	82	Vt	Vt	NNP
18637	24582	83	.	.	NNP
18637	24582	84	140	140	CD
18637	24582	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24582	86	1854	1854	CD
18637	24582	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24582	88	,	,	,
18637	24582	89	345	345	CD
18637	24582	90	Thurlow	Thurlow	NNP
18637	24582	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24582	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	24582	93	_	_	NNP
18637	24582	94	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24582	95	,	,	,
18637	24582	96	5	5	CD
18637	24582	97	How	how	WRB
18637	24582	98	.	.	.
18637	24583	1	504	504	CD
18637	24583	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24583	3	1847	1847	CD
18637	24583	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24583	5	,	,	,
18637	24583	6	124	124	CD
18637	24583	7	Tidal	Tidal	NNP
18637	24583	8	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24583	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24583	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24583	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24583	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24583	13	Flanagan	Flanagan	NNP
18637	24583	14	,	,	,
18637	24583	15	263	263	CD
18637	24583	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24583	17	444	444	CD
18637	24583	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24583	19	1924	1924	CD
18637	24583	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24583	21	,	,	,
18637	24583	22	329	329	CD
18637	24583	23	,	,	,
18637	24583	24	332	332	CD
18637	24583	25	Tiernan	Tiernan	NNP
18637	24583	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24583	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24583	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24583	29	Rinker	Rinker	NNP
18637	24583	30	,	,	,
18637	24583	31	102	102	CD
18637	24583	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24583	33	123	123	CD
18637	24583	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24583	35	1880	1880	CD
18637	24583	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24583	37	,	,	,
18637	24583	38	185	185	CD
18637	24583	39	Tiger	Tiger	NNP
18637	24583	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24583	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24583	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24583	43	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24583	44	Investment	Investment	NNP
18637	24583	45	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24583	46	,	,	,
18637	24583	47	221	221	CD
18637	24583	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24583	49	286	286	CD
18637	24583	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24583	51	1911	1911	CD
18637	24583	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24583	53	,	,	,
18637	24583	54	864	864	CD
18637	24583	55	Tigner	Tigner	NNP
18637	24583	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24583	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24583	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24583	59	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24583	60	,	,	,
18637	24583	61	310	310	CD
18637	24583	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24583	63	141	141	CD
18637	24583	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24583	65	1940	1940	CD
18637	24583	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24583	67	,	,	,
18637	24583	68	1160	1160	CD
18637	24583	69	Tilt	Tilt	NNP
18637	24583	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24583	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	24583	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24583	73	Kelsey	Kelsey	NNP
18637	24583	74	,	,	,
18637	24583	75	207	207	CD
18637	24583	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24583	77	43	43	CD
18637	24583	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24583	79	1907	1907	CD
18637	24583	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24583	81	,	,	,
18637	24583	82	672	672	CD
18637	24583	83	Tilton	Tilton	NNP
18637	24583	84	,	,	,
18637	24583	85	The	the	DT
18637	24583	86	,	,	,
18637	24583	87	23	23	CD
18637	24583	88	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24583	89	.	.	.
18637	24584	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24584	2	.	.	.
18637	24585	1	No	no	UH
18637	24585	2	.	.	.
18637	24586	1	14,054	14,054	CD
18637	24586	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24586	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	24586	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24586	5	,	,	,
18637	24586	6	574	574	CD
18637	24586	7	Tindal	Tindal	NNP
18637	24586	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24586	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	11	Wesley	Wesley	NNP
18637	24586	12	,	,	,
18637	24586	13	167	167	CD
18637	24586	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24586	15	204	204	CD
18637	24586	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24586	17	1897	1897	CD
18637	24586	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24586	19	,	,	,
18637	24586	20	588	588	CD
18637	24586	21	,	,	,
18637	24586	22	931	931	CD
18637	24586	23	,	,	,
18637	24586	24	934	934	CD
18637	24586	25	Tinsley	Tinsley	NNP
18637	24586	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24586	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	29	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	24586	30	,	,	,
18637	24586	31	171	171	CD
18637	24586	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24586	33	101	101	CD
18637	24586	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24586	35	1898	1898	CD
18637	24586	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24586	37	,	,	,
18637	24586	38	634	634	CD
18637	24586	39	,	,	,
18637	24586	40	1096	1096	CD
18637	24586	41	Tinsley	Tinsley	NNP
18637	24586	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24586	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	45	Treat	Treat	NNP
18637	24586	46	,	,	,
18637	24586	47	205	205	CD
18637	24586	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24586	49	20	20	CD
18637	24586	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24586	51	1907	1907	CD
18637	24586	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24586	53	,	,	,
18637	24586	54	881	881	CD
18637	24586	55	Titus	Titus	NNP
18637	24586	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24586	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	59	Wallick	Wallick	NNP
18637	24586	60	,	,	,
18637	24586	61	306	306	CD
18637	24586	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24586	63	282	282	CD
18637	24586	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24586	65	1939	1939	CD
18637	24586	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24586	67	,	,	,
18637	24586	68	657	657	CD
18637	24586	69	Todok	Todok	NNP
18637	24586	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	24586	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	73	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24586	74	State	State	NNP
18637	24586	75	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24586	76	,	,	,
18637	24586	77	281	281	CD
18637	24586	78	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24586	79	449	449	CD
18637	24586	80	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24586	81	1930	1930	CD
18637	24586	82	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24586	83	,	,	,
18637	24586	84	416	416	CD
18637	24586	85	Toledo	Toledo	NNP
18637	24586	86	Newspaper	Newspaper	NNP
18637	24586	87	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24586	88	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	24586	90	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	91	United	United	NNP
18637	24586	92	States	States	NNP
18637	24586	93	,	,	,
18637	24586	94	247	247	CD
18637	24586	95	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24586	96	402	402	CD
18637	24586	97	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24586	98	1918	1918	CD
18637	24586	99	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24586	100	,	,	,
18637	24586	101	516	516	CD
18637	24586	102	,	,	,
18637	24586	103	518	518	CD
18637	24586	104	,	,	,
18637	24586	105	784	784	CD
18637	24586	106	Tomkins	Tomkins	NNP
18637	24586	107	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	24586	109	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	110	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24586	111	,	,	,
18637	24586	112	323	323	CD
18637	24586	113	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24586	114	485	485	CD
18637	24586	115	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24586	116	1945	1945	CD
18637	24586	117	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24586	118	,	,	,
18637	24586	119	1100	1100	CD
18637	24586	120	,	,	,
18637	24586	121	1101	1101	CD
18637	24586	122	,	,	,
18637	24586	123	1102	1102	CD
18637	24586	124	Tomlinson	Tomlinson	NNP
18637	24586	125	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	126	v.	v.	IN
18637	24586	127	_	_	NNP
18637	24586	128	Branch	Branch	NNP
18637	24586	129	,	,	,
18637	24586	130	15	15	CD
18637	24586	131	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24586	132	.	.	.
18637	24587	1	460	460	CD
18637	24587	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24587	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	24587	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24587	5	,	,	,
18637	24587	6	931	931	CD
18637	24587	7	Tonawanda	Tonawanda	NNP
18637	24587	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24587	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	11	Lyon	Lyon	NNP
18637	24587	12	,	,	,
18637	24587	13	181	181	CD
18637	24587	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24587	15	389	389	CD
18637	24587	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24587	17	1901	1901	CD
18637	24587	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24587	19	,	,	,
18637	24587	20	1036	1036	CD
18637	24587	21	,	,	,
18637	24587	22	1059	1059	CD
18637	24587	23	Toombs	Toombs	NNP
18637	24587	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24587	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	27	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	24587	28	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24587	29	,	,	,
18637	24587	30	281	281	CD
18637	24587	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24587	32	643	643	CD
18637	24587	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24587	34	1930	1930	CD
18637	24587	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24587	36	,	,	,
18637	24587	37	1085	1085	CD
18637	24587	38	Toomer	Toomer	NNP
18637	24587	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24587	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	42	Witsell	Witsell	NNP
18637	24587	43	,	,	,
18637	24587	44	334	334	CD
18637	24587	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24587	46	385	385	CD
18637	24587	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24587	48	1948	1948	CD
18637	24587	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24587	50	,	,	,
18637	24587	51	181	181	CD
18637	24587	52	,	,	,
18637	24587	53	245	245	CD
18637	24587	54	,	,	,
18637	24587	55	690	690	CD
18637	24587	56	Tot	Tot	NNP
18637	24587	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	24587	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	60	United	United	NNP
18637	24587	61	States	States	NNP
18637	24587	62	,	,	,
18637	24587	63	319	319	CD
18637	24587	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24587	65	463	463	CD
18637	24587	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24587	67	1943	1943	CD
18637	24587	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24587	69	,	,	,
18637	24587	70	849	849	CD
18637	24587	71	Totten	Totten	NNP
18637	24587	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	24587	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	75	United	United	NNP
18637	24587	76	States	States	NNP
18637	24587	77	,	,	,
18637	24587	78	92	92	CD
18637	24587	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24587	80	105	105	CD
18637	24587	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24587	82	1876	1876	CD
18637	24587	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24587	84	,	,	,
18637	24587	85	404	404	CD
18637	24587	86	Toucey	Toucey	NNP
18637	24587	87	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	24587	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	90	New	New	NNP
18637	24587	91	York	York	NNP
18637	24587	92	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24587	93	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	24587	94	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24587	95	,	,	,
18637	24587	96	314	314	CD
18637	24587	97	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24587	98	118	118	CD
18637	24587	99	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24587	100	1941	1941	CD
18637	24587	101	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24587	102	,	,	,
18637	24587	103	627	627	CD
18637	24587	104	,	,	,
18637	24587	105	628	628	CD
18637	24587	106	,	,	,
18637	24587	107	629	629	CD
18637	24587	108	Townsend	Townsend	NNP
18637	24587	109	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	110	v.	v.	IN
18637	24587	111	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	112	Burke	Burke	NNP
18637	24587	113	,	,	,
18637	24587	114	334	334	CD
18637	24587	115	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24587	116	736	736	CD
18637	24587	117	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24587	118	1948	1948	CD
18637	24587	119	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24587	120	,	,	,
18637	24587	121	1106	1106	CD
18637	24587	122	,	,	,
18637	24587	123	1108	1108	CD
18637	24587	124	Townsend	Townsend	NNP
18637	24587	125	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	126	v.	v.	IN
18637	24587	127	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	128	Yeomans	Yeomans	NNPS
18637	24587	129	,	,	,
18637	24587	130	301	301	CD
18637	24587	131	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24587	132	441	441	CD
18637	24587	133	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24587	134	1937	1937	CD
18637	24587	135	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24587	136	,	,	,
18637	24587	137	250	250	CD
18637	24587	138	,	,	,
18637	24587	139	996	996	CD
18637	24587	140	Tracy	Tracy	NNP
18637	24587	141	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	142	v.	v.	IN
18637	24587	143	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	144	Ginzberg	Ginzberg	NNP
18637	24587	145	,	,	,
18637	24587	146	205	205	CD
18637	24587	147	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24587	148	170	170	CD
18637	24587	149	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24587	150	1907	1907	CD
18637	24587	151	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24587	152	,	,	,
18637	24587	153	1140	1140	CD
18637	24587	154	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	24587	155	Mark	Mark	NNP
18637	24587	156	Cases	Cases	NNP
18637	24587	157	,	,	,
18637	24587	158	100	100	CD
18637	24587	159	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24587	160	82	82	CD
18637	24587	161	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24587	162	1879	1879	CD
18637	24587	163	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24587	164	,	,	,
18637	24587	165	122	122	CD
18637	24587	166	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	24587	167	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24587	168	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	169	v.	v.	IN
18637	24587	170	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	171	Parkersburg	Parkersburg	NNP
18637	24587	172	,	,	,
18637	24587	173	107	107	CD
18637	24587	174	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24587	175	691	691	CD
18637	24587	176	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24587	177	1883	1883	CD
18637	24587	178	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24587	179	,	,	,
18637	24587	180	210	210	CD
18637	24587	181	,	,	,
18637	24587	182	214	214	CD
18637	24587	183	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	24587	184	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24587	185	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	186	v.	v.	IN
18637	24587	187	_	_	NNP
18637	24587	188	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	24587	189	,	,	,
18637	24587	190	95	95	CD
18637	24587	191	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24587	192	297	297	CD
18637	24587	193	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24587	194	1877	1877	CD
18637	24587	195	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24587	196	,	,	,
18637	24587	197	896	896	CD
18637	24587	198	Travelers	Travelers	NNPS
18637	24587	199	Health	Health	NNP
18637	24587	200	Assn	Assn	NNP
18637	24587	201	.	.	.
18637	24588	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24588	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24588	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24588	4	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24588	5	,	,	,
18637	24588	6	339	339	CD
18637	24588	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24588	8	643	643	CD
18637	24588	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24588	10	1950	1950	CD
18637	24588	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24588	12	,	,	,
18637	24588	13	1079	1079	CD
18637	24588	14	Travelers	Travelers	NNPS
18637	24588	15	'	'	POS
18637	24588	16	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24588	17	.	.	.
18637	24589	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24589	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24589	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24589	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24589	5	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	24589	6	,	,	,
18637	24589	7	185	185	CD
18637	24589	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24589	9	364	364	CD
18637	24589	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24589	11	1902	1902	CD
18637	24589	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24589	13	,	,	,
18637	24589	14	693	693	CD
18637	24589	15	Travis	Travis	NNP
18637	24589	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24589	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24589	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24589	19	Yale	Yale	NNP
18637	24589	20	&	&	CC
18637	24589	21	Towne	Towne	NNP
18637	24589	22	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	24589	23	.	.	.
18637	24590	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24590	2	,	,	,
18637	24590	3	252	252	CD
18637	24590	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24590	5	60	60	CD
18637	24590	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24590	7	1920	1920	CD
18637	24590	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24590	9	,	,	,
18637	24590	10	687	687	CD
18637	24590	11	,	,	,
18637	24590	12	692	692	CD
18637	24590	13	,	,	,
18637	24590	14	1054	1054	CD
18637	24590	15	,	,	,
18637	24590	16	1061	1061	CD
18637	24590	17	,	,	,
18637	24590	18	1150	1150	CD
18637	24590	19	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	24590	20	of	of	IN
18637	24590	21	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	24590	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24590	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24590	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24590	25	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	24590	26	Preserving	Preserving	NNP
18637	24590	27	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24590	28	,	,	,
18637	24590	29	313	313	CD
18637	24590	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24590	31	62	62	CD
18637	24590	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24590	33	1941	1941	CD
18637	24590	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24590	35	,	,	,
18637	24590	36	198	198	CD
18637	24590	37	,	,	,
18637	24590	38	204	204	CD
18637	24590	39	Treat	Treat	NNP
18637	24590	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24590	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24590	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24590	43	White	White	NNP
18637	24590	44	,	,	,
18637	24590	45	181	181	CD
18637	24590	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24590	47	264	264	CD
18637	24590	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24590	49	1901	1901	CD
18637	24590	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24590	51	,	,	,
18637	24590	52	863	863	CD
18637	24590	53	Treat	Treat	NNP
18637	24590	54	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	24590	55	.	.	.
18637	24591	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24591	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24591	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24591	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24591	5	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	24591	6	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	24591	7	&	&	CC
18637	24591	8	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	24591	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24591	10	,	,	,
18637	24591	11	157	157	CD
18637	24591	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24591	13	674	674	CD
18637	24591	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24591	15	1895	1895	CD
18637	24591	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24591	17	,	,	,
18637	24591	18	896	896	CD
18637	24591	19	Tregea	Tregea	NNP
18637	24591	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24591	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24591	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24591	23	Modesto	Modesto	NNP
18637	24591	24	Irrigation	Irrigation	NNP
18637	24591	25	District	District	NNP
18637	24591	26	,	,	,
18637	24591	27	164	164	CD
18637	24591	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24591	29	179	179	CD
18637	24591	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24591	31	1896	1896	CD
18637	24591	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24591	33	,	,	,
18637	24591	34	540	540	CD
18637	24591	35	Treichler	Treichler	NNP
18637	24591	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24591	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24591	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24591	39	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	24591	40	,	,	,
18637	24591	41	338	338	CD
18637	24591	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24591	43	251	251	CD
18637	24591	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24591	45	1949	1949	CD
18637	24591	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24591	47	,	,	,
18637	24591	48	1045	1045	CD
18637	24591	49	Treigle	Treigle	NNP
18637	24591	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24591	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	24591	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24591	53	Acme	Acme	NNP
18637	24591	54	Homestead	Homestead	NNP
18637	24591	55	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	24591	56	.	.	.
18637	24591	57	,	,	,
18637	24591	58	297	297	CD
18637	24591	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24591	60	189	189	CD
18637	24591	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24591	62	1936	1936	CD
18637	24591	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24591	64	,	,	,
18637	24591	65	983	983	CD
18637	24591	66	Treinies	Treinies	NNPS
18637	24591	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24591	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	24591	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24591	70	Sunshine	Sunshine	NNP
18637	24591	71	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	24591	72	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24591	73	,	,	,
18637	24591	74	308	308	CD
18637	24591	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24591	76	66	66	CD
18637	24591	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24591	78	1939	1939	CD
18637	24591	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24591	80	,	,	,
18637	24591	81	603	603	CD
18637	24591	82	,	,	,
18637	24591	83	934	934	CD
18637	24591	84	Trenton	Trenton	NNP
18637	24591	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24591	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	24591	87	_	_	NNP
18637	24591	88	New	New	NNP
18637	24591	89	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	24591	90	,	,	,
18637	24591	91	262	262	CD
18637	24591	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24591	93	182	182	CD
18637	24591	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24591	95	1923	1923	CD
18637	24591	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24591	97	,	,	,
18637	24591	98	340	340	CD
18637	24591	99	,	,	,
18637	24591	100	609	609	CD
18637	24591	101	,	,	,
18637	24591	102	982	982	CD
18637	24591	103	,	,	,
18637	24591	104	1036	1036	CD
18637	24591	105	Trinityfarm	Trinityfarm	NNP
18637	24591	106	Const	Const	NNP
18637	24591	107	.	.	.
18637	24592	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24592	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24592	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	5	Grosjean	Grosjean	NNP
18637	24592	6	,	,	,
18637	24592	7	291	291	CD
18637	24592	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24592	9	466	466	CD
18637	24592	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24592	11	1934	1934	CD
18637	24592	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24592	13	,	,	,
18637	24592	14	731	731	CD
18637	24592	15	Truax	Truax	NNP
18637	24592	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24592	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	19	Corrigan	Corrigan	NNP
18637	24592	20	,	,	,
18637	24592	21	257	257	CD
18637	24592	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24592	23	312	312	CD
18637	24592	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24592	25	1921	1921	CD
18637	24592	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24592	27	,	,	,
18637	24592	28	991	991	CD
18637	24592	29	,	,	,
18637	24592	30	992	992	CD
18637	24592	31	,	,	,
18637	24592	32	1142	1142	CD
18637	24592	33	,	,	,
18637	24592	34	1145	1145	CD
18637	24592	35	,	,	,
18637	24592	36	1166	1166	CD
18637	24592	37	Truax	Truax	NNP
18637	24592	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24592	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	41	Raich	Raich	NNP
18637	24592	42	,	,	,
18637	24592	43	239	239	CD
18637	24592	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24592	45	33	33	CD
18637	24592	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24592	47	1915	1915	CD
18637	24592	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24592	49	,	,	,
18637	24592	50	931	931	CD
18637	24592	51	,	,	,
18637	24592	52	934	934	CD
18637	24592	53	,	,	,
18637	24592	54	1158	1158	CD
18637	24592	55	Trupiano	Trupiano	NNP
18637	24592	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24592	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	59	United	United	NNP
18637	24592	60	States	States	NNP
18637	24592	61	,	,	,
18637	24592	62	334	334	CD
18637	24592	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24592	64	699	699	CD
18637	24592	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24592	66	1948	1948	CD
18637	24592	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24592	68	,	,	,
18637	24592	69	829	829	CD
18637	24592	70	Trusler	Trusler	NNP
18637	24592	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	24592	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	74	Crooks	Crooks	NNP
18637	24592	75	,	,	,
18637	24592	76	269	269	CD
18637	24592	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24592	78	475	475	CD
18637	24592	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24592	80	1926	1926	CD
18637	24592	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24592	82	,	,	,
18637	24592	83	918	918	CD
18637	24592	84	Tua	Tua	NNP
18637	24592	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	24592	87	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	88	Carriere	Carriere	NNP
18637	24592	89	,	,	,
18637	24592	90	117	117	CD
18637	24592	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24592	92	201	201	CD
18637	24592	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24592	94	1886	1886	CD
18637	24592	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24592	96	,	,	,
18637	24592	97	264	264	CD
18637	24592	98	Tucker	Tucker	NNP
18637	24592	99	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	24592	101	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	102	Alexandroff	Alexandroff	NNP
18637	24592	103	,	,	,
18637	24592	104	183	183	CD
18637	24592	105	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24592	106	424	424	CD
18637	24592	107	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24592	108	1902	1902	CD
18637	24592	109	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24592	110	,	,	,
18637	24592	111	433	433	CD
18637	24592	112	,	,	,
18637	24592	113	493	493	CD
18637	24592	114	Tucker	Tucker	NNP
18637	24592	115	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	116	v.	v.	IN
18637	24592	117	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	118	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24592	119	,	,	,
18637	24592	120	326	326	CD
18637	24592	121	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24592	122	517	517	CD
18637	24592	123	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24592	124	1946	1946	CD
18637	24592	125	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24592	126	,	,	,
18637	24592	127	786	786	CD
18637	24592	128	Tulee	Tulee	NNP
18637	24592	129	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	130	v.	v.	IN
18637	24592	131	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	132	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24592	133	,	,	,
18637	24592	134	315	315	CD
18637	24592	135	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24592	136	681	681	CD
18637	24592	137	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24592	138	1942	1942	CD
18637	24592	139	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24592	140	,	,	,
18637	24592	141	701	701	CD
18637	24592	142	Tumey	Tumey	NNPS
18637	24592	143	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	144	v.	v.	IN
18637	24592	145	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	146	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24592	147	,	,	,
18637	24592	148	273	273	CD
18637	24592	149	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24592	150	510	510	CD
18637	24592	151	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24592	152	1927	1927	CD
18637	24592	153	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24592	154	,	,	,
18637	24592	155	1131	1131	CD
18637	24592	156	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	24592	157	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	158	v.	v.	IN
18637	24592	159	_	_	NNP
18637	24592	160	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24592	161	of	of	IN
18637	24592	162	North	North	NNP
18637	24592	163	America	America	NNP
18637	24592	164	,	,	,
18637	24592	165	4	4	CD
18637	24592	166	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	24592	167	.	.	.
18637	24593	1	8	8	CD
18637	24593	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24593	3	1799	1799	CD
18637	24593	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24593	5	,	,	,
18637	24593	6	617	617	CD
18637	24593	7	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	24593	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24593	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24593	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24593	11	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	24593	12	,	,	,
18637	24593	13	107	107	CD
18637	24593	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24593	15	38	38	CD
18637	24593	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24593	17	1883	1883	CD
18637	24593	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24593	19	,	,	,
18637	24593	20	364	364	CD
18637	24593	21	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	24593	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24593	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24593	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24593	25	New	New	NNP
18637	24593	26	York	York	NNP
18637	24593	27	,	,	,
18637	24593	28	168	168	CD
18637	24593	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24593	30	90	90	CD
18637	24593	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24593	32	1897	1897	CD
18637	24593	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24593	34	,	,	,
18637	24593	35	1093	1093	CD
18637	24593	36	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	24593	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24593	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	24593	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24593	40	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24593	41	,	,	,
18637	24593	42	338	338	CD
18637	24593	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24593	44	62	62	CD
18637	24593	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24593	46	1949	1949	CD
18637	24593	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24593	48	,	,	,
18637	24593	49	1120	1120	CD
18637	24593	50	,	,	,
18637	24593	51	1121	1121	CD
18637	24593	52	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	24593	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24593	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	24593	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24593	56	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24593	57	,	,	,
18637	24593	58	194	194	CD
18637	24593	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24593	60	279	279	CD
18637	24593	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24593	62	1904	1904	CD
18637	24593	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24593	64	,	,	,
18637	24593	65	259	259	CD
18637	24593	66	Turpin	Turpin	NNP
18637	24593	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24593	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	24593	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24593	70	Lemon	Lemon	NNP
18637	24593	71	,	,	,
18637	24593	72	187	187	CD
18637	24593	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24593	74	51	51	CD
18637	24593	75	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24593	76	1902	1902	CD
18637	24593	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24593	78	,	,	,
18637	24593	79	1057	1057	CD
18637	24593	80	Turpin	Turpin	NNP
18637	24593	81	&	&	CC
18637	24593	82	Bro	Bro	NNP
18637	24593	83	.	.	.
18637	24594	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24594	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24594	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24594	4	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
18637	24594	5	,	,	,
18637	24594	6	117	117	CD
18637	24594	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24594	8	504	504	CD
18637	24594	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24594	10	1886	1886	CD
18637	24594	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24594	12	,	,	,
18637	24594	13	321	321	CD
18637	24594	14	,	,	,
18637	24594	15	322	322	CD
18637	24594	16	Tutun	Tutun	NNPS
18637	24594	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24594	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24594	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24594	20	United	United	NNP
18637	24594	21	States	States	NNP
18637	24594	22	,	,	,
18637	24594	23	270	270	CD
18637	24594	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24594	25	568	568	CD
18637	24594	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24594	27	1926	1926	CD
18637	24594	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24594	29	,	,	,
18637	24594	30	624	624	CD
18637	24594	31	Twin	twin	NN
18637	24594	32	City	City	NNP
18637	24594	33	Nat	Nat	NNP
18637	24594	34	.	.	.
18637	24595	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24595	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24595	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24595	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24595	5	Nebeker	Nebeker	NNP
18637	24595	6	,	,	,
18637	24595	7	167	167	CD
18637	24595	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24595	9	196	196	CD
18637	24595	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24595	11	1897	1897	CD
18637	24595	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24595	13	,	,	,
18637	24595	14	102	102	CD
18637	24595	15	Twining	Twining	NNP
18637	24595	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24595	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24595	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24595	19	New	New	NNP
18637	24595	20	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	24595	21	,	,	,
18637	24595	22	211	211	CD
18637	24595	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24595	24	78	78	CD
18637	24595	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24595	26	1908	1908	CD
18637	24595	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24595	28	,	,	,
18637	24595	29	752	752	CD
18637	24595	30	,	,	,
18637	24595	31	843	843	CD
18637	24595	32	,	,	,
18637	24595	33	845	845	CD
18637	24595	34	,	,	,
18637	24595	35	967	967	CD
18637	24595	36	,	,	,
18637	24595	37	971	971	CD
18637	24595	38	,	,	,
18637	24595	39	1071	1071	CD
18637	24595	40	,	,	,
18637	24595	41	1084	1084	CD
18637	24595	42	,	,	,
18637	24595	43	1111	1111	CD
18637	24595	44	,	,	,
18637	24595	45	1112	1112	CD
18637	24595	46	,	,	,
18637	24595	47	1116	1116	CD
18637	24595	48	,	,	,
18637	24595	49	1118	1118	CD
18637	24595	50	Twitchell	Twitchell	NNP
18637	24595	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24595	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	24595	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24595	54	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24595	55	,	,	,
18637	24595	56	7	7	CD
18637	24595	57	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24595	58	.	.	.
18637	24596	1	321	321	CD
18637	24596	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24596	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24596	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24596	5	,	,	,
18637	24596	6	751	751	CD
18637	24596	7	Tyee	Tyee	NNP
18637	24596	8	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	24596	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24596	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24596	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24596	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24596	13	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	24596	14	,	,	,
18637	24596	15	240	240	CD
18637	24596	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24596	17	115	115	CD
18637	24596	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24596	19	1916	1916	CD
18637	24596	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24596	21	,	,	,
18637	24596	22	1192	1192	CD
18637	24596	23	Tyler	Tyler	NNP
18637	24596	24	,	,	,
18637	24596	25	In	in	IN
18637	24596	26	re	re	NN
18637	24596	27	,	,	,
18637	24596	28	149	149	CD
18637	24596	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24596	30	164	164	CD
18637	24596	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24596	32	1893	1893	CD
18637	24596	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24596	34	,	,	,
18637	24596	35	933	933	CD
18637	24596	36	Tyler	Tyler	NNP
18637	24596	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24596	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	24596	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24596	40	Defrees	Defrees	NNP
18637	24596	41	,	,	,
18637	24596	42	11	11	CD
18637	24596	43	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24596	44	.	.	.
18637	24597	1	331	331	CD
18637	24597	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24597	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24597	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24597	5	,	,	,
18637	24597	6	299	299	CD
18637	24597	7	Tyler	Tyler	NNP
18637	24597	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24597	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24597	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24597	11	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	24597	12	of	of	IN
18637	24597	13	the	the	DT
18637	24597	14	Court	Court	NNP
18637	24597	15	of	of	IN
18637	24597	16	Registration	Registration	NNP
18637	24597	17	,	,	,
18637	24597	18	179	179	CD
18637	24597	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24597	20	405	405	CD
18637	24597	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24597	22	1900	1900	CD
18637	24597	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24597	24	,	,	,
18637	24597	25	982	982	CD
18637	24597	26	Tyler	Tyler	NNP
18637	24597	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24597	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24597	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24597	30	United	United	NNP
18637	24597	31	States	States	NNP
18637	24597	32	,	,	,
18637	24597	33	281	281	CD
18637	24597	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24597	35	497	497	CD
18637	24597	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24597	37	1930	1930	CD
18637	24597	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24597	39	,	,	,
18637	24597	40	320	320	CD
18637	24597	41	,	,	,
18637	24597	42	540	540	CD
18637	24597	43	,	,	,
18637	24597	44	864	864	CD
18637	24597	45	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
18637	24597	46	&	&	CC
18637	24597	47	Bros.--United	bros.--unite	VBD
18637	24597	48	Theatre	Theatre	NNP
18637	24597	49	Ticket	Ticket	NNP
18637	24597	50	Offices	Offices	NNPS
18637	24597	51	_	_	NNP
18637	24597	52	v.	v.	IN
18637	24597	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24597	54	Banton	Banton	NNP
18637	24597	55	,	,	,
18637	24597	56	273	273	CD
18637	24597	57	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24597	58	418	418	CD
18637	24597	59	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24597	60	1927	1927	CD
18637	24597	61	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24597	62	,	,	,
18637	24597	63	996	996	CD
18637	24597	64	U	U	NNP
18637	24597	65	Ughbanks	Ughbanks	NNP
18637	24597	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24597	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	24597	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24597	69	Armstrong	Armstrong	NNP
18637	24597	70	,	,	,
18637	24597	71	208	208	CD
18637	24597	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24597	73	481	481	CD
18637	24597	74	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24597	75	1908	1908	CD
18637	24597	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24597	77	,	,	,
18637	24597	78	1133	1133	CD
18637	24597	79	,	,	,
18637	24597	80	1161	1161	CD
18637	24597	81	Underwood	Underwood	NNP
18637	24597	82	Typewriter	Typewriter	NNP
18637	24597	83	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24597	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24597	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	24597	86	_	_	NNP
18637	24597	87	Chamberlain	Chamberlain	NNP
18637	24597	88	,	,	,
18637	24597	89	254	254	CD
18637	24597	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24597	91	113	113	CD
18637	24597	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24597	93	1920	1920	CD
18637	24597	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24597	95	,	,	,
18637	24597	96	209	209	CD
18637	24597	97	,	,	,
18637	24597	98	1054	1054	CD
18637	24597	99	Unemployment	unemployment	NN
18637	24597	100	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	24597	101	.	.	.
18637	24598	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24598	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24598	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24598	4	Aragon	Aragon	NNP
18637	24598	5	,	,	,
18637	24598	6	329	329	CD
18637	24598	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24598	8	143	143	CD
18637	24598	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24598	10	1946	1946	CD
18637	24598	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24598	12	,	,	,
18637	24598	13	78	78	CD
18637	24598	14	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24598	15	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	24598	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24598	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24598	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24598	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24598	20	United	United	NNP
18637	24598	21	States	States	NNP
18637	24598	22	,	,	,
18637	24598	23	204	204	CD
18637	24598	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24598	25	364	364	CD
18637	24598	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24598	27	1907	1907	CD
18637	24598	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24598	29	,	,	,
18637	24598	30	78	78	CD
18637	24598	31	,	,	,
18637	24598	32	128	128	CD
18637	24598	33	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24598	34	Brokerage	Brokerage	NNP
18637	24598	35	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24598	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24598	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24598	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24598	39	Jensen	Jensen	NNP
18637	24598	40	,	,	,
18637	24598	41	322	322	CD
18637	24598	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24598	43	202	202	CD
18637	24598	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24598	45	1944	1944	CD
18637	24598	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24598	47	,	,	,
18637	24598	48	234	234	CD
18637	24598	49	,	,	,
18637	24598	50	250	250	CD
18637	24598	51	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24598	52	National	National	NNP
18637	24598	53	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24598	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24598	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	24598	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24598	57	Lamb	Lamb	NNP
18637	24598	58	,	,	,
18637	24598	59	337	337	CD
18637	24598	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24598	61	38	38	CD
18637	24598	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24598	63	1949	1949	CD
18637	24598	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24598	65	,	,	,
18637	24598	66	657	657	CD
18637	24598	67	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24598	68	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24598	69	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24598	70	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24598	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24598	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	24598	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24598	74	Pub	Pub	NNP
18637	24598	75	.	.	.
18637	24599	1	Service	Service	NNP
18637	24599	2	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	24599	3	.	.	NNP
18637	24599	4	,	,	,
18637	24599	5	248	248	CD
18637	24599	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24599	7	67	67	CD
18637	24599	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24599	9	1918	1918	CD
18637	24599	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24599	11	,	,	,
18637	24599	12	197	197	CD
18637	24599	13	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24599	14	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24600	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24600	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24600	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24600	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24600	5	United	United	NNP
18637	24600	6	States	States	NNP
18637	24600	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24600	8	Sinking	Sinking	NNP
18637	24600	9	Fund	Fund	NNP
18637	24600	10	Cases	case	NNS
18637	24600	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24600	12	,	,	,
18637	24600	13	99	99	CD
18637	24600	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24600	15	700	700	CD
18637	24600	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24600	17	1879	1879	CD
18637	24600	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24600	19	,	,	,
18637	24600	20	846	846	CD
18637	24600	21	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24600	22	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	24600	23	Collar	Collar	NNP
18637	24600	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24600	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24600	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24600	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24600	28	Van	Van	NNP
18637	24600	29	Dusen	Dusen	NNP
18637	24600	30	,	,	,
18637	24600	31	23	23	CD
18637	24600	32	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24600	33	.	.	.
18637	24601	1	530	530	CD
18637	24601	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24601	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	24601	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24601	5	,	,	,
18637	24601	6	272	272	CD
18637	24601	7	,	,	,
18637	24601	8	273	273	CD
18637	24601	9	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24601	10	Refrigerator	Refrigerator	NNP
18637	24601	11	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	24601	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24601	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24601	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	16	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
18637	24601	17	,	,	,
18637	24601	18	199	199	CD
18637	24601	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24601	20	194	194	CD
18637	24601	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24601	22	1905	1905	CD
18637	24601	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24601	24	211	211	CD
18637	24601	25	,	,	,
18637	24601	26	1041	1041	CD
18637	24601	27	,	,	,
18637	24601	28	1042	1042	CD
18637	24601	29	,	,	,
18637	24601	30	1045	1045	CD
18637	24601	31	,	,	,
18637	24601	32	1052	1052	CD
18637	24601	33	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24601	34	Tank	Tank	NNP
18637	24601	35	Line	Line	NNP
18637	24601	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	37	v.	v.	IN
18637	24601	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	39	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	24601	40	,	,	,
18637	24601	41	249	249	CD
18637	24601	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24601	43	275	275	CD
18637	24601	44	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24601	45	1919	1919	CD
18637	24601	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24601	47	,	,	,
18637	24601	48	202	202	CD
18637	24601	49	,	,	,
18637	24601	50	1053	1053	CD
18637	24601	51	United	United	NNP
18637	24601	52	Fuel	Fuel	NNP
18637	24601	53	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24601	54	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24601	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24601	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	58	Hallanan	Hallanan	NNP
18637	24601	59	,	,	,
18637	24601	60	257	257	CD
18637	24601	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24601	62	277	277	CD
18637	24601	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24601	64	1921	1921	CD
18637	24601	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24601	66	,	,	,
18637	24601	67	138	138	CD
18637	24601	68	,	,	,
18637	24601	69	182	182	CD
18637	24601	70	,	,	,
18637	24601	71	195	195	CD
18637	24601	72	United	United	NNP
18637	24601	73	Fuel	Fuel	NNP
18637	24601	74	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24601	75	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24601	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	24601	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	79	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24601	80	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24601	81	,	,	,
18637	24601	82	278	278	CD
18637	24601	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24601	84	300	300	CD
18637	24601	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24601	86	1929	1929	CD
18637	24601	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24601	88	,	,	,
18637	24601	89	1011	1011	CD
18637	24601	90	United	United	NNP
18637	24601	91	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24601	92	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24601	93	Service	Service	NNP
18637	24601	94	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24601	95	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	24601	97	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	98	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24601	99	,	,	,
18637	24601	100	303	303	CD
18637	24601	101	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24601	102	123	123	CD
18637	24601	103	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24601	104	1938	1938	CD
18637	24601	105	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24601	106	,	,	,
18637	24601	107	570	570	CD
18637	24601	108	United	United	NNP
18637	24601	109	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24601	110	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	24601	111	of	of	IN
18637	24601	112	America	America	NNP
18637	24601	113	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	114	v.	v.	IN
18637	24601	115	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	116	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	24601	117	,	,	,
18637	24601	118	330	330	CD
18637	24601	119	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24601	120	75	75	CD
18637	24601	121	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24601	122	1947	1947	CD
18637	24601	123	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24601	124	,	,	,
18637	24601	125	450	450	CD
18637	24601	126	,	,	,
18637	24601	127	460	460	CD
18637	24601	128	,	,	,
18637	24601	129	545	545	CD
18637	24601	130	,	,	,
18637	24601	131	550	550	CD
18637	24601	132	,	,	,
18637	24601	133	561	561	CD
18637	24601	134	,	,	,
18637	24601	135	794	794	CD
18637	24601	136	,	,	,
18637	24601	137	909	909	CD
18637	24601	138	United	United	NNP
18637	24601	139	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24601	140	&	&	CC
18637	24601	141	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	24601	142	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24601	143	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	144	v.	v.	IN
18637	24601	145	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	146	West	West	NNP
18637	24601	147	,	,	,
18637	24601	148	280	280	CD
18637	24601	149	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24601	150	234	234	CD
18637	24601	151	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24601	152	1930	1930	CD
18637	24601	153	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24601	154	,	,	,
18637	24601	155	1007	1007	CD
18637	24601	156	United	United	NNP
18637	24601	157	States	States	NNP
18637	24601	158	,	,	,
18637	24601	159	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24601	160	Parte	Parte	NNP
18637	24601	161	,	,	,
18637	24601	162	242	242	CD
18637	24601	163	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24601	164	27	27	CD
18637	24601	165	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24601	166	1916	1916	CD
18637	24601	167	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24601	168	,	,	,
18637	24601	169	407	407	CD
18637	24601	170	United	United	NNP
18637	24601	171	States	States	NNP
18637	24601	172	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	173	v.	v.	IN
18637	24601	174	_	_	NNP
18637	24601	175	Abilene	Abilene	NNP
18637	24601	176	&	&	CC
18637	24601	177	S.R.	S.R.	NNP
18637	24602	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24602	2	,	,	,
18637	24602	3	265	265	CD
18637	24602	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24602	5	274	274	CD
18637	24602	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24602	7	1924	1924	CD
18637	24602	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24602	9	,	,	,
18637	24602	10	850	850	CD
18637	24602	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24602	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24602	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24602	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24602	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24602	16	Aczel	Aczel	NNP
18637	24602	17	,	,	,
18637	24602	18	219	219	CD
18637	24602	19	F.	f.	NN
18637	24602	20	917	917	CD
18637	24602	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24602	22	1915	1915	CD
18637	24602	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24602	24	,	,	,
18637	24602	25	1208	1208	CD
18637	24602	26	United	United	NNP
18637	24602	27	States	States	NNP
18637	24602	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24602	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24602	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24602	31	Alford	Alford	NNP
18637	24602	32	,	,	,
18637	24602	33	274	274	CD
18637	24602	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24602	35	264	264	CD
18637	24602	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24602	37	1927	1927	CD
18637	24602	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24602	39	,	,	,
18637	24602	40	883	883	CD
18637	24602	41	United	United	NNP
18637	24602	42	States	States	NNP
18637	24602	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24602	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24602	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24602	46	Allegheny	Allegheny	NNP
18637	24602	47	County	County	NNP
18637	24602	48	,	,	,
18637	24602	49	322	322	CD
18637	24602	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24602	51	174	174	CD
18637	24602	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24602	53	1944	1944	CD
18637	24602	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24602	55	,	,	,
18637	24602	56	732	732	CD
18637	24602	57	United	United	NNP
18637	24602	58	States	States	NNP
18637	24602	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24602	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	24602	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24602	62	American	American	NNP
18637	24602	63	Bell	Bell	NNP
18637	24602	64	Tel	Tel	NNP
18637	24602	65	.	.	.
18637	24603	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24603	2	,	,	,
18637	24603	3	128	128	CD
18637	24603	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24603	5	315	315	CD
18637	24603	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24603	7	1888	1888	CD
18637	24603	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24603	9	,	,	,
18637	24603	10	584	584	CD
18637	24603	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24603	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24603	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24603	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24603	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24603	16	Amsden	Amsden	NNP
18637	24603	17	,	,	,
18637	24603	18	6	6	CD
18637	24603	19	F.	f.	NN
18637	24603	20	819	819	CD
18637	24603	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24603	22	1881	1881	CD
18637	24603	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24603	24	,	,	,
18637	24603	25	1186	1186	CD
18637	24603	26	United	United	NNP
18637	24603	27	States	States	NNP
18637	24603	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24603	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24603	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24603	31	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	24603	32	,	,	,
18637	24603	33	9	9	CD
18637	24603	34	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24603	35	.	.	.
18637	24604	1	56	56	CD
18637	24604	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24604	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	24604	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24604	5	,	,	,
18637	24604	6	547	547	CD
18637	24604	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24604	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24604	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24604	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24604	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24604	12	Appalachian	Appalachian	NNP
18637	24604	13	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	24604	14	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24604	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24604	16	,	,	,
18637	24604	17	311	311	CD
18637	24604	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24604	19	377	377	CD
18637	24604	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24604	21	1940	1940	CD
18637	24604	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24604	23	,	,	,
18637	24604	24	128	128	CD
18637	24604	25	,	,	,
18637	24604	26	131	131	CD
18637	24604	27	,	,	,
18637	24604	28	550	550	CD
18637	24604	29	,	,	,
18637	24604	30	577	577	CD
18637	24604	31	,	,	,
18637	24604	32	868	868	CD
18637	24604	33	,	,	,
18637	24604	34	869	869	CD
18637	24604	35	,	,	,
18637	24604	36	920	920	CD
18637	24604	37	United	United	NNP
18637	24604	38	States	States	NNP
18637	24604	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24604	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24604	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24604	42	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
18637	24604	43	,	,	,
18637	24604	44	295	295	CD
18637	24604	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24604	46	174	174	CD
18637	24604	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24604	48	1935	1935	CD
18637	24604	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24604	50	,	,	,
18637	24604	51	128	128	CD
18637	24604	52	United	United	NNP
18637	24604	53	States	States	NNP
18637	24604	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24604	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	24604	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24604	57	Arjona	Arjona	NNP
18637	24604	58	,	,	,
18637	24604	59	120	120	CD
18637	24604	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24604	61	479	479	CD
18637	24604	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24604	63	1887	1887	CD
18637	24604	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24604	65	,	,	,
18637	24604	66	278	278	CD
18637	24604	67	United	United	NNP
18637	24604	68	States	States	NNP
18637	24604	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24604	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	24604	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24604	72	Arredondo	Arredondo	NNP
18637	24604	73	,	,	,
18637	24604	74	6	6	CD
18637	24604	75	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24604	76	.	.	.
18637	24605	1	691	691	CD
18637	24605	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24605	3	1932	1932	CD
18637	24605	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24605	5	,	,	,
18637	24605	6	512	512	CD
18637	24605	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24605	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24605	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24605	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24605	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24605	12	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	24605	13	,	,	,
18637	24605	14	T.	T.	NNP
18637	24605	15	&	&	CC
18637	24605	16	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	24606	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24606	2	,	,	,
18637	24606	3	234	234	CD
18637	24606	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24606	5	476	476	CD
18637	24606	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24606	7	1914	1914	CD
18637	24606	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24606	9	,	,	,
18637	24606	10	137	137	CD
18637	24606	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24606	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24606	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24606	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24606	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24606	16	Athens	Athens	NNP
18637	24606	17	Armory	Armory	NNP
18637	24606	18	,	,	,
18637	24606	19	24	24	CD
18637	24606	20	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24606	21	.	.	.
18637	24607	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24607	2	.	.	.
18637	24608	1	No	no	UH
18637	24608	2	.	.	.
18637	24609	1	14,473	14,473	CD
18637	24609	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24609	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	24609	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24609	5	,	,	,
18637	24609	6	643	643	CD
18637	24609	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24609	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24609	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24609	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24609	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24609	12	Bailey	Bailey	NNP
18637	24609	13	,	,	,
18637	24609	14	9	9	CD
18637	24609	15	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	24609	16	.	.	.
18637	24610	1	238	238	CD
18637	24610	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24610	3	1835	1835	CD
18637	24610	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24610	5	,	,	,
18637	24610	6	636	636	CD
18637	24610	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24610	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24610	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24610	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24610	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24610	12	Ball	Ball	NNP
18637	24610	13	,	,	,
18637	24610	14	163	163	CD
18637	24610	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24610	16	662	662	CD
18637	24610	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24610	18	1896	1896	CD
18637	24610	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24610	20	,	,	,
18637	24610	21	839	839	CD
18637	24610	22	United	United	NNP
18637	24610	23	States	States	NNP
18637	24610	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24610	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24610	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24610	27	Ballard	Ballard	NNP
18637	24610	28	,	,	,
18637	24610	29	322	322	CD
18637	24610	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24610	31	78	78	CD
18637	24610	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24610	33	1944	1944	CD
18637	24610	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24610	35	,	,	,
18637	24610	36	766	766	CD
18637	24610	37	United	United	NNP
18637	24610	38	States	States	NNP
18637	24610	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24610	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24610	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24610	42	Ballin	Ballin	NNP
18637	24610	43	,	,	,
18637	24610	44	144	144	CD
18637	24610	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24610	46	1	1	CD
18637	24610	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24610	48	1892	1892	CD
18637	24610	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24610	50	,	,	,
18637	24610	51	96	96	CD
18637	24610	52	,	,	,
18637	24610	53	97	97	CD
18637	24610	54	,	,	,
18637	24610	55	98	98	CD
18637	24610	56	United	United	NNP
18637	24610	57	States	States	NNP
18637	24610	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24610	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24610	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24610	61	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	24610	62	&	&	CC
18637	24610	63	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	24611	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24611	2	,	,	,
18637	24611	3	17	17	CD
18637	24611	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24611	5	.	.	.
18637	24612	1	322	322	CD
18637	24612	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24612	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	24612	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24612	5	,	,	,
18637	24612	6	106	106	CD
18637	24612	7	,	,	,
18637	24612	8	340	340	CD
18637	24612	9	United	United	NNP
18637	24612	10	States	States	NNP
18637	24612	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24612	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	14	Barnow	Barnow	NNP
18637	24612	15	,	,	,
18637	24612	16	239	239	CD
18637	24612	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24612	18	74	74	CD
18637	24612	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24612	20	1915	1915	CD
18637	24612	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24612	22	,	,	,
18637	24612	23	309	309	CD
18637	24612	24	United	United	NNP
18637	24612	25	States	States	NNP
18637	24612	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24612	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	29	Bathgate	Bathgate	NNP
18637	24612	30	,	,	,
18637	24612	31	246	246	CD
18637	24612	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24612	33	220	220	CD
18637	24612	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24612	35	1918	1918	CD
18637	24612	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24612	37	,	,	,
18637	24612	38	88	88	CD
18637	24612	39	United	United	NNP
18637	24612	40	States	States	NNP
18637	24612	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24612	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	44	Bausch	Bausch	NNP
18637	24612	45	&	&	CC
18637	24612	46	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24612	47	Optical	Optical	NNP
18637	24612	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24612	49	,	,	,
18637	24612	50	321	321	CD
18637	24612	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24612	52	707	707	CD
18637	24612	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24612	54	1944	1944	CD
18637	24612	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24612	56	,	,	,
18637	24612	57	828	828	CD
18637	24612	58	United	United	NNP
18637	24612	59	States	States	NNP
18637	24612	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	24612	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	63	Bayer	Bayer	NNP
18637	24612	64	,	,	,
18637	24612	65	331	331	CD
18637	24612	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24612	67	532	532	CD
18637	24612	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24612	69	1947	1947	CD
18637	24612	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24612	71	,	,	,
18637	24612	72	840	840	CD
18637	24612	73	United	United	NNP
18637	24612	74	States	States	NNP
18637	24612	75	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	24612	77	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	78	Beebe	Beebe	NNP
18637	24612	79	,	,	,
18637	24612	80	127	127	CD
18637	24612	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24612	82	338	338	CD
18637	24612	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24612	84	1888	1888	CD
18637	24612	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24612	86	,	,	,
18637	24612	87	584	584	CD
18637	24612	88	United	United	NNP
18637	24612	89	States	States	NNP
18637	24612	90	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	91	v.	v.	IN
18637	24612	92	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	93	Bekins	Bekins	NNPS
18637	24612	94	,	,	,
18637	24612	95	304	304	CD
18637	24612	96	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24612	97	27	27	CD
18637	24612	98	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24612	99	1938	1938	CD
18637	24612	100	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24612	101	,	,	,
18637	24612	102	262	262	CD
18637	24612	103	,	,	,
18637	24612	104	264	264	CD
18637	24612	105	United	United	NNP
18637	24612	106	States	States	NNP
18637	24612	107	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	24612	109	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	110	Belmont	Belmont	NNP
18637	24612	111	,	,	,
18637	24612	112	301	301	CD
18637	24612	113	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24612	114	324	324	CD
18637	24612	115	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24612	116	1937	1937	CD
18637	24612	117	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24612	118	,	,	,
18637	24612	119	437	437	CD
18637	24612	120	,	,	,
18637	24612	121	439	439	CD
18637	24612	122	United	United	NNP
18637	24612	123	States	States	NNP
18637	24612	124	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	125	v.	v.	IN
18637	24612	126	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	127	Bennett	Bennett	NNP
18637	24612	128	,	,	,
18637	24612	129	232	232	CD
18637	24612	130	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24612	131	299	299	CD
18637	24612	132	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24612	133	1914	1914	CD
18637	24612	134	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24612	135	,	,	,
18637	24612	136	862	862	CD
18637	24612	137	United	United	NNP
18637	24612	138	States	States	NNP
18637	24612	139	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	140	v.	v.	IN
18637	24612	141	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	142	Benz	Benz	NNP
18637	24612	143	,	,	,
18637	24612	144	282	282	CD
18637	24612	145	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24612	146	304	304	CD
18637	24612	147	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24612	148	1931	1931	CD
18637	24612	149	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24612	150	,	,	,
18637	24612	151	407	407	CD
18637	24612	152	United	United	NNP
18637	24612	153	States	States	NNP
18637	24612	154	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	155	v.	v.	IN
18637	24612	156	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	157	Berwind	Berwind	NNP
18637	24612	158	-	-	HYPH
18637	24612	159	White	White	NNP
18637	24612	160	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	24612	161	Mine	Mine	NNP
18637	24612	162	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24612	163	,	,	,
18637	24612	164	274	274	CD
18637	24612	165	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24612	166	564	564	CD
18637	24612	167	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24612	168	1927	1927	CD
18637	24612	169	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24612	170	,	,	,
18637	24612	171	861	861	CD
18637	24612	172	United	United	NNP
18637	24612	173	States	States	NNP
18637	24612	174	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	175	v.	v.	IN
18637	24612	176	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	177	Bethlehem	Bethlehem	NNP
18637	24612	178	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	24612	179	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24612	180	,	,	,
18637	24612	181	315	315	CD
18637	24612	182	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24612	183	289	289	CD
18637	24612	184	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24612	185	1942	1942	CD
18637	24612	186	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24612	187	,	,	,
18637	24612	188	289	289	CD
18637	24612	189	United	United	NNP
18637	24612	190	States	States	NNP
18637	24612	191	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	192	v.	v.	IN
18637	24612	193	_	_	NNP
18637	24612	194	Bevans	Bevans	NNPS
18637	24612	195	,	,	,
18637	24612	196	3	3	CD
18637	24612	197	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24612	198	.	.	.
18637	24613	1	336	336	CD
18637	24613	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24613	3	1818	1818	CD
18637	24613	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24613	5	,	,	,
18637	24613	6	578	578	CD
18637	24613	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24613	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24613	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24613	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24613	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24613	12	Bitty	Bitty	NNP
18637	24613	13	,	,	,
18637	24613	14	208	208	CD
18637	24613	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24613	16	393	393	CD
18637	24613	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24613	18	1908	1908	CD
18637	24613	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24613	20	,	,	,
18637	24613	21	615	615	CD
18637	24613	22	United	United	NNP
18637	24613	23	States	States	NNP
18637	24613	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24613	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24613	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24613	27	Brig	Brig	NNP
18637	24613	28	Malek	Malek	NNP
18637	24613	29	Adhel	Adhel	NNP
18637	24613	30	,	,	,
18637	24613	31	2	2	CD
18637	24613	32	How	how	WRB
18637	24613	33	.	.	.
18637	24614	1	210	210	CD
18637	24614	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24614	3	1844	1844	CD
18637	24614	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24614	5	,	,	,
18637	24614	6	278	278	CD
18637	24614	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24614	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24614	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24614	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24614	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24614	12	Brime	Brime	NNP
18637	24614	13	,	,	,
18637	24614	14	272	272	CD
18637	24614	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24614	16	549	549	CD
18637	24614	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24614	18	1926	1926	CD
18637	24614	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24614	20	,	,	,
18637	24614	21	149	149	CD
18637	24614	22	United	United	NNP
18637	24614	23	States	States	NNP
18637	24614	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24614	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24614	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24614	27	Britton	Britton	NNP
18637	24614	28	,	,	,
18637	24614	29	108	108	CD
18637	24614	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24614	31	199	199	CD
18637	24614	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24614	33	1883	1883	CD
18637	24614	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24614	35	,	,	,
18637	24614	36	878	878	CD
18637	24614	37	United	United	NNP
18637	24614	38	States	States	NNP
18637	24614	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24614	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24614	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24614	42	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
18637	24614	43	,	,	,
18637	24614	44	54	54	CD
18637	24614	45	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24614	46	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	24614	47	.	.	.
18637	24615	1	995	995	CD
18637	24615	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24615	3	1944	1944	CD
18637	24615	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24615	5	,	,	,
18637	24615	6	953	953	CD
18637	24615	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24615	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24615	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24615	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24615	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24615	12	Bryan	Bryan	NNP
18637	24615	13	,	,	,
18637	24615	14	339	339	CD
18637	24615	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24615	16	323	323	CD
18637	24615	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24615	18	1950	1950	CD
18637	24615	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24615	20	,	,	,
18637	24615	21	86	86	CD
18637	24615	22	,	,	,
18637	24615	23	98	98	CD
18637	24615	24	United	United	NNP
18637	24615	25	States	States	NNP
18637	24615	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24615	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24615	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24615	29	Burnison	Burnison	NNP
18637	24615	30	,	,	,
18637	24615	31	339	339	CD
18637	24615	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24615	33	87	87	CD
18637	24615	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24615	35	1950	1950	CD
18637	24615	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24615	37	,	,	,
18637	24615	38	724	724	CD
18637	24615	39	United	United	NNP
18637	24615	40	States	States	NNP
18637	24615	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24615	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24615	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24615	44	Burns	Burns	NNP
18637	24615	45	,	,	,
18637	24615	46	12	12	CD
18637	24615	47	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24615	48	.	.	.
18637	24616	1	246	246	CD
18637	24616	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24616	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24616	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24616	5	,	,	,
18637	24616	6	275	275	CD
18637	24616	7	,	,	,
18637	24616	8	404	404	CD
18637	24616	9	United	United	NNP
18637	24616	10	States	States	NNP
18637	24616	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24616	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24616	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24616	14	Burr	Burr	NNP
18637	24616	15	,	,	,
18637	24616	16	4	4	CD
18637	24616	17	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24616	18	.	.	.
18637	24617	1	470	470	CD
18637	24617	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24617	3	1807	1807	CD
18637	24617	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24617	5	,	,	,
18637	24617	6	640	640	CD
18637	24617	7	,	,	,
18637	24617	8	643	643	CD
18637	24617	9	,	,	,
18637	24617	10	645	645	CD
18637	24617	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24617	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24617	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24617	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	16	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	24617	17	,	,	,
18637	24617	18	297	297	CD
18637	24617	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24617	20	1	1	CD
18637	24617	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24617	22	1936	1936	CD
18637	24617	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24617	24	,	,	,
18637	24617	25	114	114	CD
18637	24617	26	,	,	,
18637	24617	27	115	115	CD
18637	24617	28	,	,	,
18637	24617	29	153	153	CD
18637	24617	30	,	,	,
18637	24617	31	561	561	CD
18637	24617	32	,	,	,
18637	24617	33	564	564	CD
18637	24617	34	,	,	,
18637	24617	35	918	918	CD
18637	24617	36	United	United	NNP
18637	24617	37	States	States	NNP
18637	24617	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24617	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	41	California	California	NNP
18637	24617	42	,	,	,
18637	24617	43	297	297	CD
18637	24617	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24617	45	175	175	CD
18637	24617	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24617	47	1936	1936	CD
18637	24617	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24617	49	,	,	,
18637	24617	50	139	139	CD
18637	24617	51	,	,	,
18637	24617	52	920	920	CD
18637	24617	53	United	United	NNP
18637	24617	54	States	States	NNP
18637	24617	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24617	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	58	California	California	NNP
18637	24617	59	,	,	,
18637	24617	60	332	332	CD
18637	24617	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24617	62	19	19	CD
18637	24617	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24617	64	1947	1947	CD
18637	24617	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24617	66	,	,	,
18637	24617	67	163	163	CD
18637	24617	68	,	,	,
18637	24617	69	325	325	CD
18637	24617	70	,	,	,
18637	24617	71	585	585	CD
18637	24617	72	,	,	,
18637	24617	73	700	700	CD
18637	24617	74	United	United	NNP
18637	24617	75	States	States	NNP
18637	24617	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	24617	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	79	Capital	Capital	NNP
18637	24617	80	Transit	Transit	NNP
18637	24617	81	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24617	82	,	,	,
18637	24617	83	338	338	CD
18637	24617	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24617	85	286	286	CD
18637	24617	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24617	87	1949	1949	CD
18637	24617	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24617	89	,	,	,
18637	24617	90	137	137	CD
18637	24617	91	United	United	NNP
18637	24617	92	States	States	NNP
18637	24617	93	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	94	v.	v.	IN
18637	24617	95	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	96	Carll	Carll	NNP
18637	24617	97	,	,	,
18637	24617	98	105	105	CD
18637	24617	99	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24617	100	611	611	CD
18637	24617	101	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24617	102	1882	1882	CD
18637	24617	103	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24617	104	,	,	,
18637	24617	105	884	884	CD
18637	24617	106	United	United	NNP
18637	24617	107	States	States	NNP
18637	24617	108	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	109	v.	v.	IN
18637	24617	110	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	111	Carmack	Carmack	NNP
18637	24617	112	,	,	,
18637	24617	113	329	329	CD
18637	24617	114	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24617	115	230	230	CD
18637	24617	116	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24617	117	1946	1946	CD
18637	24617	118	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24617	119	,	,	,
18637	24617	120	865	865	CD
18637	24617	121	United	United	NNP
18637	24617	122	States	States	NNP
18637	24617	123	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	124	v.	v.	IN
18637	24617	125	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	126	Carolene	Carolene	NNP
18637	24617	127	Products	Products	NNP
18637	24617	128	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24617	129	,	,	,
18637	24617	130	304	304	CD
18637	24617	131	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24617	132	144	144	CD
18637	24617	133	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24617	134	1938	1938	CD
18637	24617	135	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24617	136	,	,	,
18637	24617	137	124	124	CD
18637	24617	138	,	,	,
18637	24617	139	563	563	CD
18637	24617	140	,	,	,
18637	24617	141	791	791	CD
18637	24617	142	,	,	,
18637	24617	143	804	804	CD
18637	24617	144	,	,	,
18637	24617	145	859	859	CD
18637	24617	146	,	,	,
18637	24617	147	918	918	CD
18637	24617	148	United	United	NNP
18637	24617	149	States	States	NNP
18637	24617	150	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	151	v.	v.	IN
18637	24617	152	_	_	NNP
18637	24617	153	Cathcart	Cathcart	NNP
18637	24617	154	,	,	,
18637	24617	155	25	25	CD
18637	24617	156	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24617	157	.	.	.
18637	24618	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24618	2	.	.	.
18637	24619	1	No	no	UH
18637	24619	2	.	.	.
18637	24620	1	14,756	14,756	CD
18637	24620	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24620	3	1864	1864	CD
18637	24620	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24620	5	,	,	,
18637	24620	6	643	643	CD
18637	24620	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24620	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24620	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24620	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24620	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24620	12	Causby	Causby	NNP
18637	24620	13	,	,	,
18637	24620	14	328	328	CD
18637	24620	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24620	16	256	256	CD
18637	24620	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24620	18	1946	1946	CD
18637	24620	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24620	20	,	,	,
18637	24620	21	867	867	CD
18637	24620	22	,	,	,
18637	24620	23	1065	1065	CD
18637	24620	24	,	,	,
18637	24620	25	1068	1068	CD
18637	24620	26	United	United	NNP
18637	24620	27	States	States	NNP
18637	24620	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24620	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24620	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24620	31	Chamber	Chamber	NNP
18637	24620	32	,	,	,
18637	24620	33	291	291	CD
18637	24620	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24620	35	217	217	CD
18637	24620	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24620	37	1934	1934	CD
18637	24620	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24620	39	,	,	,
18637	24620	40	545	545	CD
18637	24620	41	,	,	,
18637	24620	42	1214	1214	CD
18637	24620	43	United	United	NNP
18637	24620	44	States	States	NNP
18637	24620	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24620	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	24620	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24620	48	Chandler	Chandler	NNP
18637	24620	49	-	-	HYPH
18637	24620	50	Dunbar	Dunbar	NNP
18637	24620	51	Waterpower	Waterpower	NNP
18637	24620	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24620	53	,	,	,
18637	24620	54	229	229	CD
18637	24620	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24620	56	53	53	CD
18637	24620	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24620	58	1913	1913	CD
18637	24620	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24620	60	,	,	,
18637	24620	61	128	128	CD
18637	24620	62	,	,	,
18637	24620	63	130	130	CD
18637	24620	64	,	,	,
18637	24620	65	869	869	CD
18637	24620	66	,	,	,
18637	24620	67	870	870	CD
18637	24620	68	United	United	NNP
18637	24620	69	States	States	NNP
18637	24620	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24620	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	24620	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24620	73	Chemical	Chemical	NNP
18637	24620	74	Foundation	Foundation	NNP
18637	24620	75	,	,	,
18637	24620	76	272	272	CD
18637	24620	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24620	78	1	1	CD
18637	24620	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24620	80	1926	1926	CD
18637	24620	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24620	82	,	,	,
18637	24620	83	80	80	CD
18637	24620	84	,	,	,
18637	24620	85	290	290	CD
18637	24620	86	,	,	,
18637	24620	87	295	295	CD
18637	24620	88	,	,	,
18637	24620	89	865	865	CD
18637	24620	90	United	United	NNP
18637	24620	91	States	States	NNP
18637	24620	92	_	_	NNP
18637	24620	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	24620	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24620	95	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	24620	96	,	,	,
18637	24620	97	M.	M.	NNP
18637	24620	98	,	,	,
18637	24620	99	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24620	100	P.	P.	NNP
18637	24620	101	&	&	CC
18637	24620	102	Pac	Pac	NNP
18637	24620	103	.	.	.
18637	24621	1	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24621	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24621	3	,	,	,
18637	24621	4	312	312	CD
18637	24621	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24621	6	592	592	CD
18637	24621	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24621	8	1941	1941	CD
18637	24621	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24621	10	,	,	,
18637	24621	11	128	128	CD
18637	24621	12	United	United	NNP
18637	24621	13	States	States	NNP
18637	24621	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24621	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24621	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24621	17	C.I.O.	C.I.O.	NNP
18637	24621	18	,	,	,
18637	24621	19	335	335	CD
18637	24621	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24621	21	105	105	CD
18637	24621	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24621	23	1948	1948	CD
18637	24621	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24621	25	,	,	,
18637	24621	26	565	565	CD
18637	24621	27	,	,	,
18637	24621	28	793	793	CD
18637	24621	29	United	United	NNP
18637	24621	30	States	States	NNP
18637	24621	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24621	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24621	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24621	34	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	24621	35	,	,	,
18637	24621	36	8	8	CD
18637	24621	37	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24621	38	.	.	.
18637	24622	1	436	436	CD
18637	24622	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24622	3	1834	1834	CD
18637	24622	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24622	5	,	,	,
18637	24622	6	585	585	CD
18637	24622	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24622	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24622	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24622	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24622	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24622	12	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	24622	13	,	,	,
18637	24622	14	20	20	CD
18637	24622	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24622	16	.	.	.
18637	24623	1	92	92	CD
18637	24623	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24623	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	24623	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24623	5	,	,	,
18637	24623	6	477	477	CD
18637	24623	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24623	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24623	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24623	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24623	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24623	12	Classic	Classic	NNP
18637	24623	13	,	,	,
18637	24623	14	313	313	CD
18637	24623	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24623	16	299	299	CD
18637	24623	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24623	18	1941	1941	CD
18637	24623	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24623	20	87	87	CD
18637	24623	21	,	,	,
18637	24623	22	94	94	CD
18637	24623	23	,	,	,
18637	24623	24	1164	1164	CD
18637	24623	25	,	,	,
18637	24623	26	1176	1176	CD
18637	24623	27	,	,	,
18637	24623	28	1185	1185	CD
18637	24623	29	United	United	NNP
18637	24623	30	States	States	NNP
18637	24623	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24623	32	v.	v.	IN
18637	24623	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24623	34	Coe	Coe	NNP
18637	24623	35	,	,	,
18637	24623	36	155	155	CD
18637	24623	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24623	38	76	76	CD
18637	24623	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24623	40	1894	1894	CD
18637	24623	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24623	42	,	,	,
18637	24623	43	534	534	CD
18637	24623	44	United	United	NNP
18637	24623	45	States	States	NNP
18637	24623	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24623	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	24623	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24623	49	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
18637	24623	50	Grocery	Grocery	NNP
18637	24623	51	Company	Company	NNP
18637	24623	52	,	,	,
18637	24623	53	255	255	CD
18637	24623	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24623	55	81	81	CD
18637	24623	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24623	57	1921	1921	CD
18637	24623	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24623	59	,	,	,
18637	24623	60	881	881	CD
18637	24623	61	United	United	NNP
18637	24623	62	States	States	NNP
18637	24623	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24623	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	24623	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24623	66	Commodities	Commodities	NNPS
18637	24623	67	Trading	Trading	NNP
18637	24623	68	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24623	69	,	,	,
18637	24623	70	339	339	CD
18637	24623	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24623	72	121	121	CD
18637	24623	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24623	74	1950	1950	CD
18637	24623	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24623	76	,	,	,
18637	24623	77	298	298	CD
18637	24623	78	,	,	,
18637	24623	79	870	870	CD
18637	24623	80	United	United	NNP
18637	24623	81	States	States	NNP
18637	24623	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24623	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	24623	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24623	85	Commodore	Commodore	NNP
18637	24623	86	Park	Park	NNP
18637	24623	87	,	,	,
18637	24623	88	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	24623	89	,	,	,
18637	24623	90	324	324	CD
18637	24623	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24623	92	386	386	CD
18637	24623	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24623	94	1945	1945	CD
18637	24623	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24623	96	,	,	,
18637	24623	97	128	128	CD
18637	24623	98	,	,	,
18637	24623	99	868	868	CD
18637	24623	100	United	United	NNP
18637	24623	101	States	States	NNP
18637	24623	102	_	_	NNP
18637	24623	103	v.	v.	IN
18637	24623	104	_	_	NNP
18637	24623	105	Constantine	Constantine	NNP
18637	24623	106	,	,	,
18637	24623	107	296	296	CD
18637	24623	108	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24623	109	287	287	CD
18637	24623	110	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24623	111	1935	1935	CD
18637	24623	112	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24623	113	,	,	,
18637	24623	114	110	110	CD
18637	24623	115	,	,	,
18637	24623	116	111	111	CD
18637	24623	117	,	,	,
18637	24623	118	919	919	CD
18637	24623	119	,	,	,
18637	24623	120	1214	1214	CD
18637	24623	121	United	United	NNP
18637	24623	122	States	States	NNP
18637	24623	123	_	_	NNP
18637	24623	124	v.	v.	IN
18637	24623	125	_	_	NNP
18637	24623	126	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	24623	127	,	,	,
18637	24623	128	17	17	CD
18637	24623	129	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24623	130	.	.	.
18637	24624	1	168	168	CD
18637	24624	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24624	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	24624	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24624	5	,	,	,
18637	24624	6	884	884	CD
18637	24624	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24624	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24624	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24624	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24624	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24624	12	Coolidge	Coolidge	NNP
18637	24624	13	,	,	,
18637	24624	14	1	1	CD
18637	24624	15	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24624	16	.	.	.
18637	24625	1	415	415	CD
18637	24625	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24625	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	24625	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24625	5	,	,	,
18637	24625	6	878	878	CD
18637	24625	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24625	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24625	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24625	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24625	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24625	12	Coombs	Coombs	NNP
18637	24625	13	,	,	,
18637	24625	14	12	12	CD
18637	24625	15	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24625	16	.	.	.
18637	24626	1	72	72	CD
18637	24626	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24626	3	1838	1838	CD
18637	24626	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24626	5	,	,	,
18637	24626	6	578	578	CD
18637	24626	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24626	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24626	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24626	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24626	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24626	12	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
18637	24626	13	,	,	,
18637	24626	14	4	4	CD
18637	24626	15	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	24626	16	.	.	.
18637	24627	1	341	341	CD
18637	24627	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24627	3	1800	1800	CD
18637	24627	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24627	5	,	,	,
18637	24627	6	99	99	CD
18637	24627	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24627	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24627	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24627	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24627	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24627	12	Cornell	Cornell	NNP
18637	24627	13	,	,	,
18637	24627	14	25	25	CD
18637	24627	15	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24627	16	.	.	.
18637	24628	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24628	2	.	.	.
18637	24629	1	No	no	UH
18637	24629	2	.	.	.
18637	24630	1	14,867	14,867	CD
18637	24630	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24630	3	1819	1819	CD
18637	24630	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24630	5	,	,	,
18637	24630	6	307	307	CD
18637	24630	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24630	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24630	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24630	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	12	Cors	Cors	NNP
18637	24630	13	,	,	,
18637	24630	14	337	337	CD
18637	24630	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24630	16	325	325	CD
18637	24630	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24630	18	1949	1949	CD
18637	24630	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24630	20	,	,	,
18637	24630	21	298	298	CD
18637	24630	22	,	,	,
18637	24630	23	870	870	CD
18637	24630	24	United	United	NNP
18637	24630	25	States	States	NNP
18637	24630	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24630	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	29	Corson	Corson	NNP
18637	24630	30	,	,	,
18637	24630	31	114	114	CD
18637	24630	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24630	33	619	619	CD
18637	24630	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24630	35	1885	1885	CD
18637	24630	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24630	37	,	,	,
18637	24630	38	404	404	CD
18637	24630	39	United	United	NNP
18637	24630	40	States	States	NNP
18637	24630	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24630	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	44	Cramer	Cramer	NNP
18637	24630	45	,	,	,
18637	24630	46	137	137	CD
18637	24630	47	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24630	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24630	49	2d	2d	NNP
18637	24630	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24630	51	888	888	CD
18637	24630	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24630	53	1943	1943	CD
18637	24630	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24630	55	,	,	,
18637	24630	56	643	643	CD
18637	24630	57	United	United	NNP
18637	24630	58	States	States	NNP
18637	24630	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	24630	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	62	Cress	Cress	NNP
18637	24630	63	,	,	,
18637	24630	64	243	243	CD
18637	24630	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24630	66	316	316	CD
18637	24630	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24630	68	1917	1917	CD
18637	24630	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24630	70	,	,	,
18637	24630	71	128	128	CD
18637	24630	72	,	,	,
18637	24630	73	869	869	CD
18637	24630	74	,	,	,
18637	24630	75	1065	1065	CD
18637	24630	76	,	,	,
18637	24630	77	1068	1068	CD
18637	24630	78	United	United	NNP
18637	24630	79	States	States	NNP
18637	24630	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	24630	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	83	Cruikshank	Cruikshank	NNP
18637	24630	84	,	,	,
18637	24630	85	92	92	CD
18637	24630	86	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24630	87	542	542	CD
18637	24630	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24630	89	1876	1876	CD
18637	24630	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24630	91	,	,	,
18637	24630	92	806	806	CD
18637	24630	93	,	,	,
18637	24630	94	807	807	CD
18637	24630	95	,	,	,
18637	24630	96	813	813	CD
18637	24630	97	,	,	,
18637	24630	98	884	884	CD
18637	24630	99	,	,	,
18637	24630	100	967	967	CD
18637	24630	101	,	,	,
18637	24630	102	1183	1183	CD
18637	24630	103	United	United	NNP
18637	24630	104	States	States	NNP
18637	24630	105	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	106	v.	v.	IN
18637	24630	107	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	108	Curtiss	Curtiss	NNP
18637	24630	109	-	-	HYPH
18637	24630	110	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	24630	111	Export	Export	NNP
18637	24630	112	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24630	113	,	,	,
18637	24630	114	299	299	CD
18637	24630	115	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24630	116	304	304	CD
18637	24630	117	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24630	118	1936	1936	CD
18637	24630	119	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24630	120	,	,	,
18637	24630	121	72	72	CD
18637	24630	122	,	,	,
18637	24630	123	73	73	CD
18637	24630	124	,	,	,
18637	24630	125	80	80	CD
18637	24630	126	,	,	,
18637	24630	127	280	280	CD
18637	24630	128	,	,	,
18637	24630	129	380	380	CD
18637	24630	130	,	,	,
18637	24630	131	392	392	CD
18637	24630	132	,	,	,
18637	24630	133	413	413	CD
18637	24630	134	,	,	,
18637	24630	135	429	429	CD
18637	24630	136	United	United	NNP
18637	24630	137	States	States	NNP
18637	24630	138	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	139	v.	v.	IN
18637	24630	140	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	141	Darby	Darby	NNP
18637	24630	142	,	,	,
18637	24630	143	312	312	CD
18637	24630	144	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24630	145	100	100	CD
18637	24630	146	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24630	147	1941	1941	CD
18637	24630	148	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24630	149	153	153	CD
18637	24630	150	,	,	,
18637	24630	151	156	156	CD
18637	24630	152	,	,	,
18637	24630	153	163	163	CD
18637	24630	154	,	,	,
18637	24630	155	173	173	CD
18637	24630	156	,	,	,
18637	24630	157	724	724	CD
18637	24630	158	,	,	,
18637	24630	159	827	827	CD
18637	24630	160	,	,	,
18637	24630	161	883	883	CD
18637	24630	162	,	,	,
18637	24630	163	917	917	CD
18637	24630	164	,	,	,
18637	24630	165	918	918	CD
18637	24630	166	United	United	NNP
18637	24630	167	States	States	NNP
18637	24630	168	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	169	v.	v.	IN
18637	24630	170	_	_	NNP
18637	24630	171	Dawson	Dawson	NNP
18637	24630	172	,	,	,
18637	24630	173	15	15	CD
18637	24630	174	How	how	WRB
18637	24630	175	.	.	.
18637	24631	1	467	467	CD
18637	24631	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24631	3	1853	1853	CD
18637	24631	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24631	5	,	,	,
18637	24631	6	881	881	CD
18637	24631	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24631	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24631	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24631	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24631	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24631	12	De	De	NNP
18637	24631	13	Los	Los	NNP
18637	24631	14	Reyes	Reyes	NNP
18637	24631	15	,	,	,
18637	24631	16	3	3	CD
18637	24631	17	Phil	Phil	NNP
18637	24631	18	.	.	.
18637	24632	1	349	349	CD
18637	24632	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24632	3	1904	1904	CD
18637	24632	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24632	5	,	,	,
18637	24632	6	643	643	CD
18637	24632	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24632	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24632	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24632	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24632	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24632	12	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	24632	13	&	&	CC
18637	24632	14	H.	H.	NNP
18637	24632	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24632	16	,	,	,
18637	24632	17	213	213	CD
18637	24632	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24632	19	366	366	CD
18637	24632	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24632	21	1909	1909	CD
18637	24632	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24632	23	,	,	,
18637	24632	24	137	137	CD
18637	24632	25	,	,	,
18637	24632	26	565	565	CD
18637	24632	27	United	United	NNP
18637	24632	28	States	States	NNP
18637	24632	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24632	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24632	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24632	32	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
18637	24632	33	Timber	Timber	NNP
18637	24632	34	&	&	CC
18637	24632	35	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	24632	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24632	37	,	,	,
18637	24632	38	200	200	CD
18637	24632	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24632	40	321	321	CD
18637	24632	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24632	42	1906	1906	CD
18637	24632	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24632	44	,	,	,
18637	24632	45	524	524	CD
18637	24632	46	United	United	NNP
18637	24632	47	States	States	NNP
18637	24632	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24632	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	24632	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24632	51	De	De	NNP
18637	24632	52	Walt	Walt	NNP
18637	24632	53	,	,	,
18637	24632	54	128	128	CD
18637	24632	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24632	56	393	393	CD
18637	24632	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24632	58	1888	1888	CD
18637	24632	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24632	60	,	,	,
18637	24632	61	838	838	CD
18637	24632	62	United	United	NNP
18637	24632	63	States	States	NNP
18637	24632	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24632	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	24632	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24632	67	Dewitt	Dewitt	NNP
18637	24632	68	,	,	,
18637	24632	69	9	9	CD
18637	24632	70	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24632	71	.	.	.
18637	24633	1	41	41	CD
18637	24633	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24633	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	24633	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24633	5	,	,	,
18637	24633	6	122	122	CD
18637	24633	7	,	,	,
18637	24633	8	168	168	CD
18637	24633	9	,	,	,
18637	24633	10	917	917	CD
18637	24633	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24633	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24633	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24633	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24633	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24633	16	Dickinson	Dickinson	NNP
18637	24633	17	,	,	,
18637	24633	18	331	331	CD
18637	24633	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24633	20	745	745	CD
18637	24633	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24633	22	1947	1947	CD
18637	24633	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24633	24	,	,	,
18637	24633	25	867	867	CD
18637	24633	26	,	,	,
18637	24633	27	869	869	CD
18637	24633	28	United	United	NNP
18637	24633	29	States	States	NNP
18637	24633	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24633	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24633	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24633	33	Di	Di	NNP
18637	24633	34	Re	Re	NNP
18637	24633	35	,	,	,
18637	24633	36	332	332	CD
18637	24633	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24633	38	581	581	CD
18637	24633	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24633	40	1948	1948	CD
18637	24633	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24633	42	,	,	,
18637	24633	43	830	830	CD
18637	24633	44	United	United	NNP
18637	24633	45	States	States	NNP
18637	24633	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24633	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	24633	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24633	49	Doremus	Doremus	NNP
18637	24633	50	,	,	,
18637	24633	51	249	249	CD
18637	24633	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24633	53	86	86	CD
18637	24633	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24633	55	1919	1919	CD
18637	24633	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24633	57	,	,	,
18637	24633	58	111	111	CD
18637	24633	59	United	United	NNP
18637	24633	60	States	States	NNP
18637	24633	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24633	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	24633	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24633	64	Duell	Duell	NNP
18637	24633	65	,	,	,
18637	24633	66	172	172	CD
18637	24633	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24633	68	576	576	CD
18637	24633	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24633	70	1899	1899	CD
18637	24633	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24633	72	,	,	,
18637	24633	73	274	274	CD
18637	24633	74	United	United	NNP
18637	24633	75	States	States	NNP
18637	24633	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24633	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	24633	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24633	79	Dunnington	Dunnington	NNP
18637	24633	80	,	,	,
18637	24633	81	146	146	CD
18637	24633	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24633	83	338	338	CD
18637	24633	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24633	85	1892	1892	CD
18637	24633	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24633	87	,	,	,
18637	24633	88	865	865	CD
18637	24633	89	United	United	NNP
18637	24633	90	States	States	NNP
18637	24633	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24633	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	24633	93	_	_	NNP
18637	24633	94	Eaton	Eaton	NNP
18637	24633	95	,	,	,
18637	24633	96	144	144	CD
18637	24633	97	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24633	98	677	677	CD
18637	24633	99	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24633	100	1892	1892	CD
18637	24633	101	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24633	102	,	,	,
18637	24633	103	82	82	CD
18637	24633	104	,	,	,
18637	24633	105	878	878	CD
18637	24633	106	United	United	NNP
18637	24633	107	States	States	NNP
18637	24633	108	_	_	NNP
18637	24633	109	v.	v.	IN
18637	24633	110	_	_	NNP
18637	24633	111	Eckford	Eckford	NNP
18637	24633	112	,	,	,
18637	24633	113	6	6	CD
18637	24633	114	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24633	115	.	.	.
18637	24634	1	484	484	CD
18637	24634	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24634	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	24634	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24634	5	,	,	,
18637	24634	6	586	586	CD
18637	24634	7	,	,	,
18637	24634	8	619	619	CD
18637	24634	9	United	United	NNP
18637	24634	10	States	States	NNP
18637	24634	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24634	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24634	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24634	14	E.C.	E.C.	NNP
18637	24635	1	Knight	Knight	NNP
18637	24635	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24635	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24635	4	The	the	DT
18637	24635	5	"	"	``
18637	24635	6	Sugar	Sugar	NNP
18637	24635	7	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24635	8	"	"	''
18637	24635	9	Case	Case	NNP
18637	24635	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24635	11	,	,	,
18637	24635	12	156	156	CD
18637	24635	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24635	14	1	1	CD
18637	24635	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24635	16	1895	1895	CD
18637	24635	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24635	18	,	,	,
18637	24635	19	144	144	CD
18637	24635	20	,	,	,
18637	24635	21	154	154	CD
18637	24635	22	United	United	NNP
18637	24635	23	States	States	NNP
18637	24635	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24635	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24635	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24635	27	Eliason	Eliason	NNP
18637	24635	28	,	,	,
18637	24635	29	16	16	CD
18637	24635	30	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24635	31	.	.	.
18637	24636	1	291	291	CD
18637	24636	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24636	3	1842	1842	CD
18637	24636	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24636	5	,	,	,
18637	24636	6	302	302	CD
18637	24636	7	,	,	,
18637	24636	8	477	477	CD
18637	24636	9	,	,	,
18637	24636	10	482	482	CD
18637	24636	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24636	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24636	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24636	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24636	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24636	16	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	24636	17	,	,	,
18637	24636	18	213	213	CD
18637	24636	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24636	20	297	297	CD
18637	24636	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24636	22	1909	1909	CD
18637	24636	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24636	24	,	,	,
18637	24636	25	545	545	CD
18637	24636	26	,	,	,
18637	24636	27	839	839	CD
18637	24636	28	United	United	NNP
18637	24636	29	States	States	NNP
18637	24636	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24636	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24636	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24636	33	Farden	Farden	NNP
18637	24636	34	,	,	,
18637	24636	35	99	99	CD
18637	24636	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24636	37	10	10	CD
18637	24636	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24636	39	1879	1879	CD
18637	24636	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24636	41	,	,	,
18637	24636	42	477	477	CD
18637	24636	43	United	United	NNP
18637	24636	44	States	States	NNP
18637	24636	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24636	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	24636	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24636	48	Felin	Felin	NNP
18637	24636	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24636	50	J.J.	J.J.	NNP
18637	24636	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24636	52	&	&	CC
18637	24636	53	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24636	54	,	,	,
18637	24636	55	334	334	CD
18637	24636	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24636	57	624	624	CD
18637	24636	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24636	59	1948	1948	CD
18637	24636	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24636	61	,	,	,
18637	24636	62	870	870	CD
18637	24636	63	United	United	NNP
18637	24636	64	States	States	NNP
18637	24636	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24636	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	24636	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24636	68	Ferger	Ferger	NNP
18637	24636	69	,	,	,
18637	24636	70	250	250	CD
18637	24636	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24636	72	199	199	CD
18637	24636	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24636	74	1919	1919	CD
18637	24636	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24636	76	,	,	,
18637	24636	77	143	143	CD
18637	24636	78	,	,	,
18637	24636	79	919	919	CD
18637	24636	80	United	United	NNP
18637	24636	81	States	States	NNP
18637	24636	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24636	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	24636	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24636	85	Ferreira	Ferreira	NNP
18637	24636	86	,	,	,
18637	24636	87	13	13	CD
18637	24636	88	How	how	WRB
18637	24636	89	.	.	.
18637	24637	1	40	40	CD
18637	24637	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24637	3	1852	1852	CD
18637	24637	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24637	5	,	,	,
18637	24637	6	513	513	CD
18637	24637	7	,	,	,
18637	24637	8	535	535	CD
18637	24637	9	,	,	,
18637	24637	10	550	550	CD
18637	24637	11	,	,	,
18637	24637	12	551	551	CD
18637	24637	13	,	,	,
18637	24637	14	623	623	CD
18637	24637	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24637	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24637	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24637	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	24637	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24637	20	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	24637	21	,	,	,
18637	24637	22	2	2	CD
18637	24637	23	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24637	24	.	.	.
18637	24638	1	358	358	CD
18637	24638	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24638	3	1805	1805	CD
18637	24638	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24638	5	,	,	,
18637	24638	6	117	117	CD
18637	24638	7	,	,	,
18637	24638	8	307	307	CD
18637	24638	9	,	,	,
18637	24638	10	722	722	CD
18637	24638	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24638	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24638	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24638	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24638	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24638	16	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	24638	17	,	,	,
18637	24638	18	109	109	CD
18637	24638	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24638	20	143	143	CD
18637	24638	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24638	22	1883	1883	CD
18637	24638	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24638	24	,	,	,
18637	24638	25	341	341	CD
18637	24638	26	United	United	NNP
18637	24638	27	States	States	NNP
18637	24638	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24638	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24638	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24638	31	Fitzgerald	Fitzgerald	NNP
18637	24638	32	,	,	,
18637	24638	33	15	15	CD
18637	24638	34	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24638	35	.	.	.
18637	24639	1	407	407	CD
18637	24639	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24639	3	1841	1841	CD
18637	24639	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24639	5	,	,	,
18637	24639	6	702	702	CD
18637	24639	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24639	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24639	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24639	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24639	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24639	12	Fleischman	Fleischman	NNP
18637	24639	13	,	,	,
18637	24639	14	339	339	CD
18637	24639	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24639	16	349	349	CD
18637	24639	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24639	18	1950	1950	CD
18637	24639	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24639	20	,	,	,
18637	24639	21	86	86	CD
18637	24639	22	United	United	NNP
18637	24639	23	States	States	NNP
18637	24639	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24639	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24639	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24639	27	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
18637	24639	28	,	,	,
18637	24639	29	148	148	CD
18637	24639	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24639	31	84	84	CD
18637	24639	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24639	33	1893	1893	CD
18637	24639	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24639	35	,	,	,
18637	24639	36	476	476	CD
18637	24639	37	,	,	,
18637	24639	38	477	477	CD
18637	24639	39	United	United	NNP
18637	24639	40	States	States	NNP
18637	24639	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24639	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24639	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24639	44	Flores	Flores	NNP
18637	24639	45	,	,	,
18637	24639	46	3	3	CD
18637	24639	47	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24639	48	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	24639	49	.	.	.
18637	24640	1	134	134	CD
18637	24640	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24640	3	1932	1932	CD
18637	24640	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24640	5	,	,	,
18637	24640	6	279	279	CD
18637	24640	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24640	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24640	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24640	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	12	Flores	Flores	NNP
18637	24640	13	,	,	,
18637	24640	14	289	289	CD
18637	24640	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24640	16	137	137	CD
18637	24640	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24640	18	1933	1933	CD
18637	24640	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24640	20	,	,	,
18637	24640	21	279	279	CD
18637	24640	22	United	United	NNP
18637	24640	23	States	States	NNP
18637	24640	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24640	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	27	Forty	Forty	NNP
18637	24640	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	24640	29	three	three	CD
18637	24640	30	Gallons	Gallons	NNPS
18637	24640	31	of	of	IN
18637	24640	32	Whiskey	Whiskey	NNP
18637	24640	33	,	,	,
18637	24640	34	93	93	CD
18637	24640	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24640	36	188	188	CD
18637	24640	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24640	38	1876	1876	CD
18637	24640	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24640	40	,	,	,
18637	24640	41	421	421	CD
18637	24640	42	United	United	NNP
18637	24640	43	States	States	NNP
18637	24640	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24640	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	47	Forty	Forty	NNP
18637	24640	48	-	-	HYPH
18637	24640	49	three	three	CD
18637	24640	50	Gallons	Gallons	NNPS
18637	24640	51	of	of	IN
18637	24640	52	Whiskey	Whiskey	NNP
18637	24640	53	,	,	,
18637	24640	54	108	108	CD
18637	24640	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24640	56	491	491	CD
18637	24640	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24640	58	1883	1883	CD
18637	24640	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24640	60	,	,	,
18637	24640	61	432	432	CD
18637	24640	62	United	United	NNP
18637	24640	63	States	States	NNP
18637	24640	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	24640	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	67	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	24640	68	,	,	,
18637	24640	69	94	94	CD
18637	24640	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24640	71	315	315	CD
18637	24640	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24640	73	1877	1877	CD
18637	24640	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24640	75	,	,	,
18637	24640	76	308	308	CD
18637	24640	77	United	United	NNP
18637	24640	78	States	States	NNP
18637	24640	79	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	24640	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	82	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	24640	83	,	,	,
18637	24640	84	95	95	CD
18637	24640	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24640	86	670	670	CD
18637	24640	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24640	88	1878	1878	CD
18637	24640	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24640	90	,	,	,
18637	24640	91	309	309	CD
18637	24640	92	United	United	NNP
18637	24640	93	States	States	NNP
18637	24640	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	24640	96	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	97	Frankfort	Frankfort	NNP
18637	24640	98	Distilleries	Distilleries	NNPS
18637	24640	99	,	,	,
18637	24640	100	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	24640	101	,	,	,
18637	24640	102	324	324	CD
18637	24640	103	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24640	104	293	293	CD
18637	24640	105	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24640	106	1945	1945	CD
18637	24640	107	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24640	108	,	,	,
18637	24640	109	1234	1234	CD
18637	24640	110	United	United	NNP
18637	24640	111	States	States	NNP
18637	24640	112	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	24640	114	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	115	Fricke	Fricke	NNP
18637	24640	116	,	,	,
18637	24640	117	259	259	CD
18637	24640	118	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24640	119	673	673	CD
18637	24640	120	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24640	121	1919	1919	CD
18637	24640	122	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24640	123	,	,	,
18637	24640	124	643	643	CD
18637	24640	125	United	United	NNP
18637	24640	126	States	States	NNP
18637	24640	127	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	128	v.	v.	IN
18637	24640	129	_	_	NNP
18637	24640	130	Furlong	Furlong	NNP
18637	24640	131	,	,	,
18637	24640	132	5	5	CD
18637	24640	133	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24640	134	.	.	.
18637	24641	1	184	184	CD
18637	24641	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24641	3	1820	1820	CD
18637	24641	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24641	5	,	,	,
18637	24641	6	297	297	CD
18637	24641	7	,	,	,
18637	24641	8	841	841	CD
18637	24641	9	United	United	NNP
18637	24641	10	States	States	NNP
18637	24641	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24641	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24641	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24641	14	Gale	Gale	NNP
18637	24641	15	,	,	,
18637	24641	16	109	109	CD
18637	24641	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24641	18	65	65	CD
18637	24641	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24641	20	1883	1883	CD
18637	24641	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24641	22	,	,	,
18637	24641	23	93	93	CD
18637	24641	24	,	,	,
18637	24641	25	94	94	CD
18637	24641	26	United	United	NNP
18637	24641	27	States	States	NNP
18637	24641	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24641	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24641	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24641	31	Garbish	Garbish	NNP
18637	24641	32	,	,	,
18637	24641	33	222	222	CD
18637	24641	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24641	35	257	257	CD
18637	24641	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24641	37	1911	1911	CD
18637	24641	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24641	39	,	,	,
18637	24641	40	855	855	CD
18637	24641	41	United	United	NNP
18637	24641	42	States	States	NNP
18637	24641	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24641	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24641	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24641	46	Gaskin	Gaskin	NNP
18637	24641	47	,	,	,
18637	24641	48	320	320	CD
18637	24641	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24641	50	527	527	CD
18637	24641	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24641	52	1944	1944	CD
18637	24641	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24641	54	,	,	,
18637	24641	55	954	954	CD
18637	24641	56	United	United	NNP
18637	24641	57	States	States	NNP
18637	24641	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24641	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24641	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24641	61	General	General	NNP
18637	24641	62	Motors	Motors	NNPS
18637	24641	63	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24641	64	,	,	,
18637	24641	65	323	323	CD
18637	24641	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24641	67	373	373	CD
18637	24641	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24641	69	1945	1945	CD
18637	24641	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24641	71	,	,	,
18637	24641	72	298	298	CD
18637	24641	73	,	,	,
18637	24641	74	871	871	CD
18637	24641	75	United	United	NNP
18637	24641	76	States	States	NNP
18637	24641	77	_	_	NNP
18637	24641	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	24641	79	_	_	NNP
18637	24641	80	Germaine	Germaine	NNP
18637	24641	81	,	,	,
18637	24641	82	99	99	CD
18637	24641	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24641	84	508	508	CD
18637	24641	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24641	86	1879	1879	CD
18637	24641	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24641	88	,	,	,
18637	24641	89	452	452	CD
18637	24641	90	United	United	NNP
18637	24641	91	States	States	NNP
18637	24641	92	_	_	NNP
18637	24641	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	24641	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24641	95	Gettysburg	Gettysburg	NNP
18637	24641	96	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	24641	97	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24641	98	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24641	99	,	,	,
18637	24641	100	160	160	CD
18637	24641	101	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24641	102	668	668	CD
18637	24641	103	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24641	104	1896	1896	CD
18637	24641	105	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24641	106	,	,	,
18637	24641	107	114	114	CD
18637	24641	108	,	,	,
18637	24641	109	866	866	CD
18637	24641	110	United	United	NNP
18637	24641	111	States	States	NNP
18637	24641	112	_	_	NNP
18637	24641	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	24641	114	_	_	NNP
18637	24641	115	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
18637	24641	116	,	,	,
18637	24641	117	25	25	CD
18637	24641	118	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24641	119	.	.	.
18637	24642	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24642	2	.	.	.
18637	24643	1	No	no	UH
18637	24643	2	.	.	.
18637	24644	1	15,231	15,231	CD
18637	24644	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24644	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	24644	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24644	5	,	,	,
18637	24644	6	964	964	CD
18637	24644	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24644	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24644	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24644	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24644	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24644	12	Gradwell	Gradwell	NNP
18637	24644	13	,	,	,
18637	24644	14	243	243	CD
18637	24644	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24644	16	476	476	CD
18637	24644	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24644	18	1917	1917	CD
18637	24644	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24644	20	,	,	,
18637	24644	21	88	88	CD
18637	24644	22	United	United	NNP
18637	24644	23	States	States	NNP
18637	24644	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24644	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24644	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24644	27	Gratiot	Gratiot	NNP
18637	24644	28	,	,	,
18637	24644	29	14	14	CD
18637	24644	30	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24644	31	.	.	.
18637	24645	1	526	526	CD
18637	24645	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24645	3	1840	1840	CD
18637	24645	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24645	5	,	,	,
18637	24645	6	701	701	CD
18637	24645	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24645	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24645	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24645	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24645	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24645	12	Great	Great	NNP
18637	24645	13	Falls	Falls	NNP
18637	24645	14	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	24645	15	.	.	.
18637	24646	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24646	2	,	,	,
18637	24646	3	112	112	CD
18637	24646	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24646	5	645	645	CD
18637	24646	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24646	7	1884	1884	CD
18637	24646	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24646	9	,	,	,
18637	24646	10	872	872	CD
18637	24646	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24646	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24646	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24646	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24646	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24646	16	Greathouse	Greathouse	NNP
18637	24646	17	,	,	,
18637	24646	18	26	26	CD
18637	24646	19	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24646	20	.	.	.
18637	24647	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24647	2	.	.	.
18637	24648	1	No	no	UH
18637	24648	2	.	.	.
18637	24649	1	15,254	15,254	CD
18637	24649	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24649	3	1863	1863	CD
18637	24649	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24649	5	,	,	,
18637	24649	6	643	643	CD
18637	24649	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24649	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24649	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24649	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24649	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24649	12	Greiner	Greiner	NNP
18637	24649	13	,	,	,
18637	24649	14	26	26	CD
18637	24649	15	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24649	16	.	.	.
18637	24650	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24650	2	.	.	.
18637	24651	1	No	no	UH
18637	24651	2	.	.	.
18637	24652	1	15,262	15,262	CD
18637	24652	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24652	3	1861	1861	CD
18637	24652	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24652	5	,	,	,
18637	24652	6	643	643	CD
18637	24652	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24652	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24652	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24652	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24652	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24652	12	Grimaud	Grimaud	NNP
18637	24652	13	,	,	,
18637	24652	14	220	220	CD
18637	24652	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24652	16	506	506	CD
18637	24652	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24652	18	1911	1911	CD
18637	24652	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24652	20	,	,	,
18637	24652	21	76	76	CD
18637	24652	22	,	,	,
18637	24652	23	82	82	CD
18637	24652	24	United	United	NNP
18637	24652	25	States	States	NNP
18637	24652	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24652	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24652	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24652	29	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	24652	30	,	,	,
18637	24652	31	98	98	CD
18637	24652	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24652	33	343	343	CD
18637	24652	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24652	35	1879	1879	CD
18637	24652	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24652	37	,	,	,
18637	24652	38	309	309	CD
18637	24652	39	United	United	NNP
18637	24652	40	States	States	NNP
18637	24652	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24652	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24652	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24652	44	Hammond	Hammond	NNP
18637	24652	45	,	,	,
18637	24652	46	1	1	CD
18637	24652	47	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24652	48	.	.	.
18637	24653	1	15	15	CD
18637	24653	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24653	3	1801	1801	CD
18637	24653	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24653	5	,	,	,
18637	24653	6	301	301	CD
18637	24653	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24653	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24653	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24653	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24653	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24653	12	Hanway	Hanway	NNP
18637	24653	13	,	,	,
18637	24653	14	26	26	CD
18637	24653	15	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24653	16	.	.	.
18637	24654	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24654	2	.	.	.
18637	24655	1	No	no	UH
18637	24655	2	.	.	.
18637	24656	1	15,299	15,299	CD
18637	24656	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24656	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	24656	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24656	5	,	,	,
18637	24656	6	640	640	CD
18637	24656	7	,	,	,
18637	24656	8	643	643	CD
18637	24656	9	United	United	NNP
18637	24656	10	States	States	NNP
18637	24656	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24656	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24656	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24656	14	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	24656	15	,	,	,
18637	24656	16	106	106	CD
18637	24656	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24656	18	629	629	CD
18637	24656	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24656	20	1883	1883	CD
18637	24656	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24656	22	,	,	,
18637	24656	23	688	688	CD
18637	24656	24	,	,	,
18637	24656	25	953	953	CD
18637	24656	26	,	,	,
18637	24656	27	1176	1176	CD
18637	24656	28	United	United	NNP
18637	24656	29	States	States	NNP
18637	24656	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24656	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24656	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24656	33	Hartwell	Hartwell	NNP
18637	24656	34	,	,	,
18637	24656	35	6	6	CD
18637	24656	36	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24656	37	.	.	.
18637	24657	1	385	385	CD
18637	24657	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24657	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	24657	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24657	5	,	,	,
18637	24657	6	386	386	CD
18637	24657	7	,	,	,
18637	24657	8	445	445	CD
18637	24657	9	United	United	NNP
18637	24657	10	States	States	NNP
18637	24657	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24657	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24657	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24657	14	Haupt	Haupt	NNP
18637	24657	15	,	,	,
18637	24657	16	136	136	CD
18637	24657	17	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24657	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24657	19	2d	2d	CD
18637	24657	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24657	21	661	661	CD
18637	24657	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24657	23	1943	1943	CD
18637	24657	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24657	25	,	,	,
18637	24657	26	643	643	CD
18637	24657	27	United	United	NNP
18637	24657	28	States	States	NNP
18637	24657	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24657	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24657	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24657	32	Hayman	Hayman	NNP
18637	24657	33	,	,	,
18637	24657	34	342	342	CD
18637	24657	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24657	36	205	205	CD
18637	24657	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24657	38	1952	1952	CD
18637	24657	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24657	40	,	,	,
18637	24657	41	885	885	CD
18637	24657	42	United	United	NNP
18637	24657	43	States	States	NNP
18637	24657	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24657	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24657	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24657	47	Heinszen	Heinszen	NNP
18637	24657	48	&	&	CC
18637	24657	49	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24657	50	,	,	,
18637	24657	51	206	206	CD
18637	24657	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24657	53	370	370	CD
18637	24657	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24657	55	1907	1907	CD
18637	24657	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24657	57	,	,	,
18637	24657	58	858	858	CD
18637	24657	59	United	United	NNP
18637	24657	60	States	States	NNP
18637	24657	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24657	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	24657	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24657	64	Hill	Hill	NNP
18637	24657	65	,	,	,
18637	24657	66	248	248	CD
18637	24657	67	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24657	68	420	420	CD
18637	24657	69	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24657	70	1919	1919	CD
18637	24657	71	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24657	72	,	,	,
18637	24657	73	120	120	CD
18637	24657	74	,	,	,
18637	24657	75	170	170	CD
18637	24657	76	United	United	NNP
18637	24657	77	States	States	NNP
18637	24657	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24657	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	24657	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24657	81	Hodges	Hodges	NNPS
18637	24657	82	,	,	,
18637	24657	83	26	26	CD
18637	24657	84	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24657	85	.	.	.
18637	24658	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24658	2	.	.	.
18637	24659	1	No	no	UH
18637	24659	2	.	.	.
18637	24660	1	15,374	15,374	CD
18637	24660	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24660	3	1815	1815	CD
18637	24660	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24660	5	,	,	,
18637	24660	6	643	643	CD
18637	24660	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24660	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24660	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24660	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24660	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24660	12	Holliday	Holliday	NNP
18637	24660	13	,	,	,
18637	24660	14	3	3	CD
18637	24660	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24660	16	.	.	.
18637	24661	1	407	407	CD
18637	24661	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24661	3	1866	1866	CD
18637	24661	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24661	5	,	,	,
18637	24661	6	253	253	CD
18637	24661	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24661	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24661	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24661	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24661	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24661	12	Home	Home	NNP
18637	24661	13	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24661	14	.	.	.
18637	24662	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24662	2	,	,	,
18637	24662	3	22	22	CD
18637	24662	4	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24662	5	.	.	.
18637	24663	1	99	99	CD
18637	24663	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24663	3	1875	1875	CD
18637	24663	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24663	5	,	,	,
18637	24663	6	728	728	CD
18637	24663	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24663	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24663	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24663	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24663	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24663	12	Hoxie	Hoxie	NNP
18637	24663	13	,	,	,
18637	24663	14	26	26	CD
18637	24663	15	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24663	16	.	.	.
18637	24664	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24664	2	.	.	.
18637	24665	1	No	no	UH
18637	24665	2	.	.	.
18637	24666	1	15,407	15,407	CD
18637	24666	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24666	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	24666	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24666	5	,	,	,
18637	24666	6	643	643	CD
18637	24666	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24666	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24666	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24666	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24666	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24666	12	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	24666	13	&	&	CC
18637	24666	14	Goodwin	Goodwin	NNP
18637	24666	15	,	,	,
18637	24666	16	299	299	CD
18637	24666	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24666	18	498	498	CD
18637	24666	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24666	20	1937	1937	CD
18637	24666	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24666	22	,	,	,
18637	24666	23	863	863	CD
18637	24666	24	,	,	,
18637	24666	25	878	878	CD
18637	24666	26	United	United	NNP
18637	24666	27	States	States	NNP
18637	24666	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24666	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24666	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24666	31	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	24666	32	&	&	CC
18637	24666	33	Goodwin	Goodwin	NNP
18637	24666	34	,	,	,
18637	24666	35	7	7	CD
18637	24666	36	Cr	Cr	NNP
18637	24666	37	.	.	.
18637	24667	1	32	32	CD
18637	24667	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24667	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	24667	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24667	5	,	,	,
18637	24667	6	618	618	CD
18637	24667	7	,	,	,
18637	24667	8	878	878	CD
18637	24667	9	United	United	NNP
18637	24667	10	States	States	NNP
18637	24667	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24667	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	14	Hvoslef	Hvoslef	NNP
18637	24667	15	,	,	,
18637	24667	16	237	237	CD
18637	24667	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24667	18	1	1	CD
18637	24667	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24667	20	1915	1915	CD
18637	24667	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24667	22	,	,	,
18637	24667	23	322	322	CD
18637	24667	24	United	United	NNP
18637	24667	25	States	States	NNP
18637	24667	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24667	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	29	Jacobs	Jacobs	NNP
18637	24667	30	,	,	,
18637	24667	31	306	306	CD
18637	24667	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24667	33	363	363	CD
18637	24667	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24667	35	1939	1939	CD
18637	24667	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24667	37	,	,	,
18637	24667	38	864	864	CD
18637	24667	39	United	United	NNP
18637	24667	40	States	States	NNP
18637	24667	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24667	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	44	Jeffers	Jeffers	NNP
18637	24667	45	,	,	,
18637	24667	46	342	342	CD
18637	24667	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24667	48	481	481	CD
18637	24667	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24667	50	1951	1951	CD
18637	24667	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24667	52	,	,	,
18637	24667	53	824	824	CD
18637	24667	54	United	United	NNP
18637	24667	55	States	States	NNP
18637	24667	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24667	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	59	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
18637	24667	60	Electric	Electric	NNP
18637	24667	61	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24667	62	,	,	,
18637	24667	63	291	291	CD
18637	24667	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24667	65	386	386	CD
18637	24667	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24667	67	1934	1934	CD
18637	24667	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24667	69	,	,	,
18637	24667	70	550	550	CD
18637	24667	71	United	United	NNP
18637	24667	72	States	States	NNP
18637	24667	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	24667	75	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	76	John	John	NNP
18637	24667	77	J.	J.	NNP
18637	24667	78	Felin	Felin	NNP
18637	24667	79	&	&	CC
18637	24667	80	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24667	81	,	,	,
18637	24667	82	334	334	CD
18637	24667	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24667	84	624	624	CD
18637	24667	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24667	86	1948	1948	CD
18637	24667	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24667	88	,	,	,
18637	24667	89	298	298	CD
18637	24667	90	United	United	NNP
18637	24667	91	States	States	NNP
18637	24667	92	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	24667	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	95	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	24667	96	,	,	,
18637	24667	97	323	323	CD
18637	24667	98	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24667	99	273	273	CD
18637	24667	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24667	101	1944	1944	CD
18637	24667	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24667	103	,	,	,
18637	24667	104	881	881	CD
18637	24667	105	United	United	NNP
18637	24667	106	States	States	NNP
18637	24667	107	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	24667	109	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	110	Joint	Joint	NNP
18637	24667	111	-	-	HYPH
18637	24667	112	Traffic	Traffic	NNP
18637	24667	113	Assoc	Assoc	NNP
18637	24667	114	.	.	.
18637	24667	115	,	,	,
18637	24667	116	171	171	CD
18637	24667	117	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24667	118	505	505	CD
18637	24667	119	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24667	120	1898	1898	CD
18637	24667	121	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24667	122	,	,	,
18637	24667	123	147	147	CD
18637	24667	124	United	United	NNP
18637	24667	125	States	States	NNP
18637	24667	126	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	127	v.	v.	IN
18637	24667	128	_	_	NNP
18637	24667	129	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	24667	130	,	,	,
18637	24667	131	18	18	CD
18637	24667	132	How	how	WRB
18637	24667	133	.	.	.
18637	24668	1	92	92	CD
18637	24668	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24668	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	24668	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24668	5	,	,	,
18637	24668	6	477	477	CD
18637	24668	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24668	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24668	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24668	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24668	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24668	12	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	24668	13	,	,	,
18637	24668	14	109	109	CD
18637	24668	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24668	16	513	513	CD
18637	24668	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24668	18	1883	1883	CD
18637	24668	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24668	20	,	,	,
18637	24668	21	73	73	CD
18637	24668	22	,	,	,
18637	24668	23	865	865	CD
18637	24668	24	,	,	,
18637	24668	25	872	872	CD
18637	24668	26	United	United	NNP
18637	24668	27	States	States	NNP
18637	24668	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24668	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24668	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24668	31	Ju	Ju	NNP
18637	24668	32	Toy	Toy	NNP
18637	24668	33	,	,	,
18637	24668	34	198	198	CD
18637	24668	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24668	36	253	253	CD
18637	24668	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24668	38	1905	1905	CD
18637	24668	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24668	40	,	,	,
18637	24668	41	846	846	CD
18637	24668	42	,	,	,
18637	24668	43	852	852	CD
18637	24668	44	United	United	NNP
18637	24668	45	States	States	NNP
18637	24668	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24668	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	24668	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24668	49	Kagama	Kagama	NNP
18637	24668	50	,	,	,
18637	24668	51	118	118	CD
18637	24668	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24668	53	375	375	CD
18637	24668	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24668	55	1886	1886	CD
18637	24668	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24668	57	,	,	,
18637	24668	58	73	73	CD
18637	24668	59	,	,	,
18637	24668	60	253	253	CD
18637	24668	61	United	United	NNP
18637	24668	62	States	States	NNP
18637	24668	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24668	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	24668	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24668	66	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24668	67	City	City	NNP
18637	24668	68	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24668	69	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24668	70	.	.	.
18637	24669	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24669	2	,	,	,
18637	24669	3	339	339	CD
18637	24669	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24669	5	799	799	CD
18637	24669	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24669	7	1950	1950	CD
18637	24669	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24669	9	,	,	,
18637	24669	10	869	869	CD
18637	24669	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24669	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24669	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24669	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24669	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24669	16	Keehler	Keehler	NNP
18637	24669	17	,	,	,
18637	24669	18	9	9	CD
18637	24669	19	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24669	20	.	.	.
18637	24670	1	83	83	CD
18637	24670	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24670	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	24670	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24670	5	,	,	,
18637	24670	6	728	728	CD
18637	24670	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24670	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24670	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24670	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24670	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24670	12	Kirby	Kirby	NNP
18637	24670	13	,	,	,
18637	24670	14	7	7	CD
18637	24670	15	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24670	16	.	.	.
18637	24671	1	482	482	CD
18637	24671	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24671	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24671	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24671	5	,	,	,
18637	24671	6	270	270	CD
18637	24671	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24671	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24671	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24671	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24671	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24671	12	Klamath	Klamath	NNP
18637	24671	13	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	24671	14	,	,	,
18637	24671	15	304	304	CD
18637	24671	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24671	17	119	119	CD
18637	24671	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24671	19	1938	1938	CD
18637	24671	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24671	21	,	,	,
18637	24671	22	871	871	CD
18637	24671	23	United	United	NNP
18637	24671	24	States	States	NNP
18637	24671	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24671	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24671	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24671	28	Klein	Klein	NNP
18637	24671	29	,	,	,
18637	24671	30	13	13	CD
18637	24671	31	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24671	32	.	.	.
18637	24672	1	128	128	CD
18637	24672	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24672	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	24672	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24672	5	,	,	,
18637	24672	6	324	324	CD
18637	24672	7	,	,	,
18637	24672	8	407	407	CD
18637	24672	9	,	,	,
18637	24672	10	411	411	CD
18637	24672	11	,	,	,
18637	24672	12	514	514	CD
18637	24672	13	United	United	NNP
18637	24672	14	States	States	NNP
18637	24672	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24672	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24672	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24672	18	Knight	Knight	NNP
18637	24672	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24672	20	E.C.	E.C.	NNP
18637	24672	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24673	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24673	2	,	,	,
18637	24673	3	156	156	CD
18637	24673	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24673	5	1	1	CD
18637	24673	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24673	7	1895	1895	CD
18637	24673	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24673	9	,	,	,
18637	24673	10	144	144	CD
18637	24673	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24673	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24673	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24673	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24673	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24673	16	La	La	NNP
18637	24673	17	Franca	Franca	NNP
18637	24673	18	,	,	,
18637	24673	19	282	282	CD
18637	24673	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24673	21	568	568	CD
18637	24673	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24673	23	1931	1931	CD
18637	24673	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24673	25	,	,	,
18637	24673	26	841	841	CD
18637	24673	27	United	United	NNP
18637	24673	28	States	States	NNP
18637	24673	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24673	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24673	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24673	32	Lagnason	Lagnason	NNP
18637	24673	33	,	,	,
18637	24673	34	3	3	CD
18637	24673	35	Phil	Phil	NNP
18637	24673	36	.	.	.
18637	24674	1	472	472	CD
18637	24674	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24674	3	1904	1904	CD
18637	24674	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24674	5	,	,	,
18637	24674	6	643	643	CD
18637	24674	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24674	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24674	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24674	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24674	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24674	12	Landram	Landram	NNP
18637	24674	13	,	,	,
18637	24674	14	118	118	CD
18637	24674	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24674	16	81	81	CD
18637	24674	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24674	18	1886	1886	CD
18637	24674	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24674	20	,	,	,
18637	24674	21	895	895	CD
18637	24674	22	United	United	NNP
18637	24674	23	States	States	NNP
18637	24674	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24674	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24674	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24674	27	Lanza	Lanza	NNP
18637	24674	28	,	,	,
18637	24674	29	260	260	CD
18637	24674	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24674	31	377	377	CD
18637	24674	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24674	33	1922	1922	CD
18637	24674	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24674	35	,	,	,
18637	24674	36	841	841	CD
18637	24674	37	United	United	NNP
18637	24674	38	States	States	NNP
18637	24674	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24674	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24674	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24674	42	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	24674	43	,	,	,
18637	24674	44	106	106	CD
18637	24674	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24674	46	196	196	CD
18637	24674	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24674	48	1882	1882	CD
18637	24674	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24674	50	,	,	,
18637	24674	51	501	501	CD
18637	24674	52	,	,	,
18637	24674	53	588	588	CD
18637	24674	54	,	,	,
18637	24674	55	590	590	CD
18637	24674	56	,	,	,
18637	24674	57	872	872	CD
18637	24674	58	,	,	,
18637	24674	59	931	931	CD
18637	24674	60	,	,	,
18637	24674	61	934	934	CD
18637	24674	62	United	United	NNP
18637	24674	63	States	States	NNP
18637	24674	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24674	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	24674	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24674	67	Lee	Lee	NNP
18637	24674	68	,	,	,
18637	24674	69	26	26	CD
18637	24674	70	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24674	71	.	.	.
18637	24675	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24675	2	.	.	.
18637	24676	1	No	no	UH
18637	24676	2	.	.	.
18637	24677	1	15,584	15,584	CD
18637	24677	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24677	3	1814	1814	CD
18637	24677	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24677	5	,	,	,
18637	24677	6	586	586	CD
18637	24677	7	,	,	,
18637	24677	8	587	587	CD
18637	24677	9	,	,	,
18637	24677	10	643	643	CD
18637	24677	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24677	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24677	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24677	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	16	Lefkowitz	Lefkowitz	NNP
18637	24677	17	,	,	,
18637	24677	18	285	285	CD
18637	24677	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24677	20	452	452	CD
18637	24677	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24677	22	1932	1932	CD
18637	24677	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24677	24	,	,	,
18637	24677	25	828	828	CD
18637	24677	26	United	United	NNP
18637	24677	27	States	States	NNP
18637	24677	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24677	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	31	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24677	32	,	,	,
18637	24677	33	339	339	CD
18637	24677	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24677	35	699	699	CD
18637	24677	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24677	37	1950	1950	CD
18637	24677	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24677	39	,	,	,
18637	24677	40	585	585	CD
18637	24677	41	,	,	,
18637	24677	42	700	700	CD
18637	24677	43	,	,	,
18637	24677	44	894	894	CD
18637	24677	45	United	United	NNP
18637	24677	46	States	States	NNP
18637	24677	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	24677	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	50	Lovett	Lovett	NNP
18637	24677	51	,	,	,
18637	24677	52	328	328	CD
18637	24677	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24677	54	303	303	CD
18637	24677	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24677	56	1946	1946	CD
18637	24677	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24677	58	,	,	,
18637	24677	59	316	316	CD
18637	24677	60	,	,	,
18637	24677	61	460	460	CD
18637	24677	62	United	United	NNP
18637	24677	63	States	States	NNP
18637	24677	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	24677	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	67	Lowden	Lowden	NNP
18637	24677	68	,	,	,
18637	24677	69	308	308	CD
18637	24677	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24677	71	225	225	CD
18637	24677	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24677	73	1939	1939	CD
18637	24677	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24677	75	,	,	,
18637	24677	76	861	861	CD
18637	24677	77	United	United	NNP
18637	24677	78	States	States	NNP
18637	24677	79	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	24677	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	82	Lynah	Lynah	NNP
18637	24677	83	,	,	,
18637	24677	84	188	188	CD
18637	24677	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24677	86	445	445	CD
18637	24677	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24677	88	1903	1903	CD
18637	24677	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24677	90	,	,	,
18637	24677	91	865	865	CD
18637	24677	92	,	,	,
18637	24677	93	869	869	CD
18637	24677	94	,	,	,
18637	24677	95	1065	1065	CD
18637	24677	96	,	,	,
18637	24677	97	1068	1068	CD
18637	24677	98	United	United	NNP
18637	24677	99	States	States	NNP
18637	24677	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	24677	102	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	103	Macintosh	Macintosh	NNP
18637	24677	104	,	,	,
18637	24677	105	283	283	CD
18637	24677	106	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24677	107	605	605	CD
18637	24677	108	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24677	109	1931	1931	CD
18637	24677	110	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24677	111	,	,	,
18637	24677	112	257	257	CD
18637	24677	113	,	,	,
18637	24677	114	280	280	CD
18637	24677	115	,	,	,
18637	24677	116	769	769	CD
18637	24677	117	United	United	NNP
18637	24677	118	States	States	NNP
18637	24677	119	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	120	v.	v.	IN
18637	24677	121	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	122	Mack	Mack	NNP
18637	24677	123	,	,	,
18637	24677	124	295	295	CD
18637	24677	125	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24677	126	480	480	CD
18637	24677	127	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24677	128	1935	1935	CD
18637	24677	129	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24677	130	,	,	,
18637	24677	131	1214	1214	CD
18637	24677	132	United	United	NNP
18637	24677	133	States	States	NNP
18637	24677	134	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	135	v.	v.	IN
18637	24677	136	_	_	NNP
18637	24677	137	Magtibay	Magtibay	NNP
18637	24677	138	,	,	,
18637	24677	139	2	2	CD
18637	24677	140	Phil	Phil	NNP
18637	24677	141	.	.	.
18637	24678	1	703	703	CD
18637	24678	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24678	3	1903	1903	CD
18637	24678	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24678	5	,	,	,
18637	24678	6	643	643	CD
18637	24678	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24678	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24678	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24678	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24678	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24678	12	Marigold	Marigold	NNP
18637	24678	13	,	,	,
18637	24678	14	9	9	CD
18637	24678	15	How	how	WRB
18637	24678	16	.	.	.
18637	24679	1	560	560	CD
18637	24679	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24679	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	24679	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24679	5	,	,	,
18637	24679	6	161	161	CD
18637	24679	7	,	,	,
18637	24679	8	266	266	CD
18637	24679	9	,	,	,
18637	24679	10	309	309	CD
18637	24679	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24679	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24679	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24679	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24679	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24679	16	Masonite	Masonite	NNP
18637	24679	17	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24679	18	,	,	,
18637	24679	19	316	316	CD
18637	24679	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24679	21	265	265	CD
18637	24679	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24679	23	1942	1942	CD
18637	24679	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24679	25	,	,	,
18637	24679	26	275	275	CD
18637	24679	27	United	United	NNP
18637	24679	28	States	States	NNP
18637	24679	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24679	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24679	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24679	32	Maxwell	Maxwell	NNP
18637	24679	33	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24679	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	24679	35	Grant	Grant	NNP
18637	24679	36	&	&	CC
18637	24679	37	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24679	38	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24679	39	,	,	,
18637	24679	40	121	121	CD
18637	24679	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24679	42	325	325	CD
18637	24679	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24679	44	1887	1887	CD
18637	24679	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24679	46	,	,	,
18637	24679	47	702	702	CD
18637	24679	48	United	United	NNP
18637	24679	49	States	States	NNP
18637	24679	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24679	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	24679	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24679	53	McGratney	McGratney	NNP
18637	24679	54	,	,	,
18637	24679	55	104	104	CD
18637	24679	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24679	57	621	621	CD
18637	24679	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24679	59	1882	1882	CD
18637	24679	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24679	61	,	,	,
18637	24679	62	699	699	CD
18637	24679	63	United	United	NNP
18637	24679	64	States	States	NNP
18637	24679	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24679	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	24679	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24679	68	McGowan	McGowan	NNP
18637	24679	69	,	,	,
18637	24679	70	302	302	CD
18637	24679	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24679	72	535	535	CD
18637	24679	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24679	74	1938	1938	CD
18637	24679	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24679	76	,	,	,
18637	24679	77	702	702	CD
18637	24679	78	United	United	NNP
18637	24679	79	States	States	NNP
18637	24679	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24679	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	24679	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24679	83	McLemore	McLemore	NNP
18637	24679	84	,	,	,
18637	24679	85	4	4	CD
18637	24679	86	How	how	WRB
18637	24679	87	.	.	.
18637	24680	1	286	286	CD
18637	24680	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24680	3	1846	1846	CD
18637	24680	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24680	5	,	,	,
18637	24680	6	586	586	CD
18637	24680	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24680	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24680	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24680	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24680	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24680	12	McMillan	McMillan	NNP
18637	24680	13	,	,	,
18637	24680	14	165	165	CD
18637	24680	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24680	16	504	504	CD
18637	24680	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24680	18	1897	1897	CD
18637	24680	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24680	20	,	,	,
18637	24680	21	703	703	CD
18637	24680	22	,	,	,
18637	24680	23	704	704	CD
18637	24680	24	United	United	NNP
18637	24680	25	States	States	NNP
18637	24680	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24680	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24680	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24680	29	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	24680	30	,	,	,
18637	24680	31	190	190	CD
18637	24680	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24680	33	379	379	CD
18637	24680	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24680	35	1903	1903	CD
18637	24680	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24680	37	,	,	,
18637	24680	38	585	585	CD
18637	24680	39	United	United	NNP
18637	24680	40	States	States	NNP
18637	24680	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24680	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24680	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24680	44	Midwest	Midwest	NNP
18637	24680	45	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24680	46	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24680	47	,	,	,
18637	24680	48	236	236	CD
18637	24680	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24680	50	459	459	CD
18637	24680	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24680	52	1915	1915	CD
18637	24680	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24680	54	,	,	,
18637	24680	55	482	482	CD
18637	24680	56	,	,	,
18637	24680	57	702	702	CD
18637	24680	58	United	United	NNP
18637	24680	59	States	States	NNP
18637	24680	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24680	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	24680	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24680	63	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24680	64	,	,	,
18637	24680	65	307	307	CD
18637	24680	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24680	67	174	174	CD
18637	24680	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24680	69	1939	1939	CD
18637	24680	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24680	71	,	,	,
18637	24680	72	813	813	CD
18637	24680	73	United	United	NNP
18637	24680	74	States	States	NNP
18637	24680	75	_	_	NNP
18637	24680	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	24680	77	_	_	NNP
18637	24680	78	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24680	79	,	,	,
18637	24680	80	317	317	CD
18637	24680	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24680	82	369	369	CD
18637	24680	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24680	84	1943	1943	CD
18637	24680	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24680	86	,	,	,
18637	24680	87	870	870	CD
18637	24680	88	United	United	NNP
18637	24680	89	States	States	NNP
18637	24680	90	_	_	NNP
18637	24680	91	v.	v.	IN
18637	24680	92	_	_	NNP
18637	24680	93	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24680	94	,	,	,
18637	24680	95	270	270	CD
18637	24680	96	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24680	97	181	181	CD
18637	24680	98	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24680	99	1926	1926	CD
18637	24680	100	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24680	101	,	,	,
18637	24680	102	585	585	CD
18637	24680	103	United	United	NNP
18637	24680	104	States	States	NNP
18637	24680	105	_	_	NNP
18637	24680	106	v.	v.	IN
18637	24680	107	_	_	NNP
18637	24680	108	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	24680	109	,	,	,
18637	24680	110	26	26	CD
18637	24680	111	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24680	112	.	.	.
18637	24681	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24681	2	.	.	.
18637	24682	1	No	no	UH
18637	24682	2	.	.	.
18637	24683	1	15,788	15,788	CD
18637	24683	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	3	1795	1795	CD
18637	24683	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	5	,	,	,
18637	24683	6	640	640	CD
18637	24683	7	,	,	,
18637	24683	8	612	612	CD
18637	24683	9	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	10	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	14	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	24683	15	,	,	,
18637	24683	16	109	109	CD
18637	24683	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	18	146	146	CD
18637	24683	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	20	1883	1883	CD
18637	24683	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	22	,	,	,
18637	24683	23	341	341	CD
18637	24683	24	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	25	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	29	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
18637	24683	30	,	,	,
18637	24683	31	322	322	CD
18637	24683	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	33	65	65	CD
18637	24683	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	35	1944	1944	CD
18637	24683	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	37	,	,	,
18637	24683	38	843	843	CD
18637	24683	39	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	40	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	44	Monia	Monia	NNP
18637	24683	45	,	,	,
18637	24683	46	317	317	CD
18637	24683	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	48	424	424	CD
18637	24683	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	50	1943	1943	CD
18637	24683	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	52	,	,	,
18637	24683	53	842	842	CD
18637	24683	54	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	55	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	59	Montgomery	Montgomery	NNP
18637	24683	60	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	24683	61	&	&	CC
18637	24683	62	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24683	63	,	,	,
18637	24683	64	150	150	CD
18637	24683	65	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24683	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	67	2d	2d	NNP
18637	24683	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	69	369	369	CD
18637	24683	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	71	1945	1945	CD
18637	24683	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	73	,	,	,
18637	24683	74	392	392	CD
18637	24683	75	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	76	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	77	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	78	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	79	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	80	Moreland	Moreland	NNP
18637	24683	81	,	,	,
18637	24683	82	258	258	CD
18637	24683	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	84	433	433	CD
18637	24683	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	86	1922	1922	CD
18637	24683	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	88	,	,	,
18637	24683	89	303	303	CD
18637	24683	90	,	,	,
18637	24683	91	838	838	CD
18637	24683	92	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	93	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	96	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	97	Morton	Morton	NNP
18637	24683	98	Salt	Salt	NNP
18637	24683	99	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24683	100	,	,	,
18637	24683	101	338	338	CD
18637	24683	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	103	632	632	CD
18637	24683	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	105	1950	1950	CD
18637	24683	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	107	,	,	,
18637	24683	108	828	828	CD
18637	24683	109	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	110	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	111	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	112	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	113	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	114	Mosley	Mosley	NNP
18637	24683	115	,	,	,
18637	24683	116	238	238	CD
18637	24683	117	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	118	383	383	CD
18637	24683	119	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	120	1915	1915	CD
18637	24683	121	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	122	,	,	,
18637	24683	123	87	87	CD
18637	24683	124	,	,	,
18637	24683	125	88	88	CD
18637	24683	126	,	,	,
18637	24683	127	94	94	CD
18637	24683	128	,	,	,
18637	24683	129	309	309	CD
18637	24683	130	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	131	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	132	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	133	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	134	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	135	Murdock	Murdock	NNP
18637	24683	136	,	,	,
18637	24683	137	284	284	CD
18637	24683	138	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	139	141	141	CD
18637	24683	140	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	141	1931	1931	CD
18637	24683	142	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	143	,	,	,
18637	24683	144	842	842	CD
18637	24683	145	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	146	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	147	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	148	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	149	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	150	National	National	NNP
18637	24683	151	Association	Association	NNP
18637	24683	152	of	of	IN
18637	24683	153	Real	Real	NNP
18637	24683	154	Estate	Estate	NNP
18637	24683	155	Boards	Boards	NNPS
18637	24683	156	,	,	,
18637	24683	157	339	339	CD
18637	24683	158	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	159	485	485	CD
18637	24683	160	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	161	1950	1950	CD
18637	24683	162	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	163	,	,	,
18637	24683	164	840	840	CD
18637	24683	165	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	166	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	167	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	168	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	169	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	170	New	New	NNP
18637	24683	171	River	River	NNP
18637	24683	172	Collieries	Collieries	NNPS
18637	24683	173	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24683	174	,	,	,
18637	24683	175	262	262	CD
18637	24683	176	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	177	341	341	CD
18637	24683	178	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	179	1923	1923	CD
18637	24683	180	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	181	,	,	,
18637	24683	182	870	870	CD
18637	24683	183	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	184	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	185	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	186	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	187	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	188	New	New	NNP
18637	24683	189	Wrinkle	Wrinkle	NNP
18637	24683	190	,	,	,
18637	24683	191	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	24683	192	,	,	,
18637	24683	193	342	342	CD
18637	24683	194	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	195	371	371	CD
18637	24683	196	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	197	1952	1952	CD
18637	24683	198	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	199	,	,	,
18637	24683	200	275	275	CD
18637	24683	201	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	202	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	203	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	204	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	205	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	206	New	New	NNP
18637	24683	207	York	York	NNP
18637	24683	208	&	&	CC
18637	24683	209	C.	C.	NNP
18637	24683	210	Mail	Mail	NNP
18637	24683	211	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	24683	212	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24683	213	,	,	,
18637	24683	214	269	269	CD
18637	24683	215	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	216	304	304	CD
18637	24683	217	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	218	1925	1925	CD
18637	24683	219	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	220	,	,	,
18637	24683	221	859	859	CD
18637	24683	222	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	223	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	224	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	225	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	226	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	227	N.Y.	New York	NNP
18637	24683	228	Rayon	Rayon	NNP
18637	24683	229	Importing	Importing	NNP
18637	24683	230	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24683	231	,	,	,
18637	24683	232	329	329	CD
18637	24683	233	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	234	654	654	CD
18637	24683	235	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	236	1947	1947	CD
18637	24683	237	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	238	,	,	,
18637	24683	239	587	587	CD
18637	24683	240	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	241	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	242	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	243	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	244	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	245	New	New	NNP
18637	24683	246	York	York	NNP
18637	24683	247	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	24683	248	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24683	249	,	,	,
18637	24683	250	326	326	CD
18637	24683	251	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	252	638	638	CD
18637	24683	253	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	254	1946	1946	CD
18637	24683	255	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	256	,	,	,
18637	24683	257	860	860	CD
18637	24683	258	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	259	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	260	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	261	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	262	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	263	Nice	Nice	NNP
18637	24683	264	,	,	,
18637	24683	265	241	241	CD
18637	24683	266	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	267	591	591	CD
18637	24683	268	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	269	1916	1916	CD
18637	24683	270	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	271	,	,	,
18637	24683	272	253	253	CD
18637	24683	273	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	274	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	275	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	276	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	277	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	278	North	North	NNP
18637	24683	279	American	American	NNP
18637	24683	280	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24683	281	,	,	,
18637	24683	282	253	253	CD
18637	24683	283	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	284	330	330	CD
18637	24683	285	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	286	1920	1920	CD
18637	24683	287	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	288	,	,	,
18637	24683	289	495	495	CD
18637	24683	290	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	291	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	292	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	293	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	294	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	295	North	North	NNP
18637	24683	296	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24683	297	,	,	,
18637	24683	298	136	136	CD
18637	24683	299	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	300	211	211	CD
18637	24683	301	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	302	1890	1890	CD
18637	24683	303	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	304	,	,	,
18637	24683	305	584	584	CD
18637	24683	306	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	307	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	308	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	309	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	310	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	311	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24683	312	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24683	313	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24683	314	,	,	,
18637	24683	315	234	234	CD
18637	24683	316	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	317	548	548	CD
18637	24683	318	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	319	1914	1914	CD
18637	24683	320	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	321	,	,	,
18637	24683	322	137	137	CD
18637	24683	323	,	,	,
18637	24683	324	138	138	CD
18637	24683	325	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	326	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	327	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	328	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	329	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	330	Oppenheimer	Oppenheimer	NNP
18637	24683	331	,	,	,
18637	24683	332	242	242	CD
18637	24683	333	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	334	85	85	CD
18637	24683	335	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	336	1916	1916	CD
18637	24683	337	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	338	,	,	,
18637	24683	339	839	839	CD
18637	24683	340	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	341	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	342	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	343	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	344	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	345	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24683	346	,	,	,
18637	24683	347	295	295	CD
18637	24683	348	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	349	1	1	CD
18637	24683	350	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	351	1935	1935	CD
18637	24683	352	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	353	,	,	,
18637	24683	354	703	703	CD
18637	24683	355	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	356	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	357	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	358	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	359	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	360	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24683	361	State	State	NNP
18637	24683	362	Medical	Medical	NNP
18637	24683	363	Society	Society	NNP
18637	24683	364	,	,	,
18637	24683	365	343	343	CD
18637	24683	366	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24683	367	326	326	CD
18637	24683	368	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24683	369	1952	1952	CD
18637	24683	370	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24683	371	,	,	,
18637	24683	372	121	121	CD
18637	24683	373	United	United	NNP
18637	24683	374	States	States	NNP
18637	24683	375	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	376	v.	v.	IN
18637	24683	377	_	_	NNP
18637	24683	378	Ortega	Ortega	NNP
18637	24683	379	,	,	,
18637	24683	380	11	11	CD
18637	24683	381	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24683	382	.	.	.
18637	24684	1	467	467	CD
18637	24684	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24684	3	1826	1826	CD
18637	24684	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24684	5	,	,	,
18637	24684	6	571	571	CD
18637	24684	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24684	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24684	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24684	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24684	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24684	12	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24684	13	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24684	14	,	,	,
18637	24684	15	120	120	CD
18637	24684	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24684	17	227	227	CD
18637	24684	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24684	19	1887	1887	CD
18637	24684	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24684	21	,	,	,
18637	24684	22	298	298	CD
18637	24684	23	United	United	NNP
18637	24684	24	States	States	NNP
18637	24684	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24684	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24684	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24684	28	Padelford	Padelford	NNP
18637	24684	29	,	,	,
18637	24684	30	9	9	CD
18637	24684	31	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24684	32	.	.	.
18637	24685	1	531	531	CD
18637	24685	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24685	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	24685	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24685	5	,	,	,
18637	24685	6	407	407	CD
18637	24685	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24685	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24685	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24685	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24685	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24685	12	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	24685	13	,	,	,
18637	24685	14	3	3	CD
18637	24685	15	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24685	16	.	.	.
18637	24686	1	610	610	CD
18637	24686	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24686	3	1818	1818	CD
18637	24686	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24686	5	,	,	,
18637	24686	6	473	473	CD
18637	24686	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24686	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24686	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24686	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24686	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24686	12	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	24686	13	,	,	,
18637	24686	14	128	128	CD
18637	24686	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24686	16	262	262	CD
18637	24686	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24686	18	1888	1888	CD
18637	24686	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24686	20	,	,	,
18637	24686	21	275	275	CD
18637	24686	22	United	United	NNP
18637	24686	23	States	States	NNP
18637	24686	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24686	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24686	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24686	27	Paramount	Paramount	NNP
18637	24686	28	Pictures	Pictures	NNP
18637	24686	29	,	,	,
18637	24686	30	334	334	CD
18637	24686	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24686	32	131	131	CD
18637	24686	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24686	34	1948	1948	CD
18637	24686	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24686	36	,	,	,
18637	24686	37	787	787	CD
18637	24686	38	United	United	NNP
18637	24686	39	States	States	NNP
18637	24686	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24686	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24686	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24686	43	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24686	44	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24686	45	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24686	46	,	,	,
18637	24686	47	323	323	CD
18637	24686	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24686	49	612	612	CD
18637	24686	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24686	51	1945	1945	CD
18637	24686	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24686	53	,	,	,
18637	24686	54	135	135	CD
18637	24686	55	United	United	NNP
18637	24686	56	States	States	NNP
18637	24686	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24686	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	24686	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24686	60	Percheman	Percheman	NNP
18637	24686	61	,	,	,
18637	24686	62	7	7	CD
18637	24686	63	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	24686	64	.	.	.
18637	24687	1	51	51	CD
18637	24687	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24687	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	24687	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24687	5	,	,	,
18637	24687	6	423	423	CD
18637	24687	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24687	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24687	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24687	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24687	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24687	12	Perez	Perez	NNP
18637	24687	13	,	,	,
18637	24687	14	9	9	CD
18637	24687	15	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24687	16	.	.	.
18637	24688	1	579	579	CD
18637	24688	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24688	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	24688	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24688	5	,	,	,
18637	24688	6	839	839	CD
18637	24688	7	,	,	,
18637	24688	8	1135	1135	CD
18637	24688	9	United	United	NNP
18637	24688	10	States	States	NNP
18637	24688	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24688	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24688	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24688	14	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
18637	24688	15	,	,	,
18637	24688	16	116	116	CD
18637	24688	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24688	18	483	483	CD
18637	24688	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24688	20	1886	1886	CD
18637	24688	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24688	22	,	,	,
18637	24688	23	460	460	CD
18637	24688	24	United	United	NNP
18637	24688	25	States	States	NNP
18637	24688	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24688	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24688	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24688	29	Petrillo	Petrillo	NNP
18637	24688	30	,	,	,
18637	24688	31	332	332	CD
18637	24688	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24688	33	1	1	CD
18637	24688	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24688	35	1947	1947	CD
18637	24688	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24688	37	,	,	,
18637	24688	38	564	564	CD
18637	24688	39	,	,	,
18637	24688	40	883	883	CD
18637	24688	41	,	,	,
18637	24688	42	953	953	CD
18637	24688	43	,	,	,
18637	24688	44	1146	1146	CD
18637	24688	45	United	United	NNP
18637	24688	46	States	States	NNP
18637	24688	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24688	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	24688	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24688	50	Petty	Petty	NNP
18637	24688	51	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	24688	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24688	53	,	,	,
18637	24688	54	327	327	CD
18637	24688	55	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24688	56	372	372	CD
18637	24688	57	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24688	58	1946	1946	CD
18637	24688	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24688	60	,	,	,
18637	24688	61	298	298	CD
18637	24688	62	,	,	,
18637	24688	63	871	871	CD
18637	24688	64	United	United	NNP
18637	24688	65	States	States	NNP
18637	24688	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24688	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	24688	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24688	69	Pewee	Pewee	NNP
18637	24688	70	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	24688	71	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24688	72	,	,	,
18637	24688	73	341	341	CD
18637	24688	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24688	75	114	114	CD
18637	24688	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24688	77	1951	1951	CD
18637	24688	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24688	79	,	,	,
18637	24688	80	494	494	CD
18637	24688	81	,	,	,
18637	24688	82	495	495	CD
18637	24688	83	,	,	,
18637	24688	84	497	497	CD
18637	24688	85	,	,	,
18637	24688	86	871	871	CD
18637	24688	87	United	United	NNP
18637	24688	88	States	States	NNP
18637	24688	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24688	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	24688	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24688	92	Phellis	Phellis	NNP
18637	24688	93	,	,	,
18637	24688	94	257	257	CD
18637	24688	95	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24688	96	156	156	CD
18637	24688	97	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24688	98	1921	1921	CD
18637	24688	99	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24688	100	,	,	,
18637	24688	101	1195	1195	CD
18637	24688	102	United	United	NNP
18637	24688	103	States	States	NNP
18637	24688	104	_	_	NNP
18637	24688	105	v.	v.	IN
18637	24688	106	_	_	NNP
18637	24688	107	Pink	Pink	NNP
18637	24688	108	,	,	,
18637	24688	109	315	315	CD
18637	24688	110	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24688	111	203	203	CD
18637	24688	112	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24688	113	1942	1942	CD
18637	24688	114	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24688	115	,	,	,
18637	24688	116	438	438	CD
18637	24688	117	,	,	,
18637	24688	118	497	497	CD
18637	24688	119	,	,	,
18637	24688	120	722	722	CD
18637	24688	121	United	United	NNP
18637	24688	122	States	States	NNP
18637	24688	123	_	_	NNP
18637	24688	124	v.	v.	IN
18637	24688	125	_	_	NNP
18637	24688	126	Potter	Potter	NNP
18637	24688	127	,	,	,
18637	24688	128	56	56	CD
18637	24688	129	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24688	130	.	.	.
18637	24689	1	83	83	CD
18637	24689	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24689	3	1892	1892	CD
18637	24689	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24689	5	,	,	,
18637	24689	6	881	881	CD
18637	24689	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24689	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24689	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24689	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24689	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24689	12	Powell	Powell	NNP
18637	24689	13	,	,	,
18637	24689	14	27	27	CD
18637	24689	15	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24689	16	.	.	.
18637	24690	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24690	2	.	.	.
18637	24691	1	No	no	UH
18637	24691	2	.	.	.
18637	24692	1	16,079	16,079	CD
18637	24692	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24692	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24692	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24692	5	,	,	,
18637	24692	6	1173	1173	CD
18637	24692	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24692	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24692	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24692	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24692	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24692	12	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	24692	13	,	,	,
18637	24692	14	307	307	CD
18637	24692	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24692	16	214	214	CD
18637	24692	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24692	18	1939	1939	CD
18637	24692	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24692	20	,	,	,
18637	24692	21	317	317	CD
18637	24692	22	United	United	NNP
18637	24692	23	States	States	NNP
18637	24692	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24692	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24692	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24692	27	Price	Price	NNP
18637	24692	28	,	,	,
18637	24692	29	116	116	CD
18637	24692	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24692	31	43	43	CD
18637	24692	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24692	33	1885	1885	CD
18637	24692	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24692	35	,	,	,
18637	24692	36	323	323	CD
18637	24692	37	United	United	NNP
18637	24692	38	States	States	NNP
18637	24692	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24692	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	24692	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24692	42	Pryor	Pryor	NNP
18637	24692	43	,	,	,
18637	24692	44	27	27	CD
18637	24692	45	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24692	46	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24692	47	.	.	.
18637	24693	1	No	no	UH
18637	24693	2	.	.	.
18637	24694	1	16,096	16,096	CD
18637	24694	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24694	3	1814	1814	CD
18637	24694	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24694	5	,	,	,
18637	24694	6	643	643	CD
18637	24694	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24694	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24694	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24694	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24694	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24694	12	Rabinowitz	Rabinowitz	NNP
18637	24694	13	,	,	,
18637	24694	14	339	339	CD
18637	24694	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24694	16	56	56	CD
18637	24694	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24694	18	1950	1950	CD
18637	24694	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24694	20	,	,	,
18637	24694	21	566	566	CD
18637	24694	22	,	,	,
18637	24694	23	829	829	CD
18637	24694	24	United	United	NNP
18637	24694	25	States	States	NNP
18637	24694	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24694	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24694	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24694	29	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24694	30	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	24694	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24694	32	,	,	,
18637	24694	33	27	27	CD
18637	24694	34	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24694	35	.	.	.
18637	24695	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24695	2	.	.	.
18637	24696	1	No	no	UH
18637	24696	2	.	.	.
18637	24697	1	16,114	16,114	CD
18637	24697	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24697	3	1855	1855	CD
18637	24697	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24697	5	,	,	,
18637	24697	6	268	268	CD
18637	24697	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24697	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24697	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24697	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24697	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24697	12	Randenbush	Randenbush	NNP
18637	24697	13	,	,	,
18637	24697	14	8	8	CD
18637	24697	15	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24697	16	.	.	.
18637	24698	1	288	288	CD
18637	24698	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24698	3	1834	1834	CD
18637	24698	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24698	5	,	,	,
18637	24698	6	840	840	CD
18637	24698	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24698	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24698	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24698	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24698	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24698	12	Rauscher	Rauscher	NNP
18637	24698	13	,	,	,
18637	24698	14	119	119	CD
18637	24698	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24698	16	407	407	CD
18637	24698	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24698	18	1886	1886	CD
18637	24698	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24698	20	,	,	,
18637	24698	21	418	418	CD
18637	24698	22	,	,	,
18637	24698	23	696	696	CD
18637	24698	24	United	United	NNP
18637	24698	25	States	States	NNP
18637	24698	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24698	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24698	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24698	29	Ravara	Ravara	NNP
18637	24698	30	,	,	,
18637	24698	31	2	2	CD
18637	24698	32	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	24698	33	.	.	.
18637	24699	1	297	297	CD
18637	24699	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24699	3	1793	1793	CD
18637	24699	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24699	5	,	,	,
18637	24699	6	571	571	CD
18637	24699	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24699	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24699	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24699	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24699	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24699	12	Reading	Reading	NNP
18637	24699	13	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24699	14	,	,	,
18637	24699	15	123	123	CD
18637	24699	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24699	17	113	113	CD
18637	24699	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24699	19	1887	1887	CD
18637	24699	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24699	21	,	,	,
18637	24699	22	895	895	CD
18637	24699	23	United	United	NNP
18637	24699	24	States	States	NNP
18637	24699	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24699	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24699	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24699	28	Realty	Realty	NNP
18637	24699	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24699	30	,	,	,
18637	24699	31	163	163	CD
18637	24699	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24699	33	427	427	CD
18637	24699	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24699	35	1896	1896	CD
18637	24699	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24699	37	,	,	,
18637	24699	38	117	117	CD
18637	24699	39	,	,	,
18637	24699	40	323	323	CD
18637	24699	41	,	,	,
18637	24699	42	893	893	CD
18637	24699	43	United	United	NNP
18637	24699	44	States	States	NNP
18637	24699	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24699	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	24699	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24699	48	Reese	Reese	NNP
18637	24699	49	,	,	,
18637	24699	50	92	92	CD
18637	24699	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24699	52	214	214	CD
18637	24699	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24699	54	1876	1876	CD
18637	24699	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24699	56	,	,	,
18637	24699	57	93	93	CD
18637	24699	58	,	,	,
18637	24699	59	1183	1183	CD
18637	24699	60	,	,	,
18637	24699	61	1186	1186	CD
18637	24699	62	United	United	NNP
18637	24699	63	States	States	NNP
18637	24699	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24699	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	24699	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24699	67	Regan	Regan	NNP
18637	24699	68	,	,	,
18637	24699	69	232	232	CD
18637	24699	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24699	71	37	37	CD
18637	24699	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24699	73	1914	1914	CD
18637	24699	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24699	75	,	,	,
18637	24699	76	878	878	CD
18637	24699	77	United	United	NNP
18637	24699	78	States	States	NNP
18637	24699	79	_	_	NNP
18637	24699	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	24699	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24699	82	Reynolds	Reynolds	NNP
18637	24699	83	,	,	,
18637	24699	84	235	235	CD
18637	24699	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24699	86	133	133	CD
18637	24699	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24699	88	1914	1914	CD
18637	24699	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24699	90	,	,	,
18637	24699	91	950	950	CD
18637	24699	92	United	United	NNP
18637	24699	93	States	States	NNP
18637	24699	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24699	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	24699	96	_	_	NNP
18637	24699	97	Rio	Rio	NNP
18637	24699	98	Grande	Grande	NNP
18637	24699	99	Dam	Dam	NNP
18637	24699	100	&	&	CC
18637	24699	101	Irrig	Irrig	NNP
18637	24699	102	.	.	.
18637	24700	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24700	2	,	,	,
18637	24700	3	174	174	CD
18637	24700	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24700	5	690	690	CD
18637	24700	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24700	7	1899	1899	CD
18637	24700	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24700	9	,	,	,
18637	24700	10	128	128	CD
18637	24700	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24700	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24700	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24700	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24700	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24700	16	River	River	NNP
18637	24700	17	Rouge	Rouge	NNP
18637	24700	18	Improv	Improv	NNP
18637	24700	19	.	.	.
18637	24701	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24701	2	,	,	,
18637	24701	3	269	269	CD
18637	24701	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24701	5	411	411	CD
18637	24701	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24701	7	1926	1926	CD
18637	24701	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24701	9	,	,	,
18637	24701	10	128	128	CD
18637	24701	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24701	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24701	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24701	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24701	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24701	16	Rizzo	Rizzo	NNP
18637	24701	17	,	,	,
18637	24701	18	297	297	CD
18637	24701	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24701	20	530	530	CD
18637	24701	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24701	22	1936	1936	CD
18637	24701	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24701	24	,	,	,
18637	24701	25	1214	1214	CD
18637	24701	26	United	United	NNP
18637	24701	27	States	States	NNP
18637	24701	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24701	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24701	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24701	31	Robinson	Robinson	NNP
18637	24701	32	,	,	,
18637	24701	33	259	259	CD
18637	24701	34	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24701	35	685	685	CD
18637	24701	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24701	37	1919	1919	CD
18637	24701	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24701	39	,	,	,
18637	24701	40	643	643	CD
18637	24701	41	United	United	NNP
18637	24701	42	States	States	NNP
18637	24701	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24701	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24701	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24701	46	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	24701	47	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	24701	48	Co	Co	NNP
18637	24701	49	-	-	NN
18637	24701	50	operative	operative	NNP
18637	24701	51	,	,	,
18637	24701	52	307	307	CD
18637	24701	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24701	54	533	533	CD
18637	24701	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24701	56	1939	1939	CD
18637	24701	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24701	58	,	,	,
18637	24701	59	75	75	CD
18637	24701	60	,	,	,
18637	24701	61	76	76	CD
18637	24701	62	,	,	,
18637	24701	63	78	78	CD
18637	24701	64	,	,	,
18637	24701	65	160	160	CD
18637	24701	66	,	,	,
18637	24701	67	172	172	CD
18637	24701	68	,	,	,
18637	24701	69	854	854	CD
18637	24701	70	,	,	,
18637	24701	71	855	855	CD
18637	24701	72	United	United	NNP
18637	24701	73	States	States	NNP
18637	24701	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24701	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	24701	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24701	77	Russell	Russell	NNP
18637	24701	78	,	,	,
18637	24701	79	13	13	CD
18637	24701	80	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24701	81	.	.	.
18637	24702	1	623	623	CD
18637	24702	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24702	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24702	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24702	5	,	,	,
18637	24702	6	298	298	CD
18637	24702	7	,	,	,
18637	24702	8	404	404	CD
18637	24702	9	,	,	,
18637	24702	10	496	496	CD
18637	24702	11	,	,	,
18637	24702	12	872	872	CD
18637	24702	13	United	United	NNP
18637	24702	14	States	States	NNP
18637	24702	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24702	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	18	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	24702	19	Car	Car	NNP
18637	24702	20	Heating	Heating	NNP
18637	24702	21	&	&	CC
18637	24702	22	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24702	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24702	24	,	,	,
18637	24702	25	297	297	CD
18637	24702	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24702	27	88	88	CD
18637	24702	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24702	29	1936	1936	CD
18637	24702	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24702	31	,	,	,
18637	24702	32	1199	1199	CD
18637	24702	33	United	United	NNP
18637	24702	34	States	States	NNP
18637	24702	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24702	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	38	Sanchez	Sanchez	NNP
18637	24702	39	,	,	,
18637	24702	40	340	340	CD
18637	24702	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24702	42	42	42	CD
18637	24702	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24702	44	1950	1950	CD
18637	24702	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24702	46	,	,	,
18637	24702	47	111	111	CD
18637	24702	48	United	United	NNP
18637	24702	49	States	States	NNP
18637	24702	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	24702	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	53	Sandoval	Sandoval	NNP
18637	24702	54	,	,	,
18637	24702	55	231	231	CD
18637	24702	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24702	57	28	28	CD
18637	24702	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24702	59	1914	1914	CD
18637	24702	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24702	61	,	,	,
18637	24702	62	253	253	CD
18637	24702	63	,	,	,
18637	24702	64	699	699	CD
18637	24702	65	United	United	NNP
18637	24702	66	States	States	NNP
18637	24702	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	24702	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	70	San	San	NNP
18637	24702	71	Francisco	Francisco	NNP
18637	24702	72	,	,	,
18637	24702	73	310	310	CD
18637	24702	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24702	75	16	16	CD
18637	24702	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24702	77	1940	1940	CD
18637	24702	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24702	79	,	,	,
18637	24702	80	702	702	CD
18637	24702	81	United	United	NNP
18637	24702	82	States	States	NNP
18637	24702	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	24702	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	86	Sanges	Sanges	NNP
18637	24702	87	,	,	,
18637	24702	88	144	144	CD
18637	24702	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24702	90	310	310	CD
18637	24702	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24702	92	1892	1892	CD
18637	24702	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24702	94	,	,	,
18637	24702	95	839	839	CD
18637	24702	96	United	United	NNP
18637	24702	97	States	States	NNP
18637	24702	98	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	99	v.	v.	IN
18637	24702	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	101	San	San	NNP
18637	24702	102	Jacinto	Jacinto	NNP
18637	24702	103	Tin	Tin	NNP
18637	24702	104	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24702	105	,	,	,
18637	24702	106	125	125	CD
18637	24702	107	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24702	108	273	273	CD
18637	24702	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24702	110	1888	1888	CD
18637	24702	111	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24702	112	,	,	,
18637	24702	113	584	584	CD
18637	24702	114	United	United	NNP
18637	24702	115	States	States	NNP
18637	24702	116	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	117	v.	v.	IN
18637	24702	118	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	119	Saylor	Saylor	NNP
18637	24702	120	,	,	,
18637	24702	121	322	322	CD
18637	24702	122	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24702	123	385	385	CD
18637	24702	124	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24702	125	1944	1944	CD
18637	24702	126	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24702	127	,	,	,
18637	24702	128	87	87	CD
18637	24702	129	,	,	,
18637	24702	130	88	88	CD
18637	24702	131	,	,	,
18637	24702	132	94	94	CD
18637	24702	133	United	United	NNP
18637	24702	134	States	States	NNP
18637	24702	135	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	136	v.	v.	IN
18637	24702	137	_	_	NNP
18637	24702	138	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
18637	24702	139	Betsey	Betsey	NNP
18637	24702	140	&	&	CC
18637	24702	141	Charlotte	Charlotte	NNP
18637	24702	142	,	,	,
18637	24702	143	4	4	CD
18637	24702	144	Cr	Cr	NNP
18637	24702	145	.	.	.
18637	24703	1	443	443	CD
18637	24703	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24703	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	24703	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24703	5	,	,	,
18637	24703	6	576	576	CD
18637	24703	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24703	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24703	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24703	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24703	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24703	12	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
18637	24703	13	Peggy	Peggy	NNP
18637	24703	14	,	,	,
18637	24703	15	1	1	CD
18637	24703	16	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24703	17	.	.	.
18637	24704	1	103	103	CD
18637	24704	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24704	3	1801	1801	CD
18637	24704	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24704	5	,	,	,
18637	24704	6	417	417	CD
18637	24704	7	,	,	,
18637	24704	8	422	422	CD
18637	24704	9	United	United	NNP
18637	24704	10	States	States	NNP
18637	24704	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24704	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24704	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24704	14	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
18637	24704	15	Sally	Sally	NNP
18637	24704	16	,	,	,
18637	24704	17	2	2	CD
18637	24704	18	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24704	19	.	.	.
18637	24705	1	406	406	CD
18637	24705	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24705	3	1805	1805	CD
18637	24705	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24705	5	,	,	,
18637	24705	6	576	576	CD
18637	24705	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24705	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24705	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24705	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24705	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24705	12	Schurz	Schurz	NNP
18637	24705	13	,	,	,
18637	24705	14	102	102	CD
18637	24705	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24705	16	378	378	CD
18637	24705	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24705	18	1880	1880	CD
18637	24705	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24705	20	,	,	,
18637	24705	21	501	501	CD
18637	24705	22	United	United	NNP
18637	24705	23	States	States	NNP
18637	24705	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24705	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24705	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24705	27	Schwimmer	Schwimmer	NNP
18637	24705	28	,	,	,
18637	24705	29	279	279	CD
18637	24705	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24705	31	644	644	CD
18637	24705	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24705	33	1929	1929	CD
18637	24705	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24705	35	,	,	,
18637	24705	36	257	257	CD
18637	24705	37	,	,	,
18637	24705	38	769	769	CD
18637	24705	39	United	United	NNP
18637	24705	40	States	States	NNP
18637	24705	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24705	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24705	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24705	44	Shaw	Shaw	NNP
18637	24705	45	,	,	,
18637	24705	46	309	309	CD
18637	24705	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24705	48	495	495	CD
18637	24705	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24705	50	1940	1940	CD
18637	24705	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24705	52	,	,	,
18637	24705	53	587	587	CD
18637	24705	54	United	United	NNP
18637	24705	55	States	States	NNP
18637	24705	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24705	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24705	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24705	59	Shipp	Shipp	NNP
18637	24705	60	,	,	,
18637	24705	61	203	203	CD
18637	24705	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24705	63	563	563	CD
18637	24705	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24705	65	1906	1906	CD
18637	24705	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24705	67	,	,	,
18637	24705	68	520	520	CD
18637	24705	69	United	United	NNP
18637	24705	70	States	States	NNP
18637	24705	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24705	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	24705	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24705	74	Shreveport	Shreveport	NNP
18637	24705	75	Grain	Grain	NNP
18637	24705	76	&	&	CC
18637	24705	77	Elevator	Elevator	NNP
18637	24705	78	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24705	79	,	,	,
18637	24705	80	287	287	CD
18637	24705	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24705	82	77	77	CD
18637	24705	83	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24705	84	1932	1932	CD
18637	24705	85	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24705	86	,	,	,
18637	24705	87	76	76	CD
18637	24705	88	,	,	,
18637	24705	89	883	883	CD
18637	24705	90	United	United	NNP
18637	24705	91	States	States	NNP
18637	24705	92	_	_	NNP
18637	24705	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	24705	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24705	95	Simmons	Simmons	NNP
18637	24705	96	,	,	,
18637	24705	97	96	96	CD
18637	24705	98	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24705	99	360	360	CD
18637	24705	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24705	101	1878	1878	CD
18637	24705	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24705	103	,	,	,
18637	24705	104	884	884	CD
18637	24705	105	United	United	NNP
18637	24705	106	States	States	NNP
18637	24705	107	_	_	NNP
18637	24705	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	24705	109	_	_	NNP
18637	24705	110	Simms	Simms	NNP
18637	24705	111	,	,	,
18637	24705	112	1	1	CD
18637	24705	113	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24705	114	.	.	.
18637	24706	1	252	252	CD
18637	24706	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24706	3	1803	1803	CD
18637	24706	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24706	5	,	,	,
18637	24706	6	302	302	CD
18637	24706	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24706	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24706	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24706	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24706	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24706	12	Sing	Sing	NNP
18637	24706	13	Tuck	Tuck	NNP
18637	24706	14	,	,	,
18637	24706	15	194	194	CD
18637	24706	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24706	17	161	161	CD
18637	24706	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24706	19	1904	1904	CD
18637	24706	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24706	21	,	,	,
18637	24706	22	852	852	CD
18637	24706	23	United	United	NNP
18637	24706	24	States	States	NNP
18637	24706	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24706	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24706	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24706	28	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24706	29	,	,	,
18637	24706	30	5	5	CD
18637	24706	31	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24706	32	.	.	.
18637	24707	1	153	153	CD
18637	24707	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24707	3	1820	1820	CD
18637	24707	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24707	5	,	,	,
18637	24707	6	278	278	CD
18637	24707	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24707	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24707	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24707	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	12	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24707	13	,	,	,
18637	24707	14	286	286	CD
18637	24707	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24707	16	6	6	CD
18637	24707	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24707	18	1932	1932	CD
18637	24707	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24707	20	,	,	,
18637	24707	21	97	97	CD
18637	24707	22	,	,	,
18637	24707	23	454	454	CD
18637	24707	24	United	United	NNP
18637	24707	25	States	States	NNP
18637	24707	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24707	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	29	Smith	Smith	NNP
18637	24707	30	,	,	,
18637	24707	31	331	331	CD
18637	24707	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24707	33	469	469	CD
18637	24707	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24707	35	1947	1947	CD
18637	24707	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24707	37	,	,	,
18637	24707	38	314	314	CD
18637	24707	39	United	United	NNP
18637	24707	40	States	States	NNP
18637	24707	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24707	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	44	Socony	Socony	NNP
18637	24707	45	-	-	HYPH
18637	24707	46	Vacuum	Vacuum	NNP
18637	24707	47	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24707	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24707	49	,	,	,
18637	24707	50	310	310	CD
18637	24707	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24707	52	150	150	CD
18637	24707	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24707	54	1940	1940	CD
18637	24707	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24707	56	,	,	,
18637	24707	57	881	881	CD
18637	24707	58	United	United	NNP
18637	24707	59	States	States	NNP
18637	24707	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	24707	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	63	South	South	NNP
18637	24707	64	-	-	HYPH
18637	24707	65	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	24707	66	Underwriters	Underwriters	NNPS
18637	24707	67	Association	Association	NNP
18637	24707	68	,	,	,
18637	24707	69	322	322	CD
18637	24707	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24707	71	533	533	CD
18637	24707	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24707	73	1944	1944	CD
18637	24707	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24707	75	,	,	,
18637	24707	76	121	121	CD
18637	24707	77	,	,	,
18637	24707	78	168	168	CD
18637	24707	79	,	,	,
18637	24707	80	177	177	CD
18637	24707	81	,	,	,
18637	24707	82	207	207	CD
18637	24707	83	,	,	,
18637	24707	84	214	214	CD
18637	24707	85	United	United	NNP
18637	24707	86	States	States	NNP
18637	24707	87	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	24707	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	90	Spector	Spector	NNP
18637	24707	91	,	,	,
18637	24707	92	343	343	CD
18637	24707	93	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24707	94	169	169	CD
18637	24707	95	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24707	96	1952	1952	CD
18637	24707	97	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24707	98	,	,	,
18637	24707	99	261	261	CD
18637	24707	100	,	,	,
18637	24707	101	881	881	CD
18637	24707	102	United	United	NNP
18637	24707	103	States	States	NNP
18637	24707	104	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	105	v.	v.	IN
18637	24707	106	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	107	Sponenbarger	Sponenbarger	NNP
18637	24707	108	,	,	,
18637	24707	109	308	308	CD
18637	24707	110	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24707	111	256	256	CD
18637	24707	112	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24707	113	1939	1939	CD
18637	24707	114	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24707	115	,	,	,
18637	24707	116	867	867	CD
18637	24707	117	United	United	NNP
18637	24707	118	States	States	NNP
18637	24707	119	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	120	v.	v.	IN
18637	24707	121	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	122	Sprague	Sprague	NNP
18637	24707	123	,	,	,
18637	24707	124	282	282	CD
18637	24707	125	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24707	126	716	716	CD
18637	24707	127	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24707	128	1931	1931	CD
18637	24707	129	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24707	130	,	,	,
18637	24707	131	713	713	CD
18637	24707	132	,	,	,
18637	24707	133	915	915	CD
18637	24707	134	United	United	NNP
18637	24707	135	States	States	NNP
18637	24707	136	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	137	v.	v.	IN
18637	24707	138	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	139	Stafoff	Stafoff	NNP
18637	24707	140	,	,	,
18637	24707	141	260	260	CD
18637	24707	142	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24707	143	477	477	CD
18637	24707	144	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24707	145	1923	1923	CD
18637	24707	146	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24707	147	,	,	,
18637	24707	148	1214	1214	CD
18637	24707	149	United	United	NNP
18637	24707	150	States	States	NNP
18637	24707	151	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	152	v.	v.	IN
18637	24707	153	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	154	Stinson	Stinson	NNP
18637	24707	155	,	,	,
18637	24707	156	197	197	CD
18637	24707	157	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24707	158	200	200	CD
18637	24707	159	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24707	160	1905	1905	CD
18637	24707	161	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24707	162	,	,	,
18637	24707	163	610	610	CD
18637	24707	164	United	United	NNP
18637	24707	165	States	States	NNP
18637	24707	166	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	167	v.	v.	IN
18637	24707	168	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	169	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
18637	24707	170	,	,	,
18637	24707	171	274	274	CD
18637	24707	172	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24707	173	259	259	CD
18637	24707	174	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24707	175	1927	1927	CD
18637	24707	176	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24707	177	,	,	,
18637	24707	178	1201	1201	CD
18637	24707	179	United	United	NNP
18637	24707	180	States	States	NNP
18637	24707	181	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	182	v.	v.	IN
18637	24707	183	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	184	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
18637	24707	185	,	,	,
18637	24707	186	332	332	CD
18637	24707	187	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24707	188	689	689	CD
18637	24707	189	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24707	190	1948	1948	CD
18637	24707	191	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24707	192	,	,	,
18637	24707	193	153	153	CD
18637	24707	194	United	United	NNP
18637	24707	195	States	States	NNP
18637	24707	196	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	197	v.	v.	IN
18637	24707	198	_	_	NNP
18637	24707	199	Tarble	Tarble	NNP
18637	24707	200	,	,	,
18637	24707	201	13	13	CD
18637	24707	202	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24707	203	.	.	.
18637	24708	1	397	397	CD
18637	24708	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24708	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	24708	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24708	5	,	,	,
18637	24708	6	631	631	CD
18637	24708	7	,	,	,
18637	24708	8	728	728	CD
18637	24708	9	United	United	NNP
18637	24708	10	States	States	NNP
18637	24708	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24708	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24708	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24708	14	Teller	Teller	NNP
18637	24708	15	,	,	,
18637	24708	16	107	107	CD
18637	24708	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24708	18	64	64	CD
18637	24708	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24708	20	1883	1883	CD
18637	24708	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24708	22	,	,	,
18637	24708	23	795	795	CD
18637	24708	24	United	United	NNP
18637	24708	25	States	States	NNP
18637	24708	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24708	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24708	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24708	29	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24708	30	,	,	,
18637	24708	31	143	143	CD
18637	24708	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24708	33	621	621	CD
18637	24708	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24708	35	1892	1892	CD
18637	24708	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24708	37	,	,	,
18637	24708	38	585	585	CD
18637	24708	39	,	,	,
18637	24708	40	698	698	CD
18637	24708	41	United	United	NNP
18637	24708	42	States	States	NNP
18637	24708	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24708	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24708	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24708	46	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24708	47	,	,	,
18637	24708	48	339	339	CD
18637	24708	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24708	50	707	707	CD
18637	24708	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24708	52	1950	1950	CD
18637	24708	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24708	54	,	,	,
18637	24708	55	585	585	CD
18637	24708	56	,	,	,
18637	24708	57	699	699	CD
18637	24708	58	,	,	,
18637	24708	59	700	700	CD
18637	24708	60	United	United	NNP
18637	24708	61	States	States	NNP
18637	24708	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24708	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	24708	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24708	65	The	The	NNP
18637	24708	66	Thekla	Thekla	NNP
18637	24708	67	,	,	,
18637	24708	68	266	266	CD
18637	24708	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24708	70	328	328	CD
18637	24708	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24708	72	1924	1924	CD
18637	24708	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24708	74	,	,	,
18637	24708	75	610	610	CD
18637	24708	76	United	United	NNP
18637	24708	77	States	States	NNP
18637	24708	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24708	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	24708	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24708	81	Toronto	Toronto	NNP
18637	24708	82	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	24708	83	.	.	.
18637	24709	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24709	2	,	,	,
18637	24709	3	338	338	CD
18637	24709	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24709	5	396	396	CD
18637	24709	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24709	7	1949	1949	CD
18637	24709	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24709	9	,	,	,
18637	24709	10	298	298	CD
18637	24709	11	,	,	,
18637	24709	12	870	870	CD
18637	24709	13	United	United	NNP
18637	24709	14	States	States	NNP
18637	24709	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24709	16	v.	v.	IN
18637	24709	17	_	_	NNP
18637	24709	18	Trans	Trans	NNP
18637	24709	19	-	-	NNP
18637	24709	20	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24709	21	Freight	Freight	NNP
18637	24709	22	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	24709	23	.	.	.
18637	24709	24	,	,	,
18637	24709	25	166	166	CD
18637	24709	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24709	27	290	290	CD
18637	24709	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24709	29	1897	1897	CD
18637	24709	30	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24709	31	,	,	,
18637	24709	32	147	147	CD
18637	24709	33	United	United	NNP
18637	24709	34	States	States	NNP
18637	24709	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24709	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24709	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24709	38	United	United	NNP
18637	24709	39	Mine	Mine	NNP
18637	24709	40	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	24709	41	,	,	,
18637	24709	42	330	330	CD
18637	24709	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24709	44	258	258	CD
18637	24709	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24709	46	1947	1947	CD
18637	24709	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24709	48	,	,	,
18637	24709	49	485	485	CD
18637	24709	50	,	,	,
18637	24709	51	520	520	CD
18637	24709	52	,	,	,
18637	24709	53	622	622	CD
18637	24709	54	United	United	NNP
18637	24709	55	States	States	NNP
18637	24709	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24709	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24709	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24709	59	United	United	NNP
18637	24709	60	States	States	NNP
18637	24709	61	Fidelity	Fidelity	NNP
18637	24709	62	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24709	63	,	,	,
18637	24709	64	309	309	CD
18637	24709	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24709	66	506	506	CD
18637	24709	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24709	68	1940	1940	CD
18637	24709	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24709	70	,	,	,
18637	24709	71	591	591	CD
18637	24709	72	United	United	NNP
18637	24709	73	States	States	NNP
18637	24709	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24709	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	24709	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24709	77	Unzeuta	Unzeuta	NNP
18637	24709	78	,	,	,
18637	24709	79	281	281	CD
18637	24709	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24709	81	138	138	CD
18637	24709	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24709	83	1930	1930	CD
18637	24709	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24709	85	,	,	,
18637	24709	86	306	306	CD
18637	24709	87	,	,	,
18637	24709	88	307	307	CD
18637	24709	89	United	United	NNP
18637	24709	90	States	States	NNP
18637	24709	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24709	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	24709	93	_	_	NNP
18637	24709	94	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	24709	95	,	,	,
18637	24709	96	283	283	CD
18637	24709	97	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24709	98	64	64	CD
18637	24709	99	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24709	100	1931	1931	CD
18637	24709	101	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24709	102	,	,	,
18637	24709	103	585	585	CD
18637	24709	104	United	United	NNP
18637	24709	105	States	States	NNP
18637	24709	106	_	_	NNP
18637	24709	107	v.	v.	IN
18637	24709	108	_	_	NNP
18637	24709	109	Van	Van	NNP
18637	24709	110	Duzee	Duzee	NNP
18637	24709	111	,	,	,
18637	24709	112	140	140	CD
18637	24709	113	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24709	114	169	169	CD
18637	24709	115	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24709	116	1891	1891	CD
18637	24709	117	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24709	118	,	,	,
18637	24709	119	884	884	CD
18637	24709	120	United	United	NNP
18637	24709	121	States	States	NNP
18637	24709	122	_	_	NNP
18637	24709	123	v.	v.	IN
18637	24709	124	_	_	NNP
18637	24709	125	Vigol	Vigol	NNP
18637	24709	126	,	,	,
18637	24709	127	28	28	CD
18637	24709	128	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24709	129	.	.	.
18637	24710	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24710	2	.	.	.
18637	24711	1	No	no	UH
18637	24711	2	.	.	.
18637	24712	1	16,621	16,621	CD
18637	24712	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24712	3	1795	1795	CD
18637	24712	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24712	5	,	,	,
18637	24712	6	640	640	CD
18637	24712	7	,	,	,
18637	24712	8	642	642	CD
18637	24712	9	United	United	NNP
18637	24712	10	States	States	NNP
18637	24712	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24712	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	14	Waddell	Waddell	NNP
18637	24712	15	,	,	,
18637	24712	16	112	112	CD
18637	24712	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24712	18	76	76	CD
18637	24712	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24712	20	1884	1884	CD
18637	24712	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24712	22	,	,	,
18637	24712	23	309	309	CD
18637	24712	24	,	,	,
18637	24712	25	702	702	CD
18637	24712	26	,	,	,
18637	24712	27	967	967	CD
18637	24712	28	United	United	NNP
18637	24712	29	States	States	NNP
18637	24712	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24712	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	33	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	24712	34	&	&	CC
18637	24712	35	Tiernan	Tiernan	NNP
18637	24712	36	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24712	37	,	,	,
18637	24712	38	336	336	CD
18637	24712	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24712	40	793	793	CD
18637	24712	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24712	42	1949	1949	CD
18637	24712	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24712	44	,	,	,
18637	24712	45	831	831	CD
18637	24712	46	United	United	NNP
18637	24712	47	States	States	NNP
18637	24712	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	24712	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	51	Walsh	Walsh	NNP
18637	24712	52	,	,	,
18637	24712	53	331	331	CD
18637	24712	54	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24712	55	432	432	CD
18637	24712	56	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24712	57	1947	1947	CD
18637	24712	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24712	59	,	,	,
18637	24712	60	136	136	CD
18637	24712	61	,	,	,
18637	24712	62	153	153	CD
18637	24712	63	United	United	NNP
18637	24712	64	States	States	NNP
18637	24712	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	24712	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	68	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	24712	69	,	,	,
18637	24712	70	217	217	CD
18637	24712	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24712	72	333	333	CD
18637	24712	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24712	74	1910	1910	CD
18637	24712	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24712	76	,	,	,
18637	24712	77	870	870	CD
18637	24712	78	United	United	NNP
18637	24712	79	States	States	NNP
18637	24712	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	24712	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	83	Werner	Werner	NNP
18637	24712	84	,	,	,
18637	24712	85	247	247	CD
18637	24712	86	F.	f.	NN
18637	24712	87	708	708	CD
18637	24712	88	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24712	89	1918	1918	CD
18637	24712	90	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24712	91	,	,	,
18637	24712	92	643	643	CD
18637	24712	93	United	United	NNP
18637	24712	94	States	States	NNP
18637	24712	95	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	96	v.	v.	IN
18637	24712	97	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	98	West	West	NNP
18637	24712	99	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24712	100	,	,	,
18637	24712	101	295	295	CD
18637	24712	102	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24712	103	463	463	CD
18637	24712	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24712	105	1935	1935	CD
18637	24712	106	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24712	107	,	,	,
18637	24712	108	584	584	CD
18637	24712	109	,	,	,
18637	24712	110	585	585	CD
18637	24712	111	United	United	NNP
18637	24712	112	States	States	NNP
18637	24712	113	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	114	v.	v.	IN
18637	24712	115	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	116	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	24712	117	,	,	,
18637	24712	118	254	254	CD
18637	24712	119	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24712	120	281	281	CD
18637	24712	121	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24712	122	1920	1920	CD
18637	24712	123	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24712	124	,	,	,
18637	24712	125	688	688	CD
18637	24712	126	,	,	,
18637	24712	127	967	967	CD
18637	24712	128	,	,	,
18637	24712	129	1175	1175	CD
18637	24712	130	United	United	NNP
18637	24712	131	States	States	NNP
18637	24712	132	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	133	v.	v.	IN
18637	24712	134	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	135	White	White	NNP
18637	24712	136	,	,	,
18637	24712	137	322	322	CD
18637	24712	138	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24712	139	694	694	CD
18637	24712	140	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24712	141	1944	1944	CD
18637	24712	142	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24712	143	,	,	,
18637	24712	144	827	827	CD
18637	24712	145	,	,	,
18637	24712	146	844	844	CD
18637	24712	147	United	United	NNP
18637	24712	148	States	States	NNP
18637	24712	149	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	150	v.	v.	IN
18637	24712	151	_	_	NNP
18637	24712	152	William	William	NNP
18637	24712	153	,	,	,
18637	24712	154	The	the	DT
18637	24712	155	,	,	,
18637	24712	156	28	28	CD
18637	24712	157	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24712	158	.	.	.
18637	24713	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24713	2	.	.	.
18637	24714	1	No	no	UH
18637	24714	2	.	.	.
18637	24715	1	16,700	16,700	CD
18637	24715	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24715	3	1808	1808	CD
18637	24715	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24715	5	,	,	,
18637	24715	6	161	161	CD
18637	24715	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24715	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24715	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24715	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24715	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24715	12	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24715	13	,	,	,
18637	24715	14	302	302	CD
18637	24715	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24715	16	46	46	CD
18637	24715	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24715	18	1937	1937	CD
18637	24715	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24715	20	,	,	,
18637	24715	21	285	285	CD
18637	24715	22	United	United	NNP
18637	24715	23	States	States	NNP
18637	24715	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24715	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24715	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24715	27	Willow	Willow	NNP
18637	24715	28	River	River	NNP
18637	24715	29	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24715	30	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24715	31	,	,	,
18637	24715	32	324	324	CD
18637	24715	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24715	34	499	499	CD
18637	24715	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24715	36	1945	1945	CD
18637	24715	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24715	38	,	,	,
18637	24715	39	128	128	CD
18637	24715	40	,	,	,
18637	24715	41	869	869	CD
18637	24715	42	United	United	NNP
18637	24715	43	States	States	NNP
18637	24715	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24715	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24715	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24715	47	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24715	48	,	,	,
18637	24715	49	7	7	CD
18637	24715	50	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	24715	51	.	.	.
18637	24716	1	150	150	CD
18637	24716	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24716	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	24716	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24716	5	,	,	,
18637	24716	6	406	406	CD
18637	24716	7	,	,	,
18637	24716	8	407	407	CD
18637	24716	9	,	,	,
18637	24716	10	839	839	CD
18637	24716	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24716	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24716	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24716	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24716	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24716	16	Wiltberger	Wiltberger	NNP
18637	24716	17	,	,	,
18637	24716	18	5	5	CD
18637	24716	19	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24716	20	.	.	.
18637	24717	1	76	76	CD
18637	24717	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24717	3	1820	1820	CD
18637	24717	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24717	5	,	,	,
18637	24717	6	646	646	CD
18637	24717	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24717	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24717	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24717	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24717	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24717	12	Winans	Winans	NNP
18637	24717	13	,	,	,
18637	24717	14	198	198	CD
18637	24717	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24717	16	371	371	CD
18637	24717	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24717	18	1905	1905	CD
18637	24717	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24717	20	,	,	,
18637	24717	21	700	700	CD
18637	24717	22	United	United	NNP
18637	24717	23	States	States	NNP
18637	24717	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24717	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24717	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24717	27	Wong	Wong	NNP
18637	24717	28	Kim	Kim	NNP
18637	24717	29	Ark	Ark	NNP
18637	24717	30	,	,	,
18637	24717	31	160	160	CD
18637	24717	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24717	33	649	649	CD
18637	24717	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24717	35	1898	1898	CD
18637	24717	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24717	37	,	,	,
18637	24717	38	964	964	CD
18637	24717	39	United	United	NNP
18637	24717	40	States	States	NNP
18637	24717	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24717	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24717	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24717	44	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	24717	45	,	,	,
18637	24717	46	299	299	CD
18637	24717	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24717	48	123	123	CD
18637	24717	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24717	50	1936	1936	CD
18637	24717	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24717	52	,	,	,
18637	24717	53	879	879	CD
18637	24717	54	United	United	NNP
18637	24717	55	States	States	NNP
18637	24717	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24717	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24717	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24717	59	Worrall	Worrall	NNP
18637	24717	60	,	,	,
18637	24717	61	2	2	CD
18637	24717	62	Dall	dall	NN
18637	24717	63	.	.	.
18637	24718	1	384	384	CD
18637	24718	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24718	3	1790	1790	CD
18637	24718	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24718	5	,	,	,
18637	24718	6	309	309	CD
18637	24718	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24718	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24718	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24718	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24718	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24718	12	Wrightwood	Wrightwood	NNP
18637	24718	13	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
18637	24718	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24718	15	,	,	,
18637	24718	16	315	315	CD
18637	24718	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24718	18	110	110	CD
18637	24718	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24718	20	1942	1942	CD
18637	24718	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24718	22	,	,	,
18637	24718	23	122	122	CD
18637	24718	24	,	,	,
18637	24718	25	153	153	CD
18637	24718	26	,	,	,
18637	24718	27	159	159	CD
18637	24718	28	United	United	NNP
18637	24718	29	States	States	NNP
18637	24718	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24718	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24718	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24718	33	Wurzbach	Wurzbach	NNP
18637	24718	34	,	,	,
18637	24718	35	280	280	CD
18637	24718	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24718	37	396	396	CD
18637	24718	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24718	39	1930	1930	CD
18637	24718	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24718	41	,	,	,
18637	24718	42	94	94	CD
18637	24718	43	,	,	,
18637	24718	44	883	883	CD
18637	24718	45	United	United	NNP
18637	24718	46	States	States	NNP
18637	24718	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24718	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	24718	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24718	50	Yuginovich	Yuginovich	NNP
18637	24718	51	,	,	,
18637	24718	52	256	256	CD
18637	24718	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24718	54	450	450	CD
18637	24718	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24718	56	1921	1921	CD
18637	24718	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24718	58	,	,	,
18637	24718	59	110	110	CD
18637	24718	60	,	,	,
18637	24718	61	1204	1204	CD
18637	24718	62	United	United	NNP
18637	24718	63	States	States	NNP
18637	24718	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24718	65	v.	v.	IN
18637	24718	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24718	67	Zucker	Zucker	NNP
18637	24718	68	,	,	,
18637	24718	69	161	161	CD
18637	24718	70	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24718	71	475	475	CD
18637	24718	72	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24718	73	1896	1896	CD
18637	24718	74	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24718	75	,	,	,
18637	24718	76	878	878	CD
18637	24718	77	United	United	NNP
18637	24718	78	States	States	NNP
18637	24718	79	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24718	80	rel	rel	NN
18637	24718	81	.	.	.
18637	24719	1	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
18637	24719	2	General	General	NNP
18637	24719	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24719	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	24719	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24719	6	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
18637	24719	7	&	&	CC
18637	24719	8	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
18637	24719	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24719	10	,	,	,
18637	24719	11	213	213	CD
18637	24719	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24719	13	366	366	CD
18637	24719	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24719	15	1909	1909	CD
18637	24719	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24719	17	,	,	,
18637	24719	18	861	861	CD
18637	24719	19	United	United	NNP
18637	24719	20	States	States	NNP
18637	24719	21	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24719	22	rel	rel	NN
18637	24719	23	.	.	.
18637	24720	1	Bilokumsky	Bilokumsky	NNP
18637	24720	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24720	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24720	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24720	5	Tod	Tod	NNP
18637	24720	6	,	,	,
18637	24720	7	263	263	CD
18637	24720	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24720	9	149	149	CD
18637	24720	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24720	11	1923	1923	CD
18637	24720	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24720	13	,	,	,
18637	24720	14	885	885	CD
18637	24720	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24720	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24720	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24720	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24720	19	.	.	.
18637	24721	1	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	24721	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24721	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24721	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24721	5	Lane	Lane	NNP
18637	24721	6	,	,	,
18637	24721	7	232	232	CD
18637	24721	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24721	9	598	598	CD
18637	24721	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24721	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	24721	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24721	13	,	,	,
18637	24721	14	864	864	CD
18637	24721	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24721	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24721	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24721	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24721	19	.	.	.
18637	24722	1	Burnett	Burnett	NNP
18637	24722	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24722	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24722	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24722	5	Teller	Teller	NNP
18637	24722	6	,	,	,
18637	24722	7	107	107	CD
18637	24722	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24722	9	64	64	CD
18637	24722	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24722	11	1883	1883	CD
18637	24722	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24722	13	,	,	,
18637	24722	14	857	857	CD
18637	24722	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24722	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24722	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24722	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24722	19	.	.	.
18637	24723	1	Creary	Creary	NNP
18637	24723	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24723	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24723	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24723	5	Weeks	Weeks	NNP
18637	24723	6	,	,	,
18637	24723	7	259	259	CD
18637	24723	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24723	9	336	336	CD
18637	24723	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24723	11	1922	1922	CD
18637	24723	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24723	13	,	,	,
18637	24723	14	847	847	CD
18637	24723	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24723	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24723	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24723	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24723	19	.	.	.
18637	24724	1	Dunlap	Dunlap	NNP
18637	24724	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24724	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24724	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24724	5	Black	Black	NNP
18637	24724	6	,	,	,
18637	24724	7	128	128	CD
18637	24724	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24724	9	40	40	CD
18637	24724	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24724	11	1888	1888	CD
18637	24724	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24724	13	,	,	,
18637	24724	14	501	501	CD
18637	24724	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24724	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24724	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24724	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24724	19	.	.	.
18637	24725	1	Goldberg	Goldberg	NNP
18637	24725	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24725	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24725	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24725	5	Daniels	Daniels	NNP
18637	24725	6	,	,	,
18637	24725	7	231	231	CD
18637	24725	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24725	9	218	218	CD
18637	24725	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24725	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	24725	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24725	13	,	,	,
18637	24725	14	588	588	CD
18637	24725	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24725	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24725	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24725	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24725	19	.	.	.
18637	24726	1	Greathouse	Greathouse	NNP
18637	24726	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24726	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24726	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24726	5	Dern	Dern	NNP
18637	24726	6	,	,	,
18637	24726	7	289	289	CD
18637	24726	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24726	9	352	352	CD
18637	24726	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24726	11	1933	1933	CD
18637	24726	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24726	13	,	,	,
18637	24726	14	301	301	CD
18637	24726	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24726	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24726	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24726	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24726	19	.	.	.
18637	24727	1	Knauff	Knauff	NNP
18637	24727	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24727	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24727	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24727	5	Shaughnessy	Shaughnessy	NNP
18637	24727	6	,	,	,
18637	24727	7	338	338	CD
18637	24727	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24727	9	537	537	CD
18637	24727	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24727	11	1950	1950	CD
18637	24727	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24727	13	,	,	,
18637	24727	14	852	852	CD
18637	24727	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24727	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24727	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24727	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24727	19	.	.	.
18637	24728	1	McCann	McCann	NNP
18637	24728	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24728	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24728	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24728	5	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	24728	6	,	,	,
18637	24728	7	320	320	CD
18637	24728	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24728	9	220	220	CD
18637	24728	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24728	11	1943	1943	CD
18637	24728	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24728	13	,	,	,
18637	24728	14	885	885	CD
18637	24728	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24728	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24728	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24728	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24728	19	.	.	.
18637	24729	1	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	24729	2	Publishing	Publishing	NNP
18637	24729	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24729	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24729	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	24729	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24729	7	Burleson	Burleson	NNP
18637	24729	8	,	,	,
18637	24729	9	255	255	CD
18637	24729	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24729	11	407	407	CD
18637	24729	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24729	13	1921	1921	CD
18637	24729	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24729	15	,	,	,
18637	24729	16	860	860	CD
18637	24729	17	,	,	,
18637	24729	18	904	904	CD
18637	24729	19	United	United	NNP
18637	24729	20	States	States	NNP
18637	24729	21	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24729	22	rel	rel	NN
18637	24729	23	.	.	.
18637	24730	1	Randall	Randall	NNP
18637	24730	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24730	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24730	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24730	5	United	United	NNP
18637	24730	6	States	States	NNP
18637	24730	7	Marshal	Marshal	NNP
18637	24730	8	for	for	IN
18637	24730	9	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	24730	10	Dist	Dist	NNP
18637	24730	11	.	.	.
18637	24731	1	of	of	IN
18637	24731	2	New	New	NNP
18637	24731	3	York	York	NNP
18637	24731	4	,	,	,
18637	24731	5	143	143	CD
18637	24731	6	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24731	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24731	8	2d	2d	NNP
18637	24731	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24731	10	830	830	CD
18637	24731	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24731	12	1944	1944	CD
18637	24731	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24731	14	,	,	,
18637	24731	15	1214	1214	CD
18637	24731	16	United	United	NNP
18637	24731	17	States	States	NNP
18637	24731	18	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24731	19	rel	rel	NN
18637	24731	20	.	.	.
18637	24732	1	Riggs	Riggs	NNP
18637	24732	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24732	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24732	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24732	5	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	24732	6	County	County	NNP
18637	24732	7	,	,	,
18637	24732	8	6	6	CD
18637	24732	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24732	10	.	.	.
18637	24733	1	166	166	CD
18637	24733	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24733	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	24733	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24733	5	,	,	,
18637	24733	6	627	627	CD
18637	24733	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24733	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24733	9	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24733	10	rel	rel	NN
18637	24733	11	.	.	.
18637	24734	1	Tisi	Tisi	NNP
18637	24734	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24734	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24734	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24734	5	Tod	Tod	NNP
18637	24734	6	,	,	,
18637	24734	7	264	264	CD
18637	24734	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24734	9	131	131	CD
18637	24734	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24734	11	1924	1924	CD
18637	24734	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24734	13	,	,	,
18637	24734	14	78	78	CD
18637	24734	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24734	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24734	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24734	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24734	19	.	.	.
18637	24735	1	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	24735	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24735	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24735	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24735	5	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	24735	6	,	,	,
18637	24735	7	222	222	CD
18637	24735	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24735	9	204	204	CD
18637	24735	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24735	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	24735	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24735	13	,	,	,
18637	24735	14	864	864	CD
18637	24735	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24735	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24735	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24735	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24735	19	.	.	.
18637	24736	1	Turner	Turner	NNP
18637	24736	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24736	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24736	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24736	5	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24736	6	,	,	,
18637	24736	7	194	194	CD
18637	24736	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24736	9	279	279	CD
18637	24736	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24736	11	1904	1904	CD
18637	24736	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24736	13	,	,	,
18637	24736	14	874	874	CD
18637	24736	15	United	United	NNP
18637	24736	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24736	17	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24736	18	rel	rel	NN
18637	24736	19	.	.	.
18637	24737	1	T.V.A.	T.V.A.	NNP
18637	24738	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24738	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24738	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24738	4	Powelson	Powelson	NNP
18637	24738	5	,	,	,
18637	24738	6	319	319	CD
18637	24738	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24738	8	266	266	CD
18637	24738	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24738	10	1943	1943	CD
18637	24738	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24738	12	,	,	,
18637	24738	13	870	870	CD
18637	24738	14	United	United	NNP
18637	24738	15	States	States	NNP
18637	24738	16	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24738	17	rel	rel	NN
18637	24738	18	.	.	.
18637	24739	1	T.V.A.	T.V.A.	NNP
18637	24740	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24740	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24740	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24740	4	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	24740	5	,	,	,
18637	24740	6	327	327	CD
18637	24740	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24740	8	546	546	CD
18637	24740	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24740	10	1946	1946	CD
18637	24740	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24740	12	,	,	,
18637	24740	13	865	865	CD
18637	24740	14	,	,	,
18637	24740	15	1064	1064	CD
18637	24740	16	United	United	NNP
18637	24740	17	States	States	NNP
18637	24740	18	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24740	19	rel	rel	NN
18637	24740	20	.	.	.
18637	24741	1	Vajtauer	Vajtauer	NNP
18637	24741	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24741	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24741	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24741	5	Comr	Comr	NNP
18637	24741	6	.	.	.
18637	24742	1	of	of	IN
18637	24742	2	Immigration	Immigration	NNP
18637	24742	3	,	,	,
18637	24742	4	273	273	CD
18637	24742	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24742	6	103	103	CD
18637	24742	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24742	8	1927	1927	CD
18637	24742	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24742	10	,	,	,
18637	24742	11	853	853	CD
18637	24742	12	United	United	NNP
18637	24742	13	States	States	NNP
18637	24742	14	Exp	Exp	NNP
18637	24742	15	.	.	.
18637	24743	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24743	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24743	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24743	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24743	5	Kountze	Kountze	NNP
18637	24743	6	Bros.	Bros.	NNP
18637	24743	7	,	,	,
18637	24743	8	8	8	CD
18637	24743	9	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24743	10	.	.	.
18637	24744	1	342	342	CD
18637	24744	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24744	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24744	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24744	5	,	,	,
18637	24744	6	311	311	CD
18637	24744	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24744	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24744	9	Express	Express	NNP
18637	24744	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24744	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24744	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	14	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24744	15	,	,	,
18637	24744	16	223	223	CD
18637	24744	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24744	18	335	335	CD
18637	24744	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24744	20	1912	1912	CD
18637	24744	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24744	22	,	,	,
18637	24744	23	204	204	CD
18637	24744	24	United	United	NNP
18637	24744	25	States	States	NNP
18637	24744	26	Glue	Glue	NNP
18637	24744	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24744	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24744	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	31	Oak	Oak	NNP
18637	24744	32	Creek	Creek	NNP
18637	24744	33	,	,	,
18637	24744	34	247	247	CD
18637	24744	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24744	36	321	321	CD
18637	24744	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24744	38	1918	1918	CD
18637	24744	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24744	40	,	,	,
18637	24744	41	208	208	CD
18637	24744	42	United	United	NNP
18637	24744	43	States	States	NNP
18637	24744	44	Mortgage	Mortgage	NNP
18637	24744	45	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24744	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	24744	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	49	Matthews	Matthews	NNP
18637	24744	50	,	,	,
18637	24744	51	293	293	CD
18637	24744	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24744	53	232	232	CD
18637	24744	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24744	55	1934	1934	CD
18637	24744	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24744	57	,	,	,
18637	24744	58	355	355	CD
18637	24744	59	United	United	NNP
18637	24744	60	Surety	Surety	NNP
18637	24744	61	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24744	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	24744	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	65	American	American	NNP
18637	24744	66	Fruit	Fruit	NNP
18637	24744	67	Product	Product	NNP
18637	24744	68	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24744	69	,	,	,
18637	24744	70	238	238	CD
18637	24744	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24744	72	140	140	CD
18637	24744	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24744	74	1915	1915	CD
18637	24744	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24744	76	,	,	,
18637	24744	77	848	848	CD
18637	24744	78	University	University	NNP
18637	24744	79	of	of	IN
18637	24744	80	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	24744	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	82	v.	v.	IN
18637	24744	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	84	United	United	NNP
18637	24744	85	States	States	NNP
18637	24744	86	,	,	,
18637	24744	87	289	289	CD
18637	24744	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24744	89	48	48	CD
18637	24744	90	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24744	91	1933	1933	CD
18637	24744	92	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24744	93	,	,	,
18637	24744	94	107	107	CD
18637	24744	95	,	,	,
18637	24744	96	162	162	CD
18637	24744	97	Untermeyer	Untermeyer	NNP
18637	24744	98	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	99	v.	v.	IN
18637	24744	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	101	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
18637	24744	102	,	,	,
18637	24744	103	276	276	CD
18637	24744	104	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24744	105	440	440	CD
18637	24744	106	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24744	107	1928	1928	CD
18637	24744	108	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24744	109	,	,	,
18637	24744	110	863	863	CD
18637	24744	111	Upshaw	Upshaw	NNP
18637	24744	112	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	24744	114	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	115	United	United	NNP
18637	24744	116	States	States	NNP
18637	24744	117	,	,	,
18637	24744	118	335	335	CD
18637	24744	119	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24744	120	410	410	CD
18637	24744	121	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24744	122	1948	1948	CD
18637	24744	123	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24744	124	,	,	,
18637	24744	125	843	843	CD
18637	24744	126	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	24744	127	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24744	128	&	&	CC
18637	24744	129	Light	Light	NNP
18637	24744	130	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24744	131	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	132	v.	v.	IN
18637	24744	133	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	134	Pfost	Pfost	NNP
18637	24744	135	,	,	,
18637	24744	136	286	286	CD
18637	24744	137	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24744	138	165	165	CD
18637	24744	139	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24744	140	1932	1932	CD
18637	24744	141	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24744	142	,	,	,
18637	24744	143	138	138	CD
18637	24744	144	,	,	,
18637	24744	145	181	181	CD
18637	24744	146	,	,	,
18637	24744	147	1051	1051	CD
18637	24744	148	,	,	,
18637	24744	149	1148	1148	CD
18637	24744	150	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	24744	151	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24744	152	&	&	CC
18637	24744	153	Light	Light	NNP
18637	24744	154	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24744	155	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	156	v.	v.	IN
18637	24744	157	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	158	United	United	NNP
18637	24744	159	States	States	NNP
18637	24744	160	,	,	,
18637	24744	161	243	243	CD
18637	24744	162	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24744	163	389	389	CD
18637	24744	164	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24744	165	1917	1917	CD
18637	24744	166	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24744	167	,	,	,
18637	24744	168	702	702	CD
18637	24744	169	Utley	Utley	NNP
18637	24744	170	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	171	v.	v.	IN
18637	24744	172	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	173	St	St	NNP
18637	24744	174	Petersburg	Petersburg	NNP
18637	24744	175	,	,	,
18637	24744	176	292	292	CD
18637	24744	177	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24744	178	106	106	CD
18637	24744	179	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24744	180	1934	1934	CD
18637	24744	181	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24744	182	,	,	,
18637	24744	183	1059	1059	CD
18637	24744	184	Uveges	Uveges	NNPS
18637	24744	185	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	186	v.	v.	IN
18637	24744	187	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	188	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24744	189	,	,	,
18637	24744	190	335	335	CD
18637	24744	191	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24744	192	437	437	CD
18637	24744	193	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24744	194	1948	1948	CD
18637	24744	195	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24744	196	,	,	,
18637	24744	197	1100	1100	CD
18637	24744	198	,	,	,
18637	24744	199	1106	1106	CD
18637	24744	200	,	,	,
18637	24744	201	1108	1108	CD
18637	24744	202	,	,	,
18637	24744	203	1109	1109	CD
18637	24744	204	V	V	NNP
18637	24744	205	Valentine	Valentine	NNP
18637	24744	206	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	207	v.	v.	IN
18637	24744	208	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	209	Chrestensen	Chrestensen	NNP
18637	24744	210	,	,	,
18637	24744	211	316	316	CD
18637	24744	212	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24744	213	52	52	CD
18637	24744	214	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24744	215	1942	1942	CD
18637	24744	216	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24744	217	,	,	,
18637	24744	218	786	786	CD
18637	24744	219	Valentine	Valentine	NNP
18637	24744	220	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	221	v.	v.	IN
18637	24744	222	_	_	NNP
18637	24744	223	Great	Great	NNP
18637	24744	224	A.	A.	NNP
18637	24745	1	&	&	CC
18637	24745	2	P.	P.	NNP
18637	24745	3	Tea	Tea	NNP
18637	24745	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24745	5	,	,	,
18637	24745	6	299	299	CD
18637	24745	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24745	8	32	32	CD
18637	24745	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24745	10	1936	1936	CD
18637	24745	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24745	12	,	,	,
18637	24745	13	1149	1149	CD
18637	24745	14	Vallandigham	Vallandigham	NNP
18637	24745	15	,	,	,
18637	24745	16	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24745	17	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24745	18	,	,	,
18637	24745	19	28	28	CD
18637	24745	20	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	24745	21	.	.	.
18637	24746	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	24746	2	.	.	.
18637	24747	1	No	no	UH
18637	24747	2	.	.	.
18637	24748	1	16,816	16,816	CD
18637	24748	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24748	3	1863	1863	CD
18637	24748	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24748	5	,	,	,
18637	24748	6	643	643	CD
18637	24748	7	Vallandigham	Vallandigham	NNP
18637	24748	8	,	,	,
18637	24748	9	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24748	10	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24748	11	,	,	,
18637	24748	12	1	1	CD
18637	24748	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24748	14	.	.	.
18637	24749	1	243	243	CD
18637	24749	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24749	3	1864	1864	CD
18637	24749	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24749	5	,	,	,
18637	24749	6	612	612	CD
18637	24749	7	Valvoline	Valvoline	NNP
18637	24749	8	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24749	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24749	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24749	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24749	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24749	13	United	United	NNP
18637	24749	14	States	States	NNP
18637	24749	15	,	,	,
18637	24749	16	308	308	CD
18637	24749	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24749	18	141	141	CD
18637	24749	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24749	20	1939	1939	CD
18637	24749	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24749	22	,	,	,
18637	24749	23	860	860	CD
18637	24749	24	Van	Van	NNP
18637	24749	25	Brocklin	Brocklin	NNP
18637	24749	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24749	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24749	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24749	29	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	24749	30	,	,	,
18637	24749	31	117	117	CD
18637	24749	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24749	33	151	151	CD
18637	24749	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24749	35	1886	1886	CD
18637	24749	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24749	37	,	,	,
18637	24749	38	699	699	CD
18637	24749	39	,	,	,
18637	24749	40	703	703	CD
18637	24749	41	,	,	,
18637	24749	42	732	732	CD
18637	24749	43	Vance	Vance	NNP
18637	24749	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24749	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24749	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24749	47	Vance	Vance	NNP
18637	24749	48	,	,	,
18637	24749	49	108	108	CD
18637	24749	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24749	51	514	514	CD
18637	24749	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24749	53	1883	1883	CD
18637	24749	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24749	55	,	,	,
18637	24749	56	355	355	CD
18637	24749	57	Vancouver	Vancouver	NNP
18637	24749	58	S.S.	S.S.	NNP
18637	24749	59	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24749	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24749	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	24749	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24749	63	Rice	Rice	NNP
18637	24749	64	,	,	,
18637	24749	65	288	288	CD
18637	24749	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24749	67	445	445	CD
18637	24749	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24749	69	1933	1933	CD
18637	24749	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24749	71	,	,	,
18637	24749	72	581	581	CD
18637	24749	73	Vandenbark	Vandenbark	NNP
18637	24749	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24749	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	24749	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24749	77	Owens	Owens	NNP
18637	24749	78	-	-	HYPH
18637	24749	79	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	24749	80	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24749	81	,	,	,
18637	24749	82	311	311	CD
18637	24749	83	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24749	84	538	538	CD
18637	24749	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24749	86	1941	1941	CD
18637	24749	87	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24749	88	,	,	,
18637	24749	89	608	608	CD
18637	24749	90	Van	Van	NNP
18637	24749	91	Dyke	Dyke	NNP
18637	24749	92	_	_	NNP
18637	24749	93	v.	v.	IN
18637	24749	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24749	95	Geary	Geary	NNP
18637	24749	96	,	,	,
18637	24749	97	244	244	CD
18637	24749	98	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24749	99	39	39	CD
18637	24749	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24749	101	1917	1917	CD
18637	24749	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24749	103	,	,	,
18637	24749	104	1002	1002	CD
18637	24749	105	Van	Van	NNP
18637	24749	106	Home	Home	NNP
18637	24749	107	's	's	POS
18637	24749	108	Lessee	Lessee	NNP
18637	24749	109	_	_	NNP
18637	24749	110	v.	v.	IN
18637	24749	111	_	_	NNP
18637	24749	112	Dorrance	Dorrance	NNP
18637	24749	113	,	,	,
18637	24749	114	2	2	CD
18637	24749	115	Dall	dall	NN
18637	24749	116	.	.	.
18637	24750	1	304	304	CD
18637	24750	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24750	3	1795	1795	CD
18637	24750	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24750	5	,	,	,
18637	24750	6	560	560	CD
18637	24750	7	Van	Van	NNP
18637	24750	8	Ness	Ness	NNP
18637	24750	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24750	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24750	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24750	12	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24750	13	of	of	IN
18637	24750	14	United	United	NNP
18637	24750	15	States	States	NNP
18637	24750	16	,	,	,
18637	24750	17	13	13	CD
18637	24750	18	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24750	19	.	.	.
18637	24751	1	17	17	CD
18637	24751	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24751	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	24751	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24751	5	,	,	,
18637	24751	6	302	302	CD
18637	24751	7	Van	Van	NNP
18637	24751	8	Oster	Oster	NNP
18637	24751	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24751	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24751	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24751	12	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24751	13	,	,	,
18637	24751	14	272	272	CD
18637	24751	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24751	16	465	465	CD
18637	24751	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24751	18	1926	1926	CD
18637	24751	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24751	20	,	,	,
18637	24751	21	1032	1032	CD
18637	24751	22	Veazie	Veazie	NNP
18637	24751	23	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24751	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24751	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24751	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24751	27	Fenno	Fenno	NNP
18637	24751	28	,	,	,
18637	24751	29	8	8	CD
18637	24751	30	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24751	31	.	.	.
18637	24752	1	533	533	CD
18637	24752	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24752	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24752	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24752	5	,	,	,
18637	24752	6	108	108	CD
18637	24752	7	,	,	,
18637	24752	8	266	266	CD
18637	24752	9	,	,	,
18637	24752	10	310	310	CD
18637	24752	11	,	,	,
18637	24752	12	319	319	CD
18637	24752	13	Veix	Veix	NNP
18637	24752	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24752	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24752	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24752	17	Sixth	Sixth	NNP
18637	24752	18	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	24752	19	Building	Building	NNP
18637	24752	20	&	&	CC
18637	24752	21	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	24752	22	Ass'n	Ass'n	:
18637	24752	23	.	.	.
18637	24753	1	of	of	IN
18637	24753	2	Newark	Newark	NNP
18637	24753	3	,	,	,
18637	24753	4	310	310	CD
18637	24753	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24753	6	32	32	CD
18637	24753	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24753	8	1940	1940	CD
18637	24753	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24753	10	,	,	,
18637	24753	11	359	359	CD
18637	24753	12	Venner	Venner	NNP
18637	24753	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24753	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24753	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24753	16	Great	Great	NNP
18637	24753	17	Northern	Northern	NNP
18637	24753	18	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24753	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24753	20	,	,	,
18637	24753	21	209	209	CD
18637	24753	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24753	23	24	24	CD
18637	24753	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24753	25	1908	1908	CD
18637	24753	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24753	27	,	,	,
18637	24753	28	620	620	CD
18637	24753	29	Vial	Vial	NNP
18637	24753	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24753	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24753	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24753	33	Penniman	Penniman	NNP
18637	24753	34	,	,	,
18637	24753	35	103	103	CD
18637	24753	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24753	37	714	714	CD
18637	24753	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24753	39	1881	1881	CD
18637	24753	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24753	41	,	,	,
18637	24753	42	355	355	CD
18637	24753	43	Vicksburg	Vicksburg	NNP
18637	24753	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24753	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24753	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24753	47	Tobin	Tobin	NNP
18637	24753	48	,	,	,
18637	24753	49	100	100	CD
18637	24753	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24753	51	430	430	CD
18637	24753	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24753	53	1880	1880	CD
18637	24753	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24753	55	,	,	,
18637	24753	56	366	366	CD
18637	24753	57	Vicksburg	Vicksburg	NNP
18637	24753	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24753	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24753	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24753	61	Vicksburg	Vicksburg	NNP
18637	24753	62	Waterworks	Waterworks	NNP
18637	24753	63	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24753	64	,	,	,
18637	24753	65	202	202	CD
18637	24753	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24753	67	453	453	CD
18637	24753	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24753	69	1906	1906	CD
18637	24753	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24753	71	,	,	,
18637	24753	72	329	329	CD
18637	24753	73	Vicksburg	Vicksburg	NNP
18637	24753	74	&	&	CC
18637	24753	75	M.R.	M.R.	NNP
18637	24754	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24754	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24754	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24754	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24754	5	Putnam	Putnam	NNP
18637	24754	6	,	,	,
18637	24754	7	118	118	CD
18637	24754	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24754	9	545	545	CD
18637	24754	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24754	11	1886	1886	CD
18637	24754	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24754	13	,	,	,
18637	24754	14	895	895	CD
18637	24754	15	Vicksburg	Vicksburg	NNP
18637	24754	16	S.	S.	NNP
18637	24754	17	&	&	CC
18637	24754	18	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24755	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24755	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24755	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24755	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24755	5	Dennis	Dennis	NNP
18637	24755	6	,	,	,
18637	24755	7	116	116	CD
18637	24755	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24755	9	665	665	CD
18637	24755	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24755	11	1886	1886	CD
18637	24755	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24755	13	,	,	,
18637	24755	14	348	348	CD
18637	24755	15	Viereck	Viereck	NNP
18637	24755	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24755	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24755	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24755	19	United	United	NNP
18637	24755	20	States	States	NNP
18637	24755	21	,	,	,
18637	24755	22	318	318	CD
18637	24755	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24755	24	236	236	CD
18637	24755	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24755	26	1943	1943	CD
18637	24755	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24755	28	,	,	,
18637	24755	29	881	881	CD
18637	24755	30	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24755	31	,	,	,
18637	24755	32	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24755	33	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24755	34	,	,	,
18637	24755	35	100	100	CD
18637	24755	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24755	37	339	339	CD
18637	24755	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24755	39	1880	1880	CD
18637	24755	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24755	41	,	,	,
18637	24755	42	1176	1176	CD
18637	24755	43	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24755	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24755	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24755	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24755	47	Imperial	Imperial	NNP
18637	24755	48	Sales	Sales	NNP
18637	24755	49	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24755	50	,	,	,
18637	24755	51	293	293	CD
18637	24755	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24755	53	15	15	CD
18637	24755	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24755	55	1934	1934	CD
18637	24755	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24755	57	,	,	,
18637	24755	58	200	200	CD
18637	24755	59	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24755	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24755	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	24755	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24755	63	Rives	Rives	NNP
18637	24755	64	,	,	,
18637	24755	65	100	100	CD
18637	24755	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24755	67	313	313	CD
18637	24755	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24755	69	1880	1880	CD
18637	24755	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24755	71	,	,	,
18637	24755	72	1142	1142	CD
18637	24755	73	,	,	,
18637	24755	74	1168	1168	CD
18637	24755	75	,	,	,
18637	24755	76	1176	1176	CD
18637	24755	77	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24755	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24755	79	v.	v.	IN
18637	24755	80	_	_	NNP
18637	24755	81	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
18637	24755	82	,	,	,
18637	24755	83	148	148	CD
18637	24755	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24755	85	503	503	CD
18637	24755	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24755	87	1893	1893	CD
18637	24755	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24755	89	,	,	,
18637	24755	90	367	367	CD
18637	24755	91	,	,	,
18637	24755	92	369	369	CD
18637	24755	93	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24755	94	_	_	NNP
18637	24755	95	v.	v.	IN
18637	24755	96	_	_	NNP
18637	24755	97	West	West	NNP
18637	24755	98	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24755	99	,	,	,
18637	24755	100	11	11	CD
18637	24755	101	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24755	102	.	.	.
18637	24756	1	39	39	CD
18637	24756	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24756	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24756	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24756	5	,	,	,
18637	24756	6	369	369	CD
18637	24756	7	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24756	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	11	West	West	NNP
18637	24756	12	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	13	,	,	,
18637	24756	14	206	206	CD
18637	24756	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24756	16	290	290	CD
18637	24756	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24756	18	1907	1907	CD
18637	24756	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24756	20	,	,	,
18637	24756	21	595	595	CD
18637	24756	22	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24756	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	26	West	West	NNP
18637	24756	27	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	28	,	,	,
18637	24756	29	209	209	CD
18637	24756	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24756	31	514	514	CD
18637	24756	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24756	33	1908	1908	CD
18637	24756	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24756	35	,	,	,
18637	24756	36	595	595	CD
18637	24756	37	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24756	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	41	West	West	NNP
18637	24756	42	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	43	,	,	,
18637	24756	44	220	220	CD
18637	24756	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24756	46	1	1	CD
18637	24756	47	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24756	48	1911	1911	CD
18637	24756	49	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24756	50	,	,	,
18637	24756	51	593	593	CD
18637	24756	52	,	,	,
18637	24756	53	595	595	CD
18637	24756	54	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24756	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	58	West	West	NNP
18637	24756	59	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	60	,	,	,
18637	24756	61	222	222	CD
18637	24756	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24756	63	17	17	CD
18637	24756	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24756	65	1911	1911	CD
18637	24756	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24756	67	,	,	,
18637	24756	68	595	595	CD
18637	24756	69	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	24756	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	73	West	West	NNP
18637	24756	74	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	75	,	,	,
18637	24756	76	231	231	CD
18637	24756	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24756	78	89	89	CD
18637	24756	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24756	80	1913	1913	CD
18637	24756	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24756	82	,	,	,
18637	24756	83	595	595	CD
18637	24756	84	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	24756	87	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	88	West	West	NNP
18637	24756	89	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	90	,	,	,
18637	24756	91	234	234	CD
18637	24756	92	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24756	93	117	117	CD
18637	24756	94	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24756	95	1914	1914	CD
18637	24756	96	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24756	97	,	,	,
18637	24756	98	595	595	CD
18637	24756	99	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	24756	102	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	103	West	West	NNP
18637	24756	104	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	105	,	,	,
18637	24756	106	238	238	CD
18637	24756	107	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24756	108	202	202	CD
18637	24756	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24756	110	1915	1915	CD
18637	24756	111	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24756	112	,	,	,
18637	24756	113	595	595	CD
18637	24756	114	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	115	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	116	v.	v.	IN
18637	24756	117	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	118	West	West	NNP
18637	24756	119	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	120	,	,	,
18637	24756	121	241	241	CD
18637	24756	122	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24756	123	531	531	CD
18637	24756	124	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24756	125	1916	1916	CD
18637	24756	126	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24756	127	,	,	,
18637	24756	128	595	595	CD
18637	24756	129	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	130	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	131	v.	v.	IN
18637	24756	132	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	133	West	West	NNP
18637	24756	134	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24756	135	,	,	,
18637	24756	136	246	246	CD
18637	24756	137	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24756	138	565	565	CD
18637	24756	139	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24756	140	1918	1918	CD
18637	24756	141	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24756	142	,	,	,
18637	24756	143	356	356	CD
18637	24756	144	,	,	,
18637	24756	145	370	370	CD
18637	24756	146	,	,	,
18637	24756	147	595	595	CD
18637	24756	148	,	,	,
18637	24756	149	593	593	CD
18637	24756	150	Virginian	Virginian	NNP
18637	24756	151	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24756	152	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24756	153	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	154	v.	v.	IN
18637	24756	155	_	_	NNP
18637	24756	156	System	System	NNP
18637	24756	157	Federation	Federation	NNP
18637	24756	158	No	No	NNP
18637	24756	159	.	.	.
18637	24757	1	40	40	CD
18637	24757	2	,	,	,
18637	24757	3	300	300	CD
18637	24757	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24757	5	515	515	CD
18637	24757	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24757	7	1937	1937	CD
18637	24757	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24757	9	,	,	,
18637	24757	10	142	142	CD
18637	24757	11	,	,	,
18637	24757	12	540	540	CD
18637	24757	13	,	,	,
18637	24757	14	622	622	CD
18637	24757	15	,	,	,
18637	24757	16	855	855	CD
18637	24757	17	,	,	,
18637	24757	18	859	859	CD
18637	24757	19	Voeller	Voeller	NNP
18637	24757	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24757	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24757	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24757	23	Neilston	Neilston	NNP
18637	24757	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24757	25	,	,	,
18637	24757	26	311	311	CD
18637	24757	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24757	28	531	531	CD
18637	24757	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24757	30	1941	1941	CD
18637	24757	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24757	32	,	,	,
18637	24757	33	1083	1083	CD
18637	24757	34	Voight	Voight	NNP
18637	24757	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24757	36	v.	v.	IN
18637	24757	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24757	38	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	24757	39	,	,	,
18637	24757	40	141	141	CD
18637	24757	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24757	42	62	62	CD
18637	24757	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24757	44	1891	1891	CD
18637	24757	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24757	46	,	,	,
18637	24757	47	238	238	CD
18637	24757	48	Von	Von	NNP
18637	24757	49	Hoffman	Hoffman	NNP
18637	24757	50	_	_	NNP
18637	24757	51	v.	v.	IN
18637	24757	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24757	53	Quincy	Quincy	NNP
18637	24757	54	,	,	,
18637	24757	55	4	4	CD
18637	24757	56	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24757	57	.	.	.
18637	24758	1	535	535	CD
18637	24758	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24758	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	24758	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24758	5	,	,	,
18637	24758	6	354	354	CD
18637	24758	7	,	,	,
18637	24758	8	355	355	CD
18637	24758	9	,	,	,
18637	24758	10	356	356	CD
18637	24758	11	Von	Von	NNP
18637	24758	12	Moltke	Moltke	NNP
18637	24758	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24758	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	16	Gillies	Gillies	NNPS
18637	24758	17	,	,	,
18637	24758	18	332	332	CD
18637	24758	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24758	20	708	708	CD
18637	24758	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24758	22	1948	1948	CD
18637	24758	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24758	24	,	,	,
18637	24758	25	885	885	CD
18637	24758	26	W	W	NNP
18637	24758	27	Wabash	Wabash	NNP
18637	24758	28	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24758	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24758	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24758	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	33	Adelbert	Adelbert	NNP
18637	24758	34	College	College	NNP
18637	24758	35	,	,	,
18637	24758	36	208	208	CD
18637	24758	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24758	38	38	38	CD
18637	24758	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24758	40	1908	1908	CD
18637	24758	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24758	42	,	,	,
18637	24758	43	627	627	CD
18637	24758	44	Wabash	Wabash	NNP
18637	24758	45	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24758	46	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24758	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	24758	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	50	Defiance	Defiance	NNP
18637	24758	51	,	,	,
18637	24758	52	167	167	CD
18637	24758	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24758	54	88	88	CD
18637	24758	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24758	56	1897	1897	CD
18637	24758	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24758	58	,	,	,
18637	24758	59	352	352	CD
18637	24758	60	Wabash	Wabash	NNP
18637	24758	61	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24758	62	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24758	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	64	v.	v.	IN
18637	24758	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	66	Flannigan	Flannigan	NNP
18637	24758	67	,	,	,
18637	24758	68	192	192	CD
18637	24758	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24758	70	29	29	CD
18637	24758	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24758	72	1904	1904	CD
18637	24758	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24758	74	,	,	,
18637	24758	75	656	656	CD
18637	24758	76	Wabash	Wabash	NNP
18637	24758	77	,	,	,
18637	24758	78	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24758	79	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24758	80	&	&	CC
18637	24758	81	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24758	82	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24758	83	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24758	84	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	24758	86	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	87	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	24758	88	,	,	,
18637	24758	89	118	118	CD
18637	24758	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24758	91	557	557	CD
18637	24758	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24758	93	1886	1886	CD
18637	24758	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24758	95	,	,	,
18637	24758	96	134	134	CD
18637	24758	97	,	,	,
18637	24758	98	220	220	CD
18637	24758	99	Wachovia	Wachovia	NNP
18637	24758	100	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	24758	101	&	&	CC
18637	24758	102	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24758	103	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24758	104	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	105	v.	v.	IN
18637	24758	106	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	107	Doughton	Doughton	NNP
18637	24758	108	,	,	,
18637	24758	109	272	272	CD
18637	24758	110	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24758	111	567	567	CD
18637	24758	112	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24758	113	1926	1926	CD
18637	24758	114	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24758	115	,	,	,
18637	24758	116	1046	1046	CD
18637	24758	117	Wade	Wade	NNP
18637	24758	118	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	119	v.	v.	IN
18637	24758	120	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	121	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
18637	24758	122	,	,	,
18637	24758	123	336	336	CD
18637	24758	124	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24758	125	684	684	CD
18637	24758	126	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24758	127	1949	1949	CD
18637	24758	128	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24758	129	,	,	,
18637	24758	130	286	286	CD
18637	24758	131	,	,	,
18637	24758	132	839	839	CD
18637	24758	133	Wade	Wade	NNP
18637	24758	134	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	135	v.	v.	IN
18637	24758	136	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	137	Mayo	Mayo	NNP
18637	24758	138	,	,	,
18637	24758	139	334	334	CD
18637	24758	140	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24758	141	672	672	CD
18637	24758	142	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24758	143	1948	1948	CD
18637	24758	144	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24758	145	,	,	,
18637	24758	146	634	634	CD
18637	24758	147	,	,	,
18637	24758	148	1105	1105	CD
18637	24758	149	,	,	,
18637	24758	150	1108	1108	CD
18637	24758	151	,	,	,
18637	24758	152	1109	1109	CD
18637	24758	153	Wadley	Wadley	NNP
18637	24758	154	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24758	155	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24758	156	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24758	157	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	158	v.	v.	IN
18637	24758	159	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	160	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	24758	161	,	,	,
18637	24758	162	235	235	CD
18637	24758	163	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24758	164	651	651	CD
18637	24758	165	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24758	166	1915	1915	CD
18637	24758	167	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24758	168	,	,	,
18637	24758	169	1013	1013	CD
18637	24758	170	Waggoner	Waggoner	NNP
18637	24758	171	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	172	v.	v.	IN
18637	24758	173	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	174	Flack	Flack	NNP
18637	24758	175	,	,	,
18637	24758	176	188	188	CD
18637	24758	177	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24758	178	595	595	CD
18637	24758	179	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24758	180	1903	1903	CD
18637	24758	181	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24758	182	,	,	,
18637	24758	183	355	355	CD
18637	24758	184	Wagner	Wagner	NNP
18637	24758	185	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	186	v.	v.	IN
18637	24758	187	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	188	Covington	Covington	NNP
18637	24758	189	,	,	,
18637	24758	190	251	251	CD
18637	24758	191	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24758	192	95	95	CD
18637	24758	193	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24758	194	1919	1919	CD
18637	24758	195	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24758	196	,	,	,
18637	24758	197	183	183	CD
18637	24758	198	,	,	,
18637	24758	199	184	184	CD
18637	24758	200	,	,	,
18637	24758	201	191	191	CD
18637	24758	202	,	,	,
18637	24758	203	239	239	CD
18637	24758	204	Wagner	Wagner	NNP
18637	24758	205	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	206	v.	v.	IN
18637	24758	207	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	208	Leser	Leser	NNP
18637	24758	209	,	,	,
18637	24758	210	239	239	CD
18637	24758	211	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24758	212	207	207	CD
18637	24758	213	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24758	214	1915	1915	CD
18637	24758	215	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24758	216	,	,	,
18637	24758	217	1041	1041	CD
18637	24758	218	Wagoner	Wagoner	NNP
18637	24758	219	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	220	v.	v.	IN
18637	24758	221	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	222	Evans	Evans	NNP
18637	24758	223	,	,	,
18637	24758	224	170	170	CD
18637	24758	225	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24758	226	588	588	CD
18637	24758	227	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24758	228	1898	1898	CD
18637	24758	229	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24758	230	,	,	,
18637	24758	231	703	703	CD
18637	24758	232	Waite	Waite	NNP
18637	24758	233	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	234	v.	v.	IN
18637	24758	235	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	236	Macy	Macy	NNP
18637	24758	237	,	,	,
18637	24758	238	246	246	CD
18637	24758	239	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24758	240	606	606	CD
18637	24758	241	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24758	242	1918	1918	CD
18637	24758	243	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24758	244	,	,	,
18637	24758	245	590	590	CD
18637	24758	246	Wales	Wales	NNP
18637	24758	247	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	248	v.	v.	IN
18637	24758	249	_	_	NNP
18637	24758	250	Stetson	Stetson	NNP
18637	24758	251	,	,	,
18637	24758	252	2	2	CD
18637	24758	253	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24759	1	143	143	CD
18637	24759	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24759	3	1806	1806	CD
18637	24759	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24759	5	,	,	,
18637	24759	6	338	338	CD
18637	24759	7	Waley	Waley	NNP
18637	24759	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24759	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24759	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24759	11	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	24759	12	,	,	,
18637	24759	13	316	316	CD
18637	24759	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24759	15	101	101	CD
18637	24759	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24759	17	1942	1942	CD
18637	24759	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24759	19	,	,	,
18637	24759	20	314	314	CD
18637	24759	21	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	24759	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24759	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24759	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24759	25	Johnston	Johnston	NNP
18637	24759	26	,	,	,
18637	24759	27	312	312	CD
18637	24759	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24759	29	275	275	CD
18637	24759	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24759	31	1941	1941	CD
18637	24759	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24759	33	,	,	,
18637	24759	34	314	314	CD
18637	24759	35	,	,	,
18637	24759	36	885	885	CD
18637	24759	37	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	24759	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24759	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24759	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24759	41	McLoud	McLoud	NNP
18637	24759	42	,	,	,
18637	24759	43	204	204	CD
18637	24759	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24759	45	302	302	CD
18637	24759	46	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24759	47	1907	1907	CD
18637	24759	48	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24759	49	,	,	,
18637	24759	50	864	864	CD
18637	24759	51	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	24759	52	_	_	NNP
18637	24759	53	v.	v.	IN
18637	24759	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24759	55	New	New	NNP
18637	24759	56	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	24759	57	&	&	CC
18637	24759	58	S.P.R.	S.P.R.	NNP
18637	24760	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24760	2	,	,	,
18637	24760	3	165	165	CD
18637	24760	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24760	5	593	593	CD
18637	24760	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24760	7	1897	1897	CD
18637	24760	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24760	9	,	,	,
18637	24760	10	703	703	CD
18637	24760	11	,	,	,
18637	24760	12	892	892	CD
18637	24760	13	,	,	,
18637	24760	14	894	894	CD
18637	24760	15	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	24760	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24760	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24760	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24760	19	Sauvinet	Sauvinet	NNP
18637	24760	20	,	,	,
18637	24760	21	92	92	CD
18637	24760	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24760	23	90	90	CD
18637	24760	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24760	25	1876	1876	CD
18637	24760	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24760	27	,	,	,
18637	24760	28	893	893	CD
18637	24760	29	,	,	,
18637	24760	30	971	971	CD
18637	24760	31	,	,	,
18637	24760	32	1096	1096	CD
18637	24760	33	Walker	Walker	NNP
18637	24760	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24760	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	24760	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24760	37	Whitehead	Whitehead	NNP
18637	24760	38	,	,	,
18637	24760	39	16	16	CD
18637	24760	40	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24760	41	.	.	.
18637	24761	1	314	314	CD
18637	24761	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24761	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	24761	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24761	5	,	,	,
18637	24761	6	332	332	CD
18637	24761	7	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24761	8	,	,	,
18637	24761	9	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24761	10	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24761	11	,	,	,
18637	24761	12	107	107	CD
18637	24761	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24761	14	265	265	CD
18637	24761	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24761	16	1883	1883	CD
18637	24761	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24761	18	,	,	,
18637	24761	19	528	528	CD
18637	24761	20	,	,	,
18637	24761	21	847	847	CD
18637	24761	22	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	24761	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24761	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	26	Adams	Adams	NNP
18637	24761	27	,	,	,
18637	24761	28	204	204	CD
18637	24761	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24761	30	415	415	CD
18637	24761	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24761	32	1907	1907	CD
18637	24761	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24761	34	,	,	,
18637	24761	35	534	534	CD
18637	24761	36	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	24761	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	24761	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	40	Hines	Hines	NNP
18637	24761	41	,	,	,
18637	24761	42	253	253	CD
18637	24761	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24761	44	66	66	CD
18637	24761	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24761	46	1920	1920	CD
18637	24761	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24761	48	,	,	,
18637	24761	49	202	202	CD
18637	24761	50	,	,	,
18637	24761	51	203	203	CD
18637	24761	52	,	,	,
18637	24761	53	1053	1053	CD
18637	24761	54	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
18637	24761	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24761	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	58	United	United	NNP
18637	24761	59	States	States	NNP
18637	24761	60	,	,	,
18637	24761	61	257	257	CD
18637	24761	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24761	63	541	541	CD
18637	24761	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24761	65	1922	1922	CD
18637	24761	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24761	67	,	,	,
18637	24761	68	404	404	CD
18637	24761	69	,	,	,
18637	24761	70	460	460	CD
18637	24761	71	Wallach	Wallach	NNP
18637	24761	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	73	v.	v.	IN
18637	24761	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	75	Van	Van	NNP
18637	24761	76	Riswick	Riswick	NNP
18637	24761	77	,	,	,
18637	24761	78	92	92	CD
18637	24761	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24761	80	202	202	CD
18637	24761	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24761	82	1876	1876	CD
18637	24761	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24761	84	,	,	,
18637	24761	85	645	645	CD
18637	24761	86	Walla	Walla	NNP
18637	24761	87	Walla	Walla	NNP
18637	24761	88	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	24761	90	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	91	Walla	Walla	NNP
18637	24761	92	Walla	Walla	NNP
18637	24761	93	Water	Water	NNP
18637	24761	94	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24761	95	,	,	,
18637	24761	96	172	172	CD
18637	24761	97	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24761	98	1	1	CD
18637	24761	99	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24761	100	1898	1898	CD
18637	24761	101	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24761	102	,	,	,
18637	24761	103	329	329	CD
18637	24761	104	,	,	,
18637	24761	105	349	349	CD
18637	24761	106	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	24761	107	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	24761	109	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	110	Jacksonville	Jacksonville	NNP
18637	24761	111	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	24761	112	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24761	113	317	317	CD
18637	24761	114	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24761	115	564	564	CD
18637	24761	116	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24761	117	1943	1943	CD
18637	24761	118	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24761	119	,	,	,
18637	24761	120	157	157	CD
18637	24761	121	Walling	Walling	NNP
18637	24761	122	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	123	v.	v.	IN
18637	24761	124	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	125	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	24761	126	,	,	,
18637	24761	127	116	116	CD
18637	24761	128	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24761	129	446	446	CD
18637	24761	130	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24761	131	1886	1886	CD
18637	24761	132	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24761	133	,	,	,
18637	24761	134	185	185	CD
18637	24761	135	Walls	wall	NNS
18637	24761	136	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	137	v.	v.	IN
18637	24761	138	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	139	Midland	Midland	NNP
18637	24761	140	Carbon	Carbon	NNP
18637	24761	141	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24761	142	,	,	,
18637	24761	143	254	254	CD
18637	24761	144	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24761	145	300	300	CD
18637	24761	146	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24761	147	1920	1920	CD
18637	24761	148	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24761	149	,	,	,
18637	24761	150	1026	1026	CD
18637	24761	151	Walsh	Walsh	NNP
18637	24761	152	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	153	v.	v.	IN
18637	24761	154	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	155	Brewster	Brewster	NNP
18637	24761	156	,	,	,
18637	24761	157	255	255	CD
18637	24761	158	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24761	159	536	536	CD
18637	24761	160	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24761	161	1921	1921	CD
18637	24761	162	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24761	163	,	,	,
18637	24761	164	1199	1199	CD
18637	24761	165	Walton	Walton	NNP
18637	24761	166	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	167	v.	v.	IN
18637	24761	168	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	169	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24761	170	Package	Package	NNP
18637	24761	171	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24761	172	,	,	,
18637	24761	173	320	320	CD
18637	24761	174	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24761	175	540	540	CD
18637	24761	176	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24761	177	1944	1944	CD
18637	24761	178	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24761	179	,	,	,
18637	24761	180	157	157	CD
18637	24761	181	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	24761	182	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	183	v.	v.	IN
18637	24761	184	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	185	Love	Love	NNP
18637	24761	186	County	County	NNP
18637	24761	187	,	,	,
18637	24761	188	253	253	CD
18637	24761	189	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24761	190	17	17	CD
18637	24761	191	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24761	192	1920	1920	CD
18637	24761	193	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24761	194	,	,	,
18637	24761	195	1060	1060	CD
18637	24761	196	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	24761	197	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	198	v.	v.	IN
18637	24761	199	_	_	NNP
18637	24761	200	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	24761	201	,	,	,
18637	24761	202	12	12	CD
18637	24761	203	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24761	204	.	.	.
18637	24762	1	418	418	CD
18637	24762	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24762	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	24762	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24762	5	,	,	,
18637	24762	6	185	185	CD
18637	24762	7	,	,	,
18637	24762	8	692	692	CD
18637	24762	9	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	24762	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24762	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24762	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24762	13	Race	Race	NNP
18637	24762	14	Horse	Horse	NNP
18637	24762	15	,	,	,
18637	24762	16	163	163	CD
18637	24762	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24762	18	504	504	CD
18637	24762	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24762	20	1896	1896	CD
18637	24762	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24762	22	,	,	,
18637	24762	23	432	432	CD
18637	24762	24	,	,	,
18637	24762	25	701	701	CD
18637	24762	26	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	24762	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24762	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24762	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24762	30	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24762	31	,	,	,
18637	24762	32	316	316	CD
18637	24762	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24762	34	547	547	CD
18637	24762	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24762	36	1942	1942	CD
18637	24762	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24762	38	,	,	,
18637	24762	39	1113	1113	CD
18637	24762	40	Ward	Ward	NNP
18637	24762	41	&	&	CC
18637	24762	42	Gow	Gow	NNP
18637	24762	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24762	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24762	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24762	46	Krinsky	Krinsky	NNP
18637	24762	47	,	,	,
18637	24762	48	259	259	CD
18637	24762	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24762	50	503	503	CD
18637	24762	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24762	52	1922	1922	CD
18637	24762	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24762	54	,	,	,
18637	24762	55	989	989	CD
18637	24762	56	,	,	,
18637	24762	57	1159	1159	CD
18637	24762	58	Ware	Ware	NNP
18637	24762	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24762	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	24762	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24762	62	Hylton	Hylton	NNP
18637	24762	63	,	,	,
18637	24762	64	3	3	CD
18637	24762	65	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	24762	66	.	.	.
18637	24763	1	199	199	CD
18637	24763	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24763	3	1797	1797	CD
18637	24763	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24763	5	,	,	,
18637	24763	6	335	335	CD
18637	24763	7	,	,	,
18637	24763	8	415	415	CD
18637	24763	9	,	,	,
18637	24763	10	416	416	CD
18637	24763	11	,	,	,
18637	24763	12	555	555	CD
18637	24763	13	Ware	Ware	NNP
18637	24763	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24763	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24763	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24763	17	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	24763	18	County	County	NNP
18637	24763	19	,	,	,
18637	24763	20	209	209	CD
18637	24763	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24763	22	405	405	CD
18637	24763	23	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24763	24	1908	1908	CD
18637	24763	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24763	26	,	,	,
18637	24763	27	189	189	CD
18637	24763	28	Waring	Waring	NNP
18637	24763	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24763	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24763	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24763	32	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
18637	24763	33	,	,	,
18637	24763	34	5	5	CD
18637	24763	35	How	how	WRB
18637	24763	36	.	.	.
18637	24764	1	441	441	CD
18637	24764	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24764	3	1847	1847	CD
18637	24764	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24764	5	,	,	,
18637	24764	6	574	574	CD
18637	24764	7	,	,	,
18637	24764	8	576	576	CD
18637	24764	9	,	,	,
18637	24764	10	577	577	CD
18637	24764	11	,	,	,
18637	24764	12	893	893	CD
18637	24764	13	Waring	Waring	NNP
18637	24764	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24764	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24764	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24764	17	Mobile	Mobile	NNP
18637	24764	18	,	,	,
18637	24764	19	8	8	CD
18637	24764	20	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24764	21	.	.	.
18637	24765	1	110	110	CD
18637	24765	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24765	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24765	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24765	5	,	,	,
18637	24765	6	364	364	CD
18637	24765	7	Warren	Warren	NNP
18637	24765	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	24765	9	Bradshaw	Bradshaw	NNP
18637	24765	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24765	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24765	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24765	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24765	14	Hall	Hall	NNP
18637	24765	15	,	,	,
18637	24765	16	317	317	CD
18637	24765	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24765	18	88	88	CD
18637	24765	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24765	20	1942	1942	CD
18637	24765	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24765	22	,	,	,
18637	24765	23	157	157	CD
18637	24765	24	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24765	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24765	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24765	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24765	28	Dawson	Dawson	NNP
18637	24765	29	&	&	CC
18637	24765	30	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24765	31	,	,	,
18637	24765	32	264	264	CD
18637	24765	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24765	34	219	219	CD
18637	24765	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24765	36	1924	1924	CD
18637	24765	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24765	38	,	,	,
18637	24765	39	311	311	CD
18637	24765	40	,	,	,
18637	24765	41	581	581	CD
18637	24765	42	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24765	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24765	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24765	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24765	46	Superior	Superior	NNP
18637	24765	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	24765	48	,	,	,
18637	24765	49	289	289	CD
18637	24765	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24765	51	361	361	CD
18637	24765	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24765	53	1933	1933	CD
18637	24765	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24765	55	,	,	,
18637	24765	56	1078	1078	CD
18637	24765	57	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24765	58	ex	ex	NN
18637	24765	59	rel	rel	NN
18637	24765	60	.	.	.
18637	24766	1	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
18637	24766	2	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24766	3	&	&	CC
18637	24766	4	N.	N.	NNP
18637	24766	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24766	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24766	7	v.	v.	IN
18637	24766	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24766	9	Fairchild	Fairchild	NNP
18637	24766	10	,	,	,
18637	24766	11	224	224	CD
18637	24766	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24766	13	510	510	CD
18637	24766	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24766	15	1912	1912	CD
18637	24766	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24766	17	,	,	,
18637	24766	18	1013	1013	CD
18637	24766	19	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24766	20	ex	ex	NN
18637	24766	21	rel	rel	NN
18637	24766	22	.	.	.
18637	24767	1	Seattle	Seattle	NNP
18637	24767	2	Title	Title	NNP
18637	24767	3	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24767	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24767	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24767	6	v.	v.	IN
18637	24767	7	_	_	NNP
18637	24767	8	Roberage	Roberage	NNP
18637	24767	9	,	,	,
18637	24767	10	278	278	CD
18637	24767	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24767	12	116	116	CD
18637	24767	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24767	14	1928	1928	CD
18637	24767	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24767	16	,	,	,
18637	24767	17	1029	1029	CD
18637	24767	18	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24767	19	Market	Market	NNP
18637	24767	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24767	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24767	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	24767	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24767	24	District	District	NNP
18637	24767	25	of	of	IN
18637	24767	26	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	24767	27	,	,	,
18637	24767	28	172	172	CD
18637	24767	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24767	30	361	361	CD
18637	24767	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24767	32	1899	1899	CD
18637	24767	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24767	34	,	,	,
18637	24767	35	304	304	CD
18637	24767	36	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24767	37	-	-	HYPH
18637	24767	38	Southern	Southern	NNP
18637	24767	39	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	24767	40	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24767	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24767	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24767	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24767	44	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	24767	45	&	&	CC
18637	24767	46	P.S.B.	P.S.B.	NNP
18637	24768	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24768	2	,	,	,
18637	24768	3	263	263	CD
18637	24768	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24768	5	629	629	CD
18637	24768	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24768	7	1924	1924	CD
18637	24768	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24768	9	,	,	,
18637	24768	10	526	526	CD
18637	24768	11	Washington	Washington	NNP
18637	24768	12	University	University	NNP
18637	24768	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24768	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24768	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24768	16	Rouse	Rouse	NNP
18637	24768	17	,	,	,
18637	24768	18	8	8	CD
18637	24768	19	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24768	20	.	.	.
18637	24769	1	439	439	CD
18637	24769	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24769	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24769	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24769	5	,	,	,
18637	24769	6	351	351	CD
18637	24769	7	Waterloo	Waterloo	NNP
18637	24769	8	Distilling	Distilling	NNP
18637	24769	9	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24769	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24769	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24769	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24769	13	United	United	NNP
18637	24769	14	States	States	NNP
18637	24769	15	,	,	,
18637	24769	16	282	282	CD
18637	24769	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24769	18	577	577	CD
18637	24769	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24769	20	1931	1931	CD
18637	24769	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24769	22	,	,	,
18637	24769	23	841	841	CD
18637	24769	24	Waters	Waters	NNPS
18637	24769	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	24769	26	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
18637	24769	27	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24769	28	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24769	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24769	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	24769	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24769	32	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24769	33	,	,	,
18637	24769	34	212	212	CD
18637	24769	35	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24769	36	86	86	CD
18637	24769	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24769	38	1909	1909	CD
18637	24769	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24769	40	,	,	,
18637	24769	41	1017	1017	CD
18637	24769	42	,	,	,
18637	24769	43	1133	1133	CD
18637	24769	44	Watkins	Watkins	NNP
18637	24769	45	,	,	,
18637	24769	46	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24769	47	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24769	48	,	,	,
18637	24769	49	3	3	CD
18637	24769	50	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	24769	51	.	.	.
18637	24770	1	193	193	CD
18637	24770	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24770	3	1830	1830	CD
18637	24770	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24770	5	,	,	,
18637	24770	6	313	313	CD
18637	24770	7	,	,	,
18637	24770	8	314	314	CD
18637	24770	9	,	,	,
18637	24770	10	904	904	CD
18637	24770	11	Watkins	Watkins	NNP
18637	24770	12	,	,	,
18637	24770	13	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24770	14	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24770	15	,	,	,
18637	24770	16	7	7	CD
18637	24770	17	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	24770	18	.	.	.
18637	24771	1	568	568	CD
18637	24771	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24771	3	1833	1833	CD
18637	24771	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24771	5	,	,	,
18637	24771	6	302	302	CD
18637	24771	7	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	24771	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24771	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24771	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24771	11	Buck	Buck	NNP
18637	24771	12	,	,	,
18637	24771	13	313	313	CD
18637	24771	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24771	15	387	387	CD
18637	24771	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24771	17	1941	1941	CD
18637	24771	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24771	19	,	,	,
18637	24771	20	564	564	CD
18637	24771	21	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	24771	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24771	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	24771	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24771	25	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	24771	26	,	,	,
18637	24771	27	13	13	CD
18637	24771	28	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24771	29	.	.	.
18637	24772	1	679	679	CD
18637	24772	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24772	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	24772	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24772	5	,	,	,
18637	24772	6	627	627	CD
18637	24772	7	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	24772	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24772	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24772	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24772	11	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	24772	12	,	,	,
18637	24772	13	218	218	CD
18637	24772	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24772	15	173	173	CD
18637	24772	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24772	17	1910	1910	CD
18637	24772	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24772	19	,	,	,
18637	24772	20	1024	1024	CD
18637	24772	21	,	,	,
18637	24772	22	1145	1145	CD
18637	24772	23	,	,	,
18637	24772	24	1146	1146	CD
18637	24772	25	,	,	,
18637	24772	26	1155	1155	CD
18637	24772	27	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	24772	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24772	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24772	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24772	31	Mercer	Mercer	NNP
18637	24772	32	,	,	,
18637	24772	33	8	8	CD
18637	24772	34	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24772	35	.	.	.
18637	24773	1	88	88	CD
18637	24773	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24773	3	1834	1834	CD
18637	24773	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24773	5	,	,	,
18637	24773	6	327	327	CD
18637	24773	7	Watson	Watson	NNP
18637	24773	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24773	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24773	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24773	11	Tarpley	Tarpley	NNP
18637	24773	12	,	,	,
18637	24773	13	18	18	CD
18637	24773	14	How	how	WRB
18637	24773	15	.	.	.
18637	24774	1	517	517	CD
18637	24774	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24774	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	24774	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24774	5	,	,	,
18637	24774	6	604	604	CD
18637	24774	7	Watts	Watts	NNP
18637	24774	8	,	,	,
18637	24774	9	In	in	IN
18637	24774	10	re	re	NN
18637	24774	11	,	,	,
18637	24774	12	190	190	CD
18637	24774	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24774	14	1	1	CD
18637	24774	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24774	16	1903	1903	CD
18637	24774	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24774	18	,	,	,
18637	24774	19	265	265	CD
18637	24774	20	Watts	Watts	NNP
18637	24774	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24774	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	24774	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24774	24	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
18637	24774	25	,	,	,
18637	24774	26	338	338	CD
18637	24774	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24774	28	49	49	CD
18637	24774	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24774	30	1949	1949	CD
18637	24774	31	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24774	32	,	,	,
18637	24774	33	1120	1120	CD
18637	24774	34	,	,	,
18637	24774	35	1121	1121	CD
18637	24774	36	Watts	Watts	NNP
18637	24774	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24774	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	24774	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24774	40	United	United	NNP
18637	24774	41	States	States	NNP
18637	24774	42	,	,	,
18637	24774	43	1	1	CD
18637	24774	44	Wash.	Washington	NNP
18637	24774	45	Terr	Terr	NNP
18637	24774	46	.	.	.
18637	24775	1	288	288	CD
18637	24775	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24775	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	24775	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24775	5	,	,	,
18637	24775	6	435	435	CD
18637	24775	7	Waugh	Waugh	NNP
18637	24775	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24775	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24775	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24775	11	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	24775	12	University	University	NNP
18637	24775	13	,	,	,
18637	24775	14	237	237	CD
18637	24775	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24775	16	589	589	CD
18637	24775	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24775	18	1915	1915	CD
18637	24775	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24775	20	,	,	,
18637	24775	21	985	985	CD
18637	24775	22	Wayman	Wayman	NNP
18637	24775	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24775	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24775	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24775	26	Southard	Southard	NNP
18637	24775	27	,	,	,
18637	24775	28	10	10	CD
18637	24775	29	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24775	30	.	.	.
18637	24776	1	1	1	CD
18637	24776	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24776	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	24776	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24776	5	,	,	,
18637	24776	6	74	74	CD
18637	24776	7	,	,	,
18637	24776	8	75	75	CD
18637	24776	9	,	,	,
18637	24776	10	79	79	CD
18637	24776	11	,	,	,
18637	24776	12	512	512	CD
18637	24776	13	,	,	,
18637	24776	14	525	525	CD
18637	24776	15	Weaver	Weaver	NNP
18637	24776	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24776	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24776	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24776	19	Palmer	Palmer	NNP
18637	24776	20	Bros.	Bros.	NNPS
18637	24776	21	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24776	22	,	,	,
18637	24776	23	270	270	CD
18637	24776	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24776	25	402	402	CD
18637	24776	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24776	27	1926	1926	CD
18637	24776	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24776	29	,	,	,
18637	24776	30	1031	1031	CD
18637	24776	31	Webb	Webb	NNP
18637	24776	32	,	,	,
18637	24776	33	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24776	34	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24776	35	,	,	,
18637	24776	36	225	225	CD
18637	24776	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24776	38	663	663	CD
18637	24776	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24776	40	1912	1912	CD
18637	24776	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24776	42	,	,	,
18637	24776	43	699	699	CD
18637	24776	44	Webber	Webber	NNP
18637	24776	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24776	46	v.	v.	IN
18637	24776	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24776	48	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24776	49	,	,	,
18637	24776	50	103	103	CD
18637	24776	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24776	52	455	455	CD
18637	24776	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24776	54	1881	1881	CD
18637	24776	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24776	56	,	,	,
18637	24776	57	185	185	CD
18637	24776	58	Weber	Weber	NNP
18637	24776	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24776	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	24776	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24776	62	Freed	Freed	NNP
18637	24776	63	,	,	,
18637	24776	64	239	239	CD
18637	24776	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24776	66	325	325	CD
18637	24776	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24776	68	1915	1915	CD
18637	24776	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24776	70	,	,	,
18637	24776	71	162	162	CD
18637	24776	72	Weber	Weber	NNP
18637	24776	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24776	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	24776	75	_	_	NNP
18637	24776	76	State	State	NNP
18637	24776	77	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	24776	78	Comrs	Comrs	NNP
18637	24776	79	.	.	.
18637	24776	80	,	,	,
18637	24776	81	18	18	CD
18637	24776	82	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24776	83	.	.	.
18637	24777	1	57	57	CD
18637	24777	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24777	3	1873	1873	CD
18637	24777	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24777	5	,	,	,
18637	24777	6	698	698	CD
18637	24777	7	Webster	Webster	NNP
18637	24777	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24777	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24777	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24777	11	Reid	Reid	NNP
18637	24777	12	,	,	,
18637	24777	13	11	11	CD
18637	24777	14	How	how	WRB
18637	24777	15	.	.	.
18637	24778	1	437	437	CD
18637	24778	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24778	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	24778	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24778	5	,	,	,
18637	24778	6	893	893	CD
18637	24778	7	Weeks	Weeks	NNPS
18637	24778	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24778	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24778	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24778	13	,	,	,
18637	24778	14	232	232	CD
18637	24778	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24778	16	383	383	CD
18637	24778	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24778	18	1914	1914	CD
18637	24778	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24778	20	,	,	,
18637	24778	21	828	828	CD
18637	24778	22	,	,	,
18637	24778	23	831	831	CD
18637	24778	24	,	,	,
18637	24778	25	905	905	CD
18637	24778	26	Weems	Weems	NNPS
18637	24778	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24778	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	30	United	United	NNP
18637	24778	31	States	States	NNP
18637	24778	32	,	,	,
18637	24778	33	217	217	CD
18637	24778	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24778	35	349	349	CD
18637	24778	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24778	37	1910	1910	CD
18637	24778	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24778	39	,	,	,
18637	24778	40	903	903	CD
18637	24778	41	Weiss	Weiss	NNP
18637	24778	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24778	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	45	Stearn	Stearn	NNP
18637	24778	46	,	,	,
18637	24778	47	265	265	CD
18637	24778	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24778	49	242	242	CD
18637	24778	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24778	51	1924	1924	CD
18637	24778	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24778	53	,	,	,
18637	24778	54	1195	1195	CD
18637	24778	55	Weiss	Weiss	NNP
18637	24778	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24778	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	59	United	United	NNP
18637	24778	60	States	States	NNP
18637	24778	61	,	,	,
18637	24778	62	308	308	CD
18637	24778	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24778	64	321	321	CD
18637	24778	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24778	66	1939	1939	CD
18637	24778	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24778	68	,	,	,
18637	24778	69	136	136	CD
18637	24778	70	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	24778	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	24778	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	74	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	24778	75	,	,	,
18637	24778	76	97	97	CD
18637	24778	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24778	78	541	541	CD
18637	24778	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24778	80	1879	1879	CD
18637	24778	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24778	82	,	,	,
18637	24778	83	304	304	CD
18637	24778	84	,	,	,
18637	24778	85	342	342	CD
18637	24778	86	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	24778	87	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	88	v.	v.	IN
18637	24778	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	90	Henry	Henry	NNP
18637	24778	91	,	,	,
18637	24778	92	305	305	CD
18637	24778	93	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24778	94	134	134	CD
18637	24778	95	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24778	96	1938	1938	CD
18637	24778	97	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24778	98	,	,	,
18637	24778	99	1039	1039	CD
18637	24778	100	,	,	,
18637	24778	101	1150	1150	CD
18637	24778	102	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	24778	103	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	104	v.	v.	IN
18637	24778	105	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	106	Swasey	Swasey	NNP
18637	24778	107	,	,	,
18637	24778	108	214	214	CD
18637	24778	109	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24778	110	91	91	CD
18637	24778	111	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24778	112	1909	1909	CD
18637	24778	113	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24778	114	,	,	,
18637	24778	115	983	983	CD
18637	24778	116	,	,	,
18637	24778	117	1027	1027	CD
18637	24778	118	,	,	,
18637	24778	119	1065	1065	CD
18637	24778	120	,	,	,
18637	24778	121	1068	1068	CD
18637	24778	122	,	,	,
18637	24778	123	1154	1154	CD
18637	24778	124	Welch	Welch	NNP
18637	24778	125	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24778	126	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	127	v.	v.	IN
18637	24778	128	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	129	New	New	NNP
18637	24778	130	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
18637	24778	131	,	,	,
18637	24778	132	306	306	CD
18637	24778	133	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24778	134	79	79	CD
18637	24778	135	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24778	136	1939	1939	CD
18637	24778	137	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24778	138	,	,	,
18637	24778	139	226	226	CD
18637	24778	140	,	,	,
18637	24778	141	251	251	CD
18637	24778	142	,	,	,
18637	24778	143	1155	1155	CD
18637	24778	144	Weller	Weller	NNP
18637	24778	145	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	146	v.	v.	IN
18637	24778	147	_	_	NNP
18637	24778	148	New	New	NNP
18637	24778	149	York	York	NNP
18637	24778	150	,	,	,
18637	24778	151	268	268	CD
18637	24778	152	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24778	153	319	319	CD
18637	24778	154	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24778	155	1925	1925	CD
18637	24778	156	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24778	157	,	,	,
18637	24778	158	1024	1024	CD
18637	24778	159	Wells	Wells	NNP
18637	24778	160	,	,	,
18637	24778	161	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24778	162	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24778	163	,	,	,
18637	24778	164	18	18	CD
18637	24778	165	How	how	WRB
18637	24778	166	.	.	.
18637	24779	1	307	307	CD
18637	24779	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24779	3	1856	1856	CD
18637	24779	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24779	5	,	,	,
18637	24779	6	407	407	CD
18637	24779	7	Wells	Wells	NNP
18637	24779	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24779	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24779	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24779	11	Roper	Roper	NNP
18637	24779	12	,	,	,
18637	24779	13	246	246	CD
18637	24779	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24779	15	335	335	CD
18637	24779	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24779	17	1918	1918	CD
18637	24779	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24779	19	,	,	,
18637	24779	20	588	588	CD
18637	24779	21	,	,	,
18637	24779	22	590	590	CD
18637	24779	23	Wells	Wells	NNP
18637	24779	24	Fargo	Fargo	NNP
18637	24779	25	&	&	CC
18637	24779	26	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24779	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24779	28	v.	v.	IN
18637	24779	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24779	30	Ford	Ford	NNP
18637	24779	31	,	,	,
18637	24779	32	238	238	CD
18637	24779	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24779	34	503	503	CD
18637	24779	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24779	36	1915	1915	CD
18637	24779	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24779	38	,	,	,
18637	24779	39	658	658	CD
18637	24779	40	Welton	Welton	NNP
18637	24779	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24779	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24779	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24779	44	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	24779	45	,	,	,
18637	24779	46	91	91	CD
18637	24779	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24779	48	275	275	CD
18637	24779	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24779	50	1876	1876	CD
18637	24779	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24779	52	,	,	,
18637	24779	53	184	184	CD
18637	24779	54	,	,	,
18637	24779	55	218	218	CD
18637	24779	56	West	West	NNP
18637	24779	57	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	24779	58	Hotel	Hotel	NNP
18637	24779	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24779	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	24779	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24779	62	Parrish	Parrish	NNP
18637	24779	63	,	,	,
18637	24779	64	300	300	CD
18637	24779	65	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24779	66	379	379	CD
18637	24779	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24779	68	1937	1937	CD
18637	24779	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24779	70	,	,	,
18637	24779	71	303	303	CD
18637	24779	72	,	,	,
18637	24779	73	855	855	CD
18637	24779	74	,	,	,
18637	24779	75	980	980	CD
18637	24779	76	,	,	,
18637	24779	77	988	988	CD
18637	24779	78	,	,	,
18637	24779	79	1146	1146	CD
18637	24779	80	,	,	,
18637	24779	81	1159	1159	CD
18637	24779	82	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24779	83	&	&	CC
18637	24779	84	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	24780	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24780	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24780	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24780	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24780	5	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	24780	6	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24780	7	Service	Service	NNP
18637	24780	8	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24780	9	,	,	,
18637	24780	10	267	267	CD
18637	24780	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24780	12	493	493	CD
18637	24780	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24780	14	1925	1925	CD
18637	24780	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24780	16	,	,	,
18637	24780	17	1012	1012	CD
18637	24780	18	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24780	19	&	&	CC
18637	24780	20	A.R.	A.R.	NNP
18637	24781	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24781	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24781	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24781	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24781	5	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	24781	6	,	,	,
18637	24781	7	279	279	CD
18637	24781	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24781	9	639	639	CD
18637	24781	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24781	11	1929	1929	CD
18637	24781	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24781	13	,	,	,
18637	24781	14	1094	1094	CD
18637	24781	15	,	,	,
18637	24781	16	1095	1095	CD
18637	24781	17	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24781	18	Distributing	Distributing	NNP
18637	24781	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24781	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24781	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24781	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24781	23	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24781	24	Serv	Serv	NNP
18637	24781	25	.	.	.
18637	24782	1	Com	com	NN
18637	24782	2	.	.	.
18637	24783	1	of	of	IN
18637	24783	2	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24783	3	,	,	,
18637	24783	4	285	285	CD
18637	24783	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24783	6	119	119	CD
18637	24783	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24783	8	1932	1932	CD
18637	24783	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24783	10	,	,	,
18637	24783	11	234	234	CD
18637	24783	12	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24783	13	Life	Life	NNP
18637	24783	14	Indemnity	Indemnity	NNP
18637	24783	15	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24783	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24783	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24783	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24783	19	Rupp	Rupp	NNP
18637	24783	20	,	,	,
18637	24783	21	235	235	CD
18637	24783	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24783	23	261	261	CD
18637	24783	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24783	25	1914	1914	CD
18637	24783	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24783	27	,	,	,
18637	24783	28	676	676	CD
18637	24783	29	Western	western	JJ
18637	24783	30	Live	Live	NNP
18637	24783	31	Stock	Stock	NNP
18637	24783	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24783	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	24783	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24783	35	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
18637	24783	36	of	of	IN
18637	24783	37	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	24783	38	,	,	,
18637	24783	39	303	303	CD
18637	24783	40	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24783	41	250	250	CD
18637	24783	42	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24783	43	1938	1938	CD
18637	24783	44	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24783	45	,	,	,
18637	24783	46	195	195	CD
18637	24783	47	,	,	,
18637	24783	48	204	204	CD
18637	24783	49	,	,	,
18637	24783	50	205	205	CD
18637	24783	51	,	,	,
18637	24783	52	207	207	CD
18637	24783	53	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24783	54	Maid	Maid	NNP
18637	24783	55	,	,	,
18637	24783	56	The	the	DT
18637	24783	57	,	,	,
18637	24783	58	257	257	CD
18637	24783	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24783	60	419	419	CD
18637	24783	61	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24783	62	1922	1922	CD
18637	24783	63	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24783	64	,	,	,
18637	24783	65	586	586	CD
18637	24783	66	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24783	67	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24783	68	Refining	Refining	NNP
18637	24783	69	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24783	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24783	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	24783	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24783	73	Lipscomb	Lipscomb	NNP
18637	24783	74	,	,	,
18637	24783	75	244	244	CD
18637	24783	76	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24783	77	346	346	CD
18637	24783	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24783	79	1917	1917	CD
18637	24783	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24783	81	,	,	,
18637	24783	82	187	187	CD
18637	24783	83	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24783	84	Paper	Paper	NNP
18637	24783	85	Makers	Makers	NNPS
18637	24783	86	'	'	POS
18637	24783	87	Chemical	Chemical	NNP
18637	24783	88	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24783	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24783	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	24783	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24783	92	United	United	NNP
18637	24783	93	States	States	NNP
18637	24783	94	,	,	,
18637	24783	95	271	271	CD
18637	24783	96	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24783	97	268	268	CD
18637	24783	98	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24783	99	1926	1926	CD
18637	24783	100	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24783	101	,	,	,
18637	24783	102	850	850	CD
18637	24783	103	Western	western	JJ
18637	24783	104	Turf	Turf	NNP
18637	24783	105	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	24783	106	.	.	.
18637	24784	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24784	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24784	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24784	4	Greenberg	Greenberg	NNP
18637	24784	5	,	,	,
18637	24784	6	204	204	CD
18637	24784	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24784	8	359	359	CD
18637	24784	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24784	10	1907	1907	CD
18637	24784	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24784	12	,	,	,
18637	24784	13	809	809	CD
18637	24784	14	,	,	,
18637	24784	15	981	981	CD
18637	24784	16	,	,	,
18637	24784	17	1024	1024	CD
18637	24784	18	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24784	19	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24784	20	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24784	21	.	.	.
18637	24785	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24785	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24785	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24785	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24785	5	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	24785	6	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24785	7	of	of	IN
18637	24785	8	Assessment	Assessment	NNP
18637	24785	9	,	,	,
18637	24785	10	132	132	CD
18637	24785	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24785	12	472	472	CD
18637	24785	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24785	14	1889	1889	CD
18637	24785	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24785	16	,	,	,
18637	24785	17	204	204	CD
18637	24785	18	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24785	19	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24785	20	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24785	21	.	.	.
18637	24786	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24786	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24786	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24786	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24786	5	Ann	Ann	NNP
18637	24786	6	Arbor	Arbor	NNP
18637	24786	7	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24786	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24786	9	,	,	,
18637	24786	10	178	178	CD
18637	24786	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24786	12	239	239	CD
18637	24786	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24786	14	1900	1900	CD
18637	24786	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24786	16	,	,	,
18637	24786	17	567	567	CD
18637	24786	18	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24786	19	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24786	20	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24786	21	.	.	.
18637	24787	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24787	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24787	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24787	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24787	5	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	24787	6	,	,	,
18637	24787	7	234	234	CD
18637	24787	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24787	9	542	542	CD
18637	24787	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24787	11	1914	1914	CD
18637	24787	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24787	13	,	,	,
18637	24787	14	232	232	CD
18637	24787	15	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24787	16	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24787	17	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24787	18	.	.	.
18637	24788	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24788	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24788	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24788	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24788	5	Chiles	Chiles	NNP
18637	24788	6	,	,	,
18637	24788	7	214	214	CD
18637	24788	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24788	9	274	274	CD
18637	24788	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24788	11	1909	1909	CD
18637	24788	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24788	13	,	,	,
18637	24788	14	305	305	CD
18637	24788	15	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24788	16	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24788	17	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24788	18	.	.	.
18637	24789	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24789	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24789	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24789	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24789	5	Commercial	Commercial	NNP
18637	24789	6	Milling	Milling	NNP
18637	24789	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24789	8	,	,	,
18637	24789	9	218	218	CD
18637	24789	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24789	11	406	406	CD
18637	24789	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24789	13	1910	1910	CD
18637	24789	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24789	15	,	,	,
18637	24789	16	232	232	CD
18637	24789	17	,	,	,
18637	24789	18	971	971	CD
18637	24789	19	,	,	,
18637	24789	20	1156	1156	CD
18637	24789	21	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24789	22	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24789	23	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24789	24	.	.	.
18637	24790	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24790	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24790	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24790	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24790	5	Crovo	Crovo	NNP
18637	24790	6	,	,	,
18637	24790	7	220	220	CD
18637	24790	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24790	9	364	364	CD
18637	24790	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24790	11	1911	1911	CD
18637	24790	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24790	13	,	,	,
18637	24790	14	232	232	CD
18637	24790	15	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24790	16	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24790	17	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24790	18	.	.	.
18637	24791	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24791	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24791	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24791	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24791	5	Foster	Foster	NNP
18637	24791	6	,	,	,
18637	24791	7	247	247	CD
18637	24791	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24791	9	105	105	CD
18637	24791	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24791	11	1918	1918	CD
18637	24791	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24791	13	,	,	,
18637	24791	14	120	120	CD
18637	24791	15	,	,	,
18637	24791	16	232	232	CD
18637	24791	17	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24791	18	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24791	19	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24791	20	.	.	.
18637	24792	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24792	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24792	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24792	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24792	5	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	24792	6	Com'n	Com'n	NNP
18637	24792	7	.	.	.
18637	24792	8	,	,	,
18637	24792	9	24	24	CD
18637	24792	10	F.	F.	NNP
18637	24792	11	Supp	Supp	NNP
18637	24792	12	.	.	.
18637	24793	1	370	370	CD
18637	24793	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24793	3	1938	1938	CD
18637	24793	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24793	5	,	,	,
18637	24793	6	1085	1085	CD
18637	24793	7	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24793	8	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24793	9	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24793	10	.	.	.
18637	24794	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24794	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24794	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24794	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24794	5	International	International	NNP
18637	24794	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	24794	7	of	of	IN
18637	24794	8	E.	E.	NNP
18637	24794	9	Workers	Workers	NNP
18637	24794	10	,	,	,
18637	24794	11	2	2	CD
18637	24794	12	F	F	NNP
18637	24794	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24794	14	2d	2d	NNP
18637	24794	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24794	16	993	993	CD
18637	24794	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24794	18	1924	1924	CD
18637	24794	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24794	20	,	,	,
18637	24794	21	953	953	CD
18637	24794	22	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24794	23	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24794	24	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24794	25	.	.	.
18637	24795	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24795	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24795	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24795	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24795	5	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24795	6	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24795	7	rel	rel	NNP
18637	24795	8	.	.	.
18637	24796	1	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
18637	24796	2	,	,	,
18637	24796	3	216	216	CD
18637	24796	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24796	5	1	1	CD
18637	24796	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24796	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	24796	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24796	9	,	,	,
18637	24796	10	196	196	CD
18637	24796	11	,	,	,
18637	24796	12	1051	1051	CD
18637	24796	13	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24796	14	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24796	15	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24796	16	.	.	.
18637	24797	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24797	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24797	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24797	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24797	5	Lenroot	Lenroot	NNP
18637	24797	6	,	,	,
18637	24797	7	323	323	CD
18637	24797	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24797	9	490	490	CD
18637	24797	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24797	11	1945	1945	CD
18637	24797	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24797	13	,	,	,
18637	24797	14	158	158	CD
18637	24797	15	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24797	16	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24797	17	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24797	18	.	.	.
18637	24798	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24798	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24798	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24798	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24798	5	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	24798	6	,	,	,
18637	24798	7	125	125	CD
18637	24798	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24798	9	530	530	CD
18637	24798	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24798	11	1888	1888	CD
18637	24798	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24798	13	,	,	,
18637	24798	14	200	200	CD
18637	24798	15	,	,	,
18637	24798	16	201	201	CD
18637	24798	17	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24798	18	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24798	19	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24798	20	.	.	.
18637	24799	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24799	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24799	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24799	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24799	5	New	New	NNP
18637	24799	6	Hope	Hope	NNP
18637	24799	7	,	,	,
18637	24799	8	187	187	CD
18637	24799	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24799	10	419	419	CD
18637	24799	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24799	12	1903	1903	CD
18637	24799	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24799	14	,	,	,
18637	24799	15	214	214	CD
18637	24799	16	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24799	17	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24799	18	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24799	19	.	.	.
18637	24800	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24800	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24800	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24800	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24800	5	Pendleton	Pendleton	NNP
18637	24800	6	,	,	,
18637	24800	7	122	122	CD
18637	24800	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24800	9	347	347	CD
18637	24800	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24800	11	1887	1887	CD
18637	24800	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24800	13	,	,	,
18637	24800	14	232	232	CD
18637	24800	15	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24800	16	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24800	17	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24800	18	.	.	.
18637	24801	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24801	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24801	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24801	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24801	5	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
18637	24801	6	,	,	,
18637	24801	7	224	224	CD
18637	24801	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24801	9	160	160	CD
18637	24801	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24801	11	1912	1912	CD
18637	24801	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24801	13	,	,	,
18637	24801	14	232	232	CD
18637	24801	15	,	,	,
18637	24801	16	1009	1009	CD
18637	24801	17	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24801	18	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24801	19	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24801	20	.	.	.
18637	24802	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24802	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24802	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24802	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24802	5	Speight	Speight	NNP
18637	24802	6	,	,	,
18637	24802	7	254	254	CD
18637	24802	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24802	9	17	17	CD
18637	24802	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24802	11	1920	1920	CD
18637	24802	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24802	13	,	,	,
18637	24802	14	122	122	CD
18637	24802	15	,	,	,
18637	24802	16	126	126	CD
18637	24802	17	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24802	18	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24802	19	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24802	20	.	.	.
18637	24803	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24803	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24803	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24803	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24803	5	Taggart	Taggart	NNP
18637	24803	6	,	,	,
18637	24803	7	163	163	CD
18637	24803	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24803	9	1	1	CD
18637	24803	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24803	11	1896	1896	CD
18637	24803	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24803	13	,	,	,
18637	24803	14	201	201	CD
18637	24803	15	Western	Western	NNP
18637	24803	16	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24803	17	Teleg	Teleg	NNP
18637	24803	18	.	.	.
18637	24804	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24804	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24804	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24804	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24804	5	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24804	6	,	,	,
18637	24804	7	105	105	CD
18637	24804	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24804	9	460	460	CD
18637	24804	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24804	11	1882	1882	CD
18637	24804	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24804	13	,	,	,
18637	24804	14	126	126	CD
18637	24804	15	,	,	,
18637	24804	16	193	193	CD
18637	24804	17	,	,	,
18637	24804	18	733	733	CD
18637	24804	19	Weston	Weston	NNP
18637	24804	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24804	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24804	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24804	23	Charleston	Charleston	NNP
18637	24804	24	,	,	,
18637	24804	25	2	2	CD
18637	24804	26	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24804	27	.	.	.
18637	24805	1	449	449	CD
18637	24805	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24805	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	24805	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24805	5	,	,	,
18637	24805	6	729	729	CD
18637	24805	7	West	West	NNP
18637	24805	8	River	River	NNP
18637	24805	9	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	24805	10	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24805	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24805	12	v.	v.	IN
18637	24805	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24805	14	Dix	Dix	NNP
18637	24805	15	,	,	,
18637	24805	16	6	6	CD
18637	24805	17	How	how	WRB
18637	24805	18	.	.	.
18637	24806	1	507	507	CD
18637	24806	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24806	3	1848	1848	CD
18637	24806	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24806	5	,	,	,
18637	24806	6	350	350	CD
18637	24806	7	West	West	NNP
18637	24806	8	Side	Side	NNP
18637	24806	9	Belt	Belt	NNP
18637	24806	10	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24806	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24806	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24806	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24806	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24806	15	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
18637	24806	16	Constr	Constr	NNP
18637	24806	17	.	.	.
18637	24807	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24807	2	,	,	,
18637	24807	3	219	219	CD
18637	24807	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24807	5	92	92	CD
18637	24807	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24807	7	1911	1911	CD
18637	24807	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24807	9	,	,	,
18637	24807	10	685	685	CD
18637	24807	11	West	West	NNP
18637	24807	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24807	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24807	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24807	15	American	American	NNP
18637	24807	16	Telephone	Telephone	NNP
18637	24807	17	&	&	CC
18637	24807	18	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	24807	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24807	20	,	,	,
18637	24807	21	311	311	CD
18637	24807	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24807	23	223	223	CD
18637	24807	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24807	25	1940	1940	CD
18637	24807	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24807	27	,	,	,
18637	24807	28	607	607	CD
18637	24807	29	West	West	NNP
18637	24807	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24807	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24807	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24807	33	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	24807	34	,	,	,
18637	24807	35	194	194	CD
18637	24807	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24807	37	258	258	CD
18637	24807	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24807	39	1904	1904	CD
18637	24807	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24807	41	,	,	,
18637	24807	42	1009	1009	CD
18637	24807	43	,	,	,
18637	24807	44	1141	1141	CD
18637	24807	45	Wetmore	Wetmore	NNP
18637	24807	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24807	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	24807	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24807	49	Karrick	Karrick	NNP
18637	24807	50	,	,	,
18637	24807	51	205	205	CD
18637	24807	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24807	53	141	141	CD
18637	24807	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24807	55	1907	1907	CD
18637	24807	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24807	57	,	,	,
18637	24807	58	659	659	CD
18637	24807	59	Wharton	Wharton	NNP
18637	24807	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24807	61	v.	v.	IN
18637	24807	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24807	63	Wise	Wise	NNP
18637	24807	64	,	,	,
18637	24807	65	153	153	CD
18637	24807	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24807	67	155	155	CD
18637	24807	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24807	69	1894	1894	CD
18637	24807	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24807	71	,	,	,
18637	24807	72	11	11	CD
18637	24807	73	,	,	,
18637	24807	74	369	369	CD
18637	24807	75	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
18637	24807	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24807	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	24807	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24807	79	Peters	Peters	NNP
18637	24807	80	,	,	,
18637	24807	81	8	8	CD
18637	24807	82	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24807	83	.	.	.
18637	24808	1	591	591	CD
18637	24808	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24808	3	1834	1834	CD
18637	24808	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24808	5	,	,	,
18637	24808	6	271	271	CD
18637	24808	7	,	,	,
18637	24808	8	274	274	CD
18637	24808	9	,	,	,
18637	24808	10	275	275	CD
18637	24808	11	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	24808	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24808	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	15	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	24808	16	,	,	,
18637	24808	17	137	137	CD
18637	24808	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24808	19	245	245	CD
18637	24808	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24808	21	1890	1890	CD
18637	24808	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24808	23	,	,	,
18637	24808	24	1092	1092	CD
18637	24808	25	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	24808	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24808	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	29	Sohmer	Sohmer	NNP
18637	24808	30	,	,	,
18637	24808	31	233	233	CD
18637	24808	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24808	33	434	434	CD
18637	24808	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24808	35	1914	1914	CD
18637	24808	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24808	37	,	,	,
18637	24808	38	1045	1045	CD
18637	24808	39	,	,	,
18637	24808	40	1047	1047	CD
18637	24808	41	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	24808	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24808	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	45	United	United	NNP
18637	24808	46	States	States	NNP
18637	24808	47	,	,	,
18637	24808	48	226	226	CD
18637	24808	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24808	50	478	478	CD
18637	24808	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24808	52	1913	1913	CD
18637	24808	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24808	54	,	,	,
18637	24808	55	827	827	CD
18637	24808	56	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
18637	24808	57	Lumber	Lumber	NNP
18637	24808	58	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	24808	59	&	&	CC
18637	24808	60	Supply	Supply	NNP
18637	24808	61	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24808	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	24808	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	65	United	United	NNP
18637	24808	66	States	States	NNP
18637	24808	67	,	,	,
18637	24808	68	281	281	CD
18637	24808	69	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24808	70	572	572	CD
18637	24808	71	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24808	72	1930	1930	CD
18637	24808	73	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24808	74	,	,	,
18637	24808	75	107	107	CD
18637	24808	76	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	24808	77	,	,	,
18637	24808	78	P.	P.	NNP
18637	24808	79	&	&	CC
18637	24808	80	C.	C.	NNP
18637	24808	81	Transportation	Transportation	NNP
18637	24808	82	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24808	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	24808	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	86	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	24808	87	,	,	,
18637	24808	88	99	99	CD
18637	24808	89	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24808	90	273	273	CD
18637	24808	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24808	92	1879	1879	CD
18637	24808	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24808	94	,	,	,
18637	24808	95	366	366	CD
18637	24808	96	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	24808	97	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	24808	98	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24808	99	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	100	v.	v.	IN
18637	24808	101	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	102	Fox	Fox	NNP
18637	24808	103	,	,	,
18637	24808	104	298	298	CD
18637	24808	105	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24808	106	193	193	CD
18637	24808	107	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24808	108	1936	1936	CD
18637	24808	109	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24808	110	,	,	,
18637	24808	111	1042	1042	CD
18637	24808	112	,	,	,
18637	24808	113	1050	1050	CD
18637	24808	114	Wheeling	Wheeling	NNP
18637	24808	115	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	24808	116	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24808	117	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	118	v.	v.	IN
18637	24808	119	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	120	Glander	Glander	NNP
18637	24808	121	,	,	,
18637	24808	122	337	337	CD
18637	24808	123	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24808	124	562	562	CD
18637	24808	125	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24808	126	1949	1949	CD
18637	24808	127	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24808	128	,	,	,
18637	24808	129	198	198	CD
18637	24808	130	,	,	,
18637	24808	131	1143	1143	CD
18637	24808	132	,	,	,
18637	24808	133	1144	1144	CD
18637	24808	134	,	,	,
18637	24808	135	1150	1150	CD
18637	24808	136	Whelan	Whelan	NNP
18637	24808	137	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	138	v.	v.	IN
18637	24808	139	_	_	NNP
18637	24808	140	United	United	NNP
18637	24808	141	States	States	NNP
18637	24808	142	,	,	,
18637	24808	143	7	7	CD
18637	24808	144	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24808	145	.	.	.
18637	24809	1	112	112	CD
18637	24809	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24809	3	1812	1812	CD
18637	24809	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24809	5	,	,	,
18637	24809	6	576	576	CD
18637	24809	7	White	White	NNP
18637	24809	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24809	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24809	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24809	11	Cannon	Cannon	NNP
18637	24809	12	,	,	,
18637	24809	13	6	6	CD
18637	24809	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24809	15	.	.	.
18637	24810	1	443	443	CD
18637	24810	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24810	3	1868	1868	CD
18637	24810	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24810	5	,	,	,
18637	24810	6	728	728	CD
18637	24810	7	White	White	NNP
18637	24810	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24810	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24810	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24810	11	Hart	Hart	NNP
18637	24810	12	,	,	,
18637	24810	13	13	13	CD
18637	24810	14	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24810	15	.	.	.
18637	24811	1	646	646	CD
18637	24811	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24811	3	1872	1872	CD
18637	24811	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24811	5	,	,	,
18637	24811	6	728	728	CD
18637	24811	7	White	White	NNP
18637	24811	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24811	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24811	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24811	11	Ragen	Ragen	NNP
18637	24811	12	,	,	,
18637	24811	13	324	324	CD
18637	24811	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24811	15	760	760	CD
18637	24811	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24811	17	1945	1945	CD
18637	24811	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24811	19	,	,	,
18637	24811	20	1102	1102	CD
18637	24811	21	,	,	,
18637	24811	22	1125	1125	CD
18637	24811	23	,	,	,
18637	24811	24	1126	1126	CD
18637	24811	25	,	,	,
18637	24811	26	1137	1137	CD
18637	24811	27	White	White	NNP
18637	24811	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24811	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24811	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24811	31	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24811	32	,	,	,
18637	24811	33	310	310	CD
18637	24811	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24811	35	530	530	CD
18637	24811	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24811	37	1940	1940	CD
18637	24811	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24811	39	,	,	,
18637	24811	40	1113	1113	CD
18637	24811	41	Whitehead	Whitehead	NNP
18637	24811	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24811	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24811	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24811	45	Shattuck	Shattuck	NNP
18637	24811	46	,	,	,
18637	24811	47	138	138	CD
18637	24811	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24811	49	146	146	CD
18637	24811	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24811	51	1891	1891	CD
18637	24811	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24811	53	,	,	,
18637	24811	54	895	895	CD
18637	24811	55	White	White	NNP
18637	24811	56	River	River	NNP
18637	24811	57	Turnpike	Turnpike	NNP
18637	24811	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24811	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24811	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	24811	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24811	62	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
18637	24811	63	Cent	Cent	NNP
18637	24811	64	.	.	.
18637	24812	1	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24812	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24812	3	,	,	,
18637	24812	4	21	21	CD
18637	24812	5	Vt	Vt	NNP
18637	24812	6	.	.	NNP
18637	24812	7	590	590	CD
18637	24812	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24812	9	1849	1849	CD
18637	24812	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24812	11	,	,	,
18637	24812	12	350	350	CD
18637	24812	13	Whitfield	Whitfield	NNP
18637	24812	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24812	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24812	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24812	17	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	24812	18	,	,	,
18637	24812	19	297	297	CD
18637	24812	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24812	21	431	431	CD
18637	24812	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24812	23	1936	1936	CD
18637	24812	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24812	25	,	,	,
18637	24812	26	217	217	CD
18637	24812	27	,	,	,
18637	24812	28	219	219	CD
18637	24812	29	,	,	,
18637	24812	30	240	240	CD
18637	24812	31	,	,	,
18637	24812	32	687	687	CD
18637	24812	33	Whitfield	Whitfield	NNP
18637	24812	34	ex	ex	NN
18637	24812	35	rel	rel	NN
18637	24812	36	.	.	.
18637	24813	1	Hadley	Hadley	NNP
18637	24813	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24813	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24813	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24813	5	Aetna	Aetna	NNP
18637	24813	6	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24813	7	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	24813	8	.	.	.
18637	24814	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24814	2	,	,	,
18637	24814	3	205	205	CD
18637	24814	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24814	5	489	489	CD
18637	24814	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24814	7	1907	1907	CD
18637	24814	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24814	9	,	,	,
18637	24814	10	1023	1023	CD
18637	24814	11	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	24814	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24814	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	15	California	California	NNP
18637	24814	16	,	,	,
18637	24814	17	274	274	CD
18637	24814	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24814	19	357	357	CD
18637	24814	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24814	21	1927	1927	CD
18637	24814	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24814	23	,	,	,
18637	24814	24	772	772	CD
18637	24814	25	,	,	,
18637	24814	26	776	776	CD
18637	24814	27	,	,	,
18637	24814	28	800	800	CD
18637	24814	29	,	,	,
18637	24814	30	1156	1156	CD
18637	24814	31	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	24814	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	33	v.	v.	IN
18637	24814	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	35	Graves	Graves	NNP
18637	24814	36	,	,	,
18637	24814	37	299	299	CD
18637	24814	38	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24814	39	366	366	CD
18637	24814	40	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24814	41	1937	1937	CD
18637	24814	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24814	43	,	,	,
18637	24814	44	1054	1054	CD
18637	24814	45	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	24814	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	24814	48	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	49	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
18637	24814	50	,	,	,
18637	24814	51	124	124	CD
18637	24814	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24814	53	190	190	CD
18637	24814	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24814	55	1888	1888	CD
18637	24814	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24814	57	,	,	,
18637	24814	58	421	421	CD
18637	24814	59	,	,	,
18637	24814	60	422	422	CD
18637	24814	61	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
18637	24814	62	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	63	v.	v.	IN
18637	24814	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	65	State	State	NNP
18637	24814	66	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24814	67	Com	Com	NNP
18637	24814	68	.	.	NNP
18637	24814	69	,	,	,
18637	24814	70	309	309	CD
18637	24814	71	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24814	72	530	530	CD
18637	24814	73	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24814	74	1940	1940	CD
18637	24814	75	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24814	76	,	,	,
18637	24814	77	1039	1039	CD
18637	24814	78	Whitten	Whitten	NNP
18637	24814	79	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	80	v.	v.	IN
18637	24814	81	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	82	Tomlinson	Tomlinson	NNP
18637	24814	83	,	,	,
18637	24814	84	160	160	CD
18637	24814	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24814	86	231	231	CD
18637	24814	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24814	88	1895	1895	CD
18637	24814	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24814	90	,	,	,
18637	24814	91	634	634	CD
18637	24814	92	Wichita	Wichita	NNP
18637	24814	93	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24814	94	&	&	CC
18637	24814	95	L.	L.	NNP
18637	24814	96	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24814	97	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	98	v.	v.	IN
18637	24814	99	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	100	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24814	101	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	24814	102	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24814	103	,	,	,
18637	24814	104	260	260	CD
18637	24814	105	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24814	106	48	48	CD
18637	24814	107	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24814	108	1922	1922	CD
18637	24814	109	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24814	110	,	,	,
18637	24814	111	75	75	CD
18637	24814	112	,	,	,
18637	24814	113	1000	1000	CD
18637	24814	114	Wickard	Wickard	NNP
18637	24814	115	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	116	v.	v.	IN
18637	24814	117	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	118	Filburn	Filburn	NNP
18637	24814	119	,	,	,
18637	24814	120	317	317	CD
18637	24814	121	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24814	122	111	111	CD
18637	24814	123	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24814	124	1942	1942	CD
18637	24814	125	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24814	126	,	,	,
18637	24814	127	147	147	CD
18637	24814	128	,	,	,
18637	24814	129	153	153	CD
18637	24814	130	,	,	,
18637	24814	131	159	159	CD
18637	24814	132	,	,	,
18637	24814	133	564	564	CD
18637	24814	134	,	,	,
18637	24814	135	857	857	CD
18637	24814	136	Wiggins	Wiggins	NNPS
18637	24814	137	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
18637	24814	138	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24814	139	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	140	v.	v.	IN
18637	24814	141	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	142	East	East	NNP
18637	24814	143	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24814	144	Louis	Louis	NNP
18637	24814	145	,	,	,
18637	24814	146	107	107	CD
18637	24814	147	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24814	148	365	365	CD
18637	24814	149	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24814	150	1883	1883	CD
18637	24814	151	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24814	152	,	,	,
18637	24814	153	231	231	CD
18637	24814	154	,	,	,
18637	24814	155	366	366	CD
18637	24814	156	Wight	Wight	NNP
18637	24814	157	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	158	v.	v.	IN
18637	24814	159	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	160	Davidson	Davidson	NNP
18637	24814	161	,	,	,
18637	24814	162	181	181	CD
18637	24814	163	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24814	164	371	371	CD
18637	24814	165	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24814	166	1901	1901	CD
18637	24814	167	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24814	168	,	,	,
18637	24814	169	303	303	CD
18637	24814	170	,	,	,
18637	24814	171	846	846	CD
18637	24814	172	Wilcox	Wilcox	NNP
18637	24814	173	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	174	v.	v.	IN
18637	24814	175	_	_	NNP
18637	24814	176	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	24814	177	ex	ex	NNP
18637	24814	178	dem	dem	NNP
18637	24814	179	.	.	.
18637	24815	1	McConnel	McConnel	NNP
18637	24815	2	,	,	,
18637	24815	3	13	13	CD
18637	24815	4	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24815	5	.	.	.
18637	24816	1	498	498	CD
18637	24816	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24816	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	24816	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24816	5	,	,	,
18637	24816	6	477	477	CD
18637	24816	7	,	,	,
18637	24816	8	703	703	CD
18637	24816	9	Wiley	Wiley	NNP
18637	24816	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24816	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24816	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24816	13	Sinkler	Sinkler	NNP
18637	24816	14	,	,	,
18637	24816	15	179	179	CD
18637	24816	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24816	17	58	58	CD
18637	24816	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24816	19	1900	1900	CD
18637	24816	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24816	21	,	,	,
18637	24816	22	87	87	CD
18637	24816	23	,	,	,
18637	24816	24	967	967	CD
18637	24816	25	Wilkerson	Wilkerson	NNP
18637	24816	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24816	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24816	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24816	29	Utah	Utah	NNP
18637	24816	30	,	,	,
18637	24816	31	99	99	CD
18637	24816	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24816	33	130	130	CD
18637	24816	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24816	35	1879	1879	CD
18637	24816	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24816	37	,	,	,
18637	24816	38	904	904	CD
18637	24816	39	Wilkes	Wilkes	NNP
18637	24816	40	County	County	NNP
18637	24816	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24816	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24816	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24816	44	Coler	Coler	NNP
18637	24816	45	,	,	,
18637	24816	46	180	180	CD
18637	24816	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24816	48	506	506	CD
18637	24816	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24816	50	1901	1901	CD
18637	24816	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24816	52	,	,	,
18637	24816	53	331	331	CD
18637	24816	54	Willamette	Willamette	NNP
18637	24816	55	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	24816	56	Bridge	Bridge	NNP
18637	24816	57	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24816	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24816	59	v.	v.	IN
18637	24816	60	_	_	NNP
18637	24816	61	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	24816	62	,	,	,
18637	24816	63	125	125	CD
18637	24816	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24816	65	1	1	CD
18637	24816	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24816	67	1888	1888	CD
18637	24816	68	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24816	69	,	,	,
18637	24816	70	229	229	CD
18637	24816	71	,	,	,
18637	24816	72	699	699	CD
18637	24816	73	Willard	Willard	NNP
18637	24816	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24816	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	24816	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24816	77	Presbury	Presbury	NNP
18637	24816	78	,	,	,
18637	24816	79	14	14	CD
18637	24816	80	.	.	.
18637	24817	1	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24817	2	.	.	.
18637	24818	1	676	676	CD
18637	24818	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	24818	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	5	,	,	,
18637	24818	6	304	304	CD
18637	24818	7	Willcox	Willcox	NNP
18637	24818	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	11	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
18637	24818	12	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24818	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24818	14	,	,	,
18637	24818	15	212	212	CD
18637	24818	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	17	19	19	CD
18637	24818	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	19	1909	1909	CD
18637	24818	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	21	,	,	,
18637	24818	22	1002	1002	CD
18637	24818	23	,	,	,
18637	24818	24	1006	1006	CD
18637	24818	25	,	,	,
18637	24818	26	1008	1008	CD
18637	24818	27	Willcutts	Willcutts	NNP
18637	24818	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	31	Bunn	Bunn	NNP
18637	24818	32	,	,	,
18637	24818	33	282	282	CD
18637	24818	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	35	216	216	CD
18637	24818	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	37	1931	1931	CD
18637	24818	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	39	,	,	,
18637	24818	40	108	108	CD
18637	24818	41	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24818	42	,	,	,
18637	24818	43	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24818	44	Parte	Parte	NNP
18637	24818	45	,	,	,
18637	24818	46	277	277	CD
18637	24818	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	48	267	267	CD
18637	24818	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	50	1928	1928	CD
18637	24818	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	52	,	,	,
18637	24818	53	631	631	CD
18637	24818	54	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24818	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	58	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
18637	24818	59	,	,	,
18637	24818	60	217	217	CD
18637	24818	61	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	62	79	79	CD
18637	24818	63	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	64	1910	1910	CD
18637	24818	65	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	66	,	,	,
18637	24818	67	1156	1156	CD
18637	24818	68	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24818	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	70	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	72	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	24818	73	,	,	,
18637	24818	74	289	289	CD
18637	24818	75	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	76	36	36	CD
18637	24818	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	78	1933	1933	CD
18637	24818	79	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	80	,	,	,
18637	24818	81	982	982	CD
18637	24818	82	,	,	,
18637	24818	83	1143	1143	CD
18637	24818	84	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24818	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	86	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	87	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	88	Bruffy	Bruffy	NNP
18637	24818	89	,	,	,
18637	24818	90	96	96	CD
18637	24818	91	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	92	176	176	CD
18637	24818	93	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	94	1878	1878	CD
18637	24818	95	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	96	,	,	,
18637	24818	97	325	325	CD
18637	24818	98	,	,	,
18637	24818	99	691	691	CD
18637	24818	100	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24818	101	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	102	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	103	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	104	Bruffy	Bruffy	NNP
18637	24818	105	,	,	,
18637	24818	106	102	102	CD
18637	24818	107	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	108	248	248	CD
18637	24818	109	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	110	1880	1880	CD
18637	24818	111	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	112	,	,	,
18637	24818	113	555	555	CD
18637	24818	114	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24818	115	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	116	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	117	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	118	Fears	Fears	NNP
18637	24818	119	,	,	,
18637	24818	120	179	179	CD
18637	24818	121	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	122	270	270	CD
18637	24818	123	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	124	1900	1900	CD
18637	24818	125	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	126	,	,	,
18637	24818	127	120	120	CD
18637	24818	128	,	,	,
18637	24818	129	693	693	CD
18637	24818	130	,	,	,
18637	24818	131	967	967	CD
18637	24818	132	,	,	,
18637	24818	133	971	971	CD
18637	24818	134	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24818	135	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	136	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	137	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	138	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
18637	24818	139	,	,	,
18637	24818	140	239	239	CD
18637	24818	141	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	142	414	414	CD
18637	24818	143	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	144	1915	1915	CD
18637	24818	145	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	146	,	,	,
18637	24818	147	864	864	CD
18637	24818	148	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24818	149	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	150	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	151	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	152	Kaiser	Kaiser	NNP
18637	24818	153	,	,	,
18637	24818	154	323	323	CD
18637	24818	155	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	156	471	471	CD
18637	24818	157	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	158	1945	1945	CD
18637	24818	159	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	160	,	,	,
18637	24818	161	1100	1100	CD
18637	24818	162	,	,	,
18637	24818	163	1101	1101	CD
18637	24818	164	,	,	,
18637	24818	165	1102	1102	CD
18637	24818	166	,	,	,
18637	24818	167	1103	1103	CD
18637	24818	168	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24818	169	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	170	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	171	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	172	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	24818	173	,	,	,
18637	24818	174	170	170	CD
18637	24818	175	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	176	213	213	CD
18637	24818	177	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	178	1898	1898	CD
18637	24818	179	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	180	,	,	,
18637	24818	181	1164	1164	CD
18637	24818	182	,	,	,
18637	24818	183	1186	1186	CD
18637	24818	184	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24818	185	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	186	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	187	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	188	New	New	NNP
18637	24818	189	York	York	NNP
18637	24818	190	,	,	,
18637	24818	191	337	337	CD
18637	24818	192	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	193	241	241	CD
18637	24818	194	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	195	1949	1949	CD
18637	24818	196	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	197	,	,	,
18637	24818	198	1128	1128	CD
18637	24818	199	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24818	200	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	201	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	202	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	203	North	North	NNP
18637	24818	204	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24818	205	,	,	,
18637	24818	206	317	317	CD
18637	24818	207	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	208	287	287	CD
18637	24818	209	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	210	1942	1942	CD
18637	24818	211	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	212	,	,	,
18637	24818	213	663	663	CD
18637	24818	214	,	,	,
18637	24818	215	665	665	CD
18637	24818	216	,	,	,
18637	24818	217	1133	1133	CD
18637	24818	218	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24818	219	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	220	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	221	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	222	North	North	NNP
18637	24818	223	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24818	224	,	,	,
18637	24818	225	325	325	CD
18637	24818	226	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	227	226	226	CD
18637	24818	228	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	229	1945	1945	CD
18637	24818	230	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	231	,	,	,
18637	24818	232	663	663	CD
18637	24818	233	,	,	,
18637	24818	234	665	665	CD
18637	24818	235	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24818	236	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	237	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	238	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	239	Riley	Riley	NNP
18637	24818	240	,	,	,
18637	24818	241	280	280	CD
18637	24818	242	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	243	78	78	CD
18637	24818	244	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	245	1929	1929	CD
18637	24818	246	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	247	,	,	,
18637	24818	248	542	542	CD
18637	24818	249	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24818	250	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	251	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	252	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	253	Standard	Standard	NNP
18637	24818	254	Oil	Oil	NNP
18637	24818	255	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24818	256	,	,	,
18637	24818	257	278	278	CD
18637	24818	258	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24818	259	235	235	CD
18637	24818	260	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24818	261	1929	1929	CD
18637	24818	262	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24818	263	,	,	,
18637	24818	264	996	996	CD
18637	24818	265	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24818	266	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	267	v.	v.	IN
18637	24818	268	_	_	NNP
18637	24818	269	Suffolk	Suffolk	NNP
18637	24818	270	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	24818	271	Company	Company	NNP
18637	24818	272	,	,	,
18637	24818	273	13	13	CD
18637	24818	274	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24818	275	.	.	.
18637	24819	1	415	415	CD
18637	24819	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24819	3	1839	1839	CD
18637	24819	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24819	5	,	,	,
18637	24819	6	472	472	CD
18637	24819	7	,	,	,
18637	24819	8	473	473	CD
18637	24819	9	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24819	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24819	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24819	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24819	13	United	United	NNP
18637	24819	14	States	States	NNP
18637	24819	15	,	,	,
18637	24819	16	1	1	CD
18637	24819	17	How	how	WRB
18637	24819	18	.	.	.
18637	24820	1	290	290	CD
18637	24820	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24820	3	1843	1843	CD
18637	24820	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24820	5	,	,	,
18637	24820	6	477	477	CD
18637	24820	7	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24820	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24820	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24820	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24820	11	United	United	NNP
18637	24820	12	States	States	NNP
18637	24820	13	,	,	,
18637	24820	14	255	255	CD
18637	24820	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24820	16	336	336	CD
18637	24820	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24820	18	1921	1921	CD
18637	24820	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24820	20	,	,	,
18637	24820	21	322	322	CD
18637	24820	22	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24820	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24820	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24820	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24820	26	United	United	NNP
18637	24820	27	States	States	NNP
18637	24820	28	,	,	,
18637	24820	29	289	289	CD
18637	24820	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24820	31	553	553	CD
18637	24820	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24820	33	1933	1933	CD
18637	24820	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24820	35	,	,	,
18637	24820	36	512	512	CD
18637	24820	37	,	,	,
18637	24820	38	531	531	CD
18637	24820	39	,	,	,
18637	24820	40	534	534	CD
18637	24820	41	,	,	,
18637	24820	42	535	535	CD
18637	24820	43	Williams	Williams	NNP
18637	24820	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24820	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24820	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24820	47	United	United	NNP
18637	24820	48	States	States	NNP
18637	24820	49	,	,	,
18637	24820	50	341	341	CD
18637	24820	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24820	52	97	97	CD
18637	24820	53	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24820	54	1951	1951	CD
18637	24820	55	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24820	56	,	,	,
18637	24820	57	883	883	CD
18637	24820	58	,	,	,
18637	24820	59	1176	1176	CD
18637	24820	60	Williamson	Williamson	NNP
18637	24820	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24820	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	24820	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24820	64	Berry	Berry	NNP
18637	24820	65	,	,	,
18637	24820	66	8	8	CD
18637	24820	67	How	how	WRB
18637	24820	68	.	.	.
18637	24821	1	495	495	CD
18637	24821	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24821	3	1850	1850	CD
18637	24821	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24821	5	,	,	,
18637	24821	6	604	604	CD
18637	24821	7	,	,	,
18637	24821	8	605	605	CD
18637	24821	9	Williamson	Williamson	NNP
18637	24821	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24821	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24821	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24821	13	Osenton	Osenton	NNP
18637	24821	14	,	,	,
18637	24821	15	232	232	CD
18637	24821	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24821	17	619	619	CD
18637	24821	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24821	19	1914	1914	CD
18637	24821	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24821	21	,	,	,
18637	24821	22	601	601	CD
18637	24821	23	Williamson	Williamson	NNP
18637	24821	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24821	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24821	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24821	27	United	United	NNP
18637	24821	28	States	States	NNP
18637	24821	29	207	207	CD
18637	24821	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24821	31	425	425	CD
18637	24821	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24821	33	1908	1908	CD
18637	24821	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24821	35	,	,	,
18637	24821	36	99	99	CD
18637	24821	37	Willing	Willing	NNP
18637	24821	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24821	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	24821	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24821	41	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	24821	42	Auditorium	Auditorium	NNP
18637	24821	43	Association	Association	NNP
18637	24821	44	,	,	,
18637	24821	45	277	277	CD
18637	24821	46	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24821	47	274	274	CD
18637	24821	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24821	49	1928	1928	CD
18637	24821	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24821	51	,	,	,
18637	24821	52	551	551	CD
18637	24821	53	Willson	Willson	NNP
18637	24821	54	_	_	NNP
18637	24821	55	v.	v.	IN
18637	24821	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24821	57	Blackbird	Blackbird	NNP
18637	24821	58	Creek	Creek	NNP
18637	24821	59	Marsh	Marsh	NNP
18637	24821	60	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24821	61	,	,	,
18637	24821	62	2	2	CD
18637	24821	63	Pet	pet	NN
18637	24821	64	.	.	.
18637	24822	1	245	245	CD
18637	24822	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24822	3	1829	1829	CD
18637	24822	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24822	5	,	,	,
18637	24822	6	217	217	CD
18637	24822	7	,	,	,
18637	24822	8	229	229	CD
18637	24822	9	,	,	,
18637	24822	10	230	230	CD
18637	24822	11	Wilmette	Wilmette	NNP
18637	24822	12	Park	Park	NNP
18637	24822	13	District	District	NNP
18637	24822	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24822	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24822	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24822	17	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
18637	24822	18	,	,	,
18637	24822	19	338	338	CD
18637	24822	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24822	21	411	411	CD
18637	24822	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24822	23	1949	1949	CD
18637	24822	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24822	25	,	,	,
18637	24822	26	107	107	CD
18637	24822	27	,	,	,
18637	24822	28	109	109	CD
18637	24822	29	Wilmington	Wilmington	NNP
18637	24822	30	&	&	CC
18637	24822	31	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	24822	32	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24822	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24822	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24822	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24822	36	King	King	NNP
18637	24822	37	,	,	,
18637	24822	38	91	91	CD
18637	24822	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24822	40	3	3	CD
18637	24822	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24822	42	1875	1875	CD
18637	24822	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24822	44	,	,	,
18637	24822	45	356	356	CD
18637	24822	46	Wilmington	Wilmington	NNP
18637	24822	47	Star	Star	NNP
18637	24822	48	Min	Min	NNP
18637	24822	49	.	.	.
18637	24823	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24823	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24823	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24823	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24823	5	Fulton	Fulton	NNP
18637	24823	6	,	,	,
18637	24823	7	205	205	CD
18637	24823	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24823	9	60	60	CD
18637	24823	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24823	11	1907	1907	CD
18637	24823	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24823	13	,	,	,
18637	24823	14	971	971	CD
18637	24823	15	,	,	,
18637	24823	16	987	987	CD
18637	24823	17	Wilmington	Wilmington	NNP
18637	24823	18	Transp	Transp	NNP
18637	24823	19	.	.	.
18637	24824	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24824	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24824	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24824	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24824	5	R.R.	R.R.	NNP
18637	24825	1	Com	Com	NNP
18637	24825	2	.	.	NNP
18637	24825	3	,	,	,
18637	24825	4	236	236	CD
18637	24825	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24825	6	151	151	CD
18637	24825	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24825	8	1915	1915	CD
18637	24825	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24825	10	,	,	,
18637	24825	11	231	231	CD
18637	24825	12	Wiloil	Wiloil	NNP
18637	24825	13	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
18637	24825	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24825	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24825	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24825	17	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
18637	24825	18	,	,	,
18637	24825	19	294	294	CD
18637	24825	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24825	21	169	169	CD
18637	24825	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24825	23	1935	1935	CD
18637	24825	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24825	25	,	,	,
18637	24825	26	189	189	CD
18637	24825	27	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24825	28	,	,	,
18637	24825	29	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24825	30	Parte	Parte	NNP
18637	24825	31	,	,	,
18637	24825	32	114	114	CD
18637	24825	33	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24825	34	417	417	CD
18637	24825	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24825	36	1885	1885	CD
18637	24825	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24825	38	,	,	,
18637	24825	39	838	838	CD
18637	24825	40	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24825	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24825	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24825	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24825	44	Cook	Cook	NNP
18637	24825	45	,	,	,
18637	24825	46	327	327	CD
18637	24825	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24825	48	474	474	CD
18637	24825	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24825	50	1946	1946	CD
18637	24825	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24825	52	,	,	,
18637	24825	53	699	699	CD
18637	24825	54	,	,	,
18637	24825	55	703	703	CD
18637	24825	56	,	,	,
18637	24825	57	731	731	CD
18637	24825	58	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24825	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24825	60	v.	v.	IN
18637	24825	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24825	62	Eureka	Eureka	NNP
18637	24825	63	City	City	NNP
18637	24825	64	,	,	,
18637	24825	65	173	173	CD
18637	24825	66	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24825	67	32	32	CD
18637	24825	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24825	69	1899	1899	CD
18637	24825	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24825	71	,	,	,
18637	24825	72	1157	1157	CD
18637	24825	73	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24825	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24825	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	24825	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24825	77	Gaines	Gaines	NNP
18637	24825	78	,	,	,
18637	24825	79	103	103	CD
18637	24825	80	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24825	81	417	417	CD
18637	24825	82	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24825	83	1881	1881	CD
18637	24825	84	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24825	85	,	,	,
18637	24825	86	347	347	CD
18637	24825	87	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24825	88	_	_	NNP
18637	24825	89	v.	v.	IN
18637	24825	90	_	_	NNP
18637	24825	91	New	New	NNP
18637	24825	92	,	,	,
18637	24825	93	243	243	CD
18637	24825	94	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24825	95	332	332	CD
18637	24825	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24825	97	1917	1917	CD
18637	24825	98	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24825	99	,	,	,
18637	24825	100	142	142	CD
18637	24825	101	,	,	,
18637	24825	102	855	855	CD
18637	24825	103	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24825	104	_	_	NNP
18637	24825	105	v.	v.	IN
18637	24825	106	_	_	NNP
18637	24825	107	North	North	NNP
18637	24825	108	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	24825	109	ex	ex	NN
18637	24825	110	rel	rel	NN
18637	24825	111	.	.	.
18637	24826	1	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	24826	2	,	,	,
18637	24826	3	169	169	CD
18637	24826	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24826	5	586	586	CD
18637	24826	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24826	7	1898	1898	CD
18637	24826	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24826	9	,	,	,
18637	24826	10	1096	1096	CD
18637	24826	11	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24826	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24826	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24826	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24826	15	Seligman	Seligman	NNP
18637	24826	16	,	,	,
18637	24826	17	144	144	CD
18637	24826	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24826	19	41	41	CD
18637	24826	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24826	21	1892	1892	CD
18637	24826	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24826	23	,	,	,
18637	24826	24	1074	1074	CD
18637	24826	25	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24826	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24826	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24826	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24826	29	Standefer	Standefer	NNP
18637	24826	30	,	,	,
18637	24826	31	184	184	CD
18637	24826	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24826	33	399	399	CD
18637	24826	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24826	35	1902	1902	CD
18637	24826	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24826	37	,	,	,
18637	24826	38	355	355	CD
18637	24826	39	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24826	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24826	41	v.	v.	IN
18637	24826	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24826	43	United	United	NNP
18637	24826	44	States	States	NNP
18637	24826	45	,	,	,
18637	24826	46	162	162	CD
18637	24826	47	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24826	48	613	613	CD
18637	24826	49	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24826	50	1896	1896	CD
18637	24826	51	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24826	52	,	,	,
18637	24826	53	843	843	CD
18637	24826	54	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	24826	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24826	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	24826	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24826	58	United	United	NNP
18637	24826	59	States	States	NNP
18637	24826	60	,	,	,
18637	24826	61	221	221	CD
18637	24826	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24826	63	361	361	CD
18637	24826	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24826	65	1911	1911	CD
18637	24826	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24826	67	,	,	,
18637	24826	68	827	827	CD
18637	24826	69	,	,	,
18637	24826	70	844	844	CD
18637	24826	71	,	,	,
18637	24826	72	884	884	CD
18637	24826	73	Winnebago	Winnebago	NNP
18637	24826	74	,	,	,
18637	24826	75	The	the	DT
18637	24826	76	,	,	,
18637	24826	77	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24826	78	Iroquois	Iroquois	NNP
18637	24826	79	Transp	Transp	NNP
18637	24826	80	.	.	.
18637	24827	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24827	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24827	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24827	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24827	5	Delaney	Delaney	NNP
18637	24827	6	Forge	Forge	NNP
18637	24827	7	&	&	CC
18637	24827	8	Iron	Iron	NNP
18637	24827	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24827	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24827	11	205	205	CD
18637	24827	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24827	13	354	354	CD
18637	24827	14	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24827	15	1907	1907	CD
18637	24827	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24827	17	,	,	,
18637	24827	18	235	235	CD
18637	24827	19	Winona	Winona	NNP
18637	24827	20	&	&	CC
18637	24827	21	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24827	22	P.	P.	NNP
18637	24827	23	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24827	24	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24827	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24827	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24827	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24827	28	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24827	29	,	,	,
18637	24827	30	159	159	CD
18637	24827	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24827	32	526	526	CD
18637	24827	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24827	34	1895	1895	CD
18637	24827	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24827	36	,	,	,
18637	24827	37	1060	1060	CD
18637	24827	38	Winona	Winona	NNP
18637	24827	39	&	&	CC
18637	24827	40	St.	St.	NNP
18637	24827	41	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24828	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24828	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24828	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24828	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24828	5	Blake	Blake	NNP
18637	24828	6	,	,	,
18637	24828	7	94	94	CD
18637	24828	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24828	9	180	180	CD
18637	24828	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24828	11	1877	1877	CD
18637	24828	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24828	13	,	,	,
18637	24828	14	1143	1143	CD
18637	24828	15	Winters	Winters	NNP
18637	24828	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24828	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24828	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24828	19	New	New	NNP
18637	24828	20	York	York	NNP
18637	24828	21	,	,	,
18637	24828	22	333	333	CD
18637	24828	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24828	24	507	507	CD
18637	24828	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24828	26	1948	1948	CD
18637	24828	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24828	28	,	,	,
18637	24828	29	779	779	CD
18637	24828	30	,	,	,
18637	24828	31	1097	1097	CD
18637	24828	32	Winton	Winton	NNP
18637	24828	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24828	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	24828	35	_	_	NNP
18637	24828	36	Amos	Amos	NNP
18637	24828	37	,	,	,
18637	24828	38	255	255	CD
18637	24828	39	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24828	40	373	373	CD
18637	24828	41	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24828	42	1921	1921	CD
18637	24828	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24828	44	,	,	,
18637	24828	45	864	864	CD
18637	24828	46	Wiscart	Wiscart	NNP
18637	24828	47	_	_	NNP
18637	24828	48	v.	v.	IN
18637	24828	49	_	_	NNP
18637	24828	50	Dauchy	Dauchy	NNP
18637	24828	51	,	,	,
18637	24828	52	3	3	CD
18637	24828	53	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	24828	54	.	.	.
18637	24829	1	321	321	CD
18637	24829	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24829	3	1796	1796	CD
18637	24829	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24829	5	,	,	,
18637	24829	6	522	522	CD
18637	24829	7	,	,	,
18637	24829	8	560	560	CD
18637	24829	9	,	,	,
18637	24829	10	612	612	CD
18637	24829	11	,	,	,
18637	24829	12	614	614	CD
18637	24829	13	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	24829	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24829	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24829	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24829	17	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
18637	24829	18	,	,	,
18637	24829	19	278	278	CD
18637	24829	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24829	21	367	367	CD
18637	24829	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24829	23	1929	1929	CD
18637	24829	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24829	25	,	,	,
18637	24829	26	128	128	CD
18637	24829	27	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	24829	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24829	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24829	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24829	31	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
18637	24829	32	Mining	Mining	NNP
18637	24829	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24829	34	,	,	,
18637	24829	35	311	311	CD
18637	24829	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24829	37	452	452	CD
18637	24829	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24829	39	1940	1940	CD
18637	24829	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24829	41	,	,	,
18637	24829	42	1055	1055	CD
18637	24829	43	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	24829	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24829	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24829	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24829	47	Pelican	Pelican	NNP
18637	24829	48	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	24829	49	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24829	50	,	,	,
18637	24829	51	127	127	CD
18637	24829	52	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24829	53	265	265	CD
18637	24829	54	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24829	55	1888	1888	CD
18637	24829	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24829	57	,	,	,
18637	24829	58	596	596	CD
18637	24829	59	,	,	,
18637	24829	60	597	597	CD
18637	24829	61	,	,	,
18637	24829	62	613	613	CD
18637	24829	63	,	,	,
18637	24829	64	654	654	CD
18637	24829	65	,	,	,
18637	24829	66	658	658	CD
18637	24829	67	,	,	,
18637	24829	68	674	674	CD
18637	24829	69	,	,	,
18637	24829	70	675	675	CD
18637	24829	71	,	,	,
18637	24829	72	684	684	CD
18637	24829	73	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	24829	74	_	_	NNP
18637	24829	75	v.	v.	IN
18637	24829	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24829	77	Penney	Penney	NNP
18637	24829	78	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24829	79	J.C.	J.C.	NNP
18637	24829	80	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24829	81	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24829	82	,	,	,
18637	24829	83	311	311	CD
18637	24829	84	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24829	85	435	435	CD
18637	24829	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24829	87	1940	1940	CD
18637	24829	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24829	89	,	,	,
18637	24829	90	1054	1054	CD
18637	24829	91	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	24829	92	&	&	CC
18637	24829	93	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
18637	24829	94	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	24829	95	.	.	.
18637	24830	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24830	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24830	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24830	4	Powers	Powers	NNP
18637	24830	5	,	,	,
18637	24830	6	191	191	CD
18637	24830	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24830	8	379	379	CD
18637	24830	9	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24830	10	1903	1903	CD
18637	24830	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24830	12	,	,	,
18637	24830	13	204	204	CD
18637	24830	14	,	,	,
18637	24830	15	342	342	CD
18637	24830	16	,	,	,
18637	24830	17	343	343	CD
18637	24830	18	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	24830	19	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24830	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24830	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24830	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	24830	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24830	24	United	United	NNP
18637	24830	25	States	States	NNP
18637	24830	26	,	,	,
18637	24830	27	322	322	CD
18637	24830	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24830	29	526	526	CD
18637	24830	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24830	31	1944	1944	CD
18637	24830	32	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24830	33	,	,	,
18637	24830	34	1044	1044	CD
18637	24830	35	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	24830	36	,	,	,
18637	24830	37	M.	M.	NNP
18637	24830	38	&	&	CC
18637	24830	39	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	24831	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24831	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24831	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24831	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24831	5	Jacobson	Jacobson	NNP
18637	24831	6	,	,	,
18637	24831	7	179	179	CD
18637	24831	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24831	9	287	287	CD
18637	24831	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24831	11	1900	1900	CD
18637	24831	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24831	13	,	,	,
18637	24831	14	222	222	CD
18637	24831	15	,	,	,
18637	24831	16	1012	1012	CD
18637	24831	17	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
18637	24831	18	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
18637	24831	19	Com	Com	NNP
18637	24831	20	.	.	.
18637	24832	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24832	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	24832	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24832	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	24832	5	,	,	,
18637	24832	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	24833	1	&	&	CC
18637	24833	2	Q.R.R.	Q.R.R.	NNP
18637	24834	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24834	2	,	,	,
18637	24834	3	257	257	CD
18637	24834	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24834	5	563	563	CD
18637	24834	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24834	7	1922	1922	CD
18637	24834	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24834	9	,	,	,
18637	24834	10	136	136	CD
18637	24834	11	,	,	,
18637	24834	12	220	220	CD
18637	24834	13	Wissner	Wissner	NNP
18637	24834	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24834	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24834	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24834	17	Wissner	Wissner	NNP
18637	24834	18	,	,	,
18637	24834	19	338	338	CD
18637	24834	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24834	21	655	655	CD
18637	24834	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24834	23	1950	1950	CD
18637	24834	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24834	25	,	,	,
18637	24834	26	285	285	CD
18637	24834	27	Withers	Withers	NNP
18637	24834	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24834	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24834	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24834	31	Buckley	Buckley	NNP
18637	24834	32	,	,	,
18637	24834	33	20	20	CD
18637	24834	34	How	how	WRB
18637	24834	35	.	.	.
18637	24835	1	84	84	CD
18637	24835	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24835	3	1858	1858	CD
18637	24835	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24835	5	,	,	,
18637	24835	6	699	699	CD
18637	24835	7	,	,	,
18637	24835	8	751	751	CD
18637	24835	9	Withnell	Withnell	NNP
18637	24835	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24835	11	v.	v.	IN
18637	24835	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24835	13	Ruecking	Ruecking	NNP
18637	24835	14	Constr	Constr	NNP
18637	24835	15	.	.	.
18637	24836	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24836	2	,	,	,
18637	24836	3	249	249	CD
18637	24836	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24836	5	63	63	CD
18637	24836	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24836	7	1919	1919	CD
18637	24836	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24836	9	,	,	,
18637	24836	10	1059	1059	CD
18637	24836	11	Wolf	Wolf	NNP
18637	24836	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24836	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	15	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
18637	24836	16	,	,	,
18637	24836	17	338	338	CD
18637	24836	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24836	19	25	25	CD
18637	24836	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24836	21	1949	1949	CD
18637	24836	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24836	23	,	,	,
18637	24836	24	830	830	CD
18637	24836	25	,	,	,
18637	24836	26	831	831	CD
18637	24836	27	,	,	,
18637	24836	28	1122	1122	CD
18637	24836	29	,	,	,
18637	24836	30	1123	1123	CD
18637	24836	31	Wolff	Wolff	NNP
18637	24836	32	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	24836	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24836	34	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	35	v.	v.	IN
18637	24836	36	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	37	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	24836	38	Court	Court	NNP
18637	24836	39	,	,	,
18637	24836	40	262	262	CD
18637	24836	41	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24836	42	522	522	CD
18637	24836	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24836	44	1923	1923	CD
18637	24836	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24836	46	,	,	,
18637	24836	47	992	992	CD
18637	24836	48	,	,	,
18637	24836	49	996	996	CD
18637	24836	50	Wolff	Wolff	NNP
18637	24836	51	Packing	Packing	NNP
18637	24836	52	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24836	53	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	54	v.	v.	IN
18637	24836	55	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	56	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	24836	57	Court	Court	NNP
18637	24836	58	,	,	,
18637	24836	59	267	267	CD
18637	24836	60	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24836	61	552	552	CD
18637	24836	62	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24836	63	1925	1925	CD
18637	24836	64	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24836	65	,	,	,
18637	24836	66	986	986	CD
18637	24836	67	Wolsey	Wolsey	NNP
18637	24836	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	69	v.	v.	IN
18637	24836	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	71	Chapman	Chapman	NNP
18637	24836	72	,	,	,
18637	24836	73	101	101	CD
18637	24836	74	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24836	75	755	755	CD
18637	24836	76	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24836	77	1880	1880	CD
18637	24836	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24836	79	,	,	,
18637	24836	80	477	477	CD
18637	24836	81	Wong	Wong	NNP
18637	24836	82	Doo	Doo	NNP
18637	24836	83	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	84	v.	v.	IN
18637	24836	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	86	United	United	NNP
18637	24836	87	States	States	NNP
18637	24836	88	,	,	,
18637	24836	89	265	265	CD
18637	24836	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24836	91	239	239	CD
18637	24836	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24836	93	1924	1924	CD
18637	24836	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24836	95	,	,	,
18637	24836	96	315	315	CD
18637	24836	97	Wong	Wong	NNP
18637	24836	98	Yang	Yang	NNP
18637	24836	99	Sung	Sung	NNP
18637	24836	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	101	v.	v.	IN
18637	24836	102	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	103	McGrath	McGrath	NNP
18637	24836	104	,	,	,
18637	24836	105	339	339	CD
18637	24836	106	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24836	107	33	33	CD
18637	24836	108	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24836	109	1950	1950	CD
18637	24836	110	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24836	111	,	,	,
18637	24836	112	850	850	CD
18637	24836	113	,	,	,
18637	24836	114	852	852	CD
18637	24836	115	Wong	Wong	NNP
18637	24836	116	Wing	Wing	NNP
18637	24836	117	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	118	v.	v.	IN
18637	24836	119	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	120	United	United	NNP
18637	24836	121	States	States	NNP
18637	24836	122	,	,	,
18637	24836	123	163	163	CD
18637	24836	124	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24836	125	228	228	CD
18637	24836	126	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24836	127	1896	1896	CD
18637	24836	128	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24836	129	,	,	,
18637	24836	130	838	838	CD
18637	24836	131	,	,	,
18637	24836	132	846	846	CD
18637	24836	133	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	24836	134	&	&	CC
18637	24836	135	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
18637	24836	136	,	,	,
18637	24836	137	In	in	IN
18637	24836	138	re	re	NN
18637	24836	139	,	,	,
18637	24836	140	210	210	CD
18637	24836	141	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24836	142	246	246	CD
18637	24836	143	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24836	144	1908	1908	CD
18637	24836	145	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24836	146	,	,	,
18637	24836	147	893	893	CD
18637	24836	148	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	24836	149	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	150	v.	v.	IN
18637	24836	151	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	152	Broom	Broom	NNP
18637	24836	153	,	,	,
18637	24836	154	287	287	CD
18637	24836	155	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24836	156	1	1	CD
18637	24836	157	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24836	158	1932	1932	CD
18637	24836	159	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24836	160	,	,	,
18637	24836	161	94	94	CD
18637	24836	162	,	,	,
18637	24836	163	548	548	CD
18637	24836	164	Wood	Wood	NNP
18637	24836	165	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	166	v.	v.	IN
18637	24836	167	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	168	Lovett	Lovett	NNP
18637	24836	169	,	,	,
18637	24836	170	313	313	CD
18637	24836	171	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24836	172	362	362	CD
18637	24836	173	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24836	174	1941	1941	CD
18637	24836	175	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24836	176	,	,	,
18637	24836	177	332	332	CD
18637	24836	178	,	,	,
18637	24836	179	333	333	CD
18637	24836	180	Woodruff	Woodruff	NNP
18637	24836	181	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	182	v.	v.	IN
18637	24836	183	_	_	NNP
18637	24836	184	Parham	Parham	NNP
18637	24836	185	,	,	,
18637	24836	186	8	8	CD
18637	24836	187	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24836	188	.	.	.
18637	24837	1	123	123	CD
18637	24837	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24837	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24837	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24837	5	,	,	,
18637	24837	6	182	182	CD
18637	24837	7	,	,	,
18637	24837	8	183	183	CD
18637	24837	9	,	,	,
18637	24837	10	239	239	CD
18637	24837	11	,	,	,
18637	24837	12	363	363	CD
18637	24837	13	Woodruff	Woodruff	NNP
18637	24837	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24837	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	24837	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24837	17	Trapnall	Trapnall	NNP
18637	24837	18	,	,	,
18637	24837	19	10	10	CD
18637	24837	20	How	how	WRB
18637	24837	21	.	.	.
18637	24838	1	190	190	CD
18637	24838	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24838	3	1851	1851	CD
18637	24838	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24838	5	,	,	,
18637	24838	6	326	326	CD
18637	24838	7	Woods	Woods	NNP
18637	24838	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24838	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24838	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24838	11	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	24838	12	,	,	,
18637	24838	13	333	333	CD
18637	24838	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24838	15	138	138	CD
18637	24838	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24838	17	1948	1948	CD
18637	24838	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24838	19	,	,	,
18637	24838	20	293	293	CD
18637	24838	21	,	,	,
18637	24838	22	475	475	CD
18637	24838	23	,	,	,
18637	24838	24	859	859	CD
18637	24838	25	Woods	Woods	NNPS
18637	24838	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24838	27	v.	v.	IN
18637	24838	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24838	29	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	24838	30	,	,	,
18637	24838	31	333	333	CD
18637	24838	32	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24838	33	472	472	CD
18637	24838	34	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24838	35	1948	1948	CD
18637	24838	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24838	37	,	,	,
18637	24838	38	856	856	CD
18637	24838	39	Woods	Woods	NNP
18637	24838	40	&	&	CC
18637	24838	41	Sons	Sons	NNPS
18637	24838	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24838	43	v.	v.	IN
18637	24838	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24838	45	Carl	Carl	NNP
18637	24838	46	,	,	,
18637	24838	47	203	203	CD
18637	24838	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24838	49	358	358	CD
18637	24838	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24838	51	1906	1906	CD
18637	24838	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24838	53	,	,	,
18637	24838	54	276	276	CD
18637	24838	55	Woodson	Woodson	NNP
18637	24838	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24838	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24838	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24838	59	Deutsche	Deutsche	NNP
18637	24838	60	G.	G.	NNP
18637	24838	61	&	&	CC
18637	24838	62	S.S.V.	S.S.V.	NNP
18637	24839	1	Roessler	Roessler	NNP
18637	24839	2	,	,	,
18637	24839	3	292	292	CD
18637	24839	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24839	5	449	449	CD
18637	24839	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24839	7	1934	1934	CD
18637	24839	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24839	9	,	,	,
18637	24839	10	865	865	CD
18637	24839	11	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
18637	24839	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24839	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24839	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24839	15	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	24839	16	,	,	,
18637	24839	17	6	6	CD
18637	24839	18	Pet	Pet	NNP
18637	24839	19	.	.	.
18637	24840	1	515	515	CD
18637	24840	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24840	3	1832	1832	CD
18637	24840	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24840	5	,	,	,
18637	24840	6	431	431	CD
18637	24840	7	,	,	,
18637	24840	8	625	625	CD
18637	24840	9	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
18637	24840	10	County	County	NNP
18637	24840	11	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24840	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24840	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24840	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24840	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24840	16	Riley	Riley	NNP
18637	24840	17	,	,	,
18637	24840	18	302	302	CD
18637	24840	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24840	20	292	292	CD
18637	24840	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24840	22	1937	1937	CD
18637	24840	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24840	24	,	,	,
18637	24840	25	934	934	CD
18637	24840	26	Worthen	Worthen	NNP
18637	24840	27	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24840	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24840	29	v.	v.	IN
18637	24840	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24840	31	Kavanaugh	Kavanaugh	NNP
18637	24840	32	,	,	,
18637	24840	33	295	295	CD
18637	24840	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24840	35	56	56	CD
18637	24840	36	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24840	37	1935	1935	CD
18637	24840	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24840	39	,	,	,
18637	24840	40	361	361	CD
18637	24840	41	Worthen	Worthen	NNP
18637	24840	42	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24840	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24840	44	v.	v.	IN
18637	24840	45	_	_	NNP
18637	24840	46	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
18637	24840	47	,	,	,
18637	24840	48	292	292	CD
18637	24840	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24840	50	426	426	CD
18637	24840	51	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24840	52	1934	1934	CD
18637	24840	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24840	54	,	,	,
18637	24840	55	361	361	CD
18637	24840	56	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	24840	57	_	_	NNP
18637	24840	58	v.	v.	IN
18637	24840	59	_	_	NNP
18637	24840	60	Davidson	Davidson	NNP
18637	24840	61	,	,	,
18637	24840	62	181	181	CD
18637	24840	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24840	64	371	371	CD
18637	24840	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24840	66	1901	1901	CD
18637	24840	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24840	68	,	,	,
18637	24840	69	848	848	CD
18637	24840	70	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	24840	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24840	72	v.	v.	IN
18637	24840	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24840	74	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
18637	24840	75	R.	R.	NNP
18637	24840	76	&	&	CC
18637	24840	77	Bkg	Bkg	NNP
18637	24840	78	.	.	.
18637	24841	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24841	2	,	,	,
18637	24841	3	216	216	CD
18637	24841	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24841	5	420	420	CD
18637	24841	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24841	7	1910	1910	CD
18637	24841	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24841	9	,	,	,
18637	24841	10	347	347	CD
18637	24841	11	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	24841	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	13	v.	v.	IN
18637	24841	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	15	Mountain	Mountain	NNP
18637	24841	16	Trust	Trust	NNP
18637	24841	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24841	18	,	,	,
18637	24841	19	300	300	CD
18637	24841	20	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24841	21	440	440	CD
18637	24841	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24841	23	1937	1937	CD
18637	24841	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24841	25	,	,	,
18637	24841	26	263	263	CD
18637	24841	27	,	,	,
18637	24841	28	858	858	CD
18637	24841	29	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	24841	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	31	v.	v.	IN
18637	24841	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	33	Nagle	Nagle	NNP
18637	24841	34	,	,	,
18637	24841	35	101	101	CD
18637	24841	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24841	37	791	791	CD
18637	24841	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24841	39	1880	1880	CD
18637	24841	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24841	41	,	,	,
18637	24841	42	330	330	CD
18637	24841	43	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	24841	44	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	24841	46	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	47	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24841	48	Central	Central	NNP
18637	24841	49	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	24841	50	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24841	51	,	,	,
18637	24841	52	304	304	CD
18637	24841	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24841	54	502	502	CD
18637	24841	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24841	56	1938	1938	CD
18637	24841	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24841	58	,	,	,
18637	24841	59	263	263	CD
18637	24841	60	Wright	Wright	NNP
18637	24841	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	62	v.	v.	IN
18637	24841	63	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	64	United	United	NNP
18637	24841	65	States	States	NNP
18637	24841	66	,	,	,
18637	24841	67	302	302	CD
18637	24841	68	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24841	69	583	583	CD
18637	24841	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24841	71	1938	1938	CD
18637	24841	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24841	73	,	,	,
18637	24841	74	103	103	CD
18637	24841	75	Wuchter	Wuchter	NNP
18637	24841	76	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	77	v.	v.	IN
18637	24841	78	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	79	Pizzutti	Pizzutti	NNP
18637	24841	80	,	,	,
18637	24841	81	276	276	CD
18637	24841	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24841	83	13	13	CD
18637	24841	84	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24841	85	1928	1928	CD
18637	24841	86	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24841	87	,	,	,
18637	24841	88	661	661	CD
18637	24841	89	,	,	,
18637	24841	90	1074	1074	CD
18637	24841	91	,	,	,
18637	24841	92	1085	1085	CD
18637	24841	93	,	,	,
18637	24841	94	1088	1088	CD
18637	24841	95	Wyandotte	Wyandotte	NNP
18637	24841	96	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24841	97	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24841	98	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	99	v.	v.	IN
18637	24841	100	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	101	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
18637	24841	102	,	,	,
18637	24841	103	231	231	CD
18637	24841	104	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24841	105	622	622	CD
18637	24841	106	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24841	107	1914	1914	CD
18637	24841	108	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24841	109	,	,	,
18637	24841	110	349	349	CD
18637	24841	111	Y	Y	NNP
18637	24841	112	Yakus	Yakus	NNP
18637	24841	113	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	114	v.	v.	IN
18637	24841	115	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	116	United	United	NNP
18637	24841	117	States	States	NNP
18637	24841	118	,	,	,
18637	24841	119	321	321	CD
18637	24841	120	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24841	121	414	414	CD
18637	24841	122	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24841	123	1944	1944	CD
18637	24841	124	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24841	125	,	,	,
18637	24841	126	76	76	CD
18637	24841	127	,	,	,
18637	24841	128	289	289	CD
18637	24841	129	,	,	,
18637	24841	130	512	512	CD
18637	24841	131	,	,	,
18637	24841	132	525	525	CD
18637	24841	133	,	,	,
18637	24841	134	532	532	CD
18637	24841	135	,	,	,
18637	24841	136	620	620	CD
18637	24841	137	,	,	,
18637	24841	138	624	624	CD
18637	24841	139	,	,	,
18637	24841	140	893	893	CD
18637	24841	141	Yamashita	Yamashita	NNP
18637	24841	142	,	,	,
18637	24841	143	In	in	IN
18637	24841	144	re	re	NN
18637	24841	145	,	,	,
18637	24841	146	327	327	CD
18637	24841	147	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24841	148	1	1	CD
18637	24841	149	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24841	150	1946	1946	CD
18637	24841	151	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24841	152	,	,	,
18637	24841	153	317	317	CD
18637	24841	154	,	,	,
18637	24841	155	846	846	CD
18637	24841	156	,	,	,
18637	24841	157	851	851	CD
18637	24841	158	Yamataya	Yamataya	NNP
18637	24841	159	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	160	v.	v.	IN
18637	24841	161	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	162	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
18637	24841	163	,	,	,
18637	24841	164	189	189	CD
18637	24841	165	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24841	166	86	86	CD
18637	24841	167	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24841	168	1903	1903	CD
18637	24841	169	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24841	170	,	,	,
18637	24841	171	852	852	CD
18637	24841	172	Yarbrough	Yarbrough	NNP
18637	24841	173	,	,	,
18637	24841	174	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24841	175	parte	parte	NN
18637	24841	176	,	,	,
18637	24841	177	110	110	CD
18637	24841	178	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24841	179	651	651	CD
18637	24841	180	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24841	181	1884	1884	CD
18637	24841	182	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24841	183	,	,	,
18637	24841	184	87	87	CD
18637	24841	185	,	,	,
18637	24841	186	94	94	CD
18637	24841	187	,	,	,
18637	24841	188	309	309	CD
18637	24841	189	,	,	,
18637	24841	190	386	386	CD
18637	24841	191	,	,	,
18637	24841	192	967	967	CD
18637	24841	193	,	,	,
18637	24841	194	1172	1172	CD
18637	24841	195	,	,	,
18637	24841	196	1183	1183	CD
18637	24841	197	,	,	,
18637	24841	198	1208	1208	CD
18637	24841	199	Yarbrough	Yarbrough	NNP
18637	24841	200	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	201	v.	v.	IN
18637	24841	202	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	203	Yarbrough	Yarbrough	NNP
18637	24841	204	,	,	,
18637	24841	205	290	290	CD
18637	24841	206	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24841	207	202	202	CD
18637	24841	208	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24841	209	1933	1933	CD
18637	24841	210	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24841	211	,	,	,
18637	24841	212	671	671	CD
18637	24841	213	Yates	Yates	NNPS
18637	24841	214	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	215	v.	v.	IN
18637	24841	216	_	_	NNP
18637	24841	217	Milwaukee	Milwaukee	NNP
18637	24841	218	,	,	,
18637	24841	219	10	10	CD
18637	24841	220	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24841	221	.	.	.
18637	24842	1	497	497	CD
18637	24842	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24842	3	1870	1870	CD
18637	24842	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24842	5	,	,	,
18637	24842	6	604	604	CD
18637	24842	7	Yazoo	Yazoo	NNP
18637	24842	8	&	&	CC
18637	24842	9	M.V.R.	M.V.R.	NNP
18637	24843	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24843	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24843	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24843	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24843	5	Greenwood	Greenwood	NNP
18637	24843	6	Grocery	Grocery	NNP
18637	24843	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24843	8	,	,	,
18637	24843	9	227	227	CD
18637	24843	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24843	11	1	1	CD
18637	24843	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24843	13	1913	1913	CD
18637	24843	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24843	15	,	,	,
18637	24843	16	247	247	CD
18637	24843	17	Yazoo	Yazoo	NNP
18637	24843	18	&	&	CC
18637	24843	19	M.V.R.	M.V.R.	NNP
18637	24844	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24844	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24844	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24844	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24844	5	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
18637	24844	6	Vinegar	Vinegar	NNP
18637	24844	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24844	8	,	,	,
18637	24844	9	226	226	CD
18637	24844	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24844	11	217	217	CD
18637	24844	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24844	13	1912	1912	CD
18637	24844	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24844	15	,	,	,
18637	24844	16	1015	1015	CD
18637	24844	17	,	,	,
18637	24844	18	1092	1092	CD
18637	24844	19	Yeaton	Yeaton	NNP
18637	24844	20	_	_	NNP
18637	24844	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	24844	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24844	23	United	United	NNP
18637	24844	24	States	States	NNP
18637	24844	25	,	,	,
18637	24844	26	5	5	CD
18637	24844	27	Cr	cr	NN
18637	24844	28	.	.	.
18637	24845	1	281	281	CD
18637	24845	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24845	3	1809	1809	CD
18637	24845	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24845	5	,	,	,
18637	24845	6	1214	1214	CD
18637	24845	7	Yee	Yee	NNP
18637	24845	8	Hem	Hem	NNP
18637	24845	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24845	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24845	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24845	12	United	United	NNP
18637	24845	13	States	States	NNP
18637	24845	14	,	,	,
18637	24845	15	268	268	CD
18637	24845	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24845	17	178	178	CD
18637	24845	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24845	19	1925	1925	CD
18637	24845	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24845	21	,	,	,
18637	24845	22	849	849	CD
18637	24845	23	Yeiser	Yeiser	NNP
18637	24845	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24845	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	24845	26	_	_	NNP
18637	24845	27	Dysart	Dysart	NNP
18637	24845	28	,	,	,
18637	24845	29	267	267	CD
18637	24845	30	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24845	31	540	540	CD
18637	24845	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24845	33	1925	1925	CD
18637	24845	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24845	35	,	,	,
18637	24845	36	990	990	CD
18637	24845	37	Yerger	Yerger	NNP
18637	24845	38	,	,	,
18637	24845	39	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24845	40	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24845	41	,	,	,
18637	24845	42	8	8	CD
18637	24845	43	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	24845	44	.	.	.
18637	24846	1	85	85	CD
18637	24846	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24846	3	1869	1869	CD
18637	24846	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24846	5	,	,	,
18637	24846	6	523	523	CD
18637	24846	7	,	,	,
18637	24846	8	612	612	CD
18637	24846	9	,	,	,
18637	24846	10	619	619	CD
18637	24846	11	Yick	Yick	NNP
18637	24846	12	Wo	Wo	NNP
18637	24846	13	_	_	NNP
18637	24846	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	24846	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24846	16	Hopkins	Hopkins	NNP
18637	24846	17	,	,	,
18637	24846	18	118	118	CD
18637	24846	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24846	20	356	356	CD
18637	24846	21	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24846	22	1886	1886	CD
18637	24846	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24846	24	,	,	,
18637	24846	25	981	981	CD
18637	24846	26	,	,	,
18637	24846	27	1142	1142	CD
18637	24846	28	,	,	,
18637	24846	29	1143	1143	CD
18637	24846	30	,	,	,
18637	24846	31	1145	1145	CD
18637	24846	32	,	,	,
18637	24846	33	1157	1157	CD
18637	24846	34	,	,	,
18637	24846	35	1158	1158	CD
18637	24846	36	York	York	NNP
18637	24846	37	_	_	NNP
18637	24846	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	24846	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24846	40	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	24846	41	,	,	,
18637	24846	42	137	137	CD
18637	24846	43	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24846	44	15	15	CD
18637	24846	45	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24846	46	1890	1890	CD
18637	24846	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24846	48	,	,	,
18637	24846	49	1090	1090	CD
18637	24846	50	York	York	NNP
18637	24846	51	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
18637	24846	52	.	.	.
18637	24847	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24847	2	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	3	v.	v.	IN
18637	24847	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	5	Colley	Colley	NNP
18637	24847	6	,	,	,
18637	24847	7	247	247	CD
18637	24847	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24847	9	21	21	CD
18637	24847	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24847	11	1918	1918	CD
18637	24847	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24847	13	,	,	,
18637	24847	14	121	121	CD
18637	24847	15	Yost	Yost	NNP
18637	24847	16	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	24847	18	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	19	Dallas	Dallas	NNP
18637	24847	20	County	County	NNP
18637	24847	21	,	,	,
18637	24847	22	236	236	CD
18637	24847	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24847	24	50	50	CD
18637	24847	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24847	26	1915	1915	CD
18637	24847	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24847	28	,	,	,
18637	24847	29	357	357	CD
18637	24847	30	Young	Young	NNP
18637	24847	31	,	,	,
18637	24847	32	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24847	33	parte	parte	NNP
18637	24847	34	,	,	,
18637	24847	35	209	209	CD
18637	24847	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24847	37	123	123	CD
18637	24847	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24847	39	1908	1908	CD
18637	24847	40	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24847	41	,	,	,
18637	24847	42	524	524	CD
18637	24847	43	,	,	,
18637	24847	44	628	628	CD
18637	24847	45	,	,	,
18637	24847	46	629	629	CD
18637	24847	47	,	,	,
18637	24847	48	630	630	CD
18637	24847	49	,	,	,
18637	24847	50	931	931	CD
18637	24847	51	,	,	,
18637	24847	52	933	933	CD
18637	24847	53	,	,	,
18637	24847	54	934	934	CD
18637	24847	55	Young	Young	NNP
18637	24847	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24847	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	59	Masci	Masci	NNP
18637	24847	60	,	,	,
18637	24847	61	289	289	CD
18637	24847	62	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24847	63	253	253	CD
18637	24847	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24847	65	1933	1933	CD
18637	24847	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24847	67	,	,	,
18637	24847	68	1033	1033	CD
18637	24847	69	Young	Young	NNP
18637	24847	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	71	v.	v.	IN
18637	24847	72	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	73	United	United	NNP
18637	24847	74	States	States	NNP
18637	24847	75	,	,	,
18637	24847	76	97	97	CD
18637	24847	77	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24847	78	39	39	CD
18637	24847	79	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24847	80	1878	1878	CD
18637	24847	81	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24847	82	,	,	,
18637	24847	83	640	640	NNP
18637	24847	84	Young	Young	NNP
18637	24847	85	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24847	86	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	87	v.	v.	IN
18637	24847	88	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	89	McNeal	McNeal	NNP
18637	24847	90	-	-	HYPH
18637	24847	91	Edwards	Edwards	NNP
18637	24847	92	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24847	93	,	,	,
18637	24847	94	283	283	CD
18637	24847	95	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24847	96	398	398	CD
18637	24847	97	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24847	98	1931	1931	CD
18637	24847	99	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24847	100	,	,	,
18637	24847	101	1090	1090	CD
18637	24847	102	Youngstown	Youngstown	NNP
18637	24847	103	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24847	104	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	105	v.	v.	IN
18637	24847	106	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	107	Sawyer	Sawyer	NNP
18637	24847	108	,	,	,
18637	24847	109	343	343	CD
18637	24847	110	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24847	111	579	579	CD
18637	24847	112	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24847	113	1952	1952	CD
18637	24847	114	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24847	115	,	,	,
18637	24847	116	380	380	CD
18637	24847	117	,	,	,
18637	24847	118	489	489	CD
18637	24847	119	Yu	Yu	NNP
18637	24847	120	Cong	Cong	NNP
18637	24847	121	Eng	Eng	NNP
18637	24847	122	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	123	v.	v.	IN
18637	24847	124	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	125	Trinidad	Trinidad	NNP
18637	24847	126	,	,	,
18637	24847	127	271	271	CD
18637	24847	128	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24847	129	500	500	CD
18637	24847	130	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24847	131	1926	1926	CD
18637	24847	132	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24847	133	,	,	,
18637	24847	134	855	855	CD
18637	24847	135	Z	Z	NNP
18637	24847	136	Zabriskie	Zabriskie	NNP
18637	24847	137	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	138	v.	v.	IN
18637	24847	139	_	_	NNP
18637	24847	140	Hackensack	Hackensack	NNP
18637	24847	141	&	&	CC
18637	24847	142	N.Y.R.	N.Y.R.	NNP
18637	24848	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	24848	2	,	,	,
18637	24848	3	18	18	CD
18637	24848	4	N.J.	New Jersey	NNP
18637	24848	5	Eq	Eq	NNS
18637	24848	6	.	.	.
18637	24849	1	178	178	CD
18637	24849	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24849	3	1867	1867	CD
18637	24849	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24849	5	,	,	,
18637	24849	6	344	344	CD
18637	24849	7	Zahn	Zahn	NNP
18637	24849	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24849	9	v.	v.	IN
18637	24849	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24849	11	Board	Board	NNP
18637	24849	12	of	of	IN
18637	24849	13	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24849	14	Works	Works	NNP
18637	24849	15	,	,	,
18637	24849	16	274	274	CD
18637	24849	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24849	18	325	325	CD
18637	24849	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24849	20	1927	1927	CD
18637	24849	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24849	22	,	,	,
18637	24849	23	1028	1028	CD
18637	24849	24	Zakonaite	Zakonaite	NNP
18637	24849	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24849	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	24849	27	_	_	NNP
18637	24849	28	Wolf	Wolf	NNP
18637	24849	29	,	,	,
18637	24849	30	226	226	CD
18637	24849	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24849	32	272	272	CD
18637	24849	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24849	34	1912	1912	CD
18637	24849	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24849	36	,	,	,
18637	24849	37	853	853	CD
18637	24849	38	,	,	,
18637	24849	39	878	878	CD
18637	24849	40	Zane	Zane	NNP
18637	24849	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24849	42	v.	v.	IN
18637	24849	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24849	44	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	24849	45	County	County	NNP
18637	24849	46	,	,	,
18637	24849	47	189	189	CD
18637	24849	48	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24849	49	370	370	CD
18637	24849	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24849	51	1903	1903	CD
18637	24849	52	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24849	53	,	,	,
18637	24849	54	352	352	CD
18637	24849	55	Zap	Zap	NNP
18637	24849	56	_	_	NNP
18637	24849	57	v.	v.	IN
18637	24849	58	_	_	NNP
18637	24849	59	United	United	NNP
18637	24849	60	States	States	NNP
18637	24849	61	,	,	,
18637	24849	62	328	328	CD
18637	24849	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24849	64	624	624	CD
18637	24849	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24849	66	1946	1946	CD
18637	24849	67	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24849	68	,	,	,
18637	24849	69	831	831	CD
18637	24849	70	Ziffrin	Ziffrin	NNP
18637	24849	71	,	,	,
18637	24849	72	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	24849	73	_	_	NNP
18637	24849	74	v.	v.	IN
18637	24849	75	_	_	NNP
18637	24849	76	Reeves	Reeves	NNP
18637	24849	77	,	,	,
18637	24849	78	308	308	CD
18637	24849	79	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24849	80	132	132	CD
18637	24849	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24849	82	1939	1939	CD
18637	24849	83	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24849	84	,	,	,
18637	24849	85	241	241	CD
18637	24849	86	,	,	,
18637	24849	87	1232	1232	CD
18637	24849	88	Zorach	Zorach	NNP
18637	24849	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24849	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	24849	91	_	_	NNP
18637	24849	92	Clauson	Clauson	NNP
18637	24849	93	,	,	,
18637	24849	94	303	303	CD
18637	24849	95	N.Y.	New York	NNP
18637	24849	96	161	161	CD
18637	24849	97	,	,	,
18637	24849	98	100	100	CD
18637	24849	99	N.E.	N.E.	NNP
18637	24850	1	2d	2d	CD
18637	24850	2	463	463	CD
18637	24850	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24850	4	1951	1951	CD
18637	24850	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24850	6	,	,	,
18637	24850	7	762	762	CD
18637	24850	8	Zorach	Zorach	NNP
18637	24850	9	_	_	NNP
18637	24850	10	v.	v.	IN
18637	24850	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24850	12	Clauson	Clauson	NNP
18637	24850	13	,	,	,
18637	24850	14	343	343	CD
18637	24850	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24850	16	306	306	CD
18637	24850	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24850	18	1952	1952	CD
18637	24850	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24850	20	,	,	,
18637	24850	21	763	763	CD
18637	24850	22	Zucht	Zucht	NNP
18637	24850	23	_	_	NNP
18637	24850	24	v.	v.	IN
18637	24850	25	_	_	NNP
18637	24850	26	King	King	NNP
18637	24850	27	,	,	,
18637	24850	28	260	260	CD
18637	24850	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24850	30	174	174	CD
18637	24850	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24850	32	1922	1922	CD
18637	24850	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24850	34	,	,	,
18637	24850	35	984	984	CD
18637	24850	36	INDEX	index	NN
18637	24850	37	Readers	reader	NNS
18637	24850	38	Should	Should	MD
18637	24850	39	Also	also	RB
18637	24850	40	Consult	consult	VB
18637	24850	41	the	the	DT
18637	24850	42	Table	table	NN
18637	24850	43	of	of	IN
18637	24850	44	Contents	content	NNS
18637	24850	45	Preceding	precede	VBG
18637	24850	46	Each	each	DT
18637	24850	47	Article	Article	NNP
18637	24850	48	and	and	CC
18637	24850	49	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	24850	50	of	of	IN
18637	24850	51	the	the	DT
18637	24850	52	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	24850	53	A	A	NNP
18637	24850	54	Abandoned	Abandoned	NNP
18637	24850	55	Property	Property	NNP
18637	24850	56	,	,	,
18637	24850	57	unclaimed	unclaimed	JJ
18637	24850	58	funds	fund	NNS
18637	24850	59	of	of	IN
18637	24850	60	resident	resident	JJ
18637	24850	61	insurers	insurer	NNS
18637	24850	62	,	,	,
18637	24850	63	escheat	escheat	VB
18637	24850	64	from	from	IN
18637	24850	65	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	24850	66	company	company	NN
18637	24850	67	,	,	,
18637	24850	68	1034	1034	CD
18637	24850	69	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	24850	70	of	of	IN
18637	24850	71	Estates	Estates	NNPS
18637	24850	72	,	,	,
18637	24850	73	State	State	NNP
18637	24850	74	powers	power	NNS
18637	24850	75	as	as	IN
18637	24850	76	to	to	IN
18637	24850	77	,	,	,
18637	24850	78	1034	1034	CD
18637	24850	79	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	24850	80	Agencies	Agencies	NNPS
18637	24850	81	:	:	:
18637	24850	82	Created	create	VBN
18637	24850	83	by	by	IN
18637	24850	84	President	President	NNP
18637	24850	85	,	,	,
18637	24850	86	393	393	CD
18637	24850	87	-	-	SYM
18637	24850	88	394	394	CD
18637	24850	89	,	,	,
18637	24850	90	396	396	CD
18637	24850	91	Discretion	Discretion	NNP
18637	24850	92	to	to	TO
18637	24850	93	discriminate	discriminate	VB
18637	24850	94	,	,	,
18637	24850	95	when	when	WRB
18637	24850	96	a	a	DT
18637	24850	97	denial	denial	NN
18637	24850	98	of	of	IN
18637	24850	99	equal	equal	JJ
18637	24850	100	protection	protection	NN
18637	24850	101	,	,	,
18637	24850	102	1157	1157	CD
18637	24850	103	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	24850	104	review	review	NN
18637	24850	105	of	of	IN
18637	24850	106	,	,	,
18637	24850	107	when	when	WRB
18637	24850	108	a	a	DT
18637	24850	109	due	due	JJ
18637	24850	110	process	process	NN
18637	24850	111	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	24850	112	,	,	,
18637	24850	113	850	850	CD
18637	24850	114	-	-	HYPH
18637	24850	115	853	853	CD
18637	24850	116	Jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	24850	117	facts	fact	NNS
18637	24850	118	,	,	,
18637	24850	119	finality	finality	NN
18637	24850	120	of	of	IN
18637	24850	121	determination	determination	NN
18637	24850	122	by	by	IN
18637	24850	123	,	,	,
18637	24850	124	622	622	CD
18637	24850	125	-	-	SYM
18637	24850	126	623	623	CD
18637	24850	127	State	state	NN
18637	24850	128	,	,	,
18637	24850	129	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	24850	130	due	due	JJ
18637	24850	131	process	process	NN
18637	24850	132	,	,	,
18637	24850	133	notice	notice	NN
18637	24850	134	and	and	CC
18637	24850	135	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	24850	136	,	,	,
18637	24850	137	etc	etc	FW
18637	24850	138	.	.	.
18637	24850	139	,	,	,
18637	24850	140	1084	1084	CD
18637	24850	141	-	-	SYM
18637	24850	142	1088	1088	CD
18637	24850	143	,	,	,
18637	24850	144	1139	1139	CD
18637	24850	145	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	24850	146	Regulations	Regulations	NNPS
18637	24850	147	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24850	148	_	_	NNP
18637	24850	149	see	see	VBP
18637	24850	150	also	also	RB
18637	24850	151	_	_	NNP
18637	24850	152	Delegation	Delegation	NNP
18637	24850	153	of	of	IN
18637	24850	154	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24850	155	;	;	:
18637	24850	156	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	24850	157	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24850	158	;	;	:
18637	24850	159	President	President	NNP
18637	24850	160	:	:	:
18637	24850	161	Powers	power	NNS
18637	24850	162	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24850	163	:	:	:
18637	24850	164	Violations	violation	NNS
18637	24850	165	of	of	IN
18637	24850	166	,	,	,
18637	24850	167	how	how	WRB
18637	24850	168	punished	punish	VBN
18637	24850	169	as	as	IN
18637	24850	170	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	24850	171	,	,	,
18637	24850	172	82	82	CD
18637	24850	173	Admiralty	Admiralty	NNP
18637	24850	174	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24850	175	_	_	NNP
18637	24850	176	see	see	VBP
18637	24850	177	also	also	RB
18637	24850	178	_	_	NNP
18637	24850	179	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24850	180	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24850	181	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24850	182	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24850	183	;	;	:
18637	24850	184	Navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	24850	185	Waters	Waters	NNPS
18637	24850	186	;	;	:
18637	24850	187	States	state	NNS
18637	24850	188	;	;	:
18637	24850	189	States	state	NNS
18637	24850	190	:	:	:
18637	24850	191	Courts	court	NNS
18637	24850	192	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24850	193	:	:	:
18637	24850	194	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24850	195	,	,	,
18637	24850	196	powers	power	NNS
18637	24850	197	as	as	IN
18637	24850	198	to	to	IN
18637	24850	199	,	,	,
18637	24850	200	311	311	CD
18637	24850	201	,	,	,
18637	24850	202	573	573	CD
18637	24850	203	-	-	SYM
18637	24850	204	574	574	CD
18637	24850	205	,	,	,
18637	24850	206	576	576	CD
18637	24850	207	-	-	HYPH
18637	24850	208	583	583	CD
18637	24850	209	Public	public	JJ
18637	24850	210	merchant	merchant	NN
18637	24850	211	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	24850	212	,	,	,
18637	24850	213	immune	immune	JJ
18637	24850	214	from	from	IN
18637	24850	215	suit	suit	NN
18637	24850	216	,	,	,
18637	24850	217	474	474	CD
18637	24850	218	State	state	NN
18637	24850	219	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
18637	24850	220	death	death	NN
18637	24850	221	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	24850	222	,	,	,
18637	24850	223	application	application	NN
18637	24850	224	to	to	IN
18637	24850	225	maritime	maritime	NN
18637	24850	226	torts	tort	NNS
18637	24850	227	,	,	,
18637	24850	228	574	574	CD
18637	24850	229	-	-	SYM
18637	24850	230	575	575	CD
18637	24850	231	Advertisements	Advertisements	NNPS
18637	24850	232	.	.	.
18637	24851	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24851	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24851	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24851	4	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	24851	5	Vehicles	Vehicles	NNPS
18637	24851	6	;	;	:
18637	24851	7	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	24851	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	24851	9	Marks	Marks	NNP
18637	24851	10	.	.	.
18637	24852	1	Advisory	Advisory	NNP
18637	24852	2	Opinions	Opinions	NNPS
18637	24852	3	.	.	.
18637	24853	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24853	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24853	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24853	4	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24853	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24853	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24853	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24853	8	.	.	.
18637	24854	1	Agriculture	agriculture	NN
18637	24854	2	.	.	.
18637	24855	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24855	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24855	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24855	4	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24855	5	;	;	:
18637	24855	6	Commodity	Commodity	NNP
18637	24855	7	and	and	CC
18637	24855	8	Security	Security	NNP
18637	24855	9	Exchanges	exchange	NNS
18637	24855	10	;	;	:
18637	24855	11	Fruit	fruit	NN
18637	24855	12	;	;	:
18637	24855	13	Milk	milk	NN
18637	24855	14	;	;	,
18637	24855	15	Raisins	raisin	NNS
18637	24855	16	;	;	:
18637	24855	17	Warehouses	Warehouses	NNP
18637	24855	18	;	;	:
18637	24855	19	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24855	20	.	.	.
18637	24856	1	Aircraft	aircraft	NN
18637	24856	2	.	.	.
18637	24857	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24857	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24857	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24857	4	Airplanes	Airplanes	NNPS
18637	24857	5	.	.	.
18637	24858	1	Air	Air	NNP
18637	24858	2	Force	Force	NNP
18637	24858	3	.	.	.
18637	24859	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24859	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24859	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24859	4	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24859	5	,	,	,
18637	24859	6	Air	Air	NNP
18637	24859	7	,	,	,
18637	24859	8	and	and	CC
18637	24859	9	Naval	Naval	NNP
18637	24859	10	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	24859	11	.	.	.
18637	24860	1	Airplanes	airplane	NNS
18637	24860	2	:	:	:
18637	24860	3	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24860	4	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24860	5	,	,	,
18637	24860	6	138	138	CD
18637	24860	7	-	-	SYM
18637	24860	8	139	139	CD
18637	24860	9	State	state	NN
18637	24860	10	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24860	11	of	of	IN
18637	24860	12	,	,	,
18637	24860	13	210	210	CD
18637	24860	14	-	-	SYM
18637	24860	15	211	211	CD
18637	24860	16	Alcoholic	Alcoholic	NNP
18637	24860	17	Beverages	Beverages	NNPS
18637	24860	18	.	.	.
18637	24861	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24861	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24861	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24861	4	Intoxicating	Intoxicating	NNP
18637	24861	5	Liquors	Liquors	NNP
18637	24861	6	.	.	.
18637	24862	1	Aliens	Aliens	NNP
18637	24862	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24862	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24862	4	see	see	VBP
18637	24862	5	also	also	RB
18637	24862	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24862	7	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24862	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24862	9	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24862	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24862	11	;	;	:
18637	24862	12	Enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	24862	13	;	;	:
18637	24862	14	Japanese	Japanese	NNP
18637	24862	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24862	16	:	:	:
18637	24862	17	Deportation	deportation	NN
18637	24862	18	,	,	,
18637	24862	19	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	24862	20	,	,	,
18637	24862	21	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	24862	22	,	,	,
18637	24862	23	due	due	JJ
18637	24862	24	process	process	NN
18637	24862	25	in	in	IN
18637	24862	26	,	,	,
18637	24862	27	851	851	CD
18637	24862	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	24862	29	853	853	CD
18637	24862	30	Discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	24862	31	against	against	IN
18637	24862	32	by	by	IN
18637	24862	33	States	state	NNS
18637	24862	34	,	,	,
18637	24862	35	cities	city	NNS
18637	24862	36	,	,	,
18637	24862	37	when	when	WRB
18637	24862	38	a	a	DT
18637	24862	39	denial	denial	NN
18637	24862	40	of	of	IN
18637	24862	41	equal	equal	JJ
18637	24862	42	protection	protection	NN
18637	24862	43	,	,	,
18637	24862	44	1157	1157	CD
18637	24862	45	-	-	SYM
18637	24862	46	1158	1158	CD
18637	24862	47	Due	due	JJ
18637	24862	48	process	process	NN
18637	24862	49	of	of	IN
18637	24862	50	law	law	NN
18637	24862	51	,	,	,
18637	24862	52	protected	protect	VBN
18637	24862	53	by	by	IN
18637	24862	54	,	,	,
18637	24862	55	846	846	CD
18637	24862	56	Entry	entry	NN
18637	24862	57	,	,	,
18637	24862	58	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	24862	59	,	,	,
18637	24862	60	powers	power	NNS
18637	24862	61	of	of	IN
18637	24862	62	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24862	63	as	as	IN
18637	24862	64	to	to	IN
18637	24862	65	,	,	,
18637	24862	66	259	259	CD
18637	24862	67	-	-	SYM
18637	24862	68	261	261	CD
18637	24862	69	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	24862	70	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	24862	71	,	,	,
18637	24862	72	protected	protect	VBN
18637	24862	73	by	by	IN
18637	24862	74	,	,	,
18637	24862	75	limits	limit	NNS
18637	24862	76	,	,	,
18637	24862	77	439	439	CD
18637	24862	78	Fishing	fishing	NN
18637	24862	79	licenses	license	NNS
18637	24862	80	,	,	,
18637	24862	81	State	state	NN
18637	24862	82	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	24862	83	to	to	TO
18637	24862	84	issue	issue	NN
18637	24862	85	to	to	IN
18637	24862	86	,	,	,
18637	24862	87	validity	validity	NN
18637	24862	88	,	,	,
18637	24862	89	417	417	CD
18637	24862	90	Land	land	NN
18637	24862	91	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	24862	92	by	by	IN
18637	24862	93	,	,	,
18637	24862	94	State	state	NN
18637	24862	95	power	power	NN
18637	24862	96	to	to	TO
18637	24862	97	restrict	restrict	VB
18637	24862	98	,	,	,
18637	24862	99	416	416	CD
18637	24862	100	-	-	SYM
18637	24862	101	417	417	CD
18637	24862	102	,	,	,
18637	24862	103	968	968	CD
18637	24862	104	,	,	,
18637	24862	105	1157	1157	CD
18637	24862	106	-	-	SYM
18637	24862	107	1158	1158	CD
18637	24862	108	Property	Property	NNP
18637	24862	109	of	of	IN
18637	24862	110	,	,	,
18637	24862	111	condemnation	condemnation	NN
18637	24862	112	,	,	,
18637	24862	113	865	865	CD
18637	24862	114	Release	release	NN
18637	24862	115	from	from	IN
18637	24862	116	State	state	NN
18637	24862	117	custody	custody	NN
18637	24862	118	by	by	IN
18637	24862	119	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	24862	120	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	24862	121	from	from	IN
18637	24862	122	federal	federal	JJ
18637	24862	123	court	court	NN
18637	24862	124	,	,	,
18637	24862	125	632	632	CD
18637	24862	126	State	state	NN
18637	24862	127	curbs	curb	NNS
18637	24862	128	on	on	IN
18637	24862	129	entry	entry	NN
18637	24862	130	,	,	,
18637	24862	131	validity	validity	NN
18637	24862	132	,	,	,
18637	24862	133	215	215	CD
18637	24862	134	-	-	SYM
18637	24862	135	216	216	CD
18637	24862	136	,	,	,
18637	24862	137	241	241	CD
18637	24862	138	Alliances	Alliances	NNPS
18637	24862	139	,	,	,
18637	24862	140	States	States	NNP
18637	24862	141	not	not	RB
18637	24862	142	to	to	TO
18637	24862	143	enter	enter	VB
18637	24862	144	into	into	IN
18637	24862	145	,	,	,
18637	24862	146	325	325	CD
18637	24862	147	Ambassadors	Ambassadors	NNPS
18637	24862	148	,	,	,
18637	24862	149	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24862	150	Ministers	Ministers	NNPS
18637	24862	151	,	,	,
18637	24862	152	Consuls	Consuls	NNP
18637	24862	153	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24862	154	_	_	NNP
18637	24862	155	see	see	VBP
18637	24862	156	also	also	RB
18637	24862	157	_	_	NNP
18637	24862	158	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24862	159	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24862	160	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24862	161	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24862	162	;	;	:
18637	24862	163	States	state	NNS
18637	24862	164	:	:	:
18637	24862	165	Courts	court	NNS
18637	24862	166	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24862	167	:	:	:
18637	24862	168	Defined	define	VBN
18637	24862	169	,	,	,
18637	24862	170	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	24862	171	,	,	,
18637	24862	172	salary	salary	NN
18637	24862	173	,	,	,
18637	24862	174	etc	etc	FW
18637	24862	175	.	.	.
18637	24862	176	,	,	,
18637	24862	177	445	445	CD
18637	24862	178	-	-	SYM
18637	24862	179	447	447	CD
18637	24862	180	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	24862	181	to	to	IN
18637	24862	182	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	24862	183	.	.	.
18637	24863	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24863	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24863	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24863	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	24863	5	of	of	IN
18637	24863	6	the	the	DT
18637	24863	7	United	United	NNP
18637	24863	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24863	9	.	.	.
18637	24864	1	Amnesty	Amnesty	NNP
18637	24864	2	.	.	.
18637	24865	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24865	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24865	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24865	4	Pardons	Pardons	NNPS
18637	24865	5	;	;	:
18637	24865	6	President	President	NNP
18637	24865	7	:	:	:
18637	24865	8	Powers	power	NNS
18637	24865	9	.	.	.
18637	24866	1	Antitrust	Antitrust	NNP
18637	24866	2	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	24866	3	.	.	.
18637	24867	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24867	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24867	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24867	4	Restraint	Restraint	NNP
18637	24867	5	of	of	IN
18637	24867	6	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	24867	7	.	.	.
18637	24868	1	Apportionment	Apportionment	NNP
18637	24868	2	of	of	IN
18637	24868	3	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	24868	4	.	.	.
18637	24869	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24869	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24869	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24869	4	House	House	NNP
18637	24869	5	of	of	IN
18637	24869	6	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	24869	7	.	.	.
18637	24870	1	Appropriations	Appropriations	NNP
18637	24870	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24870	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24870	4	see	see	VBP
18637	24870	5	also	also	RB
18637	24870	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24870	7	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24870	8	Funds	Funds	NNPS
18637	24870	9	of	of	IN
18637	24870	10	United	United	NNP
18637	24870	11	States	States	NNP
18637	24870	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24870	13	:	:	:
18637	24870	14	Power	power	NN
18637	24870	15	of	of	IN
18637	24870	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24870	17	to	to	TO
18637	24870	18	make	make	VB
18637	24870	19	,	,	,
18637	24870	20	323	323	CD
18637	24870	21	-	-	SYM
18637	24870	22	324	324	CD
18637	24870	23	Required	require	VBN
18637	24870	24	for	for	IN
18637	24870	25	withdrawals	withdrawal	NNS
18637	24870	26	from	from	IN
18637	24870	27	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	24870	28	,	,	,
18637	24870	29	payment	payment	NN
18637	24870	30	of	of	IN
18637	24870	31	claims	claim	NNS
18637	24870	32	,	,	,
18637	24870	33	323	323	CD
18637	24870	34	for	for	IN
18637	24870	35	Support	support	NN
18637	24870	36	of	of	IN
18637	24870	37	armies	army	NNS
18637	24870	38	,	,	,
18637	24870	39	two	two	CD
18637	24870	40	year	year	NN
18637	24870	41	limit	limit	NN
18637	24870	42	,	,	,
18637	24870	43	279	279	CD
18637	24870	44	,	,	,
18637	24870	45	283	283	CD
18637	24870	46	-	-	SYM
18637	24870	47	284	284	CD
18637	24870	48	Army	Army	NNP
18637	24870	49	.	.	.
18637	24871	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24871	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24871	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24871	4	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24871	5	,	,	,
18637	24871	6	Air	Air	NNP
18637	24871	7	,	,	,
18637	24871	8	and	and	CC
18637	24871	9	Naval	Naval	NNP
18637	24871	10	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	24871	11	.	.	.
18637	24872	1	Arsenals	arsenal	NNS
18637	24872	2	,	,	,
18637	24872	3	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	24872	4	with	with	IN
18637	24872	5	State	state	NN
18637	24872	6	consent	consent	NN
18637	24872	7	,	,	,
18637	24872	8	federal	federal	JJ
18637	24872	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24872	10	over	over	RB
18637	24872	11	,	,	,
18637	24872	12	300	300	CD
18637	24872	13	,	,	,
18637	24872	14	306	306	CD
18637	24872	15	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	16	307	307	CD
18637	24872	17	Atomic	Atomic	NNP
18637	24872	18	Energy	Energy	NNP
18637	24872	19	,	,	,
18637	24872	20	292	292	CD
18637	24872	21	Attachment	Attachment	NNP
18637	24872	22	and	and	CC
18637	24872	23	Garnishment	Garnishment	NNP
18637	24872	24	,	,	,
18637	24872	25	railway	railway	NN
18637	24872	26	cars	car	NNS
18637	24872	27	in	in	IN
18637	24872	28	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	24872	29	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	24872	30	,	,	,
18637	24872	31	under	under	IN
18637	24872	32	State	State	NNP
18637	24872	33	law	law	NN
18637	24872	34	,	,	,
18637	24872	35	235	235	CD
18637	24872	36	Attorneys	Attorneys	NNPS
18637	24872	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24872	38	_	_	NNP
18637	24872	39	see	see	VBP
18637	24872	40	also	also	RB
18637	24872	41	_	_	NNP
18637	24872	42	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24872	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24872	44	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24872	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24872	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24872	47	:	:	:
18637	24872	48	Defendant	defendant	NN
18637	24872	49	's	's	POS
18637	24872	50	right	right	NN
18637	24872	51	to	to	IN
18637	24872	52	,	,	,
18637	24872	53	in	in	IN
18637	24872	54	federal	federal	JJ
18637	24872	55	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	24872	56	cases	case	NNS
18637	24872	57	,	,	,
18637	24872	58	884	884	CD
18637	24872	59	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	60	885	885	CD
18637	24872	61	Defendant	Defendant	NNP
18637	24872	62	's	's	POS
18637	24872	63	right	right	NN
18637	24872	64	to	to	IN
18637	24872	65	,	,	,
18637	24872	66	in	in	IN
18637	24872	67	State	state	NN
18637	24872	68	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	24872	69	trials	trial	NNS
18637	24872	70	;	;	:
18637	24872	71	fair	fair	JJ
18637	24872	72	trial	trial	NN
18637	24872	73	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	24872	74	,	,	,
18637	24872	75	1098	1098	CD
18637	24872	76	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	77	1109	1109	CD
18637	24872	78	Practice	Practice	NNP
18637	24872	79	in	in	IN
18637	24872	80	federal	federal	JJ
18637	24872	81	courts	court	NNS
18637	24872	82	,	,	,
18637	24872	83	powers	power	NNS
18637	24872	84	of	of	IN
18637	24872	85	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24872	86	as	as	IN
18637	24872	87	to	to	IN
18637	24872	88	,	,	,
18637	24872	89	etc	etc	FW
18637	24872	90	.	.	.
18637	24872	91	,	,	,
18637	24872	92	527	527	CD
18637	24872	93	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	94	528	528	CD
18637	24872	95	B	B	NNP
18637	24872	96	Bail	bail	NN
18637	24872	97	:	:	:
18637	24872	98	Denial	denial	NN
18637	24872	99	of	of	IN
18637	24872	100	,	,	,
18637	24872	101	by	by	IN
18637	24872	102	States	state	NNS
18637	24872	103	,	,	,
18637	24872	104	validity	validity	NN
18637	24872	105	,	,	,
18637	24872	106	1133	1133	CD
18637	24872	107	Excessive	Excessive	NNP
18637	24872	108	,	,	,
18637	24872	109	not	not	RB
18637	24872	110	to	to	TO
18637	24872	111	be	be	VB
18637	24872	112	required	require	VBN
18637	24872	113	,	,	,
18637	24872	114	903	903	CD
18637	24872	115	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	116	904	904	CD
18637	24872	117	Bankruptcy	Bankruptcy	NNP
18637	24872	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24872	119	_	_	NNP
18637	24872	120	see	see	VBP
18637	24872	121	also	also	RB
18637	24872	122	_	_	NNP
18637	24872	123	Due	Due	NNP
18637	24872	124	Process	Process	NNP
18637	24872	125	of	of	IN
18637	24872	126	Law	Law	NNP
18637	24872	127	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24872	128	:	:	:
18637	24872	129	Legislation	legislation	NN
18637	24872	130	,	,	,
18637	24872	131	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	24872	132	imposed	impose	VBN
18637	24872	133	by	by	IN
18637	24872	134	due	due	JJ
18637	24872	135	process	process	NN
18637	24872	136	clause	clause	NN
18637	24872	137	,	,	,
18637	24872	138	857	857	CD
18637	24872	139	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	140	858	858	CD
18637	24872	141	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	24872	142	covered	cover	VBN
18637	24872	143	by	by	IN
18637	24872	144	,	,	,
18637	24872	145	262	262	CD
18637	24872	146	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	147	263	263	CD
18637	24872	148	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	24872	149	of	of	IN
18637	24872	150	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24872	151	as	as	IN
18637	24872	152	to	to	IN
18637	24872	153	;	;	:
18637	24872	154	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	24872	155	,	,	,
18637	24872	156	263	263	CD
18637	24872	157	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	158	264	264	CD
18637	24872	159	Scope	scope	NN
18637	24872	160	of	of	IN
18637	24872	161	relief	relief	NN
18637	24872	162	to	to	IN
18637	24872	163	debtors	debtor	NNS
18637	24872	164	,	,	,
18637	24872	165	262	262	CD
18637	24872	166	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	167	263	263	CD
18637	24872	168	State	State	NNP
18637	24872	169	insolvency	insolvency	NN
18637	24872	170	laws	law	NNS
18637	24872	171	,	,	,
18637	24872	172	when	when	WRB
18637	24872	173	operative	operative	JJ
18637	24872	174	,	,	,
18637	24872	175	validity	validity	NN
18637	24872	176	,	,	,
18637	24872	177	264	264	CD
18637	24872	178	-	-	HYPH
18637	24872	179	265	265	CD
18637	24872	180	States	state	NNS
18637	24872	181	as	as	IN
18637	24872	182	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	24872	183	,	,	,
18637	24872	184	filing	filing	NN
18637	24872	185	of	of	IN
18637	24872	186	claims	claim	NNS
18637	24872	187	,	,	,
18637	24872	188	264	264	CD
18637	24872	189	-	-	HYPH
18637	24872	190	265	265	CD
18637	24872	191	Banks	Banks	NNPS
18637	24872	192	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24872	193	_	_	NNP
18637	24872	194	see	see	VBP
18637	24872	195	also	also	RB
18637	24872	196	_	_	NNP
18637	24872	197	National	National	NNP
18637	24872	198	Banks	Banks	NNPS
18637	24872	199	;	;	:
18637	24872	200	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24872	201	:	:	:
18637	24872	202	States	state	NNS
18637	24872	203	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24872	204	:	:	:
18637	24872	205	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24872	206	tax	tax	NN
18637	24872	207	on	on	IN
18637	24872	208	State	State	NNP
18637	24872	209	bank	bank	NN
18637	24872	210	notes	note	NNS
18637	24872	211	,	,	,
18637	24872	212	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	24872	213	notes	note	NNS
18637	24872	214	,	,	,
18637	24872	215	265	265	CD
18637	24872	216	,	,	,
18637	24872	217	309	309	CD
18637	24872	218	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	219	310	310	CD
18637	24872	220	in	in	IN
18637	24872	221	Interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	24872	222	business	business	NN
18637	24872	223	,	,	,
18637	24872	224	State	state	NN
18637	24872	225	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24872	226	,	,	,
18637	24872	227	234	234	CD
18637	24872	228	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	229	235	235	CD
18637	24872	230	State	state	NN
18637	24872	231	owned	own	VBN
18637	24872	232	,	,	,
18637	24872	233	suable	suable	JJ
18637	24872	234	,	,	,
18637	24872	235	930	930	CD
18637	24872	236	State	state	NN
18637	24872	237	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24872	238	of	of	IN
18637	24872	239	,	,	,
18637	24872	240	1020	1020	CD
18637	24872	241	,	,	,
18637	24872	242	1082	1082	CD
18637	24872	243	Unclaimed	unclaimed	JJ
18637	24872	244	funds	fund	NNS
18637	24872	245	in	in	IN
18637	24872	246	,	,	,
18637	24872	247	escheat	escheat	JJ
18637	24872	248	to	to	IN
18637	24872	249	State	State	NNP
18637	24872	250	,	,	,
18637	24872	251	due	due	JJ
18637	24872	252	process	process	NN
18637	24872	253	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	24872	254	,	,	,
18637	24872	255	1082	1082	CD
18637	24872	256	Bearing	bearing	NN
18637	24872	257	Arms	Arms	NNPS
18637	24872	258	:	:	:
18637	24872	259	as	as	IN
18637	24872	260	Condition	Condition	NNP
18637	24872	261	of	of	IN
18637	24872	262	naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	24872	263	,	,	,
18637	24872	264	256	256	CD
18637	24872	265	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	266	257	257	CD
18637	24872	267	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	24872	268	right	right	NN
18637	24872	269	as	as	IN
18637	24872	270	to	to	IN
18637	24872	271	,	,	,
18637	24872	272	813	813	CD
18637	24872	273	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	24872	274	of	of	IN
18637	24872	275	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	24872	276	:	:	:
18637	24872	277	Application	application	NN
18637	24872	278	to	to	IN
18637	24872	279	States	States	NNP
18637	24872	280	,	,	,
18637	24872	281	750	750	CD
18637	24872	282	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	283	752	752	CD
18637	24872	284	,	,	,
18637	24872	285	757	757	CD
18637	24872	286	,	,	,
18637	24872	287	760	760	CD
18637	24872	288	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	289	764	764	CD
18637	24872	290	,	,	,
18637	24872	291	766	766	CD
18637	24872	292	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	293	768	768	CD
18637	24872	294	,	,	,
18637	24872	295	771	771	CD
18637	24872	296	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	297	773	773	CD
18637	24872	298	,	,	,
18637	24872	299	775	775	CD
18637	24872	300	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	301	792	792	CD
18637	24872	302	,	,	,
18637	24872	303	808	808	CD
18637	24872	304	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	305	810	810	CD
18637	24872	306	,	,	,
18637	24872	307	830	830	CD
18637	24872	308	,	,	,
18637	24872	309	904	904	CD
18637	24872	310	,	,	,
18637	24872	311	985	985	CD
18637	24872	312	,	,	,
18637	24872	313	1100	1100	CD
18637	24872	314	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	315	1101	1101	CD
18637	24872	316	,	,	,
18637	24872	317	1110	1110	CD
18637	24872	318	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	319	1113	1113	CD
18637	24872	320	,	,	,
18637	24872	321	1115	1115	CD
18637	24872	322	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	323	1118	1118	CD
18637	24872	324	,	,	,
18637	24872	325	1121	1121	CD
18637	24872	326	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	327	1124	1124	CD
18637	24872	328	,	,	,
18637	24872	329	1133	1133	CD
18637	24872	330	Formulation	Formulation	NNP
18637	24872	331	,	,	,
18637	24872	332	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	24872	333	,	,	,
18637	24872	334	749	749	CD
18637	24872	335	-	-	HYPH
18637	24872	336	750	750	CD
18637	24872	337	Intended	Intended	NNP
18637	24872	338	scope	scope	NN
18637	24872	339	,	,	,
18637	24872	340	770	770	CD
18637	24872	341	Bills	Bills	NNPS
18637	24872	342	of	of	IN
18637	24872	343	Attainder	Attainder	NNP
18637	24872	344	,	,	,
18637	24872	345	passage	passage	NN
18637	24872	346	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	24872	347	,	,	,
18637	24872	348	315	315	CD
18637	24872	349	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	350	316	316	CD
18637	24872	351	,	,	,
18637	24872	352	326	326	CD
18637	24872	353	-	-	SYM
18637	24872	354	327	327	CD
18637	24872	355	Bills	Bills	NNPS
18637	24872	356	of	of	IN
18637	24872	357	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	24872	358	,	,	,
18637	24872	359	States	States	NNP
18637	24872	360	not	not	RB
18637	24872	361	to	to	TO
18637	24872	362	issue	issue	VB
18637	24872	363	,	,	,
18637	24872	364	326	326	CD
18637	24872	365	"	"	``
18637	24872	366	Blue	blue	JJ
18637	24872	367	Ribbon	Ribbon	NNP
18637	24872	368	"	"	''
18637	24872	369	Juries	jury	NNS
18637	24872	370	.	.	.
18637	24873	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24873	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24873	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24873	4	Juries	Juries	NNPS
18637	24873	5	.	.	.
18637	24874	1	Blue	Blue	NNP
18637	24874	2	Sky	Sky	NNP
18637	24874	3	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	24874	4	,	,	,
18637	24874	5	1019	1019	CD
18637	24874	6	Borrowing	Borrowing	NNP
18637	24874	7	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24874	8	,	,	,
18637	24874	9	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24874	10	,	,	,
18637	24874	11	relation	relation	NN
18637	24874	12	to	to	TO
18637	24874	13	coinage	coinage	VB
18637	24874	14	power	power	NN
18637	24874	15	,	,	,
18637	24874	16	117	117	CD
18637	24874	17	-	-	SYM
18637	24874	18	118	118	CD
18637	24874	19	,	,	,
18637	24874	20	266	266	CD
18637	24874	21	-	-	SYM
18637	24874	22	267	267	CD
18637	24874	23	Boundaries	Boundaries	NNPS
18637	24874	24	of	of	IN
18637	24874	25	States	States	NNPS
18637	24874	26	,	,	,
18637	24874	27	suits	suit	VBZ
18637	24874	28	as	as	IN
18637	24874	29	to	to	IN
18637	24874	30	,	,	,
18637	24874	31	591	591	CD
18637	24874	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	24874	33	592	592	CD
18637	24874	34	Bread	bread	NN
18637	24874	35	.	.	.
18637	24875	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24875	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24875	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24875	4	Food	Food	NNP
18637	24875	5	;	;	:
18637	24875	6	Weights	Weights	NNPS
18637	24875	7	and	and	CC
18637	24875	8	Measures	Measures	NNPS
18637	24875	9	.	.	.
18637	24876	1	Bridges	bridge	NNS
18637	24876	2	across	across	IN
18637	24876	3	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	24876	4	streams	stream	NNS
18637	24876	5	,	,	,
18637	24876	6	State	state	NN
18637	24876	7	power	power	NN
18637	24876	8	as	as	IN
18637	24876	9	to	to	IN
18637	24876	10	,	,	,
18637	24876	11	230	230	CD
18637	24876	12	-	-	SYM
18637	24876	13	231	231	CD
18637	24876	14	Building	Building	NNP
18637	24876	15	and	and	CC
18637	24876	16	Loan	Loan	NNP
18637	24876	17	Association	Association	NNP
18637	24876	18	,	,	,
18637	24876	19	conversion	conversion	NN
18637	24876	20	into	into	IN
18637	24876	21	federal	federal	JJ
18637	24876	22	,	,	,
18637	24876	23	without	without	IN
18637	24876	24	State	state	NN
18637	24876	25	consent	consent	NN
18637	24876	26	,	,	,
18637	24876	27	void	void	JJ
18637	24876	28	,	,	,
18637	24876	29	920	920	CD
18637	24876	30	-	-	SYM
18637	24876	31	921	921	CD
18637	24876	32	Building	Building	NNP
18637	24876	33	sites	site	NNS
18637	24876	34	purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	24876	35	with	with	IN
18637	24876	36	State	state	NN
18637	24876	37	consent	consent	NN
18637	24876	38	,	,	,
18637	24876	39	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24876	40	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24876	41	over	over	RB
18637	24876	42	,	,	,
18637	24876	43	300	300	CD
18637	24876	44	,	,	,
18637	24876	45	305	305	CD
18637	24876	46	-	-	SYM
18637	24876	47	307	307	CD
18637	24876	48	Business	Business	NNP
18637	24876	49	,	,	,
18637	24876	50	Trades	Trades	NNPS
18637	24876	51	,	,	,
18637	24876	52	and	and	CC
18637	24876	53	Professions	Professions	NNPS
18637	24876	54	,	,	,
18637	24876	55	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	24876	56	by	by	IN
18637	24876	57	States	States	NNP
18637	24876	58	,	,	,
18637	24876	59	Municipalities	Municipalities	NNPS
18637	24876	60	,	,	,
18637	24876	61	1017	1017	CD
18637	24876	62	-	-	SYM
18637	24876	63	1024	1024	CD
18637	24876	64	,	,	,
18637	24876	65	1155	1155	CD
18637	24876	66	Businesses	business	NNS
18637	24876	67	Affected	affect	VBN
18637	24876	68	with	with	IN
18637	24876	69	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24876	70	Interest	Interest	NNP
18637	24876	71	,	,	,
18637	24876	72	State	state	NN
18637	24876	73	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24876	74	of	of	IN
18637	24876	75	,	,	,
18637	24876	76	995	995	CD
18637	24876	77	-	-	HYPH
18637	24876	78	997	997	CD
18637	24876	79	C	C	NNP
18637	24876	80	Carriers	Carriers	NNPS
18637	24876	81	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24876	82	_	_	NNP
18637	24876	83	see	see	VBP
18637	24876	84	also	also	RB
18637	24876	85	_	_	NNP
18637	24876	86	Airplanes	Airplanes	NNPS
18637	24876	87	;	;	:
18637	24876	88	Attachment	Attachment	NNP
18637	24876	89	and	and	CC
18637	24876	90	Garnishment	Garnishment	NNP
18637	24876	91	;	;	:
18637	24876	92	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24876	93	Utilities	Utilities	NNPS
18637	24876	94	;	;	:
18637	24876	95	Restraint	Restraint	NNP
18637	24876	96	of	of	IN
18637	24876	97	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	24876	98	;	;	:
18637	24876	99	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24876	100	:	:	:
18637	24876	101	State	state	NN
18637	24876	102	;	;	:
18637	24876	103	Vessels	Vessels	NNP
18637	24876	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24876	105	:	:	:
18637	24876	106	Bills	bill	NNS
18637	24876	107	of	of	IN
18637	24876	108	lading	lading	NN
18637	24876	109	,	,	,
18637	24876	110	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24876	111	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24876	112	as	as	IN
18637	24876	113	to	to	IN
18637	24876	114	,	,	,
18637	24876	115	143	143	CD
18637	24876	116	-	-	SYM
18637	24876	117	144	144	CD
18637	24876	118	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	24876	119	,	,	,
18637	24876	120	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24876	121	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24876	122	of	of	IN
18637	24876	123	,	,	,
18637	24876	124	138	138	CD
18637	24876	125	,	,	,
18637	24876	126	139	139	CD
18637	24876	127	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	24876	128	,	,	,
18637	24876	129	State	State	NNP
18637	24876	130	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24876	131	of	of	IN
18637	24876	132	,	,	,
18637	24876	133	211	211	CD
18637	24876	134	-	-	SYM
18637	24876	135	213	213	CD
18637	24876	136	,	,	,
18637	24876	137	226	226	CD
18637	24876	138	-	-	SYM
18637	24876	139	228	228	CD
18637	24876	140	,	,	,
18637	24876	141	250	250	CD
18637	24876	142	,	,	,
18637	24876	143	1032	1032	CD
18637	24876	144	-	-	SYM
18637	24876	145	1033	1033	CD
18637	24876	146	,	,	,
18637	24876	147	1153	1153	CD
18637	24876	148	,	,	,
18637	24876	149	1155	1155	CD
18637	24876	150	Pipelines	Pipelines	NNPS
18637	24876	151	,	,	,
18637	24876	152	oil	oil	NN
18637	24876	153	and	and	CC
18637	24876	154	gas	gas	NN
18637	24876	155	,	,	,
18637	24876	156	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24876	157	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24876	158	of	of	IN
18637	24876	159	,	,	,
18637	24876	160	137	137	CD
18637	24876	161	-	-	HYPH
18637	24876	162	138	138	CD
18637	24876	163	Pipelines	Pipelines	NNPS
18637	24876	164	,	,	,
18637	24876	165	power	power	NN
18637	24876	166	of	of	IN
18637	24876	167	States	States	NNPS
18637	24876	168	to	to	TO
18637	24876	169	compel	compel	VB
18637	24876	170	service	service	NN
18637	24876	171	by	by	IN
18637	24876	172	,	,	,
18637	24876	173	1025	1025	CD
18637	24876	174	Railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	24876	175	,	,	,
18637	24876	176	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	24876	177	of	of	IN
18637	24876	178	State	State	NNP
18637	24876	179	,	,	,
18637	24876	180	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24876	181	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24876	182	as	as	IN
18637	24876	183	to	to	IN
18637	24876	184	,	,	,
18637	24876	185	246	246	CD
18637	24876	186	-	-	HYPH
18637	24876	187	247	247	CD
18637	24876	188	,	,	,
18637	24876	189	251	251	CD
18637	24876	190	Railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	24876	191	,	,	,
18637	24876	192	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24876	193	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24876	194	of	of	IN
18637	24876	195	labor	labor	NN
18637	24876	196	,	,	,
18637	24876	197	rates	rate	NNS
18637	24876	198	,	,	,
18637	24876	199	safety	safety	NN
18637	24876	200	,	,	,
18637	24876	201	etc	etc	FW
18637	24876	202	.	.	FW
18637	24876	203	,	,	,
18637	24876	204	due	due	JJ
18637	24876	205	process	process	NN
18637	24876	206	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	24876	207	,	,	,
18637	24876	208	132	132	CD
18637	24876	209	-	-	SYM
18637	24876	210	137	137	CD
18637	24876	211	,	,	,
18637	24876	212	139	139	CD
18637	24876	213	-	-	SYM
18637	24876	214	143	143	CD
18637	24876	215	,	,	,
18637	24876	216	861	861	CD
18637	24876	217	-	-	SYM
18637	24876	218	862	862	CD
18637	24876	219	Railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	24876	220	,	,	,
18637	24876	221	grade	grade	NN
18637	24876	222	crossing	crossing	NN
18637	24876	223	elimination	elimination	NN
18637	24876	224	,	,	,
18637	24876	225	compellable	compellable	JJ
18637	24876	226	services	service	NNS
18637	24876	227	,	,	,
18637	24876	228	etc	etc	FW
18637	24876	229	.	.	FW
18637	24876	230	,	,	,
18637	24876	231	rates	rate	NNS
18637	24876	232	,	,	,
18637	24876	233	safety	safety	NN
18637	24876	234	;	;	:
18637	24876	235	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	24876	236	powers	power	NNS
18637	24876	237	of	of	IN
18637	24876	238	States	States	NNP
18637	24876	239	as	as	IN
18637	24876	240	to	to	IN
18637	24876	241	,	,	,
18637	24876	242	134	134	CD
18637	24876	243	-	-	SYM
18637	24876	244	137	137	CD
18637	24876	245	,	,	,
18637	24876	246	220	220	CD
18637	24876	247	-	-	SYM
18637	24876	248	225	225	CD
18637	24876	249	,	,	,
18637	24876	250	998	998	CD
18637	24876	251	-	-	HYPH
18637	24876	252	1008	1008	CD
18637	24876	253	,	,	,
18637	24876	254	1010	1010	CD
18637	24876	255	-	-	SYM
18637	24876	256	1016	1016	CD
18637	24876	257	,	,	,
18637	24876	258	1156	1156	CD
18637	24876	259	Transportation	transportation	NN
18637	24876	260	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	24876	261	,	,	,
18637	24876	262	State	state	NN
18637	24876	263	control	control	NN
18637	24876	264	of	of	IN
18637	24876	265	,	,	,
18637	24876	266	scope	scope	NN
18637	24876	267	,	,	,
18637	24876	268	228	228	CD
18637	24876	269	Censorship	censorship	NN
18637	24876	270	.	.	.
18637	24877	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24877	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24877	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24877	4	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	24877	5	of	of	IN
18637	24877	6	Religion	Religion	NNP
18637	24877	7	,	,	,
18637	24877	8	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	24877	9	,	,	,
18637	24877	10	Press	Press	NNP
18637	24877	11	,	,	,
18637	24877	12	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
18637	24877	13	;	;	:
18637	24877	14	Motion	Motion	NNP
18637	24877	15	Pictures	Pictures	NNP
18637	24877	16	;	;	:
18637	24877	17	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	24877	18	Service	Service	NNP
18637	24877	19	;	;	:
18637	24877	20	War	War	NNP
18637	24877	21	.	.	.
18637	24878	1	Census	Census	NNP
18637	24878	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24878	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24878	4	See	See	NNP
18637	24878	5	also	also	RB
18637	24878	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24878	7	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	24878	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24878	9	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24878	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24878	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24878	12	:	:	:
18637	24878	13	Basis	basis	NN
18637	24878	14	of	of	IN
18637	24878	15	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	24878	16	of	of	IN
18637	24878	17	seats	seat	NNS
18637	24878	18	in	in	IN
18637	24878	19	House	House	NNP
18637	24878	20	of	of	IN
18637	24878	21	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	24878	22	,	,	,
18637	24878	23	89	89	CD
18637	24878	24	-	-	SYM
18637	24878	25	90	90	CD
18637	24878	26	Decennially	decennially	RB
18637	24878	27	taken	take	VBN
18637	24878	28	;	;	:
18637	24878	29	extended	extended	JJ
18637	24878	30	scope	scope	NN
18637	24878	31	,	,	,
18637	24878	32	89	89	CD
18637	24878	33	-	-	SYM
18637	24878	34	90	90	CD
18637	24878	35	Chain	Chain	NNP
18637	24878	36	Stores	Stores	NNPS
18637	24878	37	,	,	,
18637	24878	38	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24878	39	of	of	IN
18637	24878	40	,	,	,
18637	24878	41	validity	validity	NN
18637	24878	42	,	,	,
18637	24878	43	1055	1055	CD
18637	24878	44	,	,	,
18637	24878	45	1147	1147	CD
18637	24878	46	-	-	SYM
18637	24878	47	1148	1148	CD
18637	24878	48	Child	Child	NNP
18637	24878	49	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24878	50	:	:	:
18637	24878	51	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24878	52	laws	law	NNS
18637	24878	53	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	24878	54	,	,	,
18637	24878	55	validity	validity	NN
18637	24878	56	,	,	,
18637	24878	57	152	152	CD
18637	24878	58	-	-	SYM
18637	24878	59	158	158	CD
18637	24878	60	State	state	NN
18637	24878	61	laws	law	NNS
18637	24878	62	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	24878	63	,	,	,
18637	24878	64	987	987	CD
18637	24878	65	Chinese	Chinese	NNPS
18637	24878	66	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24878	67	_	_	NNP
18637	24878	68	see	see	VB
18637	24878	69	also	also	RB
18637	24878	70	_	_	NNP
18637	24878	71	Aliens	Aliens	NNP
18637	24878	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24878	73	:	:	:
18637	24878	74	Assigned	assign	VBN
18637	24878	75	to	to	IN
18637	24878	76	negro	negro	JJ
18637	24878	77	schools	school	NNS
18637	24878	78	,	,	,
18637	24878	79	validity	validity	NN
18637	24878	80	,	,	,
18637	24878	81	1161	1161	CD
18637	24878	82	Cigarettes	Cigarettes	NNPS
18637	24878	83	,	,	,
18637	24878	84	State	state	NN
18637	24878	85	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24878	86	of	of	IN
18637	24878	87	sale	sale	NN
18637	24878	88	,	,	,
18637	24878	89	240	240	CD
18637	24878	90	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	24878	91	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24878	92	State	State	NNP
18637	24878	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24878	94	,	,	,
18637	24878	95	Entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	24878	96	to	to	IN
18637	24878	97	Privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	24878	98	of	of	IN
18637	24878	99	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	24878	100	in	in	IN
18637	24878	101	other	other	JJ
18637	24878	102	States	state	NNS
18637	24878	103	.	.	.
18637	24879	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24879	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24879	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24879	4	Comity	Comity	NNP
18637	24879	5	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	24879	6	.	.	.
18637	24880	1	Citizenship	Citizenship	NNP
18637	24880	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24880	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24880	4	see	see	VBP
18637	24880	5	also	also	RB
18637	24880	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24880	7	Comity	Comity	NNP
18637	24880	8	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	24880	9	;	;	:
18637	24880	10	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	24880	11	;	;	:
18637	24880	12	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24880	13	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24880	14	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24880	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24880	16	;	;	:
18637	24880	17	President	President	NNP
18637	24880	18	:	:	:
18637	24880	19	Powers	power	NNS
18637	24880	20	;	;	:
18637	24880	21	Privileges	Privileges	NNPS
18637	24880	22	and	and	CC
18637	24880	23	Immunities	Immunities	NNPS
18637	24880	24	of	of	IN
18637	24880	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	24880	26	and	and	CC
18637	24880	27	State	State	NNP
18637	24880	28	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	24880	29	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24880	30	:	:	:
18637	24880	31	Defined	define	VBN
18637	24880	32	;	;	:
18637	24880	33	how	how	WRB
18637	24880	34	acquired	acquire	VBN
18637	24880	35	,	,	,
18637	24880	36	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	24880	37	,	,	,
18637	24880	38	254	254	CD
18637	24880	39	-	-	SYM
18637	24880	40	256	256	CD
18637	24880	41	,	,	,
18637	24880	42	312	312	CD
18637	24880	43	,	,	,
18637	24880	44	699	699	CD
18637	24880	45	,	,	,
18637	24880	46	963	963	CD
18637	24880	47	-	-	SYM
18637	24880	48	965	965	CD
18637	24880	49	How	how	WRB
18637	24880	50	lost	lost	JJ
18637	24880	51	;	;	:
18637	24880	52	expatriation	expatriation	NN
18637	24880	53	,	,	,
18637	24880	54	etc	etc	FW
18637	24880	55	.	.	.
18637	24880	56	,	,	,
18637	24880	57	256	256	CD
18637	24880	58	-	-	SYM
18637	24880	59	259	259	CD
18637	24880	60	of	of	IN
18637	24880	61	Inhabitants	Inhabitants	NNPS
18637	24880	62	of	of	IN
18637	24880	63	territories	territory	NNS
18637	24880	64	,	,	,
18637	24880	65	254	254	CD
18637	24880	66	-	-	SYM
18637	24880	67	255	255	CD
18637	24880	68	,	,	,
18637	24880	69	963	963	CD
18637	24880	70	-	-	HYPH
18637	24880	71	964	964	CD
18637	24880	72	Jus	Jus	NNP
18637	24880	73	sanguinis	sanguinis	NN
18637	24880	74	,	,	,
18637	24880	75	as	as	IN
18637	24880	76	basis	basis	NN
18637	24880	77	of	of	IN
18637	24880	78	,	,	,
18637	24880	79	254	254	CD
18637	24880	80	-	-	HYPH
18637	24880	81	255	255	CD
18637	24880	82	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	24880	83	of	of	IN
18637	24880	84	naturalized	naturalized	JJ
18637	24880	85	persons	person	NNS
18637	24880	86	,	,	,
18637	24880	87	257	257	CD
18637	24880	88	-	-	SYM
18637	24880	89	258	258	CD
18637	24880	90	Who	who	WP
18637	24880	91	are	be	VBP
18637	24880	92	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	24880	93	,	,	,
18637	24880	94	254	254	CD
18637	24880	95	-	-	SYM
18637	24880	96	255	255	CD
18637	24880	97	,	,	,
18637	24880	98	312	312	CD
18637	24880	99	,	,	,
18637	24880	100	963	963	CD
18637	24880	101	-	-	HYPH
18637	24880	102	965	965	CD
18637	24880	103	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	24880	104	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	24880	105	,	,	,
18637	24880	106	infraction	infraction	NN
18637	24880	107	by	by	IN
18637	24880	108	individuals	individual	NNS
18637	24880	109	,	,	,
18637	24880	110	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24880	111	can	can	MD
18637	24880	112	not	not	RB
18637	24880	113	punish	punish	VB
18637	24880	114	,	,	,
18637	24880	115	1175	1175	CD
18637	24880	116	-	-	SYM
18637	24880	117	1176	1176	CD
18637	24880	118	Claims	claim	NNS
18637	24880	119	against	against	IN
18637	24880	120	United	United	NNP
18637	24880	121	States	States	NNP
18637	24880	122	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24880	123	_	_	NNP
18637	24880	124	see	see	VBP
18637	24880	125	also	also	RB
18637	24880	126	_	_	NNP
18637	24880	127	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24880	128	Debt	Debt	NNP
18637	24880	129	of	of	IN
18637	24880	130	the	the	DT
18637	24880	131	United	United	NNP
18637	24880	132	States	States	NNP
18637	24880	133	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24880	134	:	:	:
18637	24880	135	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24880	136	,	,	,
18637	24880	137	powers	power	NNS
18637	24880	138	as	as	IN
18637	24880	139	to	to	IN
18637	24880	140	,	,	,
18637	24880	141	324	324	CD
18637	24880	142	for	for	IN
18637	24880	143	Emancipation	emancipation	NN
18637	24880	144	of	of	IN
18637	24880	145	slaves	slave	NNS
18637	24880	146	,	,	,
18637	24880	147	void	void	JJ
18637	24880	148	,	,	,
18637	24880	149	1174	1174	CD
18637	24880	150	Claims	claim	NNS
18637	24880	151	of	of	IN
18637	24880	152	United	United	NNP
18637	24880	153	States	States	NNP
18637	24880	154	,	,	,
18637	24880	155	powers	power	NNS
18637	24880	156	of	of	IN
18637	24880	157	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24880	158	as	as	IN
18637	24880	159	to	to	IN
18637	24880	160	,	,	,
18637	24880	161	311	311	CD
18637	24880	162	Clear	clear	JJ
18637	24880	163	and	and	CC
18637	24880	164	Present	Present	NNP
18637	24880	165	Danger	Danger	NNP
18637	24880	166	.	.	.
18637	24881	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24881	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24881	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24881	4	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	24881	5	of	of	IN
18637	24881	6	Religion	Religion	NNP
18637	24881	7	,	,	,
18637	24881	8	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	24881	9	,	,	,
18637	24881	10	Press	Press	NNP
18637	24881	11	,	,	,
18637	24881	12	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
18637	24881	13	.	.	.
18637	24882	1	Coal	coal	NN
18637	24882	2	:	:	:
18637	24882	3	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24882	4	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24882	5	as	as	IN
18637	24882	6	to	to	IN
18637	24882	7	,	,	,
18637	24882	8	153	153	CD
18637	24882	9	-	-	SYM
18637	24882	10	154	154	CD
18637	24882	11	Prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	24882	12	of	of	IN
18637	24882	13	mining	mining	NN
18637	24882	14	,	,	,
18637	24882	15	under	under	IN
18637	24882	16	city	city	NN
18637	24882	17	streets	street	NNS
18637	24882	18	,	,	,
18637	24882	19	etc	etc	FW
18637	24882	20	.	.	.
18637	24882	21	,	,	,
18637	24882	22	1026	1026	CD
18637	24882	23	Coins	Coins	NNPS
18637	24882	24	and	and	CC
18637	24882	25	Coinage	Coinage	NNP
18637	24882	26	.	.	.
18637	24883	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24883	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24883	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24883	4	Counterfeiting	Counterfeiting	NNP
18637	24883	5	;	;	:
18637	24883	6	Money	money	NN
18637	24883	7	.	.	.
18637	24884	1	Comity	Comity	NNP
18637	24884	2	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	24884	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24884	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24884	5	See	See	NNP
18637	24884	6	also	also	RB
18637	24884	7	_	_	NNP
18637	24884	8	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	24884	9	:	:	:
18637	24884	10	State	state	NN
18637	24884	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24884	12	:	:	:
18637	24884	13	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	24884	14	not	not	RB
18637	24884	15	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	24884	16	to	to	IN
18637	24884	17	benefits	benefit	NNS
18637	24884	18	of	of	IN
18637	24884	19	,	,	,
18637	24884	20	688	688	CD
18637	24884	21	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	22	689	689	CD
18637	24884	23	Privileges	Privileges	NNPS
18637	24884	24	and	and	CC
18637	24884	25	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	24884	26	of	of	IN
18637	24884	27	State	State	NNP
18637	24884	28	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	24884	29	,	,	,
18637	24884	30	scope	scope	NN
18637	24884	31	,	,	,
18637	24884	32	689	689	CD
18637	24884	33	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	34	693	693	CD
18637	24884	35	Sources	Sources	NNPS
18637	24884	36	,	,	,
18637	24884	37	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	24884	38	of	of	IN
18637	24884	39	,	,	,
18637	24884	40	how	how	WRB
18637	24884	41	implemented	implement	VBN
18637	24884	42	,	,	,
18637	24884	43	686	686	CD
18637	24884	44	-	-	HYPH
18637	24884	45	688	688	CD
18637	24884	46	State	State	NNP
18637	24884	47	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	24884	48	,	,	,
18637	24884	49	scope	scope	NN
18637	24884	50	of	of	IN
18637	24884	51	,	,	,
18637	24884	52	688	688	CD
18637	24884	53	State	state	NN
18637	24884	54	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	24884	55	as	as	IN
18637	24884	56	to	to	IN
18637	24884	57	nonresidents	nonresident	NNS
18637	24884	58	,	,	,
18637	24884	59	limits	limit	NNS
18637	24884	60	,	,	,
18637	24884	61	691	691	CD
18637	24884	62	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	63	693	693	CD
18637	24884	64	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24884	65	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24884	66	_	_	NNP
18637	24884	67	see	see	VBP
18637	24884	68	also	also	RB
18637	24884	69	_	_	NNP
18637	24884	70	Carriers	Carriers	NNPS
18637	24884	71	;	;	:
18637	24884	72	Child	Child	NNP
18637	24884	73	Labor	labor	NN
18637	24884	74	;	;	:
18637	24884	75	Coal	Coal	NNP
18637	24884	76	;	;	:
18637	24884	77	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	24884	78	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24884	79	;	;	:
18637	24884	80	Hydroelectric	Hydroelectric	NNP
18637	24884	81	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24884	82	;	;	:
18637	24884	83	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	24884	84	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24884	85	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24884	86	;	;	:
18637	24884	87	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	24884	88	;	;	,
18637	24884	89	Original	Original	NNP
18637	24884	90	Package	Package	NNP
18637	24884	91	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	24884	92	;	;	:
18637	24884	93	Police	police	NN
18637	24884	94	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24884	95	;	;	:
18637	24884	96	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	24884	97	;	;	:
18637	24884	98	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24884	99	;	;	:
18637	24884	100	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	24884	101	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24884	102	:	:	:
18637	24884	103	Commerce	commerce	NN
18637	24884	104	clause	clause	NN
18637	24884	105	of	of	IN
18637	24884	106	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	24884	107	as	as	IN
18637	24884	108	source	source	NN
18637	24884	109	of	of	IN
18637	24884	110	National	national	JJ
18637	24884	111	power	power	NN
18637	24884	112	,	,	,
18637	24884	113	118	118	CD
18637	24884	114	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	115	173	173	CD
18637	24884	116	,	,	,
18637	24884	117	214	214	CD
18637	24884	118	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	119	215	215	CD
18637	24884	120	,	,	,
18637	24884	121	217	217	CD
18637	24884	122	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	123	220	220	CD
18637	24884	124	,	,	,
18637	24884	125	246	246	CD
18637	24884	126	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	127	253	253	CD
18637	24884	128	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24884	129	clause	clause	NN
18637	24884	130	of	of	IN
18637	24884	131	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	24884	132	,	,	,
18637	24884	133	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	24884	134	,	,	,
18637	24884	135	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	24884	136	of	of	IN
18637	24884	137	terms	term	NNS
18637	24884	138	,	,	,
18637	24884	139	118	118	CD
18637	24884	140	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	141	126	126	CD
18637	24884	142	Concurrent	Concurrent	NNP
18637	24884	143	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24884	144	-	-	HYPH
18637	24884	145	State	State	NNP
18637	24884	146	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	24884	147	as	as	IN
18637	24884	148	to	to	IN
18637	24884	149	,	,	,
18637	24884	150	246	246	CD
18637	24884	151	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	152	252	252	CD
18637	24884	153	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	24884	154	,	,	,
18637	24884	155	powers	power	NNS
18637	24884	156	of	of	IN
18637	24884	157	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24884	158	as	as	IN
18637	24884	159	to	to	IN
18637	24884	160	interstate	interstate	NN
18637	24884	161	and	and	CC
18637	24884	162	,	,	,
18637	24884	163	compared	compare	VBN
18637	24884	164	,	,	,
18637	24884	165	123	123	CD
18637	24884	166	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	167	125	125	CD
18637	24884	168	,	,	,
18637	24884	169	162	162	CD
18637	24884	170	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	171	163	163	CD
18637	24884	172	,	,	,
18637	24884	173	165	165	CD
18637	24884	174	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	175	167	167	CD
18637	24884	176	Grain	Grain	NNP
18637	24884	177	futures	future	NNS
18637	24884	178	,	,	,
18637	24884	179	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24884	180	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24884	181	of	of	IN
18637	24884	182	,	,	,
18637	24884	183	149	149	CD
18637	24884	184	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	185	150	150	CD
18637	24884	186	with	with	IN
18637	24884	187	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	24884	188	tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	24884	189	,	,	,
18637	24884	190	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	24884	191	power	power	NN
18637	24884	192	as	as	IN
18637	24884	193	to	to	IN
18637	24884	194	,	,	,
18637	24884	195	252	252	CD
18637	24884	196	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	197	253	253	CD
18637	24884	198	Instruments	Instruments	NNPS
18637	24884	199	of	of	IN
18637	24884	200	,	,	,
18637	24884	201	powers	power	NNS
18637	24884	202	of	of	IN
18637	24884	203	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24884	204	as	as	IN
18637	24884	205	to	to	IN
18637	24884	206	,	,	,
18637	24884	207	125	125	CD
18637	24884	208	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	209	126	126	CD
18637	24884	210	,	,	,
18637	24884	211	139	139	CD
18637	24884	212	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	24884	213	,	,	,
18637	24884	214	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	24884	215	of	of	IN
18637	24884	216	,	,	,
18637	24884	217	powers	power	NNS
18637	24884	218	of	of	IN
18637	24884	219	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24884	220	as	as	IN
18637	24884	221	to	to	IN
18637	24884	222	,	,	,
18637	24884	223	144	144	CD
18637	24884	224	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	225	150	150	CD
18637	24884	226	Regulations	Regulations	NNPS
18637	24884	227	,	,	,
18637	24884	228	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24884	229	,	,	,
18637	24884	230	favoring	favor	VBG
18637	24884	231	certain	certain	JJ
18637	24884	232	ports	port	NNS
18637	24884	233	,	,	,
18637	24884	234	322	322	CD
18637	24884	235	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	236	323	323	CD
18637	24884	237	Reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	24884	238	powers	power	NNS
18637	24884	239	of	of	IN
18637	24884	240	States	state	NNS
18637	24884	241	as	as	IN
18637	24884	242	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	24884	243	on	on	IN
18637	24884	244	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24884	245	powers	power	NNS
18637	24884	246	as	as	IN
18637	24884	247	to	to	IN
18637	24884	248	,	,	,
18637	24884	249	121	121	CD
18637	24884	250	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	251	122	122	CD
18637	24884	252	,	,	,
18637	24884	253	917	917	CD
18637	24884	254	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	255	921	921	CD
18637	24884	256	State	state	NN
18637	24884	257	power	power	NN
18637	24884	258	to	to	TO
18637	24884	259	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	24884	260	interstate	interstate	NN
18637	24884	261	,	,	,
18637	24884	262	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24884	263	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	24884	264	,	,	,
18637	24884	265	177	177	CD
18637	24884	266	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	267	214	214	CD
18637	24884	268	,	,	,
18637	24884	269	224	224	CD
18637	24884	270	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	271	225	225	CD
18637	24884	272	,	,	,
18637	24884	273	249	249	CD
18637	24884	274	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	275	252	252	CD
18637	24884	276	,	,	,
18637	24884	277	968	968	CD
18637	24884	278	,	,	,
18637	24884	279	1027	1027	CD
18637	24884	280	Stockyards	Stockyards	NNP
18637	24884	281	,	,	,
18637	24884	282	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24884	283	supervision	supervision	NN
18637	24884	284	of	of	IN
18637	24884	285	,	,	,
18637	24884	286	149	149	CD
18637	24884	287	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24884	288	Merchants	Merchants	NNPS
18637	24884	289	,	,	,
18637	24884	290	State	state	NN
18637	24884	291	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24884	292	of	of	IN
18637	24884	293	,	,	,
18637	24884	294	235	235	CD
18637	24884	295	Commodity	Commodity	NNP
18637	24884	296	and	and	CC
18637	24884	297	Security	Security	NNP
18637	24884	298	Exchanges	Exchanges	NNP
18637	24884	299	,	,	,
18637	24884	300	State	state	NN
18637	24884	301	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24884	302	of	of	IN
18637	24884	303	,	,	,
18637	24884	304	250	250	CD
18637	24884	305	,	,	,
18637	24884	306	1019	1019	CD
18637	24884	307	Common	Common	NNP
18637	24884	308	Law	Law	NNP
18637	24884	309	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24884	310	_	_	NNP
18637	24884	311	see	see	VBP
18637	24884	312	also	also	RB
18637	24884	313	_	_	NNP
18637	24884	314	Juries	Juries	NNP
18637	24884	315	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24884	316	:	:	:
18637	24884	317	No	no	DT
18637	24884	318	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24884	319	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	24884	320	under	under	IN
18637	24884	321	,	,	,
18637	24884	322	877	877	CD
18637	24884	323	Communication	communication	NN
18637	24884	324	,	,	,
18637	24884	325	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	24884	326	of	of	IN
18637	24884	327	,	,	,
18637	24884	328	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24884	329	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24884	330	,	,	,
18637	24884	331	138	138	CD
18637	24884	332	-	-	SYM
18637	24884	333	139	139	CD
18637	24884	334	Communists	Communists	NNPS
18637	24884	335	,	,	,
18637	24884	336	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	24884	337	of	of	IN
18637	24884	338	,	,	,
18637	24884	339	in	in	IN
18637	24884	340	relation	relation	NN
18637	24884	341	to	to	IN
18637	24884	342	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	24884	343	of	of	IN
18637	24884	344	speech	speech	NN
18637	24884	345	and	and	CC
18637	24884	346	press	press	NN
18637	24884	347	,	,	,
18637	24884	348	795	795	CD
18637	24884	349	-	-	HYPH
18637	24884	350	802	802	CD
18637	24884	351	Compacts	compact	NNS
18637	24884	352	between	between	IN
18637	24884	353	States	States	NNP
18637	24884	354	.	.	.
18637	24885	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24885	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24885	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24885	4	States	States	NNP
18637	24885	5	:	:	:
18637	24885	6	Agreement	agreement	NN
18637	24885	7	with	with	IN
18637	24885	8	other	other	JJ
18637	24885	9	States	state	NNS
18637	24885	10	.	.	.
18637	24886	1	Confederations	confederation	NNS
18637	24886	2	,	,	,
18637	24886	3	States	States	NNPS
18637	24886	4	not	not	RB
18637	24886	5	to	to	TO
18637	24886	6	enter	enter	VB
18637	24886	7	into	into	IN
18637	24886	8	,	,	,
18637	24886	9	325	325	CD
18637	24886	10	Confessions	Confessions	NNPS
18637	24886	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24886	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24886	13	see	see	VBP
18637	24886	14	also	also	RB
18637	24886	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24886	16	Self	Self	NNP
18637	24886	17	-	-	HYPH
18637	24886	18	Incrimination	Incrimination	NNP
18637	24886	19	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24886	20	:	:	:
18637	24886	21	Forced	force	VBN
18637	24886	22	,	,	,
18637	24886	23	in	in	IN
18637	24886	24	State	state	NN
18637	24886	25	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	24886	26	trials	trial	NNS
18637	24886	27	,	,	,
18637	24886	28	effect	effect	NN
18637	24886	29	,	,	,
18637	24886	30	1111	1111	CD
18637	24886	31	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	32	1121	1121	CD
18637	24886	33	Confrontation	confrontation	NN
18637	24886	34	:	:	:
18637	24886	35	Right	right	RB
18637	24886	36	of	of	IN
18637	24886	37	,	,	,
18637	24886	38	in	in	IN
18637	24886	39	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24886	40	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	24886	41	trials	trial	NNS
18637	24886	42	,	,	,
18637	24886	43	884	884	CD
18637	24886	44	Right	right	RB
18637	24886	45	of	of	IN
18637	24886	46	,	,	,
18637	24886	47	presence	presence	NN
18637	24886	48	of	of	IN
18637	24886	49	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	24886	50	,	,	,
18637	24886	51	in	in	IN
18637	24886	52	State	state	NN
18637	24886	53	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	24886	54	trials	trial	NNS
18637	24886	55	,	,	,
18637	24886	56	1126	1126	CD
18637	24886	57	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	58	1130	1130	CD
18637	24886	59	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24886	60	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24886	61	_	_	NNP
18637	24886	62	see	see	VBP
18637	24886	63	also	also	RB
18637	24886	64	_	_	NNP
18637	24886	65	Contempt	Contempt	NNP
18637	24886	66	;	;	:
18637	24886	67	Elections	election	NNS
18637	24886	68	;	;	:
18637	24886	69	House	House	NNP
18637	24886	70	of	of	IN
18637	24886	71	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	24886	72	;	;	:
18637	24886	73	Impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	24886	74	;	;	:
18637	24886	75	Investigations	investigation	NNS
18637	24886	76	;	;	:
18637	24886	77	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	24886	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24886	79	:	:	:
18637	24886	80	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	24886	81	Organization	Organization	NNP
18637	24886	82	;	;	:
18637	24886	83	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	24886	84	Process	Process	NNP
18637	24886	85	:	:	:
18637	24886	86	Bills	bill	NNS
18637	24886	87	,	,	,
18637	24886	88	how	how	WRB
18637	24886	89	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	24886	90	into	into	IN
18637	24886	91	law	law	NN
18637	24886	92	,	,	,
18637	24886	93	101	101	CD
18637	24886	94	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	95	103	103	CD
18637	24886	96	Concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	24886	97	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	24886	98	,	,	,
18637	24886	99	uses	use	NNS
18637	24886	100	,	,	,
18637	24886	101	104	104	CD
18637	24886	102	Journal	Journal	NNP
18637	24886	103	of	of	IN
18637	24886	104	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	24886	105	,	,	,
18637	24886	106	contents	content	NNS
18637	24886	107	,	,	,
18637	24886	108	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	24886	109	,	,	,
18637	24886	110	etc	etc	FW
18637	24886	111	.	.	.
18637	24886	112	,	,	,
18637	24886	113	95	95	CD
18637	24886	114	,	,	,
18637	24886	115	98	98	CD
18637	24886	116	Representatives	representative	NNS
18637	24886	117	,	,	,
18637	24886	118	choice	choice	NN
18637	24886	119	of	of	IN
18637	24886	120	Speaker	Speaker	NNP
18637	24886	121	,	,	,
18637	24886	122	officers	officer	NNS
18637	24886	123	,	,	,
18637	24886	124	90	90	CD
18637	24886	125	Resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	24886	126	,	,	,
18637	24886	127	etc	etc	FW
18637	24886	128	.	.	FW
18637	24886	129	,	,	,
18637	24886	130	how	how	WRB
18637	24886	131	made	make	VBN
18637	24886	132	effective	effective	JJ
18637	24886	133	,	,	,
18637	24886	134	status	status	NN
18637	24886	135	,	,	,
18637	24886	136	104	104	CD
18637	24886	137	-	-	HYPH
18637	24886	138	105	105	CD
18637	24886	139	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	24886	140	bills	bill	NNS
18637	24886	141	,	,	,
18637	24886	142	origination	origination	NN
18637	24886	143	,	,	,
18637	24886	144	amendment	amendment	NN
18637	24886	145	,	,	,
18637	24886	146	101	101	CD
18637	24886	147	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	148	102	102	CD
18637	24886	149	Rules	rule	NNS
18637	24886	150	of	of	IN
18637	24886	151	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	24886	152	,	,	,
18637	24886	153	determination	determination	NN
18637	24886	154	,	,	,
18637	24886	155	95	95	CD
18637	24886	156	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	157	97	97	CD
18637	24886	158	Yea	yea	NN
18637	24886	159	and	and	CC
18637	24886	160	Nay	Nay	NNP
18637	24886	161	votes	vote	NNS
18637	24886	162	,	,	,
18637	24886	163	entry	entry	NN
18637	24886	164	into	into	IN
18637	24886	165	journal	journal	NNP
18637	24886	166	,	,	,
18637	24886	167	95	95	CD
18637	24886	168	,	,	,
18637	24886	169	98	98	CD
18637	24886	170	,	,	,
18637	24886	171	102	102	CD
18637	24886	172	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	24886	173	direction	direction	NN
18637	24886	174	,	,	,
18637	24886	175	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	24886	176	from	from	IN
18637	24886	177	,	,	,
18637	24886	178	500	500	CD
18637	24886	179	Members	member	NNS
18637	24886	180	of	of	IN
18637	24886	181	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	24886	182	or	or	CC
18637	24886	183	House	House	NNP
18637	24886	184	:	:	:
18637	24886	185	Attendance	attendance	NN
18637	24886	186	,	,	,
18637	24886	187	compulsion	compulsion	NN
18637	24886	188	of	of	IN
18637	24886	189	,	,	,
18637	24886	190	95	95	CD
18637	24886	191	Beginning	beginning	NN
18637	24886	192	of	of	IN
18637	24886	193	term	term	NN
18637	24886	194	,	,	,
18637	24886	195	1225	1225	CD
18637	24886	196	Compensation	compensation	NN
18637	24886	197	for	for	IN
18637	24886	198	services	service	NNS
18637	24886	199	before	before	IN
18637	24886	200	departments	department	NNS
18637	24886	201	,	,	,
18637	24886	202	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	24886	203	,	,	,
18637	24886	204	97	97	CD
18637	24886	205	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	206	98	98	CD
18637	24886	207	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	24886	208	,	,	,
18637	24886	209	how	how	WRB
18637	24886	210	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	24886	211	;	;	:
18637	24886	212	when	when	WRB
18637	24886	213	begins	begin	VBZ
18637	24886	214	,	,	,
18637	24886	215	99	99	CD
18637	24886	216	Disorderly	disorderly	JJ
18637	24886	217	behavior	behavior	NN
18637	24886	218	,	,	,
18637	24886	219	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	24886	220	,	,	,
18637	24886	221	95	95	CD
18637	24886	222	Election	election	NN
18637	24886	223	of	of	IN
18637	24886	224	,	,	,
18637	24886	225	qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	24886	226	,	,	,
18637	24886	227	each	each	DT
18637	24886	228	House	House	NNP
18637	24886	229	to	to	TO
18637	24886	230	judge	judge	VB
18637	24886	231	,	,	,
18637	24886	232	95	95	CD
18637	24886	233	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	234	96	96	CD
18637	24886	235	Expulsion	Expulsion	NNP
18637	24886	236	,	,	,
18637	24886	237	95	95	CD
18637	24886	238	,	,	,
18637	24886	239	97	97	CD
18637	24886	240	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	241	98	98	CD
18637	24886	242	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	24886	243	from	from	IN
18637	24886	244	arrest	arrest	NN
18637	24886	245	,	,	,
18637	24886	246	libel	libel	NN
18637	24886	247	suits	suit	NNS
18637	24886	248	,	,	,
18637	24886	249	limits	limit	NNS
18637	24886	250	,	,	,
18637	24886	251	99	99	CD
18637	24886	252	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	253	100	100	CD
18637	24886	254	not	not	RB
18637	24886	255	Impeachable	impeachable	JJ
18637	24886	256	,	,	,
18637	24886	257	500	500	CD
18637	24886	258	Incompatible	incompatible	JJ
18637	24886	259	offices	office	NNS
18637	24886	260	,	,	,
18637	24886	261	100	100	CD
18637	24886	262	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	263	101	101	CD
18637	24886	264	,	,	,
18637	24886	265	383	383	CD
18637	24886	266	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	24886	267	electors	elector	NNS
18637	24886	268	,	,	,
18637	24886	269	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	24886	270	as	as	IN
18637	24886	271	,	,	,
18637	24886	272	383	383	CD
18637	24886	273	Qualifications	Qualifications	NNPS
18637	24886	274	,	,	,
18637	24886	275	when	when	WRB
18637	24886	276	fulfilled	fulfil	VBN
18637	24886	277	,	,	,
18637	24886	278	enlargement	enlargement	NN
18637	24886	279	of	of	IN
18637	24886	280	,	,	,
18637	24886	281	87	87	CD
18637	24886	282	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	283	89	89	CD
18637	24886	284	,	,	,
18637	24886	285	91	91	CD
18637	24886	286	as	as	IN
18637	24886	287	Treaty	treaty	NN
18637	24886	288	negotiators	negotiator	NNS
18637	24886	289	,	,	,
18637	24886	290	eligibility	eligibility	NN
18637	24886	291	,	,	,
18637	24886	292	449	449	CD
18637	24886	293	Powers	power	NNS
18637	24886	294	in	in	IN
18637	24886	295	Relation	Relation	NNP
18637	24886	296	to	to	IN
18637	24886	297	Executive	executive	NN
18637	24886	298	:	:	:
18637	24886	299	Conduct	conduct	NN
18637	24886	300	of	of	IN
18637	24886	301	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	24886	302	relations	relation	NNS
18637	24886	303	,	,	,
18637	24886	304	cooperation	cooperation	NN
18637	24886	305	with	with	IN
18637	24886	306	President	President	NNP
18637	24886	307	in	in	IN
18637	24886	308	,	,	,
18637	24886	309	467	467	CD
18637	24886	310	-	-	HYPH
18637	24886	311	471	471	CD
18637	24886	312	Executive	executive	JJ
18637	24886	313	officers	officer	NNS
18637	24886	314	,	,	,
18637	24886	315	control	control	NN
18637	24886	316	of	of	IN
18637	24886	317	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	24886	318	of	of	IN
18637	24886	319	,	,	,
18637	24886	320	478	478	CD
18637	24886	321	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	322	480	480	CD
18637	24886	323	Sessions	session	NNS
18637	24886	324	:	:	:
18637	24886	325	Adjournment	adjournment	NN
18637	24886	326	by	by	IN
18637	24886	327	one	one	CD
18637	24886	328	House	House	NNP
18637	24886	329	,	,	,
18637	24886	330	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	24886	331	,	,	,
18637	24886	332	95	95	CD
18637	24886	333	Frequency	frequency	NN
18637	24886	334	;	;	:
18637	24886	335	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	24886	336	of	of	IN
18637	24886	337	,	,	,
18637	24886	338	1225	1225	CD
18637	24886	339	Quorum	Quorum	NNP
18637	24886	340	required	require	VBN
18637	24886	341	for	for	IN
18637	24886	342	,	,	,
18637	24886	343	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	24886	344	,	,	,
18637	24886	345	95	95	CD
18637	24886	346	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	347	96	96	CD
18637	24886	348	Conservation	conservation	NN
18637	24886	349	of	of	IN
18637	24886	350	Natural	Natural	NNP
18637	24886	351	Resources	Resources	NNPS
18637	24886	352	,	,	,
18637	24886	353	powers	power	NNS
18637	24886	354	of	of	IN
18637	24886	355	States	States	NNP
18637	24886	356	,	,	,
18637	24886	357	242	242	CD
18637	24886	358	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	359	246	246	CD
18637	24886	360	,	,	,
18637	24886	361	1025	1025	CD
18637	24886	362	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	363	1027	1027	CD
18637	24886	364	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	24886	365	of	of	IN
18637	24886	366	the	the	DT
18637	24886	367	United	United	NNP
18637	24886	368	States	States	NNP
18637	24886	369	:	:	:
18637	24886	370	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	24886	371	of	of	IN
18637	24886	372	,	,	,
18637	24886	373	process	process	NN
18637	24886	374	,	,	,
18637	24886	375	limits	limit	NNS
18637	24886	376	of	of	IN
18637	24886	377	power	power	NN
18637	24886	378	,	,	,
18637	24886	379	scope	scope	NN
18637	24886	380	for	for	IN
18637	24886	381	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	24886	382	review	review	NN
18637	24886	383	,	,	,
18637	24886	384	711	711	CD
18637	24886	385	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	386	715	715	CD
18637	24886	387	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
18637	24886	388	,	,	,
18637	24886	389	dates	date	NNS
18637	24886	390	of	of	IN
18637	24886	391	ratification	ratification	NN
18637	24886	392	of	of	IN
18637	24886	393	,	,	,
18637	24886	394	37	37	CD
18637	24886	395	-	-	HYPH
18637	24886	396	54	54	CD
18637	24886	397	Amendments	amendment	NNS
18637	24886	398	,	,	,
18637	24886	399	resolutions	resolution	NNS
18637	24886	400	proposing	propose	VBG
18637	24886	401	,	,	,
18637	24886	402	not	not	RB
18637	24886	403	submitted	submit	VBN
18637	24886	404	to	to	IN
18637	24886	405	President	President	NNP
18637	24886	406	,	,	,
18637	24886	407	105	105	CD
18637	24886	408	Doctrines	doctrine	NNS
18637	24886	409	of	of	IN
18637	24886	410	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	24886	411	of	of	IN
18637	24886	412	,	,	,
18637	24886	413	71	71	CD
18637	24886	414	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	415	81	81	CD
18637	24886	416	Preamble	preamble	NN
18637	24886	417	to	to	IN
18637	24886	418	,	,	,
18637	24886	419	19	19	CD
18637	24886	420	,	,	,
18637	24886	421	59	59	CD
18637	24886	422	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	423	60	60	CD
18637	24886	424	,	,	,
18637	24886	425	166	166	CD
18637	24886	426	Ratification	ratification	NN
18637	24886	427	of	of	IN
18637	24886	428	,	,	,
18637	24886	429	effective	effective	JJ
18637	24886	430	date	date	NN
18637	24886	431	,	,	,
18637	24886	432	etc	etc	FW
18637	24886	433	.	.	FW
18637	24886	434	,	,	,
18637	24886	435	743	743	CD
18637	24886	436	Ratification	Ratification	NNP
18637	24886	437	,	,	,
18637	24886	438	historical	historical	JJ
18637	24886	439	note	note	NN
18637	24886	440	on	on	IN
18637	24886	441	,	,	,
18637	24886	442	9	9	CD
18637	24886	443	-	-	SYM
18637	24886	444	15	15	CD
18637	24886	445	Consuls	consul	NNS
18637	24886	446	.	.	.
18637	24887	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24887	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24887	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24887	4	Ambassadors	Ambassadors	NNPS
18637	24887	5	.	.	.
18637	24888	1	Containers	Containers	NNP
18637	24888	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24888	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24888	4	see	see	VBP
18637	24888	5	also	also	RB
18637	24888	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24888	7	Fraud	Fraud	NNP
18637	24888	8	;	;	:
18637	24888	9	Original	original	JJ
18637	24888	10	Package	Package	NNP
18637	24888	11	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	24888	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24888	13	:	:	:
18637	24888	14	Regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24888	15	by	by	IN
18637	24888	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24888	17	,	,	,
18637	24888	18	1018	1018	CD
18637	24888	19	Contempt	Contempt	NNP
18637	24888	20	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24888	21	_	_	NNP
18637	24888	22	see	see	VBP
18637	24888	23	also	also	RB
18637	24888	24	_	_	NNP
18637	24888	25	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24888	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24888	27	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24888	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24888	29	;	;	:
18637	24888	30	Courts	court	NNS
18637	24888	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24888	32	State	State	NNP
18637	24888	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24888	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24888	35	:	:	:
18637	24888	36	of	of	IN
18637	24888	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24888	38	,	,	,
18637	24888	39	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	24888	40	,	,	,
18637	24888	41	85	85	CD
18637	24888	42	-	-	SYM
18637	24888	43	86	86	CD
18637	24888	44	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
18637	24888	45	,	,	,
18637	24888	46	civil	civil	JJ
18637	24888	47	,	,	,
18637	24888	48	distinguished	distinguished	JJ
18637	24888	49	,	,	,
18637	24888	50	521	521	CD
18637	24888	51	of	of	IN
18637	24888	52	State	State	NNP
18637	24888	53	court	court	NN
18637	24888	54	,	,	,
18637	24888	55	summary	summary	NN
18637	24888	56	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	24888	57	,	,	,
18637	24888	58	1129	1129	CD
18637	24888	59	-	-	SYM
18637	24888	60	1130	1130	CD
18637	24888	61	Contracts	contract	NNS
18637	24888	62	,	,	,
18637	24888	63	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	24888	64	by	by	IN
18637	24888	65	State	state	NN
18637	24888	66	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	24888	67	,	,	,
18637	24888	68	329	329	CD
18637	24888	69	-	-	SYM
18637	24888	70	362	362	CD
18637	24888	71	Convict	convict	NN
18637	24888	72	-	-	HYPH
18637	24888	73	Made	make	VBN
18637	24888	74	Goods	good	NNS
18637	24888	75	,	,	,
18637	24888	76	State	state	NN
18637	24888	77	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24888	78	of	of	IN
18637	24888	79	sale	sale	NN
18637	24888	80	of	of	IN
18637	24888	81	,	,	,
18637	24888	82	240	240	CD
18637	24888	83	Coolie	Coolie	NNP
18637	24888	84	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24888	85	System	System	NNP
18637	24888	86	.	.	.
18637	24889	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24889	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24889	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24889	4	Involuntary	Involuntary	NNP
18637	24889	5	Servitude	Servitude	NNP
18637	24889	6	.	.	.
18637	24890	1	Copyright	copyright	NN
18637	24890	2	:	:	:
18637	24890	3	Nature	nature	NN
18637	24890	4	,	,	,
18637	24890	5	scope	scope	NN
18637	24890	6	of	of	IN
18637	24890	7	right	right	JJ
18637	24890	8	secured	secure	VBN
18637	24890	9	,	,	,
18637	24890	10	274	274	CD
18637	24890	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	24890	12	276	276	CD
18637	24890	13	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	24890	14	of	of	IN
18637	24890	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24890	16	as	as	IN
18637	24890	17	to	to	IN
18637	24890	18	,	,	,
18637	24890	19	271	271	CD
18637	24890	20	,	,	,
18637	24890	21	275	275	CD
18637	24890	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	24890	23	276	276	CD
18637	24890	24	Royalties	royalty	NNS
18637	24890	25	from	from	IN
18637	24890	26	,	,	,
18637	24890	27	State	state	NN
18637	24890	28	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24890	29	of	of	IN
18637	24890	30	,	,	,
18637	24890	31	734	734	CD
18637	24890	32	State	State	NNP
18637	24890	33	powers	power	NNS
18637	24890	34	as	as	IN
18637	24890	35	to	to	IN
18637	24890	36	,	,	,
18637	24890	37	276	276	CD
18637	24890	38	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	24890	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24890	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24890	41	see	see	VBP
18637	24890	42	also	also	RB
18637	24890	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24890	44	Comity	Comity	NNP
18637	24890	45	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	24890	46	;	;	:
18637	24890	47	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24890	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24890	49	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24890	50	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24890	51	;	;	:
18637	24890	52	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24890	53	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24890	54	:	:	:
18637	24890	55	Charters	charter	NNS
18637	24890	56	,	,	,
18637	24890	57	termination	termination	NN
18637	24890	58	by	by	IN
18637	24890	59	States	state	NNS
18637	24890	60	,	,	,
18637	24890	61	1016	1016	CD
18637	24890	62	Charters	charter	NNS
18637	24890	63	,	,	,
18637	24890	64	when	when	WRB
18637	24890	65	contracts	contract	VBZ
18637	24890	66	not	not	RB
18637	24890	67	to	to	TO
18637	24890	68	be	be	VB
18637	24890	69	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	24890	70	,	,	,
18637	24890	71	336	336	CD
18637	24890	72	-	-	SYM
18637	24890	73	339	339	CD
18637	24890	74	,	,	,
18637	24890	75	343	343	CD
18637	24890	76	-	-	SYM
18637	24890	77	352	352	CD
18637	24890	78	Dissolved	dissolve	VBN
18637	24890	79	by	by	IN
18637	24890	80	State	state	NN
18637	24890	81	,	,	,
18637	24890	82	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
18637	24890	83	for	for	IN
18637	24890	84	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	24890	85	,	,	,
18637	24890	86	263	263	CD
18637	24890	87	Due	due	JJ
18637	24890	88	process	process	NN
18637	24890	89	of	of	IN
18637	24890	90	law	law	NN
18637	24890	91	,	,	,
18637	24890	92	protected	protect	VBN
18637	24890	93	by	by	IN
18637	24890	94	,	,	,
18637	24890	95	981	981	CD
18637	24890	96	,	,	,
18637	24890	97	1016	1016	CD
18637	24890	98	Equal	equal	JJ
18637	24890	99	protection	protection	NN
18637	24890	100	of	of	IN
18637	24890	101	the	the	DT
18637	24890	102	laws	law	NNS
18637	24890	103	,	,	,
18637	24890	104	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	24890	105	to	to	IN
18637	24890	106	,	,	,
18637	24890	107	exceptions	exception	NNS
18637	24890	108	,	,	,
18637	24890	109	1142	1142	CD
18637	24890	110	-	-	SYM
18637	24890	111	1144	1144	CD
18637	24890	112	,	,	,
18637	24890	113	1146	1146	CD
18637	24890	114	-	-	SYM
18637	24890	115	1147	1147	CD
18637	24890	116	,	,	,
18637	24890	117	1149	1149	CD
18637	24890	118	-	-	SYM
18637	24890	119	1150	1150	CD
18637	24890	120	,	,	,
18637	24890	121	1152	1152	CD
18637	24890	122	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24890	123	,	,	,
18637	24890	124	liability	liability	NN
18637	24890	125	for	for	IN
18637	24890	126	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
18637	24890	127	acts	act	NNS
18637	24890	128	,	,	,
18637	24890	129	586	586	CD
18637	24890	130	-	-	SYM
18637	24890	131	587	587	CD
18637	24890	132	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24890	133	,	,	,
18637	24890	134	powers	power	NNS
18637	24890	135	of	of	IN
18637	24890	136	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24890	137	as	as	IN
18637	24890	138	to	to	IN
18637	24890	139	,	,	,
18637	24890	140	267	267	CD
18637	24890	141	,	,	,
18637	24890	142	309	309	CD
18637	24890	143	-	-	HYPH
18637	24890	144	310	310	CD
18637	24890	145	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24890	146	,	,	,
18637	24890	147	suability	suability	NN
18637	24890	148	of	of	IN
18637	24890	149	,	,	,
18637	24890	150	590	590	CD
18637	24890	151	-	-	SYM
18637	24890	152	591	591	CD
18637	24890	153	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24890	154	,	,	,
18637	24890	155	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24890	156	by	by	IN
18637	24890	157	States	States	NNP
18637	24890	158	,	,	,
18637	24890	159	etc	etc	FW
18637	24890	160	.	.	FW
18637	24890	161	,	,	,
18637	24890	162	732	732	CD
18637	24890	163	-	-	SYM
18637	24890	164	734	734	CD
18637	24890	165	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	24890	166	,	,	,
18637	24890	167	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	24890	168	of	of	IN
18637	24890	169	agent	agent	NN
18637	24890	170	for	for	IN
18637	24890	171	service	service	NN
18637	24890	172	of	of	IN
18637	24890	173	process	process	NN
18637	24890	174	,	,	,
18637	24890	175	1074	1074	CD
18637	24890	176	,	,	,
18637	24890	177	1077	1077	CD
18637	24890	178	-	-	SYM
18637	24890	179	1080	1080	CD
18637	24890	180	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	24890	181	,	,	,
18637	24890	182	equal	equal	JJ
18637	24890	183	protection	protection	NN
18637	24890	184	clause	clause	NN
18637	24890	185	as	as	IN
18637	24890	186	limit	limit	NN
18637	24890	187	on	on	IN
18637	24890	188	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24890	189	of	of	IN
18637	24890	190	,	,	,
18637	24890	191	1149	1149	CD
18637	24890	192	-	-	SYM
18637	24890	193	1150	1150	CD
18637	24890	194	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	24890	195	,	,	,
18637	24890	196	right	right	JJ
18637	24890	197	to	to	TO
18637	24890	198	sue	sue	VB
18637	24890	199	in	in	IN
18637	24890	200	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24890	201	courts	court	NNS
18637	24890	202	,	,	,
18637	24890	203	638	638	CD
18637	24890	204	Foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	24890	205	,	,	,
18637	24890	206	State	State	NNP
18637	24890	207	control	control	NN
18637	24890	208	over	over	IN
18637	24890	209	admission	admission	NN
18637	24890	210	,	,	,
18637	24890	211	licensing	licensing	NN
18637	24890	212	,	,	,
18637	24890	213	operation	operation	NN
18637	24890	214	,	,	,
18637	24890	215	231	231	CD
18637	24890	216	-	-	SYM
18637	24890	217	232	232	CD
18637	24890	218	,	,	,
18637	24890	219	234	234	CD
18637	24890	220	,	,	,
18637	24890	221	249	249	CD
18637	24890	222	,	,	,
18637	24890	223	1009	1009	CD
18637	24890	224	,	,	,
18637	24890	225	1016	1016	CD
18637	24890	226	,	,	,
18637	24890	227	1021	1021	CD
18637	24890	228	-	-	SYM
18637	24890	229	1022	1022	CD
18637	24890	230	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	24890	231	,	,	,
18637	24890	232	suability	suability	NN
18637	24890	233	,	,	,
18637	24890	234	due	due	JJ
18637	24890	235	process	process	NN
18637	24890	236	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	24890	237	,	,	,
18637	24890	238	1075	1075	CD
18637	24890	239	-	-	SYM
18637	24890	240	1080	1080	CD
18637	24890	241	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	24890	242	of	of	IN
18637	24890	243	speech	speech	NN
18637	24890	244	and	and	CC
18637	24890	245	assembly	assembly	NN
18637	24890	246	,	,	,
18637	24890	247	not	not	RB
18637	24890	248	claimable	claimable	JJ
18637	24890	249	by	by	IN
18637	24890	250	,	,	,
18637	24890	251	809	809	CD
18637	24890	252	Privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	24890	253	and	and	CC
18637	24890	254	immunities	immunity	NNS
18637	24890	255	of	of	IN
18637	24890	256	United	United	NNP
18637	24890	257	States	States	NNP
18637	24890	258	,	,	,
18637	24890	259	State	State	NNP
18637	24890	260	,	,	,
18637	24890	261	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	24890	262	,	,	,
18637	24890	263	not	not	RB
18637	24890	264	eligible	eligible	JJ
18637	24890	265	to	to	IN
18637	24890	266	,	,	,
18637	24890	267	965	965	CD
18637	24890	268	Production	production	NN
18637	24890	269	of	of	IN
18637	24890	270	books	book	NNS
18637	24890	271	and	and	CC
18637	24890	272	papers	paper	NNS
18637	24890	273	in	in	IN
18637	24890	274	State	state	NN
18637	24890	275	investigations	investigation	NNS
18637	24890	276	,	,	,
18637	24890	277	1122	1122	CD
18637	24890	278	Publications	publication	NNS
18637	24890	279	supporting	support	VBG
18637	24890	280	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	24890	281	,	,	,
18637	24890	282	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	24890	283	on	on	RB
18637	24890	284	,	,	,
18637	24890	285	793	793	CD
18637	24890	286	Self	self	NN
18637	24890	287	-	-	HYPH
18637	24890	288	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	24890	289	,	,	,
18637	24890	290	not	not	RB
18637	24890	291	protected	protect	VBN
18637	24890	292	against	against	IN
18637	24890	293	,	,	,
18637	24890	294	826	826	CD
18637	24890	295	,	,	,
18637	24890	296	843	843	CD
18637	24890	297	Stockholders	Stockholders	NNPS
18637	24890	298	'	'	POS
18637	24890	299	derivative	derivative	JJ
18637	24890	300	actions	action	NNS
18637	24890	301	,	,	,
18637	24890	302	security	security	NN
18637	24890	303	for	for	IN
18637	24890	304	costs	cost	NNS
18637	24890	305	,	,	,
18637	24890	306	1089	1089	CD
18637	24890	307	-	-	SYM
18637	24890	308	1090	1090	CD
18637	24890	309	Counsel	Counsel	NNP
18637	24890	310	.	.	.
18637	24891	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24891	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24891	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24891	4	Attorneys	Attorneys	NNP
18637	24891	5	.	.	.
18637	24892	1	Counterfeiting	counterfeiting	NN
18637	24892	2	:	:	:
18637	24892	3	of	of	IN
18637	24892	4	Foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	24892	5	money	money	NN
18637	24892	6	,	,	,
18637	24892	7	power	power	NN
18637	24892	8	to	to	TO
18637	24892	9	punish	punish	VB
18637	24892	10	,	,	,
18637	24892	11	278	278	CD
18637	24892	12	Punishment	punishment	NN
18637	24892	13	,	,	,
18637	24892	14	powers	power	NNS
18637	24892	15	of	of	IN
18637	24892	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24892	17	,	,	,
18637	24892	18	States	States	NNP
18637	24892	19	,	,	,
18637	24892	20	265	265	CD
18637	24892	21	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	22	266	266	CD
18637	24892	23	,	,	,
18637	24892	24	278	278	CD
18637	24892	25	Court	Court	NNP
18637	24892	26	of	of	IN
18637	24892	27	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	24892	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24892	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24892	30	see	see	VBP
18637	24892	31	also	also	RB
18637	24892	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24892	33	Claims	Claims	NNPS
18637	24892	34	against	against	IN
18637	24892	35	United	United	NNP
18637	24892	36	States	States	NNP
18637	24892	37	;	;	:
18637	24892	38	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24892	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24892	40	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24892	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24892	42	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24892	43	:	:	:
18637	24892	44	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	24892	45	review	review	NN
18637	24892	46	of	of	IN
18637	24892	47	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	24892	48	,	,	,
18637	24892	49	status	status	NN
18637	24892	50	,	,	,
18637	24892	51	535	535	CD
18637	24892	52	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	53	536	536	CD
18637	24892	54	Jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24892	55	,	,	,
18637	24892	56	expansion	expansion	NN
18637	24892	57	as	as	IN
18637	24892	58	to	to	IN
18637	24892	59	adjudicated	adjudicated	JJ
18637	24892	60	claims	claim	NNS
18637	24892	61	,	,	,
18637	24892	62	311	311	CD
18637	24892	63	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24892	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24892	65	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24892	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24892	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24892	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24892	69	see	see	VB
18637	24892	70	also	also	RB
18637	24892	71	_	_	NNP
18637	24892	72	Boundaries	Boundaries	NNPS
18637	24892	73	of	of	IN
18637	24892	74	States	States	NNPS
18637	24892	75	;	;	:
18637	24892	76	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	24892	77	;	;	:
18637	24892	78	Habeas	Habeas	NNP
18637	24892	79	Corpus	Corpus	NNP
18637	24892	80	;	;	:
18637	24892	81	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	24892	82	;	;	:
18637	24892	83	Juries	jury	NNS
18637	24892	84	;	;	:
18637	24892	85	Labor	labor	NN
18637	24892	86	;	;	,
18637	24892	87	Political	Political	NNP
18637	24892	88	Questions	Questions	NNPS
18637	24892	89	;	;	:
18637	24892	90	Prizes	Prizes	NNPS
18637	24892	91	of	of	IN
18637	24892	92	War	War	NNP
18637	24892	93	;	;	:
18637	24892	94	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24892	95	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	24892	96	of	of	IN
18637	24892	97	the	the	DT
18637	24892	98	United	United	NNP
18637	24892	99	States	States	NNP
18637	24892	100	;	;	:
18637	24892	101	States	state	NNS
18637	24892	102	:	:	:
18637	24892	103	Courts	court	NNS
18637	24892	104	;	;	:
18637	24892	105	States	state	NNS
18637	24892	106	:	:	:
18637	24892	107	Officers	officer	NNS
18637	24892	108	;	;	:
18637	24892	109	States	state	NNS
18637	24892	110	:	:	:
18637	24892	111	Powers	power	NNS
18637	24892	112	;	;	:
18637	24892	113	States	state	NNS
18637	24892	114	:	:	:
18637	24892	115	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	24892	116	by	by	RB
18637	24892	117	and	and	CC
18637	24892	118	against	against	IN
18637	24892	119	;	;	:
18637	24892	120	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	24892	121	Court	Court	NNP
18637	24892	122	of	of	IN
18637	24892	123	the	the	DT
18637	24892	124	United	United	NNP
18637	24892	125	States	States	NNP
18637	24892	126	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24892	127	:	:	:
18637	24892	128	Admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	24892	129	and	and	CC
18637	24892	130	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	24892	131	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24892	132	;	;	:
18637	24892	133	scope	scope	NN
18637	24892	134	,	,	,
18637	24892	135	types	type	NNS
18637	24892	136	of	of	IN
18637	24892	137	cases	case	NNS
18637	24892	138	,	,	,
18637	24892	139	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	24892	140	in	in	IN
18637	24892	141	,	,	,
18637	24892	142	etc	etc	FW
18637	24892	143	.	.	FW
18637	24892	144	,	,	,
18637	24892	145	278	278	CD
18637	24892	146	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	147	279	279	CD
18637	24892	148	,	,	,
18637	24892	149	572	572	CD
18637	24892	150	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	151	583	583	CD
18637	24892	152	Advisory	advisory	JJ
18637	24892	153	opinions	opinion	NNS
18637	24892	154	not	not	RB
18637	24892	155	rendered	render	VBN
18637	24892	156	by	by	IN
18637	24892	157	,	,	,
18637	24892	158	549	549	CD
18637	24892	159	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	160	550	550	CD
18637	24892	161	Ancillary	ancillary	JJ
18637	24892	162	,	,	,
18637	24892	163	inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	24892	164	powers	power	NNS
18637	24892	165	,	,	,
18637	24892	166	511	511	CD
18637	24892	167	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	168	512	512	CD
18637	24892	169	,	,	,
18637	24892	170	515	515	CD
18637	24892	171	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	172	528	528	CD
18637	24892	173	Attorneys	Attorneys	NNPS
18637	24892	174	,	,	,
18637	24892	175	admission	admission	NN
18637	24892	176	,	,	,
18637	24892	177	disbarment	disbarment	NN
18637	24892	178	by	by	IN
18637	24892	179	,	,	,
18637	24892	180	527	527	CD
18637	24892	181	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	182	528	528	CD
18637	24892	183	Cases	case	NNS
18637	24892	184	and	and	CC
18637	24892	185	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	24892	186	before	before	RB
18637	24892	187	,	,	,
18637	24892	188	defined	define	VBN
18637	24892	189	,	,	,
18637	24892	190	attributes	attribute	NNS
18637	24892	191	of	of	IN
18637	24892	192	,	,	,
18637	24892	193	538	538	CD
18637	24892	194	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	195	553	553	CD
18637	24892	196	,	,	,
18637	24892	197	561	561	CD
18637	24892	198	,	,	,
18637	24892	199	585	585	CD
18637	24892	200	Cases	case	NNS
18637	24892	201	arising	arise	VBG
18637	24892	202	under	under	IN
18637	24892	203	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	24892	204	,	,	,
18637	24892	205	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	24892	206	,	,	,
18637	24892	207	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	24892	208	,	,	,
18637	24892	209	553	553	CD
18637	24892	210	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	211	570	570	CD
18637	24892	212	Citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	24892	213	for	for	IN
18637	24892	214	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	24892	215	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	24892	216	,	,	,
18637	24892	217	597	597	CD
18637	24892	218	,	,	,
18637	24892	219	599	599	CD
18637	24892	220	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	221	603	603	CD
18637	24892	222	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24892	223	,	,	,
18637	24892	224	powers	power	NNS
18637	24892	225	as	as	IN
18637	24892	226	to	to	IN
18637	24892	227	organization	organization	NN
18637	24892	228	,	,	,
18637	24892	229	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24892	230	of	of	IN
18637	24892	231	,	,	,
18637	24892	232	310	310	CD
18637	24892	233	,	,	,
18637	24892	234	525	525	CD
18637	24892	235	,	,	,
18637	24892	236	528	528	CD
18637	24892	237	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	238	537	537	CD
18637	24892	239	,	,	,
18637	24892	240	551	551	CD
18637	24892	241	,	,	,
18637	24892	242	574	574	CD
18637	24892	243	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	244	580	580	CD
18637	24892	245	,	,	,
18637	24892	246	582	582	CD
18637	24892	247	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	248	586	586	CD
18637	24892	249	,	,	,
18637	24892	250	591	591	CD
18637	24892	251	,	,	,
18637	24892	252	600	600	CD
18637	24892	253	,	,	,
18637	24892	254	603	603	CD
18637	24892	255	,	,	,
18637	24892	256	606	606	CD
18637	24892	257	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	258	608	608	CD
18637	24892	259	,	,	,
18637	24892	260	611	611	CD
18637	24892	261	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	262	624	624	CD
18637	24892	263	,	,	,
18637	24892	264	630	630	CD
18637	24892	265	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	266	632	632	CD
18637	24892	267	,	,	,
18637	24892	268	635	635	CD
18637	24892	269	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	270	636	636	CD
18637	24892	271	Consular	Consular	NNP
18637	24892	272	courts	court	NNS
18637	24892	273	,	,	,
18637	24892	274	533	533	CD
18637	24892	275	Consuls	consul	NNS
18637	24892	276	,	,	,
18637	24892	277	etc	etc	FW
18637	24892	278	.	.	NN
18637	24892	279	,	,	,
18637	24892	280	suable	suable	JJ
18637	24892	281	in	in	RP
18637	24892	282	,	,	,
18637	24892	283	571	571	CD
18637	24892	284	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	285	572	572	CD
18637	24892	286	Contempts	Contempts	NNPS
18637	24892	287	,	,	,
18637	24892	288	power	power	NN
18637	24892	289	to	to	TO
18637	24892	290	punish	punish	VB
18637	24892	291	,	,	,
18637	24892	292	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24892	293	by	by	IN
18637	24892	294	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24892	295	,	,	,
18637	24892	296	511	511	CD
18637	24892	297	,	,	,
18637	24892	298	515	515	CD
18637	24892	299	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	300	521	521	CD
18637	24892	301	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	24892	302	,	,	,
18637	24892	303	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	24892	304	for	for	IN
18637	24892	305	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	24892	306	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	24892	307	,	,	,
18637	24892	308	status	status	VBP
18637	24892	309	to	to	TO
18637	24892	310	sue	sue	VB
18637	24892	311	in	in	RP
18637	24892	312	,	,	,
18637	24892	313	568	568	CD
18637	24892	314	,	,	,
18637	24892	315	597	597	CD
18637	24892	316	,	,	,
18637	24892	317	601	601	CD
18637	24892	318	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	319	603	603	CD
18637	24892	320	,	,	,
18637	24892	321	638	638	CD
18637	24892	322	Declaratory	declaratory	JJ
18637	24892	323	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	24892	324	,	,	,
18637	24892	325	power	power	NN
18637	24892	326	to	to	TO
18637	24892	327	issue	issue	VB
18637	24892	328	,	,	,
18637	24892	329	validity	validity	NN
18637	24892	330	,	,	,
18637	24892	331	etc	etc	FW
18637	24892	332	.	.	.
18637	24892	333	,	,	,
18637	24892	334	513	513	CD
18637	24892	335	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	336	514	514	CD
18637	24892	337	,	,	,
18637	24892	338	551	551	CD
18637	24892	339	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	340	553	553	CD
18637	24892	341	District	District	NNP
18637	24892	342	of	of	IN
18637	24892	343	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	24892	344	residents	resident	NNS
18637	24892	345	,	,	,
18637	24892	346	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	24892	347	for	for	IN
18637	24892	348	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	24892	349	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	24892	350	,	,	,
18637	24892	351	599	599	CD
18637	24892	352	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	353	600	600	CD
18637	24892	354	in	in	IN
18637	24892	355	District	District	NNP
18637	24892	356	of	of	IN
18637	24892	357	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	24892	358	,	,	,
18637	24892	359	status	status	NN
18637	24892	360	,	,	,
18637	24892	361	powers	power	NNS
18637	24892	362	,	,	,
18637	24892	363	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24892	364	by	by	IN
18637	24892	365	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24892	366	,	,	,
18637	24892	367	304	304	CD
18637	24892	368	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	369	305	305	CD
18637	24892	370	,	,	,
18637	24892	371	522	522	CD
18637	24892	372	,	,	,
18637	24892	373	536	536	CD
18637	24892	374	-	-	HYPH
18637	24892	375	537	537	CD
18637	24892	376	Full	full	JJ
18637	24892	377	faith	faith	NN
18637	24892	378	and	and	CC
18637	24892	379	credit	credit	NN
18637	24892	380	clause	clause	NN
18637	24892	381	in	in	IN
18637	24892	382	,	,	,
18637	24892	383	684	684	CD
18637	24892	384	Immunity	immunity	NN
18637	24892	385	from	from	IN
18637	24892	386	suit	suit	NN
18637	24892	387	of	of	IN
18637	24892	388	United	United	NNP
18637	24892	389	States	States	NNP
18637	24892	390	,	,	,
18637	24892	391	States	States	NNP
18637	24892	392	,	,	,
18637	24892	393	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	24892	394	states	state	NNS
18637	24892	395	,	,	,
18637	24892	396	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	24892	397	,	,	,
18637	24892	398	etc	etc	FW
18637	24892	399	.	.	FW
18637	24892	400	,	,	,
18637	24892	401	585	585	CD
18637	24892	402	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	403	591	591	CD
18637	24892	404	,	,	,
18637	24892	405	609	609	CD
18637	24892	406	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	24892	407	tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	24892	408	,	,	,
18637	24892	409	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	24892	410	from	from	IN
18637	24892	411	suit	suit	NN
18637	24892	412	,	,	,
18637	24892	413	removal	removal	NN
18637	24892	414	of	of	IN
18637	24892	415	cases	case	NNS
18637	24892	416	,	,	,
18637	24892	417	591	591	CD
18637	24892	418	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	24892	419	tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	24892	420	,	,	,
18637	24892	421	not	not	RB
18637	24892	422	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	24892	423	state	state	NN
18637	24892	424	for	for	IN
18637	24892	425	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	24892	426	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	24892	427	,	,	,
18637	24892	428	431	431	CD
18637	24892	429	,	,	,
18637	24892	430	610	610	CD
18637	24892	431	Inferior	Inferior	NNP
18637	24892	432	,	,	,
18637	24892	433	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	24892	434	matters	matter	NNS
18637	24892	435	,	,	,
18637	24892	436	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24892	437	over	over	RB
18637	24892	438	,	,	,
18637	24892	439	623	623	CD
18637	24892	440	-	-	HYPH
18637	24892	441	624	624	CD
18637	24892	442	Inferior	Inferior	NNP
18637	24892	443	,	,	,
18637	24892	444	creation	creation	NN
18637	24892	445	,	,	,
18637	24892	446	abolition	abolition	NN
18637	24892	447	,	,	,
18637	24892	448	etc	etc	FW
18637	24892	449	.	.	FW
18637	24892	450	,	,	,
18637	24892	451	by	by	IN
18637	24892	452	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24892	453	,	,	,
18637	24892	454	277	277	CD
18637	24892	455	,	,	,
18637	24892	456	528	528	CD
18637	24892	457	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	458	530	530	CD
18637	24892	459	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	24892	460	and	and	CC
18637	24892	461	juries	jury	NNS
18637	24892	462	in	in	IN
18637	24892	463	,	,	,
18637	24892	464	functions	function	NNS
18637	24892	465	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	24892	466	,	,	,
18637	24892	467	directed	direct	VBN
18637	24892	468	verdicts	verdict	NNS
18637	24892	469	,	,	,
18637	24892	470	895	895	CD
18637	24892	471	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	472	897	897	CD
18637	24892	473	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	24892	474	review	review	NN
18637	24892	475	by	by	IN
18637	24892	476	,	,	,
18637	24892	477	origin	origin	NN
18637	24892	478	,	,	,
18637	24892	479	scope	scope	NN
18637	24892	480	,	,	,
18637	24892	481	limits	limit	NNS
18637	24892	482	,	,	,
18637	24892	483	etc	etc	FW
18637	24892	484	.	.	.
18637	24892	485	,	,	,
18637	24892	486	554	554	CD
18637	24892	487	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	488	566	566	CD
18637	24892	489	,	,	,
18637	24892	490	799	799	CD
18637	24892	491	Jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24892	492	concurrent	concurrent	NN
18637	24892	493	with	with	IN
18637	24892	494	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	24892	495	Court	Court	NNP
18637	24892	496	,	,	,
18637	24892	497	scope	scope	NN
18637	24892	498	,	,	,
18637	24892	499	613	613	CD
18637	24892	500	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	501	614	614	CD
18637	24892	502	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	24892	503	,	,	,
18637	24892	504	scope	scope	NN
18637	24892	505	,	,	,
18637	24892	506	525	525	CD
18637	24892	507	,	,	,
18637	24892	508	538	538	CD
18637	24892	509	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	510	635	635	CD
18637	24892	511	,	,	,
18637	24892	512	638	638	CD
18637	24892	513	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	24892	514	,	,	,
18637	24892	515	creation	creation	NN
18637	24892	516	,	,	,
18637	24892	517	etc	etc	FW
18637	24892	518	.	.	FW
18637	24892	519	,	,	,
18637	24892	520	by	by	IN
18637	24892	521	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24892	522	,	,	,
18637	24892	523	310	310	CD
18637	24892	524	,	,	,
18637	24892	525	533	533	CD
18637	24892	526	-	-	HYPH
18637	24892	527	537	537	CD
18637	24892	528	Nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	24892	529	functions	function	NNS
18637	24892	530	,	,	,
18637	24892	531	powers	power	NNS
18637	24892	532	of	of	IN
18637	24892	533	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24892	534	to	to	TO
18637	24892	535	vest	vest	VB
18637	24892	536	in	in	RB
18637	24892	537	,	,	,
18637	24892	538	533	533	CD
18637	24892	539	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	540	535	535	CD
18637	24892	541	,	,	,
18637	24892	542	537	537	CD
18637	24892	543	Power	power	NN
18637	24892	544	to	to	TO
18637	24892	545	render	render	VB
18637	24892	546	and	and	CC
18637	24892	547	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	24892	548	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	24892	549	,	,	,
18637	24892	550	595	595	CD
18637	24892	551	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	24892	552	use	use	NN
18637	24892	553	of	of	IN
18637	24892	554	,	,	,
18637	24892	555	to	to	TO
18637	24892	556	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	24892	557	laws	law	NNS
18637	24892	558	,	,	,
18637	24892	559	484	484	CD
18637	24892	560	-	-	CD
18637	24892	561	486	486	CD
18637	24892	562	Referees	Referees	NNPS
18637	24892	563	,	,	,
18637	24892	564	masters	master	NNS
18637	24892	565	,	,	,
18637	24892	566	special	special	JJ
18637	24892	567	aids	aids	NNP
18637	24892	568	,	,	,
18637	24892	569	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	24892	570	by	by	IN
18637	24892	571	,	,	,
18637	24892	572	527	527	CD
18637	24892	573	Rule	rule	NN
18637	24892	574	-	-	HYPH
18637	24892	575	making	make	VBG
18637	24892	576	power	power	NN
18637	24892	577	,	,	,
18637	24892	578	derivation	derivation	NN
18637	24892	579	,	,	,
18637	24892	580	limits	limit	NNS
18637	24892	581	,	,	,
18637	24892	582	process	process	NN
18637	24892	583	,	,	,
18637	24892	584	74	74	CD
18637	24892	585	,	,	,
18637	24892	586	525	525	CD
18637	24892	587	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	588	526	526	CD
18637	24892	589	of	of	IN
18637	24892	590	Specialized	Specialized	NNP
18637	24892	591	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24892	592	,	,	,
18637	24892	593	organization	organization	NN
18637	24892	594	,	,	,
18637	24892	595	powers	power	NNS
18637	24892	596	,	,	,
18637	24892	597	etc	etc	FW
18637	24892	598	.	.	.
18637	24892	599	,	,	,
18637	24892	600	531	531	CD
18637	24892	601	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	602	533	533	CD
18637	24892	603	,	,	,
18637	24892	604	620	620	CD
18637	24892	605	State	State	NNP
18637	24892	606	courts	court	NNS
18637	24892	607	,	,	,
18637	24892	608	controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	24892	609	,	,	,
18637	24892	610	concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	24892	611	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24892	612	,	,	,
18637	24892	613	with	with	IN
18637	24892	614	,	,	,
18637	24892	615	comity	comity	NN
18637	24892	616	,	,	,
18637	24892	617	624	624	CD
18637	24892	618	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	619	635	635	CD
18637	24892	620	State	State	NNP
18637	24892	621	courts	court	NNS
18637	24892	622	,	,	,
18637	24892	623	removal	removal	NN
18637	24892	624	of	of	IN
18637	24892	625	cases	case	NNS
18637	24892	626	to	to	TO
18637	24892	627	,	,	,
18637	24892	628	from	from	IN
18637	24892	629	,	,	,
18637	24892	630	310	310	CD
18637	24892	631	,	,	,
18637	24892	632	567	567	CD
18637	24892	633	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	634	569	569	CD
18637	24892	635	States	state	NNS
18637	24892	636	,	,	,
18637	24892	637	interest	interest	NN
18637	24892	638	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	24892	639	for	for	IN
18637	24892	640	suits	suit	NNS
18637	24892	641	in	in	IN
18637	24892	642	,	,	,
18637	24892	643	114	114	CD
18637	24892	644	,	,	,
18637	24892	645	543	543	CD
18637	24892	646	,	,	,
18637	24892	647	594	594	CD
18637	24892	648	Status	status	NN
18637	24892	649	to	to	TO
18637	24892	650	sue	sue	VB
18637	24892	651	in	in	RP
18637	24892	652	,	,	,
18637	24892	653	114	114	CD
18637	24892	654	,	,	,
18637	24892	655	541	541	CD
18637	24892	656	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	657	543	543	CD
18637	24892	658	,	,	,
18637	24892	659	594	594	CD
18637	24892	660	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	24892	661	against	against	IN
18637	24892	662	States	state	NNS
18637	24892	663	by	by	IN
18637	24892	664	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	24892	665	of	of	IN
18637	24892	666	other	other	JJ
18637	24892	667	States	States	NNPS
18637	24892	668	,	,	,
18637	24892	669	etc	etc	FW
18637	24892	670	.	.	.
18637	24892	671	,	,	,
18637	24892	672	929	929	CD
18637	24892	673	-	-	HYPH
18637	24892	674	930	930	CD
18637	24892	675	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	24892	676	between	between	IN
18637	24892	677	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	24892	678	of	of	IN
18637	24892	679	different	different	JJ
18637	24892	680	States	state	NNS
18637	24892	681	,	,	,
18637	24892	682	law	law	NN
18637	24892	683	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	24892	684	to	to	IN
18637	24892	685	,	,	,
18637	24892	686	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	24892	687	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24892	688	diversity	diversity	NN
18637	24892	689	of	of	IN
18637	24892	690	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	24892	691	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24892	692	,	,	,
18637	24892	693	302	302	CD
18637	24892	694	,	,	,
18637	24892	695	332	332	CD
18637	24892	696	,	,	,
18637	24892	697	599	599	CD
18637	24892	698	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	699	608	608	CD
18637	24892	700	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	24892	701	between	between	IN
18637	24892	702	State	state	NN
18637	24892	703	,	,	,
18637	24892	704	or	or	CC
18637	24892	705	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	24892	706	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	24892	707	,	,	,
18637	24892	708	and	and	CC
18637	24892	709	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	24892	710	states	state	NNS
18637	24892	711	,	,	,
18637	24892	712	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	24892	713	,	,	,
18637	24892	714	etc	etc	FW
18637	24892	715	.	.	FW
18637	24892	716	,	,	,
18637	24892	717	609	609	CD
18637	24892	718	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	719	611	611	CD
18637	24892	720	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	24892	721	between	between	IN
18637	24892	722	States	States	NNP
18637	24892	723	,	,	,
18637	24892	724	591	591	CD
18637	24892	725	-	-	HYPH
18637	24892	726	595	595	CD
18637	24892	727	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	24892	728	by	by	IN
18637	24892	729	States	state	NNS
18637	24892	730	against	against	IN
18637	24892	731	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	24892	732	of	of	IN
18637	24892	733	another	another	DT
18637	24892	734	State	state	NN
18637	24892	735	,	,	,
18637	24892	736	suits	suit	NNS
18637	24892	737	by	by	IN
18637	24892	738	,	,	,
18637	24892	739	as	as	IN
18637	24892	740	parens	paren	NNS
18637	24892	741	patriae	patriae	NNS
18637	24892	742	,	,	,
18637	24892	743	596	596	CD
18637	24892	744	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	745	599	599	CD
18637	24892	746	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	24892	747	by	by	IN
18637	24892	748	States	state	NNS
18637	24892	749	to	to	TO
18637	24892	750	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	24892	751	their	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	24892	752	penal	penal	JJ
18637	24892	753	laws	law	NNS
18637	24892	754	,	,	,
18637	24892	755	597	597	CD
18637	24892	756	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	24892	757	of	of	IN
18637	24892	758	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	24892	759	under	under	IN
18637	24892	760	land	land	NN
18637	24892	761	grants	grant	NNS
18637	24892	762	of	of	IN
18637	24892	763	different	different	JJ
18637	24892	764	States	States	NNP
18637	24892	765	,	,	,
18637	24892	766	608	608	CD
18637	24892	767	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	768	609	609	CD
18637	24892	769	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	24892	770	of	of	IN
18637	24892	771	United	United	NNP
18637	24892	772	States	States	NNP
18637	24892	773	as	as	IN
18637	24892	774	party	party	NN
18637	24892	775	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
18637	24892	776	or	or	CC
18637	24892	777	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	24892	778	,	,	,
18637	24892	779	suits	suit	NNS
18637	24892	780	of	of	IN
18637	24892	781	,	,	,
18637	24892	782	against	against	IN
18637	24892	783	States	States	NNP
18637	24892	784	,	,	,
18637	24892	785	584	584	CD
18637	24892	786	-	-	HYPH
18637	24892	787	591	591	CD
18637	24892	788	Territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	24892	789	,	,	,
18637	24892	790	how	how	WRB
18637	24892	791	created	create	VBN
18637	24892	792	,	,	,
18637	24892	793	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24892	794	,	,	,
18637	24892	795	etc	etc	FW
18637	24892	796	.	.	FW
18637	24892	797	,	,	,
18637	24892	798	703	703	CD
18637	24892	799	Territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	24892	800	,	,	,
18637	24892	801	transferral	transferral	JJ
18637	24892	802	of	of	IN
18637	24892	803	cases	case	NNS
18637	24892	804	from	from	IN
18637	24892	805	,	,	,
18637	24892	806	when	when	WRB
18637	24892	807	,	,	,
18637	24892	808	699	699	CD
18637	24892	809	Writs	writ	NNS
18637	24892	810	,	,	,
18637	24892	811	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	24892	812	power	power	NN
18637	24892	813	as	as	IN
18637	24892	814	to	to	TO
18637	24892	815	issue	issue	VB
18637	24892	816	by	by	IN
18637	24892	817	,	,	,
18637	24892	818	312	312	CD
18637	24892	819	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	820	313	313	CD
18637	24892	821	,	,	,
18637	24892	822	522	522	CD
18637	24892	823	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	824	525	525	CD
18637	24892	825	,	,	,
18637	24892	826	621	621	CD
18637	24892	827	-	-	SYM
18637	24892	828	622	622	CD
18637	24892	829	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24892	830	Martial	Martial	NNP
18637	24892	831	.	.	.
18637	24893	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24893	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24893	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24893	4	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24893	5	,	,	,
18637	24893	6	Air	Air	NNP
18637	24893	7	and	and	CC
18637	24893	8	Naval	Naval	NNP
18637	24893	9	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	24893	10	.	.	.
18637	24894	1	Courts	court	NNS
18637	24894	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24894	3	State	state	NN
18637	24894	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24894	5	:	:	:
18637	24894	6	Errors	error	NNS
18637	24894	7	of	of	IN
18637	24894	8	,	,	,
18637	24894	9	not	not	RB
18637	24894	10	effecting	effect	VBG
18637	24894	11	denial	denial	NN
18637	24894	12	of	of	IN
18637	24894	13	due	due	JJ
18637	24894	14	process	process	NN
18637	24894	15	,	,	,
18637	24894	16	1140	1140	CD
18637	24894	17	-	-	SYM
18637	24894	18	1141	1141	CD
18637	24894	19	Impartiality	Impartiality	NNP
18637	24894	20	essential	essential	JJ
18637	24894	21	to	to	IN
18637	24894	22	due	due	JJ
18637	24894	23	process	process	NN
18637	24894	24	;	;	:
18637	24894	25	effect	effect	NN
18637	24894	26	of	of	IN
18637	24894	27	mob	mob	NN
18637	24894	28	violence	violence	NN
18637	24894	29	,	,	,
18637	24894	30	1131	1131	CD
18637	24894	31	,	,	,
18637	24894	32	1138	1138	CD
18637	24894	33	-	-	SYM
18637	24894	34	1139	1139	CD
18637	24894	35	Crimes	Crimes	NNPS
18637	24894	36	and	and	CC
18637	24894	37	Offenses	Offenses	NNP
18637	24894	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24894	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24894	40	see	see	VB
18637	24894	41	also	also	RB
18637	24894	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24894	43	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
18637	24894	44	Prosecutions	Prosecutions	NNPS
18637	24894	45	;	;	:
18637	24894	46	Elections	election	NNS
18637	24894	47	;	;	:
18637	24894	48	Felonies	felony	NNS
18637	24894	49	;	;	:
18637	24894	50	High	High	NNP
18637	24894	51	Seas	Seas	NNPS
18637	24894	52	;	;	:
18637	24894	53	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24894	54	:	:	:
18637	24894	55	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24894	56	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24894	57	:	:	:
18637	24894	58	Definition	definition	NN
18637	24894	59	;	;	:
18637	24894	60	powers	power	NNS
18637	24894	61	of	of	IN
18637	24894	62	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24894	63	as	as	IN
18637	24894	64	to	to	IN
18637	24894	65	,	,	,
18637	24894	66	277	277	CD
18637	24894	67	-	-	SYM
18637	24894	68	279	279	CD
18637	24894	69	,	,	,
18637	24894	70	308	308	CD
18637	24894	71	-	-	SYM
18637	24894	72	309	309	CD
18637	24894	73	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24894	74	,	,	,
18637	24894	75	petty	petty	JJ
18637	24894	76	,	,	,
18637	24894	77	serious	serious	JJ
18637	24894	78	,	,	,
18637	24894	79	defined	define	VBN
18637	24894	80	,	,	,
18637	24894	81	877	877	CD
18637	24894	82	-	-	SYM
18637	24894	83	878	878	CD
18637	24894	84	,	,	,
18637	24894	85	881	881	CD
18637	24894	86	-	-	SYM
18637	24894	87	883	883	CD
18637	24894	88	under	under	IN
18637	24894	89	National	National	NNP
18637	24894	90	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	24894	91	Act	Act	NNP
18637	24894	92	,	,	,
18637	24894	93	effect	effect	NN
18637	24894	94	of	of	IN
18637	24894	95	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	24894	96	,	,	,
18637	24894	97	1214	1214	CD
18637	24894	98	Penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	24894	99	,	,	,
18637	24894	100	gradation	gradation	NN
18637	24894	101	for	for	IN
18637	24894	102	different	different	JJ
18637	24894	103	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	24894	104	,	,	,
18637	24894	105	different	different	JJ
18637	24894	106	criminals	criminal	NNS
18637	24894	107	,	,	,
18637	24894	108	validity	validity	NN
18637	24894	109	,	,	,
18637	24894	110	1160	1160	CD
18637	24894	111	-	-	SYM
18637	24894	112	1161	1161	CD
18637	24894	113	Vagueness	Vagueness	NNP
18637	24894	114	of	of	IN
18637	24894	115	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	24894	116	defining	define	VBG
18637	24894	117	,	,	,
18637	24894	118	effect	effect	NN
18637	24894	119	,	,	,
18637	24894	120	881	881	CD
18637	24894	121	-	-	SYM
18637	24894	122	883	883	CD
18637	24894	123	,	,	,
18637	24894	124	984	984	CD
18637	24894	125	,	,	,
18637	24894	126	1097	1097	CD
18637	24894	127	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
18637	24894	128	Prosecutions	Prosecutions	NNPS
18637	24894	129	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24894	130	_	_	NNP
18637	24894	131	see	see	VBP
18637	24894	132	also	also	RB
18637	24894	133	_	_	NNP
18637	24894	134	Attorneys	Attorneys	NNP
18637	24894	135	;	;	:
18637	24894	136	Confrontation	confrontation	NN
18637	24894	137	;	;	:
18637	24894	138	Crimes	Crimes	NNPS
18637	24894	139	and	and	CC
18637	24894	140	Offenses	offense	NNS
18637	24894	141	;	;	:
18637	24894	142	Double	double	JJ
18637	24894	143	Jeopardy	Jeopardy	NNP
18637	24894	144	;	;	:
18637	24894	145	Due	due	IN
18637	24894	146	Process	Process	NNP
18637	24894	147	of	of	IN
18637	24894	148	Law	Law	NNP
18637	24894	149	;	;	:
18637	24894	150	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24894	151	Post	Post	NNP
18637	24894	152	Facto	Facto	NNP
18637	24894	153	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	24894	154	;	;	:
18637	24894	155	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	24894	156	Juries	Juries	NNPS
18637	24894	157	;	;	:
18637	24894	158	Habeas	Habeas	NNP
18637	24894	159	Corpus	Corpus	NNP
18637	24894	160	;	;	:
18637	24894	161	Juries	jury	NNS
18637	24894	162	;	;	:
18637	24894	163	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24894	164	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	24894	165	of	of	IN
18637	24894	166	United	United	NNP
18637	24894	167	States	States	NNP
18637	24894	168	;	;	:
18637	24894	169	Territories	Territories	NNPS
18637	24894	170	;	;	:
18637	24894	171	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	24894	172	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24894	173	:	:	:
18637	24894	174	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24894	175	,	,	,
18637	24894	176	place	place	NN
18637	24894	177	of	of	IN
18637	24894	178	trial	trial	NN
18637	24894	179	,	,	,
18637	24894	180	880	880	CD
18637	24894	181	-	-	SYM
18637	24894	182	881	881	CD
18637	24894	183	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24894	184	,	,	,
18637	24894	185	rights	right	NNS
18637	24894	186	of	of	IN
18637	24894	187	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	24894	188	,	,	,
18637	24894	189	scope	scope	NN
18637	24894	190	,	,	,
18637	24894	191	877	877	CD
18637	24894	192	-	-	SYM
18637	24894	193	885	885	CD
18637	24894	194	Cruel	Cruel	NNP
18637	24894	195	and	and	CC
18637	24894	196	Unusual	unusual	JJ
18637	24894	197	Punishment	Punishment	NNP
18637	24894	198	,	,	,
18637	24894	199	not	not	RB
18637	24894	200	to	to	TO
18637	24894	201	be	be	VB
18637	24894	202	inflicted	inflict	VBN
18637	24894	203	,	,	,
18637	24894	204	what	what	WP
18637	24894	205	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	24894	206	,	,	,
18637	24894	207	903	903	CD
18637	24894	208	-	-	SYM
18637	24894	209	905	905	CD
18637	24894	210	,	,	,
18637	24894	211	1133	1133	CD
18637	24894	212	-	-	SYM
18637	24894	213	1135	1135	CD
18637	24894	214	D	D	NNP
18637	24894	215	Dams	Dams	NNPS
18637	24894	216	,	,	,
18637	24894	217	across	across	IN
18637	24894	218	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	24894	219	streams	stream	NNS
18637	24894	220	,	,	,
18637	24894	221	State	state	NN
18637	24894	222	powers	power	NNS
18637	24894	223	as	as	IN
18637	24894	224	to	to	IN
18637	24894	225	,	,	,
18637	24894	226	229	229	CD
18637	24894	227	-	-	SYM
18637	24894	228	230	230	CD
18637	24894	229	Debts	debt	NNS
18637	24894	230	due	due	JJ
18637	24894	231	the	the	DT
18637	24894	232	United	United	NNP
18637	24894	233	States	States	NNP
18637	24894	234	,	,	,
18637	24894	235	collection	collection	NN
18637	24894	236	,	,	,
18637	24894	237	117	117	CD
18637	24894	238	Debts	debt	NNS
18637	24894	239	of	of	IN
18637	24894	240	the	the	DT
18637	24894	241	United	United	NNP
18637	24894	242	States	States	NNP
18637	24894	243	:	:	:
18637	24894	244	Abrogation	abrogation	NN
18637	24894	245	of	of	IN
18637	24894	246	gold	gold	NN
18637	24894	247	clause	clause	NN
18637	24894	248	in	in	IN
18637	24894	249	United	United	NNP
18637	24894	250	States	States	NNP
18637	24894	251	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	24894	252	,	,	,
18637	24894	253	validity	validity	NN
18637	24894	254	,	,	,
18637	24894	255	117	117	CD
18637	24894	256	Contraction	Contraction	NNP
18637	24894	257	,	,	,
18637	24894	258	payment	payment	NN
18637	24894	259	,	,	,
18637	24894	260	117	117	CD
18637	24894	261	Declaratory	Declaratory	NNP
18637	24894	262	Judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	24894	263	.	.	.
18637	24895	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24895	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24895	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24895	4	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24895	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24895	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24895	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24895	8	.	.	.
18637	24896	1	Delegation	delegation	NN
18637	24896	2	of	of	IN
18637	24896	3	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24896	4	:	:	.
18637	24896	5	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	24896	6	,	,	,
18637	24896	7	to	to	IN
18637	24896	8	administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	24896	9	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	24896	10	,	,	,
18637	24896	11	521	521	CD
18637	24896	12	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	24896	13	,	,	,
18637	24896	14	by	by	IN
18637	24896	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24896	16	,	,	,
18637	24896	17	71	71	CD
18637	24896	18	,	,	,
18637	24896	19	73	73	CD
18637	24896	20	-	-	SYM
18637	24896	21	81	81	CD
18637	24896	22	,	,	,
18637	24896	23	392	392	CD
18637	24896	24	,	,	,
18637	24896	25	442	442	CD
18637	24896	26	to	to	IN
18637	24896	27	President	President	NNP
18637	24896	28	,	,	,
18637	24896	29	in	in	IN
18637	24896	30	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	24896	31	of	of	IN
18637	24896	32	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	24896	33	relations	relation	NNS
18637	24896	34	,	,	,
18637	24896	35	80	80	CD
18637	24896	36	,	,	,
18637	24896	37	380	380	CD
18637	24896	38	Rule	rule	NN
18637	24896	39	-	-	HYPH
18637	24896	40	making	making	NN
18637	24896	41	,	,	,
18637	24896	42	to	to	IN
18637	24896	43	courts	court	NNS
18637	24896	44	,	,	,
18637	24896	45	74	74	CD
18637	24896	46	,	,	,
18637	24896	47	525	525	CD
18637	24896	48	-	-	SYM
18637	24896	49	526	526	CD
18637	24896	50	by	by	IN
18637	24896	51	State	state	NN
18637	24896	52	legislatures	legislature	NNS
18637	24896	53	,	,	,
18637	24896	54	to	to	TO
18637	24896	55	rate	rate	NN
18637	24896	56	-	-	HYPH
18637	24896	57	making	make	VBG
18637	24896	58	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	24896	59	,	,	,
18637	24896	60	77	77	CD
18637	24896	61	in	in	IN
18637	24896	62	War	War	NNP
18637	24896	63	,	,	,
18637	24896	64	289	289	CD
18637	24896	65	-	-	SYM
18637	24896	66	291	291	CD
18637	24896	67	,	,	,
18637	24896	68	392	392	CD
18637	24896	69	Descent	Descent	NNP
18637	24896	70	.	.	.
18637	24897	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24897	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24897	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24897	4	Succession	Succession	NNP
18637	24897	5	to	to	IN
18637	24897	6	Property	Property	NNP
18637	24897	7	.	.	.
18637	24898	1	Direct	Direct	NNP
18637	24898	2	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24898	3	.	.	.
18637	24899	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24899	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24899	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24899	4	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	24899	5	:	:	:
18637	24899	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24899	7	.	.	.
18637	24900	1	Discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	24900	2	.	.	.
18637	24901	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24901	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24901	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24901	4	Aliens	Aliens	NNP
18637	24901	5	;	;	:
18637	24901	6	Chinese	Chinese	NNP
18637	24901	7	;	;	:
18637	24901	8	Comity	Comity	NNP
18637	24901	9	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	24901	10	;	;	:
18637	24901	11	Equal	Equal	NNP
18637	24901	12	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	24901	13	of	of	IN
18637	24901	14	the	the	DT
18637	24901	15	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	24901	16	;	;	:
18637	24901	17	Involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	24901	18	Servitude	servitude	NN
18637	24901	19	;	;	:
18637	24901	20	Negroes	negro	NNS
18637	24901	21	;	;	:
18637	24901	22	Restraint	Restraint	NNP
18637	24901	23	of	of	IN
18637	24901	24	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	24901	25	.	.	.
18637	24902	1	District	District	NNP
18637	24902	2	of	of	IN
18637	24902	3	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	24902	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24902	5	_	_	NNP
18637	24902	6	see	see	VBP
18637	24902	7	also	also	RB
18637	24902	8	_	_	NNP
18637	24902	9	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24902	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24902	11	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24902	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24902	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24902	14	:	:	:
18637	24902	15	Cession	cession	NN
18637	24902	16	by	by	IN
18637	24902	17	States	state	NNS
18637	24902	18	,	,	,
18637	24902	19	effect	effect	NN
18637	24902	20	,	,	,
18637	24902	21	301	301	CD
18637	24902	22	-	-	SYM
18637	24902	23	302	302	CD
18637	24902	24	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24902	25	of	of	IN
18637	24902	26	,	,	,
18637	24902	27	powers	power	NNS
18637	24902	28	,	,	,
18637	24902	29	status	status	NN
18637	24902	30	,	,	,
18637	24902	31	304	304	CD
18637	24902	32	-	-	SYM
18637	24902	33	305	305	CD
18637	24902	34	Diversity	diversity	NN
18637	24902	35	of	of	IN
18637	24902	36	citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	24902	37	clause	clause	NN
18637	24902	38	,	,	,
18637	24902	39	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	24902	40	to	to	IN
18637	24902	41	,	,	,
18637	24902	42	302	302	CD
18637	24902	43	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	24902	44	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	24902	45	,	,	,
18637	24902	46	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24902	47	of	of	IN
18637	24902	48	,	,	,
18637	24902	49	by	by	IN
18637	24902	50	,	,	,
18637	24902	51	304	304	CD
18637	24902	52	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	24902	53	trial	trial	NN
18637	24902	54	,	,	,
18637	24902	55	residents	resident	NNS
18637	24902	56	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	24902	57	to	to	IN
18637	24902	58	,	,	,
18637	24902	59	303	303	CD
18637	24902	60	,	,	,
18637	24902	61	892	892	CD
18637	24902	62	as	as	IN
18637	24902	63	a	a	DT
18637	24902	64	Municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	24902	65	corporation	corporation	NN
18637	24902	66	,	,	,
18637	24902	67	suability	suability	NN
18637	24902	68	,	,	,
18637	24902	69	powers	power	NNS
18637	24902	70	,	,	,
18637	24902	71	300	300	CD
18637	24902	72	-	-	SYM
18637	24902	73	301	301	CD
18637	24902	74	,	,	,
18637	24902	75	304	304	CD
18637	24902	76	Police	police	NN
18637	24902	77	power	power	NN
18637	24902	78	of	of	IN
18637	24902	79	,	,	,
18637	24902	80	303	303	CD
18637	24902	81	Retrocession	Retrocession	NNP
18637	24902	82	of	of	IN
18637	24902	83	Alexandria	Alexandria	NNP
18637	24902	84	County	County	NNP
18637	24902	85	to	to	IN
18637	24902	86	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	24902	87	,	,	,
18637	24902	88	301	301	CD
18637	24902	89	as	as	IN
18637	24902	90	Seat	seat	NN
18637	24902	91	of	of	IN
18637	24902	92	government	government	NN
18637	24902	93	,	,	,
18637	24902	94	powers	power	NNS
18637	24902	95	of	of	IN
18637	24902	96	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24902	97	as	as	IN
18637	24902	98	to	to	IN
18637	24902	99	,	,	,
18637	24902	100	300	300	CD
18637	24902	101	-	-	SYM
18637	24902	102	305	305	CD
18637	24902	103	as	as	IN
18637	24902	104	a	a	DT
18637	24902	105	"	"	``
18637	24902	106	State	State	NNP
18637	24902	107	"	"	''
18637	24902	108	for	for	IN
18637	24902	109	certain	certain	JJ
18637	24902	110	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	24902	111	,	,	,
18637	24902	112	302	302	CD
18637	24902	113	State	state	NN
18637	24902	114	laws	law	NNS
18637	24902	115	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	24902	116	to	to	IN
18637	24902	117	,	,	,
18637	24902	118	302	302	CD
18637	24902	119	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24902	120	in	in	IN
18637	24902	121	,	,	,
18637	24902	122	303	303	CD
18637	24902	123	-	-	SYM
18637	24902	124	304	304	CD
18637	24902	125	Diversity	Diversity	NNP
18637	24902	126	of	of	IN
18637	24902	127	Citizenship	Citizenship	NNP
18637	24902	128	.	.	.
18637	24903	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24903	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24903	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24903	4	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24903	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24903	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24903	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24903	8	.	.	.
18637	24904	1	Divorce	divorce	NN
18637	24904	2	.	.	.
18637	24905	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24905	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24905	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24905	4	Due	Due	NNP
18637	24905	5	Process	Process	NNP
18637	24905	6	of	of	IN
18637	24905	7	Law	Law	NNP
18637	24905	8	;	;	:
18637	24905	9	Full	Full	NNP
18637	24905	10	Faith	Faith	NNP
18637	24905	11	and	and	CC
18637	24905	12	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	24905	13	.	.	.
18637	24906	1	Docks	Docks	NNPS
18637	24906	2	and	and	CC
18637	24906	3	Dock	Dock	NNP
18637	24906	4	Yards	Yards	NNP
18637	24906	5	.	.	.
18637	24907	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24907	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24907	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24907	4	Wharves	Wharves	NNPS
18637	24907	5	and	and	CC
18637	24907	6	Docks	Docks	NNPS
18637	24907	7	.	.	.
18637	24908	1	Dogs	dog	NNS
18637	24908	2	,	,	,
18637	24908	3	protection	protection	NN
18637	24908	4	conditioned	condition	VBN
18637	24908	5	on	on	IN
18637	24908	6	owner	owner	NN
18637	24908	7	's	's	POS
18637	24908	8	payment	payment	NN
18637	24908	9	of	of	IN
18637	24908	10	tax	tax	NN
18637	24908	11	,	,	,
18637	24908	12	1035	1035	CD
18637	24908	13	Domestic	Domestic	NNP
18637	24908	14	Violence	Violence	NNP
18637	24908	15	,	,	,
18637	24908	16	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24908	17	protection	protection	NN
18637	24908	18	of	of	IN
18637	24908	19	States	States	NNP
18637	24908	20	against	against	IN
18637	24908	21	,	,	,
18637	24908	22	704	704	CD
18637	24908	23	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	24	705	705	CD
18637	24908	25	Double	double	JJ
18637	24908	26	Jeopardy	Jeopardy	NNP
18637	24908	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24908	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24908	29	see	see	VB
18637	24908	30	also	also	RB
18637	24908	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24908	32	Due	Due	NNP
18637	24908	33	Process	Process	NNP
18637	24908	34	of	of	IN
18637	24908	35	Law	Law	NNP
18637	24908	36	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24908	37	:	:	:
18637	24908	38	Guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	24908	39	against	against	IN
18637	24908	40	,	,	,
18637	24908	41	not	not	RB
18637	24908	42	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	24908	43	to	to	IN
18637	24908	44	military	military	JJ
18637	24908	45	forces	force	NNS
18637	24908	46	,	,	,
18637	24908	47	286	286	CD
18637	24908	48	What	what	WDT
18637	24908	49	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	24908	50	;	;	:
18637	24908	51	protection	protection	NN
18637	24908	52	against	against	IN
18637	24908	53	,	,	,
18637	24908	54	limits	limit	NNS
18637	24908	55	,	,	,
18637	24908	56	837	837	CD
18637	24908	57	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	58	841	841	CD
18637	24908	59	,	,	,
18637	24908	60	1135	1135	CD
18637	24908	61	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	62	1137	1137	CD
18637	24908	63	Drugs	drug	NNS
18637	24908	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24908	65	_	_	NNP
18637	24908	66	see	see	VBP
18637	24908	67	also	also	RB
18637	24908	68	_	_	NNP
18637	24908	69	Pharmacies	Pharmacies	NNP
18637	24908	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24908	71	:	:	:
18637	24908	72	State	state	NN
18637	24908	73	,	,	,
18637	24908	74	etc	etc	FW
18637	24908	75	.	.	FW
18637	24908	76	,	,	,
18637	24908	77	laws	law	NNS
18637	24908	78	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	24908	79	sale	sale	NN
18637	24908	80	of	of	IN
18637	24908	81	,	,	,
18637	24908	82	1030	1030	CD
18637	24908	83	Dual	Dual	NNP
18637	24908	84	Federalism	Federalism	NNP
18637	24908	85	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24908	86	_	_	NNP
18637	24908	87	see	see	VB
18637	24908	88	also	also	RB
18637	24908	89	_	_	NNP
18637	24908	90	States	States	NNPS
18637	24908	91	:	:	:
18637	24908	92	Powers	power	NNS
18637	24908	93	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24908	94	,	,	,
18637	24908	95	106	106	CD
18637	24908	96	,	,	,
18637	24908	97	915	915	CD
18637	24908	98	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	99	919	919	CD
18637	24908	100	Due	due	IN
18637	24908	101	Process	Process	NNP
18637	24908	102	of	of	IN
18637	24908	103	Law	Law	NNP
18637	24908	104	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24908	105	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	24908	106	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	24908	107	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24908	108	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24908	109	_	_	NNP
18637	24908	110	see	see	VB
18637	24908	111	also	also	RB
18637	24908	112	_	_	NNP
18637	24908	113	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	24908	114	Agencies	Agencies	NNPS
18637	24908	115	;	;	:
18637	24908	116	Aliens	alien	NNS
18637	24908	117	;	;	:
18637	24908	118	Bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
18637	24908	119	;	;	:
18637	24908	120	Carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	24908	121	;	;	:
18637	24908	122	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	24908	123	;	;	:
18637	24908	124	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24908	125	,	,	,
18637	24908	126	Air	air	NN
18637	24908	127	,	,	,
18637	24908	128	and	and	CC
18637	24908	129	Naval	Naval	NNP
18637	24908	130	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	24908	131	;	;	:
18637	24908	132	Police	police	NN
18637	24908	133	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24908	134	;	;	:
18637	24908	135	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24908	136	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	24908	137	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24908	138	:	:	:
18637	24908	139	in	in	IN
18637	24908	140	Administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	24908	141	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	24908	142	,	,	,
18637	24908	143	essentials	essential	NNS
18637	24908	144	of	of	IN
18637	24908	145	,	,	,
18637	24908	146	849	849	CD
18637	24908	147	-	-	HYPH
18637	24908	148	853	853	CD
18637	24908	149	in	in	IN
18637	24908	150	Criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	24908	151	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	24908	152	,	,	,
18637	24908	153	essentials	essential	NNS
18637	24908	154	of	of	IN
18637	24908	155	,	,	,
18637	24908	156	847	847	CD
18637	24908	157	,	,	,
18637	24908	158	881	881	CD
18637	24908	159	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	160	885	885	CD
18637	24908	161	Discriminatory	Discriminatory	NNP
18637	24908	162	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	24908	163	,	,	,
18637	24908	164	relation	relation	NN
18637	24908	165	to	to	IN
18637	24908	166	,	,	,
18637	24908	167	853	853	CD
18637	24908	168	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	169	854	854	CD
18637	24908	170	Indictment	Indictment	NNP
18637	24908	171	by	by	IN
18637	24908	172	grand	grand	JJ
18637	24908	173	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	24908	174	,	,	,
18637	24908	175	precision	precision	NN
18637	24908	176	required	require	VBN
18637	24908	177	by	by	IN
18637	24908	178	,	,	,
18637	24908	179	838	838	CD
18637	24908	180	,	,	,
18637	24908	181	883	883	CD
18637	24908	182	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	183	884	884	CD
18637	24908	184	as	as	IN
18637	24908	185	to	to	IN
18637	24908	186	Infamous	infamous	JJ
18637	24908	187	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	24908	188	requiring	require	VBG
18637	24908	189	grand	grand	JJ
18637	24908	190	jury	jury	NN
18637	24908	191	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	24908	192	,	,	,
18637	24908	193	837	837	CD
18637	24908	194	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	195	838	838	CD
18637	24908	196	Meaning	meaning	NN
18637	24908	197	,	,	,
18637	24908	198	source	source	NN
18637	24908	199	,	,	,
18637	24908	200	evolution	evolution	NN
18637	24908	201	of	of	IN
18637	24908	202	,	,	,
18637	24908	203	751	751	CD
18637	24908	204	,	,	,
18637	24908	205	844	844	CD
18637	24908	206	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	207	846	846	CD
18637	24908	208	,	,	,
18637	24908	209	854	854	CD
18637	24908	210	-	-	HYPH
18637	24908	211	855	855	CD
18637	24908	212	Procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	24908	213	protection	protection	NN
18637	24908	214	of	of	IN
18637	24908	215	,	,	,
18637	24908	216	essentials	essential	NNS
18637	24908	217	,	,	,
18637	24908	218	846	846	CD
18637	24908	219	-	-	HYPH
18637	24908	220	853	853	CD
18637	24908	221	Retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	24908	222	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	24908	223	,	,	,
18637	24908	224	deprivation	deprivation	NN
18637	24908	225	of	of	IN
18637	24908	226	property	property	NN
18637	24908	227	,	,	,
18637	24908	228	as	as	IN
18637	24908	229	affected	affect	VBN
18637	24908	230	by	by	IN
18637	24908	231	,	,	,
18637	24908	232	855	855	CD
18637	24908	233	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	234	858	858	CD
18637	24908	235	Self	self	NN
18637	24908	236	-	-	HYPH
18637	24908	237	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	24908	238	,	,	,
18637	24908	239	protection	protection	NN
18637	24908	240	against	against	IN
18637	24908	241	,	,	,
18637	24908	242	825	825	CD
18637	24908	243	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	244	827	827	CD
18637	24908	245	,	,	,
18637	24908	246	830	830	CD
18637	24908	247	,	,	,
18637	24908	248	837	837	CD
18637	24908	249	,	,	,
18637	24908	250	841	841	CD
18637	24908	251	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	252	844	844	CD
18637	24908	253	Substantive	Substantive	NNP
18637	24908	254	,	,	,
18637	24908	255	essentials	essential	NNS
18637	24908	256	of	of	IN
18637	24908	257	,	,	,
18637	24908	258	853	853	CD
18637	24908	259	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	260	864	864	CD
18637	24908	261	Due	due	IN
18637	24908	262	Process	Process	NNP
18637	24908	263	of	of	IN
18637	24908	264	Law	Law	NNP
18637	24908	265	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24908	266	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	24908	267	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	24908	268	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24908	269	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24908	270	_	_	NNP
18637	24908	271	see	see	VB
18637	24908	272	also	also	RB
18637	24908	273	_	_	NNP
18637	24908	274	Full	Full	NNP
18637	24908	275	Faith	Faith	NNP
18637	24908	276	and	and	CC
18637	24908	277	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	24908	278	;	;	:
18637	24908	279	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	24908	280	Vehicles	Vehicles	NNP
18637	24908	281	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24908	282	:	:	:
18637	24908	283	in	in	IN
18637	24908	284	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	24908	285	,	,	,
18637	24908	286	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	24908	287	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	24908	288	;	;	:
18637	24908	289	notice	notice	NN
18637	24908	290	and	and	CC
18637	24908	291	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	24908	292	,	,	,
18637	24908	293	etc	etc	FW
18637	24908	294	.	.	.
18637	24908	295	,	,	,
18637	24908	296	1084	1084	CD
18637	24908	297	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	298	1088	1088	CD
18637	24908	299	,	,	,
18637	24908	300	1139	1139	CD
18637	24908	301	Appeal	Appeal	NNP
18637	24908	302	,	,	,
18637	24908	303	new	new	JJ
18637	24908	304	trial	trial	NN
18637	24908	305	,	,	,
18637	24908	306	etc	etc	FW
18637	24908	307	.	.	FW
18637	24908	308	,	,	,
18637	24908	309	not	not	RB
18637	24908	310	required	require	VBN
18637	24908	311	by	by	IN
18637	24908	312	,	,	,
18637	24908	313	1139	1139	CD
18637	24908	314	in	in	IN
18637	24908	315	Civil	civil	JJ
18637	24908	316	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	24908	317	,	,	,
18637	24908	318	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24908	319	required	require	VBN
18637	24908	320	,	,	,
18637	24908	321	perfected	perfect	VBN
18637	24908	322	by	by	IN
18637	24908	323	service	service	NN
18637	24908	324	of	of	IN
18637	24908	325	process	process	NN
18637	24908	326	,	,	,
18637	24908	327	appearance	appearance	NN
18637	24908	328	,	,	,
18637	24908	329	etc	etc	FW
18637	24908	330	.	.	FW
18637	24908	331	,	,	,
18637	24908	332	1070	1070	CD
18637	24908	333	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	334	1089	1089	CD
18637	24908	335	,	,	,
18637	24908	336	1096	1096	CD
18637	24908	337	Comparison	comparison	NN
18637	24908	338	with	with	IN
18637	24908	339	clause	clause	NN
18637	24908	340	in	in	IN
18637	24908	341	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	24908	342	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	24908	343	,	,	,
18637	24908	344	971	971	CD
18637	24908	345	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	346	972	972	CD
18637	24908	347	in	in	IN
18637	24908	348	Criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	24908	349	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	24908	350	,	,	,
18637	24908	351	1096	1096	CD
18637	24908	352	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	353	1139	1139	CD
18637	24908	354	in	in	IN
18637	24908	355	Divorce	Divorce	NNP
18637	24908	356	actions	action	NNS
18637	24908	357	;	;	:
18637	24908	358	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24908	359	required	require	VBN
18637	24908	360	,	,	,
18637	24908	361	662	662	CD
18637	24908	362	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	363	671	671	CD
18637	24908	364	Enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	24908	365	of	of	IN
18637	24908	366	,	,	,
18637	24908	367	by	by	IN
18637	24908	368	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24908	369	,	,	,
18637	24908	370	limits	limit	NNS
18637	24908	371	,	,	,
18637	24908	372	1175	1175	CD
18637	24908	373	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	374	1177	1177	CD
18637	24908	375	Historical	historical	JJ
18637	24908	376	development	development	NN
18637	24908	377	,	,	,
18637	24908	378	971	971	CD
18637	24908	379	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	380	980	980	CD
18637	24908	381	Judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	24908	382	without	without	IN
18637	24908	383	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24908	384	,	,	,
18637	24908	385	process	process	NN
18637	24908	386	,	,	,
18637	24908	387	etc	etc	FW
18637	24908	388	.	.	FW
18637	24908	389	,	,	,
18637	24908	390	as	as	IN
18637	24908	391	denial	denial	NN
18637	24908	392	of	of	IN
18637	24908	393	,	,	,
18637	24908	394	658	658	CD
18637	24908	395	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	396	661	661	CD
18637	24908	397	,	,	,
18637	24908	398	670	670	CD
18637	24908	399	-	-	HYPH
18637	24908	400	673	673	CD
18637	24908	401	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	24908	402	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	24908	403	,	,	,
18637	24908	404	as	as	IN
18637	24908	405	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	24908	406	on	on	IN
18637	24908	407	State	State	NNP
18637	24908	408	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24908	409	of	of	IN
18637	24908	410	,	,	,
18637	24908	411	1089	1089	CD
18637	24908	412	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	413	1096	1096	CD
18637	24908	414	in	in	IN
18637	24908	415	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	24908	416	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	24908	417	,	,	,
18637	24908	418	notice	notice	NN
18637	24908	419	and	and	CC
18637	24908	420	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	24908	421	,	,	,
18637	24908	422	etc	etc	FW
18637	24908	423	.	.	.
18637	24908	424	,	,	,
18637	24908	425	1087	1087	CD
18637	24908	426	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	427	1088	1088	CD
18637	24908	428	,	,	,
18637	24908	429	1139	1139	CD
18637	24908	430	"	"	``
18637	24908	431	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	24908	432	"	"	''
18637	24908	433	,	,	,
18637	24908	434	protected	protect	VBN
18637	24908	435	by	by	IN
18637	24908	436	,	,	,
18637	24908	437	983	983	CD
18637	24908	438	-	-	HYPH
18637	24908	439	997	997	CD
18637	24908	440	,	,	,
18637	24908	441	1017	1017	CD
18637	24908	442	,	,	,
18637	24908	443	1019	1019	CD
18637	24908	444	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	445	1020	1020	CD
18637	24908	446	,	,	,
18637	24908	447	1022	1022	CD
18637	24908	448	"	"	``
18637	24908	449	Persons	Persons	NNPS
18637	24908	450	"	"	''
18637	24908	451	,	,	,
18637	24908	452	protected	protect	VBN
18637	24908	453	by	by	IN
18637	24908	454	,	,	,
18637	24908	455	981	981	CD
18637	24908	456	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	457	982	982	CD
18637	24908	458	Retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	24908	459	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	24908	460	of	of	IN
18637	24908	461	certain	certain	JJ
18637	24908	462	rights	right	NNS
18637	24908	463	,	,	,
18637	24908	464	when	when	WRB
18637	24908	465	a	a	DT
18637	24908	466	denial	denial	NN
18637	24908	467	of	of	IN
18637	24908	468	,	,	,
18637	24908	469	1035	1035	CD
18637	24908	470	,	,	,
18637	24908	471	1039	1039	CD
18637	24908	472	Scope	scope	NN
18637	24908	473	of	of	IN
18637	24908	474	protection	protection	NN
18637	24908	475	,	,	,
18637	24908	476	981	981	CD
18637	24908	477	-	-	SYM
18637	24908	478	1139	1139	CD
18637	24908	479	E	e	NN
18637	24908	480	Earmarked	Earmarked	NNP
18637	24908	481	Funds	Funds	NNPS
18637	24908	482	.	.	.
18637	24909	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24909	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24909	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24909	4	General	General	NNP
18637	24909	5	Welfare	Welfare	NNP
18637	24909	6	;	;	:
18637	24909	7	Spending	spend	VBG
18637	24909	8	for	for	IN
18637	24909	9	the	the	DT
18637	24909	10	General	General	NNP
18637	24909	11	Welfare	Welfare	NNP
18637	24909	12	.	.	.
18637	24910	1	Education	education	NN
18637	24910	2	.	.	.
18637	24911	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24911	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24911	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24911	4	Negroes	Negroes	NNPS
18637	24911	5	;	;	:
18637	24911	6	Schools	Schools	NNPS
18637	24911	7	and	and	CC
18637	24911	8	Colleges	Colleges	NNP
18637	24911	9	.	.	.
18637	24912	1	Elections	election	NNS
18637	24912	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24912	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24912	4	see	see	VBP
18637	24912	5	also	also	RB
18637	24912	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24912	7	House	House	NNP
18637	24912	8	of	of	IN
18637	24912	9	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	24912	10	;	;	:
18637	24912	11	Negroes	negro	NNS
18637	24912	12	;	;	:
18637	24912	13	President	President	NNP
18637	24912	14	;	;	:
18637	24912	15	Election	election	NN
18637	24912	16	;	;	:
18637	24912	17	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24912	18	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	24912	19	of	of	IN
18637	24912	20	the	the	DT
18637	24912	21	United	United	NNP
18637	24912	22	States	States	NNP
18637	24912	23	;	;	:
18637	24912	24	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	24912	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24912	26	:	:	:
18637	24912	27	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	24912	28	,	,	,
18637	24912	29	use	use	NN
18637	24912	30	of	of	IN
18637	24912	31	State	state	NN
18637	24912	32	officers	officer	NNS
18637	24912	33	,	,	,
18637	24912	34	etc	etc	FW
18637	24912	35	.	.	FW
18637	24912	36	,	,	,
18637	24912	37	powers	power	NNS
18637	24912	38	of	of	IN
18637	24912	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24912	40	as	as	IN
18637	24912	41	to	to	IN
18637	24912	42	,	,	,
18637	24912	43	87	87	CD
18637	24912	44	,	,	,
18637	24912	45	92	92	CD
18637	24912	46	-	-	SYM
18637	24912	47	94	94	CD
18637	24912	48	,	,	,
18637	24912	49	738	738	CD
18637	24912	50	-	-	SYM
18637	24912	51	739	739	CD
18637	24912	52	Crimes	crime	NNS
18637	24912	53	in	in	IN
18637	24912	54	relation	relation	NN
18637	24912	55	to	to	IN
18637	24912	56	,	,	,
18637	24912	57	92	92	CD
18637	24912	58	Declaration	declaration	NN
18637	24912	59	of	of	IN
18637	24912	60	intention	intention	NN
18637	24912	61	as	as	IN
18637	24912	62	prerequisite	prerequisite	JJ
18637	24912	63	to	to	IN
18637	24912	64	voting	voting	NN
18637	24912	65	,	,	,
18637	24912	66	validity	validity	NN
18637	24912	67	,	,	,
18637	24912	68	1165	1165	CD
18637	24912	69	Grandfather	Grandfather	NNP
18637	24912	70	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	24912	71	,	,	,
18637	24912	72	void	void	JJ
18637	24912	73	,	,	,
18637	24912	74	1184	1184	CD
18637	24912	75	Inequalities	Inequalities	NNPS
18637	24912	76	in	in	IN
18637	24912	77	voting	vote	VBG
18637	24912	78	power	power	NN
18637	24912	79	from	from	IN
18637	24912	80	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	24912	81	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	24912	82	and	and	CC
18637	24912	83	nominating	nominating	NN
18637	24912	84	procedures	procedure	NNS
18637	24912	85	,	,	,
18637	24912	86	92	92	CD
18637	24912	87	-	-	SYM
18637	24912	88	94	94	CD
18637	24912	89	,	,	,
18637	24912	90	1165	1165	CD
18637	24912	91	,	,	,
18637	24912	92	1207	1207	CD
18637	24912	93	-	-	SYM
18637	24912	94	1208	1208	CD
18637	24912	95	Literacy	Literacy	NNP
18637	24912	96	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	24912	97	for	for	IN
18637	24912	98	voting	voting	NN
18637	24912	99	,	,	,
18637	24912	100	1184	1184	CD
18637	24912	101	-	-	SYM
18637	24912	102	1186	1186	CD
18637	24912	103	of	of	IN
18637	24912	104	Members	Members	NNPS
18637	24912	105	of	of	IN
18637	24912	106	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24912	107	,	,	,
18637	24912	108	each	each	DT
18637	24912	109	House	House	NNP
18637	24912	110	to	to	TO
18637	24912	111	be	be	VB
18637	24912	112	judge	judge	NN
18637	24912	113	of	of	IN
18637	24912	114	,	,	,
18637	24912	115	95	95	CD
18637	24912	116	-	-	SYM
18637	24912	117	96	96	CD
18637	24912	118	Municipal	Municipal	NNP
18637	24912	119	,	,	,
18637	24912	120	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24912	121	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24912	122	pertaining	pertain	VBG
18637	24912	123	to	to	IN
18637	24912	124	,	,	,
18637	24912	125	92	92	CD
18637	24912	126	-	-	SYM
18637	24912	127	93	93	CD
18637	24912	128	Primary	Primary	NNP
18637	24912	129	,	,	,
18637	24912	130	for	for	IN
18637	24912	131	nomination	nomination	NN
18637	24912	132	of	of	IN
18637	24912	133	Congressmen	Congressmen	NNPS
18637	24912	134	,	,	,
18637	24912	135	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24912	136	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24912	137	as	as	IN
18637	24912	138	to	to	IN
18637	24912	139	,	,	,
18637	24912	140	94	94	CD
18637	24912	141	Primary	primary	JJ
18637	24912	142	,	,	,
18637	24912	143	status	status	NN
18637	24912	144	of	of	IN
18637	24912	145	political	political	JJ
18637	24912	146	parties	party	NNS
18637	24912	147	in	in	IN
18637	24912	148	,	,	,
18637	24912	149	1185	1185	CD
18637	24912	150	Qualifications	qualification	NNS
18637	24912	151	of	of	IN
18637	24912	152	voters	voter	NNS
18637	24912	153	;	;	,
18637	24912	154	voting	voting	NN
18637	24912	155	rights	right	NNS
18637	24912	156	,	,	,
18637	24912	157	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24912	158	protection	protection	NN
18637	24912	159	of	of	IN
18637	24912	160	,	,	,
18637	24912	161	etc	etc	FW
18637	24912	162	.	.	.
18637	24912	163	,	,	,
18637	24912	164	87	87	CD
18637	24912	165	,	,	,
18637	24912	166	92	92	CD
18637	24912	167	-	-	SYM
18637	24912	168	94	94	CD
18637	24912	169	,	,	,
18637	24912	170	386	386	CD
18637	24912	171	,	,	,
18637	24912	172	1170	1170	CD
18637	24912	173	-	-	SYM
18637	24912	174	1172	1172	CD
18637	24912	175	,	,	,
18637	24912	176	1183	1183	CD
18637	24912	177	-	-	SYM
18637	24912	178	1186	1186	CD
18637	24912	179	,	,	,
18637	24912	180	1207	1207	CD
18637	24912	181	-	-	SYM
18637	24912	182	1208	1208	CD
18637	24912	183	,	,	,
18637	24912	184	1219	1219	CD
18637	24912	185	-	-	SYM
18637	24912	186	1220	1220	CD
18637	24912	187	Time	Time	NNP
18637	24912	188	-	-	HYPH
18637	24912	189	off	off	IN
18637	24912	190	-	-	HYPH
18637	24912	191	for	for	IN
18637	24912	192	-	-	HYPH
18637	24912	193	voting	voting	NN
18637	24912	194	laws	law	NNS
18637	24912	195	,	,	,
18637	24912	196	validity	validity	NN
18637	24912	197	,	,	,
18637	24912	198	988	988	CD
18637	24912	199	Electricity	Electricity	NNP
18637	24912	200	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24912	201	_	_	NNP
18637	24912	202	see	see	VBP
18637	24912	203	also	also	RB
18637	24912	204	_	_	NNP
18637	24912	205	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24912	206	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	24912	207	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24912	208	:	:	:
18637	24912	209	Interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	24912	210	distribution	distribution	NN
18637	24912	211	of	of	IN
18637	24912	212	,	,	,
18637	24912	213	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24912	214	,	,	,
18637	24912	215	State	State	NNP
18637	24912	216	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24912	217	,	,	,
18637	24912	218	137	137	CD
18637	24912	219	,	,	,
18637	24912	220	223	223	CD
18637	24912	221	Embargoes	embargo	NNS
18637	24912	222	.	.	.
18637	24913	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24913	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24913	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24913	4	Conservation	Conservation	NNP
18637	24913	5	;	;	:
18637	24913	6	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	24913	7	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24913	8	.	.	.
18637	24914	1	Eminent	Eminent	NNP
18637	24914	2	Domain	Domain	NNP
18637	24914	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24914	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24914	5	see	see	VBP
18637	24914	6	also	also	RB
18637	24914	7	_	_	NNP
18637	24914	8	Aliens	Aliens	NNP
18637	24914	9	;	;	:
18637	24914	10	Navigable	Navigable	NNP
18637	24914	11	Waters	water	NNS
18637	24914	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24914	13	:	:	:
18637	24914	14	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24914	15	,	,	,
18637	24914	16	just	just	RB
18637	24914	17	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	24914	18	defined	define	VBN
18637	24914	19	,	,	,
18637	24914	20	enforced	enforce	VBN
18637	24914	21	;	;	:
18637	24914	22	right	right	RB
18637	24914	23	to	to	IN
18637	24914	24	interest	interest	NN
18637	24914	25	,	,	,
18637	24914	26	etc	etc	FW
18637	24914	27	.	.	.
18637	24914	28	,	,	,
18637	24914	29	866	866	CD
18637	24914	30	-	-	SYM
18637	24914	31	867	867	CD
18637	24914	32	,	,	,
18637	24914	33	869	869	CD
18637	24914	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	24914	35	872	872	CD
18637	24914	36	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24914	37	,	,	,
18637	24914	38	of	of	IN
18637	24914	39	State	State	NNP
18637	24914	40	lands	land	NNS
18637	24914	41	,	,	,
18637	24914	42	920	920	CD
18637	24914	43	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24914	44	power	power	NN
18637	24914	45	of	of	IN
18637	24914	46	,	,	,
18637	24914	47	scope	scope	NN
18637	24914	48	,	,	,
18637	24914	49	837	837	CD
18637	24914	50	,	,	,
18637	24914	51	864	864	CD
18637	24914	52	-	-	HYPH
18637	24914	53	872	872	CD
18637	24914	54	,	,	,
18637	24914	55	920	920	CD
18637	24914	56	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24914	57	,	,	,
18637	24914	58	public	public	JJ
18637	24914	59	use	use	NN
18637	24914	60	defined	define	VBN
18637	24914	61	,	,	,
18637	24914	62	determined	determine	VBN
18637	24914	63	,	,	,
18637	24914	64	865	865	CD
18637	24914	65	-	-	SYM
18637	24914	66	866	866	CD
18637	24914	67	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24914	68	,	,	,
18637	24914	69	what	what	WP
18637	24914	70	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	24914	71	a	a	DT
18637	24914	72	"	"	``
18637	24914	73	taking	taking	NN
18637	24914	74	"	"	''
18637	24914	75	,	,	,
18637	24914	76	867	867	CD
18637	24914	77	-	-	HYPH
18637	24914	78	869	869	CD
18637	24914	79	President	President	NNP
18637	24914	80	,	,	,
18637	24914	81	powers	power	NNS
18637	24914	82	of	of	IN
18637	24914	83	,	,	,
18637	24914	84	in	in	IN
18637	24914	85	war	war	NN
18637	24914	86	time	time	NN
18637	24914	87	,	,	,
18637	24914	88	403	403	CD
18637	24914	89	State	state	NN
18637	24914	90	,	,	,
18637	24914	91	power	power	NN
18637	24914	92	of	of	IN
18637	24914	93	,	,	,
18637	24914	94	inalienable	inalienable	JJ
18637	24914	95	,	,	,
18637	24914	96	limited	limit	VBN
18637	24914	97	by	by	IN
18637	24914	98	due	due	JJ
18637	24914	99	process	process	NN
18637	24914	100	clause	clause	NN
18637	24914	101	,	,	,
18637	24914	102	349	349	CD
18637	24914	103	-	-	SYM
18637	24914	104	350	350	CD
18637	24914	105	,	,	,
18637	24914	106	1062	1062	CD
18637	24914	107	-	-	SYM
18637	24914	108	1070	1070	CD
18637	24914	109	State	State	NNP
18637	24914	110	,	,	,
18637	24914	111	"	"	``
18637	24914	112	taking	take	VBG
18637	24914	113	"	"	''
18637	24914	114	,	,	,
18637	24914	115	"	"	''
18637	24914	116	for	for	IN
18637	24914	117	public	public	JJ
18637	24914	118	use	use	NN
18637	24914	119	"	"	''
18637	24914	120	,	,	,
18637	24914	121	just	just	RB
18637	24914	122	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	24914	123	,	,	,
18637	24914	124	uncompensated	uncompensated	JJ
18637	24914	125	takings	taking	NNS
18637	24914	126	,	,	,
18637	24914	127	consequential	consequential	JJ
18637	24914	128	damages	damage	NNS
18637	24914	129	,	,	,
18637	24914	130	defined	define	VBN
18637	24914	131	,	,	,
18637	24914	132	1003	1003	CD
18637	24914	133	-	-	SYM
18637	24914	134	1068	1068	CD
18637	24914	135	War	war	NN
18637	24914	136	damage	damage	NN
18637	24914	137	,	,	,
18637	24914	138	liability	liability	NN
18637	24914	139	of	of	IN
18637	24914	140	United	United	NNP
18637	24914	141	States	States	NNP
18637	24914	142	,	,	,
18637	24914	143	298	298	CD
18637	24914	144	Emoluments	Emoluments	NNPS
18637	24914	145	,	,	,
18637	24914	146	acceptance	acceptance	NN
18637	24914	147	from	from	IN
18637	24914	148	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	24914	149	states	state	NNS
18637	24914	150	by	by	IN
18637	24914	151	public	public	JJ
18637	24914	152	officers	officer	NNS
18637	24914	153	,	,	,
18637	24914	154	restricted	restrict	VBN
18637	24914	155	,	,	,
18637	24914	156	324	324	CD
18637	24914	157	Enemies	enemy	NNS
18637	24914	158	:	:	:
18637	24914	159	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	24914	160	,	,	,
18637	24914	161	confiscation	confiscation	NN
18637	24914	162	of	of	IN
18637	24914	163	property	property	NN
18637	24914	164	,	,	,
18637	24914	165	865	865	CD
18637	24914	166	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	24914	167	,	,	,
18637	24914	168	deportation	deportation	NN
18637	24914	169	after	after	IN
18637	24914	170	end	end	NN
18637	24914	171	of	of	IN
18637	24914	172	hostilities	hostility	NNS
18637	24914	173	,	,	,
18637	24914	174	474	474	CD
18637	24914	175	-	-	SYM
18637	24914	176	475	475	CD
18637	24914	177	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	24914	178	,	,	,
18637	24914	179	not	not	RB
18637	24914	180	protected	protect	VBN
18637	24914	181	by	by	IN
18637	24914	182	due	due	JJ
18637	24914	183	process	process	NN
18637	24914	184	of	of	IN
18637	24914	185	law	law	NN
18637	24914	186	,	,	,
18637	24914	187	846	846	CD
18637	24914	188	Alien	Alien	NNP
18637	24914	189	,	,	,
18637	24914	190	property	property	NN
18637	24914	191	,	,	,
18637	24914	192	rights	right	NNS
18637	24914	193	,	,	,
18637	24914	194	status	status	NN
18637	24914	195	;	;	:
18637	24914	196	effect	effect	NN
18637	24914	197	of	of	IN
18637	24914	198	war	war	NN
18637	24914	199	on	on	RB
18637	24914	200	,	,	,
18637	24914	201	80	80	CD
18637	24914	202	,	,	,
18637	24914	203	294	294	CD
18637	24914	204	-	-	SYM
18637	24914	205	298	298	CD
18637	24914	206	,	,	,
18637	24914	207	402	402	CD
18637	24914	208	,	,	,
18637	24914	209	846	846	CD
18637	24914	210	,	,	,
18637	24914	211	865	865	CD
18637	24914	212	Equal	equal	JJ
18637	24914	213	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	24914	214	of	of	IN
18637	24914	215	the	the	DT
18637	24914	216	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	24914	217	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24914	218	_	_	NNP
18637	24914	219	see	see	VBP
18637	24914	220	also	also	RB
18637	24914	221	_	_	NNP
18637	24914	222	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
18637	24914	223	;	;	:
18637	24914	224	Elections	election	NNS
18637	24914	225	;	;	:
18637	24914	226	Negroes	negro	NNS
18637	24914	227	;	;	:
18637	24914	228	State	state	NN
18637	24914	229	:	:	:
18637	24914	230	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24914	231	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24914	232	:	:	:
18637	24914	233	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24914	234	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	24914	235	of	of	IN
18637	24914	236	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	24914	237	;	;	:
18637	24914	238	limits	limit	NNS
18637	24914	239	,	,	,
18637	24914	240	807	807	CD
18637	24914	241	-	-	SYM
18637	24914	242	808	808	CD
18637	24914	243	,	,	,
18637	24914	244	919	919	CD
18637	24914	245	,	,	,
18637	24914	246	1175	1175	CD
18637	24914	247	-	-	SYM
18637	24914	248	1177	1177	CD
18637	24914	249	Scope	Scope	NNP
18637	24914	250	of	of	IN
18637	24914	251	protection	protection	NN
18637	24914	252	,	,	,
18637	24914	253	1141	1141	CD
18637	24914	254	-	-	SYM
18637	24914	255	1170	1170	CD
18637	24914	256	State	State	NNP
18637	24914	257	action	action	NN
18637	24914	258	denying	deny	VBG
18637	24914	259	,	,	,
18637	24914	260	what	what	WP
18637	24914	261	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
18637	24914	262	,	,	,
18637	24914	263	1141	1141	CD
18637	24914	264	-	-	SYM
18637	24914	265	1142	1142	CD
18637	24914	266	Escheat	Escheat	NNP
18637	24914	267	.	.	.
18637	24915	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24915	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24915	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24915	4	Banks	Banks	NNPS
18637	24915	5	;	;	:
18637	24915	6	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	24915	7	.	.	.
18637	24916	1	Estate	Estate	NNP
18637	24916	2	,	,	,
18637	24916	3	Gift	Gift	NNP
18637	24916	4	,	,	,
18637	24916	5	and	and	CC
18637	24916	6	Inheritance	Inheritance	NNP
18637	24916	7	Taxes	Taxes	NNP
18637	24916	8	.	.	.
18637	24917	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24917	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24917	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24917	4	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	24917	5	.	.	.
18637	24918	1	Evidence	evidence	NN
18637	24918	2	and	and	CC
18637	24918	3	Presumptions	Presumptions	NNP
18637	24918	4	,	,	,
18637	24918	5	burden	burden	NN
18637	24918	6	of	of	IN
18637	24918	7	proof	proof	NN
18637	24918	8	,	,	,
18637	24918	9	prima	prima	VB
18637	24918	10	facie	facie	JJ
18637	24918	11	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	24918	12	,	,	,
18637	24918	13	etc	etc	FW
18637	24918	14	.	.	FW
18637	24918	15	,	,	,
18637	24918	16	due	due	JJ
18637	24918	17	process	process	NN
18637	24918	18	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	24918	19	on	on	IN
18637	24918	20	State	State	NNP
18637	24918	21	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24918	22	as	as	IN
18637	24918	23	to	to	IN
18637	24918	24	,	,	,
18637	24918	25	1093	1093	CD
18637	24918	26	-	-	SYM
18637	24918	27	1096	1096	CD
18637	24918	28	Excises	excise	NNS
18637	24918	29	.	.	.
18637	24919	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24919	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24919	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24919	4	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	24919	5	.	.	.
18637	24920	1	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	24920	2	Agreements	Agreements	NNP
18637	24920	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24920	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24920	5	see	see	VBP
18637	24920	6	also	also	RB
18637	24920	7	_	_	NNP
18637	24920	8	President	President	NNP
18637	24920	9	:	:	:
18637	24920	10	Powers	power	NNS
18637	24920	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24920	12	:	:	:
18637	24920	13	Distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	24920	14	from	from	IN
18637	24920	15	Treaties	Treaties	NNP
18637	24920	16	,	,	,
18637	24920	17	433	433	CD
18637	24920	18	,	,	,
18637	24920	19	442	442	CD
18637	24920	20	,	,	,
18637	24920	21	444	444	CD
18637	24920	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	24920	23	445	445	CD
18637	24920	24	Examples	Examples	NNPS
18637	24920	25	of	of	IN
18637	24920	26	,	,	,
18637	24920	27	authorized	authorize	VBN
18637	24920	28	,	,	,
18637	24920	29	approved	approve	VBN
18637	24920	30	by	by	IN
18637	24920	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24920	32	,	,	,
18637	24920	33	419	419	CD
18637	24920	34	,	,	,
18637	24920	35	433	433	CD
18637	24920	36	,	,	,
18637	24920	37	441	441	CD
18637	24920	38	-	-	SYM
18637	24920	39	443	443	CD
18637	24920	40	,	,	,
18637	24920	41	445	445	CD
18637	24920	42	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	24920	43	,	,	,
18637	24920	44	over	over	IN
18637	24920	45	conflicting	conflict	VBG
18637	24920	46	State	state	NN
18637	24920	47	laws	law	NNS
18637	24920	48	,	,	,
18637	24920	49	1201	1201	CD
18637	24920	50	Types	type	NNS
18637	24920	51	of	of	IN
18637	24920	52	,	,	,
18637	24920	53	419	419	CD
18637	24920	54	,	,	,
18637	24920	55	433	433	CD
18637	24920	56	-	-	SYM
18637	24920	57	445	445	CD
18637	24920	58	Validity	validity	NN
18637	24920	59	,	,	,
18637	24920	60	binding	bind	VBG
18637	24920	61	effect	effect	NN
18637	24920	62	of	of	IN
18637	24920	63	,	,	,
18637	24920	64	433	433	CD
18637	24920	65	-	-	SYM
18637	24920	66	444	444	CD
18637	24920	67	Exports	export	NNS
18637	24920	68	.	.	.
18637	24921	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24921	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24921	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24921	4	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24921	5	;	;	:
18637	24921	6	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	24921	7	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24921	8	;	;	:
18637	24921	9	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	24921	10	.	.	.
18637	24922	1	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	24922	2	Post	Post	NNP
18637	24922	3	Facto	Facto	NNP
18637	24922	4	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	24922	5	:	:	:
18637	24922	6	Application	application	NN
18637	24922	7	to	to	IN
18637	24922	8	war	war	NN
18637	24922	9	criminals	criminal	NNS
18637	24922	10	,	,	,
18637	24922	11	402	402	CD
18637	24922	12	-	-	SYM
18637	24922	13	403	403	CD
18637	24922	14	Defined	define	VBN
18637	24922	15	,	,	,
18637	24922	16	316	316	CD
18637	24922	17	-	-	SYM
18637	24922	18	317	317	CD
18637	24922	19	Passage	Passage	NNP
18637	24922	20	by	by	IN
18637	24922	21	States	States	NNP
18637	24922	22	,	,	,
18637	24922	23	scope	scope	NN
18637	24922	24	of	of	IN
18637	24922	25	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	24922	26	,	,	,
18637	24922	27	327	327	CD
18637	24922	28	-	-	SYM
18637	24922	29	329	329	CD
18637	24922	30	Test	test	NN
18637	24922	31	oaths	oath	NNS
18637	24922	32	for	for	IN
18637	24922	33	office	office	NN
18637	24922	34	holding	holding	NN
18637	24922	35	,	,	,
18637	24922	36	736	736	CD
18637	24922	37	Extradition	Extradition	NNP
18637	24922	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24922	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24922	40	see	see	VBP
18637	24922	41	also	also	RB
18637	24922	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24922	43	Habeas	Habeas	NNP
18637	24922	44	Corpus	Corpus	NNP
18637	24922	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24922	46	:	:	:
18637	24922	47	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24922	48	,	,	,
18637	24922	49	powers	power	NNS
18637	24922	50	as	as	IN
18637	24922	51	to	to	IN
18637	24922	52	,	,	,
18637	24922	53	693	693	CD
18637	24922	54	-	-	SYM
18637	24922	55	694	694	CD
18637	24922	56	Duty	Duty	NNP
18637	24922	57	of	of	IN
18637	24922	58	State	State	NNP
18637	24922	59	to	to	TO
18637	24922	60	surrender	surrender	VB
18637	24922	61	fugitives	fugitive	NNS
18637	24922	62	,	,	,
18637	24922	63	693	693	CD
18637	24922	64	-	-	SYM
18637	24922	65	694	694	CD
18637	24922	66	,	,	,
18637	24922	67	738	738	CD
18637	24922	68	Felons	felon	NNS
18637	24922	69	fleeing	flee	VBG
18637	24922	70	District	District	NNP
18637	24922	71	of	of	IN
18637	24922	72	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	24922	73	,	,	,
18637	24922	74	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
18637	24922	75	,	,	,
18637	24922	76	303	303	CD
18637	24922	77	to	to	IN
18637	24922	78	Foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	24922	79	nations	nation	NNS
18637	24922	80	,	,	,
18637	24922	81	by	by	IN
18637	24922	82	President	President	NNP
18637	24922	83	,	,	,
18637	24922	84	464	464	CD
18637	24922	85	to	to	IN
18637	24922	86	Foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	24922	87	nations	nation	NNS
18637	24922	88	,	,	,
18637	24922	89	by	by	IN
18637	24922	90	States	state	NNS
18637	24922	91	,	,	,
18637	24922	92	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	24922	93	,	,	,
18637	24922	94	325	325	CD
18637	24922	95	Fugitive	fugitive	JJ
18637	24922	96	from	from	IN
18637	24922	97	justice	justice	NN
18637	24922	98	defined	define	VBN
18637	24922	99	,	,	,
18637	24922	100	694	694	CD
18637	24922	101	-	-	SYM
18637	24922	102	695	695	CD
18637	24922	103	Removal	removal	NN
18637	24922	104	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	24922	105	,	,	,
18637	24922	106	rights	right	NNS
18637	24922	107	of	of	IN
18637	24922	108	fugitive	fugitive	JJ
18637	24922	109	,	,	,
18637	24922	110	695	695	CD
18637	24922	111	-	-	SYM
18637	24922	112	696	696	CD
18637	24922	113	F	F	NNP
18637	24922	114	Fair	Fair	NNP
18637	24922	115	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	24922	116	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24922	117	_	_	NNP
18637	24922	118	see	see	VBP
18637	24922	119	also	also	RB
18637	24922	120	_	_	NNP
18637	24922	121	Attorneys	Attorneys	NNP
18637	24922	122	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24922	123	,	,	,
18637	24922	124	1098	1098	CD
18637	24922	125	-	-	SYM
18637	24922	126	1109	1109	CD
18637	24922	127	,	,	,
18637	24922	128	1111	1111	CD
18637	24922	129	-	-	SYM
18637	24922	130	1113	1113	CD
18637	24922	131	,	,	,
18637	24922	132	1129	1129	CD
18637	24922	133	-	-	SYM
18637	24922	134	1133	1133	CD
18637	24922	135	,	,	,
18637	24922	136	1138	1138	CD
18637	24922	137	-	-	SYM
18637	24922	138	1139	1139	CD
18637	24922	139	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24922	140	-	-	HYPH
18637	24922	141	State	State	NNP
18637	24922	142	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	24922	143	,	,	,
18637	24922	144	736	736	CD
18637	24922	145	-	-	SYM
18637	24922	146	739	739	CD
18637	24922	147	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24922	148	Supremacy	Supremacy	NNP
18637	24922	149	.	.	.
18637	24923	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24923	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24923	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24923	4	National	National	NNP
18637	24923	5	Supremacy	Supremacy	NNP
18637	24923	6	.	.	.
18637	24924	1	Felonies	Felonies	NNP
18637	24924	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24924	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24924	4	see	see	VBP
18637	24924	5	also	also	RB
18637	24924	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24924	7	Crimes	Crimes	NNPS
18637	24924	8	and	and	CC
18637	24924	9	Offenses	Offenses	NNPS
18637	24924	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24924	11	:	:	:
18637	24924	12	Committed	commit	VBN
18637	24924	13	on	on	IN
18637	24924	14	high	high	JJ
18637	24924	15	seas	sea	NNS
18637	24924	16	,	,	,
18637	24924	17	power	power	NN
18637	24924	18	of	of	IN
18637	24924	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24924	20	as	as	IN
18637	24924	21	to	to	IN
18637	24924	22	,	,	,
18637	24924	23	277	277	CD
18637	24924	24	-	-	SYM
18637	24924	25	279	279	CD
18637	24924	26	Ferries	Ferries	NNPS
18637	24924	27	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24924	28	_	_	NNP
18637	24924	29	see	see	VBP
18637	24924	30	also	also	RB
18637	24924	31	_	_	NNP
18637	24924	32	Carriers	Carriers	NNP
18637	24924	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24924	34	:	:	:
18637	24924	35	on	on	IN
18637	24924	36	Navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	24924	37	streams	stream	NNS
18637	24924	38	,	,	,
18637	24924	39	State	state	NN
18637	24924	40	powers	power	NNS
18637	24924	41	over	over	IN
18637	24924	42	,	,	,
18637	24924	43	231	231	CD
18637	24924	44	Firearms	firearm	NNS
18637	24924	45	.	.	.
18637	24925	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24925	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24925	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24925	4	Bearing	Bearing	NNP
18637	24925	5	Arms	Arms	NNP
18637	24925	6	.	.	.
18637	24926	1	Fish	fish	NN
18637	24926	2	,	,	,
18637	24926	3	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	24926	4	of	of	IN
18637	24926	5	,	,	,
18637	24926	6	powers	power	NNS
18637	24926	7	of	of	IN
18637	24926	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24926	9	,	,	,
18637	24926	10	217	217	CD
18637	24926	11	,	,	,
18637	24926	12	245	245	CD
18637	24926	13	,	,	,
18637	24926	14	690	690	CD
18637	24926	15	,	,	,
18637	24926	16	1027	1027	CD
18637	24926	17	Flag	flag	NN
18637	24926	18	,	,	,
18637	24926	19	reproduction	reproduction	NN
18637	24926	20	on	on	IN
18637	24926	21	salable	salable	JJ
18637	24926	22	articles	article	NNS
18637	24926	23	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	24926	24	,	,	,
18637	24926	25	1154	1154	CD
18637	24926	26	Flag	Flag	NNP
18637	24926	27	Salute	Salute	NNP
18637	24926	28	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	24926	29	.	.	.
18637	24927	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24927	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24927	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24927	4	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	24927	5	of	of	IN
18637	24927	6	Religion	Religion	NNP
18637	24927	7	,	,	,
18637	24927	8	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	24927	9	,	,	,
18637	24927	10	Press	Press	NNP
18637	24927	11	,	,	,
18637	24927	12	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
18637	24927	13	.	.	.
18637	24928	1	Flood	Flood	NNP
18637	24928	2	Control	Control	NNP
18637	24928	3	,	,	,
18637	24928	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24928	5	power	power	NN
18637	24928	6	as	as	IN
18637	24928	7	to	to	IN
18637	24928	8	,	,	,
18637	24928	9	132	132	CD
18637	24928	10	Food	Food	NNP
18637	24928	11	,	,	,
18637	24928	12	State	State	NNP
18637	24928	13	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24928	14	as	as	IN
18637	24928	15	to	to	TO
18637	24928	16	manufacture	manufacture	VB
18637	24928	17	,	,	,
18637	24928	18	sale	sale	NN
18637	24928	19	,	,	,
18637	24928	20	purity	purity	NN
18637	24928	21	,	,	,
18637	24928	22	labelling	labelling	NN
18637	24928	23	,	,	,
18637	24928	24	weights	weight	NNS
18637	24928	25	,	,	,
18637	24928	26	etc	etc	FW
18637	24928	27	.	.	.
18637	24928	28	,	,	,
18637	24928	29	248	248	CD
18637	24928	30	,	,	,
18637	24928	31	250	250	CD
18637	24928	32	,	,	,
18637	24928	33	1030	1030	CD
18637	24928	34	,	,	,
18637	24928	35	1154	1154	CD
18637	24928	36	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	24928	37	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24928	38	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24928	39	_	_	NNP
18637	24928	40	see	see	VBP
18637	24928	41	also	also	RB
18637	24928	42	_	_	NNP
18637	24928	43	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24928	44	;	;	:
18637	24928	45	Game	Game	NNP
18637	24928	46	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24928	47	:	:	:
18637	24928	48	Prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	24928	49	of	of	IN
18637	24928	50	,	,	,
18637	24928	51	by	by	IN
18637	24928	52	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24928	53	,	,	,
18637	24928	54	160	160	CD
18637	24928	55	-	-	SYM
18637	24928	56	163	163	CD
18637	24928	57	State	State	NNP
18637	24928	58	police	police	NNS
18637	24928	59	and	and	CC
18637	24928	60	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	24928	61	powers	power	NNS
18637	24928	62	,	,	,
18637	24928	63	relation	relation	NN
18637	24928	64	to	to	IN
18637	24928	65	,	,	,
18637	24928	66	177	177	CD
18637	24928	67	-	-	SYM
18637	24928	68	178	178	CD
18637	24928	69	,	,	,
18637	24928	70	215	215	CD
18637	24928	71	-	-	SYM
18637	24928	72	217	217	CD
18637	24928	73	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	24928	74	Corporations	Corporations	NNPS
18637	24928	75	.	.	.
18637	24929	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24929	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24929	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24929	4	Corporations	Corporations	NNPS
18637	24929	5	.	.	.
18637	24930	1	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	24930	2	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	24930	3	.	.	.
18637	24931	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24931	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24931	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24931	4	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	24931	5	Agreements	Agreements	NNPS
18637	24931	6	;	;	:
18637	24931	7	President	President	NNP
18637	24931	8	:	:	:
18637	24931	9	Powers	power	NNS
18637	24931	10	;	;	:
18637	24931	11	Recognition	Recognition	NNP
18637	24931	12	;	;	:
18637	24931	13	Treaties	Treaties	NNP
18637	24931	14	.	.	.
18637	24932	1	Forts	fort	NNS
18637	24932	2	,	,	,
18637	24932	3	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24932	4	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24932	5	over	over	RB
18637	24932	6	,	,	,
18637	24932	7	300	300	CD
18637	24932	8	,	,	,
18637	24932	9	305	305	CD
18637	24932	10	-	-	SYM
18637	24932	11	307	307	CD
18637	24932	12	Franchise	Franchise	NNP
18637	24932	13	Taxes	Taxes	NNPS
18637	24932	14	.	.	.
18637	24933	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24933	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24933	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24933	4	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	24933	5	.	.	.
18637	24934	1	Fraud	fraud	NN
18637	24934	2	,	,	,
18637	24934	3	in	in	IN
18637	24934	4	sales	sale	NNS
18637	24934	5	,	,	,
18637	24934	6	prevention	prevention	NN
18637	24934	7	by	by	IN
18637	24934	8	States	state	NNS
18637	24934	9	,	,	,
18637	24934	10	etc	etc	FW
18637	24934	11	.	.	FW
18637	24934	12	,	,	,
18637	24934	13	1018	1018	CD
18637	24934	14	-	-	SYM
18637	24934	15	1019	1019	CD
18637	24934	16	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	24934	17	of	of	IN
18637	24934	18	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
18637	24934	19	.	.	.
18637	24935	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24935	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24935	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24935	4	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	24935	5	of	of	IN
18637	24935	6	Religion	Religion	NNP
18637	24935	7	,	,	,
18637	24935	8	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	24935	9	,	,	,
18637	24935	10	Press	Press	NNP
18637	24935	11	,	,	,
18637	24935	12	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
18637	24935	13	.	.	.
18637	24936	1	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	24936	2	of	of	IN
18637	24936	3	Press	Press	NNP
18637	24936	4	.	.	.
18637	24937	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24937	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24937	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24937	4	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	24937	5	of	of	IN
18637	24937	6	Religion	Religion	NNP
18637	24937	7	,	,	,
18637	24937	8	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	24937	9	,	,	,
18637	24937	10	Press	Press	NNP
18637	24937	11	,	,	,
18637	24937	12	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
18637	24937	13	.	.	.
18637	24938	1	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	24938	2	of	of	IN
18637	24938	3	Religion	Religion	NNP
18637	24938	4	,	,	,
18637	24938	5	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	24938	6	,	,	,
18637	24938	7	Press	Press	NNP
18637	24938	8	,	,	,
18637	24938	9	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
18637	24938	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24938	11	_	_	NNP
18637	24938	12	see	see	VBP
18637	24938	13	also	also	RB
18637	24938	14	_	_	NNP
18637	24938	15	Communists	Communists	NNPS
18637	24938	16	;	;	:
18637	24938	17	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	24938	18	;	;	:
18637	24938	19	Labor	labor	NN
18637	24938	20	;	;	:
18637	24938	21	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24938	22	,	,	,
18637	24938	23	Air	Air	NNP
18637	24938	24	and	and	CC
18637	24938	25	Naval	Naval	NNP
18637	24938	26	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	24938	27	;	;	:
18637	24938	28	Lobbying	Lobbying	NNP
18637	24938	29	;	;	:
18637	24938	30	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	24938	31	Service	Service	NNP
18637	24938	32	;	;	:
18637	24938	33	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24938	34	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	24938	35	of	of	IN
18637	24938	36	the	the	DT
18637	24938	37	United	United	NNP
18637	24938	38	States	States	NNP
18637	24938	39	;	;	:
18637	24938	40	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	24938	41	;	;	:
18637	24938	42	States	state	NNS
18637	24938	43	:	:	:
18637	24938	44	Officers	officer	NNS
18637	24938	45	;	;	:
18637	24938	46	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	24938	47	Court	Court	NNP
18637	24938	48	of	of	IN
18637	24938	49	the	the	DT
18637	24938	50	United	United	NNP
18637	24938	51	States	States	NNP
18637	24938	52	;	;	:
18637	24938	53	War	War	NNP
18637	24938	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24938	55	:	:	:
18637	24938	56	of	of	IN
18637	24938	57	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
18637	24938	58	and	and	CC
18637	24938	59	petition	petition	NN
18637	24938	60	;	;	:
18637	24938	61	history	history	NN
18637	24938	62	,	,	,
18637	24938	63	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	24938	64	on	on	IN
18637	24938	65	,	,	,
18637	24938	66	805	805	CD
18637	24938	67	-	-	SYM
18637	24938	68	810	810	CD
18637	24938	69	Clear	clear	JJ
18637	24938	70	and	and	CC
18637	24938	71	present	present	JJ
18637	24938	72	danger	danger	NN
18637	24938	73	rule	rule	NN
18637	24938	74	,	,	,
18637	24938	75	772	772	CD
18637	24938	76	-	-	HYPH
18637	24938	77	784	784	CD
18637	24938	78	,	,	,
18637	24938	79	787	787	CD
18637	24938	80	-	-	HYPH
18637	24938	81	792	792	CD
18637	24938	82	,	,	,
18637	24938	83	794	794	CD
18637	24938	84	-	-	SYM
18637	24938	85	801	801	CD
18637	24938	86	Guaranty	Guaranty	NNP
18637	24938	87	of	of	IN
18637	24938	88	,	,	,
18637	24938	89	absorption	absorption	NN
18637	24938	90	into	into	IN
18637	24938	91	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	24938	92	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	24938	93	,	,	,
18637	24938	94	757	757	CD
18637	24938	95	of	of	IN
18637	24938	96	Press	Press	NNP
18637	24938	97	,	,	,
18637	24938	98	contempt	contempt	NN
18637	24938	99	of	of	IN
18637	24938	100	court	court	NN
18637	24938	101	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	24938	102	as	as	IN
18637	24938	103	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	24938	104	on	on	IN
18637	24938	105	,	,	,
18637	24938	106	517	517	CD
18637	24938	107	,	,	,
18637	24938	108	783	783	CD
18637	24938	109	-	-	SYM
18637	24938	110	784	784	CD
18637	24938	111	of	of	IN
18637	24938	112	Press	Press	NNP
18637	24938	113	,	,	,
18637	24938	114	group	group	NN
18637	24938	115	libel	libel	NN
18637	24938	116	laws	law	NNS
18637	24938	117	as	as	IN
18637	24938	118	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	24938	119	on	on	IN
18637	24938	120	,	,	,
18637	24938	121	802	802	CD
18637	24938	122	-	-	SYM
18637	24938	123	804	804	CD
18637	24938	124	of	of	IN
18637	24938	125	Press	Press	NNP
18637	24938	126	,	,	,
18637	24938	127	motion	motion	NN
18637	24938	128	picture	picture	NN
18637	24938	129	censorship	censorship	NN
18637	24938	130	,	,	,
18637	24938	131	validity	validity	NN
18637	24938	132	,	,	,
18637	24938	133	787	787	CD
18637	24938	134	-	-	HYPH
18637	24938	135	788	788	CD
18637	24938	136	of	of	IN
18637	24938	137	Religion	Religion	NNP
18637	24938	138	,	,	,
18637	24938	139	compulsory	compulsory	JJ
18637	24938	140	public	public	JJ
18637	24938	141	school	school	NN
18637	24938	142	attendance	attendance	NN
18637	24938	143	,	,	,
18637	24938	144	effect	effect	NN
18637	24938	145	on	on	IN
18637	24938	146	,	,	,
18637	24938	147	765	765	CD
18637	24938	148	of	of	IN
18637	24938	149	Religion	religion	NN
18637	24938	150	,	,	,
18637	24938	151	liability	liability	NN
18637	24938	152	to	to	IN
18637	24938	153	military	military	JJ
18637	24938	154	service	service	NN
18637	24938	155	as	as	IN
18637	24938	156	condition	condition	NN
18637	24938	157	prerequisite	prerequisite	JJ
18637	24938	158	to	to	IN
18637	24938	159	certain	certain	JJ
18637	24938	160	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	24938	161	,	,	,
18637	24938	162	effect	effect	NN
18637	24938	163	on	on	IN
18637	24938	164	,	,	,
18637	24938	165	768	768	CD
18637	24938	166	of	of	IN
18637	24938	167	Religion	religion	NN
18637	24938	168	,	,	,
18637	24938	169	"	"	``
18637	24938	170	no	no	DT
18637	24938	171	preference	preference	NN
18637	24938	172	"	"	''
18637	24938	173	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	24938	174	,	,	,
18637	24938	175	758	758	CD
18637	24938	176	-	-	SYM
18637	24938	177	759	759	CD
18637	24938	178	of	of	IN
18637	24938	179	Religion	Religion	NNP
18637	24938	180	,	,	,
18637	24938	181	public	public	JJ
18637	24938	182	bus	bus	NN
18637	24938	183	transportation	transportation	NN
18637	24938	184	for	for	IN
18637	24938	185	parochial	parochial	JJ
18637	24938	186	schools	school	NNS
18637	24938	187	,	,	,
18637	24938	188	effect	effect	NN
18637	24938	189	on	on	IN
18637	24938	190	,	,	,
18637	24938	191	759	759	CD
18637	24938	192	,	,	,
18637	24938	193	764	764	CD
18637	24938	194	of	of	IN
18637	24938	195	Religion	religion	NN
18637	24938	196	,	,	,
18637	24938	197	"	"	''
18637	24938	198	released	release	VBN
18637	24938	199	time	time	NN
18637	24938	200	"	"	''
18637	24938	201	for	for	IN
18637	24938	202	religious	religious	JJ
18637	24938	203	instruction	instruction	NN
18637	24938	204	,	,	,
18637	24938	205	effect	effect	NN
18637	24938	206	on	on	IN
18637	24938	207	,	,	,
18637	24938	208	760	760	CD
18637	24938	209	-	-	SYM
18637	24938	210	763	763	CD
18637	24938	211	of	of	IN
18637	24938	212	Religion	religion	NN
18637	24938	213	,	,	,
18637	24938	214	rights	right	NNS
18637	24938	215	of	of	IN
18637	24938	216	Mormons	Mormons	NNP
18637	24938	217	,	,	,
18637	24938	218	759	759	CD
18637	24938	219	of	of	IN
18637	24938	220	Religion	religion	NN
18637	24938	221	,	,	,
18637	24938	222	scope	scope	NN
18637	24938	223	,	,	,
18637	24938	224	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	24938	225	on	on	RB
18637	24938	226	,	,	,
18637	24938	227	563	563	CD
18637	24938	228	-	-	SYM
18637	24938	229	564	564	CD
18637	24938	230	,	,	,
18637	24938	231	764	764	CD
18637	24938	232	-	-	SYM
18637	24938	233	769	769	CD
18637	24938	234	of	of	IN
18637	24938	235	Religion	religion	NN
18637	24938	236	,	,	,
18637	24938	237	"	"	''
18637	24938	238	wall	wall	NN
18637	24938	239	of	of	IN
18637	24938	240	separation	separation	NN
18637	24938	241	"	"	''
18637	24938	242	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	24938	243	,	,	,
18637	24938	244	759	759	CD
18637	24938	245	-	-	SYM
18637	24938	246	763	763	CD
18637	24938	247	Religious	religious	JJ
18637	24938	248	property	property	NN
18637	24938	249	,	,	,
18637	24938	250	tax	tax	NN
18637	24938	251	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	24938	252	,	,	,
18637	24938	253	validity	validity	NN
18637	24938	254	,	,	,
18637	24938	255	764	764	CD
18637	24938	256	Religious	religious	JJ
18637	24938	257	schools	school	NNS
18637	24938	258	,	,	,
18637	24938	259	free	free	JJ
18637	24938	260	textbooks	textbook	NNS
18637	24938	261	for	for	IN
18637	24938	262	,	,	,
18637	24938	263	effect	effect	NN
18637	24938	264	on	on	IN
18637	24938	265	,	,	,
18637	24938	266	764	764	CD
18637	24938	267	of	of	IN
18637	24938	268	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	24938	269	and	and	CC
18637	24938	270	press	press	NN
18637	24938	271	,	,	,
18637	24938	272	censorship	censorship	NN
18637	24938	273	,	,	,
18637	24938	274	786	786	CD
18637	24938	275	-	-	SYM
18637	24938	276	788	788	CD
18637	24938	277	of	of	IN
18637	24938	278	Speech	speech	NN
18637	24938	279	and	and	CC
18637	24938	280	press	press	NN
18637	24938	281	,	,	,
18637	24938	282	in	in	IN
18637	24938	283	parks	park	NNS
18637	24938	284	and	and	CC
18637	24938	285	streets	street	NNS
18637	24938	286	,	,	,
18637	24938	287	784	784	CD
18637	24938	288	-	-	SYM
18637	24938	289	786	786	CD
18637	24938	290	,	,	,
18637	24938	291	791	791	CD
18637	24938	292	of	of	IN
18637	24938	293	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	24938	294	and	and	CC
18637	24938	295	press	press	NN
18637	24938	296	,	,	,
18637	24938	297	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	24938	298	by	by	IN
18637	24938	299	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24938	300	,	,	,
18637	24938	301	labor	labor	NN
18637	24938	302	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24938	303	,	,	,
18637	24938	304	etc	etc	FW
18637	24938	305	.	.	.
18637	24938	306	,	,	,
18637	24938	307	792	792	CD
18637	24938	308	-	-	SYM
18637	24938	309	793	793	CD
18637	24938	310	of	of	IN
18637	24938	311	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	24938	312	and	and	CC
18637	24938	313	press	press	NN
18637	24938	314	,	,	,
18637	24938	315	scope	scope	NN
18637	24938	316	,	,	,
18637	24938	317	769	769	CD
18637	24938	318	-	-	SYM
18637	24938	319	805	805	CD
18637	24938	320	of	of	IN
18637	24938	321	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	24938	322	,	,	,
18637	24938	323	curbs	curb	NNS
18637	24938	324	on	on	IN
18637	24938	325	sound	sound	JJ
18637	24938	326	trucks	truck	NNS
18637	24938	327	,	,	,
18637	24938	328	street	street	NN
18637	24938	329	car	car	NN
18637	24938	330	radios	radio	NNS
18637	24938	331	,	,	,
18637	24938	332	effect	effect	NN
18637	24938	333	on	on	IN
18637	24938	334	,	,	,
18637	24938	335	767	767	CD
18637	24938	336	,	,	,
18637	24938	337	785	785	CD
18637	24938	338	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	24938	339	of	of	IN
18637	24938	340	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	24938	341	.	.	.
18637	24939	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24939	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24939	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24939	4	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	24939	5	of	of	IN
18637	24939	6	Religion	Religion	NNP
18637	24939	7	,	,	,
18637	24939	8	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	24939	9	,	,	,
18637	24939	10	Press	Press	NNP
18637	24939	11	,	,	,
18637	24939	12	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
18637	24939	13	.	.	.
18637	24940	1	Fruit	fruit	NN
18637	24940	2	:	:	:
18637	24940	3	Export	export	NN
18637	24940	4	of	of	IN
18637	24940	5	,	,	,
18637	24940	6	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	24940	7	by	by	IN
18637	24940	8	States	States	NNP
18637	24940	9	,	,	,
18637	24940	10	243	243	CD
18637	24940	11	-	-	SYM
18637	24940	12	244	244	CD
18637	24940	13	,	,	,
18637	24940	14	1027	1027	CD
18637	24940	15	Immature	immature	JJ
18637	24940	16	citrus	citrus	NN
18637	24940	17	fruit	fruit	NN
18637	24940	18	,	,	,
18637	24940	19	exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	24940	20	by	by	IN
18637	24940	21	States	state	NNS
18637	24940	22	from	from	IN
18637	24940	23	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	24940	24	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	24940	25	,	,	,
18637	24940	26	1027	1027	CD
18637	24940	27	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	24940	28	of	of	IN
18637	24940	29	orchards	orchard	NNS
18637	24940	30	by	by	IN
18637	24940	31	State	state	NN
18637	24940	32	by	by	IN
18637	24940	33	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	24940	34	of	of	IN
18637	24940	35	private	private	JJ
18637	24940	36	property	property	NN
18637	24940	37	,	,	,
18637	24940	38	1026	1026	CD
18637	24940	39	-	-	SYM
18637	24940	40	1027	1027	CD
18637	24940	41	Fugitive	Fugitive	NNP
18637	24940	42	Slave	Slave	NNP
18637	24940	43	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	24940	44	,	,	,
18637	24940	45	696	696	CD
18637	24940	46	Fugitives	fugitive	NNS
18637	24940	47	from	from	IN
18637	24940	48	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	24940	49	.	.	.
18637	24941	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24941	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24941	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24941	4	Extradition	Extradition	NNP
18637	24941	5	.	.	.
18637	24942	1	Full	full	JJ
18637	24942	2	Faith	Faith	NNP
18637	24942	3	and	and	CC
18637	24942	4	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	24942	5	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	24942	6	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24942	7	_	_	NNP
18637	24942	8	see	see	VBP
18637	24942	9	also	also	RB
18637	24942	10	_	_	NNP
18637	24942	11	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24942	12	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24942	13	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24942	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24942	15	;	;	:
18637	24942	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	24942	17	Court	Court	NNP
18637	24942	18	of	of	IN
18637	24942	19	the	the	DT
18637	24942	20	United	United	NNP
18637	24942	21	States	States	NNP
18637	24942	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24942	23	:	:	:
18637	24942	24	Adoption	adoption	NN
18637	24942	25	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	24942	26	,	,	,
18637	24942	27	effect	effect	NN
18637	24942	28	on	on	IN
18637	24942	29	inheritance	inheritance	NN
18637	24942	30	in	in	IN
18637	24942	31	forum	forum	NN
18637	24942	32	State	State	NNP
18637	24942	33	,	,	,
18637	24942	34	673	673	CD
18637	24942	35	Common	common	JJ
18637	24942	36	law	law	NN
18637	24942	37	,	,	,
18637	24942	38	statutory	statutory	JJ
18637	24942	39	,	,	,
18637	24942	40	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	24942	41	rights	right	NNS
18637	24942	42	,	,	,
18637	24942	43	scope	scope	NN
18637	24942	44	of	of	IN
18637	24942	45	recognition	recognition	NN
18637	24942	46	by	by	IN
18637	24942	47	States	States	NNP
18637	24942	48	,	,	,
18637	24942	49	675	675	CD
18637	24942	50	-	-	SYM
18637	24942	51	683	683	CD
18637	24942	52	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24942	53	,	,	,
18637	24942	54	power	power	NN
18637	24942	55	to	to	TO
18637	24942	56	effectuate	effectuate	VB
18637	24942	57	,	,	,
18637	24942	58	651	651	CD
18637	24942	59	-	-	SYM
18637	24942	60	652	652	CD
18637	24942	61	,	,	,
18637	24942	62	657	657	CD
18637	24942	63	,	,	,
18637	24942	64	683	683	CD
18637	24942	65	-	-	SYM
18637	24942	66	685	685	CD
18637	24942	67	Decrees	Decrees	NNPS
18637	24942	68	awarding	award	VBG
18637	24942	69	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	24942	70	,	,	,
18637	24942	71	custody	custody	NN
18637	24942	72	of	of	IN
18637	24942	73	children	child	NNS
18637	24942	74	,	,	,
18637	24942	75	670	670	CD
18637	24942	76	-	-	SYM
18637	24942	77	671	671	CD
18637	24942	78	Divorce	Divorce	NNP
18637	24942	79	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	24942	80	,	,	,
18637	24942	81	domicile	domicile	VBP
18637	24942	82	as	as	IN
18637	24942	83	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	24942	84	prerequisite	prerequisite	NN
18637	24942	85	to	to	IN
18637	24942	86	;	;	:
18637	24942	87	effect	effect	NN
18637	24942	88	on	on	IN
18637	24942	89	alimony	alimony	NN
18637	24942	90	,	,	,
18637	24942	91	custody	custody	NN
18637	24942	92	of	of	IN
18637	24942	93	children	child	NNS
18637	24942	94	,	,	,
18637	24942	95	property	property	NN
18637	24942	96	,	,	,
18637	24942	97	662	662	CD
18637	24942	98	-	-	SYM
18637	24942	99	670	670	CD
18637	24942	100	Garnishment	Garnishment	NNP
18637	24942	101	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	24942	102	,	,	,
18637	24942	103	673	673	CD
18637	24942	104	-	-	SYM
18637	24942	105	674	674	CD
18637	24942	106	Judgments	Judgments	NNPS
18637	24942	107	,	,	,
18637	24942	108	effect	effect	NN
18637	24942	109	in	in	IN
18637	24942	110	forum	forum	NN
18637	24942	111	State	State	NNP
18637	24942	112	,	,	,
18637	24942	113	limits	limit	NNS
18637	24942	114	,	,	,
18637	24942	115	653	653	CD
18637	24942	116	-	-	SYM
18637	24942	117	674	674	CD
18637	24942	118	,	,	,
18637	24942	119	685	685	CD
18637	24942	120	Judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	24942	121	,	,	,
18637	24942	122	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	24942	123	as	as	IN
18637	24942	124	defense	defense	NN
18637	24942	125	to	to	IN
18637	24942	126	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	24942	127	of	of	IN
18637	24942	128	,	,	,
18637	24942	129	674	674	CD
18637	24942	130	Judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	24942	131	,	,	,
18637	24942	132	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24942	133	prerequisite	prerequisite	JJ
18637	24942	134	to	to	IN
18637	24942	135	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	24942	136	,	,	,
18637	24942	137	657	657	CD
18637	24942	138	-	-	SYM
18637	24942	139	670	670	CD
18637	24942	140	,	,	,
18637	24942	141	682	682	CD
18637	24942	142	-	-	HYPH
18637	24942	143	683	683	CD
18637	24942	144	Penal	Penal	NNP
18637	24942	145	judgments	judgment	NNS
18637	24942	146	,	,	,
18637	24942	147	limits	limit	NNS
18637	24942	148	on	on	IN
18637	24942	149	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	24942	150	,	,	,
18637	24942	151	674	674	CD
18637	24942	152	-	-	HYPH
18637	24942	153	675	675	CD
18637	24942	154	Probate	probate	JJ
18637	24942	155	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	24942	156	,	,	,
18637	24942	157	672	672	CD
18637	24942	158	-	-	SYM
18637	24942	159	673	673	CD
18637	24942	160	Purpose	purpose	NN
18637	24942	161	of	of	IN
18637	24942	162	clause	clause	NN
18637	24942	163	,	,	,
18637	24942	164	652	652	CD
18637	24942	165	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	24942	166	against	against	IN
18637	24942	167	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	24942	168	,	,	,
18637	24942	169	by	by	IN
18637	24942	170	stockholders	stockholder	NNS
18637	24942	171	,	,	,
18637	24942	172	creditors	creditor	NNS
18637	24942	173	,	,	,
18637	24942	174	policy	policy	NN
18637	24942	175	holders	holder	NNS
18637	24942	176	,	,	,
18637	24942	177	law	law	NN
18637	24942	178	applied	apply	VBN
18637	24942	179	by	by	IN
18637	24942	180	forum	forum	NN
18637	24942	181	,	,	,
18637	24942	182	677	677	CD
18637	24942	183	-	-	SYM
18637	24942	184	681	681	CD
18637	24942	185	Tort	tort	NN
18637	24942	186	and	and	CC
18637	24942	187	contract	contract	NN
18637	24942	188	actions	action	NNS
18637	24942	189	,	,	,
18637	24942	190	law	law	NN
18637	24942	191	applied	apply	VBN
18637	24942	192	by	by	IN
18637	24942	193	forum	forum	NN
18637	24942	194	,	,	,
18637	24942	195	677	677	CD
18637	24942	196	,	,	,
18637	24942	197	681	681	CD
18637	24942	198	-	-	SYM
18637	24942	199	682	682	CD
18637	24942	200	Workmen	Workmen	NNP
18637	24942	201	's	's	POS
18637	24942	202	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	24942	203	acts	act	NNS
18637	24942	204	,	,	,
18637	24942	205	application	application	NN
18637	24942	206	in	in	IN
18637	24942	207	forum	forum	NN
18637	24942	208	,	,	,
18637	24942	209	681	681	CD
18637	24942	210	-	-	SYM
18637	24942	211	682	682	CD
18637	24942	212	G	g	NN
18637	24942	213	Gambling	gambling	NN
18637	24942	214	:	:	:
18637	24942	215	Building	building	NN
18637	24942	216	used	use	VBN
18637	24942	217	for	for	IN
18637	24942	218	,	,	,
18637	24942	219	lien	lien	NNP
18637	24942	220	on	on	RP
18637	24942	221	,	,	,
18637	24942	222	for	for	IN
18637	24942	223	money	money	NN
18637	24942	224	lost	lose	VBN
18637	24942	225	,	,	,
18637	24942	226	1031	1031	CD
18637	24942	227	Lotteries	lottery	NNS
18637	24942	228	,	,	,
18637	24942	229	etc	etc	FW
18637	24942	230	.	.	FW
18637	24942	231	,	,	,
18637	24942	232	State	state	NN
18637	24942	233	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	24942	234	of	of	IN
18637	24942	235	,	,	,
18637	24942	236	1031	1031	CD
18637	24942	237	Game	Game	NNP
18637	24942	238	,	,	,
18637	24942	239	conservation	conservation	NN
18637	24942	240	,	,	,
18637	24942	241	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	24942	242	on	on	IN
18637	24942	243	export	export	NN
18637	24942	244	of	of	IN
18637	24942	245	,	,	,
18637	24942	246	by	by	IN
18637	24942	247	States	States	NNP
18637	24942	248	,	,	,
18637	24942	249	217	217	CD
18637	24942	250	,	,	,
18637	24942	251	242	242	CD
18637	24942	252	-	-	SYM
18637	24942	253	243	243	CD
18637	24942	254	,	,	,
18637	24942	255	690	690	CD
18637	24942	256	,	,	,
18637	24942	257	1027	1027	CD
18637	24942	258	Garbage	Garbage	NNP
18637	24942	259	,	,	,
18637	24942	260	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	24942	261	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24942	262	as	as	IN
18637	24942	263	to	to	IN
18637	24942	264	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	24942	265	of	of	IN
18637	24942	266	,	,	,
18637	24942	267	1030	1030	CD
18637	24942	268	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	24942	269	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24942	270	_	_	NNP
18637	24942	271	see	see	VB
18637	24942	272	also	also	RB
18637	24942	273	_	_	NNP
18637	24942	274	Carriers	Carriers	NNPS
18637	24942	275	;	;	:
18637	24942	276	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24942	277	Utilities	Utilities	NNPS
18637	24942	278	;	;	:
18637	24942	279	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24942	280	:	:	:
18637	24942	281	States	state	NNS
18637	24942	282	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24942	283	:	:	:
18637	24942	284	Conservation	conservation	NN
18637	24942	285	,	,	,
18637	24942	286	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	24942	287	of	of	IN
18637	24942	288	export	export	NN
18637	24942	289	of	of	IN
18637	24942	290	,	,	,
18637	24942	291	by	by	IN
18637	24942	292	States	States	NNP
18637	24942	293	,	,	,
18637	24942	294	243	243	CD
18637	24942	295	,	,	,
18637	24942	296	1025	1025	CD
18637	24942	297	-	-	SYM
18637	24942	298	1026	1026	CD
18637	24942	299	Damages	damage	NNS
18637	24942	300	from	from	IN
18637	24942	301	drilling	drill	VBG
18637	24942	302	for	for	IN
18637	24942	303	,	,	,
18637	24942	304	requiring	require	VBG
18637	24942	305	bond	bond	NN
18637	24942	306	to	to	TO
18637	24942	307	cover	cover	VB
18637	24942	308	,	,	,
18637	24942	309	1026	1026	CD
18637	24942	310	Gasoline	Gasoline	NNP
18637	24942	311	.	.	.
18637	24943	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24943	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24943	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24943	4	Police	Police	NNP
18637	24943	5	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24943	6	;	;	:
18637	24943	7	Prices	price	NNS
18637	24943	8	,	,	,
18637	24943	9	Charges	Charges	NNPS
18637	24943	10	,	,	,
18637	24943	11	Rates	Rates	NNPS
18637	24943	12	;	;	:
18637	24943	13	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24943	14	;	;	:
18637	24943	15	Zoning	zoning	NN
18637	24943	16	.	.	.
18637	24944	1	General	General	NNP
18637	24944	2	Welfare	Welfare	NNP
18637	24944	3	,	,	,
18637	24944	4	powers	power	NNS
18637	24944	5	of	of	IN
18637	24944	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24944	7	as	as	IN
18637	24944	8	to	to	IN
18637	24944	9	;	;	:
18637	24944	10	State	state	NN
18637	24944	11	reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	24944	12	powers	power	NNS
18637	24944	13	as	as	IN
18637	24944	14	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	24944	15	on	on	IN
18637	24944	16	,	,	,
18637	24944	17	112	112	CD
18637	24944	18	-	-	SYM
18637	24944	19	117	117	CD
18637	24944	20	,	,	,
18637	24944	21	917	917	CD
18637	24944	22	-	-	SYM
18637	24944	23	919	919	CD
18637	24944	24	Gift	Gift	NNP
18637	24944	25	Taxes	Taxes	NNPS
18637	24944	26	.	.	.
18637	24945	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24945	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24945	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24945	4	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	24945	5	.	.	.
18637	24946	1	Gold	gold	NN
18637	24946	2	.	.	.
18637	24947	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24947	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24947	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24947	4	Money	Money	NNP
18637	24947	5	;	;	:
18637	24947	6	Public	public	JJ
18637	24947	7	Debt	Debt	NNP
18637	24947	8	of	of	IN
18637	24947	9	the	the	DT
18637	24947	10	United	United	NNP
18637	24947	11	States	States	NNP
18637	24947	12	.	.	.
18637	24948	1	Governors	governor	NNS
18637	24948	2	.	.	.
18637	24949	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24949	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24949	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24949	4	States	States	NNP
18637	24949	5	:	:	:
18637	24949	6	Governors	Governors	NNP
18637	24949	7	.	.	.
18637	24950	1	Grain	grain	NN
18637	24950	2	.	.	.
18637	24951	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24951	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24951	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24951	4	Agriculture	Agriculture	NNP
18637	24951	5	;	;	:
18637	24951	6	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24951	7	;	;	:
18637	24951	8	Commodity	Commodity	NNP
18637	24951	9	and	and	CC
18637	24951	10	Security	Security	NNP
18637	24951	11	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
18637	24951	12	;	;	:
18637	24951	13	Conservation	Conservation	NNP
18637	24951	14	;	;	:
18637	24951	15	Warehouses	Warehouses	NNP
18637	24951	16	.	.	.
18637	24952	1	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	24952	2	Jury	Jury	NNP
18637	24952	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24952	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24952	5	see	see	VB
18637	24952	6	also	also	RB
18637	24952	7	_	_	NNP
18637	24952	8	Due	Due	NNP
18637	24952	9	Process	Process	NNP
18637	24952	10	of	of	IN
18637	24952	11	Law	Law	NNP
18637	24952	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24952	13	:	:	:
18637	24952	14	Abolition	abolition	NN
18637	24952	15	by	by	IN
18637	24952	16	States	States	NNP
18637	24952	17	,	,	,
18637	24952	18	837	837	CD
18637	24952	19	,	,	,
18637	24952	20	1098	1098	CD
18637	24952	21	Grants	grant	NNS
18637	24952	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	24952	23	in	in	IN
18637	24952	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	24952	25	Aid	aid	NN
18637	24952	26	,	,	,
18637	24952	27	113	113	CD
18637	24952	28	,	,	,
18637	24952	29	116	116	CD
18637	24952	30	Group	Group	NNP
18637	24952	31	Libel	Libel	NNP
18637	24952	32	,	,	,
18637	24952	33	802	802	CD
18637	24952	34	-	-	SYM
18637	24952	35	804	804	CD
18637	24952	36	H	H	NNP
18637	24952	37	Habeas	Habeas	NNP
18637	24952	38	Corpus	Corpus	NNP
18637	24952	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24952	40	_	_	NNP
18637	24952	41	see	see	VBP
18637	24952	42	also	also	RB
18637	24952	43	_	_	NNP
18637	24952	44	Prisoners	Prisoners	NNP
18637	24952	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24952	46	:	:	:
18637	24952	47	Errors	error	NNS
18637	24952	48	at	at	IN
18637	24952	49	trial	trial	NN
18637	24952	50	,	,	,
18637	24952	51	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	24952	52	to	to	TO
18637	24952	53	correct	correct	VB
18637	24952	54	,	,	,
18637	24952	55	312	312	CD
18637	24952	56	-	-	SYM
18637	24952	57	313	313	CD
18637	24952	58	in	in	IN
18637	24952	59	Extradition	Extradition	NNP
18637	24952	60	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	24952	61	,	,	,
18637	24952	62	695	695	CD
18637	24952	63	Issuance	issuance	NN
18637	24952	64	by	by	IN
18637	24952	65	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24952	66	courts	court	NNS
18637	24952	67	,	,	,
18637	24952	68	312	312	CD
18637	24952	69	-	-	SYM
18637	24952	70	314	314	CD
18637	24952	71	Issuance	Issuance	NNP
18637	24952	72	by	by	IN
18637	24952	73	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24952	74	or	or	CC
18637	24952	75	State	State	NNP
18637	24952	76	court	court	NN
18637	24952	77	to	to	TO
18637	24952	78	release	release	VB
18637	24952	79	prisoner	prisoner	NN
18637	24952	80	in	in	IN
18637	24952	81	custody	custody	NN
18637	24952	82	of	of	IN
18637	24952	83	other	other	JJ
18637	24952	84	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24952	85	,	,	,
18637	24952	86	624	624	CD
18637	24952	87	,	,	,
18637	24952	88	626	626	CD
18637	24952	89	,	,	,
18637	24952	90	631	631	CD
18637	24952	91	-	-	SYM
18637	24952	92	633	633	CD
18637	24952	93	Military	military	JJ
18637	24952	94	tribunal	tribunal	NN
18637	24952	95	,	,	,
18637	24952	96	to	to	TO
18637	24952	97	review	review	VB
18637	24952	98	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	24952	99	of	of	IN
18637	24952	100	,	,	,
18637	24952	101	286	286	CD
18637	24952	102	Review	Review	NNP
18637	24952	103	of	of	IN
18637	24952	104	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	24952	105	,	,	,
18637	24952	106	use	use	NN
18637	24952	107	by	by	IN
18637	24952	108	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
18637	24952	109	to	to	TO
18637	24952	110	obtain	obtain	VB
18637	24952	111	,	,	,
18637	24952	112	1109	1109	CD
18637	24952	113	,	,	,
18637	24952	114	1124	1124	CD
18637	24952	115	-	-	SYM
18637	24952	116	1126	1126	CD
18637	24952	117	not	not	RB
18637	24952	118	a	a	DT
18637	24952	119	Substitute	Substitute	NNP
18637	24952	120	for	for	IN
18637	24952	121	appeal	appeal	NN
18637	24952	122	,	,	,
18637	24952	123	314	314	CD
18637	24952	124	Suspension	suspension	NN
18637	24952	125	,	,	,
18637	24952	126	when	when	WRB
18637	24952	127	valid	valid	JJ
18637	24952	128	,	,	,
18637	24952	129	315	315	CD
18637	24952	130	,	,	,
18637	24952	131	399	399	CD
18637	24952	132	-	-	SYM
18637	24952	133	401	401	CD
18637	24952	134	Habitual	Habitual	NNP
18637	24952	135	Offenders	Offenders	NNPS
18637	24952	136	,	,	,
18637	24952	137	successively	successively	RB
18637	24952	138	heavier	heavy	JJR
18637	24952	139	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	24952	140	on	on	IN
18637	24952	141	,	,	,
18637	24952	142	validity	validity	NN
18637	24952	143	,	,	,
18637	24952	144	1133	1133	CD
18637	24952	145	,	,	,
18637	24952	146	1135	1135	CD
18637	24952	147	,	,	,
18637	24952	148	1137	1137	CD
18637	24952	149	,	,	,
18637	24952	150	1160	1160	CD
18637	24952	151	Health	Health	NNP
18637	24952	152	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24952	153	_	_	NNP
18637	24952	154	see	see	VBP
18637	24952	155	also	also	RB
18637	24952	156	_	_	NNP
18637	24952	157	Drugs	Drugs	NNPS
18637	24952	158	;	;	:
18637	24952	159	Food	food	NN
18637	24952	160	;	;	:
18637	24952	161	Garbage	garbage	NN
18637	24952	162	;	;	:
18637	24952	163	Milk	milk	NN
18637	24952	164	;	;	,
18637	24952	165	Sewers	Sewers	NNP
18637	24952	166	;	;	:
18637	24952	167	Water	water	NN
18637	24952	168	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24952	169	:	:	:
18637	24952	170	Power	power	NN
18637	24952	171	of	of	IN
18637	24952	172	States	States	NNP
18637	24952	173	,	,	,
18637	24952	174	etc	etc	FW
18637	24952	175	.	.	FW
18637	24952	176	,	,	,
18637	24952	177	to	to	TO
18637	24952	178	safeguard	safeguard	VB
18637	24952	179	,	,	,
18637	24952	180	1029	1029	CD
18637	24952	181	-	-	SYM
18637	24952	182	1031	1031	CD
18637	24952	183	High	High	NNP
18637	24952	184	Seas	Seas	NNPS
18637	24952	185	:	:	:
18637	24952	186	Offenses	offense	NNS
18637	24952	187	committed	commit	VBD
18637	24952	188	on	on	IN
18637	24952	189	,	,	,
18637	24952	190	defined	define	VBN
18637	24952	191	,	,	,
18637	24952	192	277	277	CD
18637	24952	193	-	-	SYM
18637	24952	194	279	279	CD
18637	24952	195	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24952	196	of	of	IN
18637	24952	197	States	States	NNPS
18637	24952	198	over	over	IN
18637	24952	199	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	24952	200	on	on	IN
18637	24952	201	,	,	,
18637	24952	202	325	325	CD
18637	24952	203	Holding	Holding	NNP
18637	24952	204	Companies	Companies	NNPS
18637	24952	205	.	.	.
18637	24953	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24953	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24953	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24953	4	Public	Public	NNP
18637	24953	5	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	24953	6	.	.	.
18637	24954	1	Hot	Hot	NNP
18637	24954	2	Pursuit	Pursuit	NNP
18637	24954	3	,	,	,
18637	24954	4	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	24954	5	with	with	IN
18637	24954	6	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
18637	24954	7	for	for	IN
18637	24954	8	crossing	crossing	NN
18637	24954	9	of	of	IN
18637	24954	10	boundary	boundary	NN
18637	24954	11	by	by	IN
18637	24954	12	troops	troop	NNS
18637	24954	13	,	,	,
18637	24954	14	434	434	CD
18637	24954	15	House	House	NNP
18637	24954	16	of	of	IN
18637	24954	17	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	24954	18	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24954	19	_	_	NNP
18637	24954	20	see	see	VBP
18637	24954	21	also	also	RB
18637	24954	22	_	_	NNP
18637	24954	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24954	24	;	;	:
18637	24954	25	Elections	election	NNS
18637	24954	26	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24954	27	:	:	:
18637	24954	28	Apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	24954	29	,	,	,
18637	24954	30	representation	representation	NN
18637	24954	31	in	in	IN
18637	24954	32	,	,	,
18637	24954	33	reduced	reduce	VBN
18637	24954	34	for	for	IN
18637	24954	35	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	24954	36	voting	voting	NN
18637	24954	37	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	24954	38	,	,	,
18637	24954	39	etc	etc	FW
18637	24954	40	.	.	.
18637	24954	41	,	,	,
18637	24954	42	1170	1170	CD
18637	24954	43	-	-	SYM
18637	24954	44	1172	1172	CD
18637	24954	45	Composition	Composition	NNP
18637	24954	46	,	,	,
18637	24954	47	89	89	CD
18637	24954	48	-	-	SYM
18637	24954	49	90	90	CD
18637	24954	50	Election	election	NN
18637	24954	51	to	to	TO
18637	24954	52	fill	fill	VB
18637	24954	53	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
18637	24954	54	in	in	IN
18637	24954	55	,	,	,
18637	24954	56	90	90	CD
18637	24954	57	Election	election	NN
18637	24954	58	to	to	IN
18637	24954	59	,	,	,
18637	24954	60	State	state	NN
18637	24954	61	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24954	62	as	as	IN
18637	24954	63	to	to	IN
18637	24954	64	,	,	,
18637	24954	65	93	93	CD
18637	24954	66	-	-	SYM
18637	24954	67	94	94	CD
18637	24954	68	Impeachment	Impeachment	NNP
18637	24954	69	,	,	,
18637	24954	70	powers	power	NNS
18637	24954	71	as	as	IN
18637	24954	72	to	to	IN
18637	24954	73	,	,	,
18637	24954	74	90	90	CD
18637	24954	75	Revenue	revenue	NN
18637	24954	76	bills	bill	NNS
18637	24954	77	originate	originate	VBP
18637	24954	78	in	in	IN
18637	24954	79	,	,	,
18637	24954	80	101	101	CD
18637	24954	81	-	-	SYM
18637	24954	82	102	102	CD
18637	24954	83	Hydroelectric	Hydroelectric	NNP
18637	24954	84	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24954	85	,	,	,
18637	24954	86	scope	scope	NN
18637	24954	87	of	of	IN
18637	24954	88	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24954	89	,	,	,
18637	24954	90	State	State	NNP
18637	24954	91	powers	power	NNS
18637	24954	92	as	as	IN
18637	24954	93	to	to	IN
18637	24954	94	,	,	,
18637	24954	95	130	130	CD
18637	24954	96	-	-	SYM
18637	24954	97	132	132	CD
18637	24954	98	I	i	NN
18637	24954	99	Immigration	immigration	NN
18637	24954	100	.	.	.
18637	24955	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24955	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24955	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24955	4	Aliens	Aliens	NNP
18637	24955	5	.	.	.
18637	24956	1	Impairment	impairment	NN
18637	24956	2	of	of	IN
18637	24956	3	Obligation	Obligation	NNP
18637	24956	4	of	of	IN
18637	24956	5	Contracts	Contracts	NNPS
18637	24956	6	,	,	,
18637	24956	7	329	329	CD
18637	24956	8	-	-	SYM
18637	24956	9	362	362	CD
18637	24956	10	Impeachment	Impeachment	NNP
18637	24956	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24956	12	_	_	NNP
18637	24956	13	see	see	VBP
18637	24956	14	also	also	RB
18637	24956	15	_	_	NNP
18637	24956	16	House	House	NNP
18637	24956	17	of	of	IN
18637	24956	18	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	24956	19	;	;	:
18637	24956	20	President	President	NNP
18637	24956	21	;	;	:
18637	24956	22	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	24956	23	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24956	24	:	:	:
18637	24956	25	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	24956	26	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	24956	27	;	;	:
18637	24956	28	when	when	WRB
18637	24956	29	presiding	preside	VBG
18637	24956	30	officer	officer	NN
18637	24956	31	at	at	IN
18637	24956	32	trial	trial	NN
18637	24956	33	,	,	,
18637	24956	34	91	91	CD
18637	24956	35	Judgment	judgment	NN
18637	24956	36	on	on	IN
18637	24956	37	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	24956	38	,	,	,
18637	24956	39	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	24956	40	on	on	IN
18637	24956	41	penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	24956	42	,	,	,
18637	24956	43	92	92	CD
18637	24956	44	Officers	officer	NNS
18637	24956	45	subject	subject	JJ
18637	24956	46	to	to	IN
18637	24956	47	;	;	:
18637	24956	48	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	24956	49	for	for	IN
18637	24956	50	,	,	,
18637	24956	51	501	501	CD
18637	24956	52	Implied	implied	JJ
18637	24956	53	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	24956	54	of	of	IN
18637	24956	55	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24956	56	,	,	,
18637	24956	57	72	72	CD
18637	24956	58	-	-	SYM
18637	24956	59	73	73	CD
18637	24956	60	Imports	import	NNS
18637	24956	61	.	.	.
18637	24957	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24957	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24957	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24957	4	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24957	5	;	;	:
18637	24957	6	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	24957	7	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24957	8	;	;	:
18637	24957	9	Inspection	Inspection	NNP
18637	24957	10	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	24957	11	;	;	:
18637	24957	12	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	24957	13	.	.	.
18637	24958	1	Income	Income	NNP
18637	24958	2	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	24958	3	.	.	.
18637	24959	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24959	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24959	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24959	4	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	24959	5	.	.	.
18637	24960	1	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	24960	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24960	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24960	4	see	see	VB
18637	24960	5	also	also	RB
18637	24960	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24960	7	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24960	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24960	9	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24960	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24960	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24960	12	:	:	:
18637	24960	13	Citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	24960	14	of	of	IN
18637	24960	15	,	,	,
18637	24960	16	254	254	CD
18637	24960	17	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24960	18	with	with	IN
18637	24960	19	,	,	,
18637	24960	20	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	24960	21	power	power	NN
18637	24960	22	as	as	IN
18637	24960	23	to	to	IN
18637	24960	24	,	,	,
18637	24960	25	252	252	CD
18637	24960	26	-	-	SYM
18637	24960	27	253	253	CD
18637	24960	28	Crimes	crime	NNS
18637	24960	29	on	on	IN
18637	24960	30	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	24960	31	,	,	,
18637	24960	32	State	state	NN
18637	24960	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	24960	34	as	as	IN
18637	24960	35	to	to	IN
18637	24960	36	,	,	,
18637	24960	37	698	698	CD
18637	24960	38	Fishing	fishing	NN
18637	24960	39	rights	right	NNS
18637	24960	40	of	of	IN
18637	24960	41	,	,	,
18637	24960	42	under	under	IN
18637	24960	43	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	24960	44	,	,	,
18637	24960	45	application	application	NN
18637	24960	46	of	of	IN
18637	24960	47	State	state	NN
18637	24960	48	game	game	NN
18637	24960	49	laws	law	NNS
18637	24960	50	to	to	IN
18637	24960	51	,	,	,
18637	24960	52	700	700	CD
18637	24960	53	-	-	SYM
18637	24960	54	701	701	CD
18637	24960	55	Liquor	Liquor	NNP
18637	24960	56	,	,	,
18637	24960	57	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	24960	58	on	on	IN
18637	24960	59	lands	land	NNS
18637	24960	60	used	use	VBN
18637	24960	61	by	by	IN
18637	24960	62	,	,	,
18637	24960	63	253	253	CD
18637	24960	64	,	,	,
18637	24960	65	698	698	CD
18637	24960	66	,	,	,
18637	24960	67	702	702	CD
18637	24960	68	"	"	``
18637	24960	69	Not	not	RB
18637	24960	70	taxed	tax	VBN
18637	24960	71	"	"	''
18637	24960	72	;	;	,
18637	24960	73	included	include	VBN
18637	24960	74	in	in	IN
18637	24960	75	apportioning	apportion	VBG
18637	24960	76	seats	seat	NNS
18637	24960	77	in	in	IN
18637	24960	78	House	House	NNP
18637	24960	79	of	of	IN
18637	24960	80	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	24960	81	,	,	,
18637	24960	82	1171	1171	CD
18637	24960	83	-	-	SYM
18637	24960	84	1172	1172	CD
18637	24960	85	Regulations	Regulations	NNPS
18637	24960	86	governing	govern	VBG
18637	24960	87	,	,	,
18637	24960	88	due	due	JJ
18637	24960	89	process	process	NN
18637	24960	90	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	24960	91	,	,	,
18637	24960	92	864	864	CD
18637	24960	93	State	state	NN
18637	24960	94	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	24960	95	on	on	IN
18637	24960	96	lessees	lessee	NNS
18637	24960	97	of	of	IN
18637	24960	98	lands	land	NNS
18637	24960	99	of	of	IN
18637	24960	100	,	,	,
18637	24960	101	735	735	CD
18637	24960	102	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	24960	103	with	with	IN
18637	24960	104	,	,	,
18637	24960	105	status	status	NN
18637	24960	106	,	,	,
18637	24960	107	abrogation	abrogation	NN
18637	24960	108	,	,	,
18637	24960	109	etc	etc	FW
18637	24960	110	.	.	.
18637	24960	111	,	,	,
18637	24960	112	431	431	CD
18637	24960	113	-	-	SYM
18637	24960	114	432	432	CD
18637	24960	115	Vested	vested	JJ
18637	24960	116	property	property	NN
18637	24960	117	rights	right	NNS
18637	24960	118	of	of	IN
18637	24960	119	,	,	,
18637	24960	120	protected	protect	VBN
18637	24960	121	by	by	IN
18637	24960	122	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
18637	24960	123	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	24960	124	,	,	,
18637	24960	125	432	432	CD
18637	24960	126	Indictment	indictment	NN
18637	24960	127	.	.	.
18637	24961	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24961	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24961	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24961	4	Due	Due	NNP
18637	24961	5	Process	Process	NNP
18637	24961	6	of	of	IN
18637	24961	7	Law	Law	NNP
18637	24961	8	;	;	:
18637	24961	9	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	24961	10	Juries	Juries	NNPS
18637	24961	11	.	.	.
18637	24962	1	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	24962	2	Relations	Relations	NNPS
18637	24962	3	.	.	.
18637	24963	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24963	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24963	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24963	4	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24963	5	;	;	,
18637	24963	6	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	24963	7	Seizure	Seizure	NNP
18637	24963	8	Case	Case	NNP
18637	24963	9	.	.	.
18637	24964	1	Infamous	infamous	JJ
18637	24964	2	Crimes	Crimes	NNPS
18637	24964	3	.	.	.
18637	24965	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24965	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24965	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24965	4	Due	Due	NNP
18637	24965	5	process	process	NN
18637	24965	6	of	of	IN
18637	24965	7	Law	Law	NNP
18637	24965	8	.	.	.
18637	24966	1	Inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	24966	2	Powers	power	NNS
18637	24966	3	of	of	IN
18637	24966	4	National	National	NNP
18637	24966	5	Government	Government	NNP
18637	24966	6	,	,	,
18637	24966	7	279	279	CD
18637	24966	8	-	-	SYM
18637	24966	9	280	280	CD
18637	24966	10	,	,	,
18637	24966	11	380	380	CD
18637	24966	12	Inheritance	Inheritance	NNP
18637	24966	13	Taxes	Taxes	NNPS
18637	24966	14	.	.	.
18637	24967	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24967	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24967	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24967	4	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	24967	5	.	.	.
18637	24968	1	Insolvency	insolvency	NN
18637	24968	2	.	.	.
18637	24969	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24969	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24969	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24969	4	Bankruptcy	Bankruptcy	NNP
18637	24969	5	.	.	.
18637	24970	1	Inspection	Inspection	NNP
18637	24970	2	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	24970	3	,	,	,
18637	24970	4	State	State	NNP
18637	24970	5	,	,	,
18637	24970	6	power	power	NN
18637	24970	7	to	to	TO
18637	24970	8	impose	impose	VB
18637	24970	9	,	,	,
18637	24970	10	application	application	NN
18637	24970	11	to	to	IN
18637	24970	12	imports	import	NNS
18637	24970	13	,	,	,
18637	24970	14	exports	export	NNS
18637	24970	15	,	,	,
18637	24970	16	235	235	CD
18637	24970	17	-	-	SYM
18637	24970	18	238	238	CD
18637	24970	19	,	,	,
18637	24970	20	248	248	CD
18637	24970	21	,	,	,
18637	24970	22	250	250	CD
18637	24970	23	,	,	,
18637	24970	24	364	364	CD
18637	24970	25	-	-	SYM
18637	24970	26	365	365	CD
18637	24970	27	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	24970	28	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24970	29	_	_	NNP
18637	24970	30	see	see	VBP
18637	24970	31	also	also	RB
18637	24970	32	_	_	NNP
18637	24970	33	Abandoned	Abandoned	NNP
18637	24970	34	Property	Property	NNP
18637	24970	35	;	;	:
18637	24970	36	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	24970	37	;	;	:
18637	24970	38	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24970	39	:	:	:
18637	24970	40	State	state	NN
18637	24970	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24970	42	:	:	:
18637	24970	43	Agents	agent	NNS
18637	24970	44	acting	act	VBG
18637	24970	45	as	as	IN
18637	24970	46	undertakers	undertaker	NNS
18637	24970	47	,	,	,
18637	24970	48	sharing	share	VBG
18637	24970	49	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	24970	50	,	,	,
18637	24970	51	State	state	NN
18637	24970	52	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24970	53	as	as	IN
18637	24970	54	to	to	IN
18637	24970	55	,	,	,
18637	24970	56	1021	1021	CD
18637	24970	57	Foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	24970	58	companies	company	NNS
18637	24970	59	,	,	,
18637	24970	60	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	24970	61	of	of	IN
18637	24970	62	entry	entry	NN
18637	24970	63	,	,	,
18637	24970	64	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24970	65	of	of	IN
18637	24970	66	relations	relation	NNS
18637	24970	67	with	with	IN
18637	24970	68	,	,	,
18637	24970	69	1021	1021	CD
18637	24970	70	-	-	SYM
18637	24970	71	1022	1022	CD
18637	24970	72	as	as	IN
18637	24970	73	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	24970	74	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	24970	75	,	,	,
18637	24970	76	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24970	77	,	,	,
18637	24970	78	State	State	NNP
18637	24970	79	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24970	80	of	of	IN
18637	24970	81	,	,	,
18637	24970	82	214	214	CD
18637	24970	83	-	-	SYM
18637	24970	84	215	215	CD
18637	24970	85	Liquidation	liquidation	NN
18637	24970	86	of	of	IN
18637	24970	87	companies	company	NNS
18637	24970	88	,	,	,
18637	24970	89	rights	right	NNS
18637	24970	90	of	of	IN
18637	24970	91	dissenting	dissent	VBG
18637	24970	92	policyholders	policyholder	NNS
18637	24970	93	,	,	,
18637	24970	94	1023	1023	CD
18637	24970	95	Policy	policy	NN
18637	24970	96	provisions	provision	NNS
18637	24970	97	,	,	,
18637	24970	98	State	state	NN
18637	24970	99	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24970	100	as	as	IN
18637	24970	101	to	to	IN
18637	24970	102	,	,	,
18637	24970	103	1022	1022	CD
18637	24970	104	-	-	SYM
18637	24970	105	1023	1023	CD
18637	24970	106	Rates	Rates	NNP
18637	24970	107	,	,	,
18637	24970	108	agent	agent	NN
18637	24970	109	's	's	POS
18637	24970	110	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	24970	111	,	,	,
18637	24970	112	State	state	NN
18637	24970	113	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24970	114	of	of	IN
18637	24970	115	,	,	,
18637	24970	116	996	996	CD
18637	24970	117	,	,	,
18637	24970	118	1153	1153	CD
18637	24970	119	,	,	,
18637	24970	120	1155	1155	CD
18637	24970	121	State	State	NNP
18637	24970	122	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24970	123	of	of	IN
18637	24970	124	,	,	,
18637	24970	125	996	996	CD
18637	24970	126	,	,	,
18637	24970	127	1021	1021	CD
18637	24970	128	-	-	SYM
18637	24970	129	1023	1023	CD
18637	24970	130	,	,	,
18637	24970	131	1153	1153	CD
18637	24970	132	,	,	,
18637	24970	133	1155	1155	CD
18637	24970	134	Insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	24970	135	.	.	.
18637	24971	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24971	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24971	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24971	4	National	National	NNP
18637	24971	5	Supremacy	Supremacy	NNP
18637	24971	6	.	.	.
18637	24972	1	Interest	interest	NN
18637	24972	2	.	.	.
18637	24973	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24973	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24973	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24973	4	Money	Money	NNP
18637	24973	5	Lending	Lending	NNP
18637	24973	6	.	.	.
18637	24974	1	International	International	NNP
18637	24974	2	Law	Law	NNP
18637	24974	3	:	:	:
18637	24974	4	Application	application	NN
18637	24974	5	to	to	IN
18637	24974	6	prizes	prize	NNS
18637	24974	7	of	of	IN
18637	24974	8	war	war	NN
18637	24974	9	,	,	,
18637	24974	10	295	295	CD
18637	24974	11	-	-	SYM
18637	24974	12	296	296	CD
18637	24974	13	as	as	IN
18637	24974	14	National	national	JJ
18637	24974	15	public	public	JJ
18637	24974	16	law	law	NN
18637	24974	17	,	,	,
18637	24974	18	277	277	CD
18637	24974	19	Offenses	offense	NNS
18637	24974	20	against	against	IN
18637	24974	21	,	,	,
18637	24974	22	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	24974	23	by	by	IN
18637	24974	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24974	25	;	;	:
18637	24974	26	trial	trial	NN
18637	24974	27	of	of	IN
18637	24974	28	,	,	,
18637	24974	29	by	by	IN
18637	24974	30	military	military	JJ
18637	24974	31	commissions	commission	NNS
18637	24974	32	,	,	,
18637	24974	33	277	277	CD
18637	24974	34	-	-	SYM
18637	24974	35	279	279	CD
18637	24974	36	President	President	NNP
18637	24974	37	,	,	,
18637	24974	38	as	as	IN
18637	24974	39	enforcer	enforcer	NN
18637	24974	40	of	of	IN
18637	24974	41	,	,	,
18637	24974	42	435	435	CD
18637	24974	43	,	,	,
18637	24974	44	486	486	CD
18637	24974	45	-	-	SYM
18637	24974	46	487	487	CD
18637	24974	47	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	24974	48	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24974	49	.	.	.
18637	24975	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24975	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24975	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24975	4	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24975	5	.	.	.
18637	24976	1	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	24976	2	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	24976	3	Commission	Commission	NNP
18637	24976	4	,	,	,
18637	24976	5	creation	creation	NN
18637	24976	6	,	,	,
18637	24976	7	powers	power	NNS
18637	24976	8	,	,	,
18637	24976	9	134	134	CD
18637	24976	10	-	-	SYM
18637	24976	11	137	137	CD
18637	24976	12	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	24976	13	Compacts	compact	NNS
18637	24976	14	.	.	.
18637	24977	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24977	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24977	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24977	4	States	States	NNPS
18637	24977	5	:	:	:
18637	24977	6	Agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	24977	7	with	with	IN
18637	24977	8	other	other	JJ
18637	24977	9	States	state	NNS
18637	24977	10	.	.	.
18637	24978	1	Intoxicating	Intoxicating	NNP
18637	24978	2	Liquors	Liquors	NNP
18637	24978	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24978	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24978	5	see	see	VBP
18637	24978	6	also	also	RB
18637	24978	7	_	_	NNP
18637	24978	8	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	24978	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	24978	10	;	;	:
18637	24978	11	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	24978	12	Repeal	Repeal	NNP
18637	24978	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	24978	14	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24978	15	:	:	:
18637	24978	16	Destined	destine	VBN
18637	24978	17	for	for	IN
18637	24978	18	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24978	19	area	area	NN
18637	24978	20	,	,	,
18637	24978	21	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	24978	22	from	from	IN
18637	24978	23	State	state	NN
18637	24978	24	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24978	25	,	,	,
18637	24978	26	1283	1283	CD
18637	24978	27	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24978	28	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24978	29	,	,	,
18637	24978	30	as	as	IN
18637	24978	31	affected	affect	VBN
18637	24978	32	by	by	IN
18637	24978	33	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	24978	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	24978	35	first	first	NNP
18637	24978	36	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	24978	37	,	,	,
18637	24978	38	1233	1233	CD
18637	24978	39	-	-	SYM
18637	24978	40	1234	1234	CD
18637	24978	41	Imported	import	VBN
18637	24978	42	,	,	,
18637	24978	43	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	24978	44	in	in	IN
18637	24978	45	favor	favor	NN
18637	24978	46	of	of	IN
18637	24978	47	domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	24978	48	,	,	,
18637	24978	49	by	by	IN
18637	24978	50	States	state	NNS
18637	24978	51	,	,	,
18637	24978	52	1231	1231	CD
18637	24978	53	-	-	SYM
18637	24978	54	1232	1232	CD
18637	24978	55	State	State	NNP
18637	24978	56	power	power	NN
18637	24978	57	as	as	IN
18637	24978	58	to	to	IN
18637	24978	59	,	,	,
18637	24978	60	scope	scope	NN
18637	24978	61	under	under	IN
18637	24978	62	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
18637	24978	63	-	-	HYPH
18637	24978	64	first	first	NNP
18637	24978	65	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	24978	66	,	,	,
18637	24978	67	1231	1231	CD
18637	24978	68	-	-	SYM
18637	24978	69	1234	1234	CD
18637	24978	70	State	State	NNP
18637	24978	71	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	24978	72	,	,	,
18637	24978	73	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24978	74	of	of	IN
18637	24978	75	sale	sale	NN
18637	24978	76	,	,	,
18637	24978	77	of	of	IN
18637	24978	78	,	,	,
18637	24978	79	238	238	CD
18637	24978	80	-	-	SYM
18637	24978	81	239	239	CD
18637	24978	82	,	,	,
18637	24978	83	1031	1031	CD
18637	24978	84	-	-	SYM
18637	24978	85	1032	1032	CD
18637	24978	86	,	,	,
18637	24978	87	1155	1155	CD
18637	24978	88	Transportation	transportation	NN
18637	24978	89	into	into	IN
18637	24978	90	States	States	NNPS
18637	24978	91	in	in	IN
18637	24978	92	violation	violation	NN
18637	24978	93	of	of	IN
18637	24978	94	State	State	NNP
18637	24978	95	law	law	NN
18637	24978	96	,	,	,
18637	24978	97	1231	1231	CD
18637	24978	98	-	-	SYM
18637	24978	99	1233	1233	CD
18637	24978	100	Investigations	investigation	NNS
18637	24978	101	by	by	IN
18637	24978	102	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24978	103	,	,	,
18637	24978	104	scope	scope	NN
18637	24978	105	of	of	IN
18637	24978	106	power	power	NN
18637	24978	107	as	as	IN
18637	24978	108	to	to	IN
18637	24978	109	,	,	,
18637	24978	110	82	82	CD
18637	24978	111	-	-	HYPH
18637	24978	112	86	86	CD
18637	24978	113	Involuntary	involuntary	JJ
18637	24978	114	Servitude	servitude	NN
18637	24978	115	:	:	:
18637	24978	116	Conscription	conscription	NN
18637	24978	117	does	do	VBZ
18637	24978	118	not	not	RB
18637	24978	119	create	create	VB
18637	24978	120	,	,	,
18637	24978	121	284	284	CD
18637	24978	122	-	-	SYM
18637	24978	123	285	285	CD
18637	24978	124	Discriminations	Discriminations	NNPS
18637	24978	125	,	,	,
18637	24978	126	compulsions	compulsion	NNS
18637	24978	127	,	,	,
18637	24978	128	not	not	RB
18637	24978	129	amounting	amount	VBG
18637	24978	130	to	to	IN
18637	24978	131	,	,	,
18637	24978	132	284	284	CD
18637	24978	133	-	-	SYM
18637	24978	134	285	285	CD
18637	24978	135	,	,	,
18637	24978	136	951	951	CD
18637	24978	137	-	-	SYM
18637	24978	138	953	953	CD
18637	24978	139	Peonage	peonage	NN
18637	24978	140	defined	define	VBN
18637	24978	141	as	as	IN
18637	24978	142	,	,	,
18637	24978	143	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	24978	144	creating	create	VBG
18637	24978	145	,	,	,
18637	24978	146	950	950	CD
18637	24978	147	-	-	SYM
18637	24978	148	951	951	CD
18637	24978	149	Prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	24978	150	,	,	,
18637	24978	151	except	except	IN
18637	24978	152	as	as	IN
18637	24978	153	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	24978	154	for	for	IN
18637	24978	155	crime	crime	NN
18637	24978	156	;	;	:
18637	24978	157	powers	power	NNS
18637	24978	158	of	of	IN
18637	24978	159	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24978	160	as	as	IN
18637	24978	161	to	to	IN
18637	24978	162	,	,	,
18637	24978	163	950	950	CD
18637	24978	164	-	-	SYM
18637	24978	165	951	951	CD
18637	24978	166	,	,	,
18637	24978	167	953	953	CD
18637	24978	168	-	-	SYM
18637	24978	169	954	954	CD
18637	24978	170	J	J	NNP
18637	24978	171	Japanese	Japanese	NNP
18637	24978	172	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24978	173	_	_	NNP
18637	24978	174	see	see	VB
18637	24978	175	also	also	RB
18637	24978	176	_	_	NNP
18637	24978	177	Aliens	Aliens	NNP
18637	24978	178	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24978	179	:	:	:
18637	24978	180	Exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	24978	181	from	from	IN
18637	24978	182	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
18637	24978	183	Coast	Coast	NNP
18637	24978	184	in	in	IN
18637	24978	185	World	World	NNP
18637	24978	186	War	War	NNP
18637	24978	187	II	II	NNP
18637	24978	188	,	,	,
18637	24978	189	297	297	CD
18637	24978	190	,	,	,
18637	24978	191	394	394	CD
18637	24978	192	-	-	SYM
18637	24978	193	395	395	CD
18637	24978	194	Jeopardy	Jeopardy	NNP
18637	24978	195	.	.	.
18637	24979	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24979	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24979	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24979	4	Double	Double	NNP
18637	24979	5	Jeopardy	Jeopardy	NNP
18637	24979	6	.	.	.
18637	24980	1	Judgments	Judgments	NNP
18637	24980	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24980	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24980	4	see	see	VBP
18637	24980	5	also	also	RB
18637	24980	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24980	7	Full	Full	NNP
18637	24980	8	Faith	Faith	NNP
18637	24980	9	and	and	CC
18637	24980	10	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	24980	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24980	12	:	:	:
18637	24980	13	Award	award	NN
18637	24980	14	of	of	IN
18637	24980	15	execution	execution	NN
18637	24980	16	as	as	IN
18637	24980	17	essential	essential	JJ
18637	24980	18	to	to	IN
18637	24980	19	finality	finality	NN
18637	24980	20	of	of	IN
18637	24980	21	,	,	,
18637	24980	22	511	511	CD
18637	24980	23	-	-	SYM
18637	24980	24	512	512	CD
18637	24980	25	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	24980	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24980	27	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24980	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24980	29	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24980	30	_	_	NNP
18637	24980	31	see	see	VB
18637	24980	32	also	also	RB
18637	24980	33	_	_	NNP
18637	24980	34	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24980	35	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24980	36	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24980	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24980	38	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24980	39	:	:	:
18637	24980	40	Impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	24980	41	,	,	,
18637	24980	42	502	502	CD
18637	24980	43	-	-	HYPH
18637	24980	44	504	504	CD
18637	24980	45	of	of	IN
18637	24980	46	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	24980	47	courts	court	NNS
18637	24980	48	,	,	,
18637	24980	49	tenure	tenure	NN
18637	24980	50	,	,	,
18637	24980	51	salary	salary	NN
18637	24980	52	,	,	,
18637	24980	53	534	534	CD
18637	24980	54	-	-	SYM
18637	24980	55	535	535	CD
18637	24980	56	Nonjudicial	nonjudicial	JJ
18637	24980	57	functions	function	NNS
18637	24980	58	,	,	,
18637	24980	59	549	549	CD
18637	24980	60	Salaries	salary	NNS
18637	24980	61	,	,	,
18637	24980	62	diminution	diminution	NN
18637	24980	63	by	by	IN
18637	24980	64	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	24980	65	,	,	,
18637	24980	66	etc	etc	FW
18637	24980	67	.	.	FW
18637	24980	68	,	,	,
18637	24980	69	105	105	CD
18637	24980	70	-	-	SYM
18637	24980	71	106	106	CD
18637	24980	72	,	,	,
18637	24980	73	511	511	CD
18637	24980	74	,	,	,
18637	24980	75	530	530	CD
18637	24980	76	-	-	HYPH
18637	24980	77	531	531	CD
18637	24980	78	Tenure	Tenure	NNP
18637	24980	79	,	,	,
18637	24980	80	511	511	CD
18637	24980	81	,	,	,
18637	24980	82	528	528	CD
18637	24980	83	-	-	SYM
18637	24980	84	530	530	CD
18637	24980	85	Judges	Judges	NNPS
18637	24980	86	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24980	87	State	State	NNP
18637	24980	88	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24980	89	,	,	,
18637	24980	90	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
18637	24980	91	interest	interest	NN
18637	24980	92	in	in	IN
18637	24980	93	verdict	verdict	NN
18637	24980	94	,	,	,
18637	24980	95	violative	violative	JJ
18637	24980	96	of	of	IN
18637	24980	97	due	due	JJ
18637	24980	98	process	process	NN
18637	24980	99	,	,	,
18637	24980	100	1131	1131	CD
18637	24980	101	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	24980	102	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24980	103	:	:	.
18637	24980	104	Administrative	administrative	JJ
18637	24980	105	power	power	NN
18637	24980	106	,	,	,
18637	24980	107	as	as	IN
18637	24980	108	aid	aid	NN
18637	24980	109	to	to	IN
18637	24980	110	,	,	,
18637	24980	111	521	521	CD
18637	24980	112	Defined	define	VBN
18637	24980	113	,	,	,
18637	24980	114	scope	scope	NN
18637	24980	115	,	,	,
18637	24980	116	attributes	attribute	NNS
18637	24980	117	of	of	IN
18637	24980	118	,	,	,
18637	24980	119	511	511	CD
18637	24980	120	-	-	SYM
18637	24980	121	539	539	CD
18637	24980	122	,	,	,
18637	24980	123	595	595	CD
18637	24980	124	Inherent	inherent	JJ
18637	24980	125	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	24980	126	of	of	IN
18637	24980	127	,	,	,
18637	24980	128	maxims	maxim	NNS
18637	24980	129	of	of	IN
18637	24980	130	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	24980	131	,	,	,
18637	24980	132	561	561	CD
18637	24980	133	-	-	SYM
18637	24980	134	566	566	CD
18637	24980	135	Vested	vest	VBN
18637	24980	136	in	in	IN
18637	24980	137	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	24980	138	Court	Court	NNP
18637	24980	139	and	and	CC
18637	24980	140	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	24980	141	courts	court	NNS
18637	24980	142	created	create	VBN
18637	24980	143	by	by	IN
18637	24980	144	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24980	145	,	,	,
18637	24980	146	511	511	CD
18637	24980	147	-	-	SYM
18637	24980	148	512	512	CD
18637	24980	149	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	24980	150	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	24980	151	.	.	.
18637	24981	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24981	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24981	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24981	4	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24981	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24981	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24981	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24981	8	;	;	:
18637	24981	9	Courts	court	NNS
18637	24981	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24981	11	State	State	NNP
18637	24981	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24981	13	.	.	.
18637	24982	1	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
18637	24982	2	Review	Review	NNP
18637	24982	3	.	.	.
18637	24983	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24983	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24983	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24983	4	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24983	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24983	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24983	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24983	8	.	.	.
18637	24984	1	Juries	jury	NNS
18637	24984	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24984	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24984	4	see	see	VBP
18637	24984	5	also	also	RB
18637	24984	6	_	_	NNP
18637	24984	7	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24984	8	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24984	9	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24984	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24984	11	;	;	:
18637	24984	12	Public	public	JJ
18637	24984	13	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	24984	14	of	of	IN
18637	24984	15	the	the	DT
18637	24984	16	United	United	NNP
18637	24984	17	States	States	NNP
18637	24984	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24984	19	:	:	:
18637	24984	20	Challenges	challenge	NNS
18637	24984	21	in	in	IN
18637	24984	22	selecting	select	VBG
18637	24984	23	,	,	,
18637	24984	24	"	"	``
18637	24984	25	blue	blue	JJ
18637	24984	26	ribbon	ribbon	NN
18637	24984	27	"	"	''
18637	24984	28	juries	jury	NNS
18637	24984	29	,	,	,
18637	24984	30	State	state	NN
18637	24984	31	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24984	32	as	as	IN
18637	24984	33	to	to	IN
18637	24984	34	,	,	,
18637	24984	35	1109	1109	CD
18637	24984	36	-	-	SYM
18637	24984	37	1111	1111	CD
18637	24984	38	in	in	IN
18637	24984	39	Common	common	JJ
18637	24984	40	law	law	NN
18637	24984	41	suits	suit	NNS
18637	24984	42	in	in	IN
18637	24984	43	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24984	44	courts	court	NNS
18637	24984	45	,	,	,
18637	24984	46	functions	function	NNS
18637	24984	47	of	of	IN
18637	24984	48	judges	judge	NNS
18637	24984	49	and	and	CC
18637	24984	50	,	,	,
18637	24984	51	right	right	RB
18637	24984	52	to	to	IN
18637	24984	53	,	,	,
18637	24984	54	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	24984	55	,	,	,
18637	24984	56	891	891	CD
18637	24984	57	-	-	SYM
18637	24984	58	897	897	CD
18637	24984	59	in	in	IN
18637	24984	60	Criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	24984	61	trials	trial	NNS
18637	24984	62	in	in	IN
18637	24984	63	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24984	64	courts	court	NNS
18637	24984	65	,	,	,
18637	24984	66	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	24984	67	,	,	,
18637	24984	68	etc	etc	FW
18637	24984	69	.	.	.
18637	24984	70	,	,	,
18637	24984	71	638	638	CD
18637	24984	72	,	,	,
18637	24984	73	878	878	CD
18637	24984	74	-	-	SYM
18637	24984	75	880	880	CD
18637	24984	76	Dispensing	dispense	VBG
18637	24984	77	with	with	IN
18637	24984	78	,	,	,
18637	24984	79	in	in	IN
18637	24984	80	State	State	NNP
18637	24984	81	civil	civil	JJ
18637	24984	82	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	24984	83	,	,	,
18637	24984	84	1096	1096	CD
18637	24984	85	Right	right	UH
18637	24984	86	to	to	IN
18637	24984	87	,	,	,
18637	24984	88	in	in	IN
18637	24984	89	State	state	NN
18637	24984	90	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	24984	91	trials	trial	NNS
18637	24984	92	,	,	,
18637	24984	93	1109	1109	CD
18637	24984	94	-	-	SYM
18637	24984	95	1111	1111	CD
18637	24984	96	Selection	Selection	NNP
18637	24984	97	,	,	,
18637	24984	98	number	number	NN
18637	24984	99	,	,	,
18637	24984	100	size	size	NN
18637	24984	101	of	of	IN
18637	24984	102	vote	vote	NN
18637	24984	103	by	by	IN
18637	24984	104	,	,	,
18637	24984	105	power	power	NN
18637	24984	106	of	of	IN
18637	24984	107	States	States	NNPS
18637	24984	108	to	to	TO
18637	24984	109	alter	alter	VB
18637	24984	110	,	,	,
18637	24984	111	1096	1096	CD
18637	24984	112	,	,	,
18637	24984	113	1109	1109	CD
18637	24984	114	-	-	SYM
18637	24984	115	1111	1111	CD
18637	24984	116	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
18637	24984	117	,	,	,
18637	24984	118	defined	define	VBN
18637	24984	119	,	,	,
18637	24984	120	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	24984	121	from	from	IN
18637	24984	122	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	24984	123	power	power	NN
18637	24984	124	,	,	,
18637	24984	125	511	511	CD
18637	24984	126	-	-	SYM
18637	24984	127	512	512	CD
18637	24984	128	K	K	NNP
18637	24984	129	Kingbolt	Kingbolt	NNP
18637	24984	130	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	24984	131	.	.	.
18637	24985	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24985	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24985	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24985	4	National	National	NNP
18637	24985	5	Supremacy	Supremacy	NNP
18637	24985	6	.	.	.
18637	24986	1	L	L	NNP
18637	24986	2	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24986	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24986	4	_	_	NNP
18637	24986	5	see	see	VBP
18637	24986	6	also	also	RB
18637	24986	7	_	_	NNP
18637	24986	8	Child	Child	NNP
18637	24986	9	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	24986	10	;	;	,
18637	24986	11	Full	Full	NNP
18637	24986	12	Faith	Faith	NNP
18637	24986	13	and	and	CC
18637	24986	14	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	24986	15	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	24986	16	;	;	:
18637	24986	17	President	President	NNP
18637	24986	18	:	:	:
18637	24986	19	Powers	power	NNS
18637	24986	20	;	;	:
18637	24986	21	Women	woman	NNS
18637	24986	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24986	23	:	:	:
18637	24986	24	Collective	collective	JJ
18637	24986	25	bargaining	bargaining	NN
18637	24986	26	;	;	:
18637	24986	27	closed	closed	JJ
18637	24986	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	24986	29	shop	shop	NN
18637	24986	30	;	;	:
18637	24986	31	picketing	picket	VBG
18637	24986	32	;	;	:
18637	24986	33	strikes	strike	NNS
18637	24986	34	,	,	,
18637	24986	35	slow	slow	JJ
18637	24986	36	-	-	HYPH
18637	24986	37	downs	down	NNS
18637	24986	38	,	,	,
18637	24986	39	and	and	CC
18637	24986	40	boycotts	boycotts	NNP
18637	24986	41	;	;	:
18637	24986	42	unions	union	NNS
18637	24986	43	;	;	:
18637	24986	44	yellow	yellow	JJ
18637	24986	45	-	-	HYPH
18637	24986	46	dog	dog	NN
18637	24986	47	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	24986	48	,	,	,
18637	24986	49	State	State	NNP
18637	24986	50	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24986	51	as	as	IN
18637	24986	52	to	to	IN
18637	24986	53	,	,	,
18637	24986	54	781	781	CD
18637	24986	55	,	,	,
18637	24986	56	991	991	CD
18637	24986	57	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	58	994	994	CD
18637	24986	59	,	,	,
18637	24986	60	1158	1158	CD
18637	24986	61	Employer	Employer	NNP
18637	24986	62	's	's	POS
18637	24986	63	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	24986	64	of	of	IN
18637	24986	65	speech	speech	NN
18637	24986	66	,	,	,
18637	24986	67	Wagner	Wagner	NNP
18637	24986	68	Act	Act	NNP
18637	24986	69	as	as	IN
18637	24986	70	curb	curb	NN
18637	24986	71	on	on	IN
18637	24986	72	,	,	,
18637	24986	73	793	793	CD
18637	24986	74	Employment	Employment	NNP
18637	24986	75	agencies	agency	NNS
18637	24986	76	,	,	,
18637	24986	77	State	state	NN
18637	24986	78	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24986	79	of	of	IN
18637	24986	80	fees	fee	NNS
18637	24986	81	,	,	,
18637	24986	82	etc	etc	FW
18637	24986	83	.	.	.
18637	24986	84	,	,	,
18637	24986	85	997	997	CD
18637	24986	86	,	,	,
18637	24986	87	1023	1023	CD
18637	24986	88	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	24986	89	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24986	90	,	,	,
18637	24986	91	under	under	IN
18637	24986	92	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	24986	93	clause	clause	NN
18637	24986	94	,	,	,
18637	24986	95	139	139	CD
18637	24986	96	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	97	143	143	CD
18637	24986	98	,	,	,
18637	24986	99	152	152	CD
18637	24986	100	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	101	158	158	CD
18637	24986	102	Hours	hour	NNS
18637	24986	103	of	of	IN
18637	24986	104	,	,	,
18637	24986	105	State	state	NN
18637	24986	106	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24986	107	of	of	IN
18637	24986	108	,	,	,
18637	24986	109	968	968	CD
18637	24986	110	,	,	,
18637	24986	111	1158	1158	CD
18637	24986	112	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	113	1159	1159	CD
18637	24986	114	Injunctions	Injunctions	NNPS
18637	24986	115	in	in	IN
18637	24986	116	disputes	dispute	NNS
18637	24986	117	,	,	,
18637	24986	118	issuance	issuance	NN
18637	24986	119	by	by	IN
18637	24986	120	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24986	121	courts	court	NNS
18637	24986	122	,	,	,
18637	24986	123	etc	etc	FW
18637	24986	124	.	.	.
18637	24986	125	,	,	,
18637	24986	126	not	not	RB
18637	24986	127	productive	productive	JJ
18637	24986	128	of	of	IN
18637	24986	129	slavery	slavery	NN
18637	24986	130	,	,	,
18637	24986	131	484	484	CD
18637	24986	132	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	133	486	486	CD
18637	24986	134	,	,	,
18637	24986	135	621	621	CD
18637	24986	136	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	137	622	622	CD
18637	24986	138	,	,	,
18637	24986	139	953	953	CD
18637	24986	140	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
18637	24986	141	of	of	IN
18637	24986	142	contract	contract	NN
18637	24986	143	,	,	,
18637	24986	144	State	state	NN
18637	24986	145	interference	interference	NN
18637	24986	146	with	with	IN
18637	24986	147	,	,	,
18637	24986	148	985	985	CD
18637	24986	149	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	150	994	994	CD
18637	24986	151	Longshoremen	Longshoremen	NNPS
18637	24986	152	's	's	POS
18637	24986	153	and	and	CC
18637	24986	154	Harbor	Harbor	NNP
18637	24986	155	Workers	Workers	NNPS
18637	24986	156	'	'	POS
18637	24986	157	Act	Act	NNP
18637	24986	158	,	,	,
18637	24986	159	581	581	CD
18637	24986	160	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	161	582	582	CD
18637	24986	162	Loyalty	Loyalty	NNP
18637	24986	163	affidavits	affidavit	NNS
18637	24986	164	required	require	VBN
18637	24986	165	of	of	IN
18637	24986	166	union	union	NN
18637	24986	167	officers	officer	NNS
18637	24986	168	,	,	,
18637	24986	169	794	794	CD
18637	24986	170	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	171	795	795	CD
18637	24986	172	Picketing	picketing	NN
18637	24986	173	,	,	,
18637	24986	174	control	control	NN
18637	24986	175	of	of	IN
18637	24986	176	,	,	,
18637	24986	177	as	as	IN
18637	24986	178	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	24986	179	on	on	IN
18637	24986	180	freedom	freedom	NN
18637	24986	181	of	of	IN
18637	24986	182	speech	speech	NN
18637	24986	183	,	,	,
18637	24986	184	press	press	NN
18637	24986	185	,	,	,
18637	24986	186	781	781	CD
18637	24986	187	-	-	HYPH
18637	24986	188	783	783	CD
18637	24986	189	Railway	Railway	NNP
18637	24986	190	,	,	,
18637	24986	191	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24986	192	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24986	193	as	as	IN
18637	24986	194	to	to	IN
18637	24986	195	,	,	,
18637	24986	196	139	139	CD
18637	24986	197	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	198	143	143	CD
18637	24986	199	State	State	NNP
18637	24986	200	laws	law	NNS
18637	24986	201	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	24986	202	,	,	,
18637	24986	203	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	24986	204	with	with	IN
18637	24986	205	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24986	206	,	,	,
18637	24986	207	effect	effect	NN
18637	24986	208	,	,	,
18637	24986	209	249	249	CD
18637	24986	210	,	,	,
18637	24986	211	251	251	CD
18637	24986	212	-	-	HYPH
18637	24986	213	252	252	CD
18637	24986	214	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	24986	215	Seizure	Seizure	NNP
18637	24986	216	Case	Case	NNP
18637	24986	217	,	,	,
18637	24986	218	489	489	CD
18637	24986	219	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	220	499	499	CD
18637	24986	221	Union	Union	NNP
18637	24986	222	publications	publication	NNS
18637	24986	223	supporting	support	VBG
18637	24986	224	candidates	candidate	NNS
18637	24986	225	,	,	,
18637	24986	226	restraints	restraint	NNS
18637	24986	227	on	on	RB
18637	24986	228	,	,	,
18637	24986	229	793	793	CD
18637	24986	230	Wages	Wages	NNPS
18637	24986	231	,	,	,
18637	24986	232	State	state	NN
18637	24986	233	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24986	234	as	as	IN
18637	24986	235	to	to	IN
18637	24986	236	payment	payment	NN
18637	24986	237	,	,	,
18637	24986	238	rates	rate	NNS
18637	24986	239	,	,	,
18637	24986	240	assignments	assignment	NNS
18637	24986	241	of	of	IN
18637	24986	242	,	,	,
18637	24986	243	987	987	CD
18637	24986	244	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	245	988	988	CD
18637	24986	246	,	,	,
18637	24986	247	1020	1020	CD
18637	24986	248	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	249	1021	1021	CD
18637	24986	250	,	,	,
18637	24986	251	1158	1158	CD
18637	24986	252	Wartime	wartime	JJ
18637	24986	253	controls	control	NNS
18637	24986	254	of	of	IN
18637	24986	255	,	,	,
18637	24986	256	wage	wage	NN
18637	24986	257	stabilization	stabilization	NN
18637	24986	258	,	,	,
18637	24986	259	392	392	CD
18637	24986	260	,	,	,
18637	24986	261	395	395	CD
18637	24986	262	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	263	397	397	CD
18637	24986	264	Workmen	Workmen	NNPS
18637	24986	265	's	's	POS
18637	24986	266	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	24986	267	laws	law	NNS
18637	24986	268	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24986	269	State	State	NNP
18637	24986	270	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24986	271	,	,	,
18637	24986	272	application	application	NN
18637	24986	273	to	to	IN
18637	24986	274	maritime	maritime	JJ
18637	24986	275	workers	worker	NNS
18637	24986	276	,	,	,
18637	24986	277	abolition	abolition	NN
18637	24986	278	of	of	IN
18637	24986	279	common	common	JJ
18637	24986	280	law	law	NN
18637	24986	281	defenses	defense	NNS
18637	24986	282	,	,	,
18637	24986	283	etc	etc	FW
18637	24986	284	.	.	FW
18637	24986	285	,	,	,
18637	24986	286	311	311	CD
18637	24986	287	,	,	,
18637	24986	288	580	580	CD
18637	24986	289	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	290	582	582	CD
18637	24986	291	,	,	,
18637	24986	292	989	989	CD
18637	24986	293	-	-	HYPH
18637	24986	294	990	990	CD
18637	24986	295	,	,	,
18637	24986	296	1091	1091	CD
18637	24986	297	Work	work	NN
18637	24986	298	stoppages	stoppage	VBZ
18637	24986	299	via	via	IN
18637	24986	300	union	union	NN
18637	24986	301	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	24986	302	during	during	IN
18637	24986	303	working	working	NN
18637	24986	304	hours	hour	NNS
18637	24986	305	,	,	,
18637	24986	306	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	24986	307	,	,	,
18637	24986	308	809	809	CD
18637	24986	309	Land	land	NN
18637	24986	310	,	,	,
18637	24986	311	Air	Air	NNP
18637	24986	312	and	and	CC
18637	24986	313	Naval	Naval	NNP
18637	24986	314	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	24986	315	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24986	316	_	_	NNP
18637	24986	317	see	see	VBP
18637	24986	318	also	also	RB
18637	24986	319	_	_	NNP
18637	24986	320	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	24986	321	;	;	:
18637	24986	322	President	President	NNP
18637	24986	323	:	:	:
18637	24986	324	Powers	power	NNS
18637	24986	325	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24986	326	:	:	:
18637	24986	327	Air	Air	NNP
18637	24986	328	Force	Force	NNP
18637	24986	329	,	,	,
18637	24986	330	establishment	establishment	NN
18637	24986	331	,	,	,
18637	24986	332	284	284	CD
18637	24986	333	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24986	334	,	,	,
18637	24986	335	power	power	NN
18637	24986	336	to	to	TO
18637	24986	337	raise	raise	VB
18637	24986	338	,	,	,
18637	24986	339	support	support	VBP
18637	24986	340	,	,	,
18637	24986	341	regulate	regulate	VB
18637	24986	342	,	,	,
18637	24986	343	279	279	CD
18637	24986	344	,	,	,
18637	24986	345	283	283	CD
18637	24986	346	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	347	287	287	CD
18637	24986	348	,	,	,
18637	24986	349	299	299	CD
18637	24986	350	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	351	300	300	CD
18637	24986	352	Conscription	Conscription	NNP
18637	24986	353	,	,	,
18637	24986	354	validity	validity	NN
18637	24986	355	,	,	,
18637	24986	356	284	284	CD
18637	24986	357	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	358	285	285	CD
18637	24986	359	,	,	,
18637	24986	360	299	299	CD
18637	24986	361	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	362	300	300	CD
18637	24986	363	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24986	364	martial	martial	JJ
18637	24986	365	,	,	,
18637	24986	366	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	24986	367	review	review	NN
18637	24986	368	of	of	IN
18637	24986	369	,	,	,
18637	24986	370	when	when	WRB
18637	24986	371	a	a	DT
18637	24986	372	due	due	JJ
18637	24986	373	process	process	NN
18637	24986	374	requisite	requisite	JJ
18637	24986	375	,	,	,
18637	24986	376	285	285	CD
18637	24986	377	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	378	286	286	CD
18637	24986	379	,	,	,
18637	24986	380	851	851	CD
18637	24986	381	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24986	382	martial	martial	JJ
18637	24986	383	,	,	,
18637	24986	384	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	24986	385	sanction	sanction	NN
18637	24986	386	of	of	IN
18637	24986	387	,	,	,
18637	24986	388	decrees	decree	NNS
18637	24986	389	of	of	IN
18637	24986	390	,	,	,
18637	24986	391	476	476	CD
18637	24986	392	Jury	jury	NN
18637	24986	393	,	,	,
18637	24986	394	not	not	RB
18637	24986	395	open	open	JJ
18637	24986	396	to	to	IN
18637	24986	397	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	24986	398	or	or	CC
18637	24986	399	trial	trial	NN
18637	24986	400	by	by	IN
18637	24986	401	,	,	,
18637	24986	402	285	285	CD
18637	24986	403	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	404	286	286	CD
18637	24986	405	,	,	,
18637	24986	406	838	838	CD
18637	24986	407	Offenses	offense	NNS
18637	24986	408	arising	arise	VBG
18637	24986	409	in	in	IN
18637	24986	410	,	,	,
18637	24986	411	trial	trial	NN
18637	24986	412	,	,	,
18637	24986	413	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	24986	414	,	,	,
18637	24986	415	285	285	CD
18637	24986	416	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	417	286	286	CD
18637	24986	418	Personnel	Personnel	NNS
18637	24986	419	,	,	,
18637	24986	420	care	care	NN
18637	24986	421	of	of	IN
18637	24986	422	,	,	,
18637	24986	423	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24986	424	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	24986	425	as	as	IN
18637	24986	426	to	to	IN
18637	24986	427	,	,	,
18637	24986	428	285	285	CD
18637	24986	429	,	,	,
18637	24986	430	299	299	CD
18637	24986	431	-	-	SYM
18637	24986	432	300	300	CD
18637	24986	433	Recruiting	recruiting	NN
18637	24986	434	,	,	,
18637	24986	435	etc	etc	FW
18637	24986	436	.	.	NN
18637	24986	437	,	,	,
18637	24986	438	of	of	IN
18637	24986	439	,	,	,
18637	24986	440	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	24986	441	obstructing	obstructing	NN
18637	24986	442	,	,	,
18637	24986	443	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	24986	444	,	,	,
18637	24986	445	794	794	CD
18637	24986	446	Legal	Legal	NNP
18637	24986	447	Tender	Tender	NNP
18637	24986	448	.	.	.
18637	24987	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24987	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24987	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24987	4	Money	Money	NNP
18637	24987	5	.	.	.
18637	24988	1	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	24988	2	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24988	3	:	:	:
18637	24988	4	Delegation	delegation	NN
18637	24988	5	of	of	IN
18637	24988	6	,	,	,
18637	24988	7	71	71	CD
18637	24988	8	-	-	SYM
18637	24988	9	82	82	CD
18637	24988	10	Enumeration	enumeration	NN
18637	24988	11	of	of	IN
18637	24988	12	;	;	:
18637	24988	13	doctrine	doctrine	NN
18637	24988	14	of	of	IN
18637	24988	15	,	,	,
18637	24988	16	71	71	CD
18637	24988	17	-	-	SYM
18637	24988	18	73	73	CD
18637	24988	19	Preamble	Preamble	NNP
18637	24988	20	no	no	DT
18637	24988	21	source	source	NN
18637	24988	22	of	of	IN
18637	24988	23	,	,	,
18637	24988	24	59	59	CD
18637	24988	25	-	-	SYM
18637	24988	26	60	60	CD
18637	24988	27	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	24988	28	Process	Process	NNP
18637	24988	29	.	.	.
18637	24989	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24989	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24989	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24989	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24989	5	;	;	:
18637	24989	6	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	24989	7	Organization	Organization	NNP
18637	24989	8	;	;	:
18637	24989	9	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	24989	10	Power	Power	NNP
18637	24989	11	.	.	.
18637	24990	1	Libel	libel	NN
18637	24990	2	,	,	,
18637	24990	3	group	group	NN
18637	24990	4	,	,	,
18637	24990	5	802	802	CD
18637	24990	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	24990	7	804	804	CD
18637	24990	8	Liens	Liens	NNPS
18637	24990	9	,	,	,
18637	24990	10	on	on	IN
18637	24990	11	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	24990	12	,	,	,
18637	24990	13	under	under	IN
18637	24990	14	State	State	NNP
18637	24990	15	laws	law	NNS
18637	24990	16	,	,	,
18637	24990	17	235	235	CD
18637	24990	18	Limitation	Limitation	NNP
18637	24990	19	of	of	IN
18637	24990	20	Actions	Actions	NNPS
18637	24990	21	,	,	,
18637	24990	22	State	state	NN
18637	24990	23	enactment	enactment	NN
18637	24990	24	of	of	IN
18637	24990	25	,	,	,
18637	24990	26	due	due	JJ
18637	24990	27	process	process	NN
18637	24990	28	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	24990	29	on	on	IN
18637	24990	30	,	,	,
18637	24990	31	1092	1092	CD
18637	24990	32	-	-	SYM
18637	24990	33	1093	1093	CD
18637	24990	34	Liquor	Liquor	NNP
18637	24990	35	.	.	.
18637	24991	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24991	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24991	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24991	4	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	24991	5	;	;	:
18637	24991	6	Intoxicating	Intoxicating	NNP
18637	24991	7	Liquors	Liquors	NNP
18637	24991	8	.	.	.
18637	24992	1	Lobbying	lobby	VBG
18637	24992	2	,	,	,
18637	24992	3	as	as	IN
18637	24992	4	right	right	NN
18637	24992	5	of	of	IN
18637	24992	6	petition	petition	NN
18637	24992	7	,	,	,
18637	24992	8	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24992	9	,	,	,
18637	24992	10	810	810	CD
18637	24992	11	Lotteries	lottery	NNS
18637	24992	12	.	.	.
18637	24993	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24993	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24993	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24993	4	Gambling	Gambling	NNP
18637	24993	5	.	.	.
18637	24994	1	M	M	NNP
18637	24994	2	Mandamus	Mandamus	NNP
18637	24994	3	.	.	.
18637	24995	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24995	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24995	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24995	4	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	24995	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	24995	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	24995	7	)	)	-RRB-
18637	24995	8	;	;	:
18637	24995	9	States	state	NNS
18637	24995	10	:	:	:
18637	24995	11	Officers	officer	NNS
18637	24995	12	.	.	.
18637	24996	1	Maritime	Maritime	NNP
18637	24996	2	Law	Law	NNP
18637	24996	3	.	.	.
18637	24997	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24997	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24997	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24997	4	Admiralty	Admiralty	NNP
18637	24997	5	.	.	.
18637	24998	1	Marque	Marque	NNP
18637	24998	2	and	and	CC
18637	24998	3	Reprisal	Reprisal	NNP
18637	24998	4	,	,	,
18637	24998	5	Letters	Letters	NNPS
18637	24998	6	of	of	IN
18637	24998	7	,	,	,
18637	24998	8	grant	grant	VB
18637	24998	9	by	by	IN
18637	24998	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	24998	11	,	,	,
18637	24998	12	279	279	CD
18637	24998	13	Martial	Martial	NNP
18637	24998	14	Law	Law	NNP
18637	24998	15	:	:	:
18637	24998	16	Effect	effect	NN
18637	24998	17	on	on	IN
18637	24998	18	personal	personal	JJ
18637	24998	19	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	24998	20	,	,	,
18637	24998	21	484	484	CD
18637	24998	22	Nature	nature	NN
18637	24998	23	of	of	IN
18637	24998	24	,	,	,
18637	24998	25	when	when	WRB
18637	24998	26	lawfully	lawfully	RB
18637	24998	27	invoked	invoke	VBD
18637	24998	28	,	,	,
18637	24998	29	398	398	CD
18637	24998	30	-	-	SYM
18637	24998	31	403	403	CD
18637	24998	32	Meat	meat	NN
18637	24998	33	,	,	,
18637	24998	34	importation	importation	NN
18637	24998	35	,	,	,
18637	24998	36	etc	etc	FW
18637	24998	37	.	.	.
18637	24998	38	,	,	,
18637	24998	39	of	of	IN
18637	24998	40	,	,	,
18637	24998	41	State	state	NN
18637	24998	42	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	24998	43	,	,	,
18637	24998	44	236	236	CD
18637	24998	45	-	-	SYM
18637	24998	46	238	238	CD
18637	24998	47	Migration	Migration	NNP
18637	24998	48	,	,	,
18637	24998	49	interstate	interstate	NN
18637	24998	50	,	,	,
18637	24998	51	State	state	NN
18637	24998	52	curbs	curb	NNS
18637	24998	53	on	on	IN
18637	24998	54	,	,	,
18637	24998	55	241	241	CD
18637	24998	56	-	-	SYM
18637	24998	57	242	242	CD
18637	24998	58	,	,	,
18637	24998	59	968	968	CD
18637	24998	60	Military	Military	NNP
18637	24998	61	Commissions	Commissions	NNPS
18637	24998	62	,	,	,
18637	24998	63	trial	trial	NN
18637	24998	64	by	by	IN
18637	24998	65	,	,	,
18637	24998	66	validity	validity	NN
18637	24998	67	,	,	,
18637	24998	68	294	294	CD
18637	24998	69	,	,	,
18637	24998	70	399	399	CD
18637	24998	71	-	-	SYM
18637	24998	72	403	403	CD
18637	24998	73	Military	Military	NNP
18637	24998	74	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	24998	75	.	.	.
18637	24999	1	_	_	NNP
18637	24999	2	See	See	NNP
18637	24999	3	_	_	NNP
18637	24999	4	Land	Land	NNP
18637	24999	5	,	,	,
18637	24999	6	Air	Air	NNP
18637	24999	7	,	,	,
18637	24999	8	and	and	CC
18637	24999	9	Naval	Naval	NNP
18637	24999	10	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	24999	11	.	.	.
18637	25000	1	Military	Military	NNP
18637	25000	2	Law	Law	NNP
18637	25000	3	.	.	.
18637	25001	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25001	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25001	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25001	4	Land	Land	NNP
18637	25001	5	,	,	,
18637	25001	6	Air	Air	NNP
18637	25001	7	and	and	CC
18637	25001	8	Naval	Naval	NNP
18637	25001	9	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	25001	10	;	;	:
18637	25001	11	Militia	Militia	NNP
18637	25001	12	.	.	.
18637	25002	1	Militia	militia	NN
18637	25002	2	:	:	:
18637	25002	3	Jury	jury	NN
18637	25002	4	,	,	,
18637	25002	5	not	not	RB
18637	25002	6	open	open	JJ
18637	25002	7	to	to	IN
18637	25002	8	indictment	indictment	NN
18637	25002	9	or	or	CC
18637	25002	10	trial	trial	NN
18637	25002	11	by	by	IN
18637	25002	12	,	,	,
18637	25002	13	837	837	CD
18637	25002	14	-	-	SYM
18637	25002	15	838	838	CD
18637	25002	16	Powers	Powers	NNPS
18637	25002	17	of	of	IN
18637	25002	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25002	19	,	,	,
18637	25002	20	States	States	NNP
18637	25002	21	,	,	,
18637	25002	22	as	as	IN
18637	25002	23	to	to	IN
18637	25002	24	,	,	,
18637	25002	25	299	299	CD
18637	25002	26	-	-	SYM
18637	25002	27	300	300	CD
18637	25002	28	Refusal	refusal	NN
18637	25002	29	to	to	TO
18637	25002	30	serve	serve	VB
18637	25002	31	with	with	IN
18637	25002	32	,	,	,
18637	25002	33	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	25002	34	,	,	,
18637	25002	35	299	299	CD
18637	25002	36	Milk	milk	NN
18637	25002	37	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25002	38	_	_	NNP
18637	25002	39	see	see	VB
18637	25002	40	also	also	RB
18637	25002	41	_	_	NNP
18637	25002	42	Conservation	Conservation	NNP
18637	25002	43	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25002	44	:	:	:
18637	25002	45	Export	export	NN
18637	25002	46	,	,	,
18637	25002	47	import	import	NN
18637	25002	48	,	,	,
18637	25002	49	sale	sale	NN
18637	25002	50	of	of	IN
18637	25002	51	,	,	,
18637	25002	52	State	State	NNP
18637	25002	53	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	25002	54	as	as	IN
18637	25002	55	to	to	IN
18637	25002	56	,	,	,
18637	25002	57	236	236	CD
18637	25002	58	-	-	SYM
18637	25002	59	238	238	CD
18637	25002	60	,	,	,
18637	25002	61	244	244	CD
18637	25002	62	-	-	SYM
18637	25002	63	245	245	CD
18637	25002	64	,	,	,
18637	25002	65	1030	1030	CD
18637	25002	66	-	-	SYM
18637	25002	67	1031	1031	CD
18637	25002	68	Price	price	NN
18637	25002	69	-	-	HYPH
18637	25002	70	fixing	fix	VBG
18637	25002	71	under	under	IN
18637	25002	72	Agricultural	Agricultural	NNP
18637	25002	73	Marketing	Marketing	NNP
18637	25002	74	Agreement	Agreement	NNP
18637	25002	75	Act	Act	NNP
18637	25002	76	,	,	,
18637	25002	77	159	159	CD
18637	25002	78	-	-	SYM
18637	25002	79	160	160	CD
18637	25002	80	Price	Price	NNP
18637	25002	81	,	,	,
18637	25002	82	purity	purity	NN
18637	25002	83	of	of	IN
18637	25002	84	,	,	,
18637	25002	85	State	State	NNP
18637	25002	86	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	25002	87	as	as	IN
18637	25002	88	to	to	IN
18637	25002	89	,	,	,
18637	25002	90	236	236	CD
18637	25002	91	-	-	SYM
18637	25002	92	238	238	CD
18637	25002	93	,	,	,
18637	25002	94	244	244	CD
18637	25002	95	-	-	SYM
18637	25002	96	245	245	CD
18637	25002	97	,	,	,
18637	25002	98	996	996	CD
18637	25002	99	-	-	SYM
18637	25002	100	997	997	CD
18637	25002	101	,	,	,
18637	25002	102	1030	1030	CD
18637	25002	103	-	-	SYM
18637	25002	104	1031	1031	CD
18637	25002	105	,	,	,
18637	25002	106	1154	1154	CD
18637	25002	107	Mob	Mob	NNP
18637	25002	108	violence	violence	NN
18637	25002	109	.	.	.
18637	25003	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25003	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25003	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25003	4	Confrontation	Confrontation	NNP
18637	25003	5	;	;	:
18637	25003	6	Domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	25003	7	Violence	violence	NN
18637	25003	8	;	;	:
18637	25003	9	Due	due	IN
18637	25003	10	Process	Process	NNP
18637	25003	11	of	of	IN
18637	25003	12	Law	Law	NNP
18637	25003	13	.	.	.
18637	25004	1	Money	money	NN
18637	25004	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25004	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25004	4	see	see	VBP
18637	25004	5	also	also	RB
18637	25004	6	_	_	NNP
18637	25004	7	Bills	Bills	NNPS
18637	25004	8	of	of	IN
18637	25004	9	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	25004	10	;	;	:
18637	25004	11	Counterfeiting	counterfeiting	NN
18637	25004	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25004	13	:	:	:
18637	25004	14	Coinage	coinage	NN
18637	25004	15	and	and	CC
18637	25004	16	borrowing	borrow	VBG
18637	25004	17	powers	power	NNS
18637	25004	18	of	of	IN
18637	25004	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25004	20	,	,	,
18637	25004	21	relation	relation	NN
18637	25004	22	,	,	,
18637	25004	23	etc	etc	FW
18637	25004	24	.	.	.
18637	25004	25	,	,	,
18637	25004	26	265	265	CD
18637	25004	27	-	-	SYM
18637	25004	28	267	267	CD
18637	25004	29	,	,	,
18637	25004	30	309	309	CD
18637	25004	31	-	-	SYM
18637	25004	32	310	310	CD
18637	25004	33	Gold	gold	NN
18637	25004	34	clauses	clause	NNS
18637	25004	35	in	in	IN
18637	25004	36	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	25004	37	,	,	,
18637	25004	38	abrogation	abrogation	NN
18637	25004	39	,	,	,
18637	25004	40	powers	power	NNS
18637	25004	41	,	,	,
18637	25004	42	of	of	IN
18637	25004	43	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25004	44	as	as	IN
18637	25004	45	to	to	IN
18637	25004	46	,	,	,
18637	25004	47	265	265	CD
18637	25004	48	-	-	SYM
18637	25004	49	267	267	CD
18637	25004	50	,	,	,
18637	25004	51	287	287	CD
18637	25004	52	Legal	legal	JJ
18637	25004	53	tender	tender	NN
18637	25004	54	,	,	,
18637	25004	55	powers	power	NNS
18637	25004	56	of	of	IN
18637	25004	57	States	States	NNP
18637	25004	58	as	as	IN
18637	25004	59	to	to	IN
18637	25004	60	,	,	,
18637	25004	61	326	326	CD
18637	25004	62	Legal	legal	JJ
18637	25004	63	tender	tender	NN
18637	25004	64	,	,	,
18637	25004	65	Treasury	Treasury	NNP
18637	25004	66	notes	note	VBZ
18637	25004	67	as	as	IN
18637	25004	68	,	,	,
18637	25004	69	266	266	CD
18637	25004	70	-	-	SYM
18637	25004	71	267	267	CD
18637	25004	72	,	,	,
18637	25004	73	287	287	CD
18637	25004	74	Money	Money	NNP
18637	25004	75	Lending	Lending	NNP
18637	25004	76	,	,	,
18637	25004	77	State	state	NN
18637	25004	78	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25004	79	of	of	IN
18637	25004	80	,	,	,
18637	25004	81	1020	1020	CD
18637	25004	82	-	-	SYM
18637	25004	83	1021	1021	CD
18637	25004	84	Monopolies	Monopolies	NNPS
18637	25004	85	.	.	.
18637	25005	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25005	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25005	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25005	4	Restraint	Restraint	NNP
18637	25005	5	of	of	IN
18637	25005	6	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	25005	7	.	.	.
18637	25006	1	Morals	moral	NNS
18637	25006	2	,	,	,
18637	25006	3	State	state	NN
18637	25006	4	protection	protection	NN
18637	25006	5	of	of	IN
18637	25006	6	,	,	,
18637	25006	7	1031	1031	CD
18637	25006	8	-	-	SYM
18637	25006	9	1032	1032	CD
18637	25006	10	Mortgages	Mortgages	NNPS
18637	25006	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25006	12	_	_	NNP
18637	25006	13	see	see	VBP
18637	25006	14	also	also	RB
18637	25006	15	_	_	NNP
18637	25006	16	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	25006	17	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25006	18	:	:	:
18637	25006	19	Moratorium	moratorium	NN
18637	25006	20	,	,	,
18637	25006	21	when	when	WRB
18637	25006	22	valid	valid	JJ
18637	25006	23	,	,	,
18637	25006	24	354	354	CD
18637	25006	25	,	,	,
18637	25006	26	359	359	CD
18637	25006	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	25006	28	361	361	CD
18637	25006	29	Motion	Motion	NNP
18637	25006	30	Pictures	Pictures	NNP
18637	25006	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25006	32	_	_	NNP
18637	25006	33	see	see	VBP
18637	25006	34	also	also	RB
18637	25006	35	_	_	NNP
18637	25006	36	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	25006	37	of	of	IN
18637	25006	38	Religion	Religion	NNP
18637	25006	39	,	,	,
18637	25006	40	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	25006	41	,	,	,
18637	25006	42	Press	Press	NNP
18637	25006	43	,	,	,
18637	25006	44	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
18637	25006	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25006	46	:	:	:
18637	25006	47	Censorship	censorship	NN
18637	25006	48	,	,	,
18637	25006	49	importation	importation	NN
18637	25006	50	of	of	IN
18637	25006	51	,	,	,
18637	25006	52	State	State	NNP
18637	25006	53	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	25006	54	as	as	IN
18637	25006	55	to	to	IN
18637	25006	56	,	,	,
18637	25006	57	237	237	CD
18637	25006	58	,	,	,
18637	25006	59	787	787	CD
18637	25006	60	-	-	HYPH
18637	25006	61	788	788	CD
18637	25006	62	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	25006	63	Vehicles	Vehicles	NNPS
18637	25006	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25006	65	_	_	NNP
18637	25006	66	see	see	VBP
18637	25006	67	also	also	RB
18637	25006	68	_	_	NNP
18637	25006	69	Carriers	Carriers	NNPS
18637	25006	70	;	;	:
18637	25006	71	Public	Public	NNP
18637	25006	72	Utilities	Utilities	NNPS
18637	25006	73	;	;	:
18637	25006	74	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	25006	75	:	:	:
18637	25006	76	State	state	NN
18637	25006	77	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25006	78	:	:	:
18637	25006	79	Advertising	advertising	NN
18637	25006	80	signs	sign	NNS
18637	25006	81	on	on	IN
18637	25006	82	,	,	,
18637	25006	83	limited	limited	JJ
18637	25006	84	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	25006	85	,	,	,
18637	25006	86	validity	validity	NN
18637	25006	87	,	,	,
18637	25006	88	1032	1032	CD
18637	25006	89	-	-	SYM
18637	25006	90	1033	1033	CD
18637	25006	91	,	,	,
18637	25006	92	1153	1153	CD
18637	25006	93	-	-	SYM
18637	25006	94	1154	1154	CD
18637	25006	95	Insurer	Insurer	NNP
18637	25006	96	of	of	IN
18637	25006	97	operators	operator	NNS
18637	25006	98	of	of	IN
18637	25006	99	,	,	,
18637	25006	100	liability	liability	NN
18637	25006	101	,	,	,
18637	25006	102	1022	1022	CD
18637	25006	103	Nonresident	nonresident	JJ
18637	25006	104	owners	owner	NNS
18637	25006	105	,	,	,
18637	25006	106	etc	etc	FW
18637	25006	107	.	.	FW
18637	25006	108	,	,	,
18637	25006	109	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	25006	110	of	of	IN
18637	25006	111	agent	agent	NN
18637	25006	112	for	for	IN
18637	25006	113	service	service	NN
18637	25006	114	of	of	IN
18637	25006	115	process	process	NN
18637	25006	116	,	,	,
18637	25006	117	660	660	CD
18637	25006	118	-	-	SYM
18637	25006	119	661	661	CD
18637	25006	120	,	,	,
18637	25006	121	1074	1074	CD
18637	25006	122	State	state	NN
18637	25006	123	,	,	,
18637	25006	124	etc	etc	FW
18637	25006	125	.	.	FW
18637	25006	126	,	,	,
18637	25006	127	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	25006	128	powers	power	NNS
18637	25006	129	as	as	IN
18637	25006	130	to	to	IN
18637	25006	131	,	,	,
18637	25006	132	211	211	CD
18637	25006	133	-	-	SYM
18637	25006	134	212	212	CD
18637	25006	135	,	,	,
18637	25006	136	226	226	CD
18637	25006	137	-	-	SYM
18637	25006	138	228	228	CD
18637	25006	139	,	,	,
18637	25006	140	250	250	CD
18637	25006	141	,	,	,
18637	25006	142	1032	1032	CD
18637	25006	143	-	-	SYM
18637	25006	144	1033	1033	CD
18637	25006	145	,	,	,
18637	25006	146	1153	1153	CD
18637	25006	147	,	,	,
18637	25006	148	1155	1155	CD
18637	25006	149	Municipal	Municipal	NNP
18637	25006	150	Corporations	Corporations	NNPS
18637	25006	151	.	.	.
18637	25007	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25007	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25007	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25007	4	States	States	NNP
18637	25007	5	:	:	:
18637	25007	6	Political	Political	NNP
18637	25007	7	Subdivisions	Subdivisions	NNPS
18637	25007	8	.	.	.
18637	25008	1	N	N	NNP
18637	25008	2	National	National	NNP
18637	25008	3	Banks	Banks	NNPS
18637	25008	4	:	:	:
18637	25008	5	Incorporation	incorporation	NN
18637	25008	6	,	,	,
18637	25008	7	etc	etc	FW
18637	25008	8	.	.	FW
18637	25008	9	,	,	,
18637	25008	10	by	by	IN
18637	25008	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25008	12	,	,	,
18637	25008	13	265	265	CD
18637	25008	14	,	,	,
18637	25008	15	267	267	CD
18637	25008	16	,	,	,
18637	25008	17	309	309	CD
18637	25008	18	State	state	NN
18637	25008	19	laws	law	NNS
18637	25008	20	,	,	,
18637	25008	21	application	application	NN
18637	25008	22	to	to	IN
18637	25008	23	,	,	,
18637	25008	24	national	national	JJ
18637	25008	25	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	25008	26	,	,	,
18637	25008	27	725	725	CD
18637	25008	28	State	state	NN
18637	25008	29	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	25008	30	of	of	IN
18637	25008	31	,	,	,
18637	25008	32	729	729	CD
18637	25008	33	,	,	,
18637	25008	34	733	733	CD
18637	25008	35	National	National	NNP
18637	25008	36	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
18637	25008	37	Recovery	Recovery	NNP
18637	25008	38	Act	Act	NNP
18637	25008	39	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25008	40	NIRA	NIRA	NNP
18637	25008	41	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25008	42	,	,	,
18637	25008	43	void	void	JJ
18637	25008	44	,	,	,
18637	25008	45	152	152	CD
18637	25008	46	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	47	153	153	CD
18637	25008	48	National	National	NNP
18637	25008	49	Supremacy	Supremacy	NNP
18637	25008	50	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25008	51	_	_	NNP
18637	25008	52	see	see	VBP
18637	25008	53	also	also	RB
18637	25008	54	_	_	NNP
18637	25008	55	National	National	NNP
18637	25008	56	Banks	Banks	NNPS
18637	25008	57	;	;	:
18637	25008	58	Public	Public	NNP
18637	25008	59	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	25008	60	of	of	IN
18637	25008	61	the	the	DT
18637	25008	62	United	United	NNP
18637	25008	63	States	States	NNP
18637	25008	64	;	;	:
18637	25008	65	States	state	NNS
18637	25008	66	:	:	:
18637	25008	67	Courts	court	NNS
18637	25008	68	;	;	:
18637	25008	69	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	25008	70	:	:	:
18637	25008	71	State	state	NN
18637	25008	72	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25008	73	:	:	:
18637	25008	74	Conflict	conflict	NN
18637	25008	75	with	with	IN
18637	25008	76	Tenth	Tenth	NNP
18637	25008	77	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	25008	78	,	,	,
18637	25008	79	915	915	CD
18637	25008	80	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	81	921	921	CD
18637	25008	82	Examples	example	NNS
18637	25008	83	,	,	,
18637	25008	84	122	122	CD
18637	25008	85	,	,	,
18637	25008	86	134	134	CD
18637	25008	87	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	88	137	137	CD
18637	25008	89	,	,	,
18637	25008	90	139	139	CD
18637	25008	91	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	92	140	140	CD
18637	25008	93	,	,	,
18637	25008	94	148	148	CD
18637	25008	95	,	,	,
18637	25008	96	231	231	CD
18637	25008	97	,	,	,
18637	25008	98	276	276	CD
18637	25008	99	,	,	,
18637	25008	100	310	310	CD
18637	25008	101	,	,	,
18637	25008	102	386	386	CD
18637	25008	103	,	,	,
18637	25008	104	416	416	CD
18637	25008	105	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	106	418	418	CD
18637	25008	107	,	,	,
18637	25008	108	437	437	CD
18637	25008	109	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	110	438	438	CD
18637	25008	111	,	,	,
18637	25008	112	554	554	CD
18637	25008	113	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	114	555	555	CD
18637	25008	115	,	,	,
18637	25008	116	568	568	CD
18637	25008	117	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	118	569	569	CD
18637	25008	119	,	,	,
18637	25008	120	626	626	CD
18637	25008	121	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	122	627	627	CD
18637	25008	123	,	,	,
18637	25008	124	631	631	CD
18637	25008	125	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	126	633	633	CD
18637	25008	127	,	,	,
18637	25008	128	636	636	CD
18637	25008	129	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	130	637	637	CD
18637	25008	131	,	,	,
18637	25008	132	698	698	CD
18637	25008	133	,	,	,
18637	25008	134	702	702	CD
18637	25008	135	,	,	,
18637	25008	136	721	721	CD
18637	25008	137	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	138	722	722	CD
18637	25008	139	,	,	,
18637	25008	140	724	724	CD
18637	25008	141	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	142	739	739	CD
18637	25008	143	,	,	,
18637	25008	144	868	868	CD
18637	25008	145	,	,	,
18637	25008	146	916	916	CD
18637	25008	147	,	,	,
18637	25008	148	919	919	CD
18637	25008	149	,	,	,
18637	25008	150	966	966	CD
18637	25008	151	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25008	152	contractors	contractor	NNS
18637	25008	153	,	,	,
18637	25008	154	State	state	NN
18637	25008	155	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	25008	156	of	of	IN
18637	25008	157	,	,	,
18637	25008	158	application	application	NN
18637	25008	159	of	of	IN
18637	25008	160	State	state	NN
18637	25008	161	laws	law	NNS
18637	25008	162	to	to	IN
18637	25008	163	,	,	,
18637	25008	164	726	726	CD
18637	25008	165	,	,	,
18637	25008	166	730	730	CD
18637	25008	167	-	-	HYPH
18637	25008	168	732	732	CD
18637	25008	169	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25008	170	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	25008	171	,	,	,
18637	25008	172	securities	security	NNS
18637	25008	173	,	,	,
18637	25008	174	State	state	NN
18637	25008	175	tax	tax	NN
18637	25008	176	exemption	exemption	NN
18637	25008	177	,	,	,
18637	25008	178	728	728	CD
18637	25008	179	-	-	HYPH
18637	25008	180	736	736	CD
18637	25008	181	Meaning	Meaning	NNP
18637	25008	182	,	,	,
18637	25008	183	interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	25008	184	,	,	,
18637	25008	185	of	of	IN
18637	25008	186	,	,	,
18637	25008	187	721	721	CD
18637	25008	188	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	189	722	722	CD
18637	25008	190	,	,	,
18637	25008	191	724	724	CD
18637	25008	192	-	-	HYPH
18637	25008	193	736	736	CD
18637	25008	194	State	State	NNP
18637	25008	195	laws	law	NNS
18637	25008	196	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	25008	197	during	during	IN
18637	25008	198	insurrection	insurrection	NN
18637	25008	199	,	,	,
18637	25008	200	effect	effect	NN
18637	25008	201	,	,	,
18637	25008	202	728	728	CD
18637	25008	203	Naturalization	naturalization	NN
18637	25008	204	:	:	:
18637	25008	205	Cancellation	cancellation	NN
18637	25008	206	for	for	IN
18637	25008	207	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	25008	208	,	,	,
18637	25008	209	residence	residence	NN
18637	25008	210	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	25008	211	,	,	,
18637	25008	212	256	256	CD
18637	25008	213	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	214	257	257	CD
18637	25008	215	Powers	power	NNS
18637	25008	216	of	of	IN
18637	25008	217	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25008	218	as	as	IN
18637	25008	219	to	to	IN
18637	25008	220	,	,	,
18637	25008	221	254	254	CD
18637	25008	222	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	223	259	259	CD
18637	25008	224	Retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	25008	225	effect	effect	NN
18637	25008	226	of	of	IN
18637	25008	227	,	,	,
18637	25008	228	258	258	CD
18637	25008	229	Navigable	Navigable	NNP
18637	25008	230	Waters	Waters	NNPS
18637	25008	231	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25008	232	_	_	NNP
18637	25008	233	see	see	VBP
18637	25008	234	also	also	RB
18637	25008	235	_	_	NNP
18637	25008	236	Flood	Flood	NNP
18637	25008	237	Control	Control	NNP
18637	25008	238	;	;	:
18637	25008	239	Hydroelectric	Hydroelectric	NNP
18637	25008	240	Power	Power	NNP
18637	25008	241	;	;	:
18637	25008	242	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	25008	243	;	;	:
18637	25008	244	Vessels	Vessels	NNP
18637	25008	245	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25008	246	:	:	:
18637	25008	247	Defined	define	VBN
18637	25008	248	,	,	,
18637	25008	249	577	577	CD
18637	25008	250	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	251	578	578	CD
18637	25008	252	,	,	,
18637	25008	253	867	867	CD
18637	25008	254	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	255	868	868	CD
18637	25008	256	Regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	25008	257	powers	power	NNS
18637	25008	258	of	of	IN
18637	25008	259	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25008	260	,	,	,
18637	25008	261	States	States	NNP
18637	25008	262	as	as	IN
18637	25008	263	to	to	IN
18637	25008	264	,	,	,
18637	25008	265	126	126	CD
18637	25008	266	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	267	132	132	CD
18637	25008	268	,	,	,
18637	25008	269	228	228	CD
18637	25008	270	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	271	231	231	CD
18637	25008	272	Riparian	riparian	JJ
18637	25008	273	owners	owner	NNS
18637	25008	274	injured	injure	VBN
18637	25008	275	by	by	IN
18637	25008	276	improvement	improvement	NN
18637	25008	277	of	of	IN
18637	25008	278	,	,	,
18637	25008	279	right	right	RB
18637	25008	280	to	to	IN
18637	25008	281	compensation	compensation	NN
18637	25008	282	,	,	,
18637	25008	283	867	867	CD
18637	25008	284	-	-	HYPH
18637	25008	285	869	869	CD
18637	25008	286	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
18637	25008	287	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25008	288	_	_	NNP
18637	25008	289	see	see	VBP
18637	25008	290	also	also	RB
18637	25008	291	_	_	NNP
18637	25008	292	Hydroelectric	Hydroelectric	NNP
18637	25008	293	Power	Power	NNP
18637	25008	294	;	;	:
18637	25008	295	Navigable	Navigable	NNP
18637	25008	296	Waters	water	NNS
18637	25008	297	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25008	298	:	:	:
18637	25008	299	Instruments	instrument	NNS
18637	25008	300	of	of	IN
18637	25008	301	,	,	,
18637	25008	302	docks	dock	NNS
18637	25008	303	,	,	,
18637	25008	304	ferries	ferry	NNS
18637	25008	305	,	,	,
18637	25008	306	etc	etc	FW
18637	25008	307	.	.	FW
18637	25008	308	,	,	,
18637	25008	309	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25008	310	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25008	311	of	of	IN
18637	25008	312	,	,	,
18637	25008	313	128	128	CD
18637	25008	314	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	315	130	130	CD
18637	25008	316	Obstructions	obstruction	NNS
18637	25008	317	to	to	IN
18637	25008	318	,	,	,
18637	25008	319	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25008	320	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	25008	321	of	of	IN
18637	25008	322	,	,	,
18637	25008	323	126	126	CD
18637	25008	324	-	-	SYM
18637	25008	325	128	128	CD
18637	25008	326	Navy	Navy	NNP
18637	25008	327	.	.	.
18637	25009	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25009	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25009	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25009	4	Land	Land	NNP
18637	25009	5	,	,	,
18637	25009	6	Air	Air	NNP
18637	25009	7	and	and	CC
18637	25009	8	Naval	Naval	NNP
18637	25009	9	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	25009	10	.	.	.
18637	25010	1	Nazi	Nazi	NNP
18637	25010	2	Saboteurs	Saboteurs	NNP
18637	25010	3	,	,	,
18637	25010	4	trial	trial	NN
18637	25010	5	by	by	IN
18637	25010	6	military	military	NNP
18637	25010	7	commission	commission	NN
18637	25010	8	,	,	,
18637	25010	9	285	285	CD
18637	25010	10	-	-	SYM
18637	25010	11	286	286	CD
18637	25010	12	,	,	,
18637	25010	13	401	401	CD
18637	25010	14	-	-	SYM
18637	25010	15	402	402	CD
18637	25010	16	"	"	``
18637	25010	17	Necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	25010	18	and	and	CC
18637	25010	19	Proper	proper	JJ
18637	25010	20	"	"	''
18637	25010	21	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	25010	22	,	,	,
18637	25010	23	110	110	CD
18637	25010	24	,	,	,
18637	25010	25	121	121	CD
18637	25010	26	,	,	,
18637	25010	27	266	266	CD
18637	25010	28	-	-	SYM
18637	25010	29	267	267	CD
18637	25010	30	,	,	,
18637	25010	31	307	307	CD
18637	25010	32	-	-	SYM
18637	25010	33	311	311	CD
18637	25010	34	,	,	,
18637	25010	35	426	426	CD
18637	25010	36	-	-	SYM
18637	25010	37	427	427	CD
18637	25010	38	Negroes	Negroes	NNPS
18637	25010	39	:	:	:
18637	25010	40	Citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	25010	41	of	of	IN
18637	25010	42	,	,	,
18637	25010	43	963	963	CD
18637	25010	44	-	-	HYPH
18637	25010	45	964	964	CD
18637	25010	46	Home	home	NN
18637	25010	47	ownership	ownership	NN
18637	25010	48	,	,	,
18637	25010	49	occupancy	occupancy	NN
18637	25010	50	,	,	,
18637	25010	51	public	public	JJ
18637	25010	52	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	25010	53	on	on	IN
18637	25010	54	,	,	,
18637	25010	55	private	private	JJ
18637	25010	56	covenants	covenant	NNS
18637	25010	57	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	25010	58	,	,	,
18637	25010	59	validity	validity	NN
18637	25010	60	,	,	,
18637	25010	61	1028	1028	CD
18637	25010	62	,	,	,
18637	25010	63	1142	1142	CD
18637	25010	64	,	,	,
18637	25010	65	1161	1161	CD
18637	25010	66	Right	right	UH
18637	25010	67	to	to	TO
18637	25010	68	vote	vote	VB
18637	25010	69	,	,	,
18637	25010	70	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
18637	25010	71	devices	device	NNS
18637	25010	72	denying	deny	VBG
18637	25010	73	,	,	,
18637	25010	74	validity	validity	NN
18637	25010	75	,	,	,
18637	25010	76	1163	1163	CD
18637	25010	77	-	-	SYM
18637	25010	78	1164	1164	CD
18637	25010	79	,	,	,
18637	25010	80	1183	1183	CD
18637	25010	81	-	-	SYM
18637	25010	82	1186	1186	CD
18637	25010	83	,	,	,
18637	25010	84	1208	1208	CD
18637	25010	85	Segregation	Segregation	NNP
18637	25010	86	in	in	IN
18637	25010	87	schools	school	NNS
18637	25010	88	,	,	,
18637	25010	89	conveyances	conveyance	NNS
18637	25010	90	,	,	,
18637	25010	91	laws	law	NNS
18637	25010	92	as	as	IN
18637	25010	93	to	to	IN
18637	25010	94	,	,	,
18637	25010	95	validity	validity	NN
18637	25010	96	,	,	,
18637	25010	97	1161	1161	CD
18637	25010	98	-	-	SYM
18637	25010	99	1163	1163	CD
18637	25010	100	Segregation	Segregation	NNP
18637	25010	101	,	,	,
18637	25010	102	State	State	NNP
18637	25010	103	powers	power	NNS
18637	25010	104	as	as	IN
18637	25010	105	to	to	IN
18637	25010	106	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	25010	107	carriers	carrier	NNS
18637	25010	108	,	,	,
18637	25010	109	225	225	CD
18637	25010	110	-	-	SYM
18637	25010	111	226	226	CD
18637	25010	112	,	,	,
18637	25010	113	230	230	CD
18637	25010	114	Nobility	Nobility	NNP
18637	25010	115	,	,	,
18637	25010	116	titles	title	NNS
18637	25010	117	of	of	IN
18637	25010	118	,	,	,
18637	25010	119	not	not	RB
18637	25010	120	granted	grant	VBN
18637	25010	121	by	by	IN
18637	25010	122	United	United	NNP
18637	25010	123	States	States	NNP
18637	25010	124	,	,	,
18637	25010	125	nor	nor	CC
18637	25010	126	accepted	accept	VBN
18637	25010	127	by	by	IN
18637	25010	128	public	public	JJ
18637	25010	129	officers	officer	NNS
18637	25010	130	without	without	IN
18637	25010	131	consent	consent	NN
18637	25010	132	of	of	IN
18637	25010	133	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25010	134	,	,	,
18637	25010	135	324	324	CD
18637	25010	136	O	o	NN
18637	25010	137	Oaths	Oaths	NNPS
18637	25010	138	,	,	,
18637	25010	139	powers	power	NNS
18637	25010	140	of	of	IN
18637	25010	141	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25010	142	as	as	IN
18637	25010	143	to	to	IN
18637	25010	144	,	,	,
18637	25010	145	736	736	CD
18637	25010	146	Obligation	Obligation	NNP
18637	25010	147	of	of	IN
18637	25010	148	Contracts	contract	NNS
18637	25010	149	.	.	.
18637	25011	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25011	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25011	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25011	4	Contracts	Contracts	NNP
18637	25011	5	.	.	.
18637	25012	1	Officers	officer	NNS
18637	25012	2	of	of	IN
18637	25012	3	the	the	DT
18637	25012	4	United	United	NNP
18637	25012	5	States	States	NNP
18637	25012	6	.	.	.
18637	25013	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25013	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25013	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25013	4	Public	Public	NNP
18637	25013	5	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	25013	6	of	of	IN
18637	25013	7	the	the	DT
18637	25013	8	United	United	NNP
18637	25013	9	States	States	NNP
18637	25013	10	.	.	.
18637	25014	1	Oil	oil	NN
18637	25014	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25014	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25014	4	see	see	VB
18637	25014	5	also	also	RB
18637	25014	6	_	_	NNP
18637	25014	7	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	25014	8	:	:	:
18637	25014	9	State	state	NN
18637	25014	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25014	11	:	:	:
18637	25014	12	Conservation	conservation	NN
18637	25014	13	,	,	,
18637	25014	14	powers	power	NNS
18637	25014	15	of	of	IN
18637	25014	16	States	States	NNP
18637	25014	17	,	,	,
18637	25014	18	1025	1025	CD
18637	25014	19	-	-	SYM
18637	25014	20	1026	1026	CD
18637	25014	21	Damages	damage	NNS
18637	25014	22	from	from	IN
18637	25014	23	drilling	drilling	NN
18637	25014	24	,	,	,
18637	25014	25	requiring	require	VBG
18637	25014	26	bond	bond	NN
18637	25014	27	to	to	TO
18637	25014	28	cover	cover	VB
18637	25014	29	,	,	,
18637	25014	30	1026	1026	CD
18637	25014	31	Leases	lease	NNS
18637	25014	32	from	from	IN
18637	25014	33	United	United	NNP
18637	25014	34	States	States	NNP
18637	25014	35	,	,	,
18637	25014	36	cancellation	cancellation	NN
18637	25014	37	for	for	IN
18637	25014	38	fraud	fraud	NN
18637	25014	39	,	,	,
18637	25014	40	311	311	CD
18637	25014	41	under	under	IN
18637	25014	42	Marginal	marginal	JJ
18637	25014	43	belt	belt	NN
18637	25014	44	along	along	IN
18637	25014	45	coast	coast	NN
18637	25014	46	,	,	,
18637	25014	47	powers	power	NNS
18637	25014	48	of	of	IN
18637	25014	49	United	United	NNP
18637	25014	50	States	States	NNP
18637	25014	51	as	as	IN
18637	25014	52	to	to	IN
18637	25014	53	,	,	,
18637	25014	54	325	325	CD
18637	25014	55	,	,	,
18637	25014	56	700	700	CD
18637	25014	57	"	"	``
18637	25014	58	Okies	Okies	NNPS
18637	25014	59	"	"	''
18637	25014	60	,	,	,
18637	25014	61	State	state	NN
18637	25014	62	curbs	curb	NNS
18637	25014	63	on	on	IN
18637	25014	64	entry	entry	NN
18637	25014	65	,	,	,
18637	25014	66	242	242	CD
18637	25014	67	,	,	,
18637	25014	68	968	968	CD
18637	25014	69	Oleomargarine	Oleomargarine	NNP
18637	25014	70	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25014	71	_	_	NNP
18637	25014	72	see	see	VB
18637	25014	73	also	also	RB
18637	25014	74	_	_	NNP
18637	25014	75	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	25014	76	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25014	77	:	:	:
18637	25014	78	State	state	NN
18637	25014	79	laws	law	NNS
18637	25014	80	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	25014	81	,	,	,
18637	25014	82	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	25014	83	sale	sale	NN
18637	25014	84	of	of	IN
18637	25014	85	,	,	,
18637	25014	86	239	239	CD
18637	25014	87	-	-	SYM
18637	25014	88	240	240	CD
18637	25014	89	,	,	,
18637	25014	90	1030	1030	CD
18637	25014	91	,	,	,
18637	25014	92	1154	1154	CD
18637	25014	93	Original	Original	NNP
18637	25014	94	Package	Package	NNP
18637	25014	95	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
18637	25014	96	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25014	97	_	_	NNP
18637	25014	98	see	see	VB
18637	25014	99	also	also	RB
18637	25014	100	_	_	NNP
18637	25014	101	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	25014	102	:	:	:
18637	25014	103	State	state	NN
18637	25014	104	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25014	105	:	:	:
18637	25014	106	Effect	effect	NN
18637	25014	107	on	on	IN
18637	25014	108	State	State	NNP
18637	25014	109	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25014	110	of	of	IN
18637	25014	111	cigarettes	cigarette	NNS
18637	25014	112	,	,	,
18637	25014	113	convict	convict	NN
18637	25014	114	-	-	HYPH
18637	25014	115	made	make	VBN
18637	25014	116	goods	good	NNS
18637	25014	117	,	,	,
18637	25014	118	liquors	liquor	NNS
18637	25014	119	,	,	,
18637	25014	120	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
18637	25014	121	,	,	,
18637	25014	122	etc	etc	FW
18637	25014	123	.	.	FW
18637	25014	124	,	,	,
18637	25014	125	236	236	CD
18637	25014	126	-	-	SYM
18637	25014	127	241	241	CD
18637	25014	128	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	25014	129	and	and	CC
18637	25014	130	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	25014	131	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	25014	132	,	,	,
18637	25014	133	relation	relation	NN
18637	25014	134	to	to	IN
18637	25014	135	,	,	,
18637	25014	136	177	177	CD
18637	25014	137	-	-	SYM
18637	25014	138	178	178	CD
18637	25014	139	,	,	,
18637	25014	140	180	180	CD
18637	25014	141	,	,	,
18637	25014	142	182	182	CD
18637	25014	143	-	-	SYM
18637	25014	144	189	189	CD
18637	25014	145	,	,	,
18637	25014	146	194	194	CD
18637	25014	147	,	,	,
18637	25014	148	236	236	CD
18637	25014	149	-	-	SYM
18637	25014	150	241	241	CD
18637	25014	151	,	,	,
18637	25014	152	362	362	CD
18637	25014	153	-	-	SYM
18637	25014	154	363	363	CD
18637	25014	155	P	P	NNP
18637	25014	156	Packers	Packers	NNPS
18637	25014	157	and	and	CC
18637	25014	158	Stockyards	Stockyards	NNPS
18637	25014	159	Act	Act	NNP
18637	25014	160	.	.	.
18637	25015	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25015	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25015	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25015	4	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	25015	5	.	.	.
18637	25016	1	Pardons	pardon	NNS
18637	25016	2	:	:	:
18637	25016	3	Congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	25016	4	powers	power	NNS
18637	25016	5	as	as	IN
18637	25016	6	to	to	IN
18637	25016	7	;	;	:
18637	25016	8	amnesty	amnesty	NNP
18637	25016	9	,	,	,
18637	25016	10	etc	etc	FW
18637	25016	11	.	.	.
18637	25016	12	,	,	,
18637	25016	13	324	324	CD
18637	25016	14	,	,	,
18637	25016	15	411	411	CD
18637	25016	16	,	,	,
18637	25016	17	527	527	CD
18637	25016	18	-	-	SYM
18637	25016	19	528	528	CD
18637	25016	20	for	for	IN
18637	25016	21	Contempts	Contempts	NNP
18637	25016	22	,	,	,
18637	25016	23	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	25016	24	on	on	IN
18637	25016	25	President	President	NNP
18637	25016	26	,	,	,
18637	25016	27	408	408	CD
18637	25016	28	-	-	SYM
18637	25016	29	409	409	CD
18637	25016	30	,	,	,
18637	25016	31	521	521	CD
18637	25016	32	Legal	legal	JJ
18637	25016	33	nature	nature	NN
18637	25016	34	,	,	,
18637	25016	35	essentials	essential	NNS
18637	25016	36	,	,	,
18637	25016	37	of	of	IN
18637	25016	38	;	;	:
18637	25016	39	limited	limited	JJ
18637	25016	40	effect	effect	NN
18637	25016	41	,	,	,
18637	25016	42	324	324	CD
18637	25016	43	,	,	,
18637	25016	44	406	406	CD
18637	25016	45	-	-	SYM
18637	25016	46	407	407	CD
18637	25016	47	,	,	,
18637	25016	48	409	409	CD
18637	25016	49	-	-	SYM
18637	25016	50	411	411	CD
18637	25016	51	,	,	,
18637	25016	52	527	527	CD
18637	25016	53	-	-	SYM
18637	25016	54	528	528	CD
18637	25016	55	of	of	IN
18637	25016	56	Participant	Participant	NNP
18637	25016	57	in	in	IN
18637	25016	58	Civil	Civil	NNP
18637	25016	59	War	War	NNP
18637	25016	60	,	,	,
18637	25016	61	effect	effect	NN
18637	25016	62	,	,	,
18637	25016	63	1173	1173	CD
18637	25016	64	Patents	patent	NNS
18637	25016	65	:	:	:
18637	25016	66	Nature	nature	NN
18637	25016	67	and	and	CC
18637	25016	68	scope	scope	NN
18637	25016	69	of	of	IN
18637	25016	70	right	right	JJ
18637	25016	71	secured	secure	VBN
18637	25016	72	,	,	,
18637	25016	73	274	274	CD
18637	25016	74	-	-	SYM
18637	25016	75	275	275	CD
18637	25016	76	Patentable	patentable	JJ
18637	25016	77	discoveries	discovery	NNS
18637	25016	78	,	,	,
18637	25016	79	271	271	CD
18637	25016	80	-	-	SYM
18637	25016	81	273	273	CD
18637	25016	82	State	State	NNP
18637	25016	83	powers	power	NNS
18637	25016	84	as	as	IN
18637	25016	85	to	to	IN
18637	25016	86	,	,	,
18637	25016	87	276	276	CD
18637	25016	88	Peddlers	Peddlers	NNPS
18637	25016	89	,	,	,
18637	25016	90	State	state	NN
18637	25016	91	laws	law	NNS
18637	25016	92	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	25016	93	,	,	,
18637	25016	94	786	786	CD
18637	25016	95	,	,	,
18637	25016	96	1155	1155	CD
18637	25016	97	-	-	SYM
18637	25016	98	1156	1156	CD
18637	25016	99	Penalties	penalty	NNS
18637	25016	100	.	.	.
18637	25017	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25017	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25017	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25017	4	Crimes	Crimes	NNPS
18637	25017	5	and	and	CC
18637	25017	6	Offenses	Offenses	NNPS
18637	25017	7	.	.	.
18637	25018	1	Peonage	peonage	NN
18637	25018	2	.	.	.
18637	25019	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25019	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25019	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25019	4	Involuntary	Involuntary	NNP
18637	25019	5	Servitude	Servitude	NNP
18637	25019	6	.	.	.
18637	25020	1	People	People	NNS
18637	25020	2	of	of	IN
18637	25020	3	the	the	DT
18637	25020	4	United	United	NNP
18637	25020	5	States	States	NNP
18637	25020	6	:	:	:
18637	25020	7	"	"	``
18637	25020	8	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	25020	9	"	"	''
18637	25020	10	,	,	,
18637	25020	11	synonymous	synonymous	JJ
18637	25020	12	with	with	IN
18637	25020	13	Sovereignty	Sovereignty	NNP
18637	25020	14	,	,	,
18637	25020	15	possessors	possessor	NNS
18637	25020	16	of	of	IN
18637	25020	17	,	,	,
18637	25020	18	59	59	CD
18637	25020	19	-	-	SYM
18637	25020	20	60	60	CD
18637	25020	21	Perjured	Perjured	NNP
18637	25020	22	testimony	testimony	NN
18637	25020	23	,	,	,
18637	25020	24	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	25020	25	on	on	IN
18637	25020	26	,	,	,
18637	25020	27	validity	validity	NN
18637	25020	28	,	,	,
18637	25020	29	1124	1124	CD
18637	25020	30	-	-	SYM
18637	25020	31	1126	1126	CD
18637	25020	32	Petition	Petition	NNP
18637	25020	33	,	,	,
18637	25020	34	Right	right	RB
18637	25020	35	of	of	IN
18637	25020	36	.	.	.
18637	25021	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25021	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25021	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25021	4	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	25021	5	of	of	IN
18637	25021	6	Religion	Religion	NNP
18637	25021	7	,	,	,
18637	25021	8	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	25021	9	,	,	,
18637	25021	10	Press	Press	NNP
18637	25021	11	,	,	,
18637	25021	12	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
18637	25021	13	.	.	.
18637	25022	1	Pharmacies	pharmacy	NNS
18637	25022	2	,	,	,
18637	25022	3	corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	25022	4	operation	operation	NN
18637	25022	5	of	of	IN
18637	25022	6	,	,	,
18637	25022	7	State	state	NN
18637	25022	8	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25022	9	as	as	IN
18637	25022	10	to	to	IN
18637	25022	11	,	,	,
18637	25022	12	1023	1023	CD
18637	25022	13	Picketing	picket	VBG
18637	25022	14	.	.	.
18637	25023	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25023	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25023	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25023	4	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	25023	5	.	.	.
18637	25024	1	Piers	pier	NNS
18637	25024	2	.	.	.
18637	25025	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25025	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25025	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25025	4	Wharves	Wharves	NNPS
18637	25025	5	and	and	CC
18637	25025	6	Docks	Docks	NNPS
18637	25025	7	.	.	.
18637	25026	1	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	25026	2	Lines	Lines	NNP
18637	25026	3	.	.	.
18637	25027	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25027	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25027	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25027	4	Carriers	Carriers	NNPS
18637	25027	5	;	;	:
18637	25027	6	Public	Public	NNP
18637	25027	7	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	25027	8	.	.	.
18637	25028	1	Piracy	piracy	NN
18637	25028	2	,	,	,
18637	25028	3	power	power	NN
18637	25028	4	of	of	IN
18637	25028	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25028	6	to	to	TO
18637	25028	7	define	define	VB
18637	25028	8	,	,	,
18637	25028	9	punish	punish	VB
18637	25028	10	,	,	,
18637	25028	11	277	277	CD
18637	25028	12	-	-	SYM
18637	25028	13	279	279	CD
18637	25028	14	Plants	plant	NNS
18637	25028	15	.	.	.
18637	25029	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25029	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25029	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25029	4	Quarantine	Quarantine	NNP
18637	25029	5	Laws	Laws	NNP
18637	25029	6	.	.	.
18637	25030	1	Police	police	NN
18637	25030	2	Power	power	NN
18637	25030	3	:	:	:
18637	25030	4	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	25030	5	,	,	,
18637	25030	6	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	25030	7	of	of	IN
18637	25030	8	,	,	,
18637	25030	9	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	25030	10	by	by	IN
18637	25030	11	,	,	,
18637	25030	12	345	345	CD
18637	25030	13	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	14	348	348	CD
18637	25030	15	,	,	,
18637	25030	16	350	350	CD
18637	25030	17	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	18	352	352	CD
18637	25030	19	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25030	20	,	,	,
18637	25030	21	as	as	IN
18637	25030	22	limited	limit	VBN
18637	25030	23	by	by	IN
18637	25030	24	due	due	JJ
18637	25030	25	process	process	NN
18637	25030	26	clause	clause	NN
18637	25030	27	,	,	,
18637	25030	28	859	859	CD
18637	25030	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	25030	30	862	862	CD
18637	25030	31	Foreign	Foreign	NNP
18637	25030	32	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	25030	33	,	,	,
18637	25030	34	in	in	IN
18637	25030	35	relation	relation	NN
18637	25030	36	to	to	IN
18637	25030	37	,	,	,
18637	25030	38	215	215	CD
18637	25030	39	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	40	217	217	CD
18637	25030	41	Implementation	implementation	NN
18637	25030	42	of	of	IN
18637	25030	43	,	,	,
18637	25030	44	by	by	IN
18637	25030	45	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25030	46	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	25030	47	of	of	IN
18637	25030	48	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	25030	49	,	,	,
18637	25030	50	169	169	CD
18637	25030	51	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	52	173	173	CD
18637	25030	53	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	25030	54	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	25030	55	,	,	,
18637	25030	56	in	in	IN
18637	25030	57	relation	relation	NN
18637	25030	58	to	to	IN
18637	25030	59	,	,	,
18637	25030	60	215	215	CD
18637	25030	61	,	,	,
18637	25030	62	217	217	CD
18637	25030	63	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	64	252	252	CD
18637	25030	65	,	,	,
18637	25030	66	968	968	CD
18637	25030	67	,	,	,
18637	25030	68	1232	1232	CD
18637	25030	69	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	70	1233	1233	CD
18637	25030	71	State	State	NNP
18637	25030	72	,	,	,
18637	25030	73	as	as	IN
18637	25030	74	limited	limit	VBN
18637	25030	75	by	by	IN
18637	25030	76	equal	equal	JJ
18637	25030	77	protection	protection	NN
18637	25030	78	clause	clause	NN
18637	25030	79	,	,	,
18637	25030	80	1144	1144	CD
18637	25030	81	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	82	1146	1146	CD
18637	25030	83	,	,	,
18637	25030	84	1153	1153	CD
18637	25030	85	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	86	1163	1163	CD
18637	25030	87	State	State	NNP
18637	25030	88	,	,	,
18637	25030	89	conflict	conflict	NN
18637	25030	90	with	with	IN
18637	25030	91	national	national	JJ
18637	25030	92	supremacy	supremacy	NN
18637	25030	93	,	,	,
18637	25030	94	722	722	CD
18637	25030	95	-	-	HYPH
18637	25030	96	726	726	CD
18637	25030	97	State	State	NNP
18637	25030	98	,	,	,
18637	25030	99	defined	define	VBN
18637	25030	100	,	,	,
18637	25030	101	due	due	JJ
18637	25030	102	process	process	NN
18637	25030	103	clause	clause	NN
18637	25030	104	as	as	IN
18637	25030	105	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	25030	106	on	on	IN
18637	25030	107	,	,	,
18637	25030	108	974	974	CD
18637	25030	109	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	110	980	980	CD
18637	25030	111	,	,	,
18637	25030	112	982	982	CD
18637	25030	113	-	-	HYPH
18637	25030	114	1036	1036	CD
18637	25030	115	,	,	,
18637	25030	116	1091	1091	CD
18637	25030	117	State	state	NN
18637	25030	118	,	,	,
18637	25030	119	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	25030	120	of	of	IN
18637	25030	121	contracts	contract	NNS
18637	25030	122	by	by	IN
18637	25030	123	,	,	,
18637	25030	124	357	357	CD
18637	25030	125	-	-	HYPH
18637	25030	126	361	361	CD
18637	25030	127	Political	Political	NNP
18637	25030	128	Questions	Questions	NNPS
18637	25030	129	,	,	,
18637	25030	130	concept	concept	NN
18637	25030	131	of	of	IN
18637	25030	132	,	,	,
18637	25030	133	examples	example	NNS
18637	25030	134	,	,	,
18637	25030	135	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	25030	136	by	by	IN
18637	25030	137	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25030	138	courts	court	NNS
18637	25030	139	,	,	,
18637	25030	140	etc	etc	FW
18637	25030	141	.	.	.
18637	25030	142	,	,	,
18637	25030	143	93	93	CD
18637	25030	144	,	,	,
18637	25030	145	282	282	CD
18637	25030	146	,	,	,
18637	25030	147	309	309	CD
18637	25030	148	,	,	,
18637	25030	149	420	420	CD
18637	25030	150	,	,	,
18637	25030	151	425	425	CD
18637	25030	152	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	153	426	426	CD
18637	25030	154	,	,	,
18637	25030	155	471	471	CD
18637	25030	156	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	157	475	475	CD
18637	25030	158	,	,	,
18637	25030	159	546	546	CD
18637	25030	160	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	161	549	549	CD
18637	25030	162	,	,	,
18637	25030	163	562	562	CD
18637	25030	164	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	165	566	566	CD
18637	25030	166	,	,	,
18637	25030	167	571	571	CD
18637	25030	168	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	169	572	572	CD
18637	25030	170	,	,	,
18637	25030	171	610	610	CD
18637	25030	172	,	,	,
18637	25030	173	704	704	CD
18637	25030	174	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	175	705	705	CD
18637	25030	176	,	,	,
18637	25030	177	712	712	CD
18637	25030	178	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	179	715	715	CD
18637	25030	180	,	,	,
18637	25030	181	1064	1064	CD
18637	25030	182	,	,	,
18637	25030	183	1172	1172	CD
18637	25030	184	Poll	Poll	NNP
18637	25030	185	Taxes	Taxes	NNP
18637	25030	186	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25030	187	_	_	NNP
18637	25030	188	see	see	NN
18637	25030	189	also	also	RB
18637	25030	190	_	_	NNP
18637	25030	191	Elections	Elections	NNP
18637	25030	192	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25030	193	:	:	:
18637	25030	194	as	as	IN
18637	25030	195	Direct	direct	JJ
18637	25030	196	tax	tax	NN
18637	25030	197	,	,	,
18637	25030	198	105	105	CD
18637	25030	199	,	,	,
18637	25030	200	317	317	CD
18637	25030	201	,	,	,
18637	25030	202	319	319	CD
18637	25030	203	,	,	,
18637	25030	204	321	321	CD
18637	25030	205	Exemptions	exemption	NNS
18637	25030	206	,	,	,
18637	25030	207	validity	validity	NN
18637	25030	208	of	of	IN
18637	25030	209	,	,	,
18637	25030	210	1152	1152	CD
18637	25030	211	as	as	IN
18637	25030	212	Qualification	Qualification	NNP
18637	25030	213	for	for	IN
18637	25030	214	voting	voting	NN
18637	25030	215	,	,	,
18637	25030	216	970	970	CD
18637	25030	217	,	,	,
18637	25030	218	1152	1152	CD
18637	25030	219	Polygamy	Polygamy	NNP
18637	25030	220	:	:	:
18637	25030	221	Religious	religious	JJ
18637	25030	222	precepts	precept	NNS
18637	25030	223	,	,	,
18637	25030	224	practice	practice	NN
18637	25030	225	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	25030	226	to	to	IN
18637	25030	227	,	,	,
18637	25030	228	759	759	CD
18637	25030	229	,	,	,
18637	25030	230	765	765	CD
18637	25030	231	-	-	SYM
18637	25030	232	766	766	CD
18637	25030	233	Seat	Seat	NNP
18637	25030	234	in	in	IN
18637	25030	235	House	House	NNP
18637	25030	236	of	of	IN
18637	25030	237	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	25030	238	refused	refuse	VBD
18637	25030	239	practitioner	practitioner	NN
18637	25030	240	of	of	IN
18637	25030	241	,	,	,
18637	25030	242	89	89	CD
18637	25030	243	Posse	Posse	NNP
18637	25030	244	Comitatus	Comitatus	NNP
18637	25030	245	,	,	,
18637	25030	246	use	use	NN
18637	25030	247	by	by	IN
18637	25030	248	President	President	NNP
18637	25030	249	,	,	,
18637	25030	250	etc	etc	FW
18637	25030	251	.	.	FW
18637	25030	252	,	,	,
18637	25030	253	in	in	IN
18637	25030	254	law	law	NN
18637	25030	255	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	25030	256	,	,	,
18637	25030	257	483	483	CD
18637	25030	258	Post	Post	NNP
18637	25030	259	Roads	Roads	NNPS
18637	25030	260	.	.	.
18637	25031	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25031	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25031	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25031	4	Roads	Roads	NNPS
18637	25031	5	.	.	.
18637	25032	1	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	25032	2	Power	Power	NNP
18637	25032	3	.	.	.
18637	25033	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25033	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25033	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25033	4	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	25033	5	Service	Service	NNP
18637	25033	6	;	;	:
18637	25033	7	Roads	road	NNS
18637	25033	8	.	.	.
18637	25034	1	Postal	Postal	NNP
18637	25034	2	Service	Service	NNP
18637	25034	3	:	:	:
18637	25034	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25034	5	,	,	,
18637	25034	6	power	power	NN
18637	25034	7	to	to	TO
18637	25034	8	create	create	VB
18637	25034	9	,	,	,
18637	25034	10	protect	protect	VB
18637	25034	11	,	,	,
18637	25034	12	267	267	CD
18637	25034	13	-	-	SYM
18637	25034	14	268	268	CD
18637	25034	15	Exclusion	exclusion	NN
18637	25034	16	from	from	IN
18637	25034	17	mails	mail	NNS
18637	25034	18	,	,	,
18637	25034	19	censorship	censorship	NN
18637	25034	20	,	,	,
18637	25034	21	268	268	CD
18637	25034	22	-	-	SYM
18637	25034	23	270	270	CD
18637	25034	24	,	,	,
18637	25034	25	804	804	CD
18637	25034	26	-	-	SYM
18637	25034	27	805	805	CD
18637	25034	28	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25034	29	police	police	NN
18637	25034	30	power	power	NN
18637	25034	31	,	,	,
18637	25034	32	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	25034	33	as	as	IN
18637	25034	34	to	to	IN
18637	25034	35	,	,	,
18637	25034	36	859	859	CD
18637	25034	37	State	state	NN
18637	25034	38	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	25034	39	affecting	affect	VBG
18637	25034	40	,	,	,
18637	25034	41	270	270	CD
18637	25034	42	Preamble	preamble	JJ
18637	25034	43	.	.	.
18637	25035	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25035	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25035	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25035	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	25035	5	of	of	IN
18637	25035	6	the	the	DT
18637	25035	7	United	United	NNP
18637	25035	8	States	States	NNP
18637	25035	9	.	.	.
18637	25036	1	Presentment	presentment	NN
18637	25036	2	.	.	.
18637	25037	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25037	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25037	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25037	4	Due	Due	NNP
18637	25037	5	Process	Process	NNP
18637	25037	6	of	of	IN
18637	25037	7	Law	Law	NNP
18637	25037	8	.	.	.
18637	25038	1	President	President	NNP
18637	25038	2	:	:	:
18637	25038	3	Cabinet	Cabinet	NNP
18637	25038	4	as	as	IN
18637	25038	5	adviser	adviser	NN
18637	25038	6	of	of	IN
18637	25038	7	,	,	,
18637	25038	8	origin	origin	NN
18637	25038	9	,	,	,
18637	25038	10	meetings	meeting	NNS
18637	25038	11	,	,	,
18637	25038	12	405	405	CD
18637	25038	13	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	14	406	406	CD
18637	25038	15	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	25038	16	of	of	IN
18637	25038	17	,	,	,
18637	25038	18	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	25038	19	on	on	IN
18637	25038	20	alteration	alteration	NN
18637	25038	21	,	,	,
18637	25038	22	dual	dual	JJ
18637	25038	23	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	25038	24	,	,	,
18637	25038	25	etc	etc	FW
18637	25038	26	.	.	FW
18637	25038	27	,	,	,
18637	25038	28	384	384	CD
18637	25038	29	,	,	,
18637	25038	30	388	388	CD
18637	25038	31	Election	election	NN
18637	25038	32	:	:	:
18637	25038	33	Candidate	candidate	NN
18637	25038	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	25038	35	elect	elect	NNP
18637	25038	36	,	,	,
18637	25038	37	death	death	NN
18637	25038	38	of	of	IN
18637	25038	39	,	,	,
18637	25038	40	powers	power	NNS
18637	25038	41	of	of	IN
18637	25038	42	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25038	43	as	as	IN
18637	25038	44	to	to	IN
18637	25038	45	,	,	,
18637	25038	46	1225	1225	CD
18637	25038	47	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	48	1226	1226	CD
18637	25038	49	by	by	IN
18637	25038	50	Electors	elector	NNS
18637	25038	51	,	,	,
18637	25038	52	number	number	NN
18637	25038	53	,	,	,
18637	25038	54	duties	duty	NNS
18637	25038	55	of	of	IN
18637	25038	56	,	,	,
18637	25038	57	etc	etc	FW
18637	25038	58	.	.	FW
18637	25038	59	,	,	,
18637	25038	60	dispute	dispute	VBP
18637	25038	61	over	over	IN
18637	25038	62	selection	selection	NN
18637	25038	63	,	,	,
18637	25038	64	political	political	JJ
18637	25038	65	loyalty	loyalty	NN
18637	25038	66	,	,	,
18637	25038	67	disposition	disposition	NN
18637	25038	68	,	,	,
18637	25038	69	383	383	CD
18637	25038	70	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	71	386	386	CD
18637	25038	72	,	,	,
18637	25038	73	941	941	CD
18637	25038	74	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	75	944	944	CD
18637	25038	76	by	by	IN
18637	25038	77	House	House	NNP
18637	25038	78	of	of	IN
18637	25038	79	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	25038	80	,	,	,
18637	25038	81	when	when	WRB
18637	25038	82	,	,	,
18637	25038	83	how	how	WRB
18637	25038	84	,	,	,
18637	25038	85	383	383	CD
18637	25038	86	,	,	,
18637	25038	87	941	941	CD
18637	25038	88	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	89	944	944	CD
18637	25038	90	,	,	,
18637	25038	91	1225	1225	CD
18637	25038	92	Immunity	immunity	NN
18637	25038	93	from	from	IN
18637	25038	94	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	25038	95	direction	direction	NN
18637	25038	96	,	,	,
18637	25038	97	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	25038	98	,	,	,
18637	25038	99	etc	etc	FW
18637	25038	100	.	.	.
18637	25038	101	,	,	,
18637	25038	102	499	499	CD
18637	25038	103	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	104	501	501	CD
18637	25038	105	,	,	,
18637	25038	106	546	546	CD
18637	25038	107	Impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	25038	108	of	of	IN
18637	25038	109	,	,	,
18637	25038	110	501	501	CD
18637	25038	111	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	112	503	503	CD
18637	25038	113	Message	message	NN
18637	25038	114	to	to	IN
18637	25038	115	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25038	116	,	,	,
18637	25038	117	381	381	CD
18637	25038	118	Oath	Oath	NNP
18637	25038	119	of	of	IN
18637	25038	120	office	office	NN
18637	25038	121	,	,	,
18637	25038	122	effect	effect	NN
18637	25038	123	,	,	,
18637	25038	124	time	time	NN
18637	25038	125	for	for	IN
18637	25038	126	,	,	,
18637	25038	127	384	384	CD
18637	25038	128	,	,	,
18637	25038	129	388	388	CD
18637	25038	130	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	131	389	389	CD
18637	25038	132	Powers	power	NNS
18637	25038	133	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25038	134	_	_	NNP
18637	25038	135	see	see	VBP
18637	25038	136	also	also	RB
18637	25038	137	_	_	NNP
18637	25038	138	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	25038	139	Agencies	Agencies	NNPS
18637	25038	140	;	;	:
18637	25038	141	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	25038	142	of	of	IN
18637	25038	143	the	the	DT
18637	25038	144	United	United	NNP
18637	25038	145	States	States	NNP
18637	25038	146	;	;	:
18637	25038	147	Delegation	Delegation	NNP
18637	25038	148	of	of	IN
18637	25038	149	Power	Power	NNP
18637	25038	150	;	;	,
18637	25038	151	Eminent	Eminent	NNP
18637	25038	152	Domain	Domain	NNP
18637	25038	153	;	;	:
18637	25038	154	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	25038	155	Agreements	Agreements	NNPS
18637	25038	156	;	;	:
18637	25038	157	Extradition	Extradition	NNP
18637	25038	158	;	;	:
18637	25038	159	Pardons	pardon	NNS
18637	25038	160	;	;	:
18637	25038	161	Posse	Posse	NNP
18637	25038	162	Comitatus	Comitatus	NNP
18637	25038	163	;	;	:
18637	25038	164	Public	public	JJ
18637	25038	165	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	25038	166	of	of	IN
18637	25038	167	the	the	DT
18637	25038	168	United	United	NNP
18637	25038	169	States	States	NNP
18637	25038	170	;	;	:
18637	25038	171	War	War	NNP
18637	25038	172	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25038	173	:	:	:
18637	25038	174	to	to	TO
18637	25038	175	Appoint	Appoint	NNP
18637	25038	176	officers	officer	NNS
18637	25038	177	,	,	,
18637	25038	178	404	404	CD
18637	25038	179	,	,	,
18637	25038	180	412	412	CD
18637	25038	181	,	,	,
18637	25038	182	445	445	CD
18637	25038	183	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	184	450	450	CD
18637	25038	185	,	,	,
18637	25038	186	452	452	CD
18637	25038	187	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	188	455	455	CD
18637	25038	189	as	as	IN
18637	25038	190	Commander	Commander	NNP
18637	25038	191	in	in	IN
18637	25038	192	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	25038	193	;	;	:
18637	25038	194	a	a	DT
18637	25038	195	civilian	civilian	JJ
18637	25038	196	officer	officer	NN
18637	25038	197	,	,	,
18637	25038	198	380	380	CD
18637	25038	199	,	,	,
18637	25038	200	389	389	CD
18637	25038	201	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	202	405	405	CD
18637	25038	203	,	,	,
18637	25038	204	434	434	CD
18637	25038	205	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	206	435	435	CD
18637	25038	207	,	,	,
18637	25038	208	470	470	CD
18637	25038	209	,	,	,
18637	25038	210	476	476	CD
18637	25038	211	,	,	,
18637	25038	212	486	486	CD
18637	25038	213	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	214	499	499	CD
18637	25038	215	to	to	TO
18637	25038	216	Conduct	conduct	VB
18637	25038	217	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	25038	218	relations	relation	NNS
18637	25038	219	,	,	,
18637	25038	220	412	412	CD
18637	25038	221	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	222	413	413	CD
18637	25038	223	,	,	,
18637	25038	224	423	423	CD
18637	25038	225	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	226	426	426	CD
18637	25038	227	,	,	,
18637	25038	228	433	433	CD
18637	25038	229	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	230	437	437	CD
18637	25038	231	,	,	,
18637	25038	232	439	439	CD
18637	25038	233	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	234	443	443	CD
18637	25038	235	,	,	,
18637	25038	236	445	445	CD
18637	25038	237	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	238	449	449	CD
18637	25038	239	,	,	,
18637	25038	240	462	462	CD
18637	25038	241	-	-	CD
18637	25038	242	471	471	CD
18637	25038	243	,	,	,
18637	25038	244	473	473	CD
18637	25038	245	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	246	475	475	CD
18637	25038	247	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	25038	248	,	,	,
18637	25038	249	use	use	VB
18637	25038	250	by	by	RB
18637	25038	251	,	,	,
18637	25038	252	to	to	TO
18637	25038	253	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	25038	254	laws	law	NNS
18637	25038	255	,	,	,
18637	25038	256	484	484	CD
18637	25038	257	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	258	486	486	CD
18637	25038	259	Duty	duty	NN
18637	25038	260	to	to	TO
18637	25038	261	execute	execute	VB
18637	25038	262	the	the	DT
18637	25038	263	laws	law	NNS
18637	25038	264	;	;	:
18637	25038	265	powers	power	NNS
18637	25038	266	derived	derive	VBN
18637	25038	267	from	from	IN
18637	25038	268	,	,	,
18637	25038	269	462	462	CD
18637	25038	270	,	,	,
18637	25038	271	470	470	CD
18637	25038	272	-	-	CD
18637	25038	273	471	471	CD
18637	25038	274	,	,	,
18637	25038	275	475	475	CD
18637	25038	276	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	277	499	499	CD
18637	25038	278	Exercise	exercise	NN
18637	25038	279	of	of	IN
18637	25038	280	,	,	,
18637	25038	281	when	when	WRB
18637	25038	282	in	in	IN
18637	25038	283	person	person	NN
18637	25038	284	or	or	CC
18637	25038	285	by	by	IN
18637	25038	286	agents	agent	NNS
18637	25038	287	,	,	,
18637	25038	288	476	476	CD
18637	25038	289	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	290	477	477	CD
18637	25038	291	to	to	TO
18637	25038	292	Inform	Inform	NNP
18637	25038	293	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25038	294	,	,	,
18637	25038	295	convene	convene	VB
18637	25038	296	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25038	297	in	in	IN
18637	25038	298	special	special	JJ
18637	25038	299	sessions	session	NNS
18637	25038	300	,	,	,
18637	25038	301	462	462	CD
18637	25038	302	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	303	463	463	CD
18637	25038	304	as	as	IN
18637	25038	305	to	to	IN
18637	25038	306	Lawmaking	Lawmaking	NNP
18637	25038	307	,	,	,
18637	25038	308	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	25038	309	process	process	NN
18637	25038	310	,	,	,
18637	25038	311	approval	approval	NN
18637	25038	312	,	,	,
18637	25038	313	veto	veto	NN
18637	25038	314	of	of	IN
18637	25038	315	bills	bill	NNS
18637	25038	316	,	,	,
18637	25038	317	etc	etc	FW
18637	25038	318	.	.	.
18637	25038	319	,	,	,
18637	25038	320	101	101	CD
18637	25038	321	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	322	105	105	CD
18637	25038	323	Military	military	JJ
18637	25038	324	forces	force	NNS
18637	25038	325	,	,	,
18637	25038	326	use	use	NN
18637	25038	327	by	by	RB
18637	25038	328	,	,	,
18637	25038	329	to	to	TO
18637	25038	330	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	25038	331	laws	law	NNS
18637	25038	332	,	,	,
18637	25038	333	482	482	CD
18637	25038	334	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	335	485	485	CD
18637	25038	336	to	to	TO
18637	25038	337	Negotiate	negotiate	VB
18637	25038	338	executive	executive	JJ
18637	25038	339	agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	25038	340	,	,	,
18637	25038	341	scope	scope	NN
18637	25038	342	,	,	,
18637	25038	343	433	433	CD
18637	25038	344	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	345	445	445	CD
18637	25038	346	to	to	TO
18637	25038	347	Negotiate	Negotiate	NNP
18637	25038	348	,	,	,
18637	25038	349	terminate	terminate	NN
18637	25038	350	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	25038	351	,	,	,
18637	25038	352	412	412	CD
18637	25038	353	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	354	413	413	CD
18637	25038	355	,	,	,
18637	25038	356	419	419	CD
18637	25038	357	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	358	420	420	CD
18637	25038	359	,	,	,
18637	25038	360	423	423	CD
18637	25038	361	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	362	426	426	CD
18637	25038	363	of	of	IN
18637	25038	364	Pardon	Pardon	NNP
18637	25038	365	,	,	,
18637	25038	366	amnesty	amnesty	NN
18637	25038	367	,	,	,
18637	25038	368	commutation	commutation	NN
18637	25038	369	,	,	,
18637	25038	370	scope	scope	NN
18637	25038	371	,	,	,
18637	25038	372	406	406	CD
18637	25038	373	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	374	411	411	CD
18637	25038	375	to	to	TO
18637	25038	376	Protect	protect	VB
18637	25038	377	citizens	citizen	NNS
18637	25038	378	and	and	CC
18637	25038	379	property	property	NN
18637	25038	380	abroad	abroad	RB
18637	25038	381	,	,	,
18637	25038	382	487	487	CD
18637	25038	383	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	384	488	488	CD
18637	25038	385	to	to	TO
18637	25038	386	Receive	receive	VB
18637	25038	387	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
18637	25038	388	,	,	,
18637	25038	389	etc	etc	FW
18637	25038	390	.	.	.
18637	25038	391	,	,	,
18637	25038	392	462	462	CD
18637	25038	393	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	394	469	469	CD
18637	25038	395	of	of	IN
18637	25038	396	Recognition	Recognition	NNP
18637	25038	397	,	,	,
18637	25038	398	465	465	CD
18637	25038	399	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	400	470	470	CD
18637	25038	401	,	,	,
18637	25038	402	472	472	CD
18637	25038	403	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	404	473	473	CD
18637	25038	405	to	to	TO
18637	25038	406	Remove	remove	VB
18637	25038	407	officers	officer	NNS
18637	25038	408	,	,	,
18637	25038	409	378	378	CD
18637	25038	410	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	411	380	380	CD
18637	25038	412	,	,	,
18637	25038	413	404	404	CD
18637	25038	414	,	,	,
18637	25038	415	453	453	CD
18637	25038	416	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	417	460	460	CD
18637	25038	418	,	,	,
18637	25038	419	478	478	CD
18637	25038	420	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	421	481	481	CD
18637	25038	422	to	to	TO
18637	25038	423	Seize	seize	VB
18637	25038	424	plants	plant	NNS
18637	25038	425	,	,	,
18637	25038	426	factories	factory	NNS
18637	25038	427	,	,	,
18637	25038	428	etc	etc	FW
18637	25038	429	.	.	FW
18637	25038	430	,	,	,
18637	25038	431	395	395	CD
18637	25038	432	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	433	397	397	CD
18637	25038	434	,	,	,
18637	25038	435	489	489	CD
18637	25038	436	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	437	499	499	CD
18637	25038	438	Source	Source	NNP
18637	25038	439	of	of	IN
18637	25038	440	,	,	,
18637	25038	441	nature	nature	NN
18637	25038	442	,	,	,
18637	25038	443	scope	scope	NN
18637	25038	444	,	,	,
18637	25038	445	377	377	CD
18637	25038	446	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	447	381	381	CD
18637	25038	448	as	as	IN
18637	25038	449	to	to	IN
18637	25038	450	Subordinates	Subordinates	NNP
18637	25038	451	,	,	,
18637	25038	452	control	control	NN
18637	25038	453	,	,	,
18637	25038	454	protection	protection	NN
18637	25038	455	of	of	IN
18637	25038	456	,	,	,
18637	25038	457	460	460	CD
18637	25038	458	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	459	462	462	CD
18637	25038	460	,	,	,
18637	25038	461	478	478	CD
18637	25038	462	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	463	481	481	CD
18637	25038	464	to	to	TO
18637	25038	465	Suspend	suspend	VB
18637	25038	466	writ	writ	NNP
18637	25038	467	of	of	IN
18637	25038	468	habeas	habeas	NNP
18637	25038	469	corpus	corpus	NNP
18637	25038	470	,	,	,
18637	25038	471	when	when	WRB
18637	25038	472	valid	valid	JJ
18637	25038	473	,	,	,
18637	25038	474	315	315	CD
18637	25038	475	to	to	TO
18637	25038	476	Take	take	VB
18637	25038	477	measures	measure	NNS
18637	25038	478	short	short	JJ
18637	25038	479	of	of	IN
18637	25038	480	war	war	NN
18637	25038	481	,	,	,
18637	25038	482	487	487	CD
18637	25038	483	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	484	489	489	CD
18637	25038	485	as	as	IN
18637	25038	486	to	to	IN
18637	25038	487	War	War	NNP
18637	25038	488	,	,	,
18637	25038	489	281	281	CD
18637	25038	490	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	491	283	283	CD
18637	25038	492	,	,	,
18637	25038	493	290	290	CD
18637	25038	494	,	,	,
18637	25038	495	297	297	CD
18637	25038	496	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	497	298	298	CD
18637	25038	498	,	,	,
18637	25038	499	380	380	CD
18637	25038	500	,	,	,
18637	25038	501	390	390	CD
18637	25038	502	-	-	HYPH
18637	25038	503	404	404	CD
18637	25038	504	,	,	,
18637	25038	505	419	419	CD
18637	25038	506	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	507	420	420	CD
18637	25038	508	,	,	,
18637	25038	509	434	434	CD
18637	25038	510	,	,	,
18637	25038	511	470	470	CD
18637	25038	512	-	-	CD
18637	25038	513	471	471	CD
18637	25038	514	,	,	,
18637	25038	515	474	474	CD
18637	25038	516	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	517	475	475	CD
18637	25038	518	,	,	,
18637	25038	519	487	487	CD
18637	25038	520	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	521	489	489	CD
18637	25038	522	to	to	IN
18637	25038	523	Withhold	Withhold	NNP
18637	25038	524	confidential	confidential	JJ
18637	25038	525	communications	communication	NNS
18637	25038	526	from	from	IN
18637	25038	527	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25038	528	,	,	,
18637	25038	529	courts	court	NNS
18637	25038	530	,	,	,
18637	25038	531	460	460	CD
18637	25038	532	-	-	CD
18637	25038	533	462	462	CD
18637	25038	534	Qualifications	Qualifications	NNPS
18637	25038	535	,	,	,
18637	25038	536	384	384	CD
18637	25038	537	,	,	,
18637	25038	538	386	386	CD
18637	25038	539	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	540	387	387	CD
18637	25038	541	Refusal	Refusal	NNP
18637	25038	542	to	to	TO
18637	25038	543	accept	accept	VB
18637	25038	544	office	office	NN
18637	25038	545	;	;	:
18637	25038	546	resignation	resignation	NN
18637	25038	547	,	,	,
18637	25038	548	how	how	WRB
18637	25038	549	effected	effect	VBN
18637	25038	550	,	,	,
18637	25038	551	388	388	CD
18637	25038	552	Succession	Succession	NNP
18637	25038	553	to	to	IN
18637	25038	554	;	;	:
18637	25038	555	vacancy	vacancy	NN
18637	25038	556	existing	exist	VBG
18637	25038	557	at	at	IN
18637	25038	558	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	25038	559	of	of	IN
18637	25038	560	term	term	NN
18637	25038	561	,	,	,
18637	25038	562	etc	etc	FW
18637	25038	563	.	.	FW
18637	25038	564	,	,	,
18637	25038	565	384	384	CD
18637	25038	566	,	,	,
18637	25038	567	387	387	CD
18637	25038	568	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	569	388	388	CD
18637	25038	570	,	,	,
18637	25038	571	1225	1225	CD
18637	25038	572	Term	Term	NNP
18637	25038	573	,	,	,
18637	25038	574	maximum	maximum	JJ
18637	25038	575	duration	duration	NN
18637	25038	576	,	,	,
18637	25038	577	expiration	expiration	NN
18637	25038	578	,	,	,
18637	25038	579	377	377	CD
18637	25038	580	,	,	,
18637	25038	581	382	382	CD
18637	25038	582	,	,	,
18637	25038	583	1225	1225	CD
18637	25038	584	,	,	,
18637	25038	585	1237	1237	CD
18637	25038	586	Price	price	NN
18637	25038	587	control	control	NN
18637	25038	588	in	in	IN
18637	25038	589	wartime	wartime	NN
18637	25038	590	,	,	,
18637	25038	591	etc	etc	FW
18637	25038	592	.	.	.
18637	25038	593	,	,	,
18637	25038	594	392	392	CD
18637	25038	595	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	596	393	393	CD
18637	25038	597	,	,	,
18637	25038	598	1234	1234	CD
18637	25038	599	Price	price	NN
18637	25038	600	-	-	HYPH
18637	25038	601	fixing	fixing	NN
18637	25038	602	,	,	,
18637	25038	603	validity	validity	NN
18637	25038	604	,	,	,
18637	25038	605	159	159	CD
18637	25038	606	-	-	SYM
18637	25038	607	160	160	CD
18637	25038	608	,	,	,
18637	25038	609	296	296	CD
18637	25038	610	Prices	price	NNS
18637	25038	611	,	,	,
18637	25038	612	Charges	Charges	NNPS
18637	25038	613	,	,	,
18637	25038	614	Rates	Rates	NNP
18637	25038	615	,	,	,
18637	25038	616	etc	etc	FW
18637	25038	617	.	.	.
18637	25039	1	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25039	2	_	_	NNP
18637	25039	3	see	see	VBP
18637	25039	4	also	also	RB
18637	25039	5	_	_	NNP
18637	25039	6	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	25039	7	;	;	,
18637	25039	8	Milk	milk	NN
18637	25039	9	;	;	:
18637	25039	10	Public	Public	NNP
18637	25039	11	Utilities	Utilities	NNPS
18637	25039	12	;	;	:
18637	25039	13	Stockyards	stockyard	NNS
18637	25039	14	;	;	,
18637	25039	15	Warehouses	Warehouses	NNP
18637	25039	16	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25039	17	:	:	:
18637	25039	18	State	state	NN
18637	25039	19	laws	law	NNS
18637	25039	20	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	25039	21	,	,	,
18637	25039	22	994	994	CD
18637	25039	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	25039	24	1008	1008	CD
18637	25039	25	Primary	Primary	NNP
18637	25039	26	Elections	Elections	NNPS
18637	25039	27	.	.	.
18637	25040	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25040	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25040	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25040	4	Elections	Elections	NNPS
18637	25040	5	.	.	.
18637	25041	1	Priorities	priority	NNS
18637	25041	2	.	.	.
18637	25042	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25042	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25042	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25042	4	Rationing	Rationing	NNP
18637	25042	5	.	.	.
18637	25043	1	Prisoners	prisoner	NNS
18637	25043	2	,	,	,
18637	25043	3	right	right	RB
18637	25043	4	to	to	IN
18637	25043	5	appeals	appeal	NNS
18637	25043	6	,	,	,
18637	25043	7	corrective	corrective	JJ
18637	25043	8	process	process	NN
18637	25043	9	,	,	,
18637	25043	10	1137	1137	CD
18637	25043	11	-	-	SYM
18637	25043	12	1139	1139	CD
18637	25043	13	Privileges	Privileges	NNPS
18637	25043	14	and	and	CC
18637	25043	15	Immunities	Immunities	NNPS
18637	25043	16	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	25043	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25043	18	Art	art	NN
18637	25043	19	.	.	.
18637	25044	1	IV	IV	NNP
18637	25044	2	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25044	3	.	.	.
18637	25045	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25045	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25045	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25045	4	Comity	Comity	NNP
18637	25045	5	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	25045	6	.	.	.
18637	25046	1	Privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	25046	2	and	and	CC
18637	25046	3	Immunities	Immunities	NNPS
18637	25046	4	of	of	IN
18637	25046	5	State	State	NNP
18637	25046	6	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	25046	7	.	.	.
18637	25047	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25047	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25047	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25047	4	Comity	Comity	NNP
18637	25047	5	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	25047	6	.	.	.
18637	25048	1	Privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	25048	2	and	and	CC
18637	25048	3	Immunities	Immunities	NNPS
18637	25048	4	of	of	IN
18637	25048	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25048	6	Citizens	Citizens	NNPS
18637	25048	7	:	:	:
18637	25048	8	Abridgment	abridgment	NN
18637	25048	9	by	by	IN
18637	25048	10	States	state	NNS
18637	25048	11	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
18637	25048	12	;	;	:
18637	25048	13	scope	scope	NN
18637	25048	14	of	of	IN
18637	25048	15	protection	protection	NN
18637	25048	16	,	,	,
18637	25048	17	963	963	CD
18637	25048	18	,	,	,
18637	25048	19	965	965	CD
18637	25048	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	25048	21	971	971	CD
18637	25048	22	Enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	25048	23	of	of	IN
18637	25048	24	guaranty	guaranty	NN
18637	25048	25	by	by	IN
18637	25048	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25048	27	,	,	,
18637	25048	28	limits	limit	NNS
18637	25048	29	,	,	,
18637	25048	30	1175	1175	CD
18637	25048	31	-	-	SYM
18637	25048	32	1177	1177	CD
18637	25048	33	Enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	25048	34	,	,	,
18637	25048	35	242	242	CD
18637	25048	36	,	,	,
18637	25048	37	751	751	CD
18637	25048	38	,	,	,
18637	25048	39	808	808	CD
18637	25048	40	-	-	SYM
18637	25048	41	809	809	CD
18637	25048	42	,	,	,
18637	25048	43	967	967	CD
18637	25048	44	-	-	HYPH
18637	25048	45	971	971	CD
18637	25048	46	Prizes	Prizes	NNPS
18637	25048	47	of	of	IN
18637	25048	48	War	War	NNP
18637	25048	49	,	,	,
18637	25048	50	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	25048	51	of	of	IN
18637	25048	52	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25048	53	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	25048	54	as	as	IN
18637	25048	55	to	to	IN
18637	25048	56	,	,	,
18637	25048	57	295	295	CD
18637	25048	58	,	,	,
18637	25048	59	575	575	CD
18637	25048	60	Production	Production	NNP
18637	25048	61	,	,	,
18637	25048	62	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25048	63	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25048	64	of	of	IN
18637	25048	65	,	,	,
18637	25048	66	under	under	IN
18637	25048	67	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	25048	68	clause	clause	NN
18637	25048	69	,	,	,
18637	25048	70	152	152	CD
18637	25048	71	-	-	SYM
18637	25048	72	160	160	CD
18637	25048	73	Professions	Professions	NNPS
18637	25048	74	.	.	.
18637	25049	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25049	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25049	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25049	4	Business	Business	NNP
18637	25049	5	,	,	,
18637	25049	6	Trades	Trades	NNPS
18637	25049	7	,	,	,
18637	25049	8	Professions	Professions	NNPS
18637	25049	9	.	.	.
18637	25050	1	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	25050	2	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	25050	3	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25050	4	_	_	NNP
18637	25050	5	see	see	VBP
18637	25050	6	also	also	RB
18637	25050	7	_	_	NNP
18637	25050	8	Crimes	Crimes	NNPS
18637	25050	9	and	and	CC
18637	25050	10	Offenses	offense	NNS
18637	25050	11	;	;	:
18637	25050	12	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	25050	13	:	:	:
18637	25050	14	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25050	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25050	16	,	,	,
18637	25050	17	1213	1213	CD
18637	25050	18	-	-	SYM
18637	25050	19	1214	1214	CD
18637	25050	20	Prohibition	Prohibition	NNP
18637	25050	21	Repeal	Repeal	NNP
18637	25050	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	25050	23	,	,	,
18637	25050	24	1213	1213	CD
18637	25050	25	,	,	,
18637	25050	26	1231	1231	CD
18637	25050	27	-	-	SYM
18637	25050	28	1234	1234	CD
18637	25050	29	Property	Property	NNP
18637	25050	30	.	.	.
18637	25051	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25051	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25051	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25051	4	Due	Due	NNP
18637	25051	5	Process	Process	NNP
18637	25051	6	of	of	IN
18637	25051	7	Law	Law	NNP
18637	25051	8	;	;	:
18637	25051	9	States	States	NNP
18637	25051	10	;	;	:
18637	25051	11	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	25051	12	;	;	:
18637	25051	13	United	United	NNP
18637	25051	14	States	States	NNP
18637	25051	15	.	.	.
18637	25052	1	Protective	Protective	NNP
18637	25052	2	Tariffs	Tariffs	NNPS
18637	25052	3	,	,	,
18637	25052	4	162	162	CD
18637	25052	5	Psychopathic	psychopathic	JJ
18637	25052	6	personality	personality	NN
18637	25052	7	,	,	,
18637	25052	8	commitment	commitment	NN
18637	25052	9	of	of	IN
18637	25052	10	,	,	,
18637	25052	11	validity	validity	NN
18637	25052	12	,	,	,
18637	25052	13	984	984	CD
18637	25052	14	Public	public	JJ
18637	25052	15	Debt	Debt	NNP
18637	25052	16	of	of	IN
18637	25052	17	the	the	DT
18637	25052	18	United	United	NNP
18637	25052	19	States	States	NNP
18637	25052	20	:	:	:
18637	25052	21	Contracted	contract	VBN
18637	25052	22	before	before	IN
18637	25052	23	adoption	adoption	NN
18637	25052	24	of	of	IN
18637	25052	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	25052	26	,	,	,
18637	25052	27	721	721	CD
18637	25052	28	Gold	gold	NN
18637	25052	29	clause	clause	NN
18637	25052	30	in	in	IN
18637	25052	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25052	32	bonds	bond	NNS
18637	25052	33	,	,	,
18637	25052	34	validity	validity	NN
18637	25052	35	of	of	IN
18637	25052	36	abrogation	abrogation	NN
18637	25052	37	,	,	,
18637	25052	38	1174	1174	CD
18637	25052	39	Validity	Validity	NNP
18637	25052	40	not	not	RB
18637	25052	41	to	to	TO
18637	25052	42	be	be	VB
18637	25052	43	questioned	question	VBN
18637	25052	44	,	,	,
18637	25052	45	1174	1174	CD
18637	25052	46	Public	Public	NNP
18637	25052	47	Funds	Funds	NNPS
18637	25052	48	of	of	IN
18637	25052	49	the	the	DT
18637	25052	50	United	United	NNP
18637	25052	51	States	States	NNP
18637	25052	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25052	53	_	_	NNP
18637	25052	54	see	see	VBP
18637	25052	55	also	also	RB
18637	25052	56	_	_	NNP
18637	25052	57	Appropriations	Appropriations	NNP
18637	25052	58	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25052	59	:	:	:
18637	25052	60	Accounting	accounting	NN
18637	25052	61	of	of	IN
18637	25052	62	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	25052	63	and	and	CC
18637	25052	64	expenditures	expenditure	NNS
18637	25052	65	required	require	VBN
18637	25052	66	,	,	,
18637	25052	67	323	323	CD
18637	25052	68	Public	Public	NNP
18637	25052	69	Lands	Lands	NNPS
18637	25052	70	.	.	.
18637	25053	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25053	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25053	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25053	4	United	United	NNP
18637	25053	5	States	States	NNP
18637	25053	6	.	.	.
18637	25054	1	Public	Public	NNP
18637	25054	2	Ministers	Ministers	NNPS
18637	25054	3	.	.	.
18637	25055	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25055	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25055	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25055	4	Ambassadors	Ambassadors	NNPS
18637	25055	5	.	.	.
18637	25056	1	Public	public	JJ
18637	25056	2	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	25056	3	of	of	IN
18637	25056	4	the	the	DT
18637	25056	5	States	States	NNP
18637	25056	6	.	.	.
18637	25057	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25057	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25057	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25057	4	States	States	NNPS
18637	25057	5	:	:	:
18637	25057	6	Officers	officer	NNS
18637	25057	7	.	.	.
18637	25058	1	Public	public	JJ
18637	25058	2	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	25058	3	of	of	IN
18637	25058	4	the	the	DT
18637	25058	5	United	United	NNP
18637	25058	6	States	States	NNP
18637	25058	7	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25058	8	_	_	NNP
18637	25058	9	see	see	VBP
18637	25058	10	also	also	RB
18637	25058	11	_	_	NNP
18637	25058	12	Ambassadors	Ambassadors	NNPS
18637	25058	13	;	;	:
18637	25058	14	President	President	NNP
18637	25058	15	:	:	:
18637	25058	16	Powers	power	NNS
18637	25058	17	;	;	:
18637	25058	18	Secret	Secret	NNP
18637	25058	19	Agents	Agents	NNPS
18637	25058	20	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25058	21	:	:	:
18637	25058	22	_	_	NNP
18637	25058	23	Ad	Ad	NNP
18637	25058	24	interim	interim	JJ
18637	25058	25	_	_	NNP
18637	25058	26	designations	designation	NNS
18637	25058	27	by	by	IN
18637	25058	28	President	President	NNP
18637	25058	29	,	,	,
18637	25058	30	455	455	CD
18637	25058	31	Appointment	Appointment	NNP
18637	25058	32	by	by	IN
18637	25058	33	President	President	NNP
18637	25058	34	,	,	,
18637	25058	35	with	with	IN
18637	25058	36	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	25058	37	approval	approval	NN
18637	25058	38	,	,	,
18637	25058	39	453	453	CD
18637	25058	40	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	41	454	454	CD
18637	25058	42	Categories	category	NNS
18637	25058	43	of	of	IN
18637	25058	44	,	,	,
18637	25058	45	"	"	``
18637	25058	46	inferior	inferior	JJ
18637	25058	47	"	"	''
18637	25058	48	,	,	,
18637	25058	49	"	"	``
18637	25058	50	employees	employee	NNS
18637	25058	51	"	"	''
18637	25058	52	,	,	,
18637	25058	53	etc	etc	FW
18637	25058	54	.	.	.
18637	25058	55	,	,	,
18637	25058	56	452	452	CD
18637	25058	57	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25058	58	,	,	,
18637	25058	59	assertion	assertion	NN
18637	25058	60	of	of	IN
18637	25058	61	appointing	appoint	VBG
18637	25058	62	power	power	NN
18637	25058	63	,	,	,
18637	25058	64	449	449	CD
18637	25058	65	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	66	450	450	CD
18637	25058	67	,	,	,
18637	25058	68	452	452	CD
18637	25058	69	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25058	70	,	,	,
18637	25058	71	power	power	NN
18637	25058	72	to	to	IN
18637	25058	73	condition	condition	NN
18637	25058	74	removal	removal	NN
18637	25058	75	of	of	IN
18637	25058	76	,	,	,
18637	25058	77	by	by	IN
18637	25058	78	President	President	NNP
18637	25058	79	,	,	,
18637	25058	80	459	459	CD
18637	25058	81	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	82	460	460	CD
18637	25058	83	Control	control	NN
18637	25058	84	of	of	IN
18637	25058	85	conduct	conduct	NN
18637	25058	86	of	of	IN
18637	25058	87	,	,	,
18637	25058	88	by	by	IN
18637	25058	89	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25058	90	,	,	,
18637	25058	91	449	449	CD
18637	25058	92	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	93	452	452	CD
18637	25058	94	Disqualification	Disqualification	NNP
18637	25058	95	for	for	IN
18637	25058	96	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	25058	97	,	,	,
18637	25058	98	treason	treason	NN
18637	25058	99	;	;	:
18637	25058	100	removal	removal	NN
18637	25058	101	of	of	IN
18637	25058	102	disability	disability	NN
18637	25058	103	by	by	IN
18637	25058	104	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25058	105	,	,	,
18637	25058	106	1173	1173	CD
18637	25058	107	Doctrines	Doctrines	NNPS
18637	25058	108	as	as	IN
18637	25058	109	to	to	IN
18637	25058	110	,	,	,
18637	25058	111	"	"	``
18637	25058	112	estate	estate	NN
18637	25058	113	in	in	IN
18637	25058	114	office	office	NN
18637	25058	115	"	"	''
18637	25058	116	,	,	,
18637	25058	117	"	"	``
18637	25058	118	nature	nature	NN
18637	25058	119	of	of	IN
18637	25058	120	office	office	NN
18637	25058	121	"	"	''
18637	25058	122	,	,	,
18637	25058	123	457	457	CD
18637	25058	124	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	125	458	458	CD
18637	25058	126	Impeachment	Impeachment	NNP
18637	25058	127	of	of	IN
18637	25058	128	,	,	,
18637	25058	129	455	455	CD
18637	25058	130	,	,	,
18637	25058	131	457	457	CD
18637	25058	132	,	,	,
18637	25058	133	501	501	CD
18637	25058	134	Indemnification	indemnification	NN
18637	25058	135	of	of	IN
18637	25058	136	,	,	,
18637	25058	137	by	by	IN
18637	25058	138	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25058	139	,	,	,
18637	25058	140	501	501	CD
18637	25058	141	Jury	jury	NN
18637	25058	142	service	service	NN
18637	25058	143	by	by	RB
18637	25058	144	,	,	,
18637	25058	145	in	in	IN
18637	25058	146	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25058	147	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	25058	148	trials	trial	NNS
18637	25058	149	,	,	,
18637	25058	150	879	879	CD
18637	25058	151	Liability	Liability	NNP
18637	25058	152	of	of	IN
18637	25058	153	,	,	,
18637	25058	154	for	for	IN
18637	25058	155	excess	excess	NN
18637	25058	156	of	of	IN
18637	25058	157	authority	authority	NN
18637	25058	158	,	,	,
18637	25058	159	500	500	CD
18637	25058	160	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	161	501	501	CD
18637	25058	162	Membership	membership	NN
18637	25058	163	in	in	IN
18637	25058	164	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25058	165	restricted	restrict	VBD
18637	25058	166	,	,	,
18637	25058	167	100	100	CD
18637	25058	168	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	169	101	101	CD
18637	25058	170	"	"	``
18637	25058	171	Office	Office	NNP
18637	25058	172	"	"	''
18637	25058	173	,	,	,
18637	25058	174	defined	define	VBN
18637	25058	175	,	,	,
18637	25058	176	445	445	CD
18637	25058	177	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	178	446	446	CD
18637	25058	179	,	,	,
18637	25058	180	449	449	CD
18637	25058	181	,	,	,
18637	25058	182	457	457	CD
18637	25058	183	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	184	458	458	CD
18637	25058	185	Political	political	JJ
18637	25058	186	activities	activity	NNS
18637	25058	187	of	of	IN
18637	25058	188	,	,	,
18637	25058	189	restricted	restricted	JJ
18637	25058	190	,	,	,
18637	25058	191	94	94	CD
18637	25058	192	,	,	,
18637	25058	193	793	793	CD
18637	25058	194	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	195	794	794	CD
18637	25058	196	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	25058	197	electors	elector	NNS
18637	25058	198	,	,	,
18637	25058	199	status	status	NN
18637	25058	200	as	as	IN
18637	25058	201	,	,	,
18637	25058	202	385	385	CD
18637	25058	203	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	204	386	386	CD
18637	25058	205	Recess	recess	NN
18637	25058	206	appointments	appointment	NNS
18637	25058	207	of	of	IN
18637	25058	208	,	,	,
18637	25058	209	455	455	CD
18637	25058	210	Removal	Removal	NNP
18637	25058	211	of	of	IN
18637	25058	212	,	,	,
18637	25058	213	by	by	IN
18637	25058	214	President	President	NNP
18637	25058	215	,	,	,
18637	25058	216	453	453	CD
18637	25058	217	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	218	460	460	CD
18637	25058	219	,	,	,
18637	25058	220	478	478	CD
18637	25058	221	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	222	481	481	CD
18637	25058	223	Speaker	Speaker	NNP
18637	25058	224	of	of	IN
18637	25058	225	the	the	DT
18637	25058	226	House	House	NNP
18637	25058	227	,	,	,
18637	25058	228	President	President	NNP
18637	25058	229	pro	pro	JJ
18637	25058	230	tem	tem	NN
18637	25058	231	of	of	IN
18637	25058	232	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	25058	233	,	,	,
18637	25058	234	as	as	IN
18637	25058	235	,	,	,
18637	25058	236	387	387	CD
18637	25058	237	State	state	NN
18637	25058	238	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	25058	239	of	of	IN
18637	25058	240	salaries	salary	NNS
18637	25058	241	of	of	IN
18637	25058	242	,	,	,
18637	25058	243	731	731	CD
18637	25058	244	Subordinates	Subordinates	NNPS
18637	25058	245	of	of	IN
18637	25058	246	President	President	NNP
18637	25058	247	,	,	,
18637	25058	248	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	25058	249	review	review	NN
18637	25058	250	,	,	,
18637	25058	251	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	25058	252	of	of	IN
18637	25058	253	,	,	,
18637	25058	254	500	500	CD
18637	25058	255	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	256	501	501	CD
18637	25058	257	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	25058	258	against	against	IN
18637	25058	259	,	,	,
18637	25058	260	removal	removal	NN
18637	25058	261	from	from	IN
18637	25058	262	State	State	NNP
18637	25058	263	to	to	IN
18637	25058	264	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25058	265	courts	court	NNS
18637	25058	266	,	,	,
18637	25058	267	568	568	CD
18637	25058	268	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	269	569	569	CD
18637	25058	270	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	25058	271	against	against	IN
18637	25058	272	,	,	,
18637	25058	273	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	25058	274	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	25058	275	issue	issue	NN
18637	25058	276	,	,	,
18637	25058	277	580	580	CD
18637	25058	278	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	279	590	590	CD
18637	25058	280	Trial	Trial	NNP
18637	25058	281	of	of	IN
18637	25058	282	,	,	,
18637	25058	283	for	for	IN
18637	25058	284	offense	offense	NN
18637	25058	285	against	against	IN
18637	25058	286	,	,	,
18637	25058	287	etc	etc	FW
18637	25058	288	.	.	FW
18637	25058	289	,	,	,
18637	25058	290	State	state	NN
18637	25058	291	laws	law	NNS
18637	25058	292	,	,	,
18637	25058	293	removal	removal	NN
18637	25058	294	to	to	IN
18637	25058	295	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25058	296	court	court	NN
18637	25058	297	,	,	,
18637	25058	298	501	501	CD
18637	25058	299	,	,	,
18637	25058	300	632	632	CD
18637	25058	301	-	-	HYPH
18637	25058	302	634	634	CD
18637	25058	303	,	,	,
18637	25058	304	724	724	CD
18637	25058	305	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	306	728	728	CD
18637	25058	307	Public	Public	NNP
18637	25058	308	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	25058	309	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25058	310	_	_	NNP
18637	25058	311	see	see	VBP
18637	25058	312	also	also	RB
18637	25058	313	_	_	NNP
18637	25058	314	Carriers	Carriers	NNPS
18637	25058	315	;	;	:
18637	25058	316	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	25058	317	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25058	318	:	:	:
18637	25058	319	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25058	320	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25058	321	of	of	IN
18637	25058	322	,	,	,
18637	25058	323	due	due	JJ
18637	25058	324	process	process	NN
18637	25058	325	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	25058	326	,	,	,
18637	25058	327	860	860	CD
18637	25058	328	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	329	862	862	CD
18637	25058	330	Holding	Holding	NNP
18637	25058	331	companies	company	NNS
18637	25058	332	,	,	,
18637	25058	333	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25058	334	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25058	335	of	of	IN
18637	25058	336	,	,	,
18637	25058	337	150	150	CD
18637	25058	338	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	339	151	151	CD
18637	25058	340	Rate	rate	NN
18637	25058	341	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25058	342	by	by	IN
18637	25058	343	States	States	NNP
18637	25058	344	,	,	,
18637	25058	345	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	25058	346	review	review	NN
18637	25058	347	of	of	IN
18637	25058	348	,	,	,
18637	25058	349	972	972	CD
18637	25058	350	,	,	,
18637	25058	351	998	998	CD
18637	25058	352	-	-	HYPH
18637	25058	353	1008	1008	CD
18637	25058	354	State	state	NN
18637	25058	355	,	,	,
18637	25058	356	etc	etc	FW
18637	25058	357	.	.	FW
18637	25058	358	,	,	,
18637	25058	359	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
18637	25058	360	powers	power	NNS
18637	25058	361	as	as	IN
18637	25058	362	to	to	IN
18637	25058	363	,	,	,
18637	25058	364	220	220	CD
18637	25058	365	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	366	234	234	CD
18637	25058	367	,	,	,
18637	25058	368	249	249	CD
18637	25058	369	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	370	251	251	CD
18637	25058	371	,	,	,
18637	25058	372	1008	1008	CD
18637	25058	373	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	374	1016	1016	CD
18637	25058	375	,	,	,
18637	25058	376	1156	1156	CD
18637	25058	377	State	state	NN
18637	25058	378	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	25058	379	of	of	IN
18637	25058	380	,	,	,
18637	25058	381	operated	operate	VBN
18637	25058	382	interstate	interstate	NN
18637	25058	383	,	,	,
18637	25058	384	209	209	CD
18637	25058	385	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	386	214	214	CD
18637	25058	387	Q	Q	NNP
18637	25058	388	Quarantine	Quarantine	NNP
18637	25058	389	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	25058	390	:	:	:
18637	25058	391	State	state	NN
18637	25058	392	,	,	,
18637	25058	393	power	power	NN
18637	25058	394	to	to	TO
18637	25058	395	adopt	adopt	VB
18637	25058	396	,	,	,
18637	25058	397	validity	validity	NN
18637	25058	398	,	,	,
18637	25058	399	217	217	CD
18637	25058	400	,	,	,
18637	25058	401	235	235	CD
18637	25058	402	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	403	237	237	CD
18637	25058	404	,	,	,
18637	25058	405	248	248	CD
18637	25058	406	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	407	249	249	CD
18637	25058	408	State	state	NN
18637	25058	409	,	,	,
18637	25058	410	relation	relation	NN
18637	25058	411	to	to	IN
18637	25058	412	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	25058	413	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	25058	414	,	,	,
18637	25058	415	217	217	CD
18637	25058	416	Quartering	Quartering	NNP
18637	25058	417	Soldiers	Soldiers	NNPS
18637	25058	418	in	in	IN
18637	25058	419	Private	Private	NNP
18637	25058	420	Homes	Homes	NNPS
18637	25058	421	,	,	,
18637	25058	422	817	817	CD
18637	25058	423	R	r	NN
18637	25058	424	Radio	radio	NN
18637	25058	425	:	:	:
18637	25058	426	Censorship	censorship	NN
18637	25058	427	of	of	IN
18637	25058	428	,	,	,
18637	25058	429	via	via	IN
18637	25058	430	broadcast	broadcast	NN
18637	25058	431	licenses	license	NNS
18637	25058	432	,	,	,
18637	25058	433	787	787	CD
18637	25058	434	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25058	435	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25058	436	,	,	,
18637	25058	437	seizure	seizure	NN
18637	25058	438	,	,	,
18637	25058	439	125	125	CD
18637	25058	440	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	441	126	126	CD
18637	25058	442	,	,	,
18637	25058	443	138	138	CD
18637	25058	444	-	-	SYM
18637	25058	445	139	139	CD
18637	25058	446	,	,	,
18637	25058	447	486	486	CD
18637	25058	448	,	,	,
18637	25058	449	495	495	CD
18637	25058	450	Railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	25058	451	.	.	.
18637	25059	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25059	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25059	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25059	4	Carriers	Carriers	NNPS
18637	25059	5	.	.	.
18637	25060	1	Raisins	raisin	NNS
18637	25060	2	,	,	,
18637	25060	3	marketing	marketing	NN
18637	25060	4	of	of	IN
18637	25060	5	,	,	,
18637	25060	6	State	state	NN
18637	25060	7	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25060	8	,	,	,
18637	25060	9	249	249	CD
18637	25060	10	Rates	rate	NNS
18637	25060	11	.	.	.
18637	25061	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25061	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25061	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25061	4	Prices	Prices	NNPS
18637	25061	5	,	,	,
18637	25061	6	Charges	Charges	NNPS
18637	25061	7	,	,	,
18637	25061	8	Rates	Rates	NNPS
18637	25061	9	,	,	,
18637	25061	10	Etc	Etc	NNP
18637	25061	11	.	.	.
18637	25062	1	Rationing	ration	VBG
18637	25062	2	in	in	IN
18637	25062	3	wartime	wartime	NN
18637	25062	4	,	,	,
18637	25062	5	397	397	CD
18637	25062	6	-	-	SYM
18637	25062	7	398	398	CD
18637	25062	8	Real	real	JJ
18637	25062	9	Property	property	NN
18637	25062	10	.	.	.
18637	25063	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25063	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25063	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25063	4	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	25063	5	:	:	:
18637	25063	6	State	state	NN
18637	25063	7	.	.	.
18637	25064	1	Reciprocal	Reciprocal	NNP
18637	25064	2	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	25064	3	Agreements	Agreements	NNPS
18637	25064	4	,	,	,
18637	25064	5	441	441	CD
18637	25064	6	-	-	SYM
18637	25064	7	442	442	CD
18637	25064	8	Recognition	Recognition	NNP
18637	25064	9	of	of	IN
18637	25064	10	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	25064	11	governments	government	NNS
18637	25064	12	,	,	,
18637	25064	13	States	States	NNP
18637	25064	14	,	,	,
18637	25064	15	465	465	CD
18637	25064	16	,	,	,
18637	25064	17	467	467	CD
18637	25064	18	-	-	SYM
18637	25064	19	470	470	CD
18637	25064	20	,	,	,
18637	25064	21	472	472	CD
18637	25064	22	-	-	SYM
18637	25064	23	473	473	CD
18637	25064	24	Red	red	JJ
18637	25064	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	25064	26	light	light	NN
18637	25064	27	districts	district	NNS
18637	25064	28	,	,	,
18637	25064	29	creation	creation	NN
18637	25064	30	by	by	IN
18637	25064	31	municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	25064	32	,	,	,
18637	25064	33	1031	1031	CD
18637	25064	34	Rent	Rent	NNP
18637	25064	35	Control	Control	NNP
18637	25064	36	,	,	,
18637	25064	37	validity	validity	NN
18637	25064	38	,	,	,
18637	25064	39	296	296	CD
18637	25064	40	,	,	,
18637	25064	41	358	358	CD
18637	25064	42	-	-	SYM
18637	25064	43	359	359	CD
18637	25064	44	,	,	,
18637	25064	45	475	475	CD
18637	25064	46	,	,	,
18637	25064	47	855	855	CD
18637	25064	48	Republican	Republican	NNP
18637	25064	49	Form	Form	NNP
18637	25064	50	of	of	IN
18637	25064	51	Government	Government	NNP
18637	25064	52	,	,	,
18637	25064	53	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25064	54	guarantee	guarantee	NN
18637	25064	55	of	of	IN
18637	25064	56	to	to	IN
18637	25064	57	States	States	NNP
18637	25064	58	,	,	,
18637	25064	59	704	704	CD
18637	25064	60	Resale	Resale	NNP
18637	25064	61	Price	Price	NNP
18637	25064	62	Maintenance	Maintenance	NNP
18637	25064	63	.	.	.
18637	25065	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25065	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25065	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25065	4	Restraint	Restraint	NNP
18637	25065	5	of	of	IN
18637	25065	6	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	25065	7	.	.	.
18637	25066	1	Reserved	Reserved	NNP
18637	25066	2	Powers	power	NNS
18637	25066	3	.	.	.
18637	25067	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25067	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25067	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25067	4	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	25067	5	;	;	:
18637	25067	6	General	General	NNP
18637	25067	7	Welfare	Welfare	NNP
18637	25067	8	;	;	:
18637	25067	9	States	States	NNP
18637	25067	10	.	.	.
18637	25068	1	Restraint	Restraint	NNP
18637	25068	2	of	of	IN
18637	25068	3	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	25068	4	:	:	:
18637	25068	5	Interstate	Interstate	NNP
18637	25068	6	,	,	,
18637	25068	7	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25068	8	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	25068	9	of	of	IN
18637	25068	10	,	,	,
18637	25068	11	144	144	CD
18637	25068	12	-	-	SYM
18637	25068	13	149	149	CD
18637	25068	14	Monopoly	Monopoly	NNP
18637	25068	15	privileges	privilege	NNS
18637	25068	16	,	,	,
18637	25068	17	State	State	NNP
18637	25068	18	grant	grant	NN
18637	25068	19	of	of	IN
18637	25068	20	,	,	,
18637	25068	21	validity	validity	NN
18637	25068	22	,	,	,
18637	25068	23	1160	1160	CD
18637	25068	24	Resale	resale	NN
18637	25068	25	price	price	NN
18637	25068	26	maintenance	maintenance	NN
18637	25068	27	,	,	,
18637	25068	28	unfair	unfair	JJ
18637	25068	29	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	25068	30	,	,	,
18637	25068	31	etc	etc	FW
18637	25068	32	.	.	FW
18637	25068	33	,	,	,
18637	25068	34	State	state	NN
18637	25068	35	laws	law	NNS
18637	25068	36	on	on	IN
18637	25068	37	,	,	,
18637	25068	38	1017	1017	CD
18637	25068	39	State	state	NN
18637	25068	40	antitrust	antitrust	JJ
18637	25068	41	laws	law	NNS
18637	25068	42	,	,	,
18637	25068	43	1160	1160	CD
18637	25068	44	Retroactive	Retroactive	NNP
18637	25068	45	.	.	.
18637	25069	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25069	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25069	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25069	4	Contracts	Contracts	NNPS
18637	25069	5	;	;	:
18637	25069	6	Due	Due	NNP
18637	25069	7	Process	Process	NNP
18637	25069	8	of	of	IN
18637	25069	9	Law	Law	NNP
18637	25069	10	.	.	.
18637	25070	1	Revenue	revenue	NN
18637	25070	2	.	.	.
18637	25071	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25071	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25071	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25071	4	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	25071	5	:	:	:
18637	25071	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25071	7	;	;	:
18637	25071	8	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	25071	9	:	:	:
18637	25071	10	State	state	NN
18637	25071	11	.	.	.
18637	25072	1	Right	right	JJ
18637	25072	2	to	to	IN
18637	25072	3	Bear	Bear	NNP
18637	25072	4	Arms	arm	NNS
18637	25072	5	.	.	.
18637	25073	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25073	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25073	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25073	4	Bearing	Bearing	NNP
18637	25073	5	Arms	Arms	NNP
18637	25073	6	.	.	.
18637	25074	1	Rights	right	NNS
18637	25074	2	,	,	,
18637	25074	3	other	other	JJ
18637	25074	4	than	than	IN
18637	25074	5	enumerated	enumerate	VBN
18637	25074	6	in	in	IN
18637	25074	7	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
18637	25074	8	,	,	,
18637	25074	9	retention	retention	NN
18637	25074	10	by	by	IN
18637	25074	11	people	people	NNS
18637	25074	12	,	,	,
18637	25074	13	909	909	CD
18637	25074	14	Roads	road	NNS
18637	25074	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25074	16	_	_	NNP
18637	25074	17	see	see	VB
18637	25074	18	also	also	RB
18637	25074	19	_	_	NNP
18637	25074	20	Public	Public	NNP
18637	25074	21	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	25074	22	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25074	23	:	:	:
18637	25074	24	Post	post	VB
18637	25074	25	roads	road	NNS
18637	25074	26	,	,	,
18637	25074	27	power	power	NN
18637	25074	28	of	of	IN
18637	25074	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25074	30	to	to	TO
18637	25074	31	establish	establish	VB
18637	25074	32	,	,	,
18637	25074	33	132	132	CD
18637	25074	34	,	,	,
18637	25074	35	267	267	CD
18637	25074	36	-	-	SYM
18637	25074	37	268	268	CD
18637	25074	38	State	State	NNP
18637	25074	39	toll	toll	NN
18637	25074	40	tax	tax	NN
18637	25074	41	on	on	IN
18637	25074	42	,	,	,
18637	25074	43	mail	mail	NN
18637	25074	44	trucks	truck	NNS
18637	25074	45	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	25074	46	,	,	,
18637	25074	47	268	268	CD
18637	25074	48	Rule	rule	NN
18637	25074	49	-	-	HYPH
18637	25074	50	Making	Making	NNP
18637	25074	51	Power	Power	NNP
18637	25074	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25074	53	_	_	NNP
18637	25074	54	see	see	VB
18637	25074	55	also	also	RB
18637	25074	56	_	_	NNP
18637	25074	57	Administrative	Administrative	NNP
18637	25074	58	Regulations	Regulations	NNPS
18637	25074	59	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25074	60	,	,	,
18637	25074	61	76	76	CD
18637	25074	62	-	-	SYM
18637	25074	63	78	78	CD
18637	25074	64	S	S	NNP
18637	25074	65	Safety	Safety	NNP
18637	25074	66	.	.	.
18637	25075	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25075	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25075	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25075	4	Zoning	Zoning	NNP
18637	25075	5	.	.	.
18637	25076	1	Schools	school	NNS
18637	25076	2	and	and	CC
18637	25076	3	Colleges	Colleges	NNP
18637	25076	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25076	5	_	_	NNP
18637	25076	6	see	see	VBP
18637	25076	7	also	also	RB
18637	25076	8	_	_	NNP
18637	25076	9	Negroes	Negroes	NNP
18637	25076	10	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25076	11	:	:	:
18637	25076	12	Curricula	Curricula	NNP
18637	25076	13	,	,	,
18637	25076	14	military	military	JJ
18637	25076	15	training	training	NN
18637	25076	16	,	,	,
18637	25076	17	attendance	attendance	NN
18637	25076	18	at	at	IN
18637	25076	19	,	,	,
18637	25076	20	State	State	NNP
18637	25076	21	laws	law	NNS
18637	25076	22	regulating	regulate	VBG
18637	25076	23	,	,	,
18637	25076	24	984	984	CD
18637	25076	25	-	-	SYM
18637	25076	26	985	985	CD
18637	25076	27	Searches	Searches	NNPS
18637	25076	28	and	and	CC
18637	25076	29	Seizures	Seizures	NNPS
18637	25076	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25076	31	_	_	NNP
18637	25076	32	see	see	VBP
18637	25076	33	also	also	RB
18637	25076	34	_	_	NNP
18637	25076	35	Corporations	Corporations	NNPS
18637	25076	36	;	;	:
18637	25076	37	Due	due	IN
18637	25076	38	Process	Process	NNP
18637	25076	39	of	of	IN
18637	25076	40	Law	Law	NNP
18637	25076	41	;	;	:
18637	25076	42	Self	self	NN
18637	25076	43	-	-	HYPH
18637	25076	44	Incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	25076	45	;	;	:
18637	25076	46	Wiretapping	wiretapping	NN
18637	25076	47	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25076	48	:	:	:
18637	25076	49	Evidence	evidence	NN
18637	25076	50	obtained	obtain	VBN
18637	25076	51	by	by	IN
18637	25076	52	,	,	,
18637	25076	53	use	use	NN
18637	25076	54	of	of	IN
18637	25076	55	,	,	,
18637	25076	56	830	830	CD
18637	25076	57	-	-	SYM
18637	25076	58	831	831	CD
18637	25076	59	Incidental	incidental	JJ
18637	25076	60	to	to	TO
18637	25076	61	arrest	arrest	VB
18637	25076	62	,	,	,
18637	25076	63	828	828	CD
18637	25076	64	-	-	SYM
18637	25076	65	829	829	CD
18637	25076	66	Records	Records	NNPS
18637	25076	67	,	,	,
18637	25076	68	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	25076	69	of	of	IN
18637	25076	70	keeping	keeping	NN
18637	25076	71	,	,	,
18637	25076	72	disclosing	disclose	VBG
18637	25076	73	as	as	IN
18637	25076	74	a	a	DT
18637	25076	75	,	,	,
18637	25076	76	827	827	CD
18637	25076	77	Self	self	NN
18637	25076	78	-	-	HYPH
18637	25076	79	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	25076	80	,	,	,
18637	25076	81	seizures	seizure	NNS
18637	25076	82	entailing	entail	VBG
18637	25076	83	,	,	,
18637	25076	84	etc	etc	FW
18637	25076	85	.	.	FW
18637	25076	86	,	,	,
18637	25076	87	effect	effect	NN
18637	25076	88	,	,	,
18637	25076	89	825	825	CD
18637	25076	90	-	-	SYM
18637	25076	91	827	827	CD
18637	25076	92	by	by	IN
18637	25076	93	State	State	NNP
18637	25076	94	,	,	,
18637	25076	95	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	25076	96	,	,	,
18637	25076	97	validity	validity	NN
18637	25076	98	,	,	,
18637	25076	99	1121	1121	CD
18637	25076	100	-	-	SYM
18637	25076	101	1124	1124	CD
18637	25076	102	Unreasonable	Unreasonable	NNP
18637	25076	103	,	,	,
18637	25076	104	protection	protection	NN
18637	25076	105	against	against	IN
18637	25076	106	,	,	,
18637	25076	107	823	823	CD
18637	25076	108	-	-	HYPH
18637	25076	109	831	831	CD
18637	25076	110	Vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	25076	111	,	,	,
18637	25076	112	search	search	NN
18637	25076	113	of	of	IN
18637	25076	114	,	,	,
18637	25076	115	without	without	IN
18637	25076	116	warrant	warrant	NN
18637	25076	117	,	,	,
18637	25076	118	830	830	CD
18637	25076	119	Warrants	warrant	NNS
18637	25076	120	for	for	IN
18637	25076	121	,	,	,
18637	25076	122	necessity	necessity	NN
18637	25076	123	,	,	,
18637	25076	124	sufficiency	sufficiency	NN
18637	25076	125	of	of	IN
18637	25076	126	,	,	,
18637	25076	127	825	825	CD
18637	25076	128	-	-	HYPH
18637	25076	129	830	830	CD
18637	25076	130	Seat	Seat	NNP
18637	25076	131	of	of	IN
18637	25076	132	Government	Government	NNP
18637	25076	133	.	.	.
18637	25077	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25077	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25077	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25077	4	District	District	NNP
18637	25077	5	of	of	IN
18637	25077	6	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	25077	7	.	.	.
18637	25078	1	Secret	secret	JJ
18637	25078	2	agents	agent	NNS
18637	25078	3	,	,	,
18637	25078	4	437	437	CD
18637	25078	5	-	-	SYM
18637	25078	6	438	438	CD
18637	25078	7	,	,	,
18637	25078	8	447	447	CD
18637	25078	9	-	-	SYM
18637	25078	10	449	449	CD
18637	25078	11	,	,	,
18637	25078	12	1156	1156	CD
18637	25078	13	Secret	Secret	NNP
18637	25078	14	Societies	Societies	NNPS
18637	25078	15	,	,	,
18637	25078	16	State	State	NNP
18637	25078	17	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25078	18	of	of	IN
18637	25078	19	,	,	,
18637	25078	20	985	985	CD
18637	25078	21	,	,	,
18637	25078	22	1156	1156	CD
18637	25078	23	Securities	Securities	NNPS
18637	25078	24	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25078	25	_	_	NNP
18637	25078	26	see	see	VBP
18637	25078	27	also	also	RB
18637	25078	28	_	_	NNP
18637	25078	29	Blue	Blue	NNP
18637	25078	30	Sky	Sky	NNP
18637	25078	31	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	25078	32	;	;	,
18637	25078	33	Commodity	Commodity	NNP
18637	25078	34	and	and	CC
18637	25078	35	Security	Security	NNP
18637	25078	36	Exchanges	Exchanges	NNP
18637	25078	37	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25078	38	:	:	:
18637	25078	39	Brokers	broker	NNS
18637	25078	40	in	in	IN
18637	25078	41	,	,	,
18637	25078	42	State	state	NN
18637	25078	43	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25078	44	,	,	,
18637	25078	45	235	235	CD
18637	25078	46	Issuance	issuance	NN
18637	25078	47	,	,	,
18637	25078	48	trading	trading	NN
18637	25078	49	in	in	IN
18637	25078	50	,	,	,
18637	25078	51	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25078	52	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25078	53	,	,	,
18637	25078	54	150	150	CD
18637	25078	55	-	-	SYM
18637	25078	56	151	151	CD
18637	25078	57	Sale	sale	NN
18637	25078	58	of	of	IN
18637	25078	59	,	,	,
18637	25078	60	State	State	NNP
18637	25078	61	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	25078	62	as	as	IN
18637	25078	63	to	to	IN
18637	25078	64	,	,	,
18637	25078	65	1156	1156	CD
18637	25078	66	Segregation	segregation	NN
18637	25078	67	.	.	.
18637	25079	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25079	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25079	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25079	4	Chinese	Chinese	NNPS
18637	25079	5	;	;	:
18637	25079	6	Japanese	Japanese	NNPS
18637	25079	7	;	;	:
18637	25079	8	Negroes	negro	NNS
18637	25079	9	.	.	.
18637	25080	1	Self	self	NN
18637	25080	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	25080	3	Incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	25080	4	:	:	:
18637	25080	5	Privilege	privilege	NN
18637	25080	6	against	against	IN
18637	25080	7	,	,	,
18637	25080	8	scope	scope	NN
18637	25080	9	,	,	,
18637	25080	10	825	825	CD
18637	25080	11	-	-	SYM
18637	25080	12	827	827	CD
18637	25080	13	,	,	,
18637	25080	14	841	841	CD
18637	25080	15	-	-	SYM
18637	25080	16	844	844	CD
18637	25080	17	,	,	,
18637	25080	18	1111	1111	CD
18637	25080	19	-	-	SYM
18637	25080	20	1121	1121	CD
18637	25080	21	in	in	IN
18637	25080	22	State	State	NNP
18637	25080	23	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	25080	24	trials	trial	NNS
18637	25080	25	,	,	,
18637	25080	26	1111	1111	CD
18637	25080	27	-	-	SYM
18637	25080	28	1121	1121	CD
18637	25080	29	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	25080	30	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25080	31	_	_	NNP
18637	25080	32	see	see	VBP
18637	25080	33	also	also	RB
18637	25080	34	_	_	NNP
18637	25080	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25080	36	;	;	:
18637	25080	37	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	25080	38	Agreements	Agreements	NNP
18637	25080	39	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25080	40	:	:	:
18637	25080	41	Assent	assent	NN
18637	25080	42	to	to	IN
18637	25080	43	appointment	appointment	NN
18637	25080	44	of	of	IN
18637	25080	45	officers	officer	NNS
18637	25080	46	,	,	,
18637	25080	47	453	453	CD
18637	25080	48	-	-	SYM
18637	25080	49	454	454	CD
18637	25080	50	Impeachments	Impeachments	NNPS
18637	25080	51	,	,	,
18637	25080	52	trial	trial	NN
18637	25080	53	by	by	IN
18637	25080	54	,	,	,
18637	25080	55	vote	vote	NN
18637	25080	56	to	to	TO
18637	25080	57	convict	convict	VB
18637	25080	58	,	,	,
18637	25080	59	91	91	CD
18637	25080	60	Members	member	NNS
18637	25080	61	not	not	RB
18637	25080	62	to	to	TO
18637	25080	63	serve	serve	VB
18637	25080	64	as	as	IN
18637	25080	65	presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	25080	66	electors	elector	NNS
18637	25080	67	,	,	,
18637	25080	68	91	91	CD
18637	25080	69	-	-	SYM
18637	25080	70	92	92	CD
18637	25080	71	,	,	,
18637	25080	72	94	94	CD
18637	25080	73	,	,	,
18637	25080	74	1207	1207	CD
18637	25080	75	-	-	SYM
18637	25080	76	1208	1208	CD
18637	25080	77	Members	member	NNS
18637	25080	78	of	of	IN
18637	25080	79	,	,	,
18637	25080	80	number	number	NN
18637	25080	81	of	of	IN
18637	25080	82	,	,	,
18637	25080	83	popular	popular	JJ
18637	25080	84	election	election	NN
18637	25080	85	,	,	,
18637	25080	86	91	91	CD
18637	25080	87	-	-	SYM
18637	25080	88	92	92	CD
18637	25080	89	,	,	,
18637	25080	90	94	94	CD
18637	25080	91	,	,	,
18637	25080	92	1207	1207	CD
18637	25080	93	-	-	SYM
18637	25080	94	1208	1208	CD
18637	25080	95	Officers	Officers	NNPS
18637	25080	96	of	of	IN
18637	25080	97	,	,	,
18637	25080	98	how	how	WRB
18637	25080	99	chosen	choose	VBN
18637	25080	100	,	,	,
18637	25080	101	91	91	CD
18637	25080	102	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	25080	103	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
18637	25080	104	agents	agent	NNS
18637	25080	105	,	,	,
18637	25080	106	powers	power	NNS
18637	25080	107	as	as	IN
18637	25080	108	to	to	IN
18637	25080	109	choice	choice	NN
18637	25080	110	of	of	IN
18637	25080	111	,	,	,
18637	25080	112	etc	etc	FW
18637	25080	113	.	.	.
18637	25080	114	,	,	,
18637	25080	115	437	437	CD
18637	25080	116	-	-	SYM
18637	25080	117	438	438	CD
18637	25080	118	,	,	,
18637	25080	119	447	447	CD
18637	25080	120	-	-	CD
18637	25080	121	449	449	CD
18637	25080	122	Revenue	revenue	NN
18637	25080	123	bills	bill	NNS
18637	25080	124	,	,	,
18637	25080	125	may	may	MD
18637	25080	126	amend	amend	VB
18637	25080	127	,	,	,
18637	25080	128	101	101	CD
18637	25080	129	-	-	SYM
18637	25080	130	102	102	CD
18637	25080	131	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	25080	132	,	,	,
18637	25080	133	powers	power	NNS
18637	25080	134	,	,	,
18637	25080	135	duties	duty	NNS
18637	25080	136	as	as	IN
18637	25080	137	to	to	IN
18637	25080	138	,	,	,
18637	25080	139	412	412	CD
18637	25080	140	-	-	SYM
18637	25080	141	413	413	CD
18637	25080	142	,	,	,
18637	25080	143	419	419	CD
18637	25080	144	,	,	,
18637	25080	145	434	434	CD
18637	25080	146	,	,	,
18637	25080	147	444	444	CD
18637	25080	148	-	-	HYPH
18637	25080	149	445	445	CD
18637	25080	150	Vacancies	Vacancies	NNPS
18637	25080	151	in	in	RB
18637	25080	152	,	,	,
18637	25080	153	how	how	WRB
18637	25080	154	filled	fill	VBN
18637	25080	155	,	,	,
18637	25080	156	1207	1207	CD
18637	25080	157	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	25080	158	-	-	HYPH
18637	25080	159	President	President	NNP
18637	25080	160	to	to	TO
18637	25080	161	preside	preside	VB
18637	25080	162	over	over	RB
18637	25080	163	,	,	,
18637	25080	164	casting	cast	VBG
18637	25080	165	vote	vote	NN
18637	25080	166	,	,	,
18637	25080	167	when	when	WRB
18637	25080	168	,	,	,
18637	25080	169	91	91	CD
18637	25080	170	Separation	separation	NN
18637	25080	171	of	of	IN
18637	25080	172	Powers	power	NNS
18637	25080	173	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25080	174	_	_	NNP
18637	25080	175	see	see	VBP
18637	25080	176	also	also	RB
18637	25080	177	_	_	NNP
18637	25080	178	Delegation	Delegation	NNP
18637	25080	179	of	of	IN
18637	25080	180	Power	Power	NNP
18637	25080	181	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25080	182	:	:	:
18637	25080	183	Immunity	immunity	NN
18637	25080	184	of	of	IN
18637	25080	185	legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	25080	186	,	,	,
18637	25080	187	executive	executive	JJ
18637	25080	188	branches	branch	NNS
18637	25080	189	from	from	IN
18637	25080	190	judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	25080	191	direction	direction	NN
18637	25080	192	,	,	,
18637	25080	193	499	499	CD
18637	25080	194	-	-	SYM
18637	25080	195	500	500	CD
18637	25080	196	Severance	severance	NN
18637	25080	197	Taxes	Taxes	NNPS
18637	25080	198	.	.	.
18637	25081	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25081	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25081	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25081	4	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	25081	5	.	.	.
18637	25082	1	Sewers	sewer	NNS
18637	25082	2	,	,	,
18637	25082	3	compelling	compel	VBG
18637	25082	4	property	property	NN
18637	25082	5	owners	owner	NNS
18637	25082	6	to	to	TO
18637	25082	7	connect	connect	VB
18637	25082	8	with	with	IN
18637	25082	9	,	,	,
18637	25082	10	1030	1030	CD
18637	25082	11	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
18637	25082	12	Act	Act	NNP
18637	25082	13	.	.	.
18637	25083	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25083	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25083	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25083	4	Restraint	Restraint	NNP
18637	25083	5	of	of	IN
18637	25083	6	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	25083	7	.	.	.
18637	25084	1	Shrimp	Shrimp	NNP
18637	25084	2	,	,	,
18637	25084	3	State	State	NNP
18637	25084	4	restriction	restriction	NN
18637	25084	5	on	on	IN
18637	25084	6	export	export	NN
18637	25084	7	of	of	IN
18637	25084	8	,	,	,
18637	25084	9	245	245	CD
18637	25084	10	Slavery	Slavery	NNP
18637	25084	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25084	12	_	_	NNP
18637	25084	13	see	see	VB
18637	25084	14	also	also	RB
18637	25084	15	_	_	NNP
18637	25084	16	Involuntary	Involuntary	NNP
18637	25084	17	Servitude	Servitude	NNP
18637	25084	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25084	19	:	:	:
18637	25084	20	Importation	importation	NN
18637	25084	21	of	of	IN
18637	25084	22	,	,	,
18637	25084	23	not	not	RB
18637	25084	24	to	to	TO
18637	25084	25	be	be	VB
18637	25084	26	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
18637	25084	27	before	before	IN
18637	25084	28	1808	1808	CD
18637	25084	29	,	,	,
18637	25084	30	312	312	CD
18637	25084	31	Social	Social	NNP
18637	25084	32	Security	Security	NNP
18637	25084	33	Act	Act	NNP
18637	25084	34	,	,	,
18637	25084	35	validity	validity	NN
18637	25084	36	,	,	,
18637	25084	37	115	115	CD
18637	25084	38	Sound	sound	JJ
18637	25084	39	Trucks	Trucks	NNPS
18637	25084	40	.	.	.
18637	25085	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25085	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25085	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25085	4	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
18637	25085	5	of	of	IN
18637	25085	6	Religion	Religion	NNP
18637	25085	7	,	,	,
18637	25085	8	Speech	Speech	NNP
18637	25085	9	,	,	,
18637	25085	10	Press	Press	NNP
18637	25085	11	,	,	,
18637	25085	12	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
18637	25085	13	.	.	.
18637	25086	1	Sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	25086	2	,	,	,
18637	25086	3	where	where	WRB
18637	25086	4	located	locate	VBN
18637	25086	5	,	,	,
18637	25086	6	59	59	CD
18637	25086	7	-	-	SYM
18637	25086	8	60	60	CD
18637	25086	9	,	,	,
18637	25086	10	72	72	CD
18637	25086	11	Special	Special	NNP
18637	25086	12	Assessments	Assessments	NNPS
18637	25086	13	.	.	.
18637	25087	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25087	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25087	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25087	4	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	25087	5	:	:	:
18637	25087	6	State	state	NN
18637	25087	7	.	.	.
18637	25088	1	Spending	spending	NN
18637	25088	2	for	for	IN
18637	25088	3	the	the	DT
18637	25088	4	General	General	NNP
18637	25088	5	Welfare	Welfare	NNP
18637	25088	6	,	,	,
18637	25088	7	powers	power	NNS
18637	25088	8	of	of	IN
18637	25088	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25088	10	,	,	,
18637	25088	11	112	112	CD
18637	25088	12	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	13	117	117	CD
18637	25088	14	Stare	Stare	NNP
18637	25088	15	Decisis	Decisis	NNP
18637	25088	16	,	,	,
18637	25088	17	565	565	CD
18637	25088	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	25088	19	566	566	CD
18637	25088	20	States	state	NNS
18637	25088	21	:	:	:
18637	25088	22	Admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	25088	23	matters	matter	NNS
18637	25088	24	,	,	,
18637	25088	25	rights	right	NNS
18637	25088	26	,	,	,
18637	25088	27	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	25088	28	as	as	IN
18637	25088	29	to	to	IN
18637	25088	30	,	,	,
18637	25088	31	574	574	CD
18637	25088	32	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	33	582	582	CD
18637	25088	34	Admission	admission	NN
18637	25088	35	on	on	IN
18637	25088	36	terms	term	NNS
18637	25088	37	of	of	IN
18637	25088	38	equality	equality	NN
18637	25088	39	,	,	,
18637	25088	40	697	697	CD
18637	25088	41	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	42	701	701	CD
18637	25088	43	Agreements	agreement	NNS
18637	25088	44	with	with	IN
18637	25088	45	other	other	JJ
18637	25088	46	States	state	NNS
18637	25088	47	:	:	:
18637	25088	48	Compact	compact	JJ
18637	25088	49	clause	clause	NN
18637	25088	50	,	,	,
18637	25088	51	history	history	NN
18637	25088	52	,	,	,
18637	25088	53	365	365	CD
18637	25088	54	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	55	367	367	CD
18637	25088	56	Compacts	compact	NNS
18637	25088	57	,	,	,
18637	25088	58	consent	consent	NN
18637	25088	59	of	of	IN
18637	25088	60	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25088	61	to	to	IN
18637	25088	62	,	,	,
18637	25088	63	when	when	WRB
18637	25088	64	required	require	VBN
18637	25088	65	,	,	,
18637	25088	66	365	365	CD
18637	25088	67	,	,	,
18637	25088	68	367	367	CD
18637	25088	69	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	70	369	369	CD
18637	25088	71	Compacts	compact	NNS
18637	25088	72	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
18637	25088	73	from	from	IN
18637	25088	74	treaties	treaty	NNS
18637	25088	75	,	,	,
18637	25088	76	367	367	CD
18637	25088	77	Compacts	compact	NNS
18637	25088	78	,	,	,
18637	25088	79	substance	substance	NN
18637	25088	80	,	,	,
18637	25088	81	legal	legal	JJ
18637	25088	82	effect	effect	NN
18637	25088	83	of	of	IN
18637	25088	84	,	,	,
18637	25088	85	367	367	CD
18637	25088	86	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	87	370	370	CD
18637	25088	88	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	25088	89	clause	clause	NN
18637	25088	90	,	,	,
18637	25088	91	as	as	IN
18637	25088	92	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	25088	93	on	on	IN
18637	25088	94	powers	power	NNS
18637	25088	95	of	of	IN
18637	25088	96	,	,	,
18637	25088	97	173	173	CD
18637	25088	98	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	99	214	214	CD
18637	25088	100	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	25088	101	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25088	102	_	_	NNP
18637	25088	103	see	see	VB
18637	25088	104	also	also	RB
18637	25088	105	_	_	NNP
18637	25088	106	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	25088	107	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25088	108	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25088	109	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25088	110	;	;	:
18637	25088	111	Full	full	JJ
18637	25088	112	Faith	Faith	NNP
18637	25088	113	and	and	CC
18637	25088	114	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	25088	115	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25088	116	:	:	:
18637	25088	117	Concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	25088	118	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	25088	119	with	with	IN
18637	25088	120	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25088	121	courts	court	NNS
18637	25088	122	,	,	,
18637	25088	123	comity	comity	NN
18637	25088	124	,	,	,
18637	25088	125	624	624	CD
18637	25088	126	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	127	627	627	CD
18637	25088	128	,	,	,
18637	25088	129	636	636	CD
18637	25088	130	Consuls	consul	NNS
18637	25088	131	,	,	,
18637	25088	132	suable	suable	JJ
18637	25088	133	in	in	RP
18637	25088	134	,	,	,
18637	25088	135	571	571	CD
18637	25088	136	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	137	572	572	CD
18637	25088	138	Contempt	contempt	NN
18637	25088	139	power	power	NN
18637	25088	140	of	of	IN
18637	25088	141	,	,	,
18637	25088	142	517	517	CD
18637	25088	143	Controversies	controversy	NNS
18637	25088	144	with	with	IN
18637	25088	145	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25088	146	courts	court	NNS
18637	25088	147	,	,	,
18637	25088	148	comity	comity	NN
18637	25088	149	,	,	,
18637	25088	150	624	624	CD
18637	25088	151	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	152	635	635	CD
18637	25088	153	Crimes	crime	NNS
18637	25088	154	on	on	IN
18637	25088	155	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	25088	156	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	25088	157	,	,	,
18637	25088	158	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	25088	159	,	,	,
18637	25088	160	698	698	CD
18637	25088	161	Enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	25088	162	of	of	IN
18637	25088	163	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25088	164	laws	law	NNS
18637	25088	165	by	by	IN
18637	25088	166	,	,	,
18637	25088	167	635	635	CD
18637	25088	168	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	169	637	637	CD
18637	25088	170	,	,	,
18637	25088	171	726	726	CD
18637	25088	172	-	-	HYPH
18637	25088	173	727	727	CD
18637	25088	174	,	,	,
18637	25088	175	736	736	CD
18637	25088	176	-	-	HYPH
18637	25088	177	739	739	CD
18637	25088	178	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25088	179	courts	court	NNS
18637	25088	180	,	,	,
18637	25088	181	interference	interference	NN
18637	25088	182	with	with	IN
18637	25088	183	,	,	,
18637	25088	184	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	25088	185	,	,	,
18637	25088	186	727	727	CD
18637	25088	187	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	188	728	728	CD
18637	25088	189	Judicial	judicial	JJ
18637	25088	190	review	review	NN
18637	25088	191	by	by	IN
18637	25088	192	,	,	,
18637	25088	193	560	560	CD
18637	25088	194	Procedure	Procedure	NNP
18637	25088	195	in	in	IN
18637	25088	196	;	;	:
18637	25088	197	State	state	NN
18637	25088	198	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25088	199	,	,	,
18637	25088	200	due	due	JJ
18637	25088	201	process	process	NN
18637	25088	202	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	25088	203	on	on	IN
18637	25088	204	,	,	,
18637	25088	205	1089	1089	CD
18637	25088	206	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	207	1096	1096	CD
18637	25088	208	,	,	,
18637	25088	209	1139	1139	CD
18637	25088	210	Records	Records	NNPS
18637	25088	211	of	of	IN
18637	25088	212	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	25088	213	court	court	NN
18637	25088	214	,	,	,
18637	25088	215	transfer	transfer	VB
18637	25088	216	to	to	IN
18637	25088	217	,	,	,
18637	25088	218	on	on	IN
18637	25088	219	State	State	NNP
18637	25088	220	admission	admission	NN
18637	25088	221	,	,	,
18637	25088	222	699	699	CD
18637	25088	223	Removal	removal	NN
18637	25088	224	of	of	IN
18637	25088	225	cases	case	NNS
18637	25088	226	from	from	IN
18637	25088	227	,	,	,
18637	25088	228	to	to	IN
18637	25088	229	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25088	230	courts	court	NNS
18637	25088	231	,	,	,
18637	25088	232	567	567	CD
18637	25088	233	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	234	569	569	CD
18637	25088	235	Review	Review	NNP
18637	25088	236	of	of	IN
18637	25088	237	,	,	,
18637	25088	238	by	by	IN
18637	25088	239	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25088	240	courts	court	NNS
18637	25088	241	,	,	,
18637	25088	242	554	554	CD
18637	25088	243	-	-	HYPH
18637	25088	244	555	555	CD
18637	25088	245	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	25088	246	in	in	IN
18637	25088	247	,	,	,
18637	25088	248	at	at	IN
18637	25088	249	common	common	JJ
18637	25088	250	law	law	NN
18637	25088	251	,	,	,
18637	25088	252	in	in	IN
18637	25088	253	lieu	lieu	NN
18637	25088	254	of	of	IN
18637	25088	255	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25088	256	admiralty	admiralty	NN
18637	25088	257	actions	action	NNS
18637	25088	258	,	,	,
18637	25088	259	575	575	CD
18637	25088	260	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	261	576	576	CD
18637	25088	262	,	,	,
18637	25088	263	578	578	CD
18637	25088	264	-	-	HYPH
18637	25088	265	579	579	CD
18637	25088	266	Debts	debt	NNS
18637	25088	267	incurred	incur	VBN
18637	25088	268	in	in	IN
18637	25088	269	aid	aid	NN
18637	25088	270	of	of	IN
18637	25088	271	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	25088	272	,	,	,
18637	25088	273	void	void	JJ
18637	25088	274	,	,	,
18637	25088	275	1174	1174	CD
18637	25088	276	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25088	277	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	25088	278	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	25088	279	,	,	,
18637	25088	280	application	application	NN
18637	25088	281	after	after	IN
18637	25088	282	State	state	NN
18637	25088	283	admission	admission	NN
18637	25088	284	,	,	,
18637	25088	285	698	698	CD
18637	25088	286	Governors	Governors	NNPS
18637	25088	287	,	,	,
18637	25088	288	veto	veto	NN
18637	25088	289	of	of	IN
18637	25088	290	congressional	congressional	JJ
18637	25088	291	districting	districting	NN
18637	25088	292	laws	law	NNS
18637	25088	293	,	,	,
18637	25088	294	93	93	CD
18637	25088	295	Immunity	immunity	NN
18637	25088	296	from	from	IN
18637	25088	297	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25088	298	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	25088	299	,	,	,
18637	25088	300	105	105	CD
18637	25088	301	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	302	109	109	CD
18637	25088	303	Immunity	immunity	NN
18637	25088	304	from	from	IN
18637	25088	305	suit	suit	NN
18637	25088	306	without	without	IN
18637	25088	307	consent	consent	NN
18637	25088	308	,	,	,
18637	25088	309	609	609	CD
18637	25088	310	Obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	25088	311	owed	owe	VBD
18637	25088	312	to	to	IN
18637	25088	313	,	,	,
18637	25088	314	by	by	IN
18637	25088	315	United	United	NNP
18637	25088	316	States	States	NNP
18637	25088	317	,	,	,
18637	25088	318	704	704	CD
18637	25088	319	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	320	705	705	CD
18637	25088	321	Offenses	offense	NNS
18637	25088	322	on	on	IN
18637	25088	323	navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	25088	324	waters	water	NNS
18637	25088	325	,	,	,
18637	25088	326	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	25088	327	by	by	IN
18637	25088	328	,	,	,
18637	25088	329	578	578	CD
18637	25088	330	Officers	officer	NNS
18637	25088	331	:	:	:
18637	25088	332	Acting	act	VBG
18637	25088	333	under	under	IN
18637	25088	334	void	void	JJ
18637	25088	335	statute	statute	NN
18637	25088	336	,	,	,
18637	25088	337	status	status	NN
18637	25088	338	of	of	IN
18637	25088	339	,	,	,
18637	25088	340	929	929	CD
18637	25088	341	Denying	deny	VBG
18637	25088	342	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	25088	343	rights	right	NNS
18637	25088	344	,	,	,
18637	25088	345	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25088	346	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	25088	347	of	of	IN
18637	25088	348	,	,	,
18637	25088	349	1176	1176	CD
18637	25088	350	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	351	1177	1177	CD
18637	25088	352	Disqualification	Disqualification	NNP
18637	25088	353	for	for	IN
18637	25088	354	rebellion	rebellion	NN
18637	25088	355	,	,	,
18637	25088	356	treason	treason	NN
18637	25088	357	;	;	:
18637	25088	358	removal	removal	NN
18637	25088	359	of	of	IN
18637	25088	360	disability	disability	NN
18637	25088	361	by	by	IN
18637	25088	362	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25088	363	,	,	,
18637	25088	364	1173	1173	CD
18637	25088	365	National	national	JJ
18637	25088	366	duties	duty	NNS
18637	25088	367	of	of	IN
18637	25088	368	,	,	,
18637	25088	369	limits	limit	NNS
18637	25088	370	,	,	,
18637	25088	371	736	736	CD
18637	25088	372	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	373	737	737	CD
18637	25088	374	Office	Office	NNP
18637	25088	375	of	of	IN
18637	25088	376	,	,	,
18637	25088	377	when	when	WRB
18637	25088	378	a	a	DT
18637	25088	379	contract	contract	NN
18637	25088	380	not	not	RB
18637	25088	381	to	to	TO
18637	25088	382	be	be	VB
18637	25088	383	impaired	impair	VBN
18637	25088	384	,	,	,
18637	25088	385	340	340	CD
18637	25088	386	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	387	341	341	CD
18637	25088	388	Political	political	JJ
18637	25088	389	activity	activity	NN
18637	25088	390	of	of	IN
18637	25088	391	,	,	,
18637	25088	392	application	application	NN
18637	25088	393	of	of	IN
18637	25088	394	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25088	395	Hatch	Hatch	NNP
18637	25088	396	Act	Act	NNP
18637	25088	397	,	,	,
18637	25088	398	etc	etc	FW
18637	25088	399	.	.	FW
18637	25088	400	,	,	,
18637	25088	401	116	116	CD
18637	25088	402	,	,	,
18637	25088	403	793	793	CD
18637	25088	404	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	405	794	794	CD
18637	25088	406	Presidential	presidential	JJ
18637	25088	407	electors	elector	NNS
18637	25088	408	,	,	,
18637	25088	409	status	status	NN
18637	25088	410	as	as	IN
18637	25088	411	,	,	,
18637	25088	412	385	385	CD
18637	25088	413	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	414	386	386	CD
18637	25088	415	Restraint	Restraint	NNP
18637	25088	416	of	of	IN
18637	25088	417	,	,	,
18637	25088	418	by	by	IN
18637	25088	419	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25088	420	courts	court	NNS
18637	25088	421	,	,	,
18637	25088	422	629	629	CD
18637	25088	423	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	424	630	630	CD
18637	25088	425	Salaries	salary	NNS
18637	25088	426	of	of	IN
18637	25088	427	,	,	,
18637	25088	428	subject	subject	JJ
18637	25088	429	to	to	IN
18637	25088	430	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25088	431	income	income	NN
18637	25088	432	tax	tax	NN
18637	25088	433	,	,	,
18637	25088	434	105	105	CD
18637	25088	435	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	436	106	106	CD
18637	25088	437	,	,	,
18637	25088	438	108	108	CD
18637	25088	439	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	25088	440	against	against	IN
18637	25088	441	,	,	,
18637	25088	442	when	when	WRB
18637	25088	443	immune	immune	JJ
18637	25088	444	from	from	IN
18637	25088	445	,	,	,
18637	25088	446	930	930	CD
18637	25088	447	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	448	935	935	CD
18637	25088	449	Test	test	NN
18637	25088	450	oaths	oath	NNS
18637	25088	451	for	for	IN
18637	25088	452	,	,	,
18637	25088	453	illegal	illegal	JJ
18637	25088	454	,	,	,
18637	25088	455	736	736	CD
18637	25088	456	Political	political	JJ
18637	25088	457	Subdivisions	Subdivisions	NNPS
18637	25088	458	:	:	:
18637	25088	459	Bonds	bond	NNS
18637	25088	460	and	and	CC
18637	25088	461	charters	charter	NNS
18637	25088	462	of	of	IN
18637	25088	463	municipal	municipal	JJ
18637	25088	464	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	25088	465	,	,	,
18637	25088	466	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	25088	467	by	by	IN
18637	25088	468	States	States	NNP
18637	25088	469	,	,	,
18637	25088	470	339	339	CD
18637	25088	471	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	472	340	340	CD
18637	25088	473	,	,	,
18637	25088	474	356	356	CD
18637	25088	475	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	476	357	357	CD
18637	25088	477	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25088	478	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	25088	479	,	,	,
18637	25088	480	scope	scope	NN
18637	25088	481	of	of	IN
18637	25088	482	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	25088	483	from	from	IN
18637	25088	484	,	,	,
18637	25088	485	106	106	CD
18637	25088	486	-	-	HYPH
18637	25088	487	109	109	CD
18637	25088	488	Municipalities	municipality	NNS
18637	25088	489	,	,	,
18637	25088	490	equal	equal	JJ
18637	25088	491	protection	protection	NN
18637	25088	492	of	of	IN
18637	25088	493	the	the	DT
18637	25088	494	laws	law	NNS
18637	25088	495	,	,	,
18637	25088	496	not	not	RB
18637	25088	497	entitled	entitle	VBN
18637	25088	498	to	to	TO
18637	25088	499	invoke	invoke	VB
18637	25088	500	,	,	,
18637	25088	501	1143	1143	CD
18637	25088	502	State	state	NN
18637	25088	503	control	control	NN
18637	25088	504	of	of	IN
18637	25088	505	,	,	,
18637	25088	506	effect	effect	NN
18637	25088	507	of	of	IN
18637	25088	508	due	due	JJ
18637	25088	509	process	process	NN
18637	25088	510	clause	clause	NN
18637	25088	511	on	on	IN
18637	25088	512	,	,	,
18637	25088	513	1035	1035	CD
18637	25088	514	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	515	1036	1036	CD
18637	25088	516	Powers	power	NNS
18637	25088	517	denied	deny	VBD
18637	25088	518	to	to	IN
18637	25088	519	,	,	,
18637	25088	520	325	325	CD
18637	25088	521	Property	property	NN
18637	25088	522	owned	own	VBN
18637	25088	523	during	during	IN
18637	25088	524	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	25088	525	status	status	NN
18637	25088	526	,	,	,
18637	25088	527	effect	effect	NN
18637	25088	528	of	of	IN
18637	25088	529	admission	admission	NN
18637	25088	530	as	as	IN
18637	25088	531	,	,	,
18637	25088	532	on	on	IN
18637	25088	533	title	title	NN
18637	25088	534	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25088	535	off	off	IN
18637	25088	536	shore	shore	NN
18637	25088	537	oil	oil	NN
18637	25088	538	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25088	539	,	,	,
18637	25088	540	700	700	CD
18637	25088	541	Property	property	NN
18637	25088	542	transfers	transfer	NNS
18637	25088	543	during	during	IN
18637	25088	544	territorial	territorial	JJ
18637	25088	545	status	status	NN
18637	25088	546	,	,	,
18637	25088	547	effect	effect	NN
18637	25088	548	on	on	IN
18637	25088	549	,	,	,
18637	25088	550	of	of	IN
18637	25088	551	admission	admission	NN
18637	25088	552	as	as	IN
18637	25088	553	State	State	NNP
18637	25088	554	,	,	,
18637	25088	555	700	700	CD
18637	25088	556	Reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	25088	557	powers	power	NNS
18637	25088	558	of	of	IN
18637	25088	559	,	,	,
18637	25088	560	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	25088	561	by	by	IN
18637	25088	562	treaty	treaty	NN
18637	25088	563	-	-	HYPH
18637	25088	564	making	make	VBG
18637	25088	565	power	power	NN
18637	25088	566	,	,	,
18637	25088	567	etc	etc	FW
18637	25088	568	.	.	.
18637	25088	569	,	,	,
18637	25088	570	428	428	CD
18637	25088	571	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	572	430	430	CD
18637	25088	573	,	,	,
18637	25088	574	915	915	CD
18637	25088	575	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	576	921	921	CD
18637	25088	577	Suits	suit	NNS
18637	25088	578	against	against	IN
18637	25088	579	,	,	,
18637	25088	580	scope	scope	NN
18637	25088	581	of	of	IN
18637	25088	582	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	25088	583	from	from	IN
18637	25088	584	,	,	,
18637	25088	585	consent	consent	NN
18637	25088	586	,	,	,
18637	25088	587	waiver	waiver	NN
18637	25088	588	,	,	,
18637	25088	589	929	929	CD
18637	25088	590	-	-	HYPH
18637	25088	591	936	936	CD
18637	25088	592	United	United	NNP
18637	25088	593	States	States	NNP
18637	25088	594	,	,	,
18637	25088	595	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	25088	596	,	,	,
18637	25088	597	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	25088	598	,	,	,
18637	25088	599	in	in	IN
18637	25088	600	cessions	cession	NNS
18637	25088	601	of	of	IN
18637	25088	602	property	property	NN
18637	25088	603	to	to	IN
18637	25088	604	,	,	,
18637	25088	605	305	305	CD
18637	25088	606	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	607	307	307	CD
18637	25088	608	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	25088	609	Seizure	Seizure	NNP
18637	25088	610	Case	Case	NNP
18637	25088	611	,	,	,
18637	25088	612	489	489	CD
18637	25088	613	-	-	SYM
18637	25088	614	499	499	CD
18637	25088	615	Sterilization	Sterilization	NNP
18637	25088	616	,	,	,
18637	25088	617	sexual	sexual	JJ
18637	25088	618	,	,	,
18637	25088	619	State	state	NN
18637	25088	620	laws	law	NNS
18637	25088	621	providing	provide	VBG
18637	25088	622	for	for	IN
18637	25088	623	,	,	,
18637	25088	624	984	984	CD
18637	25088	625	,	,	,
18637	25088	626	1161	1161	CD
18637	25088	627	Stockyards	Stockyards	NNP
18637	25088	628	,	,	,
18637	25088	629	State	State	NNP
18637	25088	630	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25088	631	of	of	IN
18637	25088	632	charges	charge	NNS
18637	25088	633	by	by	IN
18637	25088	634	,	,	,
18637	25088	635	996	996	CD
18637	25088	636	Succession	succession	NN
18637	25088	637	to	to	IN
18637	25088	638	Property	Property	NNP
18637	25088	639	,	,	,
18637	25088	640	right	right	NN
18637	25088	641	of	of	IN
18637	25088	642	election	election	NN
18637	25088	643	to	to	IN
18637	25088	644	surviving	survive	VBG
18637	25088	645	spouse	spouse	NN
18637	25088	646	,	,	,
18637	25088	647	effect	effect	NN
18637	25088	648	of	of	IN
18637	25088	649	creation	creation	NN
18637	25088	650	,	,	,
18637	25088	651	1033	1033	CD
18637	25088	652	Suffrage	suffrage	CD
18637	25088	653	.	.	.
18637	25089	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25089	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25089	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25089	4	Elections	Elections	NNPS
18637	25089	5	.	.	.
18637	25090	1	Sunday	Sunday	NNP
18637	25090	2	Blue	Blue	NNP
18637	25090	3	Laws	Laws	NNPS
18637	25090	4	,	,	,
18637	25090	5	1031	1031	CD
18637	25090	6	,	,	,
18637	25090	7	1154	1154	CD
18637	25090	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
18637	25090	9	Court	Court	NNP
18637	25090	10	of	of	IN
18637	25090	11	the	the	DT
18637	25090	12	United	United	NNP
18637	25090	13	States	States	NNP
18637	25090	14	:	:	:
18637	25090	15	Appellate	appellate	VB
18637	25090	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	25090	17	,	,	,
18637	25090	18	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	25090	19	of	of	IN
18637	25090	20	,	,	,
18637	25090	21	by	by	IN
18637	25090	22	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25090	23	,	,	,
18637	25090	24	614	614	CD
18637	25090	25	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	26	615	615	CD
18637	25090	27	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	25090	28	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	25090	29	,	,	,
18637	25090	30	presides	preside	NNS
18637	25090	31	at	at	IN
18637	25090	32	President	President	NNP
18637	25090	33	's	's	POS
18637	25090	34	impeachment	impeachment	NN
18637	25090	35	trial	trial	NN
18637	25090	36	,	,	,
18637	25090	37	91	91	CD
18637	25090	38	Concurrent	concurrent	JJ
18637	25090	39	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	25090	40	with	with	IN
18637	25090	41	lower	low	JJR
18637	25090	42	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25090	43	courts	court	NNS
18637	25090	44	,	,	,
18637	25090	45	613	613	CD
18637	25090	46	Full	full	JJ
18637	25090	47	faith	faith	NN
18637	25090	48	and	and	CC
18637	25090	49	credit	credit	NN
18637	25090	50	clause	clause	NN
18637	25090	51	,	,	,
18637	25090	52	application	application	NN
18637	25090	53	by	by	IN
18637	25090	54	,	,	,
18637	25090	55	682	682	CD
18637	25090	56	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	57	685	685	CD
18637	25090	58	Legislative	legislative	JJ
18637	25090	59	courts	court	NNS
18637	25090	60	,	,	,
18637	25090	61	appellate	appellate	VB
18637	25090	62	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	25090	63	over	over	RB
18637	25090	64	,	,	,
18637	25090	65	536	536	CD
18637	25090	66	Original	original	JJ
18637	25090	67	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	25090	68	,	,	,
18637	25090	69	571	571	CD
18637	25090	70	,	,	,
18637	25090	71	591	591	CD
18637	25090	72	-	-	HYPH
18637	25090	73	595	595	CD
18637	25090	74	,	,	,
18637	25090	75	611	611	CD
18637	25090	76	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	77	613	613	CD
18637	25090	78	Protection	Protection	NNP
18637	25090	79	of	of	IN
18637	25090	80	,	,	,
18637	25090	81	against	against	IN
18637	25090	82	noises	noise	NNS
18637	25090	83	,	,	,
18637	25090	84	banners	banner	NNS
18637	25090	85	,	,	,
18637	25090	86	etc	etc	FW
18637	25090	87	.	.	.
18637	25090	88	,	,	,
18637	25090	89	792	792	CD
18637	25090	90	Rule	Rule	NNP
18637	25090	91	-	-	HYPH
18637	25090	92	making	make	VBG
18637	25090	93	authority	authority	NN
18637	25090	94	,	,	,
18637	25090	95	derivation	derivation	NN
18637	25090	96	,	,	,
18637	25090	97	etc	etc	FW
18637	25090	98	.	.	FW
18637	25090	99	,	,	,
18637	25090	100	608	608	CD
18637	25090	101	Size	size	NN
18637	25090	102	,	,	,
18637	25090	103	internal	internal	JJ
18637	25090	104	organization	organization	NN
18637	25090	105	,	,	,
18637	25090	106	sessions	session	NNS
18637	25090	107	,	,	,
18637	25090	108	etc	etc	FW
18637	25090	109	.	.	FW
18637	25090	110	,	,	,
18637	25090	111	528	528	CD
18637	25090	112	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	113	529	529	CD
18637	25090	114	State	State	NNP
18637	25090	115	court	court	NN
18637	25090	116	decisions	decision	NNS
18637	25090	117	,	,	,
18637	25090	118	review	review	NN
18637	25090	119	by	by	IN
18637	25090	120	,	,	,
18637	25090	121	570	570	CD
18637	25090	122	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	123	571	571	CD
18637	25090	124	State	state	NN
18637	25090	125	procedure	procedure	NN
18637	25090	126	,	,	,
18637	25090	127	scope	scope	NN
18637	25090	128	of	of	IN
18637	25090	129	review	review	NN
18637	25090	130	by	by	IN
18637	25090	131	,	,	,
18637	25090	132	1140	1140	CD
18637	25090	133	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	134	1141	1141	CD
18637	25090	135	State	State	NNP
18637	25090	136	's	's	POS
18637	25090	137	corrective	corrective	JJ
18637	25090	138	process	process	NN
18637	25090	139	in	in	IN
18637	25090	140	criminal	criminal	JJ
18637	25090	141	trials	trial	NNS
18637	25090	142	,	,	,
18637	25090	143	review	review	NN
18637	25090	144	of	of	IN
18637	25090	145	adequacy	adequacy	NN
18637	25090	146	,	,	,
18637	25090	147	by	by	IN
18637	25090	148	,	,	,
18637	25090	149	1138	1138	CD
18637	25090	150	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	151	1139	1139	CD
18637	25090	152	T	T	NNP
18637	25090	153	Tariffs	Tariffs	NNPS
18637	25090	154	,	,	,
18637	25090	155	as	as	IN
18637	25090	156	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25090	157	of	of	IN
18637	25090	158	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	25090	159	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	25090	160	,	,	,
18637	25090	161	162	162	CD
18637	25090	162	Taxation	taxation	NN
18637	25090	163	:	:	:
18637	25090	164	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25090	165	:	:	:
18637	25090	166	Capital	capital	NN
18637	25090	167	gains	gain	NNS
18637	25090	168	,	,	,
18637	25090	169	computing	compute	VBG
18637	25090	170	income	income	NN
18637	25090	171	tax	tax	NN
18637	25090	172	on	on	IN
18637	25090	173	,	,	,
18637	25090	174	1197	1197	CD
18637	25090	175	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	176	1200	1200	CD
18637	25090	177	Cooperatives	Cooperatives	NNPS
18637	25090	178	,	,	,
18637	25090	179	unincorporated	unincorporate	VBN
18637	25090	180	joint	joint	JJ
18637	25090	181	stock	stock	NN
18637	25090	182	associations	association	NNS
18637	25090	183	,	,	,
18637	25090	184	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	25090	185	,	,	,
18637	25090	186	1196	1196	CD
18637	25090	187	Corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	25090	188	dividends	dividend	NNS
18637	25090	189	,	,	,
18637	25090	190	when	when	WRB
18637	25090	191	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	25090	192	as	as	IN
18637	25090	193	income	income	NN
18637	25090	194	,	,	,
18637	25090	195	1193	1193	CD
18637	25090	196	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	197	1195	1195	CD
18637	25090	198	Corporate	corporate	JJ
18637	25090	199	earnings	earning	NNS
18637	25090	200	,	,	,
18637	25090	201	undistributed	undistributed	JJ
18637	25090	202	,	,	,
18637	25090	203	etc	etc	FW
18637	25090	204	.	.	FW
18637	25090	205	,	,	,
18637	25090	206	when	when	WRB
18637	25090	207	taxable	taxable	JJ
18637	25090	208	as	as	IN
18637	25090	209	income	income	NN
18637	25090	210	,	,	,
18637	25090	211	1195	1195	CD
18637	25090	212	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	213	1197	1197	CD
18637	25090	214	Customs	Customs	NNP
18637	25090	215	,	,	,
18637	25090	216	import	import	NN
18637	25090	217	duties	duty	NNS
18637	25090	218	,	,	,
18637	25090	219	319	319	CD
18637	25090	220	Direct	direct	JJ
18637	25090	221	,	,	,
18637	25090	222	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	25090	223	,	,	,
18637	25090	224	defined	define	VBN
18637	25090	225	,	,	,
18637	25090	226	89	89	CD
18637	25090	227	,	,	,
18637	25090	228	105	105	CD
18637	25090	229	,	,	,
18637	25090	230	317	317	CD
18637	25090	231	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	232	319	319	CD
18637	25090	233	,	,	,
18637	25090	234	321	321	CD
18637	25090	235	Discriminatory	Discriminatory	NNP
18637	25090	236	,	,	,
18637	25090	237	retroactive	retroactive	JJ
18637	25090	238	,	,	,
18637	25090	239	etc	etc	FW
18637	25090	240	.	.	FW
18637	25090	241	,	,	,
18637	25090	242	due	due	JJ
18637	25090	243	process	process	NN
18637	25090	244	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	25090	245	,	,	,
18637	25090	246	862	862	CD
18637	25090	247	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	248	864	864	CD
18637	25090	249	in	in	IN
18637	25090	250	District	District	NNP
18637	25090	251	of	of	IN
18637	25090	252	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	25090	253	,	,	,
18637	25090	254	303	303	CD
18637	25090	255	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	256	304	304	CD
18637	25090	257	,	,	,
18637	25090	258	321	321	CD
18637	25090	259	Excises	Excises	NNPS
18637	25090	260	,	,	,
18637	25090	261	defined	define	VBN
18637	25090	262	,	,	,
18637	25090	263	318	318	CD
18637	25090	264	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	265	321	321	CD
18637	25090	266	,	,	,
18637	25090	267	1191	1191	CD
18637	25090	268	Exports	export	NNS
18637	25090	269	,	,	,
18637	25090	270	exempt	exempt	JJ
18637	25090	271	from	from	IN
18637	25090	272	,	,	,
18637	25090	273	105	105	CD
18637	25090	274	,	,	,
18637	25090	275	321	321	CD
18637	25090	276	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	277	322	322	CD
18637	25090	278	Extermination	extermination	NN
18637	25090	279	by	by	IN
18637	25090	280	,	,	,
18637	25090	281	111	111	CD
18637	25090	282	Forbidden	forbidden	JJ
18637	25090	283	subjects	subject	NNS
18637	25090	284	,	,	,
18637	25090	285	105	105	CD
18637	25090	286	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	287	109	109	CD
18637	25090	288	Income	Income	NNP
18637	25090	289	,	,	,
18637	25090	290	allowable	allowable	JJ
18637	25090	291	deductions	deduction	NNS
18637	25090	292	,	,	,
18637	25090	293	exemptions	exemption	NNS
18637	25090	294	,	,	,
18637	25090	295	losses	loss	NNS
18637	25090	296	,	,	,
18637	25090	297	etc	etc	FW
18637	25090	298	.	.	.
18637	25090	299	,	,	,
18637	25090	300	1198	1198	CD
18637	25090	301	,	,	,
18637	25090	302	1200	1200	CD
18637	25090	303	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	304	1201	1201	CD
18637	25090	305	Income	Income	NNP
18637	25090	306	,	,	,
18637	25090	307	as	as	IN
18637	25090	308	direct	direct	JJ
18637	25090	309	,	,	,
18637	25090	310	or	or	CC
18637	25090	311	excise	excise	VB
18637	25090	312	,	,	,
18637	25090	313	tax	tax	NN
18637	25090	314	,	,	,
18637	25090	315	319	319	CD
18637	25090	316	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	317	321	321	CD
18637	25090	318	,	,	,
18637	25090	319	1191	1191	CD
18637	25090	320	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	321	1192	1192	CD
18637	25090	322	Income	Income	NNP
18637	25090	323	,	,	,
18637	25090	324	due	due	JJ
18637	25090	325	process	process	NN
18637	25090	326	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	25090	327	,	,	,
18637	25090	328	862	862	CD
18637	25090	329	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	330	863	863	CD
18637	25090	331	Income	income	NN
18637	25090	332	tax	tax	NN
18637	25090	333	,	,	,
18637	25090	334	power	power	NN
18637	25090	335	of	of	IN
18637	25090	336	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25090	337	to	to	TO
18637	25090	338	levy	levy	VB
18637	25090	339	,	,	,
18637	25090	340	1191	1191	CD
18637	25090	341	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	342	1201	1201	CD
18637	25090	343	Inheritance	Inheritance	NNP
18637	25090	344	tax	tax	NN
18637	25090	345	,	,	,
18637	25090	346	1192	1192	CD
18637	25090	347	Levy	Levy	NNP
18637	25090	348	as	as	IN
18637	25090	349	penalty	penalty	NN
18637	25090	350	to	to	TO
18637	25090	351	enforce	enforce	VB
18637	25090	352	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25090	353	,	,	,
18637	25090	354	State	State	NNP
18637	25090	355	laws	law	NNS
18637	25090	356	,	,	,
18637	25090	357	1196	1196	CD
18637	25090	358	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	359	1197	1197	CD
18637	25090	360	,	,	,
18637	25090	361	1214	1214	CD
18637	25090	362	License	license	NN
18637	25090	363	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	25090	364	,	,	,
18637	25090	365	110	110	CD
18637	25090	366	Power	power	NN
18637	25090	367	of	of	IN
18637	25090	368	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25090	369	to	to	TO
18637	25090	370	levy	levy	VB
18637	25090	371	,	,	,
18637	25090	372	105	105	CD
18637	25090	373	,	,	,
18637	25090	374	110	110	CD
18637	25090	375	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	376	117	117	CD
18637	25090	377	Preferences	preference	NNS
18637	25090	378	to	to	IN
18637	25090	379	ports	port	NNS
18637	25090	380	of	of	IN
18637	25090	381	one	one	CD
18637	25090	382	State	state	NN
18637	25090	383	,	,	,
18637	25090	384	duties	duty	NNS
18637	25090	385	on	on	IN
18637	25090	386	outbound	outbound	JJ
18637	25090	387	vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	25090	388	,	,	,
18637	25090	389	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
18637	25090	390	,	,	,
18637	25090	391	322	322	CD
18637	25090	392	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	393	323	323	CD
18637	25090	394	Regulation	Regulation	NNP
18637	25090	395	by	by	IN
18637	25090	396	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	25090	397	,	,	,
18637	25090	398	110	110	CD
18637	25090	399	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	400	112	112	CD
18637	25090	401	on	on	IN
18637	25090	402	Rental	rental	JJ
18637	25090	403	value	value	NN
18637	25090	404	,	,	,
18637	25090	405	when	when	WRB
18637	25090	406	a	a	DT
18637	25090	407	direct	direct	JJ
18637	25090	408	,	,	,
18637	25090	409	or	or	CC
18637	25090	410	income	income	NN
18637	25090	411	,	,	,
18637	25090	412	tax	tax	NN
18637	25090	413	,	,	,
18637	25090	414	1200	1200	CD
18637	25090	415	Reserved	reserved	JJ
18637	25090	416	powers	power	NNS
18637	25090	417	of	of	IN
18637	25090	418	States	state	NNS
18637	25090	419	,	,	,
18637	25090	420	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	25090	421	by	by	IN
18637	25090	422	,	,	,
18637	25090	423	109	109	CD
18637	25090	424	,	,	,
18637	25090	425	916	916	CD
18637	25090	426	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	427	919	919	CD
18637	25090	428	,	,	,
18637	25090	429	921	921	CD
18637	25090	430	Revenue	revenue	NN
18637	25090	431	bills	bill	NNS
18637	25090	432	,	,	,
18637	25090	433	originate	originate	VBP
18637	25090	434	in	in	IN
18637	25090	435	House	House	NNP
18637	25090	436	of	of	IN
18637	25090	437	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
18637	25090	438	,	,	,
18637	25090	439	101	101	CD
18637	25090	440	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	441	102	102	CD
18637	25090	442	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	25090	443	to	to	TO
18637	25090	444	recover	recover	VB
18637	25090	445	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	25090	446	,	,	,
18637	25090	447	alteration	alteration	NN
18637	25090	448	of	of	IN
18637	25090	449	right	right	NN
18637	25090	450	,	,	,
18637	25090	451	858	858	CD
18637	25090	452	Tariffs	tariff	NNS
18637	25090	453	,	,	,
18637	25090	454	protective	protective	JJ
18637	25090	455	,	,	,
18637	25090	456	112	112	CD
18637	25090	457	Uniformity	Uniformity	NNP
18637	25090	458	of	of	IN
18637	25090	459	duties	duty	NNS
18637	25090	460	,	,	,
18637	25090	461	imports	import	NNS
18637	25090	462	,	,	,
18637	25090	463	excises	excise	NNS
18637	25090	464	,	,	,
18637	25090	465	105	105	CD
18637	25090	466	,	,	,
18637	25090	467	109	109	CD
18637	25090	468	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	469	110	110	CD
18637	25090	470	of	of	IN
18637	25090	471	Unlawful	unlawful	JJ
18637	25090	472	articles	article	NNS
18637	25090	473	,	,	,
18637	25090	474	1201	1201	CD
18637	25090	475	,	,	,
18637	25090	476	1214	1214	CD
18637	25090	477	State	state	NN
18637	25090	478	:	:	:
18637	25090	479	Airplanes	airplane	NNS
18637	25090	480	operated	operate	VBN
18637	25090	481	in	in	IN
18637	25090	482	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	25090	483	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	25090	484	,	,	,
18637	25090	485	210	210	CD
18637	25090	486	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	487	211	211	CD
18637	25090	488	,	,	,
18637	25090	489	1052	1052	CD
18637	25090	490	Banks	bank	NNS
18637	25090	491	,	,	,
18637	25090	492	1147	1147	CD
18637	25090	493	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	494	1148	1148	CD
18637	25090	495	Businesses	business	NNS
18637	25090	496	selling	sell	VBG
18637	25090	497	goods	good	NNS
18637	25090	498	of	of	IN
18637	25090	499	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	25090	500	origin	origin	NN
18637	25090	501	,	,	,
18637	25090	502	186	186	CD
18637	25090	503	-	-	HYPH
18637	25090	504	192	192	CD
18637	25090	505	Carriers	Carriers	NNPS
18637	25090	506	operated	operate	VBN
18637	25090	507	in	in	IN
18637	25090	508	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	25090	509	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	25090	510	,	,	,
18637	25090	511	179	179	CD
18637	25090	512	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	513	180	180	CD
18637	25090	514	,	,	,
18637	25090	515	192	192	CD
18637	25090	516	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	517	193	193	CD
18637	25090	518	,	,	,
18637	25090	519	197	197	CD
18637	25090	520	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	521	203	203	CD
18637	25090	522	,	,	,
18637	25090	523	206	206	CD
18637	25090	524	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	525	213	213	CD
18637	25090	526	Collection	Collection	NNP
18637	25090	527	by	by	IN
18637	25090	528	bailees	bailee	NNS
18637	25090	529	,	,	,
18637	25090	530	employers	employer	NNS
18637	25090	531	,	,	,
18637	25090	532	retailers	retailer	NNS
18637	25090	533	,	,	,
18637	25090	534	safe	safe	JJ
18637	25090	535	deposit	deposit	NN
18637	25090	536	companies	company	NNS
18637	25090	537	,	,	,
18637	25090	538	validity	validity	NN
18637	25090	539	,	,	,
18637	25090	540	1061	1061	CD
18637	25090	541	Collection	Collection	NNP
18637	25090	542	,	,	,
18637	25090	543	levy	levy	NN
18637	25090	544	of	of	IN
18637	25090	545	,	,	,
18637	25090	546	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	25090	547	due	due	JJ
18637	25090	548	process	process	NN
18637	25090	549	in	in	IN
18637	25090	550	,	,	,
18637	25090	551	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	25090	552	,	,	,
18637	25090	553	etc	etc	FW
18637	25090	554	.	.	.
18637	25090	555	,	,	,
18637	25090	556	1039	1039	CD
18637	25090	557	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	558	1062	1062	CD
18637	25090	559	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	25090	560	clause	clause	NN
18637	25090	561	as	as	IN
18637	25090	562	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	25090	563	on	on	IN
18637	25090	564	,	,	,
18637	25090	565	177	177	CD
18637	25090	566	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	567	214	214	CD
18637	25090	568	Companies	company	NNS
18637	25090	569	engaged	engage	VBN
18637	25090	570	in	in	IN
18637	25090	571	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	25090	572	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	25090	573	,	,	,
18637	25090	574	gross	gross	JJ
18637	25090	575	receipts	receipt	NNS
18637	25090	576	,	,	,
18637	25090	577	income	income	NN
18637	25090	578	,	,	,
18637	25090	579	franchise	franchise	NN
18637	25090	580	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	25090	581	,	,	,
18637	25090	582	etc	etc	FW
18637	25090	583	.	.	.
18637	25090	584	,	,	,
18637	25090	585	179	179	CD
18637	25090	586	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	587	180	180	CD
18637	25090	588	,	,	,
18637	25090	589	186	186	CD
18637	25090	590	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	591	198	198	CD
18637	25090	592	,	,	,
18637	25090	593	202	202	CD
18637	25090	594	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	595	215	215	CD
18637	25090	596	Considerations	consideration	NNS
18637	25090	597	as	as	IN
18637	25090	598	to	to	IN
18637	25090	599	validity	validity	NN
18637	25090	600	;	;	:
18637	25090	601	public	public	JJ
18637	25090	602	purpose	purpose	NN
18637	25090	603	,	,	,
18637	25090	604	severity	severity	NN
18637	25090	605	,	,	,
18637	25090	606	benefit	benefit	NN
18637	25090	607	,	,	,
18637	25090	608	1036	1036	CD
18637	25090	609	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	610	1037	1037	CD
18637	25090	611	,	,	,
18637	25090	612	1041	1041	CD
18637	25090	613	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	614	1043	1043	CD
18637	25090	615	Copyright	Copyright	NNP
18637	25090	616	royalties	royalty	NNS
18637	25090	617	,	,	,
18637	25090	618	734	734	CD
18637	25090	619	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	25090	620	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	25090	621	in	in	IN
18637	25090	622	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	25090	623	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	25090	624	,	,	,
18637	25090	625	193	193	CD
18637	25090	626	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	627	204	204	CD
18637	25090	628	,	,	,
18637	25090	629	206	206	CD
18637	25090	630	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	631	215	215	CD
18637	25090	632	,	,	,
18637	25090	633	1040	1040	CD
18637	25090	634	,	,	,
18637	25090	635	1049	1049	CD
18637	25090	636	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	637	1053	1053	CD
18637	25090	638	,	,	,
18637	25090	639	1148	1148	CD
18637	25090	640	,	,	,
18637	25090	641	1151	1151	CD
18637	25090	642	,	,	,
18637	25090	643	1153	1153	CD
18637	25090	644	Due	due	JJ
18637	25090	645	process	process	NN
18637	25090	646	clause	clause	NN
18637	25090	647	as	as	IN
18637	25090	648	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	25090	649	on	on	IN
18637	25090	650	,	,	,
18637	25090	651	1036	1036	CD
18637	25090	652	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	653	1062	1062	CD
18637	25090	654	Equal	equal	JJ
18637	25090	655	protection	protection	NN
18637	25090	656	clause	clause	NN
18637	25090	657	as	as	IN
18637	25090	658	limitation	limitation	NN
18637	25090	659	on	on	IN
18637	25090	660	,	,	,
18637	25090	661	1146	1146	CD
18637	25090	662	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	663	1153	1153	CD
18637	25090	664	Equitable	equitable	JJ
18637	25090	665	interest	interest	NN
18637	25090	666	of	of	IN
18637	25090	667	purchaser	purchaser	NN
18637	25090	668	of	of	IN
18637	25090	669	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25090	670	property	property	NN
18637	25090	671	,	,	,
18637	25090	672	306	306	CD
18637	25090	673	Exemption	Exemption	NNP
18637	25090	674	,	,	,
18637	25090	675	as	as	IN
18637	25090	676	a	a	DT
18637	25090	677	contract	contract	NN
18637	25090	678	protected	protect	VBD
18637	25090	679	against	against	IN
18637	25090	680	impairment	impairment	NN
18637	25090	681	,	,	,
18637	25090	682	341	341	CD
18637	25090	683	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	684	343	343	CD
18637	25090	685	,	,	,
18637	25090	686	347	347	CD
18637	25090	687	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	688	348	348	CD
18637	25090	689	,	,	,
18637	25090	690	350	350	CD
18637	25090	691	Exports	export	NNS
18637	25090	692	,	,	,
18637	25090	693	imports	import	NNS
18637	25090	694	,	,	,
18637	25090	695	when	when	WRB
18637	25090	696	valid	valid	JJ
18637	25090	697	,	,	,
18637	25090	698	362	362	CD
18637	25090	699	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	700	365	365	CD
18637	25090	701	of	of	IN
18637	25090	702	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25090	703	contractors	contractor	NNS
18637	25090	704	,	,	,
18637	25090	705	730	730	CD
18637	25090	706	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	707	732	732	CD
18637	25090	708	of	of	IN
18637	25090	709	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25090	710	instrumentalities	instrumentality	NNS
18637	25090	711	,	,	,
18637	25090	712	functions	function	NNS
18637	25090	713	,	,	,
18637	25090	714	securities	security	NNS
18637	25090	715	,	,	,
18637	25090	716	etc	etc	FW
18637	25090	717	.	.	FW
18637	25090	718	,	,	,
18637	25090	719	728	728	CD
18637	25090	720	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	721	737	737	CD
18637	25090	722	Federally	federally	RB
18637	25090	723	chartered	charter	VBN
18637	25090	724	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	25090	725	,	,	,
18637	25090	726	property	property	NN
18637	25090	727	of	of	IN
18637	25090	728	,	,	,
18637	25090	729	732	732	CD
18637	25090	730	Goods	good	NNS
18637	25090	731	in	in	IN
18637	25090	732	interstate	interstate	JJ
18637	25090	733	transit	transit	NN
18637	25090	734	,	,	,
18637	25090	735	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	25090	736	,	,	,
18637	25090	737	179	179	CD
18637	25090	738	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	739	183	183	CD
18637	25090	740	Income	Income	NNP
18637	25090	741	,	,	,
18637	25090	742	due	due	JJ
18637	25090	743	process	process	NN
18637	25090	744	,	,	,
18637	25090	745	equal	equal	JJ
18637	25090	746	protection	protection	NN
18637	25090	747	clause	clause	NN
18637	25090	748	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	25090	749	on	on	IN
18637	25090	750	;	;	:
18637	25090	751	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	25090	752	;	;	:
18637	25090	753	collection	collection	NN
18637	25090	754	by	by	IN
18637	25090	755	withholding	withholding	NN
18637	25090	756	,	,	,
18637	25090	757	etc	etc	FW
18637	25090	758	.	.	.
18637	25090	759	,	,	,
18637	25090	760	1039	1039	CD
18637	25090	761	,	,	,
18637	25090	762	1053	1053	CD
18637	25090	763	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	764	1055	1055	CD
18637	25090	765	,	,	,
18637	25090	766	1061	1061	CD
18637	25090	767	,	,	,
18637	25090	768	1150	1150	CD
18637	25090	769	Inheritance	Inheritance	NNP
18637	25090	770	,	,	,
18637	25090	771	estate	estate	NN
18637	25090	772	,	,	,
18637	25090	773	gift	gift	NN
18637	25090	774	;	;	:
18637	25090	775	due	due	JJ
18637	25090	776	process	process	NN
18637	25090	777	,	,	,
18637	25090	778	equal	equal	JJ
18637	25090	779	protection	protection	NN
18637	25090	780	clause	clause	NN
18637	25090	781	,	,	,
18637	25090	782	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	25090	783	on	on	IN
18637	25090	784	,	,	,
18637	25090	785	1037	1037	CD
18637	25090	786	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	787	1039	1039	CD
18637	25090	788	,	,	,
18637	25090	789	1045	1045	CD
18637	25090	790	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	791	1049	1049	CD
18637	25090	792	,	,	,
18637	25090	793	1061	1061	CD
18637	25090	794	,	,	,
18637	25090	795	1150	1150	CD
18637	25090	796	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	797	1151	1151	CD
18637	25090	798	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	25090	799	companies	company	NNS
18637	25090	800	;	;	:
18637	25090	801	due	due	JJ
18637	25090	802	process	process	NN
18637	25090	803	,	,	,
18637	25090	804	equal	equal	JJ
18637	25090	805	protection	protection	NN
18637	25090	806	clause	clause	NN
18637	25090	807	,	,	,
18637	25090	808	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	25090	809	on	on	RB
18637	25090	810	,	,	,
18637	25090	811	etc	etc	FW
18637	25090	812	.	.	.
18637	25090	813	,	,	,
18637	25090	814	1055	1055	CD
18637	25090	815	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	816	1056	1056	CD
18637	25090	817	,	,	,
18637	25090	818	1062	1062	CD
18637	25090	819	,	,	,
18637	25090	820	1148	1148	CD
18637	25090	821	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	822	1150	1150	CD
18637	25090	823	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
18637	25090	824	companies	company	NNS
18637	25090	825	engaged	engage	VBD
18637	25090	826	in	in	IN
18637	25090	827	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	25090	828	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	25090	829	,	,	,
18637	25090	830	214	214	CD
18637	25090	831	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	832	215	215	CD
18637	25090	833	Lessees	lessee	NNS
18637	25090	834	of	of	IN
18637	25090	835	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	25090	836	lands	land	NNS
18637	25090	837	,	,	,
18637	25090	838	validity	validity	NN
18637	25090	839	,	,	,
18637	25090	840	735	735	CD
18637	25090	841	Motor	Motor	NNP
18637	25090	842	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
18637	25090	843	,	,	,
18637	25090	844	211	211	CD
18637	25090	845	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	846	213	213	CD
18637	25090	847	,	,	,
18637	25090	848	1151	1151	CD
18637	25090	849	Multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	25090	850	,	,	,
18637	25090	851	1041	1041	CD
18637	25090	852	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	853	1056	1056	CD
18637	25090	854	Multiple	multiple	JJ
18637	25090	855	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	25090	856	test	test	NN
18637	25090	857	applied	apply	VBN
18637	25090	858	to	to	IN
18637	25090	859	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	25090	860	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	25090	861	,	,	,
18637	25090	862	204	204	CD
18637	25090	863	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	864	208	208	CD
18637	25090	865	,	,	,
18637	25090	866	1052	1052	CD
18637	25090	867	Nonresident	Nonresident	NNP
18637	25090	868	,	,	,
18637	25090	869	scope	scope	NN
18637	25090	870	for	for	IN
18637	25090	871	discrimination	discrimination	NN
18637	25090	872	,	,	,
18637	25090	873	692	692	CD
18637	25090	874	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	875	693	693	CD
18637	25090	876	Oleomargarine	Oleomargarine	NNP
18637	25090	877	,	,	,
18637	25090	878	1148	1148	CD
18637	25090	879	Preference	preference	NN
18637	25090	880	of	of	IN
18637	25090	881	ports	port	NNS
18637	25090	882	,	,	,
18637	25090	883	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	25090	884	on	on	IN
18637	25090	885	,	,	,
18637	25090	886	inapplicable	inapplicable	JJ
18637	25090	887	,	,	,
18637	25090	888	322	322	CD
18637	25090	889	Property	Property	NNP
18637	25090	890	employed	employ	VBN
18637	25090	891	in	in	IN
18637	25090	892	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	25090	893	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	25090	894	,	,	,
18637	25090	895	apportionment	apportionment	NN
18637	25090	896	,	,	,
18637	25090	897	198	198	CD
18637	25090	898	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	899	212	212	CD
18637	25090	900	Public	public	JJ
18637	25090	901	utilities	utility	NNS
18637	25090	902	,	,	,
18637	25090	903	213	213	CD
18637	25090	904	,	,	,
18637	25090	905	1039	1039	CD
18637	25090	906	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	907	1040	1040	CD
18637	25090	908	,	,	,
18637	25090	909	1050	1050	CD
18637	25090	910	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	911	1053	1053	CD
18637	25090	912	,	,	,
18637	25090	913	1148	1148	CD
18637	25090	914	,	,	,
18637	25090	915	1151	1151	CD
18637	25090	916	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	917	1153	1153	CD
18637	25090	918	Railroads	railroad	NNS
18637	25090	919	,	,	,
18637	25090	920	1052	1052	CD
18637	25090	921	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	922	1053	1053	CD
18637	25090	923	Real	real	JJ
18637	25090	924	property	property	NN
18637	25090	925	,	,	,
18637	25090	926	due	due	JJ
18637	25090	927	process	process	NN
18637	25090	928	,	,	,
18637	25090	929	equal	equal	JJ
18637	25090	930	protection	protection	NN
18637	25090	931	clause	clause	NN
18637	25090	932	,	,	,
18637	25090	933	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	25090	934	on	on	IN
18637	25090	935	assessment	assessment	NN
18637	25090	936	and	and	CC
18637	25090	937	collection	collection	NN
18637	25090	938	,	,	,
18637	25090	939	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	25090	940	,	,	,
18637	25090	941	etc	etc	FW
18637	25090	942	.	.	.
18637	25090	943	,	,	,
18637	25090	944	1039	1039	CD
18637	25090	945	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	946	1041	1041	CD
18637	25090	947	,	,	,
18637	25090	948	1057	1057	CD
18637	25090	949	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	950	1062	1062	CD
18637	25090	951	,	,	,
18637	25090	952	1152	1152	CD
18637	25090	953	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	954	1153	1153	CD
18637	25090	955	Sales	sale	NNS
18637	25090	956	and	and	CC
18637	25090	957	use	use	VB
18637	25090	958	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	25090	959	,	,	,
18637	25090	960	application	application	NN
18637	25090	961	to	to	IN
18637	25090	962	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	25090	963	commerce	commerce	NN
18637	25090	964	,	,	,
18637	25090	965	184	184	CD
18637	25090	966	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	967	192	192	CD
18637	25090	968	Severance	severance	NN
18637	25090	969	,	,	,
18637	25090	970	due	due	JJ
18637	25090	971	process	process	NN
18637	25090	972	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	25090	973	,	,	,
18637	25090	974	1039	1039	CD
18637	25090	975	Special	special	JJ
18637	25090	976	assessments	assessment	NNS
18637	25090	977	,	,	,
18637	25090	978	due	due	JJ
18637	25090	979	process	process	NN
18637	25090	980	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	25090	981	on	on	IN
18637	25090	982	,	,	,
18637	25090	983	1040	1040	CD
18637	25090	984	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	985	1041	1041	CD
18637	25090	986	Suits	Suits	NNPS
18637	25090	987	to	to	TO
18637	25090	988	recover	recover	VB
18637	25090	989	,	,	,
18637	25090	990	when	when	WRB
18637	25090	991	within	within	IN
18637	25090	992	State	state	NN
18637	25090	993	immunity	immunity	NN
18637	25090	994	from	from	IN
18637	25090	995	suit	suit	NN
18637	25090	996	,	,	,
18637	25090	997	935	935	CD
18637	25090	998	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	999	936	936	CD
18637	25090	1000	Tangible	tangible	JJ
18637	25090	1001	,	,	,
18637	25090	1002	intangible	intangible	JJ
18637	25090	1003	personalty	personalty	NN
18637	25090	1004	,	,	,
18637	25090	1005	due	due	JJ
18637	25090	1006	process	process	NN
18637	25090	1007	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	25090	1008	on	on	IN
18637	25090	1009	,	,	,
18637	25090	1010	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	25090	1011	,	,	,
18637	25090	1012	1041	1041	CD
18637	25090	1013	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	1014	1053	1053	CD
18637	25090	1015	Tonnage	tonnage	NN
18637	25090	1016	duties	duty	NNS
18637	25090	1017	,	,	,
18637	25090	1018	restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	25090	1019	on	on	IN
18637	25090	1020	,	,	,
18637	25090	1021	365	365	CD
18637	25090	1022	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	1023	366	366	CD
18637	25090	1024	Trusts	Trusts	NNPS
18637	25090	1025	,	,	,
18637	25090	1026	and	and	CC
18637	25090	1027	beneficiaries	beneficiary	NNS
18637	25090	1028	of	of	IN
18637	25090	1029	,	,	,
18637	25090	1030	due	due	JJ
18637	25090	1031	process	process	NN
18637	25090	1032	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	25090	1033	on	on	IN
18637	25090	1034	,	,	,
18637	25090	1035	1044	1044	CD
18637	25090	1036	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	1037	1049	1049	CD
18637	25090	1038	,	,	,
18637	25090	1039	1053	1053	CD
18637	25090	1040	Vessels	vessel	NNS
18637	25090	1041	operated	operate	VBN
18637	25090	1042	in	in	IN
18637	25090	1043	interstate	interstate	NNP
18637	25090	1044	commerce	commerce	NNP
18637	25090	1045	,	,	,
18637	25090	1046	209	209	CD
18637	25090	1047	-	-	SYM
18637	25090	1048	210	210	CD
18637	25090	1049	Teachers	teacher	NNS
18637	25090	1050	.	.	.
18637	25091	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25091	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25091	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25091	4	States	States	NNPS
18637	25091	5	:	:	:
18637	25091	6	Officers	officer	NNS
18637	25091	7	.	.	.
18637	25092	1	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
18637	25092	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25092	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25092	4	see	see	VBP
18637	25092	5	also	also	RB
18637	25092	6	_	_	NNP
18637	25092	7	Public	Public	NNP
18637	25092	8	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	25092	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25092	10	:	:	:
18637	25092	11	State	state	NN
18637	25092	12	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25092	13	of	of	IN
18637	25092	14	,	,	,
18637	25092	15	231	231	CD
18637	25092	16	-	-	SYM
18637	25092	17	232	232	CD
18637	25092	18	Territories	Territories	NNPS
18637	25092	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25092	20	_	_	NNP
18637	25092	21	see	see	VB
18637	25092	22	also	also	RB
18637	25092	23	_	_	NNP
18637	25092	24	Citizenship	Citizenship	NNP
18637	25092	25	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25092	26	:	:	:
18637	25092	27	Acquisition	acquisition	NN
18637	25092	28	by	by	IN
18637	25092	29	conquest	conquest	NN
18637	25092	30	,	,	,
18637	25092	31	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	25092	32	of	of	IN
18637	25092	33	,	,	,
18637	25092	34	403	403	CD
18637	25092	35	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25092	36	,	,	,
18637	25092	37	powers	power	NNS
18637	25092	38	as	as	IN
18637	25092	39	to	to	IN
18637	25092	40	,	,	,
18637	25092	41	703	703	CD
18637	25092	42	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	25092	43	guaranties	guaranty	NNS
18637	25092	44	,	,	,
18637	25092	45	application	application	NN
18637	25092	46	to	to	IN
18637	25092	47	,	,	,
18637	25092	48	703	703	CD
18637	25092	49	Courts	Courts	NNPS
18637	25092	50	of	of	IN
18637	25092	51	,	,	,
18637	25092	52	powers	power	NNS
18637	25092	53	of	of	IN
18637	25092	54	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25092	55	as	as	IN
18637	25092	56	to	to	IN
18637	25092	57	,	,	,
18637	25092	58	etc	etc	FW
18637	25092	59	.	.	.
18637	25092	60	,	,	,
18637	25092	61	310	310	CD
18637	25092	62	,	,	,
18637	25092	63	533	533	CD
18637	25092	64	-	-	SYM
18637	25092	65	535	535	CD
18637	25092	66	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25092	67	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	25092	68	,	,	,
18637	25092	69	uniformity	uniformity	NN
18637	25092	70	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	25092	71	as	as	IN
18637	25092	72	to	to	IN
18637	25092	73	,	,	,
18637	25092	74	109	109	CD
18637	25092	75	-	-	SYM
18637	25092	76	110	110	CD
18637	25092	77	Unincorporated	unincorporate	VBN
18637	25092	78	;	;	:
18637	25092	79	rights	right	NNS
18637	25092	80	of	of	IN
18637	25092	81	persons	person	NNS
18637	25092	82	accused	accuse	VBN
18637	25092	83	of	of	IN
18637	25092	84	crimes	crime	NNS
18637	25092	85	in	in	IN
18637	25092	86	,	,	,
18637	25092	87	877	877	CD
18637	25092	88	"	"	``
18637	25092	89	Third	Third	NNP
18637	25092	90	Degree	Degree	NNP
18637	25092	91	"	"	''
18637	25092	92	.	.	.
18637	25093	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25093	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25093	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25093	4	Confessions	Confessions	NNPS
18637	25093	5	.	.	.
18637	25094	1	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	25094	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25094	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25094	4	see	see	VBP
18637	25094	5	also	also	RB
18637	25094	6	_	_	NNP
18637	25094	7	Cigarettes	Cigarettes	NNP
18637	25094	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25094	9	,	,	,
18637	25094	10	240	240	CD
18637	25094	11	,	,	,
18637	25094	12	990	990	CD
18637	25094	13	Tonnage	tonnage	NN
18637	25094	14	Duties	Duties	NNPS
18637	25094	15	.	.	.
18637	25095	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25095	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25095	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25095	4	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	25095	5	:	:	:
18637	25095	6	State	state	NN
18637	25095	7	.	.	.
18637	25096	1	Trade	Trade	NNP
18637	25096	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	25096	3	Marks	Marks	NNP
18637	25096	4	;	;	:
18637	25096	5	Advertisements	advertisement	NNS
18637	25096	6	,	,	,
18637	25096	7	nature	nature	NN
18637	25096	8	of	of	IN
18637	25096	9	,	,	,
18637	25096	10	in	in	IN
18637	25096	11	relation	relation	NN
18637	25096	12	to	to	IN
18637	25096	13	patents	patent	NNS
18637	25096	14	,	,	,
18637	25096	15	copyrights	copyright	NNS
18637	25096	16	,	,	,
18637	25096	17	276	276	CD
18637	25096	18	Trades	trade	NNS
18637	25096	19	.	.	.
18637	25097	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25097	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25097	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25097	4	Business	Business	NNP
18637	25097	5	,	,	,
18637	25097	6	Trades	Trades	NNPS
18637	25097	7	,	,	,
18637	25097	8	Professions	Professions	NNPS
18637	25097	9	.	.	.
18637	25098	1	Trading	trade	VBG
18637	25098	2	Stamps	Stamps	NNP
18637	25098	3	,	,	,
18637	25098	4	State	state	NN
18637	25098	5	licensee	licensee	NN
18637	25098	6	fees	fee	NNS
18637	25098	7	on	on	IN
18637	25098	8	use	use	NN
18637	25098	9	,	,	,
18637	25098	10	1019	1019	CD
18637	25098	11	Transportation	transportation	NN
18637	25098	12	.	.	.
18637	25099	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25099	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25099	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25099	4	Carriers	Carriers	NNPS
18637	25099	5	;	;	:
18637	25099	6	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
18637	25099	7	;	;	:
18637	25099	8	Vessels	Vessels	NNP
18637	25099	9	.	.	.
18637	25100	1	Treason	treason	NN
18637	25100	2	,	,	,
18637	25100	3	definition	definition	NN
18637	25100	4	,	,	,
18637	25100	5	requirements	requirement	NNS
18637	25100	6	for	for	IN
18637	25100	7	conviction	conviction	NN
18637	25100	8	,	,	,
18637	25100	9	punishment	punishment	NN
18637	25100	10	,	,	,
18637	25100	11	638	638	CD
18637	25100	12	-	-	SYM
18637	25100	13	646	646	CD
18637	25100	14	Treaties	Treaties	NNPS
18637	25100	15	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25100	16	_	_	NNP
18637	25100	17	see	see	VBP
18637	25100	18	also	also	RB
18637	25100	19	_	_	NNP
18637	25100	20	Executive	Executive	NNP
18637	25100	21	Agreements	Agreements	NNPS
18637	25100	22	;	;	:
18637	25100	23	Indians	Indians	NNPS
18637	25100	24	;	;	:
18637	25100	25	Political	Political	NNP
18637	25100	26	Questions	Questions	NNPS
18637	25100	27	;	;	:
18637	25100	28	President	President	NNP
18637	25100	29	:	:	:
18637	25100	30	Powers	power	NNS
18637	25100	31	;	;	:
18637	25100	32	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	25100	33	;	;	:
18637	25100	34	States	States	NNP
18637	25100	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25100	36	:	:	:
18637	25100	37	Effect	effect	NN
18637	25100	38	of	of	IN
18637	25100	39	war	war	NN
18637	25100	40	on	on	IN
18637	25100	41	,	,	,
18637	25100	42	417	417	CD
18637	25100	43	Exterritorial	exterritorial	JJ
18637	25100	44	rights	right	NNS
18637	25100	45	granted	grant	VBN
18637	25100	46	by	by	IN
18637	25100	47	,	,	,
18637	25100	48	effect	effect	NN
18637	25100	49	,	,	,
18637	25100	50	877	877	CD
18637	25100	51	Implementation	implementation	NN
18637	25100	52	,	,	,
18637	25100	53	repeal	repeal	NN
18637	25100	54	,	,	,
18637	25100	55	termination	termination	NN
18637	25100	56	by	by	IN
18637	25100	57	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25100	58	,	,	,
18637	25100	59	418	418	CD
18637	25100	60	-	-	SYM
18637	25100	61	421	421	CD
18637	25100	62	,	,	,
18637	25100	63	423	423	CD
18637	25100	64	-	-	SYM
18637	25100	65	427	427	CD
18637	25100	66	,	,	,
18637	25100	67	431	431	CD
18637	25100	68	-	-	SYM
18637	25100	69	432	432	CD
18637	25100	70	Interpretation	interpretation	NN
18637	25100	71	of	of	IN
18637	25100	72	,	,	,
18637	25100	73	by	by	IN
18637	25100	74	whom	whom	WP
18637	25100	75	,	,	,
18637	25100	76	423	423	CD
18637	25100	77	,	,	,
18637	25100	78	425	425	CD
18637	25100	79	-	-	SYM
18637	25100	80	426	426	CD
18637	25100	81	as	as	IN
18637	25100	82	Law	Law	NNP
18637	25100	83	of	of	IN
18637	25100	84	the	the	DT
18637	25100	85	land	land	NN
18637	25100	86	;	;	:
18637	25100	87	as	as	IN
18637	25100	88	contract	contract	NN
18637	25100	89	;	;	:
18637	25100	90	effect	effect	NN
18637	25100	91	on	on	IN
18637	25100	92	State	state	NN
18637	25100	93	laws	law	NNS
18637	25100	94	,	,	,
18637	25100	95	State	state	NN
18637	25100	96	courts	court	NNS
18637	25100	97	,	,	,
18637	25100	98	413	413	CD
18637	25100	99	-	-	SYM
18637	25100	100	425	425	CD
18637	25100	101	,	,	,
18637	25100	102	431	431	CD
18637	25100	103	-	-	SYM
18637	25100	104	432	432	CD
18637	25100	105	when	when	WRB
18637	25100	106	Self	self	NN
18637	25100	107	-	-	HYPH
18637	25100	108	executing	execute	VBG
18637	25100	109	,	,	,
18637	25100	110	417	417	CD
18637	25100	111	-	-	SYM
18637	25100	112	418	418	CD
18637	25100	113	as	as	IN
18637	25100	114	Source	Source	NNP
18637	25100	115	of	of	IN
18637	25100	116	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25100	117	power	power	NN
18637	25100	118	,	,	,
18637	25100	119	limits	limit	NNS
18637	25100	120	,	,	,
18637	25100	121	426	426	CD
18637	25100	122	-	-	SYM
18637	25100	123	431	431	CD
18637	25100	124	States	States	NNPS
18637	25100	125	not	not	RB
18637	25100	126	to	to	TO
18637	25100	127	enter	enter	VB
18637	25100	128	into	into	IN
18637	25100	129	,	,	,
18637	25100	130	325	325	CD
18637	25100	131	Termination	termination	NN
18637	25100	132	as	as	IN
18637	25100	133	international	international	JJ
18637	25100	134	compact	compact	NN
18637	25100	135	,	,	,
18637	25100	136	how	how	WRB
18637	25100	137	,	,	,
18637	25100	138	by	by	IN
18637	25100	139	whom	whom	WP
18637	25100	140	,	,	,
18637	25100	141	423	423	CD
18637	25100	142	-	-	SYM
18637	25100	143	426	426	CD
18637	25100	144	Troops	troop	NNS
18637	25100	145	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25100	146	_	_	NNP
18637	25100	147	see	see	VB
18637	25100	148	also	also	RB
18637	25100	149	_	_	NNP
18637	25100	150	Land	Land	NNP
18637	25100	151	,	,	,
18637	25100	152	Air	Air	NNP
18637	25100	153	and	and	CC
18637	25100	154	Naval	Naval	NNP
18637	25100	155	Forces	Forces	NNPS
18637	25100	156	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25100	157	:	:	:
18637	25100	158	Keeping	keep	VBG
18637	25100	159	in	in	IN
18637	25100	160	peacetime	peacetime	NN
18637	25100	161	,	,	,
18637	25100	162	by	by	IN
18637	25100	163	States	States	NNP
18637	25100	164	,	,	,
18637	25100	165	365	365	CD
18637	25100	166	-	-	SYM
18637	25100	167	366	366	CD
18637	25100	168	U	U	NNP
18637	25100	169	Uniformity	Uniformity	NNP
18637	25100	170	of	of	IN
18637	25100	171	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25100	172	taxes	taxis	NNS
18637	25100	173	.	.	.
18637	25101	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25101	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25101	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25101	4	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	25101	5	:	:	:
18637	25101	6	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25101	7	.	.	.
18637	25102	1	Unit	unit	NN
18637	25102	2	Rule	rule	NN
18637	25102	3	in	in	IN
18637	25102	4	State	State	NNP
18637	25102	5	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
18637	25102	6	of	of	IN
18637	25102	7	Carriers	Carriers	NNPS
18637	25102	8	,	,	,
18637	25102	9	200	200	CD
18637	25102	10	-	-	SYM
18637	25102	11	201	201	CD
18637	25102	12	United	United	NNP
18637	25102	13	States	States	NNP
18637	25102	14	:	:	:
18637	25102	15	Obligations	obligation	NNS
18637	25102	16	owed	owe	VBN
18637	25102	17	to	to	IN
18637	25102	18	States	States	NNP
18637	25102	19	,	,	,
18637	25102	20	704	704	CD
18637	25102	21	-	-	SYM
18637	25102	22	705	705	CD
18637	25102	23	Property	Property	NNP
18637	25102	24	ceded	cede	VBN
18637	25102	25	by	by	IN
18637	25102	26	States	state	NNS
18637	25102	27	,	,	,
18637	25102	28	conditions	condition	NNS
18637	25102	29	,	,	,
18637	25102	30	reservations	reservation	NNS
18637	25102	31	as	as	IN
18637	25102	32	to	to	IN
18637	25102	33	,	,	,
18637	25102	34	306	306	CD
18637	25102	35	-	-	SYM
18637	25102	36	307	307	CD
18637	25102	37	Property	Property	NNP
18637	25102	38	of	of	IN
18637	25102	39	,	,	,
18637	25102	40	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	25102	41	as	as	IN
18637	25102	42	to	to	IN
18637	25102	43	,	,	,
18637	25102	44	305	305	CD
18637	25102	45	-	-	SYM
18637	25102	46	307	307	CD
18637	25102	47	Property	Property	NNP
18637	25102	48	of	of	IN
18637	25102	49	,	,	,
18637	25102	50	powers	power	NNS
18637	25102	51	as	as	IN
18637	25102	52	to	to	IN
18637	25102	53	,	,	,
18637	25102	54	disposal	disposal	NN
18637	25102	55	,	,	,
18637	25102	56	etc	etc	FW
18637	25102	57	.	.	FW
18637	25102	58	,	,	,
18637	25102	59	701	701	CD
18637	25102	60	-	-	SYM
18637	25102	61	703	703	CD
18637	25102	62	Property	Property	NNP
18637	25102	63	of	of	IN
18637	25102	64	,	,	,
18637	25102	65	State	State	NNP
18637	25102	66	powers	power	NNS
18637	25102	67	as	as	IN
18637	25102	68	to	to	IN
18637	25102	69	,	,	,
18637	25102	70	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	25102	71	of	of	IN
18637	25102	72	,	,	,
18637	25102	73	305	305	CD
18637	25102	74	-	-	SYM
18637	25102	75	307	307	CD
18637	25102	76	,	,	,
18637	25102	77	732	732	CD
18637	25102	78	Public	public	JJ
18637	25102	79	lands	land	NNS
18637	25102	80	of	of	IN
18637	25102	81	,	,	,
18637	25102	82	powers	power	NNS
18637	25102	83	of	of	IN
18637	25102	84	States	States	NNP
18637	25102	85	as	as	IN
18637	25102	86	to	to	IN
18637	25102	87	,	,	,
18637	25102	88	305	305	CD
18637	25102	89	,	,	,
18637	25102	90	702	702	CD
18637	25102	91	-	-	SYM
18637	25102	92	703	703	CD
18637	25102	93	Public	public	JJ
18637	25102	94	lands	land	NNS
18637	25102	95	,	,	,
18637	25102	96	powers	power	NNS
18637	25102	97	as	as	IN
18637	25102	98	to	to	IN
18637	25102	99	,	,	,
18637	25102	100	701	701	CD
18637	25102	101	-	-	SYM
18637	25102	102	702	702	CD
18637	25102	103	V	V	NNP
18637	25102	104	Vaccination	vaccination	NN
18637	25102	105	,	,	,
18637	25102	106	compulsory	compulsory	NN
18637	25102	107	,	,	,
18637	25102	108	State	state	NN
18637	25102	109	laws	law	NNS
18637	25102	110	providing	provide	VBG
18637	25102	111	for	for	IN
18637	25102	112	,	,	,
18637	25102	113	984	984	CD
18637	25102	114	Vessels	Vessels	NNPS
18637	25102	115	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25102	116	_	_	NNP
18637	25102	117	see	see	VBP
18637	25102	118	also	also	RB
18637	25102	119	_	_	NNP
18637	25102	120	Carriers	Carriers	NNPS
18637	25102	121	;	;	:
18637	25102	122	War	War	NNP
18637	25102	123	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25102	124	:	:	:
18637	25102	125	on	on	IN
18637	25102	126	Inland	Inland	NNP
18637	25102	127	waters	water	NNS
18637	25102	128	,	,	,
18637	25102	129	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25102	130	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25102	131	of	of	IN
18637	25102	132	,	,	,
18637	25102	133	128	128	CD
18637	25102	134	-	-	SYM
18637	25102	135	130	130	CD
18637	25102	136	Liens	Liens	NNPS
18637	25102	137	on	on	RP
18637	25102	138	,	,	,
18637	25102	139	under	under	IN
18637	25102	140	State	State	NNP
18637	25102	141	laws	law	NNS
18637	25102	142	,	,	,
18637	25102	143	235	235	CD
18637	25102	144	on	on	IN
18637	25102	145	Navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	25102	146	waters	water	NNS
18637	25102	147	,	,	,
18637	25102	148	State	state	NN
18637	25102	149	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25102	150	of	of	IN
18637	25102	151	,	,	,
18637	25102	152	228	228	CD
18637	25102	153	-	-	SYM
18637	25102	154	231	231	CD
18637	25102	155	Rates	rate	NNS
18637	25102	156	for	for	IN
18637	25102	157	service	service	NN
18637	25102	158	on	on	IN
18637	25102	159	,	,	,
18637	25102	160	State	state	NN
18637	25102	161	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25102	162	,	,	,
18637	25102	163	229	229	CD
18637	25102	164	,	,	,
18637	25102	165	231	231	CD
18637	25102	166	Safety	safety	NN
18637	25102	167	devices	device	NNS
18637	25102	168	on	on	IN
18637	25102	169	,	,	,
18637	25102	170	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25102	171	requirement	requirement	NN
18637	25102	172	,	,	,
18637	25102	173	139	139	CD
18637	25102	174	State	state	NN
18637	25102	175	taxation	taxation	NN
18637	25102	176	of	of	IN
18637	25102	177	,	,	,
18637	25102	178	due	due	JJ
18637	25102	179	process	process	NN
18637	25102	180	,	,	,
18637	25102	181	etc	etc	FW
18637	25102	182	.	.	FW
18637	25102	183	,	,	,
18637	25102	184	limitations	limitation	NNS
18637	25102	185	,	,	,
18637	25102	186	209	209	CD
18637	25102	187	-	-	SYM
18637	25102	188	210	210	CD
18637	25102	189	,	,	,
18637	25102	190	1052	1052	CD
18637	25102	191	Vice	Vice	NNP
18637	25102	192	President	President	NNP
18637	25102	193	:	:	:
18637	25102	194	Candidate	candidate	NN
18637	25102	195	elect	elect	NN
18637	25102	196	,	,	,
18637	25102	197	death	death	NN
18637	25102	198	of	of	IN
18637	25102	199	,	,	,
18637	25102	200	powers	power	NNS
18637	25102	201	of	of	IN
18637	25102	202	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25102	203	to	to	TO
18637	25102	204	fill	fill	VB
18637	25102	205	vacancy	vacancy	NN
18637	25102	206	,	,	,
18637	25102	207	etc	etc	FW
18637	25102	208	.	.	.
18637	25102	209	,	,	,
18637	25102	210	1225	1225	CD
18637	25102	211	-	-	SYM
18637	25102	212	1226	1226	CD
18637	25102	213	Election	Election	NNP
18637	25102	214	of	of	IN
18637	25102	215	,	,	,
18637	25102	216	duties	duty	NNS
18637	25102	217	of	of	IN
18637	25102	218	electors	elector	NNS
18637	25102	219	,	,	,
18637	25102	220	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	25102	221	,	,	,
18637	25102	222	383	383	CD
18637	25102	223	,	,	,
18637	25102	224	941	941	CD
18637	25102	225	-	-	SYM
18637	25102	226	944	944	CD
18637	25102	227	,	,	,
18637	25102	228	1226	1226	CD
18637	25102	229	as	as	IN
18637	25102	230	Presiding	preside	VBG
18637	25102	231	officer	officer	NN
18637	25102	232	in	in	IN
18637	25102	233	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	25102	234	,	,	,
18637	25102	235	casting	cast	VBG
18637	25102	236	vote	vote	NN
18637	25102	237	only	only	RB
18637	25102	238	,	,	,
18637	25102	239	91	91	CD
18637	25102	240	Resignation	resignation	NN
18637	25102	241	,	,	,
18637	25102	242	refusal	refusal	NN
18637	25102	243	to	to	TO
18637	25102	244	accept	accept	VB
18637	25102	245	,	,	,
18637	25102	246	how	how	WRB
18637	25102	247	evidenced	evidence	VBN
18637	25102	248	,	,	,
18637	25102	249	388	388	CD
18637	25102	250	Succeeds	Succeeds	NNPS
18637	25102	251	to	to	IN
18637	25102	252	Presidency	Presidency	NNP
18637	25102	253	,	,	,
18637	25102	254	when	when	WRB
18637	25102	255	,	,	,
18637	25102	256	384	384	CD
18637	25102	257	,	,	,
18637	25102	258	387	387	CD
18637	25102	259	-	-	SYM
18637	25102	260	388	388	CD
18637	25102	261	,	,	,
18637	25102	262	941	941	CD
18637	25102	263	-	-	HYPH
18637	25102	264	942	942	CD
18637	25102	265	Term	Term	NNP
18637	25102	266	,	,	,
18637	25102	267	beginning	begin	VBG
18637	25102	268	of	of	IN
18637	25102	269	,	,	,
18637	25102	270	etc	etc	FW
18637	25102	271	.	.	.
18637	25102	272	,	,	,
18637	25102	273	377	377	CD
18637	25102	274	,	,	,
18637	25102	275	1225	1225	CD
18637	25102	276	Vacancy	Vacancy	NNP
18637	25102	277	in	in	IN
18637	25102	278	,	,	,
18637	25102	279	power	power	NN
18637	25102	280	of	of	IN
18637	25102	281	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25102	282	to	to	TO
18637	25102	283	fill	fill	VB
18637	25102	284	,	,	,
18637	25102	285	384	384	CD
18637	25102	286	,	,	,
18637	25102	287	387	387	CD
18637	25102	288	-	-	SYM
18637	25102	289	388	388	CD
18637	25102	290	Voting	voting	NN
18637	25102	291	.	.	.
18637	25103	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25103	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25103	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25103	4	Elections	Elections	NNPS
18637	25103	5	.	.	.
18637	25104	1	W	W	NNP
18637	25104	2	Wages	wage	NNS
18637	25104	3	.	.	.
18637	25105	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25105	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25105	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25105	4	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	25105	5	.	.	.
18637	25106	1	War	War	NNP
18637	25106	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25106	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25106	4	see	see	VB
18637	25106	5	also	also	RB
18637	25106	6	_	_	NNP
18637	25106	7	Eminent	Eminent	NNP
18637	25106	8	Domain	Domain	NNP
18637	25106	9	;	;	:
18637	25106	10	Japanese	Japanese	NNP
18637	25106	11	;	;	:
18637	25106	12	President	President	NNP
18637	25106	13	:	:	:
18637	25106	14	Powers	power	NNS
18637	25106	15	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25106	16	:	:	:
18637	25106	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25106	18	,	,	,
18637	25106	19	power	power	NN
18637	25106	20	to	to	TO
18637	25106	21	declare	declare	VB
18637	25106	22	,	,	,
18637	25106	23	etc	etc	FW
18637	25106	24	.	.	FW
18637	25106	25	,	,	,
18637	25106	26	279	279	CD
18637	25106	27	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	28	282	282	CD
18637	25106	29	,	,	,
18637	25106	30	286	286	CD
18637	25106	31	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	32	293	293	CD
18637	25106	33	,	,	,
18637	25106	34	296	296	CD
18637	25106	35	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	36	298	298	CD
18637	25106	37	,	,	,
18637	25106	38	395	395	CD
18637	25106	39	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	40	397	397	CD
18637	25106	41	,	,	,
18637	25106	42	399	399	CD
18637	25106	43	,	,	,
18637	25106	44	401	401	CD
18637	25106	45	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	46	404	404	CD
18637	25106	47	Dates	Dates	NNPS
18637	25106	48	of	of	IN
18637	25106	49	beginning	beginning	NN
18637	25106	50	,	,	,
18637	25106	51	termination	termination	NN
18637	25106	52	,	,	,
18637	25106	53	how	how	WRB
18637	25106	54	fixed	fix	VBN
18637	25106	55	,	,	,
18637	25106	56	282	282	CD
18637	25106	57	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
18637	25106	58	,	,	,
18637	25106	59	when	when	WRB
18637	25106	60	required	require	VBN
18637	25106	61	,	,	,
18637	25106	62	281	281	CD
18637	25106	63	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	64	282	282	CD
18637	25106	65	Economic	economic	JJ
18637	25106	66	mobilization	mobilization	NN
18637	25106	67	during	during	IN
18637	25106	68	,	,	,
18637	25106	69	280	280	CD
18637	25106	70	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	71	289	289	CD
18637	25106	72	,	,	,
18637	25106	73	296	296	CD
18637	25106	74	Eminent	eminent	JJ
18637	25106	75	domain	domain	NN
18637	25106	76	in	in	IN
18637	25106	77	time	time	NN
18637	25106	78	of	of	IN
18637	25106	79	,	,	,
18637	25106	80	liability	liability	NN
18637	25106	81	of	of	IN
18637	25106	82	United	United	NNP
18637	25106	83	States	States	NNP
18637	25106	84	,	,	,
18637	25106	85	298	298	CD
18637	25106	86	Enemy	enemy	NN
18637	25106	87	aliens	alien	NNS
18637	25106	88	,	,	,
18637	25106	89	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	25106	90	of	of	IN
18637	25106	91	,	,	,
18637	25106	92	297	297	CD
18637	25106	93	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	94	298	298	CD
18637	25106	95	Enemy	enemy	NN
18637	25106	96	property	property	NN
18637	25106	97	during	during	IN
18637	25106	98	,	,	,
18637	25106	99	294	294	CD
18637	25106	100	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	101	296	296	CD
18637	25106	102	Laws	law	NNS
18637	25106	103	of	of	IN
18637	25106	104	,	,	,
18637	25106	105	application	application	NN
18637	25106	106	,	,	,
18637	25106	107	293	293	CD
18637	25106	108	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	109	294	294	CD
18637	25106	110	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
18637	25106	111	enacted	enact	VBN
18637	25106	112	in	in	IN
18637	25106	113	prior	prior	JJ
18637	25106	114	wars	war	NNS
18637	25106	115	;	;	,
18637	25106	116	postwar	postwar	JJ
18637	25106	117	effect	effect	NN
18637	25106	118	,	,	,
18637	25106	119	286	286	CD
18637	25106	120	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	121	288	288	CD
18637	25106	122	,	,	,
18637	25106	123	292	292	CD
18637	25106	124	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	125	293	293	CD
18637	25106	126	Personal	personal	JJ
18637	25106	127	liberty	liberty	NN
18637	25106	128	,	,	,
18637	25106	129	restraint	restraint	NN
18637	25106	130	of	of	IN
18637	25106	131	,	,	,
18637	25106	132	during	during	IN
18637	25106	133	,	,	,
18637	25106	134	297	297	CD
18637	25106	135	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	136	298	298	CD
18637	25106	137	Powers	power	NNS
18637	25106	138	,	,	,
18637	25106	139	nature	nature	NN
18637	25106	140	and	and	CC
18637	25106	141	source	source	NN
18637	25106	142	of	of	IN
18637	25106	143	,	,	,
18637	25106	144	279	279	CD
18637	25106	145	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	146	281	281	CD
18637	25106	147	,	,	,
18637	25106	148	291	291	CD
18637	25106	149	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	150	293	293	CD
18637	25106	151	Preparation	Preparation	NNP
18637	25106	152	for	for	IN
18637	25106	153	,	,	,
18637	25106	154	in	in	IN
18637	25106	155	time	time	NN
18637	25106	156	of	of	IN
18637	25106	157	peace	peace	NN
18637	25106	158	,	,	,
18637	25106	159	291	291	CD
18637	25106	160	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	161	292	292	CD
18637	25106	162	President	President	NNP
18637	25106	163	,	,	,
18637	25106	164	powers	power	NNS
18637	25106	165	of	of	IN
18637	25106	166	,	,	,
18637	25106	167	absent	absent	VB
18637	25106	168	a	a	DT
18637	25106	169	declaration	declaration	NN
18637	25106	170	of	of	IN
18637	25106	171	,	,	,
18637	25106	172	281	281	CD
18637	25106	173	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	174	282	282	CD
18637	25106	175	Private	private	JJ
18637	25106	176	rights	right	NNS
18637	25106	177	during	during	IN
18637	25106	178	,	,	,
18637	25106	179	293	293	CD
18637	25106	180	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	181	298	298	CD
18637	25106	182	Prizes	prize	NNS
18637	25106	183	of	of	IN
18637	25106	184	,	,	,
18637	25106	185	laws	law	NNS
18637	25106	186	applicable	applicable	JJ
18637	25106	187	to	to	IN
18637	25106	188	,	,	,
18637	25106	189	295	295	CD
18637	25106	190	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	191	296	296	CD
18637	25106	192	Seditious	seditious	JJ
18637	25106	193	utterances	utterance	NNS
18637	25106	194	in	in	RB
18637	25106	195	,	,	,
18637	25106	196	powers	power	NNS
18637	25106	197	of	of	IN
18637	25106	198	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25106	199	as	as	IN
18637	25106	200	to	to	IN
18637	25106	201	,	,	,
18637	25106	202	297	297	CD
18637	25106	203	,	,	,
18637	25106	204	794	794	CD
18637	25106	205	Terminated	terminate	VBN
18637	25106	206	,	,	,
18637	25106	207	by	by	IN
18637	25106	208	whom	whom	WP
18637	25106	209	,	,	,
18637	25106	210	474	474	CD
18637	25106	211	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	212	475	475	CD
18637	25106	213	Theatre	Theatre	NNP
18637	25106	214	of	of	IN
18637	25106	215	war	war	NN
18637	25106	216	,	,	,
18637	25106	217	defined	define	VBN
18637	25106	218	,	,	,
18637	25106	219	by	by	IN
18637	25106	220	whom	whom	WP
18637	25106	221	,	,	,
18637	25106	222	294	294	CD
18637	25106	223	Treaty	treaty	NN
18637	25106	224	-	-	HYPH
18637	25106	225	making	make	VBG
18637	25106	226	power	power	NN
18637	25106	227	,	,	,
18637	25106	228	involvement	involvement	NN
18637	25106	229	in	in	RB
18637	25106	230	,	,	,
18637	25106	231	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
18637	25106	232	to	to	IN
18637	25106	233	,	,	,
18637	25106	234	419	419	CD
18637	25106	235	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	236	420	420	CD
18637	25106	237	War	War	NNP
18637	25106	238	Crimes	Crimes	NNPS
18637	25106	239	,	,	,
18637	25106	240	prosecution	prosecution	NN
18637	25106	241	for	for	IN
18637	25106	242	,	,	,
18637	25106	243	402	402	CD
18637	25106	244	-	-	SYM
18637	25106	245	403	403	CD
18637	25106	246	Warehouses	warehouse	NNS
18637	25106	247	,	,	,
18637	25106	248	grain	grain	NN
18637	25106	249	,	,	,
18637	25106	250	tobacco	tobacco	NN
18637	25106	251	,	,	,
18637	25106	252	State	state	NN
18637	25106	253	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25106	254	of	of	IN
18637	25106	255	charges	charge	NNS
18637	25106	256	,	,	,
18637	25106	257	etc	etc	FW
18637	25106	258	.	.	.
18637	25106	259	,	,	,
18637	25106	260	251	251	CD
18637	25106	261	,	,	,
18637	25106	262	994	994	CD
18637	25106	263	,	,	,
18637	25106	264	996	996	CD
18637	25106	265	Warrants	Warrants	NNPS
18637	25106	266	.	.	.
18637	25107	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25107	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25107	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25107	4	Searches	Searches	NNPS
18637	25107	5	and	and	CC
18637	25107	6	Seizures	Seizures	NNPS
18637	25107	7	.	.	.
18637	25108	1	Water	water	NN
18637	25108	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25108	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25108	4	see	see	VBP
18637	25108	5	also	also	RB
18637	25108	6	_	_	NNP
18637	25108	7	Public	Public	NNP
18637	25108	8	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	25108	9	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25108	10	:	:	:
18637	25108	11	Diversion	diversion	NN
18637	25108	12	by	by	IN
18637	25108	13	riparian	riparian	JJ
18637	25108	14	owner	owner	NN
18637	25108	15	,	,	,
18637	25108	16	State	State	NNP
18637	25108	17	prohibition	prohibition	NN
18637	25108	18	,	,	,
18637	25108	19	1026	1026	CD
18637	25108	20	Restrictions	restriction	NNS
18637	25108	21	by	by	IN
18637	25108	22	States	state	NNS
18637	25108	23	on	on	IN
18637	25108	24	export	export	NN
18637	25108	25	of	of	IN
18637	25108	26	,	,	,
18637	25108	27	243	243	CD
18637	25108	28	Weights	Weights	NNPS
18637	25108	29	and	and	CC
18637	25108	30	Measures	Measures	NNPS
18637	25108	31	,	,	,
18637	25108	32	265	265	CD
18637	25108	33	,	,	,
18637	25108	34	1018	1018	CD
18637	25108	35	Wharves	wharf	NNS
18637	25108	36	and	and	CC
18637	25108	37	Docks	Docks	NNPS
18637	25108	38	:	:	:
18637	25108	39	in	in	IN
18637	25108	40	Navigable	navigable	JJ
18637	25108	41	streams	stream	NNS
18637	25108	42	,	,	,
18637	25108	43	State	state	NN
18637	25108	44	powers	power	NNS
18637	25108	45	as	as	IN
18637	25108	46	to	to	IN
18637	25108	47	,	,	,
18637	25108	48	229	229	CD
18637	25108	49	-	-	SYM
18637	25108	50	231	231	CD
18637	25108	51	Purchased	purchase	VBN
18637	25108	52	with	with	IN
18637	25108	53	State	state	NN
18637	25108	54	consent	consent	NN
18637	25108	55	,	,	,
18637	25108	56	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25108	57	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	25108	58	over	over	RB
18637	25108	59	,	,	,
18637	25108	60	305	305	CD
18637	25108	61	-	-	SYM
18637	25108	62	306	306	CD
18637	25108	63	Wheat	Wheat	NNP
18637	25108	64	,	,	,
18637	25108	65	Federal	federal	JJ
18637	25108	66	regulation	regulation	NN
18637	25108	67	of	of	IN
18637	25108	68	production	production	NN
18637	25108	69	of	of	IN
18637	25108	70	,	,	,
18637	25108	71	159	159	CD
18637	25108	72	Wills	will	NNS
18637	25108	73	.	.	.
18637	25109	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25109	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25109	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25109	4	Administration	Administration	NNP
18637	25109	5	of	of	IN
18637	25109	6	Estates	Estates	NNPS
18637	25109	7	;	;	:
18637	25109	8	Succession	succession	NN
18637	25109	9	to	to	IN
18637	25109	10	Property	Property	NNP
18637	25109	11	.	.	.
18637	25110	1	Wireless	wireless	JJ
18637	25110	2	.	.	.
18637	25111	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25111	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25111	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25111	4	Radio	Radio	NNP
18637	25111	5	.	.	.
18637	25112	1	Wiretapping	wiretapping	NN
18637	25112	2	,	,	,
18637	25112	3	824	824	CD
18637	25112	4	Women	woman	NNS
18637	25112	5	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25112	6	_	_	NNP
18637	25112	7	see	see	VBP
18637	25112	8	also	also	RB
18637	25112	9	_	_	NNP
18637	25112	10	Elections	Elections	NNP
18637	25112	11	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25112	12	:	:	:
18637	25112	13	Citizenship	citizenship	NN
18637	25112	14	of	of	IN
18637	25112	15	,	,	,
18637	25112	16	255	255	CD
18637	25112	17	,	,	,
18637	25112	18	259	259	CD
18637	25112	19	,	,	,
18637	25112	20	963	963	CD
18637	25112	21	Employment	employment	NN
18637	25112	22	of	of	IN
18637	25112	23	,	,	,
18637	25112	24	State	State	NNP
18637	25112	25	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	25112	26	as	as	IN
18637	25112	27	to	to	IN
18637	25112	28	,	,	,
18637	25112	29	988	988	CD
18637	25112	30	,	,	,
18637	25112	31	1159	1159	CD
18637	25112	32	Voting	voting	NN
18637	25112	33	rights	right	NNS
18637	25112	34	of	of	IN
18637	25112	35	,	,	,
18637	25112	36	1219	1219	CD
18637	25112	37	-	-	SYM
18637	25112	38	1220	1220	CD
18637	25112	39	Workmen	Workmen	NNP
18637	25112	40	's	's	POS
18637	25112	41	Compensation	Compensation	NNP
18637	25112	42	.	.	.
18637	25113	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25113	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25113	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25113	4	Full	Full	NNP
18637	25113	5	Faith	Faith	NNP
18637	25113	6	and	and	CC
18637	25113	7	Credit	Credit	NNP
18637	25113	8	Clause	Clause	NNP
18637	25113	9	;	;	:
18637	25113	10	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	25113	11	.	.	.
18637	25114	1	Work	work	NN
18637	25114	2	-	-	HYPH
18637	25114	3	Or	or	CC
18637	25114	4	-	-	HYPH
18637	25114	5	Fight	Fight	NNP
18637	25114	6	,	,	,
18637	25114	7	work	work	NN
18637	25114	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	25114	9	or	or	CC
18637	25114	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	25114	11	starve	starve	VB
18637	25114	12	laws	law	NNS
18637	25114	13	,	,	,
18637	25114	14	validity	validity	NN
18637	25114	15	,	,	,
18637	25114	16	952	952	CD
18637	25114	17	-	-	SYM
18637	25114	18	953	953	CD
18637	25114	19	Wrongful	Wrongful	NNP
18637	25114	20	Death	Death	NNP
18637	25114	21	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
18637	25114	22	,	,	,
18637	25114	23	State	state	NN
18637	25114	24	enforcement	enforcement	NN
18637	25114	25	in	in	IN
18637	25114	26	Federal	Federal	NNP
18637	25114	27	courts	court	NNS
18637	25114	28	,	,	,
18637	25114	29	574	574	CD
18637	25114	30	,	,	,
18637	25114	31	579	579	CD
18637	25114	32	Y	Y	NNP
18637	25114	33	Yellow	Yellow	NNP
18637	25114	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	25114	35	Dog	Dog	NNP
18637	25114	36	Contracts	Contracts	NNPS
18637	25114	37	.	.	.
18637	25115	1	_	_	NNP
18637	25115	2	See	See	NNP
18637	25115	3	_	_	NNP
18637	25115	4	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	25115	5	.	.	.
18637	25116	1	Z	Z	NNP
18637	25116	2	Zoning	Zoning	NNP
18637	25116	3	,	,	,
18637	25116	4	building	build	VBG
18637	25116	5	code	code	NN
18637	25116	6	,	,	,
18637	25116	7	regulations	regulation	NNS
18637	25116	8	,	,	,
18637	25116	9	validity	validity	NN
18637	25116	10	,	,	,
18637	25116	11	1027	1027	CD
18637	25116	12	-	-	SYM
18637	25116	13	1029	1029	CD
18637	25116	14	,	,	,
18637	25116	15	1154	1154	CD
18637	25116	16	-	-	SYM
18637	25116	17	1156	1156	CD
18637	25116	18	*	*	NFP
18637	25116	19	*	*	NFP
18637	25116	20	*	*	NFP
18637	25116	21	*	*	NFP
18637	25116	22	*	*	NFP
18637	25116	23	TRANSCRIBER	TRANSCRIBER	NNP
18637	25116	24	'S	'S	NNP
18637	25116	25	NOTES	note	NNS
18637	25116	26	:	:	:
18637	25116	27	Introduction	introduction	NN
18637	25116	28	:	:	:
18637	25116	29	page	page	NN
18637	25116	30	XII	xii	NN
18637	25116	31	--	--	:
18637	25116	32	added	add	VBN
18637	25116	33	period	period	NN
18637	25116	34	after	after	IN
18637	25116	35	"	"	``
18637	25116	36	thereby	thereby	RB
18637	25116	37	"	"	''
18637	25116	38	to	to	TO
18637	25116	39	complete	complete	VB
18637	25116	40	four	four	CD
18637	25116	41	period	period	NN
18637	25116	42	ellipsis	ellipsis	NN
18637	25116	43	page	page	NN
18637	25116	44	XIV	XIV	NNP
18637	25116	45	--	--	:
18637	25116	46	corrected	correct	VBD
18637	25116	47	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25116	48	of	of	IN
18637	25116	49	"	"	``
18637	25116	50	kidnaping	kidnap	VBG
18637	25116	51	"	"	''
18637	25116	52	to	to	TO
18637	25116	53	"	"	``
18637	25116	54	kidnapping	kidnap	VBG
18637	25116	55	"	"	''
18637	25116	56	page	page	NN
18637	25116	57	XXI	XXI	NNP
18637	25116	58	--	--	:
18637	25116	59	corrected	correct	VBN
18637	25116	60	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25116	61	of	of	IN
18637	25116	62	"	"	``
18637	25116	63	injuction	injuction	NN
18637	25116	64	"	"	''
18637	25116	65	to	to	TO
18637	25116	66	"	"	``
18637	25116	67	injunction	injunction	NN
18637	25116	68	"	"	''
18637	25116	69	and	and	CC
18637	25116	70	added	add	VBN
18637	25116	71	period	period	NN
18637	25116	72	after	after	IN
18637	25116	73	"	"	``
18637	25116	74	law	law	NN
18637	25116	75	"	"	''
18637	25116	76	to	to	TO
18637	25116	77	complete	complete	VB
18637	25116	78	four	four	CD
18637	25116	79	period	period	NN
18637	25116	80	ellipsis	ellipsis	NN
18637	25116	81	page	page	NN
18637	25116	82	XXII	XXII	NNP
18637	25116	83	--	--	:
18637	25116	84	corrected	correct	VBN
18637	25116	85	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25116	86	of	of	IN
18637	25116	87	"	"	``
18637	25116	88	achivement	achivement	NN
18637	25116	89	"	"	''
18637	25116	90	to	to	IN
18637	25116	91	"	"	``
18637	25116	92	achievement	achievement	NN
18637	25116	93	"	"	''
18637	25116	94	page	page	NN
18637	25116	95	XXVIII	XXVIII	NNP
18637	25116	96	--	--	:
18637	25116	97	added	add	VBD
18637	25116	98	opening	opening	NN
18637	25116	99	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	25116	100	mark	mark	NN
18637	25116	101	to	to	IN
18637	25116	102	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	25116	103	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
18637	25116	104	'	'	POS
18637	25116	105	remarks	remark	NNS
18637	25116	106	page	page	NN
18637	25116	107	XXIX	XXIX	NNP
18637	25116	108	--	--	:
18637	25116	109	corrected	correct	VBN
18637	25116	110	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25116	111	of	of	IN
18637	25116	112	"	"	``
18637	25116	113	Genessee	Genessee	NNP
18637	25116	114	"	"	''
18637	25116	115	to	to	TO
18637	25116	116	"	"	``
18637	25116	117	Genesee	Genesee	NNP
18637	25116	118	"	"	''
18637	25116	119	in	in	IN
18637	25116	120	"	"	``
18637	25116	121	The	the	DT
18637	25116	122	Genessee	Genessee	NNP
18637	25116	123	Chief	Chief	NNP
18637	25116	124	"	"	''
18637	25116	125	page	page	NN
18637	25116	126	XXXIII	xxxiii	NN
18637	25116	127	--	--	:
18637	25116	128	added	add	VBN
18637	25116	129	period	period	NN
18637	25116	130	after	after	IN
18637	25116	131	"	"	``
18637	25116	132	etc	etc	FW
18637	25116	133	"	"	''
18637	25116	134	page	page	NN
18637	25116	135	XXXIV	xxxiv	NN
18637	25116	136	--	--	:
18637	25116	137	added	add	VBN
18637	25116	138	period	period	NN
18637	25116	139	after	after	IN
18637	25116	140	"	"	``
18637	25116	141	etc	etc	FW
18637	25116	142	"	"	''
18637	25116	143	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25116	144	23	23	CD
18637	25116	145	-	-	HYPH
18637	25116	146	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25116	147	case	case	NN
18637	25116	148	citation	citation	NN
18637	25116	149	from	from	IN
18637	25116	150	"	"	``
18637	25116	151	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	25116	152	.	.	.
18637	25117	1	54	54	CD
18637	25117	2	,	,	,
18637	25117	3	74	74	CD
18637	25117	4	"	"	``
18637	25117	5	to	to	IN
18637	25117	6	"	"	``
18637	25117	7	3	3	CD
18637	25117	8	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	25117	9	.	.	.
18637	25118	1	54	54	CD
18637	25118	2	,	,	,
18637	25118	3	74	74	CD
18637	25118	4	"	"	``
18637	25118	5	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25118	6	61	61	CD
18637	25118	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	25118	8	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25118	9	comma	comma	NN
18637	25118	10	after	after	IN
18637	25118	11	"	"	``
18637	25118	12	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	25118	13	.	.	.
18637	25118	14	"	"	''
18637	25119	1	Constitution	constitution	NN
18637	25119	2	of	of	IN
18637	25119	3	the	the	DT
18637	25119	4	United	United	NNP
18637	25119	5	States	States	NNP
18637	25119	6	:	:	:
18637	25119	7	page	page	NN
18637	25119	8	22	22	CD
18637	25119	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	10	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	11	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	12	of	of	IN
18637	25119	13	"	"	``
18637	25119	14	questiond	questiond	NN
18637	25119	15	"	"	''
18637	25119	16	to	to	TO
18637	25119	17	"	"	``
18637	25119	18	questioned	question	VBN
18637	25119	19	"	"	''
18637	25119	20	page	page	NN
18637	25119	21	54	54	CD
18637	25119	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	23	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	24	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	25	of	of	IN
18637	25119	26	"	"	``
18637	25119	27	submisssion	submisssion	NN
18637	25119	28	"	"	''
18637	25119	29	to	to	IN
18637	25119	30	"	"	``
18637	25119	31	submission	submission	NN
18637	25119	32	"	"	''
18637	25119	33	Article	article	NN
18637	25119	34	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25119	35	:	:	:
18637	25119	36	page	page	NN
18637	25119	37	68	68	CD
18637	25119	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	39	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25119	40	period	period	NN
18637	25119	41	after	after	IN
18637	25119	42	"	"	``
18637	25119	43	etc	etc	FW
18637	25119	44	"	"	''
18637	25119	45	page	page	NN
18637	25119	46	76	76	CD
18637	25119	47	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	48	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	49	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	50	of	of	IN
18637	25119	51	"	"	``
18637	25119	52	alloting	allot	VBG
18637	25119	53	"	"	''
18637	25119	54	to	to	IN
18637	25119	55	"	"	``
18637	25119	56	allotting	allot	VBG
18637	25119	57	"	"	''
18637	25119	58	page	page	NN
18637	25119	59	86	86	CD
18637	25119	60	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	61	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	62	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	63	of	of	IN
18637	25119	64	"	"	``
18637	25119	65	apropriate	apropriate	NN
18637	25119	66	"	"	''
18637	25119	67	to	to	TO
18637	25119	68	"	"	``
18637	25119	69	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
18637	25119	70	"	"	''
18637	25119	71	page	page	NN
18637	25119	72	95	95	CD
18637	25119	73	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	74	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	75	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	76	of	of	IN
18637	25119	77	"	"	``
18637	25119	78	caluse	caluse	NN
18637	25119	79	"	"	''
18637	25119	80	to	to	TO
18637	25119	81	"	"	``
18637	25119	82	clause	clause	NN
18637	25119	83	"	"	''
18637	25119	84	page	page	NN
18637	25119	85	104	104	CD
18637	25119	86	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	87	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25119	88	comma	comma	NN
18637	25119	89	after	after	IN
18637	25119	90	"	"	``
18637	25119	91	order	order	NN
18637	25119	92	"	"	''
18637	25119	93	in	in	IN
18637	25119	94	"	"	``
18637	25119	95	order	order	NN
18637	25119	96	,	,	,
18637	25119	97	resolution	resolution	NN
18637	25119	98	,	,	,
18637	25119	99	or	or	CC
18637	25119	100	vote	vote	NN
18637	25119	101	"	"	``
18637	25119	102	page	page	NN
18637	25119	103	146	146	CD
18637	25119	104	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	105	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	106	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	107	of	of	IN
18637	25119	108	"	"	``
18637	25119	109	REVIVED	revive	VBN
18637	25119	110	"	"	''
18637	25119	111	to	to	TO
18637	25119	112	"	"	``
18637	25119	113	REVISED	revised	VB
18637	25119	114	"	"	''
18637	25119	115	in	in	IN
18637	25119	116	"	"	``
18637	25119	117	THE	the	DT
18637	25119	118	SHERMAN	SHERMAN	NNP
18637	25119	119	ACT	ACT	NNP
18637	25119	120	REVIVED	revive	VBN
18637	25119	121	"	"	``
18637	25119	122	page	page	NN
18637	25119	123	146	146	CD
18637	25119	124	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	125	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	126	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	127	of	of	IN
18637	25119	128	"	"	``
18637	25119	129	Addystone	Addystone	NNP
18637	25119	130	"	"	''
18637	25119	131	to	to	IN
18637	25119	132	"	"	``
18637	25119	133	Addyston	Addyston	NNP
18637	25119	134	"	"	''
18637	25119	135	in	in	IN
18637	25119	136	"	"	``
18637	25119	137	Addystone	Addystone	NNP
18637	25119	138	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	25119	139	and	and	CC
18637	25119	140	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	25119	141	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25119	142	v.	v.	IN
18637	25119	143	United	United	NNP
18637	25119	144	States	States	NNP
18637	25119	145	"	"	''
18637	25119	146	page	page	NN
18637	25119	147	152	152	CD
18637	25119	148	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	149	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	150	"	"	''
18637	25119	151	be	be	VB
18637	25119	152	"	"	''
18637	25119	153	to	to	TO
18637	25119	154	"	"	''
18637	25119	155	by	by	IN
18637	25119	156	"	"	''
18637	25119	157	in	in	IN
18637	25119	158	"	"	``
18637	25119	159	It	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25119	160	is	be	VBZ
18637	25119	161	an	an	DT
18637	25119	162	attempt	attempt	NN
18637	25119	163	for	for	IN
18637	25119	164	social	social	JJ
18637	25119	165	ends	end	NNS
18637	25119	166	to	to	TO
18637	25119	167	impose	impose	VB
18637	25119	168	by	by	IN
18637	25119	169	sheer	sheer	JJ
18637	25119	170	fiat	fiat	JJ
18637	25119	171	noncontractual	noncontractual	JJ
18637	25119	172	incidents	incident	NNS
18637	25119	173	....	....	.
18637	25119	174	"	"	``
18637	25119	175	page	page	NN
18637	25119	176	158	158	CD
18637	25119	177	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	178	-removed	-removed	JJ
18637	25119	179	comma	comma	NN
18637	25119	180	after	after	IN
18637	25119	181	"	"	``
18637	25119	182	St.	St.	NNP
18637	25119	183	"	"	''
18637	25119	184	in	in	IN
18637	25119	185	"	"	``
18637	25119	186	10	10	CD
18637	25119	187	East	East	NNP
18637	25119	188	40th	40th	NNP
18637	25119	189	St.	St.	NNP
18637	25119	190	v.	v.	IN
18637	25119	191	Callus	Callus	NNP
18637	25119	192	"	"	''
18637	25119	193	page	page	NN
18637	25119	194	160	160	CD
18637	25119	195	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	196	-removed	-removed	JJ
18637	25119	197	second	second	JJ
18637	25119	198	"	"	''
18637	25119	199	within	within	IN
18637	25119	200	"	"	``
18637	25119	201	in	in	IN
18637	25119	202	"	"	''
18637	25119	203	Activities	activity	NNS
18637	25119	204	conducted	conduct	VBN
18637	25119	205	within	within	IN
18637	25119	206	within	within	IN
18637	25119	207	the	the	DT
18637	25119	208	State	State	NNP
18637	25119	209	lines	line	NNS
18637	25119	210	....	....	NFP
18637	25119	211	"	"	``
18637	25119	212	page	page	NN
18637	25119	213	166	166	CD
18637	25119	214	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	215	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25119	216	period	period	NN
18637	25119	217	after	after	IN
18637	25119	218	"	"	``
18637	25119	219	S	S	NNP
18637	25119	220	"	"	''
18637	25119	221	in	in	IN
18637	25119	222	"	"	``
18637	25119	223	247	247	CD
18637	25119	224	U.S	U.S	NNP
18637	25119	225	251	251	CD
18637	25119	226	"	"	''
18637	25119	227	page	page	NN
18637	25119	228	178	178	CD
18637	25119	229	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	230	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	231	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	232	of	of	IN
18637	25119	233	"	"	``
18637	25119	234	concesssion	concesssion	NN
18637	25119	235	"	"	''
18637	25119	236	to	to	IN
18637	25119	237	"	"	``
18637	25119	238	concession	concession	NN
18637	25119	239	"	"	''
18637	25119	240	page	page	NN
18637	25119	241	184	184	CD
18637	25119	242	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	243	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	244	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	245	of	of	IN
18637	25119	246	"	"	``
18637	25119	247	doctine	doctine	NN
18637	25119	248	"	"	''
18637	25119	249	to	to	TO
18637	25119	250	"	"	``
18637	25119	251	doctrine	doctrine	VB
18637	25119	252	"	"	''
18637	25119	253	page	page	NN
18637	25119	254	203	203	CD
18637	25119	255	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	256	-removed	-removed	JJ
18637	25119	257	third	third	RB
18637	25119	258	"	"	''
18637	25119	259	s	s	NN
18637	25119	260	"	"	''
18637	25119	261	from	from	IN
18637	25119	262	"	"	``
18637	25119	263	businesss	businesss	NN
18637	25119	264	"	"	''
18637	25119	265	in	in	IN
18637	25119	266	"	"	''
18637	25119	267	...	...	NFP
18637	25119	268	taxing	tax	VBG
18637	25119	269	State	state	NN
18637	25119	270	and	and	CC
18637	25119	271	of	of	IN
18637	25119	272	the	the	DT
18637	25119	273	business	business	NN
18637	25119	274	....	....	.
18637	25119	275	"	"	''
18637	25119	276	page	page	NN
18637	25119	277	216	216	CD
18637	25119	278	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	279	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25119	280	comma	comma	NN
18637	25119	281	after	after	IN
18637	25119	282	"	"	``
18637	25119	283	York	York	NNP
18637	25119	284	"	"	''
18637	25119	285	in	in	IN
18637	25119	286	"	"	``
18637	25119	287	New	New	NNP
18637	25119	288	York	York	NNP
18637	25119	289	v.	v.	IN
18637	25119	290	Miln	Miln	NNP
18637	25119	291	"	"	''
18637	25119	292	page	page	NN
18637	25119	293	220	220	CD
18637	25119	294	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	295	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	296	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	297	of	of	IN
18637	25119	298	"	"	``
18637	25119	299	supoprt	supoprt	NN
18637	25119	300	"	"	''
18637	25119	301	to	to	TO
18637	25119	302	"	"	``
18637	25119	303	support	support	VB
18637	25119	304	"	"	''
18637	25119	305	page	page	NN
18637	25119	306	221	221	CD
18637	25119	307	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	308	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25119	309	extraneous	extraneous	JJ
18637	25119	310	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	25119	311	mark	mark	NN
18637	25119	312	before	before	IN
18637	25119	313	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25119	314	1	1	CD
18637	25119	315	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25119	316	page	page	NN
18637	25119	317	238	238	CD
18637	25119	318	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	319	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	320	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	321	of	of	IN
18637	25119	322	"	"	``
18637	25119	323	manufacure	manufacure	NN
18637	25119	324	"	"	''
18637	25119	325	to	to	TO
18637	25119	326	"	"	``
18637	25119	327	manufacture	manufacture	VB
18637	25119	328	"	"	''
18637	25119	329	page	page	NN
18637	25119	330	244	244	CD
18637	25119	331	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	332	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	333	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	334	of	of	IN
18637	25119	335	"	"	``
18637	25119	336	comformably	comformably	RB
18637	25119	337	"	"	''
18637	25119	338	to	to	TO
18637	25119	339	"	"	``
18637	25119	340	conformably	conformably	RB
18637	25119	341	"	"	''
18637	25119	342	page	page	NN
18637	25119	343	249	249	CD
18637	25119	344	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	345	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25119	346	"	"	''
18637	25119	347	in	in	IN
18637	25119	348	"	"	''
18637	25119	349	to	to	TO
18637	25119	350	"	"	``
18637	25119	351	In	in	IN
18637	25119	352	"	"	''
18637	25119	353	in	in	IN
18637	25119	354	two	two	CD
18637	25119	355	places	place	NNS
18637	25119	356	page	page	NN
18637	25119	357	254	254	CD
18637	25119	358	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	359	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	360	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	361	of	of	IN
18637	25119	362	"	"	``
18637	25119	363	possesions	possesion	NNS
18637	25119	364	"	"	''
18637	25119	365	to	to	IN
18637	25119	366	"	"	``
18637	25119	367	possessions	possession	NNS
18637	25119	368	"	"	''
18637	25119	369	and	and	CC
18637	25119	370	added	add	VBD
18637	25119	371	opening	opening	NN
18637	25119	372	quotes	quote	NNS
18637	25119	373	in	in	IN
18637	25119	374	front	front	NN
18637	25119	375	of	of	IN
18637	25119	376	numbered	numbered	JJ
18637	25119	377	paragraphs	paragraph	NNS
18637	25119	378	page	page	NN
18637	25119	379	255	255	CD
18637	25119	380	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	381	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25119	382	opening	opening	NN
18637	25119	383	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	25119	384	mark	mark	NN
18637	25119	385	in	in	IN
18637	25119	386	paragraph	paragraph	NN
18637	25119	387	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25119	388	7	7	LS
18637	25119	389	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25119	390	page	page	NN
18637	25119	391	255	255	CD
18637	25119	392	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	393	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25119	394	opening	opening	NN
18637	25119	395	quotes	quote	NNS
18637	25119	396	in	in	IN
18637	25119	397	front	front	NN
18637	25119	398	of	of	IN
18637	25119	399	numbered	numbered	JJ
18637	25119	400	paragraphs	paragraph	NNS
18637	25119	401	and	and	CC
18637	25119	402	removed	remove	VBN
18637	25119	403	unmatched	unmatched	JJ
18637	25119	404	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	25119	405	mark	mark	NN
18637	25119	406	after	after	IN
18637	25119	407	"	"	``
18637	25119	408	descent	descent	NN
18637	25119	409	"	"	''
18637	25119	410	in	in	IN
18637	25119	411	"	"	''
18637	25119	412	...	...	:
18637	25119	413	persons	person	NNS
18637	25119	414	of	of	IN
18637	25119	415	Chinese	chinese	JJ
18637	25119	416	descent	descent	NN
18637	25119	417	"	"	''
18637	25119	418	;	;	:
18637	25119	419	"	"	``
18637	25119	420	page	page	NN
18637	25119	421	260	260	CD
18637	25119	422	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	423	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	424	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	425	of	of	IN
18637	25119	426	"	"	``
18637	25119	427	esssential	esssential	JJ
18637	25119	428	"	"	''
18637	25119	429	to	to	IN
18637	25119	430	essential	essential	JJ
18637	25119	431	"	"	``
18637	25119	432	page	page	NN
18637	25119	433	263	263	CD
18637	25119	434	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	435	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	436	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	437	of	of	IN
18637	25119	438	"	"	``
18637	25119	439	disolved	disolve	VBN
18637	25119	440	"	"	''
18637	25119	441	to	to	TO
18637	25119	442	"	"	``
18637	25119	443	dissolved	dissolve	VBN
18637	25119	444	"	"	''
18637	25119	445	pages	page	VBZ
18637	25119	446	272	272	CD
18637	25119	447	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	448	273	273	CD
18637	25119	449	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	450	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25119	451	opening	opening	NN
18637	25119	452	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	25119	453	marks	mark	NNS
18637	25119	454	to	to	IN
18637	25119	455	each	each	DT
18637	25119	456	paragraph	paragraph	NN
18637	25119	457	of	of	IN
18637	25119	458	list	list	NN
18637	25119	459	of	of	IN
18637	25119	460	patent	patent	NN
18637	25119	461	court	court	NN
18637	25119	462	cases	case	NNS
18637	25119	463	page	page	VBP
18637	25119	464	273	273	CD
18637	25119	465	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	466	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	467	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	468	of	of	IN
18637	25119	469	"	"	``
18637	25119	470	reinfore	reinfore	NN
18637	25119	471	"	"	''
18637	25119	472	to	to	TO
18637	25119	473	"	"	``
18637	25119	474	reinforce	reinforce	VB
18637	25119	475	"	"	''
18637	25119	476	page	page	NN
18637	25119	477	276	276	CD
18637	25119	478	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	479	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	480	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	481	of	of	IN
18637	25119	482	"	"	``
18637	25119	483	Farenheit	Farenheit	NNP
18637	25119	484	"	"	''
18637	25119	485	to	to	TO
18637	25119	486	"	"	``
18637	25119	487	Fahrenheit	Fahrenheit	NNP
18637	25119	488	"	"	''
18637	25119	489	page	page	NN
18637	25119	490	277	277	CD
18637	25119	491	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	492	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25119	493	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25119	494	of	of	IN
18637	25119	495	"	"	``
18637	25119	496	Revolutionory	Revolutionory	NNP
18637	25119	497	"	"	''
18637	25119	498	to	to	IN
18637	25119	499	"	"	``
18637	25119	500	Revolutionary	Revolutionary	NNP
18637	25119	501	"	"	''
18637	25119	502	page	page	NN
18637	25119	503	281	281	CD
18637	25119	504	-	-	HYPH
18637	25119	505	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25119	506	ending	end	VBG
18637	25119	507	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	25119	508	mark	mark	NN
18637	25119	509	after	after	IN
18637	25119	510	"	"	''
18637	25119	511	...	...	NFP
18637	25119	512	was	be	VBD
18637	25119	513	liberated	liberate	VBN
18637	25119	514	with	with	IN
18637	25119	515	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	25119	516	crew	crew	NN
18637	25119	517	.	.	.
18637	25119	518	"	"	''
18637	25120	1	page	page	NN
18637	25120	2	297	297	CD
18637	25120	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25120	4	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25120	5	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25120	6	of	of	IN
18637	25120	7	"	"	``
18637	25120	8	concered	concere	VBN
18637	25120	9	"	"	''
18637	25120	10	to	to	IN
18637	25120	11	"	"	``
18637	25120	12	concerned	concerned	JJ
18637	25120	13	"	"	''
18637	25120	14	page	page	NN
18637	25120	15	308	308	CD
18637	25120	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	25120	17	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25120	18	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25120	19	of	of	IN
18637	25120	20	"	"	``
18637	25120	21	ocurred	ocurre	VBN
18637	25120	22	"	"	''
18637	25120	23	to	to	TO
18637	25120	24	"	"	``
18637	25120	25	occurred	occur	VBN
18637	25120	26	"	"	''
18637	25120	27	page	page	NN
18637	25120	28	343	343	CD
18637	25120	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	25120	30	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25120	31	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25120	32	of	of	IN
18637	25120	33	"	"	``
18637	25120	34	eath	eath	NN
18637	25120	35	"	"	''
18637	25120	36	to	to	IN
18637	25120	37	"	"	``
18637	25120	38	each	each	DT
18637	25120	39	"	"	''
18637	25120	40	page	page	NN
18637	25120	41	356	356	CD
18637	25120	42	-	-	HYPH
18637	25120	43	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25120	44	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25120	45	of	of	IN
18637	25120	46	"	"	``
18637	25120	47	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	25120	48	Frankfurther	Frankfurther	NNP
18637	25120	49	"	"	''
18637	25120	50	to	to	IN
18637	25120	51	"	"	``
18637	25120	52	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	25120	53	Frankfurter	Frankfurter	NNP
18637	25120	54	"	"	''
18637	25120	55	page	page	NN
18637	25120	56	389	389	CD
18637	25120	57	-	-	HYPH
18637	25120	58	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25120	59	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25120	60	of	of	IN
18637	25120	61	"	"	``
18637	25120	62	probabilty	probabilty	NN
18637	25120	63	"	"	''
18637	25120	64	to	to	IN
18637	25120	65	"	"	``
18637	25120	66	probability	probability	NN
18637	25120	67	"	"	''
18637	25120	68	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25120	69	55	55	CD
18637	25120	70	-	-	HYPH
18637	25120	71	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25120	72	comma	comma	NN
18637	25120	73	to	to	TO
18637	25120	74	period	period	VB
18637	25120	75	in	in	IN
18637	25120	76	"	"	``
18637	25120	77	United	United	NNP
18637	25120	78	States	States	NNP
18637	25120	79	ex	ex	NNP
18637	25120	80	rel	rel	NN
18637	25120	81	,	,	,
18637	25120	82	Tisi	Tisi	NNP
18637	25120	83	v.	v.	IN
18637	25120	84	Tod	Tod	NNP
18637	25120	85	"	"	``
18637	25120	86	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25120	87	139	139	CD
18637	25120	88	-	-	HYPH
18637	25120	89	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25120	90	comma	comma	NN
18637	25120	91	after	after	IN
18637	25120	92	"	"	``
18637	25120	93	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	25120	94	.	.	.
18637	25120	95	"	"	''
18637	25121	1	in	in	IN
18637	25121	2	"	"	``
18637	25121	3	9	9	CD
18637	25121	4	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	25121	5	.	.	.
18637	25121	6	,	,	,
18637	25121	7	428	428	CD
18637	25121	8	,	,	,
18637	25121	9	432	432	CD
18637	25121	10	-	-	SYM
18637	25121	11	433	433	CD
18637	25121	12	"	"	''
18637	25121	13	and	and	CC
18637	25121	14	removed	remove	VBN
18637	25121	15	question	question	NN
18637	25121	16	mark	mark	NN
18637	25121	17	in	in	IN
18637	25121	18	"	"	``
18637	25121	19	Grand	Grand	NNP
18637	25121	20	Depository	Depository	NNP
18637	25121	21	of	of	IN
18637	25121	22	the	the	DT
18637	25121	23	Democratic	Democratic	NNP
18637	25121	24	Principle	Principle	NNP
18637	25121	25	"	"	''
18637	25121	26	?	?	.
18637	25122	1	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25122	2	215	215	CD
18637	25122	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25122	4	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25122	5	comma	comma	NN
18637	25122	6	after	after	IN
18637	25122	7	"	"	``
18637	25122	8	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	25122	9	"	"	''
18637	25122	10	to	to	IN
18637	25122	11	period--"Hollingsworth	period--"Hollingsworth	NNP
18637	25122	12	v.	v.	CC
18637	25122	13	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
18637	25122	14	,	,	,
18637	25122	15	3	3	CD
18637	25122	16	Dall	Dall	NNP
18637	25122	17	,	,	,
18637	25122	18	378	378	CD
18637	25122	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25122	20	1798	1798	CD
18637	25122	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25122	22	.	.	.
18637	25122	23	"	"	''
18637	25123	1	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25123	2	353	353	CD
18637	25123	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25123	4	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25123	5	comma	comma	NN
18637	25123	6	after	after	IN
18637	25123	7	"	"	``
18637	25123	8	Ball	Ball	NNP
18637	25123	9	"	"	''
18637	25123	10	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25123	11	366	366	CD
18637	25123	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	25123	13	-removed	-removed	JJ
18637	25123	14	period	period	NN
18637	25123	15	after	after	IN
18637	25123	16	"	"	``
18637	25123	17	at	at	IN
18637	25123	18	"	"	``
18637	25123	19	in	in	IN
18637	25123	20	"	"	``
18637	25123	21	311	311	CD
18637	25123	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25123	23	at	at	IN
18637	25123	24	426	426	CD
18637	25123	25	.	.	.
18637	25123	26	"	"	''
18637	25124	1	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25124	2	472	472	CD
18637	25124	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25124	4	-inserted	-inserte	VBN
18637	25124	5	hyphen	hyphen	NN
18637	25124	6	in	in	IN
18637	25124	7	"	"	``
18637	25124	8	Cooperative	Cooperative	NNP
18637	25124	9	"	"	''
18637	25124	10	in	in	IN
18637	25124	11	"	"	``
18637	25124	12	United	United	NNP
18637	25124	13	States	States	NNP
18637	25124	14	v.	v.	IN
18637	25124	15	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	25124	16	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	25124	17	Cooperative	Cooperative	NNP
18637	25124	18	"	"	''
18637	25124	19	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25124	20	565	565	CD
18637	25124	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	25124	22	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25124	23	comma	comma	NN
18637	25124	24	after	after	IN
18637	25124	25	"	"	``
18637	25124	26	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	25124	27	"	"	''
18637	25124	28	in	in	IN
18637	25124	29	"	"	``
18637	25124	30	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
18637	25124	31	Air	Air	NNP
18637	25124	32	Transport	Transport	NNP
18637	25124	33	,	,	,
18637	25124	34	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
18637	25124	35	v.	v.	CC
18637	25124	36	South	South	NNP
18637	25124	37	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	25124	38	Tax	Tax	NNP
18637	25124	39	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
18637	25124	40	.	.	.
18637	25124	41	"	"	''
18637	25125	1	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25125	2	576	576	CD
18637	25125	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25125	4	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25125	5	space	space	NN
18637	25125	6	between	between	IN
18637	25125	7	"	"	``
18637	25125	8	air	air	NN
18637	25125	9	"	"	''
18637	25125	10	and	and	CC
18637	25125	11	"	"	``
18637	25125	12	transport	transport	NN
18637	25125	13	"	"	''
18637	25125	14	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25125	15	641	641	CD
18637	25125	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	25125	17	-corrected	-corrected	NN
18637	25125	18	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25125	19	of	of	IN
18637	25125	20	"	"	``
18637	25125	21	colleced	collece	VBN
18637	25125	22	"	"	''
18637	25125	23	to	to	IN
18637	25125	24	"	"	``
18637	25125	25	collected	collect	VBN
18637	25125	26	"	"	''
18637	25125	27	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25125	28	789	789	CD
18637	25125	29	-	-	HYPH
18637	25125	30	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25125	31	space	space	NN
18637	25125	32	between	between	IN
18637	25125	33	"	"	``
18637	25125	34	Di	Di	NNP
18637	25125	35	"	"	''
18637	25125	36	and	and	CC
18637	25125	37	"	"	``
18637	25125	38	Santo	Santo	NNP
18637	25125	39	"	"	''
18637	25125	40	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25125	41	807	807	CD
18637	25125	42	-	-	HYPH
18637	25125	43	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25125	44	"	"	''
18637	25125	45	J.R.	J.R.	NNP
18637	25125	46	"	"	''
18637	25125	47	to	to	IN
18637	25125	48	"	"	``
18637	25125	49	L.R.	L.R.	NNP
18637	25125	50	"	"	''
18637	25126	1	in	in	IN
18637	25126	2	"	"	``
18637	25126	3	Hannibal	Hannibal	NNP
18637	25126	4	&	&	CC
18637	25126	5	St.	St.	NNP
18637	25126	6	J.R.	J.R.	NNP
18637	25126	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25126	8	v.	v.	IN
18637	25126	9	Husen	Husen	NNP
18637	25126	10	"	"	``
18637	25126	11	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25126	12	1061	1061	CD
18637	25126	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	25126	14	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25126	15	period	period	NN
18637	25126	16	after	after	IN
18637	25126	17	"	"	``
18637	25126	18	Elg	Elg	NNP
18637	25126	19	"	"	''
18637	25126	20	in	in	IN
18637	25126	21	"	"	``
18637	25126	22	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
18637	25126	23	v.	v.	IN
18637	25127	1	Elg	Elg	NNP
18637	25127	2	.	.	.
18637	25127	3	"	"	''
18637	25128	1	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25128	2	1121	1121	CD
18637	25128	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25128	4	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25128	5	comma	comma	NN
18637	25128	6	in	in	IN
18637	25128	7	"	"	``
18637	25128	8	218	218	CD
18637	25128	9	,	,	,
18637	25128	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25128	11	302	302	CD
18637	25128	12	"	"	``
18637	25128	13	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25128	14	1160	1160	CD
18637	25128	15	-	-	HYPH
18637	25128	16	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25128	17	period	period	NN
18637	25128	18	after	after	IN
18637	25128	19	"	"	``
18637	25128	20	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	25128	21	"	"	''
18637	25128	22	in	in	IN
18637	25128	23	"	"	``
18637	25128	24	Eunson	Eunson	NNP
18637	25128	25	v.	v.	IN
18637	25128	26	Dodge	Dodge	NNP
18637	25128	27	,	,	,
18637	25128	28	18	18	CD
18637	25128	29	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	25128	30	.	.	.
18637	25129	1	414	414	CD
18637	25129	2	,	,	,
18637	25129	3	416	416	CD
18637	25129	4	"	"	``
18637	25129	5	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25129	6	1168	1168	CD
18637	25129	7	-	-	:
18637	25129	8	-in	-in	-RRB-
18637	25129	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
18637	25129	10	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
18637	25129	11	quote	quote	VBP
18637	25129	12	,	,	,
18637	25129	13	moved	move	VBD
18637	25129	14	ending	end	VBG
18637	25129	15	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	25129	16	mark	mark	NN
18637	25129	17	after	after	IN
18637	25129	18	"	"	''
18637	25129	19	...	...	NFP
18637	25129	20	made	make	VBN
18637	25129	21	in	in	IN
18637	25129	22	good	good	JJ
18637	25129	23	faith	faith	NN
18637	25129	24	.	.	.
18637	25129	25	"	"	''
18637	25130	1	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25130	2	1190	1190	CD
18637	25130	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25130	4	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25130	5	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25130	6	of	of	IN
18637	25130	7	"	"	``
18637	25130	8	Bleisten	Bleisten	NNP
18637	25130	9	"	"	''
18637	25130	10	to	to	TO
18637	25130	11	"	"	``
18637	25130	12	Bleistein	Bleistein	NNP
18637	25130	13	"	"	''
18637	25130	14	in	in	IN
18637	25130	15	"	"	``
18637	25130	16	Bleisten	Bleisten	NNP
18637	25130	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	25130	18	Donaldson	Donaldson	NNP
18637	25130	19	Lithographing	Lithographing	NNP
18637	25130	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25130	21	"	"	``
18637	25130	22	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25130	23	1221	1221	CD
18637	25130	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	25130	25	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25130	26	period	period	NN
18637	25130	27	after	after	IN
18637	25130	28	"	"	``
18637	25130	29	Bas	Bas	NNP
18637	25130	30	"	"	''
18637	25130	31	in	in	IN
18637	25130	32	"	"	``
18637	25130	33	Bas	Bas	NNP
18637	25130	34	.	.	.
18637	25131	1	v.	v.	IN
18637	25131	2	Tingy	Tingy	NNP
18637	25131	3	"	"	``
18637	25131	4	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25131	5	1299	1299	CD
18637	25131	6	-	-	HYPH
18637	25131	7	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25131	8	comma	comma	NN
18637	25131	9	to	to	TO
18637	25131	10	period	period	VB
18637	25131	11	after	after	IN
18637	25131	12	"	"	``
18637	25131	13	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	25131	14	"	"	''
18637	25131	15	in	in	IN
18637	25131	16	"	"	``
18637	25131	17	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	25131	18	v.	v.	IN
18637	25131	19	United	United	NNP
18637	25131	20	States	States	NNP
18637	25131	21	,	,	,
18637	25131	22	11	11	CD
18637	25131	23	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	25131	24	.	.	.
18637	25132	1	268	268	CD
18637	25132	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25132	3	1871	1871	CD
18637	25132	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25132	5	.	.	.
18637	25132	6	"	"	''
18637	25133	1	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25133	2	1350	1350	CD
18637	25133	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25133	4	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25133	5	"	"	``
18637	25133	6	Sere	sere	RB
18637	25133	7	"	"	''
18637	25133	8	to	to	TO
18637	25133	9	"	"	``
18637	25133	10	Serè	serã¨	FW
18637	25133	11	"	"	''
18637	25133	12	in	in	IN
18637	25133	13	"	"	``
18637	25133	14	Sere	Sere	NNP
18637	25133	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	25133	16	Pitot	Pitot	NNP
18637	25133	17	"	"	''
18637	25133	18	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25133	19	1613	1613	CD
18637	25133	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	25133	21	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25133	22	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25133	23	of	of	IN
18637	25133	24	"	"	``
18637	25133	25	Diety	Diety	NNP
18637	25133	26	"	"	''
18637	25133	27	to	to	IN
18637	25133	28	"	"	``
18637	25133	29	Deity	Deity	NNP
18637	25133	30	"	"	''
18637	25133	31	in	in	IN
18637	25133	32	"	"	''
18637	25133	33	...	...	:
18637	25133	34	principle	principle	NN
18637	25133	35	which	which	WDT
18637	25133	36	will	will	MD
18637	25133	37	impose	impose	VB
18637	25133	38	laws	law	NNS
18637	25133	39	even	even	RB
18637	25133	40	on	on	IN
18637	25133	41	the	the	DT
18637	25133	42	Diety	Diety	NNP
18637	25133	43	....	....	NFP
18637	25133	44	"	"	''
18637	25133	45	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25133	46	1634	1634	CD
18637	25133	47	-	-	HYPH
18637	25133	48	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25133	49	"	"	``
18637	25133	50	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	25133	51	,	,	,
18637	25133	52	"	"	''
18637	25133	53	to	to	TO
18637	25133	54	"	"	``
18637	25133	55	Cf	Cf	NNP
18637	25133	56	.	.	.
18637	25133	57	"	"	''
18637	25134	1	Article	article	NN
18637	25134	2	II	ii	CD
18637	25134	3	page	page	NN
18637	25134	4	413	413	CD
18637	25134	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	25134	6	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25134	7	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25134	8	of	of	IN
18637	25134	9	"	"	``
18637	25134	10	soverign	soverign	JJ
18637	25134	11	"	"	''
18637	25134	12	to	to	IN
18637	25134	13	"	"	``
18637	25134	14	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
18637	25134	15	"	"	''
18637	25134	16	page	page	NN
18637	25134	17	433	433	CD
18637	25134	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	25134	19	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25134	20	"	"	''
18637	25134	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25134	22	"	"	''
18637	25134	23	to	to	TO
18637	25134	24	"	"	``
18637	25134	25	the	the	DT
18637	25134	26	"	"	''
18637	25134	27	in	in	IN
18637	25134	28	"	"	''
18637	25134	29	...	...	:
18637	25134	30	by	by	IN
18637	25134	31	the	the	DT
18637	25134	32	settlement	settlement	NN
18637	25134	33	the	the	DT
18637	25134	34	effect	effect	NN
18637	25134	35	of	of	IN
18637	25134	36	these	these	DT
18637	25134	37	cease	cease	NN
18637	25134	38	<	<	XX
18637	25134	39	i	i	PRP
18637	25134	40	>	>	XX
18637	25134	41	ipso	ipso	FW
18637	25134	42	facto</i	facto</i	NNP
18637	25134	43	>	>	NN
18637	25134	44	to	to	TO
18637	25134	45	be	be	VB
18637	25134	46	operative	operative	JJ
18637	25134	47	....	....	.
18637	25134	48	"	"	''
18637	25134	49	page	page	NN
18637	25134	50	443	443	CD
18637	25134	51	-	-	HYPH
18637	25134	52	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25134	53	comma	comma	NN
18637	25134	54	after	after	IN
18637	25134	55	"	"	``
18637	25134	56	sell	sell	VB
18637	25134	57	"	"	''
18637	25134	58	in	in	IN
18637	25134	59	"	"	''
18637	25134	60	...	...	.
18637	25134	61	sell	sell	VB
18637	25134	62	,	,	,
18637	25134	63	transfer	transfer	NN
18637	25134	64	title	title	NN
18637	25134	65	to	to	IN
18637	25134	66	,	,	,
18637	25134	67	exchange	exchange	NN
18637	25134	68	,	,	,
18637	25134	69	lease	lease	NN
18637	25134	70	,	,	,
18637	25134	71	lend	lend	VB
18637	25134	72	,	,	,
18637	25134	73	or	or	CC
18637	25134	74	otherwise	otherwise	RB
18637	25134	75	dispose	dispose	VB
18637	25134	76	of	of	IN
18637	25134	77	....	....	NFP
18637	25134	78	"	"	''
18637	25134	79	page	page	NN
18637	25134	80	444	444	CD
18637	25134	81	-	-	HYPH
18637	25134	82	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25134	83	comma	comma	NN
18637	25134	84	after	after	IN
18637	25134	85	"	"	``
18637	25134	86	governments	government	NNS
18637	25134	87	"	"	''
18637	25134	88	in	in	IN
18637	25134	89	"	"	''
18637	25134	90	...	...	NFP
18637	25134	91	claims	claim	NNS
18637	25134	92	against	against	IN
18637	25134	93	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	25134	94	governments	government	NNS
18637	25134	95	,	,	,
18637	25134	96	fourteen	fourteen	CD
18637	25134	97	were	be	VBD
18637	25134	98	claims	claim	NNS
18637	25134	99	....	....	NFP
18637	25134	100	"	"	``
18637	25134	101	page	page	NN
18637	25134	102	472	472	CD
18637	25134	103	-	-	HYPH
18637	25134	104	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25134	105	extraneous	extraneous	NN
18637	25134	106	"	"	''
18637	25134	107	to	to	TO
18637	25134	108	"	"	``
18637	25134	109	in	in	IN
18637	25134	110	"	"	''
18637	25134	111	...	...	NFP
18637	25134	112	assume	assume	VB
18637	25134	113	a	a	DT
18637	25134	114	fact	fact	NN
18637	25134	115	in	in	IN
18637	25134	116	regard	regard	NN
18637	25134	117	to	to	IN
18637	25134	118	to	to	IN
18637	25134	119	the	the	DT
18637	25134	120	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
18637	25134	121	....	....	.
18637	25134	122	"	"	''
18637	25134	123	page	page	NN
18637	25134	124	492	492	CD
18637	25134	125	-	-	HYPH
18637	25134	126	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25134	127	"	"	''
18637	25134	128	after	after	IN
18637	25134	129	"	"	``
18637	25134	130	action	action	NN
18637	25134	131	"	"	''
18637	25134	132	in	in	IN
18637	25134	133	"	"	''
18637	25134	134	...	...	:
18637	25134	135	successful	successful	JJ
18637	25134	136	defense	defense	NN
18637	25134	137	of	of	IN
18637	25134	138	the	the	DT
18637	25134	139	President	President	NNP
18637	25134	140	's	's	POS
18637	25134	141	action	action	NN
18637	25134	142	,	,	,
18637	25134	143	"	"	''
18637	25134	144	....	....	NFP
18637	25134	145	"	"	``
18637	25134	146	page	page	NN
18637	25134	147	495	495	CD
18637	25134	148	-	-	HYPH
18637	25134	149	-removed	-removed	JJ
18637	25134	150	comma	comma	NN
18637	25134	151	after	after	IN
18637	25134	152	"	"	``
18637	25134	153	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25134	154	"	"	''
18637	25134	155	in	in	IN
18637	25134	156	"	"	``
18637	25134	157	158	158	CD
18637	25134	158	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25134	159	,	,	,
18637	25134	160	564	564	CD
18637	25134	161	,	,	,
18637	25134	162	578	578	CD
18637	25134	163	"	"	''
18637	25134	164	and	and	CC
18637	25134	165	removed	remove	VBN
18637	25134	166	comma	comma	NN
18637	25134	167	after	after	IN
18637	25134	168	"	"	``
18637	25134	169	Wheat	Wheat	NNP
18637	25134	170	.	.	.
18637	25134	171	"	"	''
18637	25135	1	in	in	IN
18637	25135	2	"	"	``
18637	25135	3	4	4	CD
18637	25135	4	Wheat	Wheat	NNP
18637	25135	5	.	.	.
18637	25135	6	,	,	,
18637	25135	7	316	316	CD
18637	25135	8	,	,	,
18637	25135	9	424	424	CD
18637	25135	10	"	"	``
18637	25135	11	page	page	NN
18637	25135	12	502	502	CD
18637	25135	13	-	-	HYPH
18637	25135	14	-corrected	-corrected	NNP
18637	25135	15	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
18637	25135	16	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
18637	25135	17	quote	quote	UH
18637	25135	18	from	from	IN
18637	25135	19	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
18637	25135	20	No	no	UH
18637	25135	21	.	.	.
18637	25136	1	65	65	CD
18637	25136	2	by	by	IN
18637	25136	3	changing	change	VBG
18637	25136	4	"	"	``
18637	25136	5	a	a	DT
18637	25136	6	"	"	''
18637	25136	7	to	to	TO
18637	25136	8	"	"	''
18637	25136	9	in	in	IN
18637	25136	10	"	"	''
18637	25136	11	in	in	IN
18637	25136	12	"	"	''
18637	25136	13	...	...	NFP
18637	25136	14	as	as	IN
18637	25136	15	in	in	IN
18637	25136	16	common	common	JJ
18637	25136	17	cases	case	NNS
18637	25136	18	serve	serve	VBP
18637	25136	19	to	to	TO
18637	25136	20	limit	limit	VB
18637	25136	21	....	....	.
18637	25136	22	"	"	''
18637	25136	23	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25136	24	85	85	CD
18637	25136	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	25136	26	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25136	27	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25136	28	of	of	IN
18637	25136	29	"	"	``
18637	25136	30	Kahanomoku	Kahanomoku	NNP
18637	25136	31	"	"	''
18637	25136	32	to	to	IN
18637	25136	33	"	"	``
18637	25136	34	Kahanamoku	Kahanamoku	NNP
18637	25136	35	"	"	''
18637	25136	36	in	in	IN
18637	25136	37	"	"	``
18637	25136	38	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
18637	25136	39	v.	v.	IN
18637	25136	40	Kahanomoku	Kahanomoku	NNP
18637	25136	41	"	"	``
18637	25136	42	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25136	43	121	121	CD
18637	25136	44	-	-	HYPH
18637	25136	45	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25136	46	period	period	NN
18637	25136	47	after	after	IN
18637	25136	48	"	"	``
18637	25136	49	H	H	NNP
18637	25136	50	"	"	''
18637	25136	51	in	in	IN
18637	25136	52	"	"	``
18637	25136	53	W.H.	W.H.	NNP
18637	25137	1	Humbert	Humbert	NNP
18637	25137	2	"	"	``
18637	25137	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25137	4	158	158	CD
18637	25137	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	25137	6	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25137	7	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25137	8	of	of	IN
18637	25137	9	"	"	``
18637	25137	10	forefeiture	forefeiture	NN
18637	25137	11	"	"	''
18637	25137	12	to	to	TO
18637	25137	13	"	"	``
18637	25137	14	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
18637	25137	15	"	"	''
18637	25137	16	and	and	CC
18637	25137	17	corrected	correct	VBD
18637	25137	18	"	"	''
18637	25137	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25137	20	"	"	``
18637	25137	21	to	to	TO
18637	25137	22	"	"	``
18637	25137	23	be	be	VB
18637	25137	24	"	"	''
18637	25137	25	in	in	IN
18637	25137	26	"	"	''
18637	25137	27	...	...	.
18637	25137	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25137	29	the	the	DT
18637	25137	30	subject	subject	JJ
18637	25137	31	matter	matter	NN
18637	25137	32	what	what	WP
18637	25137	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25137	34	may	may	MD
18637	25137	35	....	....	.
18637	25137	36	"	"	''
18637	25137	37	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25137	38	172	172	CD
18637	25137	39	-	-	HYPH
18637	25137	40	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25137	41	comma	comma	NN
18637	25137	42	to	to	TO
18637	25137	43	period	period	VB
18637	25137	44	in	in	IN
18637	25137	45	"	"	``
18637	25137	46	6	6	CD
18637	25137	47	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	25137	48	.	.	.
18637	25138	1	160	160	CD
18637	25138	2	"	"	``
18637	25138	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25138	4	187	187	CD
18637	25138	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	6	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25138	7	"	"	''
18637	25138	8	procedents	procedent	NNS
18637	25138	9	"	"	''
18637	25138	10	to	to	TO
18637	25138	11	"	"	``
18637	25138	12	precedents	precedent	NNS
18637	25138	13	"	"	''
18637	25138	14	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25138	15	207	207	CD
18637	25138	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	17	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25138	18	apostrophe	apostrophe	NN
18637	25138	19	after	after	IN
18637	25138	20	"	"	``
18637	25138	21	States	States	NNPS
18637	25138	22	"	"	''
18637	25138	23	in	in	IN
18637	25138	24	"	"	''
18637	25138	25	...	...	:
18637	25138	26	power	power	NN
18637	25138	27	can	can	MD
18637	25138	28	consent	consent	VB
18637	25138	29	to	to	IN
18637	25138	30	the	the	DT
18637	25138	31	United	United	NNP
18637	25138	32	States	States	NNP
18637	25138	33	being	be	VBG
18637	25138	34	used	use	VBN
18637	25138	35	....	....	.
18637	25138	36	"	"	''
18637	25138	37	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25138	38	281	281	CD
18637	25138	39	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	40	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25138	41	period	period	NN
18637	25138	42	after	after	IN
18637	25138	43	"	"	``
18637	25138	44	Senate	Senate	NNP
18637	25138	45	"	"	''
18637	25138	46	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25138	47	286	286	CD
18637	25138	48	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	49	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25138	50	missing	miss	VBG
18637	25138	51	words	word	NNS
18637	25138	52	[	[	-LRB-
18637	25138	53	clerical	clerical	JJ
18637	25138	54	superiors	superior	NNS
18637	25138	55	shall	shall	MD
18637	25138	56	receive	receive	VB
18637	25138	57	any	any	DT
18637	25138	58	gift	gift	NN
18637	25138	59	or	or	CC
18637	25138	60	]	]	-RRB-
18637	25138	61	in	in	IN
18637	25138	62	brackets	bracket	NNS
18637	25138	63	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25138	64	330	330	CD
18637	25138	65	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	66	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25138	67	comma	comma	NN
18637	25138	68	after	after	IN
18637	25138	69	"	"	``
18637	25138	70	VI	VI	NNP
18637	25138	71	"	"	''
18637	25138	72	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25138	73	371	371	CD
18637	25138	74	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	75	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25138	76	comma	comma	NN
18637	25138	77	after	after	IN
18637	25138	78	"	"	``
18637	25138	79	S.A.	S.A.	NNP
18637	25138	80	"	"	''
18637	25138	81	in	in	IN
18637	25138	82	"	"	``
18637	25138	83	Compania	Compania	NNP
18637	25138	84	Espanola	Espanola	NNP
18637	25138	85	de	de	NNP
18637	25138	86	Navegacion	Navegacion	NNP
18637	25138	87	Maritima	Maritima	NNP
18637	25138	88	,	,	,
18637	25138	89	S.A.	S.A.	NNP
18637	25138	90	,	,	,
18637	25138	91	"	"	``
18637	25138	92	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25138	93	485	485	CD
18637	25138	94	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	95	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25138	96	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25138	97	of	of	IN
18637	25138	98	"	"	``
18637	25138	99	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
18637	25138	100	"	"	''
18637	25138	101	to	to	IN
18637	25138	102	"	"	``
18637	25138	103	Diary	Diary	NNP
18637	25138	104	"	"	''
18637	25138	105	Article	article	NN
18637	25138	106	III	iii	CD
18637	25138	107	page	page	NN
18637	25138	108	515	515	CD
18637	25138	109	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	110	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25138	111	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25138	112	of	of	IN
18637	25138	113	"	"	``
18637	25138	114	sutained	sutaine	VBN
18637	25138	115	"	"	''
18637	25138	116	to	to	TO
18637	25138	117	"	"	``
18637	25138	118	sustained	sustain	VBN
18637	25138	119	"	"	''
18637	25138	120	page	page	NN
18637	25138	121	526	526	CD
18637	25138	122	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	123	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25138	124	space	space	NN
18637	25138	125	between	between	IN
18637	25138	126	"	"	``
18637	25138	127	any	any	DT
18637	25138	128	"	"	''
18637	25138	129	and	and	CC
18637	25138	130	"	"	``
18637	25138	131	one	one	CD
18637	25138	132	"	"	''
18637	25138	133	page	page	NN
18637	25138	134	530	530	CD
18637	25138	135	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	136	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25138	137	comma	comma	NN
18637	25138	138	after	after	IN
18637	25138	139	"	"	``
18637	25138	140	Revenue	revenue	NN
18637	25138	141	"	"	''
18637	25138	142	in	in	IN
18637	25138	143	"	"	``
18637	25138	144	O'Malley	O'Malley	NNP
18637	25138	145	,	,	,
18637	25138	146	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	25138	147	of	of	IN
18637	25138	148	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	25138	149	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
18637	25138	150	<	<	XX
18637	25138	151	i	i	PRP
18637	25138	152	>	>	XX
18637	25138	153	v.</i	v.</i	NNP
18637	25138	154	>	>	XX
18637	25138	155	Woodrough	Woodrough	NNP
18637	25138	156	"	"	``
18637	25138	157	page	page	NN
18637	25138	158	540	540	CD
18637	25138	159	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	160	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25138	161	closing	closing	NN
18637	25138	162	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	25138	163	mark	mark	NN
18637	25138	164	before	before	IN
18637	25138	165	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25138	166	156	156	CD
18637	25138	167	anchor	anchor	NN
18637	25138	168	page	page	NN
18637	25138	169	545	545	CD
18637	25138	170	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	171	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25138	172	extraneous	extraneous	JJ
18637	25138	173	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	25138	174	mark	mark	NN
18637	25138	175	before	before	IN
18637	25138	176	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25138	177	anchor	anchor	NN
18637	25138	178	187	187	CD
18637	25138	179	page	page	NN
18637	25138	180	562	562	CD
18637	25138	181	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	182	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25138	183	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25138	184	of	of	IN
18637	25138	185	"	"	``
18637	25138	186	constitionality	constitionality	NN
18637	25138	187	"	"	''
18637	25138	188	to	to	TO
18637	25138	189	"	"	``
18637	25138	190	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
18637	25138	191	"	"	''
18637	25138	192	page	page	NN
18637	25138	193	586	586	CD
18637	25138	194	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	195	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25138	196	first	first	JJ
18637	25138	197	"	"	''
18637	25138	198	as	as	IN
18637	25138	199	"	"	``
18637	25138	200	to	to	TO
18637	25138	201	"	"	``
18637	25138	202	an	an	DT
18637	25138	203	"	"	''
18637	25138	204	in	in	IN
18637	25138	205	"	"	''
18637	25138	206	Although	although	IN
18637	25138	207	as	as	IN
18637	25138	208	officer	officer	NN
18637	25138	209	acting	act	VBG
18637	25138	210	as	as	IN
18637	25138	211	a	a	DT
18637	25138	212	public	public	NN
18637	25138	213	....	....	NFP
18637	25138	214	"	"	``
18637	25138	215	page	page	NN
18637	25138	216	587	587	CD
18637	25138	217	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	218	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25138	219	"	"	''
18637	25138	220	is	be	VBZ
18637	25138	221	"	"	``
18637	25138	222	to	to	TO
18637	25138	223	"	"	``
18637	25138	224	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25138	225	"	"	''
18637	25138	226	in	in	IN
18637	25138	227	"	"	''
18637	25138	228	...	...	NFP
18637	25138	229	where	where	WRB
18637	25138	230	is	be	VBZ
18637	25138	231	was	be	VBD
18637	25138	232	held	hold	VBN
18637	25138	233	....	....	NFP
18637	25138	234	"	"	``
18637	25138	235	page	page	NN
18637	25138	236	607	607	CD
18637	25138	237	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	238	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25138	239	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25138	240	of	of	IN
18637	25138	241	"	"	``
18637	25138	242	longr	longr	JJ
18637	25138	243	"	"	''
18637	25138	244	to	to	TO
18637	25138	245	"	"	``
18637	25138	246	longer	long	JJR
18637	25138	247	"	"	''
18637	25138	248	page	page	NN
18637	25138	249	611	611	CD
18637	25138	250	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	251	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25138	252	"	"	''
18637	25138	253	where	where	WRB
18637	25138	254	"	"	``
18637	25138	255	to	to	TO
18637	25138	256	"	"	``
18637	25138	257	were	be	VBD
18637	25138	258	"	"	``
18637	25138	259	in	in	IN
18637	25138	260	"	"	''
18637	25138	261	...	...	NFP
18637	25138	262	and	and	CC
18637	25138	263	other	other	JJ
18637	25138	264	States	States	NNPS
18637	25138	265	where	where	WRB
18637	25138	266	so	so	RB
18637	25138	267	disturbed	disturb	VBD
18637	25138	268	that	that	DT
18637	25138	269	....	....	NFP
18637	25138	270	"	"	``
18637	25138	271	page	page	NN
18637	25138	272	623	623	CD
18637	25138	273	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	274	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25138	275	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25138	276	of	of	IN
18637	25138	277	"	"	``
18637	25138	278	Consquently	consquently	RB
18637	25138	279	"	"	''
18637	25138	280	to	to	TO
18637	25138	281	"	"	``
18637	25138	282	Consequently	consequently	RB
18637	25138	283	"	"	''
18637	25138	284	page	page	NN
18637	25138	285	645	645	CD
18637	25138	286	-	-	HYPH
18637	25138	287	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25138	288	closing	closing	NN
18637	25138	289	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	25138	290	mark	mark	NN
18637	25138	291	after	after	IN
18637	25138	292	"	"	``
18637	25138	293	clause	clause	NN
18637	25138	294	2	2	CD
18637	25138	295	.	.	.
18637	25138	296	"	"	''
18637	25139	1	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25139	2	13	13	CD
18637	25139	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25139	4	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25139	5	period	period	NN
18637	25139	6	after	after	IN
18637	25139	7	"	"	``
18637	25139	8	How	how	WRB
18637	25139	9	"	"	''
18637	25139	10	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25139	11	200	200	CD
18637	25139	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	25139	13	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25139	14	period	period	NN
18637	25139	15	at	at	IN
18637	25139	16	end	end	NN
18637	25139	17	of	of	IN
18637	25139	18	sentence	sentence	NN
18637	25139	19	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25139	20	270	270	CD
18637	25139	21	-	-	HYPH
18637	25139	22	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25139	23	comma	comma	NN
18637	25139	24	after	after	IN
18637	25139	25	"	"	``
18637	25139	26	297	297	CD
18637	25139	27	"	"	''
18637	25139	28	in	in	IN
18637	25139	29	"	"	``
18637	25139	30	United	United	NNP
18637	25139	31	States	States	NNP
18637	25139	32	v.	v.	CC
18637	25139	33	Butler	Butler	NNP
18637	25139	34	,	,	,
18637	25139	35	297	297	CD
18637	25139	36	,	,	,
18637	25139	37	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25139	38	1	1	CD
18637	25139	39	,	,	,
18637	25139	40	62	62	CD
18637	25139	41	-	-	SYM
18637	25139	42	63	63	CD
18637	25139	43	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25139	44	1936	1936	CD
18637	25139	45	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25139	46	"	"	``
18637	25139	47	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25139	48	379	379	CD
18637	25139	49	-	-	HYPH
18637	25139	50	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25139	51	comma	comma	NN
18637	25139	52	to	to	IN
18637	25139	53	semi	semi	JJ
18637	25139	54	-	-	JJ
18637	25139	55	colon	colon	NN
18637	25139	56	after	after	IN
18637	25139	57	"	"	''
18637	25139	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25139	59	1867	1867	CD
18637	25139	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25139	61	"	"	``
18637	25139	62	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25139	63	422	422	CD
18637	25139	64	-	-	HYPH
18637	25139	65	-moved	-moved	JJ
18637	25139	66	comma	comma	NN
18637	25139	67	from	from	IN
18637	25139	68	after	after	IN
18637	25139	69	"	"	``
18637	25139	70	339	339	CD
18637	25139	71	"	"	''
18637	25139	72	to	to	IN
18637	25139	73	after	after	IN
18637	25139	74	"	"	``
18637	25139	75	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	25139	76	"	"	''
18637	25139	77	in	in	IN
18637	25139	78	"	"	``
18637	25139	79	United	United	NNP
18637	25139	80	States	States	NNP
18637	25139	81	v.	v.	IN
18637	25139	82	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	25139	83	339	339	CD
18637	25139	84	,	,	,
18637	25139	85	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25139	86	707	707	CD
18637	25139	87	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25139	88	1950	1950	CD
18637	25139	89	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25139	90	"	"	``
18637	25139	91	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25139	92	444	444	CD
18637	25139	93	-	-	HYPH
18637	25139	94	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25139	95	word	word	NN
18637	25139	96	"	"	''
18637	25139	97	to	to	TO
18637	25139	98	"	"	``
18637	25139	99	in	in	IN
18637	25139	100	"	"	''
18637	25139	101	...	...	NFP
18637	25139	102	was	be	VBD
18637	25139	103	held	hold	VBN
18637	25139	104	not	not	RB
18637	25139	105	[	[	-LRB-
18637	25139	106	to	to	TO
18637	25139	107	]	]	-RRB-
18637	25139	108	be	be	VB
18637	25139	109	a	a	DT
18637	25139	110	suit	suit	NN
18637	25139	111	....	....	NFP
18637	25139	112	"	"	''
18637	25139	113	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25139	114	599	599	CD
18637	25139	115	-	-	HYPH
18637	25139	116	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25139	117	reference	reference	NN
18637	25139	118	from	from	IN
18637	25139	119	"	"	``
18637	25139	120	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	25139	121	.	.	.
18637	25140	1	304	304	CD
18637	25140	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25140	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	25140	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25140	5	"	"	''
18637	25140	6	to	to	TO
18637	25140	7	"	"	``
18637	25140	8	1	1	CD
18637	25140	9	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	25140	10	.	.	.
18637	25141	1	304	304	CD
18637	25141	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25141	3	1816	1816	CD
18637	25141	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25141	5	"	"	``
18637	25141	6	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25141	7	659	659	CD
18637	25141	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	25141	9	-changed	-change	VBN
18637	25141	10	comma	comma	NN
18637	25141	11	to	to	TO
18637	25141	12	period	period	VB
18637	25141	13	in	in	IN
18637	25141	14	"	"	``
18637	25141	15	1	1	CD
18637	25141	16	Stat	Stat	NNP
18637	25141	17	,	,	,
18637	25141	18	335	335	CD
18637	25141	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25141	20	1793	1793	CD
18637	25141	21	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25141	22	"	"	``
18637	25141	23	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25141	24	660	660	CD
18637	25141	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	25141	26	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25141	27	semi	semi	JJ
18637	25141	28	-	-	NN
18637	25141	29	colon	colon	NN
18637	25141	30	after	after	IN
18637	25141	31	"	"	''
18637	25141	32	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25141	33	1856	1856	CD
18637	25141	34	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25141	35	"	"	``
18637	25141	36	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25141	37	737	737	CD
18637	25141	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	25141	39	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25141	40	semi	semi	JJ
18637	25141	41	-	-	NN
18637	25141	42	colon	colon	NN
18637	25141	43	to	to	IN
18637	25141	44	comma	comma	NN
18637	25141	45	in	in	IN
18637	25141	46	"	"	``
18637	25141	47	9	9	CD
18637	25141	48	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	25141	49	.	.	.
18637	25142	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	25142	2	.	.	.
18637	25143	1	Nos	nos	UH
18637	25143	2	.	.	.
18637	25144	1	5,126	5,126	CD
18637	25144	2	;	;	:
18637	25144	3	5,127	5,127	CD
18637	25144	4	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25144	5	1799	1799	CD
18637	25144	6	,	,	,
18637	25144	7	1800	1800	CD
18637	25144	8	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25144	9	"	"	''
18637	25144	10	,	,	,
18637	25144	11	added	add	VBD
18637	25144	12	opening	open	VBG
18637	25144	13	parenthesis	parenthesis	NN
18637	25144	14	before	before	IN
18637	25144	15	"	"	``
18637	25144	16	1863	1863	CD
18637	25144	17	"	"	''
18637	25144	18	in	in	IN
18637	25144	19	"	"	``
18637	25144	20	26	26	CD
18637	25144	21	Fed	Fed	NNP
18637	25144	22	.	.	.
18637	25145	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
18637	25145	2	.	.	.
18637	25146	1	No	no	UH
18637	25146	2	.	.	.
18637	25147	1	15,254	15,254	CD
18637	25147	2	1863	1863	CD
18637	25147	3	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25147	4	"	"	``
18637	25147	5	Article	Article	NNP
18637	25147	6	IV	IV	NNP
18637	25147	7	page	page	NN
18637	25147	8	650	650	CD
18637	25147	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	25147	10	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25147	11	period	period	NN
18637	25147	12	after	after	IN
18637	25147	13	"	"	``
18637	25147	14	etc	etc	FW
18637	25147	15	"	"	''
18637	25147	16	page	page	NN
18637	25147	17	651	651	CD
18637	25147	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	25147	19	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25147	20	"	"	''
18637	25147	21	STATIC	STATIC	NNP
18637	25147	22	RELATIONS	relations	NN
18637	25147	23	"	"	''
18637	25147	24	to	to	IN
18637	25147	25	"	"	``
18637	25147	26	STATE	STATE	NNP
18637	25147	27	'S	'S	NNP
18637	25147	28	RELATIONS	relations	NN
18637	25147	29	"	"	''
18637	25147	30	page	page	NN
18637	25147	31	652	652	CD
18637	25147	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	25147	33	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25147	34	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25147	35	of	of	IN
18637	25147	36	"	"	``
18637	25147	37	fulfilment	fulfilment	NN
18637	25147	38	"	"	''
18637	25147	39	to	to	IN
18637	25147	40	"	"	``
18637	25147	41	fulfillment	fulfillment	NN
18637	25147	42	"	"	''
18637	25147	43	page	page	NN
18637	25147	44	681	681	CD
18637	25147	45	-	-	HYPH
18637	25147	46	-changed	-changed	NN
18637	25147	47	"	"	''
18637	25147	48	Where	where	WRB
18637	25147	49	"	"	''
18637	25147	50	to	to	TO
18637	25147	51	"	"	``
18637	25147	52	Were	be	VBD
18637	25147	53	"	"	''
18637	25147	54	in	in	IN
18637	25147	55	"	"	''
18637	25147	56	Where	where	WRB
18637	25147	57	the	the	DT
18637	25147	58	company	company	NN
18637	25147	59	's	's	POS
18637	25147	60	contention	contention	NN
18637	25147	61	accepted	accept	VBD
18637	25147	62	....	....	.
18637	25147	63	"	"	``
18637	25147	64	page	page	NN
18637	25147	65	687	687	CD
18637	25147	66	-	-	HYPH
18637	25147	67	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25147	68	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25147	69	of	of	IN
18637	25147	70	"	"	``
18637	25147	71	Souse	souse	NN
18637	25147	72	"	"	''
18637	25147	73	to	to	IN
18637	25147	74	"	"	``
18637	25147	75	House	House	NNP
18637	25147	76	"	"	''
18637	25147	77	in	in	IN
18637	25147	78	"	"	``
18637	25147	79	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
18637	25147	80	-	-	HYPH
18637	25147	81	Souse	Souse	NNP
18637	25147	82	Cases	Cases	NNPS
18637	25147	83	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25147	84	3	3	CD
18637	25147	85	-	-	HYPH
18637	25147	86	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25147	87	comma	comma	NN
18637	25147	88	to	to	TO
18637	25147	89	period	period	VB
18637	25147	90	after	after	IN
18637	25147	91	"	"	``
18637	25147	92	Brock	Brock	NNP
18637	25147	93	"	"	''
18637	25147	94	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25147	95	66	66	CD
18637	25147	96	-	-	HYPH
18637	25147	97	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25147	98	period	period	NN
18637	25147	99	to	to	IN
18637	25147	100	comma	comma	NN
18637	25147	101	after	after	IN
18637	25147	102	"	"	``
18637	25147	103	287	287	CD
18637	25147	104	"	"	''
18637	25147	105	in	in	IN
18637	25147	106	"	"	''
18637	25147	107	...	...	NFP
18637	25147	108	317	317	CD
18637	25147	109	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25147	110	287	287	CD
18637	25147	111	.	.	.
18637	25147	112	he	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25147	113	would	would	MD
18637	25147	114	prefer	prefer	VB
18637	25147	115	....	....	NFP
18637	25147	116	"	"	''
18637	25147	117	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25147	118	74	74	CD
18637	25147	119	-	-	HYPH
18637	25147	120	-corrected	-corrected	NN
18637	25147	121	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25147	122	of	of	IN
18637	25147	123	"	"	``
18637	25147	124	fedual	fedual	JJ
18637	25147	125	"	"	''
18637	25147	126	to	to	IN
18637	25147	127	"	"	``
18637	25147	128	federal	federal	JJ
18637	25147	129	"	"	''
18637	25147	130	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25147	131	97	97	CD
18637	25147	132	-	-	HYPH
18637	25147	133	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25147	134	"	"	``
18637	25147	135	N.O.R.R.	N.O.R.R.	NNP
18637	25147	136	"	"	''
18637	25148	1	to	to	TO
18637	25148	2	"	"	``
18637	25148	3	N.O.R.	N.O.R.	NNP
18637	25148	4	"	"	''
18637	25149	1	in	in	IN
18637	25149	2	"	"	``
18637	25149	3	Texas	Texas	NNP
18637	25149	4	&	&	CC
18637	25149	5	N.O.R.R.	N.O.R.R.	NNP
18637	25150	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25150	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	25150	3	Miller	Miller	NNP
18637	25150	4	"	"	``
18637	25150	5	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25150	6	171	171	CD
18637	25150	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	25150	8	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25150	9	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25150	10	of	of	IN
18637	25150	11	"	"	``
18637	25150	12	Pawloske	Pawloske	NNP
18637	25150	13	"	"	''
18637	25150	14	to	to	IN
18637	25150	15	Pawloski	Pawloski	NNP
18637	25150	16	"	"	''
18637	25150	17	in	in	IN
18637	25150	18	"	"	``
18637	25150	19	Hess	Hess	NNP
18637	25150	20	v.	v.	IN
18637	25150	21	Pawloske	Pawloske	NNP
18637	25150	22	"	"	``
18637	25150	23	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25150	24	265	265	CD
18637	25150	25	-	-	HYPH
18637	25150	26	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25150	27	"	"	``
18637	25150	28	cf	cf	NN
18637	25150	29	"	"	''
18637	25150	30	to	to	TO
18637	25150	31	"	"	``
18637	25150	32	cf	cf	VB
18637	25150	33	.	.	.
18637	25150	34	"	"	''
18637	25151	1	Article	article	NN
18637	25151	2	V	v	NN
18637	25151	3	page	page	NN
18637	25151	4	712	712	CD
18637	25151	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	25151	6	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25151	7	"	"	''
18637	25151	8	...	...	:
18637	25151	9	quorum--	quorum--	NNP
18637	25151	10	,	,	,
18637	25151	11	and	and	CC
18637	25151	12	not	not	RB
18637	25151	13	...	...	:
18637	25151	14	"	"	''
18637	25151	15	to	to	IN
18637	25151	16	"	"	''
18637	25151	17	...	...	:
18637	25151	18	quorum	quorum	NN
18637	25151	19	--	--	:
18637	25151	20	and	and	CC
18637	25151	21	not	not	RB
18637	25151	22	...	...	:
18637	25151	23	"	"	``
18637	25151	24	page	page	NN
18637	25151	25	715	715	CD
18637	25151	26	-	-	HYPH
18637	25151	27	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25151	28	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25151	29	of	of	IN
18637	25151	30	"	"	``
18637	25151	31	Inamsuch	Inamsuch	NNP
18637	25151	32	"	"	''
18637	25151	33	to	to	TO
18637	25151	34	"	"	``
18637	25151	35	Inasmuch	Inasmuch	NNP
18637	25151	36	"	"	''
18637	25151	37	Aricle	Aricle	NNP
18637	25151	38	VI	VI	NNP
18637	25151	39	page	page	NN
18637	25151	40	719	719	CD
18637	25151	41	-	-	HYPH
18637	25151	42	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25151	43	period	period	NN
18637	25151	44	after	after	IN
18637	25151	45	"	"	``
18637	25151	46	etc	etc	FW
18637	25151	47	"	"	''
18637	25151	48	page	page	NN
18637	25151	49	722	722	CD
18637	25151	50	-	-	HYPH
18637	25151	51	-corrected	-corrected	NN
18637	25151	52	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25151	53	of	of	IN
18637	25151	54	"	"	``
18637	25151	55	nul	nul	NNP
18637	25151	56	"	"	''
18637	25151	57	to	to	TO
18637	25151	58	"	"	``
18637	25151	59	null	null	JJ
18637	25151	60	"	"	''
18637	25151	61	page	page	NN
18637	25151	62	733	733	CD
18637	25151	63	-	-	HYPH
18637	25151	64	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25151	65	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25151	66	of	of	IN
18637	25151	67	"	"	``
18637	25151	68	funtions	funtion	NNS
18637	25151	69	"	"	''
18637	25151	70	to	to	TO
18637	25151	71	"	"	``
18637	25151	72	functions	function	NNS
18637	25151	73	"	"	''
18637	25151	74	page	page	NN
18637	25151	75	736	736	CD
18637	25151	76	-	-	HYPH
18637	25151	77	-corrected	-corrected	NN
18637	25151	78	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25151	79	of	of	IN
18637	25151	80	"	"	``
18637	25151	81	Pinckeney	Pinckeney	NNP
18637	25151	82	"	"	''
18637	25151	83	to	to	IN
18637	25151	84	"	"	``
18637	25151	85	Pinckney	Pinckney	NNP
18637	25151	86	"	"	''
18637	25151	87	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25151	88	2	2	CD
18637	25151	89	-	-	HYPH
18637	25151	90	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25151	91	case	case	NN
18637	25151	92	citation	citation	NN
18637	25151	93	from	from	IN
18637	25151	94	"	"	``
18637	25151	95	Wheat	Wheat	NNP
18637	25151	96	.	.	.
18637	25152	1	316	316	CD
18637	25152	2	"	"	``
18637	25152	3	to	to	IN
18637	25152	4	"	"	``
18637	25152	5	4	4	CD
18637	25152	6	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	25152	7	.	.	.
18637	25153	1	316	316	CD
18637	25153	2	"	"	``
18637	25153	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25153	4	42	42	CD
18637	25153	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	25153	6	-changed	-change	VBN
18637	25153	7	comma	comma	NN
18637	25153	8	to	to	TO
18637	25153	9	period	period	VB
18637	25153	10	in	in	IN
18637	25153	11	"	"	``
18637	25153	12	9	9	CD
18637	25153	13	Wheat	Wheat	NNP
18637	25153	14	,	,	,
18637	25153	15	788	788	CD
18637	25153	16	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25153	17	1924	1924	CD
18637	25153	18	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25153	19	"	"	``
18637	25153	20	Article	article	NN
18637	25153	21	VII	vii	NN
18637	25153	22	page	page	NN
18637	25153	23	749	749	CD
18637	25153	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	25153	25	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25153	26	opening	opening	NN
18637	25153	27	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	25153	28	marks	mark	NNS
18637	25153	29	to	to	IN
18637	25153	30	paragraphs	paragraph	NNS
18637	25153	31	beginning	begin	VBG
18637	25153	32	"	"	``
18637	25153	33	Art	art	NN
18637	25153	34	.	.	.
18637	25154	1	1	1	LS
18637	25154	2	"	"	``
18637	25154	3	,	,	,
18637	25154	4	"	"	``
18637	25154	5	Art	art	NN
18637	25154	6	.	.	.
18637	25155	1	2	2	LS
18637	25155	2	"	"	``
18637	25155	3	,	,	,
18637	25155	4	"	"	``
18637	25155	5	Art	art	NN
18637	25155	6	.	.	.
18637	25156	1	3	3	LS
18637	25156	2	"	"	``
18637	25156	3	,	,	,
18637	25156	4	and	and	CC
18637	25156	5	"	"	``
18637	25156	6	Art	art	NN
18637	25156	7	.	.	.
18637	25157	1	6	6	CD
18637	25157	2	"	"	``
18637	25157	3	Bill	Bill	NNP
18637	25157	4	of	of	IN
18637	25157	5	Rights	Rights	NNPS
18637	25157	6	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25157	7	6	6	CD
18637	25157	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	25157	9	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25157	10	period	period	NN
18637	25157	11	after	after	IN
18637	25157	12	"	"	``
18637	25157	13	cit	cit	NNP
18637	25157	14	"	"	''
18637	25157	15	in	in	IN
18637	25157	16	"	"	``
18637	25157	17	op	op	NN
18637	25157	18	.	.	.
18637	25158	1	cit	cit	NNP
18637	25158	2	"	"	``
18637	25158	3	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	25158	4	1	1	CD
18637	25158	5	page	page	NN
18637	25158	6	755	755	CD
18637	25158	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	25158	8	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25158	9	period	period	NN
18637	25158	10	at	at	IN
18637	25158	11	end	end	NN
18637	25158	12	of	of	IN
18637	25158	13	"	"	``
18637	25158	14	Hague	Hague	NNP
18637	25158	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	25158	16	C.I.O	C.I.O	NNP
18637	25158	17	"	"	``
18637	25158	18	page	page	NN
18637	25158	19	758	758	CD
18637	25158	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	25158	21	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25158	22	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25158	23	of	of	IN
18637	25158	24	"	"	``
18637	25158	25	Calvanist	Calvanist	NNP
18637	25158	26	"	"	''
18637	25158	27	to	to	IN
18637	25158	28	"	"	``
18637	25158	29	Calvinist	Calvinist	NNP
18637	25158	30	"	"	''
18637	25158	31	page	page	NN
18637	25158	32	759	759	CD
18637	25158	33	-	-	HYPH
18637	25158	34	-corrected	-corrected	NN
18637	25158	35	"	"	``
18637	25158	36	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25158	37	"	"	''
18637	25158	38	to	to	IN
18637	25158	39	"	"	``
18637	25158	40	1	1	CD
18637	25158	41	"	"	''
18637	25158	42	in	in	IN
18637	25158	43	"	"	``
18637	25158	44	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25158	45	Tuck	Tuck	NNP
18637	25158	46	.	.	.
18637	25159	1	Bl	bl	UH
18637	25159	2	.	.	.
18637	25160	1	Com	com	NN
18637	25160	2	.	.	.
18637	25160	3	"	"	''
18637	25161	1	page	page	NN
18637	25161	2	761	761	CD
18637	25161	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25161	4	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25161	5	ending	end	VBG
18637	25161	6	double	double	JJ
18637	25161	7	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	25161	8	mark	mark	NN
18637	25161	9	to	to	IN
18637	25161	10	single	single	JJ
18637	25161	11	in	in	IN
18637	25161	12	'	'	``
18637	25161	13	released	release	VBN
18637	25161	14	time	time	NN
18637	25161	15	,	,	,
18637	25161	16	"	"	``
18637	25161	17	page	page	NN
18637	25161	18	771	771	CD
18637	25161	19	-	-	HYPH
18637	25161	20	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25161	21	comma	comma	NN
18637	25161	22	after	after	IN
18637	25161	23	"	"	``
18637	25161	24	Dallas	Dallas	NNP
18637	25161	25	"	"	''
18637	25161	26	in	in	IN
18637	25161	27	"	"	``
18637	25161	28	1	1	CD
18637	25161	29	Dallas	Dallas	NNP
18637	25161	30	,	,	,
18637	25161	31	319	319	CD
18637	25161	32	,	,	,
18637	25161	33	325	325	CD
18637	25161	34	"	"	``
18637	25161	35	page	page	NN
18637	25161	36	785	785	CD
18637	25161	37	-	-	HYPH
18637	25161	38	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25161	39	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25161	40	of	of	IN
18637	25161	41	"	"	``
18637	25161	42	anouncements	anouncement	NNS
18637	25161	43	"	"	''
18637	25161	44	to	to	IN
18637	25161	45	"	"	``
18637	25161	46	announcements	announcement	NNS
18637	25161	47	"	"	''
18637	25161	48	page	page	NN
18637	25161	49	786	786	CD
18637	25161	50	-	-	HYPH
18637	25161	51	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25161	52	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25161	53	of	of	IN
18637	25161	54	"	"	``
18637	25161	55	forbiding	forbiding	NN
18637	25161	56	"	"	''
18637	25161	57	to	to	IN
18637	25161	58	"	"	``
18637	25161	59	forbidding	forbid	VBG
18637	25161	60	"	"	''
18637	25161	61	page	page	NN
18637	25161	62	794	794	CD
18637	25161	63	-	-	HYPH
18637	25161	64	-removed	-removed	JJ
18637	25161	65	period	period	NN
18637	25161	66	after	after	IN
18637	25161	67	"	"	``
18637	25161	68	et	et	FW
18637	25161	69	"	"	''
18637	25161	70	in	in	IN
18637	25161	71	"	"	``
18637	25161	72	et	et	NN
18637	25161	73	.	.	.
18637	25162	1	al	al	NNP
18637	25162	2	.	.	.
18637	25162	3	"	"	''
18637	25163	1	page	page	NN
18637	25163	2	795	795	CD
18637	25163	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25163	4	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25163	5	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25163	6	of	of	IN
18637	25163	7	"	"	``
18637	25163	8	verthrowing	verthrowe	VBG
18637	25163	9	"	"	''
18637	25163	10	to	to	IN
18637	25163	11	"	"	``
18637	25163	12	overthrowing	overthrow	VBG
18637	25163	13	"	"	''
18637	25163	14	page	page	NN
18637	25163	15	797	797	CD
18637	25163	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	25163	17	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25163	18	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25163	19	of	of	IN
18637	25163	20	"	"	``
18637	25163	21	docrine	docrine	NN
18637	25163	22	"	"	''
18637	25163	23	to	to	TO
18637	25163	24	"	"	``
18637	25163	25	doctrine	doctrine	VB
18637	25163	26	"	"	''
18637	25163	27	page	page	NN
18637	25163	28	800	800	CD
18637	25163	29	-	-	JJ
18637	25163	30	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25163	31	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25163	32	of	of	IN
18637	25163	33	"	"	``
18637	25163	34	trivalities	trivalitie	NNS
18637	25163	35	"	"	''
18637	25163	36	to	to	IN
18637	25163	37	"	"	``
18637	25163	38	trivialities	triviality	NNS
18637	25163	39	"	"	''
18637	25163	40	page	page	NN
18637	25163	41	806	806	CD
18637	25163	42	-	-	HYPH
18637	25163	43	-inserted	-inserte	VBN
18637	25163	44	"	"	''
18637	25163	45	of	of	IN
18637	25163	46	"	"	''
18637	25163	47	into	into	IN
18637	25163	48	the	the	DT
18637	25163	49	phrase	phrase	NN
18637	25163	50	"	"	''
18637	25163	51	in	in	IN
18637	25163	52	any	any	DT
18637	25163	53	accurate	accurate	JJ
18637	25163	54	meaning	meaning	NN
18637	25163	55	of	of	IN
18637	25163	56	these	these	DT
18637	25163	57	words	word	NNS
18637	25163	58	"	"	``
18637	25163	59	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25163	60	22	22	CD
18637	25163	61	-	-	HYPH
18637	25163	62	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25163	63	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25163	64	of	of	IN
18637	25163	65	"	"	``
18637	25163	66	Morace	Morace	NNP
18637	25163	67	Mann	Mann	NNP
18637	25163	68	"	"	''
18637	25163	69	to	to	IN
18637	25163	70	"	"	``
18637	25163	71	Horace	Horace	NNP
18637	25163	72	Mann	Mann	NNP
18637	25163	73	"	"	''
18637	25163	74	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25163	75	167	167	CD
18637	25163	76	-	-	HYPH
18637	25163	77	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25163	78	comma	comma	NN
18637	25163	79	to	to	TO
18637	25163	80	period	period	VB
18637	25163	81	after	after	IN
18637	25163	82	"	"	``
18637	25163	83	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
18637	25163	84	"	"	''
18637	25163	85	in	in	IN
18637	25163	86	"	"	``
18637	25163	87	Communications	Communications	NNPS
18637	25163	88	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNS
18637	25163	89	,	,	,
18637	25163	90	v.	v.	IN
18637	25164	1	N.B.C.	N.B.C.	NNP
18637	25164	2	"	"	''
18637	25165	1	and	and	CC
18637	25165	2	added	add	VBN
18637	25165	3	comma	comma	NN
18637	25165	4	after	after	IN
18637	25165	5	N.B.C.	N.B.C.	NNP
18637	25166	1	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25166	2	184	184	CD
18637	25166	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25166	4	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25166	5	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25166	6	of	of	IN
18637	25166	7	"	"	``
18637	25166	8	Terminello	Terminello	NNP
18637	25166	9	"	"	''
18637	25166	10	to	to	TO
18637	25166	11	"	"	``
18637	25166	12	Terminiello	Terminiello	NNP
18637	25166	13	"	"	''
18637	25166	14	in	in	IN
18637	25166	15	"	"	``
18637	25166	16	Terminello	Terminello	NNP
18637	25166	17	v.	v.	IN
18637	25166	18	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	25166	19	"	"	``
18637	25166	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	25166	21	4	4	CD
18637	25166	22	page	page	NN
18637	25166	23	825	825	CD
18637	25166	24	-	-	HYPH
18637	25166	25	-corrected	-corrected	NN
18637	25166	26	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25166	27	of	of	IN
18637	25166	28	"	"	``
18637	25166	29	procedings	proceding	NNS
18637	25166	30	"	"	''
18637	25166	31	to	to	IN
18637	25166	32	"	"	``
18637	25166	33	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
18637	25166	34	"	"	''
18637	25166	35	page	page	NN
18637	25166	36	826	826	CD
18637	25166	37	-	-	HYPH
18637	25166	38	-inserted	-inserte	VBN
18637	25166	39	"	"	''
18637	25166	40	than	than	IN
18637	25166	41	"	"	``
18637	25166	42	after	after	IN
18637	25166	43	"	"	``
18637	25166	44	other	other	JJ
18637	25166	45	"	"	''
18637	25166	46	in	in	IN
18637	25166	47	"	"	''
18637	25166	48	...	...	NFP
18637	25166	49	if	if	IN
18637	25166	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25166	51	is	be	VBZ
18637	25166	52	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
18637	25166	53	on	on	IN
18637	25166	54	grounds	ground	NNS
18637	25166	55	other	other	JJ
18637	25166	56	self	self	NN
18637	25166	57	incrimination	incrimination	NN
18637	25166	58	....	....	.
18637	25166	59	"	"	''
18637	25166	60	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	25166	61	5	5	CD
18637	25166	62	page	page	NN
18637	25166	63	839	839	CD
18637	25166	64	-	-	HYPH
18637	25166	65	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25166	66	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25166	67	of	of	IN
18637	25166	68	"	"	``
18637	25166	69	defendent	defendent	NN
18637	25166	70	"	"	''
18637	25166	71	to	to	IN
18637	25166	72	"	"	``
18637	25166	73	defendant	defendant	NN
18637	25166	74	"	"	''
18637	25166	75	page	page	NN
18637	25166	76	841	841	CD
18637	25166	77	-	-	HYPH
18637	25166	78	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25166	79	hyphen	hyphen	NN
18637	25166	80	in	in	IN
18637	25166	81	"	"	``
18637	25166	82	accusare	accusare	NNP
18637	25166	83	-	-	HYPH
18637	25166	84	seipsum	seipsum	NN
18637	25166	85	"	"	''
18637	25166	86	page	page	NN
18637	25166	87	850	850	CD
18637	25166	88	-	-	HYPH
18637	25166	89	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25166	90	period	period	NN
18637	25166	91	after	after	IN
18637	25166	92	"	"	``
18637	25166	93	WJR	WJR	NNP
18637	25166	94	"	"	''
18637	25166	95	page	page	NN
18637	25166	96	852	852	CD
18637	25166	97	-	-	HYPH
18637	25166	98	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25166	99	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25166	100	of	of	IN
18637	25166	101	"	"	``
18637	25166	102	ailen	ailen	VBN
18637	25166	103	"	"	''
18637	25166	104	to	to	TO
18637	25166	105	"	"	``
18637	25166	106	alien	alien	JJ
18637	25166	107	"	"	''
18637	25166	108	page	page	NN
18637	25166	109	869	869	CD
18637	25166	110	-	-	HYPH
18637	25166	111	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25166	112	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25166	113	of	of	IN
18637	25166	114	"	"	``
18637	25166	115	benefitted	benefit	VBN
18637	25166	116	"	"	''
18637	25166	117	to	to	TO
18637	25166	118	"	"	``
18637	25166	119	benefited	benefit	VBN
18637	25166	120	"	"	''
18637	25166	121	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25166	122	148	148	CD
18637	25166	123	-	-	HYPH
18637	25166	124	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25166	125	hyphen	hyphen	NN
18637	25166	126	in	in	IN
18637	25166	127	"	"	``
18637	25166	128	Cooperative	Cooperative	NNP
18637	25166	129	"	"	''
18637	25166	130	in	in	IN
18637	25166	131	"	"	``
18637	25166	132	United	United	NNP
18637	25166	133	States	States	NNP
18637	25166	134	v.	v.	IN
18637	25166	135	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	25166	136	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	25166	137	Cooperative	Cooperative	NNP
18637	25166	138	"	"	''
18637	25166	139	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25166	140	155	155	CD
18637	25166	141	-	-	HYPH
18637	25166	142	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25166	143	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25166	144	of	of	IN
18637	25166	145	"	"	``
18637	25166	146	Idid	Idid	NNP
18637	25166	147	.	.	.
18637	25166	148	"	"	''
18637	25167	1	to	to	TO
18637	25167	2	"	"	``
18637	25167	3	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
18637	25167	4	.	.	.
18637	25167	5	"	"	''
18637	25168	1	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25168	2	160	160	CD
18637	25168	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25168	4	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25168	5	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25168	6	of	of	IN
18637	25168	7	"	"	``
18637	25168	8	Addystone	Addystone	NNP
18637	25168	9	"	"	''
18637	25168	10	to	to	IN
18637	25168	11	"	"	``
18637	25168	12	Addyston	Addyston	NNP
18637	25168	13	"	"	''
18637	25168	14	in	in	IN
18637	25168	15	"	"	``
18637	25168	16	Addystone	Addystone	NNP
18637	25168	17	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	25168	18	and	and	CC
18637	25168	19	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	25168	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25168	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	25168	22	United	United	NNP
18637	25168	23	States	States	NNP
18637	25168	24	"	"	``
18637	25168	25	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25168	26	165	165	CD
18637	25168	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	25168	28	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25168	29	hyphen	hyphen	NN
18637	25168	30	in	in	IN
18637	25168	31	"	"	``
18637	25168	32	Cooperative	Cooperative	NNP
18637	25168	33	"	"	''
18637	25168	34	in	in	IN
18637	25168	35	"	"	``
18637	25168	36	United	United	NNP
18637	25168	37	States	States	NNP
18637	25168	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	25168	39	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	25168	40	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	25168	41	Cooperative	Cooperative	NNP
18637	25168	42	"	"	''
18637	25168	43	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25168	44	212	212	CD
18637	25168	45	-	-	HYPH
18637	25168	46	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25168	47	comma	comma	NN
18637	25168	48	after	after	IN
18637	25168	49	"	"	``
18637	25168	50	299	299	CD
18637	25168	51	"	"	''
18637	25168	52	in	in	IN
18637	25168	53	"	"	``
18637	25168	54	299	299	CD
18637	25168	55	,	,	,
18637	25168	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25168	57	232	232	CD
18637	25168	58	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25168	59	1936	1936	CD
18637	25168	60	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25168	61	"	"	``
18637	25168	62	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25168	63	241	241	CD
18637	25168	64	-	-	HYPH
18637	25168	65	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25168	66	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25168	67	of	of	IN
18637	25168	68	"	"	``
18637	25168	69	Untermyer	Untermyer	NNP
18637	25168	70	"	"	''
18637	25168	71	to	to	TO
18637	25168	72	"	"	``
18637	25168	73	Untermeyer	Untermeyer	NNP
18637	25168	74	"	"	''
18637	25168	75	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25168	76	261	261	CD
18637	25168	77	-	-	HYPH
18637	25168	78	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25168	79	comma	comma	NN
18637	25168	80	after	after	IN
18637	25168	81	"	"	``
18637	25168	82	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25168	83	"	"	''
18637	25168	84	in	in	IN
18637	25168	85	"	"	``
18637	25168	86	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	25168	87	v.	v.	IN
18637	25168	88	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25168	89	8	8	CD
18637	25168	90	Cr	cr	NN
18637	25168	91	.	.	.
18637	25169	1	110	110	CD
18637	25169	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25169	3	1814	1814	CD
18637	25169	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25169	5	"	"	``
18637	25169	6	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	25169	7	6	6	CD
18637	25169	8	page	page	NN
18637	25169	9	882	882	CD
18637	25169	10	-	-	HYPH
18637	25169	11	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25169	12	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25169	13	of	of	IN
18637	25169	14	"	"	``
18637	25169	15	willfullness	willfullness	NN
18637	25169	16	"	"	''
18637	25169	17	to	to	TO
18637	25169	18	"	"	``
18637	25169	19	willfulness	willfulness	JJ
18637	25169	20	"	"	''
18637	25169	21	page	page	NN
18637	25169	22	883	883	CD
18637	25169	23	-	-	HYPH
18637	25169	24	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25169	25	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25169	26	of	of	IN
18637	25169	27	"	"	``
18637	25169	28	poltical	poltical	JJ
18637	25169	29	"	"	''
18637	25169	30	to	to	IN
18637	25169	31	"	"	``
18637	25169	32	political	political	JJ
18637	25169	33	"	"	''
18637	25169	34	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	25169	35	7	7	CD
18637	25169	36	page	page	NN
18637	25169	37	896	896	CD
18637	25169	38	-	-	HYPH
18637	25169	39	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25169	40	extraneous	extraneous	JJ
18637	25169	41	"	"	''
18637	25169	42	had	have	VBD
18637	25169	43	"	"	''
18637	25169	44	in	in	IN
18637	25169	45	"	"	''
18637	25169	46	...	...	.
18637	25169	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25169	48	was	be	VBD
18637	25169	49	held	hold	VBN
18637	25169	50	that	that	IN
18637	25169	51	a	a	DT
18637	25169	52	trial	trial	NN
18637	25169	53	court	court	NN
18637	25169	54	had	have	VBD
18637	25169	55	had	have	VBN
18637	25169	56	the	the	DT
18637	25169	57	right	right	NN
18637	25169	58	....	....	.
18637	25169	59	"	"	''
18637	25169	60	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	25169	61	8	8	CD
18637	25169	62	page	page	NN
18637	25169	63	903	903	CD
18637	25169	64	-	-	HYPH
18637	25169	65	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25169	66	semi	semi	JJ
18637	25169	67	-	-	NN
18637	25169	68	colon	colon	NN
18637	25169	69	in	in	IN
18637	25169	70	"	"	``
18637	25169	71	Who	who	WP
18637	25169	72	are	be	VBP
18637	25169	73	to	to	TO
18637	25169	74	be	be	VB
18637	25169	75	the	the	DT
18637	25169	76	judges	judge	NNS
18637	25169	77	?	?	.
18637	25170	1	;	;	:
18637	25170	2	"	"	``
18637	25170	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25170	4	5	5	CD
18637	25170	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	25170	6	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25170	7	"	"	``
18637	25170	8	USCA	USCA	NNP
18637	25170	9	"	"	''
18637	25170	10	to	to	IN
18637	25170	11	"	"	``
18637	25170	12	U.S.C.A.	U.S.C.A.	NNP
18637	25170	13	"	"	''
18637	25171	1	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	25171	2	11	11	CD
18637	25171	3	page	page	NN
18637	25171	4	929	929	CD
18637	25171	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	25171	6	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25171	7	"	"	''
18637	25171	8	Article	article	NN
18637	25171	9	11	11	CD
18637	25171	10	"	"	''
18637	25171	11	to	to	IN
18637	25171	12	"	"	``
18637	25171	13	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	25171	14	11	11	CD
18637	25171	15	"	"	NN
18637	25171	16	page	page	NN
18637	25171	17	933	933	CD
18637	25171	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	25171	19	-corrected	-corrected	NN
18637	25171	20	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25171	21	of	of	IN
18637	25171	22	"	"	``
18637	25171	23	legislaion	legislaion	NN
18637	25171	24	"	"	''
18637	25171	25	to	to	IN
18637	25171	26	"	"	``
18637	25171	27	legislation	legislation	NN
18637	25171	28	"	"	''
18637	25171	29	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25171	30	4	4	CD
18637	25171	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	25171	32	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25171	33	case	case	NN
18637	25171	34	citation	citation	NN
18637	25171	35	from	from	IN
18637	25171	36	"	"	``
18637	25171	37	Wheat	Wheat	NNP
18637	25171	38	.	.	.
18637	25172	1	738	738	CD
18637	25172	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25172	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	25172	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25172	5	"	"	''
18637	25172	6	to	to	TO
18637	25172	7	"	"	``
18637	25172	8	9	9	CD
18637	25172	9	Wheat	wheat	NN
18637	25172	10	.	.	.
18637	25173	1	738	738	CD
18637	25173	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25173	3	1824	1824	CD
18637	25173	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25173	5	"	"	``
18637	25173	6	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25173	7	20	20	CD
18637	25173	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	25173	9	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25173	10	case	case	NN
18637	25173	11	citation	citation	NN
18637	25173	12	for	for	IN
18637	25173	13	"	"	``
18637	25173	14	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
18637	25173	15	v.	v.	IN
18637	25173	16	McConnaughy	McConnaughy	NNP
18637	25173	17	"	"	``
18637	25173	18	from	from	IN
18637	25173	19	"	"	``
18637	25173	20	140	140	CD
18637	25173	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25173	22	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25173	23	1891	1891	CD
18637	25173	24	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25173	25	"	"	''
18637	25173	26	to	to	TO
18637	25173	27	"	"	``
18637	25173	28	140	140	CD
18637	25173	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25173	30	1	1	CD
18637	25173	31	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25173	32	1891	1891	CD
18637	25173	33	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25173	34	"	"	``
18637	25173	35	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25173	36	23	23	CD
18637	25173	37	-	-	HYPH
18637	25173	38	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25173	39	period	period	NN
18637	25173	40	after	after	IN
18637	25173	41	"	"	``
18637	25173	42	rel	rel	NN
18637	25173	43	"	"	''
18637	25173	44	in	in	IN
18637	25173	45	"	"	``
18637	25173	46	ex	ex	FW
18637	25173	47	rel	rel	NNP
18637	25173	48	"	"	''
18637	25173	49	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	25173	50	12	12	CD
18637	25173	51	page	page	NN
18637	25173	52	944	944	CD
18637	25173	53	-	-	HYPH
18637	25173	54	-corrected	-corrected	NN
18637	25173	55	"	"	''
18637	25173	56	undistinguishable	undistinguishable	JJ
18637	25173	57	"	"	''
18637	25173	58	to	to	TO
18637	25173	59	"	"	``
18637	25173	60	indistinguishable	indistinguishable	JJ
18637	25173	61	"	"	''
18637	25173	62	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	25173	63	13	13	CD
18637	25173	64	page	page	NN
18637	25173	65	952	952	CD
18637	25173	66	-	-	HYPH
18637	25173	67	-in	-in	NN
18637	25173	68	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25173	69	5	5	CD
18637	25173	70	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25173	71	,	,	,
18637	25173	72	added	add	VBN
18637	25173	73	final	final	JJ
18637	25173	74	period	period	NN
18637	25173	75	to	to	IN
18637	25173	76	"	"	``
18637	25173	77	U.S.C.A.	U.S.C.A.	NNP
18637	25173	78	"	"	''
18637	25174	1	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	25174	2	14	14	CD
18637	25174	3	page	page	NN
18637	25174	4	957	957	CD
18637	25174	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	25174	6	-corrected	-corrected	NN
18637	25174	7	page	page	NN
18637	25174	8	number	number	NN
18637	25174	9	reference	reference	NN
18637	25174	10	from	from	IN
18637	25174	11	"	"	``
18637	25174	12	669	669	CD
18637	25174	13	"	"	''
18637	25174	14	to	to	TO
18637	25174	15	"	"	``
18637	25174	16	969	969	CD
18637	25174	17	"	"	''
18637	25174	18	page	page	NN
18637	25174	19	958	958	CD
18637	25174	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	25174	21	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25174	22	period	period	NN
18637	25174	23	after	after	IN
18637	25174	24	"	"	``
18637	25174	25	etc"--three	etc"--three	NN
18637	25174	26	occurrences	occurrence	NNS
18637	25174	27	on	on	IN
18637	25174	28	page	page	NN
18637	25174	29	page	page	NN
18637	25174	30	960	960	CD
18637	25174	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	25174	32	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25174	33	period	period	NN
18637	25174	34	after	after	IN
18637	25174	35	"	"	``
18637	25174	36	etc"--two	etc"--two	NNP
18637	25174	37	occurrences	occurrence	NNS
18637	25174	38	on	on	IN
18637	25174	39	page	page	NN
18637	25174	40	page	page	NN
18637	25174	41	961	961	CD
18637	25174	42	-	-	HYPH
18637	25174	43	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25174	44	period	period	NN
18637	25174	45	after	after	IN
18637	25174	46	"	"	``
18637	25174	47	etc"--one	etc"--one	NN
18637	25174	48	occurrence	occurrence	NN
18637	25174	49	on	on	IN
18637	25174	50	page	page	NN
18637	25174	51	page	page	NN
18637	25174	52	977	977	CD
18637	25174	53	-	-	HYPH
18637	25174	54	-corrected	-corrected	NN
18637	25174	55	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25174	56	of	of	IN
18637	25174	57	"	"	``
18637	25174	58	willingess	willingess	NN
18637	25174	59	"	"	''
18637	25174	60	to	to	TO
18637	25174	61	"	"	``
18637	25174	62	willingness	willingness	VB
18637	25174	63	"	"	''
18637	25174	64	page	page	NN
18637	25174	65	1013	1013	CD
18637	25174	66	-	-	HYPH
18637	25174	67	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25174	68	opening	open	VBG
18637	25174	69	single	single	JJ
18637	25174	70	quote	quote	NN
18637	25174	71	before	before	IN
18637	25174	72	"	"	``
18637	25174	73	the	the	DT
18637	25174	74	"	"	''
18637	25174	75	in	in	IN
18637	25174	76	"	"	''
18637	25174	77	...	...	NFP
18637	25174	78	the	the	DT
18637	25174	79	furnishing	furnishing	NN
18637	25174	80	of	of	IN
18637	25174	81	such	such	JJ
18637	25174	82	necessary	necessary	JJ
18637	25174	83	....	....	.
18637	25174	84	"	"	``
18637	25174	85	page	page	NN
18637	25174	86	1014	1014	CD
18637	25174	87	-	-	HYPH
18637	25174	88	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25174	89	comma	comma	NN
18637	25174	90	after	after	IN
18637	25174	91	"	"	``
18637	25174	92	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	25174	93	"	"	''
18637	25174	94	in	in	IN
18637	25174	95	"	"	''
18637	25174	96	...	...	NFP
18637	25174	97	provides	provide	VBZ
18637	25174	98	that	that	IN
18637	25174	99	a	a	DT
18637	25174	100	railroad	railroad	NN
18637	25174	101	,	,	,
18637	25174	102	shall	shall	MD
18637	25174	103	be	be	VB
18637	25174	104	responsible	responsible	JJ
18637	25174	105	....	....	NFP
18637	25174	106	"	"	``
18637	25174	107	page	page	NN
18637	25174	108	1016	1016	CD
18637	25174	109	-	-	HYPH
18637	25174	110	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25174	111	"	"	''
18637	25174	112	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25174	113	"	"	''
18637	25174	114	to	to	TO
18637	25174	115	"	"	``
18637	25174	116	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	25174	117	"	"	''
18637	25174	118	in	in	IN
18637	25174	119	"	"	''
18637	25174	120	...	...	:
18637	25174	121	unable	unable	JJ
18637	25174	122	to	to	TO
18637	25174	123	recoup	recoup	VB
18637	25174	124	it	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25174	125	original	original	JJ
18637	25174	126	investment	investment	NN
18637	25174	127	....	....	NFP
18637	25174	128	"	"	``
18637	25174	129	page	page	NN
18637	25174	130	1030	1030	CD
18637	25174	131	-	-	HYPH
18637	25174	132	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25174	133	comma	comma	NN
18637	25174	134	after	after	IN
18637	25174	135	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25174	136	anchor	anchor	NN
18637	25174	137	[	[	-LRB-
18637	25174	138	403	403	CD
18637	25174	139	]	]	-RRB-
18637	25174	140	,	,	,
18637	25174	141	in	in	IN
18637	25174	142	"	"	``
18637	25174	143	...	...	:
18637	25174	144	statutes	statute	NNS
18637	25174	145	ordering	order	VBG
18637	25174	146	the	the	DT
18637	25174	147	destruction	destruction	NN
18637	25174	148	of	of	IN
18637	25174	149	unsafe	unsafe	JJ
18637	25174	150	and	and	CC
18637	25174	151	unwholesome	unwholesome	JJ
18637	25174	152	food[403	food[403	NN
18637	25174	153	]	]	-RRB-
18637	25174	154	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
18637	25174	155	the	the	DT
18637	25174	156	sale	sale	NN
18637	25174	157	....	....	NFP
18637	25174	158	"	"	``
18637	25174	159	page	page	NN
18637	25174	160	1030	1030	CD
18637	25174	161	-	-	HYPH
18637	25174	162	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25174	163	"	"	``
18637	25174	164	forbade	forbade	NN
18637	25174	165	"	"	''
18637	25174	166	to	to	TO
18637	25174	167	"	"	``
18637	25174	168	forbid	forbid	VB
18637	25174	169	"	"	''
18637	25174	170	in	in	IN
18637	25174	171	"	"	''
18637	25174	172	...	...	NFP
18637	25174	173	to	to	TO
18637	25174	174	forbade	forbade	VB
18637	25174	175	the	the	DT
18637	25174	176	sale	sale	NN
18637	25174	177	of	of	IN
18637	25174	178	drugs	drug	NNS
18637	25174	179	by	by	IN
18637	25174	180	itinerant	itinerant	JJ
18637	25174	181	vendors	vendor	NNS
18637	25174	182	....	....	.
18637	25174	183	"	"	''
18637	25174	184	page	page	NN
18637	25174	185	1043	1043	CD
18637	25174	186	-	-	,
18637	25174	187	-in	-in	FW
18637	25174	188	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25174	189	10	10	CD
18637	25174	190	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25174	191	,	,	,
18637	25174	192	changed	change	VBD
18637	25174	193	"	"	``
18637	25174	194	later	later	RB
18637	25174	195	"	"	''
18637	25174	196	to	to	TO
18637	25174	197	"	"	``
18637	25174	198	latter	latter	JJ
18637	25174	199	"	"	''
18637	25174	200	in	in	IN
18637	25174	201	"	"	''
18637	25174	202	...	...	NFP
18637	25174	203	protected	protect	VBN
18637	25174	204	by	by	IN
18637	25174	205	the	the	DT
18637	25174	206	later	later	JJ
18637	25174	207	and	and	CC
18637	25174	208	subject	subject	JJ
18637	25174	209	to	to	IN
18637	25174	210	its	-PRON-	PRP$
18637	25174	211	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
18637	25174	212	.	.	.
18637	25174	213	"	"	''
18637	25175	1	page	page	NN
18637	25175	2	1051	1051	CD
18637	25175	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25175	4	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25175	5	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25175	6	of	of	IN
18637	25175	7	"	"	``
18637	25175	8	coporations	coporation	NNS
18637	25175	9	"	"	''
18637	25175	10	to	to	TO
18637	25175	11	"	"	``
18637	25175	12	corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	25175	13	"	"	''
18637	25175	14	page	page	NN
18637	25175	15	1058	1058	CD
18637	25175	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	25175	17	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25175	18	"	"	''
18637	25175	19	than	than	IN
18637	25175	20	"	"	``
18637	25175	21	to	to	TO
18637	25175	22	"	"	''
18637	25175	23	that	that	IN
18637	25175	24	"	"	``
18637	25175	25	in	in	IN
18637	25175	26	"	"	''
18637	25175	27	...	...	:
18637	25175	28	opportunity	opportunity	NN
18637	25175	29	to	to	TO
18637	25175	30	submit	submit	VB
18637	25175	31	evidence	evidence	NN
18637	25175	32	and	and	CC
18637	25175	33	arguments	argument	NNS
18637	25175	34	being	be	VBG
18637	25175	35	all	all	DT
18637	25175	36	than	than	IN
18637	25175	37	can	can	MD
18637	25175	38	be	be	VB
18637	25175	39	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
18637	25175	40	vital	vital	JJ
18637	25175	41	....	....	NFP
18637	25175	42	"	"	''
18637	25175	43	page	page	NN
18637	25175	44	1071	1071	CD
18637	25175	45	-	-	HYPH
18637	25175	46	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25175	47	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25175	48	of	of	IN
18637	25175	49	"	"	``
18637	25175	50	determintion	determintion	NN
18637	25175	51	"	"	''
18637	25175	52	to	to	IN
18637	25175	53	"	"	``
18637	25175	54	determination	determination	NN
18637	25175	55	"	"	''
18637	25175	56	page	page	NN
18637	25175	57	1114	1114	CD
18637	25175	58	-	-	HYPH
18637	25175	59	-changed	-change	VBN
18637	25175	60	comma	comma	NN
18637	25175	61	to	to	TO
18637	25175	62	period	period	VB
18637	25175	63	after	after	IN
18637	25175	64	"	"	``
18637	25175	65	State	State	NNP
18637	25175	66	"	"	''
18637	25175	67	in	in	IN
18637	25175	68	"	"	''
18637	25175	69	...	...	NFP
18637	25175	70	the	the	DT
18637	25175	71	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
18637	25175	72	rights	right	NNS
18637	25175	73	of	of	IN
18637	25175	74	the	the	DT
18637	25175	75	States	States	NNPS
18637	25175	76	,	,	,
18637	25175	77	"	"	''
18637	25175	78	page	page	NN
18637	25175	79	1114	1114	CD
18637	25175	80	-	-	HYPH
18637	25175	81	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25175	82	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25175	83	of	of	IN
18637	25175	84	"	"	``
18637	25175	85	consitutionally	consitutionally	RB
18637	25175	86	"	"	''
18637	25175	87	to	to	TO
18637	25175	88	"	"	``
18637	25175	89	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
18637	25175	90	"	"	''
18637	25175	91	page	page	NN
18637	25175	92	1134	1134	CD
18637	25175	93	-	-	HYPH
18637	25175	94	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25175	95	period	period	NN
18637	25175	96	after	after	IN
18637	25175	97	"	"	``
18637	25175	98	rel	rel	NN
18637	25175	99	"	"	''
18637	25175	100	in	in	IN
18637	25175	101	"	"	''
18637	25175	102	...	...	NFP
18637	25175	103	in	in	IN
18637	25175	104	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
18637	25175	105	ex	ex	FW
18637	25175	106	rel	rel	NN
18637	25175	107	Francis	Francis	NNP
18637	25175	108	"	"	''
18637	25175	109	page	page	NN
18637	25175	110	1153	1153	CD
18637	25175	111	-	-	HYPH
18637	25175	112	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25175	113	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25175	114	of	of	IN
18637	25175	115	"	"	``
18637	25175	116	arbitary	arbitary	JJ
18637	25175	117	"	"	''
18637	25175	118	to	to	IN
18637	25175	119	"	"	``
18637	25175	120	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
18637	25175	121	"	"	''
18637	25175	122	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25175	123	12	12	CD
18637	25175	124	-	-	HYPH
18637	25175	125	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25175	126	hyphen	hyphen	NN
18637	25175	127	in	in	IN
18637	25175	128	"	"	``
18637	25175	129	Coop	Coop	NNP
18637	25175	130	.	.	.
18637	25175	131	"	"	''
18637	25176	1	in	in	IN
18637	25176	2	"	"	``
18637	25176	3	Warehouse	Warehouse	NNP
18637	25176	4	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25176	5	v.	v.	IN
18637	25176	6	Burley	Burley	NNP
18637	25176	7	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
18637	25176	8	Growers	Growers	NNPS
18637	25176	9	'	'	POS
18637	25176	10	Coop	Coop	NNP
18637	25176	11	.	.	.
18637	25177	1	Marketing	marketing	NN
18637	25177	2	Asso	Asso	NNP
18637	25177	3	.	.	.
18637	25177	4	"	"	''
18637	25178	1	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25178	2	75	75	CD
18637	25178	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25178	4	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25178	5	comma	comma	NN
18637	25178	6	after	after	IN
18637	25178	7	"	"	``
18637	25178	8	Cr	Cr	NNP
18637	25178	9	.	.	.
18637	25178	10	"	"	''
18637	25179	1	in	in	IN
18637	25179	2	"	"	``
18637	25179	3	6	6	CD
18637	25179	4	Cr	Cr	NNP
18637	25179	5	.	.	NNP
18637	25179	6	,	,	,
18637	25179	7	87	87	CD
18637	25179	8	,	,	,
18637	25179	9	128	128	CD
18637	25179	10	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25179	11	1810	1810	CD
18637	25179	12	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25179	13	"	"	``
18637	25179	14	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25179	15	94	94	CD
18637	25179	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	25179	17	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25179	18	period	period	NN
18637	25179	19	after	after	IN
18637	25179	20	"	"	``
18637	25179	21	Board	Board	NNP
18637	25179	22	"	"	''
18637	25179	23	in	in	IN
18637	25179	24	"	"	``
18637	25179	25	National	National	NNP
18637	25179	26	Labor	Labor	NNP
18637	25179	27	Relations	Relations	NNP
18637	25179	28	Board	Board	NNP
18637	25179	29	.	.	.
18637	25180	1	v.	v.	IN
18637	25180	2	Jones	Jones	NNP
18637	25180	3	&	&	CC
18637	25180	4	Laughlin	Laughlin	NNP
18637	25180	5	"	"	``
18637	25180	6	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25180	7	104	104	CD
18637	25180	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	25180	9	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25180	10	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25180	11	of	of	IN
18637	25180	12	"	"	``
18637	25180	13	Schimdinger	Schimdinger	NNP
18637	25180	14	"	"	''
18637	25180	15	to	to	IN
18637	25180	16	"	"	``
18637	25180	17	Schmidinger	Schmidinger	NNP
18637	25180	18	"	"	''
18637	25180	19	in	in	IN
18637	25180	20	"	"	``
18637	25180	21	Schimdinger	Schimdinger	NNP
18637	25180	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	25180	23	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	25180	24	"	"	``
18637	25180	25	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25180	26	157	157	CD
18637	25180	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	25180	28	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25180	29	"	"	''
18637	25180	30	in	in	IN
18637	25180	31	"	"	''
18637	25180	32	in	in	IN
18637	25180	33	"	"	''
18637	25180	34	...	...	NFP
18637	25180	35	and	and	CC
18637	25180	36	intimidations	intimidation	NNS
18637	25180	37	of	of	IN
18637	25180	38	in	in	IN
18637	25180	39	injury	injury	NN
18637	25180	40	to	to	IN
18637	25180	41	future	future	JJ
18637	25180	42	patrons	patron	NNS
18637	25180	43	....	....	.
18637	25180	44	"	"	''
18637	25180	45	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25180	46	219	219	CD
18637	25180	47	-	-	HYPH
18637	25180	48	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25180	49	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25180	50	of	of	IN
18637	25180	51	"	"	``
18637	25180	52	revelant	revelant	JJ
18637	25180	53	"	"	''
18637	25180	54	to	to	TO
18637	25180	55	"	"	``
18637	25180	56	relevant	relevant	JJ
18637	25180	57	"	"	''
18637	25180	58	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25180	59	221	221	CD
18637	25180	60	-	-	HYPH
18637	25180	61	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25180	62	period	period	NN
18637	25180	63	to	to	IN
18637	25180	64	comma	comma	NN
18637	25180	65	after	after	IN
18637	25180	66	"	"	''
18637	25180	67	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25180	68	1944	1944	CD
18637	25180	69	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25180	70	"	"	``
18637	25180	71	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25180	72	446	446	CD
18637	25180	73	-	-	HYPH
18637	25180	74	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25180	75	period	period	NN
18637	25180	76	after	after	IN
18637	25180	77	"	"	``
18637	25180	78	rel	rel	NN
18637	25180	79	"	"	''
18637	25180	80	in	in	IN
18637	25180	81	"	"	``
18637	25180	82	ex	ex	FW
18637	25180	83	rel	rel	NNP
18637	25180	84	"	"	``
18637	25180	85	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25180	86	533	533	CD
18637	25180	87	-	-	HYPH
18637	25180	88	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25180	89	comma	comma	NN
18637	25180	90	to	to	TO
18637	25180	91	period	period	VB
18637	25180	92	in	in	IN
18637	25180	93	"	"	``
18637	25180	94	4	4	CD
18637	25180	95	Wheat	Wheat	NNP
18637	25180	96	,	,	,
18637	25180	97	316	316	CD
18637	25180	98	,	,	,
18637	25180	99	429	429	CD
18637	25180	100	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25180	101	1819	1819	CD
18637	25180	102	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25180	103	"	"	``
18637	25180	104	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25180	105	540	540	CD
18637	25180	106	-	-	HYPH
18637	25180	107	-removed	-removed	JJ
18637	25180	108	unmatched	unmatched	JJ
18637	25180	109	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	25180	110	mark	mark	NN
18637	25180	111	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25180	112	695	695	CD
18637	25180	113	-	-	HYPH
18637	25180	114	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25180	115	comma	comma	NN
18637	25180	116	in	in	IN
18637	25180	117	"	"	``
18637	25180	118	19	19	CD
18637	25180	119	,	,	,
18637	25180	120	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	25180	121	.	.	.
18637	25181	1	107	107	CD
18637	25181	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25181	3	1874	1874	CD
18637	25181	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25181	5	"	"	``
18637	25181	6	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25181	7	698	698	CD
18637	25181	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	25181	9	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25181	10	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25181	11	of	of	IN
18637	25181	12	"	"	``
18637	25181	13	Millikin	Millikin	NNP
18637	25181	14	"	"	''
18637	25181	15	to	to	IN
18637	25181	16	"	"	``
18637	25181	17	Milliken	Milliken	NNP
18637	25181	18	"	"	''
18637	25181	19	in	in	IN
18637	25181	20	"	"	``
18637	25181	21	Millikin	Millikin	NNP
18637	25181	22	v.	v.	IN
18637	25181	23	Meyer	Meyer	NNP
18637	25181	24	"	"	``
18637	25181	25	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25181	26	700	700	CD
18637	25181	27	-	-	HYPH
18637	25181	28	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25181	29	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25181	30	of	of	IN
18637	25181	31	"	"	``
18637	25181	32	Pawlocki	Pawlocki	NNP
18637	25181	33	"	"	''
18637	25181	34	to	to	IN
18637	25181	35	Pawloski	Pawloski	NNP
18637	25181	36	"	"	''
18637	25181	37	in	in	IN
18637	25181	38	"	"	``
18637	25181	39	Hess	Hess	NNP
18637	25181	40	v.	v.	IN
18637	25181	41	Pawlocki	Pawlocki	NNP
18637	25181	42	"	"	``
18637	25181	43	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25181	44	761	761	CD
18637	25181	45	-	-	HYPH
18637	25181	46	-corrected	-corrected	NN
18637	25181	47	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25181	48	of	of	IN
18637	25181	49	"	"	``
18637	25181	50	untrammelled	untrammelled	JJ
18637	25181	51	"	"	''
18637	25181	52	to	to	IN
18637	25181	53	"	"	``
18637	25181	54	untrammeled	untrammeled	JJ
18637	25181	55	"	"	''
18637	25181	56	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25181	57	804	804	CD
18637	25181	58	-	-	HYPH
18637	25181	59	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25181	60	comma	comma	NN
18637	25181	61	to	to	TO
18637	25181	62	period	period	VB
18637	25181	63	in	in	IN
18637	25181	64	"	"	``
18637	25181	65	Wllson	Wllson	NNP
18637	25181	66	v.	v.	IN
18637	25181	67	North	North	NNP
18637	25181	68	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	25181	69	ex	ex	NN
18637	25181	70	rel	rel	NN
18637	25181	71	,	,	,
18637	25181	72	Caldwell	Caldwell	NNP
18637	25181	73	"	"	''
18637	25181	74	and	and	CC
18637	25181	75	corrected	correct	VBD
18637	25181	76	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25181	77	to	to	IN
18637	25181	78	"	"	``
18637	25181	79	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
18637	25181	80	"	"	''
18637	25181	81	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25181	82	854	854	CD
18637	25181	83	-	-	HYPH
18637	25181	84	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25181	85	comma	comma	NN
18637	25181	86	in	in	IN
18637	25181	87	"	"	``
18637	25181	88	342	342	CD
18637	25181	89	,	,	,
18637	25181	90	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25181	91	881	881	CD
18637	25181	92	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25181	93	1951	1951	CD
18637	25181	94	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25181	95	"	"	``
18637	25181	96	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25181	97	874	874	CD
18637	25181	98	-	-	HYPH
18637	25181	99	-inserted	-inserte	VBN
18637	25181	100	comma	comma	NN
18637	25181	101	after	after	IN
18637	25181	102	"	"	``
18637	25181	103	York	York	NNP
18637	25181	104	"	"	''
18637	25181	105	in	in	IN
18637	25181	106	"	"	``
18637	25181	107	Moore	Moore	NNP
18637	25181	108	v.	v.	IN
18637	25181	109	New	New	NNP
18637	25181	110	York	York	NNP
18637	25181	111	333	333	CD
18637	25181	112	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25181	113	565	565	CD
18637	25181	114	,	,	,
18637	25181	115	569	569	CD
18637	25181	116	-	-	HYPH
18637	25181	117	570	570	CD
18637	25181	118	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25181	119	1948	1948	CD
18637	25181	120	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25181	121	"	"	``
18637	25181	122	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25181	123	902	902	CD
18637	25181	124	-	-	HYPH
18637	25181	125	-corrected	-corrected	NN
18637	25181	126	"	"	''
18637	25181	127	Section	section	NN
18637	25181	128	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25181	129	"	"	''
18637	25181	130	to	to	TO
18637	25181	131	"	"	``
18637	25181	132	Section	section	NN
18637	25181	133	1	1	CD
18637	25181	134	"	"	``
18637	25181	135	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25181	136	937	937	CD
18637	25181	137	-	-	HYPH
18637	25181	138	-corrected	-corrected	NN
18637	25181	139	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25181	140	of	of	IN
18637	25181	141	"	"	``
18637	25181	142	Holahan	Holahan	NNP
18637	25181	143	"	"	''
18637	25181	144	to	to	TO
18637	25181	145	"	"	``
18637	25181	146	Holohan	Holohan	NNP
18637	25181	147	"	"	''
18637	25181	148	in	in	IN
18637	25181	149	"	"	``
18637	25181	150	Mooney	Mooney	NNP
18637	25181	151	v.	v.	IN
18637	25181	152	Holahan	Holahan	NNP
18637	25181	153	"	"	``
18637	25181	154	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25181	155	954	954	CD
18637	25181	156	-	-	HYPH
18637	25181	157	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25181	158	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25181	159	of	of	IN
18637	25181	160	"	"	``
18637	25181	161	habeus	habeu	NNS
18637	25181	162	"	"	''
18637	25181	163	to	to	TO
18637	25181	164	"	"	``
18637	25181	165	habeas	habea	NNS
18637	25181	166	"	"	''
18637	25181	167	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25181	168	969	969	CD
18637	25181	169	-	-	HYPH
18637	25181	170	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25181	171	closing	closing	NN
18637	25181	172	quotation	quotation	NN
18637	25181	173	mark	mark	NN
18637	25181	174	after	after	IN
18637	25181	175	"	"	``
18637	25181	176	invasion	invasion	NN
18637	25181	177	.	.	.
18637	25181	178	"	"	''
18637	25182	1	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25182	2	974	974	CD
18637	25182	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25182	4	-corrected	-corrected	NN
18637	25182	5	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25182	6	of	of	IN
18637	25182	7	"	"	``
18637	25182	8	gurantees	gurantee	NNS
18637	25182	9	"	"	''
18637	25182	10	to	to	TO
18637	25182	11	"	"	``
18637	25182	12	guarantees	guarantee	NNS
18637	25182	13	"	"	''
18637	25182	14	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25182	15	1016	1016	CD
18637	25182	16	-	-	HYPH
18637	25182	17	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25182	18	"	"	''
18637	25182	19	Q.R.R.	Q.R.R.	NNP
18637	25182	20	"	"	''
18637	25183	1	to	to	IN
18637	25183	2	"	"	``
18637	25183	3	Q.R.	Q.R.	NNP
18637	25183	4	"	"	''
18637	25184	1	in	in	IN
18637	25184	2	"	"	``
18637	25184	3	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	25184	4	,	,	,
18637	25184	5	B.	B.	NNP
18637	25185	1	&	&	CC
18637	25185	2	Q.R.R.	Q.R.R.	NNP
18637	25186	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25186	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	25186	3	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
18637	25186	4	"	"	``
18637	25186	5	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25186	6	1048	1048	CD
18637	25186	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	25186	8	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25186	9	"	"	''
18637	25186	10	exexempted	exexempte	VBN
18637	25186	11	"	"	''
18637	25186	12	to	to	IN
18637	25186	13	"	"	``
18637	25186	14	exempted	exempt	VBN
18637	25186	15	"	"	''
18637	25186	16	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25186	17	1104	1104	CD
18637	25186	18	-	-	HYPH
18637	25186	19	-changed	-change	VBN
18637	25186	20	comma	comma	NN
18637	25186	21	to	to	IN
18637	25186	22	semi	semi	JJ
18637	25186	23	-	-	JJ
18637	25186	24	colon	colon	NN
18637	25186	25	before	before	IN
18637	25186	26	"	"	``
18637	25186	27	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
18637	25186	28	"	"	''
18637	25186	29	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
18637	25186	30	1203	1203	CD
18637	25186	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	25186	32	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25186	33	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25186	34	of	of	IN
18637	25186	35	"	"	``
18637	25186	36	Atchinson	Atchinson	NNP
18637	25186	37	"	"	''
18637	25186	38	to	to	IN
18637	25186	39	"	"	``
18637	25186	40	Atchison	Atchison	NNP
18637	25186	41	"	"	''
18637	25186	42	in	in	IN
18637	25186	43	"	"	``
18637	25186	44	Atchinson	Atchinson	NNP
18637	25186	45	,	,	,
18637	25186	46	T.	T.	NNP
18637	25186	47	&	&	CC
18637	25186	48	S.F.R.	S.F.R.	NNP
18637	25187	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25187	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	25187	3	Matthews	Matthews	NNP
18637	25187	4	"	"	``
18637	25187	5	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	25187	6	16	16	CD
18637	25187	7	page	page	NN
18637	25187	8	1189	1189	CD
18637	25187	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	25187	10	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25187	11	period	period	NN
18637	25187	12	after	after	IN
18637	25187	13	"	"	``
18637	25187	14	etc	etc	FW
18637	25187	15	"	"	''
18637	25187	16	Amendment	amendment	NN
18637	25187	17	18	18	CD
18637	25187	18	page	page	NN
18637	25187	19	1213	1213	CD
18637	25187	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	25187	21	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25187	22	comma	comma	NN
18637	25187	23	to	to	TO
18637	25187	24	period	period	VB
18637	25187	25	after	after	IN
18637	25187	26	"	"	``
18637	25187	27	1935	1935	CD
18637	25187	28	"	"	''
18637	25187	29	in	in	IN
18637	25187	30	"	"	``
18637	25187	31	August	August	NNP
18637	25187	32	27	27	CD
18637	25187	33	,	,	,
18637	25187	34	1935	1935	CD
18637	25187	35	,	,	,
18637	25187	36	"	"	``
18637	25187	37	Acts	act	VBZ
18637	25187	38	Held	Held	NNP
18637	25187	39	Unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
18637	25187	40	page	page	NN
18637	25187	41	1241	1241	CD
18637	25187	42	-	-	HYPH
18637	25187	43	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25187	44	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25187	45	of	of	IN
18637	25187	46	"	"	``
18637	25187	47	Reichart	Reichart	NNP
18637	25187	48	"	"	''
18637	25187	49	to	to	IN
18637	25187	50	"	"	``
18637	25187	51	Reichert	Reichert	NNP
18637	25187	52	"	"	''
18637	25187	53	in	in	IN
18637	25187	54	"	"	``
18637	25187	55	Reichart	Reichart	NNP
18637	25187	56	v.	v.	IN
18637	25187	57	Felps	Felps	NNP
18637	25187	58	"	"	''
18637	25187	59	page	page	NN
18637	25187	60	1246	1246	CD
18637	25187	61	-	-	HYPH
18637	25187	62	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25187	63	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25187	64	of	of	IN
18637	25187	65	"	"	``
18637	25187	66	waranted	warante	VBN
18637	25187	67	"	"	''
18637	25187	68	to	to	TO
18637	25187	69	"	"	``
18637	25187	70	warranted	warrant	VBN
18637	25187	71	"	"	''
18637	25187	72	page	page	NN
18637	25187	73	1247	1247	CD
18637	25187	74	-	-	HYPH
18637	25187	75	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25187	76	"	"	``
18637	25187	77	1	1	CD
18637	25187	78	"	"	''
18637	25187	79	to	to	TO
18637	25187	80	"	"	``
18637	25187	81	I	-PRON-	PRP
18637	25187	82	"	"	''
18637	25187	83	in	in	IN
18637	25187	84	"	"	``
18637	25187	85	article	article	NN
18637	25187	86	1	1	CD
18637	25187	87	,	,	,
18637	25187	88	section	section	NN
18637	25187	89	8	8	CD
18637	25187	90	,	,	,
18637	25187	91	clause	clause	NN
18637	25187	92	3	3	CD
18637	25187	93	"	"	``
18637	25187	94	page	page	NN
18637	25187	95	1250	1250	CD
18637	25187	96	-	-	HYPH
18637	25187	97	-in	-in	CD
18637	25187	98	51	51	CD
18637	25187	99	.	.	.
18637	25187	100	,	,	,
18637	25187	101	removed	remove	VBN
18637	25187	102	comma	comma	NN
18637	25187	103	after	after	IN
18637	25187	104	"	"	``
18637	25187	105	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	25187	106	"	"	''
18637	25187	107	in	in	IN
18637	25187	108	"	"	``
18637	25187	109	Nichols	Nichols	NNP
18637	25187	110	,	,	,
18637	25187	111	Collector	Collector	NNP
18637	25187	112	,	,	,
18637	25187	113	v.	v.	IN
18637	25187	114	Coolidge	Coolidge	NNP
18637	25187	115	et	et	NNP
18637	25187	116	al	al	NNP
18637	25187	117	.	.	.
18637	25187	118	"	"	''
18637	25188	1	page	page	NN
18637	25188	2	1254	1254	CD
18637	25188	3	-	-	:
18637	25188	4	-in	-in	NFP
18637	25188	5	73	73	CD
18637	25188	6	.	.	CD
18637	25188	7	,	,	,
18637	25188	8	corrected	correct	VBN
18637	25188	9	"	"	''
18637	25188	10	article	article	NN
18637	25188	11	I	i	NN
18637	25188	12	,	,	,
18637	25188	13	section	section	NN
18637	25188	14	3	3	CD
18637	25188	15	,	,	,
18637	25188	16	clause	clause	NN
18637	25188	17	9	9	CD
18637	25188	18	"	"	''
18637	25188	19	to	to	IN
18637	25188	20	"	"	``
18637	25188	21	article	article	NN
18637	25188	22	I	i	NN
18637	25188	23	,	,	,
18637	25188	24	section	section	NN
18637	25188	25	9	9	CD
18637	25188	26	,	,	,
18637	25188	27	clause	clause	NN
18637	25188	28	3	3	CD
18637	25188	29	"	"	``
18637	25188	30	Table	table	NN
18637	25188	31	of	of	IN
18637	25188	32	Cases	case	NNS
18637	25188	33	page	page	NN
18637	25188	34	1257	1257	CD
18637	25188	35	-	-	HYPH
18637	25188	36	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25188	37	comma	comma	NN
18637	25188	38	after	after	IN
18637	25188	39	175	175	CD
18637	25188	40	in	in	IN
18637	25188	41	"	"	``
18637	25188	42	Addyston	Addyston	NNP
18637	25188	43	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
18637	25188	44	&	&	CC
18637	25188	45	Steel	Steel	NNP
18637	25188	46	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25188	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	25188	48	United	United	NNP
18637	25188	49	States	States	NNP
18637	25188	50	,	,	,
18637	25188	51	175	175	CD
18637	25188	52	,	,	,
18637	25188	53	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25188	54	211	211	CD
18637	25188	55	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25188	56	1899	1899	CD
18637	25188	57	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25188	58	"	"	``
18637	25188	59	page	page	NN
18637	25188	60	1258	1258	CD
18637	25188	61	-	-	HYPH
18637	25188	62	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25188	63	period	period	NN
18637	25188	64	after	after	IN
18637	25188	65	"	"	``
18637	25188	66	al	al	NNP
18637	25188	67	"	"	''
18637	25188	68	in	in	IN
18637	25188	69	"	"	``
18637	25188	70	et	et	FW
18637	25188	71	al	al	NNP
18637	25188	72	"	"	''
18637	25188	73	page	page	NN
18637	25188	74	1259	1259	CD
18637	25188	75	-	-	HYPH
18637	25188	76	-removed	-removed	JJ
18637	25188	77	period	period	NN
18637	25188	78	after	after	IN
18637	25188	79	"	"	``
18637	25188	80	ex	ex	FW
18637	25188	81	"	"	''
18637	25188	82	in	in	IN
18637	25188	83	"	"	``
18637	25188	84	Ashe	Ashe	NNP
18637	25188	85	v.	v.	IN
18637	25188	86	United	United	NNP
18637	25188	87	States	States	NNP
18637	25188	88	ex	ex	NNP
18637	25188	89	.	.	.
18637	25189	1	rel	rel	NNP
18637	25189	2	.	.	.
18637	25190	1	Valotta	Valotta	NNP
18637	25190	2	"	"	``
18637	25190	3	page	page	NN
18637	25190	4	1261	1261	CD
18637	25190	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	25190	6	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25190	7	period	period	NN
18637	25190	8	after	after	IN
18637	25190	9	"	"	``
18637	25190	10	S	S	NNP
18637	25190	11	"	"	''
18637	25190	12	in	in	IN
18637	25190	13	"	"	``
18637	25190	14	195	195	CD
18637	25190	15	U.S	U.S	NNP
18637	25190	16	375	375	CD
18637	25190	17	"	"	``
18637	25190	18	page	page	NN
18637	25190	19	1262	1262	CD
18637	25190	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	25190	21	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25190	22	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25190	23	of	of	IN
18637	25190	24	"	"	``
18637	25190	25	Perovick	Perovick	NNP
18637	25190	26	"	"	''
18637	25190	27	to	to	IN
18637	25190	28	"	"	``
18637	25190	29	Perovich	Perovich	NNP
18637	25190	30	"	"	''
18637	25190	31	in	in	IN
18637	25190	32	"	"	``
18637	25190	33	Biddle	Biddle	NNP
18637	25190	34	v.	v.	IN
18637	25190	35	Perovick	Perovick	NNP
18637	25190	36	"	"	''
18637	25190	37	page	page	NN
18637	25190	38	1263	1263	CD
18637	25190	39	-	-	HYPH
18637	25190	40	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25190	41	comma	comma	NN
18637	25190	42	after	after	IN
18637	25190	43	"	"	``
18637	25190	44	451	451	CD
18637	25190	45	"	"	''
18637	25190	46	in	in	IN
18637	25190	47	"	"	``
18637	25190	48	342	342	CD
18637	25190	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25190	50	451	451	CD
18637	25190	51	,	,	,
18637	25190	52	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25190	53	1952	1952	CD
18637	25190	54	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25190	55	"	"	``
18637	25190	56	page	page	NN
18637	25190	57	1264	1264	CD
18637	25190	58	-	-	HYPH
18637	25190	59	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25190	60	comma	comma	NN
18637	25190	61	after	after	IN
18637	25190	62	"	"	``
18637	25190	63	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25190	64	"	"	''
18637	25190	65	in	in	IN
18637	25190	66	"	"	``
18637	25190	67	Brown	Brown	NNP
18637	25190	68	v.	v.	IN
18637	25190	69	Western	Western	NNP
18637	25190	70	Ry	Ry	NNP
18637	25190	71	.	.	.
18637	25191	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25191	2	,	,	,
18637	25191	3	of	of	IN
18637	25191	4	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
18637	25191	5	"	"	''
18637	25191	6	page	page	NN
18637	25191	7	1268	1268	CD
18637	25191	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	25191	9	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25191	10	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25191	11	of	of	IN
18637	25191	12	"	"	``
18637	25191	13	Whitten	Whitten	NNP
18637	25191	14	"	"	''
18637	25191	15	to	to	IN
18637	25191	16	"	"	``
18637	25191	17	Whitton	Whitton	NNP
18637	25191	18	"	"	''
18637	25191	19	in	in	IN
18637	25191	20	"	"	``
18637	25191	21	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	25191	22	&	&	CC
18637	25191	23	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
18637	25191	24	R.	R.	NNP
18637	25191	25	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25191	26	v.	v.	IN
18637	25191	27	Whitten	Whitten	NNP
18637	25191	28	"	"	``
18637	25191	29	page	page	NN
18637	25191	30	1270	1270	CD
18637	25191	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	25191	32	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25191	33	comma	comma	NN
18637	25191	34	after	after	IN
18637	25191	35	"	"	``
18637	25191	36	R.	R.	NNP
18637	25191	37	"	"	''
18637	25191	38	in	in	IN
18637	25191	39	"	"	``
18637	25191	40	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
18637	25191	41	R.	R.	NNP
18637	25191	42	,	,	,
18637	25191	43	Gas	Gas	NNP
18637	25191	44	&	&	CC
18637	25191	45	E.	E.	NNP
18637	25191	46	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25191	47	v.	v.	IN
18637	25191	48	South	South	NNP
18637	25191	49	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
18637	25191	50	"	"	''
18637	25191	51	page	page	NN
18637	25191	52	1270	1270	CD
18637	25191	53	-	-	HYPH
18637	25191	54	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25191	55	period	period	NN
18637	25191	56	after	after	IN
18637	25191	57	"	"	``
18637	25191	58	Pick	Pick	NNP
18637	25191	59	"	"	''
18637	25191	60	in	in	IN
18637	25191	61	"	"	``
18637	25191	62	3	3	CD
18637	25191	63	Pick	Pick	NNP
18637	25191	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25191	65	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
18637	25191	66	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25192	1	304	304	CD
18637	25192	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25192	3	1825	1825	CD
18637	25192	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25192	5	"	"	``
18637	25192	6	page	page	NN
18637	25192	7	1270	1270	CD
18637	25192	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	25192	9	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25192	10	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25192	11	of	of	IN
18637	25192	12	"	"	``
18637	25192	13	Spratly	spratly	RB
18637	25192	14	"	"	''
18637	25192	15	to	to	IN
18637	25192	16	"	"	``
18637	25192	17	Spratley	Spratley	NNP
18637	25192	18	"	"	''
18637	25192	19	in	in	IN
18637	25192	20	"	"	``
18637	25192	21	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
18637	25192	22	Mut	Mut	NNP
18637	25192	23	.	.	.
18637	25193	1	Ins	Ins	NNP
18637	25193	2	.	.	.
18637	25194	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25194	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	25194	3	Spratly	spratly	RB
18637	25194	4	"	"	``
18637	25194	5	page	page	NN
18637	25194	6	1274	1274	CD
18637	25194	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	25194	8	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25194	9	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25194	10	of	of	IN
18637	25194	11	"	"	``
18637	25194	12	Kahanomoku	Kahanomoku	NNP
18637	25194	13	"	"	''
18637	25194	14	to	to	IN
18637	25194	15	"	"	``
18637	25194	16	Kahanamoku	Kahanamoku	NNP
18637	25194	17	"	"	''
18637	25194	18	page	page	NN
18637	25194	19	1276	1276	CD
18637	25194	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	25194	21	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25194	22	comma	comma	NN
18637	25194	23	after	after	IN
18637	25194	24	"	"	``
18637	25194	25	91	91	CD
18637	25194	26	"	"	''
18637	25194	27	in	in	IN
18637	25194	28	"	"	``
18637	25194	29	91	91	CD
18637	25194	30	,	,	,
18637	25194	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25194	32	29	29	CD
18637	25194	33	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25194	34	1875	1875	CD
18637	25194	35	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25194	36	"	"	``
18637	25194	37	page	page	NN
18637	25194	38	1285	1285	CD
18637	25194	39	-	-	HYPH
18637	25194	40	-removed	-removed	JJ
18637	25194	41	hyphen	hyphen	NN
18637	25194	42	in	in	IN
18637	25194	43	"	"	``
18637	25194	44	Holyoke	Holyoke	NNP
18637	25194	45	Water	Water	NNP
18637	25194	46	-	-	HYPH
18637	25194	47	Power	Power	NNP
18637	25194	48	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25194	49	v.	v.	IN
18637	25194	50	Lyman	Lyman	NNP
18637	25194	51	"	"	''
18637	25194	52	page	page	NN
18637	25194	53	1289	1289	CD
18637	25194	54	-	-	HYPH
18637	25194	55	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25194	56	comma	comma	NN
18637	25194	57	after	after	IN
18637	25194	58	"	"	``
18637	25194	59	Bay	Bay	NNP
18637	25194	60	"	"	''
18637	25194	61	in	in	IN
18637	25194	62	"	"	``
18637	25194	63	Kaukauna	Kaukauna	NNP
18637	25194	64	Water	Water	NNP
18637	25194	65	Power	Power	NNP
18637	25194	66	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25194	67	v.	v.	IN
18637	25194	68	Green	Green	NNP
18637	25194	69	Bay	Bay	NNP
18637	25194	70	,	,	,
18637	25194	71	&	&	CC
18637	25194	72	M.	M.	NNP
18637	25194	73	Canal	Canal	NNP
18637	25194	74	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25194	75	"	"	''
18637	25194	76	page	page	NN
18637	25194	77	1290	1290	CD
18637	25194	78	-	-	HYPH
18637	25194	79	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25194	80	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25194	81	of	of	IN
18637	25194	82	"	"	``
18637	25194	83	Morses	morse	NNS
18637	25194	84	"	"	''
18637	25194	85	to	to	TO
18637	25194	86	"	"	``
18637	25194	87	Morss	Morss	NNP
18637	25194	88	"	"	''
18637	25194	89	in	in	IN
18637	25194	90	"	"	''
18637	25194	91	Knapp	Knapp	NNP
18637	25194	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	25194	93	Morses	Morses	NNP
18637	25194	94	"	"	''
18637	25194	95	page	page	NN
18637	25194	96	1291	1291	CD
18637	25194	97	-	-	HYPH
18637	25194	98	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25194	99	period	period	NN
18637	25194	100	after	after	IN
18637	25194	101	"	"	``
18637	25194	102	ex	ex	FW
18637	25194	103	"	"	''
18637	25194	104	in	in	IN
18637	25194	105	"	"	``
18637	25194	106	Lake	Lake	NNP
18637	25194	107	Erie	Erie	NNP
18637	25194	108	&	&	CC
18637	25194	109	W.R.	W.R.	NNP
18637	25194	110	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25194	111	v.	v.	IN
18637	25194	112	State	State	NNP
18637	25194	113	Public	Public	NNP
18637	25194	114	Utilities	Utilities	NNP
18637	25194	115	Comm	Comm	NNP
18637	25194	116	.	.	.
18637	25195	1	ex	ex	NNP
18637	25195	2	.	.	.
18637	25196	1	rel	rel	NNP
18637	25196	2	.	.	.
18637	25197	1	Cameron	Cameron	NNP
18637	25197	2	"	"	``
18637	25197	3	page	page	NN
18637	25197	4	1296	1296	CD
18637	25197	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	25197	6	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25197	7	comma	comma	NN
18637	25197	8	to	to	TO
18637	25197	9	period	period	VB
18637	25197	10	after	after	IN
18637	25197	11	"	"	``
18637	25197	12	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	25197	13	"	"	''
18637	25197	14	in	in	IN
18637	25197	15	"	"	``
18637	25197	16	McCardle	McCardle	NNP
18637	25197	17	,	,	,
18637	25197	18	Ex	Ex	NNP
18637	25197	19	parte	parte	NNP
18637	25197	20	,	,	,
18637	25197	21	6	6	CD
18637	25197	22	Wall	Wall	NNP
18637	25197	23	,	,	,
18637	25197	24	318	318	CD
18637	25197	25	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25197	26	1868	1868	CD
18637	25197	27	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25197	28	"	"	``
18637	25197	29	page	page	NN
18637	25197	30	1296	1296	CD
18637	25197	31	-	-	HYPH
18637	25197	32	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25197	33	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25197	34	of	of	IN
18637	25197	35	"	"	``
18637	25197	36	McCullock	McCullock	NNP
18637	25197	37	"	"	''
18637	25197	38	to	to	IN
18637	25197	39	"	"	``
18637	25197	40	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
18637	25197	41	"	"	''
18637	25197	42	in	in	IN
18637	25197	43	"	"	``
18637	25197	44	McCullock	McCullock	NNP
18637	25197	45	v.	v.	IN
18637	25197	46	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
18637	25197	47	"	"	''
18637	25197	48	page	page	NN
18637	25197	49	1298	1298	CD
18637	25197	50	-	-	HYPH
18637	25197	51	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25197	52	comma	comma	NN
18637	25197	53	after	after	IN
18637	25197	54	"	"	``
18637	25197	55	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	25197	56	"	"	''
18637	25197	57	in	in	IN
18637	25197	58	"	"	``
18637	25197	59	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
18637	25197	60	K.	K.	NNP
18637	25197	61	&	&	CC
18637	25197	62	T.R.	T.R.	NNP
18637	25198	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25198	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	25198	3	Cade	Cade	NNP
18637	25198	4	"	"	''
18637	25198	5	page	page	NN
18637	25198	6	1301	1301	CD
18637	25198	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	25198	8	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25198	9	"	"	``
18637	25198	10	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	25198	11	,	,	,
18637	25198	12	"	"	''
18637	25198	13	after	after	IN
18637	25198	14	"	"	``
18637	25198	15	Merchants	merchant	NNS
18637	25198	16	'	'	POS
18637	25198	17	"	"	''
18637	25198	18	in	in	IN
18637	25198	19	"	"	``
18637	25198	20	New	New	NNP
18637	25198	21	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
18637	25198	22	Steam	Steam	NNP
18637	25198	23	Nav	Nav	NNP
18637	25198	24	.	.	.
18637	25199	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25199	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	25199	3	Merchants	Merchants	NNP
18637	25199	4	'	'	POS
18637	25199	5	6	6	CD
18637	25199	6	How	how	WRB
18637	25199	7	.	.	.
18637	25200	1	344	344	CD
18637	25200	2	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25200	3	1848	1848	CD
18637	25200	4	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25200	5	"	"	``
18637	25200	6	page	page	NN
18637	25200	7	1304	1304	CD
18637	25200	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	25200	9	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25200	10	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25200	11	of	of	IN
18637	25200	12	"	"	``
18637	25200	13	Hildebrandt	Hildebrandt	NNP
18637	25200	14	"	"	''
18637	25200	15	to	to	IN
18637	25200	16	"	"	``
18637	25200	17	Hildebrant	Hildebrant	NNP
18637	25200	18	"	"	''
18637	25200	19	in	in	IN
18637	25200	20	"	"	``
18637	25200	21	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
18637	25200	22	ex	ex	JJ
18637	25200	23	rel	rel	NN
18637	25200	24	.	.	.
18637	25201	1	Davis	Davis	NNP
18637	25201	2	<	<	XX
18637	25201	3	i	i	PRP
18637	25201	4	>	>	XX
18637	25201	5	v.</i	v.</i	NNP
18637	25201	6	>	>	FW
18637	25201	7	Hildebrandt	Hildebrandt	NNP
18637	25201	8	"	"	``
18637	25201	9	page	page	NN
18637	25201	10	1307	1307	CD
18637	25201	11	-	-	HYPH
18637	25201	12	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25201	13	period	period	NN
18637	25201	14	after	after	IN
18637	25201	15	"	"	``
18637	25201	16	Elg	Elg	NNP
18637	25201	17	"	"	''
18637	25201	18	in	in	IN
18637	25201	19	"	"	``
18637	25201	20	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
18637	25201	21	v.	v.	IN
18637	25202	1	Elg	Elg	NNP
18637	25202	2	.	.	.
18637	25202	3	"	"	''
18637	25203	1	page	page	NN
18637	25203	2	1310	1310	CD
18637	25203	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25203	4	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25203	5	"	"	``
18637	25203	6	O.R.R.	O.R.R.	NNS
18637	25203	7	"	"	''
18637	25204	1	to	to	IN
18637	25204	2	"	"	``
18637	25204	3	O.R.	O.R.	NNP
18637	25204	4	"	"	''
18637	25205	1	in	in	IN
18637	25205	2	"	"	``
18637	25205	3	Randall	Randall	NNP
18637	25205	4	v.	v.	IN
18637	25205	5	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
18637	25205	6	&	&	CC
18637	25205	7	O.R.R.	O.R.R.	NNP
18637	25206	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25206	2	"	"	``
18637	25206	3	page	page	NN
18637	25206	4	1310	1310	CD
18637	25206	5	-	-	HYPH
18637	25206	6	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25206	7	closing	closing	NN
18637	25206	8	parenthesis	parenthesis	NN
18637	25206	9	after	after	IN
18637	25206	10	"	"	''
18637	25206	11	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25206	12	1935	1935	CD
18637	25206	13	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25206	14	"	"	``
18637	25206	15	in	in	IN
18637	25206	16	"	"	''
18637	25206	17	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25206	18	Humphrey	Humphrey	NNP
18637	25206	19	v.	v.	IN
18637	25206	20	United	United	NNP
18637	25206	21	States	States	NNP
18637	25206	22	,	,	,
18637	25206	23	295	295	CD
18637	25206	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25206	25	602	602	CD
18637	25206	26	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25206	27	1935	1935	CD
18637	25206	28	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25206	29	"	"	``
18637	25206	30	page	page	NN
18637	25206	31	1313	1313	CD
18637	25206	32	-	-	HYPH
18637	25206	33	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25206	34	"	"	``
18637	25206	35	NLRB	NLRB	NNP
18637	25206	36	"	"	''
18637	25206	37	to	to	IN
18637	25206	38	"	"	``
18637	25206	39	N.L.R.B.	N.L.R.B.	NNP
18637	25206	40	"	"	''
18637	25207	1	page	page	NN
18637	25207	2	1314	1314	CD
18637	25207	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25207	4	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25207	5	comma	comma	NN
18637	25207	6	after	after	IN
18637	25207	7	"	"	``
18637	25207	8	Sharp	Sharp	NNP
18637	25207	9	"	"	''
18637	25207	10	in	in	IN
18637	25207	11	"	"	``
18637	25207	12	Sharp	Sharp	NNP
18637	25207	13	,	,	,
18637	25207	14	v.	v.	CC
18637	25207	15	United	United	NNP
18637	25207	16	States	States	NNP
18637	25207	17	"	"	''
18637	25207	18	page	page	NN
18637	25207	19	1315	1315	CD
18637	25207	20	-	-	HYPH
18637	25207	21	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25207	22	period	period	NN
18637	25207	23	after	after	IN
18637	25207	24	"	"	``
18637	25207	25	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	25207	26	"	"	''
18637	25207	27	in	in	IN
18637	25207	28	"	"	``
18637	25207	29	Shriver	Shriver	NNP
18637	25207	30	v.	v.	IN
18637	25207	31	Woodbine	Woodbine	NNP
18637	25207	32	Sav	Sav	NNP
18637	25207	33	.	.	.
18637	25208	1	Bank	Bank	NNP
18637	25208	2	.	.	.
18637	25208	3	"	"	''
18637	25209	1	page	page	NN
18637	25209	2	1315	1315	CD
18637	25209	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25209	4	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25209	5	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25209	6	of	of	IN
18637	25209	7	"	"	``
18637	25209	8	Galatin	Galatin	NNP
18637	25209	9	"	"	''
18637	25209	10	to	to	IN
18637	25209	11	"	"	``
18637	25209	12	Gallatin	Gallatin	NNP
18637	25209	13	"	"	''
18637	25209	14	in	in	IN
18637	25209	15	"	"	``
18637	25209	16	Sinking	Sinking	NNP
18637	25209	17	Fund	Fund	NNP
18637	25209	18	Cases	case	NNS
18637	25209	19	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25209	20	Central	Central	NNP
18637	25209	21	P.R.	P.R.	NNP
18637	25210	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25210	2	v.	v.	IN
18637	25210	3	Galatin	Galatin	NNP
18637	25210	4	...	...	:
18637	25210	5	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25210	6	"	"	``
18637	25210	7	page	page	NN
18637	25210	8	1318	1318	CD
18637	25210	9	-	-	HYPH
18637	25210	10	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25210	11	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25210	12	of	of	IN
18637	25210	13	"	"	``
18637	25210	14	Stevans	Stevans	NNPS
18637	25210	15	"	"	''
18637	25210	16	to	to	TO
18637	25210	17	"	"	``
18637	25210	18	Stevens	Stevens	NNP
18637	25210	19	"	"	''
18637	25210	20	in	in	IN
18637	25210	21	"	"	``
18637	25210	22	Stevans	Stevans	NNPS
18637	25210	23	v.	v.	NN
18637	25210	24	Gladding	gladde	VBG
18637	25210	25	"	"	''
18637	25210	26	page	page	NN
18637	25210	27	1318	1318	CD
18637	25210	28	-	-	HYPH
18637	25210	29	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25210	30	period	period	NN
18637	25210	31	after	after	IN
18637	25210	32	"	"	``
18637	25210	33	rel	rel	NN
18637	25210	34	"	"	''
18637	25210	35	in	in	IN
18637	25210	36	"	"	``
18637	25210	37	Stone	Stone	NNP
18637	25210	38	v.	v.	IN
18637	25210	39	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
18637	25210	40	ex	ex	NNP
18637	25210	41	rel	rel	NN
18637	25210	42	Harris	Harris	NNP
18637	25210	43	"	"	''
18637	25210	44	page	page	NN
18637	25210	45	1318	1318	CD
18637	25210	46	-	-	HYPH
18637	25210	47	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25210	48	spelling	spelling	NN
18637	25210	49	of	of	IN
18637	25210	50	"	"	``
18637	25210	51	Crowinshield	Crowinshield	NNP
18637	25210	52	"	"	''
18637	25210	53	to	to	IN
18637	25210	54	"	"	``
18637	25210	55	Crowninshield	Crowninshield	NNP
18637	25210	56	"	"	''
18637	25210	57	in	in	IN
18637	25210	58	"	"	``
18637	25210	59	Sturges	Sturges	NNP
18637	25210	60	v.	v.	CC
18637	25210	61	Crowinshield	Crowinshield	NNP
18637	25210	62	"	"	``
18637	25210	63	page	page	NN
18637	25210	64	1323	1323	CD
18637	25210	65	-	-	HYPH
18637	25210	66	-ordered	-ordered	JJ
18637	25210	67	page	page	NN
18637	25210	68	numbers	number	NNS
18637	25210	69	in	in	IN
18637	25210	70	numerical	numerical	JJ
18637	25210	71	order	order	NN
18637	25210	72	in	in	IN
18637	25210	73	"	"	``
18637	25210	74	United	United	NNP
18637	25210	75	States	States	NNP
18637	25210	76	v.	v.	IN
18637	25210	77	Classic	Classic	NNP
18637	25210	78	"	"	''
18637	25210	79	page	page	NN
18637	25210	80	1326	1326	CD
18637	25210	81	-	-	HYPH
18637	25210	82	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25210	83	hyphen	hyphen	NN
18637	25210	84	in	in	IN
18637	25210	85	"	"	``
18637	25210	86	Cooperative	Cooperative	NNP
18637	25210	87	"	"	''
18637	25210	88	in	in	IN
18637	25210	89	"	"	``
18637	25210	90	United	United	NNP
18637	25210	91	States	States	NNP
18637	25210	92	v.	v.	IN
18637	25210	93	Rock	Rock	NNP
18637	25210	94	Royal	Royal	NNP
18637	25210	95	Cooperative	Cooperative	NNP
18637	25210	96	"	"	''
18637	25210	97	page	page	NN
18637	25210	98	1332	1332	CD
18637	25210	99	-	-	HYPH
18637	25210	100	-removed	-remove	VBN
18637	25210	101	comma	comma	NN
18637	25210	102	after	after	IN
18637	25210	103	"	"	``
18637	25210	104	205	205	CD
18637	25210	105	"	"	''
18637	25210	106	in	in	IN
18637	25210	107	"	"	``
18637	25210	108	205	205	CD
18637	25210	109	,	,	,
18637	25210	110	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
18637	25210	111	354	354	CD
18637	25210	112	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25210	113	1907	1907	CD
18637	25210	114	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25210	115	"	"	``
18637	25210	116	page	page	NN
18637	25210	117	1332	1332	CD
18637	25210	118	-	-	HYPH
18637	25210	119	-corrected	-corrected	JJ
18637	25210	120	punctuation	punctuation	NN
18637	25210	121	in	in	IN
18637	25210	122	"	"	``
18637	25210	123	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	25210	124	,	,	,
18637	25210	125	B.	B.	NNP
18637	25211	1	&	&	CC
18637	25211	2	Q.	Q.	NNP
18637	25211	3	RR	RR	NNP
18637	25211	4	.	.	.
18637	25212	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25212	2	"	"	``
18637	25212	3	to	to	IN
18637	25212	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
18637	25212	5	,	,	,
18637	25212	6	B.	B.	NNP
18637	25213	1	&	&	CC
18637	25213	2	Q.R.R.	Q.R.R.	NNP
18637	25214	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
18637	25214	2	"	"	``
18637	25214	3	Index	index	NN
18637	25214	4	pages	page	NNS
18637	25214	5	1337	1337	CD
18637	25214	6	-	-	SYM
18637	25214	7	1361	1361	CD
18637	25214	8	-	-	HYPH
18637	25214	9	-in	-in	:
18637	25214	10	Index	Index	NNP
18637	25214	11	,	,	,
18637	25214	12	added	add	VBD
18637	25214	13	periods	period	NNS
18637	25214	14	after	after	IN
18637	25214	15	"	"	``
18637	25214	16	etc	etc	FW
18637	25214	17	"	"	''
18637	25214	18	where	where	WRB
18637	25214	19	missing	miss	VBG
18637	25214	20	page	page	NN
18637	25214	21	1337	1337	CD
18637	25214	22	-	-	HYPH
18637	25214	23	-added	-adde	VBN
18637	25214	24	period	period	NN
18637	25214	25	after	after	IN
18637	25214	26	"	"	``
18637	25214	27	etc	etc	FW
18637	25214	28	"	"	''
18637	25214	29	in	in	IN
18637	25214	30	"	"	``
18637	25214	31	State	state	NN
18637	25214	32	,	,	,
18637	25214	33	procedural	procedural	JJ
18637	25214	34	due	due	JJ
18637	25214	35	process	process	NN
18637	25214	36	,	,	,
18637	25214	37	notice	notice	NN
18637	25214	38	and	and	CC
18637	25214	39	hearing	hearing	NN
18637	25214	40	,	,	,
18637	25214	41	etc	etc	FW
18637	25214	42	"	"	``
18637	25214	43	page	page	NN
18637	25214	44	1339	1339	CD
18637	25214	45	-	-	HYPH
18637	25214	46	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25214	47	comma	comma	NN
18637	25214	48	to	to	IN
18637	25214	49	semi	semi	JJ
18637	25214	50	-	-	JJ
18637	25214	51	colon	colon	NN
18637	25214	52	in	in	IN
18637	25214	53	"	"	``
18637	25214	54	Coins	Coins	NNPS
18637	25214	55	and	and	CC
18637	25214	56	Coinage	Coinage	NNP
18637	25214	57	.	.	.
18637	25215	1	See	see	VB
18637	25215	2	Counterfeiting	Counterfeiting	NNP
18637	25215	3	,	,	,
18637	25215	4	Money	money	NN
18637	25215	5	.	.	.
18637	25215	6	"	"	''
18637	25216	1	page	page	NN
18637	25216	2	1342	1342	CD
18637	25216	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25216	4	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25216	5	"	"	``
18637	25216	6	431	431	CD
18637	25216	7	-	-	HYPH
18637	25216	8	610	610	NNP
18637	25216	9	"	"	``
18637	25216	10	to	to	IN
18637	25216	11	"	"	``
18637	25216	12	431	431	CD
18637	25216	13	,	,	,
18637	25216	14	610	610	CD
18637	25216	15	"	"	``
18637	25216	16	in	in	IN
18637	25216	17	"	"	``
18637	25216	18	Indian	indian	JJ
18637	25216	19	tribes	tribe	NNS
18637	25216	20	,	,	,
18637	25216	21	not	not	RB
18637	25216	22	foreign	foreign	JJ
18637	25216	23	state	state	NN
18637	25216	24	for	for	IN
18637	25216	25	jurisdictional	jurisdictional	JJ
18637	25216	26	purposes	purpose	NNS
18637	25216	27	,	,	,
18637	25216	28	431	431	CD
18637	25216	29	-	-	SYM
18637	25216	30	610	610	CD
18637	25216	31	"	"	``
18637	25216	32	page	page	NN
18637	25216	33	1344	1344	CD
18637	25216	34	-	-	HYPH
18637	25216	35	-added	-added	JJ
18637	25216	36	closing	closing	NN
18637	25216	37	parenthesis	parenthesis	NN
18637	25216	38	after	after	IN
18637	25216	39	"	"	``
18637	25216	40	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	25216	41	"	"	''
18637	25216	42	in	in	IN
18637	25216	43	"	"	``
18637	25216	44	Due	Due	NNP
18637	25216	45	Process	process	NN
18637	25216	46	of	of	IN
18637	25216	47	Law	Law	NNP
18637	25216	48	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25216	49	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
18637	25216	50	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
18637	25216	51	"	"	''
18637	25216	52	page	page	NN
18637	25216	53	1347	1347	CD
18637	25216	54	-	-	HYPH
18637	25216	55	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25216	56	commas	comma	NNS
18637	25216	57	to	to	IN
18637	25216	58	semi	semi	JJ
18637	25216	59	-	-	NNS
18637	25216	60	colons	colon	NNS
18637	25216	61	in	in	IN
18637	25216	62	"	"	``
18637	25216	63	Health	Health	NNP
18637	25216	64	(	(	-LRB-
18637	25216	65	see	see	VB
18637	25216	66	also	also	RB
18637	25216	67	Drugs	Drugs	NNP
18637	25216	68	,	,	,
18637	25216	69	Food	Food	NNP
18637	25216	70	,	,	,
18637	25216	71	Garbage	Garbage	NNP
18637	25216	72	,	,	,
18637	25216	73	Milk	Milk	NNP
18637	25216	74	,	,	,
18637	25216	75	Sewers	Sewers	NNPS
18637	25216	76	,	,	,
18637	25216	77	Water	Water	NNP
18637	25216	78	)	)	-RRB-
18637	25216	79	"	"	''
18637	25216	80	page	page	NN
18637	25216	81	1350	1350	CD
18637	25216	82	-	-	HYPH
18637	25216	83	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25216	84	2nd	2nd	JJ
18637	25216	85	"	"	``
18637	25216	86	Process	process	NN
18637	25216	87	"	"	''
18637	25216	88	to	to	IN
18637	25216	89	"	"	``
18637	25216	90	Power	power	NN
18637	25216	91	"	"	''
18637	25216	92	in	in	IN
18637	25216	93	"	"	``
18637	25216	94	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	25216	95	Process	Process	NNP
18637	25216	96	.	.	.
18637	25217	1	See	see	VB
18637	25217	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
18637	25217	3	;	;	:
18637	25217	4	Internal	Internal	NNP
18637	25217	5	Organization	Organization	NNP
18637	25217	6	;	;	:
18637	25217	7	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
18637	25217	8	Process	Process	NNP
18637	25217	9	"	"	''
18637	25217	10	page	page	NN
18637	25217	11	1350	1350	CD
18637	25217	12	-	-	HYPH
18637	25217	13	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25217	14	comma	comma	NN
18637	25217	15	to	to	IN
18637	25217	16	semi	semi	JJ
18637	25217	17	-	-	JJ
18637	25217	18	colon	colon	NN
18637	25217	19	in	in	IN
18637	25217	20	"	"	``
18637	25217	21	Mob	Mob	NNP
18637	25217	22	violence	violence	NN
18637	25217	23	.	.	.
18637	25218	1	See	see	VB
18637	25218	2	Confrontation	confrontation	NN
18637	25218	3	;	;	:
18637	25218	4	Domestic	domestic	JJ
18637	25218	5	Violence	violence	NN
18637	25218	6	,	,	,
18637	25218	7	Due	Due	NNP
18637	25218	8	Process	Process	NNP
18637	25218	9	of	of	IN
18637	25218	10	Law	Law	NNP
18637	25218	11	.	.	.
18637	25218	12	"	"	''
18637	25219	1	page	page	NN
18637	25219	2	1351	1351	CD
18637	25219	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25219	4	-changed	-changed	JJ
18637	25219	5	hyphen	hyphen	NN
18637	25219	6	to	to	IN
18637	25219	7	colon	colon	NN
18637	25219	8	in	in	IN
18637	25219	9	"	"	``
18637	25219	10	Municipal	Municipal	NNP
18637	25219	11	Corporations	corporation	NNS
18637	25219	12	.	.	.
18637	25220	1	See	see	VB
18637	25220	2	States	States	NNP
18637	25220	3	-	-	HYPH
18637	25220	4	Political	Political	NNP
18637	25220	5	Subdivisions	Subdivisions	NNPS
18637	25220	6	"	"	''